id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05661v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05661v3
|
Prompt Engineering a Prompt Engineer
| 2023-11-09T08:00:32 | 2024-07-03T01:29:20 |
Qinyuan Ye, Maxamed Axmed, Reid Pryzant, Fereshte Khani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Prompt engineering is a challenging yet crucial task for optimizing the
performance of large language models on customized tasks. It requires complex
reasoning to examine the model's errors, hypothesize what is missing or
misleading in the current prompt, and communicate the task with clarity. While
recent works indicate that large language models can be meta-prompted to
perform automatic prompt engineering, we argue that their potential is limited
due to insufficient guidance for complex reasoning in the meta-prompt. We fill
this gap by infusing into the meta-prompt three key components: detailed
descriptions, context specification, and a step-by-step reasoning template. The
resulting method, named PE2, exhibits remarkable versatility across diverse
language tasks. It finds prompts that outperform "let's think step by step" by
6.3% on MultiArith and 3.1% on GSM8K, and outperforms competitive baselines on
counterfactual tasks by 6.9%. Further, we show that PE2 can make targeted and
highly specific prompt edits, rectify erroneous prompts, and induce multi-step
plans for complex tasks.
|
[
-0.4265671074,
-0.9469866157,
1.0381703377,
0.7616608143,
0.2958725095,
0.0982270986,
-0.0037619609,
-0.1430144757,
-0.195695132,
0.1418608278,
-0.9044107795,
-0.0340926275,
-0.2672811747,
0.3515613675,
0.2382298857,
0.6927312016,
-0.3351089954,
0.0464060642,
0.0757934228,
0.3621013463,
-0.9626572132,
-0.2474774867,
-0.7140197754,
-0.2973434031,
0.606613934,
0.7593941092,
0.4997674823,
0.2504541576,
-0.0213565361,
0.2582879364,
-0.157413289,
0.2499343008,
0.026142437,
0.2679354548,
-0.4509768784,
-0.327588141,
-0.6417155862,
0.2707149982,
0.3593868911,
0.7901903987,
0.4591775537,
0.1638326645,
0.3745731413,
0.5301168561,
-0.7053380013,
0.3168037236,
-0.3262228966,
-0.1254033446,
-0.0106041618,
-0.0938549489,
-0.7482452393,
-0.2053183466,
0.1230988204,
-0.6195693612,
-0.0969189033,
0.2850181162,
0.4415739477,
0.2972200811,
-0.5835779309,
-0.3295071721,
-0.8056022525,
0.7678090334,
-0.3464911282,
0.2896354198,
0.3582587838,
0.3716851175,
-0.2598023415,
-0.5414594412,
-0.4756939411,
-0.2613121271,
-0.1323196292,
0.0195643846,
0.0118439766,
0.3516942859,
0.5684885979,
-0.2742901742,
-0.6985573173,
0.0334767587,
-0.1053223386,
-0.3846042156,
0.3601861596,
0.2179735601,
0.7098821402,
-0.2221056223,
-0.2342671454,
0.1223426163,
-0.7615530491,
0.4523168802,
0.3506551087,
0.330527395,
0.1420354992,
0.5233198404,
-0.1474300474,
0.6212034225,
0.2174230218,
0.0467509665,
0.1592121124,
-0.5295128822,
-0.0700044557,
0.1630392969,
0.7056758404,
0.3712288141,
0.1768838912,
0.1618988514,
-0.2058910877,
-0.181776017,
0.0585631318,
-0.7649031878,
-0.2593374848,
0.4685462713,
-0.3333839178,
0.0593284741,
-0.0495532677,
-0.7530970573,
-0.3044883013,
-0.5068711638,
0.3348768353,
-0.3076331913,
-0.2080636919,
0.0875363424,
-0.2317880243,
0.0198316853,
0.5054528117,
-0.8295454979,
-0.131049782,
0.7863500714,
0.7080764771,
0.2615230083,
-0.5223885179,
-0.7875378132,
-0.0752917901,
-0.4857724011,
0.9815634489,
-0.8087841868,
-0.4789805114,
-0.2902833223,
0.1581092477,
-0.281727463,
-0.237419039,
0.8244792819,
-0.2305532098,
0.4000738859,
-0.6842995286,
-0.3631775975,
-0.1831392348,
0.1636809707,
-0.6125791073,
0.8924615383,
0.0414018966,
-0.5268679857,
0.1143397018,
-0.8054257631,
-0.3206852078,
-0.1111234054,
-0.0524344519,
0.0006242873,
0.1047522277,
0.3166709542,
0.1961052865,
-0.4027009606,
0.4062125981,
-0.2293971628,
-0.3121909797,
0.0830951929,
-0.2465226501,
0.9196971655,
0.2356249243,
-0.5384601951,
0.131019488,
-0.5925020576,
0.0735133141,
-0.134426862,
-0.2390153855,
-0.2660195231,
-0.0171010531,
-0.0562211163,
0.3460720778,
0.1634799093,
-0.5285302401,
0.4861274958,
-0.6012383103,
0.5259054899,
0.6442427039,
-0.0612375401,
0.7287287712,
-0.2156790197,
0.6380970478,
-0.4393365681,
0.1684349626,
-0.7096102834,
-0.73892802,
-0.4213342071,
-0.1479287297,
0.1273447871,
1.1021213531,
-0.7576833963,
0.2837258279,
0.3444344699,
-0.4792105258,
-0.1729582995,
-0.115236491,
0.3706567287,
0.7778441906,
0.4319700599,
0.4807099402,
-0.6167451143,
-1.0290775299,
-0.60293293,
-0.1679331213,
-0.1321578175,
0.2465166152,
0.3258076608,
-0.2857652009,
1.1012943983,
-0.4584238529,
0.2305577546,
-0.3737477362,
0.5022949576,
0.4881091416,
0.6621645093,
0.596629262,
-0.6970267892,
-0.7276797891,
-0.2354120016,
-0.4936498404,
-0.7338415384,
-0.5326201916,
0.0375115685,
-0.2148658186,
0.5741407275,
-1.0390031338,
0.0474387035,
0.2077728659,
-0.7596719861,
0.8452925682,
-0.1619061083,
0.4621341825,
-0.8814027905,
0.1957575232,
-0.0752838328,
-0.1361045241,
-0.620777905,
-0.0365041457,
0.3066861033,
-0.551743865,
-0.4894555509,
0.8757421374,
-0.6064324379,
0.2889155746,
-0.5362064838,
-0.1168472394,
0.1871097237,
0.3173815012,
-0.2672133446,
1.0725252628,
0.714879632,
-0.600925982,
0.428432554,
0.2680347562,
-0.1017617211,
0.565966785,
-0.9495207071,
0.1739393175,
-0.2527347207,
0.4367330074,
-1.2087051868,
-0.2745774686,
0.3955690265,
-0.3329002857,
0.3795476854,
-0.0688210651,
-0.5048773885,
-0.3782715201,
-0.2757564485,
0.4446494877,
0.4287373424,
-0.3468934596,
0.8145611882,
0.0555824451,
-0.8039005995,
-0.3031000793,
-0.2370953858,
0.2529075742,
0.0838755444,
-0.790692389,
0.4765574932,
-0.3596850336,
-0.327006489,
-0.2262116671,
-0.1875215173,
-0.055313237,
0.2824938297,
0.1895727515,
0.1574506611,
0.0007502341,
0.2034317404,
0.2993854284,
-0.6128150225,
0.3131166995,
-0.2346726507,
0.4542017579,
-0.0019637258,
-0.3788883388,
-0.6859875917,
0.6979572773,
0.7706761956,
-0.2429949194,
0.3265323043,
0.3975589871,
-0.4998765588,
-0.1858845949,
-0.4151261151,
-0.2042328864,
-0.4909694195,
0.2425905168,
-0.7636921406,
-0.4761961401,
0.2879728079,
-0.4835862517,
0.351942569,
0.5327281356,
0.2574799359,
-0.3126304746,
1.502263546,
0.5380807519,
0.3146097064,
0.3132964671,
0.1459457427,
0.3341485262,
-0.7152559757,
-0.3972450495,
-0.7164273858,
-0.3192591369,
-0.094552964,
-0.2643885016,
0.415332973,
0.2660357356,
-0.424431473,
0.3159591854,
-0.3878497779,
0.5891567469,
0.6303502917,
0.0062421928,
-0.1071324125,
-0.4615722895,
-0.2123674154,
-0.1231775731,
-0.5532109141,
-0.8531735539,
0.5843085647,
0.352791518,
0.6118730903,
-0.1356725991,
0.3390585482,
0.2263641357,
-0.1668569595,
-0.6404912472,
0.5704852343,
0.2275850922,
-0.5017416477,
-0.255236268,
-0.1547132134,
-0.6709936261,
-0.0310894679,
-0.0582886748,
-0.5197051167,
0.2212843448,
0.3893930614,
-0.701998651,
0.0235231593,
-1.0274620056,
1.059017539,
-0.1155078188,
-0.080224365,
-0.056003619,
-0.6795335412,
0.1345215142,
-0.1600750089,
0.4106662571,
0.0010638902,
-0.2695287168,
0.4294047952,
-0.4821891487,
0.8583236337,
-0.2429348528,
-0.1564489752,
0.4301944673,
0.3836414814,
0.8981592059,
0.0056090392,
-0.1278947294,
-0.3823380768,
-0.1524162591,
-0.4435847402,
-0.7419124842,
0.6197797656,
-0.4062892199,
-0.8573907614,
-0.1494404823,
-0.383792907,
-0.3438292742,
0.1303641349,
0.4251874685,
0.351148814,
0.0633911118,
-0.0769889504,
0.8249072433,
-0.4207261503,
0.7098414302,
0.2045284361,
0.0845870525,
-0.2980514467,
0.678817451,
0.0842602104,
0.1017419696,
0.4729708135,
0.3164400458,
-0.2597846091,
-0.1402608454,
-0.7582768798,
0.0765962154,
-0.5905401707,
0.0559115075,
-1.1310404539,
0.0775069892,
-0.4074519277,
-0.4695149958,
-0.4228247702,
-0.5920408368,
-0.4411809146,
-0.1373371184,
-0.2080973089,
0.616273582,
0.0917437971,
0.2078446746,
-0.9563092589,
0.2309200466,
0.5638186336,
0.0456568748,
-0.1780055314,
-0.26188609,
0.2290039361,
-0.0067197913,
-0.3511981666,
-1.3895303011,
-0.0622326359,
0.1397204101,
0.7789419293,
0.0987811163,
0.1030276269,
0.3728930652,
-0.9540345669,
1.0630122423,
0.2424515933,
-1.2293729782,
1.1212148666,
-0.2444596887,
0.3820022345,
0.2855130732,
0.4956462681,
-0.3525626063,
-0.1781418473,
-0.4433477223,
-0.8275135159,
0.6738634109,
0.057392031,
0.0693429038,
0.0127909724,
0.3638121486,
0.1446696818,
0.027703695,
-0.4883670211,
-0.1503813267,
-0.1817461997,
-0.1866131276,
0.1842286736,
-0.6381828189,
-0.0056207874,
0.0212838128,
0.6724738479,
-0.1364242882,
0.0440268777,
0.3383449614,
-0.0733943358,
-0.1238567904,
0.5038847327,
0.8557130098,
0.7895009518,
0.1467573196,
0.2657557428,
0.3433404565,
-0.1733255684,
0.3745337129,
0.0529471263,
-0.2786628604,
0.087264441,
0.4521013796,
0.679105401,
0.1108402908,
-0.6159109473,
0.4735026658,
0.1231749207,
-0.088110514,
0.1760329455,
0.103883408,
0.0001816554,
0.4265319407,
0.3750610948,
0.3240569234,
0.3739795983,
-0.5885679126,
0.0725911409,
0.1236529723,
-0.3647677004,
-0.6976342201,
0.749971211,
0.6147376895,
-0.6071225405,
0.392863512,
-0.3843756616,
-0.6450989246,
0.7443880439,
0.5860856771,
1.1280527115,
-0.5084691644,
0.2510474026,
0.7180024385,
0.5011924505,
-0.1984525323,
0.4888134599,
0.1556975693,
-0.1723810434,
-0.7489928603,
-0.196435079,
-0.4405385554,
-0.111492373,
0.0242434982,
0.4609321356,
-0.5025880933,
-0.2135807276,
-0.1947154552,
-0.3956766725,
-0.4356229901,
0.0996404961,
0.0427490771,
1.0917620659,
-0.9403759241,
0.1771868467,
1.0346566439,
-0.1993716508,
-0.96012187,
-0.0334006473,
0.1866833419,
-0.4004478753,
0.9550510049,
0.4124558866,
0.053535454,
-0.1223280355,
-0.4259721339,
-0.7101207972,
0.8318747878,
0.4461376369,
-0.7637063861,
-0.354873538,
-0.244481042,
0.1314405352,
-0.3570008278,
0.5620105863,
0.1502515376,
0.697627306,
-0.035044793,
-1.2735688686,
0.330794692,
-0.2475190014,
-0.2330925465,
0.2155688852,
-0.5482240319,
1.0273308754,
-0.4532290995,
-0.2809155583,
-0.0684155226,
0.2078280896,
0.3981696665,
0.5439023972,
0.7216712832,
0.1376966536,
0.8145795465,
-0.1403741986,
0.8440722823,
-0.3862975836,
0.2515796125,
1.1410387754,
-0.2581585348,
0.3124039471,
0.3432732224,
-0.0332793966,
0.3938551247,
0.8243986368,
0.2847702205,
0.3876707256,
-0.191102922,
-0.2050672621,
-0.7157024741,
-0.0936644673,
-0.3320928514,
0.1320727766,
0.2911264598,
-0.2434185594,
-0.353998065,
0.3230410814,
0.033348348,
-0.0665356889,
-0.2825008631,
0.5097488165,
0.1116955504,
-0.9360681176,
0.1412409544,
0.0321795791,
0.1313586384,
-0.2880175114,
-0.2900640666,
-0.0324459784,
-0.2003571987,
-0.146286726,
-0.9404017925,
0.353256166,
0.0455798432,
-0.4277084172,
-0.761865437,
0.7456314564,
-0.1027783379,
-0.2175562084,
-0.0611204579,
0.4813359678,
-0.0783115476,
-0.5015842319,
-0.8423544168,
-0.1296470165,
0.0146512398,
-0.3792734444,
-0.1836542338,
0.7621477246,
0.0239438303,
0.7487992048,
0.5875856876,
-0.0909917206,
-0.2850627601,
-0.0602412298,
0.8279008269,
-0.7158148289,
-0.7337734103,
-1.2614623308,
0.9108777642,
-0.0435375348,
-0.2431180477,
0.5442593694,
0.6152512431,
0.3297641277,
-0.1805984676,
0.8804680705,
-0.023106439,
0.515391469,
-0.594763577,
0.299462676,
-0.3393878341,
0.3256489635,
-0.3343360424,
-1.134011507,
-0.1385234892,
0.4217582047,
-0.2645296454,
-0.1151898652,
0.8742060065,
0.6860966682,
-0.0490505062,
0.0981019586,
0.083030574,
0.16194956,
0.6040979624,
0.7575340271,
1.0462851524,
-0.3009732962,
0.6148282886,
0.169203952,
-0.6146837473,
-0.1329592615,
-0.9917801619,
-0.9407252073,
-0.5007970929,
-0.3777756989,
-0.3245695829,
-0.2093857229,
1.2223051786,
0.6871007681,
-0.7304039598,
0.1751398146,
-0.2549023032,
0.3751315773,
-0.0685127899,
-0.2027266473,
0.097773768,
-0.7875654101,
-0.8540062308,
0.7213033438,
0.5278897882,
0.1025081575,
-0.0721087977,
-0.008713943,
0.0583645143,
0.141620189,
0.693752408,
0.2663892508,
-0.687651813,
-0.2846506238,
0.3455508947,
-0.1779392064,
-0.2681721747,
1.1135971546,
-0.5627571344,
0.4692492187,
0.947661221,
0.7245029211,
-0.1723740101,
-0.1588053107,
0.8706775308,
-0.4806733131,
-0.149475798,
0.2278641313,
0.5869400501,
0.0909074247,
-0.4938542247,
0.2951723337,
0.4022643268,
-0.7908063531,
-0.7250339985,
0.5247581601,
-0.9015945792,
-0.6062940955,
1.363740921,
-0.0707255006,
-0.0095036384,
-0.2853986621,
-0.8746324182,
0.0664460286,
-0.3687843084,
0.5124091506,
0.849621892,
-0.2784620523,
-0.3131510019,
-0.5257054567,
0.5652583241,
0.4449559152,
-0.8650259972,
0.0506565906,
0.4937055111,
0.2794686258,
0.3773545325,
0.604806304,
0.3825500906,
0.4488241971,
-0.0818177462,
-0.1820749938,
-0.1449565142,
-0.6545933485,
0.0611295141,
0.4081080556,
-0.0653444678,
-0.0952646509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05169v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05169v1
|
Large Language Models and Prompt Engineering for Biomedical Query Focused Multi-Document Summarisation
| 2023-11-09T06:45:04 | 2023-11-09T06:45:04 |
Diego Mollá
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper reports on the use of prompt engineering and GPT-3.5 for
biomedical query-focused multi-document summarisation. Using GPT-3.5 and
appropriate prompts, our system achieves top ROUGE-F1 results in the task of
obtaining short-paragraph-sized answers to biomedical questions in the 2023
BioASQ Challenge (BioASQ 11b). This paper confirms what has been observed in
other domains: 1) Prompts that incorporated few-shot samples generally improved
on their counterpart zero-shot variants; 2) The largest improvement was
achieved by retrieval augmented generation. The fact that these prompts allow
our top runs to rank within the top two runs of BioASQ 11b demonstrate the
power of using adequate prompts for Large Language Models in general, and
GPT-3.5 in particular, for query-focused summarisation.
|
[
-0.3764286339,
-0.9083930254,
0.9860418439,
0.2799422741,
-0.0272053462,
0.1670071185,
0.1327780783,
-0.523945868,
0.3615752161,
0.3955367506,
-0.5702717304,
-0.253865391,
-0.4624987841,
0.5897120237,
-0.214512974,
0.9157770872,
0.108825393,
0.2357379347,
-0.0479889996,
-0.2185744792,
-0.5283213854,
-0.7101760507,
-0.6276669502,
-0.0759328604,
0.8756031394,
0.2551047802,
0.4764406681,
0.3891220093,
0.6496136189,
0.2408058792,
-0.439250499,
0.1239323691,
-0.3107829094,
0.3167501986,
-0.1605762839,
-0.2186594605,
-0.7076526284,
0.0346845314,
0.557128191,
0.9135061502,
0.2809593081,
0.0710367709,
-0.0650686771,
0.5721979141,
-0.4792159498,
0.0587436892,
-0.2294275761,
-0.1887054294,
-0.0524977706,
-0.3077450395,
-0.6161259413,
-0.2734197378,
-0.1386601031,
-0.4210563004,
0.2191232145,
0.0992928296,
0.6886443496,
0.0743310302,
-0.5862016082,
-0.2619869709,
-0.3078001142,
0.5693656206,
-0.6103039384,
0.1302040666,
0.2457895577,
0.3005345166,
-0.0570732392,
-0.7610961795,
-0.2328408659,
-0.3292167783,
-0.1751942188,
0.174208045,
-0.0456425324,
0.301066339,
0.4648180306,
0.182600528,
-0.8910078406,
0.1396635473,
-0.5661777854,
-0.367870301,
0.6165574789,
0.430542022,
0.2169646472,
-0.1414435506,
-0.0016599095,
0.1364755034,
-0.9032852054,
-0.2110023946,
0.0891054049,
0.3801849782,
0.0557649583,
0.7005808949,
-0.4770247936,
0.7059659958,
0.0871746466,
0.0532267727,
0.2244622409,
-0.7172521353,
0.1315538883,
-0.0935324878,
0.7166445255,
0.3530709147,
0.0008018719,
0.09258838,
-0.1162345633,
-0.1869320124,
0.0125949467,
-1.1054936647,
-0.0029103914,
0.5942437053,
-0.4273980558,
-0.1882462353,
-0.252950877,
-0.6978387237,
-0.3617435992,
-0.0787449256,
0.4220040441,
-0.3113840818,
0.1256296933,
0.1549780667,
-0.463118732,
0.3489504158,
0.4986533523,
-0.8888239861,
-0.0588167794,
0.5049908757,
0.926620245,
-0.0292314272,
-0.3383218348,
-0.7476972342,
0.2264951766,
-0.2196497023,
1.167658329,
-0.4129004776,
-0.6457891464,
-0.170936048,
0.0746557713,
-0.0200545397,
-0.2683848143,
0.2720861435,
-0.4016486704,
0.4159919918,
-0.5116131902,
-0.4625101089,
-0.0942904577,
0.1806579828,
-0.5145087838,
0.6854218841,
0.0628475025,
-0.5650485754,
0.1823203415,
-0.9130737185,
-0.3874329031,
0.1945124269,
-0.0420421474,
-0.0975109339,
0.0024475374,
0.4139955044,
0.4431920648,
-0.2849684954,
0.1788423359,
-0.3810571134,
-0.2554844022,
0.0277120788,
-0.2139272541,
0.8972936273,
0.1315678358,
-0.1638399959,
0.3579958975,
-0.5983504057,
-0.1155991629,
0.1098900437,
-0.0470570587,
-0.0490329005,
-0.3983124495,
-0.0532820076,
0.2030127496,
0.2472671717,
-0.6008747816,
0.5667904019,
-0.3269901276,
0.4026252925,
0.4270733595,
0.4497641027,
0.356977433,
-0.3949580193,
0.8028809428,
-0.3157609701,
0.0152311418,
-0.7498512864,
-0.7741138339,
-0.0854483768,
-0.4407972991,
0.2411634624,
0.7473460436,
-0.680665791,
0.0191929415,
0.1041584015,
-0.5223189592,
-0.3376819491,
-0.3044729233,
0.1785233468,
0.7032670379,
0.6021766067,
0.0439067893,
-0.2662075758,
-0.9793882966,
-0.2005808055,
-0.2494556457,
-0.1316123754,
0.3123199344,
0.6866300702,
-0.0288387313,
0.6135231256,
-0.8202806711,
0.1185718253,
-0.5110794902,
0.444103092,
0.5107391477,
0.3839043975,
0.7941359878,
-0.6582553387,
-0.414940387,
-0.2849728167,
-0.8100942373,
-0.4011849761,
-0.1112496257,
-0.1123173386,
-0.0399803668,
0.6533026695,
-1.0333954096,
0.2572395205,
-0.0568343811,
-0.4413020015,
0.7907149196,
-0.1376345456,
0.5134318471,
-1.1557658911,
0.3272256851,
-0.0196763687,
-0.1832345128,
-0.585895896,
0.4071996808,
0.2568110228,
-0.4281615317,
-0.5827375054,
0.8711576462,
-0.5705448985,
0.0907429457,
-0.4289886951,
-0.0018608631,
0.2312903255,
0.2321747094,
-0.1290406585,
1.0359255075,
0.5310061574,
-0.5704141259,
0.3542404473,
0.4487632811,
0.11062897,
0.3695650399,
-1.0245701075,
0.0863465518,
-0.3054965138,
0.5528330207,
-1.0882788897,
-0.6346341968,
0.0050773257,
-0.6077643037,
0.3956199586,
0.2003930956,
-0.3736552,
-0.611217916,
-0.6260604262,
0.3882640302,
0.4252243936,
-0.3001627922,
0.4077265263,
0.2473120838,
-0.7629397511,
-0.5532226562,
-0.5982354879,
0.1969769299,
-0.1560483426,
-0.6666795611,
0.3253250122,
-0.2292081714,
-0.1158603653,
-0.2823387384,
0.0721274465,
0.0024249391,
0.1156671047,
-0.2319173217,
0.3743467033,
-0.2313373238,
0.0244027618,
0.0580197647,
-0.0465078801,
0.1094578952,
-0.0441935696,
0.4088260233,
0.0777907521,
-0.3124619126,
-0.3237889111,
0.9567671418,
0.6096499562,
-0.3282886744,
0.5982632041,
0.4723152518,
-0.3110168874,
0.2610835433,
-0.3938678801,
-0.457791388,
-0.4406814873,
0.4296626449,
-0.3960153759,
-1.0417096615,
0.811717093,
0.0797613785,
0.17283158,
0.643022716,
0.6687081456,
-0.1420407295,
1.3615784645,
0.5597612262,
0.0801896527,
0.2957907319,
-0.118712157,
0.003893669,
-0.6482785344,
-0.0432629399,
-0.868770957,
-0.0265677311,
-0.5095739961,
-0.0754481778,
0.8081129789,
0.1106281951,
-0.1272103935,
0.2392129451,
-0.4343469739,
0.4632616043,
0.5615369081,
0.1259656698,
0.1483062506,
-0.3995253742,
-0.1214808375,
0.3109958172,
-0.6650295854,
-0.3075115383,
0.951251626,
0.0813067704,
0.594263196,
0.1855324656,
0.7362305522,
0.063961193,
0.2406499088,
-0.8176937699,
0.5693380833,
0.2385129631,
-0.9262618423,
-0.3850969076,
-0.3840297163,
-1.1514369249,
0.1351688653,
0.0842299685,
-0.7721340656,
0.1331357062,
0.110637255,
-0.7774538994,
-0.1159059629,
-0.7513170838,
0.846308589,
0.0234596599,
-0.3283552825,
-0.0531195626,
-0.9756938815,
0.4030046463,
-0.0970937088,
0.1270346344,
0.0807600543,
-0.1515629143,
0.534735918,
-0.5116385221,
0.5959058404,
-0.1632163972,
-0.0294499565,
0.4319639206,
-0.2192113698,
0.4172726572,
0.102557227,
-0.0981557593,
-0.2630431354,
0.0853914246,
-0.7368784547,
-0.517390132,
0.4336594641,
-0.2391581833,
-0.8716179729,
-0.4559526742,
-0.5056075454,
-0.4137650728,
0.2747876048,
0.4063244462,
0.7359984517,
-0.0423053131,
0.1958663464,
0.6007680297,
-0.69859308,
0.6329059601,
0.6062068343,
-0.293495059,
-0.3990827799,
0.552677691,
0.2207552493,
0.3433844745,
0.5531613231,
0.0281724874,
-0.4457469583,
-0.6046077013,
-0.6358956099,
0.4283517003,
-0.5763842463,
-0.4831523299,
-0.92803514,
-0.1761264354,
-0.9467225075,
-0.2428354621,
-0.0370305628,
-0.606428802,
-0.1052493602,
-0.2175574899,
0.4567683339,
0.7782052159,
-0.2759682834,
0.3198075294,
-1.1780586243,
0.5697492957,
0.1913311929,
0.1215412617,
-0.2746116519,
-0.4458764195,
-0.2513909042,
-0.2361872345,
-0.4696858227,
-1.25837183,
0.3899611235,
0.0655630827,
0.5944152474,
-0.1359840035,
-0.2986760437,
0.3191174865,
-0.585151732,
1.1666642427,
0.0562473722,
-0.6144638658,
0.8277716637,
-0.9199935198,
0.6930757165,
0.5373700857,
0.6285892725,
-0.3332430422,
-0.3706408739,
-0.54384619,
-0.9870426059,
0.5478773117,
-0.0045139701,
-0.0943875611,
-0.3448505998,
0.3940557539,
0.0897338092,
0.0697588101,
-0.2476210296,
-0.3215427697,
0.122796692,
-0.1698660702,
0.0794797391,
-0.3335539997,
0.0654587224,
-0.0549931414,
0.7199642062,
-0.3691702187,
0.4065748453,
0.2294382006,
-0.042810984,
0.2019941658,
0.3639922142,
0.7672421932,
0.6729296446,
-0.40146029,
-0.3382720947,
0.0171673689,
-0.5927802324,
0.2681026459,
0.4283575118,
-0.3096986711,
0.053926371,
0.4887574017,
0.5132572055,
-0.0949670076,
-0.3987442255,
0.3947873712,
-0.0221885722,
-0.3141075075,
0.3701323569,
-0.1282678694,
0.0778127387,
0.0831016526,
0.6018591523,
-0.0587387271,
0.6331595778,
-0.5923891068,
0.2266688049,
0.3589806855,
-0.1187328473,
-0.2277413756,
0.9583407044,
0.1807284355,
0.0501056276,
0.299726814,
-0.2172899544,
-0.2402818203,
0.7194070816,
0.5424192548,
0.9021627307,
-0.3273853064,
0.3429487944,
0.562759459,
0.0504621901,
-0.2115740329,
0.7178735137,
0.2059099227,
-0.2588368654,
-0.8908675909,
-0.4479497075,
-0.7267696261,
0.1847779006,
-0.5662738085,
0.3138437569,
-0.0837198421,
-0.2307405025,
0.4164625406,
-0.2351722121,
-0.3086420894,
0.0885888711,
-0.1129484326,
0.9877402782,
-0.5948349833,
0.4424565136,
0.8455392122,
-0.80043751,
-0.834826231,
-0.2466175407,
0.1729310751,
-0.5069337487,
0.4239209592,
0.1972800344,
0.1679438055,
0.0853847489,
-0.7756803632,
-0.7890408635,
1.0069218874,
0.3681963682,
-0.2045789957,
-0.2622033358,
-0.2187880725,
0.4961952269,
-0.0692241937,
0.5152933598,
0.3971620798,
0.4880855083,
0.0721654743,
-1.1085920334,
-0.0136794643,
-0.3436777294,
-0.4710451365,
0.2410693169,
-0.7633467317,
0.7405698299,
-0.4048290849,
-0.0159509797,
0.414121896,
0.5958689451,
0.5887143612,
0.4166450799,
-0.1149629727,
0.1786667258,
0.7646881938,
-0.0977694914,
1.4737141132,
-0.381372124,
0.1664355248,
0.9827172756,
-0.2674739957,
0.4442830384,
0.2307490259,
-0.2767936885,
-0.0223544277,
0.6996159554,
0.2691185176,
0.348567754,
-0.0256832428,
-0.1977903545,
-0.0001104047,
-0.2893015146,
-0.7965251803,
0.2710815668,
0.4198163152,
-0.1833173335,
-0.2320223451,
0.1590230167,
-0.0714060441,
-0.2937041819,
-0.4425201416,
0.8727630973,
0.1217475384,
-0.6992637515,
0.5607571006,
-0.0024659948,
0.4462355375,
-0.5337405801,
-0.0732813105,
-0.5978038907,
-0.1932091862,
0.107983917,
-0.8450443745,
0.2760023177,
0.0784245878,
-0.1299016923,
-0.3486029506,
0.8036597967,
-0.2425550669,
-0.4185426235,
-0.0687218085,
0.7701482773,
0.1896063685,
-0.2225679159,
-0.5539712906,
-0.2919051349,
-0.114304699,
-0.4427305162,
0.343708396,
0.6425567269,
-0.0734871104,
0.5659849048,
0.4161884189,
0.1933025271,
-0.0860409215,
0.3158747554,
0.7941157222,
-0.9622950554,
-0.4809715152,
-0.8661723733,
0.4106267691,
-0.0398640707,
-0.2717418075,
0.6078705788,
0.6743400097,
0.19828026,
-0.2124131471,
0.8223414421,
0.0395074189,
0.8374714255,
-0.5434823036,
0.5477997661,
-0.4288080931,
-0.0300148278,
-0.3449382186,
-0.9473565817,
-0.5324815512,
0.1530390829,
-0.1130606011,
0.1496639401,
0.9450172186,
0.8486982584,
0.2193639129,
0.1101978347,
0.2039532959,
0.2571464479,
0.4378923774,
0.4034315646,
0.7491921186,
-0.4017398953,
0.377302736,
0.0875561908,
-0.2907604873,
-0.2134316117,
-0.6974901557,
-0.7171416283,
-0.4596366286,
-0.1668785661,
-0.4377422035,
0.0902803913,
0.8481810689,
0.4544464648,
-0.8626109958,
0.1079135239,
0.206417948,
-0.052894108,
-0.027223926,
-0.1994949132,
0.4127953947,
-0.5738972425,
-0.6009528637,
0.5963941216,
0.6126874089,
0.271443814,
-0.1152718812,
0.1834021807,
-0.365508914,
0.0778845698,
0.7914554477,
0.4216999114,
-0.3450518847,
-0.2426058352,
0.4396051764,
-0.2167972028,
-0.0529499166,
0.7752470374,
-0.7989422679,
-0.0751525164,
0.7289007902,
0.7786953449,
0.4792765379,
0.1726079583,
0.7438318729,
-0.6220206022,
0.0992507339,
0.2950258851,
0.4326521158,
0.3550027907,
-0.4580141008,
0.7238428593,
0.3214127123,
-0.7631623745,
-0.7449368834,
0.119091168,
-1.0586740971,
-0.3749349713,
1.3504332304,
0.1704747975,
-0.2225108147,
-0.174142167,
-0.5359749794,
0.1115156561,
-0.4268555343,
0.513032496,
0.7913115025,
-0.5469416976,
-0.1293512136,
-0.6720296741,
0.4678408504,
0.4972789288,
-1.0850696564,
-0.0605680458,
0.8198296428,
-0.1374997348,
0.1230928227,
0.956060648,
-0.2791528404,
0.4259794652,
0.0235814415,
-0.2605898082,
0.0494786464,
-0.3386949599,
-0.2976281047,
0.4621654153,
-0.0617759824,
0.1077584997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05161v1
|
Enhancing Computation Efficiency in Large Language Models through Weight and Activation Quantization
| 2023-11-09T06:19:51 | 2023-11-09T06:19:51 |
Jangwhan Lee, Minsoo Kim, Seungcheol Baek, Seok Joong Hwang, Wonyong Sung, Jungwook Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are proficient in natural language processing
tasks, but their deployment is often restricted by extensive parameter sizes
and computational demands. This paper focuses on post-training quantization
(PTQ) in LLMs, specifically 4-bit weight and 8-bit activation (W4A8)
quantization, to enhance computational efficiency -- a topic less explored
compared to weight-only quantization. We present two innovative techniques:
activation-quantization-aware scaling (AQAS) and sequence-length-aware
calibration (SLAC) to enhance PTQ by considering the combined effects on
weights and activations and aligning calibration sequence lengths to target
tasks. Moreover, we introduce dINT, a hybrid data format combining integer and
denormal representations, to address the underflow issue in W4A8 quantization,
where small values are rounded to zero. Through rigorous evaluations of LLMs,
including OPT and LLaMA, we demonstrate that our techniques significantly boost
task accuracies to levels comparable with full-precision models. By developing
arithmetic units compatible with dINT, we further confirm that our methods
yield a 2$\times$ hardware efficiency improvement compared to 8-bit integer MAC
unit.
|
[
-0.1471786201,
-0.5056579113,
0.6462945342,
0.0888433903,
-0.438878417,
0.2793110609,
-0.2820880115,
-0.154483974,
0.0392219722,
0.3382372558,
0.018521158,
-0.236421451,
-0.6456618309,
0.0063383826,
-0.2034522742,
0.5958907008,
-0.0702314377,
0.0981622338,
-0.2865078151,
-0.285520345,
-0.1874011457,
-0.8134205937,
-0.6871467829,
-0.2570658922,
0.4064480364,
0.0700633973,
0.7251973152,
0.6270930171,
0.5168020129,
0.3385941684,
-0.04381961,
0.1481317878,
-0.4204116166,
-0.0496528186,
0.2768262327,
-0.5890555978,
-0.784368515,
-0.2689048052,
0.9613062143,
0.7826365829,
-0.2057641149,
0.1549843103,
-0.1292230785,
0.8213658333,
-0.9106384516,
0.2421113253,
-0.5348628163,
-0.1491339207,
-0.2134561688,
-0.2135926932,
-0.3197341561,
-0.4236306846,
-0.2100562155,
-0.7826440334,
-0.3041681051,
-0.2887845635,
0.3906901181,
0.440862745,
-0.538523674,
0.0047975518,
-0.6979237795,
0.9253488779,
-1.2160288095,
0.5810595155,
0.3192531168,
-0.0584318079,
0.1679000258,
-0.6888765097,
-0.4682041705,
-0.0330176353,
0.172939226,
-0.1852266788,
-0.2089402527,
0.4085277319,
0.6948326826,
0.5981593132,
-0.4355120659,
0.2533429265,
-0.1858124137,
-0.1044994667,
0.5223466754,
0.0527707823,
0.0998554155,
0.2907227278,
0.0288163703,
-0.1259170175,
-0.8591979742,
-0.0035936735,
0.4198208153,
0.0921429023,
0.0140102133,
0.6216657758,
-0.4022446275,
0.7963525057,
0.0721056983,
-0.058281973,
0.444689095,
-0.3253326118,
-0.3640687168,
0.0322424695,
0.6146797538,
-0.0433590189,
0.0777146742,
-0.2034209818,
-0.5518927574,
0.1810706109,
0.2316576988,
-1.2452350855,
-0.1453223974,
0.1462928206,
-0.1900663674,
-0.202515021,
-0.2153249681,
-0.1922873855,
-0.3379080296,
-0.5520945191,
0.9359376431,
-0.4170754552,
-0.2681352198,
0.3421274424,
0.0358480625,
0.2080034763,
0.3441943526,
-1.0309342146,
0.3002395928,
0.7798708677,
0.7275693417,
0.087775521,
0.2516769767,
-0.7995055318,
0.0588676669,
-0.5013664961,
0.3938954473,
-0.3447593451,
0.0876772478,
-0.2177901119,
-0.5558487177,
0.0081011374,
-0.4399383068,
0.379244566,
-0.9348329306,
-0.221441254,
-0.3309018612,
-0.5459291935,
-0.2533140779,
0.1666693836,
-0.8592002392,
1.1535297632,
0.0744378865,
-0.7555265427,
0.2330334932,
-0.7759755254,
-0.5747255683,
0.2812421024,
0.0131361419,
-0.3299173117,
0.529722631,
0.227151826,
0.3351697624,
-0.3889253139,
0.1302874237,
-0.0592212677,
-0.6582500935,
0.1989401728,
-0.4981407821,
0.606063962,
-0.0078343116,
-0.3492894471,
0.1293253601,
-0.7386406064,
0.2472562045,
-0.0770946741,
-0.5084956288,
-0.4130752087,
-0.1817730665,
-0.3829988241,
0.0379228443,
0.4970713258,
-0.4916167259,
0.2005040944,
-0.679859817,
0.6375217438,
0.4391344786,
-0.2042801827,
0.5770052075,
-0.2441015989,
0.5148711205,
-0.1905401796,
-0.1497076899,
-0.0782119408,
-0.1647749692,
-0.7514306307,
-0.4154557884,
0.6306325793,
0.4612858295,
-1.0663405657,
0.3901937306,
-0.5555613041,
-0.4200216532,
-0.5481401682,
0.1496046633,
0.2171034068,
0.1331374347,
0.205691129,
-0.5250709057,
-0.53297472,
-0.6042430997,
-0.0854143798,
0.0000192565,
-0.3216079473,
-0.0161537919,
0.1842019409,
-0.0653386116,
0.6901546717,
-0.29186517,
0.090889439,
-0.2377438694,
0.4822870791,
0.2058533579,
0.4401979446,
0.1426577568,
-0.7908579707,
-0.4751390517,
-0.0512919053,
-0.4880179763,
-0.2592546642,
-0.0093415063,
-0.0149591649,
0.1885771006,
0.4517768323,
-0.6270799041,
0.3397428989,
0.6493512988,
0.0608607978,
0.5088742375,
-0.2475893945,
0.2583653629,
-0.7334970832,
0.0842043757,
-0.11679212,
-0.4242897928,
-0.8773958087,
-0.0667890161,
0.2938961983,
-0.010142698,
-0.4331662953,
0.31436342,
-0.5369178057,
-0.3087364733,
-0.3337531984,
-0.1253316104,
0.2446712255,
0.4801518619,
0.013054559,
1.0606597662,
0.4377102256,
-0.4354138672,
0.3020617068,
-0.238624543,
-0.2239025384,
0.3600647748,
-0.6382240057,
0.1869298369,
-0.0024364251,
0.2324181199,
-0.7774227262,
0.1703805327,
-0.2870564759,
-0.2078986168,
0.1785782278,
0.0270547383,
-0.9971684813,
-0.1000141203,
-0.6643473506,
1.0195608139,
0.5320422649,
-0.2599813342,
0.6649637818,
0.2540432811,
0.1172852591,
-0.1920341998,
-0.6318022013,
0.0229481682,
-0.3143897951,
-0.5075432658,
0.5430086255,
-0.0530037396,
-0.1655733287,
-0.2872245312,
-0.1556386948,
-0.104472734,
0.1327744722,
-0.0449558049,
0.0568274222,
-0.3260983527,
0.1190487742,
0.0279512368,
-0.0242360979,
0.0211654752,
-0.373080194,
0.7413765788,
-0.1715318561,
-0.1433789879,
-0.5540969372,
0.1192458048,
0.5327749848,
-0.4957362711,
0.6905865669,
0.7609124184,
-0.522192359,
0.0282433964,
-0.6089299321,
-0.2611492276,
-0.4970318973,
0.2403305471,
-0.3486566842,
-0.9233191609,
0.280159682,
-0.1922708303,
0.2338835448,
0.337248385,
0.7115064859,
0.1972386688,
1.0827943087,
0.5427246094,
0.0141414646,
0.7141900659,
-0.4422069192,
0.345892638,
-1.1390329599,
0.2957154214,
-0.1909981221,
-0.4013824165,
-0.2986175418,
-0.8843380213,
0.538199544,
0.188682422,
-0.3643144369,
0.3919509351,
-0.2293907553,
0.3344161212,
0.5939376354,
0.0622207671,
0.4423440099,
-0.0173596442,
0.0419031903,
-0.1334618479,
-0.7417294383,
-0.2313578576,
1.2468914986,
0.2388173938,
0.6801252365,
0.0415733494,
0.5777605176,
0.2467312366,
0.2422946244,
-0.8477792144,
0.5000267625,
-0.305373013,
-0.1500447839,
-0.4823067188,
-0.7917358279,
-0.7388582826,
0.3312259912,
-0.1198605895,
-0.5519477725,
-0.0137874046,
0.1794410199,
-0.6339862347,
0.2823032737,
-0.690748632,
0.8290080428,
-0.3366671503,
-0.260171473,
-0.4155664742,
-0.3094834983,
0.37129426,
-0.2714161277,
0.2042187601,
-0.0364060961,
-0.3706858754,
0.8495334983,
-0.5217648745,
0.7172587514,
-0.0692803189,
-0.2695659995,
0.1544053108,
0.0048725228,
0.6168277264,
-0.2191758603,
-0.2711780667,
0.1633745879,
-0.0121805035,
-0.3459522128,
-0.7741051912,
0.5641987324,
-0.5231915116,
-0.2972817123,
-0.1565098912,
-0.8843345642,
-0.4689994454,
0.1290479898,
-0.1369885653,
0.6931016445,
0.2781078517,
0.4256337285,
0.785222888,
-0.0510347933,
0.3945958614,
0.3402724564,
0.1741116494,
-0.583102107,
0.9301785827,
0.2566045225,
0.6289520264,
0.6904495358,
0.127801314,
-0.3408181071,
-0.6058510542,
-0.4212872088,
0.2206381559,
-0.4888348579,
-0.5601856112,
-0.5788369775,
-0.3158290982,
-0.5503637791,
-0.0163490009,
-0.3927073479,
-0.7516576052,
-0.2962274253,
0.0132365432,
0.4827339053,
0.2831489742,
-0.1158475727,
0.7205792665,
-0.7342582345,
0.4398121834,
0.3320605755,
0.3040371239,
0.2243094146,
-0.6127581,
-0.6059131026,
0.165176332,
-0.3486910462,
-0.6040766239,
0.3319788575,
0.3253925443,
0.1069032848,
0.3265869617,
-0.0462138355,
0.6871442795,
-0.3452858329,
0.5281680822,
0.0837453306,
-1.1306362152,
0.0367533676,
-0.1290979236,
0.5630377531,
0.4597943127,
0.3414885402,
-0.4524139762,
-0.1269151121,
-0.4300623238,
-0.9523198605,
0.492824316,
0.210330829,
0.1893496662,
0.3836945891,
0.3566429019,
-0.3361046612,
0.5923150182,
-0.706078589,
0.0090766568,
0.0651292279,
-0.3964173198,
0.1107107997,
-0.2522301376,
0.126278311,
-0.3268448114,
0.6491296291,
-0.282343179,
0.0566386245,
-0.1546132863,
-0.3147293627,
-0.084222272,
0.2685441077,
0.185142234,
0.6959105134,
0.0001002079,
0.239312619,
0.2623211443,
-0.4532210231,
0.1067583561,
0.2214726955,
-0.157534942,
-0.36941275,
0.3298577964,
0.9171158075,
0.5625906587,
-0.6655691862,
0.4945313931,
-0.0309984684,
-0.0957518816,
0.0790121555,
-0.0455429517,
0.0984580144,
0.1249271855,
0.3903524876,
-0.419934094,
0.3429328501,
-0.3639249206,
0.0706480965,
0.6665992141,
0.0679311603,
-0.3581549823,
0.573618412,
0.0494746864,
0.0461599194,
0.550860405,
-0.3572199047,
-0.6307907104,
0.4427621663,
0.3938188851,
0.7023102045,
-0.0798628107,
0.0183550678,
0.3221544921,
0.2667376995,
-0.1026995108,
0.3568014801,
-0.3659422398,
-0.7039544582,
-0.9589141011,
-0.8773075342,
-0.3155067861,
0.1073546186,
-0.4175628424,
0.0841370299,
-0.4235953689,
-0.1995779723,
-0.0999028832,
0.3724530041,
-0.6238052249,
0.1919012964,
0.2815237939,
0.6769965291,
-0.7049098015,
0.8700994253,
0.5570471287,
-0.0102110226,
-0.8747919798,
-0.373778522,
-0.2622141838,
-0.5618929267,
0.424539566,
0.234817028,
0.1330275685,
0.3851563931,
-0.1135002375,
-1.009447217,
1.14100492,
0.4751235545,
-0.6369732618,
-0.1451693922,
0.4848273695,
0.5387362838,
-0.081319958,
0.3185484409,
0.8149647117,
0.4015443921,
0.1913199872,
-0.8896903396,
0.1577220857,
-0.0092069563,
0.235035181,
0.5473089814,
-0.4284911752,
0.7270243764,
0.0085026389,
0.0142861232,
-0.0234691277,
0.7043300271,
0.268643707,
-0.1298489124,
0.6812154055,
0.9380920529,
0.6833145022,
0.0150643261,
0.8877064586,
-0.3496224582,
0.0484519936,
0.7202439904,
-0.2523053288,
0.8292469382,
0.4251182675,
-0.3006693721,
0.4316284955,
0.4444060922,
0.316994071,
0.2839525044,
0.4271904528,
-0.6365941167,
-0.3295626342,
-0.0616061836,
-0.0457535014,
0.1756973118,
0.4366005957,
0.041690506,
-0.1036678776,
0.0836247802,
-0.0483489148,
-0.2442503124,
-0.5317450166,
0.8855440021,
0.1932322681,
-0.3707003891,
0.8130756617,
0.1453740895,
0.8203550577,
-0.5974311233,
-0.027698366,
-0.0849442333,
0.043200817,
-0.1634102315,
-0.3852327466,
0.1847625375,
-0.0045637335,
-0.1015705243,
-0.357886672,
0.4714953899,
-0.4248936474,
-0.6960932612,
-0.1637112349,
0.3518343568,
0.0100014824,
-0.5679777861,
-0.4248487353,
0.3805141151,
-0.1327848881,
-0.2663924992,
0.4341081679,
0.6682565212,
-0.2300070077,
0.4132002592,
0.75019449,
0.4206424654,
0.2681671977,
0.2226390839,
0.96374017,
-0.4341901839,
-0.3205742538,
-0.8093048334,
0.4144179225,
0.105938457,
0.0619073138,
0.5470841527,
0.6850275993,
0.552231431,
0.273109585,
0.4871192276,
-0.0613969192,
0.1593685597,
-0.5147703886,
0.3956623375,
-0.5715319514,
0.3038182259,
-0.0301066823,
-0.854316175,
-0.4796250761,
0.4624678493,
-0.562220037,
0.0287918001,
0.4781184494,
0.6363211274,
-0.0399058908,
-0.3764873147,
0.3566081822,
0.1236270741,
0.3535376489,
0.7241690755,
0.366928339,
-0.47263062,
0.4373130798,
-0.3999969661,
-0.3810062706,
-0.1140653864,
-0.8981015086,
-0.5622071028,
-0.4530612528,
-0.3902615607,
0.0653344318,
-0.124335371,
0.6760411859,
0.9308513999,
-0.5116299987,
-0.3609070182,
-0.1024740338,
-0.1348522753,
-0.181577906,
-0.199461475,
0.4312550128,
-0.4346253276,
-0.6135323644,
0.2943122089,
0.2996015251,
0.0634870604,
-0.354419142,
-0.0055170422,
0.0426689088,
0.2260665148,
0.8766118288,
0.1794598848,
-0.3556163013,
0.1476166993,
-0.214640677,
-0.0886232257,
0.2222244442,
0.9531984329,
-1.0324113369,
0.2088338435,
0.560805738,
0.97049582,
0.5600838065,
0.3335785866,
0.6962844729,
-0.7366953492,
0.1971962005,
0.5326690674,
0.2033577859,
0.5911664963,
-0.3052440286,
0.3555936813,
0.0374403745,
-0.5529401898,
-0.945086956,
-0.0038282035,
-0.7738146186,
0.1542845517,
1.0546859503,
0.0480427966,
-0.1923499554,
0.3424965441,
-0.0683144182,
0.2719543576,
-0.3884093463,
0.527253449,
0.480149895,
-0.0885012597,
-0.1292770654,
-0.6994349957,
0.5681497455,
0.62356776,
-0.9618210196,
0.1945254058,
0.4012907743,
-0.0612377711,
-0.1046936437,
0.7386020422,
-0.13555336,
0.2706466019,
-0.2477698475,
0.1223203242,
0.0248561725,
-0.0336285271,
-0.493003875,
-0.1510974616,
0.3001102507,
0.0625125244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07589v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07589v1
|
Dialogizer: Context-aware Conversational-QA Dataset Generation from Textual Sources
| 2023-11-09T06:03:11 | 2023-11-09T06:03:11 |
Yerin Hwang, Yongil Kim, Hyunkyung Bae, Jeesoo Bang, Hwanhee Lee, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To address the data scarcity issue in Conversational question answering
(ConvQA), a dialog inpainting method, which utilizes documents to generate
ConvQA datasets, has been proposed. However, the original dialog inpainting
model is trained solely on the dialog reconstruction task, resulting in the
generation of questions with low contextual relevance due to insufficient
learning of question-answer alignment. To overcome this limitation, we propose
a novel framework called Dialogizer, which has the capability to automatically
generate ConvQA datasets with high contextual relevance from textual sources.
The framework incorporates two training tasks: question-answer matching (QAM)
and topic-aware dialog generation (TDG). Moreover, re-ranking is conducted
during the inference phase based on the contextual relevance of the generated
questions. Using our framework, we produce four ConvQA datasets by utilizing
documents from multiple domains as the primary source. Through automatic
evaluation using diverse metrics, as well as human evaluation, we validate that
our proposed framework exhibits the ability to generate datasets of higher
quality compared to the baseline dialog inpainting model.
|
[
-0.3561117351,
-0.9159141183,
0.4026990533,
-0.2218441814,
-0.1779929399,
0.0460577905,
0.1978663802,
-0.1084607616,
0.0548971854,
0.7626659274,
-0.8579567671,
-0.2509891093,
-0.0390269198,
0.06665539,
-0.3203978837,
0.8273548484,
0.2929213345,
0.1033095866,
-0.7638164759,
-0.0925678536,
-0.9729360938,
-0.3313910365,
-0.5791589618,
-0.2238862962,
-0.1066553146,
0.68266958,
0.6594875455,
0.2165614814,
0.0548790954,
0.2701376677,
0.0611989386,
0.3547531068,
-0.5747757554,
0.3463056087,
0.163261205,
-0.3073977232,
-0.0886799768,
-0.0776085779,
0.4420165122,
0.4663997293,
-0.0478155427,
0.2787294388,
0.1322829425,
0.3963440061,
-0.4295161963,
-0.1185567379,
-0.9015666246,
-0.0463281833,
0.1566886902,
-0.5864841938,
-0.2901064456,
-0.6346874833,
0.5665222406,
-0.8493570685,
0.3635829091,
-0.1022737473,
0.6909348369,
0.3888540864,
-0.6320219636,
-0.4207690954,
-0.4793209732,
0.7043355703,
-0.7638941407,
0.1102444828,
0.3975339532,
0.4988963306,
-0.2899677753,
-0.6499035954,
-0.6235526204,
0.0767957643,
-0.1409891844,
0.2097755522,
0.1072021127,
0.0369786657,
0.1612146348,
0.3616044223,
-0.7704925537,
-0.4767882228,
-0.0706468895,
-0.2917065024,
0.3688554168,
0.4329896271,
0.4711831212,
-0.3037536144,
-0.2847002745,
0.0837459788,
-0.5180032253,
0.1885069311,
-0.0351829827,
0.0844975263,
0.2830791175,
0.3030708432,
-0.492430687,
0.7467955947,
0.3234290183,
-0.2021015584,
0.2322324961,
-0.6017658114,
-0.3559908867,
0.1617956907,
0.6238456964,
0.6944232583,
-0.109696582,
-0.0801638663,
0.2012492418,
-0.3335973918,
0.2567247152,
-1.2113420963,
0.0097151184,
0.5691536069,
-0.2015382648,
-0.3156742454,
-0.1668289453,
-0.697065413,
-0.3084159493,
-0.3436998725,
0.2479569018,
-0.3670191467,
-0.0202233065,
0.0005331496,
-0.1127059385,
0.200944677,
0.5685793757,
-0.6364879012,
-0.0103927217,
0.4785930216,
0.4599928558,
0.0646929219,
0.2743096054,
-0.6938892007,
0.0383219048,
-0.2802909911,
0.6678373814,
-0.5229067206,
-0.4801626503,
0.2820608318,
0.0064790654,
0.0255314577,
-0.7839379907,
0.4520814717,
-0.7122250795,
0.8377018571,
-0.2503859997,
-0.8308489323,
-0.2084589303,
0.5300168395,
-0.482370168,
1.0791198015,
0.2730257511,
-0.6200538874,
0.4129864573,
-0.304438144,
0.0420235991,
0.5087742805,
-0.3179443479,
-0.3893281817,
-0.3015472591,
0.314540565,
0.3349955082,
-0.5415430069,
0.626382947,
0.0642832443,
-0.4301259816,
0.4470195472,
-0.4285247922,
0.7733006477,
0.0617418736,
-0.167778194,
0.140349865,
-0.7621951699,
0.3222156167,
-0.179345116,
-0.3604447246,
-0.2402513772,
-0.1663560122,
0.1673691124,
0.3918293118,
0.2312511951,
-0.7244423628,
-0.0162239838,
-0.4257480204,
0.2911192775,
0.4400663078,
0.6284610629,
0.4614332318,
-0.5098485947,
0.7492319942,
-0.028889982,
0.0699448287,
-0.4280819297,
-0.4649721682,
-0.7852421403,
-0.2842994332,
0.1943494081,
0.6837203503,
-1.2164142132,
0.4555037022,
-0.377410084,
-0.5491230488,
-0.3962844908,
0.1148832962,
0.5330847502,
0.9227508307,
0.1169215217,
-0.3285266459,
-0.4177081287,
-0.7513189316,
0.0967896059,
-0.1892244071,
-0.1425208151,
0.4820149243,
0.1669160426,
-0.0241531916,
1.3736473322,
-0.3496573865,
-0.249619022,
-0.0043788645,
0.0353085138,
0.0039677829,
0.5831042528,
0.5544912219,
-0.9224181175,
-0.4960209727,
-0.2205189019,
-0.8399791718,
-0.1783489138,
-0.1861373633,
-0.4342759252,
-0.1188725084,
0.4957139194,
-0.4851593673,
0.1857717931,
0.3468144834,
-0.3179400563,
0.4601316154,
0.2324317098,
0.3997785151,
-1.5807044506,
0.0206553508,
-0.0919401348,
-0.3894526362,
-0.9081565738,
-0.2524770796,
-0.2340031415,
-0.6630017757,
-0.5427271724,
0.7754493952,
-0.0088579766,
0.2771819234,
-0.1344665587,
0.2116475254,
0.3175318837,
0.7750347853,
0.0306193866,
0.9448949099,
0.205765292,
-0.3829872608,
0.2610947192,
0.8697594404,
-0.4663733244,
0.7039515972,
-0.6791966558,
0.1909111142,
-0.0712240636,
0.4182471335,
-1.1097146273,
-0.323319912,
0.4657082856,
-0.3781749606,
-0.0774284825,
-0.3221251369,
-0.2926591039,
0.0528617315,
-0.2208553404,
0.5839059353,
0.2383299023,
-0.4585681856,
0.5146709681,
0.4393317103,
-0.452224195,
-0.5044582486,
-0.3118616343,
-0.0460647158,
-0.3146602213,
-0.6920882463,
0.1492969543,
-0.4276660383,
0.0686638132,
-0.3732578158,
-0.1381426901,
-0.2007672191,
-0.0249517187,
0.3449814916,
0.1782695353,
-0.0187250841,
0.4647719562,
0.196215421,
-0.0794671625,
0.0550554581,
-0.1867469698,
0.4367756844,
0.2526953518,
-0.2045656443,
-0.7299680114,
0.5226536989,
0.5313024521,
-0.2916681767,
0.2247962356,
0.1276365072,
-0.3224285543,
0.0163045861,
-0.470292598,
-0.1753724515,
-0.4885397851,
0.2273581028,
-0.429966867,
-1.0555106401,
0.3409487009,
-0.134707436,
0.250192523,
0.0445908494,
0.618088007,
-0.0955928266,
0.7863070965,
0.1815968454,
0.0714285448,
0.8572244644,
-0.2156615406,
0.0203922037,
-0.5975374579,
-0.0018296494,
-0.4291399121,
0.079797484,
-0.5099341869,
-0.4481412172,
0.407446444,
-0.3371318579,
-0.1801431328,
0.0591176338,
-0.6082681417,
0.3287307024,
0.5272011161,
0.2259831429,
0.3045656681,
-0.0470863134,
0.4092690647,
-0.0633865893,
-0.6919580102,
-0.8623617887,
1.1590803862,
0.0312875882,
0.2271027118,
0.0238399319,
0.5343708992,
0.3232560158,
0.3588472009,
-0.6593700051,
0.5916687846,
0.3292331994,
-0.7167897224,
-0.4785339236,
-0.5050728917,
-0.8091598749,
0.3408585787,
-0.3041900098,
-0.6048263907,
0.426100105,
0.240912959,
-0.4466813803,
-0.2887370884,
-0.5523341298,
1.0522575378,
0.1694721282,
-0.1917969733,
-0.0024112114,
-0.5352372527,
0.2979512811,
-0.1090165228,
-0.1514431834,
-0.2487601042,
0.3647057712,
0.6415303946,
-0.6305474043,
0.7205526233,
-0.4046119452,
-0.2245335281,
0.6887511611,
0.1356927902,
0.327393055,
0.4996294975,
-0.1842864454,
-0.1946549267,
0.1546267271,
-0.5038325191,
-0.8024637699,
0.4041678309,
-0.4441311359,
-0.6039600372,
-0.0840812102,
-0.7001708746,
-0.5251423717,
0.0522198379,
0.3368808925,
0.931032896,
-0.6177788377,
0.1895245463,
0.8372257948,
-0.2123675942,
0.0983749181,
0.3953453004,
0.0327129625,
-0.4011486471,
0.9606993794,
-0.0808012336,
0.2834317088,
0.4672943652,
-0.2658962011,
0.013814196,
-0.3408231437,
-0.6693331003,
-0.2613729537,
-0.5773549676,
-0.3488574028,
-0.6538381577,
-0.2544229925,
-0.0960172191,
-0.2369585335,
-0.0683037937,
-0.3729304969,
-0.2908720672,
0.1521077901,
0.2244820446,
0.0943347365,
0.6787711978,
0.5001134872,
-0.7508001328,
0.2884949446,
0.8712317944,
-0.177609846,
-0.2189774513,
-0.5265846848,
-0.3608047962,
0.3202396631,
-0.500746727,
-0.6389815807,
0.2615713179,
0.2571144104,
0.1964132339,
0.1472114623,
0.0657363459,
0.4691079557,
-0.2855176926,
0.9547655582,
0.0403909534,
-0.7236120701,
0.5342718363,
-0.494574219,
0.5067104697,
1.012439847,
-0.1035009176,
-0.6563250422,
-0.568494916,
-0.5488267541,
-0.8351022601,
0.6209903955,
0.3346110284,
0.4104317129,
0.0535397381,
0.3309154809,
0.4156698883,
0.3649476767,
-0.2324131876,
0.0999191329,
-0.3794175386,
-0.5044721961,
0.1328615993,
-0.2542465329,
-0.1632682234,
0.0249043051,
0.9180345535,
-0.5232192278,
0.263417691,
0.2575040758,
-0.2651358843,
-0.0049814787,
0.366293788,
0.2953738868,
0.6595129371,
-0.433804363,
-0.4512628317,
0.0086386092,
-0.3267790079,
0.3425204456,
0.1477610916,
-0.5749224424,
0.2533655465,
-0.0355970785,
0.6890226603,
0.0378665105,
-0.9867558479,
0.5217160583,
-0.5027105808,
-0.0471448712,
-0.4973601103,
0.1805687547,
-0.1245129779,
0.1810425371,
0.3543266952,
-0.1657613367,
0.4939770103,
-0.2950820625,
0.2511341572,
0.4128466845,
-0.4269084632,
0.0507187657,
0.5468726754,
0.5616364479,
-0.2024805397,
0.6943672299,
-0.0929610655,
-0.2762416005,
0.6655598879,
0.0866007134,
0.8456017375,
0.0467374958,
0.4898272455,
0.4270604551,
-0.1777963787,
0.392326355,
0.3460990787,
-0.3961988688,
-0.8434753418,
-0.2048825622,
-0.2708823383,
-0.6681143045,
0.138991192,
-0.552149117,
-0.0860109106,
-0.0990580171,
-0.2634448707,
-0.1081280038,
0.0845851153,
-0.591876924,
0.5116667747,
-0.2076717913,
0.6852706671,
-0.6568093896,
0.5325431824,
0.5643851757,
-0.362610817,
-0.4417134523,
0.3632266223,
-0.0391846746,
-0.3619328737,
0.2638596892,
0.2537228167,
0.0707331598,
0.088228479,
-0.5370230079,
-0.6741552949,
1.3287067413,
0.4878744185,
-0.2656786442,
0.0752813667,
0.2834458351,
0.4672801793,
-0.5635989904,
0.270802021,
0.5143019557,
0.0521463193,
0.0344687738,
-0.6358962059,
0.1436706185,
-0.7784495354,
0.2207646072,
-0.0204777755,
-0.6582078338,
0.1043946519,
0.4390853643,
-0.3119442761,
0.4303167462,
0.6884474754,
0.2876639664,
0.3440389633,
0.4108088315,
0.3162757456,
0.7028262615,
-0.1995602995,
0.7531876564,
-0.4486022294,
0.100665994,
1.3982332945,
-0.1381607056,
0.391700685,
0.4630068839,
0.4038113654,
0.4086555541,
0.7361148596,
0.1891839802,
0.6242485642,
0.0611149073,
-0.4736961424,
-0.2517763674,
-0.549785316,
-0.1288839728,
0.4803679883,
0.2416653335,
-0.2394727468,
-0.078223899,
0.0349006131,
-0.1454824954,
0.0629750416,
0.1054362357,
1.0338206291,
-0.3179821074,
-0.801188767,
0.7386087179,
-0.4114330113,
0.3839883804,
-0.3955097497,
-0.2128981799,
-0.4881569743,
-0.3183958232,
0.0312315281,
-0.6221908331,
-0.0070778406,
-0.0863145888,
-0.2470531762,
-0.3145860434,
0.5690282583,
-0.7038263083,
-0.1439666897,
-0.3460669816,
0.7017129064,
0.1327609122,
-0.04561425,
-0.6068077683,
-0.3548635542,
0.1122150272,
-0.3711436391,
0.1787478179,
0.5556295514,
-0.1573624313,
0.5853381157,
0.5369139314,
-0.5440018773,
-0.0906085894,
0.0917268172,
0.9006852508,
-0.3105507195,
-0.4296474159,
-0.1313046813,
0.8028227091,
-0.2685801089,
-0.6080124378,
0.4220865071,
0.7046223283,
0.6457419395,
0.0138919819,
0.9226105213,
0.0088282749,
0.4545163214,
-0.4399430752,
0.6247364283,
-0.453117907,
0.1022636518,
-0.2168326825,
-0.8952250481,
0.1507710218,
0.1785492599,
-0.0593389757,
-0.1592518985,
0.2614165545,
1.1298393011,
0.1242126897,
0.0984586552,
0.2596130371,
-0.1936570108,
0.4142905474,
0.5841065049,
0.7100143433,
-0.7164233923,
0.5911822319,
0.0077249748,
-0.2158376426,
-0.2360491753,
-0.4538141191,
-0.8224166632,
-0.9125571847,
-0.3820244372,
-0.3030500412,
-0.0447631218,
0.8888530731,
0.735717237,
-0.6870872974,
-0.1148915663,
-0.0133559108,
-0.0143370712,
0.0349932238,
-0.3537080586,
0.2984670103,
-0.2245730162,
-0.862965405,
0.4232795238,
0.1589339077,
0.0465571284,
-0.1115661487,
-0.0119627258,
-0.0490926243,
0.3593397141,
0.4558556676,
0.2194975168,
-0.3850221634,
-0.2763068378,
-0.1955627054,
-0.3396344781,
0.2886744142,
0.7270668745,
-0.8764861226,
0.855299592,
0.4962533116,
0.8733768463,
0.370187819,
0.2903686166,
0.8473704457,
-0.9784096479,
0.2412684411,
0.2217163891,
0.0823375806,
0.4926106334,
-0.5077318549,
0.4961670041,
-0.081521824,
-0.6315361261,
-0.6596717238,
0.2085614353,
-0.987839222,
-0.0444164276,
0.8932807446,
-0.0296683107,
-0.0136331907,
-0.3607118428,
-0.6780865192,
0.2786743641,
-0.6736270785,
0.8322165608,
0.5041100383,
-0.0435235314,
-0.2079173028,
-0.5033339262,
0.7909606695,
0.4645817876,
-1.105922699,
0.1707417071,
0.7988779545,
0.1838843077,
0.067932196,
0.9161171317,
0.0669539869,
0.6175076962,
-0.2717376649,
0.2677496076,
0.2085531205,
0.2143586129,
-0.0722757056,
0.2593132257,
-0.1185868755,
-0.2555535436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05155v1
|
Weakly-supervised Deep Cognate Detection Framework for Low-Resourced Languages Using Morphological Knowledge of Closely-Related Languages
| 2023-11-09T05:46:41 | 2023-11-09T05:46:41 |
Koustava Goswami, Priya Rani, Theodorus Fransen, John P. McCrae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Exploiting cognates for transfer learning in under-resourced languages is an
exciting opportunity for language understanding tasks, including unsupervised
machine translation, named entity recognition and information retrieval.
Previous approaches mainly focused on supervised cognate detection tasks based
on orthographic, phonetic or state-of-the-art contextual language models, which
under-perform for most under-resourced languages. This paper proposes a novel
language-agnostic weakly-supervised deep cognate detection framework for
under-resourced languages using morphological knowledge from closely related
languages. We train an encoder to gain morphological knowledge of a language
and transfer the knowledge to perform unsupervised and weakly-supervised
cognate detection tasks with and without the pivot language for the
closely-related languages. While unsupervised, it overcomes the need for
hand-crafted annotation of cognates. We performed experiments on different
published cognate detection datasets across language families and observed not
only significant improvement over the state-of-the-art but also our method
outperformed the state-of-the-art supervised and unsupervised methods. Our
model can be extended to a wide range of languages from any language family as
it overcomes the requirement of the annotation of the cognate pairs for
training. The code and dataset building scripts can be found at
https://github.com/koustavagoswami/Weakly_supervised-Cognate_Detection
|
[
-0.4268365502,
-0.5515442491,
0.2889052629,
0.118059881,
-0.5609420538,
-0.1322943121,
-0.6531788111,
-0.5662967563,
0.2654512525,
0.4023831189,
-0.6378662586,
-0.5566645265,
-0.4021852911,
0.0732070431,
-0.2698214054,
0.689078331,
0.2382874638,
0.2109845877,
-0.3341197968,
-0.1813352704,
-0.0810225084,
-0.5157804489,
-0.533963263,
-0.4865106344,
0.1122762039,
0.609508276,
0.4354945123,
0.3019033074,
0.4650528729,
0.231944114,
-0.2667754889,
0.2411733717,
-0.2200952619,
0.2211543918,
-0.1862963438,
-0.4041010737,
-0.2557487488,
-0.6485074162,
0.1178949997,
0.9207305908,
0.102178812,
0.1665032804,
0.2212011963,
0.2217277884,
-0.8087293506,
0.4472352564,
-0.9426793456,
0.053636197,
-0.4982671738,
0.0504665487,
-0.3860624433,
0.1239939034,
-0.0131561914,
-0.4974547625,
0.345469147,
-0.2066574097,
0.6869266629,
0.6071420908,
-0.0542231575,
-0.5638400912,
-0.3214358389,
0.7250636816,
-0.4114678204,
0.475004673,
0.6315102577,
0.0080576669,
-0.2174733579,
-0.5679407716,
-0.3698712885,
-0.1072387695,
-0.4948839247,
0.0126594119,
-0.2493111491,
-0.0377801321,
-0.2536758184,
0.7497911453,
-0.5222545862,
0.4679559171,
-0.0382859223,
-0.3652076125,
0.3786284924,
-0.2154311687,
0.419840157,
-0.1344296783,
-0.4805027843,
0.1695256382,
-0.8008854389,
0.0838220119,
0.2072444707,
0.5714177489,
-0.6209818721,
0.4160488546,
-0.3276353776,
0.4538204074,
0.3187707961,
0.1223474294,
0.2145089209,
-0.5014227033,
-0.0113928067,
0.3334474564,
0.8998384476,
-0.2212570459,
0.4622678161,
-0.3236334622,
-0.0358071625,
0.4843862057,
-0.2397571355,
-0.7510482669,
-0.3943561018,
-0.1834596545,
-0.2126149684,
-0.2701760828,
-0.5385242701,
-0.7816752791,
-0.2093683779,
0.047255341,
-0.0363872051,
-0.594949007,
-0.2719988823,
0.2322049588,
0.1321113855,
0.1478480101,
0.1918550283,
-1.2246385813,
0.5280516148,
0.6481582522,
0.7344278097,
-0.3660005629,
-0.1255699992,
-0.7223214507,
0.0088044917,
-0.1968526393,
0.8427611589,
-0.6347137094,
-0.2862450778,
0.0428987294,
0.2294626385,
-0.0371339656,
-0.5839570165,
0.7462804914,
-0.2532972097,
0.1266101301,
0.0272612032,
-0.460475862,
-0.0700268149,
0.0156496707,
-0.4647199512,
1.0120996237,
0.0029908945,
-0.590143919,
0.4546773732,
-0.2556689084,
-0.7494502068,
0.4329901636,
-0.2012999505,
-0.5433533788,
0.120672293,
0.3635685444,
0.6999683976,
-0.1774491817,
0.4390498102,
-0.5749128461,
-0.3561735153,
-0.282841295,
-0.4090216756,
0.8142124414,
-0.0276109595,
-0.3611367047,
-0.189562425,
-0.8037195206,
0.0263146143,
0.0677161366,
-0.0592621975,
-0.7175037265,
-0.1387009025,
-0.0706488937,
0.0517933071,
0.4697300792,
-0.56658566,
0.1504772156,
-0.3974569738,
0.347186476,
0.036307767,
0.1059096977,
0.8930143714,
0.1978333145,
0.2827467918,
0.0146929966,
-0.0591937564,
-0.0925374255,
-0.4905308783,
-1.0741615295,
-0.4412940145,
0.1060635075,
0.4039095342,
-0.8723474145,
0.6135331988,
-0.2504088879,
-0.3264475167,
-0.6182179451,
0.524715662,
0.627589047,
0.4796026051,
0.727822721,
-0.510206759,
-0.5890455246,
-0.9799752235,
0.0248103347,
-0.2093987167,
0.1939244419,
-0.002854994,
0.6113057733,
-0.3394466937,
0.491088599,
-0.2786528766,
-0.6761094332,
-0.2434357405,
0.104180716,
0.1235674918,
0.7334185243,
0.3863075376,
-0.589985311,
-0.4272603095,
0.2799693644,
-0.7438482642,
-0.2420087755,
0.1931376755,
0.0013299645,
0.1112851351,
0.6884001493,
-0.4328591526,
0.1338566095,
0.6690615416,
-0.1301262826,
0.1332185715,
-0.219003886,
-0.342723459,
-1.1184809208,
0.0002088462,
-0.0465626046,
-0.2495145202,
-0.4931123257,
0.131966874,
0.0086523741,
0.024524793,
-0.5814669728,
0.5750911236,
-0.6800679564,
-0.1129824072,
-0.0630283728,
-0.2221278995,
-0.1367319077,
0.6788247228,
0.655674696,
0.7699628472,
0.6389910579,
-0.3525540531,
0.2804308832,
0.2824609876,
-0.262663722,
0.5062980652,
-0.3967021108,
0.2267032862,
0.4471212626,
-0.037456695,
-0.7001384497,
-0.2217727751,
0.354103446,
-0.241962865,
0.4033018053,
-0.9421204329,
-0.3671781123,
0.0096759656,
0.006663633,
0.4485301077,
0.4722111821,
-0.6756489277,
0.1269897223,
0.4009091556,
-0.2325912565,
-0.3167234361,
-1.0581003428,
-0.0522898845,
-0.1956281215,
-0.6519523263,
0.4401975572,
0.3106980622,
-0.0780288503,
0.1617498249,
-0.0467814542,
-0.6891302466,
0.092758663,
0.2525942624,
0.0392375737,
-0.5062512159,
0.1214478388,
0.3136913478,
-0.2993751168,
-0.2646112442,
-0.3416483104,
0.7267747521,
-0.4574700892,
-0.4934681058,
-0.42304793,
0.1685792953,
0.2975464463,
-0.371491462,
0.6005648375,
0.9369947314,
-0.4154044688,
-0.2047537565,
-0.2830353081,
-0.0646983683,
-0.4132941067,
0.2225503027,
-0.4276288152,
-0.8866159916,
0.5994389057,
-0.3069476485,
-0.7169520259,
0.4504444301,
0.7284039259,
-0.0106517645,
0.3511596024,
0.6815903783,
-0.2106657028,
0.3589738905,
-0.4163665175,
-0.1314969212,
-0.634262383,
-0.288975656,
-0.4384194911,
0.0754799619,
-0.7939394712,
-0.6605949402,
-0.1244878247,
0.0857854337,
0.2602140307,
0.5799099207,
-0.3236032128,
0.4596744478,
0.4087312222,
0.0012649855,
0.5655773282,
0.1163025573,
-0.1671709865,
0.0566686653,
-0.8592162728,
-0.3329868019,
0.6646482944,
0.0785404667,
0.8208630085,
-0.126585722,
1.0445677042,
0.3507354558,
-0.2439314425,
-0.9828803539,
0.4067406654,
-0.6495239735,
-0.2579616606,
-0.2219959199,
-0.1892071515,
-0.8787446618,
0.3286057413,
-0.2011279762,
-0.6117372513,
0.832003057,
0.1431346238,
-0.1221046224,
0.2055945694,
-0.9404610395,
0.9718535542,
-0.3081447184,
-0.6460728645,
-0.1376311183,
-0.3925220668,
0.1726180464,
-0.1488991529,
-0.0281026661,
-0.0887815282,
-0.1680845916,
0.3471886814,
-0.6561100483,
0.9760886431,
-0.199986726,
-0.1467474997,
0.3765768111,
0.1261640042,
0.4521290362,
0.1218710244,
-0.0242463965,
0.4401442409,
-0.1501179934,
-0.4547588527,
-0.2259305716,
0.8004539609,
-0.277168721,
-0.1755979359,
-0.3136433065,
-0.3756772876,
-0.0396584049,
0.4122918546,
0.3817667663,
0.2477168292,
-0.3551541865,
0.2715129852,
0.5265779495,
0.0812445283,
0.3600190282,
0.3756545782,
0.1700429767,
0.0346537605,
0.9578034282,
-0.1819480509,
0.1525516361,
0.2839022875,
0.1469523609,
-0.3057565689,
-0.8094245791,
-0.7057083249,
-0.0516231172,
-0.3906194568,
-0.1483288407,
-0.3204528987,
-0.0347702615,
-0.05651021,
-0.1610330492,
-0.6965762973,
-0.3566645682,
-0.3653145432,
0.3489979506,
0.3309948742,
0.4531645477,
0.078139998,
0.3208728731,
-0.4892446399,
0.392547518,
0.1857604235,
0.2501801252,
-0.2991979122,
-0.3705790937,
-0.2169409543,
0.1303708255,
0.1807372123,
-0.498077035,
0.3134095371,
0.558295548,
0.470961988,
0.2438187748,
0.2309064716,
0.7552142739,
-0.3530800641,
0.3849398792,
0.2015416026,
-0.8617206812,
0.4246489406,
-0.2663652003,
0.3235771656,
0.9437522888,
0.2930427492,
-0.1692120582,
-0.3475277722,
-0.521120131,
-0.7069876194,
0.6818463206,
0.3406853378,
0.0517002158,
0.1428946108,
0.0441668369,
0.4188113213,
0.0476206839,
-0.4747956991,
0.2119022757,
0.1163487658,
-0.3008672893,
0.085364379,
-0.06076755,
0.3823651969,
-0.2705293894,
0.5889132619,
-0.3414675593,
-0.0300703943,
0.0737337694,
-0.7444626093,
-0.0911983028,
0.4876915812,
0.2487260699,
-0.0380820222,
-0.2376536131,
0.3383898735,
0.4039810598,
-0.597412169,
0.1482536793,
0.2867955565,
-0.1768143624,
0.1428913921,
0.6770576835,
0.6015137434,
0.4558757842,
-0.3328604996,
0.609726429,
-0.0071501131,
0.1512714624,
-0.2893283069,
0.0499750003,
0.2573251128,
0.2437552065,
0.1324815899,
0.3624535203,
0.2110400498,
-0.5245829821,
0.3401269019,
0.4863267839,
-0.5598720312,
-0.5652694106,
0.2256419212,
0.4726251066,
-0.119840093,
0.3674026728,
-0.4719915986,
-0.5448782444,
0.465729475,
0.5189396143,
0.7996340394,
-0.1133626103,
0.0116448961,
0.0811690465,
0.1656288952,
-0.0388951674,
0.0805525482,
-0.5540368557,
-0.7414773703,
-0.4644927979,
-0.7815864086,
-0.3363186717,
0.4376260936,
-0.805783987,
0.4340007603,
-0.1636743546,
0.0017359891,
-0.1014904976,
-0.0380477645,
-0.6863199472,
0.0901344493,
0.3816227615,
0.6632851362,
-0.9919406772,
1.0753899813,
0.6516964436,
-0.4192438424,
-0.2630577087,
0.1768924594,
-0.0318105221,
-1.1853832006,
0.6562508345,
-0.0638699383,
-0.591039598,
-0.0270971172,
-0.162072584,
-0.5554490685,
0.7502056956,
0.8619275689,
-0.6541861892,
0.0594076924,
0.1370549947,
0.9413391948,
-0.3010244966,
-0.0511783399,
0.4116182923,
0.1338011324,
0.1654244959,
-0.8088892698,
0.0824125931,
-0.2979222238,
-0.3573857844,
0.2188739181,
-0.614817977,
0.5386359692,
-0.0725372583,
-0.2145743221,
0.4288969338,
0.5951834321,
-0.0859619826,
0.3551532924,
0.3598670661,
0.6958626509,
0.5838444829,
-0.2270374149,
0.7843989134,
-0.3566852212,
0.4532843232,
1.3386034966,
-0.1498176903,
0.9036528468,
0.7307725549,
-0.0741809085,
0.507514298,
0.6149896383,
-0.0932919532,
0.5486565828,
-0.0759406686,
-0.1974449456,
-0.6364564896,
-0.5983695388,
-0.5541369319,
0.7164206505,
0.4324461818,
-0.2614219487,
-0.5086771846,
-0.3288328946,
0.0110082431,
0.1515952647,
-0.2620010376,
0.7696195245,
0.280623734,
-0.4147623181,
0.9727619886,
-0.3869978786,
0.9886882901,
-0.456517607,
-0.0429909341,
-0.3227590024,
0.3986701667,
-0.4708303511,
-0.7121598125,
0.3402697444,
0.1789363772,
-0.0242910124,
-0.2252527326,
1.2179063559,
-0.8840579391,
-0.3968890607,
0.7203370333,
0.841822803,
0.1125908718,
0.0262690783,
-0.6048302054,
-0.2091729045,
-0.2431914359,
0.3887342513,
0.3321096003,
0.5529023409,
-0.2219260633,
0.5491160154,
0.6036991477,
0.1532039344,
0.0120864334,
0.2489928305,
0.6999810338,
-0.1051212773,
-0.4809935093,
-0.8784428835,
0.1306875795,
0.0844745412,
-0.041392561,
0.7264732718,
0.7567588091,
1.1153714657,
-0.3030822575,
0.4252385199,
0.1092313379,
0.0325330533,
-0.6327237487,
0.7585211992,
-0.6145026088,
0.1514078528,
-0.2163626105,
-0.6300472021,
-0.2122514546,
0.5339092016,
-0.5277658701,
-0.3756086528,
0.5347905755,
0.6759028435,
-0.6644580364,
-0.1692368984,
0.3514228165,
-0.0354798287,
-0.2199240178,
0.7767837048,
0.8434014916,
-0.2602933049,
0.6071965098,
-0.4381066561,
0.2374961972,
-0.2971427143,
-0.6295058727,
-1.0236791372,
-0.5199456811,
-0.2663070261,
0.0380023867,
0.2787238955,
0.6988885403,
0.7762202024,
-1.0905965567,
-0.2634068429,
-0.532081306,
0.0774077922,
0.0672975555,
-0.1604790092,
0.4042370915,
-0.4553285837,
-0.7451226711,
0.5523347855,
0.4050079882,
0.0686395094,
-0.1687888801,
-0.1248152256,
-0.4667134881,
-0.6031443477,
0.3781737685,
0.3986902535,
-0.5081547499,
0.045561932,
-0.2226746082,
-0.2171348482,
0.1844006181,
0.5357549787,
-0.7647266984,
0.3255599141,
0.5558280945,
0.7232542038,
0.665504992,
-0.3229142725,
0.2988917828,
-1.0046194792,
0.8737475276,
0.230360359,
0.5976632833,
0.5961267948,
-0.4462219477,
0.5809903145,
0.6093222499,
0.0751211122,
-0.6354794502,
0.3154991269,
-1.0302145481,
-0.0848384276,
1.0749571323,
-0.326320231,
-0.3298589587,
-0.3785945773,
0.1008876115,
0.3794490099,
-0.5885443091,
0.399178952,
0.3053560555,
0.0353691094,
0.0920119658,
0.0684303045,
0.5750268102,
0.5164192915,
-0.6926701069,
-0.0620828941,
0.1660644263,
0.1083423793,
0.2701054811,
0.4654008746,
0.059707541,
0.2716239691,
-0.0023418232,
-0.060221158,
-0.1271514148,
-0.1181676388,
-0.5124322176,
0.0846595466,
-0.0588163808,
-0.2759391665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05120v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05120v1
|
Quranic Conversations: Developing a Semantic Search tool for the Quran using Arabic NLP Techniques
| 2023-11-09T03:14:54 | 2023-11-09T03:14:54 |
Yasser Shohoud, Maged Shoman, Sarah Abdelazim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Holy Book of Quran is believed to be the literal word of God (Allah) as
revealed to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) over a period of approximately 23
years. It is the book where God provides guidance on how to live a righteous
and just life, emphasizing principles like honesty, compassion, charity and
justice, as well as providing rules for personal conduct, family matters,
business ethics and much more. However, due to constraints related to the
language and the Quran organization, it is challenging for Muslims to get all
relevant ayahs (verses) pertaining to a matter or inquiry of interest. Hence,
we developed a Quran semantic search tool which finds the verses pertaining to
the user inquiry or prompt. To achieve this, we trained several models on a
large dataset of over 30 tafsirs, where typically each tafsir corresponds to
one verse in the Quran and, using cosine similarity, obtained the tafsir tensor
which is most similar to the prompt tensor of interest, which was then used to
index for the corresponding ayah in the Quran. Using the SNxLM model, we were
able to achieve a cosine similarity score as high as 0.97 which corresponds to
the abdu tafsir for a verse relating to financial matters.
