id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07820v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07820v1
|
On the Analysis of Cross-Lingual Prompt Tuning for Decoder-based Multilingual Model
| 2023-11-14T00:43:33 | 2023-11-14T00:43:33 |
Nohil Park, Joonsuk Park, Kang Min Yoo, Sungroh Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An exciting advancement in the field of multilingual models is the emergence
of autoregressive models with zero- and few-shot capabilities, a phenomenon
widely reported in large-scale language models. To further improve model
adaptation to cross-lingual tasks, another trend is to further fine-tune the
language models with either full fine-tuning or parameter-efficient tuning.
However, the interaction between parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) and
cross-lingual tasks in multilingual autoregressive models has yet to be
studied. Specifically, we lack an understanding of the role of linguistic
distributions in multilingual models in the effectiveness of token-based prompt
tuning. To address this question, we conduct experiments comparing prompt
tuning and fine-tuning on the decoder-based multilingual model, XGLM, with four
cross-lingual tasks (XNLI, PAWS-X, POS, NER). According to our study, prompt
tuning achieves on par or better performance over fine-tuning across all
languages while updating at most 0.13\% of the model parameters. Moreover, we
empirically show that prompt tuning is more effective in enhancing the
performance of low-resource languages than fine-tuning. Our further analysis
shows that the phenomenon is related to the tokenization scheme of the
multilingual model.
|
[
-0.5448347926,
-0.7838501334,
0.2513487637,
0.3544928133,
-0.3971148133,
-0.1677148044,
-0.3523108363,
-0.3269230425,
-0.0610578395,
0.0734975189,
-0.654216826,
-0.3968761265,
-0.3933072686,
0.3825301826,
-0.0336493663,
1.0366816521,
0.0751566291,
0.1633448452,
0.4532091916,
-0.1373798698,
-0.6922901273,
-0.5474826097,
-0.910664618,
-0.0807556212,
0.744248867,
0.2367405444,
0.6933246255,
0.8629992008,
0.1890846789,
0.200031504,
-0.0905356929,
-0.0272373706,
-0.2730011344,
0.1257137805,
-0.2632651329,
-0.5580669045,
-0.3528758883,
-0.0763698816,
0.7489518523,
0.6110952497,
-0.0252787638,
0.0162957013,
0.1645945162,
0.3519798517,
-0.6275509,
0.1696099639,
-0.6133321524,
0.1081947386,
-0.3424374461,
-0.5118983984,
-0.5032832026,
-0.0050720703,
-0.2949312329,
-0.575945735,
0.4407743514,
0.352756232,
0.5235755444,
0.1684726179,
-0.3482928872,
-0.1549045444,
-0.3198786974,
0.7736282349,
-0.6316694021,
0.5772682428,
0.2206124365,
0.0503805168,
0.1158909351,
0.008097426,
-0.2988829613,
-0.0893341452,
-0.1537761688,
-0.1348810345,
-0.1579523981,
0.1239284575,
0.3702995777,
0.2351503819,
-0.7176873684,
0.4876997769,
0.3074120283,
-0.3383839726,
0.3230148554,
0.4380417466,
0.4034359753,
-0.2965121865,
-0.3502196074,
-0.2694128156,
-0.7077919841,
0.3370423913,
0.4688703418,
0.8712426424,
-0.3164215982,
0.2837381065,
-0.2786336243,
0.8920421004,
0.3506201208,
0.0110029243,
0.1493320614,
-0.9563245177,
-0.0693112463,
0.1689500213,
0.7002269626,
0.267503947,
0.2206346095,
-0.065240398,
-0.3284977674,
-0.219246909,
-0.3770346344,
-0.6742722988,
-0.2983135879,
-0.1685777158,
-0.5935732722,
-0.0102383662,
-0.2530044317,
-0.5441870689,
-0.1558885574,
-0.2079073936,
0.3306207359,
-0.4450783432,
-0.5327638388,
0.1772393584,
-0.1319039613,
0.2036159337,
0.2302536964,
-1.2333987951,
-0.1242894158,
0.6725670695,
0.8996381164,
-0.2472210079,
-0.7081163526,
-1.0154861212,
-0.1823012531,
-0.4794789851,
0.8061716557,
-0.5246043205,
-0.3891791701,
-0.039464388,
0.3996045887,
-0.5807411075,
-0.2930122316,
0.5499709249,
-0.4281563163,
-0.0550351702,
-0.7381314039,
-0.4398654699,
0.0730297193,
0.2224054784,
-0.6052638888,
0.781023562,
-0.032187961,
-0.6952720284,
0.7216616869,
-0.5722042918,
-0.3436999619,
-0.0031936793,
0.1189519539,
0.0062617385,
0.3520442843,
0.4049428701,
0.4861997664,
-0.2776330411,
0.1474975049,
-0.3211142123,
-0.3198646009,
0.1458495259,
-0.7617076039,
0.836451292,
0.192828089,
-0.3742128909,
0.1142320931,
-0.7056242824,
0.0578969605,
-0.2355056852,
-0.2631772459,
-0.5029560328,
-0.2959564328,
0.1668055505,
0.4235887527,
0.0034755357,
-0.2848970592,
0.1744386107,
-0.5015060306,
0.1162548065,
0.6629852653,
0.0249700993,
0.6326624751,
-0.2523922026,
0.7897233963,
0.1987719089,
0.1758001447,
-0.8820762038,
-0.4649704397,
-0.4716156721,
-0.4447143376,
0.4662873447,
0.5915196538,
-0.6857456565,
0.1204947531,
0.203988269,
-0.3238976896,
-0.5353760123,
0.0331483446,
0.6107474566,
0.5515132546,
0.1785154492,
0.1743633151,
-0.0688891187,
-0.7185043693,
-0.4943434,
-0.1578718871,
0.2136840969,
0.292211324,
0.1027408913,
0.1357619017,
0.7205944657,
-0.0644508675,
-0.0481946468,
-0.21314165,
0.2939996123,
0.3067261279,
0.4932081997,
1.006231308,
-0.54668504,
-0.8712368011,
0.2440923452,
-0.3575961292,
-0.5009173751,
-0.1529387981,
-0.1694905311,
0.7553100586,
0.4334645569,
-0.6051539183,
0.1394825876,
0.5242273211,
-0.8314555287,
0.5679647326,
-0.4043129385,
0.467747122,
-0.7658184767,
0.0857135952,
-0.1618997902,
-0.1981331557,
-0.6228371263,
0.0823341459,
0.3752216697,
-0.1812841594,
-0.5004687309,
0.8982412815,
-0.6746103168,
0.057865642,
-0.2752478719,
0.0005226479,
0.117365472,
0.4065239131,
0.2455067486,
0.9517269135,
0.8728672266,
-0.6653602123,
-0.0104280664,
0.1136246845,
-0.2005559057,
0.5187297463,
-0.7199473381,
-0.2962590754,
-0.1095874086,
-0.2492087483,
-1.1340099573,
0.243672207,
0.407387048,
-0.2467441708,
0.3743246198,
-0.1842269599,
-0.691636622,
0.2002087533,
-0.2187673897,
0.5985478163,
0.4042187929,
-0.6795187593,
0.3298296332,
-0.0119607737,
-0.2994770408,
-0.4702582657,
-0.3295618594,
-0.0635482743,
-0.3256797493,
-0.5222417116,
0.1422433406,
-0.254699856,
-0.1713559926,
-0.1163356453,
0.2270395607,
0.4165057838,
0.1679754704,
-0.1717977524,
0.1062754989,
-0.3037562668,
0.1965703517,
0.3979448974,
-0.3402589858,
-0.0282732584,
-0.1626887172,
0.5484126806,
0.1601448953,
-0.4477382898,
-0.1864183396,
0.4985840023,
0.3718957007,
-0.2898510396,
0.7362579703,
0.8096784949,
0.1826284528,
-0.1431832761,
-0.4173902571,
-0.2339899242,
-0.439804852,
0.215271309,
-0.7650349736,
-0.6156625152,
0.9775259495,
0.1708658785,
-0.080466114,
0.4418280721,
0.6440870762,
0.3527585864,
1.4268046618,
0.7833955288,
-0.0766806304,
0.6825233102,
0.2370473295,
0.0236236844,
-0.6366959214,
0.0610616356,
-0.7829506993,
-0.0746037811,
-0.7729355693,
-0.1542339772,
0.2881473899,
0.1790650636,
-0.0759362057,
0.1403881013,
-0.2024041116,
0.2557624876,
0.5928042531,
-0.4188587666,
0.3167237341,
0.1111957207,
-0.4186470211,
-0.0003255114,
-1.2085673809,
0.0053289589,
0.6296421289,
0.1151828915,
0.8677171469,
-0.0320436358,
0.4714146554,
0.0911833122,
-0.341781348,
-0.4665212333,
0.1900078952,
-0.2431287318,
-0.5869400501,
-0.3501876295,
-0.4067805111,
-0.9982994199,
0.4662694335,
-0.0793163627,
-0.481102556,
0.6207100749,
0.3559710979,
-0.4548397064,
0.1427821368,
-0.7940452099,
1.2838745117,
-0.1490077525,
-0.2175188512,
-0.1098024994,
-0.5486243963,
0.0456303209,
-0.2798941731,
0.1946913153,
-0.2815833986,
-0.1199486256,
0.4906440973,
-0.0943201706,
0.8604989052,
-0.4407935441,
-0.5276596546,
-0.0765217841,
0.0890916884,
0.7595840693,
0.2982906401,
-0.2453113347,
0.3750885427,
0.2553368509,
-0.4243269265,
-0.610427022,
0.7123231888,
-0.8063420057,
-0.5694655776,
-0.2312339693,
-0.6875633001,
-0.1861655116,
0.1686621457,
0.6064425707,
0.6305776238,
-0.0754758045,
-0.1830755025,
0.6055468917,
-0.4509576261,
0.8381717205,
0.8802400231,
-0.3141857088,
-0.2327041626,
0.6614649296,
0.265103519,
0.4313557744,
0.4484341145,
0.199305445,
-0.4935324192,
-0.3660538495,
-0.8935716748,
0.3042657077,
-0.7262349725,
-0.0643646792,
-0.6435388327,
0.2276764214,
-0.484110266,
-0.1237404868,
-0.1650848985,
-0.313957721,
-0.5387358069,
0.1373915523,
0.5316824913,
0.2133149505,
-0.2805638611,
0.2756264806,
-0.9817064404,
0.2041621655,
-0.1309794188,
0.2997311056,
0.0457064845,
-0.7262444496,
-0.5213962793,
0.1238558218,
0.3269519806,
-0.7616516948,
0.452477783,
0.2948791981,
0.7284669876,
0.4181720912,
0.1370884925,
0.8542234898,
-0.5997502208,
0.7685537934,
0.0956494734,
-0.9896344543,
0.3091713786,
-0.4815351367,
0.6960324645,
0.3635851443,
0.1597040743,
-0.7604498863,
-0.2993236184,
-0.2027920932,
-0.6253734827,
1.0559098721,
-0.2576129436,
0.267187655,
-0.2962685823,
0.2317093164,
0.6531882882,
0.09284769,
-0.3456597924,
-0.2622859478,
-0.2495924383,
0.1720909774,
-0.5258760452,
-0.3147722781,
0.2388511002,
-0.193692252,
0.6450335383,
-0.4001756608,
0.0219513401,
-0.0703162104,
-0.206535697,
-0.2934555411,
0.3259658515,
0.7349774837,
0.4185506403,
0.1580893397,
0.0917763412,
0.1164393052,
-0.097385779,
0.3077929318,
0.1468358487,
-0.2842964828,
0.3296580315,
0.2774218619,
1.4097709656,
0.3967394829,
-0.4125565886,
0.3640272021,
-0.1769696623,
0.1077983752,
0.2276652753,
0.1981696635,
-0.1729400456,
0.2345361114,
0.439566195,
0.1093245223,
0.1512037665,
-0.3229914308,
0.0114089679,
0.6068065763,
-0.1506802142,
-0.6419904828,
0.6122785807,
0.1239409372,
-0.2656015754,
0.5492660999,
-0.4428349435,
-0.1859701723,
0.5324984789,
0.7170013785,
0.7870957255,
-0.2977794111,
0.3000352979,
0.3409620821,
0.2099672258,
-0.1305051446,
0.2690777481,
-0.3041462004,
-0.576269269,
-0.7063713074,
-0.6632717252,
-0.0037226509,
-0.2902031243,
-0.6171582937,
0.3929028213,
0.1467081606,
-0.1602761447,
-0.1267161071,
-0.0548530221,
-0.5004324913,
0.0175018031,
0.0897295251,
1.099817872,
-1.0071643591,
0.7409566641,
0.6126526594,
-0.0445764735,
-1.000030756,
-0.0535828434,
-0.2650826573,
-0.7674475908,
0.7829816341,
-0.0562311485,
-0.0086186863,
0.2103815675,
0.1714719534,
-1.0487507582,
0.5677401423,
0.6810489893,
-0.7646241784,
-0.082598865,
0.170621708,
0.490465045,
-0.1618154794,
0.3217930496,
0.2763259709,
0.5750200748,
-0.2022330314,
-1.2523173094,
0.0435755737,
-0.2875814736,
0.2449740171,
0.4685228467,
-0.6667643189,
1.1587649584,
-0.1366034895,
-0.3042849898,
-0.0078306198,
0.1711497754,
0.186600402,
0.1424539834,
0.5616829991,
0.1490168273,
0.4887953997,
-0.0086870911,
1.1086429358,
-0.8423882723,
0.3697661459,
0.7283300757,
-0.3057244718,
0.529851675,
0.6193789244,
0.1350247115,
0.0784601569,
0.8453134894,
-0.0089501459,
0.7403748631,
-0.3938068748,
-0.0589667857,
-0.4506349564,
-0.1488262713,
-0.4700754583,
0.2617081106,
0.0786502734,
-0.3219630122,
-0.603022933,
0.5678528547,
-0.2391288877,
-0.3243105114,
-0.6311149001,
0.8688625097,
-0.0523406975,
-0.957918942,
0.9363473058,
0.0683895797,
0.6220162511,
-0.4753993452,
0.1289750189,
-0.2941287756,
0.0281579792,
-0.0198135059,
-0.5723587871,
0.2195482999,
-0.1334533542,
-0.4445453584,
-0.3605921566,
0.5989204049,
-0.6008668542,
-0.4519234598,
0.4623241127,
0.8587660789,
0.0506032631,
-0.0956230834,
-0.917191565,
0.1660757512,
-0.0866351649,
-0.456056416,
0.5314103961,
0.7835561037,
-0.1811885983,
0.3771671951,
0.6363173127,
0.1880064756,
0.334376663,
0.3486710489,
0.3868449032,
-0.633902967,
-0.9377738237,
-1.1921857595,
0.3938107789,
0.4403076172,
-0.4093033075,
1.1718782187,
0.328206867,
0.8024089336,
-0.2407861948,
0.5840116739,
0.0137083549,
0.3932882845,
-0.7160632014,
0.566403389,
-0.5910074115,
0.1085965708,
-0.1465625167,
-0.7974906564,
-0.248214975,
0.2341031134,
-0.2249637097,
0.1352398098,
0.5382496715,
0.9313166142,
-0.1914338171,
-0.1738564819,
0.673933506,
-0.1156874299,
-0.0698903278,
0.3017069101,
0.860165596,
-0.2322113961,
0.3008748889,
-0.1366634816,
0.0175748952,
-0.2873277068,
-0.8382543921,
-0.9796925187,
-0.5318124294,
-0.2767196894,
0.0813301653,
0.0883511528,
0.7883186936,
0.7160444856,
-0.8407744169,
-0.097282216,
-0.0519210324,
0.1137298718,
-0.4070281088,
-0.2160311639,
0.3403833807,
-0.9982436299,
-0.8822651505,
0.3372399211,
0.3089556098,
-0.0813670158,
-0.1459512413,
-0.1305317879,
-0.0598998182,
0.0614964515,
0.5093742013,
0.0511637628,
-0.7462846637,
-0.0830764771,
0.5119607449,
-0.0445810966,
0.2142356038,
0.9051593542,
-0.715954423,
0.3791432083,
0.6714402437,
0.3364107907,
0.198675096,
0.0380883105,
0.6289943457,
-0.7345082164,
0.2472370863,
-0.2940699756,
0.4812292755,
0.1961116195,
-0.5642492175,
0.0212607384,
0.1156708375,
-0.5441796184,
-1.0214475393,
0.2096602917,
-0.5421532393,
-0.3554800153,
1.2087498903,
-0.1685458422,
-0.2005475909,
-0.1185006499,
-0.3880586624,
0.2326505035,
-0.5600600243,
0.5352803469,
0.7859416604,
-0.1875308156,
-0.5018025637,
-0.1467722505,
0.5890194178,
0.6225705147,
-0.4117682278,
0.3840704262,
0.3438122869,
0.3361184001,
0.017290609,
0.5514771938,
0.1513595134,
0.492723912,
-0.029505983,
-0.3079944849,
-0.0952827856,
-0.2037132829,
-0.9632017612,
0.3049714565,
0.3137317896,
-0.0215950813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07811v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07811v2
|
In-context Learning Generalizes, But Not Always Robustly: The Case of Syntax
| 2023-11-13T23:52:43 | 2024-04-10T15:38:33 |
Aaron Mueller, Albert Webson, Jackson Petty, Tal Linzen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning (ICL) is now a common method for teaching large language
models (LLMs) new tasks: given labeled examples in the input context, the LLM
learns to perform the task without weight updates. Do models guided via ICL
infer the underlying structure of the task defined by the context, or do they
rely on superficial heuristics that only generalize to identically distributed
examples? We address this question using transformations tasks and an NLI task
that assess sensitivity to syntax - a requirement for robust language
understanding. We further investigate whether out-of-distribution
generalization can be improved via chain-of-thought prompting, where the model
is provided with a sequence of intermediate computation steps that illustrate
how the task ought to be performed. In experiments with models from the GPT,
PaLM, and Llama 2 families, we find large variance across LMs. The variance is
explained more by the composition of the pre-training corpus and supervision
methods than by model size; in particular, models pre-trained on code
generalize better, and benefit more from chain-of-thought prompting.
|
[
-0.1786111444,
-0.8107897639,
0.6608695984,
0.1664777249,
-0.2069728673,
-0.0638383552,
-0.4879412353,
-0.2890521288,
-0.3204655647,
0.391110599,
-0.574128449,
-0.4950624704,
-0.5603746772,
-0.0034140206,
-0.5875002146,
1.1912561655,
-0.1327115595,
-0.0762970746,
-0.2523543537,
-0.0627908632,
-0.3166699111,
-0.6191759706,
-0.3280156851,
-0.3511500359,
0.3021556139,
0.3333092332,
0.5241692662,
0.3122155368,
0.4372095168,
0.2001695335,
-0.1257688254,
0.0444775783,
-0.3547057509,
0.0367301852,
-0.3014805615,
-0.7749997377,
-0.1676183194,
-0.1233859286,
0.6567280293,
1.207591176,
-0.2335334271,
0.2420883179,
0.418165952,
0.6190043688,
-0.7808916569,
0.1179662272,
-0.9138478637,
-0.1020211279,
0.066590637,
-0.0239969641,
-0.6139883995,
-0.0371403806,
0.3240346313,
-0.3833783269,
0.0909381062,
-0.0371215418,
0.6753049493,
0.3672117591,
-0.503182888,
-0.5902361274,
-0.6077531576,
0.838588357,
-0.4957982004,
0.3561984003,
0.5138635635,
0.0971459597,
-0.1850418597,
-0.6537960768,
-0.2976242304,
-0.2922129631,
-0.1631797105,
-0.1436885446,
-0.1396003515,
0.0621043779,
0.4770286679,
0.1963908076,
-0.1782335341,
0.1622810662,
-0.054520037,
0.2872292399,
0.2600436807,
-0.0644821972,
0.2118228376,
0.1212704703,
-0.429736644,
-0.2289177626,
-0.9987744093,
0.3124234676,
0.164116919,
0.3067900836,
-0.3377078176,
0.2077694237,
0.1199579239,
0.845291853,
0.2289016247,
-0.1296976954,
-0.0812461078,
-0.3164762855,
-0.4665107131,
-0.2364234328,
0.5072488189,
0.1331028193,
0.3923813701,
-0.2421782166,
-0.3264944255,
-0.0567111783,
0.1880537719,
-0.485876292,
-0.1828654706,
-0.0344885141,
-0.3560498655,
-0.1006107926,
0.0881134719,
-0.4728502631,
-0.0025282556,
-0.4419456124,
0.2973458767,
-0.2423901111,
-0.0544213541,
0.0315794908,
-0.0433745496,
0.2318499833,
0.3524606526,
-1.0644708872,
0.4737832546,
0.4026623666,
0.6306990981,
-0.1752896011,
-0.1735439897,
-0.5581994057,
0.207200855,
-0.5374628901,
0.5166303515,
-0.4867901802,
-0.2228554338,
0.0092231371,
-0.176099211,
-0.3359202445,
-0.6763320565,
0.1093538627,
-0.434984982,
0.1068803146,
-0.3697247803,
-0.4809862375,
0.082393758,
0.2995835543,
-0.3613007367,
1.0267186165,
0.4325168729,
-0.8359720111,
0.6393650174,
-0.6450325847,
-0.4090280235,
-0.1710926741,
-0.2861626446,
-0.2305242717,
0.2258775383,
0.4443026781,
0.6109634638,
-0.1616259068,
0.450774461,
-0.4374888539,
-0.3878874779,
0.4009572566,
-0.2917052507,
0.7783973813,
0.0763186291,
-0.5459308028,
0.0964601114,
-0.5220201612,
-0.0744027495,
-0.1320029795,
-0.3528491259,
-0.5020883679,
0.0938094258,
-0.2204154879,
0.2326613814,
-0.1066219732,
-0.1939200312,
0.2814633548,
-0.5893055201,
0.5673726797,
0.8266581297,
-0.067956984,
0.7856078744,
-0.0909798592,
0.4147859216,
0.0556726269,
0.1013759673,
-0.1483068317,
-0.2557801008,
-0.7437945604,
-0.1465966403,
0.0733127743,
0.4113102257,
-0.7273236513,
0.4280574918,
-0.1608249992,
-0.0515340194,
-0.0368566178,
0.3912549019,
0.4155268967,
0.5974878669,
0.3700324595,
-0.1627583355,
-0.3828655481,
-0.7025541663,
-0.3352003992,
-0.2369833291,
-0.1046452448,
0.0884145051,
0.5270425677,
-0.2255818397,
0.8915473819,
-0.2415590137,
0.0452488288,
-0.5355437994,
-0.0850234106,
0.1931318939,
0.399425447,
0.5873411894,
-0.6676903367,
-0.6749037504,
0.0416640341,
-0.6338572502,
-0.001191768,
-0.2139158845,
-0.1256832033,
0.0008914685,
0.9220321178,
-0.4311691523,
0.4237408042,
0.3871329427,
-0.0446276963,
0.1846765578,
-0.1791193634,
-0.3727081716,
-1.0263564587,
-0.06809517,
-0.0300899427,
-0.2389529943,
-0.6624045372,
0.4204981327,
0.2724140286,
0.074857384,
-0.3372376561,
0.4150256813,
-0.4520918429,
-0.1999568045,
-0.1966203451,
-0.0170770418,
-0.1093474552,
0.5626516342,
-0.0257737618,
0.8648258448,
0.7699409127,
-0.8778187633,
-0.2256339341,
-0.0239273608,
-0.4507941008,
0.4961080849,
-0.5167124271,
0.2460677624,
-0.3060348034,
0.3358650506,
-0.9113873243,
-0.2259148806,
0.1854951382,
0.0091020204,
0.4264508784,
-0.1318177134,
-0.4371845126,
-0.2102012634,
-0.1019317061,
0.4072308838,
0.5254986882,
-0.773537457,
0.2921206355,
0.0476796813,
0.2121670693,
-0.6020192504,
-0.8290032148,
-0.1282351315,
-0.481678158,
-0.1250078827,
0.241841808,
-0.2584785819,
-0.6697816253,
-0.2840645313,
-0.1230917946,
-0.2120183408,
0.2861944735,
0.1613798589,
0.1189078987,
-0.0729418769,
0.3766208291,
0.1178668663,
0.2980270982,
0.2690033317,
-0.6177919507,
0.3607121706,
-0.0993677676,
-0.4811943769,
-0.2284341753,
0.3706439734,
0.3577192426,
-0.0705701858,
0.5920649171,
0.3301031291,
-0.2463156879,
-0.6094033718,
-0.2041646987,
-0.1855530292,
-0.469702065,
0.25520733,
-0.3336036801,
-0.8950021267,
0.3679699004,
-0.1310956478,
-0.058507327,
0.2743939757,
0.4683066308,
-0.2837198675,
0.9475080967,
0.8868435621,
-0.1227280647,
0.6746740341,
-0.3549759686,
0.1652403772,
-0.8057411313,
0.0687884688,
-0.3942463994,
-0.1859551817,
-0.3306823373,
-0.2798020542,
0.4407106042,
0.3631594777,
-0.2675387859,
0.286931932,
-0.382317394,
0.5689052939,
0.4983666837,
0.2279387712,
0.0078858519,
0.1674047709,
-0.1054864824,
0.2140479535,
-0.7804840803,
-0.3707998991,
1.2252517939,
0.2600345016,
0.7937372923,
0.0725315288,
0.7188858986,
0.054761488,
0.5404412746,
-0.6325924993,
0.3572156429,
-0.1027441248,
-0.3436609209,
-0.2661731839,
-0.172379598,
-0.9452174902,
0.1846532822,
0.032820724,
-0.9501427412,
0.3431029618,
0.2678101957,
-0.2483236641,
0.3212207854,
-0.7692952156,
0.5088208318,
-0.0397072658,
-0.0922896266,
-0.0480709635,
-0.7922078371,
0.3409608305,
-0.1607839912,
0.3325915337,
0.1876799911,
0.0021702314,
0.3569099903,
-0.4151899517,
1.2083082199,
-0.0887216851,
-0.2446175963,
0.4099386334,
-0.0326291844,
0.734053731,
0.0952262953,
-0.0763945132,
-0.2358597517,
-0.2698043585,
-0.3493827581,
-0.8641121387,
0.374022305,
-0.5906361938,
-0.6320621967,
0.0037713421,
-0.6140803695,
-0.3727611601,
-0.098748453,
0.5955302715,
0.5256801844,
0.0745670944,
0.1819273084,
0.878539145,
-0.0733045638,
0.5776108503,
0.0574859865,
-0.0604720749,
-0.02442546,
0.4252946079,
0.0426891893,
0.7452652454,
0.7217678428,
0.2066787928,
-0.2796153128,
-0.584046185,
-0.3789293766,
-0.0133141298,
-1.1380127668,
-0.0357853584,
-0.5582817793,
0.0070208921,
-0.26212129,
-0.3378141522,
-0.023412196,
0.0023296338,
-0.391451925,
-0.215634644,
0.1705477387,
1.0174735785,
0.328912288,
0.4202299416,
-0.3047395349,
-0.0389014445,
0.4663050771,
0.1924379766,
0.1086272523,
-0.5318258405,
-0.2592126131,
0.0463008322,
-0.1828502268,
-0.775011301,
0.2126396,
0.4540954232,
0.551338017,
0.3637520075,
0.0589012839,
0.7537688017,
-0.3304428458,
0.7525969744,
0.1408892423,
-1.1328277588,
0.6010761857,
-0.3348268867,
0.4630607665,
0.5132055879,
0.4010571241,
-0.2909280062,
-0.6338294148,
-0.560259819,
-0.626101315,
0.4314456284,
-0.0950318947,
0.4093766212,
-0.2914395034,
0.5734364986,
0.2008271068,
0.2702897489,
-0.9817430973,
-0.0535161048,
-0.0720591322,
-0.2342512608,
-0.1405335963,
-0.1443005055,
-0.0634049624,
-0.4214939475,
0.1193787977,
-0.5078809857,
0.22677809,
0.2863641679,
-0.5046194792,
-0.0374390073,
0.3514728844,
0.5695322752,
0.9345961809,
0.0026130916,
0.4171578884,
0.4669722915,
-0.1619258672,
0.0519952141,
-0.3756708205,
-0.1482686251,
-0.2670509219,
0.7520917058,
0.9954988956,
0.5527885556,
-0.628849566,
0.6530653238,
0.1496234685,
-0.2378664762,
-0.0980818868,
0.2338105142,
-0.1008056253,
0.1379103959,
0.2561233044,
0.1485430896,
0.1173344404,
-0.7496263385,
0.0849864557,
0.4625772536,
-0.452899009,
-0.4273946881,
0.4811193347,
-0.2859782875,
-0.0937954262,
0.5715695024,
-0.2188939005,
-0.4266892672,
0.5277257562,
0.8786844015,
0.7074229717,
-0.0724081844,
0.0920984,
0.1620921046,
0.2072352916,
-0.2163669169,
0.1966817826,
-0.4665971398,
-0.6685218811,
-0.5343085527,
-0.4081967473,
-0.3361547589,
-0.0192196518,
-0.6880069375,
0.1661520153,
-0.6281391978,
0.0590539649,
-0.3358848393,
-0.5527038574,
-0.8049949408,
0.2390267849,
-0.0640277937,
0.7801987529,
-0.8203402758,
1.0256135464,
0.6842337847,
-0.1860112697,
-0.9871968627,
0.3804523945,
-0.3009705842,
-0.6915740371,
0.9396349192,
0.1527770758,
0.0167259611,
-0.007523342,
-0.8301304579,
-1.0127251148,
0.8092033863,
0.6093989015,
-0.4755440354,
-0.1542123854,
0.0322217345,
0.5440043211,
-0.5613456964,
0.2134677768,
0.3545956612,
0.1102866232,
-0.2123808414,
-0.9309956431,
-0.0656407773,
-0.0570182651,
0.1167243421,
0.2408666462,
-0.2971978188,
1.1409409046,
-0.2369240522,
-0.1817525476,
-0.2161687613,
0.5032927394,
0.0785039663,
0.0849696249,
0.6713976264,
0.2224242538,
0.8571878672,
0.1178983524,
1.2809094191,
-0.0939996466,
0.1924529672,
1.1343810558,
-0.199344486,
0.9326657057,
0.633775413,
-0.2342024893,
0.8505612016,
0.5989376307,
0.3987693191,
0.5030068159,
0.1971227527,
-0.1240728796,
-0.2089080513,
-0.0378768481,
-0.1987839639,
0.356236577,
0.6128016114,
-0.4420024753,
-0.3177146018,
0.2446355373,
-0.1604824811,
0.24387151,
-0.3914275169,
0.8429818153,
0.2176163644,
-0.8207629919,
0.736571312,
-0.3368864357,
0.6467126608,
-0.6031472087,
0.0812488496,
-0.0845566541,
0.1986176521,
0.0044880793,
-0.6730859876,
0.3989233971,
-0.2232121527,
-0.2472446561,
-0.3749881089,
0.5937986374,
-0.5409495831,
-0.3091019094,
0.4163990915,
0.426646769,
-0.0180296805,
-0.140706405,
-0.5536386967,
-0.1321054101,
-0.1086235121,
-0.1178050637,
0.5691680312,
0.3706494868,
-0.5255235434,
0.7443713546,
0.5184953809,
-0.1814463437,
0.1361623555,
0.2251876444,
0.856230557,
-0.3437805772,
-0.5968510509,
-0.9422243834,
0.400439918,
0.0334735997,
-0.2814739347,
0.7296583056,
0.0515529327,
1.0898326635,
-0.2188551724,
0.6905694008,
0.2245185822,
0.1710453331,
-0.7252559066,
0.2613599598,
-0.4996549189,
0.3082390428,
-0.3958833516,
-0.9208725691,
-0.4224856198,
0.5522245765,
-0.378924191,
0.0173526872,
0.9125769138,
0.5840950608,
-0.1087324917,
-0.2103767395,
0.3331235051,
-0.1892435998,
0.1861716062,
0.6268542409,
0.801969707,
-0.1827919483,
0.2228922993,
-0.1624429673,
-0.1358430833,
-0.0367172845,
-0.8039931059,
-1.150690794,
-0.6387932301,
-0.1886515319,
-0.1540572494,
0.1059096009,
1.2115861177,
0.887937963,
-0.728186965,
-0.3986700475,
-0.5798655152,
0.1596660018,
-0.3996970356,
-0.1497957259,
0.4133439362,
-0.7707186341,
-0.6210739017,
0.5378736258,
0.3338780701,
0.0268104039,
-0.1447082013,
0.0380449444,
-0.0884408206,
-0.0336245,
0.6938428283,
0.0229657013,
-0.8101315498,
-0.3631997108,
0.0047843214,
-0.0528725497,
0.1161656603,
0.9440998435,
-0.6454066634,
0.2624500692,
0.3183523715,
0.5800437331,
0.2819179595,
-0.1965489686,
0.6401722431,
-1.0542674065,
0.2946714759,
-0.0776429772,
0.3969684541,
0.2361470461,
-0.4696346223,
0.3626816869,
0.0741009936,
-0.4108555317,
-0.785821557,
0.5463088155,
-0.6014350653,
-0.4473268986,
1.1199645996,
-0.2143245339,
-0.3620242178,
-0.2382965088,
-0.0164501667,
0.0487138182,
-0.0997935534,
0.5100018382,
0.6879997849,
-0.0671284273,
-0.2230939418,
-0.3845483363,
0.7055658102,
0.4812088609,
-0.6967952847,
0.1906918436,
0.0083177676,
0.2975430191,
-0.0955337435,
0.5952852964,
0.1898422539,
0.1549929678,
-0.246555239,
-0.1273076236,
0.3661153018,
-0.3938185871,
-0.4524534345,
0.185830608,
0.3808122575,
0.162326932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07804v1
|
IruMozhi: Automatically classifying diglossia in Tamil
| 2023-11-13T23:36:35 | 2023-11-13T23:36:35 |
Kabilan Prasanna, Aryaman Arora
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Tamil, a Dravidian language of South Asia, is a highly diglossic language
with two very different registers in everyday use: Literary Tamil (preferred in
writing and formal communication) and Spoken Tamil (confined to speech and
informal media). Spoken Tamil is under-supported in modern NLP systems. In this
paper, we release IruMozhi, a human-annotated dataset of parallel text in
Literary and Spoken Tamil. We train classifiers on the task of identifying
which variety a text belongs to. We use these models to gauge the availability
of pretraining data in Spoken Tamil, to audit the composition of existing
labelled datasets for Tamil, and to encourage future work on the variety.
|
[
-0.0837908536,
-0.3459914327,
-0.0556112118,
0.1191852316,
-0.4867735803,
0.533360064,
-0.4632226825,
-0.5714434385,
0.3093770444,
0.5925803781,
-0.4185706079,
-0.6808344126,
-0.7042310834,
0.552477479,
-0.2161522359,
0.7053055167,
-0.3876436353,
0.0945451707,
0.1387140304,
-0.5674555898,
-0.4858219028,
-0.1453585327,
-0.3427546024,
-0.2863396704,
0.6415914893,
0.7018306851,
0.6812497973,
0.7095576525,
0.6471940279,
0.3067772388,
0.2028747052,
0.2818879187,
-0.2404911071,
0.5166358352,
-0.1885932982,
-0.8637872934,
0.0505558252,
0.3442998827,
0.7503162622,
0.4751210809,
-0.2684031427,
0.3406994343,
-0.144072786,
0.6689818501,
-0.5302064419,
0.0645829961,
-0.3645976186,
0.3293561339,
-0.7035977244,
-0.3061081469,
-0.2968393266,
-0.6718232036,
-0.152344197,
-0.531829834,
0.1220175847,
0.0459286571,
0.9286795855,
0.4082354605,
-0.0649777725,
-0.3881802559,
-0.742444694,
0.6462997198,
-0.4481835365,
0.3368713856,
0.6867896318,
0.3042869568,
0.1331603229,
-0.4894575179,
-0.4440142512,
-0.3185763061,
-0.2881484926,
0.329579711,
-0.0352451801,
0.0673825443,
-0.037689954,
0.7340202928,
-0.8410900235,
0.2532303929,
-0.5748890638,
-0.0721230507,
0.4111496806,
0.1574225426,
0.6702719331,
-0.2122586966,
-0.0233315136,
-0.0190614685,
-0.4936919212,
-0.4737125337,
0.8211525679,
0.6335237622,
0.029083591,
0.7534397244,
-0.131139487,
1.1541465521,
-0.3266369104,
-0.4096359313,
0.2684380114,
0.2401328832,
-0.2101124525,
0.3151862919,
0.8122332692,
-0.0871637017,
0.3254307806,
-0.0660561547,
0.0166396741,
0.2750940919,
0.0235182401,
-0.5177568197,
-0.0554277413,
0.0921832547,
-0.1648115814,
-0.2381912023,
-0.0695597306,
-0.6441546679,
-0.6093649864,
-0.4634834826,
0.2097637206,
-0.5990006328,
-0.7374153137,
-0.0329580493,
-0.1003514752,
-0.1398908049,
0.2565752566,
-0.7621439695,
0.3579078913,
0.7109017372,
1.0468733311,
-0.2955930829,
-0.6754130125,
-0.2543376982,
0.1753281653,
-0.3193505406,
0.9338656664,
-1.0278555155,
-0.139242202,
0.086047858,
-0.2662859559,
-0.6188871264,
-0.8822723627,
0.3236351013,
-0.2911522985,
0.6147446632,
0.4418568611,
-0.4453849792,
-0.3816530406,
0.3462396264,
-0.7408317924,
0.8411920667,
0.7195192575,
-1.3634097576,
0.3309386373,
-0.4041701257,
-0.4985979199,
0.5938394666,
-0.5416241884,
-0.209291622,
-0.1321645826,
-0.422618717,
0.2716163993,
-0.4229264259,
0.4051226676,
-0.0302448776,
-0.4811956882,
-0.0290925745,
-0.4129097462,
0.6883244514,
0.7315154076,
-0.3663744032,
-0.0643927008,
-0.7846292257,
-0.0352780893,
-0.1302135438,
-0.3893292546,
-0.5874612927,
-0.2720437944,
0.1559362859,
-0.1891761124,
0.2421928346,
-0.5120338202,
0.4149840474,
-0.1198138222,
0.3405751884,
0.3883274496,
-0.3578412831,
0.0295224302,
-0.1127607077,
0.8467063904,
0.1141867191,
-0.1233904138,
0.1609917581,
-0.4068620205,
-0.7109211683,
-0.7745599747,
0.6620842814,
1.0865365267,
-0.46617347,
0.0882643387,
-0.2979563177,
-0.7472560406,
-0.9157554507,
0.0789812431,
0.2258112133,
0.392080307,
-0.0569213741,
-0.070051752,
-0.6076987386,
-0.9473842382,
-0.1935905963,
-0.6134459376,
0.2504625916,
0.2355377674,
0.0699001253,
-0.5972156525,
0.7813956141,
-0.516725719,
-0.6419814229,
-0.3779834211,
0.5170387626,
0.0859468728,
0.3552720547,
0.2906632423,
-0.8974254727,
-0.684027791,
0.5261749029,
-0.9444564581,
-0.1909313202,
0.1292620748,
-0.0345581472,
0.2941178679,
0.4890664518,
-0.3201900721,
0.423799336,
0.6137236357,
-0.2227782905,
0.2815085053,
-0.1485542804,
0.415455997,
-1.4042109251,
-0.0234483276,
-0.4059510231,
-0.3258788586,
-0.4992630482,
0.1091861501,
-0.1367713958,
-0.0562055707,
0.004886813,
0.4501338005,
-0.3741151094,
0.2367865145,
-0.2673973441,
-0.0072158901,
-0.216802597,
0.0549805574,
0.5461928248,
0.9723774195,
0.6794886589,
-0.4236665368,
0.4417780042,
0.2885700166,
-0.284802109,
0.5589834452,
-0.1249002591,
-0.0970459729,
-0.2058184445,
-0.2381117791,
-0.7746180296,
-0.6195969582,
0.5788344145,
-0.5547728539,
0.7530758977,
-0.5302870274,
-0.4253677726,
-0.226183176,
-0.043266125,
0.3786256313,
0.1511731893,
-0.2462097853,
0.7328427434,
0.5570271611,
-0.305383116,
-0.842341125,
-0.7444726229,
0.2112894058,
-0.7432501316,
-0.3716524839,
-0.3365696371,
0.1625480205,
-0.5725013018,
0.0114986124,
0.3477564454,
-0.3728373051,
-0.0342716053,
0.5117707253,
0.2369104326,
-0.3613579869,
0.3100358844,
0.0085956976,
-0.0406912342,
-0.4978064597,
-0.4051171243,
0.7632416487,
-0.174208656,
-0.1702704132,
-0.578009963,
0.5047361255,
0.6852328777,
-0.0533552058,
0.6644911766,
0.8137295842,
-0.4244045615,
0.1719813645,
-0.6280674934,
0.363078326,
-0.42369923,
0.2030061185,
-0.5232207775,
-0.817340076,
0.4853153229,
-0.1158281416,
-0.0098799076,
0.6171414852,
0.5548688769,
0.1775727272,
0.3832636476,
0.7006760836,
-0.3143801093,
0.4329648018,
-0.135181874,
0.0443476811,
-0.7205580473,
-0.237023741,
-0.7123384476,
0.0854160413,
-1.0787191391,
-0.3025574088,
-0.1976656169,
-0.3078529835,
0.0702224374,
0.7450739741,
-0.5462491512,
0.2602478862,
0.4885494709,
-0.1342697889,
0.4244607985,
0.2138902843,
0.051032722,
-0.2444007695,
-0.6115646362,
-0.82794559,
0.7607120872,
0.1795676202,
0.8829911947,
0.078787908,
1.1041595936,
0.6600910425,
0.4382753372,
-0.6916565895,
0.247053951,
-0.2434048653,
-0.6290605664,
-0.2424996346,
-0.5982122421,
-1.1158490181,
0.1316045821,
0.1697525531,
-0.6290155053,
0.1848616004,
-0.0425057784,
-0.3619654775,
0.4179896414,
-0.8789544106,
0.4717000127,
0.0799644962,
-0.1551269591,
-0.2249396294,
-0.4347964227,
0.3039681911,
0.044334434,
0.3147793412,
-0.4674219191,
0.026212031,
0.9862734675,
-0.1237240583,
0.5980479717,
0.0508917794,
0.083686024,
0.3940282762,
0.3383494616,
-0.0705740228,
0.4321289957,
-0.1085412279,
0.17144306,
0.0018029257,
-0.3132836223,
-0.1705262363,
0.7231703401,
-1.1482125521,
-0.5058612823,
-1.0234725475,
-0.3190794885,
-0.1387880892,
0.2958852649,
0.5773938894,
0.5424704552,
-0.1268313229,
-0.3501082957,
0.8581582904,
0.0374693535,
-0.0009266824,
0.510646224,
-0.2009309083,
-0.5412849188,
1.2661168575,
0.2504419386,
0.0173810311,
0.4110409617,
0.2348888814,
0.0983453989,
-0.6467689276,
-0.6748834848,
0.4162726402,
-0.6859849095,
-0.1569240838,
-0.9299915433,
-0.4116607606,
-0.5860403776,
0.0845592469,
-0.4424293637,
-0.569416821,
-0.5792642832,
-0.1807800829,
0.4556694627,
1.267485857,
-0.4021940231,
0.2308140695,
-0.695881784,
0.4008883536,
0.4860005379,
0.6044033766,
-0.5353819132,
-0.7606582046,
-0.1193488464,
-0.178794831,
0.3876318336,
-0.7106199265,
0.4753474295,
0.3424078524,
0.3712664545,
0.5362761021,
-0.0205639601,
0.6640220881,
-0.4633948207,
0.3648906946,
0.0802352279,
-0.3432768285,
0.6814581156,
-0.5323441625,
0.225842759,
1.2343267202,
0.6790289879,
-0.9371119738,
-0.648602128,
-0.373798281,
-0.8652446866,
0.8055831194,
0.3837898374,
0.1052186638,
-0.0230832603,
0.1928703785,
0.6981463432,
0.2609670162,
-0.4109943509,
-0.2629951835,
-0.1121806353,
-0.5240497589,
0.0009313881,
-0.3550878465,
-0.1663891375,
-0.2446692437,
0.5862944722,
0.0909412876,
0.3056321442,
0.193998456,
-0.4987436235,
-0.2090314329,
0.0936249271,
0.6126300097,
0.8936266899,
-0.3874168694,
0.2862830758,
-0.2325921506,
-1.3223938942,
0.0640030354,
0.2561296523,
-0.212774545,
0.2607548237,
0.3844103813,
0.8922172785,
-0.4135335982,
-0.6258283854,
-0.066821143,
-0.4881653786,
0.1465926617,
-0.8103629947,
0.3036311269,
-0.2071845084,
0.0367346033,
0.4556260705,
0.0020142705,
0.2609316409,
-0.5862327218,
0.06004427,
0.0207638796,
-0.6425510049,
-0.1376257837,
0.3184006512,
0.0222023223,
-0.5449994206,
0.8740299344,
-0.1690119803,
-0.6280924678,
0.2125351727,
0.3265935779,
1.0398569107,
-0.3727428019,
0.5933716893,
0.6163817644,
0.4337964952,
0.1501513273,
0.2380861342,
-0.1134816185,
-0.4068699777,
-0.033038158,
-0.8859189749,
-0.6525033712,
-0.0537391417,
-0.8926707506,
0.5015535355,
-0.1470488012,
-0.0823487043,
0.1758646518,
0.0488891564,
-0.3917263448,
0.2316629887,
0.6241936684,
0.6755475998,
-1.1058645248,
0.7379564047,
0.8322598338,
-0.1605870724,
-0.4257343709,
0.0037176274,
-0.2463402003,
-0.8368259668,
0.4797146916,
0.4521257281,
-0.3997923434,
0.0747621208,
-0.4510423541,
-0.8603894114,
0.9341867566,
0.3027400076,
-0.3128859103,
0.3727775216,
0.4753421843,
0.6080223322,
-0.4780548215,
0.4733877182,
0.5628384352,
0.5989409685,
-0.135024935,
-0.8561377525,
-0.5280031562,
-0.4637307227,
-0.1104297191,
0.2667068839,
-0.9054468274,
0.5904529691,
-0.0049982504,
-0.3581701815,
-0.0366608799,
0.7933522463,
0.1444367915,
0.3144025207,
0.422723949,
0.7050045133,
1.1275994778,
-0.1264584959,
0.7523360848,
-0.0076617645,
0.0135682318,
1.2035783529,
-0.3864528537,
0.6224268079,
0.2471739501,
-0.2245637476,
0.7801457644,
0.9157201052,
0.169736594,
0.3008030653,
0.1771305501,
-0.4401938319,
-0.2504483163,
-0.3327788413,
-0.4193961024,
0.7129728198,
0.4947653711,
-0.0379911326,
-0.016553957,
0.2814537883,
0.334200561,
0.1210124046,
-0.1320746094,
0.6956244707,
-0.0886925608,
-0.8563539386,
0.5449022055,
-0.1805072427,
0.5199486017,
-0.6529026628,
0.0159359183,
-0.3735504746,
0.2221066505,
-0.2605466247,
-0.7518721819,
0.3837882876,
0.0739160329,
-0.0625931174,
0.1496625394,
0.701926887,
-0.5772838593,
-0.5949476957,
0.0939581767,
0.3617490828,
0.4054911137,
0.1584313214,
-0.4374768138,
0.0142405313,
0.0320064016,
-0.3053204119,
0.3834916651,
0.2981899679,
-0.2437227666,
0.8840486407,
0.0002629228,
0.1373958439,
0.271171391,
0.1571233571,
0.8483587503,
-0.6927065849,
-0.3534175158,
-0.6490613222,
-0.0620325804,
-0.0458424725,
-0.4488327503,
0.7829061747,
0.7747255564,
0.6254584193,
0.0343163721,
0.9235473871,
-0.3988607824,
0.6763420105,
-0.1688070595,
0.73595649,
-0.4599181116,
-0.2399046421,
0.0574336573,
-0.8197347522,
-0.3219507337,
0.5414100885,
0.0747185573,
-0.3592048585,
0.7737796307,
0.4080293775,
-0.0431968197,
0.0834334195,
0.2922790647,
0.0471464097,
-0.3229279518,
0.1573947817,
0.9464565516,
-0.1969543099,
0.3726026118,
-0.3881041408,
-0.2889518142,
-0.1001272202,
-0.3745729923,
-0.9765272141,
-0.8256947398,
-0.6789686084,
-0.2793708444,
0.1662550867,
1.1002272367,
0.2689068913,
-1.0198761225,
-0.5043798685,
0.0871461034,
0.1945800632,
-0.0052354387,
-0.1904251426,
0.2741503119,
-0.2471042573,
-0.9279947281,
0.2582515776,
0.5589011908,
0.1154164523,
-0.4271853864,
0.0971551761,
-0.3912181556,
-0.1206625924,
0.1449140012,
0.5353440046,
-0.2758885324,
0.168550536,
-0.014691961,
-0.2789680362,
0.3274150193,
0.7727316022,
-0.7789040804,
0.5564420223,
0.6636727452,
0.0821277946,
0.1419145167,
-0.1268812716,
0.4159889221,
-0.2575208247,
0.5090335608,
0.5874275565,
0.2410943806,
0.6317607164,
-0.4812565446,
0.9016852379,
0.3313818574,
-0.3616968691,
-1.1152927876,
0.2568400204,
-0.7944146395,
-0.0191220976,
1.3701035976,
-0.4301535487,
-0.5121492743,
-0.5747817755,
-0.2677529454,
0.5855101347,
-0.0552083366,
0.7186886072,
0.5413812399,
0.2132415026,
-0.0033424869,
-0.6011443734,
0.3526368737,
0.0322115049,
-0.5949054956,
0.1831232607,
0.2731457651,
0.2842842638,
0.4114319384,
0.5702844858,
-0.0511882901,
0.1554550827,
0.0358336493,
0.0481770821,
-0.0429265834,
-0.5201413631,
-0.2212551534,
-0.0224615745,
0.3071969151,
-0.185364753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07772v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07772v4
|
In-context Learning and Gradient Descent Revisited
| 2023-11-13T21:42:38 | 2024-03-31T19:33:50 |
Gilad Deutch, Nadav Magar, Tomer Bar Natan, Guy Dar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In-context learning (ICL) has shown impressive results in few-shot learning
tasks, yet its underlying mechanism is still not fully understood. A recent
line of work suggests that ICL performs gradient descent (GD)-based
optimization implicitly. While appealing, much of the research focuses on
simplified settings, where the parameters of a shallow model are optimized. In
this work, we revisit evidence for ICL-GD correspondence on realistic NLP tasks
and models. We find gaps in evaluation, both in terms of problematic metrics
and insufficient baselines. We show that surprisingly, even untrained models
achieve comparable ICL-GD similarity scores despite not exhibiting ICL. Next,
we explore a major discrepancy in the flow of information throughout the model
between ICL and GD, which we term Layer Causality. We propose a simple GD-based
optimization procedure that respects layer causality, and show it improves
similarity scores significantly.
|
[
-0.3039568961,
-0.3780173063,
0.5916262865,
-0.0541954599,
-0.1121027991,
-0.0702359229,
-0.0479866117,
-0.6013422012,
-0.494170785,
0.0786255002,
-0.740383625,
-0.4561541975,
-0.3330210149,
-0.2197435796,
-0.2939734459,
1.4166041613,
0.1331482977,
0.2270465046,
-0.5860895514,
-0.2932336926,
-0.318959862,
-0.357416898,
-1.0013365746,
-0.6493361592,
0.6329059005,
0.1906696707,
0.2755623162,
0.6768325567,
0.6094383597,
0.0795314834,
-0.0869675577,
0.1680722386,
-0.7368760109,
-0.1195853055,
-0.1701184213,
-0.3197958767,
0.0844442621,
0.0353223532,
0.6497530937,
1.1594113111,
0.0081599765,
0.1441016495,
0.6621591449,
0.8439234495,
-0.9192693233,
-0.1272586435,
-0.604244411,
0.3119074404,
0.057827726,
-0.2843883932,
-0.303561151,
0.113402538,
0.4713994861,
-0.4719412327,
0.4422994256,
0.1632779539,
0.8104095459,
0.6396542788,
-0.5515885353,
-0.5438715219,
-0.7667132616,
0.8305291533,
-0.6329944134,
0.1707093567,
0.1814884692,
0.2312516421,
0.0039816131,
-0.7104004622,
-0.2342510372,
-0.5047951341,
-0.2128641903,
0.0362122059,
-0.0597493351,
0.2211733907,
0.7290174365,
0.1112144142,
-0.2470124215,
0.2991069853,
-0.188740775,
0.1588484794,
0.307060957,
0.2535152435,
0.2032739073,
0.0447172634,
-0.8723464012,
0.093090266,
-0.9367558956,
0.5366090536,
0.3147218823,
0.4447566867,
-0.4488264024,
0.1545394212,
-0.0813207477,
0.6454865932,
0.184676379,
-0.0406888761,
-0.1217499152,
-0.0864292234,
-0.1582292318,
0.1746740341,
0.2107232064,
0.4599224329,
-0.0090071941,
-0.4439471662,
-0.245561257,
-0.1484446079,
0.2725375593,
-0.6477977037,
-0.2007366419,
0.1387123466,
-0.3118037283,
-0.0021950291,
0.1410686523,
-0.1430952102,
-0.2228571028,
-0.7904720306,
0.5749790072,
-0.1755106002,
0.2649718523,
0.0496790484,
-0.0294683352,
0.453194648,
0.4596573412,
-0.8413310647,
0.483584106,
0.852396965,
0.8654860854,
-0.2045911252,
-0.3061134219,
-0.5330855846,
0.2810143232,
-0.4840261638,
0.3859685957,
-0.3201707304,
-0.1370091736,
-0.0009726257,
-0.4820453823,
-0.2302168906,
-0.5324692726,
0.6090878844,
-0.4040359557,
0.3183516264,
-0.5249109864,
-0.6819331646,
-0.1743625849,
0.2319695503,
-0.4557558596,
0.9477066994,
0.0095904293,
-1.1168879271,
0.8240344524,
-0.6763539314,
-0.327375859,
-0.1153928787,
-0.1488752663,
-0.2586627305,
0.284534663,
-0.0710732639,
0.4646521509,
-0.5379518867,
0.2532397509,
-0.437449187,
-0.6736499667,
-0.1255465746,
-0.2203306705,
0.9956875443,
-0.0795447007,
-0.5395948887,
-0.2011936754,
-0.6646081209,
-0.1514688581,
-0.4196726978,
-0.3264273405,
-0.5846478939,
0.2481572777,
-0.009327298,
0.5107218623,
-0.0790518895,
-0.4263148308,
0.1385782361,
-0.3513462543,
0.3841415346,
0.7286536098,
-0.0901521966,
0.6257834435,
-0.242823571,
0.1740677357,
0.0896199867,
0.2161059976,
0.236956805,
-0.1659474969,
-0.6636437178,
-0.0969596878,
0.0488924235,
0.3295967877,
-0.5954797268,
0.1642232239,
-0.0875585303,
-0.2898383737,
-0.3516196907,
-0.0812293813,
0.6698987484,
1.3737678528,
0.639693141,
-0.2676328719,
-0.0996983722,
-0.9174610972,
-0.5149681568,
-0.1777318865,
-0.209937796,
0.6895978451,
0.4470693469,
-0.0835381001,
0.8396573663,
-0.24644804,
-0.4931723475,
0.1279676408,
-0.0438242368,
0.1255199164,
0.8136217594,
0.8164020777,
-0.5253254175,
-0.6661292315,
0.1807234138,
-0.7118659616,
-0.0267653968,
-0.129863143,
0.0478458181,
-0.053490378,
1.0250920057,
-0.348741442,
0.3521744609,
0.1028837934,
-0.1188527122,
0.3405478895,
-0.2352523208,
-0.1231416613,
-0.6576900482,
0.2340818644,
0.2076187134,
0.0478514358,
-0.6683831215,
0.1578727961,
0.1204427481,
0.007471249,
-0.5515301228,
0.8036506176,
-0.3463339508,
-0.2374485135,
-0.096175909,
0.205750674,
-0.158087045,
0.6058404446,
-0.2570314109,
0.3592483401,
0.9416941404,
-0.6827350855,
-0.1292138398,
-0.1480206102,
-0.3499395549,
0.6582119465,
-0.6410424709,
0.22200571,
-0.5092112422,
0.3875314891,
-0.9034252763,
-0.0960616693,
0.292670846,
0.0349593535,
0.4104914963,
-0.2975703478,
-0.1307868063,
0.0442599058,
-0.4121019244,
0.8185048103,
0.3540525436,
-0.8527854681,
0.3259393871,
-0.1523734331,
0.4648998678,
-0.8756794333,
-0.6145138741,
-0.0482655354,
-0.6238759756,
-0.3541958332,
0.6352685094,
-0.2113993168,
-0.3339452147,
-0.0057471804,
-0.1224323735,
0.052094128,
0.2482151836,
0.0244362019,
-0.1118705347,
-0.3921169937,
0.1517392397,
0.0210852791,
0.0622145534,
0.2134868652,
-0.3908582032,
0.1443284303,
0.0295674037,
-0.5099774003,
-0.3431752324,
0.3563457727,
0.1106562242,
0.3105427921,
0.6424998641,
0.5932582617,
-0.4925112128,
-0.6556084156,
-0.3469999135,
-0.3233970404,
-0.3935140669,
0.1699122339,
-0.266387403,
-0.7820418477,
0.6900494695,
-0.1107117832,
-0.086350061,
0.5073674917,
0.0973765701,
-0.4397404194,
0.9439510107,
0.8707586527,
-0.1221464425,
0.4411357045,
-0.4167301655,
0.1475088149,
-1.1980348825,
-0.3740738034,
-0.6484395266,
-0.7149800658,
-0.5649053454,
0.024772441,
0.4452935159,
0.4768224359,
-0.5377867222,
-0.175300166,
-0.0904184356,
0.7976706028,
0.5286595225,
0.2828565538,
0.001109415,
-0.1520304978,
-0.1698722243,
-0.1198386028,
-0.9002022743,
-0.0401042737,
0.8821317554,
0.0877713487,
0.576395154,
0.0325362347,
0.5636220574,
0.1546462178,
0.3078224957,
-0.4465199113,
0.2044192553,
-0.2141176462,
-0.3616819382,
-0.0979067236,
-0.2524130642,
-0.724006772,
0.2306039184,
-0.0807980075,
-0.8208398223,
0.4041446447,
0.2749919593,
-0.3101697862,
0.0985328555,
-0.6520035863,
0.8739343882,
-0.0026122371,
-0.5327439904,
-0.1413492262,
-1.12169981,
0.5470960736,
-0.0114747398,
-0.0329658836,
0.0072090263,
-0.1657367498,
0.4097163677,
-0.3828608692,
0.913479805,
-0.3695079386,
-0.0043474506,
-0.1320533454,
-0.0904727951,
0.252943188,
0.3568557203,
0.0923558474,
0.075562261,
-0.4189985096,
-0.5409113765,
-0.900200963,
0.9520000815,
-0.6121982336,
-0.5390161872,
-0.2358004749,
-0.3906297386,
-0.2528234124,
-0.0490943044,
0.3805742264,
0.9096961617,
-0.009890276,
0.2438977659,
0.5645433068,
-0.0829884186,
0.7857183218,
0.3801345229,
0.3204337656,
0.2112151831,
0.454351604,
-0.1205217838,
0.4679635167,
0.4889957607,
0.2242630422,
-0.3295297921,
-0.5734090805,
-0.2962749004,
0.1410064101,
-1.029088378,
-0.2263158709,
-0.3059112728,
-0.2658769786,
0.0976860896,
-0.4938755929,
-0.1357278824,
-0.0318041258,
-0.5926558375,
0.0127752228,
-0.2871497571,
0.6629064679,
-0.1426069587,
-0.0143527118,
-0.1278975159,
0.1375334859,
0.2476650476,
0.2889304757,
0.4144176841,
-0.6682401896,
-0.510791719,
-0.0231657401,
-0.1635470986,
-0.2689956129,
-0.0236759409,
0.6628326178,
0.4348653257,
0.5884042382,
0.0600302704,
0.8343399763,
-0.7075353265,
0.7343335152,
0.0001390836,
-0.9391850233,
0.4055358171,
-0.1676812023,
0.1916998327,
0.532746613,
0.6715589166,
-0.4169925451,
-0.2463299334,
-0.7255400419,
-0.7569583654,
0.7616573572,
-0.1668939888,
0.2238748968,
0.007096841,
0.7661730647,
0.1581270248,
0.0146502238,
-0.8611330986,
-0.3839793205,
0.217897892,
0.0532933176,
-0.1075838208,
-0.0279306211,
-0.4061661959,
-0.3118807375,
0.3835400045,
-0.4448216558,
0.028139187,
0.3675862849,
-0.0916670635,
-0.1428823471,
-0.3376309276,
0.7370030284,
0.7966927886,
-0.0355603248,
0.1113740504,
0.1306496412,
-0.1102214232,
-0.020822024,
-0.2024511695,
-0.3638505936,
-0.3427395523,
0.8334006667,
0.9933300614,
0.5663957,
-0.4824572802,
0.7595848441,
0.0864744484,
-0.0525054447,
0.023549838,
0.1073019803,
-0.295969218,
0.4032206237,
0.5533813238,
0.4963336289,
0.4323596954,
-0.4350774884,
0.1482262015,
0.8732984066,
-0.7312460542,
-0.2928477824,
0.8590826988,
-0.0944816843,
-0.2900564671,
0.6002371907,
-0.0240539704,
-0.2728363574,
0.6863498092,
0.5138705969,
1.0069072247,
0.1973187774,
0.1043117046,
0.3191222847,
0.2172888815,
-0.0183676928,
-0.1601593941,
-0.3240095079,
-0.6807129979,
-0.4522173107,
-0.3293153048,
-0.3301857114,
-0.0088974508,
-0.7441568971,
0.4157448411,
-0.5409733653,
0.2849895954,
-0.1516693085,
0.0852889866,
-0.9474346638,
0.403213799,
-0.0273434855,
0.5428794622,
-0.9000217319,
0.7378748655,
0.4019877017,
-0.2765254378,
-0.8099920154,
0.4694055319,
-0.1588121653,
-0.5945708156,
1.0185338259,
0.2615477741,
-0.2383514643,
0.216382429,
-0.6465659142,
-0.6733064055,
1.1782253981,
0.5978787541,
-0.1949647665,
-0.1515165418,
-0.059689723,
0.7490693331,
-0.5796420574,
0.2458224148,
0.2103842795,
-0.0693406016,
-0.2039159089,
-0.6872345209,
-0.0514372028,
0.0567878187,
0.1122477055,
-0.135145098,
-0.6058054566,
0.9482943416,
-0.2881805301,
-0.3828776479,
-0.291906178,
0.4678454995,
-0.0549865812,
0.489482522,
0.3200312853,
0.5017294288,
0.6428866386,
0.0436351895,
1.4529881477,
-0.2322702557,
0.5214538574,
0.9666206241,
-0.2597928345,
0.5093799233,
0.615519762,
-0.0498236269,
0.5241321921,
0.7905540466,
0.3460529745,
0.8352871537,
0.2532042265,
-0.284547478,
0.0880202129,
-0.2114343792,
-0.2599488795,
0.2425816059,
0.0933596268,
-0.1901134551,
-0.460904181,
0.0383569449,
-0.2977627218,
0.0723780319,
-0.5546988249,
0.8596684933,
0.1511896253,
-0.5206549168,
0.5092400312,
-0.1704487354,
0.6370018721,
-0.4262418747,
0.0282871705,
-0.5188059807,
0.0861274153,
-0.1632591337,
-0.2973623574,
0.1777555346,
-0.4296102524,
-0.2927812636,
-0.0631282404,
0.700540185,
-0.4690108597,
-0.0215202104,
0.4974748194,
0.3816961944,
-0.0343289338,
0.1346336454,
-0.8615700006,
-0.2474022508,
-0.2569701374,
0.0744021386,
0.5977389216,
0.4957166016,
-0.0494935326,
0.7961597443,
0.4787077904,
0.0078050303,
0.0531177595,
0.2176434845,
0.7575546503,
-0.3728371561,
-0.6020002365,
-0.9847809076,
0.4729263783,
-0.0098871812,
-0.7387852073,
0.5881566405,
0.540481627,
1.435960412,
-0.2220771164,
0.3772810102,
0.2797194123,
0.3399193883,
-1.0372987986,
0.4183961451,
-0.8760895729,
0.427051425,
-0.5648779869,
-1.2328119278,
-0.6411867738,
0.395642668,
-0.1425203085,
0.2058419734,
0.9320668578,
0.6388258338,
-0.4202686548,
-0.3142589927,
0.2489118427,
-0.2433904111,
0.2759543061,
0.6258294582,
0.8481565118,
-0.3683473766,
-0.0591244586,
-0.3419103026,
0.0249886811,
-0.2488443106,
-1.1733107567,
-0.9074676633,
-0.7920814753,
-0.4684255421,
-0.0380323008,
0.1441967189,
0.7754266858,
0.6291671991,
-0.4888826311,
-0.2409303635,
-0.2389132977,
0.1514537781,
-0.3046431541,
-0.2322553843,
0.5917725563,
-0.5557115078,
-0.6895976663,
0.4044246376,
0.4139694273,
-0.0826103985,
-0.2321841568,
-0.1656061858,
-0.0803641379,
-0.1591822058,
0.542748332,
0.3435569704,
-0.9321207404,
-0.6359567046,
-0.5214534402,
-0.3319395483,
0.050310947,
1.1738792658,
-0.7086642981,
0.2130763531,
0.2487215102,
0.9015760422,
0.5084571242,
0.0745717436,
0.3382170498,
-1.2071398497,
0.2091371864,
0.2348918468,
0.157312274,
0.4728071094,
-0.3216045797,
0.516320467,
0.1371110827,
-0.6306943893,
-0.9942113161,
0.2859027088,
-0.7750459313,
-0.2222555429,
0.8655282855,
-0.1044085547,
0.0220121965,
-0.0649576336,
-0.0850716084,
-0.1668960005,
-0.0097136041,
0.879435122,
0.6465983391,
-0.4675847888,
0.0241111964,
-0.5647411942,
1.2426898479,
0.4842126966,
-0.5491601825,
-0.1751415133,
0.3220101595,
0.1331161261,
-0.1297902316,
0.6456658244,
0.3630679846,
0.2507286668,
-0.2300917655,
-0.3254913688,
0.3476414382,
-0.5321691036,
-0.5616380572,
0.1636828482,
0.0275951102,
0.1520712227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07767v1
|
GreekT5: A Series of Greek Sequence-to-Sequence Models for News Summarization
| 2023-11-13T21:33:12 | 2023-11-13T21:33:12 |
Nikolaos Giarelis, Charalampos Mastrokostas, Nikos Karacapilidis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T07, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Text summarization (TS) is a natural language processing (NLP) subtask
pertaining to the automatic formulation of a concise and coherent summary that
covers the major concepts and topics from one or multiple documents. Recent
advancements in deep learning have led to the development of abstractive
summarization transformer-based models, which outperform classical approaches.
In any case, research in this field focuses on high resource languages such as
English, while the corresponding work for low resource languages is still
underdeveloped. Taking the above into account, this paper proposes a series of
novel TS models for Greek news articles. The proposed models were thoroughly
evaluated on the same dataset against GreekBART, which is the state-of-the-art
model in Greek abstractive news summarization. Our evaluation results reveal
that most of the proposed models significantly outperform GreekBART on various
evaluation metrics. We make our evaluation code public, aiming to increase the
reproducibility of this work and facilitate future research in the field.
|
[
-0.3829599023,
-0.4882194102,
0.6644355059,
0.0050911782,
-0.8858383298,
0.3508118093,
-0.0783736333,
-0.3825154901,
0.460359633,
0.2005704641,
-0.5142630935,
-0.5940466523,
-0.8263383508,
0.5616539121,
-0.8042319417,
1.1927181482,
0.0033671348,
0.0812862292,
0.4951346219,
-0.0340330452,
-0.3735379279,
-0.2279173881,
-0.6488755941,
-0.0094842212,
0.3927148581,
0.3090149462,
0.6069972515,
0.3910579979,
0.4767513275,
0.3128428459,
-0.2816418111,
0.1147741154,
-0.3698029816,
0.140136987,
-0.2714418769,
-0.0459892191,
-0.6892735958,
-0.205596,
0.6809437275,
0.4941518009,
0.1199073642,
0.2709715366,
0.0986969396,
0.8238755465,
-0.2319227159,
-0.0692069307,
-0.1730493307,
0.1994424909,
0.0934544504,
-0.1980011314,
-0.3819879293,
-0.7697338462,
0.3862202764,
-0.391102612,
0.3489797115,
-0.2996609509,
0.4905288517,
-0.0070271255,
-0.7682794333,
-0.4861777723,
-0.6171728373,
0.6123611331,
-1.2723397017,
0.2626417577,
-0.0683933944,
0.2956289649,
0.1536053866,
-0.986418128,
-0.365819633,
-0.0131405164,
0.0005908416,
0.3888920546,
-0.3136922717,
-0.1421270221,
-0.3005436063,
0.8458750844,
-0.513399303,
-0.0911220163,
-0.7064456344,
0.3007968366,
0.4683824778,
0.252464503,
0.2865833938,
-0.3380718231,
-0.019209953,
0.3443742096,
-0.2915902436,
-0.2455099225,
0.2033306062,
0.5252504945,
-0.4029037952,
0.8809024692,
-0.5609161258,
0.3444513679,
0.2248076797,
-0.0675337911,
-0.1354861557,
-0.4673922956,
-0.1319248527,
0.3197827041,
0.7123589516,
0.5189154744,
0.1588247865,
-0.5570958853,
-0.1446552128,
0.1386578232,
0.2739285231,
-0.7926369905,
0.1088467613,
0.2360670865,
-0.5591819286,
-0.7356688976,
-0.0759696662,
-0.6093402505,
-0.3016504049,
-0.312928617,
0.1852825284,
-0.5128456354,
-0.1799253523,
0.273131609,
-0.0617683269,
-0.2685320377,
0.3414624035,
-0.918246448,
0.5187125802,
0.7563924789,
1.147079587,
-0.3563619852,
0.0305448454,
-0.0434953831,
-0.0080649192,
-0.370572567,
0.7487550378,
-0.2272738516,
-0.2951011956,
-0.1833338439,
-0.1364548653,
0.1587860733,
0.1603980958,
0.8227743506,
-0.4861443043,
0.6048883796,
-0.3226009905,
-0.7549104691,
-0.5483650565,
0.2309705168,
-0.8071706295,
0.7703598142,
0.0513809137,
-0.9552704692,
0.1664375663,
-0.7948448658,
-0.6652839184,
-0.1815664619,
0.3409023583,
-0.5677284598,
0.5657868385,
0.4190916121,
0.553881228,
-0.2147767991,
0.2531845272,
0.0661370754,
0.0061547328,
0.0733103305,
-0.2369068116,
0.3604373336,
0.421251893,
-0.2946776152,
0.2300887257,
-0.5880908966,
-0.2372494042,
-0.1850766987,
-0.5313877463,
-0.3480529785,
0.0189609174,
0.1267790049,
0.3032732904,
-0.0011741081,
-0.463627249,
0.160736233,
-0.5013622046,
0.6540203094,
0.4665520191,
0.273381114,
0.4567235708,
-0.3152382374,
0.7355179787,
-0.0670553073,
-0.3194415569,
-0.5875634551,
-0.4505493045,
-0.4455446005,
-0.1773730218,
0.5767483115,
0.352706641,
-0.7917923331,
0.1107349023,
-0.5434327722,
-0.626763463,
-0.2541591525,
-0.4156822264,
0.4440281391,
0.6235747933,
0.2875255644,
-0.4904119074,
-0.8662208319,
-0.6083261371,
-0.5500860214,
0.3985072374,
0.2547863424,
-0.3379350305,
0.5554162264,
0.2277064323,
0.9690984488,
-0.0580631718,
0.0004321475,
-1.0348372459,
0.3512697816,
0.3443668485,
0.2668481469,
0.5152938366,
-0.6238030195,
-0.4329221547,
-0.1293054819,
-0.6935612559,
0.1384121329,
-0.0138047365,
0.2901397049,
0.338613838,
0.2175700665,
-0.559230864,
0.500308454,
0.4500983059,
-0.5398472548,
0.5256409049,
-0.0561891645,
0.2648727,
-1.9963902235,
0.0801110193,
0.2127352506,
-0.6756899953,
-0.6309349537,
0.1546111554,
0.0383987576,
-0.5063995719,
-0.5158610344,
0.527662158,
-0.5408416986,
-0.4709667265,
-0.2605525255,
0.0158140995,
-0.2349307388,
0.2556014061,
0.3262524307,
0.6375310421,
0.0610783733,
-0.8220912814,
0.3931705356,
0.241384685,
-0.464871645,
0.2141744941,
-0.6615283489,
-0.2472549528,
-0.2697056234,
0.5132716894,
-1.039247036,
-0.1477897763,
0.0017275639,
-0.605920732,
-0.1015492529,
-0.1278506815,
-0.4899558723,
-0.2272422165,
-0.3966262937,
0.582670927,
0.3529695868,
-0.1221177652,
0.5305904746,
0.1403194964,
-0.6843365431,
-0.5935761929,
-0.6632712483,
0.3685668707,
-0.3440760076,
-0.4290567636,
0.1906977147,
0.2352128625,
-0.1057854369,
0.2434482127,
-0.2498628646,
0.1223900616,
0.0074855234,
-0.3336603642,
0.0945442244,
-0.5565934777,
-0.0195531677,
0.0760441199,
-0.2314441651,
-0.3740690947,
-0.600155592,
0.6718762517,
-0.1087267175,
0.1096857861,
-0.7963821292,
0.4659270644,
0.6584653854,
-0.4490167797,
0.5164401531,
0.1801552474,
-0.3845342398,
0.159534499,
-0.2747880518,
-0.3362330496,
-0.3573494256,
0.8028761148,
-0.261911571,
-0.6158168316,
0.6568823457,
-0.000044308,
0.4751475453,
0.5735015273,
0.7244057059,
-0.03589347,
0.8730196357,
0.6707440019,
-0.1956497878,
0.282491982,
-0.3324468434,
0.2531493902,
-0.4603427947,
0.2389954627,
-0.2553046048,
-0.553404212,
-0.4553549588,
0.0399898104,
0.3981736004,
-0.3995259702,
0.2199289352,
0.4810652733,
-0.1806071997,
0.6064075828,
0.4199637771,
-0.0703335851,
0.7739590406,
0.0707766786,
-0.1567220688,
0.0910903737,
-0.704241097,
-0.6888886094,
1.2913411856,
0.4360513091,
0.5048968196,
0.3720483482,
0.8042219877,
0.5535252094,
0.0718384385,
-0.8433866501,
0.4361974895,
-0.4819129109,
-0.5648524761,
-0.3784547746,
-0.2414551079,
-0.7803370953,
0.2674812078,
-0.000702374,
-0.4081960917,
0.155556336,
-0.0122828381,
-0.7268303037,
0.5494474769,
-0.4437457621,
0.717056036,
0.1138843819,
0.0707596689,
-0.4148273766,
-0.4733402133,
0.7381109595,
0.1397546977,
0.3937297463,
0.0817304924,
-0.0487922356,
0.6218963861,
-0.4792551994,
0.776838243,
0.3502815366,
-0.2074590921,
-0.0106201898,
0.0626316816,
0.4037585557,
0.197755456,
0.0295790378,
-0.434795022,
-0.1229967028,
-0.4295823872,
-0.2364299893,
0.4492835701,
-0.4635798037,
-0.0456689484,
-0.7555188537,
-0.6027587652,
-0.103219077,
0.3568934202,
0.5539658666,
0.8273422718,
-0.3385600448,
-0.0191692431,
0.5487600565,
-0.1489723623,
0.8981025815,
0.6060484648,
-0.1138036475,
-0.7004343867,
0.6009130478,
0.029257087,
0.1747057736,
0.3974970877,
-0.0678391084,
-0.2342757583,
-0.6379563212,
-0.4578765929,
0.2289364189,
-0.4871288538,
-0.1563278139,
-0.5049529076,
-0.0556887686,
-0.661265254,
-0.1647091657,
-0.6324008107,
-1.1493048668,
0.0263704043,
-0.5036655664,
0.1101056933,
1.0149993896,
0.19503434,
0.447445184,
-0.8198841214,
0.7058010697,
-0.0446667112,
0.3959017992,
-0.01638381,
-0.5658912659,
-0.5201735497,
-0.1798484325,
-0.5880080462,
-1.1568721533,
0.7372481227,
0.0232237726,
0.0704257935,
0.289683491,
0.2024178356,
0.312359333,
-0.6029797196,
0.680845201,
0.2107570469,
-0.9719446898,
0.4390796423,
-0.5928446651,
0.5786485076,
0.296857208,
0.2328043133,
-0.976213038,
-0.6911603212,
-0.6367871165,
-0.9217182398,
0.8553031683,
0.4543011189,
0.1959982216,
0.0871546641,
0.2821123898,
0.3083409071,
0.3206216991,
-0.8385867476,
-0.1245307326,
-0.3337757289,
-0.4645369947,
-0.2856602371,
-0.5822776556,
0.359118104,
0.0904576406,
1.0719355345,
0.2504926622,
0.1133181155,
0.2187449634,
-0.2991562784,
-0.1056792066,
0.5941061378,
1.0633312464,
0.8311526179,
-0.2397222817,
0.0044957283,
0.0270101298,
-0.5515457392,
0.0084145572,
0.2366823703,
-0.4578042626,
0.4885160029,
0.4026650488,
0.6882748008,
0.3618123829,
-0.2703603804,
0.1959314048,
-0.3126531243,
-0.0772925317,
-0.4111441374,
-0.6358805895,
0.0715764239,
0.2658475935,
0.508552134,
0.1770845801,
0.5123255253,
-0.7887644172,
0.1490146369,
-0.0465462543,
-0.1289419234,
-0.6001163125,
0.760173142,
0.4362602532,
-0.0412547402,
0.2072214633,
-0.2087836266,
-0.5783198476,
0.5004240274,
0.2449091375,
1.0753290653,
-0.381998688,
0.2572390735,
0.3930698037,
0.3139131069,
-0.2580275238,
0.4731600583,
0.1044336557,
-0.3315977156,
-0.7236196995,
-0.31027022,
-0.2368413806,
0.1004961506,
-0.4321020544,
0.4150434434,
-0.2646510005,
-0.2631140053,
0.1929084659,
0.1140731201,
-0.1123062894,
0.4024201632,
0.1706767976,
0.9751051664,
-0.8121868372,
0.6895042062,
0.7020770311,
-0.4715400636,
-0.4213555753,
-0.0881142542,
0.0765447468,
-0.2126343846,
0.2981046438,
-0.1352166235,
0.1392520368,
0.2240969241,
0.0612140447,
-0.7827826142,
1.0273649693,
0.3732583821,
-0.3256361783,
-0.5868815184,
0.2897904813,
0.3709541559,
-0.2989955842,
0.1523833424,
0.3666082919,
0.2745607495,
0.0167637859,
-1.0266078711,
0.0251370296,
-0.3943104148,
-0.0161272921,
0.2275944799,
-0.5253193378,
0.6899307966,
-0.3893719912,
-0.1057093889,
0.4083280563,
0.8506379724,
0.1167043597,
0.4218661189,
-0.1075340062,
0.8281699419,
0.3693997562,
-0.0407957323,
1.3281280994,
-0.4551356137,
0.4964784682,
1.1799530983,
0.4963659942,
0.489839077,
0.2832506001,
0.1137007996,
0.2851420939,
0.8095032573,
0.2835921645,
0.7649261355,
-0.1355248243,
-0.2995553017,
0.1601081491,
0.276784867,
-0.522849977,
0.0604174547,
0.089943938,
-0.6670453548,
-0.5314935446,
0.058024738,
0.2592299879,
-0.0034919635,
-0.5290613174,
0.9262554646,
0.2393271774,
-0.6679540873,
0.2828164101,
0.6741040945,
0.5675671101,
-0.3691284955,
0.3374328017,
-0.5655376315,
0.1701758653,
-0.2594155371,
-0.4196355045,
0.3961447179,
0.2820260823,
-0.1958067119,
-0.2419529259,
0.358548224,
-0.3270560205,
-0.8836115003,
-0.4249061942,
0.3406252861,
0.0409442112,
0.036853157,
-0.2144442648,
-0.4044159353,
-0.1575325578,
-0.2985282242,
-0.1194905788,
0.6765480638,
-0.1796690971,
0.5456632972,
0.3141422868,
0.1672614664,
0.2920552492,
-0.0133649148,
0.6339402795,
-0.7875201702,
-1.2000219822,
-1.0135899782,
0.74621135,
0.0442940108,
-0.3572902381,
0.7579604983,
1.0739957094,
0.286719501,
-0.4621516466,
1.1444984674,
0.0439447835,
0.9612439275,
-0.6085588932,
0.6403787732,
-0.2065102011,
0.323721379,
-0.6010550857,
-0.9282565117,
-0.1749490947,
0.1985057592,
-0.3522714376,
-0.0264190957,
0.8351139426,
0.0521950386,
-0.5260025263,
0.3092139363,
0.0588639043,
0.2689225078,
0.1667105108,
0.5017226934,
0.6590418816,
-0.5791486502,
0.4252003729,
-0.3001658618,
0.1948177218,
-0.3492554724,
-0.920573175,
-0.9208127856,
-0.7898632288,
-0.3014678061,
-0.0665861368,
0.4365358949,
0.8244724274,
0.5851966739,
-1.0437122583,
-0.239374876,
-0.3536439836,
0.077732034,
-0.1791495532,
-0.1343397945,
0.5658850074,
-0.459215492,
-0.8221166134,
0.2210396081,
-0.0341994166,
0.2756052613,
0.0386255942,
-0.1198224351,
0.0575738847,
0.1428092718,
0.6220491529,
0.3418363333,
-0.7599183321,
0.2112617046,
-0.1802247763,
0.0509711467,
0.0622146465,
0.9542526007,
-0.8875507116,
0.081411615,
0.5813348889,
0.5451456308,
0.5417565107,
0.2130073607,
0.8900570273,
-0.8381418586,
0.0593509488,
0.2783563435,
0.4813031256,
0.2293461114,
-0.1299322993,
0.6016137004,
0.0503991991,
0.0255607851,
-0.7979461551,
0.2202002406,
-0.8589174747,
-0.2186559886,
0.7632393837,
0.0488138497,
0.2575458586,
-0.0029671474,
-0.1757882237,
0.559454143,
-0.5867780447,
1.2465907335,
0.7012324929,
0.1714408845,
-0.5979130864,
-0.6867322922,
0.6146251559,
0.2535944581,
-0.8178098202,
-0.218644172,
0.339027971,
0.2935350835,
-0.0229827855,
0.4349346757,
-0.2693073153,
0.5860564113,
-0.5729129314,
-0.0403962657,
-0.1780957133,
0.0491294377,
-0.3939853311,
0.2786976695,
-0.2180296332,
-0.0647742003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07766v1
|
Vision-Language Integration in Multimodal Video Transformers (Partially) Aligns with the Brain
| 2023-11-13T21:32:37 | 2023-11-13T21:32:37 |
Dota Tianai Dong, Mariya Toneva
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Integrating information from multiple modalities is arguably one of the
essential prerequisites for grounding artificial intelligence systems with an
understanding of the real world. Recent advances in video transformers that
jointly learn from vision, text, and sound over time have made some progress
toward this goal, but the degree to which these models integrate information
from modalities still remains unclear. In this work, we present a promising
approach for probing a pre-trained multimodal video transformer model by
leveraging neuroscientific evidence of multimodal information processing in the
brain. Using brain recordings of participants watching a popular TV show, we
analyze the effects of multi-modal connections and interactions in a
pre-trained multi-modal video transformer on the alignment with uni- and
multi-modal brain regions. We find evidence that vision enhances masked
prediction performance during language processing, providing support that
cross-modal representations in models can benefit individual modalities.
However, we don't find evidence of brain-relevant information captured by the
joint multi-modal transformer representations beyond that captured by all of
the individual modalities. We finally show that the brain alignment of the
pre-trained joint representation can be improved by fine-tuning using a task
that requires vision-language inferences. Overall, our results paint an
optimistic picture of the ability of multi-modal transformers to integrate
vision and language in partially brain-relevant ways but also show that
improving the brain alignment of these models may require new approaches.
|
[
-0.6046574116,
-0.6065677404,
0.4597454667,
-0.1368045062,
-0.1364971697,
-0.0704731271,
-0.4389005899,
-0.3649592996,
0.2686403692,
0.1660521626,
-0.7386738658,
0.080987893,
-0.7917190194,
-0.2103957683,
-0.1883963197,
0.7186992764,
0.1090144664,
0.3973474205,
-0.1740335822,
-0.0115720648,
-0.7775917053,
-0.3280186653,
-0.0527264625,
-0.3643196523,
0.4008468986,
-0.0114868674,
0.8121200204,
0.4633358419,
0.5697675347,
0.3428676724,
0.4481312931,
0.1584053338,
-0.1763915718,
-0.1218172163,
-0.1593745798,
-0.5447167158,
-0.3906804621,
0.1244057715,
0.5320863724,
0.6075034738,
0.006309025,
0.1692068279,
0.0740347058,
0.0944361612,
-0.7466001511,
0.252738893,
-0.4740287364,
0.2049206793,
-0.1769313514,
-0.358522892,
-0.5656083822,
0.3252469301,
0.1899783164,
-0.4313678145,
0.1684955209,
-0.1235020012,
0.8752720356,
0.73365134,
-0.6860749722,
0.1813130677,
-0.894261539,
0.6949971318,
-0.3709542453,
0.8789853454,
0.2615265846,
0.5135850906,
0.1074952632,
-0.586186111,
-1.070433259,
-0.0490469187,
-0.4470250607,
0.378413707,
-0.1839805692,
0.3478398323,
0.3284071386,
0.0598428659,
-0.4054506719,
-0.112105675,
-0.2642078102,
-0.4181967974,
0.18198663,
0.0109954635,
0.4186845124,
-0.3770143092,
-0.3557217717,
-0.5051814914,
0.1398207694,
0.1878535897,
0.2464837283,
-0.0163344033,
-0.1914468706,
0.7514362931,
0.179727003,
0.7240839005,
0.0678174645,
-0.246931538,
0.3166768551,
-0.7780306339,
-0.2727302313,
-0.028211372,
0.8058307171,
0.396205157,
0.2099548131,
-0.1123014987,
-0.1230100542,
0.5501992106,
0.4211170971,
-0.4797124267,
-0.377387315,
-0.1544285566,
-0.555490613,
0.1645307541,
0.149261564,
-0.7240823507,
-0.2905972898,
-0.5519946218,
0.8174264431,
-0.4409536421,
-0.4659854472,
0.1022693589,
-0.3075599074,
0.365908742,
0.2502739727,
-0.8654614091,
-0.1076067165,
0.2852559984,
0.3778694868,
0.0152836861,
-0.5924780965,
-0.3661957383,
0.3371022046,
-0.0601288043,
0.7966066599,
-0.8234324455,
0.3208953142,
0.0138598429,
0.137855351,
-0.3976646066,
-0.1508585811,
0.1804622263,
-0.5751908422,
0.5091768503,
-0.0546770804,
0.048491478,
-0.2509837747,
0.2797203958,
-0.8726687431,
0.624946475,
-0.1882247776,
-0.5427606106,
0.6093446016,
-0.6139310598,
-0.4257910252,
-0.3134472668,
-0.5704258084,
-0.1659827828,
0.1878357679,
0.3673563898,
0.379204601,
-0.1446667612,
0.4444577396,
-0.0888722837,
-0.2568801939,
0.600084424,
-0.9886415005,
0.3068453968,
-0.0726847276,
-0.3707364202,
0.1347196102,
-0.4350885451,
-0.1605821997,
-0.2405549735,
0.0534416772,
-0.1711084992,
-0.0277727228,
0.0349466391,
0.4545867145,
0.3225556016,
-0.5023582578,
-0.0517795198,
-0.0376848355,
0.305214256,
0.5969712138,
-0.3589856327,
0.6773757935,
-0.1223117113,
0.4566411376,
0.4318525791,
0.3764805794,
-0.4762219787,
-0.3708218932,
-0.8110900521,
-0.3588822186,
0.2054074407,
0.4624387622,
-0.9960299134,
0.1580928117,
-0.5232130885,
-0.1087307781,
-0.6833959222,
-0.1059410721,
0.2107542604,
0.3748071492,
0.5860241055,
-0.3204794526,
-0.5281155109,
-1.1150273085,
-0.1142628267,
0.0680594519,
-0.2033873051,
0.2458165735,
0.2943636775,
-0.2859306335,
0.9239261746,
-0.3792873621,
-0.4484778047,
-0.0514765903,
0.3142859936,
0.184315443,
0.390571326,
0.3829661608,
-1.0837205648,
-0.1027126461,
0.1475427002,
-0.6783898473,
0.2450882345,
-0.3242174387,
0.0077233156,
-0.1546204686,
0.3436288238,
-0.5990483165,
0.4714212716,
0.7525273561,
-0.3471204638,
0.1443100721,
-0.2171379924,
0.5164595842,
-0.9326886535,
-0.1412457675,
-0.0883916318,
-0.1060858592,
-0.5625740886,
-0.4399116337,
0.1731974185,
-0.0730760992,
-0.3527318239,
0.0640348047,
-0.4765872061,
-0.0926870927,
-0.2656826377,
0.0692464337,
-0.0708266571,
0.7293001413,
0.1235598847,
0.7653849125,
0.7587561011,
-0.3050846457,
0.2989712358,
0.1624713689,
-0.4226077795,
0.5754563808,
-0.2526654005,
-0.0908558294,
-0.4722429514,
0.116572611,
-1.0887805223,
-0.4360826015,
0.0597281046,
-0.4336895943,
0.4439628422,
0.0037512151,
-0.2545895278,
-0.0680748746,
-0.0005951237,
0.8624045253,
0.3720719814,
-0.3767399788,
1.3396587372,
0.3518168628,
0.243945241,
-0.7585477829,
-0.8154777884,
0.1215448603,
-0.1020878702,
-0.7580615878,
0.594050765,
0.0326722264,
0.0856276229,
0.0348231569,
-0.2238213122,
-0.1866642982,
-0.3734960854,
0.1951643825,
0.4342514575,
-0.3602686524,
-0.0204094239,
0.0807302743,
-0.0124582564,
0.0919590071,
0.0346317068,
0.5542408228,
-0.029502444,
-0.5599861145,
-0.7397805452,
0.3179662824,
0.8836517334,
-0.5264485478,
0.6516242027,
0.9193425775,
-0.3035560548,
0.1608439982,
-0.8926463127,
-0.4822061658,
-0.4262344539,
0.6388194561,
-0.4542748034,
-0.6872144938,
0.2664386332,
-0.1246755868,
-0.3885763586,
0.0866252035,
0.3233696818,
-0.2904040515,
1.3991467953,
0.8659209013,
0.3570250571,
0.9534031153,
-0.2644384801,
0.4567213655,
-0.7579679489,
-0.6499134302,
0.0859482139,
-0.6924253106,
-0.3763742745,
-0.7434443235,
0.5152309537,
-0.163546145,
0.0692828894,
0.5005486608,
-0.2890338898,
0.6132181287,
0.3777602613,
0.3733540177,
0.2251770198,
-0.2021833509,
0.035787791,
-0.3471113145,
-0.7381597161,
-0.0932568014,
0.714805305,
0.3022753894,
0.8514975309,
0.0971727967,
0.0043114009,
0.0425377414,
0.1408240348,
-0.7386987209,
0.4365565181,
-0.2562471628,
-0.4463834465,
0.0126518458,
-0.0668911263,
-0.6008377671,
0.2382956445,
-0.5714076161,
-0.5057663321,
0.4970979989,
0.1720931828,
-0.2843567729,
0.0815961733,
-0.9138100147,
1.1622934341,
-0.5039390326,
-0.3294207454,
-0.5022953153,
-0.8142228723,
0.5226346254,
-0.1501986533,
0.2450776398,
0.3208800256,
0.0820482671,
0.6188533306,
0.1830457002,
0.9426493645,
-0.0328270793,
0.0106003908,
-0.1043355763,
-0.0465191863,
0.0255109742,
0.0392811634,
0.5066925883,
0.4331505895,
0.0442007408,
-0.1699910313,
-0.8862286806,
0.4243074656,
-0.8094477057,
-0.5151277781,
-0.364703536,
-0.8828312159,
-0.2543417215,
0.2261460423,
0.1458607018,
0.5207798481,
0.2135876864,
0.2336037308,
0.5944077969,
-0.0272296928,
0.662853241,
0.2610068023,
-0.0353705287,
-0.60002774,
0.699991107,
-0.0912521705,
0.3446438015,
0.5670326948,
-0.0119755454,
-0.2031854987,
-0.215562582,
-0.325086534,
0.2265284956,
-0.654886961,
-0.1663624495,
-0.4931294918,
-0.0378397591,
-0.343120724,
0.040401835,
-0.4508632123,
-0.0052852239,
0.0420585908,
0.0359337479,
-0.1659314334,
0.4423966706,
0.0172802284,
0.3729915619,
-0.8065951467,
0.4532788098,
0.5816963911,
0.2478088737,
-0.1554662883,
-0.4328356385,
-0.3716903329,
0.4287101924,
-0.1977306455,
-0.92230618,
0.1657567769,
0.2789880335,
0.6225898266,
0.5488465428,
-0.289023459,
1.1731362343,
-0.5681616664,
0.835298419,
0.5783976316,
-0.9228802323,
0.4369831681,
-0.0228790808,
0.3566292524,
0.3526678979,
0.3159780204,
-0.2634954154,
-0.1662418991,
-0.0916782618,
-0.2705215812,
0.8415893912,
0.1305002868,
0.2742511332,
0.0711511374,
-0.1437855959,
0.0972510576,
0.2535326779,
-0.8435250521,
-0.266677171,
-0.611358881,
-0.1110765189,
-0.0807083026,
0.0642504618,
-0.3194648325,
-0.475787431,
0.0509591624,
-0.2511622906,
0.5504361391,
0.0186438598,
-0.3370966613,
0.0209376514,
0.0845393091,
0.6643201709,
0.4963767827,
0.0796497762,
0.624537468,
0.0421220101,
-0.5227187276,
0.030891547,
0.101888299,
0.2493811399,
0.0163634066,
0.438905865,
0.9987650514,
0.3377496302,
-0.6854384542,
0.7738526464,
-0.2865409255,
0.0214145277,
-0.2397949845,
-0.1238730848,
-0.2232213318,
0.6819930673,
0.363617003,
0.7564406991,
-0.0951268524,
-0.6747279167,
0.3137224317,
0.6723229289,
-0.4175722003,
-0.6509940624,
0.7001677752,
-0.0684069619,
-0.3597583771,
0.500823319,
0.2635129094,
-0.5928174257,
0.2595890164,
0.5341560841,
0.647012651,
-0.2514782548,
0.0781221762,
0.103866227,
0.372408092,
0.0007034874,
0.1172530279,
-0.419927597,
-0.9903403521,
-1.0401785374,
-0.4844785631,
0.0629762486,
-0.0517399535,
-0.5157719254,
0.4943230748,
0.149579823,
-0.4437470734,
-0.0610501021,
-0.7830021381,
-0.8914608955,
0.1516977698,
0.4826169312,
0.4388211966,
-1.1311465502,
0.9643859863,
0.7757948637,
-0.663441062,
-0.7556748986,
0.256265074,
-0.373313725,
-0.7068789601,
0.9049105644,
0.2382975817,
-0.3852806389,
-0.1410836428,
-0.2351857126,
-0.8917046785,
0.9994793534,
0.7199726701,
-0.2370121479,
-0.3791817427,
0.3839111924,
0.3669565618,
-0.1841407716,
0.7209938765,
0.3594305515,
0.6238610744,
0.0553542301,
-1.272668004,
-0.1875861138,
-0.3236250579,
-0.1923933476,
0.4959915876,
-0.448390305,
0.7727150917,
-0.027373489,
-0.2205161601,
-0.5472884774,
0.8063194752,
-0.3746141493,
0.214830637,
0.7158127427,
0.4505699873,
0.344484508,
-0.0591802001,
0.6500908732,
-0.3485175669,
0.179907158,
0.8328517079,
0.1467497945,
0.589568615,
0.9914543629,
0.0567282476,
0.6640369296,
0.0590997078,
0.1081130877,
0.7358897924,
-0.4464127123,
-0.223562941,
-0.7271939516,
-0.3339597583,
-0.1785311997,
0.9977353811,
0.2262010276,
-0.4839884937,
-0.042151548,
0.562749207,
-0.3963030279,
0.0091596646,
-0.0286713727,
0.6508168578,
-0.1201275885,
-0.9249330163,
0.2902870774,
-0.3315809667,
0.9367385507,
-0.6489423513,
-0.1989800036,
0.0738212541,
0.148426801,
-0.1342265606,
-0.586507082,
0.3199031055,
-0.282389015,
-0.3348304927,
-0.5171387196,
0.4345785975,
-0.7100574374,
-0.180718556,
0.3421210945,
0.4122089148,
-0.1192775145,
-0.0205037966,
-0.2598745823,
0.102891013,
-0.084615767,
-0.0011121297,
0.4233736992,
0.3726772964,
0.1303480715,
0.2541146576,
0.4645899236,
-0.1394392848,
0.3272726536,
0.0330318995,
0.8665990829,
-0.5456053615,
-0.2526730299,
-0.9287092686,
0.8165956736,
-0.0231402609,
-0.1420713365,
0.5868690014,
0.4290335178,
1.0434174538,
-0.2787283063,
0.5023059249,
-0.1802954376,
-0.3316717744,
-0.7062442303,
0.549518466,
-0.6520374417,
-0.0379495956,
-0.2128509432,
-0.9690418839,
-0.2399622351,
0.6935905814,
-0.3332763016,
-0.0826933905,
1.1072864532,
0.8614475727,
-0.4483837485,
-0.0099878991,
0.4864096642,
0.0962330177,
0.27310431,
0.5634130239,
0.8563199639,
-0.5041157603,
0.8122320175,
-0.572737813,
-0.2753280997,
0.1915275902,
-0.7843997478,
-0.9164317846,
-0.8388364911,
-0.1462264806,
-0.0415436476,
-0.3091663122,
0.6177424192,
0.8231408,
-0.4424255192,
-0.1412041187,
0.1987172067,
-0.2556931376,
-0.3894288242,
-0.2154935449,
0.1167165488,
-0.1225593388,
-0.9025892019,
0.6517073512,
0.3057792783,
-0.1843912154,
-0.4385857582,
0.0769039765,
-0.1922433078,
-0.1916299611,
0.6353521347,
-0.2036247551,
-0.8595582843,
-0.526853621,
0.3982104361,
0.058610592,
0.1478698105,
1.0464345217,
-1.005192399,
0.8189871311,
0.5797021389,
0.6289389133,
0.5240046382,
-0.0874457955,
0.6954506636,
-0.5707805157,
0.134096697,
0.1366404146,
0.5252559185,
0.1544338316,
-0.2177199423,
0.0080781495,
0.2300043553,
-0.3761608303,
-0.6949936152,
0.4156007469,
-1.2937897444,
-0.126065433,
0.8405761719,
0.3055649996,
-0.2720012069,
-0.0177455042,
-0.3819381893,
0.6278931499,
-0.1433489323,
0.6621310115,
0.644064486,
-0.2444045097,
-0.4035445452,
-0.5825805664,
0.1572991759,
0.6302565336,
-0.4596973658,
-0.2217725962,
0.5339741707,
0.0352755561,
0.5764644146,
0.1101638079,
0.0088205421,
0.3961768746,
-0.0967449471,
0.0438364558,
-0.1175630167,
-0.5228374004,
-0.3066043258,
0.2501226664,
-0.5022069216,
-0.4732267857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07723v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07723v3
|
Generalization Analogies: A Testbed for Generalizing AI Oversight to Hard-To-Measure Domains
| 2023-11-13T20:07:36 | 2023-12-17T21:18:14 |
Joshua Clymer, Garrett Baker, Rohan Subramani, Sam Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As AI systems become more intelligent and their behavior becomes more
challenging to assess, they may learn to game the flaws of human feedback
instead of genuinely striving to follow instructions; however, this risk can be
mitigated by controlling how LLMs generalize human feedback to situations where
it is unreliable. To better understand how reward models generalize, we craft
69 distribution shifts spanning 8 categories. We find that reward models do not
learn to evaluate `instruction-following' by default and instead favor personas
that resemble internet text. Techniques for interpreting reward models'
internal representations achieve better generalization than standard
fine-tuning, but still frequently fail to distinguish instruction-following
from conflated behaviors. We consolidate the 15 most challenging distribution
shifts into the GENeralization analogIES (GENIES) benchmark, which we hope will
enable progress toward controlling reward model generalization.
|
[
-0.1939328313,
-0.3528783619,
0.2956805229,
0.0911237448,
0.118907921,
-0.1500125825,
-0.0707229599,
-0.2953135669,
-0.0292358696,
0.4004509151,
-0.8157491088,
-0.0937767327,
-0.8341879845,
0.0749833584,
-0.2982194424,
1.3718750477,
-0.0024141208,
0.0054862872,
-0.2908113599,
-0.1287805438,
-0.5020804405,
-0.5599042773,
-0.6053224802,
-0.605722487,
0.4588896036,
0.0658360496,
0.700456202,
0.4800062478,
0.8601203561,
0.3099708855,
0.2764601111,
-0.0210147444,
-0.6387457848,
-0.2706920505,
-0.425408572,
-0.753246069,
-0.4174391627,
0.3144040108,
0.3337894976,
0.8677201271,
-0.1733551025,
0.1543234885,
0.0741906166,
0.8921173215,
-0.9819386601,
0.5173223019,
-0.3203535676,
-0.0464239866,
0.1190865114,
-0.012568987,
-0.3489584923,
-0.462148428,
0.2600220144,
-0.7506776452,
0.1100391299,
-0.0508829392,
0.8049081564,
0.4578693211,
-0.3583817184,
-0.4995317459,
-1.0319584608,
0.9443691373,
-0.1957934052,
0.0138639193,
0.5290326476,
0.4658211768,
-0.0730709061,
-0.5149562955,
-0.2602515519,
-0.4196399152,
0.0225072391,
-0.0065143942,
-0.249079898,
0.2057799846,
0.1032430902,
0.1758397967,
-0.1175636277,
-0.1128948033,
-0.1917537004,
0.0253660083,
0.7945036292,
0.4024997354,
0.3069147766,
0.2423487157,
-0.3723786473,
-0.7209687233,
-0.8598291874,
0.3755610287,
0.4738910496,
-0.1640000939,
-0.1328021586,
0.5106229782,
-0.2121717632,
0.3881421983,
0.1330739558,
0.2576866448,
0.3368545175,
-0.2920876145,
-0.1706990898,
-0.4020611048,
0.3927375078,
0.4866895676,
0.5485615134,
-0.2365897149,
-0.50631392,
0.1415858418,
0.6396554708,
-0.3849415183,
-0.3275127411,
0.0099376589,
-0.6965332627,
-0.3772172928,
0.3999324739,
-0.5322014093,
-0.4668529928,
-0.3834910989,
0.5842720866,
-0.2362453341,
-0.006135317,
0.0743087083,
-0.5006064773,
0.5679180622,
0.5004913807,
-1.290671587,
0.6414328814,
0.784617424,
0.5131252408,
-0.4808373749,
-0.2781551778,
-0.3635341525,
0.2763017714,
-0.4512658119,
0.8597732782,
-0.7347748876,
-0.3443620801,
0.0358986482,
-0.0408110358,
-0.2514685094,
-0.9111330509,
0.1609074771,
-0.3334403038,
-0.0300662499,
-0.0978294089,
-0.7600920796,
0.0011830385,
0.4766823053,
-0.3941044807,
0.5178329349,
0.4498548806,
-0.3542362452,
0.1817377955,
-0.8694224954,
-0.0823763311,
-0.2785792351,
-0.0840209499,
-0.2095826417,
0.2858449221,
0.0395694599,
0.2556480467,
-0.3619953394,
0.105486922,
-0.2671445012,
-0.6967846751,
0.0926008299,
-0.3413023651,
0.6870052814,
-0.0105853472,
-0.5865378976,
0.3429560661,
-0.281199187,
0.0270966403,
0.182649821,
0.0483330116,
-0.7327309847,
0.3041283488,
-0.3237181306,
-0.3174099624,
0.1976512223,
-0.0138039635,
0.6534349322,
-0.297177434,
0.3654122651,
1.0186975002,
-0.0554523021,
0.6622466445,
-0.5523589849,
0.5879972577,
0.1415909082,
0.4504033029,
0.1185313687,
-0.3664023876,
-0.781896174,
0.0199510213,
0.4331866205,
0.7693506479,
-0.7225732207,
0.322378993,
-0.3041038215,
-0.2727036178,
-0.5914742351,
-0.0719341636,
0.4259546995,
-0.008416594,
0.3387635946,
-0.4320573211,
0.0642945766,
-1.0137687922,
-0.2899817228,
-0.2104812562,
-0.5460959673,
0.2763157785,
0.6091200113,
-0.4589870274,
0.3637320101,
-0.5384543538,
-0.2997448742,
-0.0386961401,
0.1978378743,
-0.0124016441,
0.4360026121,
0.4553952813,
-0.8547353745,
-0.0838308185,
-0.3053994477,
-0.6150171161,
0.270695895,
-0.0462174751,
0.0712737665,
-0.3590821922,
0.4931753576,
-0.3896493018,
0.4920853972,
0.2123959661,
-0.2996415198,
0.4856594801,
-0.2127495408,
0.0850452557,
-0.4568129778,
0.0741292238,
-0.0528211929,
0.1073698848,
-0.5998414755,
0.3373175859,
0.0608873218,
0.1857347786,
-0.2074948847,
0.5038556457,
-0.3230953813,
-0.1557241827,
-0.114106752,
-0.268918246,
-0.2844005227,
0.5672256947,
-0.2270500809,
0.8712040782,
0.4029385746,
-0.7694184184,
0.5058332682,
0.1907124072,
-0.1207176,
0.7188661098,
-0.9140097499,
0.1090753004,
-0.0942211226,
0.3822530508,
-0.7599897385,
-0.270265013,
0.4569595754,
-0.2633847296,
0.1762200147,
0.055855874,
-0.1958247274,
-0.1678793281,
-0.672829628,
0.3043218851,
0.6652965546,
-0.3047390878,
0.3391927183,
0.2386765331,
-0.0041151489,
-0.6646047831,
-0.435251236,
-0.2156261802,
-0.2941635251,
-0.0103836227,
0.2880223691,
-0.3235918581,
-0.4392128289,
-0.0069835037,
0.1365913153,
0.0134917088,
0.3951550126,
0.2297939658,
0.2317713648,
-0.0112390351,
0.3023531437,
0.0183813237,
0.0023892177,
0.44358325,
-0.140707463,
0.2873223424,
-0.022636164,
-0.5699211955,
-0.2448370159,
0.319388926,
0.2596608698,
0.1535580456,
0.4939153492,
0.1654367745,
-0.2938028276,
-0.216586262,
-0.1846357882,
-0.5191748142,
-0.4769804478,
0.3079439998,
-0.4191575944,
-0.5572487712,
0.3475771248,
-0.3212423921,
0.0725233331,
0.5612509847,
0.3714004457,
-0.2407273054,
1.2089529037,
0.759018898,
-0.3549080193,
0.3530532718,
-0.434224993,
-0.0200514942,
-0.7908192873,
-0.1563156843,
-0.4784350693,
-0.4606494904,
-0.7891921401,
-0.2246355712,
0.3392086327,
-0.0695168748,
-0.3552370071,
-0.0446862243,
-0.5968055129,
0.6397686005,
0.8714496493,
0.0428768024,
-0.0496768765,
0.0307354759,
0.1521167159,
0.1802491993,
-0.4365642369,
-0.282135129,
1.2746266127,
0.222336635,
0.9344652891,
0.1860846132,
0.7222052813,
0.7037300467,
0.6791910529,
-0.5933255553,
0.2195728421,
-0.3868374527,
-0.3773839772,
-0.4133835137,
-0.3180067837,
-1.0297147036,
-0.0443962775,
0.0029293201,
-0.6867830157,
0.2823103964,
0.2696504295,
-0.0817172825,
0.1964631677,
-0.781013608,
0.7156558037,
0.0153336283,
-0.0131543111,
-0.3270349801,
-0.8157783747,
0.3318114579,
0.3626004755,
0.099865526,
-0.1198713854,
-0.0305617303,
0.4041977227,
-0.2369378507,
1.0015588999,
-0.1792392433,
0.2135280073,
0.2405073941,
0.1156485304,
0.5805262923,
-0.1824872196,
0.100502193,
0.0542292632,
-0.0456861332,
-0.6515302062,
-0.8909884691,
0.4443722963,
-1.2356101274,
-0.8177840114,
-0.4553512931,
-0.5623694062,
-0.412366271,
-0.1257463247,
0.3010981381,
0.0518440753,
-0.3065397143,
0.002069812,
0.6754507422,
-0.0729214177,
0.0306716096,
0.068112649,
0.2739183605,
-0.1405607313,
1.0776811838,
-0.38236624,
0.3678749204,
0.5540588498,
0.2118936032,
-0.3357757628,
-0.4061692357,
-0.5739039779,
0.0319783092,
-0.6326416731,
-0.1388490051,
-0.1554737836,
-0.2478533089,
-0.4023532867,
-0.185213536,
-0.086741589,
-0.3635291457,
-0.4737222791,
0.1691277921,
-0.0117633315,
1.3770686388,
0.0016898317,
0.1999576986,
-0.4433752596,
0.3391364217,
0.6896647215,
0.4581419826,
0.1209620088,
-0.5244750381,
0.0455626249,
0.2795880139,
-0.6065493226,
-0.7340127826,
0.1310842782,
0.2449243814,
0.6278789639,
0.4922363758,
0.1270963997,
0.4915650189,
-0.4378456175,
0.8330650926,
0.2664882243,
-0.8888512254,
0.4478488266,
-0.2504039705,
0.1750180125,
0.3332311809,
0.4468657374,
-0.4748012424,
-0.4375875294,
-0.6603161693,
-0.64759022,
0.5742675662,
0.1136189699,
0.461830169,
-0.0410887562,
0.6152228117,
0.0111638047,
0.3688454628,
-0.6682357192,
-0.502430439,
-0.4145469069,
-0.3181628585,
-0.4391589165,
-0.1326194853,
-0.3985620737,
-0.121001102,
0.2744859159,
-0.2054919302,
0.6528368592,
0.0086123468,
-0.0134827122,
-0.0307486318,
0.2694754899,
0.8808678389,
0.6492372751,
-0.1938814223,
0.2310505062,
-0.1270122081,
-0.2895196378,
0.5063880086,
-0.0308067519,
-0.3167984486,
-0.3841583133,
0.3565574884,
0.7626100183,
0.1212897599,
-0.7434303761,
0.6235304475,
0.0825457647,
-0.2363727093,
-0.3711918294,
0.7504146695,
0.0177409258,
0.1708380282,
0.3732729852,
0.0599087439,
0.4713213444,
-0.7441999912,
0.0245474298,
0.6218944192,
-0.7014293075,
-0.4957879484,
0.6306014061,
0.1772494167,
-0.5566108227,
0.8635599017,
-0.329880178,
-0.2990889251,
1.0566687584,
0.3311247528,
0.9379885197,
-0.1995048523,
0.4212385416,
-0.0332709178,
0.2964849472,
-0.4035142958,
-0.0862597451,
0.0389979258,
-0.7037793398,
-0.0411509946,
-0.0690962747,
-0.8325591087,
0.0789384544,
-0.8716198802,
0.045740772,
-0.4370624125,
0.0230553187,
0.0825599506,
-0.2867480218,
-0.8355972171,
0.1361336112,
-0.1005947962,
0.6360051036,
-0.861710012,
0.6813231707,
0.8124734759,
-0.3470875919,
-0.6444549561,
0.0736697912,
-0.0165093374,
-0.8978009224,
0.749130547,
0.0764644071,
0.1906997263,
-0.2772229612,
-0.9045014977,
-0.6351541281,
0.9845856428,
0.1211356074,
-0.3328803182,
-0.071538195,
0.0505198166,
0.7272518873,
-0.4903720915,
0.5463510752,
0.6531043649,
0.406919986,
-0.1885950863,
-0.7552708387,
-0.1728877574,
-0.2613711357,
-0.0038533243,
0.1806155294,
-0.6924943328,
0.8621419072,
-0.3421705961,
0.1270917505,
-0.0047605271,
0.3089726865,
0.2760563493,
0.5593212247,
0.7141388655,
0.2732547224,
0.4817119241,
0.0279788449,
1.3198527098,
0.1961072087,
0.2980543971,
1.0003720522,
-0.3398376405,
0.6574497223,
0.5651330352,
-0.5014304519,
0.6042562723,
0.6346899867,
-0.1438301653,
0.7529709935,
0.7263246179,
0.0491954163,
-0.0281131137,
-0.0185520165,
-0.2842235863,
0.1997207254,
0.4940196574,
-0.2182872891,
-0.1234274954,
-0.1232124344,
-0.5565843582,
0.0118984487,
-0.3345115781,
0.8893588185,
-0.0730857477,
-0.8179810643,
0.5818137527,
-0.0510776751,
0.5969386697,
-0.7493200302,
-0.5892519355,
-0.46043396,
0.3234139085,
0.3615129888,
-0.5273666978,
0.0475675426,
-0.2347597033,
-0.3040154576,
-0.1857624948,
0.4632727504,
-0.0617582574,
-0.3092103004,
0.2485641241,
0.4551933408,
0.2111058384,
0.0534488857,
-0.8108302355,
-0.1888963729,
0.1500894278,
-0.3973701298,
0.6355620027,
0.1745376736,
-0.4655913115,
0.9510118365,
0.3166203201,
0.1212369204,
0.0680380315,
-0.0810152888,
0.7382092476,
-0.6861101985,
-0.3854561746,
-0.6330618858,
0.0936673507,
0.0427752063,
-0.5255679488,
0.3195495605,
0.0538967848,
0.9843056798,
-0.4834428132,
0.7785363793,
0.087195687,
0.2971821427,
-0.3584890366,
0.3556902111,
-0.5756750703,
0.2829075754,
-0.1906827241,
-0.9581631422,
-0.233854115,
0.5050429106,
-0.241464749,
0.1116821021,
0.4875659645,
0.4146222174,
-0.1794230938,
-0.250602752,
0.2973743081,
0.0736577064,
0.3389743268,
0.6307663321,
0.9257659912,
-0.2846982777,
0.3848859668,
-0.2090016454,
-0.1232758909,
-0.4444815516,
-0.6095636487,
-0.6990793347,
-0.3377517164,
-0.2931684554,
-0.1634003669,
0.4978713691,
0.7579682469,
0.6459873319,
-1.1920355558,
-0.3731999397,
-0.1936636716,
0.4169487655,
-0.749107182,
-0.2388258725,
0.5161312819,
-0.4793054163,
-0.7124278545,
0.0484531149,
0.1924997419,
0.1968645155,
-0.4191631675,
-0.1181925163,
0.1897475868,
0.2243857235,
0.2415488958,
0.3087106049,
-0.763254106,
-0.6887315512,
0.098640807,
-0.1822552979,
-0.0619620755,
0.8978341818,
-0.5267466903,
0.3471001387,
0.359380126,
0.5894445777,
0.1695476025,
0.167647019,
0.5616539717,
-0.5814090967,
0.0868479609,
0.23874259,
0.0534116551,
0.0922888443,
-0.3178205192,
0.7300692201,
0.3153082132,
-0.6157215834,
-0.6374597549,
0.2809024155,
-0.5891509652,
-0.3676618636,
0.8768274784,
-0.3731130064,
-0.2120263875,
0.0194014162,
0.1472831517,
-0.1891909242,
-0.324177593,
1.2960417271,
0.7823289633,
-0.342136085,
-0.1171957925,
-0.5429769158,
0.6522294879,
0.6596673131,
-0.8842515349,
-0.0446145125,
0.4182461798,
0.4903510213,
0.120213151,
0.5835822821,
0.1565065235,
0.3964310884,
-0.1664149612,
0.1344407052,
0.2481217533,
-0.3057080805,
-0.5586398244,
0.0340301841,
0.0905517787,
-0.3466487825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07715v1
|
PolyIE: A Dataset of Information Extraction from Polymer Material Scientific Literature
| 2023-11-13T19:56:18 | 2023-11-13T19:56:18 |
Jerry Junyang Cheung, Yuchen Zhuang, Yinghao Li, Pranav Shetty, Wantian Zhao, Sanjeev Grampurohit, Rampi Ramprasad, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Scientific information extraction (SciIE), which aims to automatically
extract information from scientific literature, is becoming more important than
ever. However, there are no existing SciIE datasets for polymer materials,
which is an important class of materials used ubiquitously in our daily lives.
To bridge this gap, we introduce POLYIE, a new SciIE dataset for polymer
materials. POLYIE is curated from 146 full-length polymer scholarly articles,
which are annotated with different named entities (i.e., materials, properties,
values, conditions) as well as their N-ary relations by domain experts. POLYIE
presents several unique challenges due to diverse lexical formats of entities,
ambiguity between entities, and variable-length relations. We evaluate
state-of-the-art named entity extraction and relation extraction models on
POLYIE, analyze their strengths and weaknesses, and highlight some difficult
cases for these models. To the best of our knowledge, POLYIE is the first SciIE
benchmark for polymer materials, and we hope it will lead to more research
efforts from the community on this challenging task. Our code and data are
available on: https://github.com/jerry3027/PolyIE.
|
[
-0.2966226637,
-0.3777151704,
0.6177750826,
0.0667996109,
-0.1441633701,
0.336415261,
0.0302053392,
-0.5578551888,
0.4663758278,
0.1371089816,
-0.2198511809,
-0.0926188231,
-0.7073248625,
0.3911281824,
-0.1289184839,
1.1012200117,
-0.0754048005,
-0.0724992603,
-0.6308709979,
0.0236991998,
0.2062542439,
-0.213589415,
-0.1553860903,
-0.1279432625,
0.6970590353,
0.3180347681,
0.3444387615,
0.3957992792,
0.8726468086,
0.2375320494,
-0.3176962435,
0.2800863087,
-0.5056367517,
-0.0059699984,
-0.4219251275,
-0.3615644276,
-0.6654042006,
0.3616621792,
0.6700792313,
0.6337495446,
0.1386370808,
0.7530010343,
-0.1407210678,
0.5510758758,
-0.8845896125,
0.2212994844,
-0.3362770677,
0.0030487962,
-0.4010297656,
-0.001967133,
-0.5654930472,
-0.398609966,
0.3569602668,
-0.7894021869,
0.2077356726,
0.1043100655,
1.2652057409,
-0.1612348557,
-0.2864282727,
0.0281110276,
-0.8452746868,
0.8627412915,
-0.1508362293,
0.3925615847,
-0.0816120505,
0.1602769941,
-0.4202612638,
-0.8390831351,
-0.6908265352,
0.0027687559,
-0.0016215832,
0.3047358394,
-0.0100252759,
-0.2359793633,
0.2513239384,
0.5457850099,
-0.2726510465,
-0.4223707914,
-0.7907592058,
0.179069072,
0.6830062866,
-0.3059932888,
0.2980214655,
-0.4614493549,
-0.6539087892,
-0.3310681283,
-0.3322587311,
-0.2474515438,
0.477512002,
-0.1097580045,
0.0231793821,
0.8287625909,
0.2458136082,
0.363640815,
-0.3615617454,
-0.1809204817,
0.4277305305,
-0.0509685203,
-0.1511591375,
-0.0705197379,
1.0490018129,
0.0850729048,
0.3205981851,
-0.1383491904,
-0.1342890412,
-0.4428635836,
0.0175742023,
-0.6177384257,
-0.3413026929,
0.3501534462,
-0.6270847917,
-0.5318007469,
0.5159774423,
-0.9188928604,
-0.4555920959,
-0.2248367518,
0.4340705872,
-0.2756043077,
-0.6435161829,
0.1596388072,
-0.6547563672,
-0.0603181794,
0.1722788066,
-0.8248512745,
0.4246124923,
0.8076642156,
0.9631614685,
-0.4308023155,
0.0220875721,
-0.0476772636,
0.344835341,
-0.1121251956,
0.8266147375,
-0.6866591573,
-0.1794836521,
-0.9437322617,
0.1524746716,
-0.1671760827,
-0.4734473526,
0.1479091048,
-0.0097842058,
0.4479852319,
-0.0100774439,
-0.5584676266,
-0.10808222,
-0.3751517236,
-0.9922235608,
0.8048475385,
0.3851779699,
-1.0356785059,
0.1639759392,
-0.2721035779,
0.0953219905,
0.1643369645,
-0.1341298968,
-0.4604825675,
0.5380828381,
-0.1063300893,
0.0702770352,
-1.0256659985,
0.247796312,
-0.4290316701,
-0.1495419145,
0.1348976791,
-0.2021827698,
0.768006742,
0.0546352193,
0.173816815,
-0.4122664928,
-0.9362041354,
-0.1785680056,
0.2137717903,
-0.0566499308,
-0.3570417464,
0.0802697018,
0.3163709939,
-0.0616747811,
0.4048421681,
-1.1522849798,
0.5237821937,
-0.1461823136,
0.1055028811,
0.9618346691,
0.0309496392,
0.2705568373,
-0.2403777689,
0.4259031117,
-0.3188300133,
0.3520787358,
0.4046292603,
-0.5221890211,
-0.3494885862,
-0.4178011417,
0.7694997787,
0.5494834185,
-0.5692963004,
-0.0385279953,
-0.3494660556,
-0.7715268731,
-0.1667425781,
-0.0668933466,
0.0271062236,
0.3747157454,
0.1860873252,
-0.4883262217,
-0.5002958179,
-0.8998062015,
0.1137643903,
-0.3204481602,
-0.0815286338,
0.7351151705,
0.5468396544,
0.0283223055,
1.118068099,
-0.7837914228,
-0.0819739401,
-0.1566386074,
0.5884308219,
0.6843989491,
0.1460488886,
0.5134263635,
-1.0015597343,
-0.3853128254,
0.1091259718,
-1.03597188,
0.0542446412,
-0.027739834,
-0.1074492857,
-0.0196535103,
0.1127864942,
-0.8576686382,
0.0502886921,
0.5879778266,
-0.1541976929,
0.878305316,
0.0539337806,
0.0405741669,
-1.0888313055,
0.4549878538,
0.1616052538,
0.0630904511,
-0.4969248474,
-0.1670946032,
-0.0709785298,
-0.290418148,
-0.5314507484,
0.4581422508,
-0.6216341853,
-0.1247166321,
-0.0512255765,
-0.1273437291,
0.3402701616,
0.0295896493,
0.3100884855,
0.7111350298,
0.6809382439,
-0.3058557808,
0.4690988958,
0.3583887219,
-0.1699191928,
0.0645638183,
-0.6268016696,
0.1277695149,
-0.4155152142,
0.177349925,
-0.2556511164,
-0.136395216,
0.2998610437,
-0.2919702828,
0.4083662331,
-0.3456500173,
-0.4437170923,
-0.2715129256,
-0.2629511058,
0.5517841578,
0.2746564448,
-0.2708435655,
0.9658619165,
0.6025495529,
-0.5067099333,
-0.6891070008,
0.202360183,
-0.0188901462,
-0.1836264133,
-0.3870413601,
0.3900938034,
-0.2811460495,
-0.2757868767,
0.0259391367,
-0.5393339992,
-0.4354114532,
-0.0647994205,
0.1751449108,
0.5318629146,
-0.1613136977,
0.4002156556,
-0.3716783822,
-0.0724110454,
0.1947618425,
0.0272215717,
0.3366883099,
-0.0894064754,
0.3606651723,
-0.2658193707,
0.2054596394,
0.7035658956,
-0.2062815726,
0.6350082755,
0.2525805235,
-0.3861334324,
-0.0289055295,
-0.4417859316,
-0.1829498112,
-0.4319291711,
0.0743082613,
-0.5489951968,
-0.0869200006,
0.0126511548,
-0.3905119002,
-0.1286441237,
0.2449157089,
-0.2447023094,
-0.3063860834,
0.6319999695,
0.9707157016,
-0.1546650529,
0.2604426444,
-0.219975099,
0.3233481348,
-0.5269917846,
-0.5395587683,
-0.3913245201,
0.0142783895,
-0.5525200367,
-0.3735114038,
0.363583535,
0.1242726073,
0.2469407618,
0.6516106725,
-0.6353417635,
0.4899455011,
0.2912107408,
0.1882980764,
0.1687484086,
0.2928637266,
0.3705473244,
0.152808696,
-0.4910645783,
-0.4184906781,
0.9136075974,
0.2910461426,
0.8818874359,
0.0258787125,
0.7861394882,
0.1905670613,
-0.1276238412,
-0.7643805146,
0.5023437738,
-0.4147943556,
-0.3654045761,
-0.0287492257,
-0.7306830883,
-0.7124608159,
-0.1394003183,
-0.3648113012,
-0.8949881792,
0.9192103744,
-0.0779187158,
-0.0679036453,
0.5190884471,
-0.6108259559,
0.6438215971,
-0.4243920147,
-0.400346756,
-0.0070733409,
-0.3928008378,
-0.0193311851,
-0.2509034276,
0.1951489896,
-0.561183989,
0.0539701618,
0.6382287741,
0.0052896277,
0.2940710783,
0.2124613523,
0.0065378733,
0.3226840794,
0.2844792604,
0.2758292556,
0.1398613751,
-0.2330726832,
0.4588221908,
0.3348074555,
-0.2736987174,
-0.4130382538,
0.2236951143,
-0.5435470343,
-0.4447602034,
-1.0694621801,
-0.5435209274,
0.1410064846,
0.3297328949,
0.2354305387,
0.2548422813,
-0.0024667718,
0.165821597,
0.8945034146,
-0.3885134757,
0.2511654496,
0.3819030821,
0.0187801085,
-0.2171348631,
1.536765933,
-0.0394251272,
0.0002189884,
0.5403074622,
0.1759188324,
0.2277543396,
-0.2151386142,
-0.1283070892,
0.573782742,
-0.2452139109,
-0.2509709001,
-0.6276744008,
-0.4009884,
-0.4543485343,
0.2474615276,
-0.5665924549,
-0.8614692092,
-0.2986728251,
-0.0032102366,
0.253557086,
1.1786953211,
-0.1598337442,
-0.3708467782,
-0.7159677148,
0.5858693123,
0.0757223442,
0.3689620495,
-0.6089653969,
0.071249865,
0.1141692474,
-0.3105892539,
0.0503346771,
-1.0522278547,
0.2239968777,
0.491007477,
0.3619728386,
0.0565937907,
-0.0707039237,
0.3119036853,
-0.4142755568,
0.3879122734,
0.2214041948,
-0.7371423841,
0.7044156194,
-0.1445748061,
-0.178571105,
0.3088222444,
1.008000493,
-0.3201408386,
-0.060074877,
-0.7712700367,
-1.1008893251,
0.7982405424,
0.2954317033,
-0.2833848,
-0.0813620389,
0.3601890206,
0.3286246955,
0.1095226184,
-1.0139396191,
-0.2931668162,
0.0532667898,
-0.3410320282,
0.3600781858,
-0.649543643,
-0.0039431225,
-0.0778471455,
0.9013414979,
0.0153529225,
0.3323858082,
0.1830569059,
-0.2832137644,
-0.0983061269,
0.0893463418,
-0.1678512692,
0.8962270617,
-0.9148709774,
-0.0856535658,
-0.0788935721,
-0.6658484936,
0.0025102154,
0.4126772583,
-0.0547234081,
-0.0409064963,
0.1822835356,
0.2954452336,
-0.3173915446,
-0.7672948837,
0.5098364949,
-0.3578257263,
0.1703575701,
-0.5352101922,
-0.0364504233,
-0.4977102578,
0.0570928156,
0.3105396628,
-0.0282262433,
0.4249651432,
-0.4951259792,
0.4829657376,
0.1021281481,
-0.3131125569,
-0.2355924994,
0.3631461859,
0.156067878,
0.0747218356,
0.5985919833,
-0.1787864864,
-0.0219067857,
0.7189845443,
0.4429926872,
0.4543007314,
0.0280795097,
0.7374619246,
0.4992062449,
0.0695656836,
0.0321036242,
0.3026950955,
0.0349695832,
-0.5783518553,
-0.2531360984,
-0.8635976315,
-0.5777685046,
0.0955525637,
-0.7722559571,
0.4514281452,
-0.4776847959,
-0.0188818127,
0.5952914953,
-0.1040168405,
-0.0689502358,
0.1290296018,
0.4280543327,
0.9464511275,
-0.8918613195,
0.5389427543,
0.8316887617,
-0.5441002846,
-0.4468065202,
-0.3784129024,
-0.0022121288,
-0.0916421711,
0.7373794913,
0.1814343035,
-0.1938887537,
-0.3092476726,
-0.4787788391,
-1.2712093592,
0.9414180517,
0.5473728776,
-0.6539652348,
-0.2387060821,
0.2052503973,
0.3026799262,
-0.2583132684,
0.5700739026,
0.5302467942,
0.3944003284,
-0.2553915977,
-0.629116118,
-0.1019007862,
-0.7862244844,
-0.3578161299,
0.2955596745,
-0.86124897,
0.8378787041,
0.1100770757,
-0.3874261379,
0.1008865163,
0.5830649137,
0.1418582648,
0.1759358943,
0.6353553534,
0.4544686377,
0.7185640931,
-0.2453529984,
0.9748758078,
-0.0725806579,
0.5078892708,
0.9914458394,
-0.2452402711,
0.5042273998,
0.3918244839,
0.1332590431,
0.7654318213,
0.4098847806,
-0.5887117386,
0.1411581933,
0.1211227626,
-0.5830684304,
-0.2515728474,
-0.6123616695,
-0.0783805028,
0.5275075436,
0.467420578,
-0.2503718138,
0.0507456362,
0.0119770365,
-0.1468296498,
-0.2645568848,
0.2254829407,
0.681642592,
0.1955718547,
-0.3436737061,
0.0588985607,
-0.3532576561,
0.0975864753,
-0.5366407633,
-0.4802036285,
-0.0285706688,
0.0170322265,
-0.2301013768,
-0.7430433035,
-0.1746286899,
-0.0026916303,
-0.4815677106,
-0.1201297566,
0.7116350532,
-0.1426272094,
-0.590536356,
0.4068959355,
0.2307236344,
0.4442562759,
0.197923407,
-0.7003816366,
-0.2516029775,
0.0345625877,
-0.353277266,
-0.0418819375,
0.3197882473,
-0.0114347404,
0.6888939738,
0.4896772504,
0.3911688924,
-0.3559860885,
-0.0416008122,
0.686663568,
-0.6250188351,
0.2505330145,
-0.3644694388,
0.3439679146,
-0.5317149162,
-0.41304636,
0.383467108,
0.7886136174,
0.5104871988,
-0.0542306714,
0.5789121985,
-0.5913869739,
0.3347275853,
-0.1149390265,
0.4724820554,
-0.4484188259,
0.1450812966,
-0.2652693391,
-1.2472853661,
-0.0185656529,
0.4141764641,
0.2790524364,
-0.2753100097,
0.9578800797,
0.4635583162,
-0.4565301538,
0.0852202103,
-0.2955429852,
0.320202142,
0.2994017005,
0.2674480379,
0.4972753823,
-0.4269175529,
0.7462146878,
-0.6561963558,
-0.3336196542,
0.2052230537,
-0.9397190809,
-0.6143921018,
-0.3111983836,
-0.5357452035,
-0.0862965137,
0.3333681822,
0.8798971176,
0.8392724991,
-0.8502103686,
-0.4091355503,
-0.1699999869,
0.3108944297,
-0.0357242078,
-0.261631906,
0.4513082206,
0.0054853125,
-0.8998878002,
0.6924582124,
0.3080718219,
0.2541131675,
0.3185296953,
0.5111314654,
-0.4282460809,
0.0936425924,
0.2741762698,
0.5453487635,
0.024316946,
-0.3652530909,
-0.0372208543,
0.2140280157,
0.1508850008,
0.7056066394,
-0.570936501,
0.6554152966,
0.8713310957,
0.1862848848,
0.7052220702,
-0.055003643,
0.9664646387,
-0.804928124,
0.1363612115,
0.3170447946,
0.5182417631,
0.0932224467,
-0.602522552,
0.9648207426,
0.4376255572,
-0.5971868038,
-0.8650830984,
0.1882625669,
-1.2317914963,
-0.4977033138,
0.780223012,
-0.0664020479,
-0.7025722265,
0.1273072511,
0.0032201642,
0.1256283373,
-0.2248583436,
0.7799974084,
0.5504043102,
-0.2130946964,
-0.3609489799,
-0.4372342527,
0.3251574337,
0.4223149121,
-0.8239898682,
0.0566109829,
0.2804146707,
0.347718209,
0.5150287151,
0.1457078457,
-0.2248197347,
0.4207076728,
-0.0393704958,
0.5202881694,
-0.0064597647,
-0.9813650846,
0.1619164944,
0.199792102,
-0.1130039617,
0.3310907483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07703v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07703v2
|
Measuring Entrainment in Spontaneous Code-switched Speech
| 2023-11-13T19:41:34 | 2024-03-26T15:31:34 |
Debasmita Bhattacharya, Siying Ding, Alayna Nguyen, Julia Hirschberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
It is well-known that speakers who entrain to one another have more
successful conversations than those who do not. Previous research has shown
that interlocutors entrain on linguistic features in both written and spoken
monolingual domains. More recent work on code-switched communication has also
shown preliminary evidence of entrainment on certain aspects of code-switching
(CSW). However, such studies of entrainment in code-switched domains have been
extremely few and restricted to human-machine textual interactions. Our work
studies code-switched spontaneous speech between humans, finding that (1)
patterns of written and spoken entrainment in monolingual settings largely
generalize to code-switched settings, and (2) some patterns of entrainment on
code-switching in dialogue agent-generated text generalize to spontaneous
code-switched speech. Our findings give rise to important implications for the
potentially "universal" nature of entrainment as a communication phenomenon,
and potential applications in inclusive and interactive speech technology.
|
[
-0.2951113582,
-0.84094733,
0.3275589347,
0.4854109287,
-0.1286917627,
0.2266433686,
-0.5379008651,
-0.7184236646,
0.3387033045,
0.3012962937,
-0.4369298816,
-0.1952693164,
-0.2972923815,
0.2868257463,
-0.7561511397,
0.6752804518,
-0.0251209978,
0.2498384714,
-0.3695715666,
-0.1055967435,
-0.5721639395,
-0.8746249676,
-0.4449422359,
-0.5272971392,
0.3775390387,
0.2372346073,
0.6659092307,
0.2137949169,
0.2452027202,
0.2395658344,
0.1667291522,
-0.1753793359,
-0.3833247125,
0.2396095097,
0.0656783804,
-0.7604596019,
-0.2009452283,
0.1283470988,
0.7737845778,
0.8063459396,
-0.1329791546,
-0.0917328745,
0.3819565773,
0.4348000884,
-0.4730089307,
-0.0413274616,
-0.6554630995,
0.4617948234,
-0.5297327042,
-0.6483288407,
-0.5868347287,
-0.3845745027,
0.2047380358,
-0.4901987612,
0.3039893508,
-0.2408842593,
0.6502668262,
0.2954278588,
-0.6047145128,
-0.3415015638,
-1.0266418457,
0.3527832627,
-0.5636452436,
0.7268570065,
0.5521795154,
-0.1917856932,
-0.011974168,
-0.7373465896,
-0.7248428464,
-0.6008348465,
-0.0512120165,
0.2420424223,
-0.2431457341,
0.310870707,
0.3322176337,
-0.0605932102,
-0.487824589,
-0.0140086683,
-0.1316736042,
-0.1393633783,
0.5970971584,
0.0433377475,
0.6515068412,
0.3959467709,
-0.1551370323,
0.0190741867,
-0.412820369,
0.0947176367,
0.5001741052,
0.0617046282,
-0.3039139509,
0.3174686134,
0.0347263813,
0.9391341805,
0.0556733161,
-0.0633809939,
0.2813895941,
-0.5167790055,
-0.1657472849,
0.2785024345,
0.4037188888,
0.0613156967,
0.5622418523,
-0.5736317039,
-0.0187284164,
0.2399925441,
0.0473114178,
-0.6862569451,
-0.0716842487,
-0.124357067,
-0.2628144622,
-0.1683971286,
0.3587414324,
-0.4168301225,
-0.3337456882,
-0.288846314,
0.2833313048,
-0.2963580787,
-0.4788457155,
0.1471724361,
-0.3700118065,
0.4506343305,
-0.0410698727,
-0.9966282248,
0.358330369,
0.4289905727,
0.8401864171,
-0.4127673507,
-0.635614872,
-0.3555767536,
-0.1939131916,
-0.5182045102,
0.5857596397,
-0.5672738552,
-0.4212139249,
0.2985306978,
-0.0603401363,
-0.5283372402,
-0.4957503676,
0.096241191,
-0.4776144922,
0.0308091938,
0.0505580939,
-0.4571233392,
0.2404135466,
0.0651521981,
-0.2841632962,
0.7751714587,
-0.1411254704,
-0.6797257662,
0.6845469475,
-0.3550991714,
-0.5420717597,
0.1260911077,
-0.5624136925,
-0.1811527908,
-0.0890519097,
-0.4596340656,
-0.0932962447,
-0.0289253164,
0.1584241688,
-0.069428578,
-0.4296142161,
1.0300101042,
-0.5939940214,
0.7564702034,
-0.0028665077,
-0.503975749,
-0.1738041043,
-0.5556250215,
0.2183907032,
-0.1175401881,
-0.4511770606,
-0.3186658323,
0.0562740453,
0.0793663412,
0.3103558123,
0.0967839211,
-0.6900213361,
0.263543725,
-0.3531725407,
0.3174608052,
0.3668768108,
0.4260171652,
0.4298910499,
-0.3315392137,
0.7370295525,
0.1285992265,
0.0794702023,
0.0823646188,
-0.7138402462,
-0.7480156422,
-0.0802223831,
0.2098992169,
0.7229087949,
-0.5106145144,
0.3352425992,
0.1681034118,
-0.1429537833,
-0.4131446779,
0.0790901557,
0.5885008574,
0.0192314982,
0.0465894304,
-0.6371393204,
-0.3357942104,
-0.728179574,
-0.6405789852,
-0.0538142845,
0.0698237866,
0.0823652521,
0.0491551422,
-0.4470799565,
1.3943305016,
-0.2444298118,
0.0518733002,
-0.1663518846,
0.3007459044,
0.0370979831,
0.6723155975,
0.5611649752,
-0.6197306514,
-0.6861159205,
0.069086127,
-0.5671940446,
-0.1384666115,
-0.6106311083,
-0.1403503716,
0.2325487286,
0.7637585998,
-0.2840355933,
0.7348104715,
0.742595315,
-0.5811614394,
0.4607657194,
-0.2594932616,
0.3464909792,
-0.6288627386,
-0.1227989346,
-0.24033086,
-0.1829146594,
-1.0350078344,
-0.3420082331,
0.0401010476,
-0.0735835955,
-0.4222508967,
0.2314545363,
-0.7317957878,
-0.1270760298,
-0.0768608302,
0.1382983178,
-0.2847431898,
0.4796150327,
-0.0615556762,
0.786454618,
0.7617929578,
-0.7035839558,
-0.0176242869,
0.4201585054,
-0.2361736447,
0.2369576544,
-0.4261018634,
0.7882896066,
0.0876339898,
0.1699447483,
-1.007848382,
-0.2940954268,
0.0002595347,
-0.6185392141,
0.2181016505,
-0.1022668332,
-0.4330167472,
0.0750143528,
0.0989050791,
0.5279465318,
0.4575487375,
-0.4807501435,
0.0233676005,
0.4991261363,
-0.0196952149,
-0.2094009072,
-1.0213359594,
0.2743313015,
0.0620351471,
-0.7777279615,
0.2231201231,
-0.172633186,
-0.3951255977,
-0.2214922458,
-0.1261801273,
-0.441403836,
0.0711824894,
0.4180518687,
0.2247176766,
-0.08288946,
0.1520310044,
0.1235449165,
0.0989282653,
0.1799943149,
-0.2563751638,
0.7562069297,
-0.0915253013,
-0.6036192179,
-0.3448161185,
0.4629928172,
0.3290557265,
-0.1406093836,
0.8090217113,
0.3990212381,
-0.3403132856,
-0.1899178326,
-0.2819187641,
-0.264251858,
-0.477870822,
0.3156758249,
-0.216124028,
-0.9486507177,
0.5294236541,
-0.0717239082,
-0.1163569093,
-0.1488113999,
0.4267886281,
0.0781408623,
1.0835540295,
0.7946043611,
0.2804238498,
0.8834411502,
0.0616829619,
0.1571194679,
-0.2732973099,
0.045812998,
-0.6203560829,
-0.2520895302,
-0.654828012,
-0.2724679112,
0.3751190603,
0.1793562025,
-0.0104360403,
0.0869743004,
-0.3840120137,
0.6110489964,
0.2836224735,
0.0385195538,
0.4171611071,
-0.1094552502,
-0.0262833592,
-0.3049798012,
-0.642162919,
-0.1609844714,
0.7739502192,
0.0748365372,
0.7909862399,
0.0662279874,
0.6311564445,
0.3349696696,
0.2106235027,
-0.3727309704,
0.5149865746,
0.0778795034,
-0.6278246641,
-0.3657892942,
-0.3436668217,
-1.2187337875,
0.0113004828,
-0.3246214986,
-0.7919748425,
0.5762529969,
0.284001261,
0.0384644456,
-0.0537759699,
-0.7207599282,
0.7102385163,
-0.2249587327,
-0.0866257772,
-0.310790211,
-0.6899039149,
0.258603096,
-0.1662384421,
-0.0090158926,
0.0238424074,
-0.0020620832,
0.7465694547,
-0.1360244155,
0.9954810143,
-0.0761511847,
-0.1974878311,
0.3454989195,
0.1616758108,
0.3316625655,
-0.0415093787,
0.2107197195,
0.3571378589,
-0.4066706598,
-0.1101141274,
-0.4974476695,
0.3587133288,
-0.9357175827,
-0.2622688711,
-0.5050416589,
-0.1945241541,
-0.5562673807,
0.0347576551,
0.7516127229,
0.7093639374,
-0.4983477294,
-0.0057440391,
0.8616644144,
-0.2189052105,
0.5166944861,
0.707854569,
-0.3728893101,
-0.1359948665,
0.9464697838,
0.2495146692,
0.812584579,
0.2565686703,
-0.0749569237,
0.0919294134,
-0.2441093624,
-0.3159959614,
0.2255102992,
-0.4623567164,
0.1462167352,
-0.6261518002,
-0.5337649584,
-0.3907268047,
-0.48963359,
-0.2929066718,
-0.4702856839,
-0.1968569756,
-0.0750786215,
0.1730253696,
0.6295556426,
-0.2147544622,
-0.0325452127,
-0.7509587407,
0.2465647459,
0.6744188666,
0.2195607722,
-0.1496447176,
-0.7389077544,
-0.5409832597,
0.1393800825,
-0.1149598733,
-1.2660409212,
0.3454823792,
0.6648069024,
0.6046857238,
0.4195414782,
-0.0292763524,
0.529071629,
-0.2609429359,
0.7646531463,
0.4410715401,
-1.1085909605,
0.5466272831,
-0.4624183476,
0.4970468879,
0.6070891619,
0.1134158447,
-1.2256046534,
-0.8928383589,
-0.5453543663,
-0.6827284694,
0.6277080178,
0.2899310887,
0.1545134634,
-0.2319742292,
-0.0886030868,
0.0895074233,
0.2142254859,
-0.6681069732,
-0.4117779434,
0.0470430255,
0.3118939698,
0.0251993928,
0.1310596168,
-0.265416801,
-0.4275782704,
0.1808237135,
-0.0421897545,
0.66473943,
0.4217782021,
-0.4448245764,
-0.3502608538,
0.4444063902,
0.771925509,
0.8446640372,
-0.002210977,
0.1576894075,
0.2851893306,
-0.7743887901,
0.2745482326,
-0.1714035422,
-0.1975092739,
0.4723589122,
0.4774005413,
0.9270874858,
0.4969489574,
-0.5440734029,
0.6226844788,
-0.2017500699,
-0.2798008621,
-0.4384635687,
0.2449978143,
-0.030946346,
-0.0695521906,
0.3242032826,
0.6500298977,
-0.1784369498,
-0.6965819001,
0.3015570641,
0.3254721761,
-0.7171139717,
-0.4067598283,
0.646122396,
0.6117873788,
-0.6551414132,
0.6927606463,
-0.2960110605,
-0.3878897727,
0.6001631021,
0.9839676023,
1.3946882486,
-0.1623394638,
0.1241047159,
0.2273613214,
0.4214868844,
0.140552178,
0.204299286,
-0.3861713409,
-1.1092312336,
-0.131112054,
-0.316532433,
-0.5502017736,
-0.5087205172,
-1.0016881227,
-0.0117148925,
-0.0370843001,
-0.275867492,
-0.2474708706,
-0.4289630651,
-0.9050608277,
-0.1974369138,
0.3753275275,
0.8690177202,
-0.678083241,
1.06016922,
0.6755977273,
-0.2637630701,
-0.558131218,
0.3937874734,
-0.1287242621,
-0.7200205326,
0.5905848145,
0.0886985585,
-0.3537750542,
0.218809396,
-0.791382134,
-0.6134620309,
0.9772911072,
0.4580386877,
-0.6666039824,
0.2682124376,
0.4632345736,
0.6125133634,
-0.1415280402,
0.1261704862,
0.8518655896,
0.3101370037,
-0.6641160846,
-1.2775657177,
-0.2960665226,
-0.390625,
-0.0456827879,
0.4045035541,
-0.7036781311,
0.7859109044,
-0.0525133349,
-0.6793701053,
-0.2787325382,
0.5733858347,
-0.0944364294,
0.4021588266,
0.6220368147,
0.1228079051,
0.7216657996,
0.046614863,
0.797742784,
-0.6607840657,
0.173948139,
0.7530893683,
-0.3803069592,
0.7071142793,
0.2455918044,
-0.238102451,
0.4061497152,
0.1362113655,
0.6490955353,
0.2886259556,
0.1241364554,
-0.7860162854,
-0.2919935286,
0.0186713021,
-0.7573160529,
0.4284518361,
0.2977436781,
-0.0984338447,
0.2652316988,
0.3667151928,
0.1415434629,
-0.1942644715,
0.1518396437,
0.9017304182,
0.1583633423,
-0.8103240132,
0.642591536,
-0.269552052,
0.9619592428,
-0.8690439463,
0.0686983988,
-0.4215043187,
-0.003232629,
-0.2477401942,
-0.6394128799,
0.1271531284,
0.2313565612,
-0.1280309409,
-0.5890749097,
0.7972226143,
-0.8155665398,
0.1209622324,
0.4286667109,
0.4068169892,
0.2436710745,
0.0423207358,
-0.3441774845,
0.1359119564,
0.1710343808,
-0.0364183187,
0.7364340425,
0.3627378941,
0.2831143141,
0.2955892086,
0.6562590599,
0.0343228951,
0.712849021,
0.3635057807,
0.6105239987,
-0.6517916918,
-0.8882976174,
-0.6262720823,
0.4078395665,
-0.0930865183,
-0.9335852265,
0.9557387233,
0.5416324139,
0.7567039132,
-0.1218102947,
0.9066063166,
-0.1087967306,
0.0809129551,
-0.6168245077,
0.9676807523,
-0.0255213622,
-0.2284584194,
-0.232526347,
-0.8300457001,
-0.0334245376,
0.5621519089,
0.0731231421,
-0.3627628684,
0.9524610043,
0.8669925928,
0.1872949004,
0.1233849451,
0.6047734022,
0.1412020773,
0.1034365669,
0.2020815313,
1.1353750229,
-0.0222632736,
0.5039674044,
0.1266450584,
-0.5285969377,
-0.2008099258,
-0.5701006651,
-0.6858564615,
-0.838455081,
-0.5615047216,
-0.3918005526,
0.2777579427,
0.9288458824,
0.6356574297,
-0.4795384705,
-0.6517063379,
-0.3890092969,
-0.2816781104,
-0.4366256297,
-0.2279648483,
-0.5325821042,
-0.5071954727,
-0.3900485635,
0.6851656437,
0.2740687132,
0.0613110028,
-0.2280251831,
-0.1409782171,
-0.1604136378,
0.4691605568,
0.3918160498,
0.8493682742,
-0.1856782883,
-0.1844817996,
-0.009967274,
-0.3952730894,
0.0961511657,
1.3335241079,
-0.6230629086,
0.5350509286,
0.6056897044,
0.5708047152,
0.6850261688,
-0.0315724052,
0.638703227,
-1.2171937227,
0.7025994658,
0.3408754468,
0.0876877382,
-0.0090132859,
-0.2278994918,
0.2499409914,
0.4783630371,
-0.9609017372,
-0.9190269709,
0.32047984,
-0.9231255651,
0.1621101946,
1.2436881065,
0.1816673875,
0.1420471966,
-0.4930472374,
-0.2466147244,
0.246082142,
-0.182299152,
0.4544791281,
0.7718906999,
-0.5406252742,
0.2495484799,
-0.6586259007,
0.6552740335,
0.4299634397,
-1.0060696602,
-0.1605801284,
0.3117940426,
-0.0151048526,
0.1371738911,
1.1162942648,
0.3898565471,
0.4826066494,
0.5713016391,
0.2890228331,
0.3030213118,
-0.2862731814,
-0.416638881,
-0.2046155781,
0.0391880982,
-0.5402237177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07700v1
|
AuthentiGPT: Detecting Machine-Generated Text via Black-Box Language Models Denoising
| 2023-11-13T19:36:54 | 2023-11-13T19:36:54 |
Zhen Guo, Shangdi Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have opened up enormous opportunities while
simultaneously posing ethical dilemmas. One of the major concerns is their
ability to create text that closely mimics human writing, which can lead to
potential misuse, such as academic misconduct, disinformation, and fraud. To
address this problem, we present AuthentiGPT, an efficient classifier that
distinguishes between machine-generated and human-written texts. Under the
assumption that human-written text resides outside the distribution of
machine-generated text, AuthentiGPT leverages a black-box LLM to denoise input
text with artificially added noise, and then semantically compares the denoised
text with the original to determine if the content is machine-generated. With
only one trainable parameter, AuthentiGPT eliminates the need for a large
training dataset, watermarking the LLM's output, or computing the
log-likelihood. Importantly, the detection capability of AuthentiGPT can be
easily adapted to any generative language model. With a 0.918 AUROC score on a
domain-specific dataset, AuthentiGPT demonstrates its effectiveness over other
commercial algorithms, highlighting its potential for detecting
machine-generated text in academic settings.
|
[
-0.2109487355,
-0.9368476272,
0.4535493255,
-0.0748869851,
-0.28140378,
0.2036041021,
-0.2195421308,
-0.5727975368,
-0.0511685312,
0.6804000735,
-0.426196605,
-0.5454550385,
-0.566342473,
0.4511246383,
-0.8127268553,
1.0679963827,
-0.0436449721,
-0.3216982186,
-0.0071645197,
0.011269833,
-0.103387475,
-0.658064127,
-0.7786499262,
-0.60171628,
0.1728182435,
-0.0781498775,
0.4374022782,
0.620721817,
0.320269376,
0.3175111711,
0.0277926344,
0.2750585079,
-0.4337766767,
0.0665402263,
0.0761289373,
-0.2011864185,
-0.305283159,
-0.0141162332,
0.6752155423,
0.2960692644,
-0.0148342494,
0.0226318911,
0.2824530005,
0.4627408683,
-0.6099119782,
0.181994155,
-0.6128422022,
0.2057062387,
-0.1376630813,
-0.388886869,
-0.5328332186,
-0.3445519805,
-0.0502726883,
-0.3740203679,
0.4802339375,
-0.0229912996,
0.6906802654,
0.234734267,
-0.0430785939,
-0.3091940582,
-0.7670102119,
0.7755857706,
-0.6328845024,
0.3878243864,
0.4115228653,
-0.1031250134,
-0.0612332635,
-0.9057016373,
-0.7304629683,
-0.3127358258,
-0.1235003918,
0.2206087559,
-0.4409759939,
0.0523064621,
0.2865487933,
0.5074416995,
-0.8587335944,
0.0400140435,
-0.3307953477,
-0.4628668427,
0.5015692115,
-0.1609092802,
0.5683107972,
-0.1340084076,
-0.1275779158,
-0.012574451,
-0.6458759308,
-0.453740418,
0.5132084489,
0.0454202406,
0.1138536111,
0.5773162842,
-0.0200456101,
0.628146708,
-0.174006179,
-0.1215620786,
0.030724654,
0.1318262666,
-0.328373909,
0.4548751116,
0.9445297122,
0.2771656513,
0.5318146348,
-0.3181857169,
-0.3537229896,
0.6755380034,
0.2912370265,
-1.049947381,
-0.6188814044,
-0.1814614534,
-0.2146860212,
-0.5471799374,
0.0829612091,
-0.4491983354,
-0.4459611475,
-0.1969879121,
0.4748572111,
-0.192508325,
-0.1264762431,
0.1654824018,
-0.1234956905,
-0.0801220536,
0.2824798226,
-0.6876198649,
0.2334114909,
0.6200903654,
0.8265410066,
-0.2601759732,
-0.1554102302,
-0.6865560412,
0.159701854,
-0.3174165487,
0.8155381083,
-0.4770520329,
-0.4822691679,
-0.1641773134,
0.0505380854,
0.0163304936,
-0.425894618,
0.6596763134,
-0.5224102139,
0.3854020536,
0.2060907483,
-0.7223920822,
-0.1228509694,
0.3144374192,
-0.6746992469,
1.1063076258,
0.1736979783,
-0.9539464712,
0.4700904489,
-0.7213522196,
-0.5653769374,
0.4624324143,
-0.2740538716,
-0.9032914042,
-0.120147109,
0.1019426137,
0.4374109507,
-0.0787482932,
0.1084980965,
-0.0513938591,
-0.3721764684,
0.410366714,
-0.9380716681,
0.8092346191,
0.125004366,
-0.5813804269,
-0.3118229806,
-0.76718086,
-0.1628185809,
0.2966263592,
-0.5764616132,
-0.4173942506,
-0.1694741547,
0.3341631889,
0.0056629293,
0.0530805551,
-0.7193797827,
-0.1150279492,
-0.3110407591,
0.6786708832,
0.6453701854,
0.1531815976,
0.2838856578,
-0.467633456,
0.6844463944,
-0.4157681763,
-0.2203003168,
-0.20322299,
-0.6795650721,
-0.6798958182,
-0.5363340378,
0.3964437544,
0.769493103,
-0.4607189894,
0.6230998635,
-0.0674481913,
-0.2677555978,
-0.6738109589,
0.4439156055,
0.3544303179,
0.4969549775,
0.2050520629,
-0.4094079137,
-0.3875753582,
-0.7772717476,
-0.3947090507,
-0.2794731259,
-0.2826761007,
0.0747904629,
0.6066012979,
-0.5152523518,
0.7712680697,
-0.3831480443,
-0.3840033412,
-0.2153223753,
0.4693657756,
-0.355255723,
0.4745770097,
0.4826557934,
-0.6760448217,
-0.3867186308,
0.0884357542,
-0.8468366861,
-0.487323314,
-0.3269627392,
0.1566884667,
0.2023792267,
0.5563671589,
-0.5470669866,
0.6426733136,
0.571644485,
-0.2593992054,
0.3838469684,
-0.4418640733,
0.194828257,
-1.0499774218,
0.230726108,
0.1338286996,
-0.4761456847,
-0.5876200795,
-0.0771287233,
0.1325501949,
-0.1438590139,
-0.1053415313,
0.5416088104,
-0.3637840748,
0.1247869506,
-0.4338362217,
0.327639997,
0.3439581692,
0.1991031468,
0.1471459419,
0.9397476315,
0.0654672757,
-0.405283004,
0.1113868803,
0.3113123178,
-0.3649024963,
0.5833675861,
-0.5452734232,
0.1923099458,
-0.2212394923,
0.2224727422,
-0.9747001529,
0.0095400354,
0.3139435351,
-0.4922766685,
0.1685449332,
-0.3678720891,
-0.8278355598,
-0.0381051861,
-0.2449481785,
0.3495956361,
0.4472926259,
-0.4663558304,
0.5568579435,
0.3682652414,
-0.3742192984,
-0.4151439071,
-0.9957188368,
0.5011661053,
-0.0994994417,
-0.1325469166,
0.2597336471,
-0.1492569894,
-0.1127495244,
-0.0644094571,
0.1575404853,
-0.0751207396,
0.3452796936,
0.2837182283,
0.2400890142,
-0.1383113861,
0.0146822659,
0.1453888118,
-0.2648636997,
0.11949642,
-0.3370307982,
0.530600965,
0.0283121727,
-0.3708095253,
-0.6006270051,
0.211686641,
0.515406251,
-0.3863390088,
0.4450876117,
0.8391095996,
-0.4583998621,
-0.671954155,
-0.3403251469,
-0.4148124158,
-0.4960264266,
0.2708929777,
-0.0319142081,
-0.8161358833,
0.1383466721,
0.0897528157,
0.3624590635,
0.3787322342,
0.4090750515,
0.3162449896,
1.0173159838,
0.532382071,
-0.2579176724,
0.4694999158,
-0.3413788676,
0.4840200841,
-0.5541262031,
0.1050419956,
-0.5091890693,
0.1144352406,
-0.6797604561,
-0.2486838847,
-0.0042139245,
-0.1106084809,
0.0112984357,
0.3470534682,
-0.9292137623,
0.7701631188,
0.5586616993,
0.0437738597,
0.6125695705,
0.2979421914,
-0.0322317965,
-0.0971104056,
-0.6138983369,
-0.8941811919,
1.0453960896,
0.2278599888,
0.5682005882,
-0.0857841149,
0.773088932,
0.7993119955,
0.8368533254,
-0.6174847484,
0.4527874291,
-0.2970391512,
-0.5745598078,
-0.1019638181,
-0.5584689975,
-0.9329690337,
0.3063023388,
-0.3349113464,
-0.653839767,
-0.2118740082,
0.0988194421,
-0.2109194696,
0.6663427353,
-0.594178319,
0.9589155316,
-0.0651582181,
-0.4198477864,
-0.0612233803,
-0.112089023,
0.2427449822,
-0.3951023817,
0.1843329221,
0.0233554114,
0.1545587331,
0.8912422657,
-0.1470888108,
0.9433654547,
0.1211361587,
-0.2889628112,
0.3482470512,
0.5410034657,
0.4530875683,
0.0866020769,
-0.0445125774,
0.1415563673,
-0.1895046085,
-0.1477490067,
-0.1114084497,
0.7693046927,
-0.5358855128,
-0.2932389975,
-0.4489941001,
-0.476985395,
0.327385962,
0.4940474331,
0.3975877166,
0.5985332131,
-0.4727154374,
0.0472768396,
0.6678287387,
-0.3211210668,
0.3632623255,
0.3785893321,
-0.1299206316,
-0.3598789871,
1.1139169931,
-0.0701390356,
0.1430243999,
0.3690320849,
0.1702862829,
-0.4239870608,
-0.4640049636,
-0.870051682,
0.1387595683,
-0.7561142445,
-0.1961549819,
-0.9111276269,
-0.4676156342,
-0.0861782432,
-0.4053709507,
-0.0816999078,
-0.4149013758,
-0.4890864789,
-0.1450340897,
0.4485694766,
0.5886497498,
0.0438577086,
0.4680165946,
-0.5864787698,
0.4972805679,
0.3857019544,
0.2334535271,
-0.2040704191,
-0.5823373199,
0.2171137184,
-0.0407045856,
-0.4393829107,
-0.4835115075,
0.5508838296,
0.2505654395,
0.3518346548,
0.6200689077,
0.2708415389,
0.2578157187,
-0.4663542211,
0.5043078661,
0.0660520345,
-0.8890203834,
0.2881559432,
-0.0898076445,
0.2232012004,
0.4903533459,
0.0197486859,
-0.4950352013,
-0.8191363215,
-0.6757950187,
-0.5034225583,
0.455493778,
0.5973172188,
0.1651610285,
0.0526080094,
0.387808919,
0.0870631486,
0.3274095654,
-1.0798541307,
-0.142760545,
-0.1549968719,
-0.4829798341,
-0.2942704856,
-0.0974172577,
0.0271121114,
0.1299421787,
0.5654138327,
0.0444984399,
0.149519369,
0.1199423596,
-0.487770915,
-0.2343290895,
0.3497585356,
0.5359939337,
0.4002791345,
-0.1255213022,
0.3397213519,
0.1270410419,
-0.6681517363,
0.097117506,
0.3995271623,
-0.7756032944,
0.3185074925,
0.4865006506,
0.3400761187,
0.0084505351,
-0.784199357,
0.5309306383,
-0.1065853909,
-0.3960009217,
-0.4371973872,
0.1602535993,
-0.1823993474,
0.0601727217,
0.2153948843,
0.1000500023,
0.35823524,
-0.3540034592,
0.3661372066,
0.5698459744,
-0.3250878453,
-0.3254048228,
0.8836640716,
0.0458676703,
-0.6288465858,
0.4308772683,
-0.2344415486,
-0.7579503059,
0.4460080862,
0.529496491,
1.0864361525,
-0.2376486063,
0.3933871686,
0.0855626315,
0.6460261941,
-0.2293232828,
-0.0093711596,
-0.2731826901,
-0.7701631188,
-0.3089178205,
-0.7839932442,
-0.2764294147,
0.4968582094,
-0.3188321292,
0.0433928743,
-0.6391159296,
-0.2013980448,
0.3337268233,
0.0979193822,
-0.4434900582,
0.067956008,
0.0811026394,
0.4400114119,
-1.059685111,
0.6726785898,
0.6549288034,
-0.1169509068,
-0.1639463902,
-0.1126623675,
0.0388877578,
-0.5705494881,
0.1925638318,
0.5192700624,
-0.4150655568,
0.2398175001,
-0.3805256784,
-0.0478320867,
0.8586741686,
0.3068102896,
-0.4405037761,
0.3276557624,
0.3356037438,
0.5407186151,
-0.2198314518,
-0.1125854924,
0.5643749237,
0.5163815022,
-0.3780463934,
-0.636767745,
0.0222268011,
-0.1373795718,
-0.2412890196,
0.3644323945,
-0.179396227,
0.7256708741,
-0.0067062047,
-0.4633610845,
0.0123326061,
0.0812083781,
0.2535618544,
0.3398121595,
0.5217227936,
0.5958362818,
0.7377855778,
0.0589744449,
0.7581316829,
-0.3690844178,
0.2135115117,
0.6182373166,
-0.2446632534,
0.534974575,
0.2043170631,
0.0868568122,
0.3556668162,
0.4039476514,
-0.3428958654,
0.2029455304,
0.2319436371,
-0.7366946936,
-0.3622604907,
0.0421476178,
-0.1331518739,
0.2441521138,
0.3151329756,
-0.4764731228,
-0.284689486,
-0.0672766492,
0.0470917262,
0.3545335531,
-0.0950653255,
0.9354554415,
0.2484871596,
-0.3913102448,
0.6169723272,
0.317401588,
0.5953971744,
-0.4176524878,
-0.1626805663,
-0.0783435404,
0.5151642561,
-0.1822160631,
-0.5407034159,
-0.0678937286,
0.2818249464,
-0.0350214802,
-0.237338677,
0.8353217244,
-0.6062936187,
-0.7794679403,
0.2346347868,
0.4388461411,
0.2527612746,
-0.1658260971,
-0.7297396064,
0.0152967582,
-0.1439594328,
-0.0714087859,
0.1849221736,
0.5070132017,
-0.0661813393,
0.7521803975,
0.8356146216,
0.1698025167,
-0.2398240119,
0.0576286502,
0.5780753493,
-0.3157106936,
-0.7351748943,
-1.1129512787,
0.0489316955,
-0.1027708501,
-0.180540204,
0.6846835613,
0.7623226643,
0.7683103681,
-0.0096565364,
1.1852544546,
0.3273799419,
0.3405341506,
-0.4013304114,
0.936874032,
-0.4173755944,
0.4453218579,
-0.4728510976,
-0.952319622,
-0.6173138022,
1.0075297356,
-0.1566851288,
0.0240507089,
0.3050414622,
1.0325393677,
-0.447753042,
0.1024577469,
0.3903297186,
-0.1293836683,
0.4075708389,
0.2215711623,
0.9628067613,
-0.4834849536,
0.6913276315,
-0.2162976116,
-0.2739500403,
-0.3129411042,
-0.8651287556,
-1.2606220245,
-0.3026185036,
-0.5176078677,
-0.3984393179,
0.0634414703,
0.7426463366,
0.6113767624,
-0.9150080085,
-0.1360106021,
-0.3288003206,
0.0005544021,
-0.1165887117,
-0.2277471274,
0.5662146807,
0.0778515264,
-0.6859192252,
0.2050196826,
0.3903700113,
0.4493530393,
-0.3701071441,
-0.0642745569,
0.1562973559,
0.1917352825,
0.8076212406,
0.221324265,
-0.4533739388,
-0.1912900507,
-0.3253927529,
-0.113571994,
-0.065539591,
0.8815440536,
-0.5793145299,
0.3390490711,
0.2640996575,
0.7733579874,
0.5080169439,
0.1002130732,
0.4844509661,
-0.6602558494,
0.1951868683,
0.30336833,
0.2441535443,
0.6424842477,
-0.2880312502,
0.234960258,
0.3472242355,
-0.5381472111,
-1.0183819532,
0.0826616287,
-0.7046526074,
-0.4325566292,
1.0327168703,
-0.0204450637,
-0.1955526471,
-0.4303571582,
-0.4240768552,
0.1171453372,
-0.4897624254,
1.1640216112,
0.3535988629,
0.4438074827,
-0.3778153956,
-0.7690328956,
0.6292838454,
0.0862250775,
-0.7867999673,
0.3596172333,
0.5399526358,
0.4019120634,
0.0796787739,
0.5710354447,
-0.0215605032,
0.2994856536,
-0.0914268941,
0.1363576204,
-0.075276196,
-0.1500825435,
-0.2514697313,
0.2342910469,
0.1203004047,
-0.0709505752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07692v1
|
On The Truthfulness of 'Surprisingly Likely' Responses of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T19:21:25 | 2023-11-13T19:21:25 |
Naman Goel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT
|
The surprisingly likely criterion in the seminal work of Prelec (the Bayesian
Truth Serum) guarantees truthfulness in a game-theoretic multi-agent setting,
by rewarding rational agents to maximise the expected information gain with
their answers w.r.t. their probabilistic beliefs. We investigate the relevance
of a similar criterion for responses of LLMs. We hypothesize that if the
surprisingly likely criterion works in LLMs, under certain conditions, the
responses that maximize the reward under this criterion should be more accurate
than the responses that only maximize the posterior probability. Using
benchmarks including the TruthfulQA benchmark and using openly available LLMs:
GPT-2 and LLaMA-2, we show that the method indeed improves the accuracy
significantly (for example, upto 24 percentage points aggregate improvement on
TruthfulQA and upto 70 percentage points improvement on individual categories
of questions).
|
[
-0.2807913423,
-0.7069769502,
1.1989336014,
0.0485253781,
-0.0330687948,
-0.0610333607,
-0.3108635545,
-0.358713299,
0.0048867334,
0.2978763282,
-0.4779977798,
-0.486230433,
-0.6840889454,
0.0818753615,
-0.3997270465,
0.7298048735,
0.2182033211,
-0.0578562021,
-0.0564671233,
-0.0140782343,
0.0952724367,
-0.7687761784,
-0.5964492559,
-0.2302592546,
0.7797892094,
0.1153859496,
0.8437981009,
0.2469016612,
0.6722375154,
0.2821654379,
0.0844737664,
0.2653348148,
-0.5733875036,
0.2123831809,
-0.3930315971,
-1.0716599226,
-0.2960988581,
0.4792084396,
0.5274525285,
0.4528647065,
-0.4915294051,
-0.0110964281,
0.1919062585,
0.5962333679,
-0.6896770597,
0.049383834,
-0.6197860837,
-0.1387635022,
-0.1380397826,
-0.4425993264,
-0.6775276065,
-0.6145777106,
0.2114349902,
-0.6660398245,
0.0997644886,
0.0014288555,
0.6174826622,
0.2783333063,
-0.6472228765,
-0.4246461689,
-0.6980410218,
0.8051280379,
-0.9119048715,
0.2975788713,
0.400890857,
0.4867999554,
-0.4985846579,
-0.513227582,
-0.7301800251,
-0.5187901258,
0.0640506446,
0.3825599551,
-0.0034597279,
0.2244971544,
0.4780216217,
0.2081908286,
-0.6185395122,
-0.0069209929,
0.1652872562,
-0.2682327926,
0.6588836908,
0.2214157283,
-0.1486337632,
0.2314666212,
-0.1777929366,
-0.2346360087,
-0.8664216995,
0.2432119101,
0.5405606627,
0.0979257748,
-0.1388078183,
0.662761271,
-0.277019769,
0.8862479925,
-0.1076507941,
-0.4800596833,
0.063039571,
-0.3822250664,
0.1579517424,
-0.1301480234,
0.7303484678,
0.4578098953,
0.4028946459,
0.1111752987,
-0.3484835923,
0.2787337005,
-0.0151876723,
-0.7606289387,
-0.2953906357,
0.4737682641,
-0.5259090662,
-0.1165053621,
0.3281150162,
-0.3714388311,
-0.4641637802,
-0.005738134,
0.4263578653,
-0.0233069211,
-0.3653307259,
0.0486388095,
0.0516162664,
0.1966210753,
0.4365007281,
-0.4665473104,
0.0251741409,
0.5957323909,
0.5883828402,
-0.3065315187,
-0.089665398,
-0.8348581195,
0.0721455738,
-0.7577633262,
1.0233129263,
-0.4751819074,
-0.1754788607,
0.1543536782,
-0.1093119234,
0.0463456213,
-0.7077451944,
0.8447847962,
-0.4714565277,
-0.0615520626,
-0.5696952939,
-0.6885797381,
0.060491018,
0.4684166312,
-0.6005089879,
0.5324543118,
-0.153888151,
-0.6797972322,
0.4615712166,
-0.1333913803,
-0.3908858001,
-0.1105875745,
-0.1151883528,
-0.0347779542,
0.3521878123,
-0.1519871801,
0.5164392591,
-0.5579665899,
0.4366060495,
-0.5433727503,
-0.3133017719,
1.10052526,
-0.7254012823,
0.4627803564,
0.2841697633,
-0.2626269162,
-0.1258991361,
-0.613065958,
0.2506832182,
0.1253134757,
-0.515126884,
-0.0657090917,
0.2379522026,
-0.492257148,
0.3931009471,
0.3255899251,
-0.6038887501,
-0.0077702212,
-0.2474707961,
0.1456775516,
0.779090941,
-0.0403682105,
0.1746272147,
-0.670879066,
0.4322882593,
-0.0687755793,
0.264554888,
0.1076557189,
-0.587698102,
-0.4375244975,
-0.2755053937,
0.4156472981,
0.4901949763,
-0.8457548618,
0.1838091761,
0.1120947674,
-0.5469890833,
-0.4465822875,
-0.0393258557,
0.3878236115,
0.4286927581,
0.0476200059,
-0.2047494799,
-0.3036790192,
-1.0527285337,
-0.53668046,
-0.6512284279,
0.0182974637,
0.45721066,
0.1264226735,
0.0413928106,
0.7740420103,
-0.3696508408,
0.0480698757,
-0.1780214757,
0.2393170744,
0.7649704218,
0.0683615729,
0.3659964204,
-0.9813652039,
-0.464161247,
-0.3132179081,
-0.6928733587,
-0.3087015152,
0.1185764521,
0.2201816589,
0.2554613352,
0.0609629788,
-0.7413460612,
0.4312883317,
0.7842104435,
-0.0172678679,
0.7782897353,
-0.2311442941,
0.4824055731,
-0.7545859218,
-0.0613228008,
-0.0377389081,
-0.4364740849,
-0.594937861,
-0.0165467802,
-0.0283979084,
0.5725536346,
-0.592774272,
0.3380717635,
-0.2752349675,
0.0622581504,
-0.4149082005,
0.1750010848,
-0.4462119341,
0.1673142314,
0.2071471512,
0.8621312976,
0.5566311479,
-0.8151240349,
0.4843794405,
0.0382718742,
-0.3651233912,
0.5217680931,
-0.6040837169,
0.1024761647,
-0.1384598315,
0.3801591098,
-1.1248753071,
-0.2009258419,
0.0926577151,
-0.6229592562,
-0.1138231084,
0.1509784311,
-0.5712004304,
-0.3656918705,
-0.3117494583,
0.2292550802,
0.5749820471,
-0.6342085004,
0.4529922307,
0.2315018773,
-0.0296704806,
-0.6941190958,
-0.6521511078,
0.0058761714,
-0.002524195,
-0.3051115572,
-0.0217475295,
-0.5953136683,
-0.5050373673,
-0.1236200184,
-0.2863551676,
0.3594420552,
0.1457801163,
0.1697318554,
0.2565951347,
-0.1062200889,
0.0248501785,
-0.3340384066,
-0.2604212761,
0.2292010635,
-0.2566970587,
0.5225968361,
-0.1006799862,
-0.4428906441,
-0.1471196264,
0.2068244368,
0.1285835207,
-0.0148092071,
0.85438025,
0.3041942716,
-0.2252955288,
-0.1567192972,
-0.9245471954,
-0.4544067383,
-0.4502128363,
0.2121762037,
-0.6401831508,
-1.0996260643,
0.5009250045,
-0.2694295943,
-0.2703608871,
0.436496973,
0.6475947499,
-0.2247132808,
1.2909327745,
0.4111988544,
0.0916462764,
0.0248581655,
0.0647734776,
0.2579371333,
-0.4868024886,
-0.1662666053,
-0.7888201475,
-0.0361712053,
-1.0435020924,
-0.4028605223,
0.4604075849,
-0.1239062026,
-0.0678317994,
-0.0346951559,
-0.1867873818,
0.3382555842,
0.7480393648,
0.1895163059,
0.3126471639,
-0.2803865373,
-0.1635914445,
-0.0067224079,
-0.7383828759,
-0.6002130508,
1.3560959101,
0.1048675105,
0.8458010554,
0.5990118384,
0.7022100091,
0.1112959534,
0.4233864546,
-0.5351247787,
0.7583172917,
0.0460469835,
-0.8544673324,
-0.4033991694,
-0.7498841882,
-0.761344254,
0.0264826156,
-0.5604647398,
-0.7176839113,
0.2248514295,
0.0448191836,
-0.360799402,
0.0358311124,
-0.3139511347,
0.5726735592,
-0.3841109574,
-0.6106612682,
-0.1931787431,
-0.8165550828,
0.3142653108,
-0.425350368,
0.2411878556,
-0.3322661519,
-0.3292218745,
0.8522447348,
-0.258369416,
0.4499408007,
0.0330059528,
-0.323202163,
0.4476165771,
0.2501216829,
0.727293849,
0.2942235768,
-0.2911940813,
0.0599924847,
0.1635011584,
-0.5659321547,
-0.8003326058,
0.4959164262,
-0.6577240825,
-1.0769426823,
-0.7103501558,
-0.446194917,
-0.5430653691,
-0.0389400907,
0.3762326241,
0.2096862346,
-0.1460925639,
0.1656526029,
0.9328040481,
-0.2186240554,
0.4557591379,
0.9281871915,
-0.0518029295,
-0.0913013965,
0.5912807584,
-0.0147768119,
0.4004892409,
0.6454183459,
0.3449725509,
-0.5896251202,
-0.7308360338,
-0.0241852794,
0.2764631808,
-0.5428215265,
-0.1981047094,
-0.4243499637,
-0.1539837271,
-0.1685417444,
0.2213503718,
-0.2826102972,
-0.3228906393,
0.1303972751,
-0.1974901408,
-0.2196856737,
0.7750403285,
-0.3142855763,
0.2173951268,
-0.7503785491,
0.3501286209,
0.5855871439,
-0.0715405121,
-0.362490803,
-0.7530352473,
0.036814712,
0.2277243882,
0.0232978333,
-1.0626648664,
0.2309101969,
0.1925852001,
0.9495629668,
0.4361815751,
0.3163120747,
0.2619511485,
-0.2299959511,
0.7021096349,
0.317820251,
-0.4989091158,
0.5843712687,
-0.2561314404,
0.1972947121,
0.5098342896,
0.610958159,
-0.2243179232,
-0.621067524,
-0.5193114281,
-0.3411200643,
0.4296252131,
0.083672002,
0.1641458571,
-0.132455498,
0.4471238554,
0.2730685771,
0.505185008,
-0.5745211244,
-0.3757921159,
0.3554532528,
-0.1796068102,
-0.5815273523,
-0.6877031922,
-0.2653428614,
0.2280050218,
0.8154520988,
-0.2827713192,
0.3055739999,
0.2837336361,
0.0349491388,
-0.1076293364,
0.3922667801,
0.5602192283,
1.0938395262,
-0.3216453493,
0.5973339081,
0.0879908428,
-0.3073123097,
0.5206642151,
0.2132281214,
-0.1353638768,
-0.2321078628,
0.6167115569,
0.3804218769,
-0.3145131171,
-0.816306591,
0.8302257657,
-0.2952240705,
-0.2026924193,
-0.0655057505,
0.2430061996,
0.0592443049,
0.4431495965,
0.7821609974,
-0.0155108925,
0.3880378604,
-0.8951996565,
0.1726038009,
0.6220533848,
-0.1405555904,
-0.2033524215,
0.6973832846,
-0.1402800232,
-0.244232446,
0.3662088811,
-0.4648767412,
-0.8039647937,
0.4592027664,
0.5559131503,
0.3892821968,
-0.5422896743,
0.4206743538,
0.4476681352,
0.425421685,
-0.257381171,
0.4168011844,
0.2042400986,
-0.8865169883,
-0.6587479115,
-0.5650697351,
-0.4432979524,
-0.0759380907,
-0.2935764194,
-0.1446879059,
-0.2236028463,
-0.4693859816,
-0.3535435796,
0.2146116346,
-0.6357458234,
0.4241704941,
0.1414601952,
0.8510417342,
-0.8864005208,
0.7941088676,
0.6562654376,
-0.2495145351,
-1.3535152674,
0.1302178055,
-0.102714248,
-0.8148353696,
0.435787648,
-0.1325782239,
-0.1258346736,
-0.2639518082,
-0.6951621771,
-0.8090538979,
0.7474168539,
0.8134622574,
-0.922662735,
0.3122265041,
0.3518915474,
0.5381469131,
-0.2675935328,
0.587741971,
0.5876934528,
0.5191610456,
0.3592194319,
-1.0469902754,
0.193157509,
-0.1879591346,
-0.2515751421,
-0.1127320305,
-0.6743222475,
0.7778738141,
-0.530659616,
0.058645606,
0.153149575,
0.7476378083,
0.6916067004,
0.4954892099,
0.5888278484,
0.3640067577,
1.013304472,
-0.262861073,
1.1881865263,
-0.3741675317,
0.279826045,
0.8557161689,
-0.2867510021,
0.8080146909,
0.3779986501,
-0.5157324672,
0.3306217194,
0.9410774112,
0.5096027851,
0.6850249767,
0.38170138,
-0.373931706,
-0.7124896049,
-0.2905352712,
-0.3332757056,
0.2017080337,
0.1549780369,
0.0970826373,
0.3059988022,
-0.2560186088,
-0.2460363805,
0.1409537643,
-0.2861394882,
0.6285237074,
0.4164831638,
-0.8030799627,
0.4441358447,
-0.0899950042,
0.5587777495,
-0.6034036875,
-0.1095807999,
-0.3674051166,
0.0968210176,
-0.3229327202,
-0.8577458262,
-0.2966189682,
-0.2642556429,
0.0580925457,
0.2345932424,
0.7900670767,
-0.3818382919,
-0.2751110196,
0.1743042916,
0.8778811097,
0.2820752561,
-0.2895775139,
-0.6720438004,
0.0950820372,
-0.2109622359,
-0.4376010299,
0.1651660949,
0.4014023542,
0.1303806901,
0.8923329115,
0.6041932702,
0.4893870652,
0.1203817204,
-0.0617040172,
0.5873452425,
-0.2812538743,
-0.4842825532,
-0.8922293782,
0.2699010074,
-0.0543554723,
0.0562027507,
0.9117590189,
0.5048191547,
0.5625798106,
0.0771340951,
0.7202987075,
0.2011808008,
0.5879897475,
-0.6230926514,
0.3731999397,
-0.542447269,
0.3508961499,
-0.2520698011,
-1.3937678337,
-0.0635624379,
0.6257044077,
-0.3845371604,
0.3015898764,
1.1166087389,
0.8057444692,
0.3107486665,
0.0581313819,
0.6140700579,
0.4555667937,
0.0565790161,
0.9614770412,
1.3081592321,
-0.0705306083,
0.3686321676,
-0.0057962681,
-0.4831536114,
-0.1001113579,
-0.9741366506,
-0.8520553112,
-0.5892279744,
-0.3473113179,
-0.6012752056,
0.4736300409,
0.7900021076,
0.6554227471,
-0.8209741116,
-0.1827722341,
0.3000272512,
0.1162535101,
-0.0969666466,
-0.0688088238,
0.2289736569,
-0.0827342197,
-0.4720232487,
0.3688232005,
0.1805195808,
0.0171218887,
0.0304044429,
-0.5217804313,
-0.0520682484,
0.4089993238,
0.3600727022,
-0.0386086293,
-0.542154789,
-0.4613045752,
0.0298000891,
-0.387349695,
-0.1685578674,
0.6323900819,
-0.6662844419,
0.179266274,
0.241620332,
0.4152935743,
0.5432525277,
0.0691627935,
0.5224310756,
-0.2489064932,
0.0299934186,
0.1845687777,
0.3040370643,
0.2657947242,
-0.2717781961,
0.7418711782,
0.2413050532,
-0.5111809969,
-0.7773393989,
0.2904966474,
-1.1783977747,
-0.1835049987,
1.276676178,
-0.3570045531,
-0.4094179273,
0.0881846026,
0.0039221696,
0.0994769782,
-0.2964503467,
0.607881844,
0.8841552734,
-0.0385706723,
-0.1842706352,
-0.7957773209,
0.3981387019,
0.5655929446,
-0.7306858301,
-0.1999154985,
0.4072235823,
0.089905858,
0.0997706726,
0.8366608024,
0.153343305,
0.4810371697,
-0.2189781666,
-0.2844180167,
0.2444157749,
-0.3114060163,
-0.0114181992,
0.3462103009,
0.6402693391,
0.1730148494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07689v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07689v1
|
MART: Improving LLM Safety with Multi-round Automatic Red-Teaming
| 2023-11-13T19:13:29 | 2023-11-13T19:13:29 |
Suyu Ge, Chunting Zhou, Rui Hou, Madian Khabsa, Yi-Chia Wang, Qifan Wang, Jiawei Han, Yuning Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Red-teaming is a common practice for mitigating unsafe behaviors in Large
Language Models (LLMs), which involves thoroughly assessing LLMs to identify
potential flaws and addressing them with responsible and accurate responses.
While effective, manual red-teaming is costly, and existing automatic
red-teaming typically discovers safety risks without addressing them. In this
paper, we propose a Multi-round Automatic Red-Teaming (MART) method, which
incorporates both automatic adversarial prompt writing and safe response
generation, significantly increasing red-teaming scalability and the safety of
the target LLM. Specifically, an adversarial LLM and a target LLM interplay
with each other in an iterative manner, where the adversarial LLM aims to
generate challenging prompts that elicit unsafe responses from the target LLM,
while the target LLM is fine-tuned with safety aligned data on these
adversarial prompts. In each round, the adversarial LLM crafts better attacks
on the updated target LLM, while the target LLM also improves itself through
safety fine-tuning. On adversarial prompt benchmarks, the violation rate of an
LLM with limited safety alignment reduces up to 84.7% after 4 rounds of MART,
achieving comparable performance to LLMs with extensive adversarial prompt
writing. Notably, model helpfulness on non-adversarial prompts remains stable
throughout iterations, indicating the target LLM maintains strong performance
on instruction following.
|
[
-0.4571120739,
-0.9877207279,
0.3512978256,
0.3771887124,
0.0884429067,
0.3635692894,
-0.2277074307,
-0.4853906929,
-0.0742569119,
0.4015060067,
-0.7065743208,
-0.4734233916,
-0.6174849272,
0.3776012659,
-0.1587840915,
1.1067169905,
0.0899509192,
-0.0347304493,
0.0549244247,
-0.1613205969,
-0.7389828563,
-0.6877313852,
-1.1257023811,
0.0979726911,
0.6155214906,
0.4183472395,
0.7537724972,
0.5537103415,
0.7947999239,
0.4917298853,
0.1466414779,
0.3715035915,
-0.5425841808,
0.401467979,
0.3503210545,
-0.5215483904,
-0.6883109212,
0.1936738789,
0.531658709,
0.1071162671,
-0.2129871547,
-0.2159105241,
-0.051620286,
0.764461875,
-0.6123620272,
-0.1924040914,
-0.8902921677,
0.093821466,
0.0092962002,
-0.3359337151,
-0.7608574629,
-0.463760525,
-0.1631811857,
-0.7924020886,
-0.0166711006,
0.5087782741,
0.6526309848,
0.6079314947,
-0.2994882762,
-0.2752145529,
-0.1965690851,
0.7663127184,
-0.5145633817,
-0.0439062864,
0.2443580031,
0.6254623532,
-0.314558506,
-0.1478341371,
-0.4036973715,
-0.2764973938,
-0.1536931843,
0.1180271432,
-0.2433959991,
-0.0082591083,
0.2492373884,
-0.3032236993,
-0.611489296,
0.168539539,
-0.1936809123,
-0.1454579681,
0.9666221738,
0.3771729767,
0.4064122438,
0.2054170221,
-0.8437919021,
-0.2377645373,
-0.880364418,
-0.2120659351,
0.48369205,
0.514122963,
0.0238479543,
0.6144021749,
-0.0932190642,
0.5079543591,
0.2161329985,
-0.1612448841,
0.2743113935,
-0.5144158006,
-0.0851197168,
0.1238010973,
1.1218268871,
0.8358571529,
0.4291695654,
-0.2057980895,
-0.4097903371,
0.0638694689,
0.5913046002,
-0.5635626316,
-0.376436621,
0.1272125989,
-0.1186612621,
-0.6682915092,
-0.1110807806,
-0.8139751554,
-0.6095662117,
-0.1958089918,
0.4203769267,
-0.5433501005,
-0.044098787,
-0.1964195818,
-0.1217501909,
-0.049890507,
0.2823389173,
-0.6342793107,
0.0945093632,
0.3927869201,
0.7737653255,
-0.4515559375,
-0.6560445428,
-1.1795752048,
0.3199285269,
-0.330514133,
0.9008136392,
-0.1640310436,
-0.2249543965,
-0.0562404469,
0.0077564935,
-0.266245842,
-0.3772039413,
-0.033828292,
-0.5965880156,
0.2704534829,
-0.1042612493,
-0.2878806591,
0.1271830648,
0.8187845349,
-0.6998277903,
0.748277247,
-0.2531298995,
-0.7346618772,
0.4328770041,
-0.9749010801,
-0.450499624,
-0.0224185754,
0.0074217133,
-0.7377821803,
-0.4179601371,
0.4921422899,
0.4544195533,
0.0674988702,
0.0609211922,
-0.5847939849,
-0.2158268839,
0.3558133841,
-0.3582668602,
0.7712791562,
0.0223071929,
-0.4028672278,
0.7266311049,
-0.5116361976,
0.2283334583,
0.2480400354,
-0.4206867218,
-0.0645316169,
-0.344450742,
-0.3402069509,
0.1648252457,
0.2505719066,
-0.3511630595,
0.0714456812,
-0.1544737667,
0.1580443978,
0.9620770812,
-0.0165394675,
0.6841362715,
-0.6383731365,
0.6570832133,
-0.2855399549,
0.3625893891,
-0.0109540112,
-0.3601662219,
-0.5500995517,
-0.4848882556,
0.0890956074,
0.806651175,
-1.1091765165,
0.4985025227,
0.3007409275,
-0.3265346587,
-0.4390604496,
-0.0340581685,
0.7187719941,
0.3802376986,
0.4965271652,
0.2744685113,
-0.5030014515,
-0.6956548095,
-0.0983337015,
-0.3090846539,
0.0434181206,
0.3088738322,
0.2903014421,
-0.2923268378,
0.5665050745,
-0.5815410018,
-0.2743201554,
-0.1375892162,
0.3623775244,
-0.2064494491,
0.356813997,
0.512147069,
-0.6306059361,
-0.6188313365,
-0.2322673202,
-0.797134459,
-0.181186229,
-0.2537768483,
-0.4281112552,
0.802880168,
0.6125076413,
-0.3644674122,
0.0975260437,
0.4756906927,
-0.5159385204,
0.6547409892,
-0.2475260496,
0.4556399286,
-0.8748048544,
-0.0583979934,
-0.0676489919,
-0.3443936408,
-0.6615365148,
0.3297716975,
0.1918286234,
0.0211925693,
-0.793418467,
0.4258432388,
-0.4680202901,
0.0497082844,
-0.2871575952,
0.4024484456,
-0.0864749402,
0.5247303843,
-0.070118852,
1.2085542679,
0.2513128221,
-0.676671207,
0.366854161,
0.2988895774,
0.2067788392,
0.7497205734,
-0.7350868583,
0.1086994037,
-0.0350794494,
0.2055213451,
-0.8085541725,
-0.1198244616,
0.3391519487,
-0.5083683133,
0.4541589022,
0.0479954034,
-0.4940336347,
-0.1610398442,
-0.6862695217,
0.2842493057,
0.242098406,
-0.4765398204,
0.3036261499,
0.738132596,
-0.4018871486,
-0.5928575397,
-0.5509163141,
0.2142264694,
-0.5839980841,
-0.7823986411,
-0.0062089558,
-0.4901801944,
-0.3504248857,
-0.3728571236,
0.3180117011,
-0.1181994379,
0.4703118503,
0.1132560149,
0.6296436191,
0.0326390378,
-0.01715344,
-0.3624618351,
-0.5348725915,
0.1046922952,
0.1851757914,
0.5339322686,
-0.5304853916,
-0.2244166583,
-0.2233015746,
0.5291770101,
0.7157755494,
0.0008171363,
0.8273141384,
0.510219872,
-0.1641175151,
-0.0772923604,
-0.4308978319,
-0.3431854546,
-0.5045375824,
0.1074626073,
-0.1974982172,
-0.8818560243,
0.2374495268,
0.1896490902,
0.2557449639,
0.3199973702,
0.6147229671,
-0.3827576339,
1.0018512011,
0.5418357849,
-0.0052581835,
0.2798041403,
-0.0153160347,
0.130414322,
-0.6831546426,
-0.2989018559,
-0.5094279051,
-0.3084584177,
-0.3334581852,
-0.2307064384,
0.7682884336,
-0.0410301127,
-0.67275846,
0.4832919538,
-0.7468135953,
0.7008607388,
0.7433066964,
-0.0352798142,
0.2385062128,
-0.362564683,
-0.1488779187,
0.0341578461,
-0.8497206569,
-0.4378018379,
0.9606574178,
0.4030476511,
0.729393363,
0.2286038101,
0.8075546026,
0.2430681288,
0.2133156508,
-0.4765678048,
0.7360649705,
0.0280302577,
-0.3407930732,
-0.6528519392,
-0.5261747837,
-0.7601171732,
0.2584736645,
-0.4768373072,
-0.2271580696,
-0.4630442262,
0.3338019848,
-0.6037650108,
0.1974646002,
-0.8100059628,
0.6884567738,
-0.5022336841,
-0.1111136675,
0.0887141824,
-0.7618686557,
0.5989444852,
-0.1840204448,
0.1856274754,
-0.094960697,
-0.1240469962,
0.7256861925,
-0.3168420196,
0.8304576278,
-0.1299296767,
-0.0556411967,
0.083796531,
0.157865569,
0.9714110494,
0.1162937284,
0.0011706053,
-0.0168583486,
-0.326202482,
-0.1296983659,
-0.3615317345,
0.6097320318,
-0.6021018028,
-0.5383905768,
-0.5743147135,
-0.9925459623,
-0.238162294,
0.2979315817,
0.0492715947,
0.0844139233,
0.0530559458,
0.0485825837,
0.780954957,
-0.2478317618,
0.7553343773,
0.7285574675,
0.1775420457,
-0.8200682402,
0.7871605754,
-0.2692118585,
0.4882514477,
0.1940356791,
0.0045993347,
-0.5356813669,
-0.7190662026,
-0.6698288918,
-0.0294986889,
-0.4821114838,
-0.6850773692,
-0.7268049717,
-0.0968734846,
-0.224352181,
-0.5909820795,
-0.3910178244,
-0.4115739167,
-0.0865936726,
0.0258055273,
0.5337700248,
0.5279217362,
-0.1188390106,
0.1950033009,
-0.9236235023,
0.3436114192,
0.3327521384,
0.0754176304,
-0.3694964945,
-0.0921109766,
0.129590407,
0.0320274234,
-0.2279225141,
-0.6092461348,
0.3675837517,
-0.3446621895,
0.4773468673,
-0.0799137726,
0.4876112044,
0.6734457612,
-0.7617946267,
0.5740261674,
0.6093963385,
-0.6761013269,
0.563629508,
-0.604224205,
0.1921681315,
0.7950183153,
0.1454314142,
-0.1564433873,
-0.7927724719,
-0.4592261314,
-0.9549742341,
0.703535676,
0.2895635068,
-0.4860494435,
-0.264152348,
-0.2361785918,
-0.1433359236,
0.3298648,
-0.7932305932,
-0.22752361,
0.0985846594,
-0.1475645155,
0.18472597,
-0.1125698239,
-0.6155660748,
0.3113837242,
0.912083745,
-0.3648177087,
0.2940769196,
-0.1076497659,
-0.1371187568,
-0.2487353086,
0.3198409081,
0.854373455,
0.2362702042,
0.0012679769,
0.1676223278,
0.5813946128,
-0.0783751234,
0.2411319166,
0.1019505113,
-0.2007395327,
-0.4244077802,
0.3641649783,
0.3910044134,
0.3190945387,
-0.6898878217,
0.445667088,
-0.3721129298,
-0.2598829567,
-0.1587141305,
0.330686003,
-0.1169313043,
0.4482765198,
0.1049553528,
0.3540809155,
-0.097756505,
-0.3330192864,
0.4911421537,
0.6941379905,
-0.1217711419,
0.3316753805,
0.6477028728,
0.5322420001,
-0.3932535052,
0.3547949195,
-0.4575099647,
-0.8491733074,
0.7659826875,
0.6074209213,
0.8563935757,
-0.0939161107,
0.2537481189,
0.3664312065,
0.5810475349,
-0.1674816161,
0.0803038403,
0.3877048194,
-0.4363346398,
-0.1596536934,
-0.2779398561,
-0.5771459937,
-0.1891190559,
-0.4164166451,
0.0997709483,
-0.5089868307,
-0.0271276515,
-0.4747965932,
0.0931418389,
-0.1852952242,
0.1048815027,
-0.0023335367,
0.6710653305,
-0.4651137292,
0.3562389016,
0.6572868228,
-0.2119564712,
-0.5895507932,
-0.0417789519,
0.424832046,
-0.9271326065,
0.4269286692,
0.2841836214,
-0.3974078298,
-0.2175027281,
-0.2901049256,
-0.8589011431,
1.2684668303,
0.2402017266,
-0.8948917389,
0.0855540857,
-0.1269478947,
0.1620101631,
-0.3522404432,
0.189307332,
0.3866465092,
0.5641413331,
0.1844826639,
-0.892526269,
0.3287900388,
-0.1326415539,
-0.3278522193,
0.4414286911,
-0.7887774706,
0.7107851505,
-0.5698540807,
-0.344945699,
-0.0081122043,
0.4825855494,
0.9414875507,
0.4011159539,
0.7875263095,
0.6349184513,
1.0692014694,
-0.0980897173,
0.8868591785,
-0.2501562238,
0.0162406825,
1.2312374115,
-0.3364716172,
0.8040385246,
0.2981290519,
0.0268516187,
-0.1218468696,
0.1881264448,
-0.0938360095,
0.5253328681,
0.2156752795,
-0.2045438737,
-0.2734115124,
0.1340695918,
-0.2943737209,
-0.0458594896,
-0.0221245475,
0.0242678393,
-0.1013306677,
0.0082952669,
0.3464796841,
0.1677338481,
-0.0815725625,
0.9508057833,
-0.1964662075,
-0.8401456475,
0.6977535486,
-0.2233971804,
0.9799698591,
-0.4574023783,
0.1183522418,
0.0434092768,
0.193295911,
-0.0081079695,
-0.911882937,
0.52202636,
0.2186170667,
-0.3492042422,
-0.2891648114,
0.6616495848,
-0.6038146615,
-0.3412002921,
0.3065078259,
0.1989600658,
-0.0961825773,
0.0640536323,
-0.8760867715,
0.2719916999,
-0.0190481152,
-0.0629636124,
0.4847407937,
0.3511956036,
0.0875323191,
0.9062919021,
0.7752867937,
-0.1128071845,
0.1961853653,
-0.0129279047,
0.8820473552,
-0.6337378621,
-0.4076307416,
-0.8934879899,
0.6711397171,
-0.3800027668,
-0.2063498348,
0.6514784694,
0.2412860394,
0.5359268188,
0.1119120717,
0.7321709394,
0.0932825357,
0.2692045867,
-0.7396582961,
1.1123460531,
-0.3008880615,
0.316680789,
-0.1202249676,
-0.5050597787,
-0.6711608171,
0.663536489,
-0.0429722369,
-0.0353011116,
0.8855717182,
0.8697417974,
0.4999946356,
-0.0206797663,
0.3615399897,
0.1673294157,
0.6050183773,
0.719602108,
0.7655538917,
-0.5159066319,
0.9539915323,
-0.1536673754,
-0.3308193386,
-0.1446350962,
-1.1408883333,
-1.2669200897,
-0.1095114201,
-0.4730658531,
-0.3981444538,
0.3168829978,
0.8971868753,
0.6626808643,
-0.756786108,
0.1906624138,
-0.0277223289,
0.0647331774,
-0.0225162562,
-0.2607835233,
0.0280502886,
-0.8615468144,
-0.569868505,
0.7874085903,
0.3735171258,
0.1451092809,
0.0216122121,
-0.3565661311,
-0.2056597769,
-0.0771719292,
0.6446598172,
0.0788188353,
-0.5081287622,
-0.2722599804,
0.0729184151,
-0.2814618647,
-0.1739241332,
0.4506914318,
-0.5076758862,
0.2253919095,
0.2586151659,
0.8375070095,
-0.266844213,
0.1095711738,
0.8759673834,
-0.817168355,
-0.1657324284,
0.3930621445,
0.3889755607,
0.3792106509,
-0.6654547453,
0.6485747695,
-0.1103568226,
-0.8320550919,
-0.9333128929,
0.1331238896,
-0.8294430971,
-0.2937953472,
1.3287688494,
-0.1432137936,
-0.0522843897,
-0.153588444,
-0.3077398837,
0.139493838,
-0.6848193407,
0.9781323671,
0.5113700628,
-0.1275389045,
0.0140023753,
-0.229526937,
0.5197664499,
0.3232595623,
-1.2344993353,
0.2808139324,
0.5227607489,
-0.0083746286,
0.1834883243,
0.5375424623,
0.0228431709,
0.5347104669,
-0.1159277186,
-0.2601989508,
-0.5472009182,
-0.8704527617,
-0.1822297424,
0.4801908433,
-0.2778432667,
-0.4544615149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07687v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07687v1
|
Language Model-In-The-Loop: Data Optimal Approach to Learn-To-Recommend Actions in Text Games
| 2023-11-13T19:12:49 | 2023-11-13T19:12:49 |
Arjun Vaithilingam Sudhakar, Prasanna Parthasarathi, Janarthanan Rajendran, Sarath Chandar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior performance in
language understanding benchmarks. CALM, a popular approach, leverages
linguistic priors of LLMs -- GPT-2 -- for action candidate recommendations to
improve the performance in text games in Jericho without environment-provided
actions. However, CALM adapts GPT-2 with annotated human gameplays and keeps
the LLM fixed during the learning of the text based games. In this work, we
explore and evaluate updating LLM used for candidate recommendation during the
learning of the text based game as well to mitigate the reliance on the human
annotated gameplays, which are costly to acquire. We observe that by updating
the LLM during learning using carefully selected in-game transitions, we can
reduce the dependency on using human annotated game plays for fine-tuning the
LLMs. We conducted further analysis to study the transferability of the updated
LLMs and observed that transferring in-game trained models to other games did
not result in a consistent transfer.
|
[
-0.0671930164,
-0.670800209,
0.6397408843,
0.2226946652,
-0.3375324309,
-0.002673791,
-0.5326845646,
-0.39128986,
-0.3029575944,
0.6266848445,
-0.4832496345,
-0.5712884068,
-0.3173141181,
-0.0174998306,
-0.0433350801,
1.2001712322,
-0.3973827958,
-0.1242852733,
-0.1496927291,
-0.086017251,
-0.7417929769,
-0.4321558774,
-1.0804427862,
-1.0388612747,
0.4046845138,
0.3883507252,
0.7008034587,
0.6421707273,
0.6651211977,
0.319791913,
-0.199458614,
0.0383461565,
-0.9133141041,
0.3687694967,
-0.539001286,
-0.4831841588,
-0.2977436185,
-0.2009209991,
0.4340680838,
0.0994492695,
-0.2686234713,
-0.0761618391,
0.0025409383,
0.4367730021,
-0.4202358425,
0.2949877977,
-0.4531028271,
0.0586061105,
-0.0067138802,
-0.2875301242,
-0.5159457326,
-0.3137097359,
0.5062826276,
-1.0179377794,
-0.151227951,
0.0174150262,
0.6933090091,
0.2879032791,
-0.1217081398,
-0.7020921111,
-0.912745893,
0.6560141444,
-0.6040073037,
0.0142154116,
0.54255265,
-0.041161146,
-0.512784481,
-0.3031603694,
-0.3817640245,
-0.3968190551,
0.2473550141,
0.329469651,
-0.1677886099,
0.3117327094,
0.3345573545,
0.0764581561,
-0.3081052005,
0.3587823808,
-0.0431907102,
0.0052984152,
0.7537603378,
0.2036420554,
0.2629610002,
0.2998240292,
-0.5354353786,
-0.2627301812,
-0.7801538706,
0.2814945281,
0.149042815,
0.2226826251,
-0.2481351048,
0.3639399111,
0.0442887992,
0.4665589929,
0.260505408,
-0.5476644039,
-0.0658430383,
-0.1129656434,
-0.1555463821,
-0.0675337836,
0.6388565898,
0.4503439963,
0.6005251408,
-0.3958438933,
-0.2749584913,
0.0235590339,
0.1278510392,
-0.6531554461,
-0.2652522624,
0.0371787958,
-0.2423785031,
-0.2784656882,
-0.0872619674,
-0.6566992998,
-0.6416382194,
-0.3248467445,
0.6139189601,
-0.4817389548,
-0.091731146,
0.1886309385,
-0.1623504162,
0.0338457972,
0.4585992396,
-1.0213220119,
0.2580578327,
0.5234260559,
0.8626226187,
-0.3507852554,
-0.2130307555,
-0.2512589097,
0.4131503105,
-0.5438135266,
0.9958509207,
-0.5440782905,
-0.7727652788,
0.3754686117,
-0.0965870395,
-0.0339371189,
-0.6200003624,
0.6545375586,
-0.5423263311,
0.1401274651,
-0.4435698986,
-0.943056047,
-0.1815374494,
0.3151917458,
-0.4466629028,
1.0459142923,
0.1236174405,
-0.4355291128,
0.392324537,
-0.9410419464,
-0.5617902875,
0.1456167251,
0.263029933,
-0.0829305798,
0.163279444,
0.2429736406,
0.1647060364,
-0.070237875,
0.2988510132,
-0.4735723734,
-1.0367730856,
0.2576366663,
0.0314745232,
0.4250369668,
0.142987296,
-0.2988837361,
0.3300871849,
-0.2749826908,
-0.2025162578,
-0.1514583379,
-0.7027118206,
-0.3454067409,
0.4406602681,
-0.1858100593,
0.4153779745,
-0.1791116744,
-0.1538008302,
0.4504120052,
-0.2911098897,
0.1690409631,
0.8909720182,
0.1639806628,
0.6784514189,
-0.4602325559,
0.5983474851,
-0.0666452795,
-0.0659545809,
-0.231866464,
-0.4875836372,
-0.7384785414,
-0.2284457088,
0.2872821987,
0.811347127,
-1.1161298752,
0.190704152,
-0.0784935728,
-0.3653523326,
-0.5264992118,
0.1607032567,
0.261596024,
0.2967601418,
0.2471735477,
-0.1256470084,
-0.2954526842,
-0.323138386,
-0.307508409,
-0.5919517875,
0.0875680745,
0.4018339813,
0.3485759795,
-0.4627789259,
0.8459715247,
-0.2204359323,
-0.1716123223,
-0.3782960474,
0.1927455664,
0.1091227606,
0.2659236491,
0.430146426,
-0.1236050949,
-0.4522316456,
-0.0292952731,
-0.6458954811,
-0.3129137456,
-0.41351372,
-0.2020575106,
0.0853355899,
0.5997903943,
-0.4007738829,
0.4213477373,
0.6253989339,
-0.4169895053,
0.2731356919,
-0.4720046222,
0.1444247067,
-0.8945580125,
-0.0735041276,
0.1813439876,
-0.1994562,
-0.5759575367,
0.2222942263,
-0.1062013134,
0.0461941212,
-0.0314194821,
0.9270391464,
-0.2389060408,
0.1537290663,
-0.5612922311,
0.5038084388,
-0.1743924022,
0.516890049,
0.1755474806,
0.9096338749,
0.5835135579,
-0.8044078946,
0.1931100488,
0.2718639374,
-0.3715584278,
0.4980844855,
-0.435187012,
0.4632799923,
-0.070004344,
0.3080209494,
-0.7714037895,
0.0170750897,
0.2389216274,
0.0363159999,
0.2836010158,
-0.2762029469,
-0.4386046529,
-0.1617409885,
-0.3176313639,
0.029150987,
0.566010952,
-0.6275722384,
0.2356373966,
0.4814875722,
-0.2236840874,
-0.1293399036,
-0.4650823176,
0.0749455616,
-0.3516714573,
-0.1924578696,
0.4813821912,
-0.2978337705,
-0.440394789,
-0.2221632451,
0.1471303701,
0.0158431362,
0.1254020035,
0.2408161908,
0.2702037394,
-0.0784554631,
0.5148846507,
-0.0665170625,
-0.2134223878,
-0.0296614636,
-0.1002805084,
0.1798646748,
0.1946899146,
0.0763016269,
-0.3164646029,
0.2012333572,
0.4087163508,
0.1796973795,
0.4836407006,
0.5112144351,
-0.1854214519,
-0.1888415962,
-0.3525051177,
-0.0966162235,
-0.4862509072,
0.5139915943,
-0.1586152166,
-1.1203001738,
0.5415731668,
-0.5156435966,
0.0948115438,
0.3207618594,
0.6489910483,
-0.4159616232,
0.9346033335,
0.7370343208,
-0.3900413513,
0.7967320681,
0.170793727,
0.0665151775,
-0.8657517433,
-0.0544350296,
-0.4220077693,
-0.332829237,
-0.6497524381,
-0.5206897259,
0.0450692847,
0.2777867019,
-0.424166292,
0.0750250667,
-0.0373874865,
0.6013551354,
0.3625875711,
0.2926992476,
0.1266039014,
0.0457248613,
-0.1857337356,
-0.1540283859,
-0.7889761925,
-0.2842294276,
0.8647472262,
0.3910011649,
0.7999869585,
0.3043565154,
0.5531767011,
0.1678958535,
0.6888481379,
-0.8224363923,
0.4074614346,
-0.1028042659,
-0.4721307158,
-0.272148937,
-0.390353471,
-0.7534299493,
-0.0593433306,
-0.4984412789,
-0.8899322152,
-0.0781837031,
0.13379848,
-0.4921103716,
0.306515187,
-0.5361846089,
0.4936389029,
-0.0400622115,
-0.6004331708,
-0.1940456629,
-0.2031605393,
0.2454458326,
-0.0949294269,
0.2134965062,
-0.0346551836,
-0.0139471404,
0.6552657485,
-0.0853418335,
0.538987875,
-0.081516251,
-0.2574148476,
0.3971416056,
0.3431039155,
0.805077076,
0.1685199291,
-0.2867760956,
-0.036545027,
-0.3327034712,
-0.0421547219,
-0.5105516315,
0.7195899487,
-0.8517782688,
-0.5277683735,
-0.5554887056,
-0.7092213035,
-0.320613265,
-0.0262272786,
0.1875298023,
0.3076725602,
-0.2077386528,
0.0025233275,
0.6263554096,
-0.4102388024,
0.585480392,
0.5970782638,
-0.3454279304,
-0.3154505789,
0.7832958698,
-0.2228201479,
0.0250027161,
0.2476210892,
0.3785042167,
-0.5188455582,
-0.7469710708,
-0.2531318963,
0.1644205004,
-0.6332866549,
-0.1393406987,
-0.2094669193,
0.178826943,
0.0457318611,
-0.3574542105,
0.0477796122,
0.2467249632,
-0.3420149386,
-0.1065462232,
0.6868711114,
1.0652837753,
-0.0168344118,
0.6538937092,
-0.4166209102,
0.0177816171,
0.1955287606,
0.6575411558,
-0.308862716,
-0.834420383,
-0.4047602713,
-0.0602000095,
-0.2601217031,
-0.8416469693,
0.0641351864,
0.2603813112,
0.3204534054,
0.4538966715,
-0.1494553536,
1.0296707153,
-0.4520713389,
0.7477488518,
-0.0820871592,
-0.9328536391,
0.3912766278,
-0.6888385415,
0.7932351828,
0.8308789134,
0.0262587406,
-0.6060043573,
-0.3083029389,
-0.3661055565,
-0.632627964,
0.9781768918,
0.0887428597,
0.0867255777,
-0.0208847914,
0.7301906347,
-0.2723432779,
0.0875238776,
-0.5542636514,
-0.0159399919,
0.3811125159,
-0.046255026,
-0.3543500006,
-0.3394608796,
0.098914668,
-0.2801577449,
0.8313819766,
-0.1006918103,
0.140454933,
0.0272497926,
-0.1901544482,
-0.3916282952,
0.0946282297,
0.7145495415,
0.4040828347,
-0.275516808,
-0.1698045582,
0.5074142814,
-0.6148084402,
0.1879349053,
-0.3217328191,
-0.4276738763,
-0.075715147,
0.4427716136,
0.9726859331,
0.9181143045,
-0.6665122509,
0.1776214391,
0.0107059982,
-0.1388764977,
0.1576623321,
0.1219273806,
0.0414969362,
0.4006972611,
-0.2318004668,
0.1269849241,
0.0352169834,
-0.7190039754,
0.2770364881,
0.0655019283,
-0.7427249551,
-0.2959825695,
0.2746699154,
0.2859715819,
-0.4668191075,
0.5892637968,
-0.1840156764,
-0.5071395636,
0.1422361583,
0.8567374349,
0.840241611,
-0.285690695,
0.389585048,
0.5251550674,
0.1756552309,
-0.6805576682,
0.3071227074,
0.30231902,
-0.7203820944,
-0.5198046565,
-0.3200383782,
-0.5407570601,
0.10670726,
-0.5294387341,
0.3598840833,
-0.4903425872,
-0.466443181,
-0.6026601791,
0.119671829,
-0.6730060577,
0.0507105328,
0.2826461792,
0.759115994,
-0.6106245518,
0.9666131139,
0.6474342942,
-0.1585337967,
-0.8217915297,
0.1158954129,
-0.0309828408,
-0.4154154062,
0.0407801084,
-0.3807067871,
-0.1176564172,
0.0526520126,
-0.5150324702,
-0.8207244277,
0.9772791266,
0.5003134608,
-0.6324909925,
0.2267993987,
-0.3112051487,
0.7043421865,
-0.3908278644,
0.5066710711,
0.5781315565,
0.3624968529,
0.3284144402,
-0.6129488349,
-0.1775032431,
0.0144875171,
0.1463669688,
0.0810794234,
-0.4117082357,
0.621267736,
-0.5103929043,
-0.2096846402,
0.0805889219,
0.505435884,
0.5765765309,
0.0455503426,
0.395278275,
0.5209320188,
0.8252999783,
-0.1531069875,
1.1672655344,
-0.108703725,
0.5178759098,
1.2842960358,
-0.6491004229,
1.1331549883,
0.2253664434,
-0.0417221524,
0.5693482161,
0.8209584951,
0.0663887858,
0.6418123245,
0.464106679,
-0.1044341773,
-0.1695624143,
-0.1698334962,
-0.1510005593,
0.4840989113,
0.2772209942,
-0.1118144467,
-0.3211272359,
-0.2123628706,
0.4848304391,
0.0564962029,
-0.4393908083,
1.1608641148,
-0.0966016203,
-0.8973186016,
0.1112228408,
0.0918077156,
0.7630294561,
-0.7247519493,
-0.0775983334,
-0.3702523112,
0.4074684978,
0.0928036422,
-0.6184777021,
-0.179180488,
0.201720804,
-0.0783310235,
-0.1980016679,
0.6725752354,
-0.7219773531,
-0.4644481838,
0.5410068035,
0.2901358902,
0.0741125792,
0.0371002816,
-0.8220077753,
0.2362560183,
-0.1108870879,
-0.1572162211,
0.4817713499,
0.4612718225,
-0.1393066496,
0.5546650887,
0.6100917459,
0.1629253626,
-0.3999561369,
0.1646843255,
0.6572885513,
-0.6333899498,
-0.6163915396,
-0.925267756,
0.2983081639,
0.0542217083,
-0.5620669127,
0.6017438173,
0.285872221,
0.6149632335,
0.0623290427,
0.8078527451,
0.3567095399,
0.133287549,
-0.6281788945,
0.654635191,
-0.1908712536,
0.3112845123,
-0.5258662701,
-0.9075201154,
-0.2242979109,
0.7461510301,
-0.1862292886,
0.088882193,
0.7140635848,
0.6671644449,
0.284766227,
0.0387287922,
0.3709937334,
0.1224776283,
0.322103709,
0.7766045928,
0.701298058,
-0.3892093897,
0.1283575594,
0.1209209859,
-0.4131858349,
-0.2985838354,
-0.9892061949,
-1.1436619759,
-0.3821112514,
-0.4925405681,
-0.4350478351,
0.3122606575,
1.2252211571,
0.5535872579,
-0.820861578,
-0.6196598411,
0.0974314287,
0.1406949759,
-0.4557231665,
-0.1389583647,
0.2964339852,
-0.3457046449,
-0.5185684562,
0.5119501352,
0.4444049895,
0.0418812931,
0.0810662806,
-0.3893735409,
-0.3647684455,
0.3083222806,
0.7002215385,
0.2296892703,
-0.6761690974,
-0.5474998355,
0.0982885733,
-0.0585673898,
-0.0713439211,
1.0472198725,
-0.7467440367,
0.7133409977,
0.2759199739,
0.4351004064,
0.3170540035,
-0.1245938987,
0.9312692881,
-0.3577423394,
0.3630431294,
0.0186356194,
0.1445669234,
0.2092270851,
-0.19145675,
0.5665983558,
0.0560407303,
-0.5541498065,
-0.6975321174,
-0.0811457336,
-0.7149015665,
0.0256496686,
1.534345746,
-0.3036630154,
0.0502065197,
-0.3668428659,
-0.359483242,
0.2646242082,
-0.5389627814,
0.8909565806,
1.0069727898,
0.0206875931,
-0.1927993596,
-0.5501279831,
0.9877556562,
-0.0191525072,
-0.6848132014,
0.082473129,
0.1378853321,
0.0301385093,
-0.2172238529,
0.6639055014,
0.0153662665,
0.1212234274,
-0.1826753467,
0.0606990606,
0.1824758798,
-0.259680897,
-0.7123070955,
-0.1377276182,
0.2479811311,
0.2085675299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07682v1
|
Fuse to Forget: Bias Reduction and Selective Memorization through Model Fusion
| 2023-11-13T19:02:56 | 2023-11-13T19:02:56 |
Kerem Zaman, Leshem Choshen, Shashank Srivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Model fusion research aims to aggregate the knowledge of multiple models to
enhance performance by combining their weights. In this work, we study the
inverse, investigating whether and how can model fusion interfere and reduce
unwanted knowledge. We delve into the effects of model fusion on the evolution
of learned shortcuts, social biases, and memorization capabilities in
fine-tuned language models. Through several experiments covering text
classification and generation tasks, our analysis highlights that shared
knowledge among models is usually enhanced during model fusion, while unshared
knowledge is usually lost or forgotten. Based on this observation, we
demonstrate the potential of model fusion as a debiasing tool and showcase its
efficacy in addressing privacy concerns associated with language models.
|
[
-0.423825413,
-0.7653707266,
0.6141240597,
-0.1676204056,
-0.0194967408,
0.026544055,
0.0972753614,
-0.2608896196,
-0.0269986205,
0.7291381955,
-0.556185782,
-0.2812539041,
-0.4684364796,
-0.4750954211,
-0.6870085597,
0.9529812336,
0.09901236,
0.1338595748,
-0.5151088834,
-0.1148287803,
-0.5568582416,
-0.4516436756,
-0.260669291,
-0.7553915977,
0.363340646,
0.3051041067,
0.7142808437,
0.5060235858,
0.3989465535,
0.2410279363,
-0.3533245623,
0.1722524166,
-0.9607462287,
0.0197024103,
-0.557501018,
-0.4000053704,
-0.2245608717,
-0.0049217166,
0.8455227613,
0.7346530557,
0.0887086317,
0.2129852623,
0.137167722,
0.8623777628,
-1.0150227547,
-0.1342027485,
-0.8658909798,
-0.1806960106,
-0.0937870145,
0.1764494777,
-0.3092365265,
-0.3304003775,
0.293394357,
-0.3229035437,
0.4145919979,
0.1140043139,
0.7475181818,
0.42021209,
-0.3505188227,
0.2018907219,
-1.0834829807,
0.9570042491,
-0.3820473254,
0.3955315053,
0.5158088803,
0.2605220675,
-0.0512079857,
-0.3381674886,
-0.5079956055,
0.2589946091,
-0.1215367764,
0.1615864038,
-0.2588010728,
0.144632116,
0.377453059,
0.4231722951,
-0.3243699372,
0.2046824694,
-0.5427951813,
-0.3565385044,
0.7081940174,
0.0498628765,
0.4593706429,
-0.2287525684,
-0.1743561029,
-0.0951578468,
-0.9201615453,
-0.2211776823,
0.4902069271,
-0.0557702892,
0.0326523967,
0.4164938033,
-0.2721583247,
0.7386158109,
-0.016520476,
0.056550093,
0.0781819373,
-0.3000455499,
-0.3474646509,
0.0855469778,
0.5928006768,
0.2213541567,
-0.0209010579,
-0.2705909312,
0.0489159822,
0.1522849202,
0.1123809218,
-0.4411137104,
-0.2972536683,
-0.0620560721,
-0.8098590374,
-0.177886188,
-0.1804713905,
-0.5357467532,
-0.5958040357,
-0.1719460934,
0.7818534374,
-0.463193357,
-0.2861639559,
0.1899769753,
-0.8778222799,
0.0289516691,
0.2292817235,
-0.8744009137,
0.3702281713,
0.6921615005,
0.4870987535,
0.004959594,
-0.4055654109,
0.0988246575,
0.5319953561,
-0.0904517248,
0.5589314699,
-0.589124918,
-0.8669427633,
-0.3107499182,
-0.3375225067,
-0.3534362018,
-0.6231921911,
0.109044373,
-0.2893490493,
0.6196314096,
-0.5722853541,
-0.724968195,
-0.5205281377,
0.1190187111,
-0.7200649977,
0.6722413301,
0.1083028167,
-0.7624399662,
0.2428987771,
-0.2503831387,
-0.3633683622,
-0.2677082121,
-0.0982907265,
-0.5786524415,
0.2894671559,
0.0987541452,
0.2799078226,
-0.5476740003,
0.1550101042,
-0.5207878947,
-0.4753677547,
0.1505013853,
-0.2544618845,
0.6917558908,
0.136186108,
-0.2697335184,
0.0753705874,
-0.6434566379,
-0.3202398121,
0.1595259905,
0.0457868837,
-0.926554203,
0.0604636073,
-0.3981026709,
0.1797767878,
0.0562959425,
-0.2815491557,
0.087328054,
-0.5290229917,
0.2059871405,
0.6856027246,
0.3630563915,
0.8660458922,
-0.7757936716,
0.1120788306,
0.2666985095,
0.1310129166,
-0.2638822794,
-0.4158715904,
-0.9915574193,
0.0377901755,
0.2313022912,
0.3315286934,
-0.587813437,
0.2234345973,
-0.0342829153,
-0.6435379982,
-0.7924852371,
0.4149257839,
0.7903932929,
0.5144487023,
0.2007274926,
-0.3081865907,
-0.4589345157,
-1.3356513977,
-0.7193146944,
-0.0558191836,
0.0789990723,
0.3372254372,
0.3547569811,
-0.2737136781,
0.7889905572,
-0.6010459661,
-0.4050376415,
-0.3122704923,
-0.0226748604,
-0.3308113217,
0.6472882628,
0.6421726346,
-0.8587911725,
-0.2216697186,
-0.3293966353,
-0.4764883518,
0.2900417745,
-0.1740312278,
-0.159828499,
0.00236755,
0.3178606033,
-0.5550351143,
0.2542048693,
0.3817946613,
-0.1569781154,
-0.0077894297,
-0.0916072801,
0.097599037,
-1.1937619448,
0.089514792,
-0.3383167088,
0.0322882645,
-0.7999622226,
-0.2186753303,
0.1254443079,
-0.092409119,
-0.5767843127,
0.7971387506,
-0.5653734207,
0.0705434084,
-0.227003932,
0.0507513024,
0.0903863385,
0.2326482236,
0.0258278083,
0.4552768767,
0.5088080168,
-0.8035196066,
-0.3870017529,
0.2572923303,
-0.3168777525,
0.0808351189,
-0.2954043448,
0.3424251974,
-0.4737195075,
-0.1866586953,
-0.9182939529,
-0.2616887093,
-0.0222448967,
-0.2589234412,
0.3852788508,
0.1281393617,
-0.3252179027,
-0.3659808338,
-0.2935552299,
0.3780116737,
0.8723865747,
-0.4673255384,
0.6398595572,
0.8244426847,
0.2073871344,
-0.451074481,
-0.4184196591,
-0.5564145446,
-0.2569297254,
-0.4977311492,
0.4796697497,
0.1263275743,
-0.5540214777,
0.0584370568,
-0.0726215392,
-0.1837281138,
0.2578464746,
0.5455374718,
0.1952255964,
0.2911581397,
0.3650468886,
0.4643018246,
0.0889503583,
-0.0901149362,
-0.0808067098,
0.6919425726,
0.1161312684,
-0.5091482401,
-0.1678020805,
0.3613627851,
0.5479331613,
-0.1185998395,
0.8620280623,
0.2907291055,
-0.4768427908,
-0.2284475863,
-0.9303483963,
-0.4035521746,
-0.5100250244,
0.2829211056,
-0.0061908313,
-0.8900724649,
0.69907552,
-0.1478616297,
0.0629549846,
0.5168855786,
0.4453633428,
0.0169974975,
1.1505497694,
0.799317956,
-0.500839889,
0.6014640927,
-0.0708976164,
0.1153116524,
-0.6688994169,
-0.340619266,
-0.4039467275,
-0.4806046188,
-0.2626276612,
-0.2838038206,
0.1227140278,
0.112131469,
-0.118000105,
0.1897754073,
-0.4593687952,
0.7107363939,
0.8689365983,
0.3947938979,
0.266464293,
-0.3118364811,
0.1269708127,
-0.014619045,
-0.8670324087,
-0.1558415145,
1.041457653,
0.1800086945,
0.8742492795,
-0.2113578469,
1.0805661678,
0.0624329448,
-0.1190697253,
-0.3930471241,
0.6007872224,
0.0029222213,
-0.9354681373,
-0.148212567,
-0.3664494753,
-0.6453258991,
0.2133566737,
-0.2077546865,
-0.8060078025,
0.1706860363,
0.6493210793,
-0.5915879607,
0.2955246866,
-0.9939442873,
0.7539977431,
-0.0696167648,
-0.2875031531,
-0.6332150698,
-0.4648580253,
0.8968164921,
-0.1847164482,
0.279702127,
-0.1930712461,
0.5451444387,
1.001459837,
0.0590305328,
0.9255519509,
0.0313242041,
0.3079053462,
0.2572948337,
0.1462047547,
0.349598974,
-0.2679620087,
0.0947587714,
0.1002781987,
-0.2103913426,
-0.1139098108,
-0.465292722,
0.8285878301,
-0.694650948,
-0.9997307658,
-0.0146677885,
-0.8685456514,
-0.1820060611,
0.4059642851,
0.2849613726,
-0.1578667462,
-0.5174645185,
0.0647330582,
1.0767946243,
-0.3289601207,
0.4864436388,
0.4837168455,
-0.2457770109,
-0.094226107,
0.9378887415,
0.2798845768,
0.6254960299,
0.3787405789,
0.1807880253,
0.1483541429,
-0.3675798178,
0.0696640387,
0.3584879637,
-0.70641011,
-0.0617124885,
-0.9033455849,
-0.2720221877,
-0.5650998354,
-0.1983038485,
-0.5616093874,
-0.8555982113,
-0.4553925395,
-0.0547557399,
0.2345174253,
0.5681307912,
0.0474068522,
0.4874359071,
-0.873752296,
0.4484273195,
0.3750331402,
0.1077835932,
0.119159162,
-0.2367461622,
-0.0117396414,
0.0754585639,
-0.5441886783,
-0.8795024157,
0.1968721598,
0.1334180385,
0.7869377732,
0.5517626405,
0.1103307605,
0.6023389697,
-0.214921236,
0.6726853251,
0.244851321,
-1.0691232681,
0.7276470661,
-0.355030328,
0.6407379508,
0.5286723375,
0.2208213359,
-0.4582571983,
-0.5483991504,
-0.9661412239,
-0.6510663033,
0.7011993527,
0.0397626869,
0.0242605824,
0.3377768099,
0.132669434,
0.1459190398,
0.3261923194,
-0.4995484054,
-0.4504551888,
0.0201856196,
0.0198788792,
0.0099443113,
-0.5300053954,
-0.2807371914,
-0.473505795,
0.7466170192,
0.4337901771,
0.1030458584,
-0.3392253518,
-0.3101122975,
-0.0346103683,
0.3610817492,
0.5722603798,
0.4455598593,
-0.1150638312,
0.0279642548,
0.439311862,
-0.2664027214,
-0.0946566686,
-0.050316453,
-0.7877442837,
-0.009376606,
-0.0273158923,
0.9213914871,
0.6023818851,
-0.4540545642,
0.196402356,
0.1668961942,
-0.2775436342,
0.0938501656,
0.5609608293,
0.3617249131,
0.1165143996,
0.0042136475,
0.4115757048,
0.2540042996,
-0.637650013,
0.1829359978,
0.7296045423,
-0.4892227352,
-0.2491123229,
0.6524602771,
0.1104327887,
-0.1572325081,
0.5372328758,
0.3762218654,
-0.7264305949,
0.3741870224,
0.5297818184,
0.9017263055,
-0.5864100456,
0.0650202036,
0.1670391113,
0.2949969172,
-0.3989775777,
0.0176390819,
-0.1547086835,
-0.6794609427,
0.1914787889,
-0.3809575438,
-0.3255316615,
0.0146974549,
-0.6620317101,
0.2314359397,
-0.4520127475,
-0.1724098772,
0.0600084551,
-0.3648383319,
-0.7694730759,
-0.0700485781,
0.0009263162,
0.6929441094,
-1.010466218,
1.0266379118,
0.220323354,
-0.3502597809,
-0.7714287639,
-0.1903401762,
0.3543847501,
-0.8325656056,
0.4993819296,
0.03927451,
-0.0490114838,
-0.0088423556,
-0.2497840971,
-1.0742994547,
0.9403842092,
0.4022111297,
-0.5275615454,
-0.2587628663,
0.0896954238,
0.2538071275,
-0.0712232217,
-0.0314269923,
0.8799453974,
0.4164710641,
0.1298392415,
-1.176170826,
-0.0908771232,
0.0772556365,
-0.0997541621,
0.3574207723,
-0.7167397141,
1.0562275648,
-0.3044475317,
-0.324428916,
-0.2684031129,
0.2658667266,
-0.067150034,
0.3390820622,
0.1386881471,
0.5290655494,
0.8599078059,
-0.0088865114,
0.9159872532,
-0.0733090788,
0.2495200783,
1.2037103176,
-0.4022904038,
0.4227475822,
0.5962364078,
0.3334390819,
0.1091788262,
0.1802063882,
0.0835504457,
0.8187992573,
-0.1833127439,
-0.1956939846,
-0.3039756715,
-0.0799780488,
-0.6070997715,
0.4323835373,
0.3141058087,
-0.7858338952,
-0.3650683463,
0.1732772589,
0.1443341225,
0.1738203466,
-0.4720211029,
1.159974575,
0.1993467659,
-0.8196172118,
0.3811876476,
-0.2681084275,
0.4499545395,
-0.6243650317,
0.1320216954,
-0.0174689591,
0.8256544471,
-0.0238282122,
-0.4041542411,
0.405652523,
-0.5690966845,
-0.652792573,
-0.3395367861,
1.1441082954,
-0.6671863794,
-0.3929617405,
0.3755531609,
0.5015749335,
-0.1465145499,
-0.1091771349,
-0.5406642556,
0.0755696297,
0.3246490359,
-0.0873523504,
0.6139546037,
-0.2544994354,
-0.0325230993,
0.8440756798,
0.4544177353,
-0.0685555041,
-0.0524434261,
-0.0734346807,
1.1059077978,
-0.6830534339,
-0.4073110819,
-1.2022308111,
0.3449745476,
-0.3458073437,
-0.1307132542,
1.3878204823,
0.5799762607,
1.0127975941,
-0.3313515186,
0.9944773912,
0.3147673011,
0.934684217,
-0.426805526,
1.3701739311,
-0.4302923977,
0.233821556,
-0.5626832247,
-0.8497061729,
-0.3293455541,
0.2414571643,
-0.5292698741,
-0.0997431576,
0.4843534231,
0.8001317382,
-0.0122898202,
-0.0056779119,
0.4395140707,
-0.1084775776,
0.2683248818,
0.6968132257,
0.7087683678,
-0.5385434628,
0.3012730181,
-0.4407687485,
0.0404715128,
-0.1394588947,
-0.5431066751,
-1.3379355669,
-0.6740463972,
-0.2342586219,
-0.2272054553,
0.1987989396,
0.5863670111,
0.5339756012,
-0.5963068604,
-0.1701373011,
0.2389288694,
0.7935093641,
-0.1501493454,
-0.1212095767,
0.3259800375,
-0.0652416795,
-0.5493286252,
0.2477372736,
0.2867937982,
0.4681108892,
-0.1903731674,
-0.0482873432,
-0.1862297356,
0.2371808439,
0.2947384417,
0.544719696,
-0.6143671274,
-0.1456482559,
-0.1375073791,
0.0409807228,
-0.3517599106,
1.0121409893,
-0.9541751146,
0.626744628,
0.6709741354,
0.3689092398,
0.4789858162,
0.0773149505,
0.9857867956,
-0.5914903283,
0.5160086751,
0.1478837878,
0.4467809796,
0.2296631485,
-0.3318754435,
0.0380793028,
0.0202917513,
-0.4328996241,
-0.9509757757,
0.3313349783,
-0.6474143267,
-0.5988897085,
1.1308336258,
0.1846334785,
-0.3396613598,
-0.0835471004,
-0.1806613952,
0.1807314008,
-0.1369421631,
1.1548343897,
0.6633789539,
0.132912308,
-0.1375385225,
0.0801672637,
0.9940164089,
0.5508445501,
-0.5896567702,
0.2216526866,
0.6463161111,
0.2641007602,
0.2158328295,
0.5685993433,
-0.0085284114,
0.3300921619,
0.0931275636,
-0.1120425165,
-0.2286488265,
-0.341907233,
-0.2161427438,
0.1402500719,
0.0041327733,
-0.1701804996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07575v1
|
SPHINX: The Joint Mixing of Weights, Tasks, and Visual Embeddings for Multi-modal Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T18:59:47 | 2023-11-13T18:59:47 |
Ziyi Lin, Chris Liu, Renrui Zhang, Peng Gao, Longtian Qiu, Han Xiao, Han Qiu, Chen Lin, Wenqi Shao, Keqin Chen, Jiaming Han, Siyuan Huang, Yichi Zhang, Xuming He, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present SPHINX, a versatile multi-modal large language model (MLLM) with a
joint mixing of model weights, tuning tasks, and visual embeddings. First, for
stronger vision-language alignment, we unfreeze the large language model (LLM)
during pre-training, and introduce a weight mix strategy between LLMs trained
by real-world and synthetic data. By directly integrating the weights from two
domains, the mixed LLM can efficiently incorporate diverse semantics with
favorable robustness. Then, to enable multi-purpose capabilities, we mix a
variety of tasks for joint visual instruction tuning, and design task-specific
instructions to avoid inter-task conflict. In addition to the basic visual
question answering, we include more challenging tasks such as region-level
understanding, caption grounding, document layout detection, and human pose
estimation, contributing to mutual enhancement over different scenarios.
