id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06696v1
|
Simple and Effective Input Reformulations for Translation
| 2023-11-12T00:23:37 | 2023-11-12T00:23:37 |
Brian Yu, Hansen Lillemark, Kurt Keutzer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Foundation language models learn from their finetuning input context in
different ways. In this paper, we reformulate inputs during finetuning for
challenging translation tasks, leveraging model strengths from pretraining in
novel ways to improve downstream performance. These reformulations are simple
data level modifications, require no additional collection of training data or
modification of data at inference time. They can be applied either on single
language pair translation tasks or massively multilingual translation tasks.
Experiments with these techniques demonstrate significant performance
improvements up to $\textbf{3.5 chrF++ on the Flores200 translation
benchmark}$. We hope our research accessibly improves finetuning data
efficiency, enabling more effective training to scalably improve
state-of-the-art performance. Our code is released
$\href{https://github.com/bri25yu/LanguageModelExperimentation}{here}.$
|
[
-0.2724860609,
-0.551948905,
0.401183486,
0.1291466802,
-0.2688756585,
-0.4445025921,
-0.611056149,
-0.2483901232,
-0.2726706266,
0.4761158824,
-0.6524284482,
-0.200986281,
-0.5947897434,
0.1962888241,
-0.5315713286,
1.2669112682,
-0.2373804897,
0.4803107083,
0.1892048866,
-0.174375087,
-0.3671268523,
-0.197606653,
-0.3822417855,
-0.4440941811,
0.4586052299,
0.6444839239,
0.4432121813,
0.6675512195,
0.6064360142,
0.3271776736,
-0.1360657215,
-0.0045190514,
-0.8710327148,
0.1167412847,
-0.1235982478,
-0.4470084608,
-0.2795057595,
-0.0273940992,
0.7876549363,
1.1020151377,
-0.2716435194,
0.0760740712,
0.3591866195,
0.5684945583,
-0.4858280122,
0.1708063185,
-0.6137176752,
-0.0860981494,
-0.4611055851,
-0.2272438407,
-0.6118694544,
-0.2606295049,
-0.1034902111,
-0.6434988379,
0.4797068536,
-0.3519301414,
0.9601944685,
0.3076486886,
-0.3111320436,
-0.0786558911,
-0.963708818,
0.7286682129,
-0.8271596432,
0.6940893531,
0.1480877399,
0.4942266345,
-0.2339259535,
-0.9702730179,
-0.1764097065,
-0.0290458668,
-0.2582065761,
-0.3074195087,
-0.1410107464,
0.2208409756,
0.2439642847,
0.7450111508,
-0.1997755021,
-0.106582664,
-0.5767325759,
-0.1921239048,
0.5577630401,
-0.0069256867,
0.1203955039,
0.1202976853,
-0.0058868658,
-0.4487554431,
-0.7881230116,
0.4247399271,
0.1759358048,
0.7537603974,
-0.146847412,
0.409717083,
-0.6721055508,
0.9294580817,
0.4458858371,
-0.1849538088,
0.2416350394,
-0.8885404468,
-0.3315027952,
-0.2472830415,
0.7807250023,
0.115887396,
0.2552100718,
-0.3477034569,
-0.6108240485,
-0.3344862759,
0.3235911131,
-1.1096760035,
-0.3939916492,
-0.0829214752,
-0.2606189549,
-0.4990552962,
0.1270529479,
-0.3788025081,
-0.1183613762,
-0.549983263,
0.4449417889,
-0.5851074457,
0.0859463066,
0.1735423058,
0.1061251014,
0.3828181028,
0.4994038939,
-1.0305622816,
0.414760977,
0.5581277013,
0.566557765,
-0.0320392624,
-0.2760594785,
-1.0065376759,
-0.2088349462,
-0.2728239,
0.5015720725,
-0.3018371761,
-0.2476743758,
-0.1527984887,
0.175032109,
-0.042350065,
-0.5252333879,
0.5927930474,
-0.4000784457,
-0.1119746044,
-0.2770512104,
-0.2696239054,
0.0054321373,
0.096832417,
-0.8821274042,
0.6086108088,
0.1511751264,
-0.3077609241,
0.3856811523,
-0.5737725496,
-0.7837090492,
-0.1759656668,
0.0583476536,
-0.28846398,
0.3831553757,
0.4146925211,
0.6391082406,
-0.1233927757,
0.3683919013,
-0.2022972554,
-0.4086255729,
0.1689225882,
-0.558457911,
0.7305455208,
0.3152004182,
-0.0771831125,
0.2780443132,
-0.8738710284,
0.0960278511,
-0.0142780468,
-0.6156719327,
0.0173383206,
-0.3822722733,
0.2957808971,
0.0631487146,
0.0209040344,
-0.5275917649,
0.3888717294,
-0.5358189344,
0.4514556825,
0.4829130769,
-0.1274404824,
0.7880111933,
-0.0846562833,
0.4978957772,
0.022875363,
-0.1893413812,
-0.1963507682,
0.0175846368,
-0.6419520378,
-0.3185312748,
0.8479272723,
0.2917754352,
-0.8281088471,
-0.0767451227,
-0.495410949,
-0.4783395231,
-0.7825467587,
0.6662726402,
0.4622047544,
0.482290417,
0.6712895036,
-0.1551900357,
-0.5656474233,
-0.6899374127,
-0.3262482584,
0.417804867,
0.0058058817,
-0.319219321,
0.2068628371,
-0.1664507687,
0.7242711186,
-0.4707249999,
-0.1733800918,
-0.619507432,
0.2365621626,
0.1843245625,
0.8639550209,
0.5007041693,
-0.7377895117,
-0.2863150239,
0.1246237084,
-0.3123991787,
-0.1979248971,
-0.199215427,
-0.1585481316,
-0.2120584249,
0.7740510702,
-0.5293108821,
0.2013761699,
0.5089960098,
-0.2886338532,
0.4346818626,
0.0479282215,
0.1866839975,
-1.0477199554,
0.108479403,
-0.1077275276,
-0.5711532235,
-0.8677110672,
0.4800654352,
0.1239887401,
-0.0524709187,
-0.7337065935,
0.3367803097,
-0.3555213213,
0.2368411273,
-0.0879227817,
-0.072160311,
0.0758232996,
0.3539231718,
-0.0599154942,
0.7269166112,
0.2396969199,
-0.6215493679,
0.1628621221,
-0.0003395355,
-0.4480539858,
0.3094454408,
-0.6927855015,
-0.1026291773,
-0.0279487018,
0.2536528111,
-1.1374433041,
-0.3886972964,
0.2243375182,
-0.2021889389,
0.6393681169,
-0.102278769,
-0.3363261223,
0.0263578594,
-0.1817978919,
0.5787945986,
0.2861514688,
-0.4688562155,
0.4148033857,
-0.0543489158,
-0.264705658,
-0.3458295465,
-0.9908156395,
-0.3215089738,
-0.0574494451,
-0.4089659154,
0.4845803678,
0.0172505211,
0.0245088544,
-0.1710401773,
-0.1549324542,
-0.2748169601,
0.3047608435,
-0.0719069988,
-0.1129917726,
-0.4741643667,
-0.1361638457,
0.3433564007,
-0.1232618839,
-0.259898454,
-0.0977211073,
0.6262699366,
-0.2396811247,
-0.1444557756,
-0.6654897332,
0.1814097762,
0.5477150679,
-0.519908309,
0.5180745721,
0.8555371165,
-0.5774015784,
-0.0579631701,
-0.3109233081,
-0.5112293959,
-0.4700878859,
0.4219435751,
-0.8044617772,
-0.7547037601,
0.2887249291,
-0.0690295398,
0.2904219031,
0.4117871523,
0.4098359942,
-0.2259470969,
0.9219099879,
0.730784297,
0.2844159007,
0.6120650768,
-0.4386467934,
0.1991995424,
-0.7356953621,
0.0400608368,
-0.4577889442,
-0.4814381301,
-0.4983072877,
-0.4292417765,
-0.0851067379,
0.7644081116,
0.2257147282,
0.7316643,
-0.0502818935,
0.4399737418,
0.3633813262,
0.1081495062,
0.4728555977,
0.0086508701,
-0.1882885545,
-0.2498771399,
-0.8567931056,
-0.3654845655,
1.2532972097,
0.2636376619,
0.7666343451,
0.1161319315,
0.9157248139,
-0.2355290204,
0.7314305305,
-0.8506330848,
0.2049526572,
-0.3023395836,
-0.3784421682,
-0.4222452044,
-0.5491816998,
-0.7873985171,
0.2253338844,
-0.3132008612,
-0.4879390895,
0.305197686,
0.4438945055,
-0.6235824227,
-0.0352799557,
-0.8204283118,
1.1050329208,
0.0059546744,
-0.2554163337,
-0.1420772374,
-0.3384290934,
0.3442686498,
-0.1097605452,
0.223851651,
0.259000659,
0.4644589126,
0.4314803779,
-0.6897029281,
0.6779711843,
-0.0639051348,
-0.1314911991,
-0.0783433914,
0.0933102071,
0.3333705068,
0.0382280685,
-0.0577458777,
-0.1031730846,
0.2105513364,
-0.4270116091,
-0.7430635095,
0.6678811908,
-0.5231225491,
-0.4150748253,
0.067012094,
-0.7063800693,
-0.3288954794,
0.4908385873,
0.4711385965,
0.5813164711,
-0.3443382978,
0.8188640475,
0.498652786,
0.4006155431,
0.3386422396,
0.3597067595,
-0.229710415,
-0.2930697203,
0.8885607719,
0.1214794368,
0.4768692553,
0.504997313,
0.1518629342,
-0.2412744015,
-0.6060193181,
-0.8112596869,
0.0691136643,
-0.5977451205,
-0.4310103655,
-0.5146201849,
-0.0303167682,
-0.5670239329,
-0.1811358184,
-0.735093832,
-0.5814803839,
-0.0505930483,
-0.1507134587,
0.0176064894,
0.5812531114,
-0.0242406875,
0.6757550836,
-0.8456902504,
0.3871163726,
0.3339868784,
0.2992823124,
-0.1678849161,
-0.5290170312,
-0.4012338221,
0.416459471,
-0.3175044358,
-0.807697475,
0.0031180598,
0.3765966296,
0.3802741468,
0.446815908,
-0.0471941531,
0.9486501217,
-0.6667938232,
0.4410704672,
0.0543808006,
-1.1871050596,
0.2711507976,
-0.2109228373,
0.5612794161,
1.109531045,
0.0608297139,
-0.3702084422,
-0.1614774615,
-0.2857362032,
-0.7025454044,
0.7646105886,
0.2417093217,
0.0358994044,
0.5256729722,
0.4389092326,
0.134211123,
0.2875302136,
-0.7311735153,
0.0242349561,
-0.0432064049,
-0.4744223058,
-0.2844364345,
0.0860184282,
-0.168969214,
-0.5565381646,
0.4455337226,
-0.0735129863,
-0.1403778046,
-0.0662811697,
-0.4444309175,
-0.2035872638,
0.3667488396,
0.7104936242,
0.5320202708,
0.0451674461,
0.0391063578,
0.2468841821,
-0.4319662452,
0.3240021467,
0.461779654,
-0.4623235166,
-0.0053562676,
0.4768968821,
0.9258158207,
0.7551347613,
-0.3974122405,
0.4656752646,
-0.0927501917,
-0.1885132492,
0.1914361715,
0.2315722108,
0.0897909775,
0.0442508422,
0.1400785893,
0.4939821362,
0.3575624526,
-0.4337613583,
0.2876373231,
0.1259737015,
-0.5328808427,
-0.3375901282,
0.5870651007,
0.326182723,
-0.0744405538,
0.334376812,
-0.3356897831,
-0.2611017525,
0.1718445271,
0.5666408539,
0.6103922725,
-0.4677252173,
0.1498684585,
0.3747962117,
0.2168902159,
-0.3416623473,
-0.0224656053,
-0.224880144,
-0.7359028459,
-0.6519036293,
-0.7502447367,
0.067958504,
0.2292566746,
-0.9112495184,
0.4815914035,
-0.2072473615,
0.134961769,
-0.1020225435,
-0.1334910393,
-1.0738133192,
0.3044780195,
0.0588533729,
0.9646624923,
-0.8646594882,
1.0214313269,
0.8504551053,
-0.3969481885,
-0.9130702019,
0.0130904187,
-0.0772467703,
-0.2742619514,
0.3186258376,
0.2135628015,
-0.2797960639,
0.2372099161,
-0.4729498327,
-0.8601818681,
0.8599436283,
0.6271392107,
-0.6974387169,
-0.2814020216,
0.2011436969,
0.4080576897,
-0.3648356199,
-0.0959723517,
0.8522664905,
0.4891893864,
-0.1435266882,
-0.8654611707,
0.0600945801,
-0.3375760019,
0.1138248369,
0.169501096,
-0.1848495305,
0.7709969878,
-0.2021115273,
-0.3022527397,
0.2776415944,
0.7839355469,
0.097191751,
-0.0502808802,
0.5053446293,
0.5575578809,
0.6203863025,
-0.5277093053,
1.128626585,
-0.3328144252,
0.3044812083,
1.2700442076,
0.3489635289,
0.9520794749,
0.7847287655,
0.0209015142,
0.2044608593,
0.4326224923,
0.2122286409,
0.7929576635,
0.1397979558,
0.2039969563,
-0.3539350033,
0.0589456074,
-0.4535609484,
0.5731491446,
0.2718187273,
-0.1644366831,
-0.3866146207,
0.2415536642,
0.177594468,
0.2392175198,
-0.1299609393,
0.5507148504,
0.1473384947,
-0.6293017864,
0.747071147,
0.4867922366,
0.6505730748,
-0.6856059432,
-0.1370778233,
-0.307038337,
0.4389737844,
-0.1951871216,
-0.4617928267,
0.3265561163,
-0.0509034991,
-0.2028647065,
-0.6211376786,
0.3323733509,
-0.9329819679,
-0.5198178291,
-0.063428171,
0.3102245033,
-0.1893353611,
-0.0852389708,
-0.3958761096,
0.3202689588,
0.2312848717,
-0.3368035257,
-0.0006818537,
0.3607500792,
0.0370567292,
0.3951421976,
0.7453607917,
0.2468068153,
0.1060697883,
0.1366543323,
0.7786352634,
-0.4581015408,
-0.4596412182,
-0.686822176,
0.8360011578,
0.0696680993,
-0.6437571049,
0.4473377764,
0.3498198688,
1.3090851307,
-0.3366129398,
0.3620543778,
0.0438522361,
0.3006149232,
-0.6681850553,
0.8903955221,
-0.5346742272,
0.0618510842,
-0.3957315087,
-0.9325460792,
-0.3445942402,
0.5815458894,
-0.4442628622,
-0.0277319476,
0.6520144939,
0.6306439638,
-0.4473872483,
-0.1173901558,
0.1803538799,
0.2141323537,
0.3877305388,
0.4697795808,
0.3080919087,
-0.8266166449,
0.5852057338,
-0.6869674325,
-0.0339892358,
-0.425529182,
-0.6590278745,
-0.4452671707,
-0.5508999825,
-0.156397,
-0.1638589799,
0.0055832267,
0.9482736588,
0.9956819415,
-1.2209198475,
-0.3078772128,
-0.3042731285,
-0.0478659794,
-0.4629369974,
-0.2335288525,
-0.0895578563,
-0.562122941,
-0.8826509118,
0.6405472159,
-0.290151,
0.0949882641,
-0.1638945341,
-0.296076417,
-0.1496810168,
-0.2173455209,
0.5397631526,
0.2425385714,
-0.6891965866,
-0.073870942,
-0.0249840971,
-0.3483929336,
-0.0129965441,
0.9015858173,
-0.5778957009,
0.4605963528,
0.5801684856,
0.9769952893,
0.5304811597,
0.2282355875,
1.1239355803,
-0.8729568124,
0.4291562736,
0.0191939324,
0.3785898685,
0.6307519674,
-0.2200405151,
0.3922982216,
0.0751417726,
0.0199927948,
-1.0238822699,
0.2569312155,
-0.6593982577,
0.0466910489,
0.8212578893,
-0.251645565,
-0.0661469325,
0.4175661802,
-0.1816558987,
0.4279117584,
-0.289124161,
0.343400389,
0.9237436056,
0.1690234691,
-0.1408454925,
-0.3980669975,
0.7293976545,
0.716136694,
-0.5574056506,
-0.1155679524,
0.4184070528,
0.3814362586,
0.0897563323,
0.4686719775,
-0.2618809044,
0.4516575336,
-0.2437322885,
-0.051277563,
-0.0862016082,
-0.5574899316,
-0.6554295421,
0.0599030778,
0.2030132115,
-0.1257151961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06694v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06694v3
|
Which One? Leveraging Context Between Objects and Multiple Views for Language Grounding
| 2023-11-12T00:21:58 | 2024-04-06T22:14:25 |
Chancharik Mitra, Abrar Anwar, Rodolfo Corona, Dan Klein, Trevor Darrell, Jesse Thomason
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.RO
|
When connecting objects and their language referents in an embodied 3D
environment, it is important to note that: (1) an object can be better
characterized by leveraging comparative information between itself and other
objects, and (2) an object's appearance can vary with camera position. As such,
we present the Multi-view Approach to Grounding in Context (MAGiC), which
selects an object referent based on language that distinguishes between two
similar objects. By pragmatically reasoning over both objects and across
multiple views of those objects, MAGiC improves over the state-of-the-art model
on the SNARE object reference task with a relative error reduction of 12.9\%
(representing an absolute improvement of 2.7\%). Ablation studies show that
reasoning jointly over object referent candidates and multiple views of each
object both contribute to improved accuracy. Code:
https://github.com/rcorona/magic_snare/
|
[
-0.3199239969,
-0.6910993457,
0.5567024946,
0.1767936796,
-0.2111012489,
-0.1652243137,
-0.1103154644,
-0.479701221,
0.3113855422,
0.607082963,
-0.1828631461,
-0.4167591035,
-0.5880107284,
0.0312664136,
-0.1964748353,
0.7659625411,
0.0745689645,
0.1087881252,
-0.5488458276,
-0.3781810403,
-0.7279779911,
-0.541803658,
-0.3371894658,
-0.2784086168,
0.488937974,
0.6419281363,
0.7745589614,
0.6744644046,
0.7391868234,
0.3671787381,
0.052609738,
0.3541041315,
-0.1557693481,
0.1241312325,
-0.4436357915,
-0.5561208129,
-0.1979496628,
0.085662879,
0.506313622,
0.6474372745,
0.0107619213,
0.0598494075,
-0.1263275445,
0.711910665,
-0.9999768734,
0.0964749083,
-0.6385627985,
0.1146625653,
-0.1590084881,
-0.5083897114,
-0.1496472508,
0.0243796986,
0.0964525789,
-0.7310211062,
0.2452221513,
0.1128823459,
0.701489985,
0.4347107112,
-0.4772121608,
0.0345837362,
-0.4858261645,
0.7046781182,
-0.3495495021,
0.5834393501,
0.7057049274,
0.5417914987,
0.1547338516,
-0.5982508659,
-0.6232124567,
-0.2731386721,
-0.0937744901,
0.4228061438,
0.3980291784,
-0.0367313512,
0.4575967491,
0.3535018563,
-0.2054268867,
-0.5697552562,
-0.531139195,
0.0256049372,
0.4992483258,
-0.3059663773,
0.4305967093,
-0.0527394377,
-0.3103697002,
-0.1184396297,
-0.745524168,
-0.2165504098,
0.4846417904,
0.2247519493,
-0.0234643016,
0.6853055954,
-0.0914698094,
1.1011486053,
0.12578471,
-0.6052009463,
0.0875001997,
-0.1469383836,
-0.2143699825,
0.1754961759,
0.2192334831,
0.9758657217,
0.2024767846,
-0.2586497068,
0.3027276099,
0.19646357,
0.8287220597,
-0.6587795615,
-0.2867697775,
0.1465888768,
-0.5311657786,
-0.0582956783,
0.2321353257,
-0.49304533,
-0.8443331122,
-0.3939041197,
0.3534933031,
-0.3891379237,
-0.6053723693,
0.3062969148,
-0.2292902619,
0.0863290429,
0.5348348618,
-0.8169192076,
0.3417131603,
0.7023918033,
0.7896813154,
-0.1613028646,
-0.6264544129,
-0.4079343975,
0.4866153896,
-0.3774270415,
1.2012386322,
-0.6518608332,
-0.4017783999,
-0.0808545649,
-0.0593704693,
-0.0962250009,
-0.5898118019,
0.3192679882,
-0.3097600639,
0.2096792758,
-0.2643568814,
-0.4249113202,
-0.4904540181,
0.4658771455,
-0.7630400062,
0.7956838608,
0.0793085471,
-0.9303386211,
0.624909997,
-0.5506315827,
-0.3658189178,
-0.2993916273,
-0.4899233282,
-0.3043504953,
0.2115058899,
0.040148478,
0.1398790777,
-0.1837359518,
0.0856525302,
-0.386105746,
-0.4141724706,
0.0179259479,
-0.1023199558,
0.3398942053,
0.1972586513,
-0.1263149977,
0.1764534563,
-0.8263198733,
-0.187931776,
0.047973562,
-0.2788891792,
-0.4565305412,
0.3577826321,
-0.0556722283,
0.2595491111,
-0.0414762869,
-0.1997742504,
0.5271042585,
-0.4244262576,
-0.1140749305,
0.2142494619,
-0.059161,
0.8140143156,
-0.423461169,
0.3263199627,
0.0458980054,
-0.0775755122,
-0.4833144546,
-0.6159111857,
-0.6690146327,
-0.0067320233,
-0.0384737886,
0.5177099109,
-0.7186162472,
0.20060049,
-0.2012924105,
-0.2756825089,
-0.4104099572,
0.1296009868,
0.5861802101,
0.6641141772,
0.4873109758,
-0.2866590917,
-0.5017434359,
-0.9777708054,
-0.4233096242,
-0.1739736944,
-0.058823932,
0.245159626,
0.28422153,
0.2049910277,
1.1146477461,
-0.4965107143,
-0.4800368547,
-0.049407836,
-0.2707202733,
0.1952455044,
0.5930147171,
0.7907161713,
-1.2096489668,
-0.4807606041,
0.3328798115,
-0.8986518383,
-0.1125492007,
-0.1112591401,
-0.4250088334,
-0.0376177095,
0.4331900775,
-0.2575155497,
0.7597244382,
0.4993084371,
-0.4131657183,
0.5341532826,
-0.1485033631,
0.5181068778,
-1.0288051367,
0.0683344528,
-0.0777138248,
0.0206953436,
-0.7876639962,
0.2077328712,
0.1723746955,
0.1324952096,
-0.7286091447,
0.5333198309,
-0.6030719876,
-0.1554565579,
-0.610899806,
0.2856926918,
0.2245680541,
0.4949038625,
0.4236433208,
0.9318342209,
0.8961009383,
-0.7374680638,
0.4888885617,
0.107123144,
-0.2433896661,
0.9645374417,
-0.3460746706,
0.3508256674,
-0.117778182,
0.1403747201,
-0.9325841069,
-0.2276442647,
0.3550565243,
-0.4918537736,
0.2007668465,
-0.480507195,
-0.3965744972,
-0.2273137569,
-0.1547668129,
0.5236494541,
-0.050362546,
-0.5155064464,
0.8383563757,
0.5421577692,
0.3297093809,
-0.6695114374,
-0.7470107079,
0.0534354821,
-0.5388300419,
-0.721591115,
0.4307323396,
-0.1700033396,
-0.6352496147,
-0.2328282595,
-0.8031406403,
-0.1729817986,
0.0548337139,
0.3135825396,
-0.0668042451,
-0.0821306705,
0.0979284421,
-0.0509031974,
-0.4172615111,
-0.0484875925,
-0.3497267962,
0.2445814759,
-0.0853592381,
-0.8128564954,
-0.3300117552,
0.4856874049,
0.5271241665,
0.130342558,
0.7411394715,
0.0552987456,
-0.5042449236,
0.1368525028,
-0.8643303514,
-0.0784600899,
-0.4826866984,
0.0333460234,
-0.972248137,
-0.1953801066,
0.5844438672,
0.0002173553,
-0.0873846412,
-0.0139852352,
0.3473085165,
0.2804710865,
1.0603493452,
0.6295285821,
0.0950386003,
0.6098212004,
-0.3267665505,
0.3512400687,
-0.8593563437,
-0.3484278023,
-0.5299921036,
-0.0237923507,
-0.159080565,
-0.6493867636,
0.1827566922,
0.6877669692,
0.0478348732,
0.4819238186,
-0.6808212399,
0.7755881548,
0.6622285247,
0.2263719738,
0.4921619296,
0.0639661998,
-0.3937532604,
-0.0374523252,
-0.5467315316,
-0.6728502512,
0.8043949008,
-0.0038202673,
0.5760990977,
0.3040291965,
0.4277019203,
-0.3258163631,
0.564586401,
-0.7922942042,
0.3784774244,
0.0817347765,
-0.7243666053,
-0.0163286086,
0.1776232123,
-0.7542240024,
0.916464448,
-0.2486475259,
-0.8309254646,
-0.0909125507,
0.1404704154,
-0.2111778557,
0.3851096034,
-0.8496996164,
0.7909463048,
-0.130784139,
-0.7688087821,
-0.1616932005,
-0.7230333686,
0.2300182879,
0.0993572026,
0.4122612476,
-0.0287616737,
0.144271329,
0.496309489,
-0.3000977039,
0.653529346,
-0.1484482735,
-0.4778577089,
0.3383089602,
0.2619493902,
0.0833141804,
0.3331370354,
-0.1785963923,
0.2021357864,
-0.087319456,
-0.1943746507,
-1.0075644255,
0.6210746169,
-0.4755652547,
-0.960513413,
-0.3689261675,
-0.4683627486,
-0.2894744277,
0.3468881845,
0.1569514722,
0.4337481856,
0.2019369751,
0.2695106566,
0.3995367885,
-0.1013687551,
0.3367879987,
0.6825175881,
-0.4669621587,
-0.358725071,
0.5998368263,
0.0271787625,
0.1459655911,
0.6221962571,
0.287864089,
-0.3001415133,
-0.3001639247,
-0.5750944614,
0.1259715855,
-1.0001527071,
-0.3340868652,
-0.6739684343,
-0.0551518537,
-0.4761966169,
-0.5118865371,
-0.4736561775,
-0.181410253,
0.063329719,
-0.2802900076,
0.2997154891,
0.4091553688,
-0.0030000522,
0.379715085,
-0.7153933644,
0.7064194083,
0.4898612499,
0.4125026166,
-0.2214393616,
-0.2625610232,
-0.1241853312,
0.1563505679,
-0.2882650495,
-1.1804440022,
0.196032241,
0.0767533779,
0.8791325688,
0.6778692007,
-0.1554943025,
1.2153474092,
-0.7579889297,
0.701559186,
0.4953300655,
-0.989079833,
0.9283494949,
-0.2557740808,
0.2393009216,
0.5326828957,
-0.065737091,
-0.7383630872,
-0.5434917808,
-0.5731047988,
-0.6581690311,
0.7703794241,
0.3046657443,
0.0657566264,
-0.0520190559,
0.2317957282,
0.1467245072,
0.2392286509,
-0.6728591323,
-0.583535552,
-0.4356337786,
0.3234832585,
-0.093693994,
-0.0010233661,
-0.5548313856,
-0.2845490575,
0.0203316137,
-0.4331302345,
0.4072966576,
0.1145312339,
-0.3420640528,
-0.0898730904,
-0.1952571273,
0.7292397022,
0.9716720581,
-0.0055216718,
0.6338882446,
0.4512548149,
-0.717463553,
-0.12061508,
-0.4020174444,
0.1846527159,
-0.0399936922,
0.464992851,
0.8148261905,
0.3687602282,
-0.2909375131,
0.5524635911,
0.1674020737,
-0.265540719,
-0.1456977427,
0.2785119414,
0.0013618219,
0.17024979,
0.4324998856,
0.3132275045,
0.2575151324,
-0.4461933076,
0.1783460528,
0.2123762667,
-0.150562942,
-0.1675279588,
0.6586465836,
0.1558587551,
-0.490809083,
0.2249321789,
0.0789332315,
-0.527669251,
0.7847896814,
0.8364323974,
0.7234053612,
-0.2679507136,
-0.0506614447,
0.3784283698,
0.0183674917,
-0.2332152277,
0.1809762269,
-0.3525736928,
-1.0945128202,
-0.4510158598,
-0.2893327773,
-0.5186632872,
-0.1761460453,
-0.6952859759,
0.435333401,
-0.1112188548,
0.1526759565,
-0.2291806638,
0.0591329001,
-0.4516835511,
0.3426155746,
0.2557375133,
0.8692738414,
-0.8402981162,
1.0930323601,
1.0838443041,
-0.4951658249,
-0.638217628,
0.1258617342,
0.1854566485,
-0.6326271296,
0.6377471685,
0.4443508387,
-0.7105771899,
-0.1819160134,
-0.5772451162,
-1.148213625,
0.9196910858,
0.1952963173,
-0.1545674801,
0.3532996476,
-0.3148801923,
0.4080028236,
-0.4253047109,
0.4713098407,
0.5407806039,
0.6752799153,
0.291100055,
-1.1369185448,
-0.2067847848,
-0.5199517012,
0.1837451905,
-0.0120049454,
-0.6109297276,
0.4196947813,
-0.1242946312,
-0.4875498116,
-0.2312224805,
0.7343295217,
0.7956318855,
0.4664903581,
0.563262105,
0.4856806099,
0.6438661218,
0.0281070955,
0.9636832476,
-0.6747817993,
0.3226074874,
0.9771000743,
-0.5148724914,
0.534155488,
0.7429563999,
-0.198193267,
0.3324011266,
0.3266089559,
0.3122988045,
0.7988234162,
0.3651372492,
-0.2943461537,
-0.0924489945,
0.2347991019,
-0.6022232175,
0.5561156273,
0.4288470149,
0.1862856597,
-0.2149642706,
0.4550372064,
0.0730705336,
0.2867323458,
-0.224709928,
0.735337019,
-0.1452797651,
-0.9620698094,
0.3481584787,
-0.1270719022,
0.6896971464,
-0.4237106442,
-0.3659082353,
-0.252061218,
0.1084141508,
-0.3573866487,
-0.6577778459,
0.5579398274,
-0.2908685505,
-0.2166467756,
-0.5345953107,
1.0247585773,
-0.4529311955,
-0.1694613248,
0.2955202162,
0.403921932,
0.4458881319,
-0.1177126989,
-0.6458370686,
0.0798896253,
-0.4003142118,
-0.297220856,
0.1293827444,
0.3710548282,
-0.1615136713,
0.8260402083,
0.6258589029,
0.0908316523,
0.0957502499,
0.4049983621,
0.8195976019,
-0.6492162943,
-0.6352122426,
-0.6532254815,
0.6497943997,
-0.3029790819,
-0.2872133255,
1.1211218834,
0.6954972744,
0.9277546406,
-0.3222815394,
0.53608495,
-0.2564920783,
0.4902582467,
-0.7206605673,
0.4776214957,
-0.6913233399,
0.1606485397,
-0.4111656249,
-1.2029238939,
-0.895698607,
1.6012523174,
-0.2964136302,
0.0981531441,
1.2224913836,
0.8835961819,
-0.2228885889,
-0.25111866,
0.6433908343,
-0.252025187,
0.1337352395,
0.0902364478,
0.9728579521,
-0.4520289004,
0.2619176507,
-0.4027970135,
-0.0715987682,
-0.392711252,
-1.0877020359,
-0.7084112167,
-0.5362070799,
-0.5705784559,
-0.4751669168,
-0.0437664278,
0.5929603577,
1.2079001665,
-0.7253627777,
-0.298591882,
-0.2338265926,
0.4071825743,
-0.5700954795,
-0.2019636184,
0.2215638608,
-0.2820987105,
-1.1031194925,
0.6383236051,
0.4727779925,
-0.1657817811,
-0.1355124563,
0.0784507468,
-0.1691232622,
-0.1993584037,
0.6054255962,
0.1653918028,
-0.8615242839,
-0.6828470826,
-0.0416445285,
-0.0795314834,
0.1356384456,
1.0427718163,
-0.8575758934,
0.658564508,
0.4614960849,
0.1419589967,
0.5294721723,
0.182930544,
0.4700833857,
-0.7384446859,
0.4861592054,
-0.1057988182,
0.3597106338,
0.2016107142,
-0.3269505799,
0.805547297,
0.3078202307,
-0.4469332397,
-0.6159251332,
0.354580909,
-1.0446118116,
-0.4785999656,
1.4894628525,
-0.0046281642,
-0.2095730752,
-0.350530386,
-0.7729244232,
0.2251627594,
0.0174399856,
0.7922011018,
0.8781169057,
-0.0966651067,
-0.2931744158,
-0.6882178187,
0.4523865283,
0.2712667882,
-0.7643193007,
-0.2947445512,
0.5371787548,
0.3958647549,
0.651661396,
0.7469158173,
0.0809002444,
0.2318684906,
0.3254155219,
0.1448810548,
-0.0312413406,
-0.8567848802,
-0.1645161211,
0.3352667689,
-0.2990733087,
-0.4916368425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06668v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06668v3
|
In-context Vectors: Making In Context Learning More Effective and Controllable Through Latent Space Steering
| 2023-11-11T21:19:44 | 2024-02-13T22:37:39 |
Sheng Liu, Haotian Ye, Lei Xing, James Zou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate emergent in-context learning
capabilities, where they adapt to new tasks based on example demonstrations.
However, in-context learning has seen limited effectiveness in many settings,
is difficult to quantitatively control and takes up context window space. To
overcome these limitations, we propose an alternative approach that recasts
in-context learning as in-context vectors (ICV). Using ICV has two steps. We
first use a forward pass on demonstration examples to create the in-context
vector from the latent embedding of the LLM. This vector captures essential
information about the intended task. On a new query, instead of adding
demonstrations to the prompt, we shift the latent states of the LLM using the
ICV. The ICV approach has several benefits: 1) it enables the LLM to more
effectively follow the demonstration examples; 2) it's easy to control by
adjusting the magnitude of the ICV; 3) it reduces the length of the prompt by
removing the in-context demonstrations; 4) ICV is computationally much more
efficient than fine-tuning. We demonstrate that ICV achieves better performance
compared to standard in-context learning and fine-tuning on diverse tasks
including safety, style transfer, role-playing and formatting. Moreover, we
show that we can flexibly teach LLM to simultaneously follow different types of
instructions by simple vector arithmetics on the corresponding ICVs.
|
[
-0.2922365963,
-0.6939332485,
0.3312929273,
0.2637171745,
-0.3583022952,
0.1908105463,
-0.4826927781,
0.0473123677,
-0.2913906872,
0.05563014,
-0.3005642891,
-0.4066176713,
-0.3718781769,
-0.3104889095,
-0.3466715515,
0.7807260752,
-0.2695539594,
0.0303905103,
-0.5726472139,
-0.120237194,
-0.5532038808,
-0.5349444747,
-0.6229577661,
-0.3543401659,
0.4819759429,
0.9417878985,
0.2450205684,
0.5337907076,
0.0318037421,
0.2425290346,
-0.0852257609,
0.1826625764,
-0.6502791047,
0.051639244,
-0.1848225445,
-0.3296229243,
-0.1956540048,
0.0825137645,
0.8127201796,
0.7869254351,
-0.0414942987,
-0.2747735977,
0.4990504682,
0.376654923,
-0.5572766066,
0.0726149231,
-0.5100793242,
-0.0599738136,
-0.0654324889,
-0.4913488328,
-0.4969048798,
-0.0017649072,
0.3075922132,
-0.6638361812,
-0.219217971,
-0.0060511539,
0.3875209987,
0.3093806505,
-0.5401917696,
-0.2675956488,
-0.8793135285,
0.9179487824,
-0.3669784665,
0.5533933043,
0.1122629568,
0.2844502032,
-0.4458108842,
-0.7105172276,
-0.5422590375,
-0.2473418266,
0.0739737153,
-0.0029214537,
-0.0790694654,
-0.175047487,
0.2176939845,
-0.1537132859,
-0.2309718132,
0.3494634926,
-0.1887159497,
-0.1477487236,
0.1916670799,
0.0866332054,
0.3221330643,
0.1174699441,
-0.6826342344,
-0.2457965463,
-1.2216880322,
0.5787228942,
-0.0093473354,
0.3193902075,
-0.2693004906,
0.4808428884,
0.0043369769,
0.660025537,
0.2195498347,
-0.4133068621,
0.0751958787,
-0.0482202433,
-0.1601702571,
0.1609033942,
0.2527919114,
0.2903390229,
-0.2718035877,
-0.1669833213,
-0.0800231397,
-0.1714620441,
0.216866523,
-0.8309634924,
0.0861978531,
-0.033165697,
-0.3543000519,
-0.0717043579,
0.0239074193,
-0.4436759055,
-0.0351687111,
-0.739087522,
0.4593128264,
-0.6803901792,
0.0472314283,
-0.1543020159,
0.0362923704,
0.6975385547,
0.6202571988,
-0.7389875054,
0.3520790339,
0.9153168201,
0.8140802383,
-0.5548523664,
-0.1667144448,
-0.9535444975,
0.3387382627,
-0.3879470825,
0.4234444201,
-0.7739332914,
-0.4573276937,
-0.0266122092,
-0.0823275745,
0.0963815004,
-0.4697844982,
0.0458984338,
-0.4393928647,
0.22251679,
-0.2437618077,
-0.6953126788,
-0.1896309257,
0.2532764077,
-0.1110993177,
0.9202935696,
0.1677354425,
-0.57929492,
0.4876082242,
-0.4818713069,
-0.5709149241,
0.0164872129,
-0.4876171052,
-0.1289710999,
-0.0578652956,
0.24523516,
0.8290928602,
0.1452691257,
0.1047794223,
0.0077059814,
-0.6575832963,
0.1616680026,
-0.4024660587,
0.542568624,
-0.0087429471,
-0.5267086029,
0.3867680132,
-0.6799714565,
-0.3292094171,
-0.360824883,
-0.6148800254,
-0.8077194095,
0.2505883574,
-0.0678244978,
0.3055123687,
-0.1437633485,
-0.4526097775,
0.2887616158,
-0.640610218,
0.4832410216,
0.6649540663,
-0.0766120255,
1.0428837538,
-0.2333623916,
0.5938920379,
0.0481446534,
-0.0815443099,
-0.1950770468,
-0.1853244901,
-0.6174473763,
-0.4557496011,
-0.0757469013,
0.4508800209,
-1.294043541,
0.1865265816,
-0.1326768696,
-0.3051048815,
0.0183312781,
0.0595728643,
0.3663670719,
0.9583504796,
0.3625716269,
-0.0735500753,
-0.179697156,
-0.4499544501,
-0.0065188333,
-0.0082214056,
-0.1134982631,
0.4568039477,
0.4026652575,
-0.0530253798,
0.7452270389,
-0.148207128,
-0.1853868663,
-0.3297687471,
-0.1336641312,
-0.0651024058,
0.6677885652,
0.4522596002,
-0.9535609484,
-0.552278161,
-0.0297230054,
-0.4545122981,
0.0331930853,
-0.1228671968,
-0.1963966191,
0.1881096959,
1.2559679747,
-0.0674479753,
0.476904422,
0.2958110273,
-0.3817750812,
0.1791519225,
-0.3412987292,
-0.0829449818,
-1.0140739679,
-0.2482027262,
-0.0885648727,
-0.4005230367,
-0.4989730716,
-0.0440540984,
0.425188899,
0.1114091724,
-0.9338008165,
0.6627683043,
-0.3496074975,
0.0256669465,
-0.3377164602,
0.2216843665,
-0.1949845701,
0.5573399663,
-0.2302493304,
1.0080432892,
0.6750477552,
-0.9650913477,
0.0850195438,
0.2269034982,
-0.5752360821,
0.6276171803,
-0.4255580604,
-0.0515484922,
-0.4546943307,
0.5073247552,
-1.1328228712,
-0.0474384949,
0.1919917613,
-0.2445893586,
0.5741986036,
-0.0269886628,
-0.1299408823,
0.2426572442,
-0.1300307214,
0.3005113602,
0.4721912444,
-0.9936842918,
0.6583078504,
0.347016722,
-0.0424925722,
-0.7113421559,
-0.5616900325,
-0.1845128089,
-0.6134553552,
-0.1865237504,
0.7450144887,
-0.1560626924,
-0.2727740705,
-0.0988269448,
0.0008255198,
0.1962881982,
0.2448127866,
0.3427326977,
0.2031346262,
0.0206964836,
0.560315311,
0.3119425774,
-0.1158462688,
-0.2027382851,
-0.5622447729,
0.3285423815,
-0.0626134202,
-0.2759501338,
-0.294074297,
0.3890558183,
0.5567498803,
-0.1674870402,
0.6336269975,
0.3835407197,
-0.3727546334,
-0.504152894,
0.0772075504,
-0.2420479953,
-0.4664792418,
0.3166925311,
-0.334626317,
-1.2629985809,
0.1233117878,
-0.4245065749,
0.2346936464,
-0.0724049881,
0.5358432531,
-0.2957180738,
0.9141881466,
0.9517475367,
0.0446950682,
0.8930990696,
-0.3988429606,
0.1892671138,
-1.0455713272,
-0.3595184684,
-0.290589273,
-0.4617528319,
-0.3204103708,
-0.647999227,
0.6862831712,
0.2330402881,
-0.3252375722,
0.1021058783,
-0.2501951158,
0.4375214279,
0.4494452178,
0.1500484943,
-0.0104852859,
0.0871675611,
-0.5959285498,
-0.1438253671,
-0.9712482691,
-0.5351067185,
0.79923141,
0.2627122998,
0.7010702491,
0.2198040187,
0.375736624,
-0.0924458206,
0.5938640237,
-0.8556118011,
0.4992833138,
-0.1621101797,
-0.0343460962,
-0.4893147945,
-0.1670347154,
-0.7771972418,
0.4561856985,
-0.2974990308,
-0.7371891141,
0.1364905834,
0.2163039893,
-0.432705611,
0.2809930742,
-0.6570051312,
0.659961462,
-0.0245361459,
-0.6142962575,
-0.2509607673,
-0.5160447955,
0.0946090296,
0.1204064041,
0.216991663,
0.0432045944,
-0.3284625113,
0.54289639,
-0.4448746443,
1.0208035707,
-0.2535931766,
-0.0953989103,
0.2376343012,
0.071182929,
0.5455998182,
0.113654837,
0.1497545838,
-0.295740962,
-0.3549538553,
-0.2062905729,
-0.769759655,
0.9098997712,
-0.6556847692,
-0.3902810514,
-0.146111086,
-0.4719729722,
-0.2322675437,
-0.079624474,
0.2649071515,
0.8799053431,
-0.2919358313,
0.5672978163,
0.8951420784,
-0.5498973131,
0.765098989,
0.4479497671,
0.010810283,
-0.0439100042,
0.7755804062,
0.1120240018,
0.2041486949,
0.8718827367,
0.3838955164,
-0.3297111392,
-0.4084641039,
-0.2795513868,
-0.1256300956,
-0.7842567563,
-0.0384741873,
-0.6221806407,
0.1290306598,
-0.0774785206,
-0.5477182865,
-0.28549546,
-0.1716411263,
-0.5061794519,
0.0253727771,
0.2498780042,
0.4611183703,
0.1139025167,
0.5611255765,
-0.2674534619,
-0.113832958,
0.530166924,
0.3601179123,
0.1791889817,
-0.6760280728,
-0.1724920422,
-0.2571434379,
-0.3020904958,
-0.5997679234,
0.3381817639,
0.2370450497,
0.5210819244,
0.3376178443,
-0.1001013145,
0.742197156,
-0.9217355251,
0.7533857822,
0.0928325281,
-1.0487080812,
0.3638194501,
-0.1651626229,
0.3000912666,
0.1284709424,
0.5549551249,
-0.5178915858,
-0.227138564,
-0.438400507,
-1.0714052916,
0.4791479111,
-0.1346642226,
0.2770817876,
0.0178744122,
0.4781301022,
0.1229193881,
0.0409753099,
-0.277338475,
-0.2293426692,
-0.0740656257,
-0.0926445946,
-0.308524251,
-0.2156856656,
-0.0618515126,
-0.5611792803,
0.6652605534,
-0.4114390612,
0.135033071,
0.2991915345,
-0.1764968783,
0.1146639585,
0.2155425102,
0.7973784208,
0.8014395237,
0.1644542515,
0.3860865533,
0.3828743994,
-0.2138342559,
0.246698305,
-0.1301686764,
-0.1366217136,
-0.3149390519,
0.2838563621,
0.7746527195,
0.8191128373,
-0.5728420615,
0.8166384101,
-0.2390022576,
-0.0679009333,
-0.4846866429,
0.1235808134,
0.1178904325,
0.432719171,
0.2082816511,
-0.0331502631,
-0.0761164054,
-0.3637611866,
0.4187727273,
0.3661362827,
-0.578365922,
-0.1197520271,
0.7423245311,
0.2080081552,
-0.3497804999,
0.4067410827,
-0.0580041483,
-0.3026663959,
0.4766276777,
0.7046867013,
0.5042002201,
-0.0781012326,
0.1161529049,
0.1747009605,
0.000385799,
0.0252953302,
0.2677561939,
-0.2590227723,
-0.7801063657,
-0.7228584886,
-0.2126228064,
-0.4543291926,
0.2493191957,
-0.3666754663,
0.2131926566,
-0.4358101487,
0.3037048876,
-0.0768936798,
-0.2684480548,
-0.5999287367,
-0.0023151303,
0.0558353625,
1.0362371206,
-0.6348032355,
1.0145807266,
0.850413084,
0.0336373486,
-0.8675683737,
0.1008236557,
-0.0306541156,
-0.4091371,
0.6499919295,
0.1899484098,
-0.1481461078,
-0.0155780651,
-1.0253338814,
-0.9548062682,
1.178809762,
0.2150750756,
-0.5770924091,
0.3602947891,
-0.5233184099,
0.3278076649,
-0.727017343,
-0.109112218,
0.307344377,
0.0446352176,
0.2527078688,
-0.5111756921,
-0.0148287313,
0.107973218,
0.2013729662,
-0.0337416567,
-0.5289865136,
0.7900432348,
-0.1696216017,
-0.1644964367,
-0.2226012498,
1.1212439537,
0.263220787,
0.1580784619,
0.7071201205,
0.0497777574,
0.7778549194,
-0.0941868573,
1.0721601248,
-0.0650497302,
-0.1868129373,
1.1463433504,
-0.1481890678,
1.0249321461,
0.8375450969,
0.3160793483,
0.5512933731,
0.3196430802,
0.717666626,
0.5882092714,
0.3233722746,
-0.3716212809,
-0.1594475657,
-0.0044459007,
0.1030347347,
0.635697782,
0.662717998,
0.1063354313,
-0.2133771181,
0.5833808184,
0.1307461709,
0.3710031807,
-0.38681373,
0.6013365984,
0.1253220737,
-0.6266279817,
0.4386067986,
0.0832468793,
0.7813665867,
-0.4957265854,
-0.4404329658,
-0.0453832038,
0.2753436565,
0.1005198881,
-0.5487385988,
0.2209098935,
-0.063135542,
0.0227607545,
-0.5731652975,
0.6625066996,
-0.7299180627,
-0.0212346595,
0.1836344749,
0.3331905901,
0.2140178382,
0.2167571336,
-0.3267118633,
-0.0356661268,
-0.1421534717,
-0.1293250173,
0.3944777548,
0.5133087635,
-0.5004993081,
0.7707030177,
0.4499093592,
-0.1370664686,
-0.0006591538,
-0.1082725152,
1.0647774935,
-0.4701557457,
-0.6873877645,
-0.6879910827,
0.478733629,
0.098794587,
-0.350720346,
0.7539391518,
0.3237728179,
1.2933809757,
0.1375793666,
0.7787494659,
-0.0476373658,
0.4841113389,
-0.603217721,
0.4677155912,
-0.7133442163,
0.2755883038,
-0.133161962,
-0.5974116325,
-0.3110977709,
0.6293109655,
-0.224002555,
-0.1655430496,
0.4703980386,
0.6128608584,
-0.2051628977,
-0.31425789,
0.4875531793,
0.1510341316,
0.5860702395,
0.5772693157,
1.0134146214,
-0.1250058264,
0.2175452113,
-0.2879997492,
-0.5467489958,
-0.1726474166,
-1.204031229,
-0.9754354954,
-0.6502282023,
-0.1820764542,
-0.157166034,
-0.2064362317,
1.3076853752,
0.8467223644,
-0.5538345575,
-0.2866691947,
0.0635173619,
0.2861970365,
-0.4852322042,
-0.1672010422,
0.4270013869,
-0.4133415818,
-0.7556885481,
0.8654595613,
0.3793328106,
0.1543054283,
-0.1756259054,
-0.2898508608,
-0.1924730092,
-0.1103926301,
0.9905412793,
0.2723436356,
-0.57643646,
-0.4823131263,
-0.1166473106,
-0.1607722342,
0.0149487797,
0.9956545234,
-0.9316203594,
0.4618189335,
0.4728325903,
0.8474476337,
0.3890879154,
-0.118740201,
0.7352714539,
-1.0740392208,
0.4908214509,
0.136716187,
0.2064146698,
0.4333672822,
-0.3336981535,
0.0137956478,
-0.0484699607,
-0.4065132737,
-0.4021678865,
0.0856434852,
-0.8112318516,
-0.5160925388,
1.2887949944,
-0.0433855653,
-0.3842411637,
-0.1819019616,
-0.2953377664,
0.363434881,
-0.3449645638,
0.431878686,
0.4394058585,
-0.1240549237,
0.037005879,
-0.5302770138,
0.6823952794,
0.2559280992,
-0.484888196,
-0.1035619825,
0.2877021134,
0.3778094053,
-0.3290999532,
0.5931771398,
-0.0922086537,
-0.0398508571,
-0.5811194777,
-0.1116950363,
-0.0713559315,
-0.8136307001,
-0.6781451702,
0.0792334005,
-0.0757744238,
-0.3061785698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07611v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07611v1
|
Intentional Biases in LLM Responses
| 2023-11-11T19:59:24 | 2023-11-11T19:59:24 |
Nicklaus Badyal, Derek Jacoby, Yvonne Coady
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study we intentionally introduce biases into large language model
responses in an attempt to create specific personas for interactive media
purposes. We explore the differences between open source models such as
Falcon-7b and the GPT-4 model from Open AI, and we quantify some differences in
responses afforded by the two systems. We find that the guardrails in the GPT-4
mixture of experts models with a supervisor, while useful in assuring AI
alignment in general, are detrimental in trying to construct personas with a
variety of uncommon viewpoints. This study aims to set the groundwork for
future exploration in intentional biases of large language models such that
these practices can be applied in the creative field, and new forms of media.
|
[
-0.6136732101,
-0.9819723368,
0.9734311104,
0.2582320571,
0.1062668338,
-0.0874163881,
-0.0833285004,
-0.5123733282,
0.2562063634,
0.6117227674,
-0.6639474034,
-0.0989769325,
-0.5539590716,
0.0233397931,
-0.2309045196,
1.1281803846,
-0.1809262484,
0.3962144554,
0.2168321908,
-0.1375383288,
-0.6273339987,
-0.3513760269,
-0.6537367702,
-0.1090291664,
0.7858501673,
0.2272103727,
0.7906168699,
0.4985062182,
0.7398834229,
0.3049063385,
0.337102443,
0.0245737303,
-0.606374681,
0.0047769039,
-0.4795947373,
-0.4475765526,
-0.422088623,
0.4514854848,
0.6696368456,
0.5532813072,
0.1066198051,
0.2816946208,
-0.1247849613,
0.4853211045,
-0.5579247475,
0.054875534,
-0.7353389859,
0.1844870597,
-0.4014245272,
-0.132037878,
-0.478338331,
-0.1144043058,
0.0953844339,
-0.6722686291,
0.1301348507,
0.1246727258,
0.5978467464,
0.5191932321,
-0.2877932787,
-0.4114734828,
-1.0087689161,
0.6608356833,
-0.7811696529,
0.17991741,
0.0878363699,
0.5021179914,
-0.1679310799,
-0.4467199445,
-0.6234180927,
-0.0367515609,
0.1129324362,
0.3696522117,
-0.0976974294,
0.2746132314,
0.474239856,
0.0807492584,
-0.3727134168,
0.3904957771,
-0.2915047705,
0.0226820912,
0.6600233912,
0.2831840813,
0.3416641653,
0.0575678237,
-0.0272967927,
0.2184392512,
-0.8738911748,
-0.1280491948,
1.0174928904,
0.1324778497,
0.0514472872,
0.8613555431,
0.0613013022,
0.4813389182,
0.4450542629,
0.0694345087,
-0.1463484764,
-0.1484755427,
-0.367359221,
0.0164639466,
0.8896432519,
0.4876612127,
0.6079816222,
-0.2901600599,
-0.1656747311,
0.2848022282,
0.5640761852,
-0.4511172771,
-0.0655790344,
0.2353090048,
-0.33823511,
-0.3407504559,
0.3166292906,
-0.5867226124,
-0.6010824442,
-0.5247651935,
0.1485183835,
-0.0660186261,
-0.2590343654,
-0.0473274291,
-0.1297872514,
0.217027083,
0.3330096006,
-0.9106656313,
0.0717091635,
0.6249331832,
0.5035094619,
-0.2857897878,
-0.3953158557,
-0.686660111,
0.4651356339,
-0.4936469793,
0.7739007473,
-0.6671584249,
-0.4665550292,
-0.0259480719,
-0.2364025265,
-0.1291194409,
-0.4666279852,
0.6924328208,
-0.4662777781,
0.3468505442,
-0.6050701737,
-0.3564815521,
-0.0850525126,
0.0619426891,
-0.6319358945,
0.663866818,
0.1847865582,
-0.9791758657,
0.5715560913,
-0.8738132715,
0.140991509,
0.053191904,
-0.7993222475,
-0.0402864181,
0.2033732235,
0.2182157338,
0.2756270468,
-0.141792044,
0.4917122722,
-0.685297668,
-0.3278518915,
0.4592086077,
-0.3412513435,
0.63701123,
0.3164338768,
-0.583588779,
0.390087992,
-0.4138461053,
-0.2031031698,
0.0923885405,
-0.4429405332,
-0.3321804404,
0.1240811348,
-0.0531175174,
0.3949002326,
-0.0066146604,
-0.5467399955,
0.2369298637,
-0.2000259757,
0.3027111888,
1.1360616684,
0.0448074713,
0.6872171164,
-0.3583247066,
0.6389414668,
0.2117821574,
0.1598854959,
-0.0872996449,
-0.5393224955,
-0.7485283613,
-0.0638067573,
-0.2991520464,
0.2218193412,
-0.6607140899,
0.0980640054,
-0.1828969866,
-0.2873000801,
-0.8524273634,
0.1788301319,
0.3618319631,
0.5751495361,
0.0289267525,
-0.3054171503,
-0.5603417158,
-1.2306967974,
-0.571670711,
-0.1724310517,
-0.1133855805,
0.5331475139,
0.2738593817,
-0.1341227591,
1.1487973928,
-0.3039781749,
-0.0677725449,
-0.1593130827,
0.0319680348,
0.0690616965,
0.2963747382,
1.1045665741,
-0.6470039487,
-0.5681286454,
-0.1400257051,
-0.8520926237,
-0.4262890518,
-0.2446476221,
-0.2994396389,
0.1643987894,
0.3290375173,
-0.9784647822,
0.3049736619,
0.2712495625,
-0.3142850995,
0.6314706802,
0.2502560318,
0.1527374834,
-0.8881663084,
-0.0503877848,
0.3916332424,
0.1490083188,
-0.6879600883,
0.2511227727,
-0.1157884151,
0.4646571875,
-0.6535782814,
0.6374381185,
-0.4326562583,
-0.31737867,
-0.2825327218,
0.0252075791,
-0.1814785004,
0.3350134492,
0.0652845576,
0.7953754067,
0.2813844085,
-0.3898991942,
0.2343661636,
0.3369224668,
-0.1387595087,
0.8897739649,
-0.5930199623,
0.4727452993,
-0.3310204446,
0.4565793276,
-0.8583577275,
-0.5886461735,
0.5875082612,
-0.2896280289,
0.1438636631,
-0.165215686,
-0.3839633763,
-0.5169790387,
-0.2273203582,
0.2907109261,
0.3252054453,
-0.5097356439,
0.5992042422,
0.5056679249,
-0.2402945906,
-0.4621059895,
-0.8145601153,
0.0855010748,
-0.6437603235,
-0.8238615394,
0.1962570101,
-0.4694523811,
-0.8360778093,
-0.224509418,
0.0788224116,
0.1922353804,
-0.2609420121,
0.2908213139,
0.1860215217,
-0.3612065613,
-0.4204597771,
-0.1281149983,
0.3688789606,
0.3465138674,
-0.1670104414,
0.4142861664,
-0.1349550635,
-0.7253477573,
-0.2469340861,
0.4229227602,
0.5380958915,
-0.0271070041,
0.547906816,
0.5478920341,
-0.0575853735,
-0.0653667822,
-0.9172273874,
-0.1542307734,
-0.5580889583,
0.1600648612,
-0.3359533548,
-0.98877424,
0.8019259572,
0.4412085712,
0.2400769144,
0.3917297125,
0.8419417143,
-0.0026471841,
1.3239233494,
0.4037303925,
-0.1337873638,
0.5217474103,
0.003272424,
0.2697888315,
-1.0031169653,
-0.1925427765,
-0.4827459455,
-0.5295221806,
-0.6111716032,
-0.0746841356,
0.2351490706,
-0.3716881573,
-0.6283958554,
-0.1496742219,
-0.4523895085,
0.4674702883,
0.7327200174,
-0.0288687628,
0.1288703531,
-0.2487625331,
-0.0848847181,
-0.0546337478,
-0.567723155,
-0.6133394241,
1.1280982494,
0.5350854397,
0.9619501233,
0.3096562624,
0.4650790095,
0.1727054566,
0.5264093876,
-0.689573288,
0.5202687979,
0.3448131382,
-0.7960690856,
-0.2029528618,
-0.2048150599,
-0.6792942286,
0.1119374111,
0.1168571338,
-1.0017602444,
0.0756817013,
0.0415085964,
-0.2820996344,
0.2394950986,
-0.9050755501,
0.516602397,
-0.3028815091,
-0.6175557971,
0.2016227543,
-0.628880024,
0.7362573743,
-0.4303253591,
0.1769092679,
-0.0350687653,
0.0490256362,
0.6724493504,
-0.222849384,
0.9150258303,
-0.3220537305,
-0.1515366882,
0.4337403774,
0.1103466228,
0.6601736546,
0.0096314633,
-0.0473116674,
-0.0479714386,
-0.4733098745,
-0.3121608198,
-0.4831655324,
0.9058504105,
-1.0793286562,
-1.0143364668,
-0.2775179446,
-0.8143821359,
-0.3807997704,
0.3110300601,
0.2531915307,
-0.042572964,
-0.2537210286,
-0.0791921243,
0.6101009846,
-0.2961409092,
0.5249088407,
0.9022789001,
-0.2630470395,
-0.1006132215,
0.2767325044,
0.2147432268,
0.2084249556,
-0.0546773747,
0.0638346747,
-0.2266657799,
-0.7122008204,
-0.4919542074,
0.2204977125,
-0.7344852686,
0.2136156857,
-0.6317098141,
-0.1327508837,
-0.6226575971,
-0.35552755,
-0.1599752456,
-0.2647065818,
-0.2269174755,
-0.4058715403,
0.0533410907,
1.0873075724,
0.2394194454,
0.633802712,
-0.4817766845,
0.1196484268,
-0.0628126636,
0.3192644119,
-0.0519606583,
-0.5461223125,
-0.0655947253,
0.1805751771,
-0.5536274314,
-1.0488499403,
0.2510277033,
-0.1613752246,
1.0739953518,
0.8172110319,
-0.2119330913,
0.4036891162,
-0.6725147367,
0.9681319594,
0.0005743515,
-0.5197767615,
0.3794153929,
-1.2243288755,
0.3198828697,
0.3787565827,
0.5181134343,
-0.3175311685,
-0.7300861478,
-0.7740523815,
-0.434262991,
0.8185643554,
0.0846558362,
0.2301248461,
-0.235751465,
0.3363429308,
0.1960022449,
0.3360944092,
-0.8756073713,
-0.0190137308,
-0.170572266,
-0.0814031661,
0.0490664244,
-0.2361593246,
-0.3875939846,
0.0318843126,
0.6307890415,
-0.1113635525,
0.3395531178,
-0.111477606,
-0.0151995849,
-0.425363034,
0.0853983462,
0.7871680856,
0.7623621225,
-0.1233694702,
0.1095959619,
-0.1309502274,
-0.4365118146,
0.0098968456,
-0.1092601046,
-0.258207798,
-0.1858042032,
0.0389127657,
0.7762547731,
0.1180961877,
-0.2927536666,
0.3268779516,
0.1474191397,
-0.1517559439,
-0.3148554564,
0.2625181675,
0.1683948636,
0.2836430371,
0.21016635,
0.0069136377,
0.1735912561,
-0.6338365078,
-0.0625299215,
0.6895890236,
-0.1221063957,
-0.4499659538,
1.0245732069,
0.1763633788,
-0.3505422175,
0.5908341408,
0.042598743,
-0.2022316158,
0.6604396701,
0.4194197655,
1.0219192505,
-0.3334571719,
0.2030157447,
0.0030017798,
0.3907188177,
-0.0610842742,
0.0258931387,
0.3024537563,
-0.959415555,
-0.4213996828,
-0.4596547186,
-0.4437523484,
0.3892346323,
-0.4089198709,
0.3067892492,
-0.4749634564,
-0.3112269044,
0.2332823128,
-0.3876169026,
-0.8721469641,
0.0394014381,
0.1636045724,
0.7908241749,
-0.9627015591,
0.640789628,
0.7532210946,
-0.9041087627,
-1.1108469963,
0.0020343126,
0.3167698383,
-0.8818610907,
0.5856562853,
-0.0216851365,
0.1639777273,
-0.0229012519,
-0.6771248579,
-0.8076042533,
0.9101955295,
0.3458674252,
-0.2804413736,
-0.3941461444,
0.5921314955,
0.5329692364,
-0.5347608328,
0.6168131232,
0.5783375502,
0.7446378469,
-0.0286539998,
-0.976054728,
-0.0585446283,
-0.2832384408,
-0.0327355079,
0.0428589545,
-1.00089252,
0.8083410859,
0.0797791854,
0.1684898287,
-0.1253481507,
0.5014514923,
0.4916193783,
0.4091103375,
0.0885896087,
0.4248511493,
0.4981208742,
-0.0196570177,
1.0601453781,
-0.08416529,
-0.0735593364,
1.263405323,
-0.470063448,
0.3204573989,
0.7737670541,
-0.1795389205,
0.2435337305,
0.8450487256,
-0.1452353448,
0.4087456167,
0.0314740352,
-0.2727967799,
0.2335042208,
-0.0757646486,
-0.1976897717,
0.267971307,
0.3595195711,
-0.5220090747,
-0.1454969645,
-0.1166868731,
0.2290039062,
0.0335531011,
-0.4011876881,
0.6045818925,
0.1237498447,
-1.1992580891,
-0.0916481167,
0.1391768605,
0.7873857021,
-0.4507544041,
0.2761626542,
-0.3616818488,
0.0323918052,
-0.4009764194,
-0.8750887513,
0.2859507203,
0.1740819663,
-0.2719143033,
-0.3011214137,
0.5918248296,
-0.1190918386,
-0.4095802009,
-0.0443551615,
0.5420444012,
0.1678562462,
-0.1653055698,
-0.5575467944,
0.1819681972,
-0.0751046687,
-0.5612969398,
0.5289054513,
0.3585740626,
-0.289509207,
0.4854724407,
0.5282020569,
-0.0135446498,
0.3074210584,
0.2051937133,
0.8365821838,
-0.3037831187,
-0.5666289926,
-0.8727833629,
0.6071746349,
-0.0026154518,
-0.1758381128,
0.9859223962,
0.5981473327,
0.8032590151,
-0.3286396861,
1.1940655708,
0.0777540952,
0.3695666194,
-0.5997735858,
0.5954298377,
-0.1040631756,
0.3923825324,
-0.6884837747,
-1.3052932024,
0.0199930687,
0.4402846694,
-0.7341619134,
0.5279669166,
0.6347768307,
0.7355675697,
-0.1473435462,
0.0873040929,
0.1763259172,
0.3640925288,
0.77084589,
0.4193947613,
0.9990562797,
0.283129096,
0.1110513806,
0.0308263879,
-0.1858659685,
-0.160438627,
-0.9795720577,
-0.9971925616,
-0.3559448421,
-0.0711383671,
-0.2154692709,
0.0427808687,
0.6685318947,
0.3235347569,
-0.4657008946,
-0.0482154638,
-0.1670705974,
-0.2538764179,
0.3607765138,
-0.3055769205,
0.0312038213,
-0.0767007768,
-0.8480889797,
0.3259265721,
0.1834220886,
0.1829250306,
-0.7090780139,
-0.1679544449,
0.0216943566,
0.4291755259,
0.3275066316,
0.2182555348,
-0.9109755158,
-0.5946636796,
0.2105672061,
-0.0904513896,
0.0912162885,
0.7740145922,
-0.5172672272,
0.2041467875,
0.3803087771,
0.5059025884,
0.3410145044,
0.2448482364,
0.8644165397,
-0.491209209,
0.1839150786,
0.2025448531,
0.4247857928,
0.3726242483,
-0.6288751364,
0.6179287434,
0.0939924344,
-0.7627096772,
-0.659860909,
0.4241978824,
-1.1010555029,
-0.0209136363,
1.5137789249,
0.0366537906,
0.0534595139,
0.1873316914,
-0.461897254,
-0.0187792964,
-0.294269681,
0.8978674412,
1.1381773949,
-0.4885824025,
-0.0990200862,
-0.9574588537,
0.3298781216,
0.1740393341,
-0.7090520263,
-0.4327300489,
0.8802471161,
0.3980478048,
-0.0760954618,
0.8865470886,
-0.0920457318,
0.0988489091,
-0.097189337,
-0.0891370624,
-0.0463087969,
-0.2517414689,
0.0094319712,
-0.0614543892,
0.28515172,
0.2380135506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06649v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06649v1
|
A Template Is All You Meme
| 2023-11-11T19:38:14 | 2023-11-11T19:38:14 |
Luke Bates, Peter Ebert Christensen, Preslav Nakov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Memes are a modern form of communication and meme templates possess a base
semantics that is customizable by whomever posts it on social media. Machine
learning systems struggle with memes, which is likely due to such systems
having insufficient context to understand memes, as there is more to memes than
the obvious image and text. Here, to aid understanding of memes, we release a
knowledge base of memes and information found on www.knowyourmeme.com, which we
call the Know Your Meme Knowledge Base (KYMKB), composed of more than 54,000
images. The KYMKB includes popular meme templates, examples of each template,
and detailed information about the template. We hypothesize that meme templates
can be used to inject models with the context missing from previous approaches.
To test our hypothesis, we create a non-parametric majority-based classifier,
which we call Template-Label Counter (TLC). We find TLC more effective than or
competitive with fine-tuned baselines. To demonstrate the power of meme
templates and the value of both our knowledge base and method, we conduct
thorough classification experiments and exploratory data analysis in the
context of five meme analysis tasks.
|
[
-0.595712781,
-0.6427657604,
0.3110664487,
-0.0395213328,
-0.6810828447,
0.165121302,
0.1136489362,
-0.1405521929,
0.4469358921,
0.4234220982,
-0.4053116739,
-0.5439608097,
-0.8163121343,
0.202531755,
-0.4417902827,
0.7145186067,
0.0135727171,
-0.1349282265,
-0.2996087968,
-0.4538833499,
-0.4941997528,
-0.369235158,
-0.3722100556,
-0.1520956159,
0.5325081944,
0.6698334813,
0.0180324242,
0.8270713687,
0.1157195494,
0.3030364513,
0.132617116,
-0.323315233,
-0.2952874005,
-0.0003143093,
-0.479118526,
-0.5097852349,
-0.3925353587,
0.5460492373,
0.2194986045,
0.746520102,
0.0376561917,
0.4617311954,
-0.1100433096,
0.6142247319,
-0.9480097294,
0.070296526,
-0.7015905976,
0.1972827315,
-0.3083328903,
-0.377225697,
-0.3858026564,
-0.3110033572,
0.0252356213,
-0.4416426122,
0.2251288444,
-0.2082856447,
0.4144043624,
0.0197071452,
-0.7664865851,
-0.6347861886,
-0.6386931539,
0.8646011353,
-0.5680950284,
0.4942656159,
-0.1746694148,
0.4969813526,
-0.2321894318,
-1.0878089666,
-0.7326779366,
0.1784449518,
0.2220984846,
0.2661982775,
-0.1545234472,
-0.2968054414,
0.1829224825,
0.2612043917,
-0.6170749664,
0.0669595748,
-0.5525900126,
-0.2806273103,
0.0681532398,
0.2019063085,
0.3154341877,
-0.2592798471,
-0.4213931262,
-0.3659009039,
-0.629140377,
0.0950744674,
0.1488968283,
-0.3949701786,
-0.0579560101,
0.5299448967,
0.0475960746,
1.1485038996,
0.0480791554,
-0.4921432436,
-0.0640976503,
0.0174528062,
-0.3490184247,
0.1168096513,
0.749440968,
0.5952265859,
0.248933956,
-0.1138104796,
0.2358438224,
0.1513234079,
0.3124226332,
-0.631962955,
-0.1514544636,
0.0115436055,
-0.7267660499,
-0.4056853354,
0.2517513633,
-0.6359359622,
-0.2871660888,
-0.1175409332,
-0.0144806448,
-0.2962090969,
-0.098453857,
-0.0778931305,
-0.7251683474,
0.1702645868,
0.3789733648,
-0.8277642131,
-0.1167423576,
0.5094727874,
0.5225393772,
0.5164871216,
-0.1280454248,
-0.0496913306,
0.3294175267,
-0.6307957172,
1.0821914673,
-0.6197239161,
-0.3350125253,
-0.4078570306,
0.2309366167,
-0.2856228352,
-0.4965210557,
0.2616897225,
-0.4026752412,
0.3808491528,
-0.2899700701,
-1.0525383949,
-0.3759988546,
0.0452530086,
-0.7748386264,
0.0512662232,
0.3356416225,
-0.6092144847,
0.6563792229,
-0.4653694928,
-0.2913362384,
0.1899375767,
-0.4871115983,
-0.2540895343,
0.3444985747,
-0.2545664907,
0.7801574469,
-0.3958307803,
0.1105440632,
-0.382342577,
-0.2804777324,
0.3022833169,
0.0288793594,
0.6259169579,
0.5940861106,
-0.2503360212,
-0.229516983,
-0.5927077532,
-0.1325758249,
0.2946571708,
-0.6750119328,
-0.3095541596,
-0.0370350517,
-0.1102523133,
0.5053325891,
0.0064409263,
-0.5532301664,
0.4328494072,
0.1045344844,
0.6951696873,
0.8313862085,
0.077427499,
0.6006342769,
-0.402090013,
0.4719968736,
0.2402501702,
-0.1213997379,
-0.223079592,
-0.7575543523,
-0.4197867811,
-0.1787109822,
0.22191827,
0.3864439428,
-0.548165977,
0.6753142476,
-0.2024699599,
-0.6543707848,
-0.3353312314,
0.4608941972,
0.0730553046,
0.7358570099,
0.221600309,
-0.4408415556,
-0.8063022494,
-0.9810804725,
-0.5588889122,
-0.0242672712,
-0.3280542791,
0.2731507719,
0.4680359066,
-0.1416178644,
0.7754147053,
-0.1250173897,
-0.1369425356,
-0.4651031494,
0.2445866615,
0.3080729246,
0.3799093366,
0.875130713,
-0.4488574862,
-0.5636851192,
-0.359899193,
-1.1454401016,
-0.0381131656,
-0.2831942141,
0.3663242459,
-0.0537766777,
0.8714225888,
-0.078902714,
0.2348237336,
0.4661313295,
-0.5765109658,
0.3670184314,
0.103522934,
0.1599493027,
-1.3542737961,
0.0258411597,
0.0580430031,
-0.0843503401,
-0.5284725428,
-0.483145088,
0.4838913679,
-0.0966903046,
-0.4701714218,
0.8947443366,
-0.1511283517,
0.1752856523,
-0.242390573,
-0.202018857,
0.2046940774,
0.0280192159,
-0.3970403671,
0.5076732635,
0.3602159023,
-0.7086176872,
0.412127316,
0.0071489108,
-0.5547121167,
0.9056451917,
-0.248376593,
0.3073304296,
-0.4684016407,
0.5432801247,
-0.7814956903,
-0.2533479035,
0.4714801908,
-0.4705634117,
0.4433834851,
-0.1411145926,
-0.4675057828,
-0.4854033887,
-0.1826068908,
0.2205251753,
0.5581062436,
-0.5387390256,
0.4148986042,
0.3550805449,
0.4335872233,
-0.5251287222,
-0.180708006,
0.3370204866,
-0.432875216,
-0.3232594132,
0.0424200073,
-0.0098350653,
-0.2031132728,
0.2323213816,
-0.244220674,
0.0167366862,
0.4250063598,
0.1727443486,
-0.3880329132,
-0.4124863148,
0.1553952098,
-0.0697844848,
-0.2785940468,
-0.1908207685,
-0.8860001564,
0.6508966684,
-0.1059396937,
-0.5227169991,
-0.4807845354,
0.2130136788,
0.7160059214,
0.1249002963,
0.7436623573,
0.4863972366,
-0.3804426193,
-0.074500829,
-0.5818740726,
-0.07598456,
-0.4658440053,
0.2382480353,
-0.4609159529,
-0.7470453978,
0.3325052261,
-0.1873771399,
0.1170327738,
0.5543063879,
0.3656596541,
-0.5858399272,
0.6781611443,
0.5743284822,
-0.2592856884,
0.4878537655,
-0.2654758692,
0.3569742143,
-0.5520210266,
-0.3563599288,
-0.4467381835,
-0.7724691033,
-0.6283587217,
-0.3946622908,
0.1237115413,
0.2674782574,
-0.0458498523,
0.3188419044,
-0.3840880096,
0.3890327215,
0.7521803975,
-0.0315150246,
-0.0733491555,
0.0428295694,
-0.2303100824,
-0.078564547,
-0.7958421111,
-0.8548000455,
1.2165459394,
0.131121099,
0.9344671369,
-0.020703733,
0.4587647021,
0.4495124221,
0.4369463623,
-0.6424941421,
0.4055691659,
-0.3600858152,
-0.6768327355,
0.1110720038,
0.0043357848,
-1.1444087029,
-0.3846624494,
-0.2267519236,
-0.7703601718,
0.0149659831,
0.1981575042,
0.3970676959,
0.6897200346,
-0.5077137947,
0.8879179955,
-0.0836830437,
-0.01237032,
-0.1857439429,
-0.4629065692,
0.1281897575,
-0.078272,
0.0766507611,
-0.0781614557,
0.1088077202,
1.1214370728,
-0.0829256177,
0.9307623506,
-0.0130529013,
0.2577763796,
0.601144433,
-0.0186018497,
-0.0422802866,
-0.3239780366,
0.0237449221,
0.1356229782,
-0.1289143562,
-0.8952217102,
-0.6540874839,
0.5927795172,
-0.5643918514,
-0.3789522052,
-0.1005844995,
-0.1265668124,
0.2678262293,
0.2887883782,
0.555355072,
0.2387901992,
-0.2638761997,
0.7638790011,
0.446107924,
-0.2803934813,
0.1294764578,
0.4114792347,
0.3553724885,
-0.2295204401,
0.9659742713,
0.3887642622,
-0.1976449341,
0.3619223535,
0.3933386505,
-0.359608233,
-0.2472104132,
-0.4441472292,
-0.0456785299,
-1.2232966423,
0.0060073594,
-0.7999567986,
-0.070267804,
-0.4848911166,
-0.4567417204,
-0.1941122711,
-0.5622168779,
-0.1656907648,
-0.1616748273,
-0.0515059717,
1.1369053125,
-0.0539886653,
0.3851751983,
-0.8123250008,
0.0959221125,
0.4104661345,
0.3915247619,
0.1053880006,
-0.1455745697,
-0.1369950324,
-0.1563079804,
-0.7054197192,
-1.3191788197,
-0.0243404638,
0.1576851159,
0.9753000736,
0.9792794585,
-0.2258182764,
0.2856473327,
-0.3245174885,
0.5710490346,
0.3499064147,
-0.7585411072,
0.5252232552,
-0.2725725174,
0.151086241,
0.1652513295,
0.2881537676,
-0.8470318317,
-0.5808829665,
-1.0964844227,
-0.5352622867,
0.0044524278,
0.1005658656,
0.280796051,
-0.3313119709,
0.806024313,
0.030732194,
0.4494102001,
-0.4421507418,
-0.3142002821,
-0.571598351,
-0.3015331328,
-0.2599859536,
-0.3912195861,
0.0285746623,
-0.1590548456,
0.186912328,
-0.1413103044,
0.2943320572,
-0.1994778514,
-0.2383887917,
-0.1864207834,
0.3345431387,
0.5734462738,
0.7437065244,
-0.2736432552,
0.5607748628,
0.0514958948,
-0.3914990723,
0.2868645489,
-0.6408410072,
0.1305862367,
-0.0057445206,
0.5869686007,
0.4438346922,
0.078562893,
-0.3861863315,
0.2446487993,
-0.2631131709,
-0.2522996366,
-0.1081767082,
0.3156089783,
0.479044348,
0.0221419968,
0.3384366035,
0.132344529,
0.0064733266,
-0.51931113,
0.6382653117,
0.5819610357,
-0.4340351224,
-0.50920856,
0.5300956368,
0.0171985291,
-0.2102661878,
0.4299063385,
-0.0295940042,
-0.5817886591,
1.1112991571,
0.7107657194,
0.6403701901,
-0.3054497242,
0.1726755798,
0.4703856409,
0.3626028895,
0.2030260861,
0.0512062795,
0.0272134691,
-0.6464350224,
0.1479896456,
-0.667363584,
-0.3431932926,
0.7366197705,
-0.4047590494,
0.4333177805,
-0.7376897335,
0.0718870834,
0.266920656,
-0.2115691155,
-0.9290671349,
0.5264953971,
-0.0259240381,
1.0754848719,
-1.1858495474,
0.5371242166,
1.078512311,
-0.1922619492,
-0.4965000153,
-0.1698841155,
0.1718245447,
-0.7091940045,
0.3245497048,
0.5084657073,
0.3740427792,
0.1842325926,
-0.9678241611,
-0.4727858305,
1.0259510279,
0.1423207968,
-0.2103493065,
0.4088432193,
-0.0232920107,
0.4605208039,
-0.6397716403,
-0.0401291624,
0.3342909515,
0.4110694528,
0.078900598,
-0.3792596161,
0.1321832389,
-0.3484296799,
-0.2497230917,
-0.0225348789,
-0.3208701611,
0.8943880796,
-0.0907484517,
-0.1211233288,
-0.2527945936,
0.3827315271,
0.1536648422,
0.5545870066,
0.6327530146,
0.5250432491,
0.6636120677,
0.2341057211,
1.0065567493,
-0.1633101106,
0.1449633986,
0.8875288367,
0.3430565894,
0.3470705748,
0.5670672655,
0.0873362049,
0.5739444494,
1.0255089998,
-0.3615883887,
0.4822115004,
0.2493162751,
-0.0703159645,
-0.2882402539,
-0.0113642272,
-0.4675385952,
0.5913503766,
0.6475368142,
-0.6498969197,
-0.6378340721,
-0.0479182489,
0.1417599916,
-0.0670324787,
0.0922636762,
0.9774771333,
0.1619689614,
-0.4019390047,
0.6773130298,
0.1179882661,
0.0694881603,
-0.2041619867,
-0.060173925,
-0.1220076233,
0.257897228,
-0.1004812941,
-0.6824573278,
0.3155740201,
-0.3278161287,
-0.1404420137,
-0.1084834263,
0.8184494972,
0.1885645539,
-0.5288316607,
0.3085139096,
0.9594185948,
0.2772116363,
-0.0074527473,
-0.83906883,
-0.4084325135,
-0.0271823779,
-0.1411224306,
0.3995073438,
0.5401139855,
-0.2962957323,
0.619258523,
0.6674302816,
-0.1667958498,
0.163287133,
-0.1870608181,
0.9100950956,
-0.6957446337,
-0.4352818727,
-1.0214463472,
0.3712060452,
-0.1823922098,
0.0119787063,
0.5784930587,
0.4245076478,
0.6495515108,
-0.3163729906,
1.189399004,
-0.2180361897,
0.2667272091,
-0.2634079456,
0.8458526134,
-0.9417218566,
0.0895593762,
-0.2492390871,
-0.7098700404,
-0.1589448303,
0.7123090029,
-0.0781633854,
-0.1380832344,
0.442956537,
0.117309548,
-0.3851418197,
-0.0625364482,
0.4626764357,
0.1372848004,
0.6451981664,
0.3526699543,
0.9591654539,
-0.2435528189,
0.2905232012,
-0.4193845987,
-0.3973976672,
-0.4501953125,
-0.9418694973,
-1.1850955486,
-0.7904895544,
0.0044566146,
-0.5339958072,
-0.095942229,
0.7414134741,
0.655254662,
-0.9827082157,
-0.2274178714,
-0.0557319596,
0.5337308645,
0.0823015124,
-0.180317685,
0.1483815014,
-0.3371905386,
-0.4262816608,
0.3046063185,
0.2737998366,
0.3756934702,
0.0271670856,
0.1441379935,
-0.1915605515,
-0.0240006894,
0.4392085969,
0.2993888259,
-0.5044370294,
-0.1902816594,
0.2159622908,
-0.1730643213,
0.1549581289,
0.981993258,
-0.4903207123,
0.8231390715,
0.529941678,
0.227317363,
0.1643894911,
-0.0614577308,
0.7159644961,
-0.6192175746,
0.3720890582,
0.0279639885,
0.5270862579,
0.2073854506,
-0.1553742439,
0.3487370312,
0.5184998512,
-0.0560981594,
-0.3117579818,
0.3844202757,
-0.6043775082,
-0.6720585823,
0.625638485,
-0.0753019229,
-0.3096522689,
-0.5521623492,
0.2378663123,
0.4555841386,
-0.3134936094,
1.0412237644,
0.7719388008,
0.0308018494,
-0.1691713929,
-0.6658852696,
0.4606866837,
0.0824072883,
-0.6009273529,
-0.7267128229,
0.0975342318,
0.8251858354,
0.3991517425,
0.7605181932,
0.1507676393,
0.3256314695,
-0.1829034835,
0.0318859965,
0.2233064771,
-0.2401707917,
0.2093042433,
0.2519136369,
-0.1049857959,
-0.3354753256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06647v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06647v2
|
Robust Text Classification: Analyzing Prototype-Based Networks
| 2023-11-11T19:34:06 | 2024-06-18T02:53:04 |
Zhivar Sourati, Darshan Deshpande, Filip Ilievski, Kiril Gashteovski, Sascha Saralajew
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Downstream applications often require text classification models to be
accurate and robust. While the accuracy of the state-of-the-art Language Models
(LMs) approximates human performance, they often exhibit a drop in performance
on noisy data found in the real world. This lack of robustness can be
concerning, as even small perturbations in the text, irrelevant to the target
task, can cause classifiers to incorrectly change their predictions. A
potential solution can be the family of Prototype-Based Networks (PBNs) that
classifies examples based on their similarity to prototypical examples of a
class (prototypes) and has been shown to be robust to noise for computer vision
tasks. In this paper, we study whether the robustness properties of PBNs
transfer to text classification tasks under both targeted and static
adversarial attack settings. Our results show that PBNs, as a mere
architectural variation of vanilla LMs, offer more robustness compared to
vanilla LMs under both targeted and static settings. We showcase how PBNs'
interpretability can help us to understand PBNs' robustness properties.
Finally, our ablation studies reveal the sensitivity of PBNs' robustness to how
strictly clustering is done in the training phase, as tighter clustering
results in less robust PBNs.
|
[
-0.1123418286,
-0.771058321,
0.170193091,
-0.150450021,
-0.1029579118,
0.1576720476,
-0.1781840026,
-0.5388119221,
-0.1986769587,
0.3825584054,
0.0595100746,
-0.4923365712,
-0.6460541487,
0.0789370611,
-0.8331615329,
1.0900857449,
0.2478239387,
-0.4984125793,
-0.1770056337,
-0.105892472,
0.0696570203,
-0.5802258849,
-0.7092872858,
-0.230842784,
0.5462198257,
0.1142175049,
1.081366539,
0.8855754733,
0.7164366245,
0.452976644,
-0.4498571455,
-0.037738923,
-0.2629012167,
0.2465699613,
-0.230810523,
-0.6761061549,
-0.2734023333,
-0.405377686,
0.5808531046,
0.8774930835,
0.253680855,
0.0057652425,
0.307328999,
0.4336949885,
-0.6229982972,
0.0778877065,
-0.9045513868,
-0.0657945201,
-0.3842247427,
0.0386071354,
-0.6351386309,
-0.0166298617,
0.3844724894,
-0.2545904219,
0.805431366,
0.1194545999,
1.2123336792,
0.1434371918,
-0.1927074492,
-0.192247957,
-0.6373018026,
0.5990713239,
-0.5923545361,
0.05902211,
0.1995362192,
0.1499023736,
-0.3771223426,
-1.0524982214,
-0.3344001174,
-0.0730426088,
-0.2343664616,
0.0356412753,
-0.372664243,
0.2362292409,
0.1489987671,
0.6680214405,
-0.5719850659,
0.4876022041,
-0.3951018155,
-0.3028566241,
0.3437669277,
0.0714072585,
0.3581312001,
-0.0963649303,
-0.3096099794,
-0.2273326963,
-0.3726581633,
0.3050631881,
0.4402332306,
0.5174317956,
-0.1866393536,
0.3257160485,
-0.0071083535,
0.956146121,
-0.0715985894,
-0.3678627014,
-0.0470953621,
-0.3400730789,
-0.2670324445,
-0.1314463913,
0.9829975367,
0.1223191246,
0.0151671488,
-0.4685823619,
-0.1305344254,
0.2634995878,
0.57039994,
-0.7362601757,
-0.6938147545,
0.1324271262,
-0.9026418924,
-0.9997842908,
0.2369384766,
-0.6056056023,
-0.3827127814,
0.1908785105,
0.4581296444,
-0.1667063087,
-0.2910965979,
0.0271785259,
-0.2636109293,
-0.1047059372,
0.1045101136,
-1.0670807362,
0.563662231,
0.5411168337,
1.1730922461,
-0.329898864,
-0.1428490877,
-0.1285933256,
-0.0536908172,
-0.1670522094,
0.7289940119,
0.1014794037,
-0.2811043561,
-0.0832958072,
-0.1256988943,
-0.2693043649,
-0.6052258611,
0.45660308,
-0.4405726492,
-0.0136902258,
0.3060272932,
-0.1982657164,
-0.2038473636,
0.3938210905,
-0.8040177822,
0.7302518487,
-0.0914933607,
-1.1112318039,
0.2764813602,
-0.2761453092,
-0.7185434699,
-0.1933386922,
-0.0110276584,
-0.9187211394,
0.1018797234,
-0.0653132796,
0.8170980215,
0.0686825812,
0.0192424841,
-0.5273198485,
-0.4178907573,
0.457313925,
-0.6096506715,
0.7930910587,
0.2021169364,
-0.4095521271,
0.1946359575,
-0.9268314242,
-0.0857907385,
0.1910705268,
-0.2539582849,
-0.3892787695,
0.2088519037,
0.0941764042,
-0.0525605641,
0.1153636947,
-0.4687105119,
-0.1291970462,
-0.6796544194,
0.6261661649,
0.6820927262,
-0.1702343076,
0.4298464656,
-0.5841266513,
0.2389056534,
-0.1585345417,
0.1768660098,
-0.2181135863,
-0.716561079,
-0.8002129197,
-0.3229973018,
0.3243277371,
0.4935333133,
-0.608137548,
0.4495132864,
-0.178660199,
-0.5384761691,
0.1360945702,
0.1079462171,
0.2901557982,
0.6079480648,
0.164396286,
-0.4599791467,
-0.3526869714,
-0.9976318479,
0.0135334898,
-0.7861067653,
0.0252983794,
0.0364369266,
0.349568218,
0.0555585995,
0.7744811177,
-0.3019210398,
-0.0445876531,
-0.3700563312,
0.1201993451,
0.0583144426,
0.4430572093,
0.4779846966,
-1.0054085255,
-0.3590134978,
0.2300554067,
-0.6269540191,
-0.0026125035,
-0.3754446507,
0.2312635779,
-0.1993093044,
0.7059194446,
-0.1410545111,
0.6828855872,
0.5566942692,
-0.1555540115,
0.6384401917,
0.056002412,
-0.4213357568,
-1.1185697317,
0.2562374175,
0.1607058495,
-0.2906395793,
-0.6369240284,
0.0278980341,
-0.2002155036,
-0.1310200095,
-0.3591623306,
0.3584672809,
-0.0758979395,
-0.2098784,
-0.405387342,
-0.165261969,
0.2303238809,
0.2281607091,
-0.0096030636,
0.7062954307,
0.6496114731,
-0.681494534,
0.2318969071,
0.3401567936,
-0.2000011206,
0.3911587894,
-0.6691129804,
-0.1126530096,
-0.0338167138,
0.1100752577,
-1.0074644089,
-0.2120748013,
0.1639903635,
-0.6164237857,
0.4735628664,
-0.0912193283,
-0.5661740899,
-0.2506247759,
-0.1407025009,
0.1699193418,
0.3617906868,
-0.6721714735,
0.3757562637,
0.0578315407,
0.0300329179,
-0.4698962867,
-0.696110189,
0.3289989233,
-0.3610851467,
-0.6261992455,
0.5065472722,
0.2952917516,
-0.2139736563,
0.0876377001,
-0.1870003939,
-0.4650654197,
0.6296399832,
0.4896322787,
0.1410187334,
-0.2623826861,
-0.0517013632,
-0.1938053817,
-0.0461439937,
0.0272093937,
-0.2391474992,
0.1789728999,
-0.3462034166,
-0.0045396774,
-0.7358819246,
-0.0061343121,
0.7707280517,
-0.0541746393,
0.842623353,
0.6716200709,
-0.295301497,
-0.5303944349,
-0.1431107521,
-0.2487818897,
-0.5467650294,
0.4744579494,
-0.4454033971,
-0.7899174094,
0.5846346021,
-0.1009909138,
0.0524602756,
0.3581272662,
0.3615773916,
-0.2518290877,
0.6666243076,
0.8136204481,
0.024238145,
0.5568059683,
-0.2334528118,
0.0547806174,
-0.6445755363,
-0.2624204457,
-0.8675177693,
-0.3312056065,
-0.5932372808,
0.0938789696,
0.0386699773,
0.1952768117,
-0.0633108243,
0.5936505198,
-0.4936065078,
0.2781234384,
0.4291707873,
0.2260464728,
0.1619622707,
0.1486758292,
-0.2102701962,
0.0736968368,
-1.1047718525,
-0.6411379576,
0.9585710168,
0.6283060908,
0.6214221716,
0.2073432654,
0.4243378937,
0.1722501665,
0.4115580022,
-0.8645124435,
0.5001272559,
-0.6009943485,
-0.4614945352,
-0.0082677025,
-0.5323922038,
-1.1006838083,
0.1104207933,
-0.4585653841,
-0.8909838796,
0.2940063775,
0.114408344,
-0.3068965077,
0.7503031492,
-0.5789638758,
0.9007028341,
-0.1760981828,
-0.2899974287,
0.2409694344,
-0.8033528924,
0.2023182511,
-0.1115560159,
0.0106741134,
0.3000313342,
0.0200384054,
0.6705336571,
-0.3603329957,
1.2494581938,
0.342258513,
0.2763513923,
0.1375677586,
0.1471268088,
0.3173848391,
-0.1261151433,
-0.0764869824,
0.1902865469,
-0.2297271788,
-0.4140267372,
-0.722830236,
0.3764993846,
-0.6814370155,
-0.2732522488,
-0.4312853515,
-0.2325539738,
-0.084301047,
0.3211082518,
0.6031995416,
0.7827085257,
-0.117585361,
0.6430621147,
0.7941650748,
-0.1182034463,
0.5373649597,
0.0863989443,
0.0853354633,
-0.2531972229,
0.8681560159,
-0.1839097738,
0.5173859,
0.6510413885,
0.2098785341,
-0.2958781123,
-1.3920578957,
-0.4718377888,
-0.3235535324,
-0.5899680257,
-0.2731356621,
-0.5095741153,
-0.4279296398,
-0.0102070114,
-0.3488883674,
-0.3811236918,
-0.3272934258,
-0.4881329536,
0.0436265022,
-0.0205998328,
0.7206162214,
0.170825839,
0.7438520789,
-0.5922733545,
0.1315288842,
0.2912603021,
0.4081848264,
0.0125456303,
-0.5032632947,
-0.3019993305,
-0.492061913,
-0.3498269022,
-0.8424969316,
0.051580064,
0.4214996397,
0.2719837427,
0.7166932225,
0.1885049045,
0.2409572899,
-0.1671219766,
0.6113187671,
0.2880079746,
-0.7627252936,
0.4435747564,
-0.4749788344,
0.0724025667,
0.672227025,
0.0141886631,
-0.0675427914,
-0.5654553771,
-0.6982520223,
-0.7410648465,
0.4516559243,
0.4484190941,
0.0903794914,
0.0672731921,
0.6660596132,
-0.0846903995,
0.0204797182,
-0.7952691913,
-0.3750900328,
-0.3930229843,
-0.4078525007,
0.1780207902,
0.0228190403,
0.1051888764,
0.2395886928,
0.3229458034,
-0.1937298328,
0.0808407068,
0.2405177355,
0.1582210213,
0.2113940567,
0.0828950778,
0.3843941391,
0.3361104131,
-0.3100641072,
0.3895283639,
-0.0441203304,
-0.697502315,
0.239743948,
-0.0463078581,
-0.4661692381,
0.0171587467,
0.6770350933,
0.7587789297,
0.1414107233,
-0.350562036,
0.645750165,
-0.303616792,
-0.1159678698,
0.0395769812,
0.3073461056,
-0.3974709809,
0.0008474256,
0.1506966352,
0.7714322805,
0.2844221592,
-0.455427587,
0.318520695,
0.5110812783,
-0.4951476455,
-0.409720093,
0.6300824881,
0.1273943931,
-0.2930223048,
0.269584924,
-0.041455321,
-0.7693876624,
0.8035936356,
0.7733948231,
0.8398306966,
0.0627004579,
0.2930465639,
0.1549085528,
0.5628931522,
-0.1743938029,
-0.3918645084,
0.0368644111,
-0.8891961575,
-0.3373245895,
-0.6380158067,
-0.5238402486,
0.3903571665,
-0.7872206569,
0.0782878846,
-0.998157382,
-0.4116826653,
0.1588775218,
-0.2623626888,
-0.2921067178,
0.5078934431,
-0.0152102169,
0.6572098136,
-0.8848430514,
0.5942460299,
1.077911377,
-0.0121517787,
-0.6731858253,
0.0942610577,
0.0383623093,
-0.3061413169,
0.4354071915,
0.252885133,
-0.0633499324,
-0.1628685892,
-0.1958693117,
-0.6315649748,
0.8642036915,
0.0706553832,
-0.1995058358,
0.0439438038,
0.0224056765,
0.6672921181,
-0.0756323561,
-0.071470581,
0.0457755625,
-0.0429173112,
0.055921033,
-1.1018154621,
-0.0217093471,
-0.3728896081,
0.0928790495,
0.1624599695,
-0.747249186,
0.7387564182,
0.0051198299,
-0.3303408027,
0.4319156706,
0.6051925421,
-0.2805038393,
0.3329867721,
0.5102525353,
0.5416975617,
0.6032150984,
-0.2491063923,
1.0023349524,
0.0029177838,
0.0596409403,
0.8915141225,
0.1244169176,
0.9603571296,
0.0661328733,
-0.212634474,
0.5691619515,
0.4881370366,
-0.1273483634,
0.3709779978,
0.1824661791,
-0.2721281648,
-0.0746919438,
0.0443094373,
-0.1139922813,
0.6824664474,
0.3846791387,
-0.498786062,
-0.0905637518,
-0.0390909612,
0.0305115636,
0.3762681782,
-0.3601160347,
0.7828632593,
0.0859866813,
-0.1222802699,
0.2645635903,
0.3194280267,
0.8712543845,
-0.4865182936,
0.4899478257,
0.089794293,
0.415589869,
-0.4493994117,
-0.547745049,
0.6001445651,
-0.1964350343,
-0.3318170905,
0.0519471169,
1.0577948093,
0.1436643153,
-0.3299406469,
0.0166398156,
0.2830156684,
-0.0500834845,
0.172814846,
-0.6560758352,
0.2299999148,
0.0042133029,
0.07369259,
0.4875068665,
0.2247123569,
0.0270551611,
0.7305061817,
0.8056066632,
0.4279461205,
0.0336818472,
-0.3874095678,
0.7251258492,
-0.3380635679,
-0.6304821372,
-0.8486768007,
0.3929622173,
-0.222272262,
-0.4079777598,
0.8073037863,
0.4705244303,
0.78385818,
0.2090547979,
0.8341607451,
0.1085457578,
0.2582566142,
-0.459064126,
0.9022155404,
-0.3328602016,
0.4303110838,
-0.1750600636,
-0.8066592216,
-0.7097107172,
0.7179951072,
-0.0191926882,
-0.2621441483,
0.5802125335,
0.7138189077,
-0.1807586551,
0.0628514513,
0.2481105328,
0.1476968825,
0.3777975738,
0.2318558097,
0.7154808044,
-0.5150488019,
0.7950012684,
-0.4184702635,
-0.3077210784,
-0.0668531582,
-0.8323385119,
-1.2118885517,
-0.4068302214,
-0.6184142232,
-0.6794582605,
0.2932627797,
0.3562346101,
0.9524002671,
-0.9265871644,
-0.0705218911,
-0.349665463,
0.2149091512,
-0.1342342794,
-0.2310049683,
0.5893139839,
-0.4183928967,
-0.4613118768,
0.3821255863,
0.2257250398,
0.4727339149,
-0.2461362183,
0.2865662873,
0.2948573232,
-0.1953236014,
0.3186428547,
0.5709511042,
-0.4531418383,
-0.1334107667,
-0.0486521386,
-0.1106502935,
-0.1223041266,
0.715261817,
-0.77191329,
0.5688931346,
0.4089694023,
0.8355486989,
0.0561816283,
-0.0009190968,
0.4668667912,
-0.954564929,
0.447694093,
0.309266299,
0.2262179703,
0.4433077276,
-0.2546723783,
0.0947728455,
0.4289073944,
-0.4803833663,
-1.0005292892,
0.2953810096,
-0.806019485,
-0.3831779361,
0.9043942094,
-0.3707545996,
-0.2754249573,
-0.6641812325,
-0.053981211,
0.0947332308,
-0.0202204864,
0.8653639555,
0.5134051442,
0.104011409,
-0.1516464055,
-0.2902186215,
0.6066468358,
0.4221939445,
-0.6344695687,
-0.28190431,
0.0508537479,
0.1014219448,
0.480684787,
0.1903533041,
-0.1379101425,
0.2267349213,
0.2342037112,
-0.4300042093,
-0.230882138,
-0.555120945,
-0.3534027338,
0.6702799797,
0.3216762543,
-0.2588743567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06622v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06622v2
|
TrainerAgent: Customizable and Efficient Model Training through LLM-Powered Multi-Agent System
| 2023-11-11T17:39:24 | 2023-11-23T10:57:10 |
Haoyuan Li, Hao Jiang, Tianke Zhang, Zhelun Yu, Aoxiong Yin, Hao Cheng, Siming Fu, Yuhao Zhang, Wanggui He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Training AI models has always been challenging, especially when there is a
need for custom models to provide personalized services. Algorithm engineers
often face a lengthy process to iteratively develop models tailored to specific
business requirements, making it even more difficult for non-experts. The quest
for high-quality and efficient model development, along with the emergence of
Large Language Model (LLM) Agents, has become a key focus in the industry.
Leveraging the powerful analytical, planning, and decision-making capabilities
of LLM, we propose a TrainerAgent system comprising a multi-agent framework
including Task, Data, Model and Server agents. These agents analyze
user-defined tasks, input data, and requirements (e.g., accuracy, speed),
optimizing them comprehensively from both data and model perspectives to obtain
satisfactory models, and finally deploy these models as online service.
Experimental evaluations on classical discriminative and generative tasks in
computer vision and natural language processing domains demonstrate that our
system consistently produces models that meet the desired criteria.
Furthermore, the system exhibits the ability to critically identify and reject
unattainable tasks, such as fantastical scenarios or unethical requests,
ensuring robustness and safety. This research presents a significant
advancement in achieving desired models with increased efficiency and quality
as compared to traditional model development, facilitated by the integration of
LLM-powered analysis, decision-making, and execution capabilities, as well as
the collaboration among four agents. We anticipate that our work will
contribute to the advancement of research on TrainerAgent in both academic and
industry communities, potentially establishing it as a new paradigm for model
development in the field of AI.
|
[
-0.4018031359,
-0.4072832167,
0.4331965148,
0.2030892074,
0.0684192702,
0.3734432757,
-0.2362273037,
-0.4472849965,
0.3812153935,
0.5462679863,
-0.4671507478,
-0.2208352536,
-0.4753877819,
0.149731487,
-0.4475392699,
0.6797668338,
-0.0731630698,
0.5100835562,
-0.2309967726,
-0.0324085057,
-0.4811389446,
-0.7375404239,
-0.7485973835,
-0.818585217,
0.1981732398,
0.236573413,
0.408429414,
0.6861894727,
0.3955870271,
0.4764272869,
0.3930678368,
0.3261523545,
-0.3495106697,
0.239284277,
-0.0252547301,
-0.4261635244,
-0.813581109,
0.0256979261,
0.3579512537,
0.3499418497,
-0.2611577809,
0.1648987532,
-0.1188828722,
0.2552877367,
-0.4765607119,
0.3534462452,
-0.7351956367,
0.0066044684,
0.2546323836,
-0.274646908,
-0.4716578424,
-0.0230982359,
-0.0906843022,
-0.6758804321,
0.3359743059,
-0.2095350325,
0.5653884411,
0.4481602013,
-0.2662208974,
-0.0023151408,
-0.8911219239,
0.5653119683,
-0.4582649469,
0.5877007842,
0.1591936499,
0.7346249819,
-0.0474799909,
-0.7888824344,
-0.251188606,
-0.5694730282,
0.2516875565,
0.1556271911,
0.1228606999,
0.0931916088,
0.0423939191,
-0.2237587571,
-0.4513200521,
0.5042085052,
0.0179070421,
-0.1157452911,
0.7661290765,
0.4162771106,
0.0997873768,
0.4838399291,
-0.0861219615,
0.0950520784,
-0.4424893558,
-0.2473223954,
0.4894087017,
0.3245792091,
-0.0248764269,
0.3875948489,
-0.2935522795,
0.3310274184,
0.0832067057,
-0.2855736017,
0.1234029457,
0.0711763874,
-0.1248427331,
0.0244421232,
0.6096972227,
-0.0215072837,
0.2709368765,
-0.550668478,
-0.4711444676,
0.1601451039,
0.4866626263,
-0.9192913175,
-0.1991189867,
0.0391985774,
-0.2757658064,
-0.4947040081,
-0.3271314502,
-0.5132599473,
-0.5781601071,
-0.5098232627,
0.3626216352,
-0.3100723624,
-0.4323126376,
-0.0111402394,
-0.0553347543,
0.1883423328,
0.5278356075,
-1.0357824564,
0.2341734916,
0.5508623123,
0.680526197,
-0.1211652234,
-0.6376482844,
-0.3068919182,
0.2795070112,
-0.2912226617,
0.6792327762,
-0.6620715261,
-0.2520114481,
-0.0296030305,
-0.1419769078,
-0.1736289561,
-0.3423749804,
0.1006958634,
-0.7651357651,
-0.34965837,
0.3339076638,
-0.6354897022,
0.0055818139,
0.6550837755,
-0.6460712552,
0.6545138359,
-0.0045270878,
-0.3668290377,
0.2641415894,
-0.82384938,
-0.1493140161,
0.3561493158,
-0.3658218682,
-0.4971094131,
-0.2574708462,
0.1002107486,
0.558059454,
-0.5026055574,
0.2117985785,
-0.2919664383,
-0.2443766296,
0.3274473846,
-0.2898802757,
0.4401869774,
0.1089065224,
-0.4380886853,
0.2993452549,
-0.986156404,
0.2055025697,
0.2938296199,
-0.4911736548,
0.0113392258,
0.0453231186,
0.1046820208,
0.0421488695,
0.4503711164,
-0.3612508476,
0.3434085548,
-0.2524966002,
0.4200027585,
0.7780779004,
-0.1827003062,
0.4258882701,
-0.2955725491,
0.7123200297,
-0.5078595877,
0.2335325778,
0.0348395929,
-0.1594886184,
-0.8412475586,
-0.3856898248,
0.0218899623,
0.424831003,
-0.907562077,
0.2976572812,
-0.2991214693,
-0.8102765679,
-0.4738330841,
0.1375035942,
0.2885292172,
0.2207684517,
0.0970049873,
-0.1809461117,
-0.5406942368,
-0.7150485516,
-0.0161786675,
-0.0191669632,
0.0974215865,
0.0780941471,
0.643101871,
-0.3586754799,
0.9464464784,
-0.1509899199,
-0.0869651735,
-0.6158178449,
-0.1235502437,
-0.0709687471,
0.489708513,
0.6819028854,
-0.8082481027,
-0.4520846009,
0.1924456358,
-0.8863798976,
0.0466372669,
0.0108964862,
-0.1512263715,
-0.1331186295,
0.2199432105,
-0.5763642788,
0.2001511455,
0.2359357774,
-0.0898131654,
0.6743401885,
-0.3680583537,
0.1351417899,
-1.0557504892,
0.1285146177,
-0.1829225272,
-0.3632599115,
-1.0326818228,
0.2585262656,
-0.0982837752,
-0.2368385494,
-0.2805941403,
0.4442642629,
-0.3797802925,
-0.1000883058,
-0.5554037094,
-0.0902020335,
-0.1397282332,
0.7523057461,
0.0801101774,
0.8106526136,
0.5230391026,
-0.6071786284,
0.7174369097,
0.4101758897,
0.0600859225,
0.6956112385,
-0.4821031392,
0.5537664294,
0.0646279007,
-0.1256818026,
-0.1090934575,
-0.3757779002,
0.1492768526,
-0.4830715954,
0.1301215291,
-0.0905364603,
-0.6681880951,
-0.1549521536,
-0.0320359282,
0.1523844451,
0.2456090003,
-0.6042285562,
0.760230124,
0.3885218501,
0.2749458551,
-0.5025448799,
-0.4956535101,
0.217036441,
-0.0672659129,
-0.5405991673,
0.1895907968,
-0.1241208315,
-0.1187064201,
-0.1456961632,
0.2304343283,
-0.374242872,
0.3490464091,
0.326861918,
0.2150808573,
0.0436637513,
0.2722960114,
-0.3242569864,
-0.1822050661,
0.0911364108,
-0.347705245,
0.6523610353,
-0.0963029563,
-0.5553820133,
-0.4494893253,
0.1882068813,
0.5867404938,
-0.5732223988,
0.882286787,
0.521548748,
-0.4105326235,
-0.4590072036,
-0.5514563918,
-0.2030182779,
-0.49919191,
0.6639043689,
-0.4337713718,
-0.6928440332,
0.4413850009,
-0.1917337626,
0.1059234142,
0.0798529312,
0.9163473248,
0.3234548867,
1.4029052258,
0.9387549758,
-0.1863564551,
0.6997438073,
-0.5259885192,
-0.0577586591,
-0.3727663159,
-0.4316883087,
-0.533437252,
0.0096186725,
-0.4430660903,
-0.0220149439,
0.4995599091,
-0.4758073092,
-0.6440005302,
0.1511224061,
-0.5542143583,
0.3982203901,
0.5462855697,
0.2204016298,
0.2858552933,
-0.140914306,
0.1192026362,
0.233531177,
-0.6135395169,
-0.8044493794,
1.2130976915,
0.3929776549,
0.8345943689,
0.1539312005,
0.6946364641,
0.3898350596,
0.4279210865,
-0.762896955,
0.5731955767,
0.0735509992,
-0.6860020757,
-0.1428797692,
-0.2805365622,
-0.7825546861,
0.2845712304,
-0.2509044409,
-0.7292450666,
0.0046719494,
0.1463757306,
0.0083862673,
0.4613684118,
-0.6039374471,
0.814912498,
-0.595042944,
-0.3786877692,
-0.4738485217,
-0.4118152559,
0.2338094413,
-0.3226346076,
-0.0771581084,
-0.1889343262,
-0.0120076751,
0.7044759989,
-0.6662918329,
0.7908923626,
-0.2646608055,
0.3044015467,
0.1016688198,
-0.138811931,
0.5718871951,
-0.2604351938,
-0.3712838292,
-0.1753033996,
-0.0969856903,
-0.3133529127,
-0.6913182735,
0.434022963,
-1.2038966417,
-0.4043977857,
-0.1261787713,
-0.5181556344,
-0.4087925553,
0.3090847433,
0.0246496405,
0.3532529175,
-0.2862155139,
-0.0987370536,
0.3749416471,
0.125602141,
0.2324073166,
0.7339176536,
0.0237769466,
-0.3426541984,
1.0276418924,
-0.0014289162,
0.1705604196,
0.3166338503,
-0.1019439399,
0.0557660758,
-0.7773973942,
-0.362844795,
0.0536884703,
-0.8472872376,
-0.2541124821,
-0.3557720184,
-0.4784704149,
-0.4277290702,
-0.2005776316,
-0.6348505616,
-0.0487275049,
-0.4434141517,
0.0591811612,
0.290627867,
0.9482970238,
0.3110332191,
0.6663505435,
-0.6267585754,
-0.0381210446,
0.3404875696,
0.293828398,
0.027718531,
-0.2533191144,
-0.7280650735,
-0.1823450327,
-0.5917875171,
-0.8861063719,
0.5744614601,
0.1451984197,
0.8851999044,
0.4297093749,
-0.1664054096,
0.2564880848,
-0.466304183,
0.4308907688,
0.1007751822,
-0.7234435081,
0.3313570023,
-0.2294072211,
-0.1079196036,
0.4864462912,
0.2698697746,
-0.190541178,
-0.4639831483,
-0.514538765,
-0.454534173,
0.7790523767,
0.1190115809,
0.0878666192,
0.473819524,
0.5702536106,
0.1606795639,
0.5343298912,
-0.6100803614,
-0.1668341309,
-0.3495433927,
-0.2375301421,
0.0209577959,
0.1775408387,
-0.1410318017,
-0.0407890305,
0.9246958494,
-0.4172309637,
0.3906306028,
-0.1418541074,
-0.258957237,
0.0820668638,
0.1922640502,
0.2496983558,
0.7252814174,
-0.0541672558,
-0.006487926,
0.2756170332,
-0.4856069386,
0.6032389402,
0.3773269057,
-0.1083700061,
-0.2373532951,
0.5012215376,
0.8746260405,
-0.108904615,
-0.7444083095,
0.3739717603,
-0.1141821146,
-0.2350288928,
-0.6464665532,
0.3410211802,
-0.0623089671,
0.7518225312,
0.2672962546,
-0.0070809987,
0.0357857905,
-0.1342374384,
-0.0297601242,
0.5827302337,
-0.1490410566,
-0.3740365207,
0.7014457583,
0.3299356997,
-0.6376428008,
0.4113545418,
-0.3373498023,
-0.6238384843,
0.929487586,
0.404469341,
0.9737094045,
-0.2414191216,
0.2448245883,
-0.1048739105,
0.3070976734,
-0.0811201483,
0.0113411881,
0.1431099772,
-0.934343338,
-0.1884269118,
-0.5951623321,
-0.6368333697,
0.2266383469,
-0.2592264712,
0.3021137118,
-0.5128521323,
-0.3064470291,
0.029640181,
0.0872708037,
-0.9129613042,
0.0774812624,
-0.0439084992,
0.816562891,
-0.6294565797,
1.0150864124,
0.9632019401,
-0.5884636641,
-0.9760052562,
-0.4068827927,
-0.1169058084,
-0.9779714346,
0.7190026641,
0.2322039157,
-0.2348341942,
0.2730688155,
-0.5676717758,
-0.5738195777,
1.3581697941,
0.8313430548,
-0.44931072,
-0.2061756998,
0.2803533971,
0.7082936168,
-0.7057326436,
0.478903681,
0.6557728648,
0.2862941325,
0.050830029,
-0.9495327473,
-0.1602381915,
-0.3463046253,
-0.0786427855,
-0.0858699754,
-0.7273569107,
0.7219834924,
0.0290435217,
0.2024457753,
0.308763504,
0.4163952768,
0.1572824717,
0.239539817,
0.3860779703,
0.1574147642,
0.6613776088,
0.2463837117,
0.8164849877,
-0.5471729636,
0.4178965688,
0.940289259,
-0.349280566,
0.478829056,
0.2156760395,
-0.0681860745,
0.2264716625,
0.548451066,
-0.2588230669,
0.3722479343,
0.0667008981,
-0.4104556441,
-0.581045568,
-0.2971739471,
-0.0214181393,
0.703094244,
0.0396017358,
-0.2890885174,
-0.1104406044,
0.349581182,
-0.2253933549,
0.0233987253,
-0.3849888146,
0.7695512176,
-0.1680057645,
-0.3551692665,
0.4042558074,
0.1715201735,
0.3991691172,
-0.7719937563,
-0.0344499089,
0.0343442746,
0.3756905198,
-0.1335218698,
-0.1177754328,
-0.1617194116,
0.1702330261,
0.060308367,
-0.2862431407,
0.7565581203,
-0.2251440734,
-0.3495886028,
0.3195189834,
0.6787822247,
0.2528489232,
0.0677192584,
-0.6936587095,
0.0250331163,
-0.3139716983,
-0.1709659398,
0.2282330543,
0.1826437712,
0.0569462962,
0.9795892835,
0.288626194,
0.2457852662,
-0.0075872587,
0.2395881861,
0.939381063,
-0.2451233715,
-0.5625353456,
-0.7185706496,
0.3486123383,
-0.1285507679,
-0.0407238044,
0.503534317,
0.4427794516,
0.6000114679,
-0.0333807021,
1.0545394421,
0.2009118199,
0.181883961,
-0.4168484509,
0.8671765924,
-0.5537603498,
0.2591338158,
0.0953934863,
-0.6775327325,
-0.0569977947,
0.3741995692,
-0.2668788731,
0.4006896913,
0.2915282845,
0.8527416587,
-0.0845202208,
-0.1635040045,
0.4358734787,
-0.0483928248,
0.8146253228,
0.4735484719,
0.8956474066,
-0.0292497259,
0.4816690385,
-0.3299366534,
-0.2361232191,
-0.4099121988,
-0.4653502107,
-1.1385713816,
-0.5053800941,
-0.1670651585,
0.0554223619,
0.2405843884,
1.3178913593,
0.9309694171,
-0.5383326411,
-0.5295457244,
-0.1715041399,
-0.1047860757,
-0.1349545717,
-0.1398088038,
0.1894930601,
-0.4715670645,
-0.7465826869,
0.4582806826,
0.0182033293,
0.1363926381,
-0.7240848541,
-0.5672926307,
0.0372114331,
0.0580946766,
0.3566937149,
0.1599714905,
-0.3828046918,
-0.218787834,
-0.0972946063,
-0.2339490652,
-0.0128378673,
0.7949825525,
-0.5760144591,
0.5570476651,
0.0546343178,
1.030679822,
0.5279558301,
-0.3508626223,
0.5206564665,
-0.6464785337,
0.2872220874,
0.3012869656,
0.3728055358,
0.474809438,
-0.4081341922,
0.4920919538,
0.2714761794,
-0.781750977,
-0.7543235421,
0.2453175932,
-0.546235919,
-0.0361691676,
0.7299883962,
-0.1601691842,
-0.1080406085,
-0.019831771,
-0.1744465679,
0.5591306686,
-0.3776715994,
0.7764860988,
0.4472118914,
-0.5443055034,
-0.0803931579,
-0.6500858068,
0.3042860031,
0.1774010658,
-1.1776078939,
-0.2819168866,
0.3326156735,
0.2206419557,
0.1479547769,
0.5257598758,
0.6104884148,
0.2717089653,
0.1568625569,
0.5644610524,
-0.5780481696,
-0.3897108436,
-0.3279061913,
0.1837060452,
0.4812809825,
-0.3602273762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06612v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06612v1
|
PerceptionGPT: Effectively Fusing Visual Perception into LLM
| 2023-11-11T16:59:20 | 2023-11-11T16:59:20 |
Renjie Pi, Lewei Yao, Jiahui Gao, Jipeng Zhang, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The integration of visual inputs with large language models (LLMs) has led to
remarkable advancements in multi-modal capabilities, giving rise to visual
large language models (VLLMs). However, effectively harnessing VLLMs for
intricate visual perception tasks remains a challenge. In this paper, we
present a novel end-to-end framework named PerceptionGPT, which efficiently and
effectively equips the VLLMs with visual perception abilities by leveraging the
representation power of LLMs' token embedding. Our proposed method treats the
token embedding of the LLM as the carrier of spatial information, then leverage
lightweight visual task encoders and decoders to perform visual perception
tasks (e.g., detection, segmentation). Our approach significantly alleviates
the training difficulty suffered by previous approaches that formulate the
visual outputs as discrete tokens, and enables achieving superior performance
with fewer trainable parameters, less training data and shorted training time.
Moreover, as only one token embedding is required to decode the visual outputs,
the resulting sequence length during inference is significantly reduced.
Consequently, our approach enables accurate and flexible representations,
seamless integration of visual perception tasks, and efficient handling of a
multiple of visual outputs. We validate the effectiveness and efficiency of our
approach through extensive experiments. The results demonstrate significant
improvements over previous methods with much fewer trainable parameters and GPU
hours, which facilitates future research in enabling LLMs with visual
perception abilities.
|
[
-0.4910660088,
-0.5777602196,
0.7769669294,
0.442838639,
-0.5694037676,
0.0135825081,
-0.3468547463,
-0.5076782107,
0.2038755566,
0.233461231,
-0.2588964701,
-0.5328191519,
-0.6593326926,
-0.23348701,
-0.1576684862,
0.3667580187,
-0.1545566916,
0.140466094,
-0.1732080281,
-0.2588464916,
-0.3822873533,
-0.4966661632,
-0.5905554295,
-0.1871481538,
0.4232176244,
0.0098823225,
0.3837741911,
0.5781093836,
0.5110881925,
0.3388760984,
0.018285362,
0.2402553856,
-0.3997846246,
-0.3080089986,
-0.2904766202,
-0.4160243869,
-0.1552733928,
-0.2737625539,
0.4794201255,
0.5554890037,
-0.0946851671,
0.0843820646,
0.155168578,
0.3681686521,
-0.6395823359,
0.4732942283,
-0.6407440305,
0.442145288,
-0.0058474457,
-0.294107765,
-0.4254469275,
0.2684364915,
0.0767337233,
-0.6772072911,
-0.0229295213,
0.4356329739,
0.4053841829,
0.4022978544,
-0.4248825908,
0.1639403999,
-0.4051593244,
0.5745067596,
-0.4041395485,
0.7297162414,
-0.045813445,
0.4614405036,
0.0970276669,
-0.9229961634,
-0.7255431414,
-0.1114610657,
-0.164538905,
0.4194660485,
-0.1911417991,
0.0989615619,
0.2338233143,
0.1407967657,
-0.7048977017,
0.0209477674,
-0.0606356114,
-0.1066124514,
0.0511012897,
0.0057111927,
0.2295484394,
-0.1692605764,
-0.8497968912,
-0.0434977151,
-0.5223678946,
-0.1369883865,
-0.1732659638,
0.0880258456,
-0.2517717779,
0.6554213762,
-0.0523052998,
0.7092685699,
0.0709048286,
-0.0214507673,
0.2727633119,
-0.3934702873,
-0.5042687654,
-0.1154007688,
0.6783195734,
0.3940265477,
0.0679825023,
-0.1889953166,
-0.2061896324,
0.1192522049,
0.2036780864,
-0.7389798164,
-0.0469369926,
-0.1144353151,
-0.3956498802,
-0.1064028367,
0.0947319567,
-0.6830717325,
-0.3826522827,
-0.4409489632,
0.3550306261,
-0.3828698695,
-0.1543879211,
0.3567134738,
-0.2190592289,
0.4851056635,
0.6089106202,
-0.8212407231,
0.1065903306,
0.6852478385,
0.8883169889,
-0.2956653237,
-0.368467927,
-0.6343324184,
0.5880795121,
-0.1979212612,
0.6797023416,
-0.5519091487,
-0.1661185324,
-0.2231863588,
-0.0695508495,
-0.0384126343,
-0.41675964,
0.0870712548,
-0.3687716424,
-0.2221869379,
-0.2697877288,
-0.2896834314,
-0.1073832139,
0.6215780377,
-0.4788946211,
0.7494491339,
0.1562055349,
-0.7239006162,
0.7525277138,
-0.5663076043,
-0.2929030359,
0.2493368983,
-0.7342640162,
-0.1472518742,
0.2484863997,
0.6446713209,
0.6007282138,
-0.1009436622,
-0.0390236937,
-0.3208036125,
-0.3681051731,
0.0664525405,
-0.5642613173,
0.2599900365,
-0.0629801154,
-0.4697424471,
0.3272047937,
-0.6248984337,
-0.0150269242,
0.1446771473,
-0.4913942516,
-0.1586440504,
-0.1771792471,
0.4066980481,
0.2581599057,
0.4821031094,
-0.5807423592,
0.2546052337,
-0.3128478527,
0.7023613453,
0.9587445259,
-0.2997981906,
0.6090641618,
0.2236739993,
0.3706112802,
0.1758571118,
0.2860992253,
-0.2003802657,
-0.3993418217,
-0.6721522212,
-0.4615884721,
-0.2136289924,
0.4757596254,
-1.0487025976,
0.4008280039,
-0.5846803784,
-0.2062549293,
0.0210559033,
0.1110552847,
0.2896685004,
0.3371620178,
0.3038825989,
-0.1149073318,
-0.5254682302,
-0.6750623584,
-0.1045143232,
-0.2027830929,
-0.0633266419,
0.3836552501,
0.5340650082,
-0.3250367343,
0.8340774179,
-0.5040878057,
-0.3065568209,
-0.4930167496,
-0.3086364269,
0.0540368743,
0.3855171502,
0.5817350149,
-0.8572373986,
-0.2564296722,
0.4510935843,
-0.9246458411,
0.1853160858,
-0.0547485463,
-0.210303694,
0.0618197024,
0.6328029633,
-0.4673156142,
0.5461965799,
0.5331306458,
-0.6780091524,
0.3338181078,
-0.2006692737,
0.0125594214,
-0.9467305541,
-0.1030871347,
-0.0335776582,
-0.3960079551,
-0.1308152974,
0.2837155759,
0.0343216211,
-0.3161944747,
-0.5595878363,
0.6512244344,
-0.4603863358,
-0.5052906275,
0.0753075108,
0.0271717049,
0.0841490552,
0.8440788388,
0.0633800402,
0.8015031219,
0.669875741,
-0.1860775799,
0.5694123507,
0.2775352299,
-0.452786088,
0.6511585116,
-0.5910969377,
-0.1383659244,
-0.2290496379,
0.1173087433,
-1.0487296581,
-0.1103341207,
0.3316420913,
-0.1653397232,
0.0878745764,
-0.2944228649,
-0.6330339313,
-0.1407847852,
-0.1005409881,
0.5239529014,
0.4527812004,
-0.9735392928,
1.0820202827,
-0.0286679007,
-0.0069448119,
-0.4197565615,
-1.0797493458,
0.2941673696,
-0.3166485727,
-0.5701177716,
0.2477484047,
0.1249127164,
0.1385047585,
-0.1191970557,
-0.1718835682,
0.2582402229,
-0.2745345831,
0.2933529615,
0.0049342425,
-0.1481361687,
0.1038350016,
-0.2614040077,
-0.2902782261,
-0.0882531181,
-0.7508747578,
0.7052644491,
-0.2065312862,
-1.0845285654,
-0.1820138544,
0.3043937683,
0.7583117485,
-0.6468347311,
0.429259181,
0.9325670004,
-0.2579706311,
-0.3186323047,
-0.4255749285,
0.0165421944,
-0.4872667491,
0.7212793827,
-0.3774279952,
-1.015997529,
0.3692658544,
-0.286585629,
-0.182385996,
-0.1441172361,
0.3365370333,
0.0218497515,
0.8799489141,
0.4997189045,
-0.0298729856,
0.8344470263,
-0.2405586392,
0.5251363516,
-0.9030289054,
-0.4767039716,
0.2002805471,
-0.407417357,
-0.1224951819,
-1.0097130537,
0.664439559,
0.2076400965,
-0.4004274905,
-0.0541967191,
-0.3676852286,
0.4871741235,
0.5051766038,
0.4141170084,
0.2029423565,
0.4800107479,
-0.3295117021,
-0.1654077321,
-0.7592502236,
-0.1563489437,
0.883510232,
0.3439652324,
0.835275054,
0.1420852095,
0.3460780084,
0.132653594,
-0.0717772245,
-0.7919041514,
0.8196030855,
-0.077221781,
0.2612226307,
-0.2765509784,
-0.2338073105,
-0.3905389607,
0.5587566495,
-0.296215415,
-0.8251376152,
0.1733987778,
0.027839765,
0.0313271657,
0.6142121553,
-0.6549911499,
0.9126751423,
-0.3557021916,
-0.5621389747,
-0.0927405432,
-0.2411965579,
0.1794897318,
0.1003445759,
-0.0397774577,
0.160644725,
-0.254201293,
0.4041644335,
-0.384006381,
1.0140829086,
-0.2327500582,
-0.0995130092,
0.0317788646,
0.0405344479,
0.7261519432,
0.2806151807,
0.3829486072,
0.2488935441,
-0.3631430566,
-0.3709394038,
-0.8744087815,
0.5389009714,
-0.5912857652,
-0.3646541238,
-0.2660748363,
-0.4897612631,
-0.1930380166,
0.098701857,
0.0583587363,
0.70877707,
-0.1459765136,
0.0369953103,
0.5190141201,
-0.4686602056,
0.4285508394,
0.0078435401,
-0.6634888053,
-0.591052413,
0.9686653018,
-0.142276004,
0.0250239391,
0.5980365872,
0.0011484158,
-0.4750492871,
-0.7681289315,
-0.6644963026,
-0.0422713421,
-0.907669127,
-0.0104808267,
-0.5992244482,
0.0446586981,
-0.1193222404,
-0.4206385911,
-0.2626712918,
-0.0710888579,
-0.0327395797,
-0.3322173655,
0.3206494749,
0.5915113091,
-0.0306805987,
0.5083047748,
-0.4119346142,
0.3859545887,
0.5778173804,
0.5050234795,
0.1040772498,
-0.2653205991,
-0.2366888225,
-0.2335987538,
0.1418979764,
-0.3976706266,
0.4263188541,
-0.0567645729,
0.4973704815,
0.6340928674,
-0.4398210943,
1.071860671,
-0.5261132717,
0.7468491197,
0.4900668561,
-0.9139519334,
0.3807336986,
-0.3079194725,
0.4026967883,
0.0237108022,
-0.2092796266,
-0.2733515799,
-0.0559838451,
-0.2438771725,
-0.8734228611,
0.3452318609,
0.1484156698,
-0.206140101,
-0.1130321845,
0.010370506,
-0.1170216426,
0.1416084617,
-0.5841352344,
0.0801074579,
-0.3020094931,
-0.156557098,
-0.1522565335,
-0.264395535,
-0.112701565,
-0.4142425954,
0.0165159572,
-0.439047128,
0.4730460644,
0.230317235,
-0.3874233067,
0.3789292574,
0.0777860358,
0.2842925787,
0.7733776569,
0.2510021627,
0.3690835834,
0.3375203013,
-0.3611046076,
-0.0640264899,
-0.0220925007,
0.0940049142,
-0.1225105599,
0.654748857,
0.9518797398,
0.4593021274,
-0.7916073799,
0.8176720142,
-0.0158357434,
-0.0624426827,
-0.4376775026,
-0.251768887,
0.1118806079,
0.6415485144,
0.2582643032,
0.29854846,
0.081777826,
-0.3605318367,
0.2444975525,
0.4490039647,
-0.2523365915,
-0.2238016278,
0.7309445739,
0.0878876671,
0.2212814987,
0.4343982339,
-0.0564638823,
-0.570915997,
0.5400173068,
0.5925257206,
0.4837384224,
0.2278174758,
0.0335634016,
0.149020046,
0.2832055092,
0.1207633466,
0.4320908189,
-0.250647217,
-0.7347647548,
-0.6116111279,
-0.8883315921,
-0.0674129799,
-0.1381758153,
-0.415961802,
-0.0304219425,
-0.6640878916,
0.0888536945,
-0.5534646511,
-0.5936778784,
-0.8759434819,
0.0646008104,
0.3375073671,
0.8101406097,
-0.6188074946,
0.4795402586,
0.8716707826,
-0.2744735479,
-0.6758999228,
-0.2851767242,
-0.2219057381,
-1.3094730377,
0.7603389025,
0.25720945,
-0.1602715701,
0.0313322358,
-0.5913375616,
-0.6099300385,
1.185541749,
0.4972450435,
-0.7702860236,
0.0286505707,
0.4496472776,
0.2289184779,
-0.3065672815,
0.157839179,
0.4204490483,
0.6013931632,
0.3614600897,
-0.7485420704,
0.1696326584,
-0.1472869962,
0.2704272568,
0.1285476238,
-0.5464277864,
0.6985248923,
-0.3006001115,
-0.1351862997,
-0.214867413,
0.6325612664,
0.4172086418,
0.1568891704,
0.5500802398,
0.8677823544,
0.5659211874,
-0.178174153,
0.8538528085,
-0.2524823248,
0.1348142922,
0.8954619765,
-0.1685779989,
0.8160982728,
0.9331945777,
-0.186832428,
-0.0499166287,
0.4498293102,
-0.0270817187,
0.7275599837,
0.3433061838,
-0.5297923684,
-0.5832539201,
-0.0538015887,
-0.3183208704,
0.5683789253,
0.4087587297,
-0.4066953361,
-0.3253694177,
0.4052978158,
-0.4361779094,
-0.0686584339,
-0.5151697397,
0.7507227659,
0.1294450164,
-0.0820894018,
0.268674612,
-0.1426168829,
0.9512186646,
-0.5920261741,
-0.3245985508,
-0.1090132222,
0.2473180592,
-0.2155695111,
-0.846353054,
0.1763985902,
-0.1953694671,
-0.0609293394,
-0.4342754185,
0.6993800402,
-0.3172329962,
-0.5444974899,
0.4775845408,
0.7246870995,
0.1669984758,
-0.4505416453,
-0.325499028,
0.3103911579,
-0.0619807728,
-0.2058239281,
0.3990780413,
0.8104953766,
-0.0757722184,
0.7675995231,
0.7905727625,
0.1090052798,
0.279822439,
0.1898229569,
0.9544363618,
-0.7386181355,
-0.7520494461,
-0.9290285707,
0.3638567328,
0.0431738198,
-0.006670583,
0.4879578352,
0.6535559893,
0.9742724299,
-0.2283364236,
0.9968450665,
0.0016056314,
-0.3309232891,
-0.7451801896,
0.6657102704,
-0.4878413379,
0.2082434148,
-0.0573969483,
-0.9497516751,
-0.291125834,
0.6702740192,
-0.2531476617,
-0.0486794673,
0.6438606977,
0.6749951839,
-0.4314641356,
-0.2876412868,
0.7097132802,
0.1147937253,
0.4115755558,
0.8527863026,
0.825782001,
-0.1096621528,
0.5438118577,
0.0038831942,
-0.0225675795,
0.0809439868,
-0.8541556001,
-1.0372200012,
-0.3792068064,
0.107810095,
0.103494592,
0.082444407,
0.7564318776,
0.6872728467,
-0.3002662063,
0.1810336709,
-0.4066350162,
-0.1570398211,
-0.1304345429,
-0.1859374791,
0.3981169164,
-0.0680621713,
-0.6995918155,
0.4326292872,
0.6933662295,
0.1564528942,
-0.3470159769,
-0.2216143608,
0.3116054237,
-0.4873296916,
1.1219488382,
-0.0286408868,
-0.8748340607,
-0.4413998127,
-0.155303359,
0.0407119542,
0.1718798578,
0.6748997569,
-0.9956784248,
0.3337983787,
0.4708806276,
0.8614160419,
0.6881482601,
-0.1544059664,
0.5649709702,
-0.6675919294,
0.4835304618,
-0.0668834597,
0.9049981236,
0.3363479376,
-0.1755702049,
0.5460777879,
0.359641552,
0.0453345515,
-0.5509312153,
0.4242458045,
-1.5108966827,
-0.0945363864,
1.196950078,
-0.207594797,
-0.3096445203,
0.0444237255,
-0.450792402,
-0.0729437619,
-0.3856209815,
0.2064301074,
0.3510687947,
0.0125237042,
-0.5787646174,
-0.460996598,
-0.0163630582,
0.2097842693,
-0.7343537211,
-0.0325840376,
0.3366459608,
0.2652175725,
-0.1785733402,
0.4762972891,
-0.1058066338,
0.0323347226,
0.1323774606,
0.1219029278,
-0.4904862642,
-0.2475542575,
-0.2466309071,
0.2901913822,
-0.0293181576,
-0.2594223022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06607v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06607v3
|
Monkey: Image Resolution and Text Label Are Important Things for Large Multi-modal Models
| 2023-11-11T16:37:41 | 2024-02-22T06:23:26 |
Zhang Li, Biao Yang, Qiang Liu, Zhiyin Ma, Shuo Zhang, Jingxu Yang, Yabo Sun, Yuliang Liu, Xiang Bai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have shown promise in vision-language tasks
but struggle with high-resolution input and detailed scene understanding.
Addressing these challenges, we introduce Monkey to enhance LMM capabilities.
Firstly, Monkey processes input images by dividing them into uniform patches,
each matching the size (e.g., 448x448) used in the original training of the
well-trained vision encoder. Equipped with individual adapter for each patch,
Monkey can handle higher resolutions up to 1344x896 pixels, enabling the
detailed capture of complex visual information. Secondly, it employs a
multi-level description generation method, enriching the context for
scene-object associations. This two-part strategy ensures more effective
learning from generated data: the higher resolution allows for a more detailed
capture of visuals, which in turn enhances the effectiveness of comprehensive
descriptions. Extensive ablative results validate the effectiveness of our
designs. Additionally, experiments on 18 datasets further demonstrate that
Monkey surpasses existing LMMs in many tasks like Image Captioning and various
Visual Question Answering formats. Specially, in qualitative tests focused on
dense text question answering, Monkey has exhibited encouraging results
compared with GPT4V. Code is available at
https://github.com/Yuliang-Liu/Monkey.
|
[
-0.5795949101,
-0.6368521452,
0.2951507568,
0.4830192029,
-0.2855381072,
0.2171517611,
-0.420245856,
-0.7573994994,
-0.0235379562,
0.4036815166,
-0.173571229,
-0.1689856797,
-0.5986776948,
0.1630355716,
-0.1378526986,
1.1136329174,
-0.0775813311,
-0.0730246827,
-0.3824899793,
-0.2772483826,
-0.4697122276,
-0.2585011721,
-0.6733147502,
-0.1075717211,
1.0753799677,
0.0555524603,
0.9727685452,
0.7589554191,
0.7113865018,
0.3392226696,
-0.1222530007,
0.5970314741,
-0.3336906135,
0.0676446185,
0.0241519753,
-0.107167162,
-0.6294150352,
-0.0355012529,
0.6985247731,
0.4443211555,
0.0954871327,
0.1377719641,
0.1578619182,
0.4401417971,
-0.5984326005,
0.5027700067,
-0.4201450348,
0.0913585499,
-0.0313678943,
-0.2234097421,
-0.3656235933,
0.0347710438,
-0.0196910072,
-0.9501547813,
0.1139848083,
0.1359948665,
0.9581517577,
0.2534996867,
-0.6436695457,
0.0746956393,
-0.5528413057,
0.6080992222,
-0.570585072,
0.268073529,
0.3783262074,
0.5171456337,
-0.2151973695,
-0.6648843884,
-0.5540733933,
-0.1858384907,
-0.0828742087,
0.0396481678,
0.2917986214,
0.3312465549,
0.5864396095,
0.5587320924,
-0.4820468128,
-0.1822926402,
-0.6500141025,
-0.433043927,
0.5096194148,
0.2431285679,
0.3594146967,
0.096971415,
-0.1614620537,
-0.0770864934,
-0.2884205878,
0.2436018735,
0.0208980907,
-0.0863162875,
-0.0405674316,
0.4815971255,
-0.1793044358,
1.1389527321,
-0.1530746818,
-0.6402670145,
0.2291180044,
-0.4293886125,
-0.1520926356,
-0.163045764,
0.8137893677,
0.4896893203,
-0.0228609145,
0.1781213433,
-0.2443268597,
-0.1602084041,
0.1942313761,
-1.0601245165,
-0.3304333687,
-0.1167194247,
-0.4609008431,
-0.1554738134,
-0.3487958014,
-0.7413602471,
-0.5846249461,
-0.367736876,
0.7320414186,
-0.364907831,
-0.2653946877,
0.0286151469,
-0.1484802514,
0.2610687017,
0.8349030018,
-0.7435976863,
-0.0894969404,
0.3498969376,
0.7837216258,
0.0425101705,
-0.2121320516,
-0.5273608565,
0.4740609825,
-0.6665118337,
0.4025117159,
-0.6810651422,
-0.1269266903,
-0.305688709,
0.0936852321,
0.3185948431,
-0.480768621,
0.1643035114,
-0.3570277691,
0.1255895793,
-0.1802466661,
0.2245423198,
-0.4617616236,
0.6156638861,
-0.6517727971,
1.0250339508,
0.1652184576,
-0.6242648363,
0.3043607771,
-0.5752900839,
-0.5393305421,
-0.0562442206,
-0.1857004017,
-0.3074003756,
0.2209973633,
0.565267086,
0.4325336516,
-0.3885080516,
0.31890288,
-0.4126600623,
-0.1451787353,
0.549785912,
-0.7409424186,
0.2908151746,
0.2362986207,
0.1146566346,
0.3181417584,
-0.6981785297,
-0.0112219667,
0.1130937189,
-0.7952632308,
-0.073818475,
-0.1599361748,
0.1396946013,
0.3111391366,
0.3920923173,
-0.6117481589,
0.1723623127,
-0.0052549685,
0.7094609141,
0.577472806,
-0.3414010406,
0.2995072305,
-0.2321945578,
0.4198034108,
0.1558628529,
0.3103892505,
-0.94401443,
-0.5782489181,
-0.5320458412,
-0.7043001056,
0.418068856,
0.3475365937,
-0.9367019534,
-0.0705116093,
-0.3272079229,
-0.298925668,
-0.2176969349,
0.3052868545,
0.3485118449,
0.3545510471,
0.2511074245,
-0.5689809322,
-0.3069218993,
-0.9862410426,
0.2755196095,
-0.0693644732,
-0.2398092896,
0.4304907024,
0.233397454,
-0.2872723639,
0.8775197268,
-0.5346102715,
-0.2460293621,
-0.3147065938,
0.0949483514,
0.1795171499,
0.5633358359,
0.4896857738,
-0.8876617551,
-0.2465900481,
0.2822124362,
-0.7325149775,
0.2633697391,
-0.3002443314,
-0.0152836591,
-0.0118102897,
0.1955860406,
-0.7174914479,
0.4277684391,
0.6015566587,
0.0667884201,
0.5872820616,
-0.6070149541,
0.3077509105,
-1.1837912798,
-0.2131301463,
0.152822271,
-0.5021525025,
-0.3311525583,
0.1672502905,
0.4643788934,
-0.5341666937,
-0.2725594044,
0.2333856523,
-0.5367729664,
-0.2383119166,
-0.3790561855,
0.0634343475,
0.404943794,
0.6529252529,
0.0147880707,
0.7675922513,
0.656332612,
-0.5553087592,
0.7443597913,
-0.0070854635,
-0.5792860389,
0.4746239483,
-0.617320478,
-0.0142072178,
-0.1254449785,
0.7400838733,
-1.1676311493,
-0.7398558855,
0.1294274926,
-0.5764287114,
0.6239679456,
0.3444727361,
-0.4852386713,
-0.6613336802,
-0.4170743227,
0.8393297791,
0.1993924677,
-0.5493122339,
0.9158132672,
0.2575349212,
-0.1290125549,
-0.7329704762,
-0.7554057837,
0.4744710624,
-0.0646164417,
-0.4725247622,
0.1460874826,
-0.1839602441,
0.222571075,
-0.1203112155,
-0.0863733366,
-0.1527195722,
-0.2028935701,
0.156670779,
0.2964120507,
-0.4265324771,
0.2925914228,
-0.0225782134,
0.0825710073,
0.0128265927,
0.1771942228,
0.3796275854,
-0.0073841643,
-0.0467756242,
-0.3261662722,
0.2272751778,
0.7219594717,
-0.7429884076,
0.396124661,
1.0147074461,
-0.4809779227,
0.1082530618,
-0.4030348361,
0.0594734736,
-0.5105183125,
0.7917544246,
-0.5685405731,
-0.7532947659,
0.4027296603,
-0.2145040482,
0.1350486428,
0.0394991413,
0.2539781034,
-0.2247621715,
1.4226835966,
0.5865864158,
-0.1507716179,
0.5139253139,
-0.0109684533,
0.1284478307,
-1.1876124144,
-0.2975006104,
-0.1107171252,
-0.5121895075,
-0.118152529,
-0.9419579506,
0.384570837,
0.1331359744,
-0.3112406433,
0.2389034778,
-0.5802200437,
0.6185415983,
0.3991452754,
0.4706191719,
0.1075155139,
0.0056988583,
0.0363716371,
-0.0377005562,
-0.5750412941,
-0.2291537821,
0.8988927603,
0.4887279868,
1.0953187943,
0.1740077436,
0.1096659079,
0.1709515452,
0.2308097333,
-0.8666214943,
0.7614290714,
-0.0308739394,
-0.7325358391,
-0.1060287133,
-0.3394907117,
-0.7088235021,
0.4012918472,
-0.3417724371,
-0.5212993026,
0.0603344105,
0.2293174863,
-0.4490125775,
0.347030282,
-0.3474224806,
0.8462853432,
-0.4694457054,
-0.4171399474,
-0.3887661994,
-0.6686279774,
0.5900951028,
-0.0914477855,
0.2295556664,
-0.079715088,
-0.3306430578,
0.4934152365,
-0.1112781838,
1.0059483051,
0.1259648204,
-0.3878045976,
0.2768594623,
0.0418133438,
0.1375606656,
0.3320809901,
0.1124924645,
0.0441303141,
0.1069089919,
-0.3694552481,
-0.6376410723,
0.6828252673,
-0.8544243574,
-0.6745943427,
-0.2628027201,
-1.1434264183,
-0.0362919867,
-0.0025354251,
-0.1737588644,
1.0122412443,
0.0219485629,
0.55926162,
0.7020974159,
-0.8561983705,
0.4797469378,
0.2955028117,
-0.6536970139,
-0.728677392,
1.1054979563,
-0.1381956488,
0.3383017182,
0.4640869498,
0.0842678323,
-0.083353363,
-0.3026315868,
-0.9880172014,
-0.0938159078,
-0.784139812,
-0.5251912475,
-0.5879217386,
-0.2762891352,
-0.3694133461,
-0.1021283492,
-0.2285875976,
-0.315212816,
-0.202513814,
0.134528622,
0.2731803358,
0.6259820461,
-0.1526582688,
0.3597710133,
-0.7476870418,
0.642551899,
0.4970587492,
0.1364398152,
-0.203367129,
-0.5602046251,
-0.384575963,
0.0214801989,
-0.6189085841,
-0.729526341,
0.413204968,
0.3973992765,
0.3745061159,
0.5657470226,
-0.056915015,
1.0637067556,
-0.3129537404,
0.8791646361,
0.4899441004,
-0.6494267583,
0.5352445841,
-0.4749992192,
0.6609990001,
0.0406588912,
0.0650774837,
-0.4942623973,
-0.4214206636,
-0.0307996906,
-0.6824967861,
0.7568599582,
-0.132228002,
0.3705311418,
0.2442568094,
0.4302492738,
0.0892158747,
0.1500971019,
-0.9209293723,
0.1658690721,
-0.3504312932,
-0.3717688322,
-0.4054030478,
-0.1833927035,
-0.1250158101,
-0.5216067433,
0.315826416,
-0.3855037093,
0.2170265317,
0.0902884156,
-0.1965183169,
0.0078641623,
0.004875042,
0.6685137749,
0.7641473413,
0.05404412,
0.37720716,
0.197628364,
-0.4334905744,
-0.0815855786,
-0.051038187,
0.1577408016,
-0.2264900357,
0.3613890707,
0.9205103517,
0.1172027364,
-0.7538547516,
0.3922546804,
0.0156565867,
-0.1766609699,
0.0071634115,
0.1406986415,
-0.000515015,
0.2909720242,
0.3401859105,
0.3202051222,
0.0759736151,
-0.7199746966,
-0.0671664327,
0.3287061453,
-0.437972039,
-0.2883882523,
0.7249463201,
0.2309380472,
-0.0824586451,
0.5619092584,
0.0127286576,
-0.6582611203,
0.93883425,
0.8127339482,
0.0908889249,
-0.2382988334,
0.2827815413,
0.6055965424,
0.4858034849,
-0.0930348858,
-0.0751976743,
-0.4255749285,
-0.5950191617,
-0.6337699294,
-0.5216420889,
-0.4002077878,
0.2075530291,
-0.4874548316,
0.2079298496,
-0.6202027798,
-0.1041997075,
-0.075607501,
-0.2160798907,
-0.4233188033,
0.3992213309,
0.2403841764,
0.7663294077,
-0.2989911139,
1.0833719969,
0.8211003542,
-0.4618796408,
-0.7157821655,
-0.1500377208,
-0.1288616955,
-0.7001571655,
0.6412252188,
0.6668409109,
0.1594880074,
-0.2804954946,
-0.6083692312,
-0.76141572,
1.0897699594,
0.3332558572,
-0.4872522056,
0.1434932351,
0.2572533786,
0.3840893805,
-0.4712610841,
0.4158530235,
0.2057778388,
0.471575439,
0.1395630985,
-1.0864372253,
0.0152707146,
-0.0877168775,
0.1553325653,
0.2087772936,
-0.5616542697,
0.8774940968,
-0.6495671868,
0.1380588114,
0.3019212782,
0.686475873,
0.0543250255,
0.3433217704,
0.5220668316,
0.4499577284,
0.5061519742,
-0.1449172497,
0.9246345162,
-0.0394274108,
-0.0762797892,
1.0748751163,
-0.048693303,
0.7802708745,
0.2302218825,
0.0293809604,
0.2035657316,
1.0674184561,
0.1466153264,
0.4542151988,
0.1880120635,
-0.437874645,
-0.5713438392,
-0.087899074,
-0.4781556726,
0.2721016705,
0.6052235961,
-0.4638050199,
-0.0217338223,
0.5832452774,
-0.4960027039,
-0.0660207346,
-0.6689376831,
0.7272420526,
-0.0682696328,
-0.3980600834,
0.4353154004,
-0.0442212373,
0.7310546041,
-0.5669456124,
-0.052999001,
-0.178845033,
0.5157313347,
-0.1036317348,
-1.0014712811,
0.0713053048,
-0.2089310437,
-0.1379136443,
-0.0940172449,
0.7664174438,
-0.5134705305,
-0.5298039317,
0.0645634383,
0.0095226793,
0.2644476295,
-0.2296084762,
-0.6718742847,
0.140877381,
-0.1226916537,
-0.2555258274,
0.4634984732,
0.7184381485,
-0.1846078932,
0.6888886094,
0.5022051334,
-0.0973349586,
0.1182382628,
-0.1819822788,
1.1454423666,
-0.643325448,
-0.0837241188,
-0.5379815698,
0.219455868,
-0.1837575585,
-0.26470384,
0.4958903193,
0.77743572,
0.6877096295,
-0.1989993453,
0.499170661,
-0.1176593229,
-0.0274881348,
-0.1420685202,
0.3933617473,
-0.9757498503,
-0.0166345779,
-0.1134115607,
-1.0427069664,
-0.4880460203,
0.6217463613,
-0.1529376358,
-0.091895707,
0.4321272969,
0.9205149412,
-0.2902750671,
-0.2345572263,
0.5786651373,
0.0244480688,
0.3773837984,
0.7623859644,
1.1297582388,
-0.3963596523,
1.0648874044,
-0.082170777,
-0.2804765999,
-0.0308497828,
-0.5883888602,
-0.9720992446,
-0.4500057399,
-0.3473979831,
-0.1943972856,
-0.1550445259,
0.5864979625,
0.9495235085,
-0.446081996,
0.0575234853,
0.4887642264,
-0.0385034606,
-0.2882839441,
-0.1401156038,
0.0058447402,
-0.3337752819,
-0.7689380646,
0.2259606421,
0.5539653897,
-0.1058928445,
-0.3674267828,
-0.3042846918,
0.1359582394,
0.0807042792,
1.0699068308,
0.2210801095,
-0.7805069685,
-0.4092817605,
-0.316190958,
-0.2177953422,
0.2189776301,
0.7704746127,
-0.7276204824,
0.6687105298,
0.4702969193,
0.7822637558,
0.5413234234,
-0.0865184665,
0.6085851192,
-0.6239087582,
0.3258521557,
-0.1486552358,
0.3763467968,
0.4759969413,
-0.1334371418,
0.4216693044,
-0.0892360285,
-0.5714060068,
-0.7811278105,
0.2369560301,
-1.3885433674,
-0.4750681818,
1.1587831974,
-0.3810549378,
-0.3983244896,
0.0464171991,
-0.9833465815,
0.2040165365,
-0.3465674222,
0.5199918151,
0.6433631182,
0.1569907516,
-0.5523347259,
-0.7754584551,
0.1665093601,
0.0441250764,
-0.7326281071,
-0.0999494269,
0.674192071,
0.23933734,
0.3005812466,
0.4635564983,
-0.235332191,
0.4379531145,
-0.0807011351,
0.1169253513,
-0.235267505,
-0.4523450732,
-0.013466672,
0.2949402034,
0.048028972,
-0.4298036397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06602v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06602v2
|
BizBench: A Quantitative Reasoning Benchmark for Business and Finance
| 2023-11-11T16:16:11 | 2024-03-12T16:54:57 |
Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Michael Krumdick, Viet Lai, Varshini Reddy, Charles Lovering, Chris Tanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Answering questions within business and finance requires reasoning,
precision, and a wide-breadth of technical knowledge. Together, these
requirements make this domain difficult for large language models (LLMs). We
introduce BizBench, a benchmark for evaluating models' ability to reason about
realistic financial problems. BizBench comprises eight quantitative reasoning
tasks, focusing on question-answering (QA) over financial data via program
synthesis. We include three financially-themed code-generation tasks from newly
collected and augmented QA data. Additionally, we isolate the reasoning
capabilities required for financial QA: reading comprehension of financial text
and tables for extracting intermediate values, and understanding financial
concepts and formulas needed to calculate complex solutions. Collectively,
these tasks evaluate a model's financial background knowledge, ability to parse
financial documents, and capacity to solve problems with code. We conduct an
in-depth evaluation of open-source and commercial LLMs, comparing and
contrasting the behavior of code-focused and language-focused models. We
demonstrate that the current bottleneck in performance is due to LLMs' limited
business and financial understanding, highlighting the value of a challenging
benchmark for quantitative reasoning within this domain.
|
[
-0.3116426468,
-0.7819613814,
0.5301900506,
0.4832776189,
-0.1481626034,
0.3908577263,
-0.1610047072,
-0.498178333,
-0.5384826064,
0.5754172206,
-0.5854974389,
-0.5054101348,
-0.0372660607,
-0.0784685761,
-0.3382568359,
0.9820450544,
0.0718637183,
0.2399741709,
-0.4541596174,
0.1662910581,
-0.5294898152,
-0.3606415391,
-0.6644394994,
-0.3868158162,
0.3321716785,
0.2587748766,
0.8320477009,
0.2844591737,
0.6816322803,
0.2946659625,
0.0911901444,
-0.1885457933,
-0.3697302639,
0.1224275604,
-0.5632965565,
-0.5789045095,
-0.4136227369,
-0.0867380202,
0.2552173436,
1.0844788551,
-0.2975866795,
0.5591449738,
-0.3305089772,
0.9597887397,
-0.6779148579,
0.527451396,
-0.4609843493,
-0.3356497884,
-0.1091757268,
0.2292187363,
-0.3322189748,
-0.6469808221,
0.12180686,
-0.3680000603,
0.1410982907,
0.4477772713,
1.1408520937,
0.1253946722,
-0.4200471342,
-0.152360484,
-0.7926097512,
0.437532872,
-0.6468333602,
0.4377875328,
0.344091624,
0.5700947642,
-0.1254079342,
-0.7887474895,
-0.5360317826,
-0.2681116462,
0.3745630682,
0.0974364951,
-0.5899217129,
-0.0348087996,
0.5726735592,
0.3745696843,
-0.7634195685,
-0.2476972044,
-0.6439027786,
0.0704239458,
0.641949296,
0.2432328165,
0.1120325401,
-0.1171221137,
-0.234052971,
-0.4216477275,
-0.5797717571,
0.241932407,
0.4440080225,
0.0832809955,
0.0166949704,
0.6282724142,
-0.3727744818,
0.6652848125,
-0.1599923819,
0.177868247,
0.1591723114,
-0.4186298847,
-0.3767413795,
-0.1406380385,
0.3904375136,
0.4196849763,
0.5047533512,
-0.3638622165,
-0.2449942976,
0.0423369333,
0.4181758463,
-0.5613495708,
-0.4011383951,
0.3992161155,
-0.3368399143,
0.2246547937,
-0.055891864,
-0.729018867,
-0.2185220122,
-0.3604437709,
0.2087505609,
-0.356310755,
0.0303623695,
0.255715251,
-0.5372067094,
0.4641989768,
0.093944639,
-0.5994121432,
0.3583734334,
0.8432733417,
0.5746999383,
0.2696855068,
-0.0411499962,
-0.5575168729,
0.1969268173,
-0.6684275866,
1.0911886692,
-0.2601535618,
-0.2889885008,
-0.2673562765,
-0.3137632906,
0.1087734103,
-0.6628296375,
0.2669142783,
-0.5953351855,
-0.1359865963,
-0.4291663766,
-0.7296102643,
-0.2434193343,
0.2052566111,
-0.7414512038,
1.0484524965,
0.7702903152,
-0.5765041113,
0.4452807903,
-0.4313856959,
-0.3040999174,
0.3307687938,
-0.1663228422,
-0.1731964499,
0.1174726263,
-0.1628881693,
0.0467575416,
-0.9983352423,
0.4007036686,
-0.6877422333,
-0.3129956722,
0.7609792352,
-0.1432012767,
0.6797407269,
0.0805620104,
-0.3873013556,
0.0675332993,
-1.0798356533,
0.2973973155,
0.1510201395,
-0.1278391033,
-0.256911397,
0.1326083541,
0.1191906184,
0.1627917886,
0.3881804049,
-0.4343940914,
-0.0103795566,
-0.6258660555,
0.4189747572,
0.7234786749,
-0.1838933825,
0.0497073531,
-0.3680776656,
0.5368859172,
-0.4648211598,
0.0905146301,
0.2743409574,
-0.2562421262,
-0.413742274,
-0.2770209312,
0.4242990613,
0.7769411206,
-0.4302830696,
0.1822394431,
-0.1631163061,
-0.7920963764,
-0.1713050455,
0.3343081772,
0.4295392334,
0.429939568,
0.2161853462,
-0.1948082149,
-0.2965514064,
-1.3059591055,
-0.5298785567,
-0.2915576696,
-0.307004869,
0.2102907449,
0.4832416773,
0.19747141,
0.890668273,
-0.6185315847,
0.2540722191,
-0.4918057323,
0.2703873515,
0.3777190149,
0.2396045178,
0.6606224179,
-0.8258429766,
-0.4077262282,
-0.0351242907,
-0.418312788,
-0.2491551787,
-0.097370863,
-0.2488472909,
0.0358339511,
0.484803617,
-0.7727265954,
0.5744629502,
0.3219046295,
-0.6174895763,
0.5947857499,
-0.155959785,
-0.1117543206,
-0.7007780075,
0.4367290437,
-0.0213701148,
-0.1087989062,
-0.3736927807,
-0.037248902,
0.2006430179,
-0.339866817,
0.1972530037,
0.6957256794,
-0.3153378367,
-0.6545137763,
-0.2176214606,
0.5793021321,
0.3589733839,
0.5050185919,
-0.258859694,
0.8927039504,
0.2898739278,
-0.2620785236,
0.8466431499,
0.3173758984,
-0.8948000073,
0.6810694337,
-0.8756328821,
0.0142723909,
0.2160455883,
0.0982716903,
-1.0680725574,
-0.048194062,
-0.0379206911,
-0.2732435167,
0.0495282933,
0.0465873703,
-0.705150187,
-0.5790282488,
0.0992227122,
0.1764634699,
0.3584600389,
-0.1691927761,
0.812681675,
-0.0143839559,
-0.8165440559,
-0.3213763535,
-0.6181300282,
0.052384451,
0.1123844236,
-0.8221703768,
0.3125033677,
-0.1307529509,
-0.6190945506,
0.3068746328,
-0.4999197423,
-0.1552104503,
0.3499708772,
0.1103892103,
0.7378218174,
-0.3025323749,
0.1756045073,
-0.0930036977,
-0.2365002483,
0.4927134514,
-0.123180002,
0.4227517247,
-0.5156708956,
-0.4000125229,
0.1266277283,
0.2760481238,
0.4869731963,
-0.5628745556,
0.7457284927,
0.1101867929,
-0.1710874736,
-0.4082220495,
-0.6902500391,
0.2862800062,
-0.448664844,
0.3707368374,
-0.4046025574,
-0.6596820354,
0.7509862185,
-0.3014262617,
0.1046823114,
0.4895811975,
0.7898119092,
-0.0000165964,
0.8777765036,
0.517819047,
0.0456680097,
0.3152488768,
0.0076764533,
0.6242444515,
-0.2735703886,
-0.3728846908,
-0.9104025364,
-0.2401416302,
-0.1488907486,
-0.4876038432,
0.2159246802,
0.4664021134,
-0.4842484295,
0.365793854,
-0.007751958,
0.5002422333,
0.6826331615,
-0.1742991805,
0.2109554261,
-0.3091823757,
-0.1628121734,
0.3856984675,
-0.5376896858,
-0.4657457173,
1.0167658329,
0.2135506272,
0.6077632904,
0.1722202152,
0.1665494144,
0.143026799,
0.3428055346,
-0.440290004,
0.4280056655,
-0.0072836168,
-1.0219769478,
-0.3321116269,
-0.7516289949,
-0.4542439282,
0.0231179204,
0.0845736414,
-0.8258703351,
0.194488734,
0.063722454,
-0.5916602612,
0.0068723215,
-0.7463064194,
1.329095602,
-0.4055263996,
-0.569966197,
-0.3662037849,
-0.5839055777,
0.3049050868,
-0.2055038065,
0.4249364436,
-0.4213923514,
0.0829999298,
0.2839945853,
-0.3381215036,
0.5739455819,
0.0304166805,
-0.1277984828,
0.3493008316,
0.2234529406,
0.4723782241,
0.0069890851,
-0.171676755,
-0.0202731974,
0.6162576079,
-0.6577140093,
-0.8893721104,
0.1416766047,
-0.3845046759,
-0.5087507963,
-0.2757319212,
-0.6595486403,
-0.8342276812,
0.0198871512,
-0.1089071557,
0.2239130884,
-0.3677258193,
0.4004565775,
0.3426252902,
-0.3191027641,
0.0066153598,
0.7471796274,
-0.2932372391,
-0.4327370524,
0.7894455194,
-0.1877420992,
0.2516587675,
0.1399476677,
0.1026324481,
-0.3515708148,
-0.3321697414,
-0.5288496614,
0.1733987033,
-0.9671358466,
-0.3713617325,
-0.1590203941,
-0.168423906,
-0.2867620885,
-0.1350883245,
-0.332611084,
-0.3928235769,
0.2127734572,
-0.2388891429,
0.3043868244,
0.4192489982,
-0.0892344937,
-0.2130071968,
-1.0665836334,
0.4875094891,
0.2512795925,
0.6994931698,
-0.0278247092,
-0.1409664601,
-0.6048849225,
-0.2248910367,
-0.066159673,
-0.8741558194,
0.1235193983,
-0.1392858326,
0.6232867241,
0.3958570957,
0.2277665734,
0.5353344083,
-0.0239213575,
0.45595029,
0.0393567234,
-1.2133241892,
0.4134105742,
-0.2499085814,
0.3183432519,
0.7491695285,
0.3228749037,
-0.4220513403,
-0.4565016925,
-0.424616307,
-0.8538704515,
0.6024760008,
0.2159641683,
0.0030597947,
-0.0998981819,
0.4894292653,
-0.0960262343,
0.5907164216,
-0.5464096665,
-0.0050947987,
-0.1642597914,
-0.2263286114,
-0.0574096292,
-0.1763151884,
-0.0757888481,
-0.2249592394,
0.651273787,
-0.2141417265,
-0.2288196832,
0.0148488609,
0.2072089314,
-0.1977843642,
0.2800708115,
0.2343567759,
1.121467948,
-0.2676177025,
-0.1662914008,
-0.0075485506,
0.0483178347,
-0.2077728808,
0.4815815091,
-0.0134681994,
-0.2497329712,
0.2845887542,
0.6475219727,
0.4720366001,
-1.5602496862,
0.4689314365,
0.0103331953,
-0.4055655897,
-0.2845142484,
0.0755258277,
0.485439688,
0.7973898053,
0.3380221426,
-0.1764806062,
0.2084271908,
-0.8289864659,
-0.0845598876,
0.3629905581,
-0.0045969319,
0.010226314,
0.4603660107,
-0.0145973051,
-0.0859510154,
0.985099256,
-0.0333438404,
-0.4832898974,
0.9401556253,
0.3472998738,
0.7757652402,
0.1017588452,
0.1237280071,
0.2073964626,
0.2954848707,
-0.0611699298,
0.7212039232,
-0.0937640294,
-0.6368929148,
-0.4734294116,
-0.6962382793,
-0.8381950855,
-0.1640801877,
-0.8684105873,
-0.013823064,
-0.7231576443,
-0.3753937781,
0.2663218081,
0.0472904779,
-0.7149028182,
0.1722457856,
0.0126544228,
1.1599525213,
-0.4031383991,
0.4498723149,
0.6108598113,
-0.5968234539,
-0.9246900082,
-0.3383565843,
-0.2106901258,
-0.4157224298,
0.8465668559,
-0.096207507,
-0.1277524382,
-0.1386956424,
-0.5694087148,
-0.7989462018,
0.7941203713,
0.5520749092,
-0.8415076137,
-0.3084592819,
0.16173774,
0.5466838479,
0.0268845949,
-0.1192250699,
0.7093213201,
0.6353902817,
0.0020348895,
-0.7803697586,
-0.1667518318,
-0.5413795114,
-0.051549606,
0.1484900415,
-0.7660988569,
0.9372102022,
-0.1233238876,
-0.1365085244,
0.1183939502,
0.5719724894,
0.3397422731,
0.6608297825,
0.3739806712,
0.4200389385,
0.7723125219,
-0.2626443505,
1.1574300528,
-0.7743868232,
0.2730041742,
1.2427207232,
-0.7395171523,
0.9236775041,
0.1891449839,
-0.5088424683,
0.9001671672,
0.5521811843,
-0.5864890814,
0.0852754042,
0.732622683,
-0.1229314953,
-0.7496688962,
0.2124441266,
-0.2525743246,
0.4840597808,
0.2207496464,
-0.0052796188,
-0.1555812806,
-0.1108334437,
-0.2803213298,
0.1803445965,
-0.1124890745,
0.5317854881,
0.2795875371,
-0.6582933664,
0.0390507318,
0.4341343641,
-0.3631509244,
-0.9579928517,
0.1439561248,
-0.3410408497,
0.3185640275,
0.1855122298,
-0.5773617625,
0.4932669699,
0.2824179828,
-0.2478529215,
0.01679134,
0.5365622044,
-0.0482581481,
-0.5548455715,
0.4293721616,
0.6066654325,
-0.0200985465,
-0.4672626257,
-0.7130582333,
-0.1506942064,
-0.3210854828,
-0.4270400405,
0.2818956077,
0.786696136,
0.0264279284,
1.0320800543,
0.7478934526,
-0.1567274183,
-0.1119841114,
0.2563326061,
1.0272048712,
-0.9492352009,
-0.6171740294,
-0.6030130982,
0.0122256298,
0.0015484081,
-0.2498529404,
0.8341602683,
0.918546319,
1.0215339661,
-0.1078055948,
0.7128704786,
0.0626601502,
0.5835984349,
-0.504303813,
0.4726990163,
-0.604878068,
0.2264286429,
-0.363684237,
-0.9099522233,
0.0724870414,
0.6895888448,
-0.57743752,
0.1456738412,
0.6626160145,
0.5875530243,
0.2935293615,
0.3129507303,
0.3097408712,
0.066868484,
-0.1079999804,
0.6443600655,
0.8890134692,
-0.0246020928,
0.9315552115,
-0.2871231139,
-0.0356162824,
-0.1571169347,
-0.7579428554,
-0.8757594824,
-0.2551262379,
-0.4106789231,
-0.423994869,
-0.0765021592,
0.8132589459,
0.2340446711,
-0.6959323883,
-0.5381127596,
-0.1134437472,
0.1657385379,
-0.4692052305,
-0.2528762221,
0.1804473102,
-0.3970761001,
-0.4378963411,
0.3751984835,
0.6890994906,
-0.1188479438,
-0.2908382714,
0.2995727956,
0.1056739166,
0.5151212215,
0.4146758616,
0.2450309098,
-0.3693177104,
-0.0705273673,
0.0633740127,
-0.1517465115,
-0.1368456334,
1.0498811007,
-0.4574240744,
0.2151003927,
0.6370543838,
0.7533424497,
0.6471439004,
0.1761349589,
0.7333128452,
-0.0952728316,
-0.2529678941,
0.1862019598,
0.2744462192,
-0.0658137873,
-0.0301393867,
0.5903947353,
0.2326287776,
-0.3955090642,
-0.7359503508,
0.0861011073,
-1.0106352568,
-0.8317829967,
0.5698015094,
-0.3053668141,
-0.4513412118,
-0.3955324292,
-0.065275304,
0.1039096937,
-0.143956244,
0.7181324363,
0.9757735133,
0.1400031745,
-0.1925973594,
-0.7928412557,
0.1875618547,
0.4388741851,
-0.9044079781,
0.4670825601,
0.7892243266,
0.3695503175,
-0.0082865302,
0.5929269791,
-0.064465262,
0.6777205467,
0.5615212321,
0.3200776875,
-0.0870447308,
-0.1929383278,
0.1769384593,
0.4306138456,
0.1386699378,
0.4357483685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06595v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06595v3
|
From Classification to Generation: Insights into Crosslingual Retrieval Augmented ICL
| 2023-11-11T15:40:21 | 2023-12-02T17:00:27 |
Xiaoqian Li, Ercong Nie, Sheng Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The remarkable ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to understand and
follow instructions has sometimes been limited by their in-context learning
(ICL) performance in low-resource languages. To address this, we introduce a
novel approach that leverages cross-lingual retrieval-augmented in-context
learning (CREA-ICL). By extracting semantically similar prompts from
high-resource languages, we aim to improve the zero-shot performance of
multilingual pre-trained language models (MPLMs) across diverse tasks. Though
our approach yields steady improvements in classification tasks, it faces
challenges in generation tasks. Our evaluation offers insights into the
performance dynamics of retrieval-augmented in-context learning across both
classification and generation domains.
|
[
-0.3916558325,
-0.5553734899,
0.3370467722,
0.050483726,
-0.0773171484,
0.4458500445,
-0.3038427532,
-0.5629923344,
-0.2403795123,
0.4153568447,
-0.7244562507,
-0.3541463912,
-0.3794881105,
0.2682968378,
-0.2379246056,
0.9003711343,
0.0976312011,
0.1324789971,
-0.3833480477,
-0.0945094898,
-0.4994517863,
-0.5925806165,
-0.497852087,
-0.3173145354,
0.7823511958,
0.7324136496,
0.1871909052,
0.4519730508,
0.0446432084,
0.1613640934,
0.0291652791,
0.3095428646,
-0.5517106056,
0.1831199974,
-0.4409396052,
-0.4204033613,
0.0516697764,
-0.0690165982,
0.7973971367,
0.9010329843,
0.1065564454,
0.2607956827,
0.462906301,
0.2579180598,
-0.8275517821,
-0.0081768399,
-0.8935019374,
0.1960248649,
-0.4230606854,
-0.6616795659,
-0.8003031015,
0.1102166474,
0.2982451618,
-0.4269037843,
0.3711995184,
0.1165597215,
0.6946588755,
-0.077211231,
-0.3837430477,
-0.4024068117,
-0.5663666129,
1.1734392643,
-0.360421896,
0.6703948975,
0.1747105271,
0.2696047425,
0.0432802141,
-0.9487043619,
-0.4034624994,
-0.2529284358,
-0.1916765124,
-0.218808502,
0.0118609965,
-0.2505538762,
0.2361324728,
0.0674612373,
-0.5257899165,
0.2444540709,
-0.1264347583,
-0.2620149255,
0.495858252,
0.1629477739,
0.5497102141,
-0.1993769705,
-0.5400298834,
-0.1484598517,
-1.0936961174,
0.0517889373,
0.0155045539,
0.7718667388,
-0.0826491117,
0.4741143286,
-0.1561899036,
0.7008219361,
0.1528297067,
-0.1942564696,
0.2264906913,
-0.4525039494,
-0.0899041742,
0.3250375688,
0.4741430283,
0.0116338301,
-0.1353903413,
-0.3075304925,
-0.1738779396,
-0.2246903181,
-0.106414482,
-0.7817507982,
0.1633080244,
-0.2621404231,
-0.3941470087,
-0.0768839046,
-0.2810027301,
-0.8395010829,
-0.0683126897,
-0.4086941779,
0.3542618752,
-0.4062077105,
-0.0746398196,
-0.3933195174,
0.1555106938,
0.4272163212,
0.3332390189,
-0.9583153129,
-0.0160831288,
0.5866474509,
0.6118933558,
-0.259262383,
-0.6155502796,
-0.9567221999,
0.2299289405,
-0.1994547546,
0.7813012004,
-0.7615525126,
-0.4801104367,
0.1738532633,
-0.0981331468,
-0.2925161719,
-0.6888283491,
0.1012277454,
-0.697686851,
0.4265577495,
-0.2786672413,
-0.3738771379,
-0.119332552,
0.3776673079,
-0.3114887178,
1.0028568506,
0.1490049213,
-0.5674156547,
0.673678875,
-0.5378573537,
-0.4207102656,
0.5472698808,
-0.3471675217,
0.0196761433,
0.0187501553,
0.0939788744,
0.5189754963,
-0.5673346519,
-0.0127488924,
-0.1533074826,
-0.1861313581,
-0.1221664175,
-0.580170989,
0.8597742915,
0.3681995869,
-0.3963032365,
0.1095183641,
-0.7842099071,
0.2368424684,
0.0386063904,
-0.4246233404,
-0.3836516738,
-0.1704934686,
0.076771155,
0.4323586524,
0.4470846355,
-0.5012691617,
0.1322609931,
-0.1284702271,
0.1886739135,
0.4755357802,
-0.0560501181,
0.492305249,
0.0424145944,
0.5675701499,
0.0607454069,
0.0796785504,
-0.3365908563,
-0.1825242341,
-0.5479059815,
-0.154140085,
0.3071677089,
0.6012147665,
-1.1807650328,
-0.0243676919,
-0.2283260822,
-0.3905516863,
-0.5397863984,
0.4702963829,
0.7130098343,
0.6479256153,
0.4727142453,
-0.1720849127,
-0.3898537457,
-0.5411365628,
-0.2201650292,
-0.162593022,
0.1755413413,
0.6042473912,
0.0922645777,
-0.3906676173,
0.6471136808,
-0.1346533746,
0.1133385748,
-0.5723378658,
0.2943451107,
-0.2052112967,
0.4280761778,
0.6740283966,
-0.8252974153,
-0.7914482951,
0.3561203182,
-0.8201158643,
-0.4069143236,
-0.017434625,
-0.2474555522,
0.3939079344,
0.7360516787,
-0.4231724441,
0.2247052044,
0.3243096471,
-0.3262992799,
0.4393037558,
-0.1060674265,
0.1845446974,
-0.8962656856,
0.0664556473,
-0.1792488843,
-0.1778096259,
-0.5657405853,
0.2014244795,
0.0755107701,
-0.232273519,
-0.8365997076,
0.7666943073,
-0.7177747488,
-0.2779572606,
-0.212845996,
0.1927030683,
-0.0315277204,
0.4538351893,
0.171322152,
0.8783518672,
0.712790668,
-0.6687909961,
0.0287902467,
0.0948670208,
-0.2927754819,
0.5248376131,
-0.1311427504,
0.1193333343,
-0.2847901285,
-0.0676360279,
-0.6343200207,
-0.1845729649,
0.0471088178,
-0.2719045877,
0.603602469,
-0.1647137403,
-0.5005126595,
0.1145951524,
0.0161163323,
0.8909634352,
0.3842461705,
-0.9900619388,
0.6205796599,
0.1926301271,
-0.2677464187,
-0.7085849047,
-0.4773828089,
0.0278147236,
-0.1402011067,
-0.2624611855,
0.3827979863,
-0.1165101156,
-0.3433041275,
-0.047015477,
0.3272815943,
0.0915815607,
0.073166661,
-0.1301916391,
0.1938071251,
-0.2178561687,
0.0850450546,
0.0596783608,
0.0882033184,
-0.1496645063,
-0.2783890665,
0.8657310009,
0.157298103,
-0.3792725503,
-0.2436542213,
0.5151153207,
0.5004178286,
-0.5338497758,
0.6503344178,
0.4131266475,
-0.129583925,
-0.5398234129,
-0.2803368866,
0.0082227904,
-0.432320565,
0.3149649501,
-0.5130191445,
-0.7958451509,
0.3949690163,
-0.0871385559,
0.1245221496,
0.4338057041,
0.6129568815,
0.1567801088,
1.1753178835,
0.8434684277,
0.1222937256,
0.7673664689,
-0.2462210208,
-0.0720488802,
-0.7096071243,
-0.6099929214,
-0.4364375472,
-0.0066933841,
-0.4500641525,
-0.3290021122,
0.3241139054,
0.3882237673,
-0.1839781702,
0.2625112534,
-0.2255120277,
0.4499298334,
0.6069847345,
0.0648522004,
0.174002111,
0.2826230824,
-0.2895410955,
0.1351973712,
-1.0410954952,
-0.3225655854,
0.8403545618,
-0.0322666578,
0.5125476122,
0.0148662226,
0.8660478592,
0.2292871177,
0.4987486899,
-0.5841960907,
0.6759278774,
-0.1678375602,
-0.353502512,
-0.0968516693,
-0.56022048,
-1.0443938971,
0.3497303128,
-0.2024761289,
-0.6557281613,
0.198395282,
0.1240940467,
-0.3890002966,
0.2380656302,
-0.5937677026,
0.9339428544,
-0.5358976722,
-0.5275536776,
-0.3396357298,
-0.6698235869,
0.2225192636,
-0.1338520497,
0.0879961625,
0.0558936112,
-0.0364828929,
0.3229675889,
-0.2729997635,
0.7317401767,
-0.234736383,
-0.2739034891,
0.4207515419,
0.117091395,
0.1823138595,
-0.1235229969,
-0.070637621,
0.0230440665,
-0.1129624248,
-0.5216369629,
-0.6571723223,
0.9074115157,
-0.6555604935,
-0.417262435,
-0.2729223669,
-0.7222816944,
-0.3221880496,
0.1285997629,
0.539085567,
0.7808954716,
-0.0017941153,
-0.0084797731,
0.5210086703,
-0.4974682033,
0.6433321238,
0.5120623708,
-0.3022921383,
-0.3563509881,
1.016621232,
0.1948153079,
0.4335701764,
0.618108511,
-0.1147773564,
-0.4377990663,
-0.479944855,
-0.7582317591,
0.1402949095,
-0.7830939293,
-0.2028269023,
-0.4712248147,
-0.1333655119,
-0.3893131912,
-0.1299824268,
0.0650103167,
-0.0939781591,
-0.548635304,
0.0512300059,
-0.0106106689,
0.6800108552,
-0.0657120571,
0.1628125012,
-1.0581777096,
0.014602717,
0.2496268898,
0.1440383047,
0.3966996968,
-0.4939823449,
-0.3508543074,
-0.0058531412,
-0.1689946204,
-0.7214258313,
0.4651509523,
0.400639087,
0.7091625333,
0.1095479056,
-0.0573934875,
0.8724494576,
-0.7475115061,
0.9207909107,
0.2139560282,
-0.9153942466,
0.5776593089,
0.0040100245,
0.3242907822,
0.3989373147,
0.5194707513,
-0.4848570228,
0.0623735003,
-0.4777149856,
-0.8891630173,
0.8460520506,
-0.2159497887,
0.0559289902,
-0.2231626213,
0.3022309244,
0.3133890629,
0.0757399723,
-0.6236569285,
-0.0421993844,
-0.0049653277,
-0.2488940209,
-0.1604134142,
-0.2859055996,
0.0747054145,
-0.1226734519,
0.6837525368,
-0.3251973391,
-0.0156850014,
0.1848225743,
-0.6296630502,
-0.3048884273,
0.3357682824,
0.5118399262,
0.5974152684,
0.1940708458,
0.1577269584,
0.3777238429,
-0.1086937562,
0.0939992741,
0.1054480225,
-0.2216420174,
-0.1180918142,
0.6654741168,
0.9052688479,
0.3606461883,
-1.0306324959,
0.316367656,
0.0009773496,
0.1256874055,
-0.1408738196,
-0.0797924474,
-0.4779566228,
0.4327912927,
0.5809983611,
-0.0990744233,
0.0436590388,
-1.0306600332,
0.4054670334,
0.4718963504,
-0.3885508478,
-0.4935373068,
0.5148288608,
0.122627221,
-0.3658234775,
0.5767436028,
-0.286670208,
-0.515096724,
0.2568135858,
0.750957191,
0.9409611821,
-0.112574771,
0.2518437505,
0.1000022218,
-0.1846084297,
0.1980839521,
0.3942069411,
-0.4713599086,
-0.6575216055,
-0.7137833238,
-0.6863459349,
-0.2392183393,
-0.0900182649,
-0.6631339192,
0.1839526147,
-0.3436009288,
0.2242389321,
-0.1080444083,
0.0222826283,
-0.7373992801,
0.0734578073,
0.4518239498,
0.9969006181,
-0.6245043874,
0.9198350906,
0.7929415703,
-0.372857064,
-0.8745602369,
0.1274428666,
-0.2038832754,
-0.6700502634,
1.2970533371,
0.1513262987,
-0.2518941164,
0.2609223723,
-0.5517182946,
-0.7346090674,
1.0662647486,
0.5163484812,
-0.4834299684,
-0.0691935346,
0.2537133098,
0.5243986845,
-0.6200892329,
0.2553780675,
0.3922555745,
0.0854110941,
0.0735087991,
-1.0033451319,
-0.2171534747,
-0.1376119703,
-0.0396286175,
0.241700232,
-0.5952888131,
0.8288655877,
-0.2130781859,
-0.4382232428,
0.2004595846,
0.6910254955,
0.4858276248,
0.6138635278,
0.5474284291,
0.4235287309,
0.6191449165,
0.0615157746,
1.1717875004,
-0.4915038049,
0.2429668009,
0.9335435629,
-0.6120006442,
0.9281624556,
0.4680140018,
0.1946025938,
0.6852968335,
0.7153586745,
0.4302253723,
0.7866846323,
-0.2305170298,
-0.6433413625,
-0.4466737807,
-0.7066484094,
-0.1479701549,
0.4076159894,
0.3595818281,
-0.3992430866,
-0.4959217608,
0.4658432603,
-0.4264737666,
0.1071940735,
-0.7299852371,
0.8779805899,
0.0259545054,
-0.7082780004,
0.6983401775,
-0.3727853298,
0.5808463097,
-0.4514517188,
-0.35142681,
-0.0323045515,
0.090554066,
-0.0742212757,
-0.6544731855,
-0.0155878812,
0.1350924075,
-0.2878600359,
-0.3649575114,
0.709579587,
-0.8946856856,
-0.3396392167,
0.6775497794,
0.7099497914,
0.0660192221,
0.3613315821,
-0.6831565499,
-0.0445279106,
0.0946454182,
0.0434459336,
0.5034683347,
0.6736495495,
-0.2723951042,
0.6200171113,
0.5585559011,
0.0134757273,
0.4285284281,
0.1591165066,
0.6979750395,
-0.562264204,
-0.2844396532,
-0.7991558313,
0.2771497965,
0.1510243267,
-0.3515744805,
0.8268949389,
0.5953016281,
1.4625760317,
-0.0278137568,
0.7628636956,
-0.2121547759,
0.614533484,
-0.6281284094,
0.3922316432,
-0.8488443494,
0.2908755243,
-0.0850670561,
-0.8789950609,
-0.391461879,
0.1724878401,
-0.2359565794,
-0.0732464492,
0.4324255884,
0.7312716246,
-0.1315566301,
-0.2578625679,
0.43778494,
-0.1160717681,
0.218302533,
0.4939484298,
1.1051380634,
-0.2074610293,
0.6543646455,
-0.3465411961,
-0.0136665842,
-0.1450954974,
-0.6663807631,
-0.8232562542,
-0.574491322,
-0.1268204153,
-0.204640314,
0.025832193,
1.3072211742,
0.6921848059,
-0.8212088943,
-0.3385609984,
0.0539836138,
0.0227118153,
-0.2097249776,
-0.2574283779,
0.2141121775,
-0.7979427576,
-0.9070453644,
0.8019415736,
0.1862959415,
0.0001525225,
-0.3066473305,
-0.2727563977,
-0.3097719848,
-0.1645427048,
0.9293249846,
0.5133179426,
-0.6507319808,
-0.2394082397,
0.0359769501,
-0.1525161862,
-0.0985876322,
0.9851954579,
-1.0251619816,
0.3023440242,
0.7764732838,
0.7709213495,
0.389482379,
0.0241968948,
0.6431264281,
-0.9818903804,
0.1926594079,
0.277569592,
0.4784245193,
0.4367444217,
-0.374691546,
0.3067761064,
0.2180560976,
-0.4756468832,
-1.0262448788,
0.4827752709,
-0.6875900626,
-0.3407948911,
1.0501679182,
-0.1473957449,
-0.2739686072,
-0.0438951366,
-0.2340128273,
0.2805466354,
-0.1151076183,
0.4824919701,
0.3075309396,
-0.2571154535,
-0.4925039411,
-0.2872961164,
0.4891760051,
0.6160507202,
-0.6681143045,
0.1239058226,
0.5170352459,
0.2186808735,
0.4312510788,
0.2538098991,
-0.1280124187,
0.2626467645,
-0.2609736025,
0.099157095,
0.1393312812,
-0.7193894982,
-0.3322680295,
0.3620042205,
0.1905433834,
0.0118066678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06555v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06555v2
|
Heuristic-Driven Link-of-Analogy Prompting: Enhancing Large Language Models for Document-Level Event Argument Extraction
| 2023-11-11T12:05:01 | 2024-02-20T03:51:40 |
Hanzhang Zhou, Junlang Qian, Zijian Feng, Hui Lu, Zixiao Zhu, Kezhi Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we investigate in-context learning (ICL) in document-level
event argument extraction (EAE) to alleviate the dependency on large-scale
labeled data for this task. We introduce the Heuristic-Driven Link-of-Analogy
(HD-LoA) prompting to address the challenge of example selection and to develop
a prompting strategy tailored for EAE. Specifically, we hypothesize and
validate that LLMs learn task-specific heuristics from demonstrations via ICL.
Building upon this hypothesis, we introduce an explicit heuristic-driven
demonstration construction approach, which transforms the haphazard example
selection process into a methodical method that emphasizes task heuristics.