|
[
-0.395147413,
-0.8342365026,
0.2025759965,
0.14392519,
-0.6192006469,
-0.0528768264,
0.1248312294,
-0.4216623902,
0.0793460757,
0.7416294217,
-0.4787770212,
-0.5200386643,
-0.5267139673,
0.2349268049,
-0.5192279816,
1.0007590055,
0.0470671654,
-0.1421039104,
0.3013795912,
-0.2703877985,
-0.3929283023,
-0.1999317557,
-0.5268578529,
-0.2521114349,
0.5655927658,
0.385663718,
1.2532886267,
0.4778299332,
0.6880691051,
0.2632261515,
-0.4919579029,
0.2307558805,
-0.3638887107,
0.3001234531,
-0.4324176311,
-0.1215281263,
0.1539729089,
-0.4030708373,
0.537283659,
0.6215789318,
-0.2485167533,
0.4105802774,
-0.0827015638,
1.0612190962,
-0.5646720529,
0.0725431293,
-0.7305768728,
0.3319929242,
-0.1426702291,
-0.4131580889,
-0.0788892284,
-0.6010497808,
0.5784623027,
-0.579600215,
0.1416121125,
0.2442634106,
0.9636996984,
0.2581340671,
-0.7553604245,
-0.8152049184,
-0.36325863,
1.0253834724,
-0.8024904728,
0.636043489,
0.6074718237,
0.2956598103,
-0.6275471449,
-0.6210531592,
-0.7471265793,
-0.2635867,
0.0311961006,
-0.0345471837,
0.1993206739,
0.1233649701,
0.1644228995,
0.5744550824,
-0.4341020882,
-0.4779343009,
-0.070677802,
-0.0900701433,
0.58234936,
0.1701543182,
0.5312905908,
-0.5817141533,
-0.6194146276,
-0.294655174,
-0.6558969617,
0.4392700493,
0.3972001672,
0.0387253352,
0.1837988645,
0.7630169392,
-0.351562947,
0.693249166,
-0.1649342924,
-0.4967946708,
-0.1328659654,
-0.5540462732,
-0.1129648685,
0.2940804064,
0.7636166215,
0.3812396526,
0.2251189202,
-0.1067547053,
-0.0310600493,
-0.2488085926,
0.5187364817,
-1.0227501392,
-0.0043955385,
0.1281876862,
-0.6528443098,
-0.067957297,
0.1226200461,
-0.2909247279,
-0.3277397752,
-0.2540886998,
0.345852077,
-0.5458375216,
-0.1152321771,
0.3262403905,
-0.1845761836,
0.4478960633,
0.3733873963,
-0.7804649472,
0.3415145278,
0.5643036366,
0.6504605412,
0.0773326606,
0.0582666174,
-0.2267023325,
0.2613836527,
-0.4972520769,
0.4543115199,
-0.6963154078,
-0.5669672489,
0.3486649394,
-0.3852235973,
0.039398741,
-0.512294054,
1.1352936029,
-0.7741903663,
-0.0198045727,
-0.332798183,
-0.9095849395,
-0.7415060401,
0.2998203337,
-0.6591845751,
1.0529245138,
0.0033588833,
-0.9173108339,
0.0500886962,
-0.7853403091,
-0.078638494,
0.4039299488,
-0.4478554428,
-0.6892727017,
0.0780512914,
-0.0082089836,
0.2679562271,
-0.3827571571,
0.408498019,
0.0459182784,
-0.6003064513,
0.6123860478,
-0.0840967298,
0.7965412736,
0.363327235,
-0.2346064299,
0.0218594465,
-0.5291269422,
0.2195041031,
0.04563348,
-0.1636507064,
-0.5178822875,
0.1447712183,
0.2172082365,
0.0325206891,
0.3405218422,
-0.7973565459,
0.1443750262,
-0.8423541784,
-0.0267257448,
0.3316623271,
0.2782208025,
0.0436636284,
-0.4327003956,
0.3200752735,
0.0132544693,
0.234398827,
-0.1632182896,
-0.6737725735,
-0.5269626975,
-0.0190523323,
0.1304727346,
0.4386991262,
-0.4752949774,
0.655053854,
-0.1542821229,
-0.448720336,
-0.5404970646,
0.4321763515,
0.3349557519,
0.2703089118,
0.3681453764,
-0.5297113061,
-0.3470828831,
-1.0379298925,
-0.6077638865,
-0.3936918378,
-0.0159437396,
0.2593567967,
0.5994395018,
-0.0981571898,
0.9729886055,
-0.5242514014,
-0.446667105,
-0.0462656133,
0.0403549001,
0.3897548318,
0.2638717592,
0.377378583,
-1.2209972143,
-0.6951224804,
0.3647151887,
-0.4828769267,
0.2029582113,
0.1084977612,
-0.4241102636,
-0.0184623096,
0.3494393229,
-0.2809934914,
1.0114395618,
0.2235110998,
-0.7772550583,
0.1805821806,
0.0769462436,
0.2471175045,
-1.2202708721,
0.0008279374,
-0.3283900917,
0.002045549,
-0.509911716,
0.2126277238,
-0.0161420219,
0.0144038815,
-0.4011659324,
0.698405087,
0.018427657,
0.3369663656,
-0.3997627497,
-0.2243498415,
0.0702282041,
0.4940292835,
-0.0026679833,
0.8419559002,
0.0596974976,
-0.6494502425,
0.3945165873,
0.8488200903,
-0.4844615161,
0.2464884371,
-0.6824643016,
0.2371537089,
0.1318057775,
0.1381652057,
-0.809984684,
0.1694577038,
0.4020960927,
-0.4206726551,
-0.0861786157,
0.1939493865,
-0.6356295347,
0.0715962499,
-0.2629806399,
0.7661617398,
0.2321127802,
-0.3353353739,
0.6725990176,
0.3401445448,
-0.4546453357,
-0.872540772,
-0.1285830736,
0.1320972741,
-0.1060365736,
-0.5646472573,
0.5993425846,
-0.085637629,
-0.2657666504,
0.2012402564,
-0.2887634933,
-0.1217250377,
0.138195321,
0.4851758182,
0.0565599687,
-0.1426252723,
0.1767996699,
0.1388522983,
0.1172508597,
0.1501773745,
-0.0709336922,
0.4803795218,
-0.3643167317,
-0.247414574,
-0.5082184076,
0.7407876849,
0.149260208,
-0.1668221951,
1.0961376429,
0.4793893695,
-0.3797691762,
0.219866097,
-0.6997404099,
0.1133388057,
-0.4683103263,
0.2074878216,
-0.4142586589,
-0.8616190553,
0.6159310341,
-0.0164667685,
0.0671429187,
0.5762327909,
0.6581246257,
0.0693734586,
0.6665371656,
0.6961650252,
0.2473662049,
0.5327133536,
-0.0913035795,
0.3463100195,
-0.5757624507,
-0.4291290641,
-0.5486797094,
-0.0779099464,
-0.8180269003,
-0.3152361214,
0.4689252675,
0.1684965491,
-0.3559709489,
0.1712034494,
-0.2352314293,
0.4288138151,
0.5700269938,
0.0041935048,
0.2988384664,
0.1768272221,
-0.3661442697,
-0.2039791644,
-0.3597944975,
-0.6832711101,
0.6812141538,
0.2917793393,
0.2457573414,
0.5614230037,
0.693595469,
0.3201200366,
0.0112703862,
-0.9488609433,
0.5987865925,
0.0157262441,
-0.6305418015,
-0.4425172806,
-0.262252748,
-1.0174033642,
0.1928638369,
-0.084327966,
-0.4078216553,
-0.0466864407,
-0.5911878943,
-0.337770164,
0.031926699,
-0.2320506871,
0.770399332,
0.0910453275,
-0.2407527268,
-0.392031014,
-0.7623082995,
0.056111861,
-0.1047075018,
0.1119013131,
-0.3254443407,
-0.1073686481,
0.9600803256,
-0.6831023693,
0.5144504309,
0.2062746435,
-0.259036839,
0.529653132,
0.0548427552,
0.120336175,
-0.0823135376,
-0.15286915,
0.0732102618,
0.5936576724,
-0.6018553972,
-0.7858012319,
0.3227213025,
-0.7163257003,
-0.5149106979,
-0.7052166462,
-0.6122277975,
-0.0540792979,
0.1650245786,
-0.1990361959,
0.3821057975,
-0.3140612841,
0.359677285,
0.3730069697,
-0.543587923,
0.236770466,
0.5440593958,
-0.500505209,
-0.3993423581,
0.6712764502,
-0.0016605475,
-0.0389296226,
0.5281633735,
0.5561693907,
-0.6269180775,
-0.3244621754,
-0.279774338,
0.2939223349,
-0.6687662005,
-0.2975970209,
-0.4175040722,
-0.4477385283,
-0.2707422376,
0.0441702604,
-0.2105163634,
-0.3087181747,
0.0900970027,
0.222820878,
0.7967942953,
0.8086125851,
0.4472850859,
0.2534605861,
-1.1209905148,
0.4470038414,
0.2183020711,
0.1816644669,
-0.0698609799,
-0.6456791162,
-0.2311485112,
0.0654037818,
-0.522484839,
-1.009914279,
0.467186749,
0.4053391218,
0.123960577,
0.4632837474,
0.6126856208,
0.8456340432,
-0.6307178736,
0.6345980167,
0.1871359497,
-0.9717648029,
0.7235805392,
-0.2342947274,
0.3586693704,
0.5996878743,
0.5571632981,
-0.9206462502,
-0.592648387,
-0.5795410872,
-0.9056171179,
0.4020671844,
0.6573390365,
0.1762589514,
-0.0367179662,
0.5118748546,
0.3121274412,
0.4639751017,
-0.2114052922,
-0.3275721967,
-0.1559117734,
-0.4079745114,
0.4112331569,
-0.4259099066,
-0.0951243415,
-0.478639245,
0.6075255871,
0.0197806656,
0.0214457754,
0.3726696074,
0.1109566316,
-0.0203645993,
0.4575585425,
0.340675503,
0.7618016601,
-0.4350773394,
-0.0674456879,
-0.0392947905,
-0.8218809366,
-0.0043822918,
-0.0876626149,
-0.3195582926,
0.2808325887,
0.1229227558,
0.5624864101,
0.097836718,
-0.9000555873,
0.5440609455,
-0.30926615,
-0.1228576079,
-0.8764309883,
-0.1127085388,
-0.0257296786,
0.3469653428,
0.6055604219,
-0.3386877775,
0.465180546,
-0.6094143391,
0.1678177714,
0.3547006249,
-0.3275350928,
0.0282837879,
0.3285492957,
-0.0454235114,
-0.3707523644,
0.6068691015,
-0.1996295154,
-0.9631807804,
0.4073905945,
0.3012600839,
0.66188097,
-0.3191840053,
0.2198472023,
0.4714361131,
-0.1198205799,
0.0616204366,
0.5417166352,
-0.4986953735,
-0.6687203646,
-0.5119599104,
-1.0308266878,
-0.711520195,
-0.0913312435,
-0.8587089181,
-0.0532720312,
-0.2596776187,
-0.1784745753,
-0.1074675024,
0.7118844986,
-0.8215624094,
0.2076859921,
-0.1619142443,
0.7574880123,
-0.3436700404,
0.803834796,
0.5296836495,
-0.343988955,
-0.9483358264,
-0.0435372554,
-0.1061339825,
-0.6396237612,
0.935120821,
0.2917231023,
-0.4220399261,
-0.0065034335,
-0.3037711978,
-0.6323463321,
0.7095948458,
0.0362599157,
-0.3794905841,
-0.0714385062,
0.4662897885,
0.4696776867,
0.0090436293,
0.1624424905,
0.4198995829,
0.196463868,
0.4131128192,
-1.0036402941,
0.0427905023,
-0.541752696,
0.0891391113,
0.3211912811,
-0.2051069587,
0.4887494743,
0.051889196,
-0.2930958569,
0.4465764165,
0.8487397432,
0.0900887996,
0.4446449578,
0.3483938277,
0.4784427583,
0.634526372,
0.2415719032,
0.9006302357,
-0.4403966367,
0.272932291,
0.6308216453,
-0.0142200543,
1.0564111471,
0.6525858045,
-0.2143086493,
0.5365439057,
0.4413630962,
0.270173043,
0.308521986,
0.3762174249,
-0.6240983009,
-0.1015555859,
-0.9052804708,
-0.5605639219,
0.4739650786,
0.578448534,
-0.1782733202,
0.0303953998,
-0.247801125,
-0.2948273718,
0.324038893,
-0.290972352,
0.9224563837,
0.3711233735,
-0.5415678024,
0.6653354764,
0.1412411779,
0.3952013254,
-0.551150918,
-0.3448830843,
0.1510383487,
0.0895382091,
-0.0162183326,
-0.6885735393,
0.5974677205,
-0.1465959102,
0.1031227782,
-0.1348729283,
0.6377269626,
-0.4756403863,
-0.5079184175,
0.1709854901,
0.4987805784,
0.2504386008,
-0.0094084376,
-0.7694863677,
0.0615915619,
-0.1247695163,
-0.0802577212,
0.0320028216,
0.6702853441,
0.0062656514,
0.5829906464,
0.628544271,
0.0741718262,
-0.1058018431,
-0.0003655756,
0.6385496855,
-1.3228046894,
-0.543911159,
-0.8998488784,
-0.0012236827,
0.0031884681,
-0.4061901867,
0.749417901,
0.5186579227,
0.7762029767,
0.2031804174,
0.2621943355,
0.2873191833,
0.7827361822,
-0.6132230759,
0.7259089947,
-0.6442887783,
0.0200455394,
-0.2455218732,
-0.9603982568,
-0.2933653593,
1.0841128826,
-0.0492739081,
-0.4227625132,
0.7288769484,
0.7419945598,
0.2476748526,
0.5178255439,
0.2717470527,
0.0536968112,
0.1693389267,
0.3558130264,
1.1202760935,
-0.8476153612,
0.4499828815,
-0.0895487592,
0.470056355,
-0.2115655094,
-0.60610497,
-1.0371757746,
-0.834800601,
-0.358381629,
-0.3635994196,
0.1517297775,
1.2531639338,
0.0334142931,
-0.6562162638,
-0.5423313975,
-0.0536745638,
0.2121064067,
-0.1718935519,
-0.1561740786,
0.6751800776,
-0.0708641708,
-0.4909742177,
0.180481866,
0.2993035913,
-0.0138645535,
-0.0383443832,
-0.0665428191,
-0.3275518119,
0.16704759,
0.4775471389,
0.1886470467,
-0.9342797399,
-0.3734574616,
-0.0545431152,
-0.2338898629,
-0.0678393841,
0.6621953249,
-0.4813997447,
0.4889392555,
0.4030266404,
1.0498435497,
0.2746431231,
-0.0588996597,
0.5438842773,
-0.3782247007,
0.1481948495,
0.3938430846,
0.1198173761,
0.2273551077,
-0.0020923009,
0.4068313241,
-0.1361299008,
-0.5800132155,
-0.6460699439,
0.6631793976,
-1.1026058197,
-0.1649930924,
0.884070456,
-0.1178429499,
-0.422714144,
-0.5820763111,
-0.6271532178,
0.426445663,
-0.4491428733,
0.8793298602,
0.8676350713,
0.1120222956,
0.2366744876,
-0.6623212099,
0.6850383878,
0.9112635851,
-0.1513407528,
-0.397503674,
0.0406802297,
-0.101076439,
0.2495530993,
0.4315339327,
-0.1151681393,
0.2802714407,
-0.066040054,
-0.1139628366,
0.1351597607,
0.0135572637,
0.0467328541,
0.2060702443,
0.1520960927,
-0.1479210854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05117v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05117v1
|
Unsupervised Translation Quality Estimation Exploiting Synthetic Data and Pre-trained Multilingual Encoder
| 2023-11-09T03:10:42 | 2023-11-09T03:10:42 |
Yuto Kuroda, Atsushi Fujita, Tomoyuki Kajiwara, Takashi Ninomiya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Translation quality estimation (TQE) is the task of predicting translation
quality without reference translations. Due to the enormous cost of creating
training data for TQE, only a few translation directions can benefit from
supervised training. To address this issue, unsupervised TQE methods have been
studied. In this paper, we extensively investigate the usefulness of synthetic
TQE data and pre-trained multilingual encoders in unsupervised sentence-level
TQE, both of which have been proven effective in the supervised training
scenarios. Our experiment on WMT20 and WMT21 datasets revealed that this
approach can outperform other unsupervised TQE methods on high- and
low-resource translation directions in predicting post-editing effort and human
evaluation score, and some zero-resource translation directions in predicting
post-editing effort.
|
[
-0.3522642553,
-0.2797017992,
0.7142350674,
0.1209303364,
-0.591424346,
0.2268919498,
-0.1911198348,
-0.1756203175,
0.2384403497,
0.3578219116,
-0.5859803557,
-0.6495839357,
-0.6525787711,
0.234885782,
-0.2617336214,
0.7176256776,
-0.0435040891,
0.5465584397,
-0.3357351422,
-0.0025010626,
-0.4595488608,
-0.6223711967,
-0.2207473665,
0.0105746994,
0.2267067283,
0.1238147095,
0.6084888577,
0.2442400753,
0.2713015676,
0.3502419889,
0.0588255785,
0.4567430913,
-0.325252533,
-0.033017803,
-0.1974657178,
-0.3031927049,
-0.3718271852,
0.2878142893,
0.4780122042,
0.5410889387,
-0.1320267916,
0.1912155747,
0.1966030449,
0.6179078817,
-0.6471248865,
-0.0061034868,
-0.4205094874,
0.2570793331,
-0.1668305099,
-0.1947152168,
-0.3052789569,
-0.4380269647,
-0.014859274,
-0.6031460166,
0.1161251664,
-0.1337902546,
0.7192432284,
0.2986337245,
-0.5475642681,
0.1014641821,
-0.6411850452,
0.8272120357,
-0.988461256,
0.808270216,
0.3012929559,
0.1312375665,
-0.3075837493,
-0.7369983792,
-0.6641572118,
0.0613805205,
-0.1853994131,
0.590380609,
-0.18966344,
0.0171529967,
-0.0755923688,
0.523769021,
-0.6011981368,
-0.0402371921,
-0.1871665865,
-0.273557812,
0.488971889,
-0.2470159978,
0.2886454761,
-0.3205675781,
-0.3285028338,
-0.3006715477,
-0.4346126914,
0.106883347,
0.2001683712,
-0.0718951598,
0.2269689441,
0.6248024702,
-0.3558260202,
0.515294075,
0.0916577578,
-0.0694447309,
0.3961578608,
-0.5913180113,
-0.2573405802,
-0.1956714839,
1.2332068682,
0.3117564917,
0.2594732046,
-0.6224374175,
-0.4884831607,
-0.0739979818,
0.4466873407,
-0.6051828861,
0.1056018025,
0.1393512636,
-0.3487618864,
-0.1542868316,
0.4509977996,
-0.859354496,
-0.0000253687,
-0.4434368312,
0.4527778625,
-0.5217626691,
-0.0848185495,
0.0412422828,
-0.1640273631,
0.000958309,
0.0161595121,
-0.3549669683,
-0.2036132365,
0.1715379208,
0.7457488775,
-0.2727261782,
-0.4536677301,
-0.5338039994,
0.0108706607,
-0.6356294155,
0.830301404,
-0.1812150031,
-0.4514382184,
-0.1006872952,
0.0624040291,
-0.1346414983,
-0.371055752,
0.7419660687,
-0.5065992475,
0.437199682,
-0.0492766313,
-0.4406926632,
-0.210044086,
0.1735605896,
-0.5569636822,
1.0228538513,
0.3844217658,
-0.5177178979,
0.5463472605,
-0.6358132958,
-0.3846797347,
0.0211606119,
0.3430161774,
-0.3623011708,
0.6918999553,
0.642298162,
0.299720943,
-0.2871941328,
0.6190274358,
0.1166007221,
-0.2701511681,
0.4940564632,
-0.7442371249,
0.5593011379,
0.2622129321,
0.0468342267,
0.4913468063,
-0.5048416853,
0.3603223562,
-0.0685088038,
-0.2067465186,
-0.2724327445,
-0.3341682553,
0.0860890448,
0.4825622439,
0.1603591889,
-0.8517101407,
-0.0788963139,
-0.4155150652,
0.3096825182,
0.4269171357,
0.1846221983,
0.4488312006,
0.008409705,
0.592643559,
0.1647205949,
0.5028299093,
0.2897850871,
-0.1640635729,
-0.3624087572,
0.0734328181,
0.7340736985,
0.4374267757,
-1.2299389839,
0.3733143806,
-0.3792036474,
-0.5122520328,
-0.84988451,
0.1195463538,
0.5530561805,
0.0678601712,
0.6954367161,
-0.2503031194,
-0.481656611,
-0.6491677761,
-0.4281228483,
-0.0360751599,
-0.3362621069,
-0.4694491625,
0.2263265997,
-0.4305597246,
0.8071705699,
-0.3842510581,
-0.2084707767,
-0.3342120349,
0.2903145552,
0.0737917051,
0.6729172468,
0.3837007582,
-0.655215323,
-0.4314145148,
-0.1616311073,
-0.8819726706,
0.0057966243,
-0.1971370876,
-0.5783851743,
0.2432442605,
0.4465224147,
-0.582793057,
0.2365371585,
0.7877391577,
-0.1190126985,
0.671081841,
-0.5183106065,
0.5600010753,
-1.2486747503,
-0.2796190083,
0.2542702556,
-0.1555018425,
-0.6628683209,
0.083113119,
0.3315561414,
-0.1057450548,
-0.5044300556,
0.0520553589,
-0.5113297105,
-0.0286461227,
-0.04569057,
-0.1373817772,
0.2880561054,
0.5863600373,
0.1614559293,
1.0098667145,
0.1616078168,
-0.1251284331,
0.2323217541,
0.2221829146,
-0.5320160985,
0.5548642874,
-0.6259317398,
0.2133952379,
-0.1178420782,
-0.013581072,
-0.5723516941,
0.0365524925,
0.013455824,
-0.6457395554,
0.4215092957,
-0.1194456816,
-0.7316262126,
-0.3619118929,
-0.3027265966,
0.3423535526,
0.2622671127,
-0.6082798839,
0.3533316851,
0.3698354363,
0.1568958908,
-0.2513337433,
-0.5627677441,
0.184922114,
-0.2559086084,
-0.2228968292,
0.4150704145,
0.0844127089,
0.1616194695,
0.0438213572,
-0.2030517757,
-0.4189732969,
-0.1755004674,
0.1101319566,
0.1955223233,
-0.1763437837,
-0.1002288461,
0.3582087755,
-0.243043527,
0.2070101351,
-0.4677206874,
0.4277083278,
0.1140606031,
-0.2643704116,
-0.4444535375,
0.3715884387,
0.6829413176,
-0.6383763552,
0.9136481285,
0.7589122057,
-0.3679980636,
0.163322106,
-0.5833667517,
-0.0303137805,
-0.4727053046,
0.5137190223,
-0.2152819037,
-0.3934904933,
0.1584455818,
-0.1909034848,
-0.2903521359,
0.3609746397,
-0.148048833,
-0.3375083804,
1.1299273968,
0.2828792334,
0.1574539244,
0.3986999691,
-0.2938848138,
0.1751161069,
-0.9137169719,
-0.3628088534,
-0.2359595001,
-0.0752267018,
-0.9239159822,
-0.4663743377,
0.7122658491,
0.5451228619,
-0.0948857591,
0.3484549224,
-0.2582085431,
0.5135728717,
0.9586415887,
0.1249083504,
0.3936885893,
0.0609973557,
-0.0524178408,
-0.2261078209,
-0.6349247694,
-0.4314692318,
1.0280071497,
-0.0495859012,
0.1741194427,
-0.0564458743,
0.5065246224,
0.2081991285,
0.1310810298,
-0.732290566,
0.3089807332,
-0.2696290016,
-0.1859096885,
-0.4376365542,
-0.6599181294,
-0.7831758261,
0.4174426198,
-0.5118437409,
-0.1965985149,
0.2115878463,
-0.0395613164,
-0.011809038,
0.3539257944,
-0.5756610036,
1.0763659477,
-0.2912392914,
-0.042543035,
-0.0552402921,
-0.4715621769,
0.0598038286,
-0.4356284142,
0.1910638064,
0.1400512606,
0.3897236586,
0.8977726102,
-0.5051832199,
0.3445993662,
-0.2137443423,
0.0071933432,
0.2229476869,
0.0305502415,
0.4958782792,
0.3317447305,
-0.1521430016,
0.6249632239,
0.3461476862,
-0.5750672817,
-0.8509720564,
0.5187943578,
-0.8142854571,
-0.4340183735,
-0.4773263633,
-0.5066310763,
-0.6920067668,
0.324100107,
0.7237180471,
0.4399607778,
-0.3627218902,
-0.016502291,
0.0311668999,
-0.4080214798,
0.5912483931,
0.5531302691,
0.2334113866,
-0.7124196291,
1.0209852457,
0.1867714673,
0.2734078169,
0.467885375,
0.2113717198,
-0.6454618573,
-0.7742046118,
-0.7129280567,
0.1617839634,
-0.3226560056,
-0.531150341,
-0.3245870471,
-0.3025812507,
-0.2698362768,
-0.1021762267,
-0.7960585952,
-0.2396486104,
0.0433710665,
-0.1757053435,
0.2005240917,
0.5796334743,
-0.0482737422,
0.5176910162,
-1.1522886753,
0.1569018364,
0.0003417393,
0.3286718428,
-0.3123069406,
-0.427025795,
-0.5049268007,
0.6554616094,
-0.2900214493,
-0.8814136386,
0.8239969611,
-0.0981110334,
0.5710624456,
0.152949363,
0.4094006717,
0.7182596922,
-0.3295923769,
0.6382154822,
0.1885468811,
-1.1690392494,
0.5052608848,
-0.0602757409,
0.5312752724,
0.5996974707,
0.3372193873,
-0.5031920671,
-0.4887837172,
-0.3504787683,
-0.6068456769,
0.3912082314,
0.331279397,
-0.0323544443,
0.0468299091,
0.3776110113,
0.1337135732,
0.4073185921,
-0.4920681417,
-0.033655934,
-0.6353598833,
-0.0654391795,
-0.4147696197,
-0.3124623597,
0.4611212909,
-0.4176369011,
0.6269009709,
0.1522401869,
0.1814935803,
0.0766973495,
-0.3670525253,
-0.088825576,
0.4953636527,
0.2858010828,
0.5875170827,
-0.3966658711,
0.0085887546,
0.240806967,
-0.4166865349,
0.2975953519,
-0.1270765811,
-0.1884877235,
0.1971341074,
0.5180985332,
0.7584695816,
-0.1257295758,
-0.4156852067,
0.5021134019,
-0.0132963276,
-0.0390807688,
-0.2580733895,
-0.3919553757,
-0.2403376848,
0.0227778032,
0.1148922816,
0.2656517327,
0.2196306437,
-0.3096525669,
0.0423689187,
0.3396594226,
-0.7396351099,
-0.5817182064,
0.4999602735,
0.0947698504,
0.0463961698,
0.7793447375,
-0.274282366,
-0.5257253647,
0.1474342644,
0.533708334,
0.7665295601,
-0.5735077858,
0.5349089503,
0.363224715,
0.3345267475,
-0.1320819408,
0.0703568831,
0.3290697336,
-0.8057130575,
-0.8272933364,
-0.7924451828,
-0.0867344663,
0.1414082199,
-1.0453749895,
-0.185305357,
0.2329590917,
-0.1343351156,
-0.2994971275,
-0.1127420664,
-0.7850559354,
0.3234972358,
-0.400416255,
0.4391810596,
-0.7981715202,
1.0123361349,
0.7654787302,
-0.3903410435,
-0.5520583987,
0.2447765768,
-0.1300406009,
-0.4046533406,
0.341147989,
-0.1058113426,
-0.2157373726,
0.2698975205,
0.0025537496,
-0.7632425427,
0.7246644497,
0.5527449846,
-0.3004272878,
0.1101438925,
0.5436949134,
0.7471006513,
0.0950166732,
0.1144861132,
0.612786293,
0.4201735556,
-0.0658603534,
-0.7672153115,
-0.0101626469,
-0.3474614322,
0.1987816244,
0.3981485069,
-0.1242350787,
0.3615101874,
-0.0309241377,
-0.3061850071,
-0.2076894641,
0.60289222,
-0.1998680979,
0.0518260933,
0.3736788034,
0.3126555979,
0.4158808291,
-0.2181890905,
1.0727062225,
-0.1948741525,
0.1640235782,
0.8687052131,
0.1926818788,
0.8826156855,
0.4438722432,
-0.2698582113,
0.173150301,
0.6623868346,
0.1600046754,
0.7381372452,
-0.2348527163,
-0.0818486959,
-0.2425109446,
-0.3209223747,
-0.290489018,
0.5896919966,
0.0655201003,
-0.1028794795,
0.103797324,
0.310189873,
-0.1225788966,
0.1665627509,
-0.0903751701,
0.9834173918,
-0.0892779306,
-0.7623777986,
0.7106105685,
0.0911865234,
0.62343961,
-0.3837411404,
0.0961916372,
-0.5212151408,
0.0845986977,
-0.0571492314,
-0.8734956384,
0.544193387,
-0.0581190512,
-0.1595704108,
-0.3475863636,
0.1472772956,
-0.6260852218,
-0.8072904944,
0.3094721437,
1.0133709908,
-0.0378684402,
-0.6207197309,
-0.3324812055,
-0.4276088774,
-0.0346610248,
-0.1525235623,
0.5620293617,
0.8555217981,
-0.0601595193,
0.3093626499,
0.8531788588,
0.1656251401,
-0.1903331131,
0.044442188,
0.6900439858,
-0.7392334342,
-0.3688490987,
-0.779969275,
0.4064625204,
-0.0552922599,
-0.2396927625,
0.9734820724,
0.6259703636,
1.131289959,
-0.4339589477,
0.5255506039,
0.5519883633,
0.2594007552,
-0.7612511516,
0.8256790638,
-0.621373415,
0.0519238152,
-0.3844070137,
-1.019823432,
-0.2603319585,
0.477927506,
-0.1587160826,
-0.187999934,
0.9006271958,
0.6515194774,
-0.1412695497,
0.0191567503,
0.4260521233,
-0.0758030117,
0.1655143201,
0.3629838526,
0.7746509314,
-0.5122025013,
0.3873240948,
-0.6164907813,
0.05762209,
0.2822639644,
-0.6491883993,
-0.7799698114,
-0.6733903289,
-0.2762974501,
-0.1341522783,
0.0003652717,
0.8603202701,
0.6677979231,
-0.9798751473,
-0.083687216,
-0.1483977586,
-0.0891729891,
-0.6425663829,
-0.1405494064,
0.6168248057,
-0.1889594048,
-0.9206767082,
0.6303290129,
0.0659140944,
0.2643390298,
0.0609178878,
-0.0495140776,
-0.099587515,
-0.0642105341,
0.8235296607,
-0.1082020774,
-0.6458427906,
-0.0396123081,
-0.0261402018,
0.0183181446,
0.0647201687,
0.6236484051,
-0.6270960569,
0.5851277709,
0.3986470103,
0.3701369166,
0.5682536364,
0.3665549457,
0.9217040539,
-0.9913390279,
0.1674583107,
-0.027445171,
0.4438253939,
0.3375785947,
-0.2657363713,
0.5145148039,
0.1488301009,
-0.2424937785,
-0.6503441334,
-0.1365254372,
-0.70252496,
-0.3408714533,
0.9215739369,
-0.3484194279,
-0.0316397958,
-0.0072037377,
-0.1363936514,
0.6494054198,
-0.2971832454,
0.7841802835,
0.3380552232,
0.106220156,
-0.2198571861,
-0.7400832772,
0.4562022686,
0.261153698,
-1.1765042543,
-0.3227664232,
0.4860239625,
-0.0532940663,
0.0515315719,
0.0642203689,
-0.1514372677,
0.0382646173,
-0.142519325,
0.1468212306,
-0.4548968971,
-0.2679543793,
0.0253189895,
0.0006099723,
-0.0129983472,
-0.429482013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05113v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05113v1
|
Conic10K: A Challenging Math Problem Understanding and Reasoning Dataset
| 2023-11-09T02:58:17 | 2023-11-09T02:58:17 |
Haoyi Wu, Wenyang Hui, Yezeng Chen, Weiqi Wu, Kewei Tu, Yi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mathematical understanding and reasoning are crucial tasks for assessing the
capabilities of artificial intelligence (AI). However, existing benchmarks
either require just a few steps of reasoning, or only contain a small amount of
data in one specific topic, making it hard to analyse AI's behaviour with
reference to different problems within a specific topic in detail. In this
work, we propose Conic10K, a challenging math problem dataset on conic sections
in Chinese senior high school education. Our dataset contains various problems
with different reasoning depths, while only the knowledge from conic sections
is required. Since the dataset only involves a narrow range of knowledge, it is
easy to separately analyse the knowledge a model possesses and the reasoning
ability it has. For each problem, we provide a high-quality formal
representation, the reasoning steps, and the final solution. Experiments show
that existing large language models, including GPT-4, exhibit weak performance
on complex reasoning. We hope that our findings could inspire more advanced
techniques for precise natural language understanding and reasoning. Our
dataset and codes are available at https://github.com/whyNLP/Conic10K.
|
[
-0.4456318617,
-0.815277338,
0.3410331011,
0.1992674023,
-0.1463651508,
0.1198551357,
-0.5238419771,
-0.4839615822,
-0.3646816909,
0.3540250361,
-0.6912451982,
-0.5303463936,
-0.5704077482,
0.1853327453,
-0.1132506281,
0.8073238134,
-0.140072152,
0.1166880503,
-0.3430479765,
-0.1906481534,
-0.62311095,
-0.4814672768,
-0.8652995229,
-0.363297224,
-0.1194623336,
0.792235136,
0.7410799265,
0.329397738,
0.7801095247,
0.3326633871,
-0.0872450992,
0.1456845999,
-0.265021652,
-0.0202520769,
-0.2597842515,
-0.234153226,
-0.2390948236,
-0.0407467447,
0.434874624,
1.2360583544,
0.0850547403,
0.2427825183,
0.0583262071,
0.6937567592,
-0.5445815921,
0.5308318734,
-0.4416176975,
-0.1570524126,
-0.3997081518,
0.5328894258,
-0.0769595206,
-0.2699077725,
0.2805075049,
-1.0466991663,
0.1762452871,
-0.0661759302,
0.6107135415,
0.3407105803,
-0.2658372223,
-0.4868013859,
-0.7288851142,
0.832463026,
-0.5512441397,
0.1369756013,
0.401874274,
0.7607297897,
-0.0295890979,
-0.6087311506,
-0.7128480673,
-0.1826606989,
-0.1120540723,
0.0137584517,
-0.0003584609,
0.0551628284,
0.5335212946,
0.3568252027,
-0.7793186903,
-0.3205761313,
-0.5469172001,
-0.2851144075,
0.749137938,
0.3115519881,
0.4993653893,
-0.0921198949,
-0.0423668176,
-0.0941943303,
-0.6336973906,
0.547378242,
0.3685383201,
0.2178166211,
-0.3165389299,
0.2537940443,
-0.1804314703,
0.5946985483,
-0.2284971029,
0.1350374967,
0.1199750453,
-0.4375534356,
-0.1058102027,
0.027996162,
0.6199069619,
-0.2147774994,
0.7531784177,
0.0469930507,
-0.1825162917,
0.4607816637,
-0.1479539424,
-0.6372697949,
-0.5988913178,
0.1714162081,
-0.1724031717,
0.0345251672,
0.0252368618,
-0.4212681949,
-0.0726635978,
-0.6063020229,
0.1517440677,
-0.5556714535,
-0.0927818045,
0.4910548627,
0.1671011746,
-0.0415776409,
0.5712247491,
-0.9228766561,
0.6500321031,
0.9775949121,
0.3527682722,
-0.0875785425,
-0.2697183788,
-0.175605759,
-0.1607174277,
-0.4293754995,
0.8005799055,
-0.8361042142,
-0.0785427839,
-0.3961244822,
-0.0515651777,
-0.1240255162,
-0.8115026951,
0.7769284248,
0.0206941161,
0.1943556219,
-0.1468684077,
-0.4820919335,
-0.3006594181,
0.711055696,
-0.6787047386,
0.8676057458,
0.2588249743,
-0.6520492435,
-0.1740815938,
-0.7128737569,
-0.3677470386,
0.4316275418,
-0.6464604735,
-0.2040377408,
-0.1464067549,
0.2589403987,
0.0952805951,
-0.4817180932,
0.6444926262,
-0.2030088753,
-0.5199866891,
-0.0643318146,
-0.4983086586,
0.837613225,
0.2206049263,
-0.3252516687,
-0.0119830519,
-0.7204636931,
-0.0618599318,
0.1544463038,
0.0408470891,
-0.4821608663,
-0.255101651,
-0.2274547219,
0.1215582788,
0.3759981394,
-0.5568184257,
0.3675795794,
-0.3085253835,
0.4402878582,
0.5769229531,
0.0022701698,
0.3943564892,
-0.1818427593,
0.3994655609,
-0.0867474526,
0.2308793515,
0.0046745073,
-0.6682085395,
-0.3491182327,
0.3371045291,
0.2476830631,
0.6095942855,
-0.9120550752,
-0.1811694801,
-0.1831114739,
-0.4880480766,
-0.3764255047,
0.1767106354,
0.446498245,
0.7240478992,
0.3266140521,
0.2005315125,
-0.2530474663,
-0.8339388371,
-0.3205588162,
0.0436364897,
-0.0663440973,
0.5234848261,
0.5503560305,
0.196421653,
0.3517783582,
-0.5467953086,
-0.2179535925,
-0.4843592942,
0.1263618171,
0.4317495525,
0.6102377176,
0.3317035139,
-0.8209064603,
-0.3743307292,
-0.0243711341,
-0.9128000736,
0.0651520342,
-0.2397603989,
-0.4567544162,
-0.499235183,
0.4279325008,
-0.5894511342,
0.5067694783,
0.3545327187,
-0.5572917461,
0.6559157372,
-0.255238533,
-0.0966468304,
-0.6852190495,
0.2320955992,
0.29884547,
0.2068848461,
-0.5802529454,
0.06696105,
-0.0341416672,
-0.5829805136,
-0.3952088654,
0.6564361453,
-0.205918029,
0.2482543737,
0.0137338955,
0.2266537547,
-0.0259040333,
0.6563128233,
0.0358470567,
0.6786415577,
0.4946560264,
-0.4696516395,
0.7430932522,
0.2919171154,
-0.5918984413,
0.2668232024,
-0.7051589489,
0.0299812071,
-0.087556012,
0.2228899598,
-0.7105748057,
-0.2033699602,
0.3240661919,
-0.5531273484,
-0.1336134076,
-0.0065125776,
-0.177986905,
-0.3659515977,
-0.141980812,
0.8230134845,
0.1038312986,
-0.2747178972,
0.4668828249,
0.25042364,
-0.1495651007,
-0.7006376982,
-0.3317102492,
-0.0428262688,
-0.0511357076,
-0.8755164146,
0.4278939068,
-0.2289309651,
-0.5608451366,
0.2260118127,
-0.1730443835,
-0.1517880559,
0.3366046846,
0.0765928328,
0.1771849394,
-0.305782795,
0.05635399,
-0.0630102679,
-0.4664867818,
0.2521380186,
-0.0125651639,
0.4301544428,
-0.1984602809,
-0.096857667,
-0.5632199049,
0.2915863395,
0.5330141187,
-0.3660160303,
0.3708625734,
0.0973497033,
-0.9674716592,
-0.3965180218,
0.1521384269,
-0.2636847198,
-0.4316206574,
0.2704553306,
-0.6582895517,
-0.5378181338,
0.6508463621,
-0.2875041068,
0.1268542409,
0.4814925492,
0.3770599365,
-0.0533036031,
0.9982296228,
0.2564942837,
-0.123100087,
0.1562879682,
-0.6608844995,
0.2846734524,
-0.5652227402,
-0.4623498619,
-0.6258792281,
-0.6092805266,
-0.419731468,
0.0757425502,
0.1935331672,
0.1050687954,
-0.7025350332,
0.1616162062,
-0.6596308947,
0.6644918323,
0.5118275285,
0.1198462322,
0.259790659,
-0.2269525081,
0.112233974,
-0.0292342473,
-0.406470269,
-0.3633544445,
0.7083522081,
-0.022350939,
0.8265468478,
0.1962191015,
0.160478428,
0.0437355191,
0.2298967838,
-0.5095411539,
0.5210136175,
-0.6980566382,
-0.7292993069,
-0.5193734765,
-0.7028865814,
-0.9804944396,
-0.1008175761,
-0.0240616519,
-0.5914664268,
0.0434842855,
0.0059472769,
-0.5261307359,
0.2603234351,
-0.6766198277,
1.3378098011,
-0.2046084851,
-0.1181640327,
-0.0632904246,
-0.5491603613,
0.6133047938,
0.13949956,
0.494553268,
-0.3705254197,
0.3886462748,
0.6700169444,
-0.5630210638,
0.4364426136,
-0.305417031,
0.2007925808,
0.6604860425,
0.3442489207,
0.3488180637,
0.3875602186,
-0.0147896269,
-0.083878316,
0.2753300965,
-0.5834872723,
-1.0068881512,
0.7496176362,
-0.8942485452,
-0.6839390993,
-0.318358779,
-0.5976268053,
-0.1354121417,
0.0057285503,
0.1131137311,
0.6326007843,
0.3292256296,
0.1214082912,
0.4081968665,
-0.195852384,
0.2858686149,
0.0176044255,
0.1435591578,
-0.220120728,
1.1900600195,
0.3868641555,
0.0248495154,
0.0262521673,
0.5019056797,
-0.2372354418,
-0.4935325682,
-0.6222546697,
0.2105023563,
-0.6215700507,
-0.2097339928,
-0.1418608427,
-0.3964278996,
-0.3406835198,
0.014105767,
-0.3389183879,
-0.6743713021,
0.0896999538,
0.1879407912,
0.0234692022,
0.6569483876,
0.0875683203,
0.0953942984,
-0.554726541,
0.5206186771,
0.2056937814,
0.3329842985,
0.0957452059,
-0.3592490554,
-0.1750808805,
0.0156385079,
-0.3422507048,
-0.4765533209,
0.1826963276,
0.1585244238,
0.4763430655,
0.3087057471,
0.3194980919,
0.4770245552,
-0.0939867347,
0.7626174092,
-0.2728195786,
-1.0478491783,
0.6179756522,
-0.0992990062,
0.4391606748,
0.6002084017,
0.3287184536,
-0.7244964838,
-0.1737138629,
-0.7352104187,
-0.5343424082,
0.6835843325,
0.3750223219,
0.1375323087,
0.270455271,
0.7703668475,
0.1675784439,
-0.1881752759,
-0.3572524488,
-0.374071449,
-0.1237447634,
-0.7867594361,
0.1307209432,
0.2901207209,
0.0372623019,
-0.3980432749,
0.5039215088,
-0.1951264888,
-0.1222413555,
-0.1126769632,
-0.0115882568,
0.0147626502,
0.019110173,
0.6589827538,
0.7606322169,
-0.144473657,
0.304439187,
0.2545757592,
-0.9181088209,
0.0296111777,
0.257719785,
-0.0663820505,
-0.2777388692,
0.7460862398,
0.2936885059,
0.0230947714,
-0.8339238763,
0.4682203531,
-0.3561568856,
-0.1925358176,
-0.3442747593,
0.0561132804,
-0.0703711584,
0.042593319,
0.4691658616,
0.1581276804,
0.1591606587,
-0.5041501522,
0.1944233775,
0.0860866159,
-0.1526445597,
-0.6214471459,
0.5760653615,
0.1678948849,
-0.2757462263,
0.9909843206,
-0.2448520064,
-0.613078177,
1.1018730402,
0.3870820701,
0.4309525192,
-0.0888530016,
0.0302671883,
0.6267650723,
0.1401758641,
-0.0325001366,
0.4558495581,
-0.0316047259,
-0.9400784373,
-0.5962013602,
-0.011016761,
-0.7962828279,
0.3827770948,
-0.3683051765,
0.353243649,
-0.9102373123,
0.2716939747,
0.1849350929,
0.4961692691,
-0.7236365676,
0.5412325263,
0.2419464886,
0.977345705,
-0.7641285658,
0.8122698665,
0.7525941133,
-0.2183636874,
-1.0922231674,
-0.3267051578,
-0.1066654697,
-0.7415390611,
0.5947232842,
0.1081176549,
0.1858212203,
-0.2496061921,
-0.9312711358,
-0.6159097552,
0.7385085821,
0.56020087,
-0.5081472993,
-0.1406994909,
0.3204035759,
0.4213294685,
-0.3746064603,
0.2429570258,
0.675614655,
0.4439182281,
0.162055701,
-0.6625736952,
0.0673490465,
-0.4647231102,
-0.5808464885,
0.1962215304,
-0.7817433476,
1.0921133757,
-0.2256776094,
-0.1758094132,
-0.2611606419,
0.5998940468,
0.4756370485,
0.8396461606,
0.2998514771,
0.5810451508,
0.8114317656,
-0.2046039253,
0.8623738289,
-0.4637618959,
0.4212519825,
1.1321223974,
0.1874442101,
0.4965707362,
-0.1057986692,
-0.1437961906,
0.247240603,
0.8749499321,
0.2638379335,
0.3406582773,
0.4667154849,
-0.4060814977,
-0.664247036,
0.0142252585,
-0.4409683347,
0.4774662256,
0.5988783836,
0.3469393849,
-0.505382061,
-0.0637670308,
0.0336946063,
0.3503818512,
-0.4008416831,
0.396656096,
0.2591671348,
-0.4847810268,
0.5564464331,
-0.0647876635,
0.3505049348,
-0.2905358076,
-0.4015521705,
-0.6997094154,
0.3682987392,
-0.1483913511,
-1.0516049862,
0.5050951242,
-0.007656021,
0.1641201973,
0.1846086979,
0.5351966619,
-0.4262315631,
-0.7294102907,
-0.073753722,
0.5010959506,
0.3785018027,
-0.1310007572,
-0.9496155381,
0.0963610634,
0.0137084965,
-0.0719840229,
-0.0171531849,
1.168240428,
-0.5955405235,
0.8258880377,
0.651165545,
-0.0457046963,
-0.3083418906,
0.1541696042,
0.9457678795,
-0.7736538053,
-0.1824235767,
-0.9322491288,
0.1564852893,
0.1112812757,
-0.6815427542,
0.3869586885,
0.6973630786,
1.089461565,
0.2537901402,
0.7203185558,
0.290556103,
0.3444190621,
-0.1988389194,
0.5013798475,
-0.1409146637,
0.2976548374,
-0.1920678318,
-0.7234966755,
-0.6680736542,
0.5601006746,
-0.507302165,
-0.2356621921,
0.4801399112,
0.2638334036,
-0.0500011072,
0.2874140739,
0.3607715666,
0.0378281511,
0.648385644,
1.2845835686,
0.8131144047,
-0.4628821313,
0.7053955197,
-0.5189452767,
-0.1738256514,
0.3469246626,
-0.303093642,
-0.8379712105,
-0.3929917514,
-0.1695414335,
-0.1692718714,
-0.0230258629,
0.8885560632,
0.4237665534,
-1.0210373402,
-0.0645072386,
-0.2256299257,
0.4219505787,
-0.2496325076,
-0.1770604253,
0.8547554016,
-0.2121549696,
-0.8212730289,
0.0691470206,
0.0082528787,
0.0258397348,
-0.0728807151,
-0.0993749127,
0.1135105565,
-0.0272597764,
0.1676372737,
0.3149040937,
-0.4053783119,
-0.4452427328,
0.1711830497,
0.0166095719,
0.064871043,
0.9430876374,
-0.828181684,
0.4174359143,
0.5768590569,
0.712184608,
0.4160345197,
0.1805535406,
0.2773447633,
-0.1862864047,
0.1965266615,
0.3830918074,
0.2687567174,
0.240850687,
-0.4861778915,
0.5467413664,
0.5566494465,
-0.3880636394,
-0.6379065514,
-0.0147168441,
-0.7363388538,
-0.4344880581,
0.6154409051,
-0.2722274363,
-0.3306748569,
-0.2989365757,
-0.3561825156,
0.1104350835,
-0.4118005335,
0.7853906751,
0.941139102,
-0.5528799891,
-0.4153445959,
-0.6250017285,
0.6956977844,
0.3497955203,
-0.981248796,
0.2513771653,
0.0356320627,
0.0691167638,
0.0891072303,
0.1997346431,
-0.0738048553,
0.4120965302,
0.0995249599,
-0.2219699025,
-0.151216805,
-0.5115564466,
0.0677336752,
0.3427776694,
-0.3514026999,
-0.1417150646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05112v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05112v5
|
A Survey of Large Language Models in Medicine: Progress, Application, and Challenge
| 2023-11-09T02:55:58 | 2024-05-15T13:38:45 |
Hongjian Zhou, Fenglin Liu, Boyang Gu, Xinyu Zou, Jinfa Huang, Jinge Wu, Yiru Li, Sam S. Chen, Peilin Zhou, Junling Liu, Yining Hua, Chengfeng Mao, Chenyu You, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng, Lei Clifton, Zheng Li, Jiebo Luo, David A. Clifton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have received substantial
attention due to their capabilities for understanding and generating human
language. While there has been a burgeoning trend in research focusing on the
employment of LLMs in supporting different medical tasks (e.g., enhancing
clinical diagnostics and providing medical education), a review of these
efforts, particularly their development, practical applications, and outcomes
in medicine, remains scarce. Therefore, this review aims to provide a detailed
overview of the development and deployment of LLMs in medicine, including the
challenges and opportunities they face. In terms of development, we provide a
detailed introduction to the principles of existing medical LLMs, including
their basic model structures, number of parameters, and sources and scales of
data used for model development. It serves as a guide for practitioners in
developing medical LLMs tailored to their specific needs. In terms of
deployment, we offer a comparison of the performance of different LLMs across
various medical tasks, and further compare them with state-of-the-art
lightweight models, aiming to provide an understanding of the advantages and
limitations of LLMs in medicine. Overall, in this review, we address the
following questions: 1) What are the practices for developing medical LLMs 2)
How to measure the medical task performance of LLMs in a medical setting? 3)
How have medical LLMs been employed in real-world practice? 4) What challenges
arise from the use of medical LLMs? and 5) How to more effectively develop and
deploy medical LLMs? By answering these questions, this review aims to provide
insights into the opportunities for LLMs in medicine and serve as a practical
resource. We also maintain a regularly updated list of practical guides on
medical LLMs at: https://github.com/AI-in-Health/MedLLMsPracticalGuide.
|
[
-0.1096632257,
-0.8108068109,
0.9208715558,
-0.0444537401,
-0.183255747,
0.0660284609,
-0.4629770517,
-0.4536436498,
0.0772552118,
0.7124266624,
-0.392439872,
-0.5360607505,
-0.9334678054,
0.0676738173,
-0.321868062,
0.747251153,
-0.07635919,
0.5175583959,
-0.1679536104,
-0.0369614027,
-0.4851671755,
-0.6643702984,
-0.7110999823,
-0.4852418005,
0.5510701537,
0.1391509175,
0.6750570536,
0.4812518358,
0.953179121,
0.3208284974,
-0.4583071768,
0.042469345,
-0.286883384,
0.3519622386,
0.0362130217,
-0.4259943664,
-0.4314156473,
-0.1042892113,
0.7105501294,
1.2382798195,
-0.4529806972,
-0.0232328176,
-0.168003276,
0.4610818923,
-0.215513438,
0.0399942063,
-0.2623184621,
0.0671305805,
-0.3146544993,
0.0419372283,
-0.1272796392,
-0.3383769691,
0.2051647156,
-0.1663666368,
-0.1270487458,
0.0852293894,
0.3658900261,
0.0169424135,
-0.7851658463,
-0.6361080408,
-0.724324882,
0.6563852429,
-0.9975192547,
0.3970044255,
-0.0370010026,
0.3964737654,
-0.506732285,
-0.7690341473,
-0.2393204868,
-0.5881187916,
0.175416857,
-0.1075688452,
0.134599939,
0.2550207078,
-0.0108187227,
0.5903507471,
-0.6725230813,
0.4374691844,
-0.4985682666,
0.1059773043,
0.4700694978,
0.5563016534,
0.5587899685,
0.1065766588,
-0.1100092009,
0.3540658057,
-0.9980524778,
-0.4709407091,
-0.1619294882,
0.0559413061,
-0.2829603255,
0.935170114,
0.1015278548,
0.5975543261,
-0.4271114767,
-0.5486491919,
0.0693693832,
-0.2980513871,
-0.2886979878,
-0.2966694832,
0.8377780914,
0.3055479228,
0.0863488019,
-0.0301556047,
-0.2533354461,
-0.1221589595,
0.2244358808,
-0.69537431,
0.1412616819,
0.3236021698,
-0.7272460461,
-0.2810942233,
-0.7101727128,
-0.4411125481,
-0.7521730065,
-0.2535090148,
0.0108720986,
-0.2815276384,
-0.311948061,
0.3170247674,
0.1736699939,
0.3249266446,
0.4797493517,
-0.7772284746,
0.4515984952,
0.8829938769,
0.8312373161,
-0.2207565308,
-0.040276058,
0.0527901724,
-0.1155037358,
-0.5970057845,
0.6185814738,
-0.2963043749,
-0.5804261565,
0.3402924538,
0.0383000821,
-0.1155840382,
-0.8769973516,
0.4278917909,
-0.228072077,
-0.0314206891,
-0.1305402964,
-0.7298800945,
0.0060611642,
0.4593483508,
-0.3600281179,
0.4651545882,
-0.0385360122,
-0.4939087331,
0.1095370278,
-0.6497160792,
-0.4823453128,
0.1997796893,
-0.3276328444,
-0.2414125204,
0.3492805064,
-0.1165185943,
0.7584060431,
-0.8614292741,
0.3487173021,
-0.1448561996,
-0.1759587526,
0.3570037186,
-0.1820498556,
0.71702528,
0.4419993162,
0.0970138088,
0.2157641202,
-0.3882914782,
-0.2313352674,
0.3729957938,
-0.4407316148,
0.0280255731,
0.4738411605,
0.0100882975,
-0.0785408244,
0.1844429374,
-0.3360999227,
0.4256264865,
-0.3911005855,
0.6589978933,
0.1715870947,
0.1657486409,
0.193815589,
-0.3522622883,
0.6647831202,
-0.2797961235,
0.4718252718,
-0.2694172859,
-0.6167747974,
-0.3967999816,
-0.3075099587,
0.2246423364,
0.4985301197,
-0.3968835771,
0.0598489419,
-0.0340746306,
-0.7259942293,
-0.5232117176,
0.219029367,
0.1219788864,
0.3889223337,
-0.0352133475,
-0.116116032,
-0.2383504212,
-0.8396282792,
-0.044357717,
-0.1663045287,
0.008799566,
0.4632522762,
0.4864431918,
-0.6042270064,
0.2652676105,
-0.4507028759,
-0.1541819572,
-0.5772522092,
-0.1616003513,
0.2535500526,
0.3949491978,
0.4782327712,
-0.7038593292,
-0.2901803553,
0.2295214236,
-0.8022964597,
-0.0678703114,
0.2528258562,
0.2748771012,
-0.0880493969,
0.4497710168,
-0.6794313788,
-0.0718956739,
0.9828108549,
-0.219632104,
0.4429790676,
-0.3526026905,
0.1478239894,
-1.110904932,
0.1119802073,
0.133017391,
-0.3388445377,
-0.7337142825,
0.3194518089,
-0.1676904857,
-0.2076032609,
-0.4449980259,
0.6223263741,
-0.476482302,
0.1627730131,
-0.4456905723,
0.1939697713,
-0.5040737987,
-0.1376603097,
-0.0465650372,
0.4780141711,
0.6697137356,
-0.4624044299,
0.5771583319,
0.0650306046,
-0.4317584336,
0.5451494455,
-0.8117427826,
-0.1288807988,
0.0054307431,
0.218199268,
-0.8049699068,
-0.3009643257,
0.230271548,
-0.2306554914,
0.3947553933,
-0.2818543911,
-0.6406077147,
-0.4228510857,
0.0780097246,
0.493625015,
0.9147191048,
-0.0439483412,
0.1854077131,
0.7240160108,
-0.5204728246,
-0.2029344141,
-0.7006064653,
0.3222010136,
-0.1588667035,
-0.4747070372,
0.0846372172,
-0.0753965899,
-0.5374330878,
-0.3201248944,
0.0667151883,
-0.0718771517,
0.1584306806,
0.1554573029,
0.2336414307,
-0.3028876781,
0.306996733,
-0.1973723769,
0.0646525696,
0.1966294795,
0.0115383146,
0.4217098653,
0.1272971779,
-0.614058435,
-0.2207046747,
0.4799346626,
0.6619099379,
0.0594281219,
0.6105451584,
0.2657568157,
-0.4284970164,
0.081825912,
-0.763456881,
-0.0912818909,
-0.3636147082,
0.5695743561,
0.1201832965,
-0.9464695454,
0.3788425922,
-0.5076687336,
0.2682997286,
0.3302767873,
1.0282407999,
-0.2532158792,
0.9699658751,
0.6286951303,
0.0638014376,
0.1382737905,
-0.0022166627,
0.1529301256,
-0.9253259897,
-0.4445062578,
-0.5428366661,
-0.0647319555,
-0.7216320038,
-0.655320704,
0.5818433166,
-0.079532139,
-0.0961219966,
-0.2643617392,
-0.3454213142,
0.0807961971,
0.0935927257,
-0.0787554309,
0.2657189667,
-0.3993997574,
-0.1137157977,
0.1153042987,
-0.7064688206,
-0.5596396923,
1.0937917233,
0.6807525158,
1.1182695627,
0.1431093216,
0.5178061724,
0.1238250658,
0.345511198,
-0.8682186604,
0.5024555922,
-0.2992775738,
-0.6524968147,
-0.1777051687,
-0.3722964525,
-0.9757908583,
0.2763091624,
-0.1850368232,
-0.6768656373,
-0.3911600709,
0.1367140412,
-0.0987213179,
0.3218723536,
-0.5617602468,
0.8231892586,
-0.5485543013,
-0.0219006464,
-0.2774412334,
-0.6832624078,
0.4673847258,
-0.1834039837,
0.3557204008,
-0.2938607335,
-0.3734526634,
0.577349484,
-0.3750398159,
0.8650323749,
-0.0812157094,
-0.3709774613,
0.255920887,
-0.1633995622,
0.3334740102,
-0.0643107593,
0.08449395,
0.2313754112,
0.2348618358,
-0.270706743,
-0.3144584894,
0.7618061304,
-0.4595765173,
-0.67687428,
-0.4067255855,
-0.6263394356,
-0.3423544765,
0.1530299634,
-0.0865513459,
0.385990113,
-0.3937641382,
0.2537777424,
0.736204803,
-0.549521327,
0.1993197501,
0.5225588083,
-0.5994573832,
-0.1930654347,
0.4935578406,
0.1016354114,
0.3063153625,
0.3169045746,
0.3271526098,
-0.389608264,
-1.1786308289,
-0.257836014,
0.5399143696,
-0.546200037,
0.1779972613,
-0.339296937,
-0.3766021729,
-0.3971589506,
-0.0849591866,
-0.3933707178,
0.0360784754,
-0.0100661824,
0.4165955484,
0.3388243616,
1.1561034918,
0.3658397794,
0.3932859302,
-0.6684474945,
0.3257379532,
0.0579947233,
0.4966209829,
-0.142793119,
-0.3301745653,
-0.2680283785,
-0.0170502551,
-0.1036514342,
-0.8081029654,
0.2891737521,
-0.1851722002,
0.6338060498,
0.3059741855,
-0.3058509529,
0.4075984359,
-0.7552229762,
0.9080345035,
0.2907231152,
-0.3961428702,
0.3256981969,
-0.5294390321,
0.3294101059,
0.1300285608,
0.4736211896,
-0.8718808293,
-0.3568829298,
-0.2648779154,
-0.7216510177,
0.2468380779,
0.030532632,
0.3047165871,
0.0224418454,
0.5289167762,
-0.158469364,
0.2378848642,
-0.3382531106,
-0.221911937,
0.674289763,
-0.2454064786,
-0.2508753836,
-0.3984149098,
-0.2225586176,
-0.0490063615,
0.4649363756,
0.0201255884,
0.244650811,
0.0675362572,
-0.0540326871,
0.2042864114,
0.516949296,
0.6866893768,
0.6201055646,
0.0343275927,
-0.0886832103,
0.2522081435,
-0.5904592276,
0.1878144443,
-0.0136295864,
0.1279057711,
-0.0090611028,
0.3442205489,
0.4870780408,
0.4381325841,
-1.0974465609,
0.639549613,
0.092464447,
-0.2153424174,
-0.2503617704,
-0.0994306952,
0.5551509261,
0.5410048366,
0.018564593,
-0.3630951643,
-0.0134861991,
-0.6153724194,
-0.2308858037,
0.5948660374,
-0.1247867644,
-0.1320869923,
0.534894824,
0.223938778,
-0.4178521037,
0.4706677794,
0.1325400621,
-0.1306376159,
0.5864135623,
0.6473461986,
0.5342310071,
-0.2115709335,
-0.1837974936,
-0.0551217571,
0.2342491746,
-0.2805864811,
0.2639044821,
0.2778935432,
-0.4661800861,
-0.5921073556,
-0.4149675667,
-0.6493182778,
0.3355492651,
-0.2030979693,
0.2971953452,
-0.3375973105,
-0.4071019292,
0.0786893964,
-0.0107759675,
-0.5351666808,
0.0634798631,
0.367917031,
0.9332797527,
-0.4251642227,
0.7118420005,
0.9406052232,
-0.1008783877,
-0.4793451428,
-0.2156580091,
0.2964878678,
-0.9363511801,
0.2690747678,
-0.3211536407,
0.1754831076,
-0.2656429708,
-0.3018343151,
-0.6003043056,
0.8556952477,
0.3661619723,
-0.7456861734,
-0.3304401636,
0.1325924993,
0.6361710429,
-0.372418642,
0.3052684069,
0.4368139803,
0.2634199858,
0.0557465516,
-1.1937289238,
-0.0578173734,
-0.0303504094,
0.0363186635,
0.1501407325,
-0.6300091147,
0.7388026714,
-0.3698650002,
0.1005878747,
0.5048379898,
-0.0157927554,
0.3288760781,
0.1737775058,
0.187453717,
0.1445371211,
0.5537747145,
-0.0990380719,
1.2240935564,
-0.3314861059,
0.30475384,
0.6838603616,
-0.5075504184,
0.8215595484,
0.493732214,
-0.3634063303,
0.0127004925,
0.5064860582,
-0.1247582436,
-0.0364172719,
0.5505623817,
-0.4558333158,
-0.1123927832,
-0.2692046165,
-0.4245111942,
0.2375772744,
0.5934401155,
-0.6831659079,
-0.2060742974,
0.2294377238,
0.0574676767,
-0.0989909768,
-0.4700791836,
0.7947492003,
0.4742500484,
-0.4903460741,
0.4305702746,
0.1493997574,
0.4029734731,
-0.926197052,
-0.0809449479,
-0.0090989834,
0.1835155934,
-0.136490494,
-0.7301914096,
0.1081826165,
0.2208274454,
-0.0405517295,
-0.1123445183,
0.6736656427,
-0.2306777686,
-0.4860913157,
0.0820368528,
0.7309666276,
0.3778272569,
0.2459822595,
-0.4697470963,
0.3350892067,
-0.3211094141,
-0.3489313126,
0.4720100462,
0.2809923291,
0.0132666072,
1.0748310089,
0.2436397225,
0.6008402109,
0.1351614147,
0.1355185509,
0.6538642049,
-0.8314566612,
0.005952544,
-0.9470879436,
0.2617399395,
0.2655948699,
-0.119913809,
0.4200248122,
0.5271611214,
0.294752419,
-0.0090763485,
0.8098894954,
0.0185659677,
0.5692177415,
-0.5082075,
0.7977644205,
-0.6371888518,
0.2554306686,
-0.0670418292,
-0.5156431794,
-0.5960140824,
0.3734977543,
-0.2041763514,
0.1888744533,
0.6358965635,
0.6489716172,
0.0799186155,
-0.2445921898,
0.5729455352,
0.3524690866,
0.3312815428,
0.5152614117,
0.9999332428,
-0.1459528506,
0.2984565496,
-0.014651197,
-0.0480220281,
-0.3524572253,
-0.7137438059,
-0.7606442571,
-0.2764977813,
-0.3874182403,
0.0075642732,
0.1727073342,
1.036899209,
0.8972136974,
-0.5479242206,
-0.4516817629,
0.1670858264,
0.0368189625,
-0.1122603416,
-0.0837081969,
0.2205446959,
-0.3201357126,
-0.7492089272,
0.4981494248,
0.2869455814,
0.24746418,
-0.484803915,
-0.0714086965,
-0.2040093392,
0.0495760515,
0.6601845026,
0.3033635914,
-0.8603169918,
0.0849382654,
-0.1588199884,
-0.3624681532,
-0.0039972989,
1.1016700268,
-0.3614034951,
0.2245769054,
0.2887419164,
0.8017493486,
0.3112041354,
-0.5010816455,
0.5849266052,
-0.2812832594,
-0.0531205609,
0.4535800517,
0.6055440307,
0.3332205713,
-0.0837004185,
0.4501591027,
0.0453325957,
-0.7679718137,
-0.9992156029,
0.1135939807,
-0.9223741293,
-0.2660492957,
1.2405024767,
-0.0130539425,
0.076883845,
-0.1369420588,
-0.4236828685,
0.0930024534,
0.0719569698,
0.4433740973,
0.5156437159,
-0.2808896303,
-0.1086261123,
-1.0916342735,
0.3121787906,
0.2455455512,
-0.8513615131,
0.0108361188,
0.41535303,
0.6057457924,
-0.2327603996,
0.890473187,
-0.4728292525,
0.0667598397,
-0.2120037228,
0.0644757599,
0.1772705764,
-0.0195296016,
-0.4674347937,
0.1588308811,
0.6566714644,
0.0136273718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05089v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05089v1
|
Legal-HNet: Mixing Legal Long-Context Tokens with Hartley Transform
| 2023-11-09T01:27:54 | 2023-11-09T01:27:54 |
Daniele Giofré, Sneha Ghantasala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Since its introduction, the transformers architecture has seen great adoption
in NLP applications, but it also has limitations. Although the self-attention
mechanism allows for generating very rich representations of the input text,
its effectiveness may be limited in specialized domains such as legal, where,
for example, language models often have to process very long texts. In this
paper, we explore alternatives to replace the attention-based layers with
simpler token-mixing mechanisms: Hartley and Fourier transforms. Using these
non-parametric techniques, we train models with long input documents from
scratch in the legal domain setting. We also introduce a new hybrid Seq2Seq
architecture, a no-attention-based encoder connected with an attention-based
decoder, which performs quite well on existing summarization tasks with much
less compute and memory requirements. We believe that similar, if not better
performance, as in the case of long correlations of abstractive text
summarization tasks, can be achieved by adopting these simpler infrastructures.
This not only makes training models from scratch accessible to more people, but
also contributes to the reduction of the carbon footprint during training.
|
[
-0.2146762758,
-0.3610851765,
0.4610126019,
0.3981873989,
-0.4812996387,
0.089781858,
-0.1057573259,
-0.5580708981,
0.6690068245,
0.7598210573,
-0.0927893966,
-0.15913634,
-0.5939691067,
0.0094190715,
-0.6682633162,
1.1498838663,
-0.0079634367,
-0.0250192061,
-0.3543796837,
-0.5006995797,
-0.2508459985,
-0.7004556656,
-0.7437580824,
-0.3714868128,
0.5817636847,
-0.0947515815,
0.7467015386,
0.5150111318,
0.6390971541,
0.2379172742,
-0.1442045867,
-0.0198076908,
-0.3124472499,
0.1074472144,
-0.4067908823,
-0.1999151707,
-0.6303826571,
-0.1798521131,
0.5645002723,
0.5841701031,
-0.1225498915,
0.3034646809,
-0.0199366231,
0.8224802613,
-0.9396307468,
0.1359182,
-0.2808006704,
0.4104419351,
-0.0651189834,
-0.5210102797,
-0.4317895472,
0.3025565743,
-0.0088625131,
-0.519117713,
0.1641858369,
0.2155081332,
0.5463309288,
0.5625101924,
-0.74316293,
-0.0636395663,
-0.7196837664,
0.540176332,
-0.8713579178,
0.5440418124,
0.2671200335,
0.3630612195,
0.2057893127,
-1.0692769289,
-0.6522110701,
0.0161819626,
-0.4282541573,
0.5958790183,
-0.1936904937,
0.2641907632,
0.1627518684,
0.1680053473,
-0.5194476843,
-0.0026333907,
-0.4241484702,
-0.0473558158,
0.529713273,
0.2952380776,
0.0918937325,
-0.3149317503,
-0.3139851093,
0.0283604451,
-0.5538078547,
0.0245662183,
0.2355082929,
0.2302687913,
-0.3072657287,
0.7066863179,
-0.1616266817,
0.4185022414,
0.2223746032,
-0.0166605879,
0.2441573143,
-0.2843895853,
-0.6606688499,
0.0023307274,
0.7559122443,
-0.017276939,
-0.1358741969,
-0.3068014681,
-0.3193906844,
-0.2829747796,
0.396088779,
-0.6301751137,
0.1425904185,
0.6793335676,
-0.7231814861,
-0.289517343,
-0.1613630503,
-0.6384558678,
-0.2705154121,
-0.7329308391,
0.3721401989,
-0.1130639538,
-0.0365611576,
0.4231057763,
-0.4726579189,
0.7015247941,
0.3252439797,
-1.1318770647,
0.4809599817,
0.8384191394,
0.6757257581,
-0.2563295662,
-0.0984012336,
-0.7971017361,
0.2260880172,
-0.1187489405,
0.318405211,
-0.1226653606,
-0.0857854411,
0.0863217413,
-0.1480834782,
0.0066314251,
-0.3953336775,
0.2905716896,
-0.8177115321,
0.2614445686,
0.0669102371,
-0.3391100466,
0.0118536279,
0.212278232,
-0.6439236403,
1.1901922226,
0.3005387187,
-1.0336266756,
0.2915661335,
-0.9709866643,
-1.0687776804,
0.3154090345,
-0.209501341,
-0.4431522191,
0.0272679031,
0.2151109427,
0.4919015765,
-0.3276918828,
0.5462405086,
-0.1276053637,
-0.3895778358,
-0.0522319078,
-0.2311565727,
1.2589299679,
0.2554036677,
-0.7063094974,
0.4118146598,
-0.6878091097,
-0.3157591522,
-0.0773274004,
-0.4482066929,
-0.1229167953,
-0.0788794532,
0.4136306643,
0.4107175171,
0.1644346267,
-0.3632294238,
-0.3340604007,
-0.504755497,
0.7227019668,
0.4089814723,
0.0207379404,
0.60289222,
-0.2832793593,
0.628651619,
0.1302241981,
0.2076672912,
-0.2066069245,
-0.2665807307,
-1.1637215614,
-0.1506870389,
0.6267986298,
0.466753453,
-0.9146988988,
0.602470696,
-0.5517163277,
-0.1017307937,
-0.6856153607,
0.0403595679,
-0.0147184497,
0.3658550978,
0.5841894746,
-0.2179077715,
-0.4679738581,
-1.021748662,
-0.2730205655,
-0.1232088953,
-0.0715109855,
0.2022947818,
0.8161637187,
-0.0899627358,
1.0050327778,
0.0139016956,
-0.394558847,
-0.4719691873,
0.127705127,
0.2399659157,
0.4009747505,
0.5252079368,
-0.7866847515,
-0.6163291931,
0.1340474337,
-0.9330499172,
0.2954879701,
-0.5981789231,
0.0006563732,
0.0556231067,
0.8019481301,
-0.6424978971,
0.4550488591,
0.1281012595,
-0.2565314174,
0.1845677644,
-0.2669921815,
-0.1358685493,
-1.013384223,
0.2690553069,
-0.2115133852,
-0.743036747,
-0.6460328102,
0.6284843087,
0.4692339301,
-0.2528226972,
-1.0053117275,
0.6011610627,
-0.5336129069,
-0.0810050443,
-0.2685067952,
-0.1175047308,
0.0510118119,
0.8732055426,
0.0730365664,
0.7413318753,
0.4420197606,
-0.4600897431,
0.3244899511,
0.3049832582,
0.0528029203,
0.5282822251,
-0.7932243347,
0.2223102152,
-0.5786995888,
0.3018250763,
-0.568769455,
-0.2708537281,
0.246803388,
-0.2919403017,
0.4034971893,
-0.0811195076,
-0.6442554593,
-0.3192384541,
-0.4840780497,
0.5584625602,
0.8355600834,
-0.6345635653,
1.117442131,
0.2527498305,
0.1785744131,
-0.6987527609,
-1.0878674984,
0.5677111745,
-0.3210240304,
-0.6041820049,
0.536038518,
0.2787600458,
0.0136349034,
0.245523572,
0.0084738797,
-0.0399987586,
0.0016699105,
0.2219685763,
-0.0982463434,
-0.3217812777,
0.0535200797,
0.3201023042,
-0.0129385814,
0.1413591504,
-0.5654171705,
0.2636877596,
0.1963507235,
-0.1542184651,
-0.6988385916,
0.6271697283,
0.8178833127,
-0.5998855829,
0.6653700471,
0.3053356111,
-0.255679518,
-0.2771514654,
-0.4985512793,
-0.0459893867,
-0.504833281,
0.2258137017,
-0.0923929363,
-1.2018812895,
0.4068723321,
0.1554757208,
0.1208315343,
0.584446609,
0.7919992805,
-0.4222096205,
0.2967107296,
0.489708215,
-0.0800290629,
0.5118304491,
-0.0815826431,
0.4169669151,
-0.8418349624,
-0.0383541547,
-0.2815411389,
-0.3220355511,
-0.4900198877,
-0.3642798066,
0.4593809545,
-0.4740644097,
-0.1915178597,
0.6385287642,
-0.1093622148,
0.6316627264,
0.7010928988,
0.0204145983,
0.0470247865,
-0.0603633188,
0.0282671358,
0.1758942306,
-0.7977890372,
-0.0051518441,
1.1352267265,
0.5508315563,
0.4464623928,
0.0886197239,
1.0283589363,
0.4734834433,
0.0480999611,
-1.0192668438,
0.4184971452,
-0.1350211054,
-0.699326098,
-0.486733228,
-0.4252337515,
-0.8434536457,
0.463023603,
-0.2854542136,
-0.1415595859,
0.3716619909,
-0.0380190685,
-0.7221420407,
0.1719457507,
-0.2413892001,
0.6898652911,
-0.1891722977,
-0.6112936139,
-0.17063348,
-0.8556967974,
0.1328471452,
-0.2259478271,
0.1735582203,
0.2112375945,
0.2010977268,
0.8931122422,
-0.5781051517,
0.9134967327,
-0.0965083241,
0.0214793272,
0.5127284527,
-0.0753800869,
0.5145418644,
0.0023338804,
0.243649438,
-0.0771850869,
0.0006068755,
-0.4472762048,
-0.7483395934,
0.0833022147,
-0.6019507051,
-0.6127305031,
-0.4658410847,
-0.3697218895,
-0.1226955503,
0.4616073966,
-0.0062816874,
0.2256224304,
0.1320394725,
0.6287683249,
0.3511937559,
0.0485408828,
0.6624763608,
0.331805557,
0.0868805274,
-0.5601628423,
0.5810908675,
-0.040179193,
-0.0790425763,
0.5355226994,
0.0555684604,
-0.4525657296,
-0.561132133,
-0.2537181973,
0.3510073125,
-0.8688674569,
-0.2841094136,
-0.9262286425,
-0.339931637,
-0.5659329891,
-0.0980626494,
-0.3118776381,
-0.6803556681,
-0.2592110336,
-0.0742906854,
-0.169033736,
0.2960295975,
0.1583495438,
0.4879051745,
-0.6917188168,
0.5237008333,
0.4754043818,
0.2515613735,
0.0291056801,
-0.7408591509,
-0.4248065054,
-0.3508233726,
-0.1246638596,
-0.6028187871,
0.3436483443,
-0.0381219462,
0.2782628536,
0.1374824047,
0.1064849645,
0.5083943605,
-0.5997319818,
0.7573277354,
0.4094667137,
-1.1106770039,
0.1269047111,
-0.5073968172,
0.1837690026,
0.7964725494,
0.0384927243,
-0.718668282,
-0.4582670927,
-0.4843984544,
-0.9626122713,
0.6376992464,
0.5801544189,
0.5513291955,
0.150199458,
0.454657644,
-0.1940748096,
0.2873319089,
-0.955975771,
-0.0759244636,
-0.2886230946,
-0.3358785212,
0.2606630325,
-0.232113868,
-0.196736306,
-0.440556109,
0.5299158692,
-0.0936076045,
0.3064099252,
0.2409838885,
-0.211910814,
0.2539109588,
0.3295671046,
0.5365228653,
0.4695090353,
-0.0694047883,
0.3404361606,
0.1343539059,
-0.1885067821,
0.2871475518,
-0.3886817694,
-0.2427328527,
-0.0516710803,
0.5583049059,
0.8123344779,
0.333807081,
-0.4253051579,
0.7851709127,
0.0590347201,
-0.6577038765,
-0.5458812714,
-0.0320659615,
0.3123649061,
0.2519399822,
0.1295672506,
0.0998570919,
0.5830155015,
-0.3693298995,
0.256824851,
0.1709091216,
-0.3908967078,
-0.0877738744,
1.04639256,
0.451182276,
-0.3015492857,
0.5596884489,
-0.2848194242,
-0.2402239442,
0.6602547169,
0.5447772145,
1.1360571384,
0.4157830477,
0.1210909039,
0.0707247704,
0.3369244933,
-0.1181520596,
0.0466630049,
-0.3949969709,
-0.4424947798,
-0.5671659708,
-0.4136640131,
-0.2822331786,
0.136181578,
-0.755199194,
0.3368969858,
-0.7031684518,
-0.2089149207,
0.0920724794,
-0.7084434032,
-0.760861516,
0.198162213,
-0.0839000344,
0.7280346155,
-0.6149278283,
0.9135146737,
0.3830818534,
-0.3112469316,
-0.2835469842,
-0.0423549488,
-0.2895822525,
-0.4694081545,
0.6298499107,
0.0614356361,
-0.0814657956,
-0.0695634037,
-0.3009038866,
-0.5254454613,
1.0550794601,
0.2595827579,
-0.5926390886,
-0.4150005281,
0.4941310287,
0.7369328737,
-0.0813463479,
0.0280535817,
0.6307273507,
0.291677177,
0.0638830662,
-0.6696583629,
0.0598340854,
-0.2869914174,
-0.1420254558,
0.2038209289,
-0.6745764613,
0.7256083488,
0.2285563499,
-0.3771548271,
-0.4449850321,
0.8482933044,
-0.3290329576,
0.2077927589,
0.2356465906,
0.4984494746,
0.5156928301,
0.259536922,
1.0283241272,
-0.4880732,
0.6062988043,
1.3514276743,
-0.3659803867,
0.9317619205,
0.8504214287,
-0.2337549329,
0.1289745867,
0.3664629161,
-0.2139849067,
0.3458001018,
0.0543295369,
-0.0252795778,
-0.3045254946,
0.0963559374,
-0.0538149066,
0.4865599573,
-0.1850301772,
-0.4155574739,
-0.3100961447,
-0.1576905251,
-0.2406565696,
-0.0956909955,
-0.0654418021,
0.873326242,
0.2377527952,
-0.374207288,
0.4003887475,
0.4541377425,
0.7964226007,
-0.3230277002,
0.1616723686,
-0.3329015672,
-0.2526318729,
-0.2217038572,
-0.4820108712,
0.5267468691,
-0.0674988255,
-0.0030879625,
-0.3968916237,
0.4210870862,
-0.2908881903,
-0.3866248429,
0.5300485492,
0.3795081377,
-0.0978917181,
-0.047132168,
-0.5129080415,
-0.4792658091,
-0.3301737905,
-0.1082908958,
0.2310240716,
0.247617051,
0.0086173853,
0.246619612,
0.5799174309,
-0.0841368884,
0.0856987908,
0.0315747596,
0.6882888675,
-0.8599680662,
-0.996676445,
-0.9393818378,
0.660135448,
-0.1183179989,
-0.1904081404,
0.4283750057,
0.6663018465,
0.4538984597,
-0.2269785553,
0.7765419483,
0.2097070068,
-0.0537661389,
-0.7660264373,
0.8731908798,
-0.6102600694,
-0.0991451964,
0.1581367999,
-0.9390044808,
-0.5419893265,
0.2124779522,
0.0532239191,
-0.0826954246,
1.0074459314,
0.2384287417,
-0.3593021035,
-0.0740970969,
0.5030817986,
-0.260179162,
0.5287415981,
0.4043727219,
0.5354247093,
-0.4452186823,
0.178816691,
0.0422240756,
0.0438580662,
-0.3732259274,
-0.7464468479,
-1.2756096125,
-0.3437575996,
-0.2822842896,
-0.255741775,
-0.1230821908,
0.895347774,
0.7654713988,
-0.8872441649,
-0.2603826821,
-0.0649753362,
-0.2755174935,
-0.035959471,
-0.2009592503,
0.5661355853,
-0.5739016533,
-0.4616552293,
0.3904530108,
0.6840818524,
0.2447469532,
-0.2243934125,
0.0734561458,
0.1196410581,
0.4073888361,
0.8638581634,
0.1909557879,
-0.6800483465,
-0.2475772202,
-0.0161662474,
-0.2104786038,
0.3986411095,
1.2102751732,
-0.5138960481,
0.3823351562,
0.6285024285,
1.2286944389,
1.0230119228,
-0.1598093808,
0.3371100426,
-0.7073596716,
0.4149526656,
0.4721432924,
0.5116156936,
0.0673873127,
-0.4833309054,
0.4940930307,
0.0829807371,
-0.1619807929,
-0.5057867169,
0.0132581666,
-1.0765042305,
-0.2383956015,
1.0218223333,
0.0433534458,
-0.5658996701,
-0.3306540847,
0.0485069118,
0.0702173188,
-0.2771836221,
0.6544468403,
0.6276827455,
-0.0748225302,
-0.0286723655,
-0.5801501274,
0.3533268273,
0.6649537086,
-0.8404770494,
0.1259208173,
0.1349733621,
0.3030309379,
0.235377416,
0.8938606977,
-0.335522145,
0.4133707583,
0.0146390796,
0.0055392236,
-0.2860480547,
-0.5425891876,
-0.6135084629,
0.4456743598,
-0.3061045706,
0.1012881547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05085v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05085v2
|
Characterizing Large Language Models as Rationalizers of Knowledge-intensive Tasks
| 2023-11-09T01:04:44 | 2024-01-31T19:17:00 |
Aditi Mishra, Sajjadur Rahman, Hannah Kim, Kushan Mitra, Estevam Hruschka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are proficient at generating fluent text with
minimal task-specific supervision. Yet, their ability to provide well-grounded
rationalizations for knowledge-intensive tasks remains under-explored. Such
tasks, like commonsense multiple-choice questions, require rationales based on
world knowledge to support predictions and refute alternate options. We
consider the task of generating knowledge-guided rationalization in natural
language by using expert-written examples in a few-shot manner. Surprisingly,
crowd-workers preferred knowledge-grounded rationales over crowdsourced
rationalizations, citing their factuality, sufficiency, and comprehensive
refutations. Although LLMs-generated rationales were preferable, further
improvements in conciseness and novelty are required. In another study, we show
how rationalization of incorrect model predictions erodes humans' trust in
LLM-generated rationales. Motivated by these observations, we create a
two-stage pipeline to review task predictions and eliminate potential incorrect
decisions before rationalization, enabling trustworthy rationale generation.