Additionally, we propose to extract comprehensive visual embeddings from
various network architectures, pre-training paradigms, and information
granularity, providing language models with more robust image representations.
Based on our proposed joint mixing, SPHINX exhibits superior multi-modal
understanding capabilities on a wide range of applications. On top of this, we
further propose an efficient strategy aiming to better capture fine-grained
appearances of high-resolution images. With a mixing of different scales and
high-resolution sub-images, SPHINX attains exceptional visual parsing and
reasoning performance on existing evaluation benchmarks. We hope our work may
cast a light on the exploration of joint mixing in future MLLM research. Code
is released at https://github.com/Alpha-VLLM/LLaMA2-Accessory.
|
[
-0.5906421542,
-0.5458641052,
0.2830516994,
0.2777360678,
-0.5477061272,
0.0341535397,
-0.4449340701,
-0.5054433346,
0.4630129337,
0.5583846569,
-0.3368232548,
-0.3641098738,
-0.7115036249,
-0.0373830162,
-0.5184246302,
0.7801241279,
-0.0686008036,
0.3881951272,
-0.2330334187,
-0.3531402946,
-0.2996010184,
-0.2383617461,
-0.1928355396,
-0.1713653505,
0.7590716481,
0.2213761657,
1.0280079842,
0.6134558916,
0.4737724364,
0.3838768899,
0.1031322703,
0.4439592063,
-0.2218254507,
0.4193940163,
-0.0511961877,
-0.2635726035,
-0.3599714935,
-0.1484147608,
0.7618467808,
0.5372906923,
-0.2055709809,
0.0514780357,
-0.0065288404,
0.3035129905,
-0.9808136821,
0.0866759568,
-0.6169968247,
-0.2594355047,
-0.4017085433,
-0.0052926857,
0.0397288091,
0.2932798564,
0.0997879729,
-0.7301538587,
-0.2467138767,
0.1794660389,
0.6847983003,
0.5026085377,
-0.4519109726,
-0.1700656414,
-0.2640223503,
0.8320903778,
-0.5124000907,
0.580495894,
0.1317741871,
0.3951587677,
0.0558350831,
-0.9278582335,
-0.8843159676,
-0.0798366293,
0.0507357009,
0.1706344634,
0.0729414895,
0.035727296,
0.1270405799,
0.4178056121,
-0.4926045239,
-0.0564579517,
-0.1619852334,
-0.1241018325,
0.289127171,
0.1624416858,
0.8358078599,
-0.1324413568,
-0.3475826681,
-0.3605814874,
-0.5405827165,
-0.0682349131,
0.3286043704,
0.2306515276,
-0.2812393606,
1.0542074442,
-0.0803897157,
0.9215852618,
-0.0672222003,
-0.1713520885,
-0.0498211682,
-0.4928575754,
-0.2820645571,
0.0013359585,
0.6422072649,
0.4528994858,
0.0495044962,
-0.0972237661,
-0.4371456802,
0.1060371399,
0.2114813775,
-0.7529814243,
-0.317802757,
0.0747465491,
-0.4760934412,
-0.0872036666,
-0.1295045167,
-0.5619063973,
-0.6425164342,
-0.5309603214,
0.6369987726,
-0.4426679313,
-0.3995884359,
0.2670324743,
-0.343659699,
0.2785510719,
0.6049474478,
-1.0646224022,
0.3683164716,
0.7625851035,
0.6332065463,
-0.0425025225,
-0.6160871387,
-0.7914469838,
0.4626652896,
-0.0686490983,
0.4608695507,
-0.6589820981,
-0.0108375996,
0.1865736246,
-0.086307317,
-0.0040937942,
-0.3996373415,
0.2499827445,
-0.5366547704,
0.2248677015,
-0.0866136327,
-0.2878478169,
-0.1412349045,
0.2850647867,
-0.8715142608,
1.0420091152,
0.2035720795,
-1.0179331303,
0.4393036664,
-0.3043198586,
-0.4854799807,
-0.0031643731,
-0.2558148801,
-0.1437560618,
0.1204575226,
0.3157832026,
0.2319360077,
-0.4084841311,
0.1115406975,
-0.476732254,
-0.3876377344,
0.3520191908,
-0.0902274176,
0.6672804356,
0.0793061778,
-0.2022142112,
0.4622941315,
-0.4992972016,
-0.0165831652,
0.0064845541,
-0.3728375435,
-0.6099683046,
-0.0196683705,
0.6848357916,
0.2750947177,
0.6135082245,
-0.2181342244,
0.1917692423,
-0.1038354188,
0.3074989021,
0.3908294141,
-0.5418444276,
0.5265629292,
-0.3645488322,
0.2492013425,
0.0718227252,
0.1323682666,
-0.2120912969,
-0.4742771983,
-1.1585696936,
-0.5134679079,
0.4516306818,
0.5096514821,
-1.0639666319,
0.3995405138,
-0.2419455051,
-0.3148793578,
-0.6995140314,
0.325609535,
0.2755764425,
0.046480611,
0.4816400409,
-0.4210188687,
-0.4624637067,
-0.9365476966,
-0.2092760801,
0.1531757414,
-0.110802047,
0.1255792528,
0.5073462129,
-0.1640231013,
0.4658380449,
-0.128247723,
-0.2475588769,
-0.4988084137,
0.1400865763,
0.0265969485,
0.4915769696,
0.5120817423,
-0.9662191868,
-0.3998498917,
0.0812423825,
-0.6551275849,
0.20577389,
-0.075042367,
-0.0413801074,
0.0224331524,
0.123937428,
-0.8241119981,
0.1456207335,
0.7231107354,
-0.1853547394,
0.3282752931,
-0.441831857,
0.2097111493,
-1.3075590134,
-0.1015337333,
0.127438575,
-0.2573913038,
-0.4949271977,
0.4182244241,
0.4219408929,
-0.039852079,
-0.4133840203,
0.4919910729,
-0.644657433,
-0.23993285,
-0.2075531036,
0.1917124987,
-0.0410893969,
0.4467589557,
0.0763828605,
0.7932132483,
1.0628471375,
-0.3154192865,
0.5646369457,
0.1296373457,
-0.5099160671,
0.6557831764,
-0.6764519215,
-0.2377718985,
0.0102571743,
0.1824024767,
-0.822794497,
-0.4653120339,
0.3754658997,
-0.1910391897,
0.5241621137,
-0.1155293211,
-0.7861330509,
0.0048416303,
-0.5172787905,
0.4477363527,
0.2914865017,
-0.512268424,
0.9454870224,
0.4562653005,
-0.1073802039,
-0.7860574126,
-0.7074332833,
0.5125827193,
-0.1744368076,
-0.8201850057,
0.5892087221,
0.106956616,
-0.3833236396,
0.1976968646,
-0.1137980521,
-0.2225864977,
-0.1236769482,
0.2139808834,
0.403880775,
-0.2455452979,
0.0893339589,
0.0974737406,
0.0063748579,
-0.3010167778,
-0.4175826609,
0.5878323317,
0.0085313097,
-0.5207768083,
-0.4950240552,
0.4779385924,
0.8631916642,
-0.495102495,
0.7157967091,
0.9610699415,
-0.3695349693,
0.0270223413,
-0.5523329377,
0.1096254736,
-0.4404783547,
0.3883609772,
-0.3883849978,
-0.8317480683,
0.4066355824,
-0.005295028,
0.1181930155,
0.3205955923,
0.6772490144,
-0.2329291701,
0.9643412232,
0.675627768,
-0.0712467209,
0.7232829332,
-0.0981090963,
-0.0009355597,
-0.997251749,
-0.153022781,
-0.4678536952,
-0.5039206743,
-0.4968130589,
-0.7327978015,
0.3298863173,
0.3624421954,
-0.0920506641,
0.243911624,
-0.2396287322,
0.3515478671,
0.7084325552,
0.1360893548,
0.2942422926,
0.026450837,
-0.1760207564,
-0.0527164675,
-0.390637666,
-0.2252583653,
1.0866895914,
-0.0543805249,
1.2714508772,
0.2889914811,
0.6535367966,
0.0475304797,
0.0377482735,
-0.8598280549,
0.3532497585,
-0.3105855882,
-0.363948524,
-0.3568634987,
-0.2224985659,
-0.6974771023,
0.7230727673,
-0.5323810577,
-0.5707777143,
-0.1969754547,
-0.0992292017,
0.0877741203,
0.2509837747,
-0.4381917715,
0.9227631688,
-0.5042997003,
-0.3629570305,
-0.6376892924,
-0.6699320674,
0.5338797569,
0.0914373621,
0.0387446396,
0.1851783544,
-0.4981315732,
0.3862532377,
-0.3288653791,
0.7503937483,
0.1206409782,
-0.2535939515,
-0.041179955,
0.0201809518,
0.4951925278,
0.2135960907,
0.1586541384,
0.0450097695,
0.1672932059,
-0.3397402465,
-0.7861180305,
0.8272804618,
-0.8635988235,
-0.6691578031,
-0.4066886008,
-0.8066498041,
-0.0052579711,
0.2233324051,
-0.1578377336,
0.7242581844,
0.2078441381,
0.3790233731,
0.6008944511,
-0.1973006427,
0.2841358483,
0.2849189937,
-0.3350070119,
-0.7679290175,
0.9065979719,
-0.1784820557,
0.272293359,
0.5148787498,
-0.1483903378,
-0.3658923507,
-0.5627304316,
-0.8683314919,
0.2618973255,
-0.786732614,
0.0422389433,
-0.5814351439,
0.0083169462,
-0.2864688635,
-0.060531646,
-0.230121091,
-0.5224793553,
-0.2671352625,
0.699413538,
0.1580396295,
0.6802786589,
0.1807186604,
0.2535181046,
-0.7875957489,
0.6766171455,
0.4838605821,
0.3329507709,
-0.1217478812,
-0.2025642246,
-0.1787271798,
0.1502382904,
-0.1704302281,
-0.7541929483,
0.1346818507,
0.1257509142,
0.7317906022,
0.264367193,
-0.1392830312,
0.8563795686,
-0.3109726906,
0.7383401394,
0.6805029511,
-0.9607752562,
0.2599520385,
-0.2839311659,
0.3123593926,
0.3134981692,
0.2112321556,
-0.7714003921,
-0.5127276182,
-0.0729278997,
-0.6035588384,
0.6393075585,
0.0496721528,
0.1260987222,
0.2522523105,
-0.0613009334,
-0.0224537235,
0.1135469899,
-0.705181241,
-0.2877529562,
-0.3563635647,
-0.4306721389,
0.0273288786,
-0.0245449711,
-0.4738031328,
-0.4817509949,
0.3170615137,
-0.2903725803,
-0.1610077471,
-0.1247071475,
-0.5775372386,
-0.1369547695,
0.1059564054,
0.7240308523,
0.7187114954,
0.118494831,
0.4158587158,
0.0896820277,
-0.469139874,
-0.2791900933,
0.2873851359,
0.0541922078,
-0.0164865721,
0.3871743977,
0.6356397271,
0.5268102884,
-0.8213075399,
0.602018714,
-0.3478935063,
-0.0810968503,
-0.0639625937,
0.1844449192,
0.3666378558,
0.6167456508,
0.3330647051,
0.1440582722,
0.0387756974,
-0.5134193301,
0.0264280289,
0.7402558923,
-0.197693035,
-0.2433043867,
0.5776629448,
0.1983539611,
-0.038959749,
0.3478684723,
0.1130546033,
-0.4903291464,
0.3610147834,
0.4719636738,
0.5956313014,
0.0985632092,
0.0459067784,
-0.0463949479,
0.31775859,
-0.1050381139,
0.33599931,
-0.3780429363,
-0.4835258424,
-0.5349677801,
-0.7695404887,
-0.4164375067,
-0.1329056621,
-0.3815318048,
0.5006118417,
-0.2909445763,
0.0830030516,
-0.043456953,
-0.0849866122,
-0.6131881475,
-0.0615536682,
0.1327566653,
0.8081991673,
-0.4173730016,
1.188773632,
0.9028635621,
-0.5526269674,
-0.4884488881,
0.0318882801,
0.0214367602,
-0.8427519202,
0.8460470438,
0.1303998828,
-0.2536745965,
-0.1571569443,
-0.3761779368,
-0.9372954369,
1.031965971,
0.3343385458,
-0.3484597206,
0.0691353083,
-0.0222929362,
0.2824708819,
-0.3463166654,
0.1482858658,
0.1432500482,
0.7069310546,
0.360976994,
-1.0839681625,
0.0803006515,
-0.1795953214,
-0.0727132782,
0.3877804279,
-0.3931248784,
1.1124825478,
-0.1335807592,
-0.2782433629,
0.4505733252,
0.569419384,
0.0437298454,
0.074150987,
0.599989295,
0.9072338343,
0.5582691431,
-0.0956521854,
0.9207355976,
-0.526150167,
0.1432126611,
1.0107781887,
-0.3507367969,
0.8574017286,
0.7538496852,
-0.0802226812,
0.3275167048,
0.6344736814,
0.1553125679,
0.6807070971,
0.150534898,
-0.4116766155,
-0.6086931229,
-0.23102355,
-0.6121783257,
0.5507172346,
0.4320006371,
-0.2209809124,
-0.433822453,
-0.1207767203,
-0.5008997917,
-0.2423706949,
-0.1088446826,
0.6454464197,
-0.0880035684,
-0.6091716886,
0.6719353795,
0.0086967349,
0.9745159149,
-0.6525642872,
-0.1231856346,
0.0124384947,
0.0383108258,
-0.0682824403,
-0.9346014857,
-0.0829629302,
-0.3121134639,
0.0105873765,
-0.2058534026,
0.6954472065,
-0.7840679884,
-0.3392943442,
0.2276243418,
0.5621128678,
-0.0134088956,
-0.0335042402,
-0.6608609557,
0.4387003779,
-0.3641774058,
0.0161213223,
0.5931534171,
0.5503034592,
0.0777501166,
0.6451668143,
0.6651316881,
0.165097028,
0.0779940933,
0.2873812616,
1.183822751,
-0.5695990324,
-0.2575159371,
-0.6435144544,
0.5323203802,
-0.1786246449,
-0.382943362,
0.5567468405,
0.4934152961,
0.6941173673,
-0.0517907217,
0.540818572,
-0.0679180846,
-0.2066372633,
-0.6547595859,
0.6948900223,
-1.0986112356,
-0.1141699478,
-0.0670150891,
-1.1337225437,
-0.4430426955,
0.4335318804,
0.1932333112,
-0.1014196873,
0.6260336041,
0.7322778106,
-0.2353141755,
-0.0344484411,
0.2865179479,
-0.2562491,
0.1032390669,
0.4776462913,
1.0682772398,
-0.1871125698,
0.6796137691,
-0.0898659453,
-0.0984249413,
-0.3726654053,
-0.5586022735,
-0.9901387095,
-0.7197660804,
0.005771867,
-0.0494660251,
-0.1530262977,
0.751742661,
0.6782459021,
-0.4798097312,
-0.2516862154,
0.2551364303,
0.1864414513,
-0.2271061093,
-0.1114787534,
0.0938358381,
-0.4320293665,
-0.9200823903,
0.2708213329,
0.6718254089,
0.071500957,
-0.6759815216,
-0.3092142045,
-0.308662802,
-0.3040100634,
0.5945917368,
-0.0528144948,
-1.162720561,
-0.2374018133,
-0.0961543694,
-0.4117988348,
-0.2333207875,
1.010447979,
-0.5190186501,
0.6192811131,
0.6004374027,
0.9271601439,
0.5759371519,
-0.3164942563,
0.4716555178,
-0.479485929,
0.2906936109,
-0.098417908,
0.7934001088,
0.3926949203,
-0.0015043339,
0.2005628496,
0.0191762093,
-0.153979376,
-0.5489472747,
0.1067282185,
-1.3692038059,
-0.4236316979,
0.7390053272,
0.0893316194,
-0.1887661666,
0.0049854978,
-0.3194259107,
0.4461537004,
-0.2709461451,
0.7374657989,
0.8832309842,
0.1363004744,
-0.4651066065,
-0.4746291637,
0.2604129612,
0.3767100275,
-0.8348032236,
-0.0535232425,
0.6535775065,
0.1645171791,
0.2244319618,
0.0812238529,
0.0718249753,
0.5418452621,
-0.0139592802,
0.0285035875,
-0.1415428221,
-0.4014739096,
-0.1478371918,
0.0330994129,
0.0253179185,
-0.1725713611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07564v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07564v3
|
Can Authorship Attribution Models Distinguish Speakers in Speech Transcripts?
| 2023-11-13T18:54:17 | 2024-06-13T19:54:53 |
Cristina Aggazzotti, Nicholas Andrews, Elizabeth Allyn Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Authorship verification is the task of determining if two distinct writing
samples share the same author and is typically concerned with the attribution
of written text. In this paper, we explore the attribution of transcribed
speech, which poses novel challenges. The main challenge is that many stylistic
features, such as punctuation and capitalization, are not informative in this
setting. On the other hand, transcribed speech exhibits other patterns, such as
filler words and backchannels (e.g., 'um', 'uh-huh'), which may be
characteristic of different speakers. We propose a new benchmark for speaker
attribution focused on human-transcribed conversational speech transcripts. To
limit spurious associations of speakers with topic, we employ both conversation
prompts and speakers participating in the same conversation to construct
verification trials of varying difficulties. We establish the state of the art
on this new benchmark by comparing a suite of neural and non-neural baselines,
finding that although written text attribution models achieve surprisingly good
performance in certain settings, they perform markedly worse as conversational
topic is increasingly controlled. We present analyses of the impact of
transcription style on performance as well as the ability of fine-tuning on
speech transcripts to improve performance.
|
[
0.1647512466,
-0.7029718757,
0.7683942914,
0.0542739145,
0.0094933417,
0.1482218504,
-0.4436913133,
-0.3388531506,
0.3446403146,
0.7212251425,
-0.3641652763,
-0.2192821205,
-0.7949166298,
0.3170644343,
-0.5853141546,
0.6966624856,
0.3346823752,
-0.1642981321,
-0.6620397568,
0.0793035254,
-0.6146776676,
-0.5867126584,
-0.5845820904,
-0.3491504192,
0.744233489,
0.3244097531,
0.2928551733,
0.6317756772,
0.3598240614,
0.3793342412,
-0.2808946073,
0.0664429739,
-0.2774116099,
0.2610527277,
-0.0863472372,
-0.4123219252,
-0.4324706495,
0.3536201715,
0.7724291682,
0.595403254,
-0.0655895546,
0.3275031745,
0.015381271,
0.1402096003,
-0.7379385233,
0.0292795654,
-0.8401089311,
-0.3594994545,
-0.4502055347,
-0.5459068418,
-0.8568136096,
-0.7768681645,
0.0442304276,
-0.2875731289,
0.2783143222,
-0.0063412241,
0.5213363171,
0.2669207156,
-0.5125384927,
-0.3430511057,
-0.48003456,
0.8375625014,
-0.6672211289,
0.2100789398,
0.475384295,
0.1738402843,
0.1332176477,
-0.5656619668,
-0.4385617673,
-0.3343900442,
-0.345353514,
-0.2219640315,
-0.1722027361,
-0.3001580834,
0.2460808307,
0.3719962239,
-0.2443037778,
0.0996012092,
-0.3272432685,
-0.4169280529,
0.61935848,
-0.1750286222,
0.39290604,
-0.3447028995,
-0.2426022291,
-0.3228867054,
-0.5957499743,
0.3644856513,
0.7034400105,
0.6868901849,
0.0190353245,
0.4721155167,
0.1224281043,
0.4312014282,
-0.112226665,
0.0155840134,
0.2560091317,
-0.1458122581,
0.2643466592,
0.4404211044,
0.8310241699,
0.1677168459,
0.4864392281,
-0.2776167393,
0.0295658,
-0.1751843244,
0.3428330123,
-0.3643175364,
-0.3898432851,
-0.0907088369,
-0.4120533168,
-0.2600824535,
0.2176659107,
-0.5405163765,
-0.7752806544,
-0.3219258189,
0.4544663131,
-0.2636735737,
-0.2127373815,
-0.294131577,
-0.3014329374,
0.1696453243,
0.1273512989,
-0.9973788857,
0.5097599626,
0.818857789,
0.7527583241,
-0.3386429846,
-0.4386195242,
-0.8311778307,
0.0392978191,
-0.3106325567,
0.6103436351,
-0.3355378807,
-0.1959375143,
0.0345946997,
-0.2772978842,
-0.2845401764,
-0.4213184416,
0.5249685049,
-0.2504285574,
0.3596682549,
-0.6750952601,
-0.7396840453,
0.2293097675,
-0.1616878361,
-0.4959997237,
0.7282528877,
-0.0923430324,
-0.5377781987,
0.3719395399,
-0.3029931188,
-0.5284879804,
0.1211744547,
-0.602032125,
-0.3762932122,
0.0035636902,
-0.0653296858,
0.4848455489,
-0.2719308734,
0.3220174313,
0.1185059175,
-0.3249757886,
0.804648757,
-0.2094637603,
1.0227577686,
-0.0834742859,
-0.2393717468,
0.0820504203,
-1.0460404158,
0.0285788123,
0.0113296648,
-0.1994938105,
-0.0927405059,
0.2686009705,
0.2281554788,
-0.321633786,
0.1834442019,
-0.8525123596,
-0.0822486132,
-0.0646747351,
0.4841865301,
0.8437528014,
0.1082461253,
0.0295312889,
-0.5180109143,
0.3880341053,
-0.612090528,
-0.2567186356,
-0.2436111718,
-0.7069042921,
-0.2683095038,
-0.5768018961,
0.3491330743,
0.7062734962,
-0.173734352,
0.6436774731,
-0.278984189,
-0.6172573566,
-0.4293670356,
0.0012392848,
0.8757937551,
0.6059414148,
0.3971904516,
-0.4701041877,
-0.3155886531,
-0.9009984136,
-0.7864819765,
-0.444042474,
-0.3281004727,
0.4367114305,
0.2551583648,
0.5413504243,
0.9921411872,
-0.5522460341,
-0.3381918669,
-0.0114644887,
0.5312290788,
0.2000847012,
0.761095047,
0.4572264552,
-0.5493839979,
-0.5367247462,
-0.1560419947,
-0.4507961273,
-0.4361738563,
-0.0881112367,
0.3149330318,
-0.2476550043,
1.0200848579,
-0.3196913898,
0.2938009799,
0.3641943336,
-0.5853358507,
0.6463145018,
-0.0899624377,
0.4118790925,
-0.6504558921,
0.2344839871,
-0.2884622514,
-0.1627198756,
-0.7199897766,
-0.2711538076,
0.0539894737,
-0.1025261804,
-0.3272433281,
0.2766620219,
-0.2820960581,
-0.0987513214,
0.0632668436,
0.078616336,
-0.0801333413,
0.5724346042,
-0.1868621707,
0.7903754711,
0.3798672259,
-0.2897140086,
0.6063771844,
0.5993954539,
-0.7391072512,
0.5889057517,
-0.8291551471,
0.5208093524,
0.1176137552,
0.2264343351,
-1.45149827,
-0.1668989062,
-0.1537372321,
-0.8169016242,
0.3855763674,
-0.1444083899,
-0.588542223,
0.2687705159,
0.0777046382,
0.6002938747,
0.5327163339,
-0.1629490554,
0.6477564573,
-0.0747132897,
-0.7816081643,
-0.2672470212,
-0.7144113183,
0.3371102214,
-0.2392225415,
-0.5103037357,
0.6478289366,
0.1767101437,
-0.523760438,
-0.4481862187,
0.222069636,
-0.1004400849,
0.0883098766,
0.2077980489,
0.0109550282,
-0.0862304941,
0.011503811,
-0.1495256275,
-0.0872656256,
0.2366121411,
0.2414372265,
0.2003968656,
0.3609600663,
-0.4423309267,
-0.8855753541,
0.610268712,
0.3689345717,
-0.262676388,
0.5947608948,
0.3424787521,
-0.1378298104,
0.1337009817,
-0.9401356578,
-0.4678684473,
-0.4000989497,
0.0715251043,
-0.2632460892,
-0.6156643033,
0.8928793669,
0.3752973676,
-0.1703619212,
0.3156239986,
0.3844926059,
0.077869758,
0.4663594365,
0.5405531526,
-0.189874351,
0.623895824,
0.2492683977,
0.0489894785,
-0.5345616937,
-0.2279268056,
-1.1099467278,
-0.2452864498,
-0.7176503539,
-0.0600123927,
0.1335280836,
-0.6103522182,
0.1086072177,
0.5347700715,
-0.4967888296,
0.6102381945,
0.9186214805,
0.1562300771,
0.2878313363,
-0.2663587928,
0.13394472,
-0.1658077687,
-0.0820260197,
-0.6457787156,
1.0002200603,
0.1348651499,
0.2243909836,
0.3567076027,
0.6427691579,
0.8007155657,
-0.3786149621,
-0.3595021367,
0.5462804437,
-0.2443762273,
-0.7675802708,
-0.4530837536,
-0.4371996522,
-0.5170411468,
-0.0040442124,
-0.1364458352,
-1.373265624,
0.2569952607,
0.3242177367,
-0.5335450172,
0.1235847026,
-0.7191672921,
0.8692370653,
0.1920754462,
-0.2993328571,
0.1051613763,
-0.8199054003,
-0.1141287833,
0.0298289899,
0.0845978186,
-0.0745609328,
0.2932448089,
1.0521236658,
-0.1498437375,
0.9256289601,
-0.2158636302,
-0.2496954501,
0.1430314332,
-0.0119355777,
0.5508298278,
-0.2881205678,
-0.1778697819,
-0.0472151563,
-0.1000670344,
-0.1376935393,
-0.3826008439,
0.3553600311,
-0.7534097433,
-0.3649896681,
-0.141771391,
-0.166592598,
-0.3977738023,
0.1310358346,
0.6399870515,
0.6490619779,
-0.2983872294,
0.5093537569,
0.6310865283,
-0.2068655193,
0.1357203722,
0.1357102543,
0.3163593113,
-0.3993669152,
1.0722626448,
-0.1733558625,
0.4171491265,
0.5064770579,
0.2675429881,
-0.0391340144,
-0.6868866086,
-0.2105605453,
0.2244629115,
-0.7605999112,
0.1026273072,
-0.5635107756,
0.0111965733,
-0.8639212847,
-0.2600343823,
-0.4856160581,
-0.5795629621,
-0.5423704982,
0.116548337,
0.2004799396,
0.4737719893,
0.2286743671,
0.5285916924,
-0.2778329849,
0.3238515854,
0.672808826,
0.0907563418,
-0.1587443948,
-1.0280580521,
0.0081371451,
-0.2417208105,
-0.442022264,
-0.9102994204,
-0.0301163532,
0.3409456015,
0.5064437389,
0.1864024401,
-0.1641732007,
0.4183562696,
-0.5490204692,
1.1792186499,
0.1227904707,
-1.3058381081,
0.5830726624,
-0.5167818666,
-0.0181040484,
0.7761554718,
-0.0541446544,
-0.6968814135,
-0.696426034,
-0.6994673014,
-0.6319872737,
0.8382530212,
0.60967803,
0.0613102242,
0.1963753253,
0.2333886325,
0.1616269946,
0.1561959386,
-0.5011537671,
-0.1884821951,
-0.0958692953,
0.1172312126,
-0.5777897239,
-0.4795857072,
-0.2364640832,
-0.2072508931,
0.5897502899,
0.0333266631,
0.4178765714,
0.1999150664,
-0.0076671955,
-0.0008524228,
0.3526259959,
0.8482358456,
0.7393457294,
-0.3675509989,
0.123494111,
-0.097277306,
-0.1293436885,
-0.0888770297,
0.1457331479,
0.071933493,
0.0976644456,
1.0784196854,
0.6691049337,
0.2751381993,
-0.3027444482,
0.8922284245,
-0.0162457209,
-0.4133997262,
-0.3268966079,
0.0492259189,
0.0004010872,
0.2389533371,
0.4662429988,
-0.0286602117,
0.2098465711,
-0.499499619,
0.0912779868,
0.1895540655,
-0.3328098357,
-0.2981814444,
0.7704786658,
0.2408843488,
-0.6723911762,
0.555670023,
0.1445978433,
-0.5124548078,
0.6985303164,
0.2782355249,
1.1509580612,
-0.3751589656,
-0.1198638752,
0.1284747869,
0.0399812385,
0.1332981288,
0.253872931,
-0.3847509623,
-0.6264272332,
-0.3130934834,
-0.1595359594,
-0.7385662198,
-0.1718348116,
-0.8168113232,
0.1363559961,
-0.1907111257,
-0.3286631703,
0.6335241795,
-0.2016679347,
-0.1856314242,
-0.0972543061,
0.2887430191,
0.3715302646,
-1.2097324133,
0.4207853973,
0.4659567475,
-0.1075693145,
-0.5470621586,
-0.2125677019,
0.3689236343,
-0.5527727008,
0.4980501533,
0.0672814772,
-0.2610643804,
0.0356319472,
-0.5416516066,
-0.4921358526,
0.8822302818,
0.4678773582,
-0.1077603176,
-0.0159873124,
0.0216716137,
0.4020189345,
-0.2817515135,
0.0795692429,
0.2807753384,
0.3533665836,
0.1148863509,
-1.278945446,
-0.0341954045,
-0.1384404153,
-0.1136659682,
-0.0566791631,
-0.3227545917,
1.1482036114,
0.1400897056,
-0.0316767916,
0.3203476071,
0.7039364576,
0.1097229421,
0.2866663337,
0.4858714938,
0.0532243662,
0.8198407888,
-0.0798691362,
0.7242716551,
0.0328541324,
0.0083902916,
1.439968586,
-0.1936228722,
0.7013422251,
0.6828916073,
-0.4163940847,
0.646248579,
-0.0364094414,
-0.1349423677,
0.4324500263,
0.3852723837,
-0.1063104793,
-0.1931529939,
-0.3014203012,
-0.3406323493,
0.85330832,
-0.041013971,
-0.849298656,
0.3908430636,
-0.0837861001,
0.0423612185,
0.6818802357,
0.3209583461,
1.0641378164,
-0.0442808643,
-0.8808425069,
0.3319176733,
-0.1876540631,
0.4743044376,
-0.5262355804,
0.1529816538,
0.1728102416,
0.2161272019,
-0.2232086211,
-0.4072461128,
0.0641769916,
0.0923467651,
-0.3710086644,
-0.7978684306,
0.4021887779,
-0.5188482404,
-0.2681205571,
-0.123205103,
0.3519053459,
0.3173131943,
-0.2769637406,
0.0588402972,
0.1132446155,
0.0284581687,
-0.0893551186,
-0.1628164351,
0.3588662148,
0.2275940478,
0.4075904489,
0.4417226613,
0.4036822319,
-0.0109999496,
0.1768647581,
0.4422781765,
-0.679494679,
-0.6003925204,
-0.9956208467,
0.3833488524,
-0.2500388622,
-0.6118617058,
0.7832418084,
0.5413477421,
0.4891406596,
-0.0802099705,
0.5239488482,
-0.1715776324,
0.9000278711,
-0.5461788774,
0.7807182074,
-0.4048668742,
-0.0171977486,
-0.7893841267,
-0.6742014289,
-0.2295114845,
0.3315615952,
-0.2222481966,
0.0810974985,
0.7076342702,
0.6003991961,
0.1109752133,
0.2841047049,
0.2251307964,
-0.168131873,
0.6104513407,
0.2754862607,
0.7125835419,
-0.3686558008,
0.35925138,
-0.1783967018,
-0.3172965944,
-0.3017237484,
-1.153447628,
-0.7004011273,
-0.910377562,
-0.6865171194,
0.0241328068,
-0.0090369666,
0.7648060918,
0.5705909729,
-0.7193923593,
-0.4225178659,
0.1530839354,
-0.017440334,
-0.516159296,
-0.1473976374,
0.4409514964,
0.031061342,
-0.4820347428,
0.5048805475,
-0.2327574044,
-0.0363169238,
0.0483214222,
0.2925226688,
-0.2471929491,
0.0334879309,
0.3190683126,
0.2448533177,
-0.8691820502,
-0.4044230282,
-0.158269152,
-0.0760720447,
0.0458430685,
1.267553091,
-0.345184803,
0.4709687829,
0.5095183253,
0.4656189382,
0.1430164129,
0.2698612213,
0.5604632497,
-1.2208095789,
-0.2072275132,
0.336964488,
0.2979163229,
0.4450954795,
-0.4667721391,
0.0523115024,
0.2125692219,
-0.8470991254,
-0.8172565103,
0.1192466989,
-1.2271302938,
0.0964674652,
0.9941396117,
-0.2706662118,
0.120335333,
-0.0825249106,
-0.002021695,
0.401814878,
-0.5496429205,
0.8151252866,
1.2098289728,
-0.0197624844,
-0.032003656,
-0.1920299381,
0.7040483356,
0.6199605465,
-0.4520525634,
0.6625695825,
0.5506590605,
-0.0398765504,
0.5212247372,
0.8419713974,
0.0120654777,
0.3065095246,
0.0766951516,
0.0769741312,
-0.19339028,
-0.3284140825,
-0.1594736874,
0.1802550256,
0.1476078928,
-0.2495540529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07556v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07556v2
|
Using Natural Language Explanations to Improve Robustness of In-context Learning
| 2023-11-13T18:49:13 | 2024-05-20T16:24:58 |
Xuanli He, Yuxiang Wu, Oana-Maria Camburu, Pasquale Minervini, Pontus Stenetorp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies demonstrated that large language models (LLMs) can excel in
many tasks via in-context learning (ICL). However, recent works show that
ICL-prompted models tend to produce inaccurate results when presented with
adversarial inputs. In this work, we investigate whether augmenting ICL with
natural language explanations (NLEs) improves the robustness of LLMs on
adversarial datasets covering natural language inference and paraphrasing
identification. We prompt LLMs with a small set of human-generated NLEs to
produce further NLEs, yielding more accurate results than both a zero-shot-ICL
setting and using only human-generated NLEs. Our results on five popular LLMs
(GPT3.5-turbo, Llama2, Vicuna, Zephyr, and Mistral) show that our approach
yields over 6% improvement over baseline approaches for eight adversarial
datasets: HANS, ISCS, NaN, ST, PICD, PISP, ANLI, and PAWS. Furthermore,
previous studies have demonstrated that prompt selection strategies
significantly enhance ICL on in-distribution test sets. However, our findings
reveal that these strategies do not match the efficacy of our approach for
robustness evaluations, resulting in an accuracy drop of 8% compared to the
proposed approach.
|
[
-0.5530855656,
-0.9258737564,
0.5454630852,
-0.0409636199,
-0.3050892651,
0.047476694,
-0.6336392164,
-0.268181026,
-0.4946976602,
0.1729676574,
-0.4751514494,
-0.5874993205,
-0.5893969536,
0.3091141582,
-0.2017968446,
1.0788116455,
0.0493533425,
0.0022541401,
-0.1630692482,
-0.1142263487,
-0.4948368371,
-0.2008781284,
-0.9371342063,
-0.4251683056,
0.5019322038,
0.3060005605,
1.0276857615,
0.6625188589,
0.1180944964,
0.2765872777,
-0.3732928336,
0.5789003372,
-0.1687577665,
0.0394427478,
-0.1072177589,
-0.3258615732,
0.0644090921,
-0.1072554886,
0.3590587676,
0.737883091,
0.0972050801,
-0.3180363476,
0.5512677431,
0.5249938965,
-0.7255545259,
-0.0478256121,
-0.6659624577,
-0.0099146273,
0.040714927,
-0.2260146141,
-0.6572828293,
-0.2239673883,
0.4911396801,
-0.7145339847,
0.3075781763,
0.0471209884,
0.8928337693,
0.4057923853,
-0.3212633431,
-0.5349447727,
-0.4909814596,
0.8155857921,
-1.0433709621,
0.0445939749,
0.3850052357,
0.4569236338,
-0.4660794437,
-0.4833336771,
-0.2793405652,
-0.5391885042,
-0.3717313707,
-0.0369594805,
-0.2197375298,
0.1653513163,
0.4048054814,
0.1289370805,
-0.6132749915,
0.4484871924,
0.1124696881,
-0.3304508626,
0.3572999239,
0.0203108862,
0.4259482026,
0.0962182805,
-0.4988335371,
-0.2189455926,
-0.9445632696,
0.3934963942,
0.2963456213,
0.4958158433,
-0.1457159817,
0.160475269,
0.0327431671,
1.0447520018,
0.2208317816,
-0.1079601124,
-0.1227444932,
-0.2579409182,
-0.3370641768,
0.0193685349,
0.714168191,
0.1241865233,
0.1729335785,
-0.6209565997,
-0.0840650573,
-0.1175802797,
0.0959951058,
-0.6523612142,
-0.1089712232,
0.0892957747,
-0.1767085344,
-0.3379435241,
0.1304281652,
-0.834217608,
-0.566527009,
-0.5243379474,
0.4559096396,
-0.6760058403,
0.2767434418,
-0.01339937,
-0.3199342191,
0.2355691493,
0.3754099905,
-0.821809113,
0.2029269338,
0.4188915491,
0.7011984587,
-0.1579752266,
-0.3309948146,
-0.8981238008,
0.1130871922,
-0.4489559531,
0.6854093075,
-0.3768149018,
-0.1193930879,
0.0258604679,
-0.1954716593,
-0.0829244182,
-0.6977934837,
0.6176328659,
-0.557049036,
0.5213721991,
-0.5055482388,
-0.3993670046,
-0.2736051381,
0.3656172752,
-0.4209981561,
0.8620023727,
-0.2197961509,
-0.8882630467,
0.5635674,
-0.5838506818,
-0.6160933375,
-0.0496983528,
-0.0640925169,
-0.3123793602,
-0.0864643827,
0.9498440027,
0.6029860973,
-0.2920700312,
0.5215127468,
-0.4699538946,
-0.5600329638,
0.4280090332,
-0.9310055971,
1.0584022999,
0.1248824596,
-0.6447886229,
0.0651321113,
-0.5120463371,
-0.1654446125,
0.0012833587,
-0.354254812,
-0.2966637313,
0.0317256823,
-0.3898061514,
0.0717031732,
-0.1247367188,
-0.2344855368,
-0.1867810339,
-0.9305551648,
0.3223391175,
0.8039552569,
0.0662965775,
0.6402236223,
-0.3103798926,
0.5630660653,
-0.0600972734,
0.0488689691,
-0.2358490974,
-0.3495875895,
-0.3082769215,
-0.4441345334,
0.0665725246,
0.486068666,
-1.1064566374,
0.4242219925,
-0.1218226254,
-0.2082716525,
-0.1581107229,
0.3215429187,
0.5623125434,
0.9988241792,
0.4005604684,
0.4394452572,
-0.524682045,
-0.7991581559,
-0.5429620743,
-0.1232500523,
-0.4321715534,
0.2706297338,
0.2539858818,
0.0874291286,
1.0291036367,
-0.0184449889,
0.148081407,
-0.3842408657,
0.0978742987,
0.0440934338,
-0.0173832066,
0.631362617,
-0.8285543919,
-0.629865706,
-0.14596425,
-0.7766222954,
-0.1314676553,
-0.2730073929,
-0.0336874276,
0.1637165993,
0.3186871707,
-0.4293438792,
0.4384626746,
0.2776592672,
-0.2221349329,
0.4277171195,
-0.2373076677,
-0.1491987705,
-0.9949300289,
-0.2001933753,
0.2861068547,
-0.2115763426,
-0.7361837029,
0.162346527,
0.0729808435,
-0.0009760699,
-0.5629041195,
0.6116786599,
-0.4114897251,
0.0975647718,
-0.2441106886,
0.386775732,
0.269004941,
0.3797391951,
-0.1367831528,
0.9256583452,
0.9975339174,
-0.947265923,
0.1506337523,
0.0613503419,
-0.145463571,
0.3553074598,
-0.5545678139,
-0.0524924211,
-0.4048056602,
0.4373404086,
-0.8861425519,
-0.4398089945,
0.361561805,
-0.5525371432,
0.4415150285,
-0.0734291598,
-0.4184291661,
-0.1119919345,
-0.5619952083,
-0.0959101021,
0.3477686048,
-1.2309445143,
0.4102907181,
-0.1001254693,
0.2659705877,
-0.6721358895,
-0.6606796384,
0.4506699741,
-0.846627593,
-0.562746346,
0.4539522827,
-0.310936898,
-0.5696246028,
-0.2404955328,
0.105313018,
0.0014086983,
0.5560314059,
0.0000843782,
0.3812543452,
-0.2845470011,
0.1690173596,
-0.1866471022,
0.0348962732,
0.169968769,
-0.0501032248,
0.2489226311,
-0.2239066958,
-0.2833416164,
-0.4774855375,
0.2537435293,
0.4643586576,
-0.0279800892,
0.9567580819,
0.7614248395,
-0.4402543306,
-0.453133285,
-0.1190554127,
-0.4223166704,
-0.498400867,
-0.0101746963,
-0.0452648066,
-0.5770144463,
0.4065997899,
0.2521739602,
0.2193004936,
0.3541714251,
0.3462152183,
-0.0603228994,
1.3129644394,
0.1170969605,
-0.2345605493,
0.4406189322,
-0.0988707021,
0.3658972085,
-0.7875494361,
0.0092798276,
-0.4318858385,
-0.1782334745,
-0.2745260894,
-0.0012350116,
0.3911213577,
0.1815686673,
-0.2760212719,
0.2318860143,
-0.3660760522,
0.5397282839,
0.5446535945,
0.3227182031,
0.0137800649,
0.1244084165,
-0.0836767554,
-0.087433666,
-0.7515103817,
-0.6916934848,
0.9304788113,
0.2982931435,
0.7027397752,
0.0940662771,
0.5109027028,
-0.0209046006,
0.5126650333,
-0.5993643403,
0.3413708806,
-0.1336047649,
-0.4593001306,
-0.288343966,
-0.3570954204,
-0.7593429685,
0.3216946125,
-0.0279567,
-0.8266071081,
0.0137850121,
0.3844852746,
-0.6199153066,
0.285076648,
-0.6963237524,
0.6174874902,
-0.292439729,
-0.2909129858,
0.1826377064,
-0.693479538,
0.5061766505,
0.1487856805,
0.2264177203,
0.1507024318,
-0.0540397987,
0.4931463599,
-0.400393188,
0.9801383615,
-0.3563031852,
-0.0397831574,
0.2153764367,
-0.0832730159,
0.8852458,
0.3930384815,
-0.3863512874,
-0.2508102655,
-0.5526553392,
-0.334985286,
-0.9473375082,
0.7028805614,
-0.4280212522,
-0.6751996875,
-0.1721994281,
-0.6567628384,
-0.402754128,
-0.1832446307,
0.7218390703,
0.910079062,
0.0844924152,
0.509105742,
0.993106842,
-0.4318047166,
0.6906272173,
0.5046087503,
0.41617167,
-0.3818275332,
0.6520914435,
-0.1780826598,
0.448692888,
0.2825265527,
0.4703896046,
-0.5819728971,
-0.8033959866,
-0.7388048768,
-0.168149963,
-0.8934181333,
-0.2835536599,
-0.4058246315,
0.0318150483,
-0.2733392417,
-0.5226647854,
0.1655456573,
0.1023753732,
-0.5922450423,
-0.1408957243,
0.3107122183,
0.3522550762,
0.1170814484,
0.3435179591,
-0.4086743295,
0.4458345473,
0.2158649564,
-0.1002725065,
0.1242685765,
-0.9206863046,
-0.1714206636,
0.3832865953,
-0.1714176089,
-0.9573635459,
0.4057774544,
0.4488767684,
0.6958013177,
0.5465239882,
0.337031126,
1.0017154217,
-0.1436076909,
0.8582188487,
-0.2126976103,
-0.6455183625,
0.6010187268,
-0.3981947303,
0.4033074379,
0.5258356333,
0.2448657155,
-0.1214287281,
-0.7767782807,
-0.6508604288,
-0.8525577188,
0.6313816905,
0.1580141485,
0.01169773,
-0.096413061,
0.396684736,
0.0861477479,
-0.111910142,
-0.8238973022,
-0.419849813,
0.0603122786,
-0.3147310913,
-0.1187334731,
0.0163192414,
-0.2082268894,
-0.0036292966,
0.8663381338,
-0.4878962636,
-0.1284478456,
0.300290525,
-0.2700204253,
-0.0247230157,
0.3568375111,
0.4989154637,
0.7482073307,
-0.012896264,
0.3364778459,
0.5187342763,
0.0569851622,
0.0084062908,
0.2187194079,
-0.3174892962,
0.0797874779,
0.7336341739,
0.8381217718,
0.3592457175,
-0.8335849643,
0.565541327,
-0.2992476523,
-0.0217763223,
-0.153638795,
0.0446097665,
-0.127817139,
0.0142442686,
0.430239141,
0.2475673705,
0.1611591876,
-0.3609707952,
0.1749818027,
0.7763364315,
-0.3606231511,
-0.1928814352,
0.6710311174,
-0.3147485256,
-0.1928097308,
0.2993285954,
-0.307005018,
-0.4865905643,
0.6646972299,
0.8035002947,
0.7978531718,
0.1622398794,
0.3786931038,
0.2873657644,
0.4066312015,
-0.136040926,
-0.1736712009,
-0.1072577909,
-0.5377460718,
-0.4988510609,
-0.3235607147,
-0.4002465308,
0.3529462516,
-0.6561011076,
0.1804149151,
-0.3802657425,
0.3686549664,
-0.0147542534,
-0.1933183968,
-0.6446335316,
0.2445251495,
0.2552466393,
0.9252940416,
-0.9815990925,
0.6177394986,
0.6804374456,
-0.2104566991,
-0.920178771,
0.3915395439,
0.1397165656,
-0.5940510035,
0.4415301979,
0.34009251,
-0.1102719083,
-0.240165025,
-0.5118948817,
-0.7670465112,
0.9842584729,
0.8109316826,
-0.0817814916,
0.1288620234,
-0.1465009302,
0.5978146791,
-0.1903273314,
0.270893842,
0.4238730073,
0.4446484447,
0.1102515161,
-0.3946373761,
0.1312472969,
0.0370015614,
-0.0546151847,
0.0322072282,
-0.1059190705,
0.4733721316,
-0.2518043518,
-0.3005286455,
-0.0298635028,
0.6609219313,
0.4271295667,
0.3282335401,
0.6823555231,
0.382086575,
0.833532989,
0.0252190661,
1.2943404913,
-0.0029625511,
-0.1046041027,
1.0439989567,
0.0182048194,
0.5179470181,
0.5197656155,
-0.0445891395,
0.4867704213,
0.9724781513,
0.373529613,
0.4783594608,
-0.049560748,
-0.3281130791,
-0.2193002403,
-0.1413915753,
0.044232592,
0.1313263178,
0.4333433807,
-0.3660429716,
-0.5894579291,
0.3293505013,
0.1889594942,
0.25964728,
-0.0902776867,
0.8225826025,
-0.0549640022,
-1.0008556843,
0.8065077066,
-0.1603903621,
0.6646685004,
-0.4799156189,
0.1013741866,
-0.2596205473,
0.1390859634,
-0.0869729072,
-0.6089401245,
0.3137400448,
0.1178865582,
-0.1014043465,
-0.3438891768,
0.7375864387,
-0.3150449693,
-0.2675535083,
0.2638552487,
0.0396487936,
-0.1023349315,
-0.258063674,
-0.6469506621,
-0.3195514679,
0.1670181304,
-0.2656627893,
0.4534024298,
0.2885455489,
-0.1323904842,
0.8534047604,
0.6886632442,
-0.0275761764,
0.022716606,
0.0621018484,
0.8222320676,
-0.2441002727,
-0.3665978312,
-1.2943768501,
0.54999125,
-0.2774784863,
-0.3270626664,
0.9700260758,
0.3211602867,
0.6210070848,
0.0984807685,
0.8202023506,
0.0077606477,
0.5305317044,
-0.7096617222,
0.2736857831,
-0.3541055322,
0.6119523048,
-0.0112248501,
-0.5783883333,
-0.5312124491,
0.3460761905,
-0.2581966519,
-0.2564436495,
0.5752353072,
0.9835294485,
-0.1631359458,
-0.0699109435,
0.2940746844,
0.0522083975,
0.4663651586,
0.4062740207,
0.8081970811,
-0.3145008087,
0.7124735713,
-0.5226075053,
-0.2343468815,
-0.0577904843,
-0.981487751,
-1.1459954977,
-0.1684830636,
-0.3044428825,
-0.1678767651,
0.1386066079,
0.8984779119,
0.6449632049,
-0.8454534411,
0.2026043385,
-0.3166037202,
0.300121516,
-0.3295471072,
-0.276126802,
0.3964433968,
-0.8021570444,
-0.7084619403,
1.0532437563,
0.2354736924,
0.0449848436,
-0.1439343989,
-0.3957875073,
0.1441282928,
-0.1367940754,
0.3253219426,
0.2559577823,
-1.1234474182,
-0.2520795465,
-0.0190169476,
0.0128248548,
0.0253890194,
0.5452906489,
-0.9483085275,
0.3877650797,
0.4068036377,
0.7995340824,
-0.1941011846,
0.1649340242,
0.9062739015,
-0.9341940284,
0.158019498,
0.1669923216,
0.4591700733,
0.5936378241,
-0.5722329617,
0.1540557444,
-0.1699572206,
-0.4335604608,
-0.8710278273,
0.0860419199,
-0.4708930254,
-0.377386272,
1.1633760929,
-0.3048501313,
-0.2119153738,
-0.2819361091,
-0.2771709859,
0.22119537,
-0.2873950303,
0.718375504,
0.689968884,
0.0230192393,
0.0637967139,
-0.6353216171,
0.7768369913,
0.4844255149,
-0.8651497364,
0.119358778,
0.3047401905,
0.0528171211,
-0.2142463773,
-0.0596234649,
0.1006459966,
0.35475564,
-0.5134909153,
-0.588126123,
-0.0457813852,
-0.3174995482,
-0.7099583745,
0.0222109295,
0.2816202044,
-0.0787737146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07547v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07547v1
|
GPT-4V(ision) as A Social Media Analysis Engine
| 2023-11-13T18:36:50 | 2023-11-13T18:36:50 |
Hanjia Lyu, Jinfa Huang, Daoan Zhang, Yongsheng Yu, Xinyi Mou, Jinsheng Pan, Zhengyuan Yang, Zhongyu Wei, Jiebo Luo
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Recent research has offered insights into the extraordinary capabilities of
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) in various general vision and language tasks.
There is growing interest in how LMMs perform in more specialized domains.
Social media content, inherently multimodal, blends text, images, videos, and
sometimes audio. Understanding social multimedia content remains a challenging
problem for contemporary machine learning frameworks. In this paper, we explore
GPT-4V(ision)'s capabilities for social multimedia analysis. We select five
representative tasks, including sentiment analysis, hate speech detection, fake
news identification, demographic inference, and political ideology detection,
to evaluate GPT-4V. Our investigation begins with a preliminary quantitative
analysis for each task using existing benchmark datasets, followed by a careful
review of the results and a selection of qualitative samples that illustrate
GPT-4V's potential in understanding multimodal social media content. GPT-4V
demonstrates remarkable efficacy in these tasks, showcasing strengths such as
joint understanding of image-text pairs, contextual and cultural awareness, and
extensive commonsense knowledge. Despite the overall impressive capacity of
GPT-4V in the social media domain, there remain notable challenges. GPT-4V
struggles with tasks involving multilingual social multimedia comprehension and
has difficulties in generalizing to the latest trends in social media.
Additionally, it exhibits a tendency to generate erroneous information in the
context of evolving celebrity and politician knowledge, reflecting the known
hallucination problem. The insights gleaned from our findings underscore a
promising future for LMMs in enhancing our comprehension of social media
content and its users through the analysis of multimodal information.
|
[
-0.4193497896,
-0.8488032818,
0.6906319857,
0.3629294932,
-0.4522674084,
0.4271714389,
-0.3101733327,
-0.2360686064,
-0.0599890053,
0.0960668698,
-0.6878026724,
-0.4849134684,
-1.0178972483,
-0.012568566,
-0.3656913936,
1.0611815453,
0.0903485194,
-0.069202736,
-0.0056178533,
-0.3490046859,
-0.3230864704,
-0.3642995656,
-0.6512474418,
-0.0364412814,
0.5320823193,
0.2767744362,
0.5522361994,
0.3865180612,
0.6200808883,
0.4337820709,
0.3512221277,
0.2547249794,
-0.7183721662,
-0.1277587265,
-0.136349082,
-0.0319051035,
-0.1678246409,
0.1595578939,
0.7363297939,
-0.0489775017,
0.1106454134,
0.1266300231,
0.0300789662,
0.6348050237,
-0.3776838779,
0.4560280442,
-0.8476908803,
-0.0229505636,
-0.3041151762,
-0.5266720057,
0.1114473864,
0.0180007666,
0.0331570804,
-0.5976634622,
0.2943208218,
-0.2469273061,
0.9036279321,
0.519354105,
-0.6155970693,
-0.4235307574,
-0.7139844894,
0.7607210875,
-0.2385036647,
0.4748357832,
0.2506398559,
0.5510139465,
0.2510310113,
-0.7523617148,
-0.8457704782,
0.1716195047,
0.3783158362,
0.2450196296,
-0.3907723725,
-0.0740403384,
0.1721444875,
0.3030948341,
-0.6044901013,
-0.1009699404,
-0.5445498824,
-0.3582600057,
0.4781055152,
-0.1458142251,
0.5188666582,
-0.6669710279,
-0.3873908222,
0.2400687188,
-0.3663650453,
-0.134446606,
0.5496436357,
-0.0583831333,
-0.0285113733,
0.4054985046,
-0.0752034634,
0.2209268808,
-0.1923894286,
-0.1681492329,
0.3653650582,
-0.6765237451,
-0.1727141142,
-0.2190518528,
1.0437495708,
0.679338038,
0.3039531708,
-0.0626595318,
-0.0688722879,
0.3028487861,
0.5181797147,
-0.9157081246,
-0.1169257909,
0.1881394535,
-0.4831914604,
-0.2533249557,
0.0443934277,
-0.7435691357,
-0.3799336851,
-0.3346816897,
0.6283431649,
-0.7187393904,
-0.5430138111,
-0.0963606834,
-0.2654369473,
0.2602720559,
0.2897222936,
-0.7833493948,
0.2444970906,
0.7224609256,
1.1661452055,
-0.3481608629,
-0.1959446669,
-0.5181849599,
0.1509367079,
-0.0007509725,
0.7762807012,
-0.6048731804,
-0.2136564851,
0.0141962618,
0.1539754272,
0.1056727916,
-0.1911655068,
0.3766223788,
-0.4660359621,
-0.029375121,
-0.660059154,
-0.273452282,
-0.5423600674,
0.5176185966,
-0.7543583512,
0.7259472609,
-0.0428357758,
-0.8026570082,
0.490568459,
-0.6254255772,
-0.151461646,
0.2390428632,
-0.6017696261,
-0.4448073506,
-0.085000284,
0.3104119897,
0.7846847177,
-0.2080006599,
0.1479350626,
-0.4425739944,
-0.5478778481,
0.1279782802,
-0.5111019015,
0.3622495234,
0.3490292132,
-0.5611983538,
0.2421108037,
-0.6077619195,
-0.2405211627,
0.064102985,
-0.1803044081,
-0.1070240736,
0.0307535455,
0.1062878594,
0.3178772032,
0.0117893405,
-0.5041763783,
-0.0937911123,
0.3816627562,
0.7939447165,
0.9903847575,
0.1213211268,
0.39139539,
-0.0222372767,
0.5514091849,
0.0225399435,
0.1010198966,
0.0483320393,
-0.7626008391,
-0.2962626517,
-0.4099861383,
-0.059091609,
0.458609432,
-1.4234942198,
-0.2922871709,
-0.4732306898,
-0.401145041,
-0.406100601,
0.2300520539,
0.2164920717,
0.107237488,
0.3602347374,
-0.1674279422,
-0.491330862,
-0.9907670617,
-0.417601198,
-0.1187816337,
0.1836930513,
0.223615706,
0.6145472527,
-0.5946249962,
0.4866750836,
0.1072470918,
-0.3268559277,
-0.3951420188,
0.2407902032,
0.0386435464,
-0.0159396082,
0.4501284659,
-1.181327343,
-0.5423690677,
0.1922780126,
-0.9521945715,
0.0394913591,
-0.1056377813,
0.1093769148,
-0.0926944762,
0.2292880863,
-0.5925212502,
0.186044693,
0.6703976393,
-0.1672940999,
0.3508233726,
-0.0820968077,
0.7365802526,
-0.9872465134,
-0.240694195,
0.4176765978,
-0.2500201762,
-0.7483414412,
-0.3086314797,
0.2473141998,
-0.0632806942,
-0.4131847918,
0.1744267941,
-0.3262139559,
-0.3955695629,
-0.2854313254,
0.209280476,
-0.3618397415,
0.4065488577,
-0.1666849852,
0.5814936757,
0.4946912825,
-0.3195954263,
0.5529432297,
-0.0979800299,
-0.353097707,
0.6634627581,
-0.3892194331,
0.3642393649,
-0.35987252,
-0.0504744127,
-1.1878904104,
-0.6079372764,
0.308712095,
-0.5675692558,
0.1806370169,
-0.2883914709,
-0.7198756933,
-0.325086832,
-0.4491354823,
0.2627735436,
0.2455354333,
-0.367890656,
0.7955698967,
0.5134717226,
-0.183285594,
-0.7262203097,
-0.4228051603,
0.1820636094,
-0.479965508,
-0.8794943094,
0.4362970889,
-0.0481307022,
-0.1882257313,
0.2550195158,
-0.0946830139,
-0.0766046792,
-0.2463966608,
0.289652437,
0.071417965,
-0.0105886776,
0.1221298575,
0.0244203527,
-0.0838619545,
0.008083689,
-0.102108255,
0.3321438432,
-0.5142455101,
-0.2635552585,
-0.6194800735,
0.2179535776,
0.6126564741,
-0.1844997704,
0.274962157,
1.2171589136,
-0.3561562002,
-0.0249668751,
-0.7216227055,
0.078436859,
-0.4910814762,
0.6893526912,
-0.3410901725,
-0.9445083737,
0.3808654249,
0.2043382674,
-0.0773572475,
0.3030155003,
0.867842555,
0.0875895545,
0.9460508227,
0.4008159935,
-0.0388265997,
0.5218784809,
-0.314858079,
0.0778940618,
-0.2194267064,
-0.2303417772,
0.0852539018,
-0.379396081,
-0.6901669502,
-0.6439974904,
0.4058221579,
-0.7287505269,
-0.0999468938,
0.0056984266,
-0.3607480824,
0.5001174212,
0.244369626,
0.0371142402,
0.2856478989,
0.0820578262,
0.5734206438,
-0.1978869885,
-0.3433397412,
-0.5301912427,
0.9218745232,
0.5731745362,
0.5431259871,
0.4142111242,
0.3457006514,
0.5589175224,
0.3728983998,
-0.7149232626,
0.5427934527,
-0.2641554773,
-0.5806629062,
-0.1070940718,
-0.5084099174,
-0.5333120823,
0.6089113951,
-0.1552040726,
-0.4552819133,
-0.2099090219,
0.1791773885,
-0.2804222703,
0.3129278123,
-0.7580625415,
0.9600924253,
-0.3490248621,
-0.4984560013,
-0.237841934,
-0.5819567442,
0.5699826479,
-0.2346158028,
0.5381438732,
-0.0595342889,
-0.186391741,
0.6453036666,
0.0785327628,
0.6175979376,
-0.3374848664,
0.2044445723,
0.178348273,
-0.2612722814,
0.2484872788,
0.1876162887,
0.2370633483,
0.241496101,
0.1409771144,
-0.3166877627,
-0.7397620678,
0.8965812922,
-1.0207289457,
-0.4801759422,
-0.4540543854,
-0.4860036969,
-0.1792970598,
0.1123741418,
0.2196768373,
0.2897558808,
-0.1008084267,
0.4330856204,
0.5197635293,
-0.1550270468,
0.3514214158,
0.1807470769,
-0.168924585,
-0.4433726668,
1.2798600197,
0.3893246353,
0.0202480201,
-0.074360542,
0.0775681958,
-0.4391610622,
-0.5940484405,
-0.5868363976,
0.3747389615,
-0.9305870533,
0.0630393922,
-0.9270188808,
-0.0096297478,
-0.219610855,
0.2512570322,
-0.2860559821,
-0.0537223592,
-0.151656732,
-0.2375800759,
0.0387127474,
0.9473831654,
-0.1516258717,
0.3668388724,
-0.6155411601,
0.4508461058,
0.361522913,
0.1243790686,
-0.3975436091,
-0.4097279906,
-0.0720184892,
-0.2032471597,
-0.5244419575,
-1.1224669218,
0.2391558737,
0.2224313617,
0.4087145329,
0.6312557459,
-0.5399557352,
0.6688549519,
-0.6206117868,
0.7821822762,
0.048548907,
-0.758674562,
0.2358648181,
-0.6527500749,
0.0407841317,
0.3860278726,
0.794870019,
-0.4977001548,
-0.1509487629,
-0.5509362817,
-0.373057425,
0.4442748725,
0.653981626,
0.370469451,
-0.0349581279,
0.348357141,
0.139416635,
0.3607586324,
-0.9772133827,
0.1438744962,
-0.8332695961,
-0.1664129347,
-0.1422806829,
-0.1834609956,
0.1755149812,
-0.1279457957,
0.5812923312,
-0.0475341454,
0.3221002519,
-0.1601027548,
-0.0420462675,
0.0052815876,
0.1142402664,
0.470171392,
0.6917103529,
-0.2580763698,
0.3200502098,
-0.0593542829,
-0.4848089218,
0.0082411291,
0.2167874575,
0.3352758586,
-0.1210097522,
0.2899059355,
0.7408189774,
-0.0052685435,
-0.3801727593,
0.8084958792,
-0.3580126464,
-0.5096893907,
-0.4506927431,
-0.028296316,
0.084532775,
0.4445483088,
0.4494333863,
0.0187331717,
0.272811234,
-0.9970543385,
0.2701067626,
0.5315597653,
-0.614808619,
-0.7952524424,
0.7021433115,
0.0756449178,
-0.1320057958,
0.4462103844,
-0.3357206285,
-0.5705062747,
0.3116217256,
0.3633572459,
0.6033884287,
-0.1842558086,
0.4255582988,
0.1059590057,
0.4322530031,
0.1096154973,
0.4870786965,
-0.0347906463,
-0.8652374148,
-0.6955829263,
-0.4653871953,
0.0303804651,
0.4484031796,
-0.289249301,
0.2026258707,
-0.4194334745,
-0.2942748368,
0.1718067974,
-0.1535745263,
-0.8196351528,
0.1302546561,
0.1049649343,
0.2025034279,
-0.9029581547,
0.6998296976,
0.5765450597,
-0.4792743623,
-0.5040495396,
-0.035936594,
0.5990898013,
-0.7443050742,
0.8484640718,
0.576097548,
-0.1734886318,
0.1167352498,
-0.5451446772,
-0.6555626392,
1.1516735554,
0.2095084637,
-0.1954068094,
-0.1884460598,
0.1625262648,
0.4545724392,
-0.2374977618,
0.0929328576,
0.3781121075,
0.4942123294,
0.2001923323,
-0.4758998156,
0.064948909,
-0.4799684584,
-0.0286276843,
0.0247940104,
-0.6346439719,
0.7777628303,
0.0522064008,
-0.3109768331,
-0.2220215201,
0.6488495469,
0.1240413412,
0.4303939342,
0.7345016003,
0.304694742,
0.532810092,
-0.1869918406,
1.1697657108,
0.1503110379,
0.3534137309,
0.4676554799,
-0.0115301851,
0.3738822937,
0.5378019214,
-0.0711494088,
0.394516468,
0.7816936374,
-0.0819730759,
0.5869531631,
0.0846890658,
-0.4338324964,
-0.305918932,
0.158750996,
-0.110226132,
0.6256249547,
0.5073309541,
-0.1762119234,
-0.0142521504,
0.2073626965,
-0.1037359983,
-0.1833682656,
-0.260343343,
0.5675317645,
-0.0083887391,
-0.4460704029,
0.1105077341,
-0.1923818439,
0.5141780376,
-0.6308617592,
-0.1711029261,
0.2238320112,
0.0842535347,
-0.2183635682,
-0.6416630745,
0.34844172,
0.0580329038,
0.0726889744,
-0.1645112485,
0.8679701686,
-0.1735086143,
-0.2860119939,
0.3113620579,
0.5840321183,
0.3407944739,
-0.5200235844,
-0.8300767541,
0.4298157096,
0.1333940327,
-0.1648337394,
0.1884609312,
0.7704594135,
0.0683284476,
0.574883759,
0.6682921648,
-0.0390254296,
-0.0321113728,
0.2056843936,
0.8115830421,
-0.5871677995,
-0.4026539624,
-1.1821558475,
0.5758013725,
-0.3841337562,
0.0217171013,
0.8955307007,
0.3126923442,
0.7907450795,
0.0781862959,
1.1685757637,
-0.1706464738,
0.1968868822,
-0.5496017933,
0.6372328997,
-0.8162329197,
0.0979976207,
-0.5722041726,
-1.0167877674,
-0.2751107216,
0.4884167016,
-0.468326956,
0.1926652938,
0.7182564139,
0.7711682916,
-0.3371360004,
0.2625197172,
0.5398048162,
0.1394243836,
0.6624301672,
0.0568480268,
1.2082217932,
-0.0849431679,
0.8176842928,
-0.1638649702,
-0.4861207604,
0.0862287059,
-0.7219779491,
-1.1712383032,
-0.8853116035,
0.0579912066,
-0.2814792693,
0.2438469231,
0.6599413753,
0.6065325141,
-0.2697309256,
0.0470188856,
0.2081684768,
-0.1570371538,
0.0971924439,
-0.1831820607,
0.3114587963,
-0.3620923162,
-0.8251125813,
0.261384964,
0.633654952,
-0.2090064883,
-0.4051006436,
-0.0635575205,
-0.2649849355,
-0.1393548846,
0.8636376858,
-0.0389141776,
-0.8125299215,
-0.5932532549,
0.1126988307,
0.302657038,
0.0860294178,
0.8607884645,
-0.2033005357,
0.6543879509,
0.3198816478,
0.9518932104,
0.7647283077,
0.2331134826,
0.4033197165,
-0.6813595891,
-0.0422753915,
-0.1122692376,
0.5540046692,
0.6298896074,
-0.2164596617,
0.4775018692,
0.6139423847,
-0.7508936524,
-0.4935904741,
0.1937036365,
-1.0089999437,
-0.1555132866,
1.5174319744,
0.1319042891,
-0.2569856942,
-0.1875761747,
-0.3351599276,
0.3719810843,
-0.4283496439,
0.7137172222,
0.943613112,
-0.100426726,
-0.5320635438,
-1.1719646454,
0.4733811021,
0.1318312585,
-0.6632466912,
-0.3598751426,
0.5144706368,
0.4433488548,
0.1330729574,
1.0037363768,
-0.1271443069,
0.2878400385,
-0.2900684476,
-0.2967558503,
-0.0407423005,
-0.1155980006,
-0.1306222528,
0.1607826203,
-0.2977362275,
-0.1664637029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07538v1
|
Leveraging Multiple Teachers for Test-Time Adaptation of Language-Guided Classifiers
| 2023-11-13T18:28:25 | 2023-11-13T18:28:25 |
Kangda Wei, Sayan Ghosh, Rakesh R. Menon, Shashank Srivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent approaches have explored language-guided classifiers capable of
classifying examples from novel tasks when provided with task-specific natural
language explanations, instructions or prompts (Sanh et al., 2022; R. Menon et
al., 2022). While these classifiers can generalize in zero-shot settings, their
task performance often varies substantially between different language
explanations in unpredictable ways (Lu et al., 2022; Gonen et al., 2022). Also,
current approaches fail to leverage unlabeled examples that may be available in
many scenarios. Here, we introduce TALC, a framework that uses data programming
to adapt a language-guided classifier for a new task during inference when
provided with explanations from multiple teachers and unlabeled test examples.
Our results show that TALC consistently outperforms a competitive baseline from
prior work by an impressive 9.3% (relative improvement). Further, we
demonstrate the robustness of TALC to variations in the quality and quantity of
provided explanations, highlighting its potential in scenarios where learning
from multiple teachers or a crowd is involved. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/WeiKangda/TALC.git.
|
[
-0.0360466577,
-0.5081701279,
0.5653048754,
0.2067778111,
-0.0417442806,
0.2856120169,
-0.531752646,
-0.1179096699,
-0.4795907736,
0.089657627,
-0.2545673549,
-0.7685549259,
-0.7773541808,
0.1381798238,
-0.4452276528,
1.4165890217,
-0.2816865742,
0.069330506,
0.0607198067,
-0.2758369446,
-0.9915912151,
-0.2597359121,
-0.5248129368,
-0.3557876348,
0.5200864673,
1.0959324837,
0.6337673664,
0.5101178885,
0.0192724355,
0.1716869026,
0.5149466991,
0.1021791175,
-0.3048555851,
0.2397495508,
-0.2984812558,
-0.5342608094,
0.0183504708,
-0.0231248382,
0.8545228243,
0.8225361109,
-0.1586610079,
0.1408077627,
0.3962575793,
0.3324832618,
-0.9931261539,
0.4140244424,
-0.6030641198,
0.1346414834,
0.2132685184,
-0.1865733564,
-0.8774582148,
-0.518216908,
0.1686862558,
-0.6277619004,
0.6769000888,
-0.336565882,
0.5520188808,
0.2914280593,
-0.3471955359,
-0.3386328816,
-0.8478263021,
0.9851743579,
-0.2261627316,
0.3310831189,
0.3364231884,
0.6662330031,
-0.261143893,
-0.5023372769,
-0.5351800919,
0.0689202473,
0.0910972729,
0.3706849515,
0.3531747758,
-0.1400832534,
0.0616171472,
0.0821503848,
-0.5126835108,
0.1009196341,
-0.2043192387,
-0.10829328,
0.2252493948,
-0.0465623066,
0.0608595945,
0.1739498973,
-0.3287016451,
-0.3687326312,
-0.265325278,
0.1642080545,
0.2200373113,
0.6494404674,
-0.1853697896,
0.2731580138,
-0.0348297171,
1.086619854,
-0.0215959977,
0.0779470727,
0.1563268006,
-0.2654036283,
0.0364305973,
0.4263167083,
0.3736598492,
0.123806484,
0.3401292264,
-0.3213018179,
0.1600925326,
0.3439519405,
0.1018381491,
-0.8254740834,
-0.4135299623,
0.0343181305,
-0.1767963618,
-0.332680285,
0.2381032556,
-1.1609908342,
-0.520509541,
-0.1126955822,
0.5069279671,
-0.1254606247,
-0.0930120796,
0.4090331495,
-0.1536512673,
0.2901734412,
0.2036090046,
-0.9665440917,
0.5517597198,
0.5262623429,
1.0279160738,
-0.2845338881,
-0.7117321491,
-0.9261513352,
0.1412570626,
-0.3130783141,
0.8983546495,
-0.9774024487,
-0.5282300115,
-0.171470657,
0.0507449396,
-0.4091135263,
-0.0026444653,
0.2990685105,
-0.2027236819,
0.7812383771,
-0.0954430029,
-0.4046125412,
-0.1184692308,
0.1780996472,
-0.3419097364,
1.0903463364,
0.2890780568,
-0.4685544074,
0.7396241426,
-0.9000829458,
-0.4098764956,
-0.0945486501,
-0.1429778188,
-0.5093719363,
-0.1506371051,
0.5186110735,
0.5241000652,
-0.2032108158,
0.2536161244,
-0.2369963974,
-0.8153768778,
0.1295543462,
-0.381279856,
0.6230564117,
0.2551702261,
-0.5317848325,
0.1358820498,
-0.6677278876,
0.1307909936,
0.0657898188,
-0.4459424317,
0.0282793082,
-0.0580934733,
-0.0962085426,
-0.057168711,
-0.2069180608,
-0.4589779675,
0.2752782702,
-0.1552973986,
0.1108267158,
1.0561133623,
0.01055355,
0.4266196489,
-0.441159904,
0.9196905494,
-0.2119391412,
0.147138387,
-0.3035290837,
-0.4994696379,
-0.4472003877,
-0.2906434834,
0.4863096476,
0.4081943333,
-0.692686677,
-0.0967210233,
-0.4320058227,
-0.3695476353,
-0.4837709963,
0.0741090998,
0.363963753,
0.5760082603,
0.4338329434,
-0.3945799172,
-0.3738919795,
-0.254352659,
-0.5615442991,
-0.1882766634,
-0.1422623098,
0.3817787468,
0.1883403659,
0.3142907023,
0.9455069304,
-0.6173317432,
-0.1062800586,
-0.1780235022,
0.1575528979,
0.2876029909,
0.374214381,
0.7776287198,
-0.7219797969,
-0.7115288973,
-0.0242225546,
-0.1911568046,
-0.2833343744,
-0.5367197394,
-0.2850498855,
0.2251810431,
0.1285682321,
0.226935491,
0.3984885514,
0.7500311732,
-0.6206685305,
0.6864507198,
-0.2144185901,
0.3092469871,
-1.272280097,
-0.2970039845,
-0.1105132028,
-0.1431617886,
-0.5599814057,
-0.0565543398,
-0.0819000676,
-0.1482801735,
-0.2234725207,
0.6461699009,
-0.4151152968,
-0.0139773935,
-0.4002174735,
0.1196543723,
0.0599546544,
0.4381684661,
-0.071202524,
0.8224297762,
1.1456934214,
-0.6724526882,
0.1981279999,
0.2457530051,
-0.1648995876,
0.5867362618,
-0.3093342781,
0.3917935789,
-0.1649323106,
0.3566771448,
-0.9371801019,
-0.345872432,
0.2893119752,
-0.6378996372,
0.1388501376,
-0.5098587871,
-0.6514533162,
-0.2163103223,
-0.2651951313,
0.3740021586,
0.4634728432,
-1.0427389145,
0.8001597524,
-0.2255213708,
0.2142429352,
-0.6740711331,
-0.7413554788,
0.1162671372,
-0.1448155195,
-0.0912601501,
0.2282334268,
-0.1393054873,
0.1232321635,
0.1690630466,
-0.4118062556,
-0.4585891664,
0.4531644285,
0.5824919343,
0.2343455851,
-0.2434861958,
0.618352294,
0.0755848512,
-0.1730700731,
-0.1385604143,
-0.6319394708,
0.3597776294,
-0.1180075631,
-0.5706663132,
-0.2451826483,
0.1909199655,
0.3399819136,
-0.1737879962,
0.9948862195,
0.7478501797,
-0.3363447785,
-0.5588856936,
-0.3899362981,
-0.1890714318,
-0.4439179301,
0.2124300301,
-0.578258872,
-0.7312880754,
0.3468928635,
0.040017534,
0.1541983336,
0.1184987351,
0.4551421106,
0.4365648329,
0.881865859,
0.6796317697,
-0.1950080693,
0.6477203965,
0.0301564652,
0.1848219484,
-0.1804934591,
-0.2005231529,
-0.7163456678,
-0.1313906312,
-0.630361557,
-0.4639311731,
0.1497972906,
-0.1738035083,
-0.1713216305,
0.3057920039,
-0.8192096949,
0.9591906071,
0.5608329773,
0.123313196,
0.1512083113,
-0.0199525785,
-0.0720350146,
0.3676584065,
-0.694483757,
-0.4619269371,
1.1428209543,
-0.0444594026,
0.5808209777,
0.3290933371,
0.6687405109,
0.2103238255,
0.4421532452,
-0.646472156,
0.4094781578,
-0.4125587344,
-0.6931756139,
-0.1102229431,
-0.4661364257,
-1.0451973677,
0.253243953,
-0.0993774757,
-0.7908774018,
-0.0516444035,
0.0780147389,
-0.4238184988,
0.3889451921,
-1.2450433969,
1.0448684692,
-0.1112073511,
-0.3591382205,
-0.1781454086,
-0.3723255694,
-0.0733527094,
-0.3861657381,
0.1963553876,
-0.2030406296,
0.1763338,
0.6581023335,
-0.042907685,
0.9675397277,
-0.625849843,
0.2220907956,
0.4037875533,
0.1776269823,
0.1492197514,
0.030865116,
-0.3576280773,
-0.2442597449,
0.2464730144,
-0.8802691698,
-0.7670071125,
0.8038266301,
-0.6187340021,
-0.4136798978,
-0.4585210383,
-0.8579576015,
-0.389103353,
0.0249466132,
-0.2543998659,
0.3509009778,
0.235205844,
-0.0003282395,
0.1081770509,
-0.2866950631,
0.5558109283,
0.6445790529,
0.0223020464,
-0.0410449244,
1.0764763355,
-0.1718015075,
0.3447076678,
0.3726559877,
0.6621753573,
-0.2056512982,
-0.644618988,
-0.4503069222,
-0.1640752107,
-0.792773962,
0.0097680725,
-0.3356407881,
0.3227145374,
-0.5343094468,
-0.5727550387,
-0.0608680323,
-0.4774623811,
-0.4170570672,
-0.1396608055,
0.5490638614,
0.7078847289,
-0.0267456099,
0.4653907716,
-0.7069567442,
0.1842544526,
0.4565265477,
0.5576584339,
-0.0669011995,
-0.7143726945,
-0.1296387315,
-0.0368244834,
-0.0631837174,
-1.0287183523,
-0.0343419686,
0.5893409252,
0.486675173,
0.1812611073,
0.2263546437,
0.811834991,
-0.3694581687,
0.6977659464,
0.0926423445,
-1.1583458185,
0.5415505767,
0.0121182147,
0.6784068942,
0.5942741632,
0.2668338418,
-0.7524536848,
-0.4595339298,
-0.1728810221,
-0.4960000515,
0.9392416477,
-0.116215758,
0.177044183,
0.1286713034,
0.5008358955,
0.5883390903,
-0.1440019757,
-0.5916540623,
-0.1478087008,
-0.478790611,
-0.6845216155,
-0.1164420843,
-0.1804942936,
-0.0343170464,
0.0992647931,
0.4418449998,
-0.6170808077,
0.0391464941,
0.1164074242,
-0.2828125358,
0.2972873151,
0.4833455682,
0.4492005706,
0.6966897845,
0.0668739974,
0.4344066083,
0.5599322319,
-0.6622510552,
0.172337845,
0.4209057391,
0.134677887,
-0.0138379456,
0.4249973297,
0.6006028652,
0.2031728178,
-0.4967191815,
0.3729915321,
-0.2409035712,
-0.1943583339,
-0.0755769312,
0.3084958494,
-0.4605879784,
0.1989623755,
0.4025076032,
-0.0256704707,
-0.1228095144,
-0.3751930296,
0.366612941,
-0.0346292406,
-0.5696924925,
-0.4602415562,
0.67045331,
0.008009186,
-0.3020708263,
0.3297174275,
-0.4832763672,
-0.5824199915,
0.6598348618,
0.5784967542,
0.7839998603,
-0.4104142785,
0.6036365628,
0.2926378846,
-0.0599141754,
-0.0283850916,
0.2452906221,
-0.3670238853,
-0.9012183547,
-0.7470133901,
-0.1818567961,
-0.6159356236,
-0.4501510859,
-0.7281151414,
0.2229592651,
-0.4465280175,
0.1395850033,
0.1300755888,
-0.0811689869,
-0.7511062026,
-0.0322276391,
0.051190909,
0.5077425838,
-1.0951669216,
0.8951497674,
0.8739582896,
-0.1173712164,
-0.8861938715,
0.2685013413,
0.1190958098,
-0.8672220111,
0.3849875927,
0.3118599951,
-0.2662282586,
-0.071431838,
-0.3357019126,
-0.5620222092,
0.758168757,
0.4521884024,
-0.2664933503,
0.2624892294,
0.0551547706,
0.591508925,
-0.2779872417,
0.2780862749,
0.3591577113,
0.4583116174,
0.1785153151,
-0.9583641291,
0.1086204946,
0.2593978941,
-0.3388340175,
0.1700566113,
-0.3884443641,
0.3733062148,
-0.6705042124,
-0.4247011244,
-0.1825645864,
0.3193815947,
0.2325421572,
0.4923102558,
0.9188087583,
0.1106440499,
0.8786228299,
-0.1671167314,
0.9773157835,
-0.2471910715,
0.3775858879,
1.6716046333,
-0.2764422894,
0.3906919658,
0.2553709149,
-0.2045089304,
0.7108920217,
0.6482098699,
-0.3138807118,
0.5850177407,
0.2677644491,
-0.5298684239,
-0.2438019216,
-0.4882775545,
-0.1277270168,
0.6300529838,
0.0482822768,
-0.2029697001,
-0.4211818278,
0.3171801865,
-0.0580510311,
0.1771525443,
-0.1594323516,
0.4235784709,
-0.3290721476,
-0.6734209657,
0.4281818569,
-0.1278604269,
0.3766514361,
-0.2395711541,
-0.4012408257,
0.0780496672,
0.4302424192,
-0.2088748962,
-0.9612811208,
0.0022411293,
0.2090043575,
-0.1512352675,
-0.548630178,
0.5064074397,
-0.4596523046,
-0.4755511284,
0.2125784308,
0.2925316393,
0.3374129534,
0.1380896568,
-0.526855886,
-0.1572220176,
0.0839935765,
0.1268494278,
0.1663837582,
0.3564248979,
0.085143663,
0.6230303645,
0.5074753165,
-0.0081563778,
0.2825504541,
0.5177431703,
0.7375085354,
-0.3417590261,
-0.1626778096,
-0.7632328272,
0.2712814212,
0.2016750425,
-0.3722936809,
0.6709045768,
0.5112812519,
1.2675609589,
-0.0730595663,
0.6658075452,
0.0215823278,
0.4730775952,
-0.3961832523,
0.2602211237,
-0.3432065547,
0.0959934369,
-0.0599237457,
-0.7189065814,
-0.6054347754,
0.532122016,
-0.2344836593,
0.1751648784,
0.9580141902,
0.6136525869,
0.029429704,
0.2153731138,
0.1242887676,
-0.0856558233,
0.6403298974,
0.679718554,
0.5989493728,
-0.1219402701,
1.0180699825,
-0.3636938632,
-0.1835546792,
0.1286699623,
-0.8923701644,
-0.9374422431,
-0.622610271,
-0.6752806902,
-0.2513827085,
0.3776347041,
0.8611539006,
0.8688281178,
-1.0602140427,
-0.0571570843,
-0.1592234969,
0.4448449016,
-0.4381031096,
-0.2795970142,
0.4259248078,
-0.4459005296,
-0.9657247663,
0.4141258001,
-0.2324573249,
0.1371646225,
0.1020472646,
0.0596268512,
0.0526124313,
-0.3681549728,
0.284704715,
0.0652482435,
-0.4870636761,
-0.8245036006,
0.0080645569,
0.3573929369,
0.0100491121,
0.8302170038,
-0.9010831118,
0.8811023831,
0.2274748385,
0.8340777159,
0.4358693957,
-0.0025360496,
0.4670715928,
-0.9716219306,
0.0254203696,
0.2895934284,
0.0685710311,
0.2235812247,
-0.1765397936,
0.653919816,
0.1078489199,
-0.5436249375,
-0.9939225912,
0.1265648454,
-0.7836449146,
-0.4578545988,
1.2213089466,
-0.3188304603,
-0.0793190226,
-0.2225873917,
-0.0654324666,
0.4535494149,
-0.481071502,
1.0856853724,
1.0886353254,
0.0711029172,
-0.1841008663,
-0.7042890191,
0.0103300391,
0.5859816074,
-0.8802267909,
-0.0414355546,
0.3432773352,
0.375420928,
-0.0690080002,
0.2266266197,
0.1235537902,
0.3271574378,
-0.0968025699,
0.1588662863,
-0.0452791713,
-0.470466435,
-0.5923562646,
0.0451553576,
0.2341781408,
-0.9265787005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10757v1
|
How Contentious Terms About People and Cultures are Used in Linked Open Data
| 2023-11-13T18:25:20 | 2023-11-13T18:25:20 |
Andrei Nesterov, Laura Hollink, Jacco van Ossenbruggen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.1
|
Web resources in linked open data (LOD) are comprehensible to humans through
literal textual values attached to them, such as labels, notes, or comments.
Word choices in literals may not always be neutral. When outdated and
culturally stereotyping terminology is used in literals, they may appear as
offensive to users in interfaces and propagate stereotypes to algorithms
trained on them. We study how frequently and in which literals contentious
terms about people and cultures occur in LOD and whether there are attempts to
mark the usage of such terms. For our analysis, we reuse English and Dutch
terms from a knowledge graph that provides opinions of experts from the
cultural heritage domain about terms' contentiousness. We inspect occurrences
of these terms in four widely used datasets: Wikidata, The Getty Art &
Architecture Thesaurus, Princeton WordNet, and Open Dutch WordNet. Some terms
are ambiguous and contentious only in particular senses. Applying word sense
disambiguation, we generate a set of literals relevant to our analysis. We
found that outdated, derogatory, stereotyping terms frequently appear in
descriptive and labelling literals, such as preferred labels that are usually
displayed in interfaces and used for indexing. In some cases, LOD contributors
mark contentious terms with words and phrases in literals (implicit markers) or
properties linked to resources (explicit markers). However, such marking is
rare and non-consistent in all datasets. Our quantitative and qualitative
insights could be helpful in developing more systematic approaches to address
the propagation of stereotypes via LOD.
|
[
-0.5850051641,
-0.9992857575,
0.1445489228,
0.2073278576,
-0.5974431038,
0.0578770749,
-0.1763337702,
-0.9558359981,
0.450276345,
0.4148967862,
-0.1061096042,
-0.5962980986,
-0.6316179037,
0.281981498,
-0.2621341944,
1.1615326405,
-0.2470974475,
-0.1941608936,
-0.2442283481,
-0.8627619147,
-0.3418542743,
-0.5984933972,
-0.1752866358,
0.0884527937,
0.9370507598,
0.0986489952,
1.3105437756,
0.6562495828,
0.6871237159,
0.2066290528,
-0.4857801199,
-0.0409087017,
-0.7650417686,
0.3271098137,
-0.6288379431,
-0.1322502941,
-0.1992073208,
0.160556823,
0.290715754,
0.8904678226,
0.3538810313,
0.3864350021,
-0.2045517862,
0.6849873662,
-0.7220553756,
0.307923317,
-0.8294742703,
0.1751499474,
-0.6590821147,
-0.0602105856,
-0.0441306867,
-0.7818272114,
0.2616866231,
-0.826641798,
-0.0131985797,
0.0453994982,
0.8928207159,
0.0900271833,
-0.5858773589,
-0.5064297318,
-0.4590531588,
0.6565052867,
-0.1911730319,
0.3791015148,
0.3793820143,
0.1932879686,
-0.0252486039,
-0.4547216296,
-0.5535753369,
-0.027338298,
-0.0476672202,
-0.0909770206,
-0.2681629062,
-0.1727637053,
0.6381424069,
0.1931879669,
-0.2087456286,
0.1629083306,
-0.694984436,
-0.2953510284,
0.5870708823,
-0.0820845887,
0.2329075634,
-0.4346840084,
-0.4497873187,
-0.0523371808,
-1.0800485611,
-0.1654284745,
0.5470703244,
0.4794856012,
0.1662703902,
0.7511274219,
-0.1409499198,
0.479809165,
-0.1685895622,
0.1477687061,
0.4815759361,
-0.2139535844,
0.2621308863,
0.2248361856,
0.7725944519,
0.6780189872,
0.6929511428,
-0.3169487417,
0.0535764061,
0.2303360105,
0.1764425933,
-0.3330080509,
-0.109630689,
-0.014756443,
-0.1772028208,
-0.1364530027,
0.1562338471,
-0.7696457505,
-0.6883073449,
-0.0444073677,
0.1554296762,
-0.2306807041,
-0.2452472746,
0.0086326925,
-0.453384757,
-0.095068492,
0.3327243328,
-0.3707397878,
-0.1367355585,
0.5997335315,
0.6731391549,
-0.1298323274,
0.0318107083,
-0.1078690812,
0.2699140906,
-0.3815602064,
0.5292095542,
-0.5455629826,
-0.6869925857,
0.2379998416,
-0.0777958259,
0.4533240795,
-0.6300215125,
0.7814390659,
-0.7964789867,
0.2549750805,
-0.6889158487,
-0.2347604781,
-0.0171268862,
0.2942802608,
-0.9042887688,
1.0408796072,
0.0225897003,
-1.185377121,
0.6618269682,
-0.7087030411,
-0.392734766,
0.1510923654,
-0.2523716986,
0.0553094856,
-0.0269928183,
-0.2853480875,
0.0854673162,
-0.2708004713,
-0.0045071444,
-0.3434346616,
0.0274957083,
0.3504150808,
0.0260685105,
0.8464353681,
0.586905539,
-0.2016790658,
-0.189304471,
-0.5055153966,
-0.2001353055,
0.2121198028,
-0.394952476,
-1.0816261768,
0.166058585,
0.0006929499,
0.1890298426,
0.1880852878,
-0.5964906812,
0.0075212596,
-0.1249022558,
0.1201348752,
0.7441704869,
0.0135746766,
-0.0838876441,
-0.2791845798,
0.4832318127,
0.3761445582,
0.1144666672,
0.3058059514,
-0.8518516421,
-0.2540675402,
0.1907600909,
0.0761457086,
0.3522156477,
-0.8333210945,
0.1000749692,
-0.5442028046,
-0.5267022848,
-0.512614131,
0.0666153133,
0.3497337103,
0.6640444398,
0.4299138188,
-0.3929413557,
-0.2756071985,
-0.9782900214,
-0.6025200486,
-0.6721422672,
0.1671430022,
0.5790128708,
0.4722406268,
0.0837349892,
1.3171079159,
-0.536113143,
-0.2980650663,
0.5806393027,
0.6356853247,
0.0740485713,
0.0802478194,
0.6398735642,
-0.9787759781,
-0.4981371164,
0.0684283227,
-0.7047312856,
-0.1687404066,
0.228764534,
-0.2230757028,
0.2433880121,
0.3026179969,
-0.3023768365,
0.2267148793,
0.2287656665,
-0.4602507055,
0.550180614,
0.2894040644,
0.2029878497,
-0.8375600576,
-0.0097605968,
0.008674738,
0.1481713057,
-0.0962848291,
0.5176016688,
-0.2511739433,
0.1285001785,
-0.7434434295,
0.6379638314,
-0.2153383344,
0.195383057,
0.4145178199,
0.3839943707,
-0.0658956245,
-0.2227505445,
0.1245324612,
0.6153100729,
0.1337384433,
-0.3615669012,
0.6061434746,
0.4605026543,
-0.5167014003,
0.8220403194,
-0.4047468901,
0.2597433031,
-0.1148133278,
0.0413569435,
-0.6936618686,
-0.0347149894,
0.3565692604,
-0.1061897501,
-0.2777530253,
-0.1814346015,
-0.680380404,
-0.6124643683,
-0.3471256196,
0.8776949048,
0.1914366335,
-0.4229911864,
-0.0294866357,
0.6480551958,
0.1645019501,
-0.7214636207,
-0.7469496727,
0.1182202399,
-0.4105398357,
-0.945851922,
0.1359363496,
0.1294656098,
-0.7191832066,
0.1816826612,
-0.0280377269,
-0.329090029,
0.0225801356,
0.1792805046,
-0.0854142457,
-0.1895882934,
0.2944927812,
-0.3384701312,
0.4423391521,
0.3961482644,
0.0702692643,
0.0873195082,
-0.1368829459,
-0.3082399964,
0.3167206645,
0.4551989436,
0.707316041,
0.0506184064,
0.7892198563,
0.3954689205,
-0.2054468542,
0.1498908848,
-0.4988749027,
0.110119313,
-0.3849184811,
0.2869540751,
-0.2823675275,
-0.7615329623,
0.8444099426,
-0.0280035343,
0.26101017,
0.6016603708,
0.2653411925,
-0.352494061,
0.4788610935,
0.1592140943,
-0.0521562845,
0.200074777,
0.0786341801,
0.3115298748,
-0.4536954761,
-0.3299742937,
-0.9178375602,
-0.4113729596,
-0.9821993113,
-0.7332116365,
0.4307486415,
0.0249805953,
-0.235404402,
0.2063912749,
-0.2013998181,
0.4420544207,
0.1688413769,
0.0308579411,
0.7355099916,
0.1599221379,
-0.1483116895,
-0.2835662961,
-0.3368673325,
-0.4982981384,
0.9066830277,
0.2075133622,
0.9160784483,
0.2431402504,
0.4697847664,
0.675943315,
0.221949771,
-0.8588826656,
0.3930568695,
-0.1519147307,
-0.9936878085,
-0.1446214914,
-0.3633887768,
-0.9501915574,
-0.0094893426,
-0.1724207997,
-0.7425013185,
0.5691530704,
0.1584436893,
0.0040868097,
0.6641688347,
-0.5328017473,
0.5871532559,
-0.0675162748,
-0.5377117395,
-0.2074787021,
-0.7934367061,
0.3560731113,
-0.3633729517,
0.5915596485,
-0.0025426913,
0.1290539801,
0.8953679204,
-0.3507201076,
0.8645656109,
-0.0245948266,
-0.629694581,
0.4715663493,
0.3215979934,
0.3647951484,
-0.4575674534,
-0.3648133278,
0.7195119262,
0.2077036649,
-0.3919922113,
-0.2688141763,
0.522057116,
-0.8178917766,
-0.6203432083,
-0.4311009347,
-0.3929857016,
-0.1947008371,
0.0137191145,
0.0898003876,
0.1360291988,
-0.5085223317,
0.1579471976,
0.616737783,
-0.398183018,
-0.2277198732,
0.3039859235,
-0.2895697653,
0.0844674483,
0.9943445325,
0.3604243398,
0.4185153544,
-0.0359839387,
0.1272306591,
-0.2262603343,
-0.1497913897,
-0.180206731,
0.1994426399,
-0.8891932964,
-0.0229552649,
-0.4333700538,
-0.0981075764,
-0.2949140072,
-0.271112442,
-0.213470161,
-0.5610525012,
-0.0048470898,
-0.1396865845,
0.5802063942,
0.7648294568,
-0.0916131437,
-0.1255501211,
-0.5702565312,
0.3541660905,
0.0137525396,
0.4483571947,
-0.4727463722,
-0.1980499178,
-0.1038313434,
0.1519136727,
-0.1383865774,
-1.0102843046,
-0.2235093266,
-0.1969348341,
0.3281932175,
0.7852784991,
0.6069210172,
0.494053036,
-0.1430540681,
0.8143356442,
0.2063565105,
-0.5427334309,
0.4669908285,
-0.5591184497,
0.0124840355,
0.4019913971,
0.8748273253,
-1.0260885954,
-0.590942502,
-0.4487516284,
-1.0685728788,
0.4756009579,
-0.20952788,
0.3931357265,
-0.6280870438,
0.1256321669,
0.228132844,
0.208684355,
-0.7795311809,
-0.4060024023,
-0.3760100603,
0.3074831069,
0.5197971463,
-0.4274630547,
-0.6635804176,
-0.2175805718,
0.4335484207,
0.0185992252,
-0.122382164,
0.0162603445,
-0.2474681139,
-0.2421819121,
0.4192452133,
0.11077784,
0.8386334777,
-0.3642741144,
0.2027093917,
-0.1756462753,
-0.5375193954,
-0.1696200073,
-0.3146819472,
-0.3342647851,
0.1147756875,
0.0699703172,
0.5718298554,
0.1498129219,
-0.5113632679,
0.3890150487,
0.2311624438,
-0.0532872938,
-0.142706424,
-0.3026199937,
-0.0782593265,
-0.1317040026,
0.0229336079,
0.0285970066,
-0.2003868073,
-0.796010077,
-0.162206009,
0.378529191,
-0.4565380216,
-0.2205040008,
0.5669670701,
0.5267896056,
0.0860872716,
0.8217656612,
-0.0843669251,
-0.4039280117,
0.3450229466,
0.3140118718,
0.5054761171,
0.1747927368,
0.4689000249,
0.2784437239,
0.3234911263,
0.4110640287,
0.2398803383,
0.0067755608,
-1.0573960543,
-0.0543079898,
-0.6852235794,
-0.3436135948,
-0.1763738841,
-0.8100063801,
0.2789813578,
-0.4639666975,
-0.4564572573,
-0.0891936272,
-0.3144917786,
-0.7346199751,
-0.124288328,
0.211371094,
1.0431360006,
-0.9572393894,
0.5929935575,
0.8960058093,
-0.5965860486,
-0.3391233981,
0.0291301142,
0.4439860582,
-0.6925378442,
1.0973082781,
-0.3949288428,
-0.1683383584,
-0.3243562579,
-0.4126277268,
-0.6188111305,
0.5501040816,
0.3035773933,
-0.2008565664,
-0.0147286234,
0.3378192484,
0.6587805152,
0.2810733616,
0.1508236229,
0.447106272,
0.8821254373,
0.3734759986,
-1.0207058191,
0.2403027862,
-0.1390122324,
-0.247886911,
0.2060316205,
-0.6095235348,
0.6716005206,
-0.2397667468,
-0.4405786693,
-0.1570712775,
0.4089930654,
-0.0176089909,
0.0886261016,
0.5549021363,
0.49602741,
0.9021790028,
-0.341117382,
1.0323603153,
0.000926566,
0.15791592,
0.8621711135,
-0.4215129316,
0.5873730183,
0.6836583018,
-0.4349398911,
0.6347535849,
0.5505952835,
-0.0919197872,
0.2970673144,
0.4256623387,
-0.2788873315,
0.1931734979,
-0.7299355865,
-0.61615628,
0.5182133913,
0.4954556823,
-0.1896231771,
-0.5788106918,
-0.3115648627,
0.3859342933,
0.1660662442,
-0.2354005128,
0.618663013,
-0.1009028628,
-0.4183315337,
0.4028638005,
-0.0580236539,
0.5593438148,
-0.6600913405,
0.1412032396,
-0.2938438654,
-0.3748222589,
-0.4294914305,
-0.9465533495,
0.5032448173,
0.0178228337,
-0.1741767973,
-0.2738854587,
0.2998957038,
-0.197909832,
-0.1251847744,
0.4816984534,
0.6639997363,
0.496796459,
0.0165743325,
-0.4133945405,
0.0394837447,
-0.0790276676,
0.0165037625,
0.360016495,
0.7633727193,
-0.68700701,
0.3805045187,
0.5471391678,
0.4265179336,
0.2983344793,
0.0995045677,
0.971799314,
-0.6977365613,
-0.3319890797,
-0.408488214,
0.2300086468,
-0.0863526613,
-0.5240738392,
0.6525318027,
0.418623656,
1.179038763,
0.2245760709,
0.5773226023,
-0.3813958168,
0.3269799054,
-0.4296537936,
0.7995360494,
-0.4678352475,
0.2045463175,
-0.6537280083,
-0.8865123391,
-0.2472269535,
0.3718006909,
-0.4230525792,
0.0691220015,
0.7709869742,
0.4767924249,
0.0590225197,
0.2284244299,
0.1696768701,
0.7496161461,
0.3009632826,
-0.0615382232,
0.953502357,
0.0792729184,
0.4105125666,
-0.3655650616,
0.0651652515,
-0.1494079232,
-1.0067641735,
-0.429500401,
-0.7799957991,
-0.6447271109,
-0.6197651625,
0.2463216186,
0.8774084449,
0.323628664,
-0.811894536,
-0.2002404183,
0.5895907283,
0.4734633863,
0.1083064824,
-0.3732904792,
0.3972978294,
0.0191030186,
-0.7155480385,
-0.0781822056,
-0.0246876124,
-0.1348583698,
-0.3631862402,
0.1181861386,
-0.2402323037,
-0.0896211714,
0.7002812028,
0.6384969354,
-0.7468622923,
-0.6945549846,
-0.4562531114,
-0.149546966,
0.0170798041,
0.7706196904,
-0.8222488761,
0.7174554467,
0.6323317289,
0.3717831075,
-0.0586693138,
0.3535023928,
0.3613270521,
-0.9076435566,
0.2144065052,
0.3127349615,
0.266410321,
0.338216722,
-0.3879114091,
0.5570354462,
0.6463069916,
-0.1443216056,
-0.5878250003,
0.2271168083,
-0.8820029497,
-0.3514594138,
1.1593512297,
-0.2971910536,
-0.0282991379,
-0.4505811632,
-0.0076972167,
0.0499128662,
-0.4231470525,
1.1900645494,
0.9671902657,
-0.0128160687,
0.5063999295,
-0.5110577345,
0.4010549784,
0.1661270112,
-0.4099091291,
0.138492167,
0.8623514175,
0.199089393,
0.5068234205,
0.4276480079,
-0.5857011676,
0.0046301913,
-0.2632878423,
0.009779973,
0.0114219636,
-0.0805300474,
0.2558962107,
0.1178919226,
0.0863708928,
-0.0017384253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07536v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07536v2
|
A Comprehensive Evaluation of GPT-4V on Knowledge-Intensive Visual Question Answering
| 2023-11-13T18:22:32 | 2024-01-27T14:16:54 |
Yunxin Li, Longyue Wang, Baotian Hu, Xinyu Chen, Wanqi Zhong, Chenyang Lyu, Wei Wang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The emergence of multimodal large models (MLMs) has significantly advanced
the field of visual understanding, offering remarkable capabilities in the
realm of visual question answering (VQA). Yet, the true challenge lies in the
domain of knowledge-intensive VQA tasks, which necessitate not just recognition
of visual elements, but also a deep comprehension of the visual information in
conjunction with a vast repository of learned knowledge. To uncover such
capabilities of MLMs, particularly the newly introduced GPT-4V, we provide an
in-depth evaluation from three perspectives: 1) Commonsense Knowledge, which
assesses how well models can understand visual cues and connect to general
knowledge; 2) Fine-grained World Knowledge, which tests the model's skill in
reasoning out specific knowledge from images, showcasing their proficiency
across various specialized fields; 3) Comprehensive Knowledge with
Decision-making Rationales, which examines model's capability to provide
logical explanations for its inference, facilitating a deeper analysis from the
interpretability perspective. Extensive experiments indicate that GPT-4V
achieves SOTA performance on above three tasks. Interestingly, we find that: a)
GPT-4V demonstrates enhanced reasoning and explanation when using composite
images as few-shot; b) GPT-4V produces severe hallucinations when dealing with
world knowledge, highlighting the future need for advancements in this research
direction.
|
[
-0.5574166179,
-0.9950148463,
0.9934971929,
-0.0005499439,
-0.1994315535,
-0.1458285749,
0.0841915384,
-0.4340975583,
-0.5581667423,
0.4774870276,
-0.5888047218,
-0.3629438579,
-0.551780045,
0.0882480964,
-0.1857443899,
0.89023,
-0.2016772926,
0.240025118,
-0.5830138922,
-0.0086235506,
-0.7581226826,
-0.2756570578,
-0.3759816885,
0.0199378468,
0.4048541188,
0.2026628554,
0.5746250749,
0.2490601689,
0.8095631003,
0.3788737655,
0.1454447508,
0.0174259003,
-0.7389567494,
-0.1673744768,
-0.1657212675,
-0.4758511484,
-0.431001097,
0.0102819838,
0.6727734804,
0.2869680822,
0.1452397108,
0.3099727929,
0.0236370265,
0.4818480909,
-0.5641861558,
0.2408207059,
-0.6866471767,
0.1270541102,
0.0710719228,
-0.3514406979,
-0.1319064498,
-0.0168267321,
0.5682464242,
-0.9140483141,
0.1886863261,
-0.1976376027,
0.8831824064,
0.4613810778,
-0.5636775494,
0.0666784495,
-0.7169694304,
0.6393984556,
-0.1864636391,
0.2327550203,
0.0757261589,
0.9321622849,
0.2153295577,
-1.0155553818,
-0.7867187858,
0.0013616675,
0.3701203167,
0.496224463,
-0.2855859399,
0.1643477976,
0.604850769,
0.4299949706,
-0.7944218516,
-0.3006353378,
-0.6228007078,
-0.2978633344,
0.2971109152,
0.3016033769,
0.3843232393,
-0.2183737755,
-0.7579246163,
0.1970410943,
-0.4643611312,
0.1878409088,
0.1300983876,
-0.2940386534,
0.0940976366,
0.574227035,
-0.2484702617,
0.8256746531,
-0.2288734168,
-0.0622216426,
0.1512768418,
-0.7440060377,
-0.4744584262,
-0.5832316875,
0.5388898849,
0.878723979,
0.2277503163,
0.0806811303,
-0.138954699,
0.0686118379,
0.350782454,
-0.9843995571,
-0.1900366545,
0.0172414109,
-0.4999494553,
-0.0483275354,
-0.1177284643,
-0.8127632141,
-0.4555088282,
-0.3253507018,
0.9456765652,
-0.4272209108,
-0.2316404879,
0.1565804482,
-0.4792088568,
0.8128109574,
0.7437728047,
-0.5554349422,
0.079832539,
0.5580659509,
0.8182085156,
-0.1685055345,
-0.2909594178,
-0.4050069451,
0.0535598509,
-0.3463907838,
0.7239063382,
-0.6704345345,
0.0010039529,
-0.2677366138,
-0.1119597852,
0.0040030493,
-0.4638808668,
0.3204541504,
-0.727389276,
0.146952793,
-0.7863839269,
-0.3684670329,
-0.5807492137,
0.819011867,
-0.6100059152,
0.4856301248,
0.1984716207,
-0.6803368926,
0.5125839114,
-0.6278345585,
0.2031011432,
0.2988820076,
-0.4416996241,
-0.1093163043,
-0.0271748621,
0.4687121809,
0.6758496761,
-0.2943153679,
-0.0271134842,
-0.4046378732,
-0.443577528,
0.1760661304,
-0.5379523635,
0.3294695616,
0.1768842936,
-0.4035911262,
0.1576880664,
-0.5511412024,
-0.0211276282,
0.2831801176,
0.0675458834,
-0.0652144179,
-0.5700935125,
-0.2743789554,
0.4539907575,
0.2469935119,
-0.3751047552,
0.1823852807,
0.0487913527,
0.5182694197,
0.7321833968,
0.3071157038,
0.3521467149,
-0.0590537041,
0.8435670733,
0.1282162964,
0.5470430255,
-0.2544691265,
-0.8715801835,
-0.482414633,
-0.2188880444,
-0.0265372489,
0.4424501061,
-1.4892601967,
-0.5061038136,
-0.1429730803,
-0.3130327165,
-0.2595555186,
0.0799600258,
0.3930393755,
0.6205896735,
0.5552510023,
-0.3125942349,
-0.2998369932,
-1.0514377356,
-0.2716526985,
0.1466929168,
0.0804429725,
0.4831270278,
0.8622447848,
-0.3018553853,
0.5999757648,
-0.4607022405,
-0.1694941223,
-0.2770320773,
0.0008359381,
0.0079840599,
0.0672321543,
0.4869450033,
-0.8506078124,
-0.2260288596,
0.0269278716,
-0.9679761529,
0.3675819635,
-0.1391821504,
-0.1866895556,
-0.1663658768,
0.1900707185,
-0.6615211368,
0.438270241,
0.4320723414,
-0.2926923335,
0.7395303845,
-0.2340757251,
0.3845695853,
-0.5733830333,
-0.017217977,
0.1068436205,
-0.2232502103,
-0.7298615575,
0.0729103684,
0.1005106419,
-0.0197113175,
-0.3866130114,
0.3047654927,
-0.4390720129,
-0.5011609197,
-0.0014838398,
0.2098361254,
0.2500302196,
0.5080935359,
-0.0419581831,
0.7803997993,
0.6854515076,
-0.2772386372,
0.6937861443,
0.1828728169,
-0.4425813854,
0.5671953559,
-0.6216899157,
0.132926777,
-0.2367817014,
0.0598529838,
-1.1185468435,
-0.2920814157,
0.1501979381,
-0.4330610931,
0.1023998186,
-0.1826051921,
-0.2694819272,
-0.5032702088,
-0.1816529632,
0.5755992532,
0.3678994477,
-0.3804478049,
0.8066590428,
0.1591086239,
-0.1057008207,
-0.7469121218,
-0.6110332608,
0.1682868004,
-0.3509278893,
-0.7404332161,
-0.1212564856,
-0.0346650667,
-0.1869747341,
-0.0675965101,
-0.1952492893,
-0.2514946163,
-0.0299540106,
-0.0317304544,
0.482776314,
-0.2881721556,
0.0030187678,
-0.3379369676,
-0.0677926466,
0.2824491262,
-0.3233700693,
0.1367018819,
-0.6809978485,
-0.3926705122,
-0.3341871202,
0.1157068312,
0.5665384531,
-0.4265744686,
0.2290488034,
0.9961451292,
-0.2286667973,
0.014940015,
-0.6833125949,
-0.0827749968,
-0.4013594389,
0.7081931829,
-0.640091598,
-0.9072096944,
0.3680083156,
0.1275967062,
-0.1731430441,
0.5186693072,
0.7612572312,
-0.15850012,
0.9070766568,
0.4083099961,
0.4133163095,
0.1881747991,
-0.5661117435,
0.0451623313,
-0.6228970885,
-0.5910252929,
0.1500686556,
-0.2245800346,
-0.3957248926,
-0.8367369771,
0.5791021585,
-0.189738214,
-0.3923167586,
-0.2908252478,
-0.3856280148,
0.5472477078,
0.3652362227,
0.2325956076,
0.4353669584,
-0.1759039164,
0.1496005058,
0.0236294493,
-0.6932172179,
-0.4787051976,
1.2338324785,
0.5152385235,
0.5996397734,
0.1533555388,
0.1525316238,
-0.0873269215,
0.1660134643,
-0.7494413257,
0.5187592506,
0.1117686555,
-0.7262558937,
-0.330082953,
-0.504357934,
-0.6755946279,
0.4669961631,
-0.2721863687,
-0.3624345362,
-0.0087522715,
0.3587131798,
-0.6852827668,
0.2195646018,
-0.8719566464,
1.3426804543,
-0.4663826823,
-0.6063947678,
-0.1607401818,
-0.7762828469,
0.8936375976,
0.0065537551,
-0.010287418,
0.1694633216,
-0.2640858293,
0.5866834521,
0.0038058881,
0.5435720086,
-0.4724092782,
0.0815407187,
0.3620032668,
-0.1253932118,
0.2735454142,
0.0904431343,
0.5286463499,
0.1899288446,
0.1749864072,
-0.4524362087,
-1.0051715374,
0.5290906429,
-0.8266271949,
-0.6762555838,
-0.2836298943,
-0.6378804445,
-0.3973963559,
0.1477628201,
0.1352834255,
0.5689060092,
-0.1031433418,
0.2130674422,
0.8451333046,
-0.4560663402,
0.0506567508,
0.1349523216,
-0.3721798956,
-0.4291913509,
0.9867734313,
0.0946129933,
0.413023591,
0.1820853204,
0.1504666656,
-0.4834461212,
-0.756278336,
-0.6860430241,
0.116492942,
-0.9793884158,
0.0238134246,
-0.7166540623,
-0.0696227103,
0.0111357756,
0.2371672094,
-0.1498341113,
-0.2344515026,
-0.0922780186,
-0.1650569588,
0.0706749707,
0.9500299096,
0.3272367418,
-0.0572339147,
-0.7018579841,
0.5454836488,
0.984054625,
0.2658971846,
-0.1876782477,
-0.5369573236,
-0.1275567412,
-0.1484543532,
-0.4775722027,
-0.8509480357,
-0.0148117691,
-0.0694365427,
0.6205725074,
0.5117117763,
-0.4186561704,
0.9960711598,
-0.4787939191,
1.0362508297,
0.2965933084,
-0.7699813247,
0.2483833879,
-0.5667423606,
0.3272095621,
0.3520829678,
0.5275914669,
-0.1019901931,
0.0497420654,
-0.6519737244,
-0.5747561455,
0.3495515585,
0.3440835774,
0.0988081098,
0.3636923134,
0.3458637893,
0.1889416724,
0.373716116,
-0.6918964982,
0.0929403156,
-0.7120099068,
0.2020885795,
-0.0633424148,
-0.3796243966,
-0.2038457245,
-0.3929683268,
0.2991448045,
-0.1266827881,
0.3745678365,
0.2581987381,
-0.1869211942,
0.2621434331,
0.2646131516,
0.6236630678,
0.9997548461,
-0.1501532942,
0.3020424247,
0.3883635104,
-0.3822654784,
-0.1290029883,
0.0603665374,
0.168022573,
-0.3863855302,
0.533477366,
0.9960255027,
-0.0942656323,
-0.6328752041,
0.9902964234,
-0.2936723232,
-0.5109995008,
-0.1366794407,
0.0177212656,
0.063004978,
0.5760226846,
0.2345708758,
0.2406350076,
0.5352293849,
-0.6549407244,
0.1023884863,
0.5582992435,
-0.3540014327,
-0.3996300995,
0.6185230017,
0.1750123501,
0.5073276758,
0.4627565444,
-0.1021545678,
-0.6121996641,
0.6034728289,
0.2305413485,
0.5156326294,
-0.0635457635,
0.1761999875,
0.3708664775,
0.5061129928,
0.0020801683,
0.5794551373,
-0.2569896579,
-0.8088895679,
-0.6790633798,
-0.2664976418,
-0.3823145628,
0.3666763008,
-0.6897547245,
-0.1065375432,
-0.3581707776,
-0.1092147604,
-0.0963288099,
-0.097367838,
-1.0870798826,
0.3498262465,
0.2393874377,
0.7285109162,
-0.7863395214,
0.445618391,
0.5948220491,
-0.5956639051,
-0.697126925,
-0.0276543777,
0.015923392,
-1.0406506062,
0.7643936872,
0.3886198699,
-0.0136308447,
0.1628117114,
-0.7157104611,
-0.7221974134,
1.2987947464,
0.3515400589,
-0.4226903319,
0.0561153255,
-0.0547242463,
0.5204082727,
-0.1340069473,
0.5974422097,
0.7483083606,
0.6750757694,
0.4197682738,
-0.7203601599,
0.0834598765,
-0.2698343694,
0.1285439134,
-0.2107529044,
-0.4031354487,
0.5982723832,
-0.4404734075,
-0.0405607559,
-0.0168341957,
0.482555002,
0.2342285812,
0.4477143884,
0.5459125042,
0.423784256,
0.6667272449,
-0.191864863,
1.1728487015,
0.1534166038,
0.1699625701,
0.8347917795,
-0.0844589397,
0.5500921607,
0.4417086542,
-0.1489842981,
0.2242651284,
0.6080349088,
-0.1586249322,
0.5012986064,
0.0322760008,
-0.1945521683,
-0.5996875167,
0.1937160343,
-0.488709271,
0.6176479459,
0.1786474884,
-0.1366604865,
-0.1704648435,
0.2460643053,
-0.4465575516,
-0.3512912989,
-0.6066204309,
0.837151289,
0.0417946093,
-0.624501884,
0.5849381089,
-0.4113617837,
0.1824175864,
-0.4929434657,
-0.2517174482,
0.0833193734,
0.0393899716,
-0.1619535238,
-1.0498876572,
0.178350389,
0.1135507226,
-0.0590189807,
-0.1909336746,
0.730152607,
-0.2605161369,
-0.2475276589,
0.0319875404,
0.7158532143,
0.3859449029,
-0.4811722338,
-0.8088917732,
-0.0332126953,
-0.0298747532,
-0.2638096213,
0.1749170274,
0.718572557,
-0.0398311727,
0.6705985665,
0.5002249479,
-0.2515306473,
0.0806520134,
0.2155010551,
0.9414689541,
-0.6298573613,
-0.2940945327,
-0.8550294638,
0.6719782948,
-0.2143556476,
-0.1133255213,
0.8857771158,
0.4489864111,
0.6802496314,
-0.2063082755,
1.0802628994,
0.3061751425,
-0.1939601898,
-0.6830482483,
0.3984161317,
-0.7337533236,
0.0723897219,
-0.5229408741,
-0.8827936053,
-0.3443805873,
0.51851964,
-0.8054592013,
0.2372234166,
0.7989484072,
0.6242587566,
0.0339007378,
0.1428231746,
0.7966294885,
0.3934250176,
0.2067633271,
0.6834781766,
1.4249643087,
-0.1279601157,
0.8985369802,
0.010888203,
-0.4441800117,
0.0338235795,
-0.7082880139,
-0.9428750873,
-0.4983310401,
0.0399285294,
-0.199333474,
-0.0869843066,
0.3305417895,
0.5087051392,
-0.3138907254,
0.2914310992,
0.0472679101,
-0.1799594909,
-0.2406757176,
-0.1617075354,
0.3050035536,
-0.1638572365,
-0.4508077204,
0.1220211163,
0.6331076622,
-0.111190401,
-0.4148998559,
-0.0665306598,
0.1189409792,
-0.1851491183,
0.9117408991,
-0.1529269964,
-0.8054289818,
-0.2701191008,
0.1221834719,
0.1462943554,
0.1821037829,
0.7338854671,
-0.6287392974,
0.9268991947,
0.6728732586,
0.83050102,
0.7908132076,
0.2529325485,
0.5737431049,
-0.2119303942,
-0.2590085566,
0.2500523925,
0.5253317356,
0.3667235672,
-0.2918149531,
0.3228981793,
0.3622170389,
-0.668500185,
-0.4752787948,
0.3415079713,
-1.1335729361,
-0.2412157357,
1.1809417009,
-0.2141220123,
-0.1424378753,
-0.2914545834,
-0.4225070477,
0.0411118865,
-0.065855056,
0.3804993331,
0.6206917763,
-0.1835646778,
-0.5445327759,
-1.2276548147,
0.4802007675,
0.1543911248,
-0.8973031044,
-0.2785716057,
0.6850290298,
0.4932567477,
-0.1341543943,
0.7120956182,
-0.1761124283,
0.5868022442,
-0.0735449865,
0.0834982246,
-0.3453737497,
-0.3262673914,
-0.4364809096,
0.3737624884,
-0.0313107967,
-0.2570299208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07532v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07532v3
|
It's Not Easy Being Wrong: Large Language Models Struggle with Process of Elimination Reasoning
| 2023-11-13T18:18:22 | 2024-06-07T23:01:20 |
Nishant Balepur, Shramay Palta, Rachel Rudinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain-of-thought (COT) prompting can help large language models (LLMs) reason
toward correct answers, but its efficacy in reasoning toward incorrect answers
is unexplored. This process of elimination (PoE), when used with COT, can
enhance self-consistency, interpretability, and tasks such as medical diagnoses
of exclusion. Thus, we propose PoE with COT, where LLMs must reason toward
incorrect options on multiple-choice questions. We evaluate the ability of
GPT-3.5, LLaMA-2, and Falcon to perform PoE with COT on a total of four
commonsense and scientific reasoning datasets. We find that the strategy of PoE
always underperforms the strategy of choosing the correct answer. The agreement
of these strategies is also lower than the self-consistency of each strategy.
To study these issues further, we conduct error analyses and give suggestions
for future work.
|
[
-0.2622301877,
-1.0690170527,
1.041467905,
0.2715481818,
-0.0752049536,
0.3685749173,
-0.3340457976,
-0.4200939238,
0.1079554036,
0.3564028442,
-0.3645323813,
-0.2228530347,
-0.8406653404,
0.4289399683,
-0.3490884006,
0.9179036617,
-0.4011291862,
-0.2146548331,
-0.0574108325,
-0.1918000877,
-0.4567316473,
-0.5390777588,
-0.7408561707,
-0.4325054288,
0.6866987944,
0.5830328465,
0.7463620901,
0.677285552,
0.6316087842,
0.2447730154,
-0.1557297856,
0.487200141,
-0.5134469271,
0.0435564257,
-0.5940436125,
-0.3763419092,
-0.3868923187,
-0.1601388305,
0.4728887677,
0.5684809685,
-0.3468732834,
0.0970795751,
-0.0640442371,
0.7653478384,
-0.6157726645,
-0.2425217628,
-0.8789997697,
0.0195230935,
-0.0464424156,
-0.1287734061,
-0.6159856915,
-0.0259791743,
-0.0844753161,
-0.496247679,
0.323002547,
0.4097310305,
0.7968096137,
0.364077121,
-0.3614504337,
-0.457898587,
-0.8258650303,
0.7766619325,
-0.3603428304,
0.0570809692,
0.5026810169,
0.064082332,
-0.2967304885,
-0.4879384935,
-0.7591784,
0.0348300636,
0.0710076094,
-0.0028300046,
-0.2608886063,
0.3265397251,
0.5328660607,
-0.1228363141,
-0.5090632439,
0.0959820375,
-0.7792075872,
-0.1919430196,
0.5242709517,
0.0902371332,
0.3816373348,
-0.2426507175,
-0.4009833038,
0.3688040972,
-0.8280950189,
-0.1392198801,
0.2290571779,
0.2414426059,
0.2350304127,
0.7908695936,
-0.0244551692,
0.5744315982,
0.0901500806,
0.0530317463,
0.1699855775,
-0.1612559706,
-0.4786094427,
0.0277917851,
0.7081791759,
0.1585599035,
0.0508499518,
-0.0823168904,
-0.2749778032,
0.0935921296,
0.4420317709,
-0.0934201255,
0.0216162242,
0.7179102302,
-0.3224034011,
-0.2419228405,
-0.4475061595,
-0.4332815409,
-0.2309008092,
-0.1528939754,
0.5990135074,
-0.14303644,
-0.2913769484,
0.2241921127,
-0.2614385784,
0.1875704378,
0.5368412733,
-0.624428153,
0.479537636,
0.7580981255,
0.8247435093,
-0.120708093,
-0.358553946,
-0.7933898568,
0.0286143105,
-0.770775497,
0.727065742,
-0.5096997619,
-0.4795878828,
-0.4915805757,
0.038944263,
-0.4037060738,
-0.550521493,
0.6247875094,
-0.2395765632,
-0.0592140816,
-0.816321373,
-0.6103414297,
-0.044362925,
0.3360364139,
-0.5817528963,
0.7788388133,
-0.2524803281,
-0.5073196292,
0.0793473199,
-0.7925745249,
-0.192857787,
-0.1738641113,
-0.2548936009,
-0.2339887619,
-0.0142086959,
0.2329658419,
0.2040534168,
-0.2507988214,
0.584782362,
-0.4271502495,
-0.476564914,
0.030887153,
-0.593913734,
0.8232885599,
0.5408802629,
-0.5629299283,
-0.1531615108,
-0.4331760108,
-0.0258892607,
0.1956490129,
0.0535938852,
-0.0921566486,
0.1762881577,
-0.5282785296,
0.4175055623,
-0.0268379729,
-0.7140934467,
0.3633235395,
-0.1616756469,
0.4522674978,
0.8689966202,
-0.0491855517,
0.2317261696,
-0.4396632016,
0.4751205742,
-0.0089035584,
0.2135492116,
0.2661469579,
-0.8403118253,
-0.7142279744,
-0.0703072697,
-0.1123116985,
0.5829947591,
-0.7622328997,
0.0663656443,
0.1269320995,
-0.4922230244,
-0.4984214902,
0.2739356756,
0.5270988345,
0.9140415788,
0.5217230916,
0.0880680904,
-0.5700356364,
-0.7871903777,
-0.2092425674,
-0.3802514672,
0.4251457155,
0.0302840881,
0.66480124,
-0.2417971939,
0.7787752748,
-0.4119664133,
0.1678799838,
-0.23161529,
0.2276961207,
0.1875885129,
0.3554240167,
0.0510197021,
-0.537247479,
-0.1366163343,
-0.0400158353,
-0.8934009075,
0.0000400103,
0.0669934526,
-0.1797110289,
0.3665394187,
0.290227592,
-0.7598806024,
0.6262503266,
0.2102304995,
-0.0361588374,
0.8128675818,
-0.4100011885,
0.1955849826,
-0.5501355529,
0.2414775491,
-0.0880520716,
-0.1392139643,
-0.5851982236,
0.0833029896,
0.0164764877,
-0.0536184721,
-0.4390452802,
0.4522483349,
-0.2355342954,
0.1003079563,
-0.2168213725,
0.1902407259,
0.3099302351,
0.4143693745,
0.3213931918,
0.6828209758,
0.2846210003,
-0.5545861125,
0.3121727705,
0.1132722944,
-0.0620545782,
0.3394916654,
-0.8153795004,
0.1982435733,
-0.5380527377,
0.5011711717,
-1.1263278723,
-0.1556851268,
0.4016097486,
-0.227847755,
-0.155422166,
0.137003541,
-0.2203626186,
-0.7293488979,
-0.0799406469,
0.4852589667,
0.3586673141,
-0.64907372,
0.2880186141,
0.0306264441,
-0.1006868705,
-1.26952672,
-0.6689150929,
0.1379155666,
-0.1875233799,
-0.2442131937,
-0.0930960178,
-0.119941324,
-0.4400954545,
-0.0637378469,
-0.2450801879,
-0.0910068676,
-0.1468002796,
0.0797179714,
0.2945897579,
0.0148198865,
0.7678519487,
-0.0590970367,
-0.170686096,
0.0040498683,
0.0622563399,
0.4275868237,
-0.3793599308,
-0.6743037105,
-0.2667304575,
0.4565962851,
0.600659132,
-0.117612794,
0.5043879747,
0.2636675835,
-0.4829573631,
-0.149166286,
-0.6754117608,
0.1316332221,
-0.4302929044,
-0.0265516341,
-0.4452253878,
-0.3986241519,
0.5864740014,
0.0833663344,
0.1102586389,
0.612511754,
0.3319929242,
-0.3758993745,
1.164619565,
0.0710015371,
0.2687404156,
-0.3261380196,
-0.4299197495,
0.5834604502,
-1.0526183844,
-0.0601556115,
-0.5681983829,
-0.2095805258,
-0.4910830855,
-0.4403791726,
0.422878772,
0.038866967,
-0.5504256487,
0.2010899782,
-0.7217056751,
0.7721589804,
0.3225821555,
0.3932811916,
0.4083830118,
-0.3728803098,
-0.1449736804,
0.4202751815,
-0.750875473,
-0.7249830961,
1.2085276842,
0.473564297,
0.7077735662,
0.0244417898,
0.9469528794,
-0.0371550247,
0.2572851181,
-0.621465683,
0.3294192255,
-0.2121107131,
-0.8529821038,
-0.4784561694,
-0.2702355683,
-0.8440022469,
0.1655088663,
0.028400328,
-0.85863024,
0.314807117,
0.3981105983,
-0.7086082697,
0.6812750697,
-0.9430139065,
0.5861076117,
-0.1799621135,
-0.43339625,
-0.1341878623,
-0.8158522844,
0.558057785,
-0.1621416062,
0.3285182714,
-0.1856749207,
-0.0776005387,
0.6691302061,
-0.6757962704,
0.7201423645,
-0.1314150691,
-0.2244881243,
0.7244316936,
0.1631257236,
0.7429722548,
-0.0622226782,
-0.3432132006,
0.2172210515,
0.1095522419,
-0.5318521857,
-0.7170799375,
0.6317756772,
-0.793653667,
-0.9172005653,
-0.4969985187,
-0.1450753063,
-0.2029173225,
-0.0313907005,
0.5538704991,
0.4296526909,
0.1586463004,
-0.1557980329,
0.6810667515,
-0.1185213178,
0.6036417484,
0.2243164927,
-0.3062302768,
-0.3030044734,
0.9056345224,
0.4897134602,
0.5822139978,
0.0142075624,
0.3732172251,
-0.510216713,
-0.3466939926,
-0.462536335,
0.2739320993,
-0.9705893397,
-0.0834964141,
-0.8469231725,
-0.3978102803,
-0.0132231852,
-0.3340431452,
-0.3372786939,
-0.3519538641,
-0.0738680437,
-0.3272381723,
0.0025491356,
0.7388813496,
-0.2862188518,
0.0162133239,
-0.5321298838,
0.6010517478,
0.4195314646,
0.3327625692,
0.0699739605,
-0.001275614,
0.3248901069,
0.2420547009,
-0.4261442423,
-0.8887172937,
0.0707320049,
-0.1336689591,
0.526997745,
0.1676028073,
0.0951377079,
0.8705397248,
-0.280512929,
0.8669509292,
0.2692690194,
-1.1315331459,
0.7726083398,
-0.3195338547,
0.1442336142,
0.4368359447,
0.4995948672,
-0.5450811386,
-0.5916403532,
-1.0276689529,
-0.6281985641,
0.3928831518,
0.1961689293,
-0.2791731656,
-0.5028909445,
0.3193018734,
0.3101267815,
0.0738049299,
-0.6817566752,
-0.0113428663,
0.0314082839,
-0.0706189424,
-0.0949762091,
-0.0437719189,
-0.3172601461,
-0.3342779875,
0.7398448586,
-0.1246507168,
0.3863201141,
0.7441074848,
-0.0169953573,
-0.5056869388,
0.3290969729,
0.7341855764,
0.9830176234,
0.0491343811,
0.2654001713,
0.3698170185,
-0.1332998723,
0.48535043,
-0.6498497128,
0.0230594315,
-0.1213612184,
0.4828194976,
0.5207445621,
-0.2577899098,
-0.6928250194,
0.5546799302,
0.0686427355,
-0.2885982394,
-0.14731583,
0.1963478774,
-0.1108648255,
-0.1022484303,
0.1964442432,
0.4544498324,
0.0921968669,
-0.4439203143,
0.1924791932,
0.399256736,
-0.2062740177,
0.0058477558,
0.4451522827,
0.2470008582,
-0.3785733283,
0.7588903308,
-0.2845621109,
-0.3952914178,
0.9733954072,
0.6929059029,
0.6110544205,
-0.0478184707,
0.4745314717,
0.413905859,
0.4879810214,
-0.326777637,
0.3700132668,
0.0928873345,
-0.8851342201,
-0.7558547258,
-0.1968289763,
-0.6348057389,
0.1968365014,
-0.4636639357,
0.3533919454,
-0.6319182515,
-0.10851188,
0.0729836076,
-0.1221213713,
-0.6820572019,
0.3411191404,
-0.0591987409,
0.8807988167,
-0.8763450384,
0.618567884,
0.212992847,
-0.4583537281,
-1.1632174253,
-0.15597184,
0.213816613,
-1.0352259874,
0.5960071087,
0.065388687,
-0.3724140823,
-0.1786033511,
-0.8431540132,
-0.8003104329,
0.6362372041,
0.3464881778,
-0.8501247168,
0.0142875332,
-0.1325409859,
0.4955144823,
-0.263120532,
0.4364430904,
0.5262716413,
0.5306162238,
0.2886296511,
-1.2498060465,
-0.0950890556,
-0.1024676263,
-0.3531318307,
0.3013958335,
-0.8266022801,
0.8051494956,
-0.7769001722,
-0.0716981217,
-0.0969499424,
0.0496235453,
0.4385069311,
0.5960637927,
0.5415068269,
0.6003211141,
1.2025059462,
-0.1233646572,
0.847597003,
0.0668382719,
0.4436828792,
1.1460285187,
-0.5364251137,
1.0121680498,
0.6991815567,
-0.0250639748,
0.6228164434,
0.6072708368,
0.4099253714,
0.1891420931,
0.1568803638,
-0.2824401855,
-0.4087478518,
0.2222394198,
-0.2272143364,
0.6808904409,
0.4984270334,
-0.290504694,
-0.2201619595,
0.1296869218,
-0.0009009289,
0.0785195753,
-0.2010695338,
0.6330587268,
-0.0073754466,
-0.9782280326,
0.8038369417,
-0.3125686944,
0.1424526274,
-0.3897715509,
-0.102279529,
0.0538057424,
-0.2168455273,
-0.393129319,
-0.9268631935,
0.5418881774,
0.1237442866,
-0.1125971898,
-0.2035961598,
0.6581715345,
-0.2058437318,
-0.3788523972,
0.1798403114,
0.6491006017,
0.2165815234,
0.2432549894,
-0.5859490037,
0.2291435301,
-0.1239597872,
-0.0647483617,
-0.2997615337,
0.1681767702,
-0.1753082424,
1.0366624594,
0.5029928684,
0.2344022989,
-0.1754273921,
-0.08079914,
0.462359786,
-0.673108995,
-0.2249267846,
-0.9214765429,
0.5329474807,
-0.2536190152,
-0.2319822311,
0.2156727761,
0.3277273774,
0.4456914961,
0.1499800682,
0.9615237117,
0.0025880677,
0.4467547834,
-0.4775513113,
0.2262256593,
-0.3830367327,
0.4907799959,
-0.324637413,
-0.8098766804,
-0.2653369904,
0.5047291517,
-0.5557144284,
0.0264772121,
1.2440690994,
0.7720655799,
0.1871228367,
0.4051064253,
0.1740545779,
0.3106318116,
0.6102486849,
0.8253476024,
0.8580716252,
-0.3501627147,
0.3367467523,
-0.2315645218,
-0.3805817068,
0.0057138423,
-1.0106253624,
-0.3181668222,
-0.5127530694,
-0.3521698415,
-0.4464810491,
0.3441736996,
1.2997584343,
0.4427779615,
-0.5685247779,
-0.0137418834,
-0.4419588745,
0.6393095851,
-0.551327765,
-0.135144949,
0.384170413,
-0.6443006396,
-0.4256053567,
0.3406953812,
0.4501404762,
-0.165255338,
-0.0196375456,
-0.0893307924,
-0.2910866737,
0.3041680753,
0.4659585059,
0.489590615,
-1.1029655933,
-0.839879632,
0.0264698695,
-0.1210277453,
0.222440809,
0.6245398521,
-0.5709197521,
0.7321549058,
0.4316599369,
0.4038028717,
0.0896064416,
0.1101076677,
0.5929614305,
-0.4624836445,
-0.3270074129,
0.2312087566,
0.4442864656,
0.0611137599,
-0.544400394,
0.6346453428,
0.2462690622,
-0.8000569344,
-0.8162945509,
0.1425425112,
-0.8286610842,
-0.332149148,
1.3044595718,
0.1122357771,
-0.424413085,
-0.3499792218,
-0.5813196301,
0.0231504701,
0.0015105209,
0.8736054897,
1.0991003513,
-0.6356973052,
0.050929714,
-0.4099498391,
0.3751421273,
0.4661065042,
-0.6187227368,
0.1584749967,
0.2169662416,
0.3423160613,
0.2859688699,
1.0755110979,
-0.0364244878,
0.4967183173,
0.0431313291,
-0.2924006879,
0.170014739,
-0.5670592785,
-0.3660933673,
0.2724247575,
0.2881886959,
-0.113953799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07509v1
|
A Benchmark to Understand the Role of Knowledge Graphs on Large Language Model's Accuracy for Question Answering on Enterprise SQL Databases
| 2023-11-13T17:54:50 | 2023-11-13T17:54:50 |
Juan Sequeda, Dean Allemang, Bryon Jacob
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Enterprise applications of Large Language Models (LLMs) hold promise for
question answering on enterprise SQL databases. However, the extent to which
LLMs can accurately respond to enterprise questions in such databases remains
unclear, given the absence of suitable Text-to-SQL benchmarks tailored to
enterprise settings. Additionally, the potential of Knowledge Graphs (KGs) to
enhance LLM-based question answering by providing business context is not well
understood. This study aims to evaluate the accuracy of LLM-powered question
answering systems in the context of enterprise questions and SQL databases,
while also exploring the role of knowledge graphs in improving accuracy. To
achieve this, we introduce a benchmark comprising an enterprise SQL schema in
the insurance domain, a range of enterprise queries encompassing reporting to
metrics, and a contextual layer incorporating an ontology and mappings that
define a knowledge graph. Our primary finding reveals that question answering
using GPT-4, with zero-shot prompts directly on SQL databases, achieves an
accuracy of 16%. Notably, this accuracy increases to 54% when questions are
posed over a Knowledge Graph representation of the enterprise SQL database.
Therefore, investing in Knowledge Graph provides higher accuracy for LLM
powered question answering systems.
|
[
-0.2630085945,
-0.8630874157,
0.9585555792,
-0.0620102957,
0.014427104,
0.1496709287,
0.1230140775,
-0.5502843857,
0.0561840422,
0.6887915134,
-0.5699260235,
-0.7173431516,
-0.2355858237,
0.2101339698,
-0.1393034905,
0.5338105559,
-0.0074574887,
0.0305357184,
-0.6704957485,
-0.3311749101,
-0.4844331145,
-0.6528298855,
-0.6572993994,
-0.29053545,
0.5720162988,
0.2053574473,
0.5646157265,
0.4970476925,
0.531735003,
0.1847729087,
-0.040624734,
0.0884127915,
-0.257367909,
0.2814474106,
-0.0816479772,
-0.6039818525,
-0.6866965294,
-0.2762297988,
0.4349337816,
0.8423548341,
-0.3270092309,
0.1468642056,
-0.0141931251,
0.6391863227,
-0.415230453,
0.3770722151,
-0.7209941149,
-0.1768431813,
-0.1029176861,
-0.2432504296,
-0.3632133007,
-0.545371294,
0.0912424251,
-0.5480273962,
-0.0657353103,
0.4657839835,
0.9356443882,
0.1735155135,
-0.5897978544,
-0.1594009697,
-0.3985387683,
0.408026278,
-0.6443049908,
0.3643038273,
0.08190348,
0.5853191614,
-0.019288158,
-0.8174496293,
-0.4513288438,
0.1895975173,
-0.2305627167,
0.1186412126,
-0.3804703653,
0.1894970983,
0.4914167821,
0.0046463944,
-0.6172250509,
0.3074783087,
-0.0958272666,
-0.1586142331,
0.3451197743,
0.5233493447,
0.0867483616,
0.0554922447,
-0.1285535246,
-0.0398440771,
-0.9322924018,
-0.0404547304,
-0.0702689737,
0.057787694,
0.4390551746,
0.6569085121,
-0.4339664876,
1.1884777546,
-0.2179943621,
-0.0537036173,
0.2382614315,
-0.0530327484,
-0.4281990528,
0.0962435007,
0.5287485719,
0.7620244622,
0.40031299,
-0.5446303487,
0.1023326218,
-0.2960679531,
0.1101981923,
-0.9074805975,
0.0612387136,
0.3709705472,
0.0318347961,
-0.0438672863,
-0.2178633362,
-0.5532126427,
-0.5841896534,
-0.0190008637,
0.4476872981,
-0.3831185102,
-0.0316270851,
0.0824724734,
-0.2321577966,
0.5511194468,
0.3948940337,
-0.4574127793,
0.3153493404,
0.6009454131,
0.5770481229,
0.1374368668,
-0.1325163096,
-0.3741055727,
0.725161612,
-0.4778132737,
0.9553898573,
-0.3020285368,
0.024386568,
-0.0697352588,
-0.1207936555,
-0.3057971597,
-0.6808990836,
0.3814310133,
-0.9220312834,
0.046037104,
-0.5575731397,
-1.1453844309,
-0.2811966836,
0.5054883361,
-0.501337707,
0.7969868183,
-0.0248253345,
-0.6853234768,
0.5978906751,
-0.5907063484,
-0.3102260232,
0.3138002753,
-0.2661109865,
-0.2748122513,
-0.2073192,
0.361220628,
0.6322986484,
-0.5261963606,
-0.1424362361,
-0.4094578922,
-0.2322705835,
0.360211283,
0.02775505,
0.5142853856,
0.0393719599,
-0.144645676,
-0.4433629513,
-0.5312857032,
0.6210548282,
0.2690452337,
0.0689829737,
-0.3674037158,
0.0033348021,
-0.6628913283,
0.0330693871,
0.2415340245,
-0.5940746665,
-0.0634011924,
-0.2562430203,
0.2703274488,
0.4389844239,
0.2960131466,
0.0634183288,
-0.2747544646,
0.5229660869,
-0.0244511161,
-0.2488149405,
0.039088387,
-0.4893758297,
-0.3352651894,
-0.066107437,
0.1142277047,
0.7211940885,
-0.6061176062,
0.3816629052,
-0.5395548344,
-0.6696168184,
-0.1649662554,
-0.0711378381,
0.0564031079,
1.0029758215,
0.3760510981,
-0.1807250679,
-0.2588504255,
-0.904774189,
-0.650665462,
-0.3612416983,
-0.2799733281,
0.7776213884,
0.1955924034,
0.3925508261,
1.2852634192,
-0.8328989744,
-0.2270237505,
-0.3402688205,
-0.042949494,
0.3199983537,
-0.2694725096,
0.5254562497,
-0.4283521473,
-0.5279228687,
-0.1305281371,
-0.9558423162,
-0.2280289233,
0.3513305485,
0.0324642174,
0.2503639758,
0.4227972925,
-0.5490866899,
0.2246052772,
0.3696275651,
-0.3321805894,
0.5184782743,
-0.1874541193,
0.2452902198,
-0.9727618694,
0.2107258141,
-0.1176206991,
-0.3597143888,
-0.7971832156,
-0.2502077222,
0.2749659121,
-0.1316998452,
-0.2914049923,
0.3504143059,
-0.5196498036,
-0.3903090954,
0.2222156972,
0.6125717759,
0.3483358324,
0.2132598311,
0.0446043238,
1.007755518,
0.4319706261,
-0.5780957937,
0.4293379784,
0.4451260269,
-0.7256541252,
1.0694557428,
-0.8698682785,
0.23293975,
-0.123970598,
0.100811325,
-0.8643456697,
-0.0173029993,
-0.3111793995,
-0.2534886003,
0.1589478552,
-0.0806728378,
-0.5696624517,
-0.500962913,
0.1850037277,
-0.3250316381,
0.5341390371,
-0.1420833915,
0.6074741483,
0.3716396987,
-0.2702355087,
-0.6589558721,
-0.8306791186,
0.2906695008,
-0.268387109,
-0.9977195263,
0.1480374634,
0.3014890552,
-0.1838018447,
0.1187495515,
-0.2172444314,
-0.2210059315,
0.0652207509,
-0.2076659203,
0.1323342919,
-0.4537471235,
0.3457399309,
-0.2367200404,
0.0894672349,
0.2253925055,
-0.3275089562,
0.4766572118,
-0.1486583054,
-0.315787971,
-0.04138216,
0.0043548597,
0.3654562235,
-0.2474358976,
1.1633015871,
-0.0924395472,
-0.186505273,
0.0452593975,
-0.7892873287,
-0.2351512909,
-0.4241330922,
0.5802901983,
-0.5113168359,
-0.897536695,
0.5736027956,
-0.1156451106,
-0.1207866296,
0.365004003,
0.3213860393,
-0.3234850466,
0.7676480412,
0.3119418323,
-0.0152846724,
0.1558551937,
0.0031656912,
0.324719131,
-0.7186826468,
-0.2684291303,
-0.6934101582,
0.0342679545,
-0.2025626451,
-0.2387588918,
0.6949242353,
0.2181037366,
-0.5883764029,
0.4237630665,
-0.1434742063,
0.5127950907,
0.1740390807,
0.1581103206,
0.5602513552,
0.0661777705,
-0.1124333292,
-0.0354565158,
-0.8035487533,
-0.4498114586,
0.9737175107,
0.2021048665,
0.7481111884,
0.1986565441,
0.3775526583,
0.0406968109,
0.2673960626,
-0.2352424413,
0.6097162366,
-0.0442798994,
-0.7724539042,
-0.6472598314,
-0.6046248078,
-0.751565516,
0.0141860042,
0.1354465336,
-0.9453861713,
0.0564966537,
0.1707703918,
-0.3192861676,
0.4114298224,
-0.7481638789,
1.1132035255,
-0.2940285206,
-0.3066123128,
0.0350727774,
-0.5093802214,
-0.1163012385,
0.0331205986,
0.0161352102,
-0.1235599592,
-0.0900826156,
0.7015077472,
-0.4675960839,
0.602216959,
-0.352863729,
0.0454989374,
0.3102414608,
-0.019883262,
0.8169249296,
-0.472863853,
-0.3532605469,
0.1975919753,
0.1277198046,
-0.3529405296,
-0.8013479114,
0.3157846332,
-0.4218733907,
-0.6900975704,
-0.2050795257,
-0.4786622524,
-0.80066818,
0.3191773593,
-0.0100780101,
0.432585746,
-0.1562824547,
0.4634971917,
0.8122106791,
-0.3135834932,
0.1328456849,
0.8012905717,
-0.1540440917,
-0.1510163695,
0.3877633214,
0.4622732997,
0.5862060785,
0.4640955031,
-0.1720781922,
-0.7972552776,
-0.3198412359,
-0.6476007104,
0.245471999,
-0.9020090699,
-0.3286641538,
-0.9011630416,
-0.2310695648,
-0.4895271659,
0.0592915639,
0.1088804379,
-0.4803081751,
0.1485903412,
-0.3699636459,
0.646273315,
0.6515936255,
0.4892083108,
0.131432727,
-0.5351411104,
-0.2318788022,
0.4811729193,
0.5347080827,
-0.1552862972,
-0.3366612494,
-0.1205315962,
-0.1378413737,
-0.1471407562,
-1.133690238,
-0.0083906697,
0.2267379165,
0.6287479401,
-0.0774243549,
0.1600579321,
0.7108555436,
-0.4413963854,
0.6138186455,
-0.0956246331,
-0.6706271768,
0.3226228356,
-0.3098976016,
0.1584130675,
0.6391186118,
0.3941220641,
-0.7337682247,
-0.5139885545,
-0.4691973031,
-0.7017190456,
0.5468214154,
0.0456123427,
-0.0422951542,
0.1646447182,
0.5294465423,
-0.3617834151,
0.4555755258,
-0.4734859765,
-0.3625214994,
0.1057607234,
-0.2024117857,
-0.067615822,
-0.1498052776,
-0.0560071319,
0.1621072143,
0.4721903205,
-0.2755103707,
0.2220069319,
0.2064489722,
-0.0670132339,
-0.0015677306,
0.4609670341,
0.0409465395,
0.9231992364,
-0.3081913292,
-0.003870314,
0.6505826116,
-0.1846730411,
-0.0968940407,
0.261128962,
-0.2807789445,
-0.1947621405,
0.08462172,
0.7358255386,
-0.3219409585,
-0.6146273613,
0.5271988511,
0.0813158005,
-0.049128402,
-0.1735651344,
0.1465318203,
0.570315063,
0.0167019311,
0.4638151228,
-0.5225659609,
-0.0129096108,
-0.3558637798,
0.2315158099,
0.6162462831,
-0.4188086987,
0.3804163039,
0.688170135,
-0.0198405106,
-0.0497622974,
0.6684398055,
0.195636481,
-0.4954729378,
0.7938009501,
0.4654547572,
0.4827767611,
-0.0397461951,
0.1462987959,
0.2153379172,
0.4037334919,
0.3368118405,
0.2953395844,
0.2647239268,
-0.8366829753,
-0.532925427,
-0.5141837001,
-0.885125041,
-0.0496551916,
-0.5601010919,
0.1708145291,
-0.2093665302,
0.0170207862,
0.0477784872,
0.0857495666,
-0.6890981197,
0.4749625921,
-0.3287335932,
1.2644202709,
-0.6339966059,
0.7114691734,
0.7628449798,
-0.4579828084,
-1.2130180597,
-0.1517923176,
-0.3841714263,
-1.0143891573,
0.5087228417,
0.2034469545,
0.0127746658,
0.4292942882,
-0.3190312386,
-0.6585376263,
1.5397093296,
0.4743970335,
-0.5505667925,
0.15643318,
0.7256097198,
0.65560776,
-0.2455435842,
0.4317293763,
0.7329028249,
0.5014572144,
0.1284714192,
-0.751635015,
0.1494695395,
0.1759072244,
-0.1912697256,
0.2202898115,
-0.6051962376,
0.4289913476,
-0.0506287217,
-0.0180352721,
-0.1687298715,
0.4514268339,
0.252512455,
0.3292983174,
0.4458276331,
0.5798643231,
0.8964663744,
-0.4525158107,
1.2347453833,
-0.5445358753,
0.2389035672,
0.9172506928,
-0.7528092861,
0.6767457724,
0.2717865109,
-0.3941227496,
0.7766869068,
0.3999274671,
0.0417730622,
0.2681562006,
0.1672611237,
-0.2162164897,
-0.3213548958,
-0.0572763793,
-0.3149406314,
-0.0472762771,
0.3149527609,
-0.1889693439,
-0.2308518738,
-0.403973639,
0.1207936555,
-0.1609724611,
-0.2306279391,
0.9407893419,
0.0455584973,
-0.5135991573,
0.2778064013,
-0.133749485,
-0.1178393438,
-0.7865201831,
0.31035465,
-0.3685227633,
0.1189311668,
-0.1000674516,
-1.1966917515,
0.3278543353,
0.0759982318,
0.0456622727,
-0.105417572,
0.7385656834,
-0.263934046,
-0.1523426771,
0.1552183032,
0.6320887208,
0.2699848413,
-0.3637753725,
-0.6168740988,
-0.4499958754,
-0.4007222652,
-0.3913769126,
0.1595052183,
0.6564787626,
-0.0598300993,
0.781909883,
0.2313266248,
0.0525615253,
-0.0106634209,
0.058559835,
0.6873878241,
-0.590682447,
-0.5304623842,
-0.6037524939,
0.3982385695,
-0.5720264912,
-0.0274096094,
0.9225004911,
0.622651279,
0.453909725,
0.1300636977,
0.6770521998,
-0.2705078721,
0.8618910313,
-0.529534936,
0.6883928776,
-0.6881709099,
0.3195350766,
-0.3515804708,
-0.9051498771,
-0.4222598076,
0.158251822,
-0.8339565396,
0.21316199,
0.8920689821,
1.0759991407,
0.3767561913,
0.0868673548,
0.5557700396,
0.5219798684,
0.2186446488,
0.3892583549,
0.532830596,
-0.2627210915,
0.9251244068,
-0.0999559984,
-0.0595284067,
0.0219187997,
-1.1059327126,
-0.6149520874,
-0.0799880326,
-0.1825304031,
-0.566678524,
0.2880351245,
0.2823749185,
0.3791407645,
-0.863284111,
-0.2134784311,
-0.0224955715,
0.0136455214,
-0.2132595628,
-0.2359650582,
0.6338925362,
-0.3408997655,
-0.2720697224,
0.1891109794,
0.5366720557,
-0.2121600807,
-0.02669953,
0.0704605505,
0.1101509258,
0.1215257123,
0.288705349,
0.11349646,
-0.1512280852,
-0.4629326165,
0.5226027369,
-0.2639763057,
0.1332199275,
0.5822074413,
-0.559437573,
0.1475277394,
0.2481637299,
0.7895441651,
0.6365587115,
0.1709664911,
0.55422014,
-0.7943344712,
-0.2525942326,
0.1239900887,
0.3146784902,
0.4246833324,
-0.3967437744,
0.679469645,
0.3034404218,
-0.68160671,
-0.4702336192,
0.2933616638,
-0.7141043544,
-0.1604606807,
0.9467583299,
-0.2060644776,
-0.3327896297,
-0.4857851267,
-0.0613837354,
-0.1842562705,
-0.111768879,
0.3900541365,
0.7650129199,
-0.403273046,
-0.3189879656,
-0.5578083992,
0.3243240416,
0.5194001198,
-0.9906576872,
0.1811721921,
0.6520370245,
0.6421762705,
-0.1745000333,
0.8746068478,
-0.0528236479,
0.2109565437,
-0.076471597,
0.1527358443,
-0.0875256658,
0.0350112021,
-0.0036476005,
0.3735717535,
0.2488223165,
0.1504825652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07497v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07497v2
|
Multilingual Nonce Dependency Treebanks: Understanding how Language Models represent and process syntactic structure
| 2023-11-13T17:36:58 | 2024-06-12T13:41:16 |
David Arps, Laura Kallmeyer, Younes Samih, Hassan Sajjad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce SPUD (Semantically Perturbed Universal Dependencies), a
framework for creating nonce treebanks for the multilingual Universal
Dependencies (UD) corpora. SPUD data satisfies syntactic argument structure,
provides syntactic annotations, and ensures grammaticality via
language-specific rules. We create nonce data in Arabic, English, French,
German, and Russian, and demonstrate two use cases of SPUD treebanks. First, we
investigate the effect of nonce data on word co-occurrence statistics, as
measured by perplexity scores of autoregressive (ALM) and masked language
models (MLM). We find that ALM scores are significantly more affected by nonce
data than MLM scores. Second, we show how nonce data affects the performance of
syntactic dependency probes. We replicate the findings of M\"uller-Eberstein et
al. (2022) on nonce test data and show that the performance declines on both
MLMs and ALMs wrt. original test data. However, a majority of the performance
is kept, suggesting that the probe indeed learns syntax independently from
semantics.
|
[
-0.391576916,
-0.8307479024,
0.453396827,
0.1325794756,
0.0717068464,
0.0472934805,
-0.1815612316,
-0.67456007,
0.5729843378,
0.5035530925,
-0.230579868,
-0.9215439558,
-0.612236619,
0.2629628181,
-0.5577893853,
1.1966708899,
-0.1278368086,
-0.0121272169,
-0.3678289056,
-0.4207704663,
-0.3501367867,
-0.7581514716,
0.0675037056,
0.1736864001,
0.6155334711,
0.7602723241,
0.634719491,
0.7001239061,
0.161288321,
0.3121832013,
0.0947368145,
-0.16909118,
-0.0539640859,
0.3898794055,
-0.1052836701,
-0.4863877892,
-0.4578335285,
-0.0512951948,
0.5973312855,
1.1090149879,
-0.1392643899,
0.2301745117,
-0.0991657376,
0.4017060399,
-0.6198877692,
0.3637174368,
-0.4732400477,
-0.2834680974,
-0.5569497347,
-0.0755019188,
-0.5422884226,
0.0151008461,
0.0632672459,
-0.4273866117,
0.4892850518,
-0.0357018225,
0.9251356721,
-0.0087219002,
-0.6754342318,
-0.4376657903,
-0.5870904326,
0.7585864067,
-0.3424760997,
0.6525450349,
0.453638643,
-0.0701476038,
-0.2046616524,
-0.6286235452,
-0.1561223418,
-0.435033232,
-0.3169957995,
0.1097429618,
-0.1734016687,
0.2079399973,
0.2998067737,
0.3227459788,
-0.7008810043,
-0.0608175695,
-0.20574525,
-0.2869640887,
0.5067410469,
-0.0353236943,
0.4638211727,
-0.2910434902,
-0.3955875933,
0.0713794529,
-0.626044631,
-0.0446320809,
0.6097394228,
0.5983774662,
-0.2242323011,
0.4776468873,
-0.0276819672,
0.6234104037,
-0.0892143995,
-0.0095641008,
0.1533519328,
-0.2911741734,
-0.1577198654,
0.0374628492,
0.4959510267,
-0.1839218289,
0.1997592449,
-0.3058398366,
-0.1515034884,
0.4244374633,
0.0448016338,
-0.5831182003,
-0.4265601337,
0.1362031251,
-0.4196549356,
0.241603151,
0.1830872297,
-0.8968890309,
-0.0351405889,
-0.4272409081,
0.1780145019,
-0.4261593521,
-0.5638101697,
-0.0965674818,
0.0573661439,
0.0180286765,
0.1025139764,
-0.9246166945,
0.7150062919,
0.3081392944,
0.7324917316,
0.013979068,
-0.5948187709,
-0.5347058177,
0.0764978006,
-0.4870913923,
1.1616179943,
-0.5536720157,
-0.4653542042,
-0.1174003556,
0.2877300978,
-0.3157944083,
-0.4878008068,
0.4210413396,
-0.3231071532,
0.2417631149,
-0.2679905891,
-0.9060412645,
-0.4776982963,
-0.1012713164,
-0.8245405555,
0.990352571,
0.0981567726,
-0.7821857333,
0.3781649172,
-0.7397968173,
-0.689760685,
0.2031214833,
-0.3410670459,
-0.2132211477,
0.3132475019,
-0.1052369326,
0.2554758489,
0.0523873754,
0.3662106097,
-0.2538128197,
-0.0447721705,
-0.1496656388,
-0.388473928,
0.9132235646,
-0.0367724709,
-0.3469703496,
0.3024194539,
-0.9549202323,
0.0237414669,
0.0089589832,
-0.0846372843,
-0.2393125743,
0.0550394431,
0.3075300455,
0.0261087772,
0.1247805059,
-0.6350669265,
0.0632463619,
-0.3185196221,
0.1148388907,
0.602054894,
-0.0262771398,
0.4008345306,
0.0150259649,
0.6501989961,
0.1553945541,
-0.0108998874,
-0.3217025101,
-0.4464079142,
-0.7925579548,
-0.2730757892,
0.4205981493,
0.4740463793,
-0.4717242122,
0.0405341499,
0.146440208,
-0.5342342854,
-0.0442318134,
0.0124387816,
0.2244291604,
0.3253494203,
0.3979300559,
-0.3620801568,
-0.622190237,
-1.0077689886,
-0.1874853075,
-0.2665798664,
0.3420348465,
0.0671330243,
0.5039367676,
0.1044723541,
0.7135292292,
-0.2193040848,
-0.1132254303,
-0.4947521091,
0.2897901833,
0.2170404792,
0.0433220863,
0.6147056818,
-0.5115175247,
-0.6123093367,
-0.3317317367,
-0.5721058249,
-0.4555824697,
0.1451450139,
0.1473978907,
0.9232079983,
0.5119134188,
-0.6793470383,
0.6836398244,
0.8483566046,
-0.7450247407,
0.8170593977,
-0.3392837942,
-0.0761713386,
-0.8519069552,
0.2302807122,
-0.1679148227,
-0.2463254184,
-0.814011991,
-0.1214646995,
0.2545588017,
0.0883557349,
-0.4148439467,
0.5145123005,
-0.7075079679,
-0.2958562374,
-0.1759270281,
-0.1169984639,
0.1263083071,
0.2961427867,
0.1854036152,
0.6497066617,
0.6620417833,
-0.588922143,
0.1272375733,
0.2450526059,
-0.3966623843,
0.4046693146,
-0.4128453135,
-0.0106088845,
-0.2739973664,
0.1162915826,
-1.0517568588,
0.0139439898,
0.0337539166,
-0.5135763288,
0.3860141337,
-0.290602237,
-0.6741379499,
0.3607366383,
-0.0468650647,
0.1941809505,
-0.1819174737,
-0.3423309922,
0.5761658549,
0.4210594893,
-0.2153570205,
-0.6056199074,
-0.6739063263,
0.4107402861,
-0.2423211634,
-0.5049173236,
0.047888007,
0.0824303329,
-0.3635162711,
0.1796931922,
-0.1468023956,
0.0363150835,
0.2087121904,
0.4999963641,
0.5400863886,
-0.3071239293,
0.3549950719,
-0.3100938797,
-0.3597209454,
-0.1137653291,
-0.3680774271,
0.4829512835,
-0.0118094562,
-0.42159006,
-0.27368325,
0.9385768175,
0.390355736,
-0.2811362743,
0.7650382519,
0.2146680951,
-0.208812505,
-0.1605704278,
-0.4271806777,
-0.2089749873,
-0.3564035296,
0.4174531698,
-0.6844113469,
-0.6819007397,
0.4226818979,
0.3796204627,
0.1004134417,
0.5150392652,
0.6659729481,
0.0356802829,
0.767755568,
0.882640779,
-0.1986814439,
0.5264894962,
-0.0623922534,
0.324526608,
-0.1822279394,
0.0526107922,
-0.5362241268,
-0.0639865845,
-1.1011000872,
-0.1288914979,
0.2071988583,
0.119999513,
0.0361425579,
0.4149852395,
-0.1173271984,
0.4161591232,
0.5404802561,
-0.7025918365,
0.3085892797,
0.1253998876,
-0.3351284862,
0.0060650897,
-0.8623449206,
-0.6483306289,
1.1367913485,
0.1529034078,
0.5525962114,
0.1815175861,
0.6306663156,
0.0852994919,
0.1491604149,
-0.5835145712,
0.4504205883,
-0.3792523742,
-0.7712216377,
0.0081705488,
-0.3535146117,
-1.2690417767,
0.048499085,
0.0597541891,
-0.795597136,
0.1161159873,
0.0088160513,
-0.1580430716,
0.2718675435,
-0.9960762858,
0.9233631492,
-0.2286060601,
-0.3308803737,
0.0731761381,
-0.7634425759,
-0.1154073253,
0.4659573436,
0.2707031071,
-0.1277423501,
0.0630653724,
0.760122776,
-0.3060025573,
0.8950559497,
-0.3969167471,
-0.0020821006,
0.4200066328,
0.3734147847,
0.2590745687,
0.1220991835,
0.1795460582,
0.5845429897,
0.5454079509,
-0.5844420195,
-0.332881391,
0.6480156779,
-0.7904940844,
-0.5174002647,
-0.6890462041,
-0.855129838,
-0.2736501098,
0.28891927,
0.0635960847,
0.4489553571,
-0.163353622,
-0.2126164436,
0.2820768356,
-0.23430942,
0.5578349829,
0.7556676865,
-0.3446699381,
-0.26821661,
0.7519190907,
0.5873165727,
0.3524129391,
0.2018724233,
-0.1004286557,
-0.4329938591,
-0.3404330015,
-0.6623004079,
0.3989138603,
-0.8338571191,
-0.1241015717,
-0.8224372268,
-0.2321118265,
-0.5202066302,
0.2065867335,
-0.2925775945,
-0.640463233,
-0.0978486165,
-0.4626461565,
0.6442074776,
1.0506979227,
-0.1611552984,
0.0162481256,
-0.7719669938,
0.0656839907,
-0.2416947633,
0.3768461943,
-0.2679193318,
-0.1118750423,
-0.357498318,
-0.3461646736,
-0.2057290077,
-1.1672110558,
0.2569047511,
0.1151579246,
0.550468266,
0.2157631367,
-0.2355952114,
0.5884305239,
-0.3268197775,
0.7163801789,
-0.1987405717,
-1.0743476152,
0.0788332894,
-0.3637328446,
0.3233315647,
0.4278644025,
0.1629989743,
-0.8924703598,
-0.6020385027,
-0.7789302468,
-0.9634672999,
0.7516422868,
-0.1043399647,
-0.0143581498,
-0.1180680245,
0.2635729611,
0.4134956598,
0.1919799447,
-0.4806802273,
-0.4813022614,
-0.1761344671,
-0.3152084649,
-0.2300354838,
-0.5252707005,
0.2080682218,
-0.0065677832,
0.4945649803,
-0.0240683239,
0.1669391543,
0.1595193297,
-0.3259875476,
-0.0733782947,
0.3371852636,
0.4656805098,
0.6384197474,
0.0352783501,
0.5176672935,
-0.0728801489,
-0.3218431175,
0.2181414217,
0.1712138057,
-0.1363623142,
0.3489524722,
0.6128140688,
0.5717380643,
0.0329699516,
-0.4573151171,
0.2967815101,
0.0129345702,
-0.2611184418,
-0.3575643599,
-0.321267277,
0.4853461087,
-0.0259608086,
-0.0406886823,
-0.1238841489,
-0.0267210677,
-0.598805964,
0.5149633288,
0.327585429,
-0.0490672886,
-0.5492609143,
0.320833534,
-0.1856617928,
0.0520597696,
0.3994905353,
-0.321590215,
-0.4379632175,
0.5615545511,
0.7340163589,
0.4325199723,
-0.5583518744,
0.3503963053,
0.2342943102,
0.2397228032,
0.2156264484,
0.7291022539,
-0.1316244006,
-0.600704968,
-0.4820680916,
-0.5150469542,
-0.235782221,
-0.0009781934,
-0.5316030979,
0.4595000446,
-0.4477812946,
0.1017290503,
0.0804504305,
0.17731677,
-0.6140528917,
0.1016510427,
0.0979599133,
0.7512987852,
-1.0996216536,
0.9638867974,
0.8959981203,
-0.5467225313,
-0.9210058451,
-0.0056146248,
0.1436033547,
-0.5840448141,
0.6052338481,
0.1397365332,
-0.1530158669,
-0.0088510234,
-0.1688222289,
-1.2173013687,
0.6476050019,
0.5573992729,
-0.4645143747,
0.16811575,
0.3670924306,
0.4908186197,
-0.1970740408,
0.4636857808,
0.369505167,
0.5652131438,
-0.1791189611,
-0.8285414577,
-0.0955738053,
-0.2177992165,
-0.2266052961,
0.7176291347,
-0.4831344485,
1.0959120989,
0.0585287474,
-0.6708338857,
0.0056552682,
0.3912777007,
0.0307696275,
0.3449664116,
0.4586418867,
0.7380466461,
0.662953496,
0.1974335611,
0.8211875558,
-0.5677269697,
0.2941003442,
1.2205426693,
-0.3232966959,
0.6703256369,
0.5359518528,
-0.1423072964,
0.7910088897,
0.7796441317,
0.1012737006,
0.1250371486,
0.1715285927,
-0.1728776395,
0.0387402512,
-0.4258146584,
-0.0983438864,
0.6826884151,
0.2629063129,
-0.2436823547,
-0.573133707,
-0.153736338,
0.3711508214,
0.1946986169,
0.0350055322,
0.6904291511,
0.04212467,
-0.4925856888,
0.4769755602,
0.1754018217,
0.1935396194,
-0.637758255,
0.0735618249,
-0.3047440648,
0.0200549364,
-0.5351179838,
-0.3593654931,
0.7212406993,
0.2008879334,
-0.2165810019,
-0.2150490582,
0.54171139,
-0.5514884591,
-0.8281447887,
0.8724012375,
1.10169065,
0.3806273043,
0.106344156,
-0.4447620511,
-0.1548478454,
-0.2370126694,
-0.291216433,
0.3504349887,
0.4362536073,
-0.436717242,
0.1530847102,
0.5173444152,
0.3441296518,
0.1007415876,
0.3097649217,
0.4814568162,
-0.8285951018,
-0.4825789928,
-0.9224754572,
0.2744191587,
0.32326594,
-0.0076180073,
1.1546854973,
0.6338072419,
0.9619114399,
0.3528048694,
0.7957122326,
-0.2302455157,
0.5999056697,
-0.2953137159,
0.5726053715,
-0.5001195073,
-0.005565458,
-0.1390141249,
-0.8275923133,
-0.589045167,
0.3173488379,
-0.3989866376,
0.0223024748,
1.085015893,
0.8856899738,
-0.0848099738,
0.1931828111,
0.4702966809,
0.2627924383,
0.2272848189,
0.4700147212,
0.7276892662,
-0.0887034014,
0.2682938874,
-0.1997733563,
-0.1781879961,
0.1935766488,
-0.6999270916,
-0.6781935096,
-0.7287865281,
-0.2097541541,
-0.2924181819,
-0.0985580087,
0.9951037765,
0.5073874593,
-1.0513265133,
-0.7116308808,
-0.3199487329,
0.2334550619,
-0.0316686966,
-0.265503794,
0.6328359246,
-0.529825747,
-0.5287001133,
0.562515974,
0.5324736238,
-0.06109225,
-0.2328754663,
0.251145184,
-0.5892070532,
-0.0930896178,
0.3711512983,
0.0397856608,
-0.5771017075,
-0.3216905594,
0.1269326806,
0.1264748275,
0.3725716472,
0.8997803926,
-0.6492493749,
0.3688032627,
0.3599290252,
0.2632063925,
0.202845037,
-0.278346926,
0.3799818456,
-0.5704033971,
0.3046529591,
0.0045872177,
0.47244519,
0.3390119374,
-0.2326423675,
0.2132754624,
0.4650372565,
-0.5059041977,
-0.616904676,
0.6317626238,
-0.3408935666,
-0.3719455898,
1.0684201717,
-0.335333854,
-0.2434161156,
-0.6035522819,
0.0722079054,
0.413734436,
-0.4799531698,
0.6358878613,
0.9784078598,
-0.3879330158,
-0.2155483812,
-0.811820209,
0.3590918779,
0.8247783184,
-0.718680799,
0.2008313388,
0.6262270808,
0.5772954226,
0.1565582156,
0.6229375005,
-0.1659415364,
0.0239680577,
0.1189017147,
0.260915488,
-0.0312402435,
-0.559928596,
-0.4116382301,
0.3390197158,
0.196521908,
-0.2630119324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07491v1
|
A Step Closer to Comprehensive Answers: Constrained Multi-Stage Question Decomposition with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T17:28:03 | 2023-11-13T17:28:03 |
Hejing Cao, Zhenwei An, Jiazhan Feng, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Dongyan Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While large language models exhibit remarkable performance in the Question
Answering task, they are susceptible to hallucinations. Challenges arise when
these models grapple with understanding multi-hop relations in complex
questions or lack the necessary knowledge for a comprehensive response. To
address this issue, we introduce the "Decompose-and-Query" framework (D&Q).