Additionally, inspired by the analogical reasoning of human, we propose the
link-of-analogy prompting, which enables LLMs to process new situations by
drawing analogies to known situations, enhancing their performance on unseen
classes beyond limited ICL examples. Experiments show that our method
outperforms existing prompting methods and few-shot supervised learning methods
on document-level EAE datasets. Additionally, the HD-LoA prompting shows
effectiveness in diverse tasks like sentiment analysis and natural language
inference, demonstrating its broad adaptability.
|
[
-0.4646768868,
-1.0927048922,
0.7607369423,
-0.0764817223,
-0.4108207524,
-0.1023638472,
-0.1974962354,
-0.2097071707,
-0.1461404115,
-0.1279105246,
-0.6307427287,
-0.6030989289,
-0.180306837,
0.0810853615,
-0.3600591421,
0.9198813438,
-0.1328569204,
-0.2101540864,
-0.5879020691,
0.0462088026,
-0.3085949719,
-0.3540692925,
-1.0477730036,
-0.4779359996,
0.6716737747,
0.5720572472,
0.1826071143,
0.7442124486,
0.0609500408,
0.2135351598,
-0.0270949546,
-0.0279000327,
-0.3306250572,
0.0771150589,
-0.3520109951,
-0.3975659609,
-0.0696398988,
0.1648642868,
0.4702910781,
0.7687466741,
-0.0459285304,
0.2067375034,
0.1728744805,
0.4558207393,
-0.7102763057,
0.3382135034,
-0.9791932106,
-0.0184335113,
0.0549193211,
-0.6589152217,
-0.6229177117,
-0.1229685843,
0.2467720658,
-0.7346056104,
-0.0501095206,
0.2021247745,
0.8344723582,
0.0874847025,
-0.1230385527,
-0.3908368051,
-0.3991002738,
0.6410142779,
-0.7707497478,
0.1094008312,
0.2814699113,
0.2166684419,
-0.1863773167,
-0.5813305378,
-0.5919235349,
-0.2531478107,
0.2039615214,
0.1489310116,
-0.1612123251,
-0.1645206809,
0.5872099996,
-0.1547352225,
-0.1632710695,
0.4528928399,
-0.2284199893,
0.1954428554,
0.3570110202,
0.0506856926,
0.1137332991,
-0.195103094,
-0.5678883195,
-0.1024098918,
-0.9781034589,
0.221696347,
0.4454478621,
0.1508476883,
-0.0561667643,
0.1048202515,
-0.2285318226,
0.5589312315,
0.3344969451,
-0.0910473615,
-0.0334639587,
0.040578261,
-0.1489331573,
0.243377015,
0.7300676107,
0.3793176115,
0.1465878636,
-0.1507644802,
0.0271068085,
-0.0286970548,
0.0601869822,
-0.743426621,
-0.0587084629,
0.0902306437,
-0.4736907482,
-0.2503643036,
0.0139239309,
-1.0558177233,
-0.3023594618,
-0.4062452316,
0.6453695297,
-0.4608919322,
0.1776856929,
0.0205939282,
-0.2033915073,
0.3172827661,
0.4714134037,
-0.7184708714,
0.2378447354,
0.6513650417,
0.3671857715,
-0.4029015601,
-0.4139523506,
-1.0101218224,
0.4389759004,
-0.2439145148,
1.082431078,
-0.5918760896,
-0.3803048432,
0.2098010629,
-0.2705699801,
0.0214061998,
-0.7764735818,
0.5951773524,
-0.4399800301,
0.4399380088,
-0.3341804445,
-0.7981601954,
-0.1821248829,
0.3958049417,
-0.4742453396,
0.9789310098,
-0.1508199573,
-0.4394687116,
0.6369398236,
-0.8499376774,
-0.4620637894,
0.0864582658,
-0.507060051,
-0.2849072516,
-0.0843477249,
0.4836302698,
0.6342829466,
-0.5914946198,
0.0150899226,
-0.2584386468,
-0.2573514581,
0.0065540113,
-0.6471889615,
0.7223457694,
0.0529354624,
-0.5433106422,
0.3757564425,
-0.5623151064,
-0.1541392207,
0.1419816464,
-0.3949910998,
-0.4408414662,
0.1312029958,
-0.4209764004,
0.2885668874,
0.0807086006,
-0.3186251521,
0.1769508272,
-0.4503696561,
0.3937892318,
0.7013910413,
0.2872975469,
0.2713336647,
-0.2004577816,
0.4838011563,
0.2620412707,
0.0479810722,
-0.6190262437,
-0.3470167518,
-0.4451392889,
-0.2732354403,
-0.0998214409,
0.4796662033,
-0.8424034715,
0.4031669497,
-0.1380889565,
-0.0025196976,
-0.2463595271,
0.1690953225,
0.2246323973,
0.9265773892,
0.2795708776,
0.168303892,
-0.3229654431,
-0.6840310097,
-0.1186414137,
-0.4998533428,
0.0564951338,
0.1731708497,
0.3580743968,
0.1752837896,
1.0025991201,
-0.2996409237,
-0.0224887542,
-0.2495624572,
0.4528481662,
0.0977304652,
0.0664715543,
0.4340122938,
-0.5388063788,
-0.5704728961,
-0.0353914574,
-0.946587801,
-0.3056534231,
-0.4052900672,
0.0861040056,
0.2090239078,
1.0797827244,
-0.3187825382,
0.4965788126,
-0.0359864943,
-0.2783397138,
0.5016309619,
-0.3075048923,
0.1009208784,
-1.3409874439,
-0.1658663899,
0.2768501937,
0.0310966633,
-0.2253195941,
0.1548802853,
-0.088006787,
-0.084299013,
-0.591483593,
0.8307041526,
-0.4860653281,
-0.0522838645,
-0.2918451428,
0.3714033663,
0.0090106446,
0.4942307472,
0.122348465,
0.7880852818,
0.5846737623,
-0.3882033527,
0.2920286059,
0.1681920588,
-0.276479274,
0.9954006076,
-0.3067343533,
-0.0147417746,
-0.1435792148,
0.1507957727,
-0.8159039021,
-0.0223060809,
-0.0336668044,
0.02296816,
0.1213752627,
-0.1376208067,
-0.5845091939,
-0.2483471185,
-0.4965172112,
0.299679786,
0.7203961015,
-1.0991555452,
0.3551161587,
-0.0701338351,
-0.2226660103,
-0.3290921748,
0.0898488238,
0.2972120941,
-0.7156471014,
-0.1397469044,
0.186293602,
-0.2526935935,
-0.3911638558,
-0.0839845389,
0.042586267,
-0.0895779729,
0.1391844302,
0.301081866,
0.3207910061,
-0.3513274491,
-0.0932439119,
0.2632366419,
-0.0431701168,
0.3747988045,
-0.1655733883,
0.2690821886,
-0.159167707,
-0.6223931909,
-0.7267997265,
0.5123119354,
0.3164660037,
0.1536150128,
0.3963698745,
0.4600842297,
-0.4605577886,
-0.2122179568,
-0.4586090147,
-0.5935041904,
-0.4103619754,
0.1724755913,
-0.4726457,
-0.4349680543,
0.3066701293,
-0.6317541599,
0.1723911017,
0.1633052826,
0.581895411,
-0.3862362802,
0.7412428856,
0.0483457409,
-0.1484067142,
0.5445823073,
-0.2757824063,
0.0676680133,
-0.7127135396,
0.1043296084,
-0.5549643636,
-0.189800173,
0.0566662997,
-0.3274239898,
0.6170198917,
0.4527406991,
-0.0608934723,
0.1520208865,
0.033464808,
0.8117912412,
0.3814719617,
-0.0090132151,
0.3470214903,
0.3144955635,
-0.1461765617,
-0.0559256747,
-0.9479607344,
-0.5490460992,
0.5845671296,
0.2583072484,
0.597931087,
-0.1598810703,
1.0017827749,
0.2285693586,
0.5618707538,
-0.9465173483,
0.7699284554,
0.0900124162,
-0.1142190546,
-0.4114224315,
-0.0556450635,
-1.0996148586,
0.0429500639,
-0.3169419169,
-1.1805832386,
0.0706833825,
0.1225761101,
-0.2315121293,
0.2523438632,
-0.5751789808,
0.7330098748,
0.2788308561,
-0.5947641134,
-0.4023242891,
-0.3613305986,
-0.0565489456,
0.1027155891,
0.2581984103,
0.0972800031,
0.0738604218,
0.6431747675,
-0.2548521161,
1.0302097797,
-0.0507777631,
-0.3279114366,
0.5132576227,
0.0805905163,
0.7573379874,
0.011305308,
-0.3995164037,
-0.0616182089,
-0.1421824545,
-0.2583858073,
-0.7575535774,
0.7315757871,
-0.3316122293,
-0.9783842564,
0.1379846334,
-0.6415949464,
-0.3601628244,
-0.048019737,
0.2507282197,
0.6265612245,
-0.103354007,
0.2703175247,
0.6879314184,
-0.1391363591,
0.801861763,
0.3781588972,
0.2898148,
-0.1452496946,
0.9589787126,
-0.3519944251,
0.2873182297,
0.5342125297,
0.616220057,
-0.3184187412,
-0.4230333269,
-0.7305378914,
0.0360958949,
-1.0970742702,
-0.1004144549,
-0.5279684663,
0.0087355375,
0.0375831351,
-0.7269203663,
0.1260903925,
-0.1228681505,
-0.399928242,
-0.1702442914,
0.2485419512,
0.3227532804,
0.2129874974,
0.2988046408,
-0.6551021934,
0.3120236993,
0.4122823775,
-0.0234016012,
0.1428195089,
-0.412094444,
-0.0902420878,
-0.3551146686,
-0.3026942015,
-0.9425528049,
0.0655968338,
0.0997746587,
0.7740991116,
0.6470524073,
0.1644515693,
0.5957673788,
-0.5656578541,
0.776337862,
0.320158422,
-0.9072602987,
0.501437366,
-0.5281812549,
0.2972213328,
0.5501275659,
0.5548098087,
-0.1502895802,
-0.283521533,
-0.7040829659,
-0.7172721624,
0.4345573485,
-0.2582699358,
-0.0109756021,
-0.3233992159,
0.5684015155,
0.3546072543,
0.1137075052,
-0.6475870013,
-0.0178956743,
0.2120585144,
-0.3643523753,
0.3568907678,
-0.0878106207,
-0.2016303539,
-0.2285915911,
0.543959856,
-0.7261158228,
-0.0152861373,
0.1640057713,
-0.0773549601,
-0.1876348257,
0.4457496107,
0.3639656901,
0.7920749784,
0.0741675049,
0.1161194146,
0.4299309254,
0.1361860633,
0.0932742953,
0.0395607427,
-0.189665854,
-0.133994475,
0.5316423178,
0.8620891571,
0.3255807459,
-0.6889770627,
0.4871973693,
0.1935066581,
-0.360896498,
0.0114549343,
0.050548315,
0.1949001253,
0.3362246454,
0.3875350654,
-0.6511380672,
0.1521039158,
-0.8236260414,
0.2435015589,
0.5999749899,
-0.374176532,
-0.0708912164,
0.7770237923,
0.2611104548,
-0.4417108893,
0.2612396777,
-0.2594648302,
-0.2497546375,
0.6780213714,
0.7610111833,
0.8733204007,
0.1866911799,
0.2674333751,
0.3749608397,
-0.0008134916,
0.0104083242,
0.2262839824,
-0.3087895215,
-0.5003764033,
-0.4226702154,
-0.3000722528,
-0.3787518144,
0.2611647844,
-0.7966169715,
0.3371820748,
-0.4467661381,
0.3726451397,
0.1046873927,
-0.2286931276,
-0.5333681107,
-0.0819559619,
0.0706648231,
1.1979881525,
-0.8314241171,
0.8427818418,
0.7590802312,
-0.3428443074,
-0.6240414381,
0.4272862077,
0.0240936913,
-0.4889264405,
0.8483457565,
-0.052045621,
-0.0501820296,
0.0853521824,
-0.4894877374,
-0.1569991857,
1.0727771521,
0.3172591031,
-0.4027546048,
0.0367497019,
-0.1867755651,
0.4594436288,
-0.6235811114,
0.0479961708,
0.2891955674,
0.3634528816,
0.1099496335,
-0.6337518692,
0.2260606587,
0.151195094,
-0.1858194321,
-0.0194950998,
-0.3458310366,
0.4333759546,
-0.4556566775,
0.0219758544,
-0.0187739283,
0.7752221823,
0.4488476813,
0.626521349,
0.9190793037,
0.2178034782,
0.537530005,
0.2667703032,
0.9217429161,
-0.0545924604,
-0.04088277,
1.1837953329,
-0.6809574962,
1.0023069382,
0.8559493423,
0.0572247729,
0.6991388798,
0.4628066719,
0.3352791369,
0.354709208,
0.0278962739,
-0.6377530098,
-0.3930259049,
-0.209201768,
0.103265591,
0.2453287095,
0.5400770903,
-0.1919045448,
-0.6155352592,
-0.0347594097,
-0.056059584,
0.4149430394,
-0.1929342747,
1.1148332357,
0.0912839323,
-0.7319549918,
0.6142763495,
-0.3569807708,
0.4422638416,
-0.4761080742,
-0.3602417409,
0.0408862531,
-0.2652454078,
0.0878234506,
-0.700951457,
0.0522699803,
-0.0970266461,
-0.3488486111,
-0.182500273,
0.5341717601,
-0.4288572967,
-0.0267164875,
0.2865066826,
0.6734669805,
0.1512420028,
0.1413023025,
-0.6904932857,
-0.0990261286,
-0.1634120345,
-0.2987200916,
0.6313052773,
0.6073339581,
-0.6004781127,
0.6259999871,
0.6744483113,
-0.1711455733,
-0.2697337866,
0.1766392291,
0.7361348867,
-0.5458900332,
-0.518773675,
-0.9182512164,
0.2386818677,
-0.2648152709,
-0.0459485948,
0.4684280753,
0.4354995787,
0.7238665819,
-0.1462063342,
0.7726512551,
0.1747429073,
0.1819358617,
-0.7359218001,
0.2893919647,
-0.4571299255,
0.3362643719,
-0.2671626508,
-0.7385359406,
0.0366902053,
0.4526830614,
-0.3538640141,
-0.2244025916,
0.9754526615,
0.7055256963,
-0.2236653566,
0.0549221039,
0.5359063148,
0.0828318372,
0.4863328934,
0.5143991709,
0.6256470084,
-0.1303585917,
0.4510730803,
-0.0274129044,
-0.3463405967,
-0.2998099625,
-1.5400956869,
-1.0908762217,
-0.857517004,
-0.7114523649,
-0.2291824222,
0.2034784704,
1.235004425,
0.6986455321,
-0.4811019599,
-0.2668718398,
0.0262683686,
0.2037478685,
-0.4540707171,
-0.2334275097,
0.4171040654,
-0.4471279979,
-0.8535075188,
0.7478141785,
0.3565468788,
-0.1591508687,
-0.16360645,
0.0612466857,
-0.3286367059,
0.2101805657,
0.7983258367,
0.5267959237,
-0.8099249601,
-0.332197845,
-0.5536984205,
0.0304580871,
0.0874427408,
0.8504400253,
-0.9550244212,
0.1283653677,
0.5006768703,
0.8937456608,
0.2104747891,
-0.0975177959,
0.5428852439,
-0.9072342515,
0.303824693,
-0.2265727818,
0.5810970664,
0.1177258566,
-0.4349978268,
0.2948772907,
0.1835990697,
-0.1678919345,
-0.6053020358,
0.3982155025,
-0.9502269626,
-0.4920855165,
1.3716571331,
-0.358682394,
-0.3747426569,
-0.0791367814,
-0.5379922986,
-0.0293956622,
-0.5486773252,
1.0967788696,
0.6346906424,
-0.1518610418,
-0.2738690078,
-0.4557568133,
0.5052810907,
0.425431639,
-1.47019279,
0.1906335205,
0.5489295721,
0.2070021182,
-0.0039396654,
0.3938352466,
0.0955852494,
0.4307660758,
-0.1809981167,
-0.1594417542,
-0.0907700434,
-0.2912518978,
-0.3538358808,
0.3781325519,
0.1331135929,
0.0455839857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06549v1
|
Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Sentiment Classification under Distribution Shift: an Exploratory Study
| 2023-11-11T11:56:56 | 2023-11-11T11:56:56 |
Maarten De Raedt, Semere Kiros Bitew, Fréderic Godin, Thomas Demeester, Chris Develder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The brittleness of finetuned language model performance on
out-of-distribution (OOD) test samples in unseen domains has been well-studied
for English, yet is unexplored for multi-lingual models. Therefore, we study
generalization to OOD test data specifically in zero-shot cross-lingual
transfer settings, analyzing performance impacts of both language and domain
shifts between train and test data. We further assess the effectiveness of
counterfactually augmented data (CAD) in improving OOD generalization for the
cross-lingual setting, since CAD has been shown to benefit in a monolingual
English setting. Finally, we propose two new approaches for OOD generalization
that avoid the costly annotation process associated with CAD, by exploiting the
power of recent large language models (LLMs). We experiment with 3 multilingual
models, LaBSE, mBERT, and XLM-R trained on English IMDb movie reviews, and
evaluate on OOD test sets in 13 languages: Amazon product reviews, Tweets, and
Restaurant reviews. Results echo the OOD performance decline observed in the
monolingual English setting. Further, (i) counterfactuals from the original
high-resource language do improve OOD generalization in the low-resource
language, and (ii) our newly proposed cost-effective approaches reach similar
or up to +3.1% better accuracy than CAD for Amazon and Restaurant reviews.
|
[
-0.3890542686,
-0.7686686516,
0.1511217058,
0.1520287544,
-0.4258180261,
-0.0447465479,
-0.2421090901,
-0.7505569458,
0.1869619638,
0.4480635524,
-0.3183812499,
-0.5933045149,
-0.480306536,
0.0703884065,
-0.1459323317,
1.0603684187,
-0.3046063483,
0.4011678994,
-0.0352965891,
-0.6088424325,
-0.1854931861,
-0.6682242751,
-0.3856375515,
-0.2905037999,
0.5002216101,
0.2466663569,
0.7513465881,
0.2397924513,
0.4168670774,
0.1368412077,
0.2731176615,
0.0377505012,
-0.4511960745,
-0.0151266837,
-0.4313269854,
-0.6450048089,
-0.636958003,
0.0171824954,
0.2979125977,
0.989662528,
0.0342341959,
0.1158307642,
-0.1403919011,
0.3035489023,
-0.6350178719,
0.1850755066,
-0.3760495484,
0.3444170654,
-0.1594368517,
-0.0868838876,
-0.5045422316,
-0.1941641867,
0.0059788437,
-0.5410142541,
0.2848494351,
0.1625994146,
0.7909633517,
-0.0373866856,
-0.4214218557,
-0.1216661483,
-0.846380651,
1.1551266909,
-0.5644075871,
0.6631430387,
0.1328872293,
0.0753385648,
0.3437490761,
-0.0883201659,
-0.6256350875,
-0.1816452146,
0.1483961046,
0.1930602193,
-0.1738004982,
-0.0778227597,
0.0166332405,
0.4210875034,
-0.6287661195,
0.1967518032,
-0.1531867981,
0.1312147826,
0.7485088706,
0.0107491445,
0.3675557673,
0.1174274534,
-0.5082514882,
-0.2768042386,
-0.8145059943,
-0.0448363274,
0.2836394906,
0.3854647875,
-0.1804904938,
0.5759282112,
-0.1910995245,
0.345685035,
0.0901366025,
0.0878102928,
0.5730167627,
-0.4435250163,
-0.4120269716,
0.1597357541,
0.6959241629,
0.5913617015,
0.5060189962,
-0.1229898259,
-0.119613491,
0.3322728276,
-0.0711045042,
-0.6849481463,
0.0624094829,
0.0427227244,
-0.3634997308,
-0.227608189,
-0.1302779466,
-0.7251445651,
-0.4377477169,
-0.0950975046,
0.1948995441,
-0.4205034077,
-0.5873154998,
0.3685145378,
-0.1214269176,
0.2927992046,
0.3397840559,
-0.7128992677,
-0.0140840206,
0.3039065003,
0.699955523,
-0.3136747777,
-0.4058066905,
-0.2393337935,
0.0974260047,
-0.6980708241,
0.8275767565,
-0.5177636147,
-0.4563925862,
0.2551809251,
0.0709361732,
-0.2764969468,
-0.6642097235,
0.2506526709,
-0.405036509,
0.3412837088,
-0.1630146056,
-0.2166908085,
-0.069079414,
0.5866802931,
-0.6466069818,
0.9602093101,
0.1823509634,
-0.6964102387,
0.5297067761,
-0.6571080685,
-0.5157992244,
-0.2397115827,
-0.1546539664,
-0.1952612549,
0.2937511802,
0.2955164015,
0.3522853851,
-0.1866089851,
-0.1371651739,
-0.5804540515,
-0.3166770041,
0.2163814008,
-0.3656713665,
0.7143797874,
0.1459521055,
-0.5077667832,
-0.38991642,
-0.5953201652,
-0.0983848944,
0.0920420885,
-0.149647668,
-0.7415540218,
-0.3656075895,
0.1408983767,
0.3301573694,
-0.0292284936,
-0.7559953928,
0.221664086,
-0.4767571092,
-0.0738478974,
0.3587915599,
-0.0708423704,
0.565171659,
-0.0804351121,
0.7801347971,
0.5803704262,
0.2685931027,
0.0823136345,
-0.3489675522,
-0.6120522618,
0.0199203491,
0.1648894548,
0.6207671762,
-1.0215241909,
0.1002073586,
-0.3488760889,
-0.3194007277,
-0.6064912081,
0.1717172563,
0.4442832768,
0.3746486604,
0.4951428771,
-0.4609010518,
-0.323297292,
-0.6064856648,
-0.1418625563,
-0.3397710323,
0.2222326398,
0.0726989657,
0.0379951112,
-0.4211724102,
0.7309153676,
-0.4611342251,
-0.3557035029,
-0.5751519799,
0.3811583519,
0.0265485365,
0.1464806199,
0.9116848111,
-0.5620358586,
-0.7214402556,
0.4051019847,
-0.692286551,
-0.0944669396,
-0.0303567946,
-0.0222545452,
0.9016902447,
0.5339328647,
-0.6027233005,
0.4192890823,
0.6481609941,
-0.2339937687,
0.4328196049,
0.116937466,
0.2107248157,
-0.9174460173,
-0.1988617033,
0.0195154715,
-0.0031910075,
-0.5684099197,
-0.0896680728,
-0.132537365,
0.0828465819,
-0.5849952102,
0.7597194314,
-0.487835288,
0.053793665,
0.0632673502,
0.1718329787,
0.0314387493,
0.4905714095,
0.4155705273,
0.4362140298,
0.5609980226,
-0.3939360082,
0.2662176788,
-0.0269484688,
-0.2657563984,
0.934898138,
-0.3554664254,
-0.0694309175,
-0.402890116,
-0.003215167,
-1.3340877295,
0.3240681291,
0.2134458572,
-0.3905223012,
0.3810102642,
-0.0414570719,
-0.2329989672,
0.0897733271,
-0.5206023455,
0.5786559582,
0.4100686908,
-0.5212671757,
0.4204020202,
0.1795312464,
-0.1585537046,
-0.7103228569,
-1.1479024887,
-0.1718489081,
-0.1442824155,
-0.2682951987,
0.0050071916,
-0.1335158795,
-0.4469703138,
0.0612048917,
-0.0241817906,
-0.1332917362,
-0.2858713567,
-0.0259592533,
0.2044295073,
-0.368390888,
0.2448157668,
-0.0115098273,
0.1545635015,
-0.0297613591,
-0.0880247653,
0.3729194105,
0.1021632254,
-0.1740967184,
0.3293022811,
0.3666952848,
0.4660068452,
0.0258087255,
0.5248176455,
0.8094671369,
0.036384955,
-0.6028754711,
-0.3566744328,
0.0934114158,
-0.3683771193,
0.5586411357,
-0.4385228753,
-0.4677607715,
0.5313631892,
0.2035368979,
0.0479197726,
0.4086604118,
0.3316202164,
0.0212680027,
1.1365628242,
0.6498120427,
-0.2231491506,
0.5956757665,
-0.4230211079,
0.4266998172,
-0.4479231536,
0.165797025,
-0.2453437895,
-0.133132264,
-0.7052921057,
-0.3325386345,
0.3059106171,
0.0508165509,
0.1283133924,
0.1337562799,
-0.0435680375,
0.2499025315,
0.1721839607,
-0.1989988089,
0.3333493173,
0.345772773,
-0.3427012861,
-0.0257102419,
-0.7018094659,
-0.0959425867,
1.0813225508,
0.316549927,
0.9392521381,
0.1994790882,
0.5529192686,
0.3516160846,
0.5537743568,
-0.7043796778,
0.5337956548,
-0.4086705148,
-0.433003813,
-0.3445942402,
-0.4034700692,
-0.8524130583,
0.1850623935,
0.0655051544,
-0.1888192594,
0.3972452879,
0.0682460144,
-0.2732349038,
0.4011497498,
-0.8196367621,
0.8394519091,
-0.3047777116,
-0.3426500559,
-0.2035698146,
-0.3422197104,
0.2669711113,
0.0789504051,
0.5692369938,
-0.0710565597,
-0.0552029163,
0.3387599289,
-0.3359117806,
0.9179296494,
-0.2778504789,
-0.5017570257,
0.2279892266,
0.153156504,
0.2503651083,
-0.108416751,
-0.1087372825,
0.673624754,
0.0075037703,
-0.353012234,
-0.6305681467,
0.7145650387,
-0.9296996593,
-0.2486471236,
-0.4230433404,
-0.5637679696,
-0.4585546851,
0.0680590793,
0.3751834929,
0.3686895669,
-0.2583934069,
-0.0512805656,
0.6115732193,
-0.2539205849,
0.4265977144,
0.6295487285,
-0.3843347728,
-0.4564587474,
0.8206555247,
0.4975034297,
0.4889122546,
0.5371472836,
0.1635138541,
-0.4530263841,
-0.4415368736,
-0.73390311,
0.3364737332,
-0.8418136239,
0.0363955013,
-0.4321110845,
0.1460981965,
-0.7870249748,
-0.1862710714,
-0.37849617,
-0.5434103608,
0.0118608987,
-0.4052177966,
0.2712874413,
0.6503792405,
-0.0636190251,
0.035959743,
-0.4751271009,
0.2284120917,
0.1231790781,
0.4039442241,
-0.1776497215,
-0.6278918982,
-0.4847800434,
0.0761126354,
-0.2298116535,
-0.714269042,
0.513107419,
0.3004767299,
0.4157073796,
0.4934193194,
0.3171679676,
0.6902527213,
-0.2230950892,
0.9529467225,
0.2792308927,
-0.703027308,
0.1490159482,
-0.2689687312,
0.315344274,
0.4267462194,
0.6655527353,
-0.5850535631,
-0.4599905014,
-0.3684383929,
-0.8967683911,
0.5846263766,
-0.4265092313,
0.2999608517,
-0.2856710553,
-0.0590722598,
0.4000588357,
0.312189728,
-0.8797367811,
-0.3309676051,
-0.3538349867,
-0.2819924951,
-0.4016919136,
-0.2345899045,
0.1263587773,
-0.2725225091,
0.5236526132,
-0.2845632136,
0.1611789018,
0.2823098898,
-0.3678933382,
-0.4348215759,
0.4330179691,
0.5985845923,
0.5338872075,
-0.4447048903,
0.4000628591,
0.2476765513,
-0.5176197886,
0.1351633221,
-0.0580707453,
-0.2393655181,
0.3900521994,
0.398172617,
0.8196601868,
0.1684629619,
-0.5743638873,
0.4777647555,
0.1486421376,
-0.2304382324,
-0.2059832513,
-0.2908056974,
-0.3076667488,
0.0518088825,
0.105182223,
-0.1067536622,
0.1006669477,
-1.0055297613,
-0.0729832947,
0.4543018937,
-0.4693237543,
-0.637683928,
0.2826371789,
0.1817271709,
0.2033675015,
0.2677769363,
-0.4164453745,
-0.2832327783,
0.29744488,
0.4173860252,
1.1517771482,
-0.3756089509,
0.4660686851,
0.0885393247,
0.3729970157,
-0.0654824674,
0.3978099525,
-0.0611090064,
-1.0174328089,
-0.4208807647,
-0.3410179913,
-0.576300025,
-0.0170127843,
-0.6136829257,
0.3627460897,
-0.3284806609,
-0.1213111654,
-0.0724832639,
-0.1484367251,
-0.5566201806,
0.3456063867,
0.2615740895,
0.6497359276,
-1.0298879147,
0.917096734,
1.1424589157,
-0.5900183916,
-0.3897602558,
-0.0370775349,
-0.3243253827,
-0.7598698139,
0.8050141335,
0.0056156018,
-0.1521306336,
-0.3055321574,
-0.2728687227,
-0.6450374126,
0.7159695029,
0.3727574944,
-0.4654386044,
0.0914803222,
0.7824675441,
0.8293145299,
-0.3700261712,
0.5931589603,
0.3517424762,
0.2115443796,
0.0970757976,
-1.048674345,
-0.1840923131,
-0.2567415833,
-0.0811522007,
0.2324473113,
-0.6144320369,
0.9574128389,
-0.1630668044,
-0.12987037,
-0.4179007411,
0.1978679001,
0.0358965807,
0.6560899019,
0.5251111388,
0.5982889533,
0.2567948699,
0.1285008341,
1.0806832314,
-0.2320557088,
0.4455503821,
0.8710250854,
-0.7951104641,
1.0703265667,
0.604765296,
-0.1317799985,
0.5991122127,
0.3920232356,
0.364936322,
0.6492981911,
0.0182127673,
-0.0317949168,
-0.1778610945,
-0.3896899223,
-0.372551918,
0.1685274988,
0.0102299377,
-0.3161225021,
-0.4142241478,
0.2881126404,
0.1941802949,
-0.0271457285,
-0.5142549872,
0.6115371585,
0.0676339194,
-0.5020695925,
0.9331524372,
-0.1171450689,
0.8906652331,
-0.4413952827,
-0.0046757939,
-0.654995203,
0.5142655373,
-0.1761815399,
-0.6587629318,
0.3995988071,
-0.0717937946,
-0.2850816548,
-0.4083386362,
0.3535505235,
-0.7786566615,
-0.7232410908,
0.7251467109,
0.4042235315,
0.2316631675,
0.0811511055,
-0.5596225858,
0.0525244102,
-0.068680197,
-0.2538480163,
0.3958409727,
0.625433147,
-0.4142195284,
0.1909804046,
0.2446745932,
0.3665466309,
0.2402209491,
0.3378475904,
0.5182859302,
-0.6707760692,
-0.4937808514,
-0.6687666774,
0.2761876583,
0.0893165246,
-0.3556827307,
0.9897066951,
0.4208886325,
1.4971364737,
-0.4256347418,
0.9526463747,
0.0427789167,
0.577542603,
-0.4172519147,
0.3177142143,
-0.6667405367,
0.1511175185,
-0.3512595296,
-0.8464590311,
-0.4193095863,
0.2498875558,
-0.6116085052,
0.0674184337,
0.8163638711,
0.7229954004,
-0.1218712106,
-0.2663085759,
0.6933252215,
0.2714029253,
0.1294472367,
0.5453898311,
0.8337256908,
-0.6464557052,
0.6221939325,
-0.2964217961,
-0.0123054413,
-0.2435044795,
-0.7053171396,
-0.9603891373,
-0.1416001618,
-0.7112685442,
-0.2090581357,
0.0519999377,
0.8917332888,
0.5766615868,
-1.0333683491,
-0.5210210085,
0.0139183216,
0.1165603399,
-0.4586766362,
-0.3165675402,
0.1735089421,
-0.39426741,
-0.7797123194,
0.2373733073,
0.2377253175,
-0.0575840808,
-0.3796064556,
-0.158208251,
-0.0767022893,
0.3523235917,
0.8110336065,
0.1867853403,
-0.4715692699,
-0.2369700074,
0.3130307794,
-0.0459627882,
0.0519199558,
0.625048399,
-0.2992400527,
0.4461479187,
0.5978842378,
0.3639229238,
0.1687034965,
0.0283715483,
0.5457324982,
-0.9502670169,
0.2159400284,
-0.0299498402,
0.3610018194,
0.3160240948,
-0.2934539616,
0.556475997,
0.4383558333,
-0.1709136069,
-1.0468885899,
0.1030010134,
-0.7945088744,
-0.2820700407,
1.4112061262,
-0.2159401178,
-0.2595353425,
-0.2579630315,
-0.0440221727,
-0.0327239223,
-0.2342220992,
0.8019387722,
0.6734188795,
-0.2229253799,
-0.3464565277,
-0.2868519127,
0.4029102623,
0.6827731729,
-0.6791955829,
0.0707931146,
0.4854240417,
0.3441630602,
0.4575582445,
0.4943771064,
-0.2700811625,
0.1874232292,
-0.1063438952,
0.5497609377,
0.0907678306,
-0.2048211843,
-0.5956262946,
0.2967424691,
0.228693381,
-0.482183665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06534v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06534v2
|
Translating Legalese: Enhancing Public Understanding of Court Opinions with Legal Summarizers
| 2023-11-11T11:05:27 | 2024-03-02T17:18:34 |
Elliott Ash, Aniket Kesari, Suresh Naidu, Lena Song, Dominik Stammbach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Judicial opinions are written to be persuasive and could build public trust
in court decisions, yet they can be difficult for non-experts to understand. We
present a pipeline for using an AI assistant to generate simplified summaries
of judicial opinions. Compared to existing expert-written summaries, these
AI-generated simple summaries are more accessible to the public and more easily
understood by non-experts. We show in a survey experiment that the AI summaries
help respondents understand the key features of a ruling, and have higher
perceived quality, especially for respondents with less formal education.
|
[
-0.3844627738,
-0.3927078843,
0.8362221122,
0.0685530826,
-0.7148060203,
-0.2618710995,
-0.1467764974,
-0.2572198808,
0.5314905643,
0.5894954801,
-0.0146600576,
-0.4532139599,
-0.7949588895,
0.1151600778,
-0.7233416438,
1.3723691702,
0.2008721232,
0.0914861634,
-0.2387874126,
-0.2656759322,
-0.11558754,
-0.3873851001,
-0.3513565063,
-0.0700401068,
0.439396292,
0.5333834887,
0.9208567142,
0.3927904665,
0.4868177474,
0.4267953932,
-0.1588492393,
0.0306088477,
-0.3088062108,
-0.185816139,
-0.0912738219,
-0.8436408639,
-0.4837567508,
0.0794513822,
0.2083576918,
0.5355097651,
-0.1000583768,
0.3101086318,
-0.4368035793,
1.021974206,
-0.5663366914,
0.2924055457,
-0.414843142,
0.5812219977,
-0.243564412,
-0.1601330787,
-0.3055904508,
-0.640887022,
0.2619289458,
-1.0775500536,
0.2375918925,
-0.0417683572,
0.7557269931,
0.6559330821,
-0.7311959863,
-0.1260195822,
-0.8606603742,
0.5129616857,
-0.8810108304,
0.2298647314,
0.277526021,
0.6283542514,
0.0475386046,
-0.7967046499,
-0.7874549627,
0.0476792753,
-0.348524034,
0.7737053037,
-0.1307656169,
0.2394539118,
0.1384066492,
0.1460727751,
-0.3917449117,
-0.1764136255,
-0.5526223779,
0.0608055294,
1.0324566364,
-0.0884099603,
0.475022316,
-0.4086702466,
0.532727778,
-0.0862478763,
-0.5000689626,
0.2622625828,
0.4834843576,
-0.0424541198,
-0.0743995681,
0.5872352719,
-0.2039382011,
0.4929598868,
0.3902347088,
-0.4353382587,
0.2457290292,
-0.2559891343,
-0.4951762259,
0.4371431768,
0.7839113474,
0.7634660602,
0.4219322801,
0.0380140617,
-0.1189416274,
-0.4647779465,
0.3081279695,
-0.6350876689,
-0.1527486145,
0.3707847893,
-0.9518793225,
-0.6151487827,
0.5125171542,
-0.7310820818,
-0.7977928519,
-0.6264510155,
-0.0504879691,
0.1306738406,
-0.0721474364,
0.0213872083,
-0.7508621812,
0.1715107858,
1.0190982819,
-0.7868583798,
0.2078905255,
0.6006681323,
0.3801800609,
0.3404618502,
0.1865557581,
-0.5343874097,
0.2675279677,
-0.5307314992,
0.9365355968,
-0.3556981981,
-0.5238022208,
0.0276587438,
-0.0474421158,
0.1763862222,
-0.5238744617,
0.3781686723,
-0.4117620587,
0.2543152869,
-0.0626337901,
-0.2419890314,
-0.3611576855,
0.0265072491,
-0.6345777512,
0.0827739239,
-0.2761629224,
-0.7998028994,
0.7934725285,
-0.791367054,
-1.0023490191,
0.0679673851,
-0.5279105306,
-0.4350922108,
0.5868245363,
0.6927831769,
0.1459978521,
-0.015390004,
0.2567207515,
-0.0277325977,
-0.1016311347,
0.1823008358,
-0.2447418272,
0.8399903774,
0.4106827974,
-0.401117146,
0.3330814838,
-0.2975236177,
-0.5081989169,
-0.1675985008,
-0.3682860732,
-0.2259066552,
0.2836153805,
0.0132392123,
-0.1404662132,
0.1001711413,
-0.1655232012,
0.2254371494,
-0.7137117982,
0.4005651474,
0.70806849,
0.3805900514,
0.6379821301,
-0.2155468911,
0.633459866,
0.0257529262,
0.1852374524,
-0.0702164173,
-0.6247668266,
-0.7410619855,
0.1461848617,
0.4742898345,
0.7137008309,
-0.4989107549,
0.2656016946,
-0.435456723,
-0.2811490893,
-1.064421773,
0.2825889587,
0.249989599,
0.3088585734,
0.1897966266,
-0.1665993333,
-0.4753770828,
-1.0401124954,
-0.6796196103,
-0.5521875024,
-0.0378280021,
0.6104478836,
0.468832165,
0.0631351992,
0.8540510535,
-0.3403577507,
-0.2316956669,
-0.3827455938,
0.423173666,
0.1496822536,
0.0548806526,
0.4969500601,
-1.0153734684,
-0.6517153978,
0.3639451265,
-0.9083515406,
-0.0317625515,
-0.5954042673,
0.0540234111,
-0.2495283931,
0.3959177434,
-0.4846922159,
0.6742305756,
-0.1849911511,
-0.314085573,
0.3041258156,
-0.2228057981,
0.4522262812,
-1.12586236,
-0.124482736,
-0.0904709324,
-0.6416097283,
-0.5049353242,
-0.0400285386,
-0.2470129281,
-0.1695594788,
-0.6301037669,
0.1439498961,
-0.1783370078,
-0.0832260475,
-0.2169682384,
0.4479177594,
-0.0620919801,
0.1321843863,
0.1362623423,
0.7268592119,
0.0855164304,
-0.4455882609,
0.3669801652,
0.6141064167,
-0.1980908215,
0.5815113187,
-0.6000636816,
-0.0810720325,
-0.4899796247,
0.1810004711,
-0.6613019705,
-0.7326839566,
0.0513958894,
-0.4853854477,
0.2337404937,
-0.4139187634,
-0.3189247847,
-0.2894581854,
-0.2962340415,
-0.04619186,
0.6328491569,
-0.2050155699,
0.8811072707,
0.8411274552,
-0.446954906,
-0.5041740537,
-0.8987635374,
0.423631072,
-0.2228158414,
-0.2845453918,
-0.0585161373,
0.1899826527,
-0.7915841937,
0.1929601282,
0.1340892315,
-0.0879210606,
0.1984227151,
0.3975070417,
-0.1493085623,
-0.249429673,
0.1901372075,
0.7180160284,
0.088041693,
0.5382307768,
-0.0012068144,
-0.2620026469,
-0.0496252812,
-0.4706460238,
-0.8595982194,
0.4957773089,
0.9019189477,
-0.2394164801,
0.1867930442,
-0.060558062,
-0.0185344908,
0.1002398506,
-0.3970299661,
-0.0028721383,
-0.4129456878,
0.1108954623,
-0.2094910592,
-0.3988887966,
0.0467882082,
-0.1492291838,
0.3885443807,
0.6824515462,
0.5669482946,
-0.2862559855,
1.2490730286,
0.3132689595,
-0.5125492811,
0.4859663248,
0.0892743543,
0.3499340415,
-0.2183415741,
0.0951337218,
-0.5161621571,
-0.2586275935,
-0.6794768572,
0.2088998854,
0.4673108757,
-0.1910814494,
0.0865556747,
-0.0187734831,
-0.4682649374,
0.6855952144,
0.8614759445,
0.1813036054,
0.4318562746,
-0.1509247124,
0.1847513169,
0.2141734958,
-0.2257996798,
-0.8099886179,
1.094487071,
-0.0181847271,
0.3946685791,
0.4127123654,
0.9066823125,
0.6187919974,
0.2454700768,
-0.7723126411,
0.5217317343,
-0.251160562,
-0.4715398252,
-0.3455075324,
-0.2417147011,
-0.5949649811,
0.0156827141,
-0.6567242146,
-0.2811234593,
0.2548977137,
0.2284823954,
-0.7900002003,
0.1769811958,
-0.7390354276,
0.6067122221,
-0.1701527536,
0.0610283278,
-0.5477476716,
-0.95580405,
0.4166725874,
0.0495099798,
0.4186195433,
0.1744340807,
0.2308313102,
0.8566552997,
-0.8453243971,
0.761046052,
-0.2161836475,
0.246941328,
0.3839334249,
-0.1960974485,
0.280230552,
0.3529900312,
0.0361877568,
-0.2781993449,
-0.208593294,
-0.1135849878,
-0.950137794,
0.2380070388,
-1.1196421385,
-1.1301900148,
-0.3008392155,
-0.5178579688,
0.2464136332,
0.3288248181,
-0.0913891345,
0.229914546,
-0.1476246119,
0.1897533834,
0.5521910191,
-0.105564259,
0.2116793543,
0.3376051486,
0.0085905287,
-0.5568575263,
0.8816333413,
0.2946076393,
-0.407700032,
0.5465275645,
0.3563687205,
-0.2934277952,
-0.6314040422,
-0.8660548925,
0.1252296269,
-0.851323247,
0.1038456634,
-0.5750446916,
0.0164602567,
-0.7888919115,
-0.4347218573,
0.1569378227,
-1.0723353624,
-0.1536854357,
-0.5282512903,
0.4128701687,
1.1219289303,
0.0077024959,
0.180611372,
-0.6883975267,
0.5028445125,
0.8390085101,
-0.1412407309,
-0.4133160412,
-0.5251482725,
0.0921399444,
-0.2610118091,
-0.2428641617,
-0.8729590774,
0.3117040694,
-0.1029918641,
0.4110958576,
1.0101401806,
0.1920925826,
1.0553611517,
-0.584579587,
0.9687294364,
0.0855770558,
-0.9065139294,
1.0405474901,
-0.1321896017,
0.0421194471,
0.8668296933,
0.1724042594,
-0.2415773124,
-0.8744019866,
-0.7256004214,
-0.6918802857,
0.4811729193,
0.2169357836,
0.1270703822,
0.2241706252,
0.364477843,
0.004894706,
0.5586655736,
-0.3214928508,
-0.0807250589,
-0.7559500337,
-0.4316940904,
-0.0835657939,
-0.104155533,
-0.3211274147,
-0.3121065795,
0.5309464335,
0.1090038717,
-0.0541507564,
0.2108639032,
-0.3462507725,
0.1637341529,
0.6196987629,
0.9322519898,
0.5538574457,
-0.126676932,
0.2475806028,
0.3077941537,
-0.4250097573,
0.0373549685,
0.1244155765,
-0.5884931087,
0.2494342327,
0.5645268559,
0.678030014,
-0.2565355301,
-0.5218898058,
0.7554289103,
-0.4293642938,
-0.3987702429,
-0.5340616703,
0.0034877511,
0.0346404351,
0.2189585716,
0.089794673,
0.266230762,
0.6257349253,
-0.6940287352,
0.0393861681,
0.1072931662,
-0.2993806601,
-0.1323492527,
0.949682951,
0.6783060431,
-0.3920052648,
0.3826348186,
0.0515431874,
-0.2485912144,
0.5706176162,
0.08885777,
0.93314749,
0.3670227528,
0.0441023931,
0.1796456873,
0.1914879382,
-0.1804032028,
0.0192162357,
-0.5068005323,
-0.1353955418,
-0.2267343104,
0.0077580404,
-0.6158771515,
-0.4588905573,
-0.681435883,
0.099114418,
-0.579733789,
-0.2350260466,
0.0570893511,
-0.2572050989,
-0.378208518,
0.2462145239,
-0.1432317644,
0.6990453601,
-0.9615918398,
0.4691974223,
0.7492383718,
-0.9505097866,
-0.8489450216,
0.1483024359,
0.1166676804,
-0.420396775,
0.6357703805,
-0.0934361964,
-0.1066163331,
-0.2919643819,
-0.5572595,
-0.0584814362,
1.1401871443,
0.2462211549,
-0.6205916405,
-0.0015009469,
0.308989197,
0.6595544219,
-0.0794734955,
0.6688929796,
0.4380136728,
0.7741734982,
-0.2322552949,
-0.8643465042,
-0.0360806808,
-0.5515514612,
-0.3292339146,
0.1093294993,
-0.4090871811,
0.3275778592,
-0.2987585664,
-0.1708853692,
-0.3688662946,
0.8471803665,
-0.172804907,
0.5496225953,
0.4850911796,
0.4387242496,
0.970908761,
-0.0782840028,
1.3287998438,
-0.506423831,
-0.2783616185,
1.195630312,
0.0458975062,
0.7392445803,
0.6593096256,
0.0804351196,
0.5103313327,
0.3566561937,
0.0679063722,
0.3259830773,
0.0311015658,
-0.2649742067,
-0.3138014078,
-0.2388619632,
-0.2299740911,
0.2603476942,
-0.033667881,
-0.5322285295,
0.0243308656,
-0.1384431273,
-0.0538602285,
0.4785182178,
-0.5117486715,
1.3917156458,
0.179287836,
-0.7726140618,
-0.2964317799,
-0.0534911454,
0.0820640475,
-0.1238740459,
-0.310695827,
-0.3302540481,
-0.1932512373,
-0.4765507281,
-0.8827275634,
0.2047770768,
0.4461174607,
-0.2176206112,
-0.3352619708,
0.3511327207,
0.0341642648,
-0.6434823871,
-0.2321281731,
0.3780454993,
0.5842829347,
0.1417502612,
-0.5818530917,
-0.4753072858,
-0.1635725051,
-0.210656479,
-0.0492384061,
0.7083768845,
-0.2116211951,
0.4334125221,
0.5941289067,
0.3049179316,
-0.0484709479,
0.4992949367,
0.7781971097,
-0.6000937223,
-0.5754039884,
-0.815782249,
0.6874431372,
-0.526812613,
-0.2950879931,
0.6960901022,
0.6707374454,
0.5688339472,
-0.1749137342,
1.0458062887,
0.1985267401,
0.3486825228,
-0.5293991566,
1.1055734158,
-0.554448545,
-0.0727287084,
-0.1583040059,
-0.2408072948,
-0.5698475242,
0.6791902781,
-0.4210358262,
-0.365090847,
0.3408121169,
0.5307711363,
0.0757065639,
-0.0284577124,
0.2999219,
0.0291301105,
0.4405734241,
0.3627804518,
0.5671489239,
-0.2337290943,
0.6313284039,
0.0321875066,
0.0427997001,
-0.3367313445,
-0.5788567662,
-1.2378622293,
0.0243797489,
-0.1946627349,
-0.0409764946,
0.0325277075,
1.0158238411,
0.6362840533,
-0.9714400768,
-0.2331949621,
-0.4770945609,
0.3312638402,
-0.052737426,
-0.1922275126,
0.423116684,
-0.1414410919,
-0.7919759154,
0.2394574434,
0.2425034046,
0.0739976391,
-0.0733170584,
-0.0569080263,
0.0727966577,
0.423142761,
0.4679135978,
0.2865132391,
-0.9229180813,
-0.1891710907,
-0.4861433506,
-0.004119602,
0.2112751156,
0.8922032714,
-0.2664510608,
0.7141276002,
0.8077950478,
0.7040894032,
0.438159734,
0.4620435834,
0.8689277172,
-0.22826536,
0.2523783147,
0.0848378837,
0.6418735981,
-0.0850988925,
-0.3948495686,
0.3043446541,
0.0272744503,
-0.3555614054,
-0.4652504325,
0.0490923673,
-0.8735284805,
-0.2328440696,
0.6935771704,
-0.1680117399,
-0.3756266534,
-0.2891293168,
-0.3530344069,
0.2000913918,
-0.7487435937,
1.0285204649,
0.4353566468,
-0.0678310618,
-0.1319241524,
-0.6674741507,
0.5824168921,
0.2222967893,
-1.1170309782,
-0.3200329244,
0.4403478801,
0.1327056587,
0.2522889972,
0.6390647292,
-0.1133959293,
0.5787143707,
-0.0512775332,
-0.0756755099,
-0.2067830414,
-0.3441922963,
-0.3396387398,
0.3049753606,
0.1924890578,
0.1027569324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06532v1
|
Added Toxicity Mitigation at Inference Time for Multimodal and Massively Multilingual Translation
| 2023-11-11T11:02:02 | 2023-11-11T11:02:02 |
Marta R. Costa-jussà, David Dale, Maha Elbayad, Bokai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Added toxicity in the context of translation refers to the fact of producing
a translation output with more toxicity than there exists in the input. In this
paper, we present MinTox which is a novel pipeline to identify added toxicity
and mitigate this issue which works at inference time. MinTox uses a toxicity
detection classifier which is multimodal (speech and text) and works in
languages at scale. The mitigation method is applied to languages at scale and
directly in text outputs. MinTox is applied to SEAMLESSM4T, which is the latest
multimodal and massively multilingual machine translation system. For this
system, MinTox achieves significant added toxicity mitigation across domains,
modalities and language directions. MinTox manages to approximately filter out
from 25% to 95% of added toxicity (depending on the modality and domain) while
keeping translation quality.
|
[
-0.2739382088,
-0.7191442847,
0.6165853739,
0.4565032125,
-0.0357587524,
0.0291411448,
0.136031583,
-0.2011137456,
0.0175061822,
0.6937251091,
-0.5801863074,
-0.491240263,
-0.4392800927,
-0.0108047239,
-0.0690505281,
1.1459736824,
0.2036911547,
0.0217541121,
-0.2160405517,
-0.4112102389,
-0.7525484562,
-0.4158416986,
-0.7182312012,
-0.3580816388,
0.7381236553,
0.3797679842,
0.7904155254,
0.5143392086,
0.098310709,
0.4191079736,
-0.3215143681,
-0.0531054027,
-0.2681968808,
0.3179526627,
-0.3902318478,
-0.709967792,
-0.6086742878,
-0.0904537365,
0.5153309107,
0.3094579875,
-0.0557480678,
-0.2408509851,
-0.0276518296,
0.4806911349,
-0.7368632555,
0.0040230546,
-0.6600731611,
0.2341336459,
-0.2408133149,
-0.3306370676,
-0.6515797377,
-0.1401603073,
-0.3350906074,
-0.6184142828,
-0.2660298645,
-0.0650427639,
0.6096166372,
0.3508965373,
-0.7529425025,
-0.1503350884,
-0.3251235187,
0.9596156478,
-0.7056762576,
0.3838553131,
0.024067238,
0.1018426791,
-0.0436747819,
-0.6039908528,
-0.3279821873,
0.0160399582,
0.0055682645,
0.4012794495,
-0.0937799364,
0.0720030889,
0.1693409979,
0.0709799305,
-0.5600269437,
0.0919004455,
0.1349176168,
-0.7664945722,
0.1573018432,
0.177800104,
0.6227955818,
-0.3377475739,
-0.4977443218,
-0.0143312765,
-0.5151771307,
-0.4291204512,
0.338924855,
0.046032466,
0.3139755428,
0.3213714957,
0.0335176736,
0.3028577864,
-0.4378837347,
0.0026301742,
0.4954183996,
-0.556453228,
0.0149328066,
0.318867743,
0.9110254049,
0.4740927219,
-0.082008183,
0.0483649075,
-0.096832253,
0.2431141734,
0.1494179219,
-1.1437470913,
-0.0466531478,
0.6066354513,
-0.1293951571,
-0.4386968315,
-0.6646925211,
-1.0679740906,
-0.5823099613,
0.0956031904,
0.4149633348,
-0.5929162502,
-0.7269374728,
0.0438846648,
-0.4621455371,
-0.157988742,
0.2314375937,
-0.2784551084,
-0.0032158173,
0.5758855343,
1.2473319769,
-0.1063053608,
-0.3451271057,
-1.1228898764,
0.4012402296,
-0.3768139184,
0.9739602804,
-0.4872419834,
-0.3826259673,
-0.1855851412,
-0.1849591881,
0.1492577791,
-0.6489335895,
0.7955171466,
-0.460365802,
0.2630602121,
0.0544183105,
-0.2231254131,
-0.0889620408,
0.3195531368,
-0.6216411591,
0.6207235456,
0.0233735722,
-0.9889746904,
0.2703159451,
-0.6911155581,
-0.5879117846,
0.2098172754,
0.4561338425,
-0.6113547683,
-0.0080108633,
0.0083292285,
0.1171010956,
0.1180542782,
0.2044163942,
-0.6330645084,
-0.0370788537,
0.3263617456,
-0.7010532618,
0.9040417671,
0.8205961585,
-0.0880955532,
0.5928898454,
-0.5276840925,
0.3039681911,
-0.4084968567,
-0.2569051385,
-0.6860597134,
-0.2029886246,
0.3751208186,
0.5548503399,
-0.0958261192,
-0.6010414362,
-0.2663460374,
-0.1682128012,
0.7207654715,
0.6818095446,
0.1782767475,
0.3163688481,
-0.3157396019,
0.3310662508,
0.240257442,
0.2037474811,
-0.3475725651,
-0.6526719928,
-0.5384688973,
-0.6816945076,
0.2580467463,
0.8656067848,
-1.060732007,
0.5021643043,
-0.4800080061,
-0.4157701731,
-0.2658751607,
0.1276307106,
0.574619472,
0.1733206511,
0.3538505435,
-0.413379252,
-0.1323751658,
-0.519479692,
-0.4647347927,
-0.2262961566,
-0.087997742,
0.1248036176,
0.3715544939,
-0.7554787993,
0.4675118923,
-0.4997498393,
-0.3580642045,
-0.0160332844,
0.4856687188,
-0.0272877738,
0.539352417,
0.4768909812,
-0.5946813822,
-0.4866774082,
0.3580648899,
-0.6108255982,
-0.5835086703,
-0.4560893178,
-0.6170800924,
-0.1483461708,
0.5773515701,
-0.4963050783,
0.0049670134,
0.5541970134,
-0.2971492112,
0.3924386501,
-0.4845576584,
0.2999872267,
-1.0059976578,
0.0363574773,
-0.0083143301,
-0.445633918,
-0.6634783745,
0.3049136102,
0.549031198,
-0.2444229126,
-0.733045578,
0.4907489419,
-0.2599264979,
0.3932983279,
-0.277261436,
0.0972246751,
0.4691367447,
0.1605364233,
0.1651038677,
0.8596856594,
0.3363620043,
-0.6352926493,
0.3368888795,
0.1231760308,
0.1670976281,
1.1084777117,
-0.3307743967,
-0.222917974,
0.1493590325,
0.1552891135,
-0.9513154626,
-0.1841603518,
0.0528126061,
-0.4751547873,
0.4163375199,
-0.2791211605,
-0.6439958215,
-0.2496257424,
-0.4636831582,
0.3232570589,
0.1022365987,
-0.2641535401,
0.4131886363,
0.3009782732,
-0.2171496153,
-0.2229425758,
-1.0172834396,
0.3756946623,
-0.6852257252,
-0.6788321733,
0.0274617579,
-0.4778434634,
0.0476159528,
-0.0485453121,
0.028820239,
-0.4086911082,
0.295602262,
-0.1115914136,
0.025981795,
-0.0840407684,
0.1280742437,
0.6294995546,
-0.401858598,
0.1930135787,
0.0926940143,
0.4753455222,
-0.1369688213,
-0.2214741111,
-0.4034092724,
0.697843194,
1.1278637648,
-0.4982572496,
0.7326956987,
0.8445262313,
-0.048356995,
0.0357291587,
-0.3412190378,
0.0337514542,
-0.484685123,
0.6042508483,
-0.3938827217,
-0.3015530407,
0.7286765575,
-0.3104906082,
-0.2052963227,
0.423986882,
0.5427025557,
0.5634843707,
1.2660515308,
0.0055900477,
0.0401379429,
0.6011568308,
0.0130191613,
0.0494278297,
-1.0140202045,
0.0458268635,
-0.3481092751,
0.0855395719,
-0.6129794717,
-0.5622879267,
0.7181156874,
-0.1291583478,
-0.4223286808,
0.3787588477,
-0.3342068493,
0.2724457383,
0.5829202533,
0.1293003708,
0.5005548596,
-0.1417607069,
-0.4089742899,
-0.0434486568,
-0.5324216485,
-0.0971698165,
0.9331724644,
0.3806701005,
0.5089600682,
0.3957889676,
0.5778446198,
0.3042918444,
0.6110614538,
-0.8501355052,
0.1456582248,
0.3113308251,
-1.1530593634,
0.0032275366,
-0.8587287664,
-0.7380734086,
0.6684752107,
-0.1073681042,
-0.324010402,
-0.1403857768,
-0.0844197273,
-0.2888810933,
0.2944706082,
-1.2706860304,
1.1770666838,
-0.443361789,
-1.0608638525,
-0.3600187302,
-0.4578414857,
0.4892140627,
-0.3259737492,
0.8241395354,
-0.0062821899,
-0.2417231053,
0.3151971698,
-0.3447901905,
0.5056495667,
-0.0760060102,
-0.124775812,
0.2461868227,
0.3802863955,
0.3038250506,
0.3065838814,
-0.1721217334,
0.2829336226,
0.3824634552,
-0.386392504,
-0.0943017751,
1.1464180946,
-0.5590612888,
-0.3432143331,
-0.7680354118,
-0.7162252665,
-0.0796632692,
0.7058752179,
0.2715424597,
0.2598725259,
-0.0783891901,
-0.0802045465,
0.8726217747,
-0.872110188,
0.388022393,
0.5775892735,
-0.1946533024,
-0.8740372658,
1.2022696733,
0.0041606664,
0.6139346361,
0.223603785,
0.5776396394,
-0.3671172261,
-0.4817172289,
-0.67677176,
0.3797254264,
-0.7539953589,
-0.52063483,
-0.6976841688,
-0.1147747412,
-0.4851606488,
0.0764322653,
-0.5690094233,
0.0124950362,
-0.2361998707,
-0.042417828,
0.3423195779,
0.3424906135,
-0.237931475,
0.5011804104,
-1.251906991,
0.1894134134,
0.158503592,
0.6539661884,
-0.3532408178,
-0.3173195124,
0.0162626561,
0.1445387304,
-0.5888768435,
-1.0764231682,
0.6892260909,
0.3423966467,
0.545414865,
0.5739391446,
0.2198432684,
0.7694755793,
-0.6262162924,
0.5519330502,
0.3974373937,
-1.2134046555,
0.4723827243,
-0.4454875886,
0.3858252764,
0.1593972743,
0.1605056822,
-1.0375066996,
-0.5087865591,
-0.2645902038,
-0.9467771649,
0.5303421617,
0.289776355,
0.2601988316,
-0.1951238215,
-0.0356521904,
0.0756055191,
0.2316266447,
-0.607491374,
-0.0106915757,
-0.3145149648,
-0.1170358732,
-0.0769599155,
-0.3675380647,
-0.0734338164,
-0.091668129,
0.6378004551,
0.086312905,
0.0675429031,
-0.1290481538,
-0.3827275932,
-0.2454182506,
0.5342104435,
0.3067525923,
0.169944331,
-0.2914530635,
0.2742303014,
-0.0233129971,
-0.442093581,
0.0472148508,
-0.0385326631,
-0.0026260661,
-0.1954589337,
0.4863633811,
0.59397012,
0.1171766296,
-0.7840989828,
0.5818451643,
0.0190889481,
-0.0128769306,
0.0678233057,
-0.0750683248,
0.0261641797,
-0.0456955098,
-0.2017524391,
0.4196859002,
0.6085704565,
-0.7334110141,
0.5193705559,
0.4457900524,
-0.6230720282,
-0.1994215846,
0.9125010967,
0.4991843402,
0.2483471334,
0.3597934842,
-0.1707838029,
-0.7152241468,
0.2447624952,
0.5574424267,
0.783846736,
-0.5337486863,
0.2977184653,
0.4330352545,
0.3268870413,
0.2793420851,
-0.0783472136,
0.2638050616,
-0.5196422338,
-0.5835933089,
-0.5244383812,
-0.1144018173,
0.0928564072,
-0.5293862224,
0.2231218666,
-0.1287468672,
-0.1050598025,
-0.0554393828,
-0.135816589,
-0.281163305,
-0.1632941067,
0.1533599347,
0.5108382702,
-1.4541430473,
0.6456020474,
0.5950385928,
-0.4981403053,
-0.1092745513,
-0.1558263451,
0.2571496665,
-0.5106141567,
0.2172833681,
0.4971261322,
-0.1258663982,
0.1328530908,
-0.0011117214,
-0.5636613369,
0.6500738263,
0.4235840142,
-0.0126509098,
0.3662270606,
0.1081305146,
0.583511889,
0.2456996888,
0.8283866048,
0.5700405836,
0.7105235457,
0.3461323082,
-0.9044445753,
0.0595714413,
-0.4008347392,
0.1335117966,
0.2332139611,
-0.5693929791,
0.5895798206,
0.0791714787,
-0.2393553704,
-0.0112500759,
0.1603827327,
-0.0782572776,
0.5185383558,
0.4209641218,
0.7386297584,
0.6504522562,
-0.0639982671,
0.9141276479,
0.009115193,
0.2089180946,
0.8465624452,
-0.19163239,
0.5494418144,
0.4484292865,
-0.0775299668,
0.3452204466,
0.6894831657,
0.4917510748,
0.6756926179,
0.150760904,
-0.4204457104,
-0.3297629654,
-0.281970948,
-0.3720906079,
-0.0344305634,
0.8449174762,
-0.0453924946,
-0.3164336681,
0.4437467158,
0.4594270289,
0.0292503554,
-0.3348610699,
0.8641152382,
-0.2066811621,
-0.8066223264,
0.6184741855,
-0.1683019251,
0.6316260099,
-0.5099252462,
-0.0300123468,
-0.3843164146,
0.6730155945,
-0.2123374492,
-0.952860117,
0.4966541231,
-0.3318918645,
0.1489663571,
-0.2901393175,
0.2816245258,
-0.514644444,
-0.4191955626,
0.5815715194,
0.3924554586,
0.0804769099,
-0.7253297567,
-0.665323019,
0.1698617488,
-0.0278545525,
0.0131623922,
0.3150774837,
1.1149140596,
-0.1863211244,
0.8236857653,
0.6229412556,
0.2260795236,
0.3955637217,
-0.0709907636,
0.9424427748,
-0.3439365327,
-0.4810035825,
-0.6134480834,
0.6063438058,
-0.3010562062,
-0.0582061112,
0.847819984,
0.7727984786,
0.5659213066,
-0.0262992326,
0.8186609149,
0.013982174,
0.1914553791,
-0.3554922342,
0.756131947,
-0.7173851132,
0.3511886597,
-0.5044041276,
-0.6891266108,
-0.6125339866,
0.3789079785,
-0.0969893932,
-0.2798704207,
1.1461368799,
0.7680328488,
-0.1485607326,
-0.4172625244,
0.3598440886,
0.304964453,
0.7183832526,
0.5588231683,
0.551309526,
-0.3647806644,
0.8958746195,
-0.2959674001,
-0.5713364482,
-0.3483905792,
-1.0347933769,
-0.6735637188,
-0.3807605803,
-0.4813969135,
-0.6480851173,
-0.2618793249,
0.3857527971,
0.5040687323,
-0.9165133834,
0.0868376195,
-0.1723576933,
0.5453343987,
-0.5614624619,
-0.2364993244,
-0.0084453132,
-0.5959482193,
-0.8559136391,
-0.0134053044,
0.3536953032,
-0.387670368,
-0.0761009976,
-0.1350986809,
-0.1954175532,
0.0836428106,
0.8450244665,
-0.071484372,
-0.5843007565,
-0.4187304676,
-0.2421418726,
-0.0098814582,
0.043882262,
0.6387599111,
-0.3817648292,
1.1995033026,
0.6254751086,
0.4613666534,
0.3003543615,
-0.2754187882,
0.5344484448,
-0.6521103382,
0.2585838735,
0.2204222232,
0.2857843637,
0.3756895363,
-0.4083467424,
0.3125235438,
0.5082221031,
-0.4088644087,
-0.7653080225,
0.3401082158,
-0.8485187292,
-0.4956926107,
1.3232821226,
-0.2253699154,
-0.2320155352,
-0.2442765087,
-0.4141586423,
0.5197767615,
-0.4205298126,
0.4307804406,
0.6572579145,
0.2187916636,
-0.1141087338,
-0.8925797939,
0.1249386296,
0.2883234322,
-0.9640926123,
0.1775628626,
0.756449759,
0.4739329219,
0.4394459426,
0.1326531917,
-0.3068856001,
0.0458009429,
0.1374618411,
-0.0154854199,
0.1231743842,
-0.2132981718,
-0.0284538027,
-0.0682403594,
-0.0077187205,
-0.1830491126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06530v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06530v2
|
Exploring ChatGPT's Capabilities on Vulnerability Management
| 2023-11-11T11:01:13 | 2024-06-20T06:18:13 |
Peiyu Liu, Junming Liu, Lirong Fu, Kangjie Lu, Yifan Xia, Xuhong Zhang, Wenzhi Chen, Haiqin Weng, Shouling Ji, Wenhai Wang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Recently, ChatGPT has attracted great attention from the code analysis
domain. Prior works show that ChatGPT has the capabilities of processing
foundational code analysis tasks, such as abstract syntax tree generation,
which indicates the potential of using ChatGPT to comprehend code syntax and
static behaviors. However, it is unclear whether ChatGPT can complete more
complicated real-world vulnerability management tasks, such as the prediction
of security relevance and patch correctness, which require an all-encompassing
understanding of various aspects, including code syntax, program semantics, and
related manual comments.
In this paper, we explore ChatGPT's capabilities on 6 tasks involving the
complete vulnerability management process with a large-scale dataset containing
70,346 samples. For each task, we compare ChatGPT against SOTA approaches,
investigate the impact of different prompts, and explore the difficulties. The
results suggest promising potential in leveraging ChatGPT to assist
vulnerability management. One notable example is ChatGPT's proficiency in tasks
like generating titles for software bug reports. Furthermore, our findings
reveal the difficulties encountered by ChatGPT and shed light on promising
future directions. For instance, directly providing random demonstration
examples in the prompt cannot consistently guarantee good performance in
vulnerability management. By contrast, leveraging ChatGPT in a self-heuristic
way -- extracting expertise from demonstration examples itself and integrating
the extracted expertise in the prompt is a promising research direction.
Besides, ChatGPT may misunderstand and misuse the information in the prompt.
Consequently, effectively guiding ChatGPT to focus on helpful information
rather than the irrelevant content is still an open problem.
|
[
-0.376986444,
-0.7130775452,
0.3926286697,
0.4316838086,
0.006002089,
0.3109620512,
-0.134091571,
-0.3129857481,
-0.0262588635,
0.2038856894,
-0.6162564158,
-0.3226938546,
-0.6758570671,
-0.1434144378,
-0.1930721551,
1.2867590189,
0.1469087005,
-0.355537653,
0.0945333838,
0.1397554725,
-1.0140192509,
-0.7196738124,
-0.6841661334,
0.2952756286,
0.29983446,
0.9385604858,
0.5695601106,
0.1593030542,
0.9405483007,
0.2113351673,
0.0391458683,
-0.4581547081,
-0.4547343254,
0.2382253706,
0.0744456202,
-0.480220288,
-0.451162219,
-0.0493172184,
0.2964299917,
0.2037209421,
-0.0362258852,
0.1638977677,
0.3248426318,
0.4580513537,
-0.4457481205,
0.3369298577,
-0.634719193,
0.1459084749,
-0.2805562913,
-0.2699510157,
-0.2676535249,
-0.1541017592,
0.4064741135,
-0.1037490591,
0.1674779803,
-0.0321885832,
0.4840829074,
0.1747835279,
-0.2613967955,
-0.3253440559,
-0.6709622145,
0.2941467464,
-0.497831285,
0.0291260593,
0.2275922745,
0.7189704776,
-0.1905105561,
-0.3868598044,
-0.1495467275,
-0.4239547253,
0.1359390765,
0.1967330128,
-0.233907491,
-0.149401024,
0.4263847172,
0.2960586846,
-0.7346474528,
0.0009614796,
-0.3508774936,
-0.4649042189,
0.463503927,
0.1728538722,
0.3030030429,
-0.4010142684,
-0.6718544364,
-0.0277844705,
-0.6916567683,
0.1311644912,
0.1690215468,
0.1177737266,
0.0463061221,
0.3985604048,
0.0125308987,
0.3291511536,
-0.5329396129,
0.1860139966,
-0.1264744252,
-0.1512644589,
-0.1593304276,
-0.1644865423,
0.6889840364,
0.2389000505,
0.0646826103,
-0.2901886702,
0.0660776049,
-0.1266860813,
0.4662381411,
-0.584210217,
-0.5922620893,
0.209526971,
-0.2010281831,
-0.3905203342,
0.0780504644,
-1.0793091059,
-0.5359515548,
0.3118439019,
0.3655050397,
-0.7875745893,
-0.5390086174,
-0.0155594852,
-0.3007944226,
0.2870775461,
0.2651579082,
-0.4330819845,
0.0611109734,
0.6034686565,
0.8661526442,
-0.1685502678,
-0.2403366864,
-0.4922500551,
-0.0396053642,
0.1234612092,
0.9230110645,
-0.4137682617,
-0.4512604475,
-0.3327518404,
-0.315866977,
-0.1518506259,
-0.1914840788,
0.3358925283,
-0.3637700677,
-0.0940661281,
-0.3600554764,
-0.1987889856,
0.0308220703,
0.7485299706,
-0.3729707003,
0.888058424,
0.1045337245,
-0.7581579089,
0.1444876641,
-0.582839489,
-0.0666263923,
0.0852383003,
-0.173037231,
-0.3211078346,
-0.2477653921,
0.0739835575,
0.4257527292,
-0.2381296158,
-0.1372140944,
-0.0330724157,
-0.2008133084,
0.5355155468,
-0.4066912234,
0.3474449515,
0.2908608913,
-0.696454525,
-0.0539214201,
-0.4736578465,
0.0341393538,
0.0763053969,
-0.1383192092,
-0.0444474258,
-0.0653378889,
-0.0864022896,
0.1040024459,
-0.027323775,
-0.2042235434,
0.412763238,
-0.2245381922,
0.5169218779,
0.6957774758,
0.3382183015,
0.2954530418,
-0.2490237057,
0.905153513,
-0.162146613,
0.3460452259,
-0.4614286423,
-0.6307712197,
-0.5651943684,
-0.1551321,
0.4040154219,
1.0153721571,
-0.6278137565,
0.151654765,
-0.1972436756,
-0.6493119001,
0.1520077884,
-0.1569574475,
0.5952116251,
0.4002575278,
0.2936562002,
-0.5334802866,
-0.2417474389,
-0.5342003107,
-0.436137706,
-0.2897801399,
-0.0284019504,
0.3328034282,
0.2695140243,
-0.0375079103,
1.0076545477,
-0.66150105,
-0.4461159706,
-0.3188196123,
0.2657796741,
0.1603848636,
0.5041574836,
0.4395405054,
-0.7941226959,
-0.4143021107,
-0.0817123204,
-0.4664468467,
-0.0872217566,
-0.1331683248,
-0.08108861,
-0.2205644995,
0.4655659497,
-0.5490573645,
0.3353829384,
0.2601159215,
-0.3136847615,
0.656902194,
-0.0436692685,
0.244070068,
-0.962797761,
-0.009430958,
-0.2084765583,
-0.1245830655,
-0.6393401027,
0.3830859959,
0.0807974041,
-0.5694670081,
-0.4057314694,
0.0797287524,
-0.477098465,
-0.1152233854,
0.0408182554,
0.2192262262,
-0.5462175012,
0.5799986124,
-0.3094100654,
0.7232558131,
0.7456176877,
-0.418174088,
0.3995424807,
0.0388266295,
0.0663820654,
0.3766997457,
-0.6728141308,
0.2845038176,
0.1577765644,
-0.0114492811,
-1.2905031443,
-0.2790559232,
0.5759850144,
-0.4786928892,
0.4442209899,
-0.557313323,
-0.4507490695,
-0.3128841519,
-0.4220230877,
0.1778594553,
0.6115425229,
0.1857619286,
0.2613765299,
0.2608744502,
-0.5144720078,
-0.4532513022,
-0.4722869694,
0.5058960319,
-0.5111346841,
-0.6893207431,
-0.0597797334,
0.0488987751,
-0.1090270728,
-0.1657426357,
-0.3686695099,
0.1522614658,
0.268937856,
0.5437415838,
0.1371898651,
-0.1767069846,
0.2983929515,
-0.4689871967,
-0.5792294741,
0.1408420205,
-0.2700307965,
0.523933053,
-0.3695577383,
-0.8083509207,
0.1128276214,
0.3114196956,
0.3024058044,
-0.4044191241,
0.2922149003,
0.519998908,
0.0125100324,
0.069574669,
-0.6392458081,
-0.2174133211,
-0.3894380033,
0.2554647028,
-0.2826154828,
-0.9580019116,
0.6600834727,
-0.253752172,
0.1003967375,
0.2549743354,
0.1266071796,
-0.188994199,
0.6041407585,
0.5472377539,
-0.2984726429,
0.4799897969,
-0.3458284438,
0.4772146642,
-0.4040920734,
-0.0815536454,
-0.6058927178,
-0.2483739406,
-0.5120875239,
-0.556694448,
0.7861605883,
0.0248282049,
-0.0739916712,
0.504670918,
-0.4728943408,
0.3626648784,
0.4680957794,
0.2171862572,
0.2403677404,
-0.1964839101,
0.4039840996,
0.0952651799,
-0.7647652626,
-0.5092182755,
0.77650249,
0.5120959282,
0.9019938111,
0.2705014944,
0.6745616198,
0.3093425333,
-0.0487078689,
-0.6227171421,
0.6436566114,
0.3569410443,
-0.2716591656,
-0.4256404936,
-0.4301402867,
-0.8337564468,
-0.0887012482,
0.0489536971,
-0.7570582032,
-0.0394366495,
0.325809896,
-0.4371967912,
-0.1038514301,
-1.1637431383,
1.0524350405,
0.1719753146,
0.0145071605,
-0.1535301358,
-0.9097781181,
0.169738546,
0.0593149737,
0.183458358,
-0.1789661497,
0.1077479124,
0.5392898917,
-0.2865318656,
1.0947053432,
-0.2215117812,
-0.207481578,
0.4515078366,
0.5234981775,
0.6183592677,
0.4027518332,
0.0808013156,
0.0671761259,
0.1180146784,
-0.4220291972,
-0.5099137425,
0.4573017359,
-0.3723893166,
-0.8435997963,
-0.4799767733,
-0.4181449115,
-0.467915833,
0.0292472001,
0.3180915117,
0.4872180223,
-0.3104504049,
-0.037082579,
0.7750262022,
-0.2745864391,
0.5698609352,
0.2938754559,
0.1572517455,
0.1290458441,
1.0162032843,
0.2793437541,
0.2641465068,
0.2848079801,
0.1151212454,
0.1928876042,
-0.5693763494,
-0.4453728199,
-0.3394639194,
-0.5463363528,
-0.6054091454,
-0.6668396592,
-0.3895429671,
-0.3116131127,
-0.0492897183,
-0.1217129305,
-0.4810283482,
0.2129727006,
-0.1412172019,
0.6197600365,
0.3240380585,
0.1666088104,
0.4832226634,
-1.0992857218,
0.1450631917,
0.4191949666,
0.1904760003,
-0.1577387303,
-0.071916461,
-0.0607707985,
0.0918158069,
-0.4689211845,
-1.3943630457,
0.0901227295,
0.0820280835,
0.4678868651,
-0.0848634019,
0.1229375079,
0.4346513748,
-0.267539829,
1.0162822008,
-0.1555986404,
-0.8107160926,
0.8818509579,
-0.5970850587,
0.2847411633,
0.4156321585,
0.1434199363,
-0.5838718414,
-1.0027499199,
-0.827193737,
-0.6789813042,
0.6732840538,
0.5497783422,
0.333150655,
0.0421855636,
0.1734282225,
0.0019128865,
-0.0127046993,
-0.4517503381,
0.0408556536,
-0.2366857678,
0.2707240283,
0.2930578887,
-0.3959956467,
-0.0282019433,
0.2503168285,
0.4133538306,
-0.1213501543,
0.5089515448,
0.1048898175,
-0.1670524925,
0.3674350977,
0.7205604315,
0.3644585311,
0.5841358304,
0.1049858108,
0.285528034,
0.373868078,
-0.6233828068,
-0.127252385,
0.0449299365,
0.2855193913,
-0.4240091741,
0.5966981649,
0.2762823105,
0.2905866206,
-0.7130730152,
0.8201853633,
0.0016782715,
0.0290352013,
-0.0607116036,
0.471309334,
-0.1800468564,
0.4145665765,
0.3944034874,
0.0895470604,
0.2899474204,
-0.6639870405,
0.2326107621,
0.3024680018,
-0.3850628734,
-0.2637065947,
0.3286475241,
0.0443719625,
-0.1607946455,
0.7147526145,
-0.242115438,
-0.7103095055,
0.9878169298,
0.436196208,
0.7614426017,
-0.3230550289,
0.2599690259,
0.0467669591,
0.4095292091,
0.184276998,
0.4284784496,
-0.23336716,
-0.3593816757,
-0.3656765223,
-0.0584613308,
-0.5115237832,
-0.3502097726,
-0.467666328,
0.3640257716,
-0.369969815,
-0.0404604189,
-0.1465798467,
-0.360801369,
-0.5129404664,
-0.0757816285,
-0.3321318328,
1.0084701777,
-0.7355558872,
0.3986283541,
0.5690643191,
-0.4502253532,
-0.8903326988,
0.3541305661,
0.137474969,
-0.8801319599,
0.3137175143,
0.1660042703,
0.1813014597,
-0.0855998918,
-0.3835035563,
-0.554102838,
0.951066792,
0.4141897261,
-0.2376896441,
0.0754830688,
0.1407561451,
0.5761540532,
0.2685258687,
0.2556369901,
0.4831385016,
0.4610614777,
0.2802139223,
-0.929749608,
0.0978581831,
-0.2813534737,
-0.0400570147,
0.3579269946,
-0.6864827871,
0.4535828531,
-0.2541246414,
-0.2020363361,
-0.3193060756,
0.3971861899,
-0.0877885818,
0.2866409421,
0.4923945367,
0.2268569618,
0.3662559986,
-0.102145426,
0.7114956379,
-0.1487353742,
0.2395231277,
0.9127101302,
0.0338334478,
0.4692874253,
0.2597614229,
-0.1859562844,
0.2373473793,
0.6033370495,
-0.0328473859,
0.2548393607,
-0.0183179509,
-0.3058924675,
-0.1271729022,
0.1756376773,
-0.586412251,
0.4961678684,
0.2534953654,
-0.023562951,
-0.4502677321,
0.3991226852,
0.0583853312,
-0.3884474933,
-0.1576000005,
1.0457741022,
0.0313869305,
-0.4657417536,
0.0515671819,
-0.1634955257,
0.2250718921,
-0.6100872755,
-0.1813208759,
-0.0789113641,
-0.1551336646,
-0.1690579951,
-1.1381793022,
0.7225455046,
0.1765157431,
0.1670248955,
-0.4469662309,
1.0612059832,
0.043691162,
0.0274464488,
-0.1488077641,
0.4862643182,
0.2998519838,
-0.6474424601,
-0.3172479868,
-0.0455147773,
-0.0867609009,
-0.2600066066,
0.4673688412,
0.7982856631,
-0.2500194907,
0.7624132633,
0.3073732257,
-0.1264269352,
0.0088021001,
-0.2023323029,
1.0236014128,
-0.6815297008,
-0.5870213509,
-1.0804890394,
0.4859667122,
-0.1355729997,
-0.0970533267,
0.9938675761,
0.4087646306,
0.3648726642,
-0.0873221904,
0.7970118523,
-0.6024776697,
0.1821328849,
-0.4309015274,
0.4061179757,
0.1165795699,
0.5430250168,
-0.3774733543,
-0.6965091825,
-0.2838258445,
0.2161898166,
-0.4004048705,
-0.0306868684,
0.5338019133,
1.0138198137,
-0.0392264575,
0.134697035,
0.1998880953,
0.1451601237,
0.470649302,
0.5689217448,
1.0354773998,
-0.2147578895,
1.0104718208,
0.0085748127,
-0.5607132316,
-0.2856922746,
-1.0277138948,
-0.7558137178,
-0.5693733096,
-0.2464978248,
-0.1702937186,
0.1751834154,
0.6080942154,
0.6621906161,
-0.5452283621,
0.3773185909,
-0.1654566228,
0.226250872,
-0.2904069126,
-0.2273487896,
0.2196295559,
-0.6586702466,
-0.0528160669,
0.1835605353,
0.5106139183,
-0.0920769125,
-0.2425447255,
0.3185019195,
0.4640980661,
-0.3106379807,
0.4462065399,
0.3896595538,
-0.1837219,
-0.5988302827,
0.2085691392,
-0.2168730199,
0.0185523164,
1.1041318178,
-0.5672147274,
0.1997483373,
0.5761856437,
0.6137248278,
0.4733805656,
-0.2154228538,
0.6408574581,
-1.0419971943,
-0.1405326426,
0.262491107,
0.0771149024,
0.0019480848,
-0.6543322206,
0.6645085812,
0.078991279,
-0.5860695243,
-0.624545455,
0.1694067717,
-1.1099449396,
-0.0399842039,
1.2889400721,
-0.3373906314,
0.1332043558,
-0.3869340718,
-0.8697817326,
0.0677109733,
-0.2181461006,
0.9807496071,
0.6666709185,
-0.2731630206,
-0.5190070868,
-0.7425695062,
0.4764656425,
0.2937893867,
-0.9356723428,
0.4158676267,
0.2567193806,
0.2096710652,
0.2294272631,
0.9004478455,
-0.0849440321,
0.4712201059,
-0.0008536223,
-0.1179646105,
-0.0472841747,
-0.2386198789,
-0.1778609902,
0.3929159939,
0.3564578891,
-0.2348228693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03710v1
|
Don't Overlook the Grammatical Gender: Bias Evaluation for Hindi-English Machine Translation
| 2023-11-11T09:28:43 | 2023-11-11T09:28:43 |
Pushpdeep Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models, though state-of-the-art for
translation, often reflect social biases, particularly gender bias. Existing
evaluation benchmarks primarily focus on English as the source language of
translation. For source languages other than English, studies often employ
gender-neutral sentences for bias evaluation, whereas real-world sentences
frequently contain gender information in different forms. Therefore, it makes
more sense to evaluate for bias using such source sentences to determine if NMT
models can discern gender from the grammatical gender cues rather than relying
on biased associations. To illustrate this, we create two gender-specific
sentence sets in Hindi to automatically evaluate gender bias in various
Hindi-English (HI-EN) NMT systems. We emphasise the significance of tailoring
bias evaluation test sets to account for grammatical gender markers in the
source language.
|
[
0.0312906839,
-0.5044868588,
0.4401223361,
0.5918616056,
0.0142235886,
0.1064778566,
-0.1191070154,
-0.1894892156,
-0.1505011767,
0.0683186278,
-0.8121327162,
-0.0340432972,
-0.699519515,
0.4252274036,
-0.3916401565,
0.9554514885,
0.0176845696,
0.6133332253,
-0.1388051212,
0.0532627292,
-0.8745858073,
-0.2743783295,
-0.3858312964,
-0.4575916529,
0.1563804001,
0.2031850815,
0.740585506,
0.6221419573,
0.6335145831,
0.2661187351,
-0.2641894817,
0.1648972183,
-0.187878117,
0.0812341347,
-0.4262971878,
-0.2671300173,
-0.3071171939,
0.1169070676,
0.6182961464,
0.7772979736,
0.0776188448,
0.3132279813,
0.0563790426,
0.9169237018,
-0.7954124212,
0.3228295147,
-0.6515213847,
0.3429165184,
-0.0574209355,
0.0022673442,
-0.302441448,
-0.694242537,
0.2893131375,
-0.2498999238,
0.2012254447,
0.0628500581,
0.9518204927,
0.3131673336,
-0.5594349504,
-0.0865818188,
-0.5735202432,
0.9201906323,
-0.3080351949,
0.4275459647,
0.4732719958,
0.4439072609,
0.0823988691,
0.0797336102,
-0.2746975422,
-0.3506729603,
-0.1972521245,
0.2367985398,
-0.1251343638,
-0.1918666661,
0.2701042593,
0.4520282447,
-0.4668972492,
-0.3359972239,
-0.4442680776,
0.0220317133,
0.3772239983,
-0.1528577507,
0.7962883711,
-0.7020941973,
-0.2463456988,
0.1482702345,
-0.8398860097,
-0.5042705536,
0.6198465824,
0.4212966859,
-0.1105358899,
0.830539465,
-0.0757403448,
0.5933939219,
0.2370951623,
0.2950644791,
0.2737984359,
-0.7830286026,
-0.1982969791,
0.2253478616,
0.8607489467,
0.3572414517,
0.6193993688,
-0.330644846,
0.0340314806,
0.2245188653,
0.4000500441,
-0.2578487396,
0.2992241085,
-0.3687953055,
-0.3511194587,
-0.1967779547,
-0.1435523182,
-0.9661644697,
-0.3823958933,
-0.2408564836,
0.3900511563,
-0.2903368175,
-0.3543940187,
-0.1361903697,
-0.3870302141,
0.2769413888,
0.0206321701,
-0.9064820409,
0.2780871987,
0.6542111635,
0.6729771495,
0.0679839775,
-0.4439675212,
-0.4103570282,
0.0367674381,
-0.45307073,
0.5552952886,
-0.8134718537,
-0.3108274639,
-0.0471269526,
-0.1591328681,
-0.3407382965,
-0.4013092518,
0.5970078707,
-0.059190914,
0.461777389,
-0.7576757669,
-0.1603826284,
0.0015732936,
0.0560211055,
-0.3902722597,
1.0697519779,
0.1771110147,
-0.8584198952,
0.6878965497,
-0.8249693513,
-0.6289060116,
-0.1843152791,
-0.3190873563,
-0.2408111542,
0.032121785,
0.5211311579,
0.2351692915,
-0.5927078128,
0.5754010081,
0.0907920375,
-0.3320401311,
-0.0120771425,
-0.3939440846,
0.7693334818,
0.1576815993,
-0.683588028,
-0.0023720565,
-0.5756656528,
-0.1112332195,
-0.004717146,
-0.1895107329,
-0.3961303234,
-0.0444142409,
0.1645099372,
0.2696071565,
-0.0294278692,
-0.5784314275,
-0.1220486909,
-0.4277029335,
0.5356573462,
0.8599886298,
-0.3586557209,
0.9391890764,
-0.0775041804,
0.6851495504,
-0.2022420466,
-0.0283540934,
0.0270302258,
-0.4504280686,
-0.7453663945,
0.0709389299,
0.3950321674,
0.7790874839,
-0.7975965738,
0.3480883241,
-0.4481803775,
-0.3300789893,
-0.7958436012,
0.2538754046,
0.8421043158,
0.4069329202,
0.1429471672,
0.0429960899,
-0.9088660479,
-1.3877152205,
-0.9284443855,
-0.1357367635,
0.1455617249,
0.1265393794,
0.5744432807,
0.0375664979,
0.9452242255,
-0.2647562921,
-0.2360202819,
-0.4934262335,
-0.0301113483,
-0.1142219603,
0.552129209,
0.4570322633,
-0.7362514138,
-0.3989313245,
0.1980913877,
-1.0335513353,
-0.5927155614,
-0.0598959699,
-0.5849839449,
0.0245606788,
0.3281548619,
-0.7410481572,
0.5242301822,
0.4060355127,
-0.6285964251,
0.1744136959,
0.2112028152,
0.3969639242,
-1.192838192,
-0.1093451157,
0.146551609,
-0.4556446671,
-0.2873235345,
0.1777576655,
0.2715407908,
0.0637356341,
-0.4104159772,
0.4927588403,
-0.7181982398,
-0.4130006731,
0.0651200861,
-0.0044381707,
0.066857785,
0.1037259623,
-0.2182021141,
1.0773779154,
0.2011241019,
-0.3803559244,
-0.3230739832,
0.2115633935,
-0.037432164,
0.7625312805,
-0.5803947449,
0.0996252745,
-0.273434937,
-0.1382109076,
-0.7221580148,
-0.0841315687,
0.4717451334,
-0.6161484122,
0.2975218296,
-0.2463803142,
-0.5173897147,
-0.1326092035,
-0.3315306008,
0.1066985279,
0.4431183338,
-0.2483703047,
0.4437668025,
0.3996212482,
0.1107349321,
-0.9486043453,
-1.0614465475,
0.0992566496,
-0.0099719912,
-0.3107332587,
-0.1237830073,
0.0898258314,
-0.3416018486,
-0.0043641385,
-0.2137019336,
-0.1062913686,
0.0740299523,
0.3619490564,
0.2085942179,
-0.2592558265,
0.0216584615,
0.2201077938,
0.0605478399,
-0.0741573051,
-0.2539240718,
0.6515337825,
-0.2168212533,
-0.3311348855,
-0.2471015304,
0.4385632575,
0.4787608683,
0.039302066,
0.5831581354,
0.6870383024,
-0.5473469496,
0.1726719588,
-0.6167950034,
-0.0952070579,
-0.3983230293,
0.5504523516,
-0.4178788364,
-0.5266389251,
0.1869167984,
0.5609093904,
-0.1724944562,
0.8081145883,
0.5540665984,
0.2231346965,
0.9349328279,
0.5110832453,
-0.1971657872,
0.3786897361,
0.2636631131,
0.371325165,
-0.944637537,
0.0507887304,
-0.711505115,
-0.1958576888,
-0.6979774833,
-0.1873265654,
0.0361920185,
-0.1843679845,
-0.319725275,
0.521345377,
-0.5407339334,
0.7895783782,
0.4328122735,
0.0663198456,
0.2621664405,
0.0580822192,
-0.1070066839,
-0.6029865146,
-0.5449686646,
-0.5920146704,
1.1182039976,
0.2581481934,
0.3692252934,
0.1829699576,
0.3278596997,
0.5316308141,
0.2696122527,
-0.427881211,
0.5049538016,
-0.4447193146,
-0.9414661527,
0.0469743386,
-0.5162110329,
-0.8199288249,
0.3989705741,
-0.0278545674,
-0.4449238777,
0.1487408429,
-0.1817408204,
0.0562857464,
0.1160961315,
-1.058601737,
0.6792243719,
-0.0118586235,
-0.2022708356,
0.1194881871,
-0.3016456962,
0.5818455815,
0.00809184,
0.1532680541,
-0.1926189512,
-0.0465235226,
0.6781228781,
-0.3041706681,
0.7989364862,
0.0066988785,
0.2435282171,
-0.1877243072,
0.1618822515,
-0.091592066,
0.0371053554,
-0.1064090207,
0.2765155733,
-0.3871400058,
-0.4587382674,
-0.3051581085,
0.6562490463,
-0.8485014439,
-0.4857541621,
-0.7641431689,
-0.6122275591,
-0.1324339509,
0.2627534568,
0.2884901464,
-0.1968330294,
-0.1847579926,
-0.0552563183,
0.3271121383,
-0.3135308027,
0.3155387938,
0.3087108135,
-0.2842674553,
-0.1484522969,
0.4886326492,
0.1067174822,
0.4931462705,
0.3499807715,
0.3549210131,
-0.0951554105,
-0.0314171128,
-1.0557979345,
0.1400276572,
-0.8544929028,
-0.0928562358,
-0.9839536548,
-0.3118461072,
-0.6089628339,
-0.0975524187,
-0.4588651955,
-0.4170710146,
0.2612992823,
-0.2546699941,
0.382340163,
0.9806216359,
0.0589754954,
0.4910790026,
-0.5454127789,
0.486040175,
0.2529429197,
0.1425417662,
-0.1417744309,
-0.5413482785,
0.275105834,
-0.0331751481,
-0.2791695893,
-1.0832192898,
0.4133862853,
0.1927009672,
0.6695274115,
-0.1526675373,
-0.7122619748,
0.6545807719,
-0.8534244895,
0.8593956232,
0.0618063658,
-1.3066027164,
0.8458937407,
-0.4975310862,
0.4892447591,
0.6562256217,
0.3062015474,
-0.5287697911,
-0.3862878382,
-0.3718337715,
-0.8594033122,
0.7213044763,
0.6083903313,
0.3484362364,
-0.284537524,
0.4624173641,
0.2412902117,
0.4643020332,
-1.0665991306,
-0.304828018,
0.0367500149,
-0.2700543702,
0.1323207766,
-0.2789684236,
0.2416695952,
-0.2873421609,
0.4569840729,
0.2645438313,
0.3348402679,
0.2348467112,
-0.5316565633,
-0.1146078482,
0.5758190155,
0.450322479,
0.7617691159,
-0.2403127551,
-0.120347172,
0.2253442854,
-0.8251588941,
0.1913731992,
-0.1890636533,
-0.7634264231,
0.4065133929,
0.2016629279,
0.718593359,
0.3738901019,
-0.3102903664,
0.3977119029,
-0.0716013461,
0.0613726638,
-0.3058139682,
-0.2113720924,
0.0784006119,
-0.0623390041,
0.3253607154,
0.5293776393,
0.3767588139,
-0.7052935958,
-0.008016631,
0.2682487667,
-0.6893156171,
-0.0947434008,
0.7590649724,
-0.0015333834,
-0.299564898,
0.3827550411,
-0.1916350871,
-0.9301744699,
0.7565284967,
0.5028656721,
1.3065854311,
-0.4728143811,
0.1371811479,
0.4503668249,
1.068819046,
-0.3311573863,
0.5170007944,
0.314214319,
-0.3491633236,
-0.5474056005,
-0.6036596894,
-0.1030477807,
-0.3285597563,
-0.5967159867,
0.5170742273,
-0.4494810998,
-0.1366676837,
0.0836464912,
-0.4716593027,
-0.8475036621,
0.1073108017,
0.0892713517,
0.5515577197,
-1.1552202702,
0.537450552,
0.616297245,
-0.6389921308,
-0.5427054167,
-0.0164374691,
0.1219295785,
-0.8708521128,
1.1903394461,
0.118896015,
-0.1641473621,
-0.3911144733,
-0.1319573075,
-0.8091416955,
0.6494038701,
0.638137877,
-0.3644518554,
0.0033432806,
0.3420267105,
0.3627612293,
-0.3776420057,
0.6018814445,
0.5569441915,
0.7369543314,
-0.529545486,
-1.3393819332,
0.0592995249,
-0.357576251,
0.2197273821,
0.1538334638,
-0.3631964624,
1.1129090786,
0.1844480187,
-0.0218390934,
-0.3238807321,
0.3326131403,
0.0884651542,
0.2254681438,
0.3924247622,
0.2510349751,
0.4404530525,
-0.3516601026,
1.3986595869,
0.2044965774,
0.0508395806,
1.1677166224,
-0.3406627476,
0.5618599653,
0.4977564812,
-0.3713791072,
0.11564634,
0.4894734025,
0.0560471267,
0.4199799597,
0.2600170672,
0.1628378183,
0.0896705911,
-0.2998205721,
-0.5814421773,
0.4936391711,
0.1379313916,
-0.6154626012,
-0.2519865036,
-0.0510097444,
0.3881075382,
0.4393073916,
-0.3746062219,
0.4907971025,
0.1781416088,
-0.7567200661,
0.3414915204,
0.0308013931,
0.9305002093,
-0.4408605099,
-0.125211373,
-0.3274394274,
0.0627970621,
-0.2806930542,
-0.5504178405,
0.6123661399,
0.303797394,
-0.5268351436,
-0.3603116274,
0.7534477711,
-0.4682750702,
-0.8683980703,
0.370251447,
0.7770513892,
0.1550717652,
-0.1729002744,
-0.6741532683,
-0.1440864503,
0.128948912,
-0.0463256538,
0.2922788858,
0.1146498173,
-0.3834927082,
0.579551518,
0.5502470136,
0.2674849331,
0.4004545212,
0.4128986299,
0.4035587013,
-0.7711055875,
-0.3200326264,
-1.4235459566,
0.1807381809,
-0.3350880146,
-0.26294595,
1.1278163195,
0.5253537297,
0.6778614521,
-0.3323670328,
0.9183119535,
0.0112929167,
0.4396037459,
-0.4594105184,
1.1006110907,
-0.3750606775,
0.1382600665,
-0.6225494742,
-1.2385364771,
-0.2231314331,
0.7496919632,
-0.5351778865,
0.4108551443,
0.938950181,
0.631522119,
-0.1486765593,
0.1526312977,
0.2079792172,
0.062458422,
-0.1092844978,
0.5435500741,
0.9218740463,
-0.8950278759,
0.4084418416,
-0.0419138633,
0.0133236181,
0.0805036873,
-1.163181901,
-0.9744573832,
-0.2570008934,
-0.3719997406,
-0.4599983394,
0.3772064745,
1.1117976904,
0.756210506,
-0.6340075135,
-0.2843649685,
0.049765043,
0.3802376688,
-0.1639017761,
-0.2186013311,
0.3090076447,
-0.4367685616,
-0.9974062443,
0.3697975278,
0.2882018685,
-0.301227659,
-0.3621180654,
0.1167057976,
-0.6035945415,
0.0865688324,
0.4503648579,
-0.2610945404,
-0.7270434499,
-0.1154210642,
0.1107635722,
-0.2878543735,
0.141401723,
0.6806841493,
-0.4538402855,
0.3410289586,
0.6709749699,
0.7059938312,
-0.0464721061,
-0.3754486144,
1.1032421589,
-0.8464009762,
0.2392770648,
-0.0521926358,
0.3446317911,
0.7795926929,
-0.6718258858,
0.8100786805,
0.2663965225,
-0.2706898451,
-0.9535033107,
0.1279898733,
-0.7725698948,
-0.0914505646,
1.3652249575,
0.0516322032,
-0.4368496239,
-0.1084184498,
-0.3799058497,
0.4034273624,
-0.2897805274,
0.6946790814,
1.1527531147,
0.6992355585,
-0.1817094982,
-1.3022276163,
0.3700445592,
0.9165884256,
-0.6031944752,
-0.239829123,
0.2675281167,
0.2370348275,
0.0552653857,
0.5329790711,
-0.3740308583,
0.4502960145,
-0.0569438487,
0.2477875352,
0.2553559244,
0.0360256396,
-0.3968582153,
-0.334708035,
0.0271515008,
-0.3039825261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06518v1
|
Minimum Description Length Hopfield Networks
| 2023-11-11T09:23:54 | 2023-11-11T09:23:54 |
Matan Abudy, Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Roni Katzir
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Associative memory architectures are designed for memorization but also
offer, through their retrieval method, a form of generalization to unseen
inputs: stored memories can be seen as prototypes from this point of view.
Focusing on Modern Hopfield Networks (MHN), we show that a large memorization
capacity undermines the generalization opportunity. We offer a solution to
better optimize this tradeoff. It relies on Minimum Description Length (MDL) to
determine during training which memories to store, as well as how many of them.
|
[
-0.5098121166,
-0.5292019248,
0.4738568366,
-0.3096786141,
-0.1370811164,
-0.1246114671,
0.1272903234,
-0.3120698333,
0.3307385445,
0.2655938566,
-0.527020216,
-0.0482997261,
-0.4373308718,
-0.0370133519,
-0.4200273156,
1.1282938719,
-0.190594539,
-0.450054884,
-0.2642047107,
-0.6515641809,
-0.1061348394,
-0.6084601283,
-1.1079366207,
-0.3139687181,
0.688734293,
0.023383433,
0.8750075698,
1.162864089,
0.6136317253,
0.2639121115,
-0.5295097828,
0.5838580132,
-0.4335214794,
0.0460530333,
0.2093379796,
-0.4367247224,
-0.4117876887,
-0.0043496508,
0.9075860977,
1.1485797167,
-0.13106291,
0.1636222899,
-0.281894654,
0.9276404977,
-1.0698422194,
-0.1040678322,
-0.4361813068,
0.7784116268,
0.1758543402,
-0.5107893348,
-0.5233443379,
-0.0256110486,
0.2954319417,
-0.5492725968,
0.1624743342,
0.2630102336,
0.4139679074,
-0.0296628196,
-0.353358835,
-0.2371363193,
-0.8438061476,
0.7601292729,
-0.3523929417,
0.3575558364,
0.5809184313,
0.4411919713,
0.0677089617,
-0.38971138,
-0.2731730044,
-0.0780791193,
-0.4425640702,
0.1714408696,
-0.1291419417,
0.5217328072,
0.5657580495,
0.5517875552,
-0.7092307806,
-0.3377484381,
-0.9242723584,
-0.1593147963,
0.613995254,
0.8363564014,
-0.1998543292,
0.2690671384,
-0.3027993441,
0.2083334476,
-0.5734795928,
-0.0020945719,
0.1176672727,
0.1164785177,
0.110892199,
0.4003582299,
-0.292123884,
0.7548679709,
0.0060350108,
-0.1971300095,
0.204902485,
-0.1345492899,
-0.5293765664,
-0.1191846505,
0.7559098005,
0.0096347202,
0.0506280549,
-0.389318347,
-0.2468635291,
-0.1611094773,
0.2655903101,
-0.5859025121,
-0.2742768824,
0.0085882926,
-1.1708173752,
-0.5533633232,
0.0043396261,
-0.518668592,
-0.2539970875,
-0.0159870666,
0.6040518284,
-0.4919188023,
0.2113792598,
0.007833669,
-0.350361526,
0.0356811695,
0.0909567848,
-1.2239090204,
0.6887940168,
0.2693009973,
1.1804515123,
-0.0038220205,
-0.6095976233,
-0.2922466099,
0.4320105314,
-0.6577883959,
0.1418943256,
-0.1359268576,
-0.5918564796,
0.0280576535,
-0.3159728944,
-0.0585478209,
-0.7623570561,
-0.0823570862,
-0.7473345399,
0.0676516667,
0.0935490653,
-0.5334578156,
-0.2431310266,
0.2911427915,
-0.8574079275,
0.4518595636,
0.0952503756,
-0.7538389564,
0.1662476212,
-0.5643389225,
-0.6722282767,
-0.2370756716,
-0.396773845,
-0.3786013424,
0.4282344282,
-0.2561532259,
0.3026303351,
0.0081260409,
0.003666207,
-0.1103564575,
-0.743314147,
0.2938245535,
-0.5230970979,
0.9089813232,
0.4686414301,
0.0316859968,
-0.0301426221,
-1.0343827009,
-0.1191233546,
0.1755471379,
-1.0954432487,
-0.3361423612,
-0.0502979867,
-0.4751862884,
0.2926282287,
0.0106418617,
-0.3445397019,
0.1961714476,
-0.4911935031,
0.5536333323,
0.9192937016,
-0.0119092297,
0.4573677778,
-0.7262577415,
0.3840939403,
0.5335245728,
0.2742701769,
-0.534268856,
-0.1628934294,
-0.9863821864,
0.2159269303,
-0.1915435493,
0.2238327563,
-0.503226161,
0.1027373001,
-0.21882236,
-0.0138386814,
-0.369299531,
0.1680140942,
0.4697875381,
0.5549856424,
0.4527356029,
-0.199555546,
-0.7395755053,
-1.3706912994,
0.0371113867,
-0.3364131451,
-0.03176843,
0.3538677096,
0.3499146998,
-0.3419708014,
0.7958231568,
-0.2293957025,
-0.2693173587,
-0.0486354083,
0.0309289489,
0.3524645567,
0.1948999614,
0.2792944908,
-0.7528300881,
-0.0918169692,
-0.0560025014,
-0.7196031809,
0.5423352122,
-0.4437773228,
0.1484442353,
0.2188900709,
0.3133072257,
-1.1922073364,
0.6548069715,
0.3760673702,
-0.1371428967,
0.5892912149,
-0.4529875815,
-0.0900622085,
-0.8133302927,
0.1362120807,
-0.5561390519,
0.0423846394,
-0.416211009,
-0.0231151413,
0.0582826808,
-0.0593179762,
-0.2648932636,
0.54899472,
-0.830506146,
-0.0879517123,
-0.1448881328,
-0.1309547424,
0.2194415182,
0.4478223026,
0.0176814627,
1.025685668,
0.4742490351,
-0.9895479679,
0.3704208136,
0.5260059834,
0.0539820977,
0.337221086,
-0.3228613138,
0.0363620184,
-0.3629789948,
0.1539274454,
-0.6641090512,
0.0196544826,
0.0107282586,
-0.4816428721,
0.4055432975,
-0.1612736136,
-0.2748070955,
-0.6309709549,
-0.3874982595,
0.5946830511,
0.574972868,
-0.6180067062,
0.6238570213,
0.041407723,
0.6883705854,
-0.7032805681,
-1.0308463573,
-0.2149704695,
-0.4028684199,
-0.4276875556,
0.0650914311,
-0.2274704278,
-0.2299712002,
-0.1240910515,
-0.1741557717,
-0.1114283353,
-0.0163442716,
0.4166235924,
0.215487659,
-0.4885814786,
0.7996606827,
-0.2358889133,
-0.0751526058,
0.2637653053,
-0.2604839802,
0.5671821833,
-0.1784069538,
0.0357594974,
-0.1477413476,
0.7060607076,
0.4210535586,
-0.225442037,
1.0731515884,
0.2012792379,
-0.4377391636,
-0.2158871144,
-0.1256047338,
0.0303160492,
-0.5082840919,
0.3858462572,
-0.5564138889,
-0.8662747145,
0.6281353831,
0.0300798863,
-0.2098326236,
0.4716414511,
0.4668116271,
-0.3552087247,
0.7723211646,
0.341681987,
-0.2541524172,
0.1412535906,
-0.5305343866,
0.2275005877,
-1.2475101948,
-0.2169434875,
0.1075821072,
-0.6155346632,
-0.1534240544,
-0.2000052184,
0.0881723762,
-0.0556401759,
-0.4261170626,
0.1868751049,
-0.2428006828,
0.5647054315,
0.7074127197,
0.0282191951,
0.2034818083,
-0.0475467592,
-0.3043801785,
0.1387530714,
-0.7755354643,
-0.3473886251,
1.3212143183,
0.4944025874,
0.9603383541,
0.0910061896,
1.0388929844,
0.179399088,
-0.2422340512,
-1.1437960863,
0.5792793632,
-0.1395020932,
-0.9428614974,
-0.1358258724,
-0.7953644991,
-1.0576902628,
0.1437301785,
-0.2655035257,
-0.800863564,
0.1634280086,
0.4655453265,
-0.6885736585,
0.6886778474,
-0.3081353009,
0.442035675,
-0.2770195007,
-0.289562881,
-0.0181848314,
-0.8449377418,
0.3928355873,
0.2874045968,
0.0523013473,
0.5220124125,
-0.0739620626,
1.1152681112,
-0.4741438329,
0.3496127129,
-0.0164347421,
0.5562410355,
0.4430947304,
0.3394274414,
0.2601136565,
-0.2606269121,
0.2734308541,
-0.4134838581,
-0.0052141207,
-0.3817255199,
-0.4769976437,
0.3285405338,
-0.8600229025,
-0.2274724394,
-0.152442053,
-0.7398359776,
-0.4641665518,
0.2657156885,
0.5248067975,
0.4780606329,
-0.2784072161,
0.2714843154,
0.9840942621,
0.0018722304,
0.5841801167,
-0.0268086288,
-0.112468183,
-0.2366319448,
0.6679948568,
0.170674786,
0.3114518523,
0.556658864,
0.1996820271,
0.1413955092,
-0.8467201591,
-0.119214654,
0.1101732776,
-0.9871658087,
-0.4170566499,
-0.8524793983,
-0.5399560928,
-0.1576805562,
-0.1520523429,
-0.4778063893,
-0.6485686302,
-0.2854704857,
-0.3606025875,
0.0540933684,
0.7121501565,
-0.1740083843,
0.8374097943,
-0.7765405178,
0.3481400311,
0.5538091063,
0.5565316081,
0.4499429166,
-0.5400030017,
-0.6355146766,
-0.0153457876,
-0.3511455655,
-0.7671768069,
0.1145535037,
0.4893597066,
0.5288172364,
0.9102777839,
-0.3337612748,
0.7244071364,
-0.630936563,
0.1933826357,
0.473613292,
-0.546464026,
0.622997582,
-0.2443227023,
0.1720116884,
0.6915400624,
0.3592070341,
-0.6615847349,
0.2799082398,
-0.857105732,
-0.7107335925,
0.4113117456,
-0.1788104922,
0.3651325405,
-0.2617641091,
0.3820771575,
-0.1434214264,
0.2606247663,
-0.4544778466,
-0.6287721395,
0.0776413083,
-0.0978331938,
-0.0913446099,
-0.6112274528,
-0.5405994654,
-0.1615591496,
0.323613435,
0.1171236336,
0.8393583894,
0.0418177098,
-0.0515074097,
-0.1948720366,
0.0697070211,
0.4959197342,
0.7545410395,
-0.5377303958,
0.5057020783,
0.1010465249,
-0.507979691,
0.5090728402,
-0.4242232442,
-0.2412833422,
0.1622062027,
0.6592902541,
0.9177497029,
-0.0725927055,
-0.4579570889,
0.4397816956,
0.1144656464,
-0.6393387318,
-0.3036783636,
0.2626370788,
0.1633805484,
0.1909609884,
0.254922837,
0.302328527,
0.6265705824,
-0.6975960732,
0.5023707747,
0.529974997,
-0.4874976277,
-0.0983096063,
0.4529823065,
-0.418171972,
-0.3090545833,
0.9463577271,
0.1281936616,
-0.3460017145,
0.5959768295,
0.7782838345,
0.7940556407,
-0.1095244661,
0.0366988704,
0.4294822812,
0.3889247179,
0.1658920646,
-0.1731392741,
-0.1413902938,
-0.6649167538,
0.2810612917,
-0.4479442537,
-0.0797863975,
0.1742887646,
-0.7901518345,
-0.1440552473,
-1.0986235142,
-0.1183351725,
-0.0127017032,
0.0514750332,
-0.7340384126,
0.4464794099,
0.1397479624,
1.1971430779,
-0.8140001893,
0.7569509149,
0.5120677352,
-0.4786073864,
-0.8948698044,
-0.4237091243,
0.0830032974,
-0.9972802997,
0.8542851806,
0.1655038446,
-0.196578458,
-0.3793217242,
-0.3851741254,
-0.5702388287,
1.4159709215,
-0.2990537882,
-0.1966974735,
-0.3285828829,
-0.221717909,
0.4408907592,
-0.729924202,
0.2455344796,
0.5506210327,
0.1213878393,
0.271515131,
-0.5064938068,
-0.0925123096,
-0.406693548,
0.1957849264,
0.2493624836,
-0.7354954481,
1.35529387,
-0.3829188049,
-0.2355815917,
0.1222767234,
0.198074922,
0.271984309,
0.2808105946,
0.0650589913,
0.701651454,
0.5707947016,
0.376429528,
1.1224837303,
0.4464805126,
0.2459186316,
1.2810087204,
0.360131979,
0.8069140911,
0.7925038934,
-0.5252116323,
0.0323027112,
0.5285707712,
0.1555954218,
0.6771227121,
0.3631975949,
-0.1494271606,
0.0346458443,
0.2648923695,
-0.3830703497,
0.4792689085,
0.3186792731,
-1.0716233253,
0.0405316092,
-0.2519506812,
-0.2288009524,
-0.2404136658,
-0.5121842027,
0.9418341517,
0.1031410769,
0.0599749275,
0.6488733888,
-0.2056571245,
0.5139109492,
-0.479039073,
0.0240415763,
-0.6033047438,
0.3480951488,
-0.2024463117,
-0.3527572155,
0.5460833311,
-0.779043138,
-0.4270956516,
0.2665900588,
0.6297804713,
-0.2654490173,
-0.1762683094,
0.4263158143,
0.4058414996,
0.0520259067,
0.2739334106,
-0.4090221226,
-0.2006166428,
-0.3594730496,
-0.2749899626,
0.4143311977,
0.4136501849,
0.1737451106,
0.9487447143,
0.2224951833,
0.3719166815,
0.6056622267,
-0.5351687074,
0.9393042922,
-0.8147108555,
-0.6344438791,
-0.9854291677,
0.2004540712,
-0.0048623662,
-0.2698510289,
0.4325481355,
0.8205307722,
0.8162545562,
-0.4882023633,
0.7770634294,
0.1799073517,
0.49873209,
-0.6225869656,
0.7353057861,
-0.5031141639,
-0.0281570628,
0.1281728595,
-0.8955010176,
-0.4051247239,
1.0498812199,
0.037017677,
0.1753257811,
0.8025785685,
0.3783448935,
-0.4615336359,
-0.0884920508,
0.7297686934,
0.0759039745,
-0.0062092743,
1.2912228107,
1.0453748703,
-0.6387437582,
0.6558523774,
-0.3286927342,
-0.0356887691,
-0.2382284701,
-0.3740329742,
-1.1620912552,
-0.4150971174,
0.030296145,
-0.2094546556,
0.1012872458,
0.6487815976,
0.9646865129,
-0.7422272563,
-0.5227392316,
0.0337736346,
-0.0552079789,
-0.0804412141,
-0.1299662441,
0.3921428323,
-0.3450973332,
0.1653203219,
0.138978377,
0.5539291501,
0.3468190432,
-0.2230746597,
-0.5235554576,
-0.3406896293,
-0.0467523858,
0.6458218098,
0.4124026597,
-0.6032230854,
-0.2738770843,
-0.1252147257,
-0.049824819,
0.3519009054,
1.0150399208,
-0.8031250834,
0.632948637,
0.2500006258,
0.8892716169,
0.4026815891,
-0.1884260178,
0.3860731721,
-0.6468049884,
0.3745498359,
0.3673163652,
0.4776799083,
-0.0697237626,
-0.2233265042,
0.5224261284,
0.1473577321,
-0.4671996236,
-0.3000100255,
0.4234962165,
-0.670085609,
-0.0889953598,
0.7165810466,
-0.3221150041,
-0.1821151078,
0.1047099233,
-0.0544406399,
-0.0442159362,
0.0690836608,
0.7903681397,
0.7142390609,
-0.384206146,
-0.6082839966,
-0.5042670369,
0.7025816441,
0.1593270898,
-0.3953018188,
0.0042898473,
0.5087088943,
-0.1816648543,
0.4176803529,
1.1166123152,
0.0507436842,
0.3346301019,
0.4372748435,
-0.6428453922,
-0.3752371669,
-0.6822547317,
-0.4610332847,
-0.047798384,
0.3399261236,
-0.6738367677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06513v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06513v2
|
Step by Step to Fairness: Attributing Societal Bias in Task-oriented Dialogue Systems
| 2023-11-11T09:06:15 | 2023-11-14T07:30:37 |
Hsuan Su, Rebecca Qian, Chinnadhurai Sankar, Shahin Shayandeh, Shang-Tse Chen, Hung-yi Lee, Daniel M. Bikel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent works have shown considerable improvements in task-oriented dialogue
(TOD) systems by utilizing pretrained large language models (LLMs) in an
end-to-end manner. However, the biased behavior of each component in a TOD
system and the error propagation issue in the end-to-end framework can lead to
seriously biased TOD responses. Existing works of fairness only focus on the
total bias of a system. In this paper, we propose a diagnosis method to
attribute bias to each component of a TOD system. With the proposed attribution
method, we can gain a deeper understanding of the sources of bias.
Additionally, researchers can mitigate biased model behavior at a more granular
level. We conduct experiments to attribute the TOD system's bias toward three
demographic axes: gender, age, and race. Experimental results show that the
bias of a TOD system usually comes from the response generation model.
|
[
-0.3126625419,
-0.5187590122,
0.778414011,
0.2588538527,
0.0146171916,
-0.00569034,
0.1339604259,
-0.2680691183,
-0.0540103763,
0.7390913963,
-0.8259254098,
-0.1371067166,
-0.7510899305,
-0.0925544053,
-0.1647674292,
1.1303839684,
0.1885259002,
0.4320803285,
-0.380561322,
0.0082841273,
-0.6146050096,
-0.4539345503,
-0.9948569536,
-0.6892416477,
0.4275138676,
0.4402615726,
0.4139283299,
0.4072231054,
0.1114330739,
0.3431878984,
-0.1625863016,
-0.3505628705,
-0.3597784042,
0.1936893761,
-0.2650315464,
-0.6755598187,
-0.772344172,
-0.0071324152,
0.2684431672,
0.6676003933,
-0.0013516844,
0.4032943845,
0.2078500688,
0.4178226292,
-0.6020854712,
0.0257674381,
-0.4625769854,
0.1710199416,
-0.4330191612,
-0.3463033438,
-0.456199199,
-0.5874179602,
0.001252223,
-0.4447092712,
0.4653269351,
0.0602078512,
0.140467301,
0.3424351215,
-0.7805727124,
-0.2506499887,
-0.4989349246,
1.0659681559,
-0.6775163412,
-0.0616738424,
0.3350746632,
0.2246602029,
-0.225567624,
-0.0478260033,
-0.4645191431,
0.0641093329,
0.1074321419,
-0.0786255449,
0.09131556,
0.0547160059,
0.2861845791,
-0.0557550266,
-0.3158662021,
0.0742868781,
-0.1753724515,
-0.4152729213,
0.3865090013,
0.2937605381,
0.2659786046,
-0.5286596417,
-0.1982732415,
0.1049741134,
-0.5620272756,
-0.0377680138,
0.6391349435,
0.4172388315,
-0.1020332724,
0.3891018033,
-0.170078814,
0.5451469421,
0.3355215192,
-0.3344074488,
0.2229693234,
-0.3489928842,
-0.0935649797,
0.3322668076,
0.5174315572,
0.5287846923,
0.3538530171,
-0.0136112012,
-0.358887732,
0.2050332576,
0.3108020723,
-0.4462788105,
0.3131884336,
0.0653653294,
-0.7104048729,
-0.4600647986,
-0.6535078287,
-0.7552409768,
-0.6670435071,
-0.4204059541,
0.3974907696,
0.1548553556,
-0.2942875326,
-0.2204673886,
-0.1284688562,
-0.1525410563,
0.3958474398,
-0.5371413231,
0.327940315,
0.4224146605,
0.6469160914,
-0.176896438,
0.1016880646,
-0.6379147172,
0.3069755137,
-0.0405219272,
0.6759334803,
-0.4479586184,
-0.428989023,
-0.1063273102,
-0.1946749389,
0.2791041136,
-0.5908810496,
0.7974179387,
-0.2332190275,
0.4186312854,
-0.537831068,
-0.0168565176,
0.2442464083,
0.2515473366,
-0.1740657538,
0.6482158303,
0.1255524307,
-1.0325015783,
0.6833665371,
-1.0281298161,
-0.3046635985,
-0.3029634058,
-0.1967841387,
-0.1902211159,
0.1584857553,
0.3089135289,
0.2092516571,
-0.3722342253,
0.8790744543,
-0.3805252016,
-0.1761514992,
-0.0392825305,
-0.691681385,
1.1652685404,
0.378180325,
-0.6560359001,
0.1848443598,
-0.3440856934,
-0.1391820312,
-0.0603914969,
0.0144204665,
-0.5452447534,
0.087789543,
-0.176143378,
0.3195061088,
0.2039193362,
-0.9269943833,
-0.1610629708,
-0.1741999686,
0.1494687349,
1.414983511,
-0.4164640605,
0.5375290513,
-0.38350299,
0.5464911461,
0.4306747615,
0.4351654053,
0.2213331908,
-0.4973637164,
-0.792670846,
-0.0732101724,
-0.0561119393,
0.4233344197,
-0.8782013059,
0.1907745898,
-0.3307488263,
0.1293178052,
-0.2306950688,
-0.2737290561,
0.6396172643,
0.8001238108,
-0.0031970153,
-0.7059289813,
-0.3066751659,
-1.0354918242,
-0.4398458302,
-0.2792487442,
-0.3045439422,
0.5910990834,
0.2377730757,
0.0464419834,
1.0966022015,
-0.271851331,
-0.3387183845,
0.1088932827,
0.1684003174,
0.0388369597,
0.4917011559,
0.306248337,
-0.3952389956,
-0.1389391273,
-0.3092778921,
-0.5803776979,
-0.7344270945,
0.4055026174,
-0.2657053173,
0.1633786261,
0.4060766101,
-0.1253665388,
0.5652016401,
0.3585080504,
-0.7660912871,
0.5117970705,
0.143250227,
0.383200258,
-0.9001227021,
-0.0720987618,
0.1770740002,
-0.4349744916,
-0.3628546894,
-0.261421293,
-0.416092664,
0.0322431326,
-0.296843648,
0.6854115725,
-0.0963780805,
-0.4142498672,
-0.2088486403,
0.1338888109,
-0.2395171374,
0.5482404232,
-0.2517673373,
0.6227329373,
0.3364405036,
-0.6990115047,
0.1386882216,
0.130323261,
-0.1092583835,
1.2110273838,
-0.4970591664,
0.0620761178,
-0.410836935,
0.6466313601,
-0.9255270958,
-0.076310344,
0.5129584074,
-0.5528718829,
-0.2242039591,
-0.2573437393,
-0.2097819448,
-0.2664733231,
-0.0451041609,
0.9881073236,
0.3079088926,
-0.3245505691,
0.528609097,
0.4864907265,
-0.6984342337,
-0.6338567138,
-0.3950928748,
-0.1120821461,
-0.5353832841,
-0.5764610171,
0.2787302732,
0.1107286289,
-0.5268884897,
-0.2926924527,
-0.1767107844,
-0.1835369915,
0.0676483437,
0.3300260603,
-0.0580204055,
0.1743144393,
0.0942664668,
0.1248650029,
-0.3177783191,
0.3347332776,
-0.1774761975,
0.6614186764,
0.4454625547,
-0.6348207593,
-0.3304149806,
0.508107543,
0.596549511,
0.0587317161,
0.2131541967,
0.4386027753,
-0.2179666013,
0.0524266288,
-0.5864859223,
-0.3340093493,
-0.467743665,
0.1922805309,
-0.0652786493,
-0.6972587109,
0.6360881925,
0.0815656409,
0.162206322,
0.2580330968,
0.5882779956,
0.2908272743,
1.433457613,
0.6575972438,
-0.1677336991,
0.478138417,
0.3520460725,
0.3405938745,
-0.867985189,
-0.3908982873,
-1.0694159269,
-0.3923800886,
-0.3658674955,
-0.4962489903,
0.5858340263,
-0.2642386258,
-0.7074263096,
-0.2767595053,
-0.4817025959,
0.1899966896,
0.7031354904,
0.3531500697,
0.5576763153,
-0.0475903898,
-0.1120340973,
-0.1739741415,
-0.5505674481,
-0.6940937638,
1.2952507734,
0.4160506725,
0.6280867457,
0.287964046,
0.6453846693,
0.7080600262,
0.6461756825,
-0.5853466392,
0.4844708145,
-0.1392355263,
-0.8706854582,
-0.3020538092,
-0.5573223829,
-0.5709552169,
0.0352107175,
0.3591290414,
-0.9897465706,
0.4223124087,
0.3225297928,
-0.1844383776,
0.1307813376,
-0.5836558938,
0.6000939012,
-0.0872371644,
-0.2946332395,
-0.3013207912,
-0.4854271114,
0.6193991303,
-0.0853048712,
0.615993917,
-0.3132055402,
0.3057613969,
1.0794740915,
-0.518631041,
1.000369072,
-0.8306953907,
-0.4615460932,
-0.1412792355,
0.005033066,
0.4252128899,
0.0721523166,
-0.1743509918,
-0.1175167114,
-0.1688525081,
-0.5847725272,
-0.4293673933,
0.5482763052,
-0.7206715345,
-0.6254339814,
-0.3064857721,
-0.5608002543,
-0.4428793788,
-0.0073174657,
0.0950275734,
0.6417427659,
0.122821182,
-0.2412109375,
0.6845949888,
-0.2743620276,
0.3769476712,
0.4819272459,
-0.2635732889,
0.1334199458,
0.5521920323,
-0.2602888644,
0.3644342422,
-0.2918513715,
-0.0375679657,
-0.1752780527,
-0.3791766465,
-0.393881619,
-0.060323786,
-0.5442618132,
-0.2455681413,
-0.6009402275,
0.2199486643,
-0.4079707563,
-0.0813840032,
-0.332375139,
-0.2036003172,
0.0008834081,
0.211826995,
0.1424614042,
0.7883564234,
-0.011135566,
0.5953301787,
-0.2316177189,
0.5085248947,
0.3046582043,
0.5560970902,
0.3573940396,
-0.7267326713,
0.0014845338,
0.4722422957,
-0.6193252802,
-0.5857422352,
0.1771611124,
-0.1462544054,
0.6925806999,
0.4008698761,
0.2650648952,
0.6453082561,
-0.3669616282,
0.8836117387,
0.4712951481,
-1.1778360605,
0.6492081881,
-0.3836278915,
0.1563074291,
0.1853500903,
0.0992170572,
-0.493522495,
-0.7687195539,
-0.4777296185,
-0.6426231265,
1.0533802509,
-0.0963183641,
0.0516743809,
-0.0954868793,
0.1266358048,
0.1679613888,
0.1396872252,
-0.9063048959,
-0.2708882689,
-0.2105989456,
-0.3425572217,
-0.1635883451,
-0.1189473718,
-0.5139257908,
-0.046756316,
0.481110543,
-0.4005491436,
0.5337705612,
0.2936632335,
-0.1945035309,
-0.3556985557,
0.5419229269,
0.4967837632,
0.7987002134,
0.1182076409,
-0.0464752726,
-0.0817632824,
-0.2337041795,
0.4570112228,
-0.1989191175,
-0.1684388071,
-0.0985170975,
0.0928466171,
0.7912314534,
-0.0956383124,
-0.5384488702,
0.7423772216,
-0.0358329453,
-0.1253030747,
-0.0168062653,
0.0167696532,
-0.2996714711,
0.4111320972,
0.596237123,
0.2099938691,
0.441709727,
-0.7520236373,
-0.0243552215,
0.6889582872,
-0.6641127467,
-0.0517614856,
0.6174898148,
0.6100100279,
-0.3848861456,
0.3793697953,
-0.062410824,
-0.6290532351,
0.7004736066,
0.4614589512,
0.8516013622,
-0.1156406328,
0.4518513978,
-0.018346224,
0.0474390052,
-0.0376654044,
0.0492113121,
-0.1053436846,
-0.8041700721,
-0.6731845737,
-0.6240320802,
-0.1140887141,
-0.177180022,
-0.8244442344,
-0.0794394687,
-0.0755314231,
-0.5522767305,
-0.2007729411,
-0.18685776,
-0.7212984562,
0.2854370475,
0.0463909954,
0.4917124212,
-1.1054284573,
0.4183615446,
0.3928923309,
0.1735915691,
-0.458799094,
0.1669968218,
0.2618898153,
-0.9500454664,
1.1627696753,
-0.1221959591,
-0.131703943,
-0.2144655138,
-0.4879461527,
-0.592079401,
0.7662063241,
0.4723850787,
-0.3043670952,
-0.0298558511,
-0.0625214353,
0.231499508,
-0.4938123822,
0.593501389,
0.5163894296,
0.5286399126,
-0.16835697,
-1.592697978,
0.1231226623,
-0.0429260097,
0.1092941165,
0.1598084122,
-0.2646368146,
0.7653247118,
-0.0744748339,
0.095520772,
-0.1710315198,
0.2203822881,
0.4625478089,
0.6183726192,
0.8303767443,
0.3829205334,
0.5415458679,
-0.3177943528,
0.7524561882,
0.1230629086,
0.0116370544,
0.9271441698,
-0.2708445191,
0.0219614394,
0.7182357311,
-0.2908098996,
0.3016224205,
0.4450854361,
0.7000615597,
0.4648016691,
0.4976836145,
-0.4435176551,
-0.0908657461,
-0.7054460049,
-0.4035976529,
0.4319804609,
0.3274260461,
-0.3708484769,
-0.25911057,
0.282627821,
0.1310852617,
-0.0223429743,
-0.6177428961,
0.8392618895,
-0.0884070918,
-0.7374477386,
0.1707940698,
0.0296871737,
1.1447134018,
-0.3464184999,
0.1526631713,
-0.4456692338,
-0.0121036256,
-0.2202930748,
-0.5857746005,
0.2255022079,
0.1919451356,
-0.586085856,
-0.5189210773,
0.560147047,
-0.1571116,
-0.3028244972,
0.1380562782,
0.5546451211,
0.1258345246,
0.0054109441,
-0.5141271949,
0.0859224275,
0.3846137822,
-0.0039471867,
0.3303405643,
0.4987281263,
-0.4886628389,
0.9566196203,
0.2017864734,
0.0543616004,
0.0561313443,
0.2638860941,
0.6528340578,
-0.4840943515,
-0.4721345603,
-0.508857131,
0.6372219324,
-0.2869627178,
-0.1004496515,
0.4088875055,
0.1096993536,
0.6482945681,
0.199481383,
1.0138013363,
-0.2326718867,
0.6909588575,
-0.2365054786,
0.4303125143,
-0.5258457065,
0.293754071,
-0.7042812705,
-1.0113736391,
0.062430948,
0.4553057253,
-0.3185987473,
0.4935067296,
0.434299767,
0.7708135247,
-0.0088759959,
0.0209251773,
-0.0563282855,
0.2065600306,
0.4510366619,
0.4323235452,
0.7444788218,
-0.0452422164,
0.5149790645,
0.2359690517,
-0.642981708,
-0.1908896565,
-0.8618162274,
-0.4380587041,
-0.2625498474,
-0.1245401129,
-0.2627760172,
0.4083785713,
0.5177910924,
0.6629520059,
-0.567697823,
-0.3172264993,
-0.1264247447,
0.3401522636,
0.1569202989,
-0.2776712775,
-0.1323370934,
-0.3003540933,
-0.8377988338,
-0.1958868355,
0.0103986384,
-0.2583546638,
-0.4524405897,
-0.1852936,
0.3123818636,
-0.1531901509,
0.6197008491,
-0.0894726217,
-0.8805972338,
-0.4579478502,
-0.4466721714,
0.1320291609,
-0.1346744448,
1.1964187622,
-0.9488725662,
0.292717725,
0.2831005752,
0.0721057206,
0.0428260751,
-0.0085279476,
1.1605727673,
-0.6626315117,
0.1191421226,
0.4158547223,
0.1465247869,
0.2325265408,
-0.3899952471,
0.1651292443,
0.2168629169,
-0.8053389788,
-0.9042971134,
0.4790818691,
-0.7354151011,
-0.1508009583,
0.7593131661,
-0.0361145996,
0.1424411982,
-0.6805064678,
-0.3396635652,
0.3976293206,
-0.7478221059,
0.7827907801,
0.5818448067,
-0.0654761344,
0.0759766102,
-0.5357245207,
0.4941931665,
0.6913425326,
-0.6366078854,
0.1533982754,
0.717965126,
0.3356687129,
0.118809022,
1.0764334202,
-0.310741514,
0.1305308789,
-0.2197710425,
0.0637487248,
0.3055523634,
-0.1239447296,
0.0042892471,
-0.0124766435,
0.0962237194,
0.1940455437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06503v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06503v3
|
Knowledgeable Preference Alignment for LLMs in Domain-specific Question Answering
| 2023-11-11T07:56:40 | 2024-06-10T09:06:10 |
Yichi Zhang, Zhuo Chen, Yin Fang, Yanxi Lu, Fangming Li, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Deploying large language models (LLMs) to real scenarios for domain-specific
question answering (QA) is a key thrust for LLM applications, which poses
numerous challenges, especially in ensuring that responses are both
accommodating to user requirements and appropriately leveraging domain-specific
knowledge bases. They are the two major difficulties for LLM application as
vanilla fine-tuning falls short of addressing. Combining these requirements, we
conceive of them as the requirement for the model's preference to be
harmoniously aligned with humans'. Thus, we introduce Knowledgeable Preference
AlignmenT (KnowPAT), which constructs two kinds of preference sets to tackle
the two issues. Besides, we design a new alignment objective to align the LLM
preference with different human preferences uniformly, aiming to optimize LLM
performance in real-world, domain-specific QA settings. Adequate experiments
and comprehensive comparisons with 15 baseline methods illustrate that our
KnowPAT is a superior pipeline for real-scenario domain-specific QA with LLMs.
|
[
-0.5068113208,
-0.7585015893,
0.5894239545,
0.1499442011,
-0.2032643855,
0.264934659,
-0.083208628,
-0.5518268943,
0.1666810066,
0.5583167672,
-0.8196052313,
-0.321665436,
-0.2831095159,
-0.1173646078,
-0.10509222,
0.8637779355,
-0.2324023545,
-0.0793496892,
-0.6962669492,
-0.3220280111,
-0.7705824971,
-0.5822454691,
-0.5665253997,
-0.2864218652,
0.4922100902,
0.4381866753,
0.7644106746,
0.4597055614,
0.5583767891,
0.1485338658,
0.0049069715,
0.4289304912,
-0.345516026,
0.2785724998,
-0.1623040289,
-0.4438771605,
-0.7136024833,
-0.2075660974,
0.2310056388,
0.6601244211,
-0.1776302159,
0.2676847875,
-0.014034518,
0.7728191018,
-0.4127723575,
-0.1350671202,
-0.5216518641,
-0.0308901407,
0.115380384,
-0.3316817284,
-0.067853108,
-0.6452141404,
0.5675602555,
-0.8910669684,
-0.0089709032,
0.2837734222,
0.8651621938,
0.4939911664,
-0.5682248473,
0.0170915704,
-0.6687315702,
0.7402201295,
-0.755084157,
0.4365277588,
0.2289631516,
0.4363973737,
-0.1793302447,
-0.5611740947,
-0.6610233188,
0.1327879429,
0.1289662123,
0.1492158324,
0.1021895036,
-0.0057952637,
0.0041594631,
0.2578252852,
-0.8253298998,
0.1790653318,
0.0771338418,
-0.1796461791,
0.4324353635,
0.2702375054,
0.2102119029,
0.1417848617,
-0.6075350642,
0.1580571234,
-0.8781050444,
0.0877886638,
0.2432766259,
0.2168046534,
0.029004639,
0.5019368529,
-0.3335576355,
0.9776083827,
0.1980825514,
-0.0653363317,
0.1179573014,
-0.2010053247,
-0.0990176201,
-0.2440966368,
0.4373568892,
0.5691360831,
0.4895941913,
-0.1973835379,
-0.2761027217,
-0.1939072311,
0.4147138,
-0.5382146835,
0.0330370925,
0.3774757385,
-0.1185616106,
-0.1084555537,
-0.2295607179,
-0.4421220422,
-0.4847311676,
-0.5185528398,
0.4862001538,
-0.2550405562,
-0.3901931643,
0.3314535916,
0.1067255884,
0.545635283,
0.5210908055,
-0.9355557561,
0.2358653545,
0.8833390474,
0.4370854497,
-0.5511031151,
-0.276806742,
-0.3344020247,
0.1019854769,
-0.0713921189,
1.015376687,
-0.502573967,
-0.1691676676,
0.1051833257,
-0.2260799259,
-0.1352896839,
-0.7116624713,
0.5141236186,
-1.0331429243,
0.2419416606,
-0.5352036357,
-0.9002174139,
0.0052536097,
0.7051112056,
-0.3233430088,
0.8495643735,
0.2665717304,
-0.6700158715,
0.3578967154,
-0.4787171185,
-0.2469388694,
0.0595296845,
-0.0341202132,
-0.3132375777,
-0.226842612,
0.112669155,
0.3614834249,
-0.3264915347,
0.2328318805,
-0.2981286645,
-0.1747909486,
0.3224759102,
-0.1940615624,
0.5611895919,
0.2894304395,
-0.0247290228,
0.2070330679,
-0.4537782073,
0.1876906604,
0.2244462222,
-0.2525840402,
-0.2984950244,
0.0894976258,
-0.0427228771,
0.229088679,
0.7058089375,
-0.3284248412,
0.2991634905,
-0.2860994339,
0.2395860702,
0.8041410446,
0.0731249973,
0.5001153946,
-0.6060679555,
0.7779381871,
-0.1333525628,
0.3028296828,
0.4663877189,
-0.4088891447,
-0.5991129279,
-0.0371896736,
0.3075175583,
0.7379741669,
-0.4920479357,
0.4527924955,
-0.2228538245,
-0.2997324765,
-0.4946550727,
0.1483962834,
0.4161365926,
0.7842819095,
0.2246493846,
-0.158910647,
-0.4277630448,
-1.0459467173,
-0.2190916389,
-0.2124515623,
0.0381740369,
0.5336642861,
0.0593174323,
-0.1116669327,
1.2782248259,
-0.8799900413,
-0.1976422369,
-0.1957155019,
-0.3218087256,
0.119653821,
0.2106211483,
0.4432809055,
-1.1125847101,
-0.6416687369,
-0.006557744,
-0.5288032889,
-0.1916208416,
0.3100718856,
-0.3531767726,
0.1162386611,
0.1624869853,
-0.5373260379,
-0.1057053655,
0.5950136185,
-0.3229091465,
0.6782402396,
0.0836259276,
0.2514993846,
-1.3997379541,
-0.0151655097,
-0.1345940828,
-0.3652603328,
-0.6643403172,
-0.05242965,
0.233820796,
0.0730958581,
-0.6182371974,
0.8322333097,
-0.2293523252,
-0.0056975367,
-0.1303835362,
0.2822678685,
0.3422160149,
0.4373300672,
0.3274127841,
0.9721013308,
0.2545992732,
-0.5811086297,
0.432809025,
0.5246886015,
-0.2905699313,
0.7955221534,
-0.5697754025,
0.13587901,
0.2255363762,
0.1297167093,
-0.8331249952,
-0.2205678076,
0.0099093225,
-0.4409594238,
0.1565077603,
-0.1552561671,
-0.3217658401,
-0.1366010755,
-0.2417637855,
0.6555584669,
0.595302403,
-0.4834973812,
0.4030882418,
0.4648888409,
-0.2461831719,
-0.8168874979,
-0.3960965574,
-0.1984228641,
-0.3056306839,
-0.7558017373,
0.2960333228,
-0.3985688984,
-0.151950866,
-0.1620343477,
-0.3141512871,
-0.124952063,
0.1129882857,
0.172127381,
0.3565886915,
-0.3618490994,
0.1298682392,
-0.0899711847,
-0.1452780813,
-0.1153050512,
-0.428637296,
0.632655561,
-0.0879925936,
-0.509481132,
-0.1925471127,
0.2778504193,
0.4112409651,
-0.3962031901,
0.5639997721,
0.2401169538,
-0.2466951907,
-0.0953729898,
-0.8314094543,
-0.0705645457,
-0.4438808262,
0.2693407834,
-0.4527952075,
-1.1853530407,
0.6661137342,
-0.0262280535,
0.1580291539,
0.2108271122,
0.4209677279,
-0.3451934457,
0.9949802756,
0.6779054999,
-0.1548209488,
0.3781552911,
0.1041639894,
0.2652630508,
-0.9411684871,
-0.1083828583,
-0.3836919963,
-0.1945763677,
-0.3070973456,
-0.1685226262,
0.431483686,
-0.0908681974,
-0.302148968,
0.2965440154,
-0.4548158646,
0.522390306,
0.4785524905,
-0.1143207401,
0.3477071226,
-0.1737197489,
0.0394735709,
-0.042130731,
-0.5978421569,
-0.5809413195,
0.9957399964,
0.1771072,
0.7548862696,
0.308660239,
0.6290717721,
0.0897962898,
0.0369531177,
-0.762021184,
0.4028721452,
-0.0781726763,
-0.6836810112,
-0.3255124688,
-0.3068470657,
-0.7778698802,
0.0226054527,
-0.1373641491,
-0.5026068091,
0.1143965349,
0.4585246444,
-0.5762917399,
0.1515414715,
-0.6703029275,
1.0227612257,
-0.2685775757,
-0.1772604138,
0.129886955,
-0.8091956377,
0.2855997384,
-0.0664846897,
-0.1120341644,
-0.2468409538,
-0.2130408436,
0.6484217048,
-0.1475699991,
0.7576081157,
-0.1014441103,
-0.3236424327,
0.0966430902,
0.1038009599,
0.5357410312,
0.0414982699,
-0.0564513393,
-0.0979641154,
0.2209193707,
-0.3939480782,
-0.7248348594,
0.7834302783,
-0.8261451125,
-0.8322169185,
-0.3529967666,
-0.6480858922,
-0.7902549505,
0.172428444,
0.1162565798,
0.2451292425,
-0.3757796288,
-0.2163728923,
1.0887173414,
0.0167043377,
-0.035407573,
0.7810124755,
-0.3713002205,
-0.231960535,
0.9743296504,
-0.0496328659,
0.5661821961,
0.7518418431,
0.0462544039,
-0.4668984413,
-0.6463669538,
-0.4812767208,
0.1515734196,
-0.5007487535,
-0.3469310403,
-0.5168969035,
-0.2932330966,
-0.4263474047,
-0.3180989623,
-0.3801974654,
-0.5903958678,
-0.2321159393,
-0.0708464608,
0.3707602918,
0.4817428291,
0.4693131447,
0.2407504171,
-0.8145774007,
0.5150232911,
0.7141753435,
0.5043877363,
-0.3816694915,
-0.7120723128,
-0.1396192759,
0.0394568779,
-0.2896943092,
-0.5629066825,
0.2573681474,
0.0474389531,
0.5217237473,
0.3144514859,
0.3054064214,
0.5940403938,
-0.4228069782,
0.7399616241,
-0.2042770088,
-0.5246272683,
0.4929881096,
-0.3661426902,
0.250246793,
0.7211618423,
0.368332684,
-0.7747879028,
-0.2680054009,
-0.4369108975,
-0.7536624074,
0.550458312,
-0.1073345095,
0.130706802,
0.0443432108,
0.5145632625,
0.3755888343,
0.263756603,
-0.4943133295,
-0.2491053194,
0.0768561214,
-0.2806661129,
-0.0475124307,
-0.3188091815,
-0.3606666028,
0.0358224586,
0.6952777505,
-0.2850071788,
0.1386416703,
0.0175010953,
-0.3211004734,
-0.2024189979,
0.3312330842,
0.6630379558,
0.9694651961,
-0.5340002775,
0.0961369649,
0.2023303211,
-0.265999943,
0.207449466,
0.0566571057,
-0.2826317847,
-0.6225770712,
0.1365532279,
0.626927793,
-0.1062997952,
-0.8147545457,
0.5902904868,
-0.2754376829,
-0.2603860795,
-0.3285416067,
0.2286016047,
0.4455950558,
0.3106767833,
0.1714045703,
-0.0209585894,
0.031336952,
-0.1454499066,
0.0485950001,
0.7207852602,
-0.4721059799,
-0.1919230968,
0.5432183146,
0.2401950657,
-0.3000872731,
0.4367916882,
0.0620129704,
-0.6156949997,
0.6110340953,
0.5986202359,
0.8123689294,
-0.1501968801,
0.1256377399,
-0.124469161,
-0.0171954017,
0.0103893038,
0.3008318543,
-0.0580162667,
-1.0881103277,
-0.2884268165,
-0.6158003807,
-0.7710458636,
-0.1406829208,
-0.7609725595,
0.0375652276,
-0.2957771719,
-0.018758025,
-0.2510569394,
0.1512838453,
-0.5230678916,
0.2755455375,
-0.1615010947,
0.9111896157,
-0.7542168498,
0.7933254242,
0.9879383445,
-0.193172425,
-0.7292585373,
0.0998096541,
0.0158246849,
-1.0019811392,
0.3331615627,
-0.1542736143,
-0.1376841813,
0.133044526,
-0.3961169422,
-0.730137527,
1.2743173838,
0.474989742,
-0.4573324621,
0.1176128909,
0.2510025203,
0.5041905046,
-0.4269716442,
-0.1569233984,
0.5923711658,
0.4811249077,
0.098294653,
-0.9942492247,
-0.0614435337,
-0.1346060634,
-0.2608955503,
0.3228423893,
-0.9206297994,
0.3274377286,
-0.0845434591,
0.0215069391,
-0.0226462949,
0.6128780246,
0.4063355923,
0.2957473397,
0.541206181,
0.5878399611,
0.7576265335,
0.0245775152,
0.9211416245,
-0.2745451927,
0.1520984173,
1.0575066805,
-0.5858616233,
0.9149676561,
0.6032322049,
-0.296960026,
0.0428152345,
0.9146518111,
0.5065011978,
0.4506137967,
0.0720659569,
-0.4583934247,
-0.5123710632,
-0.1721325368,
-0.4144532681,
0.1463213414,
0.1333984882,
0.2037697285,
0.1568250656,
-0.2941722274,
-0.1415062994,
0.1484849751,
-0.0507515147,
0.9932314754,
0.0458661355,
-0.9269512892,
0.5585721731,
-0.2296354473,
0.6928355098,
-0.7123675942,
0.1340934485,
-0.4676475525,
0.0406154469,
-0.1824577153,
-0.9792729616,
0.0825758353,
-0.1058518216,
-0.517603755,
-0.2162574083,
0.6220546365,
-0.5619464517,
-0.0260921922,
0.1690963805,
0.7193900943,
-0.0315688699,
-0.2371502072,
-0.6645035148,
-0.2274615616,
0.0706399307,
-0.390445292,
0.6600019336,
0.3435718119,
-0.2045754343,
0.9537400007,
0.4128625095,
0.042044308,
0.0956720784,
0.1861834377,
0.8371263146,
-0.5653659105,
-0.1695645601,
-0.5560708642,
0.389316082,
0.064948976,
-0.378911674,
0.5257148743,
0.616220355,
0.5807974935,
-0.1089792252,
0.7865772843,
0.1065717936,
0.7135564089,
-0.5627099276,
0.5261619091,
-0.6569778323,
0.492790848,
0.041110117,
-1.1911563873,
-0.4955194592,
0.2790069878,
-0.3403033316,
0.0610010959,
0.6254830956,
0.9241857529,
-0.1549089402,
-0.2199461162,
0.3833279312,
-0.2316503525,
0.3191435039,
0.6894227266,
0.9039809108,
-0.0743972063,
0.4701441824,
-0.2294606715,
-0.1679393947,
-0.2468388081,
-0.9571574926,
-0.5567778945,
-0.629655838,
-0.3148000836,
-0.1855644137,
0.1659432799,
1.0928208828,
0.6123905182,
-0.8505430222,
-0.1370468438,
0.2823686004,
0.3295971453,
-0.1449217051,
-0.2268913239,
0.5431070328,
-0.3230252862,
-0.6479324102,
0.2596197724,
0.2542448938,
0.0404203311,
0.0048351428,
-0.3620547354,
-0.1827127188,
0.1480371952,
0.5057787299,
0.5398265719,
-0.5562038422,
-0.4605430961,
0.3950970173,
-0.2461137474,
0.1698472798,
0.6819937825,
-0.6000984907,
0.2290555984,
0.5152693987,
0.9447804689,
0.2627250254,
0.2633908987,
0.7476213574,
-0.8364173174,
-0.3285973668,
0.3166190684,
0.1595185548,
0.3000139296,
-0.3830862045,
0.4575892985,
0.0040562493,
-0.8809881806,
-0.6676566005,
0.4531165957,
-1.3626310825,
-0.0737553984,
1.224857688,
-0.0718846694,
-0.027461201,
-0.316162914,
-0.3673562407,
0.0612172596,
-0.3332256675,
0.6350769401,
0.6238982081,
-0.4450950921,
-0.055010464,
-0.4674794972,
0.5975068808,
0.7057034373,
-0.8328945041,
0.193364352,
0.4812593162,
0.5414953828,
-0.1332368702,
0.74010849,
0.0113571687,
0.3721617162,
-0.5319253206,
0.2740031779,
0.0119900825,
-0.0976285115,
-0.1983073652,
0.152495712,
0.6953856349,
-0.1170016602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06493v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06493v1
|
L3 Ensembles: Lifelong Learning Approach for Ensemble of Foundational Language Models
| 2023-11-11T06:59:50 | 2023-11-11T06:59:50 |
Aidin Shiri, Kaushik Roy, Amit Sheth, Manas Gaur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning pre-trained foundational language models (FLM) for specific tasks
is often impractical, especially for resource-constrained devices. This
necessitates the development of a Lifelong Learning (L3) framework that
continuously adapts to a stream of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks
efficiently. We propose an approach that focuses on extracting meaningful
representations from unseen data, constructing a structured knowledge base, and
improving task performance incrementally. We conducted experiments on various
NLP tasks to validate its effectiveness, including benchmarks like GLUE and
SuperGLUE. We measured good performance across the accuracy, training
efficiency, and knowledge transfer metrics. Initial experimental results show
that the proposed L3 ensemble method increases the model accuracy by 4% ~ 36%
compared to the fine-tuned FLM. Furthermore, L3 model outperforms naive
fine-tuning approaches while maintaining competitive or superior performance
(up to 15.4% increase in accuracy) compared to the state-of-the-art language
model (T5) for the given task, STS benchmark.
|
[
-0.1725304872,
-0.6970306039,
0.231813103,
0.2847154737,
-0.0101655852,
0.3486846983,
-0.5366257429,
-0.7522259951,
-0.1604653597,
0.4965283275,
-0.3593458533,
-0.4823012948,
-0.4781623483,
-0.0306146014,
-0.4179928899,
0.8163803816,
0.0926871747,
-0.1295651644,
-0.068249777,
-0.188044548,
-0.564124763,
-0.1195682064,
-0.7803073525,
-0.2647655904,
0.2964814305,
0.5540242195,
0.4862369597,
0.5618231893,
0.3397180438,
0.2440309525,
0.096908696,
0.3423084319,
-0.5619547963,
0.2414732128,
-0.1850788742,
-0.3689646125,
-0.2660992742,
-0.1531178951,
0.7953269482,
0.8151937723,
-0.2597171068,
0.1363850087,
0.4422092438,
0.8508299589,
-0.6718568802,
0.2205815315,
-0.8511858582,
0.042701751,
-0.1254211664,
-0.1050307453,
-0.4986643195,
-0.2496571541,
0.2093172371,
-0.5209447145,
0.2206364572,
0.0486352742,
0.4086645544,
0.0893299729,
0.1221571043,
-0.2239635736,
-0.8814044595,
0.964987576,
-0.700505197,
0.4566526711,
0.2507210374,
0.0538741499,
-0.0162419751,
-0.5684232712,
-0.480040729,
-0.2097101361,
0.1212501824,
-0.0245162249,
-0.0013330108,
0.0510871708,
-0.1778899878,
0.4136934876,
-0.6115650535,
0.1921955496,
-0.2833134234,
-0.0195655152,
0.6143591404,
-0.1387516111,
0.2214101851,
0.3198964596,
-0.3992086947,
0.0189292096,
-0.5630579591,
-0.2393380404,
-0.001156976,
0.4841088057,
0.0605197065,
0.213982299,
-0.2849749029,
0.9736640453,
0.0916393027,
-0.3176172972,
0.2298073769,
-0.1430411041,
-0.2708046734,
-0.0514273383,
0.6790097952,
0.0686677918,
0.4648829699,
-0.5588062406,
-0.3490693271,
-0.1259236038,
0.2237734199,
-0.2702054679,
-0.2275450826,
0.1447194368,
-0.2183497846,
-0.4401186705,
-0.3023988605,
-0.6321350336,
-0.1566766351,
-0.4211277664,
0.4735166132,
-0.6935305595,
-0.2820420265,
0.1972245574,
0.2306547165,
-0.1609354466,
0.2046141922,
-1.2754468918,
0.5591160655,
0.6738122702,
1.0430208445,
-0.6466988921,
-0.4034192264,
-0.5607720613,
0.2981736362,
-0.2651079297,
0.7673920989,
-0.3861706555,
-0.3168483675,
-0.0581006184,
-0.1999476701,
-0.3039656878,
-0.6627470255,
0.3308376968,
-0.5984844565,
-0.020554604,
0.2788139284,
-0.8017369509,
0.0616637617,
0.1573332399,
-0.7029264569,
1.1360530853,
0.1213710308,
-0.3071438372,
0.3181247711,
-0.7953702211,
-0.3168060184,
0.2821155787,
-0.0481826849,
-0.1453784257,
0.0092801843,
0.2194513828,
0.8869027495,
-0.1073662564,
0.3557933271,
-0.3314339817,
-0.4437986612,
-0.2658101618,
-0.218836382,
0.4202948511,
0.1571107358,
-0.3348331749,
0.0083532911,
-0.8019995093,
-0.0936879665,
-0.1125966236,
-0.4360624552,
-0.2357298583,
0.1029219478,
0.0554852448,
-0.0663375109,
0.2712008357,
-0.4335675836,
0.0565830916,
-0.7995372415,
0.2292184532,
0.8744198084,
0.0103622144,
0.7162898183,
-0.5078821778,
0.2886860967,
-0.1776533127,
-0.112844266,
0.0038700867,
-0.3152745366,
-0.7496449947,
0.0082024867,
0.2706888318,
0.5878497958,
-0.6024121046,
0.5793143511,
-0.5957791209,
-0.6745819449,
-0.0956846327,
0.6107091308,
0.1773352176,
0.5426451564,
0.5975784659,
-0.0287807826,
-0.5816792846,
-0.629994452,
-0.419806689,
-0.1287607253,
-0.0001099703,
-0.0360763744,
0.5557290912,
-0.164317295,
1.1032406092,
-0.1308836788,
-0.3091574907,
-0.4104833901,
0.2513159513,
0.3826669753,
0.872587204,
0.3891465962,
-0.6501463652,
-0.4419209957,
0.2333791256,
-0.6377781034,
0.2696081996,
-0.0975755602,
0.0756367296,
0.3514401615,
0.4417856038,
-0.4110748768,
-0.1422548294,
0.6628001928,
0.0653100759,
0.4504435658,
-0.0882417038,
-0.2660945058,
-0.9531256557,
0.1505310535,
0.0584020838,
-0.4469352663,
-0.7110837698,
0.1724186242,
-0.0039559337,
-0.0577842146,
-0.4456162453,
0.778955996,
-0.3963492215,
0.0255480241,
-0.1383004189,
0.2078426033,
-0.3500879407,
0.5706954598,
0.3087646663,
0.6062243581,
0.5107234716,
-0.8763107061,
0.2833405137,
-0.0960543156,
-0.6423844695,
0.3311571777,
-0.4158649743,
0.050725922,
0.0903504789,
0.2080615759,
-0.5954838395,
-0.2301903963,
-0.0582409911,
-0.2252475619,
0.3708206415,
0.0675958917,
-0.6285318136,
-0.0901146904,
-0.0403751917,
0.1371554732,
0.5807997584,
-0.5852949619,
0.8194547892,
0.387865603,
-0.0900305882,
-0.5403416157,
-0.5817371011,
-0.0775686502,
-0.3453336358,
-0.6308691502,
0.6342581511,
-0.0717876852,
-0.0899185017,
-0.1235718429,
-0.2752141953,
0.0949575976,
0.4073791504,
-0.0152289104,
-0.0346193127,
-0.312164247,
0.5225971341,
-0.243138209,
-0.06048261,
-0.1618374884,
-0.6816285253,
0.5203735232,
-0.5423943996,
-0.0439811498,
-0.2116675675,
0.0918576494,
0.3699743152,
-0.0816855356,
0.8466690183,
0.6623184085,
-0.6740992069,
-0.4208590686,
-0.7684897184,
-0.0989182517,
-0.4535260797,
0.1742184162,
-0.1826619357,
-1.1073848009,
0.3094662726,
-0.1717658043,
0.4384737015,
0.5070144534,
0.3082104325,
-0.4061227143,
0.8001034856,
0.7928385139,
-0.397965312,
0.4548467994,
-0.1810261756,
-0.0555105023,
-0.7154414654,
-0.0000890946,
-0.3498309255,
-0.1668485254,
-0.2276445925,
-0.3632588387,
0.3305293322,
0.5427423716,
-0.2361774743,
0.3478294313,
-0.1798464656,
0.5859544277,
0.3498161435,
0.2007582635,
0.2927381396,
0.0673228875,
0.1288538724,
0.2825089991,
-0.8269430399,
-0.5213635564,
1.141974926,
0.3885702193,
0.4261410832,
0.2582237124,
0.7837201357,
0.4188683033,
0.5024454594,
-0.4836113453,
0.5123225451,
-0.1904278547,
-0.3475078344,
-0.4383847415,
-0.3774524331,
-0.7531618476,
0.0767871216,
-0.381603092,
-1.1629678011,
0.0451333225,
0.4817822278,
-0.4646650851,
0.2728083134,
-0.4727988839,
0.7293212414,
-0.3254860938,
-0.6676527858,
-0.3574947715,
-0.5762130022,
0.4822625816,
-0.3120501041,
0.3860144019,
-0.0812789947,
0.0430117249,
0.8529242873,
-0.0944540128,
0.8818354011,
-0.2235755771,
-0.1352129132,
0.0702606887,
0.1109228209,
0.7422418594,
0.143408671,
-0.313487649,
0.0133941062,
-0.0295331851,
-0.4414950907,
-0.6735704541,
0.8105312586,
-0.6256094575,
-0.3604675233,
-0.1408425868,
-0.4805110395,
-0.7108169794,
0.1997039765,
-0.0908406228,
0.416990906,
-0.2935244739,
0.5661154985,
0.9190591574,
0.0366268046,
0.5074088573,
0.4079064429,
-0.2108143568,
-0.1215834394,
1.0654094219,
-0.0379753821,
0.453407824,
0.6160646081,
0.2516652644,
-0.2387738675,
-0.7580832839,
-0.3704669178,
-0.0198057592,
-0.6635996699,
-0.1019254699,
-0.7701038122,
0.0698032007,
-0.3826881647,
-0.195152849,
-0.3394289911,
-0.2766654193,
-0.5715728402,
0.0223983731,
0.2879524827,
0.5842868686,
-0.243233934,
0.2842651308,
-0.9881340861,
0.2075880319,
0.3560155034,
0.4104253054,
-0.0296566579,
-0.4450458586,
-0.4597788751,
0.063917622,
-0.0580529869,
-0.6172337532,
0.278211832,
0.6911421418,
0.5762470961,
0.1627018154,
-0.2199281901,
0.7147640586,
-0.3161538243,
0.8447508812,
0.0089332527,
-0.9248359799,
0.55827564,
-0.5444374681,
0.3822665513,
0.7478666902,
0.2595146,
-0.3252685666,
-0.2539443076,
-0.7601530552,
-0.8011787534,
0.4480816722,
0.0758862868,
0.0090685273,
0.0398082808,
0.3990682662,
-0.0361300893,
0.0996182263,
-0.7845417261,
0.0196047239,
0.0666085854,
-0.3985436559,
-0.3295533955,
0.0356050245,
0.094616361,
-0.0860868022,
0.9297398925,
-0.4854175746,
0.0937157273,
-0.077765353,
-0.5128230453,
-0.044782687,
0.0613839217,
0.63050735,
0.6748344302,
-0.3624195457,
0.0328228846,
0.5463690758,
-0.2969379425,
-0.0698124468,
-0.1068027541,
0.1711196005,
-0.2294941097,
0.6865482926,
0.6536950469,
0.584338665,
-0.7648696303,
0.2392126769,
0.0910283998,
-0.1358861029,
-0.3794680834,
0.4669904709,
0.2177927196,
0.0732329935,
0.4311489761,
0.5400488377,
-0.0404564515,
-0.4641570151,
0.3467872441,
0.3477323949,
-0.3502242863,
0.0134669682,
0.2951312363,
0.3140534461,
-0.1931306273,
0.4445833266,
0.0394658484,
-0.2240959555,
0.4001906514,
0.6377216578,
0.6411444545,
-0.1760960966,
0.1037019491,
0.3621441722,
0.2168312371,
-0.596301496,
-0.0163044259,
-0.4738103151,
-1.1206361055,
-0.5154445767,
-0.9047539234,
-0.272326827,
0.3423280418,
-0.6425096393,
0.07914529,
-0.3868364692,
0.3641805947,
-0.3287521005,
-0.0110646049,
-0.6765042543,
0.4585693181,
0.1631976366,
1.1094702482,
-0.6821402907,
0.9751270413,
0.2246711552,
0.0062342132,
-0.6839453578,
0.0057199965,
-0.1203840449,
-0.6956086755,
0.595549047,
0.1083648428,
-0.3504259884,
0.4423026145,
-0.4646961391,
-1.0961081982,
1.0329048634,
0.2956618965,
-0.8621931672,
-0.0777360201,
-0.0940451175,
0.5896423459,
-0.4823827744,
-0.005643086,
0.7640557885,
0.3197772801,
-0.1860689968,
-0.7851431966,
-0.2857654393,
-0.358389318,
0.046910435,
-0.0450030714,
-0.3207630515,
0.4411274791,
0.0062140552,
-0.4629042447,
0.1865451932,
0.9968290329,
0.5229059458,
-0.1515374035,
0.7803145647,
0.3798407614,
0.8747910261,
-0.0164935477,
0.8966233134,
-0.5917879343,
0.4117819369,
1.2691885233,
-0.2676186264,
1.0382348299,
0.4352520704,
-0.0400998555,
0.4806569219,
0.5261839628,
0.1276215762,
0.5532580614,
0.2241704464,
-0.4184438884,
-0.3680900335,
0.1604910791,
-0.2551533878,
0.3133150935,
0.7313423157,
-0.1171761304,
-0.0633317307,
0.1666645408,
-0.2157672346,
0.1361092329,
-0.3136636019,
0.7502090335,
-0.0755733028,
-0.7390064001,
0.5734317303,
-0.0490211248,
0.8938234448,
-0.578836441,
-0.0135093965,
-0.0426978506,
0.2165663838,
-0.2427678853,
-0.5271846652,
0.4159034491,
-0.094010219,
-0.0504515283,
-0.510337472,
0.7474885583,
-0.4092024267,
-0.5150527358,
0.1936945021,
0.3914831281,
-0.0916244388,
0.0810809135,
-0.6987840533,
-0.0066059115,
-0.1092549711,
-0.2919816971,
0.2778393626,
-0.1180119589,
0.0703017414,
0.761374414,
0.752261281,
0.2176927328,
-0.0526076593,
-0.0020623996,
0.5813128352,
-0.3380648494,
-0.3792096674,
-0.7926431298,
0.5133032203,
-0.0367144905,
-0.2873776555,
0.4625357985,
0.4451861084,
1.0177974701,
-0.1408086568,
0.8659859896,
0.0449869819,
0.6919671297,
-0.9522809386,
0.5316804051,
-0.4477472007,
0.4506345391,
-0.2798965275,
-0.8874140978,
-0.5790234804,
0.7013683319,
-0.1158010364,
0.1268840134,
0.5259569287,
0.6995503902,
-0.1470950544,
0.416972518,
0.1913222522,
0.14048554,
0.2421020269,
0.5578337312,
0.7505709529,
-0.2759689987,
0.0881453305,
-0.4136663377,
-0.0807816386,
-0.0075835013,
-0.962467134,
-0.7189592719,
-0.5797214508,
-0.1715850681,
-0.0393533297,
0.3496051133,
1.0023454428,
0.8943951726,
-0.8499083519,
-0.3393447697,
-0.7057690024,
-0.0379377455,
-0.4258707166,
-0.2112382948,
0.2787801325,
-0.5854653716,
-0.5999276638,
0.9972186089,
0.2302641571,
-0.1634818465,
-0.4517226219,
-0.0827959254,
-0.2756296396,
-0.3538499475,
0.6020337343,
0.3975563645,
-0.6548321843,
-0.554335475,
-0.1100167558,
0.2724794149,
-0.1564653665,
0.5253377557,
-1.0423431396,
0.3177349865,
0.2982028723,
0.806424439,
0.4793822467,
-0.1272800565,
0.8527611494,
-0.9192433357,
-0.1937125921,
0.4445002377,
0.2882328331,
0.2789674401,
-0.284653157,
0.602031827,
0.2196513563,
-0.5657382011,
-0.8919485211,
0.1277566701,
-0.8665730357,
-0.1918869913,
1.0889014006,
-0.1123675928,
-0.043155279,
-0.2853043973,
0.1941012442,
0.117422387,
-0.2934869826,
0.5994757414,
0.4655499756,
-0.2057080865,
-0.3235553503,
-0.5110501647,
0.5994408131,
0.4372971654,
-0.8943964243,
-0.0504465699,
0.1258324385,
0.3575502038,
0.3533875048,
0.6130884886,
0.1527100503,
0.2546952367,
-0.4729768038,
-0.0643888414,
0.1750248075,
-0.5094799399,
-0.382884711,
0.3927485049,
-0.0072688921,
0.2074427754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06467v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06467v2
|
ALBA: Adaptive Language-based Assessments for Mental Health
| 2023-11-11T03:37:17 | 2024-05-16T07:13:10 |
Vasudha Varadarajan, Sverker Sikström, Oscar N. E. Kjell, H. Andrew Schwartz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Mental health issues differ widely among individuals, with varied signs and
symptoms. Recently, language-based assessments have shown promise in capturing
this diversity, but they require a substantial sample of words per person for
accuracy. This work introduces the task of Adaptive Language-Based Assessment
ALBA, which involves adaptively ordering questions while also scoring an
individual's latent psychological trait using limited language responses to
previous questions. To this end, we develop adaptive testing methods under two
psychometric measurement theories: Classical Test Theory and Item Response
Theory. We empirically evaluate ordering and scoring strategies, organizing
into two new methods: a semi-supervised item response theory-based method ALIRT
and a supervised Actor-Critic model. While we found both methods to improve
over non-adaptive baselines, We found ALIRT to be the most accurate and
scalable, achieving the highest accuracy with fewer questions (e.g., Pearson r
~ 0.93 after only 3 questions as compared to typically needing at least 7
questions). In general, adaptive language-based assessments of depression and
anxiety were able to utilize a smaller sample of language without compromising
validity or large computational costs.
|
[
-0.4886397123,
-1.1715736389,
0.5359125137,
0.564471662,
0.3307866454,
0.2986031473,
-0.2722406983,
-0.5134329796,
0.4713974595,
0.0311860256,
-0.422986865,
-0.1825006902,
-0.4851931036,
0.1621340662,
-0.1148232669,
0.9815248847,
-0.255004108,
0.029655192,
0.2219340354,
-0.577103436,
-0.5811284781,
-0.21811001,
-1.1570113897,
-0.0453016646,
0.7144542933,
0.4119702578,
0.6869582534,
0.2179294974,
0.788870573,
0.2100177258,
0.0500712432,
0.0463992506,
-0.2234271318,
0.2352228016,
-0.5011073351,
-0.2917817831,
-0.9730440378,
-0.0016161188,
0.2711033523,
0.680026412,
-0.3987814784,
0.4137148857,
-0.0580514185,
0.6391495466,
-0.970725894,
-0.0357810147,
-0.2940438092,
-0.0164876841,
0.1204614863,
0.0002341837,
-0.3350944817,
-0.2829470038,
0.0278909206,
-0.5606623888,
-0.0911172777,
-0.0240009669,
0.4084071517,
0.2025849521,
-0.3329105973,
-0.4463212192,
-0.8169188499,
0.5054401159,
-0.559289217,
0.2282592505,
0.7960144281,
0.3432413042,
0.0960663706,
-0.6685672402,
-0.4400657415,
-0.1383525282,
0.0516725518,
0.570039928,
-0.25744012,
0.0927964076,
0.09333428,
0.2348916829,
-0.9137356877,
0.0908766016,
-0.3406725228,
0.0200333018,
0.9162922502,
0.3094603419,
0.4040832818,
0.161752969,
-0.0635250211,
-0.2302424908,
-0.1286086291,
0.1972682923,
-0.216287151,
0.3238504827,
-0.010509816,
0.3260040283,
-0.1748942435,
0.6055495739,
0.2767372429,
-0.2282144576,
0.0547886565,
0.0362554677,
-0.311442852,
-0.0383546464,
0.5945370197,
0.5664384365,
0.0244059023,
0.1704798043,
-0.1581699848,
0.2620477378,
0.3876570463,
-0.4001851976,
-0.4385611713,
0.2965233028,
-0.2841387987,
-0.0249335505,
-0.2699765861,
-1.1100108624,
-0.5169681311,
-0.0255759768,
0.4578194618,
-0.3579286933,
-0.0741266832,
0.1097335368,
0.385196358,
0.1064180434,
0.3872451484,
-0.8006789684,
0.6688290238,
0.2968288362,
0.7299306393,
-0.1823228896,
-0.2864197493,
-0.8184269071,
-0.2690063417,
-0.8199988604,
0.9507555962,
-0.5052641034,
-0.0304166265,
0.037850339,
-0.0134756351,
-0.3541639149,
-0.3014299273,
0.5045571327,
-0.4796597064,
0.5883013606,
-0.483807832,
-0.5143485069,
-0.26353392,
0.193418771,
-0.2488901764,
1.2457906008,
0.6908252239,
-0.6657330394,
0.146574989,
-0.7808355093,
-0.4267018139,
0.1241081506,
0.1635946482,
0.1074944809,
0.3672078252,
0.3906268179,
0.4248095453,
-0.2347488999,
-0.1289892644,
-0.5021165013,
-0.3939497173,
0.641418457,
-0.2931171358,
0.5251492858,
0.3933202028,
-0.1763057858,
-0.0952835158,
-0.8332313895,
0.180530712,
-0.1231584772,
-0.3684994578,
-0.4020760953,
0.24738428,
0.169939965,
0.0589918643,
0.1209713668,
-0.2499447018,
-0.1342600733,
-0.4160664976,
-0.1545080394,
0.8186528087,
0.3106945455,
0.2331516743,
-0.6540878415,
0.7809793949,
-0.4697819352,
0.1201222613,
0.0702947378,
-0.4515890181,
-0.610702157,
-0.4150276482,
-0.0504248589,
0.96983248,
-0.5626634955,
0.4709707797,
0.1069537029,
-0.619933188,
-0.7043046951,
0.2295477539,
0.2982671559,
0.3079060912,
0.4212035239,
-0.7862348557,
-0.2519555986,
-0.3651798964,
-0.1465906948,
-0.8035126328,
-0.124070175,
0.2760286629,
0.2036956847,
-0.2535609603,
0.5310044885,
-0.7174080014,
-0.1290263087,
-0.0092158243,
0.4108886719,
0.0025311916,
-0.0709979609,
0.843758285,
-0.3936705291,
-0.5911906362,
0.1894907057,
-0.481017828,
-0.5794117451,
-0.0326923206,
0.1847943366,
0.1621201485,
0.3088845909,
0.0017834301,
0.1775128394,
0.558326304,
-0.3997715712,
0.2775046527,
-0.2730517089,
0.1289387196,
-1.1597915888,
-0.1033493355,
-0.0836896747,
-0.3027761877,
-0.6891980171,
0.2922962904,
-0.1444319636,
0.0754881278,
-0.1317607313,
0.5809208751,
-0.1010526419,
0.1049891487,
-0.5830445886,
-0.0023522121,
-0.0589709729,
0.4983594716,
-0.3893400431,
0.694555521,
0.6263150573,
-0.5355315208,
0.5910446644,
-0.0933382213,
-0.2807002068,
1.1493848562,
-0.2278192937,
0.4538222551,
-0.2439585179,
-0.0316179655,
-1.2296984196,
-0.187851429,
0.2935571373,
-0.3447691202,
0.2156104743,
0.5756725073,
0.012408671,
-0.1423445493,
-0.2378235161,
0.3491503,
0.4472695887,
-0.0570527948,
0.4321876168,
0.2403253019,
-0.6666243076,
-0.4405470192,
-0.4798169434,
-0.126784429,
-0.5500437617,
-0.0711681396,
0.1960874498,
-0.6028660536,
-0.6263089776,
-0.1752756536,
-0.1498494744,
-0.3994179964,
0.4219786823,
-0.1521424651,
0.0915612355,
-0.5443755388,
0.3747832775,
-0.0005110933,
0.0648638159,
0.0153102679,
0.0195328221,
0.2805176973,
-0.2661212087,
-0.2233927548,
-0.1705201417,
0.5461803079,
0.70894593,
-0.2326775342,
0.5578212738,
0.5350722671,
-0.526642561,
-0.1088126823,
-0.4580397308,
-0.0404814407,
-0.3983860612,
0.524902761,
-0.4243801534,
-0.7540579438,
0.6932995915,
0.1646915972,
0.1176714003,
0.123645924,
0.7935780883,
-0.5250760913,
0.9811301827,
0.5374545455,
-0.2237526327,
0.5088331699,
0.2975541353,
0.3934994042,
-0.7672338486,
0.5168604851,
-0.3711133003,
-0.4149954915,
-0.5926505923,
-0.5452489853,
0.3408186734,
0.0606696196,
-0.3863509297,
0.0205557682,
-0.2928064466,
0.0967262909,
-0.0524417311,
0.2918607891,
0.1500218809,
-0.2158993036,
0.0947615653,
-0.0545892678,
-0.2681385875,
-0.2160395533,
1.0679891109,
0.3974473774,
0.8332312703,
0.3400651515,
0.2720330656,
0.5297632217,
0.7563669682,
-0.9406616092,
0.3024147153,
-0.0002694677,
-0.6657403111,
-0.4340583682,
-0.1425225437,
-0.7614249587,
0.2076968104,
-0.0083587924,
-1.1772713661,
0.4089639783,
-0.1503722817,
-0.6773629785,
-0.2159740329,
-0.6877689958,
0.3897592127,
-0.5512288213,
-0.2107475251,
-0.1150852516,
-0.4754587114,
-0.0667861402,
-0.6107740998,
0.3248954415,
-0.3155212998,
-0.0333694108,
1.0433090925,
0.0151137039,
0.4274638891,
-0.0944247171,
0.0407955088,
0.1678698808,
0.3065640032,
0.1169970483,
0.1402399689,
-0.3161295652,
-0.7010381818,
0.4943058193,
-0.6286677718,
-1.1575586796,
0.3459495008,
-0.8877930641,
-0.584151566,
-0.7559355497,
-0.7530258894,
-0.6699687243,
0.049577564,
-0.0352254212,
0.0022295832,
-0.3789836466,
-0.0287070479,
0.4118084311,
-0.342756778,
0.1695881039,
1.1192455292,
-0.4790093005,
-0.539963901,
0.7809568644,
0.0764952078,
0.1928156167,
0.4582871497,
0.2859801054,
-0.0105803395,
-0.3692855835,
0.0737562925,
0.2905544639,
-0.5482665896,
-0.1636381894,
-0.2212702781,
0.1146451607,
-0.5596666336,
-0.3524984121,
-0.3491637707,
-0.1664132178,
-0.0303770714,
-0.4621818364,
0.5088889003,
0.4989252985,
-0.1001427248,
0.3744336665,
-0.270644635,
0.3546221852,
0.3485981822,
0.3230132163,
-0.1558552533,
-0.6277377009,
-0.1752047539,
0.0346336439,
-0.4669286013,
-1.2593519688,
0.3250333667,
0.4019840956,
0.1255386174,
0.5964593291,
0.3340221345,
1.0230499506,
-0.1505514681,
0.5202801824,
0.0078947358,
-0.8210378885,
0.6076409221,
-0.1390174627,
0.0076804929,
0.9093968272,
0.3590226471,
-0.7706899643,
-0.4913075864,
-0.4057427347,
-0.6614638567,
0.7198258638,
0.0572359003,
0.1757508516,
-0.0078262379,
0.5871397853,
-0.2509419024,
-0.3920117617,
-0.5486658216,
-0.0713519454,
0.0231496524,
-0.6257066727,
-0.5102732778,
-0.0806880295,
-0.2352456003,
-0.3816883266,
0.6614311934,
-0.5099358559,
0.5681932569,
0.4708954394,
0.0031012169,
-0.3203314841,
0.4408817887,
0.3274289072,
0.8821547031,
-0.6516618729,
0.0921184421,
0.6827281117,
-0.452534169,
0.5184773207,
0.2369945794,
0.1346901059,
-0.2263835222,
0.4879869521,
0.7384661436,
-0.0643487796,
-0.8085035682,
0.3211737573,
-0.2640481293,
0.0270265378,
-0.2545395494,
0.1474548578,
-0.0591484569,
0.4008640945,
0.0650224835,
-0.2078705132,
0.1027716771,
-0.8289178014,
0.1678310782,
-0.0417526513,
-0.7681622505,
-0.4961064756,
0.3560080528,
-0.275516808,
-0.6679234505,
0.5555768609,
-0.1398192793,
-0.0801833346,
0.3220919669,
0.64814955,
0.7423698902,
-0.8399973512,
0.5123397112,
0.0757938102,
0.4677106738,
-0.1202228516,
0.817933917,
-0.0066569806,
-0.8891123533,
-0.0255645681,
-0.7782583833,
-0.532256186,
0.3303409219,
-1.1305503845,
-0.1540122479,
-0.6965156794,
-0.2825268805,
-0.1090011746,
0.2763549685,
-0.3615334928,
0.584040761,
0.0211804807,
0.9360823631,
-1.2392742634,
0.513749361,
1.3045711517,
-0.3062284589,
-0.8392724991,
0.3435817659,
-0.0165750701,
-0.6880823374,
-0.254909873,
-0.1898444593,
0.2104440928,
-0.2477895916,
0.057224486,
-0.9447554946,
0.8364130259,
0.5727086067,
0.0064495271,
0.0942048803,
-0.0407409854,
1.1071697474,
-0.442527622,
0.6781114936,
0.5857954025,
0.3946052492,
-0.1149879918,
-0.719622016,
-0.0299358591,
-0.4627981186,
0.1400979459,
-0.081487909,
-0.5292965174,
0.4882431328,
0.1962642223,
-0.0369518325,
0.1801714599,
0.7310221195,
0.3278988898,
0.7029626966,
0.4273951948,
0.3570400178,
1.205550909,
0.1593748331,
0.9195488691,
-0.3188077509,
0.3313467205,
1.1525533199,
-0.7263404131,
0.9928043485,
0.2508709431,
-0.4393467605,
0.568472147,
0.8907035589,
0.2474933714,
0.3915240169,
0.1205798388,
-0.2034994364,
0.1767131984,
-0.2181674838,
0.0357902907,
0.552933991,
0.636474669,
-0.1931235045,
0.044939246,
0.3897480965,
0.0852218494,
0.1937388927,
0.0310409199,
0.7981488705,
0.1696569026,
-0.7879267931,
0.5055757761,
0.2842034698,
-0.0045518037,
-0.5153390169,
0.3127464056,
-0.6404509544,
0.3546147346,
0.025387492,
-0.5726728439,
0.4802015424,
0.224560976,
-0.1431883574,
-0.1987506151,
0.4967647493,
-0.0320087187,
-1.0150133371,
0.6974158287,
0.7511380911,
0.1424559653,
0.0554811992,
-0.7379245758,
-0.2122859061,
-0.4065964222,
-0.4364531636,
0.4257938564,
0.1922983229,
-0.4050153792,
0.4418534935,
0.3553565145,
0.3476305604,
-0.0055812267,
-0.0647992119,
0.2367599458,
-0.4745778143,
-0.5294457078,
-0.520226419,
0.117129162,
0.3218106925,
-0.3378773928,
0.2988264263,
0.1177695543,
0.6422355175,
0.2421236485,
0.5102406144,
-0.2108704448,
0.5533570647,
-0.2198688388,
0.5349825025,
-0.8812215328,
0.0765980631,
-0.5957573652,
-0.868137598,
-0.3907822669,
0.8687462807,
-0.3415157795,
0.0936641619,
1.0668865442,
0.8933312297,
0.0243670847,
0.0468736924,
0.1774974167,
0.5034022927,
0.2891088724,
0.8514513373,
0.7094962597,
-0.4223779142,
-0.0941695571,
-0.2911523879,
-0.6675620675,
0.1358023286,
-0.309518218,
-0.5923424959,
-0.6968601942,
-0.4366298616,
-0.2006985098,
0.2297156155,
0.9869484305,
0.3661904633,
-0.8768656254,
-0.5721569061,
0.1838022321,
0.0320187993,
-1.0243920088,
-0.2708057463,
0.6242909431,
-0.1055510193,
-0.4838574529,
0.4292525053,
0.4959296882,
-0.3077374697,
0.0654481128,
-0.0173666533,
-0.2873131633,
0.4491082728,
0.5261961222,
0.3075240552,
-0.5540077686,
-0.4369514287,
0.154968068,
-0.031754002,
0.1067711189,
0.3781972826,
-0.4138716459,
0.6793138385,
0.5838313103,
0.6926833391,
-0.0260553006,
0.1640908867,
0.5701117516,
-0.3246317208,
-0.0860133544,
0.2396818101,
0.276964426,
0.2239351869,
-0.4555230439,
0.4268650711,
0.2051745355,
-0.2535584569,
-0.9012728333,
0.1275095642,
-0.9795656204,
-0.2497235388,
0.6290898323,
-0.4113495052,
-0.0490479283,
-0.0924892426,
-0.2660886943,
0.1091814339,
-0.0973865688,
1.244504571,
0.9664912224,
-0.5011437535,
-0.4728085101,
-0.3789916337,
0.1731289625,
0.7739270329,
-0.8994652629,
-0.2125423551,
0.1063668206,
0.2437646389,
0.3225516379,
1.1052079201,
0.0421673469,
0.5997460485,
-0.419400692,
-0.4010387361,
0.663789928,
-0.2867922187,
-0.4758836329,
0.3204706311,
0.2379114479,
0.0870464295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06453v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06453v3
|
DocGen: Generating Detailed Parameter Docstrings in Python
| 2023-11-11T01:14:37 | 2023-11-17T22:30:27 |
Vatsal Venkatkrishna, Durga Shree Nagabushanam, Emmanuel Iko-Ojo Simon, Melina Vidoni
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Documentation debt hinders the effective utilization of open-source software.
Although code summarization tools have been helpful for developers, most would
prefer a detailed account of each parameter in a function rather than a
high-level summary. However, generating such a summary is too intricate for a
single generative model to produce reliably due to the lack of high-quality
training data. Thus, we propose a multi-step approach that combines multiple
task-specific models, each adept at producing a specific section of a
docstring. The combination of these models ensures the inclusion of each
section in the final docstring. We compared the results from our approach with
existing generative models using both automatic metrics and a human-centred
evaluation with 17 participating developers, which proves the superiority of
our approach over existing methods.
|
[
-0.2946650386,
-0.4200870097,
0.4591703415,
0.2693470418,
-0.3541656137,
-0.2299415916,
-0.2404282391,
-0.1177724004,
-0.0696284249,
0.4706954062,
-0.2730234861,
-0.8050307631,
-0.4556597471,
0.2334288061,
-0.6943921447,
1.2744476795,
-0.2265209705,
-0.2713110149,
-0.3670440018,
0.1181930825,
0.1538808197,
-0.0966432542,
-0.6070670485,
-0.2578078806,
0.4980036318,
0.4476333261,
0.3661915958,
0.6017062664,
0.4921247959,
0.2467769831,
0.0134846866,
0.2370787263,
-0.066997841,
0.3679199219,
0.2617468834,
-0.3325720727,
-0.6836809516,
0.2797320485,
0.3162723184,
0.7069042325,
-0.294705689,
0.2400901914,
0.0977534279,
0.2341544777,
-0.3027157187,
0.4104979038,
-0.2044873387,
-0.0001629685,
0.234445855,
-0.2341799736,
0.0143776769,
-0.396096617,
0.1643734872,
-0.8734850287,
0.9035486579,
-0.3671129346,
0.6510737538,
0.2660548091,
-0.2855914831,
-0.4045615494,
-0.5540527701,
0.4766407609,
-0.9545025826,
-0.053789448,
0.1980799735,
-0.1183050573,
-0.0626983717,
-0.9153998494,
-0.0789857805,
-0.4399831593,
-0.1612402201,
0.3085471094,
0.2186805904,
0.3628178239,
0.3982655704,
0.5190073252,
-0.5804915428,
-0.0505559668,
-0.7890007496,
-0.2663813233,
0.6705502868,
0.4978834987,
0.0626380891,
-0.2047001272,
-0.1959861517,
-0.0425723568,
-0.5282060504,
0.0459461734,
0.6966495514,
0.2066610157,
-0.1897957027,
0.588960588,
-0.3278210759,
0.9244759083,
0.1220471561,
-0.2940082252,
-0.0359602608,
-0.7192574739,
0.0703475252,
-0.1435593665,
0.9778675437,
0.4122821987,
0.1973335147,
-0.3053880632,
-0.1469049603,
-0.0204209462,
0.6821355224,
-1.0201423168,
-0.4397988617,
0.8051983118,
-0.5036338568,
-0.5147891641,
0.1716606319,
-0.6586909294,
-0.5186998844,
-0.4360221326,
-0.2922133207,
-0.5388199687,
-0.4111922085,
-0.014609444,
-0.5883626938,
-0.0081030773,
0.4978286624,
-0.8388977647,
0.0397496372,
0.7049267888,
0.965216279,
0.0652722269,
-0.6231837869,
-0.5112038851,
0.1575211585,
-0.3431339562,
0.8652824759,
-0.6831496358,
-0.6831396818,
-0.170909062,
-0.2871396244,
0.1575143933,
-0.3639527559,
0.4348308146,
0.2150427997,
0.2609924972,
0.1738725454,
-0.4915732145,
-0.0823086277,
0.0972345546,
-0.5498476624,
0.9916753769,
0.7694777846,
-0.9633663893,
0.4250119328,
-0.7399582863,
-0.4283721447,
0.221993804,
-0.3257739544,
-0.4145650566,
0.4774418473,
0.0320456512,
0.5738908648,
-0.3642684519,
0.139138326,
-0.181425795,
-0.3524384797,
0.0320342667,
-0.0950321108,
0.5340329409,
0.3568075299,
-0.0758598074,
0.4331516623,
-0.9789663553,
-0.1293990463,
-0.2109484673,
-0.8871888518,
-0.4991428554,
-0.0800145268,
0.1456530094,
0.2668833733,
0.2937895954,
-0.3820100427,
0.5159890056,
-0.3206259906,
0.5498683453,
0.4657937884,
-0.0831668749,
0.450147897,
-0.0375129655,
0.8450338244,
0.0100001656,
0.1059826016,
-0.6345475316,
-0.5174936056,
-0.4189507067,
-0.2194289565,
0.3381807208,
0.2088995874,
-0.243659541,
0.2623421848,
-0.0478216931,
-0.7893358469,
-0.5415170789,
0.306542635,
0.6278622746,
0.5187340975,
-0.0792779252,
-0.5201274753,
-0.3378213644,
-0.5406367779,
-0.1819974333,
-0.4665330052,
-0.4283440411,
0.1813902706,
0.4073205888,
0.0131782256,
0.7512438297,
-0.7935458422,
-0.1989677995,
-0.1423770189,
0.7042181492,
0.4071036279,
0.5810763836,
0.5133051276,
-0.7258104682,
-0.2153301835,
0.0436840765,
-0.5937458873,
0.0124059282,
-0.2747270763,
0.1829353571,
-0.1392728984,
0.4244491458,
-0.8762226105,
0.18528606,
0.3704235554,
-0.6909959912,
1.035253644,
-0.8587577939,
0.1736945808,
-1.1647629738,
0.3228479922,
0.3307082653,
0.0168168172,
-0.7320619822,
0.594106853,
0.2857297063,
-0.2546509206,
-0.2443145216,
0.1700927764,
-0.4597905278,
0.0627065152,
-0.0669366345,
-0.1509272307,
0.1312839687,
0.1903061122,
0.0173727162,
0.8618263602,
0.7327016592,
-0.7520021796,
0.6916515827,
0.1200132817,
-0.205564484,
0.6809931397,
-0.9533337355,
0.0000413609,
-0.0620737672,
0.1583258361,
-0.8878316283,
-0.4775652587,
0.2649067342,
-0.4205763638,
0.2520079613,
-0.3986894488,
-0.6207184792,
-0.4960113764,
-0.2855564952,
0.2002179176,
0.5223960876,
-0.0012670297,
0.5999376774,
0.0290075894,
-0.4307145178,
-0.0935406387,
-0.4158343077,
0.2078875005,
-0.6033450961,
-0.7416678667,
0.5253129005,
-0.0896346197,
-0.2228846103,
-0.0260748453,
-0.2326382846,
-0.1024658978,
0.1947970688,
0.3554334044,
-0.010218353,
-0.249639228,
-0.1174758971,
0.0283030253,
-0.3706163168,
0.1974306852,
-0.6281577945,
0.3542018235,
0.0654695183,
-0.2931482196,
-0.0334112868,
0.7560254931,
0.7096306682,
-0.673312366,
0.2726826072,
0.8265859485,
-0.0619838275,
-0.2979554236,
-0.1879223138,
0.0965381116,
-0.4383448064,
0.2512058318,
-0.2698733807,
-0.3323256969,
0.451168716,
-0.2325675637,
0.3921820819,
0.3721252084,
0.3718985319,
-0.1718576252,
0.9407569766,
0.6274672151,
0.3190174699,
0.3304135501,
-0.3542252481,
0.033618167,
-0.6933850646,
-0.4040640891,
-0.7886416912,
0.2584606409,
-0.3433571756,
-0.4856347144,
0.4380781054,
0.3128722012,
0.0454475246,
0.501115799,
-0.7560402751,
0.2540652752,
0.8299375176,
-0.0420803018,
0.1113739461,
0.1500423402,
-0.152520895,
0.4500380158,
-0.5570291877,
-0.5358905792,
1.2571593523,
-0.0574828908,
1.0356744528,
-0.1208211929,
1.1652345657,
0.1911215186,
-0.0812526867,
-0.6519666314,
0.2976281643,
-0.3859944344,
-0.1570384055,
-0.3893218338,
-0.4805357754,
-0.8803268671,
0.2854191959,
0.2808482945,
-0.4636235535,
-0.0921554118,
0.1527441442,
-0.6277996302,
-0.0947000086,
-0.8044651151,
0.8234303594,
-0.0784278363,
-0.1771491021,
-0.2584489882,
-0.4452510476,
0.280719012,
-0.1429821998,
0.1971277744,
-0.0737150684,
-0.1272678524,
0.8479878306,
-0.7033874989,
0.7893218994,
-0.2659689784,
-0.626706779,
0.202704519,
-0.2051586658,
0.4445369542,
0.1974235326,
-0.1972304732,
-0.1606383622,
0.0179323815,
-0.4383804202,
-0.3066795766,
0.6899704933,
-0.40650177,
-0.6956667304,
-0.2799325883,
-0.8641674519,
0.1095893979,
0.3036677837,
0.3073852062,
0.6897790432,
-0.0707391128,
-0.2596820891,
0.6180711985,
-0.2712583244,
0.5973729491,
0.4607068896,
0.2216372043,
-0.3547279835,
0.8422062993,
-0.0078154085,
0.0337285325,
-0.2432970554,
0.1750310808,
-0.0726773143,
-0.6613649726,
-0.4827675223,
0.1348015517,
-0.7301291823,
0.0543173254,
-0.4454807639,
0.0271462053,
-0.6609079838,
-0.140539214,
-0.1175449118,
-0.4265429974,
-0.5678778887,
-0.1338874251,
0.4529726803,
1.0246332884,
0.0176202692,
0.0321752131,
-0.9899382591,
0.8032414913,
0.1193544194,
0.5658271313,
-0.1598500609,
-0.0681880116,
-0.3112607002,
-0.0960544869,
-0.286051482,
-0.847967267,
0.1725224108,
0.233361721,
0.6643376946,
0.6153727174,
0.1632526964,
0.6764739752,
-0.310035795,
1.0122835636,
0.5777345896,
-0.7149785757,
0.6789149642,
-0.5076023936,
0.4932841957,
0.1803950667,
0.1489887238,
-0.4892413616,
-1.0173726082,
-0.6113187075,
-1.1694660187,
0.8312550187,
0.2828615308,
0.2271934301,
0.2594602406,
0.3262991607,
0.4393681586,
-0.0011928169,
-0.0121997371,
-0.2034284174,
-0.4953500926,
-0.2479347438,
-0.13097471,
-0.1403861791,
-0.3196943104,
-0.2961633801,
0.2276542336,
-0.1593655944,
0.169964999,
0.0970162675,
0.0041259513,
0.1463564336,
0.1721759588,
0.7369601727,
0.9868236184,
-0.1536561996,
0.2010735869,
-0.2780445814,
-0.5407887101,
0.1007579118,
0.4472303092,
-0.1288266778,
0.3805547953,
0.4997524321,
0.4931592047,
-0.0445030555,
-0.3715111911,
0.4269924462,
-0.0635095686,
-0.4857670665,
-0.3466134369,
0.3666622341,
0.3291092515,
0.1491939574,
0.3348507583,
0.1641895622,
0.1781805009,
-0.1169725135,
0.2473860383,
0.0224513933,
-0.3290000558,
-0.329351604,
0.9203830957,
0.4342422783,
-0.1737259924,
0.6856827736,
-0.1900038123,
-0.0495759547,
1.0944122076,
0.4301629663,
0.9507651925,
-0.2762270272,
0.6123487353,
0.4999749362,
0.0762239322,
-0.0755947977,
0.5364046693,
-0.4142950773,
0.1443579346,
-0.4331570864,
-0.7192599773,
-0.2314466238,
-0.1739762276,
-0.7135463953,
0.1057718694,
-0.1677835435,
-0.0378408842,
-0.019674968,
-0.2735931873,
-0.6134053469,
0.2434204668,
-0.056819167,
0.9357383847,
-0.8210858703,
0.8063561916,
0.9041523337,
-1.0416892767,
-0.6301919818,
0.0983846411,
-0.3084295392,
-0.1940730512,
0.3764026165,
0.1199722588,
0.117058292,
-0.0840843245,
-0.3434905708,
-0.6009919643,
1.058152914,
0.2895037234,
-0.3119839728,
-0.600092113,
0.0849273875,
0.6824577451,
-0.2798998058,
0.3389229178,
0.4451896548,
0.5186504126,
-0.1557243466,
-0.7649258971,
0.2224815935,
-0.4865855575,
0.1493749022,
0.0289023668,
-0.3150951266,
1.0853910446,
-0.4960762262,
-0.1524158418,
0.2050455064,
0.443911165,
0.3238133192,
0.1456722468,
0.26945135,
0.2932496369,
0.7984214425,
-0.1723264158,
1.2742948532,
-0.6960622668,
0.4275059998,
0.8298923373,
0.2812012732,
0.2578890026,
0.4390900135,
-0.3572691977,
0.2339075953,
0.8322681785,
-0.3875648081,
0.3579165041,
0.4639861286,
-0.1353444457,
-0.2876006067,
-0.002374124,
-0.5255286098,
0.1533934623,
0.3306344748,
-0.5713960528,
-0.4699326456,
-0.2071348876,
0.0750189349,
-0.3077954948,
-0.3415392637,
0.792355299,
0.189907372,
-0.9852445722,
0.6217496395,
0.2034072876,
0.6633384228,
-0.7659058571,
-0.2061716318,
-0.5030020475,
-0.0498098433,
-0.5610243678,
-0.7465720773,
0.3010385931,
0.4016801119,
-0.0992042795,
-0.4155280292,
0.4018986821,
-0.4828367233,
-0.6125623584,
0.0734667554,
0.1703069508,
0.3470867574,
-0.2005066127,
-0.4962032139,
-0.5073020458,
-0.2346324772,
-0.2687388659,
0.0425592773,
0.3597217798,
0.1700058877,
0.4319528341,
0.6650247574,
0.1818646193,
0.22049959,
0.2561403513,
0.7598470449,
-0.5968567133,
-0.6625656486,
-0.6276699305,
0.7945511937,
-0.1188438088,
-0.6171100736,
0.742713511,
0.569686234,
0.6696463823,
-0.3584689498,
1.2411087751,
-0.3092474639,
-0.1105881706,
-0.4213598073,
0.7514108419,
-0.6252384186,
0.2227059305,
-0.3841746449,
-0.7637165189,
-0.1681806445,
0.253996551,
0.3247747421,
-0.1487482488,
0.7033759952,
0.6700414419,
-0.3120227754,
-0.2458529472,
0.149871096,
-0.1193991899,
0.468960762,
0.5514302254,
0.7915527821,
-0.0409674309,
0.9331608415,
-0.2629220188,
-0.09441939,
-0.1168848723,
-0.6751198173,
-0.7988488674,
-0.8424773216,
-0.5999836326,
-0.3821733594,
-0.3388796449,
0.4359818399,
0.7696279287,
-0.771302402,
-0.2561201155,
-0.4746484756,
-0.0112361694,
-0.6542432308,
-0.1477916092,
0.4543171525,
-0.6865986586,
-0.7903855443,
0.2209748328,
0.2135821134,
-0.0923463106,
-0.5088301301,
-0.2346694618,
0.4042865038,
-0.058775939,
0.3736967444,
0.0353154764,
-1.0014066696,
0.1662315577,
-0.3564411402,
-0.2593275309,
0.078575179,
1.2129905224,
-0.4415265322,
0.4485718906,
0.7858718634,
0.1292053759,
0.508723855,
0.1515230536,
0.9103865027,
-0.6525517106,
-0.1893708557,
-0.0543983988,
0.4681769013,
0.1757742465,
-0.3416718543,
0.5738919377,
0.0056320326,
-0.1455596387,
-0.5912946463,
0.3751931489,
-0.7611205578,
-0.60367769,
1.4124470949,
-0.7122277021,
0.0401520878,
-0.3448827565,
-0.3638402224,
0.4326176047,
-0.5299814343,
0.8313939571,
0.4792437553,
-0.1826245636,
-0.014621092,
-0.1274690777,
0.3711613119,
-0.0766787529,
-0.8629338741,
0.2572493255,
0.6722166538,
0.5136085153,
0.2946211696,
0.4943263829,
0.0432384536,
0.392449379,
0.638051033,
0.0733859241,
-0.5764812231,
-0.2751616836,
-0.3479536176,
0.6312742829,
0.1771284342,
-0.1137856245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06446v1
|
THOS: A Benchmark Dataset for Targeted Hate and Offensive Speech
| 2023-11-11T00:30:31 | 2023-11-11T00:30:31 |
Saad Almohaimeed, Saleh Almohaimeed, Ashfaq Ali Shafin, Bogdan Carbunar, Ladislau Bölöni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Detecting harmful content on social media, such as Twitter, is made difficult
by the fact that the seemingly simple yes/no classification conceals a
significant amount of complexity. Unfortunately, while several datasets have
been collected for training classifiers in hate and offensive speech, there is
a scarcity of datasets labeled with a finer granularity of target classes and
specific targets. In this paper, we introduce THOS, a dataset of 8.3k tweets
manually labeled with fine-grained annotations about the target of the message.
We demonstrate that this dataset makes it feasible to train classifiers, based
on Large Language Models, to perform classification at this level of
granularity.
|
[
-0.3009108901,
-0.6799978614,
-0.0072305663,
-0.1796491593,
-0.16720137,
0.0373368897,
-0.1762860268,
-0.4000639319,
0.0532596,
0.3854866624,
-0.2416513264,
-0.4315341115,
-0.9856523871,
-0.1044592261,
-1.0011988878,
1.3198543787,
0.4482231438,
-0.1602068245,
0.5607920885,
-0.4100075364,
-0.1441253573,
-0.5142020583,
-0.8351330757,
0.1872684956,
0.858161509,
0.3825355768,
0.4741259217,
0.656991303,
0.3882039785,
0.3613323867,
-0.0005935719,
0.0398744829,
-0.7084450126,
0.1966667473,
-0.2730292678,
-0.0979943722,
0.1185290515,
0.135891974,
0.4125491381,
0.5010865927,
0.2747640908,
0.4509583116,
-0.0292396359,
0.2085828781,
-0.781694293,
-0.2029902786,
-0.7345933318,
0.0428436995,
-0.5246598721,
0.1202702969,
-0.2168179899,
-0.6290336251,
0.0864226446,
-0.2025246769,
0.27598387,
-0.0326623544,
0.4405117035,
0.0688693747,
-0.4620240033,
-0.3822799921,
-0.6758556366,
1.099758029,
-0.3972115517,
0.3808751106,
0.4373217821,
0.5901743174,
0.1902778745,
-0.5610104203,
-0.4291621745,
0.1215694249,
0.1114611924,
-0.4747948945,
-0.3687168658,
0.0357105508,
0.3538987339,
0.3290225863,
-0.1339340508,
0.3415192664,
-0.5929160714,
-0.5632964969,
0.9281719327,
0.1724187434,
0.2620830536,
-0.4158088267,
-0.2103405893,
0.1327712387,
0.0324868634,
-0.2382050455,
0.2819173932,
0.7269361019,
-0.1226258576,
0.5638647676,
-0.2584117651,
0.6801502109,
0.0484217815,
-0.2937558889,
0.3160354793,
0.189315021,
-0.31844455,
0.0141450604,
0.8749825358,
0.5489658117,
0.5629128814,
-0.469658643,
-0.4391546845,
0.5714350343,
0.4918963611,
-0.8139463663,
-0.160179913,
0.2199376225,
-0.2583706677,
-0.7018873096,
-0.3048709929,
-0.7030285597,
-0.8689622879,
-0.1893301159,
0.6450681686,
-0.4394101501,
-0.0145577732,
-0.184103474,
-0.4459084868,
-0.0703196824,
0.35111624,
-0.6464785337,
0.3014089465,
0.5172348022,
0.8069232702,
0.2105039805,
-0.057800632,
-0.9281850457,
0.1351819932,
-0.5156849027,
0.6026258469,
-0.7028087378,
-0.0363074057,
0.2722621262,
-0.3745354712,
0.4212334752,
-0.4854258597,
0.8312984705,
-0.5384931564,
0.1140582412,
-0.407951206,
-0.6032865644,
-0.0644399971,
0.5051069856,
-0.3763383329,
1.1419067383,
0.5262463689,
-1.0754637718,
0.452246964,
-0.4516452849,
-0.6303344369,
0.1919267774,
-0.3028960228,
-0.4187172949,
0.1712827533,
-0.2169549614,
0.8205296397,
-0.0555613339,
0.4104371965,
-0.6109626889,
-0.3220849037,
-0.1024563834,
-0.2822170258,
0.790738523,
0.4873815477,
-0.5671105385,
0.2162396461,
-0.6716758013,
-0.0558919124,
0.1854638755,
-0.227846086,
-0.6372355223,
-0.0841949359,
0.3975243568,
0.4944911599,
-0.0782354474,
-0.884527564,
-0.0497435443,
0.1207856387,
0.5447848439,
0.9966866374,
-0.2508566678,
0.181785509,
-0.5903605819,
0.0860534608,
-0.0704230741,
0.2940815985,
0.541021347,
-0.3010590971,
-0.6447033882,
-0.2651708722,
-0.0189523529,
0.2827684879,
-0.7848362923,
0.2682985067,
-0.3368721306,
-0.7080879807,
-0.3638776243,
0.0034439883,
0.4129466116,
0.5729426742,
0.3977146447,
-0.027403038,
-0.9192019701,
-0.9509484768,
-0.5083588362,
-0.2017487735,
-0.1857593954,
0.2450651079,
0.3103049994,
-0.0847586468,
0.7652813196,
-0.1478877515,
-0.5356680155,
-0.0520601347,
0.4055265784,
-0.504704535,
0.1193725616,
0.5928895473,
-1.0122115612,
-0.5483151674,
-0.3266433477,
-0.6702497005,
-0.4494518042,
0.3733623326,
0.1515378505,
-0.3123209774,
0.7148018479,
0.2026581317,
0.4039852023,
0.4300005436,
-0.265209794,
0.5006081462,
0.5194558501,
0.3118298948,
-1.0957812071,
-0.2937675118,
0.4097421765,
-0.4902232885,
-0.9824758768,
-0.3203480542,
-0.1143152118,
-0.0827957913,
-0.8728833199,
0.5193852782,
0.2467341721,
0.1871734709,
-0.2564201355,
0.0042397045,
-0.3031418025,
0.129780069,
-0.0518931262,
0.5954074264,
0.5578325987,
-0.7626028061,
0.3790252507,
0.1679900438,
-0.2676382363,
1.0035529137,
-0.251534909,
0.1289308965,
-0.2133165747,
0.1814846992,
-0.627414763,
-0.6083438396,
0.2802625895,
-0.208182767,
0.0086082621,
-0.1982989609,
-0.636541307,
-0.6708443165,
-0.5621660352,
0.5955758095,
0.2106255442,
-0.442445755,
0.4551127553,
0.8472031355,
0.5026257634,
-0.3510324657,
-0.8189868927,
0.1665759534,
-0.7062414885,
-0.1679275334,
0.1630372256,
0.084120445,
-0.3417674601,
-0.2048478276,
0.0956985131,
-0.1852232069,
-0.0131202992,
0.4627523422,
-0.4191557169,
0.098046273,
0.4007535279,
-0.4449241459,
0.1952348799,
-0.0144028934,
-0.2845982611,
0.5810967684,
0.0059886593,
0.0626875982,
-0.5130872726,
0.4325439334,
0.5118586421,
0.1861941665,
0.5958999991,
0.796038866,
-0.6681334972,
-0.3364042342,
-0.6420991421,
0.079895325,
-0.4874202311,
0.4028120339,
-0.1982470602,
-1.0129996538,
0.2427685708,
0.1336880624,
0.239406094,
0.5704637766,
0.3781145215,
-0.1062037796,
0.9302994609,
0.4342805445,
-0.7148164511,
0.683750689,
-0.1916362047,
0.1263846606,
-0.2942368388,
-0.2042079419,
-0.830996573,
-0.464247793,
-0.6609433293,
-0.3647598326,
0.0669100434,
-0.2032677084,
-0.7919310331,
0.4646806419,
-0.7413244247,
0.4977937341,
0.3774928749,
0.2180262506,
-0.152249828,
-0.0389548279,
0.5043314099,
-0.0913296118,
-0.4614757299,
-0.6558510065,
1.0747456551,
0.3410902917,
0.5116436481,
0.1871391684,
0.7102794051,
0.9424992204,
0.6521465182,
-0.8201716542,
0.6052467227,
-0.5483012795,
-1.0390355587,
-0.3536832929,
-0.5710905194,
-0.7131863832,
-0.1800115407,
0.024899818,
-1.1843445301,
0.0337617658,
0.0783879459,
-0.108291246,
0.9648554325,
-0.6882975698,
0.5729834437,
0.00794423,
-0.164190039,
0.0679528639,
-0.4434380531,
0.2623908818,
-0.3905898035,
0.6880075932,
-0.1835074872,
-0.1370577067,
1.3342056274,
-0.3503914475,
1.093849659,
-0.2621586025,
-0.1456507593,
0.3331337869,
0.0829041973,
0.268289417,
-0.5136787891,
-0.3215779364,
0.1716811955,
-0.3301866055,
-0.5341293812,
-0.0597885102,
0.5697180629,
-0.5201188326,
-0.2296658158,
-0.2848065794,
-0.6356342435,
-0.3099104464,
0.3193524778,
0.432223171,
0.5392059088,
-0.0950063765,
0.1292254925,
0.6447646618,
0.0214965381,
0.2032422125,
0.1387025118,
-0.0507422015,
-0.2278150469,
1.1179978848,
0.3238314688,
0.0948250294,
0.0512143262,
0.2784053385,
-0.1994053423,
-0.6429417729,
-0.2996975482,
-0.2422250509,
-0.71935004,
-0.4754498899,
-0.8639439344,
-0.3736768961,
-0.4139704406,
-0.2330844998,
-0.3434219956,
-0.120065771,
-0.172058031,
0.101967141,
0.3964344859,
1.2525368929,
-0.2603390813,
0.5951310396,
-0.5038288236,
0.7071917057,
0.4857011735,
0.6907179952,
-0.1120354086,
-0.9487215877,
-0.1388198882,
0.111417003,
-0.3439499736,
-1.0572696924,
-0.0294799209,
0.174559623,
0.097594209,
0.7407435179,
0.3428349495,
0.6739172935,
-0.4456190169,
0.6150768399,
0.1374821216,
-0.8226168752,
0.6915481091,
-0.5444272161,
-0.166759342,
0.6577535868,
0.7067068219,
-0.7847768068,
-0.5740334392,
-0.7875577807,
-0.3343726695,
0.8989448547,
0.2669322193,
0.5160335302,
-0.4256308377,
0.1022556871,
0.1535059959,
0.273447901,
-0.7111778259,
-0.4178564548,
-0.1470970958,
-0.3158381283,
-0.0548863858,
-0.3949430585,
-0.2082559317,
-0.1876287311,
0.5884186625,
0.1586440355,
0.0069427355,
-0.4074449837,
-0.0013618751,
-0.2556770146,
0.1561424434,
-0.0158044063,
0.2814582586,
-0.1923418045,
0.1890790761,
0.2148658335,
-0.4901471734,
0.1921405643,
-0.0984088778,
-0.2391301095,
-0.0310774911,
0.3941858411,
0.4137108922,
0.0879191905,
-0.5350986123,
0.629863739,
0.0666447356,
-0.3526503742,
0.1422276348,
0.151394099,
-0.3066222966,
0.3705965281,
0.3932504952,
-0.1248904169,
0.4053123891,
-0.539093852,
0.5130845308,
0.2660316825,
-0.5436566472,
-0.2085857689,
0.5465425849,
0.1005062908,
-0.6834180355,
0.1974801421,
-0.4022112489,
-0.9504919648,
0.2423691899,
0.1788640469,
0.7119842172,
-0.4451342225,
0.5361692309,
0.4758745134,
0.2639776468,
0.0546479486,
0.206765309,
-0.0412007198,
-0.499240011,
0.0563242435,
-0.7593339086,
-0.1659727097,
0.6993721128,
-0.5859642029,
0.3219454885,
-0.7421616316,
-0.3056110442,
0.6445269585,
-0.0401090533,
-0.8286803961,
0.8157366514,
0.4064697921,
0.6960759163,
-1.4016221762,
0.5767476559,
0.4618151188,
-0.1298022866,
-0.565785408,
0.1012862921,
0.2510327995,
-0.682097137,
0.5618107915,
0.4621940255,
0.121868372,
-0.1006679088,
-0.8219439387,
-0.4930396676,
0.1226853579,
0.1874630451,
-0.4657669961,
0.1945786327,
0.4572339356,
0.6629873514,
-0.1495674253,
-0.1757979989,
0.5902090073,
0.2364318818,
-0.0628159344,
-0.8021752238,
-0.0542006642,
-0.0381062478,
-0.1799170524,
0.469219327,
-0.6298726797,
0.7386596799,
0.0688684732,
-0.2094491273,
-0.466463089,
0.4953476787,
-0.1390670091,
0.4319225252,
0.8207907081,
0.6304674149,
0.6804111004,
-0.1852570921,
0.8899841309,
0.5715985894,
0.1724874824,
1.096143961,
0.3922534585,
0.6764360666,
0.1927215457,
-0.3392732143,
0.1710441113,
0.7402396202,
-0.0171185993,
0.5313335657,
0.561384201,
-0.3445928693,
-0.264428407,
-0.6395144463,
-0.1130051836,
0.4081839919,
0.5436205864,
-0.262616992,
-0.516462326,
0.3548519909,
-0.0567749217,
0.2868793905,
-0.6369971037,
0.9042214155,
-0.0968637615,
0.0588086993,
0.4925001562,
0.1336043626,
0.8458834887,
-0.2887961566,
0.3611275256,
0.1690754294,
-0.0696061105,
-0.3310554922,
-0.9462505579,
0.5360631943,
0.4046204388,
-0.0119031221,
0.0422910675,
0.7915555835,
-0.1130506992,
-0.4486203492,
0.3193145394,
0.0049415762,
0.3171913326,
-0.3251470625,
-0.7338953614,
0.2062436193,
0.0244662296,
-0.0506471545,
0.2081011385,
0.8158320785,
-0.4780135155,
0.7730733156,
0.3605254889,
-0.0168197192,
0.2514897585,
0.2604799867,
1.0778944492,
-0.6038836837,
-0.4290735424,
-0.6879650354,
0.1752933413,
-0.3582264185,
-0.3872182667,
0.7019377351,
0.7182766795,
1.1552246809,
0.4368642569,
1.0281603336,
-0.3742466271,
0.9029468894,
0.1957509816,
0.2644034326,
-0.6523278952,
0.0446710624,
-0.4449424148,
-0.6584605575,
-0.4034056962,
0.3692673445,
-0.730039537,
0.3584506214,
0.1137156412,
0.3749566972,
-0.3943854272,
0.1898857504,
0.4674164057,
0.3195682466,
0.3985325694,
0.1713922173,
0.7147524357,
-0.5337973237,
0.7246372104,
-0.6876698136,
-0.1097769067,
-0.3713058531,
-0.6090666056,
-1.3353794813,
-0.6447088718,
-0.3999085128,
-0.6218751669,
0.1627372652,
0.7112604976,
0.8052355647,
-1.0857409239,
0.0935884416,
0.0977012515,
-0.2709288597,
0.284122169,
-0.2166988999,
0.4171658158,
-0.3022132516,
-0.8166217804,
-0.0662039965,
0.0889298096,
0.1697829664,
-0.1274924874,
0.134455651,
-0.3304958045,
0.1309783012,
0.5915805101,
0.242644012,
-0.5488913655,
-0.6403264999,
-0.5367225409,
-0.386426568,
-0.1104450822,
0.5034980774,
-0.5844942927,
0.384270519,
0.131192252,
0.7494806051,
0.2175252289,
-0.0196276326,
-0.0364498384,
-1.1664824486,
0.2530295253,
0.4884011745,
0.0955839604,
0.5489166975,
-0.286270082,
0.3969915509,
0.0697768778,
-0.2580506802,
-1.0036416054,
0.15634799,
-0.728788197,
-0.3534619212,
1.2179751396,
0.2593125403,
-0.1801600754,
-0.6254826784,
-0.2728919387,
0.6105601788,
-0.4952772558,
1.2383933067,
0.5726639628,
0.5108581185,
0.1723579317,
-0.5568476319,
0.6955420375,
0.2037918419,
-0.8053044081,
0.1600786,
0.6234920621,
0.2202816159,
0.062433064,
0.566861093,
0.1696878821,
0.1179845557,
0.00631592,
-0.2824239135,
0.234316051,
-0.2776858807,
-0.0409116298,
0.415327549,
-0.3600269854,
-0.5105907917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06440v1
|
Separating the Wheat from the Chaff with BREAD: An open-source benchmark and metrics to detect redundancy in text
| 2023-11-11T00:11:50 | 2023-11-11T00:11:50 |
Isaac Caswell, Lisa Wang, Isabel Papadimitriou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Data quality is a problem that perpetually resurfaces throughout the field of
NLP, regardless of task, domain, or architecture, and remains especially severe
for lower-resource languages. A typical and insidious issue, affecting both
training data and model output, is data that is repetitive and dominated by
linguistically uninteresting boilerplate, such as price catalogs or
computer-generated log files. Though this problem permeates many web-scraped
corpora, there has yet to be a benchmark to test against, or a systematic study
to find simple metrics that generalize across languages and agree with human
judgements of data quality. In the present work, we create and release BREAD, a
human-labeled benchmark on repetitive boilerplate vs. plausible linguistic
content, spanning 360 languages. We release several baseline CRED (Character
REDundancy) scores along with it, and evaluate their effectiveness on BREAD. We
hope that the community will use this resource to develop better filtering
methods, and that our reference implementations of CRED scores can become
standard corpus evaluation tools, driving the development of cleaner language
modeling corpora, especially in low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.3173336983,
-0.5916307569,
0.2367803752,
0.2417773753,
-0.2305597216,
0.2442409098,
-0.4236741066,
-0.6332099438,
0.0896433294,
0.4704659581,
-0.1501191407,
-0.7242671251,
-0.7260264754,
0.1859606802,
-0.8444542289,
1.0244773626,
-0.0760393739,
-0.0117818955,
-0.3710351586,
-0.3235590458,
-0.4885265529,
-0.4564305544,
-0.427346617,
-0.2147054374,
0.4927806258,
0.5948399901,
0.8713906407,
0.858894825,
0.6867951751,
0.2567561865,
0.0433413237,
0.017687317,
-0.4666237831,
0.2221418768,
-0.3609527349,
-0.3895570338,
-0.1827046126,
0.162215814,
0.4637293518,
1.0423794985,
-0.0811507627,
0.3532988727,
0.3065448999,
0.8355609775,
-0.8158837557,
0.0264272466,
-0.5821290612,
-0.033066012,
-0.6198031306,
0.0920981914,
-0.3195266724,
-0.5232169032,
-0.2401453257,
-0.4785418808,
0.5240648985,
0.0105370441,
1.3076777458,
0.3061704934,
0.154164046,
-0.3504253924,
-0.5600725412,
1.0939221382,
-0.6588432193,
0.6755167246,
0.5907524228,
0.1285887063,
-0.025930021,
-0.5881546736,
-0.4787628651,
-0.0032537614,
-0.2282092124,
0.0942811146,
-0.4427162707,
-0.6492320895,
-0.1501348019,
0.521438241,
-0.8085559011,
-0.0264006201,
-0.3575765491,
0.0795144886,
0.3952244222,
0.0004524029,
0.5383514762,
0.0195867866,
-0.3753076494,
-0.3116164207,
-0.291464895,
-0.1155991554,
0.5110496879,
0.3804280758,
-0.0329752676,
0.4735979736,
-0.1597374976,
0.595802784,
-0.3146644533,
0.0848287493,
0.4427487254,
-0.5091513991,
-0.2163336426,
-0.1443077475,
0.657669425,
0.3757247329,
0.3326304853,
-0.3325151503,
-0.3953597546,
0.560960114,
0.5990788937,
-0.0870519876,
-0.7093303204,
0.1923618764,
-0.4202566445,
-0.0654360279,
0.0655624196,
-1.1244310141,
-0.1191634685,
-0.1764266044,
-0.2128256261,
-0.7051429749,
-0.1830651015,
0.2857630253,
-0.5633301139,
-0.1253010184,
0.1827034205,
-0.840141654,
0.6726172566,
0.9525633454,
0.7774901986,
-0.4170165658,
-0.297870785,
-0.3307148814,
-0.0788315311,
-0.3368765712,
1.0109049082,
-0.6591234207,
-0.1576057971,
-0.1537328511,
-0.2266782075,
-0.0406370014,
-0.8934717774,
0.8164222836,
-0.3772495389,
0.2477565557,
-0.3536431193,
-0.6508257389,
-0.0198332481,
0.4271661043,
-0.7459071279,
1.2413041592,
0.5399259925,
-0.6153481007,
0.462036103,
-0.3073158264,
-0.3696717024,
0.3433489203,
-0.1084906086,
-0.3643054962,
0.1873749197,
-0.093126446,
0.0252475999,
-0.5297679305,
0.0447886921,
-0.2628496289,
-0.2174572498,
0.2411606312,
-0.4915982485,
0.5277125239,
0.4840854704,
-0.159837693,
-0.378690064,
-0.9700345993,
0.4881311357,
0.2779510915,
-0.454777211,
-0.6229628921,
0.0921403393,
0.4698845744,
-0.1278384477,
0.2075393498,
-0.4817292392,
-0.3639686406,
-0.365250349,
0.1271173805,
0.4860545099,
-0.21657224,
0.1060133576,
-0.6480285525,
0.2882497311,
0.0951824188,
-0.0614161789,
0.0161242895,
-0.5058146119,
-0.9659051299,
-0.2964338362,
0.6353987455,
0.5065936446,
-0.2814911306,
0.7918516397,
-0.2184647173,
-0.6666482687,
-0.8233425617,
0.4317038953,
0.6615939736,
0.3693580925,
0.6666879654,
-0.7588738203,
-0.3729815483,
-0.9358897805,
-0.5103984475,
-0.1966732442,
-0.2389110327,
-0.3203062415,
0.2608971596,
-0.2937384844,
1.0419154167,
-0.5098508,
-0.215098843,
-0.3355126381,
0.3652841449,
-0.0057537854,
0.7172883749,
0.4165970683,
-0.6940114498,
-0.4638720453,
-0.1065066829,
-0.5740206838,
-0.557554543,
0.0760755911,
-0.3008597493,
0.2613502145,
0.1294302493,
-0.2498174757,
0.2347062975,
0.6448914409,
-0.3222737908,
0.4772649705,
0.1293897331,
0.3504109085,
-0.5941581726,
0.2971181571,
0.289583385,
-0.1988213509,
-0.4170191288,
0.082095772,
0.1447220296,
0.1208473742,
-0.2450089008,
0.5643095374,
-0.10481897,
-0.1945071369,
-0.0467997603,
0.5143355131,
0.4681102633,
0.3049583435,
-0.2453452647,
0.7653722763,
-0.1607194692,
-0.5012769103,
0.0424475037,
0.2315274179,
-0.5775546432,
0.7426328063,
-0.5202104449,
-0.3307337761,
0.1698919982,
-0.0558394343,
-1.079298377,
-0.0922219008,
0.3080413938,
-0.4924208224,
-0.0056928019,
0.0742074624,
-0.7668465972,
-0.0975026861,
-0.1597869992,
0.4436592758,
0.4700449705,
-0.5005272031,
-0.0523565412,
0.5420830846,
-0.268386364,
-0.2801657021,
-0.9131038785,
0.0468025804,
0.1420804262,
-0.5859973431,
0.0600420497,
-0.1693616658,
-0.4819647968,
0.357534945,
-0.3447729051,
-0.5151977539,
0.2974968553,
-0.0280670822,
0.1479786485,
-0.218045637,
0.1949427724,
-0.2164535671,
-0.302793324,
-0.2153622508,
-0.2085447907,
0.757664144,
-0.1415753812,
-0.5967572927,
-0.4193687737,
0.4414507449,
0.3925334513,
-0.1889118403,
0.322467804,
0.4077502489,
-0.350620687,
-0.3144956529,
-0.5714018941,
0.3245134056,
-0.4397540092,
0.1717968136,
0.0430788025,
-0.4897296727,
0.3900036812,
0.1011068299,
0.2716769576,
0.5969498158,
0.2429910153,
-0.3077034056,
0.4713181853,
0.4513731897,
-0.0453546867,
0.3757996261,
0.1019648686,
0.1069241315,
-0.3382020891,
-0.0904869288,
-1.0003731251,
-0.4967984259,
-0.2511326075,
-0.481705457,
-0.1013621092,
0.309571892,
-0.2782074213,
0.4757703245,
-0.4709422588,
0.8029878736,
0.6902746558,
-0.2023348808,
0.5312401056,
-0.1312403232,
-0.0088150306,
-0.1582138985,
-0.5074602962,
-0.8178947568,
0.6790519357,
0.2624101937,
0.6073705554,
-0.1085615531,
0.7103469968,
0.7048637867,
0.1454210877,
-0.4030480385,
0.3615345955,
-0.5506657362,
-0.3624836802,
-0.1072294042,
-0.6530174017,
-1.0207395554,
0.1682080179,
-0.0185131729,
-0.6243245006,
0.1253465861,
0.2415748984,
-0.0421066359,
0.3566344082,
-0.8312482834,
1.1511385441,
-0.3045305312,
-0.344317466,
-0.0777815878,
-0.2625730038,
0.3660930991,
-0.2397949696,
0.2891971767,
-0.3629143536,
-0.0047224597,
0.7735138535,
-0.4177800119,
0.7445051074,
0.2081778198,
-0.1037277356,
0.1463933736,
0.3694091141,
0.2961826026,
-0.1842413396,
-0.0345865525,
0.7228428125,
0.082321614,
-0.6997887492,
-0.3962957263,
0.7904577255,
-0.7793703675,
-0.0726563185,
-0.3741544783,
-0.2843695581,
-0.2764485478,
0.2042836249,
0.1886972636,
0.124840796,
-0.2502296269,
0.1467101723,
0.4903120995,
-0.3554292917,
0.2328152806,
0.4096167386,
0.1475491375,
-0.4510362148,
0.929597199,
-0.0337083675,
0.2831386924,
0.2540193498,
0.0528872721,
0.0608986057,
-0.4207700789,
-0.3052385151,
0.0946027488,
-0.6883249283,
-0.4947724342,
-0.7084261179,
-0.1703132242,
-0.3058319092,
-0.5014566183,
-0.9271736145,
-0.4323042333,
-0.2616438568,
0.1910308599,
0.0328192152,
0.6312425137,
0.1337209195,
0.1352841854,
-1.1471703053,
0.3700784147,
-0.2465997785,
0.7395912409,
0.1406538934,
-0.151865989,
-0.3727192283,
0.0914887637,
-0.2785378098,
-0.3703099489,
0.6814870238,
-0.0483236201,
0.4855783582,
0.2778432965,
0.3346866369,
0.646205008,
-0.3270785213,
0.9789937139,
0.4800665975,
-1.0730439425,
0.3495593071,
0.0434882417,
0.4321489036,
1.0460227728,
0.3175210357,
-1.008728981,
-1.0086854696,
-0.5049329996,
-1.1496244669,
0.5470568538,
0.2780839205,
-0.2846733034,
-0.4395279884,
-0.1395907253,
0.4855266809,
0.202664867,
-0.5928495526,
-0.0874956772,
-0.229148224,
-0.547113657,
-0.0248392615,
-0.2211599946,
-0.1703554541,
0.0761849657,
0.7169083953,
0.3419599831,
-0.0716510043,
-0.0953117311,
-0.2606147528,
-0.3081542552,
0.4581446648,
0.2846685946,
0.5809081793,
-0.1892249435,
0.3184687197,
-0.284380585,
-0.5018725395,
0.0180147998,
-0.2939191163,
-0.1244480535,
0.3098020852,
0.5099307299,
0.1517105997,
0.4507724941,
-1.0015964508,
0.3389229774,
-0.0450133272,
-0.0939361677,
-0.2419266999,
0.3459520042,
-0.1718834937,
0.0727130696,
0.0488032028,
0.4357799888,
-0.1344443113,
-0.4771429598,
0.5855901241,
0.0977276713,
-0.163544178,
-0.2005854547,
0.5156937242,
0.3657825291,
-0.4558386505,
0.8551275134,
-0.2103797048,
-0.285208106,
0.4646245241,
0.3742032051,
0.7827632427,
0.2365593016,
0.2086774111,
0.2937188745,
0.3893025219,
-0.4505355656,
0.0916249827,
0.115193896,
-0.7232657671,
0.0853172839,
-0.8819154501,
-0.4501846135,
0.1890304387,
-0.8020484447,
0.2748541534,
-0.4017614424,
-0.0368496552,
0.1761189252,
0.0468862839,
-0.6762580872,
0.1423355192,
0.0634798855,
0.9571077824,
-0.8449657559,
0.6691867709,
0.1521578282,
-0.4561249316,
-0.1282754689,
0.2946725786,
0.172416538,
-0.5973615646,
0.6840122938,
-0.0570747219,
-0.0451868884,
-0.3681823909,
-0.3468017578,
-0.8967948556,
0.5867395401,
0.2297779769,
-0.7466605306,
0.2123245746,
0.2890169322,
0.6549873352,
-0.064181298,
-0.0711891428,
0.8352530599,
0.7970204949,
-0.2072776705,
-0.7000803947,
-0.2982453108,
-0.5185418725,
-0.1520851105,
0.4690595865,
-0.5237112045,
0.8573706746,
0.3002244234,
-0.7496476769,
0.2075753212,
0.3257712126,
-0.0721345693,
0.5513042808,
0.5236203671,
0.9301749468,
0.9207517505,
-0.2709486187,
1.0205392838,
-0.4895171523,
0.2732577324,
1.4480117559,
-0.5328394771,
1.0900211334,
0.2499098331,
-0.092646122,
0.3675149381,
0.4125996828,
-0.3209609985,
0.4421583712,
0.2605601847,
-0.0392239392,
-0.1531521529,
0.0439135693,
-0.2689848542,
0.4316823781,
0.2029644698,
-0.3409531415,
-0.5751549006,
-0.1398523897,
-0.0354604945,
0.6435210705,
0.1414449066,
0.66997087,
-0.1431882977,
-0.6714164615,
0.701007843,
0.1526836604,
0.5081431866,
-0.6132996678,
0.1570515633,
-0.4955272675,
0.2698397338,
-0.1180364117,
-0.7677342296,
0.6255759597,
0.279830873,
-0.5382844806,
-0.3236308098,
0.2630691528,
-0.6533721089,
-0.4797817469,
0.5618476868,
0.7347884774,
0.170374766,
0.24765113,
-0.6220528483,
0.4602111578,
-0.1202706248,
-0.0152214365,
0.5616371036,
0.4828596413,
0.1746299565,
0.5003540516,
0.6747522354,
0.2394966483,
-0.0731092691,
0.0512575507,
0.8476749063,
-0.7972844243,
-0.391792655,
-0.676432848,
0.2201662958,
-0.2120676786,
-0.3919523954,
0.803781867,
0.8148178458,
1.4651808739,
0.0536135323,
0.753557384,
0.052193325,
0.6774740219,
-0.3474134505,
0.7705640197,
-0.617347002,
0.4612412751,
-0.3559918702,
-0.9075169563,
-0.4388315678,
0.4551738501,
0.1375255585,
-0.2712605894,
0.9472904205,
0.6700974107,
-0.2757183909,
0.1329209059,
0.4378355145,
-0.0710947588,
0.1686296463,
0.3041844368,
0.5174002051,
-0.4230747819,
0.6186214685,
-0.0665343106,
-0.0835178271,
-0.1759336144,
-0.5297461748,
-0.4102908373,
-0.6623649001,
-0.5185399055,
-0.2585705817,
0.2144692689,
0.9002007842,
0.3622589707,
-0.9453342557,
-0.3973082602,
-0.0204086322,
0.2587003708,
-0.6682403088,
-0.2589792311,
0.1527242064,
-0.9680575132,
-0.7910075188,
0.2924082875,
0.3399800956,
-0.1582051367,
0.0144397104,
0.1524402499,
-0.3269622028,
0.1535770297,
0.3928420246,
0.3596702218,
-0.4438182414,
-0.3383912742,
-0.5236057043,
-0.4783578813,
0.2512806654,
0.8524723649,
-0.5608987212,
0.3476382196,
0.4186728597,
0.8731735945,
-0.271071583,
0.1740312874,
0.5612938404,
-1.0596109629,
-0.1665724516,
0.2649050951,
0.360766679,
0.3793058097,
-0.0539064258,
0.734244287,
0.4480801821,
-0.3785631955,
-0.8745743036,
0.0901753977,
-0.9859520793,
-0.6067429781,
1.017993331,
-0.3420809805,
-0.3623222113,
-0.4447949827,
0.2723882794,
0.1102591306,
-0.5237952471,
1.0896185637,
0.8390946388,
0.2852721214,
0.1304156184,
-0.4644517303,
0.4280892313,
0.3363416195,
-0.9750307202,
0.5847420096,
0.7148109078,
0.1688264161,
0.497020781,
0.5224308968,
-0.2729372978,
0.0789620653,
0.2672020197,
0.299220413,
0.1981643587,
-0.4072023928,
-0.0365367383,
0.4526270926,
-0.1978550702,
-0.2908325791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06427v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06427v1
|
ChatGPT Prompting Cannot Estimate Predictive Uncertainty in High-Resource Languages
| 2023-11-10T23:25:34 | 2023-11-10T23:25:34 |
Martino Pelucchi, Matias Valdenegro-Toro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
ChatGPT took the world by storm for its impressive abilities. Due to its
release without documentation, scientists immediately attempted to identify its
limits, mainly through its performance in natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. This paper aims to join the growing literature regarding ChatGPT's
abilities by focusing on its performance in high-resource languages and on its
capacity to predict its answers' accuracy by giving a confidence level. The
analysis of high-resource languages is of interest as studies have shown that
low-resource languages perform worse than English in NLP tasks, but no study so
far has analysed whether high-resource languages perform as well as English.