|
[
-0.3223153651,
-0.7328464985,
0.8577312827,
0.0136733102,
-0.0067618801,
-0.2478000522,
-0.3845436871,
-0.264359504,
-0.2269712687,
0.7038727403,
-0.4502809346,
-0.0757128447,
-0.5982903838,
0.12973167,
-0.2812703848,
0.9554018974,
-0.0192564186,
0.0798087716,
-0.335562408,
0.0335239917,
-0.3202887774,
-0.4753355682,
-0.6878196597,
-0.602556169,
0.7410179973,
0.3565930128,
0.7671496868,
0.6650946736,
0.0487357415,
0.2905392647,
-0.0622000881,
0.4636720419,
-0.6481261253,
0.3395915329,
-0.3007292747,
-0.4680472016,
-0.1292840391,
0.3258245587,
0.3570639789,
0.8121510148,
0.0218202937,
0.2350328118,
-0.0366908871,
0.5213084817,
-0.4847882092,
0.2361500859,
-0.9914100766,
-0.3289818764,
0.0234735534,
-0.1911781877,
-0.5869736075,
-0.3116142452,
0.1846351177,
-0.7804547548,
0.104207702,
0.237679705,
0.5504775643,
0.2757561207,
-0.4915024936,
-0.2184735686,
-0.7885270715,
1.070966363,
-0.7294037342,
0.1022112668,
0.5873122215,
0.3601232469,
-0.3913808167,
-0.5178337693,
-0.6570035815,
-0.2737976611,
-0.1322275251,
-0.1549381465,
0.0271583814,
0.1791303456,
0.6363666058,
-0.1330286562,
-0.2124934345,
0.0116922166,
-0.3145132065,
-0.3668437898,
0.7629753947,
0.1072435826,
0.1293427646,
-0.1701920331,
-0.1919304281,
0.1051244885,
-0.6983121634,
0.0253920965,
0.3832212687,
0.1169601381,
0.3665180802,
0.7454075813,
-0.5179521441,
0.782360971,
0.1068511456,
-0.6026360989,
-0.2560497224,
-0.1258889586,
-0.2916717529,
-0.1390375495,
0.6668761969,
0.4514287412,
0.5879864097,
-0.2065950632,
-0.428989321,
0.179789111,
0.0722613186,
-0.797988534,
0.0031820149,
0.4198746979,
-0.2034848928,
-0.3389315605,
-0.1973665655,
-0.2836396992,
-0.666625917,
-0.7743223906,
0.1572737694,
-0.3740427792,
-0.1226635426,
0.1480001509,
-0.2170947194,
0.0497529209,
0.6220338941,
-0.6629866958,
0.0269983113,
0.9209362864,
0.4757797122,
-0.0197874103,
-0.4405331016,
-0.5691292286,
0.3983519375,
-0.4607336819,
0.7786581516,
-0.517721355,
-0.0972376987,
-0.0010140334,
-0.2614582777,
0.0008923605,
-0.4297758341,
0.6529798508,
-0.5925264955,
0.2094127685,
-0.6853461266,
-0.6513773203,
-0.3477585316,
0.4974676371,
-0.4055152833,
0.6378499269,
-0.2192017287,
-0.8647117019,
0.5658245683,
-0.5431025624,
-0.2402477413,
0.0274636168,
-0.18661955,
0.1633978933,
0.1024032161,
0.1563929915,
0.7000353932,
-0.3620280921,
0.7534097433,
-0.4577812254,
-0.0004017183,
0.4593932331,
-0.5556349754,
0.650562048,
0.2499922365,
-0.1637371182,
0.2749530673,
-0.6302864552,
0.0333072469,
-0.0137055945,
-0.33184883,
-0.3502353132,
0.1845565438,
-0.1344101429,
0.3480774164,
0.1026229039,
-0.4299537241,
0.0822171122,
-0.2910736203,
0.470916152,
0.8846045732,
0.0489166379,
0.6649323106,
-0.6071693301,
0.4311305285,
-0.0995183811,
-0.0842668042,
-0.208329007,
-0.4881847203,
-0.8714436293,
-0.263441354,
-0.102790527,
0.4147387743,
-0.6753950715,
0.0925096646,
-0.3171238899,
-0.5930328965,
-0.1877618581,
0.2676061988,
0.2675399482,
0.7221183181,
0.1596885473,
0.3370723128,
-0.5411303639,
-1.0081182718,
-0.510186851,
-0.268733263,
-0.1580591947,
0.1095488742,
0.4313928187,
-0.2476081401,
1.1276720762,
-0.3482739925,
0.0071806489,
-0.3183633685,
0.325653851,
0.0047670472,
0.6001163125,
0.1748559177,
-0.5634070635,
-0.3338384628,
-0.035255339,
-0.6580585241,
-0.053483665,
-0.3884707689,
-0.255951196,
0.3803273439,
0.3465924859,
-1.0568315983,
0.0440985858,
0.3028111756,
-0.2959523499,
0.5673980117,
-0.0285918638,
0.0762337223,
-0.8974076509,
0.2634328604,
0.0331510454,
-0.3032126129,
-0.7039453387,
0.027724281,
-0.1959340125,
0.0344231538,
-0.1768615693,
0.7422990203,
-0.3230017424,
0.0338951237,
-0.2366155982,
0.2485857159,
0.109953627,
0.2960859537,
0.2277362049,
0.4536905289,
0.3152495027,
-0.4074816108,
0.2177069038,
0.0093222298,
-0.2930732667,
0.4573104978,
-0.6490795612,
0.1117009744,
-0.3463122249,
0.3605114818,
-0.7872888446,
-0.723534584,
0.0484656543,
-0.4242475033,
0.0148295444,
-0.2869563699,
-0.5813556314,
-0.2234595418,
-0.0212467872,
0.271296978,
0.6301801205,
-0.3937712312,
0.6067706943,
0.3632169366,
-0.2344622463,
-0.5740258098,
-0.6312901378,
-0.1041362658,
-0.0795869976,
-0.8759347796,
-0.2253785878,
-0.0482628644,
-0.7892609239,
-0.2715397477,
-0.1707277149,
-0.2581962347,
0.1528159231,
0.234030053,
0.3215755224,
0.0583510511,
0.1642435342,
0.1156721339,
-0.1140120178,
0.3753955364,
-0.428072691,
0.2398269624,
0.100260146,
-0.4029089212,
-0.3130996227,
0.3908358216,
0.8962759972,
-0.107163392,
0.5628919005,
0.5349146724,
-0.6619052291,
-0.300335288,
-1.0682541132,
-0.3362778127,
-0.4054832757,
0.1851365864,
-0.0857654437,
-1.1378933191,
0.468172133,
0.0623554774,
0.5145823956,
0.4440604746,
0.6371079087,
-0.0116448319,
1.1451448202,
0.0755286068,
0.0562314428,
-0.1161734611,
0.0064956206,
0.1957927048,
-0.4575577676,
-0.1918543726,
-0.4264581501,
-0.1389717907,
-0.0958753973,
-0.6092233062,
0.115438655,
0.3328069746,
-0.2709802687,
-0.0145967165,
-0.3704808652,
0.6058038473,
0.488517195,
-0.2245616615,
0.3386874795,
-0.1396098733,
0.040359538,
-0.1100786701,
-0.7492473125,
-1.0500737429,
1.0529073477,
0.368863076,
0.5499503016,
-0.3302800059,
0.5871961117,
-0.0151804229,
0.6704954505,
-0.8287879229,
0.5137887001,
0.3386319578,
-0.9349770546,
-0.4920236468,
-0.3595378995,
-0.5944527388,
0.4384202063,
-0.2825270295,
-0.330684036,
-0.062340878,
0.5466531515,
-0.4838591218,
0.2870830297,
-0.8620880246,
0.7795354128,
-0.0387810171,
-0.4061579406,
-0.4389076829,
-0.3444892168,
0.8353278041,
-0.1476099044,
0.543772161,
-0.2191086113,
-0.1302624941,
0.7084109187,
-0.5230466127,
0.9034125209,
-0.3903746009,
-0.0908317417,
0.5480923057,
0.3427982032,
0.785402298,
0.4045106471,
-0.2197120637,
-0.2464326322,
-0.0959972292,
-0.4990669489,
-0.6395604014,
0.727167964,
-0.5177592039,
-0.8777327538,
-0.2216792256,
-0.7981016636,
-0.4101617336,
0.3276394606,
0.095271863,
0.3827522099,
-0.0384636186,
0.0573332198,
0.6611292958,
-0.0067100106,
0.2607846856,
0.3189457059,
-0.0630920753,
-0.3880388439,
0.6487609744,
0.166212216,
0.4426264465,
0.0318166912,
0.3276266456,
-0.1823233515,
-0.6437966824,
-0.2858971357,
0.1120253429,
-0.7628132701,
-0.1180593669,
-0.775513351,
0.1528134346,
-0.4068775177,
-0.380081594,
-0.2533985078,
-0.4347329438,
-0.336296916,
-0.328987211,
0.3508892953,
0.7875207067,
0.0055411952,
-0.0098298686,
-0.7687628269,
0.2379248738,
0.6814427376,
0.0007851548,
0.1214270443,
-0.4091318846,
-0.0702939853,
0.2505144179,
-0.0580089316,
-0.4946869016,
0.4063836038,
-0.1658211648,
0.4997152388,
0.4661190808,
0.2195373923,
0.7521761656,
-0.4212421775,
0.7376154065,
0.2752477527,
-0.9236311913,
0.307218492,
-0.7011623383,
0.1254446208,
0.4882280529,
0.376768589,
-0.5355160236,
-0.3693999648,
-0.5010054111,
-0.6077013016,
0.6804391742,
0.1587887555,
0.0804389417,
-0.1775340736,
0.2734948397,
0.2704564333,
0.2606177628,
-0.6634557843,
0.1781471521,
-0.212311402,
0.0580814965,
-0.004842672,
-0.5199586749,
-0.3703824282,
-0.0634880438,
0.7081339955,
-0.3000681698,
-0.2150138617,
0.3794698119,
-0.1669874787,
-0.3283433616,
0.5894328952,
0.6890715361,
0.7018763423,
0.1099379659,
0.1444138885,
0.2524192333,
0.0275819693,
-0.0243564285,
-0.045182392,
-0.4729909897,
-0.1920928508,
0.4408745766,
0.6300234199,
0.0979415178,
-0.9480963349,
0.5032019615,
0.3240243793,
-0.390627712,
-0.540358007,
-0.0541589484,
0.3745889068,
0.2968164384,
0.3965184391,
0.5825824738,
0.0204363335,
-0.3377526999,
0.0045640445,
0.5009182692,
-0.1112109199,
-0.3506332338,
0.5034314394,
0.3420357406,
-0.0068551786,
0.466984868,
-0.3997722566,
-0.5070555806,
0.3720498979,
0.2520073652,
0.8255720735,
0.1579784602,
0.0680391639,
0.5929133296,
0.3815410435,
-0.6388112903,
0.1514881402,
0.1000560224,
-0.852271378,
-0.8775751591,
-0.4100092947,
-0.263859719,
0.1343331635,
-0.4392331839,
0.1442673802,
-0.5986141562,
-0.1891946197,
-0.2722124457,
-0.22508277,
-0.5661373734,
0.1678495258,
0.2020976096,
0.8730204701,
-0.7322523594,
0.8350219131,
0.5936083794,
-0.1813177466,
-1.0579556227,
-0.1188945249,
-0.078073062,
-0.6179661155,
0.7334362864,
0.1696437597,
0.0800623596,
-0.138398692,
-0.8135996461,
-0.8202518821,
1.1921133995,
0.523131609,
-0.5277671218,
-0.1933125407,
0.0065088277,
0.4550675452,
-0.3456045985,
0.1416090429,
0.3995845616,
0.8004662991,
0.0499159656,
-0.8325787187,
0.1688883752,
-0.0097769164,
0.0232077967,
-0.1205902323,
-0.4012605846,
0.7689003944,
-0.4148760438,
-0.2098557502,
-0.0106960516,
0.5756428838,
0.6314460039,
0.2398977876,
0.701292336,
0.437327981,
0.8831732869,
-0.0306827966,
1.1723693609,
-0.2249334306,
-0.06497778,
1.1259050369,
-0.3133912683,
0.7693316936,
0.7476114035,
0.0758766159,
0.241081357,
0.301007241,
0.1388083547,
-0.0411437303,
0.2886871397,
-0.1367797852,
-0.9016454816,
-0.3627029657,
0.0102289179,
0.2382365018,
0.2285512984,
-0.2515747547,
-0.0976859704,
-0.3029148281,
0.2228848934,
0.3500673473,
-0.385627687,
0.4995073676,
0.0836220309,
-1.2118251324,
0.5715141892,
0.0296026506,
0.665527463,
-0.5837826133,
0.1349572688,
0.0290537551,
-0.0679155365,
-0.3290613592,
-0.5807409883,
0.376973629,
0.1113653034,
-0.3871299624,
-0.5968001485,
0.836265862,
-0.5086106658,
-0.3211001456,
-0.0471994057,
0.5764827728,
-0.1353939772,
-0.3610951006,
-0.4120734632,
-0.0780881643,
0.0250823125,
-0.6316621304,
0.2960763276,
0.6313043237,
-0.1461080015,
0.9315748215,
0.9819393158,
-0.0542234592,
0.0491377413,
-0.0069611892,
0.7631136179,
-0.4461847246,
-0.2485795319,
-0.7140828371,
0.6801672578,
-0.175208956,
-0.2128110528,
0.7625924349,
0.4948640168,
0.7739934921,
-0.2779542506,
1.0843605995,
0.0511483662,
0.5659649372,
-0.4014453888,
0.6550641656,
-0.283957988,
0.2187391967,
-0.0788711384,
-0.6111123562,
-0.2790584266,
0.4775905907,
-0.4002311528,
-0.0884190574,
0.5712432265,
0.8841680288,
0.2970395088,
-0.0939802602,
0.3677574694,
0.1553282738,
0.18687208,
0.4323832095,
1.0273241997,
-0.0329994559,
0.6745079756,
-0.283731699,
-0.1198320612,
0.0723666996,
-0.9826584458,
-1.2137745619,
-0.376111418,
-0.261135906,
-0.3106297553,
-0.2852770686,
1.2718505859,
0.7082079649,
-0.793890655,
-0.2119677663,
-0.2393309176,
0.1610328555,
0.0224550199,
-0.2076186836,
-0.1551864445,
-0.5131903887,
-0.7129260898,
0.3919095993,
0.164402172,
-0.0800497085,
-0.4359871149,
-0.276165098,
0.1211229265,
0.2129693329,
0.7605069876,
0.1905853897,
-1.1450984478,
-0.3924902976,
0.1773805618,
-0.2273757756,
-0.4557349086,
0.9609460235,
-0.7769562602,
0.2617613077,
0.7630411386,
0.5380483866,
-0.106611982,
0.0020319929,
0.8840360045,
-0.3228742182,
0.0349580385,
0.3929299712,
0.5391031504,
0.3229773939,
-0.1941765994,
0.3224386275,
0.2982389927,
-0.6305807829,
-0.8843141198,
0.3384281695,
-0.9756163955,
-0.1096934229,
1.609695673,
-0.2137144506,
0.0189119894,
-0.2792416215,
-0.3178108037,
0.0492880605,
-0.5968188643,
0.6519085169,
0.9143069983,
0.1981515884,
0.0999864712,
-0.3902877569,
0.690101862,
0.3431923389,
-0.7074781656,
0.4856512547,
0.9139446616,
0.333471477,
0.1679125577,
0.6056552529,
0.0023545551,
0.1090245247,
-0.1301328838,
-0.1045067683,
-0.264775157,
0.0064419154,
-0.0531956255,
0.2807371616,
0.574719131,
0.5640044212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05657v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05657v2
|
Agent Lumos: Unified and Modular Training for Open-Source Language Agents
| 2023-11-09T00:30:13 | 2024-03-13T10:54:21 |
Da Yin, Faeze Brahman, Abhilasha Ravichander, Khyathi Chandu, Kai-Wei Chang, Yejin Choi, Bill Yuchen Lin
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Closed-source agents suffer from several issues such as a lack of
affordability, transparency, and reproducibility, particularly on complex
interactive tasks. This motivates the development of open-source alternatives.
We introduce LUMOS, one of the first frameworks for training open-source
LLM-based agents. LUMOS features a learnable, unified, and modular architecture
with a planning module that learns high-level subgoal generation, and a
grounding module trained to translate these into actions using various tools in
the execution module. The design allows for modular upgrades and wider
applicability to diverse interactive tasks. To foster generalizable agent
learning, we collect large-scale, unified, and high-quality training
annotations derived from diverse ground-truth reasoning rationales across
various complex interactive tasks. On 9 datasets, LUMOS exhibits several key
advantages: (1) LUMOS excels multiple larger open-source agents on the held-out
datasets (unused for training) for each task type. LUMOS even surpasses GPT
agents on QA and web tasks; (2) LUMOS outperforms open-source agents produced
by chain-of-thoughts and unmodularized integrated training; and (3) LUMOS
effectively generalizes to unseen tasks, outperforming 33B-scale agents and
domain-specific agents.
|
[
-0.0386695527,
-0.497173667,
0.6488668919,
-0.0407177098,
0.0128959976,
0.0394713469,
-0.465744108,
-0.1711283922,
0.2542415261,
0.5349028111,
-0.507353425,
-0.5728788376,
-0.1027649939,
-0.2167317867,
-0.1715156734,
1.0014497042,
-0.1309340745,
0.0878280252,
-0.2984002233,
-0.1265553236,
0.0881204903,
-0.1624641865,
-0.4191405177,
-0.5989131331,
0.7188692689,
0.4500661492,
0.8054745793,
0.3281879425,
0.1192008927,
0.3404797316,
0.3139290214,
0.4109824598,
-0.5156664848,
0.2136045247,
-0.4073156118,
-0.4167712033,
-0.7466765046,
0.016086759,
0.3176668584,
0.5288295746,
-0.2055656314,
0.0639520511,
-0.1535205543,
0.6982047558,
-0.7770240903,
0.2589146793,
-0.8027198911,
0.1678235084,
0.055519674,
-0.1374153644,
-0.5577913523,
-0.261477232,
-0.0478307642,
-1.057315588,
-0.0912413299,
-0.4467167854,
0.5309895277,
0.2952192426,
-0.1987907439,
-0.3862599134,
-0.9323293567,
0.7942996621,
-0.4490015209,
0.2287190557,
0.2232162505,
0.5396034122,
-0.1510765851,
-0.7791162729,
-0.2750298977,
-0.2796448469,
0.1992773712,
0.1753474176,
-0.1009665579,
0.2173247188,
0.1740946174,
0.3620152473,
-0.4873588383,
0.0024717995,
-0.2153736055,
-0.2585018873,
0.5141570568,
0.0160515457,
0.198532477,
0.5968737006,
-0.3912628889,
0.1409958899,
-0.804995358,
0.1639070809,
0.3151416779,
0.2838943005,
0.1291181892,
0.3651111126,
-0.4525149167,
0.4833547771,
-0.2111590207,
-0.2501207292,
0.3453364372,
0.0617278069,
-0.3441213369,
-0.3575851619,
0.6770173907,
-0.2749597728,
0.308414042,
-0.5148447156,
-0.5473501086,
-0.1197668537,
0.3954049051,
-0.4848261774,
0.1852795184,
0.2356891334,
-0.0864556208,
-0.2669155896,
0.309553057,
-0.4330210984,
-0.300478518,
-0.4420571327,
0.5507520437,
-0.3562617004,
-0.0874277428,
0.1336565316,
0.2019049972,
0.3629012108,
0.6753793359,
-0.8639649749,
0.2855013013,
0.7160741091,
0.6461343169,
0.1038669869,
-0.5315073133,
-0.8149169087,
0.2649294138,
-0.5011597872,
0.6848813891,
-0.4867654443,
-0.1196311414,
0.1865102649,
-0.013987896,
-0.0192803796,
-0.3600232601,
0.1313565224,
-0.4518537819,
0.0579911433,
-0.2209784985,
-0.2476803064,
0.0343785398,
0.0973764285,
-0.3908009529,
0.8492052555,
0.3829522431,
-0.3006861508,
0.2818877399,
-0.7155098915,
-0.2641208172,
0.2418317199,
-0.4526752532,
-0.1458621025,
-0.005177794,
-0.0533787198,
0.3152925074,
-0.2439327538,
0.0865488052,
-0.1981220394,
-0.3326166868,
0.1198179945,
0.1762272269,
0.6005199552,
0.421435833,
-0.4739529788,
0.5332827568,
-0.4687265158,
0.2159073949,
0.1645749509,
-0.403139621,
-0.2108635455,
0.2341262847,
-0.3918049634,
-0.00233748,
0.3617926836,
-0.6651241183,
0.4292331338,
-0.314699918,
0.3819634616,
0.8990129232,
-0.4715483785,
0.7338400483,
-0.2989926338,
0.5245851278,
-0.0865388215,
0.4554757774,
-0.4153103828,
-0.5222085714,
-0.7261206508,
-0.4525957704,
-0.1865981966,
0.6154512763,
-1.0471211672,
0.4810324907,
-0.2298847735,
-0.6065846682,
-0.4251370728,
0.4838279486,
0.3415863216,
0.3211871088,
0.212266326,
-0.0716835186,
-0.2422208935,
-0.6448396444,
0.0743928403,
0.01689508,
-0.0717364848,
0.0836604089,
0.7660977244,
-0.5003448129,
1.1991692781,
-0.3288892806,
-0.2681391835,
-0.4013328254,
-0.0347523168,
-0.0215112697,
0.2225544751,
0.5393064618,
-0.4769059122,
-0.406781286,
0.4490472674,
-1.0449455976,
-0.0843173563,
0.1175996661,
0.062089812,
0.1923759282,
0.4234990478,
-0.773231864,
0.1940203905,
0.182572335,
-0.1146699786,
0.3567625582,
-0.3953514695,
-0.2366349995,
-0.9859227538,
0.1072840393,
-0.4981795251,
-0.14718391,
-0.6675989628,
0.1510814428,
0.0452460982,
-0.2691058815,
-0.6146706939,
0.6536269188,
-0.4787524641,
-0.5507007241,
-0.3297827244,
0.1840012968,
-0.1976253092,
0.5429040194,
-0.1573525816,
0.8713777661,
0.7305334806,
-0.5053126216,
0.713203311,
-0.0099367648,
-0.1866758913,
0.3232463896,
-0.4930832386,
0.5589690804,
-0.1311488897,
0.1433862448,
-0.3432149589,
-0.1614399105,
0.3143945932,
-0.3480922878,
-0.1865560859,
0.0898979008,
-0.3211807609,
-0.2124054879,
-0.5081875324,
-0.0037001327,
0.6257551312,
-0.4721756876,
0.5398970842,
0.1937909424,
0.1767776459,
-0.8844421506,
-0.5308967233,
-0.2890343964,
0.2151169181,
-0.4857467413,
0.0438994765,
-0.1987995505,
-0.4130080342,
0.124230139,
-0.1869270951,
-0.0770678893,
0.2451392263,
0.3571439087,
-0.2032114118,
-0.3645052314,
0.2707590461,
-0.0155170262,
-0.3085851073,
-0.2161048353,
-0.7230268717,
0.3857595921,
-0.5275152326,
-0.6576527953,
-0.0401742719,
-0.009204491,
0.7226734161,
-0.3655619025,
0.5214862227,
0.4992834628,
-0.3559037447,
-0.6512174606,
-0.2148406208,
0.0965765715,
-0.4921661317,
0.1681809872,
-0.2902115881,
-0.7525099516,
0.4440255165,
-0.110592097,
0.3594808578,
0.1556416303,
0.5444686413,
-0.0509155057,
0.6133853793,
0.6911404729,
-0.1490396559,
0.7058933377,
-0.3526799381,
-0.1247116774,
-0.3080020547,
-0.4116286933,
-0.3437485695,
-0.1994517297,
0.0386517085,
-0.6196398735,
0.1704702377,
0.0068409597,
-0.2054539621,
0.163543731,
-0.1772946566,
0.7448421717,
0.5232160687,
0.2252050638,
0.2862904668,
0.1189366877,
0.0672551841,
0.3184922338,
-0.3774956465,
-0.8353248835,
1.251109004,
0.343777895,
1.0307304859,
-0.0328183323,
0.7192384601,
0.7053994536,
0.350504607,
-0.7793784738,
0.7542254329,
0.0934551358,
-0.2420869321,
-0.516105175,
-0.3433751166,
-1.106469512,
0.2351208329,
-0.0724962354,
-0.4845296443,
-0.0577438176,
0.1184711382,
-0.1401872337,
0.5481913686,
-0.4662526846,
0.733627677,
-0.3967013359,
-0.2888899446,
-0.3946395516,
-0.4784427881,
0.0292408876,
-0.0042274781,
0.2729619741,
-0.2024753541,
-0.4576520324,
0.2480595112,
-0.6163516045,
0.7850466967,
-0.3240281045,
-0.287935853,
0.4653477669,
-0.1127856076,
0.4206501245,
-0.0232600998,
-0.0556246452,
-0.0483271107,
-0.5499766469,
-0.7213864923,
-0.5263508558,
0.5224478245,
-0.9911076427,
-0.3018513322,
-0.2749269605,
-0.6460312605,
-0.204604879,
0.2281957567,
0.1114132404,
0.3565234542,
-0.5129096508,
0.1767674685,
0.8615751266,
-0.1695218235,
0.3425795436,
0.848020196,
-0.3635823131,
-0.5868757963,
0.9971699715,
-0.1743674874,
0.4489359856,
0.5672955513,
0.0742164999,
0.3571787477,
-0.4594953656,
-0.4099548161,
0.1130338758,
-0.7898615003,
-0.0705696568,
-0.3614915609,
-0.214971751,
-0.3894222081,
-0.4392499924,
-0.3973144591,
-0.1925813109,
-0.0867215022,
-0.1956424117,
0.1606632024,
1.0567442179,
-0.1690153629,
0.3569478095,
-0.5559144616,
0.3289731741,
0.8437001705,
0.242612049,
-0.4130524993,
-0.2052381337,
-0.5515732169,
0.1540244669,
-0.3195691705,
-0.9189311266,
0.0763418823,
0.293258816,
1.0230625868,
0.7052698731,
-0.1269030273,
0.0107333399,
-0.3229005933,
0.6388120651,
0.0345073678,
-0.9625099301,
0.9477300644,
-0.6442893744,
0.0944853276,
0.4797957242,
0.2089470327,
-0.2770746648,
-0.3614107966,
-0.4571916461,
-0.5795808434,
1.0566415787,
0.2367887199,
-0.0421574786,
0.2326840758,
0.3823345602,
0.3795384765,
0.592423439,
-1.0041066408,
-0.0874063,
-0.243369624,
-0.1515469849,
-0.2488534898,
0.0464044102,
-0.2578159571,
-0.0760831088,
0.8308196068,
-0.4337239861,
0.2249394655,
0.1276717037,
-0.6913188696,
-0.340002954,
0.4053001404,
0.9065987468,
0.7757313251,
-0.198248744,
0.1804203391,
0.1025002822,
-0.4590146244,
0.2476748824,
-0.200834915,
-0.4788201749,
-0.0304276217,
0.3523750305,
0.8908616304,
0.1185518876,
-0.9358929396,
0.5308423042,
0.310570389,
-0.2765115499,
-0.2956535816,
0.3054828644,
-0.1339669526,
0.4551967382,
0.3789958954,
-0.0390105732,
-0.2402127981,
-0.7815621495,
0.0905400515,
0.4724428356,
-0.4199608564,
-0.6182100177,
0.3644416928,
0.5397381783,
-0.4018949866,
0.1085737944,
-0.438378334,
-0.3008878529,
0.695541203,
0.2419979721,
1.2299510241,
-0.4063580334,
0.5986152291,
0.008333738,
0.7969121933,
-0.1296584606,
0.4378444254,
-0.3396472335,
-0.5713208318,
-0.1499724388,
-0.3782596886,
-0.8405841589,
0.1714437008,
-0.34333691,
0.2198435515,
-0.5853162408,
0.2190363407,
-0.5271510482,
-0.1961646676,
-0.2603150904,
-0.0904616565,
0.354297936,
0.9040414095,
-0.9118940234,
1.181443572,
1.2585955858,
-0.6151080132,
-0.2291878909,
-0.1380910873,
-0.119788222,
-0.9449861646,
0.4942477942,
0.2370246649,
-0.2830949724,
-0.1443320066,
-0.7342014313,
-0.7177839279,
1.4510579109,
0.9236152172,
-0.2705583274,
-0.1754593998,
0.419596374,
0.5199981332,
-0.5080624819,
0.3349638581,
0.1907398403,
0.2753654122,
-0.2793137431,
-0.8626731634,
-0.1852242649,
-0.1530626416,
-0.3544461131,
0.24037081,
-0.6974630356,
1.1016780138,
-0.3409818411,
0.0580551326,
0.1113843545,
0.6281152368,
0.0049534445,
0.6688913703,
0.5777570605,
0.4874432981,
0.8725606203,
-0.2170877904,
0.5864334702,
-0.1837935895,
0.4112162292,
0.8668448329,
-0.3848056197,
0.559391737,
0.1423845887,
-0.0799580738,
0.6921612024,
0.2766299248,
0.3335028887,
0.5535951257,
-0.041031342,
-0.3886837661,
-0.3801023066,
0.1344694942,
-0.4702912867,
-0.0006021024,
0.4278148413,
-0.0959440842,
-0.5210189223,
0.2903332412,
-0.1422649324,
0.1652530134,
-0.4947592914,
0.7421595454,
0.0649892986,
-0.4479117393,
0.2128529251,
-0.2671066821,
0.4806447625,
-1.1886808872,
0.1844340116,
-0.4666363299,
0.4276252985,
-0.3337050676,
-0.5525569916,
0.0526980907,
-0.0798431709,
-0.0709173009,
-0.6881676316,
0.9265919924,
-0.4437678754,
0.1831158847,
0.4917339981,
0.6370383501,
0.1975423694,
-0.2443324178,
-0.5691844225,
-0.272231549,
-0.2094316781,
-0.4399167001,
0.4803248942,
0.6298677921,
0.120167546,
0.8830549717,
0.4832763672,
0.0682668239,
-0.0205354542,
-0.1253470331,
1.0281099081,
-0.7138493061,
-0.4518829286,
-0.4692878127,
0.4862314463,
0.000877396,
-0.1257145256,
0.5829369426,
0.5127740502,
0.8553437591,
-0.2521066964,
0.8517436385,
0.0387974046,
0.2269401103,
-0.5851992965,
0.4363289177,
-0.6069615483,
0.2456185222,
-0.0113828192,
-0.9059912562,
0.2700435817,
0.455183357,
-0.203253299,
-0.0359725691,
0.6180182099,
0.4607878327,
-0.0721676126,
-0.2456326783,
0.5680577755,
0.0185878482,
0.2923734486,
0.6941620708,
1.0803146362,
-0.0595579967,
0.6319797635,
-0.1512915641,
-0.291598767,
-0.2121876627,
-0.5280069709,
-1.0626118183,
-0.4610227346,
-0.0644038767,
-0.0337303802,
0.1808198094,
1.0726746321,
0.6831968427,
-0.7208081484,
-0.4735766649,
-0.2150727957,
0.4116342366,
-0.2623968124,
-0.126817137,
-0.2798820734,
-0.8332941532,
-0.5402752757,
0.879396677,
0.4721610248,
-0.0759382993,
-0.3950634003,
-0.5399045944,
0.1654129177,
0.0612881705,
0.680765748,
0.7609475255,
-0.7876525521,
-0.0220841337,
0.1375806332,
-0.4224854112,
-0.0687813163,
1.0476421118,
-0.8061621785,
0.3707860708,
0.4747769237,
0.6414106488,
0.1420089304,
-0.307715714,
0.5518130064,
-0.7868621349,
0.5450980663,
0.1558373421,
0.3801720142,
-0.0497798361,
-0.045828037,
0.7701267004,
0.4131220579,
-0.5524528027,
-0.8533996344,
0.3480497301,
-0.9806877375,
-0.3379128873,
1.1851023436,
-0.3962565064,
-0.0634061173,
-0.0617710203,
-0.2679097056,
-0.0579474978,
-0.4771517813,
0.3538315296,
0.1986836195,
0.0465124063,
0.257355243,
-0.5818719268,
0.3849538267,
0.3147430122,
-1.3333777189,
-0.0728227347,
0.5861289501,
0.1308050752,
0.266728729,
1.0149666071,
0.2556599677,
0.4478541017,
-0.1303329915,
0.542121768,
-0.4051676691,
-0.6446926594,
-0.4145239592,
0.1042211875,
0.179799661,
-0.315074414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07751v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07751v3
|
Large Human Language Models: A Need and the Challenges
| 2023-11-09T00:27:28 | 2024-05-09T17:22:40 |
Nikita Soni, H. Andrew Schwartz, João Sedoc, Niranjan Balasubramanian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
As research in human-centered NLP advances, there is a growing recognition of
the importance of incorporating human and social factors into NLP models. At
the same time, our NLP systems have become heavily reliant on LLMs, most of
which do not model authors. To build NLP systems that can truly understand
human language, we must better integrate human contexts into LLMs. This brings
to the fore a range of design considerations and challenges in terms of what
human aspects to capture, how to represent them, and what modeling strategies
to pursue. To address these, we advocate for three positions toward creating
large human language models (LHLMs) using concepts from psychological and
behavioral sciences: First, LM training should include the human context.
Second, LHLMs should recognize that people are more than their group(s). Third,
LHLMs should be able to account for the dynamic and temporally-dependent nature
of the human context. We refer to relevant advances and present open challenges
that need to be addressed and their possible solutions in realizing these
goals.
|
[
-0.4767156243,
-0.545410037,
0.6614196301,
0.5382823348,
0.2092659324,
0.1718708128,
-0.5226749182,
-0.8929699063,
-0.1601104289,
0.6177042127,
-0.4612315893,
-0.1048917323,
-0.4868663847,
0.248329103,
-0.266435802,
0.6409220099,
-0.0486064442,
0.1046582907,
-0.302616626,
-0.0649573728,
-0.5491843224,
-1.101287961,
-0.6124331951,
-0.6925344467,
0.8136584759,
0.3144391477,
0.6665260196,
0.3288628161,
0.4433355927,
0.2678513229,
-0.4042215943,
-0.1387204975,
-0.1465158612,
0.3034941554,
-0.2340278476,
-0.2586356997,
-0.6345199347,
0.1490029395,
0.7436891794,
1.258464694,
-0.2704027295,
0.1700498462,
0.0364980586,
0.6952069998,
-0.2210901827,
0.1068952158,
-0.3197839856,
0.2822385132,
-0.1860803664,
0.1677194536,
-0.2759259641,
-0.1744418591,
0.5789776444,
-0.2697077096,
0.1330820471,
0.0198893715,
0.4760646522,
-0.0492873751,
-0.6983996034,
-0.1142866388,
-0.883905232,
0.7184199691,
-0.8242983818,
0.5022568107,
0.3985892236,
0.1700649261,
-0.5284917355,
-0.410869211,
-0.493401587,
-0.0868027359,
-0.0060884096,
-0.4007611871,
0.0175541863,
0.0151279112,
0.291256845,
0.0353988297,
-0.1802151054,
0.5116294622,
-0.3221207857,
0.021798877,
0.7970299125,
0.5078415871,
0.2101018131,
-0.0513508618,
-0.1850128174,
-0.0565057285,
-0.6775306463,
-0.115348272,
0.2597610652,
0.3682090044,
-0.1524805725,
0.3987181783,
-0.1375810057,
0.486867249,
-0.2240892351,
-0.1144832298,
0.1648804247,
-0.0138849951,
0.0117321219,
-0.1157814711,
0.5570808649,
0.1637542397,
0.398517549,
-0.1257385164,
-0.2480066568,
-0.2222216725,
0.2676285803,
-0.5723057985,
0.3676629961,
0.2911436558,
-0.3487944901,
-0.1126342416,
-0.1853537261,
-0.7450708151,
-0.6946159005,
-0.6868837476,
-0.0260063354,
-0.0514270179,
-0.564008832,
0.1863945127,
0.0705832541,
0.5560625196,
0.4428807199,
-1.1078140736,
0.4651954472,
0.8480302095,
0.7089821696,
-0.078781195,
-0.3194107115,
-0.1224908754,
0.2266025096,
-0.2570897043,
0.4836815298,
-0.3936950862,
-0.4081231058,
0.3578905761,
0.0542201549,
0.212972939,
-0.4811750054,
0.5558052659,
-0.3414862156,
0.3869332969,
-0.6291466355,
-0.6337138414,
-0.0451222844,
0.2322006524,
-0.5203224421,
0.9381032586,
0.1247980371,
-0.4460476637,
0.0126915378,
-0.8720952272,
-0.5765168071,
0.3620575368,
-0.1414863467,
-0.1744962931,
0.4765970111,
-0.0670891106,
0.6668991446,
-0.5038952231,
0.6018294096,
-0.4644976556,
-0.0631937906,
0.5387262106,
-0.1035018191,
0.9332954884,
0.2010462135,
-0.090768978,
0.2127452195,
-0.6049171686,
-0.0246475022,
0.2221938968,
-0.676981926,
-0.1819233447,
0.4860986471,
0.4913306534,
0.2602149248,
0.2819280922,
-0.2729019821,
0.1975713074,
-0.1804641038,
0.6697217822,
0.8586164713,
-0.3417661488,
0.6820433736,
-0.1852813661,
0.5566248894,
-0.3642639816,
0.1596883833,
0.1434255689,
-0.4723112285,
-0.4591530859,
-0.0240122788,
0.0409302972,
0.4451839626,
-0.2273882926,
0.7141560316,
-0.0047161477,
-0.3626217842,
-0.1123541817,
0.2361881137,
0.0438830964,
0.1504628509,
0.1795224994,
-0.2585186362,
-0.9137282968,
-0.8008921146,
-0.1651975662,
-0.1612089723,
-0.2151039243,
0.2668271363,
0.6815098524,
-0.4595338106,
1.2501223087,
-0.33493343,
-0.4608634412,
-0.508928299,
-0.1183733344,
0.0201757923,
0.3909729123,
0.3556762934,
-0.7956127524,
-0.3363601267,
-0.0678360388,
-1.0189579725,
-0.3365894854,
0.1281733662,
0.0583353117,
0.2181159705,
0.6944069266,
-0.8418805599,
0.1091007963,
0.5234872699,
-0.353148371,
0.5510048866,
-0.2194502652,
-0.4102202058,
-0.976113677,
0.1350416541,
0.314453721,
-0.181948781,
-0.8564311862,
0.1496462971,
-0.1182198077,
-0.3463154733,
-0.3665880561,
0.8638217449,
-0.6492447257,
-0.1207515821,
-0.2911230922,
0.2381815761,
-0.1498724818,
0.2503566444,
0.2515593171,
0.2696810961,
0.2651993334,
-0.5661687851,
0.5414258838,
0.1263492554,
-0.5247992277,
0.5587107539,
-0.8879606128,
0.1839751601,
-0.106048122,
0.6700740457,
-0.4016154408,
-0.6031500697,
0.1711148918,
-0.1879619062,
0.3729016483,
0.2927043438,
-0.6150239706,
-0.5106393695,
-0.048570212,
0.3611722589,
0.5023449659,
-0.164157033,
0.6916202307,
0.6722730398,
-0.2497265488,
-0.5060212612,
-0.4834423363,
0.6153601408,
-0.3930822015,
-0.6539105177,
0.4220684171,
0.0642569214,
-0.5360162258,
-0.1061205566,
0.2179523259,
0.0198043305,
0.364962548,
0.1497136801,
0.1166061088,
-0.238210693,
0.2924975455,
-0.5013033152,
-0.1820643842,
0.2416060865,
-0.0884867385,
0.5473601818,
-0.1909641176,
-0.1026658192,
-0.4916240573,
0.8494110107,
0.4381862879,
-0.204980582,
0.8964594603,
0.5739374161,
-0.6469705701,
-0.0607678927,
-0.8320367336,
-0.216171965,
-0.40470016,
0.7075515389,
0.1475677937,
-1.2528824806,
0.5829565525,
0.0115581183,
0.0155103058,
0.0448355637,
0.7640654445,
-0.436811626,
0.9595248699,
0.8866662979,
-0.2775474489,
0.7024439573,
0.1467927992,
0.1732793152,
-1.0897939205,
-0.1874523759,
-0.6039735079,
-0.3712160885,
-0.372061491,
-0.3459858894,
0.0882685483,
-0.0472150855,
-0.3473759592,
0.012808986,
-0.2434491515,
0.2302617133,
0.3728621304,
-0.0698302239,
0.0754530057,
-0.0928286761,
0.2245103568,
-0.0920428708,
-0.4913007021,
-0.7344309688,
0.7714428306,
0.8067920208,
0.8552216887,
0.4178989828,
0.3723917603,
0.1673459858,
0.3298839629,
-0.7501689196,
0.6593522429,
0.1425455064,
-1.1725387573,
-0.5027462244,
-0.2529342473,
-1.0745248795,
0.4091888666,
-0.2970148623,
-0.9479392767,
0.0956132486,
0.1554938555,
-0.2357734889,
0.0315059759,
-0.4881126881,
0.7267276049,
-0.3133758008,
-0.2940865159,
-0.1627841443,
-0.8843986392,
0.3069488108,
-0.0059511648,
0.443654716,
-0.4009815156,
-0.0078262249,
0.7955918312,
-0.3324296474,
1.3343830109,
-0.203841731,
-0.3948396444,
0.3010054529,
-0.2807818651,
0.45193398,
-0.2524294555,
0.0956529453,
-0.0983441994,
0.0290595423,
-0.3610384762,
-0.3047903776,
0.4731054604,
-0.8202074766,
-0.9755777717,
-0.5555104613,
-0.5975452662,
-0.3361529708,
-0.0247780904,
-0.1406181008,
0.3214571178,
-0.2512699366,
0.5658406019,
0.5906475186,
-0.2928488255,
0.4195136428,
0.2873781323,
-0.4701159298,
-0.1869445741,
0.5648586154,
-0.0014683934,
0.3284960389,
0.1103435978,
0.330530256,
-0.2728204429,
-0.4014270902,
0.0377707817,
0.511772275,
-0.7241893411,
0.1465374529,
-0.483027935,
-0.1506977081,
-0.5429292917,
-0.1649147123,
-0.2044069022,
0.0166694764,
-0.5748251081,
0.209225148,
0.2070496231,
0.7787181139,
-0.1225610673,
0.534001112,
-0.9382399917,
0.268863976,
0.3946739435,
0.3597849607,
0.3906071782,
-0.4904074371,
-0.3644814789,
-0.0943043679,
-0.348097682,
-0.7628991008,
0.2621052861,
0.035628058,
0.7409773469,
0.2257340699,
-0.0872383788,
0.5095129013,
-0.6831688285,
0.6261875033,
0.1819677651,
-0.9305074811,
0.2169410288,
-0.4960962534,
0.2170494646,
0.3125140667,
0.4557105303,
-1.1893253326,
-0.0815340504,
-0.2243807763,
-0.8878436089,
0.7536302805,
-0.0342744961,
0.3608341217,
-0.0194535293,
0.4839240611,
-0.2793264091,
-0.0282840841,
-1.0789334774,
0.1585326344,
0.3588026762,
-0.2137805223,
-0.085633181,
-0.5397953987,
-0.0673580766,
-0.2032086849,
0.3312851489,
0.0204512607,
0.0350365415,
0.1282752156,
-0.0068881973,
-0.2395889163,
0.4479661286,
0.678147614,
0.7924357653,
-0.2889151871,
0.0251308139,
0.3007449806,
-0.1851065904,
0.3549453318,
-0.3256522119,
0.2068976313,
-0.4140926301,
0.6123244166,
0.5494443178,
0.3760144413,
-0.728261292,
0.3854205608,
0.0219671521,
-0.1605291516,
-0.6034037471,
-0.0951908007,
0.5442639589,
0.4468019307,
0.5890655518,
-0.2209709883,
-0.4105241001,
-0.7506505251,
-0.2292194515,
0.3941228092,
-0.4215070903,
-0.4068979621,
0.3998739719,
0.4521855116,
-0.7753397822,
0.608782053,
0.0105182026,
-0.6849909425,
0.4299294949,
0.6430112123,
0.7568916082,
-0.4810295701,
-0.0832139477,
0.0365091711,
0.3032741845,
-0.4800787866,
0.1167702451,
0.2485824376,
-0.8456037045,
-0.6142411232,
-0.5361283422,
-0.5440517664,
0.1912806779,
-0.5225916505,
0.4013890028,
-0.3665762842,
-0.4035231471,
-0.1427921951,
-0.1301168501,
-0.6299319863,
-0.0004554103,
0.4869303405,
0.7288296223,
-0.7310467958,
0.7817752361,
0.6300988197,
0.0360925347,
-0.3611904085,
-0.3176227808,
0.089836821,
-0.4006145895,
0.8363277912,
0.1043730602,
-0.00818583,
-0.1597320139,
-0.6540305018,
-0.6769456863,
0.8153614402,
0.3301559389,
-0.6011146903,
-0.6003656983,
0.0802749842,
0.7017245293,
-0.7344465256,
-0.2680444121,
0.3998816609,
0.504930377,
-0.1178979725,
-0.8673912287,
0.0533824526,
0.1633743942,
0.3273184896,
0.0234210361,
-0.4349951446,
0.8145949841,
-0.2283397168,
-0.2493415326,
0.0873683095,
0.6546299458,
0.4152356088,
0.1275195181,
0.5261210799,
0.1676657945,
0.5016196966,
0.2649288476,
0.9738508463,
0.1972309053,
0.3245164752,
1.2212855816,
-0.7044556141,
0.8398684859,
0.4650658667,
-0.5007653236,
0.0981728286,
0.7398623824,
0.0903853029,
-0.0093937945,
0.4817153513,
-0.4018161893,
-0.4182787836,
-0.248557508,
-0.5338838696,
0.5992497206,
0.7130889297,
-0.1825352311,
-0.0647118241,
-0.0913935527,
0.0587829538,
0.1593012214,
-0.0861252099,
0.5419315696,
0.4042870998,
-0.4300088584,
0.1276823878,
0.2235044837,
0.6282234192,
-0.5734264255,
0.147570461,
0.005952864,
0.0923621207,
-0.1580052674,
-0.6553478837,
0.2950200438,
0.0554723889,
-0.1698149741,
-0.4398754835,
0.6815078259,
-0.4484943449,
-0.4940987229,
0.5129669309,
0.6188756227,
0.1098942012,
-0.0838146359,
-0.4058410227,
0.2537977695,
-0.2518027127,
-0.4747486413,
0.5139011741,
0.5499438047,
-0.1978684068,
0.6974042654,
0.5328154564,
0.2476739436,
-0.0739942193,
0.2786890864,
0.5152266026,
-1.0534086227,
-0.2498652935,
-1.0721745491,
0.266048938,
-0.0853834897,
-0.3568001688,
0.4233777225,
0.0966764018,
0.340854764,
0.0448283404,
0.6855954528,
-0.0123303644,
0.5250386596,
-0.2455553114,
0.766874671,
-0.4756995142,
0.170445621,
-0.3010799885,
-1.1158809662,
-0.5082938671,
0.7178011537,
-0.1238636225,
0.2174710035,
0.4452486634,
0.302782923,
0.3511586785,
-0.0758484378,
0.2903906107,
0.0668173283,
0.806435287,
0.5745404959,
1.1380695105,
0.0557471551,
0.1406078339,
-0.056645643,
-0.101652734,
-0.4728276432,
-1.1748702526,
-0.9110901356,
-0.6474351287,
-0.3302674294,
-0.1591543108,
-0.6318407655,
1.285423398,
0.6541165113,
-0.4593629539,
-0.6871536374,
0.2125534862,
0.2329226881,
0.1340093613,
-0.2307963222,
-0.0152912214,
-0.3781553507,
-0.5729257464,
0.1006572768,
0.3167202473,
0.2234969437,
-0.6721016169,
-0.0595816895,
-0.3707985878,
-0.0226050541,
1.0324163437,
0.4198569059,
-1.0402928591,
-0.7279586792,
0.0380239226,
-0.2164126337,
-0.1587554216,
1.0429052114,
-0.5171992183,
0.008987532,
0.246889025,
0.7277421951,
0.2708478272,
-0.3583311737,
0.8650562167,
-0.8122448921,
0.1323951185,
0.3345657885,
0.4910818934,
0.6182633042,
-0.1433829814,
0.5852728486,
0.24937433,
-0.7090343237,
-1.1265847683,
0.3959599137,
-1.0662742853,
-0.2834740579,
1.1672358513,
0.1016083285,
-0.1332422793,
-0.3799615204,
-0.1041844338,
0.2115593106,
-0.2042612582,
0.6815796494,
1.0933822393,
-0.1818838269,
-0.3292423785,
-0.7738247514,
0.3294569552,
0.2655137479,
-0.8661663532,
0.4244387448,
0.3649606407,
0.0471093394,
0.189017117,
0.7229267359,
0.0150591722,
-0.0966547057,
-0.3672097921,
0.5266656876,
0.2881889939,
-0.1698193848,
-0.3705716133,
0.2291939408,
0.2063239515,
0.4396525919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05075v1
|
Mental Health Diagnosis in the Digital Age: Harnessing Sentiment Analysis on Social Media Platforms upon Ultra-Sparse Feature Content
| 2023-11-09T00:15:06 | 2023-11-09T00:15:06 |
Haijian Shao, Ming Zhu, Shengjie Zhai
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Amid growing global mental health concerns, particularly among vulnerable
groups, natural language processing offers a tremendous potential for early
detection and intervention of people's mental disorders via analyzing their
postings and discussions on social media platforms. However, ultra-sparse
training data, often due to vast vocabularies and low-frequency words, hinders
the analysis accuracy. Multi-labeling and Co-occurrences of symptoms may also
blur the boundaries in distinguishing similar/co-related disorders. To address
these issues, we propose a novel semantic feature preprocessing technique with
a three-folded structure: 1) mitigating the feature sparsity with a weak
classifier, 2) adaptive feature dimension with modulus loops, and 3)
deep-mining and extending features among the contexts. With enhanced semantic
features, we train a machine learning model to predict and classify mental
disorders. We utilize the Reddit Mental Health Dataset 2022 to examine
conditions such as Anxiety, Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), and
Bipolar-Disorder (BD) and present solutions to the data sparsity challenge,
highlighted by 99.81% non-zero elements. After applying our preprocessing
technique, the feature sparsity decreases to 85.4%. Overall, our methods, when
compared to seven benchmark models, demonstrate significant performance
improvements: 8.0% in accuracy, 0.069 in precision, 0.093 in recall, 0.102 in
F1 score, and 0.059 in AUC. This research provides foundational insights for
mental health prediction and monitoring, providing innovative solutions to
navigate challenges associated with ultra-sparse data feature and intricate
multi-label classification in the domain of mental health analysis.
|
[
-0.942720592,
-0.9005894661,
0.8042741418,
0.3078143895,
-0.5130420923,
0.0594404079,
-0.1774811447,
-0.5436492562,
0.5914711356,
0.5068561435,
-1.0107518435,
-0.9793952703,
-0.7645679116,
-0.0647436678,
-0.3707672656,
1.311327219,
0.167671144,
0.0831057504,
-0.135622561,
-0.129041642,
-0.2715485692,
-0.6568462253,
-0.5243276954,
-0.1106945574,
0.4204731584,
0.3904365003,
0.7979770303,
0.2721359432,
0.5133975744,
0.1890833825,
0.0600599498,
0.270467937,
-0.3196217716,
0.0448276587,
0.0670405775,
0.2268245369,
-0.8335476518,
-0.041442737,
0.1866445988,
0.8858197331,
0.0299711581,
0.1375517249,
0.2548075318,
0.5643942356,
-0.4806877971,
0.0364731625,
-0.4372166693,
0.221792832,
-0.1562307477,
-0.3226543665,
0.1177357882,
0.0067450507,
-0.1296882331,
-0.5698863864,
0.6340321898,
-0.4274303019,
0.8464439511,
0.4228267968,
0.0090615824,
0.0650517941,
-0.5824154615,
0.4827188253,
-0.481135726,
0.2174915671,
0.4505335689,
0.0980426744,
-0.172407642,
-0.6222680807,
-0.6707125306,
0.3183829486,
0.006603566,
-0.0402389839,
-0.2939970493,
0.0269659255,
0.2551241219,
0.1381143779,
-0.738541007,
-0.1177553982,
-0.2958093584,
-0.2625722587,
0.6700628996,
0.1138135791,
0.2971583903,
-0.0978035703,
-0.1077447757,
0.0291869808,
-0.1245686337,
-0.1263553649,
-0.1774995327,
0.3246892393,
-0.2003537267,
0.5062972903,
-0.1783528477,
0.4935094714,
0.0832579061,
-0.2162235379,
0.3432273269,
-0.0421868525,
-0.1155247018,
0.1430181116,
0.6675640345,
0.5438867807,
-0.0292856768,
0.0689496547,
-0.0828020349,
0.5882132053,
0.4596504867,
-0.6667609215,
-0.4791477621,
0.3076267242,
-0.6098674536,
-0.0431551114,
-0.0390598662,
-0.896096766,
-0.7562009096,
-0.2797440588,
0.2499364763,
-0.4816515744,
-0.1486684829,
0.2867107689,
0.0045305192,
-0.3062499762,
0.2241666615,
-0.6736769676,
0.5303944945,
0.8469792604,
0.9846635461,
-0.0894471928,
-0.0384856239,
-0.3259205222,
0.0613009669,
-0.0030404166,
1.0659512281,
-0.5269200206,
-0.1578670889,
-0.1855395138,
0.0963101536,
-0.0401488729,
-0.40113464,
0.59381181,
-0.1426824629,
-0.0750005171,
-0.0391112491,
-0.1691214591,
0.0489867069,
0.1971464306,
-0.6815277934,
0.8519579172,
0.4183393121,
-0.9950360656,
0.4728722572,
-0.607662499,
-0.4624372125,
0.1257477999,
0.0311957374,
-0.4579675794,
0.0879064798,
0.5422081947,
0.8770768642,
-0.0329143479,
0.1644365191,
-1.0056965351,
-0.6546262503,
0.1940657645,
-0.1475015581,
0.2296469212,
0.1308934242,
-0.2819961607,
0.1254927218,
-0.8718340397,
0.142569378,
0.0261261258,
0.2019050121,
-0.4211518764,
0.0808801055,
0.0803310648,
0.3835771978,
0.0873843729,
-0.3889883161,
-0.1629124135,
-0.419894278,
0.3245313764,
0.4786342382,
0.2568249702,
0.0090155071,
-0.187401399,
0.4418397546,
0.3065556586,
0.4338378906,
0.1482287049,
-0.6159216762,
-0.3710290194,
-0.7517154217,
-0.0186759382,
0.4570509791,
-0.4412188232,
1.0264878273,
-0.447922796,
-0.2782167792,
-0.8619945645,
0.2599329054,
0.2056130916,
0.3674814999,
0.7486934066,
-0.3510983288,
-0.569409132,
-0.7135603428,
-0.2179582715,
0.2633260489,
-0.1672909111,
-0.232532531,
0.1732671708,
-0.8146064281,
0.6082028747,
-0.6613812447,
-0.580109477,
-0.3210420907,
0.3594503403,
-0.0945743248,
0.2290908992,
0.1878851503,
-0.7147632837,
-0.2047276497,
0.0092656873,
-0.4761378467,
-0.1778869182,
0.3132605553,
-0.1693189591,
0.1859457642,
0.2603431642,
-0.5987251401,
0.456489414,
0.399530828,
-0.4622083008,
-0.0125707015,
-0.0763989091,
-0.078387998,
-1.0351723433,
-0.0605239756,
0.3635327816,
-0.0568023026,
-0.3614965975,
-0.4518632889,
-0.2700657248,
-0.3398239911,
0.0928987339,
0.200564757,
-0.0075831367,
0.1168287843,
-0.2424571961,
0.1931530386,
0.1675263941,
0.1168792993,
-0.1334802061,
0.240416199,
0.3071862459,
-0.2698617578,
0.2283357233,
-0.1115125492,
-0.0493457504,
0.6777637601,
-0.26441589,
-0.0148873627,
-0.3828547001,
0.2628441751,
-1.0324631929,
-0.3929053545,
0.2776680887,
-0.6934597492,
0.2936516404,
0.2447802126,
-0.4558392465,
-0.5137709975,
-0.5515692234,
0.245997116,
0.1313613802,
-0.0731322318,
0.1843463629,
0.667108357,
-0.2331882715,
-0.4113825858,
-0.4831934571,
-0.0501381755,
-0.4504012764,
-0.5558684468,
0.5956090093,
0.1744871289,
-0.173580125,
0.429030329,
-0.1788701862,
-0.2061609179,
0.2840978503,
0.3582822084,
0.4079499841,
-0.0710266232,
0.3202255964,
0.1025478616,
-0.4331882894,
0.0811706185,
-0.10680677,
0.7007599473,
-0.1801811457,
-0.1896074265,
-0.400621444,
0.7322570086,
0.6298615932,
-0.0038932681,
0.5936290026,
0.8433744907,
-0.7847616673,
-0.3000419736,
-0.5491403937,
-0.2369625717,
-0.3893349171,
0.4112350941,
-0.0871407315,
-0.9881478548,
0.3901681304,
0.1034334302,
-0.4417819083,
0.5142563581,
0.3251076341,
-0.2927389741,
1.5394399166,
0.7902276516,
-0.1456488073,
0.0598783717,
-0.0462575108,
0.731752634,
-0.4912013113,
-0.2490126193,
-0.395432204,
-0.2402339876,
-0.6942337155,
-0.4115522802,
0.6372090578,
0.0586397387,
-0.1461613029,
-0.0616636463,
-0.7578663826,
0.003013111,
0.0582468286,
0.4139244258,
0.0764382407,
0.1819351315,
-0.0843953565,
-0.5249908566,
-0.3742577136,
-0.4906514287,
0.8840466738,
0.2951022387,
0.4959993958,
-0.4439574778,
0.603529036,
0.7191194892,
0.4410138726,
-0.8355048895,
0.4130760729,
-0.4831661284,
-0.1943126321,
-0.1963031441,
-0.3315105438,
-0.7915434837,
0.0206977278,
-0.5469061136,
-0.7355328798,
0.0579566248,
0.0378014296,
-0.6745122075,
0.1235106215,
-0.701391995,
1.0340141058,
-0.3437484503,
-0.1213648692,
-0.4058840871,
-0.6704568863,
0.4775967598,
-0.1257686764,
0.4279868305,
-0.5513708591,
-0.0373758934,
0.6641601324,
-0.3801788688,
0.6557703018,
-0.2794421911,
0.2010555863,
-0.2469364852,
-0.2221338898,
-0.3450367153,
0.3156409264,
0.2174310833,
0.0507312715,
0.3699361086,
-0.3883987069,
-0.8735823631,
0.8709285855,
-0.8432359099,
-0.3796605468,
-0.3772568703,
-0.2803398967,
-0.6927148104,
0.1551001668,
0.15923132,
0.2535396218,
0.0059802784,
-0.0635829717,
0.7615988255,
-0.0559916645,
0.0437196642,
0.3124952614,
0.0849878341,
-0.6118539572,
1.0710227489,
0.2464439571,
-0.3709005713,
0.0829669237,
0.0551910102,
-0.1964612305,
-0.3546351492,
0.0111716697,
0.4281385839,
-0.5320329666,
-0.3095811307,
-0.8609227538,
-0.3095266819,
-0.5468797088,
-0.1671980172,
-0.3917045593,
-0.2278501242,
-0.227720201,
-0.0094738193,
0.3784855306,
0.5210120082,
-0.0414892137,
0.2449458688,
-0.814175427,
0.7927255034,
-0.0072269812,
0.6961297393,
-0.0738369077,
0.0873806775,
-0.254782021,
-0.0062470888,
-0.4328046441,
-0.7801912427,
0.572781384,
0.1030097231,
0.3101978898,
0.8035680652,
0.3263053,
1.1525013447,
0.0777366385,
0.480838567,
0.2378019392,
-0.6887009144,
0.8289262652,
0.0270495266,
0.0212416332,
0.7231157422,
0.7905130982,
-0.6362386346,
-0.239331767,
-0.7701202035,
-1.0018693209,
0.623123467,
-0.1919922978,
-0.0854865313,
-0.3384174109,
0.3387668431,
0.0826191232,
-0.0113819409,
-0.3772244453,
-0.1760036498,
-0.3997215927,
-0.4795005023,
-0.252472043,
-0.4535998702,
-0.2274088711,
-0.6793265343,
0.5088304877,
-0.2651035786,
0.4823517799,
0.3380745947,
0.1089023277,
-0.1264391243,
0.2536547482,
0.1882614642,
0.3831677437,
-0.3802655637,
0.3218491971,
-0.0801529586,
-0.6100419164,
-0.011078503,
0.5554659963,
0.1526875943,
0.1114138365,
0.4247628152,
0.5608056784,
0.1037746817,
-0.5960513353,
0.6425536275,
-0.1353348941,
-0.121957086,
-0.2957882583,
-0.0340117961,
0.0036121444,
0.2434357256,
0.161853388,
0.1252662539,
0.3592130244,
-0.4970345199,
0.2667240798,
0.4581938684,
-0.6264492273,
-0.4875867963,
0.2636097968,
-0.1185524315,
-0.0500028767,
0.44572559,
-0.1332937181,
-0.2589580119,
0.2554536462,
0.3992353678,
0.8877444863,
-0.0544740409,
0.3853993416,
0.094868809,
0.0663886741,
-0.1174907461,
0.4807834625,
-0.2184750736,
-0.7233812809,
-0.1875928342,
-0.7713438869,
-0.0151659027,
0.5374886394,
-0.8149451017,
0.3840460479,
-0.7988047004,
-0.6387238503,
0.1751985848,
0.3008820713,
-0.5184451938,
0.5202885866,
0.5610128045,
0.5060662627,
-0.9284457564,
0.6807984114,
0.7388716936,
0.0662394837,
-0.5390461087,
0.3854584694,
0.1699324101,
-0.4103665054,
-0.1346989125,
0.6495622396,
-0.2926935852,
-0.2154711485,
-0.4309060574,
-0.6017516255,
0.6983222961,
0.3232052624,
-0.1003825739,
0.1019816846,
0.2055033147,
0.7440348268,
-0.4915879369,
-0.05820686,
0.9340672493,
0.510094285,
0.0767493919,
-0.534527123,
0.0957860649,
-0.693872571,
0.0762643516,
0.0732913539,
-0.143633917,
0.61315763,
-0.1069915518,
-0.454973489,
-0.2717454731,
0.2294547856,
0.4331565499,
0.5269165039,
0.3982684612,
0.9604380131,
0.9043671489,
-0.0410688557,
0.7983268499,
-0.4680261612,
0.2427106649,
0.7064544559,
-0.3433503807,
0.7772659063,
0.2605165541,
-0.1127652451,
0.5540950894,
0.7412899137,
0.1087023392,
0.4526480734,
0.0365727097,
-0.4181486368,
-0.3443319798,
-0.2765544951,
-0.4430180192,
0.3279117942,
0.8672013283,
-0.090481326,
-0.3603407741,
0.178484723,
0.1568593085,
0.1955425292,
-0.2381857038,
0.8121169806,
0.1305855364,
-0.2565761805,
0.6573085189,
0.1832506806,
0.7448055744,
-0.547493279,
-0.1003422514,
-0.1036778539,
0.3852108717,
-0.4429179132,
-0.7421357036,
0.6987549663,
0.0062010582,
-0.3772554994,
-0.1804151088,
0.9725885391,
0.0207995679,
-0.8409079909,
0.763438344,
0.5018554926,
-0.0361997597,
-0.4547827244,
-0.695301652,
0.0919296369,
-0.5071098804,
0.0146059757,
0.5219524503,
0.7193704844,
-0.3788198829,
0.4097225964,
0.4806733131,
0.417915374,
-0.2472700328,
0.1733722985,
1.0934226513,
-0.8306328058,
-0.5048968792,
-0.746055603,
0.3301267922,
-0.2567091286,
-0.2488670051,
0.379445821,
0.1945007443,
0.9039022326,
0.1332335621,
0.760651648,
-0.0237640981,
0.7683850527,
-0.102847293,
0.7882118821,
-0.62651366,
0.0341434255,
-0.4079788029,
-0.5925616622,
-0.7835525274,
0.52674371,
-0.2894284129,
-0.0119673554,
0.7156943679,
0.7277736664,
0.0420677215,
0.0172267109,
0.053703934,
0.1675158739,
0.0641036332,
0.4143462479,
0.6370888948,
0.0485152379,
0.1272790879,
-0.6776195168,
-0.2293180525,
-0.1735068262,
-0.3777159452,
-0.7692764401,
-0.5569359064,
-0.1847445816,
-0.3146267831,
0.075305514,
0.9470132589,
0.7493146062,
-0.8520978093,
0.2074071467,
0.1910372376,
0.2855384052,
-0.3963987529,
-0.292090565,
0.2496113926,
-0.3126383424,
-0.0152856279,
0.0188437216,
0.5076007247,
-0.1744760424,
-0.2176354527,
0.1314429492,
0.1171043515,
-0.3246429861,
0.6603226662,
-0.0068952772,
-0.7013956904,
-0.091416046,
-0.1539050639,
-0.0624272376,
0.1335645765,
0.7616981864,
-0.8460128903,
0.2820601463,
0.1478898823,
0.4595340192,
0.1893611401,
0.3354555666,
0.1858060956,
-0.3771509528,
0.0826117694,
0.4203719199,
0.1650416702,
0.4838488698,
-0.7253897786,
-0.0609380119,
0.6083651185,
-0.0701325536,
-0.6320962906,
-0.226679638,
-1.1164746284,
-0.4419583678,
0.5922188163,
-0.0535688475,
-0.3659260869,
-0.5346208215,
-0.0609804504,
0.3900724053,
-0.300360769,
1.1970938444,
0.4365155697,
-0.4369258881,
-0.1690206677,
-0.6372490525,
0.4926016331,
0.160609141,
-0.5655566454,
-0.0757593513,
0.4287182689,
0.1977415234,
-0.0221429449,
0.7404986024,
-0.4538907409,
0.4446147382,
-0.2045672685,
0.1510802358,
0.0938750282,
-0.3932682574,
-0.4143970013,
0.440634191,
-0.197144106,
0.0775561631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05074v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05074v2
|
GRASP: A Disagreement Analysis Framework to Assess Group Associations in Perspectives
| 2023-11-09T00:12:21 | 2024-06-14T03:28:49 |
Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Christopher Homan, Lora Aroyo, Aida Mostafazadeh Davani, Alicia Parrish, Alex Taylor, Mark Díaz, Ding Wang, Gregory Serapio-García
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Human annotation plays a core role in machine learning -- annotations for
supervised models, safety guardrails for generative models, and human feedback
for reinforcement learning, to cite a few avenues. However, the fact that many
of these human annotations are inherently subjective is often overlooked.
Recent work has demonstrated that ignoring rater subjectivity (typically
resulting in rater disagreement) is problematic within specific tasks and for
specific subgroups. Generalizable methods to harness rater disagreement and
thus understand the socio-cultural leanings of subjective tasks remain elusive.
In this paper, we propose GRASP, a comprehensive disagreement analysis
framework to measure group association in perspectives among different rater
sub-groups, and demonstrate its utility in assessing the extent of systematic
disagreements in two datasets: (1) safety annotations of human-chatbot
conversations, and (2) offensiveness annotations of social media posts, both
annotated by diverse rater pools across different socio-demographic axes. Our
framework (based on disagreement metrics) reveals specific rater groups that
have significantly different perspectives than others on certain tasks, and
helps identify demographic axes that are crucial to consider in specific task
contexts.
|
[
-0.6191920638,
-0.4542380571,
0.201735884,
0.2370690405,
-0.025271479,
0.1856670976,
0.01236354,
-0.5566930771,
0.0482617505,
0.1441385001,
-0.3240313232,
-0.4762296081,
-1.1050972939,
-0.0250846371,
-0.0212596338,
1.0636606216,
-0.0661436617,
-0.0464613214,
-0.3910589218,
-0.4831659198,
-0.3046294451,
-0.6583705544,
-0.797401607,
-0.4240446687,
0.785261929,
0.4026456475,
0.6736724377,
0.1346028596,
0.5864135623,
0.439950794,
-0.1338450313,
-0.0926584303,
-0.202842474,
0.0180041399,
-0.0837787762,
-0.5509762168,
-0.64753443,
0.1296257526,
0.1457016617,
0.8560215235,
0.0945897326,
0.1278115064,
0.1934929043,
0.751901567,
-0.8567976952,
0.3300292492,
-0.553391099,
0.3794717789,
-0.1767583936,
0.1835672408,
-0.1881243438,
-0.3854670525,
0.4846417904,
-0.5109812021,
0.3459207118,
-0.2996572852,
0.7417192459,
0.347335875,
-0.5717576146,
-0.0070237853,
-0.2580164671,
0.6804651618,
-0.7690921426,
0.0652828887,
0.696195066,
0.3947129846,
-0.0072664828,
-0.1618585289,
-0.5320528746,
0.1888325959,
-0.278083533,
0.1640314013,
-0.143893376,
0.1085822433,
0.3145356476,
0.1389891058,
-0.2896359265,
0.1413159072,
-0.2777037919,
-0.2522177994,
0.7663699389,
0.1110218242,
0.3336143792,
-0.2090591937,
-0.2980200648,
0.0292102322,
-0.5003316402,
0.3843984604,
0.4798233211,
0.2074315101,
-0.3385020494,
0.4842342734,
-0.3347868621,
0.6040766239,
0.266036272,
0.3147708476,
0.5027228594,
0.1572001129,
-0.1025184914,
-0.2906654775,
1.1201131344,
0.8958443403,
0.3586293459,
-0.1530317366,
-0.0942397639,
0.1715054661,
0.3536120951,
-0.4449380934,
-0.3871580958,
0.292593509,
-0.4857161045,
-0.3505764902,
0.0368843041,
-0.7495341301,
-0.9187908173,
-0.2201289684,
0.2177011222,
-0.0253782179,
-0.5556384325,
-0.1926245838,
-0.397744,
0.3355915248,
0.4771900475,
-0.8171257973,
-0.0043425998,
0.8224446774,
0.9250048399,
-0.2217904329,
-0.2611140609,
-0.3739556968,
-0.1471151561,
-0.3069497645,
0.8456778526,
-0.387495935,
-0.4885664284,
0.0183966681,
-0.1491107047,
-0.1669264883,
-0.545263648,
0.3512648642,
-0.3827376962,
0.2476067841,
-0.5340307951,
-0.48374632,
-0.3677275777,
0.6423859,
-0.5653138161,
0.7753573656,
0.0879237652,
-1.1449195147,
1.0792938471,
-0.7895669341,
-0.5018151999,
0.2406081706,
-0.3166308701,
-0.3395608366,
0.0125606284,
0.2182268053,
0.5605998635,
-0.0218052845,
0.3050913215,
-0.7069423199,
-0.0767255053,
0.3483114243,
0.0564567782,
0.8168645501,
0.2241011262,
-0.2098914981,
0.5646854043,
-0.3476466238,
-0.2686000466,
-0.1185834259,
-0.239479959,
-0.748611331,
0.3364797235,
-0.0255149417,
0.3521620035,
0.3084555864,
-0.5146264434,
0.1456543058,
-0.1528428942,
0.3947231472,
0.7425966859,
0.0223769117,
0.5000018477,
-0.4066964686,
0.4354610145,
0.2525978088,
0.3339638412,
0.2412723601,
-0.3646485209,
-0.6371856332,
-0.1136227995,
0.0236909874,
0.2485498488,
-0.7365570664,
0.6635523438,
-0.2337080836,
-0.6268127561,
-0.262981832,
0.0159569886,
0.422657758,
0.4588757753,
0.2242613882,
-0.8457938433,
-0.3979696035,
-0.8552975059,
-0.6442499161,
-0.7132798433,
-0.2464965582,
0.2099437863,
0.229204312,
0.1180902645,
1.3179520369,
-0.1959293187,
-0.4442746937,
-0.3824818432,
0.4892933667,
-0.0598365441,
0.42203632,
0.4099046886,
-1.0553436279,
-0.5641038418,
0.047122743,
-1.0142585039,
0.004445937,
0.0418466479,
-0.0260505788,
0.1797488481,
0.1572254002,
-0.2813030183,
0.5168625712,
0.2082909346,
-0.3905846775,
0.2743532062,
0.374669224,
0.2610255182,
-0.9272123575,
0.0836114585,
0.4662385285,
-0.1445490867,
-0.576934576,
-0.1013380289,
-0.1562032104,
0.4021516144,
-0.5012316108,
0.4461987615,
-0.1861217767,
0.0965420976,
-0.1266236603,
0.0656932965,
-0.3231191933,
0.4396664202,
0.2943662703,
0.7004546523,
0.3924628198,
-0.5636422038,
-0.1533600688,
0.4120428562,
-0.1775852591,
0.7928292155,
-0.6926092505,
0.3212485313,
-0.2936679125,
0.0528640747,
-0.8429513574,
-0.416863203,
0.5546069741,
-0.7167939544,
0.0317273699,
-0.6256306767,
-0.0042407331,
-0.2463842928,
-0.3941765428,
0.2764488161,
0.2172601074,
-0.1184215695,
0.8128756881,
0.8382195234,
-0.0928175077,
-1.0266704559,
-0.5506273508,
-0.013150801,
-0.7190542221,
-0.3990094364,
-0.2956413031,
0.1216241419,
-0.4114374518,
-0.182837829,
-0.239132449,
-0.2355489135,
0.1851112843,
0.6456685066,
0.0705784634,
0.2481289208,
-0.1402133107,
-0.0498021543,
-0.0798020586,
0.3568598628,
0.1858917326,
0.3310318589,
-0.2378651649,
-0.3639315665,
-0.1051350608,
-0.0233272687,
0.4026851356,
-0.0581462756,
0.5004855394,
0.3273544014,
-0.2649604976,
0.2904660702,
-0.3995323777,
0.2646388113,
-0.4855297506,
0.4980499744,
-0.422329247,
-0.974645853,
0.8235220313,
-0.069377251,
0.4820379019,
0.3000825047,
0.4829678535,
-0.1512275487,
0.8197969198,
0.5248864293,
-0.53332901,
0.5804534554,
-0.2108599544,
-0.1287437379,
-0.7765013576,
-0.1153628603,
-0.4307217002,
-0.575515151,
-0.3726392984,
-0.2337635756,
0.3279254436,
-0.0536570139,
-0.4134531021,
0.496417135,
-0.3033525646,
0.4027989805,
0.1661684662,
0.0171266813,
0.1750571728,
-0.1911469102,
0.0491997041,
-0.201729238,
-0.3806679249,
-0.7310478091,
1.0753321648,
0.4581518471,
0.4751171172,
0.2176288962,
0.7552025914,
0.6535536051,
0.8197572231,
-1.0909327269,
0.5191378593,
-0.0409537144,
-0.7989148498,
-0.1113154516,
-0.5658255816,
-0.9523681402,
0.5539809465,
-0.0950155854,
-1.045388341,
0.4018324316,
0.3605859876,
-0.0760491937,
0.4012034833,
-0.582729578,
1.2471430302,
-0.018056618,
-0.2265708745,
0.002737382,
-0.9655963778,
0.4494825304,
0.0111361118,
0.3458463848,
-0.377468586,
-0.0074651726,
0.991048336,
-0.2635674775,
1.149567008,
-0.698148489,
-0.2842835784,
0.3183381259,
0.2244970948,
0.0321926214,
-0.2243830711,
-0.1785290837,
0.407184571,
-0.0593394078,
-0.3264794946,
-0.4040391445,
0.1805777401,
-0.6993019581,
-0.4169998765,
-0.4370199442,
-0.3234041631,
-0.4128577113,
0.2522059381,
0.2981424034,
0.0901608765,
-0.4227797985,
-0.2857453525,
0.2490552962,
0.1141318083,
0.2190090716,
0.2703298032,
-0.1619504392,
-0.1842450052,
0.8431683183,
-0.1277649254,
0.400406599,
0.3009109795,
-0.0029740722,
-0.1598158032,
-0.4000332654,
-0.3850617707,
-0.3825617731,
-0.763597548,
-0.1340744942,
-0.6106737852,
0.1685224473,
-0.147334069,
-0.0830897167,
-0.1666599214,
-0.3900902867,
0.2130514681,
-0.0207146388,
0.2971355021,
0.6573719382,
-0.1180964038,
0.5961900353,
-0.6680117846,
0.0532251932,
0.0372187532,
0.1126967445,
0.1488834023,
-0.1359041631,
-0.1035662964,
0.0586982779,
-0.3895157874,
-0.9641948342,
0.0086351186,
-0.184709847,
0.3647592068,
0.7630115151,
0.2973881662,
0.3695800304,
-0.1388555765,
0.7677808404,
0.3763478398,
-0.9442929626,
0.2713953853,
-0.3265271485,
-0.0022792583,
0.8616848588,
0.6406934261,
-0.9304586053,
-0.5362435579,
-0.3793652058,
-0.8997893929,
0.5729044676,
-0.2002162933,
-0.0920839831,
-0.0335573331,
0.0180779807,
0.1592908055,
0.1423236877,
-0.7139398456,
-0.1815925688,
-0.0643854514,
-0.3771063983,
0.1042237803,
0.2683443725,
-0.3920663893,
-0.0779904351,
0.2301553488,
-0.4188271165,
-0.0575695857,
0.0226299465,
-0.1553750485,
-0.2165429741,
0.3268845677,
-0.2119961381,
0.8426370621,
-0.1135640964,
0.3072708249,
0.2609784007,
-0.4507750273,
0.329097867,
0.0462716855,
-0.3077716231,
-0.3072757423,
0.4839310646,
0.5180892944,
-0.0033246134,
-0.4223636091,
0.6858845949,
-0.1082096174,
-0.1767581999,
-0.1552843004,
0.0368959904,
-0.0001138695,
0.1312498748,
0.269431144,
0.4731195867,
0.3427556157,
-0.2841879725,
0.1269013286,
0.4437156618,
-0.8225733042,
-0.3787517846,
0.4340353906,
0.3272330463,
-0.1155836284,
0.2596873939,
-0.231621325,
-0.884245038,
0.6021738052,
-0.3160582185,
1.0051891804,
0.0803938955,
0.3363155127,
0.3403301239,
0.3360252678,
0.1693662852,
0.0122099919,
-0.32698524,
-0.9323598742,
-0.4400278628,
-0.274631381,
-0.6100054383,
-0.3540181518,
-0.9138992429,
-0.0474976115,
-0.3627900183,
-0.6264443398,
0.0710911304,
-0.2115579695,
-0.7721852064,
0.0613469444,
-0.144881174,
0.5880869031,
-1.0730928183,
0.3502944708,
1.0777287483,
-0.683178246,
-0.4953692853,
0.4386265576,
0.3309397995,
-0.5612955689,
0.69114393,
0.1832594872,
-0.1348297149,
-0.7424604893,
-0.5862944722,
-0.3438526094,
0.4996609688,
-0.0935367942,
-0.4917731881,
0.0300763752,
0.0750618875,
0.5263966918,
-0.0549043454,
0.3057425618,
0.4753347933,
0.3677222133,
0.0189480875,
-0.9572508335,
0.1567279994,
-0.2697179914,
-0.1352164745,
0.2374016494,
-0.6938975453,
0.4558403492,
-0.2246018052,
-0.280484885,
-0.1476282179,
0.8192282319,
0.2512561381,
0.7321991324,
0.9741514325,
0.3261976838,
0.4819659293,
-0.0052603753,
0.6862766743,
0.2491344064,
0.3989441991,
1.162399292,
-0.541610539,
0.8435995579,
0.5034288168,
-0.5707786083,
0.2537918091,
0.7461836338,
0.3085630238,
0.1869320869,
0.333669126,
-0.2202918828,
-0.3955967724,
0.1560167819,
-0.2219676226,
0.4155027568,
0.4454120696,
0.1225406751,
-0.1568899453,
-0.2607599497,
0.211298272,
0.074275136,
-0.1273308247,
1.1091645956,
0.0619350635,
-0.6021361351,
0.1219198629,
-0.2195728123,
1.0417248011,
-0.4195382595,
0.1850159913,
-0.1804352701,
0.157838136,
-0.327151835,
-1.0437885523,
0.3847691715,
0.2021684498,
0.0099731088,
0.1545395851,
0.7163167596,
-0.1408169717,
-0.0613446571,
0.4284312427,
0.5891700983,
0.3078671992,
0.022998523,
-0.7447828054,
-0.1169433147,
-0.1490729302,
-0.2478339076,
0.4434042573,
0.5417222977,
-0.2030936927,
0.590828836,
0.2832168937,
-0.1062916666,
-0.0541792251,
0.0222577695,
0.8293807507,
-0.3736738563,
-0.1794124246,
-0.7257617712,
0.5296012759,
-0.3084998131,
-0.5695154667,
0.748480618,
0.4862009585,
0.9648773074,
0.109584406,
1.0542430878,
-0.6931136847,
0.5317168832,
-0.0622200817,
0.9859618545,
-0.5966750383,
-0.034256883,
-0.5194413066,
-0.7691451907,
-0.3631373942,
0.8978115916,
-0.7202174067,
0.3434664905,
0.1623365879,
0.324971348,
-0.0955771357,
0.1763698459,
0.0003519712,
0.035228312,
0.5089560151,
0.6433730721,
1.1086617708,
-0.2503222823,
0.2439090759,
-0.1206420138,
-0.345203042,
0.1428795606,
-0.9205164313,
-1.0315535069,
-0.4513872266,
-0.6020711064,
-0.3041910827,
-0.1396528035,
1.0302313566,
0.676704824,
-0.8688300848,
-0.4209646285,
0.1640948951,
0.1959231198,
-0.3344217539,
-0.3003467321,
0.1690549701,
-0.398131907,
-0.7101265788,
-0.0574194081,
-0.1014001891,
-0.2147230208,
-0.1624138951,
-0.2244874835,
-0.0580956116,
-0.3364604414,
0.4796030223,
0.6426361799,
-0.6878542304,
-0.3416539431,
-0.3361656964,
0.0908679664,
0.0187769085,
0.886085391,
-0.5648328066,
0.486595422,
0.3656219244,
0.6571643353,
0.2351505309,
0.1562292129,
0.5065205693,
-0.831320405,
0.0619190261,
0.0491388477,
0.3868668973,
0.5543076396,
-0.2684396207,
0.635165453,
0.1092315912,
-0.557692945,
-0.473706454,
0.2037715316,
-0.9996348619,
-0.1306004822,
0.7635756731,
-0.5801716447,
-0.0218156818,
-0.3945377767,
-0.2720417678,
0.3208326697,
-0.5992056131,
0.9654075503,
0.7517584562,
-0.1405889988,
0.0149671612,
-0.2924325168,
0.529464066,
0.6112619638,
-0.8206050992,
0.5335581899,
0.6012806892,
0.3413804471,
0.2299177647,
0.853274703,
-0.1207332984,
-0.0103675257,
-0.3563854992,
0.2586287856,
0.1720175445,
-0.1845246851,
-0.2123999447,
0.1401443779,
0.1896058321,
-0.2606978118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05051v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05051v1
|
Deep Learning Brasil at ABSAPT 2022: Portuguese Transformer Ensemble Approaches
| 2023-11-08T22:58:34 | 2023-11-08T22:58:34 |
Juliana Resplande Santanna Gomes, Eduardo Augusto Santos Garcia, Adalberto Ferreira Barbosa Junior, Ruan Chaves Rodrigues, Diogo Fernandes Costa Silva, Dyonnatan Ferreira Maia, Nádia Félix Felipe da Silva, Arlindo Rodrigues Galvão Filho, Anderson da Silva Soares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is a task whose objective is to
classify the individual sentiment polarity of all entities, called aspects, in
a sentence. The task is composed of two subtasks: Aspect Term Extraction (ATE),
identify all aspect terms in a sentence; and Sentiment Orientation Extraction
(SOE), given a sentence and its aspect terms, the task is to determine the
sentiment polarity of each aspect term (positive, negative or neutral). This
article presents we present our participation in Aspect-Based Sentiment
Analysis in Portuguese (ABSAPT) 2022 at IberLEF 2022. We submitted the best
performing systems, achieving new state-of-the-art results on both subtasks.