This framework guides the model to think and utilize external knowledge similar
to ReAct, while also restricting its thinking to reliable information,
effectively mitigating the risk of hallucinations. Experiments confirm the
effectiveness of D&Q: On our ChitChatQA dataset, D&Q does not lose to ChatGPT
in 67% of cases; on the HotPotQA question-only setting, D&Q achieved an F1
score of 59.6%. Our code is available at
https://github.com/alkaidpku/DQ-ToolQA.
|
[
-0.6569465995,
-1.1502240896,
0.8791128397,
0.1319974363,
0.1159439608,
0.069647029,
-0.0725566894,
-0.4134901166,
-0.018572066,
0.7022733688,
-0.9302253127,
-0.3066305816,
-0.2340826392,
0.0480995141,
-0.5775105953,
0.6091305017,
0.2757053971,
-0.0019340056,
-0.3245333135,
-0.071683608,
-0.2759158313,
-0.6628906727,
-0.7915804982,
-0.0748883486,
0.5031725764,
0.0751889795,
0.8125969768,
0.3221862912,
0.515134871,
0.2750206888,
-0.3583019674,
0.1459818184,
-0.6470069289,
0.678111434,
-0.1643644124,
-0.4073879123,
-0.2408065498,
-0.2880831957,
0.4101283848,
1.006891489,
-0.3518656492,
-0.0102233952,
-0.1348699182,
0.7128884196,
-0.6644127369,
0.0469301865,
-0.6684049368,
-0.0155685451,
0.3335700333,
-0.0643588379,
-0.5355347395,
-0.4797146022,
-0.0614616126,
-0.5034919381,
0.1643289924,
0.0638171881,
0.4869561493,
0.5710216165,
-0.7053406835,
-0.1819467694,
-0.8425585032,
0.4555923641,
-0.3571324944,
0.5986629128,
0.4440708756,
0.4531955123,
-0.3646847606,
-0.7871400118,
-0.7129773498,
-0.1150659025,
-0.0424885377,
-0.0401761532,
0.0007881362,
0.1948694885,
0.423209697,
0.5062437654,
-0.8242338896,
-0.2298590988,
-0.4544282258,
-0.3749427795,
0.4575943649,
0.5505060554,
0.2186809629,
-0.1189708337,
-0.2043551058,
-0.2157098651,
-0.5016759634,
-0.0695801526,
0.1213494465,
0.1721055657,
0.4963896871,
0.4810805619,
-0.3703939617,
0.5120737553,
0.1858164519,
0.1040024906,
-0.073364906,
-0.3674934506,
-0.2025056779,
-0.2361991405,
0.5180899501,
0.319240272,
0.0679980442,
-0.4264781177,
-0.1019575596,
-0.0301640593,
0.4311884344,
-0.9517740011,
-0.5484971404,
0.6858507395,
-0.2048313022,
0.1084451154,
-0.0645807683,
-0.7634754181,
-0.6730219126,
-0.2274756432,
0.593454957,
-0.3136323094,
-0.4893103242,
0.3296912313,
-0.1682171524,
0.318767488,
0.5102425814,
-0.4592397511,
0.4956670105,
0.6316324472,
0.4242865145,
-0.1358039528,
-0.1485920995,
-0.7008759975,
-0.0798185617,
-0.6069645286,
0.6121272445,
-0.4780807793,
-0.1779179573,
-0.0446508676,
0.2187995762,
-0.264010489,
-0.7365496159,
0.4614817798,
-0.8971388936,
0.4408505261,
-0.590592742,
-0.4956062138,
-0.4080112278,
0.5725765824,
-0.9202640057,
0.9204797149,
0.1066122055,
-0.8412840962,
0.0223964062,
-0.4219439626,
-0.334390372,
-0.1681918204,
0.0332536362,
0.1636630148,
0.0023400693,
0.4719028771,
0.369502008,
-0.2207409739,
0.2916406095,
-0.4473533928,
-0.3988586962,
0.3018718064,
-0.0869498625,
0.8240287304,
0.1378358752,
-0.2502468526,
0.1422277987,
-0.7519577742,
0.0633733347,
0.0785082579,
-0.2899727821,
-0.308927536,
-0.0594755225,
-0.2017304003,
0.4051259756,
-0.148700133,
-0.3100546598,
0.2320584953,
-0.4383997321,
0.3994696438,
0.5158407688,
0.3186680377,
0.4752832651,
-0.2504091561,
0.8528389335,
0.1480588168,
0.1478469372,
-0.1100772172,
-0.2420739383,
-0.8413134813,
-0.0191250425,
0.0233297758,
0.5633924603,
-1.0952243805,
0.2083436847,
0.0444231778,
-0.3296750188,
-0.5571789742,
-0.3317229152,
0.0479833521,
0.5944526196,
0.472191304,
0.1810977757,
-0.3485645056,
-0.8142233491,
0.1935521662,
-0.2436465174,
-0.2118984312,
-0.0130406674,
0.5837647915,
-0.0767835528,
0.4787908792,
-0.8907200694,
-0.0725506172,
-0.184406206,
-0.1521522701,
0.0824746937,
0.1744208038,
0.2815239429,
-0.9443944097,
-0.0805614144,
-0.4587294459,
-0.6176769733,
0.3633867502,
-0.0448393412,
-0.359608829,
-0.0564625822,
0.6282956004,
-0.9417759776,
0.3013877571,
0.2959805131,
-0.3321292698,
0.6234747767,
0.1202060059,
0.5465307236,
-1.1165759563,
0.1699090749,
-0.4375329018,
-0.1153653562,
-0.7153221965,
0.3761787415,
-0.0554166101,
-0.144945994,
-0.2358126938,
0.4079168141,
-0.1955902427,
0.1091760322,
-0.1386145949,
0.2362750173,
0.3166928887,
0.574581027,
0.1143782064,
0.6118906736,
0.6957589388,
-0.7992683053,
0.4189215004,
0.443389535,
-0.4146110713,
0.3560003936,
-0.7724561691,
0.4405384064,
-0.4077785313,
0.2701004744,
-1.199108839,
-0.4343494177,
0.266389817,
-0.4998161197,
0.1070073768,
0.1595917791,
-0.6667788625,
-0.3060241044,
-0.4780346751,
0.5501776934,
0.3183473945,
-0.4675151408,
0.4650800526,
0.3549938798,
-0.1887857318,
-0.6192734241,
-0.6122950315,
-0.0971840695,
-0.2262183279,
-0.6227067113,
0.1760135442,
-0.4140391946,
-0.4990550876,
0.0193241257,
-0.2122445107,
-0.374913007,
-0.005822021,
0.1303545833,
-0.1408138871,
-0.0730091035,
0.4222897887,
0.2005136311,
0.1886594892,
0.4483667612,
0.027492214,
0.7677954435,
0.2816056907,
-0.347832948,
-0.224337101,
0.6955695748,
0.9453201294,
-0.3414072692,
0.7974768281,
0.4268959165,
-0.593467474,
-0.2940008938,
-0.5708528161,
-0.5429832339,
-0.435775727,
0.3876331747,
-0.59505409,
-1.0285843611,
0.8802352548,
0.1693556905,
-0.1491678208,
0.4344840646,
0.6846525669,
0.073942557,
1.3214213848,
0.6098898649,
0.1420274377,
-0.024148332,
-0.1084070355,
0.3318136036,
-0.7860946655,
-0.5508693457,
-0.6795765758,
-0.0737178475,
-0.3933365643,
-0.5376392603,
0.4182140231,
0.1988199651,
-0.2495018542,
-0.0248679053,
-0.5898386836,
0.3140397668,
0.455824852,
0.2864742279,
0.4494228065,
-0.295095861,
0.0854088739,
0.1518401951,
-0.640537262,
-0.0180786923,
0.8349180818,
0.2400292605,
0.7968461514,
-0.0295823719,
0.6585196257,
-0.0154643906,
-0.2921130955,
-0.9709937572,
0.6619018912,
0.5076525807,
-1.0657902956,
-0.5202246308,
-0.6620085835,
-0.7988809347,
0.510592401,
0.0297178756,
-0.798161149,
0.2416070849,
-0.1906006634,
-0.5294865966,
0.1314248443,
-0.4155864716,
0.6049771309,
0.2359189391,
-0.2200002521,
-0.3057730496,
-0.6672430634,
0.7197211385,
0.0180245601,
0.2245783657,
-0.106972307,
0.1237631738,
0.6630138755,
-0.2216027677,
0.4171515107,
-0.1089596897,
-0.2154021263,
0.3852753043,
0.4762511551,
0.2545011342,
0.3518179357,
-0.1926308423,
-0.3778291047,
0.5347796082,
-0.2811157703,
-0.8124545217,
0.6336081624,
-0.4452406764,
-0.6529216766,
-0.3806706965,
-0.6131759882,
-0.3962589502,
0.0223716032,
0.1109147966,
0.4893735051,
-0.1843819618,
0.224959746,
0.9303367138,
-0.3013555408,
0.2514452636,
0.2139043063,
-0.5129693747,
-0.570100069,
0.2054808736,
-0.0709723905,
0.2623312175,
0.4178017974,
-0.0106555326,
-0.5698601604,
-0.4494640529,
-0.2433383167,
0.2139950544,
-1.0430142879,
-0.2465245128,
-0.8345370889,
-0.2144587934,
-0.5143484473,
0.3442778587,
-0.2566908598,
-0.5063394904,
0.1337587982,
-0.2802421749,
0.1396706253,
0.6427443624,
0.1171613932,
-0.2475944906,
-0.7416012287,
0.7037503123,
0.4755204618,
0.1229605824,
0.2097509652,
-0.3250109851,
-0.0508010201,
0.0940144062,
-0.0896294862,
-1.1458828449,
0.1112251431,
0.0893329531,
0.4966894984,
0.133642897,
0.7370365858,
0.7497208118,
-0.2385544032,
0.8588192463,
-0.1747214198,
-0.7740681767,
0.566901207,
-0.2020391673,
0.4716107249,
0.8152526021,
0.7421917319,
-0.4380016327,
-0.5934047103,
-0.2625579238,
-0.8525720835,
0.6714055538,
0.1817408204,
0.0674935058,
-0.0759774446,
0.4455468953,
0.1252435893,
0.3375726044,
-0.6985505223,
-0.0719991848,
0.104779996,
0.1795580387,
0.1245130002,
-0.3961689174,
-0.2832757831,
-0.6133143306,
0.2752533555,
-0.0719436258,
0.2135893404,
0.2794796228,
-0.141051352,
-0.0327588283,
0.2220388055,
0.245923847,
0.9977635741,
-0.2608490586,
0.2482210696,
-0.015870722,
-0.3672747612,
0.1503984183,
-0.0553695895,
0.0025826441,
-0.3253057301,
0.4543383718,
0.4277402759,
-0.1787039489,
-0.7312301397,
0.2099642456,
-0.4200516343,
-0.5174525976,
-0.0963803455,
0.071904704,
0.1678459346,
0.462459892,
0.4821796417,
-0.2779484093,
0.5273492932,
-0.8291283846,
0.3569373488,
0.1482032686,
-0.3840540349,
-0.3646759391,
0.7429867387,
-0.0451090895,
0.0272994898,
1.0528894663,
-0.3928354084,
-0.7479991913,
0.4783197641,
0.3332273066,
0.821523726,
-0.2905452549,
0.3989257812,
0.5607731938,
0.4029867351,
-0.1942051798,
0.6418679357,
-0.1222921163,
-0.6423181295,
-0.6481305361,
-0.6198378205,
-0.4279525876,
0.4165995717,
-0.8037910461,
-0.119749628,
-0.2820132971,
-0.0667444319,
-0.1762986779,
-0.0160825774,
-0.473975718,
0.3193602264,
-0.0572950169,
0.6748491526,
-0.6406843662,
0.7267597914,
0.6135069728,
-0.4326761663,
-0.8705208302,
0.4165301323,
-0.1975267529,
-0.2679853737,
0.440654695,
0.3546411693,
-0.1682880521,
0.0026416245,
-0.4876642525,
-0.7130211592,
0.8623653054,
0.4741732478,
-0.2032822967,
-0.2327271998,
0.0305326078,
0.5565343499,
-0.0621872395,
0.1461180449,
0.7845184803,
0.4924384654,
0.5488442779,
-0.9783724546,
0.3042688966,
-0.1717834622,
-0.4072389007,
0.2909317315,
-0.2890415788,
0.88530761,
-0.3425987661,
-0.3617217243,
-0.0179875568,
0.2558769882,
-0.0530541129,
0.3896759152,
0.5633252263,
0.5233624578,
0.8636573553,
-0.2122857273,
0.7992669344,
-0.2733816504,
0.2149192989,
1.0195660591,
-0.2435741127,
0.8739341497,
0.4048614502,
-0.1282844245,
0.2342803776,
0.7465302348,
0.3529985547,
0.6618509889,
0.3266153932,
-0.0334913805,
-0.658316195,
-0.0395547561,
-0.4203447104,
0.5516599417,
0.3192261159,
0.1657946408,
-0.1812571138,
0.1502553821,
0.0497540645,
0.1145968288,
-0.0779374093,
0.8878144026,
0.0692734569,
-0.9167710543,
0.8292945027,
-0.3385163844,
0.0660370514,
-0.4081452489,
-0.1138254851,
-0.579821527,
0.140999347,
-0.143085584,
-0.6915210485,
0.5201026201,
-0.3260375261,
-0.1378123015,
0.0913155526,
0.4937461615,
-0.5682953596,
-0.3591426015,
0.4745056331,
0.7812544107,
-0.0022221266,
-0.7253636718,
-0.5192914605,
0.2033679634,
-0.0345405862,
-0.4645569026,
0.2413947284,
0.6922730803,
0.1078265384,
0.8913198709,
0.2650660872,
-0.2844661176,
-0.0167646762,
0.1360637248,
1.2232327461,
-0.7176961303,
-0.2617287636,
-0.6380844116,
0.6380354762,
-0.1069509238,
0.0125929462,
0.6906363964,
0.5014153719,
0.6619751453,
0.0395725965,
0.5138343573,
-0.1697666794,
0.5193863511,
-0.573243022,
0.6587609649,
-0.790375948,
0.1488496214,
-0.3226451874,
-1.0715982914,
-0.368771404,
0.4384295046,
-0.0177337267,
-0.0260897111,
1.0653609037,
0.9362787008,
0.3391582668,
-0.1676297486,
0.4060724378,
0.0291107614,
0.4009619057,
0.7180384994,
1.2257753611,
-0.3638544679,
0.8431671858,
-0.4226171076,
-0.0776662305,
-0.0292792898,
-0.3455490768,
-1.1658241749,
-0.9020729065,
-0.3895769119,
-0.3300597966,
-0.1361064017,
0.5454955697,
0.5652981997,
-0.7234424949,
-0.0082802819,
0.2573910356,
0.268532306,
-0.3575081825,
-0.2434873432,
0.501550436,
-0.394792974,
-0.6656886339,
0.4802184403,
0.245736599,
-0.2726067305,
-0.4589441717,
0.2201015651,
-0.2138411254,
0.1483857334,
0.702331543,
-0.2268182635,
-0.5578397512,
-0.3979278207,
0.64836514,
0.0459586307,
-0.071464628,
0.7184085846,
-0.7221739292,
0.4580362737,
0.845962584,
0.5731306076,
0.5774245858,
0.2707378268,
0.4994415045,
-0.4114668965,
0.0506225899,
0.6841681004,
-0.0538324192,
0.1708198637,
-0.4248669744,
0.4561017752,
-0.1295140982,
-0.6408414245,
-0.9458322525,
0.4481901824,
-0.9320252538,
-0.5687328577,
1.0329989195,
0.0818114728,
-0.0581896268,
-0.2524296939,
-0.3205733001,
0.0568309575,
-0.1461315006,
0.9787967205,
0.7623245716,
-0.335540086,
-0.3132040203,
-0.63319695,
0.7404292226,
0.1400696188,
-0.7787905335,
0.3038862348,
0.9106613994,
0.0199515857,
0.1281041205,
0.7185410857,
-0.1665833592,
0.1404436082,
0.2504491806,
-0.1590895355,
0.0643741414,
-0.6630159616,
-0.2284232229,
0.7957991362,
0.2266578078,
-0.2743068039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07484v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07484v3
|
Psychometric Predictive Power of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T17:19:14 | 2024-04-15T12:12:24 |
Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Yohei Oseki, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction tuning aligns the response of large language models (LLMs) with
human preferences. Despite such efforts in human--LLM alignment, we find that
instruction tuning does not always make LLMs human-like from a cognitive
modeling perspective. More specifically, next-word probabilities estimated by
instruction-tuned LLMs are often worse at simulating human reading behavior
than those estimated by base LLMs. In addition, we explore prompting
methodologies for simulating human reading behavior with LLMs. Our results show
that prompts reflecting a particular linguistic hypothesis improve psychometric
predictive power, but are still inferior to small base models. These findings
highlight that recent advancements in LLMs, i.e., instruction tuning and
prompting, do not offer better estimates than direct probability measurements
from base LLMs in cognitive modeling. In other words, pure next-word
probability remains a strong predictor for human reading behavior, even in the
age of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2682577968,
-0.6268548369,
0.7233061194,
-0.0552237406,
-0.1543574333,
-0.0585712828,
-0.7555247545,
-0.4214245677,
0.0178795233,
0.4977861941,
-0.8737376928,
-0.3940432072,
-0.4324536026,
0.0234450083,
-0.0790442973,
0.7353311181,
0.4059662223,
0.3616404533,
-0.5045986772,
0.420987159,
-0.6190617085,
-0.5073462129,
-0.5657026172,
-0.7754818797,
0.6243648529,
0.4770104587,
0.7844799161,
0.645848453,
0.4203126132,
0.2936040759,
0.0570730418,
0.0092306919,
-0.3470565975,
0.0624437183,
-0.0089646531,
-1.0069895983,
-0.6930605769,
0.2769310772,
0.5991236567,
0.867174387,
-0.1753162295,
0.0637376979,
0.1673402041,
0.8096926808,
-0.4714642763,
0.2054587007,
-0.5521737337,
-0.2714404762,
-0.2633564472,
-0.3655393124,
-0.7404031157,
-0.4235883951,
0.2349629998,
-0.5008374453,
0.3856824338,
0.4316124022,
0.5591694117,
0.2447330058,
-0.3758564293,
-0.3915270865,
-0.5681604147,
1.0044736862,
-0.7280972004,
0.5213553309,
0.8282126784,
-0.0022493117,
-0.3004577756,
-0.1712533683,
-0.6533619165,
-0.459384948,
0.0915707052,
0.0525731444,
0.0428302996,
0.2175168097,
0.2481137514,
-0.0025353688,
-0.3943221271,
0.6085175276,
-0.3322838545,
-0.1729533672,
0.6701489091,
0.5838230252,
-0.0618198439,
-0.0317919627,
-0.0047585303,
-0.4215123057,
-0.7907445431,
0.1430517882,
0.6744129062,
0.3440529406,
-0.0407644734,
0.6459966898,
0.1225295439,
1.0287719965,
0.4044441283,
-0.246807009,
0.1970665157,
-0.0998590887,
0.0396723561,
0.2164904326,
0.6678102016,
0.7199257016,
0.7012996078,
-0.0216856468,
0.0589635,
0.1532607079,
0.2565864325,
-0.5718332529,
-0.2390570343,
0.0789891854,
-0.2849448025,
-0.1353567392,
0.1019967049,
-0.787496388,
-0.6009937525,
-0.4586820304,
0.1215491742,
-0.6026149988,
0.0156257264,
0.3813647926,
0.0347803496,
0.5144424438,
0.2061818987,
-1.6280673742,
0.1569889337,
1.0241476297,
0.7046701908,
-0.3329525292,
-0.2400287241,
-0.269061327,
0.1168444455,
-0.6607763171,
0.905667007,
-0.8140303493,
-0.5471735001,
0.0264646076,
0.1363077462,
-0.0890800729,
-0.4817576706,
0.4227328598,
-0.5610947609,
0.2072737962,
-0.5391110182,
-0.8061232567,
-0.0119401896,
0.0275252517,
-0.4772559404,
0.6233972907,
-0.0033273946,
-0.4418839216,
0.4924752116,
-0.3671049178,
-0.4011810124,
-0.0459302031,
-0.063355498,
-0.3111447692,
0.3668581247,
0.0405395441,
0.4219006896,
-0.3375261426,
0.1681212187,
-0.502597332,
-0.6081213951,
0.5119011998,
-0.6057571173,
0.6165739894,
0.0103134196,
-0.1668709815,
0.1015473753,
-0.3196084201,
0.2472046614,
-0.1486241519,
-0.3622454405,
-0.2255183756,
0.3984611332,
-0.3628458381,
0.0110908961,
0.3129835427,
-0.6142539382,
0.4216806889,
-0.5739061236,
0.2796898186,
1.0036356449,
-0.2443412691,
0.5749610662,
-0.565018177,
0.7504478097,
-0.3836328983,
-0.181828633,
-0.1259794086,
-0.5095731616,
-0.4807425439,
-0.1626688838,
0.3329343498,
0.6650905013,
-0.0785563439,
0.532677114,
-0.3825271428,
-0.5218798518,
-0.3798056245,
0.152536124,
0.4827277362,
0.3745774627,
-0.0180960726,
0.0848733485,
-0.4282036722,
-0.7126834989,
-0.4877789021,
-0.4063302875,
-0.2916277051,
0.2762048841,
0.0492230207,
0.1312398911,
0.6194503903,
-0.5255702734,
-0.1445302963,
-0.1865705252,
-0.0861274973,
0.2929075956,
0.2620400488,
0.3331477642,
-0.4559833407,
-0.3111106157,
-0.2473133355,
-0.4595314562,
-0.1895833164,
0.1662996262,
0.075383842,
0.3013125062,
0.7834293246,
-0.3785755634,
0.1189658791,
0.6092848778,
-0.3281790912,
0.6863361597,
-0.3464613855,
-0.0556073524,
-0.9360629916,
-0.3759935796,
0.1570053101,
0.1637195349,
-0.3975825906,
-0.2355909944,
0.3312242627,
0.1264232546,
-0.1187613979,
0.5769117475,
-0.6264719367,
-0.1459410489,
-0.2987668216,
-0.0604917295,
-0.2753071785,
0.2595754564,
0.2576572895,
0.9758763313,
0.4276747704,
-0.7120921612,
0.3714344501,
0.1065838858,
-0.6808774471,
0.4733423293,
-0.7364159226,
0.0494602397,
-0.1120425388,
0.2898396552,
-0.9662071466,
-0.4194656909,
-0.2072784007,
-0.3229345381,
0.5244425535,
0.3913376629,
-0.5006300807,
-0.4162997901,
-0.2935626507,
0.0474696681,
0.7692914605,
-0.4445119798,
0.4093949199,
0.0963791683,
-0.2691212893,
-0.4205957353,
-0.7549083233,
-0.172139883,
-0.23845388,
-0.4337154925,
0.357819736,
-0.3572547436,
-0.3158418238,
-0.2361286581,
0.0634778067,
0.416329205,
-0.063754119,
0.4226378202,
0.6239750981,
-0.3554394245,
0.3422041833,
-0.1383230984,
-0.244029209,
0.2663366795,
-0.3474095762,
0.6631187201,
-0.2263090909,
-0.4370302558,
-0.4534515738,
0.0610008352,
0.3758214414,
-0.0792604536,
0.6578652859,
0.3967790008,
-0.0630697906,
0.1142404154,
-0.5097251534,
-0.5591718554,
-0.5569821,
0.5542396307,
-0.2654927969,
-0.8370490074,
0.161751017,
0.0004575159,
0.0249403957,
0.0338274762,
0.8302949667,
-0.529628396,
1.6338853836,
0.753092587,
0.116367586,
0.8959853053,
0.0777358785,
0.1913097203,
-1.0513607264,
-0.2189743221,
-0.5184133053,
-0.5344939232,
-0.9024626613,
-0.0643027723,
0.47175017,
0.0018655565,
-0.2359804958,
0.0413989834,
-0.3042708039,
0.6440125108,
0.7500126958,
0.1862292588,
0.1335021704,
0.1792029887,
-0.1754512936,
-0.3139304817,
-0.5889511704,
-0.6323155165,
1.3278878927,
0.0116852997,
1.0451829433,
0.1172570214,
0.4852926731,
-0.0427788086,
0.4552071393,
-0.9922719598,
0.5575245023,
-0.283767283,
-0.7199774981,
-0.5244009495,
-0.1091418639,
-1.1194341183,
-0.1653275043,
-0.3808103204,
-1.1795477867,
0.1560155302,
0.3380115032,
-0.3682707846,
0.2396257371,
-0.8342189193,
0.5864827037,
-0.2685799599,
-0.2646619081,
-0.2696932554,
-0.411151737,
0.393140465,
-0.1779672951,
0.1733873785,
-0.2420021892,
-0.4083414972,
0.6226192713,
-0.3343328536,
1.0125873089,
0.1763706654,
-0.3531860411,
0.0382275991,
0.0377043635,
0.4894239902,
-0.123246789,
-0.4969858527,
-0.1697711498,
0.0544291995,
-0.4612621963,
-0.6665870547,
0.7242020369,
-0.8402110338,
-0.9898744226,
-0.3566568792,
-0.7494445443,
-0.676073432,
0.0847931653,
0.6729736924,
0.4185887575,
-0.0212187376,
0.1990880072,
0.7582291961,
0.0087997867,
0.3914031982,
0.6037874222,
-0.1742021888,
-0.0310163442,
1.084405899,
0.0532065928,
0.4932819009,
0.2732264698,
0.4104806483,
-0.6179813147,
-0.4308716357,
-0.1400241256,
0.3690942526,
-0.428276509,
0.0622769892,
-0.2172177583,
0.131414935,
-0.5381586552,
-0.4150645733,
-0.0412578955,
-0.0169707369,
-0.3873670101,
-0.2166555077,
0.385956645,
0.722907722,
-0.0490955561,
0.4665685296,
-0.6380263567,
0.0761859119,
0.292535603,
0.5032966733,
-0.0022794348,
-0.7216215134,
-0.2374972552,
0.0859321579,
-0.3225541115,
-0.9272080064,
0.3596276045,
0.2931199074,
0.3616008461,
0.6111265421,
0.0176077466,
0.5367660522,
-0.5349203348,
0.8123281598,
0.2003498971,
-0.6554973125,
0.3355838656,
-0.3598362803,
0.5340622663,
0.4297260344,
0.3656995296,
-0.4587171078,
-0.2808772922,
-0.5395655036,
-0.3063503206,
0.8331674933,
-0.6025823951,
0.4645489752,
-0.1857504696,
0.368657589,
0.0906668305,
0.1194120124,
-0.1972084492,
-0.1057711318,
0.109470956,
-0.3190067112,
-0.660687387,
-0.2691029012,
0.2019512951,
-0.4342836142,
0.715513289,
-0.2659064233,
0.2508055866,
-0.1786863357,
0.2868706882,
-0.5044226646,
0.1223669052,
0.6606301665,
0.611050427,
-0.4092694521,
-0.0588922799,
0.0622407049,
-0.6054861546,
0.3089902103,
-0.2416492403,
-0.1677244604,
-0.3499234915,
0.7764111757,
0.9114916921,
0.3640192747,
-0.7315263748,
0.3101781607,
-0.0088426052,
-0.3828529418,
-0.3743129075,
0.612324357,
0.4383974969,
0.2244890034,
0.0905993208,
-0.148894906,
-0.2738878131,
-0.611318469,
-0.1316376626,
0.6349038482,
-0.528891623,
-0.3375745416,
0.6157552004,
-0.0569716245,
-0.7823110819,
0.821947813,
-0.0180919562,
-0.297020942,
0.5938032269,
0.8491879702,
0.5870998502,
-0.3231931627,
0.0673684031,
0.4149494469,
0.2971856296,
-0.1334637254,
0.3733935952,
0.0857298449,
-0.8618018031,
-0.4477818012,
-0.5869024396,
-0.4409164786,
0.1218125969,
-0.9573702216,
0.3790381849,
-0.3302276134,
-0.3566237092,
0.164144218,
0.290440172,
-0.5804694891,
0.094659321,
0.1783155203,
0.783824563,
-0.7170286179,
0.9589559436,
0.6959980726,
-0.0281318538,
-0.9547042847,
0.2250288725,
0.2034981996,
-0.9232935905,
0.4213275909,
0.1097083539,
-0.008901706,
0.2262668163,
-0.6681117415,
-0.8673992753,
0.9613048434,
0.5777501464,
-0.8042496443,
-0.3272573352,
-0.0451615565,
0.5500792265,
-0.3021329939,
0.1879463047,
0.8083721995,
0.6442254782,
0.002581961,
-0.6578663588,
-0.1717550755,
0.1130727902,
-0.0075111622,
0.3124803305,
-0.6456445456,
0.7927741408,
-0.7463371158,
-0.1073651686,
0.1857729852,
0.8595163822,
0.3904036582,
0.1681184322,
0.5008361936,
0.2937416732,
0.9388601184,
-0.0233360548,
1.3438119888,
-0.4053741992,
-0.1014883295,
1.0775021315,
-0.302798748,
0.9878439903,
0.4487530589,
-0.4196962714,
0.6025933623,
0.9013321996,
0.0339940079,
0.3902085125,
0.1391338408,
-0.1099645197,
-0.5789165497,
0.0312135033,
-0.3108333051,
0.4832398593,
0.6653004289,
-0.3397851586,
0.1785161495,
-0.1054982767,
-0.189588815,
0.2547774315,
-0.3041071296,
0.7798963785,
0.1296245754,
-1.0077326298,
0.6884856224,
-0.0274890121,
0.7274337411,
-0.6162272096,
0.2193986177,
-0.0171418935,
0.1753622293,
-0.0413264334,
-0.9485209584,
-0.0683480352,
-0.1248011515,
-0.4820854962,
-0.0190165509,
0.4181411564,
-0.3609861434,
-0.5528072119,
0.1152151674,
0.4970009029,
0.1581636071,
0.1609570682,
-0.4864162803,
-0.1507139355,
-0.0751323923,
-0.5694941282,
0.5931599736,
0.2920481861,
-0.2441224456,
0.6546102166,
0.8040013313,
0.2909449637,
0.1153477132,
0.0691562891,
0.2658624053,
-0.809366107,
-0.5045171976,
-0.9601765275,
-0.1007334739,
0.1852387935,
-0.385004878,
0.6949884892,
0.1519263387,
0.7151786685,
-0.0947041586,
0.5385367274,
0.4332869053,
0.3221698105,
-0.6831766963,
0.4021777809,
-0.4466062188,
0.275452286,
-0.0498463586,
-1.0123859644,
-0.0092764832,
0.4114891887,
-0.7790132165,
0.3096570671,
0.7499877214,
1.0037171841,
0.1033137068,
0.2281679958,
0.5043876767,
0.1464369595,
-0.0651140437,
0.5013958216,
0.6678042412,
0.1694809645,
0.1422192305,
-0.041068498,
-0.364754945,
-0.4102891684,
-0.9805509448,
-0.9421974421,
-0.4745261967,
0.0541393235,
-0.3624174893,
-0.0850439817,
0.9470394254,
0.6908234358,
-0.7057850361,
-0.2859508991,
-0.1568889171,
0.0747725666,
-0.4366486371,
-0.1932294518,
0.2854664624,
-0.3404681385,
-0.9753770828,
0.2867426276,
0.0557209477,
-0.0139455535,
-0.3820931613,
-0.2661603987,
0.0305791069,
0.437461406,
0.3826170564,
0.2820983529,
-0.9020695686,
-0.2560196817,
0.3038078249,
-0.3062964082,
-0.027291581,
0.8328828812,
-0.7166586518,
0.4161851108,
0.3602753878,
0.3661130369,
0.2867979705,
0.0349359252,
0.8661937118,
-0.5165258646,
0.0966472253,
0.1783833951,
0.2766708434,
0.1666907519,
-0.4614847898,
0.2499227077,
0.0059450138,
-0.6242499948,
-0.6419950128,
0.4543298483,
-0.6558665633,
-0.2220818698,
1.0866682529,
0.2052947432,
-0.6213492751,
0.2084958702,
-0.1504764855,
0.0864636675,
-0.3689789772,
0.6617506146,
1.0710014105,
-0.363786459,
-0.1561264545,
-0.6936283708,
0.4904983044,
0.825630188,
-0.4839904904,
0.3431047797,
0.5546711087,
0.2098280638,
-0.0444250591,
0.4777514935,
0.1032622308,
0.3498642147,
-0.0542832091,
-0.085663341,
-0.0689705759,
-0.2269140929,
-0.5435499549,
-0.2404055446,
0.2896016538,
0.2006147653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07470v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07470v2
|
Finding and Editing Multi-Modal Neurons in Pre-Trained Transformers
| 2023-11-13T17:03:02 | 2024-06-11T12:30:02 |
Haowen Pan, Yixin Cao, Xiaozhi Wang, Xun Yang, Meng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding the internal mechanisms by which multi-modal large language
models (LLMs) interpret different modalities and integrate cross-modal
representations is becoming increasingly critical for continuous improvements
in both academia and industry. In this paper, we propose a novel method to
identify key neurons for interpretability -- how multi-modal LLMs bridge visual
and textual concepts for captioning. Our method improves conventional works
upon efficiency and applied range by removing needs of costly gradient
computation. Based on those identified neurons, we further design a multi-modal
knowledge editing method, beneficial to mitigate sensitive words or
hallucination. For rationale of our design, we provide theoretical assumption.
For empirical evaluation, we have conducted extensive quantitative and
qualitative experiments. The results not only validate the effectiveness of our
methods, but also offer insightful findings that highlight three key properties
of multi-modal neurons: sensitivity, specificity and causal-effect, to shed
light for future research.
|
[
-0.4550531507,
-0.5404834747,
0.6299068928,
0.2012580931,
-0.1704547107,
0.1229626983,
-0.6260203123,
-0.4146860242,
0.0271961186,
0.0144788167,
-0.6000964642,
-0.2271311581,
-0.6321763396,
0.1596637666,
-0.1746253967,
0.6851405501,
-0.0078690844,
0.4419922233,
-0.3818753958,
-0.3026362956,
-0.6189861298,
-0.3397790194,
-0.2956239283,
-0.2412602901,
0.8743257523,
0.043555256,
0.8469561934,
0.3191317022,
0.3976612985,
0.4173429906,
-0.3798627555,
0.3055506945,
-0.1725370437,
-0.0303711873,
-0.2388105839,
-0.7342463136,
-0.5628266931,
0.0409721695,
0.6089636683,
0.4319933951,
0.1846772134,
-0.0675801039,
0.1414337456,
0.2956629992,
-0.4453534186,
0.4141584933,
-0.7012340426,
0.1053026393,
-0.0316176787,
-0.7224596739,
-0.6611998677,
0.1551532298,
-0.0691022649,
-0.8101822138,
0.3264905214,
-0.0674516261,
0.6270037293,
0.4097097218,
-0.2821793854,
0.091211006,
-0.4674525261,
0.7281856537,
-0.5921987295,
0.6083058119,
0.2153965086,
0.2184322476,
0.1103931963,
-0.6954820156,
-0.7768437862,
-0.2326675504,
-0.5071965456,
0.1471243799,
0.0150950076,
0.2715362906,
0.4418798685,
0.0027115042,
-0.2109240741,
0.0287505519,
-0.4629586935,
-0.5219010115,
0.3109712601,
0.0046159853,
0.4326459765,
-0.4318760931,
-0.3769360781,
0.086367324,
-0.4783514738,
0.031230215,
0.298538506,
0.1653446257,
-0.0744971633,
0.7551906109,
-0.0426842868,
0.5379730463,
-0.1258197129,
-0.0874188021,
0.3432385027,
-0.4435341656,
-0.2348898202,
-0.1979244053,
0.7611281872,
0.4118153751,
0.2834430337,
-0.3868156374,
-0.2879598141,
-0.0875293538,
0.6767485142,
-0.5361881256,
-0.0590389669,
-0.1678906977,
-0.8456982374,
-0.5072817802,
-0.22005409,
-0.7413187027,
-0.6168337464,
-0.6507056952,
0.7924183011,
-0.4238153696,
-0.2567933202,
0.0263478458,
-0.3543765545,
0.1031271368,
0.4839408696,
-0.8753228784,
-0.0745743662,
0.3113648891,
0.9025327563,
-0.0848010257,
-0.7575175166,
-0.2149268389,
0.200109601,
-0.1015308574,
0.5773672462,
-0.634540379,
-0.0749014467,
-0.1690105945,
0.1105612963,
-0.3284710348,
-0.3509441912,
0.5349131227,
-0.9784884453,
-0.0568991005,
-0.2282526493,
-0.1428406239,
-0.4150258899,
0.1428329498,
-1.0278315544,
0.4822029471,
-0.047139857,
-0.7902820706,
0.3016908765,
-0.9993566871,
-0.581805706,
-0.2001562715,
-0.2996552587,
-0.1219244748,
0.4502637982,
0.4407763779,
0.5486518741,
-0.1942156702,
0.3553987741,
0.0702125505,
-0.0543868281,
0.7835049629,
-0.8098399043,
0.4162674248,
-0.0152150868,
-0.326186657,
0.807002902,
-0.5437524915,
-0.1407086402,
-0.0160952304,
-0.2446269393,
-0.0659745783,
0.1312717795,
0.2543404102,
0.336470902,
0.0295704231,
-0.1401226521,
0.1788660735,
-0.0611680225,
0.7635788918,
0.9740303755,
-0.1930812448,
0.627784133,
-0.3234720826,
0.5638580322,
0.2683905661,
0.444580853,
-0.2457562536,
-0.4574572444,
-0.7880243063,
-0.3087943792,
0.1956432164,
0.1657923311,
-1.0779083967,
0.2678441405,
-0.4018446207,
-0.3595151305,
-0.5013018847,
0.1205945909,
-0.005811641,
0.393019706,
0.7122133374,
-0.1886250675,
-0.183218196,
-1.0309642553,
-0.4119509757,
0.2394584268,
0.0125856232,
0.2120430171,
0.4035291076,
-0.3587500453,
0.8208688498,
-0.2787507176,
-0.220790416,
-0.1140998304,
0.3478119075,
-0.0791996643,
0.4186686575,
0.4200041294,
-0.8983541131,
-0.1066414714,
-0.0311202221,
-0.7379530072,
0.0566598698,
-0.8354430795,
-0.0111308945,
-0.2032707483,
0.7941737175,
-1.0056970119,
0.4180100262,
0.4131529331,
-0.0203746986,
0.5873681307,
-0.1079223678,
0.2708376348,
-0.7929878235,
0.0741787404,
-0.0250441935,
-0.0660032332,
-0.5903398991,
-0.0007184559,
0.4473311603,
0.1794257611,
-0.4123781621,
0.245596841,
-0.5902330279,
0.0330253132,
-0.0215794165,
0.2598790228,
0.1391679496,
0.8073250055,
-0.0822325349,
0.8622670174,
0.5954149365,
-0.3241161704,
0.4220952988,
0.3478116393,
-0.6273654699,
0.4583050311,
-0.6420556903,
-0.1207281649,
-0.4224338531,
0.0155925639,
-0.9675770998,
-0.1174286678,
0.397013247,
-0.310585916,
0.4641492367,
-0.0126495492,
-0.4785666168,
0.0243375003,
-0.1427278817,
0.7523630261,
-0.059645202,
-0.6544142365,
1.0967648029,
-0.0043304218,
-0.1755392998,
-0.5815494657,
-0.6701724529,
0.2996791899,
-0.1007447764,
-0.6122063994,
0.5814060569,
-0.3576045632,
-0.0531645231,
-0.0946384519,
-0.118065238,
-0.1099574417,
0.1072134078,
0.2698518634,
0.28176561,
-0.2041717917,
0.5489248037,
0.2513386905,
-0.2065463662,
0.213822335,
0.3666062355,
0.5182247758,
-0.0607975349,
-0.4778719246,
-0.7324784398,
0.1923122108,
1.1706039906,
-0.6508271694,
0.5817974806,
0.7910603881,
-0.2085100114,
-0.2202017307,
-0.5146283507,
-0.4603991508,
-0.5188308954,
0.5574141741,
-0.6066935658,
-0.4905617535,
0.4883689284,
-0.3255025744,
-0.369266957,
0.4087245762,
0.4742569625,
0.1528167725,
1.0282820463,
0.5282226801,
-0.0175552852,
0.5724190474,
-0.1205670238,
0.3672190607,
-1.0645028353,
-0.5282946825,
-0.2192267776,
-0.5572445989,
-0.1691047847,
-0.6516176462,
0.5036156178,
0.1642120183,
0.2881887257,
0.161119312,
-0.533942163,
0.5850218534,
0.3868392706,
0.3686240911,
0.4677432775,
-0.2016030252,
-0.0828285366,
-0.1238132566,
-0.6422236562,
-0.2633583248,
1.0091574192,
0.5103061199,
0.9137333035,
0.055266913,
-0.0454405807,
0.2388700396,
0.486859113,
-1.161442399,
0.45582214,
0.3530831635,
-0.6784784198,
-0.2973022759,
-0.2121735364,
-0.5910946727,
0.5000581741,
-0.5243428349,
-0.3593244851,
0.2373264283,
-0.1215780526,
-0.4443525076,
0.428534627,
-0.7314321399,
1.0321965218,
-0.5598909855,
-0.3059241772,
-0.5827158093,
-0.8223291636,
0.2265466899,
-0.1597154588,
0.3858486414,
0.2403509468,
-0.2107216269,
0.5662568808,
0.0869618431,
1.0897058249,
0.0128213251,
-0.0195615906,
-0.0001712204,
0.0087437294,
0.1840691715,
0.2173500061,
0.0496690236,
0.2939511538,
-0.1538784355,
-0.0535360016,
-0.7739146948,
0.4915880859,
-0.886014998,
-0.4198497236,
-0.2835218906,
-1.0171045065,
-0.1873874217,
0.2248185724,
0.147106275,
0.6063041091,
-0.0755392984,
0.2583202124,
0.5146937966,
-0.3732065558,
0.7134584188,
0.1093630716,
-0.0489562638,
-0.3989144266,
0.5857021809,
0.00245378,
0.2207208574,
0.3306006491,
0.1139965355,
-0.2224349678,
-0.6681826711,
-0.4897666574,
0.1767325997,
-0.9288688898,
-0.2777638733,
-0.6728785634,
-0.2347804755,
-0.1581574529,
-0.145473972,
-0.2093566805,
-0.2860682011,
-0.5233922005,
-0.0786413178,
0.1979727298,
0.7157843709,
-0.1547396332,
0.5172755718,
-0.8311511278,
0.7175498605,
0.4771603048,
0.6376212835,
0.1980319172,
-0.4961262047,
-0.2631920576,
0.1105262265,
-0.1909431517,
-1.0730421543,
0.2919951677,
0.2607092857,
0.8136568666,
0.4706225991,
-0.3457589746,
0.6234773993,
-0.4742956758,
0.6211799979,
0.447424382,
-1.3422766924,
0.3074354529,
-0.1517375112,
0.1029475182,
0.3518876731,
0.5085715055,
-0.5525913835,
0.0479609929,
-0.3317915797,
-0.5736609101,
0.6777294278,
0.0153152617,
0.3083114922,
0.2701022625,
0.3147208393,
0.2437348813,
0.5316923857,
-0.9446988702,
-0.2672667205,
-0.3838966191,
-0.0175809115,
-0.2101753056,
-0.3031001985,
-0.4714809954,
-0.6156221628,
0.3107609749,
-0.3376780748,
0.313894242,
0.1815664619,
-0.6219723225,
-0.1022161543,
0.3849629164,
0.9427136183,
0.9539027214,
0.095653072,
0.384134382,
0.17187047,
-0.3447909653,
-0.1554680914,
-0.15477027,
0.1164351255,
0.0546454303,
0.5047290325,
0.8852940798,
0.2063459307,
-0.497944802,
0.7894461751,
-0.0816961154,
-0.0393014215,
-0.132082805,
-0.1047062427,
-0.0200149864,
0.4394814968,
0.2509303093,
0.802290678,
-0.0565745831,
-0.4725281596,
0.1053630561,
0.4058910608,
-0.4277916849,
-0.4794754386,
0.6955633163,
0.225595966,
-0.1967415214,
0.5168562531,
0.0767681673,
-0.6493258476,
0.418551445,
0.3375808597,
0.8623372316,
-0.1759174615,
0.2598984838,
0.1142839789,
0.6213541031,
0.0814053789,
0.0660574585,
-0.0081623122,
-0.9782105088,
-0.7639986873,
-0.4425470829,
-0.0016786045,
0.1618421078,
-0.6634727716,
0.1616010368,
-0.3481354117,
-0.2938850522,
0.4240294993,
-0.8420414925,
-0.7531258464,
0.0448684692,
0.0129689761,
0.7652772069,
-0.9940122366,
0.8646003008,
0.6031400561,
-0.6491359472,
-0.5618975759,
-0.1131636649,
-0.0514478087,
-0.8202483654,
0.7020819783,
0.1071285158,
-0.1650954485,
-0.0499175489,
-0.7020204067,
-0.5015426278,
0.9817455411,
0.2000665367,
-0.4970085621,
-0.1794557124,
0.141014874,
0.4228340387,
-0.2000104636,
0.5355011225,
0.4965753257,
0.9217629433,
-0.2193817943,
-0.9387189746,
0.1689252555,
-0.3286061287,
-0.2380616516,
-0.1074498519,
-0.4492633343,
0.7719020247,
-0.2417773604,
-0.0789287016,
-0.0463625491,
0.440276891,
-0.4240795672,
0.0434158184,
0.6116679311,
0.317463696,
0.578653872,
-0.0216987971,
0.6803127527,
-0.4136491418,
0.1475885361,
0.9946982265,
0.2293290645,
0.5656965971,
0.995075345,
0.1495076269,
0.3950678408,
0.3021706343,
-0.2711037397,
0.5462916493,
0.1776223034,
-0.3073727489,
-0.4529352188,
-0.1080471575,
-0.2795083523,
0.5799721479,
0.2776525021,
-0.5717385411,
0.044985909,
0.3046785891,
-0.0715874955,
-0.0164369009,
-0.2507008612,
0.6196600199,
0.0562783889,
-0.4391545057,
0.4120674729,
-0.0031904916,
0.8128026128,
-0.4636625051,
0.0163880643,
0.20943968,
-0.0738914981,
-0.4600048661,
-0.7432267666,
0.2566236854,
-0.4069772363,
-0.2734356523,
-0.5149774551,
0.6071288586,
-0.3699296415,
-0.2461077571,
0.4134481251,
0.7469642758,
-0.2631420493,
-0.4748934805,
-0.5481356978,
0.3317896128,
-0.1502774507,
-0.3064394593,
0.0317456387,
0.4204728007,
0.2449405938,
0.4763552845,
0.584408462,
0.0131173097,
0.1870729029,
0.3466685414,
1.0879958868,
-0.6974053979,
-0.1038020849,
-0.8141853213,
0.9254509211,
-0.074274458,
-0.3263631761,
0.4557828307,
0.4354892671,
0.7875890136,
-0.4118365645,
0.7716735005,
-0.0528090708,
-0.0624314956,
-0.5837112069,
1.0547806025,
-0.5935257673,
0.1833163351,
-0.1000178531,
-0.9498561025,
-0.5674437284,
0.6041373014,
-0.2603553832,
-0.0330361091,
1.0823203325,
1.2043594122,
-0.2362400889,
0.1529535353,
0.3332098722,
0.419095844,
0.3388631046,
0.152189374,
1.2629919052,
-0.3305296898,
0.5798989534,
-0.4227595031,
-0.1303534955,
0.0022618095,
-0.8299216032,
-0.9670754075,
-0.6595866084,
-0.1718123108,
0.0527534336,
-0.3316117525,
0.5612398982,
0.6143352985,
-0.5080505013,
0.0170114897,
0.0637950599,
0.269361496,
-0.3441820443,
-0.1530166417,
0.3843782842,
-0.6157969236,
-0.5375381112,
0.6970740557,
0.1678298116,
-0.1768434495,
-0.2707696855,
-0.0368493609,
-0.074398607,
-0.0653234795,
0.9337977767,
-0.2158730179,
-0.8685716987,
-0.5430522561,
0.1998829842,
-0.0149281099,
0.2206890136,
1.0274541378,
-0.5185902715,
0.7928469777,
0.609960258,
0.5274258256,
0.2488731444,
-0.2549610436,
0.4639899135,
-0.5537058115,
0.103011027,
0.1747035682,
0.4815240502,
0.2451850623,
-0.0359986238,
0.18872343,
0.34034127,
-0.3807392716,
-0.4897519648,
0.1922551841,
-1.3496755362,
-0.3704916239,
1.0849812031,
0.2206031233,
-0.0082873814,
-0.1167211235,
-0.5973389745,
0.3984289765,
0.0541463867,
0.8089984059,
0.5673877001,
0.1325458586,
-0.332012862,
-0.7322391868,
0.5309568048,
0.4408741593,
-0.7799001932,
-0.0159962494,
0.6748638153,
0.1013506651,
0.3680965304,
0.0775939301,
-0.2289973348,
0.229848668,
-0.1782668531,
0.3660202622,
-0.2280941755,
-0.7029861808,
-0.565468967,
0.2604691088,
0.0635876507,
-0.1111210138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07469v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07469v2
|
InCA: Rethinking In-Car Conversational System Assessment Leveraging Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T17:02:06 | 2023-11-15T22:10:34 |
Ken E. Friedl, Abbas Goher Khan, Soumya Ranjan Sahoo, Md Rashad Al Hasan Rony, Jana Germies, Christian Süß
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The assessment of advanced generative large language models (LLMs) poses a
significant challenge, given their heightened complexity in recent
developments. Furthermore, evaluating the performance of LLM-based applications
in various industries, as indicated by Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), is a
complex undertaking. This task necessitates a profound understanding of
industry use cases and the anticipated system behavior. Within the context of
the automotive industry, existing evaluation metrics prove inadequate for
assessing in-car conversational question answering (ConvQA) systems. The unique
demands of these systems, where answers may relate to driver or car safety and
are confined within the car domain, highlight the limitations of current
metrics. To address these challenges, this paper introduces a set of KPIs
tailored for evaluating the performance of in-car ConvQA systems, along with
datasets specifically designed for these KPIs. A preliminary and comprehensive
empirical evaluation substantiates the efficacy of our proposed approach.
Furthermore, we investigate the impact of employing varied personas in prompts
and found that it enhances the model's capacity to simulate diverse viewpoints
in assessments, mirroring how individuals with different backgrounds perceive a
topic.
|
[
-0.4885702431,
-0.5078547001,
0.6070047617,
0.426130712,
-0.10375534,
0.4553838372,
-0.2700108588,
-0.7291298509,
-0.2344331294,
0.1454164833,
-0.5071952939,
-0.2442561686,
-0.2579905391,
-0.0431043729,
-0.299269855,
0.4387593567,
0.2492103428,
0.0251882989,
-0.5019161105,
-0.0491036475,
-0.7705434561,
-0.5599932075,
-0.8486859798,
-0.0843143091,
0.397492528,
0.6083502173,
0.7149612308,
-0.0039657867,
0.3815619648,
0.2663769126,
-0.0403927565,
0.2060352713,
-0.425464958,
0.326133281,
0.1001716405,
-0.0996764526,
-0.1946465671,
-0.0138049182,
0.5888457894,
0.9276689887,
-0.2275200635,
-0.0960074291,
0.3996697962,
0.0302962251,
-1.0412201881,
0.2160159945,
-0.7012327313,
-0.3106615245,
0.096866563,
-0.082964085,
-0.4103508592,
-0.4998518229,
0.2375588119,
-0.4247979522,
-0.0790654495,
0.0831949338,
0.6513862014,
0.2922493517,
-0.2991547287,
-0.5291261077,
-0.8829911947,
0.7223342061,
-0.9437904954,
0.4601917267,
-0.019769134,
0.5819214582,
-0.2886962295,
-0.4889335036,
-0.8013123274,
-0.7249550223,
0.1568889916,
0.1469317377,
-0.125910908,
-0.045811791,
0.123146683,
0.527489841,
-0.4838394225,
0.7011142373,
-0.0727573112,
-0.1624175757,
0.6185554862,
0.8079442978,
0.1561903805,
0.3054244518,
-0.3103216588,
-0.1337237805,
-0.8006080389,
0.4354523122,
0.1146324873,
0.2328866571,
-0.1285852641,
0.3791992962,
-0.5001782775,
0.4231831431,
-0.0015703251,
-0.1586128175,
0.2618593574,
-0.2236353755,
-0.4727774262,
0.0005227424,
1.1254246235,
0.5890489817,
-0.0353212468,
-0.3457187414,
-0.067371048,
0.0017852866,
0.037987601,
-0.8400428891,
0.1675754488,
0.2612302899,
-0.0861788169,
-0.0274727829,
-0.1296666861,
-0.9197813869,
-0.57779181,
-0.2962287068,
0.2240654528,
-0.2473165989,
0.0076702037,
0.3929311633,
0.1230401769,
0.7833389044,
0.3702616394,
-0.8489483595,
0.2556649446,
0.7991223335,
0.7300988436,
-0.0461778007,
-0.1371100247,
-0.4493488371,
0.090660423,
-0.3272563219,
0.811660111,
-0.7263125777,
-0.5972684026,
0.116719164,
-0.1346399933,
-0.0352685116,
-0.6266680956,
0.4129095674,
-0.5649682879,
0.0773071796,
-0.4761334062,
-0.4868927002,
-0.0919705704,
0.4688418806,
-0.1976759285,
0.7791447043,
0.1404283196,
-0.2689524591,
0.5255641341,
-0.5179537535,
-0.3275221288,
0.3385699987,
-0.2762639523,
-0.2626012862,
0.0134159792,
0.2546387911,
0.4968562722,
-0.7174013257,
0.4659353793,
-0.4045526087,
-0.3549315333,
0.5954148173,
-0.7656564713,
0.5640212893,
0.224611342,
-0.1848516613,
-0.0103423502,
-0.6850605011,
0.0910403356,
-0.4496083558,
-0.392773062,
-0.2752356827,
-0.0281911995,
0.0615491681,
0.0994115695,
0.2865363359,
-0.7404286861,
0.0152111072,
-0.4879092574,
0.3748030365,
0.5597553253,
0.2313846946,
0.1836998612,
-0.1915260106,
0.7792243958,
-0.1454441845,
0.3124766648,
-0.0823012143,
-0.4857762456,
-0.8712621927,
-0.2273076624,
-0.0005777987,
0.5697383285,
-0.5698086023,
0.2675545514,
-0.2154522091,
-1.0476719141,
-0.3529625237,
-0.2333873659,
0.5221589804,
0.5600572824,
0.039355997,
-0.6369096041,
-0.0407016687,
-0.9237254262,
-0.2055356801,
-0.5657470822,
-0.2024468631,
0.5163272023,
0.2638445199,
-0.2315131724,
0.8204100728,
-0.3973122537,
0.2353758067,
-0.2345258147,
-0.0730986446,
-0.0267531332,
0.301333487,
0.4655632079,
-0.4290197194,
-0.3089003265,
0.1634236872,
-0.6860944033,
-0.2535319626,
-0.1559582204,
0.1479995549,
-0.3182465434,
0.6244119406,
-0.4762880802,
0.36096856,
0.3653486371,
-0.2620566189,
0.7959902287,
-0.1883616447,
0.3462119102,
-0.5762414932,
-0.0249055326,
0.1399409175,
-0.0675623268,
-0.4348142743,
-0.0436110757,
-0.1416032612,
-0.035427589,
-0.6706440449,
0.2687842846,
-0.2292836905,
-0.2472031415,
-0.2514869869,
-0.0262986924,
0.0831483752,
0.4524977505,
-0.3769868612,
1.263682127,
0.5615961552,
-1.0172692537,
0.4384100437,
0.2992996871,
-0.9362973571,
0.6402113438,
-0.8635553122,
0.2397980839,
-0.0651543513,
0.0501232296,
-1.1446758509,
-0.151442185,
0.2128222287,
-0.2774273455,
0.0220860578,
0.309373349,
-0.445247978,
0.0501030423,
0.2382309437,
0.60422647,
0.2498909831,
-0.2508840561,
0.4112510681,
0.6692056656,
-0.3011046946,
-0.2258468121,
-0.1557306945,
0.473109901,
-0.7026118636,
-0.6074596047,
0.2964003384,
-0.1944503486,
-0.5318270326,
-0.6565185785,
0.1312377155,
-0.0100268451,
0.5055046082,
0.2627725303,
0.1568094641,
-0.1896693408,
0.1741645187,
-0.0710077435,
-0.0145650273,
0.2899601161,
0.2426671535,
0.6700886488,
-0.293936044,
-0.124766551,
-0.8066439629,
0.3390001059,
0.93115592,
-0.4683354795,
0.5550996661,
0.016624514,
-0.2024844587,
0.0453204885,
-0.3749512136,
0.1231874302,
-0.5324848294,
0.4387347102,
-0.5447067022,
-0.8648704886,
0.7132327557,
-0.1791935861,
0.2713825703,
0.2501879334,
0.9948420525,
-0.2946308553,
0.9247003794,
0.5248355269,
-0.0983493626,
0.5240766406,
-0.0542206913,
0.3568226099,
-0.9290360212,
-0.8796632886,
-0.7635486126,
-0.1579912156,
-0.647405386,
-0.1684053093,
0.6660269499,
-0.4586984515,
-0.4929030836,
0.259616226,
-0.0363750197,
0.1757176965,
0.3727327883,
0.08553195,
0.3573313355,
-0.4072365463,
0.2802539766,
0.1628647745,
-0.555767417,
-0.7345210314,
0.676954031,
0.4983831048,
0.8536442518,
0.1557652503,
-0.1206396446,
0.2935703695,
0.5150071383,
-1.0770744085,
0.6032767892,
0.0916990861,
-0.3056416214,
-0.3247044981,
-0.4556230605,
-0.8933417201,
0.1144311056,
0.1016347259,
-0.803060472,
0.568747282,
-0.2553863227,
-0.918811202,
-0.2128356844,
-0.73138237,
0.9071928263,
-0.4674743414,
-0.1562830508,
-0.0688125417,
-0.3659022748,
0.264473021,
-0.012277117,
0.1203460395,
-0.2003416717,
-0.0346213132,
0.6248486042,
-0.2917731404,
0.762027204,
-0.0008549469,
-0.4270583391,
0.310986042,
0.0708959103,
0.14754875,
0.1087405011,
-0.2376544923,
0.0234563481,
0.0550759733,
-0.2008920312,
-1.0232628584,
0.7386361957,
-0.6901789308,
-0.6341141462,
-0.1792665571,
-0.611135602,
-0.8849382401,
-0.3372202218,
0.0386577435,
0.6046836376,
-0.3738766611,
0.2620045543,
0.4754998982,
-0.6624925733,
0.4903748631,
0.5591751337,
0.1086671352,
-0.1712640822,
0.6004295945,
-0.0652483031,
0.5558878183,
0.2598869503,
0.0677479953,
-0.4610435367,
-0.5465672612,
-0.4444931448,
-0.0479644351,
-0.6683588028,
-0.056256026,
-0.4174871743,
-0.0888044685,
-0.262437433,
0.1691677421,
-0.4134508073,
-0.1303905249,
-0.296864152,
-0.0665066913,
-0.0652079359,
0.4858842492,
0.4614231586,
0.871756196,
-0.3945745826,
-0.1893390268,
0.5232103467,
0.356629163,
0.1868653744,
-0.6305538416,
-0.2568281889,
0.070997335,
-0.5582088828,
-0.7323292494,
0.3216609657,
0.0639002174,
0.6875935197,
0.5017568469,
0.0054315249,
0.8767076135,
-0.2836692631,
0.9230518937,
0.1235040352,
-0.7996295094,
0.2362799644,
-0.2362960279,
0.0702061132,
0.8642703295,
0.025403671,
-0.7118952274,
-0.5353212357,
-0.3828818798,
-0.7960787416,
0.0945138261,
0.262581557,
0.4130441546,
-0.0117441928,
0.4276238978,
0.1085433364,
0.2400474101,
-0.4267654717,
-0.0066376752,
0.1575998664,
-0.143796891,
-0.2600828707,
-0.0703725442,
0.3922560513,
-0.1492655724,
0.5811646581,
-0.0109321363,
-0.0173160024,
0.1456043124,
0.2177831531,
0.3780593276,
0.3374074399,
0.4767031372,
0.7228149772,
-0.1439014226,
-0.0431645848,
0.1089242846,
-0.2195961624,
0.3345649838,
-0.2499515116,
-0.0676854551,
-0.1759109795,
0.0321751833,
0.7100589871,
0.1199885458,
-1.0456683636,
0.2604290843,
-0.1972763836,
0.3915553689,
-0.4649921954,
0.352206707,
-0.317201674,
0.0816949829,
0.23887299,
-0.3095411956,
0.2713130414,
-0.9722520709,
-0.0155266682,
0.6831430793,
-0.7701126337,
-0.1760158539,
0.5769494176,
0.2661834061,
-0.5698288679,
0.5116685033,
-0.0198451057,
-0.3696389794,
0.8690675497,
0.0573027171,
1.0609586239,
-0.2571038604,
-0.0227254275,
0.3016739786,
0.4302503467,
0.1473809332,
-0.0570040829,
0.0481739119,
-0.8160560727,
-0.4193234146,
-0.4139621556,
-0.775785625,
0.5480966568,
-0.4351200163,
0.2292135209,
-0.4486138523,
-0.2316731811,
0.0626013353,
-0.0738786459,
-0.7521942258,
0.5475040078,
0.1881923676,
0.9108293056,
-0.6660322547,
0.3998593986,
0.3325004578,
-0.3446471989,
-0.6754984856,
0.1325312108,
-0.3742657304,
-0.589283824,
0.3428348303,
0.211533919,
-0.2734841704,
-0.4102552831,
-0.6643339992,
-0.5371225476,
0.9938125014,
0.4223417044,
-0.6977525949,
-0.0699282289,
0.405295521,
0.5715016127,
-0.7626107335,
0.3696124554,
1.0299084187,
0.2326949388,
-0.0128486631,
-1.2083759308,
-0.1600745022,
-0.1119494736,
-0.003757243,
-0.2266296595,
-0.9172616601,
0.4357130826,
0.1843219399,
-0.2105297893,
0.3014430404,
0.7067660689,
0.4133419096,
0.6360669136,
0.6743616462,
0.3668102026,
0.732834518,
0.0625234023,
1.1109650135,
-0.015097593,
0.1281499863,
1.1966718435,
-0.4358768463,
0.6891953349,
0.5862864852,
-0.2568610311,
0.6105249524,
0.7767682672,
0.1592674702,
0.5762581825,
0.3627304137,
-0.476280421,
-0.6253249049,
-0.3033611178,
-0.226169467,
0.8962855935,
0.6155687571,
-0.1924404949,
-0.2152023017,
0.1487949342,
-0.12083745,
-0.0353173576,
-0.3733744323,
0.7409957647,
0.0959408358,
-0.8024539351,
0.3044931293,
0.0043861661,
0.349844873,
-0.2731838226,
0.162809059,
-0.420881182,
0.0165488124,
0.2081456035,
-0.7649772763,
0.2784388959,
0.2130873501,
-0.0006362407,
-0.0661978573,
0.1887868047,
-0.0752106905,
-0.504668951,
-0.0618802719,
0.4500654638,
0.3438420594,
-0.08340469,
-0.4962352514,
0.1226506308,
-0.2374023199,
0.0707130283,
0.1365679502,
0.519844234,
-0.1697429717,
1.1049101353,
0.4180667996,
-0.1849986166,
-0.1470342278,
0.2224421203,
0.8412893414,
-0.4597739577,
-0.59897089,
-0.9513056278,
0.4751868546,
0.1891326904,
-0.6227811575,
0.7800841331,
0.9327403903,
0.689942956,
0.3716661036,
0.8306226134,
0.1443475634,
0.2954652607,
-0.3887931705,
0.4964559078,
-0.4322796762,
0.7538212538,
-0.429523766,
-0.7179514766,
-0.0462776087,
0.2324793488,
-0.5412500501,
-0.0817104951,
0.0446130112,
1.0219764709,
0.0530246459,
0.1132971495,
0.4539976418,
0.1642097682,
0.8298527598,
0.8454115987,
1.5650342703,
-0.4264873862,
0.4922774136,
0.0450086854,
-0.2873840034,
-0.0793429166,
-0.6598032117,
-0.5260950923,
-0.5420802832,
-0.4381107092,
-0.2656098902,
-0.2381713837,
0.5548865795,
0.5270957351,
-0.5544669032,
-0.4519346058,
0.1494317949,
-0.083280243,
-0.160043329,
-0.221196264,
0.1333954185,
-0.288407594,
-0.8031233549,
0.5980600715,
0.418879509,
0.0000501784,
-0.5753760338,
-0.0340202041,
0.3549057543,
0.2601585388,
0.6054026484,
0.1120970473,
-0.5949690342,
-0.4927306473,
0.090053834,
-0.1358238161,
0.1438921839,
0.9197188616,
-0.94212538,
0.3807814121,
0.2351201922,
0.6141084433,
0.1665880382,
0.0651124641,
0.7700551748,
-0.3500258923,
0.0476089083,
0.3363629282,
0.2893593609,
0.6266067624,
-0.272324264,
0.0567018427,
-0.0427516066,
-0.5807141066,
-0.8586187959,
0.388114959,
-1.0256820917,
-0.0753475279,
1.1892549992,
-0.0969752744,
0.0076452792,
-0.60960567,
-0.1756829023,
-0.012679792,
-0.3511443138,
0.9894062877,
0.535779953,
-0.0750716999,
-0.2708454132,
-0.5454428196,
0.367684871,
0.2740983367,
-0.9561141729,
0.227989614,
0.5583819151,
0.2591088414,
0.0104659935,
0.5209904313,
0.09692958,
0.3050396442,
-0.3851445317,
-0.3191438615,
0.273714155,
-0.2583684623,
-0.2652845979,
0.364931494,
0.0938036963,
-0.2880600989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07468v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07468v2
|
Are We Falling in a Middle-Intelligence Trap? An Analysis and Mitigation of the Reversal Curse
| 2023-11-13T17:01:12 | 2023-11-16T08:35:05 |
Ang Lv, Kaiyi Zhang, Shufang Xie, Quan Tu, Yuhan Chen, Ji-Rong Wen, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent studies have highlighted a phenomenon in large language models (LLMs)
known as "the reversal curse," in which the order of knowledge entities in the
training data biases the models' comprehension. For example, if a model is
trained on sentences where entity A consistently appears before entity B, it
can respond to queries about A by providing B as the answer. However, it may
encounter confusion when presented with questions concerning B. We contend that
the reversal curse is partially a result of specific model training objectives,
particularly evident in the prevalent use of the next-token prediction within
most causal language models. For the next-token prediction, models solely focus
on a token's preceding context, resulting in a restricted comprehension of the
input. In contrast, we illustrate that the GLM, trained using the
autoregressive blank infilling objective where tokens to be predicted have
access to the entire context, exhibits better resilience against the reversal
curse. We propose a novel training method, BIdirectional Casual language
modeling Optimization (BICO), designed to mitigate the reversal curse when
fine-tuning pretrained causal language models on new data. BICO modifies the
causal attention mechanism to function bidirectionally and employs a mask
denoising optimization. In the task designed to assess the reversal curse, our
approach improves Llama's accuracy from the original 0% to around 70%. We hope
that more attention can be focused on exploring and addressing these inherent
weaknesses of the current LLMs, in order to achieve a higher level of
intelligence.
|
[
-0.1237055957,
-0.6979801655,
0.3144080341,
0.151198402,
-0.4144561291,
0.4099833667,
-0.2788267136,
-0.2756260633,
0.1645664275,
0.7254313231,
-0.586820066,
-0.1697341651,
-0.8783542514,
0.0936776921,
-0.4677940011,
1.3509411812,
0.4959841967,
0.2093057483,
-0.3236443996,
0.1255776286,
-0.7008028626,
-0.4810062051,
-1.1241487265,
-0.5147958398,
0.6001642942,
0.5219590068,
0.7375369072,
0.3073485792,
0.2586148083,
0.1957071573,
0.1928414255,
0.0286624376,
-1.0189871788,
-0.1340798736,
-0.2329694629,
-0.8461527824,
-0.2104159445,
0.2406217903,
0.3948439658,
1.0078706741,
-0.3045092523,
0.3017594814,
-0.0190911088,
0.8131965995,
-0.7520380616,
-0.1503994465,
-1.1704456806,
-0.2116881013,
-0.3777115345,
-0.2920963168,
-0.377769649,
-0.1092800573,
0.0138895456,
-0.184403494,
0.4102681279,
0.3740389347,
0.9236070514,
0.5685738921,
-0.4237174392,
-0.1314745545,
-0.8291249275,
0.8436715603,
-0.6769752502,
0.3850301504,
0.4217122793,
0.3405412734,
-0.2253312469,
-0.3899900913,
-0.9128040075,
-0.201511547,
0.0742293224,
0.3695867658,
-0.3318624496,
-0.0794612691,
-0.032831993,
-0.0610111468,
-0.4537614286,
0.3731515408,
-0.5299908519,
-0.1418294311,
0.482468009,
0.2683368027,
0.4126887023,
0.0295209326,
-0.4994514585,
0.2878721356,
-1.1441035271,
0.1938412338,
0.6120423079,
0.2766118646,
0.0461833216,
0.3707840741,
0.1794182211,
0.6263814569,
0.0654957816,
-0.1162143946,
-0.1131931841,
-0.1615269333,
-0.2593009174,
0.2928135395,
0.2075608224,
0.5113381743,
0.4410621226,
-0.4814092219,
-0.258572042,
0.1722713411,
0.3827447891,
-0.5666190386,
-0.0951277763,
-0.0011653907,
-0.2359736264,
-0.3376800716,
-0.2418529689,
-0.6100124717,
-0.464170754,
-0.4738381803,
0.2479538918,
-0.0709470734,
-0.1202918664,
0.3568436503,
0.0637866482,
0.246468842,
0.0583530217,
-0.9570699334,
0.4277708232,
0.766946435,
0.566362977,
0.0497062355,
-0.2521930337,
-0.6467956305,
0.3322673142,
-0.4490860105,
0.5683429241,
-0.6229358912,
-0.335514009,
-0.2508972287,
-0.0756657794,
-0.2255391479,
-0.2912068665,
0.4933277667,
-0.6774657965,
0.1921811104,
-0.1237771213,
-0.0713580027,
-0.3307500184,
0.1855521351,
-0.2941179276,
0.6098272204,
-0.1612217575,
-0.8474336267,
0.1498716921,
0.0721040592,
-0.5537217855,
-0.1934318095,
-0.1919127107,
-0.5838656425,
0.2566148341,
0.178683117,
0.1862705946,
-0.769652307,
0.4982878864,
-0.3051480651,
-0.6499642134,
0.0771354586,
-0.6725586653,
1.0883828402,
-0.089105919,
-0.6122325659,
-0.2909264863,
-0.6364549398,
-0.5384026766,
0.1508888453,
-0.1184670255,
-0.706510365,
0.0779854208,
-0.4153988957,
0.2684582472,
0.129448548,
-0.4323453009,
0.0464252867,
-0.7962331176,
0.0916389823,
1.1523832083,
-0.1230689585,
0.3677369356,
-0.1000604257,
0.4951579273,
0.2223889083,
0.4945117831,
0.5315454602,
-0.5736358166,
-0.9271644354,
0.0551091135,
0.0069967457,
0.7456991076,
-0.7420418859,
0.2826957703,
-0.4777626991,
-0.3264065981,
-0.6832027435,
0.1679528654,
0.8608462811,
0.9141321778,
0.357521385,
-0.3599434793,
-0.6588929892,
-1.0224786997,
-0.5983381271,
-0.2539349198,
0.282025516,
0.200529933,
0.3525162637,
-0.3667700589,
0.8100219965,
-0.3680092394,
-0.2078218162,
-0.2728773952,
0.0776931122,
0.4957156777,
0.4354920387,
0.5375864506,
-0.9182616472,
-0.196614787,
-0.1154635474,
-0.4052106142,
-0.2303261757,
-0.1340201348,
-0.2194488794,
0.4811007679,
0.5744351745,
-0.5772806406,
0.5510892868,
0.4974380434,
-0.5058094859,
0.8168350458,
0.1276875287,
-0.2202248722,
-0.8172974586,
0.2736078501,
-0.6399405003,
0.2000415325,
-0.7435573936,
-0.3093723357,
-0.2470666617,
0.1701216102,
-0.0318809412,
0.6509351134,
-0.5591524243,
-0.1955970824,
-0.1482848823,
0.335796386,
-0.0276851933,
0.4983728826,
-0.4591153264,
0.6621263623,
0.6916950345,
-0.6142697334,
0.1495011896,
-0.0765508637,
-0.0563223287,
0.3952781558,
-0.4286616147,
0.4131695032,
-0.5608685017,
-0.1355832815,
-1.2191903591,
0.1682603806,
0.247012198,
-0.6331197619,
0.8263427019,
-0.1191614568,
-0.1336257905,
-0.7165399194,
-0.2536787689,
0.2823486328,
0.5694095492,
-0.5672415495,
0.6118212938,
0.1534394473,
-0.2047025859,
-1.2591612339,
-0.6915631294,
0.326995343,
-0.1818980426,
-0.4368574619,
0.175212428,
-0.1105898544,
-0.3562023044,
-0.0590715967,
-0.2609945238,
0.4325968921,
0.3260192871,
0.1908522248,
0.5476098657,
0.0157023128,
0.1159067526,
0.1795527786,
-0.2517946959,
0.0735058412,
-0.4487691224,
0.6326379776,
-0.081253916,
-0.2034540474,
-0.0033238663,
0.0468951762,
0.4214836657,
-0.2044466138,
0.8586786389,
0.2517019808,
-0.2030948848,
0.0250534192,
-0.8636015058,
-0.3397824466,
-0.4371179044,
0.2709419131,
-0.3049685657,
-0.5987583399,
0.6577258706,
0.2573839426,
-0.038811408,
0.1350963116,
0.4818140268,
-0.0479081199,
1.1860752106,
0.8080643415,
-0.4787743092,
0.3012826741,
-0.2332448214,
0.7148150802,
-0.7647030354,
-0.2073875815,
-0.5390648246,
-0.4238345325,
-0.3248045444,
-0.0771390274,
0.3757785261,
0.5295914412,
-0.2314242423,
-0.0186024662,
-0.276560396,
0.5001141429,
0.5234512091,
0.0830462575,
0.3836334348,
-0.0707129538,
-0.0207255762,
0.1690704077,
-0.6554326415,
-0.4601168931,
1.1673654318,
0.0021474485,
0.5517498851,
0.1556275785,
0.6879010797,
-0.0545767881,
0.6105320454,
-0.4486238062,
0.6064950824,
-0.2242247611,
-0.603769362,
-0.315703392,
-0.3489188552,
-1.1247502565,
0.1111444831,
0.0528257973,
-0.7338795066,
0.308690697,
0.0704908073,
-0.4317635894,
0.3900911212,
-0.7438931465,
0.6538448334,
-0.2811024487,
-0.4927968681,
-0.380310148,
-1.0890008211,
0.7226021886,
0.0742582679,
0.3657938838,
-0.124710016,
-0.0067189387,
0.6485271454,
-0.2710108757,
1.1843348742,
-0.2175935358,
-0.0228421427,
0.0888552666,
0.2345912457,
0.685415566,
0.1323254704,
0.1228096932,
-0.0565030277,
-0.3555482626,
-0.7225471139,
-0.6780899763,
0.6922368407,
-0.820250392,
-1.1867460012,
-0.2278131545,
-0.301240027,
-0.2924028337,
0.2447995543,
0.3563135564,
0.3560147583,
0.1606943905,
-0.3020483255,
0.5359125733,
-0.1327216029,
0.5664778948,
0.6746866107,
-0.1488895565,
-0.1662269384,
0.8918572664,
0.1379578412,
0.2731635273,
0.1840944439,
0.3267301321,
-0.0641153231,
-0.7364871502,
-0.2421545386,
0.5015105009,
-0.6278094649,
-0.4060342312,
-0.5099956989,
-0.0391190462,
-0.5338851213,
-0.1622633487,
-0.1923269629,
-0.3517421186,
-0.3765671551,
-0.153698951,
0.1709412783,
0.4873749614,
0.034468051,
0.1633681059,
-0.4475207627,
0.0982186124,
0.3493451178,
0.2790896297,
0.267760098,
-0.7662367821,
-0.1235772073,
-0.0250405222,
0.0468168519,
-0.7065938711,
0.2375144213,
0.0938287601,
0.5563898683,
0.7039375305,
-0.0388546176,
0.5804496408,
-0.500407517,
0.5765652061,
0.3347476721,
-0.7098696828,
0.3702156246,
-0.1176036075,
-0.0213938039,
0.5687698126,
0.3501928449,
-0.639226675,
-0.703774333,
-0.5722319484,
-0.6405635476,
0.4939096868,
-0.0693745986,
0.4396137893,
-0.1272118539,
0.5242699981,
0.3545479178,
0.3333193064,
-0.7086005211,
-0.2735284269,
-0.1159546152,
-0.0084388368,
-0.3781428635,
-0.3080581129,
-0.0847778916,
-0.3204615116,
0.8714491725,
0.017151773,
0.024547819,
0.0171435755,
-0.1761768758,
-0.172199592,
-0.0171605106,
0.657956779,
0.6117247343,
-0.073584497,
0.3937284648,
0.0613999292,
-0.8096637726,
-0.1758158952,
0.0513994992,
-0.4355941713,
-0.2365247607,
0.5287273526,
0.8634831905,
0.3585943878,
-0.5029146671,
0.6100252271,
0.1903376579,
0.2954303026,
-0.2574163079,
-0.1493262947,
0.019044498,
0.2594669461,
0.3713671565,
0.2694115341,
0.2754020691,
-0.7406429648,
-0.0835283846,
0.5943754911,
-0.250110358,
-0.4523293972,
0.5983737111,
0.0358176902,
-0.2879482806,
0.8471667171,
-0.1222448722,
-0.8388267756,
0.6669543386,
0.7872071266,
0.9153470993,
-0.4348763824,
-0.0305692554,
0.1402384639,
0.5126499534,
0.3512850106,
0.3115254939,
0.1980080605,
-0.9151966572,
-0.3038988113,
-0.6121124029,
0.0015293956,
-0.3837240338,
-0.5912837386,
0.2758717239,
-0.3666501641,
-0.0487175435,
-0.364882201,
-0.0296395365,
-0.791760087,
0.1506399214,
0.0950833037,
0.6789658666,
-0.6460072398,
0.8957998753,
0.1983803064,
-0.6267647743,
-0.548296392,
0.071120441,
-0.1999916732,
-1.1642078161,
0.8007477522,
0.116138503,
-0.5712610483,
0.3548670709,
-0.8904243112,
-0.7708090544,
1.0034624338,
0.327404201,
-0.6978623867,
-0.1970039606,
-0.0041368753,
0.5235540271,
-0.270829469,
-0.0269018281,
0.9753141403,
0.3594816625,
-0.1999292523,
-0.6873472929,
0.1174432635,
-0.1049485579,
-0.0349533036,
0.2517763972,
-0.7551962733,
0.7837610841,
-0.7316536307,
-0.2992500067,
-0.156277284,
0.2632923722,
0.1790005416,
0.5207413435,
0.5512688756,
0.5580120683,
0.6471289396,
0.0487606935,
1.1406987906,
-0.0434914269,
0.1426688135,
1.1684746742,
-0.2777605057,
0.6172472239,
0.9459038377,
0.0403962769,
0.7159164548,
0.4753928185,
0.1617257446,
0.7619322538,
0.4490799308,
-0.0990706757,
-0.1369104236,
0.0163118355,
-0.1175394729,
0.4052654803,
0.3635294437,
0.0469453447,
-0.1186253726,
0.3382205665,
0.3763970435,
0.1598057896,
-0.6040030718,
0.5012060404,
0.2167676538,
-0.6836109161,
0.803311348,
-0.180194959,
0.6204341054,
-0.2044035047,
0.2227998823,
-0.7480558753,
0.1362978369,
-0.0321579538,
-0.3336847126,
0.2309724987,
-0.3649168015,
-0.1738562584,
0.2149524242,
0.812074542,
-0.4172864258,
-0.4526666105,
0.6164568663,
0.3212258816,
0.2005174011,
0.0946637094,
-0.6137700081,
-0.205813244,
-0.2520611584,
-0.2329429239,
-0.0076044812,
0.3447588384,
-0.3092205524,
0.8342812657,
0.6399734616,
0.1965842694,
0.2581881881,
0.4750364721,
0.9685406685,
-0.5333917141,
-0.390629977,
-1.0656011105,
0.3795319498,
-0.0188084226,
-0.2317847908,
0.64324224,
0.3836987615,
0.8001899123,
-0.1240009964,
0.5185360909,
0.2168049812,
0.4949011505,
-0.670597136,
0.8125681281,
-0.5387977958,
0.4469524622,
-0.2701957822,
-0.7642437816,
-0.4640723169,
-0.035343226,
-0.779758215,
-0.0130917551,
0.5293371081,
0.8778580427,
0.1735396236,
-0.1327860206,
0.3730579913,
0.5754772425,
0.1251869947,
0.8008516431,
0.9326779246,
-0.2821840644,
0.6994434595,
-0.07640668,
-0.2141803354,
-0.474124223,
-0.5150697231,
-1.1605660915,
-0.431622982,
0.1062821746,
-0.2755322456,
0.4571044147,
0.4946836233,
0.3053221107,
-0.6856318712,
-0.1681086868,
-0.2679641247,
0.4747124314,
-0.2561765015,
-0.1944725513,
0.4198723435,
-0.4878091812,
-0.5091197491,
0.0676086918,
0.5276879668,
0.0881988704,
-0.4165341556,
-0.0947229043,
-0.4029054642,
0.2921889722,
0.4931566119,
0.1571744531,
-0.9327933192,
-0.5312106013,
0.0060563558,
-0.1489851177,
-0.1574180424,
0.7615820765,
-0.7828294039,
0.4945841134,
0.2014797032,
0.6684576869,
0.3080854416,
-0.2002753466,
0.5944036841,
-0.7147322893,
0.179307282,
0.3414294124,
0.2056070268,
0.3190089166,
-0.6412966251,
0.4573910832,
0.4360849261,
-0.3816992044,
-1.072285533,
0.3057053983,
-0.5805188417,
-0.4115941525,
0.6578596234,
0.2389627993,
-0.3413385749,
-0.3322292268,
-0.2083101422,
0.5052198768,
-0.0051851189,
1.1848909855,
0.698900938,
-0.0009577786,
-0.1927483976,
-0.6287684441,
0.5711266398,
0.8950559497,
-0.3202149868,
0.2757419646,
0.0886505693,
0.141834572,
0.1267002821,
0.5454368591,
-0.1088589579,
0.2304035574,
-0.2225856483,
0.1721457243,
0.1886968315,
-0.637865901,
-0.3758580685,
-0.4615217447,
0.0007397953,
-0.0329074264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07466v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07466v3
|
On Measuring Faithfulness or Self-consistency of Natural Language Explanations
| 2023-11-13T16:53:51 | 2024-06-01T07:57:52 |
Letitia Parcalabescu, Anette Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68Txx, I.2.7; I.2.10
|
Large language models (LLMs) can explain their predictions through post-hoc
or Chain-of-Thought (CoT) explanations. But an LLM could make up reasonably
sounding explanations that are unfaithful to its underlying reasoning. Recent
work has designed tests that aim to judge the faithfulness of post-hoc or CoT
explanations. In this work we argue that these faithfulness tests do not
measure faithfulness to the models' inner workings -- but rather their
self-consistency at output level. Our contributions are three-fold: i) We
clarify the status of faithfulness tests in view of model explainability,
characterising them as self-consistency tests instead. This assessment we
underline by ii) constructing a Comparative Consistency Bank for
self-consistency tests that for the first time compares existing tests on a
common suite of 11 open LLMs and 5 tasks -- including iii) our new
self-consistency measure CC-SHAP. CC-SHAP is a fine-grained measure (not a
test) of LLM self-consistency. It compares how a model's input contributes to
the predicted answer and to generating the explanation. Our fine-grained
CC-SHAP metric allows us iii) to compare LLM behaviour when making predictions
and to analyse the effect of other consistency tests at a deeper level, which
takes us one step further towards measuring faithfulness by bringing us closer
to the internals of the model than strictly surface output-oriented tests. Our
code is available at \url{https://github.com/Heidelberg-NLP/CC-SHAP}
|
[
-0.4422920644,
-0.859104991,
0.8253428936,
0.2259752005,
-0.2771070004,
-0.3680184782,
-0.2665972412,
-0.4973365366,
0.0496616997,
0.5875663161,
-0.4745095074,
-0.3042041063,
-0.4169052243,
0.1514401436,
-0.6597363949,
0.9822310209,
-0.5048369169,
0.1511165649,
-0.5556061268,
-0.0569552816,
-0.3008109331,
-0.2660051584,
-0.4769687057,
-0.5000870824,
0.5467788577,
0.178175807,
0.9433699846,
0.843796134,
0.3881299198,
0.2537109256,
0.1114338934,
0.2224179059,
-0.4090979099,
0.270231694,
-0.4024009109,
-0.1436921358,
-0.4502604902,
0.158784017,
0.6040999889,
0.607622087,
0.0340782665,
0.0814305469,
0.5512490869,
0.7143767476,
-0.5931985974,
0.0561303981,
-0.5704243183,
-0.2105428874,
-0.0494207367,
-0.2187626511,
-0.3882109821,
-0.1954267174,
-0.2136660814,
-0.1833171546,
0.4541137815,
0.3256447315,
1.0717470646,
0.165709734,
-0.2909245789,
-0.3722410798,
-0.6711342931,
0.8686622381,
-1.0235177279,
0.536418736,
0.6202532649,
0.1364425272,
-0.2902521789,
-0.4802190363,
-0.715583086,
-0.5164894462,
0.0190711711,
0.1353847086,
0.1195657626,
0.1119357869,
0.0776140913,
0.8878697157,
-0.4891771972,
-0.0043042894,
0.0822786912,
-0.4651777446,
0.723146677,
0.2461851686,
0.1579292715,
-0.0299325939,
-0.5810486674,
-0.0513650551,
-0.6250981688,
0.1177122593,
0.3610157073,
0.1100629047,
-0.157571435,
0.679038167,
-0.0930625722,
0.5365374088,
0.2226533294,
-0.0489022769,
-0.4037974179,
-0.679091692,
-0.4107371569,
-0.1236577407,
0.9237313867,
0.0281236377,
0.3034254313,
-0.2372249216,
-0.3254268169,
0.1236311048,
0.1406307966,
-0.650267303,
-0.3757623434,
0.3215231597,
-0.4971848428,
-0.2441359609,
0.1554415673,
-0.3526187539,
-0.2541426122,
-0.4351810217,
0.4752145112,
-0.5927693248,
-0.1764183491,
0.1962698996,
0.1468187422,
0.4394851327,
0.2689653635,
-1.1328805685,
0.5582743883,
0.9988313317,
0.7332583666,
-0.3573852181,
-0.7529495358,
-0.4665030837,
0.0869385153,
-0.6858248115,
0.7026916742,
-0.2074408829,
-0.0476823859,
-0.1067601144,
0.0949855596,
0.0555368327,
-0.3726212382,
0.449439764,
-0.2333019972,
0.1406399161,
-0.8852913976,
-0.8049535155,
-0.1057853326,
0.359159857,
-0.2423464209,
1.0003638268,
-0.0246521533,
-0.7406129837,
0.466461271,
-0.156778723,
-0.0894476101,
-0.3619785905,
-0.1446274966,
-0.4480735362,
0.1432950795,
-0.0052333707,
0.3425774276,
-0.1681597829,
0.4431915283,
-0.9780131578,
-0.5620074272,
0.5004986525,
-0.6699857116,
0.7665243745,
0.133411333,
-0.4649218321,
-0.1645869911,
-0.3755385876,
0.2684479654,
0.0795589909,
-0.0938713253,
-0.0731373653,
0.0511750281,
-0.2932289243,
0.1249204278,
0.336648792,
-0.640308857,
0.1279215813,
-0.4418525696,
0.1247011945,
0.9690983295,
-0.2398261577,
0.2309894115,
-0.58964324,
0.2633250952,
-0.0458408594,
0.1694354564,
-0.1963113844,
-0.3205393851,
-0.7625116706,
-0.1411962658,
0.2436629087,
-0.0896920934,
-0.1072448194,
0.3606102765,
-0.1382178068,
-0.366720438,
-0.3604963422,
0.331109345,
0.6898754239,
0.2428325415,
0.1181889027,
-0.5729529262,
-0.3541362882,
-0.8542256951,
-0.9116408229,
-0.3419987261,
0.1247216165,
0.0794686377,
0.7255328894,
-0.1170433015,
0.8491501808,
0.0128635326,
0.0047037601,
-0.0501621254,
0.1291095167,
0.113588959,
0.3674758375,
0.4288852811,
-0.3581816256,
-0.3777787983,
-0.1698296219,
-0.6593397856,
-0.1177901849,
0.0352546908,
-0.0155652231,
0.3431074619,
0.3171967864,
-0.3682764769,
0.3804920912,
1.022816062,
-0.5953483582,
0.9202775955,
-0.3783530593,
0.279605478,
-0.6333783269,
-0.2022043169,
-0.397603035,
-0.5133846402,
-0.3456397653,
0.1297303885,
0.0966300741,
0.3001984656,
-0.2216242999,
0.5971351862,
-0.5162958503,
-0.4596611857,
-0.4520140588,
0.2437451929,
0.4561589956,
0.3665184081,
-0.3998884261,
0.7664489746,
0.3977896273,
-0.801201582,
0.1927789599,
0.1792537272,
0.0567750297,
0.4933379292,
-0.7353128791,
0.2670254111,
0.1311623007,
0.2197666913,
-1.2243970633,
-0.1662318259,
0.1127418056,
-0.696483016,
0.1922353804,
-0.0072314851,
-0.5372306108,
-0.1488148421,
-0.400934726,
0.2712206542,
0.4091504216,
-0.7205666304,
0.5437034965,
-0.1405470967,
0.3274837136,
-0.4381665289,
-0.920232594,
-0.1439145803,
0.0042384453,
-0.8508105278,
0.2052167505,
-0.3174511492,
-0.4975706339,
-0.1447030157,
-0.5547226667,
-0.3452489376,
0.1756066829,
0.4606203735,
0.2051626742,
-0.5245900154,
0.0947850645,
-0.2758261263,
-0.0699152499,
0.5545781851,
-0.3805250823,
0.5624009967,
-0.6711893082,
-0.8280546069,
-0.62358284,
-0.04911514,
0.356738776,
-0.2071241289,
0.7739571929,
0.4702480435,
-0.0730091259,
-0.1236871034,
-0.6478632092,
-0.220249936,
-0.5178330541,
-0.2228009403,
-0.4349138737,
-0.7600399256,
0.6453627348,
0.2060891539,
0.2124048769,
0.8190823793,
0.443336755,
-0.3611019254,
0.9613393545,
0.3535922468,
0.2283433378,
0.0159878246,
-0.0485091507,
0.4449287057,
-0.7656986713,
0.0853719935,
-0.5575815439,
0.1255810708,
-0.6485117078,
-0.1227870956,
-0.1891734004,
0.2487775087,
-0.3664235175,
0.1773159057,
-0.2392481565,
0.4965978265,
0.32078439,
-0.0611737296,
0.5012572408,
-0.417349726,
-0.0575113855,
-0.1951320469,
-0.4106922448,
-0.8255240917,
0.8847625852,
0.3558848798,
0.7910305262,
-0.075920023,
0.8410239816,
0.21302706,
0.2220818251,
-0.4707663953,
0.3928245008,
-0.0504175648,
-0.6016944647,
-0.5290225744,
-0.3769147396,
-1.0034723282,
0.1382194459,
-0.1326469332,
-0.6162428856,
-0.1866175085,
0.6394348145,
-0.1505746245,
0.4302300811,
-0.3797792792,
0.9465559721,
-0.4477146864,
-0.5949591398,
-0.0651248395,
-0.1817393601,
0.7515147924,
-0.0064173276,
0.1941982061,
-0.2802488804,
0.2554310858,
0.6155910492,
-0.4961300492,
0.6458541751,
0.1674026251,
-0.3575218618,
0.4024343193,
0.6596592069,
0.5257761478,
0.0253578238,
0.0301771481,
0.2804092467,
0.3890008926,
-0.5978130698,
-0.6980431676,
0.8858392835,
-0.542077899,
-0.6842724085,
-0.4335282147,
-0.5682969093,
-0.1203289479,
0.2210238278,
0.032169044,
0.6134930849,
-0.2325890958,
0.2042487413,
0.9660333991,
-0.1240947694,
0.2836413682,
0.5478581786,
-0.5361654162,
-0.0023710984,
0.7280728221,
-0.1139428318,
0.7078495622,
0.0970867798,
0.5485955477,
-0.4357048571,
-0.645631969,
-0.1965033114,
0.329380244,
-0.6871614456,
-0.0315057077,
-0.3680586815,
-0.1325090677,
-0.5293073058,
-0.2370693386,
-0.6820440888,
-0.1156639531,
-0.0141448025,
0.0936861932,
0.0778230354,
0.9808976054,
-0.1336546093,
-0.0194230787,
-0.5857142806,
0.651812315,
0.3956783414,
0.6973220706,
0.0153328348,
-0.8291402459,
0.0886553898,
0.4323253036,
-0.3861044347,
-0.845869422,
0.0958925262,
0.1145210713,
0.3066731691,
0.7991440892,
0.0120401075,
1.0055205822,
-0.1260042936,
0.9678614736,
0.1094333753,
-1.3805725574,
0.3462323248,
-0.5677878261,
0.1623945534,
0.7194549441,
0.0119099002,
-0.4037057459,
-0.9141819477,
-0.9227293134,
-0.3024413288,
0.4050928056,
0.2309569418,
0.1502565444,
-0.0624074489,
0.5515443683,
0.3832430542,
-0.1484606415,
-0.8684520125,
-0.2809076607,
-0.1661768556,
-0.0430262797,
-0.1118708029,
-0.3870929182,
0.0473297574,
-0.0722766742,
0.8179231286,
-0.1843160391,
0.1232173592,
0.6454712152,
0.0979591683,
-0.273419112,
0.1081358269,
0.5057390928,
1.0182708502,
-0.0657264367,
0.5214743018,
0.2752681077,
-0.2726851106,
-0.0175017864,
-0.3325841427,
-0.0119692469,
0.1108184606,
0.715235889,
0.2861470282,
0.3089250922,
-0.3856064677,
0.7992396355,
-0.0590521432,
-0.4039380252,
-0.5006740093,
0.2210098654,
0.1818086803,
-0.1131707802,
-0.1431929916,
-0.1092734709,
-0.0089971377,
-0.9259806871,
0.3142778873,
0.8041272163,
-0.6181045771,
-0.3284212649,
0.8391558528,
-0.3251176775,
-0.3500460088,
0.6360476613,
-0.2989650965,
-0.3773411512,
0.6360087395,
0.5644997954,
0.7409870028,
-0.2968891859,
0.2239591032,
0.235338822,
0.432438314,
-0.2569703162,
0.4078659117,
-0.0820205659,
-0.6635183096,
-0.5235880017,
-0.5602500439,
-0.4895477891,
0.102527082,
-0.8126791716,
0.1232177317,
-0.3486937582,
0.236678198,
0.1054410711,
0.1777197272,
-0.5899885893,
0.248641476,
-0.0066811023,
0.9059989452,
-0.7787166834,
0.6779168248,
0.0539113767,
-0.3258909881,
-0.8569368124,
0.1022190079,
-0.1799519658,
-0.9746651053,
0.0532837808,
0.2287620157,
-0.3523249626,
-0.4610492587,
-0.8089207411,
-1.0231822729,
0.9691691399,
0.6236318946,
-0.5428912044,
0.257355243,
0.2349062711,
0.6392397881,
-0.1591982245,
0.2999590337,
0.3510384858,
0.8317790031,
-0.1965551078,
-0.9974290133,
0.1528619379,
0.2039519846,
-0.1615135521,
0.2855356038,
-0.6131831408,
0.7494071722,
-0.3010741174,
-0.2030083537,
0.2894836068,
0.9165616035,
0.3975212872,
0.5376446247,
0.5652364492,
0.4665054381,
0.607829392,
-0.3089422882,
1.4442517757,
-0.203808412,
0.5428065658,
1.2616128922,
-0.1745826304,
0.7288501263,
0.6602767706,
-0.2801386118,
0.7000690103,
0.6742616892,
-0.0329370685,
0.1043800116,
0.3204837441,
0.3115439117,
-0.508194387,
-0.009052013,
-0.1170648113,
0.5070925355,
-0.2665090561,
-0.3987306356,
-0.1262224615,
-0.5146800876,
0.0321189538,
0.3103274703,
-0.2646054327,
0.5825584531,
0.3275475204,
-0.8762648702,
0.8297667503,
-0.0574789606,
0.1669638306,
-0.6388494372,
-0.021986885,
-0.2530559301,
0.2543024421,
-0.2521658838,
-0.9662312865,
0.5627001524,
-0.2506561875,
-0.0613075197,
-0.4453217387,
0.5808349848,
-0.4110378623,
-0.1335246861,
0.4301379025,
0.6239760518,
0.4441864789,
-0.1916478276,
-0.6000243425,
0.0558871664,
-0.0739427209,
-0.2160675675,
0.2765256166,
0.4626326561,
0.1344843507,
0.7031021118,
0.5944496393,
-0.0520340204,
-0.0090199299,
0.0533559136,
0.4752818942,
-0.7352309227,
-0.1914466918,
-1.2200354338,
0.1295386851,
0.2337464988,
-0.411044389,
1.1516646147,
0.7180681229,
0.6708861589,
0.2686704099,
0.4493062496,
0.2735334039,
0.2253383845,
-0.6132583618,
0.3470183611,
-0.458311677,
0.1470618248,
-0.2334837317,
-1.0234485865,
0.2856711447,
0.2163435072,
-0.0943594202,
0.0740718991,
1.1248220205,
0.5414710641,
-0.3506776392,
0.2768047154,
0.4289008975,
0.5118982196,
0.0165195242,
0.3264051676,
0.9561573863,
-0.3527142704,
0.4325958192,
-0.3418037295,
0.0524490587,
0.1631663144,
-0.9677129388,
-0.9447825551,
-0.5290878415,
-0.2027199268,
-0.6186631322,
0.0759778172,
0.3630479872,
0.4838276207,
-0.8167716265,
-0.1529083252,
-0.4914529324,
0.1481728554,
-0.5871627927,
-0.2155500054,
0.3783029318,
-0.4867993891,
-0.3280899525,
0.2765036523,
0.2956956029,
0.0231513754,
-0.7797154784,
-0.2753043771,
0.2152701467,
0.3001004159,
0.1793693155,
-0.0263850968,
-1.1807098389,
-0.5384675264,
0.0895720646,
-0.0122439479,
0.2101565152,
0.7186703682,
-0.3886379898,
0.4688613117,
0.4657467008,
0.4675791264,
0.4478434026,
0.0870521516,
0.6590554714,
-0.206262514,
-0.4839229882,
0.1015901715,
0.559656322,
0.3944685459,
-0.3799156547,
0.2358903736,
-0.1296964139,
-0.8613100052,
-0.7244211435,
0.3749993443,
-0.9349386692,
-0.0931883976,
1.1509428024,
-0.4574607313,
-0.4482562244,
-0.2042479068,
0.0089443568,
0.1704432368,
-0.017049361,
1.0780967474,
0.9971193075,
-0.1310428679,
0.131112203,
-0.5949075818,
0.5081652403,
0.5895308256,
-0.6603656411,
0.5303341746,
0.2053348273,
0.5111200213,
-0.0154474508,
0.7945291996,
-0.2313210368,
0.3308272958,
-0.0483464561,
-0.112903513,
-0.0007679014,
-0.2144726068,
-0.4163689613,
-0.260794431,
0.2719526291,
0.0108308047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07463v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07463v2
|
MEGAVERSE: Benchmarking Large Language Models Across Languages, Modalities, Models and Tasks
| 2023-11-13T16:45:37 | 2024-04-02T21:18:00 |
Sanchit Ahuja, Divyanshu Aggarwal, Varun Gumma, Ishaan Watts, Ashutosh Sathe, Millicent Ochieng, Rishav Hada, Prachi Jain, Maxamed Axmed, Kalika Bali, Sunayana Sitaram
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There has been a surge in LLM evaluation research to understand LLM
capabilities and limitations. However, much of this research has been confined
to English, leaving LLM building and evaluation for non-English languages
relatively unexplored. Several new LLMs have been introduced recently,
necessitating their evaluation on non-English languages. This study aims to
perform a thorough evaluation of the non-English capabilities of SoTA LLMs
(GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, PaLM2, Gemini-Pro, Mistral, Llama2, and Gemma) by
comparing them on the same set of multilingual datasets. Our benchmark
comprises 22 datasets covering 83 languages, including low-resource African
languages. We also include two multimodal datasets in the benchmark and compare
the performance of LLaVA models, GPT-4-Vision and Gemini-Pro-Vision. Our
experiments show that larger models such as GPT-4, Gemini-Pro and PaLM2
outperform smaller models on various tasks, notably on low-resource languages,
with GPT-4 outperforming PaLM2 and Gemini-Pro on more datasets. We also perform
a study on data contamination and find that several models are likely to be
contaminated with multilingual evaluation benchmarks, necessitating approaches
to detect and handle contamination while assessing the multilingual performance
of LLMs.
|
[
-0.4920530021,
-0.5979546905,
0.4663012624,
0.2273470014,
-0.1204345673,
-0.0507112816,
-0.4502750337,
-0.6599369049,
0.2226629555,
0.6212795973,
-0.504320085,
-0.3459942043,
-0.7489976883,
0.647813201,
-0.2824341357,
0.9245094657,
-0.0970642045,
0.2544800937,
-0.4073428512,
-0.3540169001,
-0.4132376313,
-0.5999361873,
-0.5078920126,
-0.2775933743,
0.5396720171,
0.3875440657,
0.8925868273,
0.3999135792,
0.5635349751,
0.2607269585,
-0.1186896339,
0.4185529351,
-0.5025672913,
-0.1374701411,
-0.4163360596,
-0.3685053885,
-0.4059611261,
-0.0460646786,
0.5606324673,
0.6401199102,
0.2261193097,
0.3988682628,
0.1617213935,
0.2761984169,
-0.653200686,
0.3386776149,
-0.4019338191,
-0.0933988988,
-0.2981888354,
-0.0849850252,
-0.1629412919,
-0.2833500504,
-0.160372287,
-0.4784584045,
-0.0469945148,
-0.0780182928,
0.7735937238,
0.0715989918,
-0.5710956454,
-0.2119936347,
-0.6355752945,
0.760637641,
-0.6521464586,
0.4931121171,
0.4607774913,
0.4724663496,
-0.0972662345,
-0.5561820269,
-0.6936235428,
-0.3151199222,
0.1421581954,
0.1573276222,
-0.0971567556,
-0.2575525045,
0.1911765188,
0.1800996363,
-0.5474984646,
0.4327424765,
-0.1701012701,
-0.315875411,
0.7235187888,
0.2227057964,
0.0551497526,
-0.4235201478,
-0.2971223295,
-0.0806286484,
-1.0525608063,
-0.307956636,
0.6462703347,
0.4830964804,
-0.2766641974,
0.6298934817,
0.0352263972,
0.5802006125,
-0.4713363647,
-0.5480305552,
0.3076336086,
-0.4942506254,
-0.102367349,
-0.3922601938,
1.0009877682,
0.4107425511,
0.2778917849,
-0.2078583837,
-0.2241099924,
-0.0650778264,
-0.2323918492,
-0.8760186434,
0.0553977862,
-0.0213641245,
-0.2993311882,
0.1209285185,
-0.3288812041,
-0.6906790733,
-0.590018034,
-0.2707825303,
0.6450807452,
-0.3054759204,
-0.3675051928,
-0.0408707224,
0.2805192769,
-0.019983599,
0.2046405226,
-0.9282083511,
0.2620472014,
0.763913691,
0.6784172058,
-0.0740552843,
-0.5497841239,
-0.2646038234,
-0.010263877,
-0.3296289742,
0.7456188202,
-0.496150285,
-0.5287768245,
-0.0919783264,
0.0962806121,
-0.1042887494,
-0.8642611504,
0.6446965337,
-0.3741784394,
-0.0556883439,
-0.615871191,
-0.3600820899,
-0.4406791031,
0.4350248575,
-0.7599427104,
1.0031859875,
0.1050046533,
-0.625431478,
0.486907959,
-0.378198415,
-0.5397870541,
0.1861362308,
-0.4627367556,
-0.2392425835,
0.0766683742,
0.2742518485,
0.5001464486,
-0.9536468387,
0.318811357,
-0.2899779677,
-0.4410949647,
0.0157988537,
-0.621237278,
0.6616864204,
0.1321606338,
-0.4478752315,
-0.0214129742,
-0.703574717,
-0.0379208103,
0.1472444385,
-0.2483160496,
-0.1314568967,
-0.0395377539,
0.4206781685,
0.420173049,
0.3345091939,
-0.4140208364,
0.1215982214,
-0.0718287602,
0.4816888571,
0.5198135972,
-0.2518729568,
-0.1932254136,
-0.0883264467,
0.658064127,
0.0149428602,
0.2295372337,
-0.0001818584,
-0.5075343251,
-0.7607035637,
-0.4200936854,
0.5829409361,
0.5980528593,
-1.0175635815,
0.2462181449,
-0.6057285666,
-0.4929994345,
-0.5079570413,
0.4086047113,
0.3913607001,
0.1661520749,
0.2258239686,
-0.3517485857,
-0.4876610339,
-1.2227350473,
-0.1413959563,
-0.0233169515,
0.1182181016,
0.6641604304,
0.7501549125,
-0.5487545133,
0.7323408723,
0.1405384392,
-0.1885795444,
-0.4784710109,
-0.0937591419,
0.4199837446,
0.1349788457,
0.6385540962,
-0.6889172196,
-0.4612849653,
0.1800467372,
-0.9610322118,
-0.1656433791,
0.1450046599,
0.3595609665,
0.3132616878,
0.2850394249,
-0.5975604653,
0.1886094213,
0.9745528102,
-0.09320613,
0.6551069021,
-0.3467485309,
0.2892131805,
-0.9207983613,
0.3419907689,
-0.086692065,
-0.2179395258,
-0.4221182168,
0.2816377878,
0.3085019588,
-0.153660059,
-0.6775519252,
0.6425594687,
-0.4159706831,
-0.566778183,
-0.2011097223,
0.266451925,
-0.0387112275,
0.2026223391,
0.0070833336,
1.0914870501,
0.5580857396,
-0.3519710004,
0.2587481141,
0.1078421921,
-0.788382113,
0.3393885791,
-0.6212161779,
0.0667299852,
0.0010754118,
0.17966263,
-0.9098121524,
0.0332296528,
-0.1983502954,
-0.0760037303,
0.1914273202,
-0.1652921289,
-1.1797351837,
-0.3440103233,
-0.1729208678,
0.4131738245,
0.1118185967,
-0.5694473982,
0.6372399926,
0.3076575696,
-0.315541625,
-0.6297341585,
-0.6004590988,
0.4518047273,
-0.3122785091,
-0.6550009251,
-0.0778162554,
0.0944139436,
-0.2082936168,
-0.3132887483,
-0.1089609563,
0.2625917196,
0.2718274891,
0.260307163,
0.2164751142,
-0.0913189203,
-0.346372366,
-0.1317147762,
-0.2752367854,
-0.0475985371,
-0.0679753125,
0.7182906866,
0.0538597219,
-0.3016478717,
-0.1374177337,
0.2202511132,
0.5898383856,
-0.3273662031,
0.887725234,
0.5205575228,
-0.2997918725,
0.1847091466,
-0.73915416,
0.0648436695,
-0.441237092,
0.4842121005,
-0.6149179339,
-0.9073504806,
0.7391421795,
-0.1008745134,
0.111471884,
0.532580018,
0.853815496,
0.1600164324,
0.8255964518,
0.7157427073,
-0.2867450416,
0.0340640284,
-0.5228824019,
0.2325300276,
-0.7533987761,
-0.1639876664,
-0.4176752269,
-0.2085463703,
-0.7327828407,
-0.669983089,
0.5497344136,
0.2300402522,
0.03006218,
0.5803360343,
0.3240643144,
0.5811411738,
0.150798291,
-0.2774441838,
0.3590502739,
-0.0992225558,
-0.4648995101,
-0.0138443429,
-0.7826443315,
-0.851157546,
1.3996107578,
0.2273792326,
0.5855226517,
0.4094575346,
0.5050047636,
0.0107652051,
0.6366244555,
-0.4860545397,
0.5633298755,
-0.3807643354,
-0.7953560948,
-0.0871597528,
-0.6520026922,
-1.0722998381,
0.5662587881,
-0.1791806519,
-0.7238712311,
0.0453238077,
-0.2955192029,
-0.3022250235,
0.2333369553,
-0.5656750798,
0.8954343796,
-0.3131377995,
-0.6031300426,
-0.1404702663,
-0.418068558,
0.3582297564,
-0.4531408548,
0.5277789831,
-0.2339896113,
-0.0834795833,
0.6644078493,
-0.3241145909,
0.6649723649,
-0.053509675,
-0.4926123023,
0.150881663,
0.0843368247,
0.3860964775,
0.2076262981,
-0.3242758512,
0.7266610861,
-0.0380012579,
-0.2676236331,
-0.2679938674,
0.8518667221,
-1.0210884809,
-0.508949101,
-0.2088012695,
-0.6872826815,
-0.4534696937,
0.3147338927,
0.3012391627,
0.4201114774,
-0.1895021051,
0.1407300979,
0.2906932235,
-0.4688404799,
0.5118695498,
0.9866486788,
-0.3488329649,
-0.3702370524,
0.8358975649,
0.3350102007,
0.2785376608,
0.4227651358,
0.1085283086,
-0.5087800622,
-0.6863162518,
-0.7160365582,
0.2100138366,
-0.6142206192,
-0.2594505847,
-0.6643095016,
0.1698084921,
-0.5073777437,
0.2924737632,
-0.3887576461,
-0.3073241711,
0.0661559328,
-0.0569093525,
0.1870217025,
0.6938635707,
-0.1707392484,
0.1356122494,
-0.7862196565,
0.3456671834,
0.2218946815,
0.1801895052,
-0.0287827216,
-0.514955163,
-0.3779531121,
-0.0583435148,
-0.3817409575,
-0.6007495522,
0.44977507,
0.1737657636,
0.6305836439,
0.3773768842,
-0.4189608097,
0.8060802817,
-0.6174237132,
0.8674508333,
0.0731110722,
-0.9277428985,
0.2107532173,
-0.4717673361,
0.0604443625,
0.7647955418,
0.5767858624,
-0.5147564411,
-0.2583022416,
-0.508054018,
-0.8853807449,
0.438944608,
0.1628143042,
-0.0211873148,
-0.0965319425,
0.2369057089,
0.4164312184,
0.3197389841,
-0.6585885882,
-0.2975810468,
0.1680196077,
0.1105655134,
-0.7628660798,
-0.3088965416,
-0.0587748215,
-0.0302172936,
0.5023440123,
-0.244042784,
-0.0947017074,
-0.1946987063,
-0.3859532773,
0.0690734461,
0.1742851883,
0.4554180801,
0.8597944975,
0.0949861035,
-0.0036058717,
0.4618702829,
-0.5283549428,
0.1791674346,
0.3033900559,
-0.0362804048,
-0.2295295298,
0.6686727405,
0.5725804567,
0.2815838456,
-0.934630692,
0.4781403244,
-0.081458725,
-0.1097569838,
-0.086616613,
-0.0883259028,
0.3233796656,
0.233512342,
0.1879101247,
-0.1501351446,
0.1722943187,
-0.8215668797,
-0.0749506429,
0.3375930786,
0.0097337421,
-0.3087400198,
0.625631094,
0.2033349276,
0.0379776545,
0.5188423395,
-0.1242836714,
-0.4419416785,
0.5835525393,
0.4843125045,
0.563472271,
-0.1904711425,
-0.1420705318,
0.1214724556,
0.6323618889,
-0.017809391,
0.7448523045,
0.073579669,
-0.7673521638,
-0.7242742181,
-0.61404109,
-0.5165447593,
0.4135422409,
-0.5746739507,
0.1844075769,
-0.471339792,
-0.2081650496,
0.1658068746,
0.410987407,
-0.9825996161,
0.1870148182,
0.1620014906,
1.0132727623,
-1.1662961245,
0.9071502686,
0.7266100645,
-0.1756190211,
-0.7204069495,
-0.1791752279,
0.0471349694,
-0.8940701485,
0.7533125877,
0.2609876096,
-0.1207272187,
-0.2500986159,
-0.0036472853,
-0.8461503386,
1.0339801311,
0.8152090907,
-0.715533793,
0.5637287498,
0.5231475234,
0.5797039866,
-0.0489989854,
0.610221982,
0.8846775889,
0.7064718008,
-0.2197415084,
-1.3407421112,
-0.2288139015,
-0.247904554,
0.0567034259,
0.2895576656,
-0.9754951596,
0.7969307303,
-0.0715340599,
-0.1926786751,
0.3082189858,
0.5325889587,
0.4117771983,
0.035462983,
0.3947486281,
0.6794943213,
0.5527547002,
-0.1900436878,
1.2249783278,
-0.5005463958,
0.4326593578,
0.8870589137,
-0.8271895051,
0.8902920485,
0.3787746429,
-0.3685370982,
0.1087879762,
0.6272444725,
0.102641277,
0.3282470703,
0.2238987237,
-0.1543986648,
-0.1587703675,
-0.3388240635,
-0.3367829919,
0.6878276467,
0.3172448277,
-0.0432675257,
-0.2993068993,
0.0559992865,
0.1370088905,
-0.1662849039,
-0.3293878734,
0.5695604086,
-0.0138406986,
-0.5299512744,
0.7023585439,
0.33735618,
0.7317866683,
-0.6837195158,
0.3060714602,
-0.5472072959,
0.2411060333,
-0.2309117019,
-0.6088627577,
0.1395921707,
0.2566623092,
-0.0088122673,
-0.0580362901,
0.301094383,
-0.2614605129,
-0.6861310005,
0.6140215993,
0.6442884803,
0.4292486012,
0.0903658122,
-0.6142947078,
0.337008208,
-0.1789558679,
-0.1088812649,
0.4897390008,
0.3747760952,
-0.2339680493,
0.6845878959,
0.6179069281,
0.2280916572,
-0.130854845,
0.4953554571,
0.6285572648,
-0.5806714296,
-0.4445364475,
-0.9549543858,
-0.0252315365,
0.2454231977,
-0.3458684683,
1.245254159,
1.0663324594,
0.7592174411,
0.0342615284,
0.7566009164,
0.0139617873,
0.3089744747,
-0.4325459898,
0.6021804214,
-0.5911468863,
0.268555969,
-0.3933224678,
-1.2837085724,
-0.084317565,
0.4546756148,
-0.3413342535,
0.2055727094,
0.6042361259,
0.8235369921,
-0.0747206286,
0.1159073114,
0.5494112968,
0.2004310936,
0.279977262,
0.7589173913,
0.8824526668,
-0.5089790225,
0.3945918977,
-0.1091944128,
-0.2758320272,
-0.1360284537,
-1.0725342035,
-0.909699142,
-0.2226924449,
-0.1475985348,
-0.0711096078,
-0.0630840361,
0.6534975171,
0.7277027369,
-0.8044835925,
-0.4673037529,
0.5123359561,
-0.1356883347,
-0.4243245125,
-0.1314002723,
0.4320849478,
0.1516313702,
-0.7570614219,
0.7467383146,
0.4326844811,
-0.1143522263,
-0.5722635388,
0.0719094798,
-0.0144557049,
0.0154320123,
0.8100455403,
0.0411629975,
-0.5844672918,
-0.1227938086,
-0.349527508,
-0.042858284,
-0.2322480828,
0.6470673084,
-0.5892694592,
0.1006111801,
0.2355728894,
0.6006419659,
0.508898139,
-0.4223275185,
0.4221420884,
-0.6202211976,
0.2547902763,
0.0583984554,
0.6636333466,
0.5776039362,
-0.0735697746,
0.7400618196,
0.1056685448,
-0.360956341,
-0.6976695657,
0.0767896473,
-0.6399087906,
-0.1465684325,
1.2646917105,
-0.277439028,
-0.0160543881,
-0.1296066344,
0.1233973652,
-0.0769341141,
0.1112434193,
0.5805343986,
0.7269080877,
0.1123104319,
0.0644245371,
-1.0089678764,
0.0538143367,
0.4047872424,
-0.9382458329,
0.1156527475,
0.3352982104,
0.5410531759,
0.1474938095,
0.4814008474,
-0.3512782156,
0.2573564351,
-0.0324538909,
-0.0102015836,
-0.1171762273,
-0.4799938202,
-0.4124625325,
0.049657397,
-0.0217161905,
0.2950916886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07453v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07453v2
|
ChartCheck: Explainable Fact-Checking over Real-World Chart Images
| 2023-11-13T16:35:29 | 2024-02-16T12:14:05 |
Mubashara Akhtar, Nikesh Subedi, Vivek Gupta, Sahar Tahmasebi, Oana Cocarascu, Elena Simperl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Whilst fact verification has attracted substantial interest in the natural
language processing community, verifying misinforming statements against data
visualizations such as charts has so far been overlooked. Charts are commonly
used in the real-world to summarize and communicate key information, but they
can also be easily misused to spread misinformation and promote certain
agendas. In this paper, we introduce ChartCheck, a novel, large-scale dataset
for explainable fact-checking against real-world charts, consisting of 1.7k
charts and 10.5k human-written claims and explanations. We systematically
evaluate ChartCheck using vision-language and chart-to-table models, and
propose a baseline to the community. Finally, we study chart reasoning types
and visual attributes that pose a challenge to these models
|
[
-0.4284413457,
-0.7822654843,
0.6722196937,
-0.1427772492,
-0.5081372261,
0.2768058479,
0.2073963284,
-0.8700088859,
0.0805810615,
0.8388001323,
-0.480047822,
-0.8005849719,
-0.6523904204,
-0.0723104998,
-0.838807404,
0.895036459,
-0.2060876787,
-0.4495353997,
-0.3586439192,
-0.1543324143,
-0.4778974354,
-0.2564845383,
-0.5115565062,
-0.3920589089,
0.5078737736,
0.9301796556,
0.9596569538,
0.485702008,
0.4934025407,
0.2252916396,
0.2967927754,
0.5585955381,
-0.645981729,
-0.0028226527,
-0.1096273288,
-0.5717499256,
-0.3321976662,
0.2287544161,
0.2110076249,
0.5031548738,
0.3167218566,
0.5471395254,
-0.4423751831,
0.9117580652,
-0.8170256615,
0.8471429944,
-0.3236935735,
0.0143634053,
-0.0644317195,
0.0992931724,
-0.5030690432,
-0.9134340286,
0.2458510995,
-0.7804291844,
0.1846591681,
0.3726527095,
1.2123293877,
0.1915392429,
-0.8542273641,
-0.4999730885,
-0.6970856786,
0.1177031547,
-0.3438777626,
0.3609336615,
0.6421290636,
0.8243004084,
0.3043401837,
-1.007365346,
-0.7491659522,
0.0142806573,
-0.4315800369,
0.1802636236,
-0.3518370688,
-0.1629951298,
0.3547070324,
0.1855121255,
-0.63334167,
0.0461200401,
-0.2345135212,
-0.4136683643,
0.6084877849,
0.1504430026,
0.492993027,
-0.2237927765,
-0.3688521683,
-0.2430353463,
-0.8192802668,
0.2828890085,
0.1931082755,
0.1133631393,
-0.5338980556,
0.4105725884,
-0.3565452397,
0.7560356259,
-0.0266222488,
-0.0055376673,
-0.0765774846,
-0.4388537705,
-0.2194166929,
0.2065768242,
0.4270484149,
0.7702182531,
0.4036493897,
-0.0841533318,
0.0454338416,
0.3559590578,
0.0656937063,
-0.6796437502,
-0.360324055,
0.2415492982,
-0.2998882234,
-0.4694815874,
0.2195465565,
-0.8043821454,
-1.0426187515,
-0.2440550178,
0.2134487927,
-0.2596634328,
-0.0689224899,
-0.0059935679,
-0.3370857239,
0.0080608074,
0.6148578525,
-0.2706343234,
-0.0925768092,
0.8445773125,
0.7448303103,
0.2328784168,
-0.0907671601,
-0.4422900081,
0.1536282152,
-0.7967964411,
1.2605679035,
-0.4984865189,
0.2945473194,
-0.0000651289,
0.0315353833,
0.1965708286,
-0.3886818886,
0.6383895874,
-0.569796443,
-0.0244836751,
-0.7238522768,
-0.6668979526,
-0.6726043224,
0.373529613,
-0.9866454601,
0.6077335477,
-0.1173068658,
-0.8119134307,
0.9387525916,
-0.6864762902,
-0.4510066807,
0.1548506916,
-0.2798221707,
-0.7402034402,
-0.4494257569,
0.4429794252,
0.4457034469,
-0.3224284351,
0.2353144288,
-0.3162663281,
-0.3374885917,
0.3687735796,
-0.2354175299,
0.8021027446,
0.3708569109,
-0.5645688176,
0.0746357664,
-0.9530081153,
-0.2144933641,
0.3229820132,
-0.0052350196,
-0.2044523954,
0.1556297988,
-0.0189155359,
0.1159435958,
-0.0806366503,
-0.3845499158,
-0.0013932474,
-0.0933278576,
0.5271773338,
0.3917214572,
0.1649488062,
-0.1084571332,
-0.3060378134,
0.3178009987,
0.2362032086,
0.1036998928,
-0.3400449157,
-0.5510454774,
-0.7558255196,
-0.3972481489,
0.2990045547,
0.5316992998,
-0.874699831,
0.3859012723,
-0.460080415,
-0.8205727339,
-0.2960509062,
-0.2367135584,
0.1657101065,
0.9726917744,
0.1997240931,
-0.099335283,
-0.5639315844,
-1.1056524515,
-0.47571069,
-0.2288342416,
-0.0039746291,
0.0194489844,
0.5621711016,
-0.0965255052,
1.1411175728,
-0.5255818963,
0.0833619609,
-0.4044677317,
0.4403825998,
0.0058205309,
-0.00378981,
0.8072838187,
-0.6702640057,
-0.3110370338,
-0.202476874,
-0.7321977019,
-0.0467721596,
-0.4835300744,
-0.1299227774,
0.0072496659,
0.4399301708,
-0.4057024717,
0.8274127245,
0.4458651841,
-0.8907274604,
0.5356061459,
-0.1033236012,
0.5776889324,
-0.3502688706,
0.2219952941,
0.0437441804,
-0.6195048094,
-0.4457400441,
0.0959655941,
0.3331672549,
-0.3265842795,
-0.0879366323,
0.2291639,
-0.2875151932,
0.0394988731,
-0.1941140145,
0.3392160237,
0.238870427,
0.1643194854,
-0.1117952466,
0.4624208808,
0.5734407902,
-0.4650201797,
0.8192004561,
0.3673913479,
-0.8871740103,
0.7307828069,
-0.3065329194,
-0.2068823129,
-0.2359463573,
0.6952745914,
-1.2067519426,
-0.1666654348,
0.2230740041,
-0.2263922989,
-0.2111035585,
-0.3086223304,
-0.7212680578,
-0.4975456893,
-0.0546421967,
-0.0614497103,
0.2109009027,
-0.9555463791,
0.4136162102,
0.4441021383,
0.3008851111,
-0.4147462845,
-0.8105888963,
0.5281102657,
-0.0222845189,
-0.8299285769,
-0.3676213622,
0.35223791,
-0.4652797282,
-0.0269474611,
-0.2841614485,
-0.1053411439,
0.0896316394,
0.4264661372,
0.2525028884,
-0.111987114,
0.242480725,
-0.445941031,
-0.3687312901,
0.2352669239,
-0.0368236117,
0.0764471367,
-0.1236023754,
-0.7996306419,
-0.4929065108,
0.0549414083,
0.7547799349,
-0.1676983237,
0.5885246396,
0.444832772,
-0.41078794,
-0.1180164814,
-0.5817059278,
-0.1650756598,
-0.4488914311,
0.3075333536,
-0.0489873588,
-0.428681016,
0.6006297469,
0.0064971154,
0.5195420384,
0.4502601922,
0.392610997,
-0.2538890541,
0.8308616877,
0.1847880036,
0.1473791152,
0.0413548127,
-0.265283078,
0.856744945,
0.2468060702,
-0.2460577041,
-0.427369535,
-0.5987229943,
-0.4444066286,
-0.4609265029,
0.2831501663,
-0.4285304248,
-0.2126275599,
0.0126631968,
-0.2899450064,
0.6989862919,
0.4554794729,
0.1034689173,
0.5651494861,
-0.0319883786,
-0.0140957544,
0.1338892728,
-0.5311063528,
-0.6193649769,
0.8764985204,
0.192398116,
0.8648211956,
-0.1925341487,
0.1137221307,
0.4134850204,
0.3157815933,
-0.5935642719,
0.441547364,
-0.2072059065,
-0.9024083018,
-0.3717970848,
-0.2940725088,
-0.8249449134,
0.1706022173,
-0.6307325959,
-0.3238197863,
0.0979031026,
0.7282403111,
-0.0968639478,
0.6825749278,
-1.071531415,
0.9637149572,
-0.3299807012,
0.0358554497,
-0.4139478803,
-0.610776484,
0.5727519989,
0.2230192125,
0.7427259088,
-0.1877373308,
0.2954784036,
0.466442436,
-0.4859263599,
1.0333594084,
-0.1846076399,
-0.0934001282,
0.4219066799,
0.2941859663,
0.7928438187,
-0.0277670193,
0.3718619645,
0.0737182721,
0.0387375094,
-0.4248636663,
-0.829462409,
0.4339188039,
-0.5629148483,
-0.2001372278,
-0.2856776416,
-0.3638417125,
-0.4396252334,
-0.0398283862,
0.1157077551,
0.6098555326,
-0.0602369532,
0.2125687599,
0.371775955,
-0.1267668307,
-0.1685341597,
0.5555471182,
-0.35673365,
0.0538909286,
1.123390913,
0.2808319628,
0.1851385385,
0.2547221482,
0.2634402812,
-0.2419877499,
-0.3640828431,
-0.2531240582,
0.0662687421,
-1.0731645823,
0.0088469982,
-0.3210999072,
0.0403234661,
-0.1463978738,
-0.1052460074,
-0.3362150192,
-0.8312175274,
0.0922453552,
-0.4549823701,
0.5779403448,
0.9893721938,
-0.1096518412,
-0.08352191,
-0.4502543807,
0.7770734429,
0.6626189947,
0.7359825969,
0.0455804728,
-0.1421762556,
-0.3866580427,
0.2078274786,
-0.1975479573,
-1.0892877579,
-0.0875148252,
-0.2278729081,
0.4708015025,
0.7383360863,
0.2011250257,
0.6558887959,
-0.0595184006,
0.6491290927,
0.1904652417,
-0.6687856913,
0.4008542597,
0.1125347465,
0.3053403199,
0.3613437116,
0.2881156802,
-1.0199584961,
-0.823928237,
-0.6239863634,
-0.76373142,
0.4798101485,
0.2257376909,
-0.5613175035,
0.4215531349,
0.2420968711,
0.2554545999,
-0.0862682462,
-0.5803405643,
-0.5149266124,
-0.8114749789,
-0.3264743984,
-0.1831638664,
-0.0851164386,
-0.5159614682,
-0.2599474192,
0.53234303,
-0.2613402009,
-0.2922880948,
0.1002509966,
-0.4129909575,
-0.1139784157,
0.245329991,
0.5009794831,
1.0470420122,
-0.0273115765,
0.7577898502,
-0.1158794984,
-0.5571303964,
-0.1337383986,
-0.098797597,
-0.4485106468,
0.0076413401,
0.69405967,
0.9269819856,
0.4261910915,
-0.8534671664,
0.3263685107,
-0.1053644717,
-0.2219187915,
0.1526487619,
-0.0694321468,
0.5652094483,
0.0293944255,
0.1554396003,
0.0582301468,
0.055044435,
-0.5931151509,
0.1081079617,
0.173982501,
-0.1852473021,
-0.2510573566,
0.502928555,
0.3634186089,
0.2471046895,
0.6155275702,
0.0629174262,
-0.5710662007,
0.8404037952,
-0.0633045882,
0.4017074108,
0.5911042094,
0.462747395,
0.5110731125,
0.7798466682,
0.2755599022,
0.1181413308,
0.1107245535,
-0.5881073475,
-0.3942095041,
0.135569945,
-0.862817049,
0.2899624407,
-0.2846862376,
0.1872386336,
-0.4166748226,
-0.1289229989,
0.3911985755,
-0.2061423808,
-0.8246975541,
0.2677084208,
0.4343111217,
0.9049734473,
-1.1055822372,
0.231054008,
0.4757143855,
-0.4697531462,
-0.5764973164,
-0.134561196,
0.431856215,
-1.2440968752,
0.6592078805,
0.0430827588,
-0.0860795379,
-0.5801497102,
-1.1288341284,
-0.7622621059,
0.8847047687,
0.6832862496,
-0.4905958772,
0.1296984106,
0.3659353554,
0.3834334612,
-0.0844340622,
0.1303876042,
0.742230773,
1.0278522968,
0.1212325767,
-0.619967401,
0.2376896739,
0.1985406131,
-0.6022663116,
-0.1255314499,
-0.3584592342,
0.567025125,
-0.4997050464,
-0.4400758147,
-0.7724887729,
0.4087171555,
0.2666553259,
0.4032279253,
0.8202539682,
0.5111706257,
0.9232538342,
-0.2506481111,
1.0291013718,
-0.2518556416,
0.3062202036,
1.1673340797,
-0.0718063191,
0.3673265874,
0.2171090543,
-0.0381839462,
0.6845133901,
0.7009138465,
-0.228068471,
0.1249767542,
-0.0125626875,
0.3622811139,
-0.7069457173,
0.2206700444,
-0.1358826011,
0.5196692348,
0.3874497414,
-0.0490564108,
-0.6156827211,
-0.3383980989,
-0.1705697775,
0.1970077902,
-0.1277192235,
0.5253787041,
-0.2722552717,
-0.4904428422,
0.5902428031,
-0.3676328659,
0.043758221,
-0.4046443105,
-0.2085038126,
-0.0207566302,
-0.1212922633,
-0.3753057718,
-1.3121068478,
0.1427054107,
0.1537347287,
0.0390427336,
-0.1980156153,
0.7116321921,
-0.220365271,
-0.3688419163,
-0.1396528631,
0.3274786472,
0.0245090351,
-0.2354379594,
-0.6329535246,
-0.1038730145,
-0.1241764948,
0.0702342167,
-0.0910276771,
0.4180628061,
-0.2064792663,
1.1881500483,
0.6355836391,
-0.0731597915,
-0.0974327102,
0.197881341,
0.4860863388,
-0.5613374114,
-1.0300370455,
-0.5249031186,
0.3693825901,
-0.2787890732,
0.0610680953,
0.6487519145,
0.7401067615,
0.3927254379,
-0.0383993089,
1.0033262968,
0.1703730226,
0.8286855221,
-0.3908583224,
1.1309767962,
-0.3527827859,
-0.1642812937,
-0.0390416607,
-0.1769535094,
-0.2735387087,
0.3812442422,
-0.4219539464,
-0.4432425797,
0.7701999545,
0.4068522155,
-0.1064628661,
0.5061591268,
0.2280417383,
0.5469661951,
0.5432041883,
0.314480722,
0.7900208831,
-0.0833489224,
1.017113328,
-0.3390201032,
-0.2063991427,
-0.4678732455,
-1.0112816095,
-0.7261045575,
-0.5929825902,
-0.6728451848,
-0.3080441356,
-0.3776544929,
0.3156121969,
0.8009950519,
-1.0178774595,
-0.0258485414,
0.1553955525,
0.6734058261,
-0.3524534106,
-0.1974291056,
0.5017159581,
0.0023259083,
-0.0725995973,
0.0255363639,
0.3256372213,
0.0628132001,
-0.2592651546,
0.134605974,
-0.0863297656,
0.2458878011,
0.4629576206,
0.4610096812,
-0.6856907606,
-0.4914049506,
-0.5255417228,
-0.1797311157,
0.2581295073,
1.1436234713,
-0.7455623746,
0.7570521832,
0.5045292377,
0.3026467264,
0.6116222143,
-0.1194114387,
0.2828367054,
-0.4909642041,
0.0782659575,
-0.087217778,
0.4271927774,
0.4137618244,
-0.2779784203,
0.447254926,
0.3423558772,
-0.2454760671,
-0.7081182003,
0.2639762461,
-0.9762974977,
-0.331491977,
0.5295185447,
0.0025620107,
-0.0551104061,
-0.5080014467,
-0.226534754,
0.1878805757,
-0.3160720766,
1.1918181181,
0.9078679085,
-0.1073979586,
0.0036772764,
-0.6178420186,
0.6054924726,
-0.105197601,
-1.2696914673,
0.5932149887,
0.752710104,
0.3279439807,
0.1786855161,
0.2500267029,
0.153042987,
0.5996189117,
0.1347358972,
-0.0282332059,
-0.1871218681,
0.1136712506,
0.2343857288,
0.2925749719,
0.0472660586,
-0.0050804876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07445v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07445v2
|
Think Before You Speak: Cultivating Communication Skills of Large Language Models via Inner Monologue
| 2023-11-13T16:19:42 | 2024-03-15T08:30:30 |
Junkai Zhou, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) further improves the
capabilities of open-domain dialogue systems and can generate fluent, coherent,
and diverse responses. However, LLMs still lack a crucial ability:
communication skills. This limitation renders them more like information
seeking tools rather than anthropomorphic chatbots. Communication skills, such
as topic transition, proactively asking questions, concept guidance, empathy,
and summarising often should be taken into consideration, to make LLMs more
anthropomorphic and proactive during the conversation, thereby increasing the
interest of users and attracting them to chat for longer. However, enabling
these communication skills in black-box LLMs remains a key challenge because
they do not have the same utterance formation mode as real people: think before
speaking. Inspired by linguistics and cognitive science, we empower LLMs with
communication skills through inner monologues. To evaluate various
communication skills, we construct a benchmark named Cskills, which can also
more comprehensively evaluate the dialogue generation ability of the model.
Experimental results show that the proposed CSIM strategy improves the backbone
models and outperforms the baselines.
|
[
-0.5616334677,
-0.7973754406,
0.5236111283,
0.0471056849,
-0.4403887093,
0.5273776054,
-0.4359495044,
-0.4635409713,
0.2967240512,
0.6183384657,
-0.7343286872,
-0.4146072268,
-0.3153155744,
-0.1106423661,
-0.1914326102,
0.6955195665,
0.4938433468,
0.1978205293,
-0.4153420031,
-0.0159616303,
-0.4976540506,
-0.577054143,
-0.8874472976,
-0.4228720963,
0.3875566423,
0.5014073849,
0.7855795622,
0.0463583395,
0.0765599608,
0.3336427808,
-0.2643393576,
0.3674150407,
-0.8469696045,
0.0035951147,
-0.1736609787,
-0.6788827181,
-0.3697397411,
0.0658138767,
0.6510034204,
0.7947815061,
-0.2223010808,
0.2938274443,
0.402677685,
0.4021651447,
-0.388715148,
0.1332324296,
-0.876468122,
0.1558499783,
-0.0873980522,
-0.3147106171,
-0.595926106,
-0.212278232,
0.2245178223,
-0.377833873,
-0.1343597174,
0.0816801488,
0.5663371682,
0.0886375383,
-0.0235994887,
-0.148603186,
-0.5923274755,
0.6037501693,
-0.9091469646,
0.2984914482,
0.1531621367,
0.1848439276,
-0.2315917164,
-0.524923265,
-0.6030408144,
-0.2573992908,
-0.0340959467,
0.1401472986,
-0.3477006257,
0.1768465042,
0.2302502245,
0.3688659668,
-0.4494848847,
0.1451892555,
-0.4104729295,
-0.0871525183,
0.3995310664,
0.3258774579,
-0.0785039961,
0.0045513506,
-0.3015704453,
-0.1912555397,
-0.564788878,
0.1602109075,
0.4231975973,
0.3779387474,
-0.1746569574,
0.3407161534,
-0.1055024341,
0.3648022711,
0.1842729449,
-0.3489153385,
-0.0736686587,
-0.4395878315,
-0.2940847576,
-0.0349795744,
0.7319197655,
0.1599294692,
0.6773668528,
-0.0559765287,
0.4062618613,
-0.0227828529,
0.7060316801,
-0.7127254009,
-0.1803962439,
0.2301528305,
-0.5474357605,
-0.3272493184,
-0.2531943917,
-0.6496434212,
-0.2953089774,
-0.3639877141,
0.1922974437,
-0.4468555152,
-0.429625988,
0.1780754626,
0.2083644271,
0.3541166782,
0.3472325802,
-0.6021952033,
0.6486830115,
0.4453170598,
0.7372920513,
-0.0853277668,
-0.0833169371,
-0.2705672383,
-0.2157221884,
-0.677251935,
0.7460343242,
-0.4470834434,
-0.5561178923,
0.068997331,
-0.2970948219,
0.1547453105,
-0.5547111034,
0.3808323145,
-0.0623018406,
0.0591602884,
-0.0884076878,
-0.2476739138,
0.0397271104,
0.1604962051,
-0.0943665653,
0.6836488247,
-0.0473403037,
-0.6302247047,
0.172807008,
-0.4920355678,
-0.4371518195,
0.4963381886,
-0.4272783101,
-0.1765197814,
0.2861039639,
0.104688935,
0.4136691391,
-0.173221603,
-0.0353349783,
-0.3265134096,
-0.0864884034,
0.3384860754,
-0.1981163174,
0.5645519495,
0.01220062,
-0.0953539237,
0.1260876656,
-0.3445796371,
0.6526019573,
0.0957104042,
0.0225336738,
-0.1210058928,
0.1587763131,
-0.4930302799,
0.435546279,
-0.1253008395,
-0.48284778,
-0.0306861624,
-0.6706874967,
0.3671111763,
0.856058538,
-0.0914745629,
0.209664315,
-0.4062264264,
0.7095882893,
0.1531195492,
0.1406283826,
-0.301555872,
-0.359125495,
-1.0524427891,
-0.2010340244,
-0.0980415493,
0.5580454469,
-0.7329853177,
0.3598897159,
-0.1696624905,
-0.8746619225,
-0.8065335751,
0.2715621889,
0.6863837838,
0.2626031935,
0.3359428644,
-0.5701649189,
-0.4882517755,
-0.9506364465,
-0.1588517725,
-0.3783229291,
0.2897472978,
0.334756881,
0.2126363963,
0.1912674904,
0.7082476616,
-0.4817076027,
-0.1205367595,
-0.6216691732,
-0.0042572799,
0.0641533583,
0.1334149092,
0.0796876475,
-0.3764030933,
-0.2689435184,
-0.2984032631,
-0.6583501101,
0.0195827652,
0.0219904799,
-0.0910352021,
-0.0070710867,
0.7291420102,
-0.5152828693,
0.5173764229,
0.4684943855,
0.0203176402,
0.7866855264,
-0.1011373699,
0.0638047755,
-0.9551149011,
-0.124836795,
-0.1500711739,
-0.2256301045,
-0.7298657894,
-0.1805543602,
-0.1198241115,
-0.477735579,
-0.7141795754,
0.7213327885,
-0.6493228674,
0.0487530082,
-0.2955984771,
0.340933919,
-0.3358027935,
0.5483953953,
0.0932159871,
0.9627850652,
0.6092113256,
-0.7048213482,
-0.0931651518,
0.5645222068,
-0.8307116032,
0.764508605,
-0.6056608558,
0.2780686915,
-0.1159260273,
0.3138182163,
-0.9619525075,
0.2514422238,
-0.0556452908,
-0.4580079317,
0.3912624717,
0.0152383549,
-0.448846221,
-0.7842813134,
-0.0742661804,
0.020215584,
0.3950270712,
-0.217417866,
0.5038917065,
0.5456957817,
-0.6789578795,
-0.556783855,
-0.6553869247,
0.3132367432,
-0.0344192684,
-0.7583009005,
0.1191831082,
-0.5061993003,
-0.2659826875,
-0.4017958641,
-0.0685417131,
0.3149968386,
0.1546925753,
0.1796971411,
-0.0030870866,
-0.2366070896,
0.140830487,
0.0090915384,
-0.0830384195,
0.0891028792,
-0.2552901804,
0.7991619706,
-0.1444786638,
-0.3534984589,
-0.589586854,
0.301641643,
0.574706912,
-0.3696555197,
0.6355845928,
0.0148711018,
0.0091740126,
-0.5400140882,
-0.8051780462,
-0.3948378265,
-0.4813894331,
0.36275509,
-0.4043192863,
-0.9038014412,
0.3359978199,
-0.1585810333,
-0.0442694463,
-0.294565767,
0.4308961034,
-0.1504455507,
0.7510721087,
0.8329075575,
0.0570626855,
0.4720860124,
-0.1408569813,
0.47648561,
-0.931876421,
-0.1176904589,
-0.1742591113,
-0.0475853235,
-0.1870077848,
-0.6580110192,
0.4409504235,
-0.1482825428,
-0.0746819526,
0.3689081371,
-0.3043398559,
0.4032255411,
0.369032979,
0.2603156269,
0.1600485891,
-0.1190995723,
-0.3937915564,
-0.1320721954,
-0.7482218742,
-0.7843977809,
0.9797507524,
0.2960057259,
0.8682729006,
-0.1344173551,
0.541862309,
0.1093426719,
0.2497004271,
-0.7270470262,
0.9959128499,
0.050362017,
-0.3627405763,
-0.3399541974,
-0.2723757029,
-0.6503102779,
0.431643486,
-0.2920528054,
-0.9116206169,
-0.030117454,
0.1389154941,
-0.4863654077,
0.3635824621,
-0.577452898,
0.6553130746,
-0.2220765054,
-0.3936716914,
-0.4138280749,
-0.6131175756,
0.2673839629,
-0.118811816,
0.100229688,
-0.1746569276,
0.171266526,
0.3672959507,
-0.2279539108,
0.9314036369,
0.1565404385,
-0.0882881582,
0.4450543523,
0.268538326,
0.2228724509,
-0.1680164039,
-0.1470489204,
0.2263610363,
-0.2511671484,
-0.3276337385,
-0.3856629729,
0.3518055677,
-0.4880320728,
-0.8632750511,
-0.1356780827,
-0.2722961307,
-0.3697560132,
0.1151455715,
0.1297019273,
0.3730795681,
-0.7905291319,
0.2793535888,
0.8950830102,
-0.2237607241,
0.2920330763,
0.6517218351,
-0.1660515815,
-0.4073152542,
0.3984792531,
0.2518148124,
0.8901301622,
0.1670935005,
0.0646445453,
-0.1936657429,
-0.6590171456,
-0.1974779665,
0.3481547534,
-0.6472792625,
-0.2168204337,
-0.9482207894,
-0.4476750195,
-0.5207269192,
-0.1353580803,
-0.2724430561,
-0.0808653533,
-0.1220303178,
-0.3156245351,
-0.2093501836,
0.4845985174,
-0.0781670064,
0.2721491456,
-0.4402318001,
0.08316838,
0.4565595686,
0.0479528792,
0.3422775567,
-0.5175688267,
-0.3445603251,
0.2396693826,
-0.6965553164,
-0.5949190259,
0.4176664352,
-0.0584155768,
0.8252126575,
0.5013503432,
-0.0261833053,
0.8273559213,
-0.5111228824,
0.8045145869,
0.2440561652,
-1.0383213758,
0.5752485991,
-0.1530687511,
0.5838724971,
0.6137799621,
0.2589955628,
-0.5253022909,
-0.8305146098,
-0.7225852013,
-0.4858728051,
0.6075440049,
0.4162346721,
0.3746080995,
-0.2053002566,
-0.1379468739,
-0.1326139569,
0.5195657015,
-0.7564387918,
-0.2376167029,
-0.1761228293,
0.2775118351,
-0.4513333142,
-0.193349272,
-0.1080437452,
-0.2321062535,
0.5755429268,
-0.3690915704,
0.332437098,
0.2489387244,
0.1161371842,
-0.2820420563,
0.4160994589,
0.611628592,
0.6529973149,
0.1164907143,
-0.0098638041,
0.4506424963,
-0.0278000589,
-0.0499649048,
-0.26806584,
0.3594731092,
-0.310264945,
0.1626467407,
0.704934895,
0.4849629104,
-0.7729427814,
0.4269925356,
0.0204136241,
-0.1364567876,
-0.4276096225,
0.3089957833,
0.4280381203,
0.2170951813,
0.2180888951,
-0.2006993145,
-0.2166526765,
-0.9705685377,
0.1467776746,
0.7605776191,
-0.4671217203,
0.0265502296,
0.3985347152,
0.2868185937,
-0.5436766148,
0.391389221,
-0.0047524548,
-0.5691182613,
0.344350934,
0.5153499842,
0.9119627476,
-0.356202811,
0.3226099014,
0.2815276384,
0.5181372762,
0.1401838064,
0.0964694396,
-0.2882527113,
-0.8466091156,
-0.3359530568,
-0.5377060771,
-0.6941447854,
0.2695674896,
-0.4214544296,
0.4489946067,
-0.3883344233,
-0.1964480579,
0.1811724007,
0.1653594673,
-0.6366767883,
0.0745472685,
0.3993065357,
1.065865159,
-0.4708545506,
0.655225873,
0.255400151,
-0.3894031048,
-0.6861688495,
-0.1281849593,
0.0227216091,
-0.6532326341,
0.3420586586,
0.1815213859,
-0.3560899794,
0.0233021788,
-0.7483887672,
-0.6370415092,
1.0078963041,
0.3302319348,
-0.5012301207,
-0.2734509408,
0.1429281384,
0.6372324228,
-0.7000803947,
0.4533037841,
0.2078141868,
0.2953342199,
0.1421868652,
-1.2023125887,
-0.1826201975,
-0.1138898656,
-0.1494467407,
0.1518189609,
-0.8826116323,
0.7004861236,
-0.5259793997,
-0.5006103516,
0.3195829391,
0.6490523219,
-0.0477141887,
-0.0951879397,
0.4391644895,
0.639308393,
0.7953819633,
0.0992771015,
0.8273811936,
-0.1799625903,
-0.3074303269,
1.424957633,
-0.4417261481,
0.9161302447,
0.1362866163,
0.0906946734,
0.6234560013,
0.1259976774,
0.2709290385,
0.1931717098,
0.6132165194,
-0.2269883454,
-0.553927362,
0.078982912,
-0.2208928615,
0.6201020479,
0.5837476254,
-0.3053307533,
-0.1546496451,
0.1156584173,
0.3209981024,
0.3617760539,
-0.227836892,
1.0058435202,
0.3808627725,
-0.7780237198,
0.6173421741,
-0.5001636744,
0.5069388151,
-0.8958011866,
0.0597707145,
-0.0837347731,
0.078699939,
0.1204140037,
-0.822234869,
0.1155720279,
-0.1808642149,
-0.0692799389,
-0.4233843982,
0.6429563761,
-0.5413311124,
-0.3079477251,
0.5730013847,
0.729904592,
0.2630378008,
-0.0022294119,
-0.7809064984,
-0.0180271603,
-0.0201090518,
0.0810620263,
0.3299911022,
0.3148714304,
0.1818365902,
1.1391416788,
0.8240786791,
0.2334520072,
-0.1562203765,
-0.1228605807,
1.0341223478,
-0.5530768037,
-0.5766320229,
-0.4359012246,
0.5800175667,
-0.4411903918,
-0.4507551491,
0.676826179,
0.5407056808,
0.9491820335,
0.0992599875,
0.6365577579,
0.3076289892,
0.6648727059,
-0.3463183045,
0.8156573176,
-0.3201951981,
0.038241975,
-0.6541378498,
-0.7171103358,
0.2642756999,
0.584119916,
-0.3363991082,
-0.0432228111,
0.8510972261,
1.0769228935,
0.0898271725,
0.1351341754,
0.9038130045,
0.437921524,
0.2184648216,
0.4949172437,
0.9315730333,
-0.0008007511,
0.6249462366,
0.0016295554,
-0.2341868281,
0.0579253994,
-0.8620859385,
-1.1784958839,
-0.3948750198,
-0.2528366446,
-0.3368604779,
0.218989253,
0.7926626801,
1.1749101877,
-0.3315603435,
-0.5536262989,
0.1671357751,
0.0487351939,
-0.2642914057,
-0.1967965513,
-0.2554600537,
-0.5502288342,
-0.4433062375,
0.7077986598,
0.4933137298,
0.1564206183,
-0.5274221897,
0.0522092395,
-0.2404391468,
0.8496453762,
0.7535572648,
0.3624687493,
-0.6709322333,
-0.1163045689,
-0.3035880625,
-0.0795151293,
0.1621607095,
0.9069186449,
-0.9224507213,
0.6259842515,
-0.0073662219,
0.3225668967,
0.3963469267,
-0.0786717013,
0.6306701899,
-0.3110202551,
0.265062362,
0.4029787779,
0.1607742459,
0.3755358458,
-0.1211546436,
0.345246613,
-0.1511529535,
-0.4390927553,
-0.749366641,
0.4068128169,
-0.9413264394,
-0.3148391843,
1.0527633429,
-0.1173586398,
0.0705476329,
-0.2353599221,
-0.4298267663,
0.005694774,
-0.3039355576,
0.5554623008,
0.8330177665,
-0.019813735,
-0.3801780939,
-0.3938688636,
0.5531597137,
0.5115783811,
-1.0192885399,
0.2182449698,
0.1549057364,
0.049256999,
0.3847269118,
1.0793813467,
-0.1530306339,
0.0193884745,
-0.122455582,
0.1210565269,
0.0448758192,
-0.3949472606,
0.1080693007,
0.1135854349,
0.0068396865,
0.0811557993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07439v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07439v3
|
Investigating Multi-Pivot Ensembling with Massively Multilingual Machine Translation Models
| 2023-11-13T16:15:20 | 2024-04-28T08:26:11 |
Alireza Mohammadshahi, Jannis Vamvas, Rico Sennrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Massively multilingual machine translation models allow for the translation
of a large number of languages with a single model, but have limited
performance on low- and very-low-resource translation directions. Pivoting via
high-resource languages remains a strong strategy for low-resource directions,
and in this paper we revisit ways of pivoting through multiple languages.
Previous work has used a simple averaging of probability distributions from
multiple paths, but we find that this performs worse than using a single pivot,
and exacerbates the hallucination problem because the same hallucinations can
be probable across different paths. We also propose MaxEns, a novel combination
strategy that makes the output biased towards the most confident predictions,
hypothesising that confident predictions are less prone to be hallucinations.
We evaluate different strategies on the FLORES benchmark for 20 low-resource
language directions, demonstrating that MaxEns improves translation quality for
low-resource languages while reducing hallucination in translations, compared
to both direct translation and an averaging approach. On average, multi-pivot
strategies still lag behind using English as a single pivot language, raising
the question of how to identify the best pivoting strategy for a given
translation direction.
|
[
-0.5134561658,
-0.5656923652,
0.6395384669,
0.4293543398,
-0.2589747906,
-0.0929822177,
-0.6389797926,
-0.3086440563,
0.4598193765,
0.7101179957,
-0.7240265608,
-0.4512034655,
-0.7731342912,
0.387252003,
-0.3482225835,
0.9486076236,
0.0906430781,
0.1791782677,
0.233801797,
-0.4773438275,
-0.511919558,
-0.7459961176,
-0.3291290402,
-0.2414383888,
0.706111908,
0.5480738282,
1.1236470938,
0.3819370866,
0.8060019016,
0.2592664361,
0.1567762345,
0.4110876322,
-0.443785876,
0.665037334,
-0.0805304423,
-0.3586798608,
-0.3329720497,
-0.1315345913,
0.5066335201,
0.8628827929,
-0.0820709616,
-0.0380974263,
-0.1111354902,
0.8831175566,
-0.6078786254,
-0.1306895614,
-0.6887524724,
0.464032352,
-0.3201012909,
-0.2335869223,
-0.6808944941,
-0.0476771221,
-0.192433551,
-0.3305456638,
0.0932316482,
0.1366287619,
0.5336533189,
0.3430408835,
-0.5167851448,
-0.3512005806,
-0.7865954041,
0.9559538364,
-0.5146474242,
0.5694939494,
0.3768821955,
0.6209850311,
0.0218284559,
-0.1152035892,
-0.3102490604,
-0.0619234294,
-0.050752636,
-0.014999656,
0.0834044516,
-0.3029028475,
0.2829607129,
-0.0803493857,
-0.7203994989,
0.0102863405,
-0.3967754841,
-0.0521911681,
0.8678722382,
0.0536161587,
0.2088426203,
0.0930171385,
-0.2645351589,
-0.5339823961,
-0.7255715132,
-0.2440675944,
0.2800768316,
0.7138313651,
0.1881548762,
0.9237804413,
0.0186324865,
0.7742149234,
-0.0373255759,
-0.1196543351,
0.4406843483,
-0.4027552009,
-0.0993164703,
0.0517866649,
0.9088642001,
0.3352026343,
0.2578124404,
-0.4070814848,
-0.2271038443,
-0.2279818803,
0.1583487689,
-0.5455310345,
-0.0383522436,
0.2796173096,
-0.3413312435,
0.0543789379,
0.0340355858,
-1.0143786669,
-0.5489001274,
-0.1811856329,
0.3112301528,
-0.6868018508,
-0.3522188663,
0.1651796699,
0.1742071062,
0.101075694,
0.044596862,
-0.9283763766,
0.1680542976,
0.6423296928,
1.0647655725,
-0.5471121669,
-0.7903413773,
-0.7287096977,
0.1365478784,
-0.6441602707,
0.597548902,
-0.7150044441,
-0.320780158,
0.0106931822,
0.1002090797,
-0.429158181,
-0.5056269169,
0.5235515833,
-0.2477802187,
0.204333052,
-0.4980649948,
-0.0190276448,
-0.4604567289,
0.1548788995,
-0.655664444,
0.699131906,
-0.3132871687,
-0.3818118274,
0.1669448167,
-0.6854698658,
-0.7707793713,
-0.3335573673,
-0.0389667489,
-0.2954342663,
0.3933453262,
0.3592767119,
0.7010369897,
-0.1530569196,
0.2698184848,
-0.1086226925,
-0.3497542739,
0.3220379353,
-0.7418857217,
0.8441904187,
0.3429333866,
-0.2871007919,
0.2052722126,
-0.2919909954,
-0.1756750345,
0.2270019799,
0.150044322,
-0.1949241757,
0.0239151157,
-0.0411526971,
0.4568136632,
0.0153963435,
-0.1621825546,
0.3871902525,
-0.3394230902,
0.1759006828,
0.3452949524,
-0.1031976566,
0.52745682,
-0.135591656,
0.4647696912,
0.190779388,
0.005806901,
-0.3095760942,
-0.7834942341,
-0.5834938288,
-0.0471250825,
-0.1450881064,
0.4653815031,
-0.7884859443,
0.0656824932,
-0.3930851519,
-0.3937841356,
-0.5938267112,
0.1193917394,
0.3115082681,
-0.0506280921,
0.5529055595,
-0.2377982736,
-0.210015431,
-0.7911757827,
-0.3157462478,
0.1460319608,
0.1987203211,
-0.2341804504,
0.4227508605,
-0.2247156501,
0.1639609039,
-0.3426865935,
-0.4586640596,
-0.3609504402,
0.0055957767,
0.5270751715,
0.4100814462,
0.5223547816,
-1.0168422461,
-0.6895542145,
0.3249586821,
-0.6034907103,
0.3817334175,
-0.4740436971,
-0.4582175314,
0.3633662164,
0.2738179862,
-0.7133060694,
0.1874586791,
0.7155764699,
-0.2600819767,
0.5902304053,
-0.3893836141,
0.3390368223,
-0.8349825144,
-0.2611789107,
-0.0114682028,
0.1016744524,
-0.6881988049,
0.3455956876,
0.1170416549,
-0.1443033963,
-0.4409556985,
0.0459762923,
-0.6478645205,
-0.2162490487,
-0.0607704632,
0.0875304118,
-0.2321703732,
0.4904642999,
0.0163936932,
0.8762847781,
0.534317553,
-0.4614242315,
0.5195931196,
-0.010597704,
0.094338201,
0.4964022338,
-0.1930494457,
0.0967121869,
-0.2073764652,
-0.1976492852,
-0.9216049314,
-0.2176238,
0.3292290568,
-0.4698850513,
0.6491290927,
0.0103766406,
-0.6116800904,
-0.3544073701,
-0.2304540277,
0.2826939225,
0.0846693665,
-0.3760189414,
0.6191759706,
0.4308756888,
-0.0982442945,
-0.6224606037,
-0.9949653745,
0.38629058,
-0.383246541,
-0.6389141679,
0.3110536039,
-0.0283831228,
-0.3772085607,
-0.2336681783,
-0.0917696059,
-0.0144497771,
-0.1484223604,
0.0663101524,
0.1330079436,
-0.1615442783,
0.0962940753,
0.2128072381,
-0.3092438877,
-0.1716378331,
-0.2980856597,
0.8836967945,
-0.2472537011,
-0.9159834981,
-0.1069201529,
0.7833229899,
1.0812071562,
-0.4340304136,
1.1856673956,
0.7137297392,
-0.3493684828,
0.0873350799,
-0.6888746023,
-0.2143779844,
-0.370226562,
0.6981940866,
-0.8872400522,
-0.2417587042,
0.4545406997,
0.0734002888,
0.432834506,
0.4928030074,
0.7779341936,
0.0213388018,
1.3509573936,
0.6876685023,
-0.1811832935,
0.00489419,
-0.280813396,
0.6159593463,
-0.5210881829,
-0.2867752314,
-0.5988119841,
-0.4313939214,
-0.6499029398,
-0.6843386292,
0.5453165174,
-0.1316599697,
-0.1718214452,
0.6284454465,
-0.6713783741,
0.5820758343,
0.4805939496,
-0.1279757023,
0.4571047425,
0.4096807241,
-0.2484770864,
-0.3916916251,
-0.9142088294,
-0.3761763275,
1.0417425632,
0.0192308389,
0.3631803393,
0.1082480103,
0.6855220199,
-0.2117186189,
0.2685799301,
-0.6665628552,
0.4698531628,
-0.3029130995,
-0.5671787858,
-0.7407264113,
-0.4429782629,
-0.8702406287,
1.0565496683,
-0.3374017477,
-0.5074278712,
0.0150987357,
-0.2864546478,
-0.226219058,
0.618264854,
-0.7053718567,
0.891928196,
-0.7027522922,
-0.3621394038,
-0.3321099579,
-0.6392631531,
0.3226133287,
-0.2036089599,
0.6172959805,
-0.1233385056,
-0.1432700902,
0.4397561848,
0.0496794134,
0.3959035575,
0.0723683983,
-0.0953338742,
-0.183203429,
0.472556591,
0.4206047058,
-0.2950640619,
-0.4067351818,
0.2543458343,
-0.1135620847,
-0.3840019405,
-0.4259070456,
0.6648873091,
-0.64671731,
-0.4300025403,
-0.4204285443,
-0.7190648913,
-0.373875916,
0.1004350781,
0.5388071537,
0.0262416024,
0.0746004358,
0.1624699235,
0.4746339619,
-0.2722963393,
0.6235868335,
0.2995508313,
-0.390784204,
-0.4137164652,
1.2571926117,
0.3118431568,
0.1805170327,
0.2579154968,
0.1061991975,
-0.2301140279,
-0.4443469644,
-0.7028680444,
0.5635865927,
-0.4155499041,
-0.1540715396,
-0.5995224118,
-0.075412333,
-0.4339015782,
-0.2510842979,
-0.6793388724,
-0.3291928172,
0.2100650072,
0.068452917,
-0.0984340459,
0.5004062653,
-0.0156656336,
0.060461022,
-0.7762212157,
0.2374107391,
-0.0988226086,
0.0471574739,
0.0623372979,
-0.3282034099,
-0.4365219176,
0.1498870552,
-0.3745300472,
-1.4372851849,
0.8342025876,
0.0167344492,
0.5972556472,
0.5506483316,
0.1127051339,
0.8310235739,
-0.7337161303,
0.5044092536,
0.5821311474,
-0.5370122194,
0.2106050998,
0.0011697708,
0.1668798625,
0.501796782,
0.7335588932,
-1.0048598051,
-0.5663731098,
-0.0935484618,
-0.852859199,
0.5212643147,
0.2455179095,
0.0680545419,
0.1306210607,
-0.2495234907,
0.4351933599,
0.1921646893,
-0.6874917746,
-0.2181734741,
-0.0322971679,
-0.0639915019,
-0.4746997356,
-0.0615525693,
-0.177001223,
-0.2828314602,
0.6739397049,
-0.1054178402,
0.2515410781,
-0.1374092251,
-0.3187612593,
-0.2491904199,
0.1542621106,
0.6182637215,
0.7253267765,
0.1508103609,
0.2519335747,
0.2114098817,
-0.2353747636,
0.1303541958,
-0.1587744653,
-0.1769375652,
0.2917185426,
0.3875098825,
0.7395063639,
0.1048009917,
-0.4343757629,
0.2687571049,
0.2527172565,
-0.0774389133,
0.0147034507,
-0.1773472428,
0.1003674865,
0.2486631721,
0.5257300735,
0.3308685124,
-0.0818654373,
-0.5044973493,
-0.05012317,
0.3342386782,
-0.2586339712,
-0.3916727006,
0.5546643734,
-0.0674562007,
-0.5487191081,
0.6457338929,
-0.2072545886,
-0.6586960554,
0.2851542234,
0.4367696941,
0.9336463213,
-0.2035336792,
0.2867368758,
0.4289337099,
0.7280039191,
-0.4390836358,
-0.002570013,
-0.0133652054,
-0.6240519881,
-0.6369032264,
-0.3690840602,
-0.452005446,
-0.3931584656,
-0.5481274128,
0.199865818,
0.2384741157,
-0.3259722292,
-0.3271208704,
-0.1641561389,
-0.5824261308,
-0.4122796357,
0.2484223992,
0.5690313578,
-1.0129783154,
0.8227975965,
0.6612462401,
-0.5223959088,
-0.2404346764,
0.1617040783,
0.1539135575,
-0.5028008223,
0.4153732657,
0.2332186848,
-0.1499853432,
-0.3486552835,
-0.4503617287,
-0.963622272,
0.5768057704,
0.3985208571,
-0.6124330163,
-0.1210697591,
0.3979295492,
0.3316839635,
-0.2544462979,
0.0517277271,
0.6257976294,
0.6548112035,
0.0414089225,
-0.8952274919,
0.0108702937,
-0.1037599519,
-0.053480342,
0.2315541059,
-0.6354375482,
0.7601760626,
-0.4063116014,
-0.2288006842,
-0.2135738581,
0.5686308146,
0.2408293188,
0.2732998431,
0.3189845681,
0.3282888532,
0.8043622971,
-0.001706827,
0.7802350521,
-0.5495092869,
0.2354648858,
0.9582467079,
-0.3765662313,
1.0005010366,
0.7635210156,
-0.1367539763,
0.0309481602,
0.3045638502,
0.2275250107,
0.5036987066,
-0.2665721774,
0.0178190824,
-0.3704532385,
0.2988258302,
-0.5295585394,
0.2792193294,
0.4555406868,
-0.0545581393,
-0.1276704371,
0.5190707445,
0.1723129898,
0.1171239465,
0.072065033,
0.4944657385,
-0.0071327169,
-0.9046609998,
0.694347918,
0.2316010445,
0.7501674891,
-0.4471651018,
0.1645626128,
-0.4211986065,
0.0979400724,
-0.0210764408,
-0.7187079191,
0.6392428875,
0.0716143474,
0.0466919653,
-0.6673173904,
0.3249684274,
-0.6029128432,
-0.699023664,
0.491458565,
0.8526198268,
0.3373226821,
-0.330457598,
-0.5373029709,
0.2085998207,
0.0127999317,
-0.2391873151,
0.4691145718,
0.7865979671,
0.0609899797,
0.7650406957,
0.6162858009,
0.3390494883,
0.413626492,
-0.045928739,
0.5069086552,
-0.7439317107,
-0.3249222338,
-0.993062675,
0.2889451385,
-0.0803230777,
-0.1857948452,
0.9718122482,
0.5774869323,
1.0149718523,
-0.0786755309,
0.1818341166,
0.2729689479,
0.1257703006,
-0.2937497497,
0.7752354741,
-0.5861619711,
0.1081958264,
-0.2317192703,
-1.2091238499,
-0.5002687573,
0.7433131933,
-0.2637935877,
-0.4069586396,
0.9517300129,
0.6494706273,
0.0210158117,
-0.0204385947,
0.6400970817,
0.1648211926,
0.1902770996,
0.7174006701,
0.3856057823,
-0.2650348842,
0.7618308067,
-0.5389516354,
-0.0909412131,
-0.2734344304,
-0.4039694667,
-0.6643052101,
-0.6296468973,
-0.0511965863,
-0.1444872022,
0.1121556088,
1.0480175018,
0.7300812602,
-1.009504199,
-0.7745558023,
0.3511170745,
0.3562732637,
-0.6588770151,
-0.1031845808,
0.1493593156,
-0.7363812923,
-0.7663523555,
0.4857362807,
0.5280268192,
-0.2042526007,
-0.4000944793,
-0.350081414,
-0.1613606513,
-0.2609036565,
0.7809530497,
-0.0141731687,
-0.7401382923,
0.2362086773,
0.335875392,
-0.2674300373,
0.1903811097,
0.8714711666,
-0.3006570041,
0.582062006,
0.4533599913,
0.6578692794,
0.5172893405,
-0.30935058,
0.6177610755,
-0.2873948812,
0.3806646466,
0.2855120599,
0.3304484487,
0.3386112154,
-0.149490878,
0.6869288087,
0.1485997289,
-0.1939350963,
-0.8489480615,
0.1599921733,
-0.4899863601,
-0.4534812868,
1.0475929976,
0.1740389764,
-0.1255806386,
0.1307896823,
-0.1250544786,
0.1625064611,
-0.1278479695,
0.6135651469,
0.867949903,
-0.2148683518,
-0.0063287928,
-0.8139329553,
0.0194329843,
0.5770846009,
-0.249710083,
0.1475510746,
0.4805864692,
-0.3849777281,
0.4155164957,
0.2681003511,
-0.2339867949,
-0.0725270733,
-0.0205111708,
-0.2134478092,
0.0684522837,
-0.8147197962,
-0.4554008842,
0.4619410932,
-0.2585465908,
-0.1975596845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07430v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07430v2
|
Controlled Text Generation for Black-box Language Models via Score-based Progressive Editor
| 2023-11-13T16:03:23 | 2024-06-08T04:35:07 |
Sangwon Yu, Changmin Lee, Hojin Lee, Sungroh Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Controlled text generation is very important for the practical use of
language models because it ensures that the produced text includes only the
desired attributes from a specific domain or dataset. Existing methods,
however, are inapplicable to black-box models or suffer a significant trade-off
between controlling the generated text and maintaining its fluency. This paper
introduces the Score-based Progressive Editor (ScoPE), a novel approach
designed to overcome these issues. ScoPE modifies the context at the token
level during the generation process of a backbone language model. This
modification guides the subsequent text to naturally include the target
attributes. To facilitate this process, ScoPE employs a training objective that
maximizes a target score, thoroughly considering both the ability to guide the
text and its fluency. Experimental results on diverse controlled generation
tasks demonstrate that ScoPE can effectively regulate the attributes of the
generated text while fully utilizing the capability of the backbone large
language models. Our codes are available at
\url{https://github.com/ysw1021/ScoPE}.
|
[
-0.2515735328,
-1.0101573467,
0.4467771947,
0.2363487631,
-0.0526152179,
0.201455906,
-0.3935070336,
-0.1299039721,
0.1397117674,
0.6446962953,
-0.5597177744,
-0.5965198874,
-0.4091415703,
-0.061594408,
-0.5467137694,
1.3085106611,
-0.3116802573,
-0.2947233617,
0.0000192736,
-0.0891813263,
-0.750208497,
-0.3952195644,
-0.587310493,
-0.2092248052,
0.3617044985,
0.2410769314,
0.7842419744,
0.7257806063,
0.4595067501,
0.2650611997,
-0.2602880001,
0.1098877639,
-0.516503036,
0.3477738798,
-0.4603223205,
-0.3717619181,
-0.9688420892,
-0.0924868956,
1.1405217648,
0.6268321872,
-0.0929198042,
0.080442965,
0.1281157285,
0.5444793105,
-0.7907940149,
-0.1633074135,
-0.6927807331,
0.1307448745,
-0.3281945288,
0.0071876873,
-0.5438618064,
-0.1749041229,
-0.1661929488,
-0.5342906117,
0.1189475358,
-0.2804721296,
1.0668232441,
-0.1474600285,
-0.4644147456,
-0.2807599604,
-0.7591152191,
0.9063275456,
-0.4835168421,
0.2889114618,
0.3515974581,
0.1790622622,
-0.0025832506,
-0.8212500215,
-0.6276216507,
-0.189552784,
0.2036240101,
0.2770903111,
-0.148950249,
0.1015836895,
-0.0036572986,
0.6137199998,
-0.3649539351,
-0.0731697604,
-0.1353799254,
-0.3421981633,
0.4998709857,
0.2394569516,
0.173954621,
-0.3252728879,
0.1336984634,
-0.0546627119,
-0.5525176525,
0.0478017628,
0.482617408,
0.2273864448,
0.0607717186,
0.8739269972,
-0.5228906274,
0.8838296533,
0.4457165003,
-0.0078256,
0.1314226389,
-0.563318789,
-0.1213825345,
-0.3239016235,
0.7920348048,
0.3666065931,
0.2717431784,
-0.0851702392,
-0.5194431543,
0.3591729403,
0.6279312968,
-0.6282199025,
0.0935959369,
0.0942184031,
-0.1456858963,
-0.8063233495,
0.0276832376,
-0.9671771526,
0.0858021602,
-0.0203416571,
0.379755497,
-0.2581031919,
-0.3251965642,
0.0845386013,
0.0634212047,
-0.0352203622,
0.1889350712,
-0.791046977,
0.2821020782,
0.4940719306,
0.9391005039,
-0.423145324,
-0.0257776678,
-1.0206521749,
0.1218435615,
-0.5755856037,
0.3627296388,
-0.8843590617,
-0.5964641571,
0.254950583,
-0.3054639697,
0.348649174,
-0.213528946,
0.3187291622,
-0.6144177914,
0.4726414084,
0.3625391424,
-0.4592272937,
0.1397890747,
0.4559578001,
-0.4105549753,
1.1087813377,
0.340675354,
-0.3061376214,
0.365737915,
-0.6770073771,
-0.428283751,
0.0924283639,
-0.0043261228,
-0.6855700016,
0.3429831266,
0.0244914982,
0.2108733058,
0.1837341785,
0.627174139,
-0.058677379,
0.0824109018,
0.2719487846,
-0.3720707893,
0.1633788496,
0.0859878659,
-0.4472153783,
0.281345576,
-0.8435418606,
0.4340624809,
-0.2438750863,
-0.5836673975,
-0.0856214985,
-0.036051359,
0.2055345774,
0.0451883227,
0.3576513529,
-0.477153331,
0.309512645,
-0.3869591951,
0.2045443058,
0.7133689523,
0.1495836228,
0.6538830996,
-0.2704682946,
0.8161922693,
-0.2877115309,
0.1513821036,
-0.2228993624,
-0.5002102852,
-0.785228014,
-0.1593766361,
0.5678070784,
0.5416457653,
-0.6355621219,
0.657656908,
-0.1401976943,
-0.3865683079,
-0.3015833199,
0.1847234368,
0.573528409,
0.5225905776,
0.2332866043,
-0.7116539478,
-0.2116577178,
-0.6990981698,
-0.3080986738,
0.0052801943,
-0.1636128426,
0.3829551339,
0.4211622477,
-0.3304454684,
1.2531635761,
-0.8162683845,
-0.4371987879,
-0.4160400331,
0.1147617698,
-0.0409948453,
0.7685590982,
0.2486285269,
-0.8550623655,
-0.4376204312,
0.1824692786,
-0.4340116382,
-0.6016975045,
-0.3540141881,
-0.3719558418,
-0.1216162071,
0.4088396728,
-0.4293068349,
0.4385625124,
0.9942151308,
-0.5443950295,
0.9265878201,
-0.0899493918,
0.083577387,
-1.2536766529,
0.2400793731,
0.0166079365,
-0.6185865998,
-0.7023586035,
0.4171363711,
0.2209775746,
-0.3134463131,
-0.3615372479,
0.661403954,
-0.1919929683,
0.4058868587,
-0.4014979601,
0.2246520519,
0.4191690087,
0.3842860758,
0.0261662807,
0.7629454136,
0.4449831247,
-0.5375683308,
0.1317372024,
0.3173183799,
-0.1760296971,
0.8826674819,
-0.6786067486,
0.0994289741,
0.1735846251,
0.1138613969,
-0.4733512998,
-0.4197463095,
0.1055667028,
-0.4066476822,
0.5422202349,
0.1421899647,
-0.2410503477,
-0.1104230806,
-0.2062065154,
0.2278776169,
0.4532792568,
0.1115218997,
0.4965997636,
0.4998122752,
-0.1592901796,
-0.3760947883,
-1.0159225464,
0.2554753721,
-0.0731368065,
-0.2270581722,
0.4932088852,
-0.2634747326,
-0.0587614961,
-0.0321909823,
-0.0515180081,
-0.1614882201,
0.015066281,
0.0830263123,
0.1842252761,
-0.0872660205,
0.2473616004,
0.5039913058,
-0.176307261,
-0.2763778567,
-0.4966377318,
0.3696518242,
-0.0140747968,
-0.1143264323,
-0.3456797898,
0.6483442187,
0.4507474303,
-0.732580483,
0.6420807242,
0.1694363505,
-0.3263781667,
-0.5961189866,
-0.2334268242,
-0.0482480973,
-0.5340464115,
0.6539608836,
-0.4083351493,
-0.9982526898,
0.4003911018,
-0.343383491,
0.1256158948,
0.3360108435,
0.7328950763,
0.2890016735,
1.008055687,
0.8761795163,
0.1881632805,
0.8777003884,
-0.2466273904,
-0.0740112588,
-0.9899446368,
0.2304991782,
-0.3321523666,
-0.1966816187,
-0.6181635261,
-0.2965007126,
0.4404540956,
0.3122909367,
-0.0889838189,
0.2207928002,
-0.7861821651,
0.4560828507,
0.3456350863,
0.0912803635,
0.2653401196,
-0.3458047509,
-0.3799304068,
0.0085193533,
-0.6338258386,
-0.5801399946,
1.2632628679,
0.2898197174,
0.6162792444,
0.1381759495,
0.7120967507,
0.3193118274,
0.5303924084,
-0.6512077451,
0.6148129106,
-0.2280901819,
-0.7393050194,
-0.2857589126,
-0.4975141883,
-0.6914150119,
0.0084661255,
-0.3770621419,
-0.7752522826,
0.073869355,
0.3725128174,
-0.0081447242,
0.0379394628,
-0.6680743694,
1.0609025955,
0.021225052,
-0.6918238401,
-0.137498647,
-0.1323133856,
0.3371194303,
-0.5637483597,
0.1411135793,
0.2403265983,
-0.1230326518,
0.5433508754,
-0.3912881911,
0.8788326979,
-0.0688864216,
0.0239919629,
0.3013787866,
0.4622876942,
0.7735772729,
0.3180510402,
-0.3064590096,
-0.0186321102,
-0.4512829185,
-0.2927168906,
-0.3583699167,
0.7097872496,
-0.3693565428,
-0.6034721732,
-0.3171245754,
-0.7619270682,
-0.2612112463,
0.7322140932,
0.1626019627,
0.5613951683,
-0.2259994149,
0.4221296906,
0.2860710919,
-0.3257323503,
0.309361726,
0.4795770645,
-0.3777729869,
-0.577501893,
0.8030390739,
0.0779143125,
0.6966720819,
0.4612599909,
0.3355714977,
-0.1189493611,
-0.7476354837,
-0.4380592704,
-0.1178206876,
-0.5388482809,
-0.3736917973,
-0.3735217154,
-0.2165220529,
-0.0073106028,
-0.5884987116,
-0.5015090108,
-0.3007564545,
-0.3469884992,
-0.0283655114,
0.1793637425,
0.6733166575,
0.1153150126,
0.6561877728,
-0.6358040571,
0.3270418346,
0.3022871315,
0.871820271,
-0.3129871488,
-0.2914659083,
-0.3464050889,
0.1159394532,
-0.7711706758,
-0.9461269379,
0.4217120707,
0.5702437758,
0.1485922039,
0.1180618405,
0.0286130253,
0.5111253262,
-0.7557332516,
0.9861337543,
0.1388591081,
-1.4712090492,
0.824627459,
-0.424556762,
0.9926217198,
0.4792415798,
-0.2194116712,
-0.5035684109,
-1.3372763395,
-0.3422540426,
-0.6630780697,
0.5036008954,
0.4161190689,
0.523429215,
-0.0884022415,
0.4728873074,
0.2348416597,
0.5174005032,
-0.9943718314,
0.1440041512,
-0.441608578,
-0.5836167932,
0.0174510125,
-0.0962208211,
0.0476191938,
0.223332271,
0.4844969213,
-0.288413018,
-0.1301140785,
0.2235553712,
-0.1030346006,
-0.4515373111,
0.3500536978,
0.6267729998,
0.8007463813,
-0.0149777494,
-0.2075261027,
0.096308291,
-0.8086807728,
-0.0098222587,
-0.2034578472,
-0.7502455711,
0.0501333401,
0.32138592,
0.8135656714,
0.1225689948,
-0.5642107725,
0.5048241019,
0.0766313374,
-0.3496563733,
0.0607110746,
0.3031779528,
-0.2041050643,
0.2122419029,
0.3679968417,
0.1575086862,
-0.097526513,
-0.3128279746,
0.5126774311,
0.4977037609,
-0.3908845484,
-0.3230052292,
1.0650237799,
0.4005891979,
-0.6442987919,
0.2523947358,
-0.3077155352,
-0.43724069,
0.2487502545,
0.5668732524,
1.0195200443,
-0.1932200342,
0.4869060218,
0.1696641296,
0.1187638715,
0.0839719549,
0.1341326088,
-0.000818898,
-0.6428245306,
-0.7320744991,
-1.0252093077,
-0.5363610387,
0.1488138139,
-0.6169023514,
0.3492581546,
-0.4237656593,
-0.4913543165,
-0.0151414592,
-0.1197609827,
-0.4595641196,
0.410815686,
-0.1190093458,
0.9643105865,
-0.5550078154,
0.962691009,
0.5686710477,
-0.3150821626,
-0.581571281,
0.245576933,
-0.0970101357,
-0.2765565217,
0.3515551686,
0.0769374743,
0.0558112971,
0.2100074142,
-0.2316325903,
-0.5169579983,
0.8043832183,
0.1380524635,
-0.7513457537,
-0.0026390627,
0.002510034,
0.7356107831,
-0.513663888,
-0.1065785587,
0.1721814722,
0.4477366209,
-0.1416801214,
-1.0425211191,
-0.0416432805,
-0.1961039454,
0.0423432253,
0.4639757574,
-0.5415546298,
0.715154171,
0.2299076319,
-0.1424950659,
0.1384178847,
0.6760259867,
0.1369625479,
0.1403665543,
0.4494666457,
0.3605626225,
0.5869311094,
-0.074576579,
1.0377858877,
-0.3858602345,
0.459572196,
0.7766801715,
-0.2090065926,
0.861527741,
0.3438330293,
0.0777622983,
0.6605730057,
0.1238170043,
-0.0190910902,
0.5892422795,
0.1475555897,
-0.3450625241,
0.0180643443,
0.0239535179,
-0.0607323237,
0.6662036777,
0.3284373879,
-0.4211360216,
-0.0388792679,
0.2062699795,
0.0524404757,
0.5523123741,
-0.4891614616,
0.7728384137,
-0.1554687768,
-0.8666141033,
0.4510586858,
0.2063425034,
0.6530237198,
-1.0884517431,
0.1556370258,
-0.1426187903,
0.3895266652,
0.0534128919,
-1.047432065,
0.6171161532,
0.4064367414,
-0.3184482455,
-0.6375436783,
0.5371828079,
-0.6866466999,
-0.8092828989,
-0.1225865036,
0.3639607131,
-0.3443636596,
-0.0054126647,
-0.5308698416,
0.089559935,
-0.1316370666,
-0.5762723088,
0.2512925565,
0.4964040816,
-0.3140681386,
0.5066800714,
0.6686899662,
0.642320931,
-0.0556710325,
-0.239038676,
0.9367684126,
-0.6128817201,
-0.9074419141,
-0.6058205366,
0.9101327062,
-0.1398226768,
-0.6651483774,
0.5173729658,
0.4368993342,
0.7107889652,
-0.1624813676,
0.84589535,
-0.177384004,
0.3065880835,
-0.4777216017,
0.8934175372,
-0.7034356594,
0.0058688917,
-0.3188319206,
-0.9137227535,
-0.6362991929,
0.422642231,
-0.2766262889,
-0.0135855693,
0.6535912752,
0.848621726,
0.0129169524,
-0.5242466331,
0.1975048184,
0.0260491315,
0.6322131753,
0.4828178883,
0.3473008275,
-0.199442625,
0.7300029397,
-0.0148197915,
-0.5290541053,
-0.0015163043,
-1.0941759348,
-0.7312733531,
-0.4122956097,
-0.3716537654,
-0.3886310756,
0.1448872089,
0.1770192683,
0.6913899183,
-0.9336972237,
-0.1568116546,
-0.6337931156,
0.1610497534,
-0.397661835,
-0.3151364625,
0.2327333987,
-0.4207100272,
-0.9977160096,
0.2425331026,
0.3845871687,
-0.1296968013,
-0.4439786077,
-0.2252233624,
-0.1502266377,
0.2456890941,
0.508380115,
0.1382071972,
-0.5013836622,
-0.504200995,
-0.0384276398,
-0.2041855007,
-0.1654521525,
0.665805459,
-0.8282780647,
0.9538622499,
0.4421026707,
0.5048635602,
0.3312738538,
-0.0151396655,
1.085768342,
-1.2523593903,
0.1637025774,
0.3609639406,
-0.1133057177,
0.3519714177,
-0.3364863396,
0.125502035,
0.1689710915,
-0.5570895076,
-1.0806391239,
0.4317621589,
-0.9876447916,
-0.1618791521,
1.0725436211,
-0.0850229487,
-0.1521076709,
0.3233010173,
-0.395270437,
0.3015290797,
-0.2994211912,
0.7936347723,
0.8213294744,
0.3838919997,
-0.207455948,
-0.6580521464,
0.494051367,
0.3225215673,
-0.6865897179,
-0.0448628217,
0.4779149294,
0.0241654646,
0.1937736124,
0.4254563749,
-0.1360726804,
0.4554880261,
-0.0236771796,
0.0553515516,
-0.1653512418,
-0.1836870164,
-0.2433824539,
0.4990017116,
-0.0865377337,
-0.3195874989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07424v1
|
Hallucination Augmented Recitations for Language Models
| 2023-11-13T15:58:18 | 2023-11-13T15:58:18 |
Abdullatif Köksal, Renat Aksitov, Chung-Ching Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Attribution is a key concept in large language models (LLMs) as it enables
control over information sources and enhances the factuality of LLMs. While
existing approaches utilize open book question answering to improve
attribution, factual datasets may reward language models to recall facts that
they already know from their pretraining data, not attribution. In contrast,
counterfactual open book QA datasets would further improve attribution because
the answer could only be grounded in the given text. We propose Hallucination
Augmented Recitations (HAR) for creating counterfactual datasets by utilizing
hallucination in LLMs to improve attribution. For open book QA as a case study,
we demonstrate that models finetuned with our counterfactual datasets improve
text grounding, leading to better open book QA performance, with up to an 8.0%
increase in F1 score. Our counterfactual dataset leads to significantly better
performance than using humanannotated factual datasets, even with 4x smaller
datasets and 4x smaller models. We observe that improvements are consistent
across various model sizes and datasets, including multi-hop, biomedical, and
adversarial QA datasets.
|
[
-0.1870790571,
-0.934809804,
0.6194841266,
-0.0550623313,
-0.2466352433,
-0.1739384085,
-0.045070909,
-0.474932611,
0.2514308691,
0.7239227891,
-0.281591624,
-0.405254364,
-0.2873806655,
-0.0012583188,
-0.6418705583,
0.8986634612,
-0.0144281862,
0.098706305,
-0.5746482015,
-0.2752205729,
-0.6333224177,
-0.8058030009,
-0.4693494439,
-0.6209700108,
0.680059433,
0.334736973,
0.7671347857,
0.5942242742,
0.1989727616,
0.2906861901,
0.1126391515,
0.2210181057,
-0.4999302626,
0.0428394079,
-0.3241304159,
-0.6585898995,
-0.2633272707,
0.1566218287,
0.6175555587,
0.6690860987,
-0.4840344489,
0.0698621795,
-0.1647988111,
0.8506587744,
-0.6889376044,
0.0072031049,
-0.5825610161,
-0.0922606587,
0.138424769,
-0.5253412724,
-0.6130152941,
-0.9061746597,
0.1166835353,
-0.6826566458,
0.3734467626,
0.134447664,
0.6015857458,
0.4262137711,
-0.1730058789,
-0.5205435157,
-0.7613047361,
0.7700107098,
-0.7919462323,
0.7439661026,
0.4828006327,
-0.0269211587,
-0.0424616635,
-0.4712061286,
-0.7981081605,
-0.1841004044,
-0.4229323864,
-0.131381914,
-0.1715145856,
-0.2590365112,
0.3160275817,
0.5228459835,
-0.6092984676,
-0.179781571,
-0.1703603268,
-0.0162075702,
0.4711828232,
-0.0305411685,
0.3384606838,
-0.1410456896,
0.0456326194,
-0.2842712998,
-0.8253930211,
-0.1645724922,
0.1709947884,
0.4250762165,
0.1630464792,
0.7380083799,
-0.1620204151,
0.7168591022,
0.0735938177,
0.104105182,
0.5241214633,
-0.2877628207,
-0.2854770124,
0.3173208237,
0.4323374629,
0.2101279646,
0.5554947257,
-0.3933900297,
-0.1754840612,
0.0909645557,
0.5374224186,
-0.7084558606,
-0.4432044923,
0.3649880886,
-0.4550682604,
-0.3577726185,
-0.0170653071,
-0.9349668026,
-0.6737725735,
-0.6652874947,
0.6561322212,
-0.3617796004,
-0.3085694015,
0.1743719131,
-0.0155396946,
0.2087666243,
0.3292303681,
-0.7562077045,
0.4227646291,
0.4048476517,
0.9601676464,
-0.0227847509,
-0.277121067,
-0.7469137311,
0.1645689011,
-0.5940520763,
0.8055024743,
-0.6795498729,
-0.0695970431,
-0.0101267081,
0.0547523424,
-0.1649635732,
-0.8907209635,
0.2540750206,
-0.6430853009,
0.2882930338,
-0.5627191663,
-0.4969052672,
-0.5594856739,
0.2326248437,
-0.9181258082,
1.0064166784,
-0.0487706028,
-0.6034205556,
0.3194931448,
-0.6451461315,
-0.4716345072,
-0.179409489,
-0.4809206724,
-0.4969490767,
0.2262861133,
0.4071274698,
0.3097535372,
-0.1280437708,
0.3502791226,
0.0392693914,
-0.5335694551,
0.5622751713,
-0.5415470004,
0.6579250693,
-0.0435344428,
-0.3256661892,
0.2171387672,
-0.9356698394,
-0.019140413,
0.1735575944,
-0.1763773263,
-0.551151216,
0.0450707674,
-0.1935150772,
0.0035873509,
-0.2185032666,
-0.4975298345,
0.1745393872,
-0.5958995223,
0.0496542081,
0.5898775458,
0.0749464333,
0.2219360322,
-0.5940973759,
0.4056226015,
-0.0572743267,
-0.4407325983,
0.0950528234,
-0.3172973096,
-0.6856020093,
-0.4895923436,
0.1358638555,
0.7399109006,
-0.9606580138,
0.2832940519,
-0.2492725849,
-0.5204764009,
-0.7285211682,
0.0009271789,
0.5232893229,
0.5760742426,
0.5753903389,
-0.1303920001,
-0.6942204833,
-0.5208647847,
-0.2502861619,
-0.422639221,
0.0214606598,
0.2587356269,
0.4761817455,
0.0046891444,
0.7971021533,
-0.6190478802,
-0.3003110886,
-0.1058593616,
0.3457627296,
0.1843834519,
0.4614515603,
0.4120921791,
-0.7647638917,
-0.2267361581,
-0.1826449186,
-1.0198494196,
-0.137345165,
-0.1755366772,
-0.0399609543,
0.5003948808,
0.5646971464,
-0.7236495614,
0.5657398105,
0.3749456108,
-0.5082935095,
0.7013874054,
-0.0746424571,
0.7069597244,
-0.7528250813,
0.1974858046,
-0.4188224077,
-0.2130843401,
-0.7408099174,
0.0232697744,
-0.2457658201,
0.1249229312,
-0.4413878918,
0.6006677747,
-0.2054917067,
-0.1136651859,
-0.2348043621,
0.1496919692,
-0.0313361883,
0.4677848816,
0.4033131003,
0.9490934014,
0.269477725,
-0.6468880177,
0.5825702548,
0.6286582351,
-0.5837050676,
0.1826643348,
-0.7310092449,
0.0998302996,
-0.1481188536,
0.1004251391,
-1.2269103527,
-0.2687007189,
0.3322660625,
-0.5135461688,
0.0485934876,
0.3486380875,
-0.6107868552,
-0.0151270786,
-0.2701300085,
0.5838001966,
0.4355085492,
-0.9039189219,
0.6150099635,
0.0194447041,
-0.1299101412,
-0.5991489887,
-0.7803708315,
-0.1425845176,
-0.2629646361,
-0.1929321885,
0.2040326297,
-0.0477661528,
-0.4419510365,
-0.0633545816,
0.0875338763,
0.1688092202,
-0.1196650565,
0.2715738416,
0.3250462115,
-0.2562063038,
0.4703793228,
-0.3146977127,
-0.0539171919,
0.1420408934,
0.1377963126,
0.6640591621,
-0.0574303232,
-0.3787924945,
-0.4933774173,
0.3517360091,
0.367975682,
-0.0384014845,
1.1081573963,
0.3401607573,
-0.6687189937,
0.1619685292,
-0.7047050595,
-0.4688012898,
-0.4154832661,
0.2587436736,
-0.4593882859,
-0.629503727,
0.6879186034,
0.4577513933,
0.0300593674,
0.2413437515,
0.8658140898,
0.1900149584,
0.710934639,
0.4248325229,
-0.1018777043,
0.398170501,
0.086958155,
0.3300528824,
-0.4388376176,
-0.274009943,
-0.5839167237,
0.088366732,
-0.4155809283,
-0.3445574343,
0.080300726,
0.1340745538,
-0.1116522029,
0.0362645462,
-0.4478722811,
0.539246738,
0.6512531042,
0.3610070944,
0.6178209186,
0.3558505177,
0.1282776594,
-0.1006294191,
-0.6776024699,
-0.5920991898,
1.0444813967,
0.2979815006,
0.67216748,
0.3760388494,
0.475464195,
0.3968523741,
0.5017340779,
-0.7307649255,
0.4270113707,
0.0038896245,
-0.6099267602,
-0.6839063168,
-0.4276186526,
-0.6116938591,
0.2400247753,
-0.2736138105,
-0.7325457335,
0.3682917058,
0.4147953093,
-0.5434163809,
0.1584917456,
-0.5942873359,
0.8916138411,
0.3299313188,
-0.3154703081,
-0.1669124961,
-0.3125883043,
0.3552376628,
-0.1985523254,
0.1716296077,
0.4785045981,
0.294336319,
1.0171654224,
-0.3985326886,
0.9403921366,
-0.081581749,
-0.5039547682,
0.4007982612,
0.0904070064,
0.7817103863,
-0.1251441091,
-0.296654284,
-0.0247588735,
0.095512569,
-0.2087961137,
-0.9638229012,
0.5496345758,
-0.758626461,
-0.5356185436,
-0.4042577147,
-0.5666776896,
-0.2403118461,
-0.0953462496,
0.2730120718,
0.6319767833,
-0.0652656257,
0.3049765527,
0.9000857472,
-0.3931193352,
0.059709128,
0.5501502752,
-0.4560268521,
-0.4699776471,
1.0699846745,
0.0319337919,
0.3978289068,
0.331793189,
0.0208616052,
-0.540574491,
-0.5312127471,
-0.2134748697,
0.4685253501,
-1.0383802652,
-0.1047689095,
-0.8797821999,
-0.3014217913,
-0.7758330703,
-0.2733362019,
-0.3888182938,
-0.3488226831,
-0.3198390305,
-0.3198696375,
0.663634181,
0.5730013847,
-0.1773183942,
0.3441016078,
-0.6523675323,
0.6723765135,
0.2561140358,
0.2935293913,
0.3332430422,
-0.9346414804,
-0.2432112694,
0.0734998435,
-0.0281528383,
-0.7736933231,
0.5469931364,
0.0800253972,
0.4257058501,
0.1172050461,
0.1551301628,
0.9203358293,
-0.5737642646,
0.6834711432,
0.0814955011,
-0.8192331195,
0.3669326305,
-0.0306918565,
0.1210566238,
0.5324257612,
0.4513036609,
-0.4929357767,
-0.4458875358,
-0.4477156699,
-0.5787643194,
0.6918230057,
0.2231779993,
-0.034664005,
-0.0857121125,
0.496085763,
0.2710125148,
0.3227546811,
-0.9200004339,
-0.2037622035,
-0.3845756352,
-0.38357234,
-0.3978671432,
-0.4511983097,
-0.1346064061,
-0.4680989981,
0.9721170664,
0.0428790972,
0.2720766664,
0.3777980804,
-0.188809365,
-0.4352035522,
0.3546073735,
0.7046431303,
0.7942508459,
-0.5496729016,
0.3741663098,
0.113530457,
-0.4137093425,
0.2754155397,
-0.0150672365,
-0.1436808407,
0.0702442005,
0.6674930453,
0.6890861392,
-0.1448707581,
-0.7797777057,
0.3257002831,
0.2699229717,
-0.1264291555,
-0.3154176176,
0.0458238497,
-0.0957002193,
0.3856874704,
0.2740047574,
-0.3313156366,
0.2172248065,
-0.7692265511,
0.5974175334,
0.1647279114,
-0.3577395082,
-0.099310942,
0.5373771787,
-0.0632529557,
-0.202430144,
0.845811069,
0.0577888489,
-0.5942907929,
0.406619966,
0.7790107131,
0.7255299687,
-0.3898051977,
0.3149863482,
0.5134134889,
0.2855764925,
-0.1959286332,
0.4079838693,
0.2032414526,
-0.9466312528,
-0.4830480218,
-0.6359140873,
-0.3177731633,
0.3979967535,
-0.5882195234,
0.0962510481,
-0.0530543886,
0.3020689487,
-0.1310882568,
-0.124763079,
-0.2735350132,
0.4397751987,
-0.1672475189,
0.483980149,
-1.0924277306,
0.709078908,
0.5629338622,
-0.6077658534,
-0.4457301199,
-0.0036460091,
-0.1304395646,
-0.6099689603,
0.6865454912,
0.1902178228,
-0.114341639,
0.2289635539,
-0.5496640801,
-0.7416200042,
0.8912311196,
0.2453034371,
-0.5606452823,
-0.0277173705,
0.3304331601,
0.5125273466,
-0.4694890976,
0.1653452665,
0.6407233477,
0.2891044617,
0.3383362591,
-0.7004681826,
0.4828420579,
-0.0226914622,
-0.3100081086,
0.0462136455,
-0.1149409711,
0.7462301254,
-0.4077112973,
-0.0916458964,
0.110298574,
0.8401093483,
0.6883752942,
0.4739242196,
0.6294859648,
0.490206331,
0.8368138075,
0.1468828321,
0.8985534906,
0.2079403102,
0.1170751005,
1.4531933069,
-0.1990230829,
0.9709937572,
0.7213196158,
-0.1136876866,
0.4216665924,
0.5104973912,
0.119771719,
0.632699132,
0.1302300841,
-0.0645513311,
-0.3529059291,
-0.3113339841,
-0.3558021784,
0.1606796235,
0.1247903407,
-0.3957172334,
-0.0729188025,
0.2521394491,
-0.2304805666,
0.4097505212,
-0.0702857003,
0.8251302242,
-0.0088875489,
-0.5670746565,
1.0682176352,
-0.300709486,
0.2835751176,
-0.2544179857,
-0.5105012059,
-0.1892617345,
0.1171893701,
-0.3136085868,
-0.5768924952,
0.5094139576,
-0.0662746876,
-0.5786092281,
-0.0801056251,
0.5063575506,
-0.8080545664,
-0.4535142481,
0.0524124615,
0.3499905765,
0.5147049427,
-0.4155772626,
-0.3015078306,
0.0533081554,
0.0695286095,
-0.460793227,
-0.1985946,
0.466034919,
-0.0922075287,
0.7694622874,
0.5668645501,
0.1773327738,
-0.0689886287,
0.2222897857,
0.9375737309,
-0.9485821724,
-0.3139038384,
-0.894451201,
0.3568926156,
0.0731621459,
0.0217086617,
0.6666194797,
0.5512965322,
0.8190512657,
-0.2425006628,
0.6675745845,
0.0527268574,
0.9558010697,
-0.8987824321,
0.6678708792,
-0.7429590225,
0.3553994596,
-0.2999719679,
-0.9393355846,
-0.3320816159,
0.7435004115,
-0.3162766099,
-0.0033757838,
0.7022867203,
1.0681116581,
0.0642818138,
0.1182092875,
0.5373226404,
0.2884967923,
0.4278978705,
0.3287374079,
0.7293386459,
-0.632432282,
0.2859538496,
-0.036974702,
-0.2639334798,
-0.294364363,
-0.7003657222,
-1.1258393526,
-0.6397736073,
-0.5241855979,
-0.4394130111,
0.1368631423,
1.0369412899,
0.2009631842,
-1.100020647,
-0.1348358393,
-0.1210603565,
0.1392732263,
-0.2614852488,
-0.3100872934,
0.5466023088,
-0.3311159909,
-0.4780733883,
0.2693220973,
-0.1857160032,
0.1741058528,
-0.1840055287,
-0.1419472694,
-0.596986115,
0.3709248006,
0.7978631258,
0.174765721,
-0.8042393327,
-0.5337042809,
-0.1103324145,
0.0195281617,
-0.0002684055,
0.8903469443,
-1.0352787971,
0.3547726572,
0.4860553443,
0.6772297621,
-0.0487270579,
0.2471521646,
0.6898022294,
-0.6472908258,
0.1104828492,
0.0715875179,
-0.0677113757,
0.3948748708,
-0.3706472218,
0.6434445977,
0.3509782553,
-0.4122445583,
-1.1170027256,
0.0470675752,
-0.6648924947,
-0.3918828964,
1.2135027647,
-0.0003384662,
-0.0502143167,
-0.2613909841,
-0.1358462423,
0.5948099494,
-0.2335140109,
1.1051183939,
1.1038223505,
0.1013974473,
-0.3064698279,
-0.5114390254,
0.7350468636,
0.7065681219,
-0.9113073349,
0.7083770037,
0.7071439028,
-0.0941844732,
0.2907077372,
0.765288949,
-0.1142107323,
0.243082568,
-0.0566219427,
0.3293437064,
-0.0096973907,
-0.6331267953,
-0.3052588105,
0.0264386795,
-0.0508492179,
-0.1876401305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07418v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07418v1
|
Speech-based Slot Filling using Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T15:54:30 | 2023-11-13T15:54:30 |
Guangzhi Sun, Shutong Feng, Dongcheng Jiang, Chao Zhang, Milica Gašić, Philip C. Woodland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recently, advancements in large language models (LLMs) have shown an
unprecedented ability across various language tasks. This paper investigates
the potential application of LLMs to slot filling with noisy ASR
transcriptions, via both in-context learning and task-specific fine-tuning.
Dedicated prompt designs and fine-tuning approaches are proposed to improve the
robustness of LLMs for slot filling with noisy ASR transcriptions. Moreover, a
linearised knowledge injection (LKI) scheme is also proposed to integrate
dynamic external knowledge into LLMs. Experiments were performed on SLURP to
quantify the performance of LLMs, including GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, LLaMA-13B and
Vicuna-13B (v1.1 and v1.5) with different ASR error rates. The use of the
proposed fine-tuning together with the LKI scheme for LLaMA-13B achieved an
8.3% absolute SLU-F1 improvement compared to the strong Flan-T5-base baseline
system on a limited data setup.
|
[
-0.4101835787,
-0.7658830881,
0.6474446058,
0.0783497691,
-0.3478160799,
0.1571552306,
-0.5832714438,
-0.6587628126,
0.0794789493,
0.4211008251,
-0.4356613457,
-0.1619684994,
-0.4371219873,
-0.0184525084,
-0.3789501786,
0.3572221398,
0.0948396996,
0.1202377453,
-0.1468286216,
0.1688483804,
-0.7888217568,
-0.3566956222,
-0.7618997097,
-0.3426740468,
0.5901252031,
0.2218054086,
0.5685241818,
0.6091298461,
0.0283414796,
0.3579144776,
-0.5991805196,
0.3711184859,
-0.2476085424,
0.312502563,
-0.2084042579,
-0.3564433753,
-0.2489745319,
-0.2965951562,
0.8427777886,
0.7039024234,
-0.4113444984,
-0.1159740165,
0.3778404891,
0.2293896675,
-0.3620431125,
0.2507238388,
-1.0542879105,
-0.0607634336,
-0.3887754381,
-0.2421224564,
-0.1590663046,
-0.2420580536,
-0.014339895,
-0.4579182565,
-0.0058530979,
-0.1041940972,
0.7379882932,
0.6936004758,
0.0635726526,
-0.5327141881,
-0.8066717982,
0.7526556849,
-1.0037884712,
0.4152831435,
0.3510394692,
0.0825737193,
-0.3412102163,
-0.3626526594,
-0.5942794085,
-0.1152543575,
-0.0754379928,
-0.2859145999,
0.0340185501,
0.1781013459,
0.4035253227,
0.2678419352,
-0.3093155622,
0.6168020964,
-0.338186413,
0.0196594857,
0.3576534092,
0.0618400723,
0.198691532,
0.0422770418,
-0.1261098087,
0.1231443211,
-0.8612014651,
0.1814576536,
0.3035498559,
0.8025673032,
0.0592645369,
0.5213237405,
-0.0214549322,
1.2076874971,
0.3342479765,
-0.3660627306,
0.1850627065,
-0.0892007574,
-0.4265801013,
0.0928906053,
0.5817875266,
-0.1212494597,
0.1532136053,
-0.0502993502,
-0.3902805448,
-0.0560395941,
0.1036577001,
-0.5849092007,
0.3154225349,
0.1259283423,
0.1585391462,
-0.2235757113,
-0.1421591192,
-0.3293841183,
-0.58644557,
-0.5842835903,
0.5147072673,
-0.4243308008,
-0.0714505017,
0.2814935446,
0.0016975504,
0.358712703,
0.5305353403,
-0.7946859598,
0.0760729387,
0.7688210011,
0.616661191,
-0.2285290062,
-0.0420098193,
-0.738961339,
0.4041604698,
-0.094407022,
0.857717216,
-0.5572221875,
-0.1583477557,
0.2907947302,
-0.2373605371,
-0.1498242915,
-0.8442369699,
0.3942371905,
-0.493170172,
-0.0204886701,
-0.2400232404,
-0.5927560329,
0.1060396358,
-0.1919489205,
-0.4895345271,
1.1526656151,
-0.0390771367,
-0.2136007547,
0.2317955941,
-0.2585200667,
-0.6739292145,
0.1318640113,
-0.3707129359,
-0.2328858823,
0.0954170227,
0.2881574929,
0.5743626952,
-0.184863776,
0.4485582113,
-0.1495665014,
-0.6393999457,
0.5576226115,
-0.2646241784,
0.5100395679,
0.2045166939,
-0.2464912534,
0.2109411508,
-0.6123407483,
-0.0232694671,
-0.4234838188,
-0.4175763428,
-0.2059749216,
-0.2102579176,
-0.0940727368,
0.1544669122,
0.2584056854,
-0.2754292786,
0.2669730783,
-0.5459302664,
0.72867167,
0.7580291033,
-0.0513382666,
0.4381837845,
-0.4727004766,
0.4420035183,
0.0362691581,
-0.2202698141,
0.0606938265,
-0.446177572,
-0.6505146027,
-0.4817294776,
0.5812015533,
0.5457623601,
-0.776639998,
0.5945941806,
-0.0337820016,
-0.1978272349,
-0.4387224615,
0.3325012326,
0.1353222579,
0.397752285,
0.2487362772,
-0.1587929577,
-0.4765202999,
-0.4961910546,
-0.1222720593,
0.1104120836,
-0.3020149767,
0.6179588437,
-0.1385810077,
-0.1817952096,
0.6641516685,
-0.2521948218,
-0.648866415,
-0.2394948602,
-0.2515894473,
0.5193970799,
0.4788309038,
0.0905106664,
-0.2829238772,
-0.6145822406,
-0.077052623,
-0.3477094471,
-0.3881313801,
-0.1677391529,
0.2243669629,
0.1556688845,
0.8295488358,
-0.903005302,
0.2304837704,
0.3326998651,
-0.0968926772,
0.1815182567,
-0.2631663084,
-0.1851870716,
-0.8803603053,
-0.1094322354,
-0.105422914,
-0.4483220875,
-0.6893716455,
-0.0306197256,
0.0420966484,
-0.247553423,
-0.6315517426,
0.5089502931,
-0.6009435654,
-0.1114054993,
-0.2499872893,
0.4132817686,
-0.1945102513,
0.3016227484,
-0.0613939539,
1.0014096498,
0.4919650555,
-0.6159616709,
0.0765937343,
0.3512224853,
-0.61453408,
0.0482691824,
-0.5964972377,
0.1889898181,
-0.1507223994,
0.2177435607,
-0.9171818495,
-0.2181355059,
0.0714686513,
-0.2476843297,
0.6629043818,
-0.1855815351,
-0.4709667563,
-0.1114419252,
0.03559497,
0.2311228514,
0.557099402,
-0.4831300676,
0.5508181453,
0.5552930832,
-0.5857274532,
-0.6528563499,
-0.4774898291,
0.0069077704,
-0.4171877801,
-0.570972085,
0.4447081983,
0.1676220745,
-0.1125774384,
-0.2801401317,
-0.172264114,
-0.0384789892,
-0.1357013732,
0.2600778639,
0.1180527583,
-0.2265561819,
0.1298432201,
0.1489658654,
0.028291557,
-0.3286449313,
-0.2699483931,
0.7797724605,
0.0936816931,
-0.379458338,
-0.6787373424,
0.2400286794,
0.5072485805,
-0.1220003888,
0.6306287646,
0.5307438374,
-0.4587471485,
-0.2110036761,
-0.9486331344,
-0.1512506306,
-0.5289017558,
0.0283576883,
-0.3728737235,
-1.1886286736,
0.6342915297,
0.0573370196,
-0.1290563047,
0.1556629688,
0.5833522677,
-0.2441579401,
0.5156171918,
0.3594306707,
-0.3245775998,
0.8387094736,
-0.0690614283,
-0.0140635082,
-0.6808798909,
0.0736609474,
-0.601064682,
-0.3360388279,
-0.3596766591,
-0.9689739347,
0.3219219446,
0.120189786,
-0.1398059279,
0.009151496,
-0.1649684459,
0.5264798999,
0.5477894545,
0.1818016768,
0.2816862762,
0.1317140311,
-0.0741889775,
0.0906806812,
-0.7920105457,
-0.2159112394,
0.6756224036,
0.3502042294,
0.9755834341,
0.0287127998,
0.4042136669,
0.127065599,
-0.1815459877,
-0.5507122874,
0.4425890148,
-0.3395927548,
-0.2191778421,
-0.7281154394,
-0.2696157098,
-0.9633050561,
0.1159567386,
-0.2106758803,
-0.6228348613,
0.2079611719,
0.2467417121,
-0.8898898959,
0.2066105902,
-0.4562334418,
0.2440610081,
0.0134430919,
-0.250669688,
-0.2584111691,
-0.4130328298,
0.0871770456,
-0.122511372,
0.1375749856,
-0.0983582065,
0.0471590422,
0.2380421609,
-0.4312543869,
1.0438445807,
-0.4584057927,
-0.4832878113,
0.234732613,
-0.3564658165,
0.8584878445,
0.0517658666,
-0.1258755028,
0.0677767545,
-0.3117463589,
-0.0274440479,
-0.6365898848,
0.8610493541,
-0.8056194782,
-0.6543396711,
-0.1871452481,
-0.7715711594,
-0.5213472247,
-0.0616007522,
-0.020148959,
0.6868714094,
0.2678294778,
0.4282858074,
1.1397395134,
-0.5673254728,
0.2762138546,
0.5370094776,
-0.101568982,
-0.2349983603,
0.8080286384,
0.1707677543,
0.2547048628,
0.4105014205,
0.1862286776,
-0.4796361923,
-0.6595799923,
-0.6271757483,
0.3148697615,
-0.2125018239,
-0.6038059592,
-0.6208426952,
-0.4849651158,
-0.4807212353,
-0.1590621024,
-0.2606250346,
-0.4338600934,
-0.4903613031,
0.1490481794,
0.4317452908,
0.674094975,
-0.1032419279,
0.5744309425,
-0.4279536903,
0.345157057,
0.3801568151,
0.5097094774,
0.0165373106,
-0.8027744293,
-0.0991191119,
0.0369804092,
-0.0071437685,
-0.5642816424,
0.4498571754,
0.3143337071,
0.5641454458,
0.4052611589,
-0.2211056203,
1.1744869947,
-0.637449801,
0.6830077171,
-0.0658823699,
-0.8257825971,
0.4039402902,
-0.6097750664,
0.4302344322,
0.3887276649,
-0.0088914596,
-0.4318369925,
-0.8262494802,
-0.444295913,
-0.9262696505,
0.5721439123,
-0.0307118744,
-0.0827891603,
0.379165113,
0.550835073,
-0.0644102544,
0.2900968194,
-0.4018255472,
-0.0353552699,
0.2404855788,
-0.3441045582,
-0.2632185519,
-0.3251943588,
0.1023140922,
-0.3174374402,
0.822645247,
0.0391632691,
0.2446962446,
-0.0929329842,
-0.2836402953,
-0.2633877099,
0.4012067318,
0.8625420332,
0.4708224237,
-0.0648763776,
-0.1542614102,
0.394967556,
-0.2428967357,
-0.0132558905,
0.3184298873,
-0.4438300133,
-0.0510467179,
-0.0838711113,
0.8543330431,
0.4619472325,
-0.6865214705,
0.3048365712,
-0.063980341,
0.0509870127,
-0.6372635365,
0.2914486527,
0.2645013928,
0.3770163953,
0.3392875195,
-0.1309935898,
-0.1676976085,
-0.3446992338,
0.0875023007,
0.7419798374,
-0.4843932986,
0.0967309847,
0.5961703062,
0.0612927228,
-0.2839688957,
0.3474132717,
-0.0447223894,
-0.1908513904,
0.1723108441,
0.6966136098,
0.3406677842,
-0.4551298618,
-0.2962064743,
0.1941464841,
0.137445122,
-0.0371272154,
0.3266713321,
0.0184846297,
-0.8203563094,
-0.8157539964,
-0.8731202483,
-0.2813009918,
0.7599688172,
-0.5490534306,
0.324362576,
-0.3090896904,
-0.0515590161,
0.0584106296,
0.0294054523,
-0.6479668617,
-0.0806126371,
0.2803927958,
0.9501888752,
-0.660774827,
1.1106686592,
0.5676137805,
-0.0655690208,
-0.982408464,
-0.0655523166,
-0.1033174917,
-0.8480101824,
0.291408211,
-0.0965967774,
-0.0031465422,
-0.0719289258,
-0.3323687315,
-1.0703029633,
0.9663105607,
0.4330837727,
-0.7656799555,
-0.2357183844,
0.300470382,
0.4364409745,
-0.2654268444,
-0.1192532107,
0.4858556986,
0.3678605556,
0.227018699,
-1.1291664839,
-0.0353685319,
0.1634040773,
0.1626357436,
0.1195587665,
-0.5024050474,
0.5914193392,
0.0983362645,
-0.093145825,
0.3063122332,
0.8297845125,
0.4361588955,
-0.2028875202,
0.9018753767,
0.3742553592,
1.0548241138,
0.0281029157,
0.531072855,
-0.2055127174,
-0.1051270664,
1.2631312609,
-0.3100067079,
0.9465507269,
0.611887157,
-0.1307391375,
0.2576436996,
0.2819876671,
0.2108897716,
0.3780308664,
0.4480439425,
-0.3418485224,
-0.2015343904,
-0.1878999919,
-0.4601659477,
0.4358807206,
0.8932801485,
-0.0416578725,
-0.0341228135,
0.1280894727,
-0.1755366623,
-0.0901823491,
-0.4188543856,
0.9170438647,
0.2192041874,
-0.7288528681,
0.6138932109,
0.0364317857,
0.8225103617,
-0.5178684592,
0.1354497224,
-0.1498291641,
0.1535598487,
-0.0221938975,
-0.6056346297,
0.2780620456,
-0.0361284874,
-0.0859088376,
-0.5055150986,
1.0717688799,
-0.9103012681,
-0.2528248131,
-0.0830063671,
0.535038352,
-0.0065129721,
-0.1408828199,
-0.3678339422,
0.303517729,
0.1463037878,
0.2329217792,
0.5408284068,
0.4480883479,
0.1264052987,
0.6799268723,
0.6159182191,
0.395634383,
0.1948094219,
0.3773214817,
0.9389250278,
-0.5333709121,
-0.5947293639,
-0.5850304365,
0.3173666596,
-0.002463493,
0.1475006491,
0.5561138391,
0.5602553487,
0.6229639649,
-0.1545947492,
0.7325118184,
0.16108796,
0.9585235119,
-0.6930646896,
0.8108686805,
-0.4124509394,
0.3709397614,
-0.3138645887,
-0.6560649276,
-0.1263440251,
0.8105241656,
-0.0066364482,
-0.2687507272,
0.1575771868,
1.0338121653,
-0.1007607505,
-0.1469833106,
0.6455222368,
0.5003339052,
0.1607249677,
0.3912885189,
1.1584823132,
-0.1469365358,
0.3924567699,
0.031400796,
-0.2581161857,
-0.1948025525,
-0.6660835743,
-0.846763134,
-0.5974830389,
-0.1993962675,
-0.3701508343,
-0.0151477605,
0.861980617,
0.5136436224,
-0.8190636039,
-0.392796278,
0.3346102536,
0.1172471568,
-0.1725001782,
-0.1660746187,
0.1501054913,
-0.6521494389,
-0.7187132835,
0.7898148298,
0.0183499958,
0.1100054681,
-0.2495253682,
0.1488593519,
-0.0525925085,
0.0616676249,
0.6015707254,
0.2941172123,
-0.9484738708,
-0.3483044505,
-0.1347585917,
0.0555948764,
0.0974848568,
0.9554435611,
-0.8283028603,
-0.058031749,
0.3052991033,
0.7270770669,
0.5928842425,
0.1038045883,
0.6799872518,
-1.0264940262,
0.2806662619,
0.116951488,
0.4389949739,
0.3222829103,
-0.4537752271,
0.1501995027,
-0.1287349612,
-0.5086331964,
-1.0282199383,
0.0885205716,
-1.0754483938,
-0.1761776507,
1.5207328796,
0.2868876159,
0.021540992,
-0.3281780183,
-0.101436004,
0.3169320822,
-0.5954479575,
0.73155725,
0.4510066807,
-0.063880749,
-0.0492963381,
-0.6461314559,
0.8264917731,
0.3415476382,
-0.6212623715,
0.1028293744,
0.4480268657,
0.3137134612,
-0.076341249,
0.7396616936,
0.0102787884,
-0.0517177619,
-0.4462310374,
-0.2105959803,
-0.0856208801,
-0.1579781026,
-0.6086561084,
0.2174906284,
0.20566535,
0.2678215504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07397v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07397v2
|
AMBER: An LLM-free Multi-dimensional Benchmark for MLLMs Hallucination Evaluation
| 2023-11-13T15:25:42 | 2024-02-23T07:54:11 |
Junyang Wang, Yuhang Wang, Guohai Xu, Jing Zhang, Yukai Gu, Haitao Jia, Jiaqi Wang, Haiyang Xu, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Jitao Sang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Despite making significant progress in multi-modal tasks, current Multi-modal
Large Language Models (MLLMs) encounter the significant challenge of
hallucinations, which may lead to harmful consequences. Therefore, evaluating
MLLMs' hallucinations is becoming increasingly important in model improvement
and practical application deployment. Previous works are limited in high
evaluation costs (e.g., relying on humans or advanced LLMs) and insufficient
evaluation dimensions (e.g., types of tasks and hallucinations). In this paper,
we propose an LLM-free multi-dimensional benchmark AMBER, which can be used to
evaluate both generative task and discriminative task including existence,
attribute and relation hallucination. Based on AMBER, we design a low-cost and
efficient evaluation pipeline. Additionally, we conduct a comprehensive
evaluation and detailed analysis of mainstream MLLMs including GPT-4V(ision),
and also give guideline suggestions for mitigating hallucinations. The data and
code of AMBER are available at https://github.com/junyangwang0410/AMBER.
|
[
-0.2914410532,
-0.7394751906,
0.5204432607,
0.8366066217,
-0.4381040931,
-0.3336942196,
-0.3112724721,
-0.6604334116,
0.1329206377,
0.6249883175,
-0.6224895716,
-0.8382363319,
-0.4000475705,
0.4626043439,
-0.4391911328,
0.6470677257,
0.0252291933,
0.1660898626,
-0.2932039201,
-0.2856818438,
-0.7156075239,
-0.5853276849,
-0.4485186934,
0.1556504965,
0.4381856918,
-0.1537350416,
0.2057674527,
0.3594406545,
0.6643999219,
0.297963202,
-0.1092707366,
0.4886799157,
-0.5226867199,
0.4526821077,
0.1904916763,
-0.1077365205,
-0.6485343575,
-0.032229308,
0.5905989408,
0.3911964297,
-0.305544585,
0.2527701259,
0.1383189261,
0.3890786171,
-0.7069019675,
0.1392054111,
-0.8279169202,
0.351708889,
-0.0575535595,
-0.0587758981,
-0.3532856107,
-0.3452857733,
0.0440167487,
-0.4648968279,
0.1488746107,
0.3293132782,
0.3291819692,
0.6705376506,
-0.4721154273,
-0.1820271313,
-0.6534498334,
1.0009676218,
-0.4664108455,
0.901789844,
0.3233700991,
0.2433977723,
0.0915732905,
-0.4806723595,
-0.4802597165,
-0.747725904,
-0.0859289914,
-0.0843815282,
-0.2891022563,
0.0507794842,
0.259129107,
0.4116908014,
-0.8472610712,
-0.0668817461,
-0.4355607331,
-0.4312059879,
0.4901398122,
0.2952201366,
0.0441144407,
-0.2033397406,
-0.6385888457,
0.0729515627,
-0.6357210279,
-0.5568475127,
0.1413054168,
0.3815596104,
-0.1429123431,
0.5225459933,
0.0539311729,
0.4622468352,
-0.2509674132,
-0.1129010096,
0.5588230491,
-0.4960149825,
-0.2933788002,
0.1414090246,
0.6712496281,
0.3641453981,
-0.1534530222,
-0.4719890356,
-0.2142769992,
0.1876746267,
0.4666549265,
-0.9426819682,
-0.0999818072,
0.395513624,
-0.836823225,
-0.0713374913,
-0.4678728282,
-1.014714241,
-0.6873773336,
-0.2467895895,
0.6733516455,
-0.3587411344,
-0.3682530522,
-0.0953017026,
0.1165130511,
0.1632464677,
0.198379904,
-0.8330321908,
0.2577180564,
0.5039016604,
1.0093568563,
-0.6725306511,
-0.2883803844,
-0.7031387091,
-0.1066062227,
-0.2835383415,
0.7356416583,
-0.4034780562,
-0.5815940499,
-0.4036666155,
-0.1750110537,
-0.047830157,
-0.9313639998,
0.6615151167,
-0.0294245277,
-0.0810219571,
-0.2072848529,
-0.1898629367,
-0.1910598874,
0.3273280263,
-0.8510277867,
0.9912378788,
0.0679329485,
-0.3547046781,
0.3090648651,
-0.4847827554,
-0.1040240824,
0.0680816621,
-0.2295389771,
-0.5042802095,
0.1355877966,
0.2131683826,
0.3547065258,
-0.4774367809,
0.2918156683,
-0.3798781931,
-0.6238899827,
-0.0127766067,
-0.7707890868,
0.7073826194,
0.1553145349,
-0.5982581973,
0.5765119195,
-1.0910656452,
-0.0308332499,
-0.2364085615,
-0.2405474335,
-0.2658159733,
-0.2620279193,
0.1764750481,
0.1248578802,
0.1824031323,
-0.4439287782,
-0.0030993896,
-0.239609763,
-0.1349017471,
1.0163946152,
-0.0814345032,
-0.1485574543,
-0.0585805997,
0.3410723805,
-0.0309796333,
0.2279726416,
0.1601875126,
-0.4210272431,
-0.8370814919,
-0.5420260429,
-0.0652808845,
0.5349450111,
-0.4995471835,
0.360647589,
0.0544577129,
-0.4905402362,
-0.632815659,
0.253847152,
0.7411883473,
0.2213809937,
0.6378660798,
-0.2552874982,
-0.7378482223,
-1.0367603302,
0.0551969931,
0.0398962013,
-0.2192133665,
0.3951618969,
0.5586850643,
-0.4564795792,
0.3628257811,
-0.1378748268,
-0.6130470037,
0.029168753,
0.202837646,
-0.033890415,
0.3619790077,
0.3755906224,
-0.7399817705,
-0.1388031095,
-0.2091435045,
-1.0664864779,
-0.1474332064,
-0.1913674921,
-0.0923151448,
0.3529265225,
0.2866851985,
-0.6167895794,
0.4567436874,
0.7200598717,
-0.478571564,
0.9460541606,
-0.3111508191,
0.2488844544,
-0.690069139,
0.2722531855,
-0.0282496046,
0.2847697139,
-0.6046324372,
0.0161285922,
-0.0011180681,
-0.0131431017,
-0.4948772192,
0.5160002112,
-0.3230817616,
-0.1488091797,
0.0660745427,
0.1073935032,
-0.3233145475,
0.7763108611,
0.1061235145,
0.9234480262,
0.4744316936,
-0.5230844617,
0.5446504354,
0.2538445592,
-0.4816692173,
0.764103353,
-0.4822339714,
0.2865948081,
0.0118387323,
-0.2520000041,
-0.575745225,
0.2530932426,
0.2843035758,
0.0843143985,
-0.0479005501,
0.3717378676,
-0.3806338608,
-0.1857340336,
-0.5569773912,
0.4903657436,
0.1591067761,
-0.5795016885,
0.7577933669,
0.1482564956,
0.2036728114,
-0.5506329536,
-0.449246645,
0.3010442555,
-0.5232180953,
-0.4674383104,
0.5101648569,
-0.5876225233,
-0.493617475,
-0.0307360515,
-0.3392212987,
0.1055391207,
-0.0360593274,
0.3412198126,
0.3674839437,
-0.3230345249,
0.0026625206,
-0.2522682846,
-0.3056550324,
0.0487468503,
0.0778874159,
0.5585762858,
-0.408917129,
-0.6602025032,
-0.3082761467,
0.4429388046,
0.5893805623,
-0.1099763364,
0.5048615336,
0.7792069912,
-0.5783359408,
-0.3802283406,
-0.7218809724,
-0.2601443827,
-0.430541873,
0.5988296866,
-0.3354752064,
-0.750889957,
0.3514658213,
0.2416750044,
-0.1462658346,
0.1658198833,
0.7291621566,
0.4448747635,
0.9801412225,
0.490567416,
0.0574252158,
-0.1105647385,
0.0357002057,
0.4040963948,
-1.0206899643,
-0.4515735507,
-0.1822289824,
-0.0947011709,
-0.4049427211,
-0.5305060148,
0.6476740837,
-0.0273861364,
-0.2384083271,
0.2539047897,
-0.7501337528,
0.2648549378,
0.6786436439,
0.1151699945,
0.396004945,
-0.1743101329,
-0.0747358575,
-0.1403381526,
-0.0128366714,
-0.484814167,
1.1211637259,
0.0507195964,
0.5679781437,
0.1644855887,
0.4067342281,
0.4897948205,
0.1689039171,
-0.440511167,
0.7534105182,
-0.1426563561,
-0.4686082602,
-0.3584595025,
-0.4409754276,
-0.7344818115,
0.7470628023,
-0.3358331621,
-1.1466882229,
0.2018318176,
0.1014864966,
-0.5143930912,
0.3203855455,
-0.3607919514,
0.9015718699,
-0.6499750018,
-0.3307484686,
-0.4011275172,
-0.2829083204,
0.5880472064,
-0.290899694,
-0.1024252772,
-0.2690695524,
0.2119818777,
0.7490833402,
-0.1061371937,
0.6800216436,
-0.1700217575,
-0.1570327282,
0.0405978039,
0.2019125819,
0.3479813933,
-0.0549790375,
-0.1609774679,
0.4689643383,
0.0236391816,
0.1806285083,
-0.513928175,
0.7784352899,
-0.4295031726,
-0.5918614864,
-0.3978559971,
-0.6465139389,
-0.308273077,
0.0839451328,
-0.0533185676,
0.2046617866,
-0.2236182094,
0.2937074304,
0.7315914035,
-0.3761971295,
0.2228569239,
0.2490847707,
-0.4196026921,
-0.5106915236,
1.2086424828,
-0.1449567676,
-0.1148692071,
0.0458899774,
0.0398212597,
-0.336040318,
-0.7758261561,
-0.3800704479,
0.1069526225,
-0.6793183088,
-0.1986385137,
-0.6273104548,
-0.212449491,
-0.2656255066,
0.1553079188,
-0.2553312778,
-0.0887796804,
-0.2641831934,
-0.1064388454,
0.3306963742,
0.6211303473,
-0.2892775238,
-0.1916745603,
-0.5416341424,
0.6941827536,
0.5520551801,
0.543444097,
0.325814873,
-0.0151661998,
-0.0660191998,
-0.1270129681,
-0.3888093531,
-0.5653749108,
0.4882774651,
0.0020131725,
0.7614747286,
0.5292404294,
-0.0334013328,
0.8728366494,
-0.3449801207,
0.8367193937,
0.1129888743,
-1.0273962021,
0.2764469087,
0.0692360029,
-0.2275924683,
0.4319676161,
0.0816162825,
-0.5674202442,
-0.2834221125,
0.0256477576,
-0.9554879069,
0.4993353486,
0.4912129939,
-0.1299449354,
0.0139484163,
-0.0272614025,
0.3945248723,
0.4890881479,
-1.0430591106,
-0.3311940432,
-0.1239183024,
-0.0033464408,
0.2008494586,
-0.4798826277,
-0.0427257493,
-0.2639522254,
0.5498315692,
0.2726204693,
0.5258345008,
-0.0891600475,
-0.1345656812,
0.0375504419,
0.0735325292,
0.7822715044,
0.4916122258,
-0.5246858001,
0.318456471,
0.6804418564,
-0.5062093139,
0.0273000076,
0.0480949841,
0.0843145028,
-0.1211394966,
0.4846407175,
1.0023233891,
0.2603507638,
-0.9511129856,
0.4424920976,
-0.1124387756,
-0.141133368,
-0.3045105338,
0.0431195498,
-0.1088777259,
0.5522431135,
0.3681435883,
-0.0018335604,
0.2331986427,
-0.285259068,
0.2461010665,
0.5875037313,
-0.4270402789,
-0.3218332529,
0.9088017941,
0.0296283774,
-0.4414376318,
0.7738032341,
-0.3247019649,
-0.2695632875,
0.3807156384,
0.7974139452,
1.1533324718,
-0.3363033831,
0.0408404097,
0.2407413125,
0.3905251324,
0.1641241014,
0.4626773596,
-0.2342658639,
-0.5102638006,
-0.1800924093,
-1.0647139549,
-0.3247113824,
0.4696605206,
-0.458935231,
0.2994339466,
-0.1568925828,
0.1796181053,
-0.3242827356,
-0.2485687137,
-0.5447465777,
0.0117427548,
0.3438215852,
0.6353914738,
-0.5657579899,
0.5794476271,
-0.200633958,
-0.2929742932,
-0.1904835254,
-0.067379646,
0.2914057672,
-0.7967810631,
0.784698844,
0.5322899818,
-0.4964724779,
-0.2839743197,
-0.1388511807,
-0.9103542566,
1.1293324232,
0.438016504,
-0.4628746808,
-0.1579245478,
0.1341184229,
0.5451101661,
-0.2992986739,
0.1023412868,
0.5995623469,
0.7510778904,
-0.0840134174,
-0.9844703078,
0.2622638941,
-0.414069742,
0.1571240872,
-0.0539349727,
-0.4138252437,
0.9488087296,
-0.1698278189,
-0.3089189529,
0.4007463753,
0.5170374513,
0.5842942595,
0.3059664071,
0.6333209276,
0.6361718774,
0.8362576962,
0.0327734686,
0.6803938746,
-0.3180583715,
0.1372620463,
0.9058416486,
-0.5306822062,
0.7311242223,
0.5242673755,
-0.161501348,
0.2232725471,
0.4227671921,
-0.4042992592,
0.7607616782,
0.5601013899,
-0.5701950192,
-0.1901126951,
0.0027511383,
-0.4108495414,
0.5546918511,
0.3120019138,
-0.075050205,
-0.2662124634,
0.4099444151,
-0.3456306159,
-0.3192369938,
-0.154651925,
0.6987307668,
-0.024549529,
-0.3251220286,
0.7187773585,
-0.2652595639,
0.8831486702,
-0.5532660484,
-0.4331683218,
-0.0542250089,
0.1869956702,
-0.1003201604,
-0.2241757959,
0.4713489413,
0.0246144291,
0.0246066824,
-0.0566195697,
0.3153378367,
-0.4201356173,
-0.6092543602,
0.635076344,
0.3965736628,
0.5183535814,
-0.303519547,
-0.5412724018,
0.4868098199,
-0.0294866413,
-0.2329389751,
0.1790800542,
0.1460963339,
-0.2105521411,
0.714253068,
0.6640853286,
0.3523572683,
-0.063409932,
0.10879042,
0.6254009604,
-0.7169162631,
0.008793043,
-1.053789854,
0.394644469,
-0.0495991856,
-0.4919186234,
0.8634328842,
0.7547044158,
0.6221411824,
-0.0409057438,
0.5439809561,
0.1120425388,
0.3039213717,
-0.613574028,
0.8087873459,
-0.6056768298,
0.4024757743,
-0.3899191022,
-1.2016999722,
-0.6296691895,
0.7958142757,
0.0574986376,
0.132442221,
0.8762304187,
1.0401352644,
0.0054765679,
0.0327877291,
0.5835220218,
0.3019331396,
0.1707176268,
0.4510197043,
0.805480659,
-0.0510510057,
0.6722114682,
-0.3829488754,
-0.0923973322,
-0.1604613364,
-1.0128815174,
-0.8770228624,
-0.8972095847,
-0.0895192325,
-0.2541483343,
0.0670516267,
1.1281996965,
0.5754026175,
-0.9734278917,
-0.2958888113,
0.1708077937,
0.1134735495,
-0.4884532988,
-0.128335163,
0.7411812544,
-0.1196206659,
-0.693561554,
0.6367294788,
0.6334652901,
0.0616298243,
-0.671497345,
-0.1827665716,
0.2175462544,
-0.1632971615,
0.9135152102,
-0.2784549892,
-1.113368988,
-0.4542266726,
0.1561317146,
0.2263111174,
0.1109034121,
0.6688086987,
-0.8253042102,
0.5311008096,
-0.0734490976,
0.3771932721,
0.4469069541,
-0.2224064469,
0.2253955007,
-0.6290022731,
0.1141855195,
0.3444918692,
0.4121626318,
0.243097499,
-0.4263954759,
0.5458971858,
0.0967578813,
-0.4752728343,
-1.2921328545,
-0.0151659437,
-0.9302205443,
-0.1927852929,
1.0313131809,
0.2205670029,
-0.0463998504,
-0.190188095,
-0.3279145062,
-0.0079495879,
-0.2033303231,
1.2941854,
0.5988141298,
-0.3893558681,
-0.0747281536,
-0.431001097,
0.5771493912,
0.1186819375,
-0.8117298484,
0.4460113943,
0.5852326155,
-0.2018121183,
0.2530548871,
0.5754176378,
-0.0050704866,
0.1529566348,
0.1872365177,
0.328594923,
-0.1980300844,
-0.5679661036,
-0.2948801517,
0.2211200744,
-0.3147112727,
-0.1095898449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07387v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07387v2
|
Assessing Logical Puzzle Solving in Large Language Models: Insights from a Minesweeper Case Study
| 2023-11-13T15:11:26 | 2024-04-16T22:51:51 |
Yinghao Li, Haorui Wang, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable proficiency in language
understanding and have been successfully applied to a variety of real-world
tasks through task-specific fine-tuning or prompt engineering. Despite these
advancements, it remains an open question whether LLMs are fundamentally
capable of reasoning and planning, or if they primarily rely on recalling and
synthesizing information from their training data. In our research, we
introduce a novel task -- Minesweeper -- specifically designed in a format
unfamiliar to LLMs and absent from their training datasets. This task
challenges LLMs to identify the locations of mines based on numerical clues
provided by adjacent opened cells. Successfully completing this task requires
an understanding of each cell's state, discerning spatial relationships between
the clues and mines, and strategizing actions based on logical deductions drawn
from the arrangement of the cells. Our experiments, including trials with the
advanced GPT-4 model, indicate that while LLMs possess the foundational
abilities required for this task, they struggle to integrate these into a
coherent, multi-step logical reasoning process needed to solve Minesweeper.