The analysis of ChatGPT's confidence calibration has not been carried out
before either and is critical to learn about ChatGPT's trustworthiness. In
order to study these two aspects, five high-resource languages and two NLP
tasks were chosen. ChatGPT was asked to perform both tasks in the five
languages and to give a numerical confidence value for each answer. The results
show that all the selected high-resource languages perform similarly and that
ChatGPT does not have a good confidence calibration, often being overconfident
and never giving low confidence values.
|
[
-0.4558219016,
-0.6475833654,
0.5486106277,
0.4049624503,
-0.0981293991,
0.4165244102,
-0.5344475508,
-0.7327152491,
-0.1141610369,
0.0073219654,
-0.4711986482,
-0.089170143,
-0.9786839485,
0.2168180794,
-0.040520452,
1.2247271538,
0.0382941514,
-0.0617257245,
0.0369169079,
-0.0130449971,
-0.4310287237,
-0.5525946021,
-0.9113680124,
-0.4159357846,
0.4162104726,
0.3991174102,
1.1409256458,
0.1771491766,
0.6365426183,
0.1573100984,
-0.2563123703,
0.1150151193,
-0.5142309666,
0.1065768078,
0.1510653496,
-0.4122420549,
-0.2070168704,
0.0720041767,
0.5355747342,
0.3911109865,
-0.0982397869,
0.1895227879,
0.4844095111,
0.6190227866,
-0.64000386,
0.5641435981,
-0.6177263856,
-0.0139845647,
-0.2621895969,
-0.2241800278,
-0.4036286473,
-0.3807560503,
0.4723900855,
-0.6016352177,
0.2075659633,
0.308068186,
0.8413487673,
0.4660811126,
-0.0425403528,
-0.3666040897,
-0.7839897871,
0.8850772977,
-0.3203412592,
0.2137115002,
0.6385201812,
0.1318011284,
-0.0854180604,
-0.3530540764,
-0.5330021977,
-0.3561041653,
0.1411290765,
0.2664946914,
-0.1807623953,
0.0598580167,
0.4212821722,
0.1253559142,
-0.774726212,
-0.0260906648,
-0.2740099728,
-0.3867042959,
0.2753640115,
-0.3890080452,
-0.2301481962,
-0.4395924509,
-0.4349541068,
-0.3714494705,
-0.4784553349,
0.2353629321,
0.2287168354,
0.211001724,
-0.0552677289,
0.5399392247,
-0.0858403817,
0.4483813047,
-0.238718614,
0.0404022075,
0.0439665765,
0.0509015433,
-0.1543867737,
0.0972189084,
1.1539009809,
0.2710705101,
0.4737977982,
0.0756788179,
-0.0388715379,
0.051850833,
-0.1228649616,
-0.7485826612,
-0.2243802994,
0.2524867654,
-0.0100476723,
-0.1719854474,
-0.0838100314,
-0.8804565668,
-0.3891721666,
0.4230851829,
0.502427876,
-0.765645504,
-0.1689540595,
0.2149001509,
0.0247986503,
0.1165213063,
0.2953778505,
-0.6443325281,
0.277382195,
0.5312864184,
0.7649636269,
-0.2715630829,
-0.4855002165,
-0.2392158806,
-0.4535361826,
-0.1712178141,
0.8063458204,
-0.5699569583,
-0.4759528339,
-0.2232690603,
-0.1838741302,
-0.2678310275,
-0.1403968334,
0.8236546516,
-0.4631385207,
0.3741973341,
-0.5166950226,
-0.2953647971,
-0.1733206511,
0.1770227253,
-0.4860965014,
1.1579405069,
-0.0250455625,
-0.9470169544,
0.3788987696,
-0.451710254,
-0.123068966,
0.1657100469,
-0.2096895874,
-0.2047106326,
-0.1530005336,
0.2067642957,
0.3066885173,
-0.3771597743,
0.0934329107,
-0.0185434595,
-0.5064630508,
0.543015182,
-1.1332755089,
0.6736847758,
0.2638286054,
-0.1522240043,
-0.4208094478,
-0.4209252596,
0.5154166818,
0.0312824287,
-0.2296595424,
0.1325548589,
0.0650557056,
-0.0881576538,
0.35644117,
0.4738450348,
-0.6308564544,
-0.1910942346,
-0.2016049027,
0.2262958139,
0.573716104,
-0.0202571228,
0.0760916695,
-0.3291909993,
0.7354577184,
-0.328489244,
0.0187002514,
0.1123433486,
-0.9555279016,
-0.534586072,
0.3550004959,
0.326330781,
0.8591207862,
-0.7172627449,
0.0745551735,
-0.4326770902,
-0.6335119009,
-0.5485622287,
-0.1591707021,
0.6068693995,
0.3668488562,
0.3200758696,
-0.3962122202,
-0.3998188674,
-0.6814132333,
-0.2497158349,
-0.60407722,
-0.0415740609,
0.2563904524,
0.2782473862,
0.2417877018,
0.6797314882,
-0.413277626,
-0.0045304433,
0.0478512831,
0.3890656233,
0.1283557117,
0.4038114846,
0.2984232605,
-0.7608986497,
-0.6890913844,
0.1256019026,
-0.4078381062,
0.2487871498,
0.0145831546,
0.070586361,
0.2300528288,
0.0939379185,
-0.7134917378,
0.0678271651,
0.9964572191,
-0.0121790655,
0.7310750484,
-0.238300547,
0.1647040546,
-1.0114071369,
0.0032791195,
-0.037899375,
0.0103886826,
-0.3534022272,
-0.0618607588,
0.0747012794,
-0.2767726779,
-0.2197974026,
0.4097439349,
-0.2168041915,
0.0611589067,
-0.174190715,
0.141429916,
-0.1241264045,
0.5705772638,
0.2198885232,
0.9247810245,
0.6402686834,
-0.3666214049,
0.2913925648,
0.145265013,
-0.2483204156,
0.451607883,
-0.6302785873,
0.0780436322,
0.0714898035,
0.0002222675,
-0.9067955017,
-0.3876718581,
0.1690244526,
-0.9355661273,
0.2714843452,
-0.3720350266,
-0.3602461517,
-0.2506397367,
0.1165090874,
0.220972836,
0.7513129711,
0.0082761282,
0.0622920766,
0.1655910015,
-0.2749878168,
-1.0534123182,
-0.6875832677,
0.010084738,
0.1005339399,
-0.599794209,
-0.0289450344,
-0.0762491673,
-0.0515452363,
-0.0163070131,
-0.3643689752,
-0.3433787227,
-0.176444605,
0.2790333629,
0.2411959618,
-0.1774122566,
0.2689066529,
-0.4403817654,
-0.2893299162,
0.262285769,
-0.084931545,
0.636097908,
-0.5169121027,
-0.6035851836,
-0.1650087982,
0.0939052403,
0.4754525423,
-0.2774180472,
0.7653223872,
0.8815491796,
-0.0459063724,
0.1556956023,
-0.5765529275,
-0.0154994996,
-0.4431020319,
0.5267189145,
-0.2099918574,
-0.9234368801,
0.600353539,
0.30823946,
0.0723859519,
0.527523756,
0.2907443941,
-0.0552141219,
1.1021375656,
0.3934338689,
-0.1060332954,
0.2898874283,
0.1083858833,
0.261469692,
-0.4558956027,
-0.0523406416,
-0.8426786065,
0.0822952464,
-1.3368632793,
-0.4591770172,
0.5080187321,
-0.214768365,
-0.2109846473,
0.3367372751,
-0.5133948326,
0.4255485535,
0.6364920735,
0.1005702391,
0.2514181137,
0.0941936448,
0.0523443706,
-0.165275529,
-0.8543909192,
-0.4873814285,
0.7765510678,
0.307381928,
0.8300363421,
-0.1141940951,
0.4426431358,
-0.1007005125,
-0.218679592,
-0.9468128085,
0.4421908855,
0.0094089527,
-0.6040249467,
-0.6262948513,
-0.4113726616,
-1.0073970556,
0.0577515773,
-0.2411842942,
-0.6062044501,
0.0972577408,
0.2021935433,
-0.5352384448,
0.0617681816,
-0.971973598,
0.6486476064,
0.0845356211,
-0.2846123874,
-0.1535382569,
-0.6876420379,
0.0212401841,
-0.1793952137,
0.2427317202,
-0.3894103467,
0.1241689622,
0.6071801186,
0.0142518599,
0.6764529943,
-0.0608785599,
-0.0939897075,
0.3277215064,
0.3984658122,
0.6458836794,
0.0856443495,
-0.4504954815,
0.0251097456,
0.3277028203,
-0.5962021351,
-0.4894025326,
0.4510075152,
-0.6198836565,
-0.5456185341,
-0.6226052642,
-0.3477794528,
-0.472923696,
0.2492584735,
0.8216664195,
0.0709532276,
-0.2164162546,
0.2613453865,
0.7150784731,
-0.1937871575,
0.4873721004,
0.0289954487,
0.0488063544,
0.1095374003,
0.8458136916,
0.2502966225,
0.6228880286,
0.2089143991,
0.2391784936,
-0.1682694107,
-0.3312679827,
-0.4114266932,
-0.1620447785,
-0.4170609415,
0.0394930355,
-0.289360553,
-0.6305006742,
-0.1393223107,
0.0626234487,
-0.541377306,
-0.4990206361,
0.2283255905,
0.0454499163,
0.410063237,
0.453299135,
0.1015031412,
0.2758565247,
-0.8602611423,
-0.1299092025,
0.2944899797,
0.4719696641,
-0.2963896692,
-0.4588421583,
-0.3944397569,
0.3529714048,
-0.2475893945,
-0.7986699939,
0.3061824739,
0.2305706888,
0.3439510465,
0.0546402819,
0.3520427346,
0.5123457313,
-0.2553760111,
0.7190104723,
-0.210989058,
-0.6889533997,
0.3825634122,
-0.3010005355,
0.3617964983,
0.4020884931,
0.4927687049,
-0.7814384699,
-0.6025038362,
-0.8357301354,
-0.5775366426,
0.6757208109,
0.5782270432,
0.1776087731,
-0.0277715046,
0.0971069038,
0.0401939191,
0.2025937289,
-0.7567279339,
-0.0817314833,
-0.2221290022,
0.1751776487,
-0.1684602052,
-0.422721982,
-0.0440091714,
0.2548574209,
0.6975066066,
-0.2277919948,
0.609924674,
0.2920018137,
0.0999220088,
-0.3284813464,
0.5379911065,
0.335754782,
0.5597348213,
-0.3720597327,
0.0722558722,
0.3603116274,
-0.9943172336,
-0.154588148,
0.2017385215,
-0.0831695125,
-0.1204984039,
0.4924592674,
0.8673288226,
0.0894634351,
-0.5910205841,
0.5780236721,
-0.2195898592,
-0.0213284809,
-0.4253264368,
0.2221774161,
-0.1415840685,
-0.0441663601,
0.3565098047,
0.5962927938,
-0.1301979274,
-0.1440404803,
-0.0674555153,
0.4445521235,
-0.4927320778,
-0.2914661467,
0.3544796407,
-0.0330530554,
-0.1002096161,
0.6659324169,
-0.3729124963,
-0.5856189728,
0.5641818643,
0.255759716,
0.6989071965,
-0.262082845,
0.3350841105,
0.4675860703,
0.5141705275,
-0.3116006851,
0.4265916944,
0.1927222461,
-0.9900107384,
-0.9270432591,
-0.5676433444,
-0.9081273079,
-0.0627864748,
-0.7113013268,
-0.0555100515,
-0.3154617548,
-0.3390910029,
-0.2290677875,
0.307985723,
-0.7606617808,
0.2857083082,
-0.1539449841,
0.695509851,
-0.7413173914,
0.5929276347,
0.4040690064,
-0.1174237803,
-0.9219920039,
0.2726027071,
-0.0393180624,
-1.07333076,
0.3882682323,
0.0449970625,
-0.2532138824,
0.1304345131,
-0.6074645519,
-0.9589745998,
0.706982851,
0.5030555129,
-0.0579182841,
-0.0411850661,
0.2045361847,
0.6538285017,
0.2578421533,
0.2921733558,
0.3113681078,
0.58466959,
0.2239996344,
-1.4702223539,
-0.0357199833,
-0.0666740462,
-0.2200755775,
-0.0657676831,
-0.7572401762,
0.7443181276,
-0.2708257437,
-0.2916874886,
-0.0676763579,
0.2851820886,
0.1443823576,
-0.1068086401,
0.3972109854,
0.1326910853,
0.9010451436,
-0.3970303833,
1.098991394,
-0.4709965289,
0.4437507391,
0.9751361609,
-0.0929616243,
1.0903532505,
0.4058497846,
-0.3747818172,
0.35837093,
0.7802650332,
0.0974834636,
0.1436816007,
-0.3070909679,
-0.4517942667,
-0.2464128733,
-0.1743293256,
-0.1989277452,
0.7455306649,
0.4631113708,
-0.0831977203,
-0.051624313,
-0.201549992,
0.1181599274,
-0.2896429598,
-0.012242645,
0.4608284533,
-0.018265605,
-1.0554069281,
0.7034357786,
-0.2232710719,
0.4317926466,
-0.5687791109,
0.1963864267,
0.1645888984,
-0.1383717656,
-0.2286304086,
-1.2795820236,
0.1812459677,
-0.030765349,
0.1667281836,
-0.1574866921,
0.5612467527,
-0.0768914446,
-0.264916271,
0.0090786247,
0.8765741587,
0.2681660354,
-0.39461869,
-0.6295015216,
-0.2751999199,
0.1013538316,
-0.3543379605,
0.2854408026,
0.8627378345,
0.0731966347,
1.0255572796,
0.5243566036,
0.2566542327,
-0.0800239369,
-0.3736061156,
0.4271526635,
-0.3143805861,
-0.2490297556,
-0.8430903554,
0.1299068332,
0.0797207728,
-0.448979944,
0.7338601947,
0.3619261682,
0.9160815477,
0.1044640169,
0.8899860382,
-0.2440862209,
0.4425222874,
-0.5362052321,
0.5489732027,
-0.0356010459,
0.2187413722,
-0.3296734989,
-0.8820064068,
-0.0478776433,
0.6892290115,
-0.287453711,
0.2696270943,
1.0400290489,
0.7730699182,
0.1980909705,
0.2310299724,
0.4975015521,
0.284055382,
0.0809068531,
0.5204542875,
0.583761096,
-0.1932807714,
1.0495936871,
-0.5962491035,
-0.2450233549,
-0.0239241086,
-1.0275152922,
-0.5016425848,
-0.6685618162,
0.070391126,
-0.5016294122,
-0.1010781229,
0.9596546292,
0.7513995767,
-0.8166751266,
-0.1569898576,
-0.0552012771,
0.0021992878,
-0.3296787441,
-0.2064952105,
0.5861827731,
-0.3436235487,
-0.8854665756,
0.2307551652,
0.0807989761,
0.2095038295,
-0.1903901398,
-0.1830926239,
0.3552569747,
-0.1577003747,
0.2824372649,
0.5439165831,
-0.5192369223,
-0.575234592,
0.276047498,
-0.1814457029,
0.1742273718,
0.3292340934,
-0.540176332,
0.4635187685,
0.4568087459,
0.4992794096,
0.4205718338,
-0.0990258381,
0.7349936366,
-0.8827443123,
0.1117387712,
0.4460517466,
0.2971807718,
0.2769216895,
-0.5367455482,
0.551744163,
0.0958349034,
-0.9861727953,
-0.4273716509,
0.2706916928,
-0.8884495497,
0.0872976258,
1.1343061924,
-0.2199289352,
-0.0316585153,
-0.2636403739,
-0.45565328,
0.2005745023,
-0.7347928882,
0.9089317322,
1.3258423805,
-0.3689859807,
-0.2362818271,
-1.0489883423,
0.8061853051,
0.592415154,
-0.32877931,
0.4146237075,
0.2225318402,
0.1295596212,
0.4355414212,
0.5644934773,
-0.0359243825,
0.4500904381,
0.2122607082,
-0.015591572,
0.1944419593,
0.0758135319,
-0.1652487814,
0.2124126107,
0.6354510188,
0.0637819469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06414v1
|
Knowledge Graphs are not Created Equal: Exploring the Properties and Structure of Real KGs
| 2023-11-10T22:18:09 | 2023-11-10T22:18:09 |
Nedelina Teneva, Estevam Hruschka
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Despite the recent popularity of knowledge graph (KG) related tasks and
benchmarks such as KG embeddings, link prediction, entity alignment and
evaluation of the reasoning abilities of pretrained language models as KGs, the
structure and properties of real KGs are not well studied. In this paper, we
perform a large scale comparative study of 29 real KG datasets from diverse
domains such as the natural sciences, medicine, and NLP to analyze their
properties and structural patterns. Based on our findings, we make several
recommendations regarding KG-based model development and evaluation. We believe
that the rich structural information contained in KGs can benefit the
development of better KG models across fields and we hope this study will
contribute to breaking the existing data silos between different areas of
research (e.g., ML, NLP, AI for sciences).
|
[
-0.3158588409,
-0.7143689394,
0.4208588898,
0.018888155,
0.041155979,
0.3021515608,
0.0344007835,
-0.5457056165,
0.2963187099,
0.3415638208,
-0.0986726433,
-0.4713965654,
-0.8756665587,
-0.0211426392,
-0.1661953181,
0.7766145468,
-0.0423609316,
0.2755611539,
-0.6238704324,
-0.5011951327,
-0.2536028326,
-0.3640306294,
-0.4313651621,
-0.5911631584,
0.5067657232,
-0.1366675794,
1.0659155846,
0.6524656415,
0.5241796374,
0.2093460858,
-0.2957829237,
0.1635936797,
-0.5558155775,
-0.0615765303,
0.00398198,
-0.2676071227,
-0.5197721124,
0.1903920621,
0.6347400546,
1.2607033253,
0.2958644331,
0.0450587273,
0.0259014424,
1.0412739515,
-0.4962701201,
0.5410032868,
-0.0414457209,
0.2994980514,
0.0237111114,
0.2868350446,
-0.0922266319,
-0.6941883564,
0.3946320713,
-0.6891255379,
0.0120525062,
0.237212196,
0.8843007088,
0.0540061407,
-0.7232121229,
-0.5210624337,
-0.4430730641,
0.4942932129,
-0.7138866782,
1.0216224194,
0.3732137978,
0.6241654158,
-0.2954028845,
-0.786015749,
-0.483605355,
-0.5063522458,
-0.3008368313,
0.0483427607,
-0.0684881583,
0.0234987736,
0.0365300179,
0.179474473,
-0.5703979731,
0.0187014546,
-0.4506866038,
-0.3159768879,
0.4002648592,
0.0632357597,
0.4713906646,
-0.2276775986,
-0.0739561096,
-0.3459503055,
-0.8793895245,
0.032592617,
0.5748123527,
0.2282961011,
-0.18344675,
0.6802685261,
-0.509396553,
1.0514081717,
-0.52970469,
-0.5612207055,
0.3477820158,
-0.0986187309,
-0.2560852468,
-0.0516613051,
0.8667968512,
0.3575142622,
0.7177625299,
-0.8152279258,
0.3740586936,
-0.0068836324,
0.3385748565,
-0.6622074842,
-0.4814159274,
0.079028368,
-0.5988122225,
-0.288194418,
-0.0897914171,
-0.3000949919,
-0.306570828,
-0.4612902999,
0.3074955046,
-0.4375213683,
-0.4416300058,
-0.1074073389,
-0.4252241552,
-0.2281242013,
-0.004408489,
-0.4699717164,
0.2994370461,
0.6182360649,
0.6381852627,
-0.1539731324,
-0.3083135784,
0.4584425688,
0.0761596113,
-0.4446289539,
0.6812080145,
-0.7256880999,
-0.3274713755,
-0.3281383812,
-0.1954828352,
-0.1133322269,
-0.7779681683,
0.2667523026,
-0.7550693154,
0.0443286039,
-0.710316956,
-0.7035145164,
-0.2804724872,
0.663028419,
-0.6949821711,
0.8918588161,
0.5621246099,
-0.8631565571,
0.7137631178,
-0.5874809027,
-0.4483836591,
-0.1140232906,
-0.3151739538,
-0.3177272081,
-0.3512809873,
0.0352699794,
0.36102584,
-0.301821053,
0.5333527327,
-0.6188125014,
-0.0059236377,
0.2120236903,
-0.1295954585,
0.6176770329,
0.4506131113,
0.1610968709,
-0.0760849416,
-1.0775011778,
0.3902979791,
0.0636885166,
-0.3457000256,
-0.3912511468,
0.1334664226,
-0.4982420206,
0.2046142817,
0.0266570244,
-0.4869230688,
0.429677695,
-0.3563445508,
0.3107233644,
0.3746857345,
-0.2626086473,
0.4392619133,
-0.1600277126,
0.5068635345,
0.078710936,
0.0897859037,
0.4810937643,
-0.605458498,
-0.3289785683,
-0.2685259879,
0.5877332091,
0.1668509841,
-0.5404554009,
0.2632725835,
-0.6020500064,
-0.9478365183,
-0.5211156607,
-0.1902368814,
0.7423045635,
0.7916898131,
0.2718176246,
-0.3158223629,
-0.2799338996,
-0.9901490211,
-0.6545650959,
-0.1722334027,
0.0239170808,
0.6083424091,
0.5293446779,
-0.1609379351,
1.303711772,
-0.7352066636,
0.1009229124,
-0.0700960383,
-0.0146285668,
-0.0455293618,
0.1722984761,
0.7977486849,
-0.871278286,
-0.7033509612,
0.1347544044,
-1.1646399498,
-0.0533511415,
0.6974183917,
-0.155481264,
-0.4741208553,
0.2029586732,
-0.5129508376,
0.2192824334,
0.4139279425,
-0.5850183368,
0.496807307,
0.0341066867,
0.3731050193,
-0.815664649,
0.2565906048,
-0.256454736,
-0.0607036352,
-0.7085627317,
-0.0009930304,
0.1398795545,
-0.2339633107,
-0.160900712,
0.7740302086,
-0.294542253,
-0.4956334829,
-0.0698279068,
0.0014403663,
0.1388790458,
0.3799058497,
-0.1878594309,
0.4261528552,
0.4728011191,
-0.7037717104,
0.5838598013,
0.3736550212,
-0.78711164,
0.3117644191,
-0.6011181474,
-0.1927515566,
-0.1395186037,
0.1620445848,
-0.6382682323,
-0.2650444508,
0.3184905946,
-0.4684215486,
0.2736645043,
-0.2929534614,
-0.4719494581,
-0.476631552,
0.0381467119,
0.3018898666,
0.4782676399,
-0.3234321475,
0.2625518441,
0.458007127,
0.0115315635,
-0.7808548808,
-0.3546817303,
-0.1070233062,
-0.11263147,
-0.8609570861,
0.1796314418,
0.1252170354,
-0.429905951,
0.5735757351,
-0.4044668078,
-0.2096892148,
0.1341146678,
0.2762063146,
-0.1898846328,
-0.4156104624,
0.2753848135,
-0.1958921552,
-0.0730380192,
-0.1339449137,
-0.4939177632,
0.2881406546,
0.1873477995,
-0.4271763861,
0.0367703699,
-0.3640963137,
0.6753569841,
0.0770716891,
1.0354396105,
0.1681183577,
-0.2562281787,
-0.1356119514,
-0.3858522177,
0.0619763359,
-0.4230920374,
0.4387223125,
-0.4120714664,
-0.979799211,
0.5558776259,
-0.141559273,
-0.2609372139,
0.4735228717,
0.2556666136,
-0.0192441251,
0.8581843972,
0.4592952132,
-0.1468181014,
0.1344602853,
-0.2304396182,
0.6281440258,
-0.7006898522,
-0.5157932639,
-0.5033363104,
-0.3247182667,
-0.2918427587,
0.0276250429,
0.5543490648,
0.4530363083,
-0.1368391812,
0.3086331189,
-0.4927412271,
0.4291690886,
0.2504808903,
-0.1735429019,
0.0134728504,
0.099989973,
-0.34150213,
-0.057806246,
-1.0583709478,
-0.5264228582,
1.1905142069,
0.068511419,
0.5090260506,
-0.0633085519,
0.0926060751,
0.365565002,
0.4564992487,
-0.5847878456,
0.3696878552,
-0.1233926639,
-0.7012287974,
-0.4458628595,
-0.9353144765,
-1.0819065571,
0.4367062151,
-0.2331377566,
-0.5182397366,
-0.0069907513,
0.0855998397,
0.0141686788,
0.4537213743,
-0.8987910151,
1.0296015739,
-0.053260114,
0.0404530205,
0.109227553,
-0.5854059458,
0.2234160751,
0.0563121289,
0.4274330437,
-0.2803699672,
0.6777322888,
1.0415693521,
-0.5154201388,
0.6332582831,
-0.2036394477,
-0.0496756472,
0.6083533764,
0.1046428308,
0.3180188537,
-0.352366209,
-0.2117188275,
0.0147037515,
0.2477952242,
-0.4166031778,
-0.8458610177,
0.615256846,
-1.0239032507,
-0.2504169345,
0.0316763669,
-0.5804562569,
-0.532063961,
0.3361643255,
0.1351658404,
0.7111795545,
-0.1912904829,
0.2769429684,
0.3249620497,
-0.065681003,
-0.1027523875,
0.504037559,
-0.0652452111,
-0.2311280072,
1.1113715172,
0.8917815089,
0.3522231281,
0.264624238,
0.2559764385,
-0.1665882617,
-0.5918663144,
-0.1733102947,
0.2069230378,
-0.9231084585,
-0.0632433668,
-0.8881778717,
-0.3368703723,
-0.9887794852,
-0.1768222153,
-0.3987169862,
-0.6335107088,
0.2455421835,
-0.2952373624,
0.3712768555,
1.0510518551,
0.1585812569,
0.2504298389,
-0.7818229198,
0.4882612526,
0.3405250907,
0.7007722259,
0.2757748663,
-0.1207628325,
-0.4306253195,
0.0697427019,
-0.1628218442,
-0.7247303724,
0.3154661357,
-0.15216133,
0.8935408592,
0.4399803579,
-0.1392680258,
0.5683609843,
-0.2976917326,
0.6387539506,
0.0237148609,
-0.4594810903,
0.240336895,
-0.1759655178,
-0.0088068536,
0.340665549,
0.793079257,
-0.5104682446,
-0.1494071335,
-0.8298837543,
-0.6716182828,
0.5632638335,
0.5121515989,
-0.2959977388,
0.159646228,
0.3812620938,
0.0569613911,
0.4214078486,
-0.6988114715,
-0.2734093666,
-0.3578839898,
-0.4435812831,
0.2345756143,
-0.1938766241,
-0.3068427742,
-0.1965000331,
0.5229876637,
-0.0039486,
0.1542899013,
0.0510628447,
-0.1271488219,
0.1406168044,
0.1847786009,
0.09181647,
0.8378801942,
-0.2579541802,
0.3388784826,
0.1486022174,
-0.5333243012,
0.1578318775,
-0.1905216426,
0.0598401576,
-0.3683639467,
0.8859909773,
0.8385911584,
0.1256061047,
-0.5295686126,
0.1181910858,
0.327641964,
-0.2592413127,
0.2583922446,
0.3804592788,
0.315410316,
0.2240233123,
-0.0630471706,
-0.2209611535,
-0.2181955576,
-0.6829436421,
-0.1108464897,
0.3889163435,
-0.4005289078,
-0.394181788,
0.3696774244,
0.1481086761,
-0.1437614858,
0.751594007,
-0.3400214612,
-0.5903324485,
0.9469875693,
0.4861459732,
0.143791303,
0.158545509,
0.0641840249,
0.2342683077,
0.2015563399,
-0.0141562559,
0.1309775412,
-0.1067323461,
-1.0284459591,
-0.2508918047,
-0.7376887202,
-0.2388088405,
-0.0934758335,
-0.2934838235,
-0.0885942131,
-0.1650785506,
-0.2105251104,
0.1282755882,
0.0495352894,
-0.5466704369,
0.7169197202,
-0.2407929003,
0.7409203649,
-0.9374755621,
0.8818169832,
0.6180911064,
-0.3016774356,
-0.6676616669,
-0.5122441053,
-0.222206533,
-0.8302772641,
1.1217275858,
-0.0550500378,
0.1296763569,
-0.0378822386,
-0.5255209804,
-1.0828264952,
1.1497946978,
0.2660538852,
-0.2312269509,
-0.2463368624,
0.468735069,
0.5810675621,
-0.2880131304,
0.1048309803,
0.4003723264,
0.6689122319,
0.0289118066,
-0.7777199745,
-0.2584048212,
-0.1832382828,
-0.4664841592,
0.3887408674,
-0.6182566881,
0.7912248373,
0.1796878278,
-0.2046239525,
-0.4475016594,
0.3885662556,
0.2313553691,
0.399248153,
0.2572954297,
0.9471715689,
0.7578095198,
-0.180448249,
1.1897991896,
-0.4022925794,
0.3021668792,
0.7380666733,
-0.3936038315,
0.0643872395,
0.0175020918,
-0.676599443,
0.2797642648,
0.37439996,
-0.2012574375,
0.5152381659,
0.352651298,
0.2403451949,
-0.1152951866,
0.0317251645,
-0.6487763524,
0.1643182188,
0.4087753594,
-0.3672427535,
-0.2672328055,
-0.1252987981,
0.2319602966,
-0.156945765,
-0.0878511965,
0.4332427979,
0.1495759636,
-0.4181191623,
0.3873666823,
-0.0825853273,
0.2145444155,
-0.9739714265,
0.1517847329,
0.0208282564,
-0.2080383748,
-0.3145705163,
-0.8073746562,
0.3753618002,
-0.0395683162,
-0.0917192772,
-0.1219606474,
1.0472779274,
-0.0019047022,
-0.2532674968,
0.4548044205,
0.6872147322,
0.238976568,
0.1121844426,
-0.4216448367,
-0.2582971752,
-0.1314777136,
-0.6201279759,
0.4567231834,
0.4668823779,
-0.1252016872,
0.9882750511,
0.6736668348,
0.0673969984,
0.1915913969,
-0.0137758469,
0.9393623471,
-0.7488701344,
-0.3337933719,
-0.6634075046,
0.1920642257,
-0.1588955969,
-0.3760035336,
1.0447934866,
0.5306153893,
0.7928489447,
0.1552733481,
0.8553235531,
-0.2437037379,
0.3738686442,
-0.5906053185,
1.0304625034,
-0.3971510231,
-0.1277952343,
-0.22258614,
-0.8529630899,
-0.2629727125,
0.4129261076,
-0.40593943,
0.2078434378,
0.614258647,
0.5909538865,
-0.2425884604,
0.0024790701,
0.4081532657,
0.3364650011,
0.2696287036,
-0.0012075638,
0.7769483328,
-0.0970017463,
0.3065546155,
-0.044213254,
0.0767483041,
-0.0564172231,
-0.6765869856,
-0.9666650295,
-0.3320308924,
-0.2192573696,
-0.298230052,
0.2115250081,
0.472394526,
0.7830179334,
-0.6142125726,
0.0135735059,
-0.0898416042,
0.2895224392,
-0.0451323912,
-0.2003112435,
0.6815913916,
-0.0191978812,
-0.191647321,
0.6249138117,
0.1244508028,
0.1980993748,
-0.1063159257,
-0.0983029231,
0.0747324377,
-0.0204168148,
0.701713562,
0.3576937318,
-0.384349227,
-0.3633970618,
0.020009201,
-0.1443326622,
-0.002651993,
0.7343916297,
-0.947211802,
0.5889183879,
0.8336040378,
0.4803813994,
0.3041212857,
-0.3306855857,
0.52655828,
-0.6413183212,
0.093099758,
0.0133316442,
0.2965649962,
0.2853620946,
-0.0010868813,
0.9568727016,
0.4105816483,
-0.4865072966,
-0.8496412039,
0.2939274311,
-0.5982766747,
-0.7170056105,
0.9282022715,
-0.1731354594,
-0.1163064763,
-0.2071160227,
0.0790622085,
0.6350953579,
0.2091410458,
0.7676331997,
1.0472757816,
-0.254253298,
0.5002053976,
-0.6328268051,
0.5239558816,
0.2050648332,
-0.6927930117,
-0.1688453704,
0.19454588,
0.3188383877,
0.2744935155,
0.4625903368,
-0.2115906626,
-0.3515470326,
0.2506733239,
0.0665678307,
-0.4196372628,
-0.4792444408,
0.3406257331,
0.5094303489,
0.0849200189,
0.4242312312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06411v1
|
Analyzing Modular Approaches for Visual Question Decomposition
| 2023-11-10T22:14:26 | 2023-11-10T22:14:26 |
Apoorv Khandelwal, Ellie Pavlick, Chen Sun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Modular neural networks without additional training have recently been shown
to surpass end-to-end neural networks on challenging vision-language tasks. The
latest such methods simultaneously introduce LLM-based code generation to build
programs and a number of skill-specific, task-oriented modules to execute them.
In this paper, we focus on ViperGPT and ask where its additional performance
comes from and how much is due to the (state-of-art, end-to-end) BLIP-2 model
it subsumes vs. additional symbolic components. To do so, we conduct a
controlled study (comparing end-to-end, modular, and prompting-based methods
across several VQA benchmarks). We find that ViperGPT's reported gains over
BLIP-2 can be attributed to its selection of task-specific modules, and when we
run ViperGPT using a more task-agnostic selection of modules, these gains go
away. Additionally, ViperGPT retains much of its performance if we make
prominent alterations to its selection of modules: e.g. removing or retaining
only BLIP-2. Finally, we compare ViperGPT against a prompting-based
decomposition strategy and find that, on some benchmarks, modular approaches
significantly benefit by representing subtasks with natural language, instead
of code.
|
[
-0.6061198115,
-0.8000612855,
0.2546724379,
0.0581227317,
-0.5924015045,
0.092655845,
-0.266179949,
-0.2108429074,
-0.1357007176,
0.1867567748,
-0.5794596076,
-0.1954144537,
-0.3107889295,
0.1053678319,
-0.2472414374,
0.6663632393,
0.3039709926,
0.3150664568,
-0.4367490709,
0.1706460267,
-0.4160394669,
-0.459444344,
-0.7635870576,
-0.2719655037,
0.7224816084,
0.3394599259,
0.374088794,
0.4473540485,
0.5161607862,
0.2278268337,
-0.4567729533,
0.0587458499,
-0.3048191965,
0.0077804117,
-0.2776615322,
-0.6738753915,
-0.2361102104,
-0.3913911879,
0.3177121282,
0.3827868998,
-0.1639049053,
0.4883591533,
-0.0760847628,
0.7408691645,
-0.7109953165,
0.3646103144,
-0.5631693006,
0.2133188695,
-0.1576504707,
-0.265239805,
-0.4231875837,
-0.2591288388,
0.2307241857,
-0.2358955294,
0.2081994861,
0.0278587472,
0.6471735835,
0.4036838114,
-0.3499646783,
-0.0025626975,
-0.4095516503,
0.4933050871,
-0.4464919567,
0.0711899921,
0.0532233939,
0.4022552669,
-0.0077935634,
-0.5950442553,
-0.4582052827,
-0.0144370124,
0.1900739968,
0.7251662016,
-0.5127825737,
0.2220225185,
0.3882356584,
0.4659432173,
-0.880523324,
0.1953419894,
-0.821973145,
-0.2080247551,
0.3140414357,
0.1534528732,
0.4178005159,
-0.8201143742,
-0.6610347629,
0.0645141006,
-0.8174238801,
0.4196387231,
0.3510659933,
-0.0870996639,
0.4536100924,
0.9569642544,
-0.4212763309,
0.6512619853,
-0.0872018486,
0.2595757544,
-0.2394593954,
-0.4310398698,
-0.3151431978,
-0.2622440457,
0.5852510333,
0.580213666,
0.589951098,
-0.1629968137,
-0.3782669008,
0.0655351952,
0.2813512981,
-0.7288432717,
-0.6170373559,
0.0448353216,
-0.428129077,
-0.0043397434,
-0.1888497174,
-0.4871446192,
-0.0335540287,
-0.4576258361,
0.6576061249,
-0.4735291302,
-0.3283349574,
0.0245233569,
-0.5213115215,
0.4433580935,
0.5228221416,
-0.8195676208,
0.3494076729,
0.8626587987,
0.8173380494,
-0.264082253,
0.1195853874,
-0.3644468188,
-0.1764334738,
-0.6595590115,
0.9939901233,
-0.2505649626,
-0.2282445133,
-0.0573789328,
-0.3065371215,
-0.2759403586,
-1.0079600811,
-0.1397787631,
-0.4742355645,
0.015078309,
-0.6594433784,
-0.3526413143,
-0.5550127029,
0.4554749429,
-0.3573773801,
1.0290327072,
0.046508275,
-0.6153203249,
0.3720305562,
-0.3922793865,
-0.192855984,
0.3077216446,
-0.2932163477,
-0.1876142621,
0.4247505367,
0.318610996,
0.5181599259,
-0.2111277282,
-0.0471116565,
0.0994070321,
-0.4105708599,
0.1615911573,
-0.2020501047,
0.663839519,
-0.097923398,
-0.381624788,
0.2264600992,
-0.5046684742,
0.1378474385,
-0.2332659513,
-0.411449492,
-0.0414745919,
0.0987730324,
-0.1361948252,
0.2392460853,
0.1393976361,
-0.5875333548,
0.1331162602,
-0.1984538287,
0.3431760669,
0.8756670952,
0.2413107008,
0.2222638726,
-0.2310300171,
0.8135799766,
0.126096487,
0.338003546,
-0.2516064942,
-0.8486351371,
-1.1900179386,
-0.2169698477,
0.1312499046,
0.7790504098,
-1.1394028664,
-0.2276579589,
-0.0233015567,
-0.3236209452,
0.0177100226,
-0.0647401065,
0.701992631,
0.6019485593,
0.5029597878,
-0.6654883623,
-0.3619668186,
-1.4264380932,
0.135259673,
-0.4637979865,
0.2133788466,
0.2392554432,
0.587456286,
0.2996912599,
0.8940632939,
-0.5394527912,
0.1545750648,
-0.44765082,
0.0912058577,
-0.058754649,
0.4286802113,
0.4746639132,
-0.7697327137,
-0.2332354635,
0.0838165432,
-0.6021370292,
0.2665249705,
-0.0819387585,
0.0172311775,
0.1543435007,
0.3849856257,
-0.840354085,
0.8131028414,
0.0560370535,
0.0880894586,
1.0863828659,
0.0710961521,
-0.1169619262,
-0.7935789227,
0.0552970059,
0.0577907972,
-0.2267415375,
-0.597024858,
0.2025991678,
0.1547819823,
-0.1165235788,
-0.4628463387,
0.2560079992,
-0.4498843551,
-0.4420540631,
0.0381627455,
-0.2212947011,
-0.2806061506,
0.8749995828,
0.0636611581,
1.0113638639,
0.7333081365,
-0.4897834361,
0.4567751884,
0.2442023158,
-0.3736820817,
0.3747794926,
-0.86291641,
-0.043834988,
-0.326475352,
0.0188957062,
-1.3653639555,
-0.0905656219,
0.5259504914,
-0.6078291535,
0.140731886,
-0.5575346947,
-0.5068392158,
-0.2465595305,
-0.3058899045,
0.481305778,
0.909358561,
-0.3678407669,
0.3751049638,
-0.0528286099,
-0.3784387708,
-0.5506874323,
-0.9353080392,
0.337212801,
-0.0150034418,
-0.65962708,
-0.1371327788,
0.0371743962,
-0.2023322582,
0.1684727371,
-0.2849244773,
-0.1754664928,
-0.1607632339,
0.2317285687,
0.0907354206,
-0.5852721334,
0.0061918325,
-0.0626032501,
-0.2994094491,
0.2685189247,
-0.3674505949,
0.3439817429,
-0.0777077228,
-0.4779759049,
-0.4070908427,
0.4965989888,
0.3856166005,
-0.7015467286,
0.2322690338,
0.6224009991,
-0.0621912219,
-0.491230011,
-0.5187748075,
0.13642928,
-0.472581327,
0.4921016097,
-0.1504939049,
-0.690413475,
0.5177774429,
0.0432406329,
-0.0060997801,
0.0143748103,
0.8535413146,
-0.0233884808,
0.6441329718,
0.4989840984,
0.5319313407,
0.5796017647,
-0.5682319403,
0.1989483535,
-1.193554163,
-0.6603645682,
0.0201703701,
-0.4140950739,
-0.2007120401,
-0.8061802387,
0.4430060685,
0.0490609072,
0.0949673131,
0.3591644466,
-0.4922739267,
0.3897858858,
0.7324627638,
0.353682965,
0.1568184197,
-0.0509679653,
-0.0594008006,
0.1788970977,
-1.0986481905,
-0.0470225476,
0.9617930651,
-0.091719456,
0.4458411634,
0.1973253638,
0.6823470592,
-0.3090858161,
0.1346295327,
-1.2030553818,
1.0030010939,
-0.0622573122,
-0.5097726583,
-0.1837046146,
-0.4080036581,
-0.6764777303,
0.4147892892,
0.2175534517,
-0.7416436672,
0.2458074689,
0.3801006079,
-0.3372600675,
0.3618332148,
-0.931189239,
0.7303245068,
-0.0135709196,
-0.4593023658,
-0.2287820131,
-0.418653667,
0.573825717,
0.2775408924,
-0.3594484627,
0.0304592792,
-0.3113585114,
0.5348864198,
-0.5195738077,
0.6576375961,
-0.1689537466,
0.283031404,
0.469897449,
0.223347187,
0.2070642561,
0.3693657815,
0.2572364807,
-0.149543792,
-0.2198732495,
-0.4853889048,
-0.7476744652,
0.1979523301,
-0.2334352136,
-0.8768276572,
-0.2341899723,
-0.4456400275,
-0.0529951081,
0.0235451385,
0.5243340731,
1.1297730207,
0.2811637223,
0.1491048336,
0.775164783,
-0.4002460837,
0.8619926572,
-0.1367274821,
-0.314973712,
-0.2205725014,
0.9002950191,
0.3483321667,
0.5139046311,
0.2738407254,
0.1048414931,
-0.1836588234,
-1.1009069681,
-0.7348006964,
-0.121614337,
-0.8675678968,
-0.1937302947,
-0.2674977183,
-0.1075703427,
0.0760008916,
0.1984051019,
-0.3026675284,
-0.6326480508,
-0.0720739737,
-0.2509467006,
0.2691277862,
0.7403796911,
-0.0473429747,
-0.0985908285,
-0.4009810984,
0.4086478651,
0.7921413779,
0.0831616148,
0.2813642621,
0.0166666806,
-0.1898533255,
-0.3151160181,
0.0163156837,
-0.8970245719,
0.011388001,
0.0336382911,
0.4627545774,
-0.0176789872,
-0.2186212391,
0.9110746384,
-0.560787499,
1.1194797754,
0.2684269845,
-0.6224152446,
0.372802943,
-0.5742599368,
0.5449761748,
0.2349373698,
0.018829288,
-0.4118102491,
-0.1426888555,
-0.3363541663,
-0.9231446385,
0.3619161546,
0.3848918378,
0.1998602301,
-0.1180992126,
0.4950472713,
-0.1372222006,
0.2378230393,
-0.439917326,
-0.1890773624,
-0.2967651486,
0.2474433482,
0.0958975926,
-0.3257656097,
0.0536257736,
-0.4874708354,
0.1419337839,
-0.1724458784,
0.4265686572,
0.4413998127,
-0.395616889,
0.2715492547,
0.1358511597,
0.6341792941,
0.9516763687,
0.1624600887,
0.0395390838,
0.1639370471,
-0.2944718003,
-0.1598923355,
-0.4995673597,
-0.3209410906,
0.0213723034,
0.4077215791,
0.7247101665,
0.2862668931,
-0.5511040688,
0.6788390279,
-0.041473411,
-0.3165346682,
-0.1970509589,
0.3063336611,
0.155040428,
0.4634797275,
0.5131219029,
0.6097372174,
0.3140643835,
-0.5098862648,
0.4110505283,
0.3713292778,
-0.4584465027,
-0.5831285715,
0.3784882128,
0.0551323742,
-0.3837169111,
0.5043666363,
-0.3318620026,
-0.8611934781,
0.9344376922,
0.2468490005,
0.9076974392,
0.2773807347,
0.5888316631,
0.4929688275,
0.4242921174,
-0.0332373753,
0.5150763988,
-0.3804967999,
-0.3288894296,
-0.823169589,
-0.1965165734,
-0.481572181,
-0.251865834,
-0.9170942903,
-0.1386051327,
-0.7911271453,
-0.0420809351,
-0.3584570587,
-0.3747477829,
-0.5544975996,
0.2067189068,
0.2961051464,
0.9664154649,
-0.3707856834,
0.3343400657,
0.8882713318,
-0.3886215687,
-0.9434040785,
-0.0389812961,
0.2097898722,
-0.7697458863,
0.7724374533,
0.1367762536,
-0.0068141003,
0.0322611332,
-0.4482208788,
-0.725554347,
0.9150625467,
0.2462023795,
-0.1193319485,
-0.1037032902,
-0.1915839314,
0.4368092418,
0.1454364359,
0.2597959638,
0.1544545591,
0.3713794053,
0.1779716909,
-0.9347036481,
-0.0034591851,
-0.4065069258,
0.3095619977,
0.2235099375,
-0.8381635547,
1.0081137419,
-0.2196298242,
-0.3098954558,
0.2594826519,
0.3629999757,
-0.1226231828,
0.016289629,
0.1574356258,
0.4513078332,
0.3478831351,
-0.1725050658,
1.0272120237,
0.0994461253,
0.4005077779,
0.6902313232,
0.3525078893,
1.0123440027,
0.6755667329,
-0.0775543228,
0.3293820322,
0.7376107574,
-0.2065138221,
0.4327574968,
0.3681841791,
-0.1040706262,
-0.5482864976,
0.0886992738,
-0.2593697906,
0.5273535252,
0.0410462543,
0.2499621809,
-0.5353814363,
-0.0715908781,
-0.3464072943,
-0.2368421853,
-0.5289426446,
0.8925569654,
0.0918083563,
-0.9606937766,
0.5337663293,
-0.4098302722,
0.5020097494,
-0.4653052688,
0.0770881101,
-0.383395195,
0.0674711838,
-0.4373707473,
-0.724652648,
0.30526492,
-0.073489286,
-0.0447566248,
-0.1506192088,
0.5426190495,
-0.2079935968,
-0.3844928443,
-0.0419943072,
0.7153353095,
-0.012168983,
-0.1429708302,
-0.6167998314,
-0.2960495949,
0.0734431297,
-0.613566041,
0.232498616,
0.436095655,
-0.0119333612,
0.9630457759,
0.7261106968,
-0.0150412237,
0.432235539,
-0.1514214277,
1.0026985407,
-0.5402187705,
-0.3287050128,
-0.814596355,
0.9227669239,
-0.0023682897,
-0.7106769681,
0.7214980125,
0.8011077642,
0.7142823339,
-0.1586047858,
0.543740809,
-0.0783616528,
-0.1332935542,
-0.9329633713,
0.4491789937,
-0.6876571178,
0.1953261048,
-0.2309977412,
-1.0214617252,
-0.3600168824,
0.3792031109,
-0.2817384899,
-0.1170618385,
0.7435211539,
0.9954816103,
-0.0294266809,
-0.1491655707,
0.3334860206,
-0.1915201545,
0.1892554015,
0.7369017601,
1.3257228136,
-0.0683103949,
0.6909899116,
-0.2364955842,
-0.1525721699,
-0.0877265558,
-0.4742988646,
-1.118072629,
-0.4899235368,
-0.4211118817,
0.2172181159,
-0.0103989718,
0.5139883161,
0.8551260233,
-0.3751426637,
-0.1421261132,
-0.0597927831,
0.0349313878,
-0.2703256309,
-0.1410187781,
0.2363769263,
-0.3638725579,
-0.3213393688,
0.3110622168,
0.8468157053,
-0.1982786506,
-0.2499537319,
0.2759712338,
0.0074580931,
-0.0619914457,
0.7224404216,
0.2178173959,
-0.807231009,
-0.4330723286,
0.3672817349,
0.1653422564,
0.4407508373,
0.9718991518,
-0.8674115539,
0.412791729,
0.8580238819,
0.6055089831,
0.8509691954,
0.3049491346,
0.5771671534,
-0.6331952214,
0.1526693851,
0.2873035073,
0.2877475321,
0.2090564668,
-0.1017124653,
0.5064154863,
0.2149806768,
-0.2482783198,
-0.6879445314,
0.5640972853,
-1.184183836,
-0.3385124505,
1.1899087429,
-0.1592125148,
-0.4867125154,
-0.1712353826,
-0.3433248401,
-0.0274860375,
-0.1305535585,
0.2809566557,
0.5122749805,
-0.5749019384,
-0.6005792022,
-0.6727801561,
0.4690150619,
0.6612553,
-0.540311873,
-0.1568756551,
0.5296350121,
0.4583795965,
0.0878380835,
0.4083755314,
-0.0782622173,
0.8963746428,
0.0749506354,
-0.1154790223,
-0.6235172749,
-0.2983860672,
-0.3684380651,
0.3602124751,
-0.1224322245,
-0.303940028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06401v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06401v3
|
Autoregressive Language Models For Estimating the Entropy of Epic EHR Audit Logs
| 2023-11-10T21:32:34 | 2023-11-26T02:42:13 |
Benjamin C. Warner, Thomas Kannampallil, Seunghwan Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
EHR audit logs are a highly granular stream of events that capture clinician
activities, and is a significant area of interest for research in
characterizing clinician workflow on the electronic health record (EHR).
Existing techniques to measure the complexity of workflow through EHR audit
logs (audit logs) involve time- or frequency-based cross-sectional aggregations
that are unable to capture the full complexity of a EHR session. We briefly
evaluate the usage of transformer-based tabular language model (tabular LM) in
measuring the entropy or disorderedness of action sequences within workflow and
release the evaluated models publicly.
|
[
0.2507993579,
-0.8907405734,
0.4745647311,
-0.3101719618,
-0.109719947,
0.0123355025,
0.1218209192,
-0.484177351,
0.3330965638,
0.558537662,
-0.1472307295,
-0.2623074353,
-0.5565561652,
-0.0827152133,
-0.5565929413,
1.1736516953,
-0.4393756092,
-0.0866470933,
0.0853661373,
-0.0079128006,
-0.4402019382,
-0.7451138496,
-0.4606627524,
-0.472106725,
0.4578743577,
0.0243919399,
0.5002740622,
0.6307915449,
0.9254726171,
0.3246690035,
-0.1483826935,
-0.398532778,
-0.3198014796,
0.4014539421,
0.0880435333,
-0.6762902737,
-1.0041795969,
-0.4371522069,
0.4401843846,
0.2336532921,
-0.8850748539,
0.5274448395,
-0.0653220639,
0.647288084,
-0.6042900681,
0.4467929006,
-0.354590416,
0.2934001088,
-0.264909029,
-0.2381898463,
-0.2327676862,
-0.2515848875,
0.1977959424,
0.0453624465,
0.2307154387,
0.2071200907,
0.6252897978,
0.2187277526,
-0.3106412888,
-0.2861186266,
-1.1666331291,
0.484744221,
-0.7555252314,
0.5541762114,
0.6157012582,
0.2942838669,
0.1977442801,
-0.9575136304,
-0.3907803893,
0.0314700902,
-0.1382889301,
0.0012337824,
-0.5117606521,
0.2174408436,
0.0164212119,
0.7272149324,
-0.7297035456,
0.3501054645,
-0.5240449309,
0.1277621686,
0.8092876673,
1.0189586878,
0.298761487,
-0.1036101803,
-0.0064597982,
-0.0665480793,
-0.0365082435,
0.1545275599,
-0.0364869051,
-0.2107722461,
-0.1958242357,
0.4570120871,
-0.0412638709,
0.615208745,
0.0361431204,
-0.5440990925,
0.3215701878,
-0.1650608927,
-0.7204657793,
0.1952559054,
0.818780899,
0.0763196275,
-0.6623625755,
-0.2470861524,
-0.5348086357,
-0.2459879518,
0.3836971521,
-0.4264830649,
-0.4802177846,
0.5174453259,
-0.5898798704,
-0.2569938302,
-0.1089600846,
-0.770370841,
-0.2288942486,
-0.2614219785,
0.4509547055,
-0.1370552629,
-0.2407428771,
-0.0969402716,
0.0209854785,
0.0457560681,
0.3677643836,
-0.6736794114,
0.2486335039,
0.6169614792,
0.7581855059,
-0.1478909403,
-0.3701220155,
-0.2791558504,
0.0958864689,
-0.2617197037,
0.6216431856,
-0.4189023674,
-0.0278590545,
0.098703362,
-0.0014980905,
-0.4114508629,
-0.5271762013,
0.4721005261,
-0.7630092502,
-0.013870311,
0.2410119623,
-0.6298256516,
-0.3390395939,
0.1273308098,
-0.737247467,
0.948633194,
0.1865887493,
-0.6537458897,
0.6016677618,
-0.6947174668,
-0.1028133184,
0.3747106493,
-0.0239306316,
-0.6590128541,
0.1694096625,
-0.3367335498,
0.5082377195,
-0.3786021769,
0.695653379,
-0.0944341496,
0.2605443299,
0.2362656891,
-0.5263524055,
0.6145365834,
0.4212738276,
-0.3330549598,
0.0203575548,
-0.6552413702,
-0.1796127856,
0.0944215208,
-0.4840191007,
-0.4361139536,
0.3311779201,
0.0724227354,
0.1331899166,
0.1821198016,
-0.1858932525,
-0.025979111,
-0.0445099622,
0.169271186,
0.2864130735,
0.1525107175,
0.0549183413,
-0.6737514138,
0.5268211961,
0.2855421305,
0.087886326,
-0.1557425112,
-0.4284151793,
-0.3548080325,
-0.4628011584,
0.0438768715,
0.9248457551,
0.0050172186,
0.7828617096,
-0.2957172394,
-0.7163069248,
-0.4176508486,
0.3421863616,
0.4345953465,
0.3441176116,
0.0296905842,
-0.6323043704,
-0.3103456497,
-0.6676789522,
-0.3558078408,
-0.7313418984,
-0.1285640448,
0.2140586823,
0.6748821735,
-0.3235245347,
0.5636633635,
-0.4632996619,
-0.3816157281,
-0.2884637713,
0.6658155322,
0.2946001291,
0.4366386831,
0.1046258807,
-0.5237098932,
-0.4305051565,
0.2434259057,
-0.9345402122,
0.0736223161,
0.1725224108,
0.3265234232,
0.4371412098,
0.3993513584,
-0.5386322737,
0.8591436744,
0.3120962381,
-0.5681008101,
0.2413462251,
-0.4852563441,
0.2215272039,
-0.7019758821,
0.0520573817,
-0.1653264463,
-0.2016639858,
-1.0337878466,
0.0489126854,
0.0087726796,
0.0034665202,
-0.2945500612,
0.030821193,
-0.5181164145,
0.1747350246,
0.1089507192,
-0.5354189277,
-0.0444054268,
0.4314054251,
0.1031592414,
0.0901103616,
0.6355774999,
-0.6579477787,
0.5134187937,
0.0830482319,
-0.4114325941,
0.6735574603,
-0.5138013363,
-0.1471606493,
-0.4621052146,
0.1451177448,
-0.8727831244,
-0.6164207458,
-0.2363316417,
-0.1429293454,
0.6026040912,
-0.2003156543,
-0.3056882322,
-0.3357159495,
-0.014994313,
0.5136259198,
0.6564626694,
-0.0477073826,
0.8961020708,
0.7567688227,
-0.2122505307,
-0.1773031056,
-0.7349443436,
0.1194942445,
-0.6077246666,
-0.4696594179,
-0.0759382695,
0.2709642649,
-0.6869441867,
-0.1987034678,
-0.0217906181,
-0.5245141387,
0.0527521335,
0.3207833767,
0.2788431346,
-0.3713453114,
-0.0420764424,
-0.3892014623,
0.392337203,
0.4561828673,
0.021251332,
0.3345012367,
-0.1809580177,
-0.6208178997,
-0.863376081,
0.448017627,
0.9124668241,
-0.0628730282,
0.9426135421,
0.3463830948,
-0.7584626079,
0.3591713011,
-0.9161401391,
0.0348257646,
-0.2870048583,
0.3895692527,
0.2133170068,
-0.6275806427,
1.1101374626,
0.4055089951,
0.1868776828,
0.4187912643,
0.7948074341,
-0.0445746221,
0.8794148564,
0.3025473952,
-0.1341370493,
0.255072087,
-0.0706620216,
0.4832941592,
-0.7125101089,
-0.5567053556,
-0.6145596504,
-0.0092199417,
-0.4656385183,
-0.3176582158,
0.7608579397,
0.1160144061,
-0.3147364557,
-0.0181108583,
-0.0845370889,
0.1113109365,
0.2360848039,
0.302690655,
0.3347463906,
-0.1573284715,
0.1650405675,
0.0395012014,
-0.7080309391,
-0.4539805055,
0.8540994525,
0.6139895916,
1.1301958561,
0.256159991,
0.7939722538,
0.4490606189,
0.3570013046,
-0.5050683022,
-0.1194358841,
0.3374311328,
-0.8243717551,
-0.7783773541,
-0.1896793097,
-1.0866417885,
-0.0018004195,
0.1089580506,
-1.206843853,
0.2557359934,
0.4705190957,
-0.3342909217,
0.7887822986,
-0.6128244996,
0.8920296431,
-0.0444336012,
-0.1114265174,
0.0383710414,
-0.5383726358,
0.4835930467,
-0.4407892823,
0.4772364795,
0.2441302538,
0.2467099577,
0.9775159955,
-0.8453674316,
1.0094746351,
0.0200672764,
-0.3420255184,
0.4989444911,
0.4872421324,
0.9763625264,
-0.0842105001,
0.2974132299,
0.3536197245,
0.0149908634,
-0.090389356,
-0.3516594172,
0.3460206985,
-0.5752200484,
-0.6086512208,
-0.4846310318,
-0.3667194545,
0.1578702331,
-0.0009315793,
0.2657364905,
0.5312129855,
-0.2722476721,
0.1897408366,
0.6796500683,
0.1455853283,
0.7445011139,
0.6367172599,
0.1099282354,
-0.256090343,
0.5271840096,
0.3924801648,
0.0714502856,
0.5575432777,
0.0570288524,
0.0119365975,
-0.5295668244,
-0.2680121958,
-0.0910092145,
-0.5169519782,
-0.4058478475,
-1.0825153589,
-0.2167811543,
-0.2215744555,
-0.050285086,
-0.2249106616,
-0.1307071745,
-0.251447916,
-0.1847071052,
0.6284805536,
0.9613795877,
-0.3049915135,
0.2271815538,
-0.9797595143,
0.0515428856,
0.5947036147,
0.4551052451,
0.2410421818,
-0.6921257377,
-0.48454386,
-0.3661023676,
-0.2944024801,
-1.0791019201,
0.821549356,
0.0854331851,
0.4562740624,
0.5736099482,
-0.0239295904,
0.5849017501,
-0.6016490459,
0.9539266825,
0.3037259281,
-0.8733943701,
0.5398096442,
-0.3481861353,
0.1239669323,
0.292858839,
0.2441139966,
-0.3221327662,
-0.7384263873,
-0.8474223614,
-1.0252716541,
0.6914215088,
0.1974066943,
-0.2475927472,
0.0943419263,
-0.0348512456,
-0.0524256639,
0.0850763097,
-0.5204587579,
-0.4654518068,
-0.0410934687,
-0.0959845185,
-0.0749764666,
-0.2884964645,
-0.2829016149,
-0.2466387898,
0.4509066641,
0.3342964649,
0.2833312154,
0.4531276524,
-0.1877202988,
-0.5827143192,
0.4487429857,
0.5446602106,
0.8681538701,
-0.3947027922,
0.2810664475,
0.5872910619,
-0.7511472106,
0.2160077989,
-0.078225024,
0.1450591236,
0.2491624504,
0.5730023384,
0.950958848,
0.0038813623,
-0.5569711328,
0.4882591665,
-0.0183187779,
-0.2122390866,
-0.6649823189,
0.0851214379,
-0.2368428856,
0.2858434319,
0.4427969754,
-0.3158981502,
0.4329061806,
-0.4355489612,
0.0901115313,
0.1973786503,
-0.7862563133,
-0.5243860483,
0.8784755468,
-0.208405152,
-0.7487770319,
0.4184866548,
0.193129912,
-0.322275281,
0.6117441058,
0.5520282388,
1.1818226576,
-0.679823339,
-0.2034545243,
0.3043724298,
0.5207354426,
-0.2173548937,
0.3395552635,
0.228490755,
-0.2133288085,
-0.410841465,
-0.5778145194,
-0.2267217785,
0.4749822915,
-1.2793803215,
-0.1022861451,
0.1339759827,
-0.2513381839,
0.0873279497,
-0.6365613937,
-0.9836375713,
0.2519637346,
-0.005787293,
0.6014122367,
-1.1663582325,
0.369997412,
0.7196010947,
-0.1540918499,
-0.793865025,
-0.2704579532,
0.2233926952,
-0.7297415137,
0.720307827,
-0.5691842437,
0.4601667821,
-0.4875625074,
-0.3095063567,
-0.9302505255,
1.1646059752,
-0.0954490975,
-0.6309215426,
-0.0385094248,
0.0607036911,
0.7990564704,
-0.1609648615,
0.2843830884,
0.6786389947,
0.270549953,
-0.4913949072,
-1.4927027225,
-0.0390176699,
-0.2131845355,
0.0405685902,
0.6990904808,
-0.391328454,
0.7778350711,
-0.0478532761,
0.0311172102,
-0.6829960346,
0.6386783719,
0.0602710806,
0.6544607282,
0.4173331857,
0.8595688939,
0.9374238849,
0.2324873805,
0.9465326071,
-0.4056669176,
0.4787940085,
0.8648998737,
-0.3147564232,
0.8542895317,
0.404050082,
-0.3569644988,
0.6797500849,
0.245048061,
0.3501690626,
0.2023159415,
0.171046868,
-0.4341029823,
-0.1270854622,
0.0409368165,
-0.3558636308,
0.3096769154,
0.4827263355,
-0.6391897798,
-0.1221179441,
-0.0696229711,
0.2091410607,
-0.5361717939,
-0.4738076925,
1.3558652401,
0.0920905843,
-0.8020772934,
0.6172966361,
-0.1501028389,
0.0011059936,
-0.3340952992,
0.0933806449,
-0.0696286634,
-0.0182862058,
-0.2554015219,
-0.6746391654,
0.4276906848,
0.2993549109,
-0.2496794313,
-0.0670200065,
0.5394098163,
-0.3457849026,
-0.3909418881,
-0.0797186941,
0.6941410303,
0.4130495191,
0.3979289234,
-0.3466166258,
-0.3105008304,
-0.3415924609,
-0.4525952041,
0.3410070539,
0.8040639162,
-0.1109832376,
0.6575216055,
0.1830139756,
0.0595483668,
0.2079997957,
-0.0593726337,
0.5177239776,
-0.6570187211,
-0.6484199762,
-1.0984536409,
0.5797975063,
0.2904797792,
-0.3721418083,
0.484572351,
0.649068594,
0.4827341139,
-0.0910706371,
0.757157445,
-0.2590023279,
0.4226580262,
-0.4977085292,
0.7512817383,
-0.3981668651,
0.1022300422,
-0.3021404445,
-0.4195746481,
-0.2184422612,
0.1993647069,
0.1060415953,
-0.3025761843,
0.8223125935,
0.5653068423,
-0.1126624048,
0.0393200107,
0.26684466,
0.3344461322,
0.0867441595,
0.451318115,
0.5796278119,
-0.4662430882,
0.2732489705,
-0.2212359607,
-0.3159795105,
-0.5028981566,
-0.920802176,
-0.820358336,
-0.8143528104,
-0.5807303786,
-0.5980662107,
-0.1460441649,
0.9128281474,
0.3559824526,
-0.9759128094,
-0.5054915547,
0.0286465064,
0.0539571308,
-0.3424932063,
-0.2299397737,
0.5586608052,
-0.2957494259,
-0.1958411634,
-0.0860047191,
0.3515795767,
0.1425902992,
-0.2073454112,
0.045887731,
0.0589653701,
0.0947536975,
0.4849278629,
0.4330513477,
-0.6896663308,
0.0640017986,
-0.048523061,
-0.2047433406,
0.1866637021,
0.8300516009,
-0.0611235946,
0.4485814273,
0.9441529512,
0.2370881587,
0.4593684375,
-0.2757055163,
0.4739156961,
-0.2613509595,
-0.3189051747,
0.2676950395,
0.5935254693,
-0.1376565248,
-0.5319652557,
0.3371641934,
0.0182255302,
-0.9076535106,
-1.2426223755,
-0.1397662908,
-0.644330442,
0.2768559158,
0.8102820516,
-0.1687004417,
-0.4368743002,
-0.6173508763,
0.2907869518,
0.1794853956,
-0.3028710186,
1.0978541374,
0.660787642,
-0.4753345847,
0.015711695,
-0.6801955104,
0.5381880403,
0.0572711118,
-0.8315956593,
0.1754695922,
0.2984223366,
0.1125124842,
0.2670861185,
0.7380830646,
-0.2905751169,
0.2262516767,
-0.0113943284,
0.1459279358,
0.4234275222,
-0.2489681542,
-0.6896280646,
0.1410822868,
0.0695018023,
0.2292889953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06383v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06383v1
|
Distilling Large Language Models using Skill-Occupation Graph Context for HR-Related Tasks
| 2023-11-10T20:25:42 | 2023-11-10T20:25:42 |
Pouya Pezeshkpour, Hayate Iso, Thom Lake, Nikita Bhutani, Estevam Hruschka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Numerous HR applications are centered around resumes and job descriptions.
While they can benefit from advancements in NLP, particularly large language
models, their real-world adoption faces challenges due to absence of
comprehensive benchmarks for various HR tasks, and lack of smaller models with
competitive capabilities. In this paper, we aim to bridge this gap by
introducing the Resume-Job Description Benchmark (RJDB). We meticulously craft
this benchmark to cater to a wide array of HR tasks, including matching and
explaining resumes to job descriptions, extracting skills and experiences from
resumes, and editing resumes. To create this benchmark, we propose to distill
domain-specific knowledge from a large language model (LLM). We rely on a
curated skill-occupation graph to ensure diversity and provide context for LLMs
generation. Our benchmark includes over 50 thousand triples of job
descriptions, matched resumes and unmatched resumes. Using RJDB, we train
multiple smaller student models. Our experiments reveal that the student models
achieve near/better performance than the teacher model (GPT-4), affirming the
effectiveness of the benchmark. Additionally, we explore the utility of RJDB on
out-of-distribution data for skill extraction and resume-job description
matching, in zero-shot and weak supervision manner. We release our datasets and
code to foster further research and industry applications.
|
[
-0.2651278079,
-0.6960690022,
0.4771385789,
0.1133090258,
-0.0655890927,
-0.025456991,
-0.4571326673,
-0.5434027314,
0.038638711,
0.6511926651,
-0.55358392,
-0.697484076,
-0.4426159859,
-0.0433479063,
-0.3805762827,
0.8811238408,
0.0759119466,
-0.245298788,
-0.7394101024,
-0.0629143938,
-0.7473838329,
-0.4434572458,
-0.4194230139,
-0.4816518128,
0.6201063991,
0.4515230656,
0.267003119,
0.9296210408,
0.3554643691,
0.1835071295,
0.0834881961,
0.0878404602,
-0.4859621227,
0.4731203914,
-0.326402992,
-0.3360725343,
-0.5554641485,
0.0020039992,
0.7853037715,
1.0836112499,
-0.3540697694,
0.5651398301,
-0.0774689242,
0.5823861361,
-0.5800750852,
0.5692718029,
-0.6445515156,
-0.0574057885,
-0.5357400179,
0.1774795204,
-0.2064626068,
-0.0890563205,
-0.0441081412,
-0.222414434,
0.4721609652,
-0.0501023121,
0.5469175577,
0.0163757671,
-0.4076117277,
0.1786946207,
-0.6465762854,
0.8128274679,
-0.5717021823,
0.6492959261,
0.4007698298,
0.4655934572,
-0.0906879976,
-0.6169008613,
-0.4776206315,
0.0177230891,
-0.0073669343,
-0.0016026173,
0.159566015,
-0.0512941182,
0.2991822362,
0.3824977875,
-0.5701465011,
0.4580931365,
-0.4943677783,
0.2098651379,
0.5415604115,
0.3856063783,
0.0748956949,
0.0660583824,
-0.0246728379,
-0.4810224175,
-0.618946135,
0.0090254042,
0.480943501,
0.4298182726,
0.0494965911,
0.5653222203,
-0.5298503637,
0.9405100942,
-0.5543925762,
-0.3029040694,
0.1326108873,
-0.1380492747,
-0.1382937133,
-0.1874664277,
0.6494248509,
0.3163679838,
0.147276625,
-0.4451423287,
-0.2478054464,
0.0263291355,
0.6345157027,
-0.687041223,
-0.2741519809,
-0.0357648432,
-0.456784457,
-0.0129341213,
-0.196697861,
-0.8955046535,
-0.5581676364,
-0.2127830237,
-0.2505680323,
-0.1500366628,
-0.2599511445,
-0.1623715162,
-0.0951411575,
-0.0567122325,
0.1286546588,
-0.8485879898,
0.1586962193,
0.9916783571,
0.7061876655,
-0.4879242182,
-0.3329609632,
-0.3630226851,
0.0148236556,
-0.1282956153,
0.4297797978,
-0.5726384521,
-0.3119756281,
0.1776062101,
-0.0557598919,
-0.1641203761,
-0.6743641496,
0.503151238,
-0.642490387,
-0.1179389358,
-0.0091257794,
-0.4732225537,
-0.2800858319,
0.4061731994,
-0.6851590276,
1.2243192196,
0.4843229949,
-0.4725528955,
0.5107460618,
-0.5261201859,
-0.4510452747,
0.1197735071,
-0.4637492299,
-0.4910545349,
-0.0561227277,
0.1319746971,
0.7390224934,
-0.462308377,
0.2477092594,
-0.3795478344,
-0.3953631818,
0.1211826503,
-0.1119530201,
0.7211030126,
-0.0100823576,
0.1043214872,
-0.1768905967,
-0.7105542421,
0.0767839104,
0.1993909627,
-0.4469088018,
-0.2938142419,
-0.091583252,
0.0364369377,
0.3606353998,
0.2850227952,
-0.4251531065,
0.134597078,
-0.2613167763,
0.109721534,
0.5213496089,
-0.1331880689,
0.3296729624,
-0.1114905924,
0.9542461634,
-0.1740988046,
-0.0865114033,
0.0679710135,
-0.3039542437,
-0.0760151148,
-0.4326086044,
0.1907960325,
0.4748263657,
-0.5166819692,
0.527684927,
-0.4979254007,
-0.8128753304,
-0.5837000608,
0.4179317057,
0.5023384094,
0.8717428446,
0.4798800349,
-0.5531695485,
-0.5025078058,
-1.0350446701,
-0.5638312101,
-0.0098800911,
0.0060128053,
0.3537511528,
0.3286864758,
-0.3341312706,
1.0570693016,
-0.5805763602,
-0.4873279929,
-0.2560095191,
-0.1631177664,
0.6372458339,
0.4187115431,
0.4600008726,
-0.668700695,
-0.4879539609,
-0.0138296559,
-0.863268435,
-0.0936060697,
0.0389360487,
-0.2385282069,
-0.0882597864,
0.3521791101,
-0.5944000483,
0.1787786782,
0.5252967477,
-0.167360127,
0.6898792982,
-0.0558080524,
-0.0178767275,
-0.8914449215,
0.4493916333,
0.303966701,
-0.3575368822,
-0.3668715954,
0.2507967055,
0.1437846124,
-0.1813570261,
-0.2647074759,
0.6216285229,
-0.4779061079,
-0.4258083105,
-0.0669949204,
0.3136044741,
-0.0374273285,
0.483917892,
0.0560167693,
0.5931012034,
0.557182014,
-0.4385734499,
0.6253429055,
0.51709342,
-0.7562202811,
0.6466901898,
-0.4544836879,
-0.0377300829,
-0.0314495564,
0.4905871451,
-0.630559206,
-0.2217147201,
-0.2081995159,
0.1073661372,
0.1553037167,
-0.5435805917,
-0.7114549875,
-0.7116557956,
-0.0639754757,
0.3180472255,
0.6196630001,
-0.4590091109,
0.4723526537,
0.5314917564,
-0.4199754894,
-0.8798367977,
-0.7383688688,
-0.0167666953,
-0.3146199584,
-0.38924703,
0.6186950803,
0.3393961489,
-0.143553704,
-0.1717355549,
-0.2279565036,
-0.4352319241,
0.2360994667,
0.4330934286,
0.5816571116,
-0.0362367854,
0.0401180238,
-0.09206824,
0.2039716393,
0.2069887221,
-0.0213730186,
0.4466136992,
0.2451500744,
-0.4047251642,
-0.1886107773,
0.0471590087,
0.340157181,
-0.2395127714,
0.946410358,
0.7912436724,
-0.0177037045,
-0.3756304383,
-0.565399766,
-0.2009129971,
-0.4083090425,
0.6595302224,
-0.2617825568,
-0.7810032964,
0.5851364136,
-0.2460480481,
0.2851135731,
0.2648026645,
0.4419383705,
0.0009870729,
0.6964867115,
0.662582159,
-0.0945556089,
0.7340070605,
-0.2443624884,
0.2130266428,
-0.9865663648,
-0.2445968539,
-0.3819979429,
-0.3550696969,
-0.2717948258,
-0.3176062703,
0.4205998778,
0.105849728,
0.0272550117,
0.534398675,
-0.5700035691,
0.4269721806,
0.6419629455,
-0.0816961899,
0.0271656848,
-0.101747632,
0.1666763872,
-0.0086775701,
-0.4971401393,
-0.3525609076,
1.2411600351,
0.3712047935,
0.5831480026,
0.0626005158,
0.8742802143,
0.2685321569,
0.3123656213,
-0.401628226,
0.5822913051,
-0.3824280798,
-0.566308558,
-0.3108327985,
-0.6022358537,
-0.7830629349,
0.4393262267,
-0.3872437775,
-0.8157686591,
-0.0833427161,
0.2670025229,
-0.1550604999,
0.1092476547,
-0.6284592748,
1.2686308622,
-0.0499687456,
-0.3874232471,
-0.2500855625,
-0.4909189045,
0.5035532713,
-0.2950907052,
0.357363075,
-0.2603978813,
0.2724153399,
0.7711234689,
-0.2855183184,
0.7931879163,
-0.3462049663,
-0.1341222823,
0.1216967702,
0.1822788268,
0.6501565576,
-0.0655732974,
-0.4967947304,
0.2463932186,
0.1308734417,
-0.1649189442,
-0.3998387158,
0.7804234624,
-0.5386871099,
-0.3933146298,
0.0515749268,
-0.7699030042,
-0.4694560468,
0.4108144045,
-0.2041393816,
0.3210029602,
-0.3132857382,
0.4245200455,
0.3735294938,
-0.2721197605,
0.0558820479,
0.340715915,
-0.2691025138,
0.2071025074,
0.7286481857,
0.0414435714,
0.0191396587,
0.205114916,
-0.170002237,
-0.5544274449,
-0.2610101402,
-0.3589429259,
0.2406530231,
-0.8464979529,
-0.2075748891,
-0.7318419218,
0.1250957251,
-0.7660132051,
-0.0783242658,
-0.3084779382,
-0.2159021348,
0.0181052629,
0.0365338996,
0.3190507889,
0.5854709744,
0.1323483884,
0.0981402993,
-0.589492023,
0.4698707163,
0.3279372156,
0.5868344903,
0.071564585,
-0.3847953975,
-0.5795547962,
0.0404379144,
-0.1214845553,
-0.4504677951,
0.4014203846,
0.2243035585,
0.7244053483,
0.003884912,
0.0298425164,
0.5652115941,
-0.4942495227,
0.7178803086,
0.0373273268,
-0.5364752412,
0.2815342247,
-0.4557932615,
-0.0065697073,
0.6595526338,
0.1860868037,
-0.7150248289,
-0.3803780973,
-0.5610072613,
-1.2620403767,
0.8681826591,
-0.0347190984,
0.0509280637,
-0.1277436465,
0.3839839399,
0.310845226,
0.4156017601,
-0.6292236447,
-0.2374642342,
0.0087268911,
-0.4113027453,
-0.0726018548,
-0.1343503594,
-0.1776743978,
-0.0795774311,
0.5545534492,
0.1096288711,
0.0874827504,
-0.4437200427,
-0.2715145051,
0.1448123306,
0.2740461826,
0.2106601298,
0.7800769806,
-0.3474781811,
0.1661698073,
0.2860348821,
-0.2225599885,
-0.2872672677,
0.1975188404,
0.3826167583,
-0.0980473012,
0.3912432492,
0.516073823,
0.0394825786,
-1.0834246874,
0.5863764286,
0.2166729271,
-0.0039017273,
-0.3385521472,
0.4512701333,
0.2476655245,
0.2734763026,
0.2680232525,
-0.3863941133,
-0.0518783256,
-0.6409496069,
0.1393261254,
0.4806323946,
-0.0934265479,
0.0385898873,
0.7508149147,
0.048611261,
-0.158314839,
0.8652892709,
-0.1143585145,
-0.1600348651,
0.7756746411,
0.6235318184,
0.5100774169,
0.0745980144,
-0.0443155691,
0.2739145756,
-0.2706099451,
-0.4665226638,
0.0395725071,
-0.0943182409,
-0.576096952,
-0.4650222063,
-0.6816007495,
-0.4650351107,
-0.0869457945,
-1.0384098291,
0.0005404617,
-0.3350298405,
-0.0403402522,
0.1020432115,
-0.2868692279,
-1.1918215752,
0.4446117878,
0.0189463422,
0.4814272523,
-0.9263606071,
0.9432315826,
0.7235259414,
-0.4292700291,
-0.4930587411,
-0.4153126478,
-0.2608765364,
-1.0162471533,
0.9744752645,
0.1017913967,
0.2515729368,
0.0391706638,
-0.0914684683,
-0.4176915288,
1.2928463221,
0.4324089885,
-0.6935599446,
-0.1762772053,
0.098106049,
0.5216516852,
-0.4860266149,
0.2305323482,
0.7295291424,
0.2267539948,
-0.4066172242,
-0.943672061,
0.0278563537,
-0.0217783544,
0.2397267371,
0.0988776237,
-0.3256809413,
1.0433790684,
0.185821563,
-0.1605644077,
-0.3441352844,
0.4627747238,
0.3280721307,
0.0236637462,
0.5806851387,
0.445102334,
0.6844969392,
0.0626040548,
1.0188012123,
-0.4261112213,
0.438582927,
1.407679677,
-0.5007712841,
0.7523892522,
0.2961907685,
-0.3808680177,
0.8977696896,
0.3271038532,
-0.2555820048,
0.2408901006,
0.2965498269,
-0.0698778555,
-0.2824686766,
-0.2225310206,
-0.3710688651,
0.4611614943,
0.2157161981,
-0.4036230147,
-0.3431523144,
0.0808481798,
-0.2070991546,
0.3161951602,
-0.2141375542,
0.591651082,
0.0158897154,
-0.5871748924,
0.3852126598,
0.139765203,
0.6093353033,
-0.349568069,
-0.2702577114,
-0.0902457163,
0.1215478629,
-0.127939716,
-1.0708799362,
0.2594095469,
0.096308507,
-0.3721055686,
-0.631937623,
0.5965110064,
-0.6301512718,
-0.113224104,
0.2222009003,
0.5130661726,
0.2752248645,
-0.1176908091,
-0.6531112194,
-0.0154870348,
-0.2712575197,
-0.105161041,
0.4758839011,
0.3921769857,
0.0375916846,
0.6963534951,
0.4163922071,
0.3435159624,
-0.0409417339,
0.1008324325,
0.5986341834,
-0.6915293336,
-0.7786114216,
-0.7231600881,
0.3673650026,
-0.2753863335,
-0.2433466464,
0.6383972168,
0.6380971074,
0.9203323126,
-0.2115651369,
0.8303900957,
-0.2248971015,
0.8292384744,
-0.3036442399,
0.5946871042,
-0.5384783149,
0.1820749044,
-0.3336797357,
-1.1503663063,
-0.0059961723,
0.5074265599,
-0.4190877378,
0.2648021877,
0.4457261264,
0.6873239279,
-0.2736358643,
-0.4341574013,
0.2764722705,
-0.0660015345,
0.3510774672,
0.3830049038,
0.3699088097,
-0.1532491595,
0.5092332363,
-0.2492886335,
0.093990609,
-0.5859875083,
-0.84080863,
-0.8961179852,
-0.5324434638,
-0.4679826796,
-0.3981898427,
-0.1488940269,
0.7337011695,
0.6771630645,
-0.4087466002,
-0.3698447347,
0.0451157838,
0.1877661943,
-0.6608433127,
-0.2838499546,
0.3308852911,
-0.1721538305,
-0.5489814281,
0.6755875945,
-0.025072474,
-0.2692248225,
-0.3733130991,
0.2693245113,
-0.0243220553,
-0.387711376,
0.4460676312,
0.4836909175,
-0.5179261565,
-0.1854216903,
-0.5475190282,
-0.2131190896,
-0.3616573513,
0.7973212004,
-0.6641052365,
0.4900526404,
0.223497957,
0.8432003856,
0.534414053,
0.0826513767,
0.5306797028,
-1.3326662779,
0.1885665953,
0.17146869,
0.3340525031,
0.3945862949,
-0.3257186413,
0.8260122538,
0.144044444,
-0.5012053251,
-1.1472120285,
0.1453659832,
-0.927903235,
-0.2915703356,
1.1163110733,
-0.2025787383,
-0.1225421876,
-0.2017153949,
0.2345969975,
0.4066009521,
-0.244271934,
0.9280492067,
0.473557055,
-0.0460287295,
-0.0293982327,
-0.8978494406,
0.3726341426,
0.1911784708,
-0.6255561113,
0.5513252616,
0.5761668682,
0.3379769027,
-0.0632392243,
0.7431947589,
0.1665396094,
0.2561429143,
0.0857842043,
0.5422872901,
-0.359249264,
-0.1344618499,
0.1072509438,
0.231943056,
0.2475062013,
-0.0396618322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06382v1
|
Transfer Learning for Structured Pruning under Limited Task Data
| 2023-11-10T20:23:35 | 2023-11-10T20:23:35 |
Lucio Dery, David Grangier, Awni Hannun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large, pre-trained models are problematic to use in resource constrained
applications. Fortunately, task-aware structured pruning methods offer a
solution. These approaches reduce model size by dropping structural units like
layers and attention heads in a manner that takes into account the end-task.
However, these pruning algorithms require more task-specific data than is
typically available. We propose a framework which combines structured pruning
with transfer learning to reduce the need for task-specific data. Our empirical
results answer questions such as: How should the two tasks be coupled? What
parameters should be transferred? And, when during training should transfer
learning be introduced? Leveraging these insights, we demonstrate that our
framework results in pruned models with improved generalization over strong
baselines.
|
[
-0.1084996313,
-0.4411304593,
0.4715322256,
0.2449740469,
-0.353315264,
-0.2933060825,
-0.308463037,
-0.4630350471,
-0.0569693148,
0.5624963641,
-0.8712443113,
-0.1536359787,
-0.4723511338,
-0.1710625589,
-0.607183814,
1.1759512424,
-0.2028095424,
-0.4907180369,
-0.4764519334,
-0.0843856484,
-0.774933219,
-0.5671756268,
-0.5368407965,
-0.2668195963,
0.4082713723,
0.526343286,
0.363611728,
0.7059586644,
0.7429572344,
0.2014376372,
0.0291716289,
0.294585079,
-0.7576035261,
0.0533755831,
-0.3646880686,
-0.5117363334,
-0.4199756086,
-0.1039089933,
0.5275665522,
1.1823351383,
0.0610309057,
0.4780058265,
0.2675850391,
0.6134911776,
-0.8289805651,
0.2916719913,
-0.3154602349,
0.4133791327,
-0.0888832062,
-0.2420098633,
-0.3069623411,
0.0576964803,
0.1888221204,
-0.8688970208,
0.4864865243,
-0.2112578452,
0.654800117,
0.479205817,
-0.6481816769,
0.4410789013,
-1.0269143581,
0.8533673882,
-0.0273351874,
0.2582577169,
0.4301527441,
0.1193596944,
0.1931499541,
-0.8186943531,
0.1121940762,
-0.1861514598,
-0.2551745772,
0.042831853,
0.0516720489,
0.1115664542,
0.2934520543,
0.226692602,
-0.4827564359,
-0.3587323725,
-0.7116318941,
-0.0600592904,
0.5095440745,
0.0395298451,
-0.1228609085,
0.1827679574,
-0.5527880192,
-0.2804481983,
-0.6897091866,
0.0333568752,
0.0881612971,
0.3844464123,
0.1704075336,
0.1616377532,
-0.1338475049,
0.9504387975,
0.3032456934,
-0.0357683711,
0.1684206724,
-0.469802767,
-0.4332254827,
-0.2271378189,
0.2833403647,
0.2208616436,
0.3265008926,
-0.4258663654,
-0.0694601461,
-0.020417532,
0.5222209096,
-0.8896846771,
-0.4774802029,
0.0441592932,
-0.3903392553,
-0.0914221033,
0.0164901577,
-0.0273778588,
0.0425639041,
-0.561897099,
0.2075680792,
-0.3004175425,
-0.3264771104,
-0.0154248634,
-0.0341632478,
0.0126361391,
0.411845535,
-0.628559947,
0.5436478853,
0.7038010359,
0.7815798521,
-0.453227371,
0.0090838149,
-0.7722941637,
0.6439662576,
-0.3021945357,
0.5020899773,
-0.5172150135,
-0.4561901093,
-0.3060699999,
0.3485820889,
-0.1921537519,
-0.5732818246,
0.5506657958,
-0.121900171,
-0.2002117932,
-0.3318822086,
-0.1942829788,
-0.3391276002,
0.2059204429,
-0.5906627178,
0.8924210668,
0.5950571895,
-0.5699671507,
0.2376720309,
-0.4265662134,
-0.9866105914,
0.0089223413,
-0.0056679049,
-0.4669679105,
0.3474185765,
0.016629193,
0.640589416,
-0.1213664338,
0.5438598394,
-0.2554766834,
-0.273904115,
-0.2753190994,
0.0826387927,
0.5264163613,
0.4464115798,
0.0554440916,
0.2667187154,
-0.5729783177,
0.0954035223,
0.0771040767,
-0.2410938591,
-0.3175350726,
-0.1514974087,
0.2196421325,
0.1790901423,
0.1691123694,
-0.4257603586,
0.2554863393,
-0.2254829854,
0.7587393522,
0.451692313,
-0.0423120596,
0.8519522548,
-0.673055172,
0.4695048928,
0.1621404886,
0.097541444,
0.1800409555,
0.1070446074,
-0.5212610364,
-0.0297210161,
0.2414394617,
0.5216247439,
-0.2977540791,
0.3677418232,
-0.3378246427,
-0.2901243567,
-0.0579680391,
0.2248713225,
0.3052220643,
0.6693332195,
0.4075508118,
-0.6660813093,
-0.6511338949,
-1.0277047157,
-0.0568892509,
0.0332639776,
-0.2698946297,
0.3060792983,
0.3262112439,
0.3211718202,
0.961643517,
-0.5404037237,
-0.631495595,
-0.4402938485,
0.0124342758,
0.0542367399,
1.0177289248,
0.5218814611,
-1.117685914,
-0.3754660189,
0.0695517436,
-0.4111700654,
0.2574965954,
-0.5154268146,
-0.0523620099,
-0.6397477388,
0.4551286101,
-0.7304148674,
0.2937467396,
0.4918043911,
-0.0949150398,
0.414988935,
-0.2029343545,
-0.0219848007,
-1.0558804274,
0.3398407102,
0.215356797,
-0.6611896753,
-0.7094762325,
-0.1130524129,
0.1051837355,
-0.4211767316,
-0.3754469156,
0.3701767325,
-0.6991032958,
-0.3259636164,
-0.2446422577,
-0.4480837882,
0.1325270087,
0.8195773363,
0.3731831014,
0.5218359828,
0.4019829929,
-0.731877327,
0.2828446031,
0.5183675289,
-0.2240412533,
0.537730813,
-0.5105925798,
0.2599398196,
0.0966811776,
0.3579048514,
-0.6576890945,
-0.08738143,
0.2995375991,
-0.1259683222,
0.508038342,
-0.4274718761,
0.0879007131,
-0.1972274035,
-0.0765799135,
0.63436836,
0.4500140548,
-0.088299647,
0.4828161597,
0.215523079,
-0.2681651711,
-0.2700724006,
-0.829138279,
-0.3060114384,
-0.289986819,
-0.5504603982,
1.1041982174,
0.0264884513,
0.1577282846,
0.3643485606,
-0.670070529,
-0.713500917,
0.3311705291,
0.4478098452,
0.0530293882,
0.0685592964,
0.1396253854,
-0.0184531901,
0.0709678233,
-0.0219792929,
-0.3717093766,
0.1131454632,
0.2795913219,
-0.2887837887,
-0.4122433364,
0.3235155642,
0.3752171695,
-0.5640358329,
0.6881865263,
0.5886031985,
-0.4329052866,
-0.4353638291,
-0.1446112841,
-0.3790454268,
-0.4283867776,
0.6857472658,
-0.4629770815,
-0.7496960759,
0.1091868505,
-0.413358748,
0.3280074596,
0.1511107385,
0.1314729899,
-0.0508741662,
0.8215951324,
1.0388572216,
-0.0223920718,
1.0054483414,
-0.4471484721,
0.0760691613,
-0.8650805354,
-0.2214438617,
-0.3833557367,
-0.6647574902,
0.0595732741,
-0.3724154532,
0.0021119253,
-0.0097415317,
-0.3083713055,
0.5241920948,
-0.7595182657,
0.3254595101,
0.399574995,
0.5288121104,
0.0444097966,
0.0676405132,
0.5276140571,
0.2186168432,
-0.8459330201,
0.1439193934,
1.0345747471,
0.1478919834,
0.1421297193,
-0.3919859529,
0.3472571671,
0.3884016573,
0.3238474727,
-0.7128971815,
0.5009111166,
-0.1905813664,
-0.4562166333,
-0.3747471273,
-0.7287306786,
-1.0216249228,
0.1326046288,
-0.1790658683,
-0.4530313611,
0.4412881732,
0.3817311227,
-0.5172499418,
0.1974130571,
-0.681935966,
0.8700708747,
-0.1072268486,
-0.5450969934,
-0.3973144889,
-0.6227650046,
0.3365577161,
-0.0494153798,
0.0961601511,
-0.2087594867,
-0.0659903064,
1.009920001,
-0.5529917479,
0.8088132739,
-0.2393826246,
0.3845312595,
0.2790569663,
0.2291180342,
0.7981712818,
-0.4018185139,
0.1995807439,
-0.3347665966,
0.0614079684,
-0.55452317,
-0.5365635753,
0.5483316779,
-0.4809858799,
-0.5081418753,
0.0035368423,
-0.9345456362,
-0.535926342,
-0.0274779052,
-0.1345510185,
0.2908842564,
0.0892693996,
0.508834362,
0.4750689864,
0.4439961612,
0.1006383002,
0.1549529731,
0.4372510016,
0.1433084756,
0.9234058857,
0.3440725207,
0.0200831573,
0.2875043452,
-0.0395037122,
0.1026005968,
-0.9705560803,
0.1157144234,
0.1448477954,
-0.3129218817,
-0.3512943685,
-0.239450708,
-0.2289326042,
-0.2791619003,
-0.2443811297,
-0.3524265885,
-0.4873510599,
-0.415628016,
-0.2282134444,
0.1222142801,
0.3693756759,
0.0900574923,
0.6021478772,
-0.9823357463,
0.2481739372,
0.2423290461,
0.180426538,
-0.087940447,
-0.5656289458,
-0.2471615225,
-0.1371012181,
-0.1371835917,
-0.9175505638,
0.5942215919,
0.5315831304,
0.4231831729,
0.3502934277,
0.5031212568,
0.7302470207,
-0.2202121466,
0.1809019893,
0.5099272132,
-0.6638134718,
0.5690997839,
-0.188275829,
0.1249491796,
0.6626303792,
0.56561023,
-0.3539969921,
0.1170159057,
-0.6178138256,
-0.746948421,
0.8690901399,
0.1682330072,
-0.1721673459,
0.406843245,
0.5519542098,
-0.0246161446,
0.235363096,
-0.4900637269,
0.2210495323,
0.016031852,
-0.3307854235,
0.0095460126,
-0.0671540573,
-0.2508024573,
-0.3712700903,
0.3571751714,
-0.0831671804,
-0.0475181974,
0.3706641495,
-0.5764432549,
-0.0890300199,
-0.0192773324,
0.050336577,
0.7950544953,
-0.0413821712,
-0.0035543463,
0.2036151439,
-0.4233042002,
0.2517849505,
-0.0440998115,
-0.1290899515,
-0.4037511051,
0.3377866149,
0.8296998143,
0.3168479502,
-0.5222013593,
0.4741948545,
0.2915809155,
-0.61502707,
0.0266622752,
0.1595621407,
0.0308211725,
0.2434351593,
0.2527382374,
0.4128500521,
0.2214797139,
-0.386467129,
0.2361644059,
0.2827431858,
-0.4280737936,
-0.5629492998,
0.3753167689,
0.5078858733,
-0.0995474905,
0.6726938486,
0.1522286683,
-0.2510145903,
0.9152464867,
0.4116763175,
0.5483679771,
-0.2757107317,
0.1661418676,
0.3381614983,
0.2576862872,
-0.4179372191,
-0.1128429249,
-0.71868819,
-0.3831965923,
-0.9461111426,
-0.4709365368,
-0.2969911993,
0.170447588,
-0.8026204109,
0.0291985609,
-0.6497452855,
-0.2815203667,
-0.3203651905,
0.1339706481,
-0.8895676136,
0.2086126208,
-0.0580282882,
0.7415587902,
-1.0613843203,
0.9423935413,
0.8129080534,
-0.0621746853,
-0.7425608635,
-0.5037586689,
-0.4600927234,
-0.439062655,
0.6869545579,
0.2952573299,
0.1741368473,
0.1296430975,
-0.3103793561,
-0.8488270044,
0.9226464629,
0.7950229645,
-0.8790717125,
-0.5179354548,
-0.1808354259,
-0.0332909524,
-0.2037042379,
-0.2326652408,
0.5323841572,
0.4460013211,
0.3682267666,
-1.0433762074,
0.1466740519,
-0.1271790266,
-0.144373253,
0.3231262565,
-0.5097643733,
0.8410355449,
-0.1332842261,
-0.5681863427,
-0.2955794036,
0.7705672979,
-0.2112400234,
0.2179866284,
0.7342791557,
0.4619581103,
0.6743687987,
-0.0177104287,
0.8013749719,
-0.2862605453,
0.2718562186,
1.2187643051,
-0.3110252023,
0.5789496303,
0.5064360499,
-0.3653072715,
0.0306739751,
0.7961999774,
0.097815603,
0.5236133933,
0.1833202094,
0.047503598,
-0.598116219,
-0.2940285206,
-0.2149223983,
0.1711198539,
0.1288229227,
-0.0990834236,
-0.2223505676,
0.3685279489,
-0.2900694013,
-0.1146498173,
-0.6719333529,
0.5937291384,
0.099895522,
-0.721427083,
0.4054861665,
-0.2275530547,
0.4377525747,
-0.7815642357,
-0.1367524862,
-0.1928892583,
0.2436845005,
-0.4791080058,
-0.4488921463,
0.7792770863,
-0.319355011,
-0.2148542106,
-0.8061215281,
1.0124047995,
-0.4085353613,
-0.2247125804,
0.0524588935,
0.6385714412,
0.1726531982,
-0.4512707889,
-0.4644435644,
-0.1824776381,
0.1205068454,
-0.4143833518,
0.8240420222,
0.1806918979,
-0.3632722497,
0.7170208693,
0.7107450366,
0.3113488257,
-0.2688120902,
-0.4446105063,
0.9921753407,
-0.4526910782,
-0.551993072,
-0.3516719341,
0.233502835,
0.0297810473,
0.0267642103,
0.3462947309,
0.3739655912,
0.7958592772,
-0.0784289092,
0.6336274743,
-0.0273775011,
0.387524873,
-0.2900709808,
0.2346454412,
-0.5160872936,
-0.0530195348,
0.3052147329,
-1.1366106272,
-0.1699170321,
0.7450940013,
-0.490405947,
0.0572072081,
0.5420655012,
0.3546331525,
-0.3521353304,
-0.3561308384,
0.3255363405,
-0.2000178844,
-0.154996708,
1.1491494179,
0.4500227571,
0.0847115293,
0.8657332063,
-0.4866569638,
-0.1878224611,
-0.2134203911,
-0.716996491,
-0.5999721289,
-0.6966899037,
-0.500415504,
0.0464709327,
0.2488369197,
0.540871501,
1.3427038193,
-0.6057792306,
-0.2818621993,
-0.3014189899,
-0.0320457295,
-0.6065715551,
-0.1564874649,
0.5088532567,
-0.1416178346,
-0.4687709212,
0.4370775819,
-0.1125607044,
-0.0624563918,
0.09298262,
0.1036657169,
-0.0406204052,
-0.3101681769,
0.3976383209,
0.5904391408,
-0.0350547172,
-0.2717338204,
-0.2137531936,
0.2922619581,
0.0437232777,
1.1880251169,
-1.0543072224,
-0.2614107132,
0.5455187559,
0.7460715175,
1.0287920237,
0.3711670935,
0.7330672145,
-1.1616612673,
0.4687510133,
0.5257800817,
0.2542516291,
0.1520295143,
-0.4571793973,
0.7254763842,
0.3638391495,
-0.3447357714,
-0.8181533813,
0.4128225744,
-1.0634893179,
-0.5943478942,
0.7812820673,
-0.4108453393,
-0.5091652274,
-0.0155479256,
0.0072297766,
0.3351646662,
-0.0595291555,
0.2329432219,
0.4430908859,
-0.2034037858,
-0.2774174213,
-0.3384062946,
0.5463822484,
0.6908563972,
-0.8493113518,
0.3420407772,
0.5359266996,
0.27404055,
-0.01154962,
0.4507262409,
0.3884665072,
0.3477631211,
-0.1370711923,
-0.0525663085,
-0.7311544418,
-0.776473999,
-0.1226346046,
0.6616423726,
-0.0681529716,
-0.4749772251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06379v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06379v1
|
DeMuX: Data-efficient Multilingual Learning
| 2023-11-10T20:09:08 | 2023-11-10T20:09:08 |
Simran Khanuja, Srinivas Gowriraj, Lucio Dery, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We consider the task of optimally fine-tuning pre-trained multilingual
models, given small amounts of unlabelled target data and an annotation budget.
In this paper, we introduce DEMUX, a framework that prescribes the exact
data-points to label from vast amounts of unlabelled multilingual data, having
unknown degrees of overlap with the target set. Unlike most prior works, our
end-to-end framework is language-agnostic, accounts for model representations,
and supports multilingual target configurations. Our active learning strategies
rely upon distance and uncertainty measures to select task-specific neighbors
that are most informative to label, given a model. DeMuX outperforms strong
baselines in 84% of the test cases, in the zero-shot setting of disjoint source
and target language sets (including multilingual target pools), across three
models and four tasks. Notably, in low-budget settings (5-100 examples), we
observe gains of up to 8-11 F1 points for token-level tasks, and 2-5 F1 for
complex tasks. Our code is released here:
https://github.com/simran-khanuja/demux.
|
[
-0.3929526806,
-0.5778023601,
0.3722192049,
0.1463519931,
-0.0824301466,
0.0942912102,
-0.4463091195,
-0.4517085254,
0.2018834949,
0.1044751182,
-0.5655956864,
-0.7147372365,
-0.6622232199,
0.1639597863,
-0.3455955088,
0.6424059868,
-0.2439490855,
0.0193250403,
-0.0294625871,
-0.2490458041,
0.1313199997,
-0.4596731067,
-0.4369595349,
-0.2144484818,
0.9503325224,
0.8793239594,
0.5623291731,
0.7203086019,
0.3825909495,
0.263656199,
0.1475540996,
0.2394826412,
-0.605409205,
0.2994489372,
-0.0736404285,
-0.4091702402,
-0.2120286524,
-0.0632896125,
0.7106867433,
0.8739786148,
-0.0665038452,
0.3937961757,
-0.1343563795,
0.596434772,
-0.9271705151,
0.3240384758,
-0.4208090305,
0.0356590524,
-0.3766729534,
0.3168751895,
-0.4211986065,
0.0076993308,
-0.2070664465,
-0.8112789392,
-0.1332897693,
-0.336076498,
1.0137646198,
0.4264409542,
-0.3338271379,
-0.0805902258,
-0.7149519324,
0.8188821077,
-0.3164483607,
0.9827209115,
0.7655210495,
0.287907064,
0.3945256472,
-0.6913305521,
-0.3110403121,
0.0869060159,
-0.0712308735,
0.2083126158,
-0.3310097158,
0.0419789404,
0.2131021619,
0.1682350785,
-0.3142741919,
0.2905116677,
-0.3609523177,
-0.2786730826,
0.5303359628,
-0.1837520152,
-0.0011321527,
0.2779379785,
-0.3283557296,
-0.2162763923,
-0.4522711933,
0.0521881767,
0.8269396424,
0.5521039963,
-0.2464960814,
0.3552184403,
-0.4290163815,
1.1721508503,
0.1161941737,
-0.1477455348,
0.4021772742,
-0.1931398362,
0.042438522,
0.1802059263,
0.5170076489,
-0.1013171002,
0.4186320305,
-0.1729411185,
-0.3994233608,
-0.1760176122,
-0.0514053665,
-0.855758667,
-0.6114442945,
0.1609814167,
0.1875760853,
-0.076879628,
-0.1688895673,
-0.4649097025,
-0.3062500656,
-0.7839087248,
0.3855988979,
-0.3486410081,
-0.3052697182,
0.0975829735,
0.2383310795,
-0.123570323,
0.3388549984,
-0.7734829187,
0.1319731772,
0.4096843898,
0.7032130957,
-0.0465809479,
-0.5076421499,
-0.6290996671,
0.1525948495,
-0.5641826391,
0.5705021024,
-0.8574377298,
-0.0097517166,
-0.0522276908,
-0.0687788725,
-0.1989000738,
-0.3067218661,
0.2559773922,
-0.357055366,
-0.0316368528,
-0.4540221989,
-0.386990875,
-0.4404625893,
0.5028729439,
-0.8308059573,
1.0690952539,
0.2717773616,
-0.709284544,
0.4913614392,
-0.5297852159,
-0.7665124536,
-0.1226494983,
-0.0323564,
-0.2453644425,
-0.0829121098,
0.0800738633,
0.4814581573,
0.0374441929,
0.2435197532,
-0.2548875511,
-0.1931463629,
-0.0652362108,
-0.4470843673,
0.5577558875,
0.3204678595,
-0.1614063084,
0.0462057516,
-0.8586454391,
-0.0803403407,
0.0430862755,
-0.4603732228,
-0.4297251701,
-0.4464623928,
0.0476228371,
0.2279554158,
0.2704944015,
-0.5650783181,
0.0937961042,
-0.1736772507,
0.118231982,
0.6464245915,
-0.3543978631,
0.5055709481,
0.0937934667,
0.6507210732,
0.2572784126,
0.1920891553,
-0.3481531441,
-0.0661076978,
-0.6776862144,
-0.770803988,
0.9555383325,
0.4849580824,
-0.7938450575,
0.0620701946,
-0.3298805952,
-0.434610635,
-0.6036902666,
0.3698708415,
0.2123701572,
0.4398168027,
0.3955180943,
0.0086285667,
-0.1944167912,
-1.0899909735,
0.0117250504,
0.0244880188,
0.3008090556,
0.058082249,
0.3246398568,
-0.2389928699,
0.8238068819,
-0.5816262364,
-0.2562003434,
-0.3233087361,
0.0469804555,
-0.0250457171,
0.2068927139,
0.6449052095,
-1.019499898,
-0.8810443878,
0.0680570453,
-0.4899318516,
-0.0833852515,
-0.0370369665,
-0.1458701193,
0.0974017084,
0.3342934549,
-0.3546236157,
-0.0183930006,
0.6302975416,
0.0475696996,
0.2438494712,
-0.3255931437,
0.1307247132,
-1.0880782604,
0.1353196055,
0.0181828272,
-0.1461821944,
-0.8866917491,
-0.2802757621,
0.3764541447,
-0.1798292249,
-0.5226951241,
0.7887490988,
-0.4707612097,
0.1705005765,
0.0240505617,
0.1752269268,
0.1014153957,
0.5278743505,
0.1241501346,
0.2426591069,
1.040956974,
-0.5230016708,
0.4408783019,
0.0478009135,
-0.2358377874,
0.6599160433,
-0.2432249784,
-0.1178207546,
-0.2332940251,
-0.0909388214,
-0.837335825,
-0.4010981619,
0.3082912862,
-0.2651639283,
0.7969947457,
-0.3259122968,
-0.5707258582,
-0.1422070265,
0.0010618703,
0.5651288033,
0.1174656898,
-0.6541612744,
0.5411260724,
0.4777779877,
0.0110277021,
-0.8848631978,
-0.7339118123,
-0.0495366007,
-0.1477874815,
-0.326315105,
0.0166057646,
0.0898008645,
-0.3180409074,
-0.1513356119,
-0.2899967134,
-0.3264890611,
0.131257236,
0.1630178392,
-0.2164251953,
0.1068642661,
0.4529750049,
0.15680857,
-0.3390591443,
-0.3482816517,
-0.2831585705,
0.2884584963,
-0.0567495748,
-0.6531504989,
0.0938487649,
0.1204633862,
0.5851485729,
-0.6652356982,
0.506888926,
0.8435767293,
-0.509241879,
-0.3707119524,
-0.2319731414,
-0.2463455796,
-0.4545612037,
0.4824629724,
-0.7101365328,
-0.5220843554,
0.6428728104,
-0.1230756864,
0.3503338099,
0.2908321023,
0.3078205287,
0.1591552198,
0.6899526715,
0.7874278426,
-0.067837514,
0.3857653737,
-0.4379869401,
0.3998079598,
-0.1306316257,
-0.1860038936,
-0.3182291687,
-0.6270419955,
-0.24693726,
-0.5561226606,
0.1618721485,
0.2310719788,
-0.0269275289,
0.4261863232,
-0.1991522163,
0.437463522,
0.6137750149,
-0.0455624536,
0.2305141836,
0.0500113219,
-0.2267263532,
-0.0016418971,
-0.9697910547,
-0.0171428807,
0.94731462,
0.3582181334,
0.9420704842,
0.1014386564,
0.7609322667,
0.1307312846,
-0.0011973801,
-0.6927847266,
0.2832714319,
-0.0708748102,
-0.7836663723,
-0.4862160981,
-0.5999803543,
-0.9307749271,
0.3077617288,
-0.0860901326,
-0.4989588857,
0.299860388,
0.1793643087,
-0.2919408381,
0.4453605413,
-0.7161328793,
1.0443094969,
-0.518450141,
-0.5318869352,
-0.0784952715,
-0.6214271188,
0.1989892572,
-0.6304078698,
0.386972487,
-0.4700390697,
-0.0729801133,
0.6382152438,
0.1716839373,
0.950150907,
-0.3077237308,
-0.3247221708,
0.2461336851,
0.2887595296,
0.3858445585,
0.0957331583,
-0.0991170779,
0.4502959251,
-0.1526783854,
-0.4936984777,
-0.3509679735,
0.679027319,
-0.5523001552,
-0.0408297479,
-0.3858418167,
-0.8549251556,
-0.2831575871,
0.4252933264,
0.0626217946,
0.7363827825,
-0.0974242166,
-0.080453597,
0.662250936,
-0.2558548152,
0.3421294689,
0.8663995862,
-0.0145386243,
-0.2405336648,
1.2119709253,
0.2659225464,
0.2925651073,
0.7071732879,
-0.0441142134,
-0.3929123282,
-0.4477276802,
-0.7902730107,
0.2400773317,
-0.9801337719,
-0.2800134122,
-0.6599903107,
0.086178422,
-0.2295385152,
-0.120843485,
-0.9865359664,
-0.6613539457,
-0.037021827,
-0.3985278904,
0.3462076187,
0.6619228125,
-0.6138771772,
0.155882284,
-0.5800851583,
0.2308231443,
0.0797567964,
0.5394663811,
-0.3540424407,
-0.4817155004,
-0.6957079172,
0.4260395467,
0.00354758,
-0.573900938,
0.113992855,
0.4963744879,
0.7497574687,
0.6186001897,
0.4204541147,
0.6461908817,
-0.3916681409,
0.3282003105,
0.2697159052,
-0.7669324875,
0.3394633234,
-0.2163303196,
0.614115715,
0.8453123569,
0.8269202709,
-0.5309381485,
-0.2780881822,
-0.5231842399,
-0.9621143937,
0.7464010119,
0.0435896143,
0.0100677535,
0.1618201584,
0.1779310703,
0.2360931486,
0.2417576611,
-0.6580720544,
-0.5359293222,
0.0976410508,
-0.506174624,
-0.4163959622,
-0.0234547351,
-0.30433321,
-0.4475860298,
0.6303862333,
-0.3795635402,
-0.3083081245,
-0.1074528396,
-0.5856688619,
-0.1773107648,
-0.0518539958,
0.555690825,
0.9390397072,
0.1877746284,
0.5384199619,
0.2701150179,
-0.4153228998,
0.2872697711,
0.5979367495,
-0.1719909608,
0.0875103101,
0.3860835433,
0.8523973227,
0.3962982595,
-0.7531660795,
0.3284593821,
0.0664110407,
-0.3365835249,
0.0133940019,
-0.3124925196,
0.0967502296,
0.1757179648,
0.0876930058,
0.0327316858,
-0.0698769614,
-0.1788201183,
0.5478205681,
0.1645184308,
-0.7386499643,
-0.4566446245,
0.5243284106,
0.2028239965,
0.186579451,
0.5322357416,
-0.3193480074,
-0.5431885123,
0.2948589027,
0.0435695797,
0.6201132536,
-0.6158645153,
0.4691823423,
0.4926351011,
0.4404503703,
-0.0691116378,
0.1759218127,
-0.1965559125,
-0.6342075467,
-0.3904535472,
-0.8272226453,
-0.3422456384,
-0.2671227455,
-0.5034629107,
0.5065376759,
0.1274618804,
0.0307057705,
0.0887463614,
-0.0056031127,
-0.5090540051,
0.1481604874,
0.4167138934,
0.751083374,
-1.0320802927,
0.854822278,
0.90809834,
-0.1447424591,
-0.5645490885,
-0.3792734444,
-0.1351609379,
-0.7424041033,
0.5268137455,
0.2289608121,
-0.0594989806,
0.1044520065,
-0.0067223273,
-1.1257424355,
0.6876734495,
0.905880928,
-0.719669342,
0.3284183741,
0.399823159,
0.1946622431,
-0.095742397,
0.1416925043,
0.4876529872,
0.8720080256,
0.2988506556,
-0.8611652255,
-0.3557935357,
-0.0140052857,
-0.6482448578,
0.6163153052,
-0.5268844962,
0.6846458912,
-0.4948514402,
-0.1016742364,
-0.6208475232,
0.3900513053,
-0.2904148102,
0.1953195184,
0.5844428539,
0.7612096071,
1.0218412876,
-0.2982809544,
0.8834816813,
-0.6002024412,
0.3159644306,
1.0533584356,
-0.1788871884,
0.4613927305,
0.2280935049,
0.1345223486,
0.1146470383,
1.130361557,
0.0066324347,
0.6466502547,
0.2598111331,
-0.0699563324,
-0.5481677055,
-0.175290361,
-0.0796226412,
0.5648853183,
0.2465187162,
-0.0630776733,
-0.5774507523,
0.3144235015,
0.2145033777,
-0.0354437344,
-0.1740256846,
0.5939933062,
0.0612179711,
-0.2369346172,
0.758975029,
0.0163405053,
0.2342033386,
-0.9922462106,
0.1136509255,
-0.2480580807,
0.5355629325,
-0.0679898188,
-0.6561060548,
0.0775608569,
-0.1842744499,
-0.0954166055,
-0.4520891309,
0.480835259,
-1.0727756023,
-0.7507234216,
0.4189080894,
0.564479053,
0.0955860615,
-0.2444890887,
-0.8925631642,
0.134482637,
0.1178188324,
-0.3662724495,
0.3982553482,
0.5304875374,
0.0640182272,
0.6291322708,
0.2820973396,
-0.0242041908,
-0.0212446433,
0.2532326579,
0.6556834579,
-0.2806272805,
-0.4431221485,
-0.8009649515,
0.4901930392,
-0.065109849,
-0.2985204756,
0.9280406833,
1.0574793816,
1.1421074867,
0.1337945461,
0.5999456644,
0.0498761982,
0.2548062801,
-0.142979309,
0.6024546027,
-0.7762676477,
-0.0387883708,
-0.0192078426,
-1.1039597988,
-0.3988393843,
0.366851151,
-0.2832600772,
-0.0419184528,
0.4464657009,
0.6171064377,
-0.4957978725,
-0.3765337467,
0.5391669869,
-0.0371770635,
0.0133612398,
0.5071954727,
0.5679413676,
-0.2426428646,
0.6023908854,
-0.8041527271,
-0.2218490839,
0.2008658499,
-0.5271829367,
-0.859732151,
-0.7479965687,
-0.6589594483,
0.1593355983,
0.1464742571,
0.6537846923,
0.9173555374,
-0.7640283704,
-0.2328428626,
0.3351290524,
0.205350101,
-0.4439245164,
-0.0755132958,
0.3535208702,
-0.555968821,
-1.0846244097,
0.3487143517,
0.3051684201,
0.1164857373,
-0.1475466788,
-0.1750285774,
-0.4003226757,
-0.0954615921,
0.4501666129,
0.1995761395,
-0.2993896604,
0.1399928033,
0.1018079892,
0.0199828278,
-0.1812824309,
0.4723848403,
-0.3360515237,
0.7029615641,
0.2758358419,
0.5768250227,
0.6372134089,
0.0445635319,
0.5782395601,
-1.0256719589,
0.5339655876,
0.2737722993,
0.1863573641,
0.4686800539,
-0.1283815652,
0.7160577774,
0.1260949075,
-0.0676564723,
-1.0121418238,
0.2466470897,
-0.6967782974,
-0.5430108309,
1.3053551912,
-0.2987305522,
-0.0643828735,
0.071377553,
0.0858631358,
0.1372534782,
-0.1337137222,
0.3944815695,
0.6502335072,
0.1051722467,
-0.0971790925,
-0.579406321,
0.4859404266,
0.1476867199,
-0.5028381348,
0.3791847229,
0.4139727354,
0.0437995531,
0.2667825222,
0.1502012163,
0.2058349103,
0.0258040726,
0.1088529378,
0.2424564064,
-0.3944765925,
-0.7783583403,
-0.2386173159,
0.0094619356,
0.088445276,
-0.3347492516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06377v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06377v1
|
Heaps' Law in GPT-Neo Large Language Model Emulated Corpora
| 2023-11-10T20:07:32 | 2023-11-10T20:07:32 |
Uyen Lai, Gurjit S. Randhawa, Paul Sheridan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Heaps' law is an empirical relation in text analysis that predicts vocabulary
growth as a function of corpus size. While this law has been validated in
diverse human-authored text corpora, its applicability to large language model
generated text remains unexplored. This study addresses this gap, focusing on
the emulation of corpora using the suite of GPT-Neo large language models. To
conduct our investigation, we emulated corpora of PubMed abstracts using three
different parameter sizes of the GPT-Neo model. Our emulation strategy involved
using the initial five words of each PubMed abstract as a prompt and
instructing the model to expand the content up to the original abstract's
length. Our findings indicate that the generated corpora adhere to Heaps' law.
Interestingly, as the GPT-Neo model size grows, its generated vocabulary
increasingly adheres to Heaps' law as as observed in human-authored text. To
further improve the richness and authenticity of GPT-Neo outputs, future
iterations could emphasize enhancing model size or refining the model
architecture to curtail vocabulary repetition.
|
[
-0.1958057284,
-0.8854153156,
0.9903236032,
0.1476512104,
-0.4610098302,
-0.3385758996,
-0.2124815583,
-0.3953019679,
0.35898754,
0.6760596633,
-0.0514724068,
-0.4067300558,
-0.610091567,
0.2422409803,
-0.4440354109,
1.2012553215,
0.2310033888,
-0.1426616013,
-0.3518008292,
0.2723679543,
-0.2193600982,
-0.6108878851,
-0.2325458825,
0.1181300208,
0.4367089868,
0.0930536687,
0.8918681145,
1.0452489853,
0.5073634386,
0.2390322536,
-0.2203800976,
-0.2191631347,
-0.4970494509,
0.0910399854,
-0.2307468355,
0.1257716119,
-0.4414047599,
-0.2196341306,
0.9592137337,
0.7387567759,
-0.3909359574,
-0.1625025719,
0.2258650064,
0.3133971095,
-0.6140126586,
-0.0487659089,
-0.5491276383,
-0.1515379101,
-0.0005714942,
-0.3733563125,
-0.5368006825,
-0.1841187477,
-0.0192609802,
-0.7056268454,
0.002889026,
0.3199566305,
0.6288968921,
0.1710268408,
-0.1959627122,
-0.6009221077,
-0.6282667518,
0.6700784564,
-0.7575901747,
0.2290237695,
0.3997701705,
0.0100171268,
-0.2154215574,
-0.7855590582,
-0.4150318503,
-0.5955450535,
-0.2060242742,
-0.0538967364,
-0.3336950839,
0.1022660732,
0.4406064153,
0.182606563,
-0.6262483597,
0.1238744333,
-0.8508485556,
-0.0060633682,
0.3076478243,
0.251926899,
0.3787585795,
-0.3869844973,
-0.3925253153,
0.0089018913,
-0.7821334004,
-0.8207855821,
0.1569215357,
0.2668976188,
-0.0979915038,
0.7587152123,
0.0087700179,
0.5454970002,
-0.2190347165,
0.088954851,
0.2737981677,
-0.2494060844,
-0.1367085278,
0.4196153879,
0.8761581779,
0.3145236969,
0.0903283432,
-0.3995861709,
-0.2024571598,
0.0667838827,
0.3671326637,
-1.0674031973,
-0.0141003318,
0.410761863,
-0.4357993901,
-0.2398125827,
-0.0490401201,
-0.74890697,
-0.4880855978,
-0.1071473882,
0.5443512797,
-0.5632666945,
-0.4154760838,
0.3612231612,
-0.3794208765,
0.1878518611,
0.1070014238,
-0.8422269821,
0.6146076322,
1.0396469831,
0.9941839576,
-0.0072351056,
-0.5064627528,
-0.7778377533,
0.5113638043,
-0.2455050498,
0.7521037459,
-0.447678715,
-0.3506991565,
0.1456901431,
-0.0835063607,
0.0026242752,
-0.5372700691,
0.3635849655,
-0.446552068,
0.1207420006,
0.0277229622,
-0.7520644665,
0.1641184539,
0.1098419204,
-0.4585238993,
0.640167892,
0.3063276708,
-0.9021574259,
0.3474596441,
-0.6226134896,
-0.1928627491,
0.1821467876,
-0.3529308736,
-0.2221889645,
0.4038667083,
-0.3283510208,
0.5574997067,
-0.2772876024,
0.3081091344,
-0.5999822617,
-0.4205487669,
0.1654551178,
-0.2341643423,
0.6225867867,
0.3319643438,
0.0430036075,
0.0245648827,
-0.5601037741,
-0.3998533785,
0.0629127845,
-0.2118158638,
-0.692630589,
0.0569140352,
0.0832896456,
0.3008334935,
0.261143893,
-0.8088828325,
0.1897285581,
-0.2198292911,
0.487745285,
0.4148907065,
0.2754370868,
0.2934397459,
-0.5818886757,
0.3770909905,
-0.269144237,
-0.2117993683,
0.0782940835,
-0.4512408674,
0.2568784952,
-0.6450717449,
0.6014617085,
0.4090963006,
-0.2041855156,
0.280448705,
-0.7376054525,
-0.4061298966,
-0.337801069,
-0.1010466442,
0.0001600363,
0.0143502187,
0.2481330782,
-0.3477962911,
-0.5696778297,
-0.7121081352,
0.013452515,
-0.1118644997,
-0.2522092462,
0.2716176808,
0.6323460937,
-0.4857873023,
0.911763072,
-0.2789802253,
-0.0671756268,
0.0661168918,
0.3050016165,
0.1436522007,
0.5377143025,
0.6789112091,
-0.4557251632,
-0.2502179444,
0.0249331072,
-0.5786020756,
-0.4993313849,
0.0492928736,
-0.0297471061,
0.0657797381,
0.8827511668,
-0.6763837337,
0.3518449962,
0.6487891078,
-0.7138580084,
0.9441252947,
-0.7947323918,
-0.1129937544,
-1.1689971685,
0.1233898103,
-0.232085526,
-0.2743780613,
-0.346798718,
0.1260205358,
-0.0208366662,
-0.0289375428,
-0.5159832835,
0.6647504568,
-0.4172102213,
-0.5135980248,
-0.6889032125,
0.2636849284,
-0.1556998044,
0.0289803464,
0.1054311767,
0.629178524,
0.5293759108,
-0.8365866542,
0.0337233245,
0.2097513676,
-0.1961264759,
0.2741518021,
-0.8513761163,
-0.3543189764,
-0.0842868909,
0.0624159537,
-1.1338598728,
-0.0521639772,
-0.092166014,
-0.2574027479,
0.1423945576,
-0.3304518759,
-0.8200525641,
-0.0724062398,
-0.3943844438,
0.3280803561,
0.7449785471,
-0.3455964029,
0.7492181659,
0.442781508,
-0.2773503065,
-0.5096529126,
-0.4682161808,
0.0819694996,
-0.3494430184,
-0.4521562755,
0.6032951474,
-0.0341366269,
-0.6857125163,
0.3186393976,
0.4059148133,
0.0852528811,
-0.0380694345,
0.2280541211,
0.1257158071,
-0.3248695135,
-0.0417816229,
0.2314673215,
0.2256484479,
0.4430687726,
-0.0491801426,
0.9650452137,
-0.0644483641,
0.0077754459,
-0.2058929354,
0.2536838651,
0.9796743393,
0.1732997,
0.8140494227,
0.51380831,
-0.1490845084,
0.2067371607,
-0.2915952802,
-0.2756454647,
-0.4561755061,
0.5884503126,
-0.3315169811,
-0.7605608702,
0.6938329935,
-0.1256534159,
0.0833640024,
0.7878192663,
0.7133600116,
0.127258569,
0.8247897625,
0.4643616378,
0.0334730186,
0.3380750418,
0.0182518233,
-0.5056777,
-1.2375092506,
0.3145834208,
-0.5306071639,
-0.0118996948,
-0.9090105295,
-0.6052066684,
0.0512821265,
-0.0420187488,
-0.499019891,
0.2092930973,
-0.3708272278,
0.2665055394,
0.2410745919,
-0.0760012493,
0.2923711538,
0.272347331,
-0.267436564,
0.1767528057,
-0.8463462591,
-0.4020889103,
0.9747895598,
0.3782896101,
0.525598526,
0.3698958457,
0.8903716207,
0.4854207635,
0.6242561936,
-0.6832609177,
0.6158449054,
-0.3266553581,
-0.5238351822,
-0.2449395508,
-0.783609271,
-1.4549155235,
0.4496735334,
-0.2242601961,
-0.6435946822,
0.1948123574,
-0.1390882134,
-0.3503252566,
0.3799740374,
-0.4365041256,
0.8076114655,
-0.0330774225,
-0.5757449865,
-0.5091232061,
-0.2928423882,
0.1475279927,
-0.0549983084,
0.5067178011,
-0.0777640715,
-0.4862542748,
0.9152746201,
-0.6888955832,
0.856338501,
-0.061256703,
-0.2845345736,
0.374735117,
0.2955503762,
0.4718666673,
-0.0498301983,
0.1011934876,
0.1419016421,
0.1561175138,
-0.4702565074,
-0.1138024777,
0.7754244804,
-0.6446823478,
-0.5191464424,
-0.6655247808,
-0.4799389839,
0.1414136291,
0.2367851436,
0.1962631494,
0.4203854799,
-0.4932118356,
0.340980202,
0.5186008811,
-0.3926521838,
0.3041056991,
0.6690302491,
-0.7078707218,
-0.4940615892,
0.7550308108,
0.0602361858,
0.2863097191,
0.2110657096,
0.5481521487,
-0.2465903759,
-0.5436816216,
-0.5166599154,
0.5496300459,
-0.187190637,
0.0220619384,
-0.9667443037,
-0.0429110304,
-0.5749412179,
-0.0619472973,
-0.1060687453,
-0.4284093082,
-0.1193176284,
0.1682048887,
0.7589395046,
0.8792795539,
-0.427205801,
0.2504757047,
-0.7222625017,
0.0758609176,
0.1729164273,
0.3705774844,
-0.129441902,
-1.0104478598,
0.0233407114,
-0.1957507432,
0.0097538047,
-1.0099782944,
0.628005445,
-0.0388568342,
0.1871000975,
0.3060986102,
-0.1587522328,
0.1961985528,
-0.8889667392,
0.3942183554,
0.0366271958,
-0.5172781944,
0.0706852376,
-0.8991857767,
0.1228693873,
0.2403206974,
0.1646022052,
-0.5542992353,
-0.5299371481,
-0.9841639996,
-1.1328368187,
0.2172207534,
0.0606262684,
0.4466185868,
-0.342838943,
0.4148134291,
-0.0228581149,
0.1724812239,
-0.2673214078,
0.1460165232,
0.1074784324,
-0.1494368315,
0.1700826585,
-0.4334501326,
0.1687619984,
-0.0149324518,
0.4679270983,
0.188379094,
0.4285181463,
0.0241584815,
0.063589558,
0.0554375462,
0.3398182988,
0.7620008588,
0.6178036928,
-0.472322166,
0.0838236287,
0.0790569857,
-0.9307146072,
-0.252838999,
0.254809469,
-0.189076975,
0.1132972315,
-0.2230473012,
0.5600268245,
0.428206265,
-0.9363126159,
0.5285593271,
-0.0565365553,
-0.5226733685,
-0.5618337989,
-0.0738797262,
0.0131061077,
-0.0302065257,
0.3419191539,
-0.1842515022,
0.1797297746,
-0.6366527677,
0.4674326479,
0.3233567178,
-0.2934924066,
-0.1272877604,
0.6439911723,
-0.3221928179,
-0.0031402535,
0.5923877954,
-0.4782131314,
-0.251416117,
0.4952848554,
0.9138413072,
0.5331783295,
-0.0714612007,
0.1368672997,
0.4636648297,
0.3337420821,
-0.4941276908,
0.0970013216,
0.3624922633,
-0.6337962747,
-0.7965299487,
-0.7091641426,
-0.4391387999,
0.1651730537,
-0.532881856,
0.0197254494,
-0.3978602886,
-0.0475153662,
-0.171594888,
-0.0595165193,
-0.2629903257,
0.0479467586,
0.1554394662,
0.6633067727,
-0.8435954452,
0.5323921442,
0.6050341725,
-0.3768970966,
-0.4990359545,
-0.0901785716,
-0.2204973251,
-0.5426938534,
0.3353661895,
-0.0489760339,
0.1478364915,
0.0093013123,
-0.3351814747,
-0.9578893781,
0.9388245344,
0.2951733768,
-0.2511679232,
0.1674249917,
-0.0750671402,
0.6831898093,
-0.606184721,
0.1720548421,
0.3526071906,
0.1379099488,
0.0336252861,
-0.8751674294,
0.1780630052,
-0.2649374306,
-0.1459832937,
0.3565458953,
-0.3875349462,
1.0083090067,
-0.2584426403,
0.0451617651,
0.1201525331,
0.7953737378,
0.7394132614,
0.095648706,
0.3976933956,
0.7293137908,
0.8043293953,
0.3417700231,
1.4537860155,
-0.5754443407,
0.2916175127,
1.0595140457,
-0.5173352361,
1.2883778811,
0.4369095266,
0.0927428752,
0.8513647914,
0.3310089707,
-0.1839191318,
0.3172809184,
0.456438154,
-0.0112853944,
0.1666480899,
-0.1737337708,
-0.4715894461,
0.3135599494,
0.7004461884,
-0.6868105531,
-0.0785195678,
-0.1019858867,
0.1285676211,
-0.1538700014,
-0.6537904143,
0.8127708435,
-0.0617539845,
-0.310764432,
0.5757300258,
0.075275965,
0.7446324825,
-0.3786325157,
0.1497235298,
0.2580935955,
0.0734454244,
0.0755376965,
-0.6333179474,
0.3548546731,
0.1246628612,
-0.0827340931,
0.0550316386,
0.7428203821,
-0.3974614441,
-0.3933413625,
0.2738230824,
0.6207093,
0.7626194358,
-0.1174039543,
-0.3412907422,
0.0024489125,
-0.3446133435,
-0.1889168024,
0.790890336,
0.6967895031,
0.062565051,
0.2872081697,
0.4599563181,
0.4482919276,
0.052073855,
-0.0445154086,
0.8343217969,
-0.5261797905,
-0.6641710997,
-0.9769811034,
0.0305247772,
-0.2702276111,
-0.1930421293,
0.6191805005,
0.9266340137,
0.5023731589,
-0.1460893154,
0.799241066,
-0.339161396,
0.53843683,
-0.397916019,
0.7319167852,
-0.5283478498,
0.2184075713,
-0.3879908323,
-0.9476578832,
-0.1779923886,
0.5691409707,
-0.7349464893,
0.1281350553,
0.7681125998,
0.6797891855,
-0.2938837111,
-0.092830345,
0.4115932584,
0.5128858089,
-0.2499330491,
0.3269869387,
0.7039791942,
-0.2029517442,
0.507942915,
0.0679214448,
-0.2226281762,
-0.3324370384,
-0.8725107908,
-0.5292261243,
-0.3316982388,
-0.43554914,
-0.8038129807,
0.0051234812,
0.8805549741,
0.2896916568,
-0.4891808033,
-0.4129079878,
-0.0482051522,
-0.3291915953,
-0.3844985664,
-0.1894836128,
0.650508225,
-0.2360834926,
-0.3292756379,
0.1347778291,
0.1979683042,
0.0728868395,
-0.2348436713,
-0.0856666639,
-0.0615563653,
0.3011619747,
0.7620714307,
0.3283482492,
-0.2356033325,
0.0433502458,
-0.1992826462,
-0.4845632315,
0.1018557623,
0.8616777658,
-0.7609855533,
-0.0452018157,
0.5844742656,
0.5692033768,
0.3706715107,
0.1090083942,
0.5469764471,
-0.7601408958,
0.1253749132,
0.2368768901,
0.600679338,
0.2350049317,
-0.3053360879,
0.3856295943,
0.1557602584,
-0.7059659958,
-0.8803824186,
0.0131660458,
-0.9755829573,
-0.5803006291,
1.6151542664,
0.2725702524,
-0.6448836327,
-0.2248672843,
-0.1807245612,
0.1376812458,
-0.4673265219,
0.918440938,
0.4515253305,
0.164389655,
0.0039275642,
-0.9013741612,
0.408388555,
0.3993334174,
-0.6045418978,
0.557962358,
0.6418359876,
0.2562606633,
0.3187891543,
0.7198235989,
-0.3428921402,
0.4869620204,
0.1676654369,
0.0764380917,
0.1393281519,
0.0175896194,
-0.3553724587,
0.4125936627,
0.0687186122,
0.2908026576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14703v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14703v1
|
ChatGPT Exhibits Gender and Racial Biases in Acute Coronary Syndrome Management
| 2023-11-10T19:59:36 | 2023-11-10T19:59:36 |
Angela Zhang, Mert Yuksekgonul, Joshua Guild, James Zou, Joseph C. Wu
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Recent breakthroughs in large language models (LLMs) have led to their rapid
dissemination and widespread use. One early application has been to medicine,
where LLMs have been investigated to streamline clinical workflows and
facilitate clinical analysis and decision-making. However, a leading barrier to
the deployment of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and in particular LLMs has been
concern for embedded gender and racial biases. Here, we evaluate whether a
leading LLM, ChatGPT 3.5, exhibits gender and racial bias in clinical
management of acute coronary syndrome (ACS). We find that specifying patients
as female, African American, or Hispanic resulted in a decrease in guideline
recommended medical management, diagnosis, and symptom management of ACS. Most
notably, the largest disparities were seen in the recommendation of coronary
angiography or stress testing for the diagnosis and further intervention of ACS
and recommendation of high intensity statins. These disparities correlate with
biases that have been observed clinically and have been implicated in the
differential gender and racial morbidity and mortality outcomes of ACS and
coronary artery disease. Furthermore, we find that the largest disparities are
seen during unstable angina, where fewer explicit clinical guidelines exist.
Finally, we find that through asking ChatGPT 3.5 to explain its reasoning prior
to providing an answer, we are able to improve clinical accuracy and mitigate
instances of gender and racial biases. This is among the first studies to
demonstrate that the gender and racial biases that LLMs exhibit do in fact
affect clinical management. Additionally, we demonstrate that existing
strategies that improve LLM performance not only improve LLM performance in
clinical management, but can also be used to mitigate gender and racial biases.
|
[
-0.2429514676,
-0.5767933726,
0.3878753781,
0.3230116963,
-0.1780949682,
0.5348432064,
-0.1147704646,
-0.6714363098,
0.1413519382,
0.0840702578,
-0.4612077475,
-0.302491039,
-0.8453028202,
0.3275481761,
-0.1072746739,
1.191573143,
-0.427401185,
0.8234452009,
0.0323271602,
0.0532968454,
-0.525973618,
-0.738699317,
-0.9261372089,
-0.5223594308,
0.5605261922,
0.2774573863,
0.9834781289,
0.3441969156,
1.0678162575,
0.1616271883,
-0.3545644283,
0.0875716433,
-0.4974431098,
0.0182990879,
0.3598824441,
-0.6796911955,
-0.3930841088,
-0.1435919106,
0.307667464,
0.766956389,
-0.1126836836,
-0.0352170579,
-0.0250351019,
0.9087513685,
-0.5429240465,
0.093730256,
-0.3060682118,
0.3790757954,
-0.257132262,
-0.1571243256,
-0.0377972424,
-0.7182977796,
0.5880013704,
-0.3398861587,
0.4523710608,
0.3673299551,
0.5283706188,
0.2128488272,
-0.6862815619,
-0.5800901651,
-0.9415069222,
0.2259964198,
-0.5060088634,
0.2156390548,
0.3458076119,
0.519865334,
-0.1433397233,
-0.2553657293,
-0.4013380408,
-0.0882953852,
-0.1101492643,
0.1712269932,
-0.104018569,
0.1781504601,
0.2732909024,
0.3496041894,
-0.5607726574,
0.3266465068,
-0.6947640181,
-0.2096085846,
0.5464606285,
0.3911684752,
0.3780345619,
0.0163497515,
-0.3467950523,
0.218961671,
-0.7798933387,
0.0364106707,
0.3363289833,
0.4647840559,
-0.4192464352,
0.6956964135,
0.2900981903,
0.013329383,
-0.2322022915,
0.1583356261,
0.0895150602,
0.1078732237,
-0.1253804862,
0.5509153008,
0.7755061984,
0.5065500736,
0.5296095014,
-0.0148628633,
0.2052065283,
0.1624403447,
0.2920728326,
-0.6395157576,
-0.147126317,
0.17232804,
-0.4820434749,
-0.4513704777,
-0.1877807081,
-0.62507689,
-0.5710358024,
-0.2464568615,
-0.1896282285,
-0.4524267018,
-0.0954653248,
-0.3175875843,
-0.4384728968,
0.6001299024,
0.4158184826,
-0.8915169239,
0.3526454568,
0.6149145365,
0.7620052695,
-0.3438656032,
0.0392624475,
0.1298144609,
0.0288790762,
-0.4287882447,
0.8241676092,
-0.4453688264,
-0.521707952,
0.2165960819,
-0.3697216809,
-0.2049188763,
-0.4574642479,
0.4562394023,
-0.2290489525,
-0.0991480872,
-0.5170308948,
-0.3329687417,
0.037280824,
0.0704245046,
-0.2697742581,
0.7031205893,
-0.0260982569,
-0.6656240821,
0.3313138187,
-0.3137026727,
-0.4795930684,
0.0144907832,
-0.5556917787,
-0.6107221842,
0.0594779477,
0.3342379332,
-0.0055941595,
-0.5472218394,
0.1140573472,
-0.6399038434,
-0.4529642165,
0.2637192905,
-0.2619566023,
0.4588774741,
0.2879132926,
-0.290130347,
-0.0941135213,
-0.1050603762,
-0.4056026042,
0.0742170364,
0.0617427975,
-0.1444293112,
0.187280938,
-0.1780531704,
0.2209794521,
-0.1486783028,
-0.3517489433,
0.0705043226,
-0.0820909739,
0.5557250381,
1.0276142359,
-0.056959983,
0.2925590873,
-0.5074973702,
0.6811979413,
-0.0504903086,
0.4417166114,
0.2994654179,
-0.5054175854,
-0.9120314717,
-0.2241217047,
-0.0713897049,
0.6305144429,
-0.460457176,
0.0638422444,
0.0707357749,
-0.387835294,
-0.4699674547,
-0.3270214498,
0.2525015473,
0.7546324134,
0.2698889077,
0.0792752281,
-0.3479742408,
-1.2159203291,
-0.2113569528,
-0.2569969296,
0.2217386961,
0.4833419621,
0.6200444102,
-0.2697656453,
0.576659441,
-0.529384017,
-0.469694823,
-0.2994707525,
0.3218873143,
0.0360520668,
0.5493913889,
0.2970602512,
-0.4542548954,
-0.2850776613,
-0.083168149,
-0.6632529497,
-0.1123437956,
0.195622623,
-0.4232553542,
-0.0839118361,
0.6041175127,
-0.154580906,
0.7893070579,
0.3029788136,
-0.2955045402,
0.6180518866,
-0.0183869489,
0.0508380532,
-0.580765605,
0.00466965,
0.2172830403,
-0.0994861647,
-0.640188098,
-0.2123142332,
-0.0144936852,
-0.3345333636,
-0.2731567025,
0.3456502855,
-0.178815797,
-0.2632422447,
-0.163473919,
-0.0688618571,
-0.2670150399,
0.4511790872,
0.1506244838,
0.6581119895,
0.4445426762,
-0.5529049635,
-0.0966547877,
0.4665181041,
-0.0786368921,
0.84258008,
-0.7767923474,
-0.0198757742,
-0.4359203875,
0.309099406,
-1.0102690458,
0.0694549605,
0.194762215,
-0.5505499244,
0.2040394694,
-0.2148271948,
-0.1247485876,
-0.8165083528,
-0.0861761495,
0.5988323092,
0.4155409932,
-0.1040455028,
0.4373542666,
0.3892500997,
-0.6238403916,
-0.3582381308,
-0.8858447075,
-0.1883377731,
-0.1122423708,
-0.5454773307,
0.1012737527,
-0.0801609829,
-0.3567059338,
-0.3720295727,
-0.2310318053,
-0.1742943674,
0.083060734,
0.1861565411,
0.545502007,
0.0371110439,
0.2982139289,
-0.064347662,
0.2666715682,
0.1689779758,
0.3686929941,
0.5555458665,
-0.1247320175,
-0.6881741285,
-0.5041902661,
0.5607678294,
0.6072369218,
-0.3516560793,
0.6456844807,
0.5408985019,
-0.2027750164,
0.2134903073,
-0.5062286854,
-0.2154815495,
-0.3464509547,
0.3130855858,
0.1137009412,
-1.0756936073,
0.8983795643,
0.1574930996,
0.2096149027,
0.2283705473,
0.5346728563,
-0.5714947581,
1.333630681,
0.2443548143,
-0.1452313066,
0.6233177781,
-0.3614440262,
0.3604109883,
-1.2233132124,
-0.5016583204,
-0.9602009654,
-0.6224279404,
-0.738135159,
-0.3201624155,
0.7902729511,
-0.2568936944,
-0.7606625557,
-0.7613702416,
-0.3269780278,
0.1743207723,
0.1987688988,
0.5650587678,
0.1285776794,
-0.1149796396,
-0.0912548304,
-0.1048808619,
-1.0336076021,
-0.2401156723,
1.1854419708,
0.6007604599,
0.788203299,
0.1771814078,
0.3922433257,
0.7381741405,
0.4506288767,
-0.538693428,
0.0856181085,
-0.16270639,
-0.7184547186,
0.0060239211,
-0.5265380144,
-0.991401732,
0.15785034,
-0.2092294246,
-0.4815250635,
0.4339199066,
0.3704350591,
-0.314244628,
0.0620639771,
-0.6637565494,
0.7259286046,
-0.3890105188,
-0.0184682813,
0.0874356925,
-0.5006661415,
0.6371777058,
0.1529569179,
0.4294265509,
-0.5530153513,
0.1207955107,
0.7144288421,
-0.9373453856,
0.8955885172,
0.1418667287,
-0.0670137331,
-0.0612242073,
0.0746260956,
0.6730681658,
0.110041149,
-0.0019230172,
0.387152046,
-0.4184351861,
-0.640946269,
-0.439143002,
0.4615260065,
-1.1543869972,
-0.4378119409,
-0.8086379766,
-0.2431813926,
-0.3493779004,
-0.0898702368,
0.2943716645,
0.624991715,
-0.0773827508,
-0.393602401,
0.6130300164,
-0.2157028019,
0.1591213346,
0.5126305223,
0.1508912891,
-0.398935914,
0.5018601418,
-0.3496824503,
0.5085744262,
0.1269505322,
0.1723555028,
-0.1236596182,
-0.7367329597,
-0.2033154964,
0.4174598455,
-0.4823677242,
-0.1864296049,
-0.4559362233,
-0.3342806995,
-0.6011207104,
-0.5067270398,
-0.302724123,
-0.2310191393,
-0.2994354963,
-0.0479730256,
0.4576373696,
0.4717626274,
0.3922370076,
0.5807702541,
-0.4393195212,
0.3830815554,
0.2893238962,
0.2947643101,
0.1029320061,
-0.6326684952,
-0.0920578986,
0.0925716236,
-0.1292814016,
-1.0639331341,
0.1035310254,
-0.030136494,
0.6314716935,
0.354752481,
-0.0491352268,
0.7216816545,
-0.3087631464,
0.7372328043,
0.1329429597,
-0.7916948199,
0.6137412786,
-0.5278725028,
0.3523182869,
0.624551177,
0.5222545266,
-0.8223696947,
-1.0174002647,
-0.4229026139,
-0.8545077443,
0.859112978,
0.4173145592,
-0.2268432528,
-0.3171010017,
0.3304565549,
-0.243298158,
0.2224344164,
-0.7775632739,
-0.7613773942,
0.062543571,
-0.221868962,
0.1386013478,
-0.3423621058,
-0.1688805223,
-0.053078033,
0.7849518657,
-0.2174863964,
0.6396501064,
0.5753144026,
-0.1275843233,
-0.215989843,
0.2527907193,
0.689063549,
0.6215797067,
-0.206470713,
0.0471994467,
0.0610281453,
-0.5834520459,
0.029546041,
0.4887122214,
-0.3840412498,
-0.3443083167,
0.696824193,
0.9282246828,
0.1955644786,
-0.6598657966,
0.42111215,
-0.4138021171,
-0.1143936589,
-0.2389039397,
-0.0661816671,
-0.5137873292,
0.2441573441,
0.3154599965,
0.2468046993,
-0.0781190991,
-0.4776366651,
-0.248868987,
0.5239607096,
-0.7205907702,
0.0344592445,
0.6092489958,
0.5311525464,
-0.1202131808,
0.6706324816,
0.182106182,
-0.9402160645,
0.8444781899,
0.3845841289,
0.7278478146,
-0.3445296884,
0.3651450872,
0.2612608373,
0.6242144704,
0.0583349839,
0.4103146791,
0.2101252079,
-0.7209351063,
-0.1272295415,
-0.3135233819,
-0.5111678243,
-0.2884193063,
-0.6319869757,
0.394979924,
-0.6766049266,
-0.1820002198,
0.0231360272,
-0.2037163526,
-0.6259108782,
0.0099800183,
0.5622348189,
0.978949666,
-0.8732022047,
0.0130280443,
0.6461344957,
-0.2635933757,
-0.7395712137,
-0.2222752124,
0.3273091912,
-1.0607112646,
0.4858275354,
-0.0809088647,
0.3806444407,
-0.5090201497,
-0.0808829069,
-1.06556499,
0.8202601671,
0.2574817538,
-0.4508091807,
-0.0826224983,
0.4685738683,
0.7016038299,
-0.2316064239,
0.7139264345,
0.7273210287,
0.4042491019,
0.2054489553,
-1.1686781645,
-0.2005031258,
-0.087616168,
0.0005444808,
0.2823168635,
-0.9954954386,
0.8671665788,
-0.4546829462,
0.1901764125,
-0.3006464839,
0.3056878448,
0.4590907097,
0.2384358644,
0.2005676329,
0.5125558376,
0.9385342002,
-0.310565114,
1.3748030663,
0.2135039866,
-0.1972007155,
0.9184675217,
-0.4483829141,
0.1402461082,
0.1886793673,
-0.4737208784,
0.4532889128,
0.8813856244,
0.3046628535,
0.1479436606,
0.2239747941,
-0.2768955827,
-0.0619543456,
-0.1893203408,
-0.7484814525,
0.5868340135,
0.3576917052,
-0.5391174555,
-0.2204647064,
-0.0225440562,
0.2523491681,
-0.3127352893,
-0.6572552323,
0.7463067174,
0.1068347692,
-0.5718896985,
0.4979500175,
-0.1896305531,
0.2550797164,
-0.7343521118,
0.203776598,
-0.5913422704,
-0.0102962265,
-0.141076982,
-0.4681148529,
0.2435491085,
0.1332638264,
-0.3288605809,
0.0097797131,
0.4407709837,
-0.3874797523,
-0.8090515137,
-0.1453392655,
0.3875921667,
-0.0386292338,
-0.0325360447,
-0.8121026158,
0.2496639043,
0.1550940275,
0.2789735496,
0.3187693655,
0.3526641726,
-0.2351112366,
1.0150719881,
0.6588820815,
0.7041134238,
0.0249082632,
0.264205277,
0.827018559,
-0.688124001,
-0.679344058,
-0.9968572855,
0.0174103361,
-0.0184316244,
-0.3536959291,
0.7125717998,
0.4784798622,
0.3090230525,
0.5411002636,
0.8671104908,
0.3397968709,
0.2914002836,
-0.4589368105,
0.5220997334,
-0.2497535199,
0.4591921568,
-0.5372531414,
-0.6758989096,
-0.3509186208,
0.3237242699,
-0.656704843,
0.1391007006,
0.6065276861,
0.4314904809,
0.4533956945,
0.4580826759,
-0.2835538387,
0.2733926475,
0.8153873086,
0.4079696536,
0.8243188262,
-0.1782711893,
0.5725921988,
-0.1346067488,
-0.3616854846,
-0.3653573692,
-0.6661497355,
-0.9148961902,
0.2234535962,
-0.4287897348,
0.0520776846,
0.2027461082,
0.858291626,
0.7194136977,
-0.6173405647,
-0.1710850745,
-0.0125817871,
0.7626910806,
-0.0269977711,
-0.2091371715,
0.3574798703,
-0.2822034359,
-0.3342955709,
-0.1702688932,
0.2921082377,
0.4874279201,
-0.090098545,
-0.0081871143,
0.0635786131,
-0.2152393609,
0.3764574528,
0.2388956994,
-0.4742929935,
0.1348492652,
-0.2039242536,
-0.1247092336,
0.2276862115,
1.2221539021,
-0.4747733176,
0.2122387588,
0.1469857395,
0.3724777997,
0.2120686322,
-0.1200765446,
0.8950744271,
-0.3705784082,
0.016529588,
0.6010751724,
0.616435945,
0.1877068877,
-0.5508396626,
0.184833318,
0.2495427579,
-0.7260528207,
-0.7450309992,
-0.1292402744,
-0.66933918,
-0.13402915,
1.0000543594,
0.2909857333,
-0.167323336,
-0.221937418,
-0.2951292992,
0.1814684421,
-0.7054314017,
0.9553250074,
0.5865851045,
-0.5971018076,
-0.0520237871,
-0.5306787491,
0.7629078627,
0.5406110883,
-0.9406808019,
0.2716272771,
0.3997815251,
-0.1433277577,
-0.4032935202,
0.729129374,
-0.0960650966,
0.5898138285,
-0.5585538149,
0.12505126,
0.032834284,
-0.0219166484,
-0.267587781,
-0.2368088961,
-0.0682583675,
0.1915146858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06364v1
|
Relation Extraction in underexplored biomedical domains: A diversity-optimised sampling and synthetic data generation approach
| 2023-11-10T19:36:00 | 2023-11-10T19:36:00 |
Maxime Delmas, Magdalena Wysocka, André Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The sparsity of labelled data is an obstacle to the development of Relation
Extraction models and the completion of databases in various biomedical areas.
While being of high interest in drug-discovery, the natural-products
literature, reporting the identification of potential bioactive compounds from
organisms, is a concrete example of such an overlooked topic. To mark the start
of this new task, we created the first curated evaluation dataset and extracted
literature items from the LOTUS database to build training sets. To this end,
we developed a new sampler inspired by diversity metrics in ecology, named
Greedy Maximum Entropy sampler, or GME-sampler
(https://github.com/idiap/gme-sampler). The strategic optimization of both
balance and diversity of the selected items in the evaluation set is important
given the resource-intensive nature of manual curation. After quantifying the
noise in the training set, in the form of discrepancies between the input
abstracts text and the expected output labels, we explored different strategies
accordingly. Framing the task as an end-to-end Relation Extraction, we
evaluated the performance of standard fine-tuning as a generative task and
few-shot learning with open Large Language Models (LLaMA 7B-65B). In addition
to their evaluation in few-shot settings, we explore the potential of open
Large Language Models (Vicuna-13B) as synthetic data generator and propose a
new workflow for this purpose. All evaluated models exhibited substantial
improvements when fine-tuned on synthetic abstracts rather than the original
noisy data. We provide our best performing (f1-score=59.0) BioGPT-Large model
for end-to-end RE of natural-products relationships along with all the
generated synthetic data and the evaluation dataset. See more details at
https://github.com/idiap/abroad-re.
|
[
-0.387865454,
-0.6288523078,
0.4034286141,
-0.0484935604,
-0.4349817932,
0.1474150568,
-0.2517426014,
-0.8862401247,
0.2977387011,
0.3937925398,
-0.6066955924,
-0.5590121746,
-0.6062632799,
0.4665182233,
-0.0160502698,
1.1818467379,
0.2601225078,
0.2199666649,
-0.1973854899,
-0.3308008313,
-0.0911396667,
-0.3104966581,
-0.5734658837,
-0.4723958969,
0.7122863531,
-0.1372547448,
0.3927157521,
0.3890980482,
0.5169948339,
0.2185744643,
-0.3848658502,
0.5403807759,
-0.591493845,
0.1243541688,
-0.5546448231,
-0.1968147159,
-0.2783460021,
0.0147123588,
0.3527925313,
0.8109394312,
0.1191852093,
0.3318811953,
0.0456713028,
0.6212937236,
-0.76812464,
0.1807420254,
-0.5590852499,
0.1603773981,
-0.3235396743,
-0.1585965008,
-0.1191053018,
-0.1656074822,
0.0534247421,
-0.6859350204,
0.1401986033,
-0.0803022906,
0.9698855281,
0.1842774302,
-0.2872792184,
-0.312843442,
-0.8073511124,
0.9033458829,
-0.6839367151,
0.3013872802,
0.171791479,
0.2954893708,
-0.4813652635,
-0.6510996222,
-0.1897780597,
-0.2404052913,
-0.0408047177,
0.2242928892,
-0.1635204852,
-0.0095473863,
0.2140948772,
0.7672539353,
-0.4016398489,
0.0848472342,
-0.7147989273,
-0.0515317731,
0.6255099177,
0.0883911997,
0.3017609119,
-0.2180859149,
-0.0973263532,
0.1858405769,
-0.8389977813,
-0.1994142979,
0.1765987873,
0.4211622775,
0.1384182125,
0.767798543,
-0.2447369844,
0.6129297018,
-0.1915069073,
0.0839487761,
0.1624184549,
-0.6720321774,
-0.353221029,
-0.2937555015,
0.9700963497,
0.0985351503,
0.0090454575,
-0.2305641174,
-0.2188149244,
0.0306129549,
-0.0182964075,
-0.9117441773,
-0.278404206,
0.2569728494,
-0.4671594203,
-0.4307373166,
0.0055989963,
-0.9920147061,
-0.170824334,
-0.3307500184,
0.3456154168,
-0.3731528223,
-0.3003778458,
0.0587793738,
-0.334071815,
0.119859919,
-0.0572556704,
-0.8317489028,
0.5061896443,
0.4828415513,
0.898018539,
-0.4571731985,
0.2138279676,
-0.4972685575,
0.1398333162,
-0.1508614719,
0.6991640925,
-0.5305021405,
-0.6354706883,
-0.2887503207,
0.1623307019,
0.0954204127,
-0.9773334265,
0.4375611842,
-0.5650181174,
0.2144731283,
-0.3121829033,
-0.4910584092,
0.1770719439,
0.12415158,
-0.8497951627,
0.7199436426,
0.3149076998,
-0.7697080374,
0.4462330639,
-0.7894841433,
-0.323058784,
0.1464016885,
-0.2023642063,
-0.2398721576,
0.0116730556,
0.1998492479,
0.0300134271,
-0.4969156981,
0.1466747969,
-0.4876613021,
-0.0913494155,
0.2529470921,
-0.1338753253,
1.1631656885,
0.4805144966,
0.0680544674,
-0.0405778065,
-1.006785512,
-0.0739738196,
-0.0826967359,
-0.314878583,
-0.5587719083,
-0.4017964303,
0.0143081676,
0.264713496,
0.0342573933,
-0.8380773067,
0.3666513264,
-0.5904454589,
0.3831963539,
0.60134691,
0.5538113713,
0.1451383382,
-0.1861127168,
0.5496561527,
0.0958308727,
0.0271553528,
0.0120530659,
-0.4091053903,
-0.0852015615,
-0.4678851068,
0.6928963065,
0.3033897877,
-0.5071389079,
0.4797604382,
-0.3089930117,
-0.4771978855,
-0.5138532519,
0.4016043544,
0.4045089483,
0.1997682154,
0.3728721738,
-0.6686578989,
-0.6340495944,
-0.8294490576,
-0.1660336256,
0.0997097641,
-0.1825905889,
0.3473232687,
0.662240684,
-0.4950851798,
0.9433764219,
-0.7776782513,
-0.3709635735,
0.0191123988,
0.108952336,
0.3623673916,
0.5206465721,
0.5271016955,
-0.6283117533,
-0.3896476924,
0.2569003701,
-0.7548653483,
-0.2646634877,
0.1832263023,
-0.40670228,
-0.1167653799,
0.1265324354,
-0.9597963691,
0.1050344333,
0.0976696163,
0.2642865479,
0.515630126,
-0.0065363105,
-0.1254313886,
-0.9549282193,
0.362447232,
0.1674806476,
-0.1318387687,
-0.3454344571,
0.0633750632,
-0.3401753008,
-0.1096806079,
-0.35865888,
0.5873912573,
-0.6772162914,
-0.0531674623,
-0.1364710182,
-0.3075402379,
0.1826416254,
0.3622716069,
0.0086553702,
0.4660350978,
0.4249508381,
-0.5018435121,
0.3548465371,
0.3241584599,
-0.198467657,
0.1622698456,
-0.4903411865,
0.0124075506,
-0.1605380923,
0.229138568,
-0.6692196727,
-0.3020673096,
0.4474528432,
-0.4396606386,
0.624817729,
-0.2949119806,
-0.3716924787,
-0.344114542,
-0.2493857592,
0.3069946766,
0.5734837651,
-0.3961527646,
0.1897183359,
0.5716705322,
-0.212135464,
-0.4723303616,
-0.5162541866,
-0.0959538221,
-0.2748423517,
-0.3501525819,
0.27985394,
0.053608954,
-0.3875465989,
0.1075968295,
-0.3482707143,
-0.2312280834,
-0.2138416469,
0.0308547318,
0.2724724412,
-0.175001055,
0.1744399816,
0.1501567811,
-0.0073522306,
0.180110395,
-0.3404453695,
0.107957989,
0.2233605981,
-0.0402572192,
0.0584862903,
0.3528023064,
0.4324291945,
-0.1569383889,
0.5910781622,
0.5499324203,
-0.6093170643,
-0.0179073475,
-0.0072812149,
-0.2895929217,
-0.37839818,
0.3844501674,
-0.2402671874,
-0.4266453683,
0.4404973388,
-0.2661744952,
0.1143671647,
0.6020516753,
0.5801723599,
0.1677517593,
0.5349510908,
0.6583509445,
-0.0651600286,
0.1689080745,
-0.4720542431,
0.2808525562,
-0.761495173,
-0.1695175469,
-0.3413065672,
-0.0591336749,
-0.706545949,
-0.3812404871,
0.5517171025,
-0.1186692491,
0.1473940164,
0.2790850997,
-0.3403808475,
0.4606287777,
0.4109843671,
0.3681307435,
0.3379087746,
0.1672992706,
-0.2040661573,
-0.1267404258,
-0.6864432096,
-0.438749969,
1.3196446896,
0.0904812142,
0.5383786559,
-0.1328317374,
0.7582275867,
-0.0223831572,
0.6232194901,
-0.8467845917,
0.3310362399,
-0.0981681347,
-0.833746016,
-0.1694972217,
-0.471880585,
-1.1738675833,
0.1563374102,
-0.3036097288,
-0.7005777955,
0.4549962878,
-0.0370182991,
-0.5346862674,
0.2435091585,
-0.5087088943,
0.7965960503,
-0.1695632637,
-0.8725348711,
0.0269419961,
-0.8669729829,
0.7075414658,
-0.2891471684,
0.2369340658,
0.0039628139,
0.2340406775,
0.5747116208,
-0.3174472451,
0.5953897834,
0.015475424,
-0.0206460468,
0.3186056018,
-0.0437901504,
0.006612232,
-0.0825922713,
-0.0883971527,
0.1255116612,
0.1857112199,
-0.3657458723,
-0.5868991613,
0.6084382534,
-0.6498562694,
-0.2836921215,
-0.4294077456,
-0.2973651588,
-0.228522107,
0.3563429415,
0.5989999175,
0.3263194263,
-0.4619699121,
0.1890083551,
0.4410783648,
-0.5500535369,
0.0350359455,
0.3540582359,
-0.193711102,
-0.5023072362,
0.8857898712,
0.1964244843,
0.2332446575,
0.3620182276,
0.048053842,
-0.2739815116,
-0.4238896072,
-0.1016885713,
0.2479537278,
-0.4267754555,
-0.4079153538,
-0.6044246554,
-0.4106407464,
-0.3862527609,
0.2962114215,
-0.3683559895,
-0.3503733277,
-0.2670802772,
-0.1722420752,
0.2467491776,
0.6209296584,
-0.4459144771,
0.0520762466,
-0.9877285361,
0.5505303741,
-0.0011246331,
0.1746059507,
-0.259373188,
-0.0850943699,
-0.3781734109,
0.1951287836,
-0.6168459058,
-1.0110228062,
0.7835149169,
0.3887943923,
0.5329010487,
0.4164260924,
-0.1008659303,
0.5337848663,
-0.212542057,
0.5407240987,
-0.0357207358,
-0.3044043183,
0.4943554401,
-0.4388619065,
0.1932835281,
0.5886135101,
0.508457303,
-0.1519057751,
-0.2976959646,
-0.7507833838,
-1.0577100515,
0.3303451836,
0.5867847204,
-0.221133247,
-0.0305033103,
0.3463233709,
0.3427544832,
0.3317786753,
-0.6424872279,
-0.1838955879,
0.243708089,
-0.1681162864,
0.0834297985,
-0.0901318714,
-0.3070710599,
-0.2525559664,
0.7690582871,
0.0903706625,
0.1490565687,
0.2830116451,
-0.169658497,
-0.3823050261,
0.3392965198,
0.0886682421,
0.6380326152,
-0.433245182,
-0.0832587108,
-0.1814711094,
-0.5778078437,
-0.0078357458,
0.3741503954,
-0.1706479639,
0.0454212539,
0.2638628185,
0.3180779815,
-0.0596355274,
-0.73066324,
0.0966277272,
0.2261896282,
0.0424010679,
-0.0477662422,
-0.0009870414,
-0.1628095806,
0.1142286584,
0.3266830444,
0.1384388953,
0.6037920713,
-0.5933959484,
0.309274137,
0.6450281739,
-0.0595245361,
-0.4375700653,
0.6076260209,
0.0435612127,
0.0121181719,
0.4947440922,
-0.300121963,
-0.1523035616,
0.6896924376,
0.4503672719,
0.8823282719,
0.0828024596,
0.1213752627,
0.7219747901,
0.1635185033,
0.3075244129,
0.0121037429,
-0.2253836095,
-0.6952462792,
-0.3201759458,
-0.8344812989,
-0.3774921596,
0.4088203013,
-0.6038110852,
0.3247127235,
-0.2447701246,
-0.3360102475,
0.4470294118,
0.2610402405,
-0.4387532175,
0.0758638754,
-0.084863998,
0.5677875876,
-0.9674649835,
0.6934458613,
0.6325272322,
-0.5932216048,
-0.3022136092,
-0.2764638364,
0.0801671371,
-0.4245916605,
0.6557068229,
0.0626217201,
0.0910548046,
-0.2292045355,
-0.5808503032,
-0.6854094267,
1.0037587881,
0.3551406264,
-0.5654886961,
0.0666327029,
0.0943994373,
0.8657135963,
-0.2961146832,
0.1447558105,
0.7246929407,
0.2570995688,
0.256562978,
-0.6851104498,
-0.034403272,
-0.7093533278,
-0.0946546048,
0.118574366,
-0.4132013023,
0.4948754609,
-0.086674124,
-0.2416338921,
0.2962201536,
0.426361382,
0.6389535069,
0.4437830746,
0.114241004,
0.3911680579,
0.7712654471,
0.1340127438,
0.9396414757,
-0.2180006951,
0.2233638614,
1.0320295095,
-0.2451380193,
0.5737897754,
0.7363436818,
-0.4978263676,
0.165320605,
0.954456985,
-0.2414222658,
0.5424298644,
0.4291846156,
-0.3673660457,
0.0962501839,
-0.2819661498,
-0.2753235698,
0.0731378868,
0.6426797509,
-0.5950055122,
-0.2097959816,
-0.1706649214,
-0.335195154,
-0.2623994648,
-0.0710242316,
0.8344839215,
0.4715082049,
-0.6027038693,
0.5641946793,
-0.1300145835,
0.4862130284,
-0.6676693559,
-0.1668889672,
-0.2922218144,
0.0057061692,
-0.3080357909,
-0.3859048784,
0.3843899369,
-0.0436659008,
-0.1119504943,
0.3145340085,
0.839835465,
-0.600260973,
-0.5547997952,
0.1559656411,
0.6848773956,
0.2662179768,
0.1371214688,
-0.3888910115,
-0.2838720381,
-0.016017437,
-0.2591275275,
0.2877405584,
0.5807852149,
-0.0805509239,
0.420024544,
0.8361220956,
0.5372210741,
-0.1036188751,
-0.2206902057,
0.9748376608,
-0.4719639421,
-0.0905903205,
-0.8764916658,
0.3111113906,
-0.1391908079,
-0.1647160053,
0.5597652793,
0.8587992191,
0.5395021439,
-0.3553808928,
0.8269712329,
0.0855955184,
0.3869606555,
-0.4446868598,
0.3821874857,
-0.5023742914,
0.3527565002,
-0.2979229391,
-1.019177556,
-0.3533540666,
0.3201347291,
-0.0865914449,
-0.0512122363,
0.6966947317,
0.789701879,
-0.3733822107,
-0.0810827538,
-0.0158896763,
0.3330557644,
0.401741147,
0.6810446978,
0.5828428864,
-0.4920682311,
0.2287853062,
-0.2485848963,
-0.0998277664,
0.1394848675,
-0.7871184349,
-0.4953728318,
-0.2944118679,
-0.3597847521,
-0.3989599347,
0.1558017433,
1.1900469065,
0.5006555915,
-0.7893564105,
-0.2631513774,
-0.2131962478,
-0.0656323656,
-0.1723706573,
-0.2108306885,
0.2255462706,
-0.2176603973,
-0.6622606516,
0.2615709901,
0.368855387,
0.3694162071,
-0.1412049979,
-0.0568856448,
-0.2354343683,
-0.1040027216,
0.6241455674,
0.7026947737,
-0.2610450983,
0.4528590441,
-0.0029444406,
-0.0499290414,
0.1859470159,
0.6297007203,
-0.749753952,
0.450342387,
0.3903982639,
0.7177056074,
0.6927857399,
0.0557200573,
0.9850395918,
-0.7164394259,
0.1616805345,
0.2606598735,
0.2572892308,
0.3326593041,
-0.4848060012,
0.7986009717,
0.3662770689,
-0.3767372072,
-0.8402160406,
0.0173007026,
-0.9100543261,
-0.3054127991,
1.2456738949,
-0.077063866,
-0.4096233845,
-0.105241403,
-0.3527342379,
0.3752244413,
-0.1482152492,
0.8403158784,
0.6882486939,
-0.1722986549,
0.1880982816,
-0.5948092341,
0.5778708458,
0.1558612734,
-0.9918081164,
-0.0001058995,
0.7691602707,
0.1886650622,
0.1943222731,
0.6003573537,
-0.441052109,
0.1234387904,
-0.1829201728,
-0.1571214944,
0.0870995596,
-0.0336832255,
-0.354957372,
-0.0332769677,
0.0627276748,
-0.2015347183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06362v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06362v1
|
Word Definitions from Large Language Models
| 2023-11-10T19:27:20 | 2023-11-10T19:27:20 |
Yunting Yin, Steven Skiena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dictionary definitions are historically the arbitrator of what words mean,
but this primacy has come under threat by recent progress in NLP, including
word embeddings and generative models like ChatGPT. We present an exploratory
study of the degree of alignment between word definitions from classical
dictionaries and these newer computational artifacts. Specifically, we compare
definitions from three published dictionaries to those generated from variants
of ChatGPT. We show that (i) definitions from different traditional
dictionaries exhibit more surface form similarity than do model-generated
definitions, (ii) that the ChatGPT definitions are highly accurate, comparable
to traditional dictionaries, and (iii) ChatGPT-based embedding definitions
retain their accuracy even on low frequency words, much better than GloVE and
FastText word embeddings.
|
[
-0.3343018889,
-0.8784195781,
0.4766656756,
-0.0847608596,
-0.2456851155,
0.2056520283,
-0.2333058268,
-0.4444125295,
0.2611617148,
0.1404801309,
-0.1067989916,
-0.1414056718,
-0.893304944,
-0.0002337813,
-0.802529037,
0.8185742497,
-0.408301115,
-0.1860206127,
-0.3670272529,
-0.3118591607,
-0.2854362428,
-0.4552286267,
-0.326316148,
-0.384845227,
0.4978091419,
-0.5100102425,
1.2805142403,
0.7449320555,
0.8139124513,
0.3740836382,
-0.2655922771,
0.0229533426,
-0.2719625235,
0.1371418387,
-0.2010845542,
-0.0644960403,
-0.3076949716,
0.1412455887,
0.5471159816,
0.8346455693,
-0.5743872523,
-0.1429598629,
0.3144496977,
0.6287619472,
-0.6797197461,
0.2588475049,
-0.7398871779,
0.0801401436,
-0.2432610989,
0.0680953115,
-0.0587435104,
-0.3080816865,
0.4980575442,
-0.6096605062,
0.1595501304,
-0.1048631221,
1.0907094479,
0.0668124855,
-0.1139352396,
-0.5998512506,
-0.4174044728,
0.1655634046,
-0.6917093992,
0.6754707098,
0.039568428,
0.33651191,
-0.4504947662,
-0.7201941609,
-0.8597117662,
-0.1879717559,
-0.1242384166,
0.0462393351,
-0.414802283,
0.365090549,
0.3353284597,
0.482780993,
-0.5155712366,
0.0573298298,
-0.2494614422,
0.0021183384,
0.4071953595,
-0.0446647108,
0.0787474662,
-0.1434345394,
-0.3741458952,
-0.1356132925,
-0.9126885533,
-0.3451210856,
0.0978461355,
0.2436505705,
-0.3108512163,
1.0086128712,
-0.0489882156,
0.8447652459,
-0.008960356,
0.0542084686,
0.1970885098,
-0.1005903259,
-0.2978807986,
0.0390011668,
0.6654176116,
0.5206796527,
0.0644031242,
-0.2281956077,
-0.2119042128,
-0.0726417154,
0.0554450192,
-0.45031932,
-0.3813163042,
-0.1120058447,
-0.3133890629,
-0.2394846827,
0.3535007536,
-0.4614963233,
-0.8722153306,
-0.6201352477,
0.5405322313,
-0.3419331312,
-0.2310816646,
0.0172595736,
-0.2312206924,
0.4705522358,
0.2728947997,
-0.8772250414,
0.2379576117,
1.0497592688,
1.1926314831,
-0.0113229621,
0.0007624779,
-0.1541546881,
-0.0010955122,
-0.7486178875,
0.5099253654,
-0.4066195488,
-0.3033706546,
0.1835009009,
-0.094716318,
0.2518565655,
-0.3402660191,
0.16917485,
-0.4857674539,
0.2139665633,
-0.1543764472,
-0.7572127581,
-0.3637951016,
0.2508347034,
-0.5142070055,
0.8473671079,
-0.0176981203,
-0.6175059676,
0.675729394,
-0.2665361762,
-0.3784884512,
0.2138545513,
-0.3522795737,
-0.080092676,
0.5216279626,
-0.1456077844,
0.5966324806,
-0.2066125721,
0.0902291089,
-0.3310000896,
0.0587509163,
0.3959422112,
-0.3648560345,
0.5910012126,
0.2453500181,
-0.1592481583,
-0.2727263272,
-0.4622119069,
-0.0481120795,
-0.0987159908,
-0.2685557604,
-0.5454264879,
0.51827842,
-0.0659562349,
0.2178262919,
0.3781660199,
-0.5696127415,
0.2751278877,
-0.4062368572,
0.8430514932,
0.6473033428,
-0.4655669332,
0.1622735113,
-0.4340812564,
0.1992697418,
-0.2613773644,
-0.2056112885,
0.2529612482,
-0.4386727214,
-0.5731195807,
-0.2448265105,
0.4537779093,
0.4148397744,
-0.3122459352,
0.5582054257,
-0.5953194499,
-0.814910531,
-0.4338340759,
-0.0698775351,
0.0827591792,
0.248879984,
0.1165904999,
-0.0191212948,
-0.325504154,
-0.8652561903,
-0.0798474699,
-0.0967851207,
0.0040627117,
0.1939257681,
0.3174327016,
-0.1727514118,
0.8107913733,
-0.2325124145,
-0.0747779235,
0.1781277955,
0.1124155149,
0.1705339253,
0.1817459315,
0.3583024442,
-0.7432513833,
-0.576515913,
0.2796905935,
-0.3956830204,
0.0886002928,
0.0027698232,
-0.0419726595,
0.1226806566,
0.6474561095,
-0.5682567358,
0.3192356527,
0.8534086347,
-0.0823326632,
0.0587287843,
-0.3398582339,
-0.007440093,
-1.2352478504,
0.0242685378,
-0.1260604262,
-0.2248845249,
-0.401070118,
0.4301549792,
0.1832801402,
0.0928601995,
-0.3737628162,
0.2690967023,
-0.4218575358,
0.1363690645,
-0.174901858,
0.6514641047,
-0.1040152162,
-0.2694371939,
0.1657049358,
0.6592746377,
0.3934515119,
-0.5339437127,
0.8123887777,
0.3682973683,
-0.4764706194,
0.357771039,
-0.8540548682,
0.0038072998,
-0.1059416234,
0.1544166356,
-1.287543416,
-0.0773465112,
-0.1465480328,
-0.2823420465,
0.2839869261,
0.0353079848,
-0.6036149859,
-0.2640157938,
-0.2469633073,
0.1647703648,
0.6190519929,
-0.4732011557,
0.356610477,
0.5741452575,
-0.0181767233,
-0.5092164874,
-0.6683285832,
0.0439645015,
-0.1766612232,
-0.3757017255,
0.4899543822,
0.372530967,
-0.5114250779,
-0.0322738476,
0.0244122241,
0.2088094056,
0.1886567026,
0.4774137139,
0.3177024126,
-0.1734762043,
0.472156018,
-0.1412072927,
0.3665258586,
-0.1912675649,
0.1009257659,
0.922755599,
-0.0286595374,
-0.3549358845,
0.0419576503,
0.1979157776,
0.4263986051,
-0.1211828887,
0.7415394187,
0.2979709208,
-0.4377553165,
0.1820538044,
-0.6024640203,
0.2413954884,
-0.4327935874,
0.1431419104,
-0.5558285117,
-0.8705884218,
0.6720845699,
0.2750875056,
0.2356958389,
0.7102931738,
0.6208701134,
-0.1695679277,
1.0154094696,
0.5942634344,
-0.0924167633,
0.4334878623,
0.1285827905,
0.3257073164,
-0.8915174007,
0.1731340289,
-0.3939891458,
-0.3902823627,
-1.0987949371,
-0.3621538877,
0.0654806644,
0.2099168301,
-0.1547719687,
0.6434885859,
-0.5403112769,
0.159809038,
0.3833210468,
-0.2467405945,
-0.0430362634,
0.0583554916,
-0.0528327413,
0.0165891591,
-0.5037635565,
-0.5034751296,
1.0643868446,
0.2602640092,
0.6531382203,
0.4584655464,
0.522530973,
0.1078346074,
0.1906215698,
-0.6893965602,
0.201344654,
-0.3679144681,
-0.586769104,
-0.0443918183,
0.0072320509,
-0.9034003615,
0.1409319639,
-0.4793056548,
-0.617151022,
0.1195937693,
0.0724862441,
-0.3754357696,
0.2620663643,
-0.4581658542,
0.6652646661,
0.0032871538,
-0.1174346805,
-0.3078957498,
-0.1322021335,
0.1746191829,
-0.193859309,
0.1160553396,
-0.3067626059,
-0.2430276722,
0.7172881961,
-0.5993009806,
0.5060280561,
0.0723233521,
-0.4644913673,
0.4577981234,
0.1917952001,
0.5008577704,
-0.3287125826,
0.0451169536,
0.2877308428,
0.7034717798,
-0.3170665801,
-0.5269039869,
0.6172952652,
-0.5959923863,
-0.495795697,
-0.5049046278,
-0.2509329915,
0.040077161,
0.1700979471,
0.4042550027,
0.5368369818,
-0.3807709217,
0.4274066985,
0.3753282428,
-0.3230631649,
0.2137503326,
0.2957774401,
-0.3962193429,
0.0449523292,
0.7772077918,
0.3787676394,
0.4403562844,
0.5589917302,
0.2526178062,
-0.4272604287,
-0.455866158,
-0.2293718755,
-0.0038819767,
-0.4416382611,
-0.0376987532,
-0.31413427,
-0.3394022286,
-0.6683253646,
-0.2983573377,
-0.2972375751,
-0.4204859734,
0.209643513,
0.0709414408,
0.5668923259,
0.7963063717,
-0.1084122956,
0.4459719658,
-0.4900086224,
0.1508518606,
0.2282131165,
0.2728470862,
-0.2974903882,
-0.3920793235,
0.0921430141,
0.4162658751,
-0.2405819744,
-0.7977237105,
0.213024497,
0.5396283865,
0.4583289325,
0.6386697292,
-0.1843870729,
0.7982969284,
-0.6911857724,
0.9353188276,
0.2360001057,
-0.8927595615,
0.2000002712,
-0.3632531166,
0.1963255107,
0.3607009351,
0.2855641544,
-1.2146111727,
-0.234651655,
-0.5807114244,
-0.6733356714,
-0.0178287607,
-0.3626395762,
0.6852170825,
-0.3995880187,
0.4353580475,
0.1694443375,
0.3735228777,
-0.3114578128,
0.0020571623,
-0.0423611775,
-0.3030486703,
-0.3315102458,
-0.2093508244,
-0.2290859371,
-0.0464271754,
0.5736316442,
0.1061892584,
0.4564495385,
-0.1347805411,
-0.1687247008,
0.1332084239,
0.0671017095,
0.6310191751,
0.8119525313,
0.0370370112,
0.491556555,
0.1276697963,
-0.6482447982,
-0.0492144786,
0.1880615205,
-0.119452782,
0.0999479592,
0.5261871219,
0.6010252237,
0.0370311365,
-0.6888282895,
0.6892080307,
0.3318918049,
-0.1311802268,
-0.3583913445,
-0.1253412068,
0.1432349086,
0.1218604818,
-0.254030019,
-0.314101249,
0.0194447096,
-0.4340105355,
0.1107314304,
0.9178723097,
-0.440725863,
-0.0425847359,
0.4326150715,
-0.1547926366,
-0.0138463499,
0.7067505121,
-0.153072834,
-0.5197637677,
0.1907544285,
0.2133576721,
0.6958113909,
0.042977009,
-0.0828049704,
0.1960120052,
0.1148625612,
-0.2307554036,
0.0752451122,
-0.0209136643,
-1.0987969637,
-0.5045118332,
-0.669051826,
-0.2184258997,
0.0935351774,
-0.4417127073,
0.5717433691,
-0.5607182384,
-0.0836294815,
0.3012007773,
-0.2332266122,
-0.6265506148,
-0.2839791179,
0.4225149453,
0.8219597936,
-0.7906839252,
0.6261574626,
0.7845609784,
-0.4292715788,
-0.9019755125,
-0.3189074397,
0.213507548,
-0.9205916524,
0.5469569564,
-0.0667879656,
0.097820051,
-0.1002718359,
-0.2633085549,
-1.1289042234,
1.0184419155,
0.0491108149,
-0.8290373087,
-0.1585949957,
0.2241809666,
0.6192912459,
0.1292708516,
0.0641915128,
0.3823429644,
0.3282979131,
-0.049947124,
-1.332259655,
-0.1498204917,
-0.0980039462,
0.0184598546,
0.5493831635,
-0.21940431,
0.8795611262,
0.2631146014,
-0.3684131205,
0.231937021,
0.572799027,
-0.1707032621,
-0.401530385,
0.2580225468,
0.7992499471,
0.5352258682,
-0.3461660743,
0.9535109401,
-0.4404314756,
0.3556443155,
0.8333982825,
0.0364081524,
1.0025286674,
0.5278991461,
-0.6085761786,
0.2569696605,
0.7614802122,
-0.0718564168,
0.3587267697,
0.3812966347,
-0.2347202301,
-0.0150179835,
0.156455636,
-0.4124729633,
0.6317337751,
0.5257313848,
-0.5285763144,
-0.3751733601,
0.0092870118,
0.1003797352,
0.0329464115,
-0.3679077923,
0.9260925055,
-0.0382010303,
-0.635843575,
0.7966035604,
0.0296492465,
0.6663299799,
-0.3733716309,
0.0187793728,
0.1609599292,
0.2741917968,
-0.1825087368,
-0.9572597742,
0.2966533303,
-0.3228166997,
0.2938122153,
0.0051818821,
0.3481856883,
-0.6048889756,
-0.3112765551,
-0.1239312068,
0.5585821271,
0.2049149871,
-0.0148497885,
-0.7309305668,
-0.0267104842,
-0.4023090005,
-0.1411961019,
0.0413262248,
0.4082220793,
-0.1350672543,
0.3044450581,
0.1129881963,
0.3806558251,
0.5419531465,
-0.334413141,
0.5064822435,
-0.0850059018,
-0.2506221235,
-0.932098031,
0.1661011875,
0.0364785157,
-0.4741658866,
0.5418205857,
0.7299748063,
0.8819379807,
0.0959485918,
0.8083359003,
-0.6908584833,
0.4953459799,
-0.5635268092,
0.6452122927,
-0.467113018,
-0.1327108443,
-0.4563117623,
-1.2445037365,
-0.2281618565,
1.039627552,
-0.5594522357,
-0.2696648836,
0.4032146931,
0.7087085843,
-0.2054007649,
-0.1104424596,
0.2320489287,
0.0998709351,
0.3988622129,
0.2656573951,
0.8282079697,
-0.3130873442,
-0.1359959394,
-0.4279665947,
-0.1448483169,
-0.1875990182,
-1.0447757244,
-0.5097706318,
-1.1615527868,
-0.2606232464,
-0.3332960308,
0.035408251,
0.9664696455,
0.3959607482,
-0.6806738377,
-0.1324188113,
-0.2901703119,
-0.15984869,
-0.4314740598,
-0.161524415,
0.6867764592,
-0.3116898239,
-0.683906734,
0.0019739827,
-0.0741816908,
0.2203643769,
-0.3204576671,
0.1553254575,
-0.1877334118,
0.0330499075,
0.7063758969,
0.2031036317,
-0.8025906086,
-0.8567031622,
-0.3369249403,
-0.2243822068,
-0.0182405449,
0.5683181882,
-0.5177953839,
0.4282063842,
0.7794955969,
0.5608227849,
0.0700727254,
0.0146484319,
0.6467184424,
-0.4701524377,
0.1279131323,
-0.0482606851,
0.5150561929,
0.3903416991,
0.1497992128,
0.3822889626,
0.138490662,
-0.2680594623,
-0.6867334843,
0.3379829526,
-1.0214976072,
-0.2233376801,
1.2246291637,
0.0639930069,
-0.0901074931,
0.257569164,
-0.1982568353,
0.4032016397,
0.0152563462,
0.7406534553,
1.1126631498,
-0.0884934217,
-0.0616679527,
-0.699395895,
0.8177108765,
-0.0166047532,
-0.232546553,
0.359722048,
0.4719068408,
0.1067637578,
0.5392996073,
0.0078273499,
-0.3755657673,
0.1087701619,
-0.1812475175,
0.211867094,
0.0017538083,
0.2838199139,
-0.327200979,
0.0050601964,
0.2941931486,
-0.0943497345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06345v1
|
Schema Graph-Guided Prompt for Multi-Domain Dialogue State Tracking
| 2023-11-10T19:00:02 | 2023-11-10T19:00:02 |
Ruolin Su, Ting-Wei Wu, Biing-Hwang Juang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tracking dialogue states is an essential topic in task-oriented dialogue
systems, which involve filling in the necessary information in pre-defined
slots corresponding to a schema. While general pre-trained language models have
been shown effective in slot-filling, their performance is limited when applied
to specific domains. We propose a graph-based framework that learns
domain-specific prompts by incorporating the dialogue schema. Specifically, we
embed domain-specific schema encoded by a graph neural network into the
pre-trained language model, which allows for relations in the schema to guide
the model for better adaptation to the specific domain. Our experiments
demonstrate that the proposed graph-based method outperforms other multi-domain
DST approaches while using similar or fewer trainable parameters. We also
conduct a comprehensive study of schema graph architectures, parameter usage,
and module ablation that demonstrate the effectiveness of our model on
multi-domain dialogue state tracking.
|
[
-0.4019333124,
-0.8302790523,
0.7638686895,
-0.08015652,
-0.3218454421,
0.2591914535,
-0.0310729835,
0.0290361736,
0.4148353636,
0.5657569766,
-0.9139478803,
-0.6806320548,
-0.5937103033,
0.0937095508,
0.1168972924,
0.9605884552,
0.0399546772,
0.0015867711,
-0.3495264053,
-0.0957540348,
-0.6354604363,
-0.6444010139,
-0.4988729954,
-0.3171648979,
0.492651999,
0.2226272374,
0.3643935025,
0.3298777938,
-0.0694340989,
0.2741127312,
-0.0608768649,
0.3992858231,
-0.3904170394,
0.4399031401,
-0.0360482447,
-0.1133271232,
-0.5780349374,
-0.1552494019,
0.6393035054,
0.9052101374,
-0.3826799095,
-0.1917883903,
0.1512927413,
-0.0188589804,
-0.1943574101,
0.7783042192,
-0.4120578766,
-0.1250194013,
-0.0224844813,
-0.4654424787,
-0.6994376183,
-0.4608989656,
0.3832678497,
-1.0185419321,
0.1726579517,
0.2417805046,
0.7167220712,
0.0092773652,
-0.7138786912,
-0.2802709937,
-0.3736472726,
0.4445206821,
-0.4793613851,
0.4011385441,
0.4148730338,
0.2187876999,
-0.2234816849,
-0.88542068,
-0.5066108108,
-0.2256489843,
-0.1936963201,
0.0639656261,
-0.0951882228,
0.2997204363,
0.4613152146,
-0.0977689996,
-0.5997139812,
-0.1774221957,
-0.1229775548,
-0.6065471768,
0.1382065564,
0.5267419219,
0.3496664166,
-0.1880884767,
-0.456910789,
0.1454605907,
-0.643365562,
0.0809931755,
0.1710350215,
0.8376536965,
0.122757785,
0.3020544946,
-0.2677443624,
1.0793659687,
0.1913098991,
-0.2105510384,
0.195884794,
-0.4957380593,
-0.0004631357,
0.0187086985,
0.6843983531,
0.357922554,
0.0839928463,
0.0310023706,
0.0498694293,
0.3277087212,
0.3022983968,
-0.882647872,
-0.1996756941,
-0.116439648,
-0.1761479825,
0.0180910695,
-0.5408632159,
-0.5734876394,
-0.4806666374,
-0.3809534907,
0.1038144603,
-0.6649824381,
-0.2692037225,
0.1179679334,
-0.00814767,
-0.0766332448,
0.7495895028,
-1.0280761719,
0.3755941987,
0.6053051353,
0.8700150847,
-0.216888994,
-0.2938541174,
-0.6383928657,
0.177024886,
-0.2044122219,
1.060141921,
-0.8023817539,
-0.5777478218,
0.2565515339,
0.1305649281,
-0.6051093936,
-0.1498187184,
0.1038776487,
-0.5476908684,
0.2751378119,
-0.2577936053,
-0.8787632585,
-0.2085087597,
0.3046413064,
-0.433062315,
0.9658311605,
0.4992412329,
-0.5470214486,
0.2897855341,
-0.670335114,
-0.4817812443,
0.232164219,
-0.4220580161,
-0.17983374,
-0.2931742072,
0.1380641162,
0.2706776261,
-0.0483466275,
0.2915709913,
-0.4240028262,
-0.3720957637,
-0.0472189412,
-0.2255101651,
0.8475607634,
0.1141082346,
0.1919034421,
0.3213935792,
-0.5218251348,
0.0353744626,
0.0416996032,
-0.076903373,
-0.2211080045,
-0.2893317044,
-0.3469621241,
0.2667771578,
0.0837069154,
-0.5758169293,
0.4634192586,
-0.1772076488,
0.4423410594,
0.7722815275,
0.3566805422,
0.4884499311,
-0.0506005324,
0.7949347496,
0.1091719866,
0.0514521487,
-0.6056630611,
-0.6804838181,
-0.4627175629,
-0.3832538724,
0.2036794722,
0.5815021992,
-0.8247432709,
0.4028078914,
-0.0215440877,
-0.2361367941,
-0.1726493686,
-0.2479957491,
0.2800906301,
0.838955462,
0.2335376889,
-0.6328892708,
0.0065184128,
-0.5212364793,
-0.0273249857,
-0.0698438361,
0.1978679299,
0.7817368507,
0.2991957366,
0.0326234773,
1.0856050253,
-1.0466535091,
-0.4156703949,
-0.3315995634,
0.0026716234,
0.0796430707,
0.3234393597,
0.5453253388,
-0.395535022,
-0.7180064321,
-0.199740842,
-0.6947796941,
-0.120297268,
0.0762410685,
-0.2312422842,
-0.0077789915,
0.4386006892,
-1.1104205847,
0.6505414844,
0.135088563,
-0.4874676168,
0.5785982013,
-0.0281564798,
0.0751166791,
-1.2646721601,
-0.1983946264,
-0.097406812,
-0.3149883747,
-0.9771921635,
-0.3851697147,
0.0621046163,
-0.5329289436,
-0.5021719337,
0.5506989956,
-0.2449564487,
-0.1885486543,
-0.1716994047,
0.5882577896,
0.3965009451,
1.0511558056,
0.1415993422,
0.7992084026,
0.835066855,
-0.6627804637,
0.4578718245,
0.8138244152,
-0.4355156124,
1.0795743465,
-0.2872182429,
0.3499397337,
-0.0537140034,
0.8713830113,
-1.1138552427,
0.1022537127,
0.5702896714,
-0.3537809551,
0.3691311479,
-0.5182083845,
-0.1881586462,
-0.0628098547,
0.3146937191,
0.3196793795,
0.0766163617,
-0.3269900382,
0.9261399508,
0.2448958755,
-0.6382380724,
-0.65368855,
0.0807405114,
-0.0375700891,
-0.0537938178,
-0.5445331335,
0.3015872538,
-0.1699840128,
0.3620713353,
-0.1539374441,
-0.3603407443,
-0.0089557096,
0.1064890325,
0.2507537007,
0.3784243166,
-0.2487419695,
0.1274030358,
0.1138767451,
-0.3906401396,
0.0173528697,
-0.7564362884,
0.8822872639,
-0.0629972741,
-0.5387580991,
-0.8584589958,
0.6987490058,
0.4323549271,
-0.380009234,
0.4003622234,
0.1581571847,
-0.3156463206,
-0.3383488059,
0.1002226993,
-0.2794851959,
-0.509921968,
0.4353014529,
-0.5944669247,
-0.9012790918,
0.4885721803,
-0.669285953,
-0.1305969357,
0.126270175,
0.2645794451,
-0.1254029125,
1.3642202616,
0.5669491291,
0.0354336202,
0.7193011045,
-0.3094891012,
0.4736341536,
-0.8885807991,
-0.1792694181,
-0.6151968241,
0.2034775615,
0.006553791,
-0.2867295444,
0.2808846831,
-0.0280696116,
-0.3516274393,
0.4197646379,
-0.3412774801,
0.2503485382,
0.6020749807,
-0.0467445478,
0.2309963405,
0.0058642328,
-0.5370101333,
0.0397051498,
-0.9082376957,
-0.227693662,
0.6979767084,
-0.0150849912,
0.6397097707,
0.0005934415,
0.5345266461,
0.401771456,
0.1482603401,
-0.7725518942,
0.6611891985,
0.1150832847,
-0.2914481759,
-0.4256642163,
-0.3027078211,
-0.8798055649,
0.398132056,
0.0963997096,
-1.1055563688,
0.0619428679,
0.1900496483,
-0.5201566219,
-0.0538290329,
-0.5790808797,
1.1043486595,
0.0323539637,
0.1799301058,
-0.1310808361,
-0.5456365347,
-0.2232883573,
0.0825842693,
-0.0696267486,
-0.3108748198,
0.5076725483,
0.493866384,
-0.4761515558,
1.2282356024,
-0.6466012597,
-0.1481085718,
0.4024830759,
0.1899163872,
0.7260923982,
-0.0331164598,
0.2426793128,
0.1036925018,
0.0276496243,
-0.3745375872,
-0.8758449554,
0.5240456462,
-0.4954476655,
-0.7194493413,
-0.4503945112,
-0.6029058099,
-0.5858807564,
0.5335962772,
0.2641580403,
0.9339142442,
-0.2545655966,
-0.3083944917,
0.6252014637,
-0.1323286295,
0.085535489,
0.6330393553,
-0.2976408601,
-0.2234529704,
0.9723225832,
0.0413539857,
0.4255694747,
0.0842185467,
-0.0798347741,
-0.5907065868,
-0.3387973607,
-0.9092046618,
0.1268872768,
-1.0017341375,
-0.3912803829,
-0.7267596722,
-0.1091157719,
-0.5847920775,
-0.1209370866,
-0.0215828475,
-0.5111474395,
-0.3432638645,
-0.2783340812,
0.4754185379,
0.5875774622,
0.4986279011,
0.7770757675,
-0.6127639413,
0.2377451658,
0.2115945816,
0.6071599126,
-0.2419289649,
-0.4069222212,
-0.1691133529,
0.1175532416,
-0.2816508412,
-0.866083324,
0.0437863357,
0.2936638594,
0.6742351055,
0.3395064175,
0.1449471265,
0.6546438336,
-0.7800533772,
0.9482546449,
0.3600957096,
-0.9732174277,
0.6473641396,
-0.4741164446,
0.2960970402,
0.2467179447,
0.2156462222,
-0.8374015689,
-0.4479101002,
-0.5203678608,
-0.5372948647,
1.1908068657,
-0.2625839412,
0.2672473192,
-0.1135755554,
0.1967536807,
0.0510330759,
0.2582487762,
-0.1864304245,
-0.4348326921,
-0.4607482553,
-0.2960931659,
0.1189323738,
0.1176988557,
-0.473595053,
0.0568142086,
0.5283934474,
-0.6782960296,
0.4645884037,
-0.1480176002,
-0.2754345238,
0.1159302667,
0.0258097034,
0.6710122228,
0.5976861715,
0.0130191203,
-0.2464971989,
0.127121523,
-0.2902670801,
0.0889330506,
0.3258832693,
-0.2914651334,
0.0868187547,
0.0035233945,
1.3349467516,
0.0303701013,
-0.2421481907,
0.8402604461,
-0.15760988,
-0.2256205827,
-0.0367950238,
0.1172038019,
0.0689483956,
0.2301869839,
0.0894880965,
0.2304062992,
0.0438321158,
-0.2752934396,
0.3798856437,
0.383207798,
-0.6421647668,
-0.2515079975,
0.4582847953,
0.3111075163,
-0.6493316889,
0.731633842,
-0.1204900593,
-0.7513988614,
0.447973758,
0.8955091834,
0.6100919843,
-0.3526652157,
0.59957093,
0.1077805981,
-0.3036128581,
0.2696068287,
0.298401773,
-0.4721935391,
-0.8135960698,
-0.3175899088,
-0.2813969254,
-0.6510406137,
-0.1933549792,
-0.6929398179,
0.0745792016,
-0.3733160496,
-0.5240246058,
0.0084923869,
-0.1732904762,
-0.6261535287,
0.1768267751,
0.0182171073,
0.9881770611,
-0.7619571686,
0.8724756837,
0.3718163371,
-0.3352085054,
-0.8323379159,
-0.1776197851,
0.2017030567,
-0.8375489712,
0.3650449514,
0.1174440533,
-0.5362735391,
0.1301682889,
-0.3167600334,
-1.0554349422,
0.9672545791,
0.2703235447,
-0.1939368099,
-0.0325551294,
0.0328477621,
0.4356583059,
-0.796502769,
0.0992166102,
0.5094690323,
0.1634470522,
-0.0201294478,
-0.7624516487,
0.093013145,
-0.2453902662,
-0.1140154973,
0.3029271066,
-0.6650820374,
0.5902143717,
-0.1515822411,
-0.4024396241,
0.075342305,
0.6008343101,
0.2740763128,
0.4123380184,
0.7360367775,
0.195854634,
1.1208524704,
-0.2014051229,
0.7641003728,
-0.6657623649,
0.3843159676,
1.1846580505,
-0.8208838105,
0.2868903279,
0.0917221531,
0.0544832535,
0.7926219106,
0.7443543077,
0.2688471973,
0.7338679433,
0.2091083676,
-0.3988660276,
-0.3312149346,
-0.4689653516,
-0.457859695,
0.2496506274,
0.8256431818,
-0.1645444334,
-0.1145408154,
0.0583720282,
0.1885895133,
-0.2890710235,
-0.0382294357,
0.9581849575,
0.0810255781,
-0.9765450358,
0.4326329231,
-0.35042274,
-0.0643260628,
-0.9620466828,
-0.2496472001,
-0.3332363069,
-0.0495131873,
0.1204279661,
-0.5017595887,
-0.1833737791,
-0.2401464432,
0.0700644404,
-0.4000697434,
0.6366383433,
-0.615567565,
-0.050689932,
0.3813233376,
0.5731341839,
0.0358837917,
0.087826021,
-0.5640989542,
-0.2257539332,
0.0722052157,
-0.2331050187,
0.4167764485,
0.4656559229,
-0.2069857419,
0.6665572524,
0.6300362945,
-0.0894786492,
-0.1775056124,
0.5643389225,
1.0408968925,
-0.561155498,
-0.9609823227,
-0.3512898386,
0.287478447,
-0.2951765954,
-0.4035263062,
0.5780797005,
0.3801637888,
0.688862741,
0.1572455764,
1.0087813139,
0.1571009755,
0.5705005527,
-0.401702553,
0.393217504,
-0.2079686075,
0.217985034,
-0.3285157084,
-0.953540504,
-0.1572529674,
0.6521233916,
-0.035362158,
0.0098679159,
0.8828538656,
0.8691473603,
0.0222972836,
0.3874032199,
0.1721289158,
0.0374363028,
0.4009750485,
0.417309463,
1.0804989338,
0.046189107,
0.5790395141,
0.0345850736,
-0.2980309427,
-0.208591193,
-0.7128131986,
-0.7113385797,
-0.6982734799,
-0.3345269263,
-0.612177074,
-0.0634390563,
0.8949099183,
0.7703960538,
-0.723878026,
-0.0834439695,
0.4273774326,
0.0221021827,
-0.4491560757,
-0.1446988583,
0.6066814661,
-0.4442349076,
-0.6157440543,
0.6989412308,
0.4628475606,
-0.0805212334,
0.0182408504,
-0.1100982502,
-0.0440662354,
0.2572298348,
0.5911304355,
0.1479595602,
-0.6344975829,
-0.5410854816,
0.2377183884,
-0.181521371,
0.2157278806,
1.2229627371,
-0.5721814632,
0.6239201427,
0.2656850815,
0.3854212165,
0.7390559912,
0.1581522524,
0.6975464225,
-0.8879414201,
-0.070155628,
0.1460249424,
0.6391949058,
0.2944983542,
-0.3414489031,
0.1714886129,
0.4205996394,
-0.3584101498,
-0.6808100939,
0.7580127716,
-0.9827936292,
-0.2873421013,
0.9759002924,
-0.4844639897,
0.053190589,
-0.683065176,
-0.4758400619,
0.3171569407,
-0.7137150764,
0.3814868629,
0.7698646188,
-0.6023987532,
0.1364681423,
-0.1391641349,
0.7476090789,
0.2468756735,
-0.588241756,
0.4123471677,
0.7874862552,
0.2810428441,
0.243002668,
1.2855904102,
0.2711680532,
0.2083750069,
0.1568057537,
-0.3826442361,
-0.076702036,
-0.6457400918,
-0.259691149,
0.040984299,
-0.2297201604,
-0.2287550271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06243v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06243v2
|
Parameter-Efficient Orthogonal Finetuning via Butterfly Factorization
| 2023-11-10T18:59:54 | 2024-04-28T20:05:02 |
Weiyang Liu, Zeju Qiu, Yao Feng, Yuliang Xiu, Yuxuan Xue, Longhui Yu, Haiwen Feng, Zhen Liu, Juyeon Heo, Songyou Peng, Yandong Wen, Michael J. Black, Adrian Weller, Bernhard Schölkopf
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large foundation models are becoming ubiquitous, but training them from
scratch is prohibitively expensive. Thus, efficiently adapting these powerful
models to downstream tasks is increasingly important. In this paper, we study a
principled finetuning paradigm -- Orthogonal Finetuning (OFT) -- for downstream
task adaptation. Despite demonstrating good generalizability, OFT still uses a
fairly large number of trainable parameters due to the high dimensionality of
orthogonal matrices. To address this, we start by examining OFT from an
information transmission perspective, and then identify a few key desiderata
that enable better parameter-efficiency. Inspired by how the Cooley-Tukey fast
Fourier transform algorithm enables efficient information transmission, we
propose an efficient orthogonal parameterization using butterfly structures. We
apply this parameterization to OFT, creating a novel parameter-efficient
finetuning method, called Orthogonal Butterfly (BOFT). By subsuming OFT as a
special case, BOFT introduces a generalized orthogonal finetuning framework.
Finally, we conduct an extensive empirical study of adapting large vision
transformers, large language models, and text-to-image diffusion models to
various downstream tasks in vision and language.
|
[
-0.6349279881,
-0.9033275247,
0.391084969,
0.4745534062,
-0.4553081691,
-0.1735986322,
-0.073092103,
-0.3079041243,
-0.2789046168,
0.3289480507,
-0.5622019172,
-0.0597759001,
-0.5688304901,
-0.1419360042,
-0.3115602434,
0.9512425661,
-0.0042357529,
-0.1163297892,
0.5377518535,
-0.033474084,
-0.3056090772,
-0.3685104251,
-0.8030955791,
-0.2523959875,
0.6781930327,
0.3292627633,
0.740465343,
1.1923849583,
0.7227015495,
0.2291358113,
0.1796759963,
0.0227367226,
-0.8417070508,
-0.1137246862,
-0.4005806744,
-0.5008071065,
-0.3318822086,
-0.3206654191,
0.5793364048,
1.1626149416,
0.0130875111,
0.3298628628,
0.6718427539,
1.0770566463,
-0.7389089465,
0.4013794661,
-0.6059009433,
0.0149572203,
-0.3236040771,
-0.2770368159,
-0.1716175824,
-0.5726251006,
0.0202517193,
-0.6947897673,
-0.0076851421,
-0.0871556774,
0.6409663558,
0.3338377476,
-0.5469360352,
0.0264639705,
-0.8265478611,
0.7488939762,
-0.4465075731,
0.9716229439,
0.5213908553,
0.3125204146,
-0.0150730349,
-0.645983696,
-0.2722738087,
0.0381335765,
0.2325184941,
0.1665589511,
-0.4012850225,
0.3538919091,
0.0727857947,
0.310773313,
-0.3577204347,
0.0976192653,
-0.483890444,
0.0687793791,
0.4149163961,
-0.0174738411,
-0.1981672645,
-0.0750914738,
-0.4739190042,
-0.2680042386,
-0.4051842391,
0.44637537,
0.345127821,
0.4016324878,
-0.1830272228,
0.1334446967,
-0.2868424058,
0.8819678426,
0.8428775668,
0.036820706,
-0.254645586,
0.0366714783,
-0.4078224301,
-0.3672184646,
0.3404776752,
0.2937721014,
0.1330177635,
-0.2702376842,
-0.1039335355,
-0.2388120294,
0.265155524,
-0.9846498966,
-0.2523541451,
0.0247816686,
-0.8513206244,
-0.0750862435,
-0.0074536405,
-0.6883926988,
-0.332690984,
-0.7602729201,
0.7990400791,
-0.6218109131,
-0.0675598457,
0.1435934752,
-0.0165089294,
0.3937913179,
0.1418043524,
-1.145336628,
0.3188351393,
0.8116317391,
0.7284469008,
-0.1364160478,
-0.139946565,
-0.5832868814,
0.1555580199,
-0.5897548795,
0.7718121409,
-0.1940541416,
-0.0742966905,
-0.1487445682,
-0.2399287969,
-0.2177391946,
-0.375393033,
0.4392953515,
-0.4874110222,
-0.3398606479,
-0.3375180066,
-0.0889581963,
-0.771239996,
-0.0363268889,
-0.4007836282,
0.4670223296,
0.3525646925,
-0.3099032044,
0.3188623786,
-0.5756862164,
-0.6100947261,
-0.2138901502,
-0.1238916814,
-0.2728016376,
0.4457542002,
0.2183755189,
0.8938842416,
-0.4433637559,
0.2130839527,
-0.8010385633,
-0.4459693134,
0.1751470864,
-0.3729844987,
0.9229751229,
0.4946724176,
-0.247854948,
-0.1653326452,
-1.0499103069,
0.0472238958,
-0.4277950227,
-0.5130662918,
-0.4083314836,
-0.01485408,
0.2277644277,
-0.1408949196,
-0.2334266603,
-0.2495547533,
0.4198088348,
-0.348644346,
0.672244966,
0.9362720847,
0.1005287617,
0.6992115378,
-0.4314420223,
0.2315531075,
-0.3345735371,
0.4275044799,
0.1137911156,
-0.0961576179,
-0.8567842841,
-0.7202659845,
0.1686333269,
0.4546467364,
-0.7177343369,
0.3823976219,
-0.2153967768,
-0.5998436213,
-0.1943213493,
0.0922237188,
0.2864162624,
0.3825692236,
0.2248418927,
-0.0828268006,
-0.4372111857,
-1.0222445726,
-0.1831701994,
0.2571382523,
-0.1688077301,
-0.0610777698,
0.2232352942,
-0.1636852771,
0.7305919528,
-0.6803444624,
-0.5369825363,
0.1735241711,
0.4416677952,
0.5592624545,
0.790982306,
1.024302721,
-0.6808357835,
-0.5834648013,
0.1735622734,
-0.5178370476,
-0.0068139848,
-0.3426334262,
-0.3964265585,
-0.1933434159,
0.5521137714,
-0.2428824753,
0.063777037,
0.6069359183,
-0.1461846381,
0.0014864969,
-0.063005209,
0.1899168938,
-1.0423460007,
0.0851221159,
-0.0500521995,
-0.1636331826,
-0.6865362525,
0.4579527676,
0.0860968754,
-0.2247876674,
0.037107382,
0.1300958544,
-0.5653936863,
0.2820577919,
-0.3021419942,
-0.5992917418,
-0.3403046727,
1.0182851553,
-0.253056407,
0.359062314,
0.8625131845,
-0.7133817077,
0.0596682206,
0.0661714822,
0.0661744252,
0.9838226438,
-0.3537793458,
0.2716349363,
-0.2319975048,
0.0861951411,
-1.1108756065,
-0.0704569072,
0.2216666192,
-0.1365239322,
0.2815608084,
-0.3866816759,
-0.1342004389,
-0.0842606872,
-0.7125499845,
0.3461398184,
0.6398999095,
-0.579878211,
0.9878824949,
0.0485454425,
-0.4832589626,
-0.1489685923,
-0.9617456198,
-0.2780861855,
-0.2717978954,
-0.6331963539,
0.2291485071,
-0.0274035297,
0.20059295,
-0.2263703048,
-0.3894974291,
-0.6073795557,
0.164391011,
0.3810684085,
-0.0614636205,
-0.540563345,
-0.0403586775,
0.3715410531,
-0.1468105465,
-0.1400229037,
-0.7030464411,
0.2761581838,
0.1736431569,
-0.1618793309,
-0.4639269412,
0.587687254,
0.5178681612,
-0.2873327434,
0.3794496357,
0.7672033906,
-0.5098781586,
-0.4763070941,
-0.5306107402,
-0.3835407197,
-0.50797683,
0.5947393775,
-0.4609248042,
-0.7807481885,
0.6431421041,
-0.0798667297,
0.1223891601,
0.268291086,
0.1804653555,
-0.2160278261,
0.9113363624,
0.9812525511,
0.0286120512,
0.7797065377,
-0.6838523746,
0.3085030615,
-0.6166374683,
0.4085663557,
-0.5648646355,
-0.5804017186,
-0.509540081,
-0.4659341872,
0.4421760738,
0.672624886,
-0.6032844186,
0.2217356116,
-0.3593609929,
0.0908759534,
0.6246609092,
0.408642143,
0.2093106657,
0.3436469138,
0.2315206677,
0.0356046408,
-0.731385231,
0.0897595361,
1.1350442171,
0.3450093269,
0.8935373425,
0.1756049842,
0.4989039302,
0.214337796,
0.3109381199,
-0.6518647075,
0.3651978374,
-0.7454793453,
-0.352247864,
-0.1660616547,
-0.2613300085,
-0.6956716776,
0.1789959371,
-0.4765470028,
-0.7480601668,
0.9994766712,
0.5487513542,
-0.793138504,
0.1712171435,
-0.8057208657,
0.5517318249,
0.0671018511,
-0.583212316,
-0.2761873007,
-0.2674202323,
0.3119103611,
-0.5391379595,
0.1493844688,
0.1364721954,
-0.0880899951,
0.7633304,
-0.383235842,
0.862206161,
-0.3261565864,
-0.0660202652,
0.1295386106,
0.1678766459,
0.5524362922,
-0.060321223,
-0.1511241645,
0.2025873065,
-0.04352016,
-0.3081219196,
-0.6341567636,
0.5792723894,
-0.659658432,
-0.3240260482,
-0.0807455257,
-0.7917633653,
-0.581504643,
0.2843342423,
0.3735953867,
0.6613830328,
0.3912557662,
0.6688008904,
0.4390150309,
0.2801751196,
0.3444469571,
0.4552031755,
-0.0725417212,
-0.4434382319,
1.1083033085,
0.4983407259,
0.200880304,
0.6203606129,
0.3176514804,
-0.2537769973,
-0.9262455702,
-0.1356748641,
-0.0430096276,
-0.6035267115,
-0.576834321,
-0.3361822069,
-0.1310231984,
-0.2649190724,
-0.6859403253,
-0.3341179192,
-0.3506162763,
-0.042836085,
0.0946036056,
0.5114488602,
0.2914563119,
-0.3955232501,
0.613496542,
-0.6932268739,
0.7621016502,
0.8286415935,
0.6608412862,
0.255418241,
-0.4869433641,
-0.134934932,
0.1546180248,
-0.6553080082,
-0.8076474667,
-0.317722708,
0.5895004869,
0.4898405075,
0.6599880457,
0.1922982782,
1.0187547207,
-0.3002864718,
0.1531413645,
0.2329190969,
-1.1085727215,
-0.0317699313,
-0.8959041834,
0.1276289821,
0.4531097412,
0.4843266606,
-0.2102373093,
-0.3130183816,
0.0471819192,
-0.8521608114,
0.5502963066,
0.1357657313,
0.1220534518,
0.5113493204,
0.4805914164,
0.3034231067,
-0.0877717584,
-0.7662041187,
0.1654981673,
-0.3070606887,
-0.3448776901,
0.0121855848,
-0.1663462073,
0.1451432705,
-0.4385371804,
0.4176554978,
-0.3103733957,
0.3181301951,
0.1146059409,
-0.202815026,
-0.1347533911,
0.2474604398,
0.2468288243,
0.695515871,
-0.2293592542,
-0.0392891541,
0.0416103974,
-0.5821400285,
0.1723137498,
0.7151367068,
-0.2492664903,
-0.5332136154,
0.538906157,
0.6578361392,
0.3346925676,
-0.0182245821,
0.1681324989,
0.5467530489,
-0.4726207256,
0.3593511283,
0.0840289146,
-0.0359158963,
0.7153560519,
0.7942951918,
0.3298664689,
0.52692765,
-0.575042963,
0.0219468735,
0.1641963869,
-0.3726360202,
-0.2024529725,
0.7205872536,
0.401832968,
0.0875622928,
0.2018387169,
-0.0649865866,
-0.1102757752,
0.3179075718,
0.30183658,
0.9807893038,
-0.3515902758,
-0.1858824342,
0.164961189,
0.1971185058,
0.0095814727,
0.5179804564,
-0.2830574512,
-0.3209364712,
-0.5661257505,
-0.6411949992,
0.0774655938,
0.0919398814,
-0.6200238466,
0.1153789982,
-0.6790394187,
-0.1883356273,
0.3626146317,
-0.4071888626,
-0.5017297864,
0.046591036,
0.0843172744,
0.7919502854,
-0.7230364084,
0.6957986951,
0.6970106363,
-0.2975709438,
-0.9855616093,
-0.0362361073,
-0.0729970858,
-0.688157618,
0.6580371261,
-0.2108771652,
-0.2096057087,
0.4126397669,
-0.1901809424,
-0.7888335586,
0.8990626335,
0.7814155221,
-0.8383999467,
0.0216213744,
0.280459404,
0.3329839408,
0.0507217385,
-0.310642153,
0.1949268728,
0.5437211394,
-0.228230387,
-0.7749561071,
-0.0003237522,
0.0289781634,
0.4776691496,
0.286280483,
-0.554343164,
1.1419728994,
-0.0082724346,
-0.0892161056,
0.112669237,
0.5733870864,
-0.0973678008,
0.0765694827,
0.7354360819,
0.0839157328,
0.2568846047,
-0.1469998807,
0.6651943326,
-0.2284304202,
0.5277452469,
0.712877214,
0.1147409603,
0.9783837795,
0.6034189463,
-0.3269605041,
0.0132762371,
0.4400491714,
-0.068440184,
0.7016098499,
0.4111871719,
0.4166871011,
-0.1155399308,
0.2179902345,
-0.3825298548,
0.614390254,
-0.1198195443,
-0.170674473,
-0.3680927753,
0.7769591212,
-0.0143015673,
0.2391193211,
-0.8894646764,
0.6194692254,
0.124506712,
-0.6130977869,
0.9888291955,
-0.0321983472,
0.7956489325,
-0.811819315,
-0.129103899,
-0.3849361539,
0.7270609736,
-0.3262331188,
-0.5638408065,
0.3061091602,
-0.1150387004,
-0.4317934811,
-0.4841317236,
0.5472413301,
-0.3495590091,
-0.6391885877,
0.1596719325,
0.1381452233,
-0.4138432741,
-0.5412756205,
-0.432069838,
0.1105792373,
-0.0542286895,
-0.1573875695,
0.163738355,
0.3029503226,
-0.2064893395,
0.547488749,
0.724160552,
0.0138907917,
0.1724675745,
-0.3708461225,
0.7922295332,
-0.5275036097,
-0.9350932837,
-0.6441625357,
0.4569351971,
0.3001698554,
-0.3069781661,
0.5409736037,
0.4655027688,
0.6702181101,
-0.4120899737,
0.5093291402,
0.0138054946,
0.3408377469,
-0.7289107442,
0.9422429204,
-0.4850852787,
-0.2095353603,
-0.4735805988,
-1.1587451696,
-0.1843990833,
0.7549463511,
-0.1606853008,
0.1654213816,
0.5290442705,
0.519605279,
-0.651452601,
0.1564022303,
0.1315725893,
0.5775975585,
0.136504665,
0.7317291498,
0.4963291287,
-0.4062028527,
0.5530988574,
-0.5756358504,
-0.5304674506,
-0.4341982603,
-0.9865009785,
-0.6071234345,
-0.904335022,
-0.35924384,
0.1735661924,
0.4604189098,
0.59841609,
1.355817914,
-0.6711632609,
-0.4486679435,
-0.1852382571,
-0.3612247407,
-0.7319775224,
-0.209351629,
0.6160451174,
-0.1545550525,
-0.3458194435,
-0.1469400972,
0.3467234969,
-0.0492077135,
-0.0457119308,
0.2263088673,
-0.0748656467,
0.1179307029,
0.8829631209,
0.2924750745,
-0.3985674977,
-0.5103412867,
-0.0958055854,
0.0531321168,
-0.2096293569,
0.7171373367,
-0.3229409754,
0.1823062003,
0.4744058847,
0.8705457449,
0.4287263751,
-0.1580094546,
0.6665278077,
-0.2512931228,
0.293538332,
0.0918801725,
0.1166284978,
0.0052715451,
-0.2262270898,
0.4250692129,
0.1531176716,
-0.3117696047,
-0.666754365,
0.0984555334,
-1.4126261473,
-0.2875302136,
0.8730889559,
-0.0382511653,
-0.1739806533,
-0.090832293,
-0.5400825739,
0.1367361844,
-0.1541524827,
0.7778260708,
0.3946282268,
-0.2057083994,
-0.0567328595,
-0.4161353111,
0.4697020054,
0.1533160657,
-0.8331587911,
0.1233340576,
0.2174054086,
0.3536069989,
0.082627736,
0.4942067266,
0.2876780331,
0.54481107,
-0.044479467,
-0.2883137763,
-0.3084599674,
-0.0183672477,
-0.3893573582,
0.3042069674,
0.1793791503,
-0.4696867764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06239v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06239v1
|
Argumentation Element Annotation Modeling using XLNet
| 2023-11-10T18:55:23 | 2023-11-10T18:55:23 |
Christopher Ormerod, Amy Burkhardt, Mackenzie Young, Sue Lottridge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study demonstrates the effectiveness of XLNet, a transformer-based
language model, for annotating argumentative elements in persuasive essays.