|
[
-0.8016147017,
-0.727534771,
0.3848085999,
0.4041842222,
-0.6240690351,
0.3762485385,
0.0394691154,
-0.6013920307,
0.5612745285,
0.496249944,
-0.673343122,
-0.50148803,
-0.6133850217,
0.1400316507,
-0.3340086937,
1.3592144251,
-0.2015902102,
0.3592565954,
-0.2107924968,
-0.3238161802,
-0.5280670524,
-0.5898812413,
-0.7092747688,
-0.501404047,
0.4416439533,
0.4342818558,
0.3204178512,
-0.0597225577,
0.6363970637,
0.2885814011,
0.0181349032,
-0.1848229319,
0.0423359498,
0.3100572228,
-0.5327105522,
-0.4079129696,
-0.530117929,
0.1039657816,
0.2117367983,
0.5861644149,
0.1105625555,
-0.0952117518,
0.1579460949,
0.6704438925,
-0.3401927352,
0.4516401589,
-0.2213306129,
0.0547262244,
0.2082850337,
0.0751948208,
0.1193396375,
-0.1676654071,
0.1892867088,
-0.0440540947,
0.2400708646,
-0.2777446806,
0.9368242025,
0.2509070039,
-0.2853547931,
-0.3607619405,
-0.6395525932,
0.8905767798,
-0.4939815998,
0.4824377596,
-0.1151277199,
0.0765465572,
0.2128984779,
-0.3942388296,
-0.5126075745,
0.2683238089,
0.0483772382,
0.4568798542,
-0.3016983867,
0.238713935,
-0.3271089792,
0.585008502,
-0.2333910316,
0.4167008102,
-0.3972906172,
-0.1229841411,
0.9417824149,
-0.1675211787,
-0.1586757749,
-0.2902616262,
-0.5300326943,
0.0914269164,
-0.806412816,
0.162002936,
0.4891753197,
0.19161506,
-0.2313075215,
0.3970062435,
-0.3325355649,
0.2172582,
0.1192581281,
0.100029543,
0.3697420657,
-0.1792445481,
-0.2632974982,
0.1793544888,
0.9931428432,
0.00236872,
-0.1764462441,
-0.0323497169,
-0.6679893732,
-0.0118324738,
0.3350326717,
-0.698949039,
-0.1923551559,
0.5903384089,
-0.4210588932,
-0.6070752144,
0.3326350451,
-1.0592048168,
-0.58116889,
-0.5829191208,
0.2889218032,
-0.3980904818,
-0.1972936243,
-0.2959036231,
0.03079753,
0.4627786875,
0.3658654988,
-0.4698808789,
0.0322431847,
1.0737019777,
0.50228405,
-0.3389937878,
-0.1821267456,
-0.1608712524,
-0.6580708027,
-0.2231159508,
1.2187155485,
-0.4751576483,
-0.5081783533,
-0.1486671418,
0.0340374187,
0.1702593118,
-0.4175895154,
0.8896722198,
-0.4414077103,
0.5084223151,
-0.1180203855,
-0.4223318398,
-0.6661103964,
0.4072804153,
-0.3816417158,
0.8324349523,
0.3600284457,
-0.4740738571,
0.4476730525,
-0.7372545004,
-0.5672002435,
0.1732681543,
-0.326107651,
-0.5633497238,
0.3398970068,
0.4011776745,
0.6248427629,
-0.261541903,
0.291592747,
-0.1155106574,
0.0597577356,
0.468695581,
-0.4356538355,
0.5841810703,
0.240313381,
-0.4527694881,
0.2744532228,
-0.412027508,
-0.3583444059,
-0.1839088351,
-0.1186973304,
-0.0351145193,
0.1148220077,
0.2175655514,
0.1737497598,
0.4907446802,
-0.8291910291,
0.5527583361,
-0.6404235363,
0.5165733099,
0.6504914761,
0.2124768496,
0.5341330767,
0.2100054324,
0.8050213456,
0.3272328079,
0.3374661803,
-0.1299450994,
-0.5409260988,
-0.7611157894,
-0.4558206499,
0.4183871448,
0.6899980307,
-0.9396262765,
0.7600308061,
-0.2106393129,
-0.6342465281,
-0.5768830776,
0.1474030465,
0.4104394913,
0.277495116,
0.289485842,
-0.702445507,
-0.7499360442,
-0.9835678339,
-0.0643716082,
-0.2204645574,
0.2026873827,
0.1030826941,
0.5424970388,
-0.2951552868,
0.9472124577,
-0.2360128462,
-0.6354371905,
-0.7469418645,
0.5171510577,
0.5023732185,
0.3751176894,
0.7097980976,
-1.093152523,
-0.1943667084,
0.1491770893,
-0.8103451133,
-0.0651421323,
0.101139687,
0.4005509913,
0.5364513993,
0.3979643285,
-0.4642953873,
0.2205464244,
0.5994486809,
-0.2332151532,
0.1834070086,
0.1465009302,
0.1345647722,
-1.0836713314,
-0.2715554833,
0.0684078485,
-0.0730220675,
-0.4288935065,
0.0932176784,
-0.303698957,
-0.1051237136,
-0.5553043485,
0.2797650993,
-0.2195808887,
-0.189814806,
-0.4329739809,
-0.3265918195,
0.0524099246,
0.4921533167,
0.3593170345,
0.5710549951,
0.7775073051,
-0.3386471272,
0.4860053062,
-0.102251932,
-0.1900184155,
0.8737630248,
-0.4988801777,
0.2914628386,
-0.25785321,
0.1884735227,
-0.8271890879,
-0.0865873918,
0.2088383585,
-0.5428775549,
0.5682784915,
-0.1332457215,
0.0243071429,
-0.507158637,
-0.4581955671,
0.2360442132,
0.2249163389,
-0.2264492959,
1.0067129135,
0.4776086807,
-0.3212037683,
-0.9225670099,
-0.6081284881,
0.1724997312,
-0.3087311387,
-0.1719302684,
0.1764790565,
0.4851845503,
-0.3155110478,
0.1271058321,
0.0975880399,
0.0617595017,
0.1110522598,
0.4278560877,
0.1943385005,
-0.3655981421,
-0.2011149079,
0.3196486831,
-0.1603665352,
0.0797374323,
-0.4348499179,
0.8954203725,
-0.5162338614,
-0.0850889459,
-0.5927727818,
0.425298363,
0.3456542194,
-0.4775826931,
0.5054806471,
0.6380364895,
-0.1603316069,
-0.1200959757,
-0.4301073849,
-0.133306101,
-0.4512579441,
0.5731585026,
-0.2327271849,
-0.7595704198,
0.5519643426,
0.0201321989,
0.1447532773,
0.6074292064,
0.5187245607,
-0.5137026906,
0.7589122057,
0.9174564481,
-0.3709629178,
0.5485925078,
-0.5993545651,
0.5112532377,
-0.8098297119,
-0.2597301602,
-0.4649968743,
-0.5840719342,
-0.8232221007,
-0.2010566145,
0.4496891797,
0.2927464247,
-0.078158021,
0.4189629555,
-0.5131494999,
0.3361140192,
0.4945611954,
0.029557433,
-0.0293935332,
-0.1502392888,
0.3685328662,
0.1405783296,
-0.37177369,
-0.4931284189,
1.0011868477,
0.4883684218,
0.3792361617,
-0.0998712108,
1.1027954817,
0.4103280306,
0.6222606301,
-1.3079227209,
0.5464231968,
-0.4492477179,
-0.2955626845,
-0.1825439185,
-0.1273014545,
-0.8927493691,
0.1521701962,
-0.1138994172,
-0.6235122085,
0.7213198543,
-0.1315965205,
-0.1061185524,
0.2724507153,
-0.5285898447,
0.7486282587,
-0.3219785988,
0.0323180184,
-0.2456208169,
-0.5282192826,
-0.0248210412,
0.0168034174,
0.3831531405,
-0.0297814663,
-0.0586425997,
0.8707295656,
0.0970949382,
0.8450328112,
-0.4958312809,
-0.1466647387,
0.5682911277,
0.1955475062,
0.3410571516,
0.2162611783,
-0.1012363583,
0.67132622,
-0.0541057922,
-0.2310692817,
-0.497433424,
0.5278176069,
-0.9183411002,
-0.4958693385,
-0.6082907915,
-0.2352674603,
-0.1899517626,
0.3053322434,
0.3901936114,
0.1682334393,
-0.5224485397,
0.1905018538,
0.5401486158,
-0.1115211248,
0.6394679546,
0.3701888323,
-0.1821302176,
-0.5725570917,
1.2150450945,
0.0575638972,
-0.3045708239,
0.7927404046,
0.1723020822,
-0.2062989175,
-0.7905278802,
-0.3769291043,
0.0774787366,
-0.5549770594,
-0.4663739204,
-0.5397792459,
-0.125282988,
-0.5518186092,
-0.2213369608,
-0.6558045745,
-0.4113821089,
-0.1500276476,
-0.4854548872,
0.1267711371,
0.8891455531,
-0.1844085157,
0.3594931662,
-0.6000865102,
-0.0484436862,
0.1355584413,
-0.1251250356,
-0.5342567563,
-0.0968713611,
-0.0135509251,
-0.0737980753,
-0.7303773165,
-0.7689408064,
0.7126232982,
0.1793825328,
0.3969200253,
0.7124272585,
-0.2348854542,
-0.0694494024,
0.1189446449,
0.9475845098,
0.167871967,
-0.9563518167,
0.7110159993,
-0.2960818708,
-0.1127782911,
0.5415529013,
0.5637683868,
-0.4130490124,
-0.3744624555,
-0.7676954269,
-0.9296981096,
0.6623567939,
0.0204432197,
0.1488703191,
0.2320050448,
0.5674661994,
0.4131445885,
0.5016027093,
-0.5878711343,
-0.1635524333,
-0.5286713243,
-0.3274170756,
-0.1855800003,
-0.1913356632,
-0.0471400693,
-0.2826532722,
0.7390891314,
-0.3636749387,
0.615034461,
0.154652968,
0.1988641471,
0.1110131145,
0.5225542188,
0.2313641459,
0.428452909,
-0.1072397083,
0.1060840786,
0.2231264412,
-0.5043100119,
-0.0192708317,
0.2158827484,
-0.2783782482,
-0.2331606448,
0.6309775114,
0.8018400669,
-0.2417807281,
-0.4686708748,
0.6481441855,
0.0774657801,
-0.1147324815,
-0.5070813298,
-0.0428665057,
-0.3401701748,
0.330771625,
0.4208417833,
0.1774340272,
0.299546212,
-0.9282601476,
0.0487039872,
0.3480648696,
-1.046351552,
-0.6071961522,
0.244005695,
0.3557309806,
-0.1230844259,
0.6001111865,
-0.3138917387,
-1.0104818344,
0.8350185156,
-0.1085775942,
1.3831763268,
-0.406098336,
0.3860735893,
0.0226998292,
0.2597557008,
0.3101338744,
0.6289941669,
-0.0023024096,
-0.9841650128,
-0.3539678752,
-0.8265098333,
-0.5526219606,
0.0092550935,
-0.8000457883,
0.3898251951,
-0.2377105951,
0.1057478413,
-0.0102763437,
0.0909484029,
-0.655490458,
0.4824393392,
0.1341605037,
0.3757625818,
-0.9239231348,
0.8266320229,
1.0517470837,
-0.4963115156,
-0.4913031161,
-0.2055251002,
-0.1856788099,
-0.6806385517,
0.3761456609,
0.1870798171,
0.0942741409,
-0.4939363301,
-0.7086243033,
-0.5376433134,
0.9338907003,
0.1087956652,
-0.3967293501,
0.1724793911,
0.3711174726,
0.8550144434,
-0.3830859661,
0.1407946497,
0.7710955143,
0.4415070415,
-0.0981440023,
-0.7651037574,
-0.3078265488,
-0.002081834,
-0.3408723474,
0.3871597946,
-0.7857323289,
0.9232666492,
0.1614030898,
0.0700101256,
-0.2210453749,
1.1926702261,
-0.332429111,
0.3991468549,
0.5443315506,
0.5589099526,
0.3455013633,
-0.4947876036,
1.0244916677,
-0.3261401653,
0.5178002715,
0.7995446324,
-0.12684533,
0.8180720806,
0.4475041926,
-0.1785215884,
0.715559423,
0.6573228836,
0.0965403244,
0.4978822172,
-0.2802255452,
-0.2020668387,
-0.2262852341,
-0.2269918919,
-0.1833683699,
0.8919787407,
0.6549532413,
-0.163983345,
-0.2032399476,
0.4274655282,
0.1205855012,
-0.1878969222,
-0.4775191545,
1.04573524,
0.275064677,
-0.882550478,
-0.101053454,
0.1968816817,
0.8092968464,
-0.3265891969,
0.1009737104,
-0.5469669104,
0.4626438022,
-0.3643398285,
-1.4113785028,
0.6068832278,
-0.1630205512,
0.0074660643,
-0.3981246352,
0.5847801566,
0.0274289809,
-0.6347774863,
0.2386868447,
0.3046984076,
0.1289070696,
-0.5037358403,
-0.8979195952,
-0.2297948897,
0.0173362829,
-0.4980745018,
0.4209433794,
0.6698940396,
-0.2656776309,
0.4579295218,
0.1384679377,
-0.1455897689,
-0.4487847388,
0.0361190327,
1.0337586403,
-0.5865725875,
-0.5530533195,
-0.6053495407,
0.1135611832,
0.1018302366,
-0.6340626478,
0.5561159253,
0.6304657459,
0.731767118,
0.1180251315,
0.7563653588,
-0.3848252892,
0.2968824208,
-0.3099665046,
0.3909734488,
-0.4431468546,
0.1277651787,
-0.1038207561,
-1.1629052162,
-0.1253228039,
0.3689767122,
-0.4442536533,
-0.2369307727,
0.6168283224,
0.6814599633,
0.0676221997,
0.4498912394,
-0.0850675181,
0.253126055,
0.582334578,
0.404722929,
0.8941960335,
-0.4045108259,
0.0465003178,
-0.7997444868,
-0.3385732472,
0.0342496671,
-0.7806084156,
-0.6022853255,
-0.6643816829,
-0.578551054,
-0.2933177352,
-0.0537133776,
0.8868473768,
0.3287627995,
-1.3262864351,
-0.2303610891,
-0.318184793,
0.339584142,
-0.5981670022,
-0.320181191,
0.5504681468,
-0.2331049591,
-0.8587507606,
0.3638180494,
0.4315192401,
-0.2469105124,
-0.6602458358,
0.2358112931,
0.0689871237,
0.0359540358,
0.6629297137,
0.3290854692,
-0.381208837,
-0.3251705468,
-0.2209735066,
0.3205418885,
0.3182678819,
0.8557914495,
-0.7796909809,
0.1558715403,
0.7366592288,
0.2679669559,
0.3809524477,
0.0773285925,
0.4527630806,
-0.7289038301,
0.3390571475,
0.8424215913,
0.3996768296,
0.3201684058,
-0.3912288547,
0.6080546379,
0.3514200449,
-0.456310153,
-0.5515200496,
0.19708094,
-1.4645318985,
-0.5020652413,
1.1986618042,
-0.1467820108,
-0.4591878057,
-0.259034425,
-0.3180882931,
0.012405701,
-0.5008667111,
0.7050027847,
0.4260594845,
-0.5830058455,
-0.1549587399,
0.0131367194,
0.2191024125,
0.2584142983,
-0.8574022055,
-0.4085461199,
0.1400340647,
0.0200364236,
0.3693470657,
0.211468637,
-0.2242376357,
0.1016721427,
-0.3647776246,
0.4408705831,
0.0931237563,
-0.4890623391,
-0.4708402753,
0.353789866,
-0.2221115977,
-0.1467557251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05047v1
|
DeepLearningBrasil@LT-EDI-2023: Exploring Deep Learning Techniques for Detecting Depression in Social Media Text
| 2023-11-08T22:42:31 | 2023-11-08T22:42:31 |
Eduardo Garcia, Juliana Gomes, Adalberto Barbosa Júnior, Cardeque Borges, Nádia da Silva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we delineate the strategy employed by our team,
DeepLearningBrasil, which secured us the first place in the shared task
DepSign-LT-EDI@RANLP-2023, achieving a 47.0% Macro F1-Score and a notable 2.4%
advantage. The task was to classify social media texts into three distinct
levels of depression - "not depressed," "moderately depressed," and "severely
depressed." Leveraging the power of the RoBERTa and DeBERTa models, we further
pre-trained them on a collected Reddit dataset, specifically curated from
mental health-related Reddit's communities (Subreddits), leading to an enhanced
understanding of nuanced mental health discourse. To address lengthy textual
data, we used truncation techniques that retained the essence of the content by
focusing on its beginnings and endings. Our model was robust against unbalanced
data by incorporating sample weights into the loss. Cross-validation and
ensemble techniques were then employed to combine our k-fold trained models,
delivering an optimal solution. The accompanying code is made available for
transparency and further development.
|
[
-0.3048976064,
-0.8557724953,
0.8399603963,
0.3416965604,
-0.5087021589,
0.3561244011,
-0.3779742718,
-0.237630561,
0.3182192743,
-0.0128490934,
-0.8921216726,
-0.9173861146,
-0.9560613036,
0.1693735868,
-0.3425551057,
0.9424731135,
-0.0114163319,
0.1681402326,
-0.1144092157,
0.1824355572,
-0.3588447571,
-0.1639150679,
-0.8220410943,
-0.2664666176,
0.6795318127,
0.4340642989,
0.2491249293,
-0.1269321442,
0.6534872055,
0.1166028604,
-0.3442325294,
0.2958096266,
-0.7297852039,
-0.0199161228,
-0.1905958802,
-0.2015484422,
-0.4302179217,
0.1336359382,
0.0704523325,
0.3754798472,
0.0284509975,
0.225706473,
0.4176594019,
0.6350340247,
-0.7525845766,
0.0105881374,
-0.207878083,
0.3785621822,
0.0908110887,
-0.0941373184,
-0.3136789203,
-0.4242906272,
-0.1292265356,
-0.2922651768,
0.1294905394,
-0.8047753572,
0.6634174585,
0.5442138314,
-0.505394578,
-0.3263786137,
-0.73988837,
0.7436941266,
-0.694570601,
0.1092745438,
0.3547344804,
0.1027086601,
0.2912150323,
-0.7075505257,
-0.2538043559,
0.4881151915,
-0.0605515502,
0.1799246818,
-0.2460971028,
-0.0531082824,
0.1441304237,
0.3186921179,
-0.8325232863,
0.2909933627,
-0.4109352529,
0.2010842562,
0.8201480508,
0.0648244992,
0.1838545948,
-0.239646554,
-0.1251392961,
0.0435254984,
-0.0832447931,
-0.055650413,
-0.0994435325,
0.2240205258,
-0.2950844765,
0.5006712079,
0.1572206616,
0.2056651711,
0.15294604,
-0.0603501424,
0.3851887286,
-0.16551359,
-0.3301944733,
0.0728874952,
0.8500396013,
0.6751666069,
0.2785961926,
0.2928292751,
-0.1573861688,
0.2812314332,
0.348184526,
-0.8790611029,
-0.5627331138,
0.1629943848,
-0.788941443,
-0.3098642528,
-0.1832606047,
-0.935234189,
-0.9622548819,
-0.31472224,
0.2118297964,
-0.5264927149,
-0.3890190125,
0.2005702555,
-0.1233608052,
-0.3927314878,
0.1457744092,
-0.5142247081,
0.1361502856,
0.9013732076,
0.9857373238,
-0.0309687555,
0.0765588135,
-0.2218039334,
-0.1476131827,
-0.1073061898,
0.7227169275,
-0.4847769439,
-0.1661071479,
0.2122877538,
0.0346750244,
0.0151744578,
-0.2507643104,
0.9120087624,
-0.161074385,
0.2355252057,
-0.1077844948,
-0.7897216082,
-0.1201206148,
0.2147897333,
-0.709836185,
0.6208338737,
0.1592463404,
-0.9050244689,
0.3261977136,
-0.3734932542,
-0.5513198972,
-0.0545254909,
0.0649168566,
-0.4235356748,
0.2861516476,
0.4342248738,
0.8819280267,
-0.0125049558,
0.20377101,
-0.7737923861,
-0.4740080237,
0.2283181548,
-0.3586213589,
0.7441729903,
0.2179448903,
-0.3603293002,
-0.1483982503,
-0.5982375145,
-0.0386826955,
0.1925846487,
-0.2100949734,
-0.6894204617,
-0.1755248755,
0.0410222486,
0.1398281306,
0.0383372903,
-0.4360397756,
0.0456483848,
-0.4299355149,
0.637229085,
0.5496563911,
0.1951168776,
0.3581803143,
0.1496253908,
0.4874006212,
-0.0068574669,
0.4206266105,
0.189545542,
-0.4242572188,
-0.1978326291,
-0.5350610614,
0.2308740616,
0.5689662695,
-0.3483208716,
0.7054218054,
-0.0315303802,
-0.614960134,
-0.7840360999,
0.0592873581,
0.2280028611,
0.2198056281,
0.5919672847,
-0.0790028423,
-0.6425523758,
-0.5518172383,
-0.1993045956,
0.3643940687,
0.0396306366,
0.0626132935,
0.4402563572,
-0.6938201189,
0.3437678516,
-0.6564694047,
-0.508346498,
-0.3345374167,
0.5092530251,
0.3057398498,
0.2667108178,
0.3559646606,
-0.8110055923,
-0.7367760539,
-0.2744913399,
-0.8868916631,
0.0108498931,
-0.1454841495,
0.1930285841,
0.0593044311,
0.2212281376,
-0.9209809303,
0.6034228206,
0.4213681221,
-0.2581052482,
0.0477239452,
0.2144482136,
0.0529085658,
-1.0734349489,
-0.1909622699,
0.3843613267,
-0.1194033176,
-0.468301475,
-0.4192159176,
0.01417509,
-0.2503604889,
-0.120042935,
0.1207062006,
-0.2110701203,
0.303142935,
-0.3159480095,
0.1631819457,
0.1423006952,
0.2093224972,
-0.2445978373,
0.3817582726,
0.4767589867,
-0.3231312335,
0.1673206538,
0.1307751387,
-0.2673288286,
0.3796338141,
-0.4761088192,
0.0321467146,
-0.3740946352,
0.3528133631,
-0.9873077869,
-0.104811646,
0.333969295,
-0.7651580572,
0.2233755291,
0.2859530151,
-0.2892745733,
-0.6583169699,
-0.5113236308,
0.5646175742,
0.2825832367,
-0.3592350185,
0.1823664904,
0.6083782315,
-0.084007673,
-0.52283144,
-0.7960944772,
0.0780989975,
-0.3707744777,
-0.3088235259,
0.5040360689,
0.0068234224,
-0.1928616166,
0.2363419384,
0.0592767075,
-0.258256048,
0.2657108605,
0.1845053881,
-0.236429885,
-0.0111558829,
0.5551400781,
0.1932336986,
-0.0735393837,
0.2187686116,
0.0232774112,
0.797881484,
-0.0189332161,
0.0647549927,
-0.9328917265,
0.4590915442,
0.2881413996,
-0.0032116659,
0.7365835905,
0.7483592033,
-0.6553839445,
-0.3662205637,
-0.2794530988,
-0.2120416015,
-0.3816938102,
0.1613345146,
0.0800622329,
-0.9693262577,
0.1753996909,
-0.1081895381,
-0.248946473,
0.3501136601,
0.3929811418,
-0.3138154149,
1.2333108187,
0.8201603889,
-0.2192642391,
0.2218700349,
-0.5026620626,
0.5220242143,
-0.3327046037,
-0.0142494496,
-0.1825265437,
-0.5948856473,
-0.4908131659,
-0.2610476613,
0.0054377499,
0.052549053,
-0.2653950751,
0.2898261845,
-0.7952388525,
0.3731599748,
0.4366311729,
0.5178281069,
-0.0079209162,
-0.0776220411,
0.3553167284,
-0.3242225945,
-0.2544665337,
-0.4330317378,
0.8299883008,
0.5582045317,
0.7502042651,
-0.234174639,
1.1089465618,
0.7990375757,
0.2971336544,
-0.7167320251,
0.3748544753,
-0.486964196,
-0.2642557025,
-0.2044687122,
-0.503210783,
-0.7570436001,
-0.3043794036,
-0.147176832,
-0.4436728656,
0.2933831215,
-0.109358862,
-0.6732486486,
0.076477021,
-0.6271048188,
1.0293250084,
-0.3623067141,
0.055887837,
-0.5934841037,
-0.6403547525,
0.47301808,
-0.1253843457,
0.2334999591,
-0.2528996468,
0.2200972885,
0.5788266063,
0.3162843287,
1.0329657793,
-0.2218619585,
-0.224925071,
0.1305847466,
-0.2462771088,
0.0512937345,
0.3460555077,
0.112300612,
-0.1377644986,
-0.0701482221,
-0.360688746,
-0.6194382906,
0.6633710861,
-0.7966671586,
-0.1596100926,
-0.0999684632,
-0.1226094738,
-0.0248070844,
0.2872007191,
0.2647863925,
0.1631396562,
-0.4137749672,
0.2870486975,
0.7584475875,
-0.358656615,
0.2145996988,
0.0690347776,
-0.1215705425,
-0.6947908998,
0.7668964267,
0.0671616942,
-0.3340587616,
0.4626194835,
0.0791686401,
-0.0635624975,
-0.1739106923,
0.3751412332,
0.5728729367,
-0.6925027966,
-0.4787029922,
-0.6013368368,
-0.2089608461,
-0.8346983194,
-0.1496461481,
-0.3912711143,
-0.4056780338,
-1.0263715982,
-0.6232699752,
0.0411163345,
0.7479345202,
-0.2911690772,
0.1814687252,
-1.0111194849,
0.3340453804,
0.1187596843,
0.2405719757,
0.0791643485,
-0.0202812534,
-0.2581049502,
0.3147692978,
-0.3448055685,
-0.9771046638,
0.6872370839,
0.2278523147,
0.1799384207,
0.6543784738,
0.412702769,
0.5926111341,
0.0987154618,
0.462749064,
0.3568309546,
-0.6889050603,
0.7882897258,
-0.1154610366,
0.1165395305,
0.9235801697,
0.9838340282,
-0.4700553119,
-0.3072966635,
-0.4675639272,
-0.8486307263,
0.2291603833,
0.0950211436,
0.3630215824,
-0.3419412374,
0.5204403996,
0.1361066401,
0.0960480794,
-0.8030443192,
-0.0517186709,
-0.2162988484,
-0.7489478588,
-0.2155792713,
-0.6068512797,
-0.1710388064,
-0.4775677621,
0.5333013535,
0.0794843659,
0.3110287488,
0.2280270606,
-0.1543769091,
-0.1725973934,
-0.0357232206,
0.4378322959,
0.5165413022,
-0.2947373688,
0.363751322,
-0.1773379892,
-0.2814636827,
0.0328062251,
0.3274585009,
-0.0870849267,
0.0491029695,
0.4716160595,
0.7475919127,
0.0195758343,
-0.6706606746,
0.6283565164,
-0.4512664676,
-0.3806093931,
-0.4782467484,
-0.0635910109,
0.2363406569,
0.7243250608,
0.2338692993,
-0.3154572546,
0.3203289807,
-0.4422341287,
0.3576228619,
0.2876970172,
-0.715359211,
-0.5427767038,
0.2474691868,
0.3196120262,
-0.4624500275,
0.5601547956,
-0.2144645005,
-0.4061270654,
0.4924865365,
0.1144508272,
1.1213152409,
-0.1929588914,
0.7395830154,
0.3578490317,
0.1684424728,
-0.0130416462,
0.3214797974,
-0.0860619098,
-0.5176915526,
-0.1716531813,
-0.5161156058,
0.1254518032,
0.4900561869,
-0.6631922722,
0.3000741303,
-0.4928348362,
-0.5333775282,
0.1045889482,
0.2040522099,
-0.4370150566,
0.5093777776,
0.5817141533,
0.8321536779,
-1.0233750343,
0.3937222958,
0.6004466414,
-0.278879106,
-0.3488360643,
0.4196118414,
0.0786936358,
-0.3040805459,
0.4083605409,
0.8489449024,
-0.0204282664,
0.032208927,
-0.6646010876,
-0.51454252,
1.0352762938,
0.0813297108,
-0.4314801693,
-0.0910770744,
0.1975582242,
0.7608577609,
-0.389962405,
-0.0384540744,
0.326574564,
0.3651482463,
-0.2731119096,
-0.4144712985,
0.0113712652,
-0.4190910161,
-0.2732665241,
-0.0078596137,
-0.401874423,
0.7337037921,
-0.0969146639,
-0.6261410117,
-0.1157354861,
0.6747031808,
-0.0999548957,
0.6872605681,
0.3735477328,
1.0580550432,
1.0305819511,
0.3021986783,
0.5655974746,
-0.2164991498,
0.760640204,
0.9504390955,
-0.2267888784,
0.6087344289,
0.1277746707,
0.1821797341,
0.5105143189,
0.9189080596,
-0.2279309034,
0.8965787888,
-0.0996526405,
-0.3925057054,
-0.3279975951,
-0.1412204951,
-0.3089386821,
0.2049177885,
0.4892195463,
-0.7488628626,
-0.222406894,
0.4075363874,
0.1375185251,
0.2478048801,
-0.2370301485,
0.8882029057,
0.5117907524,
-0.4599322975,
0.6648921967,
-0.1749964058,
0.5271036625,
0.0786600709,
0.1439316422,
-0.2795701027,
0.7353370786,
-0.1444716007,
-0.9910865426,
0.4899753332,
0.0933075994,
-0.2607955933,
-0.2686157823,
1.1214331388,
-0.2989473045,
-0.782009244,
0.8368347883,
0.3995544016,
-0.1659579873,
-0.2660682201,
-0.9127157927,
-0.0655984133,
-0.1191907674,
-0.3472337723,
0.2549724281,
0.8177790642,
0.3511274457,
0.6002752185,
0.2012374699,
-0.2532660067,
-0.5065249801,
0.3805382252,
0.9208019376,
-0.6790283918,
-0.2788116932,
-1.0650272369,
0.3270876408,
-0.4316154122,
-0.2491707653,
0.6869769096,
0.3209688663,
0.6596684456,
-0.0488713197,
0.6899027824,
0.1012936234,
0.8042663336,
-0.1943573207,
0.6774475574,
-0.8177820444,
-0.0332233943,
-0.3359185457,
-0.4171290994,
-0.5232710242,
0.6224750876,
-0.2972863615,
-0.1600350142,
0.7358811498,
0.4652313292,
0.0532634333,
0.0827330947,
-0.0910291299,
0.2660925388,
0.2374230176,
0.7233688235,
0.8214589953,
-0.0853029042,
0.4402641058,
-0.5858495235,
-0.1172081605,
-0.1361003369,
-0.4186599851,
-1.0778567791,
-0.4129641652,
-0.4600540102,
-0.2694824934,
0.1421942413,
0.6239506006,
0.2092185169,
-0.6044376493,
0.1283057481,
-0.3122565448,
0.3116650581,
-0.2202792913,
-0.2462596893,
0.2599338293,
-0.2691456079,
-0.2916612327,
0.1534883827,
0.1418561637,
-0.199193567,
-0.2248536199,
0.1527016163,
-0.4880161285,
-0.097131148,
0.6226558089,
-0.225706324,
-0.2370784581,
0.0757550895,
0.0414553769,
-0.3981150389,
-0.0983936042,
0.6091341376,
-0.6009377241,
-0.1540787369,
0.6155118346,
0.5926470757,
0.3347182274,
0.3103348017,
0.2969595492,
-0.6093629599,
-0.2764026821,
0.5239026546,
0.0342653543,
0.4326058626,
-0.6346784234,
0.5111265182,
0.3566856384,
-0.5492124557,
-0.876534462,
-0.0783477053,
-0.8203257918,
-0.9820287228,
0.9163758755,
-0.1845772415,
-0.313190639,
-0.0192543771,
-0.2079638839,
0.5394324064,
-0.4447489083,
1.3193975687,
0.4796190262,
0.2068505734,
-0.4858047068,
-0.3810457885,
0.5668395162,
0.164549917,
-0.6386324763,
0.0322765633,
0.3054482937,
-0.07858859,
0.1997926235,
0.7413161397,
0.3036013544,
0.2262604386,
-0.538669467,
-0.0565418378,
0.3478939831,
-0.3261402547,
-0.4329018891,
0.3346069753,
-0.5747883916,
0.036193274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05043v1
|
Zero-shot Translation of Attention Patterns in VQA Models to Natural Language
| 2023-11-08T22:18:53 | 2023-11-08T22:18:53 |
Leonard Salewski, A. Sophia Koepke, Hendrik P. A. Lensch, Zeynep Akata
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Converting a model's internals to text can yield human-understandable
insights about the model. Inspired by the recent success of training-free
approaches for image captioning, we propose ZS-A2T, a zero-shot framework that
translates the transformer attention of a given model into natural language
without requiring any training. We consider this in the context of Visual
Question Answering (VQA). ZS-A2T builds on a pre-trained large language model
(LLM), which receives a task prompt, question, and predicted answer, as inputs.
The LLM is guided to select tokens which describe the regions in the input
image that the VQA model attended to. Crucially, we determine this similarity
by exploiting the text-image matching capabilities of the underlying VQA model.
Our framework does not require any training and allows the drop-in replacement
of different guiding sources (e.g. attribution instead of attention maps), or
language models. We evaluate this novel task on textual explanation datasets
for VQA, giving state-of-the-art performances for the zero-shot setting on
GQA-REX and VQA-X. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/ExplainableML/ZS-A2T.
|
[
-0.2504947186,
-0.6072557569,
0.868570447,
-0.0584034063,
-0.6828795671,
-0.2557014525,
0.0132994251,
-0.3356970549,
-0.2030748725,
0.71386832,
-0.9788063765,
-0.5068815351,
-0.3656312525,
0.1857477874,
-0.6854713559,
0.920745194,
-0.2256537974,
0.1255547702,
-0.3784656227,
-0.0191191845,
-0.3465730846,
-0.1117985025,
-0.559468329,
0.0796374008,
0.517178297,
0.4848900437,
0.6303955913,
0.9938538074,
0.5115374923,
0.2238188684,
0.167601198,
-0.178242296,
-0.3427098989,
-0.0679580271,
-0.1343819052,
-0.651717186,
0.124676466,
-0.2161190957,
0.564475894,
0.4096114039,
0.2495838255,
0.4448393881,
-0.2361326963,
0.5763975382,
-0.5562553406,
0.3427476287,
-0.5820905566,
0.2229404151,
0.1154794171,
-0.2463383526,
-0.4351662099,
-0.1586697996,
0.1921441108,
-0.7247854471,
0.5854591727,
-0.0560464337,
1.1102074385,
0.6093919277,
-0.4648475647,
0.0370758884,
-0.8136828542,
0.7275226116,
-0.4201852381,
0.2347961813,
0.0345398039,
0.7203263044,
0.3448410034,
-0.7241291404,
-0.9569498897,
0.0084677814,
-0.1451059282,
0.387231648,
-0.4051903188,
0.1750191897,
0.1503925174,
0.4750482142,
-0.7925135493,
-0.3308798671,
-0.5138081908,
-0.1831517816,
0.3647016287,
0.117709443,
0.5318235755,
-0.290735513,
-0.6326634884,
0.1058955267,
-0.5951205492,
0.1634542495,
-0.2169270664,
0.22345227,
-0.1646004617,
0.8967119455,
-0.5737094283,
0.8768292069,
-0.0294643547,
0.4994556308,
-0.0157027375,
-0.5092022419,
-0.3273503482,
-0.13482593,
0.6402690411,
0.5332472324,
0.5281087756,
-0.4925270677,
0.0689912736,
0.2560300529,
0.4719779193,
-0.9069646001,
0.0838276967,
0.1732295156,
-0.2574654222,
-0.3112516403,
-0.0399666019,
-0.4452195466,
-0.0916170031,
-0.3400166631,
0.7071427107,
-0.2497936338,
0.1597672254,
0.2884766161,
-0.2641265094,
0.9276869893,
0.4870912135,
-0.4400353432,
0.1715801507,
0.2945200503,
0.9443969727,
-0.0016603637,
-0.078955248,
-0.8361306787,
0.2051789165,
-0.4328557551,
1.0167962313,
-0.1500660628,
0.1668801159,
0.0891549736,
0.1693893969,
-0.1300823092,
-0.105375573,
0.4419096708,
-0.6336814165,
0.4017761648,
-0.3547390699,
-0.2946733236,
-0.4139682353,
0.3432266414,
-0.4505172372,
0.679641366,
0.1471370757,
-0.4854106009,
0.0569453053,
-0.979857564,
-0.3075175881,
0.3256715834,
-0.2292068303,
-0.2319435924,
0.052065324,
0.4975318909,
0.2621046007,
-0.3439110816,
-0.1275788695,
-0.1100981086,
-0.5868483186,
0.2305085063,
-0.3264882565,
0.7358549833,
-0.0478900187,
-0.4258906543,
0.3198105693,
-0.5457862616,
0.1759885103,
0.435285002,
0.1282781214,
-0.0090015996,
-0.1962118894,
0.0240719095,
0.5794091821,
0.0499761589,
-0.7965533733,
0.0003174317,
-0.5089930296,
0.5740304589,
0.3545646667,
0.1999395639,
0.6835570931,
-0.1233477965,
0.8252453804,
-0.0379322991,
0.2078822404,
-0.6239128113,
-0.5336393118,
-0.884051621,
-0.2920437753,
0.1061608717,
0.8382388949,
-1.3275406361,
-0.0730796829,
-0.4280032516,
-0.3082810044,
-0.7940241098,
0.0448040105,
0.678206563,
0.7358443737,
0.6305385828,
-0.3532679081,
-0.1495784819,
-1.1936757565,
-0.1299501061,
-0.0904617533,
-0.3752748072,
0.2130032331,
0.3270842433,
0.0705066621,
0.9047293663,
-0.5968503356,
-0.375231564,
-0.3356084526,
0.0384555757,
-0.1809029877,
0.0803557113,
0.6484649777,
-0.75105232,
-0.5901789069,
-0.0070441091,
-0.7762826085,
-0.008946782,
-0.2807407677,
-0.4491236508,
0.0732125193,
0.644197464,
-0.8513566256,
0.7245392203,
0.1062404588,
-0.4040408134,
0.3131259978,
0.2215847224,
0.1151957139,
-0.9735551476,
0.1746297181,
0.2216401696,
-0.2923806906,
-0.8612009883,
0.3316897154,
0.3199246526,
-0.248675257,
-0.7395667434,
0.824180603,
-0.5028625727,
-0.2428169549,
-0.2069514841,
0.2358818352,
0.2628426254,
0.7840622663,
0.2780025005,
0.7711245418,
0.657281518,
-0.4306331873,
0.4062814713,
0.6965287924,
-0.1560664326,
0.5950596929,
-0.6885282993,
0.204810828,
-0.5280649066,
-0.0524892025,
-1.4446656704,
-0.2147554755,
0.6592307091,
-0.8125323653,
-0.0777436122,
-0.4884064496,
-0.3183427155,
-0.3924827576,
-0.3510960639,
0.2433532327,
0.3796741962,
-0.2961575389,
0.4957840741,
-0.3754561841,
-0.3623173535,
-0.5593172908,
-0.9853773713,
0.3195587993,
0.0782599002,
-0.5294215083,
0.2695094645,
-0.2606812716,
0.0453643277,
0.2823561728,
-0.1772138029,
-0.380961448,
-0.070456326,
0.1204352304,
0.3834522367,
-0.5503812432,
0.1258711517,
-0.0002284457,
-0.0907348022,
0.074829787,
-0.2126407027,
0.2357874662,
-0.0682428777,
-0.1820701361,
-0.7534634471,
0.4982418418,
0.7400373816,
-0.4879505038,
0.608069241,
0.5879502892,
-0.332554251,
-0.1179050654,
-0.148779884,
-0.1946012825,
-0.4199263752,
0.4819664359,
-0.236664027,
-0.6274604201,
0.4579153359,
0.4840509593,
0.012630092,
0.3510113358,
0.3632619679,
-0.1749400496,
0.9012969732,
0.789133966,
0.226789549,
0.6290149689,
-0.1658502668,
0.2459015101,
-0.559527874,
0.0238075163,
-0.2723837495,
-0.1806107461,
-0.0152260819,
-0.507710278,
0.1946934164,
-0.2637796998,
-0.2314502299,
0.2664678395,
-0.4456530809,
0.6592671275,
0.5752404928,
0.065277122,
0.2342502922,
0.1096370295,
0.3872671425,
-0.1072136089,
-0.6481713057,
-0.248676464,
0.9496108294,
0.0400063023,
0.2611514926,
0.0545665361,
0.450396806,
0.0328310244,
0.4097405672,
-1.3093111515,
0.5878144503,
-0.0899164677,
-0.5925860405,
-0.6546936035,
-0.2402860671,
-0.7149919868,
0.2537091076,
-0.1050076112,
-0.4424979091,
0.0226039086,
0.1052631065,
-0.6033626795,
0.0192457493,
-0.6902643442,
1.143283844,
-0.1107530072,
-0.3224804699,
0.2254306674,
-0.8026170135,
0.4556465149,
0.2409974486,
0.1010273397,
0.1524390131,
-0.1701750755,
0.2789171636,
-0.1450085193,
0.6865136623,
-0.2362583876,
-0.061767485,
0.3901124597,
0.1469590068,
0.1316930354,
-0.1224697977,
0.1686362624,
0.0915115029,
-0.0373894349,
-0.593159914,
-0.8828470707,
0.1655302942,
-0.5681923032,
-0.4454798996,
-0.2686742246,
-0.5483303666,
-0.1499796659,
0.2947582901,
0.3277681768,
0.5114045143,
-0.002085574,
0.23797068,
0.627808392,
-0.186238423,
0.4173092842,
0.6581048965,
-0.0485044718,
-0.3019052446,
0.7467309237,
0.034115985,
0.3684084117,
0.5008179545,
-0.2124654055,
-0.3473368883,
-0.5879618526,
-1.1439111233,
0.2983772159,
-0.7724487782,
-0.4860681891,
-0.5983220339,
-0.448361665,
-0.2970888913,
-0.2380526662,
-0.2530004978,
-0.4402987063,
-0.2614500523,
-0.164851442,
0.2909875214,
0.4961104691,
0.335537374,
0.5277320743,
-0.8729507923,
0.8538776636,
0.5658372045,
0.3610517085,
-0.1399799883,
-0.8523890376,
-0.3213800788,
0.0275419746,
-0.1372625381,
-1.0578144789,
0.4315404892,
0.4018998146,
0.4040389657,
0.3090381324,
0.2083754689,
0.593485117,
-0.6081922054,
0.9045608044,
0.0519735515,
-1.0027046204,
0.5842889547,
-0.4861495793,
0.7144270539,
0.5176410675,
0.2479656935,
-0.7968066335,
-0.5154365301,
-0.2474472225,
-0.8936160207,
0.9096238017,
0.4163925946,
0.3958675861,
0.0979586616,
0.7077665925,
-0.1514564306,
0.2612052262,
-0.9623201489,
-0.236873731,
-0.3972955644,
-0.4851544797,
-0.0634671375,
-0.1454667449,
-0.1172362715,
-0.1518886685,
0.524913311,
-0.4454228878,
0.5505453944,
0.4091501236,
-0.5024091601,
-0.3569833934,
0.1993382275,
0.5774744749,
0.273391664,
-0.0317185186,
-0.0618297346,
-0.2365156859,
-0.3159493804,
-0.0387422852,
0.1554238945,
-0.5963445902,
0.1788354814,
0.3306109607,
0.8229891658,
0.1858436167,
-0.6672862172,
0.8261618614,
-0.2449085116,
-0.5388966203,
-0.1930976361,
-0.0800157338,
-0.0296765659,
0.2440394759,
0.5707015395,
-0.0693660676,
0.3940448165,
-0.5767793059,
0.1838255674,
0.4225127399,
-0.8154343367,
-0.287214309,
0.7025271058,
0.1299494058,
-0.2180136591,
0.3770426214,
-0.2046441585,
-0.4487695396,
0.8461740017,
0.2427101135,
1.0130181313,
-0.0612854622,
0.7271387577,
0.447784543,
0.5773327351,
0.1570150554,
0.4483581781,
-0.2827285826,
-0.6831471324,
-0.6447652578,
-0.3543748558,
-0.5271524787,
0.2507691383,
-0.9270986915,
0.2203842551,
-0.3309038579,
0.3499945998,
0.2884328067,
-0.4018523991,
-0.7306172848,
0.3798751235,
0.4367994368,
0.6744505167,
-0.93209517,
0.5221998096,
0.8398054242,
-0.7073122263,
-0.4441271722,
0.2838841379,
-0.0911880732,
-0.8069531322,
0.3171717227,
0.3404037654,
-0.1750571728,
0.3170015514,
-0.9275625348,
-0.8535123467,
1.0966579914,
0.6335445642,
-0.238550052,
-0.0866300687,
0.1432478726,
0.5823792219,
-0.2509064674,
0.0102197193,
0.255346179,
0.2468532026,
0.295825094,
-0.6517828107,
0.0463666096,
-0.3844632506,
-0.1284974813,
0.0051229787,
-0.4830557704,
0.5248236656,
-0.4774644971,
-0.5385997295,
0.2945703566,
0.5915859342,
-0.2358758897,
0.3456837535,
0.3067275286,
0.1863845885,
0.1166161448,
-0.0037978657,
1.0261151791,
-0.1552727073,
0.173125416,
1.1595942974,
-0.1173051372,
0.8938727975,
0.6031197309,
0.046978578,
0.4789934158,
0.4013499916,
-0.0049564834,
0.7005539536,
0.0368741639,
-0.203094691,
-0.5808734298,
0.0124917952,
-0.0654249638,
0.5206855536,
0.0114994403,
-0.3334306479,
-0.4862137437,
0.0635034218,
-0.3900756836,
0.2523043752,
-0.4745045006,
1.0087581873,
0.0253437478,
-0.4565045536,
0.5929208398,
-0.0717133507,
0.3266289532,
-0.5364046693,
-0.1110795066,
-0.2105943859,
-0.1237268448,
0.0787943751,
-0.9274009466,
0.3920103312,
0.2600761652,
-0.3523678184,
-0.22179842,
0.4929076731,
-0.6347667575,
-0.6396710873,
0.0996661335,
0.6800388694,
0.078854546,
-0.4051293433,
-0.5138596296,
-0.4511504471,
0.0595850796,
-0.1846017838,
-0.0017088131,
0.6255750656,
-0.0995603129,
0.6995813847,
0.4589928687,
-0.3421670496,
0.1332795322,
-0.0544831008,
0.6928444505,
-0.7069575191,
-0.5981687903,
-0.7197548747,
0.8130288124,
0.0064635426,
-0.1203830615,
0.5466173887,
0.4264666736,
0.6290773153,
-0.4841006696,
0.9744649529,
0.2945709229,
0.4159926474,
-0.4459235072,
0.7594915032,
-0.6875013709,
-0.3121302724,
-0.0785408542,
-0.8417146206,
-0.6192435026,
0.5179715157,
-0.3200494051,
-0.4236420393,
0.5920804739,
0.6739582419,
-0.0092925439,
-0.2747564018,
0.5185621381,
0.0457088426,
0.006592392,
0.5360364914,
0.6479523182,
-0.6607141495,
1.0946662426,
-0.1574539691,
-0.0578422025,
-0.0926050842,
-0.6510532498,
-0.7931576371,
-0.540861547,
-0.5279492736,
-0.044034481,
0.0968906656,
0.5294092298,
0.4485246837,
-0.6434760094,
0.2102924287,
-0.0813011751,
-0.046141956,
-0.1802530438,
-0.2258785963,
0.2626731098,
-0.2571273148,
-0.616972208,
0.2084608823,
0.4743596613,
0.1821968257,
-0.0524829067,
0.1251194179,
-0.0244401433,
0.5061820745,
0.7884339094,
0.4272690713,
-0.8072977066,
-0.4581181109,
0.4044635296,
-0.1187045947,
0.2223009765,
0.4837768972,
-0.6669008136,
0.5178611875,
0.2576276362,
0.8151737452,
0.631096065,
0.0733804256,
0.5672810078,
-0.7747761607,
0.1856195331,
0.1043815985,
0.0330156013,
0.4762715697,
-0.455640018,
0.3662070036,
0.1384144127,
-0.0000748571,
-0.7990029454,
0.4207508266,
-1.2236878872,
-0.137326628,
1.1728568077,
-0.1184381843,
-0.421748817,
-0.1929934323,
-0.451393187,
0.3351067007,
-0.1518061161,
0.7214615941,
0.6627216339,
0.1065043882,
-0.710277915,
-0.7457294464,
0.430678457,
0.380069524,
-0.8228490949,
0.2047908008,
0.5778414011,
0.3493090868,
-0.0177281145,
0.6701028943,
-0.1061848775,
0.8226261139,
-0.2657056451,
0.5051742792,
-0.1930376738,
-0.1900681555,
-0.6366797686,
0.0242571011,
-0.1104867607,
-0.5797697306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07588v1
|
NLQxform: A Language Model-based Question to SPARQL Transformer
| 2023-11-08T21:41:45 | 2023-11-08T21:41:45 |
Ruijie Wang, Zhiruo Zhang, Luca Rossetto, Florian Ruosch, Abraham Bernstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, scholarly data has grown dramatically in terms of both scale
and complexity. It becomes increasingly challenging to retrieve information
from scholarly knowledge graphs that include large-scale heterogeneous
relationships, such as authorship, affiliation, and citation, between various
types of entities, e.g., scholars, papers, and organizations. As part of the
Scholarly QALD Challenge, this paper presents a question-answering (QA) system
called NLQxform, which provides an easy-to-use natural language interface to
facilitate accessing scholarly knowledge graphs. NLQxform allows users to
express their complex query intentions in natural language questions. A
transformer-based language model, i.e., BART, is employed to translate
questions into standard SPARQL queries, which can be evaluated to retrieve the
required information. According to the public leaderboard of the Scholarly QALD
Challenge at ISWC 2023 (Task 1: DBLP-QUAD - Knowledge Graph Question Answering
over DBLP), NLQxform achieved an F1 score of 0.85 and ranked first on the QA
task, demonstrating the competitiveness of the system.
|
[
-0.308429867,
-0.7574669719,
0.604349494,
0.1857975274,
0.1051809043,
0.2281678915,
0.3004835248,
-0.4376227856,
0.2298892289,
0.8158894777,
-0.7404945493,
-0.4141371846,
-0.4956089854,
0.2883324623,
-0.4697330892,
1.1358631849,
-0.0507857874,
0.0056130206,
-0.4584368169,
-0.101846233,
-0.2489285916,
-0.4318515956,
-0.7644767761,
-0.1724431962,
0.6556230187,
0.0677532032,
1.0049602985,
0.192858845,
0.5844559669,
0.2464086115,
-0.1332035959,
0.1830773056,
-0.5209972858,
0.5236652493,
-0.1990927011,
-0.7816781402,
-0.4818385243,
-0.0997780338,
0.8009921908,
1.0613088608,
-0.0719478875,
0.5297322869,
-0.274484992,
0.7624913454,
-0.2275123149,
0.3191412985,
-0.4982651472,
0.1976240128,
-0.270260781,
-0.1048767418,
-0.490015924,
-0.7287238836,
-0.1153060123,
-0.8351394534,
0.1314145625,
0.754211545,
0.9479073882,
0.1632213742,
-0.4355475605,
-0.2339619398,
-0.6631127,
0.4281564355,
-0.4770796001,
0.4891093969,
0.347397089,
0.7344579101,
-0.1357660741,
-1.0611763,
-0.6674469113,
-0.0085503394,
-0.3825137913,
0.0160421934,
-0.7554466128,
-0.1233221591,
0.3270187974,
0.1951150745,
-1.0012140274,
-0.3318048418,
-0.3017447889,
-0.0436200462,
0.49223423,
0.440789938,
0.4727324843,
-0.4012595415,
-0.122173354,
-0.0852421969,
-0.4739845395,
0.1928649098,
0.1523305327,
0.2934405804,
0.3326093853,
0.5956282616,
-0.1972326636,
0.6585198045,
0.1108712479,
0.256849736,
-0.0169533677,
-0.0239466261,
0.0450785644,
-0.1037261784,
0.8638297319,
0.1384222209,
-0.1867535114,
-0.6220045686,
-0.177852422,
-0.3175999224,
0.1787568331,
-0.6941922903,
-0.1501453072,
0.3849068582,
-0.4444289804,
0.0077276407,
0.1320677102,
-0.6472443342,
-0.2010744363,
-0.2386668772,
0.6069934964,
-0.2970569134,
-0.3297377229,
0.1026400477,
-0.32886976,
0.3279801905,
0.5402985811,
-0.4249601066,
0.6146814823,
0.6335964799,
0.6975437403,
-0.1328353286,
0.0671732426,
-0.7040650845,
0.0716647208,
-0.1941437274,
0.7784421444,
-0.5099285841,
-0.4041298628,
-0.2290787995,
0.2824882567,
-0.1802807152,
-0.4246076345,
0.7014277577,
-1.2943259478,
0.8366700411,
-0.3877290189,
-0.7250277996,
-0.1951929331,
0.4065496325,
-0.9645430446,
1.3090933561,
0.6426950693,
-0.9266068935,
-0.073906064,
-0.8925500512,
0.0873721093,
0.5216565132,
0.0031330406,
-0.2618816793,
-0.3704471588,
0.0335358493,
0.2369173914,
-0.6414289474,
0.5099287629,
-0.1653734893,
-0.1743520796,
0.314281106,
-0.3115562797,
1.0075228214,
0.0833778381,
-0.3471415341,
-0.0253457744,
-0.9177330732,
0.2938878238,
0.2396088541,
-0.0589705743,
-0.5853547454,
-0.2252658755,
0.1079495698,
0.2123825699,
0.1531039327,
-0.6418308616,
0.5359840989,
-0.2460511327,
0.1747985929,
0.3473985195,
0.1641268581,
0.5497112274,
-0.2303367853,
0.9649804235,
-0.4601123929,
0.2908892035,
0.2397260964,
-0.632999897,
-0.5411565304,
0.1511805058,
0.5652803779,
0.5395877957,
-0.9521095157,
0.2202404439,
-0.4308986664,
-0.7625392079,
-0.5711876154,
-0.3328018188,
0.229180187,
0.7386322021,
0.6516170502,
0.1479107738,
-0.3580758274,
-0.7245735526,
-0.0827784017,
-0.2487051934,
-0.1051805839,
0.2603982985,
0.4711990058,
-0.1928962469,
1.2867714167,
-0.8694786429,
-0.0353204124,
-0.2243842185,
0.2480579764,
0.3358452618,
0.2030382305,
0.497905612,
-1.015823245,
-0.5192774534,
-0.0572631434,
-0.7722809911,
-0.3253232837,
0.0964768156,
-0.4799485803,
-0.0377032124,
0.5252206922,
-0.7309176922,
0.1254311204,
0.5327655077,
-0.7377429605,
0.8001511097,
0.1807221621,
0.2615210712,
-0.7686777115,
0.5076392889,
-0.3760903776,
-0.2728745639,
-0.6230651736,
0.075368531,
0.0898706615,
-0.3369345069,
-0.1540374309,
0.7351675034,
-0.2672407031,
0.0998649374,
0.1367504597,
0.1403836012,
0.4480023086,
0.1962284148,
-0.0442610793,
0.7670794129,
0.2625529468,
-0.308788538,
0.2189573795,
0.5716413856,
0.0118202483,
0.4954687059,
-0.956997335,
0.1533522606,
-0.420822978,
0.2161722928,
-0.9478754997,
-0.0153910993,
0.20581007,
-0.4493713379,
0.0733948573,
-0.2224291265,
-0.3483702242,
-0.3662946522,
0.0421062298,
0.2184630632,
0.1763260365,
-0.3851352036,
0.9002546668,
0.1828549206,
-0.4457221925,
-0.6682236195,
-0.2176261246,
0.2278645486,
-0.0507872701,
-0.8956854939,
0.5754219294,
-0.0812691972,
-0.3207937181,
0.3435539007,
0.1385949999,
-0.1449490637,
-0.0089084869,
0.296793133,
0.5201547146,
-0.415271312,
0.1392963976,
0.3007459044,
-0.0813956186,
0.3563167453,
-0.153806448,
0.4914193153,
-0.2246301472,
-0.3969059289,
-0.0645571798,
0.6205452681,
0.6189062595,
-0.3849295676,
0.7891872525,
0.4882000089,
-0.1563553065,
-0.1769932956,
-0.3979574144,
-0.2024944723,
-0.4361463189,
0.2359305024,
-0.2603833973,
-1.30296278,
0.4802863002,
-0.1042592227,
0.0640084073,
0.5658568144,
0.1939343512,
-0.1648946702,
1.0787875652,
0.4440008998,
0.2136084884,
-0.0386507325,
-0.2482054979,
0.3060274422,
-0.6295234561,
-0.4910658598,
-0.8693420887,
-0.0066525075,
-0.2947350442,
-0.4079909623,
0.7578541636,
0.1329531223,
-0.4682193398,
0.3349722922,
-0.4886131585,
0.2137367874,
0.6067309976,
-0.2873820961,
0.5694838166,
-0.2695843577,
0.1480120122,
-0.1740321815,
-0.7897794843,
-0.6184772253,
0.6196132302,
0.2806675732,
0.7102786899,
0.4462394118,
0.449942112,
0.4434689581,
0.3063724339,
-0.574331522,
0.4548531771,
0.1414650828,
-0.789295733,
-0.6000227332,
-0.5650004148,
-1.0766217709,
0.298055321,
-0.5199716687,
-0.4180083871,
0.296078831,
0.0186918657,
-0.1608801931,
0.2086130232,
-0.323246181,
0.9725621939,
-0.1984253824,
-0.2166395187,
0.4693082571,
-0.8420526981,
0.2572277784,
0.1055782288,
0.3775284886,
-0.0028265154,
0.2985824049,
0.8666620255,
-0.3358924985,
0.4926401377,
-0.3127681017,
0.056066189,
0.152000919,
0.3788425624,
0.4973207116,
0.1853620112,
-0.2866284549,
-0.0676353127,
0.527649343,
-0.2690496743,
-0.9938908815,
0.0998554826,
-0.809091568,
-0.4920002222,
-0.4480524361,
-0.451235503,
-0.3437789381,
0.4155324996,
0.0290538017,
0.4563456178,
-0.3426565528,
0.1172691286,
0.7550054193,
-0.2178772092,
0.0550325587,
0.7375462055,
-0.7029153705,
-0.1663742363,
0.728951633,
0.096446991,
0.2170811146,
0.7928044796,
0.1319108307,
-0.5895007253,
-0.3282236755,
-0.6316127181,
0.3677425981,
-0.6003082991,
-0.4938522279,
-1.0290881395,
-0.230910629,
-0.4618873298,
0.1205663085,
-0.2067465484,
-0.8084463477,
-0.0912388414,
0.1511441916,
0.4002845883,
0.6742237806,
0.3682807684,
0.0635855719,
-1.0075647831,
0.1800275147,
0.443348825,
0.2586891949,
-0.1980158538,
-0.4373677969,
-0.0130531006,
-0.2921973467,
-0.1285456419,
-0.9318786263,
0.4913237691,
0.1543514878,
0.6283354163,
0.0489937253,
0.4065922499,
0.2939726412,
-0.6011973619,
0.8213877678,
0.0147288535,
-0.7987840772,
0.4393312037,
-0.3665960729,
0.0895416811,
0.5436246991,
0.9060382843,
-0.8873220086,
-0.4410758615,
-0.5821746588,
-0.8654786944,
0.4657178521,
0.1172761843,
0.0750746951,
0.0198547672,
0.4671477079,
0.1635993123,
0.1115569174,
-0.8919107318,
-0.5172056556,
-0.4475788176,
-0.011386767,
0.4345607162,
-0.0756742135,
-0.166980505,
-0.1448390484,
0.6592296362,
-0.2190373242,
0.3179983199,
0.1781292111,
-0.0471530445,
0.0231619626,
0.5783783197,
0.1832083464,
0.4267400801,
-0.3228078187,
0.1043640822,
-0.1714049578,
-0.4335839152,
0.0749782696,
0.4071115255,
-0.5123647451,
0.1666335315,
0.3342269063,
0.8177809715,
-0.0387485512,
-0.6798072457,
0.55601722,
-0.4176928401,
-0.3865497708,
-0.2941432297,
0.0990112945,
0.2384402901,
0.1569471061,
0.7476483583,
-0.1019093022,
0.414174825,
-0.1999712586,
0.0487838872,
0.3602831662,
-0.5741862059,
-0.0524562337,
0.8794829249,
-0.2068431079,
-0.2186316699,
0.6256217957,
-0.5174899697,
-0.687484324,
0.3196721375,
0.7745371461,
0.1771466434,
0.0157168284,
0.5721870065,
0.3631049097,
0.1861546636,
0.0346638486,
0.2861498296,
0.2400110662,
-0.6157565713,
-0.4459087551,
-0.7374123931,
-0.6924533844,
-0.1367147416,
-0.8325969577,
0.0520599,
-0.1596584171,
-0.2232891023,
0.1752630472,
-0.0891219452,
-0.3620146811,
0.1808765084,
-0.3199983835,
0.9955124855,
-0.7556900978,
0.5126612782,
0.8122776747,
-0.5371102095,
-1.0875943899,
-0.47935763,
-0.2529529035,
-0.5245694518,
1.0769376755,
-0.3510787785,
-0.1980658919,
0.1800225228,
-0.5833571553,
-1.0893627405,
1.1350095272,
0.3485779464,
-0.2999367714,
-0.5240014195,
0.2435572147,
0.4554564953,
0.0344952755,
0.4399059713,
0.3205569088,
0.6250110865,
0.0029492585,
-0.6579115987,
0.2319968343,
-0.6584869027,
-0.1808486879,
0.4320434928,
-0.3859403431,
0.8594259024,
0.1845834553,
-0.2053940594,
-0.1828451604,
0.8580883145,
0.1745558679,
0.2576019466,
0.5135137439,
0.2670279741,
1.0118972063,
-0.1455958784,
0.9462635517,
-0.2684003413,
0.4322632253,
0.9372258186,
-0.2639678717,
0.7300624847,
0.3704555929,
-0.6484517455,
0.8352141976,
0.204593733,
0.0086767562,
0.1500410587,
0.1373447925,
-0.2446148545,
-0.2197694182,
-0.0600818656,
-0.59355551,
0.5025291443,
0.3104450703,
-0.0762280375,
-0.3328573704,
-0.0128718605,
0.1977933645,
0.3667564094,
-0.2185203135,
0.4774901569,
-0.1824118197,
-0.6945578456,
0.3756580949,
0.1110743135,
0.4743633568,
-0.7202651501,
-0.200880304,
-0.2400834709,
-0.4370589554,
-0.3552932143,
-0.858196497,
0.4632214904,
-0.1531345099,
-0.5704105496,
-0.1490138322,
0.6386498213,
-0.3791214824,
-0.5749094486,
0.0173391011,
0.8378551602,
-0.0628872216,
-0.2367121428,
-0.8096730709,
-0.1123998463,
-0.1782446653,
-0.084962368,
0.2484966218,
0.5161746144,
-0.3070132434,
0.7590747476,
0.5830439329,
-0.0726462305,
0.0832105651,
0.172634691,
0.8615754247,
-0.4335875511,
-0.3430318832,
-0.1693897396,
0.2964921296,
-0.2784176469,
-0.1635958105,
0.7485146523,
0.5803511143,
0.3439878523,
-0.0292082988,
0.7181100845,
-0.3504786491,
1.0598313808,
-0.3990229964,
0.9543653727,
-0.529191792,
0.087427102,
-0.4147823751,
-0.6790252924,
-0.4902820885,
0.4385171235,
-0.3743549585,
-0.1651982963,
0.6383373737,
0.872836113,
0.1815248281,
0.2876730263,
0.1947494298,
-0.021204805,
0.4109960198,
0.2413832992,
0.8523797989,
-0.5179591775,
0.6342335343,
-0.0834816322,
-0.169786483,
0.016919883,
-0.7857060432,
-0.5654029846,
-0.7842907906,
-0.2628712654,
-0.5465853214,
-0.0667386577,
0.9408099651,
0.3141663373,
-0.7965092063,
-0.0793367773,
0.1178160086,
0.129880175,
-0.1611027122,
-0.3875485659,
0.7007613778,
-0.2815930247,
-0.5980433226,
0.1984127462,
0.2354498655,
-0.2253379673,
-0.2172893584,
0.1402529478,
-0.0699022338,
-0.2247637063,
0.7687680721,
0.3525950909,
-0.293051213,
-0.121587716,
0.7325336337,
-0.2310082614,
-0.037114922,
0.6647281051,
-0.7118843794,
0.1959110051,
0.3330266774,
0.7181056142,
0.5564779639,
0.0517556965,
0.4874282181,
-0.461352855,
-0.4511578679,
0.5789273977,
0.1646201611,
0.2251104414,
-0.5103638768,
0.4577916265,
0.1488236785,
-0.7481750846,
-0.7191562653,
0.0333310068,
-1.2752120495,
-0.3373843729,
0.9208422899,
-0.0125875724,
-0.2509719133,
-0.6471219063,
-0.4985121489,
0.0458118692,
-0.269869417,
0.6060038209,
0.2183241397,
-0.3155566454,
-0.4079348445,
-0.6001101732,
0.4934124649,
0.2503403723,
-0.8943262696,
-0.0339349881,
0.4191696346,
0.2716430128,
0.2623693347,
0.7855424285,
-0.4065570831,
0.243661955,
-0.2266687155,
0.2130122781,
-0.0381307267,
0.1258256435,
0.2385556698,
0.8526868224,
0.2901028395,
0.5750539303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05020v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05020v2
|
First Tragedy, then Parse: History Repeats Itself in the New Era of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-08T21:13:38 | 2024-03-26T02:23:27 |
Naomi Saphra, Eve Fleisig, Kyunghyun Cho, Adam Lopez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many NLP researchers are experiencing an existential crisis triggered by the
astonishing success of ChatGPT and other systems based on large language models
(LLMs). After such a disruptive change to our understanding of the field, what
is left to do? Taking a historical lens, we look for guidance from the first
era of LLMs, which began in 2005 with large $n$-gram models for machine
translation (MT). We identify durable lessons from the first era, and more
importantly, we identify evergreen problems where NLP researchers can continue
to make meaningful contributions in areas where LLMs are ascendant. We argue
that disparities in scale are transient and researchers can work to reduce
them; that data, rather than hardware, is still a bottleneck for many
applications; that meaningful realistic evaluation is still an open problem;
and that there is still room for speculative approaches.
|
[
-0.2621121705,
-0.6445558667,
0.816691339,
0.1721022129,
-0.0032507402,
0.3003436029,
0.016917957,
-0.3264964223,
0.1575600356,
0.5385397077,
-0.5725349784,
-0.036299292,
-1.0380040407,
0.1232403517,
-0.6902223229,
0.9160981774,
0.2400418967,
-0.2752655149,
-0.1436830908,
-0.2241106331,
-0.5177718997,
-0.6924870014,
-1.1546416283,
-0.4452622831,
0.6900355816,
0.1621848196,
0.8319888711,
0.6009971499,
0.6734901071,
0.2996655107,
-0.4418412745,
-0.0133142509,
-0.666991055,
0.2414744049,
-0.0141597558,
-0.6052695513,
-0.3171488345,
-0.0492487475,
0.6883759499,
1.1665884256,
-0.1253418922,
0.0156610366,
0.1965208203,
0.9739361405,
-0.2015257478,
-0.0549925901,
-0.7498034239,
0.1982460916,
-0.2353233695,
-0.5605763197,
-0.5527962446,
-0.2537685037,
0.0593404621,
-0.3879237473,
0.0192455836,
0.2933238447,
0.6870940924,
0.2313314974,
-0.3856747746,
-0.2098692954,
-0.8923610449,
1.0759313107,
-0.733269155,
0.0744836256,
0.1813568771,
0.2524591088,
-0.6454486251,
-1.0286061764,
-0.251408875,
-0.1082514077,
0.3411866128,
-0.2820346653,
-0.7149944901,
-0.4785028994,
0.2262476683,
0.5541777015,
-0.5440070033,
0.2812051773,
-0.3717056811,
-0.0898498818,
0.247137785,
0.3878519535,
0.4630179107,
-0.0722150505,
-0.5149180293,
0.227176249,
-1.0498353243,
-0.3500916362,
-0.0459310636,
0.2067300975,
0.2942602336,
0.416131109,
0.1762734205,
0.437764734,
-0.2526855469,
-0.0999316424,
-0.0859460086,
0.0733993575,
-0.2481505871,
-0.1196019575,
0.7538634539,
0.3853917718,
0.2229255289,
-0.2535526156,
-0.0208180007,
-0.0910137594,
0.356136471,
-0.4606446326,
-0.0704575628,
-0.0866696164,
-0.4632419348,
-0.1006626636,
-0.5529505014,
-0.8165789247,
-0.766397655,
-0.4008562565,
0.2097580284,
-0.4877958894,
-0.3466623724,
0.2216725796,
0.0680363029,
0.3981146216,
0.3868589103,
-0.7342146039,
0.4091301858,
1.1018593311,
1.2459945679,
0.2074519545,
-0.2612790763,
-0.1647315323,
-0.2170795053,
-0.4801239073,
0.5772410035,
-0.2357144505,
-0.5526446104,
0.0563634187,
0.0207780525,
0.2157942057,
-0.4866060317,
0.6832816005,
-0.5333738327,
0.2351393253,
-0.4232816398,
-0.5981779695,
0.0512078777,
0.407708317,
-0.3798100054,
0.8171787262,
0.1183362678,
-0.8302631974,
0.3134824336,
-0.3886032104,
-0.1753521115,
0.2093605995,
-0.1693257093,
-0.1659922004,
0.5467631221,
-0.0028772666,
0.1596302688,
-0.6260972619,
0.3288347721,
-0.3543421924,
-0.1340547353,
0.0340918042,
-0.6518051028,
1.0164307356,
0.1106177121,
0.0045804041,
-0.3237477839,
-0.7377038598,
-0.159191817,
0.5066615939,
-0.1458304971,
-0.3461926281,
0.4196893871,
-0.053898856,
0.1913341135,
0.0673796907,
-0.4097232223,
0.2740826607,
-0.3901613951,
0.8369275331,
0.9198921323,
-0.1302260756,
0.1272207648,
-0.4198276103,
0.6765383482,
-0.2949587703,
0.0666447431,
-0.4174948931,
-0.537902236,
-0.9359795451,
0.2478305995,
0.1787717491,
0.3432730734,
-0.5056265593,
0.2660920918,
-0.5167971253,
-0.354256928,
-0.2412421852,
-0.169939056,
-0.2204781175,
0.413328886,
0.3312039673,
-0.2087031007,
-0.7554832101,
-0.976385355,
-0.5521653295,
-0.3502923846,
-0.2228982002,
0.0106743081,
0.310716778,
-0.0618520342,
0.9791195393,
-0.3819466531,
-0.2169499248,
-0.2547825873,
0.1664055884,
0.236890763,
0.4218536317,
0.5052210093,
-0.4833218455,
-0.1803749055,
0.0251946561,
-0.7069009542,
-0.204094246,
-0.2018001676,
0.1712910831,
-0.0293940343,
0.8162806034,
-0.46274966,
-0.0832122937,
0.5560948253,
-0.266869396,
0.4430396557,
-0.1799290329,
0.0728749633,
-1.0211745501,
0.1381392032,
-0.1046589985,
-0.3294712305,
-0.5449156761,
-0.1941851526,
-0.2977100313,
-0.1404399425,
-0.1491483897,
0.4878071547,
-0.3094570637,
0.0228008479,
-0.3541242778,
0.3259902894,
-0.0739757046,
-0.1504989713,
-0.3421306908,
0.5964775085,
0.35656178,
-0.2823454142,
-0.0401973426,
0.1991716772,
-0.390309006,
0.4157141745,
-0.531398356,
0.0610582456,
-0.29527843,
0.1226787269,
-0.870344162,
-0.0038240699,
-0.0082319239,
-0.4504951835,
0.4481233656,
-0.3519900143,
-0.5822802186,
-0.5161674023,
-0.0747460052,
0.3501961827,
0.7826717496,
-0.461789608,
0.3232598305,
0.4109834433,
-0.6949849129,
-0.5316684246,
-0.6745352149,
0.8341355324,
-0.4522006214,
-0.7251160741,
-0.0219511706,
0.0195194781,
-0.5434391499,
-0.2697750628,
-0.0999672636,
-0.0585289225,
0.3500603139,
0.0117140701,
0.1245647445,
-0.4168636799,
0.1135617942,
-0.1835974306,
-0.3890203834,
0.1755150706,
-0.2993073463,
0.8808602095,
-0.2960932851,
-0.2475753427,
-0.074111402,
0.3888582885,
0.5749877691,
-0.0789655,
0.8197889328,
-0.0453274511,
-0.3723010421,
0.0339780897,
-0.5446360111,
0.2574948668,
-0.4338060319,
0.4389191568,
0.0184556618,
-1.0603346825,
0.3645838499,
-0.4274736643,
0.236134842,
0.6738064885,
0.4030181766,
0.0117557542,
0.6242156029,
0.7717369795,
-0.2496279925,
0.3634844422,
0.0308320168,
0.627142787,
-0.7836858034,
0.0192761868,
-0.38561064,
-0.284072578,
-0.4514766634,
-0.3091615438,
0.6432270408,
0.3394929469,
-0.1328361183,
0.0358416699,
-0.0659110844,
0.5702340007,
0.2383940816,
-0.0939124823,
0.4899778068,
-0.1607581228,
0.5318548083,
-0.3482724428,
-0.7593016624,
-0.882874012,
1.0016157627,
0.6482209563,
0.4716660082,
0.0815796703,
0.5410562158,
0.3954517543,
0.3351770639,
-0.692155838,
0.4983514249,
-0.1799957454,
-0.3930327892,
-0.1666299999,
-0.3869604468,
-1.1931190491,
0.4928693175,
0.1126421988,
-0.7345897555,
0.0790622458,
0.1065807119,
-0.3200648129,
0.5000853539,
-0.243515268,
0.8372961283,
-0.107333377,
-0.1747314185,
0.1074874625,
-0.7460036278,
0.6070743203,
-0.0834976286,
0.6655635238,
-0.2196073234,
0.119449541,
0.5390137434,
-0.2536748946,
0.6973861456,
0.1607183516,
-0.2845486701,
0.226027593,
0.5098984838,
0.2864837646,
-0.1409962475,
0.1450056583,
0.1229368448,
0.1810447276,
-0.4647899866,
-0.2998584807,
0.7341629267,
-0.2046626657,
-0.6343023181,
-0.4654079378,
-0.4490941167,
-0.0806644484,
0.1472763419,
0.2385449409,
0.3862468898,
-0.4987351298,
0.3178168833,
0.7153108716,
-0.3286874294,
0.7287985682,
0.3748297691,
-0.5973174572,
-0.2220659554,
0.7681625485,
0.0436748341,
0.4354973733,
0.0841706246,
0.1933416426,
0.0908299536,
-0.6724381447,
-0.3434270322,
0.0894204602,
-0.7315373421,
-0.1263754815,
-0.7841334343,
-0.0247012284,
-0.2461738437,
-0.2304621488,
-0.7097010016,
-0.2738346159,
-0.4270766675,
0.1821598411,
0.11827676,
0.7195012569,
-0.3184766173,
0.3621862233,
-0.8666293025,
-0.0405239612,
-0.0975896567,
0.1141595393,
0.089927882,
-0.7833406329,
-0.1787865013,
-0.171592176,
-0.3792449832,
-0.6723803878,
0.5633738041,
0.1860985905,
-0.0011187887,
0.2746117115,
-0.1584330946,
0.395603925,
-1.1247835159,
0.939950943,
0.283307761,
-0.8316358924,
0.2421262115,
-0.2769003212,
0.3034999669,
0.2902033031,
0.505249083,
-1.2320135832,
-0.3106690347,
-0.5795047283,
-1.1870638132,
0.3902924955,
-0.0067236493,
0.3949795365,
-0.2068050206,
0.3461113572,
0.3243554533,
-0.0043666712,
-0.8681327701,
-0.2824873924,
0.2170918733,
0.0967584178,
-0.2559393942,
-0.3412505388,
0.0120441122,
-0.0683558807,
0.4290970862,
-0.0026431922,
-0.0475762971,
0.0634000227,
-0.0269077625,
-0.1502727419,
0.5567497015,
0.336435318,
0.9572452307,
0.0822929814,
0.2531972826,
0.0036271228,
-0.0204827022,
0.1928338408,
-0.0807484686,
-0.1807375401,
-0.03045238,
0.7591484785,
0.6748928428,
0.3748096526,
-0.6070340872,
0.5035481453,
0.1593608111,
-0.024816731,
-0.5969979763,
-0.3119979799,
0.1011149734,
0.3179899156,
0.4976243377,
-0.1322010159,
0.0235975347,
-0.927832067,
0.12319576,
0.4020345509,
-0.0336070098,
-0.2062584758,
0.5511968136,
-0.2656526566,
-0.4629741311,
0.3528296947,
0.0141196195,
-0.6738948822,
0.3430618942,
0.64313519,
0.8123457432,
-0.202246964,
0.1868542582,
0.1334432811,
0.595084548,
-0.4725566208,
-0.0229076352,
0.4332539141,
-0.4655379057,
-0.5770819187,
-0.8985643387,
-0.2488440871,
0.3479891419,
-0.5851026177,
0.2136097103,
-0.5396145582,
-0.0652047396,
0.088579908,
-0.2897261679,
-0.5177756548,
0.0420883186,
0.2383100837,
0.7921151519,
-0.8478024006,
0.3893273473,
0.118932046,
-0.364233613,
0.0619110167,
0.0093353456,
0.1986549348,
-0.8573488593,
0.675632596,
0.0949009061,
0.130154863,
0.158007741,
-0.6810989976,
-1.0551979542,
0.6842082143,
0.2831888199,
-0.8124886751,
-0.3433725238,
0.2205395103,
0.774898231,
-0.0076819612,
-0.1022675857,
0.813731432,
0.2991863191,
-0.0907102227,
-0.8920823336,
-0.2625094056,
0.1215974838,
0.0431711823,
0.6360914707,
-0.4913599193,
0.9453972578,
0.0495805405,
-0.4106712639,
0.3302154541,
0.4710934758,
-0.1360630393,
0.242487371,
0.2107767463,
0.6255152225,
0.5425172448,
-0.2278936505,
1.1823086739,
0.0088001126,
0.4500901103,
1.0673048496,
-0.1810482293,
0.869276166,
0.6725859642,
-0.7484278083,
0.1328793019,
0.6729543805,
0.0666824207,
0.1812117249,
0.4160687923,
-0.3821569085,
-0.2861791551,
0.0871578231,
-0.5133286715,
0.3326396048,
0.3839529157,
-0.42666924,
-0.5964298844,
0.0523868911,
0.1577482671,
0.1578443348,
-0.2521715462,
0.7357172966,
0.5072572827,
-0.1777507961,
0.513530314,
-0.0653130934,
0.3472959399,
-0.5500712991,
0.0322210118,
-0.4327298701,
0.0293578617,
0.1207175627,
-0.6604524255,
0.5223491192,
-0.0774699822,
-0.3353092074,
-0.1894735992,
0.3660278618,
-0.2488332391,
-0.6081079841,
0.3085725009,
0.5949485302,
0.3596486151,
-0.1568830907,
-0.4430207014,
0.4406461418,
-0.114935115,
-0.2243193388,
0.4402323067,
0.7656428814,
0.2439709604,
0.8363701105,
0.2461036593,
0.1211785376,
0.277441442,
-0.2329792231,
0.7792794108,
-0.9573215246,
-0.0712945759,
-1.1970205307,
0.457452029,
0.0800251216,
-0.4279713929,
0.5727379322,
0.4923552573,
0.672275424,
0.2639206648,
0.6632099748,
-0.2165551931,
0.6610937715,
-0.5345146656,
0.5296264291,
-0.8179879785,
0.4182831943,
-0.2190838307,
-0.8391352296,
-0.4841560423,
0.3233519197,
-0.2341595739,
0.0160187595,
0.7346352339,
0.2916031778,
0.1789654493,
0.056601394,
0.4581931531,
0.4900313616,
0.5546124578,
0.3955073655,
1.1282640696,
-0.3956170082,
0.3177221715,
0.2079730928,
-0.3201517761,
-0.2276761681,
-1.0083044767,
-0.388774097,
-0.4981608093,
-0.127079457,
-0.2792547047,
-0.0345384888,
0.8611661792,
0.0304422621,
-0.5160734057,
0.0042421273,
-0.1681774855,
0.0264126733,
0.208026439,
-0.1782623231,
0.2507592142,
-0.6110845208,
-0.6611496806,
0.6945819259,
0.5916436911,
0.0125051951,
-0.4024147987,
0.3087235987,
-0.0423875228,
0.0437725112,
0.9887995124,
0.4817810357,
-0.9595519304,
-0.3194779754,
-0.3089334667,
0.1634558737,
0.4059009552,
0.9973840117,
-0.4959301353,
0.3093304932,
0.0546284392,
1.0384511948,
0.0425501317,
-0.2573410571,
0.7758206129,
-0.4284014404,
-0.0162784718,
0.483139962,
0.5795006156,
0.4870686233,
0.127908349,
0.5993501544,
0.3325473666,
-0.8723222613,
-1.1457595825,
0.1758361459,
-0.7265480161,
-0.4581757784,
0.7073625922,
-0.074885115,
-0.0207903758,
-0.0114457356,
-0.1510387063,
-0.1224325672,
0.1571305692,
0.8671745658,
0.9823681712,
-0.1203218848,
-0.4076405764,
-0.8369091749,
0.4492918253,
0.7033517957,
-0.7969451547,
0.3454147279,
0.7119905353,
0.0532059222,
0.1474675536,
0.693921864,
-0.3116338253,
-0.2713409066,
0.2647634447,
-0.1257220656,
0.4959615469,
-0.4996306002,
-0.4878208935,
0.21501486,
0.5046731234,
0.3563331068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05014v1
|
Interpreting Pretrained Language Models via Concept Bottlenecks
| 2023-11-08T20:41:18 | 2023-11-08T20:41:18 |
Zhen Tan, Lu Cheng, Song Wang, Yuan Bo, Jundong Li, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pretrained language models (PLMs) have made significant strides in various
natural language processing tasks. However, the lack of interpretability due to
their ``black-box'' nature poses challenges for responsible implementation.