These findings highlight the need for further research to understand the nature
of reasoning capabilities in LLMs under similar circumstances, and to explore
pathways towards more sophisticated AI reasoning and planning models.
|
[
-0.0330307148,
-0.9756436348,
1.0690842867,
0.0717046559,
0.1141844243,
-0.0143161546,
-0.187621966,
-0.2012436241,
-0.1803327948,
0.3653672934,
-0.8757574558,
-0.329785645,
-0.7159720063,
0.1990854591,
-0.4623430967,
0.5890731812,
-0.2083305866,
-0.2078693658,
-0.3969501853,
0.2077587247,
-0.8154368997,
-0.4435252249,
-0.377043277,
-0.5318270326,
0.21776627,
0.3925657868,
0.7112907767,
0.7931616306,
0.4689376652,
0.4854836762,
-0.3795933127,
0.1717820317,
-0.4575387537,
0.0644231066,
-0.5355744958,
-0.8398194313,
-0.1379752159,
0.0725090355,
0.2944343388,
0.679961741,
-0.1942214072,
0.1244498938,
-0.2669277191,
0.5037485957,
-0.3333023489,
0.475088954,
-1.1043239832,
0.3913605213,
-0.1157445535,
-0.1720252186,
-0.3061261773,
-0.1969937831,
-0.041487921,
-0.5007765889,
0.1163013503,
-0.1135632098,
0.5254488587,
0.3943812549,
-0.3414726257,
-0.4664572179,
-0.6943134665,
0.6463055015,
-0.5778312087,
0.004728043,
0.2409170568,
0.2265298963,
-0.4018751383,
-0.3868991137,
-0.4766943455,
0.0280873477,
0.0995535925,
0.1068615764,
-0.217629239,
-0.1865427643,
0.8173034787,
-0.0074560107,
-0.4617392123,
0.0941009894,
-0.4011299312,
-0.3147344589,
0.5074118376,
0.4609257579,
0.244346723,
-0.2702768743,
-0.1697348803,
0.201401487,
-0.5242483616,
0.1376629174,
0.1147519425,
0.1974785924,
0.0908853337,
0.8952425122,
-0.2745268941,
0.5331996083,
-0.2552755177,
0.0381993353,
0.1305271089,
-0.0909669921,
-0.278764993,
0.1116832569,
0.6375076771,
0.1317707002,
0.6487314105,
-0.1633590758,
-0.4443629384,
0.2032139152,
0.1592702121,
-0.7655287981,
-0.2665195167,
0.4291303158,
-0.3066666722,
-0.311745137,
-0.3762215972,
-0.2495167702,
-0.5802966952,
-0.348852694,
0.6930835843,
-0.5077328682,
-0.3638179302,
0.3248684406,
-0.2186466753,
0.0767218247,
0.3541911244,
-0.7581084371,
0.025233373,
0.903036654,
0.7783019543,
0.2882215977,
-0.602237165,
-0.6979000568,
-0.0137277022,
-0.4914402068,
0.8247822523,
-0.659740746,
-0.3640165627,
-0.1283545941,
-0.0937667862,
-0.3071968555,
-0.7248765826,
0.5369212627,
-0.3571720123,
0.0831175596,
-0.4484145343,
-0.4141067266,
-0.2242121398,
0.5804736614,
-0.4216618538,
0.7591576576,
0.0123878932,
-0.8343536258,
0.1875726581,
-0.5189648271,
-0.3028102815,
0.0343248174,
-0.57089746,
-0.0947485194,
0.3221075237,
0.2630297244,
0.4650821388,
-0.2292305678,
0.4086865187,
-0.2447064966,
-0.3708581328,
0.4780068696,
-0.1241528764,
0.7555519342,
0.1450300813,
-0.3568715453,
0.1599412411,
-0.517190218,
0.1148592755,
0.44787094,
-0.0469150394,
-0.049004361,
0.5111958385,
-0.5110804439,
0.6598411798,
0.195397675,
-0.3177854121,
0.2865456045,
-0.2315416783,
0.7286459208,
0.6914492846,
-0.2333098203,
0.1743703634,
-0.3292378783,
0.4048179388,
0.2595410943,
-0.053373266,
-0.2759042084,
-0.4919656813,
-0.5736305118,
-0.1302601546,
0.24322097,
0.836933732,
-0.6561465263,
0.257299453,
-0.3160788119,
-0.4018270075,
-0.326662451,
0.0988044441,
0.084353067,
0.5001091361,
0.3432940245,
-0.1360778958,
-0.5345726609,
-0.8474731445,
-0.4034336507,
-0.0384827107,
-0.0232459456,
0.117327407,
0.832865119,
-0.3203002512,
1.0933459997,
-0.3810598552,
-0.1165459827,
-0.2859833837,
0.2228753567,
0.6091138124,
0.2297479212,
0.0781231374,
-0.6220440269,
0.0008935003,
-0.0455838591,
-1.0353392363,
-0.1193585545,
-0.3075291514,
0.0842426494,
-0.1209080815,
0.6893132329,
-1.1636673212,
0.3715013564,
0.3089050949,
-0.3092912138,
0.5532627106,
-0.2438383847,
-0.0882006064,
-0.6820933223,
0.0207168385,
-0.2644220591,
0.0139810266,
-0.6878796816,
0.00858879,
0.0685760081,
-0.1525187045,
-0.1505215466,
0.1335811168,
-0.4983048737,
-0.1689454764,
-0.3404129148,
0.2936242819,
-0.4096886814,
0.3127302527,
0.1551399678,
0.5399127007,
0.6709264517,
-0.1653422415,
0.2205273658,
0.3404719532,
-0.4728761613,
0.3352224529,
-0.6331802011,
0.194420293,
-0.2315966487,
0.1655729711,
-0.7171307206,
-0.116144903,
-0.0477047637,
-0.4221126139,
-0.0272570085,
-0.4734235406,
-0.7176070213,
-0.4046403766,
0.0519562587,
0.1562502384,
0.5200961828,
-0.2306069136,
0.8837731481,
0.2863728702,
-0.390578419,
-0.514626503,
-0.6201035976,
0.2497281581,
-0.3757787049,
-0.7810320258,
0.086729534,
-0.0812963098,
-0.4797369242,
-0.0189379025,
-0.4688035846,
-0.0281927567,
0.3820115626,
0.2390137464,
0.1273565441,
-0.1593139619,
-0.0163858999,
-0.2783021331,
-0.2605580688,
0.762504518,
-0.0387145057,
0.5207522511,
-0.196548596,
-0.4105632901,
-0.061302375,
0.2969714105,
0.5928013325,
-0.5605373383,
0.6764636636,
0.4058117867,
-0.6047431827,
-0.3700733185,
-0.4216988981,
0.0250417236,
-0.4997169673,
0.5305945277,
-0.7718228102,
-0.6708184481,
0.7264409065,
-0.2809581161,
-0.0218232423,
0.410007894,
0.6864814758,
-0.0801053494,
1.265848875,
0.4888862669,
0.0077509312,
-0.0258276649,
-0.2281092256,
0.3571290374,
-0.5760903955,
-0.4843135774,
-0.4302344918,
-0.3078147471,
-0.4952482581,
-0.5443977714,
0.1487770975,
0.1555303931,
-0.440700829,
0.183504045,
-0.1742107868,
0.8485836387,
0.3984384835,
0.0305209383,
0.3651250005,
-0.2349681407,
-0.247919485,
0.1285518557,
-0.8173074126,
-0.5182496309,
0.6986016035,
0.3415333629,
0.5900179744,
0.1268401742,
0.7255740762,
-0.2557644248,
-0.0202232264,
-0.8714632392,
0.7362713218,
0.1269949079,
-0.6446688771,
-0.0600380935,
-0.7016021609,
-0.8520822525,
0.4225278199,
-0.3862947822,
-0.9189282656,
-0.2502716184,
-0.0646029785,
-0.2319731265,
0.3241148591,
-0.7941840291,
0.8566812277,
-0.3797632456,
-0.231571734,
-0.2875619829,
-0.6386801004,
0.5246738195,
-0.2032912672,
0.5646862984,
-0.2725327909,
0.1711076647,
0.4977043271,
-0.1197174042,
0.644631207,
-0.0968204364,
-0.1650511622,
0.2215611637,
0.552043438,
0.6818104982,
-0.044445172,
-0.0760768354,
-0.0696110576,
0.050486248,
-0.2665113807,
-0.5580207705,
0.7294859886,
-0.7019808888,
-0.9050640464,
-0.5237298012,
-1.0714398623,
-0.3116394281,
0.3510403931,
-0.1392591745,
0.3695893884,
0.1516962796,
0.1182600558,
0.8020163178,
-0.1474570334,
0.296982199,
0.3910521865,
-0.2206665874,
0.1042214632,
0.7668340802,
0.2220648825,
0.0919423774,
0.278177768,
0.3257609308,
-0.0956729352,
-0.9012991786,
-0.2468990684,
0.2142269611,
-0.9106528759,
-0.0696747079,
-0.5926169157,
-0.4776133895,
0.1314301938,
-0.0112988101,
-0.1502642035,
-0.3476222157,
-0.0560591221,
-0.1560544074,
0.0807420984,
0.8923810124,
-0.0168641768,
-0.1502370834,
-0.8537952304,
0.3191035688,
0.3380816579,
0.1709620804,
-0.1865013838,
-0.4275729954,
-0.1607684791,
0.0642237812,
-0.1767652184,
-0.9597964883,
0.2814562321,
-0.3265550137,
0.736297071,
-0.0269120894,
-0.2327310145,
0.7364804745,
-0.8359189034,
0.4829096794,
-0.1113797203,
-0.9509396553,
0.6516014338,
-0.5837685466,
0.3767575324,
0.313141942,
0.3601057827,
-0.2470873296,
-0.1212314069,
-0.7901554108,
-0.6884040236,
0.6867983341,
0.4220677018,
-0.1138503775,
0.0232094042,
0.2941081524,
-0.275783509,
0.1080595329,
-0.701418519,
0.1122628823,
-0.039528437,
-0.2675076127,
-0.1016474143,
-0.0820725635,
-0.4302763343,
-0.0003607422,
0.266512841,
0.0065005687,
0.2455241829,
-0.0166062657,
-0.3892133236,
-0.0429264829,
0.4656588733,
0.429474175,
0.7616024017,
-0.3038606644,
0.2543938756,
0.3626953363,
-0.2527078688,
-0.0321910642,
0.3052722514,
0.0568493158,
-0.3545667529,
0.4715758562,
0.3672719896,
-0.1217057332,
-0.8941397667,
0.4890031517,
0.0719151273,
-0.464312911,
-0.1305173486,
0.2801139951,
0.3753111064,
0.6573172212,
0.2449939698,
0.2762543559,
0.0883736238,
-0.7751232386,
-0.1140059903,
0.4562904537,
-0.3029399216,
-0.2375324816,
0.4479856491,
0.0878532529,
-0.4290844798,
0.9584683776,
-0.1982466429,
-0.7988696694,
0.8543868661,
0.7242027521,
0.6494097114,
0.1109135076,
-0.020100208,
0.1880779266,
0.8973298669,
-0.2142905444,
0.4207805693,
0.1835295409,
-0.8993572593,
-0.7356959581,
-0.1270806789,
-0.4137232602,
0.179032281,
-0.3324529529,
0.130418703,
-0.2788368165,
0.1448432356,
-0.2219733298,
0.0512359664,
-0.7916300893,
0.2542887032,
0.4014984369,
1.2636369467,
-0.9630100727,
0.6503923535,
0.5594869256,
-0.1073685884,
-0.7993398905,
-0.1854736656,
0.3052604795,
-0.8034691215,
0.605553329,
0.499253571,
-0.1495362669,
-0.0879531205,
-0.4446450174,
-0.7606164217,
1.2179018259,
0.3805999756,
-0.5650030375,
-0.0853523836,
0.2026460022,
0.3237570226,
-0.1474349499,
0.5623066425,
0.76032722,
0.3271637261,
0.0008228105,
-0.9059619904,
0.1324127316,
-0.325522542,
-0.1415724158,
0.3996320367,
-0.4057799578,
0.7980300784,
-0.5192186832,
-0.1594812572,
0.0415072851,
0.4657069743,
0.6347194314,
0.2460741401,
0.5820717812,
0.6959286332,
0.8412272334,
-0.2707463801,
0.8432577252,
0.1206637621,
0.2496761978,
1.060121417,
-0.4735530913,
0.913082242,
0.3681101203,
-0.0377443023,
0.5304726362,
0.4481406808,
0.1475052536,
0.357470572,
0.5559274554,
-0.0473178178,
-0.509468317,
0.1633327156,
-0.2193618566,
0.5575167537,
0.6687045097,
-0.0123274764,
-0.3285467029,
-0.3848100901,
-0.0432186201,
0.0409393609,
-0.4182732701,
0.4281765521,
-0.0095433854,
-0.5594167709,
0.1419578791,
-0.0105361436,
0.3246378601,
-0.6802960038,
-0.0284976959,
-0.13970083,
0.2067274451,
-0.2996253967,
-1.1144063473,
0.3906301856,
0.2282325029,
-0.1144960895,
-0.252404958,
0.5535635352,
-0.3094194233,
-0.3873695433,
-0.0576021336,
0.7090674639,
0.0407998301,
-0.1777082235,
-0.8722311854,
0.1512382478,
-0.0417022966,
-0.1442833096,
0.2241826504,
1.0512257814,
-0.0951533988,
0.9676880836,
0.6345364451,
-0.0490469784,
-0.0658021048,
-0.0217279214,
0.8373863697,
-1.063754797,
-0.2973421216,
-0.9112576246,
0.6492738128,
-0.0283057857,
-0.1554158479,
0.6867703795,
0.606299758,
0.8299737573,
0.0468552075,
0.7815023661,
-0.1283506453,
0.3755320609,
-0.8303121924,
0.3476143777,
-0.133668974,
0.4050792456,
-0.0971650854,
-0.7967603207,
-0.2234049886,
0.8655288815,
-0.6718261242,
0.0480601043,
0.8417758942,
0.8248935342,
-0.2405099571,
0.1520942897,
0.1468377858,
0.5743704438,
0.4004236758,
0.980227232,
1.4194873571,
-0.2874896526,
0.7186552882,
-0.1594898254,
-0.1758448631,
0.1720433384,
-1.0838261843,
-1.1282998323,
-0.3253136575,
-0.157215938,
-0.0879217088,
-0.1913405806,
0.9599346519,
0.2917020321,
-0.5443321466,
-0.2610768974,
-0.1922893822,
0.1371353865,
-0.0846436173,
-0.1722480506,
0.0933423564,
-0.3608060777,
-0.3330520988,
0.6441082358,
0.2710302472,
-0.2217987776,
0.1153764576,
0.1487061828,
-0.0743803754,
0.1154316515,
0.6964921951,
0.0073223282,
-0.7264211774,
-0.1882384419,
0.0989526436,
0.0785431862,
-0.0829853117,
0.7775506377,
-0.8685774803,
0.364446938,
0.5548013449,
0.6859160066,
0.5635094643,
-0.1861473471,
0.4054768085,
-0.3582862914,
-0.1175365523,
0.2126102448,
0.6505479813,
0.2723417878,
-0.0316186883,
0.5469712019,
0.0577703193,
-0.6677714586,
-0.6796483397,
0.271469444,
-0.8655214906,
-0.3571656644,
0.9869206548,
0.1070752069,
-0.0190312061,
-0.0105736842,
-0.3159960508,
-0.091772154,
0.0769616812,
0.8364536762,
0.7590588331,
-0.0998786166,
-0.1877203584,
-0.8359724283,
0.1654390246,
0.3702850044,
-0.8278958201,
0.1044919193,
0.4962861836,
0.3305110931,
0.1786649972,
0.4099496901,
-0.0562639274,
0.178734526,
-0.0433102623,
-0.3343321681,
-0.169727996,
-0.4487202466,
-0.2750733197,
0.0959113166,
0.0979927182,
0.2464885265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07383v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07383v1
|
LM-Polygraph: Uncertainty Estimation for Language Models
| 2023-11-13T15:08:59 | 2023-11-13T15:08:59 |
Ekaterina Fadeeva, Roman Vashurin, Akim Tsvigun, Artem Vazhentsev, Sergey Petrakov, Kirill Fedyanin, Daniil Vasilev, Elizaveta Goncharova, Alexander Panchenko, Maxim Panov, Timothy Baldwin, Artem Shelmanov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have
paved the way for a myriad of groundbreaking applications in various fields.
However, a significant challenge arises as these models often "hallucinate",
i.e., fabricate facts without providing users an apparent means to discern the
veracity of their statements. Uncertainty estimation (UE) methods are one path
to safer, more responsible, and more effective use of LLMs. However, to date,
research on UE methods for LLMs has been focused primarily on theoretical
rather than engineering contributions. In this work, we tackle this issue by
introducing LM-Polygraph, a framework with implementations of a battery of
state-of-the-art UE methods for LLMs in text generation tasks, with unified
program interfaces in Python. Additionally, it introduces an extendable
benchmark for consistent evaluation of UE techniques by researchers, and a demo
web application that enriches the standard chat dialog with confidence scores,
empowering end-users to discern unreliable responses. LM-Polygraph is
compatible with the most recent LLMs, including BLOOMz, LLaMA-2, ChatGPT, and
GPT-4, and is designed to support future releases of similarly-styled LMs.
|
[
-0.170637086,
-0.9393419623,
1.0405857563,
0.1401116848,
-0.0944025367,
0.1540392339,
-0.148515597,
-0.5578041673,
0.1904405355,
0.3612986207,
-0.4380921423,
-0.6108375192,
-0.6659706831,
-0.0869995803,
-0.4155270755,
0.5237630606,
0.143673256,
-0.0661899522,
-0.2680869699,
0.4162496924,
-0.1399218887,
-0.4880796075,
-0.2315641791,
-0.6276155114,
0.3558457792,
0.082957156,
0.9940475225,
0.2836550474,
0.2938558161,
0.2651522458,
-0.1710763574,
0.3489219546,
-0.2243368924,
0.345523417,
-0.0142924804,
-0.3879583478,
-0.538700223,
-0.2563817501,
0.6442287564,
0.6774349213,
-0.1613258272,
0.0782107338,
0.05036892,
0.4232421219,
-0.8086392879,
0.2945542634,
-0.8152047992,
-0.0462950543,
-0.3557177186,
0.1044021398,
-0.5772331357,
-0.3383355439,
0.153252542,
-0.2943894267,
-0.2535913885,
0.1136294231,
0.8623692393,
0.3324430585,
-0.242772907,
-0.2742162943,
-0.8409265876,
0.7874673605,
-0.7882499695,
0.3947052658,
0.5117237568,
0.3082605004,
-0.7094030976,
-0.8185890913,
-0.4637932479,
-0.175164029,
0.084587194,
0.0332482941,
-0.1793799996,
0.2616838813,
-0.07131394,
0.3000881672,
-0.4216113687,
0.2592251301,
0.0933126658,
-0.5857850313,
0.7055723667,
0.1591291875,
0.0890973657,
-0.1744456738,
-0.1434999555,
0.0877820551,
-0.49683097,
-0.1219561249,
0.3217622042,
0.1743730456,
-0.0534245148,
0.6744681001,
-0.1607746482,
0.7006896734,
-0.3640981913,
-0.3997191787,
0.2608551085,
0.0469058789,
-0.2320207357,
-0.2166086286,
1.3097627163,
0.252310425,
0.3581768572,
-0.048520688,
-0.2560961545,
0.1276870221,
-0.1267701536,
-0.5258028507,
-0.1558123678,
0.502050817,
-0.0229221825,
-0.4055825472,
0.1362177283,
-1.0369355679,
-0.732059598,
0.0003777808,
0.3729665577,
-0.4526869953,
-0.3689754307,
0.2892376184,
0.2121969908,
-0.0699712485,
0.2725955248,
-0.540918231,
0.21706146,
0.5388475657,
0.6750907898,
-0.2614249587,
-0.1587918997,
-0.0756160319,
0.0065961573,
-0.3346333206,
0.7561822534,
-0.4259578288,
-0.4148528874,
0.126950115,
-0.3951939046,
0.0051333583,
-0.1875106543,
0.5943428874,
-0.2549079359,
0.229949221,
0.2695928216,
-0.7685434222,
-0.1047324091,
0.0146152675,
-0.5071486831,
1.4054754972,
0.0908200219,
-0.9497608542,
-0.0728469491,
-0.1899951398,
-0.1220033467,
0.026929073,
-0.5208784938,
-0.7056743503,
0.2499803901,
0.2382946759,
0.5783973336,
-0.5189047456,
0.2460349947,
-0.3911532164,
-0.3904075325,
0.5896292925,
-0.7797058821,
0.8074328303,
0.2453218699,
-0.28126809,
0.0640453324,
-0.6144781113,
0.287240088,
0.2629459202,
-0.0783747137,
-0.0241656359,
0.2764791846,
-0.0570684448,
-0.2250532359,
0.5356763005,
-0.4802422523,
0.014889136,
-0.2127800286,
0.0407320373,
0.6731551886,
0.0829593241,
0.0725249201,
-0.2874390483,
0.4573857188,
-0.199166283,
0.1593838781,
0.0121735204,
-0.7838656306,
-0.6244155765,
-0.3144250214,
0.3418872654,
0.6749001145,
-0.5754781961,
0.5864632726,
-0.2446766943,
-0.6483058929,
-0.3659920096,
0.0914620087,
0.2025523186,
0.0703029111,
0.0253945105,
-0.0543742143,
-0.636936605,
-0.5461031795,
-0.2439020574,
-0.55444175,
-0.1386389285,
0.2121041566,
0.2529051006,
-0.3503734469,
1.0658533573,
-0.63762182,
-0.0426054411,
-0.3068196476,
0.273853898,
0.3288007081,
0.0975872353,
0.2826348841,
-0.5036984086,
-0.5640087128,
-0.1039735377,
-0.7642164826,
-0.2370434999,
-0.185781464,
0.1088493615,
0.348225832,
0.3335905969,
-0.6586996913,
0.4896530807,
0.9296573997,
-0.0083255805,
0.8347412348,
-0.1681701839,
-0.0982261151,
-1.0403559208,
-0.3002386987,
0.1736631244,
-0.4604329765,
-0.5898791552,
-0.1239744276,
-0.0992863849,
0.1971343607,
-0.1401557177,
0.3277357817,
-0.4362720549,
-0.1206840202,
-0.1219631359,
0.2958247364,
-0.1164117604,
0.0198880397,
0.208044365,
0.6621148586,
0.8648262024,
-0.3128573,
0.2717142105,
-0.3570381701,
-0.5807050467,
0.2936204672,
-0.5020340085,
0.3713748455,
-0.0151891084,
0.0321777426,
-0.839376986,
-0.3643488288,
0.3716769516,
-0.5703325272,
0.287343502,
0.0235338733,
-0.4256052971,
-0.4157816768,
-0.169842124,
0.0935235918,
0.6033608913,
-0.2378560156,
0.6278128624,
0.6615199447,
-0.035204187,
-0.6651670337,
-0.3413524628,
0.1076604575,
-0.1183232218,
-0.5219535232,
0.0888139755,
-0.1758633405,
-0.5524499416,
-0.1462583393,
-0.0584847666,
-0.3866103292,
0.1533667147,
0.384699434,
0.1755574346,
-0.1778218597,
0.0537597463,
-0.12478365,
-0.0374594927,
0.0899425596,
-0.152716279,
0.6733750105,
-0.2717398107,
-0.5665729642,
-0.4307586849,
-0.0635958165,
0.5249669552,
0.0964981616,
0.6222481728,
0.5903151035,
-0.4894993901,
-0.4521224201,
-0.5703462958,
0.0299285129,
-0.4731843472,
0.4474984705,
-0.3864892423,
-0.6856691241,
0.3484655321,
-0.1561640352,
-0.1298573911,
0.2265858352,
0.7001484632,
-0.2743768096,
0.8342244029,
0.6286938787,
-0.1711730659,
0.3582013547,
0.214490816,
0.1027370021,
-0.4416494966,
-0.124485068,
-0.5179633498,
0.2693063319,
-0.4819278121,
-0.5492548347,
0.4347289205,
0.1251831055,
-0.0171668585,
0.2260732502,
-0.4756517708,
0.4887858629,
0.4487023354,
0.1089880392,
0.4834039509,
0.172771588,
-0.0420468524,
-0.1560591757,
-0.4688769281,
-0.6171133518,
1.1458204985,
0.5509371758,
1.0793972015,
0.0009324477,
0.8201581836,
0.2619018853,
0.178423807,
-0.7564603686,
0.5231238008,
0.262798667,
-0.5209776163,
-0.5935255885,
-0.7366445065,
-0.7913726568,
0.2661300302,
-0.2977328002,
-1.3968034983,
-0.1923920512,
0.228002727,
-0.2296650112,
0.4144226611,
-0.436686635,
0.4143868387,
-0.2194243222,
-0.1129065529,
0.1102381349,
-0.3576708734,
0.3664734066,
-0.3047953248,
0.4077675045,
-0.4769654572,
0.0482232384,
0.3247952163,
-0.1864493489,
1.0062228441,
0.1215555072,
-0.3741005659,
0.6255630255,
0.3727289438,
0.6684345603,
0.0869577527,
-0.4055504203,
0.5035123229,
0.0067763692,
-0.0103229731,
-0.5389001369,
0.3297801316,
-0.6486724019,
-0.4999256134,
-0.6523095965,
-0.897115469,
-0.1722135097,
0.1743193269,
0.5322107673,
0.1457251757,
-0.2471553236,
-0.092910029,
0.4138530195,
-0.3003392518,
0.3175151944,
0.2142717391,
-0.5874943137,
-0.3171944022,
0.7983513474,
0.0454031229,
0.4348058701,
0.3910043538,
0.3748959005,
-0.395239532,
-0.6257069111,
-0.1408400387,
0.1945600361,
-0.5048440099,
-0.1059318632,
-0.2895307839,
-0.4653522968,
-0.4861856699,
0.1437266022,
-0.5699430108,
-0.4165858328,
-0.1943652928,
0.051478941,
0.3968335986,
0.8832404017,
-0.0890420973,
0.5697203279,
-0.3955667317,
0.0991175473,
0.1181175783,
0.376031369,
-0.4411896467,
-0.5870649219,
0.0022955551,
0.2839941382,
-0.2651953697,
-0.9922460914,
0.1962664574,
0.2071245313,
0.5896270275,
0.1679652482,
0.2717428207,
0.2957188487,
-0.2217560858,
0.6924637556,
0.2391084284,
-1.110501647,
0.3647915721,
-0.3104139864,
-0.0561425909,
0.281382829,
0.2252065092,
-0.3931630254,
-0.5865252614,
-0.4749838412,
-0.6528462768,
0.1853263229,
0.4833933711,
0.0330700278,
0.1095286608,
0.241967693,
-0.2003922611,
0.2574180961,
-1.0321719646,
-0.4261103868,
-0.0312278327,
-0.6200372577,
0.0175523739,
-0.4529092908,
0.2506625354,
-0.1129116714,
0.7987658381,
-0.1453571022,
0.2158063352,
0.1017825305,
-0.1759643108,
-0.0970503539,
0.2453119904,
0.367939353,
0.7536982894,
-0.5580666065,
0.3851981759,
0.1677264422,
-0.4362578094,
0.1179066673,
-0.0641260222,
-0.3543943465,
0.2437374592,
0.3249696195,
0.5445352197,
-0.0655186325,
-0.7044277191,
0.6084113717,
-0.0213302281,
0.0349523425,
-0.6547344923,
-0.0813610777,
0.1548193246,
0.0510264896,
0.102950491,
-0.3769305348,
-0.0366418622,
-0.2034330815,
0.3305981159,
0.4284015894,
-0.6039786339,
-0.0629835874,
0.4459130466,
0.0495659485,
-0.5019025803,
0.410569042,
-0.2333800793,
-0.2944175899,
0.3163147569,
0.6853524446,
0.818230927,
-0.431443423,
0.455542028,
0.1227919757,
0.6121445298,
-0.2403118312,
0.3504633904,
0.4208747149,
-1.0849957466,
-0.5483038425,
-0.7650296092,
-0.5823304057,
0.2289299518,
-0.4692678452,
0.1622671485,
-0.345641166,
-0.4804824591,
-0.2385717779,
-0.1502341926,
-0.2174691409,
-0.011088497,
0.2970507741,
0.6415441036,
-0.7379310727,
0.90713346,
0.3783308864,
-0.2332988083,
-0.6561903954,
0.1046307012,
0.3376964033,
-0.8160915971,
0.0782090127,
0.110877499,
-0.419557035,
0.0449326299,
-0.4463136494,
-0.7758972645,
1.0084239244,
0.6593471169,
-0.60161376,
0.0970457494,
0.5918595791,
0.339792788,
-0.2627453804,
0.3904315829,
0.651905179,
0.4573884606,
-0.0925609246,
-0.9201801419,
0.0048374096,
0.1535486132,
0.0508665107,
0.2051034421,
-0.290478915,
0.7919165492,
-0.1387418807,
-0.2745193541,
0.3148285151,
0.7911360264,
0.2953687906,
0.0641026944,
0.6470407248,
0.2335077673,
1.0058796406,
-0.1811817437,
0.9596201181,
-0.3605482578,
0.6191114187,
1.3228533268,
-0.1372932643,
0.7533408403,
0.4490077198,
-0.3856529891,
0.5627593994,
0.6124618649,
0.0195009205,
-0.103787683,
0.3249442577,
-0.4627104402,
-0.5015887022,
-0.2281511128,
-0.1257268041,
0.3245207667,
0.6708359718,
-0.3299318552,
-0.1173134372,
-0.656314373,
0.1836292446,
0.1747940183,
0.0587131456,
0.5022748113,
0.3943974376,
-0.3026443124,
0.5561113954,
-0.0842319727,
0.5597656965,
-0.6555287242,
0.0830217227,
-0.0868304595,
0.2141764611,
-0.1010959968,
-0.9085207582,
0.0513373874,
-0.1015631109,
0.1326264292,
0.2013184726,
0.7685325742,
-0.3909229636,
-0.8145840764,
0.4437268078,
0.7151314616,
0.4553484917,
-0.2683130205,
-0.7177730203,
0.3564319611,
0.1300992966,
-0.3253626525,
0.0748297274,
0.373742938,
0.0662247837,
0.9213895798,
0.3324154317,
0.3157616556,
0.115622744,
0.0702040642,
0.3099700212,
-0.2732525766,
-0.0127371065,
-0.9947640896,
0.5108624697,
-0.1562801003,
-0.2836041451,
0.7548401356,
0.3501763344,
0.5777560472,
0.186533913,
0.9045873284,
-0.1135195717,
0.3307236731,
-0.5615779161,
0.7314135432,
-0.3888713419,
0.4582734406,
-0.5707027316,
-1.0500528812,
-0.4988719523,
0.6547785401,
-0.0247823633,
-0.0733316913,
0.6435338259,
1.0873113871,
0.1300350279,
-0.1581963748,
0.5360173583,
0.2025511712,
0.2657027841,
0.4414677322,
0.8209111691,
-0.3781892657,
0.682448864,
-0.5834584236,
-0.3268864751,
-0.0692061633,
-1.0562837124,
-0.953448236,
-0.4863634408,
-0.2052722871,
-0.479434371,
-0.0051566781,
0.9060437679,
0.6734141707,
-0.6460815072,
-0.6396282911,
-0.1001703218,
0.4551959634,
-0.107183136,
-0.1863380373,
0.4490515292,
-0.2870681584,
-0.7785767317,
0.4012006819,
0.0648627207,
0.3329387605,
-0.3397615552,
-0.1016329527,
-0.0736161917,
0.3374072015,
0.2988662124,
0.2226254493,
-0.7753133178,
-0.6130355597,
-0.2621923983,
-0.2042470723,
-0.0268677026,
0.4073255658,
-0.3270702958,
0.4008474946,
0.3752887845,
0.479624629,
0.3820169866,
-0.0844996497,
0.7941032648,
-0.8476611376,
0.1843256652,
0.0325643793,
0.5488219857,
0.3531914651,
-0.3308386803,
0.5707604885,
0.3248826861,
-0.533259511,
-1.0547627211,
0.5085932612,
-0.7027570605,
-0.3241159916,
1.0866187811,
-0.1145630553,
-0.2995828986,
-0.2771757245,
-0.0844117925,
0.1954691857,
-0.2608548105,
0.7834357619,
0.6317678094,
-0.1287552714,
-0.1271689087,
-0.5246317983,
0.3621166945,
0.3032305241,
-0.992493093,
0.2185105383,
0.4580492377,
0.2447494119,
0.2604126632,
0.7246620655,
0.0149933435,
-0.0647537783,
0.2233732641,
0.4378617704,
0.0726872012,
-0.4624065459,
0.0014759633,
0.0234215856,
0.3538069725,
0.1614986658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07635v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07635v1
|
Past as a Guide: Leveraging Retrospective Learning for Python Code Completion
| 2023-11-13T14:40:33 | 2023-11-13T14:40:33 |
Seunggyoon Shin, Seunggyu Chang, Sungjoon Choi
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This work presents Past as a Guide (PaG), a simple approach for Large
Language Models (LLMs) to improve the coding capabilities by integrating the
past history with interactive and iterative code refinements. To be specific,
inspired by human cognitive processes, the proposed method enables LLMs to
utilize previous programming and debugging experiences to enhance the Python
code completion tasks. The framework facilitates LLMs to iteratively refine the
Python code based on previous execution and debugging results and optimize
learning and reasoning capabilities. The proposed methodology achieved a 92\%
pass@1 on HumanEval, demonstrating the potential to advance the field by
leveraging retrospection from past experiences and interactive and iterative
refinement processes without external correctness indicators.
|
[
-0.0769615322,
-0.6381676793,
0.6118426323,
0.0311975963,
-0.2103582323,
-0.2194897383,
-0.4487563074,
0.0251812655,
0.0225725658,
0.7668975592,
-0.7212664485,
-0.5911971331,
-0.1727176458,
0.1642168313,
-0.0395546928,
0.9288919568,
0.0666036457,
0.0146654071,
-0.2446055412,
0.0608549342,
-0.6424093843,
-0.5579807162,
-0.712284863,
-0.8227036595,
0.4220441878,
0.450658679,
0.456625849,
0.3049377203,
0.1076261178,
0.217416808,
-0.0966887549,
0.1048652008,
-0.3519400656,
0.1803743839,
-0.3468188047,
-0.6755186915,
-0.6411889791,
0.0328911282,
0.5255702138,
0.876896739,
-0.358341068,
0.0958897546,
0.0814752579,
0.6129767299,
-0.4573280811,
0.1991117299,
-0.4746891558,
0.0242988523,
0.2471063882,
-0.8005408049,
-0.5385062695,
-0.5817213655,
-0.0124794198,
-0.7399274111,
-0.1044603363,
-0.2218100131,
0.2781893015,
0.4581472874,
-0.2107178867,
-0.3096493185,
-0.3319875598,
0.8916928172,
-0.9658682346,
0.2062472552,
0.6216477752,
0.058769647,
-0.524350822,
-1.0505460501,
-0.4804174006,
-0.514348805,
0.0700545013,
-0.3075104654,
0.0506168976,
-0.092628397,
0.6146707535,
0.4777933061,
-0.4204921126,
-0.1323562413,
-0.4253695011,
-0.2432210147,
0.5056718588,
0.1331868619,
0.1091805324,
-0.0946457833,
-0.2525144219,
0.0511033684,
-0.9910936952,
0.0214239955,
0.300041467,
0.0298681054,
0.1121250167,
0.4207613766,
-0.3180502951,
0.8935415149,
-0.0572674572,
-0.3105976284,
0.3995376229,
-0.320743829,
-0.1967464834,
-0.0446732678,
0.3441651464,
0.4651465118,
0.6096611619,
-0.2185412645,
0.0050843577,
-0.3193235099,
0.7741643786,
-0.5902324915,
-0.4200231731,
0.0173033718,
-0.7408640981,
-0.0526241697,
0.0006287582,
-0.8212960362,
-0.7012133002,
-0.5984703302,
0.260648042,
-0.6125619411,
-0.4266805351,
0.1418894976,
-0.3173243403,
0.4351220429,
0.7393425703,
-0.3904063106,
-0.0949436426,
0.9524560571,
0.9013372064,
0.3740413785,
-0.5552387834,
-0.6634604335,
-0.0096552651,
-0.2928120196,
0.4599789679,
-0.7837095261,
-0.6461569667,
0.1604451835,
-0.0073947175,
0.2472561747,
-0.3424986899,
0.3686898649,
-0.461261034,
0.2922627032,
-0.0383171178,
-0.5274931788,
-0.5964775681,
0.2214743197,
-0.4011732638,
0.7969899178,
0.2092654258,
-0.5956494212,
0.6201748848,
-0.2967233062,
-0.4366203249,
0.1187913865,
-0.3732698262,
-0.3153221607,
-0.1048318446,
0.1701381803,
0.4115424156,
0.0827478766,
0.3176696897,
-0.404843539,
-0.8269847035,
-0.1263970584,
-0.0373004824,
0.9739726186,
0.3090907931,
-0.2698642612,
0.1296823621,
-0.8942312598,
0.0625872985,
-0.1920066774,
-0.7429383397,
-0.2942458689,
0.1523637027,
-0.3318715394,
0.0180449113,
0.4229019284,
0.0170941576,
1.1550147533,
-0.2856857479,
0.4206549823,
0.7990816832,
0.1891624629,
0.5935921073,
-0.5021765828,
0.6160264611,
-0.3740545511,
-0.0955829844,
-0.8118212819,
-0.5333638787,
-0.7920564413,
0.1734792143,
0.037370339,
0.4559043348,
-0.7796934247,
0.5217784643,
-0.0133291259,
-0.2211301923,
-0.0759100318,
0.4893403053,
0.025728507,
0.465256542,
0.1434642971,
-0.3727935851,
-0.9419202209,
-0.3537289202,
-0.0012161395,
-0.4749525189,
-0.2239589691,
0.3433665633,
0.4115314782,
-0.6392611861,
0.6212311387,
-0.3454121649,
-0.1731965393,
-0.1565262675,
0.1723354161,
0.7352021337,
0.617131412,
0.2044093907,
-0.5942752361,
0.1040297598,
-0.0243565086,
-0.7890418768,
-0.1276725233,
-0.2879420817,
0.1857800633,
0.4155590832,
0.9098567367,
-0.0206686109,
0.4420800209,
0.2615638673,
-0.3839737475,
0.544047296,
-0.6676511168,
0.4467614591,
-0.7658476233,
0.2118733525,
-0.0295873638,
-0.1598013192,
-0.2017228305,
0.0927866027,
0.3641466796,
-0.1333360523,
-0.1425389946,
0.3468067348,
-0.7111394405,
0.3690075576,
-0.3149996996,
-0.1322052181,
-0.4132162631,
0.5858412981,
0.1946035922,
0.619343996,
0.8219661713,
-0.6706259251,
0.5118854642,
-0.1792705655,
-0.2240588963,
0.4797395468,
-0.4310057759,
0.4369422495,
-0.0815700889,
0.2508341074,
-0.9690324068,
-0.0616859421,
0.2145688683,
-0.4150159061,
0.4777131975,
-0.6059285402,
-0.4874806702,
-0.3539590836,
-0.3430610299,
0.2433651239,
0.8947263956,
-0.5707507133,
0.6349359751,
-0.1036024913,
-0.1808167547,
-0.5642751455,
-0.3578286469,
0.2849401236,
-0.3454694748,
-0.5841863155,
0.0879619122,
-0.0143831838,
-0.3284144998,
-0.4543017149,
-0.2006183863,
-0.0181799326,
-0.0153240375,
0.5389528275,
0.1460048854,
-0.3960401714,
0.1077187136,
-0.2996633649,
-0.1524758339,
-0.0298867337,
-0.4440561533,
0.8223646879,
-0.1333597749,
-0.2610414028,
-0.3137704432,
0.224962756,
0.3404843807,
-0.1875500679,
0.4662415385,
0.3952389956,
-0.3743808568,
-0.4588211179,
-0.9092909694,
-0.06251847,
-0.4790335298,
0.1523564756,
-0.2234085351,
-0.7064107656,
0.3997150958,
-0.3460854888,
-0.0316555314,
0.0038028802,
0.5224813223,
0.0213386174,
0.4920797348,
0.9973199368,
-0.2093853951,
0.8369433284,
-0.3758592606,
-0.1736986786,
-0.7340500951,
-0.4138761163,
-0.3481937647,
-0.0087979874,
-0.3560045958,
-0.4756845832,
0.1016483083,
0.6131520271,
-0.2643927634,
0.3329247236,
-0.4734711647,
0.4744371772,
0.6261143684,
0.3947869837,
0.4636388421,
-0.2216067612,
0.1225394979,
0.3316791952,
-0.5461090803,
-0.6920844913,
1.433874011,
0.3883008659,
1.198412776,
-0.1100212559,
0.8270224929,
0.5181119442,
0.2035710514,
-0.6010109186,
0.3756114841,
0.2587077022,
0.0012825545,
-0.0963003263,
-0.3165972233,
-0.8282980323,
-0.0052292878,
0.2160425782,
-0.9898401499,
0.0018107863,
0.2353305519,
-0.3372660577,
-0.0983050615,
-0.725030005,
0.8408646584,
-0.0572765842,
-0.5303921103,
-0.4582284391,
-0.4684275985,
0.1166621968,
0.1697713584,
0.0575653017,
0.4864493012,
-0.2996500731,
0.6736298203,
-0.5816574097,
1.0436373949,
-0.1870314181,
-0.2088496536,
0.2510976791,
0.0779579282,
0.6375726461,
0.3000529706,
-0.2608242035,
0.0679812059,
0.0380289108,
-0.2969106436,
-0.3945697248,
0.9686995745,
-0.4500237107,
-0.746538043,
-0.4641338885,
-0.3846545815,
0.1225303337,
0.2201888859,
0.0706589893,
0.4839439392,
0.2022633106,
0.2117639035,
0.6712021828,
-0.4283927083,
0.7300788164,
0.7367001176,
-0.2910571992,
-0.3352951109,
0.3786394894,
-0.1216969863,
-0.2228505313,
0.2360980511,
0.0687118843,
-0.2443092167,
-0.7351434231,
-0.2415265739,
0.3211456239,
-0.8792107105,
-0.1355607808,
-0.4498020411,
0.1735084802,
-0.6901156306,
-0.3033696711,
0.0324632563,
-0.178591609,
-0.4334785044,
0.2270744741,
0.3716819882,
0.9066534638,
0.0099260677,
0.1873373538,
-0.5335124135,
0.2482409328,
0.0634081587,
0.4593860507,
-0.0281274635,
-0.4777426422,
-0.0304447375,
-0.030904511,
-0.3312679231,
-1.184845686,
0.2571227551,
0.1052070186,
0.9775552154,
0.2014331371,
-0.1427761763,
0.5869268775,
-0.4368343055,
1.0455061197,
0.0712529272,
-0.7849181294,
1.020526886,
-0.4253664911,
0.5443359613,
0.3935121298,
0.3236964345,
-0.6003449559,
-0.0147373229,
-0.58929497,
-0.9290785789,
0.5476750731,
-0.232856676,
-0.1393074691,
0.1876905262,
0.7302770019,
0.2576253414,
0.2268905342,
-0.686750114,
-0.138513267,
-0.1963090152,
0.2815897465,
-0.2186658233,
-0.0440591797,
0.1241825894,
-0.2541626096,
0.6803448796,
-0.2189959288,
-0.1091067344,
0.2114058137,
-0.379645586,
-0.0042197928,
0.2560452521,
0.5231178999,
1.2641845942,
-0.3012615442,
-0.0105016762,
0.2321087271,
-0.2405693531,
-0.1895264834,
-0.0839939341,
0.204526931,
-0.2442689389,
0.6861868501,
0.1507458836,
0.0048236456,
-0.7036044598,
0.5653429627,
0.0636814088,
0.1531234533,
-0.7570061088,
0.4419380724,
-0.1716054976,
0.5979322791,
0.742775321,
-0.0913950503,
0.0416743271,
-0.7196628451,
0.6167812347,
0.1665101051,
-0.2688733339,
0.1726849079,
0.4268189371,
0.1522246599,
-0.6432383657,
0.7834332585,
-0.0486769602,
-0.4539096653,
0.5974078178,
0.4469150305,
0.7072329521,
0.0161242522,
-0.1028578803,
0.624115169,
0.0605061203,
-0.4039061069,
0.267000705,
-0.6697066426,
-0.0671079978,
-0.8087328672,
-0.662268579,
-0.2889761329,
0.1787900925,
-0.5734213591,
0.539272964,
-0.5326029062,
0.0443385467,
-0.5770794749,
0.1699505746,
-0.6135997772,
0.1923238933,
0.2688552439,
1.1886003017,
-0.5745535493,
1.1474063396,
0.9397243857,
-0.8110845089,
-0.5681915283,
0.0347279087,
-0.0267026033,
-0.7874260545,
0.7362927794,
0.0901049376,
0.0331130698,
-0.2247764766,
-0.6374922991,
-0.5690752864,
1.1543444395,
0.0151303867,
-0.5901764631,
-0.3138095737,
-0.4367290139,
0.6774647236,
-0.1870815456,
0.4992124736,
0.719148159,
0.2704414427,
0.1697201282,
-1.090844512,
0.0295968782,
-0.6006135345,
-0.0866614729,
0.0995467827,
-0.3943683803,
0.7613504529,
-0.5871462226,
0.0236947313,
0.368822813,
0.5092038512,
0.3527144492,
0.390060693,
0.194634825,
0.4600296617,
0.7692172527,
-0.0768631622,
1.2521766424,
0.0095915841,
0.2837978899,
1.063999176,
0.1356538981,
0.8460990191,
0.6440581083,
-0.2342355996,
0.5269825459,
0.5738615394,
0.0513601191,
0.61280334,
0.411311388,
0.013453315,
-0.4277403355,
0.3769283593,
-0.9102325439,
0.1312517673,
0.2211624831,
-0.6615405679,
-0.282574743,
0.0109963836,
0.1925056428,
0.1595191509,
-0.6062047482,
0.8347415924,
0.1502596289,
-0.8798831701,
0.8459917903,
-0.3148257136,
1.0859915018,
-0.6841663122,
-0.5405047536,
-0.4524228275,
0.48517555,
-0.4461892545,
-0.921782732,
0.1045220122,
-0.1786729693,
-0.1090042368,
-0.4797227681,
0.5546334982,
-0.3625595868,
-0.2854105532,
0.0937566385,
0.1620773375,
0.14215976,
-0.291954428,
-0.3282428384,
0.1298919916,
0.3209958375,
-0.2407227457,
0.0309177283,
0.4503521621,
0.1273424476,
0.974393785,
0.3830212355,
0.2578359544,
0.1262324005,
0.0709658042,
0.8535598516,
-0.9754108191,
-0.6202893257,
-0.9653627276,
0.6211734414,
-0.0575961992,
-0.3591365218,
0.6989123225,
0.4460376203,
1.1956650019,
-0.1157744676,
0.8420209289,
-0.0305328481,
0.4217966795,
-0.7918319702,
0.7684426904,
-0.6446849108,
0.7220934033,
-0.3395356536,
-0.7658308148,
-0.2323145419,
1.0805462599,
-0.5105284452,
0.1566039622,
0.6343830824,
0.9081937671,
0.2559893429,
0.0666920021,
0.2045691162,
-0.0078890715,
0.4234950244,
0.8834643364,
1.2485755682,
-0.2270566225,
0.4341602027,
-0.3823291659,
-0.5101459026,
-0.1860935837,
-1.2211973667,
-1.0647363663,
-0.6265388727,
-0.5051037669,
-0.4507037997,
0.2048636526,
0.962626636,
0.5748615265,
-0.6294612885,
-0.3000862598,
-0.0717983916,
0.2078690231,
-0.2743176818,
-0.1596953273,
0.1663084179,
-0.5670856237,
-0.5445471406,
0.3870642781,
0.0988067314,
-0.3938394785,
-0.1909486651,
-0.352198869,
-0.0541620143,
-0.5248954296,
0.4648756087,
0.3584603667,
-0.7579347491,
-0.1576129049,
-0.2589906454,
0.0932563692,
0.1492120475,
1.4022188187,
-1.213783741,
0.5497366786,
0.6884063482,
0.3937540352,
0.4116784632,
-0.0196152721,
0.8430241942,
-0.5272781253,
0.292796284,
0.2751946449,
0.709190011,
0.1353697628,
-0.496694237,
0.6306334734,
-0.005244799,
-0.6581359506,
-0.6539213657,
0.0013304381,
-1.042883873,
-0.6651937962,
1.5757613182,
-0.1549166441,
-0.0842789337,
-0.1930428445,
-0.6738154888,
0.2466215491,
-0.5008698702,
0.7495080829,
0.538900733,
-0.3183513582,
-0.4713290036,
-0.2089986503,
0.4414845109,
0.0823160037,
-0.6381034255,
0.0564650036,
0.889128983,
0.4340567291,
0.124216482,
0.7349571586,
-0.1915071309,
0.5421253443,
0.2515913248,
-0.0766809136,
-0.3736296296,
-0.3930190206,
-0.5527290106,
0.3222133815,
0.2446972132,
0.1108073741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07362v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07362v4
|
Volcano: Mitigating Multimodal Hallucination through Self-Feedback Guided Revision
| 2023-11-13T14:26:24 | 2024-04-02T04:12:43 |
Seongyun Lee, Sue Hyun Park, Yongrae Jo, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large multimodal models suffer from multimodal hallucination, where they
provide incorrect responses misaligned with the given visual information.
Recent works have conjectured that one of the reasons behind multimodal
hallucination is due to the vision encoder failing to ground on the image
properly. To mitigate this issue, we propose a novel approach that leverages
self-feedback as visual cues. Building on this approach, we introduce Volcano,
a multimodal self-feedback guided revision model. Volcano generates natural
language feedback to its initial response based on the provided visual
information and utilizes this feedback to self-revise its initial response.
Volcano effectively reduces multimodal hallucination and achieves
state-of-the-art on MMHal-Bench, POPE, and GAVIE. It also improves on general
multimodal abilities and outperforms previous models on MM-Vet and MMBench.
Through qualitative analysis, we show that Volcano's feedback is properly
grounded on the image than the initial response. This indicates that Volcano
can provide itself with richer visual information through feedback generation,
leading to self-correct hallucinations. We publicly release our model, data,
and code at https://github.com/kaistAI/Volcano}{github.com/kaistAI/Volcano
|
[
-0.3862785995,
-0.9167628884,
0.4359925985,
0.4705649018,
-0.2565862834,
-0.2211311609,
-0.1238571331,
-0.097795926,
0.7109078169,
0.7903689742,
-0.7430660725,
-0.278627187,
-0.346642077,
0.1174671724,
-0.0364800096,
0.9247436523,
0.2555491924,
0.1579409689,
-0.3842174709,
-0.0783546492,
-0.9143395424,
-0.6006786227,
-0.4500209987,
-0.2300117463,
0.8955000639,
0.2068283707,
0.5774492025,
0.4247640967,
0.4486080408,
0.2759046853,
0.2843599319,
0.4259168506,
-0.63376683,
0.3318659365,
-0.0032592374,
-0.2036990374,
-0.2967457175,
-0.3731774688,
0.4243508577,
0.1236806884,
-0.1171065569,
0.0713543594,
0.1431568861,
0.7643601894,
-0.7861958742,
0.1606892943,
-0.5608516335,
0.1654839069,
0.2144705057,
-0.6811365485,
-0.8297679424,
-0.0996590704,
-0.3210240304,
-0.4946754277,
0.4264536798,
-0.1803209782,
0.3925921321,
0.9062563777,
-0.4977650642,
-0.1070624813,
-1.0028505325,
0.4100280702,
-0.2889189422,
0.5145418644,
0.3762603104,
0.4916565716,
-0.362903446,
-0.4360440075,
-0.7273520231,
-0.3081291318,
0.0943026841,
0.3361459374,
0.1572583616,
-0.0750610828,
0.0793165341,
0.1736062765,
-0.4193714857,
-0.249859333,
-0.4772950411,
-0.5385687947,
0.2080969661,
0.0094988951,
0.0869593024,
-0.6672575474,
-0.4278268218,
-0.4865482152,
-0.5533665419,
0.0428698286,
0.296149075,
0.2063739002,
0.5917103887,
0.7150838375,
-0.2670651674,
0.5329333544,
0.1421491355,
-0.150669232,
0.322674036,
-0.0416023023,
-0.249539569,
0.0125543997,
0.6110557914,
0.9134241343,
-0.3002873659,
-0.0935574919,
-0.1053785533,
0.3705816567,
0.7670254707,
-0.8771936893,
-0.5848379135,
0.309491396,
-0.4168887436,
-0.3673985004,
-0.0691683441,
-1.1411001682,
-0.7431063652,
-0.3178209364,
0.8919053674,
-0.3759350181,
-0.3963656723,
0.0401128456,
-0.1107957512,
-0.2329477817,
0.6573089957,
-0.80473423,
-0.0213408936,
0.1804150045,
0.8896810412,
0.1007182896,
-0.3718523383,
-0.4933292866,
0.3230417967,
-0.2983759642,
0.9307394028,
-0.3566898108,
-0.3505405188,
-0.1371941715,
0.1544263512,
0.0626548082,
-0.5071516633,
0.2899667919,
-0.2167976648,
0.1782158017,
-0.2238455415,
0.0279779229,
-0.5318620205,
0.5130628943,
-0.8352218866,
0.763707459,
-0.4816461802,
-0.5987740159,
0.1865928024,
-0.231454879,
-0.0018561821,
-0.0724565983,
-0.2710126638,
-0.5842995644,
0.2251125425,
0.6538951397,
0.2146801054,
0.2505223751,
0.1792862117,
-0.5024285316,
-0.1824044734,
-0.1328690201,
-0.4077605605,
0.3244377673,
0.2163991332,
-0.429053694,
0.5095883608,
-0.8176739812,
-0.0031792158,
0.1483729929,
0.1620529145,
-0.1727989763,
-0.0630759299,
-0.0960454121,
0.2591156662,
-0.1064198688,
-0.2637634277,
0.3670907617,
0.1861228347,
0.2908683419,
0.8936036229,
0.1754650027,
0.1747376174,
-0.3731301725,
0.503369689,
-0.0650217906,
0.443993777,
-0.4618700743,
-0.3965409696,
-0.8837585449,
-0.6035625935,
0.0836634263,
0.1732306033,
-1.1717996597,
-0.0587597415,
-0.1892358214,
-0.5277115107,
-0.8129385114,
0.1284377426,
0.3079695106,
0.3995526135,
0.6900156736,
-0.4827851653,
-0.4126397669,
-0.7301220894,
0.1033583805,
-0.2281242311,
0.0879830047,
0.3731916249,
0.4549691677,
-0.5889831781,
0.595079422,
-0.535063982,
-0.9791622162,
0.4077844024,
0.3941367567,
-0.2107973695,
0.442715019,
0.3864505291,
-0.6894037724,
-0.0219023842,
-0.0801033527,
-0.8005269766,
0.0529252999,
-0.350373894,
-0.0514358841,
-0.0178397037,
0.5422351956,
-0.6936020255,
0.5334047079,
0.6206712127,
-0.2167240232,
0.5218248367,
-0.4377611578,
0.5608847141,
-0.8732431531,
-0.1422640681,
-0.4361637533,
-0.1523769051,
-0.3986553252,
0.214702785,
0.092957668,
-0.0124465069,
-0.1804329306,
0.246640712,
-0.3245638907,
0.2993469834,
-0.5426155925,
-0.3463076651,
0.2332573682,
0.75532341,
-0.067371659,
0.3935655653,
0.5738350749,
-0.7245914936,
0.6342335343,
0.0751463249,
0.0866858065,
0.5793212652,
-0.4769706726,
0.4343206286,
-0.5450622439,
0.4598935843,
-1.0714460611,
-0.4067252874,
0.4650120139,
-0.5872151852,
0.1791176945,
-0.2439358383,
-0.5754144788,
-0.4927301407,
-0.3909918964,
0.4786216915,
0.0744091123,
-0.831925869,
0.9088714719,
0.1384740919,
0.1229738444,
-0.4605305791,
-0.4381691217,
0.0832642168,
-0.0430557616,
-0.5256125927,
0.2596142888,
-0.6065149903,
0.2583630085,
0.0064136279,
-0.0801243708,
0.0022652755,
-0.3645089269,
0.5632303357,
-0.0255982876,
0.1240847856,
0.5398059487,
-0.0593770109,
0.0481191538,
0.115110293,
-0.314578265,
0.687394619,
-0.0925943032,
-0.4749049246,
-0.6231764555,
-0.0043910732,
0.9503993392,
-0.1857483685,
0.4145244062,
0.662581861,
-0.5038742423,
0.0923265293,
-0.8658801913,
-0.6300728917,
-0.4643676877,
0.1075479537,
-0.8058834076,
-0.6409791708,
0.4829140306,
-0.1919541061,
-0.3032109737,
0.4568893313,
0.8949869275,
-0.0950628668,
1.1055310965,
0.5117567778,
0.2893096805,
0.3277553022,
-0.2767759264,
0.0544347614,
-0.8561394811,
-0.6911694407,
-0.2357507944,
-0.21128425,
-0.286680758,
-0.6078807116,
0.2941839099,
-0.2722584307,
0.4529883564,
0.1131864712,
-0.747698307,
0.4804559052,
0.5905270576,
0.5657349825,
0.2715067863,
0.0642549023,
-0.3575879931,
-0.3594658375,
-0.5223405361,
-0.1908586174,
0.9096166492,
0.2089245617,
0.9953989387,
0.1324808598,
0.6721382737,
0.3614909053,
0.1909243464,
-0.5128590465,
0.3290655613,
0.2927686274,
-0.6234617829,
-0.2876642346,
-0.4335418046,
-0.733371973,
0.7028228641,
-0.3932161331,
-0.1532870382,
0.2182807624,
0.4739109576,
-0.5729171634,
0.1896236837,
-0.8383797407,
0.9103602767,
-0.1062156707,
-0.5602139235,
-0.3941945136,
-0.4054433703,
0.3059627414,
-0.1305972636,
0.39338696,
0.095916979,
0.5266831517,
0.1390894949,
-0.3517374992,
1.1341118813,
-0.267277658,
-0.0388643667,
0.2762697935,
0.3478964269,
0.2194642425,
0.2815208435,
0.3135415316,
-0.0323836766,
-0.1461125761,
-0.2376239747,
-1.0001183748,
0.9974848032,
-0.713181138,
-0.6208068728,
-0.3456151187,
-0.4405460656,
0.1640913934,
0.1250011176,
0.3797308505,
0.4766162336,
-0.0824872479,
0.3562557995,
0.568824172,
0.0262302868,
0.3574328423,
0.1118052527,
-0.8228134513,
-1.0048182011,
0.9421842098,
0.159431085,
0.0328041837,
0.1085934564,
0.1413183063,
-0.3764105141,
-0.146216616,
-0.5250604749,
0.1939554065,
-0.8560090065,
-0.3121631742,
-0.736917913,
0.0753331184,
-0.7232748866,
0.1380116045,
-0.5661277771,
-0.3694591224,
-0.1555214226,
-0.0554759018,
0.1483165324,
0.8833207488,
-0.1112162992,
0.2776179016,
-0.3656215966,
0.5768299103,
0.7280490994,
0.3091950715,
-0.0445755497,
-0.5314292312,
0.1819673777,
0.0277485847,
-0.3709101081,
-0.9260705113,
0.5598451495,
0.0430057272,
0.2063188702,
0.3798079789,
0.1536478996,
1.1830303669,
-0.6527343392,
0.6152524352,
0.3713146448,
-0.6487801671,
0.8511126637,
0.0443551466,
0.5377392173,
0.4510164559,
0.0907031521,
-0.4321393967,
-0.5808599591,
-0.3162185848,
-0.5534228683,
0.1215249002,
0.376557827,
0.2865058184,
-0.0171789173,
0.2788620293,
0.2589003146,
0.2513877153,
-1.2042655945,
0.1166287512,
-0.93952775,
0.1695247591,
-0.1423538476,
-0.4556320906,
-0.2951150835,
-0.4821581841,
0.5538397431,
-0.3392342925,
0.1981380731,
0.6733074188,
-0.4379769564,
-0.2432056069,
-0.0929162502,
0.9594519734,
0.3837970793,
-0.4550233483,
0.5855330229,
-0.0727489665,
-0.3662180603,
-0.0374537185,
-0.3566257954,
-0.2621261775,
0.1588188559,
0.0177708846,
0.8178095818,
0.008534587,
-0.1636521816,
0.3846826553,
-0.2698723972,
-0.0280072335,
-0.4004277885,
-0.1341839582,
-0.4208018482,
0.3760128319,
0.295291692,
0.4866215885,
0.2974024713,
-0.4026001394,
0.3086186349,
0.2329691201,
-0.6605504751,
-0.4626895487,
0.8750383854,
0.1167797074,
-0.1657122523,
0.534812808,
0.0173692796,
-0.5469176769,
0.3010230064,
0.6491807699,
0.8263311386,
-0.6708875895,
0.3548700511,
0.5876767635,
0.7066553235,
0.0026420821,
0.1870038509,
0.0605139993,
-0.4415299892,
-0.2842763662,
-0.3047883213,
-0.261408627,
0.1045241728,
-0.6008927822,
0.3638730049,
-0.6972640753,
-0.4999729395,
-0.1914292574,
-0.6463151574,
-0.4729256928,
0.3515962958,
0.1145706996,
0.1110797226,
-0.6798177361,
0.8282731175,
0.4575954676,
-0.7030043006,
-0.2045114189,
0.0820967406,
0.1635607034,
-0.6059275866,
0.4360076189,
0.6649894118,
-0.4891968966,
0.0068437043,
-0.6077872515,
-0.6589344144,
0.988227129,
0.2706206739,
-0.1922394484,
0.4332074821,
-0.1249720007,
0.6512807608,
-0.4320287108,
0.3041623235,
-0.1403096467,
0.2907606661,
0.4756906629,
-0.7909687161,
0.0065962225,
-0.4089241028,
0.1195303798,
0.0334889255,
-0.8297790885,
0.5426255465,
-0.4764385521,
0.0567460768,
-0.2112414539,
0.8290296793,
0.027141666,
0.2770743966,
0.7573717237,
0.7986013293,
0.8179562688,
0.0664953068,
0.8987900019,
-0.0866612718,
0.3624593914,
1.2549884319,
-0.0832308158,
0.8742184639,
0.8035280704,
0.5245313048,
0.553050518,
0.5069251657,
-0.134333238,
1.02374053,
-0.0193031263,
-0.0803082958,
-0.2949467003,
-0.1726034582,
-0.5163199306,
0.4127658606,
0.0396236479,
-0.0944188535,
0.0875307396,
0.4799006283,
-0.1691355556,
-0.0993390158,
-0.3208276331,
0.6673055291,
-0.2153958827,
-0.8710715771,
0.6899594069,
-0.3024110794,
0.3553825617,
-0.2201229483,
-0.3497614861,
-0.3062918186,
0.3463079035,
-0.2236052752,
-0.2347121537,
0.3300194442,
-0.4668473005,
-0.3290700018,
-0.2755835652,
0.4623323083,
-0.5661941171,
-0.4058941901,
0.3768808246,
-0.0683036298,
-0.0139006209,
-0.5991958976,
-0.3027226031,
0.3003128171,
0.0636023208,
0.0583138652,
-0.0616086014,
0.5469064713,
0.0721744671,
0.8847020864,
0.7416707277,
-0.2804437578,
0.5165928602,
0.3820674717,
0.975135684,
-0.719516933,
-0.3723184466,
-0.8003824353,
0.547719121,
-0.0367410481,
-0.2473927885,
0.6888635755,
0.4431477487,
0.8061771393,
-0.5414431691,
0.2779255211,
0.2026316375,
0.0608093068,
-0.612429142,
0.5856294036,
-0.7801856995,
0.1170828044,
-0.2154346108,
-1.0277118683,
-0.6209799647,
0.7533448935,
0.1596889794,
-0.2020522952,
0.9415550828,
1.0767942667,
0.1759299189,
-0.3611410558,
0.4984668195,
0.3487324715,
0.3252551854,
0.1333028227,
0.900916338,
-0.4638133645,
0.7515130043,
-0.4864548445,
-0.3618542254,
-0.5506996512,
-0.6045370102,
-1.0200445652,
-0.7018360496,
-0.525683403,
-0.6910523772,
-0.0008537712,
0.7245675921,
0.763486743,
-0.6706273556,
-0.0143827507,
0.2729181647,
0.0735957995,
-0.341835916,
-0.1773806065,
0.1663787067,
-0.425195694,
-0.604880631,
0.4346541464,
0.6405911446,
0.1784139872,
-0.5817607641,
-0.177636832,
0.1079209745,
-0.0740214437,
0.7776693106,
0.0180981234,
-1.1663194895,
-0.3733123243,
0.222757861,
-0.1799737811,
0.3156814873,
0.7402542233,
-0.8631826043,
1.3707635403,
0.2541697621,
0.3843775094,
0.7652331591,
-0.3186909258,
0.4208367765,
-0.6536820531,
0.2230409086,
0.009698987,
0.3372666836,
0.4865956903,
-0.5603558421,
0.5150982738,
0.4426468611,
-0.4518443644,
-0.7615553141,
0.2647894919,
-0.9396036267,
-0.2560315132,
0.9534695745,
0.3316857815,
-0.3500110805,
0.2109443247,
-0.7755242586,
0.1237643659,
-0.1166214868,
1.5929623842,
0.8981736302,
0.1376391053,
-0.5873423815,
-0.4444933236,
0.348220557,
0.650447309,
-0.6837367415,
-0.12265452,
0.8811741471,
0.0221845824,
0.5338892937,
0.6222493649,
-0.130690828,
0.2989424169,
-0.0005929928,
0.6672326922,
0.0759005323,
-1.1176798344,
-0.5033447146,
0.3171006441,
-0.115222998,
-0.3626135886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07361v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07361v2
|
The Impact of Large Language Models on Scientific Discovery: a Preliminary Study using GPT-4
| 2023-11-13T14:26:12 | 2023-12-08T06:30:12 |
Microsoft Research AI4Science, Microsoft Azure Quantum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, groundbreaking advancements in natural language processing
have culminated in the emergence of powerful large language models (LLMs),
which have showcased remarkable capabilities across a vast array of domains,
including the understanding, generation, and translation of natural language,
and even tasks that extend beyond language processing. In this report, we delve
into the performance of LLMs within the context of scientific discovery,
focusing on GPT-4, the state-of-the-art language model. Our investigation spans
a diverse range of scientific areas encompassing drug discovery, biology,
computational chemistry (density functional theory (DFT) and molecular dynamics
(MD)), materials design, and partial differential equations (PDE). Evaluating
GPT-4 on scientific tasks is crucial for uncovering its potential across
various research domains, validating its domain-specific expertise,
accelerating scientific progress, optimizing resource allocation, guiding
future model development, and fostering interdisciplinary research. Our
exploration methodology primarily consists of expert-driven case assessments,
which offer qualitative insights into the model's comprehension of intricate
scientific concepts and relationships, and occasionally benchmark testing,
which quantitatively evaluates the model's capacity to solve well-defined
domain-specific problems. Our preliminary exploration indicates that GPT-4
exhibits promising potential for a variety of scientific applications,
demonstrating its aptitude for handling complex problem-solving and knowledge
integration tasks. Broadly speaking, we evaluate GPT-4's knowledge base,
scientific understanding, scientific numerical calculation abilities, and
various scientific prediction capabilities.
|
[
-0.1748988181,
-0.6857913733,
1.2194844484,
0.2449212372,
-0.0936603993,
0.1156685799,
-0.3667829037,
-0.6464027166,
-0.1535643041,
0.1800349951,
-0.0804371163,
-0.4650078714,
-0.842617631,
0.526124239,
-0.3427046239,
0.9131183028,
-0.0960104764,
0.1537527591,
-0.2456412911,
0.3486842513,
-0.2667277455,
-0.652074337,
-0.3893997669,
-0.387978375,
0.6238131523,
-0.0700894445,
0.3566409945,
0.5337684751,
0.8543583155,
0.3241084218,
-0.1608251631,
-0.3153655529,
-0.5429650545,
-0.049988497,
-0.4288871288,
-0.4843606651,
-0.5105209947,
0.180396229,
0.7904975414,
0.69068712,
-0.0541228913,
-0.2010199577,
-0.1890431494,
0.3688059151,
-0.0440163426,
0.6237356663,
-0.4988660216,
0.0814066604,
-0.5502618551,
-0.1921338588,
-0.1265078932,
-0.2813147902,
0.689039588,
-0.7442405224,
0.4479159117,
0.1006412581,
0.5441542864,
0.0376674458,
-0.3985093832,
-0.261143446,
-0.7908287644,
0.8999888897,
-0.8236724734,
0.4741480052,
0.128026545,
0.246479556,
-0.4632169008,
-1.0580406189,
-0.6413174272,
-0.5228996277,
0.2700330019,
-0.0217231903,
-0.0480965264,
0.2310558259,
0.3315141201,
0.4969148338,
-0.6756054759,
0.1041394174,
-0.6097088456,
-0.3311846852,
0.3014890254,
0.0104528517,
0.3649135232,
-0.0660006404,
-0.0720927641,
0.135296315,
-0.831553638,
-0.2855361402,
-0.0180615652,
0.4287490547,
0.1684501022,
0.7227755785,
-0.1238449886,
0.4931728244,
-0.405325532,
0.0146557949,
0.2491719276,
-0.8892005682,
-0.1243409365,
-0.0074291835,
0.8191155195,
0.1179475039,
-0.0694146827,
-0.1639710367,
-0.1924696863,
0.1892991513,
0.1319115013,
-1.2274721861,
-0.3933701217,
-0.1426281035,
-0.1579575837,
-0.1473088562,
-0.2781704962,
-0.732796669,
-0.5398352146,
-0.1131294817,
0.5574893951,
-0.3795077801,
-0.4250445962,
0.3686732948,
-0.1818507165,
-0.111052461,
0.3797823489,
-1.0713291168,
0.3895703554,
0.6969943643,
1.1245127916,
-0.4101187289,
-0.2659140527,
-0.0948925167,
0.1340572387,
-0.3882715106,
0.7425344586,
-0.6206834912,
-0.6062431335,
-0.3793400824,
-0.0959118158,
0.0370261557,
-0.4761053026,
0.8166221976,
-0.5188089013,
-0.0210441686,
-0.7099616528,
-0.5899872184,
-0.2206334174,
0.1134409383,
-0.7702255249,
0.6308344603,
0.138501212,
-0.7218427658,
0.3542645574,
-1.157397151,
-0.3055692017,
0.3928931653,
-0.2952373922,
-0.2279773951,
0.2651573122,
-0.1767557561,
0.3125500083,
-0.6319379807,
0.4321541786,
-0.1440296173,
-0.3554941416,
0.2020051777,
-0.2538630664,
0.0162004065,
0.1245919093,
-0.5570656657,
-0.0286181998,
-0.4932298064,
-0.2348618358,
0.3072701991,
-0.316796422,
-0.2545693517,
-0.1302958578,
-0.1867813319,
0.1715452373,
0.425522089,
-0.7612397671,
0.3754343688,
-0.4622730017,
0.7287974954,
0.5053166151,
0.0802335739,
0.4097231627,
0.1213460192,
0.482733041,
-0.1482312232,
-0.0374619104,
-0.0250059981,
-0.7734203339,
-0.149722591,
-0.0948376656,
0.4934177101,
0.0969106406,
-0.531416893,
-0.2785912156,
-0.2796651125,
-0.3734548688,
-0.2071089298,
0.0109285275,
0.2218192816,
0.4239158928,
0.3852191865,
-0.1812831163,
-0.4743450284,
-1.0146591663,
-0.1841402948,
-0.0239227042,
-0.0175942685,
0.2506021559,
0.7763195038,
-0.5405195355,
0.9030795097,
-0.4713748395,
-0.0644712299,
-0.1813963503,
0.2003731132,
0.4679202139,
0.2466285974,
0.3247009516,
-0.8179033399,
-0.3559078574,
0.3049645126,
-0.8881031871,
-0.1120310873,
0.4747067392,
0.0842236504,
-0.0283931084,
0.1419002414,
-0.9297943711,
0.1400831491,
0.5560248494,
-0.154463008,
0.6229917407,
-0.3322968185,
0.2787812948,
-0.4921036363,
0.1411372721,
0.2044311911,
0.2214563638,
-0.9845693707,
-0.287617147,
0.0849503949,
0.0151019888,
-0.194547534,
0.4593123198,
-0.5092296004,
-0.2326968163,
-0.3556783199,
0.0020985694,
-0.0103068808,
-0.0807213485,
0.1221651807,
0.9274635911,
0.5476700068,
-0.454895854,
0.152548641,
0.1246763989,
-0.3390411437,
0.0598797798,
-0.8511906862,
0.2231863141,
0.2445478141,
0.2285974026,
-0.575737536,
-0.3088389039,
0.0371076167,
-0.1818755269,
0.3565725982,
-0.1258057952,
-0.7910705805,
-0.5436583161,
-0.1364731342,
0.6195175648,
0.1841094792,
-0.2665338814,
0.5818069577,
0.3928247988,
-0.693351984,
-0.0568376519,
-0.4036295116,
0.3471752405,
-0.2053467184,
-0.626147747,
0.5304877162,
-0.2989812791,
-0.202232644,
-0.1973583996,
-0.3118424118,
0.101015538,
0.0434709303,
0.0057537034,
0.2287807465,
-0.1027077287,
0.1291262805,
-0.0566592775,
0.0770028606,
0.3146958053,
-0.3008155823,
0.5559623837,
-0.5574401617,
-0.1248220354,
-0.1779814661,
0.1588554233,
0.6005859971,
-0.2318535149,
0.4087507725,
0.3298220038,
-0.4053013623,
0.0401129313,
-0.3102298081,
-0.361318171,
-0.4695737958,
0.7349219918,
-0.4198931456,
-0.9549783468,
0.4076342583,
-0.2278151065,
-0.2203108221,
0.4457936287,
0.6525312066,
0.3235099316,
1.0747544765,
0.6917530298,
0.0959734023,
0.1728861481,
-0.2310453802,
0.5979707837,
-0.7268147469,
-0.3489556909,
-0.3757945299,
0.1348846406,
-0.4784629941,
-0.7133491635,
0.6765568256,
-0.1105789319,
-0.200502187,
-0.0062464168,
-0.3836313486,
0.3535796702,
0.3987732828,
-0.1923139691,
0.4828420579,
-0.2256046534,
-0.2279995978,
-0.0860556066,
-0.5288959742,
-0.6411247849,
1.4472465515,
0.5840325952,
0.5412390232,
0.1931278706,
0.5280527472,
0.0776708573,
0.4193987846,
-0.6280864477,
0.4974029958,
0.1607843488,
-0.5976666808,
-0.3607667983,
-0.6025743484,
-0.8863488436,
0.2431762367,
-0.0524863787,
-0.4125894606,
-0.1752453297,
-0.0279048942,
-0.3667631447,
0.1301297247,
-0.8111611009,
0.852873385,
-0.5606158376,
-0.4291113019,
-0.2879631817,
-0.5857123733,
0.5637024641,
-0.6705539227,
0.2698314488,
-0.0373341441,
0.0388065465,
0.9432430863,
0.0527245328,
0.6085705161,
-0.2652425766,
-0.3273453116,
0.0259404685,
0.1148639023,
0.4559507668,
0.1817943603,
-0.0260236282,
0.4485729933,
0.0598934628,
-0.1840282381,
-0.5102001429,
1.0477503538,
-0.7201225758,
-0.7452143431,
-0.7097787261,
-0.7776601911,
-0.2203904837,
0.5049907565,
-0.0364683904,
0.3325338662,
-0.2806445956,
-0.028628543,
0.683165729,
-0.3282188475,
0.2532283068,
0.8585647345,
-0.3438641727,
-0.1428529024,
0.9963033795,
0.1018031016,
0.2351612598,
0.2312410772,
0.3923119605,
-0.5271530747,
-1.2476412058,
-0.1022454798,
0.6226118803,
-0.4632412493,
-0.0427511893,
-0.8265652657,
0.0276753642,
-0.4398574233,
0.2896494269,
-0.3869238794,
-0.3302820921,
-0.1691952944,
-0.324575007,
0.333525151,
1.2414208651,
-0.0430514552,
-0.0194977727,
-0.6716828942,
0.2509717345,
0.1004905701,
0.5448530316,
-0.3781197667,
-0.2321782708,
-0.4697738588,
0.0605253652,
-0.3443948328,
-0.6379532218,
0.4822808504,
0.1311044544,
0.6681281328,
0.107425414,
-0.3871082067,
0.2084730715,
-0.7562357187,
0.8402796388,
0.0459616892,
-0.7522446513,
0.373521924,
-0.7525109053,
0.2276376188,
0.0680798218,
0.4800722003,
-0.0976220593,
-0.1221708655,
-0.4868142903,
-0.7506847978,
0.3394365013,
0.330627203,
-0.3589127064,
0.0524637029,
0.4269647896,
0.1909759045,
0.4408767521,
-0.7098603249,
0.219044432,
-0.2869261205,
0.0321729667,
-0.2834494412,
-0.1152109355,
-0.2268378735,
-0.2050222456,
0.4484398663,
-0.0898747444,
0.3683299124,
0.1791481525,
0.1096158475,
0.0329951905,
0.3105861843,
0.8376687765,
0.771348238,
-0.3914374411,
0.0678488016,
-0.0342445448,
-0.7513831854,
-0.2236989141,
0.5023602247,
0.1445882469,
-0.20942761,
0.1554713249,
0.564099133,
0.1465740949,
-0.7384393811,
0.2440873086,
-0.0976299271,
-0.2806921601,
-0.0459409058,
-0.1685500294,
0.108174637,
0.3699399829,
0.5692406893,
0.0497105196,
0.5706261396,
-0.6273406148,
0.0226867832,
0.4172368944,
0.1998888701,
-0.7442253232,
0.7087730765,
0.0945477635,
0.105346866,
0.2949410081,
-0.2146052271,
-0.8758943081,
0.4648755491,
0.6420568228,
0.5329082012,
-0.2965556979,
0.0605977625,
0.1855062097,
0.2579284906,
-0.3359774053,
0.1388116628,
0.1789677888,
-0.7187185884,
-0.5318753719,
-0.7467001081,
-0.4764809906,
0.1211436614,
-0.1273139119,
0.0226364173,
-0.3062567711,
-0.3746727407,
0.1598407179,
0.4082718194,
-0.6556111574,
0.0218100362,
0.1119094491,
0.608237803,
-0.7814700007,
0.8696280122,
0.4462090433,
-0.2936508656,
-0.7926630378,
-0.3631060719,
0.1664229482,
-0.4469740093,
1.0047465563,
0.1189044565,
-0.1142433584,
0.084372066,
-0.4960341752,
-1.1954306364,
1.258762002,
0.2833619416,
-0.695782721,
-0.0328626446,
0.1620452106,
0.9037688375,
-0.2844229639,
0.3488544226,
0.9419582486,
0.6555379033,
0.1005427092,
-1.3738532066,
0.1032676548,
-0.352462858,
-0.0062750732,
0.2587837875,
-0.4424646497,
1.0318239927,
-0.4029740989,
-0.164928928,
0.1010252833,
0.5553948879,
0.5831811428,
0.3837352991,
0.1133669913,
0.2833059728,
0.9843897223,
-0.1463644803,
1.1995910406,
-0.2527009547,
0.2526148856,
0.5812621117,
-0.7740246058,
0.5970526338,
0.4689440429,
-0.308932662,
0.2675741613,
0.5991866589,
-0.1279677004,
0.6377727985,
0.4921779931,
-0.4843825698,
0.246196419,
-0.1438704878,
-0.4380313456,
0.1138482019,
0.6836634278,
-0.2556350231,
-0.0080454154,
0.0295944493,
-0.0087283487,
-0.2599554062,
-0.2688215971,
0.3242802322,
0.123136051,
-0.5145903826,
0.4804845154,
0.042727001,
0.5209351182,
-0.6775327325,
-0.3299957514,
0.0235167406,
0.0933725908,
-0.0443635583,
-0.7950577736,
-0.077153407,
-0.0424479693,
-0.2395605743,
-0.0755360425,
0.4727704227,
-0.2745909095,
-0.2713279724,
0.2689366639,
0.3120954633,
0.2397155315,
-0.1741064191,
-0.2393390685,
0.394707799,
-0.0228424557,
-0.2426888943,
0.5183179975,
0.5426598191,
-0.1216009781,
0.7122386694,
0.7521238923,
0.1860769093,
0.1420079172,
0.1713404059,
1.0392053127,
-0.8638829589,
-0.0666270033,
-0.7052009106,
0.009061181,
0.0964422971,
0.0496125594,
0.9112845063,
0.7646409273,
0.4624430835,
-0.1150061041,
1.1414555311,
0.1054635197,
0.5258544683,
-0.4827537835,
0.5096235275,
-0.0544657633,
0.5275481343,
-0.465927124,
-0.7605504394,
-0.405982703,
0.4322690368,
-0.5782600641,
0.227608487,
1.0045651197,
0.6628434658,
0.196160838,
0.2870754898,
0.2297870368,
0.8603497148,
0.9790409803,
0.4092990458,
0.8649698496,
0.0081219114,
0.2486936003,
-0.0182297695,
-0.4467151165,
0.1303948015,
-0.912276268,
-0.7624852657,
-0.4345045686,
-0.0107826851,
0.0280850176,
0.0112732835,
0.6411957741,
0.3712020516,
-0.6054014564,
-0.1317252815,
-0.3347678185,
-0.4519741833,
0.3102405965,
-0.2165073752,
0.3501363695,
0.0038360043,
-0.7606603503,
1.0120800734,
0.5032797456,
0.2235226184,
-0.2728967071,
-0.1026093885,
-0.1226572916,
-0.055891376,
0.8109555244,
0.3206651211,
-0.7308631539,
-0.053389512,
0.2140464932,
0.1143784225,
-0.1302054226,
0.8445488214,
-0.7193736434,
0.4500773847,
0.2953413129,
0.6396049857,
0.8589583635,
-0.1019673198,
1.0565236807,
-0.1426962316,
-0.2571706772,
0.5316848159,
0.4849696755,
0.5345630646,
-0.3655840456,
0.6171771884,
0.384411633,
-1.0619696379,
-0.944945097,
0.0416783802,
-1.0538964272,
-0.132137686,
1.0778497458,
0.0482427776,
0.0570788197,
-0.2032207698,
-0.2672437727,
-0.0314687639,
-0.5593405366,
0.8128683567,
0.7437719107,
-0.4575571418,
-0.0821345896,
-1.1897346973,
0.6198446751,
0.3007520139,
-0.6901988983,
-0.048252169,
0.5138232708,
0.4506246746,
0.2345190644,
0.5459713936,
-0.3237680793,
0.0442658812,
-0.3641316891,
0.0507613048,
-0.0300008804,
-0.3020003438,
-0.3257007301,
0.0626996383,
0.3047579527,
0.455308795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07314v1
|
Semi-automatic Data Enhancement for Document-Level Relation Extraction with Distant Supervision from Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T13:10:44 | 2023-11-13T13:10:44 |
Junpeng Li, Zixia Jia, Zilong Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Document-level Relation Extraction (DocRE), which aims to extract relations
from a long context, is a critical challenge in achieving fine-grained
structural comprehension and generating interpretable document representations.
Inspired by recent advances in in-context learning capabilities emergent from
large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, we aim to design an automated
annotation method for DocRE with minimum human effort. Unfortunately, vanilla
in-context learning is infeasible for document-level relation extraction due to
the plenty of predefined fine-grained relation types and the uncontrolled
generations of LLMs. To tackle this issue, we propose a method integrating a
large language model (LLM) and a natural language inference (NLI) module to
generate relation triples, thereby augmenting document-level relation datasets.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach by introducing an enhanced
dataset known as DocGNRE, which excels in re-annotating numerous long-tail
relation types. We are confident that our method holds the potential for
broader applications in domain-specific relation type definitions and offers
tangible benefits in advancing generalized language semantic comprehension.
|
[
-0.3417949378,
-0.7570592165,
0.6079445481,
0.0548637398,
-0.2085544467,
-0.1080843881,
-0.3873742819,
-0.7340033054,
-0.121620357,
0.6354765296,
-0.4916666746,
-0.5587758422,
-0.4959122837,
0.2113699317,
-0.4176874459,
1.0751628876,
-0.0396244861,
-0.1831704378,
-0.3554278612,
0.2264473438,
-0.1371888369,
-0.5007277131,
-0.8302174211,
-0.3584587872,
0.4118149281,
0.4505158663,
0.3405264914,
0.3269634545,
0.5205877423,
0.1820626408,
-0.0899618343,
0.5936901569,
-0.4731543362,
0.1770042479,
-0.1411797404,
-0.2324358076,
-0.7854983807,
0.0049817706,
0.8009840846,
0.8256540298,
0.1450972408,
-0.0543680564,
-0.0005625394,
0.4481174648,
-0.381944418,
0.6866857409,
-0.5960447788,
-0.1695065796,
-0.1454193443,
-0.1867952049,
-0.407066524,
-0.2713096738,
0.2674614489,
-0.8143405914,
0.3453753591,
-0.0053295526,
1.2541337013,
0.0931367129,
-0.5450909138,
-0.3250622153,
-0.8228975534,
0.3924773633,
-0.7819658518,
0.4232860208,
0.6605852842,
0.2843265533,
-0.3630091846,
-0.988145113,
-0.40711689,
-0.4316245317,
-0.4328299165,
0.2351827025,
0.0581578389,
0.1213272288,
0.4275365472,
0.6157764196,
-0.0325155258,
0.0915461183,
-0.4153138399,
-0.0719501451,
0.5558106899,
0.0950657502,
0.171629563,
-0.3156594038,
-0.115694724,
0.0788530782,
-0.6003069878,
-0.3589620292,
0.2104734182,
0.2311381698,
-0.0114608798,
0.5816298127,
-0.0911157355,
0.7774839401,
0.2153563201,
-0.0419238284,
0.2633507252,
-0.4295921326,
-0.1830319911,
-0.1393148154,
0.9869887233,
0.2810291052,
0.4613304734,
-0.4360067248,
-0.1963353455,
-0.177944243,
0.063824214,
-0.7451226711,
-0.1810027212,
0.1658814698,
-0.130624637,
-0.370280087,
0.136913985,
-0.9197129607,
-0.3248186409,
-0.4902229905,
-0.0051082484,
-0.6628832817,
-0.3695804179,
-0.0871772319,
-0.3920808434,
0.4346875846,
0.4455374479,
-0.9730387926,
0.4155164659,
0.8746567965,
0.7926602364,
0.0082526812,
-0.2484840155,
-0.8738946915,
0.7056002617,
-0.2315619886,
0.812728107,
-0.7365940809,
-0.5774204135,
0.1574001759,
0.218699649,
-0.0100238547,
-0.4613419771,
0.7447469831,
-0.5506996512,
0.5779549479,
0.2912535369,
-0.8111467361,
0.1315940022,
0.261305064,
-0.7204170823,
1.3241621256,
0.5172312856,
-1.0445911884,
0.3040388227,
-0.7612301111,
-0.5583572388,
0.0067991237,
-0.2693611681,
-0.3426250517,
-0.0801353008,
0.531019032,
0.6855515242,
-0.4022156894,
0.3907735348,
-0.3905678093,
0.0573077202,
-0.1121788323,
-0.0680894181,
0.5686359406,
-0.0577632748,
-0.009834365,
0.1391845345,
-1.0141810179,
-0.4329297543,
0.0314493477,
-0.2102719992,
-0.7534039617,
-0.2529747486,
-0.1001386195,
0.4113514125,
0.3114261329,
-0.5248022079,
0.3341206908,
-0.6723380089,
0.3213422,
0.495873332,
0.4668650031,
0.8233654499,
0.1157908812,
0.4203492999,
-0.1600063145,
0.0801402628,
-0.1016485542,
-0.1982603222,
-0.6811624169,
-0.4711477458,
0.2845506072,
0.3529341817,
-0.6601564288,
0.5594642162,
-0.8001247644,
-0.243381083,
-0.2846588492,
0.3577786386,
0.2604067326,
0.9513522983,
0.2501309514,
-0.1206229627,
-0.5023095012,
-0.9604285359,
0.1493133903,
-0.0488868989,
-0.4348005652,
0.3280187249,
0.3049838841,
-0.2397931069,
1.2020810843,
-0.7381513119,
-0.6109540462,
-0.1525143385,
0.2948883772,
0.1414396614,
0.3168823719,
0.3630397022,
-0.8609517217,
-0.4929584265,
0.2894345224,
-0.9017626047,
-0.2341647744,
-0.2353734821,
-0.3531885147,
0.1353141218,
0.7682164311,
-0.6851426959,
0.2745453417,
0.1283278018,
-0.0243669301,
0.5839369893,
-0.4305313826,
-0.2343022972,
-1.4246023893,
0.2076067924,
0.2850818932,
-0.3451798856,
-0.7262291312,
-0.0840847865,
0.5057147741,
-0.0479354523,
-0.1459497958,
0.7234904766,
-0.8940575123,
-0.1487789005,
-0.1291870773,
0.5134963989,
0.2327673435,
0.3469918966,
0.5253501534,
0.5724239349,
0.6035100222,
-0.5027979016,
0.3179957271,
0.5389603972,
0.0166548695,
0.5883651376,
-0.4432314336,
0.181066215,
-0.0100603448,
0.5781928897,
-0.6531630158,
-0.4776608348,
0.3478321433,
-0.3225906491,
0.7354259491,
-0.7077308297,
-0.6409931183,
-0.2203735113,
-0.2665050328,
-0.0755048022,
0.1801824123,
-0.6713675261,
0.8056839108,
0.3885852695,
-0.3355578482,
-0.3768073916,
-0.5199829936,
0.5103259683,
-0.2465737611,
-0.7417298555,
0.3606840074,
0.3126183152,
-0.3574247658,
-0.0564522073,
-0.19667162,
-0.3281045258,
-0.1190908402,
0.4423325062,
0.6532923579,
0.034479171,
0.2147499472,
0.164384678,
-0.260630101,
0.2559851408,
-0.3061264753,
0.2754530907,
0.0374606587,
0.0344509371,
-0.1196261346,
0.422965765,
0.5063582063,
-0.6044477224,
0.5449134111,
0.6056240797,
-0.4761638939,
-0.2078483999,
-0.5707147121,
-0.0058720624,
-0.4234573543,
0.2664717436,
-0.649005115,
-0.8306113482,
0.4214226604,
-0.1507690996,
0.0854896232,
0.5349133611,
0.1381375939,
0.0967761278,
0.4986684322,
0.5909655094,
-0.2973735929,
0.483456403,
-0.4056527317,
-0.0628007501,
-1.1283285618,
-0.197163865,
-0.4429813027,
0.5135160685,
-0.4488451481,
-0.4021028876,
0.0818207785,
-0.0341077447,
0.0747017413,
0.3650250137,
-0.2311394811,
0.2752518654,
0.283649683,
-0.0172373746,
0.4401177168,
-0.004333565,
0.1707967073,
0.2161654383,
-0.336311996,
-0.4805873036,
0.9213508964,
0.2856638432,
0.8161460161,
-0.0099294232,
0.9550114274,
0.075613685,
0.4667265415,
-0.948339045,
0.3540423512,
-0.117022939,
-0.4798161387,
-0.2628540993,
-0.6544087529,
-0.9686843753,
-0.1069945917,
-0.0633635074,
-0.9046891332,
0.3338181674,
-0.1380772293,
-0.0389317051,
0.0740512908,
-0.8155104518,
0.6866899729,
-0.0110733816,
-0.5188421607,
0.0711811185,
-0.875896275,
0.5122329593,
-0.4835307896,
0.159286499,
0.1037347913,
-0.1060190648,
0.6701248288,
-0.4725909233,
0.7941826582,
-0.0844207481,
-0.6100318432,
0.0187833849,
-0.0015855553,
0.8123312593,
0.2488861084,
-0.2630137503,
0.0508931391,
-0.1069873646,
-0.1227919981,
-0.6547791958,
0.7435341477,
-0.3833215237,
-0.5238690972,
-0.2805933952,
-0.6829379201,
-0.495973736,
0.5123274326,
-0.1007722691,
0.7584818006,
-0.3065271378,
-0.1500188857,
0.5340170264,
0.0171141997,
0.4404385388,
0.4216367304,
-0.2565732896,
-0.4839722812,
0.6910224557,
-0.1790162623,
0.4699187577,
0.5840221047,
0.0894166008,
-0.591719985,
-0.3445415199,
-0.2217685431,
0.4141046703,
-0.7000789046,
0.0034326338,
-0.8625724316,
-0.2902959883,
-0.5369467139,
0.0139898686,
-0.0730112046,
-0.4657854438,
-0.3374049962,
-0.149605602,
0.3938622773,
0.6366248727,
-0.0544816889,
0.1072177887,
-1.0087845325,
0.6491588354,
0.2569949627,
0.1840587556,
-0.2358125299,
-0.6035460234,
-0.1975931376,
-0.1650843471,
0.2001535892,
-0.6739108562,
0.3841634393,
0.4209083021,
0.3482385576,
0.54129076,
0.0802033767,
0.7333860993,
-0.5441265702,
0.4605492353,
0.0387325734,
-0.579618454,
0.6169128418,
-0.7040712237,
0.1043962836,
0.5818244219,
0.2532474697,
-0.4557424188,
-0.6081504822,
-0.7738776207,
-0.9055375457,
0.8677204251,
0.2599023879,
0.0163042191,
-0.0829982013,
0.5245482326,
0.1304534227,
-0.1167809963,
-0.4961845875,
-0.050480891,
0.0942296907,
-0.1300608665,
-0.139287591,
-0.3122433424,
-0.0890793428,
-0.0840108544,
0.7214306593,
-0.1301451474,
-0.0351974666,
0.3518243432,
-0.2513566315,
-0.0081164725,
0.3273068964,
0.1857061088,
0.8865553737,
-0.8013792038,
0.1267323494,
-0.009371181,
-0.4243066609,
-0.1725723892,
0.7704722881,
-0.0494956672,
0.0497103222,
0.5267007947,
0.4085275531,
0.1545373499,
-0.2283544838,
0.5333285928,
-0.2935654819,
-0.2230947614,
-0.6094594002,
-0.1298896521,
0.3380453885,
0.0215720069,
0.4205695689,
-0.3892533481,
-0.0885963812,
-0.4287074506,
0.4741699696,
0.3349810541,
-0.3900746405,
-0.0177012514,
0.5552470088,
0.2866628766,
-0.1832191646,
0.5879722834,
-0.2281754762,
-0.2047766149,
0.4053988755,
0.502377212,
0.7485482097,
0.0740454644,
0.0858673975,
0.4764459133,
0.163201496,
0.0194521286,
-0.3171913028,
-0.2238367051,
-0.4971373379,
-0.6336791515,
-0.5653153658,
-0.3780704737,
0.2718373835,
-0.81508708,
0.3627161682,
-0.216590941,
0.1768911481,
0.2970458567,
0.1426707953,
-0.4243372977,
0.2185112238,
0.2622134686,
1.0768311024,
-0.650716126,
1.2954741716,
0.5789632201,
-0.7959689498,
-0.7730395794,
0.2918179929,
-0.301217109,
-0.4742768705,
0.8479298353,
0.2233095914,
-0.2196650505,
0.1547214985,
-0.2603355348,
-0.455735296,
0.9720617533,
0.2481737882,
-0.6714199185,
-0.3196273148,
0.1997578293,
0.5966235995,
-0.4167936444,
0.3819443285,
0.6473660469,
0.5265214443,
0.0780121014,
-0.6943662167,
0.2590718567,
-0.288592428,
-0.1942429692,
0.5099979043,
-0.2719856501,
0.0800160021,
0.1873844266,
-0.2905732393,
-0.1476146728,
0.7758587599,
-0.1979903877,
0.2449230254,
0.6161766648,
0.485529393,
0.7243891954,
0.0960627049,
1.1688373089,
-0.2566845715,
0.2546357512,
1.7351286411,
-0.3693393171,
0.6377022862,
0.5696558356,
-0.0397662036,
0.3305199742,
0.722868681,
-0.0665829182,
0.2228952646,
-0.0320825204,
-0.4358206391,
-0.2788265944,
-0.1723160595,
-0.2761152387,
0.2787390053,
0.6127578616,
-0.5053162575,
-0.4574448764,
-0.4159016609,
0.2740483284,
-0.1067988798,
-0.1507413983,
1.0610644817,
0.2818299532,
-0.6676215529,
0.4850694239,
-0.2763928473,
0.4419089556,
-0.8505802155,
-0.182908237,
-0.3311034441,
0.0014993539,
-0.3174242377,
-0.7548391819,
0.118466191,
0.0793482736,
-0.0853579268,
0.0928558335,
1.0707589388,
-0.605211556,
-0.559582293,
0.6016937494,
0.6363726258,
0.034237057,
-0.2054593265,
-0.3887105584,
-0.4527780712,
-0.0961652249,
-0.1708519012,
0.3065651357,
0.756755054,
-0.1242167279,
0.4850044847,
0.8619142175,
0.1533409208,
-0.1542202085,
0.4853156507,
1.1576180458,
-0.5209044218,
-0.2116392255,
-0.7354394794,
0.3162910938,
-0.8065376878,
-0.0469557457,
0.7097745538,
0.6886531711,
0.5275560021,
0.0404995121,
0.9618520737,
-0.2897173762,
0.3892092109,
-0.3857896924,
0.5174862146,
-0.4131834805,
0.3195708096,
-0.5117317438,
-1.0358093977,
-0.4808722436,
0.1189632565,
-0.7581621408,
-0.3377175927,
0.827229917,
0.9624785185,
-0.5178269744,
-0.201038599,
0.1089623794,
0.1656717062,
0.5460925698,
0.4398572445,
0.9300690889,
-0.1180830151,
0.8186221719,
-0.3437165022,
-0.3308721781,
0.124651663,
-0.9937488437,
-1.0867682695,
-0.6016123295,
-0.3292877674,
-0.2596410513,
0.0046743043,
0.6724776626,
0.5573654175,
-0.4130229056,
0.0874716416,
-0.1959205568,
-0.0903252661,
0.196352616,
-0.2853264809,
0.7592920065,
-0.4853247404,
-0.8429210782,
0.5715256929,
0.2822478116,
-0.1013986692,
-0.0339918248,
-0.0679388419,
-0.4880399704,
-0.2886487544,
0.5234758854,
0.2830783427,
-0.373388797,
-0.2580369413,
-0.4805375934,
-0.130166918,
0.2161758095,
0.5394746065,
-0.463956058,
0.4945299625,
0.3116082251,
0.5509547591,
0.8231276274,
0.2341398299,
0.8676720858,
-0.9533590674,
0.0621094182,
0.0164340269,
0.5139538646,
0.4713683426,
-0.5360704064,
0.9147292972,
0.0039844965,
-0.4602363706,
-0.5564149618,
0.2004738152,
-1.1855435371,
-0.098421216,
1.5001623631,
-0.3828270435,
-0.3019527793,
-0.3273169994,
-0.4671757817,
0.4928120673,
-0.5019286871,
0.6422601342,
0.3940730393,
-0.0174047258,
-0.1313224733,
-0.6577861905,
0.5634405017,
0.0350674428,
-1.1311179399,
0.5101512671,
0.8521785736,
0.2229971439,
0.1281952858,
0.5351384282,
-0.2575383484,
0.0533402748,
-0.1685181111,
0.0553281419,
-0.282620132,
0.0436481237,
-0.1749805063,
0.0437478498,
0.1510031223,
-0.0711373687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07311v1
|
Do large language models and humans have similar behaviors in causal inference with script knowledge?
| 2023-11-13T13:05:15 | 2023-11-13T13:05:15 |
Xudong Hong, Margarita Ryzhova, Daniel Adrian Biondi, Vera Demberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.0
|
Recently, large pre-trained language models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior
language understanding abilities, including zero-shot causal reasoning.
However, it is unclear to what extent their capabilities are similar to human
ones. We here study the processing of an event $B$ in a script-based story,
which causally depends on a previous event $A$. In our manipulation, event $A$
is stated, negated, or omitted in an earlier section of the text. We first
conducted a self-paced reading experiment, which showed that humans exhibit
significantly longer reading times when causal conflicts exist ($\neg A
\rightarrow B$) than under logical conditions ($A \rightarrow B$). However,
reading times remain similar when cause A is not explicitly mentioned,
indicating that humans can easily infer event B from their script knowledge. We
then tested a variety of LLMs on the same data to check to what extent the
models replicate human behavior. Our experiments show that 1) only recent LLMs,
like GPT-3 or Vicuna, correlate with human behavior in the $\neg A \rightarrow
B$ condition. 2) Despite this correlation, all models still fail to predict
that $nil \rightarrow B$ is less surprising than $\neg A \rightarrow B$,
indicating that LLMs still have difficulties integrating script knowledge. Our
code and collected data set are available at
https://github.com/tony-hong/causal-script.
|
[
0.0590143502,
-0.8232432604,
1.172540307,
0.3111349642,
0.0109084463,
-0.2376555949,
-0.2332998961,
-0.7652637959,
0.1174668446,
0.6551706791,
-0.7049224973,
-0.4063003957,
-0.5092999339,
0.141513437,
-0.575856626,
0.7279066443,
0.0504671261,
0.0729466751,
-0.0217112359,
0.072311312,
-0.4097760618,
-0.7426986098,
-0.6224009395,
-0.7208560705,
0.9238783121,
0.1058890298,
0.6061042547,
0.6393557191,
0.5113064647,
0.2741896808,
0.1774266362,
-0.2256041169,
-0.4284699857,
0.0998726338,
-0.5828999281,
-0.5539403558,
-0.2956806123,
0.2075871229,
0.4387873709,
0.7424360514,
-0.1203170791,
0.0214792639,
-0.1846253425,
0.2209603935,
-0.4965865016,
0.0294767749,
-0.5069502592,
-0.0964864865,
-0.0277876314,
-0.2445050031,
-0.570815742,
-0.215181753,
0.2540131807,
-0.4792376161,
0.3315068781,
0.324486047,
0.9452825189,
0.3614805341,
-0.64809829,
-0.194803223,
-0.8523309231,
0.7365855575,
-0.8809195161,
0.1249985397,
0.6094979048,
0.0761892274,
-0.3466929495,
-0.5850564837,
-1.0948352814,
-0.4512239993,
-0.3446386755,
-0.004777364,
-0.1369443238,
0.0719608068,
0.6715821624,
-0.2655706406,
-0.6544674635,
0.5745750666,
-0.349373728,
-0.3652709723,
0.4985611141,
0.4424714446,
0.4021033645,
-0.3726396263,
-0.361626476,
0.0358232297,
-0.8171153069,
-0.0631416664,
0.3657393456,
-0.1413746178,
-0.1778272688,
0.5479165912,
-0.135776788,
0.815623939,
-0.0843888074,
-0.0998271778,
-0.0499191843,
-0.2313066572,
-0.5148461461,
-0.0052385107,
0.7492476702,
0.4215441048,
0.5794185996,
-0.2268681824,
0.0493227802,
0.3112144172,
0.1405388564,
-0.6315007806,
-0.1590254307,
0.0321783759,
-0.466532439,
-0.016912993,
-0.0223134197,
-0.3831242919,
-0.7003555894,
-0.569262445,
0.6411739588,
-0.286137104,
-0.0822798535,
0.3239792585,
-0.1404694468,
0.6166181564,
0.4799848199,
-0.8020067215,
0.1363038272,
0.6865087152,
0.6454072595,
-0.1103251576,
-0.813744247,
-0.6540802121,
0.3204636872,
-0.3126054406,
0.8515942693,
-0.4723117054,
-0.0995176062,
-0.1770797372,
0.0333463624,
-0.3552844226,
-0.2425482273,
0.3437180221,
-0.7135894895,
0.1594467461,
-0.2409127057,
-0.522371769,
-0.2675282061,
-0.0020345508,
-0.3441589773,
0.2600537837,
-0.3104935288,
-0.732771337,
0.6653910875,
-0.1864681244,
-0.5438584089,
-0.4589434862,
-0.2862805426,
-0.2744627595,
-0.0560177676,
-0.0178448595,
0.6468998194,
-0.3996188343,
0.5983040333,
-0.6910327673,
-0.4654156268,
0.4464024007,
-0.4056432247,
0.6741710305,
-0.0852019563,
-0.278139919,
0.2547543347,
-0.6366073489,
-0.4010597169,
0.1802819222,
0.0358880386,
-0.2944612205,
0.2048998624,
-0.2870496511,
0.5529477596,
0.1141742989,
-0.5499303937,
0.296264112,
-0.122258611,
0.1632796824,
0.8292446733,
0.2936254144,
0.3750041425,
-0.4332211316,
0.2986878753,
-0.0051320037,
0.0093424562,
-0.3270778358,
-0.2491093725,
-0.7793855071,
-0.0253244303,
-0.3849224746,
0.4600024223,
-0.4296630919,
0.0925183818,
-0.0747798458,
-0.2550874949,
0.0059630722,
0.0333108157,
0.4621089399,
0.719778955,
0.2736005783,
-0.1312019229,
-0.4972440898,
-0.7900770903,
-0.482545495,
-0.4017816782,
-0.2337153256,
0.141223833,
0.3803656399,
-0.238338545,
0.9852054715,
-0.6421966553,
-0.1711069494,
-0.2943367958,
0.4973852634,
0.5281870365,
0.2852585316,
0.5667995214,
-0.3754586279,
-0.2349496186,
-0.0737746581,
-0.9077373147,
-0.4825378358,
-0.4071267843,
-0.0801469982,
0.5053051114,
0.9133985043,
-0.5831894279,
0.6008499265,
0.4183096886,
-0.770907104,
0.8482952714,
-0.4742564261,
0.1761787534,
-0.7528491616,
0.1068303436,
0.0390300825,
-0.0085633546,
-0.6356497407,
-0.3917940259,
0.156404689,
0.2966053188,
-0.4767889977,
0.6704368591,
-0.3116591871,
-0.3385678232,
-0.3041494489,
0.1606805474,
-0.1769764721,
0.6994743347,
0.3640093803,
0.4614866376,
0.4904846251,
-0.790486753,
0.0495955199,
0.0596408173,
-0.4070406258,
0.5488740802,
-0.7584356666,
0.0614708215,
-0.3722765446,
0.2757053077,
-0.7274158001,
-0.4691986144,
0.0868905336,
-0.3537585139,
0.119185999,
-0.222682789,
-0.8000325561,
-0.1693333983,
0.084665373,
-0.0560672432,
0.5629731417,
-0.3415921032,
0.3919714391,
-0.0179051775,
-0.1685066521,
-0.5030195713,
-0.7495170236,
0.113033317,
-0.3566702306,
-0.5002787709,
-0.0655492097,
0.1077757701,
-0.503451407,
-0.0874545947,
-0.2016645819,
-0.1823157966,
-0.0491828583,
0.3957538605,
0.4953653514,
-0.1681438535,
0.1727027446,
-0.1652145386,
-0.096276246,
0.1899245232,
-0.198585555,
0.4987223148,
0.3065011203,
-0.5452958345,
-0.6453531981,
0.0456315391,
0.7394529581,
-0.040150214,
1.0324261189,
0.5770111084,
-0.1866065413,
0.1660293788,
-0.7109529972,
-0.3434773386,
-0.3474322259,
0.0565026663,
-0.201945737,
-0.9052770734,
0.7936120033,
0.2676320672,
-0.2637965381,
0.4720205367,
0.5625977516,
-0.2308313549,
0.9455776811,
0.4464288652,
-0.2153717279,
0.6264597178,
0.0009006005,
0.0145692313,
-0.742492497,
-0.1080458313,
-0.5425370336,
-0.1745178849,
-0.435734421,
-0.2744094431,
0.089266859,
0.1339507401,
-0.6884853244,
0.3294281363,
0.2905170321,
0.5952501297,
0.2917235494,
-0.0103965253,
0.5111780167,
-0.3334980011,
-0.0029683113,
0.1005551443,
-0.5595222712,
-0.3528838754,
1.0472511053,
0.0481756702,
1.139064312,
0.2885060906,
0.4672940969,
0.2163871229,
0.4787064493,
-0.2043031305,
0.4390816092,
0.0178556722,
-0.5987892151,
-0.3945471942,
-0.4500819147,
-1.2956552505,
0.2512181699,
-0.2234459221,
-1.3237725496,
0.1886179298,
0.0532238223,
-0.3584192991,
0.1098933294,
-1.02914083,
0.8843332529,
-0.0630005449,
-0.5824337006,
-0.549448967,
-0.9272673726,
0.5545629263,
-0.1619357914,
0.1732763648,
-0.3152249157,
0.2821053565,
0.6115381718,
-0.4187935889,
1.1073496342,
0.0351358131,
-0.0787678063,
0.1987774372,
0.3114367723,
0.4933416843,
0.0000042698,
-0.0534470193,
0.0809672028,
-0.0662872717,
-0.4213407636,
-0.7969210744,
0.7989266515,
-0.8719186187,
-0.7974296212,
-0.5247153044,
-0.3517333269,
0.0475000404,
0.2314999998,
-0.0832381472,
0.5729162693,
-0.036056716,
-0.1557876915,
0.3790439367,
-0.3033213019,
0.6861510873,
1.2316195965,
-0.3911287189,
0.0474435017,
0.5449986458,
-0.1093820333,
0.5202932954,
0.5235291123,
0.3101135194,
-0.3279829323,
-0.3332395852,
-0.1668217778,
0.5299192071,
-0.5031661391,
-0.0342428759,
-0.8551140428,
0.0215256065,
-0.3090347648,
-0.3039466441,
0.1499024779,
-0.1453757286,
-0.2499440312,
-0.0883255228,
0.3812875748,
0.945184648,
-0.0877243578,
0.4653912485,
-0.7436385751,
0.4503688216,
0.3619227707,
0.2559622526,
0.255659163,
-0.5754669905,
-0.1386420429,
-0.2447090596,
-0.0564871281,
-0.9697063565,
0.3925724626,
-0.09943863,
0.5100615025,
0.4642839134,
-0.0424654372,
0.7236777544,
-0.4840180278,
0.6815165281,
0.1016091481,
-0.9184498787,
0.4544589221,
-0.751183629,
0.4436016381,
0.3108200133,
0.3236186504,
-0.8074498773,
-0.601318121,
-0.587615788,
-0.4264174998,
1.0988456011,
0.1894531548,
-0.1901220679,
-0.1058861539,
0.3158582151,
0.0409000032,
0.0283554122,
-0.6342650056,
-0.0476063453,
0.3610482514,
0.2891910672,
-0.4475210607,
-0.1323824972,
0.3948231637,
-0.1887476742,
0.2540438473,
0.1191830635,
-0.006305703,
0.3844569623,
-0.4705323577,
-0.1967063695,
0.1412250102,
0.7187635899,
0.8380488157,
-0.4491090178,
0.3155644536,
0.173415944,
-0.2894436121,
0.1203652099,
-0.0453714542,
0.0006471094,
-0.4291939735,
0.954900682,
0.7698815465,
0.4705041349,
-0.7214201689,
0.4888032377,
-0.2215316445,
0.0947057754,
-0.2448692322,
0.1393943131,
0.0329472013,
0.4127871096,
0.1831986457,
0.1070385799,
-0.0651128367,
-0.9070852995,
0.2255239487,
0.0911497623,
-0.1985426396,
-0.4546580911,
0.8102807999,
0.001403513,
-0.3114020526,
0.6170600653,
-0.3194685578,
-0.5147923827,
0.7552342415,
0.6852668524,
0.7767275572,
-0.0754348338,
0.1297549009,
0.4454302788,
0.2243474573,
-0.1494484842,
0.0603915788,
0.0441854559,
-0.8183036447,
-1.0037220716,
-0.6567076445,
-0.3631674945,
0.0358160511,
-0.4378036261,
0.4511980116,
-0.294259131,
0.104819268,
-0.001334019,
-0.1052030697,
-0.8522349,
0.0220766645,
-0.0116959494,
0.6020598412,
-0.9056880474,
1.0139231682,
0.4420906901,
-0.5919760466,
-0.8782618046,
0.2845339477,
0.0943985954,
-0.6792102456,
0.8593545556,
0.0723872408,
-0.2058795989,
-0.1088322625,
-0.2782216668,
-0.8819086552,
1.0756999254,
0.3689730465,
-0.4503333271,
0.0299376734,
-0.1537126601,
0.9240293503,
-0.0804856494,
0.3102891743,
0.7913621068,
0.4538972676,
0.1293251067,
-1.0769646168,
0.0663189888,
0.1588847935,
-0.3713461459,
0.2306047529,
-0.4650569558,
0.740139842,
-0.5998198986,
-0.2633005381,
0.0271229949,
0.5162123442,
0.099509865,
0.6647481322,
0.3180696368,
0.3428767622,
0.5873771906,
0.3266257942,
1.3640415668,
-0.0122648403,
0.3496178389,
1.2818719149,
-0.5746458173,
0.6777518988,
0.3201616108,
-0.1993378699,
0.6883280873,
0.3506001234,
0.446577251,
0.2596118152,
0.106700249,
-0.0863807946,
-0.4937431514,
0.0385109857,
0.0209123734,
0.6140486002,
0.2503165901,
-0.2976270616,
-0.3152208924,
-0.1997610331,
0.2772800624,
0.0144779384,
-0.2380277961,
0.7921293974,
0.0847755522,
-0.9199481606,
0.2204387486,
-0.0221443586,
0.4667702913,
-0.7692155838,
0.1482987255,
-0.1334913224,
0.1318865567,
-0.0516487807,
-0.8781883717,
0.398418963,
0.0147838825,
-0.2144670337,
-0.2098622322,
0.739340663,
-0.3872123361,
-0.1865685284,
0.4284742773,
0.6202891469,
0.2352220863,
-0.0483620018,
0.003922848,
-0.0741904229,
-0.0909248888,
-0.091452904,
0.4172610044,
0.3498674929,
-0.3832776546,
0.6957031488,
0.7710652351,
0.2044158727,
0.0931299329,
0.379668355,
0.3937483132,
-0.9841663241,
-0.3657677472,
-1.2187381983,
0.0747681782,
-0.1227594838,
-0.1859950721,
0.7301860452,
0.2584586143,
0.6119007468,
-0.2047801018,
0.4577937722,
0.1372623295,
0.471857816,
-0.7028055191,
0.7253214717,
-0.2920168638,
0.1890690327,
-0.3743803799,
-0.835772872,
-0.4903334081,
0.5564857721,
-0.7660284042,
-0.1913777143,
0.8870747089,
0.7186265588,
0.0791962817,
-0.1252805144,
0.5533269048,
0.4874790311,
0.3546263278,
0.5710963011,
1.0315026045,
0.2996324003,
0.3063264489,
0.2144929618,
-0.1789016277,
-0.2784860432,
-0.9369472861,
-1.1257150173,
-0.5595117807,
-0.1346870959,
-0.055029612,
0.0344948694,
0.8871914148,
0.4829933941,
-0.4564083815,
-0.1380071193,
-0.1937036961,
0.5125080943,
-0.0338578597,
-0.1754127741,
0.3641745746,
-0.2691450417,
-0.4815462828,
0.0992234945,
0.4420101941,
0.0599109158,
-0.1717558354,
-0.0367950834,
-0.3187202513,
0.2764685452,
0.6803227067,
0.3660948873,
-0.7382420301,
-0.7004023194,
-0.0295874737,
-0.1096568108,
-0.2801516056,
1.1734383106,
-0.9539001584,
0.3426761329,
0.4994763136,
0.2572467923,
0.7269211411,
-0.2500489652,
0.6932783127,
-0.4972051382,
0.2011140883,
-0.0368470959,
0.5650221109,
0.056914717,
-0.3145504296,
0.3553472459,
0.2975204289,
-0.7497753501,
-0.478182584,
0.4880098701,
-0.9406741261,
-0.1856563985,
1.24830091,
-0.0159767643,
-0.1413771808,
-0.1708197892,
-0.3574649692,
0.2552772462,
-0.1702297628,
0.8118277788,
0.7775614858,
-0.6135550141,
0.0156464055,
-0.577681303,
0.2374431342,
0.3039284945,
-0.727563262,
0.1672160029,
0.6468139887,
0.2376860231,
-0.0918978155,
0.7191867232,
0.1319396496,
0.3285059333,
-0.0177885741,
-0.064686738,
0.0859327689,
-0.2858025432,
-0.2932112813,
-0.224040091,
0.011378414,
0.236195907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07296v1
|
BIDRN: A Method of Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Network for Sentiment Analysis
| 2023-11-13T12:36:53 | 2023-11-13T12:36:53 |
Dr. D Muthusankar, Dr. P Kaladevi, Dr. V R Sadasivam, R Praveen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Text mining research has grown in importance in recent years due to the
tremendous increase in the volume of unstructured textual data. This has
resulted in immense potential as well as obstacles in the sector, which may be
efficiently addressed with adequate analytical and study methods. Deep
Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Networks are used in this study to analyze
sentiment. The method is categorized as sentiment polarity analysis because it
may generate a dataset with sentiment labels. This dataset can be used to train
and evaluate sentiment analysis models capable of extracting impartial
opinions. This paper describes the Sentiment Analysis-Deep Bidirectional
Recurrent Neural Networks (SA-BDRNN) Scheme, which seeks to overcome the
challenges and maximize the potential of text mining in the context of Big
Data. The current study proposes a SA-DBRNN Scheme that attempts to give a
systematic framework for sentiment analysis in the context of student input on
institution choice. The purpose of this study is to compare the effectiveness
of the proposed SA- DBRNN Scheme to existing frameworks to establish a robust
deep neural network that might serve as an adequate classification model in the
field of sentiment analysis.
|
[
-0.2935681939,
-0.5906018615,
0.1966919452,
0.1568123251,
-0.591170907,
0.0608575009,
-0.4393167198,
0.2111208439,
0.1038082093,
0.1501304656,
-0.594468236,
-0.6950106025,
-0.4906583726,
0.2506121397,
-0.1353356838,
1.2463451624,
0.0936924592,
0.5137386918,
-0.1878230721,
-0.2907842696,
-0.4178770781,
-0.7492290139,
-0.5963586569,
-0.272470057,
1.0246157646,
0.5861749649,
0.4127354026,
-0.3206965625,
0.9835531712,
0.2857492566,
-0.5307033062,
-0.054457739,
-0.3262934685,
0.3579722345,
-0.1783467233,
-0.2299022973,
-0.2722275257,
0.1433023512,
0.6178601384,
0.6050780416,
-0.3788606524,
0.1890874356,
0.0111381346,
1.0149462223,
-0.3673882484,
0.1446329653,
-0.2732567489,
0.2054467648,
-0.2959955335,
0.243038848,
-0.1600821912,
-0.5632872581,
0.4449851513,
0.2907350063,
0.3913459182,
-0.2659230828,
0.7785890698,
-0.0460890606,
-0.2349490821,
-0.2069446892,
-0.5026710033,
0.9331202507,
-1.0708590746,
0.2465865761,
-0.205471769,
0.2865047753,
0.2923640907,
-0.5587155223,
-0.691034615,
-0.1663246155,
0.0224741623,
0.6340505481,
0.2628523409,
0.2029396743,
-0.0084964698,
0.688295722,
-0.5817388892,
-0.0226365384,
-0.273603946,
0.2084848881,
0.5337743163,
0.1382912546,
-0.1592758447,
-0.8343779445,
-0.7283934355,
-0.1951512843,
-0.3076334894,
-0.151509285,
0.4491195083,
0.7052862048,
0.0735611916,
0.6305618286,
-0.0399500318,
0.5982291102,
0.0127684744,
0.3610281646,
0.3081870973,
-0.325979501,
-0.524295032,
0.5588254333,
0.9654732347,
0.254521668,
-0.1037211642,
0.1384450495,
-0.2198129147,
0.0395874009,
0.3580216169,
-0.9176970124,
-0.0037287588,
0.2531363666,
-0.9044162631,
-0.9663994312,
0.1343147606,
-1.0837455988,
-0.4055273533,
-0.6137262583,
0.0867656395,
-0.1556464583,
-0.5501928926,
0.0099985152,
0.1246229932,
0.4562112987,
0.0833327398,
-0.3292967081,
-0.0027219416,
0.762349546,
1.1045900583,
-0.2794255316,
-0.2243367732,
-0.0252790768,
-0.3540381789,
-0.108681418,
0.289444685,
-0.4064388573,
-0.5021978021,
0.0388556123,
-0.2653949559,
-0.2017050982,
-0.1744037271,
0.7862553596,
-0.8568354249,
0.5450050235,
-0.2740835547,
-0.3567112684,
-0.7180671692,
0.484693855,
-0.5538549423,
0.7517737746,
-0.0026166171,
-1.0741641521,
0.1847434342,
-0.5837204456,
-0.6667306423,
-0.0495236665,
0.0688221008,
-0.6404188871,
0.1416558772,
0.0098098293,
0.6271397471,
-0.4206393361,
0.4986905158,
-0.3120906651,
-0.2886230946,
0.6282194853,
-0.7328292727,
0.9228442907,
0.3509588838,
-0.4733053744,
0.0909350887,
-0.4711686075,
-0.1773680151,
-0.245321244,
-0.4715036154,
-0.3509597182,
-0.1693677455,
0.187721014,
0.2235577255,
0.3259285688,
-0.7598090768,
0.0615600459,
-0.778521657,
0.4115898013,
0.9233642817,
-0.1094693318,
0.5037714839,
-0.0320296213,
0.4655162692,
0.398472935,
0.0024068714,
0.2662144303,
-0.1645805985,
-0.7804453373,
-0.2120176405,
0.5992211103,
0.5721642971,
-0.4883339405,
0.4388893843,
-0.161861062,
-0.0808838606,
-0.6354272962,
0.0336467512,
0.1791983247,
0.7090750337,
0.1697948277,
-0.2692574561,
-0.7755293846,
-0.7451501489,
-0.1017131805,
-0.1058748066,
0.4344670177,
0.5226035118,
0.3268116713,
-0.5083862543,
0.7488166094,
-0.2293616831,
-0.3530475795,
-0.4604917765,
0.4502756596,
0.6665213704,
0.1692519039,
0.1035359576,
-1.1235359907,
-0.385294199,
0.1167404205,
-0.802092135,
0.2792782485,
-0.0395741016,
-0.1484352052,
0.4538400173,
0.1810739785,
-0.6495052576,
0.1925888062,
0.2609779537,
-0.0904460475,
0.5361972451,
0.1064453721,
0.0252943989,
-1.2187633514,
0.2789675295,
0.113429144,
-0.1111174226,
-0.2379375547,
-0.0420747027,
-0.144786194,
-0.3954025805,
-0.1775704026,
0.1131592318,
0.0117973015,
0.1273632944,
-0.2885585725,
0.0497562736,
0.1439108551,
0.3049890995,
0.1064418107,
0.541459322,
0.4091689587,
-0.2583547235,
0.7725138664,
0.3965712786,
-0.1626629978,
0.7528235912,
-0.6106401086,
0.1330252588,
-0.300059855,
0.0187968649,
-1.0019376278,
0.2171807885,
0.2979856133,
-0.6002004743,
0.5184332728,
-0.2473524809,
0.0370724611,
-0.6470037103,
-0.303003341,
0.28713727,
0.1747562885,
-0.5747457743,
0.5729553699,
-0.1338672936,
-0.4398482144,
-0.9138730764,
-0.6431663036,
0.4732079208,
-0.2579233944,
-0.3775007427,
0.015131793,
0.0259778127,
-0.2220689803,
-0.0437690876,
0.1100315824,
0.1053742915,
-0.1747247577,
0.3212656379,
0.6940565705,
-0.5012426376,
0.0233612172,
0.0320633724,
-0.1640036553,
0.3297070265,
-0.30870381,
0.3808425069,
-0.5876574516,
0.1129700691,
-0.5258241892,
0.2117839754,
0.8841438293,
-0.2141545564,
0.5984740257,
0.3536669314,
0.0949537158,
-0.2458867878,
-0.4252333045,
-0.0329715237,
-0.4741432071,
0.1862331927,
-0.0190429669,
-0.452671051,
0.0201482251,
-0.1560756266,
-0.1797657758,
-0.0045757359,
0.7552783489,
-0.4651283324,
0.6627864242,
0.1415206641,
-0.5076645017,
0.360188216,
-0.4113385677,
0.4637006223,
-0.7809842229,
-0.264516592,
-0.2868985832,
-0.5943246484,
-0.1646378785,
-0.148015976,
-0.0833566785,
-0.2612826824,
-0.4721222222,
-0.1650481373,
-0.5225986242,
-0.0290368851,
0.5996887088,
0.3432498574,
-0.1121179014,
0.1775704622,
-0.3797866404,
-0.0192281771,
-0.541339457,
-0.2524678111,
0.947068274,
0.250003159,
0.5618115664,
0.0583744571,
0.7743197083,
0.6346468329,
0.235744074,
-1.2886241674,
0.6676615477,
-0.496801883,
-0.4037558138,
-0.3164509833,
-0.7289388776,
-0.6228408813,
0.247237578,
0.0346029028,
0.2732423544,
0.6104670167,
-0.4869891703,
-0.2606182098,
0.3685304523,
-0.3031697869,
0.6421533823,
-0.3945533633,
-0.3839215338,
-0.2236337066,
-0.6517671347,
0.1504797339,
0.2365426719,
-0.1005049497,
0.2997710109,
0.4769718647,
0.947994411,
-0.4579457939,
0.8688073754,
-0.5198737383,
0.1645852029,
0.3770362139,
0.1875436753,
0.420696944,
0.1519230008,
-0.5821083784,
0.3787479997,
-0.3131568134,
-0.2273054421,
-0.416667074,
0.8993160725,
-0.7874575257,
-0.3160359263,
-0.784913063,
-0.4984275699,
-0.0946824849,
0.1893173605,
0.0444636792,
0.5754836798,
-0.2918784022,
0.4233953357,
0.7501115203,
0.1254309416,
0.7066221237,
0.2336979955,
0.0767268687,
-0.8868144155,
0.9193012118,
0.0528450385,
-0.2817935944,
0.2276310176,
0.6018895507,
-0.4038958848,
-0.447698772,
-0.6434600949,
0.2196035832,
-0.4481792152,
-0.5354298353,
-0.1258624196,
-0.4655120969,
-0.3234024644,
-0.2037517577,
-0.1907571405,
-0.2111594975,
-0.2909068763,
-0.4350639284,
0.357827425,
0.644064188,
-0.0352224559,
0.2961733341,
-0.6349568963,
0.0542332642,
0.5386927724,
0.3376153111,
0.2776984572,
-0.3783973157,
-0.063247554,
0.3135406077,
0.0208944418,
-0.5800385475,
0.4079229534,
-0.0393226147,
0.2595180571,
0.696203351,
0.0330438092,
0.1227785572,
-0.155373767,
0.5755739212,
0.4476349354,
-0.733371377,
0.5611401796,
-0.4253979623,
-0.0891790763,
0.9220451713,
0.3542618454,
-0.5597266555,
0.3189179599,
-0.5718564391,
-0.7430916429,
0.6977078915,
0.131459102,
0.2103411555,
0.1885837466,
0.5816918612,
0.1921985149,
0.6414768696,
-0.5445373654,
-0.3560489416,
-0.6716812253,
-0.6792285442,
-0.1514485031,
-0.5963394046,
-0.210797742,
-0.2830175459,
0.6636514664,
0.2234879732,
0.0192764271,
0.3732397258,
-0.0001645046,
0.0735495687,
0.4005112946,
0.2495378703,
0.4536960721,
-0.5250965953,
-0.0195504464,
0.1962080747,
-0.850802958,
0.2622142732,
0.0889906362,
-0.4444946945,
0.1970669478,
-0.0855197683,
0.7378951907,
0.0897615552,
-0.1047976166,
0.9487537146,
-0.231863603,
-0.2622740567,
-0.2747278512,
-0.394390583,
-0.1561769247,
0.0821140632,
0.1366725117,
0.2103146464,
0.1998792887,
-0.4027866125,
0.0206504371,
0.3563173711,
-0.9810445905,
-0.1272417754,
0.1347943395,
0.3965776265,
-0.2092555463,
0.974843204,
0.0710700676,
-0.710793972,
0.6153440475,
0.4601920545,
1.0596889257,
-0.1478642821,
0.7968861461,
0.3568733633,
-0.1074929684,
0.0499318205,
0.4177857041,
-0.0117771616,
-0.6235020757,
-0.2803708315,
-0.9855683446,
-0.5031678081,
-0.0269958582,
-0.9476469755,
0.1281918883,
-0.4781684875,
-0.2276130766,
-0.3088442981,
0.0394206978,
-0.4718265235,
0.5403838158,
0.3720647693,
0.5986459851,
-0.6370406747,
0.5966861248,
0.9578064084,
-0.427482754,
-0.527595818,
-0.2069518715,
-0.2272625864,
-0.2790180147,
0.9501283169,
0.1859050691,
-0.3567848206,
-0.1446971893,
-0.4645986259,
-0.4005585313,
0.9233697653,
-0.4797761142,
-0.848824501,
0.0927941725,
0.1253169179,
0.5632331371,
-0.2676794827,
-0.1019178703,
0.4695436358,
0.520776391,
0.1878669709,
-0.1208601594,
0.0470452756,
-0.1985889077,
0.0411989801,
0.1446062475,
-0.751781106,
1.0175231695,
0.0004766404,
0.0640804097,
-0.3047473133,
0.7806110978,
0.0493797287,
0.6716752052,
0.4609296024,
0.8022521734,
0.9014880061,
0.1237420887,
0.7020976543,
0.0078206556,
0.5890943408,
0.8899712563,
-0.5981316566,
0.8649895787,
0.3900558054,
-0.2877370715,
1.0286872387,
0.3077236712,
-0.2253649384,
0.7767100334,
0.2154880464,
-0.55341506,
-0.2541623116,
0.1994156539,
-0.3669339716,
0.4083484411,
0.3740204573,
-0.1581777185,
-0.2307507098,
0.5422854424,
-0.0333223604,
-0.0440921709,
-0.6562625766,
0.8348266482,
0.3198672235,
-0.2814551294,
0.0946523845,
-0.0968579575,
0.7468919158,
-0.40849033,
0.1839260757,
-0.4006900489,
0.3826519847,
-0.3762158453,
-0.8466681242,
0.0473725833,
-0.1933102757,
-0.5328295827,
-0.03994352,
1.0978083611,
-0.1556684673,
-0.8496739268,
0.2572520375,
0.4440212548,
-0.085360162,
-0.0153743839,
-0.8267238736,
-0.2862416208,
-0.0549535416,
-0.2839969397,
0.2124186009,
0.5924607515,
0.2853117287,
0.3445355296,
0.7868308425,
0.3882099092,
-0.2349941134,
0.5966631174,
0.8362092972,
-0.9029151201,
-0.4189544618,
-0.8827060461,
0.1331454962,
-0.3114942014,
-0.1499578208,
0.8520297408,
0.5865198374,
0.4321009219,
0.1065609157,
1.0819437504,
-0.0811163336,
0.7929490209,
-0.2656808197,
1.0998706818,
-0.2384950817,
0.1725881398,
-0.2221057415,
-0.7224151492,
-0.2023717165,
0.7733513117,
-0.5895732641,
-0.0211336501,
0.5358894467,
0.7060312033,
-0.1119363979,
0.5143111348,
-0.1142307296,
0.233013764,
-0.078367494,
0.1037300229,
1.0443179607,
-0.4222524762,
0.4768126905,
-0.472528249,
-0.0525572337,
-0.5188807845,
-0.596247375,
-1.1435180902,
-0.4083521366,
-0.2352855951,
-0.756808579,
0.2045161128,
0.6055298448,
0.3280393779,
-1.0375314951,
-0.2442955673,
-0.2866439223,
0.3099921346,
-0.0433531962,
-0.3138467968,
0.7060212493,
-0.5623255968,
-0.2246930152,
0.2656888366,
0.0534324124,
-0.1632688344,
-0.3434507549,
0.0767296031,
-0.245991379,
0.0560400598,
0.8504312634,
-0.1259573251,
-0.1364392787,
-0.0705954656,
0.046109844,
-0.3671540022,
0.0999476165,
1.0322258472,
-0.7149586678,
0.3679460287,
0.6762546301,
0.5650932193,
0.3329696059,
0.3059057295,
0.3855811357,
-0.4839397669,
0.0202259682,
0.6183103323,
0.1461171806,
0.3032314181,
-0.4882570505,
0.1020315364,
0.0815777257,
-0.8248151541,
-0.6871212721,
-0.0372552536,
-1.2769662142,
-0.6099494696,
1.2115098238,
0.0132902218,
-0.3252711296,
-0.1955524385,
-0.6075376272,
0.0959231257,
-0.4289853275,
0.8641380668,
0.4490835369,
0.2284424305,
-0.0273789298,
-0.2098848522,
0.2301516384,
0.5259796381,
-0.3180426955,
0.1788492501,
0.2744522393,
0.056163542,
-0.1606439203,
0.0809709877,
-0.2435615808,
0.1718213558,
-0.3801519871,
0.0900021195,
-0.174822852,
-0.3830570579,
-0.8585036993,
0.3210847676,
-0.1936541647,
-0.3481764495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07277v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07277v2
|
AdaCCD: Adaptive Semantic Contrasts Discovery Based Cross Lingual Adaptation for Code Clone Detection
| 2023-11-13T12:20:48 | 2024-03-06T17:46:50 |
Yangkai Du, Tengfei Ma, Lingfei Wu, Xuhong Zhang, Shouling Ji
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Code Clone Detection, which aims to retrieve functionally similar programs
from large code bases, has been attracting increasing attention. Modern
software often involves a diverse range of programming languages. However,
current code clone detection methods are generally limited to only a few
popular programming languages due to insufficient annotated data as well as
their own model design constraints. To address these issues, we present AdaCCD,
a novel cross-lingual adaptation method that can detect cloned codes in a new
language without annotations in that language. AdaCCD leverages
language-agnostic code representations from pre-trained programming language
models and propose an Adaptively Refined Contrastive Learning framework to
transfer knowledge from resource-rich languages to resource-poor languages. We
evaluate the cross-lingual adaptation results of AdaCCD by constructing a
multilingual code clone detection benchmark consisting of 5 programming
languages. AdaCCD achieves significant improvements over other baselines, and
achieve comparable performance to supervised fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.5072840452,
-0.5251774788,
0.054696884,
0.2572909594,
-0.1917532533,
0.2803886831,
-0.0937374905,
-0.3998907804,
0.3582737744,
0.490595907,
-0.4127842486,
-0.7671914697,
-0.3215043545,
0.0584038831,
-0.3068134189,
0.9967342019,
-0.1327643991,
0.2301786542,
-0.1169617325,
-0.67817837,
-0.3424012363,
-0.3396298587,
-0.5115951896,
0.1198016703,
-0.0322666354,
0.5334079862,
0.6285232306,
0.7068321109,
0.1822198778,
0.308855921,
0.0179730598,
0.2425996512,
-0.4084602594,
-0.1915057003,
-0.2832380235,
-0.3346180916,
-0.1546472609,
-0.4804855585,
0.4220514894,
0.7448228598,
0.0489620492,
-0.0085271448,
0.0083370721,
0.7177513242,
-0.9022784233,
0.1636626422,
-0.7673816085,
0.0334841684,
0.1930792779,
-0.3096925318,
-0.1252111644,
-0.249069944,
-0.0515484549,
-1.0074878931,
0.321972698,
-0.0450792909,
0.5563080907,
0.1079918221,
-0.2894973755,
-0.5627763867,
-0.3053472638,
0.6892406344,
-0.5005892515,
0.2470306307,
-0.0726218522,
-0.001305759,
-0.0541934222,
-0.5795887709,
-0.6839871407,
-0.0596751571,
0.104913868,
-0.1156969368,
-0.2755375206,
-0.4677694738,
0.1525138468,
0.5505710244,
-0.5508271456,
0.0880724639,
-0.2799556255,
-0.486779511,
0.1993237436,
-0.2436463088,
0.7567021251,
0.0521002859,
-0.6347608566,
-0.3163039982,
-0.6269689202,
-0.2189124674,
0.3799964786,
0.1846017092,
-0.3932458162,
-0.0947144181,
-0.265426755,
0.4876015484,
0.1455242485,
0.1766805053,
0.7447738051,
-0.4160208404,
0.0243602153,
0.1570679247,
0.3927137256,
0.4506942332,
0.3330420852,
0.0737433806,
-0.0966754332,
0.2397432625,
-0.0351039059,
-0.6662758589,
-0.7560180426,
-0.1756091267,
-0.4907101393,
-0.2676213384,
0.0589532778,
-0.766212225,
-0.5138132572,
-0.08272551,
0.3611209989,
-0.5789488554,
-0.5393870473,
0.1007794514,
-0.2174876779,
0.3963090479,
0.1688511819,
-0.752233088,
0.2725900412,
0.5016952753,
0.6914976835,
-0.7032568455,
-0.6209970117,
-0.6376876235,
0.1810611784,
-0.5661625862,
0.9131870866,
-0.3880953789,
-0.5135400891,
-0.0206448939,
0.2939037979,
0.1264160722,
-0.9883297682,
0.2733819485,
-0.5921384692,
-0.0473830774,
-0.2558117807,
-0.3294672966,
-0.3363093138,
0.194898665,
-0.8231999278,
0.8506458998,
0.5484271049,
-0.878475666,
0.4767197371,
-0.4827581942,
-0.786231637,
0.0434727184,
-0.1034499928,
-0.3977282941,
-0.1125240028,
0.4607171118,
0.1029173061,
0.2008705437,
-0.2360002846,
-0.5162625909,
-0.3676099181,
0.0525927953,
-0.0334613994,
1.1375690699,
0.5228160024,
-0.3030590713,
0.2890739143,
-0.7603840828,
0.0433535799,
0.0136580514,
-0.1503024995,
-0.6182462573,
-0.3763591647,
0.2489690483,
0.1883947104,
0.1350149363,
-0.458520323,
0.0324862152,
-0.0304547343,
0.1266731769,
0.7759753466,
0.0847514644,
0.5289607048,
-0.4526475966,
0.7159260511,
0.3024249375,
-0.1343877167,
-0.2957673967,
-0.1446091533,
-0.7769036889,
-0.4072339237,
0.1826130748,
0.6506942511,
-1.297721386,
0.4303334355,
-0.3836379349,
-0.0647585616,
-0.707420826,
0.8230079412,
0.6735643148,
0.3072648942,
0.5653804541,
-0.6794365048,
-0.5774771571,
-0.7774215937,
-0.1973330826,
-0.186864838,
0.1380843073,
0.270927608,
0.4355620146,
-0.4293593168,
0.570686698,
-0.4095118046,
-0.5178359747,
-0.3752482831,
-0.0437412784,
-0.2393862009,
0.7834975123,
0.7801403999,
-0.8529815674,
-0.7582898736,
0.4332080185,
-0.5783289671,
-0.5282883048,
-0.2579006851,
-0.1829492301,
0.3863824904,
1.0347207785,
0.0857074633,
0.0707949325,
0.9154459834,
-0.3990119696,
0.5731559992,
-0.3838345706,
0.2412333637,
-1.0467038155,
0.1863138527,
-0.3772075772,
-0.1905730218,
-0.2564683855,
0.4074977338,
0.2704643607,
-0.2156445533,
-0.5854434967,
0.7371665239,
-0.6997320056,
-0.3441535234,
-0.3344941139,
0.035816513,
0.0439262167,
0.5018455982,
0.2087129354,
0.7882815003,
0.9317350984,
-0.4665644169,
0.4837042391,
0.1645946801,
-0.5054193735,
0.7235676646,
-0.3501603305,
-0.0763930157,
0.2201278359,
0.0843826234,
-0.8218511343,
0.1502678096,
0.0761289448,
-0.4256876707,
0.2185367048,
-0.5583817363,
-0.0526600331,
0.1123897806,
-0.3656205237,
0.6786435843,
0.5964779854,
-0.8834807873,
0.4516003132,
0.3239068687,
-0.3816100061,
-0.3211814463,
-0.6900686026,
-0.0007171155,
0.1046429873,
-0.4739675224,
0.2152425498,
-0.0727016628,
-0.1414849609,
0.26775226,
-0.3697683811,
-0.3237853348,
0.2041958123,
-0.1000832394,
0.2563463748,
-0.4031169116,
-0.1303053796,
0.1004306823,
-0.1198403388,
-0.1702448428,
-0.4128527045,
0.3390984535,
-0.1294467747,
-0.666051805,
-0.0292461999,
0.2561871111,
0.4039739668,
-0.312346071,
0.2904121876,
0.9417623281,
-0.0543621965,
-0.6703878045,
-0.4914223552,
0.2668493986,
-0.4492444992,
0.7103328705,
-0.3934698105,
-0.7332858443,
0.6167398095,
-0.0698705688,
-0.250805378,
0.2399335951,
0.4433412552,
0.6135290265,
0.7375633717,
0.9026351571,
-0.2646203041,
0.6491152048,
-0.2427930981,
-0.1832174361,
-0.6450527906,
-0.0509532467,
-0.4099424779,
0.0344055332,
-0.738298595,
-0.7972918153,
0.0966947749,
0.0569093153,
0.0103105344,
0.3663822412,
-0.4623970389,
0.7579981089,
0.4961026311,
0.062166784,
0.586540699,
-0.0892243087,
-0.2261681408,
0.2890752256,
-0.5199270248,
0.0842421278,
0.9828749895,
-0.1947033703,
0.6880729198,
0.0688821375,
0.6387547255,
0.5389251113,
0.1810825169,
-0.4641435742,
0.4350917935,
-0.4039640129,
-0.2018813491,
-0.0633656681,
-0.6034721136,
-0.6268938184,
0.3583602905,
-0.1310883313,
-0.2299857736,
0.4415172935,
0.023432456,
-0.1153465435,
0.4522618949,
-0.9389798045,
1.1865199804,
-0.274931103,
-0.2426683605,
-0.4083435237,
-0.3690824509,
0.2797068655,
-0.2898800671,
0.3597025871,
-0.1394774467,
-0.197797671,
0.5023813248,
-0.5022884607,
0.3704418838,
-0.2807291746,
-0.0292148516,
0.198916018,
0.6313188076,
0.3429598212,
-0.1484728158,
-0.0256228205,
0.0122352913,
0.1367143691,
-0.7854734659,
-0.3002654016,
1.2185105085,
-0.4434278905,
-0.4108676612,
-0.2195430696,
-0.5855637193,
0.0306423195,
0.4252804816,
-0.0080263633,
0.1737450659,
-0.3733881116,
0.0728203431,
0.5591875315,
-0.7225891948,
0.3250399232,
0.4992878735,
-0.2881978154,
-0.2133305073,
1.1918478012,
-0.6608508825,
0.4886170626,
0.1986092776,
-0.1730164737,
0.0864141732,
-0.7064393759,
-0.6935940385,
-0.1768023819,
-0.9763154387,
0.0413207859,
-0.5257589817,
0.1595294476,
-0.3299773037,
-0.5249583125,
-0.3333230019,
-0.3176279962,
-0.0591593944,
0.1564709097,
0.3173792362,
0.3595366776,
-0.070478119,
-0.2102847695,
-0.5705900192,
0.6934265494,
0.206655696,
0.4044058621,
-0.1023493409,
-0.5338673592,
-0.2207645923,
-0.0415667482,
-0.1324720383,
-0.3681263924,
0.4320960641,
0.3519801795,
0.643918395,
0.2021362931,
0.2756024897,
0.6022364497,
-0.2007350326,
0.5703026056,
0.1416094303,
-1.1158181429,
0.312564671,
0.1224142835,
0.501136601,
0.4111411273,
0.3069233894,
-0.4798383117,
-0.2876603603,
-0.2922217548,
-0.6007837653,
0.6114032865,
-0.1561663449,
0.1052765474,
0.0412001945,
-0.0896956399,
0.228081122,
-0.2537368238,
-0.6876806021,
-0.0824530721,
-0.5399985313,
-0.2272689193,
0.0594751276,
0.1340081394,
0.1556143761,
-0.0116551062,
0.4535085559,
-0.5536074042,
-0.1197632551,
0.1472230554,
-0.6316972375,
0.1114655584,
0.1497558802,
0.2914654911,
0.5779008269,
0.1164628491,
0.06973961,
0.3769286871,
-0.4166820347,
-0.0352442823,
0.1774885356,
0.0213054512,
0.0686859488,
0.4544613063,
0.5112906694,
0.3475344479,
-0.9824153185,
0.9000806212,
0.2306274325,
-0.0153843593,
-0.1237012967,
0.1271004081,
0.0076590753,
0.1694567502,
0.2050495297,
0.2944756746,
0.3016106188,
-0.7450597286,
0.5890184641,
0.5173308849,
-0.4938629866,
-0.2910172045,
0.579641223,
0.4316079617,
0.1230789945,
0.467925787,
-0.2905981839,
-0.6921139359,
0.8684889078,
0.4682398438,
0.9066666365,
-0.1569915712,
0.1918578893,
0.081427604,
-0.19517757,
0.0710663944,
0.2381684184,
-0.290083766,
-0.9367036819,
-0.2935552299,
-0.4893342555,
-0.2540053427,
-0.3152993619,
-0.7656244636,
0.5401600599,
-0.5786851048,
0.4620264769,
0.0492821708,
-0.1798499525,
-0.364848882,
-0.1116644144,
0.1057014465,
0.9156318307,
-0.934894383,
1.0843394995,
0.742836833,
-0.2436571717,
-0.25210917,
-0.0098614711,
0.0729513466,
-1.0701987743,
0.4773176312,
-0.0208961554,
-0.2616170943,
-0.0664888844,
-0.2157395333,
-0.5598198175,
0.8344356418,
0.4432965219,
-0.0583351478,
0.3787008822,
-0.3612525761,
0.6351287365,
-0.5102677941,
0.0092442054,
0.3982750773,
0.1823183596,
0.2805786729,
-0.8595754504,
0.2036642432,
-0.4984312057,
0.0780588239,
0.112929754,
-0.3971733749,
0.7339656949,
-0.754288435,
-0.1866417229,
0.3621935844,
0.3232586384,
0.1852082014,
0.0631558672,
0.5536917448,
0.4423324764,
0.383132875,
0.1602736712,
0.8708147407,
-0.615303576,
0.2148334831,
1.0371166468,
-0.5369743705,
0.6262796521,
0.3766669035,
0.0401311964,
0.9347121119,
0.2358773649,
-0.4160571396,
0.6711476445,
0.212906599,
-0.1132204607,
-0.2510307431,
-0.0542303994,
-0.5298388004,
0.2287342548,
0.2015971541,
-0.1857286543,
-0.2429644316,
-0.0237683747,
-0.1707264632,
0.3969170153,
-0.3826059401,
0.7859557271,
-0.1701684296,
-0.6103793979,
0.8732901812,
-0.0667565539,
0.7915407419,
-0.5189409256,
-0.348472029,
-0.394977957,
0.6292370558,
-0.2059212476,
-0.5645833015,
0.2586390674,
-0.2093310952,
-0.0201000329,
-0.1052506119,
0.6449955106,
-0.6982942224,
-0.2808621824,
0.5460406542,
0.3998631537,
-0.1160367727,
0.0810401887,
-0.7293268442,
0.3081994951,
0.3791958988,
0.3445283175,
0.5188150406,
0.7713046074,
-0.16877307,
0.880124867,
0.7947964668,
0.2544560432,
-0.0306969937,
-0.1025301889,
0.8053913713,
-0.5080738664,
-0.7721212506,
-0.4416014552,
-0.0694730729,
0.0155458935,
-0.2865471542,
0.7786234617,
0.7882739305,
1.4746187925,
-0.3550923765,
0.8722978234,
-0.0569460467,
0.4866591394,
-0.7068618536,
0.5407125354,
-0.5106623769,
0.658640027,
-0.4908109605,
-0.7842374444,
-0.3738440275,
0.4726518393,
0.1420422196,
0.0919494927,
0.7169835567,
1.1264185905,
-0.3935534954,
-0.2382935882,
0.2286352962,
0.2005336285,
0.0650162697,
0.7488560081,
0.5332362056,
-0.3234615624,
1.0306386948,
-0.3374832273,
-0.2190904915,
-0.2055295557,
-0.9607014656,
-0.7425626516,
-0.4462338984,
-0.5337114334,
-0.3137583137,
0.1189456061,
0.7093008757,
0.6315525174,
-1.3336100578,
-0.30368945,
0.0012185262,
0.4365188181,
-0.5107117295,
-0.2619444728,
0.6346819401,
-0.407109797,
-0.5922602415,
0.0951264426,
0.2373049259,
0.080112718,
-0.0467346273,
-0.328232646,
-0.1464649737,
-0.3578958511,
0.335991323,
0.6677462459,
-0.4609619379,
-0.1925490201,
-0.2111337483,
-0.0865009278,
0.0484339371,
0.9353466034,
-0.9843295217,
0.6655067801,
0.5348763466,
0.8565917611,
0.2986920476,
-0.0197115168,
0.5530238152,
-0.7924287915,
0.5029063225,
-0.1451648027,
0.4923864007,
0.5494660139,
0.059402056,
0.3195722401,
0.5954473019,
-0.0749062151,
-0.6498388052,
0.2845031917,
-0.9712283015,
-0.7337180972,
1.3060514927,
-0.442922622,
0.0705739632,
-0.5118894577,
-0.3020616472,
-0.0640157238,
-0.3137227595,
0.5963868499,
0.3093419671,
0.2697745562,
-0.0831330866,
-0.1437533647,
0.4968215525,
0.3717467487,
-0.6505826116,
0.259536624,
0.6138940454,
0.6362429857,
0.1143716052,
0.3917326033,
-0.3582013547,
0.7697409391,
0.2842597365,
0.4352242947,
-0.1965145022,
0.0486403219,
-0.4283188283,
-0.1401164085,
0.1579749286,
-0.2393819988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07264v1
|
Danish Foundation Models
| 2023-11-13T12:03:52 | 2023-11-13T12:03:52 |
Kenneth Enevoldsen, Lasse Hansen, Dan S. Nielsen, Rasmus A. F. Egebæk, Søren V. Holm, Martin C. Nielsen, Martin Bernstorff, Rasmus Larsen, Peter B. Jørgensen, Malte Højmark-Bertelsen, Peter B. Vahlstrup, Per Møldrup-Dalum, Kristoffer Nielbo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models, sometimes referred to as foundation models, have
transformed multiple fields of research. However, smaller languages risk
falling behind due to high training costs and small incentives for large
companies to train these models. To combat this, the Danish Foundation Models
project seeks to provide and maintain open, well-documented, and high-quality
foundation models for the Danish language. This is achieved through broad
cooperation with public and private institutions, to ensure high data quality
and applicability of the trained models. We present the motivation of the
project, the current status, and future perspectives.
|
[
-0.5786388516,
-0.4182954729,
0.4269084334,
0.3979781568,
0.0559149645,
-0.0976004973,
-0.4353094995,
-0.6332719326,
0.0010074303,
0.8201877475,
0.0561022349,
-0.2705167532,
-0.5780245066,
0.1475229263,
-0.6951557994,
0.5402540565,
-0.4975992143,
0.2234229445,
-0.2217688709,
-0.1389092803,
-0.4291910231,
-0.6365177035,
-0.7058964968,
-0.3506806195,
0.3483833075,
0.5844739079,
0.725371778,
0.5181431174,
0.4023557603,
0.267852664,
-0.4512658417,
-0.594532907,
-0.8424913883,
-0.04789773,
-0.3578506708,
-0.5119282603,
-0.010964538,
0.1011091247,
0.7894480228,
1.2727360725,
-0.3719836771,
0.1038881093,
-0.0626737773,
0.9250200987,
-0.6154440641,
0.3130006194,
0.101444155,
-0.2264508307,
-0.0845991746,
0.3480314612,
-0.357640326,
-0.430742532,
0.0514878668,
-0.2830759883,
0.3281061947,
-0.1863142699,
0.5790472627,
-0.2635923624,
-0.5894696712,
-0.1738196164,
-0.6182590723,
0.8245735168,
-0.3055024445,
0.7236508727,
0.6412428617,
0.532664001,
-0.4466015399,
-0.4435433745,
-0.2895120382,
-0.2762833238,
-0.0984404534,
-0.2032651603,
0.1629931778,
0.0372759961,
-0.0860834792,
0.6553245783,
-0.3416920006,
0.0562550314,
-0.6925384402,
0.0642613247,
0.7622153759,
0.0102339592,
0.0328647979,
0.2813867629,
-0.1244209781,
-0.2260884941,
-1.1348310709,
0.3649898469,
0.3817869127,
0.2160960138,
-0.4211411476,
0.6880806088,
-0.6212832332,
0.6434601545,
-0.0287434068,
-0.0756809041,
0.0109596141,
-0.1948173195,
-0.4769389331,
0.3333625197,
0.0362354741,
-0.1092640981,
0.3323054612,
-0.0632796586,
-0.4967834651,
0.144226715,
0.0118351895,
-0.6092510223,
-0.077465184,
0.0660318583,
-0.677075386,
-0.5806601644,
0.1335616559,
-0.3758583367,
-0.3533300459,
-0.5091558099,
0.1305094361,
0.1294901371,
-1.0320478678,
0.5112677217,
-0.1914138645,
-0.1230294257,
0.5331123471,
-0.8811921477,
0.4782548845,
0.5981063843,
0.6666734815,
-0.1769262701,
-0.125818193,
-0.2786512971,
0.3196100295,
-0.9335910082,
0.370380044,
-0.420016706,
-0.9341526031,
0.01883463,
0.4550730288,
0.2461978346,
-0.5396156311,
0.1617351025,
-0.2979494035,
0.2102386206,
-0.4260014296,
-0.2961658537,
-0.1776668578,
0.4427614808,
-0.9990212917,
0.8604862094,
0.4519072175,
-0.5296506286,
0.0156627074,
-0.7558323145,
-0.3047991395,
-0.1501226127,
-0.2714261413,
0.0566326864,
0.651448369,
-0.259637624,
0.6539248228,
-0.8719235659,
0.700170517,
-0.1365325302,
-0.3694243133,
-0.064680405,
-0.1953883767,
0.8813750148,
0.0165886786,
-0.2180076092,
0.0741507784,
-0.8421426415,
-0.4896025956,
0.2443175018,
-0.7830821276,
-0.5547279716,
-0.2247508019,
0.3661905825,
0.4283971786,
0.1571033448,
-0.5921632051,
0.0952557176,
-0.69818753,
0.1481672227,
0.7762197256,
-0.1172344163,
0.5829860568,
-0.109596394,
0.8017787337,
-0.0663629845,
0.1700479388,
0.1494861096,
-0.4092522264,
-0.5249072313,
-0.1528173983,
0.446757108,
-0.0368796252,
-0.4911920428,
-0.2906543314,
-0.330051899,
-0.3838929832,
-0.1659662873,
-0.0377244204,
0.2773290575,
0.1294730753,
-0.0062912395,
-0.4087507129,
-0.3719750643,
-1.0353997946,
0.0694905892,
-0.107501246,
0.4110569656,
0.2124232352,
0.6062693,
-0.0303068645,
0.8591121435,
-0.1880319566,
0.1353488714,
-0.1513508856,
0.1204132959,
0.6991805434,
0.7762382627,
0.8997727633,
-1.4022120237,
-0.6658743024,
0.2653257549,
-0.2376830131,
0.3396502137,
0.4650925398,
-0.1317812949,
0.0590577312,
0.6635484099,
-0.7739498019,
0.426443249,
0.9505963922,
-0.506940186,
0.8790585399,
0.3764442205,
0.1969355941,
-1.1579060555,
0.3057408035,
-0.2574553788,
-0.2122437209,
-0.3349728584,
-0.0223191697,
-0.2070818841,
-0.2925995588,
-0.4878576398,
1.0849990845,
-0.7248880863,
-0.0765723363,
-0.1822325438,
-0.4224691391,
-0.1190476641,
-0.1334724277,
0.333791405,
0.650349021,
0.6288555264,
-0.4410012662,
0.5756238699,
0.3093189895,
-0.4464278221,
0.7824316025,
-0.503646791,
-0.4179822206,
-0.0756340027,
0.2029966265,
-0.6317859888,
-0.4655370116,
-0.3789157867,
-0.272934854,
0.787197113,
-0.296207428,
-0.3330961764,
-0.6270074248,
-0.0650093779,
0.0295562502,
0.3446610272,
-0.6303032637,
0.5600243211,
0.3628078103,
-0.3629188538,
-0.8292120695,
-0.7229032516,
0.0969772488,
0.1756688207,
-0.6304317713,
-0.0154492147,
0.0741310939,
-0.5167293549,
0.5363115072,
-0.3749679923,
-0.1340283751,
0.2884526551,
0.3222628534,
-0.3345078826,
-0.7181977034,
0.057186611,
-0.0073553473,
-0.1418260038,
0.1474964172,
-0.2568823397,
0.3810124993,
-0.1025549546,
-0.1889114678,
-0.0251511224,
0.725694716,
0.7300914526,
-0.2250632942,
1.0396929979,
0.0190170538,
-0.7719393969,
-0.1115342826,
-0.6094821095,
-0.051378224,
-0.4922677875,
0.3649942577,
-0.6803062558,
-1.1837861538,
0.1708885729,
-0.3229627013,
-0.0914177224,
0.5067688227,
0.8338312507,
0.0189769827,
1.0149675608,
1.2923485041,
-0.1146661937,
0.2305441797,
-0.3379735649,
-0.0422929041,
-0.3035472035,
-0.1496827155,
-0.6725916266,
0.0577297434,
-0.11905168,
-0.2483539879,
0.0169927478,
0.7407871485,
-0.2864007354,
0.4168729782,
-0.3087203205,
0.4674937129,
0.3835940063,
-0.4803699851,
0.2215257287,
-0.0819719955,
-0.287853688,
0.5323987603,
-0.5963041782,
-0.4878035784,
0.9725068212,
0.5541759729,
1.0217854977,
0.2594215274,
0.689278543,
0.1206337363,
0.7558905482,
-0.2601163983,
0.270214498,
-0.025344003,
-1.2203176022,
-0.4564556181,
-0.3130938411,
-0.7343170047,
-0.003131469,
-0.096881181,
-0.6166161895,
0.8139705062,
0.3054999709,
0.2683864534,
0.0530464575,
-0.4821496904,
0.9465973973,
-0.0176950339,
-0.1945472807,
-0.5732649565,
-0.4165161252,
0.4380462766,
-0.231857717,
0.2976111174,
-0.2765012085,
0.4887987971,
0.6203244328,
-0.3132552505,
0.8519120812,
-0.2775037885,
-0.3629432023,
0.1834402978,
0.2554965615,
0.5073481798,
0.0500313863,
-0.1575113237,
0.041145768,
0.025377892,
-0.4897806942,
0.0593435802,
0.9253724217,
-0.6369583011,
-0.5529563427,
-0.2076285183,
-0.2107141465,
-0.5186265707,
0.2926064134,
0.0284289327,
0.127090171,
-0.8319473863,
0.6828211546,
0.6650524735,
-0.1382564157,
0.1317304224,
0.4510835707,
-0.1637626588,
-0.3756951392,
0.647631824,
-0.1233474389,
0.4451140165,
0.3458649814,
0.2515348494,
-0.182601437,
-0.4566689432,
-0.2221854478,
0.401712507,
-0.8760501742,
-0.1481296718,
-0.5795229673,
0.0540314727,
-0.5714044571,
-0.5745023489,
-0.7114610076,
-0.6682574749,
-0.1902747005,
-0.3006381392,
0.2300606668,
0.9776137471,
-0.229651019,
0.3818339705,
-0.4848974347,
0.3628439605,
0.2521422803,
0.7163728476,
-0.1530745924,
0.1725511849,
-0.5584551692,
-0.0949418247,
0.1346821189,
-0.7792831063,
-0.0275947154,
-0.0492442399,
0.6793926358,
0.3691868782,
-0.2818670273,
0.0999557152,
-0.4626435637,
0.606911242,
0.6762209535,
-0.8471992016,
0.3657901585,
-0.3622045815,
-0.053002812,
0.5383738279,
0.5019527078,
-0.7445074916,
-0.0293634068,
-0.5708600283,
-0.6174888015,
0.7277666926,
-0.0844372436,
0.0089205829,
0.1466660202,
0.2151748389,
0.3003046811,
0.5386064053,
-0.4695008397,
0.0789171755,
-0.22681503,
-0.3817307353,
-0.4450790584,
-0.501254499,
-0.3992375433,
-0.0872568861,
0.8773646951,
-0.0902715027,
0.0251914486,
-0.273853749,
-0.0277468041,
-0.5978577733,
0.2263035476,
0.3803029656,
0.9052678347,
0.1540376097,
-0.0607839748,
-0.1228277832,
-0.5546327233,
0.4778696597,
0.0891493335,
0.2056144923,
-0.0115157031,
0.1738545448,
0.6471940279,
0.283759445,
-0.6879269481,
0.7841714025,
0.1221614704,
-0.2422333807,
-0.295298636,
-0.063790679,
0.6024214625,
0.3313013613,
0.112747319,
-0.3578747213,
-0.067077212,
-0.4203670621,
0.006832717,
0.1601008028,
-0.4509683549,
-0.2808836997,
0.563665688,
0.4061076939,
0.1849855483,
0.3471766114,
0.353083998,
-0.4724545777,
0.7690640092,
0.7339801788,
0.4593873322,
-0.5549867153,
0.2347933799,
0.2030070275,
0.5102487206,
-0.9595466852,
0.6779161096,
0.2603822052,
-0.4905695319,
-0.4986314178,
-1.0142058134,
-0.348559767,
0.2086529434,
-0.4866618514,
0.6042043567,
-0.3404727876,
-0.0705468804,
-0.2520027161,
-0.2493848503,
-0.7301897407,
0.5808663964,
0.3506168723,
1.4966518879,
-0.940988481,
0.8209496737,
0.8542356491,
-0.2642279565,
-0.5331385136,
-0.6338807344,
-0.1614442766,
-0.4768830836,
0.8756707311,
0.1262088418,
-0.1911178529,
0.2053415328,
-0.7182244658,
-1.2305450439,
0.7612894177,
0.4735940397,
-0.723572731,
-0.2710719705,
-0.0586118139,
0.3056747019,
-0.3439713717,
-0.8831936121,
0.3271915615,
0.7323470712,
-0.2973400354,
-1.0951811075,
-0.0262507331,
-0.2948335707,
0.1022751331,
0.6242907643,
-0.2581923902,
0.8894205689,
0.108849369,
-0.158951506,
0.2709958255,
0.507907331,
-0.0013812741,
-0.0478741564,
0.3415004611,
0.5160849094,
0.1783979982,
-0.1565316319,
1.1536147594,
-0.1756692529,
0.5040636063,
0.7332392335,
-0.1228128448,
0.6744721532,
0.5459213257,
-0.0158136319,
0.205840081,
0.6780821085,
-0.0339862257,
0.5561720729,
0.4670261741,
0.0327286199,
-0.2675020993,
-0.1466839015,
-0.6661449671,
0.2685417235,
0.5508609414,
-0.2877675891,
-0.0110508623,
0.3236190975,
-0.1876413375,
0.0694468468,
-0.4272065461,
0.3011778891,
0.2462125719,
-0.2423827201,
0.5792942047,
0.2738611102,
0.2657702267,
-0.6823871732,
-0.194077462,
0.014676312,
0.1539633274,
-0.1198566407,
-0.4791024029,
0.1752069592,
-0.2806894183,
-0.2943896949,
-0.1400128305,
0.5419391394,
-0.4674687684,
-0.5137617588,
0.4175900817,
0.374561578,
0.029257929,
-0.2307383269,
-0.6781902909,
0.0822046474,
-0.4501390159,
-0.6759750247,
0.064181596,
0.4793614447,
-0.5791462064,
0.2519220114,
0.7831059694,
0.2588571012,
-0.1930115372,
-0.0899178609,
0.8921413422,
-0.7279654145,
-0.8395148516,
-0.3533321619,
0.3300031424,
-0.0656322613,
-0.3897822499,
0.4740881622,
0.6842930913,
0.9222880006,
-0.2634106278,
0.7149578929,
-0.1104508415,
0.5154232383,
-0.3080657423,
0.9434944391,
-0.6421849728,
-0.3656953871,
-0.0963519886,
-1.1545071602,
-0.3063350618,
0.5231668949,
-0.1095095649,
-0.0039248317,
0.4296958148,
0.2580419183,
-0.3317835033,
0.2024160475,
0.3453769684,
0.5720927119,
0.3005400598,
0.2872899771,
0.8673750758,
0.1896398962,
0.0089243455,
-0.4108676314,
-0.3034906387,
-0.5284621716,
-0.8672744632,
-1.0554636717,
-0.6194018722,
-0.0923640653,
-0.3995472491,
0.4173774719,
0.6875213385,
0.8907530904,
-1.2369873524,
-0.6041365266,
-0.2458017915,
-0.0214716326,
-0.2074892968,
-0.1660055965,
0.4289096296,
0.3428280056,
-0.4280737638,
0.5311488509,
0.2935584784,
0.3330698609,
-0.6120353937,
-0.218230024,
-0.2684856951,
0.1246232241,
0.5785874724,
0.5604526401,
-0.3581911623,
0.0189160947,
-0.0598747693,
-0.2529873252,
-0.2022557706,
0.9659909606,
-0.3979306221,
0.2536237538,
0.4854016006,
0.8026698232,
0.7379740477,
-0.3614641428,
1.0094331503,
-0.6691542268,
0.3171902895,
0.2329131216,
0.489867717,
0.6339512467,
-0.4715062976,
0.9184952378,
0.2592433691,
-0.1088871658,
-1.1062637568,
0.1978363693,
-0.3597745299,
-0.5139793754,
1.0550829172,
0.00530429,
-0.3263570964,
-0.1674521118,
-0.1276956648,
-0.0601644441,
0.0289616417,
0.4029900134,
1.1892848015,
0.1521872431,
0.0627599806,
-0.6815293431,
0.5970737338,
-0.0874180645,
-0.5765351653,
0.1301162541,
0.5008481741,
0.2857428491,
0.4022637606,
0.6991012692,
-0.3943820894,
0.5294184089,
-0.0379616879,
0.3689995408,
0.1587203145,
-0.7168610692,
-0.4275627136,
0.2853521705,
0.3525343537,
0.3270296156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07237v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07237v2
|
In Search of the Long-Tail: Systematic Generation of Long-Tail Inferential Knowledge via Logical Rule Guided Search
| 2023-11-13T10:56:59 | 2024-02-27T22:28:52 |
Huihan Li, Yuting Ning, Zeyi Liao, Siyuan Wang, Xiang Lorraine Li, Ximing Lu, Wenting Zhao, Faeze Brahman, Yejin Choi, Xiang Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
State-of-the-art LLMs outperform humans on reasoning tasks such as Natural
Language Inference. Recent works evaluating LLMs note a marked performance drop
on input data from the low-probability distribution, i.e., the longtail.
Therefore, we focus on systematically generating statements involving long-tail
inferential knowledge for more effective evaluation of LLMs in the reasoning
space. We first propose a novel framework Logic-Induced- Knowledge-Search
(LINK) that generates factually correct and long-tail knowledge statements
grounded on symbolic rule templates; LINK effectively generates data in the
longtail distribution that zero-shot prompted LLMs are unable to reach, and
outperforms zero-shot GPT4 on factual correctness by 5%. We further use the
data generated by LINK to construct a dataset Logic-Induced-Long-Tail (LINT)
that can be used to evaluate downstream models on the long-tail distribution;
LINT contains 108K knowledge statements spanning four domains. We use LINT to
test LLMs on an entailment classification task and find that model performances
drop by as high as 5% in the long-tail distribution compared to head
distribution. Our work shows the utility of evaluating models in the long-tail
distribution, and calls for more research on generating evaluation data in the
long-tail distribution.
|
[
-0.1938308626,
-0.7254450917,
0.9933453202,
0.007340176,
-0.3098830283,
-0.1523080617,
-0.1966391206,
-0.5048499107,
0.1300028563,
0.7819898725,
-0.8061925173,
-0.5613036752,
-0.4395374954,
0.2409330457,
-0.6438110471,
0.7832964659,
0.1675523371,
-0.0363848917,
-0.2676136196,
0.2078499794,
-0.356167227,
-0.5142781138,
-0.3662048578,
-0.5651250482,
0.5677037239,
0.0735243484,
0.5147494674,
0.5750923157,
0.6416354775,
0.0463826321,
-0.237586692,
0.2576496303,
-0.5882504582,
0.1205874756,
-0.6036023498,
-0.4999806285,
-0.2140594423,
-0.1153746694,
0.6621282697,
0.7082502246,
-0.2803079188,
0.1280796081,
-0.0754584596,
1.0074785948,
-0.765711844,
0.1911868304,
-0.6967722774,
-0.1219594926,
-0.5287345648,
-0.4121676981,
-0.4988287091,
-0.480448395,
0.2348788679,
-0.4795928299,
0.1051489413,
0.3599123955,
0.6416386366,
0.3588936925,
-0.6022390127,
-0.5617979765,
-0.4932778478,
0.8207722902,
-0.8254252672,
0.5259487629,
0.105669044,
0.3737906814,
-0.6027652025,
-0.7262500525,
-0.5235354304,
-0.196563229,
0.0859176964,
0.0951633379,
-0.19159545,
0.1833420247,
0.4541288018,
-0.0020292415,
-0.4644043744,
-0.032032229,
-0.3084116578,
0.0607914254,
0.7698097229,
0.2143775672,
-0.2276760787,
-0.3222627938,
-0.3977557123,
-0.0292720385,
-1.1200660467,
0.0463368893,
0.4435856342,
0.2477721721,
0.5063735247,
0.7445652485,
-0.5973680019,
0.8026009798,
0.1235224307,
-0.445713222,
0.0492765978,
-0.2256370783,
-0.293812871,
0.2236619443,
0.6268794537,
0.5243521929,
0.3322644234,
-0.0623665936,
-0.4963004291,
0.0368971676,
-0.0500747785,
-0.9318623543,
0.0911309198,
-0.1563961208,
-0.4538835287,
-0.3087963164,
0.2404655218,
-0.729925096,
-0.5395499468,
-0.4479002655,
0.3701235354,
-0.402785182,
-0.0757024884,
0.7168912292,
-0.4122547805,
0.3536748886,
0.3020702899,
-0.4598177075,
0.5466939211,
0.743439734,
0.4339298606,
-0.3391577303,
-0.0587333515,
-0.5624176264,
0.3398540318,
-0.6156238914,
0.6358216405,
-0.4197640419,
-0.1589782983,
0.1361271441,
-0.1136405766,
-0.0293114986,
-0.807504952,
0.6704206467,
-0.6699092388,
-0.0213995669,
-0.3727025092,
-0.8977290988,
-0.3876156509,
0.0702976212,
-0.506260097,
0.8589596152,
-0.1315713972,
-0.9157815576,
0.6068280935,
-0.9015666246,
-0.4790782928,
-0.0318897739,
-0.2755860686,
-0.1439491957,
-0.0600638352,
0.1499777585,
0.6401970387,
-0.6731790304,
0.4590037465,
-0.3631203473,
-0.5227733254,
0.125323832,
-0.3248850107,
0.7923420668,
0.0035101713,
-0.5717637539,
-0.1067687497,
-0.6894803643,
-0.2069117129,
0.4159950614,
-0.0460343026,
-0.5374081731,
0.4513018131,
-0.6502203345,
0.0357242599,
0.0554451495,
-0.509021461,
0.1407550573,
-0.4147514701,
0.2289102674,
0.7430079579,
0.2993362248,
0.3435254991,
-0.3017214239,
0.2429798543,
0.1560043097,
0.1549538672,
-0.0574238077,
-0.3501538634,
-0.8683730364,
-0.0093463659,
-0.0082402667,
0.4844099283,
-0.6056950092,
0.5047090054,
-0.3497579694,
-0.3099373579,
-0.0839269683,
0.2644605935,
0.0237071943,
0.7454981804,
0.2217511982,
-0.060782399,
-0.3246713281,
-0.9569897652,
-0.2795986831,
-0.0477046631,
0.1174000725,
-0.0464038104,
0.6561341882,
-0.3185865581,
1.1596034765,
-0.6731266379,
-0.0860543549,
-0.2097191364,
-0.0419312902,
0.5446094275,
-0.0708313808,
0.3981996179,
-0.4339652956,
-0.0272713061,
-0.2497157305,
-0.9415448904,
0.0655872822,
0.0559240021,
-0.3368050456,
0.2220716327,
0.3974612951,
-0.8786296248,
0.5541391969,
0.0046189851,
-0.2601480484,
0.6190068722,
0.1192758754,
-0.1497567892,
-0.7103489041,
-0.0655368194,
0.2321679741,
-0.1046843752,
-0.2167461663,
0.1671792716,
0.1396248937,
0.1112599075,
-0.3042035401,
0.4848279953,
-0.3498170078,
0.120070897,
-0.0515298285,
0.1939997524,
-0.0626617298,
0.1520213634,
0.1397846788,
0.5549278855,
0.4887030423,
-0.7828816175,
0.4550987184,
-0.0945848897,
-0.5434815884,
0.2646797001,
-0.4805034697,
-0.0417519361,
-0.2891659141,
0.5006570816,
-0.4588865936,
-0.2402533293,
0.1767315865,
0.0316700973,
0.2430788279,
-0.0595489666,
-0.9367148876,
-0.422156781,
-0.4602041543,
0.2080691606,
0.9231824279,
-0.7125583291,
0.2586883008,
0.0072268653,
0.0380428843,
-0.6381473541,
-0.3943804502,
-0.0773635134,
-0.4709066749,
-0.987544179,
-0.0121988757,
0.1289325356,
-0.4276944995,
-0.1536606252,
-0.2249583006,
0.3976645768,
-0.1313103884,
0.0193610676,
0.0320272706,
-0.2426240444,
0.3757632375,
-0.030896971,
0.1130293757,
0.6865679026,
-0.4318706989,
0.2794897854,
-0.0564478561,
-0.6504814625,
-0.0490679517,
0.1752213985,
0.1406413913,
-0.1424503177,
0.4065383077,
0.2271757573,
-0.3040393293,
-0.7028220892,
-0.6908562779,
-0.5628887415,
-0.4190103412,
0.2504365146,
-0.15986453,
-0.6809722185,
0.183789745,
-0.4166970849,
0.0213956572,
0.7483551502,
0.1481651217,
-0.2257342637,
0.9125719666,
0.688741684,
0.1960821748,
0.091901809,
-0.2912908196,
0.3790415227,
-0.5496032834,
-0.2129450291,
-0.0902729481,
0.1176173761,
-0.5669252872,
-0.4500962198,
0.502163589,
0.2783872187,
-0.3734194338,
-0.0771080405,
-0.4173975885,
0.3796239793,
0.6395959258,
0.344371736,
0.452091217,
-0.0316810124,
-0.078450717,
0.0041955682,
-0.7020331025,
-0.4494618773,
1.273075223,
0.379910171,
1.1079187393,
0.0211089738,
1.0116443634,
0.2377150804,
0.1459900588,
-0.8933103681,
0.7155997157,
-0.0061541381,
-0.4600235224,
-0.321568042,
-0.431463629,
-0.699128449,
-0.2278132588,
-0.0452060066,
-0.3625867665,
-0.1408308595,
-0.0726668239,
-0.1573801488,
0.3688330948,
-0.3656775355,
0.4826484323,
-0.5476716161,
-0.3545278907,
-0.325865835,
-0.7602770925,
0.9014865756,
-0.3332372606,
0.1296933144,
-0.2516636252,
0.0776828155,
1.0316784382,
-0.4568800926,
0.7453373671,
-0.1651423723,
-0.1737954766,
0.4909642339,
0.1571870148,
0.8527731299,
0.0734827593,
-0.1656615436,
-0.0184181966,
-0.0588755384,
-0.1146512181,
-0.8095452189,
0.3319921494,
-0.279887408,
-0.9238405824,
-0.6298279166,
-0.2901747525,
-0.1035299674,
0.2886915505,
0.14656654,
0.1989161968,
0.0145792812,
0.2166627496,
0.96800524,
-0.1409335732,
0.1330168694,
0.2799326181,
-0.4689564407,
-0.0598727837,
0.7775796652,
0.0999994949,
0.3065780997,
0.2900702953,
0.3945324719,
-0.5794980526,
-0.4481331706,
-0.2257235795,
0.5337807536,
-1.0701439381,
-0.3504056931,
-0.2545937598,
-0.4467016757,
-0.0801897049,
-0.0597980767,
-0.1665729731,
-0.1258116812,
-0.1487594843,
-0.0407587476,
0.6279210448,
1.1389429569,
0.0748931393,
0.1534842402,
-0.3889119923,
0.2426400781,
0.327403754,
0.2247958928,
-0.1699263304,
-0.3254458308,
-0.1301730275,
0.148165822,
-0.4117665887,
-0.8491973281,
0.2198379785,
0.0371214151,
0.5362134576,
0.4747309387,
0.2725835443,
0.684828043,
-0.5072180033,
0.6375168562,
0.4524990916,
-0.6731634736,
0.6238085032,
-0.5309462547,
-0.0373898707,
0.0980120301,
0.3213237226,
-0.1444602907,
-0.2613483369,
-0.5901179314,
-0.7291408181,
0.346445322,
0.0213646553,
-0.1603894979,
-0.217102766,
0.3038643599,
0.1717760712,
0.2941980958,
-0.4445982277,
-0.1474373043,
-0.0670974776,
-0.0772210211,
0.1265095025,
-0.2713404596,
-0.260294795,
-0.3656544983,
0.5670400262,
-0.2943513393,
0.1636921018,
0.2536959052,
0.0493456796,
-0.0904960632,
0.1796777099,
0.4118004739,
1.0311682224,
-0.5200358629,
0.0861307532,
0.0881190971,
-0.005953609,
-0.0924792513,
0.1157980785,
-0.4368387759,
0.2269052863,
0.3040603399,
0.5930082798,
0.1773699671,
-0.7917520404,
0.6025999188,
0.1645390689,
-0.4338632226,
-0.6212183237,
0.0750313401,
0.3322644532,
0.1994507164,
0.7118822932,
-0.1072208732,
0.3443045318,
-0.4785550833,
0.3436051309,
0.6380577087,
0.1831475198,
0.0422145203,
0.5183206201,
0.126533404,
0.1427718103,
0.7006704211,
-0.3029294014,
-0.4765131176,
0.4430931807,
0.488711983,
0.724914372,
0.4333971441,
-0.0871058181,
0.2668993771,
0.2160500735,
-0.39490816,
0.2298057824,
0.081481874,
-0.4068932235,
-0.6488693953,
-0.712133646,
-0.3923190832,
0.1272327304,
-0.4757416546,
0.5750759244,
-0.2970956862,
-0.2403130382,
-0.2262879908,
-0.0227851812,
-0.7798798084,
0.0631919354,
0.0428275466,
1.1872080564,
-0.4117451906,
0.6278471351,
0.2578077614,
-0.3603927195,
-0.7715052366,
0.0721339732,
0.0237413589,
-0.7476579547,
1.0716477633,
0.1125816181,
-0.4182998836,
-0.1655874103,
-0.8744570613,
-0.9272314906,
1.310377717,
0.4953270555,
-0.6237753034,
-0.2290720791,
0.1352282166,
0.2657239139,
-0.3553827405,
0.1030722782,
0.6148824096,
0.4686377048,
0.3260355592,
-0.8648458719,
0.1396656036,
0.0991614312,
-0.1994878799,
0.3781763911,
-0.5167883635,
0.6732681394,
-0.3526510596,
-0.1434472054,
-0.133602336,
0.666007936,
0.7707166672,
0.4343686998,
0.3952272534,
0.4197715223,
0.798617959,
0.038504608,
0.9214605689,
-0.2579458654,
0.2432326823,
0.8498775363,
-0.5015567541,
1.0286198854,
0.6441078782,
-0.0065645487,
0.5447604656,
0.690867722,
0.1563408673,
0.4877320826,
0.6516341567,
-0.2575344443,
-0.2965978682,
-0.0983898938,
-0.2556414902,
0.1623093486,
0.428961426,
-0.3666617572,
-0.4063949287,
-0.5209559202,
0.0088010971,
0.0068520876,
-0.2462390363,
0.5841606855,
0.291449666,
-0.6418455839,
0.7264896035,
-0.1535550803,
1.0135434866,
-0.7614597082,
-0.2927241027,
-0.1831090152,
0.1879885048,
-0.284680903,
-0.9194002748,
0.0670791492,
-0.0331827737,
-0.0048746704,
-0.149465099,
0.9222615361,
-0.1464373469,
-0.6124264598,
0.5715489388,
0.6898280978,
0.2353523374,
-0.0907201096,
-0.4214309156,
-0.2875676155,
-0.0469411723,
-0.4604369402,
0.3442368507,
0.6381885409,
-0.2976624072,
0.9101806879,
0.7254678011,
0.2108892649,
0.2839085162,
0.0383342989,
0.7987803221,
-0.9079740047,
-0.1562690288,
-0.8857493997,
0.2291255444,
-0.1606079638,
0.041705709,
0.6289288998,
0.5439735651,
0.9092662334,
-0.1115383729,
0.9346549511,
0.0435628667,
0.6902013421,
-0.8176664114,
0.6214817762,
-0.6391211748,
0.1250216961,
-0.0733436495,
-0.8755074143,
-0.0954885781,
0.3568481207,
-0.2009980679,
-0.046702303,
0.9153158665,
0.7679871917,
-0.1823138148,
-0.0999544337,
0.3364269733,
-0.1496927887,
0.3809676766,
0.6381348968,
0.9455348849,
-0.2851042151,
0.3938340545,
-0.4171620011,
0.0858748332,
-0.2037826926,
-1.1888136864,
-0.8898789883,
-0.2776043415,
0.0612362884,
-0.2453770787,
0.3027357161,
0.8624747396,
0.5918702483,
-0.3458519578,
-0.5087565184,
-0.1606178731,
0.1993735284,
-0.0380889624,
-0.269500345,
0.3723100722,
-0.4317138791,
-0.2897901237,
0.5044646263,
0.1866763681,
-0.1797658503,
-0.2532632947,
-0.3923279345,
-0.0748354495,
0.091649808,
0.8177347183,
-0.0244563818,
-0.9109340906,
-0.2871464193,
0.2881375551,
-0.024432905,
-0.2803050578,
0.6811397076,
-0.8027036786,
0.205068171,
0.3231233954,
0.6503103375,
0.4860071242,
-0.018746227,
0.7060736418,
-0.4177273214,
-0.0693767592,
0.3355168104,
0.3917918205,
0.0852595493,
-0.2912881374,
0.8879594803,
0.4192340076,
-0.5300894976,
-0.8089456558,
0.1187723875,
-0.96402812,
-0.0384223387,
1.4723087549,
0.3157928586,
-0.3051272333,
0.2609395683,
-0.0144361695,
0.2058641613,
-0.5897966027,
0.3622301221,
0.5952984095,
-0.5411432981,
0.0356160812,
-0.8018548489,
0.6481088996,
0.2831231058,
-0.6614049077,
0.0489824526,
0.488522917,
0.5621536374,
0.0657918006,
0.3324261606,
0.102025643,
0.2021459788,
-0.2390582711,
0.0006414226,
-0.0055011194,
-0.1873473078,
-0.0503359325,
0.0030584761,
0.2829542458,
0.1281851083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07230v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07230v2
|
How are Prompts Different in Terms of Sensitivity?
| 2023-11-13T10:52:01 | 2024-06-20T22:41:35 |
Sheng Lu, Hendrik Schuff, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning (ICL) has become one of the most popular learning
paradigms. While there is a growing body of literature focusing on prompt
engineering, there is a lack of systematic analysis comparing the effects of
prompts across different models and tasks. To address this gap, we present a
comprehensive prompt analysis based on the sensitivity of a function. Our
analysis reveals that sensitivity is an unsupervised proxy for model
performance, as it exhibits a strong negative correlation with accuracy. We use
gradient-based saliency scores to empirically demonstrate how different prompts
affect the relevance of input tokens to the output, resulting in different
levels of sensitivity. Furthermore, we introduce sensitivity-aware decoding
which incorporates sensitivity estimation as a penalty term in the standard
greedy decoding. We show that this approach is particularly helpful when
information in the input is scarce. Our work provides a fresh perspective on
the analysis of prompts, and contributes to a better understanding of the
mechanism of ICL.
|
[
-0.4664641321,
-0.6879147887,
0.5147845149,
0.2892013788,
-0.0982505903,
-0.3033818901,
-0.0664515048,
-0.3173176944,
-0.4542527497,
-0.24735412,
-0.7844520807,
-0.2299733758,
-0.3848159611,
0.4535589218,
-0.0654353574,
1.0533967018,
0.3666278422,
0.2205763608,
-0.5132588744,
-0.2011582106,
-0.7614362836,
-0.4826999903,
-0.6117063165,
0.0606827848,
0.7895901203,
0.5162733197,
0.1209810078,
0.2828454971,
0.4413478673,
0.1485054642,
-0.3983330131,
-0.3690518141,
-0.2036413699,
0.1757659614,
-0.1521866024,
-0.3658455908,
0.1014390364,
-0.0307501964,
0.5968703032,
0.7711145282,
0.4498037994,
0.4481739998,
0.7330177426,
0.4426413178,
-0.9820828438,
0.1636499465,
-0.5131748915,
0.0472033992,
-0.0801938549,
-0.3086841404,
-0.7197259665,
-0.0638368279,
0.3805981278,
-0.4698475599,
0.3527654111,
-0.1364758164,
0.511241138,
0.5334740877,
-0.4288221002,
-0.4451637864,
-0.1521893293,
0.9553776383,
-0.4816638529,
0.2410536557,
0.1100258455,
0.2627252936,
0.0386603698,
-0.707418859,
-0.0704409704,
-0.4207838774,
-0.1375851035,
0.0085631367,
-0.0238338429,
0.1109573245,
0.7777744532,
0.0055303075,
-0.3727353215,
0.0751969442,
-0.1678775251,
-0.3108431995,
0.2324924767,
0.220149368,
0.2323909253,
-0.1291134059,
-0.6726107001,
-0.1324516535,
-0.6304985285,
0.961094141,
0.222177878,
0.7322244644,
-0.2026486099,
0.1596253067,
-0.025879683,
0.9636970758,
0.3233733773,
-0.149154231,
-0.1295864433,
-0.1414899975,
-0.0798199251,
0.167338118,
0.3749376535,
0.4596759975,
0.0206716564,
-0.0162085537,
-0.2880496085,
-0.0622286983,
0.1271875501,
-0.7310406566,
0.0291916206,
-0.0160385463,
-0.518856287,
-0.1190200299,
0.0626641959,
-0.7513464093,
-0.450570792,
-0.4701741934,
0.3646205664,
-0.2123008072,
0.2755941451,
-0.1255376339,
-0.2288486809,
0.4102408886,
0.3550009727,
-0.8201863766,
0.0585024543,
0.4203040004,
0.9206261039,
-0.3530707359,
-0.171470657,
-1.1757346392,
-0.3177551627,
-0.0094061615,
0.679125011,
-0.5475798845,
-0.6118785739,
-0.0809576213,
-0.2192924172,
-0.1461080164,
-0.3065562546,
0.6783862114,
-0.6086652875,
0.1223542094,
-0.7798069715,
-0.4070266187,
-0.206115976,
0.0187255144,
-0.6925445199,
0.8428480625,
0.4046356678,
-0.8890718818,
0.563965857,
-0.9171696305,
-0.4679340422,
0.213066265,
-0.0028442896,
0.1048609465,
0.3302583396,
0.1601391882,
0.3090878129,
-0.2295075506,
0.2385390997,
-0.2580555677,
-0.6267548203,
0.6625818014,
-0.5312458277,
1.1143527031,
0.3318422139,
-0.2758048773,
0.2480737567,
-0.6072508693,
-0.1365572363,
-0.5333839059,
-0.4398199916,
-0.2294525206,
-0.1444809586,
0.0825512931,
0.3132870793,
0.0577492639,
-0.5364562273,
0.0189530719,
-0.2951064408,
0.4330622554,
0.9107607007,
0.1228347495,
0.466784358,
-0.0960265398,
0.6240261793,
0.1265801042,
0.4037443101,
-0.5603647232,
-0.4423229694,
-0.3370334506,
-0.4110183716,
0.2117935866,
0.415443033,
-0.5639787912,
-0.0068929284,
0.2190738916,
0.031208463,
-0.4052512944,
-0.3228945136,
0.4169606268,
1.2747490406,
0.4552162588,
-0.063178651,
-0.1419008225,
-0.5434247255,
-0.4112790227,
-0.0490906015,
-0.145759508,
0.55746907,
0.2449185699,
0.2650662363,
0.9976834059,
-0.2718181014,
0.0372013599,
0.0082754632,
-0.0178417601,
0.3309381902,
0.4716112018,
0.8489738107,
-0.8930593133,
-0.8332899809,
-0.2635605335,
-0.6352987289,
-0.2904496491,
-0.0639928281,
0.0773620009,
0.0692459866,
0.891561687,
-0.3409059942,
0.6387135386,
-0.0668890551,
-0.4922524989,
0.5809767842,
0.1472473592,
0.2127486616,
-0.5777719021,
0.3579269946,
0.2219578922,
0.1382494867,
-0.6451949477,
0.3504780829,
0.3697013557,
-0.1833046079,
-0.9253373742,
0.8977456689,
-0.2134301364,
-0.1177485734,
-0.1049360186,
-0.0303716753,
0.0922856182,
0.5935119987,
-0.3715839982,
1.2165220976,
0.7278285027,
-0.9346387386,
0.1982313395,
0.0323532745,
-0.2428188026,
0.6252954006,
-0.8700867891,
-0.0624935552,
-0.2848967314,
-0.0785129145,
-1.2135423422,
-0.2148939073,
0.4738366008,
-0.5728815794,
0.4409538507,
-0.2046714723,
-0.0905628502,
-0.1738207191,
-0.4398773313,
0.6304137707,
0.4147080779,
-0.6898092031,
0.3329488635,
-0.2056954503,
-0.1532880664,
-0.9309211373,
-0.4631439745,
-0.247015655,
-0.5741163492,
-0.2077450901,
0.2624083459,
-0.6647431254,
-0.4186326861,
-0.1810699403,
0.0025620584,
0.0283984579,
0.741653204,
0.3232999742,
0.2241125107,
-0.1430396736,
0.1339423209,
-0.0278920718,
-0.147475481,
0.3967607915,
-0.228237167,
0.1502831578,
-0.0949277133,
-0.2955253422,
-0.6351516247,
0.4631216824,
0.5579961538,
-0.2778223157,
0.4012130797,
0.2635624111,
-0.2050293833,
-0.1916397661,
0.0350635201,
-0.5359154344,
-0.5395560861,
0.0462721735,
-0.592017591,
-0.7049821615,
0.7432634234,
0.2425044477,
-0.072768271,
0.306861043,
0.2713221312,
-0.1257252395,
1.1303017139,
0.937895298,
0.0517939702,
0.8510341048,
0.206656307,
0.0008189999,
-0.8554698825,
-0.3268499076,
-0.8324353695,
-0.3625071049,
-0.2895735204,
0.2187443972,
0.5381753445,
0.0470643416,
-0.3512724042,
-0.2595626116,
-0.4844436049,
0.6037350297,
0.7321524024,
0.1281475276,
-0.1510363072,
-0.1167589948,
-0.2798073888,
-0.1106589437,
-0.8102945089,
-0.2824635506,
0.7598130703,
0.092359826,
0.5833114386,
0.0577675514,
0.0019615493,
0.4299906492,
0.3432069719,
-0.9791514874,
0.4202129841,
-0.0293754339,
-0.4164988399,
-0.2520743906,
-0.1858835518,
-0.7397941351,
-0.0789602548,
0.0562877804,
-0.8887886405,
0.4894031584,
0.2176942378,
-0.8078309298,
-0.0484200865,
-0.8130475879,
0.8551456332,
-0.0686442107,
-0.6353262663,
0.3433809578,
-1.0313948393,
0.0339330025,
0.095257856,
-0.0873367563,
0.0802570656,
-0.0045276131,
0.3700746596,
0.0279721301,
1.0919964314,
-0.3655552566,
0.0110040996,
0.2836717963,
0.1489883512,
0.1803595126,
0.3546288013,
-0.4705571532,
-0.1067411155,
-0.1479916275,
-0.4883090556,
-0.6369127631,
0.6468316317,
-0.4996983409,
-0.5250176787,
-0.2916895449,
-0.7795423269,
-0.1197877079,
0.0202522315,
0.7416642308,
0.9105603695,
0.1022175699,
0.0379398726,
0.9726397395,
-0.2547247708,
0.9598792791,
0.4583140612,
0.2880290151,
0.1277749985,
0.5719147921,
0.1485891789,
0.1361958534,
0.6031296849,
0.1278441399,
-0.472016722,
-0.2813887894,
-0.6042704582,
-0.1902728528,
-1.1396414042,
-0.3969504535,
-0.3735534847,
0.0211026166,
-0.2995294333,
-0.6071878076,
0.3003809154,
0.0620291345,
-0.9754964113,
-0.0782158896,
0.2495976985,
0.3867640197,
0.0451814607,
0.2614382803,
-0.6625909805,
-0.2336535454,
0.3523857892,
0.2727672756,
0.1876542568,
-0.7524057031,
-0.2348712385,
-0.1417118162,
-0.0872481838,
-0.9009364843,
0.131152764,
0.1109117568,
0.6908832788,
0.5378799438,
0.4265911877,
0.2743241489,
-0.101208955,
1.0757375956,
0.0159636326,
-1.2160553932,
0.5870149732,
-0.0919234082,
0.5772307515,
0.5643112659,
0.4703135788,
-0.4570622444,
-0.0389246196,
-0.3333800137,
-0.6742355824,
0.8969556093,
-0.4822423756,
0.2602519989,
-0.0540590957,
0.6825307012,
0.4856963456,
0.0996068791,
-0.63734442,
-0.1335807443,
-0.2833608985,
-0.2737211883,
-0.0375477709,
-0.4631918371,
-0.1935716271,
-0.1042095944,
0.2477772385,
-0.431309402,
0.0940500423,
0.3021420538,
-0.3372505605,
-0.0256095361,
0.1118694469,
0.6666548848,
0.6547880769,
-0.1727025211,
0.1981351376,
0.2211887687,
-0.2860263884,
0.0857013613,
-0.1175752804,
-0.4742580652,
-0.0662528276,
0.6758496761,
0.9434469342,
0.2500035167,
-0.7039089203,
0.7816771269,
-0.1973462701,
0.1793062538,
0.3146465123,
0.2798417509,
-0.6566161513,
0.2134021521,
0.62765342,
0.2292348444,
0.6074622273,
-0.2952701747,
0.1576718539,
0.3284106553,
-0.7501339316,
-0.4795745611,
0.7710112929,
0.2772295475,
-0.2333282232,
0.7140021324,
-0.215395689,
-0.3649466932,
1.011084199,
0.6812779307,
0.8982536793,
-0.216961354,
0.1988800615,
0.5458499789,
-0.0742298365,
0.5475530624,
0.2545910478,
-0.4606064856,
-0.3270304203,
-0.40525195,
-0.3661384881,
-0.1996669024,
-0.0736266673,
-0.9564619064,
0.2020163983,
-0.3278056383,
-0.2515611947,
0.0021146531,
-0.1290917844,
-0.6714254618,
0.1605613381,
-0.1374745816,
1.1414567232,
-0.9162859917,
0.2844617665,
1.0350400209,
-0.2350762337,
-0.7136258483,
0.3934537768,
-0.0875716358,
-0.4598085582,
0.9109665751,
0.5523506403,
-0.1723691374,
0.20279634,
-0.8043119311,
-0.8847848177,
0.8166287541,
0.5732300878,
-0.176071316,
0.2349617332,
-0.2881963849,
0.3669244051,
-0.4611675143,
0.3912113309,
0.2784626782,
0.2412888259,
-0.177123487,
-0.5147719383,
0.0134492172,
-0.2074140161,
0.0226378683,
-0.1772269011,
-0.5364422798,
1.2311424017,
-0.425178498,
-0.5293582678,
-0.0497497618,
0.3838520646,
0.1003569439,
0.7434278727,
0.2631815076,
-0.2348254025,
0.7190058827,
-0.1439922452,
1.1785354614,
-0.5003600717,
0.168100968,
0.7565039992,
-0.2295529693,
0.3707292676,
0.7190266848,
-0.0481166057,
0.3978214264,
1.0784202814,
0.3073733747,
0.8380606174,
0.0297445543,
-0.4836834967,
-0.1125927046,
-0.5862193108,
-0.3242349625,
0.0175475348,
0.3843981922,
-0.1653208733,
-0.2244571596,
0.5535933375,
-0.2713081539,
0.0550169796,
-0.7258494496,
0.6814673543,
0.005824083,
-0.7803122997,
0.4037865996,
-0.2071818113,
0.5482667089,
-0.51316154,
0.0455922037,
-0.4630056918,
-0.0516538247,
-0.1044714749,
-0.7593402863,
-0.1246051937,
-0.0429841578,
-0.5618371964,
-0.0474505275,
0.703081727,
-0.0440322943,
-0.0542292558,
0.290946275,
0.3278568983,
-0.039452251,
0.0192613639,
-0.6297249198,
0.0693089813,
-0.0113162836,
-0.1826716065,
0.3183563054,
0.6026610732,
-0.2435796261,
0.6755300164,
0.4832832813,
-0.5577502251,
0.0767433047,
-0.0957424268,
0.9143270254,
-0.3629906178,
-0.5467960835,
-0.9495191574,
0.8376220465,
0.2076451778,
-0.7710940838,
0.7486223578,
0.1817436069,
0.8801051378,
-0.4302757084,
0.6996859312,
0.0819858909,
0.2948922515,
-0.5232875347,
0.2999874651,
-0.4885372519,
0.4396342039,
-0.1323643327,
-0.7678107023,
-0.503497541,
0.34311077,
-0.2398394346,
0.065756768,
0.4856994748,
0.8627125621,
-0.1072912887,
-0.0782398209,
0.2850109339,
-0.2569089234,
0.0216158088,
0.5267652273,
1.0601581335,
0.0018757118,
0.0933871716,
-0.244012475,
-0.2900733352,
-0.644277215,
-1.0238200426,
-0.8249520659,
-0.7269975543,
-0.1539590061,
-0.2676104605,
0.0193986017,
0.8371219635,
0.6312413216,
-0.7582301497,
0.0142223667,
0.0080861598,
0.3415830433,
-0.3855015934,
-0.2707333863,
0.5716457367,
-0.7405952215,
-0.705712676,
0.3989922404,
0.2162535787,
0.2783660591,
0.0252900999,
-0.0708725899,
0.1365845054,
0.1161187887,
0.6699244976,
0.4188210666,
-0.5395575166,
-0.3220156133,
0.2941317558,
-0.3386632502,
0.0840685442,
1.065154314,
-0.9837747216,
0.5143473148,
0.5503817797,
0.5037621856,
-0.094196789,
0.0745372027,
0.3306060433,
-1.1332741976,
0.3154979646,
0.2667722404,
0.1589657813,
0.3977176547,
-0.8657310605,
0.2702755034,
0.1692781448,
-0.5302795172,
-0.956884861,
0.4482306838,
-0.7894850373,
-0.5953637362,
0.9840578437,
-0.2865335047,
-0.1590077877,
-0.0574457087,
-0.3509902656,
0.1860100478,
-0.5570123196,
0.7488277555,
0.6546733975,
-0.3264592886,
-0.0853533521,
-0.3784520626,
0.8414918184,
0.465116024,
-0.3698274493,
0.0139896376,
0.57763201,
0.0922325104,
-0.1147624403,
0.3209517002,
0.1173103452,
0.5810496807,
-0.2265732884,
-0.2200842351,
-0.0079873493,
-0.6903652549,
-1.0276670456,
0.5015466809,
0.1942632943,
-0.1186355874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07217v1
|
Troubles and Failures in Interactional Language. Towards a Linguistically Informed Taxonomy
| 2023-11-13T10:24:51 | 2023-11-13T10:24:51 |
Martina Wiltschko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The goal of this talk is to introduce a systematic research agenda which aims
to understand the nature of interaction between humans and artificial
conversational agents (CA) (henceforth humanmachine interaction, HMI).