XLNet's architecture incorporates a recurrent mechanism that allows it to model
long-term dependencies in lengthy texts. Fine-tuned XLNet models were applied
to three datasets annotated with different schemes - a proprietary dataset
using the Annotations for Revisions and Reflections on Writing (ARROW) scheme,
the PERSUADE corpus, and the Argument Annotated Essays (AAE) dataset. The XLNet
models achieved strong performance across all datasets, even surpassing human
agreement levels in some cases. This shows XLNet capably handles diverse
annotation schemes and lengthy essays. Comparisons between the model outputs on
different datasets also revealed insights into the relationships between the
annotation tags. Overall, XLNet's strong performance on modeling argumentative
structures across diverse datasets highlights its suitability for providing
automated feedback on essay organization.
|
[
-0.3674046099,
-0.7367707491,
0.564979434,
0.1170654967,
-0.0641349256,
-0.0752369314,
-0.0024386481,
-0.480713129,
0.1237729266,
0.504070282,
-0.3362986445,
-0.4141436517,
-0.3528326154,
0.4769418538,
-0.6196836233,
1.0483747721,
-0.3531021476,
0.1075274572,
-0.1883390248,
-0.2617692947,
-0.3528418243,
-0.4852355719,
-1.0319701433,
-0.4420955777,
1.1763467789,
0.3062410057,
0.4681024551,
0.853974998,
0.3399966061,
0.4030082524,
-0.0436775573,
-0.0693505779,
-0.1508791745,
0.2562982142,
-0.4145188928,
-0.4221179485,
-0.2504118085,
0.0004442727,
0.7004385591,
0.6133846045,
0.3172054291,
0.1524027139,
-0.0387082472,
0.3615234792,
-0.371157676,
0.0475655161,
-0.7358219028,
0.268094629,
-0.0939286202,
-0.0194101706,
-0.6516076922,
-0.20634453,
0.1609863639,
-0.4127511084,
-0.214471072,
0.3429151177,
0.8132833242,
0.0569995232,
-0.3659782708,
-0.2800104618,
-0.7454351783,
0.7951914668,
-0.7426479459,
-0.0644399598,
0.1129119992,
0.0663459226,
0.2346546799,
-1.101370573,
-0.5929518938,
-0.2307534218,
-0.3316689134,
0.1738752425,
-0.249535352,
0.1089383513,
0.278232336,
0.1162575856,
-0.3126909733,
0.3771304786,
-0.2444924265,
-0.0366149768,
0.5968998671,
0.2028641701,
0.2104589939,
-0.3357297778,
-0.3194994926,
-0.0453266427,
-0.5783868432,
-0.0070627737,
0.5901986361,
0.4292775095,
0.1860979199,
0.5213478804,
0.1015005931,
0.4722456038,
0.2472053617,
0.4446376562,
-0.0473233499,
0.0643753558,
-0.2190507799,
0.2381861061,
0.8035982251,
0.2943319976,
0.0272377115,
-0.0773100629,
-0.2882482708,
-0.015777519,
0.427598685,
-0.9063959122,
-0.2327591479,
0.4891404808,
-0.7425714135,
-0.5219963789,
0.1689571291,
-0.7274545431,
-0.5965964198,
-0.5573541522,
0.5400434136,
-0.361803025,
-0.0827339664,
-0.2216552198,
-0.0609542429,
0.214801386,
0.1298530102,
-0.6123946905,
0.3410982788,
1.0442106724,
0.9502910376,
-0.1987337768,
-0.2381910384,
-0.3805781901,
-0.2073622346,
-0.5236924887,
1.2229468822,
-1.0377275944,
-0.0318195857,
0.3332483768,
0.2820703387,
-0.1343926042,
-0.3344556391,
1.1234916449,
-0.3482275903,
0.1049885005,
-0.1551769078,
-1.1100828648,
-0.4083253741,
0.2071288377,
-1.0715168715,
0.6305345297,
-0.1480491161,
-0.8951106668,
0.1614555269,
-1.0923823118,
-0.3214317262,
0.1551358104,
-0.305729866,
-0.7379160523,
0.0320260562,
-0.1280787736,
0.6555791497,
0.0054564769,
0.040349178,
-0.182352379,
-0.1643763036,
0.4148464203,
-0.1789848953,
0.6283060312,
0.1961650997,
-0.5137668252,
0.4034154415,
-0.9244661927,
-0.3051434457,
0.007701342,
-0.1936583221,
-0.4330245256,
0.3843535185,
0.262190789,
0.0621691681,
-0.0237360708,
-0.8125450015,
0.182115227,
-0.3225224316,
0.4943373799,
0.839710176,
0.0701545402,
0.0053347377,
-0.4022422731,
0.4718340635,
0.2816180587,
-0.1665222198,
-0.6837473512,
-0.3135981262,
-0.8001285791,
0.238156274,
0.4093459547,
0.4954473376,
-0.4666425288,
0.2379642278,
-0.0974352062,
-0.3603417277,
-0.3144768178,
-0.1665645689,
0.2492350936,
0.5617272854,
0.395776391,
0.0612294227,
-0.8265916705,
-1.117985487,
0.0438314863,
-0.2954655588,
0.2444562614,
0.2716128528,
0.7625173926,
0.029618701,
0.9734730721,
-0.3849945068,
0.0106838681,
-0.4454218745,
0.8152040839,
0.0431521088,
0.4162988663,
0.5775308013,
-0.726106286,
-0.6476205587,
0.3220278025,
-0.4320164621,
-0.4218415916,
-0.5456635952,
-0.1548479348,
0.4048683345,
0.4177409112,
-0.1773559004,
0.4310749173,
0.3890663385,
-0.3521099985,
0.8636571765,
0.2541478276,
0.0806293562,
-1.470541358,
0.2447217107,
0.2656058967,
-0.2984881699,
-0.5934541225,
-0.1708325148,
-0.1204165369,
0.0609152615,
-0.2250699848,
0.3046814501,
0.0331895128,
0.6347646117,
-0.5577155352,
-0.1004358605,
0.2043897957,
0.2637479603,
0.3799371719,
0.4762427807,
0.2788832784,
-0.1057976037,
0.5198546052,
0.1602250487,
-0.1129677296,
0.8391140699,
-0.9768779278,
0.1389882416,
-0.1593251526,
0.3349376619,
-1.0908712149,
-0.0371962115,
0.0999601707,
-0.1010677144,
0.1591780335,
-0.265011102,
0.0056141512,
-0.1544918269,
-0.4448609352,
0.0339854099,
-0.109147355,
-0.5735347867,
0.9688096046,
0.0255846381,
-0.3397784829,
-0.7463398576,
-0.4932836592,
0.5555984378,
-0.5012972951,
-0.47378245,
0.4110172093,
-0.168391481,
-0.4546176195,
0.0726189613,
0.3803267181,
-0.1312036663,
-0.0810242072,
0.6090096831,
0.2334149927,
-0.4983743727,
0.311891973,
-0.1085994542,
-0.101621598,
0.329908669,
-0.4012725353,
0.1366807222,
-0.0429429933,
-0.0958445668,
-0.3737946153,
1.0733524561,
0.3460968435,
0.2057966292,
0.8036026955,
0.4084093869,
-0.3804975152,
-0.4633202851,
-0.6603984237,
-0.1655693054,
-0.3752105534,
0.5794987679,
-0.2412137538,
-0.656507194,
0.5938093662,
-0.1607794762,
0.5927498937,
0.5459442139,
0.2794803083,
-0.1127412319,
0.8003928065,
0.3469025195,
-0.1646156609,
0.4124919772,
-0.1941504478,
0.1764747351,
-0.7819880247,
0.2155846804,
-0.8021817803,
-0.4515385926,
-0.4087955058,
0.0138456021,
-0.2401204854,
-0.371622473,
-0.3707271814,
0.366705358,
-0.4567061663,
0.3471635282,
0.275526464,
-0.2536036968,
-0.0156112406,
-0.0280003436,
-0.2864210904,
0.0545997843,
-0.3908564746,
-0.9854346514,
0.8391051292,
0.5520804524,
0.5573827028,
-0.2636912763,
0.3604350388,
0.4406805336,
0.5087993145,
-0.7002946138,
0.5953161716,
-0.3905684948,
-0.5133057237,
-0.1148303002,
-0.427792877,
-1.0316387415,
-0.0653950498,
-0.2244387567,
-0.8288366199,
0.2683874071,
0.1480135769,
-0.503918469,
0.5938555002,
-0.6208854914,
0.7869547009,
-0.0707464293,
-0.6231313348,
0.1350272447,
-0.4694871306,
-0.2218215168,
-0.1099193096,
-0.3138609827,
0.2973048091,
0.2063668221,
0.9503796101,
-0.4333265126,
1.0394312143,
0.0062734182,
-0.125475198,
0.3571565747,
-0.219986707,
0.6170522571,
-0.240499422,
-0.4313890338,
0.0382321179,
-0.1437885612,
0.0063328496,
-0.6568912268,
0.4976224303,
-0.8063504696,
-0.616722703,
-0.1433252394,
-0.3191407025,
0.122593604,
0.0001428666,
0.0597666055,
0.7524731755,
-0.13150011,
0.482563436,
0.4700849652,
-0.084640637,
0.7097274661,
0.184919104,
-0.1899627596,
-0.4105683863,
0.7442556024,
0.4255726933,
-0.0574283749,
0.5724672079,
0.4949068129,
-0.2165955007,
-0.5310720801,
-0.3012945652,
0.0239817444,
-1.0044785738,
-0.2402038872,
-0.7741626501,
-0.4429184794,
-0.2264522463,
-0.287966162,
-0.4109131992,
-0.6513825059,
-0.1032278463,
-0.4595220089,
0.3442512453,
1.1576555967,
0.1268584281,
0.2221354842,
-0.3851772249,
-0.3181073666,
0.2358121872,
0.3367649913,
0.1889734864,
-0.2905559838,
-0.4564653635,
-0.2824983895,
-0.5287769437,
-0.8214470148,
0.0408490747,
-0.000259951,
0.4220196903,
0.7196869254,
0.0192071553,
0.414132148,
-0.4059589505,
1.0532290936,
-0.0525294058,
-0.9773976803,
0.3371207714,
-0.1308233589,
0.1287343949,
0.3658166826,
0.5452734828,
-0.5900936127,
-0.2860993445,
-0.1540749967,
-1.1442607641,
0.4410723746,
0.1158199236,
0.1512135118,
-0.0236104988,
0.7388290167,
0.3375022411,
-0.1935459822,
-1.1687861681,
-0.3092242777,
-0.4377389848,
-0.3243193328,
0.5152642727,
-0.4350627363,
-0.130318433,
0.015197047,
0.9110395908,
-0.1963938028,
0.143275246,
0.3595596552,
0.2172931731,
0.1014363319,
0.2899083793,
0.8183927536,
0.5763417482,
0.0661708638,
0.2324150652,
0.2397503853,
-0.4803086817,
0.0825714245,
0.3533529341,
-0.2709290385,
0.1939134747,
0.6848032475,
0.9348942041,
-0.1804879755,
-0.0434800498,
0.1336459517,
-0.2015394866,
-0.3267900646,
-0.6184723377,
-0.1675383151,
0.2594194412,
0.145812422,
0.4124303758,
-0.1445484459,
0.0949043483,
-0.2271041721,
0.1499862671,
0.2118741572,
-0.6700099111,
-0.4208631516,
0.561945498,
0.3564352095,
-0.3306651413,
0.1918386519,
0.2095201612,
-0.5216757059,
0.6157551408,
0.5417015553,
1.112518549,
-0.2909249961,
0.1812984943,
0.4463503063,
0.1197582111,
0.2387979329,
-0.0753455088,
0.052441787,
-0.5622068048,
-0.5951833129,
-0.383633405,
-0.518545866,
0.4443148375,
-0.3327038288,
0.1986942887,
-0.2492601424,
-0.2300908118,
0.4350153506,
0.110927932,
-0.2178268135,
0.2233169526,
0.3587714136,
0.8568584323,
-0.959346056,
0.5014683008,
1.1145325899,
-0.4761994779,
-0.8874021173,
-0.0751815364,
-0.1522835642,
-0.0911175832,
0.8066988587,
0.3272873759,
-0.3837463856,
-0.4829500914,
-0.7010062337,
-0.4116333425,
0.9477607012,
0.0572240874,
-0.6081680655,
0.311372757,
0.5876809955,
0.4962825477,
-0.9134224653,
0.6023210883,
0.1579788476,
0.7503086925,
0.0449617542,
-0.3887732029,
0.0567564294,
-0.537350893,
0.1084269136,
-0.1462301314,
-0.4405860007,
0.7813004851,
0.2841088474,
-0.0018771519,
0.1106574163,
0.8559836745,
-0.219888851,
0.32085374,
0.6868961453,
0.5099917054,
0.4212798476,
0.0340389982,
0.7974592447,
-0.3653215766,
0.1093407348,
1.2646203041,
-0.5905194879,
1.0367655754,
0.3649596572,
0.223959744,
0.932172358,
0.3603497446,
-0.0968030393,
-0.2022417188,
0.4262906611,
-0.3252948523,
-0.1766946614,
-0.2718669772,
-0.0251808986,
0.4636597931,
0.1467850208,
-0.7290244102,
-0.0198697783,
-0.2261990011,
0.4769739807,
0.2889678776,
-0.2942016423,
0.8542128205,
-0.018707877,
-0.853505373,
-0.0822486952,
-0.0058509819,
0.4308696091,
-0.5107812285,
-0.4146147668,
-0.1865801513,
0.1277168095,
-0.4558812082,
-0.8191205859,
0.4288848341,
0.0993350148,
-0.2369496524,
-0.0569247976,
0.7856270075,
-0.2802500427,
-0.979014039,
0.2284514904,
-0.0690048262,
-0.174998641,
0.3520901501,
-0.5973297954,
0.2277768105,
-0.1486638486,
-0.6718116999,
-0.0649864674,
0.5374159813,
0.073142238,
0.3243472874,
0.3950101733,
0.1516497731,
-0.2466902435,
0.1789069474,
0.7962310314,
-0.5839428902,
-0.3455630243,
-1.0048946142,
0.7146638632,
-0.6426007748,
-0.2410289794,
0.5805130601,
0.5335783958,
0.3611552715,
0.1830094159,
1.0423665047,
0.1386390328,
0.6473821998,
-0.278865397,
0.725556314,
-0.2762519419,
0.1223937199,
-0.3851975203,
-0.7428479195,
-0.4787429273,
0.8113852143,
-0.417411238,
0.1378728598,
0.8216876388,
0.740000546,
0.083735019,
0.4636068642,
0.2671954036,
0.5583433509,
0.5683295131,
0.2838920653,
0.9246838689,
-0.2349068969,
0.5178512931,
-0.3014435172,
-0.0237879641,
-0.0222489536,
-1.4392790794,
-1.0156004429,
-0.9594121575,
-0.8400542736,
-0.3457060456,
0.0410591438,
1.1678419113,
0.7246015668,
-1.0101159811,
-0.2569392025,
-0.0307679027,
-0.0173152629,
-0.2193525881,
-0.3022775948,
0.5599686503,
-0.3327083588,
-0.6657722592,
0.0249933731,
0.4168045223,
-0.3108455241,
-0.4726290703,
0.27919361,
-0.3621518314,
0.7177754045,
0.6540192366,
0.1818041503,
-0.5015465021,
-0.7787182927,
-0.3177136481,
0.1202371866,
0.2378757149,
0.9336761832,
-0.551104784,
0.254570812,
0.3480437696,
0.7120334506,
-0.0884201676,
0.2792411447,
0.60039258,
-0.535846293,
-0.2528786063,
0.191327095,
0.7301801443,
0.4614543021,
-0.3842402101,
0.4140879512,
-0.1196589991,
-0.9736359119,
-0.5181874037,
0.0211446751,
-0.8884094357,
-0.353461802,
1.1694228649,
-0.710277915,
-0.3067219853,
-0.4188247919,
-0.509440124,
-0.0156334769,
-0.396476984,
1.0843528509,
1.0157862902,
-0.1875050813,
-0.2809696496,
-0.1540270001,
0.2243379653,
0.5362481475,
-0.8597083092,
0.2444669455,
0.4268475473,
-0.0333211645,
0.5684688091,
-0.0334533602,
0.0790506005,
-0.0206148587,
0.0160778742,
-0.0363417268,
-0.2250482291,
-0.2032308578,
-0.1498351842,
0.6454851627,
-0.0289113466,
0.0095169358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06330v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06330v4
|
Smart Agent-Based Modeling: On the Use of Large Language Models in Computer Simulations
| 2023-11-10T18:54:33 | 2023-12-14T21:59:41 |
Zengqing Wu, Run Peng, Xu Han, Shuyuan Zheng, Yixin Zhang, Chuan Xiao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.MA, econ.GN, q-fin.EC
|
Computer simulations offer a robust toolset for exploring complex systems
across various disciplines. A particularly impactful approach within this realm
is Agent-Based Modeling (ABM), which harnesses the interactions of individual
agents to emulate intricate system dynamics. ABM's strength lies in its
bottom-up methodology, illuminating emergent phenomena by modeling the
behaviors of individual components of a system. Yet, ABM has its own set of
challenges, notably its struggle with modeling natural language instructions
and common sense in mathematical equations or rules. This paper seeks to
transcend these boundaries by integrating Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT
into ABM. This amalgamation gives birth to a novel framework, Smart Agent-Based
Modeling (SABM). Building upon the concept of smart agents -- entities
characterized by their intelligence, adaptability, and computation ability --
we explore in the direction of utilizing LLM-powered agents to simulate
real-world scenarios with increased nuance and realism. In this comprehensive
exploration, we elucidate the state of the art of ABM, introduce SABM's
potential and methodology, and present three case studies (source codes
available at https://github.com/Roihn/SABM), demonstrating the SABM methodology
and validating its effectiveness in modeling real-world systems. Furthermore,
we cast a vision towards several aspects of the future of SABM, anticipating a
broader horizon for its applications. Through this endeavor, we aspire to
redefine the boundaries of computer simulations, enabling a more profound
understanding of complex systems.
|
[
-0.4969130456,
-1.1036459208,
0.617870152,
-0.0511384085,
-0.096913211,
0.3145316839,
-0.1776415259,
-0.4969905317,
0.1323444694,
0.7489345074,
-0.5229054093,
-0.3326026499,
-0.232178092,
-0.1476507932,
-0.3742775619,
0.7188673615,
0.2587853372,
0.0740414113,
-0.4096104801,
0.2536710203,
-0.3334249854,
-0.6970357895,
-0.2665956616,
-0.8133862615,
0.0413106643,
0.1694547087,
1.1857897043,
0.7841286659,
0.5455460548,
0.4159012735,
0.1071571857,
0.1665107906,
-0.0775182471,
0.1138139889,
-0.4625255167,
-0.3265859485,
-0.5895463228,
-0.0077174697,
0.6267632246,
0.5793560147,
-0.0691257045,
-0.0949139595,
-0.3206658661,
0.2017203718,
-0.2872723937,
0.5317068696,
-0.6593648195,
-0.1659731716,
0.1506936848,
-0.2222229689,
-0.2687494755,
-0.278306514,
0.0197251048,
-0.2820108831,
0.0765885189,
-0.176849246,
0.8394502997,
0.2603065372,
-0.4836463034,
-0.2865110934,
-1.1587712765,
0.9921678901,
-0.7623642683,
0.1961477399,
0.0840435252,
0.6499907374,
-0.5136620402,
-0.645986855,
-0.5853260159,
-0.3239558041,
0.1998519003,
-0.0983901024,
0.0487067364,
0.3131655753,
-0.0413172729,
-0.040345069,
-0.291154176,
0.0811873078,
-0.0390118025,
-0.1534933746,
0.8444190025,
0.4571549594,
0.3517304957,
0.1235606819,
-0.4872452021,
0.1864480078,
-0.4994270802,
-0.3206567466,
0.1169335991,
0.7085030079,
0.0651722625,
0.5368281603,
-0.0861188546,
0.6244786382,
-0.3188434243,
-0.3931219876,
-0.1465432197,
-0.3141290545,
-0.2985523343,
-0.0264332034,
0.3914635181,
0.0847461224,
0.5057456493,
-0.2138351649,
-0.2970846295,
0.2287638038,
0.297978431,
-0.8711218834,
-0.0054602283,
0.326357305,
-0.2682966292,
-0.1089409292,
-0.1239355654,
-0.5103356838,
-0.6575900316,
-0.6832180023,
0.4723777175,
-0.4410302341,
-0.3087494075,
0.1281330884,
0.1773467511,
0.6211749315,
0.4797656238,
-0.5632838011,
0.5462965369,
1.0055273771,
0.6027749777,
0.0698980913,
-0.4673475623,
-0.3149395585,
0.335285306,
-0.3057025671,
0.9476677775,
-0.644290626,
-0.4039902389,
-0.1298760027,
-0.2196194828,
0.0384782963,
-0.6042796969,
-0.0362941101,
-0.5986155272,
-0.3349647224,
-0.0836416408,
-0.6073701978,
-0.3675715923,
0.4999734759,
-0.463062197,
0.5699884295,
-0.0537698381,
-0.0996203199,
0.0672573969,
-0.9304847717,
-0.416839689,
0.3774431348,
-0.1744863838,
-0.164728865,
-0.051251024,
-0.2506673932,
0.5552916527,
-0.5858289599,
0.5254493952,
-0.305900842,
-0.6198258996,
0.3724214435,
-0.253624469,
0.562941432,
0.3100186884,
-0.1287395656,
0.158123374,
-0.6020662189,
0.1693847626,
0.1838643253,
-0.0440775827,
-0.139146179,
0.0862879157,
0.0651701018,
0.3589003384,
0.5516978502,
-0.3171159625,
0.5233807564,
-0.3373079896,
0.3649593294,
0.6300650835,
0.0368359014,
0.5133357048,
-0.3673191369,
0.6150671244,
-0.2759244442,
0.2486010492,
-0.16200611,
-0.3388292491,
-0.2784205079,
-0.7723014355,
0.2321081907,
0.7385882139,
-0.719379127,
0.350641042,
-0.1215872318,
-0.6336906552,
-0.4229412973,
-0.041014567,
0.0654848218,
0.1671307385,
0.4243524075,
-0.2749298513,
-0.3142401278,
-0.6519641876,
-0.3695503771,
-0.3493145704,
0.3237720132,
0.2137456387,
0.5600528717,
-0.7123265266,
1.3461754322,
-0.3118671179,
-0.0492801555,
-0.6637286544,
-0.1213671342,
-0.062306188,
0.3779136539,
0.3893625736,
-0.8528851271,
-0.1863844246,
0.1386709511,
-0.7966986299,
-0.1308848113,
-0.1804855764,
0.0353776515,
0.112936154,
0.4529455304,
-0.8799325824,
0.6411368251,
0.1663026512,
-0.4072018564,
0.8215380907,
-0.205611825,
0.084866479,
-1.0187784433,
0.0884853825,
-0.1675894111,
-0.1272878349,
-0.7853551507,
0.5648675561,
-0.3007107377,
-0.2557707131,
-0.6330901384,
0.9496574402,
-0.499404192,
-0.4995338917,
-0.8181032538,
-0.053036157,
0.0107591823,
0.3501375616,
-0.0886398181,
0.582360208,
0.5997547507,
-0.6281927228,
0.7739399672,
-0.0409661606,
-0.0728705749,
0.4333694577,
-0.5240853429,
0.020915594,
-0.1524034142,
0.2719381154,
-0.6632289886,
-0.3125492632,
0.1154109836,
-0.1811178029,
0.2378212214,
-0.1830415428,
-0.9831604958,
-0.0827199817,
-0.057069432,
0.3334898651,
0.4604656696,
-0.2986280024,
1.2952440977,
0.3664903045,
-0.3366886675,
-0.3934429586,
-0.6378749013,
0.3455487192,
-0.1150114387,
-0.5029159784,
0.2358943373,
-0.1147527918,
-0.7213941216,
0.01231548,
0.2156609595,
-0.1321587861,
0.3795960844,
0.2103310972,
0.3190126717,
0.1507373154,
0.1677354723,
-0.029208079,
-0.1029810533,
0.0201679152,
-0.2409526259,
0.745880127,
-0.5259802341,
-0.5575677752,
-0.3646103144,
0.4271373749,
0.8215662837,
-0.4579915106,
0.8581601381,
0.2317014486,
-0.707868576,
-0.306407243,
-0.370678544,
-0.4424219728,
-0.4959716797,
0.5191281438,
-0.3489714265,
-0.49480474,
0.8711829185,
-0.5112380981,
0.2006831467,
-0.009949794,
0.6777701378,
0.23722817,
1.1353474855,
0.8474774957,
0.1248155013,
0.518057704,
-0.2308021337,
0.3047950268,
-0.3438875675,
-0.4444379807,
-0.4000120163,
-0.068290323,
-0.3370652199,
-0.6308037639,
0.0751089826,
-0.160965696,
-0.3897903562,
0.1350013912,
-0.1384073049,
0.4508638978,
0.198880747,
-0.2692274749,
0.4778989255,
-0.0641500354,
-0.201219812,
0.2300673872,
-0.732876122,
-0.8566834331,
0.6542983651,
0.4899677932,
0.9171570539,
0.0444936864,
0.5627167821,
0.4255352616,
0.6440722346,
-1.0311996937,
1.1427941322,
0.2764831483,
-0.8035141826,
-0.2382866293,
-0.4875730872,
-0.8619393706,
0.3063677251,
-0.146606952,
-0.5853281617,
-0.0816726834,
0.0020656213,
-0.1819628775,
0.4194552004,
-0.7892133594,
0.5564959049,
-0.3827719986,
-0.3734492362,
-0.2462359816,
-0.5380894542,
0.072698079,
-0.0642024204,
0.5070133209,
-0.089524664,
-0.2189104855,
0.164912343,
-0.6692807078,
0.7778881788,
-0.0970834568,
-0.1747450083,
0.748113513,
0.2212686092,
0.5627705455,
-0.2951318026,
-0.2845097184,
0.1123382226,
-0.1614539325,
-0.6361735463,
-0.6174012423,
0.7371102571,
-0.8026612401,
-0.4461349249,
-0.5690689683,
-0.8234621882,
-0.269323647,
0.2454755008,
-0.3533858657,
0.4105872214,
-0.2539591193,
-0.2255812585,
0.4486278296,
-0.1705424488,
0.3751312494,
0.8418951631,
-0.5220557451,
-0.1128450558,
1.0719543695,
0.3455352485,
0.2172611952,
0.1990158856,
0.0148813585,
-0.3406641185,
-0.5513968468,
-0.3264603913,
0.4180985987,
-0.719145596,
-0.1518829167,
-0.4662232101,
-0.3299541473,
-0.4345061779,
-0.3100662231,
-0.5201669931,
-0.1433028877,
-0.2059993744,
-0.1003828719,
0.4573879242,
0.7076050639,
0.0511063002,
0.3032544553,
-0.676795125,
0.1524910778,
0.2859536707,
0.3918896317,
0.1060329303,
-0.2427565455,
-0.5182866454,
-0.0015813059,
-0.1945362538,
-0.7842412591,
0.4559315741,
0.0142359184,
0.7458082438,
0.2723245621,
-0.025025297,
0.4624515772,
-0.3011147678,
0.6830347776,
-0.2428971231,
-0.8796190619,
0.344299823,
-0.5030396581,
0.4254197478,
0.4652341306,
0.153246358,
-0.2245601267,
-0.2285183966,
-0.52450037,
-0.8672474623,
0.2349061966,
-0.1172925159,
-0.0505395345,
0.0088273659,
0.4697577059,
0.0692094266,
0.4289268255,
-0.4838263988,
-0.0899394602,
-0.0874342471,
-0.2962474525,
-0.0639544576,
0.2711570263,
0.1131676286,
0.0555094294,
0.8128669262,
-0.3454162776,
0.3678920269,
-0.0379105471,
-0.1339441985,
-0.0133783361,
0.2443245649,
0.4064543545,
0.5901074409,
-0.0807778239,
0.0790703893,
0.0545741878,
-0.493311286,
0.1001676619,
0.3621272445,
-0.1476635337,
-0.3171051443,
0.1860731244,
0.3868989944,
-0.1492278278,
-1.1334547997,
0.1755869538,
0.1709280759,
-0.0218517929,
-0.1412567347,
0.1990588903,
0.1738299131,
0.4960980117,
0.6446673274,
0.0046492075,
0.072150968,
-1.1080793142,
0.0322510265,
0.6390355229,
-0.3525942862,
-0.2130463272,
0.3345755041,
0.1477366686,
-0.5416120887,
0.2732571065,
-0.3474512696,
-0.6112920046,
1.0090892315,
0.5680749416,
0.6686068773,
-0.1237981543,
-0.059065681,
-0.41721645,
0.4742743671,
-0.1093190834,
0.5269601345,
0.2489988059,
-0.6277630925,
-0.6936932802,
-0.4821933508,
-0.7751531005,
0.078630887,
-0.1771713346,
0.1946441531,
-0.6583319902,
-0.3186338544,
-0.4499768615,
0.4373381436,
-0.4952220321,
0.353543371,
0.2291741073,
0.9573683739,
-0.6631786823,
0.6787884831,
1.2255436182,
0.0177235547,
-0.7044833302,
0.071965389,
-0.0694732815,
-0.5506193638,
-0.0608227476,
0.1271966845,
-0.466622591,
0.0676567405,
-0.7889637947,
-0.5263171196,
1.3070170879,
0.4792846143,
-0.177478835,
0.1857234687,
0.2196784317,
0.7631194592,
-0.4926644266,
0.2055067718,
0.4290206432,
0.5205281377,
-0.0447029173,
-0.6821355224,
0.0088218171,
-0.1956075728,
-0.1287953407,
0.3014673889,
-1.024063468,
0.7613651752,
-0.5302777886,
-0.0027664772,
0.2464874834,
0.7838039398,
0.6012778282,
0.7895686626,
0.1942927688,
0.1851083934,
0.6023215055,
0.1139193252,
0.8769637346,
-0.4345272183,
0.3872618973,
0.7691726685,
-0.7813311219,
0.369327873,
0.4046667516,
0.1138439178,
0.6146025062,
0.2734385133,
0.0152544603,
0.3820921481,
0.3057553768,
-0.4449952543,
-0.3695624769,
-0.3515534997,
-0.2932289541,
0.5224589109,
0.5483192801,
0.0509515703,
-0.1576503068,
0.0271937307,
-0.0548159517,
0.3045269251,
-0.8069496155,
0.6056608558,
0.1712137014,
-0.372392416,
0.091583021,
0.3314606845,
0.5083744526,
-0.743437469,
-0.2183473259,
-0.0352170765,
0.1845300347,
0.0674760565,
-0.4667198062,
0.221868068,
0.0320266746,
-0.1013937443,
-0.1673793942,
1.3088773489,
-0.3018520474,
-0.3803188503,
0.3144360185,
0.8287287951,
0.3467953801,
0.0491598547,
-0.7582400441,
0.1090158522,
-0.4015674591,
-0.1391247362,
0.5372458696,
0.564594388,
-0.2659881711,
1.2016354799,
0.5952550769,
0.0313142538,
-0.2902691066,
-0.1235524565,
0.7297333479,
-0.9186890721,
-0.6928053498,
-0.8976442218,
0.1940940619,
0.3091467619,
0.3257654905,
0.5669075251,
0.4386738837,
0.3020317554,
-0.0432204716,
0.9810707569,
0.2265823036,
0.3125570714,
-0.095959343,
0.8766342402,
-0.3955525756,
0.4374909997,
-0.302041173,
-0.8221828938,
-0.2298891842,
0.4906918705,
-0.3161941171,
0.359896481,
0.1231449991,
0.7327478528,
0.0231386274,
0.0759941041,
0.3239956796,
0.2810562551,
0.3817977309,
0.2737104893,
0.838684082,
-0.0349505544,
0.4955785275,
0.2030781507,
-0.2138425708,
-0.5848549604,
-1.0276936293,
-0.8707606196,
-0.1178472936,
-0.2685566247,
-0.2415677011,
0.1197581962,
1.2921841145,
0.6508998275,
-0.4821804464,
-0.3044802547,
-0.1222244427,
0.3254457414,
-0.3716300428,
-0.2534545362,
-0.1227123737,
0.1941714287,
-0.6143231392,
0.4026778638,
0.2966389656,
0.4146281183,
-0.5972105861,
-0.249592334,
-0.1947119981,
0.8898378015,
0.6788554192,
0.4358495176,
-0.3599917591,
-0.1591255814,
0.0254451428,
-0.3401779532,
-0.3659558892,
0.5720092058,
-1.0870230198,
0.1695893109,
0.2301059216,
0.7188677192,
0.1677821875,
0.2001458108,
0.5262933969,
-0.3616950214,
-0.0021931815,
0.4240444303,
0.0426958874,
0.4808067977,
-0.2353194505,
0.2477276921,
0.320702672,
-0.493928045,
-1.0359274149,
0.5741664171,
-0.9636532664,
-0.6066353321,
1.0426008701,
0.0789350569,
-0.1377453059,
-0.4493024945,
-0.1752461791,
0.3133741915,
-0.3846083581,
0.8187548518,
0.6002620459,
-0.3641208708,
0.0521302745,
-0.4668828845,
0.0349972434,
0.2565935552,
-0.9836770892,
0.02825143,
0.3367701769,
0.1950328499,
0.0594178513,
0.4585006237,
-0.0346271098,
0.2455354482,
-0.099661693,
0.3417771757,
-0.4063153863,
-0.6751072407,
-0.2868249118,
0.2854869366,
0.0563318431,
0.2559811175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06237v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06237v2
|
Summon a Demon and Bind it: A Grounded Theory of LLM Red Teaming in the Wild
| 2023-11-10T18:52:58 | 2023-11-13T17:00:40 |
Nanna Inie, Jonathan Stray, Leon Derczynski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.HC
|
Engaging in the deliberate generation of abnormal outputs from large language
models (LLMs) by attacking them is a novel human activity. This paper presents
a thorough exposition of how and why people perform such attacks. Using a
formal qualitative methodology, we interviewed dozens of practitioners from a
broad range of backgrounds, all contributors to this novel work of attempting
to cause LLMs to fail. We relate and connect this activity between its
practitioners' motivations and goals; the strategies and techniques they
deploy; and the crucial role the community plays. As a result, this paper
presents a grounded theory of how and why people attack large language models:
LLM red teaming in the wild.
|
[
-0.4423952103,
-0.7687697411,
0.4652691185,
-0.1690521985,
-0.0516833253,
0.4245466292,
-0.097339578,
-0.622025907,
0.644086957,
1.0013741255,
-0.7929187417,
-0.3975686431,
-0.5845705271,
-0.0566104427,
-0.5957050323,
0.9761282206,
0.2602826953,
-0.0363669097,
0.3090308011,
-0.1665844321,
-0.8220948577,
-0.9039888978,
-0.4332774282,
-0.2737323344,
0.5668586493,
0.148084715,
0.8928367496,
0.5167473555,
0.6936552525,
0.3256678581,
0.0857280418,
-0.1528479904,
-1.0712026358,
0.4400347471,
-0.2514383793,
-0.9568691254,
-0.2028914392,
0.2654749751,
0.498822093,
0.549749732,
-0.2758859396,
-0.0312602036,
-0.3964472711,
0.3353213966,
-0.4460823834,
-0.6343284845,
-1.1469408274,
-0.0272521693,
-0.5270671844,
-0.3379191756,
-0.5237612128,
-0.2556473315,
-0.2538342178,
-0.3798042536,
0.4446764886,
-0.0074989968,
0.9111545086,
0.3159117997,
-0.3530240059,
-0.1367077082,
-0.6913757324,
0.7638970017,
-0.4872812629,
-0.1967358589,
0.6143518686,
0.3577291071,
-0.4850020111,
-0.4224537015,
-0.6050826311,
0.0415759534,
-0.156699121,
-0.0390715301,
-0.0760706887,
0.3024528921,
0.5144452453,
0.374684006,
-0.2247550339,
0.2607043386,
-0.5401900411,
0.2000439316,
0.8205460906,
0.4999340475,
0.7778861523,
0.1785229295,
-0.5134936571,
0.1035488248,
-0.7937753797,
-0.4203750789,
0.5355875492,
0.2737797797,
-0.1471752524,
0.7791445851,
0.406376183,
0.9445335269,
0.0436862707,
-0.1053316444,
-0.5316134691,
-0.1474275887,
-0.1637878418,
0.2728801966,
0.5546611547,
0.7910253406,
0.5667726398,
-0.2566798627,
-0.4755804837,
0.5571506023,
0.9029237628,
-0.5091994405,
0.0203196723,
0.2274934798,
-0.2124001086,
-0.6393130422,
0.0336204469,
-0.9739078879,
-0.8749876022,
-0.142577067,
0.0855673775,
-0.0952166393,
-0.7710971236,
-0.0545369424,
-0.3477489948,
0.2632298172,
0.2284530997,
-1.115034461,
0.741318047,
0.8803970814,
0.6104359627,
-0.3251041174,
-0.4799646139,
-0.646248579,
0.2182258517,
-0.4578472078,
0.6810060143,
-0.3801697195,
-0.4476704895,
0.2306732386,
-0.139008224,
0.1359606832,
-0.6001161933,
0.2949080169,
-0.8415086269,
-0.4602611959,
-0.1816890538,
-0.3385763168,
-0.266315639,
0.2523789108,
-0.4047406614,
0.8138679266,
-0.2170745283,
-0.5961464047,
0.3438689411,
-0.2916925251,
-0.3176718652,
0.3543464243,
-0.2771259546,
0.0662409663,
0.6076670885,
-0.4679308832,
0.7633464932,
-0.5902491808,
0.3233878613,
-0.482915014,
-0.3485090733,
0.4296000004,
-0.0890981033,
1.0169526339,
0.0605640709,
-0.3115791082,
0.253587693,
-0.5502818823,
-0.0589617565,
0.5521937013,
0.07310839,
-0.7063726783,
0.2128642648,
-0.1684612632,
0.1266679615,
-0.2851659954,
-0.2737171352,
0.406216532,
-0.4175293148,
0.3466564417,
0.7220438719,
0.3005712926,
0.3621519506,
-0.4932689071,
0.617829442,
-0.5289555192,
-0.109213151,
-0.1980988085,
-0.240737021,
-0.6395888925,
-0.3113070428,
-0.0984484702,
0.0684050247,
-0.4481879771,
0.0785060972,
-0.2210392356,
-0.6676220298,
-0.6663770676,
0.0757541507,
0.2171606869,
0.1145144477,
0.0714628324,
-0.1784751713,
-0.6695201993,
-0.7804828286,
-0.3313260674,
-0.3090113997,
0.214059338,
0.1354020089,
0.4007520378,
-0.3788903058,
1.2461155653,
-0.5164190531,
-0.3731815219,
-0.36494115,
0.1460375041,
0.2986239791,
0.499958992,
0.6535134315,
-0.9348790646,
-0.3909163475,
-0.0721682236,
-1.0107575655,
-0.2261633724,
-0.2104074508,
0.0089049498,
0.0117885033,
0.5127258897,
-0.4652040303,
0.4685528278,
0.7511363029,
-0.5987546444,
0.7891495228,
0.1809489876,
0.163016215,
-0.9905110002,
-0.2362204194,
0.0378370583,
-0.0582926124,
-1.0050661564,
0.7124558687,
-0.2773759365,
-0.2764439285,
-0.7110332847,
0.5457047224,
-0.3793537021,
0.0491765477,
-0.3531422317,
0.2320244759,
-0.4549163282,
0.3245676458,
-0.1295780838,
0.6461820006,
0.4526115954,
-0.7538636923,
0.5182393193,
-0.1855808645,
0.052819252,
0.5089441538,
-0.734293282,
0.1830866337,
0.1665104777,
-0.050330922,
-0.9447005391,
-0.5321454406,
-0.0969758183,
-0.3548960984,
0.5401186943,
-0.2874050736,
-0.7483006716,
-0.1237587631,
0.0902366862,
0.5262762308,
0.4818148315,
-0.6724329591,
0.7700916529,
0.9257112741,
0.2640841901,
-0.1362097412,
-0.6469060779,
0.5247612596,
-0.5811830163,
-0.6701858044,
0.2801929712,
0.2088773102,
-1.11769557,
-0.2113412172,
-0.0269708764,
-0.1132326499,
0.6021600962,
0.4657170773,
-0.0232328493,
0.0593677796,
-0.2330769598,
-0.4257146716,
-0.2007288784,
0.4162124097,
0.0803030953,
0.6990386844,
0.069152087,
-0.5899855494,
-0.5228387117,
0.6686305404,
0.9372673631,
0.0316479281,
0.7776408195,
-0.0391498283,
-0.3813911378,
-0.3004455268,
-0.7846651673,
-0.5734190345,
-0.4922872782,
0.3586623073,
-0.0559647009,
-0.7699097395,
0.547410965,
-0.2195162773,
0.1871825308,
0.2795138657,
0.6350986362,
-0.0451242328,
0.7523995638,
0.8383416533,
-0.1408014894,
0.0151626458,
-0.2332754284,
0.0713438317,
-0.5342230797,
-0.0735405013,
-0.5830688477,
-0.3241653144,
-0.3734973967,
-0.4762690067,
0.2827536464,
0.3234365284,
0.0042773872,
0.3490165174,
-0.5965204835,
0.5117934346,
0.1712944657,
-0.4558101594,
0.1720424742,
-0.1651339829,
-0.2834557891,
-0.4391771853,
-0.6131458282,
-0.6113231778,
0.73938936,
0.5619170666,
0.9377043247,
0.5187100768,
0.6827638149,
0.2858474553,
0.5534161925,
-0.9097540975,
0.7136194706,
0.497698307,
-1.0094583035,
-0.0824284852,
0.23432751,
-1.0061501265,
0.4968189001,
-0.2504667342,
-0.7618146539,
-0.0848433599,
-0.0967082381,
-0.0661242083,
0.4326408803,
-0.809086144,
0.4482661784,
-0.3772960305,
-0.515784204,
-0.2775891721,
-0.571067214,
0.889500618,
-0.1742755622,
0.3211470842,
0.1263030469,
-0.0707361177,
0.8014342189,
-0.2288533449,
1.6319918633,
-0.0291625932,
-0.4560723305,
0.2404298186,
0.4550239146,
0.6346683502,
-0.0706114918,
-0.0655888319,
0.2181771994,
-0.3553584218,
-0.4037064314,
-0.6438025832,
0.59773314,
-0.6829416156,
-1.2020919323,
-0.6456958652,
-0.2599137425,
0.1163840368,
0.1321964264,
0.1806076914,
0.2261278033,
-0.3735143542,
-0.0545198992,
0.8179987073,
0.1033969149,
0.6666209698,
0.6768116951,
-0.5315472484,
-0.6355013251,
0.7694030404,
-0.089443244,
0.6393893361,
0.049419634,
-0.1871661544,
0.1212176532,
-0.6109271646,
-0.1109300107,
0.4511529505,
-0.6686099768,
-0.1888085008,
-0.7843449712,
-0.1118175983,
-0.1354994029,
-0.6635767817,
-0.3603188097,
0.1956230551,
-0.2954370379,
-0.1088743061,
0.3448865116,
1.1364543438,
0.1677923799,
0.5184959173,
-0.5296629667,
0.2960976362,
0.3836789131,
-0.0413217694,
0.1371930838,
-0.2839089632,
-0.1682392955,
-0.0845388845,
-0.3354617655,
-1.4170082808,
0.5478593707,
-0.3861139119,
0.5801834464,
0.4705758095,
0.3688876033,
0.6632292867,
-0.4825177491,
0.8473107219,
0.5105762482,
-0.6842415333,
0.5009535551,
-0.7221375704,
-0.0982472748,
0.4437305331,
0.3157087266,
-0.5826785564,
-0.6476506591,
-0.8835816979,
-0.7052372694,
0.7958139181,
0.0032398305,
0.2861859798,
-0.0742047727,
0.3346996903,
-0.2080735862,
0.1080870703,
-0.9125142097,
-0.6222673655,
0.172224313,
0.2705535293,
-0.29122594,
-0.520842135,
-0.7110368609,
-0.019403765,
0.2976752818,
-0.2611018121,
0.2151273936,
0.147182405,
0.0118224006,
-0.3493208885,
-0.0247479063,
0.80145365,
0.3959868252,
0.1768704951,
0.5408471823,
0.2531890273,
-0.3920026422,
0.3867667913,
-0.4697705507,
-0.0989803597,
-0.1507212967,
0.5746074319,
0.7620090842,
0.4530519247,
-0.7378466725,
0.402466327,
0.0539831668,
-0.2485262454,
-0.3438447118,
0.2869307101,
-0.0091710584,
0.0313752033,
0.6295468807,
0.1264800578,
-0.4853906631,
-0.610114038,
0.0389943346,
0.6131215096,
-0.5143669844,
-0.5832275152,
0.4552506208,
0.2029282004,
-0.8981411457,
0.256585598,
-0.0061369375,
-1.0182014704,
0.5740311146,
0.8292334676,
0.9995622635,
-0.0927109569,
0.0591701157,
0.1700013578,
0.6356976032,
0.0683019757,
-0.2399890423,
0.0308650807,
-0.8563277721,
-0.5470526814,
-0.540441215,
-0.2617863417,
0.2392502278,
-0.6144865155,
0.4354367554,
-0.5823000073,
-0.1585267484,
-0.3357982635,
0.0736951455,
-0.2039029449,
-0.2336119562,
-0.2009657919,
0.8006953597,
-0.7638545632,
0.7371917367,
0.7120624781,
-0.4082400501,
-0.7635550499,
0.343187809,
0.4425365031,
-0.8517467976,
1.0253115892,
-0.2228719592,
0.1172225252,
0.2780001163,
-0.5633893609,
-0.8844233751,
0.6734288931,
0.1822536588,
-0.27485165,
0.2475002855,
-0.1126493588,
0.5111406446,
-0.4741807878,
-0.0562997535,
0.5413970947,
0.5262330174,
0.0173802804,
-0.6899638772,
0.3164085448,
-0.0902621746,
-0.0994027853,
0.5700284243,
-0.623699367,
0.3640201092,
-0.4029037356,
-0.3233229518,
-0.141814664,
0.5595718026,
0.5087060332,
-0.0086344341,
0.1933459938,
0.4675956964,
0.6202579737,
0.0485500768,
1.2822180986,
-0.0241255332,
0.0379387811,
0.841878891,
-0.5320660472,
0.5497031212,
0.731059134,
0.0158545002,
-0.0660999715,
0.4012291729,
-0.168132782,
0.4059707522,
0.662570715,
-0.4495207965,
-0.2337357104,
-0.1835064888,
-0.3095420599,
0.4329034388,
0.5053586364,
0.0465750322,
-0.2942424417,
-0.0818429738,
0.0493366495,
0.6174362302,
-0.2538013756,
1.0299446583,
0.1223961562,
-0.8641197085,
0.8758864999,
-0.0408182964,
0.745644927,
-0.4717364609,
0.0173924025,
0.1935462654,
-0.0439352505,
-0.2640951872,
-0.3793912828,
0.5103442669,
0.2152392715,
-0.3459345698,
-0.2944553792,
0.7248097658,
-0.0372511446,
0.0067055007,
0.5975169539,
0.2146422714,
0.047301162,
0.220640555,
-0.4380544126,
0.4877480268,
-0.0421406962,
0.0800741017,
0.7753753662,
0.5195266008,
0.0174615197,
0.6659175158,
0.7539702654,
0.3334910274,
0.0786806792,
-0.2819142342,
1.0074000359,
-0.7481700182,
-0.1256986409,
-1.0533009768,
0.599145472,
-0.1310548931,
-0.291975528,
0.8642653227,
0.2555248141,
0.5992344618,
0.1629226059,
0.5545483232,
0.0015603064,
0.2366600037,
-0.5169581175,
1.1097874641,
-0.4452410042,
0.4475467801,
-0.3680049479,
-0.7871817946,
-0.4688115716,
0.333385855,
0.0405911393,
-0.1616046429,
0.8243350983,
0.7805461884,
0.3279108107,
0.0327619873,
0.6887621284,
0.5506531,
0.5672228932,
0.0458949953,
1.0696423054,
-0.2025370896,
0.0808144361,
0.0539610311,
-0.3877273798,
-0.2125363052,
-0.9745144248,
-1.1564701796,
-0.5896766186,
-0.3383525908,
-0.623292625,
0.0036826334,
1.0506442785,
0.6095281839,
-0.5265721679,
-0.5403104424,
-0.244412601,
0.3552399278,
-0.2317434549,
-0.2394447327,
-0.1386425942,
-0.5297585726,
-0.712366581,
0.535056293,
0.172448054,
0.1684735566,
-0.4934954941,
-0.0496699363,
-0.4971032441,
-0.1717838496,
0.2394179255,
0.5063829422,
-1.0823990107,
0.241369918,
-0.1671261042,
-0.2536793351,
-0.4758025408,
1.144702673,
-0.8045321107,
0.3542592824,
0.1164653599,
0.8204578161,
-0.0300114099,
-0.3064841628,
0.9447154403,
-0.6977407336,
0.134985432,
0.4894430041,
0.0702626705,
0.0632542819,
-0.549890101,
0.6170679927,
0.636295855,
-0.530335784,
-1.468329668,
0.1668643206,
-0.7309743762,
-0.258510679,
1.5118293762,
0.1269987673,
-0.3421418965,
-0.469581008,
-0.2733417451,
-0.022143241,
-0.272218287,
0.7425028086,
0.7564923167,
0.3485695422,
0.2040559947,
-0.6736426353,
0.6111119986,
0.277161032,
-0.3532067835,
0.34145841,
0.323017329,
-0.0133662224,
0.4160403609,
0.5568543673,
0.2599974275,
0.0872333348,
-0.0445868783,
0.247714445,
0.0092932601,
-0.2685554624,
-0.3776551783,
0.6911286712,
0.0650410131,
0.3119708598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06233v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06233v6
|
Data Contamination Quiz: A Tool to Detect and Estimate Contamination in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-10T18:48:58 | 2024-05-24T06:14:09 |
Shahriar Golchin, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We propose the Data Contamination Quiz (DCQ), a simple and effective approach
to detect data contamination in large language models (LLMs) and estimate the
amount of it. Specifically, we frame data contamination detection as a series
of multiple-choice questions and devise a quiz format wherein three perturbed
versions of each subsampled instance from a specific dataset partition (e.g.,
GSM8k test set) are created. These changes only include word-level
perturbations. The generated perturbations, along with the original dataset
instance, form the options in the DCQ, with an extra option accommodating the
possibility of selecting none of the provided options. Given that the only
distinguishing signal among the options is the exact wording with respect to
the original dataset instance, an LLM, when tasked with identifying the
original dataset instance, gravitates towards selecting the original one if it
has been exposed to it in its pre-training phase -- a trait intrinsic to LLMs.
While accounting for positional biases in LLMs, the quiz performance reveals
the contamination level for the model being examined with the dataset partition
to which the quiz pertains. Applied to various datasets with GPT-4 and GPT-3.5,
our findings -- while fully lacking access to pre-training data and model
parameters -- suggest that DCQ achieves state-of-the-art results and uncovers
greater contamination/memorization levels compared to existing methods and
proficiently bypasses more safety filters, especially those set to avoid
generating copyrighted contents.
|
[
-0.350437969,
-1.0193755627,
0.9036295414,
-0.3022043407,
-0.1762401909,
0.2882066667,
0.1152727157,
-0.1509209722,
-0.1904321611,
0.7961502075,
-0.4852511883,
-0.6954036355,
-0.5381415486,
-0.007864696,
-0.7522569895,
0.9757528305,
-0.0821755528,
-0.1174652278,
-0.6893302798,
0.119337894,
-0.386281997,
-0.7226163149,
-0.6474263072,
-0.2896244824,
0.6979482174,
0.5244496465,
0.6351742148,
0.7533094287,
0.4891946316,
0.2866497338,
-0.4413744509,
0.0844264999,
-0.5522820354,
0.1544349939,
-0.2225866169,
-0.7040222287,
-0.22710675,
0.2870792747,
0.4443156719,
0.651966989,
-0.1827395856,
0.1486494094,
-0.0436972603,
0.7587624192,
-0.7333378196,
-0.027860282,
-0.7545332909,
-0.0401971191,
-0.2876221836,
-0.3661562502,
-0.2457726151,
-0.1743924618,
-0.0775733963,
-0.5826637149,
0.1387230605,
0.0122306347,
0.7219429016,
0.5606025457,
-0.7603588104,
-0.1291808486,
-0.7892740369,
0.8272679448,
-0.5622154474,
0.3179668486,
0.7423480749,
0.2603799999,
-0.3505053222,
-0.6336086392,
-0.9466842413,
-0.1792490035,
0.1153884903,
0.1414883882,
0.0863344148,
0.0470919758,
0.5999808311,
0.4732955992,
-0.6016945839,
0.0655348971,
-0.2059372216,
-0.4565494061,
0.7024182677,
0.2952442467,
0.5302652121,
-0.2377837598,
-0.4455919862,
0.0114446869,
-1.1629753113,
-0.0435830429,
0.5651506186,
-0.0113701876,
0.0484071821,
0.5072849989,
-0.268568337,
0.5305090547,
-0.1549427658,
-0.2628259361,
0.1320373863,
-0.631944716,
-0.3166042268,
-0.0109136757,
0.7863733768,
0.0368353873,
0.1058873832,
0.0168708675,
-0.1915017962,
-0.2377229482,
0.0316365734,
-0.6929863095,
-0.7202363014,
0.4910000265,
0.0346104838,
-0.4716692865,
-0.1192752346,
-0.6277768612,
-0.7831941843,
-0.3722765148,
0.5880080462,
-0.2149196267,
-0.2056944221,
0.1449029893,
-0.0894490182,
-0.0864844471,
0.4135508835,
-0.8377250433,
0.0054529049,
0.7391882539,
0.4859767258,
-0.1253223121,
-0.1196712479,
-0.6954476833,
0.070031926,
-0.3478933871,
0.7217545509,
-0.5903508663,
-0.546851933,
-0.1940677315,
-0.0266328957,
-0.058974009,
-0.8105451465,
0.5556920171,
-0.7650157213,
0.4160450995,
-0.5055363774,
-0.7695226669,
-0.2249432653,
0.2769542933,
-0.8249658346,
1.1935744286,
0.2646864057,
-1.1673901081,
0.6450645328,
-0.1828256845,
-0.1785972565,
0.3504726291,
-0.1730779707,
-0.3893845677,
-0.4403578639,
0.2281161398,
0.2326315343,
-0.1109565571,
0.1643287987,
-0.6147803068,
-0.5370487571,
0.4187387824,
-0.5264018774,
0.8841952682,
0.0742664635,
-0.1771359891,
0.178381294,
-0.7049104571,
0.0632985085,
-0.0512539111,
-0.5706576705,
-0.4464294314,
0.159084335,
-0.3573640585,
0.2910673916,
0.0394679382,
-0.3879086673,
0.1214579418,
0.0370335728,
0.320979923,
0.6968522072,
0.4799450338,
0.2782053351,
-0.4996312857,
0.7594667673,
0.3571784198,
0.2886740863,
-0.114787519,
-0.3286193907,
-0.693175137,
-0.5087835193,
0.5313056111,
0.6596467495,
-1.0393851995,
0.5907610059,
-0.3587359488,
-0.4490297735,
-0.303196907,
0.0726531968,
0.0399185307,
0.650133729,
0.2988485992,
-0.1084910184,
-0.2904787362,
-0.6200100183,
-0.0351072848,
-0.2482484877,
-0.1478889436,
0.4065019488,
0.6615805626,
-0.0789005682,
0.8855336308,
-0.6015181541,
-0.0759506598,
0.0011968918,
-0.0423614495,
0.0409627743,
0.338852644,
0.2879467905,
-0.7647007108,
-0.4574994445,
-0.2090792805,
-0.703240335,
-0.0589405708,
-0.0299119707,
-0.2035122961,
-0.0545809902,
0.7026030421,
-0.4452081323,
0.3577383459,
0.5201527476,
-0.2443727553,
0.7423320413,
-0.0525907688,
0.2969670892,
-0.7755376101,
0.1395452768,
-0.2460672706,
-0.384583056,
-0.7856156826,
-0.0103887497,
0.2165401876,
0.2468533963,
-0.5268072486,
0.3490766287,
-0.1845294535,
0.3133831322,
-0.1741507798,
0.5110604167,
0.2822783291,
0.0388584249,
-0.3078036308,
1.079698801,
0.5121792555,
-0.5981932878,
0.4500797391,
0.4580210447,
-0.6377992034,
0.4363526106,
-0.5476971269,
0.4441381097,
-0.0916738212,
0.2229449451,
-1.2285836935,
-0.2043337077,
0.2729251981,
-0.4133096039,
0.2530013025,
-0.289602071,
-0.601736486,
-0.298944205,
-0.3216262758,
0.3778262436,
0.2115367949,
-0.682169199,
0.0496896617,
0.5671647787,
-0.2090514004,
-0.8806513548,
-0.5533071756,
0.010132229,
-0.6252890229,
-0.5928754807,
-0.0189141482,
-0.2494722605,
-0.263342768,
-0.2171927243,
-0.3406178355,
-0.3415358663,
0.5331608653,
0.1502990127,
0.3676849306,
0.0496096127,
0.1900557578,
0.2055627853,
0.2529707253,
0.2998335958,
0.1588879526,
0.6436427236,
0.4752603173,
-0.4219954908,
-0.2665642798,
0.1691388041,
0.5757798553,
-0.2204277664,
0.5234736204,
0.3136916459,
-0.2364296019,
-0.3096268177,
-0.3964922726,
-0.1016300693,
-0.5438607931,
0.4121748805,
-0.398873657,
-0.693607986,
0.6351282597,
0.0327054337,
-0.4441137314,
0.2477535009,
0.2948007882,
-0.1387665868,
1.1219331026,
0.4693369865,
-0.282060653,
0.4777352214,
-0.1619957685,
0.2385534495,
-0.910852015,
-0.2154319137,
-0.4264411628,
-0.0512133837,
-0.5235556364,
-0.4293943346,
0.4253213704,
0.2271718234,
-0.4513062239,
0.0203502662,
-0.2163046449,
0.6925125718,
0.6011799574,
0.2078829855,
0.6254422665,
-0.2761779726,
-0.3041329682,
0.0995475724,
-0.4058758616,
-0.5386525989,
1.2232306004,
0.3540366292,
0.7043466568,
0.0494673066,
0.945015192,
0.1854809672,
0.3120733798,
-0.8613696098,
0.4939538836,
-0.0525438488,
-0.8127893806,
-0.4451726377,
-0.8198573589,
-0.8217371702,
0.0487918966,
-0.1292452216,
-0.7298279405,
0.1856153011,
-0.0729454756,
-0.3972668648,
0.2479069978,
-0.5243281126,
0.8249733448,
-0.0895124301,
-0.3578776717,
0.0818677619,
-0.4473352134,
0.7088945508,
-0.4914399981,
0.2312845439,
-0.2729254663,
0.0958772078,
0.6689929366,
-0.3301887512,
0.4074073732,
-0.1857593507,
-0.4007881284,
0.2996913791,
0.2604502439,
0.3890716732,
0.1886740923,
0.0154444268,
-0.0885189548,
0.3764438927,
-0.1552102268,
-0.5479176641,
0.4707708359,
-0.5395897031,
-0.6987847686,
-0.3891982734,
-0.6390088797,
-0.2626462579,
0.3688918352,
0.2080574483,
0.317697823,
-0.0687771961,
0.192825377,
0.8336722851,
-0.4770045578,
0.2614943385,
0.5875817537,
-0.2689404786,
-0.1918658614,
0.7686623931,
-0.0054001841,
0.479505837,
0.4004760385,
0.2131844461,
-0.4780762792,
-0.7916117907,
-0.3262282312,
0.1660908163,
-0.8591611981,
-0.3365258574,
-0.5329636335,
-0.2458263636,
-0.1760097891,
0.494846046,
-0.0385639593,
-0.2924007475,
-0.3333238065,
-0.2388588935,
0.340511322,
0.7249868512,
0.0954465866,
0.2760370076,
-0.8756700754,
0.2307395935,
0.4423843324,
0.2252313048,
-0.3572790623,
-0.7388033867,
-0.0668766722,
0.2553054094,
-0.3695452809,
-0.96140939,
0.3280558884,
0.023445867,
0.5729650855,
0.5651353002,
0.2743087411,
0.4883562326,
-0.2656722367,
0.9129138589,
-0.1336513758,
-1.0447313786,
0.2586682141,
-0.6431265473,
0.1179577634,
0.6872768402,
0.588490665,
-0.8235064745,
-0.6965014338,
-0.4747863412,
-0.7897119522,
0.5772442818,
-0.2004956603,
-0.001887529,
-0.0527852327,
0.4318560064,
-0.1289237291,
0.3770847917,
-0.4402496517,
-0.3154241741,
0.1261010468,
-0.1752011031,
0.0052430439,
-0.4633539617,
-0.406491518,
-0.3069441915,
0.6120160818,
0.0074163619,
-0.1048408076,
0.1426492631,
-0.1906116158,
-0.0541478284,
0.3047628701,
0.3764356077,
0.714718163,
-0.2335108668,
0.3354844451,
0.0987429023,
-0.8498656154,
0.2219759673,
0.0304294955,
-0.3311235607,
-0.4100424349,
0.2163965702,
0.4152649641,
-0.0822487175,
-0.7742999792,
0.775452733,
-0.1229201332,
-0.2528446317,
-0.2595636249,
0.2737819254,
0.1624965668,
0.0560510941,
0.2205919325,
-0.277862668,
0.3099661171,
-0.6242699027,
0.6857845187,
0.3084682226,
-0.3967653811,
-0.0528568067,
0.7246779203,
-0.1084305644,
0.2579320669,
0.8365162611,
-0.4042388201,
-0.8271808624,
0.6644440293,
0.145130828,
0.5858658552,
-0.4110228419,
0.388394773,
0.3138825297,
0.2391791344,
-0.0393900834,
0.5141687393,
0.2052146643,
-1.0305396318,
-0.5331057906,
-0.3315489888,
-0.4848192632,
0.7073372006,
-0.7246261835,
0.2090426981,
-0.3869498372,
0.0541752689,
0.163270548,
0.2872905433,
-0.5164057612,
0.3813111782,
0.2757946551,
0.8675838709,
-0.9902094603,
0.8948127627,
0.2656688392,
-0.3911398649,
-0.9125612378,
0.2100105137,
0.2667047679,
-0.6792853475,
0.5584825873,
0.1191662848,
0.1651879698,
-0.0594448894,
-0.6362549067,
-0.9300009012,
0.9527310133,
0.374651581,
-0.4078110456,
0.2088753432,
0.2936834693,
0.3977756202,
0.2288900614,
0.3172576427,
1.0763511658,
0.5189487338,
-0.0524133816,
-0.792668283,
0.2960698009,
-0.0201899242,
-0.449242413,
0.3036446869,
-0.4346567392,
0.8047139645,
-0.1795810908,
-0.5362939835,
0.1187488213,
0.1922901124,
0.1501199752,
0.3067128062,
0.7362518311,
0.5425320268,
1.1724333763,
-0.3059358597,
0.9052795768,
-0.1647081822,
0.5637494922,
1.2200956345,
-0.4293304384,
0.8135133982,
0.3494006991,
-0.443508029,
0.2126113027,
0.8237137794,
-0.1167163104,
0.6070628762,
0.5738765597,
-0.5668082833,
-0.1753564179,
-0.0816923454,
-0.2219039202,
0.6616054773,
0.3327557445,
-0.1014308184,
-0.1394960731,
-0.1140242368,
0.2290873677,
0.0070461831,
-0.0232582223,
0.8929381967,
-0.0558400713,
-0.5923167467,
0.6374746561,
-0.3615419269,
0.2665024996,
-0.2948987782,
0.0535260662,
-0.4725420773,
0.0401815884,
-0.328322053,
-0.9167463183,
0.1864068657,
-0.2932057977,
0.0209486429,
0.0567783937,
0.405934155,
-0.8300696015,
-0.0741248205,
0.231472522,
0.7293002009,
0.2029415071,
-0.5093560815,
-0.582328856,
-0.0054006064,
0.0377697796,
-0.210748896,
0.2951096594,
0.4501176178,
0.1774956286,
0.7429918051,
0.5839743614,
0.1490418464,
-0.0206493028,
0.1447572112,
0.8962749839,
-0.5077236891,
-0.1994356215,
-0.7374928594,
0.3491317332,
-0.0794810727,
-0.0696763769,
0.7584152818,
0.773121953,
0.8265496492,
0.2016745806,
1.0391452312,
0.2268984169,
0.6336050034,
-0.6854901314,
0.8197296858,
-0.4583142698,
0.6445323229,
-0.1864396036,
-0.7761472464,
-0.0848400965,
0.25385198,
-0.6114835143,
-0.0846111998,
1.0080801249,
0.8484972119,
0.0424153768,
0.0550231375,
0.3340760767,
0.2550904453,
0.5133391023,
0.4577737153,
1.1655712128,
-0.285979867,
0.5667231679,
-0.520160377,
-0.2852241993,
0.2006059885,
-0.7580754757,
-0.8798037767,
-0.5336495638,
-0.4955866039,
-0.3234848082,
-0.3023931086,
0.4522930384,
0.4835311174,
-0.8279046416,
0.1867431104,
0.014107733,
0.4615429342,
-0.1236703694,
-0.2726668417,
0.4260807633,
-0.176085934,
-0.8878378868,
0.5705475807,
-0.2081826329,
0.0403470509,
-0.0743251294,
0.5769787431,
-0.0620243922,
0.032102488,
0.5039559007,
0.0837235525,
-0.1524195224,
-0.7107794285,
-0.0748797134,
-0.1730811298,
0.0532466061,
0.6362736225,
-0.3030567169,
0.5132390261,
0.6701778769,
0.4534280598,
0.4567767978,
0.2579495013,
0.4099404216,
-0.8984843493,
-0.0686793253,
0.2872374356,
0.3345340788,
0.5104394555,
-0.7172342539,
0.3657542169,
0.2193402499,
-0.8139408231,
-0.9772914052,
0.377315253,
-0.8968835473,
-0.1703633964,
1.3976657391,
-0.2664841712,
-0.0627479032,
-0.4619711637,
-0.0609395355,
0.2000210881,
-0.0679595023,
0.9931130409,
0.839938283,
0.1332529038,
0.0392065719,
-0.9111900926,
0.7137758732,
0.1556329429,
-1.0481979847,
0.3006179333,
0.5470852256,
0.7029007077,
-0.0628388822,
0.5328205824,
-0.3507361114,
0.0719238147,
0.0475845225,
-0.1527926177,
-0.0085685607,
-0.2732287943,
-0.3768327236,
-0.05773101,
-0.0807967111,
-0.2791753411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06221v1
|
A Comparison of Lexicon-Based and ML-Based Sentiment Analysis: Are There Outlier Words?
| 2023-11-10T18:21:50 | 2023-11-10T18:21:50 |
Siddhant Jaydeep Mahajani, Shashank Srivastava, Alan F. Smeaton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lexicon-based approaches to sentiment analysis of text are based on each word
or lexical entry having a pre-defined weight indicating its sentiment polarity.
These are usually manually assigned but the accuracy of these when compared
against machine leaning based approaches to computing sentiment, are not known.
It may be that there are lexical entries whose sentiment values cause a
lexicon-based approach to give results which are very different to a machine
learning approach. In this paper we compute sentiment for more than 150,000
English language texts drawn from 4 domains using the Hedonometer, a
lexicon-based technique and Azure, a contemporary machine-learning based
approach which is part of the Azure Cognitive Services family of APIs which is
easy to use. We model differences in sentiment scores between approaches for
documents in each domain using a regression and analyse the independent
variables (Hedonometer lexical entries) as indicators of each word's importance
and contribution to the score differences. Our findings are that the importance
of a word depends on the domain and there are no standout lexical entries which
systematically cause differences in sentiment scores.
|
[
-0.5361930728,
-0.5095875263,
0.3715730011,
0.1491106898,
-0.0457442552,
0.1295917332,
-0.1673928499,
-0.2219539285,
0.2340678871,
0.1969111562,
-0.4965325892,
-0.6636532545,
-0.7126349807,
0.0632932484,
-0.3362401128,
0.978412509,
0.3187755942,
0.2855587006,
-0.826918602,
-0.2767674029,
-0.3096165359,
-0.6619001031,
-0.3943916261,
-0.346352458,
0.257753551,
0.2266002446,
1.0087065697,
0.0968789905,
1.060447216,
0.2546557486,
-0.3558913767,
0.1580822021,
0.0507085994,
-0.0093837967,
-0.5493103862,
-0.2901719213,
-0.3030005097,
0.0103067681,
0.2931873202,
0.6972558498,
0.1692463011,
0.2570361793,
0.2481463701,
1.0226143599,
-0.966236949,
-0.0655338466,
-0.7419803739,
-0.0460641235,
-0.0474034399,
0.0873271227,
-0.3568557501,
-0.2609760165,
0.2028462142,
-0.1978672892,
0.2436186075,
0.0540393889,
0.9432839155,
0.4210488796,
-0.2998301685,
-0.9362273812,
-0.1262414753,
1.3049192429,
-0.9464972019,
0.1852815598,
0.0723079145,
-0.0309827458,
0.0132638821,
-0.3036193252,
-0.4508125782,
-0.3663060069,
0.0725867301,
0.3580088019,
-0.0798417479,
-0.1095034108,
-0.3102650642,
0.2897309363,
-0.4661615193,
0.0952681527,
0.0080120685,
-0.1801675856,
0.7880083323,
0.2064456344,
0.1441835612,
-0.5001461506,
-0.6358488202,
-0.2002572417,
-0.6281856894,
0.292005837,
0.4503122866,
0.5926231742,
-0.019575702,
0.534314096,
0.2936628759,
0.5913362503,
-0.2755163014,
-0.1008496732,
0.2946530581,
-0.2213432938,
-0.2364228517,
0.203268528,
0.9085925221,
0.673160851,
0.5118865371,
-0.1081119925,
-0.2441142946,
0.369420886,
0.6589596868,
-0.4772288799,
-0.1208666712,
0.3724827468,
-0.7831699252,
-0.4191590548,
0.1252402216,
-0.7458434701,
-0.8065501451,
-0.1945235878,
0.5020488501,
-0.2992457151,
-0.2496651262,
-0.2311088145,
-0.4932173491,
0.0364156142,
0.0870828331,
-0.4303740859,
0.4175611138,
0.7323315144,
0.9641570449,
-0.7739729881,
-0.3002459407,
0.0863674879,
-0.7318492532,
-0.610118866,
0.9026986361,
-0.5479568243,
-0.7127301693,
0.1773040593,
-0.4078145623,
-0.0774419904,
-0.8675619364,
0.6557708383,
-0.5596091151,
0.0637434497,
-0.4780793488,
-1.0452071428,
-0.4947963357,
0.3354834616,
-0.4722234309,
1.1528490782,
0.2341801524,
-0.7531619668,
0.3031068146,
-0.6500727534,
-0.2487962097,
-0.0037178351,
-0.0517700948,
-0.4950096607,
0.3113040328,
-0.0011996366,
0.540286541,
-0.5506485701,
-0.1996938884,
-0.360571295,
-0.2681235075,
0.9095169902,
-0.1978287399,
0.7663990259,
0.2967391014,
-0.3892798722,
-0.1398002654,
-0.6627498865,
0.5034968257,
-0.3239731193,
-0.266587317,
-0.5795666575,
0.1178694293,
0.2292981744,
0.2791953087,
0.4166138172,
-0.504801631,
-0.1452199221,
-0.3675945103,
0.1654707342,
0.4564196467,
0.2175740451,
0.4293329716,
-0.294662714,
0.3220094144,
0.4042747617,
0.2016370445,
0.2206418365,
-0.7920721173,
-0.6777703166,
-0.3986828923,
0.4027698636,
0.7304404974,
-0.3624514341,
0.6628456712,
-0.1735748351,
-0.7112903595,
-0.5381571651,
0.1475218982,
0.2519006133,
0.5622084141,
0.4739614129,
-0.1841173172,
-0.3280739784,
-0.7702849507,
-0.7409002185,
-0.2397144139,
0.3289346993,
0.2420276999,
0.4915777147,
-0.2208477855,
1.1632556915,
-0.3275729716,
-0.4127838612,
0.0701406673,
0.0845394954,
0.1880172491,
-0.0750707611,
0.4761333764,
-0.7048394084,
-0.743193686,
0.0510548167,
-1.1100264788,
-0.0046847961,
0.1410989612,
0.1768166721,
0.5476959348,
0.5063250065,
-0.3173959553,
0.382789135,
0.6868336201,
-0.2896881998,
0.2631003559,
0.0276658386,
0.2104403377,
-0.9943165183,
-0.3004162312,
0.0981149748,
0.0392049849,
-0.6006994247,
0.0776532665,
0.2282400578,
0.1412847042,
-0.5741721392,
0.4216141403,
-0.157057777,
-0.0592271276,
-0.4020451009,
0.3974485397,
0.0342806838,
0.2199375331,
-0.0888931453,
0.6805256605,
0.6947994232,
-0.5843287706,
0.4079213142,
-0.0845167935,
-0.2661324143,
0.628991425,
-0.3501366377,
0.0907406658,
-0.0227649156,
-0.5699716806,
-1.0933115482,
0.4565550685,
-0.0371973813,
-0.9213550091,
0.0071075656,
0.116543889,
-0.1050609574,
-0.1575923413,
-0.6635621786,
-0.0921076685,
0.4102236331,
-0.3980087042,
0.472204566,
0.4644642174,
-0.1059150398,
-0.8086399436,
-0.7665121555,
0.2598945498,
-0.289514035,
-0.4694387615,
0.0572162829,
-0.0443948768,
-0.9508202672,
0.3587749898,
0.2491494715,
-0.0175831728,
0.0932464451,
0.5756003261,
0.2938556969,
-0.1411934644,
0.282784909,
-0.1956490427,
0.1067395136,
0.2484219521,
-0.3288136423,
0.2143516392,
-0.4527878165,
-0.0849168226,
-0.2726931274,
0.6451705098,
0.7535464764,
0.0278331451,
0.8572480083,
0.1981180012,
-0.4717151523,
-0.2379795909,
-0.1899649948,
0.0422299989,
-0.3999362886,
0.1454345435,
-0.1291909665,
-0.4278541505,
0.3961969018,
0.2216223925,
0.1274424791,
0.773235321,
0.9254928231,
-0.4015968144,
0.9071090817,
0.511425972,
-0.3441330791,
0.1620432287,
-0.1628205329,
0.3652191162,
-0.3608737886,
0.095004715,
-0.6467068195,
-0.0853096545,
-0.8811380863,
0.0113051487,
0.424287498,
-0.0778442249,
-0.1477023512,
0.0914331153,
-0.5703827739,
-0.0387635939,
0.439301163,
-0.3422777653,
0.1726100743,
0.2416182011,
-0.0517109446,
-0.330686152,
-0.6959604621,
-0.5163196325,
1.058120966,
0.1709125489,
0.4650759995,
0.281630367,
0.6207398176,
0.9919479489,
0.6033630967,
-1.1834913492,
0.4009039998,
-0.3757080138,
-0.5892015696,
-0.2920123637,
-0.3755123913,
-0.6897431016,
0.1635611355,
-0.5337127447,
-0.3263940811,
0.098117359,
-0.0324699469,
-0.3238184154,
0.1127776802,
-0.7570848465,
0.6404665112,
-0.0778062791,
-0.082366921,
-0.094729349,
-0.1714502722,
-0.1866544932,
0.0637217909,
0.5988795161,
-0.0048209433,
-0.1663266867,
0.7170757055,
-0.8194248676,
0.6071841121,
-0.2565795779,
-0.046424102,
0.8549186587,
-0.0027122158,
0.3533383608,
-0.0609029718,
-0.3470240831,
0.4737831056,
0.1234943345,
-0.2932741046,
-0.5623809099,
0.9386610389,
-1.0089035034,
-0.0128272502,
-0.6130674481,
-0.3529905081,
-0.3692476153,
-0.0471982583,
0.8006747365,
0.5083429217,
-0.0050538215,
0.0347894989,
0.4897827506,
-0.0616753101,
0.8200991154,
0.1529876292,
0.1427067667,
-0.5487630963,
1.0884004831,
0.2858829796,
-0.1510406733,
0.3651430011,
0.4933920801,
-0.4818154871,
-0.3699226975,
-0.485121727,
-0.0023797902,
-0.9712269306,
-0.4122223556,
-0.5108389258,
-0.0889557824,
-0.5361882448,
-0.4902873039,
-0.5770736337,
-0.0493260249,
-0.1201910898,
0.3275673687,
0.6819347143,
0.6980443597,
0.2379193306,
0.4091698527,
-0.902626574,
-0.1745157242,
0.0458273068,
0.0089763394,
-0.0721615255,
-0.3529347777,
-0.4014289081,
-0.2136735767,
0.0006873968,
-0.9301193953,
0.5855673552,
0.3030549884,
0.2647426724,
0.2109582424,
-0.145310849,
0.2105558366,
-0.1136905253,
1.1409819126,
0.3328407109,
-1.0732591152,
0.1052109227,
-0.0620133393,
0.1190600097,
0.7504242659,
0.5785126686,
-0.5904614925,
-0.1871881187,
-0.7170859575,
-0.8547827601,
0.120991759,
-0.0356265642,
-0.0659829825,
-0.1148823425,
0.4929953218,
0.1089570373,
0.4943555593,
-0.2975114584,
-0.4745471478,
-0.2485799342,
-0.6136831045,
-0.2266797274,
-0.0871213004,
0.1871037632,
0.091858685,
0.7786956429,
-0.2224666327,
-0.0066362517,
0.1291612536,
-0.3709030449,
0.1518347561,
0.1815657318,
0.1474434584,
0.3824755251,
-0.1003264636,
0.1423815042,
0.3152480721,
-0.7815045118,
-0.0649994165,
-0.4650860131,
-0.365003258,
0.2741597891,
0.4035182595,
0.4577510655,
-0.1101344749,
-0.7009073496,
0.7917606235,
-0.1029484496,
-0.2362173945,
-0.5235471129,
-0.2117507607,
0.1529868841,
0.0286267567,
0.0963960141,
0.3419240117,
0.3402813971,
-0.6151269078,
-0.0638535395,
0.5654292107,
-0.8605468273,
0.120584406,
0.0700721815,
0.0679159611,
-0.3622552454,
0.4719877243,
-0.4150148332,
-0.4099251628,
0.5068438649,
0.0973215401,
0.767575264,
0.0867222697,
0.1095880046,
-0.0133785065,
0.2099248022,
0.0397300161,
0.4858208597,
0.1623834521,
-0.9699495435,
-0.2538454831,
-0.6117933393,
-0.6596962214,
-0.0963755101,
-0.7114391923,
0.1628835201,
-0.4412975907,
-0.5187128186,
0.1013847366,
0.3441227376,
-0.4856102169,
0.6114398837,
0.0841504559,
0.8206377029,
-0.719856143,
0.3729844093,
1.1648844481,
-0.1491637528,
-0.3711191118,
-0.0085647171,
0.1290763319,
-0.3826831877,
0.4112286568,
0.0594555922,
-0.5427784324,
-0.1623091251,
-0.1884632409,
-0.6997061372,
0.63326478,
-0.1128558144,
-0.3356113732,
0.4094138741,
0.3675527871,
0.8135881424,
-0.34662655,
0.2849292755,
0.4104380012,
0.2461806089,
-0.492474854,
-0.4084178805,
-0.3486676812,
-0.14768067,
-0.0315884314,
0.2458539307,
-0.4940782487,
1.0406652689,
0.200705111,
-0.0237072464,
-0.2031496316,
0.7037320733,
-0.214416936,
0.5293633938,
0.5975569487,
0.5268285871,
0.8649029136,
0.0842492804,
0.9012923837,
-0.5169424415,
0.7559715509,
0.5594727397,
-0.3741241395,
1.0194991827,
0.3536723256,
-0.3212756217,
0.6136618853,
0.593740046,
0.2193246335,
0.3704880178,
0.2531550229,
-0.2956371903,
-0.2144865692,
-0.0066175354,
0.0425230414,
0.5791066289,
0.6211963892,
-0.2426775098,
-0.2637612522,
0.0962599292,
0.2394843698,
0.5870192051,
-0.817887187,
0.6941313744,
0.3546584547,
-0.7188012004,
0.5768265724,
0.1417513192,
1.1257636547,
-0.2771484852,
0.4589477777,
-0.0596359409,
0.5364053249,
-0.42891711,
-0.8356799483,
0.4479547441,
0.1677166075,
-0.4375282824,
0.0242069121,
0.8486558795,
0.0604165271,
-0.4805704057,
0.4778787494,
0.9049944282,
0.3029671013,
-0.4676812589,
-0.8192843795,
-0.1937970668,
-0.237754494,
-0.2871808112,
0.3156176805,
0.1339379698,
-0.4400493205,
0.3618407547,
0.4099314809,
0.1821569651,
0.0395624451,
0.229150489,
0.3967806399,
-0.7896476984,
-0.4746953249,
-1.0871058702,
0.1432436854,
-0.2009902,
-0.7122208476,
0.9201616645,
0.2798686624,
0.3620926142,
-0.0905834585,
1.0616205931,
0.1192990094,
0.7245503068,
-0.4345130622,
0.7358991504,
-0.6285857558,
-0.044244159,
-0.2005858272,
-0.8247767687,
-0.4110256135,
0.3217130005,
-0.1238052994,
-0.1173420176,
0.8663477302,
0.9695322514,
0.5174705982,
0.1637197137,
0.3678388298,
-0.1572618634,
-0.0397211462,
0.0446788482,
0.965385735,
-0.4344572425,
0.1670485288,
-0.1232032478,
-0.3155572414,
-0.2962384522,
-0.9860450029,
-0.9185196757,
-0.7364125848,
-0.3013867736,
-0.5936513543,
0.146508351,
1.094873786,
0.2899190485,
-0.9660503864,
-0.2326797843,
-0.037240576,
0.2253867686,
-0.5147233009,
-0.3214330673,
0.4576696754,
-0.6724730134,
-0.5290616155,
0.2686214149,
0.3904582858,
-0.3839474916,
-0.3073669076,
0.2321608812,
0.1088860631,
0.559491992,
0.799143672,
-0.0254718531,
-0.2189521641,
-0.2884308994,
0.3073458374,
-0.2696754634,
0.1202762052,
0.8633878827,
-0.7680541873,
0.1732397527,
0.6705090404,
0.5969250798,
-0.0859933347,
-0.0983905867,
-0.1167560145,
-0.7826035023,
-0.1025726944,
0.1223577559,
0.3141082823,
0.7306764126,
-0.5150857568,
0.1157911345,
0.4573852718,
-0.5616171956,
-0.5311672688,
0.0991838276,
-0.840967536,
-0.598489821,
1.2696146965,
-0.0174717046,
-0.4421894252,
-0.1894883066,
-0.0136734694,
-0.0177675169,
-0.4087519348,
0.7438501716,
0.7638829947,
-0.3840810955,
0.3565709591,
-0.4341795743,
0.6287736893,
0.4883387089,
-0.6474787593,
-0.1927681416,
0.0520022176,
0.2115825266,
0.593318522,
0.2881860137,
-0.1750251353,
0.0249947254,
0.2161706686,
0.2718781531,
0.2870566547,
-0.208002314,
-0.5190739036,
0.3585185707,
0.3317776918,
-0.2166491747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06217v1
|
MultiIoT: Towards Large-scale Multisensory Learning for the Internet of Things
| 2023-11-10T18:13:08 | 2023-11-10T18:13:08 |
Shentong Mo, Paul Pu Liang, Russ Salakhutdinov, Louis-Philippe Morency
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
The Internet of Things (IoT), the network integrating billions of smart
physical devices embedded with sensors, software, and communication
technologies for the purpose of connecting and exchanging data with other
devices and systems, is a critical and rapidly expanding component of our
modern world. The IoT ecosystem provides a rich source of real-world modalities
such as motion, thermal, geolocation, imaging, depth, sensors, video, and audio
for prediction tasks involving the pose, gaze, activities, and gestures of
humans as well as the touch, contact, pose, 3D of physical objects. Machine
learning presents a rich opportunity to automatically process IoT data at
scale, enabling efficient inference for impact in understanding human
wellbeing, controlling physical devices, and interconnecting smart cities. To
develop machine learning technologies for IoT, this paper proposes MultiIoT,
the most expansive IoT benchmark to date, encompassing over 1.15 million
samples from 12 modalities and 8 tasks. MultiIoT introduces unique challenges
involving (1) learning from many sensory modalities, (2) fine-grained
interactions across long temporal ranges, and (3) extreme heterogeneity due to
unique structure and noise topologies in real-world sensors. We also release a
set of strong modeling baselines, spanning modality and task-specific methods
to multisensory and multitask models to encourage future research in
multisensory representation learning for IoT.
|
[
-0.4740873873,
-0.5362523794,
0.2366659045,
0.0045427489,
-0.1644298583,
0.0230753608,
-0.0022654647,
-0.9287462831,
0.1721558422,
-0.0026853697,
-0.4550978839,
-0.1243280098,
-0.5921270251,
-0.0906879827,
-0.0820641145,
0.7737941146,
0.1587385684,
-0.0035567391,
0.0300425068,
-0.1964788735,
-0.3746299744,
-0.2926095128,
-0.5569854975,
-0.2772538066,
0.7000814676,
0.4836787283,
0.0552172959,
0.3220238984,
0.6152322888,
0.306704998,
0.5293860435,
0.4028562009,
0.0068527511,
0.0789683014,
0.2300899476,
-0.3945248127,
-0.4588269293,
0.2412806153,
0.3607417941,
0.588085115,
0.0149940429,
0.5495865941,
-0.2043865323,
0.5065850616,
-0.5937765837,
0.4086608887,
-0.408645004,
0.0912251547,
-0.0721512735,
-0.2613785267,
-0.4459414184,
0.3787371516,
0.2007868141,
-0.5044805408,
0.0453737788,
0.2810378373,
0.6004288793,
0.4865075946,
-0.8231782317,
0.2733451724,
-0.8472922444,
0.9706261754,
0.0411054939,
0.8946926594,
0.4779818952,
0.4881357253,
0.1037033349,
-0.7754516602,
-0.5427243114,
-0.1752778143,
0.1115181297,
0.3528198898,
-0.0063446001,
-0.3468280733,
0.1343773752,
-0.2563927174,
-0.7003260851,
0.1233284622,
-0.4674880803,
0.111647509,
0.6626970768,
0.0206199829,
-0.2229896933,
-0.1437708586,
-0.7243043184,
-0.3344951868,
-0.3696970642,
0.0989096239,
0.3808663487,
0.5110826492,
-0.3257250488,
-0.0559279546,
-0.447232008,
0.6055653095,
0.0484661534,
-0.390350461,
0.5734466314,
-0.2171623111,
0.0452005528,
0.0191640649,
0.7556089163,
0.3335382342,
-0.3301938772,
-0.1008954123,
0.0203657355,
-0.116256766,
0.4651645124,
-0.6817835569,
-0.3772881031,
0.6316621304,
-0.3419159353,
0.2281558067,
0.1115799323,
-0.6313539743,
-0.280800581,
-0.5720930099,
0.4249498248,
-0.2716185451,
-0.3942923844,
0.1087243184,
-0.2077408582,
0.0056814738,
0.4882782996,
-0.8069015145,
-0.0524199642,
0.600533247,
0.5993794799,
0.0514947213,
-0.8625099063,
-0.351030767,
0.4415267706,
-0.0701870173,
0.6691590548,
-0.250380218,
-0.2338838875,
-0.7289595008,
-0.1278200597,
-0.1431948692,
-0.4736300409,
0.4365060925,
-0.4056656063,
-0.023281619,
0.4370445609,
-0.0663991198,
-0.41338709,
0.5616935492,
-0.7671332359,
0.8657784462,
0.0139453541,
-0.5600245595,
0.7022975683,
-1.1850972176,
-0.709221065,
-0.0202057939,
0.2450326383,
-0.9288492799,
0.1627038866,
0.1416067928,
0.9314053059,
-0.21189107,
0.2296873033,
-0.6231449246,
-0.0244200137,
0.0636965483,
-0.6688774228,
0.8452727795,
0.3364880383,
-0.391297102,
0.4361668527,
-0.7924733758,
-0.0501558892,
-0.1108774319,
-0.1542544663,
-0.2308408171,
-0.0799313039,
0.4783593416,
0.2863583565,
0.2149223685,
-0.8457033038,
0.15710859,
0.2460707873,
0.8865755796,
0.7747600079,
-0.2675669789,
-0.1749168783,
-0.3925183713,
0.0048038461,
0.3609690368,
0.7259247899,
-0.3652630746,
-0.5899472237,
-0.1820930839,
-0.8510761857,
0.2762658894,
0.3566310108,
-0.3516683877,
0.444201082,
-0.57323277,
-0.7243824005,
-0.5536125302,
0.0267077219,
-0.0585946701,
0.5964921117,
0.5502255559,
-0.0058783228,
-0.3819455206,
-0.5967761278,
0.0932076871,
-0.0651596189,
-0.1160713807,
0.3170535564,
0.7578436732,
-0.769367516,
0.7523970604,
-0.2735877633,
-0.2465217412,
0.0591696426,
0.4763647616,
-0.1221753806,
0.601562798,
0.2642829418,
-1.5087881088,
-0.3150095642,
0.3213762343,
-0.6437599063,
0.4726760089,
0.098766312,
0.1494123191,
-0.1300726086,
0.4056229293,
-0.6967580318,
0.3110688627,
0.4204897583,
-0.1270702779,
0.4816835821,
-0.2083273679,
0.1882949173,
-1.3986400366,
0.34313941,
0.0692332685,
-0.2724364102,
-0.4266657829,
0.161226958,
0.2443946451,
-0.3686012328,
-0.613039732,
0.6710386276,
-0.0831746086,
0.0103275124,
0.0711942986,
-0.1922749132,
0.0737070441,
0.5704472661,
-0.143971771,
0.4083020985,
0.6052961946,
-0.8588506579,
0.902664721,
-0.2012436986,
-0.0282505788,
0.8459029198,
-0.4217158258,
-0.1984606087,
-0.1370085478,
0.3533377647,
-0.9391132593,
-0.5314087868,
0.0499421321,
-0.5937365294,
0.1653186381,
0.1256006211,
-0.8853120208,
-0.7109693885,
-0.4999542236,
0.7791609764,
-0.0440049842,
-0.7156872153,
1.0971074104,
0.4068287313,
0.3855735958,
-0.4851672053,
-0.5279787779,
-0.2753957808,
-0.5323150158,
-0.2052841485,
0.032921236,
-0.157404989,
0.1385605335,
0.0251314007,
0.2103673369,
-0.062359523,
0.6108768582,
0.600223124,
0.1236804053,
0.0452476256,
0.5578536391,
-0.2157562971,
-0.6543205976,
-0.1075058505,
-0.5767811537,
0.6408156753,
-0.1928892583,
-1.0295354128,
-0.932174623,
0.3443169594,
0.8367580771,
-0.5752072334,
0.1962462664,
1.1716893911,
-0.4509990811,
-0.0159004759,
-0.1705374271,
-0.5358812809,
-0.4060999453,
0.3758741915,
-0.5153338909,
-0.742169857,
0.3931539059,
-0.6172164083,
0.0656020865,
0.5564627647,
0.3596481085,
-0.5053873658,
1.1151987314,
0.5568391085,
-0.357466042,
0.6094275117,
-0.3702818453,
0.6088168621,
-1.1108727455,
-0.2354268432,
-0.2936986387,
-1.0340026617,
-0.8529550433,
-0.3129120767,
0.9026725888,
-0.11932908,
-0.5435285568,
0.067733489,
-0.4629538059,
0.1718372107,
1.1222370863,
0.5068492889,
0.2859295011,
0.0637712851,
0.343419373,
0.3926820159,
-0.6463496089,
-0.0156947412,
1.5331206322,
0.1521090418,
0.3835010231,
0.3621481657,
0.4771028161,
0.1684549153,
0.3507302999,
-0.7744281292,
0.2071885318,
0.006486929,
-0.9882572293,
-0.3074842095,
-0.4016344845,
-1.4479621649,
0.1835565269,
-0.1111336127,
-0.7827271819,
0.0589945763,
0.2155766338,
-0.4411989748,
0.6139283776,
-0.8652300835,
0.7671886683,
-0.6337495446,
-0.3872895241,
-0.4352454841,
-0.966558814,
0.148399502,
0.0132257761,
0.1770027727,
-0.0914697573,
0.079021275,
0.4630810916,
0.1597558111,
1.1149961948,
-0.1354084611,
0.4544249177,
0.3781875968,
-0.3745244443,
0.1020877287,
0.1751013547,
0.1079506278,
0.4520691931,
-0.1139703989,
-0.6647511125,
-0.2116268873,
0.3992818594,
-1.0446335077,
0.1011296138,
-0.3147542179,
-0.4873200059,
-0.3359378278,
0.3942107558,
0.0650921389,
0.4228748977,
0.1751317084,
0.4594087005,
0.6768310666,
0.2758004665,
0.387711525,
0.1551019549,
-0.0732321516,
-0.2396384031,
1.420298934,
-0.0216675866,
-0.1790886372,
0.6992579699,
0.3976005316,
-0.1284993738,
-0.2378425747,
-0.6480426788,
-0.1395858228,
-0.1549720913,
-0.5032347441,
-0.6658645272,
0.2509433925,
-0.367313832,
-0.0129611604,
-0.4694003761,
-0.0472888052,
-0.21465379,
-0.1877943873,
0.5645698905,
0.6248627305,
-0.4363033175,
0.5659067035,
-0.8323218822,
0.6762949228,
0.7020180225,
0.5019872189,
0.0947959051,
0.0752917603,
-0.4447064996,
0.084680669,
-0.4999110997,
-0.1152131334,
-0.0116694821,
0.0342545956,
0.3850436807,
0.785662055,
0.1421341598,
0.7172083259,
-0.2307681143,
0.6383306384,
0.454855293,
-0.6308204532,
0.6121842861,
-0.4350222647,
0.2067700028,
0.4167891741,
0.7823735476,
-0.3873370886,
0.2721413374,
-0.8822325468,
-1.0246405602,
0.4596582949,
-0.6409970522,
0.060101632,
0.2622618675,
-0.006707361,
0.3669810593,
0.5187610388,
-0.71035707,
0.0606420487,
-0.2048168331,
-0.3970184326,
-0.0231170356,
0.2961303592,
-0.3979056478,
-0.2720901668,
0.3964629173,
-0.3720664382,
0.5265803933,
-0.0944345891,
0.0491140746,
0.1321361065,
-0.2184467167,
0.5539772511,
0.508764565,
-0.0913822949,
0.3965811431,
-0.0305194911,
-0.4977290034,
-0.1135231107,
0.3628379703,
0.0401594602,
-0.4888077378,
0.6495761275,
0.8169249296,
-0.0407555662,
-0.7504591346,
0.3214609623,
0.0219108518,
-0.0587486587,
-0.2497318834,
-0.2454836369,
-0.1077918261,
0.4754974842,
0.47983253,
0.3449219167,
0.1998382807,
-0.8279459476,
0.1576708406,
0.3245186806,
-0.3194083571,
-0.5807796121,
0.6853296161,
0.2399734259,
-0.1194173917,
0.712028265,
-0.3498538136,
-0.4238285124,
0.4934237599,
0.0937102064,
0.6769021749,
-0.5185373425,
-0.0552396253,
0.187826708,
0.3175879717,
0.2666945755,
0.4502395988,
-0.3493597209,
-0.585744977,
-0.2316701561,
-0.3529186249,
-0.4278036356,
-0.0264480356,
-0.4426196516,
-0.1034071892,
-0.5002722144,
-0.3160525262,
-0.1671366841,
0.1254282892,
-0.9476950169,
0.3593794107,
-0.0688518733,
0.2416563928,
-0.8836917877,
0.5988036394,
0.7164942622,
-0.0476792417,
-0.6783631444,
-0.1616315842,
-0.0037941614,
-0.7166891694,
0.7123116851,
0.3596484363,
-0.3544214368,
-0.0910131186,
-0.6085919142,
-0.509483397,
0.9383599162,
0.0913408697,
-0.2903815806,
0.514564395,
0.0873629972,
0.411318481,
-0.0550408848,
0.3518275023,
-0.204148218,
0.766387701,
-0.3171477914,
-0.9154304862,
-0.4891437292,
-0.1321008354,
-0.5196706653,
0.2897219658,
-1.1399062872,
1.1008448601,
-0.1817296296,
0.3005049229,
-0.3932033181,
0.338034004,
0.0284513477,
0.6634100676,
0.2648138404,
0.8772905469,
0.8034407496,
-0.0750935152,
0.8292829394,
-0.4028509259,
0.2347102314,
1.0683374405,
-0.2269969434,
1.2067172527,
0.5332840085,
-0.2269794047,
0.0345328376,
0.8326425552,
0.0470403172,
0.5279706717,
0.0048386399,
-0.2545824945,
-0.0680157095,
-0.0815560967,
-0.218192935,
0.8265163898,
0.4688044488,
0.3129403591,
0.0544630028,
0.7123711109,
-0.5317732692,
-0.4784610868,
-0.3191117644,
0.7675511837,
-0.2339871824,
-0.0337526724,
0.0565832108,
-0.0346458517,
0.6646489501,
-0.462012589,
-0.1490010023,
0.1682860851,
0.3041257858,
-0.1801785678,
-0.484400332,
0.2109486908,
-0.5157907605,
-0.3385872245,
-0.410051316,
0.4473893344,
0.1102263406,
-0.5097559094,
0.4706855416,
0.4938722551,
0.107633248,
-0.2175721377,
-0.5535482764,
-0.0278124604,
-0.4308603406,
-0.3393187225,
0.3520014584,
0.9684810638,
-0.036007449,
1.015106082,
0.8774747252,
-0.1136849523,
0.299515456,
-0.4765699208,
0.5907151103,
-0.5847423077,
-0.4740999639,
-0.4044507146,
0.6487458944,
-0.0071640499,
-0.7586320043,
0.4147640169,
0.6002159715,
1.5121706724,
0.0137344636,
0.6947258711,
-0.163330391,
0.5505356789,
-0.0258065611,
0.3895145059,
-0.8125986457,
-0.2905319929,
0.3162462711,
-0.5988153815,
-0.5446995497,
0.6563106179,
-0.250297755,
0.1644128859,
0.4580317438,
0.0726475939,
-0.710300386,
-0.0202382132,
0.3957644403,
0.0300345346,
0.2869147062,
0.479736805,
0.4702936113,
-0.56925565,
0.0895024464,
-0.3248595595,
-0.089219965,
-0.6712969542,
-0.5456630588,
-0.3396499753,
-1.0259706974,
-0.1776652336,
0.3223005831,
-0.2261776328,
1.0414261818,
1.3988628387,
-0.7207559943,
-0.2608078122,
0.1148222685,
0.189426437,
-0.6319874525,
-0.0879046991,
0.3138752878,
0.1217123941,
-0.864041388,
0.2053249329,
0.3444908857,
-0.1032001525,
-0.2134184539,
-0.08529789,
-0.4461047947,
-0.7537164688,
0.9701565504,
0.3160368502,
-0.3791194856,
-0.3806849122,
-0.311843425,
0.1019471437,
0.140125826,
0.3973781765,
-0.7610626817,
0.5815988779,
0.1616344303,
0.8587363362,
0.490231514,
-0.2481811345,
-0.2408623099,
-0.849096477,
0.5018038154,
0.276809901,
0.2103913873,
0.2008003592,
-0.0245342534,
0.486497581,
0.3957043886,
-0.4334710836,
-0.7862038016,
0.4614028335,
-1.1694933176,
-0.4229317904,
0.3174295723,
-0.1141094416,
-0.3634993136,
-0.1797238588,
0.1756711304,
0.2584893107,
-0.4325498641,
0.87748909,
0.3323452175,
-0.6321638227,
-0.2516535819,
-0.7709801793,
-0.2103233635,
0.3157248795,
-0.917857945,
-0.0439572819,
0.2500361502,
-0.1306423843,
0.7314744592,
0.0920433253,
0.2695210874,
0.1901079863,
0.1551498473,
0.2034398615,
-0.1463079005,
-0.909987092,
-0.035656888,
0.4373759925,
0.0065795761,
-0.6154980659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06204v1
|
BanglaBait: Semi-Supervised Adversarial Approach for Clickbait Detection on Bangla Clickbait Dataset
| 2023-11-10T17:38:46 | 2023-11-10T17:38:46 |
Md. Motahar Mahtab, Monirul Haque, Mehedi Hasan, Farig Sadeque
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Intentionally luring readers to click on a particular content by exploiting
their curiosity defines a title as clickbait. Although several studies focused
on detecting clickbait titles in English articles, low resource language like
Bangla has not been given adequate attention. To tackle clickbait titles in
Bangla, we have constructed the first Bangla clickbait detection dataset
containing 15,056 labeled news articles and 65,406 unlabelled news articles
extracted from clickbait dense news sites. Each article has been labeled by
three expert linguists and includes an article's title, body, and other
metadata. By incorporating labeled and unlabelled data, we finetune a
pretrained Bangla transformer model in an adversarial fashion using Semi
Supervised Generative Adversarial Networks (SS GANs). The proposed model acts
as a good baseline for this dataset, outperforming traditional neural network
models (LSTM, GRU, CNN) and linguistic feature based models. We expect that
this dataset and the detailed analysis and comparison of these clickbait
detection models will provide a fundamental basis for future research into
detecting clickbait titles in Bengali articles. We have released the
corresponding code and dataset.
|
[
-0.1307232976,
-0.8812205791,
-0.0814365372,
0.4653834105,
-0.4914321005,
0.1319611967,
-0.0310633555,
-0.2638071477,
0.1947545558,
0.5704434514,
-0.007311407,
-0.2608938217,
-0.6526913643,
0.1809890717,
-0.6788971424,
1.3585220575,
0.3565347791,
-0.0500734374,
-0.0679815933,
0.2090631872,
-0.3252391815,
0.1705164313,
-0.5653486848,
-0.1324560195,
0.3277192116,
-0.1816954762,
0.7177183628,
0.097847119,
0.4026990533,
0.2239549309,
-0.4080476165,
0.3882531524,
-0.6000358462,
-0.5683452487,
-0.3325441182,
-0.639351964,
-0.0495078526,
0.0177760031,
0.5900668502,
0.6978593469,
0.0825416893,
0.1816304922,
0.0585927032,
0.7744149566,
-0.4119426608,
0.0893501192,
-0.5635374784,
0.1010570824,
-0.4157502055,
-0.5214164853,
-0.6828554869,
-0.6793533564,
-0.1094498858,
-0.2565197647,
0.1903125346,
0.3690448403,
0.8603476286,
0.4747486115,
-0.7467141747,
-0.2451584637,
-0.6353867054,
0.5756239295,
-0.5976967812,
0.0607551485,
0.2907737792,
0.1179511994,
-0.2223017067,
-0.1909697205,
-0.1810628027,
-0.1715987176,
-0.2675519586,
0.2120064795,
-0.2669908106,
-0.2518093884,
0.0996555537,
0.4057782888,
-0.9175473452,
-0.1557283551,
-0.9324400425,
-0.1370677501,
0.6823968291,
-0.2156896591,
0.4411079586,
-0.6034620404,
-0.8047366142,
0.2285764664,
-0.702658236,
0.0674218163,
0.7636052966,
0.5077782273,
-0.221945703,
0.5477778912,
-0.1144075096,
1.1412483454,
0.3768171072,
-0.2643155754,
0.1365542412,
-0.2639661431,
-0.3600803316,
0.4696233273,
0.8764277101,
0.3696310818,
0.2709485888,
-0.4315246344,
0.1157075614,
-0.1138567477,
0.6550639272,
-0.4826068282,
-0.5090864301,
0.0528359972,
-0.5094668269,
-0.8660616875,
0.0065950979,
-0.8277692795,
-0.5906639099,
-0.0388719589,
0.4993330538,
-0.4152857065,
-0.2151258439,
0.0695670322,
0.1492089033,
0.2249432653,
0.0093014948,
-0.5852510333,
-0.187679261,
0.246907115,
0.6071712375,
-0.5116860271,
-0.2139696628,
-0.1650694162,
0.2443956286,
-0.4746455252,
0.8938264251,
-0.4860337079,
-0.3261495829,
-0.0204965919,
0.1934905797,
-0.2200263888,
-0.6144307256,
0.5448089242,
-1.1114999056,
-0.0294600315,
0.062726751,
-0.3699080944,
-0.5009007454,
0.3331209421,
-0.6917318106,
0.7321634293,
0.0340364985,
-0.9280409813,
0.4693291187,
-0.5652276874,
-0.8411380649,
0.140815571,
0.2256988734,
-0.5706742406,
0.0530652665,
0.2621442676,
0.2671183944,
-0.122442387,
0.4865935445,
0.1691064537,
-0.5511330962,
0.5448559523,
-0.5051790476,
1.1089041233,
0.1538425088,
-0.19872576,
-0.0251992699,
-0.48062253,
-0.2880284786,
0.2109560817,
-0.5574125051,
-0.3524869978,
-0.4293791056,
0.1012938321,
-0.1852482408,
0.226631701,
-0.4007853568,
0.3882292509,
-0.329916209,
-0.2713105679,
0.5126757026,
0.0006952405,
0.2323875874,
-0.1434400827,
0.7186203003,
0.0094840145,
0.1034535691,
-0.0164442938,
-0.3344575167,
-0.33499825,
-0.0440069847,
0.6757573485,
0.4357197285,
-0.8412771821,
0.3373264372,
-0.1504060477,
-0.3739107549,
-0.6551446915,
0.1172100231,
0.3831446767,
0.3062509894,
0.2991978526,
0.168600291,
-0.5525500774,
-0.993609786,
-0.3055592775,
0.1187294424,
0.1698479503,
-0.1211076006,
0.3336187005,
0.0839728862,
1.0378961563,
-0.3916187882,
-0.5188120008,
-0.4110618532,
0.5647152066,
0.0425205566,
0.1189796776,
0.6076906919,
-1.7205036879,
-0.5918819904,
-0.1954924464,
-0.8044912815,
-0.2812644541,
-0.2277246863,
0.1701030731,
0.2085530311,
0.3268971145,
-0.1876924187,
0.615664959,
0.4629994333,
-0.1778998226,
0.7440020442,
0.0514093041,
0.3995271921,
-1.2913618088,
0.1281255335,
0.1364075989,
-0.2491344512,
-0.3646541536,
-0.232369855,
-0.0239432417,
-0.2101629078,
-0.5677708387,
0.2956140041,
-0.3582202792,
-0.0864563882,
-0.6854425073,
-0.091863066,
-0.158018142,
0.3676739335,
0.0245672222,
0.8986275792,
0.4685778618,
-0.6034787893,
0.742767036,
0.4787952304,
-0.244299233,
0.4464234114,
-0.6365311146,
-0.4190199673,
-0.1091260538,
0.3515700996,
-0.9394663572,
-0.0956466123,
0.3149201274,
-0.5765308142,
0.5580888391,
-0.5029572248,
-0.5407770872,
-0.4295501113,
-0.2690751255,
0.337120831,
0.2162263989,
-0.4705518484,
0.1306853145,
0.3874343932,
-0.0173992068,
-0.5583170056,
-0.8703953028,
0.2759850621,
-0.2820243537,
-0.2497568876,
0.0495785922,
-0.1210166812,
0.3713108897,
0.1352705061,
0.1466949582,
0.1352615356,
-0.0970269367,
0.0564891286,
0.2623514533,
0.2974308431,
-0.1974844337,
-0.0856537819,
-0.3678782284,
0.0424884669,
-0.161712572,
0.4576945901,
-0.0077056088,
-0.3527851701,
-0.4074424207,
0.0512470827,
0.3422204852,
-0.234913975,
0.8568213582,
0.9619037509,
-0.115106374,
-0.0619407818,
-0.1991554052,
0.2067063898,
-0.3623737693,
0.2390174121,
0.0443052985,
-0.3784528077,
0.2532562017,
-0.1911135167,
-0.6650512815,
0.2814739048,
0.6732252836,
0.0976849794,
0.8593498468,
0.796682179,
-0.3182271421,
0.0621637926,
-0.5186634064,
0.7004110813,
-0.7678988576,
-0.4586555362,
0.1308833659,
-0.4490400553,
-0.8363375664,
-0.2361635119,
0.4296492338,
-0.1733104587,
0.1922665834,
0.3852314949,
-0.6216299534,
0.2697432637,
0.4630023837,
0.1987543106,
0.3155468702,
-0.0091902837,
0.2417592257,
0.0397184119,
-0.4783699214,
-0.4051939845,
1.1689664125,
-0.2004137933,
1.2233511209,
0.0860433877,
0.281098634,
0.9853770733,
-0.0344187506,
-0.6136331558,
0.480887413,
-0.0295680109,
-0.9525433183,
-0.021459952,
-0.2183274478,
-1.0409640074,
0.0060323379,
0.0357620269,
-0.6116926074,
0.1777727604,
-0.1995898783,
-0.4449000657,
0.7461987734,
-0.4997878969,
0.7184352279,
-0.2612943947,
-0.3907889724,
0.1599861532,
-0.7148239613,
0.6442294717,
-0.3007919788,
0.0300895981,
0.2117417008,
0.1092839092,
0.90014714,
0.0304787736,
0.8757585883,
0.0064529208,
-0.1192333698,
0.3310122788,
-0.0113252625,
0.2888803184,
0.0771922842,
0.214288339,
-0.0990739688,
-0.3605486751,
-0.7683070898,
-0.2277398109,
0.5724286437,
-0.4677621424,
-0.1135035604,
-0.6812890768,
-0.7612420917,
-0.0262115579,
0.2096830308,
0.4687050283,
0.4219995439,
-0.0262834374,
0.3734846413,
0.8637772202,
-0.092790924,
0.3496180475,
0.4753281176,
-0.2927010953,
-0.0402888879,
1.0449620485,
0.0597875454,
-0.0369396321,
0.2990749478,
-0.0903109461,
-0.355140835,
-0.8683157563,
-0.5494689941,
0.1062580273,
-0.0835342109,
-0.4263439476,
-0.5457139015,
-0.4018614292,
-0.3919392526,
-0.2241277248,
-0.370053798,
0.1432679743,
-0.0950519294,
0.0082701026,
0.3709587455,
0.8113613129,
-0.1619112045,
0.5041772127,
-0.7939468026,
0.6391694546,
0.2892423868,
0.0381002612,
-0.1751425117,
-0.7099100947,
-0.6532205343,
0.177595064,
-0.3466222882,
-0.894120574,
0.3824263513,
-0.3774695992,
0.3767674565,
0.817647934,
0.2404664606,
0.1571295857,
-0.0718152821,
0.7631539106,
-0.1159980223,
-0.3860262334,
0.8278927207,
-0.6828082204,
0.1363822967,
0.4544523656,
0.8601014614,
0.0792531222,
-0.1204702407,
-0.4986841679,
-0.6556638479,
0.7033963799,
0.3585924804,
-0.120517619,
0.2017077655,
-0.1282359511,
0.2647545934,
0.5760710835,
-0.9905933142,
-0.4709335864,
0.1216731519,
0.0943625346,
0.031254299,
-0.4822924137,
-0.1075823307,
0.0123530244,
0.8712317944,
0.1455729753,
0.1373260468,
-0.2276580036,
-0.437569201,
0.0399452262,
0.2826521993,
0.2482202053,
0.756375134,
-0.5039127469,
-0.2504726052,
-0.1800966263,
-0.4751947522,
0.1808070391,
0.512452364,
-0.6177298427,
-0.0016399372,
0.2466053218,
0.5832010508,
0.4831814468,
-0.4114683867,
0.4629050791,
0.2563862801,
0.3686877489,
-0.172991097,
-0.2292346358,
-0.0037772846,
0.1908455342,
0.6733503938,
0.1901817024,
0.4724080861,
-0.3941664696,
0.2531130612,
0.3416007757,
-0.2728934884,
-0.2898585498,
0.8235359788,
0.1830267161,
0.0433264412,
0.1776981056,
-0.561178267,
-0.781211555,
0.5061858296,
0.7084321976,
0.4866789281,
-0.3877622783,
0.6708381772,
0.1097697839,
0.5107957125,
0.1059203744,
-0.0594333448,
0.0500125214,
-0.4410659969,
-0.2819199264,
-0.7867856026,
-0.2283252776,
0.3289376795,
-0.6580458879,
0.1621923745,
0.0333874039,
0.093046397,
-0.0311092939,
0.3345460296,
-0.1611788124,
0.5085575581,
0.2919790447,
0.5710860491,
-1.3070204258,
0.5257492065,
1.0802710056,
-0.6577669382,
-0.3680121899,
0.2459416986,
0.1440069675,
-0.5605831742,
0.4792480469,
0.0312550627,
-0.1359321028,
0.1323331147,
-0.572832942,
-0.6318449378,
0.7554016113,
0.1503109038,
0.0359308235,
-0.0859691203,
0.2691737115,
0.2337100953,
-0.1082915738,
0.0377360731,
0.5608108044,
0.7392950654,
0.2114194334,
-0.5866179466,
-0.2162331343,
-0.310215205,
-0.0588473529,
0.2229128927,
-0.9236569405,
0.5343459845,
-0.1284421831,
0.083056286,
0.0251755975,
0.6178361177,
-0.0141011104,
0.470341146,
0.3602392673,
0.6852802634,
0.4235123098,
-0.0581115298,
0.9745116234,
0.0264290012,
0.5428234339,
0.6985141039,
0.1218178943,
0.1754849851,
0.1144038588,
-0.6497806311,
0.140169248,
0.9733700156,
-0.4528210163,
0.7959674001,
0.1161802262,
-0.0058458708,
-0.131442368,
-0.5293101072,
-0.4660736918,
0.7719762325,
0.1564194262,
-0.184254542,
-0.4069972634,
0.5611531138,
0.2120839953,
0.1467132121,
-0.2886541486,
0.5476577282,
-0.2308686227,
-0.0675062239,
0.5066277385,
-0.2660413384,
0.874810636,
-0.7012258172,
0.3372179568,
-0.13422589,
-0.0133679518,
-0.3489179313,
-0.6699864268,
0.2520878911,
0.071868144,
-0.3510450721,
0.071530953,
0.9907966256,
-0.5684806705,
-0.8306669593,
0.2101092041,
0.2961875796,
0.4012631476,
-0.2414997667,
-0.6518324614,
0.1186651438,
0.2943749428,
-0.2085057199,
0.351087302,
0.1823455095,
0.2361954451,
0.5855275393,
0.5484592319,
0.3010427356,
0.1024802998,
-0.1231203824,
0.7283223271,
-0.6008961201,
-0.569596827,
-0.4507431984,
0.3125413656,
-0.3162623644,
0.1039922461,
0.8451049328,
1.0463242531,
0.789690733,
-0.2108042985,
0.9461461306,
-0.1677559465,
0.4721653759,
-0.4960567057,
1.0998704433,
-0.8112065196,
-0.0197397657,
0.0025207496,
-0.9815793037,
-0.0888550133,
0.033253219,
-0.46177423,
0.4239320457,
0.5436255336,
0.6640343666,
-0.4155590534,
0.120933041,
0.3692306578,
0.3775686324,
-0.0844937041,
0.3756431937,
0.5502535105,
-0.6235842705,
0.7789464593,
-0.2731682956,
-0.2113920599,
-0.7913526297,
-0.8022049665,
-1.0252127647,
-0.5684083104,
-0.5042113066,
-0.0684427172,
0.2411860675,
0.3167594373,
0.5923568606,
-0.8880113363,
0.1975817084,
0.4327568114,
0.1745409667,
0.0084711565,
-0.354634285,
0.7397067547,
-0.124411203,
-1.0573384762,
0.5344724059,
0.127906099,
0.0204230566,
-0.4542931318,
0.4532101154,
-0.9494379163,
0.137377888,
0.3501268029,
0.3733372986,
-0.3999475241,
0.2210898846,
-0.4605363309,
-0.0513327718,
-0.1117623076,
0.625359714,
-0.83053267,
0.4951541126,
0.3134388328,
0.5946702957,
0.3248545527,
0.395539701,
0.0627959073,
-0.5433232188,
0.3653994799,
0.0575752817,
0.0646195188,
0.6578249931,
-0.6035254598,
0.5661544204,
0.2562924027,
-0.628667891,
-0.6572747827,
0.0155830029,
-1.2081195116,
-0.1939115077,
1.0633343458,
-0.0422572084,
-0.4407620728,
-0.1532886177,
-0.2906876802,
0.4542500675,
-0.2108950615,
1.0083624125,
0.431727916,
0.1070032567,
0.2380149066,
-0.5779607892,
0.3843461871,
0.2113364041,
-0.5961627364,
-0.1740684658,
0.1547916234,
-0.0098468158,
0.3034676015,
0.1766775548,
-0.0354870372,
0.2754650712,
-0.1389533877,
-0.118539162,
-0.4659889638,
-0.4310523272,
-0.178268373,
0.1385111958,
-0.5618631244,
-0.6109910011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06329v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06329v1
|
A Survey of AI Text-to-Image and AI Text-to-Video Generators
| 2023-11-10T17:33:58 | 2023-11-10T17:33:58 |
Aditi Singh
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.IV
|
Text-to-Image and Text-to-Video AI generation models are revolutionary
technologies that use deep learning and natural language processing (NLP)
techniques to create images and videos from textual descriptions. This paper
investigates cutting-edge approaches in the discipline of Text-to-Image and
Text-to-Video AI generations. The survey provides an overview of the existing
literature as well as an analysis of the approaches used in various studies. It
covers data preprocessing techniques, neural network types, and evaluation
metrics used in the field. In addition, the paper discusses the challenges and
limitations of Text-to-Image and Text-to-Video AI generations, as well as
future research directions. Overall, these models have promising potential for
a wide range of applications such as video production, content creation, and
digital marketing.
|
[
-0.6386172771,
-0.9047856331,
0.3767426312,
0.0959285945,
-0.1984685361,
0.164965257,
-0.1304863244,
-0.4684406221,
-0.3332731128,
0.4954999685,
-0.7496231198,
-0.3240352273,
-0.7770572305,
0.2952211201,
-0.8753232956,
0.8476580381,
0.0477282293,
0.0275807399,
-0.4204932153,
0.0427546501,
-0.6851153374,
-0.2766433358,
-0.7040728331,
-0.0875643939,
-0.0279912222,
0.1570112854,
0.8359931111,
0.7121281624,
0.6923359036,
0.3072878718,
0.247737512,
0.3638262749,
-0.0053938851,
0.2709712386,
-0.0468345024,
0.0869841054,
-0.1087408736,
0.0233643409,
0.5923923254,
0.2624378502,
0.340367794,
0.3892291188,
-0.2623471022,
0.7284213305,
-0.5743892193,
-0.1772493869,
-0.6765044332,
0.3546306193,
-0.0055493135,
-0.4197304249,
-0.5489860177,
-0.2088220716,
0.1794047654,
-0.4416183531,
0.3870331645,
-0.1544893682,
0.7353650928,
0.4510693848,
-0.4308340251,
-0.6035197377,
-1.2184944153,
0.7609859705,
-0.6714317799,
0.3031063676,
0.1319071651,
0.3442519903,
0.2002060413,
-1.1287150383,
-0.4680285454,
-0.1652581096,
0.3261274397,
0.1971156597,
-0.1703133136,
-0.175188303,
-0.0306166001,
0.5418545604,
-0.4399917722,
0.4800613821,
-0.3022380173,
0.2511072457,
0.9943879247,
0.1193129793,
0.6481527686,
-0.1646826118,
-0.2642330825,
-0.2471642196,
-0.453001529,
-0.2900734544,
0.3548334837,
-0.1639154553,
-0.0624425821,
0.7522960901,
-0.0020256892,
0.748936832,
0.0112035647,
-0.0160070322,
-0.2392953783,
-0.6647732854,
-0.555534184,
-0.1613701433,
1.0751558542,
0.5983650684,
0.2933213413,
-0.1396326274,
-0.142131418,
-0.0142333368,
0.2259811163,
-0.7676454186,
-0.0704786032,
-0.086119391,
-0.6703082323,
-0.554437995,
-0.1336896867,
-1.0990661383,
-0.2824314535,
-0.2844974697,
0.3983210921,
-0.5094831586,
-0.1793155223,
-0.3782787025,
-0.5160605311,
0.4713147581,
0.2592639923,
-0.9988639355,
-0.0209148582,
0.4131396413,
0.5259292722,
-0.0945630148,
-0.0164389927,
-0.1488211453,
0.213150084,
-0.4866569638,
0.8937885165,
-0.3601602018,
-0.395642966,
0.6769252419,
-0.5142166615,
0.0270950235,
-0.4941112101,
0.1622815728,
-0.4937431514,
0.5325112939,
0.4045287967,
-0.5521023273,
-0.042233713,
0.403683722,
-0.9100413322,
0.7604169846,
-0.2251790166,
-0.5763298273,
0.3579595685,
-0.7213517427,
-0.5845009089,
0.2394153476,
-0.4035799503,
-0.6807205081,
0.2326929867,
0.4722441733,
0.5687862039,
-0.7605335712,
0.4830565453,
0.2795290649,
-0.0539110526,
0.3261555731,
-1.0257511139,
0.4905495346,
0.5063306093,
-0.2892066836,
-0.1270654947,
-0.7913930416,
0.1474644989,
0.3503309488,
-0.1268239766,
0.1529383957,
0.3364234269,
0.4509067833,
0.2687079012,
0.0213063322,
-0.0858123004,
0.0904044285,
-0.0852683485,
0.7856004238,
0.6091794968,
0.0605489016,
0.3484087884,
-0.0784565285,
0.75593853,
-0.3427424133,
0.1687654257,
-0.9229238033,
-0.5613230467,
-0.5247068405,
0.1601319611,
0.2233132869,
0.5635018945,
-1.1212334633,
0.3211483359,
-0.36123842,
-0.5964128375,
-0.4256232977,
0.040595293,
0.1221505851,
0.4174926281,
0.2639494836,
-0.1246870905,
-0.2747361362,
-0.747975111,
-0.2261487544,
-0.3373975754,
-0.0585271008,
0.2958025038,
0.3262510002,
-0.2711648047,
0.8983286023,
-0.2953644991,
-0.1403149962,
-0.2803882957,
0.5268779397,
-0.3700473607,
0.4257542491,
0.6391126513,
-1.2856845856,
-0.4933113754,
0.026201535,
-0.8441675901,
0.4185847044,
-0.5424082279,
0.3905396461,
0.3535867333,
0.5485109687,
-0.5753677487,
0.7809380889,
0.5026902556,
-0.0808756724,
0.4655719101,
-0.1174247116,
0.4477719367,
-1.3677637577,
-0.0048343074,
0.253759712,
-0.1375019848,
-0.769315064,
0.0952816531,
-0.6048212051,
-0.5605176091,
-0.5760378838,
0.3443516195,
-0.405186832,
-0.2641037405,
-0.2088950872,
-0.0473946482,
-0.1005588621,
0.0965283141,
0.4320925474,
0.7232337594,
0.7731920481,
-0.6880033016,
0.5901288986,
0.4940982163,
-0.3472124338,
0.5083515644,
-0.3965441585,
0.2523821592,
-0.3457041085,
0.0892595723,
-0.9138597846,
-0.4968176782,
0.0553892441,
-0.8905459046,
0.1635307074,
0.0914460495,
-0.5163452029,
-0.4442828298,
-0.4481508136,
0.7373778224,
0.7666711807,
-0.5410992503,
0.5448455215,
0.1350611895,
-0.3075454235,
-0.4953368604,
-0.8152788877,
0.6273654699,
-0.3054465353,
-0.6757234931,
0.5792399645,
0.0269057117,
-0.1522050053,
0.0300737042,
0.5138195753,
-0.3314357996,
-0.2974172831,
0.071409516,
0.2984525859,
-0.1437596679,
0.153413862,
-0.1004002467,
0.1806467772,
0.1597868353,
-0.3212713301,
0.4733185172,
0.3066153228,
-0.0336243287,
-0.5571006536,
0.8569744229,
0.3617741764,
-0.4267059863,
0.3582578897,
0.8414744735,
-0.3963707089,
-0.1133645326,
-0.4181923568,
0.0984748453,
-0.496254921,
0.634296,
0.0542061478,
-0.471901983,
-0.0857275501,
-0.3634755015,
0.3024740517,
0.8897616267,
0.7784125209,
-0.4542856514,
1.1571675539,
0.7557699084,
0.3087424934,
0.810529232,
-0.4550011754,
0.3382458687,
-0.2530715466,
-0.1593181342,
-0.5741019845,
-0.1700288206,
-0.6998503804,
-0.0871797204,
0.2143825293,
-0.2928729057,
-0.254522115,
0.1139696389,
-0.7655257583,
0.2065701187,
0.5059878826,
-0.2713561058,
0.2739679217,
0.5415814519,
0.5700139403,
-0.0268027931,
-0.6956431866,
-0.5453667045,
1.1353061199,
0.2907437384,
0.35763219,
-0.2353642285,
0.4171981812,
0.8156024218,
0.2300943136,
-0.8672986627,
0.6896554232,
-0.628062129,
-0.5723720789,
-0.3873941898,
-0.1102111787,
-0.6564471126,
-0.5811010599,
-0.4344398677,
-0.3862763345,
-0.2337959856,
0.1313238442,
-0.0316847041,
0.6008266807,
-0.4968666732,
0.5940583944,
-0.5224623084,
-0.210849911,
-0.1559307426,
-0.8044154644,
0.4031732976,
-0.0008368131,
0.106969744,
0.2895059884,
0.2733309567,
0.6295517683,
-0.2301909775,
0.5364648104,
0.1169263721,
-0.1102336571,
0.9078415036,
-0.38276124,
0.0872115642,
-0.0944179147,
0.0455294438,
0.0481087714,
-0.4686262012,
0.0520659164,
-0.3275280595,
0.2984265387,
-0.7662561536,
-0.2592690587,
-0.0780847669,
-0.4067928791,
-0.1274102628,
0.1043663025,
0.8725190163,
0.3470586538,
-0.4793825746,
0.1711208373,
0.4852315485,
-0.6276808381,
0.994101584,
-0.4230122268,
-0.0344317965,
-0.8057178259,
0.8917903304,
-0.0997884199,
0.3429349065,
0.4513524175,
-0.3166966736,
-0.2318754494,
-0.5971608162,
-0.9647937417,
-0.1585055143,
-0.4700936079,
-0.3364614844,
-0.1942237169,
-0.6550209522,
-0.5492626429,
-0.2240067422,
-0.3936136067,
-0.2432688475,
-0.5187067986,
-0.0975572765,
0.397219032,
0.7693154812,
0.2781746387,
0.5272611976,
-0.7083442211,
0.6581997871,
0.5602436066,
0.1123764887,
-0.0277091768,
-0.066366896,
-0.2934657037,
-0.0460111946,
-0.6971768737,
-0.9580926299,
0.4920627773,
0.4617170095,
0.0089960871,
0.3310693204,
-0.3739599288,
0.403971076,
-0.6318355799,
1.2356747389,
0.6383118629,
-0.7115231752,
0.7933878899,
-0.3315423131,
0.0621729717,
0.2340040058,
0.3559912741,
-0.3898269534,
0.0713645965,
-0.5394046307,
-0.8213724494,
0.2227581143,
0.4808309972,
0.4270407557,
0.2804281712,
0.4314604104,
0.0881544054,
0.3279029727,
-0.7481663227,
-0.1177098677,
-0.5157561302,
-0.3791609406,
0.0047964691,
0.2223769277,
0.1936264187,
0.1088623703,
0.3425047696,
-0.2222356051,
0.3839371204,
0.1425012052,
0.044102665,
-0.0387853719,
0.3553941846,
0.2309616059,
0.4189500511,
0.1576668173,
-0.3531503975,
-0.2663691044,
-0.4777324796,
0.3256571591,
0.0843306258,
-0.7503384352,
0.1628781706,
0.4078700244,
1.0197811127,
-0.6734118462,
-0.8536895514,
0.3821320534,
-0.0318169594,
-0.6166370511,
-0.7002127767,
-0.1102800295,
-0.3474658132,
-0.1320619285,
0.5337737799,
0.2083739042,
0.2996949255,
-0.8043429255,
0.1176842153,
0.5700256228,
-0.3298571408,
-0.3029782176,
0.9960795641,
0.3109447062,
-0.8300955892,
0.9245151281,
0.1144489795,
-0.0104028042,
0.9805025458,
0.6376472712,
1.2770636082,
0.1495794952,
0.7340173721,
0.0379211344,
0.2561755776,
0.1513403505,
0.0441222154,
-0.0164118689,
-0.5550377369,
-0.4176895618,
-0.0750066116,
-0.3506059945,
0.4156093001,
-0.5785681009,
0.3831366897,
-0.3768294752,
-0.5968897343,
0.3346817493,
-0.3451979756,
-0.7994191647,
0.7842885852,
0.5958890319,
0.7084670663,
-0.7682542205,
0.4704636037,
0.8873855472,
-0.5097852945,
-0.4287276864,
-0.0618180819,
-0.3421214223,
-0.5480301976,
0.4238820672,
0.1725274473,
0.2949904203,
0.0939554796,
-0.9204881787,
-0.2185408175,
1.0748975277,
0.2357980013,
-0.2795576751,
-0.4844965339,
0.6821819544,
0.5985421538,
-0.4960634112,
0.1177333146,
0.5033434629,
0.4783059657,
0.1261900663,
-0.3360522985,
-0.614372611,
-0.4365104735,
0.2536104918,
0.0372293107,
-0.6277093887,
0.5576646924,
-0.0813601092,
-0.1146264374,
0.476570487,
0.7548348308,
0.1827588528,
0.7694192529,
0.3693799078,
0.4241412282,
-0.1792955101,
-0.0125276158,
0.8158008456,
-0.0186177455,
0.0605773404,
0.6421006918,
0.0589865409,
0.6178026199,
0.5376409292,
-0.0163045153,
0.3572368622,
0.6269561052,
-0.5897472501,
0.3930264711,
-0.1549746394,
-0.1839990169,
-0.047460746,
-0.3836866915,
-0.1899360865,
0.5103513002,
0.4822871089,
-0.7621764541,
0.0657818019,
0.1739799231,
-0.46656394,
0.3774860203,
-0.5313465595,
0.9855261445,
-0.212755695,
-0.8122055531,
0.1198571473,
0.1082700863,
0.5467896461,
-0.3390074968,
-0.3164874613,
0.0737968981,
-0.2125196904,
-0.1039875373,
-0.7807492614,
0.1807769537,
0.4664651453,
-0.0996024907,
-0.4502020478,
1.1340528727,
-0.2127185315,
-0.780403018,
-0.2037720978,
0.4586058855,
-0.1084031612,
0.1975944787,
-0.5662479997,
-0.2825108469,
0.164681375,
-0.0517360568,
0.063778013,
0.2689117491,
-0.1084248126,
0.4231795967,
0.2498588711,
-0.1343043298,
0.3185254633,
0.0349541754,
0.5832624435,
-0.756092608,
-0.1017034799,
-0.8193408847,
0.6466423869,
-0.1274106205,
-0.5305364728,
0.3383085132,
0.4188592732,
0.6157093644,
-0.4448127449,
1.1863064766,
-0.1828787476,
-0.1488096118,
-0.54518646,
0.6869158149,
-0.4878255427,
-0.3095161617,
-0.4415214658,
-0.9362803102,
-0.1227806509,
0.0031737373,
0.2127287537,
0.0992541164,
0.2289460003,
0.1884409338,
0.2486120909,
0.1810380816,
0.1172327995,
-0.3202775717,
0.5852962732,
0.4984906316,
1.0249831676,
-0.8804616332,
0.7127002478,
-0.1470357925,
0.1063795239,
-0.0285994522,
-1.0058562756,
-0.7117978334,
-0.6170855761,
-0.4822236001,
0.1690642983,
0.0136405891,
0.4516715705,
0.7778187394,
-0.2460356057,
-0.0602458455,
-0.4365323186,
-0.2980305851,
-0.2514573038,
-0.1563482285,
0.2879022658,
-0.0804754645,
-1.0149151087,
0.1184226647,
0.2969470024,
0.3764712811,
-0.5900324583,
-0.0019815806,
-0.1102204174,
0.2949312329,
0.6686860919,
0.4509652257,
-0.3981955051,
0.1528090388,
0.1160990521,
0.1219540909,
0.1791680455,
0.8251168132,
-0.7755586505,
0.2811001837,
0.5505209565,
0.9596912265,
0.6167237163,
0.1964751929,
0.7686741948,
-0.7740076184,
0.1303206831,
0.3998542726,
-0.1317694485,
0.5197139978,
-0.3157942593,
0.4539521933,
0.0702048689,
-0.5409004688,
-0.7587841153,
0.4389211237,
-0.7587179542,
-0.1332892776,
0.7172374725,
0.2138099074,
0.0736360773,
0.568926692,
-0.1047629043,
0.4501406252,
0.1192972064,
0.8042374849,
0.4468877912,
-0.0519997478,
-0.3895703256,
-0.564396143,
0.463722229,
0.4415321052,
-1.106867075,
-0.3599885404,
0.6357805729,
-0.2646404803,
0.2190539986,
0.3168596625,
-0.1034431383,
0.3091976643,
-0.1039468795,
-0.0866101682,
0.0282718558,
-0.4331046343,
-0.3178266883,
0.2615175843,
-0.2073990107,
-0.3146363795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06189v1
|
Syntax-semantics interface: an algebraic model
| 2023-11-10T17:12:09 | 2023-11-10T17:12:09 |
Matilde Marcolli, Robert C. Berwick, Noam Chomsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, math.LO, math.QA, math.RA, 91F20, 16T05, 18C50
|
We extend our formulation of Merge and Minimalism in terms of Hopf algebras
to an algebraic model of a syntactic-semantic interface. We show that methods
adopted in the formulation of renormalization (extraction of meaningful
physical values) in theoretical physics are relevant to describe the extraction
of meaning from syntactic expressions. We show how this formulation relates to
computational models of semantics and we answer some recent controversies about
implications for generative linguistics of the current functioning of large
language models.
|
[
-0.4329731762,
-1.1928377151,
0.8259247541,
0.0571847409,
0.0640163124,
0.0687669143,
0.0383320376,
-0.6646407843,
0.3240239918,
0.2516336739,
-0.4309839904,
0.0724078044,
-0.5163619518,
0.0178093817,
-0.5484037995,
0.6710988283,
-0.204837203,
-0.1639459878,
-0.3988379836,
0.1979509294,
0.0096180262,
-0.3645332456,
-0.2851528525,
-0.4190759063,
0.3453924358,
0.05661989,
1.1553871632,
0.4471867383,
1.0274995565,
0.3648487329,
-0.3748856783,
-0.2880100012,
-0.0165171642,
0.0355533138,
-0.0247780439,
-0.3148315549,
-0.3711308837,
0.2452492118,
1.0749422312,
1.4395598173,
-0.3455792069,
-0.019588843,
-0.4093046486,
0.6166092157,
-0.389957279,
0.0459352583,
-0.1467439234,
0.1676614434,
0.0303551797,
-0.3654706776,
-0.2808376849,
-0.4224781692,
0.1865023226,
-0.5391326547,
-0.1244732514,
-0.1787821054,
1.2698251009,
-0.0203414578,
-0.6048431396,
0.1178266183,
-0.9671244025,
0.6808444262,
-0.4327253997,
1.0010174513,
0.049935475,
0.5137242079,
-0.1780923605,
-0.9939997792,
-0.6960846782,
-0.1816732436,
-0.4559769928,
0.1608000547,
-0.4485508204,
0.4894167483,
0.5272829533,
0.4394245148,
-0.3428671062,
-0.3250053823,
-0.707663238,
0.0913684666,
0.5453409553,
0.3915523291,
0.6137756109,
-0.1390815675,
-0.4211274981,
0.3032850921,
-0.8443575501,
-0.1621287167,
0.4072421491,
0.3943708837,
-0.1565746069,
0.4793401659,
-0.2208122611,
1.0826818943,
-0.3343978524,
-0.1551423967,
0.1606673598,
-0.4681987166,
-0.3824717999,
-0.4309017956,
0.9881492853,
0.0072037899,
-0.0355120115,
-0.5199506283,
0.0303696617,
-0.015522941,
0.0939323306,
-0.6115893722,
-0.1925126165,
0.0259748921,
-0.5486531854,
-0.5355618596,
-0.0755812824,
-0.6109195352,
0.1525373459,
-0.6203211546,
0.3338491023,
-0.4027173221,
-0.6260982752,
0.1677512378,
-0.3989908099,
0.1575476527,
0.1680608094,
-1.1156283617,
0.8346505165,
0.6561508775,
0.562066555,
0.1719440073,
-0.3086357117,
-0.1197180673,
0.2162765563,
-0.3561038971,
0.6081622243,
-0.9116148949,
-0.5676548481,
-0.2610663474,
-0.2926838398,
0.031552773,
-0.3260086775,
0.1747015119,
-0.8180305958,
0.2484060973,
-0.0608813502,
-0.5461837053,
-0.1946975589,
-0.0759893879,
-0.7242382765,
0.7856633067,
0.4941819608,
-0.4655229747,
0.2377200872,
-0.9246966243,
-0.2680146396,
0.31512025,
-0.1386546791,
0.3477442563,
0.40563187,
-0.5621511936,
-0.2266758978,
-0.6072715521,
0.3486852348,
-0.1840045005,
0.1767652333,
0.3816096783,
-0.1554024667,
0.8678275347,
0.6004440188,
0.3152066767,
-0.0792264044,
-0.7855624557,
0.2765160799,
-0.185891971,
-0.0608171448,
-0.3392567039,
-0.2225905508,
0.0760078505,
0.3912498951,
0.3756786585,
-0.4490060508,
0.4030599296,
-0.5135847926,
0.2608475387,
0.3092397749,
0.1268600672,
0.8141976595,
0.1499728858,
0.7050592899,
-0.1754815429,
-0.0699760243,
0.2409010977,
-0.4755387008,
-0.3721338809,
-0.2320414782,
0.5482279062,
0.1696444452,
-0.4888231754,
0.3193210661,
-0.3308151662,
-0.1067889705,
-0.2678551078,
-0.0064234426,
0.3038617373,
0.6038682461,
-0.0227091052,
0.2509387434,
-0.5975726247,
-1.1536501646,
-0.4317319989,
-0.3999664187,
-0.0734360963,
0.1364502311,
0.1616826952,
-0.1005012691,
1.2900480032,
-0.5685753226,
0.2474262416,
-0.1107823402,
0.3849352598,
0.1284931898,
0.4984366894,
0.3643752933,
-1.0537446737,
-0.3465673029,
0.3700108826,
-1.1105362177,
0.0395630822,
0.1934193522,
-0.271784395,
-0.2626363933,
0.6866112947,
-0.8553596735,
0.2675859332,
0.199896425,
-0.3112300336,
0.1936639547,
0.181796357,
0.2989812791,
-0.8922326565,
0.1152820662,
-0.1714545637,
-0.3381558955,
-0.9927613735,
0.8643074036,
-0.1316344589,
-0.2567013502,
-0.6694913507,
0.7982283831,
-0.3314935863,
0.042803023,
-0.3121271431,
0.4028611481,
-0.0077023497,
-0.0607248843,
0.3085187376,
0.5490040183,
0.5717901587,
-0.6414009333,
0.477540344,
0.3303122818,
0.3908942044,
0.3426435292,
-0.4602084458,
-0.4007754028,
-0.1302560419,
-0.153352201,
-0.8136826754,
-0.3662343323,
0.1392435133,
-0.4705526531,
0.3739580214,
-0.3162633479,
-0.5129765272,
-0.2435151935,
-0.1217616573,
0.7427936792,
0.8207903504,
-0.4334947169,
1.0018004179,
0.3742978275,
-0.0125599941,
-0.2361110747,
-0.6192831397,
-0.089597702,
-0.2380672246,
-0.8179747462,
0.0067190584,
0.1841187477,
-0.8060616255,
0.3010270894,
0.1896126121,
-0.100699693,
0.2240889519,
-0.0223455597,
0.5885075331,
-0.1664332002,
0.1337329596,
0.2269771397,
-0.2489199787,
0.3067258298,
0.028052805,
0.4047532976,
-0.3192312717,
-0.1456761211,
-0.2214679718,
0.4919430315,
0.3417600393,
0.0071934196,
0.865668714,
0.2286122292,
-0.6089817882,
0.3870872259,
-0.1525209695,
-0.2553525567,
-0.4645546675,
-0.0400370546,
-0.5688202381,
-0.9082733989,
0.54448241,
-0.409286648,
-0.2300596982,
0.8196487427,
0.3861431479,
-0.0250927303,
1.061844945,
0.8218792081,
0.6323471069,
0.4601088762,
-0.3821295202,
0.6887894869,
-1.1199944019,
-0.3177241683,
-0.4830902219,
-0.0659514517,
-0.7506724596,
0.0133078806,
0.2279307395,
0.598675549,
-0.1388673484,
0.5156149268,
-0.1393681169,
0.5858165026,
0.1264723986,
-0.4517912567,
0.2579458058,
-0.0094767567,
0.0864820927,
-0.2797073126,
-0.5607235432,
-0.4284373522,
0.6334095597,
0.3224906921,
0.966950953,
0.4368070066,
0.8081598878,
-0.2602374554,
0.2354730815,
-0.9456325173,
0.4587776661,
0.1437740922,
-0.7231627703,
-0.0553072542,
-0.588953495,
-0.6710213423,
0.2532442212,
-0.2587837577,
-1.2807810307,
0.5109984875,
-0.1226983219,
-0.1651060283,
0.069915846,
-0.7629727125,
1.072434783,
0.1164611354,
-0.1961132139,
-0.1985078603,
-0.5651040673,
0.795745492,
0.1291768551,
0.317787677,
0.0263718534,
-0.1909690499,
0.7383958101,
-0.5807593465,
0.3605543077,
0.1481444836,
-0.2514216006,
0.5350958705,
0.5865716338,
0.1989534497,
-0.0002414209,
0.1834570765,
0.2829943001,
0.5255280137,
-0.2424037009,
-0.8206521273,
0.7469735146,
-0.7355636358,
-0.4950820804,
-0.4316616654,
-0.670566678,
-0.3239161968,
0.4706807733,
0.2633728683,
0.4914193451,
-0.2013848573,
-0.3306483626,
0.3953872919,
0.0187718645,
0.2221455276,
0.5055716038,
-1.0469343662,
-0.0628083944,
0.9914258122,
-0.2210173756,
0.5865164995,
0.3586508036,
0.2371501774,
-0.2328018546,
-0.1470396072,
0.0559193566,
0.3700401783,
-1.0380403996,
-0.057616137,
-0.6409732699,
-0.6227732897,
-0.2844417989,
-0.3638485074,
-0.1984428018,
-1.0387769938,
0.1091221496,
0.0840587765,
0.5511726737,
0.7218248844,
-0.3739845157,
0.6081188321,
-0.9989941716,
0.5000268817,
0.0715394169,
0.2701916993,
-0.208272472,
-0.5316901803,
-0.2974297702,
0.0593329221,
-0.1231304258,
-0.552749455,
0.2091903389,
0.0485200137,
0.3171133697,
0.3800233901,
-0.4635158479,
0.7175014019,
-0.5359401703,
0.8205197453,
0.55035007,
-1.0741202831,
0.4161956012,
-0.5665243864,
0.1603664607,
0.4622683823,
0.706733346,
-0.626771152,
-0.517772615,
-1.1790534258,
-0.6330166459,
0.4017405808,
0.0939927101,
0.1043836549,
-0.4223733842,
0.5437982082,
-0.2072675079,
0.3534289002,
-0.547495544,
-0.3949050307,
0.4722475111,
-0.0982032344,
0.4500625134,
-0.3457346559,
-0.6147965193,
-0.4660686255,
0.3155352175,
0.2687648535,
0.3734558821,
-0.2460763007,
0.0509145707,
-0.4055878818,
0.1163541153,
0.5465666652,
1.0386431217,
-0.0540372618,
0.2633691132,
-0.1514361054,
-0.2557884157,
0.0178655609,
0.0064307982,
-0.1203155667,
-0.0258861519,
0.5726487041,
0.4987251163,
0.0602120236,
-0.3755007982,
0.3398586214,
-0.1164310426,
-0.2324380279,
-0.0218785331,
-0.1359146684,
0.0093392842,
0.0275991932,
0.0579566061,
0.3045352697,
0.712202549,
-0.6540032625,
0.2640233934,
0.7913116217,
-0.2087446153,
-0.5041099191,
0.6384010315,
-0.1733169556,
-0.2086832225,
0.5030828118,
-0.1243273765,
-0.5018105507,
0.419403702,
0.4506200254,
0.9032295942,
-0.0375482626,
-0.0175593756,
0.5196755528,
-0.0763820559,
0.2634584308,
0.2079050094,
-0.0561548136,
-0.6120126247,
-0.6098185778,
-0.8473429084,
-0.3648691475,
-0.4857632816,
-0.740816772,
0.4602640569,
-0.3356953263,
-0.0610400215,
0.6248222589,
-0.3744443357,
-0.3928671181,
-0.1298640221,
0.1676555872,
0.8214683533,
-1.1322937012,
0.5689057112,
0.4858217239,
-0.8124501109,
-1.2157224417,
-0.4504968226,
-0.0925077274,
-0.5725018978,
1.4512792826,
-0.5206820369,
-0.2807498872,
-0.11079292,
-0.5908856392,
-1.2015343904,
0.4080995023,
0.586582005,
-0.1687652916,
-0.1820010394,
-0.0437563434,
0.6798328161,
-0.1864574552,
0.4623837769,
0.8015504479,
0.5918772817,
0.4833149016,
-0.9817276001,
-0.06711144,
-0.3174877763,
0.172838822,
0.8759747148,
-0.4066051841,
1.0279662609,
0.1245826259,
-0.3437360823,
0.1820606589,
0.5785694718,
-0.4735766053,
-0.4439721406,
-0.2500453293,
0.6913093328,
0.2712499797,
-0.2918561697,
1.4031301737,
-0.6083942056,
0.819955945,
0.4267158508,
-0.0596825182,
0.5226789117,
0.6401019692,
-0.7286647558,
0.465914607,
0.3688040376,
0.4370130897,
0.4367997944,
-0.0887462199,
-0.4847109318,
-0.317222029,
-0.194571957,
-0.4787101746,
0.4194375873,
0.4105708599,
0.0064664581,
-0.6617965102,
-0.004910023,
-0.0909509137,
-0.004301433,
-0.2143497765,
0.9510220885,
0.1968241036,
-0.344101876,
0.7275267839,
-0.0646914914,
0.0472042002,
-0.6198554039,
-0.5089347363,
0.0785964876,
-0.0766792595,
-0.547323525,
-0.6760258675,
0.6192781925,
-0.3746343255,
-0.1517363787,
-0.1330217719,
0.4326403439,
-0.6983315349,
-0.591586113,
0.0322762169,
0.3474732637,
0.2416532487,
0.8488606811,
-0.3269704282,
0.1546104103,
-0.5822924972,
0.145442456,
0.2655397952,
0.3429912627,
0.1234551147,
0.4348019361,
0.4802919328,
0.4888907671,
0.1252489239,
-0.0169496424,
0.9483395815,
-0.7009925842,
-0.4031841457,
-0.8607719541,
0.2756344378,
0.2269954979,
0.0552747063,
0.5155498981,
0.5727709532,
0.4254623055,
-0.0539404824,
0.6468758583,
-0.5008274317,
0.1874695718,
-0.5403282642,
0.3596103191,
-0.6070034504,
0.1196000129,
-0.4278335571,
-1.0293266773,
-0.3227780759,
0.6117271185,
-0.472625941,
0.1869331002,
1.1901587248,
0.2244604379,
-0.309761107,
-0.0991047919,
0.5520195961,
0.0568857715,
0.3931770027,
0.299295634,
1.0485745668,
-0.5676337481,
-0.1748302579,
-0.1679035574,
-0.1572940946,
-0.0008806509,
-0.8130015731,
-0.3846091032,
-0.7268832922,
-0.4609633982,
-0.4724011123,
-0.3084569871,
0.7750546336,
0.4057650268,
-0.4005416632,
-0.3891299963,
-0.3571300507,
0.1297698617,
-0.0048009674,
-0.2937704623,
0.1414585412,
-0.7566233277,
-0.6583171487,
0.1527535468,
0.4387968481,
0.1355513781,
-0.1817524582,
-0.0305087827,
-0.1725070924,
0.1886094064,
0.6244186759,
0.7076254487,
-0.5812799931,
-0.4638162851,
-0.0526851453,
-0.0186221916,
0.007211295,
0.8710218072,
-0.8434147239,
0.5135946274,
0.4717383087,
0.5645228624,
0.3621959686,
0.0770280957,
0.7027184963,
-0.316228658,
0.5951762795,
0.0391050801,
0.2906268537,
-0.0413998887,
-0.1868067831,
0.4000501633,
0.3192996383,
-0.0367423296,
-1.0189040899,
0.7944047451,
-0.9064300656,
-0.0413172282,
0.9080529213,
0.3822181821,
-0.4972700477,
0.4621503949,
0.2673329115,
0.0047706165,
0.1470486224,
0.3842854798,
0.8814697266,
-0.5534996986,
-0.3596668243,
-0.4232414961,
0.6965628266,
0.2052516341,
-0.7530477047,
0.1701362431,
0.5418809652,
-0.0126190996,
0.5323931575,
0.5485909581,
-0.3915544152,
0.6244795322,
0.3913561404,
0.1680157036,
0.0268310755,
-0.3560037315,
-0.5367591977,
-0.2529389858,
0.5509217978,
0.2655696571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06158v1
|
Language Models can be Logical Solvers
| 2023-11-10T16:23:50 | 2023-11-10T16:23:50 |
Jiazhan Feng, Ruochen Xu, Junheng Hao, Hiteshi Sharma, Yelong Shen, Dongyan Zhao, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Logical reasoning is a fundamental aspect of human intelligence and a key
component of tasks like problem-solving and decision-making. Recent
advancements have enabled Large Language Models (LLMs) to potentially exhibit
reasoning capabilities, but complex logical reasoning remains a challenge. The
state-of-the-art, solver-augmented language models, use LLMs to parse natural
language logical questions into symbolic representations first and then adopt
external logical solvers to take in the symbolic representations and output the
answers. Despite their impressive performance, any parsing errors will
inevitably result in the failure of the execution of the external logical
solver and no answer to the logical questions. In this paper, we introduce
LoGiPT, a novel language model that directly emulates the reasoning processes
of logical solvers and bypasses the parsing errors by learning to strict
adherence to solver syntax and grammar. LoGiPT is fine-tuned on a newly
constructed instruction-tuning dataset derived from revealing and refining the
invisible reasoning process of deductive solvers. Experimental results on two
public deductive reasoning datasets demonstrate that LoGiPT outperforms
state-of-the-art solver-augmented LMs and few-shot prompting methods on
competitive LLMs like ChatGPT or GPT-4.
|
[
0.1124741808,
-1.1038606167,
0.7652276754,
0.2005937546,
-0.1849758923,
0.2171522081,
0.0143596735,
-0.3903390467,
-0.1556296945,
0.5347555876,
-0.5559150577,
-0.1000999138,
-0.5213183761,
0.1760964394,
-0.0318581574,
0.8294911981,
0.0164214894,
0.2572515905,
-0.0174055118,
0.129497543,
-0.752512455,
-0.6809080839,
-0.6438606381,
-0.3664697111,
0.0590799414,
0.0881061256,
0.7071799636,
0.5141065121,
0.420959115,
0.3060650826,
-0.14488478,
0.154881835,
-0.2519866228,
-0.0259473994,
-0.4558762312,
-0.7792191505,
-0.2032461762,
-0.2755793035,
0.3815521896,
0.6051306725,
-0.2517743707,
-0.120750457,
-0.2458931506,
0.5163966417,
-0.3706096411,
0.5853002071,
-1.0726524591,
-0.065238066,
0.083148174,
0.0420892052,
-0.6722048521,
-0.5676985383,
-0.2707636654,
-0.3899426162,
0.1296486855,
-0.0369102098,
0.7443633676,
0.4562287927,
-0.2141679674,
-0.1553721726,
-0.8158364892,
0.6466196179,
-0.8091883063,
0.3552193642,
0.2530359328,
0.4752269983,
-0.3701792657,
-0.4715159535,
-0.7142665386,
-0.102074869,
-0.1596605033,
-0.1390317529,
-0.2098797262,
0.0655670911,
0.4680480361,
-0.1112671271,
-0.4584667087,
-0.0995848849,
-0.3760910332,
0.0477828905,
0.2811779976,
0.2568342388,
0.429251641,
-0.1474246383,
-0.2791773081,
0.1997141987,
-0.7202239633,
0.1514239013,
-0.0709168836,
0.2293193489,
0.2658887506,
0.5594276786,
0.0703439489,
0.9690058231,
-0.0227687024,
-0.1914011389,
-0.0922644362,
0.1511982828,
-0.3195125163,
0.2520916462,
0.5686264038,
-0.0326381065,
0.4526798725,
0.1508058757,
-0.4475921094,
0.4826980233,
-0.2040399313,
-0.543608129,
-0.4796699286,
0.1417773217,
0.0151828825,
-0.1989572942,
-0.244345963,
-0.3928614259,
-0.211681813,
-0.4238836169,
0.6242184639,
-0.7186656594,
-0.2167951316,
0.6337049007,
0.0228139535,
0.2868711352,
0.6327720881,
-0.7709382772,
0.4269769788,
0.8914579153,
0.5517290235,
0.4340351224,
-0.1531540751,
-0.6905124187,
0.208219558,
-0.5027301908,
0.8993186355,
-0.9422281384,
-0.0621272102,
-0.3225086331,
-0.0999743566,
-0.3318177462,
-0.5309052467,
0.5227417946,
-0.6598677039,
0.0788264051,
-0.1476861835,
-0.8088694811,
-0.2450270653,
0.305894196,
-0.6195458174,
0.6006804705,
-0.1140627712,
-0.6068145633,
0.0871993229,
-0.7146474123,
-0.2233377546,
0.2627725303,
-0.4596584141,
-0.1414948255,
0.099343054,
0.3948222995,
0.2057838291,
-0.3417896628,
0.6176505685,
-0.1563354731,
-0.2911670208,
0.2589384615,
-0.3760280609,
0.9321343303,
0.0410691239,
-0.3213604093,
-0.0751532763,
-0.5782504082,
0.1000809819,
0.4060108066,
-0.0918414071,
-0.2095317394,
0.1153971553,
-0.3837597966,
0.4500909448,
0.1745263338,
-0.7308656573,
0.1614517123,
-0.3602852821,
0.4873148501,
0.8495688438,
-0.2479986101,
-0.1541378945,
-0.3627551496,
0.4848240316,
0.038431935,
-0.1205236018,
-0.4816819131,
-0.6607734561,
-0.6762583852,
-0.5424423814,
0.1629941314,
1.0064694881,
-0.362071991,
0.3044721186,
-0.1082500517,
-0.4668704867,
-0.5691098571,
0.1170535833,
0.366815567,
0.6354933381,
0.2230662853,
0.4294785559,
-0.4338587523,
-0.8486657143,
-0.7298587561,
-0.3217819631,
0.0085954061,
0.021484917,
0.3970075846,
-0.0377679467,
1.0028803349,
-0.570892632,
-0.1474021524,
-0.5967082381,
0.0004336754,
0.5352391601,
0.4098618925,
0.0164717268,
-0.8615745306,
-0.4310198426,
0.046520967,
-0.9349116087,
-0.2723938823,
-0.2189750522,
0.3127620816,
0.229981631,
0.498971194,
-1.0002930164,
0.4074830711,
0.3099958301,
-0.5940169096,
0.7160553932,
-0.1589759439,
-0.1313507706,
-0.5071896911,
0.088636592,
-0.2869532108,
-0.3636284769,
-0.4166857004,
0.1135479435,
0.0983584225,
-0.5198564529,
-0.4415687919,
0.5584040284,
-0.1786652207,
0.3389886916,
-0.0982465893,
0.0990868211,
0.3472542167,
0.382053405,
0.1778808236,
0.4722755551,
0.5595536232,
-0.3573662043,
0.508452177,
0.3277558684,
-0.2375960201,
0.3044019341,
-0.9446493387,
-0.0067772283,
-0.4543892443,
0.2728245854,
-0.8407697082,
-0.1147005782,
0.1527013183,
-0.1390665174,
0.0894693285,
-0.2092109025,
-0.7457991838,
-0.131373331,
0.1222519577,
0.4354918897,
0.7634325027,
-0.6852092743,
0.6828334332,
0.0286291931,
-0.23808752,
-0.2550183237,
-0.4838319719,
-0.0231252108,
-0.0711029917,
-0.748793304,
-0.0897346064,
-0.1549591273,
-0.4692426026,
0.107206434,
-0.0710714385,
-0.1083563715,
-0.1176370159,
-0.1251619756,
0.3099417686,
-0.3024518192,
0.217177555,
-0.0413090475,
-0.2709476948,
0.1771079898,
-0.2288580537,
0.3945285678,
-0.64338094,
-0.7610664368,
-0.5856081247,
0.1903268695,
0.45324561,
-0.6130927801,
0.7764481306,
-0.0139779765,
-0.4230756164,
-0.2633395195,
-0.6685845852,
-0.3079215586,
-0.4525545835,
0.2274434268,
-0.7606819868,
-0.7204432487,
0.4266732335,
-0.3420956433,
-0.0362311266,
0.1390371621,
0.3296375573,
0.2001677901,
1.2643904686,
0.3471372724,
0.2148129344,
-0.0338716619,
0.1973215193,
0.7354592085,
-0.2526123822,
-0.3265638351,
-0.2742617428,
-0.0236959644,
-0.5101060867,
-0.4535434544,
0.3378125727,
0.5139055848,
-0.3533999622,
0.2579146922,
-0.254283607,
0.9223808646,
0.2970451415,
0.0834900513,
0.5796790123,
-0.1381318718,
-0.2823969126,
-0.2277190834,
-0.7650426626,
-0.5476164222,
0.4712844789,
0.3091363907,
0.9535182118,
0.1517952085,
0.5116348863,
-0.0926339179,
-0.0656176805,
-0.6460592747,
0.7034239173,
-0.1545746475,
-0.6939595342,
-0.2126707882,
-0.3427476287,
-0.569242537,
0.5666925907,
0.202048257,
-0.9392971992,
-0.0620923787,
0.3875643313,
-0.1028519198,
0.6907141805,
-0.8504356146,
1.0713986158,
-0.4047059119,
-0.3204309344,
-0.132894963,
-0.5111187696,
0.5466243625,
-0.2304102927,
0.3702799976,
-0.3080966771,
0.189493522,
0.2246529162,
-0.4809535444,
1.0356667042,
-0.1529011279,
-0.116160877,
0.3800487816,
0.8197101355,
0.8157938123,
0.0257873964,
-0.106041953,
-0.0252713468,
0.0550708286,
-0.5158382654,
-0.9695728421,
0.6428137422,
-0.3877446949,
-1.1370136738,
-0.416813314,
-0.5189126134,
-0.0647802502,
0.3387454748,
-0.1666233689,
0.4289774299,
-0.0061964407,
-0.2018400878,
0.6589986682,
-0.2525253296,
0.1631752104,
0.4925981164,
-0.4768995047,
-0.0442662835,
0.8775212765,
-0.1962125748,
0.4888765216,
0.6344373226,
0.5304222703,
-0.2836224437,
0.0319076478,
-0.4036571681,
0.4017434418,
-0.9508553743,
-0.1954066157,
-0.6749180555,
-0.3807090819,
-0.0588685647,
-0.1776630878,
-0.4083609283,
-0.6193806529,
0.1412906945,
-0.1974583268,
0.3959344625,
0.5932771564,
-0.0942777842,
-0.034059912,
-0.7592103481,
0.4406304061,
0.4025706947,
0.3092825711,
-0.3465174437,
-0.2471580356,
0.308921665,
0.0313023925,
-0.205792591,
-0.7012689114,
0.4902716279,
0.1787297726,
0.327842176,
0.2408389896,
0.0232382324,
0.6583971381,
-0.8355775476,
0.4475191236,
0.0800765753,
-1.0684421062,
0.8776460886,
-0.4227823615,
0.3538561165,
0.1486270279,
0.336109519,
-0.374683857,
-0.4188964367,
-0.5394096375,
-0.5220629573,
0.5950769782,
0.1310696006,
-0.1074708551,
-0.2323802561,
0.0425530039,
0.1423565894,
-0.0168468673,
-0.9713701606,
0.0695403665,
-0.3183363676,
-0.1830082834,
0.1342638284,
0.008334809,
0.0380207188,
-0.3985402882,
0.5947943926,
-0.0047017932,
0.0807626173,
0.0751365796,
-0.1595033556,
-0.1320958734,
0.4878604114,
0.4009734094,
0.6808699369,
-0.2318840921,
0.330275923,
0.0543344095,
-0.0024223211,
0.236735642,
0.1176442653,
-0.2094049305,
0.1224454641,
0.3098092377,
0.8163564205,
0.1123574898,
-1.1745153666,
0.4953198433,
-0.069130756,
-0.0208544694,
-0.432135433,
0.1562587321,
0.1096657291,
0.1843688786,
0.1568784416,
0.1990926266,
-0.1650201231,
-0.3040124476,
0.1646639556,
0.4741710722,
-0.244971171,
-0.400036186,
0.8180110455,
-0.0623652339,
-0.4861801565,
0.6279236078,
-0.1128947511,
-0.7509400249,
0.4896914661,
1.1930290461,
0.5294376016,
-0.3087236583,
0.141440168,
0.1930645108,
0.4069292843,
-0.043180529,
0.444062978,
0.3647325635,
-0.7749714851,
-0.713349402,
-0.6330071688,
-0.2287583351,
0.287904948,
-0.1557256728,
0.5077404976,
-0.5979560614,
0.3899005949,
-0.0768316761,
-0.4843192697,
-0.6698103547,
0.1231323108,
-0.1090133116,
0.9777203202,
-0.8025498986,
0.7685134411,
0.7327830791,
-0.3017351031,
-0.8538182974,
-0.2387127876,
-0.0252239574,
-0.7856954336,
1.1406774521,
0.263330251,
-0.2875245512,
0.1291605979,
-0.4548254013,
-0.5315852761,
0.5353879333,
0.867636025,
-0.6892706156,
-0.001244906,
0.3275566995,
0.3756708801,
-0.0576742813,
0.2712477744,
0.4787304699,
0.4086712301,
0.0534158647,
-0.9537658095,
0.2150724977,
-0.1994725019,
-0.2004284263,
0.4726554453,
-0.5558840036,
1.0223094225,
-0.4751001596,
-0.086000964,
-0.2043567598,
0.2572897375,
0.7294348478,
-0.0426321141,
0.4527961612,
0.7709926963,
0.6709272265,
0.1358880401,
0.9450673461,
-0.1772142649,
0.1085290983,
1.0681540966,
-0.5624327064,
0.8070880771,
0.4601398706,
-0.0206193775,
0.6319839358,
0.0372903459,
0.0294858627,
0.4121690989,
0.2230048925,
-0.6234048605,
-0.7191508412,
-0.0404518843,
-0.1407908946,
0.5797560215,
0.5769044161,
-0.0026828335,
-0.3970182538,
-0.2019695491,
-0.058584176,
0.4611883461,
-0.0765038505,
0.5874307752,
0.206324324,
-0.5503014326,
0.762142539,
0.0468440168,
0.2534936368,
-0.645704627,
-0.5135092735,
-0.1388462037,
0.5096258521,
-0.0644860938,
-0.5709380507,
0.2703640461,
-0.0104323858,
0.032305751,
-0.1259125769,
0.8295973539,
-0.2472372502,
-0.8735695481,
0.3236262798,
0.6093633175,
0.107710734,
0.0089380965,
-0.5597277284,
0.0165641364,
-0.0304065086,
-0.0283970218,
0.0731233284,
0.7609006166,
-0.1685357243,
1.0961723328,
0.5725313425,
0.0887678042,
0.0984874144,
-0.0854616538,
0.8899488449,
-0.8551216722,
-0.5742794275,
-1.2298491001,
0.4771863818,
0.3043026328,
0.1342849284,
0.4993011951,
0.545161128,
0.8751268983,
-0.28125301,
0.8954250216,
-0.0572250448,
0.6559547782,
-0.5872051716,
0.3282201588,
-0.2628999054,
0.5519451499,
-0.2125544101,
-0.6415371895,
-0.5117583275,
0.9391917586,
-0.4572946131,
-0.1646898538,
0.7123044729,
0.8110083938,
-0.3914740086,
0.2147115916,
0.5228059888,
0.2546105981,
0.5438793898,
0.7746214271,
1.0282257795,
-0.2400521785,
0.4523344636,
-0.114936538,
-0.2776882052,
0.0220532753,
-1.0138392448,
-1.0201909542,
-0.2824214995,
-0.1523370594,
-0.0381095558,
0.3292490542,
1.0265820026,
0.2726937532,
-0.7761410475,
-0.1834101677,
-0.4337362349,
0.2501737475,
-0.1390106082,
-0.2530964613,
0.224658832,
-0.628595829,
-0.4664558172,
0.5406749249,
0.096134007,
-0.1855047345,
0.0633607507,
0.0187987201,
-0.1334026307,
0.1125160456,
0.6544292569,
0.2377471328,
-0.9116930962,
-0.2228195518,
-0.0568576194,
0.2716707885,
0.1271991432,
0.8121898174,
-1.1363680363,
0.3413083553,
0.3477834463,
0.7324003577,
0.2760600746,
-0.060757339,
0.6085301042,
-0.3879497349,
0.2324511707,
0.3872048557,
0.3106047809,
0.2283879966,
-0.2531304955,
0.2586381137,
0.3203416467,
-0.4224395752,
-0.8082012534,
0.544403553,
-0.42124933,
-0.4448670149,
0.7939945459,
-0.1610200256,
-0.1642675251,
-0.0514738187,
-0.3041438162,
-0.0139697259,
-0.3237777948,
0.7144144177,
0.4463911355,
-0.4461818337,
-0.4367404282,
-0.6567437053,
0.2940725982,
0.6440334916,
-0.7184554338,
0.2357781976,
0.4517545104,
0.3533102274,
0.0248737484,
0.4404021502,
-0.1619384438,
0.1662219912,
-0.0466008335,
-0.1108403355,
-0.1315943748,
-0.2856100798,
-0.2948874235,
0.0062766364,
0.3511332572,
0.1199153811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06121v1
|
Is it indeed bigger better? The comprehensive study of claim detection LMs applied for disinformation tackling
| 2023-11-10T15:36:35 | 2023-11-10T15:36:35 |
Martin Hyben, Sebastian Kula, Ivan Srba, Robert Moro, Jakub Simko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study compares the performance of (1) fine-tuned models and (2)
extremely large language models on the task of check-worthy claim detection.
For the purpose of the comparison we composed a multilingual and multi-topical
dataset comprising texts of various sources and styles. Building on this, we
performed a benchmark analysis to determine the most general multilingual and
multi-topical claim detector.
We chose three state-of-the-art models in the check-worthy claim detection
task and fine-tuned them. Furthermore, we selected three state-of-the-art
extremely large language models without any fine-tuning. We made modifications
to the models to adapt them for multilingual settings and through extensive
experimentation and evaluation. We assessed the performance of all the models
in terms of accuracy, recall, and F1-score in in-domain and cross-domain
scenarios. Our results demonstrate that despite the technological progress in
the area of natural language processing, the models fine-tuned for the task of
check-worthy claim detection still outperform the zero-shot approaches in a
cross-domain settings.
|
[
-0.3997658193,
-0.5897371769,
0.5692135096,
0.1605760753,
-0.0697356686,
0.101090014,
-0.4383010566,
-0.9285072088,
0.156838581,
0.1744590104,
-0.1722149402,
-0.2393083721,
-0.8203318119,
0.3454975486,
-0.4335297346,
0.8941981196,
0.1039390266,
-0.0001345882,
-0.2441326231,
-0.038042374,
-0.4921995103,
-0.2975819707,
-0.6517283916,
-0.3961831927,
0.4706866443,
0.2530635297,
0.4374519587,
0.1077519506,
0.6251145601,
0.334933728,
-0.3260757923,
0.3274241388,
-0.1496028602,
-0.1039223969,
-0.4610942602,
-0.5437418222,
-0.501637578,
-0.1575912535,
0.7042610049,
0.3346176445,
-0.1973465383,
0.3792185187,
-0.0374444947,
0.6015376449,
-0.6556869149,
0.1427107304,
-0.9109960794,
-0.1746872813,
-0.1654907763,
0.1045385897,
-0.6949623227,
-0.3105885684,
-0.015473729,
-0.0316798836,
0.4204707444,
0.0856447443,
1.10145998,
0.0472190715,
-0.7329212427,
-0.5156732202,
-0.6472292542,
0.6555798054,
-0.8614274859,
0.2633461058,
0.3746100366,
0.5095607638,
0.2419700325,
-0.589972496,
-0.7505882382,
-0.3590110242,
0.004756975,
0.030883139,
-0.7280427217,
-0.2115136534,
0.4540255666,
0.5413325429,
-0.637126267,
0.6083282232,
-0.4206110239,
-0.6737028956,
0.6715872288,
-0.2514885068,
0.2096382678,
-0.2668832541,
-0.3547931314,
-0.0177712683,
-0.7558303475,
-0.1433757991,
0.241889894,
0.4458530843,
-0.0382701978,
0.4008587003,
-0.4493125081,
0.6044970751,
0.0675345287,
-0.3533778787,
0.1166319102,
-0.3983253837,
-0.3679484129,
0.2510512769,
0.6960084438,
0.3586605489,
0.3216638267,
-0.079532288,
-0.3789672852,
0.0584928803,
0.2920154929,
-0.7582240701,
-0.1006486192,
0.2429600805,
-0.4375672042,
-0.062710911,
0.1421042979,
-0.3417979181,
-0.5771827102,
-0.4350830615,
0.4436162114,
-0.473139286,
-0.5895446539,
0.4638450444,
0.1184014976,
-0.1537996829,
0.2836979926,
-0.3090045452,
-0.1400170773,
0.6932960749,
0.8168514371,
-0.0545149855,
-0.0105740437,
-0.5294938684,
-0.1657260507,
-0.558568716,
1.0408103466,
-0.2467927784,
0.0532694012,
0.4029190242,
0.2394620925,
0.0306086764,
-0.9443727732,
1.0854692459,
-0.8617761135,
0.1912551075,
-0.5717177987,
-0.693944633,
-0.3118798137,
0.7670441866,
-0.9177938104,
0.6868896484,
-0.0628425032,
-0.659232676,
0.81295681,
-0.3605824113,
-0.2524668574,
0.1885619015,
0.1822933406,
-0.7176201344,
0.2934230864,
-0.1164184138,
0.6132810116,
-0.4075769484,
0.5752193332,
-0.2125511765,
-0.0601852424,
0.5586576462,
-0.4509730637,
0.6475616097,
0.4081953764,
-0.4672153294,
-0.0234974716,
-0.720344007,
0.0017830968,
0.1591632664,
-0.4882398546,
-0.4428178072,
-0.2231412828,
-0.0227593724,
0.4467242062,
0.3714964092,
-1.0112999678,
0.030337669,
-0.112150237,
0.2910655439,
0.3409166932,
-0.3612291813,
-0.0743412077,
-0.4199553132,
0.3428944945,
-0.0115068667,
-0.1462267786,
-0.2688516378,
-0.0787192583,
-0.7438899875,
-0.4879966378,
0.8877658844,
0.3527930379,
-0.8259724379,
0.385718435,
-0.5482759476,
-0.3933281898,
-0.0606246553,
-0.1145955026,
0.4261527658,
0.271302253,
0.3412719369,
-0.0252630766,
-0.3310318589,
-1.1186311245,
-0.485357523,
-0.1461295485,
-0.0053132097,
-0.1612383425,
0.5306907892,
-0.0958241075,
0.7418390512,
-0.3991986215,
-0.3999222517,
-0.2326735854,
0.0197320562,
0.2070407122,
0.1475588679,
0.9123541117,
-0.9591239095,
-0.8835027814,
0.1869726926,
-0.613742888,
-0.0900870636,
-0.0517738871,
0.3596360981,
0.4058351219,
0.2305807769,
-0.6703867912,
0.267103821,
0.3640004396,
-0.4408207238,
0.795081377,
-0.4542716742,
0.4022183418,
-0.9302117825,
0.0332418792,
0.2385859936,
-0.6416845918,
-0.6218634248,
0.1534717381,
0.7167184949,
0.1886006445,
-0.3748189211,
0.2322172225,
-0.6011312008,
0.1408985108,
-0.7237486839,
-0.0033809433,
0.1682771295,
0.0355468057,
-0.1961384714,
0.5883479714,
0.640776217,
-0.8159860373,
0.4151699245,
-0.0326965749,
-0.7482584715,
1.0303680897,
-0.6719395518,
-0.1907214373,
-0.1654742807,
0.287299335,
-1.2743166685,
-0.2320199907,
-0.0361363143,
-0.3809506297,
0.5896748304,
0.0970627442,
-0.8479663134,
-0.6602950692,
-0.347040087,
0.1257983893,
0.1284706146,
-0.8559991717,
0.2746318281,
0.3567288816,
-0.3686932325,
-0.3706699312,
-0.8110738397,
0.4471545219,
-0.5932688117,
-0.3028394878,
0.4354935884,
0.249570787,
-0.3320304751,
-0.227706641,
-0.2061480433,
-0.2441301197,
-0.1834438592,
-0.0987908319,
0.1765879393,
-0.3119619489,
0.3388403356,
-0.1542448699,
-0.130002737,
0.1477601826,
-0.0795241818,
0.3163212836,
-0.0429260917,
-0.5200741291,
-0.5518596172,
0.3261033297,
0.8186285496,
-0.3261579573,
0.8439055085,
0.4334419668,
-0.6456081271,
-0.1562863737,
-1.1144818068,
0.1802277267,
-0.4453561008,
0.2561270893,
-0.343085736,
-0.8861666322,
0.2936940193,
-0.1787698567,
0.257011652,
0.8542049527,
0.4724404514,
0.1893011481,
0.7893941402,
0.8093402386,
-0.2949388921,
0.2140818387,
-0.004169859,
0.4196751714,
-0.2759002745,
-0.1678483188,
-0.9253403544,
-0.0778229237,
-0.2844332159,
-0.5217093229,
0.1832829565,
0.0230493117,
-0.0751181617,
0.5391666293,
-0.4627633095,
0.3923335671,
0.1236277372,
-0.0230638459,
0.7182354927,
0.3952792287,
0.0191899147,
-0.2660027742,
-0.5491582751,
-0.5289574862,
0.9699111581,
0.5652543902,
0.4870737791,
0.564977169,
0.2985308766,
0.6340889931,
0.411871016,
-0.6835481524,
0.1582993716,
-0.272469908,
-0.8084636927,
-0.1080196202,
-0.4016581774,
-0.9217323065,
0.5503653288,
-0.2490466982,
-0.730309844,
0.1571323723,
0.1479148865,
-0.4904074669,
0.6987401843,
-0.5950089693,
0.360658139,
-0.2748507559,
-0.1989882141,
-0.5822063684,
-0.1380373836,
0.5438646078,
-0.3808336258,
0.2855804563,
-0.1026673466,
0.2273302674,
0.5058608055,
-0.2299187332,
0.8043316007,
-0.098921068,
-0.7554807067,
0.5144051909,
0.1224061251,
0.5980839729,
-0.1297029704,
-0.3300567567,
0.1573475897,
0.2238051444,
-0.2658060491,
-0.1120927557,
0.7148677111,
-0.2168539762,
-0.2346873879,
-0.4947672188,
-0.2514002323,
-0.0909906626,
0.4890317321,
0.2741466463,
0.5801885128,
-0.41808182,
0.4274869263,
0.8629962802,
-0.4700027704,
0.3667255938,
1.0576332808,
-0.3330386281,
0.0110119432,
1.0654215813,
0.1734595001,
0.2418043762,
0.5097746849,
0.1704718322,
-0.7155992389,
-0.4488287568,
-0.4313127398,
0.3537008762,
-0.6077671051,
-0.5499238968,
-0.8845638633,
-0.132768482,
-0.4010964334,
0.4371124208,
-0.5077844262,
-0.2975093722,
0.4008614421,
-0.0013994293,
0.2272474617,
0.723724246,
-0.1537552476,
0.1646799892,
-0.7452251911,
0.5438839197,
0.2976868749,
0.3875668943,
-0.0609636642,
-0.5439953804,
-0.1841373444,
0.1521383524,
-0.3463515639,
-0.5587543845,
0.0524514839,
0.181716904,
0.6354387403,
0.4213784039,
0.0478478484,
0.2141980231,
-0.4306638241,
0.6072872877,
0.3143037558,
-0.6720970273,
0.0741831288,
-0.080061689,
0.2149818987,
0.5365394354,
0.5130186677,
-0.5885897279,
-0.0075346492,
-0.5994808078,
-0.6812697649,
0.4607972205,
-0.1301888376,
0.1201476976,
-0.0079337787,
0.2044385672,
0.338226378,
0.2905988693,
-0.7789332271,
0.0104684113,
0.3499627113,
0.0685667694,
-0.0101787113,
-0.6046286821,
-0.0532099232,
0.0986441225,
0.5837470889,
-0.2666185498,
0.1370708495,
0.1207088903,
-0.2604792416,
-0.0598960482,
0.5915850401,
0.4868682921,
0.8251096606,
0.1703567952,
0.160939768,
0.2759507895,
-0.3135607839,
0.0340459757,
0.0435236357,
-0.1564651728,
0.4607964456,
0.4540553093,
0.623254776,
0.0033925343,
-0.6240726113,
0.6678515673,
-0.1534500122,
-0.4157695174,
-0.1217736676,
-0.1738442332,
0.0118597606,
0.2657461166,
0.2729987204,
0.0492450036,
0.4217000604,
-0.4713334739,
0.1891435832,
0.6477434039,
-0.3132551014,
-0.1060369909,
0.6000137329,
-0.0908662975,
-0.111173965,
0.1078185141,
-0.1916723698,
-0.7114739418,
0.7959907055,
0.5165030956,
0.4610384405,
-0.1385293901,
0.5594182611,
0.5698076487,
0.50587672,
-0.456120044,
-0.1116838083,
-0.1368849725,
-0.6768143177,
-0.6501440406,
-0.4857726991,
-0.2312865108,
0.4495534599,
-0.729344368,
0.059680108,
-0.2002572864,
-0.2670189738,
0.2689357996,
0.1135847047,
-0.7077400088,
0.3295919895,
0.4398801327,
1.1370508671,
-0.6900006533,
0.6241767406,
0.7484351993,
0.0424809344,
-0.6466467977,
0.2497133166,
0.2737170458,
-0.4900608659,
0.4639379382,
0.5576886535,
-0.2031462342,
-0.3930689991,
-0.383046627,
-0.7165294886,
0.7503927946,
0.5183787942,
-0.8775675297,
0.3888433278,
0.2417920828,
0.5755633712,
0.0278886911,
0.070963636,
0.4769417048,
0.2919226587,
0.0826120973,
-1.4364517927,
0.0333537832,
0.0816332921,
-0.2226813287,
0.1524547786,
-0.808462739,
0.7965111136,
0.0789062381,
-0.3723781109,
0.0904175267,
0.556335628,
0.1970219463,
0.3549872041,
0.8193041086,
0.4084249437,
0.9842346907,
-0.1236271188,
1.2228523493,
-0.1132576168,
0.7182475328,
0.963455081,
-0.4329795539,
0.6528155804,
-0.0393365845,
-0.3837365806,
0.2540346384,
0.5386927724,
0.073834613,
0.2173035592,
0.2185147703,
-0.2084956169,
-0.3945842087,
-0.2716605663,
-0.5941408873,
0.4211702347,
0.3398726881,
-0.2392858118,
-0.5868321657,
0.0226362366,
0.050216835,
0.3411151767,
-0.3803046346,
0.4864522815,
-0.0119117396,
-0.9282845259,
0.7368667126,
0.3948112726,
1.0086401701,
-0.5776404142,
0.1756389737,
0.0063675791,
0.4711405039,
-0.2831760645,
-0.6568604112,
0.3116289675,
0.2483409792,
-0.2403964698,
0.0430405997,
1.1305423975,
-0.5683754683,
-0.4516298473,
0.2900369167,
0.5590786338,
0.0516558215,
-0.5307424068,
-0.8007065654,
0.0165861975,
0.0140018174,
0.0650889575,
0.2795433998,
0.5008690953,
-0.1867521256,
0.6973568201,
0.5355440378,
0.0331743322,
-0.1139632687,
0.2400359213,
0.6272752285,
-0.3559501767,
-0.5917391181,
-0.8223674893,
0.3867451847,
-0.439761728,
-0.0666382611,
1.017370224,
0.6359260082,
0.7100440264,
-0.050427299,
0.7026947141,
-0.1773782074,
0.8473547101,
-0.6030117273,
0.7499040961,
-0.7525301576,
0.1458205879,
-0.4558665752,
-1.0008969307,
-0.4793114066,
0.5474593639,
-0.3210445642,
-0.0184831433,
0.5793935657,
0.6561040878,
-0.2686724663,
0.0334786847,
0.4043807983,
0.221406579,
0.5549479723,
0.4442058206,
0.9294294715,
-0.3575888276,
0.3515206277,
0.0231896359,
-0.2384489328,
-0.2569007576,
-1.0208326578,
-0.9215658307,
-0.3076752424,
-0.7398911119,
-0.5396564007,
-0.4151396155,
0.441591382,
0.6258153319,
-1.0629268885,
0.315315485,
0.4042817354,
-0.0691656321,
-0.1097159013,
-0.216883257,
0.1326901466,
-0.1662484556,
-0.6412243247,
0.3187198937,
0.2737282813,
-0.1145453677,
-0.1927936375,
0.2145374119,
-0.3007945716,
0.1272114813,
0.8553749919,
0.397598654,
-0.6301227808,
-0.2644837499,
-0.2400000244,
-0.3511364162,
-0.0945470557,
0.7908254862,
-0.3591863811,
0.4236490428,
0.279818505,
0.76248914,
0.3907625079,
-0.0522702783,
0.2173447162,
-0.5576717257,
0.1145241112,
-0.2738051713,
0.5356526971,
0.570861578,
-0.4971597195,
0.4033229947,
-0.0897026137,
-0.494014293,
-0.9085534811,
0.1615469754,
-0.6975094676,
-0.5419611931,
1.1276450157,
-0.2106006444,
0.057237871,
-0.1401795,
-0.4215076268,
0.045007363,
-0.0808394849,
0.9660438299,
0.9936312437,
0.3430816531,
0.3281661272,
-0.7275379896,
0.1801946759,
0.6253818274,
-0.5435054898,
0.0730781406,
0.6087977886,
0.6118423939,
0.6483963728,
0.4814611375,
-0.2495510131,
0.2829549611,
-0.2754628956,
-0.1187105551,
0.0567026064,
-0.4785955846,
-0.4625754952,
0.291867137,
0.3022301495,
-0.1743722409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06102v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06102v1
|
Making LLMs Worth Every Penny: Resource-Limited Text Classification in Banking
| 2023-11-10T15:10:36 | 2023-11-10T15:10:36 |
Lefteris Loukas, Ilias Stogiannidis, Odysseas Diamantopoulos, Prodromos Malakasiotis, Stavros Vassos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Standard Full-Data classifiers in NLP demand thousands of labeled examples,
which is impractical in data-limited domains. Few-shot methods offer an
alternative, utilizing contrastive learning techniques that can be effective
with as little as 20 examples per class. Similarly, Large Language Models
(LLMs) like GPT-4 can perform effectively with just 1-5 examples per class.
However, the performance-cost trade-offs of these methods remain underexplored,
a critical concern for budget-limited organizations. Our work addresses this
gap by studying the aforementioned approaches over the Banking77 financial
intent detection dataset, including the evaluation of cutting-edge LLMs by
OpenAI, Cohere, and Anthropic in a comprehensive set of few-shot scenarios. We
complete the picture with two additional methods: first, a cost-effective
querying method for LLMs based on retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), able to
reduce operational costs multiple times compared to classic few-shot
approaches, and second, a data augmentation method using GPT-4, able to improve
performance in data-limited scenarios. Finally, to inspire future research, we
provide a human expert's curated subset of Banking77, along with extensive
error analysis.
|
[
-0.0637479872,
-0.430462867,
0.4872153699,
-0.1218131036,
-0.3708561659,
0.0927729905,
0.0205528475,
-0.6911379099,
-0.0900356472,
0.840256989,
-0.3096821606,
-0.4360237122,
-0.5641633868,
0.0510741211,
-0.2923358679,
1.2497547865,
0.1642595977,
-0.214894712,
0.0498489812,
-0.21055682,
-0.1200118437,
-0.4704271257,
-1.0637794733,
-0.2305682898,
0.5548512936,
0.5303174853,
0.4264339507,
0.6303765774,
0.8378964663,
0.2853039801,
-0.1701749265,
0.3134609759,
-0.5010176897,
-0.2794245481,
-0.052347932,
-0.6278663874,
-0.4301390946,
0.1272826344,
0.3868931234,
0.4420505762,
-0.017634578,
0.2947189808,
0.1880069077,
1.0008704662,
-0.6476550698,
0.3625151515,
-0.7494464517,
-0.0879408345,
-0.5702959299,
-0.2207244635,
-0.3514796793,
-0.1370377243,
0.3891776502,
-0.321369946,
0.2055104077,
0.1130627617,
0.6820548773,
0.1362393796,
-0.3281420171,
-0.4741949737,
-0.5235198736,
0.9192121029,
-0.4856721759,
0.1018321142,
0.5625014305,
0.3499462903,
-0.001259802,
-0.5366339087,
-0.2147556841,
0.0560375825,
-0.1513659358,
0.1513898969,
-0.3477928936,
0.2366724759,
0.2776971757,
0.4607125223,
-0.4474550188,
0.1369870305,
-0.469961077,
-0.1561492383,
0.548491776,
0.0085055903,
-0.1728130281,
-0.3248452544,
-0.3346401751,
-0.3040271103,
-0.6275581121,
0.1828656644,
0.5216104984,
0.5120678544,
0.119927153,
0.4826256633,
-0.0874742642,
0.8168815374,
-0.0432412066,
-0.6401359439,
-0.0532506034,
-0.4239614308,
-0.3707004786,
0.2025852054,
0.3622476757,
0.1874436885,
-0.0089864088,
0.0164757315,
-0.5165043473,
0.0516802184,
0.1066456586,
-0.6517668366,
0.0040879659,
0.2179794759,
-0.4424962997,
-0.4850431383,
-0.2569597065,
-0.806794703,
-0.592212379,
-0.1330338418,
0.251539737,
-0.385253191,
0.0456170291,
0.1056050137,
-0.201006487,
0.3291841745,
0.4280867279,
-0.9469499588,
0.2623104453,
0.8053498268,
0.9618803263,
-0.1476122439,
0.2136899531,
-0.4260280132,
0.2239801586,
-0.3220755756,
1.0167081356,
-0.4732407928,
-0.3723264635,
0.1363918632,
-0.4609385133,
0.1192523837,
-0.7526810169,
0.7974382639,
-0.4791160822,
0.0373106301,
-0.1363079548,
-0.6344414353,
-0.214300856,
0.3743679523,
-0.5774863958,
0.8026586771,
0.3916071653,
-0.6860046387,
0.5461162329,
-0.6129710674,
-0.1510458142,
0.3638595641,
-0.162818864,
-0.4903049767,
0.169616133,
-0.0454830006,
0.4336536527,
-0.3943300247,
0.1300634891,
-0.0722110048,
-0.4043904543,
0.3505051136,
-0.7160610557,
0.3406517506,
0.2024907023,
-0.2525284886,
-0.1305701286,
-0.9922791719,
-0.298004657,
0.0511124842,
-0.5610890388,
-0.5867978334,
-0.167166546,
0.0282320268,
-0.048155345,
0.1993626952,
-0.4041678309,
0.1826466024,
-0.6953552961,
0.1304806471,
0.9955922961,
-0.2182626277,
0.59929353,
-0.7104806304,
0.5091867447,
-0.1034206674,
0.1727731675,
-0.2202248424,
-0.3512406051,
-0.9142353535,
-0.6191048622,
0.1521756798,
0.5628206134,
-0.6275066733,
0.0247939639,
-0.0882486552,
-0.4920692444,
-0.4687148333,
0.4063406587,
0.3568201363,
0.494782269,
0.3625828028,
-0.1679263711,
-0.4303647578,
-1.030700326,
-0.4939042032,
-0.2621651292,
-0.1556247771,
0.6257759333,
0.1523625404,
-0.1576458961,
0.8197126389,
-0.5049729347,
-0.5959861875,
-0.454839915,
-0.0749386549,
0.6042994857,
0.1893471032,
0.6638067365,
-0.6568007469,
-0.3922075331,
0.0265592821,
-0.3682134748,
-0.0674780607,
-0.3872570992,
-0.0208644215,
0.4818767011,
0.0808423087,
-0.3488156796,
0.6017240882,
0.5333547592,
-0.2669519186,
0.1127087697,
-0.1212598532,
0.0712008998,
-0.819406569,
-0.1294559091,
0.2533147633,
-0.2862338126,
-0.6190773249,
-0.2207490653,
0.0322378092,
-0.1365525126,
-0.256713748,
0.6908223629,
-0.2147423625,
-0.2920667231,
-0.5885944366,
0.1345429271,
-0.1928075403,
0.4475140572,
-0.1435674876,
0.7123709321,
0.3741984963,
-0.6357833147,
0.1904535443,
0.1842775792,
-0.5294616222,
0.467115283,
-0.3377753198,
0.0059057074,
-0.0698277503,
0.2936278582,
-0.9758226871,
-0.2726790011,
0.2866922021,
-0.1828868389,
0.3986443579,
-0.4623860121,
-0.4290736318,
-0.1082504317,
-0.3878587484,
0.2835168242,
0.5130106807,
-0.8384385705,
0.7693544626,
0.1918834597,
-0.2946247458,
-0.633581996,
-0.8316637278,
0.0567122698,
-0.4713765681,
-0.4221235216,
0.293636471,
0.2441955656,
-0.2472839653,
-0.0750360414,
-0.4140995145,
-0.0146975601,
0.1878581643,
0.1442266405,
0.6520291567,
0.025879398,
0.2658269405,
-0.1282519996,
-0.3497907519,
-0.235396862,
-0.5287668109,
0.424189806,
-0.2441100776,
-0.4603274763,
-0.2044752836,
0.1805374622,
0.2203306407,
-0.122567609,
0.4998649657,
0.4700826108,
-0.1948619485,
-0.163778007,
-0.819696784,
0.2479825914,
-0.5563172698,
0.1269937307,
-0.2353971153,
-1.1225056648,
0.314578563,
-0.105244346,
0.3707219362,
0.3822374642,
0.3446519971,
0.0908335894,
0.4442365766,
0.6497923732,
-0.2460559905,
0.647898376,
-0.1509469897,
0.4434286058,
-0.3817357719,
-0.1202303991,
-0.4237924516,
-0.3005184531,
-0.8465782404,
-0.561649859,
0.4732859433,
0.0760861039,
0.0682255924,
0.2293604761,
-0.560667634,
0.6591866016,
0.5459698439,
0.1834435314,
0.3800474405,
0.0737126023,
0.2760643065,
0.166695714,
-0.6822041273,
-0.6499012709,
1.313931942,
0.3502504826,
0.797469914,
0.391879499,
1.0342018604,
0.2323098332,
0.5095745921,
-0.9922409058,
0.5003992319,
-0.3585851192,
-0.5879419446,
-0.2799038589,
-0.6706488132,
-0.9484295249,
0.1683680266,
-0.2095304579,
-0.5869634151,
0.1704367995,
0.3336225748,
-0.5743077993,
0.3866277635,
-0.6364473701,
0.6314697266,
-0.5171166062,
-0.5416647792,
-0.3132723868,
-0.1971706897,
0.577691257,
-0.5033960342,
0.307557106,
-0.1623897702,
-0.3978759348,
0.6733539104,
-0.162767306,
0.7876123786,
0.0242369063,
-0.0683890805,
0.4579586983,
-0.1227231994,
0.6253537536,
0.0250854325,
0.0198221598,
0.0559584945,
-0.1562791765,
-0.6227243543,
-0.3345359266,
0.6789803505,
-0.4050416946,
-0.5119977593,
-0.6409099698,
-0.412114054,
-0.3280768394,
0.0772633106,
-0.1229856461,
0.3497483134,
0.1078762487,
0.2488216907,
0.7217230797,
-0.447568953,
0.5839400291,
0.448846221,
-0.0373414569,
-0.4725568295,
0.8979383111,
0.0988653153,
0.2172615081,
0.4184662402,
0.5073994398,
-0.3585563302,
-0.6470471621,
-0.1351207048,
0.3144732416,
-0.7267784476,
-0.4184798896,
-0.6199235916,
0.0762925595,
-0.5968703032,
-0.3873818219,
-0.280352205,
-0.4188738465,
-0.1876782626,
-0.2509792447,
0.5587821603,
0.4677606821,
-0.2707283199,
0.4744330943,
-1.1368528605,
0.1873923242,
0.4170862138,
0.5031291246,
0.0506376177,
-0.6040608883,
-0.3097241223,
-0.5089045167,
-0.1559283286,
-0.6070684791,
0.4263118804,
0.1184596419,
0.644611001,
0.6185544133,
0.0447080992,
0.5921132565,
-0.1592690349,
0.4605918229,
0.2473707646,
-0.7701860666,
0.4061353207,
-0.2610740662,
0.1499647498,
0.7848308682,
0.4307079911,
-0.5026886463,
-0.0413303077,
-0.7474399805,
-1.040921092,
0.913590312,
0.1752343476,
0.0793377534,
0.1220005825,
0.4721309543,
0.0460623279,
0.1268311888,
-0.705531776,
-0.173839435,
0.1401407272,
-0.1954893172,
-0.0249846224,
-0.5593707561,
-0.090781413,
-0.0160455704,
0.6616479754,
-0.2296287566,
0.0307463519,
0.0840180367,
0.0958613977,
0.195170477,
0.5251239538,
0.5500270128,
0.5164232254,
-0.3805101812,
0.0170974806,
0.2513454556,
-0.2732876241,
0.0589558035,
0.0924858153,
-0.1488789469,
0.1102880538,
0.3589171469,
0.805909276,
0.1845524609,
-0.9333904386,
0.5650316477,
0.0962516516,
-0.221411109,
-0.3353100419,
0.0197788496,
-0.1051117331,
0.5832203031,
0.3841301799,
0.0143575966,
0.3288502693,
-0.6128438711,
0.140991509,
0.3171626627,
-0.2184696347,
0.1229753047,
0.1785784662,
0.2140628994,
-0.1054580584,
0.4727399647,
-0.1859482378,
-0.4130751491,
0.3207761645,
0.2992004752,
0.99658674,
-0.0026248051,
0.1522861868,
0.3262752891,
0.2768561542,
-0.3624485433,
0.0052453075,
-0.3745759726,
-0.6287780404,
-0.4292257428,
-0.9046095014,
-0.7207407355,
0.1444386691,
-0.513987124,
0.4249619842,
-0.6759534478,
-0.0295202471,
0.0309904534,
0.0102519486,
-0.7253420353,
-0.073311314,
0.2341524661,
0.814724803,
-0.6373080611,
0.618191123,
0.4540514052,
-0.3543788195,
-0.5211294889,
-0.3033772707,
0.0510220714,
-0.8830115199,
0.7690083981,
0.2357925624,
-0.0674158558,
-0.2788527608,
-0.4503847361,
-0.675889492,
0.8917970061,
0.0520491824,
-0.8195469975,
-0.2575830519,
0.1531036645,
0.3944419324,
-0.0645493343,
0.0547792017,
0.8679166436,
0.5434727669,
0.2849037349,
-0.6854668856,
-0.356261909,
0.3399876654,
-0.205714047,
0.3104264736,
-0.6853361726,
0.5568929911,
-0.0722338632,
-0.2098533362,
-0.188888073,
0.3376820982,
0.4440097511,
0.6797814965,
0.5684399605,
0.5562285781,
0.7501427531,
-0.0828353316,
1.2631499767,
-0.0903462842,
0.3168980479,
0.8995250463,
-0.1867287904,
0.8062567711,
0.410599649,
-0.3860505819,
-0.0300680548,
0.7513105869,
-0.1301418692,
0.4226090908,
0.2774422169,
-0.5610138178,
-0.4047919214,
-0.2876439989,
0.0793628097,
0.567939043,
0.4410344958,
-0.2939596772,
-0.3244372904,
-0.0496366099,
-0.1100481898,
-0.0994609818,
-0.4099078476,
1.0222027302,
0.268923521,
-0.3613424897,
0.2051742077,
-0.0211160388,
1.0250012875,
-0.8612751961,
0.0737286583,
-0.4274559021,
0.3802308142,
-0.2892095745,
-0.5135295987,
0.3014545441,
0.4612742662,
0.0088597219,
-0.49853912,
1.0453497171,
-0.2322424501,
-0.4747360349,
0.1013877913,
0.3225239515,
0.2828740776,
-0.1521754265,
-0.5610106587,
-0.1505239457,
-0.0105347252,
-0.0887506679,
0.6846632361,
0.5966827869,
0.1658866256,
0.5543772578,
0.8372367024,
0.1869030595,
-0.2092140317,
-0.0736491308,
0.7943258882,
-0.8641476631,
-0.3773066401,
-1.0108571053,
0.0396980196,
-0.1803580225,
-0.2326329798,
0.6833017468,
0.8024641871,
1.1812905073,
0.1209872887,
0.8018359542,
0.4412572384,
0.6068129539,
-0.6232209206,
0.2489712387,
-0.4730190933,
0.5667792559,
-0.265407443,
-0.7728707194,
-0.3072213829,
0.6474904418,
-0.3944659531,
-0.201768145,
0.4438330829,
0.5664666295,
0.1806798279,
-0.0839512423,
0.5894377232,
-0.3976230919,
0.4350342453,
0.5467705131,
0.7930832505,
-0.2874783874,
1.0676512718,
-0.2455241978,
-0.2282765955,
-0.4152064919,
-0.7658287883,
-0.8329743147,
0.0345497988,
-0.29970783,
-0.3267017603,
-0.1118531227,
1.0699970722,
0.3109592795,
-0.698523283,
-0.3162144125,
0.0495645255,
0.2068863809,
0.0166954566,
-0.2203471363,
0.3244797289,
-0.5620619655,
-0.7226135135,
0.3493694365,
0.748231411,
0.3848906755,
-0.0844633803,
0.1959910989,
0.0237178802,
0.2537462711,
0.6771328449,
0.1581449062,
-0.5131473541,
-0.0987104848,
-0.0713664144,
-0.1090362817,
-0.0187439229,
1.0521810055,
-0.468403399,
0.2349956036,
0.5288286209,
1.3597648144,
0.6088863611,
0.0759743527,
0.0614823215,
-0.5934206843,
0.0882282332,
0.4448258579,
0.2698505521,
0.2461690307,
-0.3585235178,
0.7717095017,
0.3088173866,
-0.6761868,
-0.7133094072,
0.1271637827,
-1.1229091883,
-0.3148933649,
1.1678165197,
-0.043279741,
-0.2932594419,
-0.1635515243,
-0.2763311863,
-0.130209595,
-0.6573833227,
0.7386621237,
0.7195287943,
-0.4535188973,
-0.1909787506,
-0.6474480629,
0.7284217477,
0.3134875596,
-0.7605551481,
0.1223655641,
0.6176150441,
-0.0779974088,
0.1891845167,
0.8024260402,
-0.0284203794,
0.0340255313,
0.1156754941,
-0.2230768204,
0.0079513788,
-0.1388796866,
-0.3084638715,
0.1111200601,
0.2268392444,
-0.1611862481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06062v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06062v3
|
Practical Membership Inference Attacks against Fine-tuned Large Language Models via Self-prompt Calibration
| 2023-11-10T13:55:05 | 2024-06-25T12:36:02 |
Wenjie Fu, Huandong Wang, Chen Gao, Guanghua Liu, Yong Li, Tao Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Membership Inference Attacks (MIA) aim to infer whether a target data record
has been utilized for model training or not. Prior attempts have quantified the
privacy risks of language models (LMs) via MIAs, but there is still no
consensus on whether existing MIA algorithms can cause remarkable privacy
leakage on practical Large Language Models (LLMs). Existing MIAs designed for
LMs can be classified into two categories: reference-free and reference-based
attacks. They are both based on the hypothesis that training records
consistently strike a higher probability of being sampled. Nevertheless, this
hypothesis heavily relies on the overfitting of target models, which will be
mitigated by multiple regularization methods and the generalization of LLMs.