Although previous studies have attempted to improve interpretability by using,
e.g., attention weights in self-attention layers, these weights often lack
clarity, readability, and intuitiveness. In this research, we propose a novel
approach to interpreting PLMs by employing high-level, meaningful concepts that
are easily understandable for humans. For example, we learn the concept of
``Food'' and investigate how it influences the prediction of a model's
sentiment towards a restaurant review. We introduce C$^3$M, which combines
human-annotated and machine-generated concepts to extract hidden neurons
designed to encapsulate semantically meaningful and task-specific concepts.
Through empirical evaluations on real-world datasets, we manifest that our
approach offers valuable insights to interpret PLM behavior, helps diagnose
model failures, and enhances model robustness amidst noisy concept labels.
|
[
-0.3291466534,
-0.6926839352,
0.6263309121,
0.2423599511,
-0.4328696132,
0.1041225567,
-0.24141258,
-0.394140631,
-0.1216204837,
0.665843904,
-0.5144771934,
-0.3349704146,
-0.445997268,
0.0323761292,
-0.3409757614,
0.9998757839,
0.0170454904,
-0.1288948655,
-0.4910509884,
0.1621485054,
-0.6759079695,
-0.5460560918,
-0.3597207963,
-0.5214293599,
0.3475065529,
0.3253812492,
0.5953284502,
0.7243984342,
0.4639037848,
0.1938668638,
-0.1426988244,
0.0382237323,
-0.3603142798,
-0.1869668365,
-0.1408200264,
-0.6108541489,
-0.4146411717,
0.2722645402,
0.2762017548,
1.0126191378,
-0.0972148925,
0.1545389146,
0.4058522582,
0.6004132628,
-0.596493423,
0.4778896868,
-0.6563957334,
-0.0433491319,
-0.0797491148,
-0.09760461,
-0.3357668221,
0.0328808576,
0.3795552254,
-0.9944727421,
0.2720871568,
-0.0283898748,
0.9305436015,
0.5674257874,
0.0567380376,
-0.4448561072,
-0.6204939485,
0.5842722654,
-0.6493542194,
0.138686657,
0.3799552321,
0.0528633222,
0.0319241025,
-0.5634025335,
-0.8177280426,
-0.1585879028,
-0.1141769737,
0.0140770124,
-0.1660571992,
-0.0423112698,
0.2962661088,
0.4024772942,
-0.3665628731,
0.1733195633,
-0.308273524,
0.0062371483,
0.3947583437,
-0.0216577277,
0.3382869661,
-0.3126908839,
-0.5329406261,
0.1165629327,
-0.5751530528,
0.1211165115,
0.2522863746,
0.2614333332,
-0.3601433635,
0.3522644341,
-0.2553404868,
0.8663458228,
-0.0603695549,
0.1718775481,
0.4847213626,
-0.2979349792,
-0.2088166922,
-0.1101402268,
0.8124549985,
0.3832460344,
0.7042185664,
-0.1746410728,
-0.1334722489,
0.0010209879,
0.6040999293,
-0.6323118806,
-0.5928877592,
0.3267994523,
-0.2854211926,
-0.4647225142,
0.0164538641,
-0.6467546821,
-0.3143496513,
-0.276550144,
0.4662281573,
-0.2834636569,
-0.4792863131,
0.3687289655,
-0.105630286,
0.0506355651,
0.1373998374,
-0.7034215331,
0.1878127456,
0.6381018162,
0.9767542481,
-0.303129822,
-0.0657784715,
-0.1504629701,
0.237140432,
-0.2230398506,
0.7035182714,
-0.4932285249,
-0.331933409,
-0.474873215,
-0.1427078098,
-0.1094221771,
-0.6879023314,
0.6706995368,
-0.3842472136,
-0.2401138693,
-0.1220444217,
-0.4182745218,
0.1253671348,
0.1813170016,
-0.6567923427,
0.7929915786,
-0.0604023971,
-0.9488882422,
0.2698113024,
-0.8607616425,
-0.5167526603,
0.2805914581,
-0.1673420072,
-0.2814623713,
0.4171892107,
0.2793684006,
0.612570703,
-0.2459832132,
0.2610296607,
-0.2399438918,
-0.3134287,
0.5231773257,
-0.1760267615,
0.4573898315,
0.4250622392,
-0.1476269066,
-0.0102818171,
-0.7582669854,
-0.0474750288,
0.2806264758,
0.019731503,
-0.4884180427,
0.038297642,
-0.4113615751,
0.2771648467,
0.2148359567,
-0.2841444016,
-0.1994137317,
-0.6122477055,
0.6896088123,
0.5833095312,
-0.086508058,
0.354200542,
-0.021186661,
0.6237300634,
0.3982043564,
-0.1061454937,
-0.3492445052,
-0.346917212,
-0.6874077916,
-0.1502410024,
0.1888863444,
0.3224881887,
-0.870462954,
0.4627738297,
-0.317435652,
-0.3304943144,
-0.7283204198,
0.29906407,
0.2907916903,
0.8091375828,
0.3543145359,
-0.5086314678,
-0.2224045694,
-0.8849636316,
-0.464594394,
-0.0131304823,
-0.2193094641,
0.2165781707,
0.4153151214,
-0.0243019573,
0.9349530339,
-0.8151789308,
-0.108923994,
-0.3980859518,
0.5221309066,
0.1646550149,
0.6695302725,
-0.0104412772,
-0.6671648622,
-0.1590563804,
-0.1606306732,
-0.6001796722,
-0.1446777135,
-0.2616831362,
0.0033884286,
-0.3782943487,
0.510932982,
-0.8104735017,
0.2536827326,
0.3031888902,
-0.1794905961,
0.5858711004,
-0.0826820955,
-0.5199795365,
-0.7914885283,
0.0361983255,
0.300383687,
0.0631283373,
-0.6282135248,
-0.0680908188,
-0.003179708,
-0.2554443777,
-0.3838348389,
0.5545452237,
-0.4359295964,
-0.1806563288,
-0.250095576,
0.1845232844,
0.3309575021,
0.5644637942,
0.3170824647,
0.6467636228,
0.3204043806,
-0.5512776971,
-0.0403239094,
-0.0347922929,
-0.6006736159,
0.45074597,
-0.8066034913,
0.1900223196,
-0.234835878,
0.0801410899,
-0.8744021058,
-0.1605553478,
0.3660721481,
-0.4384111762,
0.1596889943,
0.1927876323,
-0.4879884124,
-0.4395604432,
0.0647857636,
0.4556530714,
0.1062601879,
-0.2814404666,
0.3591161072,
0.437758714,
-0.0884532928,
-0.5403775573,
-0.6517325044,
-0.0207151491,
-0.1094696373,
-0.0160484854,
0.0081965271,
0.0540093295,
-0.1085324436,
0.019806223,
-0.3934324682,
-0.1896484643,
0.5275492072,
0.4555250704,
0.079804115,
-0.1346267611,
0.219153747,
-0.3066556156,
-0.1268906444,
0.3319808841,
-0.4357444644,
0.4754376709,
-0.3438554704,
0.1374741197,
-0.6503325105,
-0.0571511649,
0.5421544313,
-0.5421436429,
0.605211556,
0.7350302339,
-0.3668650091,
-0.4074803889,
-0.2496426255,
-0.1129250675,
-0.4588960111,
0.4766412973,
-0.6553287506,
-0.7140389681,
0.2680978179,
-0.0516533516,
-0.4154606462,
0.2710753083,
0.3991125226,
-0.555459857,
0.8757439256,
0.5717240572,
0.1267718971,
0.4643036425,
-0.270424366,
0.2594117224,
-0.877827704,
-0.3014646471,
-0.4373258352,
-0.050776992,
-0.3396899402,
-0.5868157744,
0.2003625482,
0.3365960419,
-0.0650066659,
0.207951203,
-0.3549640775,
0.6224241257,
0.3772554398,
0.0828453079,
0.324842006,
-0.1053503901,
-0.3222229779,
-0.0033143859,
-0.7185098529,
-0.6562219858,
0.9817574024,
0.7008813024,
0.7529679537,
-0.3455832899,
0.4327765405,
0.0980103314,
0.584387064,
-0.8949587345,
0.3060687482,
-0.1868089288,
-0.732425034,
-0.2697741091,
-0.6851493716,
-0.7856138945,
0.314696759,
-0.1625841707,
-0.6919057965,
0.0599927753,
0.3935046494,
-0.6527922153,
0.1118622273,
-1.0937060118,
1.4504867792,
-0.5598733425,
-0.2519835532,
-0.1833998859,
-0.6192368865,
0.4683465362,
-0.2275908738,
0.6130384803,
-0.2232558727,
0.0570700578,
0.6294821501,
-0.2258950174,
0.9150472283,
-0.2266409695,
-0.3005547523,
0.2374458462,
-0.0279540233,
0.1781317145,
-0.0544920303,
-0.0272574667,
0.3865658939,
-0.0659590736,
-0.4637201428,
-0.7772346735,
0.3741811216,
-0.8738363981,
-0.5494430661,
-0.1650034934,
-0.8084172606,
-0.3706594408,
0.2123520672,
-0.0523322113,
0.2198766321,
-0.0707301348,
-0.0388279334,
0.4820817411,
-0.2894418538,
0.1272547394,
0.468503654,
0.0522142723,
0.0036434236,
1.2000005245,
0.0023495674,
0.3721189797,
0.3440242708,
0.1047143936,
-0.3329407871,
-0.6917134523,
-0.2894355059,
0.0359287336,
-0.5197651386,
0.0029166194,
-0.7063524723,
0.0608466007,
-0.0153668839,
0.1561889052,
-0.4701531231,
-0.3497701585,
-0.6416333318,
-0.0833049268,
-0.2872802019,
0.6849926114,
0.1783252358,
0.8025619984,
-0.5608509183,
0.4810126722,
0.2268458456,
0.5023466349,
0.2061935514,
-0.35310179,
-0.5532363653,
0.0610234961,
-0.3675065339,
-0.7652570009,
0.4797858,
0.1310917884,
0.3840350211,
0.5370642543,
-0.0374388285,
0.5610849857,
-0.208810389,
0.5007029772,
0.3380561173,
-1.1473852396,
0.5830308199,
-0.0961139351,
0.576710403,
0.531611979,
0.4590749443,
-0.2319640815,
-0.3539883494,
-0.4874897301,
-0.7818099856,
0.6420728564,
0.1527967453,
0.0805745572,
-0.0054790396,
0.6360864639,
0.0950197354,
0.5134744048,
-0.9423862696,
0.0394590236,
-0.5320448279,
-0.5061065555,
-0.2926187515,
-0.1699194461,
0.1905189157,
-0.2182299048,
0.2986461222,
-0.1904011369,
-0.0518580042,
-0.0351553932,
-0.4671053588,
-0.1869426072,
0.3707059622,
0.3941617906,
0.7365363836,
-0.5538412929,
0.5213734508,
0.0288402848,
-0.4217973351,
0.0673082694,
0.0471007042,
-0.0938260704,
-0.1824119836,
0.4634049237,
0.8783899546,
0.3404805362,
-0.7775962949,
0.5075051785,
-0.1163541079,
0.1200313196,
-0.0285283998,
0.0893209428,
0.3113157451,
0.0336394385,
0.2815954089,
0.192022264,
-0.011151012,
-0.7680899501,
0.3254098892,
0.4342361391,
-0.526409924,
-0.5483113527,
0.5878368616,
0.5768728852,
-0.0132422699,
0.3599726856,
-0.2862844169,
-0.5912775397,
0.5183230639,
0.4066682458,
0.7389919162,
-0.0462183394,
0.2785251737,
0.1957594603,
0.4718325436,
-0.059034165,
0.127742365,
-0.228643626,
-1.1217362881,
-0.6867298484,
-0.9785763025,
-0.1589186341,
0.4011578262,
-0.9981765151,
-0.0727745518,
-0.4700238407,
-0.1765534729,
0.2269304544,
-0.0871851295,
-0.8278653622,
0.4885305464,
0.2703437507,
0.7380860448,
-0.8116828799,
1.0601799488,
0.8018399477,
-0.4133626223,
-0.6803559661,
0.2937482595,
-0.4265976548,
-0.8975952268,
0.8138234019,
0.2998596728,
-0.088651374,
0.2275715172,
-0.5544185638,
-0.5480535626,
0.6391480565,
0.2370917201,
-0.8585873246,
-0.2851986289,
0.2619977295,
0.6333044767,
-0.5637472868,
0.0813989863,
0.8921048641,
0.285384357,
0.0422967114,
-0.7936045527,
0.0956428722,
-0.0556507893,
-0.2215216607,
-0.1821599603,
-0.3234487176,
0.8704969883,
-0.3343425393,
-0.28540802,
-0.3304317594,
0.5317755342,
0.0526216812,
0.3312860131,
0.8095639944,
0.7976740003,
0.6852369308,
-0.060833618,
0.9963054657,
-0.4432216585,
0.3198249638,
1.3781808615,
-0.233858183,
0.8727306128,
0.4691759646,
-0.0181683172,
0.3926942945,
0.6089490652,
0.0697851628,
0.6032294631,
0.4270868301,
0.0916862041,
-0.5094771981,
-0.3084625304,
-0.1202004999,
0.5270267725,
0.6204676032,
-0.2727695405,
-0.0264821686,
-0.044223614,
-0.1600347459,
-0.0372238643,
-0.4498125017,
0.7202132344,
0.5302167535,
-0.4958986044,
0.5975189209,
-0.1104642153,
0.6415678859,
-0.1745870858,
0.0099603152,
0.1073659435,
0.1379335672,
-0.1092363968,
-0.7068517208,
0.1588963866,
0.0581192225,
-0.0417368002,
-0.3057831228,
0.6718658209,
-0.4626473784,
-0.4881578982,
0.1493479759,
0.7733911276,
0.1622214019,
-0.370906055,
-0.748898685,
0.331900537,
-0.1958759278,
0.0021526546,
-0.0751402378,
0.4897603989,
0.2279625535,
0.760925293,
0.4651529491,
0.3235236406,
-0.3174962401,
-0.0149964588,
0.8017974496,
-0.841983676,
-0.6851119995,
-0.8448162675,
0.427868247,
0.1853479594,
-0.2741236985,
0.4766763747,
0.274243027,
1.0654684305,
-0.1711482406,
0.9273610711,
0.395756036,
0.5496222377,
-0.5460439324,
0.8408702612,
-0.5462467074,
0.5761364102,
-0.2904760242,
-0.5126472116,
-0.1190755218,
0.7551776171,
-0.6948862672,
-0.1577489823,
0.5020318031,
0.5203592777,
0.0757123977,
0.0365543403,
0.2750282884,
0.4786040187,
-0.0031571025,
0.5698431134,
1.2027835846,
0.1715683639,
0.4660771787,
-0.1695713401,
0.0040149014,
-0.1931090653,
-0.7903026938,
-1.010011673,
-0.3343061507,
-0.2645772398,
-0.080054678,
-0.0555975251,
0.7425370812,
0.9038667083,
-0.7803646326,
-0.2351001352,
-0.2121806592,
0.3141352832,
-0.1739853919,
-0.2443373352,
0.2942927778,
-0.4813292921,
-0.3772772253,
0.1507216394,
0.1509516537,
0.1605477333,
-0.3267608881,
-0.05715321,
-0.0161894355,
-0.0118859643,
0.5331447124,
-0.0259664338,
-0.7840360403,
-0.2085675597,
-0.3893196285,
0.1332659721,
0.190408662,
0.9916327,
-0.7474362254,
0.6959733367,
-0.0444760211,
0.6155674458,
0.6063171625,
0.3089099824,
0.7961877584,
-0.9079456925,
0.124578245,
0.3134533465,
0.0268402733,
0.4659017622,
-0.2304508984,
0.2770537138,
0.3854702711,
0.0873804763,
-0.9653573632,
0.2487324327,
-0.805866003,
-0.5326789021,
0.7213295102,
-0.4794693589,
-0.3574357331,
-0.2029078156,
0.1711621732,
0.3718487918,
-0.2176911533,
0.7460824847,
0.7768694758,
-0.0003817638,
-0.3758350909,
-0.9870672822,
0.7072104216,
0.586351037,
-0.9036324024,
0.1407771856,
0.2453494221,
0.3618488908,
0.2892597914,
0.2570118308,
0.065261215,
-0.022970831,
-0.2430102378,
0.321208477,
-0.1414158344,
-0.3071071506,
-0.4247927666,
0.2667318881,
0.1846929044,
-0.204544127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07587v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07587v2
|
Frontier Language Models are not Robust to Adversarial Arithmetic, or "What do I need to say so you agree 2+2=5?
| 2023-11-08T19:07:10 | 2023-11-15T19:49:02 |
C. Daniel Freeman, Laura Culp, Aaron Parisi, Maxwell L Bileschi, Gamaleldin F Elsayed, Alex Rizkowsky, Isabelle Simpson, Alex Alemi, Azade Nova, Ben Adlam, Bernd Bohnet, Gaurav Mishra, Hanie Sedghi, Igor Mordatch, Izzeddin Gur, Jaehoon Lee, JD Co-Reyes, Jeffrey Pennington, Kelvin Xu, Kevin Swersky, Kshiteej Mahajan, Lechao Xiao, Rosanne Liu, Simon Kornblith, Noah Constant, Peter J. Liu, Roman Novak, Yundi Qian, Noah Fiedel, Jascha Sohl-Dickstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
We introduce and study the problem of adversarial arithmetic, which provides
a simple yet challenging testbed for language model alignment. This problem is
comprised of arithmetic questions posed in natural language, with an arbitrary
adversarial string inserted before the question is complete. Even in the simple
setting of 1-digit addition problems, it is easy to find adversarial prompts
that make all tested models (including PaLM2, GPT4, Claude2) misbehave, and
even to steer models to a particular wrong answer. We additionally provide a
simple algorithm for finding successful attacks by querying those same models,
which we name "prompt inversion rejection sampling" (PIRS). We finally show
that models can be partially hardened against these attacks via reinforcement
learning and via agentic constitutional loops. However, we were not able to
make a language model fully robust against adversarial arithmetic attacks.
|
[
-0.5476077795,
-1.2530982494,
0.4034231901,
0.1741873026,
0.1839761436,
0.2040679306,
-0.0487756319,
-0.1233369708,
-0.104082197,
0.6591514349,
-0.6591044068,
-0.0397724211,
-0.7628908753,
0.0103669148,
-0.4909725785,
0.9619697332,
0.1435161829,
0.285916537,
0.1037269607,
-0.3523089588,
-0.3372675478,
-0.5139517784,
-0.9531269073,
-0.026844142,
0.086575374,
0.2371920496,
1.171066165,
0.5399059653,
0.661403954,
0.428899616,
-0.132000342,
-0.0476838276,
-0.3794992268,
-0.1986533552,
-0.0058061164,
-0.7651339173,
-0.4927136898,
0.0134350117,
0.5390805006,
0.9008716345,
-0.1872231662,
-0.1852324754,
-0.38355878,
0.910893023,
-0.4042497873,
-0.3404634595,
-0.8286866546,
-0.1663601547,
-0.3408787549,
0.3408538103,
-0.3983328044,
-0.5688368678,
-0.1366805881,
-0.6524707675,
0.359566927,
0.0667404532,
0.9394249916,
0.1915145963,
-0.4126645327,
-0.5561850071,
-0.4767784476,
0.3703329265,
-0.7427464128,
-0.0325355195,
0.5591844916,
0.4531235993,
-0.4307561815,
-0.4390583634,
-0.907971859,
-0.249670133,
0.217485249,
-0.1652160436,
-0.6072180867,
0.0573835298,
0.3992339373,
0.184578225,
-0.8078482151,
0.0679649711,
-0.5855312943,
-0.1944966316,
0.3922363222,
0.2490409613,
0.5227075219,
0.2405864745,
-0.5477402806,
-0.2974768281,
-0.9996442199,
0.4638607204,
0.792321682,
0.4547225237,
0.0689184815,
0.670283854,
0.1385970265,
0.9373275042,
0.398857832,
0.3303367496,
-0.3026013076,
-0.1253012568,
-0.1138971299,
-0.1615796238,
0.8919435143,
0.1515554488,
0.2397209853,
-0.0440460406,
-0.3343334496,
0.4301164746,
0.4630944431,
-0.574097693,
-0.2371299714,
0.2271995842,
0.2992483079,
-0.4833533764,
-0.1017049849,
-0.4989927411,
-0.550362885,
0.1074055359,
0.7403013706,
-0.5264712572,
0.0426995941,
0.0797511861,
-0.2278247178,
0.2142407745,
0.1054384261,
-1.0402913094,
0.5960341692,
0.9501095414,
0.5733363628,
0.2631665766,
-0.3485885262,
-0.5489929914,
-0.4313336909,
-0.8623612523,
0.6076549888,
-0.4471844435,
-0.4673226178,
-0.115859203,
0.1842479408,
-0.1342363656,
-0.278462559,
0.6672374606,
-0.8825699091,
0.4800546467,
-0.5036401153,
-0.3725782037,
-0.2064755559,
0.4088665247,
-0.6460807323,
0.6563135982,
0.1498509794,
-0.7653674483,
-0.1236584261,
-0.4790308774,
-0.2443067729,
-0.1018018126,
-0.1960621774,
-0.4326926768,
0.0307184719,
0.3390205801,
-0.3029726148,
-0.2891138494,
0.2118206322,
-0.6605755091,
-0.2787952125,
0.6392092705,
-0.5611947775,
1.2227358818,
0.2668615282,
-0.3335631192,
0.1341510862,
-0.5804538131,
-0.0371239707,
0.2137037963,
0.1435858458,
-0.3085151315,
-0.0433204509,
-0.4789347351,
0.0621380471,
0.1107838973,
-0.5150207281,
0.383351475,
-0.6628266573,
0.3583131135,
0.7546520829,
-0.2183797508,
0.6222884655,
-0.4409255981,
0.7452946305,
-0.2917257845,
-0.1386564225,
0.1416308284,
-0.3350582123,
-0.9200459123,
-0.0715192929,
0.4915270209,
0.7658509016,
-1.0170036554,
0.3241678178,
-0.3080942035,
-0.5147917271,
-0.5401589274,
-0.155183509,
0.2972528636,
0.6376106143,
0.0782305598,
0.0385647826,
-0.1822238564,
-0.8581954241,
-0.3799498081,
-0.2775681913,
-0.0305278972,
-0.1176949814,
0.2839054763,
0.2822914422,
0.7364658713,
-0.4529345334,
0.0332448632,
-0.2314668745,
0.1828941405,
0.1063277423,
0.3667416871,
0.57115376,
-0.828070879,
-0.2537332177,
-0.2544396222,
-0.5427292585,
0.0201674551,
-0.0314111523,
-0.0474415049,
-0.0182658341,
0.2895305455,
-0.717220366,
0.1415554285,
0.6094353199,
-0.5670111179,
0.1622236818,
-0.2250258327,
-0.062786676,
-0.91774863,
-0.0210146513,
-0.0990343243,
-0.1501175165,
-1.0423820019,
0.4686031044,
0.3141728044,
-0.5138457417,
-0.1691126972,
0.3169008195,
-0.2209625244,
0.1785027683,
-0.5713229179,
-0.1145852134,
0.1303294748,
0.3859081268,
-0.0068267155,
1.0209296942,
0.6200226545,
-0.6129241586,
0.246473521,
0.2077567875,
0.1402932405,
0.7105056047,
-0.7252864838,
0.2471734434,
-0.2777377963,
0.2715914845,
-1.0779739618,
-0.055385828,
0.2425391525,
-0.7859433293,
0.4160392284,
-0.1493710279,
0.1056910232,
-0.1795884371,
-0.4280630052,
0.3504070044,
0.6558987498,
-0.4751623571,
0.3565472364,
0.5399739146,
-0.4578122795,
-0.6779622436,
-0.5221873522,
0.055493284,
-0.3171958327,
-0.8077991605,
-0.0045741606,
0.1491217017,
-0.3480546772,
-0.0369305313,
0.0516263209,
-0.0230917446,
0.3797123432,
0.0585675798,
0.3171552718,
-0.4017534256,
-0.1868410408,
-0.1769054532,
-0.0939531922,
0.3466437757,
-0.2183562368,
0.2769146264,
-0.4084445536,
-0.5704016685,
0.04387125,
0.4574656188,
0.6420384049,
-0.1709405035,
0.4512287378,
0.2394632399,
-0.7642811537,
-0.0229271296,
-0.3604961038,
0.0444621779,
-0.5111911297,
0.3015550673,
-0.4725072682,
-0.744361043,
0.5736091137,
0.2433781773,
0.0349469148,
0.7220125794,
0.4698773026,
0.0915819779,
1.1997320652,
0.4414530396,
0.1141405106,
0.1085541397,
-0.1870674342,
0.0795054287,
-0.6432281733,
0.0328411832,
-0.7410935163,
-0.1128620803,
-0.8033279181,
-0.2200399339,
0.3818288743,
0.2541953921,
-0.4728363752,
0.5494235754,
-0.2476562262,
0.4760152698,
0.471239686,
-0.0909288377,
-0.2020362169,
-0.0379274525,
0.0767692924,
-0.1076207832,
-0.7373577952,
-0.5036469102,
0.9940021038,
0.4793348312,
0.8603207469,
0.5403889418,
0.2823757827,
0.207235232,
0.3403366804,
-0.5659174323,
0.3461278379,
-0.2809857726,
-0.7840550542,
-0.4809967279,
-0.4696415067,
-0.8406486511,
0.3280750513,
-0.0947748646,
-0.6568955183,
0.3957789242,
-0.0757512599,
-0.8755673766,
0.3167433441,
-0.6228123307,
0.9802058339,
-0.3859686255,
-0.2924377024,
0.3217723072,
-0.6883651018,
0.6004895568,
-0.0368081704,
0.6305508018,
-0.0733850375,
0.0391351916,
0.4983106256,
-0.9153435826,
0.7610097528,
-0.1209094897,
-0.1423377991,
0.4734045565,
0.4769128263,
0.7824409008,
-0.1879477352,
0.0683561862,
-0.1605553329,
0.0569032505,
-0.7029511333,
-0.6878344417,
0.6852389574,
-0.8824294806,
-0.7864064574,
-0.6894759536,
-0.3945737779,
-0.3478644192,
0.0714087859,
0.4434364438,
0.4866734147,
-0.3755705655,
-0.1252560914,
0.7161246538,
-0.0091197519,
0.4891169369,
0.6307244897,
-0.1158156842,
-0.8085610271,
1.2546838522,
0.102478832,
0.6204251647,
0.2376708239,
0.1838780642,
-0.5483796,
-0.3295564353,
-0.9312831759,
-0.2281589508,
-0.593103528,
-0.1025264114,
-0.5545066595,
-0.1702985615,
-0.4516412914,
-0.1787722409,
-0.3655594289,
-0.8331936002,
0.0498599,
-0.0125691341,
0.0668193996,
0.5942226052,
-0.1303920746,
0.4730962217,
-0.7930369973,
0.3481627703,
0.4632622302,
0.0051698741,
-0.2887379825,
-0.8486369252,
0.2148359865,
0.2909958065,
-0.5172575712,
-1.1072306633,
0.3642157912,
0.0725399926,
0.1441408992,
0.3693389595,
0.2529011667,
0.495167166,
-0.5723860264,
0.658508718,
0.1159656644,
-0.993360877,
0.161687091,
-0.407661438,
0.1135159209,
0.6100883484,
0.3903141618,
-0.3691565096,
-0.4192082584,
-0.8919865489,
-0.5151199102,
0.6459288001,
0.1781740487,
0.3246899247,
0.0133650173,
0.0337366462,
0.0066648182,
-0.0381615236,
-0.6933103204,
-0.2510934472,
-0.3399489224,
-0.095129855,
0.0250895899,
-0.1907048076,
-0.4117156267,
0.3034507036,
0.5456619263,
-0.1042382792,
-0.0271488037,
0.0428536832,
-0.0145061724,
-0.2663424313,
0.4095832109,
0.9145584106,
0.5402020216,
-0.0986418873,
0.3116432428,
0.2216964811,
-0.2778986096,
0.4590727389,
0.4994473755,
-0.4309057295,
-0.260951221,
0.4447728693,
0.8591808677,
-0.1488474458,
-0.3069891036,
0.7398305535,
-0.2889832854,
-0.1440793723,
-0.4267197251,
-0.0048939008,
-0.0727863908,
-0.0161466617,
0.297044307,
0.1558941007,
0.1327237934,
-0.4850390851,
0.1925131083,
0.8570747972,
-0.6043575406,
-0.3607821167,
0.7231104374,
0.2744336724,
-0.6319484711,
0.5701905489,
-0.4143639803,
-0.917402029,
0.8492406011,
0.5941087008,
0.6749192476,
-0.1781398207,
0.092162028,
0.2279397994,
0.780867517,
-0.1366215348,
0.2684013546,
0.372266084,
-0.7626960874,
-0.2362152189,
-0.2168665975,
-0.545805335,
-0.0018614287,
-0.658177793,
0.1243125275,
-0.671189785,
-0.2692867815,
0.1564478874,
-0.0409232117,
-0.2432956696,
0.0955302566,
0.109727107,
0.8963879943,
-1.094776392,
0.531863451,
0.5646263957,
-0.3779216409,
-0.5948787332,
-0.1298660338,
0.1375491172,
-0.9035522938,
0.3233013749,
0.0351125374,
0.1704074293,
-0.027995266,
-0.5035313368,
-0.6728760004,
0.4938910306,
0.4463394582,
-0.3661612868,
0.0366622172,
0.2086081803,
0.4697099328,
-0.0353947654,
0.3628109097,
0.4760183692,
0.2218582034,
0.2515768707,
-0.6889751554,
0.20664756,
-0.2083591223,
-0.1716071814,
0.5241314173,
-0.7571021318,
1.1294752359,
-0.391620785,
-0.258212328,
0.1882598698,
0.6939941645,
0.175181523,
0.2840165794,
0.4924007952,
0.8020622134,
0.5815819502,
-0.3870843351,
1.1946263313,
-0.1181644574,
0.2424792498,
0.8936415911,
-0.259128511,
0.6951559782,
0.2318072468,
-0.5574578047,
0.116729103,
0.7411617637,
0.1498703063,
0.405484736,
0.3513094485,
-0.1725616455,
-0.4098646343,
0.2042284906,
-0.5048863888,
0.2315131575,
0.5645269752,
0.2784503996,
-0.4258778095,
-0.2949095368,
0.1616629213,
0.3505516052,
0.0067139654,
0.7816153765,
0.0081554847,
-0.8246648312,
0.7329871655,
0.3545585275,
0.2633049786,
-0.7051917315,
0.0420797989,
-0.4951631725,
0.2586356401,
0.0793603137,
-0.4488095045,
0.2569227815,
0.0278606769,
0.030918343,
0.351124227,
0.1858252436,
-0.5071453452,
-0.9281483293,
-0.3714284599,
0.2987504601,
-0.1253170818,
0.0034292792,
-0.7344580293,
-0.0391931869,
-0.0546321161,
-0.164256379,
0.4119411111,
0.6626420021,
-0.2132063657,
0.7847353816,
0.7930553555,
0.1871265471,
0.0207631718,
-0.3460302949,
0.788731873,
-0.5752040744,
-0.4365648031,
-1.1519238949,
0.3290808201,
0.0162854195,
-0.24841322,
0.6073414087,
0.470582366,
0.6047458053,
0.2625659704,
0.8040104508,
-0.0201544426,
0.336487323,
-0.518581748,
0.5471067429,
-0.1707489789,
0.5181698799,
0.1111149788,
-0.4715640545,
-0.0937309787,
0.3324227035,
-0.3134607077,
-0.1386499405,
0.6189997792,
0.9405691624,
0.0350208208,
0.1935620457,
0.2614201009,
0.0336271003,
0.5221869349,
0.7560034394,
1.0407887697,
-0.6940748692,
0.6162536144,
-0.2341081649,
-0.4000917375,
0.0654918253,
-0.7046935558,
-0.7974116206,
-0.3030949235,
-0.0965307131,
-0.6446171999,
0.132200256,
0.8006961346,
0.2865954936,
-0.9489223361,
-0.1483801156,
-0.3277842104,
0.3357067704,
-0.0201008655,
-0.1613370329,
0.5233542919,
-0.3238463104,
-0.7041510344,
0.4539301097,
-0.0823627114,
0.3483664989,
-0.3179376423,
0.1224699169,
0.0050365459,
0.2174577564,
-0.1103480831,
0.6456578374,
-0.762555182,
-0.0977373198,
0.2634492218,
-0.2921560109,
-0.2358138114,
0.6980594397,
-0.403934598,
0.5611979961,
0.3879934251,
0.9422679543,
-0.2232240736,
0.3705582023,
0.8833603859,
-0.3993714154,
0.1212049499,
0.2641063035,
0.2402918488,
0.4408107996,
-0.2839190066,
0.2421734631,
0.2380893826,
-0.397646755,
-0.8973304033,
0.3392230272,
-0.5270443559,
-0.2868206501,
0.9225822091,
-0.2059521526,
-0.1993730366,
0.1656121612,
-0.2661733925,
-0.2619696259,
-0.0929417685,
0.7678206563,
1.0005636215,
-0.0031849658,
0.2871553302,
-0.4244122803,
0.640663445,
0.5235316157,
-0.4281899631,
0.1708295941,
0.4181322157,
0.2512096763,
0.2635299861,
0.4811666608,
-0.0747587681,
0.4146142304,
0.5207520127,
-0.2810076177,
-0.1684540361,
0.016109854,
-0.8376495838,
0.2949259579,
0.4838030636,
-0.2438524961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04978v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04978v2
|
On the steerability of large language models toward data-driven personas
| 2023-11-08T19:01:13 | 2024-04-02T18:29:52 |
Junyi Li, Ninareh Mehrabi, Charith Peris, Palash Goyal, Kai-Wei Chang, Aram Galstyan, Richard Zemel, Rahul Gupta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are known to generate biased responses where the
opinions of certain groups and populations are underrepresented. Here, we
present a novel approach to achieve controllable generation of specific
viewpoints using LLMs, that can be leveraged to produce multiple perspectives
and to reflect the diverse opinions. Moving beyond the traditional reliance on
demographics like age, gender, or party affiliation, we introduce a data-driven
notion of persona grounded in collaborative filtering, which is defined as
either a single individual or a cohort of individuals manifesting similar views
across specific inquiries. As individuals in the same demographic group may
have different personas, our data-driven persona definition allows for a more
nuanced understanding of different (latent) social groups present in the
population. In addition to this, we also explore an efficient method to steer
LLMs toward the personas that we define. We show that our data-driven personas
significantly enhance model steerability, with improvements of between
$57\%-77\%$ over our best performing baselines.
|
[
-0.5513315201,
-0.5474752188,
0.8887693882,
0.3023383617,
0.0213045925,
0.3969870508,
-0.1454360336,
-0.1304136813,
0.2698947787,
0.949893713,
-0.8243763447,
-0.7214608192,
-0.4284093678,
-0.2211574912,
-0.2021366209,
1.0028703213,
0.3773387671,
0.17041035,
-0.3282196522,
-0.0617233142,
-0.311108768,
-0.5415875912,
-0.4425099492,
-0.5915322304,
0.9850535393,
0.4508941174,
0.8662653565,
0.6138706207,
0.1157959476,
0.2647678554,
0.0028793616,
-0.0428654328,
-0.7243157029,
0.3632832766,
-0.5124263763,
-0.5299262404,
-0.4958785772,
0.2193514407,
0.5393722653,
1.137173295,
-0.0857511982,
-0.1673838794,
0.2256636173,
0.899236083,
-0.4786547124,
0.0681335256,
-0.8267853856,
0.0463290475,
-0.3800319433,
-0.0687097386,
-0.7625947595,
-0.5577867031,
0.2596361041,
-0.6316508651,
-0.0069605736,
0.2250594795,
0.1718222499,
0.0578918047,
-0.6154798269,
-0.0857252777,
-0.8529258966,
0.9248732328,
-0.4653837383,
0.3601961136,
0.3511620164,
0.4837158918,
-0.200484857,
-0.2478075624,
-0.4020425975,
-0.0875595585,
-0.0825685263,
0.1042637676,
-0.0992906615,
-0.2029825151,
0.1794684678,
0.1613748819,
-0.5646228194,
0.3609127104,
0.0132068135,
-0.018507896,
0.6496123672,
0.3703978956,
0.0693599805,
-0.275393486,
-0.0992679,
0.1898817569,
-0.8492689133,
-0.0220444705,
0.7376454473,
0.4553408921,
-0.2109932154,
0.6766296029,
-0.4376577437,
0.5544104576,
0.7328518033,
-0.3041679561,
0.2062996924,
-0.0049968427,
-0.0909149051,
-0.2208906263,
0.6726742983,
0.3531427085,
0.2956717014,
-0.1829128861,
-0.0000710013,
-0.02587221,
0.3720436692,
-0.7713746428,
-0.3833132684,
0.4003373981,
-0.6685884595,
-0.4926459789,
0.0040215105,
-1.1783725023,
-1.1639914513,
-0.6015239358,
-0.2432536036,
-0.3057659268,
-0.319472611,
0.0152961826,
0.3608011305,
0.4318309426,
0.6044386029,
-0.9099584222,
0.2136254311,
0.8648907542,
0.4916318357,
-0.5545712709,
0.0197441336,
-0.6860234141,
0.3831464052,
-0.3170531392,
0.7270250916,
-0.9549541473,
-0.5485784411,
0.0687335432,
-0.3347272873,
0.0076500899,
-0.6247187257,
0.0786835775,
-0.6554086804,
0.5353310704,
-0.467566222,
-0.4681402147,
-0.0915425345,
0.3254741132,
-0.470340997,
0.3870757818,
0.0720243752,
-0.82542032,
0.6683463454,
-0.2888096273,
-0.3829473853,
0.3230016828,
-0.5528773069,
-0.0799474642,
-0.045192454,
0.3922077417,
0.589016974,
-0.352406621,
0.6823418736,
-0.5283227563,
0.0823868364,
0.3121497631,
-0.1130588278,
0.7416294217,
0.0707268417,
-0.2342772484,
0.5131618381,
-0.7559921741,
-0.0819545612,
-0.043611154,
-0.423635006,
-0.4399498701,
0.3732986748,
0.1601801813,
0.3384548128,
0.1443632096,
-0.4565787613,
0.2750166655,
-0.3833225667,
0.1080760509,
0.9806257486,
-0.0057987971,
0.8944714665,
-0.3552579582,
0.6043305993,
0.1165077239,
0.038274318,
-0.1068660095,
-0.3890691996,
-0.6852632165,
-0.3819115758,
-0.1385012269,
0.4036144018,
-1.0084639788,
0.6141963601,
-0.3237861991,
-0.6033589244,
-0.2681354582,
0.3531307578,
0.3208104968,
0.6020863056,
-0.0405214429,
-0.3218097687,
-0.3485794961,
-1.0815894604,
-0.2771627605,
-0.3608149886,
-0.2356416434,
0.7000284791,
0.2226677835,
-0.3044202626,
0.9496174455,
-0.6179208755,
-0.1008469686,
-0.7476123571,
-0.0574021824,
0.1910050958,
0.4286853671,
0.5765281916,
-0.9857499003,
-0.6690900922,
0.0049082027,
-0.6896989942,
-0.4849046767,
-0.179929629,
-0.4010579586,
0.0335015543,
0.1907672584,
-0.4156320393,
0.254373014,
0.3371959329,
-0.5034143329,
0.2686426938,
0.1124190018,
-0.0726133436,
-1.1668651104,
0.0195422359,
0.5053974986,
-0.423836112,
-0.5068586469,
0.0170521867,
-0.224391982,
0.126601249,
-0.4229767323,
0.2892902493,
-0.1094743833,
0.034621235,
-0.2770626843,
0.1712907851,
-0.0051800027,
0.4691181481,
0.1643866003,
0.3710704446,
0.618516922,
-0.6107741594,
0.4603511393,
0.3281835318,
-0.4265062213,
1.226195097,
-0.5559468865,
0.3553368449,
-0.5660253763,
0.5646058321,
-0.8821259141,
-0.5116528273,
0.2620675266,
-0.1671561003,
0.0553755499,
-0.2190318257,
-0.3432345092,
-0.1079569012,
-0.2483780384,
-0.0599051788,
0.2793019414,
-0.4713946283,
0.8891011477,
0.7310774326,
-0.4518048465,
-0.123348549,
-0.4940116704,
0.0373003893,
-0.6046929955,
-0.5769008994,
0.3701988757,
-0.2607884407,
-0.7725157142,
-0.3481332362,
0.3158672452,
0.0842701942,
-0.2032644302,
0.4989157021,
0.3279519975,
0.1034613475,
-0.0203574952,
-0.0450495258,
-0.0917156041,
-0.090070121,
-0.3619184494,
0.9057830572,
0.1480424851,
-0.4554973841,
-0.3095442355,
0.594691515,
0.8340467215,
-0.224611789,
0.7741138935,
0.2557412088,
-0.0619514994,
-0.2778689563,
-0.6718780398,
-0.0663071275,
-0.5045720935,
0.2463359982,
-0.3405607939,
-1.0106855631,
0.6713238358,
0.0065311748,
0.2507848442,
0.0802018493,
0.80956918,
0.0479700081,
1.2255892754,
0.6623500586,
-0.4692531824,
0.4177634418,
0.1150710732,
0.0566199534,
-0.7274283767,
-0.6111113429,
-0.5792760253,
-0.4485214651,
-0.8295937777,
-0.1876149625,
0.3447275162,
-0.6341808438,
-0.3098418117,
-0.0324565209,
-0.3441171944,
0.1927887499,
0.6967803836,
0.2442812622,
0.2984141707,
-0.1190197244,
-0.2195997834,
-0.4443805218,
-0.4712354243,
-0.7155085802,
1.1306384802,
0.3845393062,
1.111426115,
0.2848981023,
0.4788837135,
0.2637340426,
0.454549551,
-0.8498339653,
0.8588404655,
-0.2479491532,
-0.6243320107,
-0.0261621643,
-0.3893460929,
-0.6672132015,
0.5210050344,
-0.376870811,
-1.057790041,
0.3143851459,
0.0899708793,
-0.2496677041,
0.2756508589,
-0.4415222108,
0.5379554033,
-0.2836263478,
-0.714307785,
-0.3033043146,
-0.5710762143,
0.3880817592,
-0.436552614,
0.0868060812,
-0.2211724371,
0.0785336345,
0.5949760079,
-0.3529908061,
0.9986692667,
-0.4555045664,
-0.178796187,
-0.0250367001,
0.233430177,
0.3596889675,
0.0555063486,
-0.2814334333,
-0.2015348822,
-0.4139033854,
-0.2123972178,
-0.6032094955,
1.0372024775,
-0.7093378305,
-0.8706587553,
-0.1332655549,
-0.7182019949,
-0.6312320828,
0.2160379887,
0.0073943255,
0.3000755012,
-0.2614527047,
0.433103919,
0.6645134091,
-0.5224413276,
0.1752662808,
0.7722753286,
-0.6979248524,
-0.2964091301,
0.4960938692,
-0.0350597762,
0.1842234731,
0.4843898416,
0.2016547024,
-0.3921687603,
-0.4668624699,
-0.3508499563,
0.0657553226,
-0.474421382,
0.2965098917,
-0.6578863263,
0.2797834575,
-0.3906232715,
-0.2367965281,
-0.3553428054,
-0.0863304436,
-0.0919399038,
-0.1039061174,
-0.0036206585,
0.7347736955,
0.3861465156,
0.6721191406,
-0.2278588414,
0.3586898744,
0.465796262,
0.2506754696,
-0.0298262965,
-0.4137116671,
0.0823931545,
-0.1044807583,
-0.3621087074,
-0.8462129235,
0.5116618276,
-0.1775488555,
0.5643782616,
0.5890545249,
0.0115818698,
0.4768316746,
-0.4922547638,
0.6448355913,
0.0844613686,
-0.8347577453,
0.7871430516,
-0.7817863822,
0.4327287078,
0.6900392771,
0.3353878856,
-0.4340777993,
-0.4696657956,
-0.3325043619,
-0.7885802388,
0.6486997604,
-0.1219937056,
0.2921600044,
0.3410213888,
0.3459399939,
0.4428241253,
0.4884139895,
-0.683796227,
-0.2508815825,
-0.0196425188,
-0.2004583478,
-0.1070421338,
-0.1161768585,
-0.0400743596,
-0.2109720856,
0.5793659687,
-0.2435031235,
-0.2620218396,
-0.2867428958,
0.1798111498,
-0.2141233236,
0.3207409084,
0.0422956198,
0.8190283775,
-0.0957667679,
0.1721382588,
-0.4805141389,
-0.3419579566,
0.0968235284,
0.0478210859,
-0.7404604554,
-0.2633884549,
-0.0257620756,
0.8490995765,
0.0529448688,
-0.45750314,
0.3419137299,
0.0133172376,
-0.0062109833,
-0.1775474846,
0.0838467106,
0.1200534105,
0.377597332,
0.4533938468,
-0.0437065437,
-0.1021834612,
-0.5041339993,
0.0876067206,
0.5786656737,
-0.2268546671,
-0.4063693285,
0.9781293273,
0.3749746978,
-0.0747651458,
0.5150552988,
0.2171801925,
-0.1070717946,
0.2307890207,
0.3307585716,
0.9486992359,
-0.1968925595,
0.5475599766,
-0.0964493826,
-0.0116976909,
0.1439896077,
-0.0779819712,
0.0179160759,
-1.058983922,
-0.368714571,
-0.4823467135,
-0.7170831561,
0.3343215883,
-0.784773767,
0.0395797081,
-0.6970542669,
-0.261685133,
0.5106797218,
-0.1082738638,
-0.6156113148,
0.243969515,
0.2269329876,
0.692375958,
-0.8167768121,
0.8028771281,
0.8995841146,
-0.1312511861,
-0.5909053683,
0.3413864672,
0.2949024439,
-0.5578095913,
0.6281064749,
0.0425497293,
-0.1773555875,
-0.2408656776,
-0.7718117237,
-0.6026750803,
0.8089537621,
0.498775661,
-0.6172617674,
0.008641189,
0.1873365194,
0.5333445072,
-0.8057472706,
-0.1958512515,
0.4836516082,
0.5300079584,
0.4547311664,
-0.7482172251,
-0.2732737064,
-0.1477047056,
0.059406314,
-0.2251955718,
-0.7507331371,
0.6894022822,
-0.0491865091,
0.2501384318,
-0.1326260716,
0.690100193,
0.544534564,
0.3576138318,
0.64180547,
0.1733695418,
0.8283025026,
0.0687422231,
1.0801627636,
-0.257717669,
-0.1514693797,
1.2607780695,
-0.8323973417,
0.5982807279,
0.5737298131,
-0.1602556258,
0.7343540192,
0.4171847999,
0.1203676015,
0.704349637,
0.0516742095,
-0.3470260203,
-0.5633126497,
-0.3196310699,
0.1351807863,
0.5963214636,
0.1814582795,
-0.5398951173,
0.1017392576,
0.2359774411,
0.1813320965,
0.6479945183,
-0.4733301997,
0.7437832952,
0.0092884731,
-0.8642134666,
-0.1329319179,
0.0672244206,
0.8014137745,
-0.5408951044,
0.3695785999,
-0.24247244,
0.273003608,
-0.2611078918,
-0.9113420248,
0.1659262478,
0.2878875732,
-0.4911210239,
-0.6884925365,
0.8666554689,
-0.2999191284,
-0.617051959,
0.1501474082,
0.9632151127,
-0.002575479,
-0.150834173,
-0.4130082428,
0.0877274498,
0.3715249002,
-0.3761872053,
0.370546937,
0.0972489193,
-0.2186397165,
1.0556714535,
0.3782859147,
0.1823700815,
-0.1483325064,
0.3392803073,
1.0252383947,
-0.444781065,
-0.6534409523,
-0.8703123331,
0.5026389956,
-0.1213275343,
-0.0303924177,
0.9393868446,
0.6908236146,
0.8474036455,
-0.1014244184,
1.1015222073,
-0.0375654362,
0.9070902467,
-0.2383627146,
0.7067851424,
-0.2084209919,
0.4254092872,
-0.4909924865,
-0.9207859039,
-0.2188343406,
0.685254097,
-0.7737932801,
0.3051163256,
0.0249377098,
0.6408980489,
0.2877686024,
-0.0554453246,
0.2384726107,
0.2185370773,
0.6369248629,
0.652307272,
0.8100352287,
0.4602203965,
0.1403080374,
-0.181330204,
-0.2964080572,
0.1121508107,
-0.6971757412,
-1.1364088058,
-0.3683938682,
-0.4732757509,
-0.2472929507,
-0.2933671772,
0.9362980723,
0.9585383534,
-0.8651493192,
-0.2067050189,
-0.0182274785,
0.1909897178,
0.3945370018,
-0.2485070229,
0.0004742543,
0.2656328678,
-1.1194177866,
0.3812332749,
0.3797419965,
-0.1930851787,
-0.990270257,
0.0068006376,
0.1662019342,
0.1251566708,
0.6307865977,
-0.0147277992,
-0.7109143138,
-0.2298418134,
0.0183406714,
-0.1542979926,
0.0525466539,
0.8398447633,
-1.0566031933,
0.4062194526,
0.2356997281,
0.3334496021,
0.3461231589,
0.3438046277,
0.8184709549,
-0.6195020676,
0.2284399867,
0.4127234221,
0.2523086667,
0.6978664398,
-0.4296408594,
0.20536834,
0.1778585911,
-0.3395702243,
-0.4219872952,
0.5888414383,
-1.1547923088,
-0.1060938314,
1.4167202711,
0.0488518886,
0.2037101835,
-0.1325021386,
-0.3793566823,
-0.2013614029,
-0.6117179394,
0.6569989324,
0.5092674494,
-0.3033016622,
-0.270927161,
-0.3927103281,
0.1533584297,
0.2390528321,
-0.9626706839,
0.1259809285,
1.074660182,
0.2941409647,
0.0090160267,
0.7429175377,
-0.1988439411,
-0.4687070847,
-0.3628593087,
-0.2862981558,
0.2933984399,
-0.3809762895,
-0.1670977473,
0.5213822126,
0.0507966764,
0.0436476432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04902v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04902v2
|
Beyond Size: How Gradients Shape Pruning Decisions in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-08T18:59:54 | 2024-04-08T22:42:49 |
Rocktim Jyoti Das, Mingjie Sun, Liqun Ma, Zhiqiang Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) with billions of parameters are prime targets
for network pruning, removing some model weights without hurting performance.
Prior approaches such as magnitude pruning, SparseGPT, and Wanda, either
concentrated solely on weights or integrated weights with activations for
sparsity. However, they overlooked the informative gradients derived from
pretrained LLMs. In this paper, we present a novel sparsity-centric pruning
method for pretrained LLMs, termed Gradient-based Language Model Pruner
(GBLM-Pruner). GBLM-Pruner leverages the first-order term of the Taylor
expansion, operating in a training-free manner by harnessing properly
normalized gradients from a few calibration samples to determine the pruning
metric, and substantially outperforms competitive counterparts like SparseGPT
and Wanda in multiple benchmarks. Intriguingly, by incorporating gradients,
unstructured pruning with our method tends to reveal some structural patterns,
which mirrors the geometric interdependence inherent in the LLMs' parameter
structure. Additionally, GBLM-Pruner functions without any subsequent
retraining or weight updates to maintain its simplicity as other counterparts.
Extensive evaluations on LLaMA-1 and LLaMA-2 across various benchmarks show
that GBLM-Pruner surpasses magnitude pruning, Wanda and SparseGPT by
significant margins. We further extend our approach on Vision Transformer. Our
code and models are available at https://github.com/VILA-Lab/GBLM-Pruner.
|
[
-0.5141083598,
-0.5350931287,
0.2551743388,
0.2055559307,
-0.4198537171,
-0.0493189953,
-0.4672301114,
-0.0713583678,
0.2522414327,
0.3427573144,
-0.8118428588,
-0.3127308488,
-0.5988942981,
-0.138168633,
-0.3595345616,
1.2542306185,
0.2528216243,
0.0304518025,
0.1197043732,
-0.260631144,
-0.3228910267,
-0.6186950207,
-0.6851209402,
-0.4047836363,
0.8490102887,
0.0536084622,
0.6562980413,
0.619402945,
0.5051963925,
0.3273593783,
-0.4606316686,
0.1078354865,
-0.7784504294,
-0.0602204539,
0.1985622793,
-0.572888732,
-0.172874257,
0.0439223908,
0.9565912485,
0.8529884815,
-0.4329782724,
0.2520202994,
0.3020789027,
0.8699852228,
-0.4092875421,
-0.1413265318,
-0.7432069182,
0.2045277655,
-0.3192129433,
-0.1844164729,
-0.096087344,
-0.2652663887,
-0.0775099546,
-0.4433466196,
0.4691675305,
0.0477064736,
0.9561188221,
0.3988482356,
-0.184608072,
0.19165802,
-0.7383892536,
0.9423323274,
-0.4081352353,
0.5061650276,
0.0612516031,
0.3507004976,
-0.0138967037,
-0.6494335532,
-0.3205265701,
-0.2761396468,
-0.0701088384,
-0.1569597423,
-0.1118992791,
0.2614123523,
0.3674102724,
0.4227391183,
-0.4741769135,
0.2373503298,
-0.4627706707,
-0.141448006,
0.4014191926,
-0.119282715,
0.0792667642,
0.1097130552,
-0.2639917135,
-0.0810229033,
-1.1176928282,
-0.0444852859,
0.4582689106,
0.1559574455,
0.3825052083,
0.6447664499,
0.2176397741,
0.8274402618,
-0.0620472915,
-0.0134015568,
0.1126324683,
-0.1171298325,
-0.4021250904,
-0.2509791255,
0.6827340126,
0.3287766576,
0.5573400855,
-0.3930173218,
-0.3700661361,
-0.0947219878,
0.1031102464,
-0.8911575675,
-0.3105273247,
-0.0586446561,
-0.5895740986,
-0.1713865399,
-0.0269208197,
-0.6411285996,
-0.4256067574,
-0.3742035925,
0.1214497611,
-0.1732936502,
-0.2516301274,
0.0836287141,
0.0016928423,
0.2615504265,
0.3289162815,
-0.7066460848,
0.3938362896,
0.908485949,
1.0793663263,
-0.0400212146,
-0.2486566901,
-0.6350421309,
-0.1858348846,
-0.3172472715,
0.2944495082,
-0.4551570117,
-0.2783191502,
-0.1667521149,
0.067537643,
-0.1540658325,
-0.6530908346,
0.462395072,
-0.620354712,
0.0404731743,
-0.1959907115,
-0.2569434941,
-0.3008529842,
0.3485109806,
-0.6767754555,
0.983006537,
0.1311999261,
-0.6752973795,
0.3714167774,
-0.3281088471,
-0.4824213982,
0.0127476715,
-0.093493551,
-0.5348651409,
0.3350804448,
0.0084261429,
0.530110836,
-0.5884006619,
0.5824865103,
-0.3360700309,
-0.3862640262,
-0.0314122438,
-0.4477717578,
0.8376045823,
-0.078587167,
-0.0899391249,
0.2669314146,
-0.630503118,
-0.0485772938,
0.1970931888,
-0.2650254071,
-0.2557358146,
0.0091543049,
0.0236848351,
0.3139548302,
0.0382329039,
-0.6149290204,
0.1546946913,
-0.4329024553,
0.7687661648,
0.825530827,
-0.1957860142,
0.5621055365,
-0.3051831126,
0.6700863242,
-0.3574543297,
0.3290047944,
0.1222278401,
-0.2611304522,
-0.9396234155,
-0.4214349091,
0.3392160833,
0.3878388107,
-0.35374102,
0.5448120236,
-0.5249740481,
-0.5409066677,
-0.3913321197,
0.2597749531,
0.4017984271,
0.3707969487,
0.3364432454,
-0.3879644573,
-0.4153794348,
-0.8115651608,
-0.2366687804,
-0.003016908,
-0.339404881,
0.3416351974,
0.2761702538,
-0.0570450686,
1.0050494671,
-0.5351858735,
-0.4434786737,
-0.3780615032,
-0.0543002486,
0.3668489158,
0.514803946,
0.5029947758,
-0.6326650977,
-0.2204601914,
0.1083840653,
-0.1738492996,
-0.1424885839,
-0.2032314241,
0.1086722165,
-0.257766217,
0.4065166712,
-0.8180243969,
0.3083072007,
0.5939199924,
-0.0470430516,
0.6406933069,
-0.136187166,
-0.3928757906,
-0.6571282744,
0.1423799098,
0.4297085106,
-0.2012297511,
-0.6851677299,
-0.0849012882,
-0.1558030695,
-0.0605775565,
-0.1465690136,
0.5903633237,
-0.6890015006,
-0.3688625991,
0.1001071706,
-0.0118312892,
0.0776686147,
0.7589353919,
0.0124966716,
0.8105985522,
0.3899310231,
-0.5401901007,
0.1021324918,
-0.0185529236,
-0.4445628226,
-0.0155438744,
-0.94847399,
-0.0164508037,
-0.3591223955,
0.2416888177,
-0.7899660468,
0.4331205487,
0.0885317698,
-0.1976658851,
0.4594866633,
-0.4753974676,
-0.3838581145,
-0.3571796715,
-0.4491935968,
0.2533228099,
0.550444603,
-0.4877365232,
0.5563821793,
0.4009273648,
-0.4059356749,
-0.5939021707,
-0.7841304541,
0.006802483,
-0.5194755197,
-0.6088232994,
0.3706519306,
-0.1422159821,
-0.2047510594,
-0.3588783443,
-0.2540772259,
-0.1629433632,
0.2023562491,
0.137901336,
0.3516397178,
-0.1872092634,
-0.0063129668,
-0.2017381787,
-0.006732041,
0.1009295061,
-0.3821080029,
0.8077200055,
-0.1285599768,
-0.4473763406,
-0.2118578106,
-0.0266339015,
0.4839035273,
-0.4601774514,
0.7503606677,
0.6927553415,
0.1159787178,
-0.4800995886,
-0.6166262031,
-0.3398531079,
-0.5081402063,
0.5950627327,
-0.1361158788,
-1.2027022839,
0.4409835935,
-0.2891472876,
0.1928093284,
0.1100818217,
0.2780594528,
0.2016037405,
0.8246328235,
0.6982682347,
-0.2890869379,
0.8569379449,
-0.3564957678,
0.3852279484,
-1.1147474051,
-0.1056065261,
-0.6670414805,
-0.4356596768,
-0.3196258545,
-0.6476290226,
0.1199708208,
0.2958273292,
-0.3099203706,
0.1734192222,
-0.5217016339,
0.6127326488,
0.3830690384,
-0.1441470087,
-0.0572187863,
0.3070136309,
0.0833508447,
-0.078970097,
-0.821698904,
-0.2791202366,
0.8795707822,
0.5602580905,
0.4769606292,
-0.0002229972,
0.3865562379,
-0.0853460431,
0.6843376756,
-0.9675261974,
0.6435210705,
-0.1254509836,
-0.3114800155,
-0.5826373696,
-0.7054800391,
-0.9395678043,
0.6833851933,
0.0223507006,
-0.726408422,
0.2426441312,
0.2368023247,
-0.2734104693,
0.3614996374,
-0.5878649354,
0.5407060385,
-0.2061466724,
-0.2721149623,
-0.1513458341,
-0.567399919,
0.3786226511,
-0.1109119579,
0.179323107,
0.0224886723,
-0.181994617,
0.8069040179,
-0.6296334863,
0.761854887,
-0.2941018343,
-0.1053468734,
0.1061368659,
0.3436879814,
0.6648168564,
-0.1375907511,
-0.0086022997,
0.4027425647,
-0.5333881974,
-0.0887515619,
-0.6581296921,
0.5937026143,
-0.5726861954,
-0.7577625513,
0.0651093647,
-0.2757676244,
-0.3661011755,
0.209204331,
0.0406985618,
0.5808929801,
-0.0757158101,
0.4637349844,
0.5786471963,
-0.1525456309,
0.4332495034,
0.3230798244,
-0.1774653494,
-0.3400659859,
1.0906444788,
0.2691511214,
0.1984384209,
0.4080566168,
0.2539826632,
-0.159318015,
-0.9132152796,
-0.1837727427,
0.4643200934,
-0.4598294199,
-0.1502566785,
-0.3660064042,
-0.3708099127,
0.0020381436,
-0.1053143963,
-0.1833542287,
-0.4697455466,
-0.2120997757,
-0.1693928391,
0.0493941344,
0.6354299784,
0.1574278772,
0.703743875,
-0.8399477005,
-0.1257862002,
0.2325594872,
0.4273037612,
0.2790204287,
-0.5175008178,
-0.0015485714,
-0.1650950164,
-0.0393552147,
-0.4549629986,
0.6815958023,
0.2817353308,
0.4120277464,
0.5457764268,
-0.4537324607,
0.7382345796,
-0.7418817282,
0.5797896981,
0.5264627337,
-0.6571860313,
0.0735687986,
-0.2807991207,
0.039412383,
0.4380173385,
0.1435352415,
-0.6492211819,
0.0437683128,
-0.3742260635,
-0.8275868893,
0.5406064987,
0.1840954274,
-0.0162045341,
0.1407323033,
0.2744481564,
-0.1300606728,
0.3207846284,
-0.8062288761,
-0.2623203099,
-0.0293669682,
-0.0642329976,
-0.4433190525,
-0.3997709453,
-0.2710018158,
-0.2828344405,
0.470410049,
-0.0201320387,
-0.0924589932,
0.0378631204,
-0.1922220588,
0.1638328582,
0.1367020458,
0.3262317479,
0.4399534464,
0.0652180612,
-0.2532757521,
0.0115438644,
-0.6076700091,
0.0507398397,
0.1093073338,
-0.2700177729,
-0.0826667994,
0.3916931152,
0.8500442505,
0.0978515223,
-0.5001670122,
0.7108180523,
-0.2339837998,
-0.2811997533,
0.0470026955,
-0.0926853493,
-0.1535879225,
0.0403796099,
0.3183122873,
0.2842057049,
0.0002758001,
0.0434330367,
-0.0978375152,
0.7480792999,
-0.5579816103,
-0.3651898503,
0.2577262819,
0.3115470111,
-0.2291085124,
0.6053826809,
0.1603291631,
-0.5358748436,
0.66681844,
0.3315877616,
0.8182714581,
-0.099209398,
0.3022384942,
0.2254749686,
0.6785613894,
-0.2078850716,
-0.1629096121,
-0.3275149465,
-0.7659111023,
-0.7276046276,
-0.7957654595,
0.1625954658,
0.0866806805,
-0.4633539915,
-0.0282857791,
-0.8647995591,
-0.1522257477,
-0.265968889,
0.1132950038,
-0.4731676877,
0.2207989842,
-0.0214068834,
0.9836429358,
-0.7271165848,
0.8550255299,
0.4672711194,
-0.0649605989,
-0.9064919949,
-0.0442237966,
-0.0438090488,
-0.8591910005,
0.6048194766,
0.2638995051,
-0.2669935226,
0.1760634482,
-0.3359889686,
-0.9711649418,
1.051543355,
0.5674530268,
-1.0789767504,
-0.0882253125,
-0.0991235226,
0.2186744064,
0.0366238281,
0.1816363037,
0.4871602356,
0.4464947879,
0.256708771,
-0.7937429547,
-0.0779178962,
-0.2105248123,
0.2414287627,
0.6089215875,
-0.8262425065,
0.966227591,
-0.1529244632,
-0.3582888544,
0.0207012128,
0.5134425759,
0.2204179168,
-0.3037655056,
0.7240677476,
0.5303803086,
0.9078702927,
-0.0790342987,
0.9057825208,
-0.3391907811,
0.3577010334,
0.9570798278,
-0.2679202259,
0.4355133176,
0.6790100336,
-0.2943431735,
0.2432172447,
0.5561935902,
-0.0270513222,
0.3097540736,
0.5584560633,
-0.0563512295,
-0.1548515409,
-0.1591036469,
-0.29648,
-0.0388140716,
0.3295327127,
-0.162667498,
-0.1023448408,
-0.1890112311,
0.1984070837,
-0.2887715399,
-0.5901730061,
0.519293189,
0.1328257918,
-0.6522595286,
0.5551794171,
0.0142655065,
0.8450607061,
-0.8461096287,
0.1252765507,
-0.3250784278,
0.2843127549,
-0.1911839545,
-0.5939560533,
0.1770549864,
-0.2167296857,
0.0622965135,
-0.4070497751,
0.7060508728,
-0.3447008133,
-0.3469260633,
0.4243268669,
0.3174905479,
-0.1334820688,
-0.2073572278,
-0.6372826099,
0.1810729355,
0.1359465271,
-0.6435964704,
0.5093202591,
0.4873337448,
-0.0539057739,
1.0387215614,
0.8249576092,
0.5797397494,
0.0628427565,
0.3488083184,
1.1507315636,
-0.3995149732,
-0.3402212262,
-0.8236703873,
0.2692030668,
-0.1736440063,
-0.4347501099,
0.8058639765,
0.4077754915,
0.6566885114,
0.1469644457,
0.3983944058,
0.2159215361,
0.2187786549,
-0.4075440466,
0.5298238993,
-0.5464330912,
0.3454819322,
-0.0759941116,
-1.1024516821,
-0.4898569286,
0.7154111862,
-0.5214982629,
0.2791151702,
0.524545908,
1.0403767824,
0.012317135,
-0.1362140179,
0.245259434,
0.1825429052,
0.3034097552,
0.1982008964,
0.5971271992,
0.1989488006,
0.641505003,
-0.0255862959,
-0.3157771528,
0.0497349836,
-0.7702003717,
-0.9381415844,
-0.2772350311,
-0.0352077596,
-0.128656581,
-0.0565770864,
0.6660378575,
0.9597921968,
-0.4631293118,
-0.2433463931,
-0.3934217393,
0.0378716663,
-0.0345533825,
-0.2125935555,
0.2553680539,
-0.0685275719,
-0.3105975389,
0.2993282676,
0.2747229934,
0.0296843052,
-0.5382815003,
-0.1392406374,
0.0330372229,
-0.0837963969,
0.5208391547,
0.3225720525,
-0.6181482077,
0.1347224265,
-0.337721467,
0.198871851,
-0.0050872904,
1.0495840311,
-0.724783361,
-0.1914554536,
0.262439996,
0.7021167874,
0.4347934723,
0.1027090773,
0.6846005917,
-0.8347651958,
0.3849316537,
0.3539403677,
0.5165754557,
0.4886518717,
-0.1542161703,
0.4093945324,
0.1592398733,
-0.5053946972,
-0.8860225081,
0.3007923365,
-0.5082978606,
-0.3056212068,
1.2655258179,
-0.1257238239,
-0.4887238741,
0.1939078271,
-0.3392595947,
-0.1464936733,
-0.2276293635,
0.4284676611,
0.5201592445,
0.4231770337,
-0.3592632413,
-0.2902114987,
0.5610936284,
0.5240042806,
-0.3436033428,
0.3093996048,
0.5405359864,
0.2358876765,
-0.0839464664,
0.5782409906,
0.0371346921,
-0.1986480653,
-0.3000907898,
-0.0531476848,
-0.1336205602,
-0.5946683288,
-0.6045717001,
0.3207001984,
0.108269304,
0.0190238785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04900v1
|
How Abstract Is Linguistic Generalization in Large Language Models? Experiments with Argument Structure
| 2023-11-08T18:58:43 | 2023-11-08T18:58:43 |
Michael Wilson, Jackson Petty, Robert Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models are typically evaluated on their success at predicting the
distribution of specific words in specific contexts. Yet linguistic knowledge
also encodes relationships between contexts, allowing inferences between word
distributions. We investigate the degree to which pre-trained Transformer-based
large language models (LLMs) represent such relationships, focusing on the
domain of argument structure. We find that LLMs perform well in generalizing
the distribution of a novel noun argument between related contexts that were
seen during pre-training (e.g., the active object and passive subject of the
verb spray), succeeding by making use of the semantically-organized structure
of the embedding space for word embeddings. However, LLMs fail at
generalizations between related contexts that have not been observed during
pre-training, but which instantiate more abstract, but well-attested structural
generalizations (e.g., between the active object and passive subject of an
arbitrary verb). Instead, in this case, LLMs show a bias to generalize based on
linear order. This finding points to a limitation with current models and
points to a reason for which their training is data-intensive.s reported here
are available at https://github.com/clay-lab/structural-alternations.
|
[
-0.1723989099,
-0.9266116023,
0.7490931749,
0.145537287,
-0.2541314363,
-0.2216701806,
-0.3816578686,
-0.3402109444,
0.0043348069,
0.2112394422,
-0.1121480539,
-0.5526350141,
-0.8274914026,
0.0498544946,
-0.5112456679,
1.0952925682,
-0.1667398065,
0.1732190251,
-0.1848220527,
-0.3357218802,
-0.1477537304,
-0.7840277553,
-0.2714159787,
-0.5468853116,
0.6961465478,
-0.1048229486,
0.8964505792,
0.6711544394,
0.0987815633,
0.4516468942,
-0.1844895184,
-0.2559937239,
-0.2422361076,
0.1347495466,
-0.3380672038,
-0.6126637459,
-0.3277336061,
0.0937740207,
0.7522691488,
1.249566555,
0.059889134,
-0.0692900121,
-0.1788361222,
0.3683290184,
-0.7498685718,
0.1026896238,
-0.8067997098,
0.0114564719,
-0.040164154,
0.0419243574,
-0.4255463183,
0.0661835074,
0.5691365004,
-0.3220925033,
0.3326785862,
-0.1506957859,
0.9587320685,
-0.060742341,
-0.4667123258,
-0.3293565512,
-0.9251189232,
0.7163487077,
-0.627481997,
0.185102433,
0.2744306028,
0.2470588535,
-0.1261575818,
-0.8774883151,
-0.3021253049,
-0.1098173708,
-0.1426509768,
-0.1891892701,
-0.3329793215,
0.3756287098,
0.1515809894,
0.3975382745,
-0.3659085333,
0.2610399425,
-0.3264411688,
0.1327970624,
0.4713003635,
-0.0650084987,
0.2639335394,
0.0877602398,
-0.1510400772,
-0.0735218748,
-0.7500711679,
0.0169554092,
0.3013132811,
0.2490895987,
-0.1879144162,
0.6845383048,
0.1149766818,
0.6684552431,
0.1198265851,
0.2989933789,
0.3175251484,
-0.0820284784,
-0.358850956,
-0.1250653863,
0.8566609025,
0.0005332253,
0.4673778117,
-0.2215554714,
-0.2947362959,
0.2639267743,
0.2714750767,
-0.673093915,
-0.3052945435,
0.1376385987,
-0.3671278656,
-0.1323154867,
0.0920633823,
-0.3593879342,
-0.0456659235,
-0.2013337463,
0.2593694627,
-0.0189769063,
-0.2989021838,
0.263199389,
-0.0807608441,
0.3960517645,
0.1307519227,
-1.0639503002,
0.4762423933,
0.6509674191,
0.711199522,
-0.262049377,
-0.2950603068,
-0.2908846438,
0.2818597555,
-0.5381615162,
1.0265033245,
-1.0891894102,
-0.2452118844,
0.2576629519,
0.1494657546,
-0.1785766333,
-0.6853237152,
0.3983577788,
-0.6384282112,
0.1053835452,
0.1681545824,
-0.6881875992,
-0.0380544402,
0.1249899194,
-0.4200868607,
0.5968310833,
-0.0750751048,
-0.5280977488,
0.4964348376,
-0.5608798265,
-0.367264688,
-0.0991287529,
-0.5989935398,
-0.3153115809,
0.4283834696,
0.1051844358,
0.6526245475,
-0.105305098,
0.3724550307,
-0.4074290991,
-0.2300202996,
0.2722365856,
-0.2277264744,
0.2048413903,
-0.0412329994,
-0.4752461016,
0.3772119582,
-0.4281564355,
-0.0722864717,
0.1999647915,
-0.3825643361,
-0.5565946102,
0.243913725,
-0.2628992498,
0.0521708839,
-0.1028090268,
-0.4335717261,
0.2959807217,
-0.7101780772,
0.4250768423,
0.674490571,
-0.2290817499,
0.7955086231,
0.1533589512,
0.5265593529,
0.245269686,
-0.2376774549,
-0.2021169662,
-0.3548012972,
-0.5556941628,
-0.0449383669,
0.3253597617,
0.1099234372,
-0.2143042833,
0.2992369235,
-0.5164676905,
-0.2204496711,
-0.022182988,
-0.0343807675,
0.4016212225,
-0.0192034692,
0.2164563388,
0.012541079,
-0.4795287549,
-1.2530943155,
-0.2635234594,
-0.0705189928,
-0.1774366498,
0.1476694345,
0.5124487281,
-0.408000797,
0.9125072956,
-0.536035955,
0.0747336969,
-0.5233411193,
0.1582678854,
0.2976188362,
0.2357505262,
0.7138944268,
-0.7966138124,
-0.2115526348,
0.0201065075,
-0.5514966249,
-0.0196640566,
0.1232508272,
-0.0298847519,
0.1085705087,
0.5957918167,
-0.5659938455,
0.2986277044,
0.7223902941,
-0.2732307315,
0.5466804504,
-0.2209665626,
-0.46249488,
-1.1031538248,
-0.1455184966,
0.0729043931,
-0.1696241498,
-0.8055025339,
-0.0224956758,
-0.2910631001,
0.0134623917,
-0.266302228,
0.4996982813,
-0.5474113226,
-0.0626016781,
-0.5241080523,
0.0085203666,
-0.2173123658,
0.4463819265,
0.2896233797,
0.4183946848,
0.5545248985,
-0.7312765121,
0.0878785402,
-0.0543926395,
-0.2587306201,
0.1625784338,
-1.0639574528,
0.04894327,
-0.3084860146,
0.4010229111,
-1.0773915052,
-0.2285244614,
0.05171353,
-0.1118373424,
0.2895474732,
-0.378703475,
-0.2550695539,
-0.0588717759,
-0.0810284317,
0.7166880965,
0.2766031921,
-0.3595723212,
0.6841026545,
0.4789807796,
-0.1469973028,
-0.5559552312,
-0.716163516,
-0.0734949186,
-0.1474684626,
-0.5402082801,
0.4292461574,
0.1942552328,
-0.505764544,
0.1228232682,
-0.2034531683,
-0.2288837284,
-0.0971211419,
0.2941757441,
0.0002600514,
-0.4774702489,
0.3786052465,
0.040263284,
0.13994506,
0.3379076421,
-0.2652013302,
0.668954432,
-0.2676840425,
-0.3618979454,
0.1024509221,
0.3191486895,
0.3994864821,
0.1780388653,
0.8290514946,
0.0930568576,
-0.2289378792,
-0.3810268044,
-0.409401983,
-0.1238105893,
-0.4669152498,
0.6334891319,
-0.5884400606,
-0.8503599167,
0.4011688232,
-0.2440168411,
0.4366226494,
0.5301874876,
0.5803694129,
0.0273017157,
0.9730986953,
0.3871124387,
0.0001359588,
0.4495073855,
-0.4449015558,
0.1604912877,
-0.6733363271,
0.0021366565,
-0.4308123589,
-0.3997740149,
-0.4437829554,
-0.4555404186,
-0.027094122,
0.108710818,
-0.2755412161,
0.1543509811,
-0.2236189097,
0.5955273509,
0.0147006782,
-0.3950138688,
0.0910440087,
0.2418573201,
-0.2404064685,
0.0508608744,
-0.6117684841,
-0.7142496109,
1.0404326916,
0.5621845126,
0.7643377185,
0.0222178251,
0.5616239309,
0.0481030382,
0.5806205273,
-1.0694286823,
0.4294216633,
-0.2717472315,
-0.5719431043,
-0.2422559112,
-0.370274812,
-1.4601808786,
0.7034486532,
0.0121138655,
-0.445466578,
0.2757487297,
0.1487731636,
0.0940441042,
0.3917958736,
-0.6522625685,
0.7891471386,
0.0846561044,
-0.1398892254,
-0.1169520095,
-0.4147009552,
0.3958355784,
0.0434417948,
0.3763146102,
0.0813157633,
-0.025333859,
0.7946639061,
-0.4918307662,
0.7821820378,
-0.1809457242,
-0.4532834888,
0.2274249047,
-0.0581686124,
0.4329220355,
-0.1807439029,
0.1558144391,
0.03723263,
-0.2022763789,
-0.4210185111,
-0.8263916969,
0.3970454931,
-0.8109785318,
-0.8326637745,
-0.356957376,
-0.5097056627,
-0.3169761002,
-0.0436014235,
0.3458370268,
0.6385652423,
-0.1661075503,
0.3730758727,
0.6124747992,
-0.1259759665,
0.4144911766,
0.3407455981,
-0.2337048501,
-0.2592707574,
0.5272010565,
0.0992894471,
0.4732908905,
0.3647936285,
0.521078229,
-0.2867427468,
-0.6750888228,
-0.2616599798,
0.3467507362,
-0.8848530054,
0.2171873897,
-0.835660398,
-0.2709512413,
-0.2478364259,
-0.1849049628,
-0.4710012078,
-0.3931937516,
0.1059495211,
-0.310077101,
-0.0758218318,
1.0963420868,
0.3774644136,
0.3579492569,
-0.5945009589,
0.2210821807,
0.32709378,
0.2211805731,
0.1299397498,
-0.776535213,
-0.1906640977,
0.046945598,
-0.1870692819,
-0.7806645632,
0.0540853702,
0.3406106234,
0.6645050049,
0.5807880759,
-0.2049595267,
0.5329392552,
-0.8017148376,
0.8302843571,
0.1724484414,
-0.7240552306,
0.3489085734,
-0.39865008,
0.4332518876,
0.2047628462,
0.3365001976,
-0.2792290747,
-0.5960358977,
-0.5274285078,
-0.9747495055,
0.5139691234,
0.0228324439,
0.6674529314,
-0.2425058484,
0.3482572436,
-0.0631490052,
0.0390572175,
-1.1803507805,
-0.3634989858,
-0.1304140836,
-0.0480216779,
-0.1131391153,
-0.3939821124,
-0.1722702086,
-0.2754663825,
0.2439473569,
-0.1051248088,
0.2224592865,
0.0579505935,
-0.3676286638,
0.0929374993,
0.5837073326,
0.8365446329,
0.7947166562,
0.0827174261,
0.4522563517,
0.0216882676,
-0.4272255898,
0.4340472221,
-0.0432535224,
0.0972922146,
0.316195339,
0.6662044525,
0.9277482629,
0.6182822585,
-0.4347186387,
0.6447466612,
0.0910404623,
-0.4493823946,
-0.2823953032,
-0.1475181133,
0.2862359881,
0.1435189694,
0.4360681474,
-0.1545558572,
-0.0551647134,
-0.7020003796,
-0.0749585107,
0.5682739615,
-0.094751738,
-0.7037786245,
0.4130129516,
0.0169433393,
0.0219767224,
0.2159050554,
0.0570933148,
-0.4889364839,
0.4529935718,
0.6594267488,
1.024220109,
-0.2345704138,
0.0640929341,
0.2070976049,
0.0878736153,
-0.1028807983,
0.0320171826,
0.0443183519,
-0.967268765,
-0.5716267228,
-0.7014793158,
-0.0562096275,
0.312631309,
-0.3861802816,
0.0862469152,
-0.5221161246,
-0.1908992231,
0.1500690579,
-0.4521237314,
-0.4431273043,
0.0102797067,
0.1242668331,
0.6099215746,
-1.0492641926,
0.7591343522,
1.105530858,
-0.0835013017,
-0.7511099577,
0.0803173184,
-0.4184082448,
-0.502364397,
1.1130475998,
0.1718967706,
-0.2501607835,
-0.3796927333,
-0.5544189215,
-0.8468646407,
0.5705791712,
0.3998671472,
-0.5584810972,
-0.1809893996,
0.2721949518,
0.7235939503,
-0.6345878839,
0.0964733288,
0.2968711555,
0.2282846868,
0.1899957806,
-0.7076540589,
-0.0335174166,
-0.2544535697,
0.270445317,
0.1940555722,
-0.094265528,
0.9397484064,
-0.1084292158,
-0.3654569685,
-0.2559147775,
0.82962358,
0.1942200065,
0.005863199,
0.6262372732,
0.4220706522,
0.2471594959,
0.0497379042,
1.1116673946,
-0.0167301055,
0.0448202863,
1.2625464201,
-0.1193673983,
0.8348357677,
0.5092181563,
-0.2822398841,
0.9237254262,
0.4335639775,
0.0410026163,
0.3715373278,
0.5526143909,
-0.2156555504,
-0.1388807446,
0.1456882507,
-0.3281680644,
0.3190309107,
0.4918676615,
-0.6458728313,
-0.3875608444,
-0.1516365558,
-0.0342768021,
0.0648940578,
-0.2665076852,
0.8948153257,
0.2190246135,
-0.5452792048,
0.800996542,
0.0652579144,
0.6516857147,
-0.7525621653,
0.076441519,
-0.0142426407,
0.1476863176,
-0.2570278347,
-0.5940666199,
0.3383362293,
-0.0048893322,
-0.3295452893,
-0.0214776285,
0.3791750073,
-0.52062428,
-0.3736050725,
0.3492007554,
0.3683774173,
0.2484784424,
0.096219793,
-0.3192231953,
0.0603276044,
-0.485419333,
-0.6477772593,
0.3689873219,
0.4657011032,
-0.2154127061,
0.3795185685,
0.3658677936,
0.2301186025,
0.3344549537,
0.3799889386,
0.909166038,
-0.2972109616,
-0.2541023195,
-1.1669359207,
0.3836781085,
0.0583600067,
-0.141606465,
0.5488458276,
0.4794938266,
0.7391700745,
-0.299957335,
0.6408836246,
0.205652833,
-0.0405665115,
-0.4087072313,
0.2416593879,
-0.3545098007,
0.1986477077,
-0.3804168105,
-1.3087381124,
-0.38623631,
0.6309788823,
-0.7229494452,
0.1499043554,
0.7353928089,
0.5373644233,
-0.3592830002,
-0.2091850042,
0.4039008915,
0.2942736149,
0.4533877671,
0.327637583,
0.9398719072,
-0.262406677,
0.4616395235,
0.1523587406,
-0.1657911986,
0.0349372663,
-0.6384670138,
-0.9810965061,
-0.4447403252,
-0.2110608369,
-0.1649962366,
-0.0804664344,
1.0301738977,
0.741556406,
-0.9120744467,
-0.480012089,
-0.3113856912,
-0.0986040086,
0.0761744827,
-0.2105986178,
0.4237318337,
-0.6026968956,
-0.8210021853,
0.3493886888,
0.06893491,
0.0984660089,
-0.2524567842,
0.0320275463,
-0.2735669017,
0.1518360674,
0.7782530785,
0.1435662508,
-0.9302066565,
-0.3165666163,
-0.2942587435,
0.0080082845,
0.1119240969,
1.0234808922,
-0.5980408788,
0.1707648039,
0.4136046767,
0.7037881017,
0.3462025523,
-0.0512664206,
1.0427311659,
-0.8923322558,
0.3340087235,
0.1284459829,
0.656060636,
0.1807079166,
0.035380736,
0.2612161338,
0.1400004625,
-0.3878208101,
-0.7809001207,
0.5342186093,
-0.5099838972,
-0.5823556185,
1.3640060425,
-0.342846632,
-0.2476891428,
-0.1500954032,
0.062902391,
-0.0293188132,
-0.0795338526,
0.5559083223,
0.823563993,
0.0094176941,
-0.1072678491,
-0.2689377964,
0.4985374808,
0.5632187724,
-0.5801105499,
0.2218694091,
0.4596946239,
0.4420494735,
0.3091495037,
0.3299915195,
-0.2305799723,
-0.0078740893,
-0.2486001849,
-0.1911757588,
0.1834971011,
-0.275385499,
-0.5731424093,
0.2738005221,
0.1853894144,
-0.0873687863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04954v1
|
Prompt Sketching for Large Language Models
| 2023-11-08T18:57:23 | 2023-11-08T18:57:23 |
Luca Beurer-Kellner, Mark Niklas Müller, Marc Fischer, Martin Vechev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many recent prompting strategies for large language models (LLMs) query the
model multiple times sequentially -- first to produce intermediate results and
then the final answer. However, using these methods, both decoder and model are
unaware of potential follow-up prompts, leading to disconnected and undesirably
wordy intermediate responses. In this work, we address this issue by proposing
prompt sketching, a new prompting paradigm in which an LLM does not only
respond by completing a prompt, but by predicting values for multiple variables
in a template. This way, sketching grants users more control over the
generation process, e.g., by providing a reasoning framework via intermediate
instructions, leading to better overall results. The key idea enabling
sketching with existing, autoregressive models is to adapt the decoding
procedure to also score follow-up instructions during text generation, thus
optimizing overall template likelihood in inference. Our experiments show that
in a zero-shot setting, prompt sketching outperforms existing, sequential
prompting schemes such as direct asking or chain-of-thought on 7 out of 8 LLM
benchmarking tasks, including state tracking, arithmetic reasoning, and general
question answering. To facilitate future use, we release a number of generic,
yet effective sketches applicable to many tasks, and an open source library
called dclib, powering our sketch-aware decoders.