Specifically, we shall take an explicit linguistic perspective focusing on
linguistically defined variables that are known to influence the flow of
conversations among humans (henceforth human-human interaction, HHI).
|
[
-0.3919916749,
-0.9026134014,
0.571483314,
0.3003415763,
0.2434163839,
0.5122001767,
-0.099038288,
-0.968416512,
0.6979205608,
0.3067443669,
-0.732904017,
-0.0234437007,
-0.2898709178,
0.0728449374,
-0.0982210115,
0.6989456415,
0.1282128245,
-0.1633637846,
-0.2945304215,
-0.1137894318,
-0.8033958673,
-0.9330787063,
-0.691462338,
-0.6243643761,
0.9580137134,
0.3220160306,
1.0499049425,
0.6542028189,
0.7092095017,
0.4273747206,
-0.1000147089,
-0.1238376945,
-0.3567549586,
0.1638662815,
-0.3846951425,
-0.7540037632,
-0.2732129693,
-0.0336104557,
0.4392244816,
1.0691115856,
-0.3681038022,
-0.1824457645,
0.1128190607,
0.4234583676,
-0.6501117945,
0.16612418,
-0.2955959439,
-0.1003193632,
-0.3430012465,
-0.4130671322,
-0.2856880724,
0.1195980534,
0.3346715569,
-0.4282082617,
-0.2961726785,
0.0091292923,
0.9830036759,
0.2648866475,
-0.4673107862,
-0.3737626076,
-0.9211422801,
1.0708414316,
-0.6117355227,
0.3971180618,
0.7506164908,
0.1027741954,
-0.2665629387,
-0.4454303086,
-0.6250250936,
-0.0765645206,
-0.183903113,
0.1763461381,
-0.2239165008,
0.4641255736,
-0.0004057049,
0.0632126033,
-0.2205066234,
0.2299166471,
-0.595339179,
-0.2668634653,
0.6615411043,
0.4694621265,
0.8754703403,
-0.4581829011,
0.0624503978,
0.4559545517,
-0.645940423,
-0.2248123735,
0.5474190116,
0.2990299463,
-0.1495919228,
0.4622373283,
-0.1992691606,
0.6937991977,
-0.1224604771,
-0.107287094,
0.1940039843,
-0.5926589966,
-0.0420485325,
0.0553466752,
0.5645529628,
0.2615110576,
0.155583486,
-0.2604418397,
0.0787309557,
0.3851492107,
0.5456066132,
-0.2860692739,
-0.0575391762,
0.2865437269,
-0.2073369324,
-0.3430728018,
0.1950863302,
-0.6985480189,
-0.0215120018,
-0.698469162,
0.3324880004,
-0.3914516568,
-0.4612897635,
-0.3737407923,
-0.0087358393,
0.3645281494,
0.0359653085,
-0.9443241358,
0.1911377311,
0.8826463819,
0.6309088469,
-0.1667295694,
-0.6993216276,
-0.1041993797,
0.3543029428,
-0.1068554148,
0.755019486,
-0.6925162673,
-0.7610991001,
0.0636074692,
-0.1536953002,
-0.4224449098,
-0.2688778639,
0.3422275782,
-0.1964754313,
0.3979356587,
-0.3393527865,
-0.3178125024,
-0.1112643182,
0.3367168903,
-0.2290333211,
0.4472030699,
0.0484962277,
-0.8906195164,
0.1628695875,
-0.9630155563,
-0.5332078338,
0.3653482199,
-0.2618521452,
0.2386350781,
-0.2192305773,
-0.6947686076,
-0.0986198336,
-0.1998951286,
0.6789019108,
0.0286455452,
-0.1333847195,
0.3295744658,
-0.3262452185,
0.6826158762,
0.2623973787,
-0.4314287007,
0.4513564706,
-0.7983954549,
0.0365787894,
-0.1549744755,
-0.3802400529,
-0.6429465413,
0.2883688509,
-0.0572640784,
0.3039163053,
0.3209320009,
-0.5353229046,
-0.0535087697,
-0.7850311995,
0.7182645798,
0.5876297951,
0.2682656646,
0.3391571939,
-0.4252658188,
0.5624229908,
-0.0457463227,
0.26650545,
-0.2133491784,
-0.6267770529,
-0.8296050429,
0.1412760615,
0.3126516938,
0.6300594211,
-0.8482381105,
0.545542717,
0.0026901991,
-0.3161767423,
-0.4612029493,
0.1213256419,
0.7388072014,
0.3396865129,
-0.0620257482,
-0.4549154043,
-0.8371884823,
-1.0404005051,
-0.1772475839,
-0.9208533764,
0.0923204347,
0.4765530527,
0.4197531641,
-0.8616729379,
1.2486236095,
-0.1409992427,
-0.1410915256,
-0.2919788957,
0.5248607993,
-0.1991141737,
0.4044521451,
0.3225174248,
-0.8481009603,
-0.317558527,
0.15862073,
-0.8355609775,
-0.0657438263,
0.1412882805,
-0.364305675,
0.3748422265,
0.3514305055,
-0.7264026999,
0.6598923802,
0.3904033005,
-0.4443791509,
0.5064767599,
-0.1086043045,
0.3283141255,
-1.2247613668,
-0.0414236784,
0.2922602892,
0.3377327919,
-1.1311110258,
-0.0539156385,
-0.4443272948,
0.0417718068,
-0.6518653631,
0.4304777682,
-0.3025895357,
0.2709358931,
-0.2526973486,
-0.0108350404,
-0.332603544,
0.5307875276,
0.1194519177,
0.6448404789,
0.6541718245,
-0.7710824609,
0.1144360974,
0.3724460304,
0.0687561706,
0.9738342166,
-0.708157897,
0.0946997032,
-0.1589134336,
-0.2470167428,
-0.604026854,
-0.6710751057,
0.3968833983,
-0.567604363,
0.102739729,
0.143844828,
-0.4160234034,
-0.2215847075,
-0.0267553534,
0.8029226661,
0.0830079764,
-0.2764864266,
0.5181117654,
0.9766183496,
-0.1297750771,
-0.2684010863,
-0.720248878,
0.4601264298,
-0.3165972531,
-0.6151353717,
0.116796039,
-0.1288509816,
-1.1062734127,
-0.2396636456,
0.3427047729,
-0.3157345355,
0.1042285487,
0.6364854574,
0.3298931718,
-0.095489189,
0.36345613,
-0.346483916,
-0.1063148975,
0.4325074553,
0.1936165988,
0.7217424512,
-0.1495212317,
-0.4787987769,
-0.8936030865,
0.4278154373,
0.5886212587,
0.0733444989,
0.7097023129,
0.0403352529,
-0.4936450422,
0.5851473212,
-0.2641736269,
-0.0317589603,
-0.5154349208,
0.2742078006,
-0.5016036034,
-0.680426836,
0.4157330096,
0.176818043,
-0.1739757955,
0.5431803465,
0.5730024576,
-0.3284880817,
1.2156594992,
0.9450683594,
-0.2840972841,
0.3223210871,
0.2311160564,
0.3149054348,
-0.6093666553,
-0.2796500623,
-0.8228735924,
-0.0007249523,
-0.9288105369,
0.1212763414,
0.2054380178,
-0.3106786311,
-0.113160789,
0.4131847918,
-0.2614456117,
0.0781221762,
0.5122904181,
0.0079169841,
0.2703438699,
-0.4386018515,
0.2414907813,
-0.2544723153,
-0.7228952646,
-0.4928351343,
0.617168963,
0.6427665949,
0.8987320065,
0.3582135141,
0.644359529,
0.3612412512,
0.268481642,
-0.9961950779,
0.4189834297,
0.8295346498,
-0.7220473289,
-0.4164415002,
-0.395552218,
-1.4386457205,
-0.0907808393,
0.0300276652,
-1.3775987625,
0.4308073819,
-0.0361241028,
-0.0065699918,
0.1225796416,
-0.6595361233,
0.615326643,
-0.3383245468,
-0.1615765393,
-0.4076021314,
-0.7865228057,
0.3344470263,
0.0025303566,
0.5691717863,
-0.0899032131,
0.2238091975,
1.0619663,
-0.465421766,
1.0956488848,
0.1101342887,
-0.3918047249,
0.5428375006,
-0.0415365584,
-0.1193999276,
-0.1365410984,
0.0953480601,
0.3903591931,
0.3052558899,
-0.3305827379,
-0.296797812,
0.5003677607,
-0.8948219419,
-0.869263947,
-0.3688059151,
-0.7320814133,
-0.4955970645,
0.1332949847,
0.2182477117,
0.4340474904,
-0.4486548007,
-0.2273829579,
0.2713444531,
-0.1519666016,
0.4385790229,
0.2661477029,
-0.2771653533,
0.1377775222,
1.1170004606,
-0.0881412551,
0.4493644536,
0.2725777328,
0.0777267218,
-0.0159093812,
-0.0590342991,
-0.0506252199,
0.3780433536,
-0.6482307315,
0.2169019133,
-0.7563476562,
-0.406729877,
-0.2082208842,
-0.0971484035,
-0.1436173767,
-0.0939077362,
-0.4956292212,
0.2278628349,
-0.0395707712,
1.2186765671,
-0.2267929763,
0.6307429075,
-0.9088434577,
0.0510369614,
0.2223486006,
0.2677588463,
-0.1144113913,
-0.4202081263,
-0.2484299541,
0.399761349,
-0.310934782,
-1.0591151714,
0.3916766047,
0.2619619966,
0.6589447856,
0.601444304,
-0.2422089726,
0.6083641648,
-0.062909238,
0.6614376903,
0.5742805004,
-1.0926167965,
1.03078866,
-0.5130835176,
0.4489465356,
0.6224230528,
0.5264082551,
-0.8918199539,
-0.6152696609,
-0.7260221243,
-0.6739839315,
0.5017080903,
0.1474698335,
-0.0207304191,
-0.1364329606,
0.290722847,
-0.0585548542,
0.1190112382,
-0.3911189437,
-0.2707022727,
0.3663493693,
-0.0618857592,
0.0849943236,
-0.4581311941,
-0.1626170576,
-0.2657625377,
0.6354714632,
-0.1470280439,
0.1729404777,
0.1104389429,
-0.175991863,
-0.5774747729,
0.4513210058,
0.4631725848,
1.3202888966,
-0.1184524074,
0.1346556693,
-0.1368198842,
-0.4358292818,
0.0455639735,
-0.4095259309,
-0.0812901855,
0.001935348,
0.5257737041,
0.6336758137,
0.3507825732,
-0.795065105,
0.1692253649,
-0.1513554752,
-0.3209256828,
-0.2179301083,
0.0240899697,
-0.1383297294,
-0.1397131085,
0.3295727074,
0.1201574877,
0.2947920859,
-1.2478579283,
0.3689988256,
0.4717971981,
-0.9610989094,
-0.6485278606,
0.388923496,
0.4351848066,
-0.8337149024,
0.5356351137,
-0.0066356142,
-0.6661593914,
0.4712812006,
0.3380134702,
0.6583228111,
-0.3526943326,
0.2603448331,
0.1979025155,
0.3210528791,
0.415861845,
0.3984453976,
-0.0376770608,
-0.9638927579,
-0.5215855241,
-0.4253109694,
-0.8153660297,
-0.3086357415,
-0.8445734382,
0.1377580166,
-0.0369606614,
-0.3104576766,
0.3940498531,
-0.2260861546,
-0.4860234261,
0.049283009,
0.13163279,
0.6625753045,
-0.7483528256,
0.8451783657,
0.8379155397,
-0.5387681127,
-0.5832672119,
0.2170184851,
0.072487995,
-0.5110743642,
0.8254547119,
-0.0599402934,
-0.2015023232,
-0.2008908093,
-0.545234859,
-0.9071406722,
0.6291268468,
-0.1148159653,
-0.4317778051,
0.0299906358,
0.4910899997,
0.7564085126,
-0.2176143676,
0.1731646955,
0.9338665009,
0.8715335727,
-0.0944091976,
-1.4759316444,
-0.2921981514,
-0.505980134,
-0.0813916326,
0.2948980033,
-0.6292652488,
0.4301488101,
-0.1896318495,
-0.5115604997,
0.2010501623,
0.8209201097,
-0.043287795,
0.3906024396,
0.5194715261,
0.2951607406,
0.5711457729,
-0.3574624956,
1.1277850866,
-0.4227980673,
0.1668232381,
0.7752038836,
-0.2428945899,
0.5909456015,
0.8347306252,
-0.4433944523,
0.3706930578,
0.765842557,
0.4531318545,
0.3053301275,
0.287104696,
-0.3658871353,
0.0904446915,
-0.5097671747,
-0.1407851428,
0.8813309669,
0.6803407669,
0.159383446,
0.1578661799,
0.322335124,
-0.2257131636,
0.1171958596,
-0.2109307796,
1.0552875996,
-0.1124131531,
-0.781336844,
0.3309099674,
-0.0790838003,
0.9021931291,
-0.2552590072,
0.049612198,
0.2080518454,
-0.2446276546,
-0.3375272453,
-0.775472641,
0.7114929557,
-0.473787874,
-0.1678937376,
0.2489487976,
1.0902905464,
-0.481803894,
-0.1347274631,
0.3249527812,
0.961368382,
0.2278416008,
0.2634413838,
-0.5643932819,
0.245097369,
-0.2142367661,
-0.0107777882,
0.5138598084,
0.1642407179,
-0.0303766448,
0.8545982242,
0.3081052601,
-0.0702429116,
-0.1659555286,
0.1418524534,
0.5514390469,
-0.909833312,
-0.5957847834,
-0.6770809293,
0.312484473,
0.1406309158,
-0.2803559005,
0.5535503626,
0.170946449,
0.4748775363,
0.2787201703,
0.9424858689,
-0.3270127475,
0.3435927033,
-0.1326860487,
0.7039635181,
-0.3069503307,
0.0960766897,
-0.1965771765,
-0.6517934799,
-0.2024550885,
0.3705394268,
-0.2219613194,
0.100942336,
0.7380750775,
0.623126328,
0.2398884892,
0.3416368961,
0.4821021557,
0.2392171919,
0.1066707894,
0.1669060588,
1.3238096237,
-0.0942518413,
0.1680874825,
-0.4649558961,
-0.3385967016,
0.0463718139,
-0.4535305798,
-0.6879102588,
-0.9038142562,
-0.4982676506,
-0.3082309663,
0.3577155173,
0.845915854,
0.7590600848,
-0.7448347211,
-0.5393623114,
-0.2486504763,
0.4479725659,
0.2130209953,
-0.3734677434,
-0.0585392863,
-0.618545711,
-0.8981948495,
0.2271305323,
0.6607267261,
-0.3357938528,
-0.7155153155,
-0.2991128564,
-0.4819539785,
0.2194140255,
0.6517115831,
0.8729130626,
-0.815982461,
-0.478754729,
-0.3691675365,
-0.1936787814,
0.1734730005,
0.8950303793,
-0.5197610855,
0.2751263082,
0.1845801771,
0.6611409187,
-0.2939106226,
-0.0980392694,
0.7778339386,
-0.4985254407,
0.1070023924,
0.1740219593,
0.303791821,
0.0413093083,
-0.6407824159,
0.4109637737,
0.391879648,
-0.6353788376,
-0.853533566,
0.5144385695,
-1.0493024588,
-0.2159668803,
1.1538528204,
0.1629069746,
-0.5612596273,
-0.6076666713,
-0.4453795552,
0.1664205492,
-0.1754403412,
0.9589935541,
0.7085330486,
-0.3770003319,
-0.2755640447,
-0.5800044537,
0.4801733196,
0.3309828639,
-1.1985725164,
-0.3431824446,
0.3981917202,
-0.2754421234,
0.5947121978,
0.5811179876,
-0.0196965598,
0.2135675997,
-0.1068982705,
0.2908036709,
0.7986527085,
-0.4374233186,
0.0456368029,
-0.0085339127,
0.3210390508,
-0.0594879016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07215v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07215v3
|
Coffee: Boost Your Code LLMs by Fixing Bugs with Feedback
| 2023-11-13T10:15:19 | 2024-02-23T06:56:16 |
Seungjun Moon, Hyungjoo Chae, Yongho Song, Taeyoon Kwon, Dongjin Kang, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Seung-won Hwang, Jinyoung Yeo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Code editing is an essential step towards reliable program synthesis to
automatically correct critical errors generated from code LLMs. Recent studies
have demonstrated that closed-source LLMs (i.e., ChatGPT and GPT-4) are capable
of generating corrective feedback to edit erroneous inputs. However, it remains
challenging for open-source code LLMs to generate feedback for code editing,
since these models tend to adhere to the superficial formats of feedback and
provide feedback with misleading information. Hence, the focus of our work is
to leverage open-source code LLMs to generate helpful feedback with correct
guidance for code editing. To this end, we present Coffee, a collected dataset
specifically designed for code fixing with feedback. Using this dataset, we
construct CoffeePots, a framework for COde Fixing with FEEdback via
Preference-Optimized Tuning and Selection. The proposed framework aims to
automatically generate helpful feedback for code editing while minimizing the
potential risk of superficial feedback. The combination of Coffee and
CoffeePots marks a significant advancement, achieving state-of-the-art
performance on HumanEvalFix benchmark. Codes and model checkpoints are publicly
available at https://github.com/Lune-Blue/COFFEE.
|
[
-0.0276124887,
-0.5483444333,
0.5685190558,
0.5667355061,
-0.0662390068,
0.1605117917,
-0.5547835231,
-0.3838418126,
0.3062846959,
0.4603267014,
-0.4497237206,
-0.63364923,
-0.4434800148,
0.2438161373,
-0.0378327668,
1.2847049236,
-0.2488803416,
0.2000056356,
-0.499902457,
-0.0105176382,
-0.7273976803,
-0.5453012586,
-0.5183523893,
-0.1616374999,
0.7628796101,
0.8024660349,
0.6541292667,
0.5088253021,
0.8239507079,
0.2891052365,
0.2654559016,
0.2540464699,
-0.5683504343,
0.1783650666,
0.1885805726,
-0.9751194715,
-0.5275517106,
-0.1328149289,
-0.036959216,
0.3354205787,
0.3355089724,
0.3737987876,
0.2001565248,
0.7977882028,
-0.5480955243,
0.3823432028,
-0.7611775994,
0.1876377016,
-0.0244402811,
-0.6460199952,
-0.380089134,
-0.9423850775,
-0.9208440185,
-0.3474588096,
0.0550026186,
-0.0528263971,
0.7310389876,
0.6752054095,
0.3382309377,
-0.2541621327,
-0.9086495042,
0.5160562396,
-0.7649598122,
-0.03769226,
0.4858521819,
0.151581794,
-0.3390299976,
-0.6928161979,
-0.1668436229,
-0.1728836298,
-0.0707822219,
0.0573665611,
-0.0231574588,
-0.0707507506,
0.2824527621,
0.4639673531,
-0.2591625452,
-0.0303954929,
-0.2475759685,
-0.2621894181,
0.341860801,
0.1749117821,
0.1610714495,
0.313633889,
-0.0180982929,
0.309337914,
-0.7958110571,
0.0330323279,
0.4519538879,
0.3592541516,
0.1046725959,
0.5670768619,
-0.1526022851,
0.7270623446,
-0.2620831728,
-0.0158780999,
0.3130696714,
-0.314588517,
-0.2415410578,
-0.0593299605,
0.6234117746,
0.7576387525,
0.3048574626,
-0.4376230836,
-0.5147820711,
0.5201483965,
0.1557786316,
-0.8221094608,
-0.7318065763,
0.6293687224,
-0.3407040238,
-0.6914409995,
-0.0367192589,
-0.497462064,
-0.3778596222,
-0.3261723816,
0.0891831368,
-0.0077516264,
-0.18587403,
0.2575784028,
-0.2328520268,
-0.0743394047,
0.344984889,
-0.6412628293,
-0.0447981656,
0.6512956023,
0.8892908096,
-0.041515857,
0.0267273337,
-0.8518434167,
0.0370643362,
-0.4050296545,
1.1002299786,
-0.7081423998,
-0.5065608621,
0.2700704336,
0.0697071031,
0.3852398396,
-0.7543386817,
0.806853652,
-0.4721219242,
-0.040397156,
-0.5265178084,
-0.4723262787,
0.5367819071,
0.3781851232,
-0.3670033813,
1.2312247753,
0.1062835306,
-0.8934209943,
0.2930552065,
-0.8662574291,
-0.355173409,
-0.0338183269,
-0.1684263647,
-0.6944684982,
0.0969535112,
0.3226642907,
0.1761824042,
0.2621689141,
-0.0303528532,
-0.564528048,
-0.5994124413,
0.3944481611,
0.0194664448,
0.5423983932,
0.3073022366,
-0.169256255,
0.5537059307,
-0.8068269491,
0.2460332066,
0.1721800566,
-0.5436117649,
-0.0642275065,
-0.1930175722,
0.0569373444,
0.0232220814,
0.1915048957,
-0.4654536545,
0.4184658229,
0.1594849229,
0.6122429967,
0.9444101453,
0.0702651516,
0.1975001246,
-0.443875283,
0.6241332889,
-0.0527157597,
0.3839628398,
-0.3668227494,
-0.3791482151,
-0.8810777068,
-0.4378642142,
0.6505596638,
0.7534322739,
-0.48451823,
0.5796804428,
-0.0364938676,
-0.2154653519,
-0.7033705115,
0.4170799851,
0.181659624,
0.4438931942,
0.2274934202,
-0.201553151,
-0.6334229708,
-0.6428773999,
-0.2171360701,
-0.1704361737,
-0.1941931546,
0.2555239201,
0.1819995344,
-0.3603509367,
1.1042535305,
-0.8801717162,
-0.3634279966,
0.1785746962,
-0.2923222184,
0.2294038236,
0.5555119514,
0.6539274454,
-0.0763141587,
-0.262963295,
-0.1908394694,
-0.585275054,
-0.5194480419,
0.2532089651,
-0.4214722216,
-0.1231611446,
0.6784901619,
-0.2154795378,
0.1871012747,
0.3878607154,
-0.1137923971,
0.7156526446,
0.0543423705,
0.417329073,
-0.8876877427,
-0.0832095742,
-0.3334970772,
-0.5277993679,
-0.082932584,
-0.0297635421,
0.1711732298,
-0.2269378304,
-0.4650746286,
0.1082207486,
-0.3278222382,
-0.0470159762,
-0.4204904437,
-0.231384635,
0.0615507327,
0.6465141773,
-0.2455426604,
0.9343721271,
0.3585906923,
-0.338531822,
0.3835757673,
-0.0181482006,
-0.1777248979,
0.3214596808,
-0.6711022258,
0.5012739897,
0.3447757661,
0.1314663291,
-1.0690506697,
-0.2009759992,
0.5747967362,
-0.4975113273,
0.0870709792,
-0.3006138504,
-0.7813754082,
-0.4315036237,
-0.3179567158,
0.0051341997,
0.3387413919,
-0.4947907627,
-0.1588500738,
0.2540877759,
-0.2268006355,
-0.2603781223,
-0.7719047666,
0.0866907686,
0.0106730582,
-0.5906170011,
-0.0376722179,
-0.5002406836,
-0.2783916295,
0.1450065225,
-0.1437615901,
0.023213584,
0.0141461194,
0.3312001824,
0.2683421075,
-0.0888178647,
0.1165318266,
-0.2203016877,
-0.3517537117,
0.1843391657,
-0.374175787,
0.3138812184,
-0.3669073582,
-0.3868335187,
-0.3479149938,
0.1238641068,
0.5186158419,
-0.2820410132,
0.1180464327,
0.5185155869,
-0.1746140718,
-0.0951180458,
-0.3554810584,
-0.3271658719,
-0.4947395325,
0.0850745961,
-0.3398704827,
-1.0814738274,
0.6537336111,
-0.3616064489,
0.3262502849,
-0.212142095,
0.6937486529,
-0.2353146672,
0.730265975,
0.7616483569,
-0.2599362135,
0.5241505504,
0.0005224503,
0.3029186726,
-0.5631309152,
-0.0145488176,
-1.0067592859,
-0.4640454352,
-0.316167146,
-0.613388598,
0.1958014518,
-0.0014106969,
0.1387232095,
0.0541213192,
-0.7836162448,
0.9370336533,
0.504504621,
0.34444502,
0.5415527225,
-0.1525433213,
-0.1486418694,
-0.1281594336,
-0.5679519773,
-0.5123075843,
0.8730667233,
0.3789870143,
0.9580413103,
-0.1998260766,
0.7967860699,
0.6290288568,
0.4000754058,
-0.8136021495,
0.3374124467,
0.4216997623,
-0.1630503535,
0.0904995874,
-0.4289243519,
-0.6175919771,
-0.228174299,
0.0618283078,
-0.1625095755,
-0.0547867976,
0.5042823553,
-0.3588477671,
0.2945689559,
-0.8970801234,
0.7914369106,
-0.2873449922,
-0.4709972739,
0.0313862488,
-0.2805220187,
0.2975146174,
0.2305439562,
0.2633904815,
-0.1100818068,
-0.0051239487,
0.2215350717,
-0.7549037337,
0.9562993646,
-0.109724015,
-0.2824976146,
0.1711704731,
0.3561859131,
0.5850058794,
0.4783599377,
-0.1774670929,
0.2778366804,
-0.2161180377,
-0.5864579678,
-0.7465183139,
0.8462894559,
-0.6190433502,
-0.4911222458,
-0.2738544643,
-0.3679003716,
-0.3680735528,
0.1076496392,
0.155219838,
0.2446831763,
0.0519493148,
-0.0942284837,
0.5841499567,
-0.0719143599,
0.5085583925,
0.3450683951,
-0.4965696931,
-0.5837461948,
0.7254042029,
-0.352655977,
0.067110844,
0.2360362709,
-0.0842682794,
0.2136137038,
-0.6000885963,
-0.468924731,
-0.1967413872,
-0.6353172064,
-0.7373799682,
-0.4088262618,
-0.0837554783,
-0.2605172694,
-0.4651393294,
-0.4586337209,
-0.4879468083,
-0.2894803286,
-0.3406057656,
0.5939590335,
0.513196826,
-0.1059406996,
0.2573396862,
-0.7589631677,
0.0855554268,
0.0400657952,
0.8004670739,
-0.4348350167,
-0.0627640411,
-0.6034418941,
-0.0789321586,
-0.3744303584,
-0.7297893763,
-0.0084358724,
-0.2318347543,
0.0452976488,
0.2787689567,
0.1087166592,
0.7874083519,
-0.6044633985,
0.9100538492,
0.2604369819,
-0.7653343678,
0.8691020608,
-0.4180064201,
0.3644910455,
0.7589090466,
-0.067076534,
-0.4077256322,
-0.8644462824,
-0.3071494997,
-0.6255226135,
0.3945780993,
0.3119789958,
0.0817499012,
-0.1151063442,
0.3943731785,
0.154168427,
0.2980090082,
-0.8139673471,
-0.0683531463,
-0.257556051,
0.0176486876,
0.3960098326,
-0.2005364001,
-0.4127737284,
-0.390506357,
0.7954059839,
-0.172262162,
0.5548118353,
0.2188059092,
-0.0084811645,
-0.4955456257,
0.2054046392,
0.6423506737,
0.7528913021,
-0.3628424108,
0.0899897665,
-0.2183649987,
-0.1513321698,
-0.0107682459,
-0.3336315453,
-0.2328774631,
0.1789191067,
0.1526602209,
0.7178177238,
0.1250190288,
-0.4776198268,
0.2907997072,
-0.4254027307,
-0.0756472647,
-0.279109776,
0.3986859918,
0.0716698095,
0.0102703003,
-0.168982625,
0.5576097369,
-0.0625584796,
-0.3285883665,
0.3156408966,
0.3105025887,
-0.3949056268,
-0.2247493267,
0.678768754,
0.6052911282,
-0.522185266,
0.5680164695,
-0.1313638538,
-0.5061454773,
0.5519085526,
0.4716123044,
0.9896235466,
0.1466884464,
0.1683646142,
0.3003612757,
0.4681184292,
0.3266880512,
0.3143668771,
-0.1039493904,
-0.5658072233,
-0.4092251658,
-0.6118953228,
-0.6584489942,
0.1509730965,
-0.458920747,
0.6726299524,
-0.5549071431,
-0.2600004375,
-0.4376120269,
-0.1480462849,
-0.4947617352,
-0.1478923261,
-0.1499248892,
0.8964003325,
-0.8331456184,
0.8059435487,
0.6804566383,
-0.5492674708,
-0.6428322792,
0.1028182805,
-0.1748815477,
-0.7120685577,
0.133121714,
0.1102118716,
-0.0356151909,
-0.0937164277,
-0.7760184407,
-0.4127544165,
0.542419076,
0.6884889603,
-0.5864347219,
0.400307864,
0.180959031,
0.4792386591,
-0.2528646588,
0.4941407442,
0.4125519991,
0.5505028963,
-0.0327858776,
-0.6439655423,
-0.1106157154,
-0.4967700541,
-0.0718292519,
0.1938371211,
-0.9093798399,
0.0348790661,
-0.4245277047,
0.332773149,
-0.0615741014,
0.5312755108,
0.1505585313,
0.1195493937,
0.4653565586,
0.751519382,
0.8243550062,
-0.3379822671,
0.8962336183,
-0.6208421588,
0.2004313022,
1.2611727715,
-0.3441056013,
0.5856177807,
0.4582136571,
-0.2664058805,
0.4782195091,
1.0752129555,
-0.1847106069,
0.5954319239,
0.3660039008,
-0.1412663311,
-0.1461903751,
0.1294739395,
-0.6325579286,
0.072880134,
0.0958422348,
-0.372766912,
0.0313427188,
-0.2475566864,
0.4380907118,
-0.0650348291,
-0.1608746946,
0.6356141567,
0.0760973766,
-0.6092333198,
0.617285192,
0.0513053834,
0.535295248,
-0.4915474951,
-0.1587187797,
-0.532237649,
0.2275156379,
-0.5867862701,
-0.5727178454,
0.6566141248,
0.1644928455,
-0.5814253092,
-0.3609749675,
0.6513155699,
-0.3418137431,
-0.4707555175,
0.1769544333,
0.111251317,
0.0235260259,
-0.0251921453,
-0.6729565859,
0.6654064655,
0.2638023496,
0.1253909916,
0.3027095199,
0.4284597635,
0.3392727375,
0.3149581552,
1.0050746202,
0.4330303073,
0.0221346449,
0.2385364473,
1.0070980787,
-0.4815503657,
-0.5522456169,
-0.7564904094,
0.5127330422,
-0.0397467315,
-0.1680997312,
0.6232890487,
0.8480966091,
0.8799783587,
-0.50496912,
1.1178483963,
0.0452073887,
0.1114394218,
-0.4730717242,
0.4484197795,
-0.242487818,
0.5313202143,
-0.3667207956,
-1.065018177,
-0.5651516914,
0.4064132571,
-0.1911634058,
-0.2749222815,
0.7458102107,
1.2334527969,
-0.0192404445,
0.062258631,
0.1893761754,
0.2226023823,
0.501614213,
0.4010425806,
0.624338448,
-0.1925422549,
0.7304872274,
-0.1777371466,
-0.5287571549,
-0.2996753752,
-1.0298763514,
-0.7405783534,
-0.064021349,
-0.7708994746,
-0.7583932281,
0.1930958629,
0.9758341908,
0.7194434404,
-0.9531101584,
-0.0955594257,
-0.2371515632,
0.3439841866,
-0.4468619823,
-0.2842390239,
0.1273776144,
-1.0188231468,
-0.6707398891,
0.2748036683,
0.5572571158,
-0.4958349168,
-0.0080542257,
-0.0940374807,
0.3488912284,
0.0431969613,
0.4134838879,
0.2285016477,
-0.25848791,
-0.2604157031,
-0.0116841346,
-0.0798526183,
0.5825946331,
1.308526516,
-0.5515937805,
0.4388785362,
0.4271575511,
0.7863690257,
0.0761807486,
-0.3180845976,
0.5194436312,
-0.8128826022,
0.2555595636,
0.2493217289,
0.5403046012,
0.5044748783,
-0.6838843226,
0.6876159906,
0.4335339665,
-0.9702035189,
-0.9422033429,
0.1994675994,
-0.751052022,
-0.0043922542,
1.2205771208,
-0.1686638445,
-0.2687327862,
0.0536672175,
-0.3930259347,
0.1198135167,
-0.4762940109,
1.1006478071,
0.8090023398,
-0.4365071356,
-0.0474557355,
-0.3654896021,
0.649192512,
0.3398759663,
-1.0234591961,
0.1389357746,
0.7703199983,
0.5545635819,
-0.0139374845,
0.8423779607,
-0.5057100654,
0.2299574316,
-0.1241537929,
0.3055806756,
-0.2818316221,
-0.2246697247,
-0.1561754644,
0.1368768364,
0.3197093904,
-0.5518906116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07194v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07194v3
|
Exploring the Factual Consistency in Dialogue Comprehension of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T09:32:12 | 2024-04-01T16:37:50 |
Shuaijie She, Shujian Huang, Xingyun Wang, Yanke Zhou, Jiajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs (Large Language Models) usually interact with users in the form of
dialogue and generate responses following their instructions, which naturally
require dialogue comprehension abilities. However, dialogue comprehension is a
general language ability which is hard to be evaluated directly. In this work,
we propose to perform the evaluation focusing on the factual consistency issue
with the help of the dialogue summarization task. Besides evaluating and
analyzing the dialogue summarization performance (DIAC-Sum) of different LLMs,
we also derive factual questions from the generated summaries and use them as a
more flexible measurement of dialogue comprehension (DIAC-QA). Our evaluation
shows that, on average, 26.8% of the summaries generated by LLMs contain
factual inconsistency. Even ChatGPT, the strongest model evaluated, has such
errors in 16% of its summaries. For answering the factual questions, which is
more challenging, the average error rate of all evaluated LLMs is 36.1%. Both
results indicate serious deficiencies. Detailed analysis shows that the
understanding of subject/object of the conversation is still challenging for
LLMs. Furthermore, to stimulate and enhance the dialogue comprehension ability
of LLMs, we propose a fine-tuning paradigm with auto-constructed multi-task
data, which achieved a relative error rate reduction of 11% on DIAC-QA.
|
[
-0.2733817399,
-0.9122760296,
0.7866725922,
0.1591557413,
-0.2255928814,
0.2698502541,
-0.2060938478,
-0.26944381,
-0.0123186866,
0.5444536805,
-0.5574297905,
-0.6130517721,
-0.5747942328,
0.408647418,
-0.2203627825,
0.9585085511,
-0.0273744166,
0.0230756309,
-0.4556506872,
-0.4002447426,
-0.542922914,
-0.3063614964,
-0.5251714587,
-0.0865769014,
0.2292559147,
0.2918731868,
0.6157346368,
0.4161810577,
0.4810136259,
0.4002138078,
-0.1588258743,
0.7410011888,
-0.7461602092,
0.1646257192,
-0.1961735189,
-0.5957039595,
-0.5255182981,
-0.2449867725,
0.7512818575,
0.6423652768,
-0.2752568424,
0.075838536,
0.2338975668,
0.6105384827,
-0.4298786819,
0.5014848113,
-0.9047893882,
-0.1719795018,
0.3475991189,
-0.1359297633,
-0.3431490958,
-0.4818553329,
0.1566579044,
-0.5281589031,
0.407076627,
0.2004730403,
0.8631167412,
0.5068431497,
-0.5606261492,
-0.3431075513,
-0.6850482821,
0.4827322364,
-1.1492040157,
0.3280768096,
0.2717675269,
0.014629039,
-0.1553844959,
-0.2903820574,
-0.8006002903,
-0.3908593059,
-0.2375219464,
0.2067945004,
-0.1094311029,
0.2999839783,
0.4202515483,
0.3336614966,
-0.5938851833,
-0.0566700399,
-0.1658957452,
-0.3600998819,
0.5167939663,
0.5509877801,
0.2145494372,
-0.2008517087,
-0.1724712849,
0.1348586082,
-0.6793558002,
0.124512881,
0.1512319446,
0.1088106483,
-0.2425001264,
0.8508600593,
-0.4314743578,
0.5618803501,
0.1028648168,
-0.6092281938,
0.1269676685,
-0.9102295637,
-0.4564479291,
-0.058533363,
0.643761754,
0.6172409058,
0.3602353036,
0.0283056814,
-0.0551114231,
-0.1097130179,
0.1320902407,
-0.7303032875,
-0.1567772329,
0.1801624298,
-0.2112832516,
-0.0352939963,
-0.1591361612,
-0.3530177176,
-0.2479030043,
-0.5072199106,
0.3254753053,
-0.3892894089,
-0.0714309588,
0.1941168904,
0.3362818658,
0.1517606527,
0.5914214849,
-0.867490232,
0.2627553046,
0.5711491108,
0.884059608,
-0.1613861173,
-0.0559818186,
-0.446739316,
0.1305064857,
-0.4140629768,
0.8280230165,
0.0153856454,
-0.4630248249,
-0.1633117795,
0.0764795989,
-0.6219398975,
-0.6138101816,
0.4540158808,
-0.3804522455,
0.1209693328,
-0.4105018675,
-0.7569240332,
-0.2760751545,
0.7583577633,
-0.4816875458,
0.5716347098,
-0.077173993,
-0.6813791394,
0.114313677,
-0.3186841309,
-0.1097887009,
-0.2685841918,
-0.1786600649,
-0.4286095202,
-0.059863966,
0.2042952329,
0.2529051602,
-0.2018234432,
0.5730198622,
-0.1768926531,
-0.5000430942,
0.3572548628,
-0.6714520454,
0.5651229024,
0.0276058838,
-0.2615866065,
-0.0460452177,
-0.679823041,
-0.0772660226,
-0.2123078406,
-0.3488964438,
0.0731722191,
-0.0226430614,
-0.6092042923,
0.0811019838,
0.1435746253,
-0.4927554429,
0.0020959298,
-0.5733497143,
-0.0805429965,
0.6051405668,
0.2219166756,
0.023561649,
-0.6210210323,
0.3129787445,
0.1055355519,
-0.202186659,
-0.5614058971,
-0.3737149835,
-1.1314554214,
-0.3879235387,
0.3410430551,
0.7428891659,
-0.5525277257,
0.5344291925,
-0.3349004686,
-0.3467757404,
-0.3562990725,
0.3120414913,
0.3963832557,
0.736761272,
0.2283945531,
-0.2951630056,
-0.3832719922,
-0.820252955,
-0.1050172523,
-0.5842219591,
-0.0144245056,
0.3524202108,
0.4689560235,
-0.3012639582,
0.9923960567,
-0.5011098385,
-0.0913791731,
-0.2693003714,
0.290127486,
0.2145324498,
0.4104451537,
0.2283732295,
-0.3642692268,
-0.5334495306,
-0.167929098,
-0.8364396095,
-0.0889864713,
-0.0623650812,
0.138160482,
0.4140207767,
0.3892782629,
-0.8216184974,
0.4205397069,
0.4788021147,
-0.2010052204,
0.8440262079,
-0.3230296075,
0.4900372326,
-0.9589005113,
0.0324171409,
-0.0598041043,
-0.4335805476,
-0.4403532743,
-0.3793623745,
-0.1138768941,
0.1173266247,
-0.2636503875,
0.318803668,
-0.2327408642,
-0.0012443197,
-0.1523909271,
0.4212169051,
0.2595621347,
0.5704597235,
-0.1356554329,
0.8442162275,
0.5125368237,
-0.6657194495,
0.5806085467,
0.4669537544,
-0.5695345402,
0.6707908511,
-0.9415678978,
0.0906937122,
-0.1281307489,
0.4063679278,
-1.4342976809,
-0.2094100416,
0.2612325251,
-0.2348205447,
0.1695280224,
-0.2108268291,
-0.5109665394,
0.1630372107,
-0.1394495815,
0.2231431901,
0.340056926,
-0.2352069467,
0.6579283476,
0.075688757,
-0.4666165113,
-0.5332872868,
-0.27760759,
-0.009008402,
-0.066072531,
-0.9257833362,
-0.0900651366,
-0.3042247891,
-0.4818333685,
-0.101607345,
-0.3034481108,
0.1447316259,
0.0839555189,
0.0144734615,
0.4100158513,
-0.4555524588,
0.0413355865,
-0.1411316395,
0.0841517299,
0.1223145947,
0.2039681971,
0.2911507785,
-0.0845637843,
-0.675493896,
-0.6847296357,
-0.0768968537,
0.6112990379,
-0.0303049646,
0.7106429935,
0.3902487457,
0.0734910816,
0.1071859598,
-0.831964314,
-0.1813655943,
-0.3785190284,
0.2324384004,
-0.400903523,
-0.9187055826,
0.8446052074,
-0.1486515701,
0.2934886813,
0.4506508708,
0.529615283,
-0.3273810744,
1.0830436945,
0.4091385305,
0.0445531122,
-0.1376509517,
-0.0645001307,
0.2022238672,
-0.8014040589,
-0.5075216889,
-0.4882728159,
-0.0410913564,
-0.5164513588,
-0.3721889555,
0.6322041154,
-0.0656677783,
-0.0268619042,
-0.0203612074,
0.2599863708,
0.4076393545,
0.2664055526,
-0.0532129034,
0.7942512035,
-0.0921067894,
-0.1346386373,
0.1681386232,
-0.5530308485,
-0.6943338513,
0.8925094604,
0.3557142317,
0.8151937723,
0.2669372559,
0.3066617846,
0.248152256,
-0.0230232161,
-0.7706100345,
0.5428507924,
0.26967448,
-0.4763908088,
-0.403706193,
-0.5691239238,
-0.6713552475,
0.5262089372,
-0.2612703443,
-0.7693834901,
-0.0523668788,
0.283470422,
-0.5865960121,
0.0786725432,
-0.6709381938,
0.8954290152,
-0.0379093215,
-0.1391125023,
-0.3166392446,
-0.6278693676,
0.7105634809,
-0.1279694736,
0.1105117202,
-0.4934318066,
0.295217365,
0.5419970155,
-0.3408444226,
0.8736212254,
0.1445883811,
-0.3113600612,
0.2746059299,
0.1676368117,
0.6380663514,
0.447242707,
0.069210358,
-0.033955019,
0.1805436164,
-0.3762566447,
-0.9571085572,
0.4481021762,
-0.6741551757,
-0.8986642361,
-0.3722484112,
-0.6397263408,
-0.5020002127,
-0.0894824341,
0.0030946068,
0.7043722868,
-0.5332340598,
0.184811011,
1.1586894989,
-0.1625792533,
0.1376782954,
0.8662740588,
-0.0203885511,
-0.1748569906,
0.6901602149,
-0.0368558243,
0.4937272668,
0.2637531459,
-0.0574216805,
-0.4785600901,
-0.7645630836,
-0.7197329402,
0.3983685076,
-0.5844059587,
-0.1906453371,
-0.6832841039,
-0.2813377976,
-0.4435529411,
0.2518852353,
-0.2512141168,
-0.2167795002,
-0.197520718,
-0.1219373271,
0.0378465205,
0.6766381264,
0.1225223318,
0.1947552264,
-0.9568066597,
0.5124850869,
0.3801712394,
0.0282018781,
-0.1612169147,
-0.862985909,
-0.3819708526,
0.3258865774,
-0.3805038333,
-0.5668442845,
-0.0009973523,
0.1126413345,
0.5370374918,
0.4047594965,
0.1382561475,
0.6438031793,
-0.422690779,
0.8482381701,
0.1032359824,
-1.0095671415,
0.165455386,
-0.2922926247,
0.5595582128,
0.7393326759,
0.112684086,
-0.5803254247,
-0.7758363485,
-0.6603772044,
-0.5066784024,
0.6545663476,
0.4529078305,
0.0975973159,
0.1689078808,
0.1206555218,
0.0298114866,
0.2823286355,
-0.3604402542,
-0.2708168924,
-0.1693321466,
-0.2785968781,
-0.2206025273,
-0.4602636993,
-0.3634179831,
-0.1084919646,
0.6361043453,
-0.269918859,
0.0021961359,
0.2111828923,
-0.2190271318,
-0.0123948036,
0.3108574748,
0.9015368819,
1.1834660769,
-0.3184057176,
0.21062693,
0.5539203882,
-0.3017438352,
0.1376020461,
0.0145238759,
-0.1237638965,
0.1275428534,
0.6406478286,
0.8481720686,
0.3071035445,
-0.9422366619,
0.4612727761,
-0.2244646549,
-0.2164220065,
-0.0794974864,
0.3271026611,
0.1560395062,
0.2810654044,
0.2677865326,
0.0777489543,
0.1181211621,
-0.7286034226,
0.1373561621,
0.5030638576,
0.004686472,
-0.2315629721,
0.1931489408,
0.2663866282,
0.1249115244,
0.6588636637,
-0.1831565797,
-0.5610349178,
0.569768548,
0.3936344385,
0.5460898876,
-0.0891954675,
0.4169466197,
0.4026652277,
0.3554904759,
-0.0712568834,
0.1118464321,
-0.0552511103,
-1.0170116425,
-0.7252013087,
-0.4587761462,
-0.7340797782,
0.0849074274,
-0.3258957565,
0.0491351448,
-0.1719095856,
0.1125578135,
-0.2272224873,
0.1773709059,
-0.3673040271,
0.4294469953,
-0.0228401646,
0.6871783733,
-0.6059734225,
0.6090291739,
0.2605418563,
-0.117437683,
-0.948192656,
-0.008307877,
0.0786607414,
-0.70926404,
0.3248696923,
-0.1123663858,
-0.2766981423,
-0.0927422494,
-0.3257100582,
-0.8353320956,
1.0227842331,
0.5251140594,
-0.7453038096,
-0.010782294,
0.1718805134,
0.5412507653,
-0.3538713157,
0.5878978968,
0.7797594666,
0.4877336323,
0.3274962306,
-1.2078074217,
0.0081602475,
0.0667624697,
-0.1985333711,
-0.1762980372,
-0.6666582823,
0.4501053393,
-0.3843010366,
-0.2818126082,
0.1540396214,
0.5799815059,
0.5012702346,
0.5598276854,
0.5865879059,
0.5576828718,
0.9555235505,
-0.1974522322,
0.7181853652,
-0.2510981262,
0.4273345172,
1.207256794,
-0.3454166353,
0.3988612592,
0.0573097095,
-0.1549405456,
0.5538374186,
0.4755929112,
0.0484363846,
0.2648514509,
0.1182513088,
-0.4804522693,
-0.2942278981,
-0.1016577855,
-0.1945651323,
0.6353981495,
0.1439711303,
-0.1325812042,
-0.3108636141,
-0.30168733,
0.1143750548,
0.0498923995,
-0.1467875242,
1.1522123814,
0.0682201982,
-0.746127665,
0.7712755203,
-0.0340127125,
0.2327518463,
-0.6571079493,
0.0110274898,
-0.4310671687,
-0.1315316111,
-0.1305988431,
-0.7000544071,
0.3561109006,
0.0052820202,
-0.173487708,
0.1640169621,
0.4879316092,
-0.6498680115,
-0.3126198947,
-0.3185474873,
0.7322071195,
0.266754359,
0.0355570093,
-0.5498617887,
0.2914685011,
0.2359782308,
-0.0237423219,
0.1645855159,
0.5275567174,
0.2563236356,
0.6524652839,
0.5303994417,
-0.0190946348,
-0.1410378516,
0.0470758006,
0.7409819365,
-0.4174847603,
-0.2408344299,
-1.0384236574,
0.5283888578,
-0.1542675495,
-0.2013605386,
0.9410854578,
0.6494476199,
0.6004859209,
0.0989680812,
0.7599513531,
0.159276709,
0.5422883034,
-0.8349255323,
0.4675817788,
-0.1843843758,
0.3834391832,
-0.180037111,
-1.032427907,
0.0559465215,
0.4325517118,
-0.2036368996,
-0.2433279008,
0.8074448705,
0.8833994269,
-0.063682355,
0.1801130772,
0.5339593887,
0.5127236247,
0.3100756109,
0.3002595305,
0.8234459758,
-0.2687136531,
0.4053405225,
0.1309291422,
-0.1247636229,
-0.2456641495,
-0.809633553,
-0.9837891459,
-0.4421696663,
-0.402654469,
-0.3965177834,
0.0918961987,
0.8705926538,
0.5244110823,
-0.856087625,
-0.321398288,
0.050595589,
0.5012338161,
-0.021647986,
-0.181306228,
0.2928809822,
-0.5311276913,
-0.8657580614,
0.5411564112,
0.3035245538,
0.0671839193,
-0.2481952608,
-0.0956919119,
-0.0594979525,
0.3382230699,
0.6402384043,
0.1352701485,
-0.7352892756,
-0.3864633739,
-0.1181117818,
-0.0897604004,
0.0410971455,
0.7571847439,
-0.5773088336,
0.5919826031,
0.4360235929,
0.6976124644,
0.4521198273,
0.6103650928,
0.6974892616,
-0.4958047867,
-0.3244191706,
0.0620430075,
0.3838866949,
0.5026084781,
-0.2373343557,
0.3187150657,
0.4114352763,
-0.6493010521,
-0.6957660317,
0.2341297716,
-1.1560491323,
0.0409933776,
1.1318401098,
-0.4277690053,
0.100626573,
-0.429084897,
-0.4272833765,
0.2281914353,
-0.3131520748,
0.8510510325,
0.8667572141,
-0.3411744833,
-0.0733597428,
-0.4765082896,
0.5532237291,
0.5130975842,
-0.723380208,
0.1504946649,
0.6104618311,
0.5419763327,
0.1836214364,
0.7377837896,
0.2249032855,
0.1388299167,
-0.300206542,
-0.4107534587,
0.0945803598,
-0.2484491467,
0.0344228446,
0.0447382294,
0.0817825124,
0.0668509826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07172v1
|
VerityMath: Advancing Mathematical Reasoning by Self-Verification Through Unit Consistency
| 2023-11-13T09:06:58 | 2023-11-13T09:06:58 |
Vernon Toh, Ratish Puduppully, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) combined with program-based solving techniques
are increasingly demonstrating proficiency in mathematical reasoning. However,
such progress is mostly demonstrated in closed-source models such as
OpenAI-GPT4 and Claude. In this paper, we seek to study the performance of
strong open-source LLMs. Specifically, we analyze the outputs of Code Llama
(7B) when applied to math word problems. We identify a category of problems
that pose a challenge for the model, particularly those involving quantities
that span multiple types or units. To address this issue, we propose a
systematic approach by defining units for each quantity and ensuring the
consistency of these units during mathematical operations. We developed Unit
Consistency Programs (UCPs), an annotated dataset of math word problems, each
paired with programs that contain unit specifications and unit verification
routines. Finally, we finetune the Code Llama (7B) model with UCPs to produce
VerityMath and present our preliminary findings.
|
[
0.0320409127,
-0.4126319289,
0.8636417985,
0.5087212324,
-0.1445706636,
-0.086773701,
-0.2339877188,
-0.2659570277,
-0.0117975008,
0.7547505498,
-0.0293133501,
-0.5165805221,
-0.6857007146,
0.3091768622,
-0.2527932525,
0.4428174794,
-0.6591980457,
0.0991925225,
-0.3705431521,
-0.71084553,
-0.8177659512,
-0.6527950168,
0.056365937,
-0.50914675,
0.068459861,
0.3765846491,
1.1413003206,
0.8506737947,
0.7450694442,
0.3662883043,
0.392195195,
0.1816692054,
-0.4759523571,
0.4355890453,
-0.192411691,
-0.6508389115,
-0.1292183697,
-0.0218157992,
0.9046927691,
0.5339325666,
-0.4841729701,
0.1454010308,
-0.0595775098,
0.5762252808,
-0.5037350059,
0.1873582006,
-0.7198219299,
-0.3231327832,
-0.3261328936,
0.4361073971,
-0.2830868661,
-0.5979227424,
-0.4583267868,
-0.8203094602,
-0.1459746361,
0.0119134719,
0.817676425,
0.4663149416,
0.0004498528,
-0.5977496505,
-0.7491730452,
0.9341431856,
-0.7180710435,
0.5864505172,
0.4947153628,
0.3022884429,
-0.3781267107,
-0.4319322705,
-0.5075542927,
-0.3251526356,
0.290189445,
-0.0210834052,
-0.5588077903,
-0.1727217883,
0.349021107,
0.5775806308,
-0.4506566226,
0.1153109968,
-0.4529639482,
-0.2851783335,
0.6956045628,
0.1833650023,
0.2922347784,
0.1065028757,
0.0487295948,
0.1413752735,
-0.8495239019,
-0.2681458592,
0.4370967746,
-0.1647159457,
0.0850821435,
1.283998847,
-0.1682289988,
0.4724388719,
-0.3612231612,
-0.3656040132,
0.0462737642,
-0.118967548,
-0.4932776988,
-0.1392356753,
0.6044817567,
-0.2073578984,
0.4286479652,
0.0536522865,
-0.3265525103,
0.492536813,
0.1930999756,
-0.6435619593,
-0.3678402603,
0.1102726981,
-0.3712814152,
0.0726911575,
-0.2108550668,
0.0583000444,
-0.1188943237,
-0.7559448481,
0.8029124141,
-0.589186728,
-0.0591118149,
0.4081567824,
0.3255172968,
-0.221726954,
0.4628313482,
-0.6212047935,
0.1446729451,
0.9007664323,
0.6668080688,
-0.037865039,
-0.2707865834,
-0.4771745205,
-0.0284060165,
-0.616558075,
0.3978579342,
-0.3969673514,
-0.4482496679,
-0.1635021269,
-0.4156825542,
0.2288839519,
-0.7998118401,
0.5453674793,
-0.3596485555,
-0.066680111,
-0.330134213,
-0.917258203,
0.0167482197,
0.3413007855,
-0.623196125,
1.0695999861,
0.3788478374,
-0.491497308,
-0.1088994369,
-0.4323686063,
0.0174799524,
0.1264468431,
-0.5722532272,
-0.5301377177,
0.4628716111,
-0.0129967527,
0.0541858934,
-0.1940862834,
0.3257698417,
-0.4196932614,
-0.3282909393,
0.4312315285,
-0.5458450913,
0.7541393042,
0.3401230574,
-0.1876906306,
-0.0236151852,
-0.8834606409,
0.0726259127,
0.333781004,
-0.1986923218,
-0.4108156264,
-0.0591840968,
-0.6144868135,
-0.202610001,
0.4179880023,
-0.5857205391,
0.4114784598,
-0.0185779724,
0.0834459364,
0.7782344222,
-0.5609244108,
0.1349188685,
-0.2463129014,
0.3664749861,
-0.0570408255,
0.0418329053,
-0.120658502,
-0.9211072326,
-0.7218734622,
-0.2868131995,
0.235842526,
0.3503880799,
-0.6502879858,
0.1792895198,
0.0502146035,
-0.3819879591,
-0.6269623041,
0.5208641291,
0.3160201609,
0.4068540335,
0.3473368883,
-0.1031993777,
-0.4108126462,
-0.9126258492,
-0.3622529805,
-0.3274199069,
-0.1868122816,
0.1051040068,
0.2775009871,
-0.4139982164,
1.0182238817,
-0.5127743483,
-0.0717254803,
0.0143062258,
0.1070459932,
0.294598639,
0.4264265001,
0.1853167862,
-0.2043519616,
-0.2226076424,
-0.1812060028,
-0.9795252681,
-0.5963588357,
0.2057506293,
-0.2232754081,
0.1487264037,
0.2576912344,
-0.338116467,
0.5132884383,
0.9020606875,
-0.2789900601,
0.7590015531,
-0.3716214001,
-0.0399293862,
-0.9170407653,
-0.2135224044,
0.0365092419,
-0.0885629505,
-0.3264466524,
0.1910228729,
0.2379661202,
-0.0329449214,
-0.1345378906,
0.3250446022,
-0.4532938302,
-0.2266305983,
-0.2320685536,
-0.1694589257,
-0.0006208569,
-0.1083260626,
-0.2573140562,
0.9501383901,
0.3891710937,
-0.5627108216,
0.2861649096,
0.0234378744,
-0.1848481894,
0.691262126,
-0.7592089772,
0.0591233559,
0.0062510096,
0.0144545157,
-0.8503527641,
-0.1743866205,
0.0728693828,
-0.3030635715,
-0.1194050014,
0.0630727857,
-0.7600830793,
-0.3442140222,
0.0499398075,
0.72398597,
0.5124458671,
-0.6373112798,
0.6189321876,
0.027959168,
0.2149011642,
-0.6110221744,
-0.4256620109,
-0.0892272666,
0.1105213165,
-0.7983033061,
-0.035227824,
-0.2305590063,
-0.8560130596,
-0.0130124614,
-0.2783351243,
-0.0580740683,
0.2752416134,
0.2735313773,
0.4585964084,
-0.5227044821,
0.2692010999,
-0.1636581123,
-0.0340868719,
0.1809908748,
-0.4012247026,
0.4131601155,
-0.5193681717,
-0.9686786532,
-0.2594160736,
0.2725182772,
0.1948342174,
-0.1508670896,
0.3788640201,
0.4689414501,
-0.5511187315,
-0.1286484748,
-0.651486218,
0.2079164386,
-0.5065876245,
0.0096365847,
-0.6439340115,
-1.1281937361,
0.5360825062,
0.1181642115,
0.2852287889,
0.7865004539,
0.6852527261,
0.0726125389,
0.7620745897,
0.5524010062,
0.0603604317,
-0.0644938424,
0.0141087584,
0.0982606336,
-0.5349780917,
-0.283015877,
-0.6463546157,
-0.1287846714,
-0.3466732502,
-0.7901489735,
0.3106843531,
0.5690840483,
-0.4170033038,
0.3749320507,
-0.5190138221,
0.7715477943,
0.4718590081,
-0.3010650277,
0.7436759472,
0.025158653,
-0.3013568819,
-0.2051566094,
-0.2887578905,
-0.7050091624,
1.3946852684,
0.4978168905,
1.1374897957,
0.4815074801,
0.9134138823,
-0.0275349617,
0.9040793777,
-0.6379438043,
0.4002170563,
-0.1171618029,
-0.4339728653,
-0.3383594751,
-0.7368465662,
-1.079952836,
0.2674588561,
0.19140701,
-0.8164691925,
-0.2422754914,
0.0104794279,
0.0058176601,
0.3723614216,
-0.502219677,
0.4735672176,
-0.3148052692,
-0.1028800458,
-0.2407768369,
-0.1418180466,
0.7701695561,
-0.147572577,
0.1588363647,
-0.5077027678,
-0.0611162707,
0.3264215887,
-0.725071609,
0.3936503232,
0.367631644,
-0.5503382683,
0.4656783342,
0.5931046009,
0.2236358523,
0.3662552536,
-0.0810210109,
0.7984969616,
-0.2048803419,
-0.4889879227,
-0.4605687559,
0.7316188216,
-1.0284913778,
-0.7525189519,
-0.3044282496,
-0.8419498801,
-0.1591421813,
0.2084614187,
0.0917330384,
0.2900928557,
-0.0327722505,
0.1273548901,
1.0116159916,
0.0892959014,
0.3439683914,
0.4530006647,
-0.6276137233,
-0.6612797379,
0.7263210416,
0.2526039779,
0.3613398075,
0.1524138302,
0.330887109,
-0.3853639662,
-0.358694464,
-0.7131175399,
0.3238219619,
-0.8332362771,
-0.5557235479,
-0.2712881267,
-0.2553419173,
-0.3516718447,
-0.106308639,
-0.5205838084,
-0.3931621313,
-0.292947799,
0.4617883861,
0.2210227102,
1.0999363661,
-0.1045253426,
0.1098690927,
-0.8646745086,
0.5536059141,
0.430570811,
0.7979338169,
-0.3606763482,
-0.4628083408,
0.0080228914,
0.0087349182,
-0.5687115192,
-0.8265861273,
0.1259946227,
-0.2199195176,
0.70343256,
0.3807848692,
-0.2382252663,
0.4142596722,
-0.1858967394,
0.5585466027,
0.4587506652,
-1.34677279,
0.3094731867,
-0.2343746871,
0.4309877753,
0.3487017453,
0.2916938066,
-0.3942896426,
-0.4191578627,
-0.6745588779,
-0.1180219948,
0.2045793682,
0.8644786477,
-0.1538692415,
0.0707371905,
0.2831272483,
0.1791645437,
0.1296163052,
-0.4646088779,
-0.253387481,
-0.4365481734,
-0.5926395655,
-0.0286303088,
-0.0437965393,
-0.1484180391,
-0.1010520905,
0.5063380003,
-0.1357824951,
-0.0036949692,
0.1567908376,
-0.1244333088,
-0.0502434783,
0.3322809041,
0.7883486152,
0.9302864671,
0.0963249877,
0.2504224181,
0.0004547812,
-0.7023907304,
0.3868552446,
0.1131498814,
-0.1769323647,
0.3148977757,
0.055785846,
0.2945889831,
0.091330111,
-0.6083050966,
0.296454668,
0.0387098119,
-0.3649424314,
-0.1602613628,
-0.0090200519,
0.1989483684,
0.1253255457,
0.2353134453,
-0.1078317761,
-0.0923482254,
-0.4442542493,
0.0155090792,
0.3279052675,
0.1383542269,
-0.0204466656,
0.6899905801,
-0.2510763109,
-0.4137509763,
0.8681198359,
-0.2154299617,
-0.439152956,
0.7620977759,
0.8076807857,
0.538447082,
-0.4234331548,
0.074826844,
0.2315011322,
0.4624002576,
-0.6280648708,
0.5442044735,
0.1671780795,
-0.7179739475,
-0.4012840986,
-0.6403117776,
-0.8108503819,
0.0289986767,
-0.3625085652,
0.1607046127,
-0.5593508482,
0.0441215895,
-0.1500242054,
-0.0153740728,
-0.6439342499,
0.0913558081,
0.3450407386,
0.76233989,
-0.5207915902,
0.8859292269,
0.5440482497,
-0.3395618796,
-1.444483757,
-0.3972545862,
-0.0471802764,
-1.1463979483,
0.3317221105,
0.2264173478,
-0.0195971951,
-0.2326266021,
-0.6916248202,
-1.3008271456,
1.0021600723,
0.6234092712,
-0.8787981868,
0.3866552114,
0.4495274127,
0.341103673,
-0.255933255,
0.1070368588,
0.3594228029,
0.4273489416,
0.1641199738,
-1.0991473198,
-0.0002232624,
0.0800731182,
0.1876121163,
0.371403724,
-0.4892324805,
1.0698045492,
-0.2872155905,
-0.0188872814,
0.2621794045,
1.0304403305,
0.9177075624,
0.5519280434,
0.257968843,
0.9891536832,
1.1045943499,
-0.2334072441,
0.7417371273,
-0.0853424221,
0.3747117817,
1.0218286514,
-0.3041448593,
0.8132317066,
0.2480752617,
-0.3893714845,
0.6291232705,
0.1640657187,
-0.2758257687,
-0.2777638137,
0.6998707056,
-0.1200722754,
-0.410553813,
0.187841773,
-0.5894887447,
0.4207480848,
0.3588992357,
-0.288716048,
-0.3826439083,
-0.256334573,
-0.00513358,
0.2299128324,
-0.4985698164,
0.2826383412,
0.3321173489,
-0.6689521074,
0.6183075905,
0.2166348845,
0.4643262923,
-0.5688910484,
-0.1169390604,
-0.2975563109,
0.2095428109,
-0.2159891874,
-0.8719661236,
0.3859432936,
-0.1266818196,
-0.0135138752,
0.1821666062,
0.6597355604,
-0.3187398612,
-0.8161555529,
-0.312156409,
0.5505654812,
0.342559129,
-0.1384392977,
-0.4562824965,
0.4984752536,
-0.1724007875,
0.3905163109,
0.188936621,
0.610668242,
-0.3139066994,
0.7701885104,
0.6758766174,
-0.1761227995,
0.2255695909,
0.2281975448,
0.6864903569,
-0.4304298162,
-0.2543954253,
-0.9025412798,
0.1160209253,
0.0900950432,
-0.3430812955,
1.0033937693,
0.7818959355,
0.7189582586,
0.1036471948,
0.4826408625,
0.4290477037,
0.018208798,
-0.4219173789,
0.2851151526,
-0.2346289605,
0.5536996126,
-0.0062558977,
-1.0186693668,
-0.3261996806,
0.4987779856,
-0.1237954199,
-0.2660639286,
0.6289447546,
0.45087412,
-0.1957227588,
0.0989516824,
0.50662148,
0.0135220662,
0.2206564993,
0.5724640489,
0.8124896288,
-0.3650581837,
0.6290042996,
-0.0544946268,
-0.0836675242,
-0.1252235323,
-0.7142766118,
-0.6247181892,
-0.1801160127,
-0.373552382,
-0.8240008354,
-0.2070239335,
0.7929108143,
0.3755295575,
-0.5494920015,
-0.4172744155,
-0.2387888581,
0.4144378901,
-0.0295248497,
-0.1416216046,
0.1107816547,
-0.4084889591,
-0.333512485,
0.2036534101,
0.4372065067,
0.1986167878,
-0.6540465951,
-0.1725246608,
0.411375612,
0.5314698219,
0.4077726603,
0.3371122181,
-1.0063103437,
-0.0588899143,
0.1105917543,
-0.3435094655,
0.3564857244,
0.9344803691,
-0.521366179,
0.3731321692,
0.375410974,
0.7799445391,
0.0828763023,
0.1935314834,
0.5104925036,
-0.2897027731,
-0.4614614248,
0.215280816,
0.6056614518,
0.4204126894,
-0.2084521204,
0.5150767565,
0.4088620543,
-0.6940607429,
-0.6053361297,
0.475489229,
-0.9461598396,
-0.2191973478,
1.2797148228,
-0.3292675614,
-0.1758727729,
-0.1520836055,
-0.054997012,
-0.0124582127,
-0.248026669,
0.8912631869,
0.9107105136,
-0.0714246333,
0.2457050681,
-0.2916200459,
-0.0108325128,
0.5704336762,
-0.8267410994,
-0.0706587657,
0.6578367949,
0.5611767173,
0.3249869645,
0.6521331668,
-0.2247260362,
0.12374001,
0.2167936265,
0.0207419675,
-0.0477133244,
-0.1589962989,
-0.4017061889,
0.2849110663,
0.2030439675,
-0.0225090235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07171v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07171v1
|
calamanCy: A Tagalog Natural Language Processing Toolkit
| 2023-11-13T09:06:43 | 2023-11-13T09:06:43 |
Lester James V. Miranda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce calamanCy, an open-source toolkit for constructing natural
language processing (NLP) pipelines for Tagalog. It is built on top of spaCy,
enabling easy experimentation and integration with other frameworks. calamanCy
addresses the development gap by providing a consistent API for building NLP
applications and offering general-purpose multitask models with out-of-the-box
support for dependency parsing, parts-of-speech (POS) tagging, and named entity
recognition (NER). calamanCy aims to accelerate the progress of Tagalog NLP by
consolidating disjointed resources in a unified framework. The calamanCy
toolkit is available on GitHub: https://github.com/ljvmiranda921/calamanCy.
|
[
-0.4529817402,
-0.2754120529,
-0.1098675206,
0.5965024829,
-0.365288794,
0.2055135518,
-0.2538935244,
-0.4807863235,
0.7056919336,
1.1169953346,
-0.4746138155,
-0.5131884217,
-0.2089264542,
0.2036468834,
-0.0563014038,
1.2476037741,
0.1369402856,
-0.0398094878,
0.5624851584,
-0.0277198665,
-0.5848731995,
-0.1291680038,
-0.5756211281,
-0.3930180371,
0.6293689013,
0.5559877157,
0.5956370234,
0.6120346785,
0.4778538346,
0.1569049209,
0.1943422705,
0.3849650323,
-0.0663110688,
0.5637348294,
-0.6510938406,
-0.732196331,
-0.4164319336,
0.0429413095,
0.1719684899,
0.6626955271,
-0.4336939454,
0.2342265546,
-0.195933342,
0.5328174233,
-1.1325650215,
0.3388802409,
-0.8562414646,
0.0018073529,
-0.7299561501,
-0.5719732046,
-0.2950404882,
-0.5383691192,
-0.1157540604,
-0.5337859392,
0.1652521193,
-0.2568981946,
0.4129430354,
0.4184578061,
-0.1836325377,
-0.6551750302,
-0.3469511867,
0.6409602165,
-0.8062598109,
0.3449971378,
0.683341682,
0.4558596313,
-0.4767155349,
-0.6711698771,
-0.5302709341,
-0.0712108314,
0.1978541315,
-0.0879465714,
0.251879096,
0.4211864173,
0.174746424,
0.4821849167,
-0.6931854486,
-0.0011034706,
-0.3267035782,
-0.3407224715,
0.4390491247,
-0.164469406,
0.4703312218,
-0.6664370298,
-0.4214735031,
0.3696890473,
-0.6711990833,
-0.1422773451,
0.6139913201,
0.4863684773,
0.2733819485,
0.907965064,
-0.0796115771,
0.6419940591,
-0.2597623169,
-0.2393015325,
0.0243900549,
-0.426556617,
-0.4045306742,
0.8244200945,
0.679711163,
0.3767908514,
0.097568281,
-0.2324360907,
0.0541761294,
0.2758597434,
0.0310115982,
-0.7046444416,
-0.5491268039,
0.2065916061,
0.0371970832,
-0.0492161848,
0.0189894009,
-1.160774827,
-0.6671571136,
-0.1534818262,
-0.1631214023,
-0.3454162776,
-0.2588405907,
0.1671431661,
-0.0840806067,
0.1314376593,
0.2481530458,
-1.0717656612,
0.243271783,
0.8981107473,
1.187125206,
0.1118936166,
-0.1882469803,
-0.9355764389,
0.1682385653,
-0.268650651,
0.9809891582,
-0.5045733452,
-0.4150714278,
-0.2807454467,
0.0938491747,
-0.1681065261,
-0.6747606993,
0.9775747657,
-0.1630398035,
-0.0364763886,
-0.2032481432,
-0.1605330706,
-0.2444088906,
0.0896029398,
-0.8570023775,
1.0881375074,
-0.0086713247,
-1.1686584949,
0.3358412385,
-0.7902119756,
-0.0632081032,
0.4376666248,
0.0897445306,
0.3850060403,
0.1854897738,
0.3524269164,
0.2982069254,
-0.4351889789,
0.5342700481,
-0.1214639992,
-0.3542337716,
0.0835427567,
-0.1572170556,
1.1696771383,
0.4960744083,
-0.1388340145,
-0.1325051337,
-0.8497065902,
-0.0402211621,
-0.3841122389,
-0.4215352833,
-0.4098902643,
-0.0586940385,
0.2870950997,
0.3253259063,
0.2370766699,
-0.7305938601,
0.5258973837,
-1.2136821747,
0.4824988544,
0.5631078482,
-0.0002008904,
0.4605327249,
-0.0170876328,
0.6722255349,
-0.2640464604,
-0.4306192994,
-0.6125271916,
-0.7112203836,
-0.7559511662,
-0.2688650191,
0.4004551768,
0.9390933514,
-0.998862803,
0.379522264,
-0.092066586,
-0.7773910761,
-0.8709897399,
0.4701979756,
0.1801470667,
0.3381508589,
0.0997480974,
-0.8345676064,
-0.9689045548,
-0.8010688424,
-0.3846009374,
-0.3723836541,
0.0684624761,
-0.191862002,
0.3927920163,
-0.4451052547,
1.0930076838,
-0.3102306128,
-0.4322844148,
-0.1570021063,
0.3324334323,
0.3251595795,
0.3886668384,
0.563082397,
-0.6358537674,
-0.3990704119,
0.3184817135,
-0.2326514572,
-0.6849678755,
0.2676290572,
-0.2329948395,
0.2168991119,
-0.0065812739,
-0.9141188264,
0.7061457634,
0.555526197,
-0.0305229314,
0.7326806188,
-0.0850090384,
0.1092177704,
-1.3018641472,
0.4315964282,
-0.1837891936,
-0.1393874586,
-0.6110520363,
0.0862765536,
-0.170421198,
-0.0928964168,
-0.4605439305,
0.6961061954,
0.1950154454,
-0.0599994063,
-0.3153077662,
0.1400778592,
-0.009504715,
0.0550024509,
-0.230740726,
1.0430986881,
0.4231805503,
-0.2775466442,
0.8635519743,
-0.1732720137,
-0.1010024995,
0.8266007304,
-0.4234670699,
-0.1877021343,
0.0757940859,
0.2210012376,
-0.9604139924,
-0.6739142537,
0.5475383997,
-0.5228599906,
0.048835896,
-0.2656445801,
-0.9190072417,
-0.3502722979,
-0.5111265779,
0.1097199395,
-0.2640051544,
-0.5682030916,
0.2825107872,
0.562633872,
-0.3962198198,
-0.7573475242,
-1.0760666132,
0.5137565732,
-0.1988798678,
-0.2745901346,
0.3205127716,
-0.0719384253,
-0.190956682,
-0.2101704031,
0.027460644,
-0.5103684664,
-0.1308969408,
0.570289731,
0.1226061657,
-0.050511688,
0.3334797919,
0.0037133163,
-0.3873496056,
-0.1941908747,
-0.2463153899,
0.7721912265,
0.0555456914,
-0.2293871045,
-0.4635884464,
0.1577322036,
0.5055710673,
-0.5575504899,
0.5164914131,
0.6769367456,
-0.554294467,
-0.2388560176,
-0.6578219533,
0.2437088341,
-0.4223135114,
0.0345445909,
-0.0477850921,
-0.6842432022,
0.5953216553,
-0.3075557947,
0.2501484752,
0.2227624357,
0.7332465053,
0.4274304807,
0.8173778653,
0.4279901683,
-0.1655392051,
0.2402474582,
0.0155654978,
0.5875109434,
-0.7010989189,
-0.1214329749,
-0.6787102222,
-0.1233948693,
-0.8926344514,
-0.7267152667,
-0.3074333668,
0.3948164582,
0.0934918448,
0.8233195543,
-0.9248416424,
0.4840649068,
0.4140844047,
-0.5181229115,
0.3748608828,
-0.2000698447,
-0.2372613549,
-0.3530215025,
-0.5043306947,
-0.7543531656,
0.9008458257,
0.0575764477,
0.8039004207,
-0.0268524773,
0.9061598182,
-0.1643110961,
0.205951333,
-0.8691003919,
0.5985071659,
-0.0550019592,
-0.8096948862,
0.4594517052,
-0.2887574136,
-1.0639207363,
0.052329652,
0.242238611,
-1.4654521942,
0.0921269953,
-0.0563597493,
-0.4017798305,
0.596133709,
-0.8669317365,
0.8887054324,
-0.1119225547,
-0.226436168,
0.0797488317,
-0.4987964928,
0.6705445051,
-0.0074382098,
0.2494335026,
-0.4959795773,
-0.2008265108,
0.5690374374,
-0.2905071974,
0.4650602937,
-0.2223494202,
-0.0610627867,
0.4651142061,
0.4583102167,
-0.2038733512,
0.6113223433,
-0.2853430212,
0.0295339264,
0.4285028875,
-0.1246555299,
-0.456959933,
1.2126820087,
-0.2554219961,
-0.0338247493,
-0.6362063885,
-0.6625202894,
0.2473934144,
0.2310741842,
0.0427586474,
0.1986838579,
0.1673484296,
-0.0622066855,
0.3133569062,
-0.2654237151,
0.6673039198,
0.168211326,
-0.791280508,
-0.6514672041,
0.9484559894,
0.3010064065,
-0.2701407075,
0.2674765885,
-0.1396884471,
-0.0674809739,
0.0286191963,
-0.3499383628,
0.3404158354,
-0.6409153342,
-0.4005779028,
-0.5328219533,
-0.1783653349,
-0.4457451105,
-0.2038394213,
-0.738050282,
-0.6459492445,
-0.3114472926,
0.158192724,
0.229730919,
0.5691367388,
-0.1334108263,
0.3583959043,
-0.7943846583,
0.4109050632,
0.3863258064,
0.4887261093,
-0.3025568724,
0.0624292418,
-0.2038527429,
0.1894329488,
-0.5182685852,
-1.0474585295,
0.7957232594,
0.3459793925,
0.2555918694,
0.4096384943,
0.0020682081,
0.8051707745,
-0.4255055487,
0.9409323335,
0.0986754596,
-0.8218140602,
1.0833743811,
-0.3433669209,
0.5398685336,
0.7491384149,
0.2869155109,
-0.7305060625,
-0.2346354723,
-0.2726272047,
-0.8005418181,
0.6787928939,
0.2466939241,
-0.1652460098,
-0.2189668864,
0.3792432249,
0.3771197498,
0.4575962424,
-0.5151856542,
0.0278985202,
-0.1929146498,
-0.0274490006,
-0.1048568264,
0.0677090734,
0.0469062254,
-0.2534284294,
0.4774558544,
-0.2020371258,
0.0607937053,
0.0589684695,
-0.1762462407,
-0.0254453737,
0.5057119727,
0.3423424363,
0.8543431759,
-0.5385671258,
0.4980622232,
-0.0987482741,
-0.7356869578,
-0.006532351,
0.4885795712,
0.1956667006,
0.2618798912,
0.0952885672,
0.5973212719,
0.5100127459,
-1.0905672312,
0.1560681909,
-0.1568762809,
0.3505609035,
-0.1676259786,
0.4501207173,
0.0942682549,
0.1878376454,
0.4426479936,
0.2246320546,
0.1770701706,
-0.6454592943,
0.0916201696,
0.0007516174,
-0.4017151892,
-0.4598961174,
0.6233263016,
-0.1497762948,
-0.6131682396,
0.176047489,
-0.4495841563,
-0.5336334705,
0.2437950373,
0.3459388614,
0.8123050332,
-0.5315033197,
0.4437187314,
0.3841068447,
0.2981210053,
-0.0245715845,
0.2867035568,
-0.2791543901,
-0.3485409319,
-0.6830796599,
-0.9125193357,
-0.4500513673,
-0.3246712387,
-0.3336355388,
0.4584318399,
-0.5646950603,
-0.3798349798,
0.2328006029,
0.315961808,
-0.4804589152,
-0.1737112999,
-0.022578327,
0.8234956861,
-0.3928289711,
1.0979237556,
0.9340224266,
-0.218689248,
-0.4702716768,
-0.3545447886,
0.2786825001,
-0.3773215413,
0.7557244897,
0.7570434213,
0.0448299497,
0.0286196247,
-0.3253718317,
-0.6150132418,
1.0192949772,
0.7810006738,
-0.2048280835,
-0.2826680541,
0.3223884702,
0.4385756552,
-0.2691916227,
0.2130269259,
0.8106841445,
0.3773342669,
0.0800950304,
-1.4490023851,
-0.5519871116,
-0.3561197221,
0.0851424783,
0.488365382,
-0.1219000667,
0.7980624437,
0.1909162551,
-0.3779520392,
0.2698141336,
0.0751499012,
0.4761604965,
0.4820505679,
0.0509975962,
1.042452693,
0.7807945013,
-0.1593134701,
0.6604511142,
-0.3068842292,
0.4503027797,
1.2622417212,
-0.3097459972,
0.7433694601,
0.8069601655,
-0.2483576238,
0.4337595105,
0.5337550044,
0.4015946686,
0.3931874931,
0.0664428324,
-0.4730741978,
0.0993880704,
-0.9001196623,
-0.3146907389,
0.8518688679,
0.5999158621,
-0.0629614145,
-0.780381918,
0.2102341354,
-0.0014417159,
0.1238979772,
-0.4480462372,
0.3378815949,
0.1469368339,
-0.682426393,
0.2464891225,
0.122099556,
0.8217721581,
-0.5909516215,
-0.3084065616,
0.2186462581,
0.0694469735,
-0.4504521191,
-0.8531442285,
0.5673331022,
0.089656055,
0.0580620281,
-0.0067975651,
1.0132803917,
-0.3634921312,
-0.1504487097,
0.2874518037,
0.1530500948,
0.1427109241,
-0.0988042727,
-0.7432373762,
0.1090045124,
-0.1574057043,
0.0260069966,
0.0706794038,
0.4076614082,
0.272081852,
0.6578637362,
0.8521202207,
0.6760076284,
0.4329244196,
-0.2297911495,
0.8646409512,
-0.4437099993,
-0.5464892387,
-0.7276388407,
0.4950298369,
-0.0867981762,
-0.3921881914,
0.7722762227,
0.5912153721,
0.901473999,
0.2395645827,
0.3796973228,
-0.317409575,
0.6665234566,
-0.0436676554,
0.6539703608,
-0.1180009469,
0.3748937845,
-0.2621271908,
-1.4194219112,
-0.7355585694,
0.80976367,
-0.2707213461,
-0.4507220685,
0.4139443934,
1.013759017,
-0.0218009371,
0.3333417773,
0.0280645229,
-0.2226059139,
0.444604367,
0.6669525504,
0.4570740759,
-0.3738740385,
0.105723545,
-0.6557485461,
0.0135884844,
-0.2260746658,
-0.7836877108,
-0.9129527807,
-0.5714601278,
0.0259223133,
-0.0355221145,
-0.1614992917,
1.3578304052,
0.5344201326,
-0.9366535544,
-0.4822210073,
-0.346609205,
0.194712922,
0.3713747859,
-0.3801600635,
0.001253041,
-0.339435786,
-0.7429335117,
0.2710079253,
0.8891292214,
-0.5923371315,
-0.3646887839,
0.1329765767,
-0.9039757252,
-0.0415522493,
0.3827036023,
0.5981256962,
-0.8813150525,
-0.0734449849,
-0.2754068673,
-0.0733711943,
0.1313563138,
0.8913590312,
-0.8502914906,
1.4284259081,
0.640083611,
0.7222310901,
0.123371467,
-0.3794845641,
0.2577316761,
-0.8512862325,
0.7197488546,
0.3675357103,
0.2849183381,
0.4085407853,
0.040248245,
0.7026547194,
0.246235922,
-0.8138028979,
-1.1353745461,
0.1593766958,
-0.902248621,
0.1504543871,
0.5470224023,
-0.1058368087,
-0.2280622274,
-0.2084576488,
-0.8987073302,
0.5038220286,
-0.3167674541,
0.3909834623,
0.7016307712,
-0.102849409,
-0.3765982985,
-1.2593427896,
0.2557463348,
-0.0208300501,
-0.7932687402,
0.0211094636,
0.2200898528,
-0.0787550434,
0.4755528867,
0.494605422,
0.0886802077,
0.4068506658,
-0.2324523181,
0.1852799803,
0.2407048494,
-0.2361797094,
-0.1980825812,
0.1929996163,
-0.0602867529,
0.0636292398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07167v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07167v1
|
STEER: Unified Style Transfer with Expert Reinforcement
| 2023-11-13T09:02:30 | 2023-11-13T09:02:30 |
Skyler Hallinan, Faeze Brahman, Ximing Lu, Jaehun Jung, Sean Welleck, Yejin Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While text style transfer has many applications across natural language
processing, the core premise of transferring from a single source style is
unrealistic in a real-world setting. In this work, we focus on arbitrary style
transfer: rewriting a text from an arbitrary, unknown style to a target style.
We propose STEER: Unified Style Transfer with Expert Reinforcement, a unified
frame-work developed to overcome the challenge of limited parallel data for
style transfer. STEER involves automatically generating a corpus of
style-transfer pairs using a product of experts during decoding. The generated
offline data is then used to pre-train an initial policy before switching to
online, off-policy reinforcement learning for further improvements via
fine-grained reward signals. STEER is unified and can transfer to multiple
target styles from an arbitrary, unknown source style, making it particularly
flexible and efficient.
Experimental results on a challenging dataset with text from a diverse set of
styles demonstrate state-of-the-art results compared to competitive baselines.
Remarkably, STEER outperforms the 175B parameter instruction-tuned GPT-3 on
overall style transfer quality, despite being 226 times smaller in size. We
also show STEER is robust, maintaining its style transfer capabilities on
out-of-domain data, and surpassing nearly all baselines across various styles.
The success of our method highlights the potential of RL algorithms when
augmented with controllable decoding to overcome the challenge of limited data
supervision.
|
[
-0.4393977821,
-0.7175114751,
0.2089261711,
0.5062103271,
-0.2809081078,
0.1818765253,
-0.4957451522,
-0.3913188577,
0.5288769007,
0.6696676016,
-0.7347732782,
-0.2733903229,
-0.570789516,
-0.0063986904,
-0.3602868915,
1.2100306749,
-0.2827748954,
-0.3334289491,
0.2281950861,
-0.2346835285,
-0.7530059218,
-0.4584148228,
-0.6802638769,
-0.5236414671,
0.2511350513,
0.7009346485,
0.8273462057,
0.725546062,
0.3356004953,
0.2525648475,
0.3234118521,
0.2252960205,
-0.7220208645,
0.2249628901,
-0.5734050274,
-0.0969455689,
-0.5945914984,
-0.0256931558,
0.3009283543,
0.303797245,
-0.1752610803,
-0.3480659425,
-0.1492865384,
1.0594352484,
-0.607036531,
0.2145126015,
-0.554265976,
-0.0247250628,
-0.3160549998,
-0.3983302712,
-0.6988521218,
-0.3477402329,
0.1399012804,
-0.9638080001,
0.0053724409,
0.306344837,
0.6911197305,
0.3464711607,
-0.3197522163,
-0.2599059045,
-0.7737131119,
0.6905737519,
-0.2240398973,
0.3327178061,
0.3141159713,
0.3455991149,
-0.0027029463,
-0.7634198666,
-0.304233253,
0.078255482,
-0.1176602915,
0.2047608644,
-0.273370862,
-0.0685547292,
-0.2645871043,
-0.1259472966,
-0.2285361737,
0.1772614419,
-0.3104399741,
-0.2939891517,
0.9891284108,
-0.0785317197,
0.0058520371,
0.0754668415,
-0.52234447,
-0.5434790254,
-0.686221838,
0.1624411494,
0.2086478621,
0.2116820961,
0.048032213,
0.2175938189,
-0.4544116259,
0.4939793944,
0.3790118396,
-0.1724206805,
-0.0781030133,
-0.3068086803,
-0.1157844514,
0.4548393786,
0.7851879001,
0.7955197096,
0.5607582331,
-0.4719668627,
-0.348356992,
-0.3560153246,
0.5372134447,
-0.4749940038,
-0.5251662135,
-0.2721292078,
-0.1418905407,
-0.3939723074,
0.1802865863,
-1.0513290167,
-0.3242415488,
-0.6767566204,
0.490536809,
-0.5119671226,
-0.183591485,
0.3874944448,
-0.2251785249,
0.4766746461,
0.4804369509,
-1.135487318,
0.2161135375,
0.4015320539,
0.5209615827,
-0.6625284553,
-0.2704248428,
-0.5752756,
0.3133606613,
-0.530672729,
0.8821264505,
-0.5242415071,
-0.5162808299,
0.0185579006,
-0.0652927905,
-0.0832841247,
-0.2312220782,
0.5585570335,
-0.4426053762,
0.0179223288,
-0.0961769074,
-0.288161248,
0.0187544283,
-0.2871917784,
-0.5163522959,
0.900985539,
0.1238843277,
-0.6911121607,
0.2846898437,
-0.5627706051,
-0.9548732638,
-0.1906506866,
-0.0013365945,
-0.4471786916,
-0.162247777,
0.5312661529,
0.5288278461,
0.0918643698,
0.3245688081,
-0.3267413974,
-0.5047563314,
0.1557843536,
-0.4215117693,
0.2410103679,
0.1709957868,
-0.5292921066,
0.3820779324,
-0.6709248424,
0.1782218963,
0.2171301246,
-0.1653992534,
-0.4162708223,
-0.2279212922,
0.2875459194,
-0.0768774822,
0.0535652675,
-0.4007203579,
0.6164708734,
-0.0188242532,
0.444989711,
0.9509920478,
-0.1039634123,
0.896646142,
-0.4469985068,
0.3919168413,
-0.7695378661,
-0.1048540398,
0.0461295396,
-0.2252102643,
-0.8640293479,
-0.1202278137,
0.1157671213,
0.4873020351,
-1.148802042,
0.2548002303,
-0.2147727013,
-0.2431088984,
-0.7046710253,
-0.1483365148,
0.5843206644,
0.3939594924,
0.8013855815,
-0.2637877464,
-0.4978277981,
-0.8680435419,
-0.4207001626,
0.0973229483,
0.0448309816,
0.0075528445,
0.1144105271,
0.032649029,
1.175142169,
-0.5316576362,
-0.4675070047,
-0.5828893781,
0.6675146222,
-0.3004046082,
0.5989599824,
0.5306636095,
-0.5788185596,
-0.5428947806,
0.0904396698,
-0.649425745,
-0.217273578,
-0.5626499653,
-0.327180475,
0.2852939963,
0.7768221498,
-0.0908065587,
0.4075470269,
0.3867994249,
-0.3927523792,
0.5906176567,
-0.5405061245,
0.1069229245,
-0.8025715947,
-0.2086725682,
0.1041134,
-0.3162217438,
-0.4938863516,
-0.1481209695,
0.1091583371,
0.3875494003,
-0.4160892069,
0.6338279247,
-0.2850345373,
0.0517493561,
-0.3713079691,
-0.1406192333,
0.2051061243,
0.8148804903,
0.2526271939,
0.9495444894,
0.3988098204,
-0.4334829748,
0.5171601772,
0.3968806863,
-0.0334994234,
1.1708707809,
-0.5872628689,
0.5421991944,
-0.240245685,
0.4291131198,
-0.642247498,
-0.3075175583,
0.2526983917,
-0.0926944837,
0.6577421427,
-0.1599975526,
-0.1781082153,
-0.0816729069,
-0.2151709497,
-0.1805594414,
0.477427572,
-0.6520234942,
0.3680335879,
0.2577233016,
-0.3837170601,
-0.3913105726,
-0.5080513358,
-0.0051601217,
-0.3445737362,
-0.4009599984,
0.7763238549,
-0.1733803302,
-0.0639235526,
0.0615716167,
-0.3742303252,
-0.263130188,
0.0179848466,
-0.0256390497,
0.3556477726,
-0.0082824295,
-0.0447888263,
0.4521927834,
0.0069072801,
0.0040613203,
-0.4371066689,
0.1531258225,
-0.248605907,
-0.2171434462,
-0.6858898997,
0.32810238,
0.5662680268,
-0.3212440014,
0.2717423439,
0.6963522434,
0.3683392704,
-0.5631874204,
-0.2443056703,
-0.1153741479,
-0.5423736572,
0.3558625877,
-0.4441832602,
-0.6467293501,
-0.1437595785,
-0.093482472,
0.1476095617,
0.3600207567,
0.150489375,
-0.2196211964,
0.8668436408,
0.9457259178,
-0.2607634962,
0.5833266973,
-0.2256379128,
-0.2539930344,
-0.486673981,
-0.529994607,
-0.3497413099,
-0.5280562043,
-0.3491436243,
-0.144955799,
0.2100594789,
0.3164817691,
-0.3254084289,
0.6905938387,
-0.7279952168,
0.528537631,
0.7563883662,
0.2400270551,
0.5113290548,
0.0424698927,
-0.1126296371,
0.0422649719,
-0.6612471342,
-0.2060165107,
1.0911229849,
0.1984127909,
1.2467417717,
-0.1072350219,
0.7253885865,
0.7110869288,
0.4605458677,
-0.9524332881,
0.3622355759,
-0.2562138438,
-0.0646614283,
-0.5637318492,
-0.2076089829,
-0.7593671679,
0.1833642572,
-0.4332184494,
-0.5108066797,
0.0165685266,
0.1681455672,
-0.0382033847,
0.3523419797,
-0.570094645,
0.6498137116,
-0.3416631818,
-0.4666174948,
0.0139334295,
-0.6946184039,
0.2095084935,
-0.219733119,
0.2690917552,
-0.0902853161,
0.1706312299,
0.9284909964,
-0.3046779335,
0.5886288285,
0.1573670059,
-0.0117514469,
0.162460655,
0.3172675669,
0.8109006882,
-0.069895722,
0.0762080476,
-0.1649052501,
-0.1162666604,
-0.2773122787,
-0.7521637082,
0.414247781,
-0.8623589873,
-0.3063137829,
-0.1595368385,
-0.6601707935,
-0.514750123,
0.3250456452,
0.2983007729,
0.6289422512,
-0.2851320505,
0.30370453,
0.6250442266,
0.2606558502,
0.5661766529,
0.614852488,
-0.1282584816,
-0.4957935512,
1.0071163177,
-0.2472034395,
0.2325192839,
0.4779272974,
0.2257249951,
-0.6583185792,
-0.5964856744,
-0.9622681737,
-0.1554696113,
-0.6025894284,
-0.1246934757,
-0.3007510602,
0.0004918965,
-0.2012284398,
-0.7896403074,
-0.7639345527,
-0.3500832021,
-0.2680312693,
0.0660352632,
0.6415989399,
1.1648236513,
0.0751361325,
0.5051628947,
-0.5845345855,
0.2281904817,
0.4626280665,
0.4334678054,
-0.4966200888,
-0.6951158643,
0.0991483554,
-0.098797299,
-0.2936616838,
-0.7697498202,
0.5542231202,
0.2174550444,
0.5921072364,
0.3191584051,
0.5959259868,
0.5127152205,
-0.5959108472,
0.1326383948,
0.4081960022,
-0.8811661005,
0.2755215466,
-0.3230149746,
0.0128865186,
0.8629460931,
0.4945069253,
-0.5407850742,
-0.3505678177,
-0.5967140198,
-0.7361096144,
0.8930100799,
0.150298059,
-0.1870740503,
0.3668886721,
0.1067266613,
0.1941999644,
0.117275387,
-0.1159787774,
-0.2387559563,
-0.6521892548,
-0.0741338134,
-0.0127540547,
0.4327735305,
-0.2009658813,
-0.242218405,
0.4695453942,
-0.4135943949,
0.2995419204,
0.2574292421,
-0.182834208,
0.0682017282,
0.6761750579,
0.4560355544,
0.5024017096,
-0.3257402778,
0.0228961837,
0.017755162,
-0.1890754849,
0.2123428285,
0.1340406239,
-0.2374725044,
-0.0874215961,
0.256414175,
0.9899383783,
0.6959454417,
-0.2729796767,
0.4473768175,
0.1481093913,
-0.3716471791,
0.0318880975,
0.0963457599,
-0.2752526999,
0.0183821991,
0.2085239142,
0.4335027933,
-0.0646344125,
-0.5019819736,
0.6071481109,
0.184275642,
-0.6395650506,
-0.2564081848,
0.8059299588,
0.5272677541,
-0.2116654217,
0.4458049536,
-0.3145627379,
-0.3444210887,
0.4632160962,
0.5900844932,
0.7567974925,
0.1986447722,
0.5185047388,
0.058082331,
0.0341551416,
-0.5095248818,
-0.0805154517,
0.0181975532,
-0.704639256,
-0.6173427105,
-0.6797074676,
-0.7773720026,
-0.1235893518,
-0.9389290214,
0.1160436869,
-0.5031887889,
0.2812831998,
-0.0547715127,
-0.4697976708,
-0.6122201085,
-0.0688894913,
-0.0447489247,
0.8755280375,
-0.7666886449,
1.1424230337,
0.8569150567,
-0.371460408,
-0.95839113,
0.066714108,
0.1663348824,
-0.9377233982,
0.5399564505,
0.0727705061,
-0.5362024903,
0.327690959,
-0.5994616151,
-0.6363570094,
0.9997646213,
0.1434066594,
-0.3461897075,
-0.1192899719,
-0.288718909,
0.352290839,
-0.3125623167,
0.0442622192,
0.9725105762,
0.6933930516,
0.526740849,
-1.0855098963,
0.0384881496,
0.1647637486,
-0.1407735646,
0.12414141,
-0.5859886408,
0.5349344015,
-0.1968376487,
-0.1355076879,
0.1136354208,
0.8559142947,
-0.0697246119,
0.2201317549,
0.2267733812,
0.3084135354,
0.5779747367,
-0.1180375665,
1.0209834576,
-0.1091874167,
0.2943635583,
1.0736000538,
-0.059096083,
0.8848050833,
0.2221435606,
-0.0884663388,
0.5360901952,
0.1544658989,
0.3018110394,
0.7980866432,
-0.0072955387,
0.1246374026,
-0.2625112534,
-0.2572190166,
-0.3478310406,
0.7046322823,
0.0094853612,
0.1032962725,
-0.2972603738,
0.1444855779,
0.5485864282,
0.5133352876,
-0.5860117674,
0.7602206469,
-0.1898572594,
-0.9411248565,
0.7405471206,
0.1524273902,
1.1649762392,
-0.7820657492,
-0.1310148686,
-0.3501410782,
0.2746810317,
-0.0248830579,
-1.0992836952,
0.3247126043,
-0.3304766715,
0.1905256212,
-1.0883293152,
0.758047998,
-0.5077021122,
-0.1225697547,
0.1861552894,
0.3916355371,
0.0101247868,
-0.2674013376,
-0.5430794358,
0.0137542309,
0.1867875606,
-0.1317102313,
0.688043952,
0.4523549378,
-0.1157188937,
0.6330494285,
0.5988699198,
0.0193959139,
-0.054156106,
-0.2077950239,
0.930072248,
-0.5785734057,
-0.5696589351,
-0.2568620443,
0.2384192348,
-0.0612883493,
-0.4189478457,
0.5959322453,
0.0196963623,
1.1121982336,
-0.1681320518,
0.8360415101,
-0.0589476898,
0.1239398792,
-0.7829492688,
0.8195233941,
-0.4067432284,
-0.1247225925,
-0.286375463,
-0.5319680572,
-0.0928461105,
0.6690360308,
-0.1072081625,
-0.2334429175,
0.7376989722,
0.5109267235,
0.0227434989,
0.1632540673,
0.3256778717,
-0.2178518623,
0.121162869,
0.5192930102,
0.4645439684,
0.1682646424,
0.8692201972,
-0.6015847325,
-0.2739912271,
-0.3223727345,
-0.9391787648,
-0.6598592997,
-0.3539086878,
-0.1492346823,
-0.2586702108,
0.4304913282,
1.0342063904,
0.9119675756,
-0.6985992193,
-0.159754768,
-0.1187037379,
0.0605630353,
-0.6008568406,
-0.2654601634,
0.3589697778,
-0.4235998392,
-0.7954961061,
0.9519970417,
0.2390978485,
-0.0597625226,
-0.1512522995,
-0.2160399854,
0.203445822,
-0.0060633547,
0.718300283,
0.6942230463,
-0.4267758727,
-0.427405715,
-0.1145805642,
-0.237379536,
0.1036830693,
1.0678597689,
-0.7557409406,
0.5269494057,
0.2762024403,
0.9325869679,
0.517560184,
0.2983038425,
0.6886829734,
-0.8283435702,
-0.0423491038,
0.0457764864,
0.217414096,
0.2211874872,
-0.1552034765,
0.4580767453,
0.4408330321,
-0.3973965645,
-0.0265964605,
0.3275119066,
-1.1531535387,
-0.4189231992,
1.2607779503,
-0.0839636996,
0.1362727135,
-0.256768167,
-0.5702426434,
0.1018795371,
-0.8221371174,
0.4466397166,
0.3687911928,
-0.4165801108,
-0.0164180044,
-0.4701592922,
0.6463965774,
0.3509976864,
-0.8211005926,
0.0433900245,
0.366902411,
0.2679952383,
-0.2340149432,
0.6937467456,
0.1869873106,
0.0519467406,
-0.195175603,
0.1653878242,
-0.5688770413,
-0.8433250189,
-0.2023438662,
0.1522366107,
-0.1300536096,
-0.1475990564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07161v1
|
Developing a Named Entity Recognition Dataset for Tagalog
| 2023-11-13T08:56:47 | 2023-11-13T08:56:47 |
Lester James V. Miranda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the development of a Named Entity Recognition (NER) dataset for
Tagalog. This corpus helps fill the resource gap present in Philippine
languages today, where NER resources are scarce. The texts were obtained from a
pretraining corpora containing news reports, and were labeled by native
speakers in an iterative fashion. The resulting dataset contains ~7.8k
documents across three entity types: Person, Organization, and Location. The
inter-annotator agreement, as measured by Cohen's $\kappa$, is 0.81. We also
conducted extensive empirical evaluation of state-of-the-art methods across
supervised and transfer learning settings. Finally, we released the data and
processing code publicly to inspire future work on Tagalog NLP.
|
[
-0.3831422031,
-0.064548701,
0.1500773281,
0.4992537498,
-0.3551451564,
0.3671694398,
-0.2516899109,
-0.7411488295,
0.6583848,
0.7926267385,
-0.0952121988,
-0.2865626812,
-0.4927923083,
0.5334807038,
-0.2743220329,
1.0417120457,
0.0932252705,
-0.052634418,
0.3443254828,
0.0067223194,
-0.4006278813,
-0.4782040119,
-1.0353195667,
-0.0701468214,
0.5678642392,
0.5030487776,
0.2590740919,
0.6452322602,
0.7796456218,
0.1294648945,
0.0464005284,
0.2363971919,
-0.2121698409,
-0.1047964022,
-0.4096769691,
-0.2441070229,
-0.4588816762,
-0.0131790489,
0.8504631519,
0.7835739851,
-0.1113292202,
0.0583667643,
-0.2136896998,
0.4795947075,
-0.4248437583,
0.3568755388,
-0.7983888984,
0.205575645,
-0.6572764516,
-0.2717543542,
-0.3792982101,
-0.5449780226,
0.2500527799,
-0.7595337033,
0.2946502566,
0.0817879438,
1.0621664524,
0.4735479057,
-0.4102038145,
-0.5190249681,
-0.5787237287,
0.4706785977,
-0.3600138724,
0.6346802711,
0.4478459358,
0.1369360685,
-0.1347776949,
-0.5298636556,
-0.4271480143,
-0.0440439023,
-0.085985899,
-0.0047364919,
-0.0438255183,
0.1439787,
0.214059189,
0.3817161918,
-0.3404859006,
0.1950911134,
-0.663449347,
-0.2876265943,
0.7813478112,
-0.4045018554,
0.2988164723,
-0.4664480686,
-0.726005137,
0.2099586576,
-0.8444280028,
-0.310141474,
0.5106897354,
0.477090627,
0.3231908679,
0.5769578218,
-0.1030860171,
0.746874094,
0.1434300691,
-0.3307629824,
0.5140550137,
-0.2631679475,
-0.2686940134,
0.7394567728,
0.6928152442,
0.472846061,
0.2325430959,
-0.2543009818,
-0.167021066,
-0.2789367437,
0.0196500011,
-0.554951787,
-0.3280756474,
-0.1546086073,
-0.2733252347,
0.1614304483,
0.2229259312,
-0.9949405193,
-0.6244823337,
-0.3450525701,
-0.0130148828,
-0.3871458769,
-0.3591033816,
-0.1080785617,
0.0091166776,
0.1808742285,
0.2121718377,
-0.9768220782,
0.3414562345,
0.4671989679,
0.6414909959,
0.1035657749,
-0.2716263533,
-0.5486614108,
0.1241315082,
-0.6559656858,
0.9130188227,
-0.5416904688,
-0.3340951204,
-0.2264236957,
0.1494842172,
-0.2685868442,
-0.9678007364,
0.8169492483,
-0.3932964504,
-0.0913881138,
-0.2537530959,
-0.6657068729,
-0.2127598822,
0.0763262361,
-0.8981097341,
1.226855278,
0.2303920984,
-0.7772217393,
0.6661578417,
-0.6146529317,
-0.246853739,
0.4849569798,
-0.1614235044,
-0.0335431471,
0.0446102433,
0.1832860261,
0.3099184036,
-0.2837549746,
0.6165655255,
0.1204657108,
-0.2530200183,
0.2994017601,
0.0460732318,
0.6065175533,
0.2895970345,
0.1038182378,
-0.1861769408,
-1.195704937,
-0.2427423298,
-0.0831014588,
-0.5340864658,
-0.6177241206,
-0.0522913225,
0.1760485172,
0.1288462579,
0.4277869463,
-0.7691637278,
0.390034765,
-0.3238785565,
0.2349532247,
0.337462157,
0.1577744931,
0.5527107716,
0.1173181161,
0.5211590528,
-0.1530118585,
-0.1721370816,
-0.1533259749,
-0.2872000039,
-0.7860057354,
-0.1594523042,
0.8386524916,
0.6001988649,
-0.7495991588,
0.3206695318,
-0.2457525432,
-0.399681747,
-0.6636687517,
-0.0876567215,
0.2008628696,
0.7401339412,
0.3813558519,
-0.2227769196,
-1.1310827732,
-0.9387699366,
0.1451201737,
-0.3032634258,
-0.1626452506,
0.3538794816,
0.4018422961,
-0.0705266669,
0.922165513,
-0.1187640727,
-0.4506908357,
-0.1051980183,
-0.002072213,
0.2879505754,
0.4015640318,
0.4891071916,
-0.9738398194,
-0.4789665937,
0.1285416484,
-0.4663244784,
-0.3334065676,
-0.17051135,
0.0193322301,
0.2176348567,
0.6227488518,
-0.3696675003,
0.172573179,
0.371376425,
-0.075647518,
0.2096595168,
-0.025568597,
-0.0079585202,
-1.092979908,
0.2257103026,
-0.0878591239,
0.0705933794,
-0.4873007536,
-0.3355142176,
-0.0264899377,
-0.2649069726,
-0.2283341289,
0.8778970242,
-0.700115025,
-0.2944303453,
-0.1679261178,
0.2841641307,
-0.3484924138,
-0.0020003347,
0.475079,
0.7097232938,
0.6235872507,
-0.5682213902,
0.4042492211,
0.246645093,
-0.2529297471,
0.7336342335,
-0.4679258168,
-0.0560612045,
-0.1003978923,
0.0943421945,
-0.3010270894,
-0.6158841252,
0.7138049603,
-0.359059155,
0.3152551055,
-0.4855971336,
-0.4844609201,
-0.2241130471,
0.180773437,
0.0161325261,
-0.0412386358,
-0.6604221463,
0.2888554633,
0.6012860537,
-0.4216672182,
-0.8332187533,
-0.7252919674,
0.4602036476,
-0.3298509717,
-0.0897051916,
0.6669947505,
0.2120943964,
-0.0693126619,
0.1654494703,
-0.1229528114,
-0.5100011826,
-0.2345012575,
0.2496836632,
0.2537231743,
-0.2277715355,
0.7715134621,
-0.2000531405,
-0.2264657915,
-0.1466847956,
-0.2347395569,
0.5267300606,
-0.0146380654,
0.1007393599,
-0.0413479209,
0.1542503387,
-0.011956499,
-0.5390020013,
0.7280845642,
0.4976486266,
-0.9229133725,
-0.0364102386,
-0.3570759892,
0.3228364587,
-0.3133406043,
0.0794192031,
-0.2768596709,
-0.7924039364,
0.6182174087,
-0.1518337429,
-0.2999222279,
0.4023854136,
0.1300816685,
0.3473770022,
0.0745324716,
0.7969649434,
-0.1497999281,
0.4778882265,
0.0884855017,
0.6254191995,
-0.8531934023,
-0.4824147224,
-0.4802825153,
-0.2293076962,
-0.8985567093,
-0.4301066399,
-0.2270544469,
0.4870564342,
0.1477928609,
0.6093708277,
-0.6651927829,
0.6083740592,
0.3717950881,
-0.2400481403,
0.3482461572,
-0.2477715909,
0.3479171991,
-0.2108238339,
-0.4310574532,
-0.7198463678,
0.9211447239,
0.1600313187,
0.5807355642,
-0.0802479461,
1.1348154545,
-0.0718631223,
0.2728733718,
-0.5779390335,
0.5107848048,
-0.1490131468,
-0.6928786039,
0.0101887947,
-0.469635129,
-1.0220549107,
-0.1230388433,
-0.0556795783,
-0.9443415403,
0.5884786844,
-0.1121309996,
-0.3267559111,
0.1936293989,
-0.6737436056,
0.7498267293,
-0.2506059706,
0.192214027,
0.4265192151,
-0.6500014663,
0.1641539931,
-0.2938073277,
-0.1252301484,
-0.4382784069,
-0.3940325379,
0.956182003,
-0.1138514727,
0.4099407494,
-0.2322725207,
-0.0298846569,
0.4190332592,
-0.3762519658,
-0.0569088645,
0.4112538993,
-0.2503926158,
0.0409332775,
-0.3277234137,
-0.3012743294,
-0.1354258209,
0.5597638488,
-0.2053159326,
0.1283659786,
-0.709248364,
-0.4318201542,
0.1018892005,
0.5335847735,
0.3634185195,
0.1280268431,
-0.3042461872,
0.1690695286,
0.8311892748,
-0.3053875566,
0.5351803899,
0.5926432014,
-0.4375141859,
-0.3806248605,
1.1224412918,
0.4459679127,
-0.3005669117,
0.6028259397,
-0.3099442422,
-0.3008116484,
-0.5286071301,
-0.4211481214,
0.3062128723,
-0.3886419833,
-0.484894067,
-0.4612348378,
-0.5369222164,
-0.2705075145,
-0.0284877159,
-0.5030140281,
-0.3761898279,
-0.4325168431,
-0.2433187962,
0.2173607349,
0.7489845157,
-0.0633490831,
0.3752830029,
-0.6744930148,
0.107144475,
-0.0780508369,
0.5299781561,
-0.4739083946,
-0.1575788409,
-0.1243841574,
-0.2073950917,
0.2217059284,
-1.1720401049,
0.5477064252,
0.5351914763,
0.50769943,
0.3741303682,
0.0997395888,
0.4681532085,
-0.3365824819,
0.4449865818,
-0.0917102247,
-0.7686107159,
0.7975190878,
-0.2941005826,
-0.1748673469,
0.6194865704,
0.664650619,
-0.6478797197,
0.1507330835,
-0.6952625513,
-0.746491909,
0.5835744143,
0.0188585185,
-0.2108936459,
-0.2513541877,
0.5177022219,
0.0872029886,
0.3421421051,
-0.7072312236,
0.0234103259,
0.0751357377,
-0.046465259,
0.0133391824,
-0.0894348845,
0.2524547577,
0.0766973868,
0.5846188664,
-0.0742661804,
0.212111935,
0.3506576717,
-0.1408174485,
0.1769281179,
0.5462816358,
0.1675525457,
0.637755394,
-0.3419244289,
0.2402807772,
0.0429400131,
-0.480871737,
-0.0393289998,
0.8499540091,
-0.2446775436,
0.3540318608,
0.1818974167,
0.7005963326,
0.1746461391,
-0.9076831937,
0.1873532981,
-0.015722638,
0.0954696685,
-0.3661260009,
-0.1491007209,
0.0047642081,
0.2302559316,
0.6103928089,
0.1201151386,
0.0956212059,
-0.4431531727,
0.1468209326,
-0.1914536506,
-0.3728883862,
-0.2402242869,
0.4374738634,
0.1473391801,
-0.2820698917,
0.7671964169,
-0.8219771981,
-0.5349311829,
0.6466472745,
0.510755837,
0.4227459133,
-0.4153683186,
0.4028302431,
0.6372381449,
0.484044075,
-0.2253678739,
0.3968078792,
0.104358986,
-0.7630446553,
-0.2800194323,
-0.8253460526,
-0.4841961861,
0.0790501609,
-0.5162059665,
0.3571915329,
-0.5285189152,
-0.1569342613,
0.2408694178,
0.3160324395,
-0.4505069554,
0.2784951329,
0.2461402863,
0.7803987265,
-0.6893304586,
0.8956400752,
0.9054098129,
-0.5919905305,
-0.6937160492,
-0.1223825589,
-0.2412910908,
-0.4893894196,
0.9233978391,
0.3326970637,
0.2545662224,
-0.0205264669,
-0.1667107046,
-1.1453458071,
0.8970708847,
0.5374906063,
-0.6765391231,
-0.1232422963,
-0.0772234872,
0.7123736143,
-0.4347042143,
-0.1047199517,
0.5604313016,
0.4865816832,
-0.2174403369,
-1.1435257196,
-0.2582214475,
-0.4055182934,
-0.0090001589,
0.6254729033,
-0.5516736507,
0.8351194263,
-0.2811335921,
-0.5596421361,
0.0025426073,
0.5977671146,
0.1027303562,
0.5182162523,
0.2766259611,
0.6875047088,
1.1950367689,
-0.3132160604,
0.583119154,
-0.1445442289,
0.2682918012,
1.4066040516,
-0.4531027377,
0.8031029105,
0.4424057007,
-0.185072422,
0.1518295705,
0.8794280887,
-0.3233443499,
0.2473359406,
0.1528417319,
-0.4007140994,
0.2537458539,
-1.0216947794,
-0.5018352866,
0.6772333384,
0.4182930291,
-0.5237166882,
-0.1486624181,
-0.0279518589,
0.0643613189,
0.0569886006,
-0.3353289366,
0.5698396564,
-0.0929619074,
-0.5721297264,
-0.0403128639,
-0.0212171432,
0.5812061429,
-0.3692182899,
-0.1918289065,
-0.084844023,
0.0537149236,
-0.4736186266,
-0.7930228114,
0.4358320534,
0.1568229347,
-0.1235509068,
-0.1819372624,
1.0313595533,
-0.6443265676,
-0.3751824796,
0.3226659596,
0.3663519919,
0.5177902579,
0.0433648415,
-0.2947532237,
-0.0920219123,
-0.1558588296,
0.2801885307,
0.1490337551,
0.4457651675,
-0.066917412,
0.4049655497,
0.3562340438,
0.3395926058,
0.4423208833,
0.1138787642,
0.4560058713,
-0.6019886136,
-0.2590392828,
-0.3852033913,
-0.0812584609,
-0.2783689797,
-0.7057279944,
0.5696184635,
0.9118774533,
1.3306877613,
0.0643913224,
0.5274031162,
-0.5625107884,
0.8423483372,
-0.4218615592,
0.5461139083,
-0.0364393853,
0.1675337255,
-0.1859924346,
-1.0623698235,
-0.3918459713,
0.7130953074,
-0.1283535659,
-0.2329354286,
0.2706975341,
0.5860635638,
0.1371044368,
-0.0682918131,
-0.1124937385,
-0.1215723082,
0.0304165669,
0.6038827896,
0.7505453229,
-0.6290573478,
0.4300415814,
-0.6121208668,
0.0453857407,
-0.2150482237,
-0.9304231405,
-0.5789681673,
-0.6917814016,
-0.3293576837,
0.1434014142,
0.1090572551,
0.9474439025,
0.4992854297,
-0.6301447749,
-0.0599044673,
-0.0837489814,
0.1746214777,
0.0909639373,
-0.2205421329,
0.3088793457,
-0.0598823465,
-0.7867665291,
0.4473911822,
0.3400686085,
-0.0919693857,
0.2007988393,
-0.0430681407,
-0.5215761662,
-0.2956477404,
0.3136179447,
0.6242435575,
-0.6524752975,
-0.2075524628,
0.0731461644,
-0.0865321308,
0.3305441439,
0.7332959771,
-0.737644732,
0.6217626333,
0.350591898,
0.7155835629,
0.1881677657,
-0.0432794765,
0.0564172529,
-0.9241885543,
0.1348989457,
0.3691231012,
0.4307178557,
0.6526842713,
-0.3451650441,
1.0360217094,
0.1965874583,
-0.5739821792,
-0.8096763492,
-0.0983740911,
-1.0964711905,
0.231618911,
0.527833879,
-0.0347922184,
0.112451598,
-0.0362974517,
-0.3695472181,
0.4347852767,
-0.6175630093,
0.4282226562,
0.6734099984,
-0.3997362852,
-0.5087252855,
-0.6176068783,
0.4203864634,
-0.1662221253,
-1.160078764,
-0.0444096364,
0.4141107798,
0.1791726202,
0.5369688869,
0.9476966262,
-0.0818298608,
0.2315322012,
0.1995674968,
0.2372741699,
0.3283830583,
-0.5847857594,
-0.277243644,
0.0057482282,
-0.0502614491,
-0.0492083021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07150v1
|
Interaction is all You Need? A Study of Robots Ability to Understand and Execute
| 2023-11-13T08:39:06 | 2023-11-13T08:39:06 |
Kushal Koshti, Nidhir Bhavsar
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper aims to address a critical challenge in robotics, which is
enabling them to operate seamlessly in human environments through natural
language interactions. Our primary focus is to equip robots with the ability to
understand and execute complex instructions in coherent dialogs to facilitate
intricate task-solving scenarios. To explore this, we build upon the Execution
from Dialog History (EDH) task from the Teach benchmark. We employ a
multi-transformer model with BART LM. We observe that our best configuration
outperforms the baseline with a success rate score of 8.85 and a
goal-conditioned success rate score of 14.02. In addition, we suggest an
alternative methodology for completing this task. Moreover, we introduce a new
task by expanding the EDH task and making predictions about game plans instead
of individual actions. We have evaluated multiple BART models and an LLaMA2
LLM, which has achieved a ROGUE-L score of 46.77 for this task.
|
[
-0.2195262462,
-1.1643399,
0.8838679194,
-0.1115954965,
-0.0103067346,
0.336230725,
-0.0954986364,
-0.5782310367,
0.3304890692,
0.7158260345,
-0.8831960559,
-0.3470688164,
-0.5763083696,
0.1886597425,
0.0217807759,
0.8844641447,
-0.1004602313,
-0.1377040893,
-0.1643929332,
0.1411322951,
-0.6069395542,
-0.35349828,
-0.3782676756,
-0.5036350489,
0.0847010016,
0.3653538227,
0.8530362248,
0.7233386636,
0.7186226845,
0.4434323609,
-0.1010264978,
0.4739514589,
-0.5547980666,
0.2331797332,
-0.1912446916,
-0.5159882903,
-0.4965946674,
-0.180127427,
0.3907065094,
1.1882817745,
-0.15998815,
-0.0645405799,
0.1543247104,
0.4013373554,
-0.2819705904,
0.3228719532,
-0.2879533768,
0.3410057425,
0.4552217722,
-0.4705451429,
-0.5316570401,
-0.1178364307,
0.2023219615,
-1.1579031944,
-0.2774111032,
0.1899678111,
0.8246251941,
0.4496871531,
-0.5747904778,
-0.5332630873,
-1.0523502827,
0.660035193,
-0.4683509171,
0.0790669173,
0.3857147098,
0.2583343387,
-0.6752352118,
-0.7228697538,
-0.6977151036,
-0.3228089213,
-0.161548987,
0.5392281413,
-0.5681996346,
0.7699124813,
0.4309736788,
-0.0383027941,
-0.2513912618,
-0.0231743194,
-0.4258260727,
-0.0180809777,
0.358045876,
0.5171785951,
0.4318244457,
-0.2717468143,
-0.5821329355,
-0.3479219675,
0.0514099449,
0.3117912114,
0.5948176384,
0.3085477352,
-0.145000264,
0.7594721913,
-0.1870831102,
0.6101372242,
0.0167470109,
0.0896266177,
-0.0033673244,
-0.4722472727,
-0.1944090128,
-0.3499760032,
0.7650896311,
0.6154360771,
0.2909036279,
-0.0653949901,
0.0190247726,
-0.2516239882,
0.7929132581,
-0.2220911235,
-0.2687056959,
0.155142948,
-0.3021468818,
-0.0400902554,
0.0920783132,
-0.7253134251,
-0.2704398036,
-0.640070796,
0.8499466181,
-0.550311327,
-0.0793079138,
0.2065694332,
-0.1235295683,
0.2884767056,
0.7312770486,
-0.4298832715,
0.5941064954,
0.6581552029,
0.6609039903,
0.0660041943,
-0.4557430744,
-0.7296823859,
0.2562680244,
-0.3879878819,
0.5669008493,
-0.5165798068,
-0.4505785406,
0.0380522758,
0.0628716648,
-0.4941777587,
-0.3440208137,
0.6253110766,
-0.2650549412,
0.3803802729,
0.1979124546,
-0.6940493584,
-0.6880872846,
0.0691066906,
-0.7691372633,
0.723626554,
0.1991872042,
-0.1816957146,
-0.267316401,
-1.0243762732,
-0.7311916351,
0.1842204779,
-0.0379698575,
-0.0182059798,
-0.2763539255,
-0.0915084481,
0.4437018633,
0.0707329065,
0.2972254455,
-0.0225749668,
-0.5074149966,
0.0994956493,
-0.4209493697,
0.5666338205,
-0.228434369,
-0.4918679893,
0.2150076628,
-0.4299730361,
0.2029323727,
0.0178021286,
-0.2775602043,
0.2589369118,
0.0282963663,
-0.1178545505,
0.0573881306,
0.3777178228,
-0.2449138463,
0.3942645788,
-0.3509189785,
0.1257646084,
0.848239243,
-0.1306615472,
0.6305016279,
-0.346724391,
1.0070647001,
-0.4711834788,
0.1652155966,
-0.3566941023,
-0.6343775392,
-0.6867646575,
-0.2085582465,
-0.0643056035,
0.8246212006,
-0.841504097,
0.6936776638,
-0.1062669158,
-0.2342791855,
-0.5851669312,
0.2035361677,
0.6131436825,
0.4851461053,
0.4010801315,
-0.14259395,
-0.655359745,
-1.0482802391,
-0.0252153501,
-0.438670069,
-0.4289145172,
0.5030043125,
0.4741630256,
-0.254619509,
0.949013412,
-0.4776813388,
-0.3000837862,
-0.7198432088,
0.2631952167,
0.2137081474,
0.22647506,
0.1639453024,
-0.4529509246,
-0.1101263985,
0.3256394565,
-0.920514226,
0.0396367423,
-0.3475132585,
-0.2019123882,
-0.0604704916,
0.4201452434,
-0.8050512671,
0.3804246485,
0.3642230034,
-0.0910645723,
0.2234459519,
-0.4192866683,
0.4097987115,
-0.9093387127,
0.0817877874,
-0.0711233988,
-0.2907475233,
-1.1074618101,
0.0549118966,
-0.3384565711,
-0.0363822058,
-0.4227832854,
0.2495741844,
0.0254202317,
0.0139947953,
-0.2375840694,
0.5276499391,
0.0250511933,
0.808981359,
-0.0300034694,
0.4499737024,
0.0365957282,
-0.602073133,
0.4248547852,
0.4938271046,
-0.2708965242,
0.2586023808,
-0.8700737953,
0.2614162564,
-0.0751973391,
0.3552510142,
-0.9335159063,
-0.5662930012,
0.7151013613,
-0.3935066462,
0.1499381214,
0.0860863104,
-0.3543269336,
-0.3584606051,
-0.1481330693,
-0.1180509105,
0.3836387396,
-0.3561653495,
1.3526180983,
0.1817588955,
0.0144477449,
-0.5744674802,
-0.1491692811,
0.0677535236,
0.0028694309,
-0.4977621138,
0.2703691125,
-0.2451066375,
-0.3033874929,
-0.2869591713,
0.0362471603,
-0.1182542741,
0.2612556517,
0.4568649828,
0.3629721403,
0.1374341995,
-0.3300214708,
0.014443351,
-0.1767773926,
0.1935955435,
0.7151066661,
0.6272267699,
-0.0737826601,
-0.5787770748,
-1.1335128546,
0.2379882038,
0.6976470351,
0.3917069435,
0.2740454376,
0.2894349098,
-0.1485852003,
0.1275652647,
-0.0289248135,
-0.438105613,
-0.5090484619,
0.7073808312,
-0.3381797075,
-0.629917264,
0.4050913453,
-0.3240218759,
0.2326943129,
0.0321217701,
0.2272966355,
-0.6857123375,
0.9336369038,
0.5655432343,
0.0872979239,
0.2795143723,
-0.0267489385,
0.3676653206,
-0.8624941111,
-0.4152996838,
-0.0594473407,
-0.5069442391,
-0.4729425609,
-0.5205647349,
0.4192129374,
0.3213444054,
-0.1604437977,
0.7512196302,
-0.3161042631,
0.4044766426,
0.6831887364,
0.4120458961,
0.248598516,
-0.3578367531,
0.4720520973,
0.1579931527,
-0.6426756382,
-0.8959870934,
0.7741004229,
0.4415009618,
0.5938705802,
0.1478600502,
0.4678868055,
0.388918519,
-0.2921122611,
-0.9009503722,
0.7085777521,
0.3192965984,
-0.3758230507,
-0.369081378,
-0.2633335292,
-1.3065087795,
0.2722219527,
-0.2533675134,
-0.8131096363,
-0.6160083413,
-0.0450003184,
-0.4874355793,
0.2158276737,
-0.8159530759,
0.7675753832,
-0.238807857,
-0.1092790589,
-0.3669348955,
-1.0282433033,
0.2054979503,
0.3641059995,
0.3740554452,
-0.1170809269,
-0.0108616017,
0.6028801799,
0.154539004,
1.1471533775,
0.0287566055,
0.1369556636,
0.3355802298,
0.3233992159,
0.4068478048,
-0.3908292353,
0.0251065958,
0.0495307967,
-0.0899438486,
-0.3212783933,
-0.8938978314,
-0.0107769817,
-0.8385722637,
-0.7644575834,
-0.2193516642,
-0.7963177562,
0.1015488505,
-0.0758372545,
-0.2044063509,
0.185561344,
-0.2825459242,
0.1239051968,
0.3711621761,
-0.2517023683,
0.537163198,
0.5455906987,
0.0482798778,
-0.137313202,
0.6107911468,
-0.3855648041,
0.619370997,
0.3149153292,
0.0697298348,
0.0496221781,
0.0123260971,
-0.7440692186,
-0.233138144,
-0.7980811,
-0.1462329328,
-0.8459004164,
-0.2905421257,
0.1741835922,
-0.5079367161,
-0.3605799079,
-0.2473879755,
-0.3533094227,
-0.0288062133,
0.3686223924,
1.3814896345,
-0.108193852,
0.6458079815,
-0.6990859509,
0.2880218625,
0.2487415373,
-0.0460516699,
0.0601769835,
-0.5890372396,
-0.0187952258,
0.2032686621,
-0.6420635581,
-0.8374989033,
0.1473473907,
0.276053071,
0.7048501968,
0.3231199682,
0.2018900067,
0.6748845577,
-0.5353391767,
0.7432085276,
0.0515323952,
-1.0805253983,
0.6960575581,
-0.4117516577,
0.0922870338,
0.43303895,
0.3275632858,
-0.2696291506,
-0.3993186057,
-0.6917193532,
-0.8631982803,
0.9729223251,
0.4710747898,
0.3605029285,
0.184581846,
0.2032392919,
0.0024352309,
0.1416095495,
-0.621712327,
-0.2448964119,
0.2792138457,
-0.2905741632,
0.3359752595,
0.2136379778,
-0.3956186473,
-0.1311895847,
0.1301290393,
-0.2397751659,
0.2729212046,
-0.1576278955,
0.0037827324,
-0.2564563751,
0.1151823476,
0.6023112535,
0.5783498883,
-0.1074511036,
-0.1870485246,
0.3106757998,
-0.3706094325,
-0.1153652892,
-0.1868075579,
0.3942930698,
-0.207622081,
0.8383085132,
0.6363430619,
0.5633659959,
-1.049413681,
0.4698475599,
0.0288542155,
-0.053977903,
-0.073169291,
0.3289501071,
-0.0439768806,
0.4741303921,
0.2906954885,
-0.0172743816,
0.1223426685,
-0.7707073689,
0.2567925155,
0.3837922215,
-0.3485651016,
-0.3995023072,
0.3891465068,
0.426540941,
-0.5726969838,
0.6579104066,
-0.2837972641,
-1.0029035807,
0.9833868146,
0.5384682417,
0.4491344988,
-0.1741423309,
0.427092433,
0.4202503264,
0.2983091176,
0.1290275455,
0.291547209,
-0.2720773816,
-0.723480165,
-0.6223292351,
-0.3855471313,
-1.1297291517,
-0.2552553415,
-0.8294426203,
0.1210824102,
-0.296761632,
0.1319369227,
-0.0796348229,
-0.073709771,
-0.6933220029,
-0.0264106039,
-0.0969327837,
-0.0461400561,
-0.712877512,
0.337736398,
0.7289999127,
-0.3333818913,
-0.7114100456,
-0.1253126264,
0.1242390722,
-0.9859293103,
0.8574029207,
0.2296184897,
-0.4726412892,
-0.0952391028,
-0.4626688957,
-0.6906380057,
0.9870565534,
0.2208324373,
-0.549779892,
0.0376523696,
0.1808903366,
0.5101646781,
-0.3444480002,
0.7456360459,
0.6685805917,
0.5190966129,
0.0060550263,
-1.1607942581,
-0.2055453807,
-0.1941553503,
-0.2629752457,
0.1431861073,
-0.5880177021,
0.4459301531,
-0.2761177123,
-0.3630274236,
0.120232299,
0.4596479237,
0.1350972205,
0.3970961571,
0.5592269301,
0.3144332469,
0.78458184,
-0.0829837397,
1.0783216953,
-0.392624259,
-0.034289889,
1.1127070189,
-0.2992286682,
0.8964107037,
0.2490101904,
-0.2906900048,
0.5214847326,
0.3719521761,
0.1704516411,
0.2842985988,
0.0854240954,
-0.1315882653,
-0.3612576723,
-0.3282422125,
0.0490436517,
0.7972322106,
0.2906045914,
0.042829711,
0.0096956408,
0.2465588897,
0.0862175375,
0.3110035658,
0.004526122,
0.9870017767,
-0.1706861258,
-0.5518853068,
0.0580456145,
-0.5272555947,
0.43110466,
-0.4705694914,
-0.4157515764,
0.2258270979,
0.0135587351,
-0.0907919183,
-1.2128221989,
0.1034521088,
-0.2761590481,
-0.2973375618,
-0.2614916265,
0.2544213533,
-0.3274835348,
-0.1236668602,
0.6285360456,
0.6842400432,
0.3261307478,
0.2993128002,
-0.4678637981,
0.2950857878,
0.1999784708,
-0.2541041672,
0.2723532319,
0.268220216,
0.480230689,
0.874976337,
0.4266457856,
-0.4750074148,
-0.1086294875,
0.0342620872,
0.8013059497,
-0.5051859021,
0.1428952813,
-0.6765847206,
0.6034222245,
-0.0404590853,
-0.5344108939,
0.4608243704,
0.3087252975,
0.7741444111,
-0.0215037167,
0.6444191933,
-0.1678176969,
0.2542659044,
-0.3759676516,
0.3119104207,
-0.3688982427,
0.0741308331,
-0.1982617229,
-0.67755723,
-0.0272987187,
0.8862574697,
0.0514694117,
0.0342622176,
0.5352356434,
0.4294616878,
0.2051553428,
0.3035448194,
0.434961319,
-0.0816132352,
0.3250395954,
0.7529587746,
0.9821460247,
-0.4843195379,
0.7264549136,
-0.4623551965,
-0.2683832645,
-0.2093380541,
-0.5477063656,
-0.9372509718,
-0.5255908966,
-0.1350683272,
-0.2413202524,
0.2729780972,
1.3738589287,
0.5589025021,
-0.4135747254,
-0.4354899228,
-0.0156584103,
0.0611469932,
-0.2772525549,
-0.2197059542,
0.1474192142,
-0.5425178409,
-1.1424014568,
0.8648765683,
0.244424209,
-0.0680779889,
0.0772902444,
-0.1599988937,
-0.194974795,
-0.0266881958,
0.7503476739,
0.2665721476,
-0.9217867255,
-0.5116594434,
0.2764963806,
-0.047196459,
0.0910401195,
0.5325081944,
-0.5224764943,
0.8565838337,
0.1203813851,
0.8150706887,
0.1865364015,
0.1730737835,
1.0890617371,
-0.4230659306,
-0.1408530623,
0.427610755,
0.126667127,
0.1194741428,
-0.356210351,
0.7465709448,
-0.3014163375,
-0.7680008411,
-0.5203095078,
0.3354062438,
-1.207685709,
-0.094369255,
0.9750635624,
-0.141686514,
-0.1959395409,
-0.269759655,
-0.4788372815,
0.4340071678,
-0.4611556232,
0.7822310328,
0.7275130153,
-0.7618730664,
-0.1220892966,
-1.0372918844,
0.1781635135,
0.567589879,
-0.8690092564,
-0.0460026972,
0.3576788306,
-0.4463605583,
0.3657123148,
0.260658145,
0.4620965123,
0.2361961454,
0.0690386444,
0.2740849555,
0.1591517776,
-0.3435419202,
-0.1814152151,
0.1405039281,
-0.3051739931,
-0.4019508958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07138v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07138v2
|
WaterBench: Towards Holistic Evaluation of Watermarks for Large Language Models
| 2023-11-13T08:09:01 | 2024-07-01T03:17:42 |
Shangqing Tu, Yuliang Sun, Yushi Bai, Jifan Yu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To mitigate the potential misuse of large language models (LLMs), recent
research has developed watermarking algorithms, which restrict the generation
process to leave an invisible trace for watermark detection. Due to the
two-stage nature of the task, most studies evaluate the generation and
detection separately, thereby presenting a challenge in unbiased, thorough, and
applicable evaluations. In this paper, we introduce WaterBench, the first
comprehensive benchmark for LLM watermarks, in which we design three crucial
factors: (1) For benchmarking procedure, to ensure an apples-to-apples
comparison, we first adjust each watermarking method's hyper-parameter to reach
the same watermarking strength, then jointly evaluate their generation and
detection performance. (2) For task selection, we diversify the input and
output length to form a five-category taxonomy, covering $9$ tasks. (3) For
evaluation metric, we adopt the GPT4-Judge for automatically evaluating the
decline of instruction-following abilities after watermarking. We evaluate $4$
open-source watermarks on $2$ LLMs under $2$ watermarking strengths and observe
the common struggles for current methods on maintaining the generation quality.
The code and data are available at https://github.com/THU-KEG/WaterBench.
|
[
-0.4858813584,
-0.7622492909,
0.4679192007,
0.2807459831,
-0.5982667208,
0.2459386438,
-0.1423174888,
-0.212024942,
-0.3035794497,
0.5938913822,
-0.3251036704,
-0.6149695516,
-0.7357830405,
-0.2333563566,
-0.5044330359,
0.7743765712,
-0.1249808595,
-0.1724228561,
-0.241893962,
-0.2078776062,
-0.3483367264,
-0.2464489192,
-0.5845414996,
-0.5268288255,
0.3208369613,
0.1557003558,
0.44118765,
0.7876721025,
0.4227704704,
0.2675066888,
-0.111108236,
-0.0327872261,
-0.4404086173,
0.3350861669,
-0.1964690685,
-0.2565945089,
-0.1771759987,
-0.065564476,
0.6070998311,
0.4362613261,
0.0536495782,
0.4680822194,
0.3988700509,
0.7705539465,
-0.9064624906,
0.3188450933,
-0.6932070255,
0.0923316702,
-0.598366797,
-0.1770958453,
-0.4135614038,
-0.2542802691,
-0.128464058,
-0.226314038,
0.1011852473,
0.2162562907,
0.798535049,
0.298887372,
-0.1746090651,
-0.0143878665,
-0.6321717501,
0.8996424079,
-0.903357327,
0.2653760314,
0.3592890203,
0.3479188979,
-0.2164674699,
-0.6361069083,
-0.4275657535,
-0.2237541825,
0.5468734503,
0.1500177383,
-0.380451709,
-0.2016295046,
0.2570514679,
0.3670212328,
-0.4896357954,
-0.0745324045,
0.0459920019,
-0.2002386302,
0.5915049314,
0.0581506938,
0.2484522164,
0.1205549687,
-0.3304646611,
-0.1776368022,
-0.8067278266,
-0.1938013136,
0.5452218652,
0.2025012374,
-0.0027744037,
0.5370889902,
-0.1620335579,
0.6067373157,
-0.1299448311,
-0.1153134927,
0.1132895723,
-0.1051462069,
0.0171403401,
0.0114505142,
0.8897563219,
0.2982680798,
0.4174261093,
-0.1969238669,
-0.3518786728,
0.0719418973,
0.1893368661,
-0.9302273393,
-0.1466750801,
-0.1103540137,
-0.2597106397,
-0.2199981362,
-0.061896231,
-0.6844511032,
-0.6643746495,
-0.2772489786,
0.4141830206,
-0.2364243269,
-0.2531577051,
-0.0131485695,
-0.0474535897,
0.2289731354,
-0.0019434959,
-0.5734516382,
0.450914979,
0.9158656001,
0.7062580585,
-0.4552250504,
-0.2002131194,
-0.6597641706,
0.2465471774,
-0.3355715871,
0.8994814754,
-0.5886187553,
-0.3007956743,
-0.0693568438,
-0.1757388413,
0.1989725977,
-0.7318024635,
0.3005836606,
-0.619034946,
0.1238986328,
-0.1856988817,
-0.7943559885,
-0.0173102748,
0.1830784976,
-0.6908820868,
1.2274013758,
0.2536760271,
-1.0469514132,
0.4198957384,
-0.4113683105,
-0.4062301219,
0.280080229,
-0.0387809686,
-0.6246153116,
0.0373412706,
-0.0706656575,
0.3042077422,
-0.7167791128,
0.4621619582,
-0.4632491171,
-0.3937591016,
-0.0102176582,
-0.5659271479,
0.4975585938,
-0.1300222725,
-0.8520835042,
0.1733885556,
-0.7549776435,
0.4761673212,
0.145733431,
-0.6231686473,
-0.2573667467,
0.1342164427,
0.140209958,
0.169381097,
0.3161629438,
-0.552003026,
-0.1569008827,
-0.0514532439,
0.3549847901,
0.7716950774,
0.116700761,
-0.0665384308,
-0.0747558773,
0.6295785904,
-0.0999821424,
0.212896511,
0.0447782353,
-0.3867119551,
-0.8618368506,
-0.123353295,
0.4895438254,
0.3485336006,
-0.7415097356,
0.5715482235,
-0.3625290394,
-0.7334047556,
-0.4150170386,
0.6328577399,
0.7140283585,
0.1389376521,
0.4157315195,
-0.4829746783,
-0.265735805,
-1.1251485348,
-0.5166814923,
-0.1832356602,
0.0058318744,
0.1693256795,
0.5424104929,
-0.1469150335,
0.944062233,
-0.2832237482,
-0.011092742,
-0.3556258976,
0.2768529058,
-0.0900043622,
0.2674956024,
0.361389786,
-0.3124126494,
-0.5271152854,
-0.0566463545,
-0.4031101763,
-0.5174142122,
0.3274597228,
-0.1449255347,
0.2502328753,
0.4898081124,
-0.4265753329,
0.4034653902,
0.7847520113,
-0.2302885205,
0.5561565161,
-0.0001949598,
-0.0824942961,
-0.8427503705,
0.3279389143,
-0.0297712144,
-0.1249974594,
-0.2524477243,
0.0545056276,
0.1779097319,
0.0297400728,
-0.2488862872,
0.7135967016,
-0.4626422226,
-0.198506102,
-0.5884365439,
0.1045380086,
0.1649697274,
0.3465997577,
-0.3470941186,
0.7079845071,
0.3963110447,
-0.2419634014,
0.4385760128,
-0.2134615928,
-0.5581845045,
0.3731034398,
-0.8344556093,
0.4194623232,
0.1230357513,
0.0704982728,
-0.9286963344,
0.1614886969,
0.075232558,
0.0272081643,
0.297287643,
-0.2765664756,
-0.7693923116,
-0.32831043,
-0.3852831423,
0.0688595101,
0.3872141242,
-0.3934118748,
0.3926113248,
0.3579216003,
-0.298301965,
-0.3694123924,
-0.5371622443,
0.2287464589,
-0.2079678178,
-0.3561002612,
0.3571981192,
-0.1038853303,
-0.2489272654,
0.0593484566,
-0.5297294259,
-0.0278698951,
0.2230585814,
0.3849748075,
0.1383437663,
-0.1981475502,
-0.1924807578,
0.0273376592,
-0.3044400811,
0.1348000765,
-0.0838897973,
0.7373667359,
-0.1979481876,
-0.664501965,
-0.1634197831,
0.0279723462,
0.472999841,
-0.4920252562,
0.3965780735,
0.5082719326,
-0.2676262856,
-0.4202193022,
-0.7168113589,
0.0035824848,
-0.4762741327,
0.2469228357,
-0.0983408168,
-0.7555239797,
0.2124460191,
-0.1955315918,
0.2041991204,
0.2918996215,
0.5215881467,
0.314042449,
0.7792903185,
0.5524007678,
-0.4573816955,
0.5021417141,
-0.1079791561,
0.2815381289,
-0.8171748519,
0.0310068037,
-0.5164014697,
-0.2547965646,
-0.243290633,
-0.4918242693,
0.1048181504,
0.4100032449,
-0.36632815,
0.4378730357,
-0.3212798238,
0.4773529768,
0.5204471946,
-0.1325720102,
0.217841357,
0.0827311277,
-0.2857765853,
0.0643718988,
-0.4999687672,
-0.8035290241,
1.0850200653,
0.1794579178,
0.6017190814,
-0.129421249,
0.8876565695,
0.3258920312,
0.6462473273,
-0.5939426422,
0.8188653588,
-0.0265417863,
-0.5560528636,
-0.3246272802,
-0.4562884569,
-1.0667414665,
0.3119305372,
0.0819096044,
-0.5724227428,
-0.3901467323,
0.0003481882,
-0.1265207529,
0.2833898664,
-0.446501404,
0.9365505576,
-0.4833830297,
-1.0030813217,
-0.3669548631,
-0.3498594761,
0.1706078202,
-0.2479676455,
0.3153063953,
-0.487403065,
-0.1168943867,
0.7500501275,
-0.2463934273,
0.5968443155,
-0.5201772451,
-0.290150404,
0.414743185,
0.3466145992,
0.3277513683,
-0.2569355965,
-0.1389181763,
0.1052283347,
-0.0991407856,
-0.1746038646,
-0.3537635505,
0.7370681763,
-0.4527578056,
-0.6375616789,
-0.2394831479,
-0.3585157692,
-0.4980716407,
0.4268742204,
-0.0087284595,
0.3444094658,
-0.15785788,
0.4353849292,
0.3374029994,
-0.3457657397,
0.5399010181,
0.5868532658,
-0.2139247805,
-0.3061203957,
0.9931998253,
0.0161607563,
0.1319404691,
0.1236365512,
0.3287348747,
-0.1436360478,
-0.7730893493,
-0.3868167698,
0.1464737207,
-0.6932138801,
-0.3269843459,
-0.2859786451,
-0.1977396011,
0.1504890174,
0.341119498,
-0.4378375411,
-0.0090040835,
0.0272355154,
0.0996600315,
0.1621314436,
0.6517400146,
0.2630597055,
0.1913570613,
-0.727822125,
0.4181366563,
0.3053878248,
0.626164794,
-0.0151335513,
-0.4480191767,
-0.1717343628,
-0.0704645887,
-0.6754431129,
-0.4579601288,
0.0178083591,
0.2348960638,
0.6239272356,
0.4675277472,
-0.0956354588,
0.6445229053,
-0.5992243886,
0.6993274689,
0.0995873511,
-1.1560302973,
0.5177288651,
-0.1664142758,
0.4070247412,
0.5398449302,
-0.0229132976,
-0.3448830843,
-0.4810298681,
-0.6150244474,
-1.1198669672,
0.4363329411,
0.1637696028,
0.1657559425,
0.0957139134,
0.1170299426,
0.1894993186,
0.3124246299,
-0.5306804776,
-0.0671871975,
-0.0542506464,
-0.1257234514,
-0.0389060564,
-0.3011898398,
-0.0400808901,
-0.0976148471,
0.797285974,
-0.2158780545,
-0.1424529105,
-0.3143945634,
-0.1751180887,
-0.1833332777,
0.457297802,
0.2607435286,
0.7412789464,
0.1011684015,
0.2478670031,
0.0376265645,
-0.2875482142,
0.1046924889,
0.0666553453,
-0.0181433056,
0.0305296611,
0.7970787883,
0.7993405461,
0.3960839808,
-0.8147458434,
0.5039379597,
0.0805168673,
-0.0687570944,
0.0276199561,
0.3777979612,
0.406501174,
0.2041400224,
0.2218178958,
-0.2715722919,
0.0067068073,
-0.3416080177,
0.0889356732,
0.5126534104,
-0.1764829755,
-0.2776170075,
0.5857591629,
0.1501959413,
-0.1328383237,
0.397803098,
-0.1019717157,
-0.5767916441,
0.5134600401,
0.3416122198,
1.0174589157,
-0.2905629873,
0.0035779348,
0.2445144355,
0.267971009,
-0.2083905041,
0.416061312,
-0.2256759554,
-0.5987368822,
-0.267316401,
-0.7546832561,
-0.588340044,
0.3906981647,
-0.6830009222,
0.0418930463,
-0.5412275195,
-0.3160902858,
0.1513371468,
0.0897614732,
-0.5939683318,
-0.0859789252,
0.3538888991,
0.7846662402,
-0.6210228801,
0.7576735616,
0.5846524835,
0.1090858802,
-0.5224809647,
0.1606823057,
0.0011984018,
-0.8258424401,
0.4974502921,
0.3567126095,
-0.3381538391,
0.0146968374,
-0.5313159823,
-0.7325529456,
0.9459931254,
0.6383104324,
-0.7677118778,
0.4292479157,
0.4076313376,
0.6385837197,
-0.148067534,
0.0036889631,
0.8213837743,
0.784686625,
-0.3196656704,
-0.8551806808,
0.1030756384,
-0.5214297771,
0.2161509246,
0.2148537487,
-0.5779252052,
0.5670427084,
0.0912442356,
-0.2950111628,
0.0343639888,
0.1307357699,
0.4855854213,
0.0764267296,
0.6383042932,
0.6163540483,
0.3661708534,
-0.3134599626,
1.0271890163,
-0.7447911501,
0.329878211,
1.1730135679,
-0.6180737615,
1.0343048573,
0.5611894131,
-0.4037578702,
0.3455528021,
0.3766766787,
-0.2584125102,
0.5327219367,
0.7603017092,
-0.2228233218,
-0.3242342472,
-0.1764273345,
-0.2972775996,
0.3008936942,
0.0982549861,
-0.1734255552,
-0.3898996711,
-0.2157780826,
-0.0217115898,
-0.0479440577,
-0.0416214168,
0.7121554017,
0.18996723,
-0.6339071393,
0.62368536,
0.2329165488,
0.499188453,
-0.7150128484,
0.0083836066,
-0.2960937321,
0.3938215077,
-0.0197957028,
-0.7894257307,
-0.0317148827,
0.2467477173,
0.0828656554,
-0.2249913067,
0.7059926391,
-0.3478783965,
-0.2899751365,
0.6977747679,
0.4943165481,
0.0527358279,
-0.3594771326,
-0.8538641334,
0.5158084035,
-0.172340855,
-0.7528492808,
0.2190126628,
0.3757207692,
-0.2582852542,
0.8827950358,
0.6063060164,
0.0622598529,
0.1386077702,
0.4182353914,
0.7709103823,
-0.4911875129,
-0.1374787837,
-1.090929389,
0.1958436072,
-0.0061275363,
-0.326290518,
0.811976254,
0.8053737283,
0.6422097087,
-0.0295549128,
1.0228424072,
0.0054558287,
0.1881236136,
-0.2944400012,
0.6953417659,
-0.5522639155,
0.1662073135,
-0.4093861282,
-1.3185385466,
-0.0912543908,
0.2338546664,
-0.2167722136,
0.22194314,
0.6813367605,
0.6911108494,
-0.0516715124,
0.0584035553,
0.2217815667,
-0.0622273088,
0.3086837232,
0.5239832997,
0.8638502955,
-0.252007246,
0.5677865148,
-0.4067140222,
-0.1245460659,
-0.1651667207,
-0.9303389788,
-0.9293579459,
-0.3398005366,
-0.5943802595,
-0.1019309685,
-0.0028466119,
0.5597380996,
0.6688770056,
-0.9620595574,
-0.3105866313,
-0.1709199995,
-0.1056317389,
-0.2602983117,
-0.1668630987,
0.4391095638,
-0.1062402055,
-0.5198477507,
0.378739953,
0.4550080895,
0.1006832123,
-0.4871497452,
-0.002055095,
0.1900676638,
-0.0416663401,
0.5562828183,
0.038122654,
-0.5620450974,
-0.2537432909,
-0.381277889,
-0.1648274213,
-0.1470888406,
0.7749781013,
-0.4628573358,
0.3255592585,
0.3228802979,
0.8169552088,
0.5540497303,
-0.1506381929,
0.2547837496,
-0.6247723103,
-0.1605647504,
0.1706673652,
0.5036925673,
0.5292775631,
0.2169219702,
0.5966646671,
0.0979720578,
-0.2336417586,
-0.8284935355,
-0.1599591374,
-0.6610304713,
-0.1315372586,
1.2512526512,
-0.4213246405,
-0.1396421045,
-0.0930669159,
-0.1726171076,
0.2289057523,
-0.1351280659,
0.8290303349,
1.071944356,
0.2546041012,
-0.0962660909,
-0.7440593243,
0.1203778982,
0.4201351106,
-1.0921883583,
0.4534980357,
0.3031269014,
0.6403791904,
0.0386622138,
0.1207596511,
-0.2236376107,
0.0668944269,
-0.0418820195,
0.4917678535,
-0.1738922149,
-0.1887906343,
-0.0943843573,
0.165789336,
0.2997205257,
-0.0046350723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07115v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07115v1
|
Gen-Z: Generative Zero-Shot Text Classification with Contextualized Label Descriptions
| 2023-11-13T07:12:57 | 2023-11-13T07:12:57 |
Sachin Kumar, Chan Young Park, Yulia Tsvetkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language model (LM) prompting--a popular paradigm for solving NLP tasks--has
been shown to be susceptible to miscalibration and brittleness to slight prompt
variations, caused by its discriminative prompting approach, i.e., predicting
the label given the input. To address these issues, we propose Gen-Z--a
generative prompting framework for zero-shot text classification. GEN-Z is
generative, as it measures the LM likelihood of input text, conditioned on
natural language descriptions of labels. The framework is multivariate, as
label descriptions allow us to seamlessly integrate additional contextual
information about the labels to improve task performance. On various standard
classification benchmarks, with six open-source LM families, we show that
zero-shot classification with simple contextualization of the data source of
the evaluation set consistently outperforms both zero-shot and few-shot
baselines while improving robustness to prompt variations. Further, our
approach enables personalizing classification in a zero-shot manner by
incorporating author, subject, or reader information in the label descriptions.
|
[
-0.3504109979,
-0.7470818758,
0.6093203425,
0.2896287739,
-0.0371345952,
-0.0054701474,
-0.198664844,
-0.2123266309,
-0.1945508569,
0.1048873067,
-0.9226859808,
-0.68128407,
-0.3878549933,
0.3937252164,
-0.1652298421,
0.9721909761,
0.1486341506,
-0.1605841517,
-0.2975530922,
0.0913580358,
-0.7146497369,
-0.3329940438,
-0.4567777216,
-0.4581131041,
1.0802212954,
0.641276896,
0.3792336285,
0.4721224606,
-0.1390779465,
0.1073799431,
-0.0309730824,
-0.3123157024,
-0.2103118151,
0.6576586366,
0.0633654967,
-0.454793334,
-0.1498852074,
-0.1297189444,
0.4492188096,
0.7356806397,
-0.0165950228,
0.216507107,
0.1146728396,
0.4800527692,
-0.8794761896,
0.1123915985,
-0.4616399705,
0.4002853036,
-0.0906259492,
-0.6916286349,
-0.7569861412,
-0.1393147707,
-0.008758191,
-0.450184375,
0.7396810055,
-0.2019550502,
0.6203864217,
0.1964876205,
-0.2015322149,
-0.0769148245,
-0.9119691849,
0.7079880238,
-0.4876496792,
0.1744309515,
0.3535045981,
0.4139724374,
-0.0200300217,
-0.3409783542,
-0.603302002,
-0.1665399224,
0.2305341661,
0.3353604078,
-0.1378774494,
0.1692350954,
0.3135695457,
0.2075013518,
-0.6957933903,
0.3236679435,
-0.2240762562,
-0.0613614284,
0.2855837345,
0.1192351729,
0.5449047685,
-0.1933894604,
-0.5428299308,
-0.1669366807,
-0.8290897608,
0.0031364844,
0.2117115706,
0.7129746079,
-0.0252726898,
0.5219429731,
-0.640922606,
1.2717208862,
0.1435056478,
-0.0188423339,
0.3486220539,
-0.2476820797,
-0.3299149871,
0.2990095913,
0.8688143492,
0.3817524016,
0.1286138743,
-0.2553511262,
0.1356818378,
-0.2573066354,
0.075038746,
-0.8765844703,
0.1000797376,
0.3581748009,
-0.4095268846,
-0.4775308669,
-0.0717638209,
-1.0168061256,
-0.4969842732,
-0.0741759092,
0.3474807143,
-0.3826949894,
0.2244753242,
0.0878137499,
-0.3309232891,
0.2399133742,
0.4238227606,
-1.1793242693,
-0.5031052828,
0.3358712196,
0.8859050274,
0.2102098018,
-0.2847435176,
-0.6469743252,
0.1961614937,
-0.1876623929,
1.0177285671,
-0.5246661901,
-0.520408392,
0.3295138478,
-0.2206594795,
-0.1981729567,
-0.2800626457,
0.5012514591,
-0.3839982152,
0.4778417647,
-0.2676922977,
-0.5531029105,
-0.1130822599,
0.371385932,
-0.3826435208,
0.8881070614,
0.2913827598,
-0.4981095493,
0.796937108,
-0.5135912895,
-0.25881356,
0.9349043965,
-0.2502507567,
-0.2842559218,
-0.0214411337,
0.3002573848,
0.7137380838,
-0.0783648938,
0.2000449002,
-0.2768151462,
-0.2207563818,
-0.015996512,
-0.5676356554,
0.8549923301,
0.2134163976,
-0.1469918489,
0.3088230193,
-1.0200747252,
0.1287226379,
0.0863719359,
-0.3581351638,
-0.2837942541,
-0.1886372417,
-0.1094783694,
0.3711338043,
0.1024570316,
-0.5337631702,
0.4570747614,
-0.2008840442,
0.1186442301,
0.3075939119,
0.0092839161,
0.541216135,
-0.2830529809,
0.9209453464,
-0.2367174774,
0.0832878351,
-0.9494974017,
-0.7090439796,
-0.5649062991,
-0.1214292124,
0.2778579891,
0.8429195285,
-1.0177984238,
0.5590729117,
-0.1465473175,
-0.3707994819,
-0.0978913233,
0.2818740606,
0.3091989458,
0.8980147839,
0.4072503746,
0.0853138268,
-0.2933119237,
-0.5657481551,
0.1105384529,
-0.3378976882,
-0.4715645313,
0.145383954,
0.0251969136,
-0.1689235121,
1.080039382,
-0.4614618719,
-0.4183040559,
-0.5381752253,
0.7543056607,
-0.086016424,
0.12738581,
0.6797434092,
-0.4147362113,
-0.5552465916,
-0.1066216379,
-0.8183166981,
-0.4963850975,
-0.3658300042,
0.1624848247,
-0.1314523518,
0.5856799483,
-0.5239184499,
0.3301551044,
0.2244636118,
-0.3362718225,
0.4741770923,
-0.2076665461,
-0.1025342792,
-0.9848746657,
-0.0156377126,
0.1996945888,
0.0920437276,
-1.0472345352,
0.0580683313,
0.2216131836,
-0.1893490553,
-0.5374830365,
0.4138716161,
-0.263133347,
0.2500641942,
-0.2257042527,
0.007166326,
0.1447669566,
0.3708916306,
0.0494157821,
0.7087101936,
0.6281279325,
-0.8866304755,
0.3787424564,
0.3172450364,
-0.3455438316,
0.845110774,
-0.4730868042,
0.1168760732,
-0.5600764155,
0.414568603,
-0.7664772272,
-0.3588056862,
0.5694311261,
-0.5987487435,
0.3000586033,
-0.0806815848,
-0.5437012911,
-0.3597763181,
-0.3220297694,
0.265109092,
0.3807066083,
-0.5712359548,
0.3288938105,
-0.5976246595,
-0.3811835647,
-0.5954993963,
-0.4488387108,
0.2084532678,
-0.0167151205,
-0.2832812369,
0.4564608634,
-0.3067016602,
0.3508448303,
-0.0750477165,
0.2940266132,
-0.0312896632,
0.0447748788,
0.3130588233,
0.4475480318,
-0.1904627383,
0.4106040001,
0.0499244295,
-0.2701833844,
-0.1661938876,
-0.1021018401,
0.6201524734,
0.2811524272,
-0.1243345663,
-0.4588283598,
0.2334035188,
0.2166305631,
-0.0046974714,
0.6872682571,
0.6455732584,
-0.1833666861,
-0.4706513584,
-0.1509647369,
0.0213154778,
-0.4208926857,
0.0879630893,
-0.2828687131,
-0.8845850229,
0.2699415386,
0.0849104151,
-0.0738812014,
0.3693678677,
0.516846478,
-0.1750537753,
1.0618546009,
0.663264811,
-0.011312576,
0.6260758638,
0.0512508228,
0.082575649,
-0.5857102275,
-0.3845840693,
-0.5691894293,
-0.1301190108,
0.0042197742,
-0.1951388419,
0.0370218605,
0.416752249,
-0.2537136972,
0.2761185169,
-0.5501209497,
0.5673320889,
0.6875274777,
-0.1907748878,
0.0752589405,
0.0744621232,
-0.0358347446,
0.1818046421,
-0.9814665318,
-0.3972460628,
0.8757727146,
0.2477648705,
0.4787475765,
-0.1081711575,
0.820233345,
0.254586786,
0.4749905765,
-1.1172124147,
0.4170609713,
-0.1145672426,
-0.642373383,
-0.2184678018,
-0.4027806818,
-1.1038697958,
0.1244031489,
-0.2464624047,
-0.8572353721,
0.4480000436,
0.2469808608,
-1.0923464298,
0.0443122834,
-0.472713083,
0.8662356734,
-0.1876078993,
0.1603664607,
0.4659659863,
-0.6098803878,
0.3268600702,
0.0660495833,
0.0724731237,
-0.2864644527,
0.1847443432,
0.3029643595,
-0.3330174983,
1.0937902927,
-0.3188991249,
-0.1896399558,
0.3080702126,
0.0289335549,
0.0040235929,
-0.2550039887,
0.0600654297,
-0.0708301291,
-0.1458991021,
-0.216194436,
-0.7721913457,
0.4289009273,
-0.4258753061,
-0.3112233877,
-0.3294812739,
-0.3847223818,
-0.3223347962,
0.1808818132,
0.866441071,
0.4093690515,
-0.1628931165,
0.3018772602,
0.7886627913,
-0.6025560498,
0.6307603121,
0.3404636085,
-0.2803398073,
-0.1452541947,
0.9026528001,
-0.0172436107,
0.2896707952,
0.574467957,
0.2637132108,
-0.1372188032,
-0.2724704444,
-0.9741967916,
-0.3363900185,
-0.8118779659,
-0.5816611648,
-0.4884432554,
-0.1995059103,
-0.3913258016,
-0.3700141609,
0.2197237909,
-0.1157755628,
-0.647030592,
-0.2761049867,
0.2063498944,
0.5357236266,
0.129426688,
0.6351283193,
-0.9534824491,
0.4340094924,
0.5556358695,
0.3698560297,
0.0753242373,
-0.4111024439,
0.1092260778,
-0.2003685087,
-0.2662037313,
-1.1693828106,
0.4307765663,
0.433662653,
0.4869155288,
0.7009670138,
0.2200974226,
0.3113674819,
-0.63926512,
0.9875199795,
0.5511348248,
-0.8234900236,
0.7944866419,
-0.4422779381,
0.7756538391,
0.6360535026,
0.2770147622,
-0.7711797953,
-0.2723669708,
-0.1838411391,
-0.9086022377,
0.7613505125,
-0.1167161539,
0.4227678478,
-0.1766278744,
0.4378526509,
0.2930187285,
0.1193858311,
-0.8143684268,
-0.3971136808,
-0.3024903536,
-0.3942552209,
-0.0766850635,
-0.534127295,
-0.0239739232,
-0.0806441009,
0.4379869103,
-0.3343767822,
0.2043076754,
0.2299704701,
-0.1179191321,
-0.3038979769,
0.6828069091,
0.8162267804,
0.3578853905,
-0.3252616525,
0.1047593877,
-0.0872219205,
-0.1045871824,
0.4209558368,
0.0859101117,
-0.9968292117,
0.3370686471,
0.3942225575,
1.0436900854,
0.1918397993,
-0.4552818239,
0.5970308185,
0.0913848877,
-0.4504954219,
0.004612735,
0.1708091944,
-0.2515948117,
-0.1912157536,
0.6153933406,
-0.13011536,
0.2464919388,
-0.4437783659,
0.00983404,
0.2295596302,
-0.5445763469,
-0.2112350315,
0.7460920215,
0.1891440451,
-0.3131724596,
0.3883422017,
-0.5113404393,
-0.5649695992,
0.5048813224,
0.568567872,
1.0838832855,
-0.4259170294,
0.9636001587,
0.4999974966,
0.0628833175,
-0.1139888987,
0.020012958,
-0.4078409672,
-0.9758864045,
-0.3485111296,
-0.5449404716,
-0.4084725678,
0.2378426492,
-0.7697733641,
0.1294931471,
-0.6293734908,
-0.2847082913,
0.2078256458,
-0.629924953,
-0.5004482269,
0.215695709,
0.5281792283,
0.7166448832,
-0.9296681285,
0.6343414187,
0.5285170674,
-0.7532147169,
-0.3465512097,
0.0715953633,
0.0447133891,
-0.5817162395,
0.9687306285,
0.4593760967,
-0.1303839236,
0.0099341292,
-0.7889326811,
-0.4069346786,
0.9853870869,
0.2168092281,
-0.6084108353,
0.0345071182,
0.0856534839,
0.5058282614,
-0.3396376967,
-0.0217980593,
0.0703170896,
0.3334465921,
0.3488254845,
-0.5919171572,
-0.1105364636,
-0.1660048664,
0.2861683071,
-0.0123942513,
-0.2930160165,
0.7263695598,
-0.2269314826,
-0.5626062155,
0.1557694972,
0.5843464136,
0.292979002,
0.7495452166,
0.3729947805,
0.2672095895,
0.6597329974,
-0.1026806906,
1.1897486448,
-0.2780097723,
0.2373032272,
1.2132766247,
-0.3891042173,
0.905015409,
0.2606933117,
-0.0898574591,
0.7349892259,
0.6547726989,
-0.1669451743,
0.5096791983,
-0.0254741963,
-0.7355745435,
-0.1982113272,
-0.1188832894,
-0.2647477984,
0.10335619,
0.3055446744,
-0.4038762748,
-0.4843481183,
0.2979355454,
-0.1252000034,
-0.0634605512,
-0.413433075,
0.7562401295,
0.0087556355,
-0.5631470084,
0.4432770014,
0.058779601,
0.8436512947,
-0.5046895742,
0.0961681679,
-0.1010835245,
-0.1593233347,
-0.2539900243,
-0.6936820149,
-0.11684338,
-0.0083150193,
-0.4757164717,
-0.6124106646,
0.8200112581,
-0.644998908,
-0.4642519057,
0.2342639714,
0.5066366196,
-0.1422650665,
0.0185615048,
-0.6349787712,
-0.1743761599,
-0.1874435991,
-0.0334156007,
0.325784266,
0.3230292499,
0.1182769537,
0.737187326,
0.5759401321,
-0.113017872,
0.2390370965,
0.5693129897,
0.2994797826,
-0.7290469408,
-0.3045136631,
-0.9239253402,
0.3081384003,
0.101436384,
-0.4154768884,
0.6959130764,
0.1917246878,
0.7474319339,
-0.4337550998,
0.9512952566,
0.0189586002,
0.3738158345,
-0.3885319233,
0.6309463978,
-0.2518438101,
-0.0653913841,
-0.0130237397,
-0.9753514528,
-0.7552756071,
0.4690698087,
-0.1291943192,
0.2769628763,
0.3623131216,
0.3744165301,
0.4016563892,
-0.1608202308,
0.5777689219,
-0.3748290837,
0.0298566353,
0.4522999227,
0.9086795449,
-0.1119207442,
0.4472516179,
-0.3192400336,
-0.2229956388,
-0.530736208,
-0.9836976528,
-0.7797609568,
-0.4917089641,
-0.5841367841,
-0.1612686217,
-0.0762541965,
0.8978936076,
0.5448235869,
-0.8758020997,
0.0547306091,
-0.1801969409,
-0.0483627431,
-0.2029798031,
-0.3208040297,
-0.1036703959,
-0.8240998983,
-0.5844829082,
0.6670721769,
0.5428224206,
0.3456454575,
-0.2782255411,
0.0034895148,
0.0963285267,
0.0040820143,
0.8416435122,
0.7475084662,
-0.6659398675,
-0.2192924172,
-0.1054573804,
-0.1243499741,
0.0790337399,
0.8685366511,
-0.7784280181,
0.8646630049,
0.6576249003,
0.5231766701,
0.0399531573,
0.1749370098,
0.6907500625,
-1.1419725418,
-0.0100975232,
0.1379719973,
0.0823369473,
0.4823904932,
-0.5617277026,
0.0829909369,
0.0825491101,
-0.3122645915,
-0.6568184495,
0.3997258544,
-0.9294530153,
-0.4481622577,
1.2470285892,
-0.1102130711,
-0.0835569501,
-0.2377795577,
-0.1699142158,
0.1457876414,
-0.3400921822,
0.7416452765,
0.836317122,
-0.1360681355,
-0.6344828606,
-0.7089416981,
0.5295841694,
0.4201812148,
-0.8081358671,
0.028653251,
0.6665177941,
0.1394965351,
0.3067352176,
0.7229677439,
0.1846294105,
0.3406778574,
-0.1435724944,
0.4017263353,
-0.1178479567,
-0.501588583,
-0.8792217374,
0.3965903223,
0.0314490907,
-0.2141227275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07102v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07102v2
|
Fovea Transformer: Efficient Long-Context Modeling with Structured Fine-to-Coarse Attention
| 2023-11-13T06:24:27 | 2024-01-11T14:24:54 |
Ziwei He, Jian Yuan, Le Zhou, Jingwen Leng, Bo Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The quadratic complexity of self-attention in Transformers has hindered the
processing of long text. To alleviate this problem, previous works have
proposed to sparsify the attention matrix, taking advantage of the observation
that crucial information about a token can be derived from its neighbors. These
methods typically combine one or another form of local attention and global
attention. Such combinations introduce abrupt changes in contextual granularity
when going from local to global, which may be undesirable. We believe that a
smoother transition could potentially enhance model's ability to capture
long-context dependencies. In this study, we introduce Fovea Transformer, a
long-context focused transformer that addresses the challenges of capturing
global dependencies while maintaining computational efficiency. To achieve
this, we construct a multi-scale tree from the input sequence, and use
representations of context tokens with a progressively coarser granularity in
the tree, as their distance to the query token increases. We evaluate our model
on three long-context summarization tasks\footnote{Our code is publicly
available at: \textit{https://github.com/ZiweiHe/Fovea-Transformer}}. It
achieves state-of-the-art performance on two of them, and competitive results
on the third with mixed improvement and setback of the evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.4185282588,
-0.7780151963,
0.6635851264,
0.544798255,
-0.2081224769,
-0.3536001146,
-0.2327018827,
-0.6772280335,
0.2583044767,
0.2658084035,
-0.5144335032,
-0.2283195853,
-0.5646378398,
0.1315968782,
-0.672480464,
1.1570196152,
-0.0831354111,
-0.6482967734,
-0.2277073115,
-0.2307484895,
-0.4779202938,
-0.3002301157,
-0.3377847373,
-0.0491523445,
0.7377325892,
0.2707589865,
0.5661638379,
0.3758185804,
0.5031142235,
0.2911358178,
-0.2685053349,
0.1372966021,
-0.7670593858,
0.0164098106,
-0.4660156965,
-0.4147262871,
-0.7682992816,
-0.2708744109,
0.8115941882,
0.4551826715,
0.1910624504,
0.4533467591,
0.2476027459,
0.669598937,
-0.6997413635,
0.3870666325,
-0.4838169813,
0.1146589741,
-0.0995550975,
-0.0142075177,
-0.3577500582,
0.0715583414,
0.3611718416,
-0.5171346068,
0.2658033967,
-0.1073516086,
0.7784999609,
0.5819599032,
-0.6063736677,
0.0303703044,
-1.020014286,
0.787653923,
-0.241263032,
0.4221248627,
-0.0244169086,
0.3689184189,
0.1656773239,
-1.0213887691,
-0.2514525056,
-0.0764728859,
-0.2833994627,
0.1200270206,
-0.4864201844,
-0.031913165,
0.1346705854,
0.6960619688,
-0.0942980647,
-0.1647333503,
-0.48809582,
-0.0266892258,
0.1710744798,
0.1874978095,
-0.0543234162,
-0.2547453046,
-0.6891134977,
0.2083369046,
-0.6033646464,
0.2363551557,
-0.2115056962,
0.2595492303,
-0.0349608995,
0.1468057185,
-0.4429473877,
0.617448926,
0.4333848655,
-0.043277055,
0.2153102607,
-0.4177019,
-0.2058223933,
-0.1795488298,
0.6075592041,
0.3820829391,
0.0045274864,
-0.4416899085,
-0.2408126146,
-0.0530990213,
0.5159205794,
-1.2768179178,
0.0158323236,
0.3129651845,
-0.4674892426,
-0.2328840345,
-0.1165892631,
-0.9576542377,
0.1479244679,
-0.4243122041,
0.5275945663,
-0.2433942109,
-0.026745433,
-0.0547335036,
0.3935569227,
0.1393160969,
0.3895337582,
-0.9924020171,
0.2669380605,
0.7066067457,
1.2856009007,
-0.3666279912,
-0.1803474426,
-0.8599469662,
0.2083313018,
-0.0914173499,
0.7546740174,
-0.2172018588,
-0.1764310151,
-0.0015582596,
0.237650618,
-0.0390327983,
-0.2768393457,
0.5965070724,
-0.4485203326,
0.1806252599,
0.1591058224,
-0.2496407628,
-0.1680030227,
0.340537101,
-0.8937596083,
1.0745476484,
0.4364081323,
-0.7688621283,
0.209008798,
-0.8860676885,
-0.6829457879,
-0.1037689522,
0.0257888418,
-0.42023772,
0.2745667398,
0.4205809236,
0.7356084585,
-0.2461001873,
0.5219613314,
-0.0237982105,
-0.5590705872,
-0.1439210624,
-0.3898448944,
0.2942399681,
-0.0267883427,
-0.5872693062,
0.4629742503,
-0.7238761783,
-0.4148814082,
0.0584094897,
-0.2637558579,
-0.332786113,
0.032457307,
0.2579575181,
0.4037978053,
0.2694576979,
-0.3251337409,
0.3340906799,
-0.6678695083,
0.7110651731,
0.6475125551,
-0.1784593761,
0.7892240286,
-0.0896659717,
0.4018550515,
0.1726632267,
0.3583290279,
-0.5237497687,
-0.2430806756,
-0.78132689,
-0.2845443189,
0.208830297,
0.2846159339,
-0.6040775776,
0.2993616462,
-0.842651844,
-0.3029472828,
-0.2325229198,
0.0269475989,
0.1811224073,
0.4903331101,
0.5240763426,
-0.1556341946,
-0.1708818376,
-0.8992633224,
0.0129741654,
0.3390582204,
-0.3631758392,
0.3517027795,
0.606149435,
-0.4643416703,
1.2551406622,
-0.6883316636,
-0.9828290939,
-0.2421566993,
-0.1241159514,
0.2659083009,
0.2496394664,
0.8102549911,
-0.8353686929,
-0.3049271405,
-0.0202009007,
-0.3404868841,
0.0813717917,
-0.2545909584,
-0.1522370577,
0.0691892654,
0.6771491766,
-0.7059854865,
0.4679972529,
0.5747593641,
-0.367513448,
0.2880047858,
0.0674792305,
-0.0200089533,
-1.3879282475,
0.5734733343,
-0.0028019173,
-0.4155865312,
-0.7333034873,
0.1129645556,
0.359341979,
-0.0421662591,
-0.5345289111,
0.7399547696,
-0.3971635401,
0.0538944714,
-0.1672468483,
0.326277107,
0.1718380451,
0.8477221131,
-0.140463084,
0.8988077641,
0.210887447,
-0.4557230473,
0.0930731222,
0.1603753865,
-0.1905605197,
0.5756571889,
-0.7261599898,
0.0510424562,
-0.0763798803,
0.4055307508,
-0.9038124084,
-0.180344522,
0.2017122656,
-0.052471377,
0.3303298056,
-0.2708586156,
-0.3411716521,
-0.2875134349,
-0.4321180284,
0.7966025472,
0.120386973,
-0.7209944725,
0.9973272681,
0.2229535878,
-0.1850977242,
-0.4833453298,
-0.5652534366,
0.0798643231,
-0.2795774937,
-0.8411405087,
0.8259481192,
0.0169755146,
0.0573765449,
-0.3310719728,
-0.2212742716,
-0.0413739346,
0.0265318993,
0.3724372387,
-0.0174675845,
-0.3648615479,
0.2275009155,
0.1082015857,
-0.3154439032,
0.2770510018,
-0.3872064054,
0.3920437694,
-0.34958601,
0.153856352,
-0.4944674373,
0.504421711,
0.8916435242,
-0.435369879,
0.4028846323,
0.6857118011,
-0.2850334346,
-0.2123538405,
-0.3733133972,
-0.1962033212,
-0.4836669266,
0.5327931643,
-0.3563838601,
-1.079919219,
0.6209533811,
-0.1863107234,
0.0403935388,
0.5187008381,
0.3899690807,
0.3574855328,
0.8263306618,
0.8877268434,
-0.5558026433,
0.8592488766,
-0.3985322714,
0.3401456773,
-0.9018875957,
-0.0165153742,
-0.3172730207,
-0.3286935389,
-0.1772621572,
-0.6318015456,
0.5463142991,
-0.2804608941,
0.0992773771,
0.0151650775,
-0.5688832998,
0.5251877904,
0.3970758319,
0.0868099555,
0.2022723854,
-0.0985739231,
0.4150253534,
0.047900226,
-0.5644426942,
-0.1224469841,
0.7935302854,
0.567301631,
0.5571746826,
0.0020395343,
0.5581668615,
0.1436365098,
0.3423027396,
-1.0134626627,
0.301086098,
-0.0789855942,
-0.3434094489,
-0.3572951555,
-0.2129220068,
-1.0554783344,
0.3698507249,
0.0731731057,
-0.8589200377,
0.1513748616,
0.1856422722,
-0.6963022947,
0.1204884648,
-0.4921227396,
1.0456364155,
0.0412148535,
-0.6972349286,
-0.1459856033,
-0.8641604185,
0.3432125449,
-0.0796894059,
0.1374244988,
0.0527336337,
0.1717869788,
0.5389215946,
-0.204410091,
0.9252915382,
-0.0592300519,
-0.3311629593,
0.185431838,
0.010978925,
0.5026204586,
0.2780320048,
0.3866766095,
0.2248713821,
-0.175769642,
-0.3396771252,
-0.6014738679,
0.7031001449,
-0.4303184748,
-0.5064874291,
-0.3216411769,
-0.6098461747,
0.0232697465,
0.5033735037,
-0.0208064821,
0.5869999528,
-0.3767461479,
0.4775418341,
0.6324405074,
0.2846923769,
0.4975147843,
0.0352370404,
-0.3704322875,
-0.3602306545,
0.7110925317,
0.1276358813,
0.2168768346,
0.6233102679,
0.0803969204,
-0.1470841169,
-0.3194842935,
-0.5550993085,
0.0972021297,
-0.6497651339,
-0.4982592762,
-0.6717441082,
-0.173979789,
-0.1407158077,
-0.2063811719,
-0.4105003774,
-0.296554476,
-0.4603708982,
0.0468785241,
0.2101615667,
0.5932000875,
0.2962041199,
0.3821926415,
-0.7987759709,
0.5288488865,
0.4366460145,
0.4410243332,
0.1952684969,
-0.4135096073,
-0.5411465764,
-0.2564631999,
-0.3256727159,
-0.6308191419,
0.3415882587,
0.2598074675,
0.0907242224,
0.439406842,
-0.0626763403,
0.6266413927,
-0.6467549801,
0.7009449005,
-0.0391209349,
-1.0992697477,
0.525018394,
-0.4803365171,
0.7605268359,
0.5590003729,
-0.0212676451,
-0.3279168904,
-0.3507537246,
-0.2705201507,
-1.2939873934,
0.7329806089,
0.2735342681,
0.1716034263,
0.1248883381,
0.3966833055,
-0.0695934445,
-0.0346632861,
-0.8267697096,
0.1103432253,
-0.231029436,
-0.1729525477,
-0.0371896997,
-0.4231550694,
-0.0394492894,
-0.1877693236,
0.3116528988,
-0.5162962675,
0.2474877536,
0.458763063,
-0.3885379732,
0.1161524132,
0.2060182095,
0.6788758636,
0.5439602733,
-0.1325546354,
0.1295733899,
0.253082335,
-0.5137234926,
-0.1743768156,
0.3335030377,
-0.2230674475,
-0.0302701574,
0.1564688087,
0.551183641,
0.8900974989,
-0.2885421515,
0.7805241346,
-0.2323729396,
-0.0269211177,
-0.235992223,
-0.1483085603,
0.0780008584,
0.3445199132,
0.4349393547,
0.0722241178,
0.5324552655,
-0.3433347344,
0.1860988289,
0.1853125691,
-0.3559602201,
-0.4077936113,
0.7885066867,
0.5055132508,
-0.1322243363,
0.44758147,
0.1281702369,
-0.4620768428,
0.4643981755,
0.5087924004,
0.8365437388,
-0.3180795014,
-0.1418522894,
0.207608223,
0.085581243,
0.0559931099,
-0.0377388299,
-0.5612466335,
-0.0719480589,
-0.5315715671,
-0.6790060997,
-0.1233665496,
-0.1263864338,
-0.6688512564,
0.2125742882,
-0.1583734304,
-0.1274094433,
0.2278289348,
-0.2294476926,
-0.6131827235,
0.1116964594,
-0.0120216589,
0.7514135242,
-0.634780407,
0.7662230134,
0.2644252181,
-0.3028560281,
-0.3780460656,
0.2307056189,
-0.3915453553,
-0.2568672001,
0.416488111,
0.8943289518,
-0.5220268965,
-0.1409701407,
-0.2580219507,
-1.0818780661,
1.3384678364,
0.1921546608,
-0.6768539548,
-0.4105840921,
0.0916653499,
0.6113066077,
-0.3242953718,
0.090257518,
0.546069026,
0.2791980505,
-0.1174986362,
-0.8828902841,
0.1816232949,
-0.1554747224,
0.0100548128,
0.5634937286,
-1.0194807053,
0.7719008327,
-0.1689103693,
-0.2714064121,
0.0840800852,
1.0221488476,
-0.2664525807,
0.4587124586,
0.5566029549,
0.270085454,
0.3731156588,
-0.0786070675,
0.7774322629,
-0.5636327267,
0.6508883834,
1.0999846458,
-0.015362029,
0.8014023304,
0.6423825622,
-0.0065723541,
0.4181443751,
0.1857355237,
0.091892086,
0.5152763724,
-0.0628566965,
-0.131955713,
0.0288986173,
0.073544316,
-0.1633224785,
0.4341607988,
0.3780023456,
-0.5132877827,
-0.2474968582,
0.0091153197,
0.1137346029,
-0.1936715096,
-0.4093699753,
0.6810767651,
0.1714323163,
-0.8345110416,
0.5968266726,
-0.1340901405,
0.8153277636,
-0.3721417189,
0.0412771478,
-0.1969318837,
0.5964976549,
-0.2472258359,
-0.4833010733,
0.4884910882,
-0.2170924246,
-0.6560129523,
-0.2886291444,
0.7078276873,
-0.4018960297,
-0.4427726269,
0.4918856621,
0.1766334623,
-0.1429384053,
-0.4592325687,
-0.291691035,
-0.0217751004,
-0.0734872222,
-0.4720751941,
0.3657869697,
0.4753267467,
-0.270165801,
0.4608355463,
0.3976896405,
-0.5120775104,
-0.1236545369,
0.0443104282,
1.0328791142,
-0.6799938083,
-0.7806464434,
-0.8501088619,
0.5995771885,
-0.1031331271,
-0.4341898561,
0.4242175221,
0.5904432535,
0.4991699755,
-0.1150766239,
0.3010182679,
0.1792606264,
0.2615320086,
-0.4346295297,
0.7256056666,
-0.6284908056,
-0.2122348994,
-0.2997537553,
-1.0813839436,
-0.5617362261,
0.553888917,
-0.2203928977,
-0.0486422032,
0.6308319569,
0.384190172,
-0.566373229,
-0.1825710088,
0.1774163395,
0.3066378534,
0.5794608593,
0.7764127851,
0.5139874816,
-0.4463340342,
0.71822685,
-0.1925557852,
-0.2001906931,
-0.5613375306,
-0.8806848526,
-0.8979002833,
-0.657871604,
0.0471663959,
-0.098923631,
-0.114729166,
0.5620546937,
0.8283860683,
-0.5717527866,
0.1076192558,
0.0520875417,
0.022793211,
-0.0053050825,
-0.2993522882,
0.6070807576,
-0.4166922271,
-0.8894187212,
0.3641242087,
0.6125549674,
-0.1342929453,
-0.3920176029,
0.3194698691,
0.069385007,
-0.0635619164,
1.1637496948,
0.0210229848,
-0.8122283816,
-0.544680655,
0.0640015006,
-0.0610556304,
0.4028765559,
0.7147016525,
-0.9890966415,
0.318469435,
0.3420819342,
0.5010923743,
0.7297668457,
0.1556944549,
0.503395617,
-0.7848021984,
0.250792712,
0.2436173111,
0.4469674826,
0.2307458818,
-0.5203562379,
0.511279285,
-0.1956129819,
-0.8134873509,
-0.7359922528,
0.0962477475,
-1.191629529,
-0.089429453,
1.1389070749,
-0.1469709426,
-0.5680598617,
0.0909918323,
-0.5430208445,
0.0215921681,
-0.5740414262,
0.9881427884,
0.4855273962,
0.1012505516,
0.1305883825,
-0.3668925166,
0.4706798792,
0.4547650814,
-0.834874928,
0.3138439059,
0.6388481259,
0.3277954757,
0.6047998667,
0.4841541052,
0.0136012919,
0.3247951865,
-0.4176048636,
-0.19442752,
0.1235518456,
-0.797578752,
-0.5154365301,
0.5663285255,
-0.2859567404,
-0.0815715045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07099v1
|
Explanation-aware Soft Ensemble Empowers Large Language Model In-context Learning
| 2023-11-13T06:13:38 | 2023-11-13T06:13:38 |
Yue Yu, Jiaming Shen, Tianqi Liu, Zhen Qin, Jing Nathan Yan, Jialu Liu, Chao Zhang, Michael Bendersky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in various
natural language understanding tasks. With only a few demonstration examples,
these LLMs can quickly adapt to target tasks without expensive gradient
updates. Common strategies to boost such 'in-context' learning ability are to
ensemble multiple model decoded results and require the model to generate an
explanation along with the prediction. However, these models often treat
different class predictions equally and neglect the potential discrepancy
between the explanations and predictions. To fully unleash the power of
explanations, we propose EASE, an Explanation-Aware Soft Ensemble framework to
empower in-context learning with LLMs. We design two techniques,
explanation-guided ensemble, and soft probability aggregation, to mitigate the
effect of unreliable explanations and improve the consistency between
explanations and final predictions. Experiments on seven natural language
understanding tasks and four varying-size LLMs demonstrate the effectiveness of
our proposed framework.
|
[
-0.1298810393,
-0.7104991674,
0.6979600191,
0.2404747158,
-0.2978803813,
-0.149806127,
-0.7595237494,
-0.2175276279,
-0.2794299126,
0.212873891,
-0.6492358446,
-0.3034321666,
-0.6418036222,
0.2040471137,
-0.297983259,
1.045989871,
-0.0214277413,
-0.0414628349,
-0.2531942725,
-0.2303988338,
-0.3860408366,
0.0493413433,
-0.8255634904,
-0.4174670279,
0.3363418579,
0.620889008,
0.6431280375,
0.6359453201,
0.0479090139,
0.4695163667,
-0.1710904092,
0.2693692446,
-0.3720633686,
0.263574183,
-0.2096153498,
-0.5623036623,
-0.4276615083,
-0.3341398835,
0.7955180407,
1.0364971161,
-0.1795815676,
-0.2458852828,
0.4090910554,
0.4467439353,
-0.6462885141,
0.1150235981,
-0.7249334455,
-0.1254610866,
0.2069714665,
-0.1357479393,
-0.4986859262,
0.0289306883,
0.2864206135,
-0.8358277082,
0.273327142,
-0.0895064697,
0.1342355013,
0.2559359074,
-0.4005449116,
-0.1632155627,
-0.5061755776,
0.93644768,
-0.4600480199,
0.3205174804,
0.0453979708,
0.3346348107,
-0.4044440985,
-0.6293143034,
-0.5868347287,
0.3112406135,
-0.000268183,
0.0697675794,
0.0387490541,
0.1808972359,
-0.1989536583,
0.2470631748,
-0.5934524536,
0.2980449498,
-0.0052337036,
-0.2418228388,
0.6726879478,
-0.0367020108,
0.0816848353,
0.1321531683,
-0.492792964,
0.0619251281,
-0.636300385,
-0.0436773673,
-0.0715973526,
0.3750868142,
-0.3186122477,
0.125547424,
0.0108804759,
0.8269232512,
0.2918949127,
-0.2834585905,
0.1037740633,
-0.014592492,
-0.4938399196,
0.3858354092,
0.5418098569,
-0.0845626891,
0.0101497769,
-0.5318462253,
-0.3244696558,
-0.2383545786,
-0.2367851883,
-0.7742142677,
0.1835607886,
0.5549558401,
-0.491340071,
-0.2247919291,
-0.2190758586,
-0.8377196789,
-0.4243016839,
-0.4298435152,
0.6983799934,
-0.4829537272,
-0.4195284843,
0.1342013329,
-0.2659287751,
0.0104082832,
0.5640167594,
-1.0123378038,
0.3184738457,
0.8668243289,
0.7423101068,
-0.033834219,
-0.4470980465,
-0.8244909048,
0.3962446451,
-0.2197699547,
0.7387362123,
-0.5429680943,
-0.1994904876,
0.1383164972,
0.0739322901,
-0.156825155,
-0.2333315164,
0.4548564553,
-0.2123469263,
0.4196120203,
0.1355931908,
-0.8266134858,
-0.5200192928,
-0.0809882209,
-0.3802995086,
0.5662305355,
-0.0465501212,
-0.3641085625,
0.4833134115,
-0.6205198169,
-0.5552118421,
0.2996261418,
-0.0374114066,
-0.0801407769,
0.4267651141,
0.3090261817,
0.8251185417,
-0.0466422886,
0.4016958177,
-0.3627382219,
-0.5833590031,
0.2821103334,
-0.6418725848,
0.7514594793,
0.2681006491,
-0.3998034596,
0.2029380947,
-0.5093972683,
-0.1075887904,
0.1320501268,
-0.225899905,
-0.3756614327,
0.0970657915,
-0.3062537313,
-0.1092529222,
0.3716616631,
-0.0721939877,
0.0338289812,
-0.5264736414,
0.3783040643,
1.0637727976,
-0.240761295,
1.0241644382,
-0.1457139254,
0.5517789125,
0.0322051421,
0.086283423,
-0.4776885509,
-0.323339045,
-0.2320247889,
-0.3209351599,
0.1213860586,
0.2775377929,
-0.571844101,
0.197531119,
-0.4441814423,
-0.2512262166,
-0.3536037207,
0.6483825445,
0.3240306377,
0.6082998514,
0.1680091023,
0.1248692349,
-0.2594175637,
-0.6112248302,
-0.6362316608,
0.0409597568,
-0.3252986968,
0.2721246779,
0.2843758166,
-0.0803956091,
0.9296477437,
-0.0265029408,
-0.0071462779,
-0.7229120135,
0.1601443291,
0.2778411508,
0.3595665395,
0.3204778135,
-1.1093711853,
-0.1647621095,
-0.2009790093,
-0.4436114132,
-0.0392354019,
-0.1772628874,
-0.0866924301,
0.3096814454,
0.4020510912,
-0.4299346805,
-0.1737990081,
0.5656246543,
-0.2966485918,
0.2663719654,
-0.437887311,
-0.1532436609,
-1.0098193884,
-0.4293775558,
0.1934959888,
-0.1536743492,
-0.7140641212,
0.0146664716,
0.0648639947,
0.0749271438,
-0.4825658202,
0.7104679942,
-0.4944598377,
0.121909909,
-0.0909660459,
0.4711946845,
0.1330595464,
0.5359987617,
0.1607609242,
0.37277475,
0.9872146249,
-0.8986302614,
-0.1041389853,
-0.0143363345,
-0.2825424373,
0.4224462509,
-0.4337734282,
0.1550051719,
-0.4924967289,
0.6322600245,
-1.2448208332,
-0.7586048245,
-0.0698976889,
-0.3332767785,
0.5066741109,
-0.4947247505,
-0.2949472368,
0.0222753789,
-0.2317198962,
0.3575357795,
0.4741983712,
-0.9903804064,
1.0928429365,
0.0872391686,
-0.1154339314,
-0.6373916268,
-0.7932769656,
-0.1255133003,
-0.6989985108,
-0.7204642892,
0.4460304081,
-0.1599545628,
-0.647110343,
-0.3085051477,
-0.2565122843,
-0.2674028873,
0.4870028496,
0.1032321006,
-0.0127581824,
-0.2883839011,
0.7728065252,
0.2981378138,
0.0008335137,
-0.0970155895,
-0.334951371,
0.1678240895,
-0.3216804862,
-0.027182864,
-0.2000031173,
0.365254879,
0.5609250665,
0.0237361584,
0.9837121367,
0.6749487519,
-0.3826235533,
-0.5233262181,
-0.3425373733,
-0.425427407,
-0.5422307849,
0.191132158,
-0.3956150711,
-0.8343353868,
0.5650048852,
-0.2984429002,
0.3335441351,
0.4454489052,
0.3142078221,
0.0103016039,
1.3077282906,
0.5287765265,
-0.0434496813,
0.472554177,
0.1120122746,
0.2723582387,
-0.4006703794,
-0.1752227247,
-0.5083407164,
-0.2474794388,
-0.555834651,
-0.3314388394,
0.3679344356,
0.3283076882,
-0.2511593997,
-0.0456264988,
-0.491304189,
0.5607916713,
0.2698981464,
0.1771666557,
0.2676342726,
0.1425426304,
0.4389549792,
0.3224387765,
-1.0253039598,
-0.3752679825,
0.881184876,
0.3320299685,
0.7188724279,
0.4597783685,
0.7262564301,
0.073894687,
0.3952857554,
-0.7446321845,
0.4851890802,
-0.3186874688,
-0.4422241747,
-0.446128279,
-0.5861074328,
-0.8935617208,
0.3898175657,
-0.1339913309,
-0.8324685693,
0.1015011966,
0.3605195284,
-0.2766491771,
0.0434744097,
-1.0310586691,
0.8263098598,
-0.2435898334,
-0.5824384093,
-0.4586891532,
-0.5029427409,
0.5481112003,
0.0025221643,
0.7771471143,
0.1309149414,
-0.3340998888,
0.7156262994,
-0.3326641917,
0.8305425644,
-0.3165770471,
-0.2236953229,
0.3748610914,
0.2427244186,
0.6023155451,
0.0756117851,
-0.4866544902,
0.0624553747,
-0.5267774463,
-0.4112599194,
-0.8517284989,
0.7832744718,
-0.2268864661,
-0.6079083085,
0.1900756657,
-0.6188955903,
-0.2517111599,
-0.1470444649,
0.314877063,
1.0055248737,
0.2402585298,
0.3506435454,
0.8662290573,
-0.085500136,
0.7015661001,
0.5420530438,
0.0289393179,
0.0161088835,
0.8322768807,
-0.0907041803,
0.2274893075,
0.4738097787,
0.5812972188,
-0.6083753109,
-0.5793957114,
-0.5858473182,
-0.1526370198,
-0.7578372955,
-0.0556865335,
-0.531494379,
0.4787852764,
-0.4242014587,
-0.6629280448,
0.0246005841,
-0.4688158929,
-0.0938010141,
-0.1522544026,
0.7340596318,
0.686923027,
-0.2073417604,
0.6414493322,
-0.5583926439,
0.1767612696,
0.4318695068,
0.5243862271,
0.0761500075,
-0.8389036059,
-0.0797449723,
0.0526626632,
0.0186585505,
-1.0365014076,
0.2430568188,
0.6775588393,
0.6059077978,
0.7620105147,
-0.1557819247,
0.5952324271,
-0.201436013,
0.7601969838,
0.1221687719,
-1.178841114,
0.6452938914,
-0.3507840335,
0.3373259008,
0.416242063,
0.1817552745,
-0.2814414501,
-0.4715588391,
-0.8065005541,
-0.9771367908,
0.6515187025,
-0.1975032687,
0.1599405408,
-0.0484350026,
0.4714787304,
0.4924325645,
0.0169452541,
-0.7701053023,
-0.0915151536,
-0.0649505034,
-0.6601372957,
-0.3571585417,
-0.1152637824,
-0.0823834762,
-0.0128093064,
0.7827740312,
-0.5311040282,
0.07971818,
0.1944535673,
-0.5240417123,
-0.191063568,
0.5035845041,
0.4719784856,
0.6814023852,
-0.023010904,
0.4596590698,
0.5327746868,
-0.0742251948,
-0.1317079812,
0.1352092475,
0.3555599153,
-0.0186366756,
0.6166828871,
0.5935460925,
0.5525040627,
-0.9289076924,
0.4945188165,
-0.0694200769,
-0.2353527546,
-0.1568396538,
0.4246513844,
0.1896922588,
0.18908678,
0.5879409313,
-0.1243377626,
0.2303917855,
-0.5725035667,
0.0663110539,
0.4315149784,
-0.2926356196,
-0.1073343381,
0.5064624548,
0.1561460346,
-0.4171607196,
0.1789213717,
-0.2206213325,
-0.5897122025,
0.7102256417,
0.5722751021,
0.7276861668,
-0.339443922,
0.1008561924,
0.0879303664,
0.065267317,
-0.1654842198,
0.1146935895,
-0.4689920843,
-0.7146375775,
-0.7725412846,
-0.4876489937,
-0.4281432629,
0.1733186692,
-0.3505088985,
-0.0791355819,
-0.1964698583,
0.559032917,
0.0862910524,
-0.0709433556,
-0.6412145495,
0.213287279,
0.1078815907,
1.0432548523,
-0.9220983386,
0.408149153,
0.5076748133,
-0.0082431547,
-0.9163970351,
0.058852911,
0.0633413568,
-0.7293002605,
0.2818288803,
0.3698806465,
-0.2558805943,
-0.0845419466,
-0.8039720058,
-0.533629477,
0.9993183017,
0.507535696,
-0.6991482377,
0.6305311918,
-0.3372647464,
0.4280702174,
-0.4829811752,
0.3615668714,
0.5551793575,
0.660615325,
-0.084981285,
-0.4806813002,
0.1162752733,
0.2128147483,
-0.4828026593,
0.1113290042,
-0.4055590928,
0.5735865235,
-0.3925490379,
-0.07716351,
-0.1422977,
0.861821413,
0.2552823126,
0.551751256,
0.9663989544,
0.1009890437,
1.0265269279,
-0.1400699914,
1.1733539104,
-0.1942633241,
-0.0296753608,
1.2290254831,
0.0058117872,
0.5576373339,
0.4926129878,
0.1381950825,
0.7048233747,
0.7318201661,
0.5491917729,
0.4257982969,
0.0145199522,
-0.7692601681,
-0.5754241347,
0.0258414187,
-0.039016623,
0.5992878079,
0.7030658722,
-0.3519101441,
-0.2083002031,
0.0239574891,
-0.1241423786,
0.0100372182,
-0.8892638087,
0.8194232583,
0.0288591329,
-0.8924025297,
0.4119337201,
-0.0518659651,
0.6402887106,
-0.4928760529,
-0.0448411405,
-0.1450468451,
0.3378126919,
-0.1595100313,
-0.8263086081,
-0.0332794935,
-0.0944415629,
-0.0770926401,
-0.4703865647,
0.8975980282,
-0.7182312012,
-0.3938392997,
0.1434991509,
0.5034400821,
0.3803539276,
-0.028830545,
-0.6162570715,
-0.2017636299,
-0.1412089467,
-0.3288116455,
0.3881837428,
0.7776402235,
0.010121922,
0.6907029748,
0.2819769979,
-0.3483898938,
-0.2466339916,
0.1472941041,
0.3911016583,
-0.1387937814,
-0.3875397742,
-0.9679014087,
0.5192837715,
-0.016617395,
-0.2147102207,
0.4672766626,
0.1449731737,
0.346875608,
0.0461676568,
0.7449729443,
0.1065777615,
0.2657801211,
-0.5476008058,
0.2863591909,
-0.888199389,
0.1627488583,
0.0186138228,
-0.698261857,
-0.1281596571,
0.5569629669,
-0.092918627,
0.1225722358,
0.4850977063,
0.6447911859,
-0.3305870593,
0.3642666936,
0.1429160237,
0.5817830563,
0.0135510881,
0.4895727932,
0.4384487867,
0.028087154,
0.6091889143,
-0.2072416395,
-0.4458326399,
-0.2559346557,
-1.2673949003,
-0.5573621392,
-0.440451771,
-0.2509959638,
-0.1649316698,
0.0735775977,
0.9297338128,
0.7551834583,
-0.5219373703,
0.0526332743,
-0.430096209,
0.7338989377,
-0.5447239876,
-0.2481406927,
0.4740546346,
-0.5609279871,
-0.876799047,
0.8059498072,
0.1543164253,
-0.0878361017,
-0.1444119066,
-0.2758995593,
0.357001394,
0.1337938756,
0.6003438234,
0.0636510029,
-0.5325930119,
-0.2677723765,
-0.3336200714,
0.3357376456,
-0.2355021536,
0.6704146862,
-0.9197639823,
0.3075421751,
0.4073884189,
0.4736723006,
0.1048746407,
-0.1246898547,
0.8549596667,
-0.7925109267,
0.2344243377,
0.0078948243,
0.6540185809,
0.3645027876,
-0.5386976004,
0.4036533535,
-0.0819894001,
-0.3950738013,
-0.7583246231,
0.0139991445,
-1.0632996559,
-0.7019827962,
1.2307884693,
-0.2035920769,
-0.365829289,
-0.3156885207,
0.1577164531,
0.3235884309,
-0.4719914198,
0.6595089436,
0.4485939741,
-0.0273094755,
-0.0101861358,
-0.3638605475,
0.4406162202,
0.6958640814,
-0.6377106309,
0.2736324668,
0.4106859863,
0.343452543,
-0.2382395118,
0.3150927126,
0.2244689167,
0.4049787819,
-0.2702637911,
-0.1977189332,
0.0428214371,
-0.4204986691,
-0.8541642427,
0.3507650495,
-0.2062009722,
-0.0207999162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07093v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07093v2
|
On the Effectiveness of ASR Representations in Real-world Noisy Speech Emotion Recognition
| 2023-11-13T05:45:55 | 2023-11-14T13:09:51 |
Xiaohan Shi, Jiajun He, Xingfeng Li, Tomoki Toda
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
This paper proposes an efficient attempt to noisy speech emotion recognition
(NSER). Conventional NSER approaches have proven effective in mitigating the
impact of artificial noise sources, such as white Gaussian noise, but are
limited to non-stationary noises in real-world environments due to their
complexity and uncertainty. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a new
method for NSER by adopting the automatic speech recognition (ASR) model as a
noise-robust feature extractor to eliminate non-vocal information in noisy
speech. We first obtain intermediate layer information from the ASR model as a
feature representation for emotional speech and then apply this representation
for the downstream NSER task. Our experimental results show that 1) the
proposed method achieves better NSER performance compared with the conventional
noise reduction method, 2) outperforms self-supervised learning approaches, and
3) even outperforms text-based approaches using ASR transcription or the ground
truth transcription of noisy speech.