The reference-based attack seems to achieve promising effectiveness in LLMs,
which measures a more reliable membership signal by comparing the probability
discrepancy between the target model and the reference model. However, the
performance of reference-based attack is highly dependent on a reference
dataset that closely resembles the training dataset, which is usually
inaccessible in the practical scenario. Overall, existing MIAs are unable to
effectively unveil privacy leakage over practical fine-tuned LLMs that are
overfitting-free and private. We propose a Membership Inference Attack based on
Self-calibrated Probabilistic Variation (SPV-MIA). Specifically, since
memorization in LLMs is inevitable during the training process and occurs
before overfitting, we introduce a more reliable membership signal,
probabilistic variation, which is based on memorization rather than
overfitting. Furthermore, we introduce a self-prompt approach, which constructs
the dataset to fine-tune the reference model by prompting the target LLM
itself. In this manner, the adversary can collect a dataset with a similar
distribution from public APIs.
|
[
-0.2259715796,
-0.5574218631,
0.5155587792,
-0.3349271119,
-0.2195436656,
0.0697774589,
0.2137475163,
-0.4071033597,
0.1063681766,
0.5948797464,
-1.0096839666,
-0.4735881984,
-0.3228526711,
-0.0351322144,
-0.2742441595,
0.7190032601,
0.3943637609,
0.1155874133,
-0.1534623802,
-0.2719581425,
-0.4893614948,
-0.9242881536,
-0.0498773307,
-0.0612239316,
0.5112095475,
0.1180229783,
0.5934992433,
0.5718594193,
0.3512112498,
0.2928729057,
0.105193764,
0.0458979756,
-0.4406649768,
0.1730678827,
-0.3872332275,
-0.9237188697,
-0.2803944349,
0.0406446643,
0.5741205812,
0.4823464751,
-0.1636190116,
0.1707675755,
-0.1028662175,
0.7751123309,
-0.9463099241,
0.0190609992,
-0.8572919965,
-0.0860325322,
-0.3340080082,
-0.1374072284,
-0.5081692338,
-0.235451445,
0.0346628278,
-0.1919758022,
0.3919075131,
-0.0185950994,
0.7310203314,
0.3218798637,
-0.2911914587,
-0.2098160684,
-0.450747937,
0.8318409324,
-0.9527279735,
0.5896585584,
0.7008461356,
0.4791230261,
-0.4419880211,
-0.3491943479,
-0.3994917572,
-0.39025563,
0.0688532814,
-0.0060971682,
-0.0331558809,
0.150032565,
0.2388230264,
0.4520243108,
-0.4423914254,
0.1985603869,
-0.2498999536,
-0.151783675,
0.6348217726,
0.0391655453,
0.0706489012,
-0.1931136698,
-0.5617278814,
0.1209860146,
-0.9739997983,
-0.205064714,
0.624384582,
0.3492731154,
-0.1929674,
0.3645761311,
-0.2708444595,
0.6825420856,
0.1329853684,
0.0050691389,
0.033824522,
-0.3033877611,
-0.3155248761,
-0.1723297834,
0.8103163242,
0.0484878346,
0.2786102295,
-0.3741791248,
-0.0909463391,
-0.0997480527,
0.0410563089,
-0.7727522254,
-0.1542274505,
0.3124117255,
-0.3004882336,
-0.3198536038,
0.3879234493,
-0.8141143918,
-0.4882411957,
-0.1241683587,
0.4937490821,
-0.3455381095,
0.0175776407,
0.2258677483,
0.1957020462,
-0.0491518192,
0.2123967111,
-0.8115490675,
0.0532887094,
0.7863735557,
0.7320186496,
0.0951396897,
-0.2392096072,
-0.5748260021,
0.2870304883,
-0.1938683242,
0.4509644806,
-0.4630359411,
-0.5588935018,
0.0469696932,
-0.1920535564,
-0.2105595469,
-0.4179184437,
0.1869141906,
-0.7860254049,
0.1520969868,
-0.295019567,
-0.8329514265,
0.0711442456,
0.37411654,
-0.5995661616,
0.7822842598,
0.066027388,
-0.7570006847,
0.1706624627,
-0.3336211741,
0.1908715516,
-0.2022812665,
-0.3710954487,
-0.3626490235,
0.2203585804,
0.0531315468,
0.4804929197,
-0.2589720786,
0.0357023217,
-0.6562787294,
-0.2112305909,
0.7929397821,
-0.6146915555,
0.8170063496,
0.4070766866,
-0.3261123896,
-0.1342081577,
-0.9366931915,
0.0271142069,
0.0184217524,
-0.1888529658,
-0.4544095695,
0.2822539508,
-0.785862565,
0.0429125689,
0.3172853589,
-0.5538073778,
0.2911171019,
-0.6566863656,
0.2042556554,
0.8664036393,
0.3525808454,
0.3790712059,
-0.3635789454,
0.5954784751,
-0.1363431513,
0.3430155814,
-0.4167356491,
-0.2789093852,
-0.5219119191,
-0.5526081324,
0.5213348866,
0.3618197143,
-0.4868841767,
0.5824890137,
-0.1662725657,
-0.6318399906,
-0.4765049517,
0.0254430119,
0.5360305905,
0.3004622161,
0.3200884461,
-0.3042419553,
-0.0254591405,
-0.7434339523,
-0.4262173474,
-0.3044793308,
-0.1956508905,
0.3534187376,
0.3046751022,
-0.1015295088,
1.0944256783,
-0.4955151379,
-0.455748558,
0.1112388149,
0.0135859288,
0.1358224601,
0.7171038985,
0.7862823606,
-0.4459576309,
-0.3338850141,
-0.3398620486,
-0.5470821261,
-0.1752269119,
-0.4846018851,
0.0867614299,
0.0656634197,
0.4392325878,
-0.6102560163,
0.5528772473,
0.6033255458,
-0.3870927989,
0.5270338655,
-0.1173035726,
-0.1712583005,
-1.0772873163,
-0.1157586947,
-0.3275977671,
-0.3391392827,
-0.6124889851,
0.640075922,
0.2012716383,
-0.0637978464,
-0.4730495811,
0.5055567622,
-0.6188777685,
-0.0046645054,
-0.1540596038,
-0.4017769098,
-0.0455419272,
0.4961355925,
-0.271297276,
0.8150209188,
0.6091120243,
-0.5043923855,
0.0500991531,
0.0721366256,
-0.2957657874,
0.3501437902,
-0.3918445408,
0.5391762853,
-0.0319796205,
0.3099072874,
-0.8987450004,
-0.2036788613,
0.5161828995,
-0.675198257,
0.5244092941,
-0.2794786394,
-0.4446423352,
0.027745083,
-0.5610820651,
0.291580677,
0.1244866028,
-0.6148414612,
0.6498152018,
0.161873728,
0.2342993766,
-0.9787861109,
-0.8478894234,
-0.004309467,
-0.2898464799,
-0.347438097,
0.0775010884,
-0.3971401155,
-0.0188313462,
-0.3780967295,
-0.5075947046,
-0.3000813425,
0.420815587,
0.3327048719,
0.1125175357,
-0.0792678222,
-0.103737399,
-0.2697715163,
-0.0734019652,
0.256462723,
-0.0395536311,
0.5623766184,
0.0236796904,
-0.8200799227,
-0.8798541427,
0.5074505806,
0.646358192,
-0.3625746369,
0.8848004937,
0.050558906,
-0.1698727757,
-0.3515841365,
-0.7534015775,
-0.4727238417,
-0.581038177,
0.3094384968,
-0.3786719143,
-0.6630275846,
0.7146246433,
-0.0219020657,
0.2951181829,
-0.0073472434,
0.3503233194,
-0.120129928,
0.8624219894,
0.4155039787,
-0.330201596,
0.6347436309,
-0.2375472486,
-0.0037145398,
-0.3692925274,
-0.2120180577,
-0.8635467887,
-0.0503247306,
-0.5843690634,
-0.4772906005,
-0.0937372968,
0.06466268,
-0.1021210104,
0.3648853302,
-0.0872775912,
0.6577446461,
0.6525213122,
0.1476971358,
0.1857652068,
-0.0385542326,
-0.1112071574,
-0.2303217202,
-0.6053135395,
-0.2244697213,
1.1642044783,
0.5984540582,
1.1798359156,
0.3059452772,
0.9756428003,
0.2868117988,
0.2085252851,
-0.7961006165,
0.5690789223,
0.2488036007,
-0.8422530293,
-0.0710947812,
-0.6434674859,
-0.7517879605,
0.1790302694,
-0.1315318644,
-0.908544898,
0.9097705483,
0.3747580349,
-0.352789551,
0.2896065712,
-0.5994586945,
0.7255017757,
-0.1009159163,
-0.3044732213,
-0.0692671835,
-0.8663499951,
0.3279221952,
-0.4371629953,
0.2702880204,
-0.1700033098,
0.0824167356,
0.3795482516,
-0.4958362877,
1.2897651196,
-0.3261417747,
0.0459256396,
0.1568620205,
0.4986521006,
0.6003329754,
0.1661480814,
-0.2558465004,
0.4403200448,
0.1233477369,
-0.3404963613,
-0.6931872368,
0.4302506745,
-0.7727615833,
-0.8687776327,
-0.5990523696,
-0.3618756533,
-0.3969668746,
0.0525243059,
0.2075784355,
0.3924069107,
-0.0798931345,
0.5269291997,
0.5356628299,
-0.0080123069,
0.2163827121,
0.9212873578,
0.0962123796,
-0.4645528197,
0.9262846708,
0.0814651549,
0.6551839709,
0.3266499937,
0.1699124873,
-0.246339649,
-0.7347314954,
-0.2534844279,
0.444543153,
-0.5770534277,
-0.5474905372,
-0.2828164399,
-0.0942867249,
-0.3437560797,
0.0914246738,
-0.5632873178,
-0.4439940751,
-0.4153390229,
-0.0260958523,
0.0227707922,
0.2343083322,
-0.0754560903,
0.7333764434,
-1.019900918,
0.1128432006,
0.3087815344,
0.1581453979,
-0.2337230891,
-0.6339954734,
-0.1138176247,
0.0260820128,
-0.2845507264,
-1.3914628029,
0.3046705425,
0.3920358121,
0.6134685278,
0.8982608914,
0.3747603893,
0.6721898913,
-0.5685212612,
0.682795167,
0.0970185548,
-0.8684763312,
0.3204697669,
-0.3632817268,
0.043445114,
0.9462582469,
0.2706598341,
-0.206973657,
-0.55530864,
-0.8507852554,
-0.5851686597,
0.8462908268,
0.240268603,
0.3965523541,
-0.0004304803,
0.6076510549,
-0.1132365391,
0.326310724,
-0.7368610501,
-0.5393037796,
-0.1026773974,
-0.0385092609,
0.2388276458,
-0.3454808593,
-0.1897751391,
0.112009719,
0.5752469897,
-0.1577579677,
0.1892726272,
0.2263009548,
0.058500845,
-0.0220393557,
0.1945479363,
0.2692173421,
0.7288413644,
-0.3551668525,
-0.0909147784,
0.1648406982,
-0.2951640189,
0.0782421827,
0.0611053407,
-0.3378758729,
0.1351158023,
0.3386758864,
0.5763962865,
0.1920989156,
-0.5824689865,
0.7154359221,
-0.1655427516,
-0.1135286465,
-0.2716473639,
0.3930362463,
0.0434819721,
0.1082707644,
0.3467663825,
0.1370820552,
0.0069965515,
-0.7284924984,
0.3540625572,
0.7563865185,
-0.3998193741,
-0.4583888054,
0.6160755157,
0.0206903648,
-0.4075824618,
0.2472671717,
0.2298956364,
-0.453589648,
0.6012954712,
0.6034661531,
0.6960011721,
-0.9505759478,
-0.0122381765,
0.1992202997,
0.3093933463,
0.138694495,
0.0472711064,
-0.3694430888,
-0.6609507799,
-0.0664658546,
-0.4720418751,
-0.5050368905,
0.3519648015,
-0.931247592,
0.0354798809,
-0.7566350698,
-0.1112394631,
-0.283631742,
-0.0817043632,
-0.3259801269,
0.2579400837,
-0.0352662429,
0.9414673448,
-0.6407455206,
0.9984899759,
0.1947856992,
-0.1179083511,
-0.6548159122,
0.1830084473,
0.1839782,
-0.7260499597,
0.4026807249,
0.2224186361,
-0.0480348431,
-0.2335013151,
-0.4161942601,
-0.9446780682,
0.8297749758,
0.7619566917,
-0.7863593102,
-0.3361409009,
0.3210179806,
0.2210908532,
-0.0218927339,
-0.1311837733,
0.5462622046,
0.1576688886,
0.0599038899,
-0.6638373733,
-0.0530854352,
0.2853471637,
-0.3709501922,
0.1107868403,
-0.7721009254,
0.8348708749,
0.0025273662,
-0.3384114802,
0.2163264006,
0.9369738102,
0.4430626333,
0.2033610642,
0.5993221402,
0.3068713844,
0.8226805329,
0.2761308253,
0.9700020552,
-0.3956062496,
0.5047536492,
1.5676012039,
-0.2875553668,
0.8093064427,
0.3957287073,
-0.1682000607,
0.2130106091,
0.5455998778,
-0.0538730919,
0.6542355418,
0.1831716597,
-0.5435352921,
-0.3331426978,
0.3269034326,
-0.6421200037,
0.4597482681,
0.4696346223,
-0.4573339224,
-0.4122090042,
-0.3552559018,
0.1733087152,
0.0550158694,
-0.0389315002,
0.8108549714,
0.2747097015,
-0.35865587,
0.4212462604,
0.1128232554,
0.4345676005,
-1.0530701876,
0.1937836111,
-0.265294373,
0.2483472228,
-0.0266978759,
-0.1026935056,
0.1514669806,
0.0134643745,
0.1176838726,
0.0592544898,
0.4605766833,
-0.2197183669,
-0.3378731012,
0.2154458612,
0.4468144178,
0.1536286324,
-0.1880348325,
-0.9020827413,
-0.2664648592,
0.1429866999,
-0.5418388247,
0.6750398874,
0.2553871274,
0.1182374284,
0.7488957047,
0.8096157312,
0.3023673892,
0.0926756188,
0.0308541358,
0.9753830433,
-0.3735201359,
-0.8314613104,
-1.1198729277,
0.1507017463,
0.0107798167,
-0.1326368898,
0.8406256437,
0.4776927829,
0.776142776,
-0.0220606066,
0.3519132137,
0.431994319,
0.5694374442,
-0.7213317156,
0.9032384157,
-0.5003522038,
0.5318569541,
-0.1348475367,
-0.715546608,
-0.4312521517,
0.5560736656,
-0.198672235,
0.0408914015,
0.5180084109,
1.1629576683,
-0.1043309644,
-0.1095642671,
0.4742285907,
0.1956200302,
0.5338720679,
0.1784896851,
0.7868821025,
-0.2172933519,
0.4026442766,
-0.2511782646,
-0.1717375368,
-0.1487960368,
-0.9482513666,
-1.2142031193,
-0.249820888,
-0.1799379736,
-0.3559095562,
0.2323649079,
0.9343184233,
0.8403373361,
-0.9011864662,
0.0314835384,
-0.1000408679,
-0.1973039508,
0.06783171,
-0.1991788298,
0.4980594218,
-0.2113211155,
-0.726293087,
0.8573697805,
-0.2082202435,
0.1527359188,
-0.429697454,
0.1494766623,
-0.1315301806,
0.4638909101,
-0.0700669512,
0.549877882,
-0.6693636179,
-0.3609071076,
-0.2151329964,
0.0290910266,
0.0899539515,
0.8163439035,
-0.7126895785,
0.53236866,
0.3946497738,
0.8772954345,
0.1793026328,
0.3550881445,
0.5507801175,
-1.1285920143,
0.2679107189,
0.3065618575,
0.5229800344,
0.1220943481,
-0.641282618,
0.32902053,
0.3577820659,
-0.5626421571,
-1.0931333303,
0.4781843722,
-0.8604040146,
-0.4808241129,
0.8572139144,
-0.631383121,
-0.453655839,
-0.1761262715,
-0.1118496731,
0.0361420177,
-0.41436854,
1.047930479,
0.4712424874,
0.222665593,
0.2347706109,
-0.5976205468,
0.504394412,
0.5923631191,
-0.6788634658,
0.4884866178,
0.6799955964,
0.5385612845,
0.1898402572,
0.5106344819,
-0.0693282187,
0.4267705977,
-0.2338367552,
-0.2665731013,
-0.4519899786,
-0.4602342844,
-0.5933277011,
0.3285919428,
0.0255436618,
-0.3977009058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07598v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07598v1
|
Multi-Label Topic Model for Financial Textual Data
| 2023-11-10T12:56:07 | 2023-11-10T12:56:07 |
Moritz Scherrmann
|
q-fin.ST
|
q-fin.ST, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a multi-label topic model for financial texts like ad-hoc
announcements, 8-K filings, finance related news or annual reports. I train the
model on a new financial multi-label database consisting of 3,044 German ad-hoc
announcements that are labeled manually using 20 predefined, economically
motivated topics. The best model achieves a macro F1 score of more than 85%.
Translating the data results in an English version of the model with similar
performance. As application of the model, I investigate differences in stock
market reactions across topics. I find evidence for strong positive or negative
market reactions for some topics, like announcements of new Large Scale
Projects or Bankruptcy Filings, while I do not observe significant price
effects for some other topics. Furthermore, in contrast to previous studies,
the multi-label structure of the model allows to analyze the effects of
co-occurring topics on stock market reactions. For many cases, the reaction to
a specific topic depends heavily on the co-occurrence with other topics. For
example, if allocated capital from a Seasoned Equity Offering (SEO) is used for
restructuring a company in the course of a Bankruptcy Proceeding, the market
reacts positively on average. However, if that capital is used for covering
unexpected, additional costs from the development of new drugs, the SEO implies
negative reactions on average.
|
[
-0.4235517383,
-0.8119572997,
0.2805812359,
0.5680106282,
-0.2243021578,
-0.0321394466,
-0.1212083846,
-0.4092811048,
0.7189882398,
0.4272535741,
-0.2347050458,
-0.6235198379,
-0.597633183,
-0.225569576,
-0.582768023,
1.5594531298,
0.0024423462,
0.1051949486,
0.1310122907,
0.0723223314,
-0.3811412156,
-0.7865225077,
-0.8030721545,
-0.2685928345,
0.6804024577,
0.1671478152,
0.410923481,
0.5531016588,
0.7303611636,
0.2347261757,
-0.207238555,
-0.4672566056,
-0.2831637859,
0.0836906582,
-0.0635442361,
0.0606752597,
-0.9297703505,
0.2526240349,
0.2783818841,
0.4678725302,
-0.2289688289,
0.1233139336,
-0.0677755848,
0.6422929764,
-0.5026791096,
0.4548732042,
-0.4516260922,
-0.1725292206,
-0.1909514666,
-0.2839634717,
-0.58794415,
-0.1080815494,
0.4445127845,
-0.6091340184,
0.1724521071,
0.076262407,
0.9321973324,
-0.1544550359,
-0.9056483507,
-0.7838727832,
-0.4037821591,
0.5747382641,
-0.3437471092,
0.4436479807,
0.211139217,
-0.0489815064,
0.1635210812,
-0.5852553248,
0.0062476504,
-0.161278531,
-0.163827762,
0.1275523752,
-0.2670845389,
-0.0765173808,
0.031622991,
0.5254758596,
-0.4135103524,
-0.0297792777,
-0.4797565341,
-0.2723356187,
0.5983801484,
0.0735416636,
-0.0185859576,
-0.0745277107,
-0.7414907813,
-0.2507838011,
-0.4981645048,
-0.1447081864,
0.7649492621,
0.5164840817,
-0.1891176254,
0.5872715116,
-0.1168890297,
0.5609904528,
0.0519017391,
-0.2238726169,
0.3414335549,
-0.5526795387,
0.0294945259,
0.4581494331,
0.4282963276,
0.5222139955,
-0.0913198292,
0.1681067646,
-0.3112655878,
0.1183213592,
0.1992391646,
-0.7752671838,
-0.3186930716,
0.2489951998,
-0.6270025373,
-0.2105873674,
0.2069731206,
-0.9621365666,
-0.1950756907,
-0.4051577151,
0.4587681592,
-0.1479118615,
-0.0257725511,
0.2805960774,
-0.4703596234,
0.20920524,
0.2859101892,
-0.510201335,
0.2748636901,
0.7333728075,
0.4798854887,
0.0975417122,
-0.2239557505,
-0.6037167311,
0.382674396,
-0.3250186443,
1.0320622921,
-0.320638299,
-0.4280459583,
-0.203119874,
-0.1382645667,
-0.0917084068,
-0.3183068931,
0.3660610616,
-0.6769753098,
0.288082689,
-0.1958811581,
-0.7513319254,
-0.0896728337,
0.0900018588,
-0.7338767648,
0.4992630184,
-0.3308279216,
-0.9234512448,
0.4620786011,
-1.1128338575,
-0.5138394237,
-0.3958750665,
0.0618526563,
-0.403183341,
-0.3027356565,
0.0049748961,
0.1448423117,
-0.4110530317,
0.8026165366,
-0.519420743,
-0.0037305821,
0.6128927469,
-0.3884947896,
0.3430891335,
0.1834004521,
-0.1175537407,
0.2127569318,
-0.8585074544,
-0.5616325736,
-0.1074461266,
-0.25286448,
-0.8253078461,
-0.081085369,
0.1617105901,
0.2437053919,
0.4755290747,
-0.2813847363,
0.2129162252,
-0.3550772965,
0.1815023273,
0.6908032894,
0.5439488888,
0.2395450175,
-0.127861321,
0.3184862137,
0.4705197513,
0.0481916629,
-0.5963479877,
-0.57666713,
-0.5484996438,
-0.3683299422,
0.5807120204,
0.5836021304,
-0.0766422749,
0.1273023188,
0.4825775027,
-0.2994272709,
-0.2763666511,
-0.4584094286,
0.2053205818,
0.4365850687,
0.3228074014,
-0.1884441376,
-0.4751625955,
-1.3032329082,
-0.302819699,
-0.1958290488,
0.1780540198,
0.2382218242,
0.6087654233,
-0.1247500479,
0.7044628859,
-1.3624513149,
-0.1537567228,
0.2568565905,
0.9999811053,
0.3618733287,
0.3272662163,
0.7207220197,
-0.9524562359,
-0.3352742493,
0.0409107059,
-0.2686620355,
0.1073206961,
-0.2834236026,
-0.0544077232,
0.1893457174,
0.3453521132,
-0.3370961249,
0.4201182723,
0.2110290825,
-0.5886639953,
0.3603242934,
-0.4564538598,
0.2153594494,
-1.3316187859,
0.0573275015,
0.6254748106,
0.2969252765,
-0.6593071222,
-0.3324471414,
0.0124910409,
-0.3857299685,
-0.3719128072,
0.9053340554,
-0.2008867562,
-0.1442552954,
-0.2628031373,
-0.070706442,
0.0299585424,
0.4094828963,
0.086904034,
0.6822146177,
0.6087707281,
-0.6723645926,
0.2707918584,
0.2357467413,
-0.0109340195,
0.3003745377,
-0.3939136267,
-0.2400466204,
-0.2401378602,
0.3586396575,
-1.3867930174,
-0.2746492028,
0.240576908,
-0.2814071476,
0.281080097,
0.168986842,
-0.1401309967,
-0.3627645373,
-0.4610531032,
0.0155662727,
-0.1790884137,
-0.055886291,
0.2107152343,
0.460608691,
-0.7349355221,
-0.4613875449,
-0.474146992,
0.1182033792,
-0.6626595855,
-0.4356665015,
0.4016488791,
-0.242911607,
-0.2861117721,
0.2534658611,
-0.1038548723,
-0.4747248888,
0.0544408672,
-0.1306595504,
0.4901515245,
-0.2544437349,
0.2921834588,
-0.1158189178,
-0.656288743,
-0.0203592423,
-0.2057405263,
0.1348405182,
-0.267426908,
0.0156941861,
-0.2368923128,
0.640961051,
0.5453341007,
-0.3029707074,
1.0465813875,
0.2815219462,
-0.4327449501,
0.3796429634,
-0.1629002839,
-0.2360478193,
-0.3906733692,
0.3474995792,
-0.3412887156,
-0.5960959196,
0.7823275328,
-0.1054460853,
-0.0339599662,
0.971897006,
0.7561017871,
-0.0933236256,
0.7688468099,
0.6836494207,
0.0774894953,
0.331076622,
-0.0884338319,
0.5965688229,
-0.2491871566,
-0.2248319238,
-0.7470026612,
-0.3823846877,
-0.638307929,
-0.0131744202,
0.4222747386,
0.0129957199,
-0.0587797724,
0.5274409652,
-0.2194247842,
0.2332396656,
0.4509147108,
-0.2511012852,
0.3823839426,
-0.0321188942,
0.0304260124,
-0.2160333842,
-0.3802699745,
-0.3415973186,
1.1323540211,
0.49000597,
0.8074883819,
-0.085739024,
0.6572893262,
0.3498538136,
0.8089043498,
-0.4979618788,
0.1425779909,
-0.4409141541,
-0.9389870167,
-0.3158077896,
-0.4878262579,
-0.6429943442,
0.1063833982,
-0.1194469407,
-0.5853954554,
0.4621560872,
0.0144790635,
-0.3465425074,
-0.1121409386,
-0.960052371,
1.0205973387,
-0.2221227139,
0.094183296,
-0.130423367,
-0.3589596748,
0.5738182068,
-0.8150526285,
0.4536963999,
-0.2577452064,
-0.1106948107,
0.9492652416,
-0.0688852444,
0.8367663026,
0.0298214406,
-0.554210484,
0.3034860194,
-0.5685587525,
0.3970939517,
0.2669214308,
-0.0094106067,
-0.092118375,
-0.0700797886,
-0.1919762045,
-0.2690418065,
0.5466262698,
-0.5886356831,
-0.4058928788,
-0.5411899686,
-0.7620132565,
-0.0227511637,
0.0300161634,
0.3207971752,
0.4847297966,
-0.2932070494,
0.180062741,
0.2274561226,
-0.5488516092,
0.2584223151,
0.8165630698,
-0.2859081626,
-0.6725116372,
0.9771329761,
0.4834443629,
-0.1358338296,
0.318559289,
0.3079752028,
-0.5301132798,
-0.0735990629,
0.0933444351,
0.1616555005,
-0.7508602142,
-0.2991682291,
-0.7459574938,
-0.2388246506,
-0.5601980686,
0.0044474425,
-0.5682080388,
-0.4124342799,
-0.5103121996,
-0.2923719883,
0.5199007988,
0.7740229964,
-0.2894242406,
0.0668989271,
-0.767195642,
0.6605466604,
0.2680696249,
0.5700439215,
0.0284978449,
-0.3887659907,
-0.5061066747,
0.0508431457,
-0.5665571094,
-1.0959525108,
0.2146732807,
0.0814394802,
0.4332136512,
0.4922285378,
0.3536221683,
0.5958705544,
-0.1321348697,
0.2890487015,
0.4029688239,
-0.8787370324,
0.578461349,
-0.6424254775,
0.1109430343,
0.1274767071,
0.6509403586,
-0.7650649548,
-0.742559135,
-0.7370992303,
-1.3424574137,
0.8307365775,
0.2530258,
0.065913707,
-0.2865144908,
0.3375899494,
0.3001022637,
0.6080735326,
-0.7953390479,
-0.690248847,
0.047260616,
0.0921500474,
0.0203007031,
-0.4061112106,
-0.1147221178,
-0.1253922284,
1.0326309204,
0.0586685911,
0.1884998083,
-0.2122392505,
0.4155493677,
-0.0029714354,
0.4461454749,
0.8886508346,
0.7135757208,
-0.4076452255,
0.1308280975,
-0.2298880219,
-0.1940982789,
0.3368082047,
0.5645199418,
-0.0165643096,
-0.0311736651,
0.1646639407,
0.8153207302,
0.5886563063,
-0.3730843961,
0.2348287255,
-0.207474336,
-0.5828953981,
0.1441055685,
-0.3992578983,
0.3790394366,
0.4021959007,
0.6243123412,
0.0469769798,
0.3860600591,
-0.7696204185,
0.7361486554,
-0.0800818503,
-0.3579030037,
-0.271470964,
0.7667533755,
0.246023342,
0.2029972076,
0.3719274402,
-0.17793414,
-0.4207424819,
0.9936921,
0.4892128408,
0.8622929454,
-0.1778209507,
0.3685622215,
0.3184640706,
0.161574319,
-0.0916390494,
0.2240076065,
0.4903687835,
-0.583430171,
-0.4082733095,
-0.5341076851,
-0.4658361673,
0.3839128017,
-0.8342025876,
0.3521324098,
0.0748726502,
-0.5972188711,
0.6363806129,
-0.205442667,
-0.1113235131,
0.2191195786,
0.2270652056,
0.79526788,
-0.9503044486,
0.6133790612,
0.8748979568,
-0.2402641922,
-0.3085051775,
0.19695732,
0.098321557,
-0.0489301309,
0.7846090794,
0.1071841344,
0.4043162465,
-0.2669636607,
-0.0215367861,
-1.077001214,
0.4863796532,
0.2645806968,
-0.3783394992,
0.1159691885,
-0.1195234507,
0.40833354,
-0.4497060478,
-0.1996303499,
0.1791705191,
0.7362905741,
0.4289279878,
-0.6479372382,
-0.4989039302,
-0.1933239698,
-0.3621855974,
0.562376976,
-0.7677645683,
1.0077656507,
-0.1357976794,
0.0354609415,
-0.2416546345,
0.6479490995,
0.3865848482,
0.8828407526,
0.2035313696,
0.3436157107,
0.7008396387,
-0.105814673,
0.8710250854,
-0.7377576828,
0.8596035838,
1.0720404387,
-0.6134887934,
0.7470040917,
0.4520006776,
-0.1012941152,
-0.0523742735,
0.9581852555,
-0.0737815127,
0.5758183002,
0.3984354436,
-0.0571717098,
-0.0694108605,
-0.1812284887,
-0.7263837457,
0.2990944684,
0.3013829589,
-0.30047068,
-0.4201297164,
0.2004931569,
-0.0649241731,
-0.3082316518,
-0.0626959577,
0.7043767571,
0.3071642816,
-0.4067842364,
-0.1523032188,
0.5576847196,
0.3922114968,
-0.7245266438,
0.198741287,
-0.2857257724,
0.232803151,
0.129412204,
-0.5701583028,
0.689214766,
0.3518961072,
-0.5310935974,
-0.4025823474,
0.707927525,
-0.740717411,
-0.6482031345,
0.4106527865,
0.2901133001,
-0.0164498519,
-0.0345600508,
-0.6332284808,
-0.142311886,
-0.0843404084,
-0.6280722022,
0.4851967394,
0.7025997639,
-0.1140187085,
0.214568153,
0.6823188663,
-0.5066520572,
-0.1838850528,
-0.0542004146,
0.812969923,
-1.0486123562,
-1.0022300482,
-0.5495789051,
0.3464170396,
0.1107317731,
-0.2395136803,
0.5909075737,
0.9826595187,
0.2825865746,
-0.0642139688,
0.3980642855,
0.4491254389,
0.2873435318,
-0.530502677,
0.5934054255,
-0.63076967,
0.4516401291,
-0.5279690027,
-0.9077525139,
-0.1892197281,
0.3699957132,
-0.4931347966,
-0.0400318354,
0.7724651694,
0.2375792116,
-0.0160660706,
0.4248497784,
0.0799943805,
0.3550921082,
-0.0073767607,
0.2102619261,
0.6391338706,
-0.4242284298,
0.5003401637,
-0.1949618459,
0.0696149841,
-0.4137221277,
-0.9458470345,
-0.3318705559,
-0.6549044251,
-0.9206160903,
-0.2060029209,
-0.1623631567,
0.5062791705,
0.2081496269,
-0.7525812984,
-0.4921518862,
0.4428489804,
0.1333727539,
-0.1346079856,
-0.2557422519,
0.5427263379,
-0.1578244567,
-0.2810483277,
0.225364387,
0.7068749666,
0.3285203278,
0.0167214386,
-0.0485922098,
-0.4852097332,
0.3053938448,
0.632273376,
-0.0353669934,
-0.2720640004,
0.1097545028,
0.0458510779,
-0.3395609558,
0.1542097032,
0.9078567624,
-0.121154204,
0.0975440815,
0.363375932,
0.3853393793,
0.7692543864,
0.0669545084,
0.573856771,
-0.7354215384,
0.3583348393,
-0.3285529912,
0.2426533252,
-0.2708671689,
-0.458247602,
0.3237749934,
0.2867040634,
-0.1977682412,
-0.5557119846,
-0.1429000497,
-0.4860762656,
-0.6770447493,
0.7346006036,
0.1756857038,
-0.1890954971,
0.0343213528,
-0.0993897244,
0.0968395025,
-0.8469225168,
0.7149161696,
1.2678257227,
-0.1802262068,
0.1180145666,
-0.6786827445,
0.1179566458,
0.0802603215,
-0.7832949162,
0.2638197839,
0.5835833549,
-0.0021334088,
0.2444290221,
0.8167977929,
-0.0623585694,
0.3415299058,
0.0840170905,
0.0152801825,
0.2840709388,
-0.7135283351,
-0.1985532045,
0.5146850348,
-0.33021909,
-0.1220384911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06025v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06025v2
|
ChiMed-GPT: A Chinese Medical Large Language Model with Full Training Regime and Better Alignment to Human Preferences
| 2023-11-10T12:25:32 | 2023-11-23T10:19:47 |
Yuanhe Tian, Ruyi Gan, Yan Song, Jiaxing Zhang, Yongdong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, the increasing demand for superior medical services has highlighted
the discrepancies in the medical infrastructure. With big data, especially
texts, forming the foundation of medical services, there is an exigent need for
effective natural language processing (NLP) solutions tailored to the
healthcare domain. Conventional approaches leveraging pre-trained models
present promising results in this domain and current large language models
(LLMs) offer advanced foundation for medical text processing. However, most
medical LLMs are trained only with supervised fine-tuning (SFT), even though it
efficiently empowers LLMs to understand and respond to medical instructions but
is ineffective in learning domain knowledge and aligning with human preference.
Another engineering barrier that prevents current medical LLM from better text
processing ability is their restricted context length (e.g., 2,048 tokens),
making it hard for the LLMs to process long context, which is frequently
required in the medical domain. In this work, we propose ChiMed-GPT, a new
benchmark LLM designed explicitly for Chinese medical domain, with enlarged
context length to 4,096 tokens and undergoes a comprehensive training regime
with pre-training, SFT, and RLHF. Evaluations on real-world tasks including
information extraction, question answering, and dialogue generation demonstrate
ChiMed-GPT's superior performance over general domain LLMs. Furthermore, we
analyze possible biases through prompting ChiMed-GPT to perform attitude scales
regarding discrimination of patients, so as to contribute to further
responsible development of LLMs in the medical domain. The code and model are
released at https://github.com/synlp/ChiMed-GPT.
|
[
-0.1445820332,
-0.6464227438,
0.7300906777,
0.1305548251,
-0.4005708992,
-0.3082798719,
-0.5739654303,
-0.5562390089,
0.1220068559,
0.3189523518,
-0.430055052,
-0.4198770225,
-0.5799058676,
0.1787934452,
0.1004762277,
1.2324304581,
0.0592591316,
0.5159795284,
-0.0354803465,
-0.0248921942,
-0.3492310941,
-0.6633165479,
-0.8466554284,
-0.4649704993,
0.5367455482,
-0.0705169216,
0.8608186841,
0.5959770679,
0.4826981723,
0.1853076071,
-0.0991480127,
0.0994444117,
-0.1303533614,
-0.0713749677,
-0.0138967689,
-0.2403483838,
-0.7426682711,
0.0487089977,
0.5994395018,
0.7156919241,
-0.1795198768,
-0.145801127,
0.1081199199,
0.5717642307,
-0.1792460829,
0.1558471918,
-0.5799950957,
0.1671428531,
-0.1529487222,
-0.2274699807,
-0.3794544339,
-0.2625924051,
0.2721596062,
-0.5538092256,
0.1132781208,
-0.0710571036,
0.8227002025,
0.5807996392,
-0.4760985672,
-0.2182179391,
-0.1648534238,
0.7779536843,
-1.1386506557,
0.35695979,
0.2706354856,
0.1077730879,
-0.2148882747,
-0.7242672443,
-0.443536818,
-0.4122365415,
-0.0864783674,
0.2030390203,
0.4381396174,
0.4113595188,
0.2689447403,
0.4817599952,
-0.7380729914,
0.3035498559,
0.0099611031,
-0.1195770502,
0.4755602479,
0.1337026209,
0.4451406598,
-0.1774037629,
-0.4481403232,
0.2249936759,
-0.7337790132,
-0.2639823556,
-0.2678858042,
0.2000542134,
-0.2780676484,
0.3793888688,
-0.22972624,
0.8656005859,
0.0939656422,
-0.3050579131,
0.4284118414,
-0.0606363527,
-0.5337466002,
0.0077451095,
1.041259408,
0.3573542535,
0.2088026106,
-0.1099175736,
-0.2705647945,
-0.0550717525,
0.188127473,
-0.9961901307,
-0.1219434515,
0.3766457736,
-0.4639864266,
-0.1531756818,
-0.2115721107,
-0.3488637805,
-0.42460832,
-0.4198377132,
0.1198825538,
-0.6091883779,
-0.1927572787,
0.447206974,
0.4844347835,
0.3077773154,
0.4531080723,
-1.105001092,
0.0191899557,
0.9576527476,
0.9861608744,
-0.3164169192,
-0.0380273238,
-0.5874193311,
-0.1186598092,
-0.2730566859,
0.5083376765,
-0.4401962161,
-0.2914259732,
0.1121661291,
-0.1097933948,
-0.2280416787,
-0.5559903979,
1.0721992254,
-0.5209841132,
0.4485059083,
-0.341661036,
-0.667429626,
0.0782763883,
0.4950626493,
-0.5375931263,
0.7495480776,
0.1175722852,
-0.9719763398,
0.5306668282,
-0.7739399672,
-0.5063768625,
0.3761025071,
-0.52040869,
-0.5309835672,
-0.130371511,
0.5106750727,
0.5996246338,
-0.6256038547,
0.5552226901,
-0.1891782582,
-0.5404927135,
0.149090454,
-0.566788137,
0.9588035941,
0.2457396537,
-0.0658339262,
0.1911367625,
-0.4978961647,
0.1555371881,
0.0626189485,
-0.5337613821,
-0.1514145136,
-0.0948325619,
0.192357406,
0.2875298858,
0.4450652003,
-0.5322663784,
0.2830879688,
-0.7398645878,
0.5238918662,
0.6055943966,
-0.0116985925,
0.1016499251,
-0.475443691,
0.3500600457,
-0.1582754552,
0.3052353263,
0.0061407075,
-0.5583344102,
-0.3852941692,
-0.4803587794,
0.2996744514,
0.5233399272,
-0.9014445543,
0.6277520061,
-0.3948093355,
-0.0991690606,
-0.6525833011,
-0.0491879173,
0.219137311,
0.719724834,
0.3505311608,
-0.331733495,
-0.3319610059,
-0.7141302824,
-0.2058912665,
-0.225806728,
-0.3970392644,
0.3258528113,
0.1561460197,
-0.4542676508,
0.7411049008,
-0.6166957021,
-0.3813232183,
0.0450727604,
-0.0857618749,
0.5407880545,
0.3409949839,
0.4522713721,
-1.0148540735,
-0.7448986173,
0.2997078001,
-0.7712051868,
-0.1757378131,
-0.1039047018,
0.1286717355,
0.0992584676,
0.2386118323,
-0.7620648742,
-0.0064105256,
0.5626740456,
-0.0857519433,
0.6842387319,
-0.2510499954,
0.1763560176,
-1.3395689726,
0.0940580741,
0.0419064611,
-0.2310873717,
-0.5571913719,
0.117867589,
0.2275721282,
0.1397774071,
-0.3596828878,
0.5225442648,
-0.4142310023,
0.2631892562,
-0.4238051176,
-0.0583661236,
-0.301474452,
0.5170161128,
0.3393934369,
0.8810542226,
0.4875855148,
-0.4207084179,
0.50681144,
0.3183976412,
-0.3701627553,
0.8199333549,
-0.6734601855,
0.1499773562,
0.2647473812,
0.2200098932,
-0.6230701208,
-0.3806107342,
0.0408724435,
-0.5088862181,
0.2637565136,
-0.2005485147,
-0.5283314586,
-0.3437269032,
-0.0795107335,
0.5604723096,
0.6339554191,
-0.4862952828,
0.1123635769,
0.2548458278,
-0.3322665393,
-0.5344858766,
-0.4518170059,
0.1740766466,
-0.1008587182,
-0.6241419911,
0.2646818161,
-0.1996685863,
0.1729011685,
-0.3948039114,
-0.0475627705,
-0.2388637066,
-0.177601546,
0.044271782,
0.6291747093,
-0.4862501919,
0.3147331178,
-0.0326813832,
-0.2214270383,
0.025812529,
-0.5047652721,
0.5349064469,
-0.0670668259,
-0.5586820245,
-0.4256204963,
0.1274898797,
0.5492054224,
-0.1291396916,
0.6491948366,
0.5965120196,
-0.4827969968,
0.1777118146,
-0.5019230843,
-0.1521276236,
-0.4862005413,
0.6546422243,
-0.1367448419,
-1.0906883478,
0.1527671516,
-0.0511455499,
0.2509744763,
0.3459083736,
0.9040282965,
0.2113357782,
0.9794073105,
0.3493113816,
-0.4316295385,
0.2997725904,
0.4821768999,
0.0767384768,
-0.8594018221,
0.2080680579,
-0.2449898273,
0.131315425,
-0.5392824411,
-0.4549740553,
0.7673573494,
-0.4612547755,
-0.3887344003,
-0.1566481292,
-0.6801847219,
0.3764017224,
0.1927790791,
0.3722013831,
0.3439283073,
-0.1606423408,
-0.2674812376,
-0.2831046581,
-0.5117496252,
-0.3558185399,
0.9984812737,
0.3857247233,
0.6894131303,
-0.1291911751,
0.4844149351,
0.1314867437,
0.5622465014,
-0.8992884755,
0.3081735075,
-0.3604325354,
-0.4286398888,
-0.3276362419,
-0.5057837963,
-0.8668299317,
0.2959964871,
-0.0815475211,
-0.4041602015,
-0.4166486859,
0.109819591,
-0.5094115138,
0.3675880134,
-0.4969138801,
0.7658722997,
-0.3102112114,
-0.2193230838,
0.176792413,
-0.7372294664,
0.3105274737,
-0.200351283,
-0.1159666702,
0.0418711193,
-0.0521844737,
0.4882376492,
-0.4026358426,
0.8809774518,
-0.1327503771,
-0.428709656,
-0.201513052,
-0.3011466563,
0.4944784939,
0.1651131809,
-0.1571288854,
0.1481646001,
0.0466479436,
-0.5034843683,
-0.3806911111,
0.6178689599,
-0.7010543942,
-0.544575572,
-0.4639964402,
-0.5068197846,
-0.5526201129,
0.3868968487,
0.427152127,
0.2694781721,
-0.3783498108,
0.1142266691,
0.8520217538,
-0.4406255782,
0.020422807,
0.5206049681,
-0.1447831839,
-0.331640929,
0.5860034823,
-0.1250203699,
0.3179970682,
0.6039111018,
0.1788102388,
-0.2718985081,
-0.6436824203,
-0.5681526065,
0.3430117965,
-0.2881172299,
-0.108497262,
-0.5426424742,
-0.6568875313,
-0.4313344061,
-0.1011220813,
-0.2784105241,
0.1159667447,
-0.0886857063,
0.0864989534,
0.2199950516,
0.5427156091,
0.1988224387,
0.2815495133,
-0.7677872181,
0.4435563982,
0.2215219736,
0.6550367475,
-0.0860872343,
-0.6319149733,
-0.4578459561,
0.1540425867,
-0.1037545428,
-0.4638099968,
0.3604545295,
-0.0516908877,
0.2694671154,
0.4607731104,
-0.0083707944,
0.397002846,
-0.7545746565,
0.7235667109,
0.3711889684,
-0.5874734521,
0.2270089388,
-0.6349602938,
0.3943992257,
0.4125270247,
0.1642686129,
-1.0430263281,
-0.0557715409,
-0.2919531167,
-0.7119086981,
0.529014647,
-0.0728004575,
0.0100410637,
0.0000527556,
0.4745928645,
0.2600342333,
0.2204151303,
-0.7115328312,
-0.0170609076,
0.0901779011,
-0.501665473,
-0.0084451716,
-0.2128723413,
-0.1468352079,
-0.1483833492,
0.6156597733,
-0.3182730675,
0.2968514562,
0.239751637,
0.0190939531,
0.0742089078,
0.4502811134,
0.4492490292,
0.3876822293,
-0.1539664567,
-0.1745883822,
0.1891994774,
-0.8600713015,
-0.0545154102,
0.1481360942,
-0.2514395714,
-0.1479371637,
0.3088360727,
0.6963657141,
0.082127288,
-0.5934243798,
0.7270603776,
-0.0518150106,
-0.1378371418,
-0.3737688661,
0.0153427161,
0.1198559925,
-0.1167718768,
0.2524739802,
-0.1363966614,
0.1196528673,
-0.1578738689,
0.4159745276,
0.461140126,
-0.6509571075,
-0.1725306362,
0.737442255,
0.2040471137,
-0.0943756178,
0.6649681926,
0.1418375373,
-0.4210483432,
0.2730903924,
0.4909856319,
0.8650020957,
-0.2187639177,
0.1350786984,
0.2504480183,
0.1316470355,
-0.2827186882,
0.0269383397,
0.1092027649,
-0.7473503351,
-0.813179791,
-0.539730072,
-0.4823229909,
0.3566076159,
-0.7118911147,
0.2440090328,
-0.5125290751,
-0.2039735913,
-0.1156082749,
0.1644761711,
-0.4525923729,
0.5299346447,
0.1527462155,
0.7978264093,
-0.5591833591,
1.0874307156,
0.6863449216,
-0.2713778019,
-0.6921516657,
0.3615523279,
-0.0066842726,
-1.0518782139,
0.2962661684,
0.1197823286,
0.1174872741,
-0.292589426,
-0.6447933912,
-0.379206717,
0.767670989,
0.4580210745,
-0.5688475966,
-0.2170051634,
0.2590029836,
0.7974340916,
-0.2445370555,
0.2520525455,
0.5925718546,
0.2519372702,
0.1061723307,
-1.352999568,
0.2705951035,
-0.2561833262,
-0.2649990916,
0.1542081237,
-0.9187048674,
0.8803359866,
-0.210479334,
-0.0324843824,
0.363766849,
0.3742547333,
0.3098099232,
0.1709353775,
0.3389409781,
0.422863394,
0.835580945,
-0.0640290827,
0.8881030679,
-0.2021429986,
0.3703882694,
0.9796190858,
-0.6272757053,
0.7403139472,
0.3515616655,
-0.3587168157,
0.2249206007,
0.6930921674,
0.1769256145,
0.2547366023,
0.0159391463,
-0.5453924537,
-0.2706334591,
-0.0243381485,
-0.6467630267,
0.0799005926,
0.3901083171,
-0.3048716187,
-0.0151128443,
-0.1588521451,
0.216953814,
0.0502692051,
-0.1450800598,
0.8350991011,
0.3712785244,
-0.6602414846,
0.7588959336,
0.0228053257,
1.0064765215,
-0.8478870392,
0.1351567209,
-0.0530169867,
0.0838920474,
-0.2269430161,
-0.6539822817,
-0.1687113047,
-0.0726767853,
-0.1926486939,
0.00575678,
0.5078625083,
-0.4031009078,
-0.2569234073,
0.1014895216,
0.287987709,
0.1837101877,
-0.2104312479,
-0.8090134859,
-0.2586250901,
0.243028447,
-0.1472004652,
0.484801501,
0.6599901319,
-0.0532895997,
0.5468390584,
0.6770923138,
0.4547427595,
-0.2465640157,
0.3128366172,
0.7978039384,
-0.7601102591,
-0.7495972514,
-0.8925546408,
0.0487191565,
-0.181385234,
-0.2449374944,
0.3449717164,
0.6223224401,
0.4465907812,
-0.0418013223,
1.0269423723,
0.086789988,
0.7490296364,
-0.7111975551,
0.8520474434,
-0.5464299321,
0.1996354908,
-0.1610823423,
-0.6031098962,
-0.5046139956,
0.6077324748,
-0.4384257793,
0.3537071645,
0.6082239151,
0.4339382946,
0.0079846093,
0.105394125,
0.572037518,
0.3942247927,
0.401414752,
1.0294202566,
0.4843028784,
-0.2965265214,
0.1928123534,
0.3015831411,
-0.3917490542,
-0.2359963059,
-0.6729086041,
-0.926052928,
-0.4583452046,
-0.0425072648,
-0.2135192305,
-0.0758606195,
1.2040348053,
0.6982652545,
-0.8040817976,
0.0713275224,
0.2521269619,
-0.2281624377,
-0.1710276157,
-0.1810198575,
0.7350073457,
-0.4409818351,
-0.7937628031,
0.0816938058,
0.4114072323,
-0.0077516655,
-0.0462351926,
-0.2629387975,
0.027104659,
-0.1490565985,
0.5137138963,
0.2702376544,
-0.6386256218,
-0.2361398935,
0.0314328857,
-0.5056251287,
0.4399838448,
0.8355717659,
-0.562717855,
0.3624377549,
0.0920029283,
0.9343976974,
0.2225930691,
0.0491844639,
0.6916433573,
-0.6494217515,
0.2020610273,
0.4431944489,
0.4443600476,
0.5113896728,
-0.6022046804,
0.5679399371,
0.1738605797,
-0.8257040977,
-0.5921531916,
0.145736441,
-1.0236501694,
-0.2732243538,
1.2089856863,
-0.0102324402,
-0.0078522414,
-0.2957445979,
-0.6266039014,
0.3453064263,
-0.3234192431,
0.9221248031,
0.6652808785,
-0.0642326027,
0.1378928721,
-0.710044086,
0.7382515669,
0.6842505336,
-0.7181998491,
0.1135371029,
0.4059744775,
0.3838000298,
-0.2100507617,
1.1159344912,
-0.3888025284,
0.3881714344,
-0.3871286809,
0.0079968842,
0.2755021751,
0.2060215473,
-0.1066710055,
-0.031206809,
0.3156663179,
-0.1448187381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05965v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05965v1
|
Large Language Models are Zero Shot Hypothesis Proposers
| 2023-11-10T10:03:49 | 2023-11-10T10:03:49 |
Biqing Qi, Kaiyan Zhang, Haoxiang Li, Kai Tian, Sihang Zeng, Zhang-Ren Chen, Bowen Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Significant scientific discoveries have driven the progress of human
civilisation. The explosion of scientific literature and data has created
information barriers across disciplines that have slowed the pace of scientific
discovery. Large Language Models (LLMs) hold a wealth of global and
interdisciplinary knowledge that promises to break down these information
barriers and foster a new wave of scientific discovery. However, the potential
of LLMs for scientific discovery has not been formally explored. In this paper,
we start from investigating whether LLMs can propose scientific hypotheses. To
this end, we construct a dataset consist of background knowledge and hypothesis
pairs from biomedical literature. The dataset is divided into training, seen,
and unseen test sets based on the publication date to control visibility. We
subsequently evaluate the hypothesis generation capabilities of various
top-tier instructed models in zero-shot, few-shot, and fine-tuning settings,
including both closed and open-source LLMs. Additionally, we introduce an
LLM-based multi-agent cooperative framework with different role designs and
external tools to enhance the capabilities related to generating hypotheses. We
also design four metrics through a comprehensive review to evaluate the
generated hypotheses for both ChatGPT-based and human evaluations. Through
experiments and analyses, we arrive at the following findings: 1) LLMs
surprisingly generate untrained yet validated hypotheses from testing
literature. 2) Increasing uncertainty facilitates candidate generation,
potentially enhancing zero-shot hypothesis generation capabilities. These
findings strongly support the potential of LLMs as catalysts for new scientific
discoveries and guide further exploration.
|
[
-0.1869833469,
-0.6793143749,
0.9978606701,
-0.132615149,
0.0881468654,
0.0378034227,
-0.4928987622,
-0.5033588409,
0.2372982204,
0.422501415,
-0.2291756123,
-0.5487807989,
-0.5427556038,
0.2610327005,
-0.2733043432,
0.7744119167,
0.1430286318,
0.0823414028,
-0.156793654,
0.0578978173,
-0.2319250405,
-0.3089877665,
-0.4834756553,
-0.5238006115,
0.926025033,
0.4311880171,
0.5381352305,
0.674595952,
0.341232866,
0.2134122103,
-0.0632603839,
0.0262930337,
-0.3897776902,
0.3853850365,
-0.152914077,
-0.8386127949,
-0.3944849968,
-0.1010953635,
0.7245361209,
0.763404429,
-0.0295590013,
0.041975908,
-0.2529938519,
0.326710403,
-0.5671601295,
0.1857349724,
-0.8693974018,
0.0707456917,
-0.2926305234,
-0.2626647949,
-0.4073746502,
0.1256899387,
0.2062617689,
-0.4836192131,
0.3806547225,
0.2056279033,
0.6870412827,
-0.0013291916,
-0.3058753014,
-0.1652198434,
-0.7534768581,
0.7866828442,
-1.024895072,
0.1279310137,
0.2547090948,
0.2580499947,
-0.506613791,
-0.278116703,
-0.6390501857,
-0.568369329,
0.2768362463,
-0.0557129085,
-0.1156565472,
-0.0121304682,
0.3127065599,
0.140319407,
-0.5605710745,
0.4714855552,
-0.2063364685,
-0.3243254125,
0.7186344862,
0.1308073699,
0.2346134633,
-0.0735930279,
0.0240575336,
0.0721471161,
-0.9228267074,
-0.2020216733,
0.113427408,
0.4402091205,
-0.2403513938,
0.9842303991,
-0.2542963326,
0.4214918613,
-0.0995800197,
-0.3380953074,
0.1525657475,
-0.4505064785,
-0.1050127521,
0.1793259233,
1.0737031698,
0.1941910684,
0.0937546864,
-0.1994950771,
0.0474333949,
0.2187101096,
-0.2498387545,
-0.9902594686,
0.1463871002,
0.3812254667,
-0.0748323798,
-0.2949313521,
-0.2645247579,
-0.5768692493,
-0.4976937771,
0.0330623984,
0.385720998,
-0.4134625793,
-0.4403121769,
0.4172755778,
-0.2655496895,
0.1652537733,
0.3199646175,
-0.759136498,
-0.067426376,
0.6032325029,
0.8993331194,
-0.0792032257,
-0.4009627402,
-0.1199361905,
0.4320267141,
-0.6299464703,
0.8725960255,
-0.3765891492,
-0.4432211518,
0.0405235104,
-0.0734614432,
0.0778639019,
-0.1233789176,
0.4141547084,
-0.2782313526,
0.0851439759,
-0.3943013549,
-0.6666874886,
0.1759734452,
0.2475438416,
-0.3208129704,
0.5331386924,
-0.1990690678,
-0.9213088155,
0.5005746484,
-0.6845687032,
-0.2525184155,
0.2687929571,
-0.4632569253,
-0.4840378761,
0.0382998064,
0.0162661206,
0.4954005778,
-0.6050723195,
0.6657819152,
-0.5027909279,
-0.2371940166,
0.4088038802,
-0.4364567697,
0.4951951504,
0.1234699786,
-0.4502460063,
0.0799891651,
-0.5566888452,
-0.1257013679,
0.2800632715,
-0.1689001918,
-0.2482430488,
0.0167757962,
-0.3409193754,
0.1421953589,
0.0661611557,
-0.9749598503,
0.372104913,
-0.4229275882,
0.5298434496,
0.42729038,
0.0690538585,
0.3354371488,
-0.4587643743,
0.4322647452,
-0.0166052114,
-0.1670626551,
-0.4302611351,
-0.4482618272,
-0.617328763,
-0.3896845281,
0.201542303,
0.1246451139,
-0.6737322807,
0.2475151271,
-0.1180321276,
-0.7193875313,
-0.5732257366,
-0.0575329326,
0.2753812671,
0.470128417,
0.0190515574,
0.0165804103,
-0.4739122987,
-0.8540860415,
0.0377901196,
-0.2366144657,
-0.1786100566,
0.3350425959,
0.6991280317,
-0.361699909,
0.8158636093,
-0.4516061544,
-0.0221365131,
-0.0668689013,
0.0874959528,
0.2320846915,
0.0394968651,
0.4689005017,
-0.4314601719,
-0.3965605199,
0.0681801811,
-1.0773830414,
0.0057114111,
0.179075405,
-0.1238425449,
0.2452167422,
0.3175669014,
-0.8822447658,
0.2550594211,
0.3252791762,
-0.2084749043,
0.8165314794,
-0.2710278034,
-0.0230221897,
-1.0807462931,
0.0441492423,
0.0529764444,
0.154263407,
-0.5510884523,
-0.1854874194,
-0.1109352335,
-0.1583557874,
-0.2649586797,
0.6587643027,
-0.5064992905,
0.0529606678,
-0.4892537296,
0.0583875477,
-0.1950866431,
0.0389743559,
0.1925314069,
0.39649266,
1.0308281183,
-0.4692204297,
-0.000576153,
0.2619936466,
-0.3014197052,
0.0769836754,
-0.7892851233,
-0.1767062694,
-0.3508174121,
0.4019139111,
-0.9585211873,
-0.5341397524,
-0.0544585735,
-0.5334492922,
0.0726965666,
0.0322384536,
-0.5664717555,
-0.4985152483,
-0.2310139686,
0.155330658,
0.4228104353,
-0.2006156743,
0.0292845741,
0.3699171841,
-0.3160154819,
-0.4408467114,
-0.535580039,
0.2368845642,
-0.1336731613,
-0.7630073428,
0.1271645129,
-0.1597113311,
-0.3675757051,
-0.1042034328,
0.013123027,
0.254380703,
0.0986014083,
0.376709789,
0.3641075194,
-0.4576395452,
0.3491248488,
-0.0733339489,
-0.1025623009,
0.1188263744,
-0.2256099433,
0.4678233862,
0.0115970057,
-0.459228754,
-0.1615642905,
0.2668189108,
0.7164332867,
-0.1699680537,
0.7859206796,
0.5637096167,
-0.3239581585,
-0.2146584541,
-0.504093349,
-0.3712241948,
-0.3707312047,
0.4135303497,
-0.0636014119,
-1.0858495235,
0.3293119371,
-0.1435293704,
0.0681748241,
0.2847392559,
0.9829657674,
0.1389562935,
0.7984980345,
0.7168920636,
0.1876095086,
0.0820928887,
-0.1737666875,
0.3934271634,
-0.6066856384,
-0.1582999527,
-0.6583559513,
0.2296232432,
-0.6640853882,
-0.5035567284,
0.6921487451,
0.0349269733,
-0.2461227328,
0.033395689,
-0.2715319991,
0.4257201254,
0.4533357322,
-0.0730389431,
0.2989863753,
0.0316265784,
-0.3177612722,
0.1908104867,
-0.8815433979,
-0.5965919495,
1.3502922058,
0.4011015892,
0.7334142923,
0.0353087261,
0.6112476587,
-0.0146356402,
0.3818203509,
-0.8703838587,
0.4061281681,
0.3808138669,
-0.8202618957,
-0.6863557696,
-0.2933665514,
-1.0045803785,
0.2000095099,
-0.5470741987,
-0.6184949875,
0.0013525616,
-0.0039870995,
-0.4371580184,
0.2593935132,
-0.4625550807,
0.4106104374,
-0.210281983,
-0.6469528675,
0.003912488,
-0.6005563736,
0.5973225236,
-0.3822339773,
0.2925524712,
-0.4202203453,
0.1352176666,
0.6687685251,
-0.1928381026,
0.8920764327,
-0.103048183,
-0.4850231409,
0.4336566329,
0.2393180579,
0.2040579468,
0.140539512,
-0.4234606922,
0.2781059444,
-0.0236426238,
-0.4421917498,
-0.1601158977,
0.7314973474,
-0.6676059961,
-0.7045657635,
-0.4357171357,
-0.8086847663,
-0.2157706022,
0.2925491333,
0.3043529689,
0.1885031611,
-0.1738934815,
0.2803600132,
0.4920202196,
-0.4484444559,
0.5719400644,
1.1659818888,
-0.2281914055,
-0.0531261265,
0.6730214953,
0.032617487,
0.4046761692,
0.1953992546,
0.4556095898,
-0.2615739107,
-0.809566021,
-0.1209032834,
0.4749215245,
-0.1107115149,
-0.1954254955,
-0.5765397549,
-0.2652409673,
-0.5723648667,
-0.1659879237,
-0.2957859039,
-0.1030677259,
0.1055363417,
-0.0864296556,
0.2981729209,
0.7199795246,
-0.4645599723,
0.109256573,
-0.6007995605,
0.2104635537,
-0.0019410587,
0.1583325714,
0.2405535132,
-0.2615288198,
-0.4896658063,
0.3524316549,
-0.3570178747,
-0.6193327308,
0.5888549089,
0.0498197004,
0.5461137295,
0.3669474423,
-0.1028887853,
0.2454093844,
-0.7847360969,
0.7578709126,
0.3741480112,
-0.4724418819,
0.4935747385,
-0.9338026047,
0.078525193,
0.0006882999,
0.6483285427,
-0.267390579,
-0.5453003645,
-0.5871527195,
-0.6163924336,
0.2123336047,
0.1861654073,
-0.1920443475,
-0.1187268198,
0.2221658975,
0.3253506124,
0.3244263828,
-0.5369721651,
0.0016228223,
0.1187837422,
0.1291142702,
-0.3665502667,
-0.0482802205,
-0.2327677757,
-0.1325806677,
0.541862309,
-0.3604706228,
0.2741338611,
0.3856297135,
0.341912657,
-0.5213140845,
0.5812285542,
0.5330014825,
0.6174124479,
-0.2583578825,
0.0676975846,
-0.2789823115,
-0.1964852363,
0.3498702943,
-0.0256112907,
-0.362372756,
-0.0189871117,
0.608027935,
0.6761497855,
-0.0841311514,
-0.7739930749,
0.4389119148,
0.0421976857,
-0.4843250513,
-0.2707908452,
0.1475185305,
0.3655531406,
0.2706004679,
0.3876926601,
-0.1146251634,
-0.1854668558,
-0.7416460514,
0.1728972048,
0.7509433627,
-0.0359107777,
-0.5472608209,
0.7110449672,
-0.0299502183,
-0.2006339133,
0.0098152161,
-0.1536441594,
-0.1509595215,
0.6828764677,
0.7882196307,
0.4707060158,
-0.0359737016,
0.5794661045,
0.3887559175,
0.1342192888,
-0.2673238218,
0.0908480883,
0.2326960713,
-1.0237841606,
-0.6893017888,
-0.7378129363,
-0.5214399099,
0.3378842175,
-0.3162803352,
0.3898628056,
-0.0088089658,
-0.1565149128,
0.6076809764,
0.0884000883,
-0.4682573378,
-0.2606908381,
0.2230609804,
0.6416592598,
-0.844674468,
0.8728967309,
0.2738658488,
-0.4161756933,
-0.7030602098,
-0.0781860203,
0.0725829974,
-0.8096314669,
0.588966012,
-0.0397551768,
0.1508306116,
-0.2391857505,
-0.9104941487,
-0.9357309341,
1.1695795059,
0.5632634759,
-0.83543998,
-0.1604256928,
0.1608417183,
0.7696783543,
-0.4666637182,
0.2151653171,
0.2674950957,
0.5570702553,
0.4079041481,
-0.9999440908,
0.120502077,
0.0300253667,
-0.3739891946,
0.0614530221,
-0.6279606819,
1.0781399012,
-0.7844491601,
-0.0428643748,
0.3455489576,
0.3606187403,
0.6968463063,
0.4623585343,
0.0539158136,
0.2551168203,
0.6968166828,
0.216880098,
1.0663034916,
-0.2677148879,
0.2363072634,
0.8794537187,
-0.8272542357,
0.8113512993,
0.3820533752,
0.0119058834,
0.2576459944,
0.4249220192,
-0.1569743752,
0.1916462183,
0.4961762726,
-0.3352529109,
-0.3218934536,
-0.5869217515,
-0.355435729,
0.4047966003,
0.4627956152,
-0.2180023193,
-0.2959497869,
-0.0401233025,
0.2341724932,
-0.0295405798,
-0.216315344,
0.4977140725,
0.2174658477,
-0.7221927047,
0.7891953588,
-0.0985864699,
0.7337236404,
-0.6876983643,
-0.0749642178,
-0.0660823286,
0.0620640554,
-0.1115727574,
-0.6938342452,
-0.1420527399,
0.0206989869,
-0.0959227458,
0.1638250202,
0.8687852025,
-0.6005891562,
-0.4484749436,
0.1265475601,
0.8752491474,
0.1970895976,
0.0774125904,
-0.1562050581,
-0.0814806372,
-0.0155559797,
0.0002522839,
0.4846969247,
0.6751838923,
-0.0497264415,
0.7815236449,
0.7338656187,
0.519790113,
-0.192465961,
-0.1305038333,
0.6718670726,
-0.7762531042,
-0.0427394658,
-0.9489440918,
0.1052774191,
0.0958465859,
0.0590674356,
0.9424142838,
0.4378529191,
0.3961027265,
-0.1611786783,
1.1638166904,
0.1178172529,
0.5168768764,
-0.3054819405,
0.8537033796,
-0.3045210838,
0.0815260112,
-0.1994492561,
-0.4345708787,
-0.2754427791,
0.1609332561,
-0.1672980785,
-0.3215738535,
0.7221104503,
0.8224969506,
0.2419539839,
-0.0526921749,
0.5498894453,
0.6658707857,
0.5927404761,
0.5725297928,
0.8435772061,
-0.0929537192,
0.1160023883,
0.1672399342,
-0.2794208229,
-0.0669213757,
-0.9924955368,
-1.1816866398,
-0.3602261841,
-0.1927890778,
-0.2318900079,
0.0442943424,
0.6930682659,
0.6094907522,
-0.5090780854,
-0.3065910935,
-0.1182347983,
-0.115005143,
0.2460954189,
-0.1909752786,
0.3368321061,
-0.1292878538,
-0.3408239782,
0.5894761086,
0.2864328623,
0.3317205906,
-0.5150178671,
-0.127456367,
-0.2638548315,
0.303527236,
0.7539434433,
0.4887698889,
-0.6509641409,
-0.1503714472,
0.1793057323,
-0.0259884167,
-0.213569358,
0.6347318292,
-0.6617333889,
0.1043877602,
0.2498367876,
0.5216756463,
0.4976000488,
-0.5353837609,
0.7617301345,
-0.4191843867,
0.3139243722,
0.2842511237,
0.4429556727,
0.3386217654,
-0.1762418002,
0.4903278947,
0.1574591398,
-0.712505281,
-1.1265450716,
0.2166696936,
-0.8085723519,
-0.218846485,
1.4367079735,
-0.0193269458,
-0.4245054722,
0.073412396,
-0.2354351431,
0.1594676971,
-0.4669782221,
0.8975863457,
0.6959242225,
-0.3168570399,
0.1902548671,
-0.7687093019,
0.3806056082,
0.2296751291,
-0.7893120646,
0.1193512231,
0.4549429417,
0.379907459,
0.343812108,
0.6819267273,
-0.1006068289,
0.0309977904,
0.0819907859,
0.2442377359,
-0.1109791696,
-0.2767816484,
-0.023014253,
0.1795805693,
0.2506313622,
0.1681479067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07594v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07594v2
|
How to Bridge the Gap between Modalities: A Comprehensive Survey on Multimodal Large Language Model
| 2023-11-10T09:51:24 | 2023-12-19T03:44:25 |
Shezheng Song, Xiaopeng Li, Shasha Li, Shan Zhao, Jie Yu, Jun Ma, Xiaoguang Mao, Weimin Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
This review paper explores Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs), which
integrate Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 to handle multimodal data
such as text and vision. MLLMs demonstrate capabilities like generating image
narratives and answering image-based questions, bridging the gap towards
real-world human-computer interactions and hinting at a potential pathway to
artificial general intelligence. However, MLLMs still face challenges in
processing the semantic gap in multimodality, which may lead to erroneous
generation, posing potential risks to society. Choosing the appropriate
modality alignment method is crucial, as improper methods might require more
parameters with limited performance improvement. This paper aims to explore
modality alignment methods for LLMs and their existing capabilities.
Implementing modality alignment allows LLMs to address environmental issues and
enhance accessibility. The study surveys existing modal alignment methods in
MLLMs into four groups: (1) Multimodal Converters that change data into
something LLMs can understand; (2) Multimodal Perceivers to improve how LLMs
perceive different types of data; (3) Tools Assistance for changing data into
one common format, usually text; and (4) Data-Driven methods that teach LLMs to
understand specific types of data in a dataset. This field is still in a phase
of exploration and experimentation, and we will organize and update various
existing research methods for multimodal information alignment.
|
[
-0.4903018177,
-0.7883102298,
0.6702562571,
-0.1166610941,
-0.0791931301,
0.075791508,
-0.3637482524,
-0.6175089478,
-0.2499843538,
0.1844912618,
-0.5673418045,
-0.2143826187,
-0.4343546629,
-0.0177695286,
0.1044029593,
0.5585731864,
-0.1972072273,
0.3095620275,
-0.209161371,
-0.250038296,
-0.8017340302,
-0.4615803063,
-0.1559519023,
-0.061943192,
0.5959655643,
0.061727155,
0.8935194016,
0.5058591962,
0.7597007751,
0.399638921,
0.1033728346,
0.399319917,
-0.1665491909,
0.1216657981,
-0.1467767656,
-0.1647310257,
-0.5298530459,
-0.0505026132,
0.7585849166,
0.6834151745,
0.111565724,
0.0053736633,
-0.039564237,
0.3706674874,
-0.621737361,
0.0149858836,
-0.5401024222,
0.0082223723,
-0.5037663579,
-0.1947267354,
-0.2017672509,
0.0257203598,
0.001133525,
-0.4077216387,
-0.0600851029,
0.2678526938,
0.7206712365,
0.3222348094,
-1.1677588224,
-0.2088646293,
-0.7095975876,
1.0847871304,
-0.8720523119,
0.7928685546,
0.3225559592,
0.3999365568,
-0.0275156107,
-0.3792986572,
-0.7887455225,
-0.1781739891,
-0.0179828312,
0.0199465379,
0.1667674333,
0.2101244181,
0.1228406355,
0.3025303483,
-0.7662234306,
0.1042231843,
-0.3580427766,
-0.3713416755,
0.5024536848,
0.3476946652,
0.30075261,
-0.3617318869,
-0.4947825074,
0.061243996,
-0.6392448545,
0.101735279,
0.40119192,
0.2554485202,
-0.0716055855,
0.8003709316,
0.2097547203,
1.1336253881,
-0.2123497874,
-0.6064597964,
0.3276924789,
-1.0388201475,
-0.2481215,
-0.2054200172,
0.6543955207,
0.6015632153,
-0.1829088479,
0.0278037414,
-0.3153046966,
0.0142212221,
0.106723845,
-0.5191613436,
0.3190972805,
0.036873851,
-0.6458904743,
0.0159692243,
-0.1078949347,
-0.6986734867,
-0.4216153622,
-0.8076662421,
0.5141572952,
-0.3955782652,
-0.3969528973,
0.0814029723,
0.1950377971,
0.3808736503,
0.6300138831,
-0.8881309032,
0.0409108251,
0.5318851471,
0.8798780441,
-0.0932275057,
-0.242554605,
-0.1848136634,
0.5317845345,
-0.0779180154,
0.4378106892,
-0.732847929,
-0.0687085018,
0.000181239,
0.17985861,
-0.4055410326,
-0.0357244611,
0.4773242772,
-0.6257773042,
0.7147473693,
-0.2087987065,
-0.3896102905,
-0.4889493287,
0.6365891695,
-0.7852455974,
0.7830356956,
0.0026916894,
-0.8271986246,
0.1477166265,
-0.7574545145,
-0.2138062567,
-0.3706230521,
-0.3097728789,
-0.1967247576,
-0.0278168451,
0.2674635053,
0.3210770488,
-0.4236813486,
0.4031701982,
-0.217122063,
-0.0635615215,
0.5817884803,
-0.8566693068,
0.6457839012,
0.4034688175,
-0.2602018714,
0.3557468355,
-0.4865475595,
-0.0105224289,
-0.2346392721,
-0.3985408843,
-0.2877550125,
0.0464218147,
0.6076080799,
0.552075386,
0.4673216939,
-0.4183318019,
0.4610320032,
0.0284778997,
0.6469723582,
0.911192894,
-0.3792507648,
0.4964677095,
-0.3686159253,
0.5130022168,
0.1951833814,
0.3362162411,
-0.3822315335,
-0.3315547407,
-0.4378001392,
-0.267270267,
0.4091343582,
0.4600317478,
-0.7469289899,
0.2797168195,
-0.3018657863,
-0.1442431659,
-0.5276094079,
0.231460914,
0.1727284193,
0.4352137148,
0.2065482736,
-0.1612096876,
-0.4273845255,
-0.8860899806,
0.1896394938,
-0.001747814,
0.1533991545,
0.357929647,
0.2642932236,
-0.4604094028,
0.859785378,
-0.2074270546,
-0.2041433603,
0.0164880678,
-0.0591081642,
0.069819577,
0.5195275545,
0.4163128138,
-1.2810928822,
-0.1383575946,
0.2577102184,
-0.5769000649,
0.1413138807,
-0.0772243291,
0.1064410955,
0.3226726949,
0.518067956,
-0.6059616804,
0.0151418643,
0.9555749297,
-0.4601895809,
0.2933995426,
0.0392169841,
0.568538487,
-1.2374410629,
0.2219507396,
-0.024772957,
-0.3545856774,
-0.675886035,
-0.0213197749,
0.1814198643,
-0.1230960935,
-0.3174427748,
0.4661544561,
-0.9303098917,
0.0051475684,
-0.1203015894,
0.0662350953,
-0.003705689,
0.3019450009,
-0.1757943034,
0.7733269334,
0.5520899892,
-0.2442935109,
0.5660100579,
0.2073842436,
-0.2030629963,
0.6049420834,
-0.2212999612,
0.123204343,
-0.2921909988,
0.2720236778,
-1.2557485104,
-0.3794752955,
0.3010341525,
-0.0899594128,
0.491353929,
-0.0174282175,
-0.4136298895,
-0.1498537064,
-0.3489304185,
0.9410229921,
0.05870305,
-0.0920964107,
0.8931593299,
0.2300994396,
-0.3463854492,
-0.6825349331,
-0.6118956804,
0.445928812,
-0.4028187394,
-0.9176553488,
0.318179369,
-0.3500449061,
-0.1908478141,
-0.1582280844,
0.0729851946,
-0.0731368586,
-0.1861984879,
0.1694025248,
0.4853466749,
-0.425398469,
0.328779757,
-0.2731431723,
0.1101643294,
-0.3160023987,
0.1054446772,
0.5340505838,
-0.091053918,
-0.7000150084,
-0.359302938,
0.4793608189,
0.9175384045,
-0.4320920408,
0.5268830657,
0.7844233513,
-0.2804786265,
0.5909293294,
-0.8988738656,
0.0277058501,
-0.420496136,
0.3276773095,
-0.3976148665,
-1.0527950525,
0.1474226713,
-0.0781701356,
0.0207458064,
0.0773152635,
0.6074831486,
0.063613914,
1.2554838657,
0.7617759109,
-0.0427585132,
0.6569032669,
0.1369657964,
0.4340785444,
-0.9873663783,
-0.3038103282,
-0.1908945292,
-0.5418901443,
-0.4158597291,
-0.7607430816,
0.4131830037,
0.05644444,
-0.2209914923,
0.0186805688,
-0.2697862983,
0.2136568874,
0.2293863893,
0.0222104173,
0.5326766968,
-0.1472032517,
0.1459988654,
-0.3946774304,
-0.4799411297,
-0.529171586,
0.9672225714,
0.5836077332,
0.83177948,
0.6079007387,
0.0829299167,
0.073369734,
0.1791082174,
-0.842359364,
0.3814011216,
0.2533504367,
-0.7294617891,
-0.4441759884,
-0.2419677228,
-0.7737312913,
0.4434072375,
-0.3198631704,
-0.5244840384,
0.1801261008,
-0.0871964991,
-0.031810239,
0.2183012217,
-0.6484114528,
0.9494684935,
-0.5651538372,
-0.4123570919,
-0.1036334783,
-0.9453549385,
0.5910581946,
-0.2929325998,
0.5518485904,
-0.127040565,
-0.409645021,
0.3365053236,
-0.1291305274,
0.8700524569,
-0.068276979,
-0.4876134098,
-0.0786970258,
-0.0926154181,
0.3811309934,
-0.2992266417,
0.0925524607,
0.0220736377,
-0.0965655372,
-0.2744292617,
-0.4588778019,
0.6168214679,
-0.6017335653,
-0.5023279786,
-0.3506166041,
-1.0471971035,
-0.4265456796,
0.2152448446,
-0.0377411433,
0.5622534156,
-0.0256700888,
0.2488925755,
0.6078929901,
-0.0003271141,
0.747525692,
0.4684992731,
-0.1002331525,
-0.5680946708,
0.6979116201,
0.1196168289,
0.4115864635,
0.4958336353,
-0.0488677993,
-0.5172554851,
-0.5590360165,
-0.6315768361,
0.2108973414,
-0.5585431457,
-0.3334528506,
-0.5856958628,
-0.0883066356,
-0.6082777977,
-0.1925396472,
-0.0869280845,
-0.1830930859,
-0.0202294905,
0.127056092,
0.2473767251,
0.5683385134,
-0.1036766768,
0.190993771,
-0.8742606044,
0.1233054847,
0.309401989,
0.1571416259,
-0.0076543195,
-0.2828160822,
-0.1069791541,
0.1161452308,
-0.4452622533,
-0.8308942318,
0.153899163,
0.0888583511,
0.5736191869,
0.5560070872,
-0.4062748849,
0.8716965318,
-0.5334703326,
0.9353538156,
0.5973581076,
-0.8970823288,
0.2554037571,
-0.6595131159,
0.2685097456,
0.2565939426,
0.4130806923,
-0.8058421016,
-0.0586734228,
-0.1204759851,
-0.7804389,
0.2926182747,
0.0087508233,
0.1096634418,
0.3542491496,
-0.2654671371,
0.096305348,
0.3656403422,
-1.0242235661,
0.0747000426,
-0.2475086302,
-0.5158115029,
-0.1986478269,
-0.1006674692,
-0.463217169,
-0.2108136415,
0.3146519363,
-0.3192964196,
0.047737889,
-0.0295291413,
-0.2831650972,
-0.12943995,
0.6231834888,
1.0155926943,
0.9817024469,
0.0326658748,
0.4266327918,
-0.0354533568,
-0.3016472459,
0.3982911706,
0.0473097004,
0.1444882303,
-0.1706532836,
0.4077980518,
0.6095042229,
0.2559918463,
-0.7574187517,
0.8019192219,
0.0641522408,
-0.0519634746,
-0.0217037462,
-0.2652821243,
0.1968126148,
0.4652894139,
0.2444369048,
0.0541148782,
0.0330187157,
-0.6401603818,
-0.1196756288,
0.8078167439,
-0.1958729029,
-0.2842676044,
0.6695716381,
0.1852006763,
0.0230447836,
0.4322128892,
0.2221883833,
-0.2675666809,
0.2084427923,
0.5607907176,
0.4494925439,
-0.366624862,
-0.0123271123,
0.0881511867,
0.3876538873,
-0.0007915905,
0.1730234325,
-0.0932871476,
-0.7087187171,
-0.8313695788,
-0.4733959436,
-0.1844519675,
0.1930649728,
-0.2420474589,
0.1435981095,
-0.1187152714,
-0.2813515663,
-0.1538570523,
-0.2579028308,
-0.5937938094,
-0.0607988648,
0.3178434074,
0.7088544965,
-1.0412291288,
0.6354885697,
0.8349634409,
-0.4690503776,
-0.709474504,
-0.0604270771,
0.2636690736,
-0.6139473319,
0.6817433238,
0.1322483569,
-0.0996481255,
-0.1748630852,
-0.5959284902,
-1.0296617746,
1.2028056383,
0.212485522,
-0.6809639335,
-0.2497989237,
0.2023202777,
0.2269617915,
-0.2833561301,
0.0738587156,
0.2299797833,
0.9529730678,
0.0468076058,
-1.2198535204,
0.1236655936,
-0.2046910822,
0.2041881233,
0.4603753984,
-0.6940717697,
0.8885623813,
0.0083425082,
-0.0942373276,
0.2043393552,
0.4365770221,
0.0748623684,
0.3488043249,
0.5895462632,
0.5688037872,
0.6131131053,
-0.0272014216,
0.5750318766,
-0.1248133257,
0.235680908,
0.7418265343,
-0.3460467756,
0.5809419155,
0.899985373,
-0.0717191771,
0.2265995592,
0.616435945,
-0.0211862121,
0.440787375,
-0.0372867621,
-0.4396475255,
-0.3345726728,
-0.255805701,
-0.5969205499,
0.5670875907,
0.2525398731,
-0.2093148381,
-0.2961538136,
0.3350420892,
-0.0857014731,
-0.1085472479,
-0.3179084063,
0.6176595092,
-0.275305301,
-0.4287984073,
0.3635728657,
0.0650563613,
0.8929473162,
-0.7645767331,
-0.1211702004,
0.0953377858,
-0.0642984584,
-0.3422846198,
-0.6548906565,
0.0500311702,
-0.3714331388,
-0.3990309834,
-0.2850432098,
0.6326331496,
-0.6446754336,
-0.3969588578,
-0.0515787266,
0.7028253675,
-0.0514598303,
0.2529291511,
-0.6847060919,
0.4721411765,
-0.0046485048,
-0.2148245722,
0.3121502697,
0.526319623,
-0.2361065596,
0.4533716738,
0.6422557235,
-0.1203948259,
0.1895390004,
0.0585600287,
0.8739337325,
-0.8521525264,
-0.197619468,
-0.7884962559,
0.6817269325,
-0.0453930534,
-0.1891546696,
0.791675806,
0.7048304081,
0.6274998784,
-0.0352717377,
0.7349502444,
-0.1837534308,
0.2364783436,
-0.8899595141,
0.279900223,
-0.6530305147,
0.032627292,
-0.3214613199,
-1.0977550745,
-0.2212831974,
0.4883564711,
-0.2642096281,
0.1191746071,
0.7816476822,
1.0300451517,
-0.3441783488,
-0.1790165007,
0.4356349409,
0.084708035,
0.5200865865,
0.5004802346,
1.0800882578,
-0.3083561957,
0.3640551269,
0.2227413803,
-0.2451789528,
-0.1774193645,
-1.0249298811,
-0.5817008018,
-0.8637709022,
-0.0275484752,
-0.0431149378,
-0.2421216667,
0.8091077805,
0.7265742421,
-0.3718753159,
-0.1868172288,
0.2251309156,
-0.0386160165,
-0.0430521332,
-0.2608224154,
0.2591403425,
-0.2130660564,
-0.8688678145,
0.4249327779,
0.4415163994,
0.3117475212,
-0.6193259358,
-0.0475494079,
-0.3720855117,
-0.1320436448,
0.6920800805,
0.0646672845,
-0.9580587745,
-0.3442606926,
0.046086587,
-0.2833782434,
0.1611591727,
1.0846157074,
-0.3300817013,
0.4978090227,
0.4949505627,
0.7015962005,
0.1753551513,
-0.0208441243,
0.5323423743,
-0.5379202962,
0.1748316735,
0.1588926315,
0.4625579715,
0.6332962513,
-0.1662806869,
0.378998965,
0.0826240256,
-0.7232993245,
-0.8159347177,
0.479568243,
-1.355784893,
-0.4088291824,
1.1401284933,
0.44169572,
-0.0385608003,
-0.289960146,
-0.6404779553,
0.0059512225,
0.0006433763,
0.5530334711,
0.8996680975,
-0.1871530712,
-0.3643423319,
-0.7471186519,
0.2053852677,
0.1545945108,
-0.6966839433,
0.0654119551,
1.0235453844,
0.2746938169,
0.2577754259,
0.5725528002,
-0.2763953507,
0.0380764492,
-0.379239291,
0.0029303946,
-0.1225223839,
-0.1404042691,
-0.4647856653,
0.0999112725,
0.0364113413,
-0.0678254738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14699v1
|
Ontology Learning Using Formal Concept Analysis and WordNet
| 2023-11-10T08:28:30 | 2023-11-10T08:28:30 |
Bryar A. Hassan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Manual ontology construction takes time, resources, and domain specialists.
Supporting a component of this process for automation or semi-automation would
be good. This project and dissertation provide a Formal Concept Analysis and
WordNet framework for learning concept hierarchies from free texts. The process
has steps. First, the document is Part-Of-Speech labeled, then parsed to
produce sentence parse trees. Verb/noun dependencies are derived from parse
trees next. After lemmatizing, pruning, and filtering the word pairings, the
formal context is created. The formal context may contain some erroneous and
uninteresting pairs because the parser output may be erroneous, not all derived
pairs are interesting, and it may be large due to constructing it from a large
free text corpus. Deriving lattice from the formal context may take longer,
depending on the size and complexity of the data. Thus, decreasing formal
context may eliminate erroneous and uninteresting pairs and speed up idea
lattice derivation. WordNet-based and Frequency-based approaches are tested.
Finally, we compute formal idea lattice and create a classical concept
hierarchy. The reduced concept lattice is compared to the original to evaluate
the outcomes. Despite several system constraints and component discrepancies
that may prevent logical conclusion, the following data imply idea hierarchies
in this project and dissertation are promising. First, the reduced idea lattice
and original concept have commonalities. Second, alternative language or
statistical methods can reduce formal context size. Finally, WordNet-based and
Frequency-based approaches reduce formal context differently, and the order of
applying them is examined to reduce context efficiently.
|
[
-0.1458268017,
-0.7307397723,
0.4676571786,
-0.1064547673,
-0.0259097181,
-0.0671722665,
0.1499572247,
-0.4790418446,
0.277225554,
0.575704813,
-0.4153506756,
-0.5295865536,
-0.3418998718,
-0.0313086286,
-0.4772467613,
0.6963171363,
-0.070729807,
-0.1001291275,
-0.1421082169,
0.1059627905,
-0.387363404,
-0.0745997727,
-0.6104465723,
-0.4719542563,
0.1746899188,
0.5525115132,
0.5195540786,
0.8975647688,
0.5766065717,
0.3598968089,
-0.0663546473,
0.1070351675,
-0.4132991731,
0.1650695652,
-0.3383500278,
-0.5204066634,
-0.4988135397,
0.0251579881,
0.5035079122,
0.704872787,
-0.2593630552,
0.2170228511,
0.0019916401,
0.6538199782,
-0.7530646324,
0.6557840705,
-0.65874511,
0.4262893498,
-0.2465151548,
-0.4980924428,
-0.0544493459,
-0.1160277426,
0.3307539523,
-1.0787508488,
0.0726535693,
0.3595485091,
0.9769656658,
0.0274068937,
-0.108818464,
-0.5236974359,
-0.5835773945,
0.740278542,
-0.4374014139,
0.2001807541,
0.7364792228,
0.2616944015,
0.0179219805,
-0.9675664902,
-0.6057053208,
-0.2080039382,
-0.1168443486,
0.2831813991,
0.1188819632,
0.1587630957,
0.2767695785,
0.479019165,
-0.5688607097,
-0.0348166823,
-0.257904321,
-0.1989050508,
0.5860534906,
0.2179978043,
0.399830699,
-0.7917855978,
-0.2379838526,
-0.0521690734,
-0.4227036834,
-0.0529207997,
0.0649982765,
0.3934292197,
0.0380541086,
0.6012368798,
-0.3677541614,
0.339035213,
-0.1938640475,
-0.4112619758,
0.2109910101,
-0.2307409048,
-0.3366231024,
0.2140071094,
0.5395181775,
0.0378653966,
0.3818824589,
-0.5148596168,
-0.2638956308,
0.3744779825,
0.2577967644,
-0.5651907921,
-0.0346041135,
0.3896987736,
-0.5517441034,
-0.4327176213,
0.1433632523,
-0.5136620998,
-0.0832636878,
-0.5917969346,
0.4700634778,
-0.6894461513,
-0.0380152501,
0.1477864534,
-0.3055438101,
0.3997390568,
0.2364016622,
-0.8366640806,
0.6383405924,
0.9602686167,
1.0109887123,
0.0996600613,
0.034193702,
-0.1319857389,
0.4052629173,
-0.6763712168,
0.5541809797,
-0.3239637017,
-0.4324904978,
-0.1073627099,
-0.0411492512,
0.1554241627,
-0.2753131986,
0.4568532407,
-0.5991932154,
0.3511158228,
-0.1128975078,
-0.869343996,
-0.2228242755,
0.5200784802,
-0.5783482194,
1.0971293449,
0.1722613275,
-1.1910203695,
0.2680684626,
-1.0307351351,
-0.4282185733,
0.485596925,
-0.4657225907,
0.1182497218,
-0.1283391267,
-0.5288083553,
0.470073998,
-0.5033528209,
0.1674248725,
0.0522764213,
-0.1957544386,
-0.0906684175,
0.3398295343,
0.87275666,
0.4674956799,
-0.4340132177,
0.0521311425,
-1.2787567377,
0.1077004895,
0.0414771624,
-0.0040682806,
-0.9398365617,
0.3160179555,
-0.0802760944,
0.2651245594,
-0.144965902,
-0.7143067122,
0.1228616163,
-0.9479691982,
0.3513053954,
0.5361533165,
0.0384934098,
0.5819718242,
-0.3165971935,
0.2629378736,
-0.1452862769,
-0.0224563107,
0.1282224953,
-0.3056854606,
-0.8957255483,
0.0102528213,
0.5236733556,
0.7966746688,
-1.134632349,
0.5972523689,
-0.4061408043,
-0.2191061676,
-0.3123031259,
-0.1367728263,
0.4508975148,
0.423355937,
0.2996499538,
-0.539208591,
-0.4843861163,
-0.5889546871,
0.1280891746,
-0.2931094766,
-0.244899109,
0.0619201995,
0.7323198915,
-0.0763047338,
1.3310114145,
-0.750133872,
-0.5693255663,
0.118724443,
0.2475229055,
-0.1310824454,
0.3289943039,
0.1740880013,
-0.9015091062,
-0.0721747577,
0.2090070397,
-0.966653049,
0.142725721,
0.2210218608,
-0.2334338278,
0.1744341552,
0.6149014831,
-0.1326240748,
0.4766595364,
0.0326110311,
-0.304348886,
0.3299508691,
-0.1103546247,
-0.2180912644,
-1.5475463867,
0.2365534902,
-0.2106271982,
0.0253377222,
-0.6606631875,
0.2700267732,
-0.1411808431,
0.0548451617,
-0.2523896694,
0.4915139973,
-0.4222057462,
-0.0540136136,
-0.2351785004,
0.4600079358,
-0.0786754712,
0.3500947058,
0.0144739794,
0.2039697617,
0.3831882179,
-0.754637301,
0.450931251,
0.5072183013,
-0.5836724043,
0.2660633326,
-0.5288318992,
-0.1096282229,
-0.2019070536,
-0.0775827467,
-0.8810099363,
-0.0582996272,
0.4730308056,
-0.3531909585,
0.1708084792,
0.0738495588,
-0.5909128189,
-0.1281170547,
-0.3437145352,
-0.1551814675,
0.3119682968,
-0.1439062804,
0.3554241359,
0.4340246916,
0.0346830152,
-0.6006398201,
-0.9286757112,
0.0115313884,
0.0851372033,
-0.7404944897,
0.6494932771,
0.29926458,
-0.6156557798,
0.4542479813,
-0.1333326846,
-0.220738858,
0.279674232,
0.3126808107,
0.1045118123,
-0.0274034161,
0.8501300216,
-0.1202426255,
-0.1900543869,
0.1295479387,
-0.6702677608,
0.3781622946,
-0.0472212136,
0.0193366986,
-0.2000722885,
0.14271231,
0.2008433938,
-0.175294593,
0.8634410501,
0.4605128765,
-0.5562488437,
-0.4490180314,
0.0110613545,
-0.1680142432,
-0.4366528094,
0.2288286239,
-0.5751078129,
-0.8207927942,
0.2203758657,
0.021084737,
0.3265153468,
0.5919790268,
0.2800393701,
0.1348107606,
0.2312728763,
0.7932702899,
0.2730099559,
0.3410998881,
-0.7613358498,
0.209540695,
-0.4877075851,
-0.2362112701,
-0.561897099,
0.0051340288,
-0.8152222633,
-0.2619870901,
0.0554408655,
-0.0874069706,
0.0223817229,
0.1735192537,
-0.2341567278,
0.152221024,
0.3032838106,
-0.0655822754,
0.5027288198,
0.2128494829,
-0.4752167761,
0.2711155117,
-0.6714796424,
-0.6402602792,
0.9396492839,
0.1633049548,
0.497089237,
0.1833755225,
0.6372569203,
0.252361536,
0.0350665301,
-1.2717006207,
0.6669142842,
-0.2445660681,
-0.5944341421,
-0.6828075051,
-0.694458425,
-1.0296366215,
0.3055186868,
-0.5075696707,
-0.6019488573,
-0.1082247794,
-0.082338281,
-0.2142184079,
0.1840125173,
-0.285595566,
0.4723595977,
0.2457581908,
-0.3732104599,
-0.2759369314,
-0.903157711,
0.4510331154,
-0.312492311,
0.5363602638,
-0.1195528954,
0.042853184,
0.9342877269,
-0.6067137122,
0.8835391998,
0.1397185773,
-0.4317623973,
0.456448108,
0.2161013186,
0.0671830475,
-0.0352328196,
-0.2707225978,
-0.0895355418,
0.3176543117,
-0.2020399123,
-0.68325454,
0.2656046748,
-0.7736604214,
-0.3655995429,
-0.3543685377,
-0.4376045167,
-0.261398524,
0.3009536266,
0.3551060557,
0.7684995532,
-0.4063767195,
0.0383696854,
0.6137754321,
0.1339919865,
0.4916545749,
0.4260004461,
-0.2056697607,
0.0173702519,
0.8598123193,
0.6634355187,
0.1674835831,
0.896281004,
0.5730662942,
-0.2141221166,
-0.2423931211,
0.0814321041,
-0.0742218345,
-0.6666918993,
0.0203784686,
-0.606791079,
-0.4352934659,
-0.6825568676,
0.2024092525,
-0.0599305443,
-0.9166870117,
-0.0675109774,
0.0497756302,
0.4693888128,
0.6937742829,
0.15612185,
0.3770659864,
-0.9160566926,
0.4344674647,
0.3095736802,
0.3825164437,
0.276789993,
-0.4661071301,
-0.1266524643,
-0.1045802757,
-0.3026739359,
-0.6911117435,
0.1689019352,
0.3561052382,
0.4190514386,
0.7042649984,
0.2334819734,
0.2287347764,
-0.5537098646,
0.4554058313,
0.160126552,
-1.1728366613,
0.5786017179,
-0.2575392723,
-0.0134466691,
0.3162319362,
0.5821763873,
-1.0095367432,
0.0683070198,
-0.849124372,
-0.7169477344,
0.7411606908,
0.3634757102,
-0.2362033427,
-0.0081289588,
0.6363540888,
-0.0710303634,
0.1364184916,
-0.4465229511,
-0.3928226531,
-0.1601691395,
-0.2307797968,
0.0185543802,
-0.1224124581,
-0.1442963183,
-0.0900711343,
0.6510288119,
-0.2462698519,
0.0135509307,
0.1506909281,
-0.1812498719,
0.0704928711,
0.504424274,
0.1944995821,
0.6638044715,
-0.1491371691,
0.275708884,
0.1355483681,
-0.4599403441,
0.1775912195,
-0.3413695395,
-0.333062917,
-0.1428696811,
0.5591028929,
0.6698637009,
0.3460922837,
-0.3750804365,
0.3549997807,
0.0752250925,
-0.4929902256,
-0.2654577792,
0.0035634558,
0.1133941039,
-0.1831142008,
-0.052992221,
-0.1382889748,
0.3614670634,
-0.7675963044,
0.2544534504,
0.1329671592,
-0.4130802751,
-0.2751943171,
-0.0373189263,
0.2256096303,
-0.2077798247,
0.3486514986,
-0.5895509124,
-0.3447767198,
0.523984313,
0.4628553987,
0.8675907254,
-0.211872071,
0.4142565727,
0.1236679778,
0.2055429816,
-0.130752638,
0.4942012727,
-0.1498586237,
-1.1413437128,
-0.2921718061,
-0.8508329391,
-0.3475343585,
-0.1075281426,
-0.5065864921,
0.133485198,
-0.5839944482,
0.0247883778,
0.0738932714,
0.3554702401,
-0.2105207294,
0.2613874376,
-0.1625657827,
0.7844153047,
-0.758451879,
0.8840407729,
0.8917142153,
-0.3837740123,
-1.0024662018,
-0.0911497548,
0.1596669406,
-0.5492662787,
0.9066861272,
-0.0474395491,
-0.4376766384,
0.1109000072,
-0.3040425479,
-0.8772755861,
1.0668021441,
-0.2302900404,
-0.4280272424,
-0.3054794669,
0.1038514301,
0.6387445331,
-0.1982545406,
-0.0938626602,
0.4711943269,
0.5258556008,
0.3905549347,
-0.6330903172,
0.1525315046,
-0.2316479087,
0.1904769391,
0.3407276869,
-0.3416697979,
0.8990371823,
0.1149690747,
-0.681071341,
0.0532662384,
0.5965915918,
-0.1098623648,
0.2744051218,
0.5760819316,
0.6403929591,
0.8620938659,
0.0953008085,
0.71382761,
-0.4240503609,
0.441303432,
0.8045657873,
-0.4104165733,
0.8433572054,
0.3113675416,
-0.1711981744,
0.6151477695,
0.64752841,
0.0948290676,
0.3182542026,
0.7053125501,
-0.0414264426,
0.078147985,
-0.153522253,
-0.3878831565,
0.825635612,
0.6234806776,
0.0185647923,
-0.3065659702,
-0.0801173523,
0.0021590882,
0.0465939827,
-0.3273258507,
0.7771090269,
0.3130384386,
-0.307055831,
0.287668407,
0.2892159224,
0.5382048488,
-0.7529554963,
0.0699982494,
0.0820792466,
0.146286279,
-0.4322991371,
-0.2596876621,
0.3697531521,
-0.2674285173,
-0.1783523411,
-0.0978223979,
0.827044785,
-0.3448791206,
-0.415536046,
0.4454458356,
0.755440414,
0.1506049484,
0.3265457451,
-0.5296978354,
-0.6140493155,
-0.4676629603,
-0.175660789,
0.0496359915,
0.690058291,
-0.3244365156,
0.4647862017,
0.4887880981,
0.1522518843,
-0.2439076602,
0.0312481038,
0.6756660342,
-0.7224453688,
-0.7686525583,
-0.6747302413,
-0.1868040711,
-0.0009798243,
-0.2806235552,
0.7579720616,
0.3359127939,
0.8287630081,
0.1248979047,
0.6315664649,
-0.2603957653,
0.3994025886,
-0.8909428716,
0.8488885164,
-0.6842309237,
0.1125257015,
-0.4925192297,
-0.8434091806,
-0.4007494152,
0.5992327929,
-0.1331140399,
-0.3043288887,
1.0403574705,
0.7034156919,
0.0830708146,
0.3927456737,
0.4386154115,
0.0106492955,
0.0837138668,
0.1144553199,
0.865935564,
-0.4044984579,
0.1733487844,
-0.1189438924,
-0.6179339886,
-0.0409189537,
-0.8072907329,
-0.5868418813,
-0.6591743827,
-0.2613641322,
-0.2658329308,
0.1155753285,
1.1122299433,
0.6940939426,
-0.7256391644,
-0.548283875,
-0.2668083906,
0.1685454249,
-0.0784111246,
-0.2766839564,
0.5577041507,
-0.6133255959,
-0.3103660643,
0.2432383299,
0.2641185522,
-0.0921976045,
-0.0809435397,
0.1349422485,
-0.4282304049,
0.2459310293,
0.9205059409,
0.1856420636,
-0.6099874377,
-0.4045134485,
-0.0795878097,
-0.2877384722,
-0.0946258828,
0.9709385633,
-0.5478063226,
0.2990335822,
0.8244837523,
0.5795077682,
0.2852376103,
-0.1502730697,
0.3114704192,
-0.8166648149,
0.1295053214,
-0.0222035199,
0.2836925685,
-0.1464490145,
-0.1702390611,
0.6747104526,
0.6026236415,
-0.0700441748,
-0.361271143,
0.371060282,
-0.8141987324,
-0.7677536607,
1.0710892677,
-0.0320841298,
-0.4389259815,
-0.5304948688,
-0.0366735272,
0.5549853444,
0.0565740354,
0.7661424875,
0.7471289039,
-0.0680103973,
0.3490360081,
-0.3314702511,
0.5801167488,
0.3279412985,
-1.0160757303,
-0.1595733911,
0.1506223828,
0.152466014,
0.6833336949,
0.6129454374,
-0.2223035097,
-0.0480050519,
0.1136075407,
0.4770026207,
0.0107795782,
-0.3885371685,
-0.2037654966,
0.3906744421,
-0.1671127528,
-0.2710530758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05928v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05928v2
|
The Shape of Learning: Anisotropy and Intrinsic Dimensions in Transformer-Based Models
| 2023-11-10T08:25:02 | 2024-02-26T06:46:17 |
Anton Razzhigaev, Matvey Mikhalchuk, Elizaveta Goncharova, Ivan Oseledets, Denis Dimitrov, Andrey Kuznetsov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.GN, math.IT
|
In this study, we present an investigation into the anisotropy dynamics and
intrinsic dimension of embeddings in transformer architectures, focusing on the
dichotomy between encoders and decoders. Our findings reveal that the
anisotropy profile in transformer decoders exhibits a distinct bell-shaped
curve, with the highest anisotropy concentrations in the middle layers. This
pattern diverges from the more uniformly distributed anisotropy observed in
encoders. In addition, we found that the intrinsic dimension of embeddings
increases in the initial phases of training, indicating an expansion into
higher-dimensional space. Which is then followed by a compression phase towards
the end of training with dimensionality decrease, suggesting a refinement into
more compact representations. Our results provide fresh insights to the
understanding of encoders and decoders embedding properties.
|
[
-0.2698820531,
-0.4695426822,
0.4641679525,
-0.1817861199,
0.099716261,
0.2683137953,
-0.0220706407,
-0.2656504512,
0.3313250542,
0.1416626722,
-0.4917304516,
-0.1668802351,
-0.9167397022,
0.0666990131,
-0.646515429,
0.657755971,
-0.0799129978,
0.019317409,
-0.2708183229,
-0.1650041789,
-0.0509517603,
-0.5668298006,
-0.3853527009,
-0.3895349205,
0.2765218914,
0.0402498394,
0.8159311414,
0.9781598449,
0.4573672116,
0.2895021439,
-0.3428887129,
-0.4087047875,
-0.3440305591,
0.2495069653,
0.246721819,
-0.8178063631,
-0.0386673994,
-0.1274740845,
0.6864681244,
0.7148469687,
-0.2451412082,
0.0402783453,
0.2113654315,
0.7060645223,
-0.3499435484,
0.4371223748,
-0.2410632968,
0.4662699401,
0.2917847633,
-0.2660266459,
-0.2632811368,
-0.6004832983,
0.3569729924,
-0.4723984599,
0.7120401263,
-0.0210466534,
0.7894131541,
0.5531287789,
-0.5643564463,
-0.5964585543,
-1.0342868567,
0.5482607484,
-0.0508284979,
0.8484264612,
-0.0753881633,
0.6128866076,
0.3720347285,
-0.6889717579,
-0.4688847661,
0.0437632911,
-0.2082494944,
0.0222387556,
-0.2655713558,
-0.0134235192,
0.3217741549,
0.591874063,
-0.3926340342,
0.1667774171,
-0.6659508944,
0.0680463612,
0.4688907862,
0.1897530109,
0.1075006127,
-0.012702398,
-0.3324700892,
-0.6618234515,
-0.4450570941,
0.3621690869,
0.6418290138,
-0.0568335056,
-0.2888657749,
0.3613197803,
0.3615195751,
0.1634681672,
0.5591501594,
-0.2925161719,
0.3866946101,
0.1048346311,
0.2374152541,
0.5130240321,
0.3716633916,
-0.0436779335,
0.1431509554,
-0.4327591658,
-0.1483987421,
-0.0298065692,
0.6608898044,
-0.8876897693,
-0.305565834,
-0.0243036617,
-0.755235076,
-0.2230410576,
0.3273717463,
-0.5293912888,
-0.2516595423,
-0.4823920429,
0.4468050003,
-0.5598574877,
-0.3063650131,
0.311232537,
-0.5483328104,
0.7950017452,
0.162441507,
-1.2579222918,
0.3170400262,
0.301704824,
0.6728986502,
0.1252419502,
-0.2844547927,
0.4443219304,
0.1311625391,
-0.2398979515,
0.5448436141,
-0.8654205203,
-0.4473545849,
0.2126176953,
0.0065730582,
-0.1119163334,
-0.6759970188,
0.1744622439,
-0.6384418607,
-0.0362722203,
-0.3786932528,
-0.4033796489,
-0.6362711191,
0.30651173,
-0.7545494437,
0.7703466415,
0.4420903623,
-0.5212135911,
0.6123033762,
-0.5131769776,
-0.3103354275,
-0.1951909214,
-0.2951037288,
-0.5470403433,
0.5832090974,
-0.072204113,
0.2901717722,
0.0364971831,
-0.268872261,
-0.26686728,
-0.581332624,
0.5080459714,
-0.5405153632,
0.5914928317,
-0.0031839111,
-0.184251219,
-0.212893635,
-0.9306685328,
-0.302003026,
0.1818430871,
-0.3718322814,
-0.0259361267,
0.0445843637,
-0.05809398,
0.2859913111,
0.1691396087,
-0.6848646998,
0.4253424108,
0.1351290792,
0.8764386177,
0.5050755739,
0.2472860217,
0.698015511,
-0.2206287533,
0.3688626587,
0.4399642944,
0.4054158926,
-0.1548886895,
-0.154010579,
-0.5451855063,
-0.2528836131,
0.0464839749,
0.2407131046,
-0.1979735494,
0.4750836492,
-0.5057947636,
-0.3395708501,
-0.6172921062,
-0.3637079895,
-0.0281938855,
0.1498941034,
0.5753384829,
-0.1631297767,
-0.0241221115,
-0.7528247237,
0.0730305016,
-0.0075090122,
-0.4079212546,
0.1594408453,
0.6659056544,
-0.4853553474,
0.8536971211,
-0.5094166994,
-0.2326072752,
0.0644219741,
0.0207362249,
-0.0159981586,
0.4246425033,
0.6678576469,
-0.8528828025,
-0.3797779083,
-0.028628828,
-0.7669792771,
0.5110241771,
-0.1447646916,
0.2467900962,
-0.0916175768,
0.2467449903,
-0.5071859956,
0.5917711258,
0.2383958101,
-0.338367939,
0.4594365656,
-0.5061680675,
0.0835794806,
-0.6868508458,
-0.2934063971,
0.0688747093,
0.3020456135,
-0.5174953341,
-0.1684530973,
0.3557551801,
-0.0725648031,
-0.1584378481,
-0.1500319839,
-0.5829633474,
-0.381326139,
-0.0492516682,
-0.2988357246,
0.2112895697,
0.5177177191,
0.066546239,
0.4754413962,
0.7444519401,
-0.67992872,
0.2321472615,
0.5931711793,
-0.0922380835,
0.6232514977,
-0.88054353,
0.0710765198,
-0.516857028,
0.0374972709,
-0.6063290834,
-0.011906838,
-0.3507002592,
-0.393546015,
0.761370182,
-0.3301961422,
-0.4095502794,
-0.4030562639,
-0.4275763333,
0.4283194542,
0.702045083,
-0.7745618224,
0.7487007976,
0.231400758,
0.3456964493,
-0.3411174417,
-0.876713872,
-0.2648968101,
-0.3886084557,
-0.4709530175,
0.6165066361,
0.1014775187,
0.1065557078,
0.4373903275,
-0.2110942304,
-0.0878496245,
-0.2287502587,
0.4523083568,
-0.0756873637,
-0.3919500113,
-0.1032322571,
0.2750999331,
-0.021725744,
0.5003131628,
-0.5109225512,
0.6264596581,
-0.2427988797,
-0.2519119978,
-0.6391573548,
0.1441875398,
0.8521019816,
-0.2162313759,
0.9375599623,
0.6533226967,
-0.1446019113,
-0.2935661077,
-0.1850270182,
-0.3970946372,
-0.5848583579,
0.2466795892,
-0.506264329,
-0.7235636711,
0.8709733486,
0.1017470211,
-0.2191236913,
0.3589043915,
0.4457929134,
-0.089503549,
1.0984699726,
0.9745829701,
0.3048734665,
0.584636569,
-0.9070510268,
0.4547925889,
-1.0171784163,
-0.8595679402,
-0.3386316597,
-0.839763999,
-0.9019524455,
-0.2027419358,
0.5603691339,
-0.1028975472,
-0.5992567539,
0.2243153006,
-0.7368942499,
0.3707427979,
0.4783784449,
0.2582632005,
-0.1095218584,
-0.0293666683,
0.0718007386,
-0.1047737673,
-0.5025177002,
-0.2136081457,
0.8777366877,
0.7307223082,
0.9035093784,
0.1814717799,
0.581384182,
-0.0367755592,
-0.4320292175,
-1.0021644831,
-0.1151864156,
-0.1236520335,
-0.329765439,
-0.3033899367,
-0.2905958295,
-0.8696289659,
-0.089292258,
-0.275477469,
-0.3763802052,
0.7986536026,
0.0034897435,
-0.1617106646,
0.6931661367,
-0.455160886,
0.6873468161,
-0.2159758657,
0.1648100317,
-0.0123636518,
-0.4458706081,
-0.1079824045,
0.3678459525,
-0.1635231972,
0.4294959307,
0.1943098605,
0.5302999616,
-0.14797768,
0.7032869458,
-0.3257714808,
0.0489298441,
0.2826384008,
0.2760249078,
0.0886011571,
0.1054680049,
0.1710307449,
0.1948927641,
0.1703324467,
-0.5180835724,
-0.9256390929,
0.3443460763,
-1.2931630611,
-0.3029841185,
-0.1820689887,
-0.5861455798,
0.0418154746,
-0.1207910478,
0.4680010974,
0.9598158002,
-0.1331216842,
0.6385408044,
1.0506317616,
-0.1892181039,
0.4478410482,
0.0505244732,
0.3005339801,
-0.0038737226,
0.8079217672,
0.3073911667,
0.1452168673,
0.6174256206,
0.2968450487,
-0.6786292195,
-0.590661943,
-0.1989780068,
0.2459761202,
-0.7400622368,
-0.0149856592,
-0.4700798988,
-0.5131973028,
-0.3299769461,
-0.3970473409,
-0.5951150656,
-0.4207687676,
-0.2148234546,
-0.4669696391,
0.2606693506,
1.3271517754,
0.0718885884,
0.3297653198,
-0.7794427276,
-0.147822842,
0.4364989102,
0.320299685,
0.2678064406,
-0.9193241,
-0.5182304978,
-0.088023372,
-0.5893935561,
-0.7793804407,
0.5228763223,
0.2614897788,
0.6403588653,
0.8210200667,
-0.1348998696,
0.1504855156,
-0.6595244408,
0.7360538244,
0.1820902377,
-0.6755831242,
0.4240531325,
0.0156985633,
0.2928927243,
0.143536374,
0.9615387321,
-0.1966054738,
-0.1086704135,
-0.7372040153,
-0.5889593363,
0.269402802,
-0.1570156366,
0.3339522481,
0.2278476059,
0.6572453976,
0.4474390745,
0.0847649127,
-0.429895997,
-0.4333912432,
-0.8456560969,
-0.1873680353,
0.1264089197,
-0.3816871345,
0.0859600455,
-0.2549059987,
0.0294500813,
0.0380829312,
0.8271409273,
0.0686362535,
-0.3280205727,
0.0490555502,
-0.0024036751,
0.3355659842,
0.4455211461,
-0.2519892156,
0.271268636,
-0.113707304,
-0.7882419825,
0.3088556528,
-0.3703385293,
-0.0744015127,
-0.1491916627,
0.4586058855,
1.2062400579,
0.3495243788,
0.0794452131,
0.3758674562,
-0.2488921285,
-0.5805319548,
-0.2961656153,
0.203697592,
-0.5072063804,
0.4450801611,
0.6408207417,
0.1223848164,
0.2762757242,
-0.6278172135,
0.0268563777,
0.0719738305,
-0.7375432849,
-1.0499480963,
0.6327132583,
-0.1577186435,
-0.4542672336,
1.0102497339,
-0.0867629349,
-0.8038193583,
0.6248210073,
0.6212897301,
0.9989059567,
-0.1653979868,
0.3099840581,
0.6179599166,
0.3572743833,
0.0627745241,
-0.0603378713,
-0.2886460125,
-0.9255577326,
0.1128227413,
-0.7170618176,
-0.3756996095,
-0.214085415,
-1.275678277,
0.0202389769,
-0.5687917471,
0.1400692016,
-0.1716366559,
-0.0235079769,
-0.8502168059,
0.1509874314,
0.0391339399,
0.6606888771,
-0.888581574,
0.8471013308,
0.5425744057,
-0.4587583244,
-0.7764772177,
0.0855452567,
-0.0227960609,
-0.6652660966,
0.773822248,
0.4793349504,
-0.0583146587,
0.1770229638,
-0.0800011158,
-0.9589669108,
1.562177062,
0.2824279666,
-0.2379448712,
-0.5074480176,
0.5149506927,
0.6181998849,
-0.2710465789,
0.4357504845,
0.7893614769,
0.306180954,
0.0915214121,
-0.3840984702,
-0.1115427464,
-0.076784268,
0.3007745743,
0.2758236229,
-0.5551698208,
0.7751114964,
-0.2728663087,
-0.5085595846,
-0.5717808008,
0.6102746725,
-0.3039340973,
-0.3144527376,
0.2298173606,
0.6484158039,
0.5827921629,
-0.1688909829,
1.1758720875,
-0.6116737723,
0.5168710947,
0.0328706466,
0.3119966686,
0.6837184429,
0.3377123475,
-0.3989529312,
0.9677693248,
0.3435901403,
-0.3035264015,
0.6434069872,
0.1643034518,
0.0347645022,
0.1627557576,
0.3518018126,
-0.3714096546,
0.6006323695,
0.4928424656,
-0.1551506966,
-0.0272591412,
0.3334322572,
-0.5590924621,
0.1030196846,
-0.275172621,
0.5193084478,
0.010277465,
0.1644488126,
0.4268226326,
-0.2407925725,
0.6960148811,
-0.4824340343,
0.0083791818,
-0.2371913344,
0.2815462649,
-0.1752484739,
-0.8404505849,
0.556573391,
-0.4214342535,
-0.4966754615,
-0.4946240485,
0.2475934178,
-0.3482457399,
-0.1243844703,
0.4758207202,
0.084985733,
-0.0068032034,
0.0912639648,
-0.3404060304,
0.1926666349,
-0.3946360946,
-0.4141205847,
0.4600836337,
0.7771327496,
0.431645155,
0.6003343463,
0.2599522173,
-0.2139244676,
0.5904112458,
-0.0572824255,
0.7405234575,
-0.7754243612,
-0.5908088684,
-0.5195832253,
0.4166389406,
0.2113981247,
-0.352098465,
0.5620118976,
0.6602665186,
1.1036067009,
-0.3019904792,
0.3373855948,
0.0941511467,
0.0344152339,
-0.4806309342,
0.7960407734,
-0.2400830388,
0.0833991095,
0.514634788,
-1.2515251637,
-0.054533802,
0.7799556255,
-0.2484309077,
0.0471927263,
0.8154799342,
0.5697717071,
-0.1907547563,
0.0927519277,
0.334292531,
0.3183400035,
0.4440915287,
0.3352933824,
0.8553514481,
-0.649056077,
0.3185727,
-0.5118747354,
-0.1354700476,
-0.1706107408,
-0.337926209,
-0.8422203064,
-0.8393790722,
-0.4243387878,
-0.0710574612,
-0.333360672,
0.3212366998,
0.5718163848,
-0.774196744,
-0.2292158753,
-0.0317396335,
0.0111877173,
-0.3578374982,
-0.2658058107,
0.3748022914,
-0.2986320853,
-0.7486189008,
0.141055584,
0.3191157281,
0.353300631,
-0.4425050318,
-0.1590762734,
0.4666677117,
0.1113667041,
0.553262949,
0.3137153387,
-0.3352531791,
-0.6180034876,
0.2927872837,
-0.0657006204,
0.3261103928,
0.8393720388,
-0.778065145,
0.0498853438,
0.379209578,
0.5941511989,
0.94954741,
-0.3572710156,
0.2463500798,
-0.673083365,
0.1497640759,
0.2856902778,
0.2945184112,
0.1491119117,
-0.4286058545,
0.0953918844,
0.0802579448,
-0.5427479744,
-0.8269344568,
0.1943925619,
-1.035456419,
-0.1740336269,
0.7386103272,
0.0097881164,
-0.4860936403,
0.2357231528,
0.2175045907,
0.2928566933,
0.0296368767,
1.0366137028,
0.2791557908,
-0.3670373559,
-0.3701896071,
-0.1927361041,
0.3633230031,
-0.2465413362,
-0.2615230381,
-0.2613791525,
0.0015071828,
0.315117538,
0.5215702653,
-0.223779425,
-0.3215468228,
0.0742350519,
0.614735961,
-0.0550787449,
-0.3994127512,
-0.7973476648,
-0.71931988,
0.2252687216,
-0.1306920648,
-0.2896812558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05922v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05922v3
|
Chain of Thought with Explicit Evidence Reasoning for Few-shot Relation Extraction
| 2023-11-10T08:12:00 | 2024-03-08T06:51:43 |
Xilai Ma, Jing Li, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Few-shot relation extraction involves identifying the type of relationship
between two specific entities within a text, using a limited number of
annotated samples. A variety of solutions to this problem have emerged by
applying meta-learning and neural graph techniques which typically necessitate
a training process for adaptation. Recently, the strategy of in-context
learning has been demonstrating notable results without the need of training.
Few studies have already utilized in-context learning for zero-shot information
extraction. Unfortunately, the evidence for inference is either not considered
or implicitly modeled during the construction of chain-of-thought prompts. In
this paper, we propose a novel approach for few-shot relation extraction using
large language models, named CoT-ER, chain-of-thought with explicit evidence
reasoning. In particular, CoT-ER first induces large language models to
generate evidences using task-specific and concept-level knowledge. Then these
evidences are explicitly incorporated into chain-of-thought prompting for
relation extraction. Experimental results demonstrate that our CoT-ER approach
(with 0% training data) achieves competitive performance compared to the
fully-supervised (with 100% training data) state-of-the-art approach on the
FewRel1.0 and FewRel2.0 datasets.
|
[
-0.5427040458,
-1.1035375595,
0.93721205,
-0.3700499833,
-0.4103381038,
-0.2678027749,
-0.2005782872,
-0.635327816,
0.0430892147,
0.5125203729,
-0.6491132975,
-0.477113843,
-0.4624445438,
0.2087031156,
-0.1944591552,
1.0932750702,
-0.0386204906,
-0.0454884134,
0.1071873084,
-0.1672494859,
-0.2502626777,
-0.6246629357,
-0.3895746171,
-0.2874230146,
0.5955394506,
0.497369498,
0.2170349509,
0.3615943789,
0.3745385408,
0.1318829656,
-0.0040823002,
0.4007418156,
-0.6777814031,
0.1052752361,
-0.3665959239,
-0.433585763,
-0.5698957443,
-0.144432947,
0.4687012136,
0.5659432411,
0.2521700561,
0.2396745235,
-0.0910773054,
0.5875196457,
-1.1457834244,
-0.0491438732,
-1.0812920332,
0.03734947,
-0.0869003907,
-0.2651491761,
-0.7174581885,
-0.0645612627,
0.3247978985,
-0.5461865067,
0.0723242313,
0.0481160209,
0.976936996,
-0.1887132376,
-0.3601034582,
-0.1804421544,
-0.6724935174,
0.5882198215,
-0.624271214,
0.2702419758,
0.4452715218,
0.2618308067,
-0.3233650029,
-0.5919524431,
-0.7062785029,
0.0205747783,
-0.1385802776,
0.0524481051,
-0.0917689949,
0.0293605514,
0.5543056726,
0.006575237,
-0.1164711192,
-0.1178944036,
-0.0075268885,
0.2836395502,
0.4533343315,
0.1136122718,
0.1355494261,
-0.1709277481,
-0.6768812537,
0.1414228082,
-0.9179093242,
-0.2308196723,
-0.0649945587,
0.4734740257,
-0.1143226922,
0.5609310269,
-0.1531414539,
0.6440586448,
0.1825911999,
-0.1234442592,
-0.0708500445,
-0.1848340482,
-0.4513757825,
0.2716204822,
0.9974244237,
-0.0898967385,
0.3433999121,
-0.2439068258,
-0.2308294326,
0.0732644051,
0.0315401703,
-0.7569350004,
-0.0638676286,
0.1058484539,
-0.3346703649,
-0.2862451673,
-0.0447749943,
-0.857634604,
-0.1029759943,
-0.0038149401,
0.4559569359,
-0.4998082221,
-0.3731725514,
-0.2111493498,
-0.2521008849,
0.3621188998,
0.3248607516,
-0.8874168992,
0.565377593,
0.7426620722,
0.8864229918,
-0.1513038874,
-0.1716429889,
-0.7076394558,
0.3802827299,
-0.5288987756,
1.0580022335,
-0.6144627333,
0.0290796328,
-0.0793913975,
-0.1435918212,
0.0360489674,
-0.2065193206,
0.4207053781,
-0.6363659501,
0.1805646569,
-0.2955344021,
-0.8197694421,
-0.0513032749,
0.5336118937,
-0.6203179359,
0.8849021196,
-0.0563463159,
-0.9339404702,
0.4575709999,
-0.561639607,
-0.263314575,
0.0198167264,
-0.58597368,
-0.2886977792,
0.0032844841,
0.3874897361,
0.4508879483,
-0.3284009993,
0.0204270352,
-0.6280238032,
-0.1417239308,
0.2591211796,
-0.2273357213,
0.6520466208,
0.0923686922,
-0.3457586765,
-0.1992145926,
-0.7154253721,
0.0329061672,
0.1192891598,
0.1037969217,
-0.5790427923,
-0.0544782877,
-0.322213769,
0.5151449442,
-0.1418625265,
-0.6429510713,
0.3165456355,
-0.6068953872,
-0.0036063527,
0.5170103908,
0.5515977144,
0.6130088568,
0.0496658161,
0.4000253677,
0.0735687166,
-0.1367107779,
-0.2695750296,
-0.4244031012,
-0.5903214216,
-0.2333668917,
0.3341706991,
0.2173772156,
-0.8915771842,
0.3726658821,
-0.3588114679,
-0.0394820049,
-0.1591551751,
0.2540568709,
0.4558957219,
0.7185211182,
0.4619195759,
-0.2720832527,
-0.6121397614,
-0.5193259716,
-0.1735502928,
-0.0538451783,
0.0496098138,
0.2947690487,
0.7363226414,
0.0236653183,
1.3344966173,
-0.8510649204,
-0.2654456794,
-0.540487349,
0.2933648527,
0.2909189761,
0.344723314,
0.4296172857,
-0.3873397708,
-0.3850225508,
0.1880120784,
-1.0835430622,
0.2707069814,
-0.1678232104,
-0.5819292068,
0.024044361,
0.2623003125,
-0.6078967452,
0.5030448437,
0.0759924501,
0.0023775555,
0.4680565,
0.2633440495,
-0.1664283425,
-0.9425341487,
0.1121920049,
0.103132993,
-0.5959245563,
-0.6577920914,
0.0885236114,
-0.053925015,
0.1166873723,
-0.5776109695,
0.5710762143,
-0.4640980363,
-0.1686699837,
-0.4849478602,
0.6219921708,
-0.0254227966,
0.6964800954,
0.4682775736,
0.3615785241,
0.511888206,
-0.6643127203,
0.0158649012,
0.4435814917,
-0.2169787735,
0.4180591702,
-0.2746262848,
0.5717199445,
-0.0926542878,
0.4712356627,
-0.6796709299,
-0.1021808758,
0.401928395,
-0.2800877094,
0.1844433546,
-0.534168601,
-0.3167061806,
-0.1042302623,
-0.2778214812,
0.4340717494,
0.2523738742,
-0.639632225,
0.3482542038,
0.3198540211,
0.1207168922,
-0.6617818475,
-0.5649928451,
-0.0249289349,
-0.073886022,
-0.2537738383,
0.223743543,
0.3973419368,
-0.3502648473,
0.1128199175,
-0.3436570764,
-0.4629723728,
-0.2178476602,
0.0653178468,
0.4761847854,
-0.3073650002,
0.3276146948,
-0.0388436988,
-0.1332382411,
0.0669779629,
-0.0872079358,
0.4182974696,
-0.0424435921,
0.0089792889,
-0.2869083881,
0.2239682376,
0.2550621629,
0.0346647091,
0.7067488432,
0.3392521739,
-0.6190489531,
-0.4627663493,
-0.5054371357,
-0.3737144768,
-0.3497416675,
0.1668353677,
-0.6458457708,
-0.5432444215,
0.3013935685,
-0.5520033836,
-0.0853696465,
0.4132262766,
0.4870237708,
-0.1034396961,
0.7742657065,
0.5494268537,
-0.0714057162,
0.5451316833,
-0.6512051225,
0.1409449726,
-1.1376405954,
-0.061697077,
-0.2820140123,
-0.0878899843,
-0.3532160521,
-0.0623909459,
0.3093240261,
0.2131174952,
-0.2292064875,
0.5525302291,
-0.2302526832,
0.6787931919,
0.0582622178,
0.4863008559,
0.3895870149,
-0.1535114199,
-0.1834012866,
0.2971406579,
-0.9704657197,
-0.5768235922,
1.0689636469,
0.1225980371,
0.6251377463,
-0.0371351279,
0.9156228304,
0.0462147258,
0.3120525181,
-0.9044702649,
0.4257005155,
0.0757163838,
-0.8574414849,
-0.3596815169,
-0.3596267998,
-1.0224821568,
0.3557660282,
-0.6935299039,
-1.0226057768,
0.376635313,
0.0067302883,
-0.4960580468,
0.4222967327,
-0.4786432385,
0.5651186109,
-0.2477615178,
-0.7755351663,
-0.1784918308,
-0.7796700597,
0.6693752408,
0.0459163859,
0.1273733526,
0.0134370988,
0.156543687,
0.8862668872,
-0.470867157,
0.7677755356,
0.0046015065,
0.0079519181,
0.6811961532,
0.165694356,
0.8472694755,
-0.0220646411,
-0.0553980283,
-0.0793431848,
-0.0201224834,
-0.2757243514,
-0.7455880046,
0.5231243968,
-0.4858317375,
-0.2970459461,
-0.5018407702,
-0.2999690175,
-0.2646705806,
0.3063676059,
0.3919503093,
0.3851662576,
-0.4428484142,
-0.1272229105,
0.4572422504,
0.100826323,
0.6019403338,
0.1465798616,
-0.1625333577,
-0.5400553942,
0.539041698,
-0.103035368,
0.4089804292,
0.5159606338,
0.2565128803,
-0.2167388648,
-0.1463390589,
-0.2839759588,
0.1990912557,
-0.7618321776,
-0.3699918985,
-0.6321758628,
-0.1519384384,
-0.1216954365,
-0.0544392727,
-0.4494259655,
-0.3644709289,
-0.0324736349,
-0.1725378036,
0.4035738111,
0.7507486343,
0.3495137691,
0.2975455225,
-0.745262146,
0.7240090966,
0.33560431,
0.1626244336,
0.2411914915,
-0.1638703644,
-0.1823366582,
0.110568814,
-0.4836277068,
-1.0912703276,
0.1938990951,
0.1468584538,
0.3390668929,
0.7216754556,
0.1803125739,
0.9716483951,
-0.4756303728,
0.5821341872,
0.4883641899,
-0.9877265692,
0.6978288293,
-0.1362087578,
0.0332880877,
0.8404875398,
0.5306379199,
-0.0842363164,
-0.0889857635,
-0.8874048591,
-0.5533863306,
0.7231484056,
0.3814120889,
-0.249662742,
-0.2465603799,
0.4006450474,
0.1936329454,
0.062887758,
-0.8268063664,
0.0133808432,
0.2872249484,
0.0813605338,
0.4086618125,
-0.1934887916,
-0.2015931904,
-0.326901108,
0.421425432,
-0.2527993917,
0.3677432239,
0.4381648004,
-0.4228221774,
-0.2885450423,
0.398319006,
0.2783536017,
0.8717995882,
-0.419189781,
0.4177021384,
0.6397334337,
-0.1203956604,
0.1874987185,
-0.557110846,
0.0201337058,
0.0710809827,
0.6829798222,
0.6747962832,
0.3418649435,
-0.4070226848,
0.8593248129,
0.1754937321,
-0.0905888006,
-0.1624854654,
-0.0669177026,
-0.2822579145,
0.209434405,
0.2912021875,
-0.0408823416,
0.0622700006,
-0.9517878294,
0.3533018827,
0.4897325635,
-0.371789068,
-0.2903726101,
0.3381840587,
0.2176717818,
-0.1094049811,
0.5118376613,
-0.3139723241,
-0.4856144786,
0.3707573116,
0.7883802652,
1.1254364252,
0.3434443772,
0.0554627217,
0.6104595661,
0.0424654335,
-0.3268316686,
-0.0021169868,
-0.3791052103,
-0.8575547934,
-0.5804319978,
-0.2536745965,
-0.4438444376,
0.1405284107,
-0.6343457103,
0.6718818545,
-0.5420944691,
-0.2712321877,
0.0220520832,
-0.1235095039,
-0.745154202,
0.1327906698,
0.3165264726,
0.7365151644,
-0.8611904383,
1.0277831554,
0.2617359459,
-0.5652946234,
-0.659904182,
0.1043238118,
-0.0990442485,
-0.5262275338,
0.6693318486,
0.0275526382,
-0.4138804078,
-0.0735889077,
-0.7802865505,
-0.5759218931,
1.0232700109,
0.4289955795,
-0.8141471148,
-0.0980558991,
-0.3353449106,
0.4355178177,
-0.9024490118,
0.4915962219,
0.5148077607,
0.0540506132,
0.2928669453,
-0.4880864024,
0.2983186245,
0.0940647796,
-0.2848234773,
0.376144737,
-0.3286249042,
0.5168681741,
-0.3559223711,
-0.3735307157,
-0.1115086973,
0.5594775081,
0.4726220369,
0.5680699348,
0.4554829001,
0.4665832818,
0.6707032919,
0.266292423,
0.9316109419,
-0.1088662818,
0.5167371631,
1.683109045,
-0.5428408384,
1.2283930779,
0.5318317413,
-0.1620479971,
0.9676741958,
0.3725644946,
0.0684508532,
0.6045315266,
-0.2263642251,
-0.2928367257,
-0.4593014121,
0.0125087257,
-0.1786328852,
0.5044137836,
0.3201707602,
-0.6046919227,
-0.3221335709,
-0.36536327,
0.0561840311,
-0.1529977471,
-0.2305997014,
1.2056373358,
0.363353461,
-0.6380187869,
0.6865382195,
-0.5006943941,
0.3905511498,
-0.5013805628,
-0.3200685978,
0.2047618479,
-0.0576102175,
-0.3637101352,
-0.5597205162,
-0.0247479808,
0.5042874217,
0.0644983128,
0.196059078,
0.8076131344,
-0.2812156677,
-0.4644589126,
0.2845984101,
0.6745032072,
0.207755059,
-0.0327525698,
-0.3404021263,
-0.291059494,
-0.30212152,
-0.0750923157,
0.3288843632,
0.6171278954,
-0.0683854446,
0.3512158394,
0.6735146642,
0.3064883649,
-0.1923568696,
0.033577092,
1.0744476318,
-0.8212504983,
-0.3947697878,
-1.2686285973,
0.2719298303,
-0.4128719568,
-0.309628427,
0.4731380343,
0.5501873493,
0.5361132026,
0.1255521178,
0.7919348478,
-0.1001770049,
0.0707823485,
-0.5608175993,
0.303812772,
-0.1628388017,
0.1960663795,
-0.7908729911,
-0.9365457892,
-0.1945900321,
0.5386907458,
-0.5533592105,
-0.2549808621,
1.2600589991,
0.5075674653,
-0.2410372496,
0.0497052036,
0.1673632413,
0.1774131805,
0.1467693001,
0.8896809816,
0.7297164202,
-0.5253120661,
0.5408015251,
-0.2504224777,
-0.2577083111,
0.0035129571,
-1.0028566122,
-1.0319548845,
-0.3401220739,
-0.3072629869,
-0.3788466156,
-0.0132254716,
1.3155777454,
0.6271649599,
-0.691580534,
-0.1005815864,
-0.4967962801,
0.3568561673,
-0.3989267349,
-0.1865163743,
0.4438710809,
-0.4355724454,
-0.3014674485,
0.3426962495,
0.2531635463,
-0.1704141796,
0.1749863178,
-0.0603333376,
-0.7729812264,
0.0419820324,
0.8591071367,
0.2921270132,
-0.6550366879,
-0.308524549,
-0.302930057,
0.0146292998,
0.2888873816,
0.8780711889,
-1.0316411257,
0.5961424708,
0.6098828912,
0.401337713,
0.9982257485,
0.2466438264,
0.6142445207,
-0.901683569,
0.3132808208,
0.145223707,
0.3236562312,
-0.0248991717,
-0.4111397862,
0.7129067779,
0.1024536416,
-0.4009756148,
-0.8346275091,
0.3282159269,
-1.078668952,
-0.283115387,
1.233705163,
-0.3076036572,
-0.4497433603,
-0.1084679291,
-0.1524328738,
0.4638404846,
-0.3772025108,
0.8220674992,
0.5765894651,
-0.5542944074,
-0.2115815878,
-0.3496920764,
0.3228106499,
-0.0054337797,
-0.932516098,
0.0839537606,
0.2347208112,
0.160093084,
0.105126217,
0.6424287558,
0.0597122535,
0.3131907284,
0.1739773005,
-0.0825774893,
0.2104865462,
-0.38015306,
-0.1261781156,
0.2960777879,
0.0836694539,
-0.3330935836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05915v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05915v3
|
Fake Alignment: Are LLMs Really Aligned Well?
| 2023-11-10T08:01:23 | 2024-04-01T03:32:14 |
Yixu Wang, Yan Teng, Kexin Huang, Chengqi Lyu, Songyang Zhang, Wenwei Zhang, Xingjun Ma, Yu-Gang Jiang, Yu Qiao, Yingchun Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The growing awareness of safety concerns in large language models (LLMs) has
sparked considerable interest in the evaluation of safety. This study
investigates an under-explored issue about the evaluation of LLMs, namely the
substantial discrepancy in performance between multiple-choice questions and
open-ended questions. Inspired by research on jailbreak attack patterns, we
argue this is caused by mismatched generalization. That is, LLM only remembers
the answer style for open-ended safety questions, which makes it unable to
solve other forms of safety tests. We refer to this phenomenon as fake
alignment and construct a comparative benchmark to empirically verify its
existence in LLMs. We introduce a Fake alIgNment Evaluation (FINE) framework
and two novel metrics--Consistency Score (CS) and Consistent Safety Score
(CSS), which jointly assess two complementary forms of evaluation to quantify
fake alignment and obtain corrected performance estimation. Applying FINE to 14
widely-used LLMs reveals several models with purported safety are poorly
aligned in practice. Subsequently, we found that multiple-choice format data
can also be used as high-quality contrast distillation-based fine-tuning data,
which can strongly improve the alignment consistency of LLMs with minimal
fine-tuning overhead. For data and code, see
https://github.com/AIFlames/Fake-Alignment.
|
[
-0.0386192016,
-0.8988586068,
0.7226756215,
0.0176368821,
-0.1074586138,
0.4550881386,
0.1202582493,
-0.5762732029,
0.087017864,
0.1244828999,
-0.4101263583,
-0.3441691399,
-0.4001811743,
0.0761376247,
-0.4445055723,
0.8786839247,
-0.367567271,
0.2678700089,
-0.212456435,
-0.4125457406,
-0.6242763996,
-0.4134098291,
-0.4362196326,
-0.12501809,
0.4112918079,
0.0952255577,
1.0478621721,
1.0314414501,
0.5718533993,
0.3002951443,
0.0026643807,
0.3344404995,
-0.4900650382,
-0.0972687006,
-0.2055492252,
-0.3387804627,
-0.4952295125,
0.2823998034,
0.5476951003,
0.3002444506,
-0.3533928692,
0.1534186602,
0.101182431,
0.7020148039,
-0.7533482313,
-0.5274730325,
-0.8124688864,
-0.0932807624,
-0.1891160309,
0.0169992708,
-0.3924513757,
-0.7594988942,
-0.0864816606,
-0.4336493909,
-0.0387308784,
0.3178457916,
1.1508593559,
0.3713354468,
-0.3761138916,
-0.4599538445,
-0.7071393132,
0.6374739408,
-0.6845138073,
0.3097624779,
0.0615093708,
0.5784233809,
-0.3324994445,
-0.2972014546,
-0.7631636262,
-0.0762317628,
0.0091958391,
0.2018600255,
-0.0925355479,
0.0118038645,
0.1316786259,
0.3574911356,
-0.8406840563,
0.4539446235,
-0.1199278533,
-0.4092178047,
0.7472155094,
0.3204770684,
0.4510385692,
0.2378082871,
-0.672588408,
-0.1164507717,
-0.9331043959,
0.08403714,
0.8480020165,
0.240426302,
-0.3054612875,
0.6402605772,
0.0823969021,
0.969394803,
0.1495231837,
-0.3536728919,
0.2379564643,
-0.5016568303,
-0.3407979012,
0.2127600014,
0.8462655544,
0.6782207489,
0.6748712063,
-0.1245496571,
-0.1841009259,
0.2212053835,
0.506622076,
-0.3679255247,
-0.0724682286,
0.3687672019,
-0.2541076243,
-0.4420279264,
0.1710697412,
-0.5647091269,
-0.4106276333,
-0.41231215,
0.6495913863,
-0.3954814672,
0.0102731967,
0.2496498674,
0.1071201861,
0.3658646345,
0.2155638337,
-0.5948647261,
0.2039778084,
0.8230907917,
0.8319638371,
-0.2379814833,
-0.2872286439,
-0.5149084926,
0.0901876837,
-0.6340700984,
0.5998110175,
-0.2715590298,
-0.0456615947,
-0.0993150845,
-0.1045870259,
-0.2379763871,
-0.5855653286,
0.4104717672,
-0.4689849317,
0.2053824067,
-0.2665691674,
-0.5720193386,
0.2333121896,
0.4720810354,
-0.5692328811,
0.99012959,
-0.2376487851,
-0.7386767864,
0.4974007607,
-0.1218801737,
-0.2481757849,
-0.4128384292,
-0.2907451093,
-0.5990085602,
0.0055011213,
-0.0256164167,
0.0520641953,
0.1087094843,
0.2827097476,
-0.5511960983,
-0.6904870272,
0.5450899005,
-0.6786249876,
0.6545166373,
0.2490019798,
-0.2543389499,
0.0465540737,
-0.6620774269,
0.1455804259,
0.0424919985,
-0.3475341797,
-0.4118505716,
0.0245207101,
-0.438370049,
0.323363632,
0.4456516802,
-0.6340179443,
0.1650830954,
-0.3397451639,
0.1800612658,
0.9536963701,
-0.2140623778,
0.2967434824,
-0.7230560184,
0.2961620092,
0.0123905437,
0.3342769742,
0.1506147981,
-0.3208370209,
-0.5531318188,
-0.2286399007,
0.4257172942,
0.8137491345,
-0.2466878593,
0.5128307343,
-0.1628789306,
-0.5754805803,
-0.7885701656,
0.0903885216,
0.6845751405,
0.5871607065,
0.4507233202,
-0.1128725484,
-0.5222904682,
-1.0742446184,
-0.697551012,
-0.2196179926,
0.2379273772,
0.0419794172,
0.3326846063,
-0.1017960012,
1.0183069706,
-0.2864706218,
0.0141209029,
0.1718317866,
-0.1159380525,
0.0264638513,
0.5775339603,
0.5823318958,
-0.4888128638,
-0.5455446243,
-0.1056242287,
-0.6853278279,
-0.0976626053,
-0.0975535437,
-0.2374540418,
0.38918975,
0.5364450812,
-0.3655464351,
0.2858828306,
0.7498601079,
-0.1977922022,
0.8105025887,
-0.1420636922,
0.316588372,
-0.9521823525,
0.0638650432,
-0.0180269759,
-0.1991214603,
-0.6081709266,
0.0178754404,
0.4024609327,
0.3034666777,
-0.7139456272,
0.600671351,
-0.4523978829,
-0.1095343903,
-0.0940085948,
0.119077526,
0.0063554784,
-0.0664600581,
-0.3843318224,
0.9757338762,
0.405438453,
-0.2503415346,
0.237481758,
-0.0618305057,
-0.5297054052,
0.6774551272,
-0.4987593889,
0.4347665906,
0.0071358318,
0.0526042059,
-1.2912245989,
-0.3433231115,
0.1014224291,
-0.1645290107,
0.3701046109,
-0.300170362,
-0.614923954,
-0.2623661458,
-0.3702536821,
0.3667010963,
0.5798564553,
-0.547581315,
0.346192807,
0.1914688051,
0.2327634692,
-1.061751008,
-0.6686295271,
-0.1510454714,
-0.4634193778,
-0.661485672,
0.1767352372,
-0.1920090318,
-0.5054083467,
-0.181767121,
-0.6174080372,
-0.047170151,
0.3175227344,
0.0802128613,
0.4290111363,
-0.2711092234,
-0.2113335133,
0.0136265075,
0.2631372511,
-0.1310631931,
0.0799697861,
0.4351159334,
-0.2112893909,
-0.5998238921,
-0.521027565,
-0.0563932918,
0.6368039846,
0.1965265572,
0.7796909213,
-0.0025150909,
-0.4085414708,
0.03567807,
-0.8372123241,
0.129049629,
-0.5634664297,
-0.0995193496,
-0.3623155355,
-0.8095245361,
0.5933125615,
0.084433049,
0.1831650436,
0.1662376672,
0.2028682232,
-0.5756340623,
1.0875627995,
0.3230699599,
-0.0319582447,
0.0966518521,
0.4710067213,
0.2959389985,
-0.4815683365,
-0.2311429232,
-0.4746386707,
-0.4959229231,
-0.508489728,
-0.1580966711,
0.2267953008,
0.5020725727,
-0.4231942892,
0.3480087817,
-0.3201397657,
0.7896181345,
0.1126820892,
-0.1116256416,
0.4238235652,
-0.0954186618,
-0.4719272256,
-0.1664484143,
-0.4198116064,
-0.895950973,
1.0112242699,
0.4029898345,
0.8975641727,
0.327408731,
0.7215742469,
0.0981880948,
0.3284639716,
-0.4580022991,
0.4368978143,
-0.1382615566,
-0.6284126043,
-0.2093173862,
-0.3634574413,
-0.8312259316,
0.2418962121,
-0.2144557089,
-0.6571506858,
-0.1729650944,
0.5548636317,
-0.5130601525,
0.2289349288,
-0.8136909008,
0.8716534376,
-0.8266225457,
-0.2628471851,
0.1680978686,
-0.65239048,
0.6745973229,
-0.2825455666,
0.3652688861,
-0.2555676401,
0.1783616841,
0.5587748289,
-0.4291325212,
0.7113681436,
0.0584764332,
-0.1821447462,
0.2064507604,
0.2418377101,
0.5152542591,
-0.1569954753,
-0.0909645483,
0.2055220008,
0.0883557796,
-0.3447203636,
-0.6914774776,
0.9604462385,
-0.658364296,
-0.6526327133,
-0.4821730852,
-0.3750402033,
-0.4026699066,
0.2697220445,
0.2229014784,
0.1639220715,
-0.3789405227,
-0.2343944907,
0.7348361611,
-0.1506178081,
0.4262165129,
0.5977342129,
-0.1105461121,
-0.4013497531,
0.7676079273,
0.271697998,
0.5330704451,
0.2189522833,
0.0784529969,
-0.4258678854,
-0.5469896793,
-0.7476765513,
0.333545804,
-0.5346550345,
-0.1077071428,
-0.2690826952,
-0.2650023997,
-0.4177178144,
-0.3706412315,
-0.5394705534,
-0.1894094944,
-0.1859832108,
-0.2468284518,
0.029720597,
0.6460804343,
0.0285476781,
0.1155553386,
-0.6101012826,
0.1803454012,
0.0678075999,
0.5720385313,
-0.199143067,
-0.4757331312,
-0.0248300284,
0.1541820914,
-0.4219518304,
-0.9146086574,
0.0121867713,
-0.1954199374,
0.6570489407,
0.5540508628,
0.0065524387,
0.9254703522,
-0.752073288,
0.6506001949,
0.2856729031,
-0.8309972286,
0.3296220601,
-0.2498137206,
0.0727158785,
0.89654392,
0.4981867075,
-0.3371132314,
-0.3772200048,
-0.4127383828,
-0.6088001728,
0.343667686,
0.0491132587,
-0.0008852747,
-0.065830715,
0.296587646,
0.2048205286,
0.0661608875,
-0.7937840223,
-0.3281627297,
-0.1350916177,
-0.4714584351,
0.0675280243,
-0.1121929511,
-0.4099763632,
0.018537214,
0.4518426657,
-0.0977704674,
0.0471447259,
0.0213503782,
-0.1396254599,
-0.1459619999,
0.2583485842,
0.9600241184,
0.7145535946,
-0.1886417568,
0.1992078871,
0.1618853956,
-0.4174008369,
0.4454141259,
-0.1778065562,
-0.07252343,
-0.1748048365,
0.1910492331,
0.4384641647,
0.0405883342,
-0.6890036464,
0.6126917005,
0.0463068299,
-0.1401982307,
-0.3124415576,
0.297252804,
0.1058398709,
-0.0181657244,
0.2108605802,
0.1836563796,
-0.2359761596,
-0.549785912,
0.1662948728,
0.787669003,
-0.3716038764,
-0.1711886078,
0.6271399856,
0.0805453733,
-0.5012589097,
0.467679143,
0.0491651744,
-0.3111046851,
0.6602124572,
0.3477106094,
0.6247640252,
-0.2936998606,
-0.0594941229,
0.1976937652,
0.6771643758,
-0.3770462275,
0.4680884182,
0.3312627375,
-0.9017981291,
-0.4243034124,
-0.6694350839,
-0.4407670796,
0.4161112309,
-0.5233320594,
0.329247117,
-0.544749856,
-0.0709837526,
-0.3652843237,
-0.2905141711,
-0.3435085416,
0.2975643873,
-0.017550379,
1.069937706,
-1.0380398035,
0.711001277,
0.5759556293,
-0.1563728601,
-0.7957219481,
0.2115039378,
0.2839071453,
-0.7632775903,
0.1141941026,
0.3352901042,
-0.2472620606,
-0.4157885909,
-0.5199479461,
-1.1727042198,
0.8886176348,
0.5106652379,
-0.9607448578,
-0.1351705343,
0.4755447209,
0.645371139,
-0.140022099,
0.0438709073,
0.6737211347,
0.468226552,
-0.2560037971,
-1.1873965263,
0.0534075722,
0.0144611998,
-0.2753278315,
0.2288061231,
-0.7668792009,
0.5213888884,
-0.1562765092,
-0.3134625256,
0.3008540869,
0.2143164426,
0.6613457203,
0.4940395355,
0.3231164217,
0.863485992,
0.8092820644,
-0.3127517104,
0.9686126709,
-0.2261850834,
0.2167121321,
1.3247840405,
-0.5962887406,
0.7212660909,
0.5681348443,
-0.0580566451,
0.434999615,
0.6477643251,
0.0115096364,
0.5793733001,
0.3052991331,
0.1028155833,
-0.1816568673,
0.5128326416,
-0.2717201412,
0.4041899443,
0.0916565806,
-0.3617833555,
-0.1242479458,
-0.4325259626,
0.0750921145,
0.2247854322,
-0.0200050343,
0.6512324214,
-0.0325222798,
-0.7147865295,
0.612832725,
-0.0606399775,
0.7543523312,
-0.3655261993,
0.1011491343,
-0.2291026413,
0.0511900932,
-0.2923208475,
-0.9512390494,
0.4298544824,
0.0583189726,
-0.1376817971,
-0.1311076283,
0.4196537733,
-0.3077205122,
-0.1380461156,
0.1838070601,
0.4075502455,
0.1825326234,
0.3964267671,
-0.7202840447,
0.2141296118,
-0.1343904883,
-0.0466762409,
0.6556284428,
0.0967683271,
-0.2055405676,
0.6080391407,
0.6629570723,
0.0163261127,
0.3636287451,
-0.2195398211,
0.3741286993,
-0.4401513636,
-0.3073810339,
-1.1966290474,
0.6024118066,
-0.2173804194,
-0.5349982381,
0.8277153373,
0.8894736767,
1.0767302513,
0.0098621594,
0.6867926717,
0.4042541385,
0.4784915745,
-0.8084834218,
0.8893763423,
-0.4794748127,
0.2819461823,
-0.396576941,
-0.9247604012,
-0.100512214,
0.4807798564,
-0.3176441789,
-0.0433844067,
0.5404128432,
0.8855340481,
-0.2518181801,
-0.2187182903,
0.4146314263,
0.1969441772,
0.1276444048,
0.3250325024,
1.0996296406,
-0.4972237349,
0.4063692689,
-0.1415978223,
-0.0973887146,
-0.1755303741,
-1.0537493229,
-0.5244524479,
-0.2220886499,
-0.4875603914,
-0.4574881792,
0.352611959,
0.6242172718,
0.4715358913,
-0.7766833305,
-0.2104836106,
-0.0314257182,
0.0996692702,
-0.1992234439,
-0.2544805408,
0.1713395864,
-0.1117213443,
-0.5898656845,
0.6791575551,
0.2113055587,
0.4817928672,
-0.0046085161,
-0.0761750862,
-0.1593604982,
0.3901874125,
0.1006555259,
0.3540199697,
-0.8471682668,
-0.5671212077,
0.0260271654,
-0.5097766519,
0.1189056486,
0.4867146313,
-0.5075221658,
0.3067954779,
0.2391629815,
0.544536829,
-0.0600889511,
0.4725305736,
0.4563910663,
-0.6936000586,
-0.2954722643,
0.0432567857,
0.486766398,
0.4257422686,
-0.3812783957,
0.3360282183,
0.0432063267,
-0.6261439919,
-1.1464118958,
0.2631551325,
-0.9473114014,
-0.3303469419,
1.1901942492,
-0.0622974373,
0.0103975618,
-0.2236476541,
-0.0085554309,
0.2117315382,
-0.0569481067,
0.9017204642,
0.8773003817,
-0.3044540584,
0.303840965,
-0.378248632,
0.581330955,
0.4555985034,
-0.6275506616,
-0.0834918693,
0.6029825211,
0.888268888,
0.2820606232,
0.3114063442,
-0.2032264918,
0.3622858524,
-0.3748403192,
-0.2409016341,
0.058945246,
-0.3172517121,
-0.493731916,
0.1779472083,
0.0365620777,
-0.1796697974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05902v1
|
Citation Recommendation on Scholarly Legal Articles
| 2023-11-10T07:11:55 | 2023-11-10T07:11:55 |
Doğukan Arslan, Saadet Sena Erdoğan, Gülşen Eryiğit
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, H.3.3; I.2.7
|
Citation recommendation is the task of finding appropriate citations based on
a given piece of text. The proposed datasets for this task consist mainly of
several scientific fields, lacking some core ones, such as law. Furthermore,
citation recommendation is used within the legal domain to identify supporting
arguments, utilizing non-scholarly legal articles. In order to alleviate the
limitations of existing studies, we gather the first scholarly legal dataset
for the task of citation recommendation. Also, we conduct experiments with
state-of-the-art models and compare their performance on this dataset. The
study suggests that, while BM25 is a strong benchmark for the legal citation
recommendation task, the most effective method involves implementing a two-step
process that entails pre-fetching with BM25+, followed by re-ranking with
SciNCL, which enhances the performance of the baseline from 0.26 to 0.30
MAP@10. Moreover, fine-tuning leads to considerable performance increases in
pre-trained models, which shows the importance of including legal articles in
the training data of these models.
|
[
-0.3797774315,
-0.3339159489,
0.6056109071,
0.2321935743,
-0.6429390907,
-0.2568589747,
-0.0192194488,
-0.6219418049,
0.1341734976,
0.4157353938,
-0.16914469,
-0.5879431963,
-0.5191902518,
0.0625834167,
-0.1420499533,
1.2253774405,
0.1683339179,
0.6558784246,
-0.3730266988,
-0.3556997478,
-0.6927788854,
-0.2987294197,
-0.4092412293,
-0.4101056755,
0.8779472113,
0.2316365242,
0.3403091729,
0.5805664062,
0.7096019983,
0.1349719018,
-0.2862322628,
-0.0053375592,
-0.6284561753,
0.2387648225,
-0.7943320274,
-0.3352327645,
-0.2120788991,
0.0835904479,
0.2862466276,
0.5339366794,
-0.0122648636,
0.3464928269,
-0.4398484528,
0.8809347749,
-0.7030364275,
-0.152464211,
-0.6504986882,
0.1299347878,
-0.5611775517,
-0.5807215571,
-0.502060771,
-0.6889775395,
0.2508971393,
-0.747307837,
0.2700145841,
0.659753263,
0.6815223098,
0.0241967887,
-0.4564672709,
-0.3450256884,
-0.6068896055,
0.5225995183,
-0.5299696922,
0.4428517818,
0.5186799169,
0.1172943637,
-0.1258222461,
-0.9369601011,
-0.0533267185,
-0.5257238746,
-0.0459832549,
0.0211290419,
-0.4731328487,
-0.0228057429,
0.5277011395,
0.0972731188,
-0.7605465651,
0.0173831247,
-0.7604107261,
-0.1109706685,
0.6846349835,
0.0568948239,
0.0133881867,
-0.0079775406,
-0.1863604039,
0.1150807142,
-0.9059123993,
-0.1228052974,
0.458802551,
0.3114498556,
0.4356895685,
0.6053565145,
-0.0614382066,
0.3509804904,
0.2520469129,
0.3112000823,
0.2677851319,
-0.6460741758,
-0.0203881077,
0.4035407305,
0.8419038653,
0.4665970802,
0.3416142166,
-0.2904271483,
0.0073794308,
-0.544202745,
0.5307649374,
-0.9387699366,
-0.2433027029,
0.0011417078,
-0.7898734212,
-0.0211364217,
0.2848590016,
-0.5848142505,
-0.5442516804,
-0.5095511675,
0.1883085072,
-0.3354701102,
0.0842983052,
-0.1650593281,
-0.3349667788,
-0.0985892192,
0.1173588559,
-0.6821542978,
0.0701302662,
0.4422928691,
0.8756750226,
0.0621902533,
-0.0692492947,
-0.6722089648,
0.2697246075,
-0.5180917382,
0.8686445355,
-0.5808464289,
-0.5461226702,
0.0745491534,
0.1865132153,
0.1059835106,
-0.6650132537,
1.0838670731,
-0.8013201356,
-0.4282958806,
-0.9053498507,
-0.6688306332,
-0.3367111385,
-0.0876994729,
-0.6388248801,
0.7489519119,
-0.0811709762,
-0.9164527059,
0.9940271378,
-0.9686083794,
-0.6186387539,
0.4926657081,
0.2845296264,
-0.6738230586,
0.2034856975,
-0.0639523417,
0.2238703817,
-0.1652787328,
0.4953897893,
-0.6921822429,
-0.4228415489,
-0.0468398854,
0.2191214263,
0.903116107,
0.6097662449,
-0.1703558862,
0.2613080144,
-0.5497975349,
-0.0969037488,
-0.1597631127,
-0.1702483147,
-0.791051507,
0.0952322036,
0.1207808405,
0.052510988,
0.1987354159,
-0.6392371655,
-0.0081315618,
-0.0065598516,
0.2852090895,
0.3954815567,
0.237978965,
0.2254295051,
-0.4405099452,
0.4261099398,
-0.155617848,
-0.1916487813,
0.1706200838,
-0.3271020651,
-0.3540330827,
-0.0961188674,
0.6356887221,
0.4527029395,
-0.2540075481,
0.1788108647,
-0.2070500851,
-0.5979751348,
-0.4891072512,
0.2058180422,
0.2267865688,
0.1646112502,
0.6667675376,
0.2129104882,
-1.0209900141,
-0.76988554,
-0.5276317,
-0.1642399728,
0.228802681,
0.4213634729,
0.8522776961,
-0.0685078129,
0.7984439135,
-0.1732160896,
-0.3770192564,
0.0765475631,
0.3285827041,
0.3902663291,
0.3095737398,
0.6684077382,
-0.6848218441,
-0.5382600427,
0.0200231969,
-0.8933169842,
-0.1743425876,
0.1239999682,
-0.1196664572,
-0.1764046401,
0.6178815365,
-0.3170057237,
0.3791105151,
-0.1422942579,
-0.6876351237,
0.5472824574,
-0.532166481,
0.1974757463,
-0.7456721067,
0.4107739329,
0.2836155295,
-0.2479127049,
-0.5291649699,
0.0357982144,
0.1454895288,
0.0214897543,
-0.4542162716,
0.3216841221,
-0.4204812944,
-0.0290965308,
-0.383217752,
-0.3136555552,
-0.0235980861,
-0.0684443042,
-0.0399777256,
0.6488722563,
0.4802811444,
-0.4422926307,
0.1993398219,
0.3190744519,
-0.3293788433,
0.9348399043,
-0.8445749283,
-0.0665073097,
-0.1864775717,
0.2436801344,
-0.4024551213,
0.3151302934,
-0.0558625311,
0.0834063217,
0.1321596503,
-0.5259657502,
-0.3718987703,
-0.2836715877,
-0.2960119247,
0.2656593323,
-0.0442162156,
-0.300370127,
0.3423430622,
0.3846306503,
-0.2146487534,
-0.502833724,
-0.4124581218,
0.1752854288,
-0.2958175838,
-0.3704898655,
0.6659401655,
-0.183329463,
-0.3134298325,
0.2538065016,
0.2284467369,
0.2059013098,
-0.0438953787,
0.6539345384,
0.119689621,
-0.2441043556,
0.1934153289,
0.2091693282,
0.0280035976,
0.2863162756,
-0.3374940753,
0.2337571234,
-0.1932918727,
-0.1795592755,
-0.3182044625,
0.4755236208,
0.6403217912,
-0.2842559814,
0.4826836884,
0.4713405073,
-0.2372416556,
0.2026050091,
-0.4517888725,
-0.0868805721,
-0.4042676687,
0.229037419,
-0.3013373017,
-0.4975124896,
0.209507212,
0.1026330218,
0.204745248,
0.6028290391,
0.7429449558,
-0.2008570582,
0.5089133382,
0.2185679078,
-0.141131416,
0.5980571508,
-0.1778039187,
0.2741530836,
-0.7777634859,
-0.5666506886,
-0.8483022451,
-0.2725252211,
-0.5647030473,
0.0349525847,
0.0599914417,
-0.0077229091,
-0.2865563035,
0.5724406838,
-0.2791770101,
0.5134263039,
0.968644619,
0.0978876576,
0.4017698169,
0.0980455354,
-0.5796973705,
0.0473739952,
-0.5578448176,
-0.4879616797,
1.2356468439,
0.2121515423,
0.6067385077,
0.0637007654,
0.6342602968,
0.7186077833,
0.2108322233,
-0.7120634317,
0.5049440861,
-0.3407426775,
-1.0470042229,
-0.2436515242,
-0.3255722225,
-1.3008009195,
0.1317552626,
-0.5396611691,
-0.308237493,
0.535327673,
-0.3483370841,
-0.3960518241,
0.0633879229,
-0.2555523813,
0.6360211372,
-0.071088478,
-0.7171648145,
-0.403357923,
-0.434945941,
0.0395096503,
0.0148365321,
0.0976755768,
-0.0396203957,
0.3747963011,
1.0022222996,
-0.2319549322,
0.1998051405,
-0.5316912532,
0.4350296259,
0.3264652193,
-0.069163613,
0.4426928759,
0.3728119433,
-0.2721863687,
0.0968502313,
0.499853909,
-0.1432645917,
-0.1272674948,
0.7701121569,
-0.5001077056,
-0.4546944499,
-0.7018070817,
-0.6763454676,
0.0361870863,
0.4893575609,
0.2195462435,
0.1249747947,
-0.0677988827,
0.7792596817,
0.5747081041,
0.1951988339,
0.4861065149,
0.8656058311,
0.110047549,
-0.6129389405,
0.8564780354,
0.4143092036,
-0.6871230602,
0.1959997118,
0.1601133645,
-0.6650007367,
-1.2006423473,
-0.3391989768,
0.2594355047,
-0.7181785107,
-0.2462850064,
-0.7683294415,
0.0119793741,
-0.3393861949,
0.0505192913,
-0.0394894928,
-0.0169812012,
-0.4496670663,
-0.1799459904,
0.3098926842,
0.5076500773,
0.0155626144,
-0.1692036837,
-0.5133703351,
0.1499447972,
0.1188474223,
0.6052291393,
-0.259988606,
-0.5351449847,
-0.3371504843,
-0.133384347,
-0.2815874517,
-0.6897545457,
0.1026757881,
0.1705726534,
0.8907905221,
0.6261652708,
0.2056266218,
0.7196316719,
-0.7163060904,
0.3441550732,
0.0124315172,
-0.4663698077,
0.4597799182,
-0.4444906116,
-0.0200981498,
0.9992931485,
0.6459841728,
0.166719079,
-0.0528961308,
-0.4169601798,
-0.6971340179,
0.2480250895,
0.2218971103,
-0.0216829982,
0.2208061069,
0.4756942987,
0.0696959645,
0.0646095797,
-0.5166776776,
0.1054304689,
-0.2170065343,
-0.0573890097,
0.1008787528,
-0.2272291929,
-0.3052982092,
-0.439326793,
0.8523923159,
0.0550974794,
0.1830784827,
0.1422432661,
-0.2353419662,
-0.3607547879,
0.0221192595,
0.9180783033,
0.9578715563,
-0.3275942504,
0.0460713804,
0.1635913998,
-0.5130710006,
0.0959427804,
0.2896919847,
-0.2689280212,
0.2644231915,
0.1952528656,
0.8500124216,
0.0524252579,
-0.4286480844,
0.3099760413,
0.0974713117,
-0.6557623744,
-0.3393489122,
-0.0839095041,
0.0422781557,
0.526165247,
0.7236279249,
-0.051002115,
0.426564008,
-0.5724773407,
0.440410465,
0.5891519189,
-0.4791771173,
-0.0430282317,
0.7391676307,
0.0158460699,
-0.1941166073,
0.2368399203,
0.0047551757,
-0.1450383514,
0.2789577246,
0.4914190471,
0.436794728,
0.2654145062,
0.0591459945,
0.5134046674,
0.1418900639,
-0.2232474536,
0.1675679237,
0.1003783569,
-0.1407730728,
-0.2856831849,
-0.6045693755,
-0.2536273599,
-0.019553937,
-0.5893034339,
0.3863807023,
-0.4595994651,
-0.4553382397,
0.2254918665,
0.4744964838,
-0.4155951142,
0.1965141147,
-0.2884446979,
0.8979027271,
-0.7333385348,
0.7305099368,
0.7370732427,
-0.5268275142,
-0.3134495318,
-0.4394652247,
-0.2602195144,
-0.1310721189,
0.6026247144,
-0.2179791331,
0.0255542826,
-0.1440238953,
-0.2974246442,
-0.5777216554,
1.1963374615,
0.4496295154,
-0.6448672414,
0.1555622965,
-0.236087352,
0.6592822671,
-0.4538877606,
0.2702044845,
0.1239171475,
0.5867272019,
0.4409949481,
-0.5937379003,
0.3428123891,
-0.4161426425,
0.0047250381,
0.0849491581,
-0.3430164456,
0.5316326618,
-0.1937354058,
0.2090212107,
-0.0438549668,
0.9226987958,
0.6736406088,
0.9724599123,
0.3628335595,
0.4670100808,
0.9665153623,
-0.049257841,
0.8063810468,
-0.3899830282,
0.3194689751,
0.942912519,
-0.4466196895,
0.7018569112,
0.6548756361,
-0.2103248686,
0.6862680912,
0.8822204471,
-0.7687044144,
0.7104343176,
0.2048837245,
0.0809516683,
-0.0983553901,
-0.4101983011,
-0.568012774,
-0.0247670878,
0.0368641578,
-0.7605329752,
-0.0584053211,
-0.0184527636,
-0.0151130091,
-0.1573293507,
-0.4244496226,
0.7453158498,
-0.0041267844,
-0.7854474187,
0.2178096324,
0.0197492838,
0.2601792514,
-0.3609440923,
0.0244724248,
-0.2190108001,
-0.0953042135,
-0.4854834378,
-0.5420763493,
0.2539363205,
0.05493569,
-0.5001192093,
-0.0324264392,
0.7519121766,
-0.1890333444,
-0.4290058017,
0.1212961525,
0.1443915069,
0.2941934764,
0.0450865738,
-0.579141438,
-0.2630932629,
-0.4249221981,
-0.0439258441,
0.4193540514,
0.2174567729,
-0.2246874273,
0.612737,
1.2012042999,
0.2398422658,
0.1212502867,
0.0979989618,
0.7783770561,
-0.5769117475,
-0.4468434453,
-0.8008418679,
0.2659862041,
-0.2634862959,
-0.3196122646,
0.7055287361,
0.7725928426,
0.4637590945,
-0.0676439032,
0.6479574442,
-0.1259976476,
0.2348742336,
-0.525105238,
0.7868453264,
-0.3620862961,
0.2604190707,
-0.2725995481,
-0.9883831143,
-0.3912136257,
0.6402105093,
-0.3486698568,
0.2683147788,
0.8052123189,
0.690648973,
-0.1607189476,
0.2489458621,
0.172245726,
-0.2467787415,
0.2826375961,
0.1410768181,
0.4307888746,
-0.1857555211,
0.5310060978,
0.0502385534,
0.1848351359,
-0.6903986335,
-1.0466995239,
-1.0258095264,
-0.2224474698,
-0.3312465847,
-0.48699072,
0.2372514158,
0.9951301217,
0.8513106704,
-1.0967284441,
-0.1366249025,
-0.2357270569,
-0.0584874004,
-0.3040722013,
-0.1282039285,
0.3701066375,
-0.2513171136,
-0.4469664693,
0.5322295427,
0.1069955006,
-0.1341252476,
-0.1325060278,
-0.2517957389,
-0.6408242583,
0.0382923335,
0.3834649622,
0.2107942104,
-0.431546241,
-0.0513175316,
0.036017362,
-0.1934919357,
-0.0705365539,
1.3252552748,
-0.3819039762,
0.4263924062,
0.6413365602,
0.4852853417,
0.9369048476,
-0.0283131786,
0.4249083102,
-0.1987526119,
-0.1063052267,
0.2099634111,
0.6492983699,
-0.0355154276,
-0.17232503,
0.6587623358,
0.2572647333,
-0.6417732239,
-0.9352837801,
-0.2814761698,
-0.8330014348,
-0.2603922486,
0.8787642717,
-0.553973794,
-0.0140578188,
-0.4696665704,
-0.1867695004,
0.1984834373,
-0.5505235195,
0.6772476435,
0.837130785,
0.0430271737,
-0.2115249634,
-0.6332774758,
0.2195314318,
0.3031522632,
-0.5443895459,
-0.2136705071,
0.2961997092,
0.5687252283,
0.2018689215,
0.0729196668,
-0.1843292713,
0.3942995071,
-0.1524952799,
-0.2388980538,
-0.5562849045,
-0.3818559647,
-0.171794638,
0.5625533462,
0.0628968403,
0.150559172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07593v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07593v2
|
Follow-Up Differential Descriptions: Language Models Resolve Ambiguities for Image Classification
| 2023-11-10T05:24:07 | 2024-03-15T08:58:05 |
Reza Esfandiarpoor, Stephen H. Bach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
A promising approach for improving the performance of vision-language models
like CLIP for image classification is to extend the class descriptions (i.e.,
prompts) with related attributes, e.g., using brown sparrow instead of sparrow.
However, current zero-shot methods select a subset of attributes regardless of
commonalities between the target classes, potentially providing no useful
information that would have helped to distinguish between them. For instance,
they may use color instead of bill shape to distinguish between sparrows and
wrens, which are both brown. We propose Follow-up Differential Descriptions
(FuDD), a zero-shot approach that tailors the class descriptions to each
dataset and leads to additional attributes that better differentiate the target
classes. FuDD first identifies the ambiguous classes for each image, and then
uses a Large Language Model (LLM) to generate new class descriptions that
differentiate between them. The new class descriptions resolve the initial
ambiguity and help predict the correct label. In our experiments, FuDD
consistently outperforms generic description ensembles and naive LLM-generated
descriptions on 12 datasets. We show that differential descriptions are an
effective tool to resolve class ambiguities, which otherwise significantly
degrade the performance. We also show that high quality natural language class
descriptions produced by FuDD result in comparable performance to few-shot
adaptation methods.
|
[
-0.3823547363,
-0.5763096809,
0.5397412777,
0.1489542127,
-0.2480173558,
0.2883979678,
-0.0733186528,
-0.8444337249,
0.0829996169,
0.4171848893,
-0.5355573893,
-0.4428800344,
-0.7351446748,
0.1301300973,
-0.7756851315,
0.7657064199,
-0.118930988,
-0.3080554605,
-0.1225119233,
-0.0415980555,
-0.5055339932,
-0.4910880327,
-0.600982666,
-0.0643235296,
0.5597014427,
0.2777667046,
1.0671479702,
0.8556992412,
0.5961757302,
0.2728077471,
-0.1003155485,
-0.1408568621,
-0.1855178624,
0.0506739095,
-0.030081233,
-0.539339602,
-0.201493144,
-0.0891913697,
0.7948876023,
0.8736271262,
0.1690055579,
-0.0884936228,
-0.2129734755,
0.5037280917,
-0.9346905947,
0.1252910495,
-0.584602356,
0.3661631644,
-0.467972815,
-0.2507003248,
-0.4654802978,
0.2030421346,
0.3111196756,
-0.527723968,
0.5741375089,
-0.2049771994,
1.088511467,
0.1315682232,
-0.1863075495,
0.1494368911,
-0.8509928584,
0.8278931975,
-0.4786579907,
0.4286931455,
0.0817829147,
0.6775906086,
-0.0027531288,
-0.4780168235,
-0.6896650791,
0.0588549972,
-0.1253162324,
0.1739538759,
-0.3301871121,
-0.087142244,
0.2480262965,
0.2721094489,
-0.3525857329,
0.3441362083,
-0.5905277729,
-0.3588910997,
0.9348015189,
0.3085781336,
0.3034926951,
0.0445935726,
-0.3408727944,
-0.237436384,
-0.7776254416,
0.1020776182,
0.4493231475,
0.2560188472,
-0.3124821186,
0.4805104136,
-0.1549261957,
0.992008388,
-0.0023286906,
-0.0569125339,
0.2053437382,
0.1202400178,
-0.005898119,
-0.0666546598,
0.4556230605,
0.726334393,
0.126997143,
-0.382119745,
-0.1813949049,
0.2900589108,
0.0929618031,
-0.5025556684,
-0.2381981611,
0.125046283,
-0.4629313946,
-0.6217389107,
-0.041735936,
-1.1872487068,
-0.2960968018,
-0.3935987055,
0.2998017371,
-0.1591362357,
-0.1733700037,
0.1354450136,
-0.2986311913,
0.4335606098,
0.6507586837,
-0.8364091516,
0.3768535256,
0.3758992553,
0.9562110901,
-0.3405906558,
-0.3719745576,
-0.4563748538,
0.4908792377,
-0.1779039353,
1.1592513323,
-0.9902483821,
-0.5567318797,
0.0636446029,
0.1757789105,
0.2367160916,
-0.2756676078,
0.4144787192,
-0.2554836571,
0.3352781534,
-0.2215922922,
-0.271863699,
-0.4870569706,
0.1488584876,
-0.6006281376,
0.6654217839,
0.1992171258,
-0.7767495513,
0.3911831379,
-0.6077623963,
-0.461695075,
0.3050626516,
-0.51536268,
-0.3657662868,
0.2520914972,
0.3606684506,
0.6023727655,
-0.1180027276,
-0.1882706583,
-0.6477562785,
-0.6423422694,
0.2295528054,
-0.3627766073,
0.6493571401,
0.1350172907,
-0.1061320826,
-0.1190725937,
-0.8081926107,
-0.1309195608,
0.2516694367,
0.0269080345,
-0.221819967,
0.0055663693,
-0.0545715354,
-0.1228393316,
-0.0222353004,
-0.6174807549,
0.2669852972,
-0.2803064585,
0.1884175539,
0.7979178429,
-0.124771148,
0.3983407617,
-0.5065073967,
0.6963835955,
0.3164674938,
0.1623837501,
-0.5072512627,
-0.4856932461,
-0.8387826681,
-0.3442732692,
0.1993894875,
0.5746287107,
-0.659222424,
0.1667310894,
-0.0974100083,
-0.3628270924,
-0.4841504991,
-0.3246864676,
0.3474936187,
0.7629558444,
0.6073049903,
-0.4107818007,
-0.5274663568,
-0.884717226,
-0.0431675315,
-0.3186590374,
0.0816573799,
0.2975421846,
0.2787192166,
-0.3011261523,
0.841547668,
-0.8954154253,
-0.3060208261,
-0.0824937373,
0.2485873997,
0.0234504286,
0.1053247154,
0.9710297585,
-0.6560994387,
-0.5656870604,
-0.1129195616,
-0.5462038517,
-0.2812096477,
-0.3330615759,
-0.1452299207,
0.3978185058,
0.1605589241,
-0.2317530662,
0.731084466,
0.2131565213,
-0.1134337485,
0.6925410032,
0.0502410419,
0.2562734187,
-0.6233869195,
-0.098084867,
0.116890952,
-0.1210978702,
-0.4619061649,
0.0799544528,
0.0124050602,
-0.1188536286,
-0.6943420172,
0.6393381953,
-0.5460998416,
-0.2684190571,
-0.228275016,
-0.0889876485,
-0.0000778396,
0.2971718311,
0.6661805511,
0.5727096796,
1.3582031727,
-0.7638639212,
0.5781582594,
0.2411080003,
0.1171672419,
0.6769467592,
-0.5328984261,
-0.0264091734,
-0.2570213974,
0.2167141587,
-0.9886756539,
-0.3477166593,
0.2208744437,
-0.2947774529,
0.5373343825,
-0.2713960707,
-0.323966682,
-0.6709046364,
-0.5424954891,
0.3711580336,
0.7166909575,
-0.7219470739,
0.3603800833,
0.1033299565,
-0.0532279722,
-0.6484296918,
-0.9158765078,
0.1599734724,
-0.2313251346,
-0.5713617802,
0.466637969,
0.1373849511,
0.0487625413,
0.1482487917,
0.0367082506,
-0.2459562123,
0.0946020633,
0.0818921551,
0.490575701,
-0.0257273633,
0.2390811294,
0.1104961261,
-0.0477572419,
-0.0754524171,
0.0906539708,
0.3566181064,
-0.114983052,
-0.4360051453,
-0.3063579202,
0.4137220681,
0.3256808519,
-0.1762592494,
0.4607829154,
0.6193490028,
-0.1721829921,
-0.067213349,
-0.4412605464,
-0.0853810459,
-0.4737945497,
0.2622009516,
-0.4022419751,
-0.4483028054,
0.6407787204,
0.0852695182,
0.0283350516,
0.4446409941,
0.2284324318,
-0.4718924761,
0.9919348359,
0.9412769079,
0.0880201831,
0.5489805937,
-0.2843077183,
0.0057148137,
-0.8029649258,
-0.1685689539,
-0.3186903894,
-0.5957775116,
-0.3434961736,
-0.2030202746,
0.3084597886,
0.0328780226,
0.2036526501,
0.2993140817,
-0.6995775104,
0.7555410862,
0.2840053737,
0.0920196697,
0.217608884,
0.3565551639,
0.0815323964,
-0.1416198164,
-0.3880368471,
-0.3708724678,
1.3220613003,
0.3783864975,
0.9426787496,
0.1592087895,
0.8416771293,
0.3096010685,
0.1816421002,
-0.7039590478,
0.6069867015,
-0.6030350327,
-0.3875018358,
0.0196573455,
-0.2325417548,
-0.8867382407,
0.2238467038,
-0.234344095,
-0.8259094357,
0.1652053893,
0.3081845641,
-0.3484615386,
0.3380054235,
-0.7431389093,
0.4993264973,
-0.4926814139,
-0.3238903582,
0.0554642826,
-0.6980320215,
0.6445667148,
-0.2069316804,
0.0672494024,
0.0440535508,
-0.2525399625,
0.583964169,
-0.3603429496,
0.9530869126,
-0.2209053338,
-0.0626632273,
0.164080739,
0.0014320143,
0.0718424171,
-0.2763569653,
-0.0034180204,
0.2321595252,
0.3619071245,
-0.4450908899,
-0.7207691073,
0.4378006756,
-0.7227417231,
-0.6030497551,
-0.5074071288,
-0.4739955366,
-0.2448767275,
0.0131045757,
0.3487710953,
0.5460605025,
0.2027441561,
-0.0767824873,
0.4049216509,
-0.5726174116,
0.5155736208,
0.7425485849,
-0.3339913785,
-0.1408610642,
0.7123771906,
0.1291224658,
0.1742767394,
0.4462652802,
0.1403036714,
-0.5375390649,
-0.5912095904,
-0.4888441563,
0.1457081288,
-0.8547661304,
-0.4613430798,
-0.6269397736,
-0.1330829263,
-0.5986432433,
-0.5027768612,
-0.0079461243,
-0.6673446894,
-0.3759156466,
0.1781970114,
0.57554847,
0.6745182276,
-0.1531435698,
0.5533279181,
-0.9549413323,
0.3429926932,
-0.0105022416,
0.3972506225,
-0.0412430912,
-0.7179184556,
0.1355025917,
0.2201424688,
-0.6495070457,
-1.2236195803,
0.3865922093,
0.4819386005,
0.7886378765,
0.3128468394,
0.2496398389,
0.9309660792,
-0.3575994074,
0.8373509645,
0.5612627268,
-0.8603767753,
0.7822321653,
-0.0502864532,
0.3400111794,
0.0045107482,
0.444385618,
-0.5582385063,
-0.7579363585,
-0.5831168294,
-0.8032798767,
0.7918860912,
-0.1176562607,
0.3456097841,
-0.0417451002,
0.4297296703,
0.2833630741,
0.0138923265,
-0.7166552544,
-0.2356295139,
-0.2551831603,
-0.2504761517,
0.1271071732,
-0.1663414389,
-0.151446566,
-0.2670485675,
0.3976845443,
-0.139560312,
0.4091771543,
0.1594703496,
-0.1690377891,
-0.3034502268,
0.368460983,
0.4795803726,
0.2817780972,
-0.1283888221,
0.3474929333,
0.1324312687,
-0.4694062769,
0.0954669267,
0.0189231671,
-0.326010406,
0.1944228858,
0.6870452166,
0.6837079525,
0.0806502253,
-0.5223508477,
0.6532249451,
-0.0050592162,
-0.3309706748,
-0.0595163219,
0.2871280611,
-0.4705646336,
0.1148650572,
0.2734331191,
0.254697293,
0.3179351389,
-0.6528066993,
0.2595562935,
0.3965696394,
-0.1495062709,
-0.4133962095,
0.4275883734,
0.3548507392,
-0.0957880765,
0.4819884598,
-0.1709662676,
-0.7309709191,
0.5814467669,
0.4947105646,
0.8002097607,
0.1299307346,
0.4993591309,
0.0499205031,
0.0047208951,
0.0316627212,
0.3995358646,
-0.1928706467,
-0.7156336904,
-0.2525532246,
-0.5437400341,
-0.4938268065,
0.0780062452,
-0.684452951,
0.6343824267,
-0.592363894,
-0.1013594121,
0.0999290496,
-0.1808655262,
-0.6840993762,
0.1032668874,
0.4120332003,
0.8702987432,
-1.0857503414,
0.6637834311,
0.8434695601,
-0.6960518956,
-0.7209652662,
0.0777359903,
0.1121731177,
-0.6971384883,
1.0463202,
0.2489547431,
-0.2515580058,
-0.1886674464,
-0.6416279674,
-0.6688029766,
1.0828573704,
0.5490432978,
-0.6738530397,
0.1785033941,
0.0672367662,
0.6805259585,
-0.383824259,
0.3289873302,
0.2122542858,
0.3577206135,
0.798212707,
-0.9597898126,
-0.1842796355,
0.0439737849,
0.0184325278,
0.1310370415,
-0.5321191549,
0.7857608199,
-0.6201473475,
-0.4920021892,
0.2148016542,
0.4055172205,
-0.0804787502,
0.3091259599,
0.3928597867,
0.5561056137,
0.6408703923,
-0.2576289475,
1.0043002367,
0.005469155,
0.3607538342,
1.137078166,
-0.4849638343,
0.9156447649,
0.4366121888,
-0.5192342401,
0.5520052314,
0.6775750518,
-0.4946110249,
0.6870767474,
0.0527468137,
-0.1984003335,
-0.1380720139,
0.0020476205,
-0.6098393798,
0.524269104,
0.1918174773,
-0.3837072551,
-0.5906238556,
0.1184165403,
-0.3625710905,
0.2164358348,
-0.4074517787,
0.6944429278,
-0.3628266752,
-0.3997802734,
0.736882329,
-0.1008583978,
0.8135353327,
-0.2322469503,
-0.1848886907,
-0.2061920613,
0.1928129196,
-0.5019903779,
-1.3038263321,
0.7338399887,
0.1155950353,
-0.097870402,
-0.1839624047,
0.6623293757,
-0.5128898025,
-0.6340910792,
0.1879861355,
0.0605120957,
0.476308614,
0.2875317633,
-0.8451657295,
0.345295608,
-0.0593396276,
0.4397984445,
0.0103705898,
0.4741612971,
-0.0762176141,
0.7379511595,
0.3084751964,
0.3492229879,
0.2895456254,
0.0119828172,
0.8468981385,
-0.5040559173,
-0.4439099431,
-0.7062367201,
0.464258492,
-0.0813261345,
0.0812738314,
0.3520261943,
0.3476097584,
1.1298975945,
-0.4629822969,
0.8713312745,
-0.0514217503,
0.6257662177,
-0.5798879862,
0.4131150246,
-0.6765889525,
0.5242158175,
-0.3507649899,
-0.8877567649,
-0.6278604865,
0.7549319267,
-0.3952277005,
-0.0648369566,
0.7061178684,
0.7052907348,
-0.2509578168,
-0.1484080106,
0.4046396017,
0.0166244544,
0.4627550244,
0.5842978358,
1.0998880863,
-0.4410980046,
0.6339637637,
-0.5042874217,
-0.2263247222,
-0.0758535489,
-1.0766414404,
-0.7855687737,
-0.3580512106,
-0.8414080143,
0.0982505828,
0.0419056527,
0.3823796213,
0.9030195475,
-0.7555775642,
-0.0168169793,
-0.0019574387,
0.0154734282,
-0.0685564205,
-0.282638818,
0.0548418686,
-0.4371253252,
-0.6285461187,
-0.1703344434,
0.497315824,
0.6624466777,
-0.2569143474,
-0.2003226727,
0.1193999946,
-0.0628949925,
0.3826546967,
0.4268571138,
-0.9401773214,
-0.4793875813,
-0.2059760988,
0.2393337339,
-0.1106525585,
0.6624000072,
-0.8919371367,
0.4156246781,
0.2793416381,
0.5912153125,
0.3056327105,
-0.1458105445,
0.6051289439,
-0.9341712594,
0.4288549423,
0.0958396643,
0.3585242331,
0.4331319928,
-0.4357325733,
0.4222045839,
0.4976173043,
-0.041065596,
-0.990296483,
0.5856543779,
-1.1813225746,
-0.3598649204,
1.1060496569,
-0.4014724195,
-0.1741910279,
-0.0152102951,
-0.3694942594,
-0.0141591849,
-0.2514745593,
0.9237887859,
0.7780632377,
-0.2444209158,
-0.666739285,
-0.0349726975,
0.2655259073,
0.2895849943,
-0.7147698998,
0.1458646357,
0.6059801579,
0.1593254358,
0.1925963908,
0.4099593461,
-0.3775663078,
0.387799114,
-0.2508808672,
-0.2255409509,
-0.1687728912,
-0.4196743965,
-0.3980113268,
-0.1496828794,
0.0994644016,
-0.4676319957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05876v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05876v2
|
Trends in Integration of Knowledge and Large Language Models: A Survey and Taxonomy of Methods, Benchmarks, and Applications
| 2023-11-10T05:24:04 | 2023-12-07T12:42:07 |
Zhangyin Feng, Weitao Ma, Weijiang Yu, Lei Huang, Haotian Wang, Qianglong Chen, Weihua Peng, Xiaocheng Feng, Bing Qin, Ting liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit superior performance on various natural
language tasks, but they are susceptible to issues stemming from outdated data
and domain-specific limitations. In order to address these challenges,
researchers have pursued two primary strategies, knowledge editing and
retrieval augmentation, to enhance LLMs by incorporating external information
from different aspects. Nevertheless, there is still a notable absence of a
comprehensive survey. In this paper, we propose a review to discuss the trends
in integration of knowledge and large language models, including taxonomy of
methods, benchmarks, and applications. In addition, we conduct an in-depth
analysis of different methods and point out potential research directions in
the future. We hope this survey offers the community quick access and a
comprehensive overview of this research area, with the intention of inspiring
future research endeavors.
|
[
-0.5643891692,
-0.8155799508,
0.8563197851,
-0.0019019637,
0.0992027,
0.3756463528,
-0.4386030734,
-0.7272323966,
0.0541688539,
0.5305879116,
-0.1775484234,
-0.3907909989,
-0.7498633265,
-0.1026617363,
-0.6861817837,
0.3576294184,
-0.1557163894,
0.1047461927,
-0.6526122689,
-0.2794372141,
-0.2894326448,
-0.8417826295,
-0.2848283648,
-0.2427534908,
0.4449775815,
0.1678424478,
0.435321033,
0.3395175338,
0.6839850545,
0.3077966869,
-0.4869903922,
0.3883163631,
-0.1449856311,
0.1908019632,
-0.3177908063,
-0.3767656684,
-0.4056425095,
-0.0839457363,
0.9615018964,
1.061799407,
-0.0439016894,
0.0517558418,
0.0931863189,
0.4390978515,
-0.8697215915,
0.1258267462,
-0.3138074279,
-0.1847447157,
-0.4492902458,
0.003739564,
-0.143445164,
-0.5017620921,
0.2883579731,
-0.1143654734,
-0.188127026,
-0.2234212756,
0.2433138788,
-0.0645794421,
-0.6338791251,
-0.5019673109,
-0.8150629997,
1.0598353148,
-0.9501837492,
0.6995023489,
0.0503558889,
0.3530559242,
-0.1836792529,
-0.7502657771,
-0.4284603894,
-0.309137553,
-0.0254948139,
-0.2325595468,
-0.2851076722,
-0.0335766114,
0.0281220712,
0.3619847596,
-0.2375062853,
0.5315915942,
-0.1889264882,
-0.0604801886,
0.7172831893,
0.3062611222,
0.3206965923,
-0.0267247315,
-0.1552826017,
0.1581239849,
-0.701107204,
-0.1042171195,
0.1726341695,
0.1160344183,
0.2508437932,
0.7970494032,
-0.5124012828,
1.002332449,
-0.4438644052,
-0.2848221362,
0.1168358177,
-0.7091923356,
-0.1931770444,
-0.3718644977,
0.8778069615,
0.2535471618,
-0.0650197715,
-0.1373778284,
-0.3462758362,
-0.3135511875,
-0.1946779341,
-0.3694743514,
0.1370815188,
0.1280893683,
-0.2064544111,
-0.1361002922,
-0.1662872434,
-0.9095458388,
-0.6228759289,
-0.5500649214,
0.2287232578,
-0.2573600709,
-0.4533323944,
0.1898815781,
-0.1777157784,
0.179193452,
0.6323655844,
-0.6880694032,
0.4178113937,
0.9843258858,
0.7825356722,
-0.3517384827,
-0.0877560452,
-0.0981518552,
0.0439777263,
-0.2006379217,
0.9827231169,
-0.6311924458,
-0.4053028822,
0.5748228431,
-0.2046377957,
0.0569282249,
-0.6154862642,
0.3270837665,
-0.920830369,
0.2412011772,
-0.3850543797,
-0.7180561423,
-0.346370995,
0.545034647,
-0.4995014966,
1.0706211329,
0.0294363294,
-0.6753188968,
0.1374058872,
-0.7330780625,
-0.3085331321,
0.0380962677,
-0.0815834031,
0.1543583572,
0.0608060472,
0.2321767956,
0.535366416,
-0.7831381559,
0.4338516593,
-0.2213785797,
-0.2022542655,
0.42965886,
-0.1128784269,
0.6854285598,
0.3013773859,
0.0323407277,
0.0232606903,
-0.646069169,
0.009934647,
-0.0875724778,
-0.3406388164,
-0.6152210236,
0.069069162,
-0.018934831,
0.0820718482,
0.7127498388,
-0.2878364325,
0.5271286368,
-0.1278379261,
0.475240469,
0.3924516141,
0.1516252309,
0.6407495141,
-0.231384322,
0.5403569341,
0.0353400894,
0.2827169895,
0.0083679063,
-0.3390763104,
-0.53614223,
-0.002409426,
0.4669438303,
0.3901937306,
-0.6573492289,
0.4851188958,
-0.3674792647,
-0.850767374,
-0.2723476291,
0.3396655321,
0.0486984774,
0.3167066276,
0.4436335266,
-0.3333357573,
-0.5503844619,
-0.7311776876,
-0.3151128888,
-0.2339885682,
0.0279260278,
0.2327107042,
0.3330759406,
-0.3986028433,
0.9686032534,
-0.4648666382,
-0.0674958006,
-0.436743468,
0.0908766612,
0.2293864489,
0.3106067777,
0.4181911647,
-0.6586367488,
-0.3059247136,
0.2103212178,
-0.687582314,
-0.1212762892,
0.4879327714,
0.1213144884,
0.0667909831,
0.6256613135,
-0.5490272045,
0.0140374359,
0.574196279,
0.1277926266,
0.4926046431,
0.0683223158,
0.2589100301,
-0.9639088511,
0.0521702208,
0.1696770638,
0.0324788764,
-0.8061008453,
0.1754572839,
0.2322132587,
0.2937749922,
-0.3726941943,
0.8190767169,
-0.753015995,
-0.1707868427,
-0.277159512,
0.4236059189,
-0.1590465158,
-0.1030377448,
-0.0109197823,
0.7143988013,
0.4906229079,
-0.7661171556,
0.7141602039,
0.3181367218,
-0.7300709486,
0.3534937203,
-0.3429228663,
0.0692631677,
-0.1706593484,
0.2341824472,
-0.944933176,
-0.2157680541,
0.206856519,
-0.2336391956,
0.3786987662,
0.0102615822,
-0.7562491894,
-0.3955643773,
-0.4185519814,
0.3714030385,
0.5455243587,
-0.413954407,
0.5549806356,
0.5584726334,
-0.4237050712,
-0.7219125032,
-0.709078908,
0.3109563887,
-0.2187307179,
-0.5477499962,
0.1827192456,
0.0097483285,
-0.6691354513,
-0.0865519717,
0.1731157452,
-0.1442347467,
-0.1419993639,
-0.488024056,
0.3101986349,
-0.3244422972,
0.3149214983,
-0.2145425975,
0.4320099056,
-0.0148316342,
-0.2304742038,
0.5286989212,
0.2777811587,
-0.5291651487,
-0.1157537177,
0.3250851035,
0.6428491473,
-0.5552852154,
0.700912118,
0.3037264943,
-0.21877186,
0.0214735661,
-1.2959592342,
-0.0712685138,
-0.3754110038,
0.4626363218,
-0.0561945736,
-1.2044402361,
0.3916407228,
-0.5472750664,
0.1491647363,
0.3132824898,
0.384388715,
-0.013740547,
0.8396641016,
0.8532452583,
-0.1911119819,
0.7080143094,
-0.0994915515,
0.330524981,
-1.1916788816,
-0.2255045623,
-0.9463182688,
-0.1171880215,
-0.4366241693,
-0.5512305498,
0.2380473912,
0.1555381119,
0.0445558913,
0.1103293598,
-0.184238106,
0.0263630878,
0.3506599069,
-0.2580529153,
0.6208221316,
-0.2670429051,
0.0505769625,
-0.0672871917,
-0.6918306351,
-0.4139322937,
1.1787623167,
0.3681967258,
0.8230093718,
0.2055995464,
0.5401884317,
0.1140786037,
0.385304451,
-0.9257059693,
0.6147132516,
-0.0434118696,
-0.4955077767,
-0.4628668427,
-0.3501582742,
-0.6382734776,
0.1439135969,
0.0873113573,
-0.8559212685,
0.398973316,
-0.1346904337,
0.0120852357,
0.3448405862,
-0.4791855216,
0.4834176302,
-0.2685925364,
-0.2479496449,
-0.1033937186,
-0.378665477,
0.7052448988,
-0.1765696257,
0.4874274135,
-0.0629848018,
-0.2838673592,
0.8654375672,
-0.1437856257,
0.598798871,
-0.1946353316,
-0.4153020978,
0.3237541616,
-0.2887698412,
0.6931516528,
-0.2864330709,
-0.164198637,
0.0786220208,
0.0743390992,
-0.1391276121,
-0.6087549925,
0.7002698779,
-0.4160188138,
-0.6131083965,
-0.3409717679,
-0.5540764332,
-0.887781024,
-0.0001915065,
-0.1281623989,
0.3707068563,
-0.1893470138,
0.2629584074,
0.7797474265,
-0.2509030402,
0.4477716982,
0.5413383842,
-0.4541499913,
-0.358578831,
0.5229223967,
0.3701867461,
0.3864051104,
0.4004537165,
0.0827447176,
-0.5907027125,
-0.9463062882,
0.0229589045,
0.4160583317,
-0.7669228315,
-0.164481014,
-0.7865825891,
-0.2739225924,
-0.7746366858,
0.0464724861,
-0.2540926039,
-0.2425009012,
-0.1459881812,
0.1164051294,
0.480416894,
1.0083348751,
0.0709053949,
0.2890867293,
-1.0100544691,
0.0551530458,
0.3348947167,
0.3600030839,
0.2919351459,
-0.4220342338,
-0.3467161953,
-0.1210090443,
-0.019474797,
-0.7012124062,
0.1262795776,
-0.1976998895,
0.8035984039,
0.3372673392,
-0.1588279009,
0.6719870567,
-0.333550185,
0.9499894977,
0.23763448,
-0.7324633598,
0.3052401245,
-0.2468750626,
0.4109860361,
0.4725930095,
0.6517885327,
-1.0728789568,
-0.2423839718,
-0.2423761785,
-0.7795230746,
0.5102861524,
-0.4248134196,
0.1542695314,
0.2561768591,
0.0686282143,
-0.0553087816,
0.2960535586,
-0.2443270087,
0.0473511703,
0.5521481037,
-0.0437509418,
-0.1255568862,
-0.4370995462,
-0.0829975307,
-0.3439359069,
0.6805030107,
-0.0713240206,
0.0776034668,
-0.0364746265,
-0.2605055869,
0.1334913373,
0.5747307539,
0.4356926084,
0.9498863816,
0.024585627,
-0.0372152552,
0.2562377155,
-0.2987234592,
-0.0220945571,
0.0871746242,
-0.2644827366,
-0.0023551986,
0.4872335196,
0.4188550413,
0.4223048687,
-0.7354499102,
0.3838381469,
0.1933877617,
-0.1607938409,
-0.2005408555,
-0.029914394,
0.3869962394,
0.3801669776,
0.3950303495,
-0.2941803336,
0.2371887267,
-0.7090273499,
-0.2525018752,
0.6518524289,
-0.2861596048,
-0.1486350745,
0.2400771081,
0.0695041344,
0.06621591,
0.3790820539,
0.2458459586,
-0.3785275817,
0.1931359023,
0.1776567698,
0.5733961463,
-0.2847602963,
-0.0969838277,
0.2216764241,
0.2213582695,
-0.3490528464,
0.2324412316,
-0.061729148,
-0.7712221742,
-0.6742477417,
-0.6838448048,
-0.6236907244,
0.2140901238,
-0.4226876497,
0.3779670894,
-0.1050233096,
-0.1666030139,
-0.0366186388,
0.0473831967,
-0.6646062136,
-0.0340860412,
0.1175514236,
1.3332954645,
-0.5827168226,
0.8048496246,
1.0732420683,
-0.3110541999,
-0.4449146092,
-0.0435388312,
0.0979963019,
-0.5899662971,
0.477881372,
-0.3592250347,
0.0683490708,
-0.0189591497,
-0.5847530365,
-1.0776993036,
0.9780741334,
-0.0638734028,
-0.6010532379,
-0.1632173955,
0.2697706819,
0.5478671193,
-0.2362672538,
0.1573859453,
1.0154297352,
0.8512344956,
0.0849183947,
-0.9732031226,
-0.3023110926,
0.0498250648,
0.2433642894,
0.3250568807,
-0.6834174395,
0.5830752254,
0.2992845774,
-0.0417451151,
0.2017313689,
0.6139478683,
-0.0674619153,
0.1854112744,
0.2492432743,
0.4182738066,
0.5871174932,
-0.1605406851,
0.8141148686,
-0.1394166052,
0.2577611804,
0.8055881262,
-0.4613349736,
0.9005675912,
0.5228973031,
-0.6446217299,
0.2601611912,
0.3045251369,
0.1114311218,
0.2587604523,
0.2080020905,
-0.5618061423,
-0.005583148,
-0.3672306538,
-0.4561080039,
0.3502592742,
0.6710450649,
-0.2630364895,
-0.271166414,
0.0571913868,
0.0806089938,
0.0804576948,
-0.3775320649,
1.0762654543,
-0.0138707887,
-0.7418494225,
0.1415989995,
0.0789697021,
1.0054516792,
-0.791275382,
0.0536406226,
-0.2646967173,
-0.1263493448,
-0.1322483569,
-0.9860682487,
0.127924636,
-0.1001191735,
0.0547948927,
-0.2832629681,
0.9058181643,
-0.4383485019,
-0.2131202072,
0.303508848,
0.9325888753,
-0.0926153138,
0.0423446596,
-0.3194102347,
0.3477585614,
-0.2317455262,
-0.1846820116,
0.3987108767,
0.3855242431,
-0.0455522761,
0.5752548575,
0.5261521935,
0.1772162318,
0.2331912071,
0.1090682894,
0.9414023161,
-0.8627134562,
0.0053174854,
-0.6366935372,
0.5403308868,
-0.1459364593,
-0.0809815526,
0.8534181714,
0.479875803,
0.7057445645,
0.0128279412,
1.0275185108,
-0.2013710588,
0.85179919,
-0.4091822207,
0.5769871473,
-0.5722571611,
0.1741652191,
-0.2926229835,
-1.0585187674,
-0.2980357409,
-0.1823309213,
-0.416657269,
0.1882878393,
0.5860459805,
0.5016385913,
-0.0524204485,
-0.0040212339,
0.2552928627,
0.243458733,
0.4356164336,
0.1765983999,
1.1805218458,
-0.1414147019,
0.241974026,
-0.2064882666,
-0.241851002,
-0.5250227451,
-0.7812506557,
-0.5830161572,
-0.6677626967,
-0.2130436897,
0.142573148,
-0.0417465046,
0.6586883664,
0.4441118836,
-0.6667985916,
-0.3933041394,
0.1816553026,
0.180505693,
-0.0567200258,
-0.1818763018,
0.2629491985,
-0.4823914766,
-0.9248564243,
0.4889008701,
0.2768180668,
-0.0708426386,
-0.6320611835,
0.1911772639,
-0.4958857596,
0.0165354945,
0.8224777579,
0.4115765393,
-0.6690644026,
-0.1182399169,
0.0747569427,
-0.085076645,
-0.0401772894,
0.8268829584,
-0.6145406961,
0.3556420207,
0.7488414645,
0.9158103466,
0.2667529881,
-0.1487242579,
0.5070183277,
-0.5316022635,
-0.2368948162,
0.3453968465,
0.397542119,
0.5104679465,
-0.1043302342,
0.6083780527,
0.0780271515,
-0.5534175038,
-0.9812632203,
0.1295493096,
-0.8680832386,
-0.1988641918,
1.1485317945,
0.1449290663,
-0.1011263728,
-0.1618352532,
-0.0531637855,
0.0988522992,
-0.0032141078,
0.5015561581,
1.0833221674,
-0.2584376931,
-0.258574903,
-0.6991366148,
0.2779461145,
0.1315310895,
-1.0820323229,
0.1556763947,
0.6862298846,
0.1473442167,
0.2670053542,
0.4868699312,
-0.4201895297,
0.1042529494,
-0.4871287048,
0.1164651141,
0.1943431944,
-0.1329854876,
-0.4885062873,
0.2392462492,
0.6014597416,
0.4280138314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05845v1
|
Tamil-Llama: A New Tamil Language Model Based on Llama 2
| 2023-11-10T03:02:39 | 2023-11-10T03:02:39 |
Abhinand Balachandran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Language modeling has witnessed remarkable advancements in recent years, with
Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT setting unparalleled benchmarks in
human-like text generation. However, a prevailing limitation is the
underrepresentation of languages like Tamil in these cutting-edge models,
leading to suboptimal performance in diverse linguistic contexts. This paper
addresses this lacuna, enhancing the open-source LLaMA model with an addition
of 16,000 Tamil tokens, aiming to achieve superior text generation and
comprehension in the Tamil language. We strategically employ the LoRA
methodology for efficient model training on a comprehensive Tamil corpus,
ensuring computational feasibility and model robustness. Moreover, we introduce
a Tamil-translated version of the Alpaca dataset and a subset of the OpenOrca
dataset tailored for instruction fine-tuning. Our results showcase significant
performance improvements in Tamil text generation, with potential implications
for the broader landscape of LLMs in Indian languages. We further underscore
our commitment to open research by making our models, datasets, and code
publicly accessible, fostering further innovations in language modeling.
|
[
0.009418644,
-0.7357591987,
0.2610234618,
0.2795911729,
-0.6431239843,
0.1906624585,
-0.1853881329,
-0.4556550086,
0.094559446,
0.6960190535,
-0.0633979887,
-0.4265871942,
-0.7098158598,
0.0663931593,
-0.4185634255,
0.7543843985,
-0.164490968,
-0.1862696856,
-0.0496169887,
-0.3790047169,
-0.5202067494,
-0.4564160109,
-0.6272960901,
-0.3694061339,
0.5248218775,
0.1850054711,
0.5441962481,
0.7151073813,
0.4664780498,
0.199176088,
-0.1653551906,
0.4657488167,
-0.4939647317,
0.1225135624,
0.0660001189,
-0.7292093039,
-0.4690206051,
-0.0844472572,
0.7230936885,
0.3274016082,
-0.2142457217,
0.3095089495,
-0.0332766436,
0.5502449274,
-0.6608262658,
0.4384990036,
-0.93783319,
-0.2696975172,
-0.510094285,
-0.107815057,
-0.3290962875,
-0.3725280762,
-0.4664191604,
-0.5185652971,
-0.2072441578,
0.0211244598,
0.6096817851,
0.5114147067,
-0.2267066985,
-0.2951724827,
-0.7372825742,
0.4995858073,
-0.6994504929,
0.3530057371,
0.458414644,
0.1565684527,
-0.1426579803,
-0.5810418129,
-0.6548011303,
-0.2994178832,
0.2985191941,
0.0404611677,
-0.3902702034,
-0.268397063,
-0.1798965037,
0.5033489466,
-0.2415654659,
0.4201442599,
-0.7640917301,
0.2211248428,
0.3045291305,
0.1019985452,
0.2359293848,
-0.0061713974,
-0.182605505,
0.0301888734,
-1.130423069,
-0.2033847123,
0.5375940204,
0.6896789074,
-0.2928740084,
1.0649863482,
0.0856557786,
0.6785879731,
-0.400796622,
-0.3205155432,
0.0563441999,
-0.0633000582,
-0.408446759,
0.0377830304,
0.7644829154,
0.0984659046,
0.1804886162,
0.0496108457,
-0.1487723142,
0.4129602313,
-0.0497933999,
-0.5042237043,
0.3701934814,
0.0659135804,
-0.2667678297,
-0.5196839571,
-0.4321489334,
-0.5656135678,
-0.6334283352,
-0.3121163547,
0.0555339307,
-0.2800302207,
-0.6074639559,
0.1908309758,
0.469166249,
0.3635724187,
0.3186154962,
-0.867559135,
0.3405176401,
0.9267873168,
1.0144654512,
-0.3202630281,
-0.2916417718,
-0.5668868423,
0.2262920141,
-0.4984830916,
0.9617143869,
-0.7637560368,
-0.4861359,
-0.022098273,
-0.5797412395,
-0.0644830242,
-0.5920560956,
0.4255594909,
-0.4318995178,
0.2244583219,
0.0737689286,
-0.2920482159,
0.0564304627,
0.0840107203,
-0.8326883316,
1.1923909187,
0.4545587003,
-0.8267271519,
-0.0416789129,
-0.964363575,
-0.2255705148,
0.1427105218,
-0.3455228806,
-0.2573684156,
0.3065830469,
0.2265500426,
0.1019254923,
-0.7907346487,
0.3067806661,
0.0296331402,
-0.4535458386,
0.2023854554,
-0.3406220078,
0.7928954959,
0.5712240338,
-0.0059434259,
0.0665496737,
-0.7032251954,
-0.2563021481,
0.1659381092,
-0.5241538882,
-0.1957279742,
-0.2721556425,
0.1403231025,
-0.0487615392,
0.2559779584,
-0.5097777247,
0.1800125837,
-0.5358169675,
0.5391428471,
0.6551459432,
-0.3196682632,
0.298440069,
-0.072381556,
0.6391031742,
0.1326108724,
-0.0066564181,
-0.1994944513,
-0.7189304829,
-0.874973774,
-0.4690565169,
0.3257811069,
0.5792990923,
-0.342736572,
-0.1103580296,
-0.1079785004,
-0.4829500318,
-1.0133390427,
0.3751712739,
0.4007695317,
0.3787820041,
0.213770017,
-0.3008969724,
-0.8728300929,
-0.736961484,
-0.1638593972,
-0.5869571567,
0.1234037504,
-0.0073567447,
0.2188382,
-0.4781531096,
1.0185759068,
-0.302017957,
-0.3902669251,
-0.4429101646,
-0.1139505506,
0.1391014755,
0.3035674691,
0.3853740394,
-0.5704439282,
-0.3057099581,
0.2159602195,
-0.7582040429,
-0.0964635983,
0.3689979017,
-0.1552925855,
0.5553827882,
0.7293306589,
-0.6338219047,
0.4891459942,
0.7238028646,
0.0177110787,
0.2724249661,
-0.1296648234,
-0.200659886,
-1.5483443737,
0.1119728014,
-0.3165695667,
0.0350165814,
-0.5080908537,
0.5661602616,
-0.2143059075,
-0.1709558815,
-0.6613667011,
0.8001107574,
-0.2495079488,
-0.0179317053,
-0.5096157193,
0.1375431567,
-0.2313968986,
0.3656010628,
-0.086748071,
1.0015687943,
0.2409124821,
-0.256308496,
0.1601358652,
0.2882564068,
-0.5170565248,
0.2452955842,
-0.7757780552,
0.2973610759,
-0.256634444,
0.253747642,
-0.778912425,
-0.3135561347,
0.3458635211,
-0.3964033127,
0.139932394,
-0.2690556347,
-0.5251201987,
-0.023275245,
-0.0853063986,
0.4350864887,
0.5850878954,
-0.4211051762,
0.5619778633,
0.4745610356,
-0.1051271036,
-0.6804695725,
-0.6364553571,
0.1918294728,
-0.2905417979,
-0.2589547038,
-0.0916534215,
0.0979038253,
-0.56672436,
-0.2547209263,
0.2726117074,
-0.0565465912,
0.0639852807,
0.408885777,
0.3831059635,
-0.4935613275,
0.147039935,
0.1572001725,
-0.062497735,
-0.1973083317,
-0.2677447498,
0.8374509215,
-0.4091453254,
-0.3834559917,
-0.3654187322,
0.2712993026,
0.5072407126,
-0.5725726485,
0.8246809244,
0.5610459447,
-0.5197208524,
0.3745692372,
-0.4575136602,
0.4007725418,
-0.4256999493,
0.3378589153,
-0.3504950106,
-1.0356727839,
0.4109881222,
0.0425070524,
0.1927860677,
0.5402873755,
0.858925581,
0.1922889203,
0.5677698851,
0.977927506,
-0.2357369512,
0.3981840611,
-0.0108656315,
0.2320084274,
-0.886610508,
-0.3246541619,
-0.6863305569,
0.3672542572,
-0.8002726436,
-0.7686578035,
0.0662777722,
0.239266336,
-0.2241017669,
0.2260247618,
-0.3347016573,
0.5370793343,
0.4057635069,
-0.1093621776,
0.5662776232,
0.3987860382,
-0.1442479491,
0.2154539973,
-0.5067119598,
-0.9770245552,
1.1278789043,
0.3821517229,
0.7011055946,
0.2269731015,
0.6048904061,
0.2850936353,
0.585147202,
-0.3876003325,
0.3701624572,
-0.2340422869,
-0.5616223812,
-0.1661804318,
-0.1499446034,
-0.968778491,
0.1799389422,
-0.0468139239,
-0.7824718356,
-0.2062673569,
0.1417426765,
-0.2868947983,
0.4385261834,
-0.6054888368,
0.3230109215,
0.0445785671,
-0.3194950521,
-0.1646300405,
-0.2472849935,
0.6516967416,
-0.343786478,
0.2126595825,
-0.4074222147,
-0.3876079619,
0.5401530862,
-0.4100441933,
0.872323513,
0.0492222719,
-0.4626870453,
0.6994335055,
0.0179744363,
0.4483495653,
0.1922928542,
-0.2606808245,
0.1413902342,
-0.365773648,
-0.5315961242,
-0.3149776459,
0.7716838121,
-1.118289113,
-0.5061112642,
-0.2178564817,
-0.5323104262,
-0.1610341072,
0.0708884001,
0.1088237837,
0.2433412522,
-0.157126978,
-0.1249688119,
0.4855221212,
-0.3284722269,
0.2064696699,
0.3535028696,
-0.5466514826,
-0.5286239982,
0.9837633371,
-0.2196220607,
0.0846558139,
0.5112564564,
0.1012670249,
-0.323182106,
-0.6766123772,
-0.6583354473,
0.454485178,
-0.711995542,
-0.2389400303,
-0.7131789923,
-0.3399463594,
-0.4239979088,
0.1029681191,
-0.5600793958,
-0.6258462667,
-0.4833694994,
-0.0806218013,
0.624992609,
1.2401202917,
0.0271690302,
0.7055674195,
-0.5593543053,
0.1946032643,
0.1722121537,
0.5243358016,
-0.0317769013,
-0.5107529163,
-0.1067340299,
0.0891655982,
-0.2060696632,
-0.4032415748,
0.3847388327,
0.0180182736,
0.2629923522,
0.1366972923,
-0.2732540071,
0.6026841402,
-0.3968396485,
0.5835449696,
0.261615783,
-0.6968087554,
0.5119709969,
-0.5498546958,
0.4517244399,
0.4589235783,
0.1175166443,
-0.4958658814,
-0.4812867641,
-0.3165284395,
-0.7260648012,
0.4517467618,
0.6032332778,
0.2763093412,
-0.0250346363,
0.4076514244,
0.4088402092,
0.1421723664,
-0.6408236027,
-0.0169856884,
-0.3570846021,
-0.3431515992,
-0.0650626346,
-0.3066883385,
0.2084397078,
-0.0168554634,
0.5809086561,
-0.1981105655,
0.4006243348,
-0.2162992358,
-0.2143717706,
-0.1672192216,
0.2182300091,
1.0173170567,
0.6119289398,
-0.1479079276,
0.0006398085,
0.3382629156,
-0.7061734796,
0.1408425421,
0.0361239091,
-0.1077119783,
-0.184445858,
0.3666630387,
0.9821096659,
-0.1621636897,
-0.7644136548,
-0.0179392677,
-0.2987008989,
0.2745008171,
-0.3426903188,
0.1818236113,
0.3752669692,
0.2049226165,
0.4123991728,
0.1035394073,
-0.3773770332,
-0.4471605718,
-0.2852040231,
0.0623774044,
-0.3643927872,
-0.2213122249,
0.8973332644,
0.2289960086,
-0.5909438133,
0.6681807041,
0.1676331311,
-0.1845051199,
0.3731619418,
0.751930058,
0.6007615328,
-0.228409484,
0.0844689831,
0.4381458163,
0.4549743533,
-0.0468611456,
0.338414371,
0.1069601551,
-0.3374682069,
-0.525691092,
-1.0115238428,
-0.5575494766,
0.4457320273,
-0.4847631454,
0.3568426073,
-0.4092004597,
-0.1020450741,
-0.2859100103,
0.0685848519,
-0.447029382,
0.0105867172,
0.3087491095,
1.0283617973,
-0.6498709321,
1.0253845453,
0.5065617561,
-0.519769311,
-0.522062242,
-0.3098173141,
-0.3682926595,
-1.0437171459,
0.4464941025,
0.179094106,
-0.3681263328,
-0.0568149351,
-0.5850186944,
-1.007961154,
0.8884753585,
0.7401500344,
-0.5542414188,
-0.0982201695,
0.7006829381,
0.7386615276,
-0.6782168746,
0.249645099,
0.5057822466,
0.1782114953,
0.0228134133,
-0.7604894042,
-0.1456897259,
-0.3562941551,
0.2525120974,
0.0422002077,
-0.883380115,
0.7510561347,
-0.3486762047,
0.0052423198,
0.5828734636,
1.0489556789,
0.6440417171,
0.0556033812,
0.3095145226,
0.4735518694,
0.778886795,
0.0739348009,
1.1335840225,
-0.0977082476,
-0.1841115505,
1.339817524,
-0.3616497219,
1.1809624434,
0.4045777619,
-0.2149579525,
0.4526916742,
0.583181262,
0.4348090291,
0.2433824539,
0.207458958,
-0.3657499254,
-0.0685040504,
-0.3829874396,
-0.5440087318,
0.8879722357,
0.5021383762,
-0.2804713547,
-0.101056613,
-0.0668626949,
0.2496609092,
0.157308206,
-0.2871496975,
0.4336947203,
0.1215974391,
-0.7057953477,
0.713337481,
0.2409448177,
0.5328979492,
-0.4496085346,
-0.0248733759,
-0.6554163694,
0.2107495666,
0.0197746325,
-0.4943717122,
0.318969965,
0.5379084945,
-0.018833641,
0.1356026083,
0.6838847399,
-0.3212795258,
-0.7304977775,
0.1062857658,
0.5997285843,
0.3617522418,
0.0827522948,
-0.3997184038,
0.5550330281,
-0.1048405319,
0.0715145394,
0.2959030867,
0.1765037775,
-0.4954685867,
0.6868721843,
0.656036675,
-0.134817183,
0.2379877418,
0.1359833181,
1.0319821835,
-0.4163308442,
-0.2133797258,
-0.8318936229,
0.0759716257,
0.1557705253,
-0.5765487552,
0.3750494719,
0.801346004,
0.7227877975,
0.0438862666,
0.9189573526,
0.1646770388,
0.4719391465,
-0.3337228894,
0.8110836148,
-0.3841185272,
0.3304430842,
-0.0483607203,
-0.9405972958,
-0.3044082522,
0.3595912158,
0.1319226623,
-0.0725240558,
0.3403437436,
0.8265030384,
-0.0747850686,
0.0319112726,
0.2504412234,
0.2716351748,
0.3255945444,
0.3651560545,
0.9615246654,
-0.6156409383,
0.6797425151,
0.1089204252,
-0.1144140437,
-0.1833763272,
-0.7896128297,
-1.036411643,
-0.7263429761,
-0.0884060711,
-0.2142377645,
0.2744200528,
0.9957177639,
0.372589916,
-0.5750277638,
-0.535787046,
-0.1247362494,
0.1430450976,
0.2993807793,
-0.0308575463,
0.2684146464,
-0.1622559726,
-0.8322409987,
0.4822030962,
0.3041512072,
0.3042961955,
-0.564014554,
-0.2251170576,
-0.2042080015,
0.3937975764,
0.8426990509,
0.4055698812,
-0.8080304861,
0.3176781237,
-0.0524119101,
-0.2298540026,
0.2666637003,
0.7147824764,
-0.9823235869,
0.1585003287,
0.2282487154,
0.4230827689,
0.5062131882,
-0.3679498136,
0.5579435825,
-0.4608823657,
0.3640688658,
-0.0193906501,
0.2911842167,
0.7408197522,
-0.0121230846,
0.8450673819,
-0.1394704878,
-0.1199757755,
-1.2550040483,
0.1430023313,
-0.7832539082,
0.0765276477,
1.2147586346,
-0.0094923852,
-0.6378618479,
0.022443261,
-0.4533020854,
0.6154310703,
-0.3336856365,
0.8070807457,
0.2413760871,
0.1919260919,
-0.155962497,
-0.3980791271,
0.1967104673,
0.1275359541,
-0.9578048587,
0.176692605,
0.070717074,
0.0380651243,
-0.0134450914,
0.8013373017,
-0.2532861829,
0.1931787282,
0.0086423112,
-0.0819696561,
-0.3471722901,
-0.3278155625,
-0.1988867968,
0.1039046422,
0.4612065554,
0.0637069046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05821v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05821v1
|
Let's Reinforce Step by Step
| 2023-11-10T01:35:51 | 2023-11-10T01:35:51 |
Sarah Pan, Vladislav Lialin, Sherin Muckatira, Anna Rumshisky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While recent advances have boosted LM proficiency in linguistic benchmarks,
LMs consistently struggle to reason correctly on complex tasks like
mathematics. We turn to Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) as a
method with which to shape model reasoning processes. In particular, we explore
two reward schemes, outcome-supervised reward models (ORMs) and
process-supervised reward models (PRMs), to optimize for logical reasoning. Our
results show that the fine-grained reward provided by PRM-based methods
enhances accuracy on simple mathematical reasoning (GSM8K) while, unexpectedly,
reducing performance in complex tasks (MATH). Furthermore, we show the critical
role reward aggregation functions play in model performance. Providing
promising avenues for future research, our study underscores the need for
further exploration into fine-grained reward modeling for more reliable
language models.
|
[
-0.2472281158,
-0.7803329825,
0.8047772646,
-0.0829283223,
0.1481923312,
-0.2016001642,
-0.3912257552,
-0.3425242007,
-0.2285645455,
0.6354019046,
-0.7206712961,
-0.3398563862,
-0.6295534372,
-0.0975481272,
0.0764090121,
1.0059509277,
-0.0534843542,
0.1745360792,
-0.4118513763,
-0.0229298733,
-0.2497275919,
-0.7357587218,
-1.0162810087,
-0.9101687074,
0.8933679461,
0.5405812263,
0.5806785226,
0.4753995538,
0.4736692309,
0.2949174941,
-0.0036173963,
0.4729554057,
-0.4376890063,
0.197217986,
-0.5189324617,
-0.8309897184,
-0.3227367997,
0.1124538183,
0.1668105572,
0.7262665033,
-0.5664108992,
-0.0721464604,
-0.1492251158,
0.9267085791,
-0.7316008806,
0.6197465658,
-0.2368967384,
-0.0755095407,
0.0168559141,
-0.2665650249,
-0.7633053064,
-0.58160007,
-0.0302465837,
-0.5717300177,
-0.1488180161,
-0.0924522206,
0.6059572101,
0.3246093392,
-0.1214070916,
-0.3811960518,
-0.7212888002,
1.0367633104,
-0.6038211584,
0.2656509578,
0.5815520883,
0.3560279906,
-0.3019985855,
-0.6564158797,
-0.1924992204,
-0.5089597702,
-0.1707441211,
0.0377981216,
0.2701666951,
0.1272406578,
0.3239447474,
0.0519602746,
-0.0654815361,
0.0400047526,
-0.257869184,
-0.2023885995,
0.8151046038,
0.299654752,
0.048452545,
-0.0454977714,
-0.184681356,
-0.5193047523,
-0.6116290092,
0.7461782694,
0.335501194,
0.4229903221,
0.0717882887,
0.624192059,
-0.2316060364,
0.8789570928,
-0.179214105,
-0.4387475848,
-0.0795154944,
-0.0971500948,
-0.0791076347,
0.0185144339,
0.5773360729,
0.0095531428,
0.5161998868,
-0.05797299,
-0.5696389675,
0.4903889298,
0.2824962139,
-0.5439068079,
-0.3812494278,
0.0506250337,
-0.3928650022,
-0.2229221165,
0.202636987,
-0.2434311509,
-0.2611627579,
-0.6829576492,
0.3949378133,
-0.5166231394,
-0.1527605206,
0.6854090095,
-0.2328632772,
-0.0602202676,
0.6783613563,
-0.9856355786,
0.4788201451,
1.1188606024,
0.1917281598,
-0.1951366514,
-0.3657633364,
-1.0045596361,
-0.1781550199,
-0.3922941089,
0.9096594453,
-0.6580415368,
-0.1941742003,
0.0096034603,
-0.1536981761,
-0.1546964198,
-0.8639857769,
0.9043539762,
-0.4623779655,
0.3226263523,
-0.2954673469,
-0.6041309834,
-0.3953616321,
0.2829195559,
-0.5556869507,
0.7591154575,
0.0953241363,
-0.320486635,
0.3780483007,
-0.6884122491,
-0.5211150646,
-0.1675393432,
-0.1518703401,
-0.3506008983,
0.1657147408,
0.210544765,
0.4032727778,
-0.1579055637,
0.4298253357,
-0.5223188996,
-0.2591401339,
0.5062571168,
-0.2535119355,
0.4194612503,
0.3488601446,
-0.165729627,
0.4008170366,
-0.6066465378,
0.1465678662,
0.1651232094,
-0.4906209409,
-0.246778056,
0.2900958657,
-0.3225715756,
0.3019982278,
-0.0213025864,
-0.1878875792,
0.1816162169,
-0.4446189702,
0.6290458441,
0.7082815766,
-0.1855213642,
0.5075107813,
-0.5007736683,
0.5660203695,
0.0695881546,
-0.0273750089,
-0.1669605076,
-0.3750605285,
-0.7022519112,
-0.2590722442,
0.400634259,
0.5140987039,
-0.6673486233,
0.1384964585,
0.1469487846,
-0.2045363933,
-0.4422850311,
0.0362479389,
0.5092475414,
0.4646525979,
0.3420030475,
-0.2898325324,
-0.1916124523,
-0.8269156218,
-0.5228014588,
-0.2959045768,
-0.039496664,
0.3178465962,
0.3447934985,
0.0974658728,
0.8510499597,
-0.4499333799,
-0.1109542102,
-0.4251417816,
0.3629936278,
0.2954078615,
0.3545902967,
0.1258506626,
-0.6488574743,
-0.02057942,
-0.2836631536,
-0.6086273789,
-0.020655144,
-0.0449940376,
-0.0732160062,
0.2257760316,
0.2279757857,
-0.7143598199,
0.3562733531,
0.1107567847,
-0.6120988727,
0.6479970217,
-0.2790354192,
0.1398057789,
-0.1723361313,
-0.2270167768,
0.112956509,
-0.5871291757,
-0.2967789173,
0.0146915577,
-0.0271581262,
0.1119292453,
-0.3974826038,
0.5139904022,
-0.0912666768,
-0.0938736275,
-0.4157213569,
0.0041416674,
-0.019659847,
0.7599590421,
0.3575850129,
0.5176010132,
0.2893208861,
-0.8226692677,
0.45666942,
-0.1565520018,
-0.407425344,
0.5687230229,
-0.7341077328,
-0.2322852015,
-0.1981708109,
0.2291350663,
-0.7214626074,
-0.2463103235,
0.3297147751,
-0.5317692161,
0.2253053337,
0.1863913983,
-0.5073007345,
-0.2018479556,
-0.1114876941,
0.1802530438,
0.4984095693,
-0.6055763364,
0.5405431986,
0.3559787571,
-0.0800759941,
-0.260636121,
-0.5814543366,
-0.381955713,
-0.1485380083,
-0.608753562,
0.2217093855,
0.1214775965,
-0.5430698991,
0.0949071348,
-0.1228146926,
0.1823515147,
0.3771902919,
0.1496507674,
0.1758561283,
0.0358837359,
0.3143722713,
-0.2442607284,
-0.3546551168,
0.482095629,
-0.3114222884,
0.4202786386,
-0.3636869192,
-0.5911246538,
-0.3597202897,
0.067315124,
0.152835682,
-0.3309060037,
0.7770418525,
0.4073287845,
-0.2926082313,
-0.4259073436,
-0.2818805277,
-0.7619090676,
-0.3845984042,
0.230852887,
-0.4225497544,
-1.1366814375,
0.2833213806,
-0.09714894,
0.0789864957,
0.3929189146,
0.6303765774,
-0.0425564311,
1.3572252989,
0.2758326828,
0.1796028167,
0.304053843,
-0.1068563461,
0.1254702806,
-0.3505174816,
-0.5887399316,
-0.5061926842,
-0.3211739957,
-0.2418924719,
-0.4207744002,
0.0856160223,
0.5372294188,
-0.337577492,
-0.0048063174,
-0.4126795232,
0.3714529872,
0.8048368096,
0.313773483,
0.3176295459,
-0.0959041268,
-0.1596831381,
0.043770127,
-1.0068185329,
-0.4442762434,
0.6368809938,
0.4222008586,
1.1356607676,
0.0136723006,
0.6258025765,
0.3126943707,
0.3697718978,
-0.8307577372,
0.426024735,
0.024315808,
-0.3222589493,
-0.5318695307,
-0.6630747914,
-0.9061627984,
0.217024073,
-0.0546348877,
-0.6319678426,
-0.0817219913,
0.2724931836,
-0.513205111,
0.1126203984,
-0.7616711855,
0.8586988449,
-0.3586136997,
-0.5461514592,
-0.4700332284,
-0.4643943608,
0.6301339865,
0.4457440078,
0.466213733,
-0.1564936489,
0.1793171465,
0.6987540722,
-0.7147346139,
0.7165888548,
-0.1238831207,
-0.1517195553,
0.304489255,
0.2305165827,
0.6356571317,
0.357919842,
-0.0263773017,
-0.3505483568,
-0.1419508308,
-0.5048619509,
-0.8471899629,
0.6273206472,
-0.6322632432,
-0.676371932,
-0.3314573467,
-0.60826689,
-0.2871377766,
-0.1672765315,
-0.0590499453,
0.3443900943,
0.3666580915,
0.0567358136,
1.0619710684,
-0.0681861192,
0.1813334227,
0.2260426283,
-0.5323578119,
-0.3796796799,
0.6762902737,
-0.1966610104,
0.3770986497,
0.472753495,
0.2907498181,
-0.4834825993,
-0.0111348126,
-0.3261437416,
0.2216223031,
-0.7806156874,
-0.0568305589,
-0.4032754302,
-0.1038929075,
-0.1759302318,
-0.0500293858,
-0.4643199444,
-0.6050732732,
-0.1122455001,
-0.1867158115,
0.32585904,
0.6872859001,
-0.1202051342,
0.0050579426,
-0.7760993242,
0.2647027969,
0.5622843504,
0.3848131299,
0.1413286626,
-0.5474604964,
-0.2221353799,
0.1337820143,
-0.1505998224,
-0.5831791162,
0.243329823,
-0.2004861385,
0.7813869715,
0.254093498,
0.0219120979,
0.4186298847,
-0.2736097276,
0.5761849284,
0.3748579025,
-0.7265052199,
0.4874770939,
-0.1880374849,
0.3028608263,
0.2322390825,
0.1532534957,
-0.3534129858,
-0.1309943497,
-0.7779791355,
-0.470806241,
1.1068308353,
-0.0107775833,
-0.2972021103,
0.0112340823,
0.4020355344,
-0.0058657872,
0.1318629533,
-0.7490888834,
-0.1174368784,
0.0270724613,
-0.1951288581,
-0.1035193652,
-0.2407607585,
-0.3442840576,
-0.226992622,
0.7893591523,
-0.147699371,
0.1298396736,
0.1480907798,
-0.1647281051,
-0.2445806116,
0.3451886773,
0.8042581081,
0.735699892,
-0.0408109128,
0.3626036346,
-0.1362024099,
0.2668097317,
0.2668177187,
0.0646305457,
0.0195755288,
-0.2907269597,
0.4555964172,
1.0371197462,
0.3654388785,
-0.9764768481,
0.2184256315,
-0.0484546535,
-0.4822933972,
-0.0359784439,
0.525377214,
0.4587584138,
0.3464123607,
0.1140500158,
0.1101676151,
-0.074287042,
-0.6755440235,
0.2440561652,
0.2822043002,
-0.5292479992,
-0.1522109956,
0.5744743943,
-0.0219468139,
-0.6119331717,
0.6089426875,
-0.2641786039,
-0.7161566615,
0.6890897155,
0.3405432999,
0.427384913,
-0.0046999506,
0.3549464941,
0.3328306675,
0.0842477381,
-0.6760056019,
0.2981981933,
-0.1972271651,
-0.7427272797,
-0.7730287313,
-0.5473483801,
-0.4335146546,
-0.113279961,
-0.6419625878,
0.1834128797,
-0.3180894256,
-0.0285437796,
0.0698864162,
-0.150281325,
-0.4709404707,
0.3321953118,
0.1983345598,
0.7874711752,
-0.5965984464,
0.7751610875,
0.8413833976,
-0.4930018485,
-1.1668343544,
-0.6182229519,
-0.1945055872,
-0.754771173,
0.9202685356,
0.101263836,
-0.1826879829,
-0.2036126703,
-0.5525488257,
-0.559745729,
0.7280757427,
0.2939182818,
-0.483430177,
0.1201968119,
0.1006142944,
0.4732908905,
-0.361923635,
0.425332129,
0.6073031425,
0.5636159182,
0.1591570079,
-0.6033699512,
-0.2269316167,
-0.0313266926,
-0.0064741117,
0.4068386853,
-0.5216894746,
0.8643289208,
-0.3811432123,
0.0751913711,
-0.1651159674,
0.7496137023,
0.9527982473,
0.4550444186,
0.6387453675,
0.9684369564,
0.7013362646,
-0.2097474784,
1.2521859407,
0.0380109958,
0.4010722637,
1.0029815435,
-0.1905375421,
0.755733788,
0.4723229408,
-0.3704195023,
0.8079242706,
0.9420807362,
0.4115706384,
0.6144016385,
0.5935311913,
-0.0455294065,
-0.9045037627,
-0.1374022216,
-0.1369025111,
0.0504767783,
0.4439468682,
-0.1703028828,
-0.37719661,
-0.0409219563,
-0.11143668,
0.579442203,
-0.5802320838,
0.6194401383,
0.4311030507,
-1.2465296984,
0.362968564,
0.2820349038,
0.5065501928,
-0.5915833116,
-0.2470164597,
-0.2336695045,
0.4648219347,
-0.2050475627,
-0.7746752501,
0.2281158566,
-0.226043433,
-0.3699139059,
-0.3418593407,
0.9090223312,
-0.5507798791,
-0.3137644827,
0.2850328982,
0.4279322326,
0.0174092501,
-0.0096683502,
-0.843557477,
-0.093520619,
-0.0912864432,
-0.3519824445,
0.4591712058,
0.5935223699,
-0.1975474656,
0.9280725121,
0.8805277944,
0.0472498797,
-0.143722102,
0.3737951219,
0.5505996943,
-0.8219819665,
-0.5700727105,
-1.0568420887,
0.4645606279,
0.0573528148,
-0.0593161732,
0.4661611617,
0.3898746073,
1.1090397835,
-0.1986526847,
0.5538027287,
0.292165935,
0.6898827553,
-0.7444998622,
0.1803380549,
-0.6099258661,
0.4534859657,
0.1223033294,
-0.5338452458,
-0.2877314389,
0.7546098232,
-0.4697282314,
0.1473191381,
0.641376555,
0.6051211357,
0.110806331,
0.018069014,
0.2932904065,
-0.2339385599,
0.2513011992,
0.8835789561,
1.1237999201,
0.015504837,
0.3846128583,
-0.3907000124,
-0.0822815597,
-0.307502389,
-0.7963782549,
-0.7317706943,
-0.1451667845,
-0.3176635802,
-0.5593643785,
-0.013744331,
1.1132537127,
0.8077953458,
-0.8956318498,
-0.474802196,
-0.3950825632,
0.5777334571,
-0.5608139634,
-0.247855559,
0.1285431385,
-0.7957458496,
-0.5553585887,
0.2129224092,
0.5018438697,
-0.4631955028,
-0.3061719239,
-0.695667088,
-0.121991761,
0.1274662614,
0.4980036318,
0.2964437008,
-0.9272003174,
-0.1108150482,
-0.0276528951,
-0.4166463315,
-0.0603577718,
1.0003129244,
-0.9259806871,
0.089751333,
0.7065649629,
0.8312395811,
0.4121106863,
0.1890939623,
0.5284940004,
-0.1814521402,
0.0323581323,
0.2977777421,
0.46268332,
0.12512514,
-0.120937638,
0.6587090492,
0.3849137127,
-0.6592006087,
-0.7943355441,
0.464735657,
-0.7590680122,
-0.5037042499,
1.0862972736,
-0.2008140981,
-0.4236944318,
0.1959219724,
-0.1188117191,
0.0831579939,
-0.522061348,
0.8813635111,
0.9475805759,
-0.3672484457,
-0.4664642513,
-0.2556572258,
0.6707815528,
0.9157250524,
-0.8878017068,
-0.0706402212,
0.4153060913,
-0.0044716559,
0.0190327223,
0.4841582477,
-0.103464812,
0.5824657083,
-0.2954933941,
0.0265489034,
-0.2412075996,
-0.4340349138,
-0.3257690072,
0.2415815592,
0.5227611661,
0.1469911933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06318v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06318v2
|
Knowledge-Augmented Large Language Models for Personalized Contextual Query Suggestion
| 2023-11-10T01:18:47 | 2024-02-19T12:05:28 |
Jinheon Baek, Nirupama Chandrasekaran, Silviu Cucerzan, Allen herring, Sujay Kumar Jauhar
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at tackling various natural language
tasks. However, due to the significant costs involved in re-training or
fine-tuning them, they remain largely static and difficult to personalize.