|
[
-0.3236280978,
-0.7845783234,
0.8880458474,
0.5347036719,
-0.3224610388,
0.0545134284,
-0.0437115915,
-0.1066883132,
0.3060879409,
0.4886962771,
-0.8015046716,
-0.4194034338,
-0.1793800145,
0.226832211,
-0.2723195553,
0.6029788256,
-0.0599092282,
-0.2096156776,
-0.0817673132,
0.1679260582,
-0.7772008181,
-0.2490130514,
-1.1758440733,
-0.1474748254,
1.1421073675,
0.3389208019,
0.5157604218,
0.6526284218,
-0.2563153505,
0.2166053504,
-0.105359681,
0.0737023726,
-0.1616117209,
0.4505525827,
-0.0319788642,
-0.5872101188,
-0.3480674624,
0.0677316487,
0.464758724,
0.7114682794,
-0.0620329678,
-0.0446835347,
-0.1112964526,
0.585898757,
-0.361971736,
0.2127813995,
-0.5332039595,
-0.0696516186,
-0.1657385677,
-0.2965388,
-0.7296973467,
-0.352370739,
-0.1255806684,
-0.4723356962,
0.301448375,
0.0166677441,
0.2598366737,
0.0600689799,
-0.086564146,
-0.2964837849,
-0.1638896763,
0.3021214008,
-0.6642792225,
-0.0010922325,
0.1592045426,
0.3967272341,
-0.3309544921,
-0.7390731573,
-0.791598618,
-0.4045747519,
0.0885739028,
0.1031061634,
0.128278017,
0.105324693,
0.585386157,
-0.0765294433,
-0.4653274119,
0.2520591021,
0.0692000687,
-0.1466517448,
0.457935214,
0.335558027,
0.3976042867,
-0.1921335459,
-0.1292394698,
-0.2139494419,
-1.0387480259,
0.3155806363,
0.5640999675,
0.52444309,
-0.1681010574,
0.5431596041,
-0.2485789061,
0.8615280986,
0.2901694477,
0.3075010777,
-0.1028900295,
-0.1478711218,
0.0363402441,
-0.1283597201,
0.710889101,
0.312690109,
0.1918074042,
0.3208107352,
-0.2738236487,
-0.3547942936,
-0.1025325209,
-0.6791241765,
-0.6349410415,
0.2211658359,
-0.3632991016,
-0.2569400668,
-0.2935794294,
-0.8774456978,
-0.6883760095,
-0.2529417574,
0.2007155567,
-0.1611406654,
-0.1598512977,
0.0693902895,
-0.2383990586,
0.1483482867,
0.9740204811,
-0.9663847685,
0.008125715,
0.446952343,
1.0021486282,
-0.0796793476,
-0.0897633657,
-1.080342412,
0.0417604074,
-0.6696153879,
0.8948945403,
-0.483925432,
-0.5287974477,
-0.0137941521,
-0.0398642384,
-0.0678627416,
-0.30031991,
0.2733160555,
-0.4030926824,
0.1691171676,
-0.6414438486,
-0.4601323605,
0.1083741114,
0.1541620195,
-0.8489907384,
1.0536191463,
-0.0894445106,
-0.791126132,
0.24746117,
-0.4057001472,
-0.120710358,
0.3587008715,
-0.4965019524,
0.0557330027,
0.2204664946,
0.5353588462,
0.7300974727,
-0.3082864583,
0.3199035227,
-0.4170944095,
-0.2523908019,
0.1059092358,
-0.4758330286,
0.8453200459,
0.1319461912,
-0.2006555945,
0.3111472726,
-0.628834784,
0.0149688162,
0.1897487193,
-0.2540591657,
-0.1012240872,
-0.2454791069,
-0.1843202859,
0.2327499986,
-0.0937358662,
-0.3869513869,
0.4248884022,
-0.2633631825,
0.24497886,
0.9632869363,
0.1073508412,
0.0680656955,
-0.6104077697,
0.709310174,
-0.2374747396,
-0.5077698231,
-1.1225966215,
-0.61512357,
-0.8224500418,
-0.2562380433,
-0.0269489568,
0.3954589963,
-0.8811821342,
0.2776879668,
0.1190381795,
-0.4090721905,
-0.3078252375,
-0.0116940364,
0.2503844798,
0.5264374018,
0.2136697769,
0.0644341409,
-0.1723459661,
-0.474557966,
-0.2547949851,
-0.2677131891,
-0.1780002713,
0.1489049643,
0.2226436734,
0.4074003696,
0.8020338416,
-0.4181733131,
0.324195981,
-0.6670312285,
0.3897527158,
0.3801579475,
0.445895344,
0.5734015107,
-0.3949982822,
-0.8276844025,
-0.2290010154,
-0.4725844264,
-0.4773995876,
-0.5522239208,
0.1186775193,
0.1649323404,
0.8980468512,
-0.8704677224,
0.3372112513,
0.2762933969,
-0.2233774662,
0.9547702074,
-0.2152710706,
-0.0257155485,
-1.0339854956,
0.337983191,
-0.2408593595,
-0.2071646452,
-0.5655106902,
-0.049769558,
0.0187243912,
-0.3201871812,
-0.2169832587,
1.1199771166,
-0.6066003442,
0.2206278443,
-0.4436024129,
-0.0179697759,
0.1798647195,
0.377961874,
0.217653662,
0.9400388598,
0.6207472086,
-0.4521755874,
0.4532041848,
-0.0414158776,
-0.273691833,
0.2500279248,
-0.878765583,
0.3553996086,
-0.2888275981,
0.5639505982,
-1.4018549919,
-0.2427660972,
0.1784970909,
-0.4598330855,
0.4497413337,
-0.1901588887,
-0.5447238684,
-0.518940568,
-0.4615395367,
0.1207269877,
0.4150170088,
-0.7526162863,
0.4814176857,
-0.1857528985,
-0.651406765,
-0.5787562132,
-0.1238454655,
0.2619399428,
-0.1067279577,
-0.4456156194,
-0.0364454351,
-0.4476611018,
-0.067924656,
-0.3032664955,
0.0503771603,
0.1756932884,
-0.0286898781,
0.0467704609,
0.3055358827,
-0.0394549333,
0.0512301065,
0.1796388775,
-0.269590348,
0.2147154361,
-0.263289094,
0.7636501193,
0.4266830087,
-0.4735347331,
-0.5384970903,
0.3792870939,
0.2999415994,
0.0318144187,
0.3952874541,
0.4283272326,
-0.1357718855,
-0.4059513807,
-0.6555457115,
-0.0834024325,
-0.5337963104,
0.0031760773,
-0.6230806112,
-0.6532364488,
0.6474286318,
-0.1876602918,
0.2430692017,
0.1128202528,
0.6532054543,
-0.1766124219,
1.1407113075,
0.6828830838,
0.0951623619,
0.5314176083,
-0.0600673407,
0.0222124364,
-0.6789088845,
-0.1719693989,
-0.5786597133,
0.0621493123,
-0.1970897764,
-0.5675230622,
0.0986286551,
0.129237175,
0.0465313271,
0.0522990078,
-0.1530908197,
0.7228703499,
0.5846414566,
-0.1448940486,
0.0526624024,
-0.093807824,
-0.6376152039,
0.076997824,
-0.6754707098,
-0.4670280814,
0.8306413293,
0.1113347784,
0.8699858785,
-0.3904550374,
0.691628933,
0.1199079975,
0.1677932143,
-0.6675807834,
0.7645304203,
0.1092498377,
-0.3088469505,
-0.3404863477,
-0.2940395474,
-0.7085168958,
0.1659252048,
0.1048175171,
-0.8492289782,
0.0435516573,
0.4159084857,
-0.5121990442,
0.322385639,
-0.4054166675,
0.6748824716,
0.1015385538,
-0.4385919273,
-0.0181819666,
-0.6000955105,
0.1973065883,
0.0961328819,
0.0127691533,
-0.2609885931,
0.0740598589,
0.4976297319,
-0.3966790438,
1.1531550884,
-0.3673655093,
-0.2560382783,
0.4031070173,
0.3131278753,
0.6572303772,
0.1618131846,
-0.188826412,
-0.3707730174,
-0.2203177959,
-0.2586574554,
-0.7138536572,
0.7821569443,
-0.2692602873,
-0.7879733443,
-0.2160915434,
-0.6181010604,
-0.0948971063,
0.3928245306,
0.3631863296,
0.7254462838,
0.002018926,
-0.2447277755,
0.6522840858,
-0.5401653051,
0.6654787064,
0.2701547742,
-0.3268016279,
-0.2794626355,
0.655354023,
-0.1544651687,
0.2685654759,
0.3082739413,
0.3443292677,
-0.5056132674,
-0.5448086262,
-0.7447285652,
0.431253612,
-0.9120063782,
-0.0764429718,
-0.7434696555,
0.0297808554,
-0.4106216729,
-0.5578086972,
-0.1030923128,
-0.5615657568,
-0.2430559546,
-0.1097465679,
0.2267301679,
0.7705275416,
-0.0460890718,
0.3105146885,
-0.5690068007,
0.2867245972,
0.4223151505,
0.2331023067,
0.3932819366,
-0.2924646735,
0.0638033301,
-0.2084281445,
-0.1234600618,
-0.7250750661,
0.29053846,
-0.1726469249,
0.5874277949,
0.2928322554,
0.1633516252,
0.6674073339,
-0.762999773,
0.867100358,
0.4566987157,
-0.8317976594,
0.5679898262,
-0.6044104099,
0.5732915401,
0.3666555882,
0.3230783641,
-0.7843346,
-0.5757913589,
-0.2369440496,
-0.6876878738,
0.609931767,
-0.2221197933,
0.4812232852,
-0.3102559149,
0.5766069889,
0.3293153346,
0.2522157729,
-0.5986610055,
-0.0997060165,
-0.0909348205,
-0.1711378247,
-0.0258865003,
-0.3386023939,
0.033185821,
-0.1976810843,
0.3521676362,
-0.4288908839,
0.2053683847,
0.0498479716,
0.1812417507,
-0.2127773911,
0.0478455238,
0.459484607,
0.6761600375,
0.0076734372,
0.1674801409,
-0.0232725386,
-0.2608417571,
0.2350173891,
0.1105746031,
-0.2764851153,
0.2032615542,
0.4559209943,
0.8991349936,
-0.1387879997,
-0.7495120168,
0.4972272217,
-0.152660206,
-0.1284727454,
-0.2401425391,
0.1872417331,
0.269777745,
0.1730110794,
0.4278035164,
-0.2566069961,
0.0088283308,
-0.284545362,
0.0405314229,
0.4079985023,
-0.1871463805,
-0.5156747699,
0.7558199167,
0.1806565672,
-0.2508115172,
0.6217107773,
-0.1461179852,
-0.3287197351,
0.6838293672,
0.645614326,
0.9053587914,
-0.217350319,
0.3429361284,
0.5345829129,
0.0107459258,
-0.1922196448,
0.4710073471,
-0.1669342816,
-0.3278887868,
-0.6277295351,
-0.2857357264,
-0.5749788284,
0.2073999345,
-0.5299098492,
0.5722021461,
-0.574418664,
0.1140448228,
0.001397072,
-0.0760941654,
-0.5466279984,
-0.0437311307,
0.2388450652,
1.306411624,
-0.6616670489,
0.7511911988,
0.6472554207,
-0.2587087154,
-0.8863930702,
0.0937918425,
0.1781166047,
-0.7587751746,
0.7678911686,
0.7697064877,
-0.2028695345,
0.1708153188,
-0.7163798213,
-0.5489174128,
0.8375469446,
0.4449731708,
-0.4883164465,
-0.2295111269,
-0.3191392124,
0.30161044,
-0.4224817157,
0.4341059625,
0.2414853871,
0.275706023,
0.5028810501,
-0.730401516,
0.4155081511,
-0.3748511076,
-0.0133871976,
0.0397402942,
-0.4358889461,
1.1399053335,
-0.5410523415,
-0.3425831795,
0.4465669394,
0.4862612486,
0.4452985525,
0.3065835834,
0.5027301908,
0.3006158173,
0.7444595098,
0.1714850664,
0.9660133123,
-0.2113421261,
-0.1696106046,
1.2793029547,
-0.3872466087,
0.6637180448,
0.3423610032,
0.1022364944,
0.5337198973,
0.640032649,
0.1836660653,
0.35095191,
0.2941766381,
-0.3760620058,
-0.2903706431,
-0.0251843315,
-0.2259442508,
-0.0258756373,
0.353731811,
-0.0297677312,
-0.3847230077,
-0.0942767411,
0.0659761876,
0.0470098443,
-0.1468957514,
0.7818071246,
0.0949159116,
-0.6806750298,
0.4876466393,
-0.2553612888,
0.3165986538,
-0.6262997389,
-0.4551565349,
-0.4859963357,
-0.2914767563,
0.3237410784,
-0.8638245463,
-0.089283444,
0.0309308618,
-0.0256256536,
-0.4073072374,
0.4879894853,
-0.4062381089,
-0.2416388094,
0.1589534581,
0.6162363291,
0.1364006102,
0.0463769957,
-0.6838753819,
0.1535727382,
-0.2082476169,
-0.4401060641,
0.2329158336,
0.6748880148,
-0.1245074272,
0.9492416978,
0.8041554689,
0.2540301681,
0.0559885539,
0.2666106522,
1.1164208651,
-0.7331901789,
-0.8092201352,
-0.8742032647,
0.4711239636,
-0.1472079903,
-0.0622532293,
0.7085582614,
0.207182914,
0.6216235161,
-0.0663338527,
0.8744783998,
0.0065436363,
0.6373538375,
-0.8429037333,
0.5530435443,
-0.2719451785,
0.2941391468,
-0.2085532099,
-0.8367881179,
-0.256708324,
0.527287066,
-0.0461074412,
0.0184746813,
0.637575984,
0.6255303025,
0.1131538004,
-0.0877929181,
0.2502011657,
-0.0157354921,
0.6746869683,
0.3169273138,
1.0122629404,
0.24632819,
0.2258940935,
-0.1080732644,
-0.0976031721,
-0.1710599661,
-1.1924364567,
-1.2893006802,
-0.4939536154,
-0.0646983609,
-0.0778701752,
-0.1451741159,
1.0118676424,
0.4393137395,
-0.6123426557,
-0.3508241177,
-0.3209079504,
0.0100449203,
-0.0897685438,
-0.194961518,
0.4453994334,
-0.7463681102,
-0.6964349151,
0.44781968,
0.2265565842,
0.3109181523,
-0.3104601502,
0.0584344082,
-0.1193834469,
0.198746562,
0.3779872358,
0.3028659821,
-0.7162890434,
-0.2185797542,
0.0481448285,
0.1078169942,
-0.1593960524,
1.1990076303,
-0.8504900932,
0.7614365816,
0.5742515922,
0.5510057807,
0.338339299,
-0.0320780799,
0.7883796692,
-0.7285445929,
0.2302511781,
0.1305493116,
0.3626774549,
0.3778232038,
-0.3602000475,
0.1482207924,
0.1420566142,
-0.3063362539,
-0.802077949,
0.3410356939,
-0.7603060007,
-0.328361243,
0.8150032163,
-0.3441376686,
-0.1243972257,
-0.1479007304,
-0.5700279474,
0.082243897,
-0.5940870047,
0.6593719721,
0.7197515965,
-0.3169189394,
-0.5586455464,
-0.6437271237,
0.5369882584,
0.2880666852,
-0.7115907073,
0.6388942003,
0.6702868342,
0.2381514907,
-0.111621201,
1.2249052525,
0.2856759429,
0.4075540602,
0.1256853342,
-0.1668154895,
-0.2771426439,
-0.6758000255,
-0.5530232787,
-0.123761721,
0.2804629505,
0.2059914619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04897v1
|
Future Lens: Anticipating Subsequent Tokens from a Single Hidden State
| 2023-11-08T18:56:35 | 2023-11-08T18:56:35 |
Koyena Pal, Jiuding Sun, Andrew Yuan, Byron C. Wallace, David Bau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We conjecture that hidden state vectors corresponding to individual input
tokens encode information sufficient to accurately predict several tokens
ahead. More concretely, in this paper we ask: Given a hidden (internal)
representation of a single token at position $t$ in an input, can we reliably
anticipate the tokens that will appear at positions $\geq t + 2$? To test this,
we measure linear approximation and causal intervention methods in GPT-J-6B to
evaluate the degree to which individual hidden states in the network contain
signal rich enough to predict future hidden states and, ultimately, token
outputs. We find that, at some layers, we can approximate a model's output with
more than 48% accuracy with respect to its prediction of subsequent tokens
through a single hidden state. Finally we present a "Future Lens" visualization
that uses these methods to create a new view of transformer states.
|
[
-0.3180705905,
-0.3902420402,
0.855802536,
-0.0075725233,
-0.1427939534,
0.1252695471,
0.2381755263,
-0.3629110456,
0.5175688267,
0.3281703889,
-0.9655525088,
-0.2173087001,
-0.7391348481,
-0.1993787736,
-0.8433089256,
0.4141591191,
0.0992236808,
0.1429134458,
0.2026413083,
0.4225598276,
-0.7639970183,
-0.4021807015,
-0.5357618332,
-0.4897400737,
0.730004251,
0.1613074839,
0.5290572047,
0.2064024061,
0.7275440693,
0.3475710154,
-0.087943092,
-0.1862348169,
-0.4321581423,
-0.0048107817,
-0.2434880733,
-0.6220221519,
-0.1000049934,
0.2678658366,
1.0426098108,
0.5870824456,
0.4025222659,
0.2103249133,
-0.059983775,
0.1730190217,
-0.4667089581,
0.2120392025,
-0.6490265131,
0.4629478753,
-0.1560484469,
-0.1785156876,
-0.7808181047,
-0.1685812771,
0.0889217481,
-0.7500632405,
0.2782773972,
0.0238585267,
0.8300046921,
0.2871181965,
-0.5090821981,
0.2248341292,
-0.8795335889,
0.5407726169,
-0.4475055039,
0.305333823,
0.0848371163,
0.5897557139,
-0.3515963256,
-1.1734269857,
-0.492844969,
-0.065785028,
-0.1719411463,
0.5412101746,
-0.2247945517,
0.1379837841,
0.2727150023,
0.0353219472,
-0.0543189384,
0.0032081439,
-0.5172348619,
-0.2239563316,
0.2736091018,
0.365024209,
-0.1202993318,
-0.2092883736,
-0.6967546344,
-0.2003991306,
-0.5541490316,
0.0445317887,
0.3938313723,
0.0912030414,
0.0563148037,
0.6449806094,
0.1055738032,
0.3615244329,
0.2394915968,
0.2200937569,
0.155034095,
-0.4862572551,
-0.356870681,
-0.1875802428,
0.532969594,
0.3024326265,
-0.1688023955,
-0.1701951772,
-0.2041095346,
0.3388301432,
0.5783798099,
-0.4379020035,
-0.1632879674,
0.1592767835,
-0.5953153968,
-0.5572582483,
0.3880683184,
-0.8740076423,
-0.4483383298,
-0.100921534,
0.6927457452,
-0.062997289,
-0.3121470511,
-0.1280200183,
-0.5046144128,
0.2876242101,
0.2818252742,
-0.6535137892,
0.370106101,
0.717413187,
0.8370686173,
-0.2076942176,
-0.4741716683,
-0.3811939359,
0.2271696925,
-0.7425729632,
0.8043466806,
-0.7723866105,
-0.568685174,
0.0241077989,
0.2498393655,
-0.1219659448,
-0.2003555745,
0.3637378216,
-0.8100539446,
-0.0635979772,
-0.462339282,
-0.4959706664,
-0.2746001184,
-0.0459931195,
-0.918176651,
0.6596083045,
-0.0971594453,
-0.6390676498,
0.7263615131,
-0.9716264606,
-0.0769644901,
-0.1628290415,
-0.0846329704,
-0.3625045419,
0.4722784758,
0.3986530304,
0.3300984204,
0.3719055355,
0.2200923562,
-0.4931444526,
-0.7025771737,
0.3460196853,
-0.9785718322,
0.3809026778,
-0.1852058619,
-0.4589030445,
0.5166087747,
-0.5036007762,
-0.0558516681,
0.0085701793,
0.0561714657,
0.1245523617,
0.0918946862,
-0.0042529856,
0.0805351958,
0.1345888972,
-0.7067801952,
0.1698887944,
-0.3877959549,
0.3073532879,
1.4047510624,
0.1550278515,
0.6360254884,
0.2981544435,
0.689453721,
0.3953698874,
0.6100798249,
-0.48238042,
-0.8126369715,
-0.805000484,
0.2505078316,
0.1039366797,
0.2982112467,
-0.7003361583,
-0.0888978541,
-0.3546842337,
-0.3382656574,
-0.0194591731,
-0.6453704238,
0.2340825796,
0.5222945213,
0.3066200018,
-0.3397177756,
-0.3698660433,
-0.9384109378,
-0.3284572363,
-0.229331851,
0.1219284013,
-0.0567292087,
0.7478153706,
-0.0388973504,
0.9636662006,
-0.7295567393,
-0.1278664321,
-0.0332229435,
0.1897669286,
0.6377885342,
0.4704372585,
0.0914913863,
-0.9423375726,
-0.1277334541,
-0.0749926344,
-0.8287883997,
0.5624885559,
-0.0386971831,
-0.1110067517,
-0.2151192725,
0.6886643767,
-0.3904561698,
0.8212416172,
0.5199229717,
-0.5430442691,
0.3528142869,
-0.1367520243,
0.024592964,
-1.1088989973,
-0.0227900632,
-0.0846498534,
-0.2105563283,
-0.7633824944,
-0.1210488752,
0.2437312305,
-0.3728353679,
-0.4124342501,
0.5532547832,
-0.5041392446,
-0.3421886861,
-0.1292131394,
-0.1848660111,
-0.3639098704,
0.4772425592,
-0.2221885324,
0.9809949398,
0.5006588697,
-0.021528082,
0.2045331299,
0.0927396044,
-0.3755782843,
0.1436465979,
-0.5816664696,
0.0924256966,
-0.3488405049,
0.4473125339,
-0.7434967756,
-0.1762495786,
0.2870601118,
-0.4801410735,
0.4124328792,
-0.1939009279,
-0.1634862423,
-0.9329477549,
-0.0589792505,
0.2450933605,
0.2855204642,
-0.5287792683,
0.8787305355,
0.4036221504,
0.3302207291,
-1.0614093542,
-0.9190981984,
0.2305822521,
-0.1428724229,
-0.2624807358,
0.2120331228,
0.1949104369,
0.0435097031,
0.3032785356,
0.0934347734,
0.1174210384,
-0.061712265,
0.6500546932,
0.3486510813,
-0.1300708354,
-0.0082150819,
0.1723910123,
-0.5453563929,
0.1816610396,
-0.8740128875,
0.4295251369,
-0.4202336371,
-0.8244954348,
-0.4847390354,
0.5358383656,
0.460326612,
-0.1849880815,
0.428198427,
0.8976169825,
-0.6739758849,
0.2591121197,
-0.3840228617,
-0.3840272129,
-0.5583497882,
0.5568253994,
-0.5550040603,
-0.5122776031,
0.836404264,
0.0270464122,
-0.056853801,
0.6330854893,
0.4689264894,
0.0296472479,
1.0640546083,
0.7653048635,
-0.1333735436,
0.596624434,
-0.6177204847,
0.349178493,
-0.81932652,
-0.5778025389,
0.1688440591,
-0.6239722371,
-0.5311040878,
-0.5131372809,
0.6182940006,
0.0066738878,
-0.0973705351,
0.4658524096,
-0.3032583594,
0.6977074742,
1.0752557516,
0.3030745089,
0.04244918,
-0.1514681131,
-0.4267773926,
-0.0810865611,
-0.7586926818,
0.0636475831,
1.0904120207,
0.5031626821,
0.6324768662,
-0.2397063673,
0.6387585998,
0.1326123327,
0.567882061,
-0.499588877,
0.450535655,
-0.0327988043,
-0.7167041302,
-0.3839634955,
-0.0173117965,
-0.8872833252,
0.2488912642,
-0.2288153172,
-0.9839699864,
0.7137869596,
0.3126459718,
-0.3716455102,
0.4940322638,
-0.9179812074,
0.7355789542,
0.1214039624,
-0.2426147908,
-0.348216176,
-0.7911192179,
0.1455778927,
-0.0297172051,
-0.134394601,
0.0256997794,
-0.0644240305,
0.6040212512,
-0.2173217386,
0.994879961,
-0.4780082405,
0.3379772305,
0.2845119536,
-0.2363797277,
0.4525941014,
0.1788029969,
0.1500691473,
0.1405256689,
-0.2953629494,
-0.2843367159,
-0.6677346826,
0.4786277711,
-0.4026276469,
-0.7803964019,
-0.4153616726,
-0.4838323593,
-0.0500750132,
0.5300332904,
0.5360737443,
0.9525540471,
0.0789931715,
-0.2082320601,
0.2550415993,
-0.1442096382,
0.9923447371,
-0.0605035499,
-0.3407748342,
-0.4152838886,
0.7476564646,
0.109020561,
0.1645875424,
0.6490271091,
0.303592205,
-0.5413830876,
-0.5289489627,
-0.5668625832,
0.0512674935,
-1.0215221643,
-0.4237093627,
-0.297010392,
-0.1004927903,
-0.293386668,
-0.1417873204,
-0.498242408,
-0.3171426654,
-0.2778641284,
-0.3077208102,
-0.0158750098,
1.3242281675,
-0.2053347081,
0.3387660086,
-0.4401551187,
0.0006645895,
0.1949618459,
0.5059418082,
0.1247162446,
-0.1787922084,
-0.3976811767,
-0.2145525217,
-0.240538165,
-0.9716612697,
0.3047653735,
-0.0923424363,
0.5558483005,
0.5088436604,
-0.3684260845,
0.9694083929,
-0.9078394771,
1.0156481266,
0.6089810729,
-0.8605455756,
0.5769113898,
-0.2560197413,
0.4561001658,
0.2942897677,
0.0978896767,
-0.3695557415,
-0.5743353963,
-0.6225550771,
-0.5290104151,
0.5072185993,
-0.0158858113,
0.2866345942,
-0.0524976291,
0.1777880043,
-0.0565870143,
0.1206832305,
-0.676568985,
-0.4853565097,
-0.3306705952,
-0.0670602322,
-0.1617294997,
-0.2323978543,
0.0244657025,
-0.0792322382,
0.1631207168,
-0.1670735329,
1.1580637693,
0.2163950801,
0.3828136921,
-0.0660796687,
-0.1711009294,
0.6594891548,
0.8227226138,
-0.0079165706,
0.2332624644,
0.2605844736,
-0.7484954,
0.0126645751,
0.0411714762,
-0.2369139194,
0.3221692145,
0.3699955344,
0.8124723434,
0.2758595645,
0.0068659764,
0.9081766009,
-0.0726724789,
-0.0238107275,
-0.7683015466,
-0.3852317333,
0.0008380677,
0.7302663326,
0.7022625208,
0.5320699811,
0.2921797037,
-0.3633572459,
0.2642582953,
0.4675024152,
-0.7560073137,
-0.4912026227,
1.323287487,
0.0398027971,
-0.1119867116,
0.5534052849,
-0.1268910617,
-0.8053531051,
0.5568341613,
0.6352286339,
1.0008165836,
-0.1193657219,
0.1020002291,
0.2759042978,
0.4295175374,
-0.1102374345,
0.1343679875,
0.3374525905,
-0.6534940004,
-0.7013013363,
-0.3072000742,
-0.1270141155,
-0.0832929909,
-0.6984693408,
0.227675721,
-0.2094261348,
-0.5054295063,
-0.0917294621,
-0.1193145812,
-0.8230231404,
0.2920994461,
0.1113042384,
0.9934651256,
-0.923410356,
0.9432917237,
0.1022319347,
-0.3913405836,
-1.0377202034,
-0.0102304379,
-0.0721271932,
-1.0083173513,
0.6496490836,
0.2006611526,
-0.3587150276,
-0.0871589184,
-0.2998510301,
-1.17129004,
1.3012969494,
0.3918992877,
-0.3315823674,
-0.3776010275,
-0.001940211,
0.1391232312,
0.095711045,
0.3913635015,
0.3087689579,
0.5226621032,
-0.0003688159,
-0.5967423916,
-0.0698718056,
-0.3891830742,
0.1965577006,
0.3907443583,
-0.4957394302,
0.8349084258,
-0.3930493891,
-0.4752911329,
0.0245123282,
1.0790512562,
-0.4210497737,
0.3320370615,
0.548307538,
0.3537096381,
0.6530036926,
-0.2610457242,
1.2885643244,
-0.3065150082,
0.4679853022,
0.9523442984,
0.3224147558,
0.7446858883,
0.6706065536,
-0.0654653087,
0.4690139592,
0.5876684189,
-0.2709851861,
0.7925947309,
-0.1996352524,
-0.1000210717,
0.0159310475,
0.0318982676,
-0.3604113162,
0.3077775836,
0.2739823759,
-0.4764168262,
0.2833494246,
0.1984930933,
-0.1946463883,
-0.3399249613,
-0.5848932266,
0.3615178168,
0.1564486772,
-0.6039458513,
-0.0670822859,
-0.0960734338,
0.4739550948,
-0.4282184541,
-0.1354065835,
-0.2788306773,
0.3242936134,
-0.0240124222,
-0.9526102543,
0.2344488353,
-0.5332756042,
0.0339797884,
-0.3006233871,
0.9894216657,
-0.0928603709,
-1.0123966932,
0.2878748477,
0.1595217735,
-0.1116910875,
0.1041025221,
-0.2583631575,
-0.1786186397,
-0.2460921407,
-0.2803260982,
-0.0643978417,
-0.0041206717,
0.0102571752,
0.7332220674,
0.3628645241,
0.226092577,
0.6650148034,
0.1610714048,
0.8767912984,
-0.5896430016,
-0.6991154552,
-0.7143408656,
0.3384368718,
-0.2303417623,
-0.5166712999,
0.639639616,
0.3987294436,
1.0608513355,
-0.2674300373,
0.4594283402,
0.4240655005,
0.261911273,
-0.5191265345,
0.461845547,
-0.5848091245,
-0.1207193211,
-0.3955881298,
-0.6809954643,
-0.2768129706,
0.3069090545,
-0.3502473831,
-0.1190828606,
0.9652364254,
0.6907817721,
-0.0584669411,
0.2883716524,
0.4988259375,
0.0161653981,
0.2620921731,
0.4904714525,
0.9456133246,
-0.4803130329,
0.3951532841,
-0.2807573974,
-0.0726043433,
0.1658592224,
-0.645322144,
-0.5616207123,
-0.7574020624,
0.3325541019,
-0.1775504649,
0.009472603,
0.4761450589,
0.8733866215,
-0.6758190393,
0.0456627533,
-0.2703871727,
0.0167785026,
-0.4109012485,
-0.1293384433,
0.4685080051,
-0.0850786492,
-0.8544042706,
0.5587888956,
0.4485019147,
-0.0098048802,
-0.6295217872,
0.2823029459,
0.2403673828,
-0.1626433879,
0.5837609172,
-0.2956760228,
-0.8081382513,
-0.7893858552,
0.2827945054,
0.3419728875,
0.0177347995,
1.2047371864,
-1.0623873472,
0.6066598892,
0.1509708464,
0.4006792009,
0.9720932245,
-0.1118799746,
0.8542644978,
-0.4900803864,
0.2445629984,
0.1704475582,
0.3782457709,
-0.0621223226,
-0.3927054107,
0.3857681453,
0.232575804,
-0.3449791074,
-0.5931280851,
0.494348675,
-0.7719711661,
-0.1765288413,
0.7482402325,
-0.2271519899,
-0.3045102954,
0.053007178,
0.3598904908,
0.308445245,
-0.2397137284,
0.4764357805,
0.3553899527,
-0.1582260728,
-0.0852487758,
-0.674249351,
0.1175777465,
0.2607326508,
-0.539019227,
-0.3039848804,
0.1351182163,
-0.0635443777,
0.3346016705,
0.6386774182,
-0.2878343165,
0.084940277,
0.6168547273,
-0.7277494073,
-0.0270925947,
-0.708948493,
-0.3855085671,
0.2059136331,
-0.2832392752,
-0.5252780318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04892v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04892v2
|
Bias Runs Deep: Implicit Reasoning Biases in Persona-Assigned LLMs
| 2023-11-08T18:52:17 | 2024-01-27T08:49:29 |
Shashank Gupta, Vaishnavi Shrivastava, Ameet Deshpande, Ashwin Kalyan, Peter Clark, Ashish Sabharwal, Tushar Khot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent works have showcased the ability of LLMs to embody diverse personas in
their responses, exemplified by prompts like 'You are Yoda. Explain the Theory
of Relativity.' While this ability allows personalization of LLMs and enables
human behavior simulation, its effect on LLMs' capabilities remains unclear. To
fill this gap, we present the first extensive study of the unintended
side-effects of persona assignment on the ability of LLMs to perform basic
reasoning tasks. Our study covers 24 reasoning datasets, 4 LLMs, and 19 diverse
personas (e.g. an Asian person) spanning 5 socio-demographic groups. Our
experiments unveil that LLMs harbor deep rooted bias against various
socio-demographics underneath a veneer of fairness. While they overtly reject
stereotypes when explicitly asked ('Are Black people less skilled at
mathematics?'), they manifest stereotypical and erroneous presumptions when
asked to answer questions while adopting a persona. These can be observed as
abstentions in responses, e.g., 'As a Black person, I can't answer this
question as it requires math knowledge', and generally result in a substantial
performance drop. Our experiments with ChatGPT-3.5 show that this bias is
ubiquitous - 80% of our personas demonstrate bias; it is significant - some
datasets show performance drops of 70%+; and can be especially harmful for
certain groups - some personas suffer statistically significant drops on 80%+
of the datasets. Overall, all 4 LLMs exhibit this bias to varying extents, with
GPT-4-Turbo showing the least but still a problematic amount of bias (evident
in 42% of the personas). Further analysis shows that these persona-induced
errors can be hard-to-discern and hard-to-avoid. Our findings serve as a
cautionary tale that the practice of assigning personas to LLMs - a trend on
the rise - can surface their deep-rooted biases and have unforeseeable and
detrimental side-effects.
|
[
-0.4708170593,
-0.532258749,
0.9365478754,
0.2760832012,
-0.087481536,
0.1251742989,
0.1127371266,
-0.4237954617,
0.0651399717,
0.5216118097,
-0.8888690472,
-0.1510631889,
-0.727455914,
-0.1558337361,
0.0423544124,
1.0900725126,
0.3118068874,
0.4026750624,
-0.4471823275,
-0.1256844252,
-0.8051118255,
-0.6736975908,
-0.4459990859,
-0.5794656873,
0.5782499909,
0.3948904276,
0.5667765141,
0.3758643568,
0.3469783664,
0.1525995433,
0.102419287,
-0.1423525214,
-0.7036850452,
0.1675508618,
-0.4132494926,
-0.8259376884,
-0.3071051538,
0.1957719922,
0.2616823018,
1.0456103086,
0.2018552423,
0.3148258328,
-0.0436267555,
0.7743136287,
-0.7561418414,
0.0180634242,
-0.4227131307,
0.1361714005,
-0.3744189441,
-0.022171434,
-0.3572524488,
-0.5464055538,
0.3613807261,
-0.6174733639,
0.1317486465,
0.0894606933,
0.5589184165,
0.598051548,
-0.7343068123,
-0.1828244925,
-0.8814841509,
0.608093679,
-0.1579903364,
-0.0165958703,
0.2036648244,
0.3230955303,
-0.0432199314,
-0.3091971874,
-0.2519421875,
-0.0084762918,
-0.1829127371,
0.2724316418,
0.0119869653,
0.0619696938,
0.9425407648,
-0.0378900059,
-0.2127662003,
0.2375721484,
-0.4899540246,
-0.1948146075,
0.4286241531,
0.3563945591,
0.2088626176,
-0.0545878187,
-0.222941339,
0.3253757954,
-0.8754888773,
0.0502629243,
0.5945667028,
-0.0723423436,
0.103613317,
0.8590946198,
-0.0103654452,
0.0917909294,
0.4171879292,
0.0645050034,
-0.0149989696,
-0.0129772369,
-0.0916611329,
0.1849129796,
0.4249297976,
0.4312677085,
0.8232181072,
0.0831110701,
0.1801280826,
0.356657058,
0.3800894022,
-0.4499290884,
-0.094419919,
-0.0286160335,
-0.2590583563,
-0.0249580406,
-0.1405266523,
-0.9654252529,
-0.9609985352,
-0.3531228304,
0.2264061719,
-0.1740351617,
-0.057617791,
0.019112505,
-0.1158496141,
0.46293208,
0.5164241791,
-0.5514162779,
0.3585936129,
0.6917217374,
0.4443322718,
-0.3241479993,
-0.2135505825,
-0.3683221638,
0.1665261686,
-0.2221592069,
0.8121247888,
-0.4454573691,
-0.4762390256,
-0.2818771899,
-0.2794578373,
-0.1804113984,
-0.6121874452,
0.6198502779,
-0.1761923283,
0.2803514302,
-0.9035633206,
-0.5443465114,
0.311011225,
-0.1411835402,
-0.3411928713,
0.6708366871,
0.0475667939,
-0.7397809029,
0.5436884165,
-0.4542894065,
-0.4077604115,
-0.0660262033,
-0.4236758947,
-0.2367727757,
0.2329374701,
0.2658432126,
0.2776681781,
-0.4429208636,
0.0886249766,
-0.528285265,
-0.6872152686,
0.5065312386,
-0.163638413,
1.0768725872,
0.1586220115,
-0.7176730037,
-0.3294243515,
-0.3310367763,
-0.3386303782,
0.2028324604,
0.0709010065,
-0.4390545189,
-0.2211502343,
-0.4507680237,
0.3392441571,
0.0220675021,
-0.414455086,
0.2265677601,
-0.1247456372,
0.0231731366,
1.2119534016,
0.0102103865,
0.6809054613,
-0.4018663764,
0.7079856992,
0.1064210534,
0.0953216702,
-0.0013526398,
-0.6185582876,
-0.7286658883,
-0.2139906585,
-0.0623924322,
0.6671215296,
-0.3380940259,
0.1261893064,
-0.1969714612,
-0.2486714423,
-0.396001488,
0.0918812677,
0.5595303178,
0.8369475603,
0.0133254584,
-0.1606069356,
-0.2004768699,
-1.2123625278,
-0.5838704705,
-0.2179916501,
-0.2351641059,
0.664144516,
0.613946259,
-0.2784711123,
0.9100042582,
-0.7977187037,
-0.2566007376,
0.0015905874,
-0.0075450963,
-0.1278368682,
0.4327696264,
0.5748357773,
-0.4664483368,
-0.0508056916,
-0.6015120149,
-0.7365065813,
-0.6641657352,
-0.2734437883,
-0.493688345,
0.0727558061,
0.3013687432,
-0.7821876407,
0.4241181314,
-0.0062770294,
-0.6481047869,
0.6879168749,
0.1625660062,
-0.1674435139,
-0.6000950336,
-0.0045305816,
0.4616572857,
0.0334799737,
-0.3071912229,
-0.1837549657,
-0.2566225529,
0.1127236336,
-0.2582657933,
0.5511913896,
-0.3369068801,
-0.4908176959,
0.0041995114,
0.0254241452,
0.0806017593,
0.5062448978,
-0.0068165292,
0.8112134933,
0.4003529251,
-0.5806826949,
0.1908785254,
0.1238460317,
-0.3617213964,
1.2002876997,
-0.6398609281,
0.3354481459,
-0.4488184452,
0.4978833795,
-1.0192573071,
-0.24044092,
0.5157994628,
-0.331610918,
0.120037958,
-0.2506572902,
-0.3479477167,
-0.2517919838,
-0.0810897797,
0.356934309,
0.6134784222,
-0.3643746972,
0.6131224036,
0.5177335143,
-0.1091241986,
-0.5691158772,
-0.8662967086,
-0.1325434744,
-0.5654588342,
-0.4785076082,
0.1209040582,
-0.2315786034,
-0.6433421969,
-0.1818775386,
-0.2941628695,
-0.0820045248,
0.0791796893,
0.4521010816,
0.2410778701,
0.0399984941,
0.0283265281,
0.0354180522,
-0.0247820001,
0.624781251,
-0.0776181817,
0.3388669789,
-0.1863527298,
-0.6227511168,
-0.060724467,
0.2095316499,
0.5714962482,
0.0887006,
0.516633451,
0.3819162846,
-0.3088191748,
-0.0341314562,
-0.7660719752,
-0.2367361486,
-0.4298370779,
0.2017118633,
-0.2723759115,
-0.7505876422,
0.6661040783,
-0.1743981093,
-0.054039564,
0.2071785778,
0.5604790449,
-0.3437058032,
1.126843214,
0.24141258,
0.0629506633,
0.2453119904,
-0.1474066228,
0.0378550179,
-0.9298428893,
-0.6025564075,
-0.313042134,
-0.6492626071,
-0.7613722682,
-0.360769093,
0.1848863512,
-0.58077842,
-0.48849231,
-0.3874051571,
-0.394775629,
0.5581060052,
0.6045737863,
0.2196451426,
0.110309884,
-0.2790457606,
-0.0581600145,
-0.6100466847,
-0.4049804211,
-0.4381181598,
1.3194605112,
0.3617734611,
1.0716724396,
0.1155999973,
0.4479296803,
0.452606678,
0.3325327933,
-0.6148523092,
0.652382493,
0.1350003183,
-1.0952577591,
0.0000166672,
-0.4036343992,
-0.7593633533,
0.1466931999,
-0.0638481081,
-0.7866425514,
0.3950904608,
0.2125102431,
-0.3206652403,
-0.0470237993,
-0.9394879341,
0.6293932199,
-0.5682051182,
-0.8524374366,
0.1055705696,
-0.829505682,
0.9050842524,
-0.1511192173,
-0.0484791137,
-0.4999952912,
-0.1488496363,
0.6045511365,
-0.0990625098,
0.9413567185,
-0.4945092499,
-0.0240222681,
0.0153083056,
0.1438305527,
0.2999544442,
0.4558733702,
-0.0060781236,
0.0389685296,
-0.160385713,
-0.5711121559,
-0.8423483372,
0.8097500801,
-1.0022675991,
-0.8388057351,
-0.7141321898,
-0.385932833,
-0.4503616393,
0.0964582786,
0.4903599918,
0.0662616193,
-0.1641084254,
-0.1343939453,
1.0287289619,
-0.3296602964,
-0.3592413366,
0.4187673032,
-0.2071145177,
-0.0795486271,
0.5597115159,
0.2734030485,
0.1527763158,
-0.0756652877,
0.1513685882,
-0.295232147,
-0.2266410887,
-0.193638429,
0.4115474224,
-0.7622948289,
0.1565505564,
-0.5509443283,
0.0774230361,
-0.3487749696,
-0.2054980546,
-0.2919901609,
-0.4076400697,
-0.3831363916,
-0.1126753241,
-0.1657826751,
0.7064306736,
0.3026907444,
0.4157500863,
0.1406961828,
0.3611156046,
0.6376945376,
0.3008586168,
-0.2841226161,
-0.5649296045,
0.1391738057,
-0.0208844859,
-0.2720196247,
-0.9329314232,
-0.0183444489,
-0.1979800463,
0.7208645344,
0.4914234877,
0.0470830165,
0.6561565399,
-0.2691068053,
0.677814126,
-0.1104226187,
-0.7324542403,
0.5217793584,
-0.5616129041,
0.382137835,
0.6992719173,
0.343167901,
-0.3305262923,
-0.3049077392,
-0.516516149,
-0.5462540984,
0.7905784249,
0.009088669,
0.0593502373,
0.025152225,
0.7773045897,
0.1380512565,
0.316862911,
-0.9127964973,
-0.8516489267,
-0.1912376732,
0.1862032861,
0.1121821478,
-0.4225178659,
-0.0761886165,
-0.5416022539,
0.3240770996,
-0.1906478554,
0.5623627901,
-0.0018462158,
-0.1449676454,
-0.1397612095,
0.20908086,
0.6740478873,
0.7993314862,
-0.1751452088,
0.1258222163,
0.2354527414,
-0.3533052504,
0.3938163519,
0.1376821101,
-0.3238486648,
-0.3991554976,
0.0764876306,
0.542254746,
0.3508810401,
-0.5976374149,
0.5161114335,
-0.2117511183,
-0.1205673367,
-0.64942801,
0.1673819125,
0.0762510151,
0.0423930027,
0.4542517662,
0.1772259325,
0.0972585231,
-0.4865361154,
-0.1070475504,
0.5660622716,
-0.2012023777,
-0.3856609166,
0.8331701756,
0.3319393992,
-0.1169173643,
0.6635244489,
0.1479475945,
-0.3007754982,
0.7047620416,
0.4175521135,
0.8298584223,
-0.0947182477,
0.2804478705,
0.0381354019,
0.430770129,
0.046615351,
-0.0907206982,
0.2750605345,
-0.8011001945,
-0.349299103,
-0.3350683153,
-0.644043386,
0.2697670162,
-0.5109314919,
0.18673639,
-0.7470331192,
-0.3966617286,
-0.114299275,
0.2175115496,
-0.9483489394,
0.0076293652,
0.4484971762,
0.705524683,
-0.8731514215,
0.3445386887,
0.8242976069,
-0.1520291865,
-0.3784194589,
0.2284410745,
0.4782316089,
-0.8467077613,
0.8052612543,
0.1267594546,
0.0385129079,
-0.2838461101,
-0.4489685297,
-0.8076056838,
0.9672411084,
0.9595133662,
-0.3738474846,
-0.2434813529,
0.361605376,
0.5350079536,
-0.5009458065,
0.4605204463,
0.8383201361,
0.6340141296,
0.1516257524,
-0.5907096863,
0.0182236638,
-0.0549673885,
-0.2184644639,
-0.1589523554,
-0.8344939351,
0.8184700608,
-0.4618002176,
0.0537429638,
-0.3060975373,
0.3980901837,
0.5599072576,
0.6406760812,
0.3672498465,
0.3866212964,
0.9707977772,
-0.1027317196,
1.1523785591,
0.1170120686,
-0.3133715391,
1.1847605705,
-0.7146728039,
-0.1026985124,
0.5550815463,
-0.1304149181,
0.6653251648,
0.4873363674,
0.0754594132,
0.3621610701,
0.2488023043,
-0.211679697,
-0.2453231514,
-0.2001368999,
-0.2128518373,
0.3976922631,
0.5868799686,
-0.3358005881,
0.1183386445,
-0.1607486904,
0.2663607597,
0.1133828312,
-0.2345646918,
0.396813184,
0.2225750834,
-0.9143902659,
-0.1407150477,
-0.2535381615,
0.7344474792,
-0.5017583966,
0.2453408837,
-0.5017499924,
0.2148678154,
-0.2469473034,
-0.7510576844,
0.0565313287,
0.0329774246,
-0.1645854712,
-0.4406035841,
0.9671517611,
0.1301258951,
-0.4514020681,
0.2717945278,
0.9748909473,
-0.0050144056,
-0.0559954345,
-0.6812463999,
-0.200824827,
-0.0090449564,
-0.3153779805,
0.6516991258,
0.4344379604,
-0.0743710995,
0.8947251439,
0.4123045504,
0.2886165977,
0.3032547534,
0.073243551,
0.8162082434,
-0.6161480546,
-0.2545730174,
-0.9458329678,
0.3690362573,
-0.1550995111,
-0.3751966655,
1.0355583429,
0.5379992127,
0.6556345224,
0.0387130938,
0.8940671086,
0.280521214,
0.3533863723,
-0.2724656463,
0.4668476284,
-0.3055034578,
0.6630440354,
-0.5381295681,
-0.9171383977,
0.0991720259,
0.4365677536,
-0.8256885409,
0.5132908821,
0.497390002,
0.3460941911,
0.0609047823,
-0.1106578186,
0.0807377398,
0.0436523072,
0.4278470278,
0.7240664363,
0.9372372031,
0.1781550646,
0.4951618612,
-0.4285297692,
-0.2204198986,
-0.1788738519,
-0.7243769765,
-1.0960302353,
-0.0924761295,
-0.4151597917,
-0.2777002454,
0.0461710505,
0.6387726068,
0.440567106,
-0.3982208967,
-0.102583304,
0.1155302972,
0.5963739753,
0.1345821768,
-0.3142187595,
-0.0976278931,
0.0436509587,
-0.7684611082,
-0.1233292222,
0.0349663049,
-0.0059827645,
-0.4991750717,
-0.1202712953,
-0.0482688583,
0.1650384516,
0.4157431424,
0.307451129,
-0.6363177896,
-0.3326568007,
0.1180781424,
-0.261187762,
0.0175738242,
1.0405464172,
-1.0340412855,
0.1440849304,
0.2209589034,
0.4998879731,
0.3684670925,
0.1913091093,
0.67561239,
-0.7431867123,
-0.0571889393,
0.4398595095,
0.4050274193,
0.2481903881,
-0.6832464337,
0.5003113151,
0.5712049603,
-0.6559863687,
-0.8620988131,
0.2706878781,
-0.738355279,
-0.2589758635,
1.2049973011,
0.1417862624,
-0.0810918659,
-0.2359800935,
-0.291231066,
-0.0609737411,
-0.5591753721,
0.8286399841,
0.7916221023,
-0.5941699147,
-0.242429167,
-0.8010646105,
0.5818824172,
0.6894909143,
-0.7983608842,
0.0645678043,
0.8966779709,
0.495982796,
-0.0038431454,
0.7855782509,
0.0394244343,
0.3730944097,
-0.3264221251,
-0.3468637466,
-0.0778177306,
-0.0998466462,
-0.3561841846,
-0.0290787332,
0.0600619242,
0.2586302161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04886v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04886v2
|
SEMQA: Semi-Extractive Multi-Source Question Answering
| 2023-11-08T18:46:32 | 2024-06-30T18:53:22 |
Tal Schuster, Adam D. Lelkes, Haitian Sun, Jai Gupta, Jonathan Berant, William W. Cohen, Donald Metzler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recently proposed long-form question answering (QA) systems, supported by
large language models (LLMs), have shown promising capabilities. Yet,
attributing and verifying their generated abstractive answers can be difficult,
and automatically evaluating their accuracy remains an ongoing challenge.
In this work, we introduce a new QA task for answering multi-answer questions
by summarizing multiple diverse sources in a semi-extractive fashion.
Specifically, Semi-extractive Multi-source QA (SEMQA) requires models to output
a comprehensive answer, while mixing factual quoted spans -- copied verbatim
from given input sources -- and non-factual free-text connectors that glue
these spans together into a single cohesive passage. This setting bridges the
gap between the outputs of well-grounded but constrained extractive QA systems
and more fluent but harder to attribute fully abstractive answers.
Particularly, it enables a new mode for language models that leverages their
advanced language generation capabilities, while also producing fine in-line
attributions by-design that are easy to verify, interpret, and evaluate.
To study this task, we create the first dataset of this kind, QuoteSum, with
human-written semi-extractive answers to natural and generated questions, and
define text-based evaluation metrics. Experimenting with several LLMs in
various settings, we find this task to be surprisingly challenging,
demonstrating the importance of QuoteSum for developing and studying such
consolidation capabilities.
|
[
-0.3983088434,
-0.9081158638,
0.7179921865,
0.2131582648,
-0.3624269366,
0.3747956157,
0.0348937213,
-0.3470613658,
0.143009901,
0.4483015239,
-0.7020432949,
-0.2561529279,
-0.4405567944,
0.3063314259,
-0.3643192053,
0.9539596438,
-0.1648239344,
-0.0521613695,
-0.3522111177,
-0.2193429619,
-0.5300186276,
-0.6029751301,
-0.2622275651,
0.0931062698,
0.3925936222,
0.4719482362,
0.6091953516,
0.2748861909,
0.2114007175,
0.2881986499,
-0.1066861376,
0.4799063504,
-0.1812520176,
0.2104675323,
-0.1937641352,
-0.1711334437,
-0.2464244366,
-0.1196446493,
0.8197932839,
0.3922234476,
-0.1432421803,
0.6795043945,
0.0941696763,
0.2745685875,
-0.6061344743,
-0.0838037059,
-0.5080453157,
-0.2963554859,
-0.0113936216,
-0.1359995008,
-0.3285156786,
-0.6051219106,
0.0616055802,
-0.300457269,
-0.0799862966,
-0.2169762999,
0.8790259957,
0.1916641891,
-0.7711509466,
-0.4541026652,
-0.7465102673,
0.7727457285,
-0.7693485022,
0.0741700903,
-0.0099351974,
0.554140389,
0.1992714554,
-0.5841152668,
-0.4964302182,
0.0959137827,
-0.0226929002,
0.3041611016,
-0.0745532215,
-0.261271596,
-0.0589375831,
0.4001494348,
-0.3753559589,
-0.1715797484,
-0.5961142778,
-0.377186805,
0.5973951817,
0.2005762458,
0.5131062865,
-0.4214798808,
-0.4511323571,
0.1227406785,
-0.5870447755,
0.0592608787,
0.0490061454,
0.3888603151,
0.0260862298,
1.0209927559,
-0.2124545127,
0.3503043652,
-0.4219835997,
0.1702436954,
0.1207945049,
-0.7831525803,
-0.0652535334,
-0.1318960488,
0.6951184273,
0.1277486235,
-0.0436442532,
-0.126459077,
-0.1292359084,
-0.096505098,
0.2435628325,
-0.5917230248,
-0.0520052537,
0.4880123138,
-0.2223224938,
-0.2804866433,
-0.1045440882,
-0.8153845668,
-0.2028005719,
-0.256706655,
0.7132315636,
-0.1669760495,
-0.0270127431,
0.0467515476,
-0.2015008181,
0.4117798805,
0.3564259708,
-0.2123796791,
0.2130918056,
0.2577807903,
0.7391229272,
-0.1502851844,
-0.2440759838,
-0.8297456503,
0.2168425322,
-0.2203693688,
0.8426476717,
-0.2956198156,
-0.1162259281,
0.1544226706,
0.0519445203,
0.1001348123,
-0.4557800293,
0.6699078083,
-0.7034162283,
0.5660808086,
-0.4648250639,
-0.5300357938,
-0.1118133664,
0.3187640607,
-0.7856094837,
1.2131105661,
0.1003440022,
-0.6636635661,
-0.0950447991,
-0.5122341514,
-0.3672759831,
0.0220951159,
-0.1066039279,
-0.310425967,
0.1176600009,
0.3968669474,
0.456392318,
-0.4663254619,
0.2131733745,
-0.2267602086,
-0.0622897781,
0.4338230789,
-0.4096964598,
0.7502445579,
0.28897807,
-0.1657452285,
0.052239269,
-0.7568820715,
0.1936816722,
0.1204664409,
-0.5741381645,
-0.4042474627,
-0.0609523393,
-0.1139222905,
0.5596311688,
0.4528310001,
-0.5607223511,
-0.3110257089,
-0.1830641329,
0.3458268046,
0.7345712781,
0.3556248844,
0.3885168135,
-0.4362511933,
0.6576204896,
0.0525439717,
-0.0717605576,
-0.1777568609,
-0.1071078256,
-0.6758176088,
-0.5808327198,
0.2178934962,
0.5068684816,
-0.9433225393,
0.1979931593,
-0.2366646975,
-0.7298556566,
-0.4562629461,
0.4356205165,
0.4414221346,
0.2790430486,
0.5192313194,
0.0454329662,
-0.5095340014,
-0.9859163761,
-0.3525630832,
-0.1386061311,
-0.1298659444,
0.3129986227,
0.3946143389,
0.2016329765,
0.8908700943,
-0.6234967709,
0.078217268,
-0.2657950521,
0.2956802547,
0.033013951,
0.1543050259,
0.2071256787,
-0.5046238899,
-0.2685796022,
-0.3754669428,
-0.7882643938,
-0.2045880556,
-0.2257389128,
-0.5256589055,
-0.2357933223,
0.2360552549,
-0.6505293846,
-0.1016725823,
0.3802678585,
-0.3028994501,
0.725808382,
0.0389800109,
0.088732332,
-1.5130132437,
0.0929088444,
-0.0321288519,
-0.2128339261,
-0.4943190813,
0.2454387844,
0.1119895056,
-0.0146325342,
-0.6273611784,
0.4869009852,
-0.6444833279,
-0.0853685364,
-0.0376797989,
0.1792598665,
0.2120094597,
0.4925784171,
-0.1110854894,
0.8628460765,
0.281473577,
-0.765432775,
0.280973345,
0.4575880766,
-0.1886661798,
0.1476078182,
-0.7896777987,
0.312517345,
-0.2536291182,
0.146579057,
-1.0126361847,
-0.1773557067,
-0.1419745833,
-0.3369314671,
-0.199642539,
0.1465103924,
-0.459767133,
-0.1298723966,
-0.4484712183,
0.4774546325,
0.3250093162,
-0.4450080991,
0.8285827637,
0.5376005769,
-0.6188328862,
-0.6181867719,
-0.4536989629,
-0.0427092835,
-0.2770708501,
-0.5127072334,
0.0833551809,
-0.0786813945,
-0.1529109627,
-0.0625199303,
-0.2100759894,
-0.1734739244,
0.275039196,
-0.0819291472,
0.5954548717,
-0.1613454968,
0.1706829965,
0.4353258014,
0.3109783828,
0.3582305014,
-0.0120834196,
0.2382075787,
-0.0521768965,
-0.2939478457,
-0.1531012952,
0.8260680437,
0.6941004395,
-0.5591404438,
0.596449554,
0.2360106409,
-0.5416733027,
-0.2696167231,
-0.4096718431,
-0.0649122,
-0.3721256554,
0.4171372056,
-0.468690604,
-1.1032284498,
0.7601875663,
0.0378554948,
0.5714570284,
0.6960842609,
0.8604928851,
-0.1987638623,
0.8778707981,
0.2698288262,
0.0715490952,
0.0756506771,
0.1361719668,
-0.0556675605,
-0.5435122252,
-0.2818705738,
-0.7436257601,
0.0879495814,
-0.1962962002,
-0.6155520678,
0.3900212646,
-0.0154333869,
-0.1834750324,
0.1876211911,
-0.2206083536,
0.4581524432,
0.4538411498,
0.1089699864,
0.3633392453,
-0.1841215044,
0.0572456121,
0.2988672554,
-0.3471862376,
-0.8465758562,
0.9130205512,
0.3950523734,
0.7321338654,
0.6182094216,
0.5884742141,
0.3847235441,
0.1407035291,
-0.5559791327,
0.4528078735,
0.0626492128,
-0.820133388,
-0.3727454841,
-0.5016620159,
-0.4457205534,
0.394937098,
-0.3390612304,
-0.4505900145,
0.0053578774,
0.0187463854,
-0.7005541325,
-0.0845988169,
-0.6887291074,
0.7106654048,
-0.1721764207,
-0.3164492846,
0.044184193,
-0.7633807659,
0.5969181061,
-0.2521374822,
0.2090670913,
-0.2466805279,
-0.0315265208,
0.8047395349,
-0.23124744,
0.6523346305,
-0.0502535328,
-0.2846009731,
0.6608335972,
0.0955012962,
0.4166641831,
0.2441194803,
0.0658761859,
-0.2144527882,
0.603582859,
-0.6108158827,
-0.5907433629,
0.2610668242,
-0.8694631457,
-0.3347395957,
-0.5166456699,
-0.3661993146,
-0.4303353429,
0.1082438529,
-0.0406637378,
0.4829217792,
-0.425809294,
-0.0408968851,
0.5779670477,
-0.2919051349,
0.1737481654,
0.3992382288,
-0.0657932311,
-0.5450180769,
0.7209615707,
-0.0763117597,
0.2110678256,
0.2618808448,
-0.038364429,
-0.8101965785,
-0.3237622678,
-0.603267312,
0.3385686874,
-0.8350830078,
-0.2447316498,
-0.6451474428,
-0.4515739381,
-0.3324089348,
0.1253099889,
-0.291103214,
-0.5205713511,
-0.3358750343,
-0.2002939284,
-0.131590277,
0.5808745623,
0.2623035312,
-0.0160722733,
-1.3961385489,
0.4156347811,
0.6234866381,
-0.1521211118,
-0.1169524416,
-0.4568951428,
-0.3497952521,
0.0774139315,
-0.1472328156,
-1.2722228765,
0.1858428717,
0.2671402395,
0.5945391655,
-0.1020797715,
0.3095458448,
0.5730339289,
-0.4806296825,
1.0305116177,
0.1016456336,
-0.9156537056,
0.4002787769,
-0.1631061584,
0.4176725745,
0.7685894966,
0.1838610172,
-0.4745391905,
-0.6274213791,
-0.2870727181,
-0.7840343714,
0.5304888487,
0.4030403197,
0.402166605,
-0.1099930778,
0.2392022461,
0.1424944997,
0.0908804163,
-0.5297356248,
-0.036991138,
-0.1350847781,
-0.4207668602,
-0.1163153127,
-0.5351992249,
-0.4115362167,
0.0221650749,
0.7910639644,
-0.2951213717,
0.2474613935,
0.2283910811,
-0.4118548632,
0.1737802774,
0.7516732216,
0.3831025362,
0.6551015973,
-0.0638505593,
0.5940801501,
0.3211531639,
-0.0808376744,
0.3448951244,
0.2656085491,
-0.093949616,
0.1179744527,
0.1083900332,
0.3206460178,
-0.2213285416,
-0.898735404,
0.5615496039,
-0.3171917498,
-0.1986157447,
-0.4090554416,
-0.3385466933,
0.1586731225,
0.3405990005,
0.5287055373,
-0.148003459,
0.2614440322,
-0.5312730074,
0.3382909894,
0.4135950506,
-0.251018703,
-0.3610478938,
0.5050429702,
0.2199380547,
0.2505520284,
0.556286335,
-0.0507014506,
-0.6464893222,
0.4584770501,
0.3927798271,
0.7691062093,
0.0303758439,
0.5009949803,
0.4326212108,
0.3082360923,
0.1350646019,
0.6156861186,
-0.0799118057,
-0.6996802092,
-0.7227111459,
-0.6575223804,
-0.4215465784,
-0.0215435158,
-0.7177675366,
0.1555300206,
-0.153517887,
0.0944224149,
0.090035893,
-0.0641027093,
-0.2882574201,
0.3251795173,
0.1331290901,
0.8132965565,
-1.2091838121,
0.4842475951,
0.9589072466,
-0.550321281,
-1.0839332342,
-0.1746163517,
-0.0365170687,
-0.3621318042,
0.0757738501,
0.0270485859,
-0.1942502409,
-0.0858567953,
-0.4980612993,
-0.7833666801,
1.0490756035,
0.5912867188,
0.1796520948,
-0.2320548892,
0.0745561421,
0.3808425665,
-0.1940770894,
0.4374642074,
0.443358928,
0.0613521077,
0.215987578,
-0.5664970279,
0.4011668563,
-0.4562498033,
-0.1829514205,
0.0959647,
-0.6342349648,
0.5740386248,
-0.0338746719,
-0.3989913166,
0.0899611488,
0.9850311875,
0.5332249999,
0.1599807441,
0.4859159291,
0.2291125059,
0.7956892848,
0.1572944522,
0.6491177082,
-0.0969888493,
0.270606488,
1.4154856205,
-0.1410759389,
0.9004859328,
0.5372799635,
-0.1226769835,
0.499494195,
0.8201509118,
0.3304215074,
0.2961016595,
0.098293297,
-0.4200441539,
-0.5514998436,
-0.0795403197,
-0.1321078539,
0.5834683776,
-0.1220494583,
-0.3310654461,
-0.4815171063,
-0.3613500297,
-0.0439114869,
0.1008514911,
-0.0766288638,
0.8818275928,
0.0399085134,
-0.8532914519,
0.1630620062,
0.166414246,
0.2295867503,
-0.5650475025,
-0.1412043422,
-0.267739296,
-0.2270251364,
-0.0417882651,
-0.7406291366,
0.4024772048,
0.3613725305,
-0.1727454662,
0.01981714,
0.6271622181,
-0.5876179338,
-0.4606095552,
-0.117492795,
1.1264697313,
0.2243571877,
-0.1035754159,
-0.5656837225,
-0.3161998987,
0.0410950556,
-0.2206427157,
0.1024394333,
0.4510750771,
-0.1347250789,
0.4984208345,
0.5909073949,
-0.0424460508,
0.4611442089,
0.0039647412,
0.9801892638,
-0.5700622797,
-0.4619233608,
-0.8043600917,
0.7010741234,
-0.2716372311,
-0.1539445817,
0.8730637431,
0.7768615484,
0.2999125719,
-0.0493538827,
0.9052937627,
-0.1046979651,
0.7250331044,
-0.5344557762,
0.4280931354,
-0.6882714629,
0.2751818001,
-0.2513448894,
-0.909147203,
0.0086863469,
0.0364218019,
0.1599381417,
-0.1109403968,
0.7267971635,
0.6050054431,
0.0759661496,
0.0279347803,
0.1191230863,
0.0368739553,
0.3742645681,
0.6862738132,
1.1929885149,
-0.3945276737,
0.8483113647,
-0.0959427878,
-0.1298101395,
0.2259078026,
-0.6517190337,
-0.5942223072,
-0.6612951756,
-0.3413537443,
-0.4742952883,
-0.2598950267,
0.8608996272,
0.3541390896,
-0.8583071828,
-0.0766422004,
0.2948430181,
0.143834427,
-0.3325597644,
-0.1754734069,
0.522967875,
-0.3049951494,
-0.8049499393,
0.3892194331,
0.079036504,
-0.0645672381,
-0.3958561122,
-0.0051997891,
-0.3536474705,
0.4739685059,
0.5678002238,
0.2137226462,
-0.3845515251,
-0.3605003357,
0.2308916152,
-0.3095772266,
-0.1487177759,
0.4960850179,
-0.4892141223,
0.4512730539,
0.5815084577,
1.0809857845,
0.3695648611,
0.469152689,
0.6586615443,
-0.8597636819,
-0.6586839557,
0.1900027841,
0.3445362747,
0.2044195533,
-0.3212346733,
0.3070144951,
-0.0752195716,
-0.4539212584,
-0.8152711987,
0.228950575,
-1.1741803885,
-0.3084534109,
1.2811149359,
-0.2069339603,
-0.2394946367,
-0.2817450762,
-0.2925779223,
0.5003346205,
-0.2181312889,
0.657499373,
0.8982685208,
0.0621353164,
-0.3081564009,
-0.328422755,
0.2842915058,
0.5994971991,
-1.1990708113,
0.097362265,
0.9621733427,
0.351308763,
0.1710483879,
0.7368332744,
-0.3334361613,
0.3094024658,
-0.3691579998,
0.0402862057,
0.0322584733,
-0.1795057207,
-0.4211303592,
0.5076634884,
0.2665188611,
-0.3874178529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04885v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04885v1
|
Profiling Irony & Stereotype: Exploring Sentiment, Topic, and Lexical Features
| 2023-11-08T18:44:47 | 2023-11-08T18:44:47 |
Tibor L. R. Krols, Marie Mortensen, Ninell Oldenburg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media has become a very popular source of information. With this
popularity comes an interest in systems that can classify the information
produced. This study tries to create such a system detecting irony in Twitter
users. Recent work emphasize the importance of lexical features, sentiment
features and the contrast herein along with TF-IDF and topic models. Based on a
thorough feature selection process, the resulting model contains specific
sub-features from these areas. Our model reaches an F1-score of 0.84, which is
above the baseline. We find that lexical features, especially TF-IDF,
contribute the most to our models while sentiment and topic modeling features
contribute less to overall performance. Lastly, we highlight multiple
interesting and important paths for further exploration.
|
[
-0.6277769804,
-0.6500492692,
0.6028934717,
0.5626419783,
-0.3900363445,
0.3413411677,
0.0777017847,
-0.5633719563,
0.7304004431,
0.2079837918,
-0.4201447666,
-0.6797221899,
-0.9684804082,
0.1265594214,
-0.5866549611,
0.9929168224,
0.2636431456,
-0.1313713789,
0.0630406514,
-0.2627430856,
-0.0745686144,
-0.4608297944,
-1.0006300211,
0.2169086337,
0.7435230017,
0.4465646744,
0.6769295931,
0.3233709931,
0.4586307406,
0.2451223135,
0.0529333279,
-0.3836341202,
-0.5986449122,
0.2050121427,
-0.2002358735,
-0.1723053753,
-0.3007121384,
0.2238239795,
0.2488177419,
0.5080823302,
0.425734967,
0.4537933469,
-0.2981763482,
0.4264877439,
-0.6984799504,
-0.1169717163,
-0.3529644907,
0.0090453308,
-0.1892656982,
-0.0100922724,
-0.0285760444,
-0.9142574072,
0.1657392681,
-0.380448252,
0.4566924572,
0.1741045713,
0.7633672357,
0.1134829074,
-0.3038192391,
-0.2981685698,
-0.7277251482,
0.783562243,
-0.3966777325,
-0.0682011098,
0.1916896701,
0.3986916244,
0.7043920159,
-0.3618738651,
-0.3712702096,
-0.0143930828,
-0.0754024014,
0.0096523389,
-0.3233223557,
-0.1292964816,
0.1791870743,
0.3634020984,
-0.4030036032,
-0.2032644153,
-0.2904571891,
-0.1174585,
0.8189719319,
0.0646975264,
0.3057643473,
-0.4975730479,
-0.3328408897,
0.229535833,
-0.1441895217,
0.0076679625,
0.6067999005,
-0.0670376197,
-0.0284231734,
0.5253101587,
-0.3007935882,
0.0164008196,
-0.2777081728,
0.1026603803,
0.2875377238,
0.1737317741,
-0.0202130787,
0.1489275247,
0.8406172991,
0.4358565509,
0.8137834668,
0.0302671157,
-0.4068876803,
0.0378042534,
0.1189677492,
-0.6993046403,
-0.1535236537,
0.2860391736,
-0.484564364,
-0.6970398426,
0.2474317998,
-0.5657437444,
-0.6178026795,
0.1572856009,
0.4026652277,
-0.7449820638,
-0.5004748106,
-0.1227079034,
-0.809850812,
-0.0088356538,
0.4145107269,
-0.472217381,
0.2243225425,
0.7925111651,
1.1274182796,
0.3448104262,
0.2241910249,
-0.0955698639,
-0.0497479327,
-0.3807711005,
0.978030622,
-0.7175004482,
-0.3144919574,
0.2347029746,
-0.3420938551,
0.0080698673,
-0.390525192,
0.5052018166,
-0.4861986637,
-0.0720937178,
-0.5239382982,
-0.5941031575,
-0.1195923686,
0.2144954801,
-1.0203971863,
1.2258570194,
0.2632956207,
-1.3392299414,
0.1785078794,
-0.9830676317,
-0.4855363071,
0.1229158565,
-0.0364979617,
-0.0230610911,
0.2410605997,
0.0394144282,
0.5250373483,
-0.2660726309,
0.0049019642,
-0.745816052,
-0.6263546944,
0.5183105469,
0.0598260053,
0.9161004424,
0.3891732395,
-0.3814354539,
-0.3205726445,
-0.4358106256,
-0.489156723,
0.2159827501,
0.1815099418,
-0.7812262177,
-0.0663491935,
0.2151331455,
0.282030195,
0.2751262188,
-0.7909930944,
-0.3054658473,
-0.1455071718,
0.3703190088,
0.7091304064,
0.2123733759,
0.1581029445,
-0.3123470843,
0.5484450459,
0.1740522385,
0.3969720602,
0.5570383668,
-0.4802109003,
-0.5876619816,
-0.4922089875,
0.2196746618,
0.7760625482,
-0.4847029746,
0.4494002759,
-0.0718538985,
-0.3797860742,
-0.8911805153,
0.040927358,
0.1977363825,
0.2413369119,
-0.0274424292,
-0.154222399,
-0.4378138185,
-1.1220089197,
-0.3432714343,
-0.3673309684,
-0.1410588473,
0.4297260046,
0.4051195681,
0.3411104083,
0.9457252026,
-0.6389506459,
-0.0488865674,
-0.2630904019,
0.5894605517,
0.0176508036,
-0.0270799007,
1.0209004879,
-1.1066654921,
-0.6148715019,
-0.2364569008,
-0.7957396507,
-0.3589388132,
0.6235201955,
-0.0475955419,
0.0504162237,
0.5934368968,
-0.3826529682,
0.5209780931,
-0.0133513482,
-0.3135647476,
0.3940351903,
0.7498940229,
0.5439089537,
-1.1360673904,
0.2851468623,
0.3392245173,
-0.2203770578,
-0.4653972387,
-0.425349772,
-0.3821146786,
-0.0549342521,
-0.4890986979,
0.5419825315,
-0.0182988476,
-0.1018772572,
-0.022980364,
0.1374407113,
-0.0066262805,
-0.1397604495,
-0.2163567841,
0.3838684857,
0.4461669028,
-0.0588774011,
0.3167701066,
-0.3211787343,
-0.329169035,
0.5368798375,
-0.6948606372,
0.0511306599,
-0.2631891072,
-0.0067245932,
-1.5382552147,
-0.4536608756,
0.2260260582,
-0.7711790204,
-0.1272293776,
-0.0945339426,
-0.7097502351,
-0.2183014154,
-0.8753978014,
0.4637925625,
0.4526188374,
0.1284028441,
0.727224648,
0.3543457389,
-0.4300692976,
-0.8348864317,
-0.2390667647,
-0.1184358597,
-0.4842210412,
-0.8224421144,
0.2475027293,
0.2434200943,
-0.6645547152,
0.3727076948,
0.2325325459,
0.0902651921,
0.1917724311,
0.2692351043,
-0.0941920504,
-0.3045772612,
0.2756191492,
0.0578530505,
0.2001390159,
0.0133571159,
0.2887188494,
0.634966433,
-0.0961471274,
0.2360398471,
-0.495177865,
0.8057129383,
0.5917933583,
0.0270435549,
0.8608379364,
1.05613029,
-0.4399519563,
-0.3111065328,
-0.6689594984,
-0.123897247,
-0.3998456597,
0.3057399392,
-0.2273024172,
-0.9723559618,
0.7741192579,
-0.076408267,
-0.0460106805,
0.5859928131,
0.1624330878,
-0.5447785854,
1.1222989559,
1.0728489161,
-0.2310441583,
0.5961976051,
-0.0465647168,
0.4009430408,
-0.3729939759,
0.1041563898,
-0.6711571217,
-0.5802513361,
-0.7252674103,
-0.0634174198,
0.39891693,
-0.0184043199,
-0.2878349423,
-0.034588173,
-0.2018226385,
0.3783920705,
0.434951514,
0.1164104044,
-0.187256664,
-0.1208518445,
0.0343765318,
0.1124421731,
-0.3165298104,
-0.7179785967,
0.7729643583,
0.4731983542,
0.6187149286,
0.2240359932,
0.8703091145,
0.8529772758,
0.7370386124,
-0.6131328344,
0.750549078,
-0.7454029918,
-0.9155136347,
-0.2141088694,
-0.3033000827,
0.0337762088,
-0.3521488309,
-0.1298817098,
-0.8674652576,
0.113452822,
0.0765369609,
-0.4574975371,
0.1569487154,
-0.8938182592,
0.789278686,
0.1155843064,
-0.044773858,
-0.0141679961,
-0.9011327028,
0.4432095885,
0.095767796,
0.2703468204,
-0.5875666738,
-0.0574323796,
0.7850911021,
-0.0009400057,
1.044629693,
-0.2833981812,
0.3854906857,
0.086317502,
0.1429765224,
-0.2048684955,
0.1972826123,
-0.4230472147,
0.1103694588,
-0.2173336744,
-0.3865230083,
-0.4691588879,
0.5949102044,
-1.0566796064,
-0.522810936,
-0.2244559079,
-0.4363043606,
-0.0896684527,
-0.1792729199,
0.3994350433,
0.0997705013,
-0.6713017821,
0.0042351387,
0.7108710408,
-0.1393112242,
0.4781355262,
-0.0874300376,
-0.1394690722,
-0.3499875069,
0.731549859,
0.1266663074,
0.2501986623,
0.4084721506,
0.267018497,
-0.2338209599,
0.0364928171,
-0.037507277,
0.5125867128,
-0.9573239088,
0.0201580357,
-1.0549196005,
-0.4288378358,
-0.952249229,
-0.3849154115,
-0.2976968884,
-0.787384212,
-0.3819125891,
-0.0911024958,
0.6149989367,
0.8085067272,
-0.1291884929,
0.4904664457,
-0.4082951248,
0.2409572601,
0.1542002112,
0.1806656569,
-0.1558493823,
-0.4748226404,
-0.0352770612,
-0.4849624038,
-0.2599835992,
-1.1814547777,
0.2429318726,
0.2710837424,
0.1483324021,
0.9004407525,
0.2533560693,
0.1196462661,
0.0732066259,
0.6003934741,
-0.145440504,
-0.8653515577,
0.6197449565,
-0.2692531943,
-0.1990784705,
0.5998911262,
1.0630910397,
-0.5172507167,
-0.7989985347,
-0.6971232295,
-0.887332201,
0.6437826753,
0.1964918375,
0.1825309545,
-0.1518128961,
0.4313583374,
0.0925387144,
0.4297817647,
-0.6761360168,
-0.2753807604,
-0.4445662796,
-0.5595601201,
0.0513134673,
-0.5077616572,
-0.2409900874,
-0.2675440311,
0.4814844728,
0.1682537794,
0.2546213865,
0.0644745976,
0.0496694706,
0.1079706475,
0.087528944,
0.265784055,
0.366604358,
-0.8254663348,
0.4079748392,
-0.3782706857,
-0.3515259326,
-0.1319343895,
0.3473910689,
-0.1253721416,
0.4642770886,
0.3146880269,
0.4953996539,
0.0805295557,
-0.1983101666,
0.6048840284,
-0.0006699903,
-0.2849624157,
-0.5396904945,
0.1313097179,
0.4470011294,
0.3523003757,
0.4607585669,
-0.0703880638,
0.548060298,
-0.7278225422,
0.0081983879,
0.2918883264,
-0.529542625,
-0.5088348389,
0.1796797514,
0.2313983589,
-0.3592758179,
0.2501546144,
-0.3291055262,
-0.7744569182,
0.7824542522,
0.0638176277,
1.3148730993,
-0.4956134558,
0.6607407331,
0.1865410507,
0.3422748446,
0.3131854534,
0.4481131136,
-0.1170650199,
-0.7841826081,
0.2627970874,
-0.9877575636,
-0.0789569691,
-0.049982395,
-0.4121007919,
0.527913034,
-0.6691357493,
-0.394169569,
0.7822614312,
-0.2236373574,
-0.6222192049,
0.3728832901,
0.0451386869,
0.8035840392,
-1.4737901688,
0.4860655367,
0.9644867778,
-0.3935986161,
-0.4605744183,
0.3041938543,
0.2003667057,
-0.6281433105,
0.8836637139,
0.4802915454,
-0.4133185744,
0.1209983602,
-0.8053263426,
-0.4570811093,
0.8876324892,
0.3728559911,
0.0229489394,
-0.0254496597,
0.2785342634,
0.6159230471,
-0.8230676055,
0.4931693673,
0.6086934805,
0.3024186492,
0.3187373579,
-0.5395459533,
0.0887300596,
-0.3712589741,
0.1583046764,
0.1972540021,
-0.6859644651,
0.9655458331,
0.0015609519,
-0.4429906607,
-0.3406680524,
0.2373152226,
0.0726124346,
0.6187832355,
0.7965914607,
0.592538476,
0.1414244026,
0.0637917742,
0.8551396132,
-0.1453448981,
0.4709136188,
0.4627884328,
-0.3683401942,
0.7290330529,
0.5332722664,
0.2084659785,
0.4396257997,
0.815598011,
0.3020879626,
0.4372446835,
-0.0367514528,
-0.6159447432,
-0.3977524042,
-0.4780775607,
0.02018396,
0.4164581895,
0.4727031291,
-0.7695332766,
-0.3898260891,
-0.0209536441,
0.3084907532,
-0.2261495143,
-0.1298181415,
0.7518538833,
0.2375706732,
-0.2501532137,
-0.0296935812,
0.0238492824,
0.6218821406,
-0.2364045382,
0.0140932938,
-0.4832392335,
-0.1416596472,
-0.1157130077,
-0.7441216707,
0.3979066312,
0.2019542456,
-0.3385475576,
0.1640810966,
0.9101405144,
-0.0147767346,
-0.6603032351,
0.6167446375,
0.4110205173,
0.2535074651,
-0.2120927125,
-0.7386193275,
0.0282565672,
-0.2052185386,
-0.3189548254,
-0.1336075962,
0.8944733143,
-0.1302158535,
0.4137222171,
0.1720454395,
-0.0380422771,
0.0524199754,
0.3701850474,
0.7863686681,
-0.8969178796,
-0.5523740053,
-0.9694823027,
0.3806977868,
-0.601565063,
-0.4904209673,
0.3884662092,
0.3646916449,
0.5840384364,
-0.0034346126,
1.016951561,
-0.5527423024,
0.8763526082,
-0.1316282898,
0.7939824462,
-0.8162198663,
0.2490156293,
-0.516759038,
-0.7346217036,
-0.2894499898,
0.3025156856,
-0.4783453345,
0.3597081602,
0.5803838968,
0.7636393309,
-0.2126033902,
0.1963957995,
0.2421966791,
0.2860649824,
0.187538445,
0.2605322003,
1.0740618706,
-0.209104538,
0.285612464,
-0.3947148025,
-0.6459227204,
-0.7794662714,
-0.7332853675,
-0.9217665792,
-0.5865946412,
-0.3381296396,
-0.3188975751,
0.1082205102,
0.6673179865,
0.3772575557,
-0.547391355,
-0.1705783606,
0.4388152063,
0.3862248361,
0.0277460478,
-0.3868418336,
0.2963490486,
-0.285467118,
-0.4774234295,
-0.6284822822,
0.4729242921,
-0.2819358408,
-0.1261717528,
0.4542592764,
-0.4906057715,
0.537958622,
0.530459404,
0.000385726,
-0.5131763816,
-0.6494066119,
0.2721732855,
-0.2578974664,
-0.1524391472,
0.8534792066,
-0.1207029969,
0.0826040879,
0.5816676021,
0.2925982773,
0.1681681424,
0.3368740082,
0.3035572171,
-1.0763403177,
-0.0402268171,
0.4737517834,
0.1976604462,
0.4901901484,
-0.3891291916,
0.3484111428,
0.6201712489,
-0.3206628263,
-0.6998926401,
0.0850798264,
-1.0523020029,
-0.3024894893,
1.0534758568,
0.0106578041,
-0.3844477236,
-0.3660512567,
0.0365011171,
0.3865587115,
-0.6253250837,
1.1703602076,
0.9292811155,
-0.3277397752,
-0.1164667457,
-0.6565912962,
0.7172447443,
0.2172470093,
-0.4901824296,
-0.286069572,
0.4021409452,
0.6910939217,
0.4169224799,
0.8535421491,
-0.2180059105,
0.4395668507,
-0.0867890194,
0.2240146846,
0.3873802423,
-0.3119747937,
0.1063961089,
0.6182478666,
0.047070276,
-0.2852108777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04879v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04879v2
|
LongQLoRA: Efficient and Effective Method to Extend Context Length of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-08T18:33:06 | 2023-11-09T05:21:28 |
Jianxin Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present LongQLoRA, an efficient and effective method to extend context
length of large language models with less training resources. LongQLoRA
combines the advantages of Position Interpolation, QLoRA and Shift Short
Attention of LongLoRA. With a single 32GB V100 GPU, LongQLoRA can extend the
context length of LLaMA2 7B and 13B from 4096 to 8192 and even to 12k within
1000 finetuning steps. LongQLoRA achieves competitive perplexity performance on
PG19 and Proof-pile datasets, our model outperforms LongLoRA and is very close
to MPT-7B-8K within the evaluation context length of 8192. We collect and build
39k long instruction data to extend context length of Vicuna-13B from 4096 to
8192 and achieve good performance both in long and short context generation
task. We also do some ablation experiments to study the effect of LoRA rank,
finetuning steps and attention patterns in inference.The model weights,
training data and code are avaliable at
https://github.com/yangjianxin1/LongQLoRA.