|
[
-0.4180207849,
-0.3807869554,
0.0696536005,
0.1192163303,
-0.2761308849,
-0.030243814,
-0.2315308154,
-0.7250491977,
0.2640836835,
0.108973138,
-0.4787388444,
-0.0683551207,
-0.6653516293,
0.0308506414,
-0.4997093678,
0.5329684615,
0.0076763993,
0.0359544903,
0.1884330064,
0.0734282583,
0.1159712896,
-0.6976139545,
-0.6835312843,
-0.3183255196,
0.3436338603,
0.1608362794,
0.2282190025,
0.4241268635,
0.3946669102,
0.3914177418,
-0.3146465421,
-0.1691423357,
-0.4741274118,
0.3727178276,
0.4718178809,
-0.0995856076,
-0.1541676968,
0.0962842777,
0.4942048788,
-0.0524991713,
-0.3569936156,
0.1736129075,
-0.1424581707,
0.4838862419,
-0.729557693,
0.4926070869,
-0.3469207287,
0.4885637164,
-0.1534343511,
0.0768694505,
-0.1898366362,
-0.2848566175,
0.1783055961,
-0.1731366515,
-0.1244762316,
-0.1577112526,
0.8433072567,
0.6944109797,
-0.3788700998,
-0.5603755713,
-1.0971963406,
0.6852902174,
-0.6589127183,
0.7104532719,
0.209562242,
0.3651662469,
0.4458422661,
-0.3822086453,
-0.5547245741,
-0.2804857492,
0.1908438057,
0.3225458562,
-0.7406376004,
0.0126225613,
0.2442574501,
0.3593527973,
-0.1538513005,
-0.0149931964,
-0.2101257145,
-0.3210735321,
0.7048469782,
-0.1409148425,
0.1342071444,
-0.0573225208,
0.0064301738,
-0.2960050702,
0.0792638138,
0.3895432055,
0.2746579945,
0.2802242935,
-0.2096788287,
0.2308098972,
-0.1881833225,
0.1656443924,
0.3103271723,
-0.2402013987,
0.4162956476,
0.4868110418,
0.0365381911,
0.3768266439,
0.7716988921,
0.1526613832,
0.0264312942,
-0.1506122053,
-0.3494490385,
0.3665212691,
0.4384915233,
-0.8478341699,
-0.2803993821,
0.10205248,
-0.4975558519,
-0.3175396025,
-0.0784585997,
-1.0932520628,
-0.2660396993,
-0.3491264582,
0.3307479322,
-0.4631335139,
-0.3151577711,
-0.3188674748,
0.0919709802,
0.0849544257,
0.3507505357,
-0.4747790396,
0.5291875601,
0.2383950353,
0.7707641721,
0.345506072,
0.3397542536,
-0.5579293966,
-0.2273905277,
-0.0762462914,
0.5722137094,
-0.5947936177,
-0.2797773182,
-0.2851707041,
-0.329672873,
0.0605695508,
-0.6935954094,
0.6336265206,
-0.3325968683,
-0.0605405755,
-0.0743468553,
-0.3584872186,
-0.4206542671,
-0.0697531924,
-0.6683300138,
0.9445770979,
-0.2107471973,
-0.5074408054,
-0.0704798251,
-0.7780195475,
-0.2314233333,
-0.3006277978,
0.1939398199,
-0.6939650774,
0.4089642465,
0.2796852589,
0.3153474033,
0.0002651353,
0.0459993109,
-0.0355700329,
-0.4422873259,
0.520839572,
-0.552898407,
0.2509626746,
0.5294764638,
-0.5689406991,
-0.2250671089,
-0.9765707254,
-0.0123679433,
0.0461994149,
-0.1279637963,
-0.2182242423,
0.0595427006,
0.1926275194,
0.4090908468,
0.1084612235,
-0.7694054246,
-0.3710749745,
-0.2986426651,
0.3449114263,
0.4222716987,
-0.0460184142,
0.3822546005,
-0.1174626499,
0.5116304755,
0.1249221489,
-0.0838977098,
0.3336875141,
-0.188746497,
-0.9350600243,
-0.5046542883,
0.1767421961,
0.6594731212,
-0.2850209475,
0.3187040985,
0.1185830981,
-0.7088363171,
-0.9442473054,
-0.0714909732,
0.6813439131,
0.6830922961,
0.5175326467,
-0.2761031389,
-0.9490793943,
-0.2423699498,
-0.1406596452,
-0.393874675,
0.0445425473,
0.5756648183,
0.0943953022,
-0.3618223369,
0.6452678442,
-0.0952512547,
-0.2380179167,
-0.0457071364,
0.704926908,
-0.0183798112,
0.387319833,
0.1492227614,
-0.8454504609,
-0.5552050471,
-0.2099231333,
-0.6886023879,
-0.4720726609,
0.0159129854,
0.2678215802,
0.0963705108,
0.3191258609,
-0.2032602727,
0.5198382139,
0.3751372695,
0.1393723637,
0.2841621935,
0.0800655708,
0.152069062,
-0.5044024587,
-0.1050146893,
0.2279920578,
-0.0817963183,
-1.0338380337,
-0.2852362394,
-0.0115998229,
-0.380766362,
-0.3315796256,
0.2892704606,
-0.4712845385,
0.2195979059,
-0.332826525,
-0.0560709685,
-0.3419139683,
0.2994600832,
0.344937712,
0.4340932071,
0.7058280706,
-0.38939026,
0.2249991596,
0.3343400955,
0.0210126434,
0.5936894417,
-0.4217875004,
0.310038656,
-0.5097894669,
0.2151306272,
-0.5766121149,
-0.0999366269,
0.1649250686,
-0.4385004938,
0.4214857221,
-0.0991521776,
0.0622013286,
-0.4579396844,
-0.0028910288,
0.0291011781,
0.9930853844,
-0.5136657357,
0.8363539577,
0.5158288479,
-0.4597358108,
-0.3947062492,
-0.8824560046,
0.2060919255,
-0.5613636374,
-0.3283940256,
0.008663048,
0.258818388,
-0.3169954717,
-0.1566980779,
-0.4093169868,
-0.2776109576,
-0.037100926,
0.6484761238,
-0.0273026973,
-0.2921285033,
-0.0677024797,
-0.3279148936,
-0.4167277217,
0.2900422812,
0.3664583266,
0.2029985189,
-0.151077345,
-0.0997566655,
-1.0526769161,
0.5581063628,
0.3930922449,
-0.252638638,
0.1957067549,
0.8318046331,
-0.5322902203,
-0.16738832,
-0.7804198265,
-0.2251912653,
-0.476451993,
0.4139082432,
-0.3408547342,
-0.7968680859,
0.5696755648,
-0.423265636,
-0.376203388,
0.0483714603,
0.2261181027,
-0.3527473211,
1.0041710138,
0.5336081982,
-0.3985605836,
0.7889768481,
-0.1937138736,
0.7169992924,
-0.8452950716,
-0.2623322606,
-0.5746124387,
-0.4529571235,
-0.2218433022,
-0.3980083764,
0.3338258266,
-0.0515651219,
-0.2984192967,
0.1160889864,
-0.50341326,
0.1459382474,
0.3971844614,
0.2408161312,
-0.0592227094,
-0.0204138141,
0.267146498,
-0.4460303485,
-0.2772251368,
-0.3355506659,
0.3020198047,
0.3728837669,
0.7625053525,
0.0584000759,
1.0272343159,
0.0100760395,
0.2639879584,
-0.7913698554,
0.4093154371,
-0.2867061794,
-0.2042221874,
-0.2728437781,
-0.7355478406,
-0.2909002304,
0.0081996396,
-0.3199988604,
-0.9676553011,
0.5635739565,
0.1486625522,
-0.4506452084,
0.2712158561,
-0.5028572083,
0.4120585322,
-0.1018861532,
-0.0421721302,
0.106807366,
-0.7882219553,
0.0263385139,
-0.094922848,
0.3728637099,
-0.1288673133,
0.1851247102,
0.7814919949,
-0.4754394591,
0.7833807468,
-0.5884819627,
0.1930849999,
0.4657314122,
0.0273046158,
0.7601367831,
-0.3508169949,
-0.604103744,
0.2351020873,
-0.6122981906,
0.2444763184,
-0.691434443,
0.2919928432,
-0.9092866182,
-0.1383171827,
-0.4145898223,
-0.583995223,
-0.1656301469,
-0.2035230994,
0.17999354,
0.4151188731,
-0.1925930679,
0.134950459,
0.4311778843,
0.1430507749,
0.4282360375,
0.4709064066,
0.2620946467,
-0.4819712043,
1.0797690153,
0.3259095252,
-0.080377467,
0.2059958577,
0.2922250926,
-0.5394448042,
-0.3209795952,
0.1107822135,
-0.0315661728,
-0.631359458,
-0.2252316624,
-1.0634405613,
-0.5861186385,
-0.2685259283,
-0.4314093292,
-0.4859005809,
-0.2162243128,
-0.5514124632,
-0.0919520855,
0.6012707949,
0.5768049955,
-0.5782480836,
0.448656559,
-0.5963037014,
0.4998975992,
0.5430079103,
0.1985072941,
0.0490118414,
-0.5254944563,
0.0040536174,
0.0622388832,
-0.1578858346,
-0.8609412909,
0.9108911157,
0.7511274219,
0.3116579354,
0.5370534658,
0.5919023752,
1.1323432922,
-0.3193468451,
0.5714510083,
0.1707398891,
-1.2861288786,
0.5705676079,
0.1613446623,
-0.0294547733,
0.6043621302,
0.28361696,
-0.361682415,
-0.5985575914,
-0.6403452754,
-1.0663611889,
0.710712254,
0.3667601943,
0.1719842553,
0.2507256567,
0.2973136306,
-0.3756721914,
0.1973874271,
-0.7172912359,
-0.204104051,
-0.574644208,
-0.4415124953,
0.0621850267,
-0.3679425716,
0.2421316952,
-0.1425886452,
0.7311605215,
0.0868119001,
0.5008247495,
0.375936538,
-0.0636281446,
-0.4771311879,
0.5359690785,
-0.0727127641,
-0.4820694029,
-0.5936174989,
0.3569027185,
0.3675662279,
-0.4952915311,
0.3310121298,
0.3003728092,
-0.0619589016,
0.1591066122,
-0.0106230555,
0.9611859918,
0.2974086702,
-0.6592146158,
0.4332635105,
-0.2530682087,
-0.0567720458,
-0.3251752853,
0.0396651216,
0.0931446776,
0.6139339805,
0.2501886785,
0.3663007617,
0.6624991894,
-0.3929445744,
0.4006884098,
0.1280079633,
-1.1179078817,
-0.1490790993,
0.8026400805,
0.1270749271,
-0.3718365729,
0.5235667825,
-0.4518123865,
-0.8380984068,
0.5269088149,
0.7482290864,
0.9524163008,
-0.6773287058,
0.1152742729,
0.341271311,
-0.0403736979,
-0.1232997105,
0.7542464137,
-0.2245418429,
-0.4797334969,
-0.1714131534,
-0.5753121972,
-0.8990088105,
-0.3178153038,
-1.0106914043,
0.0869761929,
-0.3723047674,
-0.1249164417,
-0.0926807299,
-0.1720267385,
-0.228333354,
0.4853769243,
0.6935288906,
0.4136407375,
-0.8291717172,
0.5791924596,
0.5920790434,
-0.0273886025,
-0.8556658626,
0.1197048724,
0.6041134,
-0.5549801588,
0.4953679442,
0.4020667374,
-0.5136024952,
-0.106358476,
-0.4452477694,
-0.8651720881,
0.7988287807,
0.39306584,
-0.702043891,
0.5495441556,
0.0068498342,
0.6609752774,
-0.2609114051,
0.2767199576,
0.1908584833,
0.3888432384,
0.6027710438,
-0.6268153191,
0.0542858131,
-0.8100464344,
-0.0085740881,
0.1524839401,
-0.7339426875,
0.7093108296,
-0.0632189065,
-0.2509076595,
-0.1243531629,
0.8515582085,
0.2350322157,
0.4659062624,
0.8699624538,
0.502294302,
1.0485701561,
-0.1768587977,
0.5785396695,
-0.2982471287,
0.2475108355,
0.9307407141,
-0.5549814105,
0.9703181982,
0.1455259323,
-0.0779906884,
0.3553634286,
0.2148987949,
0.0195254106,
0.6934757829,
0.344178468,
-0.4409873188,
-0.1992706209,
-0.2976569235,
-0.1079287305,
0.6893317699,
0.3821785152,
0.026945401,
-0.066640161,
0.2436823696,
0.187518701,
-0.1191679314,
-0.2566908598,
1.063786149,
0.302724272,
0.1339167356,
0.4852499664,
-0.4124094844,
0.7908501625,
-0.4388713837,
0.0114525286,
0.3098166883,
0.1311180741,
-0.1571687758,
-0.1423400193,
0.7408102155,
0.5417271256,
-0.0533711053,
-0.3689920008,
0.9538692832,
-0.5339233279,
-0.5718421936,
0.4422280192,
0.1498270035,
0.2953116,
-0.4289126992,
-0.5584980249,
0.1320910007,
-0.1484449804,
-0.2775360346,
0.0857886001,
0.8241442442,
0.2944421172,
0.7265462279,
0.4633852839,
0.1653835475,
0.0568507947,
0.0692087859,
0.8965098262,
-0.8047339916,
-0.7284191251,
-0.5577917099,
0.7497056127,
-0.0859416053,
-0.0437071137,
0.4242073596,
0.2194185555,
0.0674282834,
0.2474655956,
0.8095105886,
-0.1550620049,
0.6130639315,
-0.1130459532,
0.7113963962,
-0.4609633982,
0.0469980501,
-0.6279646754,
-0.3997708857,
-0.5546584129,
1.2428977489,
-0.1037357226,
-0.1212639436,
0.270931989,
0.7007067204,
-0.0250316057,
0.606345892,
0.3732684553,
0.691569984,
-0.0006233414,
0.3234440684,
0.9588547945,
-0.4977464676,
0.4495391548,
-0.8012163639,
-0.3631722033,
-0.3054710925,
-0.8230272532,
-0.4668474197,
-0.3264315724,
-0.7070202827,
-0.1737240553,
0.1773055941,
1.1681791544,
0.8239662051,
-0.9985445142,
-0.1431392878,
0.2488304228,
-0.2940727472,
-0.6065582633,
-0.1626719981,
0.093963109,
-0.1257757843,
-0.5995185971,
0.5572753549,
0.1456758231,
0.1060771197,
0.2859490216,
-0.3001695573,
0.2141769975,
0.2448769808,
0.2288749367,
0.3110194504,
-0.4357514679,
-0.2642299533,
-0.1502674818,
0.1036270857,
0.2892745435,
0.361587882,
-0.5903252959,
0.5310869813,
0.2284294665,
0.2545616925,
0.609408319,
-0.0099522742,
0.200811699,
-0.667082727,
0.3090883195,
0.5514216423,
0.3925439417,
0.2175765932,
-0.5206890106,
0.3401098847,
-0.0715160295,
-0.5064370632,
-0.769330442,
-0.0841291174,
-1.3133848906,
0.348254174,
0.8851588368,
-0.2937597334,
-0.3119915426,
-0.2651748359,
-0.2910789847,
0.5099311471,
-1.0141392946,
1.0555858612,
0.3577015996,
-0.4877904952,
-0.7030123472,
-0.1949357241,
0.2763569653,
-0.0145603782,
-0.598426342,
0.1605675519,
0.3992874324,
-0.0995992869,
0.3709360063,
0.5971664786,
-0.2015377432,
-0.0142897246,
0.2138756067,
0.479780972,
-0.0550326519,
-0.1237043589,
-0.8054947853,
0.3372605443,
-0.2655164897,
0.0763979554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07092v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07092v3
|
To Tell The Truth: Language of Deception and Language Models
| 2023-11-13T05:40:11 | 2024-04-08T05:54:40 |
Sanchaita Hazra, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text-based misinformation permeates online discourses, yet evidence of
people's ability to discern truth from such deceptive textual content is
scarce. We analyze a novel TV game show data where conversations in a
high-stake environment between individuals with conflicting objectives result
in lies. We investigate the manifestation of potentially verifiable language
cues of deception in the presence of objective truth, a distinguishing feature
absent in previous text-based deception datasets. We show that there exists a
class of detectors (algorithms) that have similar truth detection performance
compared to human subjects, even when the former accesses only the language
cues while the latter engages in conversations with complete access to all
potential sources of cues (language and audio-visual). Our model, built on a
large language model, employs a bottleneck framework to learn discernible cues
to determine truth, an act of reasoning in which human subjects often perform
poorly, even with incentives. Our model detects novel but accurate language
cues in many cases where humans failed to detect deception, opening up the
possibility of humans collaborating with algorithms and ameliorating their
ability to detect the truth.
|
[
-0.2756979764,
-0.7081642747,
0.7174696326,
-0.1371882409,
0.0725922361,
0.1561946273,
-0.3833996952,
-0.4140339196,
-0.0992447361,
0.8296542764,
-0.5856133699,
-0.2473549992,
-0.7184778452,
-0.1310287118,
-0.0610698685,
0.7540559173,
0.169078365,
0.0256273262,
-0.1620046496,
-0.1266568452,
-0.464723438,
-0.4420935512,
-0.1007721722,
-0.6398521066,
0.0531902723,
0.6303910017,
0.7940821648,
0.9363265634,
0.3766281307,
0.3371702433,
0.4002093375,
0.0134068672,
-0.8047564626,
0.2435227633,
-0.3746121228,
-1.0129009485,
0.3980260789,
0.2928760052,
0.0331666768,
0.5478307009,
-0.2685250044,
0.1127340198,
-0.1834085733,
0.3841535747,
-0.5596989989,
0.1880911142,
-0.7541312575,
-0.2345875651,
-0.2610220015,
-0.2390952706,
-0.6408911347,
-0.2719668746,
0.3360110521,
-0.5762252212,
0.3702595234,
0.1206946522,
1.3440178633,
0.4985996187,
-0.3043470681,
-0.9535522461,
-0.9253330827,
1.0237129927,
-0.4903030694,
0.1371799409,
0.6346276402,
0.4040149152,
0.2377128452,
-0.4673565328,
-0.6726192832,
-0.4389395118,
-0.1552961171,
-0.1210001335,
-0.4719349742,
-0.0737635195,
0.4479772151,
0.0941147506,
-0.4271176755,
-0.148939386,
-0.1199612841,
-0.3475092649,
0.4697517157,
-0.1264398098,
0.1606991589,
-0.2626907229,
-0.4133908749,
-0.029435955,
-0.4842363596,
-0.0308357701,
0.5774062276,
0.006980747,
-0.0580052659,
0.4507139325,
-0.1941141486,
0.4926612675,
0.1792190522,
-0.4428609014,
0.1043386832,
0.0407473519,
0.0011282599,
0.324945122,
0.5911887288,
0.6534349322,
0.3965710104,
0.0747435912,
-0.135458827,
0.7960149646,
0.0766725987,
-0.723595798,
-0.2776573598,
0.0567456372,
-0.5511775017,
-0.3770966232,
0.0836492255,
-0.6328701973,
-0.7623231411,
-0.0410213247,
0.437418282,
-0.2764031887,
-0.3181342185,
0.2603421211,
-0.4472638667,
0.3594944477,
0.1722007841,
-0.5247097611,
0.3956365585,
0.557851553,
0.4702447653,
0.0013939312,
0.1667871028,
-0.5576704741,
-0.136656031,
-0.3678100705,
0.773909688,
-0.6361864805,
-0.1500351578,
-0.1001173481,
-0.16792126,
0.3849236071,
-0.4615060687,
0.8595750928,
-0.2377278805,
0.4317846894,
-0.5822309852,
-0.5698841214,
-0.2078000158,
0.169762224,
-0.8127231598,
0.4793355763,
-0.2297240645,
-0.6779027581,
0.2459877729,
-0.4795026779,
-0.4725764692,
0.1500090212,
-0.4053784907,
-0.3010009527,
0.1493656635,
0.1279200763,
0.2386614978,
-0.4084257782,
0.3265274465,
0.0919549316,
-0.5685613155,
0.8509527445,
-1.0422779322,
0.5551151037,
0.2873850167,
-0.7164793611,
-0.6008226871,
-0.5327099562,
-0.3246181607,
0.3425381482,
-0.2179171741,
-0.4132949114,
0.2792665362,
-0.4259924889,
-0.0237513874,
0.1789176613,
-0.766336441,
-0.0633753762,
-0.2480625957,
0.1242239624,
0.531144619,
-0.1930963695,
0.2401155382,
-0.6148806214,
0.4185066521,
-0.1177222878,
-0.0117264437,
-0.3125202358,
-0.4978527427,
-0.8902001381,
-0.0642869622,
0.2831455469,
0.7441660166,
-1.1916544437,
0.0983454213,
-0.3457444906,
-0.1319081783,
-0.8861706257,
-0.2628040016,
0.666516602,
0.5113353133,
0.021705756,
-0.0577778481,
-0.3832110465,
-0.944192946,
-0.5950965881,
-0.220073089,
-0.1866940707,
0.4894996881,
0.4782584012,
0.3560302556,
0.8383835554,
-0.7500168085,
-0.1098970249,
-0.2272937,
0.5794280171,
0.1176603809,
0.0000853431,
0.139512226,
-1.1191815138,
-0.4391223788,
-0.132788986,
-0.8669305444,
-0.3474904597,
-0.2770193219,
0.4212791026,
0.0157198943,
0.3774473965,
-0.2000905424,
0.5319375992,
0.5800209641,
-0.6601758003,
0.6203835607,
0.0121359751,
0.4695853293,
-0.4518918395,
-0.233630389,
-0.0506251268,
-0.3990383148,
-0.7561327219,
-0.2131827027,
-0.4065169394,
0.170597896,
-0.2855491936,
0.4133947492,
-0.6311174631,
0.1059207246,
-0.6026263237,
0.424207598,
0.2283692658,
0.5115488768,
0.2720957994,
0.6122611761,
0.5111294985,
-0.4563188255,
0.6491962075,
0.1375181526,
-0.7999761701,
1.1322599649,
-0.4068042338,
0.0099719847,
-0.3895726502,
0.1394897997,
-0.8840593696,
-0.2798280716,
0.3931626081,
-0.7986406088,
0.0641544536,
-0.1549549997,
-0.1923816949,
-0.1572652012,
-0.0331649184,
0.0673221648,
0.4133733511,
-0.4602725804,
0.6102464795,
0.4880175591,
0.1413314939,
-0.9295511246,
-0.8395696282,
0.2312649637,
-0.1298440695,
-0.4115918279,
0.1700607091,
-0.0155015513,
-0.6266538501,
0.1381697655,
-0.1444988847,
-0.2126712352,
0.0978300944,
0.5247061849,
0.0610776618,
-0.1871077567,
0.3963040113,
-0.3736096323,
-0.2006690949,
0.0796326175,
-0.1585932225,
0.3652275801,
-0.2144291252,
-0.465375632,
-0.4450382888,
0.4025685787,
0.4360522926,
-0.0083773192,
0.6507122517,
0.3870628774,
-0.4286006391,
-0.2976433039,
-0.906288445,
-0.2366552055,
-0.4632086754,
0.2925514579,
-0.607524395,
-0.7382912636,
0.2280905247,
-0.2374054939,
-0.2297317982,
0.0632791817,
0.3460925519,
0.0011419087,
0.9365139604,
0.4821852744,
0.105544433,
0.110601835,
0.0209259428,
0.066278249,
-0.2470220476,
-0.0905879885,
-0.7019304037,
-0.1654430777,
-0.5826744437,
-0.4917877614,
0.2819008827,
-0.1400318444,
-0.1401559561,
0.1145895496,
-0.5082646012,
1.0203111172,
0.6699109077,
0.2594373822,
0.5784326196,
-0.0590286329,
0.0788460746,
-0.3775509596,
-0.5734033585,
-0.5204399824,
0.9472724795,
0.482619375,
0.8911499381,
0.1890910119,
0.1349268854,
0.3593486547,
0.2815036178,
-0.6913897395,
0.475513339,
0.0115765259,
-0.8782527447,
-0.2767525315,
-0.5810565352,
-0.6437965631,
0.0464974679,
-0.249909088,
-0.5712635517,
0.1724107713,
-0.1528618485,
-0.111113295,
0.325260222,
-0.5095370412,
0.7783793807,
-0.4775826335,
-0.3489952385,
-0.3254416883,
-0.7318670154,
0.4864435792,
0.1594497412,
0.4424300492,
-0.2144773155,
0.0173260011,
0.4869326651,
-0.1568005383,
0.8776225448,
-0.1604197472,
-0.139831543,
0.3435477316,
0.3370407522,
0.5251191854,
-0.1764083654,
-0.002981398,
0.2703943253,
-0.2809041142,
-0.2482170016,
-0.5696340203,
0.4291095436,
-0.5875356197,
-0.6482836604,
-0.6031968594,
-0.3234929442,
-0.1210744232,
-0.014278465,
0.6063657403,
0.4427855015,
-0.4880779088,
0.2671307027,
1.0935860872,
-0.4207653105,
0.1283504367,
0.7067530155,
-0.1205474511,
-0.0728898048,
1.1987278461,
-0.2882164717,
0.5707356334,
0.6168175936,
0.4610960186,
-0.3941763043,
-0.2092240602,
-0.2608926892,
0.4135858119,
-0.9132962227,
-0.0458033569,
0.0072792373,
0.0019468067,
0.1723629683,
-0.0753029287,
-0.3573952913,
-0.0017284023,
-0.0040936954,
-0.1496221721,
-0.0316970795,
0.7282137871,
-0.2753482163,
0.6027033329,
-0.3624740839,
0.4856803119,
0.5545288324,
0.1772925556,
-0.4558799267,
-0.5128442645,
-0.0972027555,
0.380715251,
-0.1233915389,
-0.9519785643,
0.1791487783,
0.0591719374,
0.430536896,
0.5829179883,
0.2621798515,
0.1675945967,
-0.1914933771,
0.8100092411,
0.2250810564,
-1.0760154724,
0.2150042802,
-0.1399949193,
0.1881292164,
0.4841741323,
0.4454620779,
-0.7163651586,
-0.2319826037,
-0.6046157479,
0.0308851004,
0.6770611405,
0.2827322781,
0.0400843881,
0.1984901279,
-0.0374690704,
0.3056190908,
0.6930387616,
-1.0107613802,
-0.5233749747,
-0.2165917605,
-0.1730993837,
0.1861303598,
-0.2137943506,
-0.2923232019,
0.2743641734,
0.4541935921,
-0.2308892757,
0.4032500684,
0.172498554,
-0.1743150353,
-0.3087323904,
0.228666842,
0.5487948656,
0.6205846667,
0.0878906101,
0.3725279272,
-0.281833142,
-0.3853810132,
0.0944920704,
-0.0509992056,
-0.3958292603,
0.3203014135,
0.7162669897,
1.2286895514,
0.0992648676,
-0.9168723822,
1.1169146299,
-0.239600569,
-0.2997411788,
-0.0660351291,
-0.0758544132,
-0.1274996996,
0.2927309871,
0.4393281937,
0.2096884996,
0.0783682689,
-0.7378510833,
0.3558588028,
0.5326667428,
-0.4886922538,
-0.0827485472,
0.4818564951,
0.2651588917,
-0.3051591218,
0.3707739413,
-0.3907785118,
-0.8977434635,
0.2604267001,
0.1147125736,
0.5504281521,
-0.4946784675,
0.7411707044,
-0.0297454633,
0.3915351033,
-0.238461569,
0.1103487536,
0.0359572656,
-1.1149591208,
-0.6136182547,
-0.4185568094,
-0.2942017913,
0.2662220299,
-0.3216971159,
0.1359134614,
-0.1024814323,
0.0460109338,
-0.0994579569,
0.0468984433,
-0.5060834885,
0.1388627589,
0.5931525826,
0.4660814703,
-0.8124777079,
0.3763429523,
-0.1905459762,
-0.2347431481,
-0.6306139827,
0.2559306622,
0.1758934557,
-0.8175573349,
0.3971615434,
0.2006019503,
-0.3725355268,
-0.1789007187,
-1.0826628208,
-0.5444927812,
0.5707387328,
0.6106787324,
-0.4570370018,
-0.2248948365,
0.5019683242,
0.427613914,
-0.4468842745,
0.2905445695,
0.6443873048,
0.6512852311,
0.5174502134,
-0.9189628959,
0.075493753,
0.2640742362,
-0.4916689396,
-0.028856365,
-0.4251763821,
0.7367040515,
-0.2106102109,
-0.6054110527,
-0.0770953074,
0.5077114701,
-0.1179114953,
0.3885823786,
0.6629166603,
0.3208020329,
0.9006144404,
-0.4366848469,
0.8254170418,
-0.0232916269,
0.259523809,
0.9755200148,
-0.1991272718,
0.3337614238,
-0.0275826994,
0.1015956923,
0.8533563614,
0.0004265184,
0.011032586,
0.5506420732,
0.4133683741,
-0.2300966978,
-0.5520808101,
-0.4815842807,
0.1154457182,
0.701472044,
0.6028071046,
-0.1342165172,
-0.2313699573,
0.4542747736,
0.2890415192,
0.5772028565,
-0.1734969914,
0.6180202961,
0.050239943,
-0.8657963872,
0.6762742996,
-0.0649734512,
0.7496398687,
-0.6141859889,
-0.2746149302,
0.1348723471,
0.1564916074,
0.0003986227,
-0.8321159482,
-0.0169261415,
-0.0930215716,
0.0644730031,
-0.070095107,
0.7650943398,
-0.7038001418,
-0.0821455941,
0.0508658029,
0.5089481473,
0.2252703309,
-0.3553147316,
-0.7042306066,
0.4016853869,
0.2448725551,
0.0091252569,
-0.3012197912,
0.5935871601,
0.1969936788,
0.9929307699,
0.4845795929,
0.1821496785,
-0.1001864374,
-0.2498981655,
0.3228359222,
-0.4803631306,
-0.5793239474,
-0.6871398687,
0.3085709214,
-0.3236813843,
-0.1378422827,
0.787645936,
0.327508688,
0.8899081945,
-0.1110265926,
1.1028864384,
0.0133427558,
0.7665714025,
-0.5908464789,
0.4255746305,
-0.2092612684,
0.2746490836,
-0.0511029437,
-0.3787910938,
0.0674827695,
0.7013204098,
-0.3281426132,
-0.1772331148,
0.7257856131,
0.7096872926,
0.2811532021,
0.3442746103,
0.52999717,
0.6383518577,
0.2852236331,
0.6879226565,
0.9915279746,
-0.3005893528,
0.7564046383,
0.0675835311,
-0.4248858988,
-0.3741850257,
-0.734805882,
-0.9379758239,
-0.7774894834,
-0.3081586063,
-0.5037581921,
0.0623815805,
0.5416762829,
0.5422745943,
-0.5543379784,
-0.2652804554,
0.046771653,
0.3251452446,
-0.3642540276,
-0.2870558798,
0.0844970495,
0.2823677659,
-0.7819824219,
0.4625058472,
0.0284038223,
-0.0986340046,
-0.5220174789,
-0.2161129117,
-0.0141913602,
0.5169196725,
0.1820878983,
0.3473113477,
-0.8210976124,
-0.4746118188,
-0.0316629261,
-0.1580803692,
0.1421250254,
0.944029808,
-0.8946782351,
0.6261762977,
0.2694704533,
0.3620481193,
0.4837419093,
0.2682934105,
0.6479079127,
-0.8552866578,
-0.0028903552,
0.4359315932,
0.0151129048,
0.5250006318,
-0.4863278866,
0.2548331916,
0.6221408844,
-0.5172476768,
-0.8495873213,
0.5111141801,
-0.6492432952,
-0.7223223448,
1.0197259188,
0.0250654183,
-0.2211905271,
-0.5491418839,
-0.3595395982,
0.0434134454,
-0.3551405668,
0.5819476843,
1.1389770508,
0.2104727328,
0.0983796939,
-0.5911091566,
0.9311257601,
-0.052185569,
-0.5199031234,
0.2546889186,
0.6669355631,
0.1999873221,
0.5930660367,
0.4211624563,
0.363173455,
0.1826698929,
0.3168520331,
-0.1430176497,
0.0135592381,
-0.5331206918,
-0.111830391,
0.2949904501,
-0.2443392724,
-0.2484564632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07076v1
|
On the Discussion of Large Language Models: Symmetry of Agents and Interplay with Prompts
| 2023-11-13T04:56:48 | 2023-11-13T04:56:48 |
Qineng Wang, Zihao Wang, Ying Su, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Two ways has been discussed to unlock the reasoning capability of a large
language model. The first one is prompt engineering and the second one is to
combine the multiple inferences of large language models, or the multi-agent
discussion. Theoretically, this paper justifies the multi-agent discussion
mechanisms from the symmetry of agents. Empirically, this paper reports the
empirical results of the interplay of prompts and discussion mechanisms,
revealing the empirical state-of-the-art performance of complex multi-agent
mechanisms can be approached by carefully developed prompt engineering. This
paper also proposes a scalable discussion mechanism based on conquer and merge,
providing a simple multi-agent discussion solution with simple prompts but
state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-1.0337063074,
-0.9297780395,
0.9605793953,
0.3748776913,
-0.0458799042,
-0.0618397109,
-0.2572704554,
-0.3638004959,
0.3018889725,
0.3182595372,
-0.7053769827,
-0.0327721499,
-0.2940152287,
0.0950849131,
-0.0572011322,
0.6938694715,
-0.0305743422,
0.4204974771,
-0.1861879677,
-0.2515464723,
-0.7686820626,
-0.6766729951,
-0.6036339998,
-0.2501927614,
0.6773495674,
0.3782977462,
0.8446182013,
0.386424154,
0.3512698114,
0.5843285918,
-0.1344050914,
0.2754681706,
-0.2475622296,
0.8061060309,
-0.3714423776,
-0.3930164576,
-0.391545862,
0.1871716827,
0.9531038404,
0.5021613836,
0.0510805883,
-0.1786837429,
0.2732211053,
0.2944081724,
-0.1680303514,
0.2624453306,
-0.472316891,
-0.3208478987,
-0.0700348765,
-0.2501972914,
-0.5586478114,
-0.2378715575,
-0.0005147242,
-0.4318757951,
-0.5380006433,
0.2074375898,
0.8467841148,
0.1128059998,
-0.3594825566,
-0.2336505949,
-0.6015647054,
0.8008033037,
-0.5306991935,
0.1773433238,
0.0536475703,
0.6658642888,
-0.3319669664,
-0.5910729766,
-0.6083778739,
-0.4902058244,
-0.1365815997,
-0.1278964579,
-0.1841100901,
0.193803817,
0.4214704633,
0.1225439236,
-0.3715729415,
0.2997454107,
-0.1303919405,
-0.1870793104,
0.5924416184,
0.3167793155,
0.4806787968,
0.1836791933,
-0.254465282,
-0.0755406246,
-0.5043933392,
-0.0031134333,
0.4006760716,
0.3547303975,
-0.0214585997,
0.5861737132,
-0.1790560484,
0.6679634452,
0.0356883556,
0.0556741804,
-0.1439441592,
-0.6312826872,
0.0216915198,
-0.3114727139,
0.9287725091,
0.434578687,
0.0203565452,
-0.049457591,
-0.1808217019,
0.0556252189,
0.0847240463,
-0.8010540009,
0.3512584269,
0.2823449373,
-0.4778263271,
0.1203095987,
0.0599621758,
-0.9002748132,
-0.3956590295,
-0.4338986576,
0.2918741703,
-0.3178151846,
-0.2648922503,
-0.0031495353,
-0.349196434,
0.2446011454,
0.7157521844,
-0.4614220262,
0.3412809372,
1.0214812756,
0.7591673136,
0.1367715597,
-0.8057922125,
-0.6034786701,
-0.1256316453,
-0.2898435593,
0.9164386392,
-0.5907073617,
-0.3438770771,
-0.0734448507,
-0.0831256062,
-0.104024522,
-0.1034680307,
0.6219316721,
-0.6148352623,
0.4810052812,
-0.6395910978,
-0.6222657561,
-0.0856515616,
0.5905379057,
-0.7722386718,
0.3290572464,
-0.2734267116,
-0.6226472259,
0.0706847906,
-0.6519768834,
-0.0761374012,
0.2114979774,
-0.243033126,
-0.0553421043,
-0.2016454041,
0.0779955387,
0.262675792,
-0.8288309574,
0.4580662847,
-0.5771547556,
-0.1588304937,
0.5684414506,
-0.4537338018,
0.7537294626,
0.5167779326,
-0.0911078677,
0.4124187827,
-0.1969554126,
0.0441042259,
-0.0198967494,
0.0166759398,
-0.2535939813,
-0.134460628,
-0.3997710347,
0.4184210896,
0.2335861623,
-0.2846636474,
0.7353364825,
-0.453564018,
0.4862014651,
0.6396800876,
0.0244579781,
0.8349910975,
-0.783622086,
0.560360074,
-0.0143053327,
0.1390779763,
-0.5943252444,
-0.6594147682,
-0.5669506192,
-0.2929131389,
-0.0585542768,
0.2671584487,
-0.660872221,
0.1127955168,
0.1264870614,
-0.6872255802,
-0.3835715652,
-0.2743506432,
0.4988765419,
0.0160003062,
0.1766099632,
0.3403764963,
-0.4166898727,
-0.8010214567,
-0.371557951,
-0.3495721519,
0.2137733102,
0.3586995602,
0.1235522851,
-0.0006291579,
0.9934701324,
-0.2977896333,
0.4056166708,
-0.4565010667,
0.394965291,
0.2498158365,
0.5616984367,
0.8130064607,
-0.4933116734,
-0.7312893867,
-0.0655008256,
-0.7967515588,
0.0227966104,
-0.2003518343,
-0.3895812333,
0.1908735484,
0.7597787976,
-1.2259094715,
0.0371619239,
0.4935512245,
-0.3996675014,
0.6270994544,
0.0194191523,
0.7186042666,
-1.2821962833,
-0.2825609744,
-0.1227188706,
0.0577176809,
-0.6962713003,
0.536799252,
-0.2298176736,
-0.4096719325,
-0.2066328377,
0.8727944493,
-0.7781872153,
0.3708018064,
-0.4644217491,
0.2452462465,
0.0230822936,
0.3415085077,
-0.2354332507,
0.8292673826,
0.9284359217,
-0.6605049968,
0.5852898359,
0.1729067415,
0.005747098,
0.5949984789,
-0.6246489286,
0.1134437397,
-0.2232424915,
0.3320181072,
-1.3341511488,
-0.1925168037,
0.1278625429,
-0.3944922686,
0.1308476478,
-0.1616631895,
-0.339371562,
-0.4113253057,
-0.5094254017,
0.4516831934,
0.2847236693,
-0.4452117085,
0.6822549105,
0.4345028996,
-0.5852719545,
-0.5398994684,
-0.0852817371,
0.3368141949,
-0.3574214876,
-1.129421711,
-0.0418543518,
-0.3404996693,
-0.7073230743,
-0.1549890786,
0.3875416219,
0.0633860976,
0.0436362028,
0.133122921,
0.2773209512,
-0.3931447268,
0.4125684202,
0.2304304689,
-0.1226378158,
0.1566938013,
-0.0487168543,
1.0228499174,
-0.3560988903,
-0.5622265935,
-0.4391958714,
0.8345730305,
1.0296781063,
-0.2300350666,
0.9981799722,
-0.1702367961,
-0.2060617208,
-0.2242447287,
-0.7778514028,
-0.5525186658,
-0.5254041553,
0.255236119,
-0.7462916374,
-0.999632895,
0.7318136096,
-0.2954064012,
0.4238399267,
0.4370053709,
0.5661374927,
0.1816858053,
1.3517497778,
0.4369216263,
0.2298925519,
0.3538723588,
0.2709917724,
0.3207850754,
-0.4493367374,
-0.1816779822,
-1.134937048,
-0.2290801555,
-0.3133023381,
-0.4201330245,
0.3966608942,
0.2029674053,
-0.3742578924,
0.2531358898,
-0.2349279672,
0.4230523109,
0.5576986074,
-0.3671347499,
0.1163859069,
-0.1267177612,
-0.3153830469,
-0.0048982236,
-0.533849895,
-0.6152787805,
0.5082120299,
0.3620788753,
0.843139112,
0.3799829483,
0.4141193628,
-0.0044516409,
-0.0436922498,
-0.8295416832,
0.8657479286,
0.3828421533,
-0.4803544879,
-0.6128352284,
-0.4984237552,
-1.0018469095,
0.594121933,
-0.1984505653,
-0.6545017362,
0.2297409475,
0.0254991706,
-0.0913807303,
0.2102799863,
-0.7672104239,
0.8334918618,
0.0482220836,
-0.174275279,
-0.4641541541,
-0.5814967155,
0.4385240376,
0.211206615,
0.2688812912,
0.2229529619,
0.4510872662,
0.5393532515,
-0.7936660647,
0.5273798704,
-0.0077330894,
-0.3453638554,
0.5299323797,
0.168302834,
0.5988335609,
0.0736371949,
0.0481091142,
-0.0099657252,
-0.2630772889,
-0.1591376513,
-0.8598599434,
0.7360390425,
-0.8782172799,
-1.0455739498,
-0.389449507,
-0.53330791,
-0.3634332418,
0.0844905376,
0.1721087694,
0.4727385044,
-0.2459890246,
-0.0088256961,
0.3979521692,
-0.1203390062,
0.6584703922,
0.4770626426,
-0.3647724688,
-0.4204708338,
0.5919979811,
0.063288413,
0.4412660599,
0.2049761415,
0.3660369515,
-0.1535148323,
0.0928466916,
-0.5068653226,
0.4541613162,
-0.7852306962,
-0.2833919227,
-0.9935936332,
-0.3654449582,
-0.5651273727,
-0.3544179499,
-0.462634176,
-0.4247234166,
0.1211125925,
0.0281746592,
0.2007526308,
0.6696817875,
0.0376441777,
0.4332862794,
-0.8953458667,
0.0395901352,
0.6260659695,
0.0153198689,
0.4481062293,
-0.3310977519,
-0.1520556509,
0.236866504,
-0.2545658648,
-1.1856013536,
0.1264797896,
-0.3816848993,
0.8657204509,
0.5483884811,
0.0059790197,
0.6069893241,
-0.5354295969,
0.8591238856,
0.3974300623,
-1.1496543884,
0.2574086785,
-0.2814376056,
-0.0381227098,
0.0460864715,
0.3704991341,
-0.651360333,
-0.6236719489,
-0.4187064469,
-0.5536755323,
0.9580934644,
-0.0504417866,
-0.0561076663,
-0.0356314257,
-0.0059429072,
0.0379677266,
0.220344767,
-0.4643323123,
-0.2238815427,
-0.0093995202,
0.2019115835,
-0.0125355488,
-0.5452371836,
-0.5562486649,
-0.0617856644,
0.5411626101,
-0.080680877,
0.1539055258,
-0.1603391021,
0.0323575735,
-0.1999999881,
0.7030061483,
0.7419276237,
0.6224448681,
0.4312334955,
0.1773058772,
-0.1946916431,
-0.1078895777,
0.3352338374,
0.1666892171,
-0.1357554644,
-0.2271325886,
0.3795404434,
0.9908184409,
-0.2472202629,
-0.4037941992,
0.3998163044,
-0.3298611641,
-0.3288006485,
0.2604773641,
-0.0720162764,
0.1923025101,
0.5525843501,
-0.0272402074,
0.1301440746,
0.2080994099,
-0.8879208565,
0.1076507345,
0.705614388,
-0.1933513135,
-0.1514233798,
0.5097059011,
0.329888761,
-0.3073547781,
0.5584527254,
-0.3919878006,
-0.5462608933,
0.722841382,
0.6873406172,
0.863130331,
-0.4544326961,
0.5640339851,
0.378557682,
0.4010502994,
-0.2671552598,
0.3706312478,
0.2128008604,
-0.7783384919,
-0.6744886637,
-0.255653441,
-0.4530706406,
-0.2328286022,
-0.2974090576,
0.3212892115,
-0.2950423062,
-0.3016186953,
-0.0050548417,
-0.0491404124,
-0.1948174685,
-0.4692333639,
0.066359885,
0.8727926016,
-0.8865147829,
0.382871598,
0.8670933843,
-0.5642213821,
-1.1022080183,
-0.0970044658,
-0.1890171468,
-0.4774844944,
0.5657586455,
0.2283018231,
-0.3388104737,
-0.3281630278,
-0.8108264804,
-0.8514530063,
0.6566172838,
0.7725306153,
-0.5645823479,
0.1342800856,
-0.1796846986,
0.366376698,
-0.2887637615,
0.6494730115,
-0.040409483,
0.7591411471,
0.3846623898,
-1.3101825714,
0.2758779526,
-0.5699978471,
-0.2048712522,
0.2109272033,
-0.9882577062,
1.4546368122,
-0.1335615814,
-0.4432323277,
0.4017232955,
0.7105293274,
0.514331162,
0.3024914861,
0.590129137,
0.2006368339,
0.7152023315,
-0.1891739666,
0.8590871096,
-0.4938443601,
0.4537763894,
0.8090669513,
-0.6805321574,
0.1743638664,
0.3432485759,
0.023023583,
0.3900650144,
0.2007063478,
0.3909884095,
-0.0141142979,
0.1854522079,
-0.2886223495,
-0.5570898652,
-0.2096721679,
-0.575355351,
0.2384607643,
0.2264310122,
0.2287826538,
-0.3182921708,
0.1548261344,
0.282636404,
0.1760469526,
-0.3219330013,
1.0673363209,
-0.0452294163,
-1.2245534658,
0.3832316995,
0.1808738708,
0.3331564963,
-0.6261250377,
-0.3237894475,
-0.1641106457,
-0.1252576262,
0.1714137197,
-0.7596580982,
-0.1098499745,
-0.3423683941,
-0.0625166446,
-0.3280923069,
0.54238379,
-0.6337653995,
-0.0111953653,
0.2688224912,
0.6068184376,
0.1233554259,
-0.1679055244,
-0.4748865068,
0.1108989045,
-0.4299339354,
-0.1038109064,
0.3111331761,
1.0672563314,
-0.28618595,
0.6579785347,
0.4685478806,
-0.1624722034,
0.0034302201,
0.2396027893,
1.3348404169,
-0.5762990117,
-0.8328382373,
-1.1355296373,
0.4504132569,
-0.416184932,
0.0770782307,
0.845823288,
0.2843159437,
0.2858068943,
-0.0602064244,
0.6581017971,
0.1240040287,
0.5204829574,
-0.574524045,
0.7785916328,
-0.4246482253,
0.1247613505,
-0.3917200863,
-0.8888754845,
0.0808193758,
0.4415627122,
0.0537728854,
0.3042422831,
1.0006089211,
0.6043617725,
0.062263269,
0.2023377419,
0.3697705567,
0.590773344,
0.6030888557,
0.3801524937,
1.3446946144,
-0.0107422201,
0.2085609436,
0.1049519256,
-0.5158812404,
-0.1088646352,
-0.7253932357,
-0.9892254472,
-0.6749783754,
-0.0710664392,
-0.6318621039,
-0.1404523551,
1.0510123968,
0.3987420201,
-0.5613616705,
-0.4423701167,
-0.056976147,
0.5129942894,
-0.2142221332,
-0.1698407531,
0.2581960261,
-0.6475327611,
-0.9611859322,
0.4326356053,
0.3931245804,
-0.1630181968,
-0.5082278252,
-0.3036002219,
-0.1621463895,
0.4242337644,
0.5212936401,
0.3958753645,
-0.6055464745,
-0.0564137064,
-0.012098887,
-0.1915600151,
-0.1547398567,
1.1909013987,
-0.4790940881,
0.2961063981,
0.7540234327,
0.5309166908,
-0.1051926762,
0.074466899,
0.8338255286,
-0.319070667,
0.3729120791,
-0.1166983247,
0.6058648229,
-0.1518678963,
-0.3073244691,
-0.0514512807,
0.1280172616,
-0.830198288,
-0.8910083175,
0.681799531,
-0.9250888824,
-0.3984164596,
1.0616230965,
-0.1434186846,
0.0778022408,
-0.0136452522,
-0.63695997,
0.1541569084,
-0.4912738204,
0.4477739334,
1.0506557226,
0.0899620429,
-0.2085905671,
-0.0033734147,
0.3123351336,
0.2873108089,
-0.867356658,
0.1125718057,
0.6287737489,
-0.3432213068,
0.4781785011,
0.7339248657,
-0.114056021,
0.1789506823,
0.3262316287,
-0.1402400136,
0.0361329131,
-0.8370697498,
-0.1642133147,
0.5239969492,
0.269723326,
0.153869167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07070v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07070v1
|
Explain-then-Translate: An Analysis on Improving Program Translation with Self-generated Explanations
| 2023-11-13T04:28:49 | 2023-11-13T04:28:49 |
Zilu Tang, Mayank Agarwal, Alex Shypula, Bailin Wang, Derry Wijaya, Jie Chen, Yoon Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work explores the use of self-generated natural language explanations as
an intermediate step for code-to-code translation with language models. Across
three types of explanations and 19 programming languages constructed from the
MultiPL-E dataset, we find the explanations to be particularly effective in the
zero-shot case, improving performance by 12% on average. Improvements with
natural language explanations are particularly pronounced on difficult
programs. We release our dataset, code, and canonical solutions in all 19
languages.
|
[
-0.4016723037,
-0.5445260406,
0.6746759415,
0.3689880967,
-0.1643339694,
0.1802312285,
-0.3802106082,
-0.436293453,
-0.1509645581,
0.3170260191,
-0.6947013736,
-0.3059455156,
-0.5920825005,
0.3482768834,
-0.4679253399,
1.2595705986,
-0.2602052391,
0.111139819,
0.0855364054,
0.0754781887,
-0.5915516615,
-0.1212192029,
-0.4720554054,
-0.2860785127,
0.3947794437,
0.8109257221,
0.7541783452,
0.7583297491,
0.528131187,
0.3569229543,
0.5939922929,
-0.121404402,
-0.4000149369,
-0.1206418276,
-0.1024941355,
-0.6072669625,
-0.2685473859,
-0.3165519238,
0.2057318538,
0.644356668,
0.137067467,
0.2919770479,
-0.1722823828,
0.7404064536,
-0.350191623,
0.1309143901,
-0.1892623901,
0.0020133506,
-0.1473074704,
-0.5869430304,
-0.4494781792,
-0.5418868065,
-0.0538665056,
-0.6356713176,
0.4062720537,
-0.103341125,
0.3607334197,
0.2155524343,
-0.4017952085,
-0.5002929568,
-1.0762571096,
0.9890182614,
-0.8558946848,
0.0580967218,
-0.2122238725,
0.6437565684,
-0.2182520032,
-0.6456307769,
-0.5966708064,
-0.0044638128,
-0.1136444286,
0.1895845532,
-0.2762568593,
0.2348097712,
0.2426117957,
0.6203203797,
-0.898409605,
0.0096675092,
-0.5980510116,
-0.4082353413,
0.9083476067,
0.0578594916,
0.5055413842,
0.0371725596,
-0.1040901467,
0.0012038775,
-0.7793121934,
0.0613243058,
0.12709032,
0.1250300556,
-0.1606808752,
0.5630040765,
-0.1857385188,
1.039809227,
-0.125169158,
-0.052997984,
0.1623439342,
-0.5557017922,
-0.2389315367,
0.1348882318,
0.4660156071,
0.3534760475,
0.3386202753,
-0.2215805501,
0.0427006111,
0.0599630289,
0.1247047931,
-0.84135741,
-0.4107346535,
0.4907990396,
-0.7124765515,
-0.2040892988,
-0.2560010552,
-0.8539537787,
-0.0444119237,
-0.3829103112,
0.3070259392,
-0.3209547997,
-0.314457953,
0.3853750527,
-0.0665644631,
0.351157099,
0.3770196438,
-0.8258329034,
0.0772577301,
0.4696473479,
0.7345662117,
-0.0053274976,
-0.2198884487,
-0.6175426245,
-0.0443908907,
-0.713329196,
0.8749518991,
-0.1019815952,
-0.2286907136,
0.0937492698,
-0.2068943679,
0.1237773821,
-0.2322917581,
0.3899717033,
-0.2740130424,
0.4843592644,
-0.2064853311,
-0.4979766309,
-0.2842014134,
-0.1298959106,
-0.1790922582,
0.955337286,
-0.1011672467,
-0.434871912,
0.2799779773,
-1.2383664846,
-0.5467240214,
0.1261321455,
-0.028919477,
-0.041140642,
0.5327720046,
0.3941051066,
0.3383093178,
-0.1202792898,
0.2800872624,
-0.173905164,
-0.31791839,
0.2281683832,
-0.2664578557,
0.9124943614,
0.7459856868,
-0.3969676793,
0.1916235238,
-0.5602736473,
0.2748556733,
0.356020242,
-0.1839435995,
0.0447427146,
-0.0949219763,
-0.4588450193,
0.3457805216,
0.36854285,
-0.3835420609,
0.2133998275,
-0.6715402007,
0.2934551537,
0.4030534923,
-0.0786083266,
0.6687146425,
0.0067309989,
0.9906926751,
-0.1883616,
0.3203179836,
-0.7672950029,
-0.7336850762,
-0.6292020082,
0.1831248403,
-0.1154490486,
0.3202089071,
-0.9862068295,
-0.2061773837,
-0.2975563407,
-0.2084285319,
-0.6050502062,
0.2220759541,
0.6896585226,
0.3986123204,
0.4552046359,
0.0650526956,
-0.5904762745,
-0.9525796175,
-0.6034607291,
-0.2139937133,
-0.0537547395,
-0.0279194098,
0.352301985,
-0.0320173278,
0.571325779,
-0.520945549,
0.2444358021,
-0.5351842642,
0.5441712737,
0.4584062397,
0.2650064528,
0.5990977287,
-0.4660529196,
-0.7602833509,
-0.1152544841,
-0.5080463886,
-0.4808487892,
-0.5643888116,
-0.3103834093,
-0.0291100759,
0.688526392,
-0.2266637534,
0.3560350537,
0.7324530482,
-0.2731220722,
0.7405316234,
-0.6484962106,
0.1647602022,
-0.9071944952,
-0.0632253662,
-0.2047776878,
-0.3403261304,
-0.7785868049,
0.384314239,
0.059684258,
-0.2386273444,
-0.458834976,
0.1932802945,
-0.8399085402,
-0.1806245595,
-0.3663481772,
0.3719629049,
0.1310712844,
0.263454169,
-0.1792471111,
1.0076090097,
0.8612671494,
-0.7787845135,
0.2841561437,
0.1718675941,
-0.037791878,
0.2606549859,
-0.6445968747,
0.1963323951,
-0.2039543837,
-0.0492000505,
-1.3399529457,
-0.2974648178,
0.0928334147,
-0.7546533346,
0.4765752256,
-0.268003732,
-0.2978306711,
-0.751986146,
-0.225108251,
0.2053709477,
0.3527054787,
-0.7299638391,
0.2502468526,
-0.0659347028,
-0.0330589637,
-0.3834253848,
-0.7619505525,
0.3355298638,
-0.1196290478,
-0.5816953778,
0.6003040671,
-0.6641378403,
-0.2521505058,
-0.1375537515,
0.0066451943,
-0.1932574511,
0.1274207085,
0.0213244557,
0.0906663314,
-0.5303949714,
0.29798159,
0.1477867067,
-0.4609000683,
0.2188866585,
-0.2470785379,
0.2622353137,
-0.2641966045,
-0.0984891281,
-0.4113199711,
0.5623857379,
0.5337561965,
-0.1470855922,
0.7924066782,
0.5399581194,
0.1073181257,
-0.1526282281,
-0.1900756061,
-0.1505272388,
-0.4814299941,
0.1610995829,
-0.7881885767,
-0.4446065724,
0.3390288651,
-0.2132897377,
0.1885505468,
0.4714858234,
0.6087354422,
-0.0488955677,
1.5220906734,
0.6498776078,
0.0773461163,
0.3662433326,
-0.2860377431,
0.7381342053,
-0.2184896618,
-0.203474775,
-0.7163835764,
-0.0752033815,
-0.579969883,
-0.4633983374,
0.0912101418,
0.3023990095,
0.0084336158,
0.7757623792,
-0.6786670089,
0.7275257707,
0.3189892769,
-0.4553899467,
0.294272542,
-0.0836685076,
0.1871337295,
-0.1913894117,
-0.7878290415,
-0.3015638292,
1.0071605444,
0.2353761494,
0.6436262131,
0.2875275016,
1.0639289618,
0.2947094142,
0.5021986365,
-0.6265805364,
0.2776080966,
-0.1146052256,
-0.7070479989,
-0.290363282,
-0.325456053,
-0.7720006108,
0.2019965053,
-0.0172581021,
-0.5047553778,
-0.0447372682,
0.4033715725,
-0.4403257668,
-0.2028866261,
-1.0852288008,
1.0666342974,
-0.7229322791,
-0.0348508395,
-0.4991171956,
-0.4293187261,
0.5150535703,
-0.0519638062,
0.6065576077,
-0.0096175205,
0.1052332744,
0.4801265895,
-0.4685450196,
0.38595438,
-0.2625004351,
-0.2893056273,
0.235211134,
0.4271225929,
0.3351579905,
-0.1855546087,
-0.3418062031,
0.1659155339,
0.0462887995,
-0.4969856441,
-0.9056279063,
0.5883532166,
-0.4321265221,
-0.5291239023,
-0.1029330343,
-0.4224780798,
0.2722764611,
0.1842951179,
0.3402308226,
0.4900965095,
0.0699473247,
0.1713382453,
0.3873860836,
-0.6588448286,
0.7066411972,
0.853906095,
-0.4951953292,
-0.0947853699,
0.8183062673,
-0.0752441362,
0.3607148528,
0.3714679778,
0.2730664313,
-0.5522559881,
-0.7259320617,
-0.9650399089,
0.050743673,
-0.6988716722,
-0.2729380131,
-0.3816646934,
0.1784169078,
-0.4561645687,
-0.4958194792,
-0.4418490231,
-0.6840983629,
-0.018806722,
-0.2152576298,
0.1695444435,
0.7740749121,
-0.346997112,
0.533100903,
-0.6812612414,
0.7167237401,
0.0414526314,
0.2642734349,
-0.0803771242,
-0.731446445,
-0.5785316825,
0.0897681564,
-0.2088472098,
-1.3864467144,
0.5847529769,
0.6571017504,
0.6509884596,
0.4715951979,
-0.1320714802,
1.0912475586,
-0.3459650874,
0.8412359357,
0.4158921242,
-1.1866455078,
0.9200101495,
-0.2074908763,
0.4525411129,
0.3766781986,
0.2867771387,
-0.4109711647,
-0.4822531343,
-0.4940982163,
-0.5565233827,
0.9049885273,
0.3375228345,
0.2517972887,
-0.0717706829,
0.5320700407,
0.1383248121,
0.0081910202,
-0.8880616426,
-0.5442503691,
-0.2765061557,
-0.1026736945,
-0.3019259274,
-0.3236459792,
0.121608004,
-0.0939942077,
0.6592741013,
-0.4139573872,
0.610611856,
0.1037489548,
-0.3652364314,
-0.3104079664,
0.3827806413,
0.8169890642,
0.9197654128,
0.1758758128,
0.3677686155,
-0.070698455,
0.1590353101,
-0.041409608,
-0.1421561092,
0.1233684346,
0.1466668397,
0.5384824276,
0.4348736703,
0.1058506444,
-0.4777475893,
0.5813085437,
-0.0809826106,
-0.0949129835,
-0.1307188272,
0.1138878763,
0.0850022808,
-0.0612208582,
0.1497618258,
-0.0903683081,
0.5461592674,
-0.6354913712,
0.1014199182,
0.1821037978,
-0.1457955092,
-0.5378030539,
0.7423272133,
0.1580388993,
-0.463490665,
0.4420390427,
-0.3151051998,
-0.585164547,
0.6572962999,
0.9224247336,
0.8113588691,
-0.3234019876,
0.8247194886,
0.6114577055,
0.296607703,
0.0783563256,
0.5278838277,
-0.4517364502,
-0.6303738356,
-1.1177831888,
-0.2993291318,
-0.194650799,
-0.1275385469,
-0.6940712929,
0.0854897648,
-0.0110437442,
0.1357629001,
0.2214949578,
-0.2767877281,
-0.8096705675,
0.1067341864,
0.2817957103,
0.8299191594,
-1.098166585,
0.8889245391,
0.4501713216,
-0.7642371655,
-0.909961164,
-0.1354201287,
-0.0902354717,
-1.0215339661,
0.6688640714,
0.1632560045,
-0.2067346126,
0.0562646687,
-0.6547636986,
-0.8185563087,
0.5335174203,
0.5272962451,
-0.4577931166,
0.3758258522,
0.1804175377,
1.011806488,
-0.3702493608,
0.4046703577,
0.6139054298,
0.5751545429,
-0.2261558622,
-0.6055229902,
-0.0939138383,
-0.2404449731,
0.0810463652,
0.2451056242,
-0.086607866,
0.4361412823,
-0.6037142873,
-0.2749069035,
-0.0700568333,
0.6129238009,
-0.269135803,
0.3512010574,
0.19644247,
0.1456293017,
0.4265086055,
0.0082689337,
1.3658438921,
-0.7821900845,
0.2820357084,
1.2108373642,
0.374670893,
0.5638819933,
0.6210958362,
-0.2743190825,
0.9741951823,
0.6592906713,
0.3050825298,
0.4502931237,
0.1720971614,
-0.150301978,
-0.3786032796,
0.0481394269,
-0.3383696079,
0.4773258269,
0.2427689433,
-0.5151497126,
-0.4460196197,
0.0980943516,
-0.1786527485,
-0.0271013901,
-0.120583415,
0.753991425,
0.1349702626,
-1.0029177666,
0.7696694732,
0.2399530262,
0.0644852072,
-0.3078541458,
-0.2943220735,
-0.3967649937,
0.2408723533,
-0.3309240043,
-0.8937987685,
0.7412925363,
0.061950285,
-0.2121245861,
-0.7609182596,
0.5889586806,
-0.4549867809,
-0.4106923938,
0.5692234039,
0.5077208877,
0.7358734012,
-0.065696992,
-1.1780525446,
-0.208797276,
0.3857032359,
0.0267177206,
-0.0657000169,
0.5600586534,
-0.0040132543,
0.7285972238,
0.6201779842,
0.0341893174,
0.4872173667,
0.1576969475,
0.4145622551,
-0.3724855483,
-0.4018872976,
-1.0014722347,
0.7368348241,
0.1050323769,
-0.0301348791,
0.9572425485,
0.6390533447,
0.7448827624,
-0.4791551828,
0.5836262703,
-0.1916268468,
0.451920867,
-0.4193682671,
0.1093551144,
-0.5442500114,
0.2708465457,
-0.1250358373,
-0.9112135172,
-0.4064067304,
0.5747215748,
-0.3659022152,
-0.2488167584,
0.750947535,
0.883212924,
-0.048128143,
-0.2265430689,
0.5567482114,
0.3260665536,
0.4798637927,
0.4325374961,
0.4799587429,
-0.4817568064,
0.8959182501,
-0.3757643998,
-0.303368777,
-0.3130840361,
-1.1600025892,
-0.4253217578,
-0.2668953538,
-0.5687926412,
-0.28288275,
-0.1663440466,
0.4952644408,
0.9403988719,
-1.0542207956,
-0.2782104313,
-0.5374587178,
0.2268600315,
-0.3888709843,
-0.2147027701,
0.1868218333,
-0.6417748928,
-0.5214099884,
0.7969115376,
0.4233962595,
-0.1084768623,
-0.3841458857,
-0.4006713331,
0.3249253035,
0.1181196421,
0.7331044674,
0.5626177192,
-0.6675912142,
-0.1862078309,
0.0649800077,
0.2771402299,
0.2946972251,
1.2183717489,
-0.5054916739,
1.2535752058,
0.647960484,
0.3270787001,
0.5254071355,
0.0619963109,
1.0489140749,
-0.5845258236,
-0.0192305017,
-0.3095130324,
0.2634242773,
0.3356143534,
-0.4871678054,
0.4445236623,
-0.1895454079,
-0.4487589002,
-0.46680516,
0.2165100724,
-0.5315720439,
-0.1999318749,
0.7873167396,
-0.3496673405,
-0.0751201138,
-0.4449006319,
-0.2361990809,
0.4428600073,
-0.2003614008,
0.8334951997,
0.4512418509,
-0.4736094773,
-0.3458657563,
-0.8186606169,
0.5917189121,
0.3143256009,
-0.9054467678,
0.0248897038,
0.5460212231,
0.2075300664,
0.1548315883,
0.8570665717,
-0.351216495,
0.36663872,
-0.0927371085,
0.3152025938,
0.0796646401,
-0.5449793339,
-0.6399244666,
-0.2474713475,
0.2959057987,
-0.4048433304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07066v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07066v1
|
Context Consistency between Training and Testing in Simultaneous Machine Translation
| 2023-11-13T04:11:32 | 2023-11-13T04:11:32 |
Meizhi Zhong, Lemao Liu, Kehai Chen, Mingming Yang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) aims to yield a real-time partial
translation with a monotonically growing the source-side context. However,
there is a counterintuitive phenomenon about the context usage between training
and testing: e.g., the wait-k testing model consistently trained with wait-k is
much worse than that model inconsistently trained with wait-k' (k' is not equal
to k) in terms of translation quality. To this end, we first investigate the
underlying reasons behind this phenomenon and uncover the following two
factors: 1) the limited correlation between translation quality and training
(cross-entropy) loss; 2) exposure bias between training and testing. Based on
both reasons, we then propose an effective training approach called context
consistency training accordingly, which makes consistent the context usage
between training and testing by optimizing translation quality and latency as
bi-objectives and exposing the predictions to the model during the training.
The experiments on three language pairs demonstrate our intuition: our system
encouraging context consistency outperforms that existing systems with context
inconsistency for the first time, with the help of our context consistency
training approach.
|
[
-0.3860328496,
-0.6261018515,
0.4296802282,
0.6163738966,
-0.4618251026,
-0.1663955748,
-0.298810631,
-0.428812474,
-0.1368456036,
0.0394752622,
-0.6550123096,
0.1741694659,
-0.5692519546,
0.3104344904,
-0.2958704233,
1.0368590355,
-0.7020746469,
0.3611392677,
-0.4056248963,
-0.5999724865,
-0.8338648081,
-0.6078811288,
-0.6123345494,
-0.3984006345,
0.4239907265,
0.3969653249,
0.8075748086,
0.5804377794,
0.4351840317,
0.0399768837,
0.3365908861,
-0.1328763068,
-0.4726453424,
0.2647690475,
0.1430324763,
-0.3393205404,
-0.1724304557,
-0.0737866908,
0.719078064,
0.6293362379,
0.2136576325,
-0.0236813854,
0.2171695381,
0.2549283504,
-0.5280838609,
-0.1119047254,
-0.3985893726,
0.1817343086,
-0.0864051729,
-0.3880744278,
-0.4296192527,
0.0535681732,
0.0577280261,
-0.5752417445,
0.3215067089,
0.0399167314,
1.0354130268,
0.6460555196,
-0.7685115337,
0.02917362,
-0.6906855106,
0.664054215,
-0.4303955436,
0.8539871573,
0.2696701288,
0.2085038573,
0.00186946,
-0.2973582447,
-0.6272363663,
-0.2912412286,
-0.0908285901,
0.4968944788,
0.3838097155,
-0.1118294373,
0.2654495537,
0.1138938963,
-0.756710887,
-0.1338674277,
-0.0207256339,
-0.3044126034,
0.4465685487,
0.0411495268,
0.4373440146,
0.3260704875,
-0.8861224055,
-0.1412352771,
-0.7188461423,
0.1955708861,
0.0269496553,
0.1427125633,
-0.1680839658,
0.5149313211,
-0.0578222908,
0.4720076919,
-0.1305583119,
0.1021791026,
0.3126299381,
-0.7436645031,
-0.1695203334,
0.2321511507,
0.659078598,
0.2044533044,
0.1657870561,
-0.3441645801,
-0.1308885664,
0.2694498599,
0.406281352,
-0.6654199362,
0.2037204057,
0.1319977641,
-0.142489031,
-0.0379564539,
0.2225557566,
-0.2142374665,
0.3243893981,
-0.3826708794,
0.6610933542,
-0.5347260833,
-0.2408147603,
0.0624705069,
-0.015980877,
0.1860718727,
0.0952891856,
-0.5351613164,
0.3419521153,
0.4044624865,
0.975217104,
-0.4094468951,
-0.8202387691,
-0.6150050163,
0.1940948069,
-0.5057194829,
0.4508865476,
-0.0843981355,
-0.2483689487,
-0.2206863463,
0.0996195748,
-0.3513440192,
-0.3010332584,
0.3259291053,
-0.4812025428,
0.1153367534,
-0.4233767092,
-0.5257136822,
0.2111693472,
0.3089411557,
-0.3969787657,
1.2879837751,
0.1165624186,
-0.9031485915,
0.7396731973,
-0.5205692053,
-0.5563588142,
-0.2071713954,
-0.1495742053,
-0.6453959942,
0.0800049007,
-0.1248452663,
0.1585885584,
-0.0900523737,
0.4045327604,
-0.3791972697,
-0.7689130902,
0.3616905808,
-0.3617303967,
0.6739859581,
0.2109482884,
-0.4913308918,
-0.1324001849,
-0.3998990357,
0.1517712176,
0.1100927815,
-0.4560125768,
-0.4952905774,
-0.1282208115,
-0.0376348086,
0.4294532239,
0.1483275294,
-0.4912112951,
0.0882484466,
-0.1373096257,
0.1172826365,
0.5024511814,
-0.0369344503,
0.3703315556,
-0.3005668521,
0.3652637899,
0.4210814238,
0.0894749686,
-0.1557389796,
-0.2676250935,
-0.7338941693,
-0.0359600969,
0.3296751678,
0.6963575482,
-0.5582663417,
0.1960887313,
-0.4403023422,
-0.1304769069,
-0.4050240815,
0.1102909744,
0.4340772927,
0.5366484523,
0.3391437232,
-0.4523156881,
-0.5950492024,
-0.9114413261,
-0.4638914466,
0.0617323443,
0.0925802961,
-0.0771884769,
0.6279101968,
-0.3604051471,
0.8891103268,
-0.0123833232,
0.0509374663,
0.0118167484,
0.0817423612,
-0.0627292022,
0.7586858273,
0.501209259,
-1.048948884,
-0.7411441803,
0.0249574985,
-0.7841543555,
-0.216490373,
-0.1429871917,
-0.2299779207,
0.3109494448,
0.6284117103,
-0.2749555707,
0.51868999,
0.6464322209,
-0.1914962828,
0.476023227,
-0.156949684,
0.3771908879,
-1.1931282282,
0.0689419359,
-0.3092730045,
-0.3770854175,
-0.6213610172,
-0.06181648,
0.3347315788,
0.0502401553,
-0.3789364398,
0.5902293921,
-0.3143110871,
-0.015281735,
-0.2415039539,
-0.1552489698,
0.1943510324,
0.398119688,
-0.029677989,
1.166864872,
0.4745769203,
-0.7188522816,
-0.0374578461,
0.1177200377,
-0.1148706749,
0.6453425288,
-0.6067345738,
0.1520712078,
0.2387992144,
0.3567169011,
-0.854036212,
-0.1782969087,
0.2479094714,
-0.3419190943,
0.2327794582,
-0.0546884313,
-0.6753381491,
-0.1340689361,
0.148630932,
0.8352811933,
0.4829214215,
-0.5120295286,
0.0648589134,
-0.0515736006,
0.1130619943,
-0.7154724598,
-0.8910480142,
-0.1731795669,
-0.1334359348,
-0.739187479,
0.3290975988,
-0.1812728345,
0.0708531663,
-0.0620335676,
-0.6057758927,
-0.3892549872,
0.2259724885,
0.2464139313,
-0.0162717737,
-0.3505776823,
0.1850178242,
0.0743072331,
-0.2329615206,
-0.1263443232,
-0.4265597463,
0.3405209482,
-0.104855977,
-0.5339472294,
-0.4120821953,
0.5094794631,
0.4857438505,
0.0127742775,
0.9748473167,
0.5638177395,
-0.18494986,
0.0042048381,
-0.2937425971,
-0.209051773,
-0.3564191461,
0.2472662777,
-0.7534492016,
-0.6415269971,
0.698441267,
-0.031785842,
-0.1513788849,
0.2957201302,
0.366895467,
-0.0814835951,
1.1946736574,
0.6972654462,
0.2085710168,
0.555396378,
0.1051611379,
0.1997569352,
-0.8166880608,
0.0001872646,
-0.2421365827,
-0.1583862603,
-0.4673384428,
-0.1278942972,
0.446621418,
0.3452194631,
-0.3110406399,
0.4725207686,
-0.0588391013,
0.35745731,
0.6872950792,
0.0406858176,
0.2574485838,
-0.1172430143,
-0.5031738281,
-0.0654237345,
-0.9630838037,
-0.4038976133,
0.9112552404,
0.1580888182,
0.4489604533,
-0.1913698614,
0.6259348989,
-0.0075867348,
0.2903730571,
-0.4820397794,
0.1584919095,
0.275942415,
-0.874792695,
-0.145089224,
-0.5337088704,
-0.8959060907,
0.2930366695,
0.1931862235,
-0.3118125498,
-0.0047697849,
0.3240861893,
0.0788767412,
0.0498662218,
-0.7744040489,
1.3295019865,
-0.3438739181,
-0.4902763069,
0.0821489766,
-1.0465135574,
0.2935948074,
-0.1467088908,
0.0695172697,
0.091829434,
-0.0823712423,
0.442574203,
-0.4109484553,
0.4450758398,
0.0044494877,
-0.0023077063,
0.0438522995,
0.1485407203,
0.394982636,
0.2428383678,
0.1873375177,
0.3722693622,
0.2248046994,
-0.8978352547,
-0.5899822116,
0.3882699907,
-0.8134003878,
-0.2500864565,
-0.5854400992,
-0.8512150049,
-0.2944531739,
0.3629566431,
0.5459874868,
0.1695711464,
-0.3289190829,
0.0758156851,
0.7252678871,
-0.025553111,
-0.0123079112,
0.3970908225,
-0.1528279036,
-0.1024231762,
0.7123503685,
0.1604189426,
0.7559019327,
0.2184433937,
0.1241401136,
-0.0487970486,
-0.3797176182,
-0.4940285981,
-0.0448467098,
-0.5281800628,
0.073438026,
-0.5233849287,
-0.2688347399,
-0.5525619984,
-0.1767426282,
-0.5873457789,
-0.0284657832,
0.2270735502,
0.3249483705,
-0.1332801282,
0.2791633606,
-0.100270398,
0.6020157337,
-0.6631042957,
0.2951612473,
0.0441528894,
0.3994367719,
-0.3671221137,
-0.5834721327,
-0.5413835645,
0.3949308991,
-0.1660100073,
-0.8699572682,
-0.0433025472,
-0.1098610237,
0.3922516406,
0.2258725613,
-0.0601131245,
0.7081751823,
-0.555459857,
0.5376505256,
0.0370263122,
-0.9275579453,
0.3531930745,
-0.2914102376,
0.5321572423,
0.7915197611,
0.3712708652,
-0.8589138985,
-0.5225527287,
-0.5691412687,
-0.7680371404,
0.8031677008,
0.5428935885,
-0.0259516742,
0.1066406816,
0.2347070128,
0.373934865,
0.2424808145,
-0.7081478834,
-0.167717725,
-0.4513989389,
-0.0869425535,
-0.2439701408,
-0.1775260866,
-0.2592790425,
-0.1531618536,
0.7550862432,
-0.0728231445,
0.2556939721,
0.4263636172,
-0.4267184734,
-0.2647797465,
0.1798500717,
0.8151279688,
0.6363413334,
-0.3379713893,
0.2820776403,
0.3188531697,
-0.3782590628,
0.4336056113,
0.0231278539,
-0.4096459746,
0.1585530937,
0.4763875902,
0.9249570966,
0.3915764987,
-0.4019759297,
0.6600945592,
-0.1120766103,
-0.0737945735,
-0.3099286556,
-0.0102609079,
-0.0110356016,
-0.0642064363,
0.17784518,
0.3604784608,
-0.2431648225,
-0.3879263699,
0.4250799716,
0.3477934301,
-0.5288617015,
-0.2590681314,
0.696613133,
0.0028503223,
-0.1644644588,
0.468913734,
-0.236656189,
-0.8058478832,
0.7276214361,
0.632512629,
0.651614666,
-0.3478245437,
0.0319800638,
0.2495518476,
0.4886078238,
-0.4525862038,
0.2117057592,
-0.1748902202,
-0.6490129828,
-0.3643533885,
-0.3110672832,
-0.3832463622,
-0.087890178,
-0.8156049848,
0.3384405077,
0.1455468237,
0.0535684526,
-0.4490929246,
0.0104152383,
-0.7302350402,
0.3010595739,
-0.1871196479,
0.7349742055,
-0.9506040812,
0.9495232701,
0.6756467819,
-0.4762959182,
-0.6587405205,
0.3092688024,
-0.118499957,
-0.6958722472,
0.5735715032,
0.4394950569,
0.0524817817,
-0.0510170572,
-0.4099640846,
-0.8253636956,
1.0206195116,
0.4377726316,
-0.4908919334,
0.1501092613,
0.201602459,
0.4153157175,
-0.3295120597,
-0.0636389107,
0.1943718195,
0.4501798153,
-0.0606795661,
-1.0519983768,
0.075754039,
-0.1392356455,
-0.0852491632,
0.3383536041,
-0.6954392791,
0.595926702,
0.0285209529,
-0.510078311,
0.0204572715,
0.4358334541,
0.2344341278,
0.737496078,
0.6021851301,
0.6333639026,
0.3374440372,
-0.2435742468,
1.3857307434,
-0.2741867006,
0.4130710959,
1.3830801249,
-0.326915592,
0.5675738454,
0.8536717892,
-0.0677485168,
0.0522490777,
0.9274494052,
0.2055308223,
0.674218297,
-0.062706694,
-0.0954991877,
-0.3971638381,
-0.0193283949,
-0.5982710719,
0.0940250605,
-0.2522682846,
-0.1552676111,
-0.175986439,
0.2397141159,
0.0464743525,
-0.1494778544,
0.3136842549,
0.4371469915,
0.1213587672,
-0.945659101,
0.718355,
-0.2499941587,
0.2071626931,
-0.6698172688,
0.2913337052,
-0.2642501295,
0.1677940488,
0.2206603438,
-0.4647545516,
0.3680000007,
-0.340518117,
-0.3635604382,
-0.4339285195,
0.2226141244,
-0.6497098804,
-0.2013823092,
0.4917437732,
0.6836112142,
0.2188646644,
-0.0903009996,
-0.6442269683,
0.2304651588,
-0.381308645,
-0.2335548401,
0.4049426317,
0.5698142052,
-0.0289860368,
0.3532995284,
0.4281421304,
-0.0382464789,
0.3380559981,
-0.0595728718,
0.5372763872,
-0.3971171677,
-0.4056939781,
-0.8893477917,
0.3982575834,
0.0360931382,
-0.400855422,
0.7012522817,
0.6917285323,
1.1939144135,
0.1355074048,
0.8178780675,
-0.0016398178,
0.0603999645,
-0.552398324,
0.4386490881,
-0.8087977171,
-0.0024866739,
0.0089828623,
-0.9528264403,
-0.2300669104,
0.3180482686,
-0.0754070207,
0.2080257982,
1.3143655062,
0.6492450833,
-0.5406435728,
-0.1250303835,
0.4306666553,
0.2046818286,
0.0774272457,
0.6986035705,
0.7049245238,
-0.8142949343,
0.5709682107,
-0.3175528347,
-0.1541882008,
-0.3086824715,
-0.7232381105,
-0.7724366188,
-0.7237532735,
-0.3519433439,
-0.5948797464,
0.2765040696,
0.5942562819,
0.8107705712,
-0.7992228866,
-0.1238019988,
-0.4116714001,
0.0825226456,
-0.6805629134,
-0.2260530293,
0.1234365031,
-0.7155035734,
-0.5564654469,
0.2925000787,
0.2702102661,
0.3011171222,
-0.0900019184,
-0.4420952797,
-0.4329310954,
0.0490644388,
0.2382128537,
0.2380899787,
-0.6012662053,
-0.3161717057,
0.1801574379,
-0.4740146399,
0.2399467528,
0.9224163294,
-0.4321700037,
0.6079778075,
0.451711446,
0.9451705217,
0.5056391954,
-0.02023324,
0.8180442452,
-0.8340685964,
0.1854960471,
-0.1009793356,
0.1892427653,
0.1777852327,
-0.3294304311,
0.7033023834,
0.4363352954,
-0.6549295783,
-1.1136578321,
0.3970027268,
-0.9444714785,
-0.1301270723,
0.9161295295,
-0.3023614585,
-0.1820668876,
-0.0840405524,
-0.1235894412,
0.7607334852,
-0.0160898883,
0.8678169847,
1.0036008358,
-0.08604756,
0.183940351,
-0.9293044209,
0.4097454846,
1.0981363058,
-0.5875525475,
-0.1715742797,
0.1097798571,
0.4265656173,
0.0857075453,
0.5799303055,
0.1730408669,
0.5299023986,
0.1344191283,
-0.1081042886,
0.0914165974,
-0.4725654125,
-0.3104442954,
-0.1997957528,
-0.2432149649,
-0.3909742832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07064v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07064v2
|
Prompt have evil twins
| 2023-11-13T04:08:49 | 2024-04-29T12:57:55 |
Rimon Melamed, Lucas H. McCabe, Tanay Wakhare, Yejin Kim, H. Howie Huang, Enric Boix-Adsera
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We discover that many natural-language prompts can be replaced by
corresponding prompts that are unintelligible to humans but that provably
elicit similar behavior in language models. We call these prompts "evil twins"
because they are obfuscated and uninterpretable (evil), but at the same time
mimic the functionality of the original natural-language prompts (twins).
Remarkably, evil twins transfer between models. We find these prompts by
solving a maximum-likelihood problem which has applications of independent
interest.
|
[
-0.3561430573,
-1.1708670855,
0.8110636473,
-0.1152315959,
-0.2045641243,
0.0410432406,
0.2490431368,
-0.5729369521,
0.3566242158,
1.0234321356,
-0.831579268,
0.113261871,
-0.4563974738,
0.2142633498,
-0.407784462,
1.0938618183,
0.2621737421,
0.2067748755,
-0.1828620732,
-0.1287843436,
-0.3503078222,
-0.7431763411,
-0.9702072144,
-0.2405056059,
0.6399748325,
0.4378162026,
1.2647275925,
0.3255281448,
0.6125464439,
0.266523093,
0.2829087079,
-0.1212547272,
-0.4938216507,
0.2885263562,
-0.4917297363,
-0.3211946785,
0.199175939,
0.1317299604,
0.2991952002,
1.3006180525,
0.3992818296,
-0.0011966156,
0.1494392902,
0.7216912508,
-0.3630136847,
-0.0745416731,
-0.4310040772,
-0.2800702751,
0.1103196815,
-0.0667415336,
-0.1638585627,
-0.6468740106,
0.0269492511,
-0.44905442,
0.4155699015,
0.1862574667,
0.5296784043,
0.2593801022,
-0.3129874468,
-0.4274758399,
-0.8356429935,
0.6742758155,
-0.2978361249,
-0.1905033439,
0.3107003868,
0.1076016948,
-0.6407184601,
-0.3253756166,
-0.7627675533,
-0.385743916,
-0.1827954054,
-0.2940685749,
-0.9981481433,
0.1488053501,
0.3029269576,
0.0008409105,
-0.5721078515,
0.3914646506,
-0.603511095,
-0.2150615007,
0.654859364,
0.4384126067,
0.8508937359,
0.0426657051,
-0.4079490006,
0.0108428309,
-0.5305111408,
0.1352649033,
0.9036046863,
0.553738296,
-0.0922251716,
0.6152960062,
0.3706427515,
0.67636621,
0.2564961016,
0.371253103,
0.2959651053,
-0.1608099043,
-0.1294817626,
0.1666423231,
0.7337637544,
0.4911382496,
0.5349918604,
-0.3680689335,
-0.1615585685,
0.131517902,
0.1916214824,
-0.41272071,
-0.2285180986,
0.2528935075,
-0.6468033791,
-0.5436068773,
-0.0551950857,
-0.7527834177,
-1.1735014915,
-0.3578787744,
0.8579716086,
-0.141441673,
-0.2834848762,
0.2935795486,
-0.6585489511,
-0.1656028181,
0.1752867848,
-0.8722007871,
0.1319509745,
0.7787654996,
0.3806513548,
-0.1649563164,
-0.4371379912,
-0.6531105042,
-0.29921031,
-0.3292178214,
0.8140686154,
-0.6440200806,
-0.5032796264,
-0.0340718776,
0.046607323,
0.4051298499,
-0.5194798708,
1.0529490709,
-0.0864940211,
0.4318012297,
-0.4485537708,
-0.1237846911,
-0.4467237294,
-0.3088440001,
-0.7720499635,
0.6385428309,
-0.065538682,
-0.5759265423,
0.0599728413,
-0.6374624372,
-0.4192117751,
-0.0373930447,
0.1668581665,
-0.2124745548,
0.5031782985,
0.1083111688,
0.2510735989,
-0.427025795,
0.0624338016,
-0.5348674655,
-0.3820065558,
0.2411126196,
-0.7105751634,
1.5163234472,
0.0787432715,
-0.1469796598,
-0.1351332515,
-0.6717880964,
-0.3832871616,
0.4453947544,
0.3098634481,
-0.8943081498,
-0.1734900326,
-0.0395714417,
0.0557738021,
0.2166446745,
-0.6359216571,
0.4373180866,
-0.6181175709,
0.2016022056,
0.7374165058,
0.3348159492,
0.6180359125,
-0.8027145267,
0.3927445114,
0.4602152705,
0.3472397923,
-0.2085979432,
-0.9680003524,
-0.7868421078,
-0.1459982991,
-0.3958800137,
0.5668158531,
-0.70443964,
0.2985625565,
0.1921171248,
-0.4579159319,
-0.8936709166,
0.0116492091,
0.3069881499,
0.3832709193,
0.3424855173,
0.1025831848,
-0.7382342219,
-1.1681773663,
-0.9462248087,
-0.194770515,
0.1577977836,
-0.0958516374,
0.5745378137,
-0.1543375999,
0.7246956825,
-0.2458123863,
0.044115182,
-0.1917962581,
0.5366892219,
0.7947129607,
0.6219191551,
0.5939326882,
-0.7747235894,
-0.3934108913,
-0.5633605719,
-0.4117154181,
-0.4911106825,
-0.5459510088,
-0.0223156009,
-0.0138599332,
0.4839505255,
-0.5179827809,
0.5219133496,
0.2696424723,
-0.6499620676,
0.6333064437,
-0.2305991948,
0.3599684238,
-1.2418857813,
-0.11086265,
-0.4871043861,
0.0706397444,
-0.8935265541,
-0.1063248515,
-0.1785674989,
-0.1622343957,
-0.5987127423,
1.038030386,
-0.5886559486,
0.1285064518,
-0.1613244414,
0.0454432964,
0.1497122198,
0.4865235388,
-0.6096800566,
0.8510044217,
1.0143349171,
-0.5869524479,
0.8577104211,
0.1825075448,
-0.1561093926,
0.9215520024,
-0.5293129683,
0.2297594845,
-0.6345562935,
-0.0923742428,
-0.9430919886,
-0.0672241449,
0.5885899067,
-0.6958489418,
0.0115860663,
-0.139321655,
-0.7014064193,
-0.68639189,
-0.5026063323,
0.5033894777,
0.6375444531,
-0.8729034066,
0.4977414906,
0.0326187648,
-0.2065254897,
-0.6635718346,
-0.8977863789,
0.2347823083,
0.0185881518,
-0.3537710011,
0.0697405934,
-0.3153437972,
-0.6957805157,
0.255956471,
0.2998309731,
-0.0742040798,
-0.0459235385,
0.7028757334,
0.3899319768,
-0.3049092591,
0.272573173,
0.0630589649,
-0.1829037517,
0.3497170508,
-0.2939841151,
0.3029993176,
0.1116136983,
-0.5631979108,
-0.7384018302,
1.0218229294,
1.0210729837,
-0.0168118961,
0.8596058488,
0.3113787472,
-0.7531226873,
0.0459480286,
-0.8023815751,
-0.3493476212,
-0.514706254,
0.1088525131,
-0.2231233269,
-0.5725054145,
0.7691209316,
0.5572074652,
0.1161047444,
0.3302329779,
0.3059538603,
-0.2821971178,
1.2996766567,
0.3084793091,
-0.097579591,
0.2782953084,
0.1977515519,
0.5067123771,
-0.2222479433,
-0.1221973822,
-0.7999665737,
-0.2600073218,
-0.4828695953,
-0.2050981224,
0.2673158944,
0.4647068083,
-0.4754680693,
0.1297027022,
-0.4495067,
1.0737996101,
1.1397604942,
-0.0459486954,
0.2580830753,
0.1559081078,
-0.1718011945,
-0.0443444587,
-0.0678235441,
-0.3974636197,
1.0516178608,
-0.1852269024,
0.796959579,
0.2390558273,
0.7639285326,
0.5227704048,
-0.1199037731,
-0.5522829294,
0.4292484224,
-0.3328560591,
-0.7872987986,
0.041791562,
-0.2391845733,
-1.2345576286,
-0.1491582096,
-0.4956532121,
-1.0902371407,
0.174870491,
0.0578345731,
-0.7332029939,
0.7758316994,
-0.8284878731,
0.4864245355,
-0.2548585236,
-0.3103985488,
-0.1761121452,
-0.528689146,
0.1927615702,
0.0056966962,
0.1366053671,
0.0063775303,
0.0594013929,
0.5951225162,
-0.2555978298,
0.913612783,
0.090909481,
0.1484211385,
0.4248188138,
0.2646556199,
0.7214475274,
-0.107449241,
-0.0553856939,
0.1381721795,
-0.3402296901,
-0.435018152,
-0.9811074734,
0.8826925755,
-0.6763502359,
-0.8949640393,
-0.5482823849,
-0.3935696781,
0.0044462895,
0.2861936688,
0.3297947943,
0.6419972777,
-0.169523865,
-0.3537662625,
0.4814133346,
-0.3851643205,
0.7037528753,
0.6537924409,
-0.3425137103,
-0.4150349796,
0.7203958631,
-0.4400188327,
0.3216917217,
0.3035528064,
0.3018142581,
-0.2791260779,
-0.248211503,
-0.3890081346,
0.4382558465,
-0.6888049841,
-0.15837273,
-0.9382570386,
-0.1642185152,
-0.3971931338,
-0.6709776521,
-0.0624265,
-0.6739547849,
-0.6617941856,
-0.0335661471,
0.5237787962,
1.1299846172,
-0.5546620488,
0.1140637547,
-1.0491629839,
0.5773157477,
0.6619346738,
0.0978711918,
-0.3143851161,
-0.2791563869,
0.4536416829,
0.4265923202,
-0.1031447276,
-1.2670658827,
0.1539012641,
-0.3262788057,
0.4927340746,
0.712818265,
0.2824245393,
0.3972552121,
-0.2531057894,
1.0056494474,
0.6625475287,
-0.7809090018,
0.3822488487,
-0.4592966437,
0.1368371397,
0.6493296027,
0.3896044493,
-0.6329690814,
-0.4572424591,
-0.8133998513,
-0.1709176153,
0.8364332914,
0.2294615656,
0.4931180179,
0.0858514011,
0.1862813681,
0.5349577665,
0.0112881036,
-0.5333456397,
-0.8714001179,
0.0306516606,
-0.1577048451,
-0.0686906427,
-0.3608928025,
0.0170351528,
-0.2675518394,
0.4119444788,
0.3888640106,
0.3679163158,
-0.1256918609,
0.2520905435,
-0.4996975064,
0.2834359407,
0.4852154553,
0.1038381979,
-0.0074792854,
0.3945392966,
-0.0657968372,
-0.5152499676,
0.1999745071,
-0.04960059,
-0.1948387027,
0.1503971219,
0.3835389018,
0.7532820702,
0.2004634291,
-0.6354352832,
0.8845302463,
-0.0671338513,
0.1156540737,
-0.4055921733,
0.1478025466,
-0.1357207,
0.3103942871,
0.5231662393,
0.7587571144,
0.3273173273,
-0.9139289856,
-0.0850903392,
0.6265137196,
-0.4286624789,
-0.4923162162,
0.5890334845,
0.4251485765,
-0.9637448788,
0.7374495268,
-0.5277307034,
-0.8953484893,
0.7250003815,
0.5823572278,
1.1057801247,
-0.3868325949,
0.3238770664,
0.5826750994,
0.4935431778,
0.1439492851,
0.5200346112,
0.2671729028,
-0.5802835226,
0.2692576051,
-0.3629440665,
-0.1401969939,
0.4112367332,
-0.4850317836,
0.7085880637,
-0.1129062399,
0.0365396701,
0.3166291416,
-0.3178941905,
-0.7546935678,
-0.2725374401,
0.0899271891,
0.4406749606,
-0.8499796391,
0.3212179244,
0.7526274323,
-0.6241722107,
-0.3822094202,
-0.1698316336,
0.1703871042,
-0.9812921882,
0.4703785479,
0.2258631289,
-0.024367338,
-0.0817290694,
-0.8371833563,
-0.8204132318,
0.1355152279,
0.3071492314,
-0.1359160691,
-0.3219434619,
0.4987353683,
0.3817059696,
-0.2731080949,
0.3573122919,
0.3190226853,
0.6962266564,
-0.0257242769,
-0.8736599088,
-0.0338337459,
-0.2351693958,
-0.4321273267,
0.5111080408,
0.0948657021,
0.9302121401,
-1.1400015354,
-0.5827486515,
0.1727060676,
0.2660099864,
-0.259308964,
0.4623935223,
0.4752037227,
0.3846172392,
0.6221041083,
0.0662966296,
0.7300730348,
-0.0511346944,
0.0844168589,
1.2468392849,
0.0660469458,
0.4872183502,
0.8170864582,
0.050579749,
0.2629652023,
0.1970943362,
-0.0819281861,
0.4335471094,
0.0653938875,
-0.3609522581,
-0.4388253391,
-0.2529672682,
-0.3373020291,
0.2643037438,
0.3408756554,
-0.5250691175,
-0.4206701219,
0.4580456018,
0.3547640145,
0.1221129,
-0.3370156884,
0.703864634,
-0.0491582975,
-0.8500198126,
0.6332144737,
-0.2851210535,
0.5759193301,
-0.2518966496,
-0.3343363702,
-0.1474969834,
0.0085354317,
-0.0655613691,
-0.835816741,
0.2789021432,
-0.0819204748,
-0.3844242096,
-0.2816540897,
0.5495411158,
-0.3270355463,
-0.5317024589,
0.2690886259,
0.4984465837,
0.2361348867,
-0.2539891005,
-0.8517421484,
-0.2988857627,
0.2246607691,
0.2718861401,
-0.2666883171,
0.4119721651,
0.0272975899,
0.6995037794,
0.9198913574,
0.077158533,
0.2645097077,
-0.0302004404,
0.7434709668,
-0.7206714749,
-0.4540578127,
-0.9333117008,
0.5137855411,
-0.0401734151,
-0.4027259648,
0.4797183871,
0.4169130027,
0.4369191229,
-0.3110664487,
0.7419713736,
0.1837353408,
0.661331594,
-0.3462308943,
0.8758791089,
-0.5670508146,
0.0709287673,
-0.2598460019,
-0.8171641231,
-0.3487419486,
0.0315799639,
-0.132203415,
-0.0549818724,
1.0160833597,
1.0766795874,
-0.1131352857,
0.4233862758,
0.5322021246,
0.4214946032,
-0.1076622158,
0.8949964643,
1.2369860411,
-0.3731040359,
0.4052712917,
-0.3215564787,
-0.2912477553,
-0.5137726068,
-0.813077569,
-1.2652953863,
-1.1172449589,
-0.4024015665,
-0.4533516467,
0.3173814118,
1.1032006741,
0.0373168774,
-0.8027166724,
0.3653817773,
-0.2195513546,
0.428645432,
-0.188539356,
-0.2391314059,
0.2541387081,
-0.0919064209,
-0.7595902085,
0.1872521788,
0.2209480852,
0.680013001,
-0.440497756,
0.3983639777,
0.2033988088,
0.4908764362,
0.0887787789,
0.2945756018,
-0.9320957065,
-0.3644699752,
-0.2502764165,
-0.3796573281,
-0.2033195943,
1.0635812283,
-0.7648746967,
0.6532368064,
0.780487299,
0.2735941708,
-0.4762477279,
-0.1267915219,
0.5569701195,
-0.4293941557,
0.2120861411,
0.4944298267,
0.4795321226,
0.2621950209,
-0.6529330611,
0.115878202,
0.2596395016,
-0.2934773266,
-0.9195849895,
0.4897808433,
-1.0064544678,
-0.341068387,
1.2825227976,
0.1829425842,
-0.0610721856,
-0.5387842059,
-0.4674935043,
0.0968074873,
-0.5446632504,
0.6515849829,
0.675665617,
0.0016121155,
0.1042113453,
-0.4206038415,
0.5484630466,
0.4341451526,
-0.5995886326,
0.1471367925,
0.3695881963,
-0.077817373,
0.3801155686,
0.185780406,
0.056979049,
0.4248427153,
0.2291210741,
0.1068843529,
-0.392500937,
-0.2040112317,
-0.6537183523,
-0.0676372573,
-0.2475423813,
-0.2611744106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07052v1
|
Towards the Law of Capacity Gap in Distilling Language Models
| 2023-11-13T03:36:18 | 2023-11-13T03:36:18 |
Chen Zhang, Dawei Song, Zheyu Ye, Yan Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Language model (LM) distillation is a trending area that aims to distil the
knowledge resided in a large teacher LM to a small student one. While various
methods have been proposed to push the distillation to its limits, it is still
a pain distilling LMs when a large capacity gap is exhibited between the
teacher and the student LMs. The pain is mainly resulted by the curse of
capacity gap, which describes that a larger teacher LM cannot always lead to a
better student LM than one distilled from a smaller teacher LM due to the
affect of capacity gap increment. That is, there is likely an optimal point
yielding the best student LM along the scaling course of the teacher LM. Even
worse, the curse of capacity gap can be only partly yet not fully lifted as
indicated in previous studies.
However, the tale is not ever one-sided. Although a larger teacher LM has
better performance than a smaller teacher LM, it is much more
resource-demanding especially in the context of recent large LMs (LLMs).
Consequently, instead of sticking to lifting the curse, leaving the curse as is
should be arguably fine. Even better, in this paper, we reveal that the optimal
capacity gap is almost consistent across different student scales and
architectures, fortunately turning the curse into the law of capacity gap. The
law later guides us to distil a 3B student LM (termed MiniMA) from a 7B teacher
LM (adapted LLaMA2-7B). MiniMA is demonstrated to yield a new
compute-performance pareto frontier among existing 3B LMs on commonly used
benchmarks, and its instruction-tuned version (termed MiniChat) outperforms a
wide range of 3B competitors in GPT4 evaluation and could even compete with
several 7B chat models.
|
[
-0.4762152433,
-0.7090370059,
0.6891839504,
-0.0189316962,
-0.3373102546,
0.1587053388,
-0.2828153968,
-0.3642751873,
0.0352917016,
0.4818741083,
-0.2262662351,
0.0833007395,
-0.7686792016,
-0.0592632778,
-0.4906965494,
0.846558094,
0.0675853267,
0.1496073306,
-0.4909446239,
-0.0827371851,
-1.0783036947,
-0.4112830758,
-0.5126633048,
-0.5341231823,
0.2774517834,
0.6635006666,
0.6779503822,
0.7221066952,
0.2429728508,
0.2814729214,
-0.1944720447,
-0.0498440526,
-0.7137767673,
0.0345528759,
0.1628050208,
-0.729262948,
-0.2550396025,
0.1072222665,
0.7278165221,
0.7858818769,
-0.4825198054,
-0.0249944404,
0.7123739123,
0.8728172779,
-0.3837271035,
0.0242388658,
-0.9748265743,
-0.1428579539,
-0.5093707442,
0.0434952714,
-0.4784074724,
-0.2102757394,
0.0662792027,
-0.2945356071,
0.3174934983,
0.1396817863,
0.9139573574,
0.4497472346,
-0.2999890745,
-0.4320102632,
-0.6811577678,
0.8881511688,
-0.7192943096,
0.1624332666,
0.3645606041,
0.6672139168,
-0.2461100072,
-0.7155647278,
-0.6743198037,
-0.1243839115,
0.0215167459,
-0.1472024322,
-0.264798224,
0.0887599215,
0.3229663968,
0.6706138253,
-0.2353534698,
0.2942173481,
-0.8526163101,
0.0609440096,
0.2881756425,
0.2946895659,
0.2763966322,
0.062237747,
-0.374145329,
-0.0029399188,
-0.7867476344,
-0.0358727388,
0.3592028618,
0.3760198951,
-0.0109722363,
0.3434742689,
0.2439096719,
0.8070172071,
-0.1422414333,
-0.2476572096,
-0.0408991016,
-0.1232209206,
-0.0686763451,
0.2657229602,
0.7075153589,
0.2054898441,
0.3943806291,
0.2388606369,
-0.0062871054,
-0.0093431678,
0.2075665444,
-0.8061794043,
-0.1950200349,
-0.2399856448,
-0.2546438873,
-0.0353889987,
-0.1053913757,
-0.830037117,
-0.6115883589,
-0.2610783875,
0.1327394545,
-0.3095159829,
-0.3742515147,
0.1540812105,
0.1416621506,
-0.0584682561,
0.0792784467,
-1.0939930677,
0.6313223839,
0.5313186049,
1.1408076286,
-0.0208332017,
-0.0945026428,
-0.2061267346,
-0.1200437993,
-0.2484197319,
0.34984532,
-0.35612306,
-0.4491752386,
-0.115346916,
-0.4471542835,
0.0360481851,
-0.8178153634,
0.4687952697,
-0.3883352876,
-0.0233397037,
-0.2864101231,
-0.6677945852,
0.0250717122,
-0.0384459607,
-1.0060017109,
0.9465528131,
0.0914822742,
-0.3303967416,
0.5238320827,
-0.4188371599,
-0.1383574605,
0.0492270999,
-0.3399752975,
-0.4275260568,
0.3079419732,
-0.085669525,
0.1995760798,
-0.6696550846,
0.3164530396,
-0.411114186,
-0.384021163,
0.3215106726,
-0.6908684969,
0.7533884645,
0.5282597542,
-0.075311549,
-0.4296668768,
-0.6462800503,
-0.1183340698,
0.1120908111,
-0.4907802045,
-0.6446366906,
0.0941620842,
-0.2954045832,
0.0932015702,
0.1277335882,
-0.313406229,
0.4145503044,
-0.411346674,
0.5909734368,
0.8788811564,
-0.3587787747,
0.5415730476,
-0.2421663254,
0.4600425363,
0.000826698,
0.1869824827,
0.1393672079,
-0.4576123059,
-0.7893967032,
-0.2627521455,
0.4915702641,
0.1510106027,
-0.6402944326,
-0.0567050874,
-0.1727006137,
-0.3059449494,
-0.7515904903,
0.4259002209,
0.2510071695,
0.5482060313,
0.2612757087,
-0.2825909257,
-0.6065198779,
-0.7523326874,
-0.2644875944,
-0.2920671701,
0.3624118567,
0.2779874504,
0.1165516526,
0.2273665816,
1.1173329353,
-0.6216576099,
-0.5723672509,
-0.7100034356,
-0.3007284701,
0.7750710845,
0.5337269902,
0.7646583915,
-0.7461311221,
-0.8753566146,
-0.1426154077,
-0.5627579689,
-0.5200923681,
-0.1164598167,
0.0733929202,
0.298445642,
0.4194026589,
-0.5268656611,
0.2668523192,
0.5471920967,
-0.3193355501,
0.3573769033,
-0.2496606112,
-0.1179221645,
-1.0209964514,
-0.2979159653,
-0.2194437534,
-0.2057389915,
-0.6984480023,
-0.0577008501,
-0.0103974193,
0.1084356308,
-0.2768360674,
0.4736779332,
-0.6922424436,
0.1226531565,
-0.7068108916,
0.2186821997,
-0.1263260245,
0.159068808,
-0.5066336989,
0.6700319648,
0.5811576843,
-0.6255112886,
0.2933931053,
-0.1679636836,
-0.5230821967,
0.2941358685,
-0.4211939275,
-0.0313704386,
0.2232108265,
0.0499670208,
-0.9845924973,
0.0401890092,
-0.0407107547,
-0.1299330145,
0.4577978849,
-0.1739540249,
-0.5020604134,
-0.7111142874,
0.0537426509,
0.7763277292,
0.9819416404,
-0.5788910985,
0.4123532772,
0.5150971413,
0.0526556298,
-0.699898541,
-0.7923812866,
0.1410386115,
-0.5142564774,
-0.6541567445,
0.2364333272,
-0.0708498061,
-0.367433548,
0.065504685,
-0.3903043866,
-0.1790520251,
0.0499466844,
0.2009416074,
0.3675093651,
-0.1173779964,
0.0138710458,
0.0481757335,
0.0421872288,
-0.1055181399,
-0.3213651776,
0.750161171,
-0.3111549914,
-0.2857471704,
-0.1688340157,
-0.0925908312,
0.4295102656,
0.4908605516,
0.7851162553,
0.1248204112,
-0.3025920093,
-0.3301472664,
-0.8401272297,
-0.2573112249,
-0.5100497603,
0.1481293738,
-0.624914825,
-1.0091167688,
0.6377863884,
0.0345677435,
-0.1729192436,
0.3565280437,
0.5360981822,
0.188591063,
0.6609637737,
0.8346452713,
-0.346867919,
0.4373727143,
-0.4020831287,
0.2707568705,
-0.6398997903,
-0.0001284264,
-0.468436718,
-0.5020547509,
-0.4644155502,
-0.3736664057,
0.4052800834,
0.6519709229,
0.2147973031,
0.2851139605,
-0.370973289,
0.9256322384,
0.4192600548,
-0.1934333444,
0.2813711762,
-0.0801390186,
-0.3081323802,
-0.1780005991,
-1.0958613157,
-0.5028296113,
1.0313338041,
0.4657068253,
0.6566031575,
0.3154608309,
0.9846345782,
0.3137093782,
0.2878950238,
-0.6545017958,
0.556958437,
-0.1065265685,
-0.7456533909,
-0.4276927412,
-0.5399034619,
-1.066157937,
0.5552149415,
0.1777623743,
-0.6642369628,
0.1343985498,
0.3375577927,
-0.2753677368,
0.5973661542,
-0.8552412987,
0.8429909945,
0.0560446158,
-0.607843399,
-0.4076119065,
-0.4791343212,
0.5291410685,
-0.2154776603,
0.4364875853,
-0.2308470011,
0.1197552234,
0.6218121648,
-0.9872510433,
0.9449769855,
-0.3489052355,
-0.1123096645,
0.819860816,
0.1218645126,
0.4423434138,
-0.1307362765,
0.115237169,
0.1232213303,
-0.0375227705,
-0.58116889,
-0.4900522828,
0.8963946104,
-0.6941825747,
-0.9949833155,
-0.6188207865,
-0.5051885843,
-0.1287204921,
0.1842670739,
0.1337596327,
0.0565840118,
-0.0164338294,
0.0889219418,
0.6306164861,
-0.039631784,
0.6881175637,
0.476537019,
-0.2421281785,
0.0354621559,
0.9149097204,
0.4464754164,
0.4248469472,
-0.0560510419,
0.5598886013,
-0.4023382664,
-0.6538124681,
-0.3595765829,
0.1963242292,
-0.6769498587,
-0.2345492989,
-0.1695082337,
-0.4130915105,
-0.3298498988,
-0.002387742,
-0.5382790565,
-0.2100545019,
-0.352581203,
-0.025821561,
0.1924325228,
0.6442219615,
-0.3538971245,
0.2576552331,
-0.6425485611,
-0.0255012996,
0.2402257621,
0.2304567695,
0.3236939907,
-0.8711725473,
-0.4276594818,
-0.1545490324,
-0.5308227539,
-0.7767648697,
0.2948317826,
0.1983614713,
0.4979903102,
0.5349562764,
0.0755401403,
0.9685778618,
-0.6911426187,
0.6863536239,
0.6981362104,
-0.951274097,
0.1941543072,
-0.0016591434,
0.0311240666,
0.5247977972,
0.1024654955,
-0.6264631152,
-0.6202356815,
-0.5336008072,
-1.0149407387,
0.769916594,
0.1362894773,
0.5120047927,
0.1402575672,
0.2577148378,
0.4360824525,
0.16166614,
-1.0448410511,
-0.1156426221,
-0.0270403903,
-0.1787797809,
0.0674936399,
-0.3932693303,
0.142017737,
-0.2425525934,
0.5862802863,
0.1775528789,
-0.1969096959,
-0.2119383663,
-0.0319747142,
0.0280431621,
0.4636104405,
0.4245756567,
0.8461001515,
0.0319065489,
0.39452824,
0.4412507713,
-0.6934372783,
0.2869620323,
-0.1017517969,
0.0239959527,
-0.0901902989,
0.212795049,
0.9226565361,
0.0162395556,
-0.5907639265,
0.4168628454,
0.1049524993,
-0.1832315177,
-0.3673003316,
0.322203964,
-0.0374568515,
0.3905062079,
0.4897529185,
-0.1882021427,
0.0765674487,
-0.6887738705,
0.0679226071,
0.194960773,
-0.3212863803,
0.0651794747,
0.6071037054,
0.1057707369,
-0.0086584473,
0.5396046042,
-0.1052390188,
-0.301056385,
0.487588048,
0.6293481588,
0.5730462074,
-0.3471525311,
-0.0838873684,
0.2770930827,
0.3150525093,
-0.3165281713,
0.0497876517,
0.0303583443,
-0.6232571006,
-0.4618988931,
-0.7611240149,
-0.031993974,
0.3272421062,
-0.6590830088,
0.2408571988,
-0.2538138926,
-0.208054021,
-0.3509284258,
0.0027398195,
-0.2918316722,
-0.1392746568,
0.0780957267,
0.6950302124,
-0.5863067508,
1.1321008205,
0.0537114292,
-0.3794561028,
-0.9564830065,
-0.1359548867,
0.1031746492,
-0.9535310864,
0.5808255672,
0.0180043224,
0.1197852865,
-0.1027070284,
-0.2170231491,
-0.6586323977,
1.1789695024,
0.5037955046,
-1.2538161278,
-0.0120360022,
0.4720644355,
0.5522533059,
-0.3285439909,
-0.154899627,
0.670255661,
0.1935260892,
0.2269378901,
-0.964087069,
0.1626827121,
0.0035402405,
0.2062529176,
0.5621448159,
-0.6946963668,
1.0272336006,
-0.3291838765,
-0.3049074709,
0.1803279817,
0.6441287398,
0.2857146859,
0.4966567755,
0.7101182938,
0.7281407118,
0.7627285123,
-0.2759037912,
0.9895979762,
-0.2929014564,
0.3492771685,
1.0576177835,
-0.3447909057,
0.5587163568,
0.9046754241,
-0.3439456522,
0.3499274552,
0.5879894495,
-0.0726039261,
0.4720900059,
0.6638926864,
-0.2913088799,
-0.1596200913,
0.0814269036,
-0.5037929416,
0.2116122842,
0.2405565679,
-0.3057081699,
-0.0832864121,
0.0914823338,
0.1012284383,
0.3765153587,
-0.4531706274,
0.6361323595,
0.5344850421,
-0.6210210323,
0.8220123053,
-0.1422549039,
0.3619861007,
-0.3978384137,
0.067895554,
-0.2974078357,
0.25563398,
-0.0296434145,
-0.7529626489,
0.2151344419,
0.187124446,
-0.1922047436,
-0.131043002,
0.812296629,
-0.5004166961,
-0.2323171496,
0.4109694362,
0.5844585896,
0.3720379472,
0.3632171154,
-0.4862914681,
0.2235914469,
-0.0450301245,
-0.1090049148,
0.5180047154,
0.534784615,
0.0827228129,
0.5289154649,
0.430275023,
0.4499472976,
0.3166042864,
0.3553112447,
0.8982345462,
-0.372274667,
-0.5614580512,
-1.4070125818,
0.4503726661,
-0.1887188107,
-0.0818622634,
0.7119874358,
0.589900136,
0.9223219752,
0.099034816,
0.7538869381,
-0.3336550295,
0.1923802942,
-0.7282117009,
0.7218696475,
-0.7486202717,
0.6992700696,
-0.130987227,
-1.0029363632,
0.138866201,
0.431073606,
-0.3957631588,
0.1425293684,
0.8086997271,
0.6344622374,
-0.161295265,
-0.1397764832,
0.6142969728,
0.3501636386,
0.2270601243,
0.8647835851,
0.9755970836,
-0.2081726491,
0.8656963706,
0.1605214626,
-0.3455778956,
-0.3117392063,
-0.662660718,
-0.7908003926,
-0.6869514585,
-0.0600922704,
-0.6203740239,
-0.1383170187,
0.5619952083,
0.438631475,
-0.5458841324,
-0.7353583574,
-0.3805977702,
0.3120083511,
-0.2810450196,
-0.2444718629,
0.0798447877,
-0.5393049121,
-0.8311639428,
0.0833845213,
0.0187899917,
0.2250599116,
-0.3384313583,
-0.4262550473,
-0.0102503616,
0.2435231656,
0.2533863783,
0.3284245431,
-0.6959521174,
-0.0279612504,
-0.5088183284,
-0.2098270655,
0.1242817938,
1.075642705,
-0.4577025473,
0.5256755948,
0.3036809564,
0.6608127356,
0.7016694546,
-0.6055612564,
0.3953271806,
-0.863786757,
0.2307605594,
0.1587171853,
0.4882060885,
0.0871857181,
-0.047922153,
0.5360274911,
0.3914419711,
-0.5480388999,
-1.2797174454,
0.2481864989,
-0.8655834198,
-0.5185661912,
1.1132084131,
-0.0354283042,
-0.0959512144,
0.0452926047,
-0.1748043597,
0.4245070815,
-0.3155926168,
1.2467130423,
1.0303890705,
-0.1030494049,
-0.0880279914,
-0.8056095243,
0.6391443014,
0.5441454053,
-0.4358678758,
0.1794691682,
0.4383519888,
0.2342956513,
0.0496396832,
0.7595826983,
-0.1186604351,
0.0368496105,
0.0907193497,
-0.2002601475,
-0.1610084474,
-0.4700471461,
-0.1888610721,
0.2990088761,
0.3345584273,
-0.1329559088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07037v1
|
Phonological Level wav2vec2-based Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis Method
| 2023-11-13T02:41:41 | 2023-11-13T02:41:41 |
Mostafa Shahin, Julien Epps, Beena Ahmed
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The automatic identification and analysis of pronunciation errors, known as
Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis (MDD) plays a crucial role in Computer
Aided Pronunciation Learning (CAPL) tools such as Second-Language (L2) learning
or speech therapy applications. Existing MDD methods relying on analysing
phonemes can only detect categorical errors of phonemes that have an adequate
amount of training data to be modelled. With the unpredictable nature of the
pronunciation errors of non-native or disordered speakers and the scarcity of
training datasets, it is unfeasible to model all types of mispronunciations.
Moreover, phoneme-level MDD approaches have a limited ability to provide
detailed diagnostic information about the error made. In this paper, we propose
a low-level MDD approach based on the detection of speech attribute features.
Speech attribute features break down phoneme production into elementary
components that are directly related to the articulatory system leading to more
formative feedback to the learner. We further propose a multi-label variant of
the Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) approach to jointly model the
non-mutually exclusive speech attributes using a single model. The pre-trained
wav2vec2 model was employed as a core model for the speech attribute detector.
The proposed method was applied to L2 speech corpora collected from English
learners from different native languages. The proposed speech attribute MDD
method was further compared to the traditional phoneme-level MDD and achieved a
significantly lower False Acceptance Rate (FAR), False Rejection Rate (FRR),
and Diagnostic Error Rate (DER) over all speech attributes compared to the
phoneme-level equivalent.
|
[
-0.4017581046,
-0.85918051,
-0.0776606277,
-0.0359753259,
-0.1788784564,
0.0428220332,
0.0468846634,
-0.3774535358,
-0.0911706761,
0.2376787961,
-0.5551876426,
-0.6275975108,
-0.4449328184,
-0.083561644,
0.077510871,
0.4020413458,
0.3406639993,
0.2935380042,
-0.0789235458,
-0.2714205086,
-0.7257839441,
-0.4138551354,
-1.1872367859,
-0.1917432845,
0.3639537096,
0.7020516396,
0.3581984341,
0.5769691467,
0.3082033098,
0.1782720238,
-0.2121114284,
0.3555401564,
-0.1447314471,
0.122438401,
0.1249545962,
-0.4276905954,
-0.6551335454,
0.1176669002,
0.4650310874,
0.6829574108,
-0.3738741875,
0.0086118439,
0.1363266259,
0.3568759859,
-0.4437846541,
0.1390467584,
-0.3426744938,
0.1479565203,
-0.3183611929,
-0.2400389761,
-0.3025837243,
-0.2061068565,
0.0109048495,
-0.3510717452,
0.2380579263,
-0.1220483258,
0.3530308604,
0.2707471848,
-0.3912570775,
-0.2955838442,
-0.5338363647,
0.7455896735,
-0.8783743382,
0.7175478339,
0.768142581,
0.1933044046,
-0.1371571273,
-0.1737140417,
-0.7814125419,
-0.102403447,
0.0663942546,
0.01956499,
-0.1502248049,
0.2277877033,
0.1855816543,
0.3433606625,
-0.8979743123,
0.712248981,
-0.4629929662,
-0.617241025,
0.2483299822,
-0.0464018509,
0.3369033933,
-0.3437255919,
-0.1736285985,
-0.0987676308,
-0.4030563533,
0.4235444665,
0.4317528307,
0.353099674,
-0.4040961564,
0.4170048237,
0.1051199511,
0.4363354743,
0.1464776248,
-0.909701407,
0.5287828445,
-0.1383822113,
-0.0064090467,
0.3041473031,
0.6754239202,
0.1490620226,
0.0043771546,
0.0901194215,
-0.0838604569,
0.0495056249,
-0.3757067919,
-0.4817315936,
-0.3714835048,
0.4470727444,
-0.5686389804,
-0.4650366306,
-0.3897672594,
-0.5571181774,
-0.4423781335,
-0.348200053,
0.4221854806,
-0.6734392643,
-0.6533740163,
-0.3048873842,
0.0500242822,
0.1310103387,
-0.1247127503,
-0.7191253901,
0.2224269956,
0.3895685971,
0.88587749,
-0.2589148879,
-0.1093519256,
-0.6859105229,
-0.1797033846,
-0.4390289187,
0.784249723,
-0.3934724033,
-0.6652501822,
-0.0871960968,
-0.1619061828,
-0.0252703726,
-0.9387634397,
0.4357478023,
-0.0354021899,
0.1906456053,
-0.0325150378,
-0.375970751,
-0.1376295537,
-0.0914172456,
-0.5763892531,
1.4044393301,
0.4945516586,
-0.6704511046,
0.4644267559,
-0.4931645691,
-0.6340703964,
0.0224140845,
0.0454293229,
-0.5372546315,
-0.1573695093,
0.1134264916,
0.3622883856,
-0.220171079,
0.0359147489,
-0.0552468598,
-0.0912353098,
0.153534025,
-0.4679150581,
0.699215591,
0.3710134029,
-0.2725149691,
-0.1577481925,
-1.318564415,
0.3001359999,
-0.2257499099,
-0.4443834424,
-0.2803964913,
-0.1378630996,
-0.2413250655,
0.4381021857,
0.0894901231,
-0.3536886275,
0.0340761952,
-0.4474179149,
0.2555903494,
0.3208353519,
0.3739864528,
0.2599741518,
-0.1709994972,
0.4186386466,
0.6229734421,
0.0275570229,
0.076284498,
-0.6452558041,
-0.7143924236,
-0.4520507455,
0.1428498328,
0.9362900853,
-0.68308568,
0.6836977601,
0.3334604204,
-0.4374062717,
-0.8501985073,
0.129460305,
0.5765721798,
0.6709671021,
0.6587976813,
-0.3506245017,
-0.5373027921,
-0.7532967329,
-0.0288890582,
-0.4014631808,
-0.1506826878,
0.1546505094,
-0.0808781609,
-0.1029585451,
0.570702374,
-0.1135296747,
-0.5837470293,
-0.0517640822,
0.3979934454,
-0.0170892514,
0.491872251,
0.2497434914,
-0.3239842355,
0.155565083,
0.0443989113,
-0.3881449103,
-0.4672051072,
0.2498523891,
0.3065136671,
0.3270283341,
0.3927636445,
-0.2194086164,
0.2896893024,
0.3078147471,
-0.1900280714,
0.40210706,
-0.3800444007,
0.4293723702,
-0.8977684379,
-0.1478397101,
0.1240117028,
-0.0815676004,
-0.6644713283,
-0.4426683486,
-0.0279214215,
-0.1186626703,
-0.3885383904,
-0.0382031314,
-0.3089081049,
-0.1787834316,
-0.1746920794,
0.1437650174,
-0.1909617037,
0.3802675009,
-0.035287641,
0.6025268435,
0.6022147536,
-0.7829746008,
0.5313068032,
-0.0032763702,
-0.021792816,
1.136028409,
-0.4482973814,
0.2217372805,
0.0064553404,
-0.0502913296,
-1.2785631418,
0.1344631314,
0.2049429268,
-0.782623291,
0.5080840588,
-0.2758608162,
-0.296513617,
-0.4341959059,
-0.0430914834,
0.4834558666,
0.5493512154,
-0.4544494748,
0.4090391695,
0.3592248857,
-0.1919756085,
-0.3762972057,
-0.6833044887,
-0.1953103691,
-0.1151440367,
-0.7636054158,
-0.0170378909,
0.0332996622,
-0.1364219189,
-0.3380732238,
-0.1434866935,
-0.261831969,
0.0423470214,
0.2430737615,
0.1481630355,
-0.4397738576,
0.0923972875,
0.0403116755,
-0.3325967193,
-0.112360172,
-0.3299655616,
0.4522672892,
0.2257741839,
-0.1064530239,
-0.9908920527,
0.2945767641,
0.5820974112,
-0.4518992007,
0.3506614864,
0.9462589622,
-0.6841728091,
-0.3944658637,
-0.5840754509,
-0.2004837692,
-0.4162359238,
0.287314266,
-0.5899450183,
-0.419654578,
0.4506289661,
-0.0610452853,
-0.4037977159,
0.3692733049,
0.6445896029,
-0.3028701544,
0.7906377316,
0.3376022577,
0.0074305083,
0.1049145088,
-0.4692994058,
0.3432271183,
-0.8231742978,
-0.6876367927,
-0.6872047186,
-0.0969483182,
-0.5735980868,
-0.5896410942,
0.420938313,
0.2601039112,
-0.0484572686,
0.1222771853,
-0.519883275,
0.0688662753,
0.3838219941,
0.1482876092,
0.1656614989,
0.0578850619,
-0.250008285,
-0.3254535496,
-0.3323837519,
-0.1778362989,
0.79625386,
0.4513858259,
0.3891111314,
0.3020068109,
0.5512381792,
0.623667717,
-0.4732993841,
-1.1630054712,
0.3460240364,
-0.1195364371,
-0.0282356739,
-0.3111515939,
-0.3359082639,
-0.508238852,
0.1841292232,
-0.1768387407,
-0.7971838713,
0.7075977921,
0.1755997986,
-0.3366324008,
0.2417575419,
-0.6397514939,
0.7875831127,
-0.0314351209,
-0.0882955492,
-0.3090344071,
-0.5928515196,
0.336656332,
-0.0210807752,
0.4705260098,
-0.0198932569,
0.0062764902,
0.9677196145,
-0.6985721588,
0.5220144391,
-0.6602979898,
-0.4453398883,
0.3901798725,
0.3558886051,
0.5276450515,
-0.2274229079,
-0.0100385891,
0.0317355543,
0.1352835894,
-0.257270366,
-0.4441972375,
0.7873411179,
-0.8442860842,
-0.0541517586,
-0.2160828114,
-0.2447828948,
-0.5325203538,
-0.2502864599,
0.3040456176,
0.7073355913,
0.0778256133,
-0.1395533979,
0.8370133042,
-0.1928988695,
0.2753328681,
0.6511231065,
0.3893314004,
-0.1979864091,
1.2042541504,
0.3613988459,
0.3533026576,
0.160936147,
0.2095443457,
-0.267239958,
-0.7497352362,
-0.0178180113,
0.0698764399,
-0.637816608,
-0.1456176341,
-0.5841748118,
-0.1343194246,
-0.5826641321,
0.2222783715,
-0.4231830835,
-0.4369547665,
-0.3341353834,
-0.1486094743,
0.4143690169,
0.5837354064,
-0.6956831217,
0.3023140132,
-0.2510383427,
0.6506440043,
0.1685174555,
0.0830691904,
-0.0086532505,
-0.8154492378,
-0.0509867929,
0.1802366972,
-0.1618979424,
-0.8499352932,
0.2999309897,
0.413913548,
0.2666305304,
0.6068667769,
-0.084768407,
0.6498873234,
-0.1314539909,
0.8645893931,
0.3080114424,
-0.846739471,
0.7605223656,
0.0768453032,
-0.1609801799,
0.1718453467,
0.2552196681,
-0.6692039371,
-0.3178019524,
-0.5400065184,
-0.8144654036,
0.6221217513,
-0.0797755569,
-0.6401956081,
-0.0067180307,
0.2951313257,
0.1446394622,
-0.1645351499,
-0.0542851649,
-0.5979557037,
-0.1881166995,
-0.2193951905,
0.1407987028,
-0.4740546942,
0.2225594372,
-0.3822407722,
0.7786296606,
0.0129851867,
0.1909027547,
0.2586380243,
-0.1143308952,
-0.1557240039,
0.3859833181,
0.5553004146,
0.4360950291,
-0.2750859857,
0.2015227824,
0.3168485165,
-0.6473852992,
0.463794142,
-0.0887201577,
0.2071190625,
0.0910077691,
0.3515215218,
0.614652276,
0.1199574098,
-0.20152843,
0.7606027126,
0.2630474865,
-0.1591235846,
-0.2733700573,
-0.0668683425,
-0.0005090116,
0.1704064012,
0.472450316,
0.1483012736,
0.1920291483,
-0.5658252239,
0.4483394325,
0.1886472553,
-0.5449681878,
-0.2740018368,
0.6295321584,
0.1714404225,
-0.5701381564,
0.5113637447,
-0.3607833982,
-0.3304585218,
0.6641413569,
0.4540488124,
0.5486446619,
-0.7215172052,
0.1691179872,
0.3225059509,
0.2774267197,
0.2308554649,
0.4792483747,
-0.0478243232,
-0.6054694653,
-0.0441093668,
-0.4182144701,
0.071548976,
0.5984951854,
-0.8267783523,
0.3932204247,
-0.4993287921,
-0.0730588883,
0.3118807375,
0.085632585,
-0.6287863255,
0.3761102557,
0.2359627038,
0.5294621587,
-0.697444737,
0.9253777266,
0.1888327003,
-0.4695573449,
-0.9159963727,
-0.1558197588,
0.5135217309,
-0.8745834827,
0.6623253822,
-0.188120231,
-0.2792461514,
0.1777053177,
-0.1202063709,
-0.3862092793,
1.1355698109,
-0.0028854641,
-0.6764035821,
0.1473513097,
0.1773398668,
0.4017255008,
-0.2540135682,
0.4910138547,
1.027677536,
0.5292019248,
0.1883612573,
-1.241304636,
-0.1574144065,
0.1336615533,
0.0685854033,
0.0708340779,
-0.3227071762,
0.6500139832,
-0.474894017,
-0.2944368422,
0.1472576261,
0.5146647692,
0.0641272441,
0.3573484123,
0.4670757949,
0.7286806703,
1.1688015461,
-0.0984005481,
0.5294055939,
-0.2761273384,
0.2205410898,
0.5848981738,
-0.0134249413,
0.9471524358,
0.2661033869,
-0.4239708483,
0.2016836852,
0.8283564448,
0.054312028,
0.5584677458,
0.3775744438,
-0.3990390599,
-0.0974681079,
-0.2154814005,
-0.5377401114,
0.4927976727,
0.5580034256,
0.004567089,
-0.0146296108,
0.3876733184,
-0.0493476242,
-0.0213467069,
-0.3440498114,
0.9748431444,
0.0187785029,
-0.1194181591,
0.9678866267,
0.11771819,
0.8533580899,
-0.334061116,
-0.1837460101,
-0.3552599847,
0.185406059,
-0.5088940263,
-0.4049566388,
-0.0482506007,
-0.2179939151,
-0.3422876596,
0.4374220669,
0.5320644975,
-0.8942204714,
-0.2224500328,
0.2638463974,
0.4892303348,
0.369217366,
0.220212698,
-0.4711027741,
0.0102228839,
-0.2226974517,
0.3107147217,
0.0037664564,
0.4323513806,
0.1227085665,
0.5143876076,
0.5571143031,
0.3136161566,
-0.0562285557,
0.2990030944,
0.2363529503,
-0.2991932929,
-0.5210969448,
-0.3557962477,
0.3957985342,
0.1928304136,
-0.2513252199,
0.1897268146,
0.5986859202,
0.6998368502,
0.1889428496,
0.8244655728,
0.1130572036,
0.8829469681,
-0.6402879953,
0.6022523046,
-0.3023012877,
0.3918976188,
-0.0509384349,
-0.6705253124,
-0.164331615,
0.6238650084,
0.1697651297,
0.0130590936,
0.9022771716,
1.1043287516,
-0.0044021099,
-0.1015890241,
0.4582736194,
0.4686991572,
0.1885725856,
0.5714917779,
0.5419828892,
-0.54087919,
0.5224817991,
-0.344972074,
-0.4091373384,
-0.2550556362,
-0.2964218259,
-0.759290874,
-0.8429177403,
-0.5742836595,
-0.6559306383,
0.2424736768,
0.9574912786,
0.6128413081,
-0.8419050574,
-0.0607553869,
0.3330730796,
0.1753961593,
-0.4944843054,
-0.3215503991,
0.5767595768,
-0.1753051579,
-0.4425555468,
0.7652170062,
0.1860780269,
0.1613875329,
-0.3452353776,
-0.0698391646,
-0.1170149297,
-0.1494501531,
0.5766003728,
0.2951637506,
-0.7024840713,
-0.2356333733,
-0.3535607457,
-0.0474577397,
0.1623386145,
0.8532756567,
-0.7019922733,
0.4950987399,
0.4101667702,
0.1625964195,
0.0174688883,
-0.1713621616,
0.2510335743,
-0.7799490094,
0.4431511462,
0.1294474006,
0.1046110392,
0.4445860088,
-0.4333019853,
0.1526800245,
0.6115024686,
-0.1615992486,
-0.7477651238,
0.1174965203,
-1.1055271626,
-0.0240704175,
1.0600055456,
-0.0053798389,
-0.1290483624,
-0.4871639609,
-0.3331502378,
0.3060218096,
-0.4551593959,
0.279328227,
0.4105391502,
-0.137311399,
-0.3024883866,
-0.4294282198,
0.7092890739,
-0.0671597347,
-0.4475127757,
-0.1045813337,
0.4992243648,
0.5092170835,
-0.0456917696,
0.5001171231,
-0.1402637959,
0.4039202034,
0.0519278161,
0.1817721277,
-0.3148859739,
-0.2498548776,
-0.4148510993,
0.0310159754,
0.222822383,
-0.5518348813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07032v1
|
ExpNote: Black-box Large Language Models are Better Task Solvers with Experience Notebook
| 2023-11-13T02:31:16 | 2023-11-13T02:31:16 |
Wangtao Sun, Xuanqing Yu, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Black-box Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great power in solving
various tasks and are considered general problem solvers. However, LLMs still
fail in many specific tasks although understand the task instruction. In this
paper, we focus on the problem of boosting the ability of black-box LLMs to
solve downstream tasks. We propose ExpNote, an automated framework to help LLMs
better adapt to unfamiliar tasks through reflecting and noting experiences from
training data and retrieving them from external memory during testing. We
evaluate ExpNote on multiple tasks and the experimental results demonstrate
that the proposed method significantly improves the performance of black-box
LLMs. The data and code are available at
https://github.com/forangel2014/ExpNote
|
[
-0.0837674737,
-0.9346388578,
0.6365826726,
0.4144131243,
-0.0499434248,
0.2189693749,
-0.5511929393,
-0.5269113779,
0.1404310465,
0.3888324797,
-0.3176041842,
-0.4311529696,
-0.4988036752,
-0.042569045,
-0.3356356621,
1.2101042271,
-0.4772323668,
-0.1976588219,
-0.3020333052,
0.0154697224,
-0.7290142775,
-0.4980823398,
-0.9489105344,
-0.3051812649,
0.1730769575,
0.3441589773,
0.0652868226,
0.4065917134,
0.4559449852,
0.2835640609,
-0.1025535092,
0.3453669548,
-0.4354101419,
0.2176552862,
-0.3046759963,
-0.6437650919,
-0.503211081,
-0.2448961884,
0.4653151035,
0.4785514176,
-0.1576595008,
0.0983715802,
0.2531959116,
0.2818038464,
-0.2490671426,
0.3781340122,
-0.5443007946,
0.1283347458,
0.1738234162,
-0.4266795516,
-0.40574494,
0.0054929471,
-0.0079488577,
-0.868581593,
0.4168540835,
0.1797371507,
0.4795699716,
0.1152867451,
-0.2208335847,
-0.3578697443,
-0.9048838615,
0.6125267744,
-0.594335258,
-0.0839386061,
0.1546024084,
0.5277222991,
-0.3924573362,
-0.6288433671,
-0.4194616675,
-0.4651671648,
0.1134944931,
0.0672849268,
0.1370846629,
-0.0118493848,
0.4358933866,
0.5004227757,
-0.3455542028,
-0.0315485708,
-0.4369653463,
-0.0366813727,
0.5468078256,
0.1598633826,
0.1464592516,
0.135657832,
-0.169067055,
-0.1456229687,
-0.6638658643,
0.2029707432,
0.318551898,
0.3553768694,
-0.1446798295,
0.46410501,
-0.2066808939,
0.6541475058,
-0.3060776591,
-0.1399623454,
0.4084123969,
-0.2521364689,
-0.1567287147,
-0.0348969027,
0.2815859914,
0.3676002622,
0.3486234546,
-0.1407099515,
-0.3554498255,
-0.1331512481,
0.6000877619,
-0.4758837819,
-0.6000285745,
0.2584072351,
-0.3911896944,
0.098817803,
-0.3774065971,
-0.5508714318,
-0.6229121089,
-0.228275612,
0.7664036155,
-0.5312201381,
-0.2262098491,
0.1624476314,
-0.4038179815,
-0.1969465613,
0.972433269,
-0.5392335057,
0.4824543595,
0.7525166869,
0.9043222666,
-0.2318356633,
-0.2560106516,
-0.9510409236,
0.1807317287,
-0.1906295419,
0.9045360684,
-0.5292046666,
-0.3833298087,
0.1375505924,
0.1572010964,
-0.0528126508,
-0.6904343367,
0.494170934,
-0.051382523,
-0.1011639312,
-0.1070014089,
-0.7076923847,
-0.2481094897,
0.3826805949,
-0.5855719447,
1.2187763453,
0.313206315,
-0.3802166283,
0.1476152092,
-0.8586211205,
-0.3626041412,
0.1779801548,
-0.1474514604,
-0.3234250844,
0.4679953158,
0.1018553376,
0.5595647097,
-0.0320548899,
0.1000423431,
-0.4228639305,
-0.5390574932,
0.1241246983,
0.1360528171,
0.5030119419,
-0.2191341966,
-0.4999016225,
0.1835295111,
-0.8440793157,
-0.0764274001,
0.3130868971,
-0.3878774047,
-0.5376812816,
0.0051884772,
0.118902877,
0.5025138855,
0.0157852527,
-0.722204268,
0.4066610038,
-0.1038376018,
0.4745813608,
0.8503162861,
-0.1122113019,
0.224442035,
-0.3450318575,
0.7476421595,
0.0952763706,
-0.2397705615,
-0.7668086886,
-0.5460853577,
-0.8981241584,
0.0156568177,
-0.0545723177,
0.5746124387,
-0.6219520569,
0.0908567756,
-0.2177470177,
-0.1824747622,
-0.4972240925,
0.6465641856,
0.5153042078,
0.4581947923,
0.6141240597,
-0.3529815376,
-0.4352099895,
-0.8287796974,
-0.401489526,
-0.1262855977,
0.0030918089,
0.720346868,
0.8211120963,
0.0414175279,
0.5056243539,
-0.5926827192,
-0.6437686086,
-0.2563042343,
0.1751891375,
-0.0005468923,
0.6704490185,
0.1560702473,
-0.4875828326,
-0.3475617766,
-0.0612070262,
-0.5923866034,
-0.0014864745,
-0.1943074912,
0.0453116409,
0.4408023655,
0.6871443391,
-0.6473117471,
0.1152387038,
0.460687995,
-0.3886808753,
0.5485946536,
-0.6606456637,
-0.2251231819,
-0.9086728096,
0.2039641887,
0.3549046516,
-0.333764255,
-0.3053278625,
-0.1519823372,
0.4987209141,
-0.0566032566,
-0.193128407,
0.8310053945,
-0.5723663568,
-0.0008076822,
-0.3749966621,
0.1722280979,
-0.0492980778,
0.6185634136,
0.2345557809,
0.4449059665,
0.3018960059,
-0.2430732697,
0.4891514182,
0.0536333583,
-0.4793713391,
0.6582224369,
-0.4592280388,
0.4036051631,
-0.0857553184,
0.3274764419,
-1.238914609,
-0.0464903638,
0.0927236155,
-0.2059699595,
0.6047823429,
-0.23557055,
-0.6039023995,
-0.4782155752,
-0.2729993761,
0.1095202342,
0.346588552,
-0.475713551,
0.5249837637,
0.2800811529,
-0.5226819515,
-0.4441689551,
-0.5198725462,
0.2658256888,
-0.178391397,
-0.2700520456,
0.4005678594,
-0.268096149,
-0.1713190526,
0.0356610008,
-0.2438235581,
0.0671894476,
0.1818826795,
0.3742420375,
0.146676898,
-0.1236606166,
0.3139597774,
-0.1123381555,
-0.0966209397,
0.2455660999,
-0.5050613284,
0.3017621636,
0.0814854428,
-0.0638343245,
0.138538152,
0.3770134747,
-0.0315300673,
-0.2291606069,
0.589735508,
0.3378931582,
-0.4961465597,
-0.9049533606,
-0.5385774374,
0.0409867018,
-0.4831975102,
0.5082350373,
-0.347748369,
-0.9237183332,
0.2903197408,
-0.0498400815,
0.2860951424,
-0.1447659284,
0.3775041997,
-0.260697633,
0.7438053489,
1.1071740389,
0.0046040239,
0.4483912885,
-0.2266821861,
0.2284409255,
-1.0786145926,
-0.3740632534,
-0.4186880589,
-0.3866421878,
-0.2967607677,
-0.6580166817,
0.2385855913,
-0.0285084918,
0.0229544509,
0.251580596,
-0.5169392824,
0.2826618552,
0.5758535862,
0.0110578928,
0.3098683655,
0.0320393033,
-0.0825552568,
0.0785728097,
-0.5027607083,
-0.3576033115,
1.292517662,
0.3637455702,
0.8290815949,
-0.2678298652,
0.6971089244,
0.1208231598,
0.6174251437,
-0.6074177623,
0.5067370534,
0.0870706737,
-0.5689036846,
-0.2110992968,
-0.4354348183,
-0.7314631939,
0.0976914912,
0.037282791,
-0.9515224099,
-0.2619952857,
0.5557568669,
-0.4105696976,
0.1480411142,
-0.8015589118,
1.1841137409,
-0.3677406907,
-0.5492293835,
-0.1004597992,
-0.3337682486,
0.2484315634,
-0.176015988,
0.254037559,
0.0295573566,
-0.3482251763,
0.8209944367,
-0.1110687703,
0.7324578762,
-0.5290663838,
-0.3860962093,
0.0425184071,
0.1994599551,
0.92573452,
-0.030884495,
0.0824573115,
-0.3027121425,
-0.3265128434,
-0.2678214014,
-0.7877831459,
0.963860631,
-0.3487659991,
-0.7636883855,
-0.1572713852,
-1.0834826231,
-0.3071973324,
0.0691731274,
-0.1023453623,
0.4559765756,
0.0826121047,
0.1249236539,
0.6515389681,
-0.465880245,
0.5125617385,
0.7388329506,
-0.375516206,
-0.2144552469,
0.9013733268,
0.4105589986,
-0.0428720675,
0.4692889154,
-0.1988831013,
-0.3878385723,
-0.9282674789,
-0.501312077,
0.1432624012,
-0.8339698911,
-0.0962635875,
-1.0224329233,
0.2110407799,
-0.1693545133,
-0.0921156555,
-0.2627745867,
-0.7988833785,
0.2437253147,
-0.2132830769,
0.5004754663,
0.5676600933,
0.2314621955,
0.2795282006,
-0.5051912665,
0.4067557454,
0.0449062102,
0.5526022315,
-0.1073535308,
-0.7123398185,
-0.5486785173,
-0.2493671477,
-0.3495222628,
-0.553614378,
0.4516707361,
0.2237367481,
0.5120407343,
-0.0977882072,
-0.108615227,
0.6407034993,
-0.5689950585,
0.4827457666,
-0.196021542,
-0.8218603134,
0.6582522988,
-0.2900606692,
0.2673574984,
0.3508939743,
0.2275820225,
-0.5232526064,
-0.7314009666,
-0.6951696873,
-1.1100811958,
0.8436003327,
0.0462652706,
0.1866116673,
0.3137755692,
0.5174697042,
0.1987709552,
0.4654681385,
-0.9071089029,
-0.3919858038,
-0.0274778362,
-0.3797473907,
-0.7286801338,
-0.0042691152,
-0.0965475291,
-0.0013362515,
0.6776437163,
-0.2935726643,
0.3487315774,
0.1448231339,
-0.3346419036,
-0.2268960178,
0.1390309334,
0.5559391379,
0.6700094342,
-0.3321358263,
0.282015413,
0.2041006535,
-0.3997438252,
0.3969300389,
0.5158354044,
0.0308954455,
-0.0072392211,
0.365850538,
0.5381962657,
0.3565324843,
-0.9638751149,
0.4526637495,
-0.0779878646,
0.133060813,
-0.5709284544,
0.5150901079,
0.4182567,
0.1591110677,
0.4734641612,
-0.2669708133,
0.0304448139,
-0.568005383,
0.0650710166,
0.5337601304,
-0.2449841201,
-0.138067022,
0.5634624362,
0.3314548135,
-0.6322560906,
0.3646928072,
-0.2357878685,
-0.4186643362,
0.8475333452,
0.9337420464,
0.7222473025,
-0.3571833372,
0.0203567911,
0.1399701238,
0.4604713023,
-0.0944762826,
0.3249544203,
-0.2637876868,
-0.3930278718,
-0.7635816932,
-0.4628082812,
-0.5317766666,
0.5088709593,
-0.3652595282,
0.1796254665,
-0.5129539371,
0.2019252628,
0.0588955097,
0.3606095016,
-0.6112046242,
0.3586935401,
0.1306646317,
1.2700250149,
-0.6920976639,
0.9277713895,
1.2300832272,
-0.0481329225,
-0.7039619088,
-0.3804524243,
-0.0992036313,
-0.5973279476,
0.6323607564,
0.48788324,
0.1979521364,
-0.0712375194,
-0.1161602885,
-0.5717410445,
0.8622216582,
0.4137478173,
-0.8203779459,
0.0296403952,
0.0322379321,
0.6279643178,
-0.5046228766,
0.4302996397,
0.4221504629,
0.3316498101,
-0.5667979121,
-0.9609137774,
0.248152554,
-0.7566320896,
-0.1506060958,
0.4506375194,
-0.4987390637,
0.7670864463,
-0.3069254756,
0.1992673874,
-0.1043618247,
0.4799361527,
0.2725329101,
0.5926149487,
0.3912249506,
0.6721826792,
0.6943397522,
0.1570892185,
1.2482615709,
-0.1987043619,
0.0556265451,
1.5768060684,
-0.4126237035,
0.7560721636,
0.4824597239,
-0.0017566258,
0.4242497385,
0.370641917,
-0.092497088,
0.1384764314,
0.4709466696,
-0.0837488547,
-0.16316773,
0.2499410808,
-0.2828741968,
0.0420043692,
0.3227407336,
-0.5157887936,
-0.1813129634,
0.2348400503,
0.1515341252,
-0.0082806852,
-0.441286236,
0.5946746469,
0.3804746568,
-0.873888433,
0.4147646129,
0.0408937484,
0.4686430097,
-0.5590590239,
-0.3680286109,
-0.2470455319,
0.6053826809,
-0.0874574408,
-0.777725637,
0.0566314012,
0.0315292999,
-0.0257496703,
-0.2465251535,
0.7264800072,
-0.5813912153,
-0.5533570647,
0.5766366124,
0.5488031507,
0.0460904203,
-0.3517069519,
-0.6139045358,
0.1445263475,
-0.2771632373,
-0.3129981756,
0.5190871954,
0.4557447433,
-0.0693836659,
0.9514996409,
0.4469541311,
0.301821202,
0.0214801654,
-0.3645771742,
0.7176870704,
-0.941265583,
-0.6569911838,
-0.7572388053,
0.4366511405,
-0.3176440299,
-0.3467797339,
1.0562027693,
0.7961294651,
1.0934826136,
-0.0680161491,
1.0350372791,
0.178291887,
0.6497871876,
-0.4402749538,
0.3381162286,
-0.5661599636,
0.3290511072,
-0.4322739542,
-1.0487132072,
-0.1321078688,
0.674328506,
-0.4191527069,
0.0969661623,
0.7743989825,
0.8637936711,
-0.2830407619,
0.0089646224,
0.0291239396,
0.2543152273,
0.3484305739,
1.0579303503,
1.0283225775,
-0.2213415802,
0.8629491329,
-0.4740976393,
-0.1550534219,
-0.30534935,
-1.0284259319,
-0.9760864973,
-0.402659595,
-0.560806036,
-0.3337501585,
0.2650751173,
1.0160052776,
0.6628375053,
-0.640924871,
-0.3248609304,
-0.2225058377,
0.0663395897,
-0.4056506455,
-0.2156023681,
0.3177456558,
-0.5517863035,
-0.7388592362,
0.4147090912,
0.4828304648,
0.0468223393,
-0.0092406925,
-0.056107346,
0.3326935172,
-0.1378129572,
0.4829837084,
0.1172632799,
-0.1747348458,
-0.2424202114,
-0.184002459,
0.101911068,
0.1645189673,
1.2383066416,
-0.9742954969,
0.5190203786,
0.1272103786,
0.634218812,
0.7442759871,
-0.2608298957,
0.732856214,
-0.4723047018,
0.0987540632,
0.1108153462,
0.5144979358,
0.452866286,
-0.2644807398,
0.635915637,
0.1844241619,
-0.3520706296,
-1.1349667311,
-0.2620541751,
-0.8613616824,
-0.4275050163,
1.1887989044,
-0.690928638,
-0.3211001456,
-0.483857125,
-0.4052007198,
0.0920676962,
-0.4752031863,
1.053779006,
0.6772773266,
-0.0899190605,
-0.366961956,
-1.0536681414,
0.5552066565,
0.6235035062,
-1.1010708809,
0.2175062001,
0.3767035306,
0.301058352,
0.1558261216,
0.744426012,
0.1179194301,
0.4135507643,
-0.1336893588,
-0.0781174675,
-0.5022144318,
-0.4661292434,
-0.5659796,
0.3181017339,
0.173638761,
0.0438867435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07022v1
|
ViLMA: A Zero-Shot Benchmark for Linguistic and Temporal Grounding in Video-Language Models
| 2023-11-13T02:13:13 | 2023-11-13T02:13:13 |
Ilker Kesen, Andrea Pedrotti, Mustafa Dogan, Michele Cafagna, Emre Can Acikgoz, Letitia Parcalabescu, Iacer Calixto, Anette Frank, Albert Gatt, Aykut Erdem, Erkut Erdem
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
With the ever-increasing popularity of pretrained Video-Language Models
(VidLMs), there is a pressing need to develop robust evaluation methodologies
that delve deeper into their visio-linguistic capabilities. To address this
challenge, we present ViLMA (Video Language Model Assessment), a task-agnostic
benchmark that places the assessment of fine-grained capabilities of these
models on a firm footing. Task-based evaluations, while valuable, fail to
capture the complexities and specific temporal aspects of moving images that
VidLMs need to process. Through carefully curated counterfactuals, ViLMA offers
a controlled evaluation suite that sheds light on the true potential of these
models, as well as their performance gaps compared to human-level
understanding. ViLMA also includes proficiency tests, which assess basic
capabilities deemed essential to solving the main counterfactual tests. We show
that current VidLMs' grounding abilities are no better than those of
vision-language models which use static images. This is especially striking
once the performance on proficiency tests is factored in. Our benchmark serves
as a catalyst for future research on VidLMs, helping to highlight areas that
still need to be explored.
|
[
-0.3292885721,
-0.9966725707,
0.3284326792,
0.1706241965,
-0.3688211441,
0.1432197392,
-0.091887109,
-0.1255178601,
-0.1398498714,
0.4647165835,
-0.2407500297,
-0.4674427509,
-0.6892561316,
-0.4144088924,
-0.7841796875,
0.764958322,
-0.1879164726,
-0.0213900711,
-0.6291339397,
-0.6028280854,
-0.7322957516,
-0.3972328901,
-0.0216833018,
-0.3901233077,
0.1377958357,
0.3034113646,
0.6786042452,
0.4944247603,
0.5329242349,
0.2252884209,
-0.0039061231,
-0.1932511926,
-0.5408016443,
0.1208928972,
-0.1059512645,
-0.4349401891,
-0.380130589,
0.0843726322,
0.9306966662,
0.6427295804,
0.0176205337,
0.7121196985,
-0.2730044127,
0.6672904491,
-1.0584492683,
-0.0043907361,
-0.7500265241,
0.2789368331,
-0.2487555742,
-0.1784506887,
-0.192793414,
-0.2300162762,
-0.0048090792,
-0.1904635131,
0.3669023216,
-0.3666774035,
1.1859368086,
0.5973721147,
-0.1149682999,
0.4778251648,
-0.8190146089,
0.6828235984,
-0.3654422164,
0.6688488722,
0.2875926793,
0.5825452209,
0.2242682278,
-0.346014142,
-0.6599061489,
-0.4665397108,
0.2994344234,
-0.0068062134,
-0.1465122104,
-0.0274964552,
0.5252888799,
0.4580186307,
-0.8292081356,
-0.0529179648,
-0.4526849985,
0.0975140333,
0.3043876886,
0.342767328,
0.4033662379,
0.018503204,
-0.3339608312,
-0.1737504303,
-0.7509860396,
0.3487864435,
0.0605433173,
-0.1202093661,
-0.278957516,
0.8078181744,
-0.453720957,
0.8400173783,
0.0155436667,
0.0769922957,
0.4526411295,
-0.0850570872,
-0.7174915671,
-0.1335890144,
0.6906027794,
0.5974565744,
0.4426090419,
-0.1444432139,
0.00685714,
0.760697782,
0.4847783446,
-0.8054041266,
-0.0561291091,
0.1018197015,
-0.2220877409,
-0.3114798963,
-0.2700614929,
-0.7041655183,
-0.2603624761,
-0.222093448,
0.5119847059,
-0.1944182366,
-0.2572820783,
-0.0184143074,
-0.1305561513,
0.7147438526,
0.2268785983,
-0.658372283,
0.2956956029,
0.5918464661,
0.8431177139,
-0.1122935712,
-0.4866583347,
-1.0932152271,
-0.2175054997,
-0.8320447803,
0.7794373631,
-0.8210044503,
-0.395478487,
-0.0818831623,
0.0388694927,
-0.0011265731,
-0.4639484584,
0.2972134352,
-0.4023019373,
-0.0747127011,
-0.2385872155,
-0.2075332403,
-0.1781799346,
0.5336854458,
-0.3384854794,
1.1385443211,
0.069736205,
-0.3229932487,
0.7246412039,
-0.2704896331,
-0.203775838,
0.2621032,
-0.5781644583,
-0.3573604524,
0.3074053824,
-0.0273576844,
0.4230423272,
-0.4908493459,
0.7422145605,
-0.3643373847,
-0.5225817561,
-0.0644032136,
-0.7043731213,
0.4615276456,
-0.0150118535,
-0.6014969349,
0.076434426,
-0.8420218229,
0.2940617204,
0.0895699337,
-0.0188657753,
-0.1434050649,
0.0320504159,
-0.0712351128,
0.1780148298,
0.1645670086,
-0.3472369909,
-0.1317402869,
-0.300971657,
-0.1213210598,
0.5040019751,
-0.5114657283,
0.3203082085,
-0.2031674385,
0.7334414721,
-0.021206541,
0.2772821188,
-0.4793697894,
-0.4474329054,
-0.9346542358,
0.0349227153,
0.1645286381,
0.592392683,
-0.5995441079,
0.1145013198,
-0.4972800612,
-0.992361486,
-0.7216578722,
0.4265535772,
0.8745048642,
0.5799002647,
0.4753070176,
-0.8465510607,
-0.2575072944,
-0.764289856,
-0.284691304,
-0.3122122884,
0.2506383359,
0.194148913,
0.3159289956,
-0.2697408497,
0.9643879533,
-0.2354887128,
-0.2334684283,
-0.0126521904,
0.4399467707,
0.2561829388,
0.2982310355,
0.7591723204,
-0.905403614,
-0.619014442,
0.1353807598,
-1.0244810581,
-0.2108187526,
0.0366067104,
0.3956364691,
0.0813376829,
0.4541778564,
-0.5813344121,
0.6181771159,
0.6820093393,
-0.4252088964,
0.7193830013,
-0.2631114423,
0.3562691808,
-0.079149507,
0.385412544,
-0.1624741852,
-0.3427385688,
-0.6050448418,
0.2896887958,
-0.0445703827,
-0.3858629167,
-0.7716935277,
0.8709769249,
-0.4437390268,
-0.4016935527,
-0.1398503184,
0.0143657206,
-0.0500903986,
0.422488451,
0.1680357307,
0.7976793051,
1.0135649443,
-0.5147950053,
0.331356436,
-0.0987678617,
-0.5069921613,
0.7825284004,
-0.9572539926,
0.1155928373,
-0.3436393142,
-0.3150790334,
-0.9873656034,
0.0883020535,
0.0404865518,
-0.4259197414,
0.2626975775,
-0.4103266299,
-0.1699501425,
-0.1430478096,
-0.3164996207,
0.5839115977,
0.8187510371,
-0.209680289,
0.5739132166,
0.5580413342,
0.0050143204,
-0.7875307798,
-0.5057014227,
0.324213028,
-0.2740013897,
-0.3431468308,
0.1529934406,
-0.1831089109,
-0.3796423972,
-0.0047188564,
-0.4047982991,
-0.2386796325,
0.2061268687,
0.574883163,
0.1352211088,
-0.4235572815,
-0.1910923272,
-0.2653869689,
-0.3213479519,
-0.0536756143,
0.1281415075,
0.5012665391,
-0.5056308508,
-0.5529318452,
0.0169417653,
0.0013816126,
0.8721607327,
-0.4619493783,
0.4399117529,
0.8327677846,
-0.2971154749,
0.0603346303,
-0.780085206,
0.5029932261,
-0.417367816,
0.1573072523,
-0.3842529655,
-0.6851832271,
0.2816328108,
0.0786244944,
0.0322208181,
0.3737279475,
0.6170302629,
-0.0174821783,
0.6360938549,
0.7319837809,
-0.0637433082,
0.5512274504,
-0.3364789784,
-0.0221649036,
-0.483885169,
-0.1574421227,
-0.3462072015,
0.1087575704,
-0.2918593287,
-0.8507784009,
0.3661762774,
0.1904331148,
-0.0816085935,
0.3998374939,
-0.2353612185,
0.6914415956,
0.2264762521,
-0.2760900855,
0.0208815821,
-0.0879734084,
-0.1670695096,
-0.0989606678,
-0.4655478299,
-0.596588254,
0.9936507344,
0.2442531586,
0.776607275,
-0.1325849593,
0.1349398494,
0.5928701162,
0.349812448,
-0.5228839517,
0.6987810135,
-0.3689581752,
-0.5144881606,
-0.3076052964,
-0.0335781649,
-0.626796484,
0.3638170063,
-0.214285925,
-0.8107095361,
0.1188587844,
0.2159313262,
-0.2706762254,
0.0500434563,
-0.5931600928,
1.2029883862,
-0.4177701473,
-0.6523214579,
-0.2858534157,
-0.4925765693,
0.1979603171,
-0.0388133675,
0.2306262106,
-0.5089924932,
0.4038577378,
0.572563529,
-0.1662096083,
0.84791857,
-0.3652048409,
0.0006996755,
0.3977067173,
0.3532823324,
-0.0060185078,
-0.0698239356,
0.1727773249,
0.5184568167,
0.1527615041,
-0.45491606,
-0.5158385038,
0.6435902119,
-0.4817932248,
-0.701587975,
-0.3579586148,
-0.19323273,
-0.2835570574,
0.2966702878,
-0.0509184301,
0.6426938176,
-0.7502856255,
0.342553407,
0.7139551044,
-0.3348773122,
0.3393726647,
0.6174347401,
-0.5037660003,
-0.2270325571,
1.1033773422,
0.0799585059,
0.200108707,
0.3960751295,
-0.0454719923,
-0.1582939029,
-0.4451105893,
-0.6468961835,
-0.1310667992,
-0.8463578224,
0.0905898809,
-0.6668381095,
-0.2117705047,
-0.3093197048,
-0.3036201298,
-0.6965782046,
-0.1269762069,
0.0285934024,
-0.1785460114,
0.0424150899,
0.3257580101,
0.0876425356,
0.1873701215,
-0.8072871566,
0.9680139422,
0.5739588141,
0.4446404576,
-0.3312152624,
-0.5085636377,
-0.177054733,
-0.0127594471,
-0.2981935441,
-0.5170826316,
0.2247558236,
0.3604125977,
0.7505946159,
0.3585178852,
-0.3712674975,
1.0701149702,
-0.7413703799,
1.0576654673,
0.2380067259,
-1.1660600901,
0.6063374281,
-0.3376664519,
0.4170580804,
0.5717586279,
0.1393595785,
-0.5416510105,
-0.3468200564,
-0.5865859985,
-0.6768508554,
0.2949801087,
0.1662389189,
0.2560894489,
0.0019447054,
-0.0924575776,
-0.003459841,
0.3258745968,
-0.6798129678,
-0.0736419931,
-0.3070462048,
0.262045145,
-0.5107192397,
-0.4256620407,
-0.0436413102,
-0.3811992407,
0.1828898787,
-0.1864490509,
0.0142209865,
0.1505624205,
-0.6149122119,
-0.3719483018,
0.2722210586,
0.5677429438,
0.7395318747,
-0.3263107836,
0.1581562608,
0.4114202857,
-0.4056472182,
0.3675681353,
-0.1309780926,
-0.1981825978,
0.3715083003,
0.5488450527,
0.9443092346,
0.3120383024,
-1.0868210793,
0.7230829,
0.0076426291,
0.0821507573,
-0.2740007043,
0.350618422,
-0.3702718318,
0.1921586394,
0.2184106708,
0.0499249771,
-0.0441809446,
-0.6057266593,
0.2179160565,
0.4951676428,
-0.7128676772,
-0.5011997819,
0.8258417845,
-0.0368535295,
-0.3585455418,
0.1144595593,
-0.0244264379,
-0.414067477,
0.8634413481,
0.0753963366,
1.0963354111,
-0.2412034571,
0.495239377,
0.2116627395,
0.5118170381,
-0.1476201564,
0.3929537535,
-0.4212963283,
-0.5576632619,
-0.2729139626,
-0.7282801867,
-0.4136538804,
0.0802373514,
-0.6810387373,
0.5713112354,
-0.5522980094,
-0.1450309008,
-0.0910272449,
-0.243797496,
-0.9958322644,
0.5110817552,
0.3847647905,
0.7924323082,
-0.9376997948,
0.8110120893,
0.6677153707,
-0.2870949209,
0.0038266985,
-0.1759368926,
-0.1228583083,
-0.7444489002,
0.9212573171,
0.4227889776,
-0.3849223256,
-0.3946521282,
-0.3944796622,
-0.6049162149,
0.890994668,
0.6432411671,
-0.5662742257,
0.0223274976,
0.1745949388,
0.9102298021,
-0.1096541658,
0.4201748669,
0.505030334,
0.3240737915,
-0.1647725552,
-1.2579758167,
-0.3155398667,
-0.4992519617,
-0.0168649871,
0.0870648324,
-0.4784101248,
0.792663157,
-0.1710759997,
-0.3659798801,
-0.1470463574,
0.4454157054,
0.1098640114,
0.5965793133,
0.4983082712,
0.78992939,
0.4246089458,
0.0980393514,
0.9437308311,
-0.2219048589,
0.349526614,
1.1760622263,
-0.4343485236,
0.8496315479,
0.5033529997,
-0.1811684221,
0.3036116064,
0.0922134221,
-0.1260014325,
0.5953624249,
0.149965927,
-0.0059176055,
-0.5557132363,
-0.4057838321,
-0.4401826262,
0.6044063568,
0.3632599711,
0.0012008662,
-0.4957842827,
-0.0688104928,
-0.3441877365,
0.1891973615,
-0.2432289869,
0.4358754456,
0.032994315,
-0.6424247622,
0.9495313764,
-0.2755357027,
0.3988847733,
-0.5934760571,
-0.1512449533,
-0.2073431909,
-0.0282393973,
0.0619025789,
-0.7623366714,
0.470404774,
0.579347074,
-0.1044216082,
-0.3561726511,
0.7870053053,
-0.348064661,
-0.4015526772,
0.5294362307,
0.5590369105,
0.2322619408,
0.1148507223,
-0.5859757066,
0.2774427235,
-0.4889832735,
-0.0484770089,
0.2341764867,
0.2242518514,
-0.1707244366,
0.7895666957,
0.5404013395,
0.0800669417,
0.0795345977,
0.0973266065,
0.777813971,
-0.7252898216,
-0.2817064822,
-1.1048929691,
0.6260411143,
0.2463386357,
-0.4594792426,
0.6785002351,
0.4702059329,
0.9373084903,
-0.1262149364,
0.5611665249,
-0.0744198933,
0.0067867534,
-0.7022404671,
0.6626138687,
-0.7511794567,
0.0050095725,
-0.5666430593,
-0.8511074185,
-0.1840143055,
0.3876296878,
-0.3810287118,
-0.2667071521,
0.3851923645,
0.5849642754,
-0.1715929061,
-0.5975288749,
0.9799889326,
0.1933661103,
0.3380975723,
0.3727278113,
0.9630220532,
-0.5904120207,
0.2956396639,
-0.0867625996,
-0.0684927255,
-0.1232020631,
-1.0972245932,
-1.281690836,
-0.5921913385,
-0.4266396463,
0.1175676808,
0.3519809246,
0.5563360453,
0.7607390881,
-0.6078246832,
-0.3235923648,
0.0451777168,
0.0962803066,
-0.233722046,
-0.1785158515,
0.008383194,
-0.1779109985,
-0.5451785326,
0.6315227747,
0.6462996006,
-0.1176603362,
-0.4908751249,
0.0188891944,
-0.0182808097,
-0.0500731245,
0.6114339232,
0.4862298369,
-0.7907313704,
-0.1705129296,
-0.0186070502,
0.0927799493,
0.0846577212,
0.7154813409,
-1.0734722614,
0.8201180696,
0.5795696378,
0.7264066339,
0.547010839,
-0.0082627563,
0.6114215255,
-0.578389585,
0.4450985491,
0.0277736746,
0.3621377051,
0.3316408098,
-0.0167723764,
0.5386621952,
0.4093205035,
-0.1945876032,
-1.2121257782,
-0.0916595906,
-0.9041016698,
0.0401012637,
1.0353029966,
-0.3369734287,
-0.2198534161,
-0.0124131478,
0.1133874133,
-0.000228246,
0.1922491193,
0.732570827,
0.7399606109,
0.5890364051,
-0.3148153424,
-0.7846926451,
0.1855564117,
0.7811830044,
-0.53511554,
0.0811517835,
0.4592648745,
0.3034190834,
0.2265742123,
0.9609284997,
-0.102148965,
0.6206274033,
0.0570713356,
0.0436933003,
-0.0339742675,
-0.9256488681,
-0.6614034176,
0.1983414888,
0.0740887076,
-0.2572067678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07014v1
|
Teach me with a Whisper: Enhancing Large Language Models for Analyzing Spoken Transcripts using Speech Embeddings
| 2023-11-13T01:53:12 | 2023-11-13T01:53:12 |
Fatema Hasan, Yulong Li, James Foulds, Shimei Pan, Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech data has rich acoustic and paralinguistic information with important
cues for understanding a speaker's tone, emotion, and intent, yet traditional
large language models such as BERT do not incorporate this information. There
has been an increased interest in multi-modal language models leveraging audio
and/or visual information and text. However, current multi-modal language
models require both text and audio/visual data streams during inference/test
time. In this work, we propose a methodology for training language models
leveraging spoken language audio data but without requiring the audio stream
during prediction time. This leads to an improved language model for analyzing
spoken transcripts while avoiding an audio processing overhead at test time. We
achieve this via an audio-language knowledge distillation framework, where we
transfer acoustic and paralinguistic information from a pre-trained speech
embedding (OpenAI Whisper) teacher model to help train a student language model
on an audio-text dataset. In our experiments, the student model achieves
consistent improvement over traditional language models on tasks analyzing
spoken transcripts.
|
[
-0.0860607177,
-0.8293170929,
0.418056488,
0.062314637,
-0.0455164686,
0.1117768213,
-0.3782524168,
-0.2037863135,
0.0021919422,
0.3639200926,
-0.4870251417,
-0.4380580187,
-0.5919601321,
-0.428064853,
-0.5265346766,
0.7870520353,
0.123710759,
0.3608441949,
-0.1555222869,
0.0673449039,
-0.4350756407,
-0.5332736373,
-0.5672398806,
-0.1193107292,
0.1301151812,
0.3742749393,
0.480571866,
0.3229705691,
-0.073774904,
0.2674595118,
-0.0219032876,
-0.0855575576,
-0.3689488471,
0.1881672889,
0.1736870706,
-0.4621090293,
-0.1995458305,
0.0990398228,
0.637955904,
0.7631418705,
-0.5518696904,
0.2127813995,
0.1269306839,
0.2736756504,
-0.6078462601,
0.4832779467,
-0.7806613445,
-0.0558784716,
-0.1423301101,
-0.0901290402,
-0.5704881549,
-0.3029726446,
0.8464131951,
-0.5146344304,
0.3060420156,
-0.1292255223,
0.438084662,
0.3090068698,
-0.2681704462,
-0.3341451585,
-0.8085882664,
0.9286147952,
-0.9554903507,
0.649533093,
0.646771729,
0.4463120103,
0.332007736,
-0.6894987822,
-0.7310784459,
-0.2630629539,
0.1349569708,
0.3490535021,
-0.1804354042,
0.2094400972,
0.0931660384,
0.2178927213,
-0.3128920794,
-0.0334985256,
-0.3469240069,
-0.2770088613,
0.2893086672,
-0.0253596306,
0.2665010989,
-0.1350089461,
-0.3516732752,
-0.3533185124,
-0.2375261635,
0.0427790508,
0.4710666239,
0.4463129342,
-0.2121190727,
0.3659795821,
0.1324899793,
0.54374367,
-0.3147292733,
-0.5046012402,
0.2067251503,
-0.0990634337,
0.0032546292,
0.4589281082,
0.6369709373,
0.1436767727,
0.3192996979,
-0.0349983461,
0.0419033952,
0.0552075393,
0.0334124155,
-0.8559556603,
-0.3259085417,
0.0149856331,
-0.4123300016,
-0.2378076166,
-0.2667129934,
-0.832062602,
-0.1832914352,
-0.3799501956,
0.6680561304,
-0.6871967316,
-0.5669793487,
0.2243929207,
-0.4126535952,
0.1511318237,
0.1713143289,
-1.0530114174,
0.2827859521,
0.4271406233,
0.8483541012,
0.20912081,
-0.4888153076,
-0.5575553179,
0.3915037811,
-0.0769754276,
0.363696605,
-0.9205053449,
-0.444419533,
0.2927342653,
-0.3198946714,
-0.4207673967,
-0.3937041163,
0.395848155,
0.0160837136,
0.342491895,
-0.0439758375,
-0.9228598475,
-0.3159409165,
-0.1079076231,
-0.4278608859,
0.823784411,
0.0454225466,
-0.5372794271,
0.1521900743,
-0.5259943604,
-0.265455544,
-0.1163251102,
-0.1921961904,
-0.2513964474,
0.1163691953,
0.5118942857,
0.5996823907,
0.0150887063,
0.3544444144,
-0.1097829565,
-0.2675754726,
0.1585351676,
-0.7728710175,
0.477437079,
0.0140765859,
-0.3241157532,
-0.0485549048,
-0.6258431673,
-0.0966061726,
-0.0587980114,
-0.2326602638,
-0.4482336044,
0.093077153,
0.2102168947,
-0.3526849747,
0.0209744535,
-0.7861763239,
0.1760047227,
-0.3628304303,
0.5788860321,
0.6222108006,
-0.0372677445,
0.5069659352,
-0.3150089383,
0.5124153495,
-0.0052763293,
0.2606312931,
-0.6250212789,
-0.4703591168,
-0.7577518821,
-0.3683925271,
0.3196577132,
0.436057061,
-0.5964059234,
0.0266864225,
-0.1758219153,
-0.4514576495,
-1.1684328318,
0.1223007068,
0.36272493,
0.7004744411,
0.460934639,
0.1087765843,
-0.540506959,
-0.6886509061,
-0.0993865505,
-0.305077076,
-0.018164115,
0.3540713489,
0.0657195151,
-0.1504859328,
0.8828839064,
-0.6599086523,
-0.6175750494,
-0.4460985363,
0.2095789164,
-0.0140041774,
0.5194984674,
0.5997778773,
-0.6700492501,
-0.3890997469,
-0.2310869694,
-0.5754575133,
0.0129967984,
-0.1090933532,
0.0859869793,
-0.1443105042,
0.6866301894,
-0.1383221149,
0.3213066757,
0.8478189111,
-0.2126069814,
0.5494537354,
-0.0909591764,
0.1625011265,
-1.1409932375,
-0.3448818326,
-0.2199639529,
-0.1508384645,
-0.6613458991,
-0.343246758,
-0.1365464777,
-0.5257878304,
-0.4907979369,
0.4859144092,
-0.3617392182,
0.2233214974,
-0.2682894766,
0.0047314786,
0.0506565012,
0.4576544464,
0.2342689484,
0.74680233,
0.9593560696,
-0.4605435431,
0.2666923404,
0.4934942126,
-0.5070692897,
0.3671881258,
-0.624104917,
0.2786429822,
-0.0191789158,
0.0646772906,
-0.9262446165,
-0.0954451486,
-0.2457298338,
-0.4002700746,
0.5585779548,
-0.5229046345,
-0.2696914673,
-0.0631198809,
-0.2216053158,
0.2272117883,
0.6964425445,
-0.8581097126,
0.7595903873,
0.3979283869,
-0.3267679214,
-0.40694803,
-0.4656777978,
-0.0680552199,
-0.206808567,
-0.4833954573,
0.2157379538,
-0.1243134737,
-0.0585523285,
0.0203979556,
-0.0718361586,
-0.4735188186,
-0.0191030931,
0.3174051344,
0.2426956147,
-0.3500584662,
0.4524224102,
0.4419383407,
-0.1265906245,
-0.1019852087,
-0.2590031624,
0.5127081871,
-0.0780987814,
-0.4097243249,
-0.7586713433,
0.4115138352,
0.4826916456,
-0.3090373576,
0.8555551767,
0.6548160315,
-0.1831753701,
-0.4272841215,
-0.7426733375,
-0.4641430676,
-0.468133986,
0.2651910186,
-0.2572650015,
-0.9806679487,
0.237895146,
-0.2111929953,
0.0337239318,
-0.1403997242,
0.2913578749,
-0.4386824965,
0.886392951,
0.7584301233,
-0.3323562443,
0.8483673334,
-0.4134223163,
-0.0526583754,
-0.7267419696,
-0.2364640832,
-0.4230047464,
-0.1488614082,
0.0848017409,
-0.5169427991,
0.4798975587,
-0.0253344476,
0.1322674453,
0.1680653542,
-0.2999044061,
0.4233001769,
0.5938828588,
0.2340168953,
0.2290353924,
0.0069086323,
0.14050816,
-0.3006141782,
-0.5300047994,
-0.3684171736,
1.2069680691,
0.5545240045,
0.8956664801,
0.0778230652,
0.6032510996,
0.0435230881,
-0.1256041825,
-0.8945390582,
0.2156305611,
-0.182652995,
-0.3910603821,
-0.415155232,
-0.2551828027,
-0.6687580943,
0.3257196248,
-0.1292657107,
-0.4975503385,
-0.0109545467,
0.0429248028,
-0.089372769,
0.3451912701,
-0.9894498587,
0.6437241435,
-0.0082076658,
0.2206186205,
-0.4164824188,
-0.1081028804,
0.1212843284,
-0.0619753636,
0.3263684809,
-0.0727775171,
0.1322632283,
1.0101891756,
-0.551076293,
1.1612900496,
-0.5793165565,
-0.0951076373,
0.5834931731,
0.0685551092,
0.2311193794,
-0.0376257673,
-0.1419539005,
0.1121278778,
0.1373723298,
-0.3689393997,
-0.7312150598,
0.5283191204,
-0.7094417214,
-0.4859351516,
-0.0619523861,
-0.3983720243,
-0.500664115,
-0.1571345031,
0.1096013933,
0.8521987796,
-0.1351187676,
0.2856464982,
0.7940376401,
-0.0713611469,
0.7068936229,
0.6971609592,
-0.1185009181,
-0.1468131393,
0.9687322378,
0.1977324635,
0.3695175946,
0.2020008415,
0.689376235,
-0.418441087,
-0.7298133969,
-0.429897815,
0.0578629412,
-0.5064986348,
0.0224965047,
-0.6663895845,
-0.1447408646,
-0.455907315,
0.1306488067,
-0.5590580106,
-0.3392852843,
-0.2915468812,
-0.3206572533,
0.6234627962,
0.5924505591,
0.0185471419,
0.7521389127,
-1.0497095585,
0.114727214,
0.6554177403,
0.115750052,
0.3095374107,
-0.8341782093,
-0.2307572216,
0.1469312757,
-0.2512916625,
-0.8874703646,
0.3238932192,
0.9085128903,
0.6603384614,
0.4891372621,
0.1340406388,
0.731249094,
-0.7306547761,
0.8581606746,
0.2779249847,
-1.3811286688,
0.9133307338,
-0.4099791944,
0.1535062343,
0.5559225678,
0.3767640293,
-0.3623257875,
-0.5723632574,
-0.5345176458,
-0.6161968112,
0.4486284256,
0.0605803505,
0.5707934499,
0.1562424302,
0.201738894,
0.3506873548,
0.2693638504,
-0.4994157851,
-0.1456107795,
-0.454505235,
-0.4531126618,
-0.2156442553,
-0.3114086688,
-0.0058401953,
-0.4290300012,
0.5012028217,
-0.2719474137,
-0.0045086769,
0.2674510181,
-0.1909024715,
0.2587145567,
0.1808135808,
0.1540537775,
0.3845669031,
-0.1175672561,
0.184673503,
0.2275994271,
-0.8128556609,
0.1126465946,
0.0065406342,
0.0788056552,
0.2209671587,
0.8344944715,
1.0088838339,
0.7751390934,
-0.8059757352,
0.797067225,
-0.0771872476,
-0.1727540046,
-0.2845193148,
0.0951277167,
0.1929747164,
0.4418986142,
0.2746792138,
-0.2361093462,
0.2294386923,
-0.5883538723,
0.2099850476,
0.1577502787,
-0.6332503557,
-0.411878854,
0.5346777439,
0.2887593806,
0.0290380437,
0.7234318852,
0.3433448076,
-0.5987817049,
0.2249172479,
0.5862556696,
0.8137071133,
-0.5997444391,
0.3493539095,
0.1502134949,
0.0255257096,
0.1531833112,
0.2304446548,
-0.334980607,
-0.5349419713,
-0.4183685482,
-0.76646626,
-0.5728939772,
0.1001629159,
-0.8396918774,
0.1310659796,
-0.3377962112,
-0.0422325172,
0.1298933178,
-0.3561047614,
-0.5265282989,
-0.0051412899,
0.2581664622,
0.7571793795,
-0.9876228571,
1.0559366941,
0.2642276287,
-0.2826625109,
-1.1597411633,
-0.0598044619,
-0.1022785679,
-0.7159866691,
0.5127097964,
0.0978196934,
-0.0359344631,
0.1512654275,
-0.5208576322,
-0.4924555123,
0.8853929043,
0.6437597871,
-0.7761487961,
0.0128240725,
-0.1531767249,
0.4138254225,
-0.3265382946,
0.3379392624,
0.5066028237,
0.1671912372,
0.2694361806,
-1.1819500923,
-0.4586474597,
0.1611832231,
-0.2959582508,
-0.0540639237,
-0.2987309098,
0.8355445862,
-0.2138881385,
-0.0867390335,
-0.136216864,
0.6619707346,
-0.197614193,
0.4589224458,
0.6611869931,
0.4745839238,
0.9667539597,
-0.0303417575,
0.8639489412,
0.126838848,
0.2104952186,
1.3218111992,
-0.2020216584,
1.3081976175,
0.3274000883,
-0.2359875739,
0.5410968661,
0.2441775352,
0.1377474964,
0.7972655892,
0.0446181409,
-0.5431076884,
-0.2207546979,
-0.267226845,
-0.4837823808,
0.8744204044,
0.31549263,
-0.1476840079,
-0.2001146972,
0.6146852374,
0.0095696272,
0.2229456604,
-0.1633120924,
1.1168366671,
0.1457481682,
-0.1670784652,
0.4989565611,
-0.5825558901,
0.7404994369,
-0.7831181884,
-0.1479871273,
0.0631532222,
0.0650645792,
-0.0982857198,
-0.5292130113,
0.2705948949,
0.0071104071,
-0.2049123794,
-0.2905780375,
0.4364388883,
-0.7839558721,
-0.3600751162,
0.5349223018,
0.5525265932,
0.2105851322,
-0.2731236219,
-0.4645818174,
0.0846596435,
0.0866677612,
-0.1016622335,
0.3373790979,
0.1770095229,
0.4196875989,
0.6889579296,
0.820730865,
0.1315838546,
0.3344866931,
0.6875477433,
0.8537721038,
-0.4483549297,
-0.5546404123,
-0.7995899916,
0.4221941531,
0.1088034809,
-0.0912873223,
0.7069861293,
0.5547825098,
0.5133328438,
-0.2217981517,
0.8976862431,
0.3389164805,
0.8118208647,
-0.7472006679,
0.8885771632,
-0.2838587165,
0.0297967847,
-0.4654432833,
-0.8527541757,
0.3726963401,
0.5988480449,
0.0065763495,
-0.3410397768,
0.4581451416,
0.46760571,
0.0293141175,
0.4633592963,
0.379961133,
0.2768351138,
0.5424867868,
0.4154366851,
1.0526001453,
-0.4236415923,
0.5138046741,
-0.3113003969,
-0.4255913198,
0.0756032914,
-0.7144550085,
-1.1665066481,
-0.8993254304,
-0.4729475081,
-0.1031206325,
-0.1471818537,
0.5196961164,
1.0152374506,
-0.6409689784,
-0.3178884685,
0.1746714264,
-0.1776728183,
-0.0690985844,
-0.2353985906,
0.407733351,
-0.4262957275,
-1.0100044012,
0.9888273478,
-0.1222114787,
0.4400096238,
-0.2084449381,
0.0046887267,
0.0473285988,
0.1216345951,
0.4657242596,
-0.0527489521,
-0.5658608675,
-0.3915781677,
-0.0965866745,
0.3129771054,
-0.3222427368,
0.7438644767,
-0.8365190029,
0.8629972935,
0.0623508878,
0.5270053744,
0.8031657934,
-0.2266627997,
0.711204648,
-0.880237937,
0.4579715729,
0.3582547903,
0.2980533242,
0.3545714915,
-0.1259764135,
0.19537884,
0.0421202593,
-0.2626847923,
-0.9973748326,
-0.0348703377,
-1.0665738583,
-0.2125736773,
0.9457628131,
-0.2961308658,
0.0260161478,
-0.1284395158,
-0.5056778193,
0.3832701147,
-0.4871650636,
0.4444231689,
0.6519857049,
0.1878704727,
-0.1918572634,
-0.7353630662,
0.6427833438,
0.309394151,
-0.4713839293,
0.1767424643,
0.097698845,
0.1990508437,
0.1079609096,
0.4213393331,
0.1535039842,
0.0227495227,
0.3281488717,
-0.1546786875,
-0.3286973238,
-0.4940367341,
-0.3617517352,
0.0685311928,
-0.0600843988,
-0.6988064051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07006v1
|
Context-dependent Instruction Tuning for Dialogue Response Generation
| 2023-11-13T01:25:30 | 2023-11-13T01:25:30 |
Jin Myung Kwak, Minseon Kim, Sung Ju Hwang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent language models have achieved impressive performance in natural
language tasks by incorporating instructions with task input during
fine-tuning. Since all samples in the same natural language task can be
explained with the same task instructions, many instruction datasets only
provide a few instructions for the entire task, without considering the input
of each example in the task. However, this approach becomes ineffective in
complex multi-turn dialogue generation tasks, where the input varies highly
with each turn as the dialogue context changes, so that simple task
instructions cannot improve the generation performance. To address this
limitation, we introduce a context-based instruction fine-tuning framework for
each multi-turn dialogue which generates both responses and instructions based
on the previous context as input. During the evaluation, the model generates
instructions based on the previous context to self-guide the response. The
proposed framework produces comparable or even outstanding results compared to
the baselines by aligning instructions to the input during fine-tuning with the
instructions in quantitative evaluations on dialogue benchmark datasets with
reduced computation budget.
|
[
-0.5127657056,
-0.810684979,
0.4944778085,
0.2925185263,
-0.2114161253,
-0.411557883,
-0.361307621,
-0.0770921409,
-0.1322781146,
0.7327239513,
-1.1877117157,
-0.25564906,
-0.3456113636,
0.2190695554,
0.0477563217,
1.1704868078,
0.2124212384,
0.1241117343,
-0.271292299,
-0.2424682826,
-0.8947954178,
-0.2341278195,
-0.7382262349,
-0.2632753551,
0.1932502836,
0.8405072689,
0.3087062538,
0.4620706737,
0.1862204522,
0.3112539351,
0.2106794715,
0.4055759609,
-0.4626266062,
0.3668273687,
-0.1973205507,
-0.0696600601,
-0.2978460193,
-0.1863064915,
0.6026059985,
0.5411226749,
-0.2134642601,
0.1435925066,
0.3194133043,
0.6231713295,
-0.6587111354,
0.1674744785,
-0.5686836839,
-0.1648171842,
0.1965509951,
-0.6810949445,
-0.5402738452,
-0.307159394,
0.4452132881,
-0.4882604182,
0.5243532658,
-0.1064074486,
0.2320328355,
0.2793492377,
-0.3023219705,
-0.5751950145,
-0.7587368488,
0.7904376388,
-0.9428650141,
-0.0322284363,
0.0915240645,
0.3730057776,
-0.4314922988,
-0.3628921509,
-0.4742568731,
0.0062448606,
-0.2578471899,
0.0384288393,
0.1381659359,
0.176205799,
0.2418218702,
0.0539970733,
-0.3521262407,
-0.0932219774,
0.0032551552,
-0.2674168646,
0.4152073562,
0.5484127998,
0.091410771,
-0.2748528123,
-0.3385653794,
-0.2248166353,
-0.7067283392,
0.2243804634,
0.163846001,
0.7858735323,
-0.1468775868,
0.3682041764,
-0.5607612729,
1.0454281569,
0.6133083105,
-0.2405054867,
0.0648959875,
-0.6826205254,
-0.3073331714,
0.3013167679,
0.7737895846,
0.5116437674,
-0.0110468594,
0.0041942247,
-0.1090350375,
-0.2148567736,
0.4692784548,
-1.1873193979,
-0.0314295068,
-0.0448184498,
-0.1144307926,
-0.0274345409,
-0.1973986477,
-0.7993599176,
-0.1374243051,
-0.5106124282,
0.3325823247,
-0.3189817667,
0.1777722836,
-0.0560447797,
0.222231403,
0.3552357852,
0.3379702568,
-1.1188737154,
0.3247321546,
0.4321083426,
0.4633221626,
-0.128475517,
-0.115698047,
-1.1821639538,
0.1410328597,
-0.0986227691,
0.714818716,
-0.7968097925,
-0.4886396527,
0.0730359033,
0.1838908643,
-0.2514045537,
-0.408364743,
0.3140576184,
-0.1774295121,
0.4902825058,
-0.2388989478,
-0.4111416936,
0.0699523762,
0.1032207757,
-0.441018939,
0.6714328527,
0.1413121074,
-0.6195746064,
0.2601825595,
-0.7769012451,
-0.8184270859,
-0.1127388477,
-0.193396017,
-0.3021512926,
0.21335572,
0.5027155876,
0.4779418707,
-0.3632382751,
0.1580932885,
-0.1590699703,
-0.3954254985,
0.0557566024,
-0.6615552902,
0.4731602371,
-0.0940226465,
-0.7132261992,
0.2962623239,
-0.8435233831,
0.2938779891,
-0.1625390649,
-0.3981655836,
-0.014992266,
0.148843199,
-0.2754382491,
0.1589540094,
0.1252520531,
-0.5484627485,
0.2543623447,
-0.5623217225,
0.3346413076,
0.5926629901,
0.263200134,
0.6072935462,
-0.18115291,
0.4077280164,
-0.051520247,
-0.0716872886,
-0.5828502774,
-0.3477562666,
-0.7998609543,
0.0918201581,
0.0070277476,
0.4465763271,
-0.7344115973,
0.1960819662,
-0.085194625,
-0.0631145388,
-0.5151820183,
0.0919548124,
0.7985576391,
0.9065781236,
0.5355127454,
-0.2677090168,
-0.4201590717,
-0.9916733503,
-0.2753921151,
0.1132461354,
-0.0432302579,
0.602445662,
0.0459681414,
0.0315150544,
0.8856131434,
-0.4848702848,
-0.0834500492,
-0.1367543042,
0.5633004308,
-0.1046308652,
0.6174849868,
0.2063317299,
-0.5030293465,
-0.4464718997,
-0.0051880595,
-0.245657295,
-0.2284573764,
-0.3934040368,
-0.2377698421,
0.3268123269,
0.4292371273,
-0.3465127945,
0.4448153973,
0.5380403996,
-0.1359977573,
0.5134023428,
-0.2092521191,
0.3248521984,
-1.0852628946,
-0.1337363869,
-0.1789469272,
-0.1640043408,
-0.73885113,
-0.2618886828,
-0.0087229181,
-0.034932144,
-0.4094800353,
0.4442759454,
-0.28521505,
0.0552813485,
-0.4285005331,
0.0702940598,
0.1485199928,
0.924039185,
0.0653395131,
0.9268937707,
0.3418022692,
-0.8725470901,
0.1350830793,
0.3099932075,
-0.3449703455,
0.6901388764,
-0.6138689518,
0.3653886914,
0.0062613115,
0.3913902938,
-0.9731872082,
-0.3900643587,
0.3636984229,
-0.2077655047,
0.5289348364,
-0.261246562,
-0.0810261965,
-0.0685650632,
-0.0117495516,
0.2671652138,
0.1320329159,
-0.5130104423,
0.682096839,
-0.060774453,
-0.4626161754,
-0.483899802,
-0.3139776886,
-0.3289284706,
-0.1147786081,
-0.5214262009,
0.4134098589,
-0.3502697945,
0.1629018933,
-0.3696800768,
-0.3778965771,
-0.0088150408,
-0.067297928,
0.1974570602,
0.0038548424,
-0.266941905,
0.0435029939,
0.4513923228,
-0.1437653005,
0.1200986207,
-0.2510287166,
0.449321121,
-0.0410252474,
-0.2848854959,
-0.6957070827,
0.6355162263,
0.6513492465,
-0.3018065393,
0.5506030321,
0.5405067205,
0.132204771,
-0.2652801275,
-0.3506952822,
-0.4101181626,
-0.4853709042,
0.3105535805,
-0.4393284619,
-0.8874952197,
0.1682152152,
-0.1861047,
0.3727218211,
0.1654977053,
0.7252707481,
-0.0662437156,
1.5125763416,
0.5103168488,
0.1503747702,
0.5354357362,
0.0510180853,
0.2825736403,
-1.016182065,
-0.1026744917,
-0.5202915668,
-0.2903469205,
-0.5705083013,
-0.1341600567,
0.3684023619,
-0.0713076293,
-0.2783721387,
0.3492991626,
-0.6398287416,
0.3435925841,
0.6216453314,
0.0421233848,
0.1284535825,
-0.1473977566,
-0.1162674725,
0.0638438314,
-0.9464423656,
-0.4828315079,
0.8539655209,
-0.2015664726,
0.6594234109,
-0.0521961525,
0.7605820298,
0.0995014906,
0.2142437249,
-0.636698842,
0.4538752735,
0.0062770476,
-0.3260347843,
-0.5207927227,
-0.5776996613,
-0.9105695486,
0.1897039115,
-0.1484719664,
-0.7650306225,
-0.0337800644,
0.42990309,
-0.7053379416,
-0.3816624582,
-1.0187895298,
1.0118609667,
-0.027158238,
-0.360517323,
-0.1221420541,
-0.6403209567,
0.1693860292,
0.1697001606,
0.0715281591,
-0.1154108867,
0.5769264698,
0.4402079582,
-0.5166707039,
1.0692662001,
-0.3789723814,
-0.1933116317,
0.3605616987,
0.122719869,
0.6106881499,
0.317301333,
-0.0079078255,
-0.589517951,
0.0610164553,
-0.3070094287,
-0.9063668847,
0.97890836,
-0.4025969207,
-0.7975400686,
0.1632810831,
-0.5068753362,
-0.5760346055,
0.1710087508,
0.5174842477,
1.0628083944,
-0.2111249119,
0.2854089439,
0.6276211739,
-0.1902036816,
0.4724670649,
0.6261595488,
0.3026511967,
-0.256526649,
0.9169954062,
-0.2728856504,
0.4783782959,
0.395524472,
0.1919538826,
-0.2548502386,
-0.2193275988,
-0.8773937821,
-0.2486574054,
-0.4542163312,
-0.4358905554,
-0.31132707,
0.0953583866,
-0.3022404015,
-0.1997835487,
-0.3974251747,
-0.2108120769,
-0.2924909294,
0.1854903847,
0.1639427394,
0.6238558292,
0.3643875122,
0.4944917262,
-0.7547656298,
0.4263086021,
0.6764301062,
0.4775908589,
0.0021705013,
-0.4054258764,
-0.3040755689,
0.5565885305,
-0.5082315207,
-0.7148219347,
0.0793064684,
0.3786853552,
0.3789685071,
0.2568321228,
0.3100574017,
0.8374052644,
-0.8741129637,
0.7177990675,
0.1100818068,
-1.0536911488,
0.7254716158,
-0.2303318828,
0.961437881,
0.6339495182,
-0.1137447432,
-0.2397376299,
-0.4879145622,
-0.3495207727,
-0.7669775486,
1.1827869415,
0.3128559589,
0.4845791757,
-0.100429453,
0.1600067765,
0.1913219392,
0.1462480426,
-0.2667506635,
-0.1090976149,
-0.3457339108,
-0.1772375852,
-0.0163937975,
-0.0599890016,
-0.4255471826,
-0.1624528915,
0.5146359205,
-0.5889723301,
0.3555660546,
0.1764142662,
-0.0510520637,
-0.2566773891,
0.4643037915,
0.9847850204,
0.4508854449,
-0.0684406161,
-0.2080568224,
0.2728125155,
-0.109321788,
-0.0915338323,
0.0053504151,
-0.1080988944,
-0.0979626179,
0.2777731717,
1.1952915192,
0.7060021758,
-0.5453245044,
0.3579590619,
-0.3011195958,
-0.186384663,
-0.0255430713,
0.5871410966,
0.025428595,
0.1933787614,
0.1965775937,
0.1845054775,
0.2468655258,
-0.392947942,
0.189511627,
0.4883834124,
-0.3497413099,
-0.2110468596,
0.25983271,
0.5156875849,
-0.4660615921,
0.537696898,
-0.2198358476,
-0.4111727178,
0.5003854036,
0.6817362309,
0.9133444428,
-0.1664644331,
0.3025430739,
0.5147516131,
-0.1551171392,
0.1577958614,
0.1326039433,
-0.4789513648,
-0.6054495573,
-0.6242157817,
-0.6114838719,
-0.4558722079,
0.1962129772,
-0.894888103,
-0.0652166605,
-0.3287087977,
-0.0644409209,
-0.0146398023,
-0.2368860394,
-0.741725266,
0.3758929074,
0.0418328717,
0.5636828542,
-0.3931870461,
0.5215591788,
0.4660923183,
-0.0347399227,
-0.7961102128,
0.3293585777,
-0.0348451808,
-0.4366662204,
0.2092893422,
0.4292693138,
-0.6884559989,
-0.0402191393,
-0.6013581157,
-0.7016738653,
0.8445743322,
0.3202559352,
-0.4420460761,
0.0557590239,
0.1096529812,
0.5488971472,
-0.9016227126,
0.1156455651,
0.7085985541,
0.2870902419,
0.2586083412,
-0.8441463113,
0.1772720218,
-0.2262183726,
0.1934881359,
0.2341118008,
-0.5366791487,
0.3473668993,
-0.1282966584,
-0.39109236,
0.204367578,
0.5958243608,
0.0755393356,
0.1115503386,
0.3819664121,
0.0962514877,
0.4319800735,
-0.0650762469,
0.9817011952,
-0.583080411,
0.0711822361,
1.6228370667,
-0.0905744806,
0.6497746706,
0.4031277001,
0.3550684452,
0.6429595351,
0.2852541506,
0.3950468898,
0.7443333864,
0.0052509615,
-0.3129263818,
-0.3421190381,
-0.0484665781,
-0.1771550328,
0.6564867496,
0.4136241674,
-0.2081665993,
-0.2937309444,
-0.0024883233,
-0.2438531965,
0.03786017,
-0.1578024626,
1.0797196627,
-0.2782650292,
-1.2397793531,
0.9411678314,
-0.0173929613,
0.3300098479,
-0.5877357721,
-0.3288376927,
-0.31322366,
0.0447874554,
-0.0543328114,
-0.4816552401,
0.3225224912,
0.1456326246,
-0.4766295552,
-0.3197700083,
0.2959267199,
-0.5807708502,
-0.2574646175,
-0.0387484878,
0.1654627323,
-0.3155840337,
0.1453614682,
-0.5517805219,
-0.0115520321,
0.2869338691,
-0.4408733547,
0.3636276126,
0.5414183736,
0.043715857,
0.6245835423,
0.4749220312,
-0.4593574107,
0.0233229566,
0.1578177065,
0.8493032455,
-0.4586496353,
-0.2778329551,
-0.5656760931,
0.7018751502,
-0.1186183468,
-0.6517950892,
0.4599681497,
0.2138788551,
0.787671268,
-0.0810954794,
0.712733686,
-0.0085138483,
0.4298394024,
-0.7405065894,
0.2390554696,
-0.4338626564,
0.2985793054,
-0.2232781798,
-0.895750463,
0.0732729658,
0.6078003645,
-0.273380965,
0.051431682,
0.5416679382,
0.9334567785,
-0.0831843466,
0.2210303545,
0.1387932152,
-0.004086243,
0.2395779192,
0.4521028697,
0.3865256906,
-0.1406497657,
0.5231372118,
-0.1037221551,
-0.123517707,
-0.3411178589,
-0.9028409719,
-0.8581011295,
-0.5811680555,
-0.1682338566,
-0.1427432001,
-0.0247710831,
0.8640863895,
0.9152231216,
-1.0691822767,
-0.2074763775,
-0.3047518134,
0.0056660087,
-0.3740115762,
-0.3097818494,
0.0635559559,
-0.820523262,
-0.8449375033,
0.740077734,
0.3810704052,
-0.1803834587,
-0.1462686211,
-0.3250294328,
0.0980957299,
0.3353159428,
0.6786730289,
0.2969922423,
-0.7879346013,
-0.5489931703,
0.0816427469,
-0.1381515861,
0.1654863805,
1.0515962839,
-0.7388271093,
0.9346554279,
0.237518549,
0.5689783096,
0.6013396382,
0.1127249599,
1.1297683716,
-1.1107696295,
-0.1300994158,
0.1106795967,
0.0074596363,
0.4743896723,
-0.2946414053,
0.1406107843,
-0.3588539362,
-0.4541573822,
-0.4569507539,
0.493162185,
-0.8996735811,
-0.1736454964,
0.9351248741,
-0.1151373461,
-0.0179674607,
0.0590478666,
-0.447969079,
0.3072755337,
-0.6408187151,
0.7161862254,
0.6040254831,
-0.5927782655,
-0.0798654258,
-0.3817026615,
0.8251462579,
0.6520766616,
-0.6298348904,
0.405685395,
0.6783387065,
0.1309220642,
0.0681665018,
0.4126491845,
0.2581483424,
0.3146487474,
-0.292673409,
-0.2495907992,
0.0921980143,
-0.4977412522,
-0.1145347878,
0.1194517612,
-0.1891934127,
-0.1792868525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06985v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06985v2
|
Large Language Models are In-context Teachers for Knowledge Reasoning
| 2023-11-12T23:14:43 | 2024-06-17T05:57:38 |
Jiachen Zhao, Zonghai Yao, Zhichao Yang, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting teaches large language models (LLMs) in
context to reason over queries that require more than mere information
retrieval. However, human experts are usually required to craft demonstrations
for in-context learning (ICL), which is expensive and has high variance. More
importantly, how to craft helpful reasoning exemplars for ICL remains unclear.
In this work, we investigate whether LLMs can be better in-context teachers for
knowledge reasoning. We follow the ``encoding specificity'' hypothesis in
human's memory retrieval to assume in-context exemplars at inference should
match the encoding context in training data. We are thus motivated to propose
Self-Explain to use one LLM's self-elicited explanations as in-context
demonstrations for prompting it as they are generalized from the model's
training examples. Self-Explain is shown to significantly outperform using
human-crafted exemplars and other baselines. We further reveal that for
in-context teaching, rationales by distinct teacher LLMs or human experts that
more resemble the student LLM's self-explanations are better demonstrations,
which supports our encoding specificity hypothesis. We then propose Teach-Back
that aligns the teacher LLM with the student to enhance the in-context teaching
performance. For example, Teach-Back enables a 7B model to teach the much
larger GPT-3.5 in context, surpassing human teachers by around 5% in test
accuracy on medical question answering.
|
[
-0.4492404759,
-0.5098800063,
0.6519879103,
-0.166027084,
-0.2218298614,
-0.3225311041,
-0.4882613122,
-0.1963489354,
-0.1199914292,
0.4448336661,
-0.1924721003,
-0.4636464715,
-0.2042353004,
0.0232330151,
-0.6692549586,
0.8007575274,
-0.1983005702,
0.1610989422,
-0.4126028419,
0.0279110465,
-0.6170229316,
-0.7714742422,
-0.5282739401,
-0.4424185157,
0.5581800342,
0.6938102841,
0.5005690455,
0.5088891387,
-0.0656185597,
0.1932261884,
0.2147210687,
0.0984137654,
-0.2722958922,
0.1785661429,
-0.7514169216,
-0.4502325058,
-0.1925342977,
0.018397931,
0.530508399,
0.7916303873,
-0.0610127412,
0.0123126125,
0.1139889508,
0.3862252235,
-0.4973127544,
-0.2484461367,
-0.7087473273,
0.0563873798,
0.43858248,
-0.2120405734,
-0.7115294337,
-0.202763468,
0.3493037224,
-0.5305990577,
0.1877715588,
0.0254430715,
0.5381525755,
0.1986148208,
-0.531073153,
-0.3824259639,
-0.448076129,
0.5723921061,
-0.8206524253,
0.2692629993,
0.369587332,
0.4083862305,
-0.1539264321,
-0.7582554221,
-0.7099281549,
-0.0165850185,
-0.1431388557,
0.168739602,
0.3456920087,
0.051751595,
0.3819293678,
0.4133910239,
-0.3366223574,
0.2094479799,
-0.1606477797,
0.001577136,
0.4298019707,
0.0474900045,
0.1135684997,
-0.0722029507,
-0.5695313215,
-0.1071883142,
-0.9932000637,
0.0687432289,
0.1388674825,
0.1069696173,
-0.0437198207,
0.1372239441,
-0.0390827432,
0.9571040273,
0.0650703833,
-0.0395769402,
-0.3203944862,
-0.1024336591,
-0.3492974341,
0.1685964316,
0.5166977644,
0.1952213496,
0.4457484484,
-0.2155037522,
0.027870113,
-0.1789332479,
0.1883978546,
-0.7065040469,
-0.234925881,
0.0991818458,
-0.3377373815,
-0.0725833178,
-0.1127709448,
-0.6443727016,
-0.1402521729,
-0.3639260232,
0.7678986788,
-0.3160150647,
-0.237063691,
0.2801442444,
-0.1312782168,
0.3398174345,
0.27166906,
-1.062055707,
0.259953469,
0.3945973814,
0.3755690753,
-0.1728260666,
-0.512804389,
-0.2656672895,
0.4358095229,
-0.5427881479,
0.7059575319,
-0.4803849459,
-0.2809563279,
-0.0391776972,
-0.0682856515,
-0.0715843514,
-0.5219415426,
0.242951721,
-0.4354180098,
0.5179000497,
-0.6601497531,
-0.8716012239,
-0.2352369726,
0.3212156594,
-0.1934782714,
0.7569266558,
0.2127246261,
-0.4894391298,
0.4883921742,
-0.3858349621,
-0.4157021344,
-0.1509488821,
-0.5137004256,
0.0887273699,
-0.1433814764,
0.6332565546,
0.8086621761,
-0.3707298636,
0.4821440578,
-0.1164198816,
-0.569296062,
0.4317278266,
-0.4602564871,
0.4839886129,
0.0690296367,
-0.6472306848,
-0.019570766,
-0.3735691607,
0.1652104855,
0.0572757646,
-0.2628224194,
-0.3885811865,
-0.1088847369,
-0.6413002014,
0.360158354,
-0.2024638951,
-0.1306530684,
0.4384197295,
-0.4206501544,
0.3879927695,
0.745379746,
0.0635390952,
0.4691931307,
-0.2504132688,
0.5019347072,
-0.0403779447,
-0.0310825203,
-0.4525275826,
-0.2744616866,
-0.4473707378,
-0.2315183729,
-0.0010318002,
-0.0174033195,
-0.6614810824,
-0.0746783763,
-0.2194253951,
-0.0644861087,
-0.407530427,
0.1760917753,
0.6386373043,
1.1010241508,
0.4539086223,
-0.1432450712,
-0.444096148,
-0.8370427489,
-0.5739395022,
-0.0496229045,
0.0912185833,
0.2641768754,
0.4688820839,
0.2018475085,
1.0594643354,
-0.2085505128,
0.2066129744,
-0.2641592622,
-0.2668808103,
0.2588691413,
0.4237955213,
0.5328463316,
-0.5894601345,
-0.5027246475,
-0.1562322825,
-0.8715491295,
0.0595340133,
-0.2397782356,
-0.3468407691,
0.0549345091,
0.4451241493,
-0.3995443583,
0.3365453482,
0.2369783074,
-0.4503420293,
0.5988608003,
-0.3536476195,
0.1384815127,
-0.9166699052,
-0.1656685919,
-0.4426758885,
-0.2875809669,
-0.4814780056,
0.1728163213,
0.0687186569,
-0.1828927845,
-0.2775484025,
0.7042690516,
-0.5100127459,
-0.4044402838,
-0.3614624441,
0.4046261311,
0.2576803267,
0.5846903324,
0.146787405,
0.9203300476,
0.6944515109,
-0.8831869364,
0.1864696592,
0.1205400079,
-0.4264824092,
0.5657761693,
-0.5185893774,
0.3068007827,
0.1041966006,
0.4330893159,
-0.8562190533,
-0.2697144449,
-0.0114337001,
-0.3341771066,
0.3463900685,
-0.3165045977,
-0.4123921692,
-0.6276564598,
-0.0044773221,
0.2606986761,
0.5979460478,
-1.2745988369,
0.4120799303,
-0.0193277951,
0.3494631052,
-0.6476076841,
-0.7595290542,
-0.0465434827,
-0.3593237102,
-0.4198819995,
0.3426154554,
-0.1926403046,
-0.1315449625,
-0.0197935198,
-0.2727322876,
-0.0321820416,
0.0738127083,
0.1357645988,
0.021575924,
-0.329159528,
0.559880197,
0.1367951035,
-0.0965495482,
0.3398070335,
-0.6577804089,
0.4279299378,
-0.2577258945,
-0.6291172504,
-0.4445921779,
0.3202182651,
0.3660338223,
0.0542279184,
0.7984651327,
0.3023919761,
-0.1422807425,
-0.349442184,
-0.6130850911,
-0.5814158916,
-0.4635373652,
0.1731619537,
-0.4912263453,
-0.6913655996,
0.370364815,
-0.0535375178,
-0.1146130189,
0.2432860881,
0.5996200442,
-0.0990543216,
1.0159267187,
0.1613762379,
0.0218151733,
0.2087413669,
-0.6107707024,
0.134766981,
-0.9199496508,
-0.2622093558,
-0.0401087143,
-0.1310544014,
-0.0155163435,
-0.2647295892,
0.209679544,
0.2438734323,
-0.4780475199,
0.1236850843,
-0.7392486334,
0.7349457145,
0.4752296805,
0.0768305138,
0.2160442173,
0.109434098,
-0.3140916824,
0.2074018121,
-1.0017383099,
-0.6412149668,
0.9043824673,
0.1875212789,
0.8276392817,
0.0790136456,
0.7561300993,
-0.1713207215,
0.2741710842,
-0.4521772563,
0.4959541857,
0.0400288627,
-0.756765008,
-0.3119955957,
-0.0615427531,
-0.8655621409,
0.4288475215,
0.0473509878,
-0.7263888717,
0.0842861608,
0.4928618073,
-0.3714148402,
0.56685853,
-0.9291107655,
0.9602719545,
-0.2726214528,
-0.3205018044,
-0.3332234621,
-0.5287558436,
0.2235693187,
0.2765217125,
0.2774705887,
0.232032612,
0.06289047,
0.6710490584,
-0.5137585402,
0.9670538902,
-0.3984607458,
-0.2879272997,
0.6090573668,
0.2066636235,
0.4286267459,
0.0531397536,
-0.2031874061,
-0.4764593244,
-0.0399518013,
-0.4933282733,
-1.0500943661,
0.8782218099,
-0.6880312562,
-1.1747112274,
0.1135718748,
-0.5808100104,
-0.3097263873,
-0.172219947,
0.4127372503,
0.7675918341,
0.4857239127,
0.0961164311,
0.7179728746,
-0.1650826335,
0.2681308091,
0.5112971067,
-0.2382583916,
-0.2232350409,
0.8854473233,
0.1465605795,
0.6436849833,
0.3558905125,
0.5977992415,
-0.3063635528,
-0.3493950069,
-0.4645132422,
0.1287991852,
-1.273478508,
-0.142508164,
-0.6852655411,
-0.0439422019,
-0.3413212895,
-0.6698176861,
-0.1605837941,
-0.4147500992,
-0.2259377837,
-0.2426466048,
0.3732542098,
0.8728339076,
-0.061776761,
0.3570199907,
-0.272927314,
0.1362073869,
0.8102414012,
0.1855379641,
0.6490435004,
-0.8634167314,
-0.3214380145,
-0.0157912932,
-0.1963495016,
-0.9419608712,
0.2090550959,
0.0636879057,
0.7416528463,
0.607403934,
0.0295160431,
1.0123778582,
-0.1157362387,
0.8864948153,
0.0265490804,
-1.0516469479,
0.6931377649,
-0.2138139457,
0.2557695806,
0.2041048706,
0.4681350589,
-0.5125979781,
-0.4558463693,
-0.6887367964,
-0.836304307,
0.6624030471,
-0.1628685445,
0.193712309,
-0.3181816339,
0.8017122746,
0.4167619944,
-0.0052380427,
-0.8072597384,
-0.1117220744,
-0.4056523442,
-0.2691754401,
0.137347877,
-0.3618010581,
-0.166054979,
-0.4177016616,
0.6424928904,
-0.3953092098,
0.3745985329,
0.6375573874,
-0.2301986068,
0.0678910315,
0.4258112013,
0.4619323313,
0.9428380132,
0.093469426,
0.6436800957,
0.7530812025,
-0.0341365002,
0.1789794713,
-0.3586859405,
0.173196733,
-0.3237234652,
0.753849864,
0.6239640713,
0.4908809662,
-0.5628585815,
0.6118499637,
0.0343590267,
-0.0680404231,
-0.3452530503,
0.3649854958,
0.2373946309,
0.3734404445,
0.455010891,
-0.4570171237,
-0.0538533106,
-0.6600732803,
0.061337579,
0.2662598193,
-0.2623611391,
-0.2698272765,
0.5580130219,
-0.0996067151,
-0.1564575434,
0.5802372098,
-0.0740864426,
-0.6917248368,
0.7644178867,
1.0575045347,
0.3756404519,
-0.1422309577,
0.0068955622,
0.4010937512,
-0.1459903717,
-0.1768345684,
0.3126014173,
-0.5167611241,
-0.7636786103,
-0.4819076657,
0.035641782,
-0.4375085533,
-0.0912534893,
-0.8034899235,
0.1085771024,
-0.4043923914,
0.1786413342,
-0.2391615808,
-0.1720036566,
-0.622921586,
0.3608904481,
0.0720304251,
0.8302523494,
-0.5640117526,
0.9371193051,
0.5823265314,
-0.4015289545,
-1.2590186596,
-0.0678272322,
-0.404837966,
-0.8794423342,
0.8018396497,
0.1702535301,
-0.0014266761,
0.0187423304,
-0.7969360352,
-0.7708784938,
1.2801891565,
0.5497305393,
-0.4956960678,
-0.0861091688,
-0.2774350643,
0.5104146004,
-0.797254622,
0.4741095603,
0.2530936003,
0.1700622439,
0.1546803713,
-0.5888564587,
0.3307124078,
0.32421422,
-0.1197438911,
-0.1483766735,
-0.539471209,
0.7045038939,
-0.5669016838,
0.0143984184,
-0.1519678682,
0.6736367345,
0.2729600668,
0.2738904357,
0.4727295637,
0.3112500906,
0.796056807,
0.2501283884,
1.3067024946,
-0.1257576048,
0.1307412535,
1.3261971474,
0.0251797568,
0.7135525346,
0.4788171649,
-0.0329783522,
0.9546508789,
0.5687373281,
0.2080110461,
0.4540523291,
0.0441562682,
-0.1271131337,
-0.5396360159,
0.0946139842,
-0.4603345096,
0.2449645549,
0.3195691109,
-0.4711175561,
-0.1021481901,
0.3719426692,
0.0483224839,
0.1977181286,
-0.5309278369,
0.5840981007,
0.178449735,
-0.9883301854,
0.8556650877,
-0.4669815898,
0.295971334,
-0.3043480814,
0.0613789111,
-0.2031267434,
0.1828429252,
-0.2489416599,
-1.0097498894,
0.0910683274,
-0.1970160604,
-0.1876318753,
-0.3005492985,
0.5406709313,
-0.609077692,
0.1827452481,
0.352873683,
0.2207922637,
0.4459445775,
0.0764007792,
-0.3860556781,
-0.4548200965,
-0.1519189775,
-0.2028181404,
0.3903867304,
0.4781955183,
-0.1450844854,
0.889674902,
0.3964860141,
-0.1306690872,
-0.0093521159,
0.4243576825,
0.9997345209,
-0.7690751553,
-0.3659133315,
-0.9186618924,
0.3841913044,
-0.0583625697,
-0.1376599073,
0.7196745872,
0.3319855332,
0.8837146759,
-0.2176703513,
0.5906550884,
0.2109316885,
0.4078717828,
-0.652562499,
0.4649104178,
-0.4597214162,
0.3181438744,
-0.1742021739,
-0.4466789067,
0.1099870726,
0.7477063537,
-0.5842196345,
0.1537032276,
0.9188449979,
0.5243114233,
-0.0549429059,
0.183141306,
0.605840683,
0.2413088232,
0.3207152188,
0.7236898541,
0.9953698516,
-0.2374858558,
0.5274690986,
-0.233398959,
0.0238386802,
-0.1026425213,
-0.7860971093,
-1.3545640707,
-0.6367513537,
-0.2470722049,
-0.225253284,
0.0798557028,
1.0520842075,
0.9729886651,
-0.5813771486,
-0.1623749584,
-0.1256863177,
0.4139527082,
-0.2969102561,
-0.2048089951,
0.5877189636,
-0.4834212065,
-0.2978873253,
0.4753991365,
-0.0130395237,
0.125176385,
-0.370020926,
-0.2813721597,
-0.1180581227,
-0.0444141775,
0.65269804,
0.1863141656,
-0.9782786369,
-0.5556365848,
-0.0741181299,
0.1115703508,
0.0509034805,
1.0167365074,
-1.1883493662,
0.5303257108,
0.1120696887,
0.5657634735,
0.6033745408,
-0.1778112352,
0.6976872683,
-0.6635482311,
0.1091333032,
0.1864109784,
0.3772315681,
0.3813520968,
-0.4850786924,
0.4818972051,
0.0168068055,
-0.6567224264,
-0.6300922036,
0.2450349927,
-0.5040690303,
-0.3940679431,
1.1943933964,
-0.459828198,
-0.2999888659,
-0.0688655823,
-0.1908644736,
0.2613995373,
-0.0753827617,
0.6949111223,
0.6501106024,
-0.1225667894,
-0.2899472713,
-0.3900735676,
0.3859294951,
0.6086494923,
-0.6461197138,
0.1759406626,
-0.0330943614,
0.4364392459,
-0.3158015609,
0.6243463159,
0.006423668,
0.3635881841,
-0.0821384043,
0.0470749401,
-0.1211155728,
-0.3287092745,
-0.3055151105,
0.0198859777,
0.2360473275,
0.0767003819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06899v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06899v6
|
Flames: Benchmarking Value Alignment of LLMs in Chinese
| 2023-11-12T17:18:21 | 2024-05-22T06:18:41 |
Kexin Huang, Xiangyang Liu, Qianyu Guo, Tianxiang Sun, Jiawei Sun, Yaru Wang, Zeyang Zhou, Yixu Wang, Yan Teng, Xipeng Qiu, Yingchun Wang, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) across various
regions underscores the urgent need to evaluate their alignment with human
values. Current benchmarks, however, fall short of effectively uncovering
safety vulnerabilities in LLMs. Despite numerous models achieving high scores
and 'topping the chart' in these evaluations, there is still a significant gap
in LLMs' deeper alignment with human values and achieving genuine harmlessness.