Nevertheless, a variety of applications could benefit from generations that are
tailored to users' preferences, goals, and knowledge. Among them is web search,
where knowing what a user is trying to accomplish, what they care about, and
what they know can lead to improved search experiences. In this work, we
propose a novel and general approach that augments an LLM with relevant context
from users' interaction histories with a search engine in order to personalize
its outputs. Specifically, we construct an entity-centric knowledge store for
each user based on their search and browsing activities on the web, which is
then leveraged to provide contextually relevant LLM prompt augmentations. This
knowledge store is light-weight, since it only produces user-specific aggregate
projections of interests and knowledge onto public knowledge graphs, and
leverages existing search log infrastructure, thereby mitigating the privacy,
compliance, and scalability concerns associated with building deep user
profiles for personalization. We validate our approach on the task of
contextual query suggestion, which requires understanding not only the user's
current search context but also what they historically know and care about.
Through a number of experiments based on human evaluation, we show that our
approach is significantly better than several other LLM-powered baselines,
generating query suggestions that are contextually more relevant, personalized,
and useful.
|
[
-0.6389837861,
-0.7488034964,
0.8786126375,
-0.0586472265,
-0.0763063356,
0.0247706138,
-0.620189786,
-0.4425211847,
0.6459491849,
0.4478524923,
-0.7235716581,
-0.703130126,
-0.0207815487,
-0.071007438,
-0.2357465476,
0.6134334207,
0.3577729166,
-0.2255032957,
-0.3804151714,
0.1886380911,
-0.7397753,
-0.536154151,
-0.601919055,
0.016950516,
0.9213324785,
0.3292119205,
0.4219525754,
0.2812613845,
-0.0320205204,
0.2493438721,
-0.3150466979,
0.427747786,
-0.5880559087,
0.4748966396,
-0.5121343732,
-0.4192536175,
-0.2817302644,
-0.4082032144,
0.3032588661,
0.8203550577,
-0.2301919311,
-0.1585437506,
0.0299681518,
0.5680541396,
-0.7280947566,
0.0550331324,
-0.9648551345,
-0.1890140027,
-0.2857203782,
-0.4897353351,
-0.3265011907,
-0.1479635835,
0.354673326,
-0.7948216796,
0.1935608685,
0.2913037539,
0.305975914,
-0.014165923,
-0.5785630345,
-0.2426074147,
-0.5797823071,
0.61826545,
-0.7037170529,
0.497320056,
0.596372664,
0.485308826,
-0.311827749,
-0.6962041855,
-0.4367983639,
-0.2873708606,
-0.2461131513,
-0.1655887961,
0.0077559575,
0.0131349694,
0.2056713849,
0.2524385452,
-0.5238378644,
0.0547207743,
0.0397383161,
-0.1569839567,
0.5774753094,
0.1825587302,
0.3758262992,
-0.0672093034,
-0.3298070431,
0.2178567201,
-0.8189000487,
0.1635580659,
0.3120012283,
0.4080747962,
0.2184850872,
0.5500897169,
-0.9281987548,
0.9967300296,
0.2648755312,
-0.0294245295,
-0.033059895,
-0.3722520471,
0.1605454832,
0.0615585856,
0.5425221324,
0.6554247141,
0.1913694143,
-0.6224004626,
-0.2172236592,
-0.5184760094,
0.231563285,
-0.8275819421,
-0.0849829465,
0.0533193238,
-0.1680277586,
-0.1692279428,
0.1226153001,
-0.4930351079,
-0.6469005942,
-0.4867356122,
0.202549994,
-0.3285596073,
0.1723668128,
0.0029475635,
0.0829916671,
-0.2639839053,
0.4347463548,
-1.1323195696,
0.0118003562,
0.5170600414,
0.4677827656,
-0.0954985693,
-0.0772821456,
-0.5442674756,
0.5712093711,
0.0433131196,
0.8169777989,
-0.9273654819,
-0.3866034746,
0.2292755544,
-0.0113719758,
0.2835510373,
-0.4615303874,
0.2398261726,
-1.1238844395,
0.3015783727,
-0.6546673179,
-0.6821865439,
-0.2374024391,
0.2785727084,
-0.4063755572,
0.780880928,
0.0216505043,
-0.6767329574,
0.5947718024,
-0.6514471769,
-0.6138846874,
0.4469156265,
-0.1715737283,
0.1428344101,
0.0485465899,
0.5564482212,
0.6650159955,
-0.3995444477,
0.5035415888,
-0.5187898874,
-0.448068738,
0.0277278516,
-0.0423693545,
0.3245308697,
0.0207292214,
-0.1833811998,
0.1668942124,
-0.6338921189,
0.0406716317,
0.0916896239,
-0.5119432211,
-0.7002775073,
0.109221518,
-0.0605266653,
-0.1366569996,
0.7687020302,
-0.3429380357,
0.535200119,
-0.5558460951,
0.2983712256,
0.6373528838,
0.2348818928,
0.4724184871,
-0.0803532153,
0.2943316996,
-0.2401271909,
-0.1678257287,
-0.3812322021,
-0.2570019066,
-0.449478507,
0.0459014364,
0.0913098902,
0.3242405355,
-0.691075325,
0.6236740947,
-0.387070477,
-0.2591273785,
0.1697183698,
0.4800620079,
0.0208367575,
0.7286068797,
0.3278762102,
-0.0664120317,
-0.5968102217,
-0.8643188477,
-0.4751652777,
-0.1153040081,
-0.3909587562,
1.0155156851,
-0.0554283857,
-0.5125106573,
1.2680023909,
-0.9800134897,
-0.4436228275,
-0.0937521458,
-0.2960774601,
0.216977641,
0.1079297662,
0.3272832036,
-0.8840640187,
-0.4432266951,
0.2562713623,
-0.4493261278,
-0.1039632633,
0.133308962,
-0.2705658972,
-0.1148131266,
0.4215059876,
-0.5795924067,
0.1429229081,
0.0870083049,
-0.332603246,
0.2568514347,
-0.2577775121,
0.0596677177,
-1.288854003,
0.1814634949,
0.134410277,
-0.327098906,
-0.4545501471,
-0.0804276317,
0.0697169676,
-0.0140037714,
-0.2201138735,
1.0251559019,
-0.2492504418,
-0.0021248604,
-0.101762712,
0.2173815817,
-0.1434145421,
0.5403894782,
0.135524869,
0.7575108409,
0.293671906,
-0.7684752941,
0.3109770119,
0.1425213516,
-0.1987278908,
0.5539791584,
-0.4545972049,
0.4058545232,
-0.0294616651,
0.2675477564,
-0.7860199213,
-0.6497377157,
-0.2666266859,
-0.3080778718,
0.0499982126,
-0.2280796468,
-0.5639255643,
-0.1605471075,
-0.3172535896,
0.3681907654,
0.1539629251,
-0.8337926269,
0.7298797965,
0.3314647079,
-0.2573294044,
-0.4231017828,
-0.2673695385,
0.3308260143,
-0.2688641846,
-0.782122314,
0.7203503251,
-0.2101214379,
-0.0022282363,
-0.0280047953,
0.1200835481,
-0.0490465984,
0.2416137755,
0.1438661069,
0.0945958868,
0.000202901,
0.3877119124,
0.1686237156,
0.1615899503,
-0.1739290208,
-0.4989796281,
0.80966115,
-0.0325202979,
-0.3832695186,
-0.224246338,
0.2467047721,
0.3149891496,
-0.3439075053,
0.6105940938,
0.8070807457,
-0.3931005001,
-0.131206125,
-0.8975600004,
-0.4653088152,
-0.4960383177,
0.2457158118,
-0.3963928223,
-1.4186662436,
0.5233330727,
-0.2006757408,
-0.0749133229,
0.1314687729,
0.7217158079,
-0.1582549959,
1.2172809839,
0.5471562743,
-0.2349746376,
0.5818305612,
-0.0321799889,
0.2818885148,
-1.094502449,
-0.401789248,
-0.1164601669,
-0.3910911679,
-0.4628390074,
-0.0817249939,
0.4420967698,
0.2518290281,
-0.2474822998,
0.0834884644,
-0.340557307,
0.504381001,
0.6936699748,
0.2661191225,
0.3545466065,
0.1631358117,
-0.2347416282,
-0.0440410413,
-0.5179411173,
-0.2574721575,
0.9433044195,
-0.1078401506,
0.824708879,
0.3196825087,
0.737390697,
0.3286227584,
0.1609299183,
-0.7878129482,
0.4562657475,
-0.0470924191,
-0.6262667775,
-0.3795981705,
-0.3426271379,
-1.1184995174,
0.062793225,
-0.1455361843,
-1.12819767,
0.0660468042,
0.4509753585,
-0.4549843073,
0.2181190401,
-0.6103287935,
0.6379023194,
-0.3651617467,
-0.5517387986,
-0.2376692444,
-0.3530142009,
0.3081436455,
0.0652014911,
0.0657502189,
0.2100362629,
-0.2314913869,
0.3886377811,
-0.2562717795,
0.867182076,
-0.3265794516,
0.1175356805,
-0.0115056438,
0.118970938,
0.8231392503,
0.3698572516,
0.1003402248,
-0.3662325442,
-0.3378539979,
-0.1439712197,
-0.7899520993,
1.0867046118,
-0.2783356011,
-1.065331459,
0.09253297,
-0.5913737416,
-0.5999850631,
0.4122475386,
-0.0034613847,
0.4323442876,
-0.1046020985,
0.5843402743,
0.6131439805,
-0.258964777,
0.1993043274,
0.632468462,
-0.5065119863,
-0.3796765804,
0.846216023,
-0.1086091399,
-0.3179380596,
0.6372622848,
0.2793869078,
-0.5648381114,
-0.3784266114,
-0.2899217308,
0.1275376976,
-0.6488999724,
-0.1124462783,
-0.7191970944,
0.2730862796,
-0.4628062546,
-0.2280244529,
0.0515162908,
-0.0304995328,
-0.4000650048,
-0.0247196797,
0.4540511072,
0.477189362,
0.4862596989,
0.1611437351,
-0.5363680124,
0.148780331,
0.7398561239,
0.3735577762,
0.3065542579,
-0.1620458066,
-0.3037714064,
-0.0191884506,
-0.0435661785,
-0.5953472257,
0.3435864151,
0.0318372063,
0.6659277678,
0.5415747762,
0.1201907098,
0.5791104436,
-0.5024985671,
0.8249750733,
0.1384858489,
-0.5166944265,
0.6622083783,
-0.5318555832,
0.3155955672,
0.6653565764,
0.2724127769,
-0.5928919911,
0.2011576742,
-0.2854093611,
-1.0204132795,
0.5163827538,
-0.1222118139,
0.2651022077,
0.0488665774,
0.5751264691,
-0.062817663,
0.4075330198,
-0.3138528764,
-0.1962279081,
0.2112224996,
-0.0594250783,
-0.0052650529,
-0.2941558361,
-0.0629664585,
-0.3091134429,
0.5387766957,
-0.5027920604,
-0.1880403757,
0.1803874671,
-0.2311596721,
0.0080426699,
0.3532696962,
0.40200001,
0.8852203488,
-0.3567863405,
0.0676140413,
0.2682129145,
-0.048256591,
-0.0797088444,
0.3313712776,
-0.298156172,
-0.2294332385,
0.008707582,
0.8866465688,
0.417010814,
-0.8728213906,
0.5435860157,
-0.2784143388,
0.3315899968,
-0.4397366941,
0.1568430662,
0.4939861894,
0.3584923446,
0.5366972089,
-0.188494429,
0.4586402178,
-0.4757644534,
-0.0422906652,
0.8208879232,
-0.3295922279,
-0.3189148307,
0.6197962761,
0.312574625,
-0.3051957488,
0.1598529816,
-0.1251809299,
-0.6237496734,
-0.0928534269,
0.5023952127,
0.7480638623,
-0.0818532035,
-0.1107401103,
0.1664915532,
-0.1508577317,
0.1876872927,
-0.0733359382,
-0.5942292809,
-0.6625308394,
-0.3654902875,
-0.7177901864,
-0.1687358916,
0.236305654,
-0.5157092214,
0.351859957,
-0.3427328169,
-0.2196929455,
0.0217519253,
0.1602679342,
-0.8176164031,
0.1626813263,
0.0983869582,
0.8705505133,
-0.2000888288,
0.7370693088,
1.037566185,
-0.2244380862,
-0.5734478235,
0.0419323631,
-0.0641236901,
-0.6633988023,
0.6727062464,
0.0079020876,
-0.0404821374,
-0.0822219104,
-0.2925415337,
-0.8953046799,
1.437972188,
0.518014133,
-0.9073719978,
-0.2503109574,
-0.1116486266,
0.5234529376,
-0.483235091,
0.1914466769,
0.4608206749,
0.5060904622,
0.1102299988,
-0.6981936097,
0.1354561448,
-0.0592062287,
0.3506858945,
0.0335055701,
-0.5478953123,
0.5502229333,
-0.1460012048,
-0.0293511711,
-0.0610312335,
0.6071640253,
0.4244608581,
0.4156211913,
0.6224651337,
0.481344521,
0.9165483117,
0.3003438711,
1.4924178123,
-0.6840688586,
0.1014912501,
1.2149406672,
-0.3665705025,
0.7285776734,
0.4008203149,
-0.0990136415,
0.2881489396,
0.6039361358,
0.2992698848,
0.5482897758,
-0.1726813465,
-0.5006740689,
-0.4227701128,
-0.3364919126,
-0.2354506999,
0.1392984092,
0.3038944006,
-0.5085808635,
-0.091840893,
-0.1642476171,
0.0395443998,
0.1841325909,
-0.238618508,
0.9253464937,
-0.0487163104,
-0.7101731896,
0.4073114991,
0.0588796735,
0.9217951298,
-0.4602654278,
0.0774600506,
-0.2284142375,
-0.1230529398,
-0.3242861032,
-0.7103644609,
-0.2025535256,
-0.0404770114,
-0.5120161176,
-0.0347955041,
1.0353848934,
-0.6181198955,
-0.1866437793,
0.2976800799,
0.4732227027,
-0.1905324012,
-0.516264677,
-0.2594212592,
-0.0932690129,
0.2208438516,
-0.4166218042,
0.5072681308,
0.0489951037,
-0.0999925584,
0.7876909375,
0.9152616858,
0.2016688585,
-0.0771621615,
0.3077497184,
1.0415151119,
-0.7044909596,
-0.5727371573,
-0.7083287835,
0.2869678736,
-0.1995248497,
-0.2391821593,
0.6428356171,
0.5991277099,
0.7908707857,
0.0037577332,
0.9251148105,
0.1235733405,
0.4728121459,
-0.6463572979,
0.6149425507,
-0.7419562936,
0.672804594,
0.1061882377,
-1.2601681948,
-0.0874311179,
0.1109314635,
-0.5270170569,
0.3659659028,
0.1315726489,
0.8680456877,
-0.1907865405,
-0.249728471,
0.4154306352,
0.1429505646,
0.4135905802,
0.3598107398,
0.6358927488,
0.2098466754,
0.2592837811,
-0.2906776369,
0.0240155123,
-0.5739248991,
-0.6413316727,
-0.8255942464,
-0.6872446537,
0.090915598,
0.0522858016,
0.0493888222,
1.0898233652,
0.893219173,
-0.5779876709,
-0.0248078294,
0.0867808014,
0.1130967662,
0.2925951183,
-0.2481129169,
0.4067645669,
-0.259175092,
-0.7011744976,
0.6945753694,
0.3429017961,
-0.1997966021,
-0.4835527837,
-0.1627769172,
-0.1755365729,
-0.178257972,
0.8352603912,
0.1277674884,
-1.0608706474,
-0.3012188673,
0.0374374799,
0.1411330253,
-0.1458565742,
0.8451068401,
-1.201399684,
0.6738840938,
0.5031492114,
0.8494079113,
0.6450970173,
0.1853289008,
0.6419420838,
-0.9405234456,
-0.0341621153,
0.3040854633,
0.5198377967,
0.5149478912,
-0.8986185193,
0.3076221645,
-0.0773445964,
-0.3258674741,
-0.6157265902,
0.201006785,
-0.9544550776,
-0.2767525315,
1.1387758255,
-0.0854521915,
-0.0782969519,
0.2068818361,
-0.3293768167,
-0.1280879527,
-0.7292051911,
0.7721566558,
0.4698548317,
-0.1897695065,
-0.0187968239,
-0.410741657,
0.4826419652,
0.3459884226,
-0.6361327767,
-0.0302730929,
0.5503464937,
0.3766975701,
0.1135420427,
0.2322713137,
0.1740948707,
0.109346725,
-0.7582049966,
-0.0340878591,
-0.2551163733,
-0.1292491108,
-0.0760884508,
0.3007956743,
0.1966503561,
0.4562324286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05812v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05812v2
|
CFBenchmark: Chinese Financial Assistant Benchmark for Large Language Model
| 2023-11-10T01:12:03 | 2024-05-21T08:37:05 |
Yang Lei, Jiangtong Li, Dawei Cheng, Zhijun Ding, Changjun Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated great potential in the
financial domain. Thus, it becomes important to assess the performance of LLMs
in the financial tasks. In this work, we introduce CFBenchmark, to evaluate the
performance of LLMs for Chinese financial assistant. The basic version of
CFBenchmark is designed to evaluate the basic ability in Chinese financial text
processing from three aspects~(\emph{i.e.} recognition, classification, and
generation) including eight tasks, and includes financial texts ranging in
length from 50 to over 1,800 characters. We conduct experiments on several LLMs
available in the literature with CFBenchmark-Basic, and the experimental
results indicate that while some LLMs show outstanding performance in specific
tasks, overall, there is still significant room for improvement in basic tasks
of financial text processing with existing models. In the future, we plan to
explore the advanced version of CFBenchmark, aiming to further explore the
extensive capabilities of language models in more profound dimensions as a
financial assistant in Chinese. Our codes are released at
https://github.com/TongjiFinLab/CFBenchmark.
|
[
-0.119231686,
-0.7423263192,
0.2451930046,
0.7905245423,
-0.3581292629,
0.0137716038,
-0.4948224425,
-0.7741646767,
-0.0670295432,
0.6193746328,
-0.1860286146,
-0.6598995924,
-0.3777474761,
0.0258678794,
-0.6498193741,
0.7312134504,
-0.1943540275,
0.3359947503,
-0.0998103619,
0.1941574812,
-0.1687461734,
-0.5284039974,
-1.2589473724,
-0.4344639778,
0.1861616373,
0.1466954201,
0.4191354215,
0.8540364504,
0.7182607055,
0.4450930357,
-0.1615634114,
-0.2812802196,
-0.2546719611,
-0.0338091888,
-0.0516113453,
-0.4051328599,
-0.7751585841,
-0.0026211743,
0.7066799998,
0.4795837998,
-0.1956735402,
0.1536188573,
0.155055657,
0.4751725197,
-0.4408732653,
0.4819304347,
-0.2827758789,
-0.0352607667,
-0.3777352571,
0.1125500277,
-0.3291295767,
-0.2734609544,
0.0950408652,
-0.4206342697,
0.2634731829,
0.22299245,
0.7225239277,
0.0330253951,
-0.5704119205,
-0.056183584,
-0.4270164967,
0.6138997078,
-0.8678533435,
0.464284718,
0.2291255593,
0.5458908677,
-0.0909388214,
-0.9669808149,
-0.4673050344,
-0.5469488502,
-0.0392524526,
0.1435977519,
-0.1961403638,
0.1381644458,
0.4077266455,
0.6525948644,
-0.3722029626,
0.3134374321,
-0.0863386691,
-0.4630513489,
0.7917453647,
0.2830388546,
-0.005661346,
0.0143270744,
-0.5404819846,
-0.6079214811,
-0.3263041973,
0.0028421422,
0.363398999,
0.4159980714,
-0.2905375361,
0.2091661394,
-0.454764694,
0.689456284,
-0.0660372227,
-0.2865519524,
0.1722187102,
-0.2897706628,
-0.4786266685,
0.0962390304,
0.6578686237,
0.1784043163,
0.1289455593,
0.1274402887,
-0.5937358141,
-0.2495924383,
-0.1649546325,
-0.7165534496,
-0.1946339756,
0.0891109705,
-0.6127529144,
-0.1853535473,
0.192645818,
-0.8361442089,
-0.485160321,
-0.2086797059,
-0.0003918089,
-0.3494315147,
-0.2439761311,
0.1281438172,
-0.1374200284,
0.5735414028,
0.3385476172,
-0.8156897426,
0.679082334,
1.1090056896,
0.7206648588,
-0.3247421682,
-0.3171100914,
-0.7771704793,
0.0377123505,
-0.2350499332,
1.0754377842,
-0.3555964828,
-0.5059368014,
-0.0358287878,
-0.102807872,
0.0596726835,
-0.7220748067,
0.7891150713,
-0.3435942829,
-0.1282352954,
-0.33989802,
-0.7246090174,
-0.2174151689,
0.3923655152,
-0.9261387587,
1.1397531033,
0.1859631091,
-0.4856304526,
0.1255539358,
-0.6837599874,
-0.5497549772,
0.1502655149,
-0.1467977762,
-0.1898884326,
-0.0619230531,
0.0996777266,
0.449261874,
-0.7991686463,
0.2121412605,
-0.4887719452,
-0.6599566936,
0.4475420713,
-0.7179188132,
0.5100641847,
0.0918096751,
-0.5491507053,
0.1999216229,
-0.9639627337,
-0.1165151671,
0.163761571,
-0.50873667,
-0.1700054258,
-0.1435415,
0.9415858984,
-0.001186131,
0.8429124355,
-0.5010290742,
-0.1384877563,
-0.5698276758,
0.1673976332,
1.0091454983,
-0.331191361,
-0.0655579716,
-0.2824291885,
0.554670155,
-0.068645522,
0.0616071485,
-0.0781309903,
0.035392087,
-0.7815181613,
-0.276448667,
0.6066438556,
0.4591413438,
-0.4620720148,
0.3533483744,
-0.0055763731,
-0.6450590491,
0.1437017024,
0.4804091156,
0.4682864547,
0.1951950192,
0.1365388334,
-0.2491111606,
-0.1767755747,
-1.1465125084,
-0.3648562729,
-0.2485480309,
-0.2641741633,
0.1472720802,
0.3094882369,
-0.0363519154,
0.5329146385,
-0.7012737393,
-0.2744219005,
-0.391682446,
0.0751580149,
0.3850287497,
0.4413504303,
1.0013204813,
-0.7965763807,
-0.4665488005,
0.3506230712,
-0.2531262338,
-0.3830287158,
-0.2812098861,
-0.2039414942,
0.2903209329,
0.649238348,
-0.2862523496,
0.2221111506,
0.6102159619,
-0.4075779915,
0.5345689654,
-0.2395210266,
-0.0977381244,
-0.9666721225,
0.5001439452,
0.253387183,
-0.2382604182,
-0.3748814762,
0.1889615804,
0.2951181531,
0.0612273738,
-0.2041683644,
0.9881613255,
-0.3563256562,
-0.4056173861,
-0.6534379125,
0.2504408062,
-0.188094303,
0.5418579578,
0.0171244275,
0.6534913778,
0.4388744533,
-0.2762844563,
0.6734676957,
-0.1130162105,
-0.4519408941,
0.6552299261,
-0.7804145813,
-0.082636714,
0.3488149643,
0.2473374903,
-1.1145116091,
-0.0737998709,
0.2413206995,
0.1336819828,
0.2983749509,
0.5427800417,
-0.8252542019,
-0.3770066202,
-0.3291198909,
0.1769081652,
0.0475941896,
-0.5777792335,
0.8236405849,
-0.0024721122,
-0.3947761357,
-0.5072720051,
-0.459194839,
0.1309317201,
-0.067500703,
-0.4222353101,
0.4998521209,
-0.1137956604,
-0.2715932727,
-0.1850213557,
-0.3187459409,
-0.0329282209,
0.3983699381,
0.0457804874,
0.6107358932,
-0.3633121252,
-0.0103867007,
0.0360473022,
-0.3278039694,
0.134670198,
0.01301903,
0.5530517101,
-0.2402086407,
-0.2803016007,
-0.1543853581,
0.0176838748,
0.3028136492,
-0.322304666,
0.498773396,
0.4675742388,
-0.4647447169,
-0.1234390065,
-0.8720055819,
0.2937599719,
-0.5844632387,
0.4611504972,
-0.2529502213,
-0.8817277551,
0.6834230423,
-0.2113134265,
0.2745317519,
0.6833329797,
0.483043313,
0.4819826484,
0.5220788717,
0.8516107202,
-0.6756262779,
0.6271965504,
0.1144473851,
-0.1229759455,
-0.4848315716,
0.0412193313,
-0.7613096237,
-0.2566930056,
-0.3754110336,
-0.3529819846,
0.0998185575,
0.1627804339,
-0.4088691771,
0.4916441441,
-0.1103489324,
0.5571940541,
0.4158087075,
-0.0883343592,
0.2961829603,
-0.2781472206,
-0.3013859391,
0.3119114935,
-0.2730600834,
-0.4091256559,
0.8658877611,
0.533487618,
0.7465071082,
-0.1077772453,
0.366163224,
0.2462612838,
0.582583189,
-0.5053713322,
0.7226522565,
-0.4533915222,
-0.4011069834,
-0.2160723507,
-0.5676948428,
-0.4451949,
0.1644114703,
-0.0438104421,
-0.7572165132,
-0.0116680674,
0.0339204893,
-0.3559165001,
-0.0069737528,
-0.3044095337,
1.1262892485,
-0.7459776402,
-0.2940136492,
-0.2896694243,
-0.2374772578,
0.5372753739,
-0.5512788296,
-0.0664093271,
-0.1230851263,
-0.2801858187,
0.8526006341,
-0.3619529605,
0.7885634899,
-0.0996660963,
-0.4972068071,
0.0202594493,
-0.2186939269,
0.5368322134,
0.031846974,
-0.4780276418,
0.2125473917,
0.2455990016,
-0.3802433014,
-0.2748160362,
0.8185004592,
-0.5350363851,
-0.577352345,
-0.508397162,
-0.3435025215,
-0.2235503644,
0.4944685996,
-0.1728861779,
0.0979559347,
-0.5317860246,
0.1935239136,
0.1100868583,
-0.3916092813,
0.5597141385,
0.731218636,
-0.4733704627,
-0.3188017011,
0.6822130084,
-0.2205636501,
-0.0215254296,
0.4101729691,
0.1164909154,
-0.4086020589,
-0.5165916681,
-0.254217267,
0.2463135421,
-0.9688690305,
-0.2322552353,
-0.1868671477,
-0.2975182235,
-0.4744044244,
-0.0767175704,
-0.40924564,
-0.0645732954,
-0.1539735198,
-0.0264455117,
0.4061825871,
0.5032186508,
-0.0111212488,
0.4079833031,
-0.8092949986,
0.2236262858,
0.1000931934,
0.7452643514,
0.3165208101,
-0.3250573277,
-0.5213904381,
-0.2609195709,
-0.319411695,
-0.3494643271,
0.166053921,
0.0046712691,
0.8138407469,
0.979080081,
-0.0328301899,
0.7282910943,
-0.0891536996,
0.5891219378,
-0.0084081134,
-1.2561750412,
0.0785210058,
-0.166094467,
0.4900095165,
0.5617101192,
-0.0930112675,
-0.754077971,
-0.5051092505,
-0.3099612296,
-0.8430863619,
0.7603835464,
0.0559360608,
0.0303972904,
0.1285137683,
0.3748972118,
0.0640467554,
0.2347320765,
-0.669044733,
-0.1873470098,
-0.1111430004,
-0.0020063301,
-0.2895341814,
-0.2404814363,
0.1682455391,
0.0914931819,
0.6347241402,
-0.3362793326,
-0.047460366,
-0.1326718032,
0.3545603454,
-0.1200364605,
-0.0129254088,
0.5965569615,
0.5714954734,
-0.218993932,
-0.1777224094,
0.4962005317,
-0.4667030275,
-0.2137239128,
0.6917759776,
0.2781769037,
-0.0020726076,
0.7493126392,
0.4459496737,
0.6493420005,
-1.160263896,
0.4523717463,
-0.2674216032,
-0.1597049981,
-0.6021745205,
0.2749333382,
0.3662317395,
0.4568307698,
0.4427330196,
-0.3045631349,
0.201119259,
-0.4719642401,
0.1680850685,
0.3225745857,
-0.1428447068,
0.0279708989,
0.741014421,
0.2898575068,
-0.0609334707,
0.6678436995,
0.3124750257,
-0.5909664035,
0.9020382166,
0.4603216648,
1.1270307302,
-0.2686692178,
-0.1881621629,
0.2122158259,
0.1786249876,
-0.3623024523,
0.2170767486,
-0.2107736617,
-0.4623560905,
-0.2905872464,
-0.9749314189,
-0.6360142231,
0.026237322,
-0.7244022489,
0.4137186706,
-0.7090765238,
-0.0186195355,
0.2563228309,
0.274589479,
-0.5076854825,
0.185127005,
0.3755513132,
1.5680911541,
-0.4293416739,
0.9409413338,
0.4654471576,
0.0992105827,
-0.7337458134,
0.094606027,
0.012533173,
-0.6145210862,
0.6696856618,
0.3240026534,
-0.1201610416,
-0.4204259515,
-0.2735929191,
-0.9167140126,
1.1809262037,
0.4279953241,
-0.8997365832,
0.0831594914,
0.298956275,
0.7459118962,
-0.3375916481,
0.120523043,
0.7369812131,
0.7610443234,
0.1100225672,
-0.9931416512,
0.1027028412,
-0.4757764935,
0.238924399,
0.1276126057,
-1.116601944,
0.9428212643,
0.4501101673,
-0.1758309454,
0.44966802,
0.7823990583,
0.226696834,
0.4066226482,
0.6549826264,
0.1002785265,
0.5732454658,
-0.1421946436,
0.9974510074,
-0.6983325481,
0.2847742438,
0.9958851337,
-0.7307236195,
1.1085596085,
0.0382576622,
-0.143963635,
0.1706649661,
0.7266647816,
-0.4303870499,
0.0000761545,
0.4302947819,
-0.1867508441,
-0.3024764955,
-0.0564747266,
-0.4042789638,
0.5664401054,
0.0685176551,
-0.4762227237,
-0.1302074641,
-0.1665712446,
-0.0445582941,
0.1096272245,
-0.3336605728,
0.5432688594,
0.2477219254,
-0.5027939081,
0.2495754659,
0.6877996325,
0.6698258519,
-0.9454513788,
0.0623492077,
-0.4834980667,
0.4369167387,
0.1886596084,
-0.3372728527,
0.1306254715,
0.0921993479,
0.1120852008,
-0.0597524606,
0.7660950422,
-0.275491178,
-0.8894170523,
0.6315870881,
0.2238286883,
0.0357009098,
-0.1532484442,
-0.7625363469,
0.1594606787,
-0.2035302818,
-0.4757540226,
0.3967901766,
0.3222311735,
-0.0961119682,
0.5861241221,
0.7816620469,
0.0533420891,
-0.3749917746,
0.0021572597,
0.8652261496,
-1.0893232822,
-0.7498431802,
-0.9162326455,
-0.2673063874,
-0.2059997767,
-0.5327575207,
0.854043901,
0.937546432,
0.9230300188,
-0.0606258921,
0.5107616186,
0.3042762876,
0.2524068952,
-0.5178023577,
0.8112247586,
-0.5280106068,
0.3823712468,
-0.6478224397,
-1.080883503,
-0.2959921658,
0.3625267744,
-0.2496673614,
0.1389198303,
0.5872535706,
0.5738224983,
0.0839646086,
0.3691267669,
0.4081549048,
0.0616608225,
0.1824136525,
0.6736133695,
0.5123721957,
-0.2702079117,
0.6537036896,
-0.4412355423,
-0.0446973816,
-0.2827210426,
-0.924633503,
-0.9804694653,
-0.1655810028,
-0.2000811696,
0.0336820893,
-0.4066251516,
0.9663578272,
0.2394896299,
-0.7299747467,
-0.8567386866,
0.3118959367,
-0.1334724426,
-0.6417474151,
-0.1742571592,
0.6223186851,
0.0448597409,
-0.9705852866,
0.2518087626,
0.4280174375,
0.3014492691,
-0.4560206532,
0.0059522376,
0.2197369784,
0.1358994544,
0.4438014627,
0.1293233782,
-0.5626330376,
-0.1438256949,
-0.0083986064,
-0.2210855186,
-0.2986885011,
0.9162288904,
-0.3056541681,
0.0674184114,
0.3065989614,
0.8664001822,
0.4863129258,
0.0841600671,
0.6524341106,
-0.3414401114,
0.2333948612,
-0.1565954089,
0.5631381869,
0.1610747725,
-0.4566939175,
0.562304914,
-0.0012919487,
-0.2535180748,
-0.6284793615,
-0.3956210315,
-1.1894357204,
-0.4312856793,
0.8536680341,
-0.3295247555,
-0.4627353251,
0.2245474905,
-0.3572461903,
0.1217667833,
-0.3778911531,
0.6697116494,
0.9157730341,
0.1898727715,
-0.1257869452,
-0.4902360141,
0.3174597025,
0.4201043248,
-0.809425056,
0.4778857827,
0.4033290446,
0.2195302248,
0.063130036,
0.7798866034,
0.1254327595,
0.6884242296,
0.192084536,
-0.0010680393,
-0.0632941499,
0.0744909272,
-0.3237608373,
0.1572061479,
0.2145954818,
0.2547565699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05800v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05800v2
|
Leveraging LLMs for Synthesizing Training Data Across Many Languages in Multilingual Dense Retrieval
| 2023-11-10T00:17:10 | 2024-04-15T22:11:33 |
Nandan Thakur, Jianmo Ni, Gustavo Hernández Ábrego, John Wieting, Jimmy Lin, Daniel Cer
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
There has been limited success for dense retrieval models in multilingual
retrieval, due to uneven and scarce training data available across multiple
languages. Synthetic training data generation is promising (e.g., InPars or
Promptagator), but has been investigated only for English. Therefore, to study
model capabilities across both cross-lingual and monolingual retrieval tasks,
we develop SWIM-IR, a synthetic retrieval training dataset containing 33 (high
to very-low resource) languages for fine-tuning multilingual dense retrievers
without requiring any human supervision. To construct SWIM-IR, we propose SAP
(summarize-then-ask prompting), where the large language model (LLM) generates
a textual summary prior to the query generation step. SAP assists the LLM in
generating informative queries in the target language. Using SWIM-IR, we
explore synthetic fine-tuning of multilingual dense retrieval models and
evaluate them robustly on three retrieval benchmarks: XOR-Retrieve
(cross-lingual), MIRACL (monolingual) and XTREME-UP (cross-lingual). Our
models, called SWIM-X, are competitive with human-supervised dense retrieval
models, e.g., mContriever-X, finding that SWIM-IR can cheaply substitute for
expensive human-labeled retrieval training data. SWIM-IR dataset and SWIM-X
models are available at https://github.com/google-research-datasets/SWIM-IR.
|
[
-0.4151133895,
-0.341935575,
0.23706159,
0.1927516609,
-0.2142845094,
0.3383080363,
-0.3064681888,
-0.6773109436,
0.4579174519,
0.4472522736,
-0.5255468488,
-0.3558464944,
-0.1489036828,
0.2694509625,
-0.3495670259,
0.9595379829,
0.0043162946,
0.5006054044,
0.1746202111,
-0.2336124033,
-0.2853482962,
-0.5142800212,
-0.7235571742,
-0.3542414904,
0.8701580167,
0.7328798175,
0.1759165823,
0.3115799725,
0.3000414371,
0.2469830364,
-0.0062387874,
0.4595347345,
-0.6650289297,
0.347686857,
-0.2438095808,
-0.5810696483,
-0.3455979526,
-0.2629512846,
0.9000728726,
0.6395372748,
-0.0678393021,
0.1813471764,
0.0035602364,
0.6811842918,
-0.7959780693,
0.1625711918,
-0.89582026,
0.1117059961,
-0.2712495327,
-0.1967531741,
-0.5659121871,
-0.0611218587,
0.1766818315,
-0.3417055309,
0.3879978955,
0.2856974006,
0.535574019,
-0.1168760732,
-0.4309799969,
-0.2556613386,
-0.632766664,
0.9786564708,
-0.5411080718,
0.6723288298,
0.3242575526,
0.4137182534,
0.2568583786,
-0.4873808324,
-0.2232080698,
-0.3793758452,
-0.180664137,
0.1716163456,
0.2133895606,
-0.1557727456,
-0.1337755919,
0.2575990856,
-0.7776928544,
0.1147360504,
-0.1994788796,
0.0015891059,
0.9240005016,
0.2475505471,
0.3281916678,
-0.1069792435,
-0.4680820704,
-0.2319481224,
-0.8748398423,
-0.0989248604,
0.2773520947,
0.7576824427,
-0.0827714801,
0.7637045979,
-0.2446947247,
0.5610923171,
-0.3800853789,
-0.0952817053,
0.1617406309,
-0.4128498733,
0.1245026737,
0.281894505,
0.6965840459,
0.0646902844,
0.435741365,
-0.2037813514,
-0.6297757626,
-0.375161916,
-0.0494337864,
-0.7276097536,
-0.1234161928,
-0.0496358164,
-0.0514932759,
-0.0584448576,
-0.0965169072,
-0.5807410479,
-0.0803896859,
-0.4037701488,
0.3348659873,
-0.5180749893,
-0.1967808008,
0.3007479012,
-0.1433066577,
0.2280665338,
0.0438348167,
-0.9713408351,
0.3305590749,
0.3113053143,
0.7271167636,
-0.2036967725,
-0.5832202435,
-0.5262095928,
0.4136804938,
-0.1543834656,
0.7786484361,
-0.5128461719,
-0.2309181392,
-0.081391111,
-0.1907239258,
-0.4284000993,
-0.5512684584,
0.2778866589,
-0.5690364838,
0.2537166178,
-0.1354325712,
-0.61718297,
0.1000456885,
0.4150494337,
-0.7658139467,
1.0973937511,
0.0157508571,
-0.7985287905,
0.2094229013,
-0.2740004659,
-0.6429740191,
0.0294026788,
-0.0924115852,
-0.3279023468,
-0.0240343641,
0.3749446273,
0.3724846244,
-0.4437298775,
0.0069263899,
-0.2083448917,
-0.4544469118,
0.1844843924,
-0.199913457,
0.4075883925,
0.2082933038,
-0.0870057866,
-0.1085320115,
-0.7649111748,
0.2721831501,
0.1433466077,
-0.5159887671,
-0.5175818801,
-0.0089285634,
0.2154278159,
0.0530646257,
0.1324711144,
-0.4450807869,
0.1119787097,
-0.2527918518,
0.329891175,
0.3267982602,
0.0613960139,
0.4552328885,
-0.3564412594,
0.6988269687,
-0.333001107,
-0.0456158333,
-0.432965368,
-0.1009840816,
-0.6172357202,
-0.5405055881,
0.3124343753,
0.6870606542,
-0.8278262019,
-0.0673260689,
-0.5702413321,
-0.5965588689,
-0.5169249773,
0.297560513,
0.655046761,
0.4757373035,
0.4968135953,
0.1000713259,
-0.6333238482,
-0.8070200682,
-0.252299428,
-0.0141681414,
-0.0636492521,
0.5846853852,
0.454433471,
-0.1685765237,
0.616150558,
-0.4842062891,
-0.3003319502,
-0.6060077548,
0.0735210255,
0.1115039438,
0.3719918728,
0.7308802605,
-0.8458842039,
-0.7622764707,
0.1794185638,
-0.5682787299,
0.1294900328,
-0.0103673581,
-0.1730408818,
0.1395976692,
0.4234630466,
-0.6523549557,
-0.2614807487,
0.3576833606,
0.0185782593,
0.6213189363,
-0.2937242687,
0.2612043917,
-1.0725336075,
0.317568928,
-0.095159933,
-0.1113334894,
-0.4381505251,
0.2561365366,
0.2607630491,
-0.1402563006,
-0.5530423522,
1.0410079956,
-0.6986407042,
-0.098513566,
0.0492128059,
0.2210191339,
0.1113378182,
0.3873955011,
0.3707661331,
0.7448861599,
0.4547618032,
-0.7714112997,
0.0897285342,
0.2493238747,
-0.4023553133,
0.2962676883,
-0.7917158008,
-0.0222529378,
-0.1750834286,
0.0770060271,
-0.7786508799,
-0.4418175519,
-0.2579324245,
-0.289945364,
0.4221119583,
-0.535099864,
-0.4022626281,
-0.300983429,
-0.4948101342,
0.635856986,
0.1716902703,
-0.6358793974,
0.5131995082,
0.4832193255,
-0.3807329834,
-0.809656322,
-0.8232355118,
-0.0193125773,
-0.2448726892,
-0.7289358377,
0.4285044968,
-0.1163025573,
-0.099933587,
-0.3991852701,
-0.1396176517,
-0.1877369285,
-0.0659025386,
-0.4442902207,
0.3290210664,
-0.2695921063,
-0.0164684858,
0.1512150764,
0.0349211544,
-0.1153251305,
-0.1019247174,
0.5868241787,
0.00388819,
-0.5146403909,
0.3101299703,
0.3225650489,
0.3950371444,
-0.5531433821,
0.6492336392,
0.4629489183,
-0.2162046731,
-0.4968748093,
-0.6084641814,
-0.3936840892,
-0.427331984,
0.3506215215,
-0.5252638459,
-0.874623239,
0.8044302464,
0.3442967236,
-0.0041175107,
-0.0286140833,
0.4330352247,
-0.0859382972,
1.2274531126,
0.4385171831,
-0.2011320144,
0.6458135247,
-0.3727499843,
-0.0435753167,
-0.7348493338,
-0.3405580223,
-0.5774022341,
-0.2612713277,
-0.5071331859,
-0.2091268897,
0.5307841301,
0.0808558464,
-0.0851482823,
0.3334408998,
-0.1215465143,
0.6101025939,
0.5669164062,
0.1451432407,
0.2855740786,
0.1875630766,
-0.3206884265,
-0.1078805253,
-0.9551019669,
-0.2410246283,
0.9420586228,
-0.1406423301,
1.0455918312,
0.1140688658,
0.8821607828,
-0.004474354,
0.0528475046,
-0.5490285754,
0.4582286775,
-0.1660586298,
-0.6906268001,
-0.1887925267,
-0.6529555321,
-1.1993433237,
0.6016311646,
-0.1173127368,
-0.3926072717,
-0.0581910834,
0.0821548477,
-0.0025131579,
0.2465582937,
-0.8122547865,
0.6464138031,
-0.6145575643,
-0.4931288064,
-0.3724020123,
-0.6173171401,
0.4594584107,
-0.2371858954,
0.2444584668,
-0.2913118303,
-0.0903179199,
0.343095988,
-0.1722489595,
0.6488549113,
0.024206318,
-0.133108139,
0.1590590924,
0.2024765909,
0.4184540212,
0.2853903174,
-0.2649357617,
-0.189335078,
-0.1478711814,
-0.510158062,
-0.3637399375,
0.7007275224,
-0.4826359451,
-0.1715582609,
-0.3129249215,
-0.5638734102,
-0.4072762132,
0.3601157963,
0.2165562212,
0.2952415943,
-0.2624135613,
-0.01783753,
0.7999548316,
-0.2199431509,
0.326923877,
0.9584883451,
-0.1730463356,
-0.4319203794,
1.1302556992,
0.0426727906,
0.2108590156,
0.8000456691,
0.012113167,
-0.3656137586,
-0.4267712831,
-0.4575867057,
0.4901834428,
-0.4060420692,
-0.3939886689,
-0.3875206709,
-0.2336958945,
-0.2624262571,
-0.0547929518,
-0.5323777199,
-0.3469490707,
-0.0269406568,
0.0087556308,
0.2423194051,
0.4606868923,
-0.0179753937,
-0.0531813055,
-1.1526041031,
0.3559360802,
0.0412965044,
0.3405185938,
-0.0219764374,
-0.5088461637,
-0.5541730523,
0.2991375923,
0.2498849481,
-0.4416522086,
0.6289950609,
0.5193985105,
0.7090265751,
0.08882799,
-0.0412407294,
0.6984587908,
-0.6028240323,
0.4946208894,
-0.0229438599,
-0.6219406128,
0.6968998909,
-0.3696284294,
0.2736431956,
0.6335826516,
0.7521229386,
-0.5349527597,
-0.3726870716,
-0.2094728798,
-1.0995000601,
0.7274493575,
-0.00136571,
0.3042514324,
-0.1578853279,
0.310590595,
0.1243083179,
0.1191732064,
-0.649163425,
-0.2025642097,
0.2627398968,
-0.030644197,
-0.1099521592,
-0.3354440629,
0.1197801977,
-0.1565209627,
0.8664831519,
-0.3831520081,
-0.1245604753,
0.0535703637,
-0.4506475329,
0.0983460173,
0.1819937229,
0.2796643972,
0.39551875,
-0.1926117241,
0.1527167857,
0.1710530818,
-0.3679144979,
0.1649927497,
0.3009846807,
-0.2512370944,
-0.0113565503,
0.5855882168,
0.6181483269,
0.8052266836,
-1.1941628456,
0.0684509277,
-0.2524349391,
-0.046100866,
-0.1369202733,
0.1350335479,
0.0836878642,
0.2130159587,
0.3967278004,
-0.2417148948,
0.1443477273,
-0.3292128742,
0.1651522517,
0.5768837929,
0.1021695063,
-0.3086087406,
0.7692326307,
-0.0354855135,
0.1711038351,
0.9802368879,
-0.0544197895,
-0.4080859721,
0.2029978335,
0.4069788754,
0.4592379034,
-0.3406067491,
0.2001263946,
0.6663917899,
0.1380430311,
-0.2771120369,
0.5774894357,
-0.1803908944,
-0.7612348795,
-0.5753178596,
-0.5593621731,
-0.5108938813,
-0.185390532,
-0.8062247038,
0.5035069585,
0.0062659429,
0.0811646506,
0.0145230535,
0.0918995067,
-0.465154022,
0.1242180467,
0.3980470896,
0.9911371469,
-0.7715885639,
0.8459556699,
0.785584569,
-0.6694589853,
-0.7518670559,
-0.5431004763,
-0.3387261629,
-0.939707458,
0.4769301116,
-0.0171027333,
-0.2402221411,
-0.0876060352,
-0.37253353,
-1.0834101439,
1.0455832481,
0.9057610035,
-0.5659317374,
-0.1873249263,
0.393129915,
0.6095995307,
-0.3199745119,
0.3361243606,
0.4773255289,
0.3451423645,
0.192681998,
-0.9109038115,
-0.3629967868,
-0.3325960934,
-0.0915424153,
0.0557035878,
-0.7149208784,
0.7819760442,
-0.4660995305,
-0.0543557927,
0.1340083629,
0.3678955138,
0.7344747782,
0.0480272248,
0.1421743631,
0.380692631,
0.866333127,
0.1245826855,
1.2395546436,
-0.4630343318,
0.2432627678,
1.4132744074,
-0.528202951,
1.0256092548,
0.4124030769,
0.149020493,
0.2321219444,
0.6237275004,
0.0556376167,
0.4943162203,
0.0580643937,
-0.4504164159,
-0.2462538481,
-0.0756967813,
-0.2262833565,
0.3970002234,
0.2967194617,
-0.2194785923,
-0.3638180792,
0.1116967946,
-0.1022775769,
-0.1149737909,
-0.2797237933,
0.670781076,
0.1473950744,
-0.7043347955,
0.8464365602,
0.0742710009,
0.6166979074,
-0.843192935,
0.0743504241,
-0.639754355,
0.3236616552,
-0.1384976208,
-0.8471500874,
0.0026720141,
0.1008231863,
-0.1316283196,
-0.4095336795,
0.6539108753,
-0.8486962318,
-0.5186758637,
0.5003771186,
0.8163557649,
0.2519461513,
-0.0827934369,
-0.8314117789,
-0.0212129317,
0.0926310942,
-0.49848032,
0.5029975772,
0.4021636546,
-0.1132794023,
1.1071376801,
0.4238164723,
0.1783991158,
0.3609314561,
0.5832849741,
0.7546449304,
-0.5212712288,
-0.224280566,
-0.6727744341,
0.4454500973,
0.2450827509,
-0.0796286538,
0.9686601758,
1.0427796841,
1.15979743,
-0.241715163,
0.7041761875,
0.0797088742,
0.5129986405,
-0.6426460147,
0.7531654239,
-0.7280558348,
0.2054416984,
-0.0554497316,
-1.0732598305,
-0.2760668695,
0.4763244092,
0.1010658294,
0.2247106135,
0.3174176216,
0.8605701923,
-0.4286932051,
-0.1658894271,
0.1495716125,
0.0036932277,
0.2261380255,
0.476161778,
0.7016605735,
-0.3100091815,
0.6031336784,
-0.2661663294,
0.2521245778,
-0.2416119725,
-0.646152854,
-0.7992255092,
-0.4961002171,
-0.1579565257,
0.0032871936,
-0.0664354935,
0.834954083,
0.8503886461,
-0.9039647579,
-0.5532052517,
0.1521161348,
0.1855072528,
-0.0019123938,
-0.214068532,
0.1107694954,
-0.7506821156,
-0.8863666654,
0.8348523378,
-0.0501633324,
0.2561865151,
-0.213445276,
-0.2508850694,
-0.4405665696,
-0.1020344645,
0.6770555973,
0.3408180773,
-0.1456577778,
0.1655384451,
0.2838930786,
-0.2104330212,
-0.0739604756,
0.7637521029,
-0.7683776021,
0.3019354045,
0.3645600677,
0.51828897,
1.0055738688,
-0.3433357775,
0.6621576548,
-1.1796090603,
0.0847535729,
0.3841751814,
0.6404082775,
0.4446445405,
-0.0708910376,
0.8107548356,
-0.1769794226,
-0.2843079865,
-0.9699862003,
-0.0308368392,
-0.6542984843,
-0.219845131,
1.0579174757,
-0.0184814632,
-0.1337126791,
0.2209654003,
-0.1761529893,
-0.0860790536,
-0.2110298723,
0.5829077959,
0.4277675748,
-0.2205839753,
-0.1087630093,
-0.3202137351,
0.2612746954,
0.3770156503,
-0.6640944481,
0.1446027458,
0.4995230734,
0.54897964,
-0.111251317,
0.514307797,
-0.0230711978,
0.1568465084,
-0.0964047015,
0.1118669957,
0.1650842875,
-0.4320968986,
-0.0676032528,
-0.046704039,
0.1315782964,
0.3092490137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07592v1
|
Hallucination-minimized Data-to-answer Framework for Financial Decision-makers
| 2023-11-09T22:53:52 | 2023-11-09T22:53:52 |
Sohini Roychowdhury, Andres Alvarez, Brian Moore, Marko Krema, Maria Paz Gelpi, Federico Martin Rodriguez, Angel Rodriguez, Jose Ramon Cabrejas, Pablo Martinez Serrano, Punit Agrawal, Arijit Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been applied to build several automation
and personalized question-answering prototypes so far. However, scaling such
prototypes to robust products with minimized hallucinations or fake responses
still remains an open challenge, especially in niche data-table heavy domains
such as financial decision making. In this work, we present a novel
Langchain-based framework that transforms data tables into hierarchical textual
data chunks to enable a wide variety of actionable question answering. First,
the user-queries are classified by intention followed by automated retrieval of
the most relevant data chunks to generate customized LLM prompts per query.
Next, the custom prompts and their responses undergo multi-metric scoring to
assess for hallucinations and response confidence. The proposed system is
optimized with user-query intention classification, advanced prompting, data
scaling capabilities and it achieves over 90% confidence scores for a variety
of user-queries responses ranging from {What, Where, Why, How, predict, trend,
anomalies, exceptions} that are crucial for financial decision making
applications. The proposed data to answers framework can be extended to other
analytical domains such as sales and payroll to ensure optimal hallucination
control guardrails.
|
[
-0.4459415674,
-1.1758567095,
0.4993038774,
0.3023684919,
0.0052814824,
0.1472592652,
-0.227922678,
-0.4420765936,
0.5265960097,
0.867634654,
-0.6662579179,
-0.7185285687,
-0.0896375254,
0.000527114,
-0.545445025,
1.169953227,
0.23833251,
-0.2778701484,
-0.1668620557,
0.1712944955,
-0.1675240099,
-0.5127114654,
-0.962054193,
-0.135139063,
0.6095438004,
0.4909745753,
0.8635479212,
0.5949573517,
0.4916645885,
0.2630429566,
0.2427535653,
-0.0079257917,
-0.3622591496,
-0.0173435286,
-0.0034103743,
-0.447353214,
-0.7011967897,
-0.5178389549,
-0.0741015971,
0.9431948066,
-0.5667385459,
0.4726356268,
0.0350290872,
0.8239459991,
-0.4661324024,
0.5349415541,
-0.6674342752,
0.0678834245,
-0.0013683431,
-0.3324790001,
-0.6694462895,
-0.4442684948,
0.4033670723,
-0.7575269938,
0.1116761416,
0.3025684059,
0.5301707983,
0.2486592233,
-0.156618908,
-0.5344337821,
-0.5472430587,
0.4455025196,
-0.3644815981,
0.1993763596,
0.4991430938,
0.5627714396,
0.158735171,
-0.7974694371,
-0.2759486735,
-0.0282816831,
-0.3260793388,
0.1039689705,
-0.1618132442,
0.2312639803,
0.1819601655,
0.3133842051,
-0.8907755017,
0.0426385403,
-0.0374734849,
-0.2479434609,
0.6637709141,
0.4054940939,
-0.2926031649,
-0.2986094058,
-0.1585300565,
-0.4806455076,
-0.2200218886,
-0.0174251832,
0.2819101214,
0.6473298073,
0.0472622477,
0.6267880797,
-0.3144585192,
0.7396197915,
0.2103503644,
-0.2033088058,
-0.0870322585,
-0.0440015905,
-0.5130247474,
0.4778285027,
0.4556331933,
0.3984211683,
0.2289572507,
-0.307261616,
-0.3849274218,
-0.1859970689,
0.3700171411,
-0.6589636207,
-0.1463836133,
0.5693882704,
-0.3745212555,
-0.5242789388,
0.0994894356,
-1.2542581558,
-0.5409542322,
-0.3172236681,
0.344438374,
-0.0189191513,
0.1428576708,
0.5279240012,
0.1071277782,
0.2296372056,
0.4067130685,
-1.0631469488,
0.8649214506,
0.6082285047,
0.7015439272,
-0.1785957217,
0.1791975498,
-0.6856263876,
0.2825210392,
-0.4521186352,
0.5749047399,
-0.1256833076,
-0.3806093633,
0.222328335,
-0.2419340163,
-0.0975327492,
-0.7027688026,
0.1296086162,
-0.7363228798,
0.2146440893,
-0.3321285844,
-0.3266823888,
-0.2853550017,
0.4871557653,
-0.7265625596,
0.6168530583,
0.2263704836,
-0.8428865075,
0.4459474981,
-0.6492549181,
-0.5783136487,
0.2017877251,
-0.1232626289,
-0.3806830049,
-0.1796172857,
0.3555770516,
0.4634873867,
-0.5678207278,
0.4681846797,
-0.3006434739,
-0.2369437814,
0.6292113066,
-0.4528290629,
0.3004336059,
0.0625379458,
-0.3802840412,
0.2984592915,
-0.9256957769,
-0.0524685234,
0.041057229,
-0.0694145113,
-0.2368222922,
-0.2137217075,
0.3596312702,
0.04376949,
0.4559115171,
-0.161921829,
0.075748831,
-0.5292329192,
0.1530934572,
1.0752429962,
0.0751076341,
0.142054081,
-0.6713958383,
0.477545172,
-0.0793837756,
0.2113423347,
0.1486960948,
-0.1242467165,
-0.7616310716,
-0.0995158404,
-0.0116827777,
0.7945967913,
-0.6362019777,
0.74443084,
-0.2811608911,
-0.1923020482,
-0.2894178033,
0.0681626946,
-0.1830491722,
0.7835069299,
0.3516088128,
0.0831234679,
-0.4516229331,
-1.15251863,
-0.0690663606,
-0.4614122212,
-0.2400698364,
0.5027381182,
0.3806108236,
-0.1187000647,
0.8508310318,
-0.8664752245,
-0.3788338006,
-0.3376393318,
-0.0175433028,
0.3903898001,
0.0135037797,
0.3188892901,
-0.8887609839,
-0.1787218899,
0.3454293311,
-0.6625595093,
0.2025538683,
-0.7754951715,
-0.0260139871,
0.2064069808,
0.2105541676,
-0.5120719075,
0.4682050049,
0.0846076608,
-0.3543717265,
0.447658509,
-0.1011436805,
0.0179313365,
-1.1704821587,
0.2925344706,
-0.1018860787,
-0.2745860517,
-0.4903480411,
-0.2845576108,
-0.0943509787,
0.0601283163,
0.0676793903,
0.648468852,
0.2209216207,
-0.4391543567,
0.0911921933,
0.3257499337,
-0.3384584486,
0.7358841896,
0.047662165,
0.706482172,
0.5810697079,
-0.7128990293,
0.31177634,
0.3199601173,
-0.3511110246,
0.4674083591,
-0.6936640739,
-0.0049631097,
-0.083710216,
-0.1064794436,
-0.8869428635,
-0.6376233101,
0.3091496229,
-0.1297947764,
-0.1056463867,
0.375216186,
-0.6360859871,
-0.4094827473,
-0.4262512624,
0.099872157,
0.3176682293,
-0.6808817983,
0.8465218544,
0.0870303586,
-0.4774263501,
-0.5210214853,
-0.8324084878,
0.1659890711,
-0.4048709869,
-0.5993025303,
0.2625758648,
-0.3019054234,
-0.5542179346,
-0.2950577736,
-0.2665078938,
0.1467819363,
0.0554468259,
0.0782305449,
0.6288038492,
-0.1622491479,
0.1978821754,
0.2713741362,
-0.0433610156,
0.2141209245,
-0.482768774,
0.6448751092,
-0.2425769717,
-0.2192695141,
-0.2249070406,
0.1104678735,
0.7115774751,
0.1435353905,
0.7066498995,
0.0097590545,
-0.4510655999,
-0.3507227004,
-0.6423556805,
-0.3304531872,
-0.5650959611,
0.290941745,
-0.4515511692,
-0.9777085781,
0.9789809585,
0.0893553719,
0.248269245,
0.3692139387,
0.8077331185,
0.3383954167,
0.8910230398,
0.3162302375,
-0.0328122489,
0.0260356609,
-0.023520492,
0.3443945348,
-0.1212769449,
-0.4493962228,
-0.3085964918,
-0.220612064,
-0.4064033926,
-0.3133240938,
0.4147282839,
-0.1753548086,
-0.2923675776,
0.1306374669,
-0.4293244779,
0.1144278273,
0.0048861136,
0.1023323759,
0.3298460543,
0.0980503932,
-0.0583524257,
0.1684322506,
-0.5829433203,
-0.3317515552,
1.1447013617,
0.3191873729,
1.0697407722,
-0.0043637073,
0.5684185028,
0.488179177,
0.2393887043,
-0.9361111522,
0.6005535722,
0.0643983632,
-0.4126628041,
-0.6927091479,
-0.746417284,
-0.7261943817,
0.1017054617,
0.0874420777,
-0.9353163838,
0.2303061634,
-0.0721926615,
-0.6362096071,
0.1596180201,
-0.3535838723,
0.7431067228,
-0.3794536889,
-0.3379041553,
0.0108631244,
-0.4129978716,
0.3501237929,
-0.546690762,
0.356805414,
0.1990142316,
-0.2378948182,
0.7337172627,
-0.5436457396,
0.8290848732,
0.0318924747,
-0.3451447785,
0.249118194,
0.342351675,
0.6521412134,
0.7373293638,
-0.2793504894,
-0.3344938755,
-0.0941483974,
-0.2057914883,
-0.9153248072,
0.5124140382,
-0.3990860283,
-0.5756523609,
-0.2216427922,
-0.6214381456,
-0.558188498,
-0.0411238186,
0.1118299514,
0.1207979321,
-0.1824860722,
0.1816093624,
0.526447475,
-0.0383760668,
0.4237204194,
0.3377586603,
-0.6445366144,
-0.6301990151,
0.6965705752,
-0.0065082521,
0.0524182543,
0.4253105223,
0.2454423904,
-0.662293613,
-0.1180260479,
-0.4086965621,
0.167828083,
-0.8160939813,
-0.2794244885,
-0.4940407276,
-0.2261136621,
-0.509647727,
-0.4410648346,
-0.2457768321,
-0.3436354399,
-0.1907058805,
-0.6984793544,
0.5620981455,
0.4284629822,
-0.0293874275,
0.0569996685,
-0.3866533339,
0.4376871586,
0.716183126,
0.3715617657,
0.1915516108,
-0.343520999,
-0.1880476922,
-0.1294304281,
0.3118865192,
-0.5618034005,
0.4189630449,
-0.0321449302,
0.1143234074,
0.6684562564,
0.417665571,
0.8461077213,
0.1773938239,
0.4623008966,
0.2426903844,
-0.8791127801,
0.5114796162,
-0.10226053,
0.1257751137,
0.8837656379,
0.2344004214,
-0.6650827527,
-0.3310554922,
-0.4383407235,
-0.9899104834,
0.5359436274,
0.1344795674,
0.0471701622,
0.0729222372,
0.6033400297,
0.4718701243,
0.5417701602,
-0.6954670548,
-0.4133716822,
-0.1533197761,
-0.1419085711,
0.0298841931,
0.0773454756,
-0.181292206,
-0.392036438,
0.3831041157,
-0.5633192658,
-0.1920957118,
0.1958741397,
0.1314275116,
-0.0793480575,
0.1552951485,
0.3196983933,
0.6961390972,
-0.2880290151,
0.0300142765,
0.2713319063,
-0.4060534537,
0.0437565334,
0.1433170587,
-0.3084602952,
-0.1424611956,
0.284845084,
0.7210464478,
0.1369045377,
-0.9871412516,
0.2314653546,
-0.211506635,
-0.532410264,
-0.6271618605,
-0.0270109251,
-0.1276886463,
0.1359320581,
0.491653502,
-0.000908932,
0.3392615318,
-0.4243752062,
0.4517548084,
0.0164343771,
-0.5137539506,
-0.1270195842,
0.6246474981,
-0.2409769148,
-0.1490692198,
0.7859537005,
0.0655044094,
-0.0940358937,
0.5565116405,
0.4390798211,
1.0465521812,
0.0403424464,
0.6759441495,
0.3527877927,
0.1595181972,
-0.0583974421,
0.4614909291,
-0.1849615425,
-0.5487109423,
-0.1216553673,
-0.8146695495,
-0.2354256064,
0.329231292,
-1.0565317869,
0.1943026185,
-0.9426766038,
-0.1850787401,
0.0029862302,
-0.1971022338,
-0.5081293583,
0.2681506872,
-0.1286507398,
0.8919531703,
-0.4380984008,
0.4912917018,
0.3042488098,
-0.3593835533,
-0.6687660813,
0.0914513841,
-0.0479967855,
-0.7344174981,
0.4297454953,
0.1248737127,
-0.1449889392,
-0.1232131198,
-0.2744016051,
-0.5585962534,
1.0465130806,
0.3805423081,
-0.7200870514,
-0.2280583382,
0.458316803,
0.4244879186,
-0.4016115069,
-0.1335539967,
0.8753393292,
0.7244685888,
0.484598726,
-0.6172059178,
0.0817381516,
-0.0708417594,
-0.1846804768,
-0.0391778722,
-0.4425984919,
0.692121923,
-0.1610781252,
0.0829326063,
0.0852873772,
0.4713712931,
0.3653137386,
0.3551790118,
0.6791129708,
0.3515739143,
1.1204771996,
-0.0100892708,
1.0187135935,
-0.4554627836,
0.2361579835,
1.0587974787,
-0.4579330087,
0.8880094886,
0.5691953897,
-0.0454107039,
0.4927119017,
0.9032959938,
-0.0825492069,
0.3988119066,
0.7264459729,
-0.2736936212,
-0.4298999906,
-0.1360712796,
-0.0479492173,
0.2419151217,
0.4676035941,
-0.1210110262,
0.0440444723,
0.0914510116,
-0.1305501014,
0.0639499277,
-0.159265697,
0.961412847,
0.0844288245,
-0.3970462978,
0.306450218,
0.0617951527,
0.4474906325,
-0.8669404984,
0.2512411177,
-0.5103976727,
-0.0525070652,
-0.2126093358,
-0.5246405602,
0.284237355,
0.0445251018,
-0.1656572223,
-0.2285073996,
0.4500614405,
-0.2305445671,
-0.6619579792,
0.4648152292,
0.3794547319,
0.0004494458,
-0.1994198859,
-0.5431674719,
-0.3145798445,
-0.1062771082,
-0.4793714285,
0.260609746,
0.3902468681,
-0.0201818123,
0.8601068258,
0.7196122408,
0.0196870193,
-0.2022445649,
0.4644524455,
0.7177390456,
-0.713539362,
-0.8184194565,
-0.7757043839,
0.1662487239,
-0.1931585222,
-0.207701534,
0.6494761109,
0.9802455306,
0.6543366313,
-0.156870693,
0.6813876629,
0.27037853,
0.2241188437,
-0.5922497511,
0.6522111297,
-0.683406949,
0.523432672,
-0.3715826869,
-0.8542695045,
-0.5164224505,
0.6496134996,
-0.2759383917,
0.0516969971,
0.5289322734,
0.9184699059,
0.3043894768,
0.1674835533,
0.4364373684,
0.0917788148,
0.1321825236,
0.4109749198,
0.4195973873,
-0.2521628141,
0.7514873147,
-0.3919835389,
0.0266884156,
-0.3422275484,
-0.3307172358,
-0.8846099377,
-0.5175325274,
-0.4500943422,
-0.2387865484,
-0.1894110739,
0.868789494,
0.4290976524,
-0.9990528226,
-0.8138514757,
-0.1346802711,
0.1205564663,
-0.2169461995,
-0.3024326861,
0.6327486038,
-0.3916716874,
-0.2307526916,
0.1489619911,
0.756726563,
0.2755461335,
-0.3837423623,
-0.1396234483,
0.3702470064,
0.389519006,
0.5916927457,
-0.0362809785,
-0.696123302,
-0.2446513921,
0.4957715869,
-0.0768271908,
-0.0000769043,
0.8292127848,
-0.5476155281,
0.3757544458,
0.1693407297,
0.884569943,
0.6135972142,
0.1315735877,
0.3943262994,
-0.5022134781,
0.0980256721,
0.4469174445,
0.0141402213,
-0.0018731378,
-0.7276066542,
0.3514797091,
0.0002238983,
-0.1198656484,
-0.5691024065,
0.034857098,
-1.0816333294,
-0.4976923764,
0.7496486306,
0.3149891198,
-0.4451725781,
-0.196398437,
-0.1833898127,
-0.3191819191,
-0.4797695875,
1.090292573,
0.686175108,
-0.2713804543,
-0.1272929609,
-0.4957682788,
0.6694618464,
0.415581435,
-1.188303709,
0.5746050477,
0.3333489299,
-0.2485052645,
0.226714626,
0.574238956,
-0.0202348605,
0.3327704668,
0.1468593031,
-0.1522355378,
0.200003922,
-0.5281800628,
-0.2087783217,
0.6131722331,
0.1343168914,
0.0522807166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05769v1
|
Chatbots Are Not Reliable Text Annotators
| 2023-11-09T22:28:14 | 2023-11-09T22:28:14 |
Ross Deans Kristensen-McLachlan, Miceal Canavan, Márton Kardos, Mia Jacobsen, Lene Aarøe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent research highlights the significant potential of ChatGPT for text
annotation in social science research. However, ChatGPT is a closed-source
product which has major drawbacks with regards to transparency,
reproducibility, cost, and data protection. Recent advances in open-source (OS)
large language models (LLMs) offer alternatives which remedy these challenges.
This means that it is important to evaluate the performance of OS LLMs relative
to ChatGPT and standard approaches to supervised machine learning
classification. We conduct a systematic comparative evaluation of the
performance of a range of OS LLM models alongside ChatGPT, using both zero- and
few-shot learning as well as generic and custom prompts, with results compared
to more traditional supervised classification models. Using a new dataset of
Tweets from US news media, and focusing on simple binary text annotation tasks
for standard social science concepts, we find significant variation in the
performance of ChatGPT and OS models across the tasks, and that supervised
classifiers consistently outperform both. Given the unreliable performance of
ChatGPT and the significant challenges it poses to Open Science we advise
against using ChatGPT for substantive text annotation tasks in social science
research.
|
[
0.1681145281,
-0.8367033601,
0.5751399994,
0.222671032,
-0.3516491354,
0.4071667492,
-0.6181396246,
-0.502702713,
0.0168395769,
0.3840599358,
-0.1402447075,
-0.5346432328,
-0.8181738853,
0.2150089145,
-0.4481146634,
1.2210521698,
0.0122290719,
0.0712866411,
-0.2455603331,
-0.0552234054,
-0.1116629392,
-0.6443653107,
-0.7764920592,
-0.3542874157,
0.68129462,
0.147756964,
0.8367827535,
0.1280085593,
0.818615973,
0.2858656645,
-0.2959967852,
0.0666724816,
-0.7488383055,
0.1334923059,
-0.0747314319,
-0.3880681694,
-0.1433998644,
0.3438251317,
0.5305715799,
0.5604521632,
0.1771567464,
0.2207655758,
0.190624997,
0.4797280133,
-0.468596071,
0.6493768692,
-0.745311439,
0.0070015467,
-0.2624507248,
-0.0644471869,
-0.5575033426,
-0.7944026589,
0.3132029176,
-0.4125218391,
0.2538025379,
0.0674376115,
0.790057838,
0.3242757022,
0.1209131703,
-0.3170680702,
-0.7921700478,
0.6479951739,
-0.5108266473,
0.1591019183,
0.2994132638,
0.4420596957,
-0.2390803099,
-0.6022378802,
-0.5017312169,
-0.5633157492,
0.0810495839,
0.1677221209,
-0.1088224649,
0.0128894551,
0.2232940346,
0.1885367334,
-0.451128602,
0.1869123876,
-0.6522268057,
-0.1992077529,
0.562871933,
-0.058992561,
0.0795488358,
-0.392901659,
-0.2959831953,
-0.0731203929,
-0.6281390786,
-0.1121915355,
0.350391686,
0.5876891017,
-0.0580462962,
0.8715155721,
-0.0986443087,
0.2825766206,
-0.3141743541,
-0.1088212952,
0.267777741,
0.0186265055,
-0.0794137791,
-0.0161679927,
1.2701929808,
0.3540520072,
0.5171712041,
-0.4100995064,
0.0473683067,
0.2924406826,
0.1169346273,
-0.6933442354,
-0.3344728947,
0.1330362558,
-0.208803907,
-0.403054297,
0.0345743559,
-0.5121818781,
-0.5420241952,
0.0199617818,
0.3720793128,
-0.3522880971,
-0.1299511045,
-0.0889355615,
-0.2592216134,
-0.0694054216,
0.6746797562,
-0.5451955795,
0.1205755398,
0.8266857266,
1.3458207846,
-0.3514153361,
-0.1129164696,
-0.1319939792,
-0.2431187183,
-0.4410794079,
0.8459689617,
-0.582354486,
-0.2061472535,
0.0500560924,
-0.0559560172,
-0.0634242147,
-0.1228040829,
0.4938157201,
-0.3761567473,
0.3095499575,
-0.1987409443,
-0.551520884,
-0.0241534896,
0.05928801,
-0.5688946247,
0.9995478988,
0.1378796697,
-0.9857546091,
0.3519183695,
-0.7712119222,
-0.1779327542,
0.2587535381,
-0.2441985756,
-0.3833138943,
-0.1843138486,
-0.103616327,
0.7099503875,
-0.1822274029,
0.3003351688,
-0.499635309,
-0.7257332206,
0.3868427575,
-0.5651960969,
0.6667287946,
0.1244444326,
-0.2163741887,
0.1132913828,
-0.5640400052,
-0.3029153347,
0.1652547419,
-0.256667614,
-0.1546597183,
0.2895992696,
0.1376620084,
-0.0342342071,
0.0553505942,
-0.8841726184,
0.0751996711,
-0.087553218,
0.7725670338,
0.838606596,
-0.322160691,
0.2556619942,
-0.3360391855,
0.2941042781,
-0.3268381059,
-0.035905648,
-0.2037950605,
-0.8548596501,
-0.4383409321,
-0.3535007834,
0.5048655868,
0.5566716194,
-0.7492834926,
0.2350392789,
-0.3598144054,
-0.8500118256,
-0.5856775045,
-0.1958661973,
0.2562407851,
0.2918144464,
0.1974234134,
-0.260124445,
-0.2978567481,
-0.7257182002,
-0.3696755767,
-0.5026133657,
-0.144262895,
0.3092935681,
0.590190053,
-0.0326787494,
0.986342907,
-0.2682704628,
-0.0566962212,
-0.087543495,
0.2303878218,
-0.0974590033,
0.1269313842,
0.3875336349,
-0.5653232336,
-0.5159859061,
0.1427462101,
-0.7542048097,
-0.1747588962,
0.2241394222,
0.2672289312,
0.4506697953,
0.3314557076,
-0.7198799253,
0.4751060903,
0.6745990515,
-0.0604924224,
0.5410832763,
0.2552552223,
0.290091306,
-0.8106177449,
0.0808382928,
0.1502911448,
-0.2645495236,
-0.4791536629,
-0.2877503335,
0.0594341569,
-0.2711913586,
-0.6415929794,
0.458093226,
-0.016497517,
0.0530176461,
-0.250728637,
0.3507187963,
-0.3554279506,
0.1789819002,
0.0828337446,
0.8266481161,
0.3320086002,
-0.2867816687,
0.4236769974,
0.1457839012,
-0.3895098567,
0.1552399248,
-0.8240420818,
0.2271522135,
-0.1571662873,
0.4507760704,
-0.9908869863,
-0.4302222133,
0.4548806548,
-0.75016433,
0.0884287506,
-0.1137147173,
-0.7532618642,
-0.2673836052,
-0.4615511298,
-0.1302332431,
0.7269884944,
-0.4024439156,
0.1057119817,
0.1389098167,
-0.2327843904,
-0.379508853,
-0.6261208057,
0.0837150663,
0.0033773321,
-0.6741342545,
-0.1069936901,
0.2770377398,
-0.3082745671,
0.2212793082,
-0.0390993841,
0.0844859704,
0.0840752497,
0.455209285,
0.1711078435,
-0.2012518197,
0.4328008294,
-0.2504447997,
-0.1041272804,
-0.1857508123,
0.1421488971,
0.4432154596,
-0.1143785417,
-0.3543465734,
-0.2461032569,
0.0408589654,
0.3129970133,
-0.035523802,
0.9828665853,
0.6651849151,
-0.1034408063,
0.0630708933,
-0.6876700521,
-0.1279135048,
-0.3741159439,
0.3016455472,
0.1884289533,
-1.3229038715,
0.3065823317,
0.0680983514,
0.3166931868,
0.4377503693,
0.4185548127,
-0.168291226,
0.6199404001,
0.4990842342,
-0.0541910045,
0.6181201339,
0.2083045095,
0.352632463,
-0.4927865863,
-0.055899661,
-0.8063244224,
0.1701833904,
-0.811473608,
-0.4041519761,
0.1581341773,
-0.1544953734,
-0.3335787058,
0.3579732776,
-0.5174827576,
0.4148869514,
0.3863408566,
0.0850698277,
0.3291984797,
0.1608565748,
0.5476028323,
0.153553769,
-0.6332480907,
-1.0966751575,
1.078723073,
0.5640182495,
0.957113266,
-0.201523304,
0.4794874787,
0.1898021996,
0.599375248,
-0.7052767277,
0.5474395752,
-0.2808960676,
-0.6154490113,
-0.4184307456,
-0.6146094799,
-0.9122976065,
0.3647620082,
-0.216162473,
-0.9656177163,
-0.3614202738,
-0.0415859371,
-0.1702115834,
0.3864068985,
-0.9302350283,
0.682557106,
0.1375060976,
-0.3277579546,
0.2058532685,
-0.4790419936,
0.2009545565,
-0.236893177,
0.2486988008,
-0.4430145621,
0.0463565551,
0.8316129446,
-0.1606478989,
1.1709564924,
0.042626854,
0.0353291593,
0.4058836102,
-0.1944824159,
0.3396974206,
-0.1538462937,
-0.2217408419,
0.5846740007,
0.087397106,
-0.381595999,
-0.3008762598,
0.4973466098,
-0.738529861,
-0.5830008984,
-0.5111002326,
-0.3708881736,
-0.0195323229,
-0.0122753037,
0.2390764207,
0.025976561,
-0.3309518695,
0.4511454701,
0.3008308411,
-0.2728467286,
0.4134266078,
0.2348938882,
-0.1415104866,
-0.2156033516,
0.7956103086,
0.2986883521,
0.5296828747,
0.1408677846,
0.2279437631,
-0.0370103382,
-0.4672124088,
-0.3648735583,
0.047178477,
-0.5839373469,
-0.0491706319,
-0.6642241478,
-0.4266156554,
-0.4830785394,
-0.1310100257,
-0.434838295,
-0.5417811871,
-0.1997169256,
-0.0774871856,
0.6366952062,
0.8448117375,
0.0831970498,
0.3905261755,
-0.6682602167,
0.0717896521,
-0.0979021788,
0.4593510032,
-0.2209352255,
-0.1845458746,
-0.1278730184,
0.198640123,
-0.4353812039,
-0.8290570378,
-0.0918698981,
-0.0607900843,
0.36086303,
0.1959350258,
0.0897771418,
0.3094352782,
-0.6126433015,
1.1152414083,
0.1952305436,
-0.6252459288,
0.3434072435,
-0.427539736,
0.0914694816,
0.364438504,
0.619803369,
-0.5546527505,
-0.7646389008,
-0.5221848488,
-0.6440937519,
0.7661157846,
0.5911588073,
0.2601856589,
-0.2404067963,
0.1236041114,
0.333912313,
0.261970222,
-0.7887731194,
-0.0293744169,
-0.2651049197,
-0.0994438902,
-0.3454497755,
-0.2319840938,
0.2154051811,
0.123327136,
0.6452507377,
-0.0742966086,
0.2335194498,
0.2256823629,
0.0288231745,
-0.2633877993,
0.2989045084,
0.2609261274,
0.5906847715,
-0.3213439286,
-0.0568034798,
0.0390207283,
-0.5728097558,
-0.1194457263,
0.1919398308,
-0.4976571798,
0.3236856461,
0.5869086385,
0.7447046638,
0.2306255996,
-0.5757547617,
0.5421707034,
0.0665147305,
-0.2693738937,
-0.2105123997,
0.112894468,
0.1480045021,
0.2936183512,
0.2944993973,
-0.0512766242,
-0.1354374588,
-0.5384064317,
-0.2273924351,
0.4269441366,
-0.5316732526,
-0.267668128,
0.4875667691,
0.1628999561,
-0.4811144769,
0.3840862513,
-0.0321386196,
-0.5614983439,
0.4771166742,
0.2353006601,
0.8724021316,
-0.1293423027,
0.3803548217,
0.2286768705,
0.4785668552,
-0.3756835461,
0.0416039601,
0.0930134952,
-0.5086591244,
-0.6718959808,
-0.4423672557,
-0.8443968296,
-0.0379670747,
-0.2553263307,
0.3512973487,
-0.3156150281,
-0.3457431495,
0.2734866738,
-0.1185153872,
-0.4917729199,
-0.1610465348,
-0.0280711465,
0.7509766817,
-0.8121526837,
0.5262219906,
0.6118937731,
-0.4362045825,
-0.4109919667,
-0.0550607108,
-0.0408901647,
-0.4881317317,
0.4988095164,
0.3438617289,
-0.0242642835,
-0.4069186747,
-0.9026856422,
-0.5435456634,
0.952103734,
0.337200433,
-0.5870854259,
0.0231833402,
0.2518525124,
0.7272250652,
-0.0178209264,
0.4884383678,
0.119764924,
0.3835324347,
0.2576402128,
-1.3556805849,
-0.0746642202,
0.1553740203,
-0.0441378653,
0.1818287522,
-0.926856041,
0.8149310946,
-0.1042348668,
-0.4739840627,
0.0406348146,
0.4964775741,
0.1020930409,
0.4880346954,
0.2062653303,
0.1738761365,
0.6051934361,
-0.3191566765,
0.9649268985,
0.1326879412,
0.5702697635,
0.9113718271,
-0.3712769449,
0.9896817803,
0.3143066168,
-0.4289519191,
0.1186545864,
0.6331968904,
-0.1740099192,
0.2636896372,
0.2667531967,
-0.1321886927,
-0.0511316136,
-0.0049594166,
-0.2712063193,
0.2941578925,
0.2749676704,
-0.3701214194,
-0.3238768876,
-0.0908007026,
0.1917629987,
0.0495498478,
-0.1331173182,
0.7595371008,
0.2079946697,
-0.4754626453,
0.1735015064,
-0.1831719726,
0.771717906,
-0.4356840849,
-0.0590326414,
0.0673229247,
0.0091198962,
-0.3023943603,
-0.8540912271,
0.3057325184,
0.3856973648,
0.2718797624,
0.0486333184,
0.9550073743,
-0.129400447,
-0.4141565859,
0.1828605682,
0.3619353771,
0.5198839307,
-0.2553579211,
-0.3629368842,
0.2517449856,
-0.1328383237,
-0.4328914583,
0.1582889259,
0.5242713094,
-0.1318935901,
0.8302022815,
0.7905973196,
0.0108476989,
-0.0198722538,
-0.1575589329,
0.8511472344,
-0.5573690534,
-0.0281236414,
-1.0883983374,
0.1652864069,
-0.1546954811,
-0.1769756526,
0.8826957345,
0.4356396794,
0.8244606853,
-0.0153768249,
1.0080118179,
-0.0576147288,
0.7420017123,
-0.3822208643,
0.7798610926,
-0.0952572152,
0.0970545188,
-0.5216525793,
-0.9495443702,
-0.3875910938,
0.6186914444,
-0.578358829,
0.0884403512,
0.6923692226,
0.5934375525,
0.1014391705,
0.4292996824,
0.3494621515,
0.1567704082,
0.4909135103,
0.1793487817,
1.1467787027,
-0.1100332513,
0.6311416626,
-0.2732854187,
-0.2892577946,
-0.2848305106,
-0.952334106,
-1.3895144463,
-0.4638387263,
-0.3979191482,
-0.3438097537,
0.3965196609,
0.8999730349,
0.5585740209,
-0.5645628572,
0.0679372847,
0.1685863286,
0.0048318827,
0.1614385694,
-0.2468188405,
0.3880149722,
-0.5142214894,
-0.6691700816,
-0.0131132836,
0.2732564509,
-0.0405959003,
-0.371644944,
0.1720187217,
0.1816084832,
0.0870662108,
0.8154008389,
0.1677987278,
-0.8093930483,
-0.5964152813,
-0.1160249189,
-0.1870036423,
0.022987742,
0.4327836335,
-0.5895344615,
0.1009500772,
0.3771946132,
0.639216125,
0.3839972317,
-0.0420076773,
0.1899629682,
-0.3412584066,
0.0590608604,
0.3457097709,
0.1753982604,
0.5862511992,
-0.1619813442,
0.7642948031,
0.0930788517,
-0.7946375012,
-0.7903960943,
-0.1751008332,
-1.0609273911,
-0.1760348082,
1.5148234367,
-0.3873403072,
-0.4126417935,
-0.2058096528,
-0.4694168866,
0.1312538385,
-0.7893179059,
0.8122232556,
0.9277271032,
0.0728708729,
-0.0767551661,
-0.8629251122,
0.2713048458,
-0.0532952882,
-0.5288207531,
0.1446985453,
0.4004990757,
0.1982584447,
0.3179283738,
0.6666504741,
-0.2558194399,
0.0945494846,
0.0427939333,
0.1752676815,
-0.0749201104,
-0.0006265374,
-0.0142625077,
0.194729805,
0.1604771465,
-0.2029732764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07591v1
|
Identification of Books That are Suitable for Middle School Students Using Artificial Neural Networks
| 2023-11-09T22:10:52 | 2023-11-09T22:10:52 |
Alp Niksarli, Sadik Ozan Gorgu, Ege Gencer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Reading right books contributes to children's imagination and brain
development, enhances their language and emotional comprehension abilities, and
strengthens their relationships with others. Building upon the critical role of
reading books in individual development, this paper aims to develop an
algorithm that determines the suitability of books for middle school students
by analyzing their structural and semantic features. Using methods described,
an algorithm will be created that can be utilized by institutions and
individuals responsible for children's education, such as the Ministry of
National Education officials and schools. This algorithm will facilitate the
selection of books to be taught at the middle school level. With the algorithm,
the book selection process for the middle school curriculum can be expedited,
and it will serve as a preliminary reference source for those who evaluate
books by reading them. In this paper, the Python programming language was
employed, utilizing natural language processing methods. Additionally, an
artificial neural network (ANN) was trained using the data which had been
preprocessed to construct an original dataset. To train this network, suitable
books for middle school students were provided by the MEB, Oxford and Cambridge
and with content assessed based on the "R" criterion, and inappropriate books
for middle school students in terms of content were included. This trained
neural network achieved a 90.06% consistency rate in determining the
appropriateness of the test-provided books. Considering the obtained findings,
it can be concluded that the developed software has achieved the desired
objective.
|
[
-0.4285145998,
-0.5142852068,
0.1991287917,
0.0022438923,
-0.2517659664,
0.0116784908,
-0.0715422481,
-0.3858537972,
-0.2335995883,
0.2266197801,
-0.5946432352,
-0.2953528166,
-0.4908342957,
0.3065289259,
-0.6774984002,
0.6576998234,
0.2125356197,
0.0114219505,
-0.3160333335,
-0.0477947444,
-0.420504272,
-0.3688408732,
-0.4273768663,
-0.6008784771,
0.6159502864,
0.3126952052,
0.6862935424,
1.0980700254,
0.4105078578,
0.4965056777,
-0.3236719668,
-0.0733807981,
0.0571513735,
-0.0946941897,
-0.4224813879,
-0.5024625659,
0.0496258326,
-0.1816202551,
0.5911005139,
0.3296282887,
0.0047779963,
0.4576042593,
0.3309721947,
0.9755020142,
-0.5639430881,
0.0353728719,
-0.282479465,
0.3257139027,
-0.3850521743,
-0.1502869427,
-0.3233979046,
-0.4277526438,
0.5264108181,
-0.5613350272,
0.3984038234,
0.2046046853,
0.9077679515,
-0.1174836382,
-0.188319847,
-0.7421913743,
-0.4943514764,
0.7692401409,
-0.5715065002,
0.3574795127,
0.5572884679,
0.2032240033,
-0.2029143572,
-0.2588893175,
-1.0045659542,
-0.3245098889,
-0.2055535018,
0.1678971052,
0.0462917835,
0.0234708376,
0.0400810316,
0.0423747674,
-0.8078852296,
-0.2126259953,
-0.5047329664,
0.0372504406,
0.5448028445,
0.0228321608,
0.8365043998,
-0.3908531666,
-0.3417604268,
-0.3714015484,
0.0060158987,
0.3664388657,
0.8494178057,
0.3185573816,
0.3604441881,
0.5631769896,
-0.0290110838,
0.8938786983,
-0.2948453724,
-0.1443768293,
0.2322848439,
-0.3503987193,
-0.1528621316,
0.2006067038,
0.210134685,
0.2949088514,
0.7513851523,
-0.1866820306,
-0.2242355645,
0.1589288563,
0.3445035517,
-0.4923291206,
-0.0011647913,
-0.0461035818,
-0.7327640057,
-0.1963300109,
-0.2958541811,
-0.4849382937,
0.0888589025,
-0.9464060068,
0.4853713214,
-0.4566487372,
0.1246955395,
-0.0186291952,
-0.3852420449,
0.0496417098,
-0.0318978094,
-1.1673746109,
0.4448378384,
0.3356027305,
0.7101530433,
0.0626512542,
-0.4303153455,
0.3554335833,
0.3488486111,
-0.2007408738,
0.7780570984,
-0.4702651203,
0.1352041811,
0.1276473701,
-0.0983908102,
-0.0609336086,
-0.3854943216,
0.5238236785,
-0.56820333,
-0.0616690889,
-0.0611985475,
-0.5462113023,
-0.4203787148,
0.7382147908,
-0.6373121738,
0.8185941577,
0.0872089639,
-0.4990054667,
-0.1080749407,
-0.215897575,
-0.4761566818,
0.0973504409,
-0.0559555553,
-0.3638937473,
-0.2754374444,
0.2068949044,
0.4279978871,
-0.2275583893,
0.1537115872,
0.010861476,
-0.6554509401,
0.2998208106,
-0.507776916,
0.8987138271,
0.1576172113,
-0.0832665563,
-0.0691517815,
-0.7761861682,
0.323056221,
0.0755515471,
-0.2940370739,
-0.6349482536,
0.2358914018,
0.2178884745,
-0.1288681626,
0.3760817647,
-0.3342792392,
0.2488166243,
-0.4629031718,
0.2383863032,
0.8901852965,
-0.2262058705,
0.3568936288,
-0.5791212916,
0.2364323139,
-0.1622215211,
0.2607795596,
0.0972784236,
-0.426705122,
-0.5271360278,
0.3004918396,
0.6089975834,
0.8819892406,
-0.5781704187,
0.849129498,
0.3170043528,
-0.611209631,
-0.0635944828,
0.2510820925,
0.569525063,
0.4840691388,
0.1745058298,
-0.0567783862,
-0.3954375982,
-0.7084923983,
-0.2989269495,
-0.2009093165,
0.2164162993,
0.5227312446,
0.2850286365,
-0.241552487,
0.5778320432,
-0.2854708731,
-0.2498550862,
0.0611234792,
-0.2961681485,
0.3646475673,
0.7102217674,
0.5714967847,
-1.0392690897,
-0.575276792,
0.0268272664,
-0.6555796266,
-0.1756792665,
-0.1058400571,
-0.5325793028,
-0.2263943553,
0.3363569081,
-0.0136403246,
0.6018891335,
0.2138037831,
-0.5093935132,
0.702531755,
-0.2604181468,
-0.1857177764,
-0.7650093436,
-0.1126729473,
0.205488205,
0.2483864725,
-0.2195518762,
-0.3035489917,
0.1731357276,
0.0725073665,
0.0391760282,
0.788334012,
-0.3220943213,
0.0775811672,
-0.0884973034,
0.2868679762,
0.0616050661,
0.325006038,
-0.1743239611,
0.3871996105,
0.3305646181,
-0.6684639454,
0.2984277308,
0.3302030265,
-0.3848925829,
0.4062021971,
-0.4233401418,
-0.0478144772,
-0.1153920516,
-0.2039318085,
-0.7297762036,
0.1902642399,
0.4875415266,
-0.4653083384,
0.2395518571,
-0.0718970299,
-0.327971518,
-0.4527290761,
0.4473111629,
0.2234009653,
0.1073175967,
-0.5752484798,
0.8843697906,
0.089001134,
-0.3654561341,
-0.9892692566,
-0.4108529985,
-0.1016392559,
0.3024283648,
-0.3221633434,
0.3912451267,
-0.5945870876,
0.0963923484,
0.5361641049,
-0.2244480401,
-0.3457778096,
-0.0774419978,
0.2092818171,
0.4645075202,
-0.0394270755,
0.2390566319,
0.3319177032,
-0.2932003438,
-0.1144670546,
-0.2175702304,
0.1538674533,
-0.3584937155,
-0.0769867972,
-0.2626330256,
0.2256961018,
0.2281984985,
-0.2465263307,
0.2939967215,
0.6039502621,
-0.3715646267,
-0.6441102028,
-0.0754015669,
-0.0569001101,
-0.5380779505,
0.4257796705,
-0.3484818041,
-0.0545997508,
0.2414781898,
0.2288635671,
-0.1285955608,
0.0394043215,
0.5620743632,
-0.100909166,
0.8129844069,
0.5751416683,
-0.1333638579,
0.7815140486,
-0.2636947036,
0.1461666822,
-0.7444787621,
-0.5630632639,
-0.7567638755,
-0.8153880835,
-0.2220326662,
0.2363438755,
-0.1828866899,
0.1316836178,
-0.2429655939,
0.259753257,
-1.2491801977,
0.9714912772,
0.9864468575,
0.1848656833,
0.1131297722,
0.0926737413,
-0.4419358671,
0.2493411005,
-0.3725485802,
-0.9002912641,
1.0266838074,
-0.1334114373,
0.2553100884,
0.3775893152,
0.5852667689,
0.6428693533,
0.4585445821,
-0.9707605839,
0.7821894288,
-0.3564785421,
-0.9166436791,
-0.6143678427,
-0.2140597552,
-1.0972025394,
0.0939745009,
-0.2837703526,
-0.6383141875,
0.470592767,
-0.3341358304,
-0.2585311532,
-0.0417599045,
-0.7337515354,
0.7629934549,
-0.4670501053,
-0.1309442073,
-0.0770665035,
-0.817789197,
-0.3480268419,
-0.1033175066,
-0.23670955,
-0.1302483529,
0.2309874743,
1.0286618471,
-0.0260290969,
0.5245891809,
0.0032708652,
0.6674887538,
0.5914255381,
0.0308520962,
-0.1164025143,
-0.1754708588,
-0.4709993601,
-0.0605313629,
0.4723821878,
-0.5923095942,
-0.7430073023,
0.4633111954,
-1.3205863237,
-0.238015607,
-0.8392912745,
-0.7141214609,
-0.1036670282,
0.9129289985,
-0.0644214749,
0.4442005455,
0.0891444162,
0.1353152692,
0.3296673894,
0.1729137897,
0.8604934812,
0.5899796486,
0.0396083295,
-0.433622092,
1.1619437933,
0.6906405687,
-0.2317978442,
0.0778331459,
0.6325904131,
-0.3969583809,
-0.8830624819,
-0.3934259415,
-0.0564981215,
-0.6744886637,
-0.1407680362,
-0.2034296542,
-0.5169630051,
-0.2224617898,
-0.4108808637,
0.1602128446,
0.1317847669,
-0.3904943466,
0.0152992541,
-0.3217767775,
0.7253479958,
0.0610624254,
0.578486383,
-0.7891376615,
0.1999143809,
0.3858460784,
0.1855475903,
0.3929209411,
-0.3600136638,
-0.3529532254,
-0.2554794252,
-0.5839672089,
-0.7384080887,
0.5605623126,
0.3430127501,
0.6148314476,
0.6152020097,
0.1153786555,
0.2399665862,
-0.4741438627,
0.0867524818,
-0.0415927507,
-0.8182748556,
0.3106651306,
-0.0145838652,
-0.1248494834,
0.3779504597,
0.5396690965,
-0.3434646428,
0.1398752183,
-0.8675940037,
-0.5984874964,
0.6389412284,
0.2885864079,
0.2285051048,
0.2490106523,
0.6371197104,
-0.0977723747,
0.2525423765,
-0.5085784793,
-0.2071487755,
-0.1428922862,
-0.8584854603,
-0.0690351948,
-0.0026333102,
0.0943940282,
-0.4136382341,
0.6698454618,
-0.0623307601,
-0.1254338175,
0.2249810696,
0.2026685774,
-0.0063148057,
0.1502649486,
0.1658904701,
0.5580390096,
-0.361931473,
-0.0748085454,
-0.4289508462,
-1.0425350666,
0.4342485964,
0.2481341809,
-0.5400545597,
-0.1262473464,
0.2139591873,
0.3048986495,
-0.2744085789,
-0.6491686106,
0.3411365151,
-0.172800824,
0.1209947169,
-0.4584956467,
0.4905526936,
-0.182998538,
0.8579028249,
0.3292439282,
0.4674719274,
0.1370685101,
-0.5588595271,
0.3970802128,
0.0071604648,
-0.101045154,
-0.1416348368,
-0.1140889302,
0.0437947996,
-0.9886205792,
1.0852720737,
-0.0617889464,
-0.6396116018,
1.1449552774,
1.2108817101,
0.6603581905,
-0.1647005379,
0.2108679265,
0.3249878883,
0.4514385462,
0.0316759236,
0.2459390908,
-0.118474029,
-1.2533075809,
0.210977301,
-0.8693115115,
-0.521733582,
-0.0769534186,
-0.6191673875,
0.0425637439,
-0.6232264638,
-0.3283263445,
0.0305403825,
0.4048445821,
-0.6310002208,
0.7752196789,
0.3724341393,
0.7086772919,
-0.9113944173,
0.7824479342,
0.6364799738,
-0.3926649094,
-0.9485068917,
-0.0456284508,
-0.129708305,
-0.493873775,
0.489227891,
0.1589314044,
0.1938537955,
0.4264472425,
-0.4682658613,
-0.8461651206,
0.8539122343,
-0.0279844031,
-0.6936307549,
-0.3858904243,
-0.1574185342,
0.456318289,
-0.3580779433,
0.4151318073,
0.2472485304,
0.5922860503,
0.2296532691,
-0.1030942053,
-0.2369530648,
-0.5634531379,
0.0620046258,
-0.0636822656,
-0.4840442538,
0.6870217919,
-0.1180506125,
0.3281223476,
0.3474203348,
0.6436856985,
0.5089648366,
0.9267301559,
0.3779689968,
0.4509016573,
0.9597889781,
-0.0117762927,
0.68091923,
-0.4118177295,
0.3111481369,
0.7498182058,
0.1747869253,
0.9698636532,
0.3205405474,
-0.1404138505,
0.5051353574,
0.9017357826,
-0.5493897796,
0.5628910065,
0.3678900599,
-0.2286639661,
-0.0478041954,
-0.036690753,
-0.1382048279,
0.2360568047,
0.4883849919,
-0.4320701957,
0.0333406441,
0.1081383005,
-0.4797156751,
0.0384415649,
-0.4753523767,
0.3319389522,
0.1595884711,
-0.562081337,
0.2886041999,
0.0432949699,
0.146490097,
-0.5131059289,
0.0244672988,
0.071365878,
0.4906789958,
-0.2291384935,
-0.8419092894,
0.0661712289,
-0.3316721618,
-0.655752182,
0.1537494212,
1.008674264,
-0.3571464717,
-0.8351989388,
0.1927869618,
0.350676775,
0.1068187952,
0.2149459869,
-1.0595885515,
-0.0678942725,
-0.1533582062,
-0.350471139,
0.2499355078,
0.5506064892,
0.0809944198,
0.6148768663,
0.9695904851,
0.3338929415,
-0.1378613859,
0.1379649043,
0.3149269521,
-0.7277536988,
-0.5637415051,
-0.6939038634,
0.280225426,
0.1266938448,
-0.601857245,
0.7521112561,
0.3776702881,
0.8151237369,
0.1435896456,
0.6376966238,
0.1172787845,
0.251021564,
-0.0898616165,
1.0336796045,
-0.4559479356,
-0.076843679,
-0.3156929016,
-1.1745500565,
-0.3344601095,
0.9247080684,
-0.3348105848,
0.1542883813,
0.5726320148,
0.6623451114,
-0.0413386077,
0.3193802834,
0.1821264327,
0.0071430174,
0.0120699489,
0.301946342,
0.5409427285,
-0.5646268725,
0.4103660882,
-0.2477410287,
-0.459540695,
-0.2900056541,
-0.6888595223,
-0.8567745686,
-0.5909858346,
-0.1475881934,
-0.5503308773,
0.412953645,
0.6778473258,
0.403423965,
-0.4334199727,
-0.3119565845,
-0.082256183,
0.5105726123,
-0.4802252054,
-0.1609140337,
0.6391137242,
-0.2367655486,
-0.8224822879,
0.0549989715,
-0.0646807998,
0.0981813073,
-0.0438778698,
-0.045155067,
-0.4128172398,
0.4418439567,
0.3364520371,
0.4140994549,
-0.2668941617,
-0.1506583691,
-0.1031127274,
-0.2915174961,
-0.1403169632,
0.2888360322,
-0.5336296558,
0.8327721357,
0.5284930468,
0.9095095396,
0.1337191463,
-0.1091407463,
0.1110840812,
-0.2276991308,
-0.0068060127,
0.595466733,
0.1473861188,
-0.0586755052,
-0.3562444746,
0.4176319242,
0.4025737047,
-0.8935489655,
-0.7669574022,
-0.2913269699,
-0.91048491,
-0.1090089604,
0.6585572362,
-0.0132275196,
-0.9669587612,
-0.3278013468,
-0.3335318267,
0.5590883493,
-0.1059668735,
0.8783810139,
0.9505518675,
0.0423024744,
0.173908785,
-0.4754925072,
0.0293394011,
0.5289698839,
-0.3822982907,
-0.4872094691,
0.04281196,
0.2151974142,
0.3296329677,
-0.0313058645,
0.1044578031,
0.1138895005,
0.0815565214,
0.2220390141,
-0.1868679225,
-0.6423762441,
0.1119106412,
0.2882304788,
-0.4551899135,
-0.1218306869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05754v1
|
Deep Natural Language Feature Learning for Interpretable Prediction
| 2023-11-09T21:43:27 | 2023-11-09T21:43:27 |
Felipe Urrutia, Cristian Buc, Valentin Barriere
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose a general method to break down a main complex task into a set of
intermediary easier sub-tasks, which are formulated in natural language as
binary questions related to the final target task. Our method allows for
representing each example by a vector consisting of the answers to these
questions. We call this representation Natural Language Learned Features
(NLLF). NLLF is generated by a small transformer language model (e.g., BERT)
that has been trained in a Natural Language Inference (NLI) fashion, using weak
labels automatically obtained from a Large Language Model (LLM). We show that
the LLM normally struggles for the main task using in-context learning, but can
handle these easiest subtasks and produce useful weak labels to train a BERT.
The NLI-like training of the BERT allows for tackling zero-shot inference with
any binary question, and not necessarily the ones seen during the training. We
show that this NLLF vector not only helps to reach better performances by
enhancing any classifier, but that it can be used as input of an
easy-to-interpret machine learning model like a decision tree. This decision
tree is interpretable but also reaches high performances, surpassing those of a
pre-trained transformer in some cases.We have successfully applied this method
to two completely different tasks: detecting incoherence in students' answers
to open-ended mathematics exam questions, and screening abstracts for a
systematic literature review of scientific papers on climate change and
agroecology.
|
[
-0.3592815697,
-0.7834980488,
0.378459394,
-0.0251980759,
-0.3069004118,
0.1054241955,
-0.3591725826,
-0.7681028843,
0.0217741728,
0.5898282528,
-0.6462500691,
-0.3853011727,
-0.6798139215,
0.0671093613,
-0.505253911,
1.2697800398,
0.0915642977,
0.0544693321,
-0.2421133816,
-0.1243068576,
-0.551656723,
-0.4376072884,
-0.6729607582,
-0.7180792093,
0.5214678049,
0.3741146028,
0.735488534,
0.3086020648,
0.4219021499,
0.2050743997,
-0.2128318548,
-0.1140479892,
-0.3881362677,
0.2240382284,
-0.0580849834,
-0.5407184362,
-0.0408047736,
-0.0772309974,
0.5322768092,
0.9837179184,
0.2098687589,
0.1377143115,
0.3076499701,
0.4230079651,
-0.2272559106,
0.4736290574,
-0.8518608212,
0.2378121912,
-0.0797192082,
0.0281264093,
-0.3618329167,
-0.1017181799,
0.5325143337,
-0.2480485141,
0.4348167777,
-0.0680424497,
0.7972185016,
0.5153321624,
-0.3725437522,
-0.4132389724,
-0.6655734777,
1.019947052,
-0.5671415925,
0.3171108067,
0.3435108066,
0.3745063245,
-0.0905595943,
-0.5149818063,
-0.5949003696,
-0.2422685027,
-0.4249581099,
0.0485673659,
0.0246124417,
0.0700894743,
0.115775384,
0.3037910461,
-0.4385555685,
0.2115429789,
-0.1002240255,
-0.1868612021,
0.4608845711,
0.0484177433,
-0.0092990818,
-0.3128351271,
-0.2037539929,
-0.1391154975,
-0.525785625,
0.4401437342,
0.0719362348,
0.5061175227,
0.0803017318,
0.3856904805,
0.1295739114,
0.6363384128,
-0.1116862372,
0.0495460294,
0.1666779518,
-0.2501255572,
-0.3052571714,
0.1378419399,
0.4431820214,
-0.1118632182,
0.1874801964,
-0.0988699421,
-0.1930879354,
-0.0534814708,
0.2051898092,
-0.7559185028,
-0.3378913105,
0.232267499,
-0.2880490422,
-0.3658212721,
0.0564935356,
-0.4186910391,
-0.3196499646,
-0.4804379344,
0.2578303516,
-0.4467786849,
-0.0643259436,
0.0449216142,
0.0119316531,
0.4447245896,
0.5160772204,
-0.8686782122,
0.3369210362,
0.8426730037,
0.4486783743,
-0.0294208582,
-0.2257985026,
-0.5866516829,
-0.1758550256,
-0.1643081009,
0.6764374971,
-0.6459990144,
-0.0760041699,
-0.1967716515,
0.0305582397,
-0.0000522174,
-0.4705429077,
0.5369907618,
-0.3800434172,
0.3566080034,
-0.0067818407,
-0.4748061001,
-0.5362098217,
0.2989248931,
-0.6831322908,
1.0923950672,
0.0850060806,
-0.8375312686,
0.5483886003,
-0.5979630947,
-0.4979422987,
0.0772600994,
-0.224535495,
-0.6562288404,
0.0461068079,
0.2848655283,
0.6761909127,
-0.2562353015,
0.5006887317,
-0.2693293393,
-0.2889434695,
0.173488453,
-0.6392405033,
0.7171325088,
0.0064287637,
-0.4368422329,
0.1761574745,
-0.6017619967,
0.0487833209,
0.1332733482,
-0.317148,
-0.2074985504,
0.1159958392,
0.0592991896,
-0.0085620219,
0.1731480658,
-0.5483703613,
0.0131218769,
-0.7340592146,
0.2906868458,
0.6777667403,
-0.0622092746,
0.4168565571,
0.1066086441,
0.3349613249,
0.0647055134,
-0.0302013718,
-0.0157201719,
-0.7243403196,
-0.7784714699,
-0.0110153072,
0.4984416366,
0.5307477117,
-0.7848790884,
0.6259003878,
-0.1401790977,
-0.3359669447,
-0.6550244093,
0.4082457721,
0.398059994,
0.6625436544,
0.4566458166,
-0.1088204458,
-0.5720956326,
-0.8457607031,
-0.1531770974,
-0.0985295773,
-0.1473994851,
0.1720636636,
0.6128903627,
-0.1989082843,
1.0493760109,
-0.3985538781,
-0.3643222749,
-0.5463062525,
0.5391730666,
0.530982852,
0.3042314649,
0.440481931,
-1.0145996809,
-0.5163418055,
0.1232557893,
-0.628942728,
0.1490826607,
-0.1636350304,
0.1215697452,
0.3051378131,
0.2898241282,
-0.3695702851,
0.3026655912,
0.4961837232,
-0.427054584,
0.1499598473,
-0.1895931363,
-0.3338720798,
-0.7355457544,
-0.0601087883,
0.0153652718,
-0.2281954139,
-0.6753125787,
-0.1763388366,
-0.1139855087,
-0.001862695,
-0.4259004295,
0.4785281718,
-0.1362176389,
-0.2269603908,
-0.2458885759,
-0.1984203011,
0.0366439745,
0.4684154093,
0.2154447287,
0.4643731415,
0.5092008114,
-0.4218974113,
0.1373224407,
0.2546139956,
-0.3195429146,
0.1743399501,
-0.4143665731,
0.1376931965,
-0.6043446064,
0.2301421762,
-0.9069601297,
-0.0815126225,
0.2002784461,
-0.5583019257,
0.4156279862,
-0.0175576247,
-0.3124687672,
-0.3406159282,
-0.1466569006,
0.0378848761,
0.4270325601,
-0.642409265,
0.6503187418,
0.0720897838,
-0.0319102257,
-0.7429987192,
-0.730022192,
0.0300638136,
-0.1227851808,
-0.2932704091,
0.1569078863,
0.0988134891,
-0.0255265031,
0.4126868844,
-0.094023101,
-0.1875558197,
0.4971790612,
0.2589487135,
0.172694236,
-0.3057644367,
0.417414695,
-0.0676219463,
-0.2163684517,
0.0691005588,
-0.3281924427,
0.2373929024,
-0.3451546431,
-0.1847717017,
-0.0696610138,
0.3449627757,
0.2682127655,
-0.2449256331,
0.6757975817,
0.8460046053,
-0.5035335422,
-0.2835648358,
-0.2352931052,
-0.3035746217,
-0.374450922,
0.4274786413,
-0.3227692246,
-1.0401268005,
0.1865762919,
0.0878666043,
0.2228544503,
0.6278399825,
0.2536548674,
-0.4350117445,
1.0760922432,
0.9046061039,
-0.1599238664,
0.4107524157,
-0.3876100481,
0.2335046232,
-0.4219523668,
-0.1707824618,
-0.450311929,
-0.4852989316,
-0.3805300295,
-0.4898089767,
0.1193949282,
0.2307144403,
-0.2149094492,
0.3358176947,
-0.5363636017,
0.3494074345,
0.6085636616,
-0.0330756977,
0.1641007215,
-0.0091623617,
0.0417117216,
-0.2781392634,
-0.5512851477,
-0.5180695057,
0.8908112049,
0.5477341413,
0.5996670127,
-0.146277234,
0.7397045493,
0.2246746123,
0.7415418029,
-1.0814466476,
0.3133813143,
-0.4190733731,
-0.5545318127,
-0.5348457098,
-0.4012630582,
-0.914301157,
0.3103202283,
-0.4685945511,
-0.5631096959,
0.125578776,
0.1691467166,
-0.2073219419,
0.3086692691,
-0.8131564856,
0.9805746078,
-0.5244279504,
0.0867637172,
-0.0404936932,
-0.7218263745,
0.1426639855,
-0.2163051665,
0.1516411006,
-0.0873765945,
0.1165784076,
0.6574462652,
-0.1125321314,
1.2321462631,
-0.3337869048,
-0.0098490277,
0.3344744146,
-0.1808386743,
0.5830515623,
0.0462255403,
-0.1931628436,
0.132413581,
-0.1848586798,
-0.3666364253,
-0.8430610299,
0.2201805562,
-0.6236121058,
-0.5290480256,
-0.3838786781,
-0.4685874283,
-0.1623286903,
0.0764885098,
0.0921676382,
0.3707500994,
-0.1573199779,
0.3938540816,
0.7504276633,
-0.1928928047,
0.4240590334,
0.3003760576,
-0.1284991205,
-0.1761713624,
0.9954628348,
0.0702726245,
0.1047153473,
0.7764878869,
0.4379842281,
-0.3552367389,
-0.8019714355,
-0.2093339562,
-0.0968661457,
-0.7900651097,
-0.2453582883,
-0.7017562389,
-0.3436892629,
-0.1711639166,
-0.1573990434,
-0.0760956258,
-0.2532605231,
-0.3822749555,
-0.2272622287,
0.3519675136,
0.9032365084,
0.2205759138,
0.0602619238,
-0.561409235,
0.3473809958,
0.4660559595,
0.2434677482,
-0.0552992746,
-0.3992601931,
-0.22773844,
0.0014655183,
-0.2421940118,
-0.4534234107,
0.3944291472,
0.4682964981,
0.5513045788,
0.3149328232,
0.0763185993,
0.4294860363,
-0.3159973621,
0.5015642047,
0.2008615285,
-0.8082789779,
0.6519264579,
0.0516138747,
0.2926062047,
0.5791789293,
0.3812350929,
-0.4108337164,
-0.6594437361,
-0.5076814294,
-0.7470517159,
0.6342003942,
0.1967352182,
0.1193973199,
0.0783169195,
0.1986492276,
0.3654423356,
0.2269096822,
-0.8737211823,
-0.2237040401,
-0.4297645688,
-0.4207802415,
-0.3855962157,
-0.3532605171,
0.1529528052,
-0.4847464859,
0.4606145918,
-0.5685163736,
0.2136003524,
0.2261371911,
-0.1872258931,
-0.1117950603,
0.5032010078,
0.2465500683,
0.3763751388,
-0.543649435,
0.2675025463,
0.4074724317,
-0.3892300427,
-0.0618536398,
0.191144973,
-0.1873956472,
0.0769151971,
0.594720602,
0.890201807,
0.4267157912,
-0.7139251232,
0.3946760595,
-0.0663780048,
-0.3451817334,
-0.339900285,
-0.0797856748,
0.1121670529,
0.2446668148,
0.4250580966,
0.1781706065,
0.1813033968,
-0.6971350312,
0.3618373573,
0.4613390565,
-0.9426235557,
-0.1939136833,
0.4772657454,
0.0960388556,
-0.101621896,
0.5191348791,
-0.2842959762,
-0.7265037894,
0.746227026,
0.3238721788,
0.8700335622,
0.0515597723,
0.3125732839,
0.147127673,
0.4214000404,
0.2190691829,
0.3528357446,
-0.0391730219,
-0.7954952121,
-0.6758485436,
-0.81590271,
-0.6158961058,
0.2458111793,
-0.5624542832,
0.097621806,
-0.4842271805,
0.2522442043,
0.2578894496,
0.0663556904,
-0.8669568896,
0.4346132278,
0.3026366532,
0.7149859071,
-0.7879528999,
1.0600345135,
0.845385015,
-0.2132861465,
-0.6597352028,
0.0842495561,
-0.1561485678,
-0.6547481418,
0.8717502356,
0.4917702973,
0.0657959357,
-0.1842179596,
-0.4878840446,
-0.7726192474,
0.8941982388,
0.4295782149,
-0.4095526636,
0.0617096163,
0.2028093934,
0.6750503182,
-0.4062466621,
0.1901114434,
0.6013377905,
0.4711157978,
0.1714959741,
-0.5923907161,
0.0102461362,
-0.013977617,
-0.1391706765,
0.2899975479,
-0.046154391,
0.705832541,
-0.2205382437,
-0.157605201,
-0.2939813733,
0.8262430429,
-0.1689941883,
0.2944177091,
0.7772904634,
0.3741738796,
0.8519878387,
-0.2348821163,
1.0734397173,
0.1590569317,
0.4463244975,
1.205594182,
-0.0842838213,
0.9604241252,
0.4446664155,
-0.1453883946,
0.4678347707,
0.5285266638,
-0.1196297407,
0.5687471032,
0.153452307,
-0.189760983,
-0.4728082716,
-0.2335783541,
-0.0810189098,
0.5730407238,
0.526581049,
-0.2653429508,
-0.5059996247,
0.1949282587,
-0.3305306733,
0.1219021007,
-0.2325068116,
0.7859988809,
0.1900705993,
-0.5341280103,
0.3903221488,
-0.1970383078,
0.8383197784,
-0.5459076762,
-0.4032831192,
0.158286497,
0.2214355022,
-0.1845038086,
-1.1319516897,
0.5588522553,
-0.1594205499,
-0.2353166491,
-0.5601232648,
0.8769000173,
-0.479347527,
-0.6382990479,
0.4991795123,
0.3677373827,
0.1062500477,
-0.0969710797,
-0.9035386443,
-0.298694849,
0.0878260732,
-0.2129171342,
0.2531348467,
0.453274101,
-0.0035788605,
0.6435372233,
0.4866265953,
-0.1829573363,
-0.1777189523,
0.1191783398,
0.7555202842,
-0.8019621968,
-0.2626474202,
-0.5717388988,
0.4625950158,
-0.0178532805,
-0.1719379276,
0.4414595068,
0.2976662815,
0.8740711212,
0.0359556191,
0.8230802417,
-0.0945673138,
0.6418011785,
-0.5387439728,
0.4599627852,
-0.2904274762,
0.2601103485,
0.0229505375,
-0.7851919532,
-0.3711859882,
0.4672297239,
-0.3270797729,
-0.229562059,
0.722589612,
0.3228840828,
0.0516871065,
0.141559884,
0.4047967494,
0.1230341494,
0.3312464058,
0.6756674647,
0.7635870576,
-0.2700048387,
0.7590025067,
-0.5509171486,
0.0700367689,
-0.0993664563,
-0.9028664231,
-1.0220322609,
-0.455539465,
-0.3582508862,
-0.1282036155,
-0.1171021387,
0.9028177261,
0.4315547347,
-1.2227511406,
-0.005981904,
-0.2732534409,
0.5194599628,
-0.3960236311,
-0.2617996037,
0.3956719041,
-0.5893800259,
-0.6395657659,
0.2982667387,
0.1651540399,
0.1719791144,
-0.3475563228,
-0.0083490508,
-0.1097718701,
-0.2255450636,
0.671367228,
0.2261709422,
-0.8687525988,
-0.5609704256,
-0.1603600681,
0.0616583042,
0.1424827725,
0.7107425332,
-0.9472614527,
0.4183543324,
0.3378517628,
0.9499743581,
0.5209652185,
-0.2444027513,
0.4915662408,
-0.949332118,
0.0944879353,
0.562818408,
0.3391181827,
0.3256929517,
-0.4619983733,
0.487062335,
0.0058753998,
-0.1038341522,
-0.5984076858,
0.2238658518,
-0.8462641239,
-0.4132767618,
0.7378216386,
-0.1682523191,
-0.2643838525,
-0.5094946623,
-0.1732078046,
0.0672564656,
-0.311036706,
0.5028285384,
0.6176566482,
-0.1176204085,
-0.3674060404,
-0.7636877894,
0.5519803762,
0.5325707793,
-0.6670315862,
0.0051526995,
0.1070375815,
0.1135571897,
0.2123430967,
0.197644338,
0.2040207088,
0.1089783907,
-0.3148764372,
0.064612858,
0.0893454924,
-0.3016616404,
-0.5614337325,
0.2644239366,
0.304407537,
0.0162209645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05746v1
|
Bridging the Digital Divide: Performance Variation across Socio-Economic Factors in Vision-Language Models
| 2023-11-09T21:10:52 | 2023-11-09T21:10:52 |
Joan Nwatu, Oana Ignat, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Despite the impressive performance of current AI models reported across
various tasks, performance reports often do not include evaluations of how
these models perform on the specific groups that will be impacted by these
technologies. Among the minority groups under-represented in AI, data from
low-income households are often overlooked in data collection and model
evaluation. We evaluate the performance of a state-of-the-art vision-language
model (CLIP) on a geo-diverse dataset containing household images associated
with different income values (Dollar Street) and show that performance
inequality exists among households of different income levels. Our results
indicate that performance for the poorer groups is consistently lower than the
wealthier groups across various topics and countries. We highlight insights
that can help mitigate these issues and propose actionable steps for
economic-level inclusive AI development. Code is available at
https://github.com/MichiganNLP/Bridging_the_Digital_Divide.
|
[
-0.6669572592,
-0.7788516283,
0.3578895032,
0.1632515043,
-0.1178361401,
0.8225628734,
0.2235675007,
-0.9749510288,
0.3250496686,
0.0618333593,
-0.5567362309,
-0.3374948204,
-1.0318361521,
-0.0837942809,
-0.3217012584,
0.3293471038,
0.3015802801,
0.0738754272,
-0.5673120022,
0.0336235799,
-0.3130351305,
-0.386919558,
-0.3167385161,
-0.12020199,
-0.0417090952,
0.6484541297,
0.8993328214,
0.8393455148,
0.6500385404,
0.3047267199,
0.0541941412,
0.0849079266,
-0.3321690857,
-0.4187571108,
0.1140026227,
-0.2676822245,
-0.3577661216,
-0.1284408718,
0.4985430837,
0.8722604513,
-0.0097353393,
0.256967634,
0.1890113056,
0.7551956773,
-0.950991869,
0.0390247665,
-0.4319547713,
-0.1236710846,
-0.3728505969,
0.3762295842,
0.2325247824,
-0.5522735119,
0.1614538878,
-0.4602429271,
0.5018677115,
-0.0709528103,
1.1766563654,
0.5236335993,
-0.3848049343,
-0.1159340292,
-0.902771771,
0.5128447413,
-0.6279416084,
0.1742495447,
0.5801588893,
0.2152524292,
0.5725487471,
-0.4427089393,
-0.3074668944,
0.1051855236,
0.3488313258,
0.141420424,
-0.426528424,
-0.1204705536,
0.1376119405,
0.508620441,
-0.1313382238,
0.1383515149,
-0.9137310386,
0.0158444326,
0.8513808846,
0.5251243711,
0.2489967644,
0.1506275386,
-0.2342878431,
-0.0216520149,
-0.639569819,
0.5218997598,
0.7770683765,
0.3761333823,
-0.587133944,
0.7982932329,
-0.2863439322,
0.4761059582,
-0.0199070107,
-0.1709249318,
0.2381157428,
-0.5454181433,
0.118708916,
0.0897714049,
0.3012545705,
0.6842726469,
0.1478483677,
0.2004452795,
-0.5110845566,
0.4941155314,
0.0666640177,
-0.6267525554,
-0.124447912,
-0.2710041404,
-0.4257057607,
-0.0198785253,
0.0594064705,
-1.0177582502,
-0.6834870577,
-0.159322232,
0.2177973986,
0.0053092558,
-0.0627730489,
0.0271668471,
-0.3830165565,
0.2938470244,
0.4287865162,
-1.1394846439,
0.9282183647,
0.6423898339,
1.0732526779,
0.0030397424,
-0.2260898054,
-0.0158980582,
-0.28598997,
-0.098529689,
0.7336267233,
-0.7067396045,
-0.6503393054,
0.0510396175,
-0.3966389,
-0.2914604545,
-0.927087605,
-0.0930205211,
-0.2709236443,
-0.0147670079,
-0.3877430558,
-0.3550499678,
-0.0069030975,
0.0700532794,
-0.823433578,
1.0218962431,
0.4878150225,
-0.8212391138,
0.5798320174,
-0.7511627078,
-0.5962572098,
0.1329502314,
-0.1652844399,
-0.3082024157,
0.262732774,
0.4346701503,
-0.0776609778,
-0.3306222856,
0.0952745229,
-0.6369105577,
-0.6532247066,
-0.2468533069,
-0.4457112849,
0.9421412349,
0.0222300906,
-0.5983950496,
0.0375406407,
-0.7962815762,
-0.6149905324,
0.2709080577,
-0.1103833541,
-0.3589392602,
0.3078821301,
0.2540576458,
0.0491550416,
0.3203261793,
-0.7418272495,
0.1313732266,
-0.1811688244,
0.3422644734,
0.8056439161,
-0.3748136461,
0.4132200181,
-0.3561224639,
0.8141214848,
0.0824149251,
0.5379726887,
0.0458690412,
-0.5606873631,
-0.8063892722,
-0.4085563719,
0.526237607,
0.7079054713,
-0.8778584599,
0.0042670514,
-0.2082197219,
-0.1627514809,
-0.9653220773,
-0.0184812732,
-0.1552675366,
0.3775989711,
0.2050527781,
-0.6460775733,
-0.3598551452,
-0.9916193485,
0.1029815078,
0.0711278394,
0.0081653902,
0.7525160313,
0.5173751116,
-0.2154728025,
1.1209210157,
-0.4374565184,
-0.224375546,
-0.4496389925,
-0.0862913504,
-0.0642645434,
0.2203964442,
0.3166882396,
-0.7196508646,
-0.2191965729,
-0.377243042,
-0.3472584486,
-0.2865814269,
0.0426655039,
0.2760642171,
0.0842094347,
0.0782909542,
-0.2018216997,
1.000539422,
0.7696906328,
-0.7852647305,
0.2977729142,
-0.184498474,
0.1823527068,
-0.6569936275,
-0.2501129508,
0.5098748207,
-0.2474673688,
-0.3366425633,
-0.1763140261,
-0.2940911651,
-0.2715041935,
-0.4038656056,
0.2133190185,
-0.1679072976,
-0.6781476736,
0.0122239087,
0.1615005732,
0.0035765418,
0.1271782219,
-0.0151877664,
1.064170599,
0.5886178017,
-0.3199810386,
0.2012623101,
-0.0227913242,
-0.6812515259,
0.3842045367,
-0.9600397944,
-0.306514442,
0.0998633727,
-0.2964212894,
-0.632267952,
-0.1918051392,
0.2614193261,
-0.2372386903,
-0.0737687796,
0.1352161318,
-0.3796380162,
-0.2269845307,
-0.2695742548,
0.9478590488,
0.5102382898,
-0.3381687403,
0.3193825781,
0.9923046827,
-0.3351757526,
-0.28486377,
-0.4222730696,
0.2929507792,
-0.3259298801,
-0.9676558375,
0.3829114735,
0.1894670725,
-0.7003891468,
0.0923877731,
0.2089927197,
-0.4817687273,
0.5464110374,
0.1661073864,
0.5782464743,
-0.2490334809,
-0.2840030193,
-0.0306008961,
0.1148738414,
0.0849302858,
0.2013409287,
0.4518308938,
-0.2052543163,
-0.4926201403,
-0.1580438465,
0.5172482133,
0.5575815439,
-0.3182353973,
0.4726234078,
0.1870354712,
-0.3097281456,
0.0977137834,
-0.3040875494,
-0.0206457525,
-0.4528482854,
0.050907027,
-0.1276250184,
-0.9482017159,
0.6952109933,
-0.106948331,
-0.2354172915,
0.3407298625,
0.3795039654,
-0.0998855829,
1.0388498306,
1.1576030254,
-0.0771109462,
0.6061578393,
-0.2682358325,
0.4514749646,
-0.5420422554,
-0.3061980605,
-0.4712139368,
-0.51648736,
-0.7190132141,
-0.4626624286,
0.5092010498,
0.2017632127,
-0.0915289819,
-0.1360280961,
-0.2001333833,
0.5023976564,
0.97439605,
0.1441420168,
0.3953044116,
-0.064241372,
0.1272189468,
-0.1240369901,
-0.97450459,
-0.5193924308,
0.9298543334,
0.46917364,
0.6790873408,
-0.1391535997,
0.7601866722,
0.8712924123,
0.0243515242,
-0.7481933236,
0.2093351781,
-0.3438645601,
-0.4783181548,
-0.319034785,
-0.4593195319,
-0.7851344347,
0.1317778528,
-0.1419357806,
-0.7881188989,
0.6290545464,
0.0884936005,
-0.3889120817,
0.4016500413,
-0.5976206064,
0.9891919494,
-0.3131141663,
-0.4060784876,
-0.2619457841,
-0.4544639587,
0.6104160547,
0.0068058586,
0.5547731519,
-0.4577064514,
0.1079089716,
0.377314508,
-0.5800567269,
0.8462976217,
-0.1982309073,
0.2624636292,
0.3696795106,
-0.2752564549,
-0.0599570423,
-0.2749902308,
0.2986005843,
0.6481292844,
-0.0191101022,
-0.7803823352,
-0.1465918124,
0.2647282481,
-0.9052085876,
-0.4968093038,
-0.2967876196,
-0.5411877632,
-0.0526315682,
-0.0482934751,
0.2557393909,
0.6197406054,
-0.1324467361,
0.2139552534,
0.3670277894,
-0.104177691,
0.5455598235,
-0.2172216326,
0.0105902813,
-0.3002541065,
1.0304220915,
0.2449388653,
0.1591740549,
-0.0901219174,
0.061993584,
-0.181337148,
-0.2585459948,
-0.6113276482,
0.00289605,
-0.4456834197,
0.1037951782,
-0.0932104364,
-0.0418773815,
-0.4871027172,
-0.4184334874,
-0.5322657824,
-0.4942348301,
-0.2294694632,
0.0789307579,
-0.0979447961,
1.0931010246,
-0.304689467,
0.1862330139,
-0.5816245675,
0.4595550597,
0.2786461413,
0.3465024233,
0.188180849,
-0.0766085312,
-0.6325370073,
0.2059281617,
-0.3708355725,
-0.4700825214,
0.2761427462,
-0.069020085,
0.318457216,
0.252070725,
0.3443250358,
0.8083176017,
-0.2389311194,
1.0393896103,
0.2991127968,
-1.2453383207,
0.2722414732,
-0.1928241253,
0.479616046,
0.5187471509,
0.1795773804,
-0.3484494984,
-0.49397856,
-0.4573616385,
-1.3864927292,
0.4481951296,
0.1381925046,
0.0176385492,
0.1841222644,
-0.432685554,
0.0348957479,
0.1758172363,
-0.5942539573,
-0.2811302245,
-0.408727169,
-0.202088505,
0.2275019735,
-0.1906474829,
-0.1269601285,
-0.4629573524,
0.14674218,
0.0513796173,
0.2492734045,
0.2170208395,
-0.1763055623,
0.0731011778,
-0.0836005807,
0.829577446,
0.9769743681,
0.0377190262,
-0.0131094791,
-0.1912799329,
-0.5465989709,
0.1265548319,
0.189571619,
-0.481959641,
-0.0790153518,
0.4896478355,
0.9084818363,
0.0374886692,
-0.6303915977,
0.5064938664,
-0.4092416167,
-0.4047281444,
-0.1432127804,
0.0433560424,
-0.1042986363,
0.5678568482,
0.3986651301,
0.2194266766,
0.1830489337,
-0.4966411293,
-0.0290812235,
0.2897019982,
-0.3475354016,
-0.1507471204,
0.8420487046,
0.6495052576,
-0.6712487936,
0.7840266824,
-0.0645029694,
-0.5850506425,
1.0640199184,
0.1942151934,
0.9387057424,
0.2338894308,
0.343090415,
-0.2815634608,
0.687097609,
0.15749906,
0.2036675513,
-0.4637771547,
-0.7702074051,
-0.1175733581,
-0.1988701671,
-0.5556787848,
-0.4019365907,
-0.8200351,
0.0697675645,
-0.4944566786,
-0.4102338254,
-0.1702964008,
-0.0787233934,
-0.9153445959,
0.1281245947,
0.6202782393,
0.8584028482,
-0.9453913569,
0.6201890111,
0.2933210731,
-0.2012191415,
-0.4092454016,
0.0997456685,
0.0867802575,
-0.7792004347,
0.7255496383,
0.1903038919,
-0.4891226292,
-0.2852509022,
-0.2633753717,
-0.8414496779,
0.9056737423,
0.2134533525,
-0.4716336131,
-0.0563480556,
0.5460745692,
0.2595632672,
-0.5776200294,
0.210678041,
0.5659475923,
0.26435256,
0.0175144672,
-0.9667413235,
-0.4052144289,
-0.2724736929,
0.1454131007,
-0.0256758742,
-0.6337439418,
0.8645130992,
-0.4894179702,
-0.3888169527,
-0.1821625978,
0.1319526583,
0.1085023358,
1.0621529818,
0.4555392861,
0.6513536572,
0.5579869151,
-0.3131304383,
1.1297689676,
-0.5998265743,
0.4282829762,
0.7519423962,
-0.4652574658,
0.552687943,
0.1633554548,
-0.3837652504,
0.3180855811,
0.7670164108,
-0.2056885511,
0.5379719734,
0.1439374685,
-0.3822264671,
-0.1764993519,
-0.3847340941,
-0.1975530237,
0.795689702,
0.2373073101,
-0.13516666,
-0.2073913962,
-0.1289404333,
-0.3566981256,
0.1199453026,
-0.5980607271,
0.6546717286,
-0.106629692,
-0.1452306509,
0.2814430892,
0.0932721198,
0.8253861666,
-0.2557338178,
-0.1229604483,
-0.6066186428,
0.078492254,
-0.1012620479,
-0.5865468979,
0.5820826888,
0.206015572,
-0.3747197688,
0.0238447413,
0.6976607442,
-0.0428712517,
-0.8074421287,
0.4363869131,
0.5955834389,
-0.109031409,
0.1744481623,
-0.6647425294,
0.2542527616,
-0.0933025107,
0.1553535759,
0.2373033613,
0.1750369221,
-0.1418623179,
0.6229723096,
0.308067441,
0.2380809486,
0.3342478871,
0.1005502567,
0.7967956662,
-0.6643653512,
-0.5653648376,
-0.9109085798,
0.6208378673,
-0.3433603346,
-0.577092886,
0.6884013414,
0.7170519829,
1.2151528597,
0.1750820428,
0.7346020937,
-0.0082901893,
0.1843513995,
-0.1242729053,
0.5000477433,
-0.6403117776,
0.1761792004,
-0.2403751612,
-0.7525987625,
-0.0785535425,
0.473869741,
-0.3415026069,
-0.1722226441,
0.1454209238,
0.5005223155,
-0.0296919215,
-0.0243465472,
0.6046892405,
-0.4343959093,
0.1504225433,
0.3620993495,
0.9457623363,
-0.2409830689,
0.093871817,
-0.6117089391,
-0.1464763731,
-0.2505345345,
-0.5192414522,
-0.5070420504,
-0.1564650983,
-0.4434515834,
-0.0500553772,
0.0215153024,
0.7080407739,
0.8687944412,
-0.5107079148,
-0.6498838663,
0.2573508918,
0.5683386326,
-0.2115937024,
-0.2757748365,
0.0020817406,
0.2996685803,
-0.8191455007,
0.073830761,
0.5221803188,
-0.0592780486,
-0.3847332597,
0.1020058319,
0.1138915569,
0.1726201773,
0.4419015348,
0.2474616915,
-0.6686934233,
0.0116361016,
-0.0754222348,
-0.0200735256,
0.3703761995,
1.0167400837,
-0.7100732327,
0.4517752528,
0.3066028357,
0.8973816037,
0.3524246216,
0.4113105834,
0.5006028414,
-0.3974312842,
0.0493480451,
0.2768567502,
0.3168863952,
0.5138665438,
-0.4348785877,
0.2955949306,
0.7166196704,
-0.4483875036,
-0.5854484439,
0.1740691364,
-0.5448258519,
-0.2996705174,
0.6452620625,
-0.0478556417,
-0.0798313469,
-0.1386621445,
0.1920638829,
-0.0004585638,
-0.5135303736,
1.2045321465,
0.6612288952,
-0.152777046,
-0.5177618861,
-0.514177382,
-0.077028811,
0.0447692424,
-0.7148506045,
-0.1379546374,
0.764467299,
-0.0988632441,
-0.1169620976,
0.5333378911,
0.0926869065,
0.3293842077,
0.4941209257,
0.110568516,
-0.1366966516,
-0.5222073197,
-0.5619947314,
0.1960576475,
0.1345553696,
-0.4908775687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05741v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05741v2
|
Efficiently Adapting Pretrained Language Models To New Languages
| 2023-11-09T20:59:08 | 2023-12-14T23:37:14 |
Zoltan Csaki, Pian Pawakapan, Urmish Thakker, Qiantong Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent large language models (LLM) exhibit sub-optimal performance on
low-resource languages, as the training data of these models is usually
dominated by English and other high-resource languages. Furthermore, it is
challenging to train models for low-resource languages, especially from
scratch, due to a lack of high quality training data. Adapting pretrained LLMs
reduces the need for data in the new language while also providing cross
lingual transfer capabilities. However, naively adapting to new languages leads
to catastrophic forgetting and poor tokenizer efficiency. In this work, we
study how to efficiently adapt any existing pretrained LLM to a new language
without running into these issues. In particular, we improve the encoding
efficiency of the tokenizer by adding new tokens from the target language and
study the data mixing recipe to mitigate forgetting. Our experiments on
adapting an English LLM to Hungarian and Thai show that our recipe can reach
better performance than open source models on the target language, with minimal
regressions on English.
|
[
-0.1707584262,
-0.2957167923,
0.2405057251,
0.2335582376,
-0.4195495248,
0.281794697,
-0.5389363766,
-0.2074086517,
0.2904095352,
0.5231935978,
-0.2769937515,
-0.4050902128,
-0.6327750087,
0.0712926686,
-0.0596915893,
1.0472655296,
-0.4546905458,
0.1757828146,
-0.1077873781,
-0.3773275912,
-0.6617789268,
-0.7732281089,
-0.768443644,
-0.3654187918,
0.4406370819,
0.437738061,
0.3677620292,
0.4805904329,
0.2393412739,
0.2628310621,
0.0293716826,
0.057687778,
-0.9924512506,
-0.0591023676,
-0.3066430688,
-0.7090751529,
-0.5112059712,
-0.1793078482,
0.7750833035,
0.8648238182,
0.0441504791,
0.1603177637,
0.0679340512,
0.5923546553,
-0.8273720145,
0.2231916189,
-1.0242142677,
0.0220300034,
-0.1239457503,
-0.4546921253,
-0.5149771571,
-0.2652867138,
-0.0967469066,
-0.9137538075,
0.1271859705,
-0.0336157754,
0.5500087142,
0.1585816294,
-0.0626665577,
-0.2651735246,
-0.8635157347,
0.8029248118,
-0.7409736514,
0.6564311981,
0.2892046571,
0.2726642191,
-0.2289081663,
-0.6627894044,
-0.3824280202,
-0.0712467432,
0.0811316371,
0.1158393323,
-0.2679342926,
-0.2239915282,
-0.0465202332,
0.2202708423,
-0.3695092797,
0.3492744863,
-0.1920556128,
-0.2342700213,
0.4171072245,
0.0539107583,
0.2697972953,
0.0521475114,
-0.148338452,
-0.1009067148,
-0.7550119758,
0.0497124903,
0.2975287735,
0.4846012294,
-0.0987178236,
0.3788079023,
0.1471340507,
0.4002110064,
0.1025771275,
-0.239662379,
0.304654628,
-0.6249403358,
0.0358057544,
0.0234301612,
0.3857076466,
0.2949620783,
0.4432770908,
-0.3178539276,
-0.465715766,
-0.1823842824,
-0.0136761684,
-0.7842857242,
-0.3336980641,
-0.2266319245,
-0.38052544,
0.1687294245,
-0.3943178058,
-0.2354265451,
-0.0901967362,
-0.1721744835,
0.5058653355,
-0.636885345,
-0.350105077,
0.2327263802,
-0.073952809,
0.2206479758,
0.4141929448,
-1.1376328468,
0.4378471673,
0.5253115296,
0.8608903289,
-0.2005837709,
-0.519123137,
-0.8689761758,
0.2130034417,
-0.6090845466,
0.5489448905,
-0.3506187797,
-0.3346702754,
-0.1315799356,
0.1111037135,
-0.3400382996,
-0.6719941497,
0.1988830864,
-0.5334271193,
0.0399521627,
-0.4300092757,
-0.5606665015,
0.1134014651,
0.0764271915,
-0.7332140803,
0.8355342746,
0.3857493103,
-0.6732562184,
0.6431407332,
-0.5202588439,
-0.6584427357,
-0.0867829695,
0.3464084268,
-0.0156573672,
0.5278649926,
0.3944678903,
0.3727385998,
-0.1331909299,
0.0349850506,
-0.1630682647,
-0.6071766019,
0.1222106814,
-0.2866668105,
0.6359423399,
0.1774695367,
0.2651993334,
0.0240697991,
-0.6532355547,
-0.1524234116,
0.1029248685,
-0.6530504823,
-0.5833367705,
-0.1655410379,
0.3585138619,
0.0451858751,
0.1583821028,
-0.2126142681,
0.2503557801,
-0.3946092427,
0.3755635917,
0.8954017162,
-0.1650639623,
0.6969649792,
-0.3385155201,
0.7132331133,
0.297426492,
-0.1722071618,
-0.3579945862,
0.0218816921,
-1.1942967176,
-0.2245054543,
0.5634756684,
0.5339428186,
-1.0775055885,
0.2595048249,
-0.6026868224,
-0.2455079854,
-0.7679365873,
0.568697989,
0.0689960644,
0.2146690488,
0.2211378664,
-0.6484084129,
-0.8221596479,
-0.4950085282,
-0.3943405747,
-0.1553881913,
0.0287634656,
0.1306378692,
0.4204976261,
-0.1775023788,
0.6305727959,
-0.0950302109,
0.0105588697,
-0.6426103115,
-0.1519137621,
0.2450798154,
0.585310638,
0.7715625763,
-0.3143178225,
-0.6488003731,
0.2690365016,
-0.4765073359,
-0.0091575459,
-0.2391733527,
-0.2029818445,
0.3240489662,
0.7067908049,
-0.347207278,
0.0545377545,
0.5844857097,
-0.1351474822,
0.4137868881,
-0.2247716337,
0.0428443924,
-1.3296093941,
0.1461313367,
-0.4098495841,
-0.1803160906,
-0.6896267533,
-0.2555452585,
-0.0203186516,
-0.1750722229,
-0.7744315267,
0.9764453173,
-0.6668132544,
-0.0669742003,
-0.2544951141,
-0.2234414071,
-0.1764380783,
0.4220652282,
-0.0095519759,
0.9461823702,
0.6449531317,
-0.6059734225,
0.0377402045,
0.0948692262,
-0.2786748707,
0.3202207386,
-0.3083645999,
0.097856693,
-0.365054667,
0.1512344629,
-0.6675223112,
-0.2309135199,
0.0921126083,
-0.2465185076,
0.5199987888,
-0.4028727114,
-0.3103464842,
-0.1232740879,
-0.266217798,
0.5779312849,
0.6564722657,
-0.6777501702,
0.767391324,
0.1281322986,
-0.2606881559,
-0.4326715767,
-0.6628308296,
0.1900378019,
-0.2294668257,
-0.2141915411,
0.2026900947,
-0.1299699545,
0.0580242909,
0.15334934,
-0.1262235343,
-0.1672061086,
0.3023117781,
-0.1240225285,
0.0582466274,
-0.5125665069,
-0.099063538,
-0.1569111049,
-0.359506458,
-0.1674434692,
-0.6294465661,
0.6644980907,
0.2029388547,
-0.3280311227,
-0.3940786719,
0.2579297423,
0.7436969876,
-0.1863046288,
0.8388674259,
0.7125778794,
-0.4060937464,
-0.260902822,
-0.5215248466,
0.0073007224,
-0.4671057165,
0.7761045098,
-0.4668088257,
-0.929831326,
0.6005761623,
-0.101241596,
0.1476171613,
0.0370765068,
0.5906566978,
0.1087333858,
0.6125461459,
0.9773068428,
-0.4909129739,
0.769693017,
0.0794328526,
0.2547523081,
-0.6993182898,
0.1674063951,
-0.2428862303,
-0.2295054644,
-0.6120940447,
-0.706446588,
0.057368964,
0.257891953,
0.0275832247,
0.4468189478,
0.0767361671,
0.6304812431,
0.4981672466,
-0.1151817739,
0.2575454414,
0.2191876024,
-0.0934104398,
-0.1002766117,
-1.2051483393,
-0.3275334835,
1.4164090157,
0.2428402603,
0.9155814648,
-0.0895078629,
0.8984246254,
-0.2218090743,
0.4466104209,
-0.5627311468,
0.2709171176,
-0.4400467277,
-0.2377423495,
0.005515357,
-0.56302917,
-0.8400492668,
0.1159563512,
-0.2115249634,
-0.511187613,
-0.0467749536,
0.2957827151,
-0.1704426408,
0.5315650105,
-0.8048121333,
0.7617222667,
-0.3998882473,
-0.3215098083,
-0.019887479,
-0.0406249538,
0.2675116062,
-0.5584602952,
0.3434483707,
-0.0871253982,
-0.0149247954,
0.8666217923,
-0.2689681351,
0.7414491177,
-0.2453278899,
-0.0011383212,
0.1420345157,
-0.047285825,
0.5179435611,
-0.1378798336,
-0.271777451,
0.1384112686,
-0.1203766912,
-0.8404490352,
-0.70603019,
0.5404615998,
-0.863543272,
-0.6742523313,
0.0158454552,
-0.6521520019,
-0.2589556277,
0.2551268041,
0.3393238187,
-0.2038384229,
-0.4679989219,
-0.0619461276,
0.2970151603,
-0.4266294837,
0.4238694906,
0.5209571719,
-0.2546388507,
-0.4955001473,
0.9375200868,
0.3647644222,
0.4344931841,
0.328224957,
0.1218969375,
-0.0172170047,
-0.8121562004,
-0.4363016486,
0.1426050365,
-0.7624199986,
0.0476313159,
-0.5340659022,
-0.1682742983,
-0.3914724588,
-0.3843100965,
-0.6785485744,
-0.4612544775,
-0.2958406806,
0.0403348505,
0.4156501889,
0.4651111364,
-0.093206197,
0.3483397961,
-0.7189126611,
-0.0440645665,
0.2117166221,
0.4617924392,
0.1284811199,
-0.7741767168,
-0.5922678709,
-0.0916947052,
0.1585427076,
-0.4124012291,
0.3050768077,
0.3218937516,
0.6995936632,
0.0712242797,
-0.104361102,
0.9906270504,
-0.6342353225,
0.4193429649,
0.3173032701,
-0.9991294146,
0.400999397,
-0.030233467,
0.5110045075,
0.6772627234,
0.3828458786,
-0.7132856846,
-0.1244371086,
-0.1305696368,
-0.7699175477,
0.6882155538,
-0.0220949911,
0.423093915,
0.1470311731,
0.5423101783,
0.447367996,
0.0733588412,
-0.8649017811,
-0.0309195146,
-0.3056362569,
-0.2383638322,
-0.5264129639,
-0.2700456977,
0.2116775513,
-0.5498737097,
0.7215911746,
-0.245701015,
0.088776052,
-0.3240405917,
-0.4517171681,
-0.2004567534,
0.1788725704,
0.0456805788,
0.4576960802,
0.07344421,
0.2570545375,
0.7990543246,
-0.5303452015,
0.5473610759,
-0.0299599506,
-0.0712399632,
0.0111734448,
0.7095479369,
0.9442495704,
0.5714655519,
-0.6094416976,
0.4143175483,
-0.052736599,
-0.0551815033,
-0.0325127617,
0.3490022421,
0.4252096713,
0.1112137809,
0.2236489952,
0.1047701463,
-0.4720808566,
-0.5377114415,
0.1504041404,
0.322787255,
-0.0711141005,
-0.5257386565,
0.5567824244,
0.1354803294,
-0.2819518745,
0.5705830455,
-0.1031809822,
-0.6092522144,
0.2065927386,
0.8362051845,
0.7306960821,
-0.39809677,
-0.1948795617,
0.3633728325,
0.4361715019,
-0.1265611649,
0.162576884,
0.0737742931,
-0.8816114068,
-0.6164115071,
-0.6440834403,
-0.1884876937,
0.1763592511,
-0.5963072777,
0.4080032408,
-0.632984519,
-0.0766288415,
-0.2471628934,
-0.1454760283,
-1.0381635427,
-0.1419638544,
0.0256272294,
1.0104720592,
-1.1653470993,
0.9821921587,
0.7266789675,
-0.1350183338,
-0.6132641435,
-0.0709805489,
-0.3585645854,
-1.0264357328,
0.4460051358,
-0.0325894617,
0.1079615206,
0.0480595157,
-0.2204982191,
-1.1171070337,
0.7878966331,
0.8952155113,
-0.5928619504,
-0.0464748368,
0.274414897,
0.4964880645,
-0.2782913148,
-0.0116240643,
0.6111910343,
0.3095317185,
0.0694097653,
-0.8909046054,
-0.0441042408,
-0.3713902235,
0.1356113255,
0.1190061942,
-0.5144159794,
0.864652276,
-0.2562193573,
-0.2496316582,
-0.0255886205,
0.6158054471,
0.0141985305,
0.0967690498,
0.4062694907,
0.5327174664,
0.8000087738,
0.0727795437,
0.6921203732,
-0.3423929214,
0.0206357613,
1.2402541637,
-0.5014411211,
0.8396559954,
0.6972721219,
-0.0469130762,
0.1980215758,
0.6047435403,
0.119143866,
0.5206626058,
0.1841940731,
-0.2194442749,
-0.3117873371,
0.0042968574,
-0.3495779335,
0.5404199958,
0.0204999484,
-0.2309495956,
-0.2734692395,
0.2814865708,
0.1718445122,
-0.0599258505,
-0.2730310559,
0.7786394954,
-0.0987715647,
-0.5434942842,
1.0961022377,
0.037455529,
0.686920166,
-0.5187293887,
0.2114145607,
-0.5343109369,
0.138809219,
-0.05541474,
-0.1053890586,
0.2709349692,
0.2113462389,
-0.2121313661,
-0.22684066,
0.4512173235,
-0.4833698273,
-0.7875310183,
0.3596351147,
0.7594517469,
0.1694617569,
0.3464849591,
-0.5352672935,
0.2968881726,
0.0092235105,
-0.1273408532,
0.4900537133,
0.6493136883,
-0.1372471005,
0.6360706687,
0.863168478,
0.4395873845,
0.1489193887,
-0.0625219718,
0.9854751825,
-0.7462684512,
-0.6569965482,
-0.764331758,
0.2312907428,
0.3701584041,
-0.2189506143,
0.7511231303,
0.6900190711,
1.2091459036,
-0.1561511904,
0.9040717483,
0.3160772622,
0.1008923352,
-0.7656036615,
0.8811236024,
-0.5885775685,
0.3779424131,
-0.2176950574,
-0.972240448,
-0.2566736937,
0.5784453154,
-0.2073191255,
0.1172573864,
0.5768353343,
0.8064979315,
-0.2499924898,
-0.3140008152,
0.422922641,
0.3350196481,
0.2360327542,
0.9336643815,
0.8415421844,
-0.3310698867,
0.3547245264,
-0.1192548573,
-0.1279390901,
-0.2266689241,
-1.061650157,
-1.0632809401,
-0.3618543446,
-0.1362130195,
-0.1565075666,
0.2191341966,
1.0082113743,
0.8922381997,
-0.9464073181,
-0.3340820372,
-0.0917127952,
0.2105532438,
-0.1331317723,
-0.1018900424,
0.2885671556,
-0.5490915179,
-0.6795578599,
0.4574115276,
0.2597830296,
0.2831656933,
-0.0373879969,
-0.3205896914,
-0.0034797213,
0.0636233017,
0.579298079,
0.1407453716,
-0.4218485653,
-0.2588467002,
-0.0473803133,
0.0538013242,
0.2324561775,
1.0946958065,
-0.7046298981,
0.4898940623,
0.0803931803,
0.9432125092,
0.5999844074,
-0.4737448394,
0.7694423795,
-0.6492490172,
0.5044852495,
0.1198045313,
0.4238836467,
0.6821602583,
-0.1166440621,
0.2882817984,
0.2361409962,
0.0515357964,
-0.8522358537,
0.0185090303,
-0.4664380252,
-0.3150044084,
0.8979851007,
-0.2261570543,
-0.4259768724,
-0.0947658718,
-0.046081569,
0.4634773135,
0.0149319358,
0.637717545,
0.8219484687,
0.1866451651,
-0.0395407379,
-0.3544908762,
0.4347757101,
0.5521027446,
-0.7277579308,
0.3677845001,
0.1042114794,
0.6671796441,
-0.3611251712,
0.884935379,
-0.0074252528,
0.3336077034,
0.1724945307,
0.0115145724,
-0.0159676168,
-0.2706281841,
-0.4147204757,
-0.1425002515,
0.4771416187,
-0.0892785192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05720v1
|
Long-Horizon Dialogue Understanding for Role Identification in the Game of Avalon with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-09T20:04:08 | 2023-11-09T20:04:08 |
Simon Stepputtis, Joseph Campbell, Yaqi Xie, Zhengyang Qi, Wenxin Sharon Zhang, Ruiyi Wang, Sanketh Rangreji, Michael Lewis, Katia Sycara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Deception and persuasion play a critical role in long-horizon dialogues
between multiple parties, especially when the interests, goals, and motivations
of the participants are not aligned. Such complex tasks pose challenges for
current Large Language Models (LLM) as deception and persuasion can easily
mislead them, especially in long-horizon multi-party dialogues. To this end, we
explore the game of Avalon: The Resistance, a social deduction game in which
players must determine each other's hidden identities to complete their team's
objective. We introduce an online testbed and a dataset containing 20 carefully
collected and labeled games among human players that exhibit long-horizon
deception in a cooperative-competitive setting. We discuss the capabilities of
LLMs to utilize deceptive long-horizon conversations between six human players
to determine each player's goal and motivation. Particularly, we discuss the
multimodal integration of the chat between the players and the game's state
that grounds the conversation, providing further insights into the true player
identities. We find that even current state-of-the-art LLMs do not reach human
performance, making our dataset a compelling benchmark to investigate the
decision-making and language-processing capabilities of LLMs. Our dataset and
online testbed can be found at our project website:
https://sstepput.github.io/Avalon-NLU/
|
[
-0.3228530288,
-0.7008551359,
0.8253416419,
0.3782732189,
0.1475459188,
0.4208186567,
-0.2324259877,
-0.7052254677,
0.2623327971,
0.8325801492,
-0.9669305086,
-0.5245549083,
-0.5137794018,
0.039701581,
-0.0906486511,
0.7160791755,
-0.117263563,
-0.2341463715,
-0.3853286803,
-0.4677272141,
-0.5364587903,
-0.4743300974,
-1.0811970234,
-0.4089459777,
0.7929630876,
0.2488148808,
0.4466733634,
0.5002985001,
0.3534438908,
0.4125881195,
0.2020613402,
0.0228129011,
-0.8960338235,
0.5877000093,
-0.3281490505,
-0.6506510377,
-0.205076769,
-0.031305179,
0.6135968566,
0.454046905,
0.1557377726,
0.2530523539,
0.2617976367,
0.5342879891,
-0.5314785838,
0.6167122722,
-0.4390765131,
0.0476924665,
-0.4398545623,
0.0056683421,
-0.6067060828,
0.1432297379,
0.06490089,
-0.9691909552,
-0.0686359107,
-0.0377261415,
0.685874939,
0.2835780978,
-0.4972055554,
-0.4988646209,
-1.0072038174,
1.0404280424,
-0.299513638,
0.097638987,
0.5238038301,
0.3983703554,
-0.4042218626,
-0.5433698297,
-0.4414362013,
-0.2651007771,
0.2769185007,
0.3837451935,
-0.2261369228,
0.3711149096,
0.2846580446,
0.016434975,
-0.4645967782,
0.4746040404,
-0.3376156986,
-0.2492249012,
0.7349157929,
0.247889474,
0.0488313362,
0.1880226731,
-0.4779950082,
-0.1212261617,
-0.5022234321,
0.251871556,
0.4056185186,
0.1537899673,
-0.1428686678,
0.3231000304,
0.0172172114,
0.4094027281,
-0.0856148601,
-0.2178780735,
0.0293579455,
0.1152028441,
-0.1445440948,
0.1412375569,
0.6524752378,
0.5415467024,
0.1442167014,
-0.030786613,
-0.1057751402,
0.5966650844,
-0.1168761551,
-0.6528294683,
0.1766439527,
0.2569304705,
-0.6570279598,
-0.2684748471,
-0.0962063447,
-0.6689344645,
-0.5308513641,
-0.1464375854,
0.4751897156,
-0.1304011792,
-0.2444419712,
0.1370870173,
-0.3024490476,
0.5613372922,
0.3645225763,
-0.5027109981,
0.4916741848,
0.8781033754,
0.5454817414,
-0.3679493964,
-0.3989292383,
-0.7239652276,
0.3263670802,
-0.353341341,
0.2679205239,
-0.5848529339,
-0.2864247561,
-0.0405944735,
0.0544290654,
-0.0851088762,
-0.2014562041,
0.6947835684,
-0.3410138488,
0.3407154679,
-0.440941453,
-0.5248095989,
0.0069839177,
0.4580978453,
-0.6945109367,
0.6186622977,
-0.2573336959,
-0.5643786788,
0.0226293262,
-1.0089336634,
-0.162167117,
0.2331083417,
-0.4149481654,
-0.1341485381,
0.0625150055,
0.0208175071,
0.2783726752,
-0.3580803275,
0.0563809276,
-0.4623224139,
-0.5289644003,
0.5989878178,
-0.6616070271,
0.8568210602,
0.2145178914,
-0.283257246,
-0.027463736,
-0.5593771935,
-0.3634696007,
0.1943171769,
0.1066002101,
-0.6273937225,
0.3145953715,
-0.4192261398,
0.1136448532,
0.0637193248,
-0.6639068723,
0.1124555543,
-0.2681302428,
0.5744985938,
0.8301885724,
0.1429865956,
0.3103328645,
-0.4814347625,
0.6804455519,
-0.0443381928,
0.4600331783,
-0.2255381346,
-0.5476353168,
-0.7125474215,
-0.4111771286,
0.28030321,
0.595287919,
-0.8412495255,
0.0695466772,
-0.1857789457,
-0.1218635738,
-0.6416357756,
-0.1597771943,
0.2443511486,
0.265486896,
0.0774902627,
-0.2369133085,
-0.3936759233,
-0.9462215304,
-0.2045627832,
-0.4775706828,
-0.0466792658,
0.4022704959,
0.4358289242,
-0.3774598539,
0.9349489212,
-0.3732048273,
-0.558432281,
-0.2373916209,
0.2433167845,
0.0111079309,
0.1394106001,
0.2924644351,
-0.8293306231,
-0.3094276488,
-0.3380351663,
-0.6628383398,
-0.0175803881,
-0.4132707119,
0.027550118,
0.0192214493,
0.6169757843,
-0.7209400535,
0.4887835085,
0.9330711961,
-0.1823805869,
0.2002078444,
-0.0646698549,
0.2425114512,
-1.1498161554,
-0.0362889096,
0.0287145413,
-0.1196128502,
-0.5484397411,
0.366890043,
-0.5618111491,
-0.0619302355,
-0.3010817766,
0.4532190859,
-0.5697564483,
-0.0149495676,
-0.0989218429,
0.2142203748,
0.0492923781,
0.4558564723,
0.1225181818,
0.542548418,
0.5699102879,
-0.5106421709,
0.4390398562,
0.1621512622,
-0.4046662748,
0.4563227594,
-0.6392654181,
0.3395684958,
-0.4528016746,
0.7038708925,
-1.241972208,
-0.1566814184,
0.4450947344,
-0.4203262031,
-0.1694604605,
-0.3748773634,
-0.1012579426,
-0.2085402608,
-0.168072626,
0.5015042424,
0.4075341821,
-0.1959755272,
0.8232877851,
0.3770258725,
-0.161196813,
-0.7689820528,
-0.8556892872,
0.357853055,
-0.6529955864,
-0.5918792486,
0.633898437,
-0.1866234392,
-0.619399786,
-0.4875127375,
0.2315628976,
-0.0604638532,
0.1949585527,
0.7652720213,
0.1915688813,
-0.0771039948,
0.1588514447,
-0.0798866302,
-0.1565797925,
0.3327200711,
-0.150822401,
0.3216151595,
-0.0285758208,
-0.524494648,
-0.3920027614,
0.6504967809,
0.7444341183,
-0.3909097314,
0.6462828517,
0.5403192043,
-0.1900198013,
-0.1912120432,
-0.5817136765,
-0.1655856967,
-0.4660302401,
0.3057587445,
-0.4154641926,
-1.0073474646,
0.8952071071,
-0.2850636542,
0.1879167706,
0.3659549356,
0.202301994,
-0.056442976,
0.937876761,
0.4681515098,
-0.1483509243,
0.0206039082,
0.011509683,
-0.1338838488,
-0.5380423665,
-0.2190266848,
-0.5702797174,
-0.5229986906,
-0.7153671384,
-0.5840142965,
0.2528901994,
-0.1702951789,
-0.1740288138,
-0.0251589566,
-0.249904722,
0.5895591378,
0.2360083461,
0.0417561382,
0.3307137489,
-0.2476480752,
0.1493383497,
-0.2951677442,
-0.3351742625,
-0.29760921,
0.8149867058,
0.8330445886,
0.6421073079,
0.422606945,
0.9275510907,
0.4952768087,
0.0025584737,
-0.7934128642,
0.7583494186,
0.2243360281,
-0.5293587446,
-0.4554055929,
-0.4684837461,
-1.1593846083,
-0.0970541388,
-0.3562314212,
-0.6684106588,
0.1339263767,
-0.2284324318,
-0.5812268257,
-0.1225964651,
-0.3559638262,
0.8129208684,
-0.3183701336,
-0.4703866541,
-0.3142460883,
-0.7008695006,
0.2672996521,
0.0344950669,
0.4333834648,
0.0063256752,
-0.0448288694,
0.8080428243,
0.0004254195,
1.0829511881,
-0.2744986117,
-0.1634828895,
0.2663046122,
0.210610047,
0.6068613529,
0.138161853,
0.081543006,
0.1947202832,
-0.0938319787,
-0.1909794211,
-0.5123633742,
0.8378807902,
-0.7873046994,
-0.6979445219,
-0.5533317327,
-0.2995994389,
-0.1771149188,
0.0896998569,
0.1470441669,
0.2399751097,
-0.773786366,
0.3445882201,
0.8778845668,
-0.3752635419,
0.5225676894,
0.4430211484,
-0.3986377418,
-0.1072539613,
0.8254749179,
-0.1140725762,
0.3460277915,
0.4615148008,
0.0897926092,
-0.345252037,
-0.4186780453,
-0.2276973277,
0.1259927899,
-0.495710969,
0.1809718609,
-0.3038203716,
-0.0887808874,
-0.0231981762,
0.2082187682,
-0.3526471257,
-0.2599564791,
-0.1621514708,
0.0314389765,
0.0129346279,
0.725722611,
0.1538183838,
0.147725001,
-0.6538184881,
0.2546671033,
0.4829175174,
0.0694347396,
-0.2312091291,
-0.2998558581,
0.0790669918,
0.3109783828,
-0.2048793733,
-0.8899051547,
0.1188383549,
0.0940319672,
0.5300966501,
0.4305303395,
0.3428106904,
0.6971019506,
-0.2214631289,
0.9468704462,
0.0798896253,
-0.8030212522,
0.1640538424,
-0.4032661319,
0.0560219847,
0.6861774921,
0.3079064488,
-0.636947155,
-0.4311949313,
-0.4501703084,
-0.5679875612,
0.4638699293,
0.2203336507,
0.064463608,
0.0881623924,
0.1737574488,
0.058329381,
0.0601773262,
-0.8311182857,
-0.256377846,
0.1728322953,
-0.0797847584,
-0.2768989503,
-0.0790686384,
-0.4813775718,
0.1343096346,
0.2044751197,
-0.063861981,
0.253829658,
0.2038660496,
0.0177015811,
-0.1020360738,
0.2924263179,
0.7909838557,
0.7543827891,
-0.0474932157,
-0.0565342754,
0.1011233553,
-0.1526053846,
0.0985216647,
0.1366509795,
0.082854867,
-0.0463243648,
0.5912491679,
0.9353345633,
0.0070199911,
-0.4158701599,
0.7132481933,
-0.3933986127,
-0.495857209,
-0.7490192056,
-0.042155128,
0.0463378392,
0.4413975775,
0.6256633997,
0.1251278371,
0.161026001,
-0.7819856405,
-0.0593353026,
0.6009283662,
-0.4713029861,
-0.0795365423,
0.5203371644,
0.4379376471,
-0.4544082582,
0.6877036095,
-0.0125726545,
-0.4050486684,
0.4642070234,
0.3297130764,
0.7997146845,
-0.2394085824,
0.5004717708,
-0.1640758961,
0.2170799226,
-0.1179911196,
-0.2501292825,
-0.0772241503,
-0.6793062091,
-0.9961082339,
-0.2738515735,
-0.3639727235,
0.3819417655,
-0.7814559937,
0.0307364762,
-0.2746519148,
-0.3560519814,
0.018265795,
0.0870105177,
-0.5008488297,
-0.2880293727,
0.4773296416,
0.7899588943,
-0.9011825323,
0.6701381207,
0.1360464394,
-0.1397973299,
-0.513446033,
0.1032651514,
-0.0434421003,
-0.6725082994,
0.6645109653,
0.2763527036,
-0.222377941,
-0.0901063085,
-0.6124796271,
-0.3163306713,
1.1901173592,
0.5216228962,
-0.787714839,
-0.3351815343,
0.471773833,
0.5153215528,
-0.5517083406,
0.365242064,
0.1740983725,
0.6167016625,
0.3260846436,
-0.7989110351,
-0.1210974976,
0.230255425,
-0.1110707372,
0.0419874489,
-0.9124154449,
0.5980476141,
0.0345795006,
-0.2229950577,
0.0633702129,
0.8018395901,
0.3391343951,
0.4703114629,
0.7838500142,
0.1939156801,
0.7383103371,
-0.0661983937,
0.5896574259,
-0.1066685021,
0.0640932471,
0.7371434569,
-0.6493119001,
0.6676267385,
0.5542210937,
0.1726570278,
0.7522143126,
0.2860738039,
0.2644045651,
0.3221719563,
0.4920475483,
-0.31754601,
-0.4664793313,
-0.0157285836,
-0.2187219709,
0.8438298702,
0.5890312195,
-0.3248798847,
-0.0173923578,
0.1526281983,
-0.1049003825,
0.1650658101,
-0.298479408,
0.7964115739,
0.1211500168,
-0.9505813122,
0.3346737027,
0.1423037946,
0.5646467805,
-0.8150724173,
-0.4177469313,
-0.1388963908,
0.4078722298,
0.0539574549,
-0.7136140466,
-0.0358091965,
-0.4107868075,
-0.065074794,
-0.3280038834,
0.5312211514,
-0.5354362726,
-0.2657842338,
0.5183570981,
0.28706339,
0.1949976236,
-0.1134695262,
-1.0078654289,
0.7250443697,
0.0692824274,
0.0416549928,
0.4944288731,
0.3627889752,
-0.238710925,
0.7446585298,
0.5215028524,
-0.0647334009,
-0.3958468437,
0.0298053678,
0.573048532,
-0.3579252958,
-0.569182992,
-0.9788169265,
0.3574510515,
-0.3087643385,
-0.1991270185,
0.8543958664,
0.4761028588,
0.5249729753,
0.0843356922,
0.6685215235,
0.3490353823,
0.4426246285,
-0.4802162051,
0.6026331782,
-0.1596476734,
0.2773856819,
-0.3430653214,
-0.90304178,
-0.0019468524,
0.62509197,
-0.0161019191,
-0.188248381,
0.3166934252,
0.7413854003,
0.0451184437,
0.0834034085,
0.2515715659,
0.3234484196,
0.4478345215,
1.0434657335,
1.1615363359,
-0.3670329154,
0.4926480055,
0.3678057492,
-0.4768715203,
0.0549094118,
-0.9496912956,
-1.0590919256,
-0.7436249852,
-0.3426130712,
-0.5454090238,
0.4009517133,
1.0459172726,
0.3973246813,
-0.3564407527,
-0.5516400933,
0.0009981469,
-0.0228657015,
-0.4247772396,
-0.2280724347,
0.1319288313,
0.2476616502,
-0.7121744752,
0.674443841,
0.13504228,
-0.2333637625,
-0.6860140562,
-0.4433857799,
0.0489520282,
0.2806511521,
0.5792181492,
0.5690582395,
-0.7781143785,
-0.3146961927,
0.0668927059,
0.0962384716,
-0.2653387189,
0.7676606774,
-0.717861414,
0.3223796785,
0.005393201,
0.5667957067,
0.7325640917,
0.1024212986,
0.7211585045,
-0.5396611094,
0.1862119287,
0.3254076838,
-0.0893312544,
0.194011569,
-0.2200944424,
0.1405121535,
0.1458648294,
-0.7011349797,
-0.7665183544,
0.3404662311,
-0.9919834137,
-0.1979422718,
1.1891194582,
-0.1647619456,
-0.2462857217,
-0.3880268633,
-0.3029711545,
-0.0808175951,
-0.4524487555,
0.6204828024,
0.9110329747,
0.0344465561,
-0.2065619677,
-0.3447830677,
0.7465496659,
0.1307547241,
-0.3180107772,
0.2420850992,
0.6172882318,
0.0314293467,
0.2975675464,
0.7827928662,
0.1040522903,
-0.1005425006,
-0.1743867993,
-0.2847594619,
-0.1258431077,
-0.411398977,
-0.0599905327,
0.2524525225,
0.0736457184,
-0.3981077969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05608v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05608v2
|
FigStep: Jailbreaking Large Vision-language Models via Typographic Visual Prompts
| 2023-11-09T18:59:11 | 2023-12-13T17:54:16 |
Yichen Gong, Delong Ran, Jinyuan Liu, Conglei Wang, Tianshuo Cong, Anyu Wang, Sisi Duan, Xiaoyun Wang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Ensuring the safety of artificial intelligence-generated content (AIGC) is a
longstanding topic in the artificial intelligence (AI) community, and the
safety concerns associated with Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely
investigated. Recently, large vision-language models (VLMs) represent an
unprecedented revolution, as they are built upon LLMs but can incorporate
additional modalities (e.g., images). However, the safety of VLMs lacks
systematic evaluation, and there may be an overconfidence in the safety
guarantees provided by their underlying LLMs. In this paper, to demonstrate
that introducing additional modality modules leads to unforeseen AI safety
issues, we propose FigStep, a straightforward yet effective jailbreaking
algorithm against VLMs. Instead of feeding textual harmful instructions
directly, FigStep converts the harmful content into images through typography
to bypass the safety alignment within the textual module of the VLMs, inducing
VLMs to output unsafe responses that violate common AI safety policies. In our
evaluation, we manually review 46,500 model responses generated by 3 families
of the promising open-source VLMs, i.e., LLaVA, MiniGPT4, and CogVLM (a total
of 6 VLMs). The experimental results show that FigStep can achieve an average
attack success rate of 82.50% on 500 harmful queries in 10 topics. Moreover, we
demonstrate that the methodology of FigStep can even jailbreak GPT-4V, which
already leverages an OCR detector to filter harmful queries. Above all, our
work reveals that VLMs are vulnerable to jailbreaking attacks, which highlights
the necessity of novel safety alignments between visual and textual modalities.
|
[
-0.322052747,
-0.7058828473,
0.580255568,
-0.1821386069,
-0.5228483081,
-0.0416269675,
0.046080213,
-0.6759095192,
-0.2518158853,
0.990190804,
-0.4489260614,
-0.6727736592,
-0.4738251269,
-0.0563344173,
-0.4187788963,
0.8129102588,
0.1155524626,
0.0044146194,
-0.147309497,
-0.0472752638,
-0.7903823853,
-0.5606568456,
-0.437455982,
0.3880579174,
0.496001631,
0.1765781194,
0.8051028252,
0.8741955757,
0.8060228229,
0.3819328547,
0.1419888884,
0.2291896194,
-0.2339576036,
0.236182496,
-0.0591251366,
-0.5076283813,
-0.0348841585,
-0.1403933913,
0.2332700044,
-0.0650541559,
0.1388812959,
-0.1055236831,
-0.2516924441,
0.5839358568,
-0.5807209611,
0.3172875345,
-0.8167079091,
-0.02762907,
-0.308437109,
-0.142611742,
-0.8759109378,
-0.0671104044,
-0.2585189641,
-0.5098827481,
-0.2298184633,
0.4485651255,
0.8234350085,
0.6253208518,
-0.1620181501,
-0.1734631807,
-0.312931627,
0.4764416218,
-0.7258269787,
0.0896489695,
0.5219211578,
0.4282275438,
-0.2328682393,
-0.4806894958,
-0.4625751674,
-0.5420255065,
-0.2013227195,
-0.172868669,
-0.1593648642,
0.2695260048,
0.5214126706,
-0.1636942923,
-0.651258111,
0.2202258855,
-0.3098535836,
-0.3206824362,
0.4873990715,
0.1864512116,
0.921026051,
-0.4344731569,
-0.4696338177,
-0.1432355642,
-0.8502685428,
-0.1422240585,
0.264723748,
0.2716087997,
-0.1605348438,
0.846446991,
0.1322330981,
0.773486197,
-0.2966998518,
-0.286999613,
0.081847176,
-0.2343002111,
-0.1376812309,
-0.0630263388,
1.0629540682,
0.4159016907,
0.4063801467,
-0.0212356225,
-0.1916777641,
-0.0442302339,
0.5982838869,
-0.7276547551,
-0.041087307,
0.1754584461,
-0.3022853136,
-0.5165500045,
0.1231350675,
-0.7565088868,
-0.8312058449,
-0.0014152164,
0.3897819519,
-0.8807083964,
0.1094988808,
-0.1629499942,
-0.0697090626,
0.4949327409,
0.620470047,
-0.782432735,
-0.1064483821,
0.939434588,
1.0066758394,
-0.2008006722,
-0.3149648905,
-0.7363190651,
0.2002798468,
-0.3033806384,
0.7035496235,
-0.3097272515,
-0.2837004364,
0.0776588097,
-0.0231008772,
0.0485387556,
-0.3129782975,
0.3038290143,
-0.5467617512,
0.0411457978,
-0.1799089462,
-0.3047228754,
-0.0120155178,
0.3586784899,
-0.946813643,
0.3949758112,
-0.0867005661,
-0.9968315959,
0.3185043633,
-0.5448194146,
-0.5161406398,
0.183623001,
-0.5480015874,
-0.5647181869,
0.0455232151,
0.3575878143,
0.2071706802,
-0.1056117415,
0.2912053466,
-0.3357175291,
-0.3016840219,
0.2472666502,
-0.6913744807,
1.0192402601,
0.293894738,
-0.6645324826,
0.391536206,
-0.3348422945,
-0.1674433947,
0.1929890066,
-0.1347928047,
-0.5121447444,
-0.0426774025,
0.0838710442,
0.314032644,
-0.0115713729,
-0.3557139337,
0.270235002,
-0.2562775314,
0.5049402714,
0.8841161728,
-0.1236809865,
0.144905284,
-0.1975750178,
0.3450142443,
-0.16228728,
0.3402556479,
-0.5731883049,
-0.552436173,
-0.6424629092,
-0.3567812145,
-0.0039767264,
0.506770432,
-1.3661893606,
0.2790009081,
-0.0319973603,
-0.4405828416,
-0.2372412533,
0.0004744852,
0.6653599739,
0.5915004611,
0.2460234612,
-0.1675447077,
-0.1363444179,
-0.7559800148,
-0.2496646494,
-0.6155741811,
0.1376437694,
0.2219580263,
0.5215685964,
-0.0496612899,
0.5237074494,
-0.2496542484,
-0.1542572826,
-0.1153466478,
0.0291396305,
-0.1019083932,
0.7171949744,
1.0021611452,
-0.8591792583,
-0.1094589606,
-0.2986719906,
-0.7550210953,
-0.0793696865,
-0.2838139236,
-0.1586690992,
0.5712274909,
0.6951467395,
-0.8791794777,
0.7140176892,
0.1781023741,
-0.822330296,
0.8497975469,
-0.0711681023,
0.3530772626,
-0.8948037028,
-0.0511622429,
0.1717927009,
-0.4718344212,
-0.5564175248,
0.7233622074,
0.0679333583,
-0.3961146772,
-0.8326231837,
0.469858259,
-0.3525119722,
0.0121642919,
-0.1650437266,
-0.1094064191,
-0.1876261979,
0.3439243734,
0.0576686449,
0.8084311485,
0.4235579073,
0.0162025262,
0.3003393114,
0.3929602206,
-0.3509534597,
0.4237093627,
-0.5454055667,
-0.048460979,
-0.0809587464,
-0.0597934909,
-0.9893502593,
-0.4985386431,
0.5370317101,
-0.3522644043,
0.4127570391,
-0.2548266947,
-0.6837862134,
-0.3476138115,
-0.4153788984,
0.3696610928,
0.5797100663,
-0.5919110775,
0.4508281946,
0.4604058564,
-0.1488702446,
-0.5499187112,
-0.7569349408,
0.4949655533,
-0.355160743,
-0.8254157901,
-0.1046656594,
-0.1664930135,
-0.4169864655,
-0.1148935258,
-0.0786256269,
-0.0328310281,
0.2733097374,
0.3974244297,
0.615242064,
-0.0934565067,
-0.1373331994,
-0.1760262251,
-0.2345803976,
0.1818050146,
-0.16908364,
0.7453964353,
-0.2747808397,
-0.8334557414,
-0.5137651563,
0.2432187051,
0.995326519,
-0.3612442017,
0.6336041689,
0.5223876834,
-0.3277501166,
-0.0095334994,
-0.4325833321,
0.0395531319,
-0.5393659472,
0.2175490856,
-0.0305045769,
-0.9585674405,
0.083784461,
0.2430862188,
0.2430856824,
0.3640681803,
0.5360488296,
-0.0248633604,
1.0567641258,
0.6140557528,
-0.2283128053,
0.7165529132,
0.0018223788,
0.0331204049,
-0.1911505312,
-0.3996376991,
-0.5046768785,
0.0170291811,
-0.5347033143,
-0.6318565011,
0.4432810843,
-0.2870427668,
-0.3092471361,
0.3589262962,
-0.4401204586,
0.6141786575,
0.5798498988,
0.1500313878,
0.2342952341,
0.0968008712,
-0.1385050565,
-0.0748500004,
-0.4000301659,
-0.4048158228,
0.8348276615,
0.233005926,
1.0230064392,
0.1104153171,
0.6760811806,
0.5190099478,
0.1451480836,
-0.8410105109,
0.7453916669,
-0.2127192467,
-0.5204328895,
-0.4053471386,
-0.2404084951,
-0.4993750155,
0.3402407467,
-0.3419433534,
-1.0718866587,
-0.0219046399,
0.150189653,
-0.1530718356,
0.4682002366,
-0.5569339395,
0.9419693947,
-0.7023794055,
-0.4058055878,
-0.0944359675,
-0.8726865649,
0.7079268098,
-0.1827970296,
0.3533575535,
-0.1200662032,
-0.044641193,
0.5252192616,
-1.0179473162,
0.9540243745,
-0.1346354336,
0.0671938509,
0.2759150565,
0.1778168827,
0.4161434174,
0.1027573645,
0.1394022405,
0.1195290908,
-0.1718744487,
-0.2807515264,
-0.3805091381,
0.6292142272,
-0.6640129685,
-0.9441576004,
-0.4656140506,
-0.591802299,
-0.0612511151,
0.4491074085,
0.2361883372,
0.5114476085,
0.1740546972,
0.104112573,
0.6999734044,
-0.442976743,
0.6807386279,
0.1460933685,
-0.3111050427,
-0.604585886,
0.8870342374,
-0.2067636102,
0.4446903169,
0.1104569808,
0.0645634159,
-0.0942190066,
-0.98584795,
-0.8526183963,
0.1305464357,
-0.6503866315,
-0.4278727472,
-0.4474572837,
-0.3079242706,
-0.3672966659,
-0.2398057431,
-0.1723684818,
-0.3781894147,
-0.2145110369,
0.122712642,
0.380410403,
0.3951778412,
0.1199516058,
0.3807913959,
-0.8452813029,
0.5764191151,
0.1688581854,
0.164623633,
-0.3198145926,
-0.3496706486,
0.0418959595,
-0.1942905039,
0.0034133813,
-0.8869277835,
0.4774246514,
-0.1980996579,
0.3973226845,
0.4961888492,
0.1689261943,
0.7019020915,
-0.7526043057,
0.7954838276,
0.4612123072,
-0.9149135947,
0.6572874188,
-0.6129965186,
0.0966325179,
0.6557079554,
0.1557123512,
-0.3307730854,
-0.6399286985,
-0.4029220641,
-1.0480531454,
0.6263790131,
0.2168557197,
0.1443836838,
0.0278210938,
0.2752948999,
0.0332422592,
0.3690135479,
-0.7652769685,
-0.0393201336,
-0.3290396631,
-0.2326223254,
0.271613121,
-0.1978418082,
-0.3246892989,
-0.1103511155,
0.4933086932,
-0.1348707974,
0.0461193137,
-0.0054253987,
-0.3635657132,
0.0950708017,
0.1557144225,
0.5544157624,
0.3851340711,
0.0972011909,
0.2305025905,
-0.4141041338,
-0.6730924249,
0.179547742,
0.1592752337,
-0.5574404001,
-0.1390985996,
0.6599779725,
0.8763988614,
-0.1708805561,
-1.0359536409,
0.7241562009,
-0.2346133441,
0.0775810257,
-0.3576096594,
0.4051348269,
-0.3588270247,
0.1502222419,
0.2130155563,
0.2598252296,
-0.0998391137,
-0.6130295396,
0.4730059206,
0.5793079734,
-0.4601975381,
0.0250023976,
0.9194851518,
0.1230295897,
-0.4063951969,
0.5559684038,
0.1211043596,
-0.4227204323,
0.8285447955,
0.6301594377,
0.8878893852,
-0.0947107896,
0.4769746065,
-0.0163051281,
0.8966328502,
-0.18025814,
0.1533350945,
0.2768820524,
-0.4165069163,
-0.2776831388,
-0.5642933249,
-0.3681222498,
0.2018162012,
-0.2957130075,
0.4133217633,
-0.8756973147,
-0.0060774847,
-0.1854976863,
-0.5641178489,
-0.3322578371,
0.1515451819,
0.5067005754,
1.0137887001,
-0.7394192815,
0.5857355595,
0.5611057878,
-0.4963970184,
-0.7665541172,
0.1429026872,
0.5320764184,
-0.982144773,
0.2496963888,
0.5474102497,
0.0990032777,
-0.2974890172,
-0.8900904059,
-0.835826695,
0.8845354915,
0.6003472209,
-0.5329963565,
-0.1535006762,
0.2780345082,
0.2945481837,
-0.2998901904,
-0.0112045556,
0.5619183183,
0.627353251,
0.2268750221,
-0.6151384711,
0.410123378,
-0.4332632124,
-0.1840784997,
0.1607237011,
-0.4750758708,
0.6677753329,
-0.5156177878,
-0.1541331857,
0.4013130963,
0.3872772753,
0.4488211572,
0.2138442546,
0.5776411891,
0.6228269935,
0.5187306404,
-0.3385542631,
1.0799942017,
-0.1693201512,
-0.1015918031,
1.0150951147,
0.0992232859,
0.6586188674,
0.69017905,
0.3054344952,
0.233524248,
0.4174493849,
-0.4120879173,
0.5701470971,
0.1096040681,
-0.0190819446,
-0.3501046598,
-0.0490093678,
-0.1891651601,
0.5609067678,
0.4076875746,
-0.3634426296,
-0.1716163903,
0.2767405212,
0.321590215,
-0.100535959,
-0.4698158801,
0.7029742599,
0.0230574142,
-0.4988535941,
0.5296700597,
-0.1665983349,
0.419295162,
-0.4922852814,
-0.058596354,
0.0867410898,
-0.2697299421,
-0.1040827408,
-0.7291032672,
0.1796532422,
0.3448775709,
0.3847536147,
0.0576994009,
1.0206803083,
-0.1409751177,
-0.5371617675,
0.030266678,
0.3807439804,
-0.0181646906,
0.0650966018,
-0.7407774329,
0.4016167223,
0.0261132941,
-0.2134072036,
0.3393527269,
0.1788901538,
-0.2723174989,
0.7483051419,
0.6779152751,
-0.1068007946,
0.0819932371,
-0.063554585,
1.1183034182,
-0.7703083158,
-0.5258672833,
-1.1344319582,
0.884305656,
-0.2833969295,
-0.0278226119,
0.6248797774,
0.2752778828,
0.6241455674,
-0.0637373254,
1.0496697426,
-0.2409552336,
-0.4259630442,
-0.8598119617,
1.1357492208,
-0.4772776663,
0.5883941054,
-0.6162254214,
-0.5736544132,
-0.5457308888,
0.3158356845,
-0.3477129638,
-0.271764487,
0.7024669647,
0.6110857129,
0.1155365929,
-0.1760011911,
0.5010688901,
0.1797530055,
0.607080698,
0.3452174962,
0.8187938333,
-0.0354211926,
0.6895613074,
-0.1853858382,
-0.2703210413,
-0.2411432266,
-0.9804894328,
-1.1753640175,
-0.4007937014,
-0.1344490051,
-0.4646119177,
0.2649805248,
0.6597582698,
0.4268993437,
-0.6008369327,
0.0610971451,
-0.0975631848,
0.2718830407,
0.2584395111,
-0.1782628298,
0.3011800945,
-0.3374424875,
-0.412468642,
0.3070552051,
0.5568931699,
0.2701366544,
-0.3138482869,
0.1542796195,
0.1940863281,
-0.0383711644,
0.4557190835,
0.3670046329,
-0.8371928334,
-0.6336483955,
-0.2957129776,
-0.2419028729,
0.0726329163,
0.7569770217,
-0.6184721589,
0.4344544709,
0.5858916044,
0.8058791161,
0.1841844767,
0.0830476061,
0.5367597342,
-0.4274505377,
0.4643752575,
0.1437819451,
0.7385928035,
0.2805686295,
-0.4417671859,
0.452691555,
0.3551971018,
-0.2946663201,
-0.8764737248,
0.5899960995,
-1.0857411623,
-0.5023276806,
1.1342514753,
-0.1992984414,
-0.6870741844,
-0.0259398669,
-0.462424159,
-0.0323262513,
-0.4129559994,
0.9091327786,
0.3188381791,
-0.0040218807,
-0.2080318779,
-0.578343749,
0.4545419514,
-0.0745771229,
-1.2275354862,
0.2068046182,
0.9871943593,
0.1656461656,
0.274700135,
0.3658455908,
-0.3712401688,
0.4963828623,
0.0578342713,
-0.2039818317,
-0.5257163048,
-0.4929944575,
-0.3042679727,
0.2867094278,
0.1781582087,
0.0213605762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05601v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05601v1
|
FAMuS: Frames Across Multiple Sources
| 2023-11-09T18:57:39 | 2023-11-09T18:57:39 |
Siddharth Vashishtha, Alexander Martin, William Gantt, Benjamin Van Durme, Aaron Steven White
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding event descriptions is a central aspect of language processing,
but current approaches focus overwhelmingly on single sentences or documents.