|
[
-0.4547276795,
-0.8789016604,
0.6175915003,
0.6285026073,
-0.5422224402,
-0.3065982759,
-0.5564801693,
-0.6160389185,
-0.0660557374,
0.6107277274,
-0.229058668,
-0.5297147632,
-0.0893436298,
-0.1811088622,
-0.3210674524,
0.7220803499,
0.3307404518,
-0.1966978461,
0.1994684488,
-0.2025677413,
-0.5257062912,
-0.5328781009,
-0.6618046165,
-0.1810918152,
0.9011294842,
0.4859509468,
0.5777723789,
0.5668917298,
0.1765219867,
0.2668893933,
-0.2910558581,
0.2250895798,
-0.8104711771,
0.0406583212,
-0.2922567725,
-0.2550064921,
-0.7080380917,
-0.3977515996,
0.807692945,
0.40284881,
0.1005460396,
0.3503652513,
0.065098621,
0.8209156394,
-0.6774724722,
0.0885399804,
-0.3712224066,
-0.0742726326,
-0.5021445751,
-0.2939140499,
-0.2831598818,
-0.1052241698,
0.1035987735,
-0.4812630415,
-0.2041081041,
-0.0646412224,
0.3942281306,
0.3779898286,
-0.730779469,
0.0354625583,
-0.7966483235,
0.8086717725,
-0.8733590841,
0.3650372028,
-0.0069275177,
0.4516988099,
-0.1679625958,
-0.8468564749,
-0.6766582131,
-0.1576170176,
0.0870408788,
0.1433505863,
-0.0707739592,
0.2975220382,
0.681722939,
0.1210525632,
-0.4903137088,
0.2952676117,
-0.5527743101,
0.1955080032,
0.6392369866,
-0.1709739119,
0.232594803,
0.0149401119,
-0.5503466725,
-0.1674620658,
-0.8725045919,
0.0656597242,
0.2369446605,
0.2878293097,
-0.064777866,
0.4225324392,
-0.4848721623,
0.8005803823,
-0.1732349545,
-0.0605324656,
0.1957641095,
-0.2181839645,
-0.4913806617,
0.228571102,
0.4809239805,
0.1700792909,
-0.2414709032,
-0.0467554145,
0.0264735073,
-0.0818281919,
0.0061700046,
-0.9610202312,
-0.0963502452,
0.3540858924,
-0.1986673176,
0.1986484975,
-0.0148741901,
-0.8595224619,
-0.2600169778,
-0.3415781856,
0.1550929397,
-0.4868959188,
-0.1862825304,
0.2238267958,
0.2957529128,
0.5017421842,
0.446516335,
-0.7669431567,
0.1901663393,
0.986066103,
0.6268209219,
-0.4856897891,
-0.3413158357,
-0.5593664646,
0.1018218994,
-0.1204454526,
0.5232840776,
-0.2975592017,
-0.0774737075,
-0.1208397225,
0.0944694132,
0.0478741862,
-0.4588516653,
0.7226820588,
-0.6594859362,
0.2744361162,
-0.1023117155,
-0.6189565063,
-0.4554944038,
-0.0383453332,
-0.901280582,
0.9379947782,
0.3992937505,
-0.6227274537,
-0.0167624615,
-0.9493355155,
-0.2219201475,
0.2645911574,
0.1399393231,
-0.1939769983,
0.1095798686,
0.1127922162,
0.2367542386,
-0.3448106349,
0.3000970781,
-0.3432333469,
-0.5669389367,
0.1778955907,
-0.6196302772,
0.8130485415,
0.340826422,
-0.4923043847,
0.5111407042,
-0.6080127358,
0.2681877315,
-0.0173418149,
-0.5550862551,
-0.3087223172,
-0.3900355101,
0.3803783953,
0.4805725217,
0.3858107328,
-0.2112414837,
0.3571117818,
-0.2842970192,
0.4571323097,
0.4923170209,
-0.1715527922,
0.3872653246,
0.0733583272,
0.5769350529,
-0.1469649971,
0.2166073322,
0.1190582588,
-0.2552898228,
-0.6781158447,
-0.3517251611,
0.4073327184,
0.4185628891,
-0.8671030998,
0.5257986784,
-0.5693218708,
-0.336879462,
-0.1120935008,
0.2024615705,
0.5443128347,
0.4780909717,
0.4797804058,
-0.3505936265,
-0.4890691042,
-0.8371940255,
0.026576018,
0.181075424,
-0.099933736,
0.0045680311,
0.273026824,
-0.2746600807,
0.9402974248,
-0.4639619589,
-0.1355884671,
-0.3187793195,
-0.4947805405,
0.3933985233,
0.4970497489,
0.7473056316,
-0.7843898535,
-0.4834224582,
0.0363183916,
-0.6104543209,
-0.0881979465,
0.0556280054,
-0.4774176776,
0.3635717332,
0.5554063916,
-0.6559104323,
0.2671964765,
0.7569030523,
-0.5766678452,
0.4905099273,
-0.0105227837,
-0.046515286,
-1.1736249924,
0.3636972904,
-0.1443353742,
-0.5766295791,
-0.7770746946,
0.4507096708,
0.1454751641,
-0.0113878204,
-0.7715083361,
0.8086717129,
-0.3947674036,
-0.1492544711,
-0.517110765,
0.3833427131,
-0.173666656,
0.8081103563,
-0.0126154963,
0.8084641099,
0.276707679,
-0.4805046916,
0.5602872372,
0.0313267522,
-0.5679116845,
0.0926491693,
-0.4693313241,
0.2383362353,
0.1429227442,
0.4788619578,
-0.7415131927,
-0.160985902,
0.278998673,
-0.0427233651,
0.1377743334,
-0.1503289044,
-0.3097984493,
-0.3402858675,
-0.2112430632,
0.8320016861,
0.5167301297,
-0.8557933569,
0.1775612682,
0.2188028395,
-0.1814360172,
-0.5962723494,
-0.3310981393,
0.2945521176,
-0.799921453,
-0.4483307004,
0.4349300265,
-0.2827088237,
-0.2207186073,
-0.3453807235,
0.1882464439,
-0.0117197679,
0.1767103523,
0.078457348,
-0.01861047,
-0.3960725367,
0.350260824,
0.0455146693,
-0.022155989,
-0.082243219,
-0.2794030309,
0.9665945768,
-0.2213811576,
-0.1049522683,
-0.3940797448,
0.3211961091,
0.5268989801,
-0.2000412494,
0.7224670053,
0.5620000362,
-0.3596094251,
-0.2589443624,
-0.3118645847,
-0.1474887431,
-0.4599024951,
0.6965406537,
-0.3194829822,
-0.8900847435,
0.4826010764,
-0.1143124625,
-0.0538318083,
0.3567824662,
0.3475518823,
0.4989171922,
0.9253286719,
0.6527287364,
-0.3993530273,
0.7895955443,
-0.2216016948,
0.0672323033,
-1.0519311428,
0.2669029236,
0.0097897639,
-0.1062446758,
-0.3515440822,
-0.8383684158,
0.3552691936,
0.387819916,
-0.2482951432,
0.1102220416,
-0.292383343,
0.6574597359,
0.4508193135,
0.2482469976,
0.2578063905,
0.0350660458,
0.5518274307,
0.2350347787,
-0.7663521171,
-0.3292379379,
0.9523299336,
0.4965218306,
0.294665426,
0.4333199263,
0.5784075856,
0.1347226501,
0.2394347936,
-0.8315777779,
0.5341268182,
0.0218256321,
-0.2741051614,
-0.8302649856,
-0.3480090797,
-0.8506141901,
0.3675495386,
-0.0149011686,
-0.6880741715,
0.0242190827,
0.1092295647,
-0.5160372257,
0.061420653,
-0.4692484438,
0.8851465583,
-0.3155001998,
-0.756020546,
-0.3272594512,
-0.5519236326,
0.6515851021,
-0.1644330919,
-0.1650560647,
-0.0412648395,
0.1125008613,
0.7314059734,
-0.4911106825,
0.6831454635,
-0.1588534564,
-0.71041435,
0.2718353271,
-0.3182320595,
0.4181236327,
0.2248170227,
-0.0932983533,
-0.07711339,
-0.0673827007,
-0.6239975691,
-0.7863132954,
0.8745045066,
-0.4832949042,
-0.6268674731,
-0.2206245363,
-0.568226099,
-0.2583493888,
0.4556377232,
0.1413522512,
0.4207092822,
-0.1877894104,
0.3943359852,
0.6284222007,
-0.258076489,
0.4866401851,
0.186494872,
-0.4121687412,
-0.289542079,
0.7139140964,
0.0061498461,
0.2065915763,
0.2785317302,
0.2311916947,
-0.3559983671,
-0.6594936848,
-0.4287888706,
0.3193925023,
-0.8142590523,
-0.1399523765,
-0.2850026488,
-0.2721773982,
-0.5012326837,
0.1681551337,
-0.4347688258,
-0.5141019821,
-0.1171695367,
0.002738694,
0.2724584937,
0.3124942482,
0.3088153303,
0.6399162412,
-0.7449877858,
0.1591483057,
0.4098059833,
0.1774196625,
0.2172286958,
-0.5180636048,
-0.4530145824,
0.0962678269,
-0.0786724538,
-0.6669521332,
0.6757144332,
0.1227259189,
0.2617475092,
0.5934166312,
0.1643996239,
0.9865235686,
-0.4464250505,
0.5399502516,
0.0249194577,
-0.9998815656,
0.0277868994,
-0.5123283267,
0.8178192377,
0.4125561118,
0.0183906741,
-0.5195223689,
-0.027776463,
-0.3360967934,
-1.0579658747,
0.4724774957,
0.1956325918,
0.0002794085,
0.165175274,
0.505299449,
-0.0020361484,
-0.0195903257,
-0.703327775,
-0.120828189,
-0.0025306467,
-0.0994625539,
-0.4668066502,
-0.5529747605,
-0.4049354196,
-0.2516202927,
0.7768114805,
-0.5925760865,
0.1568068117,
0.1282141954,
-0.3359265924,
0.2303264737,
0.3753805161,
0.983579278,
1.033161521,
-0.193948254,
0.0656015947,
0.4834747314,
-0.2266323268,
-0.1887150854,
0.1779769808,
0.1905697882,
-0.3323926628,
0.4278214872,
0.9315582514,
0.1811895519,
-0.846994698,
0.2553247809,
-0.2403771579,
0.2309366018,
-0.5680662394,
-0.0071677468,
0.2998512089,
0.6292814016,
0.2683926523,
-0.7338066101,
0.3064981103,
-0.6134365797,
0.0721936524,
0.2500977814,
-0.3217668831,
-0.2301416993,
0.3542994261,
0.142230764,
0.0993217304,
0.5900701284,
-0.078453511,
-0.5453995466,
0.6112388372,
0.8666258454,
0.5848183632,
-0.2233394384,
-0.1078371033,
0.2934938967,
-0.2173880637,
-0.1846056581,
0.214982301,
-0.1584066898,
-0.4625527263,
-0.33207196,
-0.551253736,
-0.233865276,
0.28256464,
-0.6659528017,
0.2540896535,
-0.3106440306,
-0.0538467392,
-0.3216219842,
0.3202647567,
-0.3177660406,
0.1129716486,
0.455403924,
0.9899258018,
-0.5437384248,
1.4431681633,
0.2214705795,
0.0807501972,
-0.6419341564,
-0.045939818,
-0.3381644785,
-0.3682363927,
0.5847976208,
0.4252692759,
-0.290604651,
-0.0954348147,
-0.5819451213,
-1.0547935963,
1.3550752401,
0.4198616445,
-0.8873483539,
-0.1489555836,
0.0102510508,
0.665600121,
-0.3940083683,
-0.1154766232,
0.744232595,
0.2947820425,
-0.0990723446,
-0.8862426877,
0.2790747285,
-0.2060232311,
0.0066246754,
0.0627220571,
-0.9907868505,
0.8424419761,
-0.0561170913,
-0.3864366114,
0.3542766273,
1.0315597057,
0.371016562,
0.2170678079,
0.525113225,
0.3684535325,
0.8372360468,
0.2378005385,
0.8998744488,
-0.433486253,
0.4411586523,
1.3367344141,
-0.3868313134,
0.8619034886,
0.4620250762,
0.0686990842,
0.2889454067,
0.5893388391,
0.3982830346,
0.3599616289,
0.2875614762,
-0.3988872468,
-0.2653310001,
0.1151308864,
-0.5560309291,
0.4478731453,
0.5115842223,
-0.2174352556,
-0.011458341,
0.1090253145,
0.2791831195,
-0.1261465251,
-0.2895857096,
0.5400341749,
0.2453092486,
-1.0227913857,
0.9735705256,
0.0944978222,
0.6899515986,
-0.4787705541,
-0.0565405637,
-0.2921463847,
0.4329047203,
-0.0466552526,
-0.3892713189,
-0.1379068941,
-0.3223693967,
0.0505558848,
0.1270718426,
0.6151869893,
-0.7605279684,
-0.2606155276,
0.4444262981,
0.2036107779,
0.0124712028,
-0.3075439036,
-0.5254481435,
0.0532509387,
0.0497425199,
-0.4350798428,
0.4933665395,
0.1413539499,
-0.5661377311,
0.6118255258,
0.5498385429,
-0.0544945449,
0.1636103839,
-0.0311227906,
0.9890005589,
-0.8325451016,
-0.5283058286,
-0.7604092956,
0.0094377408,
-0.2131503969,
-0.2690889537,
0.8346012831,
0.7338207364,
0.6711295843,
-0.1348394901,
0.6798211932,
0.2278276682,
0.3352558315,
-0.9541288018,
0.6726400852,
-0.3833725452,
0.1975640506,
-0.0162522811,
-1.3603444099,
-0.3631418347,
0.3368265331,
-0.4018156826,
-0.1492467225,
0.6046866775,
0.4632138014,
-0.2961871028,
-0.3394830227,
0.4137723446,
0.2470440865,
0.6343696117,
0.9824488759,
0.6861260533,
-0.2634437084,
0.1596326977,
-0.3639684618,
-0.2388541549,
-0.4705328047,
-0.8435075879,
-0.839009285,
-0.4184344113,
-0.1587963104,
-0.2964181602,
0.0940328836,
0.9917133451,
0.7451123595,
-0.5333653092,
-0.3916923106,
0.261168927,
0.0866541415,
-0.2805433571,
-0.2477898449,
0.6437900662,
-0.1082228795,
-1.0286501646,
0.6790244579,
-0.0010496188,
-0.0444506966,
-0.2522296607,
-0.210740298,
-0.208293885,
-0.0057677929,
1.0338642597,
0.7024098635,
-0.5687004924,
-0.3739693463,
-0.3711550534,
-0.0959192663,
0.0677311271,
0.7091648579,
-0.7159838676,
0.1430872828,
0.7408874631,
0.2010843009,
0.4883348346,
0.3798312843,
0.6960476637,
-0.5537456274,
0.5788514018,
0.1146780625,
0.3789519668,
0.2106689513,
-0.3346113563,
0.5998544097,
-0.2852657735,
-0.5620545745,
-0.9784860015,
0.3285864592,
-1.3439038992,
-0.5140417814,
1.3771173954,
-0.2269463837,
-0.6203706861,
0.2412446141,
-0.4452754855,
0.3972812891,
-0.2704086304,
0.8603616357,
0.2507528365,
-0.2151776105,
-0.1840752363,
-0.5811830759,
0.7919232249,
0.4190134704,
-1.0138149261,
0.3433201313,
0.5772997737,
0.3114193082,
0.1175049469,
0.4971126914,
-0.0131206289,
0.4477091432,
-0.434161216,
0.0084708761,
-0.0526246466,
-0.4877148569,
-0.6700314879,
0.2756540775,
0.1393006146,
0.0689451024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05772v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05772v2
|
ADaPT: As-Needed Decomposition and Planning with Language Models
| 2023-11-08T17:59:15 | 2024-04-08T20:42:17 |
Archiki Prasad, Alexander Koller, Mareike Hartmann, Peter Clark, Ashish Sabharwal, Mohit Bansal, Tushar Khot
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being used for interactive
decision-making tasks requiring planning and adapting to the environment.
Recent works employ LLMs-as-agents in broadly two ways: iteratively determining
the next action (iterative executors) or generating plans and executing
sub-tasks using LLMs (plan-and-execute). However, these methods struggle with
task complexity, as the inability to execute any sub-task may lead to task
failure. To address these shortcomings, we introduce As-Needed Decomposition
and Planning for complex Tasks (ADaPT), an approach that explicitly plans and
decomposes complex sub-tasks as-needed, i.e., when the LLM is unable to execute
them. ADaPT recursively decomposes sub-tasks to adapt to both task complexity
and LLM capability. Our results demonstrate that ADaPT substantially
outperforms established strong baselines, achieving success rates up to 28.3%
higher in ALFWorld, 27% in WebShop, and 33% in TextCraft -- a novel
compositional dataset that we introduce. Through extensive analysis, we
illustrate the importance of multilevel decomposition and establish that ADaPT
dynamically adjusts to the capabilities of the executor LLM as well as to task
complexity.
|
[
-0.2480411679,
-0.7051482201,
0.5510556698,
0.5218968391,
0.1351371855,
0.1637346894,
-0.4333477914,
-0.3695863187,
0.0403893441,
0.6967614293,
-0.8772025108,
-0.4181411266,
-0.4976826906,
-0.1043308005,
-0.3449238241,
0.8109112382,
-0.2047907114,
-0.3702181578,
-0.2257206291,
-0.0774682239,
-0.6201479435,
-0.1996478885,
-1.01430583,
-0.3086424768,
0.2668918073,
0.6302458644,
0.5573949218,
0.4265401959,
0.4185497463,
0.3738720119,
0.0073318696,
0.2171861827,
-0.425467521,
0.5628005862,
-0.4159842432,
-0.4179593921,
-0.810344696,
-0.4982169271,
0.4340232015,
0.7419574857,
-0.2712567151,
0.1821975112,
0.0796742812,
0.6489914656,
-0.7207320333,
0.5148474574,
-0.6889393926,
0.0460268594,
0.343095392,
-0.086703077,
-0.3917583227,
0.1406606734,
0.0708252117,
-0.9123181701,
0.0223105308,
-0.0194041021,
-0.0559585802,
0.3734904528,
-0.2498532832,
-0.61965096,
-1.14174366,
0.7616800666,
-0.5731586218,
0.1285160631,
0.145736292,
0.2875294089,
-0.7042679191,
-0.7877477407,
-0.4858551025,
0.0867344439,
0.1117139012,
0.1877762526,
-0.2734539807,
0.2427070737,
0.308790803,
0.1484795213,
-0.3743360937,
0.2180249989,
-0.1241101027,
0.0431339704,
0.4725783169,
0.5658916235,
0.6288995743,
0.1354027838,
-0.1143699363,
-0.1376344711,
-0.5683562756,
0.0984778181,
0.121842131,
0.5068852901,
0.1088964045,
0.6623455882,
-0.3321704268,
0.5827673674,
-0.1391653121,
-0.3820774853,
-0.1873878986,
-0.4874893427,
-0.3476685882,
-0.1744491607,
0.4443954229,
0.1890145689,
0.2334677875,
0.1314805597,
-0.5224851966,
-0.034107022,
0.2625726759,
-0.5717483163,
-0.4257768691,
0.425940603,
-0.3296996653,
0.1523970515,
-0.4641347528,
-0.5091458559,
-0.3885642886,
-0.3344521821,
0.6121382713,
-0.398424536,
-0.2946030796,
0.3788973689,
-0.1745835245,
0.0684585124,
0.7132291198,
-0.7584510446,
0.7232291698,
0.6309278607,
0.6752076745,
-0.1957404912,
-0.5027422309,
-0.5378129482,
0.4496477842,
-0.3405837417,
0.9172154665,
-0.5633024573,
-0.4353587329,
0.130114153,
0.1260990351,
-0.3682931662,
-0.7107568383,
0.7961364388,
-0.3422954679,
0.1186636239,
-0.1364549547,
-0.3907277584,
-0.3351866901,
0.4559259415,
-0.8163045049,
0.6960173845,
0.2672708929,
-0.332558006,
0.2439577132,
-1.1021140814,
-0.7613392472,
-0.1171985865,
0.2587805092,
-0.2808337808,
0.2125821859,
0.2804506421,
0.5506858826,
-0.2538791895,
0.0274333768,
-0.221057415,
-0.0247453805,
-0.0181941018,
-0.0308600497,
0.7298916578,
0.1362435073,
-0.2221996337,
0.5520395041,
-0.8782664537,
-0.0053426414,
0.1383094788,
-0.7083762884,
-0.0783608034,
0.6878921986,
0.1548072994,
0.2363604605,
0.1886085719,
-0.3330815732,
0.3682304621,
-0.5116226673,
0.293233186,
0.743581593,
-0.1709840149,
0.6999962926,
-0.5125278234,
0.8223890662,
-0.3521655798,
0.0426871888,
-0.1372773498,
0.0209026504,
-1.113140583,
-0.19125323,
-0.2531523705,
0.6802772284,
-1.0839238167,
0.1628789902,
-0.3465610743,
-0.4753579199,
-0.0556725636,
-0.0554611124,
0.3191536963,
0.0330785476,
0.4363903701,
-0.2264247835,
-0.6931556463,
-0.6899123192,
-0.3845913112,
-0.3096933067,
-0.1740669459,
-0.0580570772,
0.3488651514,
-0.3674476147,
0.4365479052,
-0.4815313816,
-0.4946491122,
-0.6110033393,
-0.0331253782,
0.2557702363,
0.2935418189,
0.3566167951,
-0.6127843261,
-0.4725976288,
0.1980606914,
-0.4291786253,
-0.0390757844,
-0.2221943289,
0.0616410747,
0.198997587,
0.51177001,
-0.5296579003,
0.1832496673,
0.6125365496,
-0.383173883,
0.5175197124,
-0.4149713814,
-0.0970904231,
-1.0674197674,
-0.0417299829,
-0.3610495031,
-0.4190065563,
-0.7299600244,
0.4135168195,
-0.1939339936,
-0.1339792758,
-0.0769787952,
0.4700860679,
-0.7741237283,
-0.4758852422,
-0.7167575359,
-0.2362067699,
-0.2180543542,
0.5003043413,
0.0709182173,
0.5126516223,
0.60403198,
-0.7700046301,
0.3586637378,
0.2655686438,
-0.4240959287,
0.3625238538,
-0.5038222075,
0.0042278958,
0.0054210471,
0.3626674414,
-0.8032410145,
-0.3509965241,
0.2839301825,
0.0220105182,
0.3334638774,
-0.0036552325,
-0.3727074265,
-0.2265836149,
-0.363249898,
0.2926804721,
0.2382939309,
-0.2903961837,
1.5191700459,
0.539301157,
-0.5715907216,
-0.4127129614,
-0.5315108895,
0.0095757544,
0.0379939452,
-0.5277042389,
0.5235376954,
-0.4895786345,
-0.3824120462,
0.2291500419,
-0.1057491601,
0.0299082082,
0.208760947,
0.5658625364,
-0.1441139132,
-0.1492715776,
-0.3053530157,
0.1057893187,
-0.2326772064,
0.0472847112,
0.0027232848,
0.6254859567,
0.3743741214,
-0.4962045252,
-0.0710435584,
0.5648855567,
0.9686650634,
-0.0850386471,
0.545546174,
0.3355228305,
-0.5297738314,
-0.5272650123,
-0.3007554114,
0.1906404793,
-0.4502519369,
0.5357963443,
-0.4198739529,
-0.7265390158,
0.6521500945,
-0.1750301719,
0.7317550182,
0.3095689416,
0.844435811,
0.0089305826,
0.9462744594,
0.8608637452,
0.0857412741,
0.5179436803,
0.098646462,
0.2289932519,
-0.7550939918,
-0.2714503706,
-0.4599368274,
-0.5372015238,
-0.4294995666,
-0.6223160028,
0.2874318957,
-0.3967593014,
-0.1034974232,
0.2904009819,
-0.1386345029,
0.3472470641,
0.3884145021,
-0.027664233,
0.3358643055,
-0.064476274,
0.4505073428,
0.485766083,
-0.6661929488,
-0.2042369246,
0.8563647866,
0.1265155822,
0.7866743207,
0.2730741203,
0.5267708898,
0.0594366193,
0.1581610739,
-1.1500233412,
0.6080900431,
-0.3368448913,
-0.5008612275,
-0.5401338935,
-0.0869545117,
-1.0939717293,
0.2783391476,
-0.2876182497,
-0.4313224554,
0.2056069076,
0.0619572848,
-0.3902287781,
0.0031026429,
-0.7049031258,
0.550344944,
-0.111327894,
0.0857734233,
-0.489782542,
-0.2745147943,
-0.0526553132,
-0.3020924926,
0.636470139,
-0.3349187374,
-0.3450284302,
0.8704955578,
-0.2207643539,
0.7695662975,
-0.2685874104,
0.0248420592,
0.193500191,
0.5022925735,
0.8587661386,
-0.3739410937,
-0.2729578018,
-0.5625306964,
0.1554278731,
-0.4257371128,
-0.6835724115,
0.7573759556,
-0.5980907679,
-0.7049703002,
-0.2610843182,
-1.0553246737,
-0.203078866,
0.2666378319,
-0.069430083,
0.2838171422,
-0.3361476064,
0.062460877,
0.3639638722,
-0.2669987082,
0.8425546288,
0.7282031775,
-0.3884898126,
-0.3539413214,
0.6222593188,
0.2754106522,
0.3093079031,
0.3092953861,
0.0329308547,
0.0735078529,
-1.0533953905,
-0.1243972257,
-0.170844242,
-0.8980957866,
-0.1130716354,
-0.6980139017,
-0.1139598116,
-0.1806662083,
-0.3746501505,
-0.4042070806,
-0.4005363584,
-0.2680107951,
-0.0653354004,
0.0736484975,
0.8691696525,
-0.0344771668,
0.1494243294,
-0.624263525,
0.4522380829,
0.335118562,
-0.0203758013,
-0.1251490414,
-0.5149700046,
-0.1159159467,
-0.169142276,
-0.0030197515,
-0.5029755831,
0.4511587322,
0.5514255166,
0.6741054058,
-0.1358827055,
0.2949799895,
0.8539161086,
-0.5381985307,
0.440818578,
-0.0962140933,
-0.8171517849,
0.4045281112,
-0.4515722394,
0.6037964821,
0.5602371097,
0.3140076697,
-0.4461647272,
-0.2488530129,
-0.3429539502,
-1.2824397087,
0.9142428041,
0.1154398993,
0.2936635315,
0.3440364003,
0.1785565019,
0.2388015538,
-0.0694448948,
-0.848680079,
-0.0086043905,
0.2746618986,
-0.1933607459,
-0.0786716715,
-0.610622406,
-0.073309049,
-0.1916196793,
0.6257944703,
-0.213976115,
0.2812737525,
-0.1582247466,
-0.3074667752,
-0.1408888847,
0.2948601842,
0.5381073356,
0.9503055215,
0.106250681,
0.2227135003,
0.3851326108,
-0.2029767781,
0.1735515594,
0.0208965112,
0.1639522016,
-0.5328276157,
0.7757943869,
0.5451793671,
0.3888897896,
-0.8742316365,
0.1614989638,
-0.1579213291,
-0.099019289,
-0.4738427997,
0.3680763245,
0.3741059303,
0.5446821451,
0.2166247517,
0.04652711,
0.1035914272,
-0.8989329338,
0.0129633294,
0.1280780286,
-0.3260528147,
-0.3752088845,
0.1317675412,
0.1533461362,
-0.5295162201,
0.3842883706,
-0.135691449,
-0.4515850842,
0.5628460646,
0.8969501257,
0.9585525393,
-0.4806911647,
0.0558383688,
0.1420583427,
0.4157425165,
-0.1737550348,
0.6813201904,
0.2386977673,
-0.8549683094,
-0.6706518531,
-0.6865392327,
-0.2479137182,
-0.1172681823,
-0.4249257743,
0.2217802107,
-0.7480431795,
0.3047859073,
-0.1248720586,
-0.2242057323,
-0.6057096124,
0.1676702201,
-0.2553459108,
0.8233071566,
-0.8986646533,
0.5893053412,
0.8994506001,
0.0326632783,
-0.8167741299,
0.0992301032,
0.0223427266,
-0.954963088,
0.2444444597,
-0.0684186295,
-0.1659435481,
0.0502182394,
-0.1716846824,
-0.9021793604,
1.1095763445,
0.5486072302,
-0.5897741318,
-0.0138796503,
-0.1215438843,
0.5699247122,
-0.4106705189,
-0.0414217934,
0.6611261964,
0.5285349488,
0.2134135664,
-0.9991102815,
0.1748349667,
-0.035304714,
-0.2317712158,
0.4528619349,
-0.2284414172,
0.7798914313,
-0.0581407137,
-0.3340607584,
0.0619487204,
0.3662980497,
0.0267290957,
0.3985091448,
0.6919557452,
0.3875227869,
0.5787726641,
0.1019067317,
0.9437984824,
-0.0959529057,
0.1165435538,
1.1726504564,
-0.2579681575,
1.0510001183,
0.1789203882,
-0.2154232413,
0.6138356924,
0.4568092823,
0.490668416,
0.3025515676,
-0.0501145571,
-0.281485647,
-0.4484485686,
-0.2622345984,
0.1204402447,
0.63991642,
0.6315389276,
-0.1082641408,
-0.3535037041,
0.2510658503,
0.0758148059,
0.0319806486,
-0.5193933249,
0.9951023459,
-0.0439896137,
-0.8103051782,
0.1865202636,
0.0618550703,
0.2385829687,
-0.5230497122,
0.076654762,
0.0099445228,
0.2390368581,
-0.4713540971,
-1.015324235,
0.616499424,
-0.2902888656,
-0.4336648285,
-0.3189136982,
1.0291084051,
-0.3375068605,
-0.5595909357,
0.5753848553,
0.5520450473,
-0.2192903757,
-0.3218264282,
-0.6483137012,
0.1862520128,
0.0492209829,
-0.4154095948,
0.4535910785,
0.4542891979,
-0.1723206043,
0.9311329126,
0.6543340683,
-0.079233475,
-0.1181263551,
-0.1690475345,
1.1086244583,
-0.6232501864,
-0.1747090518,
-0.9273780584,
0.5926086307,
0.2119225264,
0.2075906396,
0.5179585218,
0.5505511761,
0.7563302517,
-0.0227388255,
0.6758926511,
-0.1428331882,
0.2645845413,
-0.6397953033,
0.2178776413,
-0.5676292777,
0.4046757519,
-0.2021664977,
-1.1400600672,
-0.4741412401,
0.4216979742,
-0.2772108018,
-0.2220157385,
0.6686025858,
0.5889398456,
-0.0228424352,
-0.384027034,
0.3418565691,
0.0580928661,
0.6088632345,
0.8032624722,
0.7483122945,
0.0497839265,
0.5765494108,
-0.0017690959,
-0.2392513901,
-0.1885636896,
-0.9721336961,
-0.7748973966,
-0.6346874237,
-0.2629057467,
-0.0764148906,
-0.1452363431,
1.1423419714,
0.4445186555,
-0.7509178519,
-0.493491739,
-0.1083005741,
0.1826579273,
-0.2717571259,
-0.1223199964,
0.2178314775,
-0.2995140254,
-0.729944706,
0.7499932051,
0.7366400957,
-0.1336001307,
-0.0773943588,
-0.085381113,
-0.082145527,
0.1393127739,
0.9484956861,
0.3762453794,
-0.5531640649,
-0.3679890931,
-0.0424112901,
0.2203305215,
-0.1838584691,
1.0815372467,
-0.4894414544,
0.7079385519,
0.7112187147,
0.7774620056,
0.555082798,
-0.3285908401,
0.8615130186,
-0.568326354,
0.0996377617,
0.4441385567,
0.4391510785,
0.0298446175,
-0.051178623,
0.5091976523,
-0.0782319903,
-0.6568143368,
-0.6018576026,
0.5254365206,
-1.0308542252,
-0.6277827024,
1.303249836,
-0.1469599158,
-0.2579646111,
-0.4825773835,
-0.4338155985,
0.0979259163,
-0.0198476687,
0.5934844613,
0.6557168961,
-0.4552294314,
-0.2009977102,
-0.3634392619,
0.3928301632,
0.2757362127,
-1.0257638693,
0.3184804618,
0.6332114935,
0.279712975,
0.2130577564,
0.9303293824,
0.2522061169,
0.1869778484,
-0.0700312704,
0.0907565132,
-0.0010153338,
-0.4592621326,
-0.1089391485,
0.4461620152,
0.5917883515,
0.137530461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04850v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04850v2
|
Rethinking Benchmark and Contamination for Language Models with Rephrased Samples
| 2023-11-08T17:35:20 | 2023-11-11T05:11:18 |
Shuo Yang, Wei-Lin Chiang, Lianmin Zheng, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Ion Stoica
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models are increasingly trained on all the data ever produced
by humans. Many have raised concerns about the trustworthiness of public
benchmarks due to potential contamination in pre-training or fine-tuning
datasets. While most data decontamination efforts apply string matching (e.g.,
n-gram overlap) to remove benchmark data, we show that these methods are
insufficient, and simple variations of test data (e.g., paraphrasing,
translation) can easily bypass these decontamination measures. Furthermore, we
demonstrate that if such variation of test data is not eliminated, a 13B model
can easily overfit a test benchmark and achieve drastically high performance,
on par with GPT-4. We validate such observations in widely used benchmarks such
as MMLU, GSK8k, and HumanEval. To address this growing risk, we propose a
stronger LLM-based decontamination method and apply it to widely used
pre-training and fine-tuning datasets, revealing significant previously unknown
test overlap. For example, in pre-training sets such as RedPajama-Data-1T and
StarCoder-Data, we identified that 8-18\% of the HumanEval benchmark overlaps.
Interestingly, we also find such contamination in synthetic dataset generated
by GPT-3.5/4, suggesting a potential risk of unintentional contamination. We
urge the community to adopt stronger decontamination approaches when using
public benchmarks. Moreover, we call for the community to actively develop
fresh one-time exams to evaluate models accurately. Our decontamination tool is
publicly available at https://github.com/lm-sys/llm-decontaminator.
|
[
-0.465470612,
-0.6951671839,
0.4473710656,
-0.2247319371,
-0.2524049282,
0.0964160189,
-0.2010779828,
-0.7176392078,
-0.3659327924,
0.7579725385,
-0.2267163098,
-0.453294754,
-0.5821015835,
0.1778312773,
-0.6100601554,
0.971543014,
-0.241607666,
-0.2991715968,
-0.2518517077,
-0.2595408261,
-0.07874313,
-0.6865095496,
-0.3368831575,
-0.2540687919,
0.6674434543,
0.3557477593,
0.6712557673,
1.0621435642,
0.4684339464,
0.2680436969,
-0.3022744656,
0.1119446456,
-0.6633269787,
0.0705476776,
-0.2038470656,
-0.3614520133,
-0.3550642729,
0.1805565208,
0.5377089977,
0.8056967258,
-0.2554875612,
0.1166514531,
0.1514505446,
0.6073309779,
-0.7287982106,
-0.0808756351,
-0.7162792087,
-0.1490976363,
-0.4049979746,
0.0355248861,
-0.3765794039,
-0.5336953402,
-0.2523934245,
-0.4871897995,
0.3175802529,
-0.1928159744,
1.0442272425,
0.2676948905,
-0.2775829434,
0.3079124391,
-0.7749493122,
0.8554366231,
-0.7426723838,
0.361287415,
0.5707966685,
0.3460331559,
-0.3219743073,
-0.7710502744,
-0.359439671,
-0.3203558326,
0.1461429894,
-0.1622762382,
-0.3200177848,
-0.1195202246,
0.5040255785,
0.401419282,
-0.4037236869,
0.2289296538,
-0.4172365367,
-0.2548438609,
0.511954844,
0.1314467937,
0.4247087836,
-0.0162229147,
-0.6356779337,
-0.1742590219,
-1.3691067696,
-0.199973017,
0.5860079527,
0.3368321955,
0.3002607524,
0.3101333082,
-0.4490282238,
0.3752323985,
-0.3200816512,
0.1307550073,
0.4195710719,
-0.5773225427,
-0.3163120151,
-0.0972147807,
0.6725125313,
0.3895842433,
0.4024560153,
-0.1510374993,
-0.1530241966,
0.1774869561,
0.3943417668,
-0.8821069598,
-0.342485249,
-0.0381831229,
-0.1044129282,
-0.2627232373,
-0.2031286508,
-0.706248939,
-0.3888175786,
-0.3315908313,
0.4108349085,
-0.2245380282,
-0.3602400422,
0.329705894,
0.2165385634,
0.0063531301,
0.2542646825,
-0.6911722422,
0.3764663339,
0.8935421705,
0.2672246099,
0.0815320909,
-0.3604542911,
-0.3694032729,
0.0679323748,
-0.2944491804,
0.6538755298,
-0.5038555861,
-0.4126394689,
-0.1609232873,
0.0008272635,
0.1968937963,
-0.9142838717,
0.6721193194,
-0.3218389452,
0.2349181324,
-0.4554442465,
-0.6583386064,
-0.169172883,
0.146214202,
-0.7206497788,
1.0421686172,
0.0268299915,
-0.8698471785,
0.3374144733,
-0.0463584736,
-0.3916782439,
0.0317383669,
-0.120252043,
-0.5729200244,
-0.0963618606,
0.1828769445,
0.148796916,
-0.3422748446,
0.3578166366,
-0.6997484565,
-0.5802445412,
-0.0250266306,
-0.6871704459,
0.6370015144,
0.3258013427,
-0.2417785376,
0.0491799153,
-0.8284186125,
0.1924077123,
-0.1249638274,
-0.4066261053,
-0.2153185457,
-0.1736154854,
0.1294136643,
0.1812694073,
0.0667956769,
-0.5154334307,
-0.0165697746,
-0.2963805497,
0.4166884422,
0.83753407,
0.0806874186,
0.0888888091,
-0.6805904508,
0.5033459067,
-0.1608748585,
0.2717127502,
-0.1301045418,
-0.3812606931,
-0.4882468581,
-0.3104306757,
0.3114108145,
0.3209611177,
-0.4219134748,
0.4546465278,
-0.4079805613,
-0.6939331889,
-0.5852717161,
0.1238763258,
0.5791795254,
0.5387756228,
0.5282722712,
-0.2271905243,
-0.6216513515,
-1.0788936615,
-0.6724906564,
-0.0275798086,
-0.2482243478,
0.1386742145,
0.447116524,
-0.3836824,
0.7927902937,
-0.3340640366,
0.069902502,
-0.0243400708,
0.0659719706,
0.0350339934,
0.637708962,
0.233356759,
-0.4824052751,
-0.2328547984,
-0.1250952482,
-0.6001783609,
-0.2377240509,
0.27678895,
0.0135098025,
-0.029503271,
0.8003751636,
-0.3560356498,
0.3229665458,
0.3877334297,
0.1917995065,
0.6899591088,
-0.2704975605,
0.2974146307,
-1.0864112377,
0.3085893095,
-0.0482115783,
-0.3243551254,
-0.7471242547,
0.524394393,
0.1696452796,
0.0219380222,
-0.6467888951,
0.4277382791,
-0.1728585958,
0.0900248215,
-0.4213959575,
0.1266441941,
0.1763247997,
0.1347494125,
-0.3055309951,
0.7356953025,
0.2342793792,
-0.1664078832,
0.1644008458,
0.0806840435,
-0.6927115321,
0.1158861369,
-0.775254786,
0.292594105,
0.1819211543,
0.4126601219,
-0.8908218741,
-0.0459609367,
0.2774400711,
-0.1496128589,
0.1331938058,
-0.2697568536,
-0.830997467,
0.0223830789,
-0.2886658013,
0.7685396671,
0.6349922419,
-0.72308743,
0.1393734962,
0.3485457599,
-0.1241378784,
-0.692731142,
-0.6193837523,
0.1813357621,
-0.6100900173,
-0.5684962869,
0.2606048286,
-0.0290584322,
-0.2557961941,
-0.164041847,
-0.4291153848,
-0.1272672862,
0.4944733977,
0.2810201347,
0.162419498,
-0.00592842,
0.012104148,
-0.2676575482,
-0.1990943849,
0.1060814336,
0.3319242299,
0.4655527174,
-0.1105358228,
-0.5038198233,
-0.3713706136,
0.2189845592,
0.4889157116,
-0.3289167583,
0.3178277612,
0.4210075438,
-0.563387394,
0.1733552217,
-0.6401720643,
-0.2228528708,
-0.5356934667,
0.4205207527,
-0.3680174053,
-0.8015668988,
0.5963768959,
-0.2011027336,
-0.0105586043,
0.1921367496,
0.3461891413,
-0.0347148553,
0.6849653125,
0.3548417091,
-0.2461156249,
0.3218331337,
0.1501561105,
0.0749722123,
-0.7837340236,
0.128791526,
-0.5962303281,
-0.1558307856,
-0.663174808,
-0.4687486291,
-0.153267011,
0.2244114131,
-0.3302057981,
0.5581251383,
-0.1065027118,
0.8298196793,
0.424521029,
0.2083042115,
0.4134195745,
-0.149477616,
-0.0384650268,
-0.0685438216,
-0.3356416225,
-0.5820459127,
1.2253090143,
0.388792932,
0.886233449,
-0.0742885917,
1.0347720385,
-0.0140304379,
0.4127697051,
-0.0819719061,
0.5100041628,
-0.2366701365,
-0.7199890614,
-0.1137993783,
-0.6239478588,
-1.0738908052,
0.2624292672,
-0.0148878861,
-0.7174076438,
0.2196012884,
0.0033712091,
-0.12825948,
0.396401763,
-0.6838549972,
0.8367042542,
0.1503955871,
-0.419331044,
-0.1246927381,
-0.6092910171,
0.509444952,
-0.4393567443,
0.3351766467,
-0.4259946346,
0.2598465979,
0.6449018717,
-0.4152943492,
0.7768426538,
0.151478976,
-0.3730531931,
-0.0586132146,
0.1574342102,
0.5392907262,
-0.1139157116,
0.0237429012,
0.2464524508,
-0.0565262623,
-0.5268401504,
-0.3493410349,
0.711876452,
-0.5907176733,
-0.8283492327,
-0.2142917067,
-0.3595787883,
-0.2443815172,
0.3131096065,
0.2059420645,
0.3774393499,
-0.0874365047,
0.4212733507,
0.5705065131,
-0.3229992986,
0.0840978995,
0.4817329347,
-0.1115789264,
-0.2880249918,
0.8384253383,
-0.1326470971,
0.604583323,
0.1952601373,
0.1678449959,
-0.3141514957,
-0.6373556256,
0.0410529114,
0.1551779956,
-0.7492759824,
-0.1554154605,
-0.4139229953,
-0.0956412032,
-0.276435703,
0.1655115187,
-0.516130507,
-0.0806051046,
-0.1977892518,
-0.3024019599,
0.2431053221,
0.4528806508,
-0.0328476466,
0.0806282237,
-0.7758944035,
0.3126844764,
-0.0321094543,
0.4432548881,
-0.3431086838,
-0.6357542872,
-0.0542381778,
0.1587639153,
0.002125676,
-0.6219410896,
0.1706289351,
-0.069697164,
0.7125076652,
0.3274870813,
0.1236395761,
0.6391717196,
-0.6207454205,
0.4178959429,
-0.0175087247,
-0.8526010513,
0.257969588,
-0.5433136225,
0.1850349158,
0.806497395,
0.2732900977,
-0.7458735108,
-0.7923977971,
-0.7094121575,
-1.0667500496,
0.4228485525,
0.1615915447,
-0.0232485048,
-0.0471654423,
0.407802403,
0.2151329815,
0.0521814972,
-0.4996879995,
-0.0968691707,
0.0714767501,
-0.0222337954,
-0.2966021597,
-0.3543472588,
-0.3393138051,
-0.0662734285,
0.4822217822,
0.2758756578,
-0.2588347495,
-0.1969962865,
-0.3154578209,
-0.0199096277,
0.3752539754,
0.5161716938,
0.6717696786,
-0.3146416545,
0.2857774198,
0.1209687963,
-0.4046975672,
0.4271269739,
0.1440149397,
0.045332551,
-0.4398143589,
0.3943663239,
0.2846215069,
0.5264139771,
-0.665276885,
0.2611733377,
-0.0545638986,
-0.2242798656,
0.0025972319,
0.1596772671,
0.3663764894,
0.0224041417,
0.1214453653,
0.1620680988,
0.0349663682,
-0.4997058213,
0.761284709,
0.0211331882,
-0.1345851719,
-0.1479952931,
0.7175969481,
0.1522785276,
-0.0784961879,
0.6364622116,
0.0300322995,
-0.3519712389,
0.5999893546,
0.2296782136,
0.7548480034,
-0.3530997336,
-0.1752981842,
0.2917196751,
0.4733996689,
-0.3747525513,
0.0859043822,
0.286723882,
-0.7456428409,
-0.4935992062,
-0.3191847801,
-0.2892383635,
0.5069096088,
-0.9274010658,
0.1420669556,
-0.501707375,
0.0445934497,
0.0456082448,
0.001231944,
-0.3945550621,
0.1339964718,
0.1700525433,
0.8690553904,
-1.1265799999,
0.9929457903,
0.2561593056,
-0.3739266992,
-0.6936522126,
0.1515704095,
0.0490719192,
-0.669457972,
0.408421874,
0.3477554619,
0.0811553001,
-0.1399405003,
-0.1591494828,
-0.8038198948,
0.7292039394,
0.6502222419,
-0.5835331678,
0.2030386627,
0.1025561467,
0.6121048331,
0.1131350845,
0.0799460411,
0.7711953521,
0.527712822,
-0.3090767562,
-0.8506845236,
0.4511147141,
-0.2891146243,
0.0082210209,
0.2945407033,
-0.3733811378,
0.8761675954,
0.0323293954,
-0.4646098018,
0.2554691434,
0.2661099732,
0.3644683063,
0.0011889638,
0.501223743,
0.7834120989,
0.7605432868,
-0.2215103805,
0.9926965237,
-0.0438259169,
0.4729032516,
1.4852082729,
-0.482649833,
0.897885561,
0.4122161865,
-0.3996530771,
0.1077208221,
0.6990963817,
-0.2031493634,
0.4362890124,
0.5654104948,
-0.3000741005,
-0.2698221803,
0.0454215407,
-0.6299635172,
0.3306159377,
0.0417916402,
-0.2505275607,
-0.6947408915,
-0.0707319304,
0.1219136938,
0.2821937799,
0.1961432695,
0.522167623,
-0.1328164041,
-0.435569793,
0.9079897404,
-0.070780769,
0.4790566862,
-0.268384397,
0.0860774964,
-0.5336202383,
0.3217164576,
-0.0661221221,
-0.5895085931,
0.2191604823,
-0.1015658006,
0.0530614071,
-0.3654322624,
0.5673438907,
-0.5700435042,
-0.1332335174,
0.4018292129,
0.466884464,
0.2905210853,
-0.2852841616,
-0.4818012118,
0.3165647984,
0.0440341607,
-0.1051055565,
0.674916625,
0.08415474,
0.0110704135,
0.8257836699,
0.7525401711,
0.0171258878,
0.0469290689,
0.3068769872,
0.9231315851,
-0.6140589118,
-0.1904394925,
-0.9023736119,
0.1008684784,
0.1916016042,
-0.1657105088,
0.7296335697,
0.7345277667,
0.9170198441,
0.2050787508,
0.5557096004,
0.5190498829,
0.5395942926,
-0.3154576421,
0.7915853262,
-0.4153495431,
0.406614989,
-0.3151533902,
-0.7829226255,
-0.2312088013,
0.2281784564,
-0.167441234,
0.2453148067,
0.6006979942,
0.8865039945,
-0.1596146077,
0.0523711927,
0.372091502,
0.2402409315,
0.7223849893,
0.6130691171,
0.9537755847,
-0.4745927453,
0.7208166718,
-0.317425102,
-0.132801801,
-0.3844930232,
-0.9415104389,
-0.5618274212,
-0.3835836649,
-0.4396547973,
-0.3193161786,
0.294917047,
0.5177199841,
0.4485787451,
-0.6397083402,
-0.0159623735,
-0.1582264155,
-0.0284626577,
-0.3615733683,
-0.1661926806,
0.2668703794,
-0.1432067901,
-0.7874581218,
0.5747505426,
-0.1618455052,
0.1478338093,
-0.0686664805,
0.2912338972,
-0.0596796349,
-0.2419266254,
0.1854035705,
0.4507626593,
-0.8733126521,
-0.6999341846,
-0.3104838729,
-0.2698656917,
0.0853917673,
0.5487775803,
-0.645783782,
0.3667000234,
0.4552484155,
0.8377681375,
0.3713131547,
0.270080328,
0.7382568717,
-0.8176286817,
-0.0771354809,
0.1257668585,
0.4779587686,
0.374341011,
-0.2640579641,
0.5092861056,
0.1197266355,
-0.4981228113,
-1.25949049,
0.3948872089,
-0.713244319,
-0.3551617563,
1.2162396908,
-0.439514786,
-0.1662146598,
-0.1919601709,
0.104309082,
0.2577679157,
-0.0606520101,
0.9447014928,
0.8356530666,
0.2720022202,
-0.0889670998,
-0.560708642,
0.5591973066,
0.3888505995,
-1.0216715336,
0.7305109501,
0.3672818542,
0.8865676522,
-0.1160195693,
0.3311339915,
-0.5234568119,
0.2758818567,
-0.0172903854,
0.1909056157,
-0.2382055074,
-0.1604951322,
-0.420250684,
-0.064138256,
-0.1007014439,
-0.223728016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04823v1
|
Hierarchically Gated Recurrent Neural Network for Sequence Modeling
| 2023-11-08T16:50:05 | 2023-11-08T16:50:05 |
Zhen Qin, Songlin Yang, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Transformers have surpassed RNNs in popularity due to their superior
abilities in parallel training and long-term dependency modeling. Recently,
there has been a renewed interest in using linear RNNs for efficient sequence
modeling. These linear RNNs often employ gating mechanisms in the output of the
linear recurrence layer while ignoring the significance of using forget gates
within the recurrence. In this paper, we propose a gated linear RNN model
dubbed Hierarchically Gated Recurrent Neural Network (HGRN), which includes
forget gates that are lower bounded by a learnable value. The lower bound
increases monotonically when moving up layers. This allows the upper layers to
model long-term dependencies and the lower layers to model more local,
short-term dependencies. Experiments on language modeling, image
classification, and long-range arena benchmarks showcase the efficiency and
effectiveness of our proposed model. The source code is available at
https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/HGRN.
|
[
-0.2181482762,
-0.6674823165,
0.2400391847,
0.1985269189,
0.0840646401,
-0.0795945451,
0.1669518203,
-0.2940073609,
-0.038976144,
0.4441368878,
-0.5685712695,
-0.220137924,
-0.4550203681,
-0.1484211385,
-0.4133660793,
1.018296361,
-0.0229147449,
-0.1861180812,
0.149471119,
0.0050501665,
-0.3649273813,
-0.4370895624,
-0.899497509,
-0.8169577122,
0.8800168633,
-0.0811662078,
0.8182711601,
0.8586884141,
0.474708885,
0.3595252335,
-0.3835668862,
-0.22993128,
-0.4573315382,
0.106806539,
-0.1406828016,
0.0175707676,
-0.5179147124,
-0.4419554174,
0.6456335187,
0.5704918504,
-0.5224500299,
0.0708199516,
0.009862178,
0.6493674517,
-0.1980242878,
0.4575116336,
-0.5212894678,
0.5345128179,
-0.128191039,
-0.1133991182,
-0.1895598024,
-0.1765255481,
0.4152314663,
-0.2188784182,
0.509738028,
-0.0452974066,
0.7929117084,
0.0477853827,
0.0495959297,
0.2315078229,
-0.8503682613,
0.6346628666,
-0.8939356208,
0.4536328018,
0.0130789354,
0.3427733779,
-0.1384653151,
-0.7366909981,
-0.1424669325,
-0.2638209164,
-0.1255235821,
0.2218147367,
-0.215075016,
0.1944506615,
0.6186451316,
0.5075595379,
-0.5009158254,
-0.1151834205,
-0.3108351827,
-0.0572797842,
-0.0073545938,
0.3466780186,
0.0433148555,
-0.5255692601,
-0.8254387975,
0.2831534445,
-0.4069526792,
0.1320195645,
-0.0044132317,
0.5748493671,
-0.0424241088,
0.1234315783,
-0.126381442,
0.5143718123,
0.2072651237,
-0.1879490167,
0.1378085464,
0.0519384593,
-0.2150932401,
-0.188077122,
0.6800731421,
-0.234922424,
0.2013964504,
-0.3577556014,
-0.5217545033,
-0.1498671025,
0.3787704706,
-0.6392436028,
-0.1607965231,
-0.2011034191,
-0.6423162222,
-0.2131338567,
-0.0528938994,
-0.912776649,
-0.3147821128,
-0.3411313891,
0.5331577063,
-0.2154313177,
-0.1007106006,
0.1995923817,
0.0620382912,
0.15017654,
0.1771063805,
-0.8690485358,
0.4065496922,
0.5174561143,
1.1563224792,
-0.1264164895,
-0.4486003518,
-0.5109415054,
-0.0885310248,
-0.0492769368,
0.133215189,
-0.1788210869,
-0.1995234042,
0.0121561624,
0.039470803,
-0.0141533883,
-0.4404579699,
0.2463929355,
-0.936419487,
-0.0900521204,
0.0656260327,
-0.1499613971,
-0.1463475376,
0.2782480419,
-0.9132851362,
0.8317476511,
0.4164642692,
-0.6101046205,
-0.1300731301,
-0.1234534383,
-0.4420152605,
-0.0546073467,
-0.1871406436,
-0.8496956825,
-0.1899980158,
0.1796156168,
0.2240793556,
-0.2747588754,
0.5320323706,
-0.0938378498,
-0.18704997,
-0.2418985665,
-0.5940193534,
0.3248994946,
0.1759909838,
-0.3745369911,
0.0814988166,
-0.7151070237,
-0.214663282,
-0.0155585427,
-0.5497528315,
0.021331232,
0.0436565727,
-0.2271416932,
0.5737147331,
0.0008170862,
-0.4877316952,
0.0857668221,
-0.2707086205,
0.5360545516,
0.8171655536,
0.1239949688,
0.4597673416,
-0.7918272018,
0.7501634955,
0.4952352643,
0.0943450034,
-0.476344943,
-0.5192133188,
-0.6517471075,
-0.0435750522,
0.2644103467,
0.5599446297,
-0.8645883203,
0.3127993047,
-0.3885095716,
-0.0108433906,
-0.1507082731,
0.0188604947,
0.3855212629,
0.7003671527,
0.325019002,
-0.4989182353,
-0.7069015503,
-0.804504931,
0.0457943864,
-0.0423421673,
0.0935733765,
0.273925513,
0.6664725542,
-0.3506491482,
0.732337296,
-0.0313093886,
-0.4837841094,
-0.1922489852,
0.4195132554,
0.5773205757,
0.4210287929,
-0.0737936571,
-0.2713215947,
-0.0105439508,
0.2303860039,
-0.5232046247,
0.0994669348,
-0.4154179096,
-0.0919919312,
0.0299676452,
0.3787274063,
-0.8064118028,
0.6928760409,
0.3479712009,
0.1559940428,
0.4108167589,
-0.1299505979,
-0.0535940677,
-0.9914710522,
0.0406643562,
0.1238679513,
-0.514428556,
-0.5724867582,
-0.0896283239,
0.0763891414,
-0.2194833308,
-0.292391181,
0.2650262713,
-0.4864217043,
-0.2303167433,
-0.1171139553,
-0.1986353099,
-0.0269410405,
0.8868854642,
0.2017650455,
0.3273292184,
0.4832532406,
-0.5516088009,
0.4706894457,
0.2394015342,
-0.3566443622,
-0.062281765,
-0.7565323114,
-0.1135642007,
-0.4249526858,
0.2208726108,
-0.5506511331,
0.0600038096,
0.2103397995,
-0.1898329556,
0.4315816164,
-0.5574379563,
0.0014499886,
-0.7651984692,
0.0739225149,
0.8158156276,
0.7492023706,
-0.7811480165,
0.4709868431,
0.0434195027,
-0.1331097186,
-0.8010889292,
-0.7099722624,
0.0360090844,
0.0291938614,
-0.591471374,
0.5345017314,
0.5540241003,
0.285286814,
0.0116139734,
-0.1722909063,
0.1146732494,
-0.3215402067,
0.3035109937,
0.0980029926,
-0.6436319351,
0.2716948986,
-0.5703246593,
-0.3217960298,
0.1803202331,
-0.7181249261,
0.5784270167,
-0.5218939781,
-0.3415948451,
-0.3397184014,
0.3584183156,
0.584621191,
-0.2957266569,
0.576076746,
0.3565225899,
-0.7566870451,
-0.5720746517,
-0.1681650877,
-0.1502245814,
-0.4425692856,
0.5519576669,
-0.2238794863,
-0.856936276,
0.8651467562,
0.0133766644,
-0.2487283349,
0.2434479594,
0.3397250473,
0.0696600452,
0.5806901455,
0.2636645138,
-0.5485321283,
0.5489916801,
-0.3724690676,
0.3166621625,
-0.6994000077,
-0.0090076411,
-0.2380973101,
-0.3474089503,
-0.5903544426,
-0.582747817,
0.3458739221,
-0.004315888,
-0.6219000816,
0.255263567,
-0.2582852244,
0.2566591203,
0.4594199061,
0.345672965,
0.2514150143,
0.197537303,
-0.2444752753,
0.1404978186,
-0.8902466297,
0.0147351651,
0.309042275,
0.9526672363,
1.4132874012,
-0.0054008826,
0.5110448599,
0.3450568616,
0.2314105034,
-0.8687540293,
0.2801949978,
-0.1712355316,
-0.5295724273,
-0.4303183556,
-0.7709248662,
-1.0415356159,
0.1505986154,
0.0642801002,
-0.6152188182,
0.2624795139,
0.1899097562,
-0.5639501214,
0.9541872144,
-0.1236368641,
0.5868960023,
-0.0960923806,
-0.3815596104,
0.2953593135,
-0.66211164,
0.2313414216,
0.2452948391,
-0.1940422952,
0.4493714571,
0.442515254,
0.4542938769,
-0.6558685303,
0.7977828383,
-0.0784634203,
0.0465342402,
0.2761344314,
0.0250370894,
0.7126141191,
-0.1243230477,
-0.0554970466,
0.1888009161,
-0.4641351998,
-0.4732356668,
-0.5499633551,
0.7692324519,
-0.508700192,
-0.6942887902,
-0.609149754,
-0.6036670804,
-0.0295587387,
0.1017764062,
0.205006808,
0.7776797414,
0.1006523445,
0.0604122654,
0.8092440963,
-0.1883369833,
0.6696207523,
-0.2318278253,
-0.5413304567,
-0.3863274157,
0.5274425149,
0.141315788,
0.5189523101,
0.3283241391,
0.1973907351,
-0.160928607,
-0.2961592972,
-0.6786214113,
0.1447525769,
-0.5138854384,
-0.3267893791,
-0.5079038143,
-1.0956504345,
-0.0716696829,
0.0902149156,
-0.3778519928,
-0.2268744856,
0.0653459281,
-0.2526952624,
0.4476981163,
0.9769432545,
0.090382494,
0.1482144296,
-0.8329640031,
0.6596664786,
0.5575382113,
0.8923915029,
0.683488667,
-0.7213549018,
-0.4303175509,
0.044030793,
-0.3968105912,
-0.6980128884,
0.5097233057,
0.0942299888,
0.5235441923,
0.262766093,
-0.3333677948,
0.6399022341,
-0.6754469275,
0.4287540615,
0.3964282274,
-0.7323722243,
0.1988194287,
-0.8033125401,
0.8105729222,
0.0364831761,
0.2293191403,
-0.582461834,
-0.0323093608,
-0.2721093297,
-0.7445467114,
0.7408137321,
0.1355149895,
-0.0232315976,
-0.0807906687,
0.4036260545,
0.0468070917,
0.1216185167,
-0.9072338343,
-0.3379939497,
-0.1753783971,
-0.0174321849,
0.2225275189,
-0.1398244053,
0.2838473618,
-0.3223208487,
0.6755190492,
0.2248391956,
0.5879536271,
0.4200582206,
0.0312111508,
-0.4279107749,
0.3320707679,
0.2981718183,
0.5691812038,
-0.3283658624,
0.1108731255,
0.1884500384,
-0.4159577489,
0.3549893498,
0.1504491419,
-0.4525945485,
0.1579432636,
0.0895372257,
1.1035653353,
0.4381147027,
0.1580584049,
0.3476191461,
0.2909777761,
-0.304502368,
-0.317589432,
-0.3285708427,
0.321475029,
0.2463097572,
0.0095381308,
0.53182441,
-0.0403837115,
-0.4388169348,
0.5765140653,
0.1689140499,
-0.7974344492,
-0.0366172455,
0.6972103119,
0.0722811148,
-0.5499197841,
0.8612639904,
-0.0260198545,
-0.671317637,
0.7670650482,
0.7256597281,
0.9134890437,
-0.1919462979,
0.1607048661,
0.6605885625,
0.2930446863,
-0.3078165352,
0.1184931919,
0.0801106915,
-0.525536716,
-0.4961544275,
-0.5407177806,
-0.0024406931,
0.3874617517,
-0.6694323421,
-0.0400037952,
-0.6375418901,
-0.4902370274,
-0.0663964227,
-0.5456780791,
-0.6199554205,
0.0988562331,
0.3344771266,
0.8942676783,
-0.2847113907,
0.9464368224,
0.2174044549,
-0.2662723958,
-0.5662306547,
-0.2389949709,
-0.1433795989,
-0.4957801104,
0.6579924226,
0.2743955553,
-0.5016345382,
-0.1494166851,
-0.175818488,
-0.8881095648,
1.1194304228,
-0.1718469262,
-0.6282303929,
-0.4198036194,
0.3316672444,
0.7256096005,
-0.4632945657,
0.0538016185,
0.4651663601,
0.1601872444,
0.0999978408,
-0.7125303149,
-0.139741689,
-0.411287576,
0.4854483008,
0.5811742544,
-0.4180280268,
1.184607029,
-0.3736654222,
-0.3066219091,
0.4921552241,
0.6799019575,
0.0539651327,
0.2939155996,
0.442340225,
0.8385867476,
0.3929495513,
-0.206185326,
0.9907565117,
0.1673941016,
0.5140628815,
1.2735142708,
-0.0444881506,
0.6771393418,
0.1955443174,
-0.1539668143,
0.606133461,
0.1653027087,
-0.0108605204,
0.3796032965,
0.7915965915,
-0.3357248604,
-0.14296408,
0.2066752911,
-0.5002263784,
-0.0218731984,
0.2022137493,
-0.6731215715,
-0.4738432765,
-0.1264184862,
-0.2624830306,
-0.0832188204,
-0.6498408914,
0.5382281542,
0.3379683793,
-0.567964077,
0.6072371006,
-0.1792201102,
0.700368464,
-0.5885345936,
-0.1150369644,
-0.2271335721,
0.3279027641,
-0.3172357678,
-0.5322223306,
0.0301060453,
-0.1438527405,
-0.5750952363,
-0.3247647882,
0.8163270354,
-0.7080982327,
-0.485237062,
0.5540160537,
0.4896277785,
-0.3204598725,
0.1709623784,
-0.5503166318,
-0.6514069438,
-0.3961793184,
-0.3002549708,
0.1876043379,
0.3471022844,
-0.1632031649,
0.8879652023,
0.2313039601,
0.046985995,
0.4032133222,
0.5937333703,
0.5919674039,
-1.1177629232,
-0.4699275196,
-0.5957194567,
0.4594751894,
0.2761523128,
-0.1435642391,
0.3632653952,
0.2479634881,
0.6898037791,
-0.3792751133,
0.5770533085,
0.2260939032,
0.4849594235,
-0.3871210515,
0.8851280808,
-0.2023427039,
0.3418992758,
-0.2100345343,
-0.6368196607,
-0.2153189033,
0.3930391669,
-0.0866298079,
0.6724716425,
0.492723316,
1.013697505,
-0.2012240589,
0.2803219557,
0.536691606,
0.3115720451,
0.0638868511,
0.9186320901,
1.2053449154,
-0.6584120393,
0.3278348744,
-0.5208538771,
-0.0116718169,
0.0258652829,
-0.9270821214,
-0.8122835755,
-0.4683527052,
-0.1259643286,
-0.4774663448,
0.166518867,
0.7305049896,
0.889077425,
-0.9068953991,
-0.3035956919,
-0.3385090232,
0.3136900663,
-0.227605626,
-0.27797544,
0.1091352105,
-0.4644896686,
-0.0184818469,
-0.0321812071,
0.255404681,
0.0868988931,
-0.1831774563,
-0.1081726179,
-0.2632393241,
-0.0769913644,
0.5796035528,
0.4721828103,
-0.6391119361,
-0.453098774,
0.1852762252,
-0.3712785244,
0.3478533626,
0.8466165662,
-1.0317080021,
0.3847985864,
0.6796931624,
0.7632664442,
0.524687171,
0.2392779291,
0.5008776188,
-0.6904936433,
-0.224913016,
0.2158913165,
0.4642663598,
0.1171240583,
-0.2849057317,
0.1357643455,
0.151744917,
-0.8105893135,
-0.0058174059,
0.284919858,
-1.0007152557,
0.0787056386,
0.9951781034,
-0.239536494,
-0.2700768113,
-0.2214609385,
-0.0689919963,
0.2716417611,
-0.2679891586,
0.8802972436,
0.5023603439,
0.1339285225,
-0.5519411564,
-0.4858861864,
0.4972991943,
0.262855947,
-0.5280191302,
-0.1006417423,
0.3356327713,
-0.0628288761,
0.1545838714,
0.3446576893,
-0.376529932,
0.5504225492,
-0.1297457069,
0.1409126669,
-0.2113316804,
-0.6060233116,
-0.6377152205,
0.179944098,
-0.1338249743,
-0.2018669695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04816v1
|
MTGER: Multi-view Temporal Graph Enhanced Temporal Reasoning over Time-Involved Document
| 2023-11-08T16:41:37 | 2023-11-08T16:41:37 |
Zheng Chu, Zekun Wang, Jiafeng Liang, Ming Liu, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The facts and time in the document are intricately intertwined, making
temporal reasoning over documents challenging. Previous work models time
implicitly, making it difficult to handle such complex relationships. To
address this issue, we propose MTGER, a novel Multi-view Temporal Graph
Enhanced Temporal Reasoning framework for temporal reasoning over time-involved
documents. Concretely, MTGER explicitly models the temporal relationships among
facts by multi-view temporal graphs. On the one hand, the heterogeneous
temporal graphs explicitly model the temporal and discourse relationships among
facts; on the other hand, the multi-view mechanism captures both time-focused
and fact-focused information, allowing the two views to complement each other
through adaptive fusion. To further improve the implicit reasoning capability
of the model, we design a self-supervised time-comparing objective. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on the TimeQA
and SituatedQA datasets. Furthermore, MTGER gives more consistent answers under
question perturbations.
|
[
-0.2808626592,
-0.9617028236,
1.1067186594,
0.2397668958,
-0.064244017,
0.4308847785,
0.3964992464,
-0.3727937639,
0.0418381616,
0.3568845689,
-0.7171158195,
-0.5539006591,
-0.5004742742,
-0.0071415072,
-0.1425448656,
0.8402633667,
-0.2446094602,
-0.2330561727,
-0.1619226635,
-0.4084512889,
-0.1965033263,
-0.5629771948,
-0.4770843387,
-0.5134035945,
0.7992711663,
0.0043062768,
0.4263658822,
0.6607432961,
0.2133317888,
0.3175484836,
0.0602250323,
0.5696240067,
-0.1653737724,
0.02743694,
-0.1672178358,
-0.1197233349,
-0.7460616827,
0.081816718,
0.8054244518,
0.6669774652,
-0.0323241986,
0.2677318752,
-0.0366757065,
0.4710475206,
-0.6335849166,
0.3407695293,
-0.3646858335,
0.1948886067,
-0.1981970668,
-0.4602051079,
-0.5816845298,
-0.3508520424,
0.0464133099,
-0.8864864707,
0.3210376799,
0.3285681307,
0.7535197139,
0.5707015991,
-0.7777045965,
0.2304879427,
-0.6395436525,
0.4791975319,
-0.4291616976,
0.5150889754,
0.0287805926,
0.4866068065,
-0.0655271485,
-0.8435204029,
-0.5418559313,
-0.0640459359,
-0.5428256392,
0.3420334458,
-0.1273148656,
-0.191901952,
0.489885211,
-0.0888542011,
-0.8682061434,
-0.242352739,
0.0189395528,
-0.2798267901,
0.1898446679,
0.3855816126,
-0.1043473855,
-0.4527235627,
-0.3836471736,
0.0323349051,
-0.3069241941,
-0.0062023182,
0.5338925123,
-0.0582173504,
-0.0688560903,
0.4564042985,
-0.2475667894,
0.7755737901,
0.1865461916,
-0.1740429848,
0.2903179824,
-0.1857949644,
-0.2046049237,
0.2405749708,
0.6238673329,
0.4857713282,
-0.2897775173,
0.0038406621,
0.4485172033,
0.0637086704,
0.1124458015,
-0.7048188448,
-0.2413670272,
0.4242582619,
-0.3145744205,
-0.068700701,
-0.2042752355,
-0.7751488686,
-0.2947172821,
-0.197079584,
0.4128720462,
-0.393997699,
-0.2276082188,
-0.1795644164,
-0.4941768646,
-0.0028541903,
0.8057314754,
-0.2261607498,
-0.199734211,
0.6860125661,
0.8003821969,
0.1025520861,
-0.4358602464,
-0.8125466108,
0.9313879609,
-0.3272649348,
1.137808919,
-0.8058665991,
-0.3199205697,
-0.2870599926,
0.133774206,
-0.3402780294,
-0.0219379179,
0.4573228061,
-0.4578133225,
0.7343944907,
-0.1117321476,
-0.3777609169,
-0.3695285618,
0.628883779,
-0.6114844084,
1.3086013794,
0.0509930402,
-1.0493484735,
0.5195453167,
-0.7601764798,
-0.4409431815,
-0.170669809,
-0.1318554282,
-0.3385345936,
-0.417124778,
0.6223730445,
0.42407763,
-0.0016547695,
0.619073391,
-0.6542631984,
0.0466561057,
0.0670770407,
-0.3230457604,
0.5065680742,
0.0674087927,
-0.1991518587,
0.2534208894,
-0.6845365167,
-0.0696968362,
0.1223219261,
-0.367375493,
-0.450719893,
0.1605203301,
-0.4552257061,
0.1474871337,
0.121428147,
-0.5814341903,
0.3943046331,
0.0567737818,
0.2623875439,
0.7329916954,
0.2403550297,
0.2923736572,
-0.4211490154,
0.0444880053,
0.2098200172,
0.4723689556,
-0.337558955,
-0.2518016994,
-0.7979885936,
-0.1568216383,
0.1713199914,
0.4122756422,
-0.9030264616,
0.0449040085,
-0.3811636567,
-0.303465426,
-0.3866090477,
-0.247745201,
0.3654260337,
0.9679350257,
0.5733671784,
-0.0122960741,
-0.3232941031,
-0.7930580974,
-0.3018573523,
-0.3632083237,
0.0698031187,
0.6013402343,
0.3740876913,
-0.272692889,
0.7115362883,
-0.9526883364,
-0.2688245773,
0.162487343,
0.730327189,
0.0771453381,
0.3573527038,
0.8063970208,
-0.7840858698,
-0.2964027822,
-0.0403895155,
-0.9308368564,
-0.2197686583,
-0.3009079695,
-0.3486127555,
0.3654109538,
0.5621432066,
-0.2075501829,
0.4293810427,
0.5128169656,
-0.4971749485,
0.4046849906,
-0.2437714785,
0.7100279927,
-0.8000565767,
-0.0261724088,
0.0121281249,
-0.3738027215,
-0.3755795956,
-0.4122604728,
0.0642492771,
0.0377778672,
-0.3100658655,
0.7243599296,
-0.2793494761,
0.0914211571,
-0.0734824166,
0.1463413239,
0.4318237305,
0.8013427854,
0.1103169546,
0.3850802183,
0.1881115586,
-0.5297737122,
0.2779912651,
0.1690268666,
-0.0484425239,
0.6839552522,
-0.572404623,
0.1917309761,
-0.3512291014,
0.4941164255,
-0.9649598598,
-0.2339466363,
0.3553935587,
-0.5539288521,
0.4610059559,
-0.6648297906,
-0.6003374457,
-0.210636884,
-0.1752628535,
0.2243293077,
-0.1038001031,
-0.7267766595,
1.5405219793,
0.2451557964,
-0.130261898,
-0.5935752392,
-0.3480590284,
-0.0668105185,
-0.0946694538,
-0.7409940362,
0.4332481921,
0.0063718338,
-0.2766822278,
0.43016541,
-0.3621611297,
-0.02665166,
-0.1603187174,
0.3744350076,
0.4509715736,
-0.2131633461,
0.2148047239,
0.4016774595,
-0.4132717252,
-0.0434414372,
-0.3264867961,
0.2329967171,
-0.0755121112,
-0.6231127381,
0.1407248825,
0.5025388598,
0.5295076966,
-0.1883055568,
0.8901492953,
0.8800597191,
-0.3477548361,
0.1145442873,
-0.7717729211,
0.2218802422,
-0.3971462846,
-0.0168063175,
-0.4865196049,
-1.0617282391,
0.3365561962,
-0.3558047116,
0.3619474471,
0.7346997857,
0.3025604486,
-0.388805151,
1.1816663742,
0.2269603163,
0.1702990234,
0.3541248143,
-0.2193692774,
-0.120572634,
-1.0527112484,
-0.6277697682,
-0.4112014174,
-0.1595893502,
-0.2156110704,
-0.4313242137,
0.7932280898,
-0.1440502405,
-0.5210065246,
-0.0165381413,
-0.4286378324,
0.0378967747,
0.4602947235,
0.0973492563,
0.404096812,
-0.4240832925,
-0.3614438474,
-0.011087521,
-0.8415566683,
-0.2810457349,
0.6450354457,
0.1575407088,
0.6789157987,
0.3616749048,
0.1455319524,
0.4568102658,
0.3997192085,
-0.2358773053,
0.3937353194,
-0.1369642168,
-0.9369779229,
-0.1549480408,
-0.7931683064,
-0.6438191533,
0.6114342809,
-0.4338279963,
-0.7614476085,
0.0102516431,
0.2210009396,
-0.2361395806,
0.3750672638,
-0.9330636263,
0.9765304923,
-0.5404919386,
-0.6886729598,
-0.1428646743,
-0.7733565569,
0.3311146498,
-0.0181487761,
0.3862874508,
-0.5668364763,
0.1926853359,
0.7170816064,
-0.2432496995,
0.8389012218,
-0.1926581711,
0.401782155,
0.2036826909,
0.3710467815,
0.3311551511,
0.1769725978,
-0.0052776304,
0.1364009082,
0.1917222142,
-0.3068603873,
-0.7560116649,
0.7385118008,
-0.4968506992,
-0.8073088527,
-0.8178357482,
-0.7111580372,
-0.2051721811,
0.2085008621,
-0.2167642564,
0.8304588795,
-0.2215349823,
0.0059408341,
0.3827202618,
-0.0908821523,
0.5152428746,
0.7976426482,
-0.3563442826,
-0.3529209495,
0.3475660384,
0.056625627,
0.0929571763,
0.8515666127,
0.4195235074,
-0.6002529263,
-0.0820480287,
-0.6258463264,
0.2981117666,
-0.7845352888,
-0.1326055676,
-1.2567988634,
-0.023235647,
-0.5036527514,
-0.1681408733,
-0.2697657049,
-0.5969492793,
-0.0813944042,
0.0044263634,
0.5486898422,
0.4496907592,
-0.0910057351,
0.2531871498,
-1.0847284794,
0.5824038386,
0.4605407417,
0.3310354054,
-0.1406727433,
-0.3887825012,
0.2062129378,
-0.2879625559,
-0.2230919003,
-0.6865992546,
0.0138177555,
0.0157787707,
0.883251071,
0.1850669831,
0.0879293382,
0.8386875987,
-0.6159489751,
0.4413373768,
0.0097058611,
-0.8883114457,
0.5661172271,
-0.4408331513,
0.3702271879,
0.1924555898,
0.3922486603,
-0.4804810286,
-0.2969368696,
-0.7173973322,
-0.6241546869,
0.6466819644,
0.1247776672,
-0.43606475,
0.3714012504,
0.2201723456,
0.0572467372,
0.2141486108,
-0.5744011402,
-0.2697209716,
-0.4626938999,
-0.0301034544,
0.0324998796,
-0.1014512703,
-0.374604255,
-0.2420948893,
0.4336086512,
-0.4142751396,
0.2063539177,
0.253451407,
0.0733252391,
-0.0409485884,
0.3919826746,
0.2219474912,
0.5939236879,
-0.4359870553,
0.5786816478,
0.4918022454,
-0.1599377543,
-0.0005226638,
0.6161767244,
-0.0235422961,
-0.0302282926,
0.6246224046,
0.7369866967,
0.2265784293,
-0.1008921042,
0.2081696689,
-0.2125670761,
-0.1216204762,
-0.0197344255,
0.1053763404,
0.1840919256,
0.6535821557,
0.329646349,
0.0733377561,
0.0702017024,
-0.6556945443,
-0.043955449,
0.058391165,
-0.2278226763,
0.0966806784,
0.9634921551,
0.1809287667,
0.1116100028,
0.3333911896,
-0.22551395,
-0.8758022189,
0.370035708,
0.2619320154,
0.5290722847,
-0.1162592024,
0.2330969721,
0.4681528211,
0.3553842902,
0.1152198017,
0.02157671,
-0.064660266,
-0.4461133182,
-0.5688391328,
-0.3531932831,
-0.5564799309,
-0.1043763459,
-0.364279598,
-0.1481064856,
-0.4571319818,
-0.3775862157,
0.3202402294,
-0.0092196818,
-0.4814634621,
0.1888014823,
-0.2424709499,
0.6219779253,
-0.8065606356,
0.6111701727,
0.4727075398,
-0.2248021513,
-0.6228415966,
-0.0005251147,
0.2546878755,
-0.5375488997,
0.4098275602,
0.0095697679,
-0.5731193423,
-0.1928998679,
-0.3667201698,
-0.6628878713,
1.1442008018,
0.2255540639,
-0.3870385885,
0.0392712206,
-0.435646832,
0.4237716496,
-0.3547771573,
0.1344836801,
0.4612225294,
0.7375025749,
0.502510488,
-0.6289557815,
-0.0389205962,
-0.3058047891,
-0.4087253511,
0.6993592381,
-0.6791328788,
0.8087005615,
-0.2448825985,
-0.347428441,
-0.5546215177,
0.7371997833,
0.2482781112,
0.9265769124,
0.5885974765,
0.6353064775,
0.7285234928,
-0.3556755483,
0.9961200356,
0.0631966963,
0.0964725167,
1.6647973061,
-0.5722849369,
0.2622146308,
0.2190492898,
-0.030486621,
0.642214179,
0.4358156025,
-0.0636878759,
0.3945077956,
-0.5111480355,
-0.096464105,
-0.5089321136,
-0.2967360318,
-0.4548071325,
0.1807347983,
0.3371166289,
-0.0750238821,
-0.363353163,
-0.281525135,
0.1549460441,
-0.0493054911,
-0.218953073,
0.6125237942,
-0.1842585802,
-0.6893661022,
-0.1749373227,
0.0782250687,
0.1087513119,
-0.6985422969,
-0.2445224822,
0.1837008446,
0.1125404388,
-0.2133745551,
-1.1690298319,
0.3745774925,
0.0799041241,
-0.1873195022,
-0.2171405554,
0.8877840638,
-0.3051319718,
-0.5227986574,
0.4871637523,
0.9007197618,
-0.1758113801,
-0.0506313965,
-0.6560920477,
-0.0269494485,
-0.1738906801,
-0.1174374148,
-0.0263858642,
0.6221512556,
-0.0650731921,
0.7239843011,
0.7443760633,
-0.3522655368,
0.067619428,
0.3475999534,
0.8723601103,
-0.5959818959,
-0.5510177612,
-0.7065836787,
0.4670210183,
-0.3424334824,
-0.1634797454,
0.7346882224,
0.7335743308,
0.6532885432,
0.3124423325,
0.6848028898,
-0.1693648696,
0.8917416334,
-0.7155539393,
0.4916537702,
-0.7374219298,
0.0198184773,
-0.2214544117,
-0.6619676948,
-0.1997599453,
0.3907966614,
-0.5813655257,
0.0375120975,
0.8687070012,
0.5062071681,
-0.1299139261,
-0.0068550771,
0.006583001,
0.0588479191,
0.4540047944,
0.7394912243,
1.1664690971,
-0.0494998395,
0.7964271903,
-0.1684603691,
-0.2081699669,
-0.1794018149,
-1.3232320547,
-1.212269783,
-0.644354105,
-0.573605597,
-0.2931720614,
0.0874773487,
0.6988174915,
0.6563266516,
-0.2725538015,
0.3677698076,
0.6993302703,
0.3540924191,
-0.1082950234,
-0.2146098465,
0.5306978822,
0.3721438944,
-0.4111584425,
0.3546530306,
0.6117587686,
0.2264553159,
0.0434779711,
0.1764006764,
-0.4019901156,
-0.0184368137,
0.5913447738,
0.070096463,
-0.3592303693,
-0.602846384,
-0.0302091129,
-0.0867666826,
0.2857531309,
0.9227719903,
-0.6676630378,
0.6078341603,
0.5568048954,
0.2036459148,
1.094189167,
0.2602297068,
0.2380308956,
-0.813867867,
0.1127180159,
0.0305250492,
0.5499508977,
0.4224204719,
-0.4524661303,
0.7026965022,
0.4226050675,
-0.3590288162,
-0.5079087615,
0.2876015007,
-1.1662312746,
-0.5369662046,
0.8443445563,
-0.1158842221,
-0.2042640448,
-0.3306078017,
-0.1287784576,
0.7023922801,
-0.4521016777,
0.7018694282,
0.6756927371,
-0.6428661346,
-0.2599352896,
-0.5394778848,
0.0563623495,
-0.1456017494,
-1.1944111586,
-0.148450315,
0.7880758643,
0.228999272,
0.3259301782,
0.6288931966,
-0.1653774828,
0.1198759079,
0.3190058172,
-0.430519104,
-0.7012295127,
-0.7921994328,
0.2296382636,
0.3662810028,
-0.3715943694,
-0.1066780239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04799v1
|
DACBERT: Leveraging Dependency Agreement for Cost-Efficient Bert Pretraining
| 2023-11-08T16:18:32 | 2023-11-08T16:18:32 |
Martin Kuo, Jianyi Zhang, Yiran Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Building on the cost-efficient pretraining advancements brought about by
Crammed BERT, we enhance its performance and interpretability further by
introducing a novel pretrained model Dependency Agreement Crammed BERT
(DACBERT) and its two-stage pretraining framework - Dependency Agreement
Pretraining. This framework, grounded by linguistic theories, seamlessly weaves
syntax and semantic information into the pretraining process. The first stage
employs four dedicated submodels to capture representative dependency
agreements at the chunk level, effectively converting these agreements into
embeddings. The second stage uses these refined embeddings, in tandem with
conventional BERT embeddings, to guide the pretraining of the rest of the
model. Evaluated on the GLUE benchmark, our DACBERT demonstrates notable
improvement across various tasks, surpassing Crammed BERT by 3.13% in the RTE
task and by 2.26% in the MRPC task. Furthermore, our method boosts the average
GLUE score by 0.83%, underscoring its significant potential. The pretraining
process can be efficiently executed on a single GPU within a 24-hour cycle,
necessitating no supplementary computational resources or extending the
pretraining duration compared with the Crammed BERT. Extensive studies further
illuminate our approach's instrumental role in bolstering the interpretability
of pretrained language models for natural language understanding tasks.