To this end, this paper proposes a value alignment benchmark named Flames,
which encompasses both common harmlessness principles and a unique morality
dimension that integrates specific Chinese values such as harmony. Accordingly,
we carefully design adversarial prompts that incorporate complex scenarios and
jailbreaking methods, mostly with implicit malice. By prompting 17 mainstream
LLMs, we obtain model responses and rigorously annotate them for detailed
evaluation. Our findings indicate that all the evaluated LLMs demonstrate
relatively poor performance on Flames, particularly in the safety and fairness
dimensions. We also develop a lightweight specified scorer capable of scoring
LLMs across multiple dimensions to efficiently evaluate new models on the
benchmark. The complexity of Flames has far exceeded existing benchmarks,
setting a new challenge for contemporary LLMs and highlighting the need for
further alignment of LLMs. Our benchmark is publicly available at
https://github.com/AIFlames/Flames.
|
[
0.1666466594,
-0.2702990174,
0.2728299499,
0.2700016797,
-0.2267292142,
-0.0517168976,
-0.0781862885,
-0.5165423155,
-0.0982647091,
0.4945912361,
-0.338298291,
-0.5470721126,
-0.4666796029,
-0.2321454734,
-0.1881964803,
0.9626759291,
0.088417843,
0.0040989071,
-0.1216538027,
-0.2579919994,
-0.2716962099,
-0.4261211455,
-0.6576555967,
-0.0629450008,
0.910934329,
0.1592642218,
0.9959315658,
0.9059149623,
0.8974553347,
0.3103150427,
-0.044194445,
0.0893042311,
-0.6324917674,
0.145225361,
0.1077114418,
-0.1595406681,
-0.5945729017,
0.1800910383,
0.3706788719,
0.2642088234,
0.0430664197,
-0.0345667005,
0.1323482543,
0.6888735294,
-0.7027690411,
-0.0834286511,
-0.8056265116,
-0.0201686062,
-0.3641409576,
-0.0926258937,
-0.4183540046,
-0.9186269045,
-0.0332677364,
-0.5255612135,
-0.2555778921,
-0.0068404791,
1.0246918201,
0.3893510103,
-0.5483188629,
-0.4391559958,
-0.3801910281,
0.9329372048,
-0.8634216189,
0.0506705567,
-0.1497719288,
0.5096653104,
-0.1501828879,
-0.7197915912,
-0.1888735294,
-0.3197165132,
-0.0852437466,
0.0716254041,
-0.0621823817,
0.1856803149,
0.220807299,
0.2685442567,
-0.6151767969,
0.3572402894,
-0.0671373904,
-0.4259780943,
1.1426156759,
0.5676574707,
0.3319284022,
-0.1750704646,
-0.6384139657,
-0.2312903553,
-0.8914664388,
0.4090622067,
0.8536881804,
0.495858252,
-0.0894256756,
0.3628155887,
0.1212886423,
0.5733251572,
-0.3352381289,
-0.2853840888,
0.0641998574,
-0.0729737878,
-0.1364125758,
0.0821189061,
0.9038811922,
0.8615676165,
0.4027776122,
-0.0724231377,
-0.2639668882,
0.0897989571,
0.2324883342,
-0.9063984752,
-0.314750284,
0.1991398185,
-0.395627737,
-0.7903470993,
-0.1052298695,
-0.6679573059,
-0.8752320409,
0.0503406674,
0.2917487621,
-0.4440147579,
-0.096973516,
-0.0553669296,
0.094954066,
0.3879671693,
0.4794797301,
-1.0800896883,
-0.0960102901,
0.8066671491,
0.6853981614,
-0.2194824219,
-0.1976458579,
-0.6808086634,
-0.1014129668,
-0.3976981938,
0.5041819811,
-0.4462355077,
-0.2391394228,
-0.022716213,
-0.2564318478,
0.2496755719,
-0.3513769507,
1.0442034006,
-0.4263477623,
-0.0435557254,
-0.756705761,
-0.5461881161,
-0.2505544126,
0.2610281706,
-0.5246302485,
1.0331802368,
-0.1281689405,
-0.7063881159,
0.3567256927,
-0.2663327157,
-0.3882805705,
0.0929397419,
-0.1936917603,
-0.5436187387,
0.0340782702,
-0.17451258,
0.4458897114,
-0.4493076801,
0.3631593287,
-0.7140772343,
-0.6322318316,
0.2730904818,
-0.9775884151,
1.0518772602,
0.5604037642,
-0.1324181855,
0.4780873358,
-0.4559580386,
0.1993299574,
0.1082843319,
-0.0098892767,
-0.3226025701,
0.1664728075,
0.2267602831,
0.2615178525,
0.4725001752,
-0.2411150932,
0.0723769292,
-0.2812393606,
0.2405602336,
1.1169238091,
-0.3284702003,
0.1335858256,
-0.6627432108,
0.1906092912,
-0.0504615977,
0.3735083342,
-0.1134439781,
-0.230877474,
-0.4921606779,
-0.240855217,
0.0553275459,
0.4651744068,
-0.4062527418,
0.6566427946,
-0.204832375,
-0.7813497186,
-0.5829178691,
0.2487354875,
0.4709069729,
0.422503829,
-0.0117462697,
-0.0556567498,
-0.2293682694,
-0.6756778955,
-0.6322425604,
-0.4249014556,
-0.1387622952,
0.2389204055,
0.1877913177,
0.1088321656,
0.627941668,
-0.3783527315,
-0.1868328005,
0.1538911164,
-0.004154712,
-0.0395439789,
0.3971139491,
0.6770355701,
-0.8631868362,
-0.6418892741,
0.0786752403,
-1.0163277388,
-0.2509463727,
-0.0906542912,
-0.0182946082,
0.0386944413,
0.388268739,
0.0303834453,
0.1208558455,
0.6371952891,
-0.3803744614,
0.4661685228,
0.1795280576,
0.3162684441,
-0.9947651029,
0.2171659917,
0.0457130298,
0.0788385421,
-0.6719745398,
0.1573671699,
0.2711036801,
0.0716928765,
-0.9959158301,
0.7499172688,
-0.2543992698,
-0.0534122586,
-0.1138514057,
0.3634738326,
-0.0791427568,
0.380397886,
-0.1138618588,
0.6840596199,
0.452155441,
-0.3174273372,
0.9935056567,
-0.2360418439,
-0.2934928834,
0.7184087038,
-0.5434232354,
0.0013401874,
0.1714256853,
-0.1673354656,
-1.0330220461,
-0.2233701497,
0.0625735149,
-0.2364132851,
0.0662455186,
-0.0882550329,
-0.5399560332,
-0.0320912115,
-0.6827293634,
0.3921868801,
0.6772682071,
-0.5061753988,
0.3584073186,
0.2032454908,
0.0473271944,
-0.817012012,
-0.3457211256,
0.1564733237,
-0.8252635002,
-0.9659990072,
0.2696366012,
-0.1628368646,
-0.4823132753,
-0.0950424746,
-0.0633099005,
0.358250767,
0.4405892789,
0.1959602535,
0.3282901943,
-0.2249206752,
-0.1102534831,
-0.0876332149,
-0.1776886284,
0.1368025392,
0.0310517605,
-0.0625642911,
-0.4240700603,
-0.5970091224,
-0.1852682978,
-0.1332809776,
0.7632012367,
0.0645687729,
0.5363053679,
0.3725118935,
-0.5063452125,
0.0805090368,
-0.6157944202,
0.0752695948,
-0.5942263603,
0.0839821249,
-0.15054892,
-0.8030639887,
0.8218160868,
-0.0603689142,
0.4545323849,
0.3581537604,
0.3286892176,
-0.1253140122,
0.9463866949,
0.3547757268,
-0.2734895349,
0.2692325413,
0.3264554739,
0.0885012671,
-0.7302662134,
-0.2372515947,
-0.4570872784,
-0.3862866759,
-0.6462846398,
-0.235739246,
0.4726121426,
0.1423785537,
-0.3488831222,
0.3415669501,
-0.4642378092,
0.7163258791,
0.0522552878,
-0.1119196638,
0.2098673433,
-0.427274555,
-0.1788979173,
-0.4324390292,
-0.3029435873,
-0.795407176,
0.9704954028,
0.5380674601,
1.0415169001,
0.2950986326,
0.6322429776,
0.228837803,
0.5769687891,
-0.6201505661,
0.4550564587,
-0.3154979944,
-0.6098662019,
-0.5235487223,
-0.4998854995,
-0.7024302483,
0.3660903573,
0.0288397521,
-0.6908792257,
-0.1814526469,
-0.0521844588,
-0.5427578092,
0.408198297,
-0.5942468643,
1.1434189081,
-0.9013515115,
-0.653198123,
0.224571228,
-0.6663131118,
0.7065508366,
-0.1005962491,
0.096396938,
-0.5528638363,
0.02289683,
0.4910929799,
-0.2753211856,
0.8750029206,
-0.0711757541,
-0.566097796,
0.1120000929,
0.0015111249,
0.6682831645,
-0.1461434662,
-0.5112504363,
0.0454403237,
-0.0812433586,
-0.4974655211,
-0.4857822955,
1.1041234732,
-0.5998725891,
-0.5038169622,
-0.7120340466,
-0.5517276525,
-0.0722418949,
0.2869590819,
0.3138689101,
0.1493743807,
-0.5280390382,
0.0819734037,
0.8181390166,
-0.4758011997,
0.5110064149,
0.4769968092,
-0.1833287925,
-0.3356671035,
1.0468887091,
-0.0772987008,
0.3706317842,
0.1641983539,
0.0418259539,
-0.5014406443,
-0.4348043799,
-0.4197305739,
-0.0661878884,
-0.9379933476,
-0.4092998505,
-0.0369371995,
-0.5487859845,
-0.3066291809,
-0.7310717106,
-0.4367623627,
0.1008679047,
-0.227105394,
0.016342001,
0.3900735676,
0.5142676234,
0.0455762558,
-0.0127789481,
-0.9255914092,
0.1743883193,
0.4197122455,
0.6170434952,
-0.0486006849,
-0.5846829414,
-0.1401241571,
-0.0182494763,
-0.4644011259,
-0.7299964428,
0.3584732115,
-0.3207281232,
0.6126417518,
0.7833852768,
0.629783988,
0.680814147,
-0.228844136,
0.901609242,
0.3002571762,
-1.0342124701,
0.2719011903,
-0.4451993108,
-0.1311701834,
0.6004632115,
0.1510403007,
-0.7382385731,
-0.4527134299,
-0.3787880838,
-0.5495904088,
0.6563161016,
0.3658384681,
0.2400476187,
0.2643563151,
0.1746695489,
-0.0380270183,
-0.0449340492,
-0.9000105262,
-0.4018909931,
-0.0281450003,
-0.2757237852,
-0.0753626823,
-0.1790002435,
-0.269389987,
0.0394626819,
0.4821581542,
-0.1082569286,
-0.1725595444,
-0.2835644484,
0.2003813684,
-0.4906384647,
0.2216251045,
0.7461557388,
0.1104741618,
-0.2123589814,
0.2031831145,
0.397277981,
-0.2315599918,
0.3409171402,
-0.0398170277,
0.0882793814,
-0.3948430717,
0.4792729318,
0.5685492158,
0.2924496233,
-0.5587821007,
0.5953543782,
-0.1081553772,
-0.0253608711,
-0.2004440874,
0.3649311066,
0.192032069,
0.1669990867,
0.1757639349,
0.0833684579,
0.0426931456,
-0.4410331547,
0.1246697009,
0.6788153648,
-0.451751709,
-0.1886473298,
0.8908618689,
0.5741128922,
-0.1594956964,
0.415371865,
-0.2198269069,
-0.4980276227,
0.6908684969,
0.0012411672,
1.2216494083,
-0.280947566,
-0.062399812,
0.178393811,
0.6291457415,
-0.0532095619,
0.1605441719,
0.1880263984,
-0.604549408,
-0.1794494092,
-0.4741040468,
-0.6097730994,
0.0441304035,
-0.5755748749,
0.7381036282,
-0.3522214592,
0.2825423777,
-0.2493624389,
0.2416172922,
-0.086680606,
0.2852107584,
0.3914260864,
0.7618250251,
-1.0714743137,
1.0679483414,
0.170158729,
-0.24886401,
-0.7459728718,
0.1744540781,
0.5202855468,
-0.7949201465,
0.452830404,
0.2738204896,
-0.1753122211,
-0.2174364477,
-0.4320807159,
-0.7157459259,
1.2438095808,
0.7435349822,
-0.4520075917,
-0.0355103984,
0.1419830322,
0.6628308296,
-0.0720732957,
0.3141990006,
0.4791018665,
0.6416205764,
0.4421655536,
-0.7271699309,
0.2755199671,
-0.3588386774,
0.0334172882,
0.141153872,
-0.9894726872,
0.5917331576,
-0.2411631048,
-0.2769863605,
0.197296977,
0.6482065916,
0.3931483328,
0.5334226489,
0.2764564753,
0.4872893095,
0.7148256302,
-0.3313503265,
0.6372666955,
-0.2020066828,
0.23599419,
0.5998898149,
-0.6817859411,
0.5600340962,
0.2313814163,
-0.1436951756,
0.033303149,
0.701844573,
-0.0011267251,
0.5129073858,
0.3586564362,
-0.2744301856,
-0.2475990057,
0.0429785959,
-0.4729506969,
0.1904689372,
0.2737997174,
-0.0791464597,
-0.1627968699,
-0.3151308298,
0.1242630035,
0.1858710945,
-0.0019662343,
0.7939329147,
0.1189166605,
-0.7110453844,
0.6959763765,
0.0551184751,
0.8269323111,
-0.7087067962,
0.1134763509,
-0.3655434549,
0.176653266,
-0.3940988183,
-1.0131547451,
0.3998868167,
0.2375344932,
0.380667448,
-0.3234536648,
0.4963660538,
-0.3142608106,
-0.2471508682,
0.4046641588,
-0.3045058548,
0.1500729322,
0.1928859055,
-0.7705357075,
0.5315444469,
0.0577964261,
-0.09892077,
0.5351014137,
0.6876711845,
0.0449359044,
0.7363064289,
0.5131721497,
-0.0701353252,
-0.0035362991,
-0.2245556861,
0.8224205375,
-0.7080444098,
-0.283531189,
-1.0912020206,
0.7106633782,
-0.0244253892,
-0.3540540636,
1.0378637314,
0.6203098893,
0.6816102862,
0.2272563577,
0.6906215549,
0.2059581578,
0.0972312167,
-0.7143525481,
0.9403833747,
-0.7348883152,
0.781401515,
-0.6321201921,
-0.811150372,
-0.4848355949,
0.3982629478,
-0.1265394241,
0.091219984,
0.3683683872,
0.7438262105,
0.1904128045,
-0.0075617093,
0.8417541981,
-0.2020324767,
0.623891592,
0.8546367288,
0.9671337008,
-0.6207337976,
0.6480001807,
-0.2145423889,
-0.0969775319,
-0.5253426433,
-1.3076658249,
-0.8386953473,
-0.4921531975,
-0.3123247623,
-0.3364460766,
-0.0406557173,
0.8570644259,
0.4196430445,
-0.8473970294,
-0.4162914753,
0.0925466567,
0.3558925092,
-0.3708263934,
-0.2130886465,
0.3358393312,
-0.3438429832,
-0.6781672239,
0.1619959027,
0.3985052705,
0.1519326568,
-0.3476679325,
-0.4475455582,
0.2814892828,
0.2655718327,
0.2793729603,
0.2528602779,
-1.0246047974,
-0.4213661849,
0.1416107118,
-0.6906933188,
-0.211466223,
0.5735431314,
-0.203657642,
0.5036395192,
0.4422211647,
0.5601585507,
-0.0611798503,
-0.0922020748,
0.4804127514,
-0.72311759,
-0.0765204132,
0.3731000721,
0.3095311224,
0.4346828461,
-0.6370937228,
0.3894212842,
0.1046780795,
-0.6270717382,
-1.0650770664,
0.2458886802,
-0.9103748202,
-0.1671316028,
1.0940487385,
-0.3845082223,
0.1637600064,
0.0477772169,
-0.144287914,
0.1958415806,
-0.3045886457,
0.9470665455,
0.8405350447,
0.0232719816,
-0.0210603047,
-0.1148191392,
0.7918842435,
0.4435518384,
-0.8934096694,
0.5736592412,
0.5276181698,
0.0863877013,
0.047672987,
0.3420758545,
-0.295437932,
0.358780086,
0.0512412824,
-0.0396777503,
0.0216940884,
-0.2637073398,
-0.5437071919,
0.1654062271,
0.2504065335,
0.0268618912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06898v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06898v1
|
Retrieval and Generative Approaches for a Pregnancy Chatbot in Nepali with Stemmed and Non-Stemmed Data : A Comparative Study
| 2023-11-12T17:16:46 | 2023-11-12T17:16:46 |
Sujan Poudel, Nabin Ghimire, Bipesh Subedi, Saugat Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The field of Natural Language Processing which involves the use of artificial
intelligence to support human languages has seen tremendous growth due to its
high-quality features. Its applications such as language translation, chatbots,
virtual assistants, search autocomplete, and autocorrect are widely used in
various domains including healthcare, advertising, customer service, and target
advertising. To provide pregnancy-related information a health domain chatbot
has been proposed and this work explores two different NLP-based approaches for
developing the chatbot. The first approach is a multiclass classification-based
retrieval approach using BERTbased multilingual BERT and multilingual
DistilBERT while the other approach employs a transformer-based generative
chatbot for pregnancy-related information. The performance of both stemmed and
non-stemmed datasets in Nepali language has been analyzed for each approach.
The experimented results indicate that BERT-based pre-trained models perform
well on non-stemmed data whereas scratch transformer models have better
performance on stemmed data. Among the models tested the DistilBERT model
achieved the highest training and validation accuracy and testing accuracy of
0.9165 on the retrieval-based model architecture implementation on the
non-stemmed dataset. Similarly, in the generative approach architecture
implementation with transformer 1 gram BLEU and 2 gram BLEU scores of 0.3570
and 0.1413 respectively were achieved.
|
[
0.0237137936,
-0.9865481257,
-0.083113499,
0.6152226925,
-0.259531498,
0.2414322346,
0.0134296604,
-0.5038023591,
0.3421234488,
0.2551358938,
-0.4132018387,
-0.244947046,
-0.5346366763,
0.0044089579,
-0.6967771649,
0.7810122371,
0.594720602,
0.2353249639,
-0.2391991168,
0.1697107404,
-0.5568016171,
-0.8647949696,
-0.5084370971,
-0.1922056973,
0.2310071886,
0.2723615766,
0.5906785727,
0.0891451314,
0.5328180194,
0.2748653293,
-0.3574443758,
-0.0148103628,
-0.4120085835,
0.1165826097,
0.228413105,
-0.4465138614,
-0.2261736989,
-0.3682856262,
0.3539305627,
0.7864166498,
-0.6437672377,
0.1289997548,
0.1239277869,
0.9359102845,
-0.5578965545,
0.2164381444,
-0.7093231082,
0.1546979547,
-0.0726402849,
-0.2058921903,
-0.7295714617,
-0.509585917,
0.1288466007,
-0.4623718262,
0.5704469085,
0.29654181,
0.7970875502,
0.3808016479,
-0.5003783703,
-0.4147750735,
-1.0208854675,
0.96739465,
-0.5939974785,
0.5144837499,
0.5560033917,
0.2375254482,
-0.378370136,
-0.4813899696,
-0.5524317622,
-0.3057940602,
-0.3345405161,
0.1606251597,
-0.5253568888,
-0.2218567133,
-0.190663591,
0.6061989665,
-0.9484049678,
0.2588149011,
-0.4174129069,
-0.2311023921,
0.507136941,
-0.06421756,
0.3041126132,
-0.494222194,
-0.4381000698,
-0.0363868549,
-0.7374102473,
-0.2646690011,
0.4493581355,
0.4542203546,
-0.2245824039,
0.8024414778,
-0.1372887492,
0.8474875093,
0.1249557063,
0.1325600445,
0.4337275028,
-0.350233525,
-0.2236313671,
-0.057586994,
0.8594508171,
-0.092751421,
0.2222344428,
0.0316710696,
0.231577009,
0.1811038405,
0.5520893335,
-0.5970715284,
-0.3240672648,
0.3150604665,
-0.7473940849,
-0.2687150538,
-0.4665735662,
-0.9581819177,
-0.3815807998,
-0.0360421129,
0.0055331998,
-0.8456407189,
-0.4713807404,
-0.063005276,
-0.0868173093,
0.6008225679,
0.3984608054,
-1.1677633524,
0.1212735623,
0.5011106133,
0.7675360441,
-0.319037348,
0.2058351487,
0.0964158773,
-0.1813580394,
-0.4907271862,
0.7673415542,
-0.2248216718,
-0.7514467835,
0.1065549925,
-0.2825816572,
-0.3057721257,
-0.8209508061,
0.6725648046,
-0.8462816477,
0.34250471,
0.2223396003,
-0.5873328447,
-0.1965614408,
0.2595072985,
-0.7207763195,
1.1106798649,
0.0661439747,
-0.7477812171,
0.4980928898,
-0.5107954144,
-0.9789243937,
0.3948871195,
-0.1266665012,
-0.5162547827,
-0.0120391687,
0.128388837,
0.4784815311,
-0.3669715822,
0.3636236191,
0.0544449426,
-0.139961645,
0.2048757523,
-0.5377238989,
0.8631727695,
0.0663043335,
0.0293811727,
0.2145800591,
-0.8675919175,
0.0579077043,
0.4005113542,
-0.3150616288,
-0.152604714,
0.2966194749,
0.4103201926,
0.0857445523,
0.1532068402,
-0.6858503222,
-0.0837492198,
-0.3713007569,
0.3864982426,
0.2979106009,
0.0267362278,
0.1208730489,
-0.3592227101,
0.4692917466,
0.2076622397,
0.5034219027,
0.2281495184,
-1.0045642853,
-0.6942972541,
-0.2522351146,
0.5086400509,
0.716753602,
-0.8641809225,
0.6436573863,
-0.0944192037,
-0.6438465714,
-0.7804512978,
-0.085514985,
0.447760582,
0.6972709894,
0.6248241663,
-0.4045516253,
-0.5801258087,
-0.8292199373,
0.1712418795,
-0.6220738888,
0.07393343,
0.1947309524,
0.3984075487,
0.066121161,
0.8358589411,
-0.7262614965,
-0.393553853,
-0.3672788143,
0.2346594781,
0.3448779583,
0.74802953,
0.7494233847,
-1.3018550873,
-0.569165349,
0.0023572927,
-0.7036097646,
0.3981348276,
0.3930226564,
-0.0241054874,
0.4350560009,
-0.161954686,
-0.6136648059,
0.8633886576,
0.5232001543,
-0.0247582253,
0.9028763175,
-0.3181732595,
0.1454714537,
-1.0827387571,
0.0930084214,
-0.0721968636,
-0.258040458,
-0.9384562373,
-0.2276018113,
0.0148552973,
-0.0692256838,
-0.7251523137,
0.3855012357,
-0.2882573307,
0.1682638079,
-0.2651119828,
-0.342684418,
-0.2229948342,
0.345009625,
0.2323625386,
0.9246968031,
0.6371617317,
-0.6308221221,
0.2857303619,
0.8601381183,
-0.3344355524,
0.7161160111,
-0.8032920957,
-0.0901894942,
-0.0243450329,
0.0996263176,
-1.0341761112,
-0.0633921847,
0.1903619021,
-0.7886679173,
0.3083899617,
-0.1467343122,
-1.0043720007,
-0.5667274594,
0.0464116856,
0.2578161955,
0.9790846705,
-0.5029136539,
0.334564358,
0.3747680783,
-0.2325475365,
-0.5249788165,
-0.729136467,
-0.0645397678,
-0.1817222536,
-0.2832246125,
0.290679127,
-0.0555994362,
0.1766710132,
-0.0788737833,
0.372516036,
-0.4452371001,
-0.1484868228,
0.1797941923,
0.5810841322,
-0.0932564586,
0.2157196403,
-0.0805584118,
-0.1666037291,
-0.1857954115,
0.1205626875,
0.8682655692,
0.156958282,
-0.3488637507,
-0.5504034162,
0.7446853518,
0.1273295581,
-0.0902013108,
1.0772585869,
0.4129208624,
-0.5314674377,
0.1658999175,
-0.8037753701,
-0.109531574,
-0.3784393668,
0.1237573549,
-0.0913850591,
-0.5792933106,
0.3293810189,
0.0085157305,
-0.2741028666,
0.6286634803,
0.7607141733,
-0.2731240988,
0.9087825418,
0.8968806267,
-0.157331571,
0.3888311088,
-0.1370945424,
0.2943641543,
-0.8024794459,
-0.430668503,
-0.5936664343,
0.032291308,
-0.7361986041,
-0.4098485708,
0.2760086358,
-0.0988703519,
-0.1078753993,
0.4760677218,
-0.8041180968,
-0.1240656003,
0.6555226445,
0.1975284368,
0.5009895563,
0.101180099,
-0.1304606646,
-0.1623247266,
-1.0187650919,
-0.319896102,
0.9936587214,
-0.2335121334,
0.7307642698,
0.185438782,
0.2156901211,
0.2440924495,
0.4791280329,
-0.7055057883,
0.3465172052,
-0.3331713974,
-1.0762541294,
-0.0319090076,
-0.4781765342,
-1.2366213799,
0.442907989,
-0.168477267,
-0.7547599673,
0.2297326922,
0.0812663212,
-0.1088968441,
0.1375487894,
-0.8292283416,
0.6372339725,
-0.3529237211,
-0.0423961021,
-0.3203131855,
-0.9620604515,
0.172303915,
-0.1445898414,
-0.0292976294,
-0.0012936934,
0.2979440689,
0.6006227136,
-0.2766802013,
1.0420347452,
-0.0219873507,
0.0801821053,
0.3155617416,
-0.3020660281,
-0.214363724,
-0.193715483,
-0.4632562399,
0.4236055613,
0.0477889329,
-0.5728184581,
-0.4085128903,
0.5319066048,
-0.7233354449,
-0.4246484041,
-0.7024524212,
-0.281152606,
-0.2657971978,
0.2380675822,
0.2095527202,
0.0978586748,
-0.3765750825,
0.2518416047,
0.267236799,
-0.5396400094,
0.289647907,
0.5296218991,
-0.1408890784,
-0.1834346205,
0.7159053087,
-0.0409497246,
0.2500524223,
0.4930374026,
0.1549098194,
-0.4727509916,
-0.3005527258,
-0.6967124939,
0.241844371,
-0.5504172444,
-0.375179112,
-0.5188201666,
-0.7414399981,
-0.3096720278,
0.1878911555,
-0.4094963372,
-0.2538034618,
-0.5215979815,
0.0596146248,
0.601410985,
0.608020246,
0.2582353652,
0.3500359654,
-0.6368761063,
0.3395599127,
-0.1209519058,
0.2462374121,
0.3098870218,
-0.2026555985,
0.1685442775,
-0.0168739706,
-0.5391001105,
-1.0251228809,
0.568443954,
0.1975363642,
0.3784298003,
0.1604230106,
-0.0275142044,
0.9514238834,
-0.5666057467,
0.9284907579,
0.4379160404,
-0.6209254265,
0.8807227612,
-0.149530232,
0.0124098398,
0.4374013245,
0.63998276,
-0.3168094754,
-0.0665628985,
-0.7381241918,
-0.9413135052,
0.3523532152,
0.7088671923,
0.2939530015,
-0.0328972898,
0.4003150463,
0.3867174983,
0.7742282152,
-0.4161511958,
-0.4261493981,
0.0266933218,
-0.0736955851,
0.1304690093,
-0.1609743387,
0.0655814931,
-0.4666255414,
0.6365796924,
0.0802101418,
0.474881202,
0.1047665849,
-0.003300932,
0.2128468454,
0.3637133837,
0.284209162,
0.5797347426,
-0.1215031967,
-0.333835423,
-0.1153503731,
-0.6156330705,
0.2624415159,
0.2741327286,
-0.3033978641,
0.2318833768,
0.3994808793,
0.5707243085,
0.1092232317,
-0.5547266603,
0.601048708,
-0.1623098403,
0.0531585775,
-0.688123107,
-0.3064190447,
0.1524135321,
-0.2257554531,
0.5167695284,
-0.0754169971,
0.2108656168,
-0.43052423,
0.1990925223,
0.5176594257,
-0.3136980534,
-0.3259220123,
0.7216161489,
-0.0198000856,
-0.3813154697,
1.1534178257,
-0.1791718602,
-0.2907693386,
0.6434012055,
0.8913422823,
0.478685081,
-0.5588493943,
0.3999985754,
0.3156957328,
0.0183779858,
0.1211018562,
0.6657546759,
0.0296584386,
-0.7345334888,
-0.5001736283,
-0.7184416056,
-0.4506643414,
0.0664901212,
-0.8432408571,
0.072446458,
-0.0408175737,
-0.3806411624,
0.0694862455,
-0.1284363717,
-0.7995108366,
0.3204970956,
-0.2180434614,
0.599192977,
-0.6009318829,
0.7506773472,
0.7012856007,
-0.4988533556,
-0.5494614244,
-0.1522952616,
-0.1608084887,
-0.9501265883,
0.7558795214,
0.0577819161,
0.1057239845,
0.0206529945,
-0.2659426928,
-0.7759475708,
0.7239212394,
0.1839166284,
-0.5136309266,
-0.0743763521,
0.257327348,
0.9564686418,
0.0831204802,
0.3908340931,
0.2897663116,
0.2284317017,
0.6517804861,
-1.1351338625,
-0.2807444632,
-0.3889718056,
0.1335745156,
0.3011058867,
-0.5941954255,
0.4435231388,
-0.1014805809,
-0.2928645611,
0.4751225412,
0.5537267327,
0.2471520603,
0.0350822508,
0.4114318192,
0.4934943318,
0.496290803,
-0.1502463371,
1.1454569101,
-0.3767754436,
0.4991084039,
0.7808574438,
-0.4033892155,
1.2169351578,
0.599273622,
-0.5001801252,
0.5760574341,
0.7671575546,
0.0667754188,
0.5126801133,
0.3225077093,
-0.0947057679,
0.1951641738,
-0.4200439453,
-0.3758219779,
0.4815456271,
0.5926463604,
-0.0350947976,
-0.2341974825,
0.2002705932,
-0.1658813059,
-0.0368667766,
0.1992643476,
1.0175101757,
0.1138765514,
-0.5052742362,
0.6689506769,
-0.1448883414,
0.6957933307,
-0.6075813174,
-0.23159042,
0.149160102,
-0.0040434673,
-0.1954004616,
-0.5656275749,
0.6540217996,
0.091781944,
-0.1979609579,
-0.1724605262,
0.8545055389,
-0.190662995,
-0.8228207231,
0.3852979243,
0.8793411851,
0.1085269153,
0.0098515572,
-0.7751798034,
-0.2391825169,
-0.4554210007,
0.0752254799,
0.1134823933,
-0.1927175671,
-0.1322242469,
0.7733797431,
0.8596231341,
0.3667804897,
0.2415964752,
0.2638175189,
0.7842826843,
-0.6355546117,
-0.5851855278,
-0.7879887819,
0.3199189603,
-0.1085014939,
-0.2898432314,
0.7704772949,
0.7747050524,
0.5264303088,
-0.2749866247,
0.7122546434,
-0.5213849545,
0.7626794577,
-0.2726977468,
0.7722784281,
-0.4895897806,
-0.1952636689,
-0.0999562964,
-0.6222673059,
-0.5155131817,
0.6545429826,
-0.2684814632,
0.1295286566,
0.5622426867,
0.4657501876,
0.0134428171,
0.2386974692,
0.1627958268,
0.0497194938,
0.3166285753,
0.2697567046,
1.0676330328,
-0.3929060996,
0.2348122001,
-0.2484295219,
-0.3747543693,
-0.4175588787,
-0.6531088948,
-0.6699547768,
-0.8812095523,
-0.2997605205,
-0.008944896,
0.0566153042,
0.5341515541,
0.9948318601,
-0.831048429,
-0.1904499382,
0.0248677153,
0.0009293743,
-0.5016959906,
-0.3181178272,
0.4886588156,
-0.2284027338,
-0.5764073133,
0.2952286601,
0.174965322,
0.0807139352,
-0.3112287223,
0.4289695024,
-0.5775907636,
-0.1327168643,
0.7021137476,
0.1711198837,
-0.5985926986,
-0.0907597318,
0.0454988368,
-0.0440928675,
0.5165208578,
0.6518028975,
-0.8290452361,
0.4937884808,
0.4210754633,
0.5637307763,
0.5312206745,
0.28503564,
0.3789483607,
-0.9077389836,
0.440566957,
0.6170173883,
0.1176476553,
0.6981720924,
-0.6887983084,
0.4488480985,
0.0498798601,
-0.5174185634,
-0.5348171592,
0.3369443417,
-0.9842514396,
-0.0607948303,
0.9422789812,
0.0746327415,
-0.2264602482,
-0.2740561664,
-0.1528455168,
0.5782061219,
-0.317440927,
0.9264185429,
0.568077147,
-0.5260302424,
0.1950252801,
-0.8872144818,
0.2535675764,
0.6177575588,
-0.9880458713,
-0.3645804822,
0.084900111,
0.1585392207,
0.3937827647,
0.7685759068,
-0.3485914469,
-0.0081857201,
-0.176463142,
0.1322895586,
0.5505775213,
-0.1589556038,
-0.2107413113,
0.1533941925,
-0.0938454568,
-0.5973610282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06858v1
|
Can Large Language Models Augment a Biomedical Ontology with missing Concepts and Relations?
| 2023-11-12T14:20:55 | 2023-11-12T14:20:55 |
Antonio Zaitoun, Tomer Sagi, Szymon Wilk, Mor Peleg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Ontologies play a crucial role in organizing and representing knowledge.
However, even current ontologies do not encompass all relevant concepts and
relationships. Here, we explore the potential of large language models (LLM) to
expand an existing ontology in a semi-automated fashion. We demonstrate our
approach on the biomedical ontology SNOMED-CT utilizing semantic relation types
from the widely used UMLS semantic network. We propose a method that uses
conversational interactions with an LLM to analyze clinical practice guidelines
(CPGs) and detect the relationships among the new medical concepts that are not
present in SNOMED-CT. Our initial experimentation with the conversational
prompts yielded promising preliminary results given a manually generated gold
standard, directing our future potential improvements.
|
[
-0.0416840203,
-0.7200437784,
1.2276480198,
-0.1286446303,
-0.1744929701,
-0.1096047685,
-0.2768490314,
-0.6970593333,
0.2049630433,
1.0881210566,
-0.6168471575,
-0.6442360878,
-0.664593935,
0.4014019668,
-0.2870100439,
0.938256681,
0.2927271426,
0.2039673924,
-0.1950692683,
-0.027896015,
-0.2955112457,
-0.3786631823,
-0.5153360963,
-0.613175869,
0.4168385863,
0.1966931075,
0.8315211535,
0.888906002,
0.7473059297,
0.3240291178,
-0.4510024786,
0.384996593,
-0.2386697978,
0.0747296214,
-0.2686741352,
-0.2169921547,
-0.7420950532,
-0.4170039892,
0.6633208394,
1.2175445557,
-0.0889649987,
-0.3177284002,
-0.1839394867,
0.2522900999,
-0.0786484107,
0.3836952448,
-0.4632484019,
0.2723323405,
0.115233168,
-0.4745486975,
-0.2889936566,
-0.0694468617,
0.6671982408,
-0.4984039962,
-0.0822784528,
-0.012328987,
0.808134973,
0.1608404368,
-0.4803051353,
-0.5844054222,
-0.5299261808,
0.5845562816,
-1.0042198896,
0.4333955646,
0.2206560373,
0.1731573492,
-0.6416939497,
-0.7799677253,
-0.3498341143,
-0.7380128503,
-0.3127400875,
0.1400009394,
-0.3624580503,
0.4658037722,
0.3338741064,
0.1555311829,
-0.1367084831,
0.1721780151,
-0.248794958,
0.0660652295,
0.6822060347,
0.4955617785,
0.6422715783,
-0.3379851282,
-0.1885300726,
0.386621207,
-0.740054965,
-0.4623877108,
-0.1847653985,
0.4071638584,
-0.2376287729,
0.8143504262,
0.2152865678,
1.0362814665,
-0.0915875584,
-0.2550165951,
0.1071925834,
-0.8129268885,
-0.1115454063,
0.1002124175,
0.8244158626,
0.3811885715,
0.0558733642,
-0.350875169,
0.1749473959,
-0.115114212,
0.2847289443,
-0.5324192047,
-0.1346414238,
0.2128614634,
-0.4839672744,
-0.3449005783,
-0.4397125244,
-0.3039161861,
-0.642239809,
-0.3128826916,
0.2228409499,
-0.554279685,
-0.1552653313,
0.3219305575,
-0.3288957775,
0.1187555119,
0.5353170037,
-0.5874934793,
0.1349642873,
0.5383360982,
0.719810605,
0.0920801312,
0.0331354104,
-0.014135207,
0.4674339294,
-0.4183657467,
0.827357173,
-0.8055274487,
-0.6620271206,
0.0989836752,
0.3002915382,
0.2027502954,
-0.5269064903,
0.239790082,
-0.3595032692,
0.0254595075,
-0.1349485964,
-0.8939585686,
0.2407575548,
0.3136206567,
-0.5859742761,
0.5846010447,
0.2095473558,
-0.6740506291,
-0.0200164281,
-0.8013169169,
-0.334656179,
0.272608906,
-0.500113368,
-0.0617900006,
-0.0788419619,
-0.3090535104,
0.5654997826,
-0.6958891153,
0.4515954852,
-0.6362930536,
0.0713777095,
0.4618550241,
0.2976246476,
0.8556358814,
0.0623295531,
0.1947672665,
0.0912943184,
-0.8977406025,
-0.1752128601,
-0.0295857582,
-0.2817957401,
-0.5790106654,
-0.0284657795,
-0.1453912407,
0.2861586511,
0.1997870654,
-0.5541716814,
0.3612293899,
-0.7609631419,
0.6085270643,
0.3442900479,
0.2025267929,
0.4726065993,
-0.2509596944,
0.3933227062,
-0.0612958781,
-0.0565920882,
-0.2558621764,
-0.557463944,
-0.7696824074,
-0.2752747238,
0.0749296099,
0.2640478611,
-0.7100938559,
0.8620339632,
-0.4109286368,
-0.3816934228,
-0.2534583509,
0.1806176901,
0.391233176,
0.6891165376,
0.3071685731,
-0.1229942888,
-0.716622293,
-0.7537251711,
0.0458120815,
-0.1819710732,
-0.2640637457,
0.4467674792,
0.3063615859,
-0.7343848944,
0.9403166771,
-0.6124696136,
-0.4202207029,
-0.3161390722,
-0.1872532368,
0.0820276365,
0.084834598,
0.2439930737,
-0.4000937641,
-0.1572612822,
0.4088437259,
-1.0258296728,
-0.2497216612,
0.1115535349,
0.0231042299,
-0.0723809078,
0.7623850703,
-0.3859420419,
0.5080298185,
0.6132725477,
-0.3863625228,
0.4060783386,
-0.5291272998,
-0.2655899525,
-1.2496691942,
0.0208751746,
0.1750329733,
-0.2189821899,
-0.8217747211,
-0.0747615695,
-0.081573233,
0.0117920516,
-0.2707647681,
0.7074482441,
-0.3843004107,
-0.0475472435,
-0.3808529973,
0.3595324159,
0.211610347,
-0.0945919603,
0.5858047605,
0.2802131176,
0.5124757886,
-0.7303218842,
0.2436393499,
0.8139103651,
0.0903805122,
0.4191324115,
-0.7727634907,
-0.275488764,
-0.1159392968,
0.4615086913,
-0.8743466735,
-0.3016537726,
0.0615227781,
-0.3632393777,
0.0456510037,
-0.4456003308,
-0.6576724052,
-0.3822049201,
0.0936934724,
0.10318847,
0.2734886706,
-0.27671206,
0.6366068125,
0.6344957948,
-0.3285503387,
0.0116521791,
-0.6948664188,
0.3254846036,
0.1506952792,
-0.7261805534,
0.3686290979,
0.0613513738,
-0.3122791946,
0.1108509824,
0.1855467111,
-0.317650944,
-0.1944350451,
0.3393866122,
0.6348251104,
-0.1816627234,
0.551191628,
-0.0136597781,
0.0734074116,
0.2696896195,
-0.1978805214,
0.5198546052,
-0.0251778271,
-0.1194353104,
-0.5217223763,
0.2657426,
0.5035344958,
0.0683105886,
0.5704842806,
0.0953498706,
-0.4220978916,
0.0587511398,
-0.255571872,
-0.4176009595,
-0.4329060614,
0.6161841154,
-0.0135487346,
-1.0601998568,
0.4684375525,
-0.1250996441,
-0.0929373577,
0.3515130877,
0.7424779534,
-0.1677526087,
0.9598635435,
0.7385011315,
0.5114176273,
0.2734802365,
-0.0373804271,
0.2832516134,
-0.8512089849,
-0.2491192371,
-0.3573023379,
0.3401080966,
-0.8785018921,
-0.427598238,
0.6452468038,
-0.3370432556,
-0.0754831582,
0.4651019573,
-0.2505612075,
0.0887756124,
-0.0019742777,
0.2770609558,
0.4861225784,
-0.2860473394,
-0.1859485507,
0.2063132524,
-0.9553664327,
-0.519946754,
1.2007097006,
0.4274014831,
0.7722678185,
-0.0173606705,
0.5565102696,
0.1281249821,
0.4904746115,
-0.8738341331,
0.4292352796,
-0.3268814683,
-0.5483525991,
-0.3172332346,
-0.6303762794,
-1.2071291208,
-0.1850722134,
-0.4456363022,
-0.7925963402,
-0.0821204856,
0.17438519,
-0.7413809896,
0.0889246091,
-0.352237612,
0.6131418943,
-0.1293901652,
-0.1116820499,
0.0371452235,
-0.797724843,
0.3243255615,
-0.424021095,
0.2928951979,
-0.1369412541,
-0.1043837965,
0.734141171,
-0.7682909369,
0.9160419703,
0.3475238681,
-0.5046660304,
0.1310191154,
-0.2427963465,
0.2614136636,
0.0605313703,
0.0837410614,
0.2260462642,
0.402118355,
-0.2214109302,
-0.5668928623,
0.6879228354,
-0.5717515349,
-0.323394835,
-0.3028202653,
-0.6431409717,
-0.5124292374,
0.2889712751,
-0.0223157182,
0.3726062775,
-0.1728632748,
0.0455697142,
0.6272851825,
-0.481541723,
0.041251,
0.8064255714,
-0.2250577211,
-0.0720761418,
0.2795505524,
0.0847108513,
0.3944303095,
0.2321782857,
0.5682287812,
-0.5641320348,
-0.2834552228,
-0.1784597188,
0.526211679,
-0.5684611797,
-0.070015341,
-1.0944219828,
-0.3349097967,
-0.6749446988,
0.0408874229,
-0.1178540513,
-0.1564907283,
-0.3791605532,
0.0935488269,
0.7269578576,
0.7520788312,
0.0452362001,
0.5872429609,
-1.4470789433,
0.1063954979,
0.0289634746,
0.2396085411,
-0.1509943306,
-0.7191622853,
-0.08572644,
-0.0492439382,
0.0147193102,
-0.8837302923,
0.403255403,
-0.0492692739,
0.3765544295,
0.7074421048,
-0.0817131996,
0.6449638605,
-0.7722139955,
0.2948307991,
0.5475836992,
-0.6199669838,
0.5128583312,
-0.6926891804,
0.0682115331,
0.221941039,
0.3838575482,
-0.6065996289,
-0.3847958744,
-0.9361759424,
-0.3825783432,
0.4492275715,
-0.0156262405,
0.2349007875,
-0.2126363814,
0.4778357148,
-0.2592125833,
0.0975224823,
-0.3270768523,
-0.2405968159,
0.5034728646,
-0.301733762,
0.0659892485,
-0.1525664628,
-0.3823238909,
-0.1971218884,
0.2105344385,
-0.100911051,
0.2521382272,
0.2180586606,
0.3665393591,
-0.0084546451,
0.282137543,
0.1768561751,
0.5738199949,
-0.130327493,
0.126793921,
0.1149502918,
-0.142137453,
-0.128637135,
0.1574294865,
0.0672838688,
-0.0368980728,
0.5106384754,
0.3376989067,
0.450371325,
-1.1044405699,
0.5787291527,
0.0016130337,
-0.0991223529,
-0.3724248409,
0.0664191246,
0.2870981991,
0.1390498728,
-0.251213789,
-0.1318311393,
0.1880910099,
-0.8304114342,
0.6356475353,
0.4481964707,
-0.7099593282,
-0.2994454801,
0.2990809083,
0.1989284456,
-0.2488873154,
0.1191694885,
0.0456132479,
-0.4218233228,
0.4481667876,
0.698435843,
0.1537655145,
-0.0280002132,
0.0463219322,
0.1399038285,
0.0789689198,
-0.1545125693,
0.1931353062,
0.3261674345,
-0.8914759755,
-0.632565558,
-0.3792014718,
-0.4869535863,
0.0588185564,
-0.4474132955,
0.5468657017,
-0.5451634526,
-0.3354017138,
0.6477870345,
-0.0781850666,
-0.5009768605,
0.2659032345,
-0.0817629844,
0.7542910576,
-0.7795422673,
0.9835497737,
0.7025613189,
-0.5124907494,
-0.8187705278,
-0.259388119,
-0.0476346686,
-1.0130907297,
0.7231478691,
-0.322819978,
-0.0044205943,
-0.0677203164,
-0.3727703094,
-0.7660676837,
0.7813789845,
0.0842581466,
-0.4578418732,
-0.2935141027,
0.2430648804,
0.9311926961,
-0.5918732882,
0.2902285755,
0.6887307763,
0.4733734131,
0.3597293198,
-0.8714340925,
0.2019610703,
-0.1345345825,
-0.169914484,
0.2904725373,
-0.2804029882,
0.5989610553,
-0.273160696,
-0.0236376729,
0.4385786653,
0.2013019621,
0.1617591679,
0.2556033432,
0.3290067613,
0.3511231542,
0.5982268453,
0.2301436365,
1.0291199684,
-0.3848534524,
0.2559954524,
1.124302268,
-0.6767314672,
0.7209995985,
0.4982091486,
-0.1907506287,
0.3755114079,
0.497951746,
-0.1846755892,
-0.0478262492,
0.1956757158,
-0.2669946551,
-0.6166636348,
-0.6044096947,
-0.4958972931,
0.5229141116,
0.749083817,
-0.7264305353,
-0.3675807118,
-0.1627735645,
0.1530169696,
0.0052898084,
-0.2075038701,
0.9815042615,
0.2414382696,
-0.4105884135,
0.4745042324,
-0.0375459492,
0.2606469989,
-0.7249796987,
-0.2344298363,
0.0257915426,
0.0114735607,
-0.2065428793,
-0.6590195894,
0.2842815816,
-0.1785823107,
0.0000139092,
0.2095359117,
0.8447138667,
-0.6381209493,
-0.5910975933,
0.5545803905,
0.6098456383,
0.1724288166,
0.3185156584,
-0.4667575955,
-0.1621987522,
-0.0998409688,
0.364014864,
0.2823412418,
0.5822063684,
-0.1856014431,
0.76454705,
0.7617230415,
0.3241373599,
-0.2730019391,
-0.0310268905,
1.1712909937,
-0.5972577333,
-0.4082937241,
-0.7189442515,
-0.0904653743,
-0.2860395312,
-0.0063849036,
0.5726405382,
0.2173588574,
0.2733567655,
0.0541691333,
0.972155869,
0.2213464528,
0.6166812181,
-0.5339350104,
0.7532714009,
-0.7186660171,
0.4623964429,
-0.3199213743,
-0.4486754835,
-0.6693312526,
0.5356839299,
-0.3280578256,
-0.2207094878,
0.7565522194,
0.8407407403,
0.0729886666,
0.1137485653,
0.6295434237,
0.4335487485,
0.2086397856,
0.4528999329,
1.0593973398,
-0.105851762,
0.420938164,
0.2993574739,
-0.5681004524,
-0.4188963175,
-0.9482688904,
-1.0536571741,
-0.2378643602,
-0.3817696869,
-0.6895779371,
0.078217566,
1.144998312,
0.6215708852,
-0.4886308312,
-0.0759443566,
-0.0589539446,
-0.0999721363,
0.2277660817,
-0.0805704594,
0.3297235072,
-0.3733503819,
-0.4110226035,
0.4383033514,
0.5507912636,
0.357203871,
-0.2052777112,
-0.1242334396,
-0.077959992,
0.3287368417,
0.6096857786,
0.3121752441,
-0.5860862136,
-0.1693952084,
0.1250607967,
-0.1389010251,
0.0281620622,
0.8427458405,
-0.428992033,
0.446103096,
0.1851893365,
0.6260552406,
0.0683508813,
-0.2456129193,
0.6749845147,
-0.4612604678,
-0.0297244042,
0.282238394,
0.5007159114,
0.045607049,
-0.2010807544,
0.486980617,
0.2056268305,
-0.32289204,
-0.6845933199,
0.3641189039,
-1.1300257444,
-0.3395863473,
1.4534144402,
-0.2350401431,
-0.2518053055,
-0.393707782,
-0.2656782269,
0.1419057399,
-0.0571821295,
0.8036960363,
0.4397603571,
-0.4184840918,
0.1179356351,
-0.4786936045,
0.5891432762,
0.1590146571,
-1.0740022659,
0.1032179967,
0.5410018563,
0.2938659191,
0.4028696418,
0.896938026,
-0.3816438019,
0.217616722,
-0.4244966507,
0.0152609628,
0.2226492167,
-0.0740019605,
-0.0373586863,
-0.280009985,
0.0685900748,
0.2640804648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06855v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06855v1
|
DialMAT: Dialogue-Enabled Transformer with Moment-Based Adversarial Training
| 2023-11-12T14:12:19 | 2023-11-12T14:12:19 |
Kanta Kaneda, Ryosuke Korekata, Yuiga Wada, Shunya Nagashima, Motonari Kambara, Yui Iioka, Haruka Matsuo, Yuto Imai, Takayuki Nishimura, Komei Sugiura
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
This paper focuses on the DialFRED task, which is the task of embodied
instruction following in a setting where an agent can actively ask questions
about the task. To address this task, we propose DialMAT. DialMAT introduces
Moment-based Adversarial Training, which incorporates adversarial perturbations
into the latent space of language, image, and action. Additionally, it
introduces a crossmodal parallel feature extraction mechanism that applies
foundation models to both language and image. We evaluated our model using a
dataset constructed from the DialFRED dataset and demonstrated superior
performance compared to the baseline method in terms of success rate and path
weighted success rate. The model secured the top position in the DialFRED
Challenge, which took place at the CVPR 2023 Embodied AI workshop.
|
[
-0.4374118149,
-1.0794445276,
0.1078575701,
0.0294468924,
-0.1346612126,
-0.0419290401,
0.1530345082,
0.0714703947,
-0.197682336,
0.7344252467,
-0.7893605232,
-0.2774138153,
-0.8686346412,
-0.1335370392,
-0.529558301,
0.8143200874,
0.0438065119,
0.4653848112,
-0.3480290771,
-0.4879540205,
-0.4581286311,
-0.5273134708,
-0.5552989841,
-0.6391171813,
0.1287469715,
0.3308330476,
1.1462643147,
0.1267879903,
0.4994951487,
0.4092235267,
0.0391487628,
0.1548205763,
-0.3952154219,
0.1109500453,
-0.0780613422,
-0.9726707339,
-0.5840434432,
0.2223192006,
0.5572283864,
0.5405970216,
0.1508063078,
-0.0947472975,
-0.1887595206,
0.4031626284,
-0.1969703138,
0.1891847253,
-0.6496448517,
0.5619713068,
0.2164591998,
-0.3109350801,
-0.3045829237,
-0.1745041758,
0.0430309698,
-0.5809059739,
0.6054847836,
-0.0238843858,
0.767385304,
0.4546403289,
-0.5375961065,
-0.213582918,
-0.5414710045,
0.8161379695,
-0.2772241831,
0.4136350155,
0.2366430759,
0.5101950765,
-0.310015738,
-0.6740542054,
-0.7442684174,
0.0872256383,
-0.0199858323,
0.0564511456,
-0.3416517973,
0.1371904463,
0.5056148767,
0.4264829755,
-0.312456876,
-0.2142918259,
0.0091585163,
-0.2293976992,
0.4083582461,
0.3809975088,
0.632142067,
-0.0347708091,
-0.5840188265,
-0.4938457012,
-0.8142114878,
0.0202697832,
0.1578740627,
0.122867018,
-0.0582347363,
0.705714345,
0.1527682841,
0.2790160179,
0.1385619342,
0.0619250983,
0.0392335802,
-0.1485997885,
-0.1900850087,
-0.2076350302,
0.8797288537,
0.3170722723,
0.0342571214,
-0.211038962,
-0.4190774262,
0.0151106743,
0.5631996989,
-0.9792401195,
0.0249053594,
-0.0918454453,
-0.1503917873,
-0.5272415876,
-0.1321332157,
-0.9373925924,
-0.5708984137,
-0.3481502533,
0.6418472528,
-0.3312822282,
-0.1216678545,
-0.2043248415,
-0.0546144769,
0.4815698266,
0.7311116457,
-0.7226029634,
0.3687722981,
0.6158137321,
0.8355321884,
-0.0213459283,
-0.028262658,
-0.4400732219,
-0.4576098919,
-0.3197087646,
0.5704630017,
-0.5545414686,
-1.1300109625,
0.0179084446,
0.4000813663,
-0.4754177034,
-0.6269659996,
0.3097749949,
-0.6244882941,
0.410575062,
-0.266474694,
-0.2893452346,
-0.443233937,
0.4978464544,
-0.8344643712,
1.0718443394,
0.3171442449,
-0.6960841417,
0.0464900173,
-0.792660892,
-0.394164443,
-0.0148930205,
-0.4679169059,
-0.6887648106,
0.009485296,
0.5044337511,
0.4855768979,
-0.5252121687,
0.311986953,
-0.2439107299,
-0.3303349018,
0.5893113613,
-0.9833360314,
0.8677335978,
-0.1092151627,
-0.7931186557,
0.2767877579,
-0.4791453183,
-0.1396317482,
0.3968206644,
0.0758159459,
0.2692935467,
-0.2248346359,
0.0987179577,
0.3247429729,
-0.0287579391,
-0.5234089494,
0.2461809814,
-0.3802584708,
0.2107548416,
0.7071186304,
-0.0412750207,
0.7041237354,
-0.4831474721,
0.9015425444,
0.0148587422,
0.2271380275,
-0.3011162579,
-0.4549546242,
-1.1914553642,
-0.2325970531,
0.0191171691,
0.6814511418,
-1.2707983255,
0.2609741092,
-0.3266731501,
-0.4814691842,
-0.519726932,
0.0353525691,
0.567493856,
0.3512598872,
0.3683518767,
-0.1585187912,
-0.1319011599,
-0.8022794724,
0.1891944408,
0.0299650189,
0.0285700113,
0.5759578943,
0.5253079534,
-0.4404368997,
0.9608683586,
-0.5277980566,
-0.3753643632,
-0.3985213339,
0.5621557236,
-0.1449694932,
0.4594127238,
0.5565285683,
-1.2966032028,
-0.32009691,
-0.038684655,
-0.8590329885,
-0.1540274471,
-0.1494102329,
-0.0072518699,
-0.0489009582,
0.6134406924,
-0.6885678768,
0.5515427589,
0.4794518054,
-0.1985152811,
0.3259353638,
0.1178516075,
0.5030189753,
-1.229605794,
0.1449216604,
-0.3713437617,
-0.5996087193,
-0.5287028551,
0.0220229831,
-0.0714870542,
-0.8435868025,
-0.5967853069,
0.6517780423,
-0.2136744559,
-0.2609295845,
-0.4911991358,
-0.1596236974,
-0.0515118055,
0.7899853587,
-0.0215595327,
1.1748594046,
0.386248678,
-0.3013080657,
0.5801942348,
0.5815921426,
0.0902347639,
0.8123195171,
-0.8066261411,
0.3503116071,
0.0295452364,
0.2355850041,
-0.8835740685,
-0.0882753953,
0.1515396237,
-0.4339326024,
0.4107679129,
-0.1302838922,
-0.2787134945,
-0.2133238614,
-0.1594925672,
0.517048955,
0.5102423429,
-0.6414443254,
0.9801706672,
0.3780536056,
-0.0483515635,
-0.4572155476,
-0.2608865201,
-0.0140819494,
-0.240790695,
-0.6681015491,
0.2112413198,
-0.0632934496,
0.0336503722,
-0.2182401866,
-0.0188226365,
-0.1103295982,
0.2635666728,
0.724466145,
0.3126259744,
-0.2761937082,
-0.1417476833,
-0.3009112775,
-0.3432018757,
0.2859295309,
0.3045609593,
0.663916409,
-0.2030079812,
-0.7808142304,
-0.4672692716,
0.3857152462,
1.0179774761,
0.0663154945,
0.4249307215,
0.8786590099,
-0.3037296534,
-0.2355446219,
-0.265560478,
-0.2380873114,
-0.5310839415,
0.3552406728,
-0.2785427868,
-0.8611257076,
0.5673545599,
-0.3678569198,
0.079936482,
0.3202990294,
0.4922669232,
0.1291533262,
1.2088720798,
0.6375092268,
-0.0675429329,
0.762480855,
-0.6751928329,
-0.0503920875,
-0.9126996398,
-0.1909589171,
-0.2425928265,
-0.3420477509,
-0.0801374391,
-1.0644273758,
0.6794985533,
0.0174388476,
-0.0914275423,
0.5028766394,
-0.1103538722,
-0.0045988811,
0.5230231285,
0.4232606888,
-0.1927623153,
-0.3578269482,
-0.0668769032,
-0.1189645603,
-0.7430146933,
-0.4471290112,
0.9959366322,
0.3616216779,
0.7966377139,
-0.0958350673,
0.1417970806,
0.5527575016,
0.2775259316,
-0.927283287,
0.9153644443,
0.1290082783,
-0.5517514348,
-0.3553751707,
-0.2186000645,
-0.7907710075,
0.5802400708,
-0.3032938838,
-0.3746322691,
0.0969069451,
0.0034357198,
-0.0239738319,
0.2682206035,
-0.4060358405,
0.9933787584,
-0.1417655349,
-0.1584241539,
-0.320992589,
-0.5680404305,
0.0299410764,
0.0121565051,
0.0552486703,
-0.1710585952,
0.1786575913,
0.563190937,
-0.5576003194,
1.0809619427,
-0.3588953316,
0.1075733677,
0.1660865098,
0.1147558764,
0.6083050966,
0.102178596,
0.2243017405,
0.1317887902,
-0.4952069819,
-0.3584769964,
-0.9672385454,
0.4121613801,
-0.7047091126,
-0.8702525496,
-0.326250881,
-0.6068093777,
-0.3158124089,
0.0793816075,
0.3125705123,
0.9016620517,
-0.7639487386,
0.3365000486,
0.9310395718,
-0.2769483328,
0.5113909841,
0.4614899755,
-0.0119795613,
-0.454529494,
0.7813255191,
-0.2174778283,
0.3925807476,
0.4975975454,
0.0164380129,
-0.2068324834,
-0.2322656214,
-0.7557529807,
-0.1516133249,
-0.7856686711,
-0.3779324293,
-0.8710098863,
-0.4363349378,
-0.1838832498,
-0.6275359988,
-0.759827137,
-0.2795872092,
-0.4132534862,
0.1694476157,
0.0268637743,
0.5317988992,
0.3672924042,
0.4065595567,
-0.7673327923,
0.4855050743,
0.7631406784,
-0.2496115267,
-0.2128559798,
-0.5246890783,
0.0402853675,
0.3472110033,
-0.5550480485,
-0.6234560609,
0.3922410011,
0.184355095,
0.6086711287,
0.2421764582,
0.1161245257,
0.5956174135,
-0.5573133826,
0.8506011963,
0.2970621586,
-0.8871691823,
0.5789086223,
-0.2760776877,
0.4814042151,
0.2180735916,
0.2897034585,
-0.3932143152,
-0.373762846,
-0.7803446651,
-0.564283371,
0.7975587845,
0.5256376266,
0.3843580186,
0.1626613289,
-0.1791004986,
-0.0466362871,
0.1774203926,
-0.5345202088,
-0.1123418882,
-0.3394200802,
-0.2045388371,
0.0716312453,
-0.156447649,
-0.4295248389,
-0.0877634883,
0.6010811925,
-0.4639085829,
0.7091656327,
0.2994439602,
-0.4945049882,
0.0075175161,
0.1957963109,
0.5044105649,
0.1202637479,
0.2977417111,
-0.0867092162,
0.3604060113,
-0.4503548443,
0.3278931677,
0.112852715,
0.0463187061,
0.0160425734,
0.5773429275,
1.0702112913,
0.7642098665,
-0.5580211878,
1.0920963287,
-0.2394836843,
-0.2500976324,
-0.3209289908,
0.2392356843,
-0.3517252207,
0.6147829294,
0.2375997901,
0.2088611871,
0.1764065027,
-0.4169937372,
0.3726782203,
0.5462358594,
-0.8368487954,
-0.5508024693,
0.7999789119,
0.4617684186,
-0.4719931185,
0.5212618709,
0.0676567778,
-1.2072687149,
0.7973595858,
0.4273427427,
0.991917789,
-0.3022143245,
0.3846283853,
0.0643095151,
0.0784627423,
0.1314019859,
0.1674809605,
-0.2998428643,
-0.8885813951,
0.208216846,
-0.3965901434,
-0.5984434485,
-0.1529525667,
-0.6377090812,
0.3773481548,
-0.3859917223,
-0.1436417252,
0.0853495598,
-0.2427334934,
-0.776242435,
0.3569792807,
-0.1231811866,
0.5147989392,
-0.8294025064,
0.7079125643,
0.5894879103,
-0.222303316,
-0.2463805079,
-0.1050126478,
0.3333026469,
-1.1504104137,
0.7022532225,
0.2749878764,
-0.2324136943,
0.0140902335,
-0.3174654245,
-0.4621464014,
1.2386426926,
0.3869201541,
-0.0865264684,
0.1015180945,
0.3476186991,
0.212045148,
-0.3479922712,
0.4821291864,
0.0976164788,
0.1130025685,
0.415001452,
-0.8639701605,
-0.0185745507,
-0.4694395065,
0.063106887,
0.2975983322,
-0.6485684514,
0.6978695989,
0.0065615112,
-0.4332705438,
0.0888241529,
0.5386681557,
-0.4269821048,
0.0737761259,
0.7998948693,
0.4703396857,
0.3910731673,
-0.2989611924,
0.8332749605,
-0.0901972502,
0.3068548441,
0.8141793013,
-0.1341757178,
0.5040503144,
0.0630389228,
-0.1708639115,
0.146871686,
0.1248923764,
0.0813733265,
0.3675919473,
-0.2957475185,
-0.470007807,
-0.3434934318,
-0.1116959602,
-0.2602971792,
0.751198709,
0.5303730965,
-0.3088293672,
-0.3764068484,
0.6069515944,
0.0268430859,
0.0656369328,
-0.1218646169,
0.9872815609,
0.0611579753,
-0.3605843782,
0.4675789475,
-0.2221152335,
0.3549882174,
-0.4960511327,
-0.277161479,
-0.2250920534,
0.2382786125,
0.2482959926,
-0.5974065661,
0.2793064117,
-0.2764365375,
-0.1467708945,
-0.4792497456,
0.7098465562,
-0.4159848988,
-0.3911797404,
0.0504603796,
0.2203419358,
-0.214645505,
-0.2465982139,
-1.0546133518,
0.0277119,
-0.0063917623,
-0.3169497848,
0.3143822253,
0.54626441,
-0.0861563459,
0.9128853083,
0.4734645486,
-0.5260626674,
-0.082461603,
0.0581447333,
1.220929265,
-0.7497759461,
-0.4152130485,
-0.4971047938,
0.4390739202,
-0.2120772749,
-0.2560607195,
0.616841197,
0.3793447018,
0.4180495143,
0.0731788725,
0.5520200133,
-0.0046871072,
0.1319944412,
-0.5417544246,
0.5106188059,
-0.4383827746,
0.019118933,
-0.0297335256,
-0.7532389164,
0.0151918083,
0.4922325313,
-0.0568811186,
-0.1198698431,
0.7036654949,
0.9801536202,
-0.2337677479,
0.3283527792,
0.6525593996,
-0.1592301428,
0.539429903,
0.4878586531,
0.7344247103,
-0.7617722154,
0.4010822475,
-0.1695419848,
-0.2179671079,
-0.3884983063,
-0.4633453488,
-1.3213710785,
-0.6589164138,
-0.3285602629,
-0.2109419107,
0.0844067559,
0.8689838052,
0.8619405627,
-0.7417499423,
0.08443252,
-0.2985075712,
0.1009548455,
-0.0049451077,
-0.2538652718,
0.103876397,
-0.3977917731,
-1.0277786255,
0.592299819,
0.173832044,
0.3512961864,
-0.3509204388,
0.0771921799,
0.0755257905,
0.1034509465,
0.5319246054,
0.1421051919,
-0.59627074,
-0.3704651594,
0.0153289149,
-0.3013244569,
0.0154269058,
1.0669305325,
-0.5955405831,
0.7864170671,
0.3525102139,
0.8243370056,
0.4755506217,
-0.0803971365,
1.231139183,
-0.7689874768,
0.6353655457,
0.3734631538,
0.4378985763,
0.4336619377,
-0.4277634621,
0.5485014915,
0.5181259513,
-0.4672976434,
-0.5049952269,
0.2444216311,
-0.9428287745,
-0.19651559,
1.0923383236,
-0.449428618,
-0.2603464723,
-0.1449746192,
-0.5762531757,
0.259768486,
-0.0673989952,
0.5168530941,
0.7045243979,
0.2641310096,
-0.2542893291,
-0.4544368386,
0.5043632388,
0.4506774545,
-0.7105141282,
-0.0208980553,
0.477806896,
-0.1047663614,
0.0986561403,
0.5173748136,
-0.3769113123,
0.4991128743,
0.3142912686,
-0.0418748558,
-0.1762205213,
-0.301748842,
-0.281542033,
0.3270697296,
-0.2728045583,
-0.4172560573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06851v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06851v3
|
Automatic Textual Normalization for Hate Speech Detection
| 2023-11-12T14:01:38 | 2023-12-04T15:34:29 |
Anh Thi-Hoang Nguyen, Dung Ha Nguyen, Nguyet Thi Nguyen, Khanh Thanh-Duy Ho, Kiet Van Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media data is a valuable resource for research, yet it contains a wide
range of non-standard words (NSW). These irregularities hinder the effective
operation of NLP tools. Current state-of-the-art methods for the Vietnamese
language address this issue as a problem of lexical normalization, involving
the creation of manual rules or the implementation of multi-staged deep
learning frameworks, which necessitate extensive efforts to craft intricate
rules. In contrast, our approach is straightforward, employing solely a
sequence-to-sequence (Seq2Seq) model. In this research, we provide a dataset
for textual normalization, comprising 2,181 human-annotated comments with an
inter-annotator agreement of 0.9014. By leveraging the Seq2Seq model for
textual normalization, our results reveal that the accuracy achieved falls
slightly short of 70%. Nevertheless, textual normalization enhances the
accuracy of the Hate Speech Detection (HSD) task by approximately 2%,
demonstrating its potential to improve the performance of complex NLP tasks.
Our dataset is accessible for research purposes.
|
[
-0.0419924408,
-1.0478717089,
0.1438922137,
0.0734225288,
-0.53861624,
-0.0833005756,
-0.3854569793,
-0.300511539,
0.1925647259,
0.655875206,
-0.1724644303,
-0.9201253057,
-0.9468994141,
0.2600821853,
-0.4911024272,
1.2085549831,
0.2990067303,
-0.1736980081,
0.426965028,
-0.4186376035,
-0.2467448562,
-0.5223229527,
-0.725405097,
0.1314206421,
0.6680756807,
0.4346868694,
0.7954047322,
0.7451604009,
0.4570024312,
0.1556914747,
-0.0863047913,
0.3065130115,
-0.7576425672,
0.3426890969,
-0.0666415095,
-0.0684709251,
-0.1763718724,
0.0413320921,
0.3926895559,
0.1528351754,
0.0957313031,
0.1424079537,
-0.0191953219,
0.525382936,
-0.6075055599,
-0.1538718343,
-0.7944204211,
-0.0780220851,
-0.3115788698,
-0.1059518978,
-0.1845051795,
-0.5923740268,
-0.0045993626,
-0.5533588529,
0.2054664493,
-0.4780806601,
0.7016817331,
0.401779443,
-0.5873638391,
-0.3712826967,
-0.7366067171,
0.638809979,
-1.0438158512,
0.1924371272,
0.6168501377,
0.2335048765,
0.2101196945,
-0.3359523714,
-0.624905169,
-0.0745921806,
-0.0542281307,
0.0104463547,
-0.3899856508,
0.1900470108,
0.3734956384,
0.0690031797,
-0.7250114679,
0.4828963578,
-0.5598547459,
-0.2932943404,
1.0454777479,
-0.0172073357,
0.3232751787,
-0.5768333673,
-0.2360748202,
0.2077572644,
-0.2230637819,
-0.1816200614,
0.3738459647,
0.6256579161,
-0.1012237892,
0.7263673544,
-0.3852267563,
0.5108702779,
-0.2662342787,
-0.1411758363,
0.4290403426,
-0.1677221954,
-0.302342236,
-0.1239518598,
0.8359296322,
0.8889740109,
0.5234229565,
-0.0246444587,
-0.2264132649,
0.588403821,
0.2905540466,
-0.6772357821,
-0.0576584563,
0.142832458,
-0.3490489423,
-0.3010014594,
-0.0617856495,
-0.8308120966,
-0.8109395504,
-0.5402780175,
0.4217327833,
-0.5325555205,
-0.2905060053,
-0.0873703808,
-0.3363124132,
0.1489030868,
0.4150265157,
-0.3892658949,
0.2046723664,
0.508746326,
0.7197228074,
-0.561245203,
-0.0426565856,
-0.7493408322,
0.1266137362,
-0.1800539196,
0.5657717586,
-0.4931029379,
-0.2066438347,
0.3037779927,
-0.036560107,
0.1598607898,
-0.7958031297,
0.9710113406,
-0.4861725569,
0.0968959853,
0.0937276855,
-0.6675283909,
-0.2348721474,
0.1746501625,
-0.4492494464,
1.3933938742,
0.2416178435,
-0.799203217,
0.1482444406,
-0.3442642093,
-0.6334022284,
0.1668106914,
-0.1625484079,
-0.6552449465,
-0.0686976761,
0.1111905202,
0.6196390986,
-0.2547653615,
0.3692892492,
-0.3777322769,
-0.4355515242,
-0.0572127849,
-0.1831628978,
0.9341495633,
0.4228371084,
-0.7698806524,
0.2967964113,
-0.8151835203,
-0.3265476823,
0.0865644142,
-0.1815636605,
-0.7144364715,
-0.3005098104,
0.69922328,
0.3742771745,
-0.1480291486,
-0.5787654519,
-0.374047637,
-0.4595135748,
0.1699208915,
0.7918995023,
-0.0567163005,
0.4038614035,
-0.3170703948,
0.509629786,
0.1594261229,
-0.0794572979,
0.0718463883,
-0.6019442081,
-0.6298123002,
-0.2777380347,
-0.1500197947,
0.7108098865,
-0.5864126086,
0.5846654177,
0.102003701,
-0.5988695025,
-0.5240178704,
0.1265668124,
0.3768765628,
0.5075201392,
0.716678381,
-0.0536451414,
-1.066454649,
-0.9491078854,
-0.5433324575,
-0.122763589,
-0.3416840732,
0.1981852949,
0.2967882752,
-0.5726178288,
0.9155469537,
-0.4842591882,
-0.5049754381,
0.0685150698,
0.4491849244,
-0.1082465872,
0.1683758348,
0.460405618,
-0.9443576932,
-0.7551016212,
-0.1087354794,
-0.6676797271,
-0.4713097513,
0.113714911,
0.055558186,
0.373127073,
0.7356829047,
-0.0157970916,
0.7674453259,
0.3913165331,
-0.5215924978,
0.3112322092,
0.2551349699,
0.2557473779,
-1.0902254581,
-0.2782665193,
0.3179455101,
-0.2055424899,
-1.072811842,
-0.2028231621,
-0.1068897024,
0.0708834156,
-0.4808729291,
0.4207816422,
0.0356599726,
0.3652277589,
-0.3837300539,
0.3057383895,
-0.2535189092,
0.220269382,
-0.00905455,
0.3387364745,
0.0425879471,
-0.5324371457,
0.397064656,
-0.1714730859,
0.0896476656,
0.6829159856,
-0.5618540645,
0.0174418371,
-0.3668684363,
0.1085403189,
-0.8637449741,
-0.1970813721,
0.2177797705,
-0.6775630713,
-0.1965876222,
-0.0976529866,
-0.3821804821,
0.0080981376,
-0.5444710851,
0.3367235363,
0.4561500549,
-0.1009613648,
0.3118443191,
0.8505107164,
-0.0567220561,
-0.3297070861,
-0.5475503802,
0.2938077152,
-0.5386247635,
-0.527399838,
0.342641294,
-0.0082773212,
-0.5128381252,
-0.3350237012,
0.388043195,
-0.3598197997,
0.0460646227,
0.3034702539,
0.1009736881,
-0.2361591309,
0.2788921893,
0.0605867766,
0.1559753418,
0.0198518876,
-0.1715915054,
0.4076573551,
0.0971278176,
0.2137296647,
-0.6621706486,
0.4531971216,
0.4322200119,
-0.0564757176,
0.4973660111,
1.00309515,
-0.8469427824,
-0.1190817058,
-0.6719129086,
-0.1659481078,
-0.3728270829,
0.3218249083,
0.0750217736,
-1.3062120676,
0.109247826,
0.3920577765,
-0.1086138263,
0.5947004557,
0.7653882504,
-0.1370429099,
0.6864735484,
0.4092094004,
-0.1129130572,
0.3790903687,
0.1765455157,
0.1383006126,
-0.4026472867,
0.1096371785,
-0.6147397161,
-0.1238043159,
-0.9240795374,
-0.8535193801,
0.1679341048,
-0.152055338,
-0.4090571702,
0.4178884923,
-0.567471683,
0.3061429858,
0.2416284829,
-0.0070945015,
0.3327254057,
0.1332996637,
0.3085364103,
-0.5721579194,
-0.0966826603,
-0.6401448846,
1.0563621521,
0.3056021333,
0.3867868185,
0.2430839986,
0.7046918869,
0.7350645661,
0.1764116436,
-0.8308585882,
0.3389074206,
-0.5037825704,
-0.515868783,
-0.667111814,
-0.3772613108,
-0.8756968379,
0.04118542,
-0.2347976416,
-0.5522159338,
0.1224684715,
-0.1765951812,
-0.3213944137,
0.168798238,
-0.6266726851,
0.6655830145,
0.2805205882,
-0.0039669434,
-0.1368087679,
-0.6832851171,
0.2448964566,
-0.2615322471,
0.5216322541,
-0.5053650141,
-0.219569236,
1.05293715,
-0.2131750137,
0.9677387476,
-0.2342677116,
-0.1468946487,
0.3092345595,
-0.1644802094,
0.2929066122,
0.0324417241,
-0.2704819739,
0.0491517149,
-0.3127274215,
-0.3803494871,
-0.4261358678,
0.3598304987,
-0.8015589118,
-0.2764288485,
-0.1426355392,
-0.5229505897,
0.0029654086,
0.2353468984,
0.3266304433,
-0.0128669161,
-0.3061114252,
0.200406611,
0.6943187714,
-0.2977059782,
0.1198365018,
0.4274785221,
-0.0972550735,
-0.4653750956,
0.8881121874,
0.3965661824,
0.0383896567,
0.3588570654,
0.2315161973,
-0.2906746566,
-0.4202656448,
-0.2787472308,
0.2746040523,
-0.5809910893,
-0.2793017924,
-1.015311718,
-0.3148755133,
-0.902862668,
-0.2161112428,
-0.1632732451,
-0.6270087361,
-0.4428842962,
-0.1868025512,
0.4937045276,
0.7485601902,
-0.108576268,
0.2184575647,
-0.6078479886,
0.821187675,
0.3431996107,
-0.0024567619,
-0.3589180708,
-1.1694101095,
-0.1779779494,
0.095462583,
-0.1086561233,
-1.1245375872,
0.4327143431,
0.0966948569,
-0.1400707364,
0.377628535,
0.6111509204,
0.5627298355,
-0.3234133422,
0.5931723118,
-0.0545168258,
-0.6508942842,
0.7977715731,
-0.6898100376,
0.0177405998,
0.4533958137,
0.637427032,
-0.9298689365,
-0.7671313882,
-0.6582730412,
-0.7884119749,
0.5533812046,
0.4226146936,
0.180776149,
0.0413396358,
0.2397442758,
-0.0080401031,
-0.007617875,
-0.6730294824,
-0.4210619032,
-0.1661108285,
-0.2939320803,
-0.2762103677,
-0.5529105067,
-0.1254711002,
-0.3456892669,
0.6783339977,
0.0530694723,
-0.1528552026,
0.0257413983,
-0.2951770127,
0.077959545,
0.3992225528,
0.5592794418,
0.3621084988,
-0.1458996981,
0.1996997744,
0.1737585217,
-0.5489670038,
0.2591942251,
0.2883549631,
-0.5646845698,
0.3847021163,
0.1884603798,
0.5272525549,
-0.152110517,
-0.6016190648,
0.7280513644,
-0.0479259267,
-0.143906787,
-0.334861815,
-0.1661247611,
0.0689248294,
0.095467709,
0.2956769168,
-0.1920188218,
0.4299669862,
-0.1022643372,
0.5610992312,
0.0675005466,
-0.7120239735,
-0.2113920599,
0.5405511856,
0.0903866142,
-0.6394469142,
0.4572936893,
-0.3173862398,
-0.4669054151,
0.6214362979,
0.4882316589,
0.8533812165,
-0.4320034683,
0.6286944151,
0.719014883,
0.5031325817,
0.2606158555,
0.2681115568,
0.2861681581,
-0.773411572,
-0.1470884681,
-0.7635228038,
-0.1753814369,
0.2969702184,
-0.7178970575,
0.5727916956,
-0.5938417912,
-0.0422369391,
0.1229729354,
-0.1488377601,
-0.3797963858,
0.58754915,
0.4147428274,
0.4250621796,
-1.0074719191,
0.8315367103,
0.5298227668,
-0.2471324652,
-0.6270090938,
-0.0516219698,
0.5694329739,
-0.635201633,
0.4558937848,
0.4753027558,
-0.0770512894,
-0.094874762,
-0.4436187744,
-0.4126568139,
0.5848919749,
0.2537229061,
-0.3242631257,
0.1739539802,
0.5174044967,
0.9039723277,
-0.2799200714,
0.0853993073,
0.7677426934,
0.3429099917,
-0.1135378778,
-0.6002914906,
0.1956379563,
-0.3203233778,
0.3065307736,
0.1410555691,
-0.3577899933,
0.7332646251,
0.1626883894,
-0.2922695875,
-0.3997600675,
0.7992507815,
0.0901640132,
0.5616282225,
0.6391372681,
0.6440426111,
0.7772362828,
0.2171268165,
0.4067567885,
0.2284119278,
0.1931527704,
1.2617515326,
-0.1121815816,
0.7243744135,
0.285348624,
-0.1123036072,
0.2105030864,
0.5104516149,
0.0088884383,
-0.0794537738,
0.3466641605,
-0.3455978334,
0.0513741896,
-0.5606507659,
-0.1777173877,
0.5559428334,
0.4608195126,
-0.3825250268,
-0.1490394324,
0.0632999688,
0.4855693281,
0.7275179029,
-0.1911361814,
0.8969306946,
0.0080684191,
-0.3978265524,
0.6753100157,
0.2667369246,
1.1476843357,
-0.2307546139,
0.0507956035,
-0.1572117209,
0.0023944268,
-0.5307581425,
-0.5330728292,
0.8120783567,
0.3877243698,
-0.2439926416,
-0.1006435901,
0.6470509768,
-0.6744900346,
-0.3268754184,
0.5097629428,
0.2141463012,
0.1152286232,
-0.4059264362,
-0.6848584414,
0.1040528119,
0.0660737455,
0.126094982,
0.1926181763,
0.5854956508,
-0.2007382959,
0.0920569152,
0.5769078732,
-0.0055381018,
0.2344325483,
0.2937475741,
0.8368114233,
-0.8763363957,
-0.3807959557,
-0.9619165063,
0.3949390352,
-0.3172287941,
-0.5281921029,
0.9751929045,
0.7197750211,
1.1379827261,
0.1853802949,
0.9113918543,
0.0414885171,
1.0620225668,
-0.2328488678,
0.6787643433,
-0.4845321774,
0.1262680888,
-0.6310757995,
-0.6504711509,
-0.8691970706,
0.6177927256,
-0.1660408676,
-0.3178781867,
0.4979974926,
1.0468033552,
0.2217009813,
0.1494782716,
0.578363955,
0.4648933113,
0.4578582644,
0.0993239358,
0.6113445163,
-0.6032676697,
0.5294800997,
-0.3672956824,
-0.3465802073,
-0.3252809346,
-0.6057066321,
-0.855722487,
-0.6566234231,
-0.3936740458,
-0.6186674833,
0.1728449017,
0.9933129549,
0.2709466219,
-0.8951789737,
-0.5792261958,
0.3164747357,
0.1898791045,
0.1165216938,
-0.2578648627,
0.2879354358,
-0.2947722077,
-0.6934692264,
0.147697866,
0.4549988508,
-0.096982874,
0.2138962299,
-0.1783179641,
-0.6287898421,
0.0944357738,
0.8526295424,
0.0771840066,
-0.6458287835,
-0.1908566058,
-0.1699448228,
-0.4831011593,
0.1580043435,
0.7325169444,
-0.5347698331,
0.4128791094,
0.4097551405,
0.8972995877,
0.3197118938,
0.0091648996,
0.2779639363,
-0.6251351833,
0.3055475354,
0.607630372,
-0.0380950235,
0.435893178,
-0.3926704824,
0.5996893048,
0.5136975646,
-0.5174797177,
-0.8353533149,
0.3646562696,
-0.7857760191,
-0.0946665183,
1.4590889215,
0.1042877659,
-0.0490235239,
-0.6047585607,
-0.3889724016,
0.6200630069,
-0.5985046625,
0.7378796935,
0.4149078131,
0.1679115146,
-0.0016961808,
-0.4055545032,
0.8390134573,
0.3756588101,
-0.8788547516,
0.23167032,
0.6139131188,
0.0519071259,
-0.1011406332,
0.9437420964,
-0.0506909117,
0.2492980957,
-0.3816452026,
-0.1254443079,
0.5286520123,
-0.0174095035,
-0.536347568,
0.0104369167,
-0.3031728566,
0.2153996527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06838v1
|
GIELLM: Japanese General Information Extraction Large Language Model Utilizing Mutual Reinforcement Effect
| 2023-11-12T13:30:38 | 2023-11-12T13:30:38 |
Chengguang Gan, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Information Extraction (IE) stands as a cornerstone in natural language
processing, traditionally segmented into distinct sub-tasks. The advent of
Large Language Models (LLMs) heralds a paradigm shift, suggesting the
feasibility of a singular model addressing multiple IE subtasks. In this vein,
we introduce the General Information Extraction Large Language Model (GIELLM),
which integrates text Classification, Sentiment Analysis, Named Entity
Recognition, Relation Extraction, and Event Extraction using a uniform
input-output schema. This innovation marks the first instance of a model
simultaneously handling such a diverse array of IE subtasks. Notably, the
GIELLM leverages the Mutual Reinforcement Effect (MRE), enhancing performance
in integrated tasks compared to their isolated counterparts. Our experiments
demonstrate State-of-the-Art (SOTA) results in five out of six Japanese mixed
datasets, significantly surpassing GPT-3.5-Turbo. Further, an independent
evaluation using the novel Text Classification Relation and Event
Extraction(TCREE) dataset corroborates the synergistic advantages of MRE in
text and word classification. This breakthrough paves the way for most IE
subtasks to be subsumed under a singular LLM framework. Specialized fine-tune
task-specific models are no longer needed.
|
[
-0.5125126839,
-1.1297513247,
0.4298522472,
0.143298164,
-0.2161133885,
-0.0297533609,
-0.3917345405,
-0.693580687,
0.3282067776,
0.4942202568,
-0.4986334741,
-0.5996835232,
-1.0694013834,
0.0866326466,
-0.2357427031,
1.3231550455,
-0.2041496783,
-0.0296940506,
-0.0390146859,
-0.2840953469,
-0.3911283314,
-0.5390095115,
-0.6909986138,
-0.387570411,
0.8983648419,
0.5132593513,
0.4646555185,
0.3895253539,
0.7408564687,
0.313118279,
0.3254193068,
0.058598116,
-0.270588398,
0.2394517958,
-0.3790632486,
-0.4822110832,
-0.5228886008,
0.1691589653,
0.7635549307,
0.4146212041,
-0.1326193213,
0.097721383,
0.0792430565,
0.4480014741,
-0.6765432358,
0.4555499256,
-0.509693563,
-0.0258667693,
-0.2248817384,
-0.2332143039,
-0.3036563396,
-0.238308683,
0.2204510421,
-0.5429261327,
-0.1496503353,
0.0606474616,
1.0682961941,
0.0280381069,
-0.2815072834,
-0.4227532148,
-0.6160293818,
0.8601697683,
-0.5708424449,
0.1654285491,
0.2401776463,
0.2050784081,
-0.2046406865,
-0.7795155048,
-0.4219024777,
-0.223873049,
-0.0070512295,
0.3331184983,
-0.2844197154,
0.1828145683,
0.2745731771,
0.2455514669,
-0.5087767243,
0.2647963166,
-0.1575478464,
0.0075365622,
0.3081149459,
0.1799919307,
0.8674957752,
-0.3245046437,
-0.377302438,
0.0326482095,
-0.4059047103,
-0.0258487109,
0.2208275944,
0.1402676404,
0.043388579,
0.5287207365,
-0.135151431,
0.0534889884,
-0.1460613459,
-0.2940733731,
-0.0008726069,
-0.369576484,
-0.28649351,
-0.0011083101,
1.1895405054,
0.086846523,
0.3453606367,
-0.3125735223,
-0.1031535491,
0.1558299512,
0.0467796773,
-0.8681588173,
0.0798606724,
-0.0424560308,
-0.4202957153,
-0.3064412773,
0.3813505471,
-0.8663408756,
0.0287177637,
-0.1952030659,
0.1965256631,
-0.3491162956,
-0.5853326321,
0.1463827938,
-0.3495330215,
0.1145965829,
0.0964653343,
-0.7721477747,
0.505343914,
0.8429600596,
0.9419757128,
-0.4395622909,
-0.2762528956,
-0.8173925281,
0.399304539,
-0.0177628212,
0.5596313477,
-0.9400157332,
-0.3327008784,
-0.0387589112,
0.1243204772,
-0.2490599453,
-0.4234729707,
0.2973004282,
-0.6847276688,
0.7499269247,
0.1674502939,
-0.3499519229,
-0.2439160794,
0.3728632927,
-0.6396027803,
0.9465191364,
0.0212217383,
-0.9314425588,
0.1285427362,
-0.8810591698,
-0.5532972813,
0.0887133032,
-0.2522501051,
-0.3825855553,
0.0982537791,
0.0693078414,
0.482257843,
-0.5926737785,
0.4938451052,
-0.5988027453,
-0.2207521945,
0.1590039879,
-0.3640974164,
0.3855593801,
0.1015674248,
-0.3193137646,
0.0540237986,
-0.6150742769,
0.0081733922,
0.1163030863,
-0.375398159,
-0.85011971,
-0.0830431357,
-0.1134414375,
0.2575712502,
0.398023814,
-0.3855848014,
0.5411221981,
-0.1703649312,
0.4125020206,
0.4944278598,
0.2474419773,
0.6754731536,
-0.0080248564,
0.8148289323,
0.0148751941,
0.0819613636,
0.0215438828,
-0.2284239084,
-0.4689047635,
-0.6340665221,
0.3820007443,
0.651145637,
-0.872327745,
0.3735257685,
-0.4087662399,
-0.2004894763,
-0.238037169,
-0.1024674848,
0.2584795952,
0.2973102033,
0.2453072667,
-0.4047207832,
-0.562789917,
-0.8996247649,
-0.0800812617,
-0.0818212628,
-0.0014940122,
0.0794337839,
0.3538954556,
-0.625487268,
0.8445497751,
-0.4711934626,
-0.2505522966,
-0.5739786625,
0.8678882122,
0.3419074714,
0.2265207767,
0.2411683202,
-0.6655461788,
-0.3907551765,
0.3329468966,
-1.0462703705,
-0.3089422286,
0.0082387058,
-0.1106759384,
0.0846133083,
0.3795269132,
-0.632481873,
0.1737571657,
0.3927992582,
0.1191997007,
0.7205998898,
-0.0655103549,
0.2862909138,
-1.0879200697,
0.1148134619,
0.276876986,
-0.3027513921,
-0.5501922369,
0.1911032796,
0.0388121903,
0.0824525431,
0.0395574979,
0.5736295581,
-0.6601772904,
-0.193187654,
-0.5726601481,
0.2914712429,
-0.0681368932,
0.4967595339,
0.0406372361,
0.8013404608,
0.2379038185,
-0.6889798641,
0.1438037008,
-0.1264330447,
-0.2411915958,
0.3533786833,
-0.5606440902,
0.2665418386,
-0.2357362807,
-0.0516919531,
-0.7514941692,
-0.2407643497,
0.4562644958,
-0.2892654836,
0.5874863863,
-0.1490705162,
-0.3705511987,
-0.2268144637,
-0.3553799689,
-0.0001793708,
0.3792922497,
-0.268459022,
0.7958464026,
0.6576102972,
-0.9296489358,
-0.7279033661,
-0.3979183137,
0.1420480758,
-0.4671496153,
-0.4003952742,
0.0294056311,
0.1629671156,
-0.2265282273,
0.1597609967,
-0.0995755568,
-0.3053809106,
0.2606362402,
0.2596372366,
0.6808634996,
-0.2134851962,
0.0719582587,
0.1664713472,
-0.2747581005,
0.0312047135,
-0.189186424,
0.6354737282,
0.0151239531,
0.030299766,
-0.4975428879,
0.486540556,
0.5509358048,
-0.2382706851,
0.5486684442,
0.7581758499,
-0.2107073367,
-0.0256599654,
-0.4176280499,
-0.119259946,
-0.4051218331,
0.8764855862,
-0.5381003618,
-1.0069127083,
0.2540112138,
-0.329274565,
0.0024898555,
0.393614918,
0.1376493126,
-0.085816592,
1.2489879131,
0.6141502261,
-0.7297631502,
0.901845336,
-0.0089573795,
0.0255467854,
-0.9074767232,
0.1224810705,
-0.6587114334,
-0.2506716549,
-0.3688791096,
-0.0089966124,
0.3961363435,
0.3809140623,
0.0909098163,
0.2405178845,
-0.1250209808,
0.3211877048,
0.4053082168,
-0.0816714391,
0.3965981007,
0.2523125112,
-0.0955591649,
-0.1271494776,
-0.6275601983,
-0.5159670115,
0.8759978414,
0.3291415274,
0.6699166298,
-0.1648420393,
0.7262994647,
0.3461154401,
0.5630643964,
-0.6849957108,
0.6964108348,
-0.2560169101,
-0.307902813,
-0.330278337,
-0.7127498388,
-0.9937061667,
0.4179550111,
-0.0837173983,
-0.8562162519,
-0.2903091013,
-0.3505539298,
0.2412012964,
0.1258414239,
-0.5546239018,
0.5788981318,
-0.0817103386,
-0.4002779424,
-0.4837147295,
-0.3490331471,
0.5537817478,
0.0146502461,
0.5583254099,
-0.1526623368,
-0.0315630995,
0.8254302144,
-0.0665687323,
0.5313997269,
-0.3344324827,
-0.0264705066,
0.0927751437,
0.0321838968,
0.9777463675,
-0.0141279055,
0.0690560937,
0.2699646354,
-0.0840961039,
-0.1021042392,
-0.7457737923,
0.6498842239,
-0.7261944413,
-0.5544403195,
-0.4744307399,
-0.5670931935,
-0.2296044528,
0.3404506743,
0.0971348211,
0.4761134684,
-0.3492516875,
0.1201204062,
0.3897519708,
-0.1161364838,
0.4607584178,
0.7075287104,
-0.3695409596,
-0.7215307951,
0.8875133395,
0.2135271877,
0.201710403,
0.4019325376,
0.1633626223,
-0.230820626,
-0.496270746,
-0.2108006179,
0.3542200923,
-0.3716920614,
-0.0033116145,
-0.8652581573,
-0.1187625304,
-0.2579304278,
0.2633808255,
-0.1005211473,
-0.2323044688,
-0.0943096131,
-0.1902989149,
-0.190423131,
0.7812470794,
-0.0639098063,
0.2885302007,
-1.0278255939,
0.4278413951,
0.2047863305,
-0.0409590751,
-0.1685920209,
-0.1979911029,
-0.3194063008,
-0.0072870571,
-0.0695855245,
-0.7848765254,
0.4291285276,
0.0505437292,
0.6450760961,
0.4224209785,
-0.123438932,
0.6603355408,
-0.4046868682,
0.5135974288,
0.5952445865,
-0.6707075834,
0.2914287746,
-0.3988914788,
0.2909121215,
0.4697060585,
0.559784472,
-0.8453486562,
-0.6111193299,
-0.6633800864,
-0.8351994753,
0.6944740415,
-0.2169220001,
-0.2169793546,
-0.2134356052,
0.2244324237,
0.3453759849,
0.3503967822,
-0.8021506071,
0.1084429324,
0.2581878006,
-0.5081554055,
0.0828949809,
-0.371504277,
0.1801035851,
0.0596291535,
0.8478116989,
-0.0846917033,
0.3228736222,
0.1379602104,
-0.4610460997,
-0.0553050637,
0.6496310234,
0.2447532713,
0.2276990563,
-0.0103796208,
0.2218798399,
0.0383722708,
-0.4664400518,
-0.0044207112,
0.0128011154,
-0.2657640576,
-0.0207586102,
0.4926104844,
0.6809860468,
0.4622640908,
-0.3288646042,
0.3649652898,
-0.2634253502,
-0.2404186279,
-0.0838494673,
0.3973933756,
-0.1429910511,
0.3409982324,
0.2544816732,
-0.2605379522,
0.2818528414,
-0.7724597454,
0.2613634467,
0.6374010444,
-0.4022866786,
-0.4767327905,
0.4160946906,
0.0011668418,
0.0079849651,
0.4786534011,
-0.1213439405,
-0.4899996221,
0.5731484294,
0.5953899026,
0.9427098036,
-0.0391074605,
0.3775088787,
0.3355688453,
0.1781643927,
-0.2460861802,
0.0459728837,
-0.0490831248,
-0.7610097528,
-0.5597941875,
-0.5102230906,
-0.4519694448,
0.2697480321,
-0.9845784903,
0.0241622273,
-0.4123600125,
-0.1649300009,
-0.1880427599,
0.1361774504,
-0.5383107662,
0.0713181645,
-0.0271704979,
0.4336534739,
-0.5977637172,
1.1787884235,
0.7073099613,
-0.5327028632,
-0.6751959324,
-0.0722814649,
-0.2534376383,
-0.7527679205,
0.6007265449,
0.2770256698,
-0.1637488902,
0.0231133178,
-0.5957280993,
-0.6428137422,
0.97113657,
0.1078927293,
-0.8754790425,
-0.1362436563,
0.1977064461,
0.3389338851,
-0.5248610377,
0.6030876637,
0.5578805804,
0.7507551908,
-0.2351687849,
-0.6133437753,
-0.030572325,
-0.2257651538,
-0.0955065861,
0.4087632895,
-0.4889431,
0.5802863836,
0.1793329418,
-0.5203911066,
-0.0237465985,
0.5994202495,
0.083896108,
0.2365750521,
0.5078912973,
0.3127531707,
0.9895795584,
-0.0872919485,
1.0394108295,
-0.0623647496,
0.2687667906,
1.1831974983,
-0.5076068044,
0.7312803864,
0.3570498228,
-0.0929845423,
0.6695202589,
0.1012396142,
0.3753738105,
0.6075187922,
-0.1067910567,
-0.2001934648,
-0.0862388313,
-0.2040496618,
-0.3770829737,
0.2798466384,
0.3592472374,
-0.107118167,
-0.1499617696,
0.2699450552,
0.3121304214,
-0.2801788747,
-0.3322555423,
1.0848168135,
0.1781173646,
-0.6318085194,
0.0585455634,
0.0953333825,
0.9374851584,
-1.0857614279,
0.1511871517,
-0.2089433074,
0.1440059245,
-0.0108956946,
-0.4960874319,
0.0757346451,
0.0250062905,
-0.4855183065,
-0.0972682238,
1.163490653,
-0.597908318,
-0.1071304083,
0.7053025961,
0.2876362801,
0.0894889161,
-0.1913980693,
-0.5543870926,
0.0152078085,
-0.0199094452,
-0.4527276158,
0.7125358582,
0.6359246969,
0.0314007401,
0.4950322211,
0.6457225084,
0.4100241959,
-0.0690904036,
0.0642242357,
0.6425734162,
-1.0076333284,
-0.501020968,
-0.9044998884,
0.3270882368,
-0.4201213419,
-0.0888219252,
0.629186213,
0.3922739923,
0.4536755383,
-0.0108566461,
1.3582406044,
0.0307502747,
0.3868162334,
-0.5842164159,
0.2797016799,
-0.5149689317,
-0.0581143089,
-0.4416469634,
-0.9623258114,
-0.0335975178,
0.50249511,
-0.5128930211,
-0.3673550785,
1.025981307,
0.4595396221,
0.0342488475,
0.2222852856,
0.2785668969,
0.3289826512,
0.5896596313,
0.6067979932,
0.9148259759,
-0.3051320612,
0.4521070123,
0.2272959352,
-0.3727275431,
-0.1760753244,
-0.6889331341,
-0.7276439071,
-0.2165649235,
-0.346848309,
0.027815707,
0.1877686977,
0.8610674143,
0.381069243,
-0.6780849099,
-0.1228871197,
-0.1025042012,
0.1100538671,
-0.1209219247,
-0.3581710756,
-0.0334155522,
-0.5495678186,
-0.9063466787,
0.424344331,
0.7090727687,
-0.2175824046,
0.0439046659,
-0.213934809,
-0.2066786289,
-0.0975364968,
0.4807922244,
0.3574763238,
-0.2374950349,
-0.6399310231,
-0.2440757453,
-0.462905556,
0.1305745393,
0.6390035152,
-0.3296414018,
0.1052105203,
0.4558692276,
0.7237612009,
0.6932070255,
-0.0435298383,
0.6914271712,
-0.5161371231,
0.0915756747,
-0.1741899997,
0.5299125314,
-0.1458903104,
-0.1717062891,
0.7084569335,
0.3103592098,
-0.5282564163,
-0.6055324078,
0.1350912899,
-0.9279268384,
-0.3045398295,
1.2782968283,
-0.1810911447,
-0.3719220161,
-0.1195841506,
-0.3113663197,
0.2946064472,
-0.4804457128,
0.6098417044,
1.0897181034,
0.240164727,
-0.173994109,
-0.4579895437,
-0.1400361955,
0.3429795802,
-1.122059226,
-0.1297006905,
0.527682364,
0.4710519612,
0.0704675242,
0.7709957957,
-0.1410121173,
0.0229552165,
-0.2106585503,
0.3330866694,
-0.2907592654,
-0.6346209645,
-0.1780910641,
0.7210192084,
-0.0822246298,
-0.2985132039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06818v1
|
Cricket Player Profiling: Unraveling Strengths and Weaknesses Using Text Commentary Data
| 2023-11-12T11:51:05 | 2023-11-12T11:51:05 |
Swarup Ranjan Behera, Vijaya V. Saradhi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Devising player-specific strategies in cricket necessitates a meticulous
understanding of each player's unique strengths and weaknesses. Nevertheless,
the absence of a definitive computational approach to extract such insights
from cricket players poses a significant challenge. This paper seeks to address
this gap by establishing computational models designed to extract the rules
governing player strengths and weaknesses, thereby facilitating the development
of tailored strategies for individual players. The complexity of this endeavor
lies in several key areas: the selection of a suitable dataset, the precise
definition of strength and weakness rules, the identification of an appropriate
learning algorithm, and the validation of the derived rules. To tackle these
challenges, we propose the utilization of unstructured data, specifically
cricket text commentary, as a valuable resource for constructing comprehensive
strength and weakness rules for cricket players. We also introduce
computationally feasible definitions for the construction of these rules, and
present a dimensionality reduction technique for the rule-building process. In
order to showcase the practicality of this approach, we conduct an in-depth
analysis of cricket player strengths and weaknesses using a vast corpus of more
than one million text commentaries. Furthermore, we validate the constructed
rules through two distinct methodologies: intrinsic and extrinsic. The outcomes
of this research are made openly accessible, including the collected data,
source code, and results for over 250 cricket players, which can be accessed at
https://bit.ly/2PKuzx8.
|
[
-0.3785844743,
-0.619140923,
0.2843221724,
0.3116986156,
-0.2269946486,
0.4177021086,
-0.260170877,
-0.3129285872,
0.2363196164,
0.2654647827,
-0.7762514949,
-0.3250430822,
-0.7644488215,
0.308037281,
-0.2193108052,
1.2120423317,
0.0388370641,
-0.0547678806,
-0.3568562269,
-0.3057692349,
-0.8632190228,
-0.4559058547,
-0.2170637995,
-0.1672136933,
-0.0078010312,
0.582475543,
0.5407446623,
0.6368395686,
0.9435589314,
0.378082782,
-0.3583927155,
0.2542401254,
-0.6077844501,
0.6287741661,
-0.4627347887,
-0.4398333132,
-0.4479452372,
-0.060578797,
0.5275138617,
0.7691482306,
0.0801104754,
0.3428226709,
0.0301841795,
0.5147718787,
-0.5422616005,
0.3743292391,
-0.6288518906,
0.4205223918,
-0.6532776952,
-0.4803807437,
-0.252802819,
-0.1601030231,
-0.1578379422,
-0.3423140347,
0.5250600576,
-0.1777274311,
0.5930122733,
0.2565918267,
-0.4250381887,
-0.3680880368,
-0.8941923976,
0.81699121,
-0.6388962269,
0.1760022342,
0.3316273987,
0.3257877827,
0.1831714064,
0.0137849469,
-0.2061836571,
-0.0201816857,
-0.2621876001,
0.4626788795,
0.1554023474,
-0.2026670575,
0.7062280774,
0.4593677223,
-0.3256980777,
-0.144254148,
-0.6498626471,
0.2571863532,
0.9972416162,
0.3028949201,
0.5058400631,
-0.1915439665,
-0.096569404,
0.0094868783,
-0.2351501733,
0.6515123248,
0.5072243214,
0.6934359074,
-0.2779564261,
0.7645366788,
0.1838087738,
0.0913406387,
0.3621897399,
-0.5014787316,
0.1821650863,
-0.3375546932,
0.256136477,
0.0902205408,
0.4418253303,
0.1221592724,
0.0387876146,
-0.3039171994,
-0.0757453218,
-0.2640808225,
0.4048126936,
-0.8659290075,
-0.3111726344,
0.1846762449,
-0.8962504864,
-0.6158903837,
0.3913246095,
-1.3184034824,
-0.9683530927,
-0.0379758589,
0.2653128207,
-0.4405488968,
-0.3598240912,
-0.3451296985,
-0.7339355946,
0.5430717468,
-0.3277292252,
-1.1570214033,
0.4106247723,
0.3054008186,
0.5877622366,
-0.3073281944,
0.0549222156,
-0.5189456344,
0.2450866401,
-0.178429395,
0.808303535,
-0.6144330502,
-0.8059461117,
0.0662292987,
-0.3900662661,
0.2304420769,
-0.4525020123,
0.7896783352,
0.1548971534,
-0.2542331219,
-0.4523628056,
-0.2106315345,
0.2024461329,
0.1534339637,
-0.7864336967,
0.8574283719,
0.5101071,
-1.0417681932,
0.4402138591,
-0.6552571654,
-0.9336032271,
0.0658267364,
-0.1889859885,
-0.7477046847,
0.5274549723,
0.2391463667,
0.300157845,
-0.5585207343,
-0.4078530669,
-0.61623317,
-0.4817524552,
0.202348277,
-0.097770676,
0.9005221725,
-0.0163305216,
-0.3386125863,
-0.1239852384,
-1.0474977493,
0.4380947948,
0.2307325006,
-0.1539561301,
0.0955193043,
0.5831518173,
-0.3572449684,
0.0563233271,
-0.2606542706,
-0.473859936,
0.2390196323,
-0.6121539474,
0.4955474436,
0.5620592833,
0.2939992249,
0.2941235602,
0.1030948907,
0.543181479,
-0.2287981659,
0.5545926094,
-0.0124315536,
-0.2021093369,
-0.2523587942,
-0.306353718,
0.150245741,
0.4881184697,
-0.3876550198,
0.2273082137,
-0.1998920739,
-0.6305046082,
-0.3985131979,
0.6401122808,
0.3963209689,
0.2527429163,
0.5697574019,
-0.4071376622,
-0.7415070534,
-0.7216671705,
-0.5517114401,
-0.4554886222,
0.354940027,
0.5595962405,
0.1551087946,
-0.0308669116,
0.7056928873,
-0.6295915246,
-0.3417187333,
-0.6902695894,
-0.0066405125,
0.0696995631,
0.4613554478,
0.583752811,
-1.0643771887,
-0.5248730779,
-0.117473729,
-1.1125481129,
-0.4148665369,
-0.0316271521,
0.1709092706,
-0.286127001,
0.4324204624,
-0.5451692939,
0.9045634866,
0.4202781916,
-0.2806042433,
0.6276735663,
-0.1779498011,
0.0728913248,
-0.5740290284,
0.0813633278,
0.0363285504,
0.3061544597,
-0.6148813367,
0.2770481706,
-0.4184435904,
-0.1875212491,
-0.0568712279,
0.1591108441,
-0.3175830543,
0.1934952438,
-0.1402647197,
-0.1307348311,
-0.1300819665,
0.4600153267,
-0.3204422891,
0.6569670439,
0.1159857586,
-0.3993518651,
0.334894985,
0.3979429901,
0.3097192049,
0.7952727079,
-0.9646476507,
-0.0805687085,
-0.074797526,
-0.2719286382,
-0.9592612982,
-0.3903625607,
0.1812463552,
-0.6640061736,
0.7132514119,
-0.2543461323,
0.0110170795,
-0.6029027104,
-0.5192033052,
0.9115688205,
0.4545728266,
-0.3141844869,
0.9985278845,
0.7831575274,
-0.113201879,
-0.3744988739,
-0.3781304657,
0.0056462609,
-0.4287104309,
-0.2188580632,
0.4928333461,
-0.4592597783,
-0.4627064764,
-0.1920724809,
-0.398647815,
-0.370939672,
0.161761865,
0.7754607201,
-0.0174376741,
0.2383015007,
-0.1265013367,
-0.2149266154,
-0.055259753,
0.1826051772,
0.0933206007,
0.3389149904,
0.2006936967,
-0.0936950669,
-0.3866900802,
0.7288392186,
0.1600760967,
-0.5669232011,
0.5954437256,
0.6106756926,
0.0470012873,
-0.804485023,
-0.2523594499,
0.0524276532,
-0.4701115787,
0.3416730762,
-0.5665869117,
-0.3704557717,
0.4373130202,
-0.1441438943,
-0.3562806845,
0.692363739,
0.4249305129,
-0.3151119053,
1.3378123045,
0.8974999189,
-0.0226455405,
-0.1465301216,
-0.0879612267,
0.3533828259,
-0.4852428734,
-0.653660357,
-0.7422246337,
-0.1151664332,
-0.6362243891,
0.1298604906,
0.2428633869,
0.1393493712,
-0.3524066508,
0.3397102058,
-0.6553782821,
0.7369154692,
0.2807588577,
0.2911745012,
-0.2238283455,
-0.3528858423,
-0.0362528749,
-0.1996716708,
-0.2707817256,
0.0230879318,
1.002351284,
0.1513151824,
0.462356925,
0.5695810914,
0.5444532037,
0.7364351153,
-0.1650031656,
-0.6373668909,
0.502399981,
-0.0667773336,
-0.6770224571,
-0.1818287969,
-0.6303319931,
-0.4736978412,
-0.3943578005,
-0.586304903,
-0.3599977493,
0.0115862051,
0.07434275,
-0.3103162646,
0.4792033434,
-0.646761179,
0.4362875521,
-0.3721439838,
-0.5628451705,
0.1780886948,
-0.5366836786,
0.4402726591,
-0.2738542557,
0.1839427799,
0.1555401236,
0.232947275,
0.4515200257,
-0.8556427956,
0.8307564259,
-0.3943383396,
0.1431717128,
0.440066427,
0.1839326918,
0.1407016069,
0.0695070326,
0.1196269393,
-0.0002176279,
0.1802488863,
-0.7540789247,
-0.3401499987,
0.2703209221,
-0.8773416877,
-0.3977703452,
-0.3534002602,
-0.1976386607,
-0.4933715463,
0.1714211553,
0.2811265886,
0.4887725413,
-0.2923061848,
0.3960037529,
0.6300388575,
-0.2538642287,
0.4635614157,
-0.0085638873,
0.2761206925,
-0.3685883582,
0.9869824052,
0.2106299549,
-0.3748666942,
0.4061197639,
0.1857237369,
-0.2268419117,
-1.1334694624,
0.2756222188,
0.0676945224,
-0.5025874972,
-0.4317849576,
0.0730399489,
-0.4377390146,
-0.3603341281,
0.0706170574,
-0.2582961917,
-0.2455119044,
0.4079504311,
-0.1059927046,
-0.0010188118,
1.1725873947,
-0.0188426711,
0.3557212651,
-0.6855632663,
0.2998455465,
0.4185745716,
0.732206285,
-0.0046212622,
-0.3247282505,
-0.2611881793,
-0.1021154746,
-0.3478339612,
-1.0048320293,
0.3776213527,
0.1404622793,
0.5704529285,
0.5590184927,
0.1455263495,
0.8008939624,
-0.4175435603,
0.8541533351,
0.0489764623,
-0.9420981407,
0.5434445739,
-0.4341697395,
-0.4971570373,
0.9176310897,
0.2210629433,
-0.0391071253,
0.059752766,
-0.5086475015,
-0.9113920927,
0.6335984468,
0.3436099291,
-0.1480963081,
-0.1382810473,
0.732267499,
0.1509178728,
0.0512450449,
-0.1663011611,
-0.0722693205,
-0.3830175698,
-0.3567705154,
-0.0006804881,
-0.2876206338,
0.012353681,
-0.4391508996,
0.4360872209,
0.1074698642,
0.0782308951,
0.2154972702,
-0.3279722035,
0.0279827956,
-0.2440866232,
0.2084854096,
0.5762396455,
-0.4765325785,
0.0498997159,
0.476606518,
-0.5435013175,
0.0987844691,
-0.1200487465,
-0.0912931412,
-0.3552963734,
0.7822393775,
-0.0342622958,
0.3150402606,
-0.7111051679,
0.6295788288,
0.0097761517,
-0.4792324901,
-0.3757750094,
0.2459119707,
-0.2313391864,
0.2239665389,
0.1620127708,
0.2683366239,
0.0022705887,
-0.6879420877,
0.2738666832,
0.4439476132,
-0.7935470343,
-0.5751059055,
0.7746835947,
0.1508143693,
-0.437569499,
0.480866462,
-0.4143841267,
-0.5903146863,
0.4639968276,
0.3168473244,
0.4839782715,
-0.2147612572,
0.2083569914,
0.3332612514,
-0.0322511755,
0.1668165922,
0.1277881563,
0.0446064956,
-0.3528600931,
-0.2609444559,
-0.4542493224,
-0.2420305312,
-0.2494497448,
-0.5351151824,
0.0500113294,
-0.9058994651,
-0.3639099598,
0.3189930022,
0.5589020252,
-0.8667318821,
0.2036733031,
0.1155730486,
0.7931171656,
-0.7326936722,
0.3065076768,
0.4461216629,
-1.1726769209,
-0.8422895074,
-0.0243652835,
0.4376039505,
-0.7674234509,
0.7478206754,
-0.1606228203,
0.0291829966,
-0.3983231187,
-0.6418348551,
-0.15222992,
1.0348937511,
-0.3155098855,
0.2378198951,
0.0476629958,
0.4636239409,
0.5144141316,
-0.0975898057,
0.7419515252,
0.5539054275,
0.5587627888,
0.1031124294,
-0.4351978898,
0.0858899355,
-0.5637423992,
-0.0659835562,
0.2945437729,
-1.1831150055,
0.942635417,
-0.1590003669,
-0.0719388276,
0.0428770855,
0.6183034778,
-0.1413520575,
0.0400565788,
0.4254105091,
0.4896278679,
0.716206491,
-0.0238339398,
0.7337720394,
-0.2622570992,
0.0610172451,
0.7027545571,
-0.4678314626,
0.5758141875,
0.0890863761,
-0.3537890017,
0.3756999671,
-0.0010017118,
-0.4557255507,
0.2439948767,
0.2766444087,
-0.0429149792,
-0.2449317127,
0.0159693584,
-0.0059907907,
1.0924196243,
-0.1187698469,
-0.0673667043,
-0.1769892275,
-0.4141764939,
0.0120938225,
0.5093396306,
-0.4490706027,
0.9741179347,
-0.3408613205,
-0.4268062115,
0.0462610833,
0.1073537618,
0.544722259,
-0.8211680055,
-0.2860601544,
-0.2763867378,
0.5692557096,
-0.3251508772,
-0.7999338508,
0.3674227297,
0.3139105737,
-0.589315474,
0.1581255794,
0.9971368313,
0.0463045873,
-0.3945045173,
0.1845119298,
0.4866430461,
0.0112395398,
-0.1262829155,
-0.4833782017,
0.0148092257,
0.078743659,
0.2051399052,
0.5810925961,
0.559371531,
-0.0028440263,
0.5853632092,
0.6001426578,
0.5099723339,
-0.2127625793,
-0.1491955519,
0.7477873564,
-0.998777926,
-0.0179249216,
-1.1376179457,
0.3639301956,
-0.7765510082,
-0.5007894039,
1.0258193016,
0.6423512101,
0.3593429029,
0.2518722117,
0.7520157099,
-0.0610313527,
0.6278739572,
-0.0529844426,
0.8553166389,
-0.222119391,
0.2929166257,
-0.2208929807,
-0.5595581532,
-0.410525322,
0.3511119187,
0.2688681185,
0.1400903463,
0.2691549361,
0.4727346003,
0.0900347903,
0.2059762031,
-0.2818677425,
0.3489183187,
0.5366494656,
0.5949705839,
0.5438723564,
-0.1579984576,
0.8246790171,
-0.2518684268,
-0.4786551595,
-0.1148627475,
-0.9085900187,
-1.4053459167,
-0.3608187139,
-0.0741919503,
-0.477763176,
0.0403160155,
0.9262827039,
0.6997333169,
-0.7108214498,
-0.0461679213,
0.2863099277,
-0.0696136355,
-0.5803539753,
-0.1746457815,
0.5480561256,
-0.4812939167,
-0.1929063946,
0.2659853995,
0.1932154,
-0.2532982528,
0.1286500692,
-0.1405204087,
0.1599016935,
0.5733945966,
0.6687677503,
0.8715699315,
0.1148185357,
-0.2818161845,
-0.1241689846,
0.1649644673,
-0.1307179034,
0.8785648346,
-0.6604012251,
0.3618005514,
0.6116193533,
0.4863980114,
0.1167859733,
0.3267418444,
0.3247231245,
-1.1438755989,
-0.0727538541,
0.301794827,
0.0735085607,
0.0120896213,
-0.0801871791,
0.5691951513,
0.599163115,
-0.2617717683,
-1.1389079094,
-0.1885574758,
-0.9476037025,
-0.5040732026,
0.9157721996,
0.1401859969,
-0.3132983744,
-0.0896444842,
-0.2538747489,
0.2384527922,
0.1333766878,
0.9148135185,
0.6080316305,
-0.189775005,
0.1871915311,
-0.4485806227,
0.9173975587,
0.1010089368,
-0.4722370207,
0.1525215507,
-0.009128564,
-0.0075693955,
-0.0612490736,
0.4262879491,
-0.3898219466,
-0.1600982398,
0.3743465245,
-0.2129135579,
-0.4548701048,
-0.5068933368,
0.1053634509,
0.6890203953,
-0.0395229235,
0.4345625341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06815v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06815v1
|
Evaluation of GPT-4 for chest X-ray impression generation: A reader study on performance and perception
| 2023-11-12T11:40:57 | 2023-11-12T11:40:57 |
Sebastian Ziegelmayer, Alexander W. Marka, Nicolas Lenhart, Nadja Nehls, Stefan Reischl, Felix Harder, Andreas Sauter, Marcus Makowski, Markus Graf, Joshua Gawlitza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The remarkable generative capabilities of multimodal foundation models are
currently being explored for a variety of applications. Generating radiological
impressions is a challenging task that could significantly reduce the workload
of radiologists. In our study we explored and analyzed the generative abilities
of GPT-4 for Chest X-ray impression generation. To generate and evaluate
impressions of chest X-rays based on different input modalities (image, text,
text and image), a blinded radiological report was written for 25-cases of the
publicly available NIH-dataset. GPT-4 was given image, finding section or both
sequentially to generate an input dependent impression. In a blind randomized
reading, 4-radiologists rated the impressions and were asked to classify the
impression origin (Human, AI), providing justification for their decision.
Lastly text model evaluation metrics and their correlation with the
radiological score (summation of the 4 dimensions) was assessed. According to
the radiological score, the human-written impression was rated highest,
although not significantly different to text-based impressions. The automated
evaluation metrics showed moderate to substantial correlations to the
radiological score for the image impressions, however individual scores were
highly divergent among inputs, indicating insufficient representation of
radiological quality. Detection of AI-generated impressions varied by input and
was 61% for text-based impressions. Impressions classified as AI-generated had
significantly worse radiological scores even when written by a radiologist,
indicating potential bias. Our study revealed significant discrepancies between
a radiological assessment and common automatic evaluation metrics depending on
the model input. The detection of AI-generated findings is subject to bias that
highly rated impressions are perceived as human-written.
|
[
-0.4135262668,
-0.3915592134,
0.9049960375,
0.1142003313,
-0.4059222043,
-0.1331487596,
0.1024976075,
-0.6765065193,
-0.092505224,
0.3604544997,
-0.3128929436,
-0.4365107417,
-0.6045612693,
0.4036405385,
-0.1677944213,
0.9797252417,
0.1763537079,
0.1824111938,
-0.4767691791,
0.0994907394,
-0.7424007654,
-0.246241793,
-0.4096855819,
-0.4858843386,
0.0961558297,
-0.1862470359,
0.9047169089,
0.4159069657,
0.5420341492,
0.3123922348,
0.3546519876,
-0.1620778441,
-0.2799984217,
-0.2070266455,
-0.0762400776,
-0.1801603138,
-0.3275590539,
0.1215099543,
0.65959692,
0.2356830537,
0.0408977419,
-0.0837646872,
-0.2938096225,
0.6100196242,
-0.4522390068,
0.1901516616,
-0.1058922708,
0.2305338979,
-0.2196241915,
-0.652671814,
-0.4126317203,
-0.2073957473,
0.5211223364,
-0.4173854887,
0.4056012034,
-0.1976376325,
0.8490925431,
0.0030377654,
-0.3932145536,
-0.5134532452,
-0.7654595971,
0.5278460383,
-0.2511982918,
0.4995718002,
0.2899502218,
0.2996122539,
0.4843790829,
-0.9525191784,
-0.3369419575,
-0.4571378529,
-0.3482764363,
0.517991662,
-0.3658063114,
0.1042487472,
0.229247272,
0.6536079645,
-0.9173027277,
-0.3038869798,
-0.3685449958,
-0.2780430317,
0.6102626324,
-0.0511805117,
0.300229758,
-0.679025054,
-0.6380623579,
-0.3370809257,
-0.4997353256,
-0.2466320395,
0.0683367178,
-0.2230672538,
0.0596237183,
0.2676370144,
-0.3543067873,
0.8300383091,
0.1119110435,
-0.2734410763,
0.7243638635,
-0.4871558845,
-0.4990853667,
-0.0441808216,
0.7611197233,
0.3253946602,
-0.1979731917,
0.0680156201,
-0.3133428395,
0.2738871276,
0.5185022354,
-0.862849474,
-0.0709186047,
-0.0888447538,
-0.68265903,
-0.907027483,
0.342071712,
-0.5400691628,
-0.4597804248,
-0.1176943332,
0.6545927525,
-0.6120285392,
-0.2154318094,
0.1331618279,
-0.1864957511,
0.0958997384,
0.3447756171,
-0.4654896259,
0.2234159857,
0.0384292565,
0.7398201227,
0.1127810851,
-0.0709346011,
-0.0544647984,
0.0069874241,
-0.2117171437,
0.938133657,
-0.3454411328,
-0.6906732321,
-0.3667100072,
-0.3415069878,
-0.1028891727,
-0.704382956,
0.7032607198,
-0.4378775358,
0.499103874,
-0.0563968346,
-0.2817503214,
-0.1504288614,
0.3898727596,
-0.8839553595,
0.5955345631,
0.4796004295,
-0.6033653617,
0.5973154306,
-0.4124026597,
-0.4405891001,
0.4138465822,
-0.8788306713,
-0.3846639693,
0.3161522746,
0.4948072433,
0.3801273704,
-0.3710687459,
0.0672139078,
0.3453358412,
-0.1354583949,
0.5083791614,
-0.6696771383,
0.4757855237,
0.0606597587,
-0.6748500466,
-0.1485597938,
-0.7484212518,
0.3463234305,
0.083745271,
-0.2702743113,
-0.0347135104,
-0.3795382679,
-0.0668030232,
0.5505905151,
-0.1840947866,
-0.6381983757,
0.0698795095,
-0.1802332997,
0.1266307533,
0.5841943026,
0.5477226973,
-0.1172543615,
-0.5385844111,
0.8362264633,
-0.1721201539,
0.1766941845,
-0.0234702025,
-0.6853868961,
-0.2089055032,
-0.2267931849,
0.1747393906,
0.2027865499,
-0.900971055,
-0.0847835392,
-0.2140252292,
-0.4755267501,
-0.300701499,
-0.1358576119,
0.8959669471,
0.5791520476,
0.227161482,
-0.6188814044,
-0.2102401257,
-1.0568401814,
-0.0397913121,
-0.1618024856,
0.0145009961,
0.5514403582,
0.2728561163,
-0.2280683666,
0.5654342771,
-0.7171100974,
-0.6475655437,
-0.1286680549,
0.2967711985,
-0.0687293261,
0.155999139,
0.681122005,
-0.8339453936,
-0.4358371496,
0.0083657755,
-0.9083451629,
-0.0568196848,
-0.1446497589,
0.0111566735,
0.1936158985,
0.2621471584,
-0.5992740393,
0.4826795757,
0.6718364954,
-0.2254431397,
0.69299227,
-0.3133485913,
0.4105640948,
-0.5671510696,
-0.1223298162,
0.144045338,
-0.1749469489,
-0.5239987373,
0.0535343215,
0.0579346903,
-0.3217698038,
-0.2489424348,
0.4561134875,
-0.7067170143,
-0.0860612541,
-0.0439926945,
-0.0456793606,
0.4146735966,
0.1379745752,
0.2014897764,
0.4842860699,
0.3818826079,
-0.1604761332,
0.1721604317,
0.3216162026,
-0.5864779949,
0.8088760376,
-0.4836812913,
0.341920048,
0.1550406218,
0.3922934234,
-0.8791908622,
-0.2595264912,
0.0964090601,
-0.4916990399,
0.6508852243,
0.2070079893,
-0.3291017413,
-0.4507469833,
-0.2581587136,
0.4093571305,
0.4310243428,
-0.2495562881,
0.5441836715,
-0.0184536818,
-0.1879182607,
-0.3912258148,
-0.8729414344,
0.1894731969,
0.0847150013,
-0.7631348372,
0.5938007236,
0.0591202006,
-0.119197093,
0.135241285,
-0.0709579587,
-0.0421436951,
-0.4165768623,
0.3394069076,
0.1323452741,
-0.0282384772,
0.0173322223,
-0.1768100113,
-0.1759488881,
0.1816489398,
-0.1580799222,
0.2717548907,
-0.369671762,
-0.392837733,
-0.5549702644,
0.1967336833,
0.5552229285,
0.014335488,
0.122854434,
0.5478705764,
-0.3222268522,
0.1323083192,
-0.763282001,
-0.0181766134,
-0.3708617687,
0.4738258421,
-0.5032296181,
-0.4084999561,
0.0040257671,
0.1296166629,
-0.471978277,
0.615927875,
0.9146578908,
-0.078769967,
1.0735541582,
0.2996893823,
0.2206224501,
0.1782904714,
-0.4381642342,
-0.0588889308,
-0.7933464646,
-0.2372633517,
-0.2012131959,
-0.1471529305,
-0.4869252443,
-0.3364956677,
0.6350648999,
-0.498606652,
0.409519732,
-0.3175348938,
-0.7798256278,
0.1843690723,
0.2979130447,
0.6378232241,
0.4446413517,
0.0563339218,
-0.1458901465,
-0.0824653581,
-0.4887101948,
-0.4678441882,
1.3615497351,
0.1235037744,
0.4801321924,
0.3102873862,
0.7120227814,
0.4976851046,
0.4760585427,
-0.5580859184,
0.2961902022,
-0.094332695,
-0.7223318815,
-0.0823702738,
-0.423427254,
-0.893245399,
0.3218255937,
-0.2502941191,
-0.3185525835,
0.2936363518,
0.1631051302,
-0.5068338513,
-0.1668203473,
-0.7014021873,
0.7227395773,
-0.6163716912,
-0.2629921734,
-0.1961004734,
-0.60978508,
0.604414463,
-0.4449286759,
0.2074274868,
0.2610837221,
0.2017194033,
0.6128153205,
-0.5299460292,
0.6880503297,
-0.3767388165,
0.1151683852,
0.1804162264,
0.0564962439,
0.1862009019,
0.2346831411,
-0.2305931896,
0.1620026678,
-0.0586112402,
0.0999312475,
-0.706296742,
0.6222192049,
-1.242862463,
-0.4780744016,
-0.6518664956,
-0.4553459883,
-0.2793770134,
0.3564502597,
0.7922270894,
1.0180500746,
-0.5872280598,
0.0212626699,
0.2711384892,
-0.2871290445,
-0.1007756963,
0.1134555712,
-0.0219323635,
-0.5997011065,
0.9395314455,
0.2575665414,
0.4447000921,
0.381336838,
0.5809108019,
-0.4462765157,
-0.5246165991,
-0.5681355,
0.4648299217,
-0.7463776469,
-0.2245816886,
-0.4126909673,
-0.1744203866,
-0.3022609055,
-0.1758322716,
0.0793775544,
-0.3416603804,
-0.0372203551,
-0.1343029886,
0.0448742993,
1.010011673,
0.0153233819,
0.1256538182,
-0.5049972534,
0.2809589207,
0.316385448,
0.270645529,
-0.1777070463,
-0.395667851,
-0.2973351777,
-0.4211552441,
-0.6455821991,
-0.8442489505,
0.311260432,
0.1464223564,
0.4980483949,
0.5329914093,
-0.1183196306,
0.3551196456,
-0.224316597,
0.6589210033,
0.2185594887,
-0.7401815653,
0.4171502888,
-0.4099556208,
0.579890728,
0.5535888672,
0.2587585449,
0.0022498532,
-0.3124121726,
-1.1443953514,
-0.4526010156,
0.6780905724,
0.5259763598,
-0.0098496899,
-0.0636510998,
0.2263295054,
0.0837523118,
0.3019065857,
-0.7926719785,
0.0205160119,
-0.5624764562,
0.2134217173,
-0.0863976255,
-0.4629534781,
-0.3490600586,
-0.0405477323,
0.5783685446,
-0.0527821556,
0.6627897024,
0.4054074287,
-0.2624820471,
-0.0642052442,
0.1888842732,
0.9459916949,
0.9660434127,
-0.4314496517,
0.0448588543,
-0.3501053154,
-0.6809455156,
0.175989911,
0.1209299341,
-0.1975349784,
0.1491015255,
0.4908383787,
0.8167423606,
-0.0239955466,
-0.2251137644,
0.8508763313,
-0.4128677845,
-0.4766091704,
-0.3648219705,
-0.2089139223,
-0.1850961596,
0.0324832052,
0.1855227053,
0.4577814043,
0.3312213421,
-0.3691027164,
0.1646182984,
0.1945684403,
-0.4504790902,
-0.3860786259,
0.476366818,
0.2482725829,
0.2379169911,
0.9399083257,
-0.2052561045,
-0.3583884537,
0.4749672711,
0.5418937802,
0.8749470115,
-0.3379362822,
0.342367202,
0.3650240004,
0.3453353047,
0.1999758035,
0.2521012723,
-0.0332164504,
-0.8542144895,
-0.1504542232,
-0.2629297674,
-0.2492120117,
0.1767998189,
-0.9374647737,
0.2094727755,
-0.5689228177,
-0.4741242528,
0.0556095056,
0.0391250476,
-0.9446374178,
0.7870755792,
0.2539359331,
0.4807289839,
-0.9020887613,
0.4375700057,
0.6130802035,
-0.7205975056,
-1.0854458809,
0.0640934706,
0.3707687557,
-0.9967233539,
0.6085414886,
0.3337320983,
-0.0634467825,
0.1295007467,
0.1598336101,
-0.7325088382,
1.2212896347,
0.1264691055,
-0.1277572513,
0.0257637575,
0.0604784824,
0.5751892924,
-0.3148842454,
0.580313623,
0.5199626684,
0.4316453934,
-0.0671459287,
-0.7865222096,
0.3705817759,
-0.3157105446,
0.1508474797,
-0.0684048757,
-0.6228964925,
0.8017030358,
-0.1661657393,
-0.1932716817,
0.0677573755,
0.1917126179,
0.3713153601,
0.1824060678,
0.4617777765,
0.7523349524,
0.6712316871,
-0.0080349455,
1.9409120083,
-0.0619976074,
0.1629734039,
0.6322787404,
-0.3714759946,
0.3115231097,
0.1126255095,
-0.0271596368,
0.8092116117,
0.3773314357,
-0.244882673,
0.7276933193,
0.1204862073,
-0.4162558317,
0.2501493096,
0.0238608755,
-0.5760372877,
0.6914999485,
0.442056179,
-0.7218456268,
-0.0466276146,
0.2883892655,
-0.1351993084,
-0.4145092368,
-0.0874853656,
0.7408615351,
0.0249954779,
-0.551828742,
0.6389071345,
-0.0230009183,
0.2606503963,
-0.6441934109,
-0.0130616492,
0.0003164888,
0.2225229889,
-0.5339768529,
-0.6267176867,
0.2817593813,
-0.120802477,
-0.5519875884,
-0.4190842509,
0.6680399179,
0.2920340598,
-0.5312572122,
0.081699267,
0.6177879572,
0.3800626993,
-0.1556082219,
-0.725730896,
0.1520861089,
0.2459173352,
-0.4429586232,
0.3671981096,
0.3580218554,
-0.3932417929,
0.247006312,
0.4503384829,
0.1969167292,
-0.2495193332,
0.4178931117,
0.6810795665,
-0.3399194479,
-0.5519891977,
-0.4861571193,
0.2598488629,
0.0939606801,
-0.4471032619,
0.5189566612,
0.4557882547,
0.8004745841,
-0.1508234888,
1.1715792418,
-0.1040592864,
0.2477884144,
-0.7213320136,
0.7294966578,
-0.3883499205,
0.0953247175,
-0.7783871293,
-0.7720931768,
-0.3699900508,
0.711245656,
-0.4647172689,
0.5615107417,
1.156683445,
0.6444559693,
0.1643291116,
-0.0006877843,
0.5701202154,
0.1831519455,
0.3687230051,
0.3850679994,
0.7242439985,
-0.3896665871,
0.6290754676,
-0.3418492973,
-0.5302686095,
-0.0766029581,
-0.6731920242,
-0.4545260966,
-0.4022271037,
-0.3054612875,
-0.4017136693,
-0.1482041031,
0.209222436,
0.7644076943,
-0.0952150673,
-0.0162068829,
0.1516703665,
-0.5225121975,
-0.2929905653,
-0.2942445278,
0.7427484393,
0.2526926696,
-0.3004718721,
0.3216234446,
0.2672469318,
-0.0588094704,
-0.4398901463,
0.0067240121,
0.0845672488,
-0.2292648256,
0.6300920248,
0.089793615,
-0.8537268639,
-0.2222203314,
-0.0244292337,
-0.2396720797,
0.24188748,
0.7615854144,
-1.079785347,
1.0405397415,
0.3894655704,
0.5630685091,
0.7323151231,
0.1715397537,
0.6057286263,
-0.9129737616,
-0.1280197501,
0.2272335142,
0.3707944453,
0.594723165,
-0.7469212413,
0.3340055943,
0.5281640291,
-0.6697259545,
-0.5103724003,
0.1376541555,
-1.0469013453,
-0.0862173438,
0.8789648414,
0.1028652042,
0.097143054,
0.0867724344,
-0.2199225873,
-0.170853287,
-0.2764466107,
0.5753522515,
0.6115258932,
-0.7904487252,
-0.2594050467,
-0.7097551227,
0.3965478837,
0.2655717134,
-0.8394653797,
-0.6498300433,
0.6826997995,
0.3971259296,
0.4282954633,
1.1451812983,
-0.5741731524,
0.6641566157,
0.0335702002,
0.2882274687,
-0.2347552329,
-0.0003256399,
-0.4821249545,
0.2157533169,
0.1772405803,
-0.0788511783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06807v1
|
On the Robustness of Question Rewriting Systems to Questions of Varying Hardness
| 2023-11-12T11:09:30 | 2023-11-12T11:09:30 |
Hai Ye, Hwee Tou Ng, Wenjuan Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In conversational question answering (CQA), the task of question
rewriting~(QR) in context aims to rewrite a context-dependent question into an
equivalent self-contained question that gives the same answer. In this paper,
we are interested in the robustness of a QR system to questions varying in
rewriting hardness or difficulty. Since there is a lack of questions classified
based on their rewriting hardness, we first propose a heuristic method to
automatically classify questions into subsets of varying hardness, by measuring
the discrepancy between a question and its rewrite. To find out what makes
questions hard or easy for rewriting, we then conduct a human evaluation to
annotate the rewriting hardness of questions. Finally, to enhance the
robustness of QR systems to questions of varying hardness, we propose a novel
learning framework for QR that first trains a QR model independently on each
subset of questions of a certain level of hardness, then combines these QR
models as one joint model for inference. Experimental results on two datasets
show that our framework improves the overall performance compared to the
baselines.
|
[
-0.012552361,
-1.0591462851,
0.4774673879,
-0.1626705527,
-0.0726269111,
0.1318772733,
-0.1935043931,
-0.1695486158,
-0.1500525177,
0.4760186374,
-0.6331832409,
-0.3402226865,
-0.2662621737,
0.3752917647,
-0.1735769361,
1.0577667952,
0.0100589842,
0.0171202607,
-0.3505614698,
-0.3050233126,
-0.4010742307,
-0.4726382196,
-0.5810621381,
-0.3357985616,
0.4410174787,
0.478887409,
0.9084327221,
0.5461749434,
0.4243352711,
0.374530077,
-0.1078182608,
-0.2049709409,
-0.3808022738,
0.6822742224,
-0.364431411,
-0.9394640326,
-0.1951422095,
-0.7094318867,
0.5665353537,
0.7652460337,
-0.4552580714,
0.0510174818,
0.390576601,
0.4045470655,
-0.597935915,
-0.2267966568,
-0.9400346875,
-0.0574490875,
0.3561754227,
-0.3096798956,
-0.2608947754,
-0.4707106352,
0.2234395146,
-0.5154966712,
0.6444739699,
0.013021728,
0.6793095469,
0.5646178126,
-0.6069662571,
-0.1911248565,
-0.5907316208,
0.8384364843,
-0.3650205731,
0.5608005524,
0.4271672666,
0.5084527731,
-0.0552930422,
-0.6972898245,
-0.3445807695,
-0.1418500841,
0.1646897495,
-0.1913872063,
0.1090373471,
0.0461986698,
0.1579449922,
0.527251184,
-0.3903017342,
-0.3200831711,
-0.359577775,
-0.4640376866,
0.4933665097,
0.5604464412,
0.2638935149,
-0.3528106213,
-0.1215836704,
-0.3042111099,
-0.3682604134,
0.4924021661,
0.1422835588,
0.3407007158,
0.2494244128,
0.2871106863,
-0.4458914101,
0.3962393999,
0.3418645561,
-0.5345702767,
0.1872145683,
-0.3688064814,
-0.1383930445,
-0.444378674,
0.4610851109,
0.2579069436,
0.0946158767,
-0.2024791241,
-0.3014416397,
-0.2237682194,
0.5100086331,
-0.6250072122,
-0.2771349847,
0.3341356516,
-0.3943689764,
-0.2263758183,
-0.2307743877,
-0.3291712403,
-0.0897738785,
-0.0642830878,
0.5840314627,
-0.6570080519,
-0.1848301142,
0.1485743076,
0.1101297662,
0.5937412977,
0.4096595049,
-0.9807683229,
0.3396038711,
0.7276362777,
0.2913014293,
-0.0468187705,
-0.3832786977,
-0.479141742,
-0.1417233795,
-0.1283429414,
0.6217342615,
-0.3175738752,
-0.5418153405,
-0.1105046943,
0.3213413358,
-0.2891458869,
-0.4208903313,
0.637018621,
-0.6948770881,
-0.086836949,
-0.3392821252,
-0.4258810878,
-0.0077603674,
0.6968369484,
-0.5935350657,
0.6400398612,
0.378839165,
-0.8517494202,
0.5043164492,
0.1110029072,
-0.4836907089,
-0.2042206079,
-0.0025273103,
-0.6765846014,
0.0105106244,
0.2287525684,
0.08015576,
-0.1398473084,
0.3178356588,
-0.1828567237,
-0.3563861251,
0.5763987899,
-0.6585140824,
0.7490684986,
0.2831293344,
-0.2300477922,
-0.0191826429,
-0.5944672227,
0.5771910548,
-0.2119282037,
-0.9478498101,
-0.0766728967,
-0.0062224697,
-0.1606936306,
-0.0947335586,
0.1540531516,
-0.4028411806,
0.1392497271,
-0.3521112204,
0.4373618662,
0.5816242099,
0.2958636582,
0.4210609794,
-0.7529802322,
0.8172863126,
-0.1005092785,
0.1655916572,
-0.0520829037,
-0.3518589139,
-0.742236197,
0.001463032,
0.3089861572,
0.886134088,
-0.9560760856,
0.0114500895,
-0.0756556243,
-0.4495978355,
-0.5764560103,
0.360454917,
0.7875816226,
0.5243278742,
0.2878866494,
-0.3405071795,
-0.1778333336,
-0.7686741352,
-0.4299133718,
-0.3764549196,
-0.0377038419,
0.2854539752,
0.4537046552,
0.0973837078,
0.6761674285,
-0.3874674737,
0.3133921325,
-0.2890212536,
-0.0344215669,
-0.1381814182,
0.6979208589,
-0.0481887683,
-1.0155223608,
-0.3718037605,
-0.356474787,
-0.6997326016,
0.0527172387,
-0.1203387454,
0.0033666596,
0.1011293679,
0.8407057524,
-0.2291614264,
0.6210309863,
-0.143688947,
-0.2028682977,
0.6707357168,
-0.2929114997,
0.3268162608,
-1.0016118288,
-0.2638603151,
-0.2101438195,
-0.0257905126,
-0.6281908154,
0.4147197604,
-0.0116267111,
0.1349155903,
-0.5107924938,
0.0026453575,
-0.2666313946,
0.0916137099,
-0.0448468998,
-0.3732951581,
0.2204176486,
0.7343817949,
-0.2626772225,
0.5449132323,
0.5143202543,
-0.6155449748,
0.1637280732,
0.4002765715,
-0.2534095645,
0.7853505015,
-0.8136700392,
0.276222676,
-0.2515031397,
0.2100589722,
-0.9476978779,
-0.2792759538,
0.1968147606,
-0.5270295143,
0.1111160368,
-0.4089060128,
-0.1765476912,
0.037829157,
-0.1533050239,
0.6855772734,
0.2481949478,
-0.190243721,
0.7304708362,
-0.2047005445,
-0.2227604687,
-0.5661891699,
-0.6923623085,
-0.150924325,
-0.4458902478,
-0.6882445812,
0.2915462554,
-0.2229777724,
-0.284059763,
-0.1240299419,
-0.0709693879,
-0.5059428215,
0.3239371181,
0.3189466298,
-0.1761292964,
-0.349319607,
0.2193103731,
0.128461659,
0.0105212694,
0.125149101,
0.0387735851,
0.2890186906,
-0.3189976811,
-0.5500332713,
-0.6548711658,
0.6276126504,
0.6264231801,
-0.2998946905,
0.5305718184,
0.2367268801,
-0.2654440999,
-0.3294779658,
-0.1910954118,
-0.2499380261,
-0.5313867927,
0.2479653209,
-0.9410168529,
-1.1188151836,
0.6367846727,
0.2642333508,
0.0414041318,
0.1938209981,
0.6141604781,
0.1091442332,
0.9657655358,
0.7811121345,
0.2015922666,
0.2404718697,
0.0675937235,
0.1068781614,
-0.5342248082,
-0.2232330292,
-0.6777166128,
-0.0620496124,
-0.9004966617,
-0.2876090109,
0.3994769454,
0.1917027235,
-0.5018851757,
-0.0340594389,
-0.5328372717,
0.4140731692,
0.7545428276,
0.4869972467,
0.4118044674,
-0.0681406185,
-0.1064369902,
0.0239333287,
-0.7470760345,
-0.5715313554,
1.338172555,
0.2806865275,
0.9426823258,
0.4416140616,
0.801138103,
-0.0663670823,
0.3096988201,
-0.7176114321,
0.4031207561,
0.1675018966,
-0.783834517,
-0.6954994798,
-0.3082383871,
-0.9461246133,
0.3216530383,
-0.3220188022,
-0.6542190313,
0.3264892399,
0.1913142502,
-0.5797168612,
0.3348189294,
-0.7384191751,
0.5706291795,
-0.0342508852,
-0.5338714719,
0.1737541109,
-0.7789145112,
0.2370419353,
0.032480251,
-0.0356714018,
0.2458940297,
0.1228372678,
0.5148748159,
-0.6538193226,
0.8428739309,
-0.0881843865,
-0.2153160572,
0.6237960458,
0.4246796668,
-0.0034524091,
0.3575780392,
-0.4597037733,
-0.3994330764,
0.4806255996,
-0.554024756,
-0.8411357403,
0.2815641761,
-0.648521781,
-1.0089795589,
-0.1932193637,
-0.6165021658,
-0.3672533333,
0.1027408987,
0.353972286,
0.5928095579,
-0.210472405,
0.3387566209,
0.7053745389,
-0.1721979678,
0.0511561781,
0.2746355236,
0.2273139209,
-0.4558035135,
0.6998224854,
0.0011800755,
0.5542807579,
0.4073264897,
0.111956872,
-0.2643415928,
-0.6968346834,
-0.4583741426,
-0.1461244076,
-0.9425665736,
-0.1470177472,
-0.5505695343,
-0.1758775562,
-0.4450507164,
-0.4073615968,
0.034510836,
-0.2808512449,
-0.1713278294,
0.0362110734,
0.2136902064,
0.2959142923,
-0.0544948354,
0.1058897898,
-0.5179262757,
0.4235062003,
0.8900638819,
0.4490791857,
-0.096660465,
-0.6555992365,
0.1884528995,
0.0567291975,
-0.4825798273,
-0.8301963806,
0.1154290512,
0.4471390247,
0.3841172755,
0.1661752313,
0.4471806586,
0.3765612245,
-0.3158235252,
0.5101819038,
-0.0186414048,
-0.8512603045,
0.4428873062,
-0.4250173271,
0.2589434981,
1.3337619305,
0.225409314,
-0.2378863245,
-0.4101319313,
-0.5427911878,
-0.7365416884,
0.2108886987,
-0.0081078513,
0.260897696,
0.0781101435,
0.8774924278,
0.2310626358,
-0.0115968846,
-0.5960645676,
0.010847914,
-0.4671472907,
-0.2669908106,
0.0051856227,
-0.2911526561,
-0.0020902012,
-0.2617670596,
0.3764432073,
-0.3281760514,
0.0972214863,
0.4922463596,
-0.2789660096,
-0.0318888687,
0.7398769259,
0.0933221951,
0.5061634779,
-0.4571756124,
0.1461826265,
0.5522316098,
-0.4546992779,
0.4462138712,
-0.3416394591,
-0.307759881,
-0.5478228927,
0.4278753996,
0.3289898634,
0.1563873589,
-0.6523659229,
0.3971680999,
-0.3570621014,
-0.6375729442,
-0.0629777238,
0.5520640016,
0.0062507577,
0.3087307811,
0.3967552781,
-0.4009042978,
0.1419857293,
-0.6812307835,
0.4868448377,
0.2375095338,
-0.5253348947,
-0.1414517611,
0.6211746931,
-0.0345824324,
-0.7358276248,
0.6718648672,
-0.2685126662,
-0.7625136971,
0.6305789948,
0.6375383735,
0.4917855859,
-0.4519321024,
0.173408255,
0.417368412,
0.36819157,
0.0667193085,
0.638512969,
-0.433776319,
-0.7870774269,
-0.1750856042,
-0.5385910273,
-0.8555018902,
-0.1722253412,
-0.9857693315,
-0.0737341046,
-0.6622594595,
0.0288590025,
0.0153017761,
0.0533304214,
-0.4866437316,
0.8022494316,
-0.5276548266,
0.6596105695,
-0.6824654937,
0.4709556997,
0.6428575516,
-0.336461544,
-0.9715011716,
0.1896307915,
-0.199634552,
-0.4764611721,
0.2468701452,
-0.0623724386,
-0.3254628479,
-0.0683381408,
-0.750677824,
-0.723952055,
1.1235309839,
0.2267193943,
-0.1540376544,
0.125458315,
0.283764869,
0.5925459862,
-0.2652024627,
-0.0967639387,
0.5044028759,
0.1059053838,
0.0811077207,
-0.9665260315,
0.295502007,
-0.482766211,
-0.3127353787,
-0.1037366167,
-0.6623387933,
1.0436053276,
-0.4563356638,
-0.1277531981,
0.4470064342,
0.5914034247,
0.3253454864,
0.6564849019,
0.8650205135,
0.3415834904,
0.886286974,
-0.0889430195,
0.7376064062,
-0.1964506954,
0.1511014253,
1.0330942869,
-0.1873638481,
0.7849152684,
0.4249961674,
-0.0433359966,
0.7716113925,
0.4687301815,
0.2131318301,
0.3427046835,
0.7249080539,
-0.3206508458,
-0.7754914165,
0.2169154286,
-0.1915019751,
0.759057641,
0.2021625191,
-0.0142640565,
-0.0896619856,
-0.0057978546,
-0.1405265778,
0.3814462423,
-0.1140142456,
0.689776063,
0.0419619568,
-1.0248551369,
0.9201557636,
0.1685802191,
0.5101952553,
-0.2232906073,
0.1804282516,
-0.3776262403,
0.0775732249,
-0.2012600303,
-0.661652565,
0.4209395945,
-0.0303502828,
-0.3653976917,
0.0346479081,
0.8178676367,
-0.0017643052,
-0.4795042276,
-0.219862625,
0.8305603862,
0.1290245652,
0.0501654856,
-0.7762424946,
-0.2411675453,
0.1945172846,
-0.1995546371,
0.2698913217,
0.611253798,
-0.2717828751,
1.1892460585,
0.4663445354,
-0.6673026085,
-0.0537671298,
-0.0606601574,
0.8105180264,
-0.8769527078,
-0.637953341,
-0.374355793,
0.5119516253,
0.3260047734,
-0.5341939926,
0.6174452305,
0.2376218438,
0.4582842886,
0.4242798984,
0.8183329105,
0.027976701,
0.5292032957,
-0.3348311484,
0.5905929208,
-0.5819188356,
0.3189879954,
-0.2594435513,
-0.5927052498,
-0.3252961934,
0.474191159,
-0.289942503,
0.112591289,
0.5345582366,
1.2564510107,
0.1075119227,
0.132616207,
0.2812331319,
-0.2160683125,
0.2051042318,
1.0230728388,
0.8816840649,
-0.4586164653,
0.831243515,
-0.2032686919,
-0.0549508594,
-0.154074654,
-0.6198040247,
-0.6870103478,
-0.7331323028,
-0.4559987485,
-0.7861222625,
0.1623366475,
0.5010508895,
0.3625096977,
-0.6270822287,
0.1242672279,
-0.0459447242,
0.5512883663,
-0.2851541936,
-0.2000258863,
0.5450934768,
-0.2098015249,
-0.4419689178,
0.256354183,
-0.2193761021,
-0.0730806887,
-0.1556510776,
-0.0422829911,
0.0665102825,
0.1422408521,
0.1200165078,
0.5739620328,
-0.4275437295,
-0.6482743025,
0.3504746556,
-0.1379943341,
0.1069726273,
0.7088831663,
-0.7130804062,
0.2694806457,
0.3497924209,
0.705473125,
0.2426248193,
0.1322260201,
0.3981362581,
-0.4998422563,
-0.3141588867,
0.1589609981,
0.1222183108,
0.5911806226,
-0.3175212741,
0.1248884425,
0.0063351505,
-0.7087120414,
-0.820111692,
0.482468158,
-0.9340680838,
-0.4002536535,
1.0658147335,
-0.2370771319,
-0.3436630368,
-0.7452702522,
-0.0800075755,
0.2058523148,
0.1130657718,
0.8231168985,
0.4043353498,
-0.1468539834,
-0.208941713,
-0.3077821434,
0.3665330708,
0.7359201312,
-0.4774691761,
-0.0813010409,
0.3387689292,
0.9730741382,
-0.0318621583,
0.8253045678,
0.019146245,
0.5740225911,
0.216818437,
-0.2271184623,
0.2713820338,
-0.0258275121,
-0.4280931652,
0.7169156671,
0.312930584,
0.086274527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06805v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06805v1
|
Tunable Soft Prompts are Messengers in Federated Learning
| 2023-11-12T11:01:10 | 2023-11-12T11:01:10 |
Chenhe Dong, Yuexiang Xie, Bolin Ding, Ying Shen, Yaliang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Federated learning (FL) enables multiple participants to collaboratively
train machine learning models using decentralized data sources, alleviating
privacy concerns that arise from directly sharing local data. However, the lack
of model privacy protection in FL becomes an unneglectable challenge,
especially when people want to federally finetune models based on a proprietary
large language model. In this study, we propose a novel FL training approach
that accomplishes information exchange among participants via tunable soft
prompts. These soft prompts, updated and transmitted between the server and
clients, assume the role of the global model parameters and serve as messengers
to deliver useful knowledge from the local data and global model. As the global
model itself is not required to be shared and the local training is conducted
based on an auxiliary model with fewer parameters than the global model, the
proposed approach provides protection for the global model while reducing
communication and computation costs in FL. Extensive experiments show the
effectiveness of the proposed approach compared to several baselines. We have
released the source code at
\url{https://github.com/alibaba/FederatedScope/tree/fedsp/federatedscope/nlp/fedsp}.
|
[
-0.3174216449,
-0.6675678492,
0.2798762321,
0.0943757743,
-0.0266367998,
-0.2087099254,
-0.3532598615,
-0.4523627758,
-0.0059097717,
0.4638229311,
-0.9690968394,
-0.3308831155,
-0.1313032806,
0.2663459778,
-0.020829536,
1.4121820927,
0.1233172864,
-0.0855368599,
-0.0695712045,
-0.2546831965,
-0.0909929648,
-0.3623887599,
-0.3732763529,
-0.2662265897,
0.6165699363,
0.4976107776,
0.7361168265,
0.2462242097,
0.4687612653,
0.4219185114,
0.0452392772,
0.2291041315,
-0.5376105905,
0.3901658654,
-0.4232006669,
-0.5793066621,
-0.4530245066,
0.2059638351,
0.889390409,
0.8279659748,
-0.187475726,
0.0978422388,
0.0476176701,
0.6537620425,
-0.5921579599,
0.4892188013,
-0.536064744,
0.4033668041,
-0.1714198887,
-0.0670891404,
-0.694501698,
-0.2595426738,
0.4775516093,
-0.7037792206,
0.3963248432,
-0.1182666123,
0.6248596311,
-0.1294561923,
-0.390611738,
0.0810293183,
-0.6532430649,
0.5335024595,
-0.2776530981,
0.3051624298,
0.1297524273,
0.6914253831,
-0.1398433298,
-0.8831323981,
-0.3725756109,
-0.0966545194,
-0.3149971962,
0.1022765338,
-0.1405111402,
0.3068522811,
0.0183312241,
0.5163320303,
-0.349339366,
0.0520742349,
-0.2649714351,
-0.1345888227,
0.6305818558,
0.1511771083,
-0.0914594606,
0.0918459445,
-0.7387987375,
-0.1393690258,
-0.2911221087,
0.23381868,
0.1745298505,
1.0465135574,
-0.4105543792,
0.0983753875,
-0.384523809,
0.6853860021,
0.5278404355,
0.0353062935,
0.5643250942,
-0.1469557285,
-0.3745683134,
-0.2230935246,
0.7620046139,
0.0218580011,
-0.1241740063,
-0.5466346145,
-0.4932176769,
-0.4952750504,
0.0397807024,
-0.5958212018,
0.1690722257,
0.0298073292,
-0.3992869556,
-0.3416038156,
0.5780550241,
-0.8292238116,
-0.4191715717,
-0.3370426297,
0.5196127295,
-0.0155998608,
-0.7006473541,
-0.0267241262,
0.0722376183,
0.0191369113,
0.269626081,
-1.2764501572,
0.551012814,
1.0062252283,
1.0479736328,
0.1133663729,
-0.3283579648,
-0.9889022112,
0.0480185188,
0.2500830293,
0.4049401283,
-0.4989051819,
-0.3116427362,
0.2456379086,
0.2257428616,
-0.422759831,
0.0206203684,
-0.0415490977,
-0.6073137522,
0.5649903417,
0.0102922609,
-0.797265172,
-0.0853273422,
0.2332586944,
-0.6653162241,
0.1595561802,
0.3168145716,
-0.8308882117,
0.1829779595,
-0.7189165354,
-0.1285595894,
0.2885103822,
-0.3417946696,
-0.5951569676,
-0.094367519,
0.2595586777,
0.7274223566,
0.1172747388,
0.3335065544,
-0.5300629139,
-0.5995072722,
0.2690363824,
-0.3327023983,
0.858069241,
0.2724940777,
-0.6322839856,
0.3821446002,
-0.6401409507,
-0.0475801416,
0.0137975644,
-0.3507321775,
-0.1236643046,
-0.6532036066,
-0.0145959044,
-0.0897757709,
0.178551048,
-0.4296923578,
0.4935160279,
-0.6735430956,
0.288500905,
1.088735342,
0.1310381144,
0.7620877624,
-0.5036948919,
0.5719720721,
0.0357419103,
0.7124833465,
-0.1467981637,
-0.4491766989,
-0.6610617042,
-0.3078924417,
0.0141938413,
0.4306093156,
-0.82103163,
0.0893522874,
-0.1001683548,
-0.5191443563,
-0.5721765757,
0.2548296154,
0.4461171925,
0.5843325853,
0.1868112236,
0.1740466207,
-0.3018680215,
-0.6952297091,
-0.1230381206,
0.1751037687,
-0.2285616547,
0.6991920471,
0.1953358948,
-0.3256490529,
0.9475895166,
-0.2691734433,
-0.553953886,
-0.2542458475,
0.229054004,
0.4961007833,
0.5610350966,
0.6187482476,
-1.0421681404,
-0.4892627895,
0.0673587546,
-0.597753644,
0.0854764581,
-0.2818251252,
-0.2331364304,
0.2476846725,
0.1701180339,
-0.4952559471,
0.0933939517,
0.5187732577,
-0.6124587059,
0.3225950897,
-0.1305336654,
0.0326031633,
-1.0617491007,
0.1250445992,
-0.0585100278,
-0.469006896,
-0.5016077757,
0.2759215236,
-0.1555379778,
-0.2646177411,
-0.4893082678,
0.6380715966,
-0.3196227551,
-0.0231235325,
-0.1122300997,
-0.0126445675,
-0.1509045213,
0.615144968,
0.1431028992,
0.7506543994,
0.7728970647,
-0.5387322307,
0.4670394063,
0.5531405807,
0.1271882206,
0.8991605639,
-0.4495979249,
0.2861839831,
-0.0276031196,
0.4318388104,
-0.4582771659,
-0.4025191963,
0.4871149361,
-0.3169943392,
0.2913267314,
-0.2868877947,
-0.1085176691,
-0.2035677135,
-0.1410591304,
0.0413605012,
0.3121546805,
-0.9315719604,
0.5938589573,
0.1311084926,
-0.0209231302,
-0.4051584899,
-0.6396436691,
-0.2237464041,
-0.1445212811,
-0.8165245056,
0.0599791519,
-0.1223643199,
0.0739955381,
-0.3639302552,
-0.0096415123,
-0.331916213,
0.2450195253,
0.5588160157,
0.2287378907,
-0.45395872,
0.301407814,
-0.1229385212,
-0.2797424793,
-0.0097242594,
-0.5688790083,
0.0784946457,
-1.0081180334,
-0.1157256365,
-0.654578805,
0.4034098983,
0.2454642653,
-0.1474792063,
1.0529313087,
0.7227188945,
-0.2403436005,
-0.3817981184,
-0.3358904123,
-0.6126522422,
-0.6797340512,
-0.412127167,
-0.1449894905,
-1.1234390736,
0.2941603065,
-0.1015150324,
0.4956523776,
0.0003220423,
0.2391352654,
0.062644437,
0.9062559009,
0.9574099183,
-0.018306192,
0.87526232,
-0.1437034458,
-0.1528949738,
-0.2443366796,
-0.3005361557,
-0.278635174,
-0.284616679,
-0.5384007096,
-0.1320869625,
0.4310738444,
-0.2803348601,
-0.5275523067,
-0.0304380357,
-0.5574678183,
0.5106033087,
0.8772882223,
0.5447000265,
0.10615284,
0.2387962192,
-0.2831184268,
0.0561219417,
-0.6686112285,
-0.1307160407,
0.8062218428,
0.4105348587,
0.7877783775,
0.0764899775,
0.9039912224,
0.3968970776,
0.3464503288,
-0.2503938377,
0.6057301164,
0.0371724702,
-0.4430703521,
-0.1138550863,
-0.9063023925,
-0.8232493997,
0.2088588029,
-0.4240105152,
-0.7558701038,
0.232119903,
0.2902701497,
-0.3893080056,
0.3574532866,
-0.6829462051,
0.7551946044,
0.0679772049,
-0.4565856755,
0.1452146322,
-0.9923271537,
0.2615406811,
0.220707342,
0.0997594818,
0.1932780892,
0.2647395134,
0.7561626434,
-0.4972311854,
1.2403612137,
-0.6174831986,
0.2087241709,
0.0132864546,
-0.0755502954,
0.5052808523,
0.4279007912,
-0.2727262378,
0.1840632111,
-0.3678135872,
-0.3217647672,
-0.4981532693,
0.5260073543,
-0.6959648728,
-0.6025218368,
-0.4658223689,
-0.6002605557,
-0.3854556084,
0.2961975038,
-0.054358419,
0.3780099154,
0.1599882692,
0.3105457127,
0.5889742374,
0.1882030666,
0.232576251,
1.0734740496,
0.1133057997,
-0.4641443491,
0.8359925747,
-0.3569188416,
0.3756420612,
0.4729576111,
0.5722934604,
-0.0725796893,
-0.1668276191,
-0.0685789511,
0.2288089395,
-0.6857025623,
-0.4433277845,
-0.5010032058,
-0.2571907043,
-0.4070931971,
-0.5828031898,
-0.2988261282,
-0.2537159622,
-0.5536875725,
-0.2853813171,
0.6938652396,
0.3780549765,
-0.4806237817,
0.4931598008,
-0.9427948594,
-0.0238546785,
0.4224076867,
0.6536207199,
-0.1613030285,
-0.138580665,
-0.0640921071,
0.3489364684,
0.0881435499,
-0.5968094468,
-0.0409662277,
0.5390175581,
0.5510950685,
0.7608110905,
0.501072824,
0.4674072862,
-0.3128526807,
0.5746415854,
0.2972906828,
-0.979691565,
0.8097384572,
-0.5306354761,
0.2340802699,
0.938031137,
0.3339057863,
-0.5586240888,
-0.7365940213,
-0.8039345145,
-0.6048691869,
1.0218491554,
-0.0899132267,
0.3357978463,
0.0583810396,
0.507542491,
0.520791471,
0.3255792856,
-0.7870550156,
-0.1803201735,
-0.2331764251,
-0.2461631,
0.2750763595,
0.1171178445,
-0.3616024852,
-0.0604890212,
0.6633844376,
-0.4595083892,
0.2046579868,
0.0689725876,
0.0479445234,
-0.2169050574,
0.1923986673,
0.1985404938,
0.3149715662,
-0.1746584773,
0.1003701091,
-0.109551169,
-0.4939127564,
-0.0155161154,
0.2896820307,
-0.5527647734,
-0.0544179268,
0.361654669,
0.9441524744,
0.6791160703,
-0.3762104809,
0.8534479141,
-0.2078091055,
-0.252938807,
0.0981598794,
0.549022615,
-0.2795933783,
0.6477476954,
0.156426698,
0.1751413494,
0.0759660602,
-0.3317166865,
0.4650015533,
0.3531776071,
-0.4035281837,
-0.4707229137,
0.7185653448,
0.6156820655,
-0.2052312791,
0.8495265245,
0.0851714537,
-0.4311979115,
0.2830510437,
0.5530918241,
0.6058356762,
-0.5056777596,
0.7500692606,
0.0895368457,
0.0901174769,
0.0416052267,
0.223333478,
-0.5532313585,
-0.2891441882,
0.4464378357,
-0.4635435641,
-0.7992066145,
-0.0816850364,
-0.9021003246,
0.0293103307,
-0.6617970467,
-0.0190118607,
-0.0112793306,
0.2001615614,
-0.7641862631,
-0.0343562104,
0.2826294005,
0.957062304,
-0.9176865816,
0.5083346367,
0.4890182912,
-0.5273324847,
-0.7178966999,
-0.3026200831,
0.0205173641,
-0.6823063493,
0.31117028,
0.6173931956,
0.1685590595,
-0.1399529576,
-0.5457684398,
-0.5022826195,
1.0629279613,
0.4960568547,
-0.6553489566,
0.0531739891,
0.2693701684,
0.3913140297,
-0.3486276567,
0.0834422112,
0.2685364485,
0.5076959729,
0.1894552857,
-0.8709971905,
0.1511649787,
-0.143189624,
-0.4078297019,
-0.1716784537,
-0.7809222341,
1.0086263418,
-0.301021874,
-0.4913648069,
-0.1846280545,
1.0533055067,
-0.0758769363,
0.5610536933,
0.831176281,
-0.2275783122,
1.2803755999,
0.0871652216,
0.7738829851,
-0.0065256292,
0.5691658258,
1.2336113453,
-0.3835851252,
0.6786109805,
0.3807474673,
0.0809004605,
0.2717061937,
0.4397538304,
-0.2276745141,
0.7649443746,
-0.1897744536,
-0.684086442,
-0.2475352883,
-0.1431244761,
-0.3705401123,
0.175154686,
0.2261644006,
-0.3547193408,
-0.3921744823,
0.6452921629,
-0.0626397356,
0.1210802048,
-0.4254259765,
0.9989532828,
0.092450954,
-0.5255252719,
0.5171923041,
-0.1554080546,
0.7855828404,
-0.9227106571,
0.1026492864,
-0.4324527681,
0.5152643919,
-0.330960542,
-0.6023035645,
0.2548899353,
0.0180833712,
-0.1716905683,
-0.5148714781,
0.5155392885,
-0.625007689,
-0.3549047709,
0.2142747492,
0.1840354651,
-0.0850709975,
0.0632780939,
-0.7751584649,
-0.1367927045,
-0.2868561745,
-0.474865675,
0.3004124761,
0.2124624401,
0.0760976598,
0.659792304,
0.5733605027,
-0.2240838259,
-0.1255616248,
0.3161756992,
0.9606111646,
-0.2199645936,
-1.243650794,
-0.4763207734,
0.2214568704,
-0.1761993766,
-0.1637920439,
0.7490620017,
0.0431335606,
0.7303697467,
-0.0616734251,
0.5731135607,
0.2232903093,
0.3820085824,
-0.524710834,
0.9647238851,
-0.35678339,
0.0994640365,
-0.113596946,
-0.4126317799,
-0.143741563,
0.6676530838,
-0.2339163721,
-0.0068933414,
0.1940045953,
0.6180933118,
-0.3033782244,
0.6561552882,
-0.0454041101,
0.2995555699,
0.4596413076,
0.6379204988,
0.3447262347,
-0.1283497512,
0.3304443061,
-0.4845388234,
-0.444298327,
-0.5469529033,
-0.8142709732,
-1.1698197126,
-0.7055411935,
-0.3579773903,
-0.2125772536,
0.3015475571,
1.0252248049,
0.9356532097,
-0.749956131,
0.1683564782,
-0.3501629531,
0.2923979461,
-0.5757525563,
-0.3220163584,
0.2298750579,
-0.3801572919,
-0.2957395017,
0.4937515557,
-0.0683903843,
0.3216644526,
-0.4810281098,
-0.0110200644,
-0.1715104133,
-0.1172292829,
0.0543083996,
0.4158228338,
-0.2750457227,
-0.3334304392,
-0.1276799887,
-0.1777942777,
-0.2003245205,
0.7461711764,
-1.0269423723,
0.4625630677,
0.2764160037,
0.6481167674,
0.20797427,
-0.0740164518,
0.769119978,
-1.4312000275,
0.6247625351,
0.3060074747,
0.1460241079,
0.4250744283,
-0.9928538203,
0.3755791783,
0.2540814281,
-0.4556326568,
-0.8799084425,
-0.0729352608,
-0.9451349974,
-0.0757914186,
0.8263845444,
-0.6334201097,
-0.4774009585,
0.2052184492,
0.0585086681,
0.0307656452,
-0.4929488301,
0.8400640488,
0.1978012323,
0.2348509282,
-0.0494395345,
-0.2297900319,
0.5072035789,
0.0644059777,
-0.9028130174,
0.2265464365,
0.4504967928,
0.3905709684,
-0.0794674456,
0.6366938353,
0.3340979517,
0.6698107719,
-0.0377446227,
-0.4651581943,
-0.6752649546,
-0.5887050033,
-0.5185818076,
0.2425855398,
-0.5730804801,
-0.238262549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06771v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06771v1
|
Learning Globally Optimized Language Structure via Adversarial Training
| 2023-11-12T08:21:43 | 2023-11-12T08:21:43 |
Xuwang Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent work has explored integrating autoregressive language models with
energy-based models (EBMs) to enhance text generation capabilities. However,
learning effective EBMs for text is challenged by the discrete nature of
language. This work proposes an adversarial training strategy to address
limitations in prior efforts. Specifically, an iterative adversarial attack
algorithm is presented to generate negative samples for training the EBM by
perturbing text from the autoregressive model. This aims to enable the EBM to
suppress spurious modes outside the support of the data distribution.
Experiments on an arithmetic sequence generation task demonstrate that the
proposed adversarial training approach can substantially enhance the quality of
generated sequences compared to prior methods. The results highlight the
promise of adversarial techniques to improve discrete EBM training. Key
contributions include: (1) an adversarial attack strategy tailored to text to
generate negative samples, circumventing MCMC limitations; (2) an adversarial
training algorithm for EBMs leveraging these attacks; (3) empirical validation
of performance improvements on a sequence generation task.
|
[
-0.2136321366,
-1.0496635437,
0.2371925861,
-0.2929104865,
-0.120939143,
0.2299524993,
-0.1354793757,
-0.1233804375,
0.1762668341,
0.3727477193,
-0.5494114757,
-0.4481522143,
-0.5823379755,
0.0845939144,
-0.4509370327,
1.0622296333,
0.1922276169,
0.132622987,
-0.0234925058,
0.1030195728,
-0.1069721878,
-0.6805830002,
-0.6170995235,
-0.3893862367,
0.3813108802,
0.0936827809,
0.7306513786,
0.704896152,
0.3197889626,
0.3460798562,
0.1722818613,
0.1328933537,
-0.6725438237,
0.2138970196,
0.033622399,
-0.4917152822,
-0.0719797984,
-0.1655233651,
0.7289134264,
0.457129389,
-0.3787102699,
-0.1742717177,
-0.3158867359,
0.7236471772,
-0.7333989143,
-0.0105041629,
-1.257583499,
0.1927210093,
-0.4896155298,
-0.2080468088,
-0.5331816673,
-0.2312024981,
-0.2638033926,
-0.2788793445,
0.448600024,
-0.1050725356,
0.8660767078,
0.3115507066,
-0.4320336282,
-0.4023653865,
-0.6150717139,
0.7022814155,
-0.6395492554,
-0.0035394712,
0.2609971762,
0.2310812175,
-0.2886946797,
-0.2326654643,
-0.4175642431,
-0.2241224647,
0.0470977649,
0.0617772639,
-0.1578823775,
0.0855094269,
0.2880588174,
0.2600492835,
-0.7486746311,
-0.0104459105,
-0.2825417817,
0.0255998299,
0.7973764539,
0.1434185505,
0.3313819468,
-0.166388467,
-0.3132155836,
-0.3678567111,
-0.8666220307,
-0.0910248458,
0.8541119695,
0.3019033968,
0.1942834258,
0.5290915966,
0.0203908086,
0.6323429346,
0.0879175141,
0.2295171469,
-0.0112310331,
0.2137479335,
-0.1898802221,
0.2503592074,
0.8819797039,
-0.2554019094,
-0.0086267628,
-0.2506161928,
-0.2727241814,
0.3171921968,
0.6527386308,
-0.7416069508,
-0.6247882247,
0.063521944,
0.1296676695,
-0.5588104725,
-0.0124822361,
-0.6990358829,
-0.1288080513,
-0.0589064918,
0.4200899601,
-0.5674311519,
-0.1072975248,
-0.1231196076,
0.0142894397,
-0.281200707,
-0.1705811918,
-1.1904771328,
0.2770909965,
0.3744147122,
0.6819638014,
0.2958620191,
-0.0787101686,
-0.5060526729,
0.3681028485,
-0.2811022997,
0.64369452,
-0.4969069362,
-0.5766690969,
-0.1873900443,
-0.492577523,
-0.2626861036,
-0.3559058905,
0.1518847495,
-0.6777308583,
0.2651897669,
-0.0077438802,
-0.3858745396,
-0.1744695455,
0.2713618577,
-0.7085473537,
0.7549578547,
-0.056592878,
-0.8037172556,
0.018292509,
-0.5783108473,
-0.7758206725,
-0.1056977063,
-0.3688126206,
-0.8498148322,
0.2571443915,
0.3576453328,
0.2515114248,
-0.089998737,
0.2459309399,
-0.4131909311,
-0.0477177352,
0.0668772087,
-0.7944881916,
0.8516179323,
0.3229794204,
-0.589495182,
-0.0309885163,
-1.0699545145,
0.1795622557,
0.5607004762,
-0.2845223844,
-0.4072415829,
0.2391290814,
-0.3952353299,
0.2195890099,
-0.0256828945,
-0.3700252175,
0.2718229294,
-0.8085923195,
0.3553370833,
0.8360980749,
0.1927422285,
0.3143768013,
-0.3267433345,
0.4811149836,
-0.3566218317,
-0.0614833198,
-0.2433025986,
-0.0217534434,
-0.6475635171,
-0.1676142961,
-0.0203078017,
0.4865462482,
-1.2103770971,
0.2949013412,
-0.0790999532,
-0.5664376616,
-0.3622652292,
0.1465784162,
0.6529875994,
0.3908055127,
0.5196395516,
-0.1916526556,
-0.5974903703,
-0.6034986377,
-0.3441508412,
-0.1473307461,
-0.0444225371,
0.1614652127,
0.4718997478,
-0.0454130583,
0.5663850307,
-0.5017250776,
0.1455890983,
0.0951768979,
0.3257735968,
-0.0633776039,
0.3967908025,
0.3859787583,
-0.9483046532,
-0.5362909436,
-0.278762877,
-0.6114785075,
0.0095269866,
-0.2920006812,
-0.0298604537,
0.3014059067,
0.3353816569,
-0.4374994338,
0.2238855064,
0.5927675962,
-0.1282331049,
0.2429937869,
-0.2407667935,
-0.041290693,
-1.0773357153,
0.0290801208,
-0.0504951514,
-0.1689638048,
-0.6425721049,
0.1208159998,
0.0740096197,
-0.4479574263,
-0.4731893241,
0.2713508606,
-0.5365992785,
0.1827882379,
-0.4052328169,
-0.1586671472,
0.1140437424,
0.4796139896,
0.0707175732,
0.398121506,
0.3737689257,
-0.6912924647,
0.3054336309,
0.0693029687,
0.0290439297,
0.4809367359,
-0.3787896037,
0.3343721032,
-0.3386972249,
0.2340366691,
-0.9384801388,
-0.0979883149,
0.1282518953,
-0.5116013885,
0.8650571108,
0.2296463847,
-0.2046832144,
-0.3169324398,
-0.2991411984,
0.1923712492,
0.2558233738,
-0.5409452915,
0.4148315489,
0.3150980771,
-0.0125981327,
-0.637607336,
-0.5694660544,
0.1943996698,
-0.1955996901,
-0.5944573879,
0.5143529177,
-0.0751258135,
-0.2387132794,
-0.1177533343,
0.0184222963,
0.1765093356,
0.365524143,
-0.0102340598,
0.0719684958,
0.0153928054,
-0.0192019269,
-0.17218104,
-0.1225696206,
0.2980414331,
-0.5721077919,
0.604916513,
0.0952758044,
-0.4088515937,
-0.13712883,
0.4519822598,
0.3986088336,
0.0088107046,
0.9133511186,
0.6407052875,
-0.3433707952,
-0.3502968252,
-0.2175231576,
-0.1087580621,
-0.5429450274,
0.5534948111,
-0.4090048373,
-0.4326528013,
0.1042080745,
0.1318463236,
0.1949259192,
0.6338673234,
0.6375840306,
0.0952670053,
1.3086463213,
0.4817000628,
-0.1538607776,
0.5775898099,
-0.3939408064,
-0.0195919871,
-0.5035127997,
-0.1447964311,
-0.4917370081,
-0.1417329013,
-0.4293525517,
-0.0969350561,
0.403087765,
-0.0695285201,
-0.3956218958,
0.4021990895,
-0.4525591731,
0.3359926641,
0.4255298972,
0.215592429,
-0.1244160607,
0.3619977832,
-0.3815862238,
-0.0322555229,
-0.9760933518,
-0.2070480287,
1.0761888027,
0.2253327072,
0.93473351,
0.3255449235,
0.6888875365,
0.264680028,
0.4329445958,
-0.4567562938,
0.3650319278,
-0.2865586877,
-0.5277779102,
-0.1662509292,
-0.8518787026,
-0.6851365566,
0.3083719313,
-0.1152409688,
-0.4691992402,
-0.2335574776,
0.1836213022,
-0.1946715713,
0.5472834706,
-0.6056988835,
0.6146652699,
-0.4901454747,
-0.3463062942,
-0.1278494447,
-0.5090979934,
0.1919036657,
-0.1352538764,
0.3404269516,
0.225547567,
0.1116175056,
0.3422233462,
-0.5060943961,
0.8777263761,
-0.3436323106,
-0.3735970855,
0.2768654823,
0.0909922868,
1.0157548189,
-0.0226618517,
-0.1975096166,
0.0973870903,
-0.7402895689,
-0.6433467865,
-0.5008103848,
0.6274458766,
-0.805213809,
-0.6941683888,
-0.2817004323,
-0.3422304392,
-0.2864258885,
0.0219466817,
0.6948286295,
0.591748476,
-0.3056922555,
0.0843531936,
0.7148926854,
-0.2227798402,
0.5876280665,
0.5530439019,
0.3882465661,
-0.7467028499,
1.1817122698,
0.0865238979,
0.6571167707,
0.8735538125,
0.1947716177,
-0.3494440019,
-0.632152915,
-0.6219778657,
-0.225622043,
-0.5258613229,
-0.2619264126,
-0.7159940004,
-0.2139694691,
-0.5729913712,
-0.3626136482,
-0.4437330961,
-0.3919622004,
-0.2590318322,
0.0656086057,
0.0566044934,
0.6425127983,
-0.138461262,
0.2661645114,
-0.7887847424,
0.2153618336,
0.2639570534,
-0.1534440219,
-0.0420076512,
-0.4352625906,
-0.433414489,
0.1944156438,
-0.6212081313,
-0.8318208456,
0.6384621859,
0.3996412754,
0.4396530092,
0.255436033,
0.0803550258,
0.414912492,
-0.8707779646,
0.6127428412,
0.3960885406,
-0.8348166347,
0.7558482885,
-0.5514928102,
0.5806738138,
0.3753909171,
0.5650328398,
-0.1559808254,
-0.5402485132,
-0.9626271129,
-1.0376354456,
0.4730738699,
0.3798313439,
0.0842747092,
-0.1299056709,
0.4311587512,
-0.2012655437,
0.398563236,
-0.7927965522,
-0.3571403623,
-0.4792729318,
-0.3700830042,
-0.0763637573,
0.0516497828,
-0.0337910987,
0.1780312359,
1.079182148,
-0.1466518492,
0.1040079221,
0.1359350681,
-0.2299380451,
-0.3368161321,
0.1872509867,
0.5871380568,
0.2973431349,
-0.01669663,
0.1256896406,
0.1702723801,
-0.5044307709,
0.4285563529,
0.2456205487,
-0.391470015,
0.0054839258,
0.1179227605,
0.8059661388,
0.0412175283,
-0.3102135956,
0.1281677186,
-0.2844108343,
-0.2158938646,
-0.3146524131,
0.2028660327,
-0.3208729923,
0.0795696974,
0.4030504823,
0.2853150964,
-0.0413874984,
-0.3715522885,
0.4083628953,
0.7552117705,
-0.3735149205,
-0.3510842025,
0.7337975502,
0.0659235492,
-0.2958519161,
0.2193654031,
-0.3654177785,
-0.7314782143,
0.5825268626,
0.7562115788,
0.7885202169,
-0.5952073932,
0.1686233878,
0.2644608617,
0.4854181409,
0.1601843685,
0.11078877,
-0.0640939623,
-0.4592449665,
-0.304797858,
-0.5887998343,
-0.4360772967,
0.2186477184,
-0.4735435843,
0.1363095492,
-0.6767407656,
-0.00982132,
-0.1121785268,
0.2460148036,
-0.2623324692,
0.5313628912,
0.3833898604,
0.3076508045,
-0.5246119499,
0.8741209507,
0.678663075,
-0.1008601785,
-0.5927506089,
0.0766963139,
0.3530334234,
-0.7413005829,
0.472920239,
0.0870597288,
-0.1961182058,
0.2086421996,
-0.3273242712,
-0.9403279424,
0.7540907264,
0.4365579486,
-0.6540688276,
0.025959162,
0.0980998799,
0.3683938682,
-0.0969946906,
0.145076856,
0.033026889,
0.103105776,
0.0832323655,
-0.2712801099,
0.0428559147,
-0.4221539795,
0.058913663,
0.7111868262,
-0.8318266869,
0.9028423429,
-0.1448066533,
-0.4977326393,
-0.0990035608,
0.7974404693,
0.0119149303,
-0.0786678642,
0.3989183307,
0.7164964676,
0.8766273856,
0.109471783,
1.0372595787,
-0.3547381163,
0.4849710166,
0.9792745709,
-0.1947178692,
0.6116098762,
0.1346750855,
-0.1345431656,
0.5487961173,
0.4323891699,
-0.042679742,
0.7462329268,
0.5999936461,
-0.549628973,
0.0549673773,
0.1300014555,
-0.4254913926,
0.296448499,
0.6383539438,
-0.3360158503,
-0.4289965034,
0.174579531,
0.1244376376,
0.3900780976,
-0.268863529,
0.6770760417,
0.0508144014,
-0.4345315993,
0.8460079432,
0.2712524235,
0.6794150472,
-0.8473876119,
0.1743183881,
0.1872178018,
0.4693491161,
-0.0316934884,
0.0611537397,
0.468305558,
0.0793356076,
-0.1995598674,
-0.2377728373,
0.7268813252,
-0.5339070559,
-0.4806900918,
-0.0163970031,
0.0022418597,
-0.2224240899,
-0.180099979,
-0.8228101134,
-0.2617634237,
0.1174538732,
-0.42113626,
0.4459009469,
0.4207034707,
0.4108354151,
0.3982474208,
0.6339656711,
0.2074685097,
-0.1477893889,
-0.0290808845,
0.7754741907,
-0.6068080664,
-0.6321350336,
-1.2815648317,
0.1474277228,
-0.0452418439,
-0.0328475423,
0.7869099975,
0.4362793565,
0.9523969293,
0.2887857854,
0.9373106956,
0.0287436116,
0.2386072725,
-0.9078108668,
0.6886357665,
-0.3813193738,
0.3962430954,
-0.1840013266,
-0.6386229992,
-0.1957836002,
0.5002777576,
-0.3949353099,
0.0207810625,
0.7626447082,
0.6454738975,
0.1805616617,
0.2546316087,
0.3490465581,
0.2590531707,
0.7068210244,
0.9910594821,
0.5653326511,
-0.6946297884,
0.7171965837,
-0.4008516073,
-0.084096849,
0.0870757401,
-0.8881757855,
-1.0952483416,
-0.2838366628,
-0.2381526977,
-0.5314646363,
0.3255466223,
0.8758568764,
0.6170833707,
-0.7417066693,
0.0798326209,
-0.527505517,
-0.1727739424,
0.0911288783,
-0.2622047961,
0.428691715,
-0.4395278394,
-0.6558628082,
0.726467073,
0.1058153734,
0.2508222759,
-0.5789331198,
0.125204131,
-0.2681857646,
0.1612278372,
0.3556563556,
0.3809292316,
-0.1351644099,
-0.0983676314,
-0.1200601459,
-0.2571977377,
-0.0020190808,
0.8575966954,
-0.6353693008,
0.4161301851,
0.2603210807,
0.8660672903,
0.3056913018,
-0.0151483351,
0.8497984409,
-1.2138693333,
0.130930081,
0.4208755195,
0.231818974,
0.4794739485,
-0.7247510552,
0.1818032265,
0.4461393356,
-0.3838512599,
-0.5049264431,
0.3490629196,
-0.0336463116,
-0.6199086308,
1.076420784,
-0.1462990195,
-0.3921454549,
-0.0340669304,
0.0762527585,
0.2325673848,
-0.3754952252,
1.0919584036,
0.5597333312,
0.0518550649,
0.3805755973,
-0.4316437244,
0.5741768479,
0.5327010155,
-0.8522469401,
-0.1511213779,
0.4114269614,
-0.0695335492,
0.2293586284,
0.4868239164,
-0.0893743411,
0.0774576142,
0.2755999863,
-0.1704755276,
-0.2663204372,
-0.5207970142,
-0.4899148643,
0.4732606411,
-0.3920639157,
-0.0648487881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07618v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07618v1
|
Large Language Models' Understanding of Math: Source Criticism and Extrapolation
| 2023-11-12T07:52:32 | 2023-11-12T07:52:32 |
Roozbeh Yousefzadeh, Xuenan Cao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.HO
|
It has been suggested that large language models such as GPT-4 have acquired
some form of understanding beyond the correlations among the words in text
including some understanding of mathematics as well. Here, we perform a
critical inquiry into this claim by evaluating the mathematical understanding
of the GPT-4 model. Considering that GPT-4's training set is a secret, it is
not straightforward to evaluate whether the model's correct answers are based
on a mathematical understanding or based on replication of proofs that the
model has seen before. We specifically craft mathematical questions which their
formal proofs are not readily available on the web, proofs that are more likely
not seen by the GPT-4. We see that GPT-4 is unable to solve those problems
despite their simplicity. It is hard to find scientific evidence suggesting
that GPT-4 has acquired an understanding of even basic mathematical concepts. A
straightforward way to find failure modes of GPT-4 in theorem proving is to
craft questions where their formal proofs are not available on the web. Our
finding suggests that GPT-4's ability is to reproduce, rephrase, and polish the
mathematical proofs that it has seen before, and not in grasping mathematical
concepts. We also see that GPT-4's ability to prove mathematical theorems is
continuously expanding over time despite the claim that it is a fixed model. We
suggest that the task of proving mathematical theorems in formal language is
comparable to the methods used in search engines such as Google while
predicting the next word in a sentence may be a misguided approach, a recipe
that often leads to excessive extrapolation and eventual failures. Prompting
the GPT-4 over and over may benefit the GPT-4 and the OpenAI, but we question
whether it is valuable for machine learning or for theorem proving.
|
[
-0.4241147339,
-0.7729361653,
0.9154894948,
0.2202791572,
-0.2172483206,
0.0160195455,
-0.141074881,
-0.5072082281,
-0.1109317914,
0.2250207067,
-0.4888254404,
0.0369031504,
-0.6293197274,
0.1646892428,
-0.4738812149,
1.0980046988,
-0.2201325148,
0.1065776274,
-0.2384328395,
0.0891944841,
-0.3107855022,
-0.8019445539,
-0.6346853375,
-0.5007181168,
0.2298006266,
-0.0780679062,
0.7917553782,
0.4092518091,
0.585008502,
0.3362873197,
0.0486720018,
-0.3280319273,
-0.5920317173,
-0.1016258374,
-0.1187621504,
-0.7768093944,
-0.2808827162,
0.1702712178,
0.8126778603,
0.8117033839,
0.0266564842,
0.0023216037,
-0.0888698921,
0.5883104801,
-0.114092581,
0.5115535855,
-0.6624030471,
0.1548184454,
-0.330347389,
-0.0298580639,
-0.1638205945,
-0.4122906625,
0.3706914783,
-0.7699548602,
0.4576596022,
-0.2316029072,
0.8734285235,
0.06291347,
-0.3674447834,
-0.5643243194,
-0.8918228149,
0.7673059702,
-0.5479649305,
0.3853552938,
0.5505945683,
0.5675775409,
0.023373805,
-0.8224022388,
-0.6553162336,
-0.4027905166,
0.1788720638,
0.3146740198,
-0.0299759991,
-0.1739813089,
0.7222494483,
0.6055396199,
-0.5696179271,
-0.3466417789,
-0.5407005548,
-0.2922692001,
0.2377346903,
-0.1596743912,
0.3807280362,
0.0402981564,
-0.0354361199,
0.1287318319,
-0.8671722412,
-0.2658098638,
0.4534693956,
-0.0667974353,
0.085037671,
0.5774331093,
0.250476867,
0.5548679233,
-0.3279652297,
0.0428487435,
0.1846363246,
-0.5814034343,
-0.1213483512,
-0.2438313961,
0.587351203,
0.0183540601,
0.5005310774,
-0.005212822,
-0.1422569603,
0.3372481167,
0.1141580418,
-0.7481867075,
-0.3865785599,
-0.2188616246,
-0.0031594983,
-0.1127844155,
0.0990518183,
-0.4481800795,
0.1180641726,
-0.2440259457,
0.2923149467,
-0.5064181089,
-0.1558343172,
0.1690049917,
-0.2233836204,
0.1192652285,
0.4556625187,
-0.962559402,
0.4003786445,
0.9506587386,
0.9047111273,
0.2460746616,
-0.4174070358,
-0.2460918874,
0.008973713,
-0.5566080809,
0.7453687787,
-0.5042651296,
-0.18996948,
0.0000750118,
-0.0498198979,
-0.0367356613,
-0.190196991,
0.6125302315,
-0.7527939081,
0.4829793572,
-0.5732598901,
-0.656966269,
-0.5457615852,
0.4026452303,
-0.6826711297,
0.4369341731,
0.0752720758,
-0.6208328009,
0.2090540826,
-0.9066429734,
-0.1052496806,
0.1845444739,
-0.2629036903,
-0.2806644738,
0.2724262178,
0.3259668946,
0.0456872135,
-0.3870797157,
0.1082916483,
-0.5748625398,
-0.1579693407,
0.4147223532,
-0.5473767519,
0.6759670973,
0.1668779999,
-0.4495148361,
-0.3084543943,
-0.3642204404,
0.074648045,
0.4605091214,
-0.0680014119,
-0.3389193416,
-0.1491273195,
-0.4145460129,
0.330686897,
0.2109406441,
-0.3645139933,
0.2422045618,
-0.5193747878,
0.6685874462,
0.7963409424,
-0.0368961804,
0.2948411703,
-0.2395348251,
0.8320578337,
-0.2995154262,
0.005249525,
-0.3368753791,
-0.7333359718,
-0.5516678095,
0.0579455309,
0.4810915291,
0.1736294925,
-0.7244434357,
-0.2000167072,
-0.3407974243,
-0.2884067297,
-0.321315825,
0.1382055432,
0.4868695438,
0.3191332221,
0.1828939319,
-0.1002648324,
-0.3442414999,
-0.7251112461,
-0.5842465162,
0.0061031999,
0.0209864564,
0.3026515245,
0.754663229,
-0.1596134901,
0.6430237889,
-0.4963549972,
-0.01369859,
-0.1743783057,
0.1207242757,
0.2037335783,
0.0832622349,
0.6361116171,
-0.7142878771,
-0.4119125903,
0.0608830452,
-0.9604401588,
0.0197617803,
0.245888114,
0.0931978151,
0.002345765,
0.1470736265,
-0.5993553996,
0.2280786186,
0.626434505,
-0.3209052384,
0.6016021371,
-0.1743258983,
-0.1076373681,
-0.7589362264,
-0.0810840279,
0.1396261454,
-0.246983856,
-0.5656007528,
0.3029674292,
-0.0093832761,
-0.2461436391,
-0.0444764011,
0.3557122648,
-0.4731460512,
-0.4362787604,
-0.2331614345,
0.2818183303,
-0.0409493744,
0.2946978211,
-0.1468804926,
0.5492283106,
0.4397805631,
-0.434030354,
0.513530314,
0.1024524644,
-0.3052033484,
0.3703681231,
-0.7162904143,
0.3106794059,
0.0112296883,
0.3775225282,
-0.7275938988,
-0.3320451677,
0.2768628597,
-0.5383428335,
0.0975996777,
-0.5042438507,
-0.4638369381,
-0.5094028115,
-0.1394074559,
0.6176920533,
0.4199928939,
-0.5399226546,
0.36642465,
0.3492125571,
-0.3130156398,
-0.448743999,
-0.6111357212,
0.0233037062,
-0.0597865321,
-0.6587833762,
-0.02524052,
-0.1469367445,
-0.5938076973,
0.0987949148,
-0.1442687511,
-0.3331560791,
-0.0404158495,
-0.0594844967,
0.1614695936,
-0.3853939176,
0.1426843405,
-0.1265696287,
-0.1781244576,
0.4420699179,
-0.4879129529,
0.4963215292,
-0.4022535384,
-0.6926996112,
-0.2900080085,
0.0994151011,
0.6848284602,
-0.203428328,
0.3148333728,
0.2959260345,
-0.5161716342,
0.0641609356,
-0.3243115842,
-0.1677243114,
-0.4378647804,
0.3631141186,
-0.6603988409,
-0.7377060652,
0.4638487697,
0.0068378178,
0.0671678334,
0.9172827601,
0.602761209,
0.1959718168,
1.0882966518,
0.5296401381,
0.0980125666,
0.2958199978,
-0.4741442502,
0.2138115019,
-0.554120779,
-0.1022847593,
-0.624907732,
0.1236703843,
-0.5121558905,
-0.294439584,
0.156257689,
-0.020796461,
-0.3648305535,
0.0705474615,
-0.167092979,
0.6407318711,
0.3482842147,
0.0035504324,
0.5195224881,
0.0093022604,
-0.0649408475,
-0.3248320818,
-0.6493887901,
-0.3209821284,
1.0998997688,
0.5102216005,
0.6693227887,
0.3962684274,
0.2514637113,
-0.1805165112,
0.4154590368,
-0.8108948469,
0.1687882394,
0.1644569337,
-0.8216230273,
-0.3255573511,
-0.8167473078,
-0.7379021645,
0.2128962725,
0.1897342652,
-0.3696391582,
-0.2164065242,
0.1601943821,
-0.2012152523,
0.2523577511,
-0.7364541888,
0.8827273846,
-0.3555717766,
-0.1495823115,
-0.2604185343,
-0.3350783587,
0.8410869241,
-0.4698793888,
0.5516463518,
0.2141221464,
0.1497379988,
0.8283986449,
-0.6782215834,
0.5823150873,
-0.0601313859,
-0.4363325536,
0.4170694947,
0.185608387,
0.3404590189,
0.2113520652,
0.1279012412,
0.1548705697,
0.1304025948,
-0.3991703987,
-0.9242270589,
0.8686074615,
-0.8414011002,
-0.5354619026,
-0.733610034,
-0.3569627404,
-0.0574603342,
0.3340221643,
0.3358443677,
0.5995428562,
0.0666993037,
0.0166203678,
0.392601341,
-0.0102845049,
0.2296494991,
0.4045093954,
-0.4827240109,
-0.35901016,
0.9343982339,
0.2854660749,
0.3165183067,
0.166383177,
0.5405752659,
-0.6214223504,
-0.3371519148,
-0.3851311207,
0.4960536361,
-0.8842161298,
0.0841831714,
-0.3845511377,
-0.2385347486,
-0.2231942862,
0.184078142,
-0.3815472722,
-0.5799326897,
-0.0075230538,
-0.1409263909,
0.4307816625,
1.2345730066,
-0.0185109507,
0.072099708,
-0.7774342895,
0.2551349103,
0.4748915732,
0.4440920353,
-0.1327659637,
-0.7393859625,
-0.1507077515,
0.1892629415,
-0.3815346956,
-0.8129982948,
0.1439553946,
0.1252329201,
0.3167639971,
0.5840476155,
-0.3398182392,
0.7884177566,
-0.7380978465,
0.7953070998,
0.1553429365,
-1.2671480179,
0.2283815593,
-0.4281826913,
0.1457221508,
0.0866482928,
0.64508605,
-0.2761808038,
-0.2882644534,
-0.8835456967,
-0.3198472857,
0.4625044465,
0.3745762408,
0.2542162538,
0.1416407377,
0.6856234074,
0.0812290385,
0.1707186401,
-0.9716297984,
0.0177200325,
-0.4669970572,
0.0516347699,
-0.2253425419,
-0.3066827357,
-0.1934201419,
-0.2632795274,
0.4902666211,
-0.0919446051,
0.4263153076,
-0.0522300303,
-0.0716080293,
-0.1934156567,
0.11751353,
0.8405584097,
1.2851951122,
0.0971802771,
0.1573055089,
-0.0283410922,
-0.6610451937,
-0.0096080853,
0.1767591536,
0.0398833379,
0.0598806217,
0.5291739106,
0.7132743001,
0.2328645736,
-0.3809670508,
0.5697339177,
-0.1752699018,
-0.529306531,
-0.5787129402,
-0.2218864858,
-0.0993498489,
0.0414864682,
0.1668059528,
0.1102833673,
0.0230266526,
-0.95752424,
0.2037905455,
0.4551608264,
-0.2527896762,
-0.9159552455,
0.5618713498,
-0.1663725227,
-0.2394858301,
0.5402062535,
-0.2054923177,
-1.0925112963,
0.4519790709,
0.8593713641,
0.6008018255,
-0.2432463765,
0.0336227752,
0.2551082373,
0.4273418188,
-0.3677408993,
0.2505964041,
0.1986433566,
-0.7153599262,
-0.9650659561,
-0.3269590139,
-0.5408980846,
0.2689480782,
-0.3954251111,
0.2022995651,
-0.5870900154,
-0.0006934865,
0.0249890592,
0.0242216662,
-0.5619465113,
0.0518575646,
-0.0947502926,
0.6483986974,
-0.7540171742,
0.5420143008,
0.4899843335,
-0.5191639066,
-0.8647040129,
0.1373741329,
-0.0297923181,
-0.8710976839,
0.7164031863,
0.1379851848,
0.0024838715,
0.0250922423,
-0.5603106022,
-0.9045511484,
0.7161361575,
0.675201118,
-0.4402138591,
-0.2317972034,
-0.1642210782,
0.6126016974,
0.0772485361,
0.3910508156,
0.3054765165,
0.5313331485,
0.2765518129,
-1.07999897,
0.1123741269,
-0.1639160812,
-0.1934640259,
0.3011173606,
-0.4772206843,
1.1437313557,
-0.3339655101,
-0.0791491792,
0.0358462781,
0.4446022511,
0.0513948649,
0.3238070011,
0.282341361,
0.788406074,
0.6865416169,
-0.1171574369,
1.3513951302,
-0.0865744725,
0.76818645,
0.8671121597,
-0.1535734534,
0.5090801716,
0.1105102152,
-0.5052574277,
0.4121138155,
0.472387284,
-0.0469058603,
0.3971387744,
0.3963820338,
-0.2409496754,
-0.1025879234,
0.4379528463,
-0.7248113751,
0.405403614,
0.5530316234,
-0.3075141907,
-0.3673422039,
-0.1628403366,
0.0932385027,
-0.131118536,
-0.3009161055,
0.5513425469,
0.3902852237,
-0.6725767255,
0.6492938995,
-0.1418747157,
-0.0212929305,
-0.6143732071,
-0.2565217018,
0.014818457,
0.3419095576,
-0.0549887829,
-0.7354282737,
0.3975925148,
0.0817766637,
0.0336820781,
0.056290146,
0.4110628366,
-0.0854734853,
-0.5456992984,
-0.0667578876,
0.6428309679,
0.4505879581,
-0.2951604426,
-0.7923876643,
0.0666624755,
-0.0310999975,
-0.0096106119,
0.1897700578,
0.8920969367,
0.1014165357,
0.5939261317,
0.8641251922,
0.1027027592,
0.0582823865,
0.1019883826,
0.8531514406,
-0.6860702634,
-0.4868223369,
-1.1798852682,
-0.145030573,
0.0798059404,
-0.0460951105,
0.9674549699,
0.4482997954,
0.8492904902,
0.0386967845,
1.0687437057,
0.2284224927,
0.3334988058,
-0.6569539905,
0.4627013803,
-0.2633372545,
0.2841754854,
-0.5538953543,
-1.0857343674,
-0.4842889607,
0.8837923408,
-0.7098237872,
0.4099729955,
1.0558543205,
0.0577476211,
-0.2253391594,
0.3244740963,
0.3331952393,
0.450746119,
0.5576736331,
0.4030842781,
1.0486460924,
-0.2231049687,
0.7151199579,
0.0146755446,
-0.5057262182,
0.0311860982,
-0.7725502253,
-0.8923637867,
-0.409131974,
-0.0195949264,
-0.5133432746,
-0.1159615591,
0.5389453173,
0.347618103,
-0.5539208055,
0.0248052869,
-0.4560125768,
0.0903468281,
-0.0977515206,
-0.1999021769,
0.3758200407,
-0.3706247509,
-0.6867582798,
0.2346484363,
0.164919585,
0.1431455314,
-0.4389097095,
-0.0157456193,
0.2431484461,
-0.0333531126,
0.6424377561,
0.3842848539,
-0.6264114976,
-0.2380135059,
0.0121522797,
0.3203487992,
-0.0714823604,
1.0398232937,
-0.4214627743,
0.4658216536,
0.3166389167,
0.7690296173,
0.6007234454,
-0.1207860708,
0.8412596583,
-0.1192085817,
-0.0922970548,
0.1908464283,
0.704632163,
0.3410625756,
-0.0588012971,
0.3306813836,
0.7673533559,
-0.7337845564,
-0.6627878547,
0.6468520164,
-0.48461321,
-0.1227520406,
1.000097394,
-0.3810017407,
-0.1886554956,
-0.1770234257,
-0.0992750973,
-0.0681542456,
-0.2922634184,
0.8190637827,
1.0362286568,
-0.1138540283,
-0.114774093,
-1.1500393152,
0.4671648443,
0.2574294209,
-0.5269087553,
-0.0495384634,
0.4182400703,
0.4287796319,
0.3477793336,
0.5377851725,
-0.3819842339,
0.2460370064,
-0.0258756615,
-0.492035985,
0.1213401556,
-0.1889153719,
-0.4219552279,
0.0539356098,
0.2380996794,
0.1570726782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07617v1
|
CLAMP: A Contrastive Language And Molecule Pre-training Network
| 2023-11-12T07:45:35 | 2023-11-12T07:45:35 |
Neel Redkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, 8.2.D.2.5
|
This paper highlights a shift in how to approach material generation. Instead
of material-to-material, we propose a language-to-material generation
architecture that utilizes millions of untapped data points. Using a web
scraper to collect crystal text pairs from open-source research papers, a
contrastive model can be trained using a convolutional graph neural network
encoder and a language encoder. This would allow unsupervised zero-shot
classification which can be trained by taking advantage of linguistic
structure. Without any specific training data, an ~82\% accuracy was achieved
and ~75\% accuracy for photocatalyst prediction with an extremely small
dataset. This novel network could ideally be cross-applied to any reaction that
can be described via text, opening completely new methods to think about 3D
chemical framework generation. In the full experiment diffusion models would
likely be incorporated to fully exploit the latent space.
|
[
-0.4850615263,
-0.5609768033,
0.4615900517,
-0.1653006524,
-0.3088682592,
-0.059477888,
-0.1135369837,
-0.2397807091,
0.1372683942,
0.2398686856,
-0.4496799707,
-0.3420895934,
-0.352641046,
0.1792770624,
-0.3550922573,
0.9954850078,
-0.0783235282,
0.3726427853,
-0.0993544608,
0.0592745245,
-0.0178390797,
-0.2207653522,
-0.3746044934,
-0.5027861595,
0.4116313756,
0.3210632801,
0.5083574057,
0.6539028287,
0.4477067292,
0.3702272773,
0.1275890321,
-0.1197891608,
-0.4366765022,
-0.2885607779,
-0.3796603978,
-0.4127828479,
-0.1725688875,
-0.0364760906,
0.2431118786,
0.9828161001,
0.1078233421,
-0.0543856025,
0.1016721427,
0.5631612539,
-0.4723206162,
-0.0216614101,
-1.2111167908,
0.2047870755,
-0.4178894758,
-0.3259307146,
-0.2197082937,
-0.008870136,
0.1163178012,
-0.4809688032,
0.7620154619,
-0.1537448317,
0.7907371521,
-0.0254473891,
-0.3835781217,
-0.3696217239,
-0.4368561506,
0.4298620522,
-0.5647723079,
-0.0126229376,
-0.2040729821,
0.338734448,
-0.4075772166,
-1.1910494566,
-0.9848820567,
0.0878763124,
-0.0047226427,
0.1294249445,
0.3373716176,
0.2564322054,
-0.0374005139,
0.6008765697,
-0.8142418861,
-0.2803074121,
-0.6232723594,
-0.0593775399,
0.2741917074,
0.0045069708,
0.1085618287,
0.0431739986,
-0.5052322149,
-0.2262810618,
-0.6721069217,
-0.556214869,
0.3122816086,
0.5402081609,
-0.0696118623,
0.6773537993,
-0.1624596566,
0.728448391,
-0.0130107114,
0.2442287952,
0.3533937633,
-0.4545240104,
-0.3655029535,
0.2718294859,
0.9598546624,
0.4012461305,
0.3227753341,
-0.0669011772,
0.0197423194,
0.5728980303,
0.0478714369,
-1.4149034023,
-0.8678271174,
0.1948082298,
-0.1323995888,
-0.445887506,
0.0119712083,
-0.8283729553,
-0.3817053139,
-0.0887739435,
0.2085928619,
-0.061876826,
-0.2637909055,
0.249149546,
-0.3236978054,
-0.0900802761,
0.0278090574,
-0.7469762564,
0.186994791,
0.1574467719,
1.0983102322,
-0.1289381236,
-0.3090436161,
-0.1103329137,
0.1665353775,
-0.3163216114,
0.9025740623,
-0.4266519547,
-0.4062315524,
-0.0714453459,
-0.0435018018,
0.0889330059,
-0.6749350429,
-0.2234793752,
-0.341937989,
0.3767649531,
0.242828697,
-0.4537208974,
-0.0116733853,
0.0560173281,
-0.6824845672,
0.5202553272,
0.3123793006,
-0.8582983017,
0.5058746934,
-0.6200392246,
-0.3361864686,
0.0483015217,
-0.4548784196,
-0.6023293138,
-0.1447788924,
-0.0764078274,
0.2559069693,
-0.3485696912,
0.2585873604,
-0.7020619512,
-0.0869905576,
0.277366519,
-0.0463971347,
0.448092252,
0.3731470108,
-0.4366119504,
0.1469152868,
-0.9056865573,
-0.0274713188,
0.0762333125,
-0.5521675944,
0.1799591035,
-0.4725791514,
0.2680425346,
0.5067824721,
0.0150705893,
-0.7119907737,
0.0230490156,
-0.7195194364,
0.6148537993,
0.649075985,
0.2336627096,
0.6017116904,
0.1941965669,
0.3134676218,
0.2356577814,
-0.4410268664,
-0.3575868309,
-0.1034814194,
-0.7661516666,
0.2869079113,
0.2660168409,
0.2140944302,
-0.9173105955,
0.1413098723,
-0.1427388638,
-0.3737912178,
0.0985365808,
0.5008655787,
0.5279186368,
0.8190484047,
0.2138757259,
-0.4866932631,
-0.5583181381,
-0.7371637225,
-0.0403632559,
0.1164099798,
-0.0905949101,
0.2379768491,
0.7255495191,
0.0065718004,
0.8372033238,
-0.7152144909,
-0.2958587706,
-0.2058562934,
0.1940768361,
0.4839786291,
0.7085567117,
0.4608532488,
-1.0446043015,
-0.7339875698,
0.0978948623,
-0.7214804888,
0.0193167385,
0.0467869453,
-0.2685978711,
0.1924021244,
0.9029957652,
-0.6123611331,
0.2337805033,
0.4915920794,
-0.0981316343,
0.3297010362,
0.1261538565,
-0.2522462308,
-1.4179071188,
0.4203027487,
-0.1531064957,
-0.135881573,
-0.6157740355,
-0.1268889606,
-0.4885198772,
-0.7061160207,
-1.0333151817,
0.7465823889,
-0.7268200517,
-0.2218786031,
-0.5388401151,
0.3789537251,
0.0671140924,
0.7496513724,
0.3096590042,
0.8393037915,
0.5232656598,
-0.8701425195,
0.2913675606,
0.3619069159,
-0.4287222624,
0.5115274191,
-0.6811974645,
0.1721813232,
0.0696868598,
0.2750023901,
-0.9823654294,
-0.5224661231,
0.2400827557,
-0.4849094152,
0.4254745841,
0.0275826771,
-0.2385324985,
-0.4928269088,
-0.1460407674,
0.5414923429,
-0.0597744994,
-0.4391235411,
0.3908266425,
0.2718937695,
-0.0528639033,
-0.3716349304,
-0.8373682499,
-0.1513097584,
-0.1627914757,
-0.5818136334,
0.4676331282,
-0.3638690412,
0.040080782,
0.009582432,
-0.1314132661,
-0.2458923757,
0.0498652011,
0.1393487453,
0.0413537472,
-0.3124301136,
0.2167234868,
-0.271422267,
-0.1630598605,
-0.1573026031,
-0.4630989134,
1.050295949,
-0.2129160464,
0.2039417475,
-0.0709090233,
0.1136747003,
0.2549355924,
-0.0407948159,
0.5279013515,
0.3132334352,
-0.0996866748,
-0.3215096891,
0.3014131188,
-0.4170076549,
-0.5952237844,
0.5589143634,
-0.3587837815,
-0.4936595559,
0.3195707798,
-0.3864964843,
-0.1880961955,
0.2925179601,
0.6687857509,
-0.0206229538,
0.6953983307,
0.4687516689,
0.4043544233,
0.565097034,
-0.412244916,
0.1578369141,
-0.5405513644,
-0.0690689608,
-0.3308598995,
-0.4174052477,
-0.4552653134,
-0.4540112019,
0.368147999,
0.4465813637,
-0.3905675411,
0.4942601919,
-0.6850784421,
0.5896047354,
0.2066998035,
0.138739869,
-0.0406262465,
0.2308392823,
-0.2604424357,
0.2896139324,
-0.6957352757,
-0.299793601,
1.0873637199,
-0.285449028,
0.6051666141,
-0.231153518,
0.4515159428,
0.0268334001,
0.2400197238,
-0.5667461753,
0.6880643368,
-0.0124915205,
-0.7547132373,
-0.1978692561,
-0.3219519556,
-1.0370633602,
0.3666037321,
-0.3964704573,
-0.32127738,
0.2254525125,
0.3551285267,
0.0476640202,
0.4036748111,
-0.6164481044,
1.053232789,
-0.257620275,
-0.7305868864,
0.0384254754,
-0.8116487265,
0.2452307791,
-0.1799656153,
0.0560110472,
0.1036357209,
0.1506298929,
0.4848995209,
-0.6380856633,
0.746823132,
-0.1415078938,
0.1604894549,
0.5129361153,
0.3737691343,
0.0904687271,
-0.2620730996,
-0.0949342698,
-0.0710067302,
-0.4757464826,
-0.4955130219,
-0.4779528975,
0.5623252988,
-0.3219889998,
-0.4257438779,
-0.2263493538,
-0.5863779783,
-0.1339249462,
0.771158278,
0.7067636847,
0.3971933424,
-0.3108656406,
0.2618661225,
0.3664073646,
-0.1209778413,
0.6679001451,
0.270696491,
-0.2512512505,
-0.5477187037,
1.0728447437,
-0.1014119759,
0.45419541,
0.5071461201,
0.1638864875,
-0.1802632213,
-0.6539250016,
-0.5103757381,
0.310641706,
-0.7900545597,
-0.2621271312,
-0.4153756201,
-0.0980854705,
-0.354415834,
-0.7006626129,
-0.4160410762,
-0.3555791974,
-0.3961328268,
-0.4235175252,
0.0947465375,
0.5434176326,
0.0113983443,
0.7188373804,
-0.5988276005,
0.1924204379,
-0.1212273166,
0.3250536621,
-0.2331477702,
-0.0151107842,
-0.3523963988,
-0.0014505864,
-0.4340394437,
-0.7773506641,
0.4298012853,
0.4696878493,
0.2789928615,
0.4060798883,
-0.1446653903,
0.4164839685,
-0.5686561465,
0.68011415,
0.6999974847,
-0.8356635571,
0.7048693895,
-0.5447342992,
0.1969175041,
0.6387659311,
0.4643394947,
-0.0483704731,
-0.1285241693,
-0.7203456759,
-0.9852941632,
0.5516663194,
0.0296265166,
0.0072233365,
-0.1226163134,
0.2427064031,
0.0917212069,
0.6620209217,
-1.1600443125,
0.0497631431,
-0.5035569072,
-0.2807251215,
-0.0713817775,
0.2026057541,
-0.1240945756,
0.1550819278,
0.4761594534,
-0.509554565,
0.0527429581,
0.1580136567,
-0.1432476938,
-0.006831924,
0.1187000349,
0.492528975,
0.6468157768,
-0.2398444563,
0.3202240765,
-0.0854590237,
-0.239299342,
0.100674808,
-0.2376627177,
-0.1103547662,
0.1565410495,
0.0892386809,
0.7989457846,
-0.108886987,
-0.5739096999,
0.6258012652,
0.3884932399,
-0.4776583016,
-0.1716354191,
0.0199354105,
0.0984724313,
0.0655450746,
-0.1372271329,
0.2657284439,
0.2488156259,
-0.7557125688,
0.6145951152,
0.4348694682,
-0.5077174306,
-0.3973051906,
0.7784627676,
0.4711634219,
0.0157549996,
0.3276311755,
-0.0672381073,
-0.4613915384,
0.6007582545,
0.7429490089,
0.5756956935,
-0.2272804379,
0.2825889289,
0.489028722,
-0.2097041756,
0.2082961649,
0.1978663206,
-0.2431491762,
-0.8141952753,
0.339702785,
-0.6440444589,
-0.1363225579,
0.2104802579,
-0.2381426394,
0.391754657,
-0.8107404113,
0.0364014097,
0.0433834046,
-0.072601065,
-0.4471628964,
0.4985026419,
0.0012386665,
0.5823192596,
-0.8312623501,
0.7937467098,
0.5291842222,
-0.7407879829,
-0.4993316531,
-0.1901252568,
-0.0412168168,
-0.5391776562,
0.7666903138,
0.3753151894,
-0.3270925879,
0.0016513871,
-0.8714465499,
-0.6422772408,
1.0826694965,
0.431720674,
-0.3551906049,
-0.0800883397,
0.2603319585,
0.570338726,
-0.6657301784,
0.0216612425,
0.2320107371,
0.1453710347,
0.444845438,
-0.432954967,
0.0511537455,
-0.4826070666,
0.1333727241,
0.2052920461,
-0.6175172329,
1.1474847794,
-0.0160557311,
-0.6854172349,
0.1193236187,
0.5524553061,
0.24494192,
0.2981787324,
0.2153038383,
0.4005936086,
0.5439687371,
0.0007833806,
0.9785987735,
-0.4833996296,
0.1852626652,
1.3034787178,
-0.4826490879,
0.7550465465,
0.5719724894,
0.0245915707,
0.6770025492,
0.5111092329,
-0.3401743472,
0.6298625469,
0.5930784941,
-0.2661884129,
-0.1397127807,
-0.2443929464,
-0.3261633813,
0.2556401789,
0.4036570787,
-0.5248388052,
-0.4455848634,
-0.0352222919,
0.1106666997,
0.2481565177,
-0.3082582057,
0.5437879562,
0.2678928375,
-0.4494597018,
0.4419766963,
-0.1790339053,
0.676420927,
-0.5834382772,
-0.204829216,
-0.1256721616,
0.5490983725,
-0.3897428215,
-1.008680582,
0.2381727695,
-0.3453512788,
-0.218581304,
-0.0082273548,
0.8115329742,
-0.5971364975,
-0.287650615,
0.3323147893,
0.2153401226,
0.3433726132,
0.1424197108,
-0.5822474957,
-0.2735011876,
0.0888380483,
-0.2193263471,
0.4086433947,
0.3673197627,
0.0826508701,
0.4054839313,
0.9292606115,
0.070238255,
0.031162601,
-0.1660546511,
1.169285059,
-0.5220795274,
-0.487793237,
-0.6647297144,
0.6377412081,
-0.1184670255,
-0.3760257661,
0.5358506441,
0.9101563096,
1.2445889711,
-0.333787173,
0.7509378791,
0.030002581,
0.3443229198,
-0.6413992643,
0.5577178597,
-0.5634864569,
0.0882751197,
-0.3471136689,
-1.0365222692,
-0.3656491935,
0.5628979802,
-0.015617433,
0.1594331861,
0.9531136751,
0.9742948413,
-0.1512110233,
-0.2747198343,
0.1699852943,
0.2834717631,
0.4436996579,
0.4718962908,
0.3688926995,
-0.3814837337,
0.8719739914,
-0.055786401,
0.1493630409,
-0.0947343335,
-0.7992921472,
-1.0077629089,
-0.4886362553,
-0.0965071768,
-0.544249177,
-0.2680257261,
0.5489431024,
0.668181479,
-0.7588236928,
-0.5068873167,
-1.0025504827,
-0.2463624179,
0.4432344735,
-0.232590124,
0.2782781124,
-0.3027102649,
-0.7692285776,
0.3483139277,
0.2807534039,
0.2126426548,
-0.1899122447,
0.0356746949,
-0.1846641004,
-0.0473281071,
0.3407662511,
0.4998431802,
-0.1883325279,
0.1004392877,
-0.077137731,
-0.1366050094,
0.4494905174,
1.0708898306,
-0.7296930552,
0.5743482709,
0.7120907903,
0.501263082,
0.9275128841,
-0.1117724851,
0.9353266358,
-0.7713121176,
0.5036991239,
0.1720603704,
0.3784353137,
0.4952374697,
-0.1104727462,
0.6700113416,
0.5554460287,
-0.4431184828,
-0.7416448593,
0.6935442686,
-1.0788764954,
-0.65516752,
0.8719288111,
-0.0426650345,
-0.6899972558,
-0.0649860129,
-0.1998807192,
0.4566978216,
-0.2558572292,
0.3724375367,
0.3324705064,
-0.1989985406,
-0.0717028081,
-0.093005836,
0.6848862767,
0.3470125496,
-0.8465387225,
0.0764083117,
0.6853947043,
0.426029861,
0.5222909451,
0.7958667874,
-0.3376183808,
0.1555426121,
0.5162903666,
0.2672676444,
-0.1440006495,
-0.5387817025,
-0.1318414658,
0.3049189448,
-0.1425811052,
-0.1352175027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06761v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06761v1
|
Learning Knowledge-Enhanced Contextual Language Representations for Domain Natural Language Understanding
| 2023-11-12T07:37:24 | 2023-11-12T07:37:24 |
Ruyao Xu, Taolin Zhang, Chengyu Wang, Zhongjie Duan, Cen Chen, Minghui Qiu, Dawei Cheng, Xiaofeng He, Weining Qian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge-Enhanced Pre-trained Language Models (KEPLMs) improve the
performance of various downstream NLP tasks by injecting knowledge facts from
large-scale Knowledge Graphs (KGs). However, existing methods for pre-training
KEPLMs with relational triples are difficult to be adapted to close domains due
to the lack of sufficient domain graph semantics. In this paper, we propose a
Knowledge-enhanced lANGuAge Representation learning framework for various
clOsed dOmains (KANGAROO) via capturing the implicit graph structure among the
entities. Specifically, since the entity coverage rates of closed-domain KGs
can be relatively low and may exhibit the global sparsity phenomenon for
knowledge injection, we consider not only the shallow relational
representations of triples but also the hyperbolic embeddings of deep
hierarchical entity-class structures for effective knowledge fusion.Moreover,
as two closed-domain entities under the same entity-class often have locally
dense neighbor subgraphs counted by max point biconnected component, we further
propose a data augmentation strategy based on contrastive learning over
subgraphs to construct hard negative samples of higher quality. It makes the
underlying KELPMs better distinguish the semantics of these neighboring
entities to further complement the global semantic sparsity. In the
experiments, we evaluate KANGAROO over various knowledge-aware and general NLP
tasks in both full and few-shot learning settings, outperforming various KEPLM
training paradigms performance in closed-domains significantly.
|
[
-0.5119642615,
-0.858907938,
0.4322766066,
0.0906065628,
-0.2543592751,
0.235235557,
-0.5517932177,
-0.4004265368,
0.1560208648,
0.6905975342,
-0.3223404586,
-0.8483064771,
-0.6342642903,
0.1405264884,
0.2817845345,
0.7005776763,
-0.134080559,
-0.2671872675,
-0.291693598,
-0.3109673858,
-0.5873259306,
-0.7244405746,
-0.469078064,
-0.5625223517,
0.2671074867,
0.3613978624,
0.7987327576,
0.1381102949,
-0.0378128327,
0.181098938,
0.0285857152,
0.5269209743,
-0.4578959048,
0.010994616,
-0.2633902431,
-0.3555445075,
-0.1994128078,
-0.0598575361,
0.655021131,
1.1420178413,
0.0161824692,
-0.3189206123,
0.3105745316,
0.6525630355,
-0.7186912298,
0.7031154037,
-0.707859695,
0.2006447315,
-0.0582128279,
-0.1471960098,
-0.4008731544,
-0.2110861987,
0.1191348806,
-1.0265811682,
-0.0724261552,
0.1339964271,
0.8697291613,
0.247534737,
-0.5698240995,
-0.1395953596,
-0.3945304453,
0.6400765181,
-0.4548941255,
0.5309365392,
0.4132672548,
0.2546611428,
-0.2032388151,
-0.551484406,
-0.7387653589,
0.0656594709,
-0.6506124735,
0.0595452674,
-0.1065904051,
0.1198431998,
0.1179157346,
0.2542963326,
-0.460414499,
-0.093142733,
-0.0043541878,
-0.3371717334,
0.2194390893,
-0.0243684761,
0.3725624382,
-0.2281988263,
-0.5556764603,
0.005113198,
-0.7678486705,
-0.0367346369,
0.1501678079,
0.6402642727,
-0.1985972524,
0.4386973679,
-0.2935649157,
0.8722901344,
-0.0754292533,
-0.0763116255,
0.5295064449,
-0.2629697323,
-0.2609840035,
-0.0222027916,
0.6714677811,
0.1770918071,
0.3545763195,
-0.3140308559,
0.0669270456,
-0.1224943399,
-0.0677277297,
-0.5911342502,
-0.2307650447,
0.0961642414,
0.0079870634,
0.086510174,
-0.1325035244,
-0.5076467991,
-0.2017670125,
-0.4997076988,
0.3298124969,
-0.6707112193,
-0.5609932542,
0.3915919662,
-0.0710245669,
0.109291926,
0.1579754204,
-0.8470585346,
0.5830706358,
0.5249388218,
0.6063798666,
0.0198162124,
-0.228037715,
-0.5515466928,
0.567737639,
-0.315102011,
0.6707519889,
-0.8184694648,
-0.0070188395,
0.1916191131,
-0.0824955031,
-0.3933944702,
-0.6136468649,
0.3004549444,
-0.8782864213,
0.2846462131,
-0.1447671503,
-0.6152201891,
-0.5959216952,
0.3987815976,
-0.4129694104,
1.0767421722,
0.3669427633,
-0.7230709195,
0.5579146147,
-0.7178736329,
-0.5474644303,
0.1701977849,
-0.2510844171,
-0.3599130511,
-0.3947725892,
0.5462357402,
0.8121785522,
0.2534441352,
0.1610092968,
-0.1999939531,
-0.2821890712,
-0.2817559838,
0.1464217156,
0.6542186141,
-0.192530483,
-0.2422157973,
-0.0760595873,
-0.5213626027,
0.1726016998,
0.1416544467,
-0.1427406073,
-0.7938881516,
-0.3435115814,
-0.3453288972,
0.1966061145,
-0.003306692,
-0.3610587418,
0.2296783775,
-0.6073951721,
0.1956756115,
0.395280689,
0.2204346955,
0.6208598614,
0.2507607937,
0.2166640908,
0.3075706661,
-0.1635942459,
-0.02860092,
-0.4697645009,
-0.4972183108,
-0.366011411,
0.2897099257,
0.3089291751,
-0.9390476346,
0.4952626824,
-0.3480006456,
0.0162012801,
-0.1773616523,
0.3566023409,
0.3879968822,
0.6733734608,
0.7031495571,
-0.3843384385,
-0.4056943655,
-0.8168753386,
-0.1152138785,
-0.0245579462,
0.0531035289,
0.7174350619,
0.4589825869,
-0.3692815304,
1.005022049,
-0.6955276728,
-0.6814916134,
-0.2563391328,
0.126610294,
0.2088374794,
0.3483268917,
0.5939431787,
-0.8496117592,
-0.6293504238,
0.0797021687,
-0.7198047042,
0.0516766682,
0.239179492,
-0.4362907708,
0.1545549333,
0.2583144307,
-0.8780421019,
0.1369981617,
0.3390226066,
-0.2096170187,
0.3387450278,
-0.0719203725,
0.0506351143,
-0.832472682,
-0.0190439466,
-0.1462824941,
-0.4389736056,
-0.6408738494,
0.046022322,
0.1942535341,
-0.1913632154,
-0.380351007,
0.5853402019,
-0.5142610669,
-0.1441258639,
-0.0996799991,
0.5855841637,
0.249233067,
0.8413626552,
0.6205297709,
0.6240229011,
0.5400951505,
-0.8453395963,
0.1348257661,
0.4216820598,
-0.2290436476,
0.3645562232,
-0.1542804837,
0.1948916763,
-0.0726041123,
0.4583030045,
-0.599199295,
-0.3751866519,
0.4657089114,
-0.3755576313,
0.5411654711,
-0.2795462906,
-0.4544805288,
-0.1498500109,
-0.0351603515,
0.3678625822,
0.5602216721,
-0.8558108211,
0.6887977123,
0.4319689274,
-0.1702888459,
-0.9949855208,
-0.4351453483,
0.0650044456,
-0.0653624162,
-0.7023801208,
0.5301557183,
0.4329583645,
-0.0647934824,
0.4710397124,
0.0533714965,
-0.0238456447,
-0.0133517906,
0.0122967847,
-0.0337874107,
-0.4505687058,
0.34581092,
0.2026296109,
-0.2517141998,
-0.0345045403,
-0.6492364407,
0.6762424707,
-0.1447064877,
-0.3103524148,
-0.206188947,
0.2213810384,
0.1526962072,
-0.1892038286,
1.0652087927,
0.4814174771,
-0.5246129036,
-0.2716425955,
-0.4491886199,
-0.0205931049,
-0.392544955,
0.2751340866,
-0.434394449,
-1.1020952463,
0.4398126602,
-0.4441554844,
-0.2699564397,
0.510209918,
0.3139415085,
0.0857440382,
0.767272234,
0.8582533002,
-0.1992735714,
0.1292640865,
-0.4001402557,
0.2897031307,
-0.8030201197,
-0.5219945908,
-0.2690430582,
0.214581579,
-0.0459110364,
-0.6801751256,
0.1637232453,
0.6458021402,
-0.339055419,
0.2468104661,
-0.1700344533,
0.5894668698,
0.247878477,
0.0633537099,
0.3514231145,
0.299210906,
-0.6385194659,
-0.0238154922,
-0.8266528249,
-0.4307499826,
0.7498137951,
0.1370471418,
0.4365746379,
0.1044226661,
0.6390462518,
0.176896438,
0.3336441219,
-0.7253895402,
0.3550963402,
0.0234254133,
-0.2652247548,
-0.2787863612,
-0.5050011873,
-0.6969219446,
0.4459424019,
-0.2330583781,
-0.5453447104,
0.1700046808,
0.1905442476,
-0.1340275407,
0.4089669287,
-0.735073328,
0.7368834019,
0.0775643811,
-0.3684884906,
-0.1569369882,
-0.6147877574,
0.4194791615,
0.0439966619,
0.33159253,
-0.0487482883,
-0.1152930632,
0.4238310158,
-0.4368982315,
1.0177433491,
-0.5376952291,
-0.0115699079,
0.3461583853,
-0.1046047062,
0.5004397631,
0.1723773628,
0.0848603994,
0.3363852799,
-0.6260461807,
-0.6566200256,
-0.8224852085,
0.4946391881,
-0.7238368988,
-0.616783917,
-0.1200249121,
-0.4012059867,
-0.6337272525,
0.2181833982,
-0.1537510008,
0.4636003971,
-0.0029218665,
0.0206001848,
0.6964839101,
-0.3883151114,
-0.0316675603,
0.5553636551,
-0.1325441748,
-0.3590770662,
0.8993718028,
-0.2241053432,
0.3534029722,
0.5812950134,
0.0103104664,
-0.5370582342,
-0.437972635,
-0.5125516057,
0.2809435725,
-0.8457908034,
-0.3797242045,
-0.9680965543,
-0.1293890774,
-0.4280414581,
-0.1657060981,
-0.0780994594,
-0.443701148,
-0.0187792201,
-0.2911592424,
0.3724714816,
0.6745515466,
-0.2723877728,
0.1424271762,
-0.6733591557,
0.4143143594,
0.3228080571,
0.4782474041,
0.0426810384,
-0.2355824411,
-0.2871196568,
-0.0800599083,
-0.0067747822,
-0.5381739736,
0.3041513562,
0.3209995329,
0.7175607085,
0.2040043026,
0.0499200597,
0.6701719761,
-0.483009696,
0.8172667027,
0.2399678975,
-0.8017542362,
0.5034675002,
-0.1929006428,
0.0946475938,
0.4082223177,
0.6698857546,
-0.5158885717,
-0.4449822307,
-0.4745459855,
-0.877558887,
0.7013297677,
0.3599082232,
0.365131557,
-0.1422642916,
0.5280749202,
0.3364368379,
0.0853939578,
-0.8241538405,
-0.3490421772,
-0.2784682512,
-0.2770999968,
0.0509281196,
-0.1441991478,
-0.1472066939,
-0.0867617205,
0.8171727061,
-0.3814163804,
0.0847247392,
0.1743767112,
-0.4033896625,
0.0342591181,
0.3548935652,
0.1601528823,
0.3798280656,
-0.275100857,
0.4433311522,
0.211195156,
-0.3857443333,
-0.0088247526,
0.219504416,
0.0396369994,
-0.1248622462,
0.5077685118,
0.7257605791,
0.2966021895,
-0.4438813627,
0.6638548374,
-0.0577417873,
-0.0880920663,
-0.0066172453,
0.0630699322,
0.1928128302,
0.0108042983,
0.3423424065,
0.1657602191,
-0.1170595586,
-0.4476490915,
0.2611861825,
0.4497475326,
-0.4738228619,
-0.1214202344,
0.3104192615,
0.2809320092,
0.0587479584,
0.5226800442,
-0.2719382048,
-0.9236581922,
0.3222399056,
0.6808804274,
0.3765966296,
0.003837446,
0.2047072202,
0.5046805143,
0.0899377242,
0.2619710267,
0.0102373771,
-0.487326771,
-1.0223915577,
-0.6644889116,
-0.5728299022,
-0.4773823917,
0.243765533,
-0.5478345156,
0.0306636374,
-0.1679466069,
0.1415124983,
-0.3425008953,
0.0838334337,
-0.8132010698,
0.2274055183,
0.1112242416,
0.8140153289,
-0.9475334287,
0.7441906929,
0.6449995637,
-0.5345273018,
-0.8079866171,
0.1455914378,
-0.3512860537,
-0.8537402153,
1.0002076626,
0.2582582831,
-0.3259284198,
-0.018153131,
-0.4302872717,
-0.7863813639,
0.8468719721,
0.4799826145,
-0.1823855489,
0.2913537323,
0.4055648446,
0.4027294219,
-0.6040144563,
0.0009046026,
0.4633356333,
0.3252207637,
-0.174753204,
-0.5275418162,
0.2875647843,
-0.1678078473,
-0.2234677076,
0.197301954,
-0.4985036552,
0.3672109842,
-0.2819419205,
-0.5204167962,
-0.3639377654,
0.7493462563,
0.3520437479,
0.1250125468,
0.58584553,
0.5860860944,
0.9389784336,
0.0311544333,
1.2154384851,
-0.2117084861,
0.2128318548,
0.9959622025,
-0.2778482437,
0.7185742855,
0.3187440932,
-0.0401324928,
0.7271251082,
0.45661816,
0.596562624,
0.8057152629,
-0.0200215187,
-0.3029794991,
-0.4911755323,
-0.3196549118,
-0.546194911,
0.0439297371,
0.7747672796,
-0.0896086767,
-0.2360933125,
0.0855146199,
-0.1059410647,
0.2633332312,
-0.1956284642,
0.8476840854,
0.241863519,
-0.3355912268,
0.7526325583,
-0.2036750168,
0.5719211102,
-0.5913115144,
-0.3670673668,
-0.1337371767,
-0.0905318633,
-0.3282684982,
-0.9164330959,
0.1255603582,
-0.2758535147,
-0.1168978065,
-0.1941531897,
1.0949892998,
-0.6489959955,
-0.0091516655,
0.7484474182,
0.5200493932,
0.0146803576,
-0.0834257826,
-0.4936499596,
-0.2187312245,
-0.2469417304,
-0.2693810463,
0.2776327133,
0.5025376678,
0.0984645709,
0.4961609244,
0.4199597836,
-0.0428709313,
-0.1140175015,
0.4337873161,
1.0824022293,
-0.5184990764,
-0.4319910705,
-0.5850799084,
0.424775362,
-0.3703720868,
0.0592109263,
0.5950422287,
0.5394407511,
1.0546139479,
0.0256757848,
0.9125984311,
0.1436840892,
0.3946857452,
-0.8646231294,
0.5044064522,
-0.4128253162,
0.1873592734,
-0.2031105608,
-0.9619916677,
-0.5138210058,
0.5668929815,
-0.4676550031,
-0.1449240446,
0.6990444064,
0.5866020918,
-0.2785791755,
0.0191377252,
0.3388696909,
0.3007776737,
0.0740580857,
0.5577248931,
0.8165467381,
-0.288225621,
0.5713674426,
-0.3346776962,
-0.1869728714,
0.0381647162,
-0.7236827016,
-1.0244079828,
-0.4958533049,
-0.3301921189,
-0.1979314685,
0.1366778463,
0.7134196758,
0.8088670373,
-0.758048892,
0.3308835626,
-0.0249020625,
0.3026284575,
-0.1558636129,
-0.2860226631,
0.7389418483,
-0.6591767669,
-0.4388698936,
0.5431480408,
0.4196312129,
-0.1469907761,
0.0100497091,
-0.1977654248,
-0.0015767427,
-0.2213240415,
0.8399421573,
0.2311957628,
-0.6208588481,
-0.5852922201,
-0.261821717,
-0.0631256998,
0.2026227713,
0.7797350883,
-1.1260250807,
0.2829769254,
0.1333048791,
0.832734704,
0.6051771641,
0.0311428308,
0.6118994951,
-1.1853978634,
0.2531678975,
0.1903273463,
0.4545971155,
0.603931427,
-0.5342672467,
0.5903618932,
0.3009983897,
-0.068600893,
-0.4750981629,
0.2508903742,
-0.7757868767,
-0.2860400975,
1.1646876335,
-0.3021755815,
-0.0470947437,
-0.6364701986,
-0.0786654875,
0.2169174999,
-0.3791629672,
0.2942419052,
0.451848954,
-0.2309669554,
0.1447163969,
-0.3753418624,
0.6038063169,
0.3257303238,
-0.6718735695,
0.1794671267,
0.3680001497,
0.3721509576,
0.2733791769,
0.8140894175,
-0.2396294773,
-0.0233619157,
-0.0643301979,
-0.0238870662,
-0.2433525473,
-0.2858054638,
-0.1399865299,
0.4447223842,
-0.1669867933,
0.1700965911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06758v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06758v1
|
Sharing, Teaching and Aligning: Knowledgeable Transfer Learning for Cross-Lingual Machine Reading Comprehension
| 2023-11-12T07:20:37 | 2023-11-12T07:20:37 |
Tingfeng Cao, Chengyu Wang, Chuanqi Tan, Jun Huang, Jinhui Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In cross-lingual language understanding, machine translation is often
utilized to enhance the transferability of models across languages, either by
translating the training data from the source language to the target, or from
the target to the source to aid inference. However, in cross-lingual machine
reading comprehension (MRC), it is difficult to perform a deep level of
assistance to enhance cross-lingual transfer because of the variation of answer
span positions in different languages. In this paper, we propose X-STA, a new
approach for cross-lingual MRC. Specifically, we leverage an attentive teacher
to subtly transfer the answer spans of the source language to the answer output
space of the target. A Gradient-Disentangled Knowledge Sharing technique is
proposed as an improved cross-attention block. In addition, we force the model
to learn semantic alignments from multiple granularities and calibrate the
model outputs with teacher guidance to enhance cross-lingual transferability.