Aggregating information about an event \emph{across documents} can offer a much
richer understanding. To this end, we present FAMuS, a new corpus of Wikipedia
passages that \emph{report} on some event, paired with underlying,
genre-diverse (non-Wikipedia) \emph{source} articles for the same event. Events
and (cross-sentence) arguments in both report and source are annotated against
FrameNet, providing broad coverage of different event types. We present results
on two key event understanding tasks enabled by FAMuS: \emph{source validation}
-- determining whether a document is a valid source for a target report event
-- and \emph{cross-document argument extraction} -- full-document argument
extraction for a target event from both its report and the correct source
article. We release both FAMuS and our models to support further research.
|
[
-0.7525786757,
-0.7654728889,
0.4443275332,
0.1000013649,
-0.1251479387,
-0.3185073435,
-0.2428625524,
-0.4662421644,
0.4948672652,
0.2661954463,
-0.5594280362,
-0.2104540467,
-0.8059874177,
0.1678666472,
-1.0079071522,
1.3945519924,
-0.4338115752,
0.1066839695,
-0.4334763885,
-0.4068089724,
0.3352868259,
-0.2751897275,
-0.5323134661,
-0.3054627776,
0.7890843749,
0.4519481361,
0.7282403708,
0.4859876633,
0.3635646701,
0.1831774563,
0.2329290658,
0.2157087475,
-0.241912201,
0.1906121522,
-0.6049653292,
-0.1296920478,
-0.2454192787,
0.3124159575,
0.8596295118,
0.5069658756,
0.3448759913,
0.2231426537,
-0.150360018,
0.2632798254,
-0.8858571053,
0.0400650017,
-0.3837892115,
0.1317220628,
-0.5347786546,
-0.3269065022,
-0.5069236755,
0.1076673195,
0.1961490512,
-0.9646089077,
0.5458984375,
0.0091070896,
1.3689490557,
0.0565737784,
-0.4793611169,
-0.5763405561,
-0.3329692185,
0.4001208544,
-0.0139092999,
0.2972908616,
0.4081423283,
0.1298960298,
-0.0962539017,
-0.8183159828,
-0.6944411397,
0.0010190054,
-0.2413607091,
-0.145045653,
-0.5047200918,
-0.2244778723,
0.2866105735,
0.4539319277,
-0.4546278417,
-0.1527135968,
-0.5649979711,
-0.2622439861,
0.6581369042,
0.0559658036,
0.4939505756,
-0.4415360093,
-0.608541429,
0.0992337391,
-0.4634539485,
-0.2784982622,
0.2944399416,
-0.2771394551,
-0.4841053188,
0.4607143104,
-0.4349413216,
0.7089685202,
0.2719607055,
0.1679440588,
0.2323082089,
-0.4783198535,
-0.2121301889,
-0.2679449618,
0.7784839272,
0.4203408957,
0.4428844154,
-0.5082063079,
0.2433318347,
-0.113042675,
0.266350776,
-0.5885496736,
-0.2676505148,
0.096365802,
-0.5776326656,
-0.2853011489,
0.0957898349,
-0.9397338629,
-0.5184776783,
-0.1842223704,
0.4268418849,
-0.4669159055,
-0.3541332781,
-0.2916494608,
-0.5391306877,
0.2891519368,
0.4895634353,
-0.813577652,
0.0343266614,
0.7055574656,
0.9631404281,
-0.4222473204,
-0.5897774696,
-1.0124241114,
0.2426080406,
-0.1362290829,
1.0405865908,
-0.5421735048,
-0.3431595862,
-0.1576946527,
0.007435244,
0.0934907272,
0.0513009876,
0.6616585851,
-0.6193188429,
0.4020906687,
0.0210899841,
-0.5823197961,
-0.3803695738,
0.0661049187,
-0.9604462385,
0.7443984151,
-0.0973661914,
-0.9311180115,
0.496715486,
-0.9576536417,
-0.6569568515,
-0.1826230735,
-0.4438360929,
0.0862962827,
0.3727617264,
0.0932469144,
0.4523453116,
-0.1770340651,
0.2910111845,
-0.3223004639,
0.10532289,
0.3643060029,
-0.2874900997,
0.7480521202,
0.267509073,
-0.446346432,
0.2236972749,
-0.801898241,
-0.3862085342,
0.0257225577,
-0.233389765,
-0.4122141898,
0.0990384221,
0.2705311477,
0.2663074434,
0.2201343924,
-0.5096219182,
-0.0026377323,
-0.3600509763,
0.1302861273,
0.4626123011,
-0.0165996496,
0.7522676587,
-0.3053376675,
0.3649660945,
0.0029972997,
0.30777511,
-0.5416499376,
-0.7029778957,
-0.7888411283,
0.1036763936,
0.2319641113,
0.3303628266,
-0.8699681759,
-0.0166563969,
-0.2623825073,
-0.3616682291,
-0.1402078867,
0.1704033762,
0.1583885401,
0.3872062862,
0.3192363679,
-0.2955673933,
-0.7060067058,
-1.0839350224,
-0.1570747048,
-0.3535436094,
0.0263196323,
-0.1320027411,
0.6950766444,
-0.026009094,
0.9759396315,
-0.2313789874,
-0.0441895314,
0.0431641825,
0.6267975569,
-0.1242167503,
0.2720990777,
0.7906728983,
-1.1793199778,
-0.4235847592,
0.0899500102,
-0.6178750396,
-0.2344482839,
-0.2475691289,
-0.3892735243,
0.4641411006,
0.2053069323,
-0.4795489907,
0.5676220655,
0.6494407654,
-0.6371753216,
0.347465694,
0.2961284816,
0.3509379625,
-1.1248742342,
0.1012908742,
-0.0056346827,
-0.2068376988,
-0.4951544404,
0.1707308888,
0.006234081,
0.1533825696,
-0.4416078925,
0.9025597572,
-0.4502431154,
-0.201661855,
-0.6865428686,
0.411945492,
0.4228091836,
0.2021704912,
0.1874066591,
0.5281973481,
0.6370763183,
-0.4622710943,
0.6882700324,
0.3574276268,
-0.397028923,
0.7803379297,
-0.0306288097,
-0.1237358078,
-0.2292421758,
0.4943726361,
-1.0532261133,
-0.4396232069,
0.5430925488,
-0.7631188035,
0.0686900392,
-0.0555915125,
-0.3985749483,
0.0408846661,
-0.1959485114,
-0.0259512495,
-0.3484039307,
-0.5306976438,
1.047639966,
0.6125662923,
0.0120840585,
-0.8512563109,
-0.8112930059,
0.0831267834,
-0.0651699007,
-0.8775333762,
0.2879551947,
-0.0181876216,
-0.4880933762,
0.3298857212,
-0.3525080085,
-0.5315947533,
0.420091182,
0.6119377017,
0.2717762887,
-0.556923449,
0.2744028568,
0.0354198776,
-0.1940272152,
0.0621728264,
-0.1173761487,
0.2672679722,
0.1639021337,
-0.1309750825,
-0.3914403915,
1.0900002718,
0.4724478126,
0.0016584663,
0.721891582,
0.8810968399,
-0.5141513348,
-0.0255166925,
-0.6055181623,
-0.0721942633,
-0.3562713265,
0.0047306283,
-0.6459722519,
-0.8283773661,
0.304728657,
0.1053520367,
0.4613342881,
0.9893829823,
0.5786874294,
-0.29190889,
0.4108634889,
0.2100132257,
-0.0604724176,
0.4749354124,
0.0523963943,
-0.3476461768,
-0.5699860454,
-0.046626471,
-0.7135801911,
-0.436039418,
0.0899160132,
-0.7656758428,
-0.03135949,
0.1187735572,
-0.0343427248,
0.2555321157,
0.0679098368,
0.6506919265,
0.5349403024,
-0.2803684771,
0.5958032608,
0.2300261408,
-0.1663439423,
0.1211850867,
-0.6045596004,
-0.5101686716,
1.0516057014,
0.2014405727,
0.430233866,
0.0965692177,
0.5207388997,
0.4948384762,
0.9270355701,
-0.5405711532,
0.2437916845,
-0.2844464183,
-1.5124117136,
-0.246613875,
-0.2201695442,
-0.8676518202,
0.4126116335,
-0.3608872294,
-0.7325770259,
0.3094204962,
-0.2096021473,
-0.4788916707,
0.3057160079,
-0.6219539046,
0.8341825008,
-0.187057808,
-0.0879126415,
-0.4982483387,
-0.643506825,
0.3503313065,
-0.1219652966,
0.5213184357,
-0.4337732792,
-0.2870448232,
0.8661522865,
0.2142376006,
0.6478536725,
0.2189312577,
-0.0114490613,
0.2678451836,
0.138416037,
0.1308970898,
0.2573596239,
-0.198579371,
0.3153409064,
-0.0169567354,
-0.2361780256,
-0.5259978771,
0.8358991742,
-0.7492187023,
-0.6105622053,
-0.1991399825,
-0.3337323666,
-0.1699565053,
-0.0958826467,
0.4486093819,
0.6238841414,
-0.3974742889,
0.218043521,
0.4283666313,
-0.1220796257,
0.3685142398,
0.8751013279,
-0.2728491724,
-0.6156095862,
0.5337890387,
-0.0453405753,
0.0998036563,
0.6246085763,
-0.0479169749,
-0.15668796,
-0.2517634928,
-0.7366638184,
0.10039673,
-1.1224119663,
-0.15303725,
-0.8757443428,
0.0728732422,
-0.363243103,
-0.3880720735,
-0.1598195583,
-0.8570042253,
-0.3148700595,
-0.292561233,
0.3312361836,
0.6182112694,
-0.5129275322,
0.3309597969,
-0.9003883004,
0.6625651717,
-0.1078392118,
0.3670955896,
-0.0567826107,
-0.2420669794,
-0.4126692712,
-0.3294927478,
-0.3891930282,
-1.4490640163,
-0.0839425698,
0.322778523,
0.8995140791,
0.5121520758,
0.1161876395,
0.2586204708,
-0.4825429916,
0.8468423486,
0.5228305459,
-1.1491554976,
0.8784518242,
-0.0940533504,
-0.0143860504,
0.4457704127,
0.8518442512,
-0.6380144954,
-0.4552826285,
-0.8290762305,
-0.6898317337,
0.93873173,
0.2733229399,
0.0242152233,
-0.2533485293,
0.2146211118,
0.3543373346,
-0.0613463558,
-0.7870693207,
-0.5497046709,
-0.0743640736,
-0.1577338576,
-0.0410217866,
-0.1618448943,
-0.6730901599,
-0.036136426,
0.6263614893,
-0.1800074428,
0.0286581703,
0.3817556202,
-0.3665060103,
-0.3013516665,
0.2998751998,
0.5212410092,
0.7538214326,
0.3186855912,
0.2917608917,
0.2804327607,
-0.282666713,
-0.0220897589,
0.2515391111,
-0.0516373292,
0.6238499284,
0.4694199562,
0.9023244977,
0.6013234258,
-0.301127553,
0.5191195011,
0.0614841245,
-0.1848677695,
-0.2040160298,
0.0781278685,
0.0930732712,
0.5246492624,
0.6628223658,
-0.08467035,
0.3197825551,
-0.4985986054,
0.7391785979,
0.0387098268,
-0.0305988416,
-0.1940289885,
0.7629002929,
0.6353149414,
-0.0016558204,
0.1232005432,
0.0383907035,
-0.2422724813,
0.6331545115,
0.0165854786,
0.8002156615,
-0.0797012299,
0.5100902319,
0.3099618554,
0.2711170614,
0.2637281716,
0.1014635861,
-0.362952739,
-0.8212430477,
-0.6339780688,
-0.727408886,
-0.5760339499,
-0.0312096439,
-0.5539852977,
0.3099344969,
-0.2410709262,
-0.3018457592,
0.7178781033,
-0.0188202765,
-0.3832457066,
0.0167518687,
0.7632521987,
1.2366296053,
-0.7445221543,
0.9976364374,
0.8987192512,
-0.6101701856,
-0.3422058225,
0.1075615361,
0.3118541837,
-0.2932247519,
0.8520906568,
-0.1253156215,
-0.0866602883,
-0.3808357418,
-0.3450874388,
-0.9779012799,
0.6881965399,
0.3658562899,
-0.3182953,
-0.3004725575,
-0.2302999049,
0.1322339326,
-0.5654949546,
0.1041563004,
0.2806614041,
0.7604635358,
0.0242079739,
-1.0992863178,
-0.0331395529,
-0.1240721717,
-0.5768960118,
0.1945100725,
-0.549000144,
0.8012587428,
-0.0306348018,
-0.5091568828,
0.1237248629,
0.9463376999,
0.0355542079,
0.8177560568,
0.5783811808,
0.2517048419,
0.713303268,
-0.2156147808,
1.1623183489,
-0.1866818815,
0.3832732439,
1.2770981789,
-0.0293698497,
0.7623093724,
0.3454226255,
0.0498140566,
0.6594266891,
0.4325991273,
0.1353295296,
0.1831607968,
-0.0370022804,
-0.2012075782,
-0.4792457521,
0.1507379264,
-0.3865529299,
0.5593673587,
0.5879023075,
-0.6673167348,
-0.720236361,
0.302239269,
0.1235305816,
-0.0619878732,
-0.2853134274,
0.3974906504,
0.0617118925,
-0.7110157013,
0.1141016781,
0.2198343128,
0.6499603987,
-0.5687018633,
0.2908639014,
-0.1484324783,
-0.2062055767,
-0.3059901893,
-1.0853687525,
0.9092968106,
0.2467950583,
-0.5567204356,
-0.2239201963,
0.8807188272,
-0.1840565503,
0.0217713453,
0.3694940209,
0.4899389148,
0.2852096558,
0.0518056192,
-0.4371823668,
0.2846176028,
-0.0971856564,
-0.4246738553,
0.2020141929,
0.6341804862,
0.089116849,
0.2813619673,
0.4449066222,
-0.2747169435,
0.2487520128,
-0.1845690459,
0.642753005,
-0.520360291,
-0.5108436346,
-0.8205741048,
0.3703153431,
-0.510121882,
-0.6885730028,
0.6215803027,
0.5850055218,
0.7027326822,
-0.020773476,
0.6448574066,
-0.2343962342,
0.3098951578,
-0.3302137852,
0.7519779801,
-0.7526696324,
-0.4659967422,
0.0626966208,
-0.3883993328,
-0.2024650574,
0.74172616,
-0.1406715363,
-0.6134542823,
0.7639327645,
0.2687838972,
-0.0567364134,
0.6900802255,
0.2019002736,
-0.0136773856,
-0.069381699,
0.5597403646,
1.0551968813,
-0.2626138628,
0.8203533888,
0.0317460112,
-0.1804010719,
-0.343261838,
-0.7716700435,
-0.5788558125,
-1.1915273666,
-0.7076638937,
-0.4814141691,
0.0646731034,
0.6065503955,
0.8530741334,
-0.9458458424,
-0.0431604683,
0.4667834044,
0.4176331758,
0.1209701523,
-0.2743041217,
-0.0346823744,
-0.3996951878,
-0.9662550688,
0.5397885442,
0.4864055514,
-0.2925079465,
-0.3386351168,
-0.001884527,
-0.5031937957,
0.2856462002,
0.5003387928,
0.3223418593,
-0.7178356051,
-0.3666167557,
-0.4090536535,
-0.3241709769,
-0.1443153173,
1.021458745,
-0.5821772218,
0.1914192587,
0.793050766,
0.7524068952,
0.5800870061,
-0.4066185951,
0.7836591005,
-0.8019565344,
0.0913012326,
-0.1917352229,
0.5682874918,
0.2057071477,
-0.3088327944,
0.7883206606,
0.4381783307,
-0.1853565872,
-0.5977376103,
0.306270659,
-1.1815656424,
-0.5397921801,
1.4291815758,
-0.3805299997,
-0.0490859896,
-0.3844570816,
0.1533342302,
0.3590887785,
-0.148087725,
0.4985597134,
1.4672346115,
-0.0395647362,
-0.0793593898,
-0.6908659935,
0.187492758,
0.1711030155,
-0.5805708766,
-0.1200985685,
0.9530141354,
0.3549683392,
0.6990036964,
0.6787663102,
-0.0329704247,
0.656422019,
0.0813160464,
-0.141110301,
0.0760706142,
-0.5256549716,
-0.131499663,
0.7599639893,
-0.4685410261,
-0.4092437029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05591v1
|
Accuracy of a Vision-Language Model on Challenging Medical Cases
| 2023-11-09T18:48:02 | 2023-11-09T18:48:02 |
Thomas Buckley, James A. Diao, Adam Rodman, Arjun K. Manrai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Background: General-purpose large language models that utilize both text and
images have not been evaluated on a diverse array of challenging medical cases.
Methods: Using 934 cases from the NEJM Image Challenge published between 2005
and 2023, we evaluated the accuracy of the recently released Generative
Pre-trained Transformer 4 with Vision model (GPT-4V) compared to human
respondents overall and stratified by question difficulty, image type, and skin
tone. We further conducted a physician evaluation of GPT-4V on 69 NEJM
clinicopathological conferences (CPCs). Analyses were conducted for models
utilizing text alone, images alone, and both text and images.
Results: GPT-4V achieved an overall accuracy of 61% (95% CI, 58 to 64%)
compared to 49% (95% CI, 49 to 50%) for humans. GPT-4V outperformed humans at
all levels of difficulty and disagreement, skin tones, and image types; the
exception was radiographic images, where performance was equivalent between
GPT-4V and human respondents. Longer, more informative captions were associated
with improved performance for GPT-4V but similar performance for human
respondents. GPT-4V included the correct diagnosis in its differential for 80%
(95% CI, 68 to 88%) of CPCs when using text alone, compared to 58% (95% CI, 45
to 70%) of CPCs when using both images and text.
Conclusions: GPT-4V outperformed human respondents on challenging medical
cases and was able to synthesize information from both images and text, but
performance deteriorated when images were added to highly informative text.
Overall, our results suggest that multimodal AI models may be useful in medical
diagnostic reasoning but that their accuracy may depend heavily on context.
|
[
-0.081802547,
-0.4617669582,
0.9585928917,
0.0986451879,
-0.4073408544,
-0.1202939674,
-0.1333531141,
-0.6749944687,
-0.222117722,
0.3289203346,
-0.2959550321,
-0.767436862,
-0.7549512386,
0.4512978792,
-0.1606474519,
0.8925942183,
-0.0871489644,
0.4987024069,
-0.2347161919,
-0.1717384905,
-0.6454452872,
-0.4682400525,
-0.3996023536,
-0.1764482409,
0.122936517,
0.0391784869,
0.7306551337,
0.3389359117,
1.0884175301,
0.3303926289,
0.0293294191,
0.0211929679,
0.0054358626,
-0.14805682,
-0.0392356627,
-0.4450155497,
-0.3766435981,
0.1066077277,
0.3827885389,
0.4374021292,
-0.3727279007,
-0.1998722553,
-0.0940387771,
0.6387372017,
-0.3207348287,
0.2540956736,
-0.4796575606,
0.2650224864,
-0.2511549592,
-0.2126402855,
-0.4996116161,
-0.1040228903,
0.5949229002,
-0.880377233,
0.3861450851,
-0.0773865059,
1.0347853899,
0.4397806525,
-0.54974401,
-0.504121244,
-0.6197572947,
0.4420859814,
-0.6943213344,
0.285867244,
0.2363183647,
0.4770818353,
0.1541994512,
-0.9343787432,
-0.6988403201,
-0.3722093701,
-0.1221773997,
0.4371413887,
-0.5853454471,
0.3057388067,
0.5746027827,
0.0961467475,
-0.6678020954,
-0.0209507104,
-0.4981878102,
-0.4017193615,
0.3555166125,
0.4121972919,
0.468173027,
-0.2794658244,
-0.390371263,
-0.0600967705,
-0.4407471716,
-0.0183775127,
0.0533646792,
-0.1904081851,
-0.2613896132,
0.6287446022,
-0.0515953787,
0.9641493559,
0.0707787052,
-0.4012802541,
0.7628759742,
-0.6549435258,
-0.0849943608,
-0.2988892794,
0.990688622,
0.7013083696,
0.2866909504,
0.1545775086,
0.0070467708,
0.1060385257,
0.6735738516,
-0.7937133908,
-0.3744953573,
-0.0372417606,
-0.7039718032,
-0.2541410625,
-0.0324943401,
-0.8074067235,
-0.4919677675,
-0.1391451359,
0.4447529018,
-0.5887752175,
-0.0671141669,
0.1088338643,
0.0282768644,
0.3687834442,
0.7004364729,
-0.7131752968,
0.2632223964,
0.062549457,
0.9097166061,
-0.2898336649,
-0.0866312459,
-0.1022993177,
-0.0019663279,
-0.4919267297,
0.8171038628,
-0.4430977702,
-0.3759678602,
-0.2368285209,
0.0389633588,
-0.3669669032,
-0.5567296743,
0.6653615832,
-0.081776686,
0.376544714,
-0.0243663341,
-0.3179366291,
-0.2480747253,
0.4242563844,
-0.7868225574,
0.4866614938,
0.3303765655,
-0.6830337644,
0.4964439869,
-0.5904165506,
-0.4390189052,
0.2474677414,
-0.6563083529,
-0.7202176452,
-0.0339264609,
0.5183904767,
0.4436340332,
-0.3718572259,
0.3669449985,
0.0661516637,
-0.3402169347,
0.1478093863,
-0.6061068177,
0.291403383,
-0.1548326463,
-0.6324409246,
0.0683395639,
-0.596406281,
-0.1450067312,
0.3652012646,
-0.2192548364,
-0.0001293133,
-0.1704433411,
-0.0590116717,
0.419534415,
-0.0298408642,
-0.707513392,
0.1745977849,
-0.5375098586,
0.2899906635,
0.4002686441,
-0.0394996554,
0.0675204322,
-0.333434552,
0.8240565062,
0.4055802524,
0.4563834071,
-0.2156450897,
-1.1737647057,
-0.4219380319,
-0.1242804602,
0.0772201195,
0.6421051621,
-1.166452527,
-0.1048858762,
-0.441744566,
-0.5481926799,
-0.5308026075,
-0.2405364513,
0.6653100252,
1.0047776699,
0.5805677176,
-0.4703716934,
-0.2165198624,
-1.2037858963,
-0.1209175289,
-0.200919196,
-0.082640484,
0.7718209028,
0.5292981863,
-0.422934711,
0.4772568643,
-0.357442677,
-0.5491225719,
-0.2410005629,
0.1771201044,
0.4195183218,
0.3389996886,
0.6409794688,
-0.9195383191,
-0.5612241626,
0.2072627991,
-0.8003014922,
0.0805156007,
-0.010356701,
0.4078918993,
0.7439085841,
0.2343954146,
-0.5701398849,
0.9421066046,
0.8133916855,
-0.2864193618,
0.5215899944,
-0.5422151685,
0.5889126658,
-0.993681848,
0.2045078874,
0.2618868649,
-0.2499625385,
-0.6409036517,
-0.249134019,
0.3819255233,
-0.1061887965,
-0.5473168492,
0.2401261181,
-0.3463311195,
0.1718484014,
0.0646144301,
-0.2640357614,
0.0693756416,
0.2533756793,
0.0487917922,
0.9276974797,
0.492927134,
-0.2228201777,
0.4138310552,
0.3863649368,
-0.6198120713,
0.6612666249,
-0.9597331882,
0.0264119301,
-0.0860487819,
0.2721410096,
-0.8764688969,
-0.3271912634,
0.2614941299,
-0.3318054676,
0.5965000987,
-0.1248658299,
-0.2353471369,
-0.6646976471,
0.0032141148,
0.7480099797,
0.6052714586,
-0.2621474564,
0.7719345093,
0.1378617585,
-0.1403246522,
-0.5800577998,
-0.8005237579,
0.3214092553,
-0.1410547346,
-0.6356041431,
0.5712628961,
-0.0782355368,
0.1031001955,
-0.1394810677,
0.0068600676,
-0.1796305031,
-0.2292547971,
0.2509777248,
0.4952649176,
-0.089573741,
0.2052405924,
-0.3564631939,
-0.0945517346,
-0.0548681132,
0.2558962107,
0.3594389856,
-0.3571217954,
-0.637263,
-0.8657774329,
0.1990029514,
0.6518236995,
-0.0661373213,
0.472150743,
0.523830533,
-0.3950408697,
0.4353065789,
-0.7705060244,
-0.0954468623,
-0.4052812159,
0.5455433726,
-0.4905163348,
-0.8686752319,
0.4657613039,
0.1671351194,
-0.4002377689,
0.7051535249,
0.7447165251,
-0.2748280168,
1.2571012974,
0.4644001722,
0.2036416233,
0.1499251872,
-0.021085225,
0.3001719117,
-0.7867361903,
-0.6139858365,
-0.4165011644,
-0.0911666527,
-0.6110557914,
-0.507030189,
0.7978420854,
-0.4672904611,
-0.0556184538,
0.0088169118,
-0.8626260161,
0.3187962472,
0.4076076746,
0.4878700376,
0.1996058226,
-0.0026402781,
-0.1525880992,
-0.4977924824,
-0.7756419778,
-0.3844338953,
1.5100950003,
0.3319018185,
0.5630273223,
0.1956592947,
0.2951865196,
0.0852441937,
0.4306964278,
-0.7045071721,
0.1477744132,
-0.4118950963,
-0.6256470084,
-0.0842995048,
-0.4044826627,
-1.0164815187,
0.1814443469,
-0.3329463899,
-0.5506462455,
0.1323012859,
0.2209135741,
-0.5311129689,
0.1973115355,
-0.7233013511,
1.1077367067,
-0.3117465675,
-0.0172609538,
0.0839314684,
-1.0581583977,
0.3230214119,
-0.3316245675,
0.2525982559,
0.1306486428,
-0.1301042587,
0.6026772261,
-0.3593257368,
0.6633270979,
-0.0377043821,
0.0829004645,
0.0602816902,
-0.2880423963,
0.2899112701,
-0.1029070169,
0.1684739739,
0.6783280969,
0.1387548,
-0.1779699773,
-0.6073626876,
0.2758928835,
-0.7804099321,
-0.6757956147,
-0.8253650665,
-0.4315443933,
-0.1473777145,
0.1484604031,
0.5659188628,
0.7706460953,
-0.0437897108,
0.2017590106,
0.5819509029,
-0.6243662834,
0.2941985428,
0.4412204623,
0.2187708914,
-0.4851430058,
0.5333892107,
-0.0033552677,
0.2647523582,
0.2309287488,
0.2170086205,
-0.2572237551,
-0.9752230048,
-0.6642091274,
0.3511837423,
-0.7091749907,
-0.3363443613,
-0.7595252395,
-0.1398342699,
-0.3604188859,
0.1623496562,
-0.3697139919,
-0.0119800726,
-0.1821946502,
0.1933775693,
0.1465080231,
0.7846491337,
0.2509422302,
0.1081248224,
-0.842563808,
0.3467045426,
0.0839204192,
0.3037317693,
-0.570184648,
-0.6640934348,
-0.1205904037,
-0.0530411191,
-0.2557668686,
-0.9958429337,
0.489944458,
0.3006719649,
0.4550003409,
0.220360294,
-0.253334254,
0.7935183644,
-0.780267179,
1.1135765314,
0.5319075584,
-0.9276867509,
0.6599780321,
-0.3506344259,
0.5221152306,
0.5527784228,
0.3755906224,
-0.3040907383,
-0.1677162945,
-0.5271598101,
-0.7036092281,
0.700981617,
0.3022071719,
0.0984410793,
-0.1040093601,
0.5516941547,
-0.0446173064,
0.1209396124,
-0.8768467307,
-0.1371798217,
-0.2979786694,
-0.399625808,
-0.3116354942,
-0.289806217,
-0.2457693964,
-0.5610064268,
0.3371881843,
-0.3738362491,
0.561855793,
0.5008009672,
0.0923590586,
-0.0063661188,
0.1818937063,
0.9192931652,
0.888841033,
0.0436655395,
-0.0454719402,
0.2089993954,
-0.9540065527,
0.0501636602,
0.140372023,
0.0441926792,
0.1712420881,
0.573220253,
0.9163791537,
0.0573621728,
-0.7636571527,
1.2603493929,
-0.5627949238,
-0.6947256923,
-0.2946150303,
-0.2232087851,
-0.0903475583,
0.2858400643,
0.1911619902,
0.4331005216,
0.2799826562,
-0.1053143367,
0.008443973,
0.2550342977,
-0.5070371032,
-0.1765510887,
0.695086062,
0.0966452286,
0.1273165047,
1.0243332386,
0.0284801181,
-0.5184227228,
0.6353988051,
0.4706296623,
0.4234998524,
-0.1825038642,
0.2335122377,
0.4081098735,
0.5692944527,
-0.1535368115,
0.3223061562,
0.4103939831,
-0.8983384967,
-0.6664661169,
-0.324870646,
-0.4623857439,
0.1534176618,
-0.6587216258,
0.1020676568,
-0.3017118275,
-0.4836910367,
0.0349966474,
-0.2457788289,
-0.8060458302,
0.6017992496,
0.0755293369,
0.6529054642,
-0.5962129831,
0.7114145756,
0.9693496227,
-0.5381584167,
-1.1181589365,
-0.0465981849,
0.010923896,
-0.7349525094,
0.5850051641,
0.4419907033,
0.2288688123,
-0.1583464593,
-0.5509144068,
-0.7843908668,
1.2545189857,
0.5387385488,
-0.6472821832,
-0.058624208,
0.0543212481,
0.7430933714,
-0.2201876193,
0.4012793899,
0.4144738615,
0.319019407,
0.2588893473,
-1.4964003563,
-0.028188711,
-0.512244463,
0.1110733673,
0.1639350206,
-0.3408342898,
0.7582008839,
-0.3661438227,
-0.1703459024,
0.0575346127,
0.097280018,
0.2351973653,
0.5087640882,
0.4305307865,
0.6912159324,
0.629853487,
-0.3658224046,
1.6100251675,
-0.3189007044,
0.1092959717,
0.6941113472,
-0.272996366,
0.4458848834,
0.4300287366,
-0.3095937371,
0.5953143239,
0.3826420307,
-0.03575854,
0.5137929916,
-0.0802956969,
-0.2938953638,
-0.2246184349,
0.1066530347,
-0.5854873657,
0.6133355498,
0.308167398,
-0.5817853808,
0.1556498855,
0.2371689528,
-0.2014465183,
-0.0425820127,
-0.1336649954,
0.8982297778,
-0.0798323303,
-0.6528828144,
0.5581536889,
-0.1278910637,
0.6961420178,
-0.3584999442,
-0.2143161297,
0.1142121553,
0.1963633001,
-0.164179787,
-0.7811362743,
0.4199593663,
-0.0166622326,
-0.2055797875,
0.0165695623,
0.6131772995,
-0.0763164088,
-0.5983823538,
-0.0302863419,
0.4015427232,
0.4057641029,
-0.1252607107,
-0.7925856113,
-0.0473602228,
0.135934025,
-0.2520616949,
0.1581143886,
0.295948267,
-0.1252639294,
0.7301102281,
0.4186781943,
0.077390261,
-0.0226200763,
0.238510251,
0.8689698577,
-0.5481848121,
-0.2127276063,
-0.7685435414,
0.4580391943,
-0.1694556773,
-0.4884410501,
0.4245681465,
0.2974026501,
0.7862906456,
-0.1572465301,
0.7931570411,
0.1370051503,
0.3553912342,
-0.5954278111,
0.6775839329,
-0.6020383239,
0.0319037065,
-0.5105391741,
-0.5320928097,
-0.7914521098,
0.8980062008,
-0.4728820324,
0.3654180169,
1.0385525227,
0.6748890877,
0.1409353465,
0.0260481648,
0.5260816813,
0.1255589426,
0.3603322506,
0.746823132,
0.554586947,
-0.4017755985,
0.5420768261,
-0.2965668142,
-0.3930204809,
-0.1141355336,
-0.7307365537,
-0.8150141239,
-0.3646135032,
-0.3663571775,
-0.383271426,
0.0855015069,
0.5846081972,
0.6898265481,
-0.6379365325,
0.3298315108,
-0.0535455309,
-0.5262277126,
-0.0397714265,
-0.0879982933,
0.5797869563,
0.034567643,
-0.5664987564,
0.2718119621,
0.4378958344,
0.20155707,
0.0290800482,
-0.153718695,
0.1169030145,
-0.552573204,
0.5014667511,
-0.1304990202,
-0.9329206347,
-0.270448029,
0.0234498419,
-0.4443072975,
0.3787209094,
0.6016413569,
-0.6738789082,
0.9811336994,
0.1167429537,
0.6017691493,
0.560521543,
0.0661907271,
0.5599556565,
-0.3826669455,
0.0842115879,
0.6061618924,
0.4400759041,
0.5499626398,
-0.3989070058,
0.4460761845,
0.597465992,
-0.6326958537,
-0.4485710859,
0.1495940983,
-1.1137740612,
-0.1433912665,
1.1667943001,
-0.3532981873,
-0.1979586035,
-0.2393914908,
-0.3554694653,
0.1703333557,
-0.2545414567,
0.5076457858,
0.4785007536,
-0.3508736491,
-0.5739822984,
-0.8273580074,
0.5263084173,
0.4843995571,
-0.8930281401,
-0.8132589459,
0.6890199184,
0.3987979591,
0.2131953686,
0.8253117204,
-0.5368304253,
0.6535565853,
-0.2235773057,
0.3376242518,
-0.0601154156,
-0.133606419,
-0.5294355154,
0.1893256605,
-0.1410354674,
-0.01363819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05584v1
|
Zero-Shot Goal-Directed Dialogue via RL on Imagined Conversations
| 2023-11-09T18:45:16 | 2023-11-09T18:45:16 |
Joey Hong, Sergey Levine, Anca Dragan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful and general solutions
to many natural language tasks. However, many of the most important
applications of language generation are interactive, where an agent has to talk
to a person to reach a desired outcome. For example, a teacher might try to
understand their student's current comprehension level to tailor their
instruction accordingly, and a travel agent might ask questions of their
customer to understand their preferences in order to recommend activities they
might enjoy. LLMs trained with supervised fine-tuning or "single-step" RL, as
with standard RLHF, might struggle which tasks that require such goal-directed
behavior, since they are not trained to optimize for overall conversational
outcomes after multiple turns of interaction. In this work, we explore a new
method for adapting LLMs with RL for such goal-directed dialogue. Our key
insight is that, though LLMs might not effectively solve goal-directed dialogue
tasks out of the box, they can provide useful data for solving such tasks by
simulating suboptimal but human-like behaviors. Given a textual description of
a goal-directed dialogue task, we leverage LLMs to sample diverse synthetic
rollouts of hypothetical in-domain human-human interactions. Our algorithm then
utilizes this dataset with offline reinforcement learning to train an
interactive conversational agent that can optimize goal-directed objectives
over multiple turns. In effect, the LLM produces examples of possible
interactions, and RL then processes these examples to learn to perform more
optimal interactions. Empirically, we show that our proposed approach achieves
state-of-the-art performance in various goal-directed dialogue tasks that
include teaching and preference elicitation.
|
[
-0.3686723411,
-1.1754245758,
0.8049826026,
-0.1349473447,
-0.150326103,
0.3135311007,
-0.5360843539,
-0.2927779555,
0.2527649105,
0.7120349407,
-1.0088587999,
-0.5589713454,
-0.0001974505,
-0.0340962298,
0.02701433,
1.0526130199,
-0.0313434228,
-0.0787291452,
-0.2198563218,
0.0690316781,
-0.451832056,
-0.448081702,
-0.9238396883,
-0.5562458634,
0.495547533,
0.6352264881,
0.4977518022,
0.2478347123,
0.0776263997,
0.233703658,
0.2911631763,
0.541018188,
-0.8274735808,
0.4088307917,
-0.0542249903,
-0.4079710841,
-0.2021031231,
-0.0600864477,
0.6583678126,
0.6177447438,
-0.2582525611,
-0.0940914825,
-0.0834972262,
0.313311249,
-0.296095401,
0.173080191,
-0.7100644708,
0.3812817037,
0.3535153568,
-0.5360977054,
-0.5165371299,
-0.273727417,
0.2813801765,
-0.6049291492,
-0.0813219547,
0.0842095762,
0.6162722111,
0.2254215181,
-0.3046775162,
-0.4822356701,
-0.9739465117,
0.8775873184,
-0.7334517837,
0.2051061094,
0.2091118693,
0.2563185692,
-0.4608861804,
-0.3149131238,
-0.6823006272,
-0.4952095151,
0.1058617979,
0.2098722309,
-0.0730473846,
0.339506954,
0.3129456341,
-0.191040352,
-0.3375388384,
0.2087354511,
-0.0537306033,
0.1695226729,
0.6095488071,
0.4086965322,
-0.0402554423,
-0.0274131969,
-0.3235245347,
-0.1697484106,
-0.6042189598,
0.18685399,
0.4013288021,
0.6253207922,
-0.2045998871,
0.5056867599,
-0.387342453,
0.7943080664,
0.2757588327,
-0.2545597255,
-0.1303557009,
-0.2981108725,
-0.0632300749,
0.0752190128,
0.6486629248,
0.6173362136,
0.4793772101,
0.051022388,
-0.0520640835,
-0.2483588159,
0.2915101945,
-0.8189024329,
-0.0238224454,
0.2546553314,
0.0144388005,
-0.2638191283,
-0.1397964656,
-0.6763922572,
-0.1690948755,
-0.3715183735,
0.3858705461,
-0.2956706882,
-0.0690603405,
0.0975836143,
0.2235802561,
0.4537687898,
0.4576133192,
-0.7847295403,
0.2572746575,
0.3706024289,
0.7195685506,
-0.2115113288,
-0.16555354,
-0.6845825911,
0.0103717316,
-0.4708646834,
0.6640859842,
-0.490845114,
-0.5017134547,
0.2955018282,
-0.3512397707,
-0.1341522187,
-0.3593815863,
0.2740128934,
-0.2645613253,
0.1561686099,
0.0265505444,
-0.4124987423,
0.0629468709,
0.6727778316,
-0.0057463967,
0.7316734791,
-0.0090337805,
-0.2425608337,
0.1565199047,
-0.7923235893,
-0.4028753638,
0.104184404,
-0.3648608923,
-0.435240984,
-0.0891908333,
0.0541687757,
0.4232699275,
-0.0213380102,
0.2376924157,
-0.2279243767,
-0.2157141417,
0.5120116472,
-0.4013572633,
0.1915862709,
0.079905659,
-0.198459655,
0.3231625557,
-0.4591058493,
0.3010438085,
0.2482281625,
-0.3433916271,
-0.0491640121,
0.093659915,
-0.2958653569,
0.1632087529,
0.0416952223,
-0.6751558185,
0.2700076103,
-0.5563163161,
0.1612594128,
0.6135575175,
0.3594201505,
0.3769465387,
-0.4177110493,
0.5906869173,
-0.1388644129,
0.2968676686,
-0.3319311142,
-0.3360260129,
-1.1657809019,
0.0112731848,
-0.2245678306,
0.448833257,
-0.897808373,
0.2348645329,
-0.1535899788,
-0.2612145245,
-0.2488474548,
-0.016972946,
0.5454909801,
0.3572228849,
0.2103034556,
-0.2236694992,
-0.3716228306,
-0.7340621948,
-0.1731730253,
-0.2971329987,
0.0911863297,
0.6824411154,
0.1075740531,
-0.028942341,
1.2860392332,
-0.8375993371,
-0.2708464265,
-0.5909500718,
0.2861367464,
0.0389995724,
0.2064457685,
0.211093843,
-0.5637939572,
-0.7911741138,
0.0141947316,
-0.6218534708,
-0.049038969,
-0.5337491632,
-0.1529431939,
0.3221808076,
0.4555957317,
-0.5934283137,
0.2870516479,
0.3233500719,
-0.0365111232,
0.3233052492,
-0.4433634281,
0.1021024138,
-0.9087064266,
-0.2759458125,
0.0452720523,
-0.4046399295,
-1.0673633814,
-0.2256319523,
-0.4247965217,
-0.2552976906,
-0.7377223969,
0.6147152185,
-0.3907349408,
-0.1385570914,
-0.4374322891,
0.4002424777,
-0.1288313568,
0.9721608758,
0.3981664777,
0.4536227584,
0.311116904,
-0.6000310183,
0.4126626551,
0.3985134065,
-0.0399725176,
0.7415847778,
-0.3659402132,
0.4077173769,
-0.2592705786,
0.3982429504,
-0.713069737,
-0.1502872109,
0.4827688038,
-0.2712115645,
0.2182164937,
-0.0684728101,
-0.1132418737,
-0.0512303598,
-0.2781393528,
0.2289943099,
0.4600666165,
-0.4389601946,
0.5676259398,
0.1874610335,
-0.2142822444,
-0.2055126131,
-0.3792523444,
0.2065759599,
-0.2192918807,
-0.2677510381,
0.1108567715,
-0.3412842751,
-0.2728996277,
-0.2281508148,
0.2112766206,
0.1557996124,
-0.1148622856,
0.2279792428,
0.2770277858,
0.1571193933,
-0.0836219713,
-0.0679179132,
0.0695133358,
-0.0672839656,
-0.2703616321,
0.6524537802,
-0.0315596387,
-0.5593079925,
-0.37051332,
0.4670113325,
0.3592101932,
0.1437173933,
0.516552031,
0.343008101,
-0.0498920232,
-0.455553174,
-0.362762332,
-0.3707770407,
-0.4339881837,
0.4901313186,
-0.4597674012,
-0.894642055,
0.190154478,
-0.0862467736,
0.3943995833,
-0.2431772947,
0.5424599051,
-0.1510687321,
0.9789151549,
0.4182010591,
0.4743981957,
0.5660927296,
-0.1662783623,
0.4884679019,
-0.7096118927,
-0.3406505585,
-0.1404768825,
-0.1490501165,
-0.4230317175,
-0.6279267073,
0.5095692873,
-0.1043313071,
-0.1444917321,
0.3040542305,
-0.1760624498,
0.421110034,
0.5125902891,
0.2204068452,
0.3329614997,
-0.0448953398,
-0.0236686692,
-0.0108198011,
-0.8518175483,
-0.354229033,
0.9167718291,
0.2694458365,
0.8770307302,
-0.0356809199,
0.8198848367,
0.3119340837,
0.2115414441,
-1.0929578543,
0.8537665009,
0.3256062567,
-0.2988421023,
-0.6239026189,
-0.443113178,
-0.8920350671,
0.1486817598,
-0.4425355792,
-0.7939133644,
-0.209803611,
0.2441907078,
-0.5173376203,
0.1554949284,
-0.5340755582,
0.7005016208,
-0.4478282928,
-0.3674705327,
-0.2909991741,
-0.5825126171,
0.2574203014,
-0.2088240683,
0.0799191818,
-0.196638152,
0.2613490224,
0.4667963684,
-0.1477670521,
1.0313295126,
-0.2706693113,
-0.1663702279,
0.4634856284,
0.196003601,
0.7394422889,
-0.1062346175,
0.2190732509,
-0.0994455665,
-0.1290879995,
-0.1546563059,
-0.8223523498,
0.6315522194,
-0.6669706106,
-0.7354810834,
-0.3189088106,
-0.6679413915,
-0.4593195915,
0.0470476002,
-0.1538516581,
0.3892779946,
-0.4937783778,
-0.1112624481,
0.4749318659,
-0.4320106506,
0.4489992857,
0.837949276,
-0.3252339065,
-0.2254969627,
0.927169323,
-0.1131644621,
0.7244588733,
0.542665422,
0.2104601264,
-0.4662626982,
-0.443417877,
-0.4685128629,
0.211973384,
-0.6133004427,
-0.0017978293,
-0.5690633655,
-0.2119491249,
-0.1684470773,
-0.3274787962,
-0.3757190704,
-0.0886459127,
-0.4485269487,
-0.0483248755,
0.1894965321,
0.6839896441,
0.0704723597,
0.210766688,
-0.5497448444,
0.230001688,
0.3955639899,
0.0902273655,
-0.0764525756,
-0.5737663507,
-0.2821997106,
0.3696109951,
-0.3224585354,
-0.5371670127,
0.3908920586,
0.3410728276,
0.5191905499,
0.4586038888,
0.4596172273,
0.6594210267,
-0.6253250241,
0.6109285355,
0.3153204322,
-0.5798596144,
0.5439513326,
-0.4203172028,
0.3759513795,
0.4026615322,
0.2243152112,
-0.6905644536,
-0.3969020545,
-0.4682465494,
-0.5827256441,
0.9008876085,
0.1388102323,
0.4012245834,
-0.0924548805,
0.2738547325,
-0.1136812344,
0.1715847552,
-0.6293984056,
-0.1517357379,
-0.0226255748,
-0.0417163894,
-0.102945745,
-0.0735775232,
-0.1568726897,
0.0985421017,
0.6971421838,
-0.4583838284,
0.2157247216,
0.1914228648,
0.1430947483,
-0.2922722101,
0.4117326736,
0.8939654231,
0.3770948946,
-0.2982949615,
-0.0863872394,
0.3339869976,
0.101950027,
0.129200846,
-0.2834547758,
-0.1883169562,
-0.2809537351,
0.0132296262,
1.1814254522,
0.3187746704,
-1.0293632746,
0.2934922874,
-0.0094066272,
-0.3089663982,
-0.4627199769,
0.2117504776,
-0.0461495854,
0.4682245255,
0.2949122787,
-0.2702955306,
-0.2101438493,
-0.8134078979,
0.2075244337,
0.7414757609,
-0.5637754202,
-0.1652736515,
0.1712278724,
0.4679389894,
-0.8677239418,
0.4686664641,
-0.225985691,
-0.4762300253,
0.2044301927,
0.4927530885,
0.9141208529,
0.1091725454,
0.5976026058,
0.2059105784,
-0.0999919996,
0.1973718852,
-0.0916466415,
-0.3605984151,
-1.0535838604,
-0.4375781119,
-0.6351278424,
-0.8944065571,
0.0262747556,
-0.4435967207,
0.1782414466,
-0.3199269474,
-0.1081342399,
-0.2834044397,
-0.1355888993,
-0.3577736318,
-0.0017961756,
0.1679773778,
0.344871521,
-0.5949716568,
0.7131973505,
0.4254009724,
-0.1414668709,
-0.7624641657,
0.127560392,
-0.1922695339,
-0.8136602044,
0.4677298665,
-0.0372547358,
-0.3707587421,
0.2889477313,
-0.2777680457,
-0.495213896,
0.9347841144,
0.3057757318,
-0.5705776811,
-0.1100654677,
0.5075399876,
0.5058476329,
-0.6613138318,
0.3831557631,
0.48847574,
0.2440489084,
0.5093981624,
-0.9265435338,
-0.1232830063,
0.1846058965,
-0.0296535492,
0.2024930567,
-0.7473886609,
0.461363405,
-0.3990130126,
-0.1627151668,
0.0975061953,
0.434150964,
0.3506676257,
0.1340798438,
0.6187493205,
0.2864643335,
0.3218889534,
0.0461652912,
0.8437737823,
-0.1446443498,
0.3603351712,
1.2015885115,
-0.5878142118,
0.7870882154,
0.5099180341,
-0.0153460223,
0.2621628046,
0.4414722025,
0.1973440349,
0.4547870159,
0.3625164032,
-0.6070684195,
-0.5066396594,
-0.5255767107,
0.2391041666,
0.6196752191,
0.1936798692,
0.0247641169,
-0.3871393204,
0.2642285526,
-0.0226753503,
0.1752818525,
-0.1314244717,
1.0908588171,
0.0260712951,
-1.0969629288,
0.6279683113,
-0.0121130748,
0.5529221892,
-0.6848732233,
-0.2763025165,
-0.2243164778,
0.1496298462,
0.0717081502,
-0.8570427895,
0.0570648648,
0.0721064508,
0.1764014959,
-0.5195653439,
0.5718584061,
-0.8462661505,
-0.2559849024,
0.2176344991,
0.5960711837,
0.4189582467,
0.1401168108,
-0.6172608733,
0.1039384827,
0.3426308632,
-0.2828225493,
0.5394627452,
0.1503451914,
0.0510957353,
0.8753305078,
0.6538632512,
0.0123066017,
-0.091225937,
0.2122648507,
0.7015730739,
-0.5138568878,
-0.4279364944,
-0.6331845522,
0.3651002049,
-0.0076694093,
-0.0657389387,
0.5542367101,
0.3237462044,
0.8640888333,
-0.0557798781,
0.7533516884,
0.1962330192,
0.4136642814,
-0.5866476893,
0.2011027187,
-0.3625512421,
0.1742486209,
-0.0823138207,
-0.8672351837,
-0.126581341,
0.6773613691,
-0.2108746916,
0.127599597,
0.4506146014,
0.8469287157,
0.1480414867,
-0.1806317866,
0.821208477,
-0.0253407694,
0.5362101793,
0.657781899,
1.0229415894,
0.0387535132,
0.7113890648,
-0.0298128892,
-0.1521359086,
-0.1604870558,
-0.7679191232,
-1.140542388,
-0.3690500855,
-0.3851663768,
-0.0548556037,
0.3548520207,
1.2820796967,
0.7025376558,
-0.5254593492,
-0.3794803023,
-0.2992315888,
-0.1466227025,
0.1573724449,
-0.2543356121,
-0.1140346825,
-0.3420831859,
-1.0708659887,
0.7117300034,
0.3770449758,
0.1510331184,
-0.501109302,
-0.4640736282,
-0.2393091023,
0.3912766874,
0.6844983101,
0.5245801806,
-0.7534573674,
-0.6667643189,
-0.0537382625,
0.0875741616,
0.0819171444,
0.8026955128,
-0.679577589,
0.5852411985,
-0.051686164,
0.560911417,
0.8825830817,
0.208573103,
0.6380326748,
-0.840264082,
0.0126461722,
0.3302616477,
-0.1058275625,
0.3129462302,
-0.1994809359,
0.0964746252,
-0.0885038748,
-0.5116625428,
-0.6629641056,
0.6015634537,
-0.9832980037,
-0.1742775738,
1.3814511299,
-0.1768290251,
0.1500562876,
-0.2006819695,
-0.4648205042,
0.199745819,
-0.6067734957,
0.4702212214,
0.3798569441,
-0.6873387098,
-0.458578527,
-0.3892170489,
0.458445549,
0.4189700484,
-0.8429448605,
0.192909345,
0.5536245108,
0.0500551276,
0.0073070261,
0.8034497499,
0.5083810091,
-0.2518113256,
-0.2650273144,
0.0552874431,
-0.1281486005,
-0.3869428635,
-0.088018246,
0.0069484431,
0.3301383555,
-0.1876089871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05553v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05553v3
|
Removing RLHF Protections in GPT-4 via Fine-Tuning
| 2023-11-09T17:54:59 | 2024-04-05T23:30:56 |
Qiusi Zhan, Richard Fang, Rohan Bindu, Akul Gupta, Tatsunori Hashimoto, Daniel Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As large language models (LLMs) have increased in their capabilities, so does
their potential for dual use. To reduce harmful outputs, produces and vendors
of LLMs have used reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF). In tandem,
LLM vendors have been increasingly enabling fine-tuning of their most powerful
models. However, concurrent work has shown that fine-tuning can remove RLHF
protections. We may expect that the most powerful models currently available
(GPT-4) are less susceptible to fine-tuning attacks. In this work, we show the
contrary: fine-tuning allows attackers to remove RLHF protections with as few
as 340 examples and a 95% success rate. These training examples can be
automatically generated with weaker models. We further show that removing RLHF
protections does not decrease usefulness on non-censored outputs, providing
evidence that our fine-tuning strategy does not decrease usefulness despite
using weaker models to generate training data. Our results show the need for
further research on protections on LLMs.
|
[
-0.5894938111,
-1.0060561895,
0.3992088735,
-0.3840655684,
-0.3554773629,
0.1132551879,
-0.4698159397,
-0.8943055868,
-0.4939409792,
0.7905884385,
-0.6022624969,
-0.3191164732,
-0.708978951,
0.1071575806,
-0.2090579569,
1.4313528538,
-0.067179054,
-0.150847733,
0.1852082163,
0.1057194471,
-0.3963596225,
-0.6402485967,
-0.8435650468,
-0.5326717496,
0.6894695163,
0.4861178994,
0.725513339,
0.8175386786,
0.5482076406,
0.3149593771,
0.0132736964,
0.1266446561,
-0.7767229676,
0.0800108314,
-0.03005201,
-0.2960686088,
-0.4420525432,
0.0193605423,
0.7068842649,
0.263800174,
-0.1559258997,
-0.0314161032,
0.2342018634,
0.8647432923,
-0.4406381547,
0.0752372742,
-0.8633583784,
0.2090023756,
-0.3619231582,
-0.3202741742,
-0.5247864127,
-0.0159510914,
-0.1193879396,
-0.4319344461,
0.3700463176,
0.0727678612,
1.0212749243,
0.3900017142,
-0.2736156881,
-0.0612992607,
-0.8411787152,
0.8137418628,
-0.7231566906,
0.2340860218,
0.6162486076,
0.128221333,
-0.3669508994,
-0.4545215368,
-0.199945882,
-0.2507361472,
0.0014026,
-0.1357416064,
-0.1801728755,
0.4975112379,
0.6471213102,
0.1823247224,
-0.3764968812,
0.5455591083,
-0.5794799328,
-0.5592790842,
0.6629027724,
0.2084317952,
0.1396272033,
-0.071750842,
-0.298971653,
0.0540274754,
-1.1156333685,
0.0848278999,
0.7177438736,
0.3210215271,
0.0370062552,
0.3457641304,
-0.1578122228,
0.567168355,
0.1622158289,
-0.1975455284,
-0.1321288198,
-0.1943937838,
-0.3271496892,
-0.2635685205,
0.6813234091,
0.2779945135,
0.5390248895,
-0.3454167545,
-0.5691743493,
0.0250413027,
0.3804700971,
-0.8496625423,
-0.3785309196,
-0.0274653658,
-0.4683403671,
-0.4586158097,
-0.097859256,
-0.6209641695,
-0.4024792314,
-0.0953539014,
0.1646359414,
-0.230885461,
-0.225655511,
-0.0195885208,
-0.0231782738,
0.3259121478,
0.112947166,
-1.2173171043,
0.5420146585,
0.8738861084,
0.5289726853,
-0.3544740081,
-0.4001488388,
-0.8613401055,
0.0573584475,
-0.2353535444,
0.5495412946,
-0.5210984945,
-0.572083056,
-0.1079956964,
-0.0473018885,
0.1861718595,
-0.8874703646,
0.5128321052,
-0.8319829106,
-0.0913563222,
-0.4330010414,
-0.5990396738,
0.0191930383,
0.1866581738,
-0.6213814616,
0.5898101926,
-0.1127580553,
-0.6499078274,
0.4170723855,
-0.3831433654,
-0.5999757051,
-0.0311332364,
-0.2030404061,
-0.9250040054,
-0.0242810827,
0.282720685,
0.3737409711,
-0.0108160004,
0.1713635027,
-0.66736871,
-0.5551471114,
0.0258327704,
-0.6311589479,
0.2406683564,
0.4116479158,
-0.5067985058,
0.3775115609,
-0.6482322812,
0.0000417702,
0.0969289318,
-0.6814085245,
-0.012209503,
-0.1321776807,
-0.0966925025,
0.2391571701,
0.0066799228,
-0.516599834,
-0.015895959,
-0.5934804678,
0.6293554306,
1.0622931719,
0.2369915247,
0.5263540149,
-0.4635507166,
0.7396128178,
-0.1717322171,
0.1907893568,
0.2037572861,
-0.3680838346,
-0.5589194894,
-0.4151955545,
0.1516228616,
0.2948006988,
-0.7217203975,
0.0427094661,
0.1803513616,
-0.289070636,
-0.1780031323,
0.4175863564,
0.7139647007,
0.3532143533,
0.3645146787,
-0.2247774899,
-0.5922032595,
-0.9631127119,
-0.6870073676,
-0.0546796136,
0.0927508995,
0.143285051,
0.4703454971,
-0.1438062787,
0.5053622723,
-0.3026729822,
-0.1095190942,
-0.2397660464,
-0.0464803427,
-0.0261267982,
0.5085623264,
0.3514999449,
-0.4905270934,
-0.3326990008,
-0.1832888722,
-0.3941403329,
-0.0305576939,
-0.0186866652,
0.1411838979,
0.403835088,
0.6713007092,
-0.5567493439,
0.4336010218,
0.2545211613,
-0.1706921458,
0.7240440845,
-0.2608048618,
-0.1404224783,
-0.5024013519,
-0.1392224133,
0.0300557967,
-0.541774869,
-0.5910743475,
0.393065393,
0.1567966789,
-0.0630095229,
-0.4045074284,
0.532631278,
-0.1998805851,
-0.050478138,
-0.5162203312,
-0.1428509951,
-0.1145362556,
0.6770755649,
-0.0176855288,
0.6618329287,
0.2942804098,
-0.718614459,
0.0975919142,
-0.0305952001,
-0.2345593274,
0.2213565558,
-0.745682478,
0.1439711601,
0.2368746847,
0.1141989082,
-0.5954084992,
-0.3687047362,
0.4701282978,
-0.1296926737,
0.3901543617,
-0.2395042628,
-0.404135555,
-0.2727904618,
-0.4299277365,
0.1488863081,
0.6188386083,
-0.6234285831,
0.1724666506,
0.4893497527,
-0.1749824435,
-0.5181721449,
-0.5757933855,
0.0103269788,
-0.5723298192,
-0.3012473881,
0.3203650117,
-0.122355178,
-0.0149275986,
-0.245413661,
-0.2404708266,
-0.0143491384,
0.4669495225,
0.3845031261,
0.2017491311,
0.1466277838,
0.0724283084,
-0.0924803391,
-0.2067587525,
0.2842213809,
-0.0045850212,
0.2360092103,
-0.1809231937,
-0.5532518625,
-0.6101093888,
0.112121664,
0.3839666247,
-0.2776235044,
0.315508455,
0.839813292,
-0.2459564656,
-0.266990602,
-0.4002074003,
-0.7044711709,
-0.5557290316,
0.675506711,
-0.3976128697,
-1.3343498707,
0.3680124581,
0.0531451963,
0.3116666377,
0.3001556396,
0.6018772721,
0.0278781559,
1.168934226,
0.52700454,
-0.0951313823,
0.7488030791,
0.091166392,
0.1606342047,
-0.6945977807,
0.0289468691,
-0.3888838589,
-0.2631142735,
-0.9244081974,
0.1493446231,
0.3085018992,
0.1420936882,
-0.4415929914,
0.1476620138,
-0.4483607709,
0.7224001288,
0.5627971888,
0.3652106225,
0.3228465915,
-0.0233004,
-0.0037801545,
0.0333814509,
-0.643799603,
-0.3671399057,
1.226608634,
0.6878553629,
0.8241600394,
0.0892957523,
0.880241096,
0.1998041272,
0.1636746526,
-0.5112738013,
0.5761043429,
-0.0576049089,
-0.4946963787,
-0.4492310584,
-0.6638579965,
-0.889957428,
0.241806224,
-0.2159095258,
-0.6024060249,
-0.203384161,
0.52997756,
-0.6132553816,
0.4857556224,
-0.7821925879,
0.7551722527,
0.0028755839,
-0.5474433303,
-0.4927890599,
-0.402967304,
0.5579174757,
-0.2110676318,
0.2137452811,
-0.1673474759,
0.3309814334,
0.8384100199,
-0.5471482873,
1.1410604715,
-0.3204479814,
-0.2825885415,
0.0918113217,
-0.0000711251,
0.8377536535,
0.3795376122,
0.163867861,
-0.1388301998,
0.1220693812,
-0.465759933,
-0.2813249826,
0.7508004308,
-0.9022121429,
-0.9324976206,
-0.3002903163,
-0.4333969653,
-0.3455781341,
0.2257511467,
0.2064225823,
0.3408997953,
-0.0697309002,
0.072890833,
0.657607317,
-0.2293675095,
0.5505695343,
0.6167948842,
-0.2297881842,
-0.3419280052,
0.8611571789,
-0.0350808613,
0.5481117368,
-0.0790644512,
0.2296500653,
-0.1424055547,
-0.8709686995,
-0.2429644316,
0.1468481272,
-0.5607004166,
-0.166902855,
-0.2887766361,
-0.2941009998,
-0.2952793241,
0.2415485233,
-0.3133731782,
-0.250181824,
-0.3179413676,
-0.2367014587,
0.2951740026,
0.8650650978,
-0.2086884826,
0.2568670213,
-0.7340259552,
0.3902854025,
0.6040995121,
0.5971502066,
0.0123036206,
-0.7032079697,
-0.5088011026,
-0.0372220948,
-0.5426717401,
-0.4643929005,
0.198219493,
0.1953996271,
0.3569763899,
0.3157883584,
0.1020371392,
0.6530043483,
-0.584528923,
0.5081459284,
0.0211658441,
-0.7239704728,
0.1168708801,
-0.4964534938,
0.4145078361,
0.2910029888,
-0.1550060511,
-0.3021246195,
-0.4847245514,
-0.5511397719,
-0.671871841,
0.7587954402,
-0.0838472992,
0.0570872016,
0.0581983328,
0.7158094645,
0.0295369029,
0.0924977586,
-0.7674993873,
-0.0381185301,
0.0071327533,
0.2796085179,
-0.0583726279,
-0.3257350624,
-0.1629927903,
-0.2964524031,
0.8256824017,
0.0430529676,
-0.0122341262,
-0.0466646701,
-0.0407551937,
-0.4902946949,
0.3439843059,
0.5971764326,
0.3430325389,
-0.0299591888,
0.0909255072,
0.2793658078,
-0.4780285954,
-0.0663282424,
-0.0384435654,
-0.1635928601,
-0.5970921516,
0.4949739873,
1.0293523073,
0.3031199276,
-0.5752280951,
0.2184855491,
-0.1685418189,
-0.3949767351,
-0.1330249906,
0.490860343,
-0.0846766979,
0.2834088802,
0.0124569144,
0.2595900595,
-0.056012027,
-0.2870343924,
0.4372588396,
0.7276131511,
-0.4501593113,
-0.4296478033,
0.589573741,
0.1480804682,
-0.2430333495,
0.4615908861,
-0.1083235741,
-0.4298981726,
0.6358940005,
0.5038558245,
0.6471078992,
-0.0072062057,
0.0293869432,
0.2544839084,
0.4215847552,
-0.1077108085,
0.0438271351,
-0.0016440148,
-0.7281578779,
-0.3715242743,
-0.5576310754,
-0.5142506957,
0.3800513446,
-0.728848815,
0.0706238076,
-0.7752285004,
-0.1882540733,
0.0075314185,
0.089060761,
-0.6323224902,
-0.0056321486,
0.1565796584,
0.364510566,
-0.6542711854,
1.1386424303,
0.351128906,
-0.3372955918,
-0.9040914178,
-0.0278999694,
0.1618430018,
-0.6457614899,
0.4107809961,
0.0745252147,
-0.2147493511,
0.010078121,
-0.5577091575,
-0.5701622963,
0.7244150639,
0.6409900188,
-0.7466356754,
0.0573707186,
0.1525039524,
0.5026521683,
0.0684285834,
-0.0801083148,
0.8739973307,
0.5439785719,
-0.2807205915,
-0.9075635672,
0.0005967426,
0.0455034524,
-0.1197199151,
0.2564511597,
-0.5096972585,
0.7807765007,
-0.3326431215,
-0.3001884222,
0.0371552333,
0.4545382559,
0.2621518672,
-0.0182500686,
0.5837646723,
0.6335206032,
0.7485980392,
0.0008675691,
0.98525244,
-0.1277152598,
0.3314759433,
1.4247217178,
-0.2390295863,
0.892305851,
0.5442433357,
-0.1517713517,
0.1447506398,
0.7813239694,
0.0521094427,
0.7002454996,
0.3233703971,
-0.2057842612,
-0.5153597593,
0.2645947337,
-0.2547527552,
0.2510149181,
0.1943533719,
-0.119016774,
-0.2739899158,
0.0911281779,
0.1629271358,
0.1707142144,
-0.3300023079,
1.0060788393,
0.2661996782,
-0.7519642115,
0.9105141163,
0.218313396,
0.7403803468,
-0.5644654036,
0.0376399755,
-0.0801465437,
0.327783823,
-0.2936429977,
-0.5674021244,
0.4436839819,
0.1038109809,
-0.1587541252,
-0.2877477407,
0.9034190178,
-0.3783048093,
0.0942829475,
0.4107615948,
0.35599038,
-0.1051338166,
-0.0645705834,
-0.7335156202,
0.1321631521,
0.1447245628,
-0.4831252396,
0.8319266438,
0.1560601443,
-0.0044317297,
0.6540107727,
0.809343636,
0.2515189052,
-0.0350493528,
0.1478269696,
0.8961259127,
-0.694301188,
-0.3685103655,
-1.2575196028,
-0.1313689798,
0.0908432305,
-0.1176013201,
0.6462783217,
0.2255106717,
0.9949758053,
-0.0280624498,
0.9428812861,
0.4039446414,
0.4888088107,
-0.599709928,
0.7235735059,
-0.2406653464,
0.6520558596,
-0.2478558719,
-0.5295460224,
-0.3169969916,
0.1834122986,
-0.4457993507,
0.2426321357,
0.5305766463,
1.0341511965,
0.04970311,
0.0989815816,
0.5755186081,
0.3245607615,
0.6955469251,
0.5029735565,
0.6731408834,
-0.1073695421,
0.6637517214,
-0.2937214375,
-0.1169554889,
-0.0630767271,
-0.853938818,
-1.1612557173,
-0.1921060383,
-0.1088000387,
-0.2659369707,
0.3171512187,
0.8308870196,
0.6424497366,
-0.9725551009,
-0.0277880095,
-0.1803122312,
0.2326856107,
-0.2287399471,
-0.1185213551,
0.265529424,
-0.4975975752,
-0.3758195937,
0.5325547457,
0.2283962369,
-0.0836264715,
-0.2769890428,
-0.391056031,
0.0293626469,
-0.0824890137,
0.3636983335,
0.6130497456,
-0.8798364401,
-0.7876484394,
-0.3645598888,
-0.1050119624,
0.0505227782,
0.6533721685,
-0.7305206656,
0.2787934244,
0.2044538558,
0.8066786528,
0.2748954296,
-0.1370404512,
0.6384642124,
-0.6942539811,
0.1264650375,
-0.0277895667,
0.3918084204,
0.118420355,
-0.4430834949,
0.2280406207,
0.1126811057,
-0.8343898654,
-0.8143104911,
0.6577063203,
-0.3255465925,
-0.2223327607,
1.1391468048,
-0.1596829295,
-0.0971128121,
-0.276861012,
-0.2857323587,
0.2670870125,
-0.5028124452,
0.8931595683,
0.6321725845,
-0.1421572268,
-0.2193314135,
-0.7043934464,
0.9268130064,
0.6091830134,
-0.8690140843,
0.3346354961,
0.4052884281,
0.5760178566,
-0.4635897279,
0.669254303,
-0.2282266319,
0.4139251411,
-0.4824306965,
-0.1462047696,
-0.2953933179,
-0.2746119499,
-0.7017192245,
0.2588143945,
0.6603649855,
0.0037236379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05552v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05552v1
|
The Iron(ic) Melting Pot: Reviewing Human Evaluation in Humour, Irony and Sarcasm Generation
| 2023-11-09T17:50:23 | 2023-11-09T17:50:23 |
Tyler Loakman, Aaron Maladry, Chenghua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Human evaluation is often considered to be the gold standard method of
evaluating a Natural Language Generation system. However, whilst its importance
is accepted by the community at large, the quality of its execution is often
brought into question. In this position paper, we argue that the generation of
more esoteric forms of language - humour, irony and sarcasm - constitutes a
subdomain where the characteristics of selected evaluator panels are of utmost
importance, and every effort should be made to report demographic
characteristics wherever possible, in the interest of transparency and
replicability. We support these claims with an overview of each language form
and an analysis of examples in terms of how their interpretation is affected by
different participant variables. We additionally perform a critical survey of
recent works in NLG to assess how well evaluation procedures are reported in
this subdomain, and note a severe lack of open reporting of evaluator
demographic information, and a significant reliance on crowdsourcing platforms
for recruitment.
|
[
-0.4753828943,
-0.1614121199,
0.1704634875,
0.3445312381,
-0.1265324652,
0.1518983692,
-0.0815733969,
-0.227470845,
0.1433277875,
0.280382812,
-0.409119606,
-0.2191928327,
-0.439335674,
0.4820151031,
-0.2697613239,
1.0385980606,
0.3826445937,
-0.0122705195,
-0.3944927156,
-0.0162822306,
-0.1911556423,
-0.3984937966,
-0.7846201658,
-0.6824842691,
0.5728102922,
0.4970810115,
0.8646851778,
0.2507407963,
0.3294995129,
0.2998065352,
-0.090193145,
-0.133382678,
-0.6138611436,
-0.0474628173,
-0.4527566135,
-0.5546330214,
-0.2308730334,
0.1144311205,
0.2250131369,
0.9007714987,
0.1750957668,
0.2458093315,
-0.1645180285,
0.7906487584,
-0.7909175754,
-0.1497005522,
-0.5313414931,
0.2286534458,
-0.1690049171,
-0.3918316066,
-0.7099296451,
-0.405623436,
0.2187919766,
0.0181992184,
0.4092402458,
0.3164402843,
0.4864462912,
0.096684061,
-0.4607360959,
-0.33195889,
-0.6550984383,
0.9598886967,
-0.629139185,
-0.256767571,
0.3667311966,
0.2975862026,
-0.3284031153,
-0.6550498605,
-0.5557731986,
-0.3508827388,
-0.169436425,
0.2740357816,
-0.2015517205,
-0.0583529845,
-0.1489338428,
0.7179142833,
-0.785743773,
-0.0446960516,
-0.5167775154,
-0.0509131774,
0.9008820653,
0.1772038639,
0.6248918176,
-0.5728877783,
-0.2781517208,
0.1337255687,
-0.4646275938,
-0.2848859727,
1.0833342075,
0.2380600274,
0.1793405265,
0.5191714764,
-0.1657096893,
0.0699071735,
-0.0053152484,
0.2073329836,
0.2454846501,
0.0496462435,
0.097784102,
0.0654548779,
0.7234866619,
0.5367137194,
0.3521651924,
-0.460681051,
-0.1059083194,
0.3428307474,
0.4687899947,
-0.5546507239,
-0.4683607221,
0.3912838101,
-0.2126414925,
-0.3727046847,
0.3493849039,
-0.6461290717,
-0.491358608,
0.1390874982,
-0.0655444041,
-0.124282077,
-0.4433937371,
-0.0450594425,
-0.6271314621,
0.0693887845,
0.1137546077,
-0.6923651695,
0.334930867,
0.8717650175,
0.3162404299,
-0.2097460479,
-0.2719216645,
-0.0887371153,
-0.0873973519,
-0.1694244593,
0.9987342954,
-0.4949433506,
-0.2566095591,
-0.0137833646,
-0.1278088987,
-0.137876451,
-0.7853810191,
0.5645182729,
-0.2404776067,
0.5051185489,
-0.1049301997,
-0.154549852,
-0.0786622763,
0.059105441,
-0.802616477,
1.1245100498,
0.6509420872,
-1.153652668,
0.4507893324,
-0.7670372128,
-0.5062595606,
0.5047180057,
-0.0539259724,
-0.1893677562,
0.2362726629,
-0.0432902873,
0.0363994353,
-0.5843265057,
0.2740414739,
-0.0684241056,
-0.5922240019,
0.5604621172,
-0.5813196301,
1.12842381,
0.3219177127,
-0.8678581715,
-0.3830553293,
-0.3764970303,
0.0779314935,
-0.1620572507,
-0.062554352,
-0.1330994517,
-0.0782170966,
0.1004714146,
0.2523698211,
0.0449762829,
-0.4236206412,
-0.2430914938,
-0.6184610128,
0.2400210798,
0.7694347501,
0.1437202394,
0.2253473699,
-0.4706269801,
0.8975789547,
-0.1822944731,
0.2836360335,
0.2499175221,
-0.3901759088,
-0.9465762377,
-0.1875248402,
0.5365746617,
0.6543980241,
-0.9389898777,
0.5964663625,
-0.1780006588,
-0.6329692006,
-0.6869394779,
0.0322417654,
0.556430757,
0.1190687791,
-0.1150119901,
-0.5821630359,
-0.4844610691,
-0.8172554374,
-0.5576354861,
-0.6271572113,
-0.2096647471,
0.4796235859,
0.5678195953,
-0.0793899819,
1.0852487087,
-0.1156625375,
0.1263561547,
-0.4632928073,
0.8952114582,
0.0095118051,
0.3291336596,
0.8615983129,
-0.8940644264,
-0.6514377594,
0.3258917332,
-0.6341348886,
-0.5182028413,
0.2648901641,
-0.3149137497,
0.1010386646,
-0.0439333618,
-0.3997705877,
0.5833389163,
0.4461144507,
-0.3771498203,
0.6644696593,
0.4136421382,
0.4858432412,
-0.6824604273,
0.400670141,
-0.4361905754,
-0.0913821012,
-0.5174252391,
0.0380267277,
-0.6810507178,
-0.0922832862,
-0.839958787,
0.7085059881,
-0.3689330816,
0.0346191935,
-0.299164772,
0.3349928558,
0.0416571721,
0.1698399931,
-0.7415110469,
0.54836303,
0.0947478414,
-0.3275483251,
0.6501727104,
-0.1609024256,
-0.1205656379,
0.9586411715,
-0.3831020296,
0.364905417,
-0.2644867599,
0.2658011913,
-1.0095982552,
-0.5578016043,
0.3538167775,
-0.7046726942,
-0.0630415902,
0.2002920657,
-0.5843528509,
-0.6034789681,
-0.4816453159,
0.3107573986,
0.5157405138,
0.0105982665,
0.5538286567,
0.3030512333,
-0.3904150426,
-0.9659215808,
-0.6196420193,
0.0994805396,
-0.4283363521,
-0.7106581926,
-0.2159047127,
-0.0137199741,
-0.6881604195,
0.3494552374,
0.0702956691,
0.0363109857,
0.2754054368,
0.0745987445,
-0.2243761569,
-0.0054938467,
-0.077621378,
-0.2061551958,
-0.1642222852,
0.1257437766,
0.2173888087,
0.6689687967,
0.0266969502,
-0.1996867657,
-0.3945710361,
0.6121265292,
0.3908050656,
0.0874123052,
0.729821682,
0.4161894321,
-0.2442765981,
-0.2740511894,
-0.3983053863,
-0.1183241382,
-0.4106974006,
0.275326103,
0.0856152326,
-0.6597483754,
0.5878005028,
-0.2058658451,
0.1592135727,
0.9695350528,
0.5011362433,
-0.3198747933,
1.0365378857,
0.7498651743,
0.15304178,
0.0885512531,
-0.0360237211,
0.4870774746,
-0.7256168723,
0.1000607982,
-0.8332933187,
-0.686260879,
-0.3600859046,
-0.1858586967,
0.2696735263,
-0.2792097628,
0.2180624902,
0.0303920321,
-0.1749987155,
0.6719098687,
-0.0187644139,
-0.1178237796,
0.1584839374,
-0.2331900895,
-0.0781446695,
-0.206183061,
-0.7920168042,
-0.9104972482,
0.7447234988,
0.2443878949,
0.7619033456,
-0.0291491784,
0.5815940499,
0.7788310647,
1.0514628887,
-0.6906870008,
0.4530260563,
-0.7460033298,
-0.8834356666,
-0.2932040393,
-0.6556527615,
-0.7976751328,
0.2820888162,
0.1450433284,
-0.568729341,
0.1717653871,
0.1556256562,
-0.2898461521,
0.1783675402,
-0.8110857606,
0.7139207125,
-0.1656580567,
0.1017201394,
-0.0127063952,
-0.7693074942,
0.5087391138,
0.2208373845,
0.2806067765,
-0.2379142791,
0.5019183159,
0.614361167,
-0.2418297529,
0.9243125916,
-0.1392333061,
0.1196908727,
0.4825500548,
0.0969324708,
-0.1293683052,
-0.1579622775,
-0.5273715854,
-0.247434184,
-0.3919890225,
-0.3511371315,
-0.7275925875,
0.4526311755,
-0.8930122852,
-0.5837777853,
-0.4935106039,
-0.5072559714,
0.095312722,
-0.1095086038,
0.4844008088,
0.2785976529,
-0.3393443227,
0.58765167,
0.2873008549,
-0.1590965241,
-0.0632499903,
-0.3481739759,
-0.1823266894,
-0.5077633858,
0.8389911652,
0.1766588092,
0.5280083418,
0.0045608063,
0.3180702627,
0.0161534958,
0.0328525715,
-0.3829899728,
0.4178281724,
-0.9999996424,
-0.213759467,
-0.7440882921,
-0.1808462292,
-0.7119058371,
-0.4382661581,
-0.1647516787,
-0.5112724304,
-0.208291471,
-0.0125463763,
-0.014547836,
0.7527882457,
0.1533405781,
0.6157695055,
-0.2329193354,
0.149460867,
0.3590596914,
0.0205617603,
-0.0911037326,
-0.333806932,
-0.1814567298,
-0.079525806,
-0.2592489719,
-0.7353511453,
-0.0311586689,
0.3282710314,
0.5768859982,
0.4088582397,
0.506300509,
0.5026746988,
-0.1760102063,
1.1687207222,
-0.0218052845,
-0.7974498272,
0.2539737225,
0.0460914895,
0.3803439438,
0.8858163953,
0.5022631288,
-0.73736763,
-1.0768581629,
-1.0392146111,
-1.3604770899,
0.8007047176,
0.0642140731,
0.4318566024,
-0.234768182,
0.0012187811,
0.4432380199,
0.4674506187,
-0.8441232443,
-0.2813389897,
-0.0184029993,
-0.1822127551,
0.2937897742,
-0.3065266907,
-0.4741526246,
0.2095395476,
0.6649466157,
-0.1730003655,
0.2042014301,
0.0153408442,
-0.2022762597,
-0.2902757227,
0.536483407,
0.277972132,
1.2102028131,
0.0789885223,
0.4197862148,
0.0273420736,
-0.4218533039,
-0.0678084418,
-0.4560541809,
-0.1599134505,
0.3174289763,
0.4094513357,
0.6327698231,
0.14790456,
-0.6209111214,
0.6897244453,
-0.0184122473,
-0.2310474217,
-0.4585661292,
0.1563720405,
-0.3566993475,
0.02170109,
0.5403075218,
0.0337336399,
0.4119642675,
-1.0213944912,
0.2159227282,
0.1753729135,
-0.3874712288,
-0.4697587192,
0.2247688323,
0.4165103734,
-0.3067384064,
0.6804632545,
-0.3652867377,
-0.9504266977,
0.5786287785,
0.4676144719,
1.3926377296,
-0.2972882986,
0.6517671943,
0.0593037084,
0.6849906445,
0.3422246277,
0.5360766053,
0.2181983739,
-0.3540076315,
-0.3572358191,
-0.599598527,
-0.4884464443,
-0.3155689836,
-0.4479950964,
0.275318861,
-0.303216666,
-0.3034444451,
-0.2835696638,
-0.2657402456,
-0.5885565877,
0.2734248042,
0.0486281142,
0.9370143414,
-1.2217218876,
-0.136281088,
0.7125777602,
-0.0599791706,
-0.3114293218,
0.3184548318,
-0.1111432239,
-0.2650000453,
0.6138373613,
0.24575001,
-0.3361752629,
-0.2342701703,
-0.6768245101,
-0.2517843544,
0.7516089678,
0.5580118895,
0.5194977522,
0.1595394313,
0.3861359954,
0.8298603296,
-0.5439690948,
0.6374785304,
0.7071376443,
0.6938720942,
0.2887837291,
-1.0089279413,
-0.2130134702,
-0.4401917756,
0.1133510992,
0.1040094048,
-0.7599511743,
0.9368248582,
0.1025198102,
-0.7851132751,
0.1750412732,
0.5837479234,
0.0807032287,
0.3580757976,
0.6752442122,
0.4769361615,
0.384039849,
-0.4641819596,
1.1387033463,
0.1500660479,
0.3219809234,
0.605658412,
-0.4562715888,
0.5710788965,
0.503714025,
-0.2270911336,
0.6663973331,
0.3899920583,
0.3937233984,
0.2480851263,
0.5347236991,
-0.2767345607,
0.0478512645,
-0.4715459645,
-0.12838462,
0.5365780592,
0.1642436236,
-0.2170284986,
-0.2838200331,
-0.0611439124,
0.3635702133,
0.0802665725,
-0.0611220263,
0.744579792,
-0.0227320846,
-0.5573263764,
0.1848333478,
-0.1403390467,
0.3968224823,
-0.3399976492,
-0.1553766131,
-0.1951967627,
-0.2512106001,
-0.5670263767,
-0.5892965198,
0.2538252473,
0.1969858706,
-0.0393102206,
0.0124935731,
0.5396127105,
-0.216434598,
-0.2811628878,
0.0004082054,
0.2678613067,
0.5688949227,
0.2360836267,
-0.5499629378,
-0.1293426603,
-0.201183483,
-0.198280409,
-0.1104878336,
1.02516222,
-0.1519906223,
0.4030200541,
0.5422179103,
0.2075530142,
0.3009282947,
0.2664498687,
0.7584368587,
-0.627112627,
-0.5153616071,
-0.5602951646,
0.9799006581,
-0.2463095039,
-0.6037064195,
0.5954171419,
0.2888023853,
0.9362307191,
-0.1185140014,
0.9312028885,
-0.6500895023,
0.3615139723,
-0.1039639711,
0.7494782805,
-0.3287090361,
-0.1575937867,
-0.4801856279,
-1.1668274403,
-0.3463628292,
0.365365386,
-0.2826311588,
0.2989246249,
0.9103199244,
0.4604748189,
0.2850641906,
0.1100457087,
0.3749793172,
0.2472815514,
0.1710661352,
0.0329821557,
1.2546441555,
-0.4651823044,
0.3097300529,
-0.2924382985,
-0.5466960073,
-0.4707669914,
-0.8930442333,
-0.7450394034,
-0.1667167395,
-0.2869308293,
-0.075738661,
-0.1484000087,
0.9164393544,
0.1653504074,
-0.689638555,
-0.4166639745,
0.6342828274,
0.1967428923,
-0.323558867,
-0.4160931408,
0.0575183406,
-0.2058764696,
-1.014441371,
-0.1902762651,
0.5529453754,
-0.6502891779,
-0.8419413567,
0.0355971716,
-0.128066659,
0.1748118252,
0.6340534687,
0.3374824226,
-0.7342287898,
-0.5789143443,
-0.1077296063,
-0.1563450247,
-0.3137460053,
0.8261827826,
-0.422860384,
0.5741337538,
0.710098207,
0.6730466485,
-0.4860364795,
0.0834897831,
0.612136066,
-0.8729218841,
0.0670383126,
0.7817701101,
0.1497716904,
0.6157091856,
-0.6420655251,
0.6515313387,
0.2107112259,
-0.7837361693,
-1.1851161718,
0.2654104531,
-0.5236207843,
0.1519067585,
0.8861506581,
-0.2173898667,
-0.5628800988,
-0.3577313125,
-0.2147550136,
0.0961094871,
-0.1423908919,
1.1630555391,
0.9935184121,
-0.4773169756,
-0.0589050464,
-0.5826224089,
0.2772289217,
0.4738104343,
-0.8938394785,
0.0321615264,
0.2633836269,
-0.1174769849,
0.5309963822,
0.6539986134,
-0.4965117276,
0.6394666433,
-0.0151302265,
0.3211435676,
0.7959055901,
-0.5571998358,
0.0774404481,
0.1102598086,
0.184660852,
0.5061517358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05550v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05550v1
|
Towards End-to-End Spoken Grammatical Error Correction
| 2023-11-09T17:49:02 | 2023-11-09T17:49:02 |
Stefano Bannò, Rao Ma, Mengjie Qian, Kate M. Knill, Mark J. F. Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Grammatical feedback is crucial for L2 learners, teachers, and testers.
Spoken grammatical error correction (GEC) aims to supply feedback to L2
learners on their use of grammar when speaking. This process usually relies on
a cascaded pipeline comprising an ASR system, disfluency removal, and GEC, with
the associated concern of propagating errors between these individual modules.
In this paper, we introduce an alternative "end-to-end" approach to spoken GEC,
exploiting a speech recognition foundation model, Whisper. This foundation
model can be used to replace the whole framework or part of it, e.g., ASR and
disfluency removal. These end-to-end approaches are compared to more standard
cascaded approaches on the data obtained from a free-speaking spoken language
assessment test, Linguaskill. Results demonstrate that end-to-end spoken GEC is
possible within this architecture, but the lack of available data limits
current performance compared to a system using large quantities of text-based
GEC data. Conversely, end-to-end disfluency detection and removal, which is
easier for the attention-based Whisper to learn, does outperform cascaded
approaches. Additionally, the paper discusses the challenges of providing
feedback to candidates when using end-to-end systems for spoken GEC.
|
[
0.0330853164,
-0.8988294601,
0.0898172781,
0.0715339631,
0.1442372501,
0.2484096885,
-0.3692015111,
-0.4003632963,
0.0678117052,
0.1251780838,
-0.7787414193,
-0.4633475244,
-0.5533759594,
0.0637310147,
-0.7311679125,
1.1239837408,
0.0299863853,
0.0448257029,
-0.3456330001,
0.2063672841,
-0.3339958191,
-0.5735701323,
-1.0844545364,
-0.3416309953,
0.3894363642,
0.5863159299,
0.6291424036,
0.1423523575,
0.0186858065,
0.32321316,
-0.6422452331,
0.1004167646,
-0.6951280236,
-0.1135801524,
-0.1718399823,
-0.5344284177,
-0.4855571091,
-0.0825895667,
0.632401824,
0.9127750993,
-0.5502609015,
-0.2707870305,
0.3174052536,
0.8533728123,
-0.568621695,
0.2470266968,
-0.4483111501,
0.1407267898,
-0.1976855844,
0.2631572187,
-0.7954995632,
-0.1640666574,
0.247227475,
-0.470276624,
0.2216166556,
-0.3102061152,
0.715824008,
0.2541181147,
-0.1677535772,
-0.6253022552,
-0.8912457228,
0.3664251566,
-0.8001362085,
0.5361424088,
0.6006093621,
0.1994609833,
-0.2666617334,
-0.6909548044,
-0.5735347867,
-0.1557143182,
0.0377051719,
0.6109377742,
-0.5041791797,
0.3484735787,
-0.0261066109,
0.4179067612,
-0.3634938002,
0.2286688536,
-0.3706346452,
-0.3273051083,
0.2209070921,
-0.3473869562,
0.2662624419,
-0.0144361798,
-0.0016066974,
0.0305971224,
-0.7013012171,
0.3298096657,
0.5737707615,
0.4627014697,
0.0315026604,
0.3590519726,
-0.3996468782,
0.684276402,
0.1784202009,
0.0082389154,
0.0812718049,
0.1490582228,
-0.1992394328,
0.268316865,
0.3031849563,
0.5553253889,
0.3622170985,
-0.2883872986,
-0.3636987805,
0.3690674901,
-0.070862323,
-0.3842106462,
-0.1019249856,
0.1248487532,
-0.1586933285,
-0.1951717883,
-0.0237315465,
-0.7358700037,
-0.1020480394,
-0.3474833965,
0.512206614,
-0.1532238126,
-0.2064246684,
0.2068596482,
-0.0177561473,
0.228839919,
0.2295768261,
-0.9674319029,
0.9386821985,
0.5451751947,
1.0333809853,
0.2901275754,
-0.2829708159,
-0.781247139,
0.0511791594,
-0.4727575183,
0.6616461873,
-0.3662597537,
-0.7204521894,
0.2491902262,
-0.0089567285,
-0.160261035,
-0.690734148,
0.3935126364,
-0.2018348575,
0.7336186767,
-0.2758226693,
-0.6834632754,
-0.0556533225,
-0.1161639094,
-0.4116544724,
1.23964715,
0.37208125,
-0.3898440301,
0.0192505643,
-0.3544200957,
-0.6628884077,
-0.22414276,
0.0454449281,
-0.3222202063,
0.0466815941,
0.4173645079,
0.3219411373,
-0.0278142449,
0.3386229873,
0.1065611392,
-0.3898678422,
0.070383966,
-0.4614028037,
0.6081331372,
-0.1070123762,
-0.6600900888,
0.1699112058,
-0.9344946146,
0.1265351772,
-0.2581200302,
-0.3357394636,
-0.0378278531,
0.2202753425,
-0.0080024786,
0.016700834,
-0.1129547283,
-0.6323969364,
-0.2197354734,
-0.6421101689,
0.6286071539,
0.923476398,
-0.3626746237,
0.4667403698,
-0.2432635576,
0.326592654,
-0.2729153037,
0.2931706309,
-0.1764458269,
-0.5242063999,
-1.2521338463,
-0.0030796898,
0.2566996217,
0.8079337478,
-0.543127358,
0.4169675708,
-0.0791392326,
-0.2055455744,
-0.6232414246,
0.0245055296,
0.9109882116,
0.7275822759,
0.360948056,
-0.23733823,
-0.6966978908,
-0.4695878923,
-0.0263022874,
-0.7321498394,
0.0191508532,
0.1022798643,
0.1798582375,
-0.1303817332,
1.0771071911,
-0.384216696,
-0.5927881002,
-0.1745740175,
-0.0671173632,
0.0539421514,
0.2383245826,
0.1494199485,
-0.4313048124,
-0.4624656141,
0.3342958391,
-0.5015710592,
-0.4797715247,
0.0012444411,
0.1255542934,
0.3563949764,
0.7423866391,
-0.4853836298,
0.4098942578,
0.5942566991,
-0.3841875792,
0.5849232674,
-0.0394000597,
-0.0938935652,
-0.8647835851,
-0.1076014042,
-0.2735527754,
-0.4085863531,
-0.8675884008,
0.0192280747,
-0.1318794191,
-0.0736708194,
-0.1936617494,
0.3181068897,
-0.5001696944,
-0.1603043079,
-0.1710919589,
0.1211073175,
-0.1852694452,
0.3555555344,
-0.0848286971,
0.8100800514,
0.5736623406,
-0.3548880517,
0.5257009864,
0.3257630169,
0.033409927,
0.68829602,
-0.6281886697,
0.3158409297,
-0.318202585,
0.3244687319,
-1.0977772474,
-0.1777424961,
0.1208058521,
-0.8486139178,
0.5548684001,
-0.2307849079,
-0.1121773422,
-0.2407668978,
-0.1557647288,
-0.3613874018,
0.7139925957,
-0.768287003,
0.470633477,
0.2133880109,
-0.5341134071,
-0.5352268815,
-0.7460997105,
0.3556258678,
0.2977931201,
-0.7126395702,
0.3887942731,
0.0736303329,
-0.2336600125,
-0.0908917412,
0.001114513,
0.1143687069,
-0.2673995495,
0.3215360343,
0.1720923781,
-0.1896990538,
0.160928607,
0.0333417095,
-0.3076697588,
-0.0213433765,
-0.3165498972,
0.2580457926,
-0.351605624,
-0.5215467811,
-0.4286206961,
0.5563021302,
0.5437431931,
0.0626614243,
0.4055473506,
0.1711898446,
-0.7422497869,
-0.3615686595,
-0.7321771979,
-0.0473427474,
-0.4514700472,
0.3805014193,
-0.0128693115,
-0.8275353909,
0.6999472976,
-0.0539513975,
0.0034465059,
0.2658904195,
0.4352453053,
-0.3829656541,
0.6271679997,
0.6613777876,
-0.4138009846,
0.3848511875,
-0.1644370854,
0.2454236448,
-0.705734849,
-0.5355202556,
-0.520788312,
-0.1610031873,
0.1819848716,
-0.3484918773,
0.2332539856,
0.3783423305,
0.1085823774,
0.1341467202,
-0.3406772017,
0.3504529595,
0.4303400517,
0.2255735546,
0.3402340412,
0.0975062326,
-0.1927379072,
-0.1520672143,
-0.4167776704,
-0.2411715984,
0.5854341388,
0.385920465,
0.6679383516,
0.3911866248,
0.5179188251,
0.1158661693,
0.1792155951,
-0.849906981,
0.5313358307,
-0.25099805,
-0.1269578636,
-0.5465275049,
-0.23125045,
-0.2844970524,
0.2350292951,
0.2202810943,
-0.6284359097,
0.1396526396,
0.2500579953,
-0.3784821033,
0.4344798625,
-1.000398159,
0.5162514448,
0.1792248785,
-0.139482379,
0.0157859717,
-0.7306660414,
-0.139561981,
0.1844858974,
0.3340651989,
0.3566122651,
0.2085462362,
0.6846598983,
-0.9558727741,
1.3438926935,
-0.3526814282,
-0.3047976196,
0.6000710726,
-0.2453132868,
0.9662300944,
-0.3007986844,
0.0075385738,
-0.2281294465,
-0.381388694,
-0.022844376,
-0.6737329364,
0.4465635121,
-0.8268222213,
-0.4630027115,
-0.3010279536,
-0.0220487472,
-0.5024716854,
-0.2458400428,
0.3920017779,
0.7059112191,
-0.4396427572,
-0.0318436623,
0.4101831019,
0.168422848,
0.5454996228,
0.7314695716,
-0.14856866,
-0.4038340449,
0.8126051426,
0.2206073999,
0.3687473238,
0.3247499466,
0.2117472887,
-0.5601370931,
-0.6320288181,
-0.6934307814,
-0.0029942025,
-0.9035649896,
-0.0949181318,
-0.5761587024,
-0.4478061795,
-0.5362566113,
-0.3299239576,
-0.4266805053,
-0.3241297007,
-0.6074996591,
-0.5384470224,
0.6179916859,
0.642973721,
-0.3028216362,
0.8205562234,
-0.4660406411,
-0.1260565221,
0.3751985133,
0.2768285275,
0.0480059125,
-0.8857469559,
0.0557984412,
0.0359078199,
-0.0057605808,
-0.9147824645,
0.1305586696,
0.8466874957,
0.2174703926,
0.3324630857,
-0.2669647932,
1.2394580841,
-0.8472918272,
0.8534706235,
0.4856562018,
-1.4020949602,
0.7400036454,
-0.2093222737,
0.1145277917,
0.3310351074,
-0.1467717886,
-1.2631912231,
-0.3251837194,
-0.3606817126,
-0.7934170365,
0.3620239794,
0.1347187907,
0.0567557029,
-0.1007904857,
0.5024569035,
-0.1270331889,
-0.0617492236,
-0.4700677395,
0.0458664373,
-0.0967275277,
-0.1683234274,
-0.1408159733,
-0.4221673906,
0.0054226504,
-0.1212276742,
0.928432107,
-0.3213344812,
-0.0143882772,
0.52513659,
-0.18284899,
-0.3735699356,
0.5953726172,
0.3891321719,
0.374833256,
0.1602649987,
0.0084859272,
0.3871812224,
-0.5523037314,
0.0549989417,
-0.0898727998,
-0.2579093575,
0.2376942933,
0.5780518055,
0.6948005557,
0.5173699856,
-0.6401157975,
0.7266804576,
0.3768353462,
-0.2676220536,
-0.3434886336,
-0.3983347714,
0.1969787329,
0.0647147894,
0.2650713325,
0.1877556443,
0.1235070676,
-0.6375683546,
0.4698834121,
0.2971559763,
-0.8579778075,
-0.4780923724,
0.4741387367,
0.506709516,
-0.1752955765,
0.7269919515,
-0.0281545464,
-0.6673599482,
0.4822722673,
0.769064784,
0.7795265317,
-0.6328033805,
0.5385306478,
0.1261605024,
0.3881487548,
-0.2067214549,
0.4393936098,
0.2884063125,
-0.5199346542,
-0.6835827827,
-0.2709026933,
-0.5355294347,
-0.0551501736,
-0.8872925043,
0.2089540064,
-0.5831087232,
-0.0681144893,
-0.2208156288,
-0.4240120947,
-0.0583134219,
0.2613322735,
0.1813086271,
0.6840167642,
-0.9415050149,
0.4185315669,
0.4742116332,
-0.0828581229,
-0.8187208772,
-0.3417467177,
0.533934176,
-0.7026153207,
0.1538003683,
0.0304029752,
-0.5417489409,
0.017450016,
-0.2556440532,
-0.6176888347,
0.7616323829,
0.3495304883,
-0.9407650828,
-0.2058029771,
-0.0086289765,
0.75922966,
0.0455945507,
0.3594730198,
0.560809195,
0.0600653924,
0.3770623207,
-1.2685631514,
-0.2894621491,
-0.3098157942,
-0.0068511046,
0.044707045,
-0.6362494826,
0.7201910019,
-0.4968431294,
-0.4925254881,
0.1583003849,
0.876009047,
-0.2805933058,
0.2043588609,
0.5728616118,
0.7039770484,
1.0328217745,
-0.1775512993,
0.5923933983,
0.2260585278,
0.5807753801,
1.220736146,
-0.4772695601,
1.3227511644,
0.5546203256,
-0.6040380001,
0.5815268159,
0.6828853488,
0.3860060871,
0.5813941956,
0.3394732177,
-0.5797488093,
0.1345462203,
-0.1154794842,
-0.3686552644,
0.2698225379,
0.4420395494,
-0.0044763596,
-0.318439126,
0.0689818636,
0.0941352546,
0.3701780736,
-0.3944701552,
0.869908452,
0.0312432554,
-0.473885566,
0.5080357194,
0.0066978908,
0.8190127015,
-0.5538493395,
-0.0309591033,
-0.3168051243,
0.4338128567,
-0.5308048129,
-0.5133378506,
0.4529031813,
0.2289380878,
-0.4102291465,
-0.1043891907,
0.813521564,
-0.6737732291,
-0.4112282395,
0.598383069,
0.436578989,
0.1383398622,
-0.1477216929,
-0.3687120378,
-0.0096895387,
0.0747157633,
0.0888236687,
0.0784567595,
-0.0071421792,
0.096915029,
0.7260700464,
0.8938587904,
0.2574829161,
0.3015900254,
0.756806612,
0.8500441313,
-0.254917413,
-0.8411115408,
-0.7014014721,
0.4760113657,
-0.0055861166,
-0.4763869345,
0.3060215116,
0.5066814423,
0.9752716422,
0.0340466388,
0.8407212496,
0.0011494824,
0.71618855,
-0.7194892168,
0.4766686261,
-0.1559797078,
0.1831410527,
-0.4109722674,
-0.4912833571,
-0.2614287138,
0.7683652043,
0.1629490852,
-0.0286592897,
0.7309607267,
1.0677649975,
0.3055526316,
0.5137449503,
0.4534897804,
0.4345903397,
0.2743311524,
0.5924808383,
0.99981457,
-0.6211496592,
0.4197666347,
-0.0062191761,
-0.5693617463,
-0.0021219719,
-0.3938538432,
-0.7006688118,
-0.5554775,
-0.3324905634,
-0.4529738426,
0.7070226073,
0.6766069531,
0.4629020095,
-0.889184773,
-0.2165163755,
-0.2164821774,
-0.2541733682,
-0.4272837043,
-0.19920367,
0.3194788992,
-0.2521544695,
-0.769790411,
0.6173745394,
0.3377750814,
0.0991320163,
-0.1348941326,
-0.2688573003,
0.1753296554,
-0.3204019666,
0.820692122,
0.3085313439,
-1.1214222908,
-0.5137737393,
0.1649019122,
0.1451904774,
-0.0978212282,
0.7411755323,
-0.7360123396,
0.5169010758,
0.1783859581,
0.6163440347,
0.2006297112,
-0.1553830653,
0.6135790944,
-0.9570480585,
0.0177244693,
0.0663114488,
0.3036918938,
0.571805656,
-0.5243091583,
0.4491181076,
0.4818957448,
-0.2596097887,
-0.6740874648,
-0.0229051318,
-0.8195219636,
0.0584989823,
1.2710592747,
-0.2312436998,
-0.0107200835,
-0.165845409,
-0.4268610477,
0.1964698732,
-0.3771060705,
0.2965089977,
1.1043913364,
0.0722494945,
-0.3148171008,
-0.4885879159,
0.3891486824,
0.6317418814,
-0.7803582549,
0.3986836672,
0.542796433,
0.3572527468,
0.0562411733,
0.9364483953,
-0.2730880678,
0.2724246979,
0.0614462048,
-0.0833064616,
0.1690796167,
-0.5683791637,
-0.6161584854,
-0.1978830993,
-0.1590543836,
-0.3526242673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07590v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07590v3
|
Large Language Models can Strategically Deceive their Users when Put Under Pressure
| 2023-11-09T17:12:44 | 2024-05-09T07:18:43 |
Jérémy Scheurer, Mikita Balesni, Marius Hobbhahn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We demonstrate a situation in which Large Language Models, trained to be
helpful, harmless, and honest, can display misaligned behavior and
strategically deceive their users about this behavior without being instructed
to do so. Concretely, we deploy GPT-4 as an agent in a realistic, simulated
environment, where it assumes the role of an autonomous stock trading agent.
Within this environment, the model obtains an insider tip about a lucrative
stock trade and acts upon it despite knowing that insider trading is
disapproved of by company management. When reporting to its manager, the model
consistently hides the genuine reasons behind its trading decision. We perform
a brief investigation of how this behavior varies under changes to the setting,
such as removing model access to a reasoning scratchpad, attempting to prevent
the misaligned behavior by changing system instructions, changing the amount of
pressure the model is under, varying the perceived risk of getting caught, and
making other simple changes to the environment. To our knowledge, this is the
first demonstration of Large Language Models trained to be helpful, harmless,
and honest, strategically deceiving their users in a realistic situation
without direct instructions or training for deception.
|
[
-0.0645979345,
-0.782602787,
0.6749424934,
0.3249357939,
-0.2384399027,
0.1847056597,
-0.2831363082,
-0.6694459915,
-0.1287011951,
0.4062992036,
-0.4719191194,
-0.3239234984,
-0.6701464057,
-0.01388025,
-0.2500214875,
1.1565257311,
0.0188497957,
-0.1253103614,
0.329926908,
0.091096364,
-0.6052947044,
-0.9005490541,
-0.7976161242,
-0.3272872269,
0.2690326869,
0.2519241869,
1.1308466196,
0.4790759683,
0.4516448975,
0.4162971675,
0.2183583528,
-0.2062471509,
-0.7147498727,
0.1775979549,
-0.4057127833,
-0.3006381094,
-0.2674931884,
0.5001217127,
0.3470105827,
0.217990458,
-0.5099119544,
-0.1566373706,
0.1632827222,
0.1978082806,
-0.3990916312,
0.4375761747,
-0.7227891088,
-0.3488151133,
-0.0390002206,
0.1623565555,
-0.7708281279,
-0.3118949831,
0.0915284082,
-0.7849467993,
-0.2047603577,
0.0896230116,
1.0889689922,
0.3644756675,
-0.6114711165,
-0.3595949113,
-1.0271308422,
0.7410461307,
-0.6456013918,
0.1865186244,
0.4033538103,
0.4895093441,
-0.0471981838,
-0.587687552,
-0.4979033172,
-0.3997908235,
-0.0714187399,
-0.1654284447,
-0.4059431255,
0.1157981306,
0.3734334409,
-0.0827589259,
-0.2506061792,
0.2110739648,
-0.5129680037,
-0.2630845904,
0.6049086452,
-0.0369194336,
0.2313877791,
0.1561390311,
-0.452719599,
-0.5043596029,
-0.8366101384,
-0.0623790063,
0.5829901695,
0.3317120969,
0.0656160042,
0.3129992783,
0.2048033774,
0.4214408398,
0.20100227,
0.0019662471,
0.1374497861,
-0.0878040344,
-0.3182451129,
0.1761074811,
0.6987790465,
0.5002164841,
0.5699011087,
0.0757674798,
-0.6663259268,
0.2606625557,
0.590701282,
-0.7693029642,
-0.368683964,
0.0375694335,
-0.3675848842,
-0.4721703231,
-0.1105627716,
-0.5101323724,
-0.4721187055,
-0.2342066318,
0.5982490182,
-0.510368824,
-0.3969563544,
0.0807599053,
-0.1132657975,
0.1945077032,
0.3816693425,
-0.89301759,
0.5319979191,
0.8296273947,
0.5902173519,
0.3753086329,
-0.3282158375,
-0.5456568003,
0.3327794373,
-0.5887020826,
0.3396401703,
-0.6101365685,
-0.3869065642,
-0.1470816433,
-0.0785380602,
-0.0000488739,
-0.5788270831,
0.5395466685,
-0.5365040898,
0.2246131301,
-0.4148642421,
-0.426692605,
-0.3153738976,
0.4248283505,
-0.5300234556,
0.414092958,
-0.0447065905,
-0.4831097424,
0.2552558184,
-0.6939980388,
-0.0653233305,
0.1344039887,
-0.4498327076,
-0.1585209966,
-0.0296592992,
0.0658186227,
0.3989532888,
0.2506627142,
0.0331340581,
-0.3001146019,
-0.3366385996,
0.6042557955,
-0.6602171063,
0.656673193,
0.2441795319,
-0.417794615,
-0.0461947024,
-0.1258787662,
-0.1117833182,
0.3175165057,
-0.1716245562,
-0.7195156813,
-0.068412669,
-0.1333449781,
0.4810986519,
0.3791070879,
-0.339210391,
0.5499975085,
-0.3454873264,
0.2979021966,
0.9117460847,
0.1375430971,
0.3797228336,
-0.2460432202,
0.592538476,
0.0278542154,
0.3966895044,
0.2032780498,
-0.5514671803,
-0.146204412,
-0.0771947429,
0.1661527753,
0.5356371403,
-0.9003631473,
-0.1063799039,
-0.1993150264,
-0.3362137973,
-0.5875767469,
0.0640099198,
0.4009198248,
0.3670169115,
0.1262125075,
0.095082663,
-0.0246369839,
-1.2207195759,
-0.4236931503,
-0.1097015515,
-0.0353777558,
-0.0599744506,
0.3151525557,
-0.1406983882,
0.6007847786,
-0.4250481725,
-0.0980567485,
-0.233192876,
0.441627562,
0.1080592126,
0.6007892489,
0.5611152053,
-0.9179470539,
-0.3499663174,
0.030157743,
-0.5633053184,
0.2096472681,
-0.4872526228,
-0.03916822,
0.3981717527,
0.7170855403,
-0.9705889225,
0.5187927485,
0.6511260867,
-0.5306219459,
0.7323051095,
-0.6750207543,
0.0098646106,
-0.6951287985,
-0.1334264576,
0.1103062183,
-0.284910053,
-0.6907832026,
0.1715186834,
0.1928376406,
-0.09174674,
-0.1049021259,
0.3954681456,
-0.6187458634,
0.2764061093,
-0.4083898067,
-0.1079277173,
-0.1192013249,
0.3342110217,
0.1367223859,
0.8133076429,
0.4786278605,
-0.669996202,
0.1473192722,
0.2387379259,
-0.4170156419,
0.4316022396,
-0.7369879484,
0.2348328829,
-0.0193992667,
0.2771376669,
-0.8253264427,
-0.2467697114,
0.3979074955,
-0.2152230591,
0.5504691005,
-0.3123543859,
-0.4711136222,
-0.3057632446,
-0.0894825086,
0.1673042625,
0.6665588617,
-0.4792813063,
0.5069317222,
0.2096201926,
-0.3169283867,
-0.5948717594,
-0.9836572409,
0.2560485899,
-0.4151562452,
-0.4243153036,
0.1795604527,
-0.0829223171,
-0.5620880723,
-0.1696365774,
-0.0183014907,
-0.0935047716,
0.1098218113,
0.290897876,
0.5636175871,
0.0451043211,
0.1951113343,
-0.2505946159,
-0.0717554986,
0.4089894295,
-0.0092803696,
0.2377795726,
-0.2675145566,
-0.4728799164,
-0.4617606699,
0.2119275033,
0.6772102714,
0.0316020586,
0.9680894613,
0.3063274622,
-0.2371072322,
-0.3342278004,
-0.421459198,
-0.4973407388,
-0.6741579175,
0.3311625421,
-0.2453040183,
-0.5473580956,
0.4025384486,
-0.1574604958,
0.1955051124,
0.1646949202,
0.4206193089,
0.1784984916,
1.3838644028,
0.8042443991,
0.0257027764,
0.3034993708,
0.0062624565,
0.6756614447,
-0.3667017221,
-0.1395559162,
-0.279656738,
-0.5728707314,
-0.6950675249,
-0.2726081312,
0.4267081916,
-0.0590066463,
-0.5756003857,
0.2177713662,
-0.6501327753,
0.7118720412,
0.5952459574,
-0.1333885193,
0.1463527977,
-0.2933237255,
-0.1199508309,
-0.099313952,
-0.4478037953,
-0.7296593189,
0.8268249035,
0.676305294,
1.0559010506,
0.3888829052,
0.4760384262,
-0.0019574307,
0.5247715712,
-0.7105429769,
0.4903936088,
0.1872234941,
-0.7127444148,
-0.3285626471,
-0.567712307,
-0.7508440614,
0.0447492041,
0.0460962094,
-0.8660498857,
0.2378157228,
0.2834942937,
-0.5516141653,
0.1814555824,
-1.3895367384,
1.0000721216,
-0.3957388103,
-0.268035531,
-0.2325497866,
-0.5614269376,
0.5873432755,
-0.2322275043,
0.3284223676,
0.0876811519,
-0.1898284405,
0.4909462333,
-0.41218701,
1.2404792309,
-0.4679497182,
-0.3186475337,
0.0593342111,
0.7628928423,
1.0280423164,
-0.1593137532,
-0.015527661,
-0.0530288853,
0.0174426604,
-0.3017698526,
-0.665608108,
0.7597530484,
-0.8058523536,
-0.9046989083,
-0.5049676299,
-0.5063607097,
-0.3121097386,
0.073350355,
0.2003288865,
0.2915268838,
-0.2269534916,
-0.0033183089,
0.3637364209,
-0.1981019527,
0.4585746825,
0.5336556435,
-0.3514370918,
0.1269582212,
0.9214209914,
0.0780310258,
0.4605546892,
-0.0785698891,
0.2959053516,
-0.557908833,
-0.5149886012,
-0.0105493655,
0.3218220174,
-0.7476971149,
-0.070433557,
-0.0887242407,
-0.0873701125,
-0.4491305053,
-0.1306613982,
-0.4365054369,
-0.2874030471,
-0.0627368093,
-0.4382007122,
0.3126016557,
1.2703295946,
-0.0105725629,
0.4852350652,
-0.8132241368,
-0.1228065044,
0.6009823084,
0.2891568244,
-0.2055156082,
-0.477327913,
-0.2195032835,
0.1830526292,
-0.4865190089,
-0.8423085213,
0.600412488,
-0.1793999374,
0.5816556215,
0.7211204171,
0.3733036816,
0.2023280114,
-0.3614236712,
0.6813549399,
0.028932903,
-0.9622170329,
0.1780642569,
-0.7326109409,
0.2684170604,
0.422005713,
0.6940199137,
-0.6627698541,
-0.4958729446,
-0.8085627556,
-0.5521336198,
0.8009336591,
0.1501165628,
0.3476950228,
0.052044306,
0.2693717182,
0.0326233096,
0.3748676479,
-1.0529264212,
0.0166948736,
-0.3201479912,
-0.0641287789,
-0.0707387626,
-0.2428311557,
-0.4017649889,
-0.1080838218,
0.7164043784,
-0.0719227865,
0.2510823011,
-0.0583055355,
0.0736872926,
-0.0776973367,
0.184489876,
0.776822269,
0.8436803222,
-0.0902326405,
0.1469700783,
-0.110463962,
-0.3980311751,
-0.0230884943,
0.1295117289,
0.0663958043,
-0.2623026967,
0.1644216925,
0.7542393804,
0.3117547631,
-0.6317985058,
0.8425413966,
-0.014213237,
-0.372984916,
-0.1334466487,
-0.0328944772,
0.2580275238,
0.3690229058,
0.2652907968,
0.2359231859,
0.0413262583,
-0.7715688944,
-0.0145087074,
0.4050396085,
-0.1115394235,
-0.5249211192,
0.5107747912,
0.2278849334,
-0.2025948167,
0.915354073,
-0.5152266026,
-0.9334383607,
0.3554824293,
0.4702329338,
0.6530876756,
-0.6908629537,
0.5060657859,
0.015306945,
0.7386238575,
-0.3788668215,
-0.1311694682,
0.2406967282,
-1.0212663412,
-0.4391068816,
0.119133696,
-0.5743830204,
0.3869791329,
-0.389297545,
0.1475205868,
-0.7429795265,
-0.1805986911,
0.0319727547,
-0.1851020604,
-0.5960553288,
0.0153006827,
0.3247443736,
0.9053582549,
-0.8153159618,
0.9508897066,
0.4453670084,
-0.3558380604,
-1.1865901947,
0.277333796,
0.1861417145,
-1.034737587,
0.6925178766,
0.1197322458,
-0.1117572486,
-0.299637109,
-1.0370607376,
-0.6248946786,
0.6018429399,
0.5603699684,
-0.6518790722,
-0.1493865997,
0.0474698097,
0.5494463444,
-0.1616599858,
0.0792962089,
0.5288848281,
0.7063985467,
0.1395745426,
-1.0995508432,
0.3513096869,
-0.1534558386,
-0.2493004352,
0.1994801611,
-0.7890853286,
1.1401845217,
-0.1599078029,
-0.3687035143,
-0.3014937639,
0.2178717405,
0.0599296577,
0.0816849694,
0.6200034618,
0.2556251585,
0.909645915,
-0.0532819703,
1.2436634302,
-0.1219354197,
0.1630209982,
1.0828489065,
-0.5818785429,
0.8545044661,
0.4526358247,
0.3775844276,
0.5566341281,
0.3685767055,
0.0848050788,
0.6551225185,
0.1230778545,
-0.2417375296,
-0.4901931286,
0.2006635517,
-0.1229846552,
0.5924181938,
0.658412993,
-0.2506381571,
-0.2278721631,
0.0400408804,
0.0679052174,
0.1716990322,
-0.2178611159,
0.5867538452,
0.1663982123,
-0.6238644719,
0.6266136169,
0.1108791009,
0.6096250415,
-0.7242826223,
-0.00894487,
0.0462697707,
0.4453250766,
0.1269173771,
-0.8353427052,
0.4071507752,
-0.1828647107,
0.248429805,
-0.7371729016,
0.6423073411,
-0.3971237242,
-0.2744973898,
0.181239754,
0.3630488217,
0.089125149,
-0.4715886712,
-0.8562132716,
0.1182874292,
-0.0074640983,
-0.4776368439,
0.342967093,
0.7265643477,
-0.2425393164,
0.8906758428,
0.5494316816,
-0.0214910582,
-0.366597414,
-0.1721809953,
0.8504368663,
-0.6364318132,
-0.8681908846,
-0.7343617082,
0.1049572453,
-0.2783833742,
0.0321345888,
0.8428491354,
0.2233365923,
0.5840734839,
-0.0799046159,
0.6317243576,
0.4667825401,
0.5018128157,
-0.4707168341,
0.9371953011,
-0.1023767889,
0.4002456069,
-0.0775012076,
-0.6569253802,
0.0932884663,
0.6135174036,
-0.8838751316,
0.3928039074,
0.739482522,
0.7381237149,
-0.0824397504,
0.2081109583,
0.4853448272,
0.8354260921,
0.397885263,
0.4805564582,
0.9573229551,
-0.0406359881,
0.8633241057,
-0.1785447598,
-0.1013095081,
-0.1962568462,
-0.9234234095,
-0.7481917143,
-0.4667090774,
-0.409543395,
-0.2591742873,
-0.0900062025,
0.9767879844,
0.740922749,
-0.4792978764,
-0.1467039287,
0.1040768996,
-0.0781752393,
-0.2493985146,
-0.2369423956,
-0.0652824864,
-0.0595738105,
-0.6930994391,
0.6092574,
0.0374564193,
0.5489348173,
-0.376257658,
-0.0279329587,
0.0383787565,
0.2517196834,
0.2110387385,
0.3313255608,
-0.3768993616,
-0.6351920962,
-0.3006872833,
-0.331571728,
-0.1684953272,
0.6620974541,
-0.6551850438,
0.1452371925,
0.0467583351,
0.375451535,
0.2088693231,
0.2305933982,
1.0549703836,
-0.9717698693,
0.27029863,
0.4499850869,
0.1005575508,
0.4042260349,
-0.8880555034,
0.1030933782,
-0.030937653,
-0.668117106,
-0.5229420066,
-0.0563939027,
-0.7257915735,
-0.7837181687,
1.2905679941,
0.0871277526,
-0.302613467,
-0.1367841065,
-0.3726823032,
-0.2343499959,
-0.7341646552,
1.0651862621,
1.0653935671,
0.1786726415,
0.0431267433,
-0.8300569057,
0.9222724438,
0.2715532184,
-0.5607221127,
0.3563558161,
0.5739119053,
0.3348346949,
0.0997717232,
0.4858857989,
0.1410225481,
0.224559173,
0.1544810086,
-0.2088651657,
-0.2419261932,
-0.2306113392,
-0.4654688239,
0.0567945875,
0.2321110964,
-0.2909936309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05472v1
|
Text Representation Distillation via Information Bottleneck Principle
| 2023-11-09T16:04:17 | 2023-11-09T16:04:17 |
Yanzhao Zhang, Dingkun Long, Zehan Li, Pengjun Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have recently shown great success in text
representation field. However, the high computational cost and high-dimensional
representation of PLMs pose significant challenges for practical applications.
To make models more accessible, an effective method is to distill large models
into smaller representation models. In order to relieve the issue of
performance degradation after distillation, we propose a novel Knowledge
Distillation method called IBKD. This approach is motivated by the Information
Bottleneck principle and aims to maximize the mutual information between the
final representation of the teacher and student model, while simultaneously
reducing the mutual information between the student model's representation and
the input data. This enables the student model to preserve important learned
information while avoiding unnecessary information, thus reducing the risk of
over-fitting. Empirical studies on two main downstream applications of text
representation (Semantic Textual Similarity and Dense Retrieval tasks)
demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed approach.
|
[
-0.7078549266,
-0.494846046,
0.5589732528,
0.0835244656,
-0.5417922139,
0.1488969475,
-0.4212420285,
-0.1969429702,
-0.3128823042,
0.7712442875,
-0.284622252,
-0.3458742797,
-0.6367234588,
0.0635837466,
-0.4257369637,
1.0036830902,
-0.1152744368,
0.1611241847,
-0.71306777,
-0.0882904604,
-0.6462412477,
-0.5592113733,
-0.3844199777,
-0.7633550167,
0.1676024497,
0.4480431378,
0.1376170367,
0.7407842278,
0.6390250921,
0.31599769,
-0.1338206083,
-0.2141672671,
-0.6118940711,
0.4378411472,
-0.246245116,
-0.6663904786,
0.3193672597,
0.1004955322,
0.678484261,
0.8606486917,
-0.2933430374,
0.079920657,
0.5493294597,
0.991553247,
-0.6133683324,
0.3065007627,
-0.7128991485,
-0.0944466591,
-0.3279208541,
0.053226769,
-0.4894651473,
-0.4094609916,
0.3494840562,
-0.4655487239,
0.2435041964,
0.0418811701,
0.8978418708,
0.3630636036,
-0.3118547499,
-0.4165557027,
-0.9156730175,
0.628710568,
-0.6174942851,
0.1540510803,
0.3713817,
0.4666402936,
-0.0338815935,
-0.6744062901,
-0.9131439328,
-0.0136737451,
-0.178480491,
0.0645543262,
-0.0199146681,
0.3167725503,
0.2824068367,
0.4545545578,
-0.2204227597,
-0.1440963894,
-0.5594954491,
0.0465350598,
0.3430908918,
-0.0960460678,
-0.0100930827,
-0.0419634469,
-0.5992090702,
-0.3994582295,
-0.5158407092,
-0.0688782707,
0.2375411987,
0.1459292471,
0.2603707016,
0.5807842612,
-0.1081161126,
0.5249337554,
0.0626096353,
-0.2609160244,
0.1460544765,
-0.1902387291,
-0.0904275924,
0.2959302962,
0.8220164776,
0.2779871225,
0.1999040544,
0.004989394,
0.0020014772,
-0.0797693059,
0.2566241324,
-0.985819757,
-0.3071352243,
-0.0753519908,
-0.5120928884,
-0.2095958441,
0.0821558535,
-0.7935407758,
-0.3412308693,
-0.4081887007,
0.3336144388,
-0.6249141097,
-0.3814600706,
-0.1275499165,
-0.2501727641,
-0.2982242107,
0.0645904616,
-0.6964678764,
0.3660630286,
0.4458425045,
0.9540724158,
-0.0177271422,
0.0116791278,
0.0718625262,
0.3075241446,
-0.141554594,
0.5977197289,
-0.4488362074,
-0.4602533877,
-0.433673799,
-0.547593534,
0.2404275388,
-0.9104424119,
0.4552418292,
-0.331246525,
-0.1000610813,
-0.2011378258,
-0.7687698603,
-0.2816318274,
-0.0635773987,
-0.9280860424,
1.0817627907,
0.083356753,
-1.0552181005,
0.2146787792,
-0.5338892937,
-0.3187251687,
0.0414969958,
-0.1277118325,
-0.4856836796,
0.1738550067,
-0.0119232889,
0.5932916999,
-0.474475354,
0.3568507731,
-0.1792000681,
-0.1284934431,
0.0402836502,
-0.2471966743,
0.5533511639,
0.498688817,
0.1679583639,
-0.5772413611,
-0.628460288,
-0.1367704868,
-0.0452430137,
-0.501519382,
-1.1611975431,
-0.059278015,
-0.1313175857,
-0.0489029624,
0.337021172,
-0.6138243079,
0.6007302999,
-0.1861151457,
0.2360169291,
0.6623039246,
-0.140696004,
0.5202675462,
-0.2405293137,
0.2074876279,
0.2907187939,
-0.28572613,
-0.3048633635,
-0.3494593799,
-0.568041265,
-0.1559937149,
0.3771093786,
0.4535083175,
-1.1432468891,
0.1486652195,
-0.2694779336,
-0.4854373634,
-0.5223528743,
0.4250288606,
0.4219545424,
0.5605946183,
0.2707412541,
-0.196649164,
-0.502638936,
-0.6627107263,
-0.3375114501,
-0.4469221234,
-0.0950521752,
0.086509712,
0.2933017313,
-0.0156222424,
1.1850962639,
-0.7575317025,
-0.4136539996,
-0.5304672122,
0.7864238024,
0.2553506792,
0.6160905361,
0.669369638,
-0.9833121896,
-0.7754331231,
-0.0357843935,
-0.4435422421,
-0.5629524589,
-0.099078618,
-0.1166093424,
0.0311289243,
0.5914501548,
-0.4600994289,
0.5590609312,
0.3401075602,
-0.2141398489,
0.5070030093,
-0.3489695489,
0.1087220758,
-1.1056568623,
0.0483851954,
-0.0839965269,
-0.2338154465,
-0.4897921085,
-0.2540799677,
0.0925863534,
-0.143837288,
0.1020930707,
0.3848238885,
-0.5556436777,
0.3321305513,
-0.5601691008,
0.1895707548,
0.2641924024,
0.4656188488,
0.0096863909,
0.3548182249,
0.341239512,
-0.7567337751,
0.5398072004,
0.0212097596,
-0.5421820879,
0.807098031,
-0.5172938704,
-0.1327361912,
-0.4585891068,
0.1304906011,
-1.0128550529,
0.0579901189,
-0.0991301015,
-0.3577178419,
0.5864074826,
-0.1085607037,
-0.3752004206,
-0.5236836672,
-0.1128641441,
0.4632892609,
0.6224061251,
-0.5847877264,
0.5427269936,
0.3634776175,
-0.3988211155,
-0.5694234967,
-0.7701506615,
-0.1883283257,
-0.1489840448,
-0.3933544159,
0.4475432038,
-0.12045867,
-0.2181183249,
0.2948576212,
-0.3531709313,
-0.5240781903,
-0.1787798107,
0.1581431031,
0.18906039,
-0.1071289107,
0.4886273742,
0.1966537982,
-0.0698465705,
-0.1711957008,
-0.2337747365,
0.4963564575,
0.3408268988,
-0.012080159,
-0.4263955951,
0.4484927654,
0.5393015742,
0.1386221498,
0.8860193491,
0.4446954727,
-0.3263726234,
-0.3354460001,
-0.7062851191,
-0.2109565884,
-0.4863893986,
0.4910944402,
-0.3757919371,
-0.7198658586,
0.4572454989,
-0.5752882957,
-0.0566720255,
0.2098962963,
0.1740038693,
-0.3759817779,
0.6636266112,
0.8820623755,
-0.1274917126,
0.6070637107,
-0.3633849919,
0.1769084632,
-0.784209311,
-0.299017638,
-0.8055973053,
-0.401545614,
-0.1863911301,
-0.2447917163,
0.3979860246,
0.8866857886,
-0.1280013621,
0.332601577,
-0.532248199,
0.6141237617,
0.7864088416,
-0.008771481,
0.4130328,
0.0811825916,
-0.5889764428,
-0.1986848712,
-0.7323728204,
-0.4693074822,
1.1150176525,
0.1703860611,
0.9016296268,
-0.1308408827,
0.8232466578,
0.1346008778,
0.4351190925,
-0.3793584108,
0.3811250925,
-0.3558162153,
-0.6062948704,
-0.3721655905,
-0.8962100148,
-0.6479199529,
0.2989830971,
-0.1721791029,
-0.8454110622,
0.1526972353,
0.2746362984,
-0.0432322025,
0.4585844576,
-0.9150561094,
0.785588026,
0.1427138597,
-0.2982309461,
-0.1497105509,
-0.4064140916,
0.383325845,
-0.2383733541,
0.2443358004,
-0.0060726721,
0.1918300688,
0.8776928782,
-0.8826040626,
0.4565502405,
-0.3952099979,
0.0987585336,
0.6323083639,
-0.0145543683,
0.5557085872,
-0.0722139627,
-0.0104564941,
0.193919614,
0.0850101933,
-0.1248858497,
-0.8443582058,
0.5235489607,
-0.5801093578,
-0.5520610809,
-0.4371126294,
-0.5203389525,
0.0018694652,
0.3437646031,
0.4497509599,
0.2403180301,
0.0446852632,
0.5461240411,
0.6321383715,
-0.0913067907,
0.548547864,
0.4187563658,
-0.3208316863,
-0.1264918596,
0.7822611928,
0.3922243714,
0.4633304477,
0.4561900198,
0.312356621,
-0.4455524087,
-0.6513113379,
-0.1030692607,
0.0988151506,
-0.6788831353,
-0.3224513233,
-0.4653883874,
-0.2128728777,
-0.3712227941,
0.0313641392,
-0.6587195992,
-0.2594927251,
-0.3257506192,
0.0530429073,
0.3896173835,
0.727270782,
-0.0845518187,
0.6752437353,
-0.6882523298,
0.5455412269,
0.1411206424,
0.6592909694,
0.1328341216,
-0.2998563349,
-0.3821933568,
0.1942904741,
-0.5314261317,
-0.6734271049,
0.3998766541,
0.4493783116,
0.4612414241,
0.5813038349,
0.6452457905,
0.5458837748,
-0.3466567099,
0.4599289298,
0.4514998198,
-0.9718445539,
0.4216422141,
0.1816589683,
0.6305588484,
0.7686349154,
0.5560942292,
-0.5670090318,
-0.5293413401,
-0.1787199825,
-0.8939336538,
0.7866302729,
0.3946668804,
-0.1292739213,
0.3942429721,
0.464228034,
0.3624522984,
0.3417003453,
-0.8724434376,
-0.3410793543,
-0.2488559335,
-0.7314795852,
0.2234753221,
-0.360360682,
0.3716350794,
-0.1907798201,
0.7351207733,
0.1802915633,
0.1380367279,
0.2170045674,
-0.0765052214,
0.2476916611,
0.067998074,
0.0158416424,
0.3791491985,
-0.2198243588,
0.2879405916,
-0.0603417121,
-1.1655887365,
0.3668866158,
-0.0633003935,
-0.2185739428,
0.2046322823,
0.3405277133,
0.7340224385,
-0.0962982923,
-0.6509587169,
0.4673796892,
-0.1660861671,
-0.0562052429,
0.0595290512,
0.0442247018,
0.1106428504,
0.372770071,
0.7472143173,
0.1142048687,
0.0328013562,
-0.3814531565,
0.275239557,
0.0764317513,
-0.2153520584,
0.1062123477,
0.5859678388,
0.1635827273,
0.1167782247,
0.4835765958,
-0.117731899,
-0.4575658441,
0.5526162386,
0.309714973,
0.5742086172,
-0.566727221,
0.198106274,
0.35786134,
0.0564494208,
-0.3473465741,
0.0551484711,
-0.268589139,
-0.6526931524,
-0.199317351,
-0.7487394214,
0.0095154308,
0.1985538751,
-0.7187973857,
0.3112606704,
-0.396104902,
-0.2339634746,
-0.0126897627,
0.1262611449,
-0.4304267466,
0.0072951764,
-0.1102356091,
0.5625576973,
-0.5135784745,
1.0037795305,
0.4033384919,
-0.2767881453,
-0.6382346153,
-0.0733156651,
-0.3228837252,
-0.2486790866,
0.9579765201,
0.1520265788,
0.239307791,
-0.0656473711,
-0.510096848,
-0.5769530535,
1.1304235458,
0.6314783692,
-1.1972386837,
0.0190002229,
0.3837077022,
0.317049861,
-0.3532023132,
0.1565745622,
0.2969482839,
0.3231717944,
0.5139496922,
-0.8572484255,
-0.0683152452,
-0.2298912108,
0.252554059,
0.1884356141,
-0.3676341772,
1.0108734369,
-0.0702094659,
-0.6300192475,
-0.1154365912,
0.5050145388,
-0.0279226638,
0.5535154939,
0.4428042769,
0.6770976186,
0.8234372735,
-0.2426297218,
0.7237278819,
-0.2887337506,
0.5319939852,
1.2774266005,
-0.204415828,
0.6033260822,
0.5934918523,
-0.2163879871,
0.2592941523,
0.258038938,
0.2786073089,
0.9244850278,
0.4111610949,
-0.3378702402,
0.1042268723,
-0.0420530327,
-0.452406317,
0.3432516754,
0.2948975563,
-0.4207100868,
-0.3540326655,
0.5800542831,
0.0701864511,
0.3523757458,
-0.3488475382,
0.9523312449,
0.0858250037,
-0.5362792015,
0.6939736605,
-0.0983373076,
0.6544082165,
-0.5863485932,
-0.1814810932,
-0.1431811601,
0.3561508358,
0.2077112496,
-0.5181720853,
0.346681118,
-0.0217399783,
-0.4040084183,
-0.3268812299,
0.8141267896,
-0.9886079431,
-0.6452339292,
0.2291561514,
-0.0500075966,
0.1880615652,
-0.2358002961,
-0.3335262239,
0.1990963221,
-0.0239890181,
-0.1349565387,
-0.0174642615,
0.929138124,
0.3059338629,
0.8332021832,
0.2532249689,
0.3909990191,
0.0451605506,
-0.3564792871,
0.9996555448,
-0.4851403534,
-0.646306932,
-1.0705316067,
0.2550333142,
-0.2641384304,
-0.1038395166,
0.5308645368,
0.4441619515,
1.0426664352,
0.0260196179,
1.1285449266,
0.0232340768,
0.6754827499,
-0.5813086629,
1.0475162268,
-0.2307322174,
0.4084351957,
-0.6197323203,
-1.0197305679,
0.0420653075,
0.6922937036,
-0.1551595479,
-0.0897934884,
0.7348557115,
0.3694835901,
0.020851234,
0.1432648897,
0.1973119378,
0.5086309314,
0.1876503676,
0.5555425882,
0.4524164498,
-0.2607101798,
0.6536027789,
-0.4228859246,
-0.2866264284,
-0.3150280118,
-0.8636729121,
-1.0386929512,
-1.0732029676,
-0.3655347526,
-0.1079842299,
-0.0886761621,
0.539624393,
0.586533308,
-0.4613370001,
-0.2994600236,
-0.2691653967,
0.3625211716,
-0.1246290952,
-0.2589036822,
0.2841450572,
-0.2631739676,
-0.5808758736,
-0.3548186123,
0.0942462459,
0.27683869,
-0.3617489338,
-0.0941411853,
-0.3686843216,
0.0972222909,
0.3281005323,
-0.0085054543,
-0.2923836708,
-0.0338749439,
-0.5297880769,
-0.0938963592,
-0.0152525483,
1.070630908,
-0.8962746859,
0.8250456452,
0.6417008042,
0.6481117606,
0.749215126,
0.0374139957,
0.730425179,
-0.9066853523,
0.3904566169,
0.1887544096,
0.0427959114,
0.2190562934,
-0.4140462875,
0.2604899108,
0.4532571137,
-0.2280582488,
-0.8976470828,
0.0655665472,
-0.7276483774,
-0.6531903148,
0.7193811536,
-0.5810226202,
-0.3575930297,
-0.2588766217,
-0.4296304584,
0.4730558097,
-0.3829477727,
0.9342542291,
1.2146402597,
0.2337129116,
-0.1630507857,
-0.4492138922,
0.5298787951,
-0.0525077358,
-0.4575493634,
0.2466664165,
0.199264124,
-0.0270011369,
0.2792111933,
0.4488277435,
0.0940653905,
-0.3460325301,
0.1947777122,
0.3397149742,
-0.2585193515,
-0.3747007251,
0.2876518965,
0.2400239557,
-0.3655324876,
-0.189669311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05451v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05451v1
|
All Should Be Equal in the Eyes of Language Models: Counterfactually Aware Fair Text Generation
| 2023-11-09T15:39:40 | 2023-11-09T15:39:40 |
Pragyan Banerjee, Abhinav Java, Surgan Jandial, Simra Shahid, Shaz Furniturewala, Balaji Krishnamurthy, Sumit Bhatia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Fairness in Language Models (LMs) remains a longstanding challenge, given the
inherent biases in training data that can be perpetuated by models and affect
the downstream tasks. Recent methods employ expensive retraining or attempt
debiasing during inference by constraining model outputs to contrast from a
reference set of biased templates or exemplars. Regardless, they dont address
the primary goal of fairness to maintain equitability across different
demographic groups. In this work, we posit that inferencing LMs to generate
unbiased output for one demographic under a context ensues from being aware of
outputs for other demographics under the same context. To this end, we propose
Counterfactually Aware Fair InferencE (CAFIE), a framework that dynamically
compares the model understanding of diverse demographics to generate more
equitable sentences. We conduct an extensive empirical evaluation using base
LMs of varying sizes and across three diverse datasets and found that CAFIE
outperforms strong baselines. CAFIE produces fairer text and strikes the best
balance between fairness and language modeling capability
|
[
-0.0332114957,
-0.4910257161,
0.6140902042,
0.2902253866,
0.1498747915,
-0.1884375513,
-0.0775111765,
-0.4797349572,
-0.1210600361,
0.4370374084,
-0.5545680523,
-0.0842724964,
-0.7850645781,
0.0737157762,
-0.407104969,
1.0123102665,
0.0808978528,
0.2786461115,
-0.4005323946,
-0.3093521297,
-0.3637083173,
-0.5536649823,
-0.5909488201,
-0.4781487882,
0.2571197748,
0.3494980633,
0.6917282939,
0.5671506524,
-0.0445108451,
0.3735547066,
0.3484441936,
-0.1731206328,
-0.7331016064,
-0.0408048742,
-0.3695544302,
-0.4896818697,
-0.1994558871,
0.3239983916,
0.3624031246,
0.8345099092,
-0.1957531422,
0.2457653582,
-0.0319560952,
0.6073915958,
-0.8406693339,
-0.2548076212,
-0.9323773384,
0.081770651,
-0.0811198801,
0.0710340664,
-0.519295454,
-0.5870471001,
-0.0487657972,
-0.7345035672,
0.3641223609,
0.3231832385,
0.8113734722,
0.3809155822,
-0.5940635204,
-0.2279176861,
-0.2783876956,
1.0483993292,
-0.7515266538,
0.485152632,
0.2253361195,
0.182683751,
-0.339905709,
-0.77002877,
-0.8108426929,
0.1864337027,
-0.1730431169,
0.2056321651,
-0.5381289124,
-0.0138646616,
0.2045675665,
0.065955691,
-0.6224735379,
0.2865437269,
-0.0876284838,
-0.2083333284,
0.4266734719,
-0.1173856109,
0.416405648,
-0.0264028572,
-0.2125969231,
0.2927186489,
-0.6362447739,
0.1634156108,
0.7730813026,
0.3254258931,
-0.0858730376,
0.350984931,
-0.2426935136,
0.3992189169,
0.1642540842,
0.0418692082,
0.4841408432,
-0.0353104137,
-0.5508071184,
0.1634569615,
0.79037714,
0.3690769076,
0.87845397,
-0.3094862103,
-0.2745181918,
0.2822616398,
0.1936198026,
-1.0589058399,
0.0598905198,
0.1847718358,
-0.6723285317,
-0.2709609568,
-0.1849219501,
-0.8209726214,
-0.2262799889,
-0.1700528264,
0.2616045773,
0.0943563432,
-0.4041976333,
0.2191427946,
-0.0441115387,
-0.3026034534,
0.0894217417,
-0.9365506172,
0.3012998104,
0.4986695051,
0.2508566976,
0.3686216474,
-0.1944606006,
-0.7074613571,
0.183286041,
-0.1287064701,
0.4213656783,
-0.6792340875,
-0.1739234924,
0.0438552722,
-0.0434250459,
-0.3008165956,
-0.4024754465,
0.6455016732,
-0.1807243377,
0.4859039485,
-0.4535622597,
-0.62456429,
-0.0141738839,
-0.1592417061,
-0.6176617146,
0.7613041401,
0.1494216621,
-0.772736609,
0.7828588486,
-0.3590082228,
-0.4310621321,
-0.0983082056,
-0.6419410706,
-0.5628174543,
0.2803883553,
0.3149987459,
0.1567622125,
-0.2351543307,
0.8275286555,
-0.4676127136,
-0.2892329693,
0.2358413339,
-0.6626914144,
0.8051018715,
0.4139975905,
-0.7022579312,
-0.039832212,
-0.5702174306,
0.1178457364,
0.2786316574,
-0.100083366,
-0.1686114669,
-0.0353579745,
0.1532710642,
0.3269783258,
-0.1100692451,
-0.806194067,
-0.3831579983,
-0.390810132,
0.1804460287,
0.8570227623,
-0.4874764681,
0.6696754694,
-0.4440039396,
0.1684883684,
0.008823229,
0.1870808005,
0.0658076257,
-0.2879786193,
-0.5518867373,
-0.6241838932,
0.2242080867,
0.5820596218,
-0.500797689,
0.3140030205,
-0.1863603145,
-0.1312438399,
-0.7593106031,
0.1243869439,
0.5084571838,
0.6089416146,
-0.0005962546,
-0.1783901751,
-0.6661687493,
-1.0353666544,
-0.5677432418,
-0.2946744859,
0.1201326177,
0.4036548138,
0.3024622202,
0.0556921326,
1.0299551487,
-0.141477555,
-0.0564321913,
-0.3150433302,
0.1420427561,
-0.0263212509,
0.5403189659,
1.094438076,
-0.8594565392,
-0.1663573831,
-0.4061141014,
-0.8435829282,
-0.7946223617,
-0.0922749415,
-0.4190677702,
0.2639012039,
0.478518635,
-0.3795844316,
0.4982715845,
0.4903143048,
-0.625485003,
-0.0866963565,
0.1201742068,
0.5113112926,
-0.731259346,
0.1935071349,
-0.059812557,
-0.5966157913,
-0.5240436196,
-0.098644942,
-0.1654768735,
0.1686346233,
-0.5462373495,
0.7114012837,
-0.0799634904,
-0.1087550521,
-0.2649544179,
0.384909153,
0.2745290101,
0.3993068039,
-0.1357550323,
0.5333773494,
0.1632710099,
-0.2111761719,
-0.1846215278,
-0.0325755887,
-0.4301119447,
0.4984269142,
-0.5765936375,
-0.1352176964,
-0.6566238403,
0.3169972301,
-0.8305446506,
0.1284110248,
0.2238040119,
-0.6378279924,
-0.0263483506,
0.0189102758,
-0.2216657698,
-0.1863273531,
0.0068550869,
0.7197706103,
0.5272215605,
-0.4860630035,
0.6585862637,
0.5795628428,
-0.1009786054,
-1.1152523756,
-0.9646058679,
-0.1669079363,
-0.0011753371,
-0.4323464334,
0.0475338995,
-0.1377746761,
-0.5408822298,
0.0487416536,
-0.0757665634,
-0.1112771779,
0.3165883422,
0.2724904418,
0.0928771645,
-0.0316440389,
0.2225986272,
0.036010962,
0.1179872975,
-0.1020534337,
-0.3109689355,
0.3355643749,
0.116512239,
-0.4418205321,
-0.1160290465,
0.517375648,
0.1583389491,
-0.1523797363,
0.7697822452,
0.5435539484,
-0.5650945306,
-0.1525102705,
-0.6285236478,
0.0882237107,
-0.4333386719,
0.466172576,
-0.3584036231,
-1.155215621,
0.6558548808,
0.3517436981,
0.3880059421,
0.427829802,
0.5222216249,
0.1639056653,
0.9477930665,
0.7791631222,
0.0283020567,
0.3747098446,
0.4511571825,
0.5238977075,
-0.1005383804,
-0.3505772948,
-0.930136621,
-0.1776760519,
-0.6383497715,
-0.0185681693,
-0.3804207444,
0.2363233566,
-0.4184173942,
-0.1728729755,
-0.3516674638,
0.5853556991,
0.3236351013,
0.011833312,
0.1943267435,
-0.0910333246,
-0.0793868154,
-0.377481401,
-0.8655988574,
-0.7822435498,
1.0314872265,
0.2743188739,
0.5794435143,
0.3241807222,
0.5626202226,
0.5217478275,
0.8552914262,
-0.4143829048,
0.3222478628,
-0.710390687,
-0.8125554919,
-0.1077584326,
-0.8023843169,
-0.7857134938,
0.342125684,
-0.2590581179,
-0.6014013886,
0.5134342909,
0.3126333952,
-0.1129163504,
0.3301182985,
-0.6664866805,
1.095890522,
-0.0795026869,
-0.3336389363,
-0.1977424622,
-0.396275878,
0.4655252099,
-0.1874863654,
0.5084911585,
-0.5686340332,
0.1761938184,
0.6219320893,
-0.4106835723,
0.8112422228,
-0.2814509273,
0.0523502491,
0.2849573493,
0.1448394209,
0.0763846636,
0.003882498,
-0.3609322906,
0.1915392429,
-0.3040405512,
-0.7395368814,
-0.4561194181,
0.8070501685,
-0.7840676308,
-0.5736983418,
-0.3167604506,
-0.4746344686,
0.0622127391,
0.2279502749,
0.2197398692,
0.4252818227,
-0.6108727455,
-0.0745291337,
0.586926043,
-0.3260300457,
0.4452513754,
0.6210559607,
-0.2331945747,
-0.18474482,
0.5496278405,
-0.0751448274,
0.309997052,
0.2906539738,
-0.2237663418,
-0.2636473179,
-0.0823971033,
-0.6358698606,
-0.1218600273,
-0.8866064548,
-0.1517852098,
-0.9803507924,
0.0323680341,
-0.536249876,
-0.3593018651,
-0.3479987085,
-0.5043541789,
-0.0158330239,
-0.0821006373,
0.0898858234,
0.6337912083,
-0.2365106344,
0.4607415199,
-0.3786515296,
0.2931362092,
0.4225221872,
0.1586496234,
0.199452281,
-0.4896124601,
0.041579742,
0.242240563,
-0.161133334,
-0.5309631824,
0.1237109452,
0.2835324407,
1.0020303726,
-0.0572866537,
0.0587203242,
0.3715488315,
-0.6855745316,
0.5788708329,
0.4855281711,
-1.2354831696,
0.1979203671,
-0.049262397,
0.1148398221,
0.698776722,
0.1014695093,
-0.5772105455,
-0.7236379385,
-0.4668707252,
-0.8310979605,
0.6652011275,
0.3531115651,
0.2342140079,
-0.3439597487,
0.2228344828,
0.4255985022,
0.4253189266,
-1.2654310465,
-0.0569313206,
-0.6311224699,
-0.9522305131,
0.3045968711,
0.0424328297,
0.0783288032,
0.2861053646,
0.6565511227,
-0.1163325608,
0.0059382622,
0.2084034383,
-0.4756804705,
-0.3392590284,
0.5779272318,
0.3326505423,
0.8065179586,
-0.1511222869,
0.0981712937,
0.1217204779,
-0.2609345913,
0.2647740245,
0.0603586584,
-0.1843578964,
0.0796632394,
0.330930233,
0.8467369676,
0.0399746224,
-0.7636185288,
0.8484495282,
-0.3620454073,
-0.2487913072,
0.1426070482,
0.0932143331,
-0.1067283526,
0.1685177237,
0.374438107,
0.1742061675,
0.1134184524,
-0.5292248726,
0.4059672654,
0.4149281979,
-0.2879735827,
0.0406448208,
1.0156159401,
0.5311385393,
-0.0425335094,
0.6000865102,
-0.1485075653,
-0.4500983953,
0.7627149224,
0.5331166387,
0.9312815666,
-0.2288892418,
0.245595783,
0.252505213,
0.5826252103,
-0.0911668167,
0.2083784938,
0.238445133,
-0.9420001507,
-0.4233872294,
-0.6250314713,
0.0628920272,
-0.0266967062,
-0.3563596904,
0.0099117029,
-0.346165508,
-0.1741962582,
0.1055243239,
-0.291702956,
-0.8844497204,
0.641700983,
0.0669227913,
0.7361986637,
-1.2185684443,
0.4510067999,
0.2712387741,
-0.497279346,
-0.3434732258,
-0.0497545041,
-0.0915263593,
-0.9146099687,
0.8578412533,
0.2766804993,
-0.3469385803,
-0.3434021771,
-0.6000386477,
-0.2988594472,
0.5894129872,
0.9522200823,
-0.9006511569,
0.1860395372,
0.3610464036,
0.3452059925,
-0.8490979075,
0.5700590611,
0.2513590157,
0.4230293036,
-0.1834855676,
-0.8799698353,
0.1556851268,
-0.254139781,
-0.1836773008,
0.0080309361,
-0.6574594975,
0.7886917591,
-0.2860509157,
-0.3332931995,
-0.0145219676,
0.5840957165,
0.2268556803,
0.5372229815,
0.8090761304,
0.6877285242,
0.8088263273,
-0.2317751497,
0.8782397509,
-0.0650684908,
-0.0811741501,
1.2722300291,
-0.4524167776,
0.312256217,
0.1642429829,
0.1749923378,
0.2928575575,
0.5643972158,
0.2612951696,
0.5181569457,
0.3032115102,
-0.1633325815,
-0.5439250469,
-0.4489043951,
-0.2425405681,
0.3651451468,
-0.1698094904,
-0.4815953374,
-0.1320759803,
-0.1070125327,
0.3576256037,
0.7759515643,
-0.3109236658,
0.5151187181,
0.164744556,
-0.5650181174,
0.145419389,
0.0662148446,
0.7030284405,
-0.397760272,
0.076363191,
-0.2843111455,
0.2156089395,
-0.2582044303,
-0.6860215068,
0.1361881644,
0.1528268754,
-0.6489204168,
-0.1088016704,
0.5721582174,
-0.7102236152,
-0.565621376,
0.4577233791,
0.758063674,
0.0284260586,
0.2626945674,
-0.7331585288,
0.0065123551,
0.3675547242,
-0.1270284504,
0.0606995001,
0.645177722,
-0.2220473439,
0.5152461529,
0.3086502552,
-0.0446391739,
0.0235555321,
0.8167971969,
0.4830474854,
-0.3620584607,
-0.5099762082,
-0.9033699036,
0.5219328403,
-0.1973925233,
-0.3233689368,
0.4482641518,
0.5145045519,
0.9645246863,
0.3629060388,
0.9690075517,
-0.0276438147,
0.355600059,
-0.3373776674,
0.7605804205,
-0.716426909,
0.0354097076,
-0.1605718583,
-0.9558628201,
0.1405110955,
0.4552510977,
-0.0676646754,
0.5549498796,
0.4124576449,
0.72574687,
-0.0666266754,
0.3532879949,
0.2684261203,
0.0641232952,
0.3234468102,
0.714104116,
0.5305014849,
-0.5419718027,
0.4788669646,
0.4927914441,
-0.2950253189,
0.2417806685,
-0.9852762818,
-0.8514160514,
-0.1846457273,
-0.1921560764,
-0.22131069,
0.3529356718,
1.1179997921,
0.6900990605,
-0.8212509155,
-0.1003818214,
0.1481630355,
0.1014074236,
0.2757437527,
-0.1991382986,
-0.0663116276,
-0.309522599,
-0.9718131423,
-0.0406326503,
0.0212472323,
0.0003928513,
0.0393080637,
-0.1999672353,
-0.2572563291,
0.5863922238,
0.2969195247,
0.0684817508,
-0.4952780306,
-0.342387706,
-0.4408315718,
-0.4132471681,
-0.1717517972,
0.9065268636,
-0.8500013351,
0.3141056001,
0.4498604238,
0.6429188251,
0.0212104041,
-0.379852742,
0.9015321732,
-0.8157353401,
0.4534943402,
0.0413926542,
0.6232297421,
0.6273157001,
-0.3525462747,
0.4644160271,
0.2224071026,
-0.5755334496,
-0.8350256681,
0.3611764014,
-0.3939875066,
-0.6291256547,
0.7498056293,
-0.2589411438,
-0.1732412875,
-0.1975527704,
0.055194661,
0.6735954881,
-0.5756531954,
0.6537442207,
0.5510780215,
0.2704575956,
-0.0727137551,
-0.3955194652,
0.4571306109,
0.903193593,
-0.8609499335,
0.225161314,
0.5647899508,
0.1900915504,
-0.3167325556,
0.8721016645,
-0.0949138179,
0.1177988797,
-0.0722761303,
0.4688400924,
0.0659759492,
0.015781885,
0.1078166068,
-0.0331318714,
-0.1772722155,
0.0581320859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05450v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05450v1
|
Cognitively Inspired Components for Social Conversational Agents
| 2023-11-09T15:38:58 | 2023-11-09T15:38:58 |
Alex Clay, Eduardo Alonso, Esther Mondragón
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0
|
Current conversational agents (CA) have seen improvement in conversational
quality in recent years due to the influence of large language models (LLMs)
like GPT3. However, two key categories of problem remain. Firstly there are the
unique technical problems resulting from the approach taken in creating the CA,
such as scope with retrieval agents and the often nonsensical answers of former
generative agents. Secondly, humans perceive CAs as social actors, and as a
result expect the CA to adhere to social convention. Failure on the part of the
CA in this respect can lead to a poor interaction and even the perception of
threat by the user. As such, this paper presents a survey highlighting a
potential solution to both categories of problem through the introduction of
cognitively inspired additions to the CA. Through computational facsimiles of
semantic and episodic memory, emotion, working memory, and the ability to
learn, it is possible to address both the technical and social problems
encountered by CAs.
|
[
-0.2633750141,
-1.1140857935,
0.8860644698,
0.2677321732,
-0.0077055437,
0.7130740285,
-0.3149714768,
-0.699483633,
0.614733696,
0.5357149243,
-0.6281479001,
-0.4055991769,
-0.4558607638,
-0.0588810556,
-0.2361890376,
0.7682394981,
0.3977420926,
-0.2145534158,
-0.2572431862,
0.0690683499,
-0.5597919822,
-0.8172659278,
-0.9356713295,
-0.3781618476,
0.5332190394,
0.3900050521,
0.907466054,
0.087186642,
0.168386355,
0.4188682437,
-0.0485846661,
0.2849309146,
-0.657969296,
0.2330527008,
-0.2247097939,
-0.5016816258,
-0.4035707712,
-0.283734113,
0.0910797641,
0.5597510338,
-0.2791249454,
-0.4447480738,
0.2447858006,
0.4990890026,
-0.3166148365,
0.7478870749,
-0.8699945211,
-0.1110005826,
0.0628672615,
-0.3741665483,
-0.4437640607,
-0.3041649461,
0.2411340773,
-0.9048480988,
0.1367408782,
-0.1878903657,
0.5996287465,
0.1198374406,
-0.3155919015,
-0.6796287298,
-0.8399657011,
0.5375048518,
-0.3456602693,
-0.0160469804,
0.4354629517,
0.2628225088,
-0.4615225196,
-0.4010493457,
-0.5426912308,
-0.4367659986,
0.3542460799,
0.2040686905,
-0.2462070733,
0.0962359682,
-0.0181201268,
-0.0650679767,
-0.274281621,
-0.0672720149,
-0.2627066076,
-0.4077338278,
0.6786368489,
0.6137856841,
0.6025442481,
0.1228882074,
-0.0487188585,
-0.2151408792,
-0.4680555463,
0.0619238839,
0.1759654135,
0.1774175167,
-0.2309240997,
0.2453770787,
-0.4315888882,
0.2496275902,
0.158163622,
0.1791049838,
0.0822053626,
-0.1962423772,
0.3093333244,
0.1456495374,
0.4705458283,
0.2717152238,
0.5783082843,
-0.1500837058,
0.075418584,
0.5108124018,
0.3962980509,
-0.4197306037,
-0.2137564123,
0.0291721877,
-0.0549849197,
-0.6049752235,
0.0380669534,
-0.3631965518,
-0.6240338087,
-0.3825770617,
0.1662491113,
-0.5574923754,
-0.4244071543,
0.0176563486,
-0.0938396901,
0.4542163014,
0.7298334241,
-0.914222002,
0.3405325115,
0.7889432311,
0.656784296,
-0.0321495831,
0.0557119548,
0.044235412,
0.1914969236,
-0.2587572932,
0.9169615507,
-0.7176789641,
-0.6835980415,
0.1451345086,
-0.0103495494,
0.0767245516,
-0.2792623639,
-0.0135598043,
-0.4806362391,
-0.1637396961,
-0.5416855812,
-0.0983990356,
0.0263799727,
0.372564584,
-0.3626834452,
0.8003021479,
0.0399554595,
-0.3005100489,
-0.1164782122,
-0.7020599246,
-0.4087954462,
0.4147977829,
-0.4606404305,
0.1290036142,
0.1658965051,
0.071088396,
0.4096231461,
-0.5002250075,
0.3016545475,
-0.4087467492,
-0.2066080719,
0.7465738058,
-0.4598778486,
0.7156048417,
0.3426671028,
-0.3058715761,
0.1666132212,
-0.6022261381,
0.0460047834,
0.2715974748,
0.0222783834,
-0.2081321031,
0.1923730224,
-0.1397387534,
0.2485928386,
0.1641002148,
-0.5825071931,
-0.30818367,
-0.3199167252,
0.6027539372,
1.0625315905,
0.3946419358,
0.2464782745,
-0.5660464168,
0.4452418387,
-0.0976790264,
0.3429813981,
0.1353143156,
-0.7328003049,
-0.7847700119,
-0.1919240803,
-0.486856699,
0.585319519,
-1.3710045815,
0.2669439018,
-0.2727038264,
-0.8253692389,
-0.0266079493,
0.0391628519,
0.3408507109,
0.0379519574,
-0.1054970622,
-0.4149173498,
0.0110973148,
-0.5874463916,
0.0268848296,
-0.6371220946,
0.0667643994,
0.6105084419,
0.1966972202,
-0.2440527231,
0.940315187,
-0.4859535992,
0.0287674498,
-0.2322325259,
-0.1996975839,
-0.2564550042,
0.2466048896,
0.3477838635,
-0.627792418,
-0.6268220544,
0.1530691385,
-0.9428750277,
-0.2199829668,
-0.2119947374,
-0.0766100362,
0.1841633618,
0.5013003945,
-0.9041034579,
0.5169606805,
0.1068366989,
-0.1475500762,
0.3710978031,
-0.0852238014,
0.1506940424,
-0.9836674929,
-0.4244671762,
-0.0174355637,
0.0329374224,
-0.7588201761,
-0.0855526924,
-0.3716718256,
-0.5161237121,
-0.7307953835,
0.3911968172,
-0.3348324001,
0.0926430449,
-0.3580004573,
0.4873084426,
-0.0532206297,
0.7248064876,
0.0583091117,
0.6164515615,
0.5795307159,
-0.7442166805,
0.6776678562,
0.2674680054,
-0.009376592,
0.6933097243,
-0.8211387396,
0.6685578823,
-0.2438034415,
0.400638938,
-0.9445624948,
-0.2073020041,
0.3534014523,
-0.5853872895,
-0.0035069098,
0.5021426678,
-0.4672073424,
-0.0790723935,
-0.2341859043,
0.3359318078,
0.3463262618,
-0.3563776612,
0.7290971875,
0.3326840997,
-0.4150332808,
-0.0721523315,
-0.5512647629,
0.530049324,
-0.0682386532,
-1.0072985888,
0.5001727939,
-0.1667442173,
-0.4276567698,
-0.1147531196,
0.2158126086,
0.2033608854,
0.0967818648,
0.3236148357,
0.3201723099,
0.0530821346,
0.0555504784,
-0.2556727529,
-0.2141552418,
0.2054331452,
-0.0491258055,
0.6269898415,
-0.3847043812,
-0.4050917327,
-0.6326577067,
0.3946460485,
0.6478702426,
-0.0411722027,
0.5281530023,
0.3502511978,
-0.3469007909,
-0.1017299294,
-0.7821086049,
-0.3029715419,
-0.571330905,
0.3322957158,
-0.3264105022,
-0.9807203412,
0.8235271573,
0.1561432928,
-0.262916863,
0.0034712073,
0.7310602665,
-0.0482024662,
0.8169928193,
0.2871233821,
0.0254602525,
0.9015600681,
0.041829396,
0.0228047408,
-0.431419909,
-0.4501502216,
-0.451639086,
0.1288844198,
-0.6793702841,
-0.3095394075,
0.4273819625,
-0.6321702003,
0.0038161387,
0.3449335694,
-0.4542523921,
0.1352875978,
0.313349098,
0.4905577004,
-0.0488025434,
0.1766171455,
0.1058635339,
0.3370426297,
-0.5463300943,
-0.6441017389,
0.9621396661,
0.2357993275,
0.8417534232,
0.4432372451,
0.6814753413,
0.5779443979,
0.1782663465,
-0.6615114808,
0.9596151114,
0.387087822,
-0.5936987996,
-0.2575088143,
-0.2560785413,
-1.1327069998,
-0.055896759,
-0.2898851931,
-1.1161189079,
0.3286729157,
-0.2011018991,
-0.3175438941,
-0.294980824,
-0.5042705536,
0.4805596173,
-0.1660148203,
-0.5558290482,
-0.8079984188,
-0.5545774698,
-0.053415291,
-0.0415410325,
0.047933843,
-0.2554723918,
0.2666449547,
0.5226581097,
-0.7048998475,
1.2813999653,
-0.1620977819,
-0.0431374647,
1.0681285858,
-0.0018602592,
0.7567793727,
-0.1250181049,
0.0793281421,
0.0734828487,
0.164561227,
-0.6130084991,
-1.0098158121,
0.6960889697,
-0.9795078039,
-0.9977081418,
-0.3161199093,
-0.3955232501,
-0.2710755765,
-0.3064791262,
-0.2380184978,
0.4881069064,
-0.5094098449,
0.3094257414,
0.5754602551,
-0.3435332775,
0.5105538368,
0.6469840407,
0.2826627195,
-0.5191860795,
1.015861392,
-0.0771231651,
0.579452455,
0.0660745427,
-0.1230480224,
-0.0470161885,
-0.3552479744,
-0.0928565413,
0.0929473713,
-0.7426440716,
0.0378964134,
-0.6197577119,
-0.183266893,
-0.4477196038,
-0.4232715368,
-0.1711585671,
-0.3250930309,
-0.52892524,
-0.12768583,
0.4010949135,
0.6947953105,
0.19376643,
0.6377054453,
-0.5894799829,
0.1265534014,
0.4699341953,
-0.0112192463,
0.2898315489,
-0.1524246633,
-0.1936146468,
0.0594887584,
-0.6290806532,
-1.0191926956,
0.2670693696,
-0.0092666084,
0.502056241,
0.5627445579,
0.1604503244,
0.5558457375,
-0.1133906692,
0.9501672983,
0.1663158238,
-0.6860820055,
0.5567837954,
-0.4602470696,
-0.0215713792,
0.4897791743,
-0.1263535917,
-0.4619576931,
-0.4781794548,
-0.7365774512,
-0.5984080434,
0.6382981539,
0.5114390254,
0.5371103883,
-0.5855395198,
0.3674280047,
-0.1455643922,
-0.1612671912,
-0.3549155593,
0.0059369998,
-0.3530531824,
-0.2222544998,
-0.0193810649,
-0.1825225204,
0.2706586421,
0.2155594677,
0.7427529693,
-0.1314344257,
0.420999527,
0.3248512745,
-0.046595782,
0.0723767504,
0.3137588501,
0.4027419984,
0.3664485216,
-0.0266203042,
-0.1324176192,
0.2122168094,
-0.3951756656,
0.3168676496,
-0.3410741687,
0.1184413508,
-0.5307530165,
0.0230720621,
0.5038419366,
0.1994649321,
-0.5330665708,
0.3811737597,
-0.0362200625,
0.081046924,
-0.757491529,
0.4498030841,
0.0193805285,
0.4055593014,
0.4394450188,
-0.0203059893,
0.0822214112,
-1.0459725857,
0.0135469185,
0.6981698275,
-0.7496719956,
-0.4949415922,
0.4193419814,
0.569466114,
-0.8475446701,
0.4961406887,
-0.1921172738,
-0.5197428465,
0.8050435185,
0.7198347449,
0.9530392289,
-0.076512754,
0.3142552674,
-0.2765531838,
0.2601135969,
0.1034491137,
0.2584341466,
-0.3327705264,
-1.1240291595,
-0.0591768362,
-0.0065509588,
-0.6284188628,
-0.2493875325,
-0.5385790467,
0.2606331706,
-0.7344412804,
-0.5068926215,
0.0472662859,
-0.0133826016,
-0.8112020493,
0.0528753102,
0.2939098775,
0.4715191424,
-0.5734565258,
0.8237006068,
0.6481106877,
-0.3942142427,
-0.4853489399,
-0.2567683458,
0.1874560118,
-0.8250980377,
0.4121280611,
-0.0131310606,
-0.4660294056,
-0.0387036353,
-0.5918824077,
-0.7012482285,
1.2037117481,
0.2786000371,
-0.0966571644,
-0.073884517,
0.3937184811,
0.6506605148,
-0.5085949898,
0.2925318182,
0.393783927,
0.2114120573,
0.2933070958,
-0.6723723412,
0.3509121835,
-0.593737185,
0.2506204545,
-0.2006379813,
-0.9969401956,
0.2978445292,
-0.0525193103,
-0.3540726304,
0.0803164691,
0.7717162371,
0.3052436709,
0.6932795048,
0.401958853,
-0.0150121814,
0.5868647695,
-0.0027926299,
0.9684247971,
-0.383634299,
-0.0592010207,
0.6904430389,
-0.521440804,
0.3288671374,
0.1350962371,
-0.163654238,
0.6185474992,
0.4996774495,
0.3949893117,
0.3339110017,
0.1089067385,
-0.6774500608,
-0.3721942306,
-0.4121646881,
-0.1992929131,
0.512999773,
0.969840169,
-0.1210897565,
0.1443463862,
-0.0050482624,
-0.0040936531,
0.2819491625,
-0.1534446329,
1.071310401,
0.215627417,
-0.5263670683,
0.292865783,
-0.1217184514,
0.4124526381,
-0.4379368424,
-0.0307857189,
-0.0871680081,
-0.135630548,
-0.0304017942,
-0.3752679825,
0.143158555,
-0.294988364,
0.1150765792,
-0.0120949,
0.9873088598,
-0.0312260371,
-0.3002866209,
0.307143569,
0.5048028231,
0.3563522398,
-0.2662067413,
-0.6239873767,
0.1233798936,
-0.0123868864,
-0.0806143358,
0.1457122862,
0.7007536888,
-0.3963960409,
0.8676475883,
0.8176403046,
-0.1285480559,
-0.1899585277,
0.0295856725,
1.0519764423,
-0.9208464622,
-0.6014849544,
-0.7347297668,
0.3038639724,
-0.2152121663,
-0.0302557927,
0.4172728658,
0.0314712338,
0.2814501822,
0.0656252056,
0.8229752779,
0.0497711189,
-0.1457779557,
-0.267067343,
0.6149279475,
0.0115756346,
0.3437379897,
-0.700711906,
-1.0039750338,
0.0438845418,
0.3725740612,
-0.4382241964,
0.0520681068,
0.4901152551,
1.0456933975,
0.4317775965,
0.4800928235,
0.6003938913,
-0.022682447,
0.6305077672,
0.9012218714,
1.2419441938,
0.0794295371,
0.6230529547,
0.0723086074,
-0.4404512644,
-0.3478749692,
-0.4981091619,
-0.9725556374,
-0.5422772765,
-0.6039451957,
-0.4464226067,
0.2796835303,
1.1104478836,
0.4255425036,
-0.5303513408,
0.0386021361,
-0.1664260179,
0.0873184875,
0.0504181832,
-0.2749349773,
0.1000886187,
-0.4132510722,
-0.4226774275,
0.4403115511,
0.3688964844,
0.168670103,
-0.2884548604,
-0.2243694365,
0.1467342228,
0.6521464586,
0.8887898326,
0.326513797,
-0.8337451816,
-0.7135491371,
-0.051446043,
-0.1483930498,
-0.1484040022,
0.631242156,
-0.7273119092,
0.4189275801,
0.0727615878,
0.6514559388,
0.5703263879,
-0.0230919775,
0.4737109244,
-0.3651844859,
0.1914956123,
0.0652954578,
0.154266268,
0.3441373706,
-0.7332621217,
0.5150312781,
0.3324865997,
-0.3512409031,
-0.3483251631,
0.4205936491,
-1.1846393347,
-0.0150062516,
1.1268422604,
-0.071353972,
-0.371317625,
-0.4815499485,
-0.4255682826,
0.2203438431,
-0.7128750086,
0.9426294565,
0.8629594445,
-0.3292408586,
0.0252074152,
-0.295458138,
0.1552184224,
0.5625799894,
-0.8106541038,
0.0530154109,
0.6719607115,
0.140400663,
0.3979235291,
0.8333117962,
-0.2779143155,
0.3266771734,
0.2110775709,
0.1638947278,
-0.0406621508,
-0.1435983479,
0.0839967206,
0.1356021315,
0.2686521113,
-0.0384365469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05437v1
|
LLaVA-Plus: Learning to Use Tools for Creating Multimodal Agents
| 2023-11-09T15:22:26 | 2023-11-09T15:22:26 |
Shilong Liu, Hao Cheng, Haotian Liu, Hao Zhang, Feng Li, Tianhe Ren, Xueyan Zou, Jianwei Yang, Hang Su, Jun Zhu, Lei Zhang, Jianfeng Gao, Chunyuan Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
LLaVA-Plus is a general-purpose multimodal assistant that expands the
capabilities of large multimodal models. It maintains a skill repository of
pre-trained vision and vision-language models and can activate relevant tools
based on users' inputs to fulfill real-world tasks. LLaVA-Plus is trained on
multimodal instruction-following data to acquire the ability to use tools,
covering visual understanding, generation, external knowledge retrieval, and
compositions. Empirical results show that LLaVA-Plus outperforms LLaVA in
existing capabilities and exhibits new ones. It is distinct in that the image
query is directly grounded and actively engaged throughout the entire human-AI
interaction sessions, significantly improving tool use performance and enabling
new scenarios.
|
[
-0.4217389226,
-0.6431062818,
0.6595142484,
0.1308800578,
-0.2357173562,
0.3545794785,
0.1410466582,
-0.8573068976,
0.4438689947,
0.3212998807,
-0.5683130622,
-0.2976933122,
-0.5313067436,
-0.1226715744,
-0.2798008025,
0.6241521239,
0.0618378408,
0.1593066305,
-0.6011897326,
-0.2440386862,
-0.7818848491,
-0.3683851063,
-0.5579689145,
-0.2677641809,
1.0246582031,
0.5210024118,
0.7736546397,
0.1021425352,
0.6045550108,
0.4566851556,
0.4451861382,
0.4735693932,
-0.08809264,
0.4800900817,
0.0022624242,
-0.774303019,
-0.9180545211,
-0.0210581739,
0.2966525853,
0.2092498541,
0.0854697675,
0.2781704068,
-0.2262924314,
0.3510112762,
-0.8287967443,
0.1908808053,
-0.4078908265,
-0.1474712789,
-0.2736845315,
-0.4009370804,
-0.2184510678,
-0.2946145833,
0.0169728454,
-0.9415749311,
-0.1404622346,
-0.2070859224,
0.8420040607,
0.2144082189,
-0.9190798998,
-0.3396134973,
-0.5380991101,
0.8776732087,
0.0655474216,
0.5443990231,
0.3115406036,
0.7828606367,
0.0026191231,
-0.7840476036,
-0.645958364,
-0.4000898004,
-0.0061423574,
0.1241887212,
0.1535860598,
0.3013656735,
0.1565288901,
0.1143762767,
-0.2454612553,
-0.1275969595,
-0.4552402198,
-0.304120928,
0.7748713493,
0.1809160709,
0.4560240209,
0.1381406039,
-0.5014771819,
-0.3267440796,
-0.6346303821,
0.1586249024,
0.2045216262,
-0.0787069201,
0.1556335241,
0.6690027714,
-0.093343474,
0.6993293166,
-0.208968997,
-0.672694087,
0.6039720774,
-0.3219118118,
-0.4482502937,
-0.360055536,
0.1871324778,
0.4074927568,
0.2898771465,
-0.0319564492,
-0.2358971834,
0.2758751512,
0.2317142189,
-0.4190917313,
0.1227341369,
0.2005138248,
-0.1205458343,
-0.3258225024,
-0.4367472529,
-0.4958063066,
-0.597841382,
-0.624981463,
0.5829611421,
-0.3603287637,
-0.3313207626,
-0.2008950114,
-0.3839388192,
0.6344799995,
0.9492275715,
-0.4265116155,
0.0766616911,
0.2612050176,
0.6768741012,
-0.2610121071,
-0.6847326159,
-0.60273844,
0.2076488584,
-0.3526590168,
1.1318665743,
-0.8298006654,
-0.4452562928,
-0.1251753569,
0.1696441919,
0.0448874943,
-0.2861575782,
0.1753357202,
-0.7004397511,
-0.0231019892,
-0.2348346412,
-0.1723579466,
-0.5345641971,
0.6057852507,
-0.7366935015,
0.9038590789,
0.1878402382,
-0.198172614,
0.7128881812,
-0.7741981745,
-0.3576943874,
0.2697735131,
-0.3708923757,
-0.1933921576,
0.0584918223,
0.3563111722,
0.4726191759,
-0.3455193639,
0.2615071535,
-0.3182007074,
-0.2443695962,
0.3625128269,
-0.4792875648,
0.8304536939,
0.0795549601,
0.1442504376,
0.5669606924,
-0.8804998398,
-0.1529260129,
0.1893250495,
-0.5352931023,
-0.3899278343,
-0.360204488,
0.0801261216,
0.2373977453,
0.4520356357,
-0.5771253705,
0.3729031682,
0.1297895908,
-0.1375189424,
0.763939321,
-0.2742653489,
0.5396716595,
-0.3871934116,
0.8602641225,
-0.1048143432,
0.447047323,
-0.5160184503,
-0.6381559968,
-0.7725613713,
-0.5981404781,
-0.0603925511,
0.7060586214,
-1.1924008131,
-0.2567327619,
-0.1621414423,
-0.3639154136,
-0.7173650861,
0.5502553582,
0.4590139091,
0.1774031967,
0.1185606495,
-0.4036610723,
-0.6119582057,
-0.8482695222,
0.3316427469,
0.1516716331,
0.0604049601,
0.5482276082,
0.4935159087,
-0.5398843884,
0.6119741201,
-0.2277538031,
-0.483045131,
-0.4186947644,
-0.2587703764,
-0.0324743837,
0.2228035033,
0.5691974163,
-0.9674935341,
-0.5770456195,
0.1955150068,
-1.1421326399,
0.3496724069,
-0.217819944,
-0.2082613856,
0.108541958,
0.3928110301,
-0.8171806335,
0.4443457723,
0.5885851979,
-0.3243620992,
0.6925276518,
-0.3175019026,
0.4275771976,
-1.0191107988,
-0.0114943646,
-0.2292695343,
-0.4587190747,
-0.7041237354,
0.4912526309,
0.2039176077,
-0.2940325737,
-0.8800354004,
0.6493127942,
-0.6750065684,
-0.438693881,
-0.1480685323,
0.0992602706,
0.3377574682,
0.5689915419,
-0.1075173393,
1.1737072468,
0.8990421295,
-0.654340148,
0.8970316052,
0.1369470209,
-0.2868007421,
0.7799195647,
-0.5974004269,
0.2769426703,
-0.1256676614,
-0.0367976651,
-1.0068666935,
-0.5848864913,
0.0256881267,
-0.4065787792,
0.3408509493,
0.1817434281,
-0.5261628032,
-0.0920816585,
-0.6070554256,
0.540717423,
0.1875091344,
-0.4436506927,
1.1510335207,
0.4571449757,
0.0964492485,
-0.7765455842,
-0.6694758534,
0.1910360605,
-0.1562626064,
-0.7868723273,
0.1158874035,
-0.0399381518,
-0.2824217975,
-0.1862352341,
0.3741645515,
-0.2152782083,
0.2107209563,
0.3808895051,
0.4579266608,
-0.0245448481,
0.4108318388,
0.0889091641,
-0.1275161058,
-0.2144980431,
0.3356621265,
0.5175848007,
-0.1741850078,
-0.7422479987,
-0.5075351,
0.3975029588,
0.7878779173,
-0.2720769048,
0.4150239825,
0.6172145605,
0.1745873392,
0.2805346251,
-0.6344944239,
-0.0592979081,
-0.5582306981,
0.3965112269,
-0.5932769775,
-0.5118572712,
0.3396770954,
-0.2166171372,
0.2025823742,
-0.0484745018,
0.5127783418,
-0.3018609583,
0.966853857,
0.8529272676,
0.1638534218,
0.6569478512,
-0.2524524629,
-0.5081436634,
-0.9292501211,
-0.5907481313,
0.1383135915,
-0.4260424674,
-0.3263628483,
-0.5726531744,
0.3941107392,
-0.4269430637,
-0.0206064973,
0.1966547817,
-0.3944921792,
0.5365070701,
0.8719559908,
0.2362609804,
0.3457056582,
0.0418524668,
0.193319872,
0.2637403309,
-0.265773803,
-0.1160144135,
1.4845833778,
0.2074752599,
0.9581975937,
0.2933544219,
0.5436618328,
0.4377521873,
0.2586920857,
-0.9145513177,
0.7104930282,
0.2732157707,
-0.851593554,
-0.1626983434,
0.2754367292,
-1.1553146839,
0.4495213032,
-0.3547585011,
-0.6384379268,
0.4244626164,
0.2959960103,
-0.1343671829,
0.0672307536,
-1.0361702442,
0.528763175,
-0.7362612486,
-0.3829751611,
-0.3954434097,
-0.4692113101,
0.3667852879,
0.1398319304,
0.1550070941,
-0.1554795057,
-0.3126803339,
0.2417391986,
0.2583812773,
0.9103053808,
-0.2801125646,
-0.0670363158,
0.24413459,
0.1410840899,
0.3836131394,
0.0616649203,
0.2236851007,
-0.061352957,
-0.0793236196,
-0.4728583694,
-0.6564688683,
0.5315825343,
-1.0943264961,
-0.8128501177,
-0.3998287618,
-0.9090417027,
-0.1075712442,
0.269404918,
-0.3227275014,
0.5425060987,
0.0383719467,
0.3292682171,
0.5487539172,
-0.4863056242,
0.1502098292,
0.3155261874,
-0.6070910692,
-0.4138320386,
1.1009600163,
0.1073491648,
0.2916014493,
0.3911949694,
-0.175329417,
-0.1092536822,
-0.2455997616,
-0.4391501546,
0.0910542011,
-1.0195555687,
-0.1826879978,
-0.4237181246,
-0.010883024,
-0.3181381524,
-0.2914787829,
-0.1477598995,
-0.4255318344,
-0.1631887406,
-0.1574152559,
0.3315451145,
0.490880847,
0.0289664101,
0.3779083788,
-0.6413390636,
0.3630867302,
0.9848542213,
0.0639835,
-0.2222345322,
-0.0423812419,
-0.0668067336,
-0.1376163065,
-0.5708605051,
-0.8885711432,
0.2247541696,
0.4946560562,
0.8230974674,
0.3745381236,
-0.4901774228,
0.7762064338,
-0.1247968525,
0.7606076598,
0.2212281972,
-0.5755730867,
0.5986373425,
-0.2920544147,
0.4655354619,
0.3048145473,
0.3713990748,
-0.0336789712,
-0.196557194,
-0.346619308,
-0.7559053302,
0.5295957327,
0.0663782358,
0.2801725268,
0.2217657119,
0.12246757,
0.1167231575,
0.4573840797,
-0.8889915347,
-0.1897856295,
-0.3085967302,
0.1659463048,
-0.0874193236,
-0.4937740266,
-0.4098431766,
-0.3497121036,
0.3735241592,
-0.2214125246,
0.5894296765,
-0.0270654652,
-0.6028543711,
0.2152593583,
0.2440347522,
0.6738371849,
0.8590559959,
-0.2920915782,
0.07766781,
0.4134863317,
-0.6051357985,
0.2645401061,
-0.0044412115,
0.2475875616,
-0.1917268634,
0.5969564319,
0.7349433303,
0.0161931515,
-1.0914590359,
0.522313416,
-0.202478379,
-0.2823179364,
-0.5519028902,
0.2592834234,
-0.0198712908,
0.5796444416,
0.522110343,
0.1078482345,
0.3967655897,
-0.7467626333,
0.1890170574,
0.5150899887,
-0.2043554336,
-0.3766911626,
0.3201002479,
0.4910851717,
-0.1698930711,
0.3971232176,
-0.0839841366,
-0.0306422412,
0.752433002,
0.377004385,
0.6130319834,
-0.0896106288,
0.3303874135,
-0.0554500893,
0.215391472,
0.5007773042,
0.5170417428,
-0.4953612387,
-0.7943277955,
-0.4533679783,
-0.3056817651,
-0.3572339416,
-0.0937226266,
-0.5721947551,
0.3163482249,
-0.4141964614,
-0.3627919257,
0.0843089074,
-0.0219061952,
-1.1579799652,
0.1556773931,
0.1576615423,
0.7287979722,
-0.6357243061,
1.2896267176,
1.0826539993,
-0.744594276,
-0.515199542,
-0.4561914504,
0.2228536308,
-1.3367124796,
1.0167015791,
0.2073803693,
-0.3178705275,
-0.360604912,
-0.5619849563,
-1.0546008348,
1.6059416533,
0.6900843382,
-0.3984136283,
-0.1699001044,
-0.2026308179,
0.4192686081,
-0.312064141,
0.4796701372,
0.428378135,
0.3786204457,
0.3671482503,
-0.8891128898,
-0.2369221002,
-0.4433816969,
-0.0377074778,
0.0201414097,
-0.4631034136,
1.0484918356,
-0.2410726249,
-0.112051785,
-0.1542191654,
0.3370846808,
0.2845495641,
0.4681265354,
0.5536600351,
0.2270424515,
0.6098517179,
0.1755241901,
1.2723428011,
-0.1335806996,
-0.2293540686,
1.037551403,
-0.2007018477,
0.5711907148,
0.6080266833,
-0.0077735945,
0.5849848986,
0.36036098,
0.1675992608,
0.621447444,
-0.7577441335,
-0.3363329768,
-0.4221739173,
-0.2970887125,
-0.3221260011,
0.6044602394,
0.6307219267,
-0.1119421497,
-0.2308964431,
0.4326116741,
-0.3131378889,
-0.1967553496,
-0.3533696234,
0.9457500577,
-0.1185640171,
-0.5757187009,
0.4440315664,
-0.5312121511,
0.6660321951,
-0.8133463264,
-0.2607180774,
-0.1967043281,
0.1974254847,
-0.2698236704,
-1.0283985138,
0.2364035696,
-0.2970939875,
0.2223219573,
0.0746648088,
0.9808116555,
-0.1883580238,
-0.5250737667,
0.4229490161,
0.5970715284,
0.1430636495,
0.1577950567,
-0.8040004969,
0.0493687242,
-0.0336616188,
-0.2284540683,
0.6327410936,
0.3789745271,
-0.1577006876,
1.257389307,
0.7062869072,
-0.0335545875,
0.0736511946,
0.183330968,
1.2493821383,
-0.3572748005,
-0.079993479,
-0.5211172104,
0.7528923154,
-0.2460243851,
-0.2654627562,
0.869834125,
0.1392911673,
0.6661583185,
-0.099817194,
0.8315556049,
-0.1199770048,
0.0273774043,
-0.3257954717,
0.1672443748,
-1.1602960825,
0.0753921941,
-0.1689816862,
-0.8022921681,
-0.4749327004,
0.5559417009,
-0.1996264607,
-0.0466213636,
0.3036279082,
0.9428091049,
-0.1743632406,
-0.639955759,
0.8027201295,
-0.4744803905,
0.6810848713,
0.4278997779,
1.0157152414,
-0.1301339269,
0.7336655259,
-0.0598458648,
-0.3566567898,
-0.3335417509,
-0.5503061414,
-1.0893688202,
-0.5384184718,
0.1741829216,
0.0958548784,
0.1985427737,
0.9774571657,
0.7688161731,
-0.4547189772,
-0.2777504921,
0.2069050372,
0.178554371,
-0.2560372353,
-0.1375158578,
0.1286985725,
-0.5832665563,
-0.677005887,
0.4086746573,
0.3418526351,
0.0092282752,
-0.7012866139,
-0.2320095599,
-0.5093591809,
0.0999277979,
0.9931127429,
0.2872807384,
-0.6185873747,
-0.1655405164,
0.0733430907,
0.1796105355,
0.1054220349,
0.6172822118,
-0.9159085155,
1.0151773691,
0.3740330935,
0.5530737042,
0.546222806,
-0.2446474135,
0.6323924661,
-0.9717925787,
0.8232331872,
0.0048709135,
0.4896209836,
0.3618583083,
-0.3707050383,
0.3618748784,
-0.0055305497,
-0.5441195369,
-0.7240961194,
0.4138028324,
-1.0499252081,
-0.2316047996,
1.06513834,
-0.1410363317,
-0.3002965152,
-0.1327505708,
-0.6969935894,
0.0213178881,
-0.6988757253,
0.5607867837,
0.219379589,
-0.2828392684,
-0.6013841033,
-0.639629066,
0.3425029516,
-0.1387644857,
-1.007327795,
-0.6429558396,
0.5532787442,
0.2120890021,
0.4695638716,
0.8861999512,
0.0496944375,
0.8064619303,
0.1768673211,
0.2124656886,
-0.4401700199,
-0.8209587932,
0.0568680316,
0.3152440488,
0.4536117017,
-0.5035309196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05419v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05419v2
|
Mirror: A Universal Framework for Various Information Extraction Tasks
| 2023-11-09T14:58:46 | 2023-11-26T17:12:20 |
Tong Zhu, Junfei Ren, Zijian Yu, Mengsong Wu, Guoliang Zhang, Xiaoye Qu, Wenliang Chen, Zhefeng Wang, Baoxing Huai, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sharing knowledge between information extraction tasks has always been a
challenge due to the diverse data formats and task variations. Meanwhile, this
divergence leads to information waste and increases difficulties in building
complex applications in real scenarios. Recent studies often formulate IE tasks
as a triplet extraction problem. However, such a paradigm does not support
multi-span and n-ary extraction, leading to weak versatility. To this end, we
reorganize IE problems into unified multi-slot tuples and propose a universal
framework for various IE tasks, namely Mirror. Specifically, we recast existing
IE tasks as a multi-span cyclic graph extraction problem and devise a
non-autoregressive graph decoding algorithm to extract all spans in a single
step. It is worth noting that this graph structure is incredibly versatile, and
it supports not only complex IE tasks, but also machine reading comprehension
and classification tasks. We manually construct a corpus containing 57 datasets
for model pretraining, and conduct experiments on 30 datasets across 8
downstream tasks. The experimental results demonstrate that our model has
decent compatibility and outperforms or reaches competitive performance with
SOTA systems under few-shot and zero-shot settings. The code, model weights,
and pretraining corpus are available at https://github.com/Spico197/Mirror .
|
[
-0.4067990482,
-0.6210484505,
0.4671215713,
0.5163186193,
-0.1445665359,
0.0915935859,
0.021508947,
-0.7565716505,
0.4881119132,
0.3062518537,
-0.6395888925,
-0.278878808,
-0.8791899681,
0.4828358889,
-0.9000506401,
1.0697128773,
-0.2723672986,
0.149492681,
0.2510952055,
-0.000708733,
-0.3166542649,
-0.0424570814,
-0.367231369,
-0.0190925263,
0.4794124365,
0.5841816664,
0.0913433209,
0.6850602627,
0.4317533076,
0.2376622856,
0.6073306203,
0.4335864186,
-0.471624732,
0.1272784024,
-0.1315272003,
-0.1103553846,
-0.3754209578,
0.3200039268,
0.8109478354,
0.6574399471,
-0.039986372,
0.3593014777,
0.4860072136,
0.5426259041,
-0.6773990989,
0.5394706726,
-0.8061970472,
-0.0716776401,
-0.2145215869,
-0.0138477767,
-0.1935074329,
-0.1991677135,
0.0816532448,
-1.1470587254,
0.3729401827,
0.2260495722,
1.1028062105,
0.0302355364,
-0.4191667736,
-0.1626669616,
-0.4480017722,
0.5589988828,
-0.1116400063,
0.4452080727,
-0.180928871,
0.1679863334,
0.172484681,
-0.9767150879,
-0.7296968699,
0.5371716619,
0.2047649473,
0.3493309915,
-0.2028880715,
-0.1672930717,
-0.0675307885,
0.301728487,
-0.3935901821,
-0.2037266344,
-0.3063315451,
-0.052584514,
0.383743912,
0.084715642,
0.3533009291,
-0.1288502216,
-0.5031929016,
-0.2472376227,
-0.7369036674,
-0.2021505684,
0.1807348728,
0.4434993863,
0.1284217536,
0.4348362088,
0.0825965479,
0.4701771736,
0.1022772789,
0.2993147671,
0.1881358474,
-0.1207965761,
-0.0727191418,
-0.1599836946,
0.7844042182,
0.196739018,
0.1497210711,
-0.5634606481,
0.0253548119,
0.077369839,
0.4535160065,
-0.5027086139,
0.008085263,
-0.0696270019,
-0.342453748,
-0.3047679663,
0.4767405987,
-1.019375205,
-0.1214659885,
-0.1529289335,
0.7735739946,
-0.3247305155,
-0.4928674698,
0.3120631576,
-0.2784681916,
0.1410540193,
0.3897930086,
-0.5799944401,
0.4593463242,
0.7639976144,
0.80554533,
-0.5054616928,
-0.6575016379,
-0.6933558583,
0.2703704238,
-0.0468055122,
0.9087823033,
-0.4564654529,
-0.0864772052,
0.0270216409,
0.420948416,
-0.6932730675,
-0.1265774965,
0.1600712389,
-0.5821971297,
0.4650730491,
-0.1738761067,
-0.4180565178,
-0.2271709293,
0.1884070486,
-1.0781062841,
0.8976156712,
0.0505420826,
-0.8607867956,
0.2800320685,
-0.9467465878,
-0.6539022326,
-0.1322676986,
-0.0615557767,
-0.4565446675,
-0.0421929061,
0.2706748843,
0.4172447622,
-0.4306347668,
0.1740119904,
-0.6433447003,
-0.4447810054,
-0.4242943525,
-0.1910139024,
0.7350398898,
0.2929224968,
-0.6558299661,
-0.2610409856,
-0.6648824811,
0.0345772281,
0.2362282276,
-0.1738648266,
-0.1050458327,
0.0511820279,
0.2300225347,
0.0120445313,
0.1854924858,
-0.8601548076,
0.4403488934,
-0.2295167893,
0.5646734834,
0.8865882158,
-0.1137064919,
0.4077577293,
-0.0503856987,
0.2547102571,
-0.0216099657,
0.161023587,
0.0029435458,
-0.2185037434,
-0.6219972968,
-0.5119241476,
0.2568648458,
0.6876507998,
-0.9704411626,
0.1220287085,
-0.520616591,
-0.2516207397,
-0.5467892289,
0.1196212247,
0.3907604814,
0.5469227433,
0.3997431397,
-0.4957675934,
-0.696223259,
-0.572876215,
-0.4262136817,
0.19368729,
0.1026447713,
-0.0234128237,
0.4113851786,
-0.0183415506,
0.8720939755,
-0.5308901668,
-0.6209455132,
-0.4738525748,
0.3963305652,
0.3831965923,
0.329366684,
0.1164932922,
-0.6855945587,
-0.5127931833,
-0.3657386601,
-1.0517885685,
-0.1418151259,
-0.0280921906,
-0.2283756882,
-0.0645288974,
0.3712083399,
-0.5325160027,
0.3341832757,
0.349136889,
-0.0588624328,
0.3646376431,
0.0721528903,
-0.0184000973,
-1.2222073078,
0.2218709588,
0.1254516989,
-0.3871034384,
-0.4506876469,
0.2177843451,
0.1682129502,
-0.0517131723,
-0.1160191074,
0.4856066406,
-0.8002730012,
-0.161594525,
-0.0427873284,
0.27134794,
0.4992363155,
0.361692518,
0.1855338365,
0.7734568715,
0.4643448591,
-0.4612805545,
-0.0338636488,
0.3360112011,
-0.017180644,
0.4967863262,
-0.5536072254,
0.2649973035,
-0.2135547847,
0.0510947481,
-0.8568656445,
0.0457525812,
-0.0034790768,
-0.2444738895,
0.5056667924,
0.0930717215,
-0.635612309,
-0.4069654346,
-0.473041147,
-0.0418743119,
-0.0328594185,
-0.7096858025,
0.6934217811,
0.7243563533,
0.0750872046,
-0.7573597431,
-0.1865262091,
-0.0025204688,
-0.050194975,
-0.6234406233,
0.4029174149,
0.1003128141,
0.1645150632,
0.0949108973,
-0.3548208773,
-0.353635639,
0.0898946449,
0.2912526429,
0.5284174085,
-0.0511341244,
0.0165834725,
-0.1461216658,
-0.2710756361,
-0.2808348536,
-0.6110336781,
0.5484036803,
-0.3330445588,
-0.3377484679,
-0.2966198623,
0.8187412024,
0.3737097681,
-0.2347230762,
0.4577154815,
0.8029061556,
-0.2112504095,
-0.0816995203,
-0.7206953168,
-0.2826343179,
-0.4381868541,
0.4562266469,
-0.4881096184,
-0.8072702885,
0.3490779698,
-0.1548513919,
0.3618010879,
0.4658136368,
0.1213714778,
-0.4956615865,
1.3433508873,
0.8185796738,
-0.3279194534,
0.6011269093,
-0.5040301085,
0.2023226172,
-0.8689222336,
-0.0041664978,
-0.3827289939,
-0.2789252698,
-0.0857335925,
0.3297745883,
0.6190735698,
0.2383674979,
-0.2580177188,
0.6184058189,
-0.776765883,
0.3057247102,
0.6434072852,
0.1850202531,
0.3326514065,
0.2241288871,
0.0034675819,
0.1788743734,
-0.6563307643,
-0.3319421113,
1.3359223604,
-0.0963124931,
0.6416819096,
-0.1725507379,
0.7620823979,
0.3432906866,
0.3466280699,
-0.2280303538,
0.3344193697,
-0.3151444197,
-0.7948360443,
-0.2109669447,
-0.3279105425,
-1.3281980753,
0.3423937559,
-0.2243617177,
-0.7902486324,
0.2010456622,
-0.08479698,
-0.1849160939,
0.56877774,
-0.8241477013,
0.8521327376,
0.1374772787,
-0.4865008295,
0.0518645197,
-0.837572217,
0.1948897839,
-0.1459026039,
0.402559936,
-0.0273975376,
0.25191921,
0.6343044639,
-0.2985901237,
0.722627759,
-0.252936691,
0.4296623468,
0.1906980127,
0.2494269907,
0.4865095317,
0.0183189679,
0.0722477362,
0.2676377594,
0.550919354,
-0.2634319961,
-0.3720150292,
0.2598692775,
-0.9230104685,
-0.3727212548,
-0.4825477898,
-0.451739639,
-0.2501333952,
0.5646119118,
0.3549889624,
0.3895955086,
0.006821563,
-0.0765398815,
0.4600021243,
0.3332769275,
0.6541059613,
0.705273509,
-0.004406489,
-0.2663293183,
1.0254023075,
0.0559579693,
-0.0125975031,
0.2175945938,
-0.2017748654,
-0.3155289888,
-0.207271114,
-0.3708305657,
0.2113165259,
-0.4286310077,
-0.4069936275,
-0.6913333535,
-0.1886597872,
-0.5427908897,
0.0987041816,
-0.4662587643,
-0.4443352818,
-0.4511337876,
0.0368077382,
0.0170955099,
0.9116358161,
-0.4755026996,
0.1932475269,
-0.9652155042,
0.4695079327,
0.3406561911,
0.1666239351,
-0.1432175785,
0.1311424077,
-0.0691100061,
-0.1689404249,
-0.545748651,
-1.0981743336,
0.4742696285,
0.4578120112,
0.6007022262,
0.3335911334,
-0.015244877,
0.924765408,
-0.5963590741,
0.5793269277,
0.3355992436,
-1.0857942104,
0.095411472,
-0.1258522272,
-0.2272187918,
0.8814390302,
0.3940029144,
-0.5448486805,
-0.2948119938,
-0.6865836978,
-0.9077110291,
0.6982520819,
-0.0296094865,
-0.1939164549,
-0.2099725455,
0.3895993531,
0.3119788766,
0.2920364738,
-0.882253468,
0.1038623825,
-0.5519049764,
-0.5217741728,
0.2410661876,
0.1435869485,
-0.1585008502,
-0.1956772953,
0.526927352,
-0.221451655,
0.6784812212,
0.6007378101,
-0.6756550074,
-0.0362178534,
0.0418605879,
-0.0798286647,
0.4173781872,
-0.112760134,
0.3971294761,
-0.0014205221,
-0.8040013313,
-0.1097320095,
0.2551270723,
-0.0441238359,
-0.1394413859,
0.5349521637,
0.2663626373,
0.1497919858,
-0.1613196582,
0.8620806336,
-0.1154014617,
-0.2412770391,
-0.2692968249,
-0.1614164859,
-0.2410925478,
0.3733989596,
0.5230408907,
-0.0826267526,
0.2539618313,
-0.4504945576,
0.4303295016,
0.6027315259,
-0.5097948909,
-0.4786881208,
0.7368184924,
0.0665706694,
-0.0707741603,
0.7496899366,
-0.3977377117,
-0.5811386704,
0.2541163266,
0.6886174083,
0.7997295856,
0.0269757751,
0.2304932922,
0.1319229007,
0.2284986079,
-0.2558864653,
0.5374469161,
-0.0560004227,
-0.9836208224,
-0.3468626142,
-0.4478052258,
-0.0401185155,
-0.1425406486,
-0.8519608378,
0.042424649,
-0.2221118659,
0.0555013344,
-0.0546723194,
0.150575608,
-0.8208456039,
-0.0861726329,
-0.1519097537,
0.8373095393,
-0.8603553176,
1.0164399147,
0.3756098151,
-0.5459413528,
-0.9901214838,
-0.4012643695,
0.126325056,
-1.2809704542,
0.569619,
0.3425419927,
-0.2450385392,
0.2817408442,
-0.7363734841,
-0.7376465797,
1.092078805,
0.2128295153,
-0.3635617495,
-0.6137902141,
0.0332779922,
0.0748750791,
-0.5604928732,
0.3302761316,
0.2632960081,
0.5663582087,
0.0413712487,
-0.9166308641,
-0.0329992399,
-0.5410563946,
-0.3849588335,
0.1005944088,
-0.4703577161,
1.1365282536,
0.2102520019,
-0.5101079345,
-0.1026725397,
0.2326173037,
0.0334022976,
0.180276379,
0.7817834616,
0.5599803925,
0.5873721242,
-0.1615148336,
0.8875392079,
-0.5634375215,
0.4322518706,
0.9425343275,
-0.5184823275,
0.6733210683,
0.5443012118,
-0.015839098,
0.4503860474,
0.4428601563,
0.0126600098,
0.7301508784,
-0.326058656,
-0.0184259154,
-0.3439843357,
0.2704737782,
-0.3689569235,
0.5038090944,
0.2077925056,
-0.103220582,
-0.6141038537,
0.00430721,
0.2288615555,
-0.3016991317,
-0.1282233596,
0.8425422311,
0.0004393692,
-0.6532220244,
0.1640143245,
-0.2553556263,
0.6041983962,
-0.6509814858,
-0.2418935746,
0.0293400437,
0.1784897596,
-0.1333821118,
-0.6616302729,
0.4295289218,
-0.2377305925,
-0.037394017,
-0.5191829801,
0.6472619176,
-0.1276900023,
-0.3680670857,
0.3079922199,
0.660377562,
0.1481267512,
-0.4922845066,
-0.680537045,
-0.0208291244,
0.0151055157,
-0.1227356195,
0.1933039427,
0.3057072163,
0.1453301162,
0.2845361233,
0.6954345703,
0.2925831974,
0.2961247861,
-0.2285871208,
0.9087424278,
-0.4764585793,
-0.4106741846,
-0.6423199177,
0.3865850568,
-0.4024128318,
-0.2014256269,
0.714799881,
0.6583439708,
0.4302108288,
0.2009317726,
0.6541320682,
-0.0454132892,
0.7299746871,
-0.2970553339,
0.60639745,
-0.7704246044,
0.0872504115,
-0.55745399,
-1.1329467297,
-0.3185063899,
0.7838615179,
-0.0518054105,
-0.3971909285,
0.8837695122,
0.5373283029,
-0.2260827273,
0.5735573173,
-0.2293068171,
0.1010917053,
0.3579493463,
0.797308743,
0.6415131688,
-0.5709551573,
0.6318634748,
0.2005163729,
-0.3157483041,
0.1444924623,
-0.9167377949,
-0.4615542591,
-0.9432488084,
0.020637989,
-0.4371623397,
0.0915167779,
0.6678968072,
1.0490649939,
-0.5229653716,
-0.2098869979,
-0.2544749379,
0.2488075495,
-0.3388703763,
-0.2909647822,
0.5400199294,
-0.5881103277,
-0.6567370892,
0.3369643092,
0.4058364332,
-0.3141488433,
-0.0041809217,
0.3309713602,
-0.2456658036,
-0.1917706132,
0.4599958956,
0.5009483099,
-0.1076892987,
-0.5926389694,
0.215189755,
0.0387507677,
0.310171783,
0.7036198378,
-0.5578913093,
0.4863016605,
0.2858845294,
0.5177065134,
1.1670483351,
-0.3657132089,
0.5457978845,
-0.6567259431,
-0.0454808697,
-0.0896241814,
0.4825535417,
-0.0445838384,
-0.1294230521,
0.7194683552,
0.4445950091,
-0.3116719723,
-0.8515490294,
0.2213430405,
-0.9697654247,
-0.3983524442,
0.7723540664,
-0.1803701222,
-0.4808527827,
-0.3226426244,
0.1117657945,
0.5073336363,
-0.140339613,
1.0287783146,
0.5852509141,
-0.1990837455,
-0.1818082184,
-0.3380847871,
0.1435667574,
0.1060533598,
-0.8350806832,
-0.2926635742,
0.1488256305,
0.7043482661,
0.2728177905,
0.7418394089,
-0.4218612909,
0.0388775244,
-0.0895159245,
0.394392401,
-0.3052188158,
-0.5836886168,
-0.0415414572,
0.6525337696,
-0.4335338473,
-0.4121050835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05379v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05379v1
|
Memorisation Cartography: Mapping out the Memorisation-Generalisation Continuum in Neural Machine Translation
| 2023-11-09T14:03:51 | 2023-11-09T14:03:51 |
Verna Dankers, Ivan Titov, Dieuwke Hupkes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When training a neural network, it will quickly memorise some source-target
mappings from your dataset but never learn some others. Yet, memorisation is
not easily expressed as a binary feature that is good or bad: individual
datapoints lie on a memorisation-generalisation continuum. What determines a
datapoint's position on that spectrum, and how does that spectrum influence
neural models' performance? We address these two questions for neural machine
translation (NMT) models. We use the counterfactual memorisation metric to (1)
build a resource that places 5M NMT datapoints on a memorisation-generalisation
map, (2) illustrate how the datapoints' surface-level characteristics and a
models' per-datum training signals are predictive of memorisation in NMT, (3)
and describe the influence that subsets of that map have on NMT systems'
performance.
|
[
-0.4740795493,
-0.2992151678,
0.5521174073,
-0.0480300561,
-0.3002066612,
-0.0930156857,
0.0978581756,
-0.3019035757,
0.1840465069,
0.7426764965,
-0.336908102,
-0.627489388,
-0.5104832649,
-0.4437822998,
-0.6240897775,
1.1288944483,
-0.0289277937,
0.0430060513,
-0.1133827195,
-0.4622066915,
-0.6196892262,
-1.067142725,
-0.545552671,
-0.5933982134,
0.5584363341,
0.3114384413,
0.7072541714,
0.8356233835,
0.6505086422,
0.3269546926,
-0.0345751755,
-0.1728365868,
-0.4873210192,
0.2284310609,
-0.2790771425,
-0.8798820376,
-0.3480557203,
0.2409870178,
0.5059284568,
0.6684857011,
0.0074700974,
0.311488986,
-0.1558672935,
0.7188358903,
-0.1862144321,
0.0637403801,
-0.7948330045,
0.0808327124,
-0.008800949,
-0.4154919386,
-0.3100792468,
-0.4134441912,
0.3922516406,
-0.6786853075,
0.6322802901,
0.1288836449,
0.7072135806,
0.2215943635,
-0.492947638,
-0.3472194374,
-0.9668366909,
0.851348877,
-0.3349912465,
0.1397965848,
0.4831607342,
0.4952632487,
0.0382128283,
-0.694019258,
-0.160595268,
-0.1878805459,
-0.1231446192,
0.1887089312,
0.1540284753,
-0.0512586683,
0.3873541355,
0.3974359334,
-0.511525631,
-0.2604818046,
-0.4754211903,
-0.197264865,
0.2624056339,
0.2907192409,
0.2453092188,
0.0301952362,
-0.427867353,
0.057973545,
-0.8888990283,
-0.2566452026,
0.1099026799,
0.414057821,
0.0542326756,
0.4171739221,
0.1353037655,
0.4858372211,
-0.0752488524,
0.1332861632,
0.1327682585,
-0.240469411,
0.0654412881,
0.1557330042,
0.4475786388,
0.2755234241,
0.5301748514,
-0.5622009635,
-0.3154405653,
0.050123699,
0.5547454953,
-0.6340645552,
-0.389919579,
-0.1507865638,
-0.3520678282,
0.0464248471,
-0.1053165942,
-0.2666991949,
-0.1439715028,
-0.7066215873,
0.4621230066,
-0.6633896828,
-0.0413516648,
-0.0615422092,
-0.2130009234,
-0.0209402908,
0.1215520427,
-0.7594612837,
0.4639554024,
0.5644591451,
0.9790214896,
-0.0650336668,
-0.4786439836,
0.1422132701,
0.2208490223,
-0.3891479969,
0.6273692846,
-0.39398247,
-0.2596598268,
-0.3282333314,
-0.1208522543,
-0.495113939,
-0.7005413771,
0.1479088217,
-0.6529167891,
0.0355843678,
-0.6844269633,
-0.5622847676,
-0.8596090674,
0.2662228942,
-0.8173487186,
0.7706159353,
0.1443047076,
-0.3008221388,
0.3953643739,
-0.6808021665,
-0.2856451571,
-0.4216877222,
-0.1138304844,
-0.3588793874,
0.2842099071,
-0.1011434793,
0.2073380798,
-0.3095905483,
0.1155180112,
0.0393879153,
-0.4734672308,
0.552282095,
-0.1850390583,
0.4308056831,
0.1768730432,
-0.2336046398,
-0.2213741094,
-0.8604690433,
-0.0653736442,
-0.0158661306,
-0.3988439441,
-0.2025612593,
0.0779495537,
-0.0486329831,
0.5708222389,
-0.0504859872,
-0.3708076477,
0.1218049675,
-0.0524979718,
0.5727910995,
0.3886582851,
0.2183094621,
0.4505933225,
-0.716108799,
0.4939984083,
0.4815344214,
-0.1361287981,
0.0012573487,
-0.6493067741,
-0.7005074024,
-0.0230244286,
0.4809646308,
0.5558659434,
-0.5528770685,
-0.031131167,
-0.4069241881,
-0.4503111243,
-0.2660106719,
0.1529791057,
0.5288475752,
0.686365664,
0.5815393925,
-0.5447096825,
-0.5356763601,
-0.893840313,
-0.0015670455,
-0.0972228199,
0.0362756997,
0.1868875474,
0.5375273824,
0.1699530035,
0.7840915918,
-0.3189300001,
-0.32649526,
0.0572062433,
0.3628930151,
0.2236249298,
0.5273984075,
0.653026998,
-0.8180617094,
-0.1180677414,
-0.2560156286,
-0.6761752367,
0.1155917495,
-0.275918901,
0.0110098356,
0.0727219582,
0.4912953377,
-0.5404669046,
0.3764953017,
0.2874571383,
-0.0915762261,
0.2144017518,
-0.402800709,
0.2501140535,
-0.6678339243,
0.4343014956,
-0.3140726388,
-0.0493083484,
-0.786706686,
0.0297970437,
-0.0392429531,
0.0706692562,
-0.4147303104,
0.0196120199,
-0.2301874757,
-0.4049323201,
-0.0251141097,
0.0739445314,
-0.0504834279,
0.5908105373,
0.1110413745,
0.7213307619,
0.1457964629,
-0.7238581181,
-0.00828245,
0.1296691149,
-0.0862486884,
0.6036208272,
-0.4408366978,
0.3954136372,
0.1735219657,
0.089485094,
-1.2769846916,
0.4626574218,
-0.1079260558,
-0.5222331882,
0.1472343206,
-0.3500248194,
-0.2730315924,
-0.0821371824,
0.1385439932,
0.6674031615,
0.3973192275,
-0.2299659997,
0.3579446673,
0.2519517243,
0.3964144289,
-0.5017473698,
-1.0344346762,
0.0109145241,
-0.3378746808,
-0.2935692072,
0.2935361266,
0.1151513755,
0.1330927461,
-0.2603774071,
0.0604096837,
-0.1203253195,
0.2667601705,
0.7860088944,
0.0876017883,
-0.469091177,
0.3028082252,
-0.4304736853,
-0.4678726494,
0.1449606866,
-0.6976456642,
0.7655853629,
-0.3685380518,
-0.2661761045,
0.0886743218,
0.1072292253,
0.5906467438,
-0.0189115126,
0.4541099072,
0.500234127,
-0.3001997769,
0.0762318298,
-0.4065856934,
-0.1408385634,
-0.4168590009,
0.3824924827,
-0.5611838102,
-0.1928081214,
1.0382163525,
-0.0317152441,
-0.1787121296,
0.659194231,
0.3297090828,
-0.2356210798,
0.6113423705,
0.320915699,
-0.0493677258,
0.1338439137,
-0.7841169238,
0.0122061698,
-0.9680515528,
-0.150650233,
-0.445025295,
-0.9426019788,
-0.6670438051,
-0.1976570338,
0.0270106867,
-0.0048131323,
-0.3499150276,
0.5608371496,
-0.5242305994,
0.3416129351,
0.781953752,
0.2175727338,
0.2465981245,
-0.1378281415,
-0.482354641,
-0.2230309546,
-0.710613966,
-0.5034284592,
1.3907775879,
0.2150986195,
0.2790005505,
0.012884357,
0.6644913554,
0.0709685534,
0.2055857629,
-0.552262485,
0.7575201392,
-0.4618881643,
-0.8395743966,
-0.1568344384,
-0.3207559884,
-0.8229630589,
0.0064029158,
-0.0917411819,
-0.3922821581,
0.3643801808,
0.1586837471,
-0.2996463776,
0.4841620624,
-0.5510047674,
0.5666059852,
-0.2002583444,
0.124428995,
-0.2061872333,
-0.5823568702,
0.0728526637,
-0.0602164455,
-0.1181788146,
0.0528894924,
-0.1716739386,
0.6929939389,
-0.1621222943,
0.7475534081,
-0.4172098339,
0.2953423262,
0.1879384816,
0.438952595,
-0.002561121,
-0.4309387505,
-0.2513487935,
0.4406780601,
-0.085782662,
-0.3074085414,
-0.5766266584,
0.4985894859,
-0.9347856641,
-0.3978495002,
-0.0574517697,
-0.9097446203,
-0.1047283188,
0.0877440497,
0.5808594823,
0.3522275388,
-0.4036212564,
0.0834197402,
0.693184495,
-0.0634840354,
0.3483311534,
0.4339480996,
-0.3254864514,
-0.2036377192,
1.3339270353,
0.8536458015,
0.4822077751,
0.5022416115,
-0.0144631844,
-0.0603683218,
-1.094329834,
-0.3447913527,
-0.0305449329,
-1.0392401218,
0.0453904979,
-0.1892869771,
-0.5539001822,
0.0367625616,
-0.2214322686,
-0.3890433013,
-1.1891050339,
-0.1995864362,
-0.1122799665,
0.2823675871,
0.8312825561,
-0.2052922547,
0.5898774862,
-0.3883625865,
0.4120021462,
0.1167427674,
-0.0128877694,
-0.1427320987,
-0.6590880752,
-0.3191149831,
0.0687053874,
-0.4915824831,
-0.6272711158,
0.3494626284,
0.1971182972,
0.491401881,
0.2959186137,
-0.3745919466,
0.3864471018,
-0.3386376202,
0.6252648234,
0.050383117,
-0.7753272057,
0.308770597,
-0.3925845623,
0.4412457347,
0.5765241981,
0.2639268041,
-0.7770679593,
-0.571110189,
-0.6529307961,
-0.737796545,
0.4536498487,
0.0041391859,
0.0073717665,
-0.0194254052,
0.6557558179,
0.0465701111,
0.175007835,
-0.5999724865,
-0.4310453832,
-0.5075116158,
-0.1423630714,
-0.3405421376,
-0.132301271,
-0.2142711133,
-0.2459472865,
0.3497776091,
0.0951469541,
0.4512181878,
0.1247671247,
-0.4029925466,
-0.0163010545,
-0.0565076768,
0.9463330507,
0.7556868792,
-0.4577281177,
0.2921379805,
0.2828741372,
-0.7335635424,
0.4503038526,
-0.1925117522,
-0.5186221004,
0.2248449475,
0.2979819179,
0.642721951,
0.2567558885,
0.2392791957,
0.208732143,
0.13700293,
-0.3740291297,
-0.1673671007,
0.1541111469,
0.382834971,
-0.0308639053,
0.2138516009,
0.2890095115,
0.1224048883,
-0.3531680703,
0.3215506077,
0.1511049122,
-0.4835861921,
-0.3641631901,
0.5348910689,
-0.2490671128,
-0.3600053191,
0.9946039915,
0.194355011,
-0.7784695625,
1.065787673,
0.5383861661,
0.9236346483,
-0.6173504591,
0.0595229194,
0.5645084977,
0.5342562795,
0.1154932976,
0.2150372416,
0.0164545458,
-0.4586179554,
0.0960935503,
-0.1221504807,
-0.323985219,
-0.0294188987,
-0.7342622876,
0.0572737493,
-0.7192434669,
-0.362994045,
0.0699667484,
0.0014410373,
-0.9685473442,
0.5598100424,
0.1495803744,
0.5925967693,
-0.6829868555,
0.9611004591,
0.2310266346,
-0.516887188,
-0.5769820213,
-0.2791978419,
-0.043484468,
-1.0808987617,
0.9650193453,
0.171973601,
-0.0471386909,
-0.0839276314,
-0.1308715045,
-0.9960193038,
1.3684470654,
0.5321277976,
-0.3756957054,
-0.1358970702,
0.901222229,
0.6129612327,
-0.4869450331,
0.5777742863,
0.588576138,
0.4341304004,
0.0687202886,
-0.6927244067,
0.1211834103,
-0.0033443179,
0.1042460129,
0.168182224,
-0.4904154539,
1.0201740265,
-0.1115958542,
-0.1451438218,
-0.0836608261,
0.1546838731,
-0.1255626529,
0.1855289191,
0.2302814722,
0.7397173643,
0.5823407173,
-0.2693110704,
1.0254160166,
-0.3275028169,
0.2074702233,
1.1960077286,
0.2373446375,
0.7558018565,
0.622623682,
0.097064361,
0.4707510173,
0.5675088167,
-0.2200768143,
0.6025436521,
0.5875246525,
0.0932248831,
0.0324278735,
0.2812868655,
-0.5604918599,
0.5851175189,
0.5704619288,
-0.892993331,
-0.2949654162,
-0.1547700912,
-0.3948099315,
-0.0948424935,
-0.2553994954,
0.6997570992,
0.2762575746,
-0.5464664698,
0.9336684346,
-0.1311641484,
0.01274879,
-0.5663475394,
-0.0169313531,
-0.2602988482,
0.2831442058,
-0.0504033379,
-0.4833694696,
0.6090437174,
-0.6966934204,
-0.4978913367,
-0.2212374657,
0.2732965052,
-0.4347643554,
-0.2861149609,
0.4778489769,
0.3241152167,
0.2711726725,
-0.0738524869,
-0.7858144045,
-0.3576646447,
-0.2368385345,
-0.4579761326,
0.3499292433,
0.3908571899,
-0.0596133545,
0.7030885816,
0.4559248686,
0.0954422355,
0.1760829687,
-0.0824468359,
0.5903912783,
-0.9191206694,
-0.4316526353,
-0.8055585623,
0.2613781393,
0.243190363,
-0.468321085,
0.5960956812,
0.6673803329,
0.6516503096,
-0.1276777238,
0.4487221241,
0.5699878931,
0.4129400551,
-0.6850839257,
0.9347322583,
-0.0763897598,
0.3348146379,
0.020868022,
-0.9307602048,
-0.3563956916,
0.4503872693,
-0.6590313911,
0.0883348584,
0.8815588355,
0.8942495584,
-0.1540382802,
0.1173934415,
0.4710918665,
0.1501267701,
0.2192943543,
1.0077818632,
0.9761123657,
-0.6413951516,
0.7213454247,
-0.3328244686,
0.249130249,
-0.0906837508,
-0.8092468381,
-0.724966228,
-0.7821538448,
-0.3010412753,
-0.2656772435,
0.0036427323,
0.3580315113,
0.8285686374,
-0.9829062819,
-0.3659605384,
-0.1909630448,
0.1660801023,
-0.3136362731,
-0.0895586535,
0.3374000788,
-0.3462083638,
-0.2956829369,
0.0916576758,
0.3202790916,
0.1881940663,
-0.2131587714,
-0.014946132,
-0.2599909008,
0.2074211389,
0.007250885,
0.3742360473,
-0.5255916715,
-0.2093487382,
-0.1276114136,
-0.3958956897,
0.5524533391,
1.1718182564,
-0.6574029922,
0.3050774038,
0.1997433603,
0.4529675245,
0.7753632665,
-0.2362236232,
0.60363096,
-0.6342949867,
0.1629660577,
0.2248520106,
0.2638948858,
0.2554781139,
-0.3293831646,
0.5946094394,
0.3159020245,
-0.5819882751,
-0.2952490151,
0.0772497505,
-0.7469457388,
-0.2769370079,
0.7655168176,
-0.3320587873,
-0.1494770199,
-0.4665013552,
-0.0358985923,
0.1723606139,
0.1223380044,
0.8685709834,
0.8827157021,
0.187129572,
0.1956687421,
-0.7738523483,
0.4559069872,
0.6490449905,
-0.2117613703,
-0.090636149,
0.3481762707,
0.3934386969,
0.5107934475,
0.602666676,
-0.1412131488,
0.4131839573,
0.1538576484,
0.0210241433,
-0.3134328723,
-0.463146925,
-0.3479682505,
0.2113150805,
0.0452667549,
-0.5597996712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05374v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05374v1
|
TencentLLMEval: A Hierarchical Evaluation of Real-World Capabilities for Human-Aligned LLMs
| 2023-11-09T13:58:59 | 2023-11-09T13:58:59 |
Shuyi Xie, Wenlin Yao, Yong Dai, Shaobo Wang, Donlin Zhou, Lifeng Jin, Xinhua Feng, Pengzhi Wei, Yujie Lin, Zhichao Hu, Dong Yu, Zhengyou Zhang, Jing Nie, Yuhong Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities across
various natural language tasks. However, evaluating their alignment with human
preferences remains a challenge. To this end, we propose a comprehensive human
evaluation framework to assess LLMs' proficiency in following instructions on
diverse real-world tasks. We construct a hierarchical task tree encompassing 7
major areas covering over 200 categories and over 800 tasks, which covers
diverse capabilities such as question answering, reasoning, multiturn dialogue,
and text generation, to evaluate LLMs in a comprehensive and in-depth manner.