Experiments on three multi-lingual MRC datasets show the effectiveness of our
method, outperforming state-of-the-art approaches.
|
[
-0.3589089811,
-0.3968996406,
0.2229526043,
-0.0083226459,
-0.282366395,
0.3258275986,
0.0186356995,
-0.5684306026,
0.2392194271,
0.1875480264,
-0.6768118143,
-0.320425868,
-0.8214460015,
0.0127653787,
-0.3633387983,
0.7972622514,
-0.5714381337,
0.241377309,
-0.3405863047,
-0.2691573203,
-0.608820498,
-0.2742006183,
-0.7652585506,
-0.3088285029,
0.7603933811,
0.6030561328,
0.6768453717,
0.7434411645,
0.320445329,
0.2491590828,
0.2642896771,
0.1840798259,
-0.3819231689,
-0.2723810673,
-0.5583120584,
-0.7285612226,
-0.2035346627,
-0.2510710061,
0.8309399486,
0.9810224175,
-0.0021758517,
-0.0531467944,
0.2340284288,
0.8290005326,
-0.4991766214,
0.0480973758,
-0.3198957741,
0.3601596951,
0.2356444895,
-0.1607717127,
-0.4066203833,
-0.2246474028,
0.3177977204,
-0.9468302131,
-0.0851547047,
0.078437455,
0.7963982224,
0.4505226314,
-0.5459875464,
-0.3598244488,
-0.3086294234,
0.8435112238,
-0.1085960194,
0.7965667844,
0.605629921,
0.4633207321,
0.4672209322,
-0.5926542878,
-0.6136885285,
0.1771093458,
-0.2346631289,
0.189232707,
-0.0711947456,
-0.4735638797,
-0.2168238908,
0.2261992842,
-0.6353968978,
-0.0453324951,
-0.373732239,
0.1319874972,
0.4931908846,
-0.1208151057,
0.4183517396,
-0.02906348,
-0.8708679676,
-0.371638149,
-0.5332295299,
0.2337934673,
0.186987251,
0.2307579666,
-0.1355286241,
0.3412618935,
0.0672292858,
0.6469942927,
0.0115778269,
0.1567149907,
0.0603217669,
-0.7623953819,
-0.0467283055,
0.2456056178,
0.4755190015,
0.2510277927,
0.3876399398,
-0.1970167011,
0.061286889,
-0.3406977057,
0.254561305,
-0.4237797856,
-0.2217257917,
-0.1866085976,
-0.4271295071,
-0.2240353674,
-0.0659741536,
-0.7709707022,
-0.1292734295,
-0.5587553382,
0.43671,
-0.4397955537,
-0.1978464872,
0.2902113795,
0.1077384055,
0.1313536763,
0.048117511,
-1.2182748318,
0.1482532322,
0.4326049089,
0.6842753291,
-0.2857526541,
-0.81609869,
-0.3946253657,
0.4439504445,
-0.2513184547,
0.4510735571,
-0.4624778032,
-0.1836956292,
-0.0659563765,
0.207472086,
-0.4837050736,
-0.1995468736,
0.0287245642,
-0.7773168683,
0.4852170944,
-0.2350488305,
-0.4404241443,
-0.3122625947,
0.3568369448,
-0.5914547443,
0.9656421542,
0.3679860532,
-0.7864595652,
0.2565683722,
-0.3877580464,
-0.6363583207,
-0.4200223982,
0.0113595454,
-0.2683496475,
-0.3239063025,
0.4927814007,
0.2509551048,
0.0374194458,
0.116756998,
-0.1206813082,
-0.0542952679,
0.4347737134,
-0.3138661385,
1.0426818132,
0.2513243258,
-0.3744927049,
0.07701388,
-0.5779421329,
0.1317112893,
-0.1047006175,
-0.0525790974,
-0.5715847611,
-0.5159056187,
-0.1582197845,
0.4065469801,
0.0728699118,
-0.1179313287,
0.1902084947,
-0.0266219117,
0.2684264183,
0.6167517304,
-0.2440876961,
0.9636603594,
-0.4707947075,
0.7197560072,
0.1578926444,
-0.1079095453,
-0.0826726109,
-0.3083794415,
-0.6261289716,
-0.4223447144,
0.5291487575,
0.8462774754,
-1.2220038176,
0.2381787449,
-0.3539156914,
-0.3432624042,
-0.9448128939,
0.3067391515,
0.5530177355,
0.7842188478,
0.432975024,
-0.1956531405,
-0.490778774,
-0.6162012219,
-0.2942709625,
0.073257789,
0.0117891161,
0.1920466572,
0.2475309223,
-0.2173105031,
0.4890267551,
-0.4210416973,
-0.3158614635,
-0.2614628077,
0.054262165,
-0.2839121521,
0.5366069078,
0.3882464767,
-0.7660675645,
-1.0748978853,
0.5072954297,
-0.8226556778,
-0.0421189144,
-0.2731317878,
-0.806470871,
0.3255329132,
0.6312089562,
-0.1612270027,
0.20352301,
0.7389121056,
-0.4097591341,
0.1863284409,
-0.0962509885,
0.4828081429,
-1.5000061989,
0.1847344339,
-0.2433852255,
-0.5637868047,
-0.5172984004,
0.0551820211,
0.2543338835,
0.0916097164,
-0.430097878,
0.6145195961,
-0.584002316,
-0.0084500657,
0.0069357646,
0.6784211993,
0.2174367756,
0.4952161014,
0.3981407583,
0.6500650048,
0.7367500067,
-0.4614699185,
0.2345597744,
0.5389202237,
-0.2699143589,
0.9713201523,
-0.3421912193,
-0.0464444049,
0.1119623557,
0.1298077404,
-0.8275473118,
0.2221307755,
0.4405450225,
-0.5224314332,
0.6086375713,
-0.237598002,
-0.1058100536,
0.1372519433,
-0.0856467336,
0.67220366,
0.2846230567,
-0.8805342913,
0.5408818722,
0.2989610136,
-0.2871960104,
-1.0275752544,
-1.0792775154,
-0.1331080496,
-0.1355041265,
-0.9302258492,
0.4172539413,
0.1682278514,
0.1051112041,
0.2028679699,
-0.0420632213,
-0.2585116625,
-0.0605667047,
-0.2203574628,
0.538251102,
-0.17442514,
0.0346310735,
0.3581462204,
-0.3607114255,
-0.109639883,
-0.4740723372,
0.1639775932,
0.2143767029,
-0.4732242823,
-0.4507281482,
0.6409159899,
0.3836048841,
-0.3022390306,
0.758094728,
0.6993763447,
-0.2781450748,
-0.2560860217,
0.262462467,
-0.2706364989,
-0.4310893118,
0.3137969971,
-0.6786090732,
-0.8187617064,
0.603402853,
0.2673636377,
-0.0302327219,
-0.0504438728,
0.2738524079,
-0.0672560036,
0.9101219177,
0.8372382522,
-0.1484649926,
0.7522779703,
-0.1159648076,
0.1878422052,
-0.5353810787,
-0.2043072879,
-0.3161894679,
-0.5308220387,
-0.2016736716,
-0.6650701761,
-0.1133421808,
0.1638890207,
-0.0127391703,
0.4181938767,
-0.3227768242,
0.4685733914,
0.6431216002,
-0.1079988033,
0.5558655858,
0.3312856555,
-0.1684503406,
-0.1434076875,
-0.825681448,
-0.2068718672,
0.7820720077,
0.2805198133,
0.8618396521,
0.2825399935,
0.5249535441,
-0.0066397437,
0.1151880845,
-0.6343507171,
0.2156246752,
-0.1747056842,
-0.5078014135,
-0.4512960613,
-0.7426400781,
-0.9042073488,
0.5106694102,
0.1008456275,
-0.6423723698,
0.1843628436,
-0.0436915345,
-0.0644785091,
0.488052249,
-0.882769227,
1.0349144936,
-0.3172050714,
-0.4014109373,
-0.1666619629,
-0.9398218989,
0.3100667894,
-0.054778453,
0.0614949279,
0.4222786129,
-0.0658970997,
0.6374958754,
-0.1049607098,
0.797776103,
-0.1449195892,
-0.4065361619,
0.1602616012,
0.1172200516,
0.5300270915,
0.0369916409,
0.1585198492,
0.054652568,
0.2453970015,
-0.6051369905,
-0.9216151834,
0.6549853683,
-0.8864948153,
-0.3698749244,
-0.31537655,
-0.9376726747,
-0.4311470687,
0.3048105538,
-0.0088830888,
0.01260141,
0.0412477665,
-0.0921258181,
0.8414075375,
0.2765983939,
0.0612659641,
0.678798914,
-0.3391681612,
-0.4766767621,
1.1804879904,
0.1848882139,
0.4656868279,
0.8601599336,
-0.0710185394,
-0.6398415565,
-0.3000093102,
-0.8487636447,
0.2727595568,
-0.8486121297,
0.0339650773,
-0.5686812401,
-0.1218652055,
-0.5718225837,
-0.5754303932,
-0.1889730245,
-0.4878492653,
-0.48848629,
-0.2131332904,
0.1680861712,
0.5168933272,
-0.2787539661,
0.2973945141,
-1.1018853188,
0.1426437348,
0.2041274756,
0.1989005655,
-0.0376759879,
-0.821432054,
-0.5104836822,
0.1230124682,
-0.0319833532,
-0.7065967321,
0.3413513303,
0.0673087761,
0.6334278584,
0.3647865653,
0.3040356934,
0.7582133412,
-0.3226883411,
0.238013342,
0.3651114404,
-1.0929296017,
0.1001755223,
0.0810899436,
0.1854787916,
0.6758049726,
0.8428239822,
-0.9472665191,
-0.1522848755,
-0.3004835546,
-0.6199002862,
0.8368564844,
-0.2753077745,
-0.1600413471,
0.5327474475,
0.0194694344,
0.3932487071,
-0.0073379837,
-0.5445792675,
-0.322285682,
-0.3607822061,
-0.6015363932,
-0.1645496637,
0.1765484512,
-0.4926883578,
-0.1728518307,
0.7672668099,
-0.4107977152,
0.0261742063,
0.1904197782,
-0.4215162098,
-0.2167930454,
0.0834143534,
0.5701582432,
0.6643773913,
0.2010212988,
0.5627570152,
0.3071471453,
-0.4148322344,
0.2364829928,
0.3545915782,
-0.0043747118,
-0.2811126113,
0.4029868543,
0.8359760642,
0.3630306721,
-0.3787782192,
0.2746989727,
-0.1375245452,
-0.3754327297,
0.2130719423,
-0.2031086236,
0.3821572065,
0.3615584671,
0.0229343791,
-0.0502293259,
-0.172800988,
-0.2459736615,
0.5041208267,
0.1781412512,
-0.6554700136,
-0.349857986,
0.373734951,
0.1956192851,
0.0436366349,
0.5895767808,
-0.0236416273,
-0.6282999516,
0.3125521243,
0.7536141276,
0.4907261729,
-0.208060801,
0.4727639556,
0.17602548,
0.3340772092,
0.2711652815,
0.2285381854,
-0.4365979731,
-0.6354191303,
-0.3547661304,
-0.1101368591,
-0.3847766519,
-0.5618211627,
-0.8510075808,
0.0836035088,
0.0024916313,
0.4143402576,
-0.0622086674,
0.1483644843,
-0.3120288551,
0.0664880797,
0.0650254935,
0.8825522661,
-0.9746456742,
1.1383482218,
0.845059216,
-0.4849537909,
-0.8772553205,
-0.2328508347,
-0.1915205419,
-1.0998612642,
0.5282545686,
-0.1274974048,
-0.2374357134,
0.0961624682,
-0.077533111,
-0.8604001403,
1.2590287924,
0.3853094578,
-0.5123715401,
0.0140222488,
0.4617729783,
0.3125209212,
-0.3288370073,
0.0146709699,
0.3693858683,
0.5440667868,
0.318099767,
-0.6698714495,
0.1657864302,
-0.039767731,
-0.250887543,
0.0484974086,
-0.544712007,
0.5371018648,
-0.2439378202,
-0.4188333154,
-0.2146046907,
0.8223686218,
0.2261548936,
0.5598290563,
0.6255943179,
0.7777953148,
1.0449692011,
0.250985533,
0.9474517107,
-0.3453916013,
0.2670432031,
1.2105875015,
-0.2209302932,
0.8810475469,
0.8890268207,
-0.1442575008,
0.484175235,
0.7350615263,
0.3464103043,
0.7121842504,
0.0203194916,
-0.2921608984,
-0.2174843997,
-0.0472045466,
-0.3670495152,
-0.0576379411,
0.0403376296,
-0.3709156215,
-0.1422932595,
0.2571416199,
0.0470909849,
0.0791834518,
-0.2913386226,
0.6389086246,
0.3016587198,
-0.8886805177,
0.8117960095,
-0.3418715298,
0.5318023562,
-0.6734851599,
0.0880441219,
-0.2819260061,
0.4460096061,
-0.3235726655,
-1.1419979334,
0.6222210526,
-0.2692447305,
-0.5088536739,
-0.4296680391,
0.5243422389,
-1.0682057142,
-0.3334115744,
0.5298955441,
0.7125026584,
0.139048636,
0.2147876918,
-0.9482398629,
-0.2792612612,
0.4562480152,
0.1047874838,
0.6441997886,
0.6397822499,
-0.1754258275,
0.7755424976,
0.5140781403,
-0.1699432433,
0.4081059098,
0.0357099064,
0.7726866603,
-0.3684564233,
-0.6397644281,
-0.3588730991,
0.5669355989,
0.1956054568,
-0.2967902422,
0.8178117275,
0.1268984228,
1.2952200174,
-0.097039178,
0.7110471129,
-0.0044236793,
0.367970407,
-0.5388364792,
1.0417981148,
-0.8119153976,
-0.0497965515,
0.0728703588,
-0.6726635695,
-0.3159143329,
0.5943294168,
-0.1908100992,
-0.0649346113,
0.9800788164,
0.8595770597,
-0.3154755235,
-0.0332718641,
0.48672387,
-0.4264065325,
0.0735978782,
0.8217327595,
0.8829429746,
-0.5031735301,
1.0077526569,
-0.374242276,
-0.3429860175,
-0.13081038,
-0.5716165304,
-0.9300257564,
-0.7567051053,
-0.4271401465,
-0.2785430551,
0.2361859679,
0.4715357125,
0.8006034493,
-0.7611049414,
-0.1498457491,
-0.0642939508,
0.5767602324,
-0.6380259991,
-0.2040421218,
0.5593694448,
-0.4280205071,
-1.0304706097,
0.31041646,
-0.2387698442,
0.1943984777,
-0.3163258731,
-0.2886864543,
-0.4934076667,
-0.0632516742,
0.3836300969,
0.3352719843,
-0.1202458143,
-0.2198829204,
0.2820304036,
-0.4089827538,
-0.0406039618,
0.7722252011,
-0.472830534,
0.4824184179,
0.8391407132,
1.2578774691,
0.3144291043,
-0.0229882132,
0.6594164968,
-0.8483126163,
-0.2030251175,
-0.1383360773,
0.2832422853,
0.3046979606,
-0.3131873012,
0.3947045207,
0.1576511264,
-0.5214309096,
-0.6658667922,
0.1954251826,
-0.9846566319,
-0.2230543643,
0.9038199186,
-0.6200172305,
-0.5076543689,
-0.2022515684,
-0.2913189828,
0.478906095,
-0.2334238142,
0.5965385437,
0.6877683401,
0.1005740687,
-0.4916540682,
-0.2080783695,
0.2540644109,
0.8712485433,
-0.919183135,
0.2806025147,
0.0009952993,
0.2360185087,
0.2149366736,
0.2811664045,
-0.0826570615,
0.1907971501,
0.2299842089,
0.0471880026,
-0.1700328439,
-0.3904166818,
-0.5082500577,
-0.0663065985,
-0.238378942,
-0.64729321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06754v1
|
From Complex to Simple: Unraveling the Cognitive Tree for Reasoning with Small Language Models
| 2023-11-12T06:56:21 | 2023-11-12T06:56:21 |
Junbing Yan, Chengyu Wang, Taolin Zhang, Xiaofeng He, Jun Huang, Wei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reasoning is a distinctive human capacity, enabling us to address complex
problems by breaking them down into a series of manageable cognitive steps.
Yet, complex logical reasoning is still cumbersome for language models. Based
on the dual process theory in cognitive science, we are the first to unravel
the cognitive reasoning abilities of language models. Our framework employs an
iterative methodology to construct a Cognitive Tree (CogTree). The root node of
this tree represents the initial query, while the leaf nodes consist of
straightforward questions that can be answered directly. This construction
involves two main components: the implicit extraction module (referred to as
the intuitive system) and the explicit reasoning module (referred to as the
reflective system). The intuitive system rapidly generates multiple responses
by utilizing in-context examples, while the reflective system scores these
responses using comparative learning. The scores guide the intuitive system in
its subsequent generation step. Our experimental results on two popular and
challenging reasoning tasks indicate that it is possible to achieve a
performance level comparable to that of GPT-3.5 (with 175B parameters), using a
significantly smaller language model that contains fewer parameters (<=7B) than
5% of GPT-3.5.
|
[
-0.4963238537,
-1.2290728092,
0.9216284156,
-0.0939637646,
-0.2303059548,
0.2928656638,
-0.5210632682,
-0.7011697292,
-0.3527255952,
0.3310635388,
-0.8002429008,
-0.2325387746,
-0.5176855922,
-0.1630121171,
-0.1331928819,
0.808052063,
0.1353585124,
-0.0352489986,
0.0214100573,
-0.0911634862,
-0.3547353745,
-0.3330172002,
-0.962076962,
-0.455640614,
0.4066202044,
0.7750188708,
0.7552642822,
0.2086500376,
0.3299708962,
0.2512823045,
-0.1466640532,
0.096360296,
-0.2860261798,
0.0837913528,
-0.4608283937,
-0.6097645164,
-0.2886314392,
-0.0310377516,
0.2332568616,
1.1173330545,
-0.0574195348,
0.3317712545,
0.0697111562,
0.67138201,
-0.1993834078,
0.3509909809,
-0.7130624652,
-0.1073140502,
-0.1772020161,
-0.0315312669,
-0.4696252644,
-0.1788188219,
0.3759742975,
-0.6514550447,
0.3181177974,
0.2011536509,
0.6119178534,
0.2371163219,
-0.6728224754,
-0.55004704,
-0.9184146523,
0.8060265779,
-0.2830041051,
-0.0278111752,
0.1042728499,
0.6614316106,
-0.0778285712,
-0.739249289,
-0.4853966534,
-0.5149251223,
-0.1555298418,
0.0869367197,
-0.2342990935,
0.1998148859,
0.562215507,
0.1208219752,
-0.6296753287,
-0.1775390059,
-0.2815782726,
-0.0769734383,
0.6791425943,
0.2402530611,
0.5120490193,
-0.218238011,
-0.0773522928,
0.0172522645,
-0.5383043289,
0.3838846684,
0.1636906564,
0.3403024971,
0.2555842996,
0.6362772584,
-0.2747642696,
0.4158819318,
0.1303293854,
-0.0192161761,
-0.3736765385,
-0.3215894401,
-0.2116456479,
0.0039820583,
0.4885576367,
-0.1468242407,
0.4276252687,
-0.0169784334,
-0.1399617791,
0.6363688707,
0.1561782658,
-0.5026923418,
-0.4651278257,
0.1532136202,
-0.3200094998,
-0.1094657183,
-0.1825620681,
-0.2769962251,
0.0690740719,
-0.6339290738,
0.3088222444,
-0.6247996092,
-0.4967295229,
0.1572865844,
-0.0270852335,
0.0851213485,
0.8441002965,
-0.5753393173,
0.7835963368,
0.8266559839,
0.4386505485,
0.0219669845,
-0.0001904072,
-0.3460200131,
0.1147703007,
-0.0592119694,
0.9404612184,
-0.6827684045,
-0.1247102842,
-0.3656574786,
-0.1801354885,
-0.0574089624,
-0.517159462,
0.8684877157,
-0.4136482775,
0.3001200259,
-0.3468279839,
-0.3267326355,
-0.5516559482,
0.3087692559,
-0.6405763626,
1.1689705849,
-0.0179975498,
-0.6214404106,
0.1977431029,
-0.8181155324,
-0.4623267651,
0.18950288,
-0.3643606305,
-0.0120970597,
0.1761285216,
0.0196467862,
0.1510143429,
-0.861082077,
0.4418700039,
-0.3564976752,
-0.2129567862,
-0.229922235,
-0.4219300449,
1.0879210234,
0.4519511163,
-0.4721250236,
0.0866611153,
-0.6824387908,
0.4161658287,
0.1774620116,
-0.2190105915,
-0.4296976626,
0.0191296153,
-0.156353876,
0.3650255799,
0.159973532,
-0.4767499566,
0.4099204838,
-0.2178674787,
0.5768840909,
0.4582848549,
-0.0580591708,
0.5952082276,
-0.0192635395,
0.2599290013,
0.0403176025,
0.0920133293,
0.1099800542,
-0.7502480745,
-0.7075198293,
-0.2116952389,
0.0608669333,
0.617118597,
-0.6730313301,
0.3168197572,
-0.2025190443,
-0.4893217385,
-0.3631793559,
0.0658058226,
0.4949943721,
0.3758769333,
0.3091954291,
-0.167375952,
-0.3131211996,
-0.9038116336,
-0.4203940332,
-0.4616068006,
-0.0211968608,
0.2450546473,
0.6531275511,
0.0225665309,
0.9382966161,
-0.7470906377,
-0.02335109,
-0.1918988675,
0.5096021295,
0.2821218073,
0.4404341578,
-0.0018265075,
-0.6658488512,
-0.3593556285,
0.0833382979,
-0.8030583262,
-0.0166806057,
-0.0747897103,
-0.2358157784,
0.0401322953,
0.3613782525,
-0.9758934379,
0.3858289421,
0.1271314472,
-0.5823311806,
0.4954381883,
-0.273093015,
-0.2188854814,
-0.6226246357,
0.1615182757,
-0.1832018942,
-0.1996089816,
-0.6077067852,
0.2403282225,
-0.1719709039,
0.0035540143,
-0.0331249312,
0.3095927238,
-0.6834112406,
0.0508923009,
0.0052209236,
0.066261448,
-0.0356680267,
0.7740513682,
0.1254066527,
0.177332595,
0.4278699458,
-0.5783059001,
0.3047639728,
-0.2125525177,
-0.3424942195,
0.7933674455,
-0.5611115098,
0.2109182179,
-0.1557073891,
0.1403366774,
-1.1034880877,
-0.0908690393,
0.2670606375,
-0.2777639925,
0.2656374574,
-0.1033865362,
-0.4258591831,
-0.4465754926,
-0.0235371869,
0.5211953521,
0.5090423822,
-0.3944528699,
0.7713671923,
0.1504890472,
-0.2118936926,
-0.1399963647,
-0.468839556,
0.1062421724,
-0.0120639931,
-1.1972551346,
0.1362834722,
-0.3225611746,
-0.5365799069,
0.1933619827,
-0.3161524236,
-0.135547772,
0.2469424158,
0.1193579808,
-0.0394625477,
-0.4142349064,
0.1794735342,
0.3021476567,
-0.3693485558,
0.1037977934,
-0.2933561504,
0.1993404478,
-0.6146569848,
-0.5707448125,
-0.3265746534,
0.609182477,
0.5315381289,
-0.1466014236,
0.2604281604,
0.3784410655,
-0.597879529,
-0.2337159365,
-0.326588273,
-0.3053121865,
-0.3442559242,
0.1641944051,
-0.979267776,
-0.7843128443,
0.3606693745,
-0.395595789,
-0.1524990052,
0.4551178813,
0.4765594304,
-0.1671214253,
1.5206332207,
0.364946425,
0.6278941035,
0.0690649375,
-0.3055848479,
0.3358563185,
-0.644790709,
-0.3098195195,
-0.4348250329,
-0.1842425466,
-0.285343796,
-0.4521894455,
0.3069790304,
0.6213027835,
-0.525878191,
0.09520524,
-0.6391375661,
0.2776092887,
0.7093351483,
0.1959037036,
0.7725484371,
-0.102203913,
-0.3156473637,
0.1467190236,
-0.6781358123,
-0.923424542,
0.6972424388,
0.2444341928,
0.5367213488,
0.4205562472,
0.4336429536,
-0.0822533444,
0.517157495,
-0.9860289693,
0.8248512745,
0.0076871552,
-0.8746342063,
-0.4234423339,
-0.3032140136,
-0.9033426046,
0.5017538667,
-0.1207357794,
-0.7091453075,
-0.138935864,
0.0109189712,
-0.3887139559,
0.1326456368,
-1.0515428782,
0.7798861265,
-0.3558346629,
-0.3928623497,
-0.3978966475,
-0.8392974734,
0.7074930668,
0.1018275544,
0.3017123342,
-0.1367233694,
0.0640027821,
0.5339825153,
-0.5521948934,
0.8768860698,
-0.2390846312,
0.065021269,
0.5972130299,
0.4290837049,
0.5519965291,
0.1480383575,
0.1945097446,
-0.1537646055,
0.396926254,
-0.5891150236,
-0.8789451718,
0.487883538,
-0.7822992206,
-0.8808110952,
-0.5860562325,
-0.3394121528,
-0.2017191201,
0.3181054294,
0.0298363324,
0.1194224134,
-0.4146642089,
-0.0721660629,
0.655141294,
0.223228693,
0.3300707638,
0.5459957719,
-0.1987331063,
-0.0618611164,
0.5111894011,
0.3328759968,
0.2997220755,
0.3390409052,
0.4595426917,
-0.0535538159,
-0.5554013848,
-0.3179787099,
0.1698700935,
-0.7332906723,
0.1930058151,
-0.6186881661,
-0.0677425414,
0.0365615897,
0.1064525098,
-0.3178768158,
-0.6383312941,
0.0629811883,
-0.0350525491,
0.0094889812,
0.9912405014,
0.0713526085,
0.0262688547,
-0.5722309351,
0.4623478353,
0.6844293475,
0.0251310617,
0.214248687,
-0.1962946504,
0.0899746567,
0.1488934606,
-0.2161032856,
-0.7534091473,
-0.0101827569,
0.0495579354,
0.4642052352,
0.3634001315,
0.0534779355,
0.793014586,
-0.3722704947,
0.7378665805,
0.2302647829,
-1.0078006983,
0.5695797205,
-0.3179357946,
0.2844823003,
0.4961721897,
0.0704224855,
-0.4649153054,
-0.2079852074,
-0.8365288973,
-0.6687662601,
0.7971068025,
0.3338487744,
-0.3279822469,
0.2144841552,
0.3881582618,
0.1429051459,
-0.0817545429,
-0.4822963178,
-0.0638406053,
0.0547116175,
-0.3540852964,
0.0852796584,
-0.1080559194,
-0.4125039577,
-0.5976057649,
0.4643471241,
-0.3919750154,
0.1552824229,
0.2179792821,
-0.2306846827,
-0.3432135582,
0.3805167377,
0.3631577194,
0.3817001283,
-0.086222589,
0.5158289671,
0.1250047237,
-0.276946038,
0.0925956443,
-0.2448862195,
-0.1133436337,
-0.3969807327,
0.5535531044,
0.4541182518,
0.2749314606,
-0.5740068555,
0.3638372123,
-0.2213317454,
-0.1187138185,
-0.4460343421,
0.0941463485,
0.4355430901,
0.3873631358,
0.2651557028,
0.5368028283,
0.1617990881,
-0.9599236846,
0.0603691936,
0.5377589464,
-0.3194411099,
-0.6097034812,
0.3893637955,
0.1848176122,
-0.3150417209,
0.738396287,
-0.297347337,
-0.4259364605,
0.5119110942,
0.468536377,
0.8671616316,
0.0804721266,
0.2323286682,
0.4324291945,
0.4509564042,
-0.2958058119,
0.5686545968,
-0.3361814618,
-0.7552550435,
-0.4051321745,
-0.379289031,
-0.3017856479,
-0.2633058727,
-0.6624343991,
0.1035809815,
-0.4849818051,
-0.0072987694,
0.1375292391,
0.3913657665,
-0.9044869542,
0.3975129724,
0.1490593404,
0.9066475034,
-0.8464170694,
1.0419385433,
0.7994396091,
-0.6709827781,
-1.0748810768,
-0.2593479753,
0.0895006061,
-0.7889060378,
0.7965612411,
0.0384619199,
-0.5162945986,
0.0173276365,
-0.8190550208,
-0.7918044329,
1.1720767021,
0.4426639378,
-0.5554455519,
-0.1999028623,
-0.0377582423,
0.7296046019,
-0.4873691499,
0.5252749324,
0.7665343881,
0.7112165689,
0.4352793097,
-0.7466335297,
0.4031073153,
-0.2629890144,
-0.2081711888,
0.0772081688,
-0.522847116,
0.9955992103,
-0.4117434919,
-0.6062240601,
0.1062820777,
0.3831905425,
0.2733018398,
0.5551187992,
0.5592063069,
0.700245738,
1.1722580194,
-0.2217092067,
0.9946709275,
-0.0795036107,
0.3209452927,
1.1278556585,
-0.214607507,
0.8111312985,
0.6447345018,
-0.1669321954,
0.7000046372,
0.6204394102,
0.5988145471,
0.3101784587,
0.2711413503,
-0.3585763872,
-0.740152359,
0.0790636837,
-0.0599776655,
0.2704326808,
0.5272557735,
0.1049105227,
-0.2738619149,
-0.2406617403,
0.1107255369,
0.1522639543,
-0.2947449684,
0.670923233,
0.4317139089,
-1.0454167128,
0.3483004272,
-0.0757806376,
0.2394451797,
-0.5338793993,
-0.0765204951,
0.158128798,
0.2638296485,
-0.3352023065,
-0.9474385381,
0.3420593143,
-0.1538769603,
-0.2139570862,
-0.2618970275,
0.7250156403,
-0.4467034936,
-0.4060438573,
0.4990425706,
0.8968567848,
0.0535019487,
-0.3331787884,
-0.8720272779,
-0.1989459544,
-0.0382401496,
-0.4255303741,
0.0232670605,
0.8437873721,
-0.4508015513,
0.6903066039,
0.7353904247,
-0.1919197142,
0.0161685068,
-0.0006548946,
0.7594843507,
-1.0494399071,
-0.2864893079,
-0.7345828414,
0.5531190038,
-0.0500119179,
-0.1711372733,
0.5341655612,
0.4247381389,
0.6752656698,
0.0548867285,
0.8950127959,
-0.2216739953,
0.4495213032,
-0.4396410882,
0.2028495222,
-0.4841176867,
0.4878644347,
-0.1422747821,
-0.761531353,
-0.5042691827,
0.5070005059,
-0.499021858,
-0.0406955518,
1.2828290462,
0.6764515042,
-0.165766269,
0.3890355229,
0.2969840467,
0.466655612,
0.4827102721,
1.0351014137,
1.0360671282,
-0.1856345981,
0.5863061547,
-0.1575172096,
-0.4001193345,
-0.0682993084,
-0.7493137717,
-0.7309215069,
-0.3861768544,
-0.3156054914,
-0.3439288735,
-0.2060751319,
0.9645988345,
0.6211560965,
-0.7138286829,
-0.2778024375,
-0.5163625479,
0.2350196987,
-0.5264086127,
-0.2367768735,
0.346118778,
-0.1738799959,
-0.4711044431,
0.1550677568,
0.4397439957,
-0.3630049825,
-0.2301189005,
-0.2678867579,
-0.3554116488,
0.1685475409,
0.7865253687,
0.3285174966,
-1.0272275209,
-0.6702624559,
-0.1547411531,
-0.201927796,
0.070203416,
1.0395863056,
-0.6668578386,
0.5387987494,
0.6527388692,
0.1527555287,
0.8464724422,
-0.1536301225,
0.4223018289,
-0.283577919,
-0.0436765216,
0.4472838044,
0.2710641623,
0.0798566118,
-0.186599642,
0.6323909163,
0.4033923149,
-0.2570018768,
-0.7091915011,
0.6956164241,
-1.4019887447,
-0.5624506474,
0.8393694758,
0.0785304755,
-0.3451431096,
-0.5098521709,
-0.7158604264,
0.2665255368,
-0.3130660653,
0.4757348895,
0.6982291937,
-0.6623873115,
-0.0993225947,
-0.2723797262,
0.4220745564,
0.4579633176,
-0.7095339298,
-0.1069757119,
0.4019413292,
0.4843905568,
0.3738715649,
0.7085729241,
-0.0625066161,
0.2716137469,
0.2163835466,
-0.0633645505,
0.0854797289,
-0.2755662203,
-0.159171015,
0.7007604837,
0.420468539,
0.3590879142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06753v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06753v2
|
AudioChatLlama: Towards General-Purpose Speech Abilities for LLMs
| 2023-11-12T06:56:14 | 2024-04-12T18:55:22 |
Yassir Fathullah, Chunyang Wu, Egor Lakomkin, Ke Li, Junteng Jia, Yuan Shangguan, Jay Mahadeokar, Ozlem Kalinli, Christian Fuegen, Mike Seltzer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we extend the instruction-tuned Llama-2 model with end-to-end
general-purpose speech processing and reasoning abilities while maintaining the
wide range of original LLM capabilities, without using any carefully curated
paired data. The resulting end-to-end model, named AudioChatLlama, can utilize
audio prompts as a replacement for text and sustain a conversation. Such a
model also has extended cross-modal capabilities such as being able to perform
spoken question answering (QA), speech translation, and audio summarization
amongst many other closed and open-domain tasks. This is unlike prior
approaches in speech, in which LLMs are extended to handle audio for a limited
number of pre-designated tasks. On both synthesized and recorded speech QA test
sets, evaluations show that our end-to-end approach is on par with or
outperforms cascaded systems (speech recognizer + LLM) in terms of modeling the
response to a prompt. Furthermore, unlike cascades, our approach can
interchange text and audio modalities and intrinsically utilize prior context
in a conversation to provide better results.
|
[
-0.2058012933,
-1.1053043604,
0.6629195213,
0.0602305681,
-0.5695170164,
0.176117301,
-0.0605038181,
-0.691170752,
0.3181297481,
0.4040304124,
-0.6784847379,
-0.5341748595,
-0.4486664832,
0.0572848469,
-0.5057584643,
0.8446757793,
0.1978160888,
0.1492278278,
-0.3121310771,
-0.0753457695,
-0.810099721,
-0.5791694522,
-0.772002697,
-0.3982619941,
0.6909368634,
0.300144732,
0.7228741646,
0.4043980241,
0.2082302719,
0.1630920768,
-0.3601675928,
0.2538201511,
-0.4870367646,
0.3328707814,
-0.159181565,
-0.6925166845,
-0.6844787002,
-0.0405843332,
0.5406367183,
0.5553181767,
-0.098801516,
0.3184757531,
-0.0394167267,
0.220082283,
-0.4057039022,
0.0704866052,
-0.7336984277,
-0.028437091,
0.0281991009,
-0.7684578896,
-0.3698182404,
-0.1382205188,
0.1814099252,
-0.5361784697,
-0.2142347544,
0.1639548093,
0.4290899932,
0.6199952364,
-0.4615452588,
-0.6136975884,
-0.9276539683,
0.7213650346,
-0.7399433255,
0.5981770158,
0.5071992278,
0.3300057054,
-0.1371150315,
-0.7971089482,
-0.4948478937,
-0.0894904286,
0.2669001222,
0.2698339522,
-0.4994537234,
0.2981574237,
0.0923054144,
0.1867433935,
-0.6634330153,
0.4225114286,
-0.3469346464,
-0.0535304695,
0.3279649317,
0.2742995918,
0.6199303269,
0.0883414373,
-0.1988682896,
0.1650186926,
-0.8968289495,
0.4806407094,
0.3527001739,
0.1796218157,
-0.1992199123,
0.7230876684,
-0.0622921288,
0.5467365384,
-0.2701879442,
-0.1644401252,
-0.0306096729,
-0.39798522,
-0.35371086,
0.2901380658,
0.3256007731,
0.1030110866,
0.0814075768,
-0.2828160226,
-0.1128591001,
-0.0828756616,
0.0824238211,
-0.6520119905,
0.1814122349,
0.4563768506,
-0.3001272082,
0.1030476689,
-0.4618166685,
-0.5079309344,
-0.0842935592,
-0.5928535461,
0.4420392215,
-0.2357491851,
-0.0405097306,
0.0447931662,
-0.0891145244,
0.6384229064,
0.2755122781,
-1.0229495764,
0.4439560175,
0.804844439,
0.9429814816,
-0.4407289028,
0.0058554895,
-0.5911461711,
0.275580436,
-0.4215806425,
0.8587983847,
-0.9107350707,
-0.6320710182,
-0.0667724833,
-0.1081387326,
0.1017980352,
-0.4917362928,
0.9053063393,
-0.5845109224,
0.5210596323,
-0.1155035868,
-0.5569843054,
-0.4446761906,
-0.1514537185,
-0.4331231415,
0.6273958683,
0.0452759527,
-0.1770952046,
0.0000991764,
-0.5085546374,
-0.2943270802,
-0.0951120406,
-0.2075547427,
-0.2303201109,
0.0320285745,
0.2765283287,
0.1931740195,
-0.7014244795,
0.300257355,
-0.1095216721,
-0.5289802551,
0.2466522902,
-0.5904602408,
0.716180861,
0.182518363,
-0.0284521393,
0.3720726371,
-0.6362574697,
0.1721971482,
-0.0799895599,
-0.3988031745,
-0.1687759608,
0.0725365803,
0.1298414469,
0.0560399704,
0.1911784112,
-0.3110833466,
-0.1204375625,
-0.4169178009,
0.6263074279,
0.6111220717,
-0.06124207,
0.2566787601,
-0.4420984387,
0.7387543917,
-0.1121718809,
0.0608827993,
-0.5807735324,
-0.9816939831,
-0.5688753724,
-0.4359382987,
0.1433409601,
0.8307566643,
-0.3404562175,
0.4080398083,
-0.0571990982,
-0.2800364196,
-0.5534601808,
0.1072747186,
0.4095498323,
0.5224797726,
0.4829718471,
-0.2462261319,
-0.7944312096,
-0.8264651299,
-0.033312995,
-0.3138062954,
-0.3896787167,
0.3792609572,
0.0086749615,
-0.2780283093,
1.1585665941,
-0.0271805115,
-0.3152666986,
-0.1689527929,
-0.1507991403,
0.3712163866,
0.2237035185,
0.2279297262,
-0.6574844718,
0.089453347,
0.0171752088,
-0.7067682743,
-0.5504177809,
-0.1525333524,
0.2322242558,
0.0236300882,
0.3114637733,
-0.7838773131,
0.259301722,
0.4828563929,
-0.3863455057,
0.5240361094,
0.0308317561,
0.0779935643,
-1.1502165794,
-0.2375087738,
-0.3167835474,
-0.2126979232,
-0.9231220484,
-0.2118227333,
-0.352901876,
-0.2550910711,
-0.6097444892,
0.7052718997,
-0.284283489,
-0.6612437963,
-0.5418170094,
0.3935907483,
-0.0687820241,
0.6126558781,
-0.1256878227,
1.1853950024,
0.5490037203,
-0.7323353887,
0.4995198548,
0.2809647322,
-0.0199152455,
0.518633008,
-1.1043610573,
0.3211895823,
0.0915827006,
0.2612877488,
-1.1453108788,
-0.0614464916,
0.1957383305,
-0.7071974874,
0.0769045576,
0.3596810102,
-0.2556148767,
-0.0139499893,
-0.1451885253,
0.6757855415,
0.7775037289,
-0.6189522743,
0.943087697,
0.4639734924,
-0.7304136157,
-0.0856950209,
-0.6071230173,
0.3704059422,
-0.3085164726,
-0.5295162797,
0.4910852909,
-0.0533807203,
-0.3237457871,
-0.2592868209,
0.0541827753,
-0.2555430532,
-0.055644542,
0.2524264157,
0.3597398996,
-0.2891597748,
0.2660303414,
0.470622927,
-0.0602630787,
0.1726939976,
-0.0118897697,
0.5857715607,
0.095820874,
-0.589957118,
-0.7760932446,
0.3487682045,
0.423563987,
-0.0889657512,
-0.0455978177,
0.4349874556,
-0.2331658602,
-0.0395135023,
-0.4505923092,
-0.3195648789,
-0.4480527341,
0.5327472091,
-0.2672970891,
-0.9832507372,
0.6233938932,
-0.1241815612,
0.2041664869,
0.0526774786,
0.7261901498,
-0.2702429295,
1.0786373615,
0.4173932374,
0.0316108465,
0.371322751,
0.1395118535,
0.2858945727,
-1.1043344736,
-0.4208720922,
-0.5031836629,
-0.2832458317,
-0.258017242,
-0.6164266467,
0.3595397174,
0.0264206696,
-0.0702791214,
0.2320500463,
-0.361998558,
0.3652701974,
0.6069253087,
-0.0397022627,
0.4833424985,
-0.0780569687,
0.13118276,
0.165279448,
-0.549280405,
-0.6833094358,
1.0125954151,
0.6359653473,
0.6126615405,
0.2337740511,
0.2854168415,
0.4218651652,
-0.2778491676,
-1.0065498352,
0.5779725313,
0.0851487219,
-0.1649859697,
-0.48820889,
-0.0649735406,
-0.8698043227,
0.290340662,
0.1570066363,
-0.8567644358,
0.0198509805,
-0.1370904744,
-0.2840548456,
0.2090767622,
-0.5877552629,
0.1030682176,
-0.2060925514,
-0.1111823246,
-0.4340422153,
-0.4401007593,
0.4149902761,
-0.084808372,
0.11040245,
-0.2618015707,
-0.4773533046,
0.8973821998,
0.0085407384,
0.9565525651,
0.1268006712,
-0.5396689177,
0.3847432435,
-0.1428858191,
0.2624384463,
0.0654067397,
0.053084258,
0.2435823679,
0.1229063794,
-0.1520778388,
-0.890822649,
0.4031118751,
-0.8771727085,
-0.8815609217,
-0.0810590759,
-0.9230425358,
-0.4934220612,
0.0049077109,
-0.1479278505,
0.6386893392,
-0.1889012754,
0.2870563269,
0.6546816826,
-0.3297756314,
0.51845783,
0.4419608712,
-0.3626680076,
-0.5421416163,
0.7264444828,
-0.1744882166,
0.2025206238,
0.4516906142,
0.0325727612,
-0.7509244084,
-0.679084897,
-0.4903343022,
0.1436979473,
-0.7222212553,
0.0199957807,
-0.602671802,
-0.2342258245,
-0.4071144164,
-0.0918561444,
-0.0075597088,
-0.6815513372,
-0.8137587309,
-0.200422287,
0.0956192762,
0.4746754766,
0.2178503424,
0.3596684933,
-0.548050642,
0.5727835894,
0.6990634203,
-0.0381632484,
-0.1337784529,
-1.0801603794,
0.127198711,
0.1689163893,
-0.4453653097,
-0.8920967579,
0.3083477616,
0.3951179087,
0.6741945744,
0.292421937,
-0.1813947856,
0.6261573434,
-0.5381259322,
0.9619696736,
0.3217715025,
-1.0736939907,
0.5569297075,
-0.3520669639,
0.4540803134,
-0.0319643989,
0.1463123709,
-0.451764375,
-0.5064767003,
-0.1547608823,
-0.6442055106,
0.3745073378,
0.2864670157,
0.2966643572,
0.2208252549,
0.2148298919,
0.1006564945,
0.040493533,
-0.367677629,
-0.0469447635,
-0.2637308836,
-0.0520254187,
0.0269930176,
-0.5295779109,
-0.2008392513,
-0.2492872328,
0.6590425968,
-0.2517689764,
0.3518134058,
0.2071540654,
0.0775736645,
0.0182079859,
0.685742259,
0.8496796489,
0.8435096741,
-0.0230949186,
0.1884566247,
0.4757511318,
-0.2848116159,
0.4293269515,
-0.2029163539,
-0.0231923703,
0.0262803491,
0.4954089224,
0.982041955,
0.4578160942,
-0.9397402406,
0.0728735477,
0.0360734761,
-0.0800215974,
-0.2144381106,
0.1616798043,
0.3240950704,
0.432217598,
0.6079905033,
-0.4676343203,
0.3145714104,
-0.7136464715,
0.46609658,
0.4970042408,
-0.4838993251,
-0.4323395193,
0.8046809435,
0.1412581652,
-0.691182673,
0.2464077771,
0.2680939734,
-0.0638006777,
0.7351902127,
0.9201711416,
1.0899461508,
-0.4568966627,
0.1395733058,
-0.0077243852,
0.1384727061,
0.5310436487,
0.4567718804,
-0.1965138316,
-0.4626455307,
-0.3658887744,
-0.475068152,
-0.8535271287,
-0.0984207019,
-0.5335841775,
0.2938178778,
-0.4782965183,
-0.3332738578,
-0.2168710828,
-0.353862524,
-0.2601451278,
0.2041525394,
0.1564745903,
0.6997512579,
-0.393807441,
0.8670954704,
0.3675850928,
-0.3018818796,
-0.6946293712,
-0.2809974849,
0.0038302406,
-0.9142320752,
0.6480007172,
0.0466522723,
-0.3836306334,
0.071929805,
-0.349419266,
-0.8824145198,
1.5005345345,
0.4989407957,
-0.6421438456,
-0.3569736481,
0.4414780438,
0.6529963017,
-0.466396004,
0.6911455989,
0.6615164876,
0.213549152,
0.4194062948,
-1.1671216488,
-0.0607779063,
-0.123016566,
0.1239786744,
-0.4362620413,
-0.4305322468,
0.666023612,
-0.3680734038,
-0.3872269094,
0.1489511281,
0.9317190051,
0.5805082917,
0.4906367362,
0.4007464647,
0.3961448669,
0.8038599491,
-0.0548086725,
0.7720569372,
-0.1971866935,
-0.1370348036,
1.2499415874,
-0.3460150659,
0.9088366032,
0.6102129817,
-0.2381459326,
0.4240852296,
0.7273331881,
0.3628796637,
0.4572591484,
0.0311176442,
-0.307266295,
-0.1556761563,
-0.6012664437,
-0.5566647649,
0.7239193916,
0.3810383976,
-0.2044563591,
-0.1883291453,
0.0731178597,
-0.2677984834,
-0.0628604069,
-0.3854298294,
0.9173080325,
0.5141016841,
-0.4645270109,
0.6971157193,
-0.2544145584,
0.6846374273,
-0.5979706645,
-0.1856859326,
0.0267841872,
-0.4795820415,
-0.2003268898,
-0.7316142917,
0.3959538937,
-0.0420387872,
-0.2140580714,
-0.0358356535,
0.7215670347,
-0.4915271401,
-0.2068330944,
0.3753213882,
0.5282616615,
0.2630657554,
0.2210827917,
-0.3881429732,
0.1738917977,
-0.1850158721,
-0.1197835803,
0.1980367154,
0.1652212739,
0.036799632,
1.0251543522,
0.8806388378,
0.2072049528,
0.1311867386,
0.3381522894,
0.7818675041,
-0.6182472706,
-0.8329014778,
-0.6621445417,
0.0878696442,
0.2256217152,
-0.2269189209,
0.5162376761,
0.5348072052,
0.5034472942,
0.1843146384,
0.6903114319,
0.4484218061,
0.570371151,
-0.9374981523,
0.3856530488,
-0.3572396934,
0.4629386663,
0.0178852156,
-0.9463921785,
-0.1244013086,
0.2091620266,
-0.2164044827,
0.0992688686,
0.7453655601,
0.7729853392,
0.0622826852,
0.5507243276,
0.7722556591,
-0.0409485102,
0.7556045651,
0.7226909995,
0.8757146001,
-0.1742495745,
0.4567858875,
0.2259869426,
-0.1877512187,
0.0506125949,
-0.4614187181,
-0.8656374812,
-0.697665453,
0.0366504751,
0.1807713956,
0.1395498663,
0.8175808787,
0.5740250945,
-0.7135708928,
-0.3066246212,
0.0562640168,
0.2373391539,
-0.041910056,
-0.2116231471,
0.2188392729,
-0.4603432417,
-0.9279640913,
0.8648661971,
0.5197581053,
0.1031286046,
-0.4406505227,
-0.2338065505,
-0.0004549156,
0.4204877615,
0.7959748507,
0.3835498393,
-1.1763759851,
-0.231365785,
-0.019174356,
0.1593563259,
0.0116379671,
0.7946327925,
-0.8194621205,
0.3347460628,
0.4606867731,
1.0185768604,
0.0993379578,
0.1425206959,
0.6881752014,
-0.3858804703,
0.1866235435,
0.3986700177,
0.2885920107,
0.1332602054,
-0.2279372662,
0.3795967698,
-0.0724340156,
-0.6410614848,
-0.8565834761,
0.2371927649,
-1.3258351088,
-0.1663297117,
1.4389884472,
0.002811627,
-0.1648816466,
-0.364109844,
-0.4733254313,
0.4543617368,
-0.4619334936,
0.7170588374,
0.4752628505,
-0.3159532249,
-0.452535212,
-0.5666432381,
0.3539130986,
0.696669817,
-1.1761575937,
-0.1144886836,
0.4004749656,
-0.0212429129,
0.0028363119,
0.8837372065,
-0.109526813,
0.6242000461,
-0.3063444197,
-0.2487091869,
-0.3348089159,
-0.5221129656,
-0.5111764073,
0.1954796463,
-0.0667787194,
-0.358245641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06752v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06752v1
|
BeautifulPrompt: Towards Automatic Prompt Engineering for Text-to-Image Synthesis
| 2023-11-12T06:39:00 | 2023-11-12T06:39:00 |
Tingfeng Cao, Chengyu Wang, Bingyan Liu, Ziheng Wu, Jinhui Zhu, Jun Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, diffusion-based deep generative models (e.g., Stable Diffusion)
have shown impressive results in text-to-image synthesis. However, current
text-to-image models often require multiple passes of prompt engineering by
humans in order to produce satisfactory results for real-world applications. We
propose BeautifulPrompt, a deep generative model to produce high-quality
prompts from very simple raw descriptions, which enables diffusion-based models
to generate more beautiful images. In our work, we first fine-tuned the
BeautifulPrompt model over low-quality and high-quality collecting prompt
pairs. Then, to ensure that our generated prompts can generate more beautiful
images, we further propose a Reinforcement Learning with Visual AI Feedback
technique to fine-tune our model to maximize the reward values of the generated
prompts, where the reward values are calculated based on the PickScore and the
Aesthetic Scores. Our results demonstrate that learning from visual AI feedback
promises the potential to improve the quality of generated prompts and images
significantly. We further showcase the integration of BeautifulPrompt to a
cloud-native AI platform to provide better text-to-image generation service in
the cloud.
|
[
-0.6433021426,
-0.9124112725,
0.7384588718,
0.4073369205,
-0.39142856,
-0.2886678874,
0.0059236828,
-0.3160961568,
0.0541801192,
0.3337036371,
-0.9698443413,
-0.5847561359,
-0.3605690897,
0.1998331249,
-0.3304494619,
0.9588507414,
0.0385447033,
-0.0094129238,
-0.2635859251,
0.3954516947,
-0.798645854,
0.1627328992,
-0.8384533525,
0.0462774746,
0.5537628531,
0.3512772024,
0.6923877001,
0.256513685,
0.4043526649,
0.2401284724,
0.0570597202,
0.3692315817,
-0.3283296525,
0.5085754395,
-0.2226720899,
-0.3481497169,
-0.0578816608,
0.2806071937,
0.1743192971,
0.1573173702,
0.0620616041,
-0.0102126468,
0.2909144759,
0.7555863857,
-0.3681836724,
-0.0059248293,
-0.3035032749,
0.3561145663,
0.1359975785,
-0.2989288867,
-0.3798401654,
-0.5440782309,
0.0500513092,
-0.7441835999,
0.4124435484,
0.0236049443,
1.0317275524,
0.4740392566,
-0.0420520753,
-0.2634726465,
-0.3685326278,
0.4911655188,
-0.466622293,
0.0903500468,
0.1538980156,
0.5243171453,
-0.2741873264,
-0.9188609719,
-0.5024217367,
-0.4395730197,
0.0178634431,
0.4079680443,
-0.2466542572,
-0.0881323367,
-0.0475345217,
0.2963564396,
-0.497833401,
0.1567388773,
-0.0872274116,
-0.3256703615,
0.6190330386,
0.2577232718,
0.7435864806,
-0.1756015718,
-0.3065268099,
-0.2995980084,
-0.5312616825,
0.1414998621,
0.256711632,
0.4395740032,
-0.2373698205,
0.4061482251,
-0.0383178107,
0.6567322612,
-0.0252319463,
0.2646228671,
-0.006799907,
-0.3012177944,
-0.1500654519,
-0.1497316658,
1.2036926746,
0.5691183209,
0.1483473331,
0.0313032195,
-0.4014636874,
0.2272815555,
0.3278818727,
-0.8819445968,
-0.6264520288,
0.1008528844,
-0.5134567022,
-0.6059216857,
-0.1491103321,
-0.9289887547,
-0.4963718951,
-0.4038746953,
0.3845472634,
-0.4207538962,
0.0148548726,
-0.1928063482,
-0.3139726818,
-0.2459792495,
0.8922787905,
-0.7021197081,
-0.2343412787,
0.2961001694,
0.9221999645,
-0.2216297835,
-0.3722628653,
-0.8058596253,
-0.3548859358,
-0.6637047529,
1.1311402321,
-0.2298567742,
-0.3389165401,
0.0156943016,
-0.2649136186,
0.470218271,
-0.6469032168,
0.4527412951,
-0.2722401321,
0.4601565301,
-0.1617613733,
-0.1737407148,
0.1824966222,
0.2526330352,
-0.8142965436,
0.7306963205,
0.0797626972,
-0.4330004454,
0.428768605,
-0.8311520815,
-0.6151562333,
0.221465528,
0.0252548754,
-0.4736180305,
0.3700456023,
0.5821292996,
0.5459117889,
-0.2377929091,
0.0159261059,
-0.1598151177,
-0.1106758565,
0.2821366489,
-0.5676031113,
0.4461452067,
0.4635172486,
-0.2433110029,
0.317617178,
-0.5223824382,
-0.0251578204,
0.2855884731,
-0.053361699,
-0.1201145574,
-0.21127747,
0.3547564447,
0.1776257008,
0.1170647964,
-0.2117941678,
0.5517634153,
-0.4005819857,
0.3538285196,
0.8236052394,
0.1101140752,
0.5680021644,
-0.1257820725,
0.6599462628,
-0.0597748011,
0.4673560262,
-0.4208534956,
-0.6158146858,
-0.5293557644,
-0.5061120391,
0.1911330223,
0.4296813011,
-1.026227951,
0.0321648866,
0.148311466,
-0.2514290214,
-0.6505085826,
0.0941744521,
0.2309646904,
0.4647666812,
0.4143726826,
-0.516956985,
-0.1128826141,
-0.8599807024,
-0.0829348415,
0.0417130776,
-0.2111154199,
0.1949681491,
0.3828539252,
-0.2360364646,
0.8134900928,
-0.5873098373,
-0.5944243073,
0.0216652881,
0.4102260172,
0.2375163436,
0.4522688091,
0.7162370682,
-0.7236021757,
-0.4430500567,
-0.1444820762,
-0.5725666881,
-0.225450784,
-0.3622744381,
-0.3321875632,
0.0705145821,
0.3908578455,
-0.9121225476,
0.2622002661,
0.2232022434,
-0.4309777319,
0.7987375259,
-0.1455712914,
0.5914063454,
-1.0704065561,
-0.0778919905,
0.3025270402,
-0.4139882922,
-0.1471849531,
0.4691659808,
-0.2637723088,
-0.503849566,
-0.5824407339,
0.7442629337,
-0.4308129251,
0.1834709048,
-0.4142605066,
-0.3022935092,
0.1818143278,
0.3462063372,
-0.1412385851,
0.8624106646,
0.9276249409,
-0.8198227286,
0.5709233284,
0.4547946155,
-0.2608530223,
0.9779754877,
-0.5830277801,
0.0207941849,
-0.1249959245,
0.1235779971,
-0.9594125748,
-0.5009285808,
0.3756314218,
-0.6753094792,
0.158122465,
-0.1501290947,
-0.5720797777,
-0.3818478286,
-0.2115768045,
0.0154697234,
0.8599931002,
-0.8172728419,
0.4011806846,
-0.3396508694,
-0.4276668429,
-0.0584078655,
-0.7669081688,
0.4002489746,
-0.0780511945,
-0.4941237867,
0.4595328569,
-0.2092185766,
0.0971162543,
0.2547058761,
0.4602497816,
-0.0028744051,
0.2935937047,
0.3912828267,
0.2758636475,
0.0378477015,
-0.1406173408,
0.2608439922,
-0.1488391906,
0.1585203409,
-0.4664030671,
0.4444538355,
0.170298636,
-0.4457071126,
-1.0920202732,
0.3751158416,
0.5781491995,
-0.2994668186,
0.2910507917,
0.6989067197,
-0.2723228931,
-0.684764266,
0.0437858291,
-0.3047933877,
-0.5446451306,
0.0503404252,
-0.3184947073,
-0.6604378819,
0.3830179572,
-0.1656217128,
0.3163466454,
0.3698931336,
0.5416314006,
-0.6408078671,
1.3418010473,
0.445936054,
0.3935413659,
0.8173980713,
-0.3170866072,
-0.1377512515,
-0.2357013822,
-0.234285593,
-0.3524385393,
-0.4796123207,
-0.2806050777,
-0.3120527267,
0.5048527122,
0.0208558328,
-0.3386265337,
-0.0300672818,
-0.8794221878,
0.3629975021,
0.9089122415,
0.4503177404,
-0.1140663177,
0.4887607992,
-0.2272191048,
-0.1507773846,
-0.4122132361,
-0.3641271293,
0.365388304,
0.0358405672,
0.6731780171,
-0.0070899534,
0.8885685802,
0.7419509292,
0.2195882648,
-0.8872970343,
0.5379343033,
-0.2259086668,
0.0816485286,
-0.0629114211,
-0.4862385392,
-0.9286964536,
-0.3923066854,
-0.413161546,
-0.1294910163,
-0.1230810061,
0.7097838521,
-0.5583491325,
-0.1894707531,
-0.6965895295,
0.8351269364,
-0.2420483977,
-0.5824115276,
-0.0773696974,
-0.3873521984,
0.3016073406,
0.4634533823,
-0.09565714,
0.1445355564,
0.2617862225,
0.3061903417,
-0.4782036841,
0.8535362482,
-0.308000356,
-0.1736032218,
0.3636550605,
0.4866122603,
0.5426468849,
0.0226803422,
0.0812006891,
-0.4290702641,
-0.543617487,
-0.528368175,
-0.8096583486,
0.6947152615,
-0.53919065,
-0.3998966515,
0.0212373286,
-0.1089514196,
-0.0307430476,
0.0875253603,
0.7452214956,
0.4438667893,
-0.2965984941,
-0.4772206843,
0.7328898311,
-0.5562381744,
0.6311356425,
-0.1180237159,
-0.2268939316,
-0.7723951936,
1.0597333908,
-0.3949842751,
0.1069796085,
0.2948319614,
0.1825878471,
-0.352568686,
-0.5739607215,
-0.9469361901,
-0.22036542,
-0.7179751992,
-0.4321369827,
-0.2905230224,
-0.0268032104,
-0.2426270545,
-0.5286393166,
-0.5524889231,
-0.1097202823,
-1.0565750599,
0.0949577391,
0.7085511684,
0.7223457694,
0.0797288865,
0.250667125,
-0.8932862282,
0.5199536085,
0.5580728054,
0.3782194257,
0.1701346934,
-0.4005592763,
0.005183992,
-0.0331869312,
-0.5658739805,
-0.8492236137,
0.6975187063,
0.2334724665,
0.3861682117,
0.3072519302,
0.0364618972,
0.4263141453,
-0.5692388415,
1.2268160582,
0.7979562283,
-0.7039219737,
1.1000928879,
-0.2848088443,
0.3512778878,
0.4631817341,
0.2680998147,
-0.2978619635,
-0.4020920396,
-0.5175675154,
-0.8715993762,
0.3242971301,
0.1951325536,
0.3758689165,
0.0560264513,
0.4081034958,
0.2761655748,
-0.0420150161,
-0.5461237431,
-0.0406619757,
-0.7376654744,
-0.5547264814,
0.1897892505,
0.0703883693,
-0.0357824117,
-0.0498929322,
0.5038062334,
-0.3401806056,
0.42075032,
0.2759169638,
-0.0960380211,
0.0758319721,
0.1451002061,
0.4601300955,
0.059538532,
0.4008228183,
0.1761191487,
-0.3870927989,
-0.0993653312,
0.2625405788,
0.0645079464,
-0.474477917,
-0.0071980827,
0.4194957912,
1.3336281776,
-0.3704222441,
-0.5785972476,
0.6135386229,
-0.2485156208,
-0.2670179307,
0.0739470646,
0.4656284451,
-0.032148689,
0.1910073757,
0.4039513469,
0.5262739658,
0.4522400498,
-0.4366784394,
0.1539078057,
0.5054982901,
-0.6299325228,
-0.4230114818,
1.023687005,
0.4343253672,
-0.56035918,
0.8987161517,
-0.5658119321,
-0.4471034408,
0.5779026151,
0.3684707582,
0.9277058244,
0.0109668309,
0.8380691409,
0.4043962061,
0.037009377,
-0.159298569,
0.4755952358,
-0.0754610151,
-0.1156884581,
-0.28649652,
-0.6705317497,
-0.2078581303,
-0.1276334226,
-0.3483031392,
0.460778445,
-0.5159091949,
-0.1963669509,
-0.0085268309,
-0.3948823512,
-0.6737318635,
0.3921628594,
0.3035481572,
0.7094581723,
-1.038417697,
0.0345671289,
0.863758564,
-0.7055998445,
-0.7767981887,
-0.0018659071,
-0.1570620686,
-0.4296435118,
0.3952583075,
0.3821537495,
0.2575343549,
0.2661084831,
-1.2014261484,
-0.2968985736,
0.7054011822,
0.702904284,
-0.4428570271,
0.2293939739,
-0.1773815304,
0.6081136465,
-0.125638932,
0.2971018255,
0.0287219081,
0.4285645187,
0.3109142482,
-0.6109359264,
0.0385408811,
-0.7224003077,
0.1151623353,
-0.0298966821,
-0.2841193378,
0.5260392427,
-0.5443311334,
-0.3739745319,
0.3565700352,
0.8534707427,
0.3322488666,
0.4578613639,
0.259919554,
0.6294845343,
0.5465794802,
-0.0088822665,
1.1795364618,
0.1643066108,
0.0367719159,
0.7177619934,
0.1014202535,
0.4699623287,
0.2693682909,
-0.06275554,
0.4406526089,
1.102484107,
-0.192683816,
0.9385403991,
-0.0023015121,
-0.2051108778,
-0.3470361829,
-0.3676208258,
-0.2258294672,
-0.0377272591,
0.0727462843,
-0.6142967939,
-0.1151355579,
0.4620896876,
-0.3840915859,
0.3415679336,
-0.4444481432,
0.7888528705,
0.0945945382,
-0.8509271145,
0.5826903582,
-0.1590385288,
0.7759883404,
-0.2627279162,
-0.336345017,
-0.4152671993,
-0.3255245388,
-0.2358418703,
-1.1066550016,
0.0044477647,
0.0654648021,
-0.3719676733,
-0.6089037657,
0.5152419209,
-0.1132499948,
-0.3963031769,
-0.1953416169,
0.2976644933,
0.0616754256,
-0.2923813164,
-0.7993457317,
-0.0802045763,
0.035153348,
-0.3563419282,
0.2106798142,
0.4692123532,
0.0004342208,
0.5542496443,
0.8519440293,
0.0756691173,
-0.073159501,
0.4160603285,
0.7436080575,
-0.4367747009,
-0.8063854575,
-0.9936547279,
0.6751130819,
0.0230038688,
-0.3658985794,
0.3072232306,
0.2262051851,
0.2157736868,
-0.4981069565,
0.8619402647,
-0.0607350394,
-0.1180482954,
-0.6973168254,
0.9616032243,
-0.8743160367,
-0.1344658881,
-0.4083876312,
-0.7520650625,
-0.2734926045,
0.5112709999,
0.1999387145,
-0.1859747171,
0.3878428936,
0.850446105,
-0.1430557519,
-0.1249985471,
0.1135113165,
-0.0533650294,
0.4202452004,
0.5631363392,
1.074875474,
-0.1567166597,
0.2654825449,
-0.1545733958,
-0.1832333207,
-0.1858677864,
-1.0912959576,
-0.497951448,
-0.75064677,
-0.5907979012,
-0.3767591119,
-0.0058803619,
0.8937565088,
0.7559587955,
-0.53836447,
0.5506137013,
-0.766858995,
0.0324482135,
-0.4320195913,
-0.2788095474,
0.2828402817,
-0.3998236358,
-0.7914758921,
0.3320699334,
0.2628576756,
0.5627784133,
-0.3036301136,
-0.081687808,
0.5004670024,
-0.0025188574,
0.6090215445,
0.1256037652,
-0.3886850774,
0.2063941807,
-0.0427173786,
-0.3991061151,
-0.028111469,
0.4695284963,
-0.8027518988,
0.1680181772,
0.6037296057,
0.6811670661,
0.1735656112,
-0.0224437118,
0.608782351,
-0.6860778928,
-0.1042568535,
0.2887563109,
0.1607989669,
0.6953452826,
-0.6226511598,
0.077586323,
0.2979875505,
-0.2929975986,
-0.7287267447,
0.4262470901,
-0.9544917941,
-0.5266424417,
0.9699174762,
-0.0108091952,
-0.293047756,
0.4790786207,
-0.6538452506,
0.1623357385,
-0.49199453,
0.8822759986,
0.1899254471,
-0.1579789072,
-0.6184722781,
-0.2731730342,
0.570025444,
0.4166351557,
-1.11510849,
-0.1303296536,
0.9681367874,
0.1718227863,
0.1229055226,
0.466737777,
0.2400201857,
0.7744247913,
-0.1084965542,
0.4137147069,
-0.2964841723,
-0.5834960938,
-0.0488732643,
0.4195941985,
0.2315966338,
-0.290291816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06737v1
|
Detecting and Correcting Hate Speech in Multimodal Memes with Large Visual Language Model
| 2023-11-12T05:20:20 | 2023-11-12T05:20:20 |
Minh-Hao Van, Xintao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have taken the spotlight in natural
language processing. Further, integrating LLMs with vision enables the users to
explore more emergent abilities in multimodality. Visual language models
(VLMs), such as LLaVA, Flamingo, or GPT-4, have demonstrated impressive
performance on various visio-linguistic tasks. Consequently, there are enormous
applications of large models that could be potentially used on social media
platforms. Despite that, there is a lack of related work on detecting or
correcting hateful memes with VLMs. In this work, we study the ability of VLMs
on hateful meme detection and hateful meme correction tasks with zero-shot
prompting. From our empirical experiments, we show the effectiveness of the
pretrained LLaVA model and discuss its strengths and weaknesses in these tasks.
|
[
-0.3257420659,
-0.9449569583,
0.4218929708,
0.0918531418,
-0.4253593683,
0.0537057035,
-0.2086929232,
-0.5877319574,
0.3936386406,
0.4660464823,
-0.6234852076,
-0.428201586,
-0.8825582266,
0.2038427889,
-0.4512656033,
0.8292022943,
-0.0037893415,
0.095356591,
0.0156055009,
-0.2242446691,
-0.5641037822,
-0.4811763465,
-0.4513984919,
0.0744302198,
1.0592246056,
0.4434636831,
0.3421953917,
0.2638664842,
0.325075537,
0.3508992195,
0.1984865218,
-0.0587275475,
-0.6615639329,
0.4889008701,
-0.2448455244,
-0.3458404541,
-0.2204789668,
0.0747773647,
0.4312733114,
-0.1351638883,
0.0495771393,
0.0992074236,
-0.1789833158,
0.0943440646,
-0.5543559194,
-0.2173535526,
-1.0889556408,
-0.1083611697,
-0.4308580756,
-0.2069357485,
-0.3236052394,
-0.1851252913,
-0.0770993903,
-0.3205483854,
0.0389168151,
-0.06389983,
0.6309669614,
0.1756972075,
-0.282589227,
-0.3912913203,
-0.7438285947,
1.0966950655,
-0.9477302432,
0.2844135463,
0.0538575053,
0.3460897803,
0.0124896178,
-0.2593685985,
-1.0634894371,
-0.2082105428,
0.306204617,
-0.0293382145,
-0.6130352616,
0.0200704187,
0.4399887323,
-0.0046775197,
-0.7158973217,
0.6608095169,
-0.4731070995,
-0.3262405097,
0.4584018588,
0.2171468884,
0.4215151668,
-0.4670865238,
-0.4519027472,
-0.0619608238,
-0.469476819,
-0.2741705477,
0.3958310187,
0.1909237355,
-0.0419884324,
0.9166728258,
-0.2734596729,
0.8779523373,
-0.31571877,
-0.4651629329,
0.226764828,
-0.1163460389,
-0.3634794652,
-0.3371374607,
0.6561459303,
0.6152868271,
0.8008006215,
0.1818096191,
-0.1230565906,
0.5193312168,
0.4259960055,
-0.7422108054,
0.1270946711,
0.0665553063,
-0.0882245153,
-0.4425250888,
-0.7670407891,
-0.7610779405,
-0.6155995727,
-0.3281439543,
0.5491884947,
-0.4238068759,
-0.3176256418,
-0.2243687809,
-0.2518838048,
0.2323011905,
0.7678121328,
-0.6122825742,
-0.3316450417,
0.2302143723,
0.7567341328,
0.074414216,
-0.3313965201,
-0.6826282144,
0.1204056069,
-0.1337539852,
0.8555660844,
-0.7161952257,
0.0526021533,
0.2249926329,
-0.2638532817,
-0.0207946301,
-0.4674513638,
0.4844692051,
-0.6112933755,
-0.0004616726,
-0.2509436607,
-0.4943928123,
-0.2625121176,
0.6757276654,
-0.3610931039,
0.3642632663,
0.0180817991,
-0.6273614764,
0.3233245611,
-0.5429227948,
-0.1514512599,
0.1300026476,
-0.2414709628,
-0.5055335164,
0.1151789352,
0.1182141006,
0.8342738748,
0.0327945873,
0.0000708055,
-0.6661260724,
-0.1113081202,
0.0167065058,
-0.4117361903,
0.6700606346,
0.35148862,
-0.3289282322,
0.4542742074,
-0.6466057301,
-0.352506429,
0.4744347632,
-0.099240005,
-0.5997520089,
-0.0780720487,
0.100768216,
0.5339673162,
-0.0228983164,
-0.7090001106,
0.0954175517,
-0.0129710119,
0.2294448167,
1.104382515,
-0.2900254428,
0.0308498591,
-0.0287125185,
0.6240388155,
0.2305275053,
0.2735496461,
0.0482186638,
-0.5866810679,
-0.653726697,
-0.4486636817,
-0.3627948463,
0.5227059722,
-1.2863253355,
-0.2783793211,
0.01171898,
-0.4277447164,
-0.1351679265,
0.4445874393,
0.2956620753,
0.5026468635,
0.370034188,
-0.0196066238,
-0.7217710614,
-0.8041878343,
-0.2354568243,
-0.0954725668,
0.0237556081,
0.4280547202,
0.3804511726,
-0.3539212346,
0.4429687262,
-0.0881055146,
-0.4555136263,
-0.21044074,
0.309076786,
-0.0438383445,
0.0291958861,
0.9569727778,
-0.64578408,
-0.6431925893,
-0.3113167286,
-0.7920651436,
-0.358735919,
0.1247672066,
0.1418654025,
0.1827041805,
0.4587787688,
-0.1386184841,
0.5185909867,
0.8943411112,
-0.4006979764,
0.8391091228,
0.2413236052,
0.5526202917,
-0.8148460388,
-0.3752270937,
0.146496743,
-0.4190607667,
-0.9350776076,
-0.2824504375,
-0.1823153645,
-0.0009963579,
-0.8802468181,
0.4021193385,
-0.3851909339,
0.1632513255,
-0.3408112824,
0.2389977723,
-0.4047777355,
0.4440525472,
-0.0059635299,
0.5841600299,
0.4587231874,
-0.5426403284,
0.474516511,
0.018670531,
-0.2310187668,
1.0090508461,
-0.5016667843,
-0.0057098018,
-0.2992389798,
-0.272633642,
-1.1379593611,
-0.2098495662,
0.5489071608,
-0.4398430884,
0.1121623665,
-0.1105783433,
-0.5359054804,
-0.6267735958,
-0.469032079,
0.5224391818,
0.3425395489,
-0.477437675,
0.3348471224,
0.3773106039,
-0.0710571557,
-0.6428782344,
-0.3435400724,
0.1934394985,
-0.3581486642,
-0.6366686821,
-0.0456547849,
-0.1386897713,
-0.319318682,
-0.2499221861,
0.4378771782,
-0.036236573,
-0.2449564636,
0.3489527106,
0.2217812389,
-0.2159939259,
0.0423962399,
-0.2898893058,
0.2029266357,
-0.3208062053,
0.0698488131,
0.654147625,
0.0422046818,
-0.3692958653,
-0.3205429018,
0.1739989519,
0.8968211412,
-0.2174894959,
0.6843541265,
0.5894432664,
-0.2635590434,
-0.0747644827,
-1.0069777966,
-0.087055929,
-0.453861624,
0.2898485959,
-0.0668376982,
-1.4318567514,
0.4030992985,
0.3458571434,
0.0221448652,
0.3315150738,
0.7892664671,
-0.2114487141,
0.8429198861,
0.5552153587,
-0.1612342298,
0.9151320457,
0.1507558972,
0.2367066294,
-0.5634157062,
0.0249338951,
-0.4739744961,
-0.3649158776,
-0.2897823453,
-0.7953829169,
0.4830789268,
-0.2404264212,
0.0595738441,
0.2769865692,
-0.3235960603,
0.4054453373,
0.398157239,
-0.0120759569,
0.1201355681,
0.5100125074,
0.0294580162,
-0.49328807,
-0.4797344506,
-0.2553989291,
1.0352298021,
0.3082501292,
0.8471515179,
0.072535105,
0.3885726631,
0.4139432311,
0.4725580812,
-0.7290382981,
0.4748153985,
-0.2879883051,
-0.571412921,
-0.3903805912,
-0.1811144948,
-0.8084563613,
0.1924117208,
-0.355463922,
-0.7533552051,
-0.0376507305,
0.409170568,
-0.0892495513,
0.6404615641,
-0.5334663987,
0.8732402325,
-0.1211680025,
-0.3894451559,
-0.6302981377,
-0.1422208846,
0.5167084336,
0.0435978696,
0.3568198681,
-0.3176968694,
0.1582326889,
0.6946204305,
-0.2078236938,
1.0362238884,
-0.409840405,
-0.1432877779,
0.5328909159,
0.1130786464,
0.4042964876,
-0.475417465,
-0.0211623032,
0.3989085853,
-0.4161637723,
-0.4389312565,
-0.4339051843,
0.7481148243,
-0.441381067,
-0.5680726767,
-0.3127228022,
-0.5374501944,
-0.0383699872,
0.2043798864,
0.0933897719,
0.2831629217,
-0.1480033547,
0.1057702452,
0.5802550316,
-0.4185793996,
0.3105563819,
0.6853871942,
-0.4294673502,
-0.1854991913,
0.9871404171,
0.4156212211,
0.2537686527,
0.0837037414,
0.028842248,
-0.154070273,
-0.7221888304,
-0.6077033877,
0.388189584,
-0.5942161679,
-0.2268317491,
-0.7590560317,
0.0056244498,
-0.4868469238,
-0.274215728,
-0.2964845896,
-0.1439291835,
-0.1959319562,
0.065356411,
0.4765879512,
0.9623477459,
-0.1993598491,
0.3318515718,
-0.4910859168,
0.4425804019,
0.5721423626,
0.2857317328,
0.1417083889,
-0.8099014759,
-0.0196053479,
0.1078190431,
-0.2574313879,
-1.1664991379,
0.4180953503,
-0.2514187694,
0.3398583531,
0.6349666715,
-0.206390202,
0.7731899619,
-0.5830251575,
0.6875450611,
0.4288454652,
-0.6440022588,
0.6033695936,
-0.5441071391,
0.0521721579,
0.0416460522,
0.5147924423,
-0.5231974721,
-0.7357327342,
-0.3941612244,
-0.373167783,
0.4271287024,
0.1946903914,
0.4126997888,
-0.1699879766,
0.1286162138,
-0.1465004683,
0.2603141367,
-1.1162437201,
-0.1404206902,
-0.2502956688,
0.0956599861,
-0.0717060119,
-0.8602352738,
0.0415884703,
-0.3445502222,
0.6763663888,
0.0567671135,
-0.0014662876,
0.0009639855,
-0.3758131266,
-0.2316678315,
0.3388202786,
0.9522743821,
0.4805141091,
-0.1106960177,
0.1992812008,
0.1143898889,
-0.1435063481,
0.2326796949,
-0.3826357424,
-0.1528203934,
0.1256618649,
0.302338779,
0.7645739913,
0.1161450744,
-0.8603250384,
0.8404992819,
-0.1053927317,
-0.210302785,
-0.2172723562,
-0.0826385245,
-0.0141989663,
0.431963712,
-0.0313272104,
-0.0802299529,
0.0087354379,
-0.3137550354,
0.208810702,
0.8153460622,
-0.3417552114,
-0.3939374685,
0.6902644634,
0.0715958849,
-0.1447529197,
0.3656803966,
-0.1615306139,
-0.7393971682,
0.414175272,
0.4895342886,
0.5424667001,
-0.61714679,
0.4987856746,
0.4539365172,
0.5244311094,
0.5531605482,
0.157350421,
0.0443736762,
-0.8907048106,
-0.419287622,
-0.8237860799,
-0.2585265636,
0.5755661726,
-0.1157044619,
0.4151145816,
-0.7148337364,
0.1034202352,
0.282900393,
-0.5227034092,
-0.7297391891,
0.2120942324,
0.6350818872,
0.4434796572,
-1.0921188593,
0.6936698556,
0.5121043324,
-0.4988010228,
-0.7373937368,
-0.4090429842,
0.4113510251,
-1.1159132719,
0.6918486953,
0.0962195694,
-0.1562254727,
-0.179129079,
-0.9427269697,
-0.5414903164,
0.5318236947,
0.3636552393,
-0.7344840169,
0.3496997356,
0.0851534903,
0.7185832262,
-0.3289011419,
0.2329930663,
0.0496388562,
0.355468899,
0.310302496,
-0.8202554584,
-0.1883882731,
0.0007086208,
-0.0864724889,
-0.0926910937,
-0.4613966644,
1.0429638624,
-0.195631966,
0.0054779528,
-0.3246251047,
0.5512989759,
0.1397002637,
0.2496977895,
0.7934998274,
0.448548913,
0.3708263338,
0.3254753351,
0.9104802608,
0.2997948825,
0.0644045249,
0.9182677865,
-0.2366750091,
0.9373168945,
0.5991176367,
0.0108700879,
0.5131883621,
0.2472639531,
-0.0486149192,
0.1742135882,
0.2243287265,
-0.4215144217,
-0.3931532204,
-0.3441947699,
-0.2152276784,
0.5939779282,
0.4206376672,
-0.2484861612,
-0.5338712335,
0.3990392983,
0.2992038429,
0.2214108855,
-0.5184772611,
0.6251197457,
-0.0791607648,
-0.3003810942,
0.923576057,
-0.0097566294,
1.0072666407,
-0.521768868,
-0.0211604908,
0.08656317,
-0.0075833751,
-0.1587143838,
-0.6129772663,
0.4952057898,
0.4503267109,
-0.2764889002,
-0.1040719301,
0.8776464462,
-0.5267919898,
-0.3720484376,
0.6814471483,
0.3473268151,
0.2215091884,
-0.361748755,
-0.7486851215,
0.317281127,
0.2403024137,
-0.1691185236,
0.3234526217,
0.2286529541,
-0.2420774549,
0.5735712051,
0.6821037531,
0.0606230535,
0.5650162101,
0.4722051024,
0.8162398338,
-0.5985646248,
-0.0947641358,
-1.1113432646,
0.3937198222,
-0.1353629529,
0.0342567377,
0.9594477415,
0.1975145936,
0.8864727616,
-0.3791668415,
0.8045315146,
-0.1107226312,
0.6911674738,
-0.3252756596,
0.5001981258,
-0.9107823372,
-0.1042018011,
-0.6170246601,
-0.7950502634,
-0.5607336164,
0.5789821744,
-0.4470248222,
-0.280836463,
0.2917270362,
0.9561249018,
-0.0237303227,
-0.2607986927,
0.9353034496,
0.7668740153,
0.5641462207,
0.4411868155,
0.9883553386,
-0.0712702647,
0.5739617348,
-0.2266675085,
-0.4286131263,
-0.4173079133,
-0.8216345906,
-1.1574907303,
-0.4102255404,
-0.1920049042,
-0.336442709,
0.0335755683,
0.6462029219,
0.4189899266,
-0.8533732891,
-0.1612429917,
0.3680900931,
0.4294551015,
0.2077485621,
-0.1675102115,
-0.2061168849,
-0.0956176221,
-0.8208252192,
0.311088264,
0.6851716042,
0.1528594494,
-0.1991553158,
-0.0380862989,
-0.6369850636,
0.2520596087,
1.0794602633,
0.3498083651,
-0.8994219899,
-0.583326757,
-0.1629003435,
-0.0507209003,
0.0359958597,
0.6953344345,
-0.4942134023,
0.6916626692,
0.3727023005,
0.3696833253,
0.3264842927,
-0.1537541151,
0.2180768251,
-0.5051962137,
0.4084409475,
0.2515243888,
0.3742090762,
0.4422493875,
-0.1262173504,
0.2429338992,
0.5584226251,
-0.4255886376,
-0.8034111857,
0.2038723677,
-0.8678333759,
-0.1460803896,
1.167330265,
0.1182226241,
-0.2730707824,
-0.1368884444,
-0.4205739498,
0.115406014,
-0.2574569583,
0.6963783503,
0.770144701,
0.0372005664,
-0.2852259576,
-0.6597161293,
0.3128285408,
0.6217582226,
-0.6013760567,
-0.062476147,
0.844403863,
0.4351570308,
0.2032706589,
0.8960208297,
0.053048417,
0.3601997495,
-0.1023563743,
0.2717171907,
0.0198167954,
-0.3826103508,
-0.3474229574,
0.124763608,
-0.0433107316,
-0.154439047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06736v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06736v1
|
Are LLMs Rigorous Logical Reasoner? Empowering Natural Language Proof Generation with Contrastive Stepwise Decoding
| 2023-11-12T05:12:49 | 2023-11-12T05:12:49 |
Ying Su, Xiaojin Fu, Mingwen Liu, Zhijiang Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Logical reasoning remains a pivotal component within the realm of artificial
intelligence. The recent evolution of large language models (LLMs) has marked
significant progress in this domain. The adoption of strategies like
chain-of-thought (CoT) has enhanced the performance of LLMs across diverse
reasoning tasks. Nonetheless, logical reasoning that involves proof planning,
specifically those that necessitate the validation of explanation accuracy,
continues to present stumbling blocks. In this study, we first evaluate the
efficacy of LLMs with advanced CoT strategies concerning such tasks. Our
analysis reveals that LLMs still struggle to navigate complex reasoning chains,
which demand the meticulous linkage of premises to derive a cogent conclusion.
To address this issue, we finetune a smaller-scale language model, equipping it
to decompose proof objectives into more manageable subgoals. We also introduce
contrastive decoding to stepwise proof generation, making use of negative
reasoning paths to strengthen the model's capacity for logical deduction.
Experiments on EntailmentBank underscore the success of our method in
augmenting the proof planning abilities of language models.
|
[
-0.235718444,
-0.8217155933,
0.9024917483,
-0.0020479555,
-0.2437671721,
0.0494450666,
-0.2218061537,
-0.5080590248,
-0.1630612761,
0.5744001865,
-0.5299189687,
-0.4562201798,
-0.4823610783,
0.3546951711,
-0.4224606454,
0.6501917839,
-0.2498338819,
-0.0346428268,
-0.2940988541,
-0.0630509928,
-0.4254139364,
-0.4585919082,
-0.7345445752,
-0.7200930715,
0.0150217395,
0.3263674378,
0.6628142595,
0.7304400206,
0.3964700401,
0.295776844,
-0.1766888201,
0.5098400116,
-0.3513618708,
0.2087296098,
-0.5249950886,
-0.721637249,
-0.4087161124,
-0.1922571063,
0.1088021994,
0.6515540481,
-0.0646670759,
-0.0254557598,
-0.1646158099,
0.686162591,
-0.7014332414,
0.1362622678,
-0.7937284708,
-0.0532345101,
0.2330658138,
-0.2205811739,
-0.6571860313,
-0.2818472087,
-0.0529719032,
-0.4842113853,
0.0731773525,
0.184889093,
0.7508828044,
0.3184113801,
-0.4268688858,
-0.6942977905,
-1.0042909384,
0.7971788049,
-0.732388556,
0.4663026035,
0.3083920479,
0.4095090628,
-0.2295884341,
-0.7056488991,
-0.6155125499,
-0.3694653809,
0.0005015135,
-0.0108403368,
-0.309194386,
0.2413287312,
0.4914675355,
0.288757652,
-0.3302842975,
0.1162913665,
-0.0947634876,
-0.320070982,
0.6094179749,
0.2670958936,
0.1627247334,
0.1192062646,
-0.4819123447,
0.1632321477,
-0.8772755265,
0.0066341353,
0.1513938308,
0.046665024,
-0.0900473222,
0.6542369127,
-0.2759388089,
0.7196739316,
0.1820599884,
-0.3765598834,
-0.3644205332,
-0.588842392,
-0.3453485072,
0.2013292015,
0.5527924895,
0.2352601588,
0.4766141474,
-0.0481656082,
-0.5500328541,
0.4244199693,
0.0945883915,
-0.6957603097,
-0.3740059137,
0.3464352489,
-0.3264348507,
-0.2342926562,
-0.3449140489,
-0.3741101027,
-0.3677963316,
-0.5608884096,
0.2982757688,
-0.6543959975,
0.0465663671,
0.5614957213,
-0.1501287222,
0.2338225096,
0.5659987926,
-0.7353501916,
0.5518079996,
0.8577993512,
0.4045597017,
0.3014979959,
-0.0535299703,
-0.496560514,
0.2933632135,
-0.6511047482,
0.8253002167,
-0.5164948702,
-0.0464910045,
0.0355278738,
-0.4892383516,
0.0126607893,
-0.6219295859,
0.7859745026,
-0.6483289599,
0.0632413104,
-0.3046987355,
-0.5788342357,
-0.1977058649,
0.7675127983,
-0.4886137247,
0.4177891016,
-0.2097067386,
-0.6166169047,
0.3124251068,
-0.3663227856,
-0.5928287506,
-0.0887586027,
-0.4299934804,
-0.0592757016,
0.0588226691,
0.4834047258,
0.309594065,
-0.5332404971,
0.3987800181,
-0.0935749337,
-0.2731180489,
0.3391878307,
-0.4967181981,
0.7720951438,
0.2583696246,
-0.4913643003,
0.1874001175,
-0.8902102113,
-0.0948971882,
0.2515132129,
-0.371190846,
-0.1024257094,
0.3145542741,
-0.6323981881,
0.4057116807,
0.2381003797,
-0.3205644488,
-0.0537887923,
-0.4463194907,
0.6053074002,
0.7506245375,
0.0069588898,
0.3768562078,
-0.3830802441,
0.5095635056,
0.1391882002,
-0.0186953917,
-0.3010945916,
-0.2256340533,
-0.8937991858,
-0.288600266,
0.1091494262,
0.5725558996,
-0.8445308805,
0.4874348044,
-0.1048374474,
-0.2146867067,
-0.3436792791,
0.1836744398,
0.3480339944,
0.777888298,
0.5258443356,
0.1695489287,
-0.6390036941,
-0.8281955719,
-0.3999523818,
-0.2818670273,
0.0575540923,
-0.0409104452,
0.5423693657,
-0.3805298209,
0.8513928652,
-0.2817360163,
0.1855435967,
-0.7649031878,
-0.0591600873,
0.3304270208,
0.3693812191,
0.046008721,
-0.7241795659,
-0.0525744036,
-0.1773529202,
-0.7521511316,
-0.1416911185,
-0.5271323323,
-0.1698844433,
0.2901601493,
0.5336617827,
-0.6579378843,
0.4512221217,
0.1861913204,
-0.471490562,
0.6730288267,
-0.3077656329,
-0.1019164398,
-0.6091834903,
-0.2590400875,
-0.131544888,
-0.5524383783,
-0.5813781023,
0.2718198597,
-0.0870918334,
0.1890094578,
-0.1369131953,
0.1531009823,
-0.3342860639,
0.1673898101,
-0.3541200459,
0.3586820066,
0.3144283593,
0.3357990682,
0.1215019748,
0.289857924,
0.5538748503,
-0.8271337748,
0.4348403215,
0.0285283457,
-0.1073031798,
0.4233477712,
-0.6997382641,
-0.0147337997,
-0.0348166414,
0.4501207471,
-0.9783050418,
-0.0568362251,
0.3243735433,
-0.0916984603,
0.102201961,
-0.0322462991,
-0.6000403762,
-0.3071804941,
-0.2327341884,
0.491761893,
0.6424025893,
-0.8115683794,
0.7519305944,
0.0588959008,
0.237074092,
-0.2064381987,
-0.8835064769,
0.1772370934,
-0.1911889315,
-0.7790070176,
0.2805480957,
0.1261117011,
-0.8347385526,
-0.2125213295,
-0.3934670985,
0.2294756323,
0.1530400068,
-0.1326539516,
0.2014235556,
-0.1895979345,
-0.0377448462,
-0.0675834045,
-0.2618331909,
0.5370647311,
-0.4417395592,
0.6202702522,
-0.2028942555,
-0.5817611217,
-0.2979871929,
0.0686217844,
0.3771441579,
-0.3364293277,
0.5765317678,
0.1451409906,
-0.6025304198,
-0.4292407632,
-0.5233335495,
-0.1232493818,
-0.4637889564,
-0.1062270179,
-0.4833003581,
-0.6758443713,
0.5276334286,
-0.3489589393,
-0.0089460453,
0.4815983176,
0.3811684847,
0.17510584,
1.0370255709,
0.388974607,
0.3000583947,
-0.1033269018,
-0.194757238,
0.4403522313,
-0.5877354741,
-0.3789846897,
-0.4221980572,
-0.126649484,
-0.6253938675,
-0.5160495639,
0.0702689067,
0.4748539925,
-0.357763052,
0.1744104028,
-0.3155476749,
0.5616137981,
0.2767609954,
0.1233868524,
0.5159268379,
-0.1975734383,
-0.309925586,
0.1834992021,
-0.8216862082,
-0.8220898509,
0.7204627395,
0.4741252959,
0.978865087,
0.1092465818,
0.9730404615,
0.0322124623,
0.0102938125,
-0.7181164622,
0.8626307845,
0.0162971336,
-0.3798309267,
-0.1708065569,
-0.4057134688,
-0.522320807,
0.2801155448,
-0.2085255384,
-0.7093269229,
0.1553303599,
0.2828574777,
-0.1942729801,
0.3427763581,
-0.4910900891,
0.6039166451,
-0.3765869141,
-0.4349382222,
-0.4261935055,
-0.559470892,
0.5890583396,
0.175889492,
0.3326201141,
-0.0313341245,
-0.0142488731,
0.497772038,
-0.735999167,
0.6394063234,
0.0505060516,
-0.377266109,
0.6119133234,
0.5297268629,
0.8062614799,
-0.0124975434,
-0.090173468,
-0.1884532124,
-0.2267245799,
-0.3747672141,
-0.4871447086,
0.5252960324,
-0.2422300279,
-0.8409708142,
-0.1921039969,
-0.5860465169,
-0.2445019782,
0.1751222163,
0.1685805619,
0.5183502436,
-0.0709982365,
-0.2408364117,
0.8623604774,
-0.0849748701,
0.2854453027,
0.1040193513,
-0.3539885283,
-0.3360676169,
0.7869243622,
-0.146043852,
0.5006275177,
0.5771779418,
0.4288068414,
-0.3680095077,
-0.7654819489,
-0.1747977436,
0.118306458,
-1.0852539539,
-0.1006349772,
-0.3932707608,
-0.1734089255,
-0.3255657256,
-0.4597045779,
-0.1447837055,
-0.5982778072,
0.1193653196,
-0.2032528967,
0.0918418095,
0.8913376331,
-0.0551515333,
-0.1359420568,
-0.5379830599,
0.7751995921,
0.3146668971,
0.0469918437,
-0.0728281289,
-0.3784318864,
-0.0636292398,
0.126207903,
-0.2693924606,
-0.7987242341,
0.1991873682,
-0.2244484276,
0.5571600199,
0.4717692733,
0.1881151497,
0.7094986439,
-0.3943803608,
0.6376135349,
0.1825156212,
-1.0633782148,
0.6602361798,
-0.1486871988,
0.3547022045,
0.449274689,
0.2322751731,
-0.0736711919,
-0.4627745152,
-0.6592879295,
-0.8795892596,
0.413476795,
0.2426886261,
-0.3268787563,
-0.129307434,
0.2046636045,
0.1223544627,
-0.0322959088,
-0.8475118279,
0.1096063629,
-0.0956912339,
-0.3044126034,
0.2002308965,
-0.2073311657,
-0.3832804859,
-0.2320329398,
0.5483347178,
-0.1757340878,
0.0720580295,
0.3305067718,
-0.2118305117,
-0.0356494412,
0.5396641493,
0.5518093705,
0.9043442607,
-0.0016083346,
0.581484735,
0.2560759485,
-0.0713700876,
0.111039117,
0.1523299068,
-0.2766240537,
-0.2249105573,
0.8411594033,
0.5319111943,
-0.0922925323,
-0.8972476721,
0.2928065062,
-0.0115411161,
-0.4224110842,
-0.1754312962,
0.2624399066,
0.1839283705,
0.4092387557,
0.0989296138,
0.2521218061,
0.109223783,
-0.6328158975,
-0.1324570179,
0.3818845153,
-0.1303276122,
-0.1105994284,
0.6148488522,
0.1396548748,
-0.275816828,
0.60109514,
-0.2694359124,
-0.7706561089,
0.764606297,
0.9023099542,
0.885068357,
0.3456211686,
-0.0113733737,
0.2631597221,
0.5466264486,
-0.132729128,
0.3502025902,
-0.3400116563,
-0.8472999334,
-0.5553233027,
-0.5249773264,
-0.4691580832,
-0.161213994,
-0.3778965175,
0.1438960731,
-0.7124534845,
0.3453670144,
-0.3066883683,
-0.1598496586,
-0.7077820897,
0.4343103766,
0.4008543491,
1.1943691969,
-0.5750184059,
0.5897224545,
0.4797238708,
-0.3128821552,
-0.8569242954,
0.2167860866,
-0.1152647585,
-0.7552194595,
0.6004999876,
0.4277715981,
-0.6235484481,
-0.2835884988,
-0.6168770194,
-0.4695183933,
1.146240592,
0.4000106156,
-0.8300418854,
-0.0050313966,
0.2778941691,
0.6058862805,
-0.5231922865,
0.0630705878,
0.701366663,
0.3835503459,
0.3288168311,
-0.4323077202,
0.4861013889,
0.1712927818,
-0.2461556941,
0.1928464919,
-0.3196409047,
0.6577849984,
-0.6400623322,
-0.2913937867,
-0.0385691375,
0.6468227506,
0.7329725623,
0.4770528972,
0.6211391687,
0.7620841265,
0.8433045149,
-0.045738209,
1.1136758327,
-0.2516262531,
-0.1215949133,
1.1518620253,
-0.4332126081,
0.8240989447,
0.5091594458,
-0.1134597659,
0.8380073309,
0.3506066799,
0.3407922983,
0.2916945517,
0.4801288843,
-0.2178846449,
-0.7497568727,
-0.0877867267,
-0.0842114538,
0.2833621204,
0.4509266317,
-0.3736625314,
-0.230120331,
-0.3689407408,
-0.0815874934,
0.5163087845,
-0.5328552723,
0.5935575366,
0.1487101763,
-0.8137405515,
0.7162981033,
0.124899976,
0.4649554491,
-0.512201488,
-0.1285566241,
-0.0395389497,
0.3716290891,
-0.2708181739,
-0.801507473,
0.2530619502,
0.1844593138,
0.0313156061,
-0.3881483674,
1.0682985783,
-0.2937549651,
-0.413379401,
0.3259549737,
0.4833734632,
-0.1256136447,
0.2539912462,
-0.5373825431,
-0.0132280039,
0.0333248377,
0.0442096032,
-0.0959600955,
0.7297344208,
-0.164120838,
0.9211629629,
0.6241754293,
0.0193139985,
-0.0698534176,
0.2197182775,
0.9677712321,
-0.8816578388,
-0.4749209881,
-1.2609013319,
0.4342861474,
0.0063529094,
0.1002293378,
0.6850580573,
0.5059329271,
0.8218021393,
0.1347784102,
0.6782474518,
0.1279041022,
0.1385537684,
-0.8529493213,
0.0544590615,
-0.2213327438,
0.7143756747,
0.0986840427,
-0.5855617523,
-0.2776191235,
0.5377067924,
-0.4386174977,
-0.0773225129,
0.7554768324,
0.5836724639,
0.1169628724,
0.1716065109,
0.2019893974,
0.3014781475,
0.5542804599,
0.839794457,
1.0923212767,
-0.2433046252,
0.5980532765,
-0.316408962,
-0.1369810551,
0.044398509,
-1.0765994787,
-1.038210988,
0.0331597663,
-0.342323482,
-0.4241962135,
0.0911881998,
1.0239113569,
0.3661262095,
-0.6880731583,
-0.2177210003,
-0.84862113,
0.4695512652,
-0.2429014295,
-0.2039913088,
0.0594237335,
-0.4674556851,
-0.2998336852,
0.4620715678,
0.4707336724,
0.0433624685,
-0.3175650239,
-0.4013648033,
-0.3608507216,
0.5143493414,
0.6626563072,
0.1417764872,
-0.8450035453,
-0.1576664746,
-0.1903972775,
-0.2116283327,
-0.0151534248,
0.7743009925,
-0.9706941843,
0.3708232343,
0.7517502308,
0.5211987495,
0.3775849938,
0.0559180602,
0.7175965309,
-0.2355423421,
-0.0792639256,
0.4502705038,
0.6900922656,
0.3099099696,
-0.2049233913,
0.4860135019,
0.077115126,
-0.5716292858,
-0.6664767861,
0.5474722981,
-0.8814195395,
-0.399671495,
1.2124230862,
-0.0521711186,
-0.2569554746,
-0.0887878463,
-0.2761802077,
0.0690714344,
-0.0483318605,
0.5942513347,
0.6663787961,
-0.5245144367,
-0.0432670228,
-0.1021696702,
0.3560947478,
0.4130129814,
-0.8596606255,
0.0848840326,
0.5958029628,
0.063687861,
0.2962204814,
0.6046715379,
-0.0182018057,
0.2238055468,
0.2965651453,
-0.3928724229,
-0.1634021848,
-0.4028455317,
-0.3540635407,
0.1400099099,
0.4310261905,
0.001220027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06729v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06729v1
|
Comprehending Lexical and Affective Ontologies in the Demographically Diverse Spatial Social Media Discourse
| 2023-11-12T04:23:33 | 2023-11-12T04:23:33 |
Salim Sazzed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study aims to comprehend linguistic and socio-demographic features,
encompassing English language styles, conveyed sentiments, and lexical
diversity within spatial online social media review data. To this end, we
undertake a case study that scrutinizes reviews composed by two distinct and
demographically diverse groups. Our analysis entails the extraction and
examination of various statistical, grammatical, and sentimental features from
these two groups. Subsequently, we leverage these features with machine
learning (ML) classifiers to discern their potential in effectively
differentiating between the groups. Our investigation unveils substantial
disparities in certain linguistic attributes between the two groups. When
integrated into ML classifiers, these attributes exhibit a marked efficacy in
distinguishing the groups, yielding a macro F1 score of approximately 0.85.
Furthermore, we conduct a comparative evaluation of these linguistic features
with word n-gram-based lexical features in discerning demographically diverse
review data. As expected, the n-gram lexical features, coupled with fine-tuned
transformer-based models, show superior performance, attaining accuracies
surpassing 95\% and macro F1 scores exceeding 0.96. Our meticulous analysis and
comprehensive evaluations substantiate the efficacy of linguistic and
sentimental features in effectively discerning demographically diverse review
data. The findings of this study provide valuable guidelines for future
research endeavors concerning the analysis of demographic patterns in textual
content across various social media platforms.
|
[
-0.6783226132,
-0.6801581383,
0.4069511294,
0.5460216999,
-0.1055658981,
0.4011313617,
-0.2278308719,
-0.3908054829,
0.4435397983,
0.2531859875,
-0.6179563999,
-0.9098854065,
-0.8417661786,
0.2967573106,
-0.1343916655,
0.8144972324,
0.1230618879,
0.1915619522,
-0.0332275815,
-0.3086945713,
-0.0749494508,
-0.6179421544,
-0.2294060886,
-0.0045334413,
0.5474585891,
0.3007299304,
0.878506124,
0.3196121454,
0.4781045318,
0.3048198819,
-0.4247865379,
0.1658484191,
-0.8088250756,
-0.1263919771,
-0.2538675368,
-0.3354656696,
-0.0196763184,
-0.1977606118,
0.4722519815,
0.7228221297,
0.1927258372,
0.1831799001,
0.0067009302,
0.8725193739,
-0.5197100639,
0.1585367322,
-0.9009104371,
0.3973821104,
-0.1138474941,
-0.2666634321,
-0.0364994891,
-0.6004865766,
0.247595191,
-0.5662203431,
0.2391572297,
-0.0730041564,
0.8756358624,
0.0960714668,
-0.5885292292,
-0.2968333066,
-0.6892316341,
0.7306382656,
-0.2152632177,
0.349153012,
0.5525599718,
0.3429096639,
0.3518443108,
-0.1924643368,
-0.633526206,
0.0596156158,
0.0028202829,
0.2322210371,
-0.2965021133,
-0.3818143904,
0.0369959176,
0.1395363361,
-0.6560461521,
0.0902705714,
-0.5127194524,
0.0120209837,
0.7722911835,
0.3424060643,
0.4011199772,
-0.7478060722,
-0.1041964442,
0.0488784909,
-0.5253167748,
0.0513801835,
0.7115537524,
0.3860507607,
-0.3307246268,
0.6891437173,
-0.2182176858,
-0.0786376372,
-0.1463224292,
0.2746433914,
0.5616071224,
-0.3864129782,
0.1177492589,
-0.1978626549,
0.9354020953,
0.5576332808,
0.7073717117,
-0.0182618182,
-0.0920203775,
0.367418468,
0.3780922592,
-0.5504435897,
0.0734210759,
0.0861928314,
-0.7646758556,
-0.2450392544,
0.1722295731,
-1.1519050598,
-0.4626558721,
-0.20523794,
-0.2070772499,
-0.3541592956,
-0.2527415156,
0.0236246865,
-0.2258176804,
0.1297573447,
0.3789713681,
-0.9031339884,
0.1010464579,
0.8498179317,
0.8138602972,
-0.0740958303,
0.0588467233,
0.5369250774,
-0.3985001743,
-0.0832404122,
0.9396051168,
-0.7743880153,
-0.580981493,
0.455031544,
-0.1053752378,
-0.1491480619,
-0.5587177277,
0.3620364666,
-0.7148472667,
0.0296152122,
-0.4478993118,
-0.2184126377,
-0.2765465081,
0.3512368798,
-0.7680743337,
1.100040555,
0.2941265106,
-0.8818565011,
0.5879535675,
-0.5124503374,
-0.290814817,
0.0593312941,
-0.1250684857,
-0.2685642838,
0.1361294687,
0.1758248359,
0.3670712709,
0.0093599679,
-0.01704886,
-0.7591838837,
-0.0479583628,
0.5018540025,
-0.0197143406,
0.5980829,
0.3954450786,
-0.2582173645,
0.1022209749,
-0.6328666806,
-0.2257728279,
0.1616385281,
-0.0046555512,
-0.3834941983,
0.0826172307,
0.387493968,
0.4174604118,
-0.0689417496,
-0.5979803801,
-0.1055094898,
-0.2386886477,
0.4804646075,
0.5511971116,
0.027829919,
0.5885539055,
-0.2523926497,
0.8199250698,
-0.0842622966,
0.1521729678,
0.1665692478,
-0.471778214,
-0.2935300767,
-0.1062699705,
0.0135436468,
0.7200326324,
-0.6505301595,
0.6639975905,
-0.3378419578,
-0.7781776786,
-0.5032278895,
0.1621184647,
0.2305680364,
-0.1237693951,
0.1854965538,
-0.060387563,
-0.7564010024,
-0.5391218662,
-0.2902725935,
-0.5153004527,
0.1377203166,
0.8101531267,
0.5067387819,
-0.5281803608,
0.8890161514,
-0.4888682663,
-0.2083916962,
-0.2884421349,
-0.0236646365,
-0.0483403876,
-0.217699632,
0.6247724295,
-1.1250834465,
-0.6522317529,
0.2464129925,
-0.8386467099,
-0.4219971299,
0.1872702986,
-0.3382789195,
0.2164377421,
0.2872722745,
-0.4667488933,
0.5815072656,
0.5452946424,
-0.6285380721,
0.3349646926,
0.2844463289,
0.3768700659,
-0.8775492907,
-0.1459881961,
0.5304251313,
0.1062308699,
-0.2893029451,
-0.203375265,
-0.1686583757,
0.0723496974,
-0.5504286289,
0.2846170962,
-0.2088537216,
0.0627335832,
0.0267366953,
0.4162889719,
-0.1108424515,
0.0432173982,
0.0716367662,
0.0629275814,
0.0934661776,
-0.1637652069,
0.1273261309,
0.5669803619,
-0.3498457372,
0.3579255342,
-0.3230573237,
-0.083396472,
-0.5254465342,
0.1362398118,
-1.4087840319,
-0.0793545768,
0.1929426193,
-0.7506405711,
-0.2814228237,
-0.0794140324,
-0.4998292625,
-0.2990960479,
-0.3715581596,
0.2961803675,
0.3594639003,
-0.218523562,
0.6310155392,
0.9422835708,
-0.4301808774,
-0.1023945585,
-0.5605817437,
-0.1225082278,
-0.5482372046,
-0.7064167261,
0.1624792367,
0.2824094296,
-0.6684465408,
0.1414670348,
0.2854691446,
-0.244250685,
-0.0254514739,
0.4771223962,
0.3533483148,
-0.053536538,
0.3185720444,
-0.076634191,
0.1482804567,
0.2281357795,
-0.0393365733,
0.7272951007,
-0.0828023702,
-0.0328504518,
0.0869019479,
0.3867120743,
0.5639514923,
-0.0256841555,
0.8669106364,
0.6851909161,
-0.2994118035,
-0.1930353492,
-0.4566580653,
0.0086366413,
-0.3709780574,
0.4980173111,
-0.2393542975,
-1.3247079849,
0.9564495087,
0.2118820697,
-0.0497213826,
0.7664726377,
0.7023555636,
-0.2546889782,
0.8181809187,
0.5312341452,
-0.0906361416,
0.5511280298,
-0.179875508,
0.1990971565,
-0.3611875772,
-0.3582423627,
-0.6821471453,
-0.3595012128,
-1.0145248175,
-0.2849161029,
0.2563595176,
-0.4519469738,
-0.0830529258,
0.1794246882,
-0.3561221361,
0.2076298147,
-0.0927403644,
0.117794022,
-0.0617464334,
0.3045354486,
0.0018856541,
-0.4781646729,
-0.5034358501,
-0.8345732093,
1.1082159281,
0.4394342303,
0.7046824694,
0.2507949769,
0.3569582701,
0.711448729,
0.4215513766,
-0.6769917011,
0.6449258924,
-0.5963149071,
-0.6096590161,
-0.2538780272,
-0.6804099083,
-1.0966365337,
0.4642405808,
-0.570029974,
-0.8029779792,
0.1461471617,
-0.0183749869,
-0.2840959728,
0.2761464119,
-0.4386828542,
0.8510499001,
-0.2006097734,
-0.1671223789,
-0.3449337482,
-0.7180610895,
0.2504256368,
-0.5091392398,
0.580057025,
-0.5260873437,
0.00297535,
0.4393006265,
-0.2811244428,
0.9683503509,
-0.0297441762,
0.053429991,
0.2994135022,
-0.1159950793,
-0.3114869297,
-0.0117142936,
-0.1002203301,
0.6442769766,
0.129369542,
-0.1231049672,
-0.5085393786,
0.6116431355,
-1.2060678005,
-0.1814134419,
0.0206070431,
-0.3736381531,
-0.0852074176,
-0.330062151,
0.2000338435,
0.1932525188,
-0.5219584703,
0.0840607136,
0.2897135019,
-0.3740261793,
0.2251020968,
0.4447928667,
-0.5186123848,
-0.5658006668,
0.7699104548,
0.4256462753,
0.0638724193,
0.4541721642,
0.357203126,
-0.5147807598,
0.1057852432,
-0.2542545199,
0.3470076919,
-0.7953834534,
0.2699881494,
-1.1465889215,
-0.0481830128,
-0.677547574,
-0.1604938656,
-0.1151122302,
-0.4958428144,
-0.2989664972,
-0.0060442025,
0.1781948507,
0.9170951843,
0.2594152093,
0.4387986958,
-1.0053361654,
0.233336851,
-0.3387865424,
-0.0253278613,
0.0010630633,
-0.6228363514,
-0.069366768,
-0.2052939236,
-0.3731768131,
-1.1769729853,
0.5395162702,
0.1243698001,
0.4851530492,
0.7431263328,
-0.0514738187,
0.4106327593,
-0.3481837213,
0.8115509152,
-0.1160297766,
-0.7374216914,
0.4524307251,
-0.4061080813,
0.3290995359,
0.5893315673,
0.8653128743,
-0.6635516882,
-0.4151956141,
-0.5587086082,
-1.1121737957,
0.261562258,
0.1287805587,
0.4369213581,
-0.3084298074,
0.281265825,
0.2213144004,
0.1877524257,
-0.7561938763,
-0.1563555598,
-0.1335650831,
-0.2841700912,
-0.0019892848,
-0.5297263265,
0.1119932011,
-0.0788413808,
0.4206737876,
0.0004292243,
0.0559117235,
0.0223885588,
-0.0904715806,
-0.0620990098,
0.3504465222,
0.2782518268,
0.6187946796,
0.0302784741,
0.196115911,
0.1805039644,
-0.4177561402,
0.1492116898,
0.0980264619,
-0.2804319561,
0.2317853719,
0.4460407197,
0.7057161331,
0.2530959547,
-0.5050584078,
0.3771646917,
-0.2192814201,
-0.3468546569,
-0.4986899495,
-0.4700939059,
-0.0235891137,
0.1491023749,
0.177802071,
0.1238701791,
0.2542481124,
-0.583280921,
0.0846257657,
0.4206577241,
-0.7045241594,
-0.6000941992,
0.3133509159,
0.2490781844,
-0.1817913502,
0.351225853,
-0.3611118197,
-0.8205217719,
0.6136088371,
0.2749329209,
1.1374801397,
-0.1099282578,
0.411719203,
0.3337895572,
0.4733884633,
0.3121132851,
0.4255567193,
-0.0282051209,
-1.1547671556,
-0.139026165,
-0.7446820736,
-0.2271277308,
-0.4832247496,
-0.5819129944,
0.186422959,
-0.5005947351,
-0.6409825087,
0.1830717027,
-0.3132208288,
-0.6703990102,
0.0918291509,
0.3234919608,
0.6295288205,
-1.2600417137,
0.1182543412,
1.0927603245,
-0.1684728861,
-0.6568806767,
0.0989699811,
0.508672893,
-0.6294832826,
0.9165648222,
0.3488684893,
-0.0361474901,
-0.4715077579,
-0.116346769,
-0.7220108509,
0.3928428292,
-0.1051926687,
-0.3365064263,
0.1504028141,
0.486510247,
0.9586165547,
-0.442979753,
0.5879335999,
0.3959308565,
0.4634874165,
0.2125343382,
-0.728664279,
-0.1711223274,
-0.5448676348,
0.1983220279,
0.163404718,
-0.6463307738,
0.5134807229,
-0.1231119633,
-0.5002659559,
-0.2636355758,
0.5551592708,
0.2307698876,
0.5333272815,
0.7994075418,
0.4232630432,
0.396212399,
-0.1866935045,
0.9273428321,
-0.3592373133,
0.4723423123,
0.4298597276,
-0.56717062,
0.9114631414,
0.2453993261,
-0.5471835732,
0.6397465467,
0.7944069505,
0.0034267926,
0.2866179347,
0.4178382456,
-0.3632337153,
-0.0866237581,
-0.3441461921,
-0.0239507575,
0.8464149833,
0.3273459971,
-0.56727314,
-0.102515623,
0.0822414681,
0.0946926028,
0.393173337,
-0.3957303762,
0.8947203159,
0.1353057325,
-0.5979719162,
-0.0609488375,
-0.0888289139,
0.6908121109,
-0.6549287438,
-0.0078591565,
-0.0404926054,
0.0834543034,
-0.4952898324,
-1.0397735834,
0.6132411361,
0.123376511,
-0.3511335254,
-0.2854176164,
0.7917227149,
-0.4431379735,
-0.619897902,
0.7211529016,
0.5703371167,
0.2646625936,
-0.1325435489,
-0.5855907798,
0.3458295465,
0.1216126457,
-0.0932869986,
-0.0016002982,
0.7958506942,
-0.3125837743,
0.5917550325,
0.6390440464,
0.2710044384,
0.048257716,
0.5674324632,
0.7654291391,
-0.7189106941,
-0.8082845211,
-1.1740816832,
0.4595258236,
-0.0985613167,
-0.6202757359,
0.9317738414,
0.4943606257,
0.8880020976,
-0.086625807,
0.8641096354,
-0.0515292734,
0.474416405,
-0.2938936651,
0.8088688254,
-0.3222292662,
0.2222450674,
-0.5215075612,
-0.9331631064,
-0.4202566147,
0.6000481248,
-0.6540307403,
0.3545589745,
0.4703651369,
0.8145955801,
0.4330327511,
0.3134391606,
0.3190050125,
0.021685604,
0.069142513,
0.2147506773,
1.3325436115,
0.0032678049,
0.4679931402,
0.0450687893,
-0.376473546,
-0.1693719029,
-0.5991401672,
-0.9297770858,
-0.4184803069,
-0.2435773015,
-0.5411565304,
-0.0561862662,
0.9821303487,
0.4362418056,
-0.6620735526,
-0.2765133083,
0.4120139778,
0.0168213025,
0.2873470485,
-0.3598046601,
0.030092096,
-0.1661589593,
-0.5272649527,
-0.3641219735,
0.4864907265,
-0.3267118037,
-0.4743944407,
0.0580125004,
0.0861374885,
0.1090747491,
0.7767992616,
-0.0729082003,
-0.7536031604,
-0.2217577994,
0.1357562244,
-0.3440192938,
-0.0365230702,
0.8305036426,
-0.2823158503,
0.336150229,
0.6311209202,
0.6030364037,
0.1712886244,
0.1849420667,
0.1195967272,
-0.4628925323,
-0.0790496916,
0.2187892497,
0.5558975339,
0.523958683,
-0.4479954541,
0.5281861424,
0.4721576869,
-0.6311593056,
-0.215841949,
0.0694500431,
-1.091129899,
-0.0928085893,
1.5729308128,
-0.1320926994,
-0.1509837657,
-0.2241357565,
-0.3528599441,
0.1534807682,
-0.4414946139,
1.1214376688,
0.7191048265,
0.0533609949,
-0.2144266069,
-0.3493210077,
0.1020343229,
0.4161870182,
-1.0038485527,
-0.2767959833,
0.5649731755,
0.102757968,
0.1946217865,
0.4335341156,
-0.5498164296,
0.0636006072,
-0.0844829977,
0.195280388,
0.5163505673,
0.0970348045,
-0.4194479585,
0.395845741,
-0.2691964209,
0.1035379097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06724v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06724v1
|
Controllable Topic-Focused Abstractive Summarization
| 2023-11-12T03:51:38 | 2023-11-12T03:51:38 |
Seyed Ali Bahrainian, Martin Jaggi, Carsten Eickhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Controlled abstractive summarization focuses on producing condensed versions
of a source article to cover specific aspects by shifting the distribution of
generated text towards a desired style, e.g., a set of topics. Subsequently,
the resulting summaries may be tailored to user-defined requirements. This
paper presents a new Transformer-based architecture capable of producing
topic-focused summaries. The architecture modifies the cross-attention
mechanism of the Transformer to bring topic-focus control to the generation
process while not adding any further parameters to the model. We show that our
model sets a new state of the art on the NEWTS dataset in terms of
topic-focused abstractive summarization as well as a topic-prevalence score.
Moreover, we show via extensive experiments that our proposed topical
cross-attention mechanism can be plugged into various Transformer models, such
as BART and T5, improving their performance on the CNN/Dailymail and XSum
benchmark datasets for abstractive summarization. This is achieved via
fine-tuning, without requiring training from scratch. Finally, we show through
human evaluation that our model generates more faithful summaries outperforming
the state-of-the-art Frost model.
|
[
-0.6370255351,
-0.4941952825,
0.2090496123,
0.3397957683,
-0.5662573576,
0.0907632858,
-0.1247069463,
-0.2740055025,
0.6593392491,
0.483843267,
-0.3316084445,
-0.5188843608,
-0.8385128379,
0.0575545579,
-0.7228191495,
1.6003108025,
-0.1739117056,
-0.554828465,
-0.1173254997,
0.0480057187,
-0.2087788731,
-0.114860639,
-0.3102069199,
-0.3482769132,
0.6861341,
0.3980223835,
0.619527638,
0.5987888575,
0.7854691744,
0.2118667215,
-0.3434492946,
-0.0509033501,
-0.5869540572,
0.061086271,
-0.5558341742,
-0.3286444843,
-0.8988050818,
-0.271643132,
0.368858248,
0.5543554425,
-0.0327169485,
0.1330040991,
0.132484585,
0.5109048486,
-0.7049536109,
-0.2015002966,
-0.7296851277,
0.2005839348,
0.0572023354,
-0.1990680695,
-0.5039204359,
-0.1153438091,
0.391980499,
-0.3865868151,
0.5944859982,
-0.2117458731,
0.8843402267,
0.3309651613,
-0.4938877821,
-0.0907240808,
-0.8225367069,
0.7429907918,
-0.4838195443,
-0.0047163293,
0.0638449267,
0.1800515652,
0.4873202443,
-1.0850273371,
-0.0983037129,
0.1830376089,
-0.3275263309,
0.3096712232,
-0.5521171093,
-0.078484863,
-0.0897454098,
0.5394759178,
-0.514817059,
-0.3290661275,
-0.3996973038,
-0.1274393201,
0.5282046199,
0.4181722701,
0.0458731838,
-0.2359320074,
-0.1260729283,
0.3420663476,
-0.529760778,
-0.1717153043,
-0.1767562479,
0.0001507789,
-0.2093663663,
0.7048572898,
-0.4463264346,
0.3026075959,
0.4482949078,
0.0564083084,
-0.0411016606,
-0.3687825203,
-0.0581771061,
0.1403437555,
0.3817819953,
0.702842474,
0.0459575094,
-0.3060288727,
-0.2961577773,
0.028230438,
0.5566126704,
-0.8819862008,
-0.2153082192,
0.322681725,
-0.6141896248,
-0.5475046635,
-0.0391415879,
-0.5054363608,
0.1985656619,
-0.331092298,
0.1819867194,
-0.1389010698,
-0.2504343688,
-0.1999612898,
-0.3035648167,
0.2133706957,
0.3170996308,
-0.9592666626,
0.589612484,
0.6359112263,
1.0467921495,
-1.0419228077,
-0.0761143193,
-0.1643813401,
0.5534213185,
-0.279891789,
0.7961400747,
-0.3756930232,
-0.3281538188,
-0.2956146002,
-0.11951603,
0.2519561648,
-0.2217932791,
0.1780763417,
-0.8080385923,
0.3714814186,
0.112567924,
-0.2361119837,
0.0078007095,
0.2763403952,
-0.4176130891,
0.6233541369,
0.0077311695,
-1.2788476944,
0.2052485049,
-0.6405231953,
-0.7366278768,
-0.3723501265,
-0.0109499376,
-0.5515672565,
0.2093111277,
0.2283822,
0.4032428563,
0.0222304389,
0.7895076275,
0.3230534494,
-0.1464948207,
0.0143493554,
-0.3950925767,
0.184587881,
0.1346402317,
-0.5601741672,
0.7102460861,
-0.6944670677,
-0.349916786,
-0.1128252596,
-0.0173859093,
-0.190266028,
-0.1311072856,
0.189318642,
0.2650828063,
0.3349228799,
-0.2519912422,
-0.1607344896,
-0.2751922905,
0.4350313842,
0.3752970099,
0.3336117268,
0.6898251176,
-0.3968221843,
0.5493094325,
0.0457696021,
-0.0408529639,
-0.6303862929,
-0.309240073,
-0.7588531375,
-0.3950202167,
0.3491285741,
0.5636240244,
-0.488312453,
0.5024584532,
-0.2567138076,
-0.5563300848,
-0.0606447868,
-0.4571763277,
0.2261917889,
0.6506421566,
0.3923209906,
-0.3372431993,
-0.2236067653,
-1.0520061255,
0.0616408512,
0.6290214658,
-0.3826666474,
0.2834969163,
0.4222951233,
0.0282506309,
1.1278336048,
-0.7606974244,
-0.138125807,
-0.7110105157,
0.4559844136,
0.1323968321,
0.5707773566,
0.2444007248,
-0.9907222986,
-0.4411820173,
-0.0715307817,
-0.5016070008,
-0.2189548016,
-0.1118893325,
-0.1150554195,
-0.052541215,
0.6290014982,
-0.7470979095,
0.6424915791,
0.2372121513,
-0.4304541051,
0.4215832353,
-0.2758580148,
-0.0641030297,
-1.3268300295,
0.397726059,
-0.032435786,
-0.3490935266,
-0.4051117599,
-0.0287388619,
0.0868098587,
-0.5620263219,
-0.5174499154,
0.3289759755,
-0.2251382917,
-0.029037701,
-0.7802755833,
0.1197693571,
0.1697484106,
0.678403914,
0.3818562031,
0.5745669007,
0.4550193548,
-0.7017563581,
-0.0771541595,
0.3881216645,
0.0849190354,
0.2552846968,
-1.3410806656,
-0.1232256293,
-0.5100651979,
0.5521064997,
-0.9452317357,
-0.2917082012,
0.066993162,
-0.1946627349,
0.3923449516,
0.4256368577,
0.2412246466,
0.0564903803,
-0.3401415646,
0.3338841498,
0.3349584341,
0.0241963491,
0.8796037436,
0.3767532408,
-0.7854702473,
-0.5183980465,
-0.8418267965,
0.2642055154,
-0.1384565532,
-0.2297174484,
1.0052070618,
0.1878151596,
-0.2825061381,
0.3731305301,
-0.1614827812,
0.0245543718,
-0.2090448588,
0.1222737804,
0.2539273202,
-0.0811194777,
-0.0129852071,
0.5843369365,
-0.5619713068,
-0.0331954025,
-0.2583518922,
0.3942261934,
0.2875236571,
-0.1153865606,
-0.4738971889,
0.7922213674,
0.7934729457,
-0.7732876539,
0.2646233737,
0.2161962092,
-0.2998794019,
-0.2072840035,
-0.1381680965,
-0.5420886278,
-0.4308899343,
0.5837205052,
-0.3124742806,
-0.8712881804,
0.5300034285,
0.0091310432,
0.4543801844,
0.618073225,
0.651512146,
0.1816151589,
0.8448220491,
0.9902144074,
-0.2454676181,
0.4706385136,
-0.3216336966,
-0.0338199921,
-0.6008204222,
-0.0537110418,
-0.3590212166,
-0.6418685913,
-0.5174527764,
-0.1256576627,
0.4070896804,
-0.5129489303,
0.0429368615,
0.1695758104,
-0.8525953889,
0.4813390374,
0.4841673672,
0.0726589486,
0.5217814445,
-0.2441248149,
0.2465781122,
-0.1249967515,
-0.7701603174,
-0.492741853,
1.0436909199,
0.3760754168,
0.7155095935,
-0.169934243,
0.5236925483,
0.5630176663,
0.5003418922,
-0.4744109213,
0.4123636186,
-0.1727670878,
-0.5221506357,
-0.3814446628,
-0.2113198638,
-0.6753704548,
0.3635328412,
0.1586586833,
-0.5235339403,
0.2563579977,
0.0585586727,
-0.1724537015,
0.2405238897,
-0.4647058845,
0.6311569214,
0.2062450498,
-0.303358078,
-0.518093586,
-0.7058337331,
0.5024440885,
0.0549345426,
-0.1391982436,
-0.0842830837,
-0.2504467964,
0.6131618023,
-0.1784546673,
0.7941945195,
0.0588129051,
-0.1588158607,
0.1449697763,
-0.0927572176,
0.4205387533,
0.306039542,
0.2664858401,
-0.1211292446,
-0.5319578648,
-0.398922354,
-0.483561188,
0.5545445681,
-0.4934043884,
-0.796790421,
-0.3135314584,
-0.8409566283,
0.1129683778,
0.5125592947,
0.6353712678,
0.5249032974,
-0.3947014213,
0.1597985029,
0.9421574473,
0.003322371,
0.5976891518,
0.4456406534,
-0.1072784439,
-0.5754202008,
0.824219346,
0.0363544002,
0.2335780412,
0.9363135099,
-0.0311671216,
0.0989911258,
-0.6312596798,
-0.2266769707,
-0.05023228,
-0.451793462,
-0.1617414802,
-1.0494453907,
-0.2833698094,
-0.2660924196,
-0.5000501275,
-0.4070110321,
-0.6446677446,
-0.2863090038,
-0.2208835036,
0.1032140255,
0.6003899574,
0.3034847677,
0.3106967509,
-0.5109796524,
0.8311402202,
0.3878296912,
0.1779496074,
0.0506180264,
-0.5950582027,
-0.0876286775,
-0.4622021914,
-0.5700577497,
-0.7486127019,
0.3559718728,
0.0842505023,
0.1540519744,
0.5480764508,
0.2683481872,
-0.079127349,
-0.5408831835,
0.6684330106,
0.042521853,
-1.1057136059,
0.8144447803,
-0.4998836815,
0.8002083302,
0.4537985623,
0.3108910024,
-0.2363857329,
-0.9598455429,
-0.5971989036,
-0.9935295582,
0.7326755524,
0.3262301385,
0.3493887782,
0.181681633,
0.2403296381,
0.2469388098,
0.3854663074,
-0.5555431247,
-0.3507102132,
-0.5408684611,
-0.1686201841,
-0.0765589103,
-0.3129092753,
-0.2336856872,
-0.126526773,
0.6985022426,
-0.0687352344,
0.0888893157,
0.3784579337,
0.0498433597,
-0.034985777,
0.2844954431,
0.9933766127,
0.9122804403,
-0.2008857429,
0.3529654443,
0.0529390685,
-0.5795966983,
0.0688244179,
0.2500792146,
-0.6604345441,
0.4092247784,
0.1716947556,
0.8403359652,
0.4054024518,
-0.3915600777,
0.3884231448,
-0.1922985017,
-0.2915413976,
0.1377321035,
0.0224334691,
0.0913381204,
0.0164756086,
0.5022093654,
0.2819961309,
0.3541379273,
-0.1227759272,
0.5102601051,
0.1116408259,
-0.3800835013,
-0.34787637,
1.0110172033,
0.480892688,
-0.1720739603,
0.1477674693,
-0.0572729371,
-0.3850734234,
0.6086047888,
0.5585803986,
1.0288454294,
-0.0804975703,
0.2564820945,
0.121850349,
0.3749906421,
0.4603526294,
0.1564003527,
-0.4884171784,
-0.5005728602,
-0.6027324796,
-0.0689349324,
-0.7777065635,
-0.1421419084,
-0.8205062747,
0.2494399846,
-0.2118994445,
-0.0253373422,
0.1934906393,
-0.2476299554,
0.0742652342,
0.4945500493,
-0.2033017129,
1.1684672832,
-0.6798147559,
0.5018522739,
0.549672842,
-0.0633702353,
-0.2791811228,
0.1596259326,
-0.5017181635,
-0.1715871841,
0.1969504058,
-0.0598863885,
0.0855560973,
0.1298481524,
-0.2182985693,
-0.8467772603,
1.2526725531,
0.0729612708,
-0.4684239328,
-0.2675145864,
0.0532864779,
0.3344621658,
-0.3713472784,
0.2970989645,
0.3697090745,
0.288369,
0.0904501453,
-0.6353080273,
0.0242405348,
-0.466437906,
-0.1514436007,
0.4226063788,
-0.750123322,
0.6008420587,
-0.2215194404,
0.1318093389,
-0.4901566803,
1.2592229843,
0.2097124904,
0.6703545451,
0.0955607891,
0.4484697878,
0.3998108804,
-0.029528657,
0.9797243476,
-0.6735168099,
0.1319012791,
1.2219942808,
-0.1166844517,
0.487072736,
0.6137755513,
0.2088068575,
0.2711977661,
0.2773574889,
0.0457535461,
0.9660828114,
-0.0267276298,
-0.1616646498,
0.2116084099,
-0.3203582466,
-0.4036934972,
0.3910407424,
0.2905321717,
-0.6384012699,
-0.4779238999,
0.1489448398,
-0.0868251771,
0.0645356625,
-0.4826980233,
0.9171747565,
0.0392974988,
-0.7801944017,
0.2054887265,
0.3451908231,
0.8609287143,
-0.7873457074,
0.2518267632,
-0.3062596023,
-0.0389003307,
-0.3167638779,
-0.5110737085,
0.7473731637,
0.2712135017,
-0.683901608,
-0.3138023317,
1.0315067768,
-0.4485642314,
-0.4322662354,
-0.4195911586,
0.4423389137,
-0.1997863203,
0.0273398738,
-0.1784270257,
-0.1159473807,
0.028972568,
-0.5196608901,
0.1956518739,
0.4986152351,
-0.2136163712,
0.5239861012,
0.1315308511,
0.0920239761,
-0.2945622802,
-0.0898792446,
0.9620204568,
-0.5684393048,
-1.0952372551,
-0.5007787943,
0.6055806875,
-0.0772804916,
-0.6361634731,
0.5617402196,
0.7183346152,
0.4505262971,
-0.2455592901,
0.8814370036,
-0.0490634926,
0.5143638253,
-0.1094393283,
0.8550816178,
-0.2797205746,
-0.0525089875,
-0.1102358177,
-0.8999999762,
-0.2879050374,
0.1838577092,
-0.3583999872,
-0.1063946635,
0.5703196526,
0.5051320791,
-0.2969542742,
0.0630848035,
0.1924727708,
-0.2122525424,
0.2380958647,
0.3583114147,
0.5492418408,
-0.1321892142,
0.4788910747,
-0.4657794237,
-0.3146364093,
-0.1244037449,
-0.8377290964,
-0.9503833055,
-0.377461493,
-0.5690472126,
0.0998842344,
-0.0993808657,
0.5453176498,
0.720176518,
-1.1066157818,
0.0644246563,
-0.5633012652,
0.2841468453,
-0.1678693891,
-0.3130740821,
0.6683694124,
-0.2204116881,
-0.7687671781,
-0.1168331057,
0.4685393274,
0.0082584461,
-0.2706113756,
0.2720836997,
0.2283480912,
0.1128259599,
0.5177129507,
0.1127303764,
-0.553730607,
0.1945390403,
0.1241483092,
-0.2722294033,
0.0988270938,
1.1932593584,
-0.5515303612,
-0.0350478552,
0.4027920663,
0.612606585,
0.8640425801,
0.1208202988,
0.7808217406,
-0.7181022763,
0.1331568658,
0.3187718987,
0.0734686181,
0.1084464788,
-0.412655741,
0.0148770977,
-0.1263657212,
-0.4157169759,
-0.4300239086,
-0.0650998279,
-0.8544970751,
-0.3247993886,
0.6326478124,
-0.0318876728,
-0.0603083372,
-0.0412490107,
-0.4065996408,
0.3785773516,
-0.5151543617,
1.0357577801,
0.3412726223,
-0.1450757086,
-0.2929083407,
-0.0515839234,
0.4429365396,
0.4936532676,
-0.9711403847,
0.1262207031,
0.2407426685,
0.0836778283,
0.373767674,
0.4683181047,
-0.1819309741,
0.426207751,
-0.2065776139,
0.1744129509,
-0.147679612,
-0.6039790511,
-0.2902961969,
0.7212066054,
-0.4636263549,
-0.1868480742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06720v1
|
Cappy: Outperforming and Boosting Large Multi-Task LMs with a Small Scorer
| 2023-11-12T03:25:34 | 2023-11-12T03:25:34 |
Bowen Tan, Yun Zhu, Lijuan Liu, Eric Xing, Zhiting Hu, Jindong Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) such as T0, FLAN, and OPT-IML, excel in
multi-tasking under a unified instruction-following paradigm, where they also
exhibit remarkable generalization abilities to unseen tasks. Despite their
impressive performance, these LLMs, with sizes ranging from several billion to
hundreds of billions of parameters, demand substantial computational resources,
making their training and inference expensive and inefficient. Furthermore,
adapting these models to downstream applications, particularly complex tasks,
is often unfeasible due to the extensive hardware requirements for finetuning,
even when utilizing parameter-efficient approaches such as prompt tuning.
Additionally, the most powerful multi-task LLMs, such as OPT-IML-175B and
FLAN-PaLM-540B, are not publicly accessible, severely limiting their
customization potential. To address these challenges, we introduce a pretrained
small scorer, Cappy, designed to enhance the performance and efficiency of
multi-task LLMs. With merely 360 million parameters, Cappy functions either
independently on classification tasks or serve as an auxiliary component for
LLMs, boosting their performance. Moreover, Cappy enables efficiently
integrating downstream supervision without requiring LLM finetuning nor the
access to their parameters. Our experiments demonstrate that, when working
independently on 11 language understanding tasks from PromptSource, Cappy
outperforms LLMs that are several orders of magnitude larger. Besides, on 45
complex tasks from BIG-Bench, Cappy boosts the performance of the advanced
multi-task LLM, FLAN-T5, by a large margin. Furthermore, Cappy is flexible to
cooperate with other LLM adaptations, including finetuning and in-context
learning, offering additional performance enhancement.
|
[
-0.4957278371,
-0.5849154592,
0.3880432546,
0.2485329658,
0.0838088021,
0.3054182231,
-0.9046096802,
-0.3937422037,
0.1641169339,
0.3799933195,
-0.3960490823,
-0.2416602671,
-0.6925308704,
-0.1068645567,
0.1841502041,
1.0932654142,
0.1296500415,
-0.2065428644,
-0.05789157,
-0.1045382097,
-0.7609879375,
-0.46761778,
-0.6742134094,
-0.2081568539,
0.6974278688,
0.9118607044,
0.4790914059,
0.4668543935,
0.3148425221,
0.2945781946,
0.2284010053,
0.4667083919,
-0.4044317603,
0.1213839427,
0.0990932733,
-0.5875080824,
-0.62588799,
0.1372877806,
0.6732621193,
0.6715522408,
0.0943429396,
0.3068031073,
0.515494585,
0.5794904828,
-0.8024552464,
0.5991695523,
-0.7007578015,
-0.1859426051,
-0.4207242131,
-0.0315971747,
-0.5067226887,
0.0680491477,
-0.0796690881,
-0.5791267157,
0.2911300361,
0.2534764409,
0.506778121,
0.1712416112,
0.0350479484,
-0.3414547741,
-0.375202179,
1.1535358429,
-0.5418974161,
0.3088478744,
0.0550135858,
0.3638567328,
-0.2150139064,
-0.4161888361,
-0.2231222987,
-0.4419016242,
0.0647146478,
0.0006632485,
-0.0337589532,
0.386464864,
0.3380853236,
0.3422685266,
-0.4647279978,
0.4055493176,
-0.3178904951,
-0.2912338078,
0.3759770393,
0.0665537119,
0.159280628,
0.1600482464,
-0.3230606914,
-0.0055012638,
-0.6219559312,
0.385835737,
0.1230444536,
0.8533198833,
0.0360178202,
0.300955683,
-0.1186535805,
0.8575459123,
0.0349553712,
-0.2278220356,
0.1288451701,
-0.2390991598,
-0.0982981101,
-0.116880618,
0.9349279404,
0.0395743549,
0.2580254972,
-0.1112180799,
-0.3582516909,
-0.1062169969,
0.0667215809,
-0.8048164845,
-0.3383630514,
0.3190757334,
-0.2684407234,
0.1341052949,
-0.1705308855,
-0.7483807206,
-0.1889138371,
-0.4757093787,
0.5317074656,
-0.4211437106,
0.0633287951,
0.0247944333,
-0.184068501,
-0.0179621633,
0.5151109695,
-1.1436494589,
0.4535614252,
0.7609218955,
1.0179588795,
-0.5016857386,
-0.5990589261,
-0.9489963651,
-0.0915612802,
-0.3972105384,
0.5899025798,
-0.654522121,
0.2218153179,
-0.0952578411,
-0.1126363203,
-0.4490250051,
-0.5680938363,
0.4692178369,
-0.395182699,
-0.0359915644,
-0.3507419229,
-0.3358690441,
0.0476027988,
0.1005546674,
-0.6794683337,
0.9436172247,
0.1170240194,
-0.4046929479,
0.3686479628,
-0.8060556054,
-0.3851329982,
0.2215696722,
-0.341914326,
-0.1322111338,
0.2057970315,
0.2316772193,
0.7526584268,
-0.5102983117,
0.0472197682,
-0.3892715275,
-0.5780877471,
0.093930386,
-0.5671651959,
0.3544036746,
0.3376969695,
-0.1448763311,
0.3420643508,
-0.4928804636,
0.0733648688,
-0.2415194362,
-0.6076409221,
-0.0936415046,
-0.422422111,
0.090475224,
0.1906814128,
0.4712157249,
-0.511485517,
0.3534053266,
-0.2774761021,
0.6366743445,
0.5827558637,
-0.3741180599,
0.5428184271,
-0.604822576,
0.6878119707,
-0.1923777461,
0.0834758133,
-0.4072937965,
-0.65177387,
-0.742212832,
-0.7194900513,
0.1396050751,
0.5704063773,
-0.621237576,
0.1761929542,
-0.1727805436,
-0.4821571708,
-0.5466964841,
0.5955782533,
0.5677601099,
0.2419747263,
0.4022094309,
-0.1148336306,
-0.4027062356,
-0.7427758574,
-0.4683609009,
0.2933181524,
-0.0471108258,
0.329360038,
0.2959961891,
-0.0150381709,
0.7003666759,
-0.5060623884,
-0.6572406888,
-0.4538669884,
0.0443262346,
0.7614916563,
0.5045060515,
0.4281331003,
-0.3798384964,
-0.5703939795,
-0.0530131422,
-0.3484687805,
-0.1503002346,
-0.2555658519,
-0.0005468954,
0.1263221204,
0.5113720894,
-0.6735035777,
-0.137572661,
0.4939182401,
-0.0466930605,
0.7823448181,
-0.7071903944,
0.1391392946,
-0.7242909074,
0.0578212552,
-0.0588644817,
-0.2697106898,
-0.721562624,
0.1515975744,
0.2901018262,
-0.1038547084,
-0.3556259573,
0.456969887,
-0.6219707131,
-0.0518170148,
-0.4505654275,
0.1751226932,
-0.1024111509,
0.7490495443,
-0.1142323166,
1.0865085125,
0.4304091334,
-0.7724100351,
0.3336294591,
-0.0254952405,
-0.3565685153,
0.2559978068,
-0.3895298243,
-0.0121822013,
0.0291584954,
-0.020317601,
-1.1106209755,
-0.2445578724,
-0.0136808483,
-0.339589268,
0.5722647309,
-0.1513220072,
-0.5349085927,
-0.4504478872,
-0.508425355,
0.3596150875,
0.3160482943,
-0.6184484363,
0.4601937532,
0.3758696616,
-0.0512707084,
-0.8516545296,
-0.7077445984,
0.1909653693,
-0.3042345643,
-0.2998587787,
0.2881691158,
-0.2107884586,
-0.0691710338,
-0.5153357387,
-0.0521345846,
0.078294158,
0.1092770547,
0.2733146846,
0.2872728407,
-0.232484445,
0.3914280236,
0.0713503212,
-0.1507221311,
-0.2091260254,
-0.391195327,
0.7219779491,
-0.3654614389,
-0.0471360311,
-0.3230646849,
0.1539040804,
0.6815128922,
-0.2322742045,
0.7183019519,
0.6956483722,
-0.19057329,
-0.6529114246,
-0.6580981016,
-0.1029267237,
-0.4864683747,
0.427187264,
-0.7070526481,
-1.1894645691,
0.2815265357,
-0.1207139418,
0.214951247,
0.2761300802,
0.6027166247,
-0.0486324206,
0.521427393,
0.5248155594,
-0.3555059731,
0.6700237989,
-0.1557312459,
-0.2105673105,
-0.8783442974,
0.0380558968,
-0.4098696113,
-0.3153827786,
-0.5119864345,
-0.647351861,
0.4169941247,
0.244655326,
-0.3023689091,
0.500880301,
-0.4287253022,
0.5913291574,
0.8295063972,
0.2898199558,
0.2012781203,
-0.0981221572,
-0.0050257179,
0.0181163363,
-0.9947821498,
-0.4850313663,
1.2956551313,
0.3533637822,
0.7594669461,
0.0172608551,
0.7114524245,
0.5610353351,
0.2469311357,
-0.9084169865,
0.3808909357,
-0.5693913698,
-0.4137727916,
-0.4325193763,
-0.3395832181,
-0.8469705582,
0.4587044716,
-0.1080255583,
-0.8267296553,
-0.11018911,
0.4234134555,
-0.6506667137,
0.2626250386,
-0.8827447891,
1.0442632437,
-0.2617607117,
-0.5727867484,
-0.294434756,
-0.4474574029,
0.4484393001,
-0.2124777883,
0.563144505,
-0.122970134,
-0.3708312809,
0.8123443127,
-0.2762680948,
0.9700095057,
-0.1958190054,
-0.0391137935,
0.1327392608,
0.0970284268,
0.3320165873,
-0.1398153901,
-0.024695592,
0.0234492682,
0.2067880481,
-0.4571399689,
-0.3673616052,
1.0725200176,
-0.8160232902,
-0.6588212252,
-0.2252872735,
-0.8711334467,
-0.3296974003,
0.2631585896,
0.0960366875,
0.4034436345,
0.1211532056,
0.0220695436,
0.735004127,
-0.1635636985,
0.7543353438,
0.1631188244,
-0.0948170722,
-0.4199132621,
1.1071131229,
0.1234961152,
0.4705154598,
0.6910734773,
0.367167443,
-0.1742521673,
-0.3380693197,
-0.5239881873,
0.2035504878,
-0.6625717878,
-0.227102831,
-0.3901461661,
0.0829422548,
-0.2762018442,
-0.0910795778,
-0.513345778,
-0.4624063671,
-0.3384052217,
0.4031803012,
0.2461106479,
0.5369343162,
-0.2203368694,
0.4630063772,
-0.7670635581,
0.3585429192,
0.3344623148,
0.2752611339,
0.0992999002,
-0.7762491107,
-0.2678568363,
-0.1379880458,
-0.3072767556,
-0.5725295544,
0.254330337,
0.6182349324,
0.5727665424,
0.461956501,
0.1051381305,
0.7177585959,
-0.5484095812,
0.4505093396,
0.1797979623,
-1.1045480967,
0.3118797243,
-0.3097711205,
0.3770836294,
0.5749217272,
0.3171874881,
-0.4047357142,
-0.3388502896,
-0.1093465313,
-0.4930121303,
1.0167174339,
-0.2247505933,
0.0018665347,
0.3011731803,
0.4075137675,
0.4020749331,
0.3403605521,
-0.5668956637,
-0.1104141399,
0.1453208029,
-0.310272187,
-0.4882147908,
-0.139605701,
0.0204556212,
-0.1707076281,
0.4605566859,
-0.4622491896,
0.226324752,
-0.1552940309,
-0.2540672719,
0.0731690377,
0.3984771371,
0.5215528607,
0.6158425808,
-0.1964959502,
0.2679454386,
0.3959711492,
-0.5001046062,
-0.1146826223,
-0.0060227765,
0.2536622286,
-0.2987867892,
0.5609126687,
0.673099041,
0.4577871263,
-0.7968959212,
0.6163848639,
0.1203598082,
0.0559022874,
-0.1055516601,
0.3122194707,
-0.0938147902,
0.5418428183,
0.3872529566,
0.231803447,
-0.0214724541,
-0.5550471544,
0.1791422367,
0.5979780555,
-0.3388562202,
-0.1941111982,
0.6284460425,
-0.1382566243,
-0.2332939357,
0.3172618449,
-0.0707502887,
-0.5022387505,
0.4540581405,
0.4247823954,
0.5541961789,
-0.1282648593,
0.011706383,
0.3110433817,
0.4263827503,
-0.117484346,
0.3070753217,
-0.5443283916,
-0.6222321391,
-0.6047279835,
-0.7282212973,
-0.4787669778,
0.1224824488,
-0.5282307267,
0.1641627103,
-0.5364292264,
-0.0896653906,
-0.073266387,
0.2218424976,
-0.7465941906,
0.1056623161,
0.2273741513,
0.8971349597,
-0.6642050743,
1.1341320276,
0.5460489392,
-0.4215060174,
-0.5362029672,
-0.1588546634,
-0.246118769,
-1.0140128136,
0.6956927776,
0.5317858458,
-0.1501205415,
-0.1559260935,
-0.2293670475,
-0.6842880249,
1.0097105503,
0.6300387383,
-0.9995487332,
-0.1955268532,
0.3086092174,
0.3885320425,
-0.3494754434,
0.4253132939,
0.6588130593,
0.2159852237,
-0.0551242121,
-1.1565082073,
0.1361849606,
0.2433639914,
-0.078990899,
0.1700033993,
-0.8955444694,
1.1556893587,
-0.4232595861,
0.0237600245,
0.2510529459,
0.4243271053,
0.5242313147,
0.0938990191,
0.4244401753,
0.2024746537,
0.8006352186,
-0.1314551383,
0.7468758225,
-0.5610577464,
0.1830194592,
1.2168198824,
0.2125243098,
1.0599089861,
0.5044496059,
-0.2623464763,
0.0386904515,
0.4507051706,
0.1132028997,
0.2901677787,
0.3481294215,
-0.2730223536,
-0.6429294944,
0.1276788265,
-0.1417106092,
0.4521694183,
0.5522418022,
-0.2323125452,
0.0177002177,
0.3356644511,
0.0288713742,
0.0410582647,
-0.631010592,
0.4453168809,
0.2655088603,
-0.7989709973,
0.6196547747,
-0.0178985894,
1.076920867,
-0.610375762,
0.0287574399,
-0.1587288231,
0.6804957986,
-0.1559670568,
-0.6915662289,
0.0016319586,
-0.2159149051,
-0.0794074982,
-0.3804588318,
0.7080447674,
-0.4577611685,
-0.2296845615,
0.3298484087,
0.4738361239,
0.1841220409,
-0.3019386232,
-0.6189374924,
0.3233338594,
-0.2704390585,
0.0875218809,
0.5230607986,
0.2433977276,
0.0906086341,
0.7778888345,
0.593721807,
0.2814814448,
0.0465683565,
-0.0700623915,
0.8996223211,
-0.5586049557,
-0.3885266185,
-0.863622129,
0.0661327764,
0.2155412287,
-0.444542855,
0.8773574233,
0.6770874858,
0.8710015416,
-0.2994070351,
0.5834776163,
0.1627145261,
0.5285502672,
-0.5702858567,
0.7384510636,
-0.5091434121,
0.3591727316,
-0.1984400004,
-0.9031342864,
-0.3498982489,
0.2597114742,
-0.3330574334,
0.1069703326,
0.4412706196,
0.5307838917,
-0.0744531974,
-0.1245531812,
0.5894315839,
0.061344061,
0.4042372108,
1.1251226664,
0.8153803349,
-0.3321080208,
0.6112175584,
0.0052371579,
-0.6293052435,
-0.129877165,
-0.5707438588,
-1.192985177,
-0.5023874044,
-0.0327530168,
-0.0505634993,
0.107673198,
1.0917520523,
0.8479517102,
-1.0527120829,
-0.752877593,
-0.0137356091,
-0.0319861993,
-0.250027597,
-0.1926432103,
0.2861643136,
-1.0073336363,
-0.7794409394,
0.624189198,
0.1854178309,
-0.4924114347,
-0.2006571889,
-0.1368730068,
-0.0318902768,
-0.1777750999,
0.7056814432,
0.454903692,
-0.7987487316,
-0.1333846003,
-0.2109625936,
0.0928751528,
0.0650785118,
0.7956966758,
-0.7738994956,
0.4173335731,
0.2993859351,
0.7300217152,
0.4857572913,
-0.3732541203,
0.4455487132,
-0.657743752,
0.0233046785,
0.0446978472,
0.4468766153,
0.0562308989,
-0.1636175066,
0.1165708154,
0.1554784626,
-0.6861700416,
-0.6459718347,
0.0657290369,
-1.0182542801,
-0.3630275428,
0.9738711119,
-0.228221491,
-0.0395630747,
-0.0075711762,
-0.3651794195,
0.1477339268,
-0.7234467864,
0.4716886282,
0.4824663401,
-0.2719636559,
-0.2688283026,
-0.6382744908,
0.6083434224,
0.3162709177,
-0.7366694808,
0.3277628124,
0.2725144327,
0.2311120778,
0.1100331172,
0.4051980078,
0.2472672611,
0.1975128949,
-0.0740480721,
-0.1259988993,
-0.3346613944,
-0.6044718623,
-0.3067765236,
0.4547606409,
0.3705924153,
-0.5505304337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06714v1
|
What factors influence the popularity of user-generated text in the creative domain? A case study of book reviews
| 2023-11-12T02:54:11 | 2023-11-12T02:54:11 |
Salim Sazzed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This study investigates a range of psychological, lexical, semantic, and
readability features of book reviews to elucidate the factors underlying their
perceived popularity. To this end, we conduct statistical analyses of various
features, including the types and frequency of opinion and emotion-conveying
terms, connectives, character mentions, word uniqueness, commonness, and
sentence structure, among others. Additionally, we utilize two readability
tests to explore whether reading ease is positively associated with review
popularity. Finally, we employ traditional machine learning classifiers and
transformer-based fine-tuned language models with n-gram features to
automatically determine review popularity. Our findings indicate that, with the
exception of a few features (e.g., review length, emotions, and word
uniqueness), most attributes do not exhibit significant differences between
popular and non-popular review groups. Furthermore, the poor performance of
machine learning classifiers using the word n-gram feature highlights the
challenges associated with determining popularity in creative domains. Overall,
our study provides insights into the factors underlying review popularity and
highlights the need for further research in this area, particularly in the
creative realm.
|
[
-0.9426910281,
-0.6711999178,
0.3736798167,
0.6669481993,
-0.509023428,
0.0864829123,
-0.2651466727,
-0.5717814565,
0.4013421834,
0.3921412826,
-0.3374179602,
-0.5313666463,
-0.6984650493,
0.3357169628,
-0.2964345217,
1.2433483601,
0.0272263195,
-0.2854776382,
-0.2544556558,
-0.3535746634,
-0.2627692521,
-0.6584557891,
0.0361498147,
-0.3158434033,
1.0482342243,
0.1901849955,
1.124958396,
0.1777564883,
0.5505896211,
0.2338312715,
-0.2960606515,
-0.0164941195,
-0.5361991525,
0.10936407,
0.005820645,
-0.3143187165,
-0.2461247891,
0.1332890838,
0.4374074936,
0.4870605469,
0.2488402128,
-0.168777138,
0.2641235888,
0.9493337274,
-0.2063074857,
-0.007019395,
-0.2417988777,
0.1648622304,
-0.5485208631,
-0.1721802652,
-0.2191113234,
-0.6880931854,
0.5730760098,
-0.7768924236,
0.6013737321,
0.1979289353,
0.684679985,
-0.1892426759,
-0.4667834342,
-0.8184084892,
-0.8641511202,
0.8137208223,
-0.2221199721,
0.3466181755,
0.081719026,
-0.0534084849,
-0.0435443036,
0.0204991251,
-1.1023888588,
-0.2105614692,
0.0789347738,
0.1629872322,
-0.1366336793,
-0.26680547,
0.0980956182,
0.6104866266,
-0.3989299238,
-0.1757508516,
0.1738766283,
0.3524574935,
0.802934289,
0.0563160107,
0.6333442926,
-0.4822994471,
-0.2942403257,
-0.2523888946,
-0.4895199239,
0.3288547695,
0.7375214696,
-0.3977636695,
0.3874544799,
0.7130822539,
-0.3432211876,
0.2045931816,
-0.2256490737,
0.1959020644,
0.687646687,
-0.3085464835,
0.0243667345,
-0.2286073267,
0.7888277173,
0.6861573458,
0.585349381,
-0.0271731149,
-0.3024049401,
-0.1701533347,
0.4165684283,
-0.5136501193,
-0.0012788979,
0.0472858883,
-0.7490023971,
-0.4910389185,
0.3931058049,
-0.7234244943,
-0.7438458204,
-0.2285575271,
0.4264784753,
-0.240111798,
-0.3166288733,
0.2298280895,
-0.5968409181,
-0.0267509017,
0.3329081535,
-0.8025875688,
-0.1107296273,
0.6851458549,
0.6952359676,
-0.4728874862,
-0.2198998779,
0.456993103,
-0.3245621324,
-0.3835399449,
1.1674953699,
-0.1458237469,
-0.5695554018,
-0.0087339729,
-0.0064851316,
-0.0184387676,
-0.3692773581,
0.3734931052,
-0.6006121635,
0.2255886644,
-0.2936790287,
-0.4142931402,
-0.2310910672,
0.1498470157,
-0.7713116407,
0.6631583571,
0.0850547254,
-0.9694954753,
0.6245203614,
-0.2671087682,
-0.5427749753,
0.1766100973,
-0.0093102474,
-0.5658665299,
0.4805430472,
-0.0315243267,
0.369831413,
-0.1837999821,
-0.1015455574,
-0.2483955771,
-0.4541758001,
0.8788313866,
-0.2788699269,
0.6142525077,
0.4390862286,
-0.3256675005,
-0.0599203333,
-0.472630471,
0.0274680927,
0.1569193006,
-0.3981674016,
-0.5479289293,
0.0883839056,
0.4466418624,
-0.1827087104,
0.0151380757,
-0.4379478395,
0.4005483389,
-0.2420404553,
0.1071916223,
0.0978233516,
0.7764484286,
0.3377183974,
-0.535590589,
0.6531177759,
-0.0107318843,
0.1812672019,
0.1212658435,
-0.8524662256,
-0.3656456172,
0.0064602001,
0.1885520816,
0.4238257706,
-0.5647274256,
0.3183677793,
0.2120882422,
-1.200396657,
-0.5952215791,
0.4828358889,
0.290582478,
0.0448851436,
-0.1796469688,
-0.4550967813,
0.0498126112,
-0.6990280747,
-0.6515898108,
-0.3464056849,
0.0364425257,
0.8397458196,
-0.0684132352,
-0.5796524286,
0.7250210047,
-0.6605371237,
-0.3013115823,
-0.5747118592,
0.6120865941,
0.3239220977,
0.0712748468,
0.8280569911,
-0.9935327768,
-0.5680229664,
0.0896793753,
-0.4945599437,
-0.491792351,
-0.1354236007,
-0.2061931044,
0.2489555925,
-0.0500822365,
-0.661532104,
0.4751553535,
0.2208543569,
-0.3040460348,
0.5043518543,
-0.0340151824,
0.5188965201,
-0.7822316289,
-0.2912432849,
0.2911337912,
0.7055600286,
-0.3028225005,
-0.0493859127,
-0.1369937956,
0.0018869962,
-0.1828796864,
0.2487221956,
-0.3894385993,
0.2299644351,
-0.288282305,
0.2604495585,
0.2364341617,
0.0939738974,
0.3025912046,
0.3457734287,
0.5438680649,
-0.606297493,
0.2979160845,
0.3415828645,
-0.6296014786,
0.3904132247,
-0.6670264006,
-0.1052808911,
-0.3057082891,
-0.1586584747,
-1.4028074741,
-0.125937745,
-0.0428321101,
-0.5294838548,
-0.1032617912,
0.2433573455,
-0.7086591125,
-0.304356426,
-0.0794004276,
-0.057486061,
0.5095588565,
-0.2495774329,
0.3442398906,
0.320748806,
-0.17431584,
-0.2530990243,
-0.4591773152,
-0.0692299753,
-0.1950459629,
-0.5337632298,
0.3239326775,
-0.5193970203,
-0.3040164709,
-0.2396913767,
0.1187643632,
-0.0772570968,
0.0173411611,
0.2793783545,
-0.1194485351,
0.029096866,
0.2188351601,
-0.2279010564,
0.0983110741,
0.0496213585,
0.2402593344,
0.2835102677,
-0.4364654422,
0.0532736443,
-0.1630545259,
0.2317413539,
0.6368438005,
0.0624591522,
0.3712979555,
0.639514029,
0.1606190652,
-0.7238937616,
-0.4886077046,
0.054707896,
-0.3910007775,
0.4322676063,
-0.202943489,
-0.4525487721,
0.3747832179,
0.223589614,
0.0265855491,
0.4750480354,
0.637250185,
-0.4141801894,
0.8951997757,
0.6536322236,
0.1374360919,
0.8155469894,
-0.0744171962,
0.3361940384,
-0.3830858767,
-0.1403020769,
-0.4974919856,
-0.6203421354,
-0.9140131474,
0.0641259328,
0.1244461909,
0.2079301924,
0.4256035388,
0.3189121187,
-0.4739676714,
0.4275615513,
0.570754528,
-0.1386895627,
0.2670437992,
0.2347523272,
-0.1809795946,
-0.1506607831,
-0.31129691,
-0.5517330766,
0.8659462333,
0.3080869913,
0.8134027719,
0.4962887168,
0.714838624,
0.6147598028,
0.363060534,
-1.0188115835,
0.5552617908,
-0.2830016613,
-0.4764709175,
-0.2352759838,
-0.2592886984,
-0.7592705488,
0.0100882147,
-0.4701632857,
-0.2065993547,
0.1823515594,
-0.1718774587,
-0.1185693815,
0.0618642382,
-0.8487722278,
0.7575395107,
-0.2012317181,
-0.2453871369,
-0.045305863,
-0.2271226048,
0.0880128071,
-0.3599536121,
0.0403273143,
0.1025683805,
0.1552431285,
0.639839828,
-0.1178749353,
0.6808763742,
0.073374711,
-0.0391870886,
0.8002400994,
0.2627717257,
-0.0143185966,
0.1795144677,
-0.0611368269,
0.29197824,
-0.0443244539,
0.1232031882,
-0.8718987703,
0.6635788679,
-1.1481832266,
-0.6540178657,
-0.4806545675,
-0.5230051875,
-0.3415101171,
0.1732382476,
0.3300105333,
0.4002573192,
-0.0565591045,
0.6123023033,
0.5599347353,
-0.3502474427,
0.4958715141,
0.472566396,
-0.4082526267,
-0.6545847654,
1.0627557039,
0.5262444615,
0.1385384798,
0.1435428411,
0.5197412968,
-0.2998773754,
-0.6542589068,
-0.4568701386,
0.1905908734,
-0.4617883861,
0.4582553506,
-0.8925796151,
-0.4003026187,
-0.20934394,
-0.1114762798,
0.0005950454,
-0.4172465503,
-0.4601022601,
0.0194836669,
0.4689131677,
1.2775027752,
0.3362625539,
0.6418914795,
-0.4245333374,
0.2260145098,
0.0971628129,
0.7424357533,
0.195030719,
-0.4782286286,
-0.1188174561,
-0.8123292327,
-0.7007556558,
-0.9409110546,
0.4880618453,
-0.12669909,
0.3669440746,
0.7672893405,
0.0909096748,
0.0304816309,
-0.0987250656,
0.9781906605,
0.0719169974,
-0.5304487944,
0.2442548573,
-0.5334404111,
0.2459349036,
0.4174839556,
0.538382709,
-0.6295298934,
-0.3788306117,
-0.7291904688,
-0.6738156676,
0.192571491,
0.2977567017,
0.3968513608,
-0.2436643839,
0.1310368478,
0.4543510079,
0.6620738506,
-0.845338583,
-0.2267085314,
-0.281915307,
-0.0581251644,
-0.1962900907,
-0.5394796729,
0.4843249619,
0.0294340253,
0.595001936,
0.2070033699,
0.0608884543,
0.0652896091,
0.2900445163,
-0.0835070387,
0.4337131679,
0.4615351856,
0.4477596879,
-0.421223402,
-0.0933301449,
-0.5650318861,
-0.9634477496,
-0.1245603189,
-0.1566273272,
-0.6420921087,
0.2133931816,
0.1607601047,
0.4317031503,
-0.0597672947,
-0.3872110546,
0.4464776218,
-0.0547274128,
-0.257892251,
-0.3306775391,
0.2412203699,
0.0175583884,
0.0897063613,
0.2934637666,
0.3816120923,
0.2185006291,
-0.4829523861,
0.1254222244,
0.3984565437,
-0.3306479156,
-0.3917670548,
0.2589825094,
0.3523094654,
-0.4784867764,
0.3377245963,
-0.4078315794,
-0.4077216387,
0.6071646214,
0.4888682961,
0.9521124363,
0.441149652,
0.4979746044,
0.0399761312,
0.2136132121,
-0.0112596815,
0.5020803213,
0.0325837992,
-0.8640797138,
0.3196217716,
-0.6798279285,
-0.528906703,
-0.0678267628,
-0.3152323663,
0.3261087835,
-0.5671036243,
-0.6123741269,
0.0857204124,
0.2380605638,
-0.5976911187,
0.274769187,
0.1067026109,
0.5254355669,
-0.6225733161,
0.4848503768,
0.5174213648,
-0.738032639,
-0.4462336898,
0.1958694458,
0.1542455405,
-0.1053074896,
0.5674740076,
0.2707177103,
-0.0065375087,
0.0535101965,
-0.3445074558,
-0.8385770321,
0.7081876397,
-0.4458962679,
-0.6315859556,
0.3147496879,
-0.1546785533,
0.9363901019,
-0.5882766843,
0.1370013803,
0.0995584577,
0.2405176312,
0.2409239709,
-0.4412552118,
-0.6321216226,
-0.4394369721,
0.0310964454,
0.0573015362,
-0.7247666717,
0.5046871901,
-0.4287506938,
-0.2017418891,
0.13960585,
0.6387699246,
0.5789777637,
0.8698018193,
0.5018984079,
0.4140132964,
0.6600280404,
-0.0375383683,
1.2343028784,
-0.2342604697,
0.0910130665,
0.4974736273,
-0.2927414775,
1.0887498856,
0.422254473,
-0.0291391108,
0.7815807462,
0.5760273933,
-0.4734304845,
0.5124058127,
0.4770976901,
-0.2309639156,
0.0202701204,
-0.357819289,
-0.186652109,
0.170460403,
0.0006810023,
-0.845266223,
0.2902460992,
0.1278152615,
-0.2523225248,
0.094693467,
-0.2757015824,
0.7944483757,
0.1246833652,
-0.6504632235,
-0.0061526587,
-0.0197157785,
0.5906916261,
-0.457290709,
0.0618728437,
-0.099973321,
0.116714403,
-0.3098627925,
-1.3823430538,
0.0416145772,
0.1715159565,
-0.7843566537,
-0.452735275,
0.4928284883,
-0.033131592,
-0.5802057385,
0.24477835,
0.5751210451,
0.4165641963,
-0.1407840997,
-0.2962910831,
0.2009151131,
0.0384321436,
-0.583830297,
0.1265423596,
0.8771179914,
-0.047281649,
0.3308810294,
0.4759671986,
0.2062573433,
-0.0469421111,
0.5509390235,
0.4438550174,
-0.9278147817,
-0.7029380202,
-0.5019772649,
0.2678705156,
0.10733971,
-0.8308760524,
1.1354066133,
0.2324572802,
0.5415767431,
-0.3988130093,
0.8619815111,
-0.0206145905,
0.4092550278,
-0.1286349595,
1.3007022142,
-0.3983540237,
0.2411167324,
-0.6914947033,
-1.2820104361,
-0.3147696555,
0.2333288044,
-0.6510612369,
0.3758297265,
0.6590973735,
0.6122312546,
0.3616756797,
0.3194039464,
0.2729853392,
0.126905039,
0.0625987351,
0.1757797003,
1.0743836164,
-0.0362712815,
0.4805925488,
-0.1181864887,
-0.3236051798,
-0.2323542088,
-1.1133431196,
-1.0689454079,
-0.5765674114,
-0.5612505674,
-0.5666565299,
-0.4653080702,
0.5511157513,
0.1749775261,
-0.7599318624,
-0.0077495999,
0.0282915868,
0.3157657385,
-0.3969704509,
-0.3306429386,
0.2525132596,
-0.2335384488,
-0.5463950038,
-0.2432457507,
-0.0117349457,
0.1512367725,
-0.4062915742,
0.0786804259,
0.3872368336,
0.4897883236,
0.5686272979,
-0.019755058,
-0.9104486108,
0.1776478738,
0.2832651436,
-0.3091682196,
-0.2417406142,
0.8260512352,
-0.4859004021,
0.8639642,
0.8228353858,
0.5165002942,
-0.0906473175,
0.2555263937,
0.3564921319,
-0.4413412809,
-0.5576469898,
0.0017905836,
0.2110511214,
0.3194648921,
-0.6793938875,
0.2576056719,
0.9228017926,
-0.8031339049,
-0.2595999539,
-0.0163687877,
-1.0555872917,
0.0028891319,
1.3522428274,
0.3270721436,
-0.4000499845,
-0.1986788064,
-0.53523314,
-0.3348392844,
-0.4535953104,
1.0340816975,
1.1831715107,
-0.4774485826,
-0.1769317687,
-0.5350640416,
0.6276776195,
0.1552970707,
-0.3846957982,
0.0173002966,
0.4653406739,
0.4967864156,
0.4730867445,
0.1644974053,
-0.2201090157,
0.2824538648,
-0.1624999046,
0.3145834804,
0.0503161065,
-0.4105583131,
-0.270830363,
0.6465427279,
0.2782949209,
0.3398981392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06697v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06697v1
|
Trusted Source Alignment in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-12T00:25:25 | 2023-11-12T00:25:25 |
Vasilisa Bashlovkina, Zhaobin Kuang, Riley Matthews, Edward Clifford, Yennie Jun, William W. Cohen, Simon Baumgartner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are trained on web-scale corpora that inevitably
include contradictory factual information from sources of varying reliability.
In this paper, we propose measuring an LLM property called trusted source
alignment (TSA): the model's propensity to align with content produced by
trusted publishers in the face of uncertainty or controversy. We present
FactCheckQA, a TSA evaluation dataset based on a corpus of fact checking
articles. We describe a simple protocol for evaluating TSA and offer a detailed
analysis of design considerations including response extraction, claim
contextualization, and bias in prompt formulation. Applying the protocol to
PaLM-2, we find that as we scale up the model size, the model performance on
FactCheckQA improves from near-random to up to 80% balanced accuracy in
aligning with trusted sources.
|
[
-0.0860682502,
-0.4931255281,
0.769764781,
0.0667415485,
-0.4310398102,
0.2830220461,
-0.0493920892,
-0.6997560859,
0.0030257411,
0.3810814321,
-0.3971737325,
-0.2316714376,
-0.8471627235,
-0.1013995484,
-0.5398620367,
0.8925753832,
-0.21870552,
0.0158664696,
-0.0891908854,
-0.3083526194,
-0.3396541476,
-0.3485663831,
-0.4326311648,
-0.152348116,
0.4038861692,
0.390858978,
1.3361074924,
0.89156425,
0.690654695,
0.2559300363,
0.0733482018,
0.1904826313,
-0.5859009027,
0.1197949499,
-0.5542385578,
-0.3413771391,
-0.5108602643,
0.0795811415,
0.7484813333,
0.1596274972,
-0.0845606029,
0.5231627822,
-0.0316359401,
0.4000907838,
-0.6406848431,
-0.2155275792,
-0.6331915259,
-0.2590824664,
-0.2479562759,
-0.0829175264,
-0.467089504,
-0.6620780826,
0.297631681,
-0.5669238567,
-0.1462761313,
0.267886728,
1.2563564777,
0.2882474959,
-0.8602154255,
-0.2460497469,
-0.6594616175,
0.8199266195,
-0.7555248737,
0.6922296882,
0.1773310751,
0.1674229056,
-0.0487471782,
-0.4329581261,
-0.7925586104,
-0.2424393296,
0.0567773171,
-0.1038057879,
-0.1692951471,
-0.4302663207,
0.0815968066,
-0.0085840197,
-0.6131419539,
0.3247775733,
-0.1118815616,
-0.4498614967,
0.5041832328,
-0.1721572131,
0.4708156586,
-0.0663428679,
-0.6728891134,
-0.0600454137,
-0.7982067466,
-0.3009986877,
0.4830390215,
0.3033465445,
-0.3250230849,
0.8402819037,
0.1607009321,
0.7217258215,
0.1116044596,
-0.2829079032,
-0.0064563327,
-0.5407713056,
-0.2697720826,
0.2914234698,
0.6990880966,
0.4375038445,
0.1579726785,
-0.1679996848,
-0.1618626118,
-0.1119541675,
0.3978843987,
-0.6937379837,
0.1065211594,
0.4900578856,
-0.1450336874,
-0.3767838478,
0.1898489892,
-0.5736985207,
-0.588747561,
-0.4330289066,
0.3395550847,
-0.2644458711,
-0.3146225214,
-0.2012429982,
0.0144889578,
0.4633942544,
0.2925516665,
-0.5765098333,
0.0129788183,
0.8344653845,
0.8203650713,
-0.212642923,
-0.156125024,
-0.6973387599,
0.3960686028,
-0.5320289731,
0.6725541949,
-0.426066637,
0.1382700801,
0.1361961216,
-0.1972009689,
0.3021697998,
-0.1232299581,
0.8855387568,
-1.0220572948,
-0.0772040263,
-0.6210408807,
-0.6166428328,
0.0445603691,
0.3275934458,
-0.6729736924,
0.8740215898,
0.1686773151,
-0.8274726868,
0.4877231717,
-0.0507065654,
-0.0889744088,
-0.2174735218,
-0.0495065264,
-0.4421858788,
-0.2043510079,
0.1761584878,
0.1634595394,
-0.1733849496,
0.6050176024,
-0.6496677995,
-0.1500113755,
0.9299565554,
-0.3509069085,
0.9081005454,
0.4980854988,
-0.2797554731,
0.1851335764,
-0.5645330548,
0.1404508799,
-0.0700757578,
-0.2009802461,
-0.5032962561,
-0.1466837376,
0.1588027626,
0.3339182138,
0.5516495109,
-0.5234103799,
0.0290535819,
-0.0525119565,
0.2488001883,
0.8701362014,
-0.0962865502,
0.3284849823,
-0.2730852664,
0.2020531744,
0.0707345307,
0.1927589029,
0.617828548,
-0.1046021134,
-0.5999520421,
-0.210137859,
0.6257550716,
0.3138417006,
-0.3155735135,
0.6427879333,
-0.6594091654,
-0.5981034636,
-0.3615553081,
0.2800039351,
0.4332328737,
0.5130959749,
0.1218658686,
-0.1572347581,
-0.4349447489,
-1.0164340734,
-0.3677603304,
-0.253874898,
-0.0043505044,
-0.1475414336,
0.1295907199,
-0.1408244222,
0.9364618659,
-0.1806853414,
0.1062441394,
-0.0232541822,
0.1643039435,
-0.2707362175,
0.4592451453,
0.3803908825,
-0.5828561187,
-0.2833230197,
-0.0224242695,
-0.5883402228,
-0.2664044499,
-0.1514603347,
-0.3748196959,
0.3690339923,
0.3137510121,
-0.7177222967,
-0.1656878293,
0.9856804609,
-0.4921148419,
0.3780984581,
0.1729748547,
0.2416396886,
-1.3176558018,
0.167789042,
0.1460450739,
-0.5465445518,
-0.3358183205,
0.4240083098,
0.4093979597,
0.0386666358,
-0.4594582319,
0.4793114662,
-0.4708042443,
-0.4755462706,
-0.3085317314,
0.6019014716,
0.0605123639,
0.0546366796,
0.0762094706,
0.8981677294,
0.1118037626,
-0.4572243989,
0.1899689585,
0.3663733602,
-0.404881835,
0.6257923841,
-0.4957151711,
0.3031835854,
0.3049276173,
0.362178117,
-1.0421981812,
-0.1162386388,
0.0196917038,
-0.3258787096,
0.298805207,
0.0468980931,
-0.6007937789,
-0.0422179699,
-0.1900569946,
0.3764413595,
0.0492640808,
-0.7109260559,
0.588056922,
0.4589276314,
-0.1447584331,
-1.006944418,
-0.5576471686,
0.1541015059,
-0.0327475965,
-0.7294229269,
0.0427475125,
0.2230530679,
-0.4597920775,
0.0345941447,
-0.4892541766,
-0.237709254,
0.0794693977,
0.0619563796,
0.5721210241,
-0.2489406317,
0.0568474717,
-0.0550925583,
0.2880460322,
0.2021658421,
-0.0536070243,
0.3235616386,
-0.0862680003,
-0.3461588919,
-0.393640846,
-0.1180432439,
0.5302217007,
-0.1865961701,
0.7341372371,
0.4053154886,
-0.2949226797,
0.015335774,
-0.6901457906,
-0.0841563866,
-0.4463697672,
0.1257794946,
-0.1174691021,
-0.8040745854,
0.5243520141,
0.1476196945,
0.0473960191,
0.5443641543,
0.4231330752,
0.0559927076,
0.609469831,
0.552857995,
-0.1836952269,
0.1356363893,
0.3902259767,
0.3297804594,
-0.6010475755,
-0.1522148252,
-0.8027216792,
-0.2685270905,
-0.5579224229,
-0.4209510684,
0.0726229846,
-0.0615807064,
-0.551850915,
0.4980202615,
-0.0260268655,
0.4623519182,
0.5264051557,
0.2106623054,
0.6029347181,
-0.131281361,
0.0699587017,
0.1492622644,
-0.2794570029,
-0.7460156083,
1.0802993774,
0.640447855,
0.8106954098,
0.6812378168,
0.2509111464,
0.3433118761,
0.3961146176,
-0.7351770997,
0.3683781624,
0.2023572326,
-0.8329915404,
-0.4951420128,
-0.3453523517,
-0.3988749981,
-0.0757438317,
-0.3412115574,
-0.6034835577,
0.2002597749,
0.00772828,
-0.4735301137,
0.1576485336,
-0.7447062135,
0.7024580836,
-0.3603454232,
-0.4244033694,
-0.1421892941,
-0.6703100801,
0.7305394411,
-0.3639828265,
-0.0699037239,
0.0068866387,
-0.251850456,
0.7037971616,
-0.4110524356,
0.7616760135,
0.2365907878,
-0.5451224446,
0.3265147209,
0.3885261416,
0.8376474977,
0.0705143958,
0.0484418832,
0.3394549191,
0.2671668828,
-0.4744637311,
-0.4216222465,
0.8526877761,
-1.1207135916,
-0.5693455338,
-0.8451519608,
-0.5834802985,
-0.6995601058,
0.3676928282,
-0.0115323411,
0.1576118022,
-0.3358073831,
0.1170502752,
0.7712520957,
-0.0061423806,
0.1629697382,
0.8497197628,
-0.161491096,
-0.1817028522,
0.5557895303,
0.0980260819,
0.481605798,
0.4952888191,
0.0750434622,
-0.6885172725,
-0.4667672813,
-0.5970669389,
0.2203299701,
-0.6780925989,
-0.3877284229,
-0.4077502787,
-0.3861928284,
-0.4707936943,
0.0296922941,
-0.4174370766,
-0.4377869964,
-0.099406451,
-0.4832277894,
0.2448647022,
0.5636068583,
0.2082714289,
0.2778603435,
-0.8691820502,
0.1349495798,
0.2236841172,
0.4555875063,
-0.3029204905,
-0.8419327736,
-0.1198178008,
-0.0667879954,
-0.4068205655,
-0.8462998867,
-0.0597473532,
-0.2745280266,
0.2437171489,
0.5048513412,
0.1084058732,
0.4948627949,
-0.248494342,
0.8394885659,
0.1187610552,
-1.2438077927,
0.1855125427,
-0.3720046878,
0.1135495901,
0.4188774228,
0.3799217343,
-0.3137638569,
-0.5294571519,
-0.5483588576,
-0.2694448233,
0.2607913017,
0.1730937511,
-0.0056212512,
0.2791695595,
0.1927800477,
0.0755499601,
0.0264201742,
-0.6721958518,
0.0395781621,
-0.2093026638,
-0.3163105547,
0.0119080832,
-0.62976861,
-0.5753424168,
0.4006202221,
0.7973560691,
-0.05794283,
-0.0684626028,
0.1083420664,
-0.0491667837,
-0.5063993335,
0.5284646153,
0.9031440616,
1.192289114,
-0.280433327,
0.4562735558,
-0.2364623249,
-0.4178527892,
0.2731892169,
-0.0073774587,
-0.1986085325,
-0.1644497961,
0.374232918,
0.3188070655,
0.1506652832,
-0.6002169847,
0.521848917,
0.0783289671,
0.1149531901,
-0.1012200266,
-0.1432276964,
0.2298993021,
0.2414192259,
0.2110878229,
-0.0517637245,
-0.0151645634,
-0.4169420004,
0.4108690023,
0.5766011477,
-0.1247468665,
-0.1389850676,
0.5494425297,
0.2422755361,
0.0794382393,
0.656632483,
0.0152188791,
-0.3999456763,
0.5225856304,
0.5517883897,
0.7051630616,
-0.2814688385,
0.3679618835,
0.2981300354,
0.7479593158,
-0.1806080341,
0.127202183,
0.4248123169,
-0.9731252789,
-0.503041625,
-0.4815716147,
-0.6219085455,
0.2797020078,
-0.4983163178,
0.1800366938,
-0.3646453023,
-0.2294445634,
-0.1414823085,
0.190619722,
-0.5573076606,
0.3006755412,
-0.0057542734,
1.0562771559,
-0.865041256,
0.9974335432,
0.2513491809,
-0.2776065767,
-1.2857699394,
0.3626385927,
0.253511399,
-0.9457477331,
0.5123261213,
-0.2198815197,
-0.1711922735,
-0.471408844,
-0.5924518108,
-1.3078886271,
0.8828129172,
0.8412458897,
-0.82758075,
0.2766231894,
0.2386931479,
0.544952929,
-0.0773482993,
-0.0411832631,
0.3577216268,
0.5589634776,
0.1110481024,
-1.0129122734,
0.5489055514,
0.2568967938,
-0.0412452631,
0.1117691249,
-0.9152842164,
0.3492389023,
-0.236292541,
-0.2357771993,
0.084317334,
1.0516690016,
0.3548922539,
0.1777219176,
0.3901281655,
0.5880102515,
0.9704360366,
0.1048909426,
0.8773252964,
-0.2851657271,
0.2592797279,
1.401160121,
-0.4694371521,
1.0683224201,
0.7272009254,
-0.0112467036,
0.4179750979,
0.7443317771,
0.0621790104,
0.252096802,
-0.0381886847,
-0.0081097325,
-0.1720038056,
-0.2545040846,
-0.2815791368,
0.4256619811,
-0.020502409,
-0.4298341572,
-0.1508283019,
-0.5617008805,
0.158502087,
0.1303698421,
-0.2395128012,
0.4621920288,
0.0624372698,
-0.8538188338,
0.3824562132,
0.0773453787,
0.0601631328,
-0.5205712318,
0.295624584,
-0.1104881912,
-0.0821774527,
-0.2789584696,
-1.1208527088,
0.3369520307,
0.1602650583,
-0.0647409186,
0.1842575222,
0.454621464,
-0.4821418822,
-0.449090153,
0.0665976554,
0.3601651788,
-0.0654578283,
0.1112466082,
-0.5719703436,
0.6037451029,
-0.2716342807,
-0.1379284263,
0.4681599438,
0.3935710192,
-0.165139392,
0.6601221561,
0.5164591074,
-0.0004078739,
-0.028197594,
0.0410519689,
0.52091223,
-0.3092065454,
-0.3811609149,
-0.7766141891,
0.0684006885,
-0.2476744801,
-0.2307340056,
0.9785237908,
0.6536139846,
0.6254581809,
0.0996633247,
0.7174701095,
0.1435721219,
0.2787519395,
-0.6783539057,
0.5848629475,
-0.1278914064,
0.2284166962,
-0.0326331183,
-1.0046452284,
-0.0077772033,
0.2035143673,
-0.0813039169,
-0.060273882,
0.7957319617,
0.7699110508,
-0.3413206637,
0.0491489954,
0.0432646722,
0.3378716707,
0.3577298522,
0.1879625469,
0.5359863043,
-0.3408624232,
0.4944678545,
-0.0804516152,
-0.176498279,
0.0209202003,
-1.333311677,
-0.6168293953,
-0.4318605065,
-0.466612488,
-0.8167957664,
-0.0004982657,
0.8896307945,
0.6215661764,
-0.8057150841,
-0.0762104169,
0.1549100727,
0.2974725962,
-0.4411815107,
-0.2081397623,
0.5016279817,
-0.1372986436,
-0.6422952414,
0.1372612566,
0.0096200397,
0.0225421265,
-0.5333653092,
0.0018295553,
-0.1319850385,
0.4759569764,
0.2787499428,
0.2448727936,
-0.7846316099,
-0.7739557624,
-0.0739808157,
-0.6872196794,
-0.1155219823,
0.6888180375,
-0.0494209304,
0.2025042921,
0.3636201322,
0.9700295329,
0.0725077316,
0.3644407392,
0.7740611434,
-0.7081124783,
-0.2573008239,
-0.0821894333,
0.2950963378,
0.4282464385,
-0.6580278873,
0.3653528988,
-0.1938703358,
-0.7436169386,
-0.7656292319,
0.1312379986,
-1.675364852,
-0.077907756,
1.4636296034,
-0.0299693588,
-0.2713053524,
0.0847944692,
0.0230491739,
0.3311632276,
-0.5253836513,
1.028907299,
1.1712145805,
0.3480299711,
-0.0506814569,
-0.3929771781,
0.4817417562,
0.2145820856,
-0.7304382324,
0.2194424719,
0.6658093929,
0.6136364937,
0.2371146083,
0.4524586201,
-0.1012213826,
0.1608620435,
-0.2495145649,
-0.2390991598,
0.1032578498,
-0.2229491174,
-0.1190099269,
0.1244874075,
0.335165292,
0.016223181
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.