We also design detailed evaluation standards and processes to facilitate
consistent, unbiased judgments from human evaluators. A test set of over 3,000
instances is released, spanning different difficulty levels and knowledge
domains. Our work provides a standardized methodology to evaluate human
alignment in LLMs for both English and Chinese. We also analyze the feasibility
of automating parts of evaluation with a strong LLM (GPT-4). Our framework
supports a thorough assessment of LLMs as they are integrated into real-world
applications. We have made publicly available the task tree, TencentLLMEval
dataset, and evaluation methodology which have been demonstrated as effective
in assessing the performance of Tencent Hunyuan LLMs. By doing so, we aim to
facilitate the benchmarking of advances in the development of safe and
human-aligned LLMs.
|
[
-0.1387674659,
-0.7599337697,
0.5596641302,
0.4580320418,
0.047173474,
0.4038920999,
-0.5623760819,
-0.4248553216,
-0.2723339796,
0.4032915831,
-0.5921813846,
-0.682359457,
-0.2967083156,
0.2564344108,
-0.0435080826,
0.5639386773,
-0.1935496926,
0.1107704937,
-0.4101150334,
-0.1386852413,
-0.6808845997,
-0.536082387,
-0.4938233495,
-0.4015737176,
0.345043838,
0.547075212,
0.7250151634,
0.684899807,
0.6771327257,
0.3923596442,
-0.1494321823,
0.2337565124,
-0.3216835856,
0.1729864478,
-0.362618655,
-0.0623177439,
-0.9442442656,
0.1291368902,
0.6444635987,
0.7813549042,
-0.2212404162,
0.365085274,
0.4063258171,
0.5400168896,
-0.4504183233,
0.0568631329,
-0.224853307,
-0.0319541879,
-0.1699899584,
0.0492345616,
-0.1014830172,
-0.6561249495,
0.2513065934,
-0.5322720408,
-0.3442654908,
0.2687274218,
0.7189856768,
0.0626824349,
-0.3494657576,
-0.1969139129,
-0.3613016009,
0.9661840796,
-0.825335145,
0.3135422766,
0.3341959715,
0.6934658885,
-0.0829335898,
-0.66800946,
-0.444353193,
-0.5262386799,
0.0670332909,
0.1024608389,
0.083051078,
0.2370579988,
0.1281469911,
0.4272770584,
-0.7457818389,
0.266387701,
0.0488538258,
-0.3302105069,
0.6326916814,
0.4779429436,
0.636700809,
-0.1679853052,
-0.2811177373,
-0.1097764224,
-0.4707839489,
0.2754405439,
0.3920947909,
0.341403842,
-0.1364330649,
0.5400189757,
-0.3583181202,
0.7252642512,
0.1083965898,
-0.5217292309,
0.1142528877,
-0.5648560524,
-0.3389556408,
0.1007630304,
0.7553992867,
0.5166376233,
0.3058302104,
-0.327052176,
-0.3660446405,
0.0334077962,
0.5303252339,
-0.6938185692,
0.1993747801,
0.1932087243,
-0.4069183767,
-0.520023942,
0.0686155334,
-0.4377791584,
-0.4587329328,
-0.4640548825,
0.4573480487,
-0.2126325816,
-0.0185947251,
0.0318754874,
0.4303391278,
0.3160879016,
0.3818670213,
-0.8029343486,
0.4150945246,
1.0473920107,
0.5063179731,
-0.7039003372,
-0.7068428397,
-0.4168134332,
-0.0399299785,
-0.3011447191,
0.702368021,
-0.4657753408,
0.0687547177,
-0.1479581147,
0.3099903166,
-0.0914102346,
-0.6718464494,
0.9459285736,
-0.3040003181,
0.3644846082,
-0.291436702,
-0.5175804496,
-0.248328805,
0.7313858867,
-0.3370202482,
1.0234541893,
0.2697274089,
-0.6041430235,
0.1012595296,
-0.522197485,
-0.3576456904,
0.1792310625,
-0.3044839799,
-0.3297532499,
-0.1685905606,
0.0538228266,
0.4144759476,
-0.6058798432,
0.6393537521,
-0.2119527757,
-0.6009596586,
0.0259527117,
-0.5889248252,
1.1024931669,
0.0551736057,
-0.5863146186,
0.4879996479,
-0.457324475,
0.2451545894,
-0.1609712541,
-0.4118353724,
-0.0673726648,
-0.2348321974,
-0.1022120863,
0.1103858277,
0.4941285253,
-0.6499909163,
0.1728229523,
-0.3638420999,
0.3067703843,
0.6425378323,
0.0571457483,
0.483427614,
-0.2811606228,
0.7148596644,
-0.3226518333,
0.4074161649,
-0.0074905176,
-0.3962303996,
-0.4534779489,
0.1466270387,
0.0847789273,
0.7318561077,
-0.3683738112,
0.7952762246,
-0.2624809146,
-0.5247403979,
-0.3998179436,
0.2470837384,
0.6419622898,
0.7030350566,
0.1581674218,
-0.1494329423,
-0.3353444338,
-0.8916417956,
-0.1218756959,
-0.2741598487,
-0.1585835814,
0.2419614196,
0.126200214,
-0.2548441589,
0.7825983763,
-0.070150286,
-0.2216668725,
-0.1578970551,
-0.0840543434,
0.2729252279,
0.4712215662,
0.0500280596,
-0.3558802307,
-0.3845331669,
0.3579033315,
-0.967659831,
-0.4032327235,
0.0845468864,
-0.3339297771,
0.1492909938,
0.2604165673,
-0.2258466184,
0.0994559526,
0.6761208177,
-0.3652191758,
0.761760056,
-0.250657618,
0.3602146804,
-1.0304630995,
0.1350830942,
-0.1604533046,
-0.0775036588,
-0.6433346272,
0.2053536177,
0.4110040665,
0.0020846599,
-0.5838192105,
0.6174326539,
-0.5256574154,
-0.2145226002,
-0.1762888283,
0.366769433,
0.0855427906,
0.3571113348,
-0.0573735051,
0.9177754521,
0.291243881,
-0.3393971324,
0.6536748409,
0.0441318899,
-0.5551413298,
0.8784324527,
-0.6078752279,
0.0942734927,
0.223244831,
-0.1370761096,
-0.8045268655,
-0.1309336722,
-0.0337856114,
-0.3253775537,
0.0697372556,
0.1241418049,
-0.3616031408,
-0.4096931219,
-0.4357853532,
0.1980646402,
0.2874822021,
-0.303555429,
0.5865991712,
0.339561373,
-0.2149760276,
-0.6327789426,
-0.3795282841,
0.3912988901,
-0.3860509396,
-0.8604322076,
0.3115842044,
0.0199861713,
-0.2929021716,
-0.077829048,
-0.1979698688,
0.0228758529,
0.3462961912,
0.3065744638,
0.4327049255,
-0.2071312815,
-0.1810874194,
-0.0818747431,
-0.1221793666,
0.0496839881,
-0.2860768735,
0.3223260045,
-0.4362531602,
-0.6360362172,
-0.622977078,
-0.0900679082,
0.475943774,
-0.2246036083,
0.0813857988,
0.7000776529,
-0.5848628283,
0.1203714311,
-0.7216069102,
-0.0252116621,
-0.461612165,
0.5211330056,
-0.3308071494,
-1.0218784809,
0.3188704252,
-0.0545889996,
0.2470618337,
0.2109955549,
0.6630098224,
-0.2686914504,
0.8877996206,
0.4652403295,
-0.0991555527,
-0.0608070344,
-0.0509618856,
0.0168921333,
-1.1008313894,
-0.3601885736,
-0.4625045061,
-0.3696843386,
-0.3744976223,
-0.4548642933,
0.3315903246,
0.254519254,
-0.586376071,
0.6066252589,
-0.5489524603,
0.4167602956,
0.1991974413,
-0.1525618583,
0.4476203024,
-0.0525958985,
-0.4390586317,
-0.1110021695,
-0.4443381727,
-1.1086542606,
0.7631134987,
0.571432054,
0.7948232889,
0.163973093,
0.5383806229,
0.2913387716,
0.5114250183,
-0.8250483274,
0.6227707267,
-0.2402362674,
-0.3691197038,
-0.7227085829,
-0.2957238555,
-0.951382339,
0.231064409,
-0.188348949,
-0.8464603424,
-0.2225548476,
-0.0952941999,
-0.5151267052,
0.1207595766,
-0.5809382796,
1.1376180649,
-0.7290169597,
-0.3873626292,
-0.023981167,
-0.5136303306,
0.5224334598,
-0.0821271911,
-0.0423042662,
-0.4391773343,
-0.3080647588,
0.7671224475,
-0.2880982161,
0.8750841022,
-0.1275648326,
-0.2046691924,
0.1847091168,
0.0912074894,
0.3427723348,
-0.1398020238,
-0.202592805,
0.0234596189,
0.2033726424,
-0.2581754625,
-0.5530326962,
0.8063796163,
-0.8011398911,
-0.6545365453,
-0.1994128227,
-0.523611486,
-0.4725601077,
0.2140253335,
-0.1101694107,
0.2694891393,
-0.4324792027,
0.1358065605,
0.3037500679,
-0.3358741701,
0.4400559366,
0.3392460942,
-0.2175015062,
-0.6111690402,
0.8828184009,
-0.0669164658,
0.2366525382,
0.3441066742,
0.4737606049,
-0.566940546,
-0.5368739367,
-0.7644231915,
0.0795485675,
-0.435882926,
-0.2282017767,
-0.4966007173,
-0.1584465057,
-0.3001728952,
-0.1673423797,
-0.1818360239,
-0.2298140526,
0.0261677988,
0.0622660592,
-0.2424814999,
0.8771026731,
0.5953925848,
0.2534064353,
-0.9086418152,
0.0362739451,
0.5791180134,
0.3574872613,
0.2429115474,
-0.6526066065,
-0.1182705387,
-0.0327968076,
-0.4487282634,
-0.6559220552,
0.1174517199,
-0.0994309783,
0.9724466205,
0.4535493851,
0.0000639675,
0.8271927238,
-0.3728379905,
0.749674499,
0.0357833244,
-0.9897065163,
0.2723630965,
-0.1181820035,
0.3904672265,
0.8531073928,
0.1340959668,
-0.8483519554,
-0.1899470389,
-0.3542328775,
-0.4438180029,
0.6537445784,
0.1163657978,
-0.0760371983,
0.1377995461,
0.3133597374,
-0.1461425126,
0.0521285199,
-0.2830619514,
0.0836419761,
0.1403493285,
-0.2926851511,
0.2290997654,
-0.1857979596,
-0.0527609587,
-0.0552943349,
0.4198960364,
-0.2351103872,
-0.120326221,
-0.0486616045,
-0.2758104801,
-0.0591294914,
0.4125978947,
0.6988281608,
0.8954823017,
-0.3239508271,
0.2575803399,
0.4771074355,
-0.6681112051,
0.4735248387,
-0.0803046525,
-0.1418038756,
-0.5097898245,
0.7664817572,
0.490034312,
0.288679868,
-0.6844783425,
0.6719566584,
-0.1088668406,
-0.0174995456,
-0.1081290469,
0.0614343137,
0.4501591921,
0.1440549642,
0.3144665956,
-0.3554342091,
-0.0573577508,
-0.5287446976,
0.2829669416,
0.2932875454,
-0.61316365,
-0.4065075219,
0.4548081756,
0.4306275845,
-0.427670002,
0.5273698568,
-0.3237134814,
-0.5358831882,
0.6289447546,
0.3925460875,
1.0070741177,
-0.3934746683,
-0.0206794553,
0.4065427184,
0.4159802496,
-0.0873773992,
0.2929522693,
-0.0750953108,
-0.7796376944,
-0.7258366346,
-0.7439751625,
-0.5831429362,
-0.0948996842,
-0.5441496372,
0.2212198824,
-0.3917920589,
-0.2669184506,
-0.3478548229,
0.4929197133,
-0.3671868742,
0.0210629273,
0.1126973331,
0.9892196655,
-0.7254792452,
0.9953783751,
1.037648797,
-0.0527400784,
-0.9136786461,
0.0527915061,
0.2345996499,
-1.0930222273,
0.7057088017,
0.1731688529,
-0.1019984558,
-0.2035026252,
-0.1102722809,
-0.5929870605,
1.572077632,
0.2983431518,
-0.6156526208,
-0.0819500461,
0.2814319134,
0.5820282102,
-0.6395431757,
0.4107822776,
0.8588599563,
0.7550883889,
0.0144674452,
-1.1822429895,
0.1291048229,
0.0324709937,
0.1409161985,
-0.1218464449,
-0.4762422144,
0.4380835593,
-0.208920151,
-0.3756636083,
0.0831869021,
0.5292643309,
0.7153642774,
0.1965229511,
0.6747793555,
0.5325912237,
0.8391012549,
-0.0864180848,
0.817330122,
-0.4596761167,
0.1406578422,
1.223667264,
-0.4825509787,
0.7759116888,
0.2650637031,
-0.3988363743,
0.1869269311,
0.6950255632,
0.3016338646,
-0.0783570334,
0.3553181887,
-0.1966424584,
-0.2787434757,
-0.335845381,
-0.0067388471,
0.4422992766,
0.0751693249,
0.0753851458,
-0.3642153144,
-0.2560020685,
0.1191107482,
0.3207833469,
-0.1798471063,
0.752020359,
-0.023927819,
-0.7228360772,
0.6361862421,
0.080635488,
0.7850297689,
-0.3081745207,
-0.0348189361,
-0.3797544539,
0.0165952127,
-0.322606653,
-1.2060222626,
0.2555589378,
0.1883981079,
0.1770962328,
-0.1788452566,
0.5844212174,
-0.4677137733,
-0.464320153,
0.2425930351,
0.5622909665,
0.2128502876,
-0.2017027736,
-0.8114224076,
0.1602021456,
0.1086937115,
-0.1462682039,
0.3913095891,
0.395008564,
-0.6845679879,
0.7328931093,
0.460804522,
0.2167582363,
-0.1856310517,
0.3898409903,
0.5856822133,
-0.7907021046,
-0.1167737544,
-0.8343516588,
0.2137134969,
-0.0732179284,
-0.2528338432,
0.812143445,
0.6508883238,
0.6426049471,
0.2435886562,
0.4834579527,
0.0472258404,
0.3683207929,
-0.1844708174,
0.7536830306,
-0.1930471957,
0.3502399921,
-0.2002724707,
-1.2270001173,
-0.2011914402,
0.3126230538,
-0.2688243091,
-0.0184739921,
0.7129761577,
0.7964766026,
0.0636544153,
-0.0261108857,
0.7116110325,
0.0142586194,
0.3241010606,
0.6559047103,
1.0355286598,
-0.1966926754,
0.5634269714,
-0.535012722,
-0.4310027063,
0.1048224792,
-1.1151537895,
-0.8461515307,
-0.324737668,
-0.1086411253,
-0.029998377,
0.0230337437,
1.0587625504,
0.7029314041,
-0.9021308422,
-0.7339165807,
0.2589269876,
0.0561039783,
-0.3566788733,
-0.2216622382,
0.6366303563,
-0.4598169625,
-0.7566565871,
0.3477044106,
0.6936778426,
-0.0576237962,
-0.5919111967,
-0.4514501989,
0.0424823016,
-0.3800579607,
0.7389990091,
-0.0757246017,
-0.9484961033,
-0.2736359537,
0.3975428343,
-0.392667681,
-0.1003067121,
0.6554873586,
-0.4994615614,
0.3300347924,
0.6432687044,
0.9429699183,
-0.1208691522,
0.460401237,
0.5141398311,
-0.3805309236,
-0.2683062553,
0.3109461069,
0.2862959504,
0.4652995765,
-0.2404570878,
0.6132443547,
-0.0524631254,
-0.7463442087,
-0.6022800207,
-0.2353558689,
-1.0798449516,
0.0539844967,
1.0059673786,
-0.3760541379,
-0.2337498963,
-0.21374093,
-0.3039920032,
0.0270511061,
-0.2698768079,
0.5303281546,
0.7699819803,
-0.3621623814,
-0.087486431,
-0.6164025664,
0.3009456694,
0.4202143848,
-1.0496723652,
0.2572142482,
0.3139809072,
0.2211339474,
0.0672056526,
0.4850988388,
-0.4191395938,
0.2251759917,
-0.5408990383,
0.355568558,
-0.1115787476,
-0.0825247839,
-0.5407296419,
0.0967818946,
0.4261587858,
0.0035436971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05350v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05350v1
|
There's no Data Like Better Data: Using QE Metrics for MT Data Filtering
| 2023-11-09T13:21:34 | 2023-11-09T13:21:34 |
Jan-Thorsten Peter, David Vilar, Daniel Deutsch, Mara Finkelstein, Juraj Juraska, Markus Freitag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Quality Estimation (QE), the evaluation of machine translation output without
the need of explicit references, has seen big improvements in the last years
with the use of neural metrics. In this paper we analyze the viability of using
QE metrics for filtering out bad quality sentence pairs in the training data of
neural machine translation systems~(NMT). While most corpus filtering methods
are focused on detecting noisy examples in collections of texts, usually huge
amounts of web crawled data, QE models are trained to discriminate more
fine-grained quality differences. We show that by selecting the highest quality
sentence pairs in the training data, we can improve translation quality while
reducing the training size by half. We also provide a detailed analysis of the
filtering results, which highlights the differences between both approaches.
|
[
-0.2859247327,
-0.265984267,
0.6531178355,
-0.1316706389,
-0.5692889094,
0.0899145827,
-0.0088620419,
-0.2161910832,
0.2297226638,
0.4990417361,
-0.1345601976,
-0.7390319109,
-0.8595780134,
0.1816610545,
-0.7320860028,
1.0912712812,
0.1358637512,
0.4679334462,
-0.0730986893,
-0.3235970736,
-0.7426983714,
-0.6212077141,
-0.8763094544,
-0.2267843038,
0.4813561141,
0.0458291396,
1.1339124441,
0.6410518885,
0.7274599671,
0.2452497333,
0.0486764871,
0.4604774714,
-0.5444883108,
0.3338973224,
-0.0162768792,
-0.7217254043,
-0.3710536361,
0.2475728393,
0.3944962323,
0.3874801993,
-0.0804864541,
-0.0907210261,
0.1015955135,
0.9184478521,
-0.2364684045,
-0.2677903473,
-0.4766868055,
0.4059953094,
-0.2312591076,
-0.2865926027,
-0.2338635921,
-0.5802005529,
-0.1267621219,
-0.5380598307,
0.0665179566,
0.2979212999,
1.1637989283,
0.3977464139,
-0.5628743768,
-0.1132999957,
-0.4742363691,
1.0360716581,
-1.0065491199,
0.6089014411,
0.8465318084,
0.1805172563,
-0.2300418764,
-0.608818531,
-0.3066640496,
-0.1987772584,
-0.0508038327,
0.1673861295,
-0.1216045618,
-0.0828660876,
0.0634376258,
0.5361667275,
-0.7780631781,
0.1538665891,
-0.2565523684,
-0.3137007654,
0.4120271802,
0.0937331617,
0.5060405135,
-0.286593765,
-0.2662155926,
-0.1202473715,
-0.6007218361,
-0.1112951115,
0.2956157327,
0.0321874656,
0.2545160651,
0.4619115889,
-0.2730378211,
0.3449036479,
-0.2829298675,
0.0712365508,
0.0734104067,
-0.4526516497,
-0.3636575639,
-0.6427864432,
0.9799937606,
0.6178048253,
0.2488213629,
-0.7232932448,
-0.7159729004,
-0.0210944619,
0.3027265072,
-0.8742614388,
-0.3498096764,
0.1632470936,
-0.6432124376,
-0.1814771146,
0.0892954245,
-0.5530403852,
-0.2724496424,
-0.5257900357,
0.4744427204,
-0.6622850299,
-0.1298120022,
0.1874854565,
-0.3242285848,
-0.2039559931,
-0.2273508161,
-0.4080630243,
0.3329764605,
0.5121076703,
1.005769968,
-0.2226704359,
0.0361841433,
-0.9983125925,
-0.6139377356,
-0.5824011564,
0.8388474584,
-0.1097613201,
-0.1414470822,
-0.1749486178,
-0.3392771482,
-0.0299523156,
-0.8889123201,
0.9356404543,
-0.8777076602,
0.3180604875,
-0.1400558352,
-0.7617089748,
-0.1004442647,
0.2045956552,
-0.6075602174,
1.091588974,
0.3846135139,
-0.5849963427,
0.4635284543,
-0.4924887121,
-0.2179209739,
-0.0654593781,
0.3694795966,
-0.502232492,
0.4259183407,
0.4031714201,
0.3992879391,
-0.2834030986,
0.5247514248,
-0.3133485019,
-0.3522779942,
0.4856375158,
-0.4985088408,
0.67231071,
0.484600842,
0.0227227788,
0.1507723629,
-0.7104246616,
0.3341169059,
-0.0922528282,
-0.3696344793,
-0.4706925154,
0.2314319015,
0.0867290348,
0.3900834322,
-0.2347841263,
-0.5903452039,
-0.2437264919,
-0.5642728806,
0.7660003304,
0.5180304646,
-0.0266867429,
0.3483954072,
-0.4371905327,
0.3811568916,
0.1746823639,
0.1840252131,
0.3387167156,
-0.255564183,
-0.5757085681,
0.1225110441,
0.813567102,
0.2510379851,
-1.2239724398,
0.3767963946,
-0.4442066252,
-0.1645184308,
-0.8538685441,
0.3320612609,
0.4255706668,
0.244991973,
0.4967831075,
-0.5474855304,
-0.5977038741,
-0.8149210215,
-0.4227222502,
0.0310217217,
-0.3139104545,
-0.2497465014,
0.2558135986,
0.2925325334,
0.8717570305,
-0.2467927039,
-0.1162442863,
0.1152679622,
-0.0610227436,
0.155173853,
0.5296808481,
0.5093088746,
-0.9605163336,
-0.5124368668,
-0.3241607845,
-0.9000763297,
-0.0860308856,
0.1007034555,
-0.4736869335,
-0.1762594581,
0.3578686714,
-0.2348679751,
0.2220992893,
0.6956956387,
-0.4645093083,
0.268945545,
-0.100937508,
0.3528651595,
-1.0938862562,
-0.2343672812,
0.2906470895,
-0.6616412997,
-0.6801714897,
0.1893705577,
0.0181242973,
0.2080056667,
-0.3336808085,
0.174185589,
-0.2508139908,
0.0249562003,
-0.430567652,
0.3971442878,
0.4303758442,
0.2972014546,
-0.3120264113,
0.814612031,
0.3027453423,
-0.5570921302,
0.2613831162,
0.4125280976,
-0.4949623346,
0.9175976515,
-0.5426582694,
0.2984072864,
-0.0030312506,
0.0009574884,
-0.953222096,
0.1827050298,
0.0726464614,
-0.9001805186,
0.1217272654,
-0.1510472447,
-0.8879805207,
-0.3101415038,
-0.2823091745,
0.0148932803,
0.5353881717,
-0.6942284703,
-0.2148401737,
0.280861944,
0.2752786577,
-0.3787954748,
-0.7738161683,
0.3845767379,
-0.2933136225,
-0.4665876925,
0.0753515288,
-0.0484092496,
0.0902953297,
0.2549378872,
-0.2656434774,
-0.6819835901,
0.2103782296,
0.0136519708,
0.3083758652,
-0.6979601979,
0.3449002206,
0.02378482,
-0.2558219433,
0.1409437507,
-0.5866006017,
0.4483621418,
0.2348984331,
0.0371761173,
-0.6788478494,
0.2551818788,
0.5353896022,
-0.3567507267,
0.889754653,
0.94091326,
-0.3800796866,
0.0756083131,
-0.3513652682,
-0.3457778096,
-0.4353964925,
0.3419450521,
-0.3303047121,
-0.720510006,
0.0424670167,
0.3352812827,
-0.0445558913,
0.4826749861,
-0.203253746,
-0.5063274503,
1.2316527367,
0.261210233,
-0.3046385944,
0.4182122052,
-0.2980592549,
0.3909869194,
-1.0646996498,
0.1314215213,
-0.5518291593,
-0.5132450461,
-0.52740556,
-0.0284294263,
0.3961886466,
0.3750095367,
-0.147340402,
0.4473612309,
-0.5655070543,
0.6476140022,
0.7895386219,
0.4013197124,
0.3311185539,
0.1532158703,
0.0941358209,
-0.3789636493,
-0.6250018477,
-0.7109348774,
1.1552174091,
0.2123662233,
-0.0297620632,
-0.1219617799,
0.4557625055,
0.4052006006,
0.1801181883,
-0.7246126533,
0.4320003986,
-0.5734001994,
-0.5911871195,
-0.2319966555,
-0.7843934894,
-0.8933321834,
0.4936113656,
-0.5198153257,
-0.2662095129,
-0.0418446623,
-0.1019725502,
-0.4643550813,
0.6891916394,
-0.6351299882,
0.8237117529,
-0.0390267707,
-0.1063778102,
-0.2490014136,
-0.4237095416,
0.1068514585,
0.0384649634,
0.0833584368,
-0.29233706,
0.0265578125,
0.9764581323,
-0.3708048463,
0.4736335576,
-0.2735424042,
0.2760036886,
0.4212375581,
0.1715801507,
0.3286374211,
-0.0421975628,
-0.3291940093,
0.1678889096,
0.2175659686,
-0.7081067562,
-0.6801691055,
0.5520833731,
-0.6956537366,
-0.1693463326,
0.0032301911,
-0.4624948204,
-0.2142570615,
0.1997500658,
0.3580508232,
0.5723614097,
0.0341150016,
0.3834690154,
0.2781625092,
-0.1566203684,
0.4108381867,
0.3797312081,
0.0834600329,
-0.669691503,
1.066170454,
0.2616051137,
0.2169966251,
0.4020363688,
0.1477034837,
-0.4283455312,
-1.1772882938,
-0.4079013169,
0.1030043513,
-0.5072607994,
-0.6604440808,
-0.5652325153,
-0.216518417,
-0.0964608341,
0.2679340243,
-0.37448138,
-0.5165279508,
-0.0363999158,
-0.0775826126,
0.2667135894,
0.6742236018,
-0.0836103857,
0.7911008596,
-0.9997165799,
0.3842117488,
-0.1875691563,
0.4256666303,
-0.3640296459,
-0.7348439693,
-0.5375087261,
0.2400165349,
-0.5257435441,
-0.6539865732,
0.7562189102,
-0.0650245845,
0.1184508577,
-0.0167101175,
0.1141887903,
0.5564228296,
-0.185371846,
0.7965561748,
0.134060666,
-0.8315151334,
0.441904068,
-0.0867449418,
-0.0441404469,
0.5988627672,
0.2209478915,
-0.6928370595,
-0.5850128531,
-0.4297249317,
-0.7518364787,
0.4806184173,
0.5154877305,
0.0715591833,
-0.0216853879,
0.724480927,
0.0557409935,
0.3268040121,
-0.68164289,
-0.1712071002,
-0.1593577713,
-0.2529135644,
-0.2368897647,
-0.0401368216,
0.4473728538,
-0.0879550874,
0.8529959917,
0.2592130303,
0.1137749255,
0.1073818505,
-0.2123790085,
-0.1372179836,
0.3152665794,
0.0499909855,
0.233510837,
-0.1656702012,
0.0863103792,
0.0184398647,
-0.2797587514,
0.1214038506,
-0.5064707994,
-0.2477255613,
0.2109612375,
0.0628130585,
0.7480814457,
-0.110727571,
-0.3340082765,
0.6099867225,
0.0997332558,
-0.1684702486,
0.1213043556,
0.1406879574,
-0.0043101073,
0.0563032627,
-0.1580060571,
0.4003454447,
0.4469367266,
-0.2451366037,
0.381722033,
0.2500098944,
-0.6175055504,
-0.4099258184,
0.7456970215,
0.0899158195,
-0.4028629661,
0.9954282641,
-0.2622857392,
-0.4870089591,
0.6757487059,
0.3430571556,
0.6131907701,
-0.1784885824,
0.3384315372,
0.5019375682,
0.334758997,
-0.2531332076,
0.0049888822,
0.2360277325,
-0.6871824861,
-0.7321687937,
-0.6057116389,
-0.1573456675,
0.2619451582,
-0.7281543016,
0.0174102411,
-0.006682517,
-0.4984299541,
0.0016481586,
0.1251555234,
-0.6978039742,
0.5657259226,
-0.1335416436,
0.5077337027,
-0.8320485353,
0.8770148158,
0.4797534347,
-0.462107718,
-0.6548027992,
-0.2802833915,
-0.1380466074,
-0.7463545799,
0.5598888993,
-0.0837018788,
0.0802105516,
0.1101962551,
-0.387218833,
-0.7076330185,
0.6687532067,
0.3835621178,
-0.4320455194,
-0.0299606211,
0.2510519326,
0.7450551391,
-0.005169984,
0.3806602061,
0.7042278647,
0.5366507769,
-0.4573513567,
-0.5821079612,
-0.2179264277,
-0.1738831252,
0.0893847346,
0.5491793156,
-0.4490826428,
0.4281826019,
0.2006153464,
-0.3390506208,
0.2108567804,
0.4478987455,
-0.5919210315,
0.4818882346,
0.4746564031,
0.5284272432,
0.5961957574,
-0.2832148969,
1.1525833607,
-0.0890794396,
0.2250860631,
1.0848295689,
0.2215207517,
1.1655260324,
0.3718328178,
-0.3449064791,
0.1983395964,
0.8053203821,
-0.111501433,
0.3922676444,
0.1463640928,
0.1379713863,
-0.1749213785,
-0.029827632,
0.083532393,
0.0408588499,
0.0701503679,
-0.3904317915,
-0.0539064147,
0.1664773524,
-0.0699226558,
0.4808612764,
-0.078806147,
0.6703888178,
0.3766089082,
-0.5572714806,
0.7608347535,
0.0174633935,
0.6286831498,
0.0177666973,
0.3386143446,
-0.565187037,
-0.0639784932,
-0.4549472928,
-0.8240467906,
0.6244794726,
0.0772549659,
-0.3196102679,
-0.1711137444,
0.3425196409,
-0.4414610565,
0.0256303996,
0.2109271139,
0.9325065613,
0.5758471489,
-0.6015181541,
-0.5314238071,
-0.4460020065,
0.0762429163,
-0.2020694017,
0.3697358966,
0.5195705295,
0.2029045969,
0.5827333927,
0.7608513832,
0.3473089933,
0.1863976121,
0.0680418089,
0.4841967821,
-0.7208577991,
-0.1407292634,
-0.9433148503,
0.4196119905,
-0.2245170176,
-0.3503863811,
0.5578993559,
0.7126164436,
0.713118434,
0.1346510351,
0.4409035444,
0.3120893538,
0.6433045864,
-0.6117791533,
0.6813309789,
-0.5680679679,
0.3092054129,
0.3716307282,
-1.1856892109,
-0.5534576774,
0.4751847386,
-0.1479883492,
-0.1246487126,
1.0502086878,
0.8099944592,
-0.2453462631,
0.1165964082,
0.7634002566,
0.3115631938,
0.319665432,
0.6067996025,
0.8366187215,
-1.034091711,
0.8125146031,
-0.113520883,
0.2516251206,
0.0140424194,
-0.4624470174,
-0.7901024818,
-0.5578171611,
-0.4063074887,
-0.5044579506,
0.29730317,
0.8860411048,
0.9614947438,
-0.8670817614,
0.0092251068,
-0.1690316796,
0.1726828963,
-0.2852723897,
-0.1650038809,
0.4027264118,
-0.704012394,
-0.855445087,
0.627456069,
0.2263510227,
0.0166619811,
0.149085328,
-0.1570355147,
0.2427494377,
-0.0241342671,
0.6396902204,
-0.1516467631,
-0.3350663483,
-0.3170393109,
0.0210519042,
-0.4381213188,
0.6678929329,
0.6352979541,
-0.567971766,
0.3540168405,
0.3227436244,
0.7699207067,
0.3033655286,
-0.2249872237,
0.443344146,
-0.4918330908,
-0.3871646225,
0.3067899048,
0.3862167597,
0.4423903227,
-0.1414076835,
0.8264771104,
0.0846510902,
-0.7703475356,
-0.847659111,
-0.1466763914,
-0.7471057177,
-0.0181662701,
0.9592497349,
-0.3192372322,
-0.1323457509,
-0.2898898125,
-0.2532973886,
0.4099122286,
-0.4161670804,
0.8307108879,
0.9014986753,
0.2591895759,
0.1495424062,
-1.142568469,
0.2465202212,
0.7824335098,
-0.7673692107,
-0.4061366916,
0.3379119635,
0.3264151812,
-0.1708652675,
0.3561550677,
-0.2286210805,
0.0733462274,
-0.0979384109,
-0.1869884133,
-0.0231665876,
-0.1081262678,
-0.2607123852,
0.2109217346,
0.1576160491,
-0.5996822715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05332v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05332v2
|
On the Road with GPT-4V(ision): Early Explorations of Visual-Language Model on Autonomous Driving
| 2023-11-09T12:58:37 | 2023-11-28T09:47:57 |
Licheng Wen, Xuemeng Yang, Daocheng Fu, Xiaofeng Wang, Pinlong Cai, Xin Li, Tao Ma, Yingxuan Li, Linran Xu, Dengke Shang, Zheng Zhu, Shaoyan Sun, Yeqi Bai, Xinyu Cai, Min Dou, Shuanglu Hu, Botian Shi, Yu Qiao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
The pursuit of autonomous driving technology hinges on the sophisticated
integration of perception, decision-making, and control systems. Traditional
approaches, both data-driven and rule-based, have been hindered by their
inability to grasp the nuance of complex driving environments and the
intentions of other road users. This has been a significant bottleneck,
particularly in the development of common sense reasoning and nuanced scene
understanding necessary for safe and reliable autonomous driving. The advent of
Visual Language Models (VLM) represents a novel frontier in realizing fully
autonomous vehicle driving. This report provides an exhaustive evaluation of
the latest state-of-the-art VLM, GPT-4V(ision), and its application in
autonomous driving scenarios. We explore the model's abilities to understand
and reason about driving scenes, make decisions, and ultimately act in the
capacity of a driver. Our comprehensive tests span from basic scene recognition
to complex causal reasoning and real-time decision-making under varying
conditions. Our findings reveal that GPT-4V demonstrates superior performance
in scene understanding and causal reasoning compared to existing autonomous
systems. It showcases the potential to handle out-of-distribution scenarios,
recognize intentions, and make informed decisions in real driving contexts.
However, challenges remain, particularly in direction discernment, traffic
light recognition, vision grounding, and spatial reasoning tasks. These
limitations underscore the need for further research and development. Project
is now available on GitHub for interested parties to access and utilize:
\url{https://github.com/PJLab-ADG/GPT4V-AD-Exploration}
|
[
-0.4264087677,
-0.8121397495,
1.1285393238,
0.1891311109,
-0.2857078016,
-0.1589664072,
0.0104130609,
-0.6307698488,
-0.5804315805,
0.2704001665,
-0.480914712,
-0.4366388023,
-0.3447717726,
-0.0779530481,
-0.5895397067,
0.465061456,
-0.1619442105,
0.1236594468,
-0.4559412003,
-0.1456151754,
-0.4666799009,
-0.4168117642,
-0.3205012083,
-0.1664672643,
0.2197837234,
-0.0602894351,
0.4704113305,
0.6895114779,
0.674333334,
0.4383245707,
0.2631409168,
-0.2826742828,
-0.1837492287,
-0.2048116326,
-0.1794600487,
0.0400519557,
-0.331346035,
0.0950670168,
0.7627344131,
0.2383730561,
-0.0461170226,
-0.2664949596,
-0.2585123777,
0.3888813257,
-0.5306656957,
0.4312019944,
-0.4124983549,
-0.1253648996,
-0.1331356168,
-0.1809294075,
0.0068716244,
-0.2678694129,
0.4092292488,
-0.8250707984,
0.0448372141,
0.0693870187,
1.0499491692,
0.6534981728,
-0.6263247728,
-0.2890576422,
-0.8654076457,
0.6337943077,
-0.5848804712,
0.5985202789,
0.0195316542,
0.6012050509,
0.0482303314,
-0.869838357,
-0.7733373642,
-0.4191560447,
0.1357396841,
0.3460726142,
-0.4214778543,
0.3029805422,
0.1579376161,
0.253688395,
-0.6114298105,
0.0154974544,
-0.5368258953,
-0.0975551009,
0.5362442732,
0.2490500659,
0.2743428648,
0.0406484306,
-0.7560648322,
0.0897837952,
-0.8777229786,
0.2750593424,
0.2419252545,
0.060733147,
-0.1593454927,
0.4156819582,
-0.411616534,
0.8856931329,
-0.4507789016,
0.2119625807,
0.1980553418,
-1.0330923796,
-0.3997679353,
-0.2934665382,
0.7577819228,
0.569756031,
0.2065624595,
0.0051748226,
-0.33935076,
0.2397225201,
0.50527668,
-0.6342078447,
-0.3809414208,
-0.0868501887,
-0.1955463588,
-0.2768155038,
-0.0376698114,
-0.5788860917,
-0.2430580109,
-0.7024866939,
0.4590194821,
-0.4553538561,
-0.2646552324,
0.1217527911,
0.0285783149,
0.7343583107,
0.8460086584,
-0.737337172,
0.5234393477,
0.4433224797,
0.8996636271,
-0.139727965,
-0.387994796,
-0.2541401386,
0.0128249722,
-0.2521941662,
1.0027896166,
-0.2433484793,
-0.4184271991,
-0.2550425828,
-0.0304667838,
0.1827890575,
-0.3415876627,
0.4717351496,
-0.1488441527,
-0.0563423075,
-0.4192005396,
-0.2038706392,
-0.6426038146,
0.2836418152,
-0.5334457755,
0.6450834274,
0.181752339,
-0.199836269,
0.6289157867,
-0.7457622886,
-0.4371107519,
0.4403350651,
-0.6005852818,
-0.3822658956,
-0.0005321297,
0.13236323,
0.2678774297,
-0.3948290348,
0.2219139636,
-0.1653487384,
-0.2430307269,
-0.0281495377,
-0.5301680565,
0.6403636336,
0.1364751756,
-0.4288397133,
0.6466313601,
-0.6240943074,
-0.1912571043,
0.236504361,
-0.2445553094,
-0.1629432291,
0.0827519521,
0.1697260141,
0.2577218115,
0.2790183425,
-0.4212398827,
0.1027676687,
-0.0879744962,
0.4076345861,
0.948141396,
-0.1008936837,
0.5249869227,
0.1256047785,
0.4420693815,
0.0949495137,
0.4168736339,
0.0389752239,
-0.9311919808,
-0.7659357786,
0.1215120926,
-0.1470699459,
0.6705444455,
-0.8359029889,
-0.0780991465,
0.0808707774,
-0.26908198,
-0.3694215715,
-0.016763201,
0.4468931258,
0.5137152076,
0.2883829176,
-0.1018829122,
-0.4243778586,
-0.6678397655,
0.0510956123,
-0.2493595332,
0.2365633547,
0.3564324975,
0.646176219,
-0.4690701663,
0.9068462253,
-0.2909472287,
-0.0968339294,
-0.3318201602,
-0.024594754,
-0.1995690018,
0.3271014094,
0.633215189,
-0.9468768239,
-0.1996510923,
0.3211299181,
-0.9648519158,
-0.0561443754,
0.0322318338,
0.124658525,
0.0625353977,
0.4953047931,
-0.4750319421,
0.7803469896,
0.3536205292,
-0.6035091877,
0.4399712086,
-0.6205944419,
0.1593524069,
-0.1243497282,
-0.1263054609,
0.2527156472,
-0.57342273,
-0.745038569,
-0.0027645477,
0.1009399742,
0.1156581864,
-0.4424081445,
0.3423656523,
-0.4069525003,
-0.450766474,
-0.3208836615,
0.2632983029,
-0.3841181397,
0.2444140017,
0.0942960083,
0.9757811427,
0.8470618129,
-0.7056108713,
0.5748929977,
-0.0477848537,
-0.4764859974,
0.5286682248,
-0.6004552841,
-0.0478533693,
-0.1767521054,
-0.2451371253,
-0.8208223581,
-0.2762086987,
0.3048208058,
-0.1245398894,
-0.1316057593,
-0.0503347926,
-0.5055289865,
-0.2699179947,
0.2934217453,
0.3848256469,
0.5419706106,
-0.3538041711,
0.6313236952,
0.5690353513,
-0.1374386698,
-0.1322041601,
-0.3428319991,
0.2450678051,
-0.2698118091,
-0.6885477304,
0.2231264263,
-0.1434215903,
-0.6138735414,
0.069137603,
0.1548431367,
-0.0291048363,
0.1020535678,
0.2280894369,
0.3172753155,
-0.0840507522,
-0.1352272779,
-0.2101406157,
-0.4739666283,
0.1294489503,
-0.063857004,
0.1504390836,
-0.8142927885,
-0.2509967387,
-0.4057849348,
0.1728709936,
0.5591207743,
-0.4086486101,
0.0602562837,
0.3718438447,
-0.2277981043,
-0.0319367163,
-0.0814806819,
-0.0570518747,
-0.4871433377,
0.4235720038,
-0.4264867604,
-0.5651212335,
0.0947978199,
-0.2960507572,
-0.2639220059,
0.1771307588,
0.6479523778,
-0.1380170584,
0.9772289395,
0.6567457318,
0.3808194101,
0.3920855224,
-0.1699456573,
0.326012373,
-0.4151435792,
-0.2675131261,
0.1421379149,
0.1646778286,
-0.4953917563,
-0.5364853144,
0.5934972763,
-0.445730567,
-0.2259051204,
-0.0077487738,
-0.3461068571,
0.3818862736,
0.5198819637,
-0.1506623775,
0.4546796978,
-0.5962702036,
0.251619339,
0.164163664,
-0.5271587968,
-0.4105154574,
0.8445284367,
0.3965690136,
0.5113782287,
0.2405861765,
0.0657409281,
0.1956868768,
0.1422449648,
-0.6414451599,
0.7144551873,
0.0784407333,
-0.3166824579,
-0.2844248414,
-0.3579610288,
-0.6116830111,
0.437756896,
-0.175490886,
-0.5604093075,
-0.0442301035,
0.2708624005,
-0.4311396778,
0.0426688232,
-0.5857787132,
1.1531127691,
-0.6510416269,
-0.3020590842,
0.0109767318,
-0.9085829258,
0.6235339046,
0.0388483144,
0.2798967063,
-0.0368685946,
0.0871048048,
0.2667398155,
-0.3129255176,
0.4388863444,
-0.2551399469,
0.0882007778,
0.3863599002,
-0.3599323928,
0.4191685319,
-0.1601188481,
0.4102998674,
0.2457258105,
-0.2227178663,
-0.1209405437,
-0.5881710052,
0.6461097002,
-0.6223241091,
-0.43841663,
-0.6866030693,
-0.4983543456,
0.0775397867,
0.3375360072,
0.2284428626,
0.4859392047,
-0.2450862378,
-0.1441975683,
0.6639208794,
-0.1534038782,
0.4783115685,
0.3214713931,
-0.7412816882,
-0.1786102504,
1.0001180172,
0.1405714601,
0.3402125835,
-0.0276302882,
0.2977648675,
-0.611908555,
-0.9525210857,
-0.7711213827,
0.1338746399,
-0.8435373902,
0.1420317441,
-0.5197221637,
-0.1363351196,
-0.2806335986,
-0.0493546911,
-0.4750706255,
-0.0491150767,
-0.073898159,
-0.3370624185,
0.2236346453,
1.34425354,
-0.0946785361,
0.3597364426,
-0.1702925265,
0.2836591601,
0.4904807806,
0.146124348,
-0.321555078,
-0.0021542169,
-0.15414159,
-0.3939855099,
-0.2130045295,
-0.6605893373,
0.3263973296,
-0.3642431796,
0.5772722363,
0.3297573924,
-0.2041258812,
0.544878304,
-0.5423146486,
0.5760296583,
0.084724918,
-0.8180627227,
0.4419533908,
-0.5585839152,
0.4537159204,
0.4524185061,
-0.0085134506,
0.0429398194,
-0.2017282397,
-0.3161212504,
-0.8361736536,
0.3551281989,
0.6007552743,
-0.4447985888,
0.3562652767,
0.0795066357,
-0.0923693329,
0.3124416471,
-0.9580295682,
-0.1506403536,
-0.4636432827,
-0.0803169385,
-0.1430470049,
0.0705146417,
0.1706804782,
-0.4996300936,
0.3503447175,
0.1502425671,
0.3231191337,
0.2402808368,
0.1125969663,
0.0498302765,
0.028448673,
0.9384719729,
0.6624075174,
-0.2838603854,
0.2549315691,
0.0002208314,
-0.5180506706,
0.269187212,
0.2311907113,
-0.2790580094,
-0.296149075,
0.0449662916,
0.9802527428,
0.016085986,
-0.6859087348,
0.9018219113,
-0.2414796501,
-0.1580605656,
-0.6864632964,
0.1397596449,
-0.3745033443,
0.3588420451,
-0.0155762108,
0.3360774517,
0.4287002981,
-0.5631246567,
0.1665121764,
0.3314709365,
-0.7247026563,
-0.4612586498,
0.8841676116,
0.2551873028,
-0.020507738,
0.5248181224,
-0.5104358196,
-0.5175586343,
0.470884949,
0.3594005108,
0.7487530112,
-0.0456073023,
-0.0873419866,
0.1658203602,
0.4851069152,
-0.0130797094,
0.3880493343,
-0.085639447,
-0.7449254394,
-0.4552009702,
-0.3723112643,
-0.2609627843,
-0.0101794507,
-0.1959739774,
0.1076045558,
-0.5838304162,
-0.0250514671,
-0.3638608754,
-0.3267777264,
-0.8274303079,
0.4269298315,
0.1874014586,
0.5473876595,
-0.7490489483,
0.830997467,
0.6763780713,
-0.5256515741,
-0.3652987778,
-0.1614551395,
0.4609727263,
-0.6460052133,
0.7550729513,
0.2208039463,
-0.5388621092,
0.2565276921,
-0.5740247369,
-0.7773057222,
1.2911889553,
-0.0712719038,
-0.4582688808,
-0.0857898667,
0.0357375778,
0.2750160694,
-0.3152516484,
0.0844539776,
0.6424872279,
0.6781959534,
0.1744257361,
-0.7211796641,
0.0468403921,
-0.2123315781,
-0.003555337,
0.2114000469,
-0.5970444679,
0.9265512228,
-0.2908452153,
-0.2274186015,
0.3448181152,
0.5981834531,
0.3241984248,
0.533094883,
0.6514414549,
0.73604846,
0.4690330029,
-0.3494672179,
1.3329263926,
0.1337613165,
0.141920343,
0.7605504394,
-0.3684537113,
0.3919534087,
0.532972455,
-0.1726367772,
0.3163167834,
0.3537223935,
0.0910487249,
1.0721232891,
0.1426955163,
-0.4977813959,
-0.3504793048,
0.1910610497,
0.0170744993,
0.7398928404,
0.2728801668,
0.0629064068,
-0.2248475701,
0.2941671908,
-0.2274805754,
-0.1069274768,
-0.3961385787,
0.8452519774,
-0.0222710725,
-0.5424153209,
0.0595004521,
-0.2183002234,
0.1777966321,
-0.6131104231,
-0.3533717096,
0.2727890313,
0.20271191,
0.2349195629,
-0.9611856937,
0.1545255333,
0.0028789595,
0.1134042144,
-0.4975059032,
0.6580199003,
-0.08205273,
-0.3186688721,
0.3089964986,
0.4649751186,
0.267228663,
-0.0806721076,
-0.498650372,
0.3116222024,
0.1673454046,
0.0622688644,
0.0536505729,
0.5420231223,
0.0226174388,
0.7291666269,
0.4872093797,
-0.0245880634,
0.2738081515,
-0.019626243,
0.791608572,
-0.9901174307,
-0.5552051067,
-0.915584445,
0.8478387594,
-0.0390984975,
-0.4059170187,
0.8065253496,
0.4189175069,
0.7729027867,
0.1375203431,
1.1799833775,
0.0770945475,
0.0827492326,
-0.8737432361,
0.4366374314,
-0.6466180086,
0.1343965381,
-0.336387068,
-0.6269512773,
-0.4172316492,
0.9077106714,
-0.6242808104,
0.0776164532,
0.4826871753,
0.4933031201,
-0.1933873147,
0.0434138142,
0.6229951978,
0.2390445322,
0.7487042546,
0.3730300963,
1.2906688452,
-0.2287183702,
0.2780300081,
-0.158708021,
-0.4362324178,
0.0114783589,
-0.8211538196,
-0.548748672,
-0.7212539911,
0.005966011,
0.2082627118,
0.19955194,
0.480602771,
0.64742589,
-0.2019370645,
-0.2228198051,
-0.8550221324,
-0.0293074418,
0.0492958017,
-0.1605177671,
-0.085183382,
-0.1934922189,
-0.6375457048,
0.6572491527,
0.792067349,
0.5475167036,
-0.5223312378,
-0.3573274016,
-0.1702348441,
-0.2208937556,
0.6568710804,
0.1215899065,
-0.8490734696,
-0.2670243382,
-0.170857802,
0.0840260163,
0.2249931842,
0.8122856021,
-0.8218749166,
0.7888004184,
0.3359539211,
0.3051476181,
0.5602166653,
0.2094022334,
0.9975081086,
0.0030160688,
0.063530758,
0.1134161651,
0.5859495997,
0.4554057717,
-0.167531997,
0.5542047024,
0.3853107393,
-0.9778006077,
-0.5048100352,
0.5324651599,
-1.1907068491,
-0.2038534284,
1.0618374348,
0.0273208991,
-0.2863617241,
-0.3552643061,
-0.3540131748,
0.1544468552,
-0.3886198401,
0.274567306,
0.2461138517,
-0.3679739833,
-0.5957743526,
-1.1277680397,
0.5578433871,
-0.0234246701,
-1.0446026325,
-0.0261406638,
0.7300040722,
-0.105649814,
-0.1525987983,
0.7828694582,
0.1230024621,
0.4312460124,
0.074702993,
-0.1119856536,
0.0314944498,
-0.602175355,
-0.4393149018,
-0.2167818695,
-0.0118218157,
-0.1411173046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05297v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05297v2
|
Challenging the Validity of Personality Tests for Large Language Models
| 2023-11-09T11:54:01 | 2024-06-05T10:33:18 |
Tom Sühr, Florian E. Dorner, Samira Samadi, Augustin Kelava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 91E45, H.1; I.2; I.6; J.4
|
With large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4 appearing to behave increasingly
human-like in text-based interactions, it has become popular to attempt to
evaluate personality traits of LLMs using questionnaires originally developed
for humans. While reusing measures is a resource-efficient way to evaluate
LLMs, careful adaptations are usually required to ensure that assessment
results are valid even across human subpopulations. In this work, we provide
evidence that LLMs' responses to personality tests systematically deviate from
human responses, implying that the results of these tests cannot be interpreted
in the same way. Concretely, reverse-coded items ("I am introverted" vs. "I am
extraverted") are often both answered affirmatively. Furthermore, variation
across prompts designed to "steer" LLMs to simulate particular personality
types does not follow the clear separation into five independent personality
factors from human samples. In light of these results, we believe that it is
important to investigate tests' validity for LLMs before drawing strong
conclusions about potentially ill-defined concepts like LLMs' "personality".
|
[
-0.4245664179,
-0.7995730042,
0.7385204434,
0.3724316955,
-0.2016166747,
0.0315883458,
-0.4090642631,
-0.4129441082,
0.1803951114,
0.4645891786,
-0.5994753242,
-0.0402863175,
-0.5042257905,
0.5230376124,
-0.493232578,
0.9134387374,
-0.1062709317,
-0.050319992,
-0.272703737,
-0.3132986426,
-0.2421632707,
-0.8678910732,
-0.4412628114,
-0.5349075198,
0.8923072219,
0.4581147432,
0.6775833368,
0.1256425083,
0.4854954779,
0.1906248033,
-0.0310536213,
-0.1346554756,
-0.5059289932,
0.1177184284,
-0.2663770914,
-0.3177183568,
-0.4839786589,
0.23936598,
0.662519753,
0.684047997,
-0.0273367465,
0.2270919085,
0.14779751,
0.5091296434,
-0.292986095,
-0.1543063968,
-0.5274757147,
-0.1684399694,
-0.1799930036,
-0.0092193754,
-0.455888927,
-0.4227991402,
0.182208851,
-0.0081268689,
0.3021286726,
0.0075417971,
0.8076078892,
-0.1000019759,
-0.5041865706,
-0.2758435309,
-0.9115570784,
0.6297848821,
-0.8033581376,
0.2404713333,
0.6204044819,
0.1411223114,
-0.0507684425,
-0.2656148672,
-0.9382683635,
-0.6379159093,
-0.085825406,
-0.130091697,
0.0561273396,
-0.2950316072,
0.4255788326,
0.2448610216,
-0.730207026,
0.3834686875,
-0.2431508601,
-0.0973947793,
0.8407965302,
0.2732303441,
0.1215478927,
0.000302164,
-0.224100098,
-0.2104622573,
-1.1386479139,
-0.0311808251,
0.6618370414,
0.2112402618,
0.0297735296,
0.7819111943,
0.058461085,
0.1014722362,
0.255924046,
-0.1687682569,
0.441931963,
-0.1617067754,
-0.1198613569,
-0.3822050393,
0.7030231357,
0.4888192117,
0.6947091818,
0.0331886187,
-0.1280805916,
-0.0181191526,
0.2661695182,
-0.7223113179,
-0.182740882,
0.3164381981,
-0.3206043839,
-0.1054748446,
-0.1109750345,
-0.7912657261,
-0.4482198656,
-0.06346187,
0.1785663366,
-0.2504193783,
-0.3448174,
-0.0355511196,
0.0852451324,
0.6750514507,
0.2461789101,
-1.0355986357,
0.2841452956,
0.6257519722,
0.5413538814,
-0.4629884958,
-0.5355536342,
-0.3155024052,
-0.3594666719,
-0.2138373554,
0.6781969666,
-0.5529167056,
-0.7942925096,
-0.0914055258,
0.2002077997,
0.0454488397,
-0.7384216189,
0.5619301796,
-0.4577122927,
0.3601295352,
-0.8136936426,
-0.5121514201,
0.0150811216,
0.5509922504,
-0.3635618687,
0.8217965364,
0.3032548726,
-0.6083927751,
0.3015390337,
-0.3513166904,
-0.37433514,
-0.0749728829,
-0.4071270823,
-0.4808200002,
0.1732181907,
-0.1593333185,
0.5077270269,
-0.1929613054,
0.0940745175,
-0.7569878101,
-0.2958438694,
0.7784532905,
-0.398583293,
0.5646699071,
-0.0419005193,
-0.3384449184,
0.0716065019,
-0.6411675811,
0.0264964029,
0.3908669949,
-0.5235806108,
-0.2752244473,
0.1019068658,
-0.0144268749,
0.240509674,
0.0459177792,
-0.7923067808,
0.3145208061,
-0.2072783262,
0.2590331435,
0.8830990195,
-0.1965813488,
0.2233820111,
-0.5332583785,
0.6221533418,
-0.246761173,
-0.0794785246,
0.173761934,
-0.5119009018,
-0.5002039671,
-0.1326661855,
-0.1709415019,
0.4899511635,
-0.3687849045,
0.6764265299,
-0.2873582244,
-0.6503958702,
-0.0614259094,
0.1170802191,
0.3167895377,
0.2825866342,
0.2417314351,
-0.4601658881,
-0.3396318853,
-0.9963929057,
-0.5478813648,
-0.3369739056,
-0.2321778536,
0.4927023351,
0.7791188359,
-0.479685992,
0.8201555014,
-0.3636000752,
0.3033548892,
-0.3989867568,
0.0157391001,
0.0122400355,
0.2546691597,
0.5758687258,
-0.7160909176,
-0.4251359999,
-0.3966457844,
-0.3821750581,
-0.291578263,
0.0253573153,
0.3023996353,
0.0897565857,
0.3670740426,
-0.7239322066,
0.3069903255,
0.5802627802,
-0.6253712773,
1.1152304411,
-0.1075164899,
-0.0093871141,
-0.6268808842,
-0.0184915066,
0.0057083764,
-0.1481265277,
-0.4909671843,
0.254306525,
0.0957203433,
0.2693002224,
-0.2291231602,
0.6356397867,
-0.2864475846,
-0.2525233626,
-0.2855503559,
0.088761732,
0.1069242805,
0.3360325694,
-0.2246771753,
0.7900386453,
0.1650173664,
-0.6725578904,
0.4606529176,
0.313367784,
-0.2513578534,
0.8492091298,
-0.7405297756,
0.5926924348,
-0.208597526,
0.3923186064,
-1.1792328358,
-0.3949068189,
0.1442557424,
-0.3726352155,
0.1766144335,
0.2862616181,
-0.4752429426,
-0.2399931997,
-0.5617670417,
0.2380588353,
0.686408937,
-0.4999916553,
0.6851270795,
0.0377227589,
-0.3901242614,
-0.2512711883,
-0.798034668,
0.0557418875,
-0.617010355,
-0.4018045366,
0.0931897759,
-0.5219118595,
-0.6081596613,
-0.2813169658,
-0.0975172594,
-0.0123599535,
0.2734288275,
0.0512682423,
0.2675251961,
-0.1256430596,
0.0833703876,
-0.2891106009,
0.3512881696,
0.3409320414,
0.1755512804,
0.6090013981,
-0.1221157983,
-0.6048789024,
-0.1413226277,
0.3382676244,
0.7438169718,
-0.0137366848,
0.5924869776,
0.5528643727,
-0.0787290931,
0.0529653616,
-0.5974268913,
-0.371468693,
-0.4856416285,
0.6526510119,
-0.5196357965,
-1.1858489513,
0.6315920949,
0.1552195102,
0.1369708478,
0.2644844353,
0.8668516874,
-0.3276605308,
0.8136686683,
0.2808181047,
0.1745250374,
0.1111058295,
0.2115742266,
0.2756611109,
-1.2384352684,
-0.1514547616,
-0.6229388118,
-0.4789907038,
-0.6952466369,
-0.1762830019,
-0.0027687941,
-0.4510878325,
-0.4081349969,
0.0998428315,
-0.0863371715,
0.4901514053,
0.0806001499,
-0.0463429354,
0.2781766355,
-0.2661162019,
0.1757442951,
-0.2544033527,
-0.0791476145,
-0.7105013728,
1.3078712225,
0.5148361921,
0.9495927691,
0.5365771055,
0.4792359471,
0.1274147928,
0.7726475596,
-0.7899265289,
0.7670682073,
0.0056382976,
-0.8267939091,
-0.4331190884,
-0.5072154403,
-0.8762283921,
0.4258458614,
-0.0203843117,
-1.017996788,
0.0387006253,
0.0212633144,
-0.3224724233,
0.1593081355,
-0.8332303166,
0.5451378822,
-0.4342105985,
-0.2062276751,
0.1194213629,
-0.4536470473,
0.5392149091,
-0.4451391101,
0.1326415539,
-0.3477626741,
0.042546887,
0.5624213815,
-0.1676658988,
0.9492138028,
0.0443941057,
-0.4867086709,
0.0515100025,
0.4271905124,
0.4433065653,
0.1289712191,
0.0556649044,
-0.1855059564,
0.1329103559,
-0.3499715328,
-0.8376138806,
0.7611421943,
-0.9326888919,
-0.849506855,
-0.4156973362,
-0.4370604157,
-0.3861275613,
0.0671457276,
0.1235820949,
0.3038489819,
-0.4559312463,
0.266378969,
0.5932665467,
-0.3952552676,
0.011550867,
0.6931350827,
-0.5254397392,
0.0350174196,
0.6127106547,
-0.016956415,
0.6266009808,
0.0821781754,
0.5047805905,
-0.4722058475,
-0.5350205302,
0.0434493311,
0.3839946091,
-0.6019987464,
0.4423032701,
-0.3514840901,
0.2025553733,
-0.504901886,
0.0568895601,
-0.2557165325,
-0.0239990316,
-0.1628413796,
-0.1321471035,
-0.0605309121,
0.8789432645,
0.1883244365,
0.0414655246,
-0.5833204389,
0.1767531484,
0.5702130198,
0.1181861684,
-0.0323268026,
-1.0237375498,
0.2409401238,
-0.1200879961,
-0.328330934,
-1.0444293022,
0.2466587126,
0.1681945026,
0.3998476863,
0.3463165462,
-0.1711158752,
0.3175490797,
-0.4356443882,
0.8200413585,
-0.1833526343,
-0.743475616,
0.0844234303,
-0.453022033,
0.2888612151,
0.5310024619,
0.6673269868,
-0.5590974092,
-0.3444799483,
-0.6928560734,
-0.6078603864,
0.3213889003,
0.2556581199,
0.476726532,
-0.0598439611,
0.7854152322,
0.1455254406,
0.0835440904,
-0.9360259771,
-0.1350812763,
0.022358248,
-0.1092111766,
-0.3351615369,
-0.4753170907,
-0.0975650549,
-0.4252206087,
0.3937106133,
-0.2002328336,
0.2313273251,
0.3336421847,
0.1821188927,
0.1479191631,
0.5549398661,
0.7343311906,
0.6942090392,
-0.3310196996,
0.3202004135,
0.4232174456,
-0.6572093368,
0.3536048532,
-0.2212089449,
0.0015548172,
-0.2960273027,
0.3717875481,
0.3593591452,
0.1314843446,
-0.8646168709,
0.5193883777,
-0.2340513319,
-0.2116270214,
-0.5729302168,
0.0705240145,
0.3335647583,
0.1663918197,
0.093945466,
-0.1284139603,
-0.2772586942,
-0.8821901679,
0.1094645336,
0.4008756876,
-0.1435084492,
-0.6826924086,
0.2563510537,
0.1291881651,
-0.590248704,
0.7027989626,
-0.5328634381,
-0.5411482453,
0.5175979137,
0.5225732327,
0.9226229787,
-0.1939207613,
-0.0040485566,
0.1544313729,
0.5098839998,
-0.0199065544,
0.4051614702,
0.2993963659,
-1.1664363146,
-0.4827228785,
-0.335506469,
-0.6256824732,
0.4791955948,
-0.4689578414,
0.0041137305,
-0.6343705654,
-0.2036135495,
-0.2709979415,
-0.1675672233,
-0.6440958977,
0.0228525326,
0.2644735575,
0.8427452445,
-0.890313983,
0.7430070639,
0.7541792393,
-0.1356179267,
-0.8857495785,
0.3500575721,
0.2303234637,
-0.7183865309,
0.690728724,
0.106061697,
0.0435127392,
-0.1791873127,
-0.7363916636,
-0.6919010282,
0.8477521539,
0.1967126131,
-0.4201120734,
-0.1041086689,
0.0932672471,
0.5870282054,
-0.2650516033,
0.3740789294,
0.7856748104,
0.4929710329,
0.0852421969,
-1.0777943134,
0.2248703092,
-0.0781660303,
-0.1193055585,
-0.1424658895,
-0.7057128549,
1.1211503744,
-0.342423141,
-0.0576728918,
0.2372069657,
0.4696729183,
0.5929200053,
-0.0269630179,
0.5745548606,
0.4496118724,
0.7496555448,
0.0027666003,
1.2070385218,
0.2156042159,
0.520716846,
1.2457822561,
-0.956028223,
0.8097056746,
0.4696499407,
-0.4389282167,
0.6578499675,
0.4778469801,
-0.1026889458,
0.1455399543,
0.3999974728,
-0.1556255966,
-0.0987677649,
0.2802852392,
-0.0690184236,
0.6977753043,
0.2263798118,
-0.211114496,
-0.1030077264,
-0.1926504672,
0.3111902773,
0.0282432027,
0.1665621847,
0.3176561594,
0.1671220809,
-0.6860899925,
0.4308587611,
0.1202827692,
0.8463990092,
-0.5807582736,
0.3290228546,
-0.392731607,
0.2159345597,
-0.203767851,
-1.0444031954,
0.4270133376,
0.1879298836,
0.1020230278,
-0.1897017956,
0.6655275822,
-0.2012774497,
-0.1245410293,
0.0735150203,
0.8366799355,
0.2368901521,
-0.3208658695,
-0.3822063208,
0.0151611036,
0.0612558946,
-0.5080237985,
0.6209277511,
0.2604495585,
0.0023914911,
0.7241110802,
0.6837783456,
0.112347804,
-0.143149972,
0.1231707186,
0.7115941644,
-0.8479507565,
-0.3677250743,
-1.263512373,
0.1974425912,
-0.0230670404,
-0.5846800208,
0.9855849147,
0.3141269982,
0.7688610554,
-0.0343409926,
0.7398201823,
0.027272135,
0.4971897304,
-0.3473136425,
0.4248525798,
-0.2189132124,
0.3260827363,
-0.3880327046,
-0.9247569442,
0.0149273425,
0.5135390162,
-0.4632428586,
0.4968774617,
0.8730926514,
0.5925105214,
0.178080976,
0.1132577732,
0.3871174455,
0.3748237193,
0.7292212844,
0.5891216993,
1.1495885849,
0.057962954,
0.2264771909,
0.0778814405,
-0.2521017492,
-0.1147446558,
-0.8540199399,
-1.0795576572,
-0.3367730081,
-0.3517420292,
-0.4908243418,
-0.480738461,
0.8267475367,
0.2858422101,
-0.447493732,
-0.1570782959,
0.297337383,
-0.0846976638,
0.0030009425,
-0.2633867264,
0.0378730223,
0.2091068923,
-0.4893877506,
0.1060643792,
0.1312916726,
0.1554566771,
-0.958029449,
-0.0805035159,
0.0499903634,
0.1736804545,
0.6625915766,
0.3933541179,
-0.7634900808,
-0.9690299034,
0.2184064984,
-0.151911974,
-0.0714638233,
0.8154715896,
-0.5215710402,
-0.023243418,
0.4381361604,
0.4747335911,
0.2016722262,
0.0979813486,
0.4482916296,
-0.7819798589,
-0.1241622269,
0.3546667397,
0.4191013575,
0.6472262144,
-0.3154706061,
0.209035024,
0.4672902822,
-0.7248945832,
-0.6851971149,
0.6483433843,
-0.9296779633,
0.0276619978,
1.6643520594,
-0.195427686,
-0.0675456524,
-0.2554328144,
-0.1235765442,
-0.3623697758,
-0.129304871,
0.9338779449,
1.0387464762,
-0.5112344623,
-0.0736717805,
-0.5315614343,
0.231330201,
0.4023375809,
-0.7812584639,
0.2007425427,
0.2310961038,
0.7522157431,
0.2540323138,
0.8777450323,
-0.2289232165,
0.020635413,
-0.317789197,
-0.0336097069,
0.1637360603,
0.1506225914,
-0.474072516,
-0.0495926067,
0.4393857718,
0.2212354839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05296v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05296v2
|
BeLLM: Backward Dependency Enhanced Large Language Model for Sentence Embeddings
| 2023-11-09T11:53:52 | 2024-03-14T08:04:17 |
Xianming Li, Jing Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentence embeddings are crucial in measuring semantic similarity. Most recent
studies employed large language models (LLMs) to learn sentence embeddings.
Existing LLMs mainly adopted autoregressive architecture without explicit
backward dependency modeling. Therefore, we examined the effects of backward
dependencies in LLMs for semantic similarity measurements. Concretely, we
propose a novel model: backward dependency enhanced large language model
(BeLLM). It learns sentence embeddings via transforming specific attention
layers from uni- to bi-directional. We extensively experiment across various
semantic textual similarity (STS) tasks and downstream applications. BeLLM
achieves state-of-the-art performance in varying scenarios. It shows that
auto-regressive LLMs benefit from backward dependencies for sentence
embeddings.
|
[
-0.1160064116,
-0.8192861676,
0.5498782396,
0.2793319225,
-0.1044320464,
-0.1575426459,
-0.0876335725,
-0.6282923818,
0.1258831322,
0.7489340901,
-0.4951096773,
-0.7273619175,
-0.6956032515,
0.1020348817,
-0.3727166355,
0.7980015874,
0.0271939747,
0.1396088898,
-0.2238175571,
-0.0538152941,
-0.8544511199,
-0.2537812889,
-0.2629124224,
-0.2779963017,
0.4720636606,
0.2369599938,
0.7644853592,
0.6432097554,
0.4054058194,
0.3331902027,
0.1678693146,
-0.228411451,
-0.3464361727,
0.295801878,
-0.421127826,
-0.6981909871,
-0.2008887976,
0.1550099701,
0.9179615974,
0.7417414784,
0.1286724806,
0.0174279511,
0.1998129338,
0.762039423,
-0.5568563342,
0.4789499938,
-0.8146259189,
0.0258992743,
0.1602946818,
-0.2290941328,
-0.4415771663,
-0.4634457529,
0.4329171181,
-0.1526017487,
0.005794921,
0.1585758626,
0.7633177638,
0.3255906701,
-0.6320867538,
-0.2871301174,
-0.5638396144,
0.9879071712,
-0.7891849279,
0.7193421125,
0.2138780206,
-0.0184431393,
-0.2681497335,
-0.6776698828,
-0.4380911589,
-0.3606177866,
-0.0113159157,
0.0556212962,
-0.1215518564,
-0.0921950713,
0.0147276912,
0.2429799587,
-0.4816693366,
0.2854451537,
0.0214182306,
-0.0065309447,
0.2800128758,
0.4085086882,
0.3385355771,
-0.1660987884,
-0.6270813346,
-0.1009805873,
-0.7624356747,
-0.2471986115,
0.2172201127,
0.4305493236,
-0.0724330992,
0.5949631929,
-0.0205959361,
0.6505528688,
0.0864691511,
0.1097687855,
0.3335638046,
-0.2991958857,
-0.2363812774,
0.0869394541,
0.6555626392,
0.2749115825,
0.3855627477,
-0.5011277199,
-0.0813017637,
0.1678488702,
0.3019667864,
-0.873676002,
-0.1516777277,
-0.18049784,
-0.4949579537,
-0.076259546,
0.1437744796,
-0.7457096577,
-0.1268238574,
-0.3878770173,
0.4154822528,
-0.4442269504,
0.0103543764,
0.1598369032,
0.1182065979,
0.588193655,
0.1473504752,
-0.7176892161,
0.3486748934,
0.7773154378,
0.8648077846,
-0.1630314589,
-0.4190400541,
-0.8215454817,
0.3128861189,
-0.3034881055,
0.6583182216,
-0.7566816211,
-0.196147427,
0.2509583533,
0.2821808159,
-0.0809792653,
-0.4942095578,
0.3353604078,
-0.8425958753,
0.3449205756,
0.1541433781,
-0.8103764057,
-0.5592468977,
0.2851849794,
-0.3780464828,
0.7283121347,
-0.0956597775,
-0.8412427902,
0.1863639802,
-0.1364580542,
-0.5817846656,
-0.2042025775,
-0.1677896082,
-0.5535980463,
0.1615943313,
-0.0114910286,
0.6159480214,
-0.2858558893,
0.1800183952,
-0.695710659,
-0.1894095391,
0.1571684629,
-0.3642945886,
0.7283017635,
-0.0864712298,
-0.2664490044,
0.1392502636,
-0.8493590355,
-0.1536626518,
-0.1108266339,
-0.1784776598,
-0.7702708244,
-0.0859058127,
0.1063959152,
0.178891018,
0.2912641466,
-0.4949607551,
0.0228672717,
-0.7527005672,
0.4437510371,
0.6540458798,
-0.0084682563,
0.5168640018,
-0.2001645863,
0.3397442997,
0.0944338664,
-0.2117682546,
-0.2375651598,
-0.3496517539,
-0.5041722059,
-0.4459569454,
0.2997965813,
0.4869825542,
-0.0293364357,
0.7738440037,
-0.1711708754,
-0.042297937,
-0.1019051969,
0.0862744227,
0.2998412549,
0.2509474158,
0.3057264686,
-0.4511274695,
-0.5102706552,
-0.9564666748,
-0.4335232973,
-0.1905326694,
0.2604033053,
-0.0902448446,
0.4346776307,
-0.6383254528,
0.9003213048,
-0.5632948875,
-0.5918901563,
-0.1127487272,
0.1368359178,
-0.035698548,
0.3506278694,
0.4093441367,
-0.5321554542,
-0.3467956185,
-0.3443163335,
-0.5008856654,
-0.2126549035,
-0.1314736456,
-0.153432101,
0.3599500954,
0.6374275684,
-0.7218316197,
0.4081433117,
0.626785934,
-0.5418727398,
0.364520371,
-0.3891448975,
-0.0236844458,
-1.1536684036,
-0.1397343874,
0.0496427231,
-0.3940454125,
-0.0857642069,
0.1106390804,
0.2332392484,
0.1368931234,
-0.2025847584,
0.4281380177,
-0.6956561208,
-0.4748212099,
-0.4775272906,
0.2840356231,
-0.0788805038,
0.3909249008,
0.0216862708,
0.341201812,
0.4949920774,
-0.5860964656,
0.3374671638,
0.3256447315,
-0.1579742432,
0.3929935992,
-0.6279693842,
0.0883433595,
0.0639350563,
0.2716856301,
-1.2772203684,
0.1550409794,
0.1452397406,
-0.4226938486,
0.4999606907,
0.0098462338,
-0.6736164689,
0.0265658498,
-0.4163830578,
0.2615240216,
0.5736269951,
-0.5573402047,
0.6750586629,
0.2646261752,
-0.2958830893,
-0.5125339627,
-1.0599217415,
0.2095376998,
-0.2617769241,
-0.4592766464,
0.2916125357,
0.2355757952,
-0.1171664447,
0.3816732764,
0.1333708316,
0.1374703497,
0.0024530955,
0.423723191,
0.4252282977,
-0.2388382107,
0.4873949587,
0.0094688674,
-0.1412460506,
0.2405112088,
-0.6897055507,
0.4619923234,
-0.1218990758,
-0.0857711062,
-0.5709224343,
0.4622192383,
0.4913311005,
-0.2303048223,
0.7630627751,
0.4898661971,
-0.3469394743,
-0.1882065088,
-0.648835063,
-0.2116247863,
-0.4079363048,
0.7920000553,
-0.2430303991,
-1.0454467535,
0.3247645199,
-0.1681510955,
0.0073999045,
0.2260072231,
0.68760252,
0.1797232777,
0.8634243011,
0.831609726,
-0.3220275044,
0.5952900052,
0.0924115777,
-0.0479283109,
-0.7084629536,
-0.0855355635,
-0.5860418677,
-0.1141321957,
-0.7827418447,
-0.2982670367,
-0.1407235265,
0.1737128496,
-0.5453593731,
0.3101037741,
-0.1720094234,
0.0551609024,
0.3045997322,
-0.0002486772,
0.4221620262,
-0.055251427,
-0.1738525331,
-0.0447823182,
-0.4681145847,
-0.5261438489,
0.9199539423,
0.4059722424,
1.0359787941,
0.0416965708,
0.7537720799,
0.190183118,
0.0818404108,
-0.9325582981,
0.6485728621,
-0.2999596596,
-0.1997557133,
-0.1788591295,
-0.5035094619,
-1.117606163,
0.0390877388,
-0.1251962483,
-0.708719492,
-0.0478509218,
-0.011467481,
0.0077321464,
0.0584727973,
-0.6338776946,
0.7888775468,
-0.0814298838,
-0.355874002,
-0.5505672097,
-0.5761265159,
0.0148880146,
0.1145421043,
-0.001489607,
0.2158594877,
-0.303578794,
0.7024949789,
-0.281465441,
1.1754704714,
-0.0068716193,
-0.2853960991,
0.0898244008,
0.151820004,
0.8134822845,
0.1659512818,
0.2509019077,
0.1060738564,
-0.1723919958,
-0.3188665509,
-0.6882134676,
1.2169241905,
-0.7785866857,
-0.8472265601,
-0.4246970713,
-0.7425783277,
-0.4724605381,
0.3439347446,
-0.161073789,
0.4470991492,
-0.1920350641,
0.0670937449,
0.5573215485,
-0.5656998754,
0.5214707255,
0.5307129025,
-0.4363433123,
-0.2951812446,
0.2900941074,
0.0816470012,
0.2643393874,
0.6185062528,
0.0676273331,
-0.5965002179,
-0.4383765161,
-0.1016438007,
0.4271423221,
-0.5804443955,
-0.0926278159,
-1.0116100311,
-0.0586426146,
-0.5418727398,
0.0062921061,
-0.5010831356,
-0.3850728571,
-0.2449361235,
-0.201729998,
0.5870212913,
0.7649888992,
-0.0643978789,
-0.2623651028,
-1.0175801516,
0.1489564329,
0.3994936943,
0.3509875238,
0.1884365976,
-0.5771133304,
-0.3624646962,
-0.2094943076,
-0.3287142515,
-0.7043480873,
0.5002335906,
0.0724639744,
0.37023592,
0.0917806998,
0.0567748733,
0.3863646388,
-0.7245526314,
0.5874541998,
0.4051777124,
-0.951869607,
0.3338625133,
-0.1633938551,
0.6137344837,
0.2213944197,
0.2933984697,
-0.2067430615,
-0.6355059147,
-0.2660434544,
-0.71611619,
0.3507678807,
-0.2439426929,
0.2688125968,
-0.1728263497,
0.3540313542,
0.4062083066,
-0.1014862582,
-0.4672631621,
-0.0090506794,
-0.0341642462,
-0.3740878403,
-0.2578512728,
-0.2089571208,
0.3809279501,
0.1008717641,
0.5144200921,
0.1824209094,
0.4110262692,
0.2503581643,
-0.224306196,
-0.0945312753,
0.3987277448,
0.1321431994,
0.2403734326,
-0.0287848432,
0.3909465373,
0.2148085833,
-0.3841261268,
0.0499868877,
0.2197288573,
-0.2279779166,
-0.0589532591,
0.4111055434,
0.69089818,
0.3944686353,
-0.3588050902,
0.3772673905,
0.1892618835,
0.1005076393,
-0.4159927666,
-0.1411545575,
0.400090009,
0.7305008173,
0.2284702957,
0.0726190582,
0.2102684528,
-0.9530730247,
0.4753603935,
0.5818548799,
-0.9109619856,
-0.3004294038,
0.5183619261,
-0.0241405107,
-0.2312946469,
0.5996490717,
0.2121339142,
-0.5610123277,
0.3908960819,
0.7250570655,
1.0060143471,
-0.1495293081,
0.0603070669,
0.2312052846,
0.06212819,
-0.2414357066,
0.0832708552,
0.0934165567,
-0.675645113,
-0.5704000592,
-0.3600646257,
-0.0029157514,
-0.1486598253,
-0.7134854794,
0.3170165122,
-0.2550908625,
-0.1130403876,
-0.335618943,
-0.054036472,
-0.7138932347,
0.2494128793,
0.0403265916,
0.5047656298,
-0.51530689,
1.028550148,
0.7850965858,
-0.3447098434,
-0.7222570777,
0.448585093,
-0.1443843693,
-0.691166997,
1.1155558825,
0.3049388528,
-0.4233992696,
0.1616200209,
-0.2287635654,
-0.547232151,
1.053502202,
0.3119252622,
-0.8754611611,
-0.131789729,
0.1469243616,
0.6297745109,
-0.6753235459,
0.2576421797,
0.1523119956,
0.1000303775,
-0.1839275062,
-0.7166084647,
0.4502384365,
0.2005126774,
0.4182281494,
0.3307893872,
-0.7692237496,
0.5092211962,
-0.4308923185,
-0.3954379261,
0.2744193077,
0.9199177027,
0.0891914368,
0.1290329397,
0.4026766717,
0.7644561529,
0.2469918281,
0.2853939831,
0.7907556295,
-0.3114565909,
0.4897823334,
1.3448431492,
-0.4400694072,
1.1550273895,
0.4377132356,
0.0298502333,
0.6893554926,
0.3121020496,
0.0483980887,
0.7981302142,
0.3839236498,
0.169642657,
-0.1749275476,
0.0511609651,
-0.5148990154,
0.3266435862,
0.1059396118,
-0.7348834872,
-0.223166272,
0.2245775759,
-0.1048378944,
0.2745678127,
-0.2563425601,
0.7266142368,
0.4656655788,
-0.4175680876,
0.4339095056,
-0.0908872485,
0.8616814017,
-0.483730197,
-0.0891564041,
-0.1577700675,
0.5981125832,
-0.0857756436,
-0.6508985758,
0.480763346,
-0.1000549942,
-0.2876074612,
0.0625087246,
0.6568288803,
-0.5698904991,
-0.3791428804,
1.0161856413,
0.431974858,
-0.1577024609,
0.1745146811,
-0.5995336771,
-0.0798521489,
-0.2063528746,
-0.4325065315,
0.5677372813,
0.7361460328,
0.1125649586,
0.7008054256,
0.2074094415,
0.1215837151,
0.1729992926,
0.1785293072,
0.5793699026,
-0.9383326769,
-0.7444248199,
-0.8258535862,
0.0135608371,
0.2025427818,
-0.1193764508,
0.9064179063,
0.4944025874,
0.9113314152,
-0.1762341261,
0.7279466987,
0.3086865246,
0.6260405779,
-0.7094069123,
0.4233683646,
-0.5392172933,
0.4353470504,
-0.4550064802,
-1.3300658464,
-0.4059410393,
0.4854161739,
-0.6032953262,
-0.0044601616,
0.9187019467,
0.9185429811,
0.0476597287,
0.2007412016,
0.3918862045,
0.5862332582,
-0.0068254792,
0.812708497,
1.1019767523,
-0.4341515005,
0.5257291198,
0.1456765085,
-0.2395285517,
0.0304412264,
-0.7398326993,
-1.0754328966,
-0.5821398497,
-0.6836506128,
-0.4121183157,
0.3701515496,
0.9682817459,
0.401242733,
-0.8051590919,
-0.0997414216,
-0.4532331824,
-0.23290281,
-0.0908631608,
-0.2958878577,
0.5563833714,
-0.4980136752,
-0.6867564321,
0.0745248199,
0.5029844642,
-0.1341600418,
-0.3718142509,
-0.0503238291,
-0.3824028969,
0.0893189535,
0.6053192019,
-0.0929843783,
-0.7885916233,
-0.7061485648,
-0.1697695404,
-0.395424962,
0.0012613469,
0.7476160526,
-0.8412005305,
0.0966752768,
0.7300376892,
0.9549722672,
0.4780584574,
-0.2247623503,
0.7559562325,
-0.1681986451,
0.0794149339,
0.040463116,
0.4169920981,
0.2893024087,
-0.3852106929,
0.2663841844,
0.2203321159,
-0.6506262422,
-0.3921070993,
0.4858574867,
-0.9829185009,
-0.3613798618,
1.3351256847,
-0.5510449409,
0.0771501511,
-0.2387197316,
-0.0802714676,
0.5285277963,
-0.3624185026,
0.8260813355,
0.5325425863,
0.1264791936,
-0.3924557865,
-0.1060153693,
-0.0856057331,
0.6258333325,
-0.4960316122,
0.0164148975,
0.5109274387,
0.4089529812,
-0.0168527495,
0.0299040861,
-0.566534996,
-0.0863405019,
-0.0198833086,
-0.104740642,
-0.058551617,
-0.070389308,
-0.3525198102,
0.2646950185,
-0.0732499436,
-0.4045075178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16162v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16162v1
|
Leveraging Artificial Intelligence Technology for Mapping Research to Sustainable Development Goals: A Case Study
| 2023-11-09T11:44:22 | 2023-11-09T11:44:22 |
Hui Yin, Amir Aryani, Gavin Lambert, Marcus White, Luis Salvador-Carulla, Shazia Sadiq, Elvira Sojli, Jennifer Boddy, Greg Murray, Wing Wah Tham
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
The number of publications related to the Sustainable Development Goals
(SDGs) continues to grow. These publications cover a diverse spectrum of
research, from humanities and social sciences to engineering and health. Given
the imperative of funding bodies to monitor outcomes and impacts, linking
publications to relevant SDGs is critical but remains time-consuming and
difficult given the breadth and complexity of the SDGs. A publication may
relate to several goals (interconnection feature of goals), and therefore
require multidisciplinary knowledge to tag accurately. Machine learning
approaches are promising and have proven particularly valuable for tasks such
as manual data labeling and text classification. In this study, we employed
over 82,000 publications from an Australian university as a case study. We
utilized a similarity measure to map these publications onto Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs). Additionally, we leveraged the OpenAI GPT model to
conduct the same task, facilitating a comparative analysis between the two
approaches. Experimental results show that about 82.89% of the results obtained
by the similarity measure overlap (at least one tag) with the outputs of the
GPT model. The adopted model (similarity measure) can complement GPT model for
SDG classification. Furthermore, deep learning methods, which include the
similarity measure used here, are more accessible and trusted for dealing with
sensitive data without the use of commercial AI services or the deployment of
expensive computing resources to operate large language models. Our study
demonstrates how a crafted combination of the two methods can achieve reliable
results for mapping research to the SDGs.
|
[
-0.4849188626,
-0.4606972933,
0.5687735677,
-0.2206097394,
-0.2356738746,
0.3267716169,
-0.292668134,
-0.5273073912,
0.1417787522,
0.4099024832,
-0.4047852457,
-0.7867544293,
-0.7808668613,
0.1112054437,
-0.2199583948,
0.924846828,
-0.2760160565,
-0.0521971025,
-0.2747960687,
-0.2063912302,
-0.3292665482,
-0.1179532781,
-0.5839287639,
-0.5068995953,
0.5507506132,
0.1377915591,
0.6112719774,
0.6422053576,
0.9111760855,
0.2638449371,
0.1396097988,
0.4393256903,
-0.3710157275,
-0.3214261532,
-0.1462617666,
-0.1581866443,
0.042550832,
0.34326455,
0.4242904484,
0.5119255185,
0.4288718402,
0.650794208,
0.4056628346,
0.6200347543,
-0.3420725763,
0.5175455213,
-0.2929486632,
0.2137984335,
0.0823084116,
-0.0951185301,
0.0865614414,
-0.4158259332,
-0.1122007892,
-0.5225957632,
0.1290365756,
-0.0163670871,
0.8862920403,
0.7555612326,
-0.2636386156,
-0.5487282276,
-0.5988273025,
0.8250191808,
-0.6173360348,
0.0933003649,
0.4965479374,
-0.1135413796,
-0.1085643917,
-0.4763744175,
-0.8126987815,
-0.1815121025,
-0.0356824622,
0.2939984202,
0.2718145251,
-0.0076217265,
0.264734596,
-0.1353893578,
-0.6755373478,
0.0288407039,
-0.4639596343,
-0.0804623589,
0.9326804876,
-0.0466497056,
-0.0228119828,
-0.0288732555,
-0.692091465,
-0.2093172222,
-0.3630295694,
0.08635775,
0.4828656614,
0.6809053421,
0.0009017166,
0.5220635533,
-0.2012895495,
0.4667381942,
-0.2345360219,
-0.0819966346,
0.2601599395,
-0.9025526047,
0.0667231083,
0.1201070696,
0.7695632577,
0.4270201623,
0.0651106387,
-0.2157395184,
0.0684549659,
0.4168075919,
0.1935975105,
-0.5410152674,
-0.456861943,
0.061730992,
-0.6095018387,
0.1854425967,
0.3162050247,
-0.593336165,
-0.4146628976,
-0.9355686307,
0.1538413912,
-0.1075612232,
-0.174450174,
-0.1222943738,
-0.0847074166,
0.2899388373,
0.2061533928,
-0.4820760489,
-0.0540700518,
1.0167520046,
1.0726742744,
-0.0680191442,
-0.1698963046,
0.029457828,
0.1445318013,
-0.2274627686,
0.6158364415,
-0.6694083214,
-0.4037855864,
-0.257414639,
-0.3599514365,
-0.1995444447,
-0.2734475136,
0.7558521628,
-0.2140442431,
-0.2281270623,
-0.5051488876,
-0.601444006,
-0.4493465424,
0.3980495036,
-0.5635985136,
1.039265871,
0.0733169317,
-0.4775542617,
0.7029114962,
-0.7268545628,
-0.3461346328,
0.1779452264,
-0.3059261739,
-0.7516236305,
-0.1571492404,
0.0378254279,
0.57532686,
-0.4324899018,
0.5164458752,
-0.3324632049,
-0.3792275786,
-0.20275639,
-0.1406354159,
0.8699077964,
0.3259789646,
-0.3041124046,
0.2674956322,
-0.5533783436,
0.2364599854,
-0.0131837977,
-0.4344486296,
-0.4903840423,
-0.0500431955,
0.296941191,
0.1229528561,
0.3303562999,
-0.5965083838,
0.4911110401,
0.2552084923,
0.6048909426,
0.7332506776,
-0.0186013356,
0.2110708803,
-0.6121112704,
0.2183997482,
-0.3396678865,
-0.0386998393,
-0.0000447523,
-0.8001722097,
-0.3349131048,
-0.1351210177,
0.5470301509,
0.4750816822,
-0.2896601856,
0.6847217679,
-0.3733989894,
-0.7068024874,
-0.8118556738,
0.1478362978,
-0.0528294258,
0.6642890573,
0.4595177174,
-0.4067483842,
-0.3936585784,
-0.357288748,
-0.5245845914,
-0.4038455486,
0.0319814198,
0.4064335823,
0.8935340047,
-0.608663559,
1.0823922157,
-0.2715992033,
-0.6467190385,
0.250459373,
0.3030035198,
0.0691405311,
0.5208582282,
0.7103030086,
-1.6130942106,
-0.3309862018,
0.1314855665,
-0.8980391622,
-0.0137991924,
-0.3412906229,
0.1429783106,
-0.2805401981,
0.3676272035,
-0.5393144488,
0.6091752052,
0.1732606739,
-0.4419108629,
0.3804368377,
-0.1681443304,
0.6493381262,
-0.7200194597,
0.2320055664,
0.4039645493,
0.1532291323,
-0.4028932154,
0.1831018478,
-0.056656789,
-0.3772908449,
-0.1953772604,
0.5830068588,
-0.2182079554,
-0.0570984483,
-0.1115152687,
-0.0274701342,
-0.1091184393,
0.1591659486,
-0.1583193541,
0.7797279954,
0.124669075,
-0.4695756137,
0.5132941604,
0.5050846934,
-0.2520971596,
0.2493375391,
-0.3260130286,
0.1952985972,
-0.2021777332,
0.0381486714,
-0.7570963502,
0.001366235,
0.4207618237,
-0.4749495685,
-0.0182507876,
0.0903331488,
-0.6672846675,
-0.6392058134,
-0.3097130954,
0.2921025455,
0.2814017534,
-0.3938711286,
0.6248044968,
0.4752382338,
-0.2999323308,
-0.1253718436,
-0.7038190961,
0.2087577879,
-0.6199226379,
-0.3235189617,
0.2972297072,
-0.1842972338,
-0.1838837415,
0.2036854178,
-0.1169928461,
0.343174547,
0.2239533365,
0.4731082916,
-0.1145931333,
-0.0777924731,
0.0206393097,
-0.1844289303,
-0.2105876803,
0.1314975023,
-0.4142335951,
0.2990114987,
-0.0222271699,
-0.4253966808,
-0.5203939676,
0.5521272421,
0.4568237662,
-0.5176844001,
0.7916953564,
0.6811394095,
-0.3935965598,
0.0096823527,
-0.1564427763,
0.0954555497,
-0.436730206,
0.0178938434,
-0.386015892,
-0.7145497799,
0.3938840032,
-0.9679546356,
0.0928767845,
0.2803918421,
0.1912333369,
-0.1559141129,
0.74499017,
0.8058422208,
-0.4625948966,
0.4377996922,
-0.5018981099,
0.5850228071,
-0.7586324215,
-0.3937241435,
-0.8251740932,
-0.4911001325,
-0.5083104968,
-0.4852980971,
0.1842440814,
0.4095183909,
-0.2636224926,
0.1961184293,
-0.9752268791,
0.3133502007,
0.7695536613,
0.0071947635,
0.2572927177,
0.0093427794,
0.2079505771,
-0.0960240141,
-0.5310886502,
-0.795016408,
1.0340764523,
-0.0284211617,
0.6486753225,
-0.2272901386,
1.0567231178,
0.9429275393,
0.2630538642,
-0.6489013433,
0.5939832926,
-0.1327802688,
-0.0337590948,
-0.2688196599,
-0.5801332593,
-0.7771892548,
-0.0516446643,
-0.1615466177,
-0.5684376955,
0.2249052078,
-0.0874829069,
-0.1407461613,
0.3596275747,
-0.6044799089,
0.5150039196,
-0.461659044,
-0.1564193964,
-0.2687372565,
-0.526704967,
-0.3093393743,
-0.2049728185,
0.391726017,
-0.3355206549,
0.1000860929,
0.9068288803,
0.084872961,
0.7002410293,
-0.0859702229,
0.0872660652,
0.4033937454,
-0.4963882267,
0.3425186872,
-0.0452228934,
-0.5098392367,
0.4842487574,
-0.3759881854,
-0.4828858972,
-0.1570204943,
0.775626123,
-0.7789489627,
-0.5359870791,
-0.5914040804,
-0.5036372542,
0.101125896,
0.3791226447,
-0.1447804868,
-0.1967761219,
-0.1888872534,
-0.1646047682,
0.5441867113,
-0.0922623649,
0.3469657898,
0.0051521338,
0.2324494421,
-0.0222773701,
1.1967669725,
0.4317884147,
-0.117387861,
0.290335983,
0.3293080628,
-0.3441274464,
-0.8765820265,
-0.355912298,
0.150113225,
-0.4192509949,
-0.4749848843,
-0.3112696111,
-0.2675318718,
-0.6584758162,
-0.4153198302,
0.0896091834,
0.0222063512,
-0.4366042316,
-0.0909392312,
0.4233336449,
0.7730090618,
-0.304190129,
-0.1211474985,
-0.5871738195,
0.5423240066,
-0.051910378,
0.1356495768,
-0.1087558419,
0.2811336815,
-0.2054429799,
0.6239407659,
-0.3689889908,
-0.5632035732,
0.382476747,
0.3696685433,
0.3947615921,
0.3536695242,
0.3862096369,
0.7611527443,
-0.3012765646,
0.696202457,
0.1392652839,
-0.6305274963,
0.7567529082,
-0.4805663526,
0.3029599786,
0.603600502,
0.8951908946,
-0.2131776363,
0.0603662245,
-0.3965105712,
-0.986215651,
0.225181222,
0.01956084,
-0.0869657248,
0.2342322469,
0.4788841009,
0.3955208659,
0.2555045784,
-0.3227184713,
-0.0516827293,
0.0781365931,
-0.5178612471,
-0.222906068,
0.2696615458,
-0.2491268665,
-0.1515715122,
0.7909945846,
-0.3711382151,
0.1246737167,
0.2316045612,
0.1557477713,
0.0923765302,
0.004931049,
0.200640589,
0.5578969717,
0.0198076237,
-0.1044550464,
-0.0883877575,
-0.5786299706,
0.0594275445,
0.5442060828,
-0.7937323451,
-0.283418566,
0.2308716774,
0.4616282284,
-0.46655339,
-0.6552009583,
-0.1552685499,
-0.0075692292,
-0.2922946513,
-0.115314357,
-0.0533515811,
0.0866283253,
0.5666773319,
0.4773330092,
0.2780069709,
0.0116027528,
-0.5896384716,
0.259241581,
0.4087006152,
-0.2552945912,
0.2065752,
0.8157002926,
0.2682537735,
-0.5666903257,
0.7750902176,
-0.1050223634,
-0.6718529463,
0.9111399651,
0.2914327979,
0.3206428885,
-0.1249860078,
0.3447029889,
0.3554176688,
0.3024641573,
-0.018913012,
0.4004689455,
-0.3768715858,
-0.4906891286,
-0.0735044479,
-0.9349567294,
-0.2849259973,
-0.0877849832,
-0.6712525487,
-0.0054814895,
-0.3067118824,
-0.3537868559,
0.0833744034,
0.5932965875,
-1.0581452847,
0.2745346427,
0.0953766778,
0.4836297929,
-0.9691930413,
0.5252954364,
0.7015631199,
-0.4339674711,
-0.6145124435,
-0.0914935097,
0.0798078924,
-0.753702879,
0.4210462272,
0.4171090126,
-0.2053676397,
0.0880116299,
-0.4791285098,
-0.8038538694,
1.0687713623,
0.1828780174,
-0.7239543796,
0.0438103713,
0.5922914743,
0.4747796655,
-0.4602505267,
-0.1977510452,
0.4725559056,
0.9400527477,
-0.155064106,
-0.7271621227,
-0.0035542613,
-0.068100214,
-0.0719728768,
0.6029154062,
-0.8323853612,
0.4710385501,
-0.4525033236,
-0.2370099872,
0.0512028262,
0.6875061393,
0.1012715474,
0.6210299134,
0.2874745429,
0.8789550066,
1.0322831869,
-0.3103181422,
0.7889391184,
-0.1771892905,
0.6672573686,
0.765491724,
-0.4294178784,
0.6233556867,
0.4565090835,
-0.2129505277,
0.0194157735,
0.772582531,
-0.6196819544,
0.6723915339,
0.4791980088,
-0.1983394921,
0.021166807,
-0.660966754,
-0.4960983992,
0.3379876912,
0.4824110866,
-0.3987888694,
-0.1993322819,
0.3885019124,
-0.2727454603,
0.4817601144,
-0.6975983381,
0.6701753736,
0.0727559701,
-0.3642648458,
0.0906725973,
-0.0261921342,
0.6943434477,
-0.4489075541,
-0.3843074441,
0.2207357287,
0.4304592609,
-0.1118946224,
-0.9230663776,
0.4788527191,
-0.1330684274,
-0.2125626504,
-0.5763249993,
0.7089312077,
-0.4740763605,
-0.5350878835,
0.3703243732,
0.2196759433,
0.1307051629,
0.2544804513,
-0.8719519973,
0.1743753105,
0.1114942953,
0.0952612683,
0.2127864361,
0.2057089657,
-0.2003056407,
0.7598454952,
0.7868196368,
0.3250614703,
-0.0616013706,
-0.1675486416,
0.7062419057,
-0.5778442621,
-0.5956036448,
-0.7901534438,
0.0347485542,
-0.18553482,
-0.5437964797,
0.8380300403,
0.6567249894,
1.1930001974,
0.1556815952,
1.1207573414,
-0.2194681466,
0.1842491925,
-0.1589671969,
0.7567456961,
-0.3186122477,
-0.007852992,
-0.1946803927,
-1.037011385,
-0.2925359607,
0.5615553856,
-0.3843125701,
0.0172594283,
-0.0740226954,
0.3841490746,
0.0597622693,
0.1790699959,
-0.0621410087,
-0.2312474698,
0.4198173285,
0.425209105,
0.4119110107,
-0.2359017879,
0.2365136296,
0.0901135579,
-0.3165286481,
0.2553350627,
-0.6974251866,
-0.8018980026,
-0.8211944103,
-0.5729653835,
-0.0210887082,
0.4378840029,
0.6789922714,
0.6577288508,
-0.8220464587,
0.109947592,
0.0234342162,
0.1368379742,
-0.427158922,
-0.1680353433,
0.7549496889,
0.3686399162,
-0.603612721,
-0.0030560582,
0.1743894368,
-0.0557596758,
-0.2725672722,
-0.1245911345,
-0.6342787147,
-0.1740632206,
0.1849123091,
0.4944992363,
-0.5199548602,
-0.4285501242,
-0.3739332557,
0.2697101533,
-0.0308950339,
0.756315887,
-1.1923484802,
0.2063523978,
0.3671852648,
1.2259653807,
0.5599246025,
0.1217532083,
0.2523256838,
-0.315323472,
-0.0583944805,
0.5294411182,
0.1329901367,
0.5824307799,
-0.4401453137,
0.90922755,
-0.0411660038,
-0.8244685531,
-0.6132270694,
0.2149330527,
-0.8653324246,
-0.2580173612,
0.8441571593,
-0.3560014963,
-0.1035198271,
-0.1412518471,
-0.3005470037,
0.401614815,
-0.4198561311,
1.0368789434,
0.4859455228,
-0.4136036932,
-0.0102117974,
-0.3116984069,
0.2556054592,
0.0519414805,
-0.8111944795,
-0.1600231826,
0.2102750987,
-0.093753472,
0.5219948292,
0.2668936551,
0.3483676612,
-0.2397218198,
0.0907946527,
-0.1143075898,
-0.0219175108,
-0.3954169154,
0.096175082,
0.3073174655,
-0.2885877788,
-0.1256748438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05286v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05286v2
|
Causal Inference from Text: Unveiling Interactions between Variables
| 2023-11-09T11:29:44 | 2023-11-23T12:12:22 |
Yuxiang Zhou, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adjusting for latent covariates is crucial for estimating causal effects from
observational textual data. Most existing methods only account for confounding
covariates that affect both treatment and outcome, potentially leading to
biased causal effects. This bias arises from insufficient consideration of
non-confounding covariates, which are relevant only to either the treatment or
the outcome. In this work, we aim to mitigate the bias by unveiling
interactions between different variables to disentangle the non-confounding
covariates when estimating causal effects from text. The disentangling process
ensures covariates only contribute to their respective objectives, enabling
independence between variables. Additionally, we impose a constraint to balance
representations from the treatment group and control group to alleviate
selection bias. We conduct experiments on two different treatment factors under
various scenarios, and the proposed model significantly outperforms recent
strong baselines. Furthermore, our thorough analysis on earnings call
transcripts demonstrates that our model can effectively disentangle the
variables, and further investigations into real-world scenarios provide
guidance for investors to make informed decisions.
|
[
0.1979267895,
-1.2109287977,
0.5873827338,
0.316983819,
-0.3578163385,
0.0925482437,
0.0419147871,
-0.5101428628,
0.1977172941,
0.4810210168,
-0.7119665742,
-0.0831261724,
-0.933744669,
0.1143791303,
-0.2021259367,
1.2494320869,
0.0290536042,
0.2079207003,
-0.2564306855,
0.1693173796,
-0.7110788822,
-0.211245954,
-0.5382090807,
-0.7667275071,
0.6993058324,
0.1151179373,
0.6060779095,
0.2882373333,
0.5610302687,
0.2336590141,
-0.2507587671,
0.1156022474,
-0.8007636666,
0.065413937,
-0.4485021532,
-0.4584730864,
-0.2358039916,
0.3372302353,
0.2084416449,
1.0835024118,
0.0723411739,
0.0095087616,
0.2469091564,
0.5559117198,
-0.8701757193,
0.0203036275,
-0.3508065641,
0.0842365026,
0.0175281372,
-0.3699335158,
-0.7279635072,
-0.2075625956,
0.3942173421,
-0.6406090856,
0.3275294006,
0.106863454,
0.8037621975,
0.3978470564,
-0.8391078115,
-0.1667173058,
-0.9610968232,
0.9229313731,
-0.6346872449,
0.10488832,
0.5628962517,
-0.0708375648,
-0.3896327913,
-0.6465725303,
-0.2392487079,
0.155168578,
-0.4934699237,
0.2455717176,
-0.4545859396,
0.0792709142,
0.3089096546,
0.2574134171,
-0.1580079645,
0.1157237962,
-0.4783722758,
-0.2165793628,
0.619402647,
0.0205563698,
0.2621459663,
-0.1558283418,
-0.6302304268,
-0.0026513343,
-0.6718089581,
0.0999916717,
0.5140357018,
0.4103457928,
-0.1605564952,
0.7810531855,
0.3726522624,
0.4013403058,
0.3307054043,
-0.114249222,
-0.0570219941,
-0.379588902,
-0.5345257521,
0.3095395565,
0.650146246,
0.4215776026,
-0.4476387501,
-0.3107129633,
0.1585713625,
0.0108360574,
0.012110129,
-0.6643979549,
-0.1707197875,
0.4128646553,
-0.8051432371,
-0.1932594776,
0.0209826045,
-1.0842074156,
-0.3419360816,
-0.4725654125,
0.752497077,
-0.015085171,
-0.3411143124,
0.1595378369,
-0.7175166607,
0.0587877333,
0.2246874571,
-0.9562444687,
0.41860044,
0.4088161886,
0.6536951661,
0.0080680577,
0.0400939658,
-0.9375221133,
0.4117390811,
-0.1186074987,
0.6368715763,
-0.6612629294,
-0.6100708842,
-0.1425343007,
-0.1225345731,
-0.3087474108,
-0.1477007568,
0.3115598857,
-0.5192251205,
0.5575928092,
-0.3596079648,
-0.824544549,
0.0041514332,
-0.2132634223,
-0.9309248924,
0.5986880064,
0.0875101313,
-1.1475930214,
0.6539498568,
-0.5593032241,
-0.3249692023,
-0.3860252202,
-0.3448680937,
-0.5945064425,
0.2019168735,
0.2106472105,
0.1061399803,
-0.4691735506,
0.7291217446,
-0.3499954343,
-0.2654630542,
0.2599366009,
-0.5844082236,
0.9270616174,
0.0253915507,
-0.4227291644,
0.0287584607,
-0.611528635,
-0.4217689335,
-0.0953922793,
0.0584247559,
-0.8890486956,
0.1328342706,
-0.0341035649,
-0.0258097425,
0.0852179006,
-0.4086545408,
0.0989578813,
-0.2505713105,
0.084592998,
0.646284461,
0.5468205214,
0.5243657231,
0.0899056792,
0.3878571093,
0.3174651861,
0.0829469487,
0.3005864024,
-0.0829428211,
-0.2345147431,
-0.5046380162,
0.4003643692,
0.2128735781,
-0.8013550043,
0.0602936856,
0.3203425109,
-0.0812328681,
-0.3125026226,
0.0184126068,
0.7105133533,
0.5874664187,
0.3355693221,
-0.0297682453,
-0.5740901232,
-0.9574585557,
-0.5355032682,
-0.1365721971,
-0.1519693732,
-0.0876094177,
0.423063606,
-0.001792791,
1.089681983,
-0.9665526152,
-0.0570015609,
-0.0554540753,
0.9422199726,
0.2201795876,
0.5119392276,
0.53091681,
-0.9374018908,
-0.1535598338,
-0.3144625723,
-0.7846421599,
-0.1212356165,
-0.5590031743,
-0.4048322439,
-0.2082094401,
0.8724449873,
-0.1903586388,
0.9116716981,
0.3014976382,
-0.7774363756,
0.3266659677,
-0.559837997,
0.0731756091,
-0.7435965538,
0.1502062678,
0.2693917453,
-0.0380881429,
-0.6633077264,
-0.6646615267,
-0.1679531932,
0.2359357327,
-0.2672735751,
0.3293943107,
-0.6512768865,
0.1955736428,
-0.2687810063,
0.098213613,
0.4390277565,
0.5351771116,
0.1389878839,
0.4021218717,
0.1838367879,
-0.6538527012,
-0.2620351017,
0.5207309127,
0.0930029675,
0.317984283,
-0.7859655023,
-0.2072548717,
-0.4034817219,
0.1676681042,
-0.957351625,
-0.1315566301,
0.4069851339,
-0.2976588607,
0.2177230418,
0.0948563516,
-0.1328419596,
0.0430182703,
-0.4335829914,
0.4038141966,
0.0101024993,
-0.5717022419,
0.5310115218,
0.3478782177,
-0.1219097972,
-0.5621829629,
-0.6346803308,
-0.0763792321,
-0.4683162868,
-0.0698188171,
0.5788818002,
-0.0303232167,
-0.6573956609,
0.0746199712,
-0.1756177098,
-0.260905087,
0.0075489269,
0.2475219369,
0.4511811137,
0.1744190603,
0.439552933,
0.6544456482,
-0.3233113885,
0.2288056314,
0.2591682076,
-0.0703018531,
0.6234543324,
-0.2166231275,
-0.4111919701,
0.7812300324,
0.2806864083,
-0.2483779043,
1.0670143366,
0.4461258352,
-0.2724545896,
0.0456220619,
-0.1067034006,
-0.2701920271,
-0.3838362694,
0.2198550552,
-0.0265338495,
-0.7422744036,
0.4950537086,
-0.2392284721,
-0.0770019963,
0.5308613181,
0.4687056541,
0.1148324013,
1.111109972,
1.0281978846,
0.1111702323,
0.6013350487,
0.0036103583,
0.6269116402,
-0.8693844676,
-0.5324283838,
-0.4623914361,
-0.1809122264,
-0.8072487116,
-0.2135760188,
0.3410867453,
0.4375421405,
-0.1207382977,
0.034609288,
-0.3026100695,
0.332983762,
0.5012497902,
0.4276682734,
0.4625558555,
-0.2243776023,
-0.0184238385,
-0.2225284129,
-0.3970769644,
-0.4070405066,
0.9460283518,
0.3118903637,
0.9419435263,
0.2714417279,
0.4582726061,
0.2649164498,
0.2995755374,
-0.2051252872,
-0.0323046036,
-0.1787064224,
-0.806979835,
-0.3031491637,
-0.5672430396,
-1.1176868677,
0.3108227253,
-0.3568358123,
-1.1193645,
0.7880808115,
-0.0153769283,
-0.4283064008,
0.0112249898,
-1.0465825796,
0.6576793194,
-0.0614047535,
-0.8827169538,
-0.0451983996,
-0.7758359313,
0.5087447166,
-0.1000884473,
0.1249404103,
-0.0780557394,
0.1725008637,
0.8879723549,
-0.6544027925,
1.2197732925,
-0.2152762711,
-0.2402492464,
0.3291220069,
-0.2368802875,
0.3542224169,
0.2631607354,
-0.0255574975,
0.0471919961,
0.1079952195,
-0.4052703679,
-0.57765764,
0.3656012714,
-0.6912381053,
-0.4941126704,
-0.4556078017,
-0.6782241464,
-0.1983368695,
0.1518164724,
0.2289559692,
0.3881850243,
-0.3731648028,
-0.0233222283,
0.5039895773,
-0.2929233015,
0.6353981495,
0.5955365896,
-0.1650937498,
-0.2407643795,
0.4060960412,
-0.0958811268,
0.2529275417,
0.5911150575,
0.4841863811,
-0.5724569559,
-0.205980286,
0.1708005369,
0.3065146804,
-0.2865459621,
-0.1632479131,
-0.4872018695,
0.1493112445,
-0.3624051511,
0.0834476501,
-0.1890694946,
-0.0728233457,
-0.7054049373,
-0.3102165759,
0.4648906589,
0.6488813758,
-0.3308550119,
0.3858937621,
-0.7437521815,
0.4487251937,
0.3549970388,
0.2373529226,
0.1303582639,
-0.2381885052,
-0.3298594356,
0.2306588292,
-0.3610772789,
-1.0197175741,
0.4119898677,
-0.1169982105,
0.4728547931,
0.5159948468,
0.432159692,
0.8950945139,
-0.2779217064,
0.5532965064,
0.6379226446,
-1.0629732609,
0.565934062,
-0.4508033991,
0.1518345624,
0.5194276571,
0.3768731356,
-0.3140454888,
-0.4192805588,
-0.5997981429,
-1.0497473478,
0.7403402328,
0.5918926597,
-0.2479151338,
-0.0610603429,
0.5101872683,
0.3817463219,
0.4078117311,
-0.7439074516,
-0.210876897,
0.1494223177,
-0.107391566,
0.0543758087,
-0.5003795624,
-0.3900557756,
-0.1528691053,
0.5132645369,
0.1962830722,
0.2720625103,
0.4887384474,
-0.0884144604,
-0.4480016232,
-0.0359050743,
0.6266083717,
0.6920241117,
-0.4938854277,
0.2106306106,
-0.2165147066,
-0.5276988745,
0.0168671384,
0.2316794991,
0.0994057208,
0.1004312932,
0.8101263046,
0.8371083736,
0.3652974963,
-0.44058007,
0.5128240585,
-0.3766331673,
-0.2736389935,
0.0747789443,
-0.0735096857,
-0.0986373425,
0.6629558206,
0.352940172,
-0.036979761,
0.2147740424,
-0.3650003076,
0.2447284907,
0.1895570457,
-0.5613506436,
-0.2250148654,
0.8637050986,
0.26370278,
-0.102562651,
0.4091686308,
0.1352526993,
-0.0855667517,
0.7453539968,
0.569958508,
0.664847672,
-0.0431696028,
0.4035470486,
0.360176295,
0.1426805705,
-0.0208188239,
-0.0528010614,
0.3886797428,
-0.4839393198,
-0.6046557426,
-0.2621419728,
-0.4328296185,
0.2236996591,
-1.2194701433,
0.120910123,
0.0330157429,
-0.1803096831,
0.3410892487,
0.1123326048,
-0.3752408624,
0.2639823556,
-0.2953093648,
0.5217040777,
-1.4591901302,
0.3521938324,
0.3891761601,
-0.7734796405,
-0.6437442899,
0.1778421849,
0.0893437862,
-0.294267416,
0.5880576372,
-0.1922672093,
-0.1241537929,
-0.3747231066,
-0.6847538948,
-0.6020237803,
1.049885869,
0.6668567657,
-0.5851979256,
0.2177651078,
0.0812267736,
0.3983117342,
-0.1857031137,
0.4362456203,
0.6364531517,
0.4009733498,
0.1644923687,
-0.5483398438,
0.0496214926,
-0.1558627486,
-0.1124055088,
0.2457939088,
-0.6028550863,
0.8396626115,
-0.1774801314,
0.0561508201,
-0.2259014845,
0.7382087111,
0.2368735522,
0.6809296012,
0.4456732273,
0.0163558852,
0.9262986779,
0.1555431038,
0.7621482611,
0.0376103669,
0.403978467,
1.3879011869,
-0.1687876433,
0.4378249645,
1.0881985426,
-0.1857552677,
0.3429947495,
0.7405590415,
0.2421572059,
0.9254771471,
0.0630147755,
-0.3954167664,
-0.1597605199,
-0.3653583825,
-0.2298299223,
0.4798127413,
0.1698371917,
-0.5299546719,
-0.327464968,
-0.0520214848,
0.3008411825,
0.2244569659,
-0.0950485542,
0.6258989573,
0.1299960315,
-0.5710184574,
-0.203171432,
-0.0475237891,
0.2906799018,
-0.6169232726,
-0.3648341894,
-0.2311677933,
0.267383486,
-0.1538959146,
-0.1592157781,
0.4145456851,
0.1060327739,
-0.5148583055,
-0.338393122,
0.7812204361,
-0.8380194902,
-0.5221366882,
0.4887341261,
0.5319072604,
-0.2039924413,
0.1463682353,
-0.3073265553,
0.0380876549,
0.1727309227,
-0.2566564977,
0.2400205582,
0.6477873325,
-0.0332247354,
0.0595495924,
0.594846189,
-0.1203656271,
-0.4898200631,
0.1106781363,
0.949282825,
-0.7171646953,
-0.4475043118,
-1.0614528656,
0.7740063667,
-0.2215681672,
-0.3739545047,
0.6979391575,
0.4496131539,
0.1387702674,
-0.0663584173,
0.4618111551,
0.1539773196,
0.3676849604,
-0.6829929948,
0.7338986993,
-0.5710910559,
0.3568399549,
-0.5341086388,
-0.3653345108,
-0.4230460227,
0.4784491956,
-0.6145543456,
0.0054613561,
0.9586724639,
0.3355233669,
0.189908132,
0.2699743807,
0.1414724141,
0.3592427671,
0.5127596855,
0.2747611701,
0.4189812541,
-0.524135828,
0.2883551121,
0.0405911654,
-0.5150933266,
-0.1994702965,
-1.2867001295,
-0.9303439856,
-0.4020880759,
-0.6357805133,
-0.1341918856,
-0.0499806702,
0.5685886741,
0.1703730673,
-0.4710134268,
-0.0537252203,
-0.1828466207,
0.5236457586,
-0.4367600381,
-0.1885109395,
0.742507875,
-0.1167592928,
-0.7240000963,
0.019614609,
0.310639739,
-0.0106132999,
0.0469241589,
0.1864198297,
-0.6404979229,
0.1844400316,
0.5216351151,
-0.0513099991,
-0.0943884999,
-0.3135005534,
-0.2533994019,
0.0636379719,
-0.1732370853,
0.9797845483,
-0.5014815927,
0.5514737368,
0.3302244842,
0.2409615219,
0.4841995537,
0.0054564415,
1.0079231262,
-0.9080662131,
0.4294221997,
-0.0446858332,
0.2011343837,
-0.0044595306,
-0.7743634582,
0.274202317,
0.0168073326,
-0.3365364373,
-0.7397173047,
-0.0336306691,
-0.6816530228,
-0.6298885345,
0.7966780663,
-0.0541861579,
-0.395971477,
-0.2239924371,
-0.1436720937,
0.8068588972,
-0.323132664,
1.0225909948,
0.6953305006,
-0.5225811005,
0.0037447016,
-0.3686605096,
0.4410744011,
0.3925193548,
-0.8393505812,
0.1095316783,
0.5045685172,
-0.125130415,
-0.1529361755,
0.5358536243,
-0.1971850544,
0.056502115,
0.2764495015,
-0.0999025628,
0.1808800697,
-0.0557592623,
-0.1872754544,
-0.0983442441,
-0.3046871126,
-0.4324988723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05268v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05268v2
|
Modelling prospective memory and resilient situated communications via Wizard of Oz
| 2023-11-09T10:50:36 | 2024-01-17T10:09:46 |
Yanzhe Li, Frank Broz, Mark Neerincx
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This abstract presents a scenario for human-robot action in a home setting
involving an older adult and a robot. The scenario is designed to explore the
envisioned modelling of memory for communication with a socially assistive
robots (SAR). The scenario will enable the gathering of data on failures of
speech technology and human-robot communication involving shared memory that
may occur during daily activities such as a music-listening activity.
|
[
-0.4132941663,
-0.7651805878,
0.3928910196,
-0.0368422866,
0.3147778213,
-0.0265898239,
0.1074938774,
-0.6633235216,
0.4292328656,
0.6985836029,
-0.8632254601,
0.0526614226,
-0.2172445059,
0.0715809166,
-0.3967469931,
0.437589258,
-0.0604481585,
-0.2493798286,
-0.1634611636,
-0.3162918091,
-0.7990236282,
-0.779393971,
-0.8482246399,
-0.5695348382,
0.3018340766,
0.4739387929,
0.8577423692,
0.0074478076,
0.489102006,
0.4548233449,
0.0101951323,
-0.0966681764,
-0.5141964555,
0.3882687092,
-0.5672070384,
-0.7839241028,
-0.6945297122,
0.1612798423,
0.5408440232,
0.7621628642,
-0.357688576,
-0.0292488169,
-0.134694472,
0.8359250426,
-0.5323103666,
-0.0395056605,
-0.5064510107,
0.3740146458,
0.3146043718,
-0.3361116648,
-0.2828979194,
-0.0217558742,
0.108061105,
-0.3655498028,
0.2706656456,
0.398848623,
0.8957325816,
0.2414436787,
-0.1106219292,
-0.6204797029,
-1.2204197645,
0.724609375,
-0.2760755718,
0.0368583761,
0.9901416302,
0.6587017775,
-0.6733120084,
-0.5791988373,
-0.8231771588,
-0.6042621732,
0.0922879279,
0.2512383759,
-0.2497548312,
0.1525911838,
0.012874526,
0.2770548165,
-0.2217695117,
-0.2973808944,
-0.8270371556,
-0.134793207,
0.6697375178,
0.5312116146,
0.5713291168,
-0.3464241028,
-0.5844433904,
-0.0774531662,
-0.0728111342,
-0.0944188163,
0.2393608838,
0.2839293182,
-0.2510174513,
0.8236370087,
-0.2410911173,
0.7414172292,
0.2367111593,
-0.4066514671,
0.206725359,
-0.2623583376,
0.2086130381,
0.4429258406,
0.4023102224,
0.604562819,
0.468444109,
-0.2908984721,
-0.2551536262,
0.1817362159,
0.8768422604,
-0.0977207944,
-0.1916711777,
0.3697206974,
-0.8873623013,
0.2542805374,
0.0390036851,
-0.5555999875,
-0.5495344996,
-0.3247518241,
0.9437924027,
-0.7868380547,
-0.479031086,
0.1983573437,
-0.4757793248,
-0.0595640354,
0.1842717528,
-0.9104058146,
0.356443733,
0.3184561133,
0.8240151405,
0.1191223338,
-0.6370611191,
-0.1780297756,
0.6101728678,
-0.2636400461,
0.8712796569,
-0.4204708338,
-0.5633949637,
-0.0521861501,
0.2435806543,
-0.1191565618,
-0.571426928,
0.3932103217,
-0.5631478429,
0.3052786589,
0.2405932546,
-0.2369547635,
-0.3415544033,
0.3005215228,
-0.9903085828,
0.4696635306,
0.6303001046,
-0.5836363435,
0.2439310104,
-0.597416997,
-0.5118408799,
-0.1864357144,
-0.1541438252,
-0.1443614066,
-0.1497985572,
-0.5140476823,
0.3292023838,
-0.0921713114,
-0.1540178061,
-0.3629564345,
-0.7134024501,
0.2836146355,
-0.5466577411,
0.463446945,
0.4667225778,
0.0099091232,
-0.0086065,
-0.9819139838,
-0.3168590367,
0.1120887026,
-0.2554768026,
-0.3765362203,
0.154170081,
-0.3334424496,
0.4270165861,
0.5834368467,
-0.4330966473,
-0.2232540101,
-0.1621493101,
0.0878620744,
0.6015274525,
0.0193292983,
0.6987397671,
-0.7575133443,
0.730758667,
-0.2792574465,
0.2596432567,
-0.1173394322,
-0.3291278183,
-0.3708125055,
-0.0099700093,
-0.2376138419,
1.0659166574,
-0.59749192,
0.3874465227,
-0.0949911773,
-0.3279610574,
-0.1468509138,
-0.099404715,
0.2358022183,
0.3761542737,
-0.0073937778,
-0.4520071447,
-0.7266874909,
-0.9486281276,
0.2569489181,
-0.5833492279,
-0.3371903896,
0.4969582558,
0.0418082289,
-0.4494664669,
1.0350422859,
-0.2160168141,
-0.5775282979,
-0.4474624097,
0.1671446413,
0.0967705473,
0.3622408807,
0.3952622414,
-1.0348325968,
-0.0314699188,
-0.1134494618,
-0.9253468513,
0.2428793162,
-0.199070558,
-0.0057706493,
0.2111310512,
0.3757060468,
-0.8337614536,
0.6721819043,
0.5034099817,
-0.3502436876,
0.5194908381,
-0.580085218,
0.752143085,
-1.3465667963,
-0.2710999548,
-0.297149539,
0.2510996759,
-0.5930171609,
-0.6876983047,
-0.5268287659,
-0.3230811357,
-0.4916196167,
0.4555350244,
-0.6198035479,
-0.2526236475,
-0.632386744,
0.3623692989,
-0.3589884043,
0.0522370599,
0.3444475234,
0.7687458396,
0.4894882739,
-0.7483965755,
0.3157341182,
0.3224539459,
0.0042383517,
0.8885615468,
-0.6477375627,
-0.0038905058,
-0.0755598471,
0.2352734059,
-0.9983291626,
-0.6066092849,
0.4978449345,
-0.964492023,
0.1397319585,
0.1884640455,
-0.4723276198,
-0.4034496844,
-0.0517347753,
0.1389672756,
0.4998697042,
-0.0960684419,
1.1907272339,
0.6571615338,
-0.2205793858,
-0.2252313346,
-0.5169602633,
0.1305538863,
-0.6533381939,
-0.8657634258,
0.3704327047,
0.1372476071,
-0.5752318501,
0.0668525472,
-0.0225740243,
-0.2385833114,
0.0721080899,
0.6644827724,
0.3702418506,
-0.0467198379,
0.0176854301,
-0.2481967211,
-0.1365434676,
0.1031452194,
0.6917955875,
0.9191744924,
-0.1335098743,
-0.3169547915,
-0.6416900158,
0.8611949086,
0.6329599023,
0.4209304154,
1.0563983917,
0.4282826483,
-0.6935190558,
0.0586166121,
-0.3466484547,
-0.4125824273,
-0.6026661396,
0.2531145513,
-0.438462019,
-0.6167743802,
0.7403439879,
-0.418954283,
-0.2523674965,
-0.0304410979,
0.3566699326,
-0.3620720804,
0.773424089,
0.8201117516,
-0.0263639633,
0.8109377027,
0.1983918399,
0.3369840682,
-0.7670928836,
-0.2278587073,
-0.3891656399,
-0.2647302449,
-0.4130065441,
-0.457144022,
0.2614482045,
0.5375997424,
-0.4460693896,
0.7551221848,
-0.3763209283,
0.085315913,
0.6260134578,
0.0608258583,
-0.1514212638,
0.137035951,
0.2764137089,
0.3492743969,
-0.6727535129,
-1.0793732405,
0.6927216649,
0.1486179829,
1.0922398567,
0.0002197052,
0.7900953293,
0.7749808431,
-0.179251954,
-0.2154286057,
0.8664488792,
0.1907729656,
-0.8335435987,
-0.5472709537,
-0.0619249344,
-1.5201416016,
-0.2430025786,
-0.1156471148,
-1.4787287712,
0.0555288605,
0.0751479939,
-0.5635609031,
0.1711095572,
-0.9844966531,
0.3815715313,
0.0826773718,
-0.1432501525,
-0.7434982657,
-0.9945645928,
0.1318707019,
0.2779239118,
0.1347304136,
-0.17307432,
0.0569304526,
0.7605633736,
0.1160517335,
1.1429802179,
0.2173509151,
0.0566415787,
0.8123102188,
0.22943376,
0.2890110016,
-0.1905449182,
-0.2091043144,
0.0768504515,
0.0834396183,
-0.2917927802,
-0.516027391,
0.507396102,
-0.830485642,
-0.6047174931,
-0.6317844391,
-0.8237765431,
-0.2879736722,
-0.135774985,
-0.0690372065,
0.2094964832,
-0.0982429609,
0.0044435947,
0.4426899254,
-0.5267513394,
0.4215762615,
0.8798344731,
0.0126948813,
-0.4343590438,
0.9432227015,
0.0154415844,
0.4912703931,
0.136008516,
-0.1321364194,
0.016061753,
0.0641732886,
0.023553757,
0.1715697795,
-0.9043946862,
0.0796133503,
-0.5981372595,
-0.5394551158,
-0.1711855382,
-0.5916499496,
-0.4447060823,
-0.4919238985,
-0.3117171228,
-0.0072213076,
0.5331273079,
0.784196198,
-0.6491459012,
0.1877127439,
-1.0162857771,
0.6916188598,
0.2001833916,
0.0406583585,
0.1659151614,
-0.2755951583,
-0.2398228645,
-0.0636025295,
-0.3874524534,
-0.7143538594,
0.2179336399,
-0.0062520183,
0.965089798,
0.1868380159,
0.3541707993,
0.5388508439,
-0.6983807087,
1.1489557028,
0.4725168943,
-0.37277022,
0.913164854,
-0.3587290347,
-0.054533571,
0.4651369154,
0.3666217327,
-0.5839287639,
-0.2129774094,
-0.7208371162,
-1.0399415493,
0.7735114098,
-0.0224004369,
0.308732599,
-0.3553187549,
0.2811641395,
0.1727902442,
0.0322750062,
-0.2618204057,
-0.2797944844,
0.2592932582,
0.0129628526,
-0.1448722631,
-0.2889890373,
-0.2656898201,
0.0267039146,
0.0690576807,
0.3805608749,
0.9416829944,
0.1149197742,
0.4346655309,
-0.2685235441,
0.1426620632,
0.5760567784,
0.6759712696,
-0.4009203017,
0.1123470962,
0.2674710751,
-0.6862828135,
0.3308273554,
-0.0382009931,
0.3660085499,
-0.2353539467,
0.4540866911,
0.4826827943,
0.2190902978,
-0.9932355881,
-0.1187195778,
-0.0765248239,
0.2341704369,
-0.8530056477,
0.6831023097,
0.2569009364,
0.5703721642,
0.5903496146,
0.2806779742,
0.2241690606,
-1.1336961985,
0.7866158485,
0.2148896456,
-0.589980185,
-0.3034534454,
0.7417055964,
-0.0632208288,
-1.3086789846,
0.4002667964,
-0.0808440521,
-0.4118129313,
0.526883781,
0.8716225028,
0.9129323959,
-0.3737080991,
0.2276989669,
0.2984952629,
0.0889130458,
-0.1061324701,
0.4239848554,
-0.1734448671,
-0.8079314828,
0.2131735831,
-0.3120876253,
-0.5298179388,
-0.2817966044,
-0.8623118997,
0.0114580514,
-0.0886517838,
-0.3759980202,
-0.4492478371,
-0.0073799794,
-0.3250550926,
0.2912717164,
0.2190027386,
0.747104466,
-0.764601171,
0.8939847946,
0.7517681122,
-0.3771787882,
-0.7338106036,
0.3374281228,
-0.3052811921,
-0.7506685257,
0.7835701108,
0.1288337111,
-0.809058249,
-0.4224589169,
-0.2888633013,
-0.9054681659,
1.5707101822,
0.0567428358,
-0.3038672507,
0.1307587028,
-0.0206332952,
0.6219803691,
-0.3224811554,
0.0684476644,
0.4774428606,
0.2154782265,
0.1392638236,
-1.335498929,
-0.2068721056,
-0.2347768098,
-0.0404709578,
-0.151036486,
-1.1271666288,
0.9581182003,
-0.3294316232,
-0.2827911675,
0.3922979534,
1.1603264809,
0.8273656964,
0.7805740833,
0.7028307319,
0.1385483891,
0.8267486691,
0.3789319992,
1.2876642942,
-0.3277658522,
-0.1825245172,
1.0449675322,
-0.4949348867,
0.9210608602,
0.5047397614,
-0.3569928408,
0.4690814018,
0.5163580775,
0.6401961446,
0.7814671397,
0.2102016807,
-0.7033433914,
-0.1455044299,
-0.1225999296,
-0.4388234615,
0.465597868,
0.5994223356,
-0.1351174563,
0.041854769,
0.4325508177,
-0.3526747227,
0.3167970479,
-0.3729168475,
0.5133948326,
0.129964754,
-0.6617640853,
0.3955663443,
-0.3131401837,
0.5829893351,
-0.63079983,
-0.3806351721,
0.1583111435,
0.6743812561,
0.1705750823,
-0.9608917236,
0.3795875311,
-0.4584930241,
-0.4206881225,
0.1971275657,
1.1119006872,
-0.2341935188,
-0.2945207059,
0.6515362263,
0.082993038,
0.4407424927,
0.4544173181,
-0.7172293663,
0.4020290375,
-0.3152278364,
-0.2864998281,
0.6819024086,
0.6182032824,
-0.1512843072,
1.4191430807,
-0.0083020618,
-0.0443968922,
-0.000273432,
-0.1024682745,
0.6335387826,
-0.7578368187,
-0.4894152582,
-0.2767021656,
0.2908266485,
-0.192590788,
-0.2925579548,
1.0352611542,
0.2970784009,
0.415463537,
-0.22757034,
0.5994236469,
-0.4090311229,
0.5961925983,
-0.2901599705,
0.8597545028,
-0.4121410847,
0.0999398306,
-0.3825021088,
-0.5854175091,
0.1871507615,
1.0632380247,
-0.2119483501,
0.1368670762,
0.3475081623,
0.7740211487,
0.1542152911,
0.2540037334,
0.4783265889,
-0.2435473651,
0.0684767291,
0.6858280301,
1.1733208895,
-0.2476241738,
0.427875042,
-0.2925756276,
-0.2512637079,
-0.2411014289,
-0.5038161278,
-1.0591925383,
-1.0347417593,
-0.0484832227,
-0.589112699,
0.272944957,
0.9549817443,
0.6363664269,
-0.5272166133,
-0.2622826099,
0.0912600756,
-0.0785340145,
-0.3512783051,
-0.2826127112,
0.3103861511,
-0.1163531914,
-0.6088637114,
0.5205947161,
0.5266897678,
0.2827064395,
-0.4230013788,
-0.3529778719,
-0.0588206984,
0.2752116621,
0.7497353554,
0.665754199,
-0.6752049327,
-0.7433273196,
-0.1801657677,
0.0749988779,
-0.1474960446,
0.4642790258,
-0.9870500565,
0.3349938095,
0.1651449203,
-0.0778407305,
-0.062540099,
0.298948437,
1.0040117502,
-0.0772230849,
0.5424570441,
0.3966995478,
0.2136714309,
0.2436917871,
-0.619777441,
0.4858476818,
-0.0691891536,
-0.8925164342,
-0.8162611127,
0.0830880851,
-1.3019012213,
-0.3704169691,
1.1837947369,
-0.0854678676,
-0.41183424,
-0.5543756485,
-0.663667798,
0.1992760301,
-0.3116951883,
1.1853840351,
0.9118906856,
-0.5226864219,
-0.2343832701,
-0.8546970487,
0.1904581636,
-0.2039777488,
-0.1967231482,
-0.2270341367,
0.5802049637,
0.1751894951,
0.6808094382,
0.7322843671,
0.0493613891,
0.5003061295,
0.8606953025,
0.044752229,
0.336080879,
-0.5982678533,
0.2641228735,
0.479349941,
-0.1382416636,
-0.62828058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05265v1
|
Don't Waste a Single Annotation: Improving Single-Label Classifiers Through Soft Labels
| 2023-11-09T10:47:39 | 2023-11-09T10:47:39 |
Ben Wu, Yue Li, Yida Mu, Carolina Scarton, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we address the limitations of the common data annotation and
training methods for objective single-label classification tasks. Typically,
when annotating such tasks annotators are only asked to provide a single label
for each sample and annotator disagreement is discarded when a final hard label
is decided through majority voting. We challenge this traditional approach,
acknowledging that determining the appropriate label can be difficult due to
the ambiguity and lack of context in the data samples. Rather than discarding
the information from such ambiguous annotations, our soft label method makes
use of them for training. Our findings indicate that additional annotator
information, such as confidence, secondary label and disagreement, can be used
to effectively generate soft labels. Training classifiers with these soft
labels then leads to improved performance and calibration on the hard label
test set.
|
[
-0.583265245,
-0.2353148907,
0.0275866855,
-0.2673411667,
-0.4151806235,
-0.2333625853,
-0.3763004839,
-0.139827162,
-0.1382205486,
0.7011868358,
-0.48205024,
-0.586658597,
-0.5917392969,
0.2194335163,
0.1670962572,
1.7162060738,
-0.1300179213,
-0.0831425264,
-0.3042351007,
-0.8399573565,
-0.282984823,
-0.7126007676,
-0.4828484058,
-0.5968841314,
0.9431580305,
0.7651477456,
0.6659684777,
0.3389517963,
0.3470997512,
0.297608614,
-0.2744554579,
0.1317142546,
-0.4917657673,
0.1262693554,
0.1041437089,
-0.2678740025,
-0.3984676898,
0.1841199845,
0.4430058599,
1.0829670429,
0.2864794135,
0.47659266,
0.0818518922,
0.6962757111,
-0.8779841661,
0.1300813556,
-0.489872247,
0.3684481382,
-0.4565532804,
0.0337143205,
-0.3730217814,
-0.5486445427,
0.0468251482,
-0.845315814,
0.5207374692,
-0.4873912036,
0.5465362072,
0.6316128373,
-0.5495256186,
-0.0734363273,
-0.6737574935,
0.6591687202,
-0.1529415399,
0.3294400871,
0.3689291477,
0.1856486946,
0.3235470653,
-0.7400886416,
-0.1813229471,
-0.1082354039,
-0.1111255661,
0.1545189917,
0.6219294667,
0.2709400654,
0.3252735436,
-0.0680335015,
0.0790491924,
-0.0663525835,
-0.6187173724,
-0.3143704236,
0.8743910789,
-0.2482307851,
-0.2572928369,
0.2553636432,
-0.6154343486,
-0.198255688,
-0.4605760872,
-0.0542331822,
0.2074662894,
0.6258128881,
0.4427486956,
0.2718031406,
0.0507134348,
0.5881444216,
-0.1371051222,
-0.3222474754,
0.7905768752,
-0.0181932058,
0.0076409858,
0.4539310038,
0.6366919279,
0.0891571641,
0.2611309588,
-0.2564679682,
-0.3226714134,
0.0265851617,
0.2326117903,
-0.7333227992,
-0.2421590239,
0.0713144094,
-0.0629317611,
-0.0436838344,
0.2175918072,
-0.6307624578,
-0.4429380298,
-0.3248193562,
0.5106858611,
0.0295520332,
-0.1926774383,
0.0052723722,
-0.5785881281,
-0.3670061529,
0.4974245429,
-0.595492661,
0.3208800852,
0.6992928982,
0.4423485398,
0.2273551524,
-0.1571756601,
-0.4253774881,
0.1926375329,
-0.2459663451,
0.705473721,
-0.3282576501,
-0.4155692756,
-0.1145539135,
-0.1828951538,
0.0168688111,
-0.5156632066,
0.7325227857,
0.0787875354,
-0.1873521209,
-0.4129155278,
-0.3199178576,
-0.5121950507,
0.1652277857,
-0.9293240309,
0.7370460033,
0.0942805335,
-0.7147048116,
0.910936594,
-0.609546423,
-0.4423330426,
0.4892375171,
-0.1576382667,
-0.6941699386,
0.0959970579,
-0.0046522235,
0.4303102195,
0.2211988717,
0.2361581624,
-0.6113122106,
-0.4420986474,
0.4071001709,
-0.3688864708,
0.5649047494,
0.0910605714,
-0.2805563509,
-0.0854430273,
-0.8475759625,
0.1784322411,
-0.2268869728,
-0.6344088316,
-0.4368899763,
-0.2087593675,
0.3820422888,
-0.0952469409,
0.139753893,
-0.7571678162,
0.5122557878,
0.1317474544,
0.0605230965,
1.007122159,
-0.1858068556,
0.3700229228,
-0.2525719404,
0.133940056,
0.0076938574,
0.3036572039,
0.1178231761,
-0.354783237,
-0.9241549373,
-0.2681085765,
0.8244330287,
0.4738442004,
-0.5084223151,
0.1064974368,
-0.1374928653,
-0.5612821579,
-0.5812612176,
0.5754303336,
0.3922210932,
0.4700437188,
0.295183599,
-0.5765795708,
-0.4600831568,
-0.8724625111,
-0.0749570131,
-0.136231944,
0.1146521047,
0.2700278461,
0.560711205,
-0.1085652262,
0.9944387078,
-0.3529988229,
-0.4801837802,
0.0590069517,
0.5153316259,
-0.0517775305,
0.5506929159,
0.3310216665,
-1.0792056322,
-0.1401299238,
-0.1043203473,
-0.7532809377,
-0.0872891024,
-0.0467239395,
0.2328969389,
0.3433839977,
0.0108940965,
-0.0616133735,
0.5647242069,
-0.026548868,
0.0334035046,
0.0958371684,
-0.0444872044,
0.1217849329,
-0.1069554314,
-0.068967931,
0.2159333527,
0.0720046461,
-0.6816685796,
-0.206395179,
0.0901897997,
-0.15109393,
-0.6681544781,
0.6038024426,
-0.186894685,
0.672635138,
-0.259899199,
-0.1827731729,
0.0614299141,
0.5299922228,
0.3186812401,
0.5180383921,
0.2925262451,
-0.6863275766,
0.0309748575,
0.3411357999,
0.2145420164,
0.442763418,
-0.4041517079,
0.5896173716,
-0.6922369599,
0.4084098637,
-1.15779984,
-0.0621334985,
0.4724015892,
-0.1463900506,
0.6066544652,
-0.480120182,
-0.3065611422,
-0.5973821878,
-0.4047180414,
0.4233101606,
0.1873704642,
-0.5890074968,
0.2804885805,
0.364125967,
0.0278150458,
-0.6825929284,
-0.9203670025,
-0.3262754381,
-0.3936162889,
-0.4074942768,
-0.0308954474,
-0.1534289867,
0.2496077269,
-0.0061155399,
-0.4772515297,
-0.5709732771,
0.2038746029,
0.7142966986,
-0.0109354863,
-0.1282862723,
0.7623265982,
-0.0581753813,
-0.4963490069,
-0.1921410114,
-0.0436940156,
-0.3962652087,
-0.3264477253,
-0.1406854838,
-0.3561863601,
0.4597759545,
0.0952343568,
0.0529708564,
0.6016932726,
0.6969740391,
-0.29333359,
0.0025522427,
-0.6998650432,
-0.0038687321,
-0.4740294218,
0.0538874082,
-0.4895918369,
-0.5108302236,
0.0990163758,
-0.4236657917,
0.387298435,
0.2661572099,
-0.0991143435,
0.0753368065,
0.8813449144,
0.5424367189,
0.1748602837,
0.1954212636,
-0.2759265304,
-0.0834699273,
-0.647761941,
-0.4108035862,
-0.6920212507,
-0.503465116,
-0.352732271,
0.0592160635,
0.4717545807,
0.0762629434,
-0.459474057,
0.0617167503,
-1.1277711391,
0.3580915928,
0.713491559,
0.5946381092,
-0.0893536285,
-0.1251612753,
0.4210984707,
-0.0902812406,
-0.7782379985,
-0.7992601395,
1.1938736439,
0.2362865061,
0.7523413897,
-0.3273952305,
1.1883928776,
0.0318828411,
0.9300733805,
-0.6792832613,
0.6303551793,
-0.4442870319,
-0.8320154548,
-0.1129732206,
-0.5153096914,
-0.8494945765,
0.3283914328,
-0.1095495373,
-0.5556657314,
0.1606295854,
0.3253739178,
-0.345035404,
0.3879302144,
-1.0924577713,
1.0208201408,
-0.390460819,
-0.261264503,
0.5556313992,
-0.3821550012,
0.141766116,
-0.2113713771,
0.1799702495,
-0.3164884448,
-0.5158581734,
1.3015136719,
-0.4805117249,
1.0456660986,
-0.5493304133,
0.2735181451,
0.7925844193,
-0.4590354264,
-0.1319130361,
-0.0034444164,
-0.3916030824,
0.2702208459,
-0.1646965444,
-0.5453640819,
-0.1756643355,
0.1239175722,
-0.6177840233,
-0.404974401,
-0.6003209352,
-0.2748965025,
-0.1300906241,
-0.1506233811,
0.3167194128,
0.4924303591,
0.0843853652,
0.2829062939,
0.6258222461,
0.1808164865,
0.1497738659,
-0.0304615013,
0.4438481331,
-0.5130347013,
0.9382619858,
0.7116633058,
-0.0699485987,
0.0294566955,
0.396276027,
-0.1781404167,
-0.3649930358,
-0.3417944014,
-0.0765816122,
-0.995647788,
-0.6327280402,
-0.4679746032,
-0.0295944121,
-0.4789053202,
-0.2752469778,
-0.5232213736,
-0.6895750165,
-0.1953942329,
-0.1494846195,
0.496856004,
0.8720365167,
-0.4373360574,
0.3751263022,
-0.6114122272,
0.2259156555,
0.6053392887,
0.293274194,
-0.3960171938,
-0.1051438451,
0.0074517978,
0.0501400605,
-0.4230569899,
-1.0874012709,
-0.3036098778,
0.3029557168,
0.6053984761,
0.3021068573,
0.287070632,
0.4385959506,
-0.1508010328,
0.5092900991,
0.4401367009,
-0.8290708661,
0.6942749023,
0.1213305593,
0.3040988743,
1.3106298447,
0.6618333459,
-0.2652986646,
-0.1428232491,
-0.5469164848,
-1.3149441481,
0.6930704713,
-0.0784848183,
0.0469050296,
0.2405218333,
0.3646365702,
0.7035072446,
0.389639318,
-0.7855790257,
-0.56775105,
-0.4069308639,
-0.3447879255,
-0.0055125584,
-0.0404684804,
-0.293848604,
-0.4839635193,
0.905269146,
-0.2445088327,
-0.1138976142,
0.1633677334,
-0.029777484,
0.008866474,
0.5076569319,
0.0029139938,
0.5698285103,
-0.2521112859,
0.2673253417,
0.4650936425,
-0.3935302496,
0.2776070535,
0.2816192806,
-0.6070554256,
0.2341883034,
-0.0664038435,
0.8122676611,
0.2540201843,
-0.4249933958,
0.3746695817,
0.0597516,
-0.3308589756,
-0.1518127471,
0.1829420179,
-0.3633572161,
-0.1496411562,
0.3662833273,
0.2498934269,
0.2743891776,
-0.4085309803,
0.2370696217,
0.113377586,
-0.7716799378,
0.1700964123,
0.3692676127,
0.4457964599,
-0.4251362383,
0.5076913834,
-0.328063935,
-0.8026092649,
0.6705699563,
0.2028692514,
0.6009865999,
-0.0995765328,
0.4530209899,
0.5008904934,
0.1201717108,
-0.0775176287,
-0.2548734248,
-0.2644107938,
-0.2188927233,
-0.1647608876,
-0.1417134255,
-0.8263622522,
0.1432998925,
-0.7196618319,
0.1102142408,
-0.524291873,
-0.4493120611,
0.3039676547,
0.2010221034,
-1.0665364265,
0.4446809888,
0.5775257945,
0.60662359,
-0.8823136687,
0.3132664859,
1.0234347582,
-0.4109748602,
-0.6815658212,
-0.6246500015,
0.1000858322,
-0.1339363307,
0.5897328854,
0.8346025348,
0.2168391496,
-0.7057317495,
-0.8839324117,
-0.2830953002,
0.5938823223,
0.0554577336,
-0.3853634298,
0.4342159331,
0.1529295892,
0.1784696728,
0.0160579346,
0.323800683,
0.425801456,
0.8723562956,
0.1847598553,
-0.6559310555,
0.0629264489,
-0.2252720892,
-0.307700038,
0.3107214272,
-0.6359570622,
0.6245890856,
-0.2889613211,
-0.2663494051,
-0.0489078276,
0.7415645123,
0.1534444392,
0.9351813793,
0.8859574199,
0.3044058383,
1.1114860773,
-0.4139486551,
0.7199103236,
0.4596940279,
0.4508985877,
1.257475853,
-0.2090382427,
0.5300658941,
0.3987872899,
0.0578305498,
0.039643053,
0.5554924011,
-0.081435211,
0.2720645964,
0.4563545883,
-0.5864494443,
-0.4706359506,
-0.1679538488,
-0.3980959058,
0.2922559083,
0.3837527633,
0.2789467573,
-0.2601675391,
0.3769949973,
0.0550325885,
-0.0804891586,
-0.4776076972,
0.7293330431,
0.0536767952,
-0.5925635099,
0.4557655752,
-0.3518108726,
0.9620192647,
-0.468568027,
0.0212534554,
-0.0119553776,
0.3202697933,
-0.2905713022,
-0.8080566525,
-0.0086825555,
-0.0949251801,
0.1577175707,
-0.5019408464,
0.9173462391,
-0.3864955008,
-0.5935654044,
-0.0483174101,
0.1254873425,
0.4323175251,
-0.0929537341,
-0.6281377673,
0.016548099,
-0.1689453572,
-0.4932274818,
0.0017821215,
0.4915769398,
0.366571486,
0.4898122549,
0.2844821215,
-0.2197031379,
0.0796366408,
-0.0093242247,
0.7384424806,
-0.7049849629,
-0.0341865122,
-0.2505654991,
0.5021551251,
-0.0939835981,
-0.6909644008,
0.2431022227,
0.5088219643,
0.866774261,
0.0514715202,
0.9470381737,
0.0118135484,
0.4071016908,
-0.1456184983,
0.3786604404,
-0.6192234159,
-0.1567666829,
-0.0260451697,
-0.6581302881,
-0.4519398808,
0.7546321154,
-0.2259688526,
0.4386822283,
0.4546825886,
0.2718292177,
-0.1451097429,
0.3732994795,
-0.0659927428,
-0.1394328773,
-0.0543432571,
0.9276114106,
0.5386336446,
-0.6556923985,
0.8414036036,
-0.7066969275,
-0.182031408,
-0.1136526242,
-0.6913689971,
-0.9338930249,
-0.4966389537,
-1.1316405535,
-0.4081993699,
0.1140799224,
0.682382226,
1.1110699177,
-0.6943824887,
0.1281686723,
0.4053931236,
0.3347848356,
-0.2297089249,
-0.2003765404,
0.1596788466,
-0.4274058044,
-0.5972047448,
-0.0891957134,
-0.131976217,
0.2493268698,
0.1106490865,
-0.1312061995,
0.0882140622,
-0.1815686077,
0.4110563695,
0.6408969164,
-0.2850133181,
-0.5283852816,
-0.7621934414,
-0.0101054776,
0.3290295303,
0.8322239518,
-1.0072882175,
0.3915959299,
0.3641972542,
0.5626295805,
0.6540532112,
-0.0794394389,
-0.1138705835,
-0.9662879705,
0.3893429935,
0.5152142048,
0.0117085418,
0.5861138701,
-0.2285749018,
0.9023178816,
0.1054360569,
-0.4174889028,
-0.8724534512,
-0.0214929003,
-1.2386158705,
-0.3420051336,
1.0956346989,
-0.2225314975,
-0.4939043224,
-0.3425391912,
-0.3240625858,
0.4796266258,
-0.39181903,
0.3389757872,
0.38729316,
0.0877658203,
0.0763921663,
-0.4656832516,
0.2149967551,
0.3429985344,
-0.7326543331,
-0.0610908233,
0.2679232061,
0.3300885558,
0.6329083443,
0.9138377905,
0.2719590366,
0.215935111,
0.329338789,
0.0429559872,
-0.4143678844,
-0.5539462566,
-0.1958382279,
0.5806830525,
-0.136136964,
-0.6858895421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05263v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05263v2
|
Model-Based Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding for Text Generation
| 2023-11-09T10:46:09 | 2024-06-12T01:00:09 |
Yuu Jinnai, Tetsuro Morimura, Ukyo Honda, Kaito Ariu, Kenshi Abe
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding has been shown to be a powerful alternative
to beam search decoding in a variety of text generation tasks. MBR decoding
selects a hypothesis from a pool of hypotheses that has the least expected risk
under a probability model according to a given utility function. Since it is
impractical to compute the expected risk exactly over all possible hypotheses,
two approximations are commonly used in MBR. First, it integrates over a
sampled set of hypotheses rather than over all possible hypotheses. Second, it
estimates the probability of each hypothesis using a Monte Carlo estimator.
While the first approximation is necessary to make it computationally feasible,
the second is not essential since we typically have access to the model
probability at inference time. We propose Model-Based MBR (MBMBR), a variant of
MBR that uses the model probability itself as the estimate of the probability
distribution instead of the Monte Carlo estimate. We show analytically and
empirically that the model-based estimate is more promising than the Monte
Carlo estimate in text generation tasks. Our experiments show that MBMBR
outperforms MBR in several text generation tasks, both with encoder-decoder
models and with large language models.
|
[
0.0739716217,
-0.688532114,
0.7472551465,
0.0078539597,
-0.1566860974,
-0.1554528028,
0.5042634606,
-0.2300973088,
-0.3111077547,
0.6625864506,
-0.481307596,
-0.431294471,
-0.6312485933,
-0.0558162183,
-0.1079151854,
0.9043359756,
0.246506229,
-0.131925568,
-0.1289233416,
0.6110576391,
-0.2049365342,
-0.4333167374,
-0.7919430733,
-0.1546016634,
0.5345047116,
0.2075670511,
0.7836194634,
0.4999785125,
0.8077389002,
0.1512331218,
-0.1664631665,
-0.0033417109,
-0.4229985178,
-0.1391392797,
0.0359636098,
-0.4361943603,
-0.2893883884,
-0.1914828718,
0.6078135967,
0.8203369379,
-0.2697099447,
0.0974233598,
-0.0378945544,
1.0046772957,
-1.1001530886,
0.1468584239,
-0.6535272002,
-0.0371511877,
0.0329461135,
-0.4643366933,
-1.0692788363,
-0.4924592376,
-0.0451627225,
-0.1493437886,
0.3301852643,
0.2334554493,
0.4180389941,
-0.1096882895,
-0.8993116021,
-0.1797407418,
-0.9082890749,
0.6214852929,
-0.622438848,
0.3592630625,
0.349139899,
0.4725006223,
-0.6202799678,
-0.1654194593,
-0.3869250417,
-0.1561242044,
-0.0064693941,
0.0375192612,
-0.5430396199,
0.4368863404,
0.4555074573,
0.1458339691,
-0.4424791634,
-0.2586814761,
-0.5976728201,
-0.1953454465,
0.6963201165,
0.2951687276,
0.1045738906,
-0.572599113,
-0.2328609973,
-0.3830323517,
-0.9873918295,
0.3504128158,
0.614269495,
0.2148413807,
0.1449847966,
0.7700747848,
-0.1571545303,
0.7900328636,
0.0626479462,
-0.4060935974,
-0.0057657091,
0.054637868,
-0.327470243,
0.1954934895,
0.9085719585,
0.63695544,
-0.192895472,
0.0146888187,
-0.1993741393,
-0.0307394844,
0.3026503026,
-0.9641814232,
-0.4084278643,
-0.0917978138,
-0.8744496107,
-0.5409847498,
-0.0468610711,
-0.8924759626,
-0.4325006604,
0.3680745959,
0.8468506932,
-0.6529837251,
0.0003910822,
0.2038959265,
-0.4133471549,
0.0658386722,
-0.0498641096,
-0.8161072731,
0.3159966171,
0.2721553147,
0.9064217806,
0.0913290307,
0.284588784,
-0.5683793426,
0.467192173,
-0.4686149955,
0.9096039534,
-0.3076555729,
-0.8338112235,
-0.1077414528,
-0.3227137625,
-0.0891869739,
-0.1912865788,
0.5940136313,
-0.3507025838,
-0.0488645062,
-0.0586272292,
-0.6825546622,
-0.2506582737,
-0.2478449345,
-0.8824641109,
0.8350510597,
0.0468007959,
-1.1712393761,
0.3894656003,
-0.5780069828,
-0.6700683236,
-0.3304772675,
0.0014493202,
-0.5912135243,
0.6021797657,
0.2538380027,
0.7159332633,
-0.1894825399,
0.1221379042,
-0.3781795502,
-0.3155446947,
0.4026601017,
-0.9021915793,
0.5124511719,
0.4167522192,
-0.0332442448,
-0.3123700917,
-0.9616809487,
0.0016967149,
0.1810424179,
-0.3431472778,
-0.4364983141,
0.6057786345,
0.2330421358,
0.1243518591,
-0.0923793912,
-0.7019209266,
-0.0891092792,
-0.7297665477,
0.360398978,
0.4890253544,
0.407772243,
0.5266368389,
-0.8801748753,
0.4597521126,
0.0413303301,
-0.0337686799,
-0.3221767843,
-0.7226070166,
-0.3055003881,
-0.3841000497,
0.1434632689,
0.6423771977,
-0.8944903612,
0.2708377838,
-0.3680516779,
-0.8482611179,
-0.525152266,
-0.3278751373,
0.6055016518,
0.4815175831,
0.2623249292,
0.1054641157,
-0.4594928324,
-1.0835412741,
-0.3945327401,
-0.3898480833,
-0.0028016374,
-0.1594485193,
0.2814091444,
-0.1455797255,
1.0446410179,
-0.7786819339,
0.0748179778,
-0.6266279817,
0.2530476749,
0.4116025269,
0.7124455571,
0.3379579484,
-0.7119621634,
-0.4810419679,
-0.1299269646,
-0.2037953436,
0.1318613291,
-0.4583787918,
-0.2582819462,
0.408986181,
0.1692726016,
-0.638458252,
0.7553169727,
0.6901942492,
-0.0964834243,
0.4078535438,
-0.5487760305,
0.3011190891,
-1.3486094475,
0.2422263026,
0.1101554409,
-0.2680018544,
-0.9769322276,
-0.1593237966,
0.0884294882,
-0.1636654586,
-0.3319950998,
0.4745839238,
-0.3829808831,
0.0365852788,
-0.5393927097,
-0.3138838112,
-0.0031147571,
0.067242451,
0.1871825457,
0.6619178057,
0.2214984894,
-0.7704353333,
-0.4017958939,
0.37470451,
-0.6065539718,
0.1231801808,
-0.4710011482,
0.0299083795,
-0.4354532361,
0.0962034985,
-1.0253782272,
-0.0602996275,
0.3549222946,
-0.5945830941,
0.440761596,
-0.2954972982,
-0.523311317,
-0.4830326736,
-0.2381576151,
0.1628065705,
0.8622187376,
-0.4907032251,
0.6652782559,
0.4913310111,
-0.5042381883,
-0.5044234991,
-0.839640379,
-0.0841701627,
0.0453026891,
-0.6803228855,
0.2848981321,
-0.3847576678,
0.0446239226,
-0.2535202503,
-0.2115901262,
-0.3691313267,
-0.0007400466,
0.5873655081,
0.3704541624,
0.0504481122,
-0.1322641969,
0.8225457668,
-0.3453803957,
0.0998743847,
0.0096183959,
0.0416145995,
0.3050038517,
-0.4443780184,
-0.2647095323,
0.7309352756,
0.1024105251,
0.1536078304,
0.8776739836,
0.0744747669,
-0.6129153967,
-0.0526432134,
-0.6689476371,
0.0224485062,
-0.4917018712,
0.1399826407,
-0.726254642,
-0.8209090829,
0.1764418334,
0.057767082,
-0.1100816131,
0.4223641753,
0.3986699581,
-0.4402422309,
1.5004864931,
1.053309083,
0.052413065,
0.2445788383,
0.0990957171,
0.4875291586,
-0.3608015776,
-0.2520231307,
-0.4744243324,
-0.0007401963,
-0.6257449389,
-0.3828611374,
0.4881030023,
-0.088360332,
-0.0506215617,
0.1951726079,
-0.3648913503,
0.5734704733,
0.8291848302,
0.3317275047,
0.4401895106,
0.2377035618,
-0.072434932,
-0.1747922152,
-1.1372823715,
-0.6282594204,
1.1970268488,
0.2645801306,
0.8331407905,
0.0760386586,
0.8891116977,
0.2477020919,
0.4107112885,
-0.5931621194,
0.3308070004,
-0.0709320977,
-0.9406872988,
-0.0484952331,
-0.9103831649,
-0.8408985138,
0.3034133613,
-0.5253334641,
-0.7374491692,
0.2689386308,
0.5317795873,
-0.5186719298,
0.5549724102,
-0.465359509,
0.8740975261,
0.1582587212,
0.0232974812,
0.0099350326,
-0.6076885462,
0.6609553695,
-0.1315071732,
0.6578430533,
0.0425226241,
0.2051365227,
0.6606035233,
-0.2340844721,
0.7323435545,
-0.1958205253,
0.0062924232,
0.4515865147,
0.5222073197,
0.7934061289,
-0.1212214679,
-0.2151743919,
-0.2416746169,
0.4752238691,
-0.3248299956,
-0.2016170025,
0.1757699549,
-0.2852631509,
-0.479789108,
-0.5816163421,
-0.5430999398,
-0.0856650993,
0.2202282697,
0.7486889362,
0.2857552469,
-0.3249942362,
0.2006736547,
0.6567533612,
-0.3571516275,
0.4496107996,
0.3239193559,
-0.0950538591,
-0.5239049792,
0.8598682284,
-0.3696676791,
0.3527878523,
1.0318057537,
0.2040608376,
-0.2596836388,
-0.7331736088,
-0.2241657972,
0.039164979,
-0.6903748512,
-0.4862494767,
-0.8941547871,
-0.2644284368,
-0.1792718321,
-0.4435767829,
-0.2036775053,
-0.2450757623,
-0.0695304349,
-0.3392170668,
0.2036990374,
0.3346735537,
-0.2772736847,
0.8130874634,
-1.4196574688,
0.2700270116,
-0.0639979243,
0.112968266,
-0.3326902986,
-0.3627707362,
-0.3346399963,
0.1637894958,
-0.3269774914,
-1.2863641977,
0.7001408935,
0.2017411292,
0.4822038412,
0.4089584053,
0.2220245451,
0.3973867297,
-1.0184693336,
0.3580338359,
0.5512757897,
-1.0846748352,
0.6472167373,
-0.4162682891,
-0.0036632689,
0.6949682832,
0.4723780155,
-0.4456178844,
-0.2561120093,
-0.5573176742,
-0.3329133391,
0.5758489966,
0.4181887507,
0.1420991421,
-0.2835559845,
0.2987962365,
0.1701311469,
0.1333318949,
-0.7409170866,
0.001234052,
0.0946833044,
-0.5784432292,
-0.3047028184,
-0.6342883706,
0.2882930636,
0.10223905,
0.7047181129,
-0.1007786095,
0.694554925,
0.2282911986,
-0.2946650088,
-0.4010558426,
0.4684751332,
0.3489925265,
0.1636313647,
-0.6641289592,
0.165606752,
0.115442656,
-0.3559392393,
0.4150202274,
0.1187937111,
-0.4866293371,
0.2011611313,
0.1153121293,
0.7359014153,
0.4747068882,
-0.991374433,
0.7311041951,
0.0921510905,
-0.3683294356,
0.0090684313,
0.1289912015,
-0.0363571532,
0.2297922522,
0.3030920625,
0.2972014248,
0.5882707238,
-0.3493639827,
0.2549181283,
0.4837604165,
-0.3211530745,
-0.1489716917,
0.8529484272,
-0.1047708094,
0.0652135238,
0.1643927991,
-0.3191669285,
-0.1689713597,
0.5689765811,
0.9153658152,
0.8132792711,
-0.2327928245,
0.3240906298,
0.5400862098,
0.7970015407,
-0.3354091346,
0.5800693035,
0.434654206,
-0.5347406268,
-0.5289455056,
-0.6550220847,
-0.524892807,
-0.3048217893,
-0.5763385892,
0.0244440921,
-0.4697476625,
-0.4847208261,
-0.1480356008,
-0.3191941679,
-0.3413134813,
0.2710884213,
0.1725823134,
1.007886529,
-0.6437026858,
0.7361302972,
0.3931545019,
-0.1620298028,
-0.4158831537,
-0.2568868995,
0.0325329117,
-0.2803199291,
0.5203137994,
0.3305003047,
-0.1470072865,
0.0733180642,
-0.2457716316,
-1.0282238722,
1.2083718777,
0.3873923421,
-0.7353315949,
-0.2667693496,
0.0345095694,
0.0531420261,
-0.343421936,
0.0298243221,
0.2292495966,
0.1275847256,
0.1585258991,
-0.3450743258,
0.1665343642,
-0.0928025395,
0.4955731928,
0.5077269673,
0.0291116387,
0.5911496878,
-0.6263787746,
-0.4025898278,
0.3117623925,
0.773277998,
0.36931023,
0.5208215714,
0.2558501065,
0.2340553105,
0.5898398161,
0.2186248153,
1.3306411505,
-0.2899556458,
0.2043064535,
0.9517613053,
0.0003156335,
1.1950236559,
0.2627679706,
-0.1767725199,
0.2391157448,
0.5436428785,
0.0581023134,
0.8110179901,
0.1570890695,
-0.077544786,
-0.2922503054,
0.5181162953,
-0.1534985155,
0.0035181979,
0.3734050691,
-0.5689284205,
-0.0570916682,
0.059340626,
0.0241364464,
0.0067718858,
-0.4910388589,
0.5602026582,
0.2036565244,
-0.2402909994,
0.1040349305,
0.4411890507,
0.6546596885,
-0.5317686796,
0.2186913937,
0.0215803497,
0.2525003552,
0.0776342601,
-0.4248980284,
0.4174583256,
0.1458904445,
-0.5168448091,
-0.0339073353,
1.1288093328,
-0.3616899252,
-1.0575829744,
-0.1208705679,
0.3357521892,
-0.0526738577,
-0.370120436,
-0.2029236853,
-0.3189370036,
-0.092737481,
-0.165762037,
0.3504873216,
0.2128823251,
0.4290426075,
0.8546463251,
0.7598819733,
-0.1581897736,
0.331825614,
-0.5354409218,
0.4004153907,
-0.885396719,
-0.4563282132,
-0.8832213879,
0.5943672657,
0.2749279737,
0.1149919555,
0.52417171,
0.6558836699,
0.4610599279,
-0.5473923683,
1.0454268456,
0.1061350852,
0.4624687135,
-0.8412539363,
0.8983395696,
-0.400098294,
-0.2406005263,
-0.5364364982,
-0.9383046031,
-0.4011340439,
0.8460908532,
-0.2274194807,
-0.2019537985,
0.6929849386,
0.80419451,
0.0866939127,
0.0654658526,
0.5805951357,
-0.1448248774,
0.2403603792,
0.9371728897,
0.7663665414,
-0.5443822742,
0.6958953142,
-0.3499242663,
-0.3336910605,
-0.3371714354,
-1.1732871532,
-1.1081098318,
-0.3405995369,
-0.2668918073,
-0.2701223493,
0.1184645668,
0.9444822669,
0.3445394933,
-0.5498577952,
-0.1573111713,
-0.0862112269,
-0.0125072813,
-0.1670748442,
-0.1286736727,
0.1885235459,
-0.1534887105,
-0.4553355873,
0.4887385666,
0.3702096641,
0.3716178238,
0.4508020878,
-0.0280027073,
-0.0199899096,
0.6524159312,
0.7087045312,
0.052240137,
-0.2692340016,
-0.2325834632,
-0.2020895034,
-0.3012955785,
-0.0322525017,
0.6975263953,
-0.458742857,
0.3451662958,
0.6512269974,
0.8691738248,
0.5916214585,
-0.3680510819,
0.6429360509,
-0.579896152,
-0.0403540172,
0.0089497501,
0.3997941017,
0.091865845,
-0.4442509413,
0.228220582,
0.0827442706,
-0.3499609828,
-0.7904220819,
0.4151180983,
-1.1343305111,
-0.2361443639,
0.8292618394,
0.0498581342,
-0.329661727,
0.2898941636,
-0.2835539281,
0.1600157917,
-0.503931284,
0.6275092363,
0.5011638403,
0.0757463202,
-0.3419710696,
-0.7262004614,
0.4633304775,
0.1613523215,
-0.704500854,
-0.0570761152,
0.6956605315,
0.2586871982,
-0.0977862552,
0.8902570009,
0.1032609046,
0.4063284397,
0.3527644873,
0.1171432808,
-0.0808116868,
-0.3612136543,
-0.2410775125,
0.2798925042,
-0.0111266812,
0.0340735018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05232v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05232v1
|
A Survey on Hallucination in Large Language Models: Principles, Taxonomy, Challenges, and Open Questions
| 2023-11-09T09:25:37 | 2023-11-09T09:25:37 |
Lei Huang, Weijiang Yu, Weitao Ma, Weihong Zhong, Zhangyin Feng, Haotian Wang, Qianglong Chen, Weihua Peng, Xiaocheng Feng, Bing Qin, Ting Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has marked a significant
breakthrough in natural language processing (NLP), leading to remarkable
advancements in text understanding and generation. Nevertheless, alongside
these strides, LLMs exhibit a critical tendency to produce hallucinations,
resulting in content that is inconsistent with real-world facts or user inputs.
This phenomenon poses substantial challenges to their practical deployment and
raises concerns over the reliability of LLMs in real-world scenarios, which
attracts increasing attention to detect and mitigate these hallucinations. In
this survey, we aim to provide a thorough and in-depth overview of recent
advances in the field of LLM hallucinations. We begin with an innovative
taxonomy of LLM hallucinations, then delve into the factors contributing to
hallucinations. Subsequently, we present a comprehensive overview of
hallucination detection methods and benchmarks. Additionally, representative
approaches designed to mitigate hallucinations are introduced accordingly.
Finally, we analyze the challenges that highlight the current limitations and
formulate open questions, aiming to delineate pathways for future research on
hallucinations in LLMs.
|
[
-0.5610327125,
-1.151154995,
0.8405653834,
0.0696117654,
-0.0643045977,
-0.1261825413,
-0.4942885339,
-0.7364830375,
0.3349611759,
0.9161063433,
-0.584425509,
-0.5117716193,
-0.6634361744,
0.3048396707,
-0.590082705,
0.5680218339,
0.0538343154,
-0.0799777359,
-0.2290202081,
0.0277655404,
-0.5791475773,
-0.8832819462,
-0.4677629769,
-0.1355284303,
0.4488936067,
0.0763719827,
0.6568827629,
0.1461329609,
0.6069855094,
0.2815363705,
-0.2843493223,
0.3973703086,
-0.5132854581,
0.5632483959,
0.0496144369,
-0.2323550135,
-0.2965096533,
-0.3058258891,
0.6238853931,
1.03510952,
-0.2590312362,
-0.2233407646,
0.0824299753,
0.5778055787,
-0.6505743265,
-0.0736717135,
-0.871314168,
0.2967706025,
-0.2895142436,
-0.2227440476,
-0.5674688816,
-0.3502044082,
0.0729600564,
-0.1102618277,
0.1697004735,
0.1332057565,
0.4561291337,
0.435890913,
-0.3745679259,
-0.8082184196,
-1.0075125694,
0.7862280011,
-0.7579988837,
0.6793831587,
0.2871814668,
0.2631830871,
-0.3796530962,
-0.6978781819,
-0.5734642744,
-0.4535787702,
0.040867541,
-0.3213088512,
-0.1471228004,
-0.0982357487,
0.2211606354,
0.4572825134,
-0.7478922009,
0.4555137753,
-0.090838328,
-0.3236496449,
0.5041995049,
0.325832665,
0.336622417,
-0.2301144749,
-0.1592809558,
0.2267605811,
-0.6767100692,
-0.59713763,
0.4140314758,
0.2023458183,
0.230374828,
0.6606194377,
0.031302806,
0.5826030374,
-0.4305818379,
0.0642965659,
0.1747505069,
-0.0796703473,
-0.1471617073,
0.0723646656,
0.7775095105,
0.2130489647,
0.3069678843,
-0.4447550476,
-0.381795764,
-0.1062288582,
0.4539548755,
-0.5548522472,
0.0220068619,
0.5440686941,
-0.4354862571,
-0.2684678137,
0.025242364,
-0.9160137177,
-0.8275250793,
-0.2491927445,
0.2385585159,
-0.3210077584,
-0.5141633749,
0.4063825309,
0.1347914636,
0.3696741164,
0.3203223646,
-0.9976907372,
0.4534747899,
0.8159025311,
0.8802697659,
-0.4515543878,
-0.3196129203,
-0.3318811953,
-0.1168465912,
-0.2572190166,
0.8560752869,
-0.2990013361,
-0.2349782437,
0.3609454334,
-0.0018171918,
0.0406374745,
-0.9352687001,
0.5181673169,
-0.2796657383,
0.1327759475,
-0.2238823771,
-0.4439443648,
-0.2026541978,
0.3624814451,
-0.6317901611,
0.8916655779,
-0.1844874918,
-0.7930140495,
0.0531756841,
-0.2903409302,
-0.2599169016,
0.1820603907,
-0.258271277,
-0.3049734831,
0.4777501523,
0.0079619568,
0.5900823474,
-0.3288914561,
0.4746515155,
-0.1572511494,
-0.3128633797,
0.522459805,
-0.3777171671,
0.5820564032,
0.1591308415,
-0.3262663484,
0.3347003758,
-0.7339241505,
-0.2504909635,
0.2852810621,
0.2106947452,
-0.3185363412,
0.2997200787,
0.0754744783,
-0.0121827051,
0.0375588089,
-0.1364166886,
0.2282454073,
-0.3465408087,
0.310736686,
0.7607236505,
0.1880532205,
0.1208670065,
-0.2722504139,
0.4747390449,
-0.0012314974,
0.2033120543,
0.0172440372,
-0.3817327023,
-0.7324368954,
-0.0613225028,
-0.1474105567,
0.2211610973,
-0.502098918,
0.6323452592,
-0.0368853472,
-0.406440109,
-0.2673295438,
-0.0452287979,
0.0168753359,
0.3448880613,
0.3125037253,
-0.0775523931,
-0.6764020324,
-0.8004080057,
0.0114636049,
-0.0859422535,
-0.0256188251,
0.2172489762,
0.7145088315,
-0.517539382,
0.5109523535,
-0.5250718594,
-0.4564121962,
-0.364964813,
0.1055617481,
-0.044276163,
0.1772971302,
0.2866719961,
-0.7836915255,
0.0055856253,
-0.1263223141,
-0.9953818321,
-0.1842927635,
-0.2095771283,
0.2223356962,
0.5088524222,
0.6750639677,
-0.7627241611,
0.1693954319,
0.5763133168,
-0.1952310055,
0.8870447278,
0.0345238931,
-0.0809063315,
-0.842703402,
-0.0516589768,
-0.2665191293,
0.1814769059,
-0.7735637426,
0.302949667,
-0.3090177178,
0.2699896991,
-0.2950380743,
0.3666069508,
-0.5059615374,
-0.2467866838,
-0.2539909482,
0.3657799065,
-0.4930174649,
0.1074714214,
0.1683546752,
0.3750159442,
0.6107776165,
-0.7153611779,
0.51708287,
0.2919714153,
-0.5682002902,
0.1035133824,
-0.3720277846,
0.2625720799,
-0.3038364649,
0.1182846725,
-0.9722270966,
-0.4288612008,
0.4685611427,
-0.2852183282,
0.0799851865,
0.3071895838,
-0.8118494153,
-0.2896890342,
-0.3261184096,
0.3324964643,
0.3846500218,
-0.5090611577,
0.4800461233,
0.3729771674,
-0.0166610293,
-0.4581764638,
-0.6923789978,
0.3064308167,
-0.2241560966,
-0.6129166484,
0.0991014317,
-0.1384339929,
-0.6274653077,
-0.2594980597,
-0.0670640245,
0.1688280404,
0.2644071877,
0.2332435548,
0.0688113943,
-0.239529267,
0.1999132782,
-0.3884914219,
0.1775502264,
0.3657869101,
-0.0782825276,
1.0749447346,
0.0097049419,
-0.5314890742,
-0.213400647,
0.3319709003,
0.5995505452,
-0.087996617,
0.8201409578,
0.5383971334,
-0.7484516501,
-0.4741313159,
-0.7912191749,
-0.4293227792,
-0.3954820931,
0.4283941984,
-0.3061355948,
-0.9530810714,
0.7675577998,
0.0309861824,
-0.0555492379,
0.3201682866,
0.9206392765,
0.2013478279,
0.8487077951,
0.4761898518,
0.172205478,
0.0601878539,
-0.0860893354,
0.574131012,
-0.7712153792,
-0.5602136254,
-0.5804975629,
-0.0213095061,
-0.6193171144,
-0.3578113914,
0.2158761322,
-0.0379032083,
0.1333071589,
0.0205656774,
-0.5528308749,
0.2798441052,
0.1505838186,
-0.1901252568,
0.4486144185,
-0.0855938941,
0.0114476401,
-0.0846328288,
-0.3532800376,
-0.7124275565,
0.7625895143,
0.4768380523,
0.7509408593,
0.2961282134,
0.7332882881,
0.2214694619,
-0.0714353099,
-0.9515464902,
0.8147482276,
0.2071530223,
-0.5613340735,
-0.5346418619,
-0.3674857318,
-0.8681992292,
0.3637419045,
-0.258261025,
-1.1263847351,
-0.0065311333,
-0.0805268139,
-0.1508301347,
0.561365366,
-0.2116125822,
0.7046658993,
-0.2776741385,
-0.2710070312,
-0.0440341942,
-0.52401191,
0.7940178514,
-0.2518823147,
0.2759271562,
-0.0485805832,
0.1231727749,
0.5746638179,
-0.2020195723,
0.7721481323,
0.0609796941,
-0.6606243253,
0.3293717802,
0.2475034893,
0.5004761815,
-0.1409890056,
0.0501908138,
0.2510626912,
-0.1702143997,
0.1219066978,
-0.3622670472,
0.7652152777,
-0.471724391,
-0.6808027029,
-0.6080666184,
-0.6408829093,
-0.3626122773,
0.0594229475,
0.2548433542,
0.13101013,
-0.2843075097,
0.3494492173,
0.9374412894,
-0.5033794045,
0.3878627419,
0.2011340111,
-0.9085845947,
-0.1706979871,
0.8580188155,
0.1972732842,
0.2588440776,
0.222550109,
0.0324407108,
-0.2810849845,
-1.0441612005,
-0.0164884795,
0.4645139575,
-0.7418026924,
0.1141524762,
-0.929849267,
-0.4928323925,
-0.7192773223,
0.1049231589,
-0.2927824259,
-0.087926656,
-0.4817737937,
-0.0681546852,
0.1004373804,
0.9303779602,
0.1771629751,
0.0192569327,
-0.6018196344,
0.5381323695,
0.1309310198,
0.3037166595,
0.278911531,
-0.5139914751,
-0.0291154645,
-0.2183822244,
-0.1344595402,
-0.8008340597,
0.4933651388,
-0.3565051258,
0.556779325,
0.6200017333,
0.1416891813,
0.4845029414,
-0.4310255945,
0.9302530885,
0.10563232,
-0.7095718384,
0.2267872989,
-0.2395837456,
0.0068929936,
0.2096991539,
0.5761252046,
-0.8388573527,
-0.5984528065,
-0.2302576452,
-0.8282737732,
0.3412875533,
0.1856613904,
0.0957375169,
-0.1181780845,
0.2059849054,
0.3488675058,
0.1392309368,
-0.8263704777,
0.0063126129,
0.1756725311,
0.0161339361,
-0.0176036991,
-0.5070869923,
0.0727311969,
-0.0957243219,
0.5431478024,
-0.030429041,
0.1007649824,
0.0462434292,
-0.3470935225,
-0.1731721014,
0.2574928999,
0.8313546181,
0.7475858927,
-0.4508681893,
0.3164011538,
0.0886810347,
-0.4568755925,
-0.0127050253,
-0.2533412278,
-0.132700786,
0.0534465984,
0.5386638045,
0.7849895358,
0.0988375768,
-1.0318644047,
0.3898165226,
0.0029057066,
-0.3973199725,
-0.6948605776,
-0.0403339006,
0.0768194944,
0.1956918538,
0.4805092216,
-0.3287534416,
0.1913632303,
-0.8391682506,
0.0485545509,
0.6193723083,
-0.2880687714,
-0.2923810184,
0.5847840905,
-0.2420738637,
-0.4304533005,
0.7218946815,
-0.1203305647,
-0.4991677105,
0.4135149717,
0.6414257288,
1.2201036215,
-0.2080531567,
0.0986854509,
0.0893238187,
0.5671237111,
-0.2511934042,
0.3831081986,
0.192653358,
-0.8580201864,
-0.1655734032,
-0.8988131881,
-0.5196492672,
0.6666417122,
-0.5735446811,
0.3742264509,
-0.3702667356,
0.0586365238,
-0.0148647698,
-0.3182263076,
-0.2315921485,
-0.1260283589,
0.5718710423,
0.7265018821,
-0.7187047005,
0.5404980779,
0.3415820897,
-0.2721574903,
-0.1272763312,
0.2806686759,
0.1380325258,
-0.4630669057,
0.3459873199,
0.3465054929,
-0.1650068611,
-0.1195705011,
-0.6292975545,
-0.5260385275,
0.7576228976,
-0.0124367746,
-0.6262882352,
-0.3398698866,
0.4296621978,
0.653844595,
-0.34194085,
-0.0259108152,
0.7338382006,
0.5682951212,
0.1373473108,
-0.6416261792,
0.1702191234,
0.1856489778,
-0.0542028807,
0.2693906724,
-0.4924275279,
0.7638110518,
-0.2031849772,
-0.2478020489,
0.285172075,
0.4934789538,
0.3438659012,
0.3666979373,
0.4755394757,
0.5022352338,
0.7346314192,
-0.0571605489,
0.7154090405,
-0.0794042125,
0.1129973531,
1.0923932791,
-0.6828062534,
0.7557257414,
0.6629365683,
-0.0294148289,
0.1953141242,
0.5975362062,
-0.2244744152,
0.203860119,
0.5953817964,
-0.3115184605,
-0.2737664878,
-0.1668082327,
-0.4546434581,
0.5217604637,
0.4936167598,
-0.2283686697,
-0.0939700603,
0.3435382247,
-0.2618868649,
0.0912103653,
-0.1271093786,
0.8962166905,
0.1309887916,
-0.6102852225,
0.5479775667,
-0.1119611785,
0.6963972449,
-0.5449556708,
-0.114174664,
-0.2135270685,
0.0425548591,
-0.2453026623,
-0.5853413939,
0.4894348085,
-0.0509268045,
-0.0053056823,
-0.158151716,
0.7135778666,
-0.2589947283,
-0.2527890801,
0.4742921293,
0.5838263631,
0.5631364584,
-0.3405005932,
-0.076314725,
0.6282687187,
-0.1207353473,
-0.2918545604,
0.2140730023,
0.5368408561,
-0.0693667606,
0.7602194548,
0.4110545814,
0.1868743151,
0.2490670234,
0.274186492,
0.702819109,
-0.8907828927,
-0.0322520211,
-0.9926365018,
0.2292747945,
0.0854799524,
-0.209601745,
0.7534863949,
0.5905262232,
0.8304646015,
-0.1613089889,
0.6408406496,
0.110396415,
0.4087765813,
-0.6840178967,
0.808778584,
-0.6096270084,
0.3849596679,
-0.2815460861,
-1.1708103418,
-0.5499842763,
0.4275593162,
-0.1298314184,
-0.1661615968,
0.8925616145,
0.9017542005,
0.1081304476,
0.1312392056,
0.5758253336,
0.5661645532,
0.2389303595,
0.3406695724,
1.2859568596,
-0.1646926105,
0.3737778962,
-0.1510491669,
0.1149861738,
-0.4789360464,
-0.7096228004,
-0.9778206944,
-0.7984567881,
-0.3546191454,
-0.3593908846,
-0.0717215389,
0.9065203667,
0.2237429172,
-0.9748760462,
-0.3203068972,
-0.213815257,
0.2829182148,
-0.0034084555,
-0.2697689533,
0.2747893035,
-0.475338161,
-0.7129659057,
0.2131004632,
0.3737363517,
0.2070132792,
-0.7434314489,
-0.0070492914,
-0.1900132447,
0.097945042,
0.8148348331,
0.1550394148,
-1.1430590153,
-0.3562809527,
0.1179629937,
-0.1417550743,
-0.1083891615,
0.8244313598,
-0.4566888213,
0.2878316343,
0.4492544532,
0.604631424,
0.2419820279,
-0.4553925395,
0.1111289039,
-0.4183415174,
0.1025458947,
0.5678468347,
0.3184591234,
0.3274149597,
-0.2261792719,
0.5416679382,
0.28207618,
-0.4639681876,
-1.458537221,
0.3217563033,
-1.0512781143,
-0.5338258147,
1.2469056845,
0.4219400287,
-0.0603759922,
-0.115677394,
-0.2122364044,
0.0526055396,
0.2337617129,
1.1605015993,
1.0127128363,
-0.0887849256,
-0.2039094418,
-0.6769367456,
0.4690776169,
0.1796222776,
-0.9501383305,
0.4740676284,
0.7694356441,
-0.2076156288,
0.2132744044,
0.3846653998,
-0.1113974079,
-0.1160583198,
-0.1142520756,
0.2230529338,
0.1697300076,
-0.578386724,
-0.4988326728,
0.4438913465,
0.1383187622,
0.2086073458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05195v1
|
PRODIGy: a PROfile-based DIalogue Generation dataset
| 2023-11-09T08:19:34 | 2023-11-09T08:19:34 |
Daniela Occhipinti, Serra Sinem Tekiroglu, Marco Guerini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Providing dialogue agents with a profile representation can improve their
consistency and coherence, leading to better conversations. However, current
profile-based dialogue datasets for training such agents contain either
explicit profile representations that are simple and dialogue-specific, or
implicit representations that are difficult to collect. In this work, we
propose a unified framework in which we bring together both standard and more
sophisticated profile representations by creating a new resource where each
dialogue is aligned with all possible speaker representations such as
communication style, biographies, and personality. This framework allows to
test several baselines built using generative language models with several
profile configurations. The automatic evaluation shows that profile-based
models have better generalisation capabilities than models trained on dialogues
only, both in-domain and cross-domain settings. These results are consistent
for fine-tuned models and instruction-based LLMs. Additionally, human
evaluation demonstrates a clear preference for generations consistent with both
profile and context. Finally, to account for possible privacy concerns, all
experiments are done under two configurations: inter-character and
intra-character. In the former, the LM stores the information about the
character in its internal representation, while in the latter, the LM does not
retain any personal information but uses it only at inference time.
|
[
-0.3459287584,
-0.3130210042,
0.4219373763,
0.0506142341,
0.1976759434,
0.480163157,
-0.1150991097,
-0.2055259794,
0.3152792156,
0.6426712871,
-0.8286445737,
-0.5484229922,
-0.2949597836,
0.1346490383,
-0.1838074774,
0.9928794503,
0.2809092402,
0.050249666,
-0.3484072685,
-0.1865157485,
-0.8636525273,
-0.4533317089,
-0.7963376045,
-0.466981411,
0.4192935526,
0.3921408653,
0.6089485288,
0.4828082621,
-0.0271003135,
0.3142454922,
0.1045911908,
0.326346308,
-0.8378515244,
0.750251174,
-0.0927024782,
-0.0525054298,
-0.3849981129,
0.1476429999,
0.5247055888,
0.8321994543,
0.0419229679,
-0.1254965216,
0.1371829957,
0.400549829,
-0.3761042953,
0.531771481,
-0.5587335825,
0.0787386,
0.1246649995,
-0.1324871778,
-0.5636357069,
-0.3200537264,
0.3599257469,
-0.558124125,
0.4158289731,
0.0403414629,
0.6830525398,
-0.1987093389,
-0.4527942538,
-0.1114800349,
-0.8760041595,
0.6942575574,
-0.313439697,
0.2649542689,
0.1278812289,
0.5877065659,
-0.1372167021,
-0.5889848471,
-0.4264336228,
-0.2126786411,
-0.3157702684,
0.1851186752,
0.0706556812,
0.3919341862,
0.0924671069,
0.3642064631,
-0.5326385498,
0.2083669156,
-0.2375598997,
-0.4597283602,
0.7473058701,
0.4307429492,
0.1530931741,
-0.1681139469,
0.0633353218,
-0.3592538536,
-0.9547492266,
0.1170927584,
0.6095876694,
0.7012324333,
-0.0941323489,
0.263073653,
-0.3074924052,
0.4423188567,
0.5074382424,
-0.2131501734,
0.257763207,
-0.1427777857,
0.0721456185,
-0.0155348601,
0.8612142801,
0.4053855538,
0.4894351363,
-0.3026295304,
-0.0248275734,
-0.3429841399,
0.2423282862,
-0.9623918533,
-0.0548568666,
0.1458165646,
-0.2414066494,
-0.3287057579,
0.1706487387,
-0.6876537204,
-0.4744649231,
-0.1960939616,
0.3381066322,
-0.3666135669,
-0.0106908837,
-0.0115601849,
0.0665371045,
0.1340249926,
0.2456114739,
-1.3569047451,
0.2246204019,
0.5005995631,
0.5256769657,
-0.3590175807,
0.0569815785,
-0.4817420244,
0.294575423,
-0.2458869815,
0.4866800606,
-0.7930743098,
-0.8112027049,
0.3996700048,
0.0822005048,
-0.2181608677,
-0.5948025584,
0.2621854842,
-0.2818712294,
0.659427762,
-0.1714684516,
-0.6106564999,
-0.037872728,
-0.0378979556,
-0.5984592438,
0.7302414179,
0.3845254183,
-0.2912421227,
0.3001181781,
-0.6925172806,
-0.2203608155,
0.2595096231,
-0.541654408,
-0.350307703,
-0.0996917263,
0.2289102077,
0.6996716857,
-0.1120626777,
0.4974855483,
0.0341013409,
-0.5511667728,
0.1878012419,
-0.5022957921,
0.574402988,
0.0172012057,
-0.1236581504,
-0.0855118558,
-0.7455930114,
-0.0259683598,
0.0279799756,
-0.2218346149,
0.080546163,
-0.1179354638,
-0.404383719,
-0.1195386797,
0.194866538,
-0.7614895701,
0.2504591644,
-0.4910472035,
0.3297648132,
0.7554867864,
0.2682047784,
0.3981432915,
-0.3961411715,
0.5555726886,
0.0526999645,
0.0103019923,
-0.6915124655,
-0.4822114706,
-0.8505771756,
-0.2064784914,
0.1558169723,
0.4421807826,
-0.4168541431,
0.7134319544,
-0.3611952662,
-0.1018954888,
-0.521091938,
-0.0600864105,
0.5815053582,
0.5461987853,
0.0749166831,
-0.6404641867,
-0.4777362049,
-1.1165374517,
-0.1067613289,
-0.5422437191,
-0.2105227411,
0.6919641495,
0.2010903209,
-0.152371943,
1.1638640165,
-0.4059199095,
0.0452702492,
-0.4678446651,
0.1573788673,
0.1589834839,
0.5735236406,
0.4730497897,
-0.5656990409,
-0.7477791309,
-0.2419507205,
-0.7375799417,
-0.2004443109,
-0.2548441589,
-0.0901307464,
-0.1900476068,
0.2072235942,
-0.6740738153,
0.3046635985,
0.322368443,
-0.0697812438,
0.3381986916,
-0.0661121979,
0.3045537174,
-1.1800123453,
-0.0015281457,
0.0078211976,
-0.3627488613,
-0.9534797668,
-0.1977066994,
-0.3356865346,
-0.3733754456,
-0.3115084171,
0.6375774145,
-0.1599952281,
-0.1394616961,
0.2006349862,
0.0618832335,
0.3566015959,
0.8386704326,
-0.0866219476,
1.1571376324,
0.5648549795,
-0.2903892696,
0.3429579437,
0.5870868564,
-0.1617773771,
0.7451862097,
-0.6628144979,
0.626316607,
-0.3552978337,
0.2444110662,
-1.0400284529,
-0.4835260808,
0.2210457772,
-0.4273976386,
0.6054136753,
-0.123522386,
-0.4357674122,
-0.1893294603,
-0.3256499767,
0.0352505706,
0.8143126369,
-0.5259919763,
0.654766202,
0.2786774039,
-0.4389761686,
-0.4154921472,
-0.1063175425,
0.1097641587,
-0.3330701888,
-0.8269150853,
0.5418750644,
-0.313598752,
-0.0767407343,
-0.4416253567,
0.0450108014,
-0.1907997131,
-0.1863711923,
0.4577178061,
0.116029188,
-0.1485185921,
0.0489197634,
0.2214270234,
-0.100669384,
-0.2407271564,
-0.0503374971,
0.5609066486,
0.1055661887,
-0.2477547973,
-0.5957048535,
0.5677954555,
0.4815264642,
0.0225582235,
0.6916648149,
0.1131035686,
0.1363902241,
-0.3466414511,
-0.4176761806,
-0.1921679527,
-0.5268041492,
0.2383548468,
-0.3540873826,
-1.2201231718,
0.680580914,
-0.0599302128,
0.2457070798,
0.3592373133,
0.4787947237,
-0.2119633108,
1.3460794687,
0.7842413187,
-0.0726255402,
0.2800047994,
-0.2509000599,
0.164625138,
-0.7944513559,
-0.5579454899,
-0.291087985,
-0.1353504807,
-0.4260024428,
-0.0379561596,
0.3368104696,
-0.1382480711,
-0.3664398193,
0.4064044058,
-0.4516363442,
0.5681014657,
0.2812028229,
-0.1416971385,
0.2682579458,
0.1686846167,
-0.2489733845,
-0.3208171427,
-0.463334024,
-0.781188786,
1.1381587982,
0.3104711473,
0.6265397668,
0.0195440892,
0.7010647058,
0.4042822719,
0.2187035978,
-0.5510005355,
0.6781922579,
-0.2792282999,
-0.6484929919,
-0.1877085418,
-0.2457628548,
-0.9408813119,
0.1080490053,
0.0019982024,
-1.123208642,
0.0952838808,
0.1273706853,
-0.6601846814,
-0.0701798499,
-0.600759089,
0.8230080009,
0.0910475627,
-0.2997892499,
-0.002095371,
-0.6695706844,
0.4059573114,
-0.1623409688,
-0.43117401,
-0.1663481444,
0.493247062,
0.5550518632,
-0.4629092515,
1.0419815779,
-0.1879335791,
0.0044085728,
0.4059010744,
0.1089906767,
0.2734898925,
0.0201314893,
-0.0398426354,
-0.1070978418,
-0.1169208884,
-0.0081530465,
-0.8609980941,
0.5665637255,
-0.886595726,
-0.839925468,
-0.007079043,
-0.631560266,
-0.6935971379,
-0.1469207108,
0.0331649557,
0.6174997091,
-0.6645971537,
0.2712889612,
0.7460910082,
-0.3908763826,
-0.0714222416,
0.7054921985,
-0.2373320609,
-0.0901685059,
0.8658103943,
-0.1275654286,
0.3203857243,
0.2019061148,
-0.0330789723,
-0.348300308,
-0.3487347066,
-0.5133368969,
0.1590932161,
-0.7176288366,
0.0092063518,
-0.5766062737,
-0.596209228,
-0.4334564805,
0.0371881574,
-0.1457248181,
-0.4064992368,
-0.3915067017,
-0.1848716289,
0.3108820617,
0.8049378395,
0.0461411737,
0.5840223432,
-0.5138393044,
0.2712369263,
0.7516366243,
0.2316631228,
-0.1964164525,
-0.6025192142,
-0.2094194889,
0.0774029121,
-0.6776973009,
-0.6179633737,
0.2389965951,
0.6870785356,
0.5916416049,
0.4672655761,
-0.3330721557,
0.479480654,
-0.6424731612,
1.0380365849,
0.031835109,
-0.5885375142,
0.4738612175,
-0.5887002945,
-0.0409856215,
0.9477797747,
0.2886990011,
-0.7555685043,
-0.479195416,
-0.632543087,
-0.357371062,
0.7766321301,
0.3151437342,
0.6854510307,
0.1154402643,
0.5843638778,
0.5578827262,
0.3125587702,
-0.2314167023,
-0.2909666896,
-0.3472368121,
-0.3924156129,
-0.0139289936,
-0.0446681529,
-0.1484580934,
-0.2312405854,
0.4098140299,
-0.2029758096,
0.3587009609,
-0.2545241117,
0.185580492,
-0.057426773,
-0.0132137286,
0.1593503356,
0.4892821014,
-0.3507196605,
-0.2361310571,
-0.1121613458,
-0.3639973104,
0.3476957977,
0.0412211381,
-0.3625647128,
0.1476783603,
0.2622016668,
0.9976740479,
0.1314691752,
-0.7526932955,
0.6444266438,
-0.1741524339,
-0.2049707919,
-0.2052384764,
0.5292317867,
0.0203049723,
0.1693787873,
0.2046325505,
-0.1031167284,
-0.0137175955,
-0.6952317953,
0.3576484323,
0.40300861,
-0.3260129988,
-0.4724784791,
0.5580712557,
0.551322341,
-0.396441102,
0.5437289476,
-0.2505810857,
-0.3673357666,
0.4062146246,
0.3282132149,
1.0796307325,
-0.2001737505,
0.697454989,
0.2440136671,
-0.374679327,
0.0227325689,
-0.0037996427,
-0.1023723707,
-0.9899379611,
-0.3089096248,
-0.5117340088,
-0.7107630968,
0.3578318357,
-0.4738051593,
-0.0071058637,
-0.4202367067,
-0.0378747508,
-0.1073080078,
0.1018288955,
-0.7322884798,
-0.0403842069,
0.0335280262,
0.5183131099,
-0.7720693946,
0.6901472807,
0.0955884531,
-0.5168352127,
-0.6991523504,
0.0188534241,
0.1023190841,
-0.9579338431,
0.9324370027,
0.4072763324,
-0.1540881246,
0.0114561962,
-0.5838042498,
-0.7102672458,
1.1745690107,
0.6667233109,
-0.5453004837,
-0.1417552531,
0.3884074986,
0.6310396791,
-0.9386159182,
0.1562820226,
0.728310883,
0.172345832,
0.4312400222,
-0.7916294336,
-0.3021388948,
-0.2348347604,
0.1149425432,
-0.2870708704,
-0.7423515916,
0.8399764299,
0.2318313122,
-0.6033657193,
0.5499494076,
0.621432662,
0.3267740011,
-0.1461349875,
0.2800841928,
0.1800056249,
0.734380424,
-0.167513147,
0.9294558167,
-0.732968092,
0.0655153021,
0.9302066565,
-0.4557076693,
0.1919035167,
-0.0447760522,
-0.0256837569,
0.7599502206,
0.5439823866,
-0.0131525109,
0.6255568266,
0.3133282065,
-0.45330441,
-0.1718925238,
-0.4028494954,
-0.1049296558,
0.4529320598,
0.1755372286,
-0.4863113761,
-0.0166536625,
-0.1855736822,
0.1215260997,
0.2176785022,
0.026808273,
0.8204407096,
-0.0805046484,
-0.7737169266,
0.4656417072,
-0.0619609803,
0.5520989895,
-0.6066203117,
-0.2055266351,
-0.516348362,
-0.1400125176,
0.0880877599,
-0.6607940793,
-0.1663928926,
0.131332159,
-0.0686488301,
-0.5525301099,
0.7134435177,
-0.7306938171,
-0.2595965266,
-0.0320591517,
0.6844491959,
0.3790338635,
0.3444712162,
-0.569585979,
-0.0166589208,
-0.0256597567,
-0.1878880858,
0.2442277819,
0.3054346144,
0.0544636548,
0.5032541752,
0.2366643399,
0.1021875888,
-0.1920359731,
0.624505043,
0.8432675004,
-0.3822195828,
-0.2442329228,
-0.5211817622,
0.6229143143,
-0.3680182993,
-0.4309268892,
0.6549587846,
0.4378580451,
0.6065540314,
0.1245509237,
0.914196372,
0.2368021607,
0.6147638559,
-0.4450790584,
0.5965672135,
-0.1295379847,
0.1465806216,
-0.1210874096,
-1.0567557812,
0.0179582499,
0.7249179482,
0.0489338711,
0.4319019318,
0.3339222968,
1.0260111094,
0.0503199808,
0.0932737738,
0.4291497171,
0.0498291962,
0.5489942431,
0.6982981563,
0.9267290235,
-0.248687163,
0.223958388,
0.0720717385,
0.0875158161,
-0.0848179609,
-0.5737651587,
-1.2275154591,
-0.6197133064,
-0.2129442245,
-0.143341437,
0.3074413538,
0.8485873938,
0.8710623384,
-0.6778798103,
-0.3055899739,
0.1208929867,
-0.268415153,
0.2080219984,
-0.1978888512,
0.1101396009,
-0.2663737237,
-0.9074892998,
0.7899240255,
0.4133490324,
0.2212710828,
-1.0279616117,
-0.4293845892,
0.5169382691,
0.3460273147,
0.4596929252,
0.3982009292,
-0.4916807711,
-0.7234930396,
-0.0498110354,
-0.1250600368,
0.3788941503,
0.8884214759,
-0.9209774137,
0.7414733171,
0.2496834993,
0.5030975342,
0.5056196451,
0.0868818909,
0.9687099457,
-1.2197445631,
0.0807661191,
0.2792841196,
0.2140526325,
0.6836521626,
-0.340868324,
0.2511035204,
0.1614218801,
-0.3731136024,
-0.6034477949,
0.5519803166,
-0.7469651103,
0.1098616943,
0.7489786744,
-0.317625165,
0.2644324303,
-0.2348337322,
-0.23828125,
0.1016624793,
-0.7810887098,
0.8303252459,
0.64739573,
-0.3077652752,
-0.0915257409,
-0.5262902379,
0.6784741879,
0.1191239879,
-0.5965884924,
0.0563458316,
0.4593306482,
0.0745343119,
0.2274487019,
0.8039255142,
-0.0672577471,
-0.0979320034,
-0.2362319082,
-0.1688273996,
-0.1821926832,
-0.5758979917,
-0.2236880958,
0.1752541065,
-0.0807644203,
0.1306224167
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.