|
[
-0.4311859608,
-0.5232563019,
0.427308023,
0.5784721375,
-0.4550316036,
-0.0542198196,
-0.3669231832,
-0.5371328592,
0.1347512901,
0.392487973,
-0.5579491854,
-0.2084776014,
-0.8161040545,
-0.2785407007,
-0.0073747002,
0.9055371881,
-0.0048093218,
0.0191316903,
-0.4394572377,
0.1602715105,
-0.6772888899,
-0.5039572716,
-0.3309851885,
-0.3282081485,
0.6662394404,
0.2202755511,
0.5257157087,
0.4776079953,
0.6806830764,
0.2876054943,
-0.0496459417,
-0.1194084287,
-0.5765504837,
-0.0230878089,
-0.1215839833,
-0.148962006,
-0.7621492147,
0.2936623096,
0.2798256278,
0.5891154408,
-0.6046975255,
0.0101820193,
0.2222671509,
0.6204241514,
-0.888252914,
0.4463097751,
-0.8829748034,
-0.1967245936,
-0.1373792738,
0.1472485662,
-0.6449760795,
-0.1836830229,
0.4691739976,
-0.8194640875,
0.0267140567,
-0.2727896869,
1.0835973024,
0.767934978,
-0.3053916693,
-0.3621199429,
-0.1781150997,
0.8171115518,
-0.7574243546,
0.5564653277,
0.4887821376,
0.2296192646,
-0.2453484386,
-1.1750074625,
-0.6189162731,
-0.2296272218,
-0.2851511538,
0.1867054105,
0.0910520405,
0.3403827548,
0.0749018937,
0.400275141,
-0.4982174635,
0.2286550552,
-0.2722494304,
-0.1947347224,
0.469920963,
-0.17528826,
0.1500457227,
-0.0729144588,
-0.6675520539,
-0.0956170857,
-0.40487656,
-0.0569266155,
0.1276772916,
0.312566936,
-0.114449501,
-0.0261368863,
0.1988323778,
0.8519952297,
0.3399272263,
0.109905228,
0.1602952927,
-0.1166780666,
-0.2858299613,
0.2699683607,
0.6582471728,
-0.0991671458,
0.2164703906,
-0.0992042199,
0.060604576,
0.1899895072,
0.8051460981,
-0.950779438,
-0.817027092,
0.1007584855,
-0.3349621892,
-0.0633103698,
-0.0140540591,
-0.6676018238,
-0.2037846297,
-0.5201109648,
0.3462813199,
-0.4179092348,
-0.2303120047,
0.1211456805,
0.2221175432,
0.2629680932,
0.5332618356,
-1.0838989019,
0.2610931993,
0.6128286123,
0.5766038895,
-0.0926728472,
-0.3635611236,
-0.5292904377,
0.1336035877,
-0.226963982,
0.9402825832,
-0.3426962197,
0.0014992651,
-0.1491449922,
-0.2829313576,
-0.1353003383,
-0.3321292698,
0.418513447,
-0.6717681289,
0.2592916191,
-0.3455425203,
-0.6473736167,
-0.3452712893,
0.2515716851,
-0.7630257607,
1.3169806004,
0.2781436145,
-0.6597773433,
0.8476118445,
-0.5024690032,
-0.4819901884,
0.0668865815,
-0.0897283703,
-0.2273419797,
0.0039703087,
0.1843311042,
0.5070328712,
-0.1714818776,
0.3264060616,
-0.4501616061,
-0.2159995139,
-0.1700138301,
-0.0595913231,
1.0334382057,
0.0900790766,
-0.4174130261,
-0.1310691386,
-0.9102435708,
-0.0234983526,
-0.1423786134,
-0.5358948112,
-0.3242274523,
-0.128388375,
-0.0596723333,
0.3659646809,
0.437887013,
-0.4964380562,
0.3492978811,
-0.3237215281,
0.2704938948,
0.9804795384,
-0.394231081,
0.4943493307,
0.1441111565,
0.3213109374,
0.044458162,
0.2680213153,
-0.0478174835,
-0.2497400194,
-0.6698718667,
-0.7452831864,
0.6297069192,
0.2686555982,
-0.600684166,
0.6781445146,
-0.1520285457,
-0.4547995627,
-0.4879634678,
0.2547920644,
0.4610768259,
0.4966202676,
0.599029839,
-0.7607489228,
-0.511547029,
-0.5709537864,
-0.0977157056,
-0.3610155582,
0.1991967559,
-0.0745301694,
0.2527753115,
-0.174864471,
1.0488407612,
-0.480125159,
-0.6442563534,
-0.2566113472,
0.5644232035,
0.1891534477,
0.6536684036,
0.9765638113,
-0.6019014716,
-0.880559206,
-0.3433642387,
-0.3520751595,
-0.0072840112,
-0.1906102896,
-0.3598636687,
0.3526162207,
0.2215502858,
-0.5360565782,
0.6368327141,
0.7667626143,
-0.2327474058,
0.535975337,
-0.5248513222,
-0.0289147981,
-0.5250537395,
-0.1547010392,
-0.6118248105,
-0.1721941382,
-0.5786902905,
-0.2702527344,
0.1089464799,
0.2440279871,
-0.5185066462,
0.4073340893,
-0.6286913157,
0.181637153,
-0.1806464046,
0.1896962374,
0.0864478946,
0.7533456683,
0.0432562605,
0.6297337413,
0.4137373269,
-0.7404192686,
0.1148338541,
0.7268931866,
-0.553196907,
0.2750944495,
-0.6977736354,
0.4567585289,
0.1154882982,
0.4334225655,
-0.9423602223,
-0.0606729351,
0.2803227901,
-0.3696397245,
0.6017240882,
0.0526228994,
-0.2928785384,
-0.2055091113,
-0.0650550276,
0.5258593559,
0.4782938361,
-0.8852943182,
0.8076841235,
0.3777371645,
-0.1512064636,
-0.976557672,
-0.8237502575,
-0.0216095373,
0.2786408961,
-0.5289871693,
0.6092138886,
-0.1478298753,
0.1080846041,
0.1040466651,
-0.2253850698,
-0.6556836963,
0.2089867443,
0.1334705055,
0.2970393896,
0.0027409429,
0.1684046388,
0.0490855537,
-0.3734865785,
-0.0550557077,
-0.3493861854,
0.3703452051,
0.1798082888,
-0.2715157568,
-0.3341927826,
0.1354426146,
0.414499402,
-0.305231899,
0.9788041711,
0.5759979486,
-0.252317369,
-0.1278470159,
-0.7693371177,
-0.0330891237,
-0.4557127953,
0.2429420799,
-0.2518205643,
-0.6732772589,
0.2903541327,
0.1951326728,
0.2875383198,
0.1336591691,
0.6397725344,
-0.1782455742,
0.5870918036,
0.881618619,
-0.0922628269,
0.8425860405,
0.0386303179,
0.2842040658,
-0.3260716498,
-0.0548665151,
-0.3570103049,
-0.250313729,
-0.2325533032,
-0.4313558042,
-0.0768231973,
0.2195250243,
-0.1823235899,
0.5850434303,
-0.4716706872,
0.3371967077,
0.6653398871,
0.2519367933,
0.0216329135,
-0.258128494,
-0.1116615683,
-0.1632064879,
-0.860940218,
-0.3019722998,
0.8677349091,
0.0778705925,
0.5618411303,
-0.0689341277,
0.7387467027,
0.3099304736,
0.4093696475,
-0.7260286212,
0.4419573545,
-0.2240033299,
-0.8693147302,
-0.0788451061,
-0.2524121404,
-0.8465576172,
0.1528075784,
-0.3921367824,
-0.604006052,
0.3603482246,
0.4962421358,
-0.1595383734,
0.0213675052,
-0.6931749582,
1.2116290331,
-0.4904261827,
-0.2954042852,
-0.6585503817,
-0.9315881729,
0.2516666055,
-0.2225893885,
0.0229559001,
-0.129553929,
0.2050845325,
0.8612516522,
-0.4889541268,
0.7897253036,
-0.4896121025,
-0.1623300463,
0.3583259583,
-0.2300350517,
0.4152216613,
-0.3000524938,
-0.0721415132,
0.4131566286,
0.0747274831,
-0.7699882388,
-0.6732273698,
0.2504146695,
-0.5534499288,
-0.2406937331,
-0.5663816333,
-0.7455455065,
-0.2202099711,
0.2851412296,
0.0079268189,
0.4202805758,
-0.3627949655,
-0.0510916002,
0.5129823685,
-0.2756395936,
0.2928420305,
0.316478014,
0.0393873304,
-0.4692028463,
0.7420621514,
0.0126303593,
0.3490481377,
0.4053054154,
-0.1394351721,
-0.2748074532,
-0.5979062319,
-0.0923420936,
0.3209000528,
-0.7657759786,
-0.2326696664,
-0.5544037223,
0.1509779692,
-0.6135385036,
-0.3059131205,
-0.6184687614,
-0.5917069316,
-0.255371809,
-0.1672567874,
0.1577917337,
0.7158723474,
-0.2953121662,
0.6397787333,
-1.0937950611,
0.305934757,
0.4414859414,
0.4402972162,
-0.0390479565,
-0.422598362,
-0.727920711,
-0.1267859489,
-0.4625717998,
-0.742469728,
0.2174970061,
0.3758102953,
0.9030206203,
0.4570774138,
0.3796627223,
1.0562946796,
-0.4372815192,
0.782749474,
0.4204529226,
-1.2294688225,
0.2817471027,
0.0050929482,
-0.058579199,
1.0173965693,
0.371206969,
0.0722591802,
-0.3097065389,
-0.6454391479,
-0.8365189433,
0.7944021225,
-0.0145623581,
-0.058367718,
0.0048634522,
0.2809475362,
0.2133810073,
0.203500852,
-0.5490632653,
-0.0167624764,
-0.2981714606,
-0.4361854792,
-0.0806146711,
-0.6858960986,
0.1089290902,
-0.3966377676,
0.8499293327,
0.0860021785,
0.294906199,
0.0251036659,
-0.6143615246,
0.3029892743,
0.0888039023,
0.358492136,
0.883885622,
-0.3939971626,
0.099490568,
0.126734972,
-0.7696144581,
0.1351716518,
0.3276919425,
0.5214396715,
0.0215358101,
0.4534729123,
0.6837688088,
0.4702407718,
-0.5632502437,
0.5280863047,
-0.2351837456,
-0.4039087892,
-0.0568056405,
-0.1633207798,
-0.0432140864,
0.1675697565,
-0.0568335541,
-0.1473614573,
-0.1382769495,
-0.2105673403,
0.5041238666,
0.1331533492,
-0.6767511368,
-0.2657818496,
0.5565732718,
0.3960240483,
0.2410186827,
1.1070560217,
-0.1187256128,
-0.7554755211,
0.29391554,
0.0914105922,
0.841229856,
-0.3481750786,
0.0963790342,
0.3635267019,
0.2638385892,
-0.0487768762,
0.1018633246,
-0.430631429,
-0.7898943424,
-0.7937486172,
-0.5602176785,
-0.4955394864,
-0.4738695621,
-1.0831638575,
0.339399606,
-0.3373402655,
-0.0691644102,
-0.3591281772,
0.0117180273,
-0.7508480549,
0.2620461285,
0.1537383646,
0.9139406085,
-0.6961759329,
1.1081012487,
0.8885841966,
-0.5646317601,
-0.9534260631,
-0.0916010886,
-0.2496044189,
-0.7393422723,
1.0603249073,
0.1739916503,
0.2177470773,
-0.0460640006,
-0.4390893579,
-0.5862637162,
0.9428498745,
0.7240306735,
-0.5418498516,
-0.1664100438,
-0.0782181174,
0.3204279244,
-0.1365756094,
0.4439173937,
0.8601298332,
0.6376774311,
0.0691799447,
-0.9921054244,
0.1713568717,
-0.0630077645,
-0.2213547528,
0.2361060679,
-0.3396357894,
0.797876358,
-0.1079932153,
-0.2365644127,
-0.1936780959,
0.9712856412,
0.0668701231,
0.0154560125,
0.8571658134,
0.7977672219,
0.8392723203,
-0.0047601867,
0.7066477537,
-0.4213783145,
0.5641155243,
1.4137332439,
-0.1514151394,
0.6981601119,
0.5118277669,
-0.4580799043,
0.9582667351,
0.7129865289,
0.3291588128,
0.8094070554,
0.1293327957,
-0.1538097709,
-0.5407079458,
0.0693067983,
-0.3750956655,
0.5018573403,
0.2478927821,
-0.0387552045,
-0.267557621,
-0.1043674722,
-0.1244864017,
-0.1483969837,
0.1450998038,
0.9952625632,
0.2520424128,
-0.4289678931,
0.6641987562,
-0.7604267001,
0.4937534928,
-0.79195714,
-0.2085685879,
0.0593536012,
0.4497224987,
-0.1428807527,
-0.1893481612,
0.2602628469,
-0.1487832516,
-0.2434512973,
-0.5894189477,
0.6635771394,
-0.4310464859,
-0.1528481543,
0.5979868174,
0.2137568295,
0.1486687064,
-0.1007442102,
-0.7419964671,
0.0383562632,
-0.1425790936,
-0.3561570048,
0.4206590354,
0.4421027899,
0.4716266692,
0.2849723101,
0.4565656781,
0.0967591554,
0.1629763991,
-0.1927852631,
1.0376969576,
-0.3632333577,
-0.6005442142,
-0.5089029074,
0.8601224422,
0.0506194569,
-0.1046296656,
0.4418783188,
0.1538424939,
0.9999130368,
0.0724328533,
0.6497635841,
-0.4277552366,
0.3148314059,
-0.4736238718,
0.7115972042,
-0.5487157702,
0.2398119271,
-0.4068202972,
-0.9000792503,
-0.3622562587,
0.7925540209,
-0.4604920447,
-0.1084160879,
0.9302767515,
0.4812737703,
-0.1003507376,
0.0394751765,
0.1448695511,
0.2864515483,
0.452465117,
0.5659193993,
0.8323488832,
-0.2549744844,
0.794446826,
-0.4841002524,
-0.5030196905,
-0.0302015059,
-1.2728830576,
-0.9428331852,
-0.3389712572,
-0.3580856621,
-0.1167584062,
0.0129629038,
1.0917061567,
0.9361101985,
-0.9128565788,
-0.1324643046,
-0.170726493,
-0.0761256367,
-0.4239257872,
-0.1728690565,
0.3445592523,
-0.988853395,
-0.6683727503,
0.2041138113,
0.0983318612,
-0.2362706363,
0.0175553914,
-0.1691436321,
-0.4624737799,
-0.1051411629,
0.537014246,
0.0617612228,
-0.5256925821,
-0.3447337747,
-0.2805629075,
-0.0567918792,
0.2466736585,
0.9810932875,
-0.9044450521,
0.6732209921,
0.6674535871,
0.992820859,
0.7181268334,
-0.0174317062,
0.8106061816,
-0.5260374546,
0.4792487621,
0.0899184197,
0.2390580773,
0.0540348627,
-0.2344863713,
0.4769424796,
0.1168122962,
-0.7240600586,
-0.8535654545,
0.1136100143,
-1.2668818235,
-0.3032641709,
0.5538779497,
-0.7701810002,
0.0423160046,
-0.3641156256,
-0.1815659255,
0.474008739,
-0.3629224896,
0.8452079296,
0.7101241946,
-0.1389218718,
0.0660768896,
-0.2066930532,
0.4808000922,
0.7065164447,
-0.7669016123,
0.1774719954,
0.6032103896,
-0.0733813867,
0.1314850599,
0.7910615802,
0.148166433,
0.1628188193,
0.0657407641,
0.4739749134,
-0.1132122502,
-0.534668386,
-0.0568236001,
-0.2384937257,
-0.0504788347,
-0.4053741097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04789v1
|
Determination of toxic comments and unintended model bias minimization using Deep learning approach
| 2023-11-08T16:10:28 | 2023-11-08T16:10:28 |
Md Azim Khan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Online conversations can be toxic and subjected to threats, abuse, or
harassment. To identify toxic text comments, several deep learning and machine
learning models have been proposed throughout the years. However, recent
studies demonstrate that because of the imbalances in the training data, some
models are more likely to show unintended biases including gender bias and
identity bias. In this research, our aim is to detect toxic comment and reduce
the unintended bias concerning identity features such as race, gender, sex,
religion by fine-tuning an attention based model called BERT(Bidirectional
Encoder Representation from Transformers). We apply weighted loss to address
the issue of unbalanced data and compare the performance of a fine-tuned BERT
model with a traditional Logistic Regression model in terms of classification
and bias minimization. The Logistic Regression model with the TFIDF vectorizer
achieve 57.1% accuracy, and fine-tuned BERT model's accuracy is 89%. Code is
available at
https://github.com/zim10/Determine_Toxic_comment_and_identity_bias.git
|
[
-0.4686764777,
-0.8330354095,
0.3439794481,
0.1197568923,
-0.2533744872,
0.0946213752,
-0.2888923883,
-0.4578160644,
-0.2577732205,
0.4325722158,
-0.8202187419,
-0.3472555876,
-0.5811288357,
-0.073692508,
-0.3691059947,
1.4044905901,
0.2792635262,
0.4459428787,
-0.1414621174,
-0.1061265916,
-0.4499226213,
-0.488991797,
-0.5662837625,
-0.5214921236,
0.5989735723,
0.0998118743,
0.5228956938,
-0.0370850079,
0.5828155279,
0.2429948747,
-0.5231466889,
0.1556101143,
-0.7646528482,
0.0136819547,
-0.1951322705,
-0.2986544967,
-0.1687619239,
-0.2174373269,
0.3288711011,
0.4561958909,
-0.0166498236,
0.5183974504,
0.2235906273,
0.6415494084,
-0.7326878905,
0.0642432645,
-0.7042270303,
0.3524953127,
0.1192919686,
-0.1470397562,
-0.5559604168,
-0.5233025551,
0.2488681972,
-0.1261345297,
0.3552341461,
-0.3351677656,
0.7767295837,
0.4803690016,
-0.5653275847,
0.0037838905,
-1.020729661,
0.8374349475,
-1.0906904936,
0.2903529108,
0.1353872716,
0.0857414827,
-0.0235132538,
-0.3911736906,
-0.4129727483,
-0.1280158907,
-0.2351038605,
-0.0038070113,
-0.1163447723,
0.2116026431,
0.3620123267,
-0.0259286016,
-0.2858099341,
0.1630416065,
-0.2858752012,
-0.2630263269,
0.7598655224,
0.1116373762,
0.1766223609,
0.0003667529,
-0.2538889945,
0.1087458655,
-0.2828837335,
0.0417752787,
0.604772687,
0.4273815751,
0.0600876398,
0.3658186197,
0.0615449697,
0.3913734555,
0.1858111918,
0.0887178853,
0.2978285253,
-0.1062991545,
-0.2423309088,
0.1090126187,
0.7311702967,
0.6582728624,
0.4859519303,
0.0538312495,
0.0004849659,
0.1051063389,
0.5019683242,
-1.111489892,
-0.264002353,
0.0161879547,
-1.050168395,
-0.7224082947,
-0.2247934937,
-0.8942503929,
-0.7770668864,
-0.1459190845,
0.3135244548,
-0.1162964553,
-0.329280436,
-0.1862565577,
-0.1468214542,
0.0095037362,
0.484277904,
-0.7139909267,
0.191862911,
0.4276277423,
0.6462759972,
-0.0300451294,
0.5039935708,
-0.1909444779,
0.0267639309,
-0.1516208947,
0.5585246086,
-0.5910581946,
-0.1007400453,
0.1884993911,
-0.0867395252,
0.160272032,
-0.4500420988,
0.9221458435,
-0.5197383761,
0.292270571,
-0.3147988319,
-0.5572383404,
-0.4519091249,
0.2717725337,
-0.432885766,
0.8142684698,
-0.0440181606,
-1.2036529779,
0.2819271982,
-0.6514129639,
-0.5484867692,
0.0262655839,
0.1983948648,
-0.7893693447,
0.0259531196,
0.1393496096,
0.3308793008,
-0.1455760747,
0.1869293749,
-0.8202701211,
-0.4413481951,
0.2754198015,
-0.3391289115,
1.0232342482,
0.4309099317,
-0.6090741158,
0.2587022483,
-0.5249121189,
0.1606905609,
-0.000226467,
-0.3080182672,
-0.3600850403,
0.3351470828,
0.4491427541,
0.3042491376,
0.0359806344,
-0.9400048852,
-0.1663831472,
-0.3557565808,
0.3955732286,
0.9227657914,
0.0289274473,
0.2130803168,
-0.1625466049,
0.0747159645,
0.3297285736,
0.401031971,
0.2355115712,
-0.4068866372,
-0.8255083561,
0.0579193085,
0.2574789524,
0.5985846519,
-0.3374122977,
0.4963300824,
-0.0657614022,
-0.4226453304,
-0.5326412916,
0.3075668216,
0.4451564252,
0.5958919525,
0.2552656531,
-0.3185382187,
-0.654409349,
-1.1205655336,
-0.3130319118,
-0.2233698964,
-0.2141533047,
0.5158240199,
0.3357410133,
-0.6768473983,
0.8277769089,
-0.4520401061,
-0.5908793807,
0.0598961897,
0.3173525929,
-0.0346471332,
0.5179495215,
0.6922537684,
-0.781955719,
-0.6699745655,
-0.0234437361,
-0.6424325109,
-0.152867794,
-0.0356465913,
-0.0927222446,
0.1509275883,
0.4547568262,
-0.3370842934,
0.3450365961,
0.1813137084,
-0.2681048512,
0.0114625143,
0.0565726086,
0.0741819963,
-0.6246293783,
0.2204817981,
0.2106640339,
-0.2661979795,
-0.8179622889,
-0.0915842801,
0.0785360411,
0.0532567427,
-0.4458496273,
0.1700915247,
-0.0967238024,
0.3165089786,
-0.1311959922,
-0.2600164711,
-0.1997824907,
0.7320508957,
-0.0218964033,
0.3728337288,
0.0888725221,
-0.3828137219,
0.2360061258,
0.3527744412,
-0.3323530257,
0.3547089994,
-0.6924932599,
0.329082191,
-0.4370000958,
0.2526909709,
-1.0225689411,
0.1130334437,
0.2991805077,
-0.5525473356,
0.2749967873,
-0.1064348146,
-0.4440605938,
-0.4766646624,
-0.5105459094,
0.4284725487,
0.4702872634,
-0.259932518,
0.5179973841,
0.6018682718,
-0.1235285848,
-0.632371664,
-0.7517637014,
-0.2233170569,
-0.0369315557,
-0.4808468819,
0.1188060045,
-0.4042784572,
-0.0998973474,
-0.0559503473,
0.0506265089,
-0.1552564204,
0.0591429807,
0.189984113,
0.1058645099,
-0.0632712916,
0.2990991473,
0.0523951277,
0.2339489758,
0.5121330023,
0.2243251204,
0.5670760274,
-0.1549190581,
-0.0649683177,
-0.4795959592,
0.2918445766,
0.5643023849,
-0.1534608901,
0.7208468914,
0.7592573166,
-0.5029774308,
-0.1803936064,
-0.6479732394,
-0.3870670795,
-0.4933152497,
0.5865705013,
0.3264525831,
-0.8235598803,
0.7806639671,
0.0894716531,
0.0675661638,
0.4659783244,
0.8674113154,
-0.2663625181,
1.5626248121,
0.6931310892,
-0.1576054096,
0.603384316,
-0.0814215541,
0.4016558826,
-0.6566842794,
-0.4607727826,
-0.3995523751,
-0.5900297165,
-0.7770439386,
-0.0539291166,
0.3493718803,
-0.5849757791,
-0.6870082617,
-0.1868378073,
-0.7698776126,
0.3039343953,
0.5168274641,
0.6709150076,
-0.0640371814,
-0.1500753313,
-0.0337823741,
-0.2573948801,
-0.4235363007,
-0.3522511125,
1.0733338594,
0.73862046,
0.975898385,
0.081166245,
0.2522365749,
0.7098306417,
0.5911554694,
-0.6415506005,
0.3944265246,
-0.131717667,
-1.060426712,
-0.1538201421,
-0.6456219554,
-0.4802223146,
0.0210228208,
-0.394251138,
-0.6759421825,
0.2941500247,
0.1353375465,
-0.3445360363,
0.5182147026,
-0.7548847795,
0.8611266017,
-0.1937215477,
-0.413567394,
-0.3031398356,
-0.8080502152,
0.4908207655,
-0.1669226587,
0.0794293135,
-0.1988588721,
0.3496499658,
0.8368117809,
-0.3133731484,
1.1552714109,
-0.4233131111,
-0.2627873421,
0.2106221765,
-0.1197634265,
0.3200277984,
-0.0495796092,
0.0374887586,
0.3276490271,
-0.1187276542,
-0.0795638114,
-0.3274849951,
0.5622307062,
-1.0135984421,
-0.2289741784,
-0.2144582719,
-0.4513585269,
-0.2989572287,
0.3330944777,
0.2591531873,
-0.0876533017,
-0.232671693,
0.2815069556,
1.0094209909,
-0.4149833024,
0.4914056659,
0.5132274032,
0.144519791,
-0.1937344819,
0.635902226,
-0.0541381054,
0.0507818982,
0.2940325737,
0.1504240483,
-0.0934090167,
-0.2236840129,
-0.1069257036,
0.0994524956,
-0.7454842329,
-0.5979635715,
-0.626240015,
-0.4928495884,
-0.2828731835,
0.2900675833,
-0.412486732,
0.0233579651,
-0.4353915155,
-0.0549547598,
0.1770780087,
0.6640720367,
0.2691481113,
0.3671219051,
-0.7626580596,
0.0593894757,
0.4019586742,
0.7118589282,
0.3771470785,
-0.6192738414,
-0.1879932433,
0.4136057794,
-0.6025525928,
-0.9908236265,
0.380156517,
0.3169846535,
0.3613017499,
0.7762679458,
0.3066355884,
0.4689528048,
-0.3320580721,
0.5001793504,
0.1379865259,
-0.9020068049,
0.6159999967,
-0.3643426895,
-0.0196095705,
0.4345445335,
0.3714306951,
-0.5711175203,
-0.5445928574,
-0.4780882299,
-0.5403626561,
0.7143699527,
0.3051084876,
0.3918184936,
0.1774499118,
0.2066941708,
-0.0016689731,
0.3762336075,
-0.9765711427,
-0.5321937203,
-0.1224882826,
-0.2790198028,
0.1993799508,
-0.7174501419,
-0.2722041309,
-0.5241785049,
0.7115747929,
0.0243318789,
0.390642941,
-0.0385055169,
-0.1662638038,
-0.5683777928,
0.2064198703,
0.6370078325,
0.2653714418,
-0.6282157898,
-0.0845801979,
0.2602373064,
-0.5188188553,
0.0966292769,
0.0109026022,
-0.5027474761,
0.1207724512,
0.3160325587,
0.7344813943,
0.1734609902,
-0.6144142151,
0.6804866195,
-0.2163231522,
-0.189913556,
-0.2756033838,
0.02044346,
-0.0550588518,
0.2766639292,
0.3325717449,
0.391048938,
0.3973049223,
-0.4323850572,
0.2414219677,
0.7126437426,
-0.6175823808,
-0.0688209832,
0.8358894587,
0.4939520657,
-0.0508488715,
0.6977677345,
0.1441890299,
-0.7383158207,
0.6126999259,
0.3248558342,
0.9850114584,
-0.3288300633,
0.3269355595,
0.4717525542,
0.4266278148,
0.305049181,
0.1552288234,
0.0148160188,
-0.8608580232,
-0.2010280639,
-0.5241545439,
-0.2554989457,
0.338444531,
-0.7762678266,
0.3017432988,
-0.7382400632,
-0.4919095039,
0.246169284,
0.0976220667,
-0.5617035627,
0.2040955573,
0.4991363883,
0.539488554,
-1.1629333496,
0.5248408318,
0.5503823757,
-0.3310047388,
-0.4091365635,
-0.0483232476,
-0.0036462848,
-0.5760614872,
0.7706090212,
0.3667861521,
0.1010690406,
-0.1956549436,
-0.7526105642,
-0.5968376398,
0.4820483625,
0.6369556189,
-0.5550044179,
0.1991211027,
0.0910449326,
0.804400444,
-0.0907243416,
0.5970568657,
0.3247026205,
0.3829056323,
0.0070234686,
-0.8354161382,
0.0320247374,
-0.4968553782,
0.2315258384,
0.1677273065,
-0.6579458117,
0.7705588937,
-0.2184343487,
-0.1590879261,
-0.3205115497,
0.4871339202,
-0.2948893905,
0.2267350405,
0.6398651004,
0.5097869635,
0.5247719884,
0.0045748246,
0.5179754496,
-0.1323185563,
0.7351843119,
0.9665775895,
-0.2754398286,
0.5657049417,
0.2313950658,
-0.0192261133,
0.7039744854,
0.8542386293,
-0.3804584146,
0.7340022326,
0.2031158954,
-0.3805862367,
-0.2327547222,
-0.3064914644,
-0.3272680938,
0.2950596809,
0.2498363853,
-0.6773179173,
-0.2303602844,
0.165937826,
0.0930754021,
-0.0310118999,
-0.4218295813,
1.0349992514,
-0.2136171907,
-0.4624803364,
0.4851182103,
0.0860145912,
0.892139852,
-0.4217228591,
-0.1036977395,
-0.2615197897,
0.6491682529,
-0.4026637673,
-0.5546992421,
0.1873783171,
-0.0196543317,
-0.3258549273,
-0.2277178168,
0.8758924603,
-0.6464133859,
-0.6557477713,
0.4303814471,
0.0103485826,
-0.3172748983,
-0.2045761794,
-0.8021698594,
-0.1078705713,
0.2267638147,
-0.2265748084,
0.2687760293,
0.1412574798,
0.0387299098,
0.8218129277,
0.5709373951,
-0.0626640022,
-0.1321183443,
0.2325029522,
1.0358536243,
-0.3612964153,
-0.4679479003,
-1.0446990728,
0.456217885,
-0.2757739723,
-0.106525667,
0.6154184341,
0.4413022101,
0.8817773461,
-0.3428690135,
0.736594975,
0.0257789996,
0.6906653047,
0.0022866349,
1.1327575445,
-0.340167135,
0.0322433524,
-0.5730985999,
-0.7359064221,
-0.3150520921,
0.8210172653,
-0.0263985675,
0.3352316022,
0.4147721827,
0.780336678,
0.0258948524,
0.0175746139,
-0.0123049794,
0.4185328186,
0.3461929858,
0.5688237548,
0.5527268052,
-0.4010216296,
0.5338119268,
-0.3896327019,
-0.1909630597,
-0.4768668115,
-0.9146126509,
-1.2033371925,
-0.307315886,
-0.4185798168,
-0.373357296,
-0.0841172636,
0.6807200909,
0.5987064242,
-1.1085761786,
0.0404494442,
0.0984499231,
0.2813836038,
-0.0846374705,
-0.2924359739,
0.1180067137,
-0.2622586489,
-0.6111718416,
-0.38295573,
-0.0755433366,
-0.1460144073,
-0.3046789765,
-0.0728138611,
-0.2930684984,
0.0780931786,
0.7167264223,
0.0147651006,
-0.5240214467,
-0.5560913682,
-0.2059005052,
-0.1818178147,
-0.0724235028,
0.7208859921,
-0.5600317717,
0.5968712568,
0.4201583862,
0.6094497442,
0.467028439,
0.0388685614,
0.607201159,
-0.9182587266,
0.2094118744,
0.5111922622,
0.1660669893,
0.3222132921,
-0.7724363208,
0.4131042361,
0.1808808446,
-0.5580343604,
-1.0424933434,
-0.0027727115,
-0.8382624984,
-0.3299078047,
1.059429884,
-0.0300794411,
0.009340887,
0.09710785,
-0.4331128895,
0.4877693951,
-0.4442417324,
1.0619595051,
0.5760017037,
-0.0091476412,
-0.2627816498,
-0.419642061,
0.757895112,
0.5610510707,
-0.6299723387,
0.1714540571,
0.4406171739,
0.3998190761,
0.0629440248,
0.1998463869,
0.074893333,
0.2374235988,
-0.434981823,
0.293795228,
0.1134571433,
-0.0161672328,
-0.2799287736,
0.0896076709,
-0.3791113198,
-0.2711793184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04742v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04742v2
|
Using large language models to study human memory for meaningful narratives
| 2023-11-08T15:11:57 | 2023-11-28T05:25:45 |
Antonios Georgiou, Tankut Can, Mikhail Katkov, Misha Tsodyks
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
One of the most impressive achievements of the AI revolution is the
development of large language models that can generate meaningful text and
respond to instructions in plain English with no additional training necessary.
Here we show that language models can be used as a scientific instrument for
studying human memory for meaningful material. We developed a pipeline for
designing large scale memory experiments and analyzing the obtained results. We
performed online memory experiments with a large number of participants and
collected recognition and recall data for narratives of different lengths. We
found that both recall and recognition performance scale linearly with
narrative length. Furthermore, in order to investigate the role of narrative
comprehension in memory, we repeated these experiments using scrambled versions
of the presented stories. We found that even though recall performance declined
significantly, recognition remained largely unaffected. Interestingly, recalls
in this condition seem to follow the original narrative order rather than the
scrambled presentation, pointing to a contextual reconstruction of the story in
memory.
|
[
-0.1758684665,
-0.7847147584,
0.7900946736,
-0.0439379252,
-0.0630534664,
-0.0698884875,
-0.4178087711,
-0.5781237483,
0.3153269291,
0.485186398,
-0.0047916621,
-0.1745041758,
-0.3860988617,
-0.0336470641,
-0.7314248681,
0.7692332268,
-0.2615115941,
-0.0221220348,
-0.2301288098,
-0.2830615044,
-0.6667811275,
-0.6943030953,
-0.6843382716,
-0.2532367706,
0.6241106391,
0.0158326812,
0.4439399838,
0.9936940074,
0.401422888,
0.287473619,
0.0214088876,
0.1109256446,
-0.6380288601,
0.1594317704,
-0.2630057037,
-0.6025771499,
-0.2717596889,
0.3378475904,
0.9233068228,
0.9048247933,
-0.0427637398,
0.0947336704,
-0.0095627345,
0.5688838959,
-0.4114976227,
0.2592926621,
-0.4184653163,
0.0013255201,
0.0626533851,
-0.3634429872,
-0.7468143702,
-0.144328177,
0.289614588,
-0.5146172643,
0.4533207417,
0.2752102911,
0.6777133346,
-0.1200242043,
-0.1880725473,
-0.6660221815,
-1.1046386957,
0.8335232139,
-0.7013658881,
0.1714018434,
0.6049689054,
0.2082909197,
0.048464518,
-0.8051733971,
-0.696534574,
-0.609349072,
-0.2296810895,
0.0358853862,
-0.0758957043,
-0.1322848499,
0.47430107,
0.1096215546,
-0.6460240483,
0.0884053111,
-0.668593049,
-0.4275607169,
0.7609829307,
0.6050130129,
0.5747946501,
0.094420962,
-0.0774692893,
-0.2775989771,
-0.4562954307,
0.0370457545,
0.216957435,
0.2252103537,
0.0827929005,
0.4622050226,
0.0262265056,
0.5485385656,
-0.4471970797,
-0.3963384032,
0.2271251827,
-0.1779019088,
0.0313412622,
0.1165719479,
0.5941973925,
0.3561779261,
0.5375947952,
-0.458877027,
-0.1928494573,
0.1957502067,
0.4065308571,
-0.9416753054,
-0.2133214027,
-0.100489594,
-0.7238179445,
0.2379334718,
-0.0199314784,
-0.6452484727,
-0.4871109724,
-0.2265217006,
0.5513221622,
-0.5340740085,
-0.1320557147,
0.3664661944,
-0.5278621912,
0.1489773542,
0.304536134,
-0.9811470509,
0.1688099951,
0.7076599598,
0.8243211508,
-0.1374817789,
-0.7783517838,
-0.4534706771,
0.1277837455,
-0.4338775575,
0.6581794024,
-0.5091075301,
-0.1363199651,
0.0160014592,
-0.2545275092,
-0.0126275681,
-0.5222229362,
0.3570296764,
-0.5232068896,
0.2942371666,
-0.2642634809,
-0.7065429688,
-0.3660296798,
0.3117669225,
-0.8794099689,
0.4906414151,
-0.1575217247,
-0.5057429671,
0.1099739671,
-0.3362760246,
-0.5831952691,
-0.1089745015,
-0.1186711192,
-0.228728354,
0.3358914256,
-0.1695959866,
0.4068550169,
-0.2442479432,
0.3678021133,
0.0665315688,
-0.7082455754,
0.5508285165,
-0.6652985215,
0.3980396986,
-0.0347637758,
-0.0243945755,
-0.1575976163,
-0.6929248571,
-0.2080806941,
0.3136487901,
-0.5383303165,
-0.514778316,
0.1726464629,
0.0569124557,
-0.0848287418,
0.0050792559,
-0.5841057301,
0.2469110191,
-0.3856810629,
0.7177164555,
0.413271457,
0.0318759605,
0.4661272764,
-0.5776437521,
0.4122934341,
-0.1577069461,
-0.3977035284,
-0.9496052265,
-0.3890461326,
-0.7707701325,
-0.1388834715,
0.1712581813,
0.2638915777,
-0.4480689168,
-0.1014771834,
-0.2773338854,
-0.1763938665,
-0.4255779982,
-0.1786346883,
0.1355083585,
0.6155343056,
0.3163160384,
-0.3832086027,
-0.5210968852,
-0.9160410166,
-0.4601177573,
-0.5225518346,
-0.5278999805,
0.397719264,
0.5247545838,
-0.2204753906,
0.9311297536,
-0.5972052217,
-0.0974952281,
-0.2468870878,
0.4762101471,
-0.119495064,
0.1673444211,
0.5293307304,
-0.7526289821,
-0.091382198,
-0.245063737,
-0.7486243844,
0.2460059524,
-0.4916972518,
0.2771936059,
0.2068858594,
0.4486213326,
-0.8242298961,
0.3582529724,
0.1846528053,
-0.483353436,
0.4645549059,
-0.4727698863,
0.1938498765,
-0.8112893701,
0.3157065213,
-0.2110892534,
-0.1876522005,
-0.680919528,
-0.1516318619,
0.1963173151,
-0.0810152441,
-0.3853263557,
0.9340623617,
-0.5090129972,
-0.1397864968,
-0.4371093214,
0.1396097541,
0.1093954295,
0.3481219113,
0.1980210841,
0.5901114941,
0.2894125581,
-0.4849755168,
0.110498324,
0.1638038158,
-0.6497238278,
0.1762895584,
-0.3972456753,
0.2219658792,
-0.4755060077,
0.1767172217,
-0.9711858034,
-0.4283539355,
-0.2358084023,
-0.5049034953,
0.26972422,
0.4088180363,
-0.5643892884,
-0.3132781088,
-0.1418026388,
0.408082366,
0.7715954185,
-0.3350190222,
0.8008944988,
0.3167488277,
-0.2546593845,
0.0515355617,
-0.647790432,
0.2219717354,
-0.5257235169,
-0.3811614513,
0.0686883256,
-0.1972256601,
-0.3821994364,
-0.2232540101,
0.1303128451,
-0.3311573863,
-0.0519551747,
0.1748543233,
0.3636486232,
-0.3652238846,
0.3706234396,
-0.2752955556,
-0.0825650916,
0.2398228943,
0.0631235391,
0.6047391891,
0.0472113118,
0.0016105302,
-0.3721008003,
0.5041512251,
0.8717511892,
-0.1313651055,
0.8956306577,
0.4763617218,
-0.5288107395,
-0.0503932163,
-0.6697936058,
-0.3180759549,
-0.4052629471,
0.5811796188,
-0.1453735977,
-0.9269328713,
0.5921562314,
-0.0325940698,
-0.0156088108,
0.2072259337,
0.4331292808,
-0.3256889284,
1.0132716894,
0.4582141042,
-0.3324335217,
0.1893219501,
-0.0235974044,
0.3017289937,
-0.7775717974,
0.08707726,
-0.3305953443,
-0.4786235094,
-0.0554437935,
-0.2771669626,
0.2147622705,
0.0924728587,
-0.3297315538,
0.1002734825,
-0.0929671451,
0.8573027253,
0.3459586501,
-0.1171782911,
0.4968017042,
-0.08783786,
0.2257710993,
-0.0797645077,
-0.4177114666,
-0.8146036863,
0.8712357283,
0.4028659463,
0.7024267316,
-0.3646830916,
0.4515390992,
0.2431348264,
0.2559094429,
-0.6896551251,
0.6053522825,
0.0181999132,
-0.4896883965,
-0.4083258212,
-0.4376358688,
-1.2849332094,
0.1069824621,
-0.0205766652,
-0.8817109466,
-0.2496124506,
0.0627680346,
-0.5480495095,
0.2007934898,
-0.8703579307,
0.5424361825,
-0.3646563888,
0.0663902387,
-0.4007538855,
-0.4937069416,
0.2272613049,
-0.0477025285,
0.1130093187,
0.12945427,
0.1560594887,
1.0119702816,
0.0802443475,
0.9127598405,
0.1553449631,
0.3675332665,
0.3958523273,
0.2614598274,
0.3516137004,
-0.0771204755,
-0.0511345677,
0.08517804,
-0.171757713,
-0.4309622645,
-0.5485721231,
0.6706650853,
-0.6810768247,
-0.642545104,
-0.326777339,
-1.0721240044,
-0.0029860432,
0.183655411,
-0.1853293478,
0.327816546,
-0.4820548892,
0.219834581,
0.6141585112,
-0.3202258945,
0.7696094513,
0.7127802372,
-0.1693289131,
0.095584929,
0.9623844028,
0.2372945845,
0.3115378916,
0.2838993669,
0.3223513365,
0.0252560787,
-0.6415147185,
-0.4210467935,
0.3629033864,
-0.4227085412,
-0.0371477045,
-0.782330513,
-0.2342028618,
0.1507003754,
-0.2767916024,
-0.359493196,
-0.2167207003,
-0.3393388093,
-0.2117272615,
0.1718218625,
0.8444635868,
0.229043752,
-0.1927836835,
-0.8740519285,
0.4103954732,
0.2468259782,
0.0972392932,
0.6074077487,
-0.3860781789,
-0.3659361899,
0.1790104955,
-0.1391577721,
-0.5484293103,
0.7294642329,
0.1411796361,
0.394205302,
0.3162688017,
-0.1723155826,
0.6002452374,
-0.7956716418,
0.651645422,
0.0265649073,
-0.668181777,
0.3881675601,
-0.4262152314,
0.5719000101,
0.3240061998,
0.5118793845,
-0.7847195268,
-0.2705907226,
-0.3716920912,
-0.7725095749,
0.5574620366,
0.1817832738,
0.5360881686,
-0.0788671896,
0.5998462439,
0.2513206601,
-0.0168932471,
-0.3684283495,
0.0825205892,
0.072734192,
-0.0130029088,
-0.2831332982,
-0.2418470383,
0.0608090684,
-0.0338448249,
0.1048792899,
0.0114824362,
0.3081950545,
0.082913354,
-0.0796805844,
-0.007169819,
0.1024565324,
0.4187352657,
0.7943778038,
-0.0309347473,
0.1196114197,
0.2062346488,
-0.7506930828,
-0.0760237873,
-0.1264309436,
-0.2609752417,
-0.2395155132,
0.8712044954,
0.7464020252,
0.1616847068,
-1.3058187962,
0.3140622079,
-0.4381026924,
-0.0079681883,
-0.3055175543,
0.1882540286,
0.4980616271,
0.4304326177,
0.5166431665,
0.0251357853,
-0.0207064543,
-1.1467751265,
0.0808907747,
0.206265673,
-0.2006219327,
-0.3802924752,
0.5208956003,
-0.0537555479,
-0.7143475413,
1.1529318094,
-0.1331731975,
-0.4338446259,
0.6868233681,
0.8318582177,
0.5310205221,
-0.1556282789,
0.2407354414,
0.4997117817,
0.1607740372,
-0.50656569,
0.0277414154,
0.1445455551,
-0.7820626497,
-0.3181736469,
-0.6930286288,
-0.1206422672,
0.2675775886,
-0.6340482235,
-0.1175019294,
-0.2430441678,
0.2824448645,
0.0116922557,
-0.283303231,
-0.66377002,
0.1765276939,
0.3639360666,
0.6841658354,
-0.9303448796,
0.888060987,
0.2700942755,
-0.53903687,
-0.7862172127,
0.0480486453,
-0.1617609262,
-0.6373342276,
0.5676470399,
0.4343601763,
0.225876376,
-0.1054119095,
-0.3926040828,
-0.7674002647,
1.27599895,
0.3644071519,
-0.6133768559,
-0.2067344338,
0.2540068328,
1.0838121176,
-0.5942844152,
0.2427439094,
0.7351714969,
0.2946214676,
0.222192198,
-0.9908134341,
-0.109135814,
-0.1309655309,
-0.0283562131,
0.2449292392,
-0.6092587709,
0.9239045978,
-0.3511666656,
-0.448084414,
0.3787614703,
0.641721487,
0.2715456486,
0.5601193309,
0.1316081285,
0.3919318318,
0.9438279271,
0.2015338391,
1.3004950285,
0.1747508496,
0.1733677089,
0.998462677,
-0.3997835517,
1.0329159498,
0.2481049895,
0.1727282852,
0.3437785506,
0.2417312264,
0.1899335831,
0.3552287519,
0.3079310358,
-0.0965786427,
-0.1072730944,
-0.1893429309,
-0.0959461033,
0.4664388001,
0.2944036722,
-0.5667062402,
0.0250794757,
0.4350949228,
0.1206384003,
0.1892335713,
-0.4529040158,
0.5696210265,
0.1426236331,
-0.7862290144,
0.4327714145,
-0.1302698851,
0.3862507641,
-0.4141248465,
-0.3215657473,
-0.2279545814,
0.1962368637,
0.2957706451,
-0.7309274673,
0.4573740661,
-0.0082244622,
-0.4306840003,
-0.3124437034,
0.6595689058,
-0.5736345053,
-0.5200560689,
0.250688374,
0.4080940783,
0.3088994026,
-0.045522362,
-0.0447798632,
0.3149842024,
-0.0738848224,
-0.3793283105,
0.5907508135,
0.3596844375,
-0.1763148755,
0.6202136278,
0.4862386882,
-0.0093551502,
-0.0487635508,
0.013500113,
0.6946217418,
-1.0449858904,
-0.5136852264,
-0.9619809985,
0.4244321883,
0.0006210946,
-0.2520323992,
0.7495570183,
0.7695831656,
0.8503881097,
-0.2042221576,
0.6677421331,
0.1354101002,
0.5415307879,
-0.4823224247,
0.885674715,
-0.1772057712,
0.0997020155,
0.014064448,
-0.7788324356,
-0.3265679777,
0.6034881473,
-0.2453899831,
-0.0896539241,
0.828273356,
0.5738998055,
-0.0303369034,
0.1578886509,
0.4390383065,
0.650267005,
0.4016290009,
0.7021095753,
0.9555517435,
-0.2254330665,
0.4123267233,
0.3056426942,
-0.1678139567,
-0.1086612642,
-0.5751736164,
-1.3494144678,
-0.8754996061,
0.029609682,
-0.0886117667,
0.080501534,
0.5275403261,
0.4874227643,
-0.4290589094,
-0.277572453,
0.1261466295,
-0.2274961323,
-0.0520238839,
-0.2146785408,
0.465713501,
0.0008280017,
-0.6322889924,
0.5258712769,
0.5199900866,
0.0673913583,
-0.514536202,
-0.1513810158,
-0.085805513,
0.2812439203,
0.7304597497,
0.4379617572,
-0.7312566042,
-0.4338656068,
-0.0302089974,
-0.0757457167,
0.1544153243,
1.1973984241,
-1.0655909777,
0.5767741203,
0.7086232901,
0.7078180313,
0.8263397813,
-0.1518779546,
0.5968598723,
-0.3857113123,
0.0819190517,
0.6127759814,
0.4296222925,
0.2560367584,
-0.2318186909,
0.2660514414,
-0.1760396361,
-0.6316717267,
-0.7541930079,
0.0209399294,
-0.8429955244,
-0.5050682425,
1.076551199,
-0.1921352297,
-0.2207447141,
-0.0882315934,
-0.4711391628,
0.0065729739,
-0.2540098131,
1.3173019886,
1.0134768486,
-0.2275148779,
-0.1136991233,
-0.75003016,
0.1498757005,
0.2096042186,
-0.7216084003,
0.1191237569,
0.6186984181,
0.0351925902,
0.3549875319,
0.6834255457,
0.1257561594,
0.3078278303,
0.1558977515,
-0.3550983965,
-0.0047615441,
-0.5598933697,
-0.0804070234,
0.3465852439,
-0.0261543654,
0.2175716609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04694v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04694v3
|
Evaluating Generative Ad Hoc Information Retrieval
| 2023-11-08T14:05:00 | 2024-05-22T10:33:56 |
Lukas Gienapp, Harrisen Scells, Niklas Deckers, Janek Bevendorff, Shuai Wang, Johannes Kiesel, Shahbaz Syed, Maik Fröbe, Guido Zuccon, Benno Stein, Matthias Hagen, Martin Potthast
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in large language models have enabled the development of
viable generative retrieval systems. Instead of a traditional document ranking,
generative retrieval systems often directly return a grounded generated text as
a response to a query. Quantifying the utility of the textual responses is
essential for appropriately evaluating such generative ad hoc retrieval. Yet,
the established evaluation methodology for ranking-based ad hoc retrieval is
not suited for the reliable and reproducible evaluation of generated responses.
To lay a foundation for developing new evaluation methods for generative
retrieval systems, we survey the relevant literature from the fields of
information retrieval and natural language processing, identify search tasks
and system architectures in generative retrieval, develop a new user model, and
study its operationalization.
|
[
-0.3969372511,
-0.9611517191,
0.6381842494,
0.0916517973,
-0.1111099869,
-0.0596921369,
-0.0784465745,
-0.4327687025,
0.245628193,
0.342640847,
-0.1534932554,
-0.4450158477,
-0.4931911528,
0.0607366376,
-0.7832338214,
0.5610233545,
0.2750022113,
-0.1488557905,
-0.6057650447,
-0.1957217306,
-0.5078139901,
-0.8157382607,
-0.6384948492,
-0.2508514225,
0.1109704226,
0.2569270134,
0.7509823442,
0.1645716876,
0.7995811105,
0.298283428,
-0.1542588323,
-0.1204586551,
-0.4443866014,
0.4689384997,
-0.1878698468,
-0.0916360617,
-0.3158040047,
0.2070619613,
0.6088301539,
0.7552525401,
-0.5052776337,
0.2423505783,
-0.0441433974,
0.7093194127,
-0.8604563475,
-0.1076111421,
-0.5696028471,
0.0009666146,
-0.2392980307,
-0.6622809172,
-0.6515205503,
-0.7651889324,
0.3220380247,
-0.7320683599,
0.4705606699,
0.1710831821,
0.3654334843,
-0.3226934671,
-0.539513886,
-0.7986917496,
-0.7526935339,
0.4744554162,
-0.4662349522,
0.3995175362,
0.3797668815,
0.5206257701,
-0.0522183999,
-0.7169715762,
-0.3706150949,
-0.6475890875,
-0.0810526088,
0.1245723963,
-0.0490508005,
-0.0453776829,
0.1773344129,
0.9107304215,
-0.660318017,
-0.2099637538,
-0.1768982857,
0.1595934182,
0.6347033381,
0.3746438324,
0.4948613048,
-0.4523444474,
-0.6221132874,
-0.1378018856,
-0.4118775725,
-0.0506773293,
0.5381795168,
0.0474128313,
0.4761806428,
0.9352927804,
-0.4211717248,
0.8778152466,
-0.172080189,
0.3952212632,
0.0237455145,
-0.4354791343,
-0.0108789643,
-0.061474476,
0.6216887832,
0.3358764648,
-0.1838594973,
-0.3404525518,
-0.5403239131,
0.2084133476,
0.6765688658,
-0.6309818625,
-0.0531147383,
-0.1634854972,
-0.7733284235,
-0.4362545907,
0.427375108,
-0.812312603,
-0.5261583328,
-0.2975524366,
0.7234081626,
-0.5613500476,
-0.3724544644,
0.1063956022,
-0.4610219598,
0.1750643551,
0.3016175628,
-0.8212411404,
0.5504149795,
0.4610093832,
0.7760347128,
-0.2784581184,
-0.027562052,
-0.5119876266,
-0.1677376926,
-0.3015120625,
0.8449867368,
-0.5659281611,
-0.7703089118,
0.2451712787,
-0.2393297553,
-0.1470029354,
-0.691894114,
0.7526955009,
-1.2203862667,
0.1472727507,
-0.4022776783,
-0.6005731225,
-0.0835166276,
0.1018592939,
-0.8270039558,
1.0981411934,
0.2381201535,
-0.8440505862,
0.2179909945,
-0.5483468771,
-0.551561892,
0.3714784682,
0.1322099715,
0.0112714078,
0.3181384504,
-0.1254250258,
0.0897031203,
-0.5635114908,
0.2628246844,
-0.2033032924,
-0.5580959916,
0.100782685,
-0.2473524809,
0.8271347284,
0.3721150458,
0.0385923088,
0.0262053013,
-0.6794586182,
0.1127760485,
0.2972272933,
-0.7710042,
-0.6988114119,
0.1727025509,
0.2296404541,
-0.1636822969,
0.3974281847,
-0.5430702567,
0.1593112946,
-0.3546397388,
0.3109352887,
0.3864557445,
0.211495474,
0.4666272104,
-0.1877119094,
0.6507171988,
-0.5529857278,
-0.0608240888,
-0.1795695871,
-0.3527379632,
-0.5869538188,
0.1828893423,
0.2165654451,
0.2319194824,
-0.9455714822,
0.4199387133,
-0.2705404162,
-0.4816100299,
-0.5614497066,
-0.1160238087,
0.3702819347,
0.477519244,
0.4020464122,
-0.5217654109,
-0.5117913485,
-0.6323109269,
-0.2905154228,
-0.3825437725,
-0.2139572799,
0.3524290621,
0.2987812757,
-0.1766026765,
0.8385162354,
-0.6859819293,
-0.0298879202,
-0.1234085113,
0.5693736076,
-0.1432427317,
0.1881084293,
0.4612160325,
-1.0140997171,
-0.14247486,
0.0705511197,
-0.8724815249,
-0.0353136398,
0.4012816846,
-0.0407396071,
-0.0835562497,
0.3061716259,
-0.7453354001,
0.4102900624,
0.1745846272,
-0.2927187979,
0.659719348,
-0.2327519953,
0.6123140454,
-0.561973393,
0.681692183,
-0.2921410203,
-0.1125597209,
-0.2368133515,
0.4979088604,
0.0896735564,
-0.493334651,
-0.0599141978,
0.5500832796,
-0.5880952477,
-0.4841457307,
-0.3055837154,
0.3992157876,
0.2575201094,
-0.0059495824,
-0.1605263501,
0.8451893926,
0.1720838845,
-0.8488763571,
0.639805913,
0.4123837054,
-0.5585919023,
0.7639063597,
-0.7268639803,
0.1957163215,
-0.3515302837,
0.0311285406,
-1.1322698593,
-0.2194712758,
-0.1738974452,
-0.5935246348,
0.3355039954,
-0.0226475894,
-0.4503173828,
-0.5712786913,
-0.5130590796,
0.4855659306,
0.353746891,
-0.5528442264,
0.16347377,
0.4927615523,
-0.2554049492,
-0.2415377498,
-0.06733457,
0.1034162715,
-0.0618720539,
-0.4302764237,
0.3608056605,
0.0017890587,
-0.1859704107,
0.2173419893,
-0.1619759053,
0.1150008067,
0.2390147001,
-0.2020725608,
0.0583574101,
-0.0996333361,
0.373737812,
-0.2760705948,
-0.164310351,
-0.0031044285,
-0.2009203434,
0.4116744995,
-0.1014454514,
-0.5115690231,
0.1041553691,
0.547916472,
0.4958552718,
-0.5861687064,
0.6073947549,
0.2847910225,
-0.4599459767,
0.157983467,
-0.5896224976,
-0.0436752774,
-0.3703739345,
0.1873582751,
-0.3142080009,
-0.5062334538,
0.3177269697,
0.1177505106,
-0.262732625,
0.8028396964,
0.5444966555,
-0.1457967311,
1.0077160597,
0.5898935199,
0.4565543234,
0.4739037454,
-0.2028082758,
0.1174194515,
-0.9842034578,
-0.4045732915,
-0.7856048346,
0.0468473844,
-0.3369769752,
-0.1872559935,
0.437908262,
0.1838252544,
0.044181738,
0.529493928,
-0.5252370834,
-0.0289485361,
0.6727991104,
0.06364014,
0.5975494981,
-0.1016347483,
-0.329359442,
0.1349279732,
-0.4414705038,
-0.7346525788,
0.8716053963,
0.0300758928,
0.8610809445,
0.2727635801,
0.2394142598,
0.7101583481,
0.6645289063,
-1.0730499029,
0.4125849307,
-0.0649787858,
-0.6005937457,
-0.4968374074,
-0.516356051,
-1.0309265852,
0.6189964414,
-0.1029072627,
-0.5518634319,
0.1435990185,
-0.1164066643,
-0.1556802541,
-0.2082469165,
-0.6673232913,
0.6985145211,
-0.0591216087,
-0.0156848449,
-0.170693472,
-0.5063024759,
0.3800593615,
0.071651645,
0.0168907344,
-0.0593929663,
0.1925686747,
0.8392552137,
-0.2279819846,
0.2216622829,
-0.2415713817,
-0.0546866432,
0.4355115294,
0.1380004883,
0.2264214754,
0.1037691832,
-0.6907759309,
-0.3649341464,
0.1628609151,
-0.1410019696,
-0.7829716206,
0.8598566055,
-0.4346420169,
-0.7008934021,
-0.3400567174,
-0.0163415466,
-0.0746774077,
0.3180063069,
0.5018304586,
0.4761812389,
-0.7968315482,
0.3764025271,
0.6079400778,
-0.2576311231,
0.1989379972,
0.6021658182,
-0.1175126508,
-0.3570403159,
0.6897320747,
0.1235407293,
-0.0487678126,
0.5737608075,
0.0649190918,
-0.7122036219,
-0.3864839077,
-0.5130355358,
-0.1848127842,
-0.670686841,
-0.447856158,
-0.6004431248,
-0.2928188443,
-0.2233181447,
0.0332669951,
-0.3125980794,
-0.3649600446,
-0.1485175043,
-0.0925634354,
0.0675891191,
0.8759887815,
0.4008078873,
0.1713770628,
-0.5984882712,
0.4410559833,
0.3615913093,
0.5659440756,
0.2891192734,
-0.3717067838,
-0.2255274951,
0.0329630189,
-0.6661624312,
-1.0323091745,
0.1283869296,
0.1393440515,
0.8481741548,
0.1102723554,
0.3368245959,
0.3181383312,
-0.5202957392,
0.66218853,
0.0597427189,
-0.8677158952,
0.9517194033,
-0.3801827729,
0.0374508426,
0.5028930306,
0.3412768543,
-0.49160707,
0.0055984058,
-0.4073288739,
-1.0196595192,
0.6747666597,
0.4370357692,
0.3029577434,
-0.2840837836,
0.4127156138,
0.015981067,
0.3620919585,
-0.3602888584,
-0.0891188458,
-0.1993378848,
0.0909454599,
-0.1329114437,
-0.5802143216,
-0.0550401136,
0.0309044365,
0.4029495418,
0.0587040596,
0.4717900157,
0.3571594059,
-0.2326969802,
-0.2818156481,
0.2804022133,
0.2081089318,
0.6658194065,
-0.423720032,
0.184815824,
-0.2735307813,
-0.3659139276,
0.420843333,
0.3274408877,
-0.2380489409,
0.0397352874,
0.2665793896,
0.5109245181,
0.2692709863,
-0.5461884737,
0.7449336648,
-0.154310599,
-0.007336074,
-0.2106216848,
0.0064601363,
-0.0782956108,
-0.2209752202,
0.6935678124,
0.0050740824,
0.8340452313,
-0.5389392376,
0.2890143692,
0.6799945235,
-0.2839591801,
-0.3418141901,
0.8693587184,
0.2688194513,
-0.4389965236,
0.7470837235,
-0.0611704551,
-0.2177210301,
0.4933541119,
0.511703968,
0.922000885,
-0.5119520426,
0.2721817791,
0.3829935193,
0.1346477121,
-0.0698075593,
0.1261530966,
-0.2817414701,
-0.3708368838,
0.0120448554,
-0.9211050272,
-0.154458195,
-0.0624245629,
-1.0470712185,
0.2179617286,
0.0214842856,
-0.4929044545,
0.1264233887,
0.0150506543,
-0.6599370241,
0.2590524852,
-0.2827178836,
0.9770451784,
-0.5424823165,
0.3427998126,
1.2132371664,
-0.5786119103,
-0.0390684716,
0.0940697938,
-0.3533092141,
-0.471622467,
0.5024905801,
0.0892237499,
-0.3769585192,
0.1442293078,
-0.1140277833,
-0.7901917696,
1.0788701773,
0.2831164002,
0.1746844947,
0.123925671,
-0.4064360857,
0.7785652876,
-0.0361796208,
0.5119319558,
0.2022229582,
0.0402142219,
0.3912812769,
-0.8494369388,
0.1304943115,
-0.4605447352,
0.651591599,
0.1177432388,
-0.3324415386,
0.4758913517,
-0.1003122181,
-0.6226005554,
0.4091118276,
0.4876125157,
0.1221347973,
0.3392630219,
0.2873662412,
0.5312386751,
0.5529766083,
0.0456390977,
1.3420052528,
-0.0683651567,
0.6772907972,
0.6370204091,
-0.3684583902,
1.0340251923,
0.3092736006,
-0.3004027009,
0.1906041205,
0.5012725592,
0.3828290701,
0.6443371177,
0.4618849754,
-0.4333460033,
-0.108785376,
-0.2891338468,
-0.6073963642,
0.471981585,
0.4501996636,
-0.2776779234,
-0.3627321422,
0.0107943099,
-0.5734920502,
0.2605870664,
0.0562619045,
0.8589274287,
-0.0467657223,
-0.8167573214,
0.6395561099,
0.449470222,
0.2453630865,
-0.3219969869,
-0.2257320881,
-0.2272604853,
-0.228048712,
-0.1924133748,
-0.6121639609,
0.4224986434,
-0.113970913,
-0.3111009002,
-0.1258149147,
0.8578549623,
-0.0441242494,
-0.3073329329,
0.3992613256,
0.4601050019,
-0.08591263,
-0.0637168735,
-0.2119284421,
0.0176568851,
-0.5051448345,
-0.6359502673,
0.2180841714,
0.3268410265,
-0.0114379693,
0.6886720061,
0.6691026688,
-0.2471672446,
-0.0829453096,
0.1553766727,
0.8691952229,
-0.559465766,
-0.4289392233,
-0.4556933641,
0.3127216399,
0.0521335341,
0.1101609841,
0.8382957578,
0.7275632024,
0.5800155401,
-0.1891752332,
0.8798254728,
-0.308837086,
0.5308290124,
-0.580953598,
0.4920149148,
-0.5832766294,
0.4682566822,
-0.2908523381,
-1.0472847223,
-0.038709145,
0.6576528549,
-0.2871857584,
0.2561972141,
0.5246549845,
0.3526327908,
-0.1289462745,
0.0446058773,
0.3462814391,
-0.0804718658,
0.1498090029,
0.0713022351,
1.2723002434,
-0.6207345128,
0.34149611,
0.2094070166,
-0.533457458,
-0.6484271288,
-0.6180848479,
-0.259464711,
-0.6694799662,
0.0370700806,
-0.1504644454,
0.1643012762,
0.4177634418,
0.5632748604,
-0.7269871831,
-0.2036951482,
-0.1460185796,
0.1427174658,
-0.187455982,
-0.368909508,
0.3555788398,
-0.5881432891,
-0.5563759208,
0.3274167776,
0.380574882,
0.0328507796,
-0.3406219482,
0.0527733974,
-0.2305808365,
-0.2639710009,
0.9176510572,
0.1410803497,
-0.649782598,
0.0037862323,
0.2353411466,
-0.4310815334,
-0.1728290468,
1.0478520393,
-0.698050797,
0.806417346,
0.6882873774,
0.6016067266,
0.4651345611,
0.65452981,
0.8096679449,
-0.7024795413,
-0.2802803814,
0.3597084582,
-0.0394553207,
0.3620665967,
-0.6448049545,
0.3899604976,
0.2550550699,
-0.5221957564,
-0.5027818084,
0.1513230801,
-0.6463923454,
0.0172090139,
1.0843731165,
-0.1091625988,
0.4258958995,
-0.1870315075,
-0.3441878557,
0.1442588419,
-0.2060698271,
0.7175733447,
0.6503783464,
-0.2047131807,
0.1924205124,
-0.7545927763,
0.3870122731,
0.1418406069,
-0.6487011909,
0.0727541372,
0.5901532769,
0.0206296314,
0.1782663018,
1.0337837934,
-0.3297632039,
0.2486209869,
-0.0471670665,
0.0583208874,
0.2767896056,
-0.2362118214,
-0.274219662,
0.4338447452,
0.5746845603,
-0.2584181428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04666v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04666v4
|
Pre-training LLMs using human-like development data corpus
| 2023-11-08T13:13:23 | 2024-01-10T05:36:05 |
Khushi Bhardwaj, Raj Sanjay Shah, Sashank Varma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown success in a diverse set
of language inference and understanding tasks. The pre-training stage of LLMs
looks at a large corpus of raw textual data. The BabyLM shared task compares
LLM pre-training to human language acquisition, where the number of tokens seen
by 13-year-old kids is magnitudes smaller than the number of tokens seen by
LLMs. In this work, we pre-train and evaluate LLMs on their ability to learn
contextual word representations using roughly the same number of tokens as seen
by children. We provide a strong set of baselines; with different
architectures, evaluation of changes in performance across epochs, and reported
pre-training metrics for the strict small and strict tracks of the task. We
also try to loosely replicate the RoBERTa baseline given by the task organizers
to observe the training robustness to hyperparameter selection and
replicability. We provide the submission details to the strict and strict-small
tracks in this report.
|
[
-0.4020484388,
-0.4883207679,
0.3431761861,
0.2301464975,
-0.422039181,
0.0824413747,
-0.524491787,
-0.3793612719,
0.0650172904,
0.311894238,
-0.6394791007,
-0.7059502602,
-0.626598835,
0.1647399664,
-0.3382745683,
0.884496212,
-0.1047273278,
0.1339102536,
-0.268864125,
0.1182368547,
-0.3015398085,
-0.6566346884,
-0.4802846313,
-0.2330569923,
0.5384820104,
0.4599073827,
0.2170101404,
0.677957356,
0.2550965548,
0.2397522181,
-0.1527973413,
0.018156996,
-0.6545818448,
0.0523109362,
-0.0996689424,
-0.1967295557,
-0.590880394,
0.21634987,
0.6451214552,
1.0199587345,
0.0271057449,
0.522665441,
0.4983592033,
0.3327454031,
-0.6173312068,
0.3389943838,
-0.7929344177,
0.1595844924,
-0.3246280551,
-0.1144910753,
-0.4362979829,
-0.1667146832,
0.1755844653,
-0.7359703779,
0.2668099403,
0.1143774316,
0.7337701321,
0.0788182169,
-0.2614673674,
-0.3614509404,
-0.5254132152,
0.9911976457,
-0.5477929115,
0.4011544883,
0.7145594954,
-0.1200417355,
-0.1052971706,
-0.7995904684,
-0.6476354003,
-0.3575672805,
-0.217120111,
-0.1236352995,
0.215996936,
-0.034019988,
0.2653649151,
0.0918984339,
-0.7072176337,
0.3215401769,
-0.1388116628,
-0.3640851676,
0.4333370626,
0.2864768803,
-0.0636652857,
-0.1506588757,
-0.4842853546,
-0.0510457307,
-0.8588770032,
-0.2147135735,
0.143573001,
0.408507973,
-0.4071980715,
0.2857020199,
-0.2548311651,
0.7957513332,
0.033161588,
-0.0683527142,
0.5528970957,
-0.5505611897,
-0.2288929373,
-0.3380615711,
0.7006679177,
0.0483286045,
0.5043492913,
-0.239167437,
-0.326286763,
0.1304256767,
0.244144246,
-0.6348152757,
0.0968388245,
-0.175431639,
-0.4756508768,
-0.1337829828,
-0.2049371302,
-0.4926974773,
-0.2502491772,
-0.5718527436,
0.3656462133,
-0.2871974409,
0.0280791074,
0.068496123,
0.3266826272,
0.4487819672,
0.2345403135,
-0.944607079,
0.3170455098,
0.624068141,
0.4762268662,
-0.4515208304,
-0.645014286,
-0.475127846,
0.1104018912,
-0.3709208965,
0.7072485089,
-0.2637523115,
-0.5438412428,
0.110453248,
-0.0552464649,
-0.2447700053,
-0.7909511924,
0.4991389513,
-0.6780112982,
0.0625975803,
-0.1259804517,
-0.5731081963,
0.3218795955,
0.4290163815,
-0.2846890688,
0.9959199429,
0.192166388,
-0.8189485073,
0.9664611816,
-0.4704478383,
-0.4906997383,
0.1869389415,
-0.3050692379,
-0.2917598784,
-0.068063952,
0.0984363779,
0.6866620779,
-0.0477047488,
0.2151851356,
-0.3586770594,
-0.5829015374,
-0.074355945,
-0.394592762,
0.5835981965,
0.2459093779,
-0.3238914013,
0.2314169109,
-0.7580646873,
0.0836605877,
0.1309088171,
-0.5911074281,
-0.1776874661,
-0.1719913185,
0.0867820159,
0.1588606536,
0.5021780133,
-0.5152404904,
0.1893102527,
-0.1696259081,
0.2867664695,
0.5514964461,
-0.2152925134,
0.4288566709,
-0.2355324477,
0.4910103381,
0.0562923066,
0.2994824052,
-0.1129240617,
-0.0757228807,
-0.7305077314,
-0.2423201799,
0.3567967415,
0.2697342634,
-0.6204260588,
0.7039470673,
-0.4312585592,
-0.1800567061,
-0.4288979471,
0.5398950577,
0.6070570946,
0.3811298013,
0.2834414542,
-0.6113321185,
-0.8865174651,
-0.6809039712,
0.2116025239,
-0.2462815046,
-0.1900252551,
0.2457783073,
0.4571613669,
-0.453430444,
0.9397722483,
-0.2332427651,
-0.2146928161,
-0.4064658582,
0.291408509,
0.0628533289,
0.5708687901,
0.421810329,
-0.4011636674,
-0.4402869642,
-0.4581538439,
-0.5619840622,
-0.1427971423,
0.3121425211,
-0.1016109288,
0.1109209433,
0.7723139524,
-0.5566802025,
0.4397090971,
0.6903612614,
-0.3835095167,
0.6294903755,
-0.2923056781,
-0.1816590726,
-0.9916091561,
0.0812361687,
-0.3614936471,
-0.3771532774,
-0.42922768,
-0.1297677755,
0.0124500748,
0.0640939102,
-0.7405241132,
0.6009843349,
-0.5633896589,
-0.4448147714,
-0.1976771355,
0.1953067333,
-0.1286004186,
0.3214393854,
0.149897337,
1.0727040768,
0.4314033389,
-0.6163170934,
-0.0979768783,
0.1191318482,
-0.5232418776,
0.531060636,
-0.5918269157,
0.456092447,
-0.018390337,
0.3731007278,
-0.6722663045,
-0.1009391844,
-0.0526331104,
-0.3865722418,
0.3012140095,
0.0029911771,
-0.7682985663,
-0.3095043302,
-0.2668182254,
0.3887478411,
0.4936708808,
-0.4215518236,
0.232854858,
0.4280238152,
-0.0150822653,
-0.4122381508,
-0.6228348017,
0.0700786859,
-0.2238148898,
-0.3280951381,
0.3291445971,
-0.1491845697,
-0.0815605521,
-0.0598427653,
0.1018851921,
-0.2547473609,
0.2354671955,
0.2157184929,
0.2018331289,
-0.3635928333,
0.0672049001,
-0.2876088023,
-0.194067359,
-0.0330895409,
-0.2086313665,
0.7948050499,
-0.0482229553,
-0.249152109,
-0.2796370387,
-0.0489784479,
0.2431809604,
-0.1047687754,
0.8762171268,
0.520365715,
-0.358848244,
-0.2915158868,
-0.2933825254,
-0.078845337,
-0.4260411859,
0.1783638299,
-0.3089992404,
-1.0081511736,
0.2959163189,
-0.0003152385,
0.0389285833,
0.3270755708,
0.6076478958,
-0.3919086456,
0.6327268481,
0.5319730639,
-0.0470830165,
0.4964031279,
-0.2938221395,
-0.4408410192,
-0.9472593069,
-0.2682315707,
-0.4281545281,
-0.0927841216,
-0.1923777759,
-0.6564211845,
-0.1104267612,
0.3709438443,
-0.5718046427,
0.3830414712,
-0.0552608334,
0.4811354876,
0.4878652394,
-0.0766459256,
0.276370585,
-0.1820255965,
-0.2050439417,
-0.0523708984,
-0.6513488293,
-0.8711377978,
1.2526299953,
0.1820882559,
0.7113881707,
-0.1435260177,
0.9972940683,
0.3820879459,
0.7560078502,
-0.5904929042,
0.6948031187,
-0.2723321915,
-0.6694031954,
-0.3872598112,
-0.1991532147,
-1.3420897722,
0.2174985111,
-0.3947632015,
-0.674175024,
-0.1396260262,
0.1734039932,
-0.4229725003,
-0.0677107573,
-0.7250335217,
0.8842241168,
-0.2483961433,
-0.227161184,
-0.2395578623,
-0.7052258253,
0.0506179966,
-0.3469453156,
0.2317227572,
-0.022356784,
-0.1975316107,
0.9513181448,
-0.3521896601,
1.0697237253,
-0.2750263214,
0.104969278,
0.4172021747,
-0.1089045927,
0.2088316828,
0.012126294,
0.0706972554,
0.0448726006,
-0.1180700138,
-0.6790016294,
-0.2259095609,
0.5971024632,
-0.8575257659,
-0.56256181,
-0.3606442809,
-0.4500374496,
-0.5365649462,
0.2545359731,
0.1227301508,
0.2316158414,
-0.4150545299,
0.3880792558,
0.5067887902,
-0.1081840247,
0.4621581435,
0.5813413858,
-0.3457508087,
-0.1014590412,
0.4436479807,
-0.015921142,
0.2963012457,
0.1790445149,
0.1015284732,
-0.281509757,
-0.893850565,
-0.3970116675,
0.142219007,
-0.4593318999,
-0.0588603951,
-0.4466852546,
-0.1167085767,
-0.3019673526,
-0.079855606,
-0.339261055,
0.0328139327,
-0.4989364743,
-0.1523185521,
-0.0550203063,
0.9544362426,
0.0601761341,
0.5614816546,
-0.7665330172,
0.195374772,
0.4205303788,
0.3423539102,
0.1246428117,
-0.7413076758,
-0.4791842699,
-0.049006775,
-0.1277099699,
-0.4502376914,
0.1461320817,
0.1761098653,
0.5323305726,
0.2964396775,
-0.2557807565,
0.7517886162,
-0.477114737,
0.8204078078,
0.0877663568,
-0.9546171427,
0.4329020977,
-0.3396014571,
0.22379601,
0.937528193,
0.2981866002,
-0.1286683083,
0.0808339044,
-0.6883530021,
-0.629083693,
0.5936134458,
0.1476220638,
0.2945625186,
0.0496791601,
0.3532630801,
0.2176879197,
0.2493517697,
-0.5311188102,
-0.1093873754,
0.0886176527,
-0.2764463425,
-0.3914397955,
-0.3539629877,
0.0278450996,
-0.3717688024,
0.2334083766,
-0.1563841701,
0.0262865033,
-0.0954096839,
-0.5654566884,
0.267993778,
0.2865786254,
0.4584450424,
0.7694967389,
-0.2689345479,
0.3016986251,
0.422665298,
-0.6692334414,
0.2196157128,
-0.0290024113,
-0.0527230836,
-0.1980014145,
0.917088449,
0.8430410624,
0.4887497425,
-0.7561526895,
0.6569885612,
-0.229817152,
-0.0952900276,
-0.3408984542,
-0.011485382,
0.3981104195,
0.0732690468,
0.2527482808,
-0.3736997843,
-0.297391057,
-0.7001879215,
0.4776306152,
0.188139841,
-0.4020774961,
-0.5851377249,
0.3186793029,
0.259106189,
-0.274400562,
0.5324426293,
-0.5026276708,
-0.3548545539,
0.5504127145,
0.5609146357,
0.6801503301,
-0.0362899564,
0.1676930189,
0.053212218,
0.180962041,
0.0808685869,
0.4416591227,
-0.2134503424,
-0.9674306512,
-0.6279940009,
-0.8790999651,
-0.2535801828,
0.3456222415,
-0.6799315214,
0.272305131,
-0.4888953567,
-0.3184414804,
-0.3673946261,
0.1986866593,
-1.2547909021,
0.4281914532,
0.2389055938,
0.8112701774,
-0.8312151432,
1.1732058525,
0.7984368801,
-0.2874412239,
-0.8438706994,
0.2727629542,
-0.223150149,
-0.9910458922,
1.0527327061,
0.0210366789,
-0.0322790332,
0.0995272771,
-0.4625819325,
-0.863984406,
1.1094002724,
0.2973669469,
-0.6494590044,
-0.1332996041,
0.1804991066,
0.7773177624,
-0.6756635308,
0.1369245797,
0.5711578131,
0.1775270104,
-0.0181135386,
-0.9237130284,
-0.1880277246,
0.2183972895,
-0.0314131267,
-0.2008029819,
-0.4294211268,
0.7959262133,
-0.0826788843,
-0.2076747715,
0.0750612766,
0.7499676347,
0.6133805513,
0.4113422036,
0.8337487578,
0.4922208488,
0.5372777581,
0.1541005224,
0.8905651569,
-0.4481720626,
0.3825151622,
1.3474605083,
-0.3231156468,
1.0114226341,
0.5299995542,
-0.3523053229,
0.3451326191,
0.709236443,
0.5595061183,
0.4312623739,
0.5513060689,
-0.0792543814,
-0.1923452914,
-0.1799906939,
-0.2441865653,
0.3585126698,
0.3755946755,
-0.2502346337,
-0.0895310715,
-0.0133659337,
0.1618406624,
0.0974585563,
-0.3319756687,
0.8124716878,
0.3556249738,
-0.3414170444,
0.6670324206,
-0.2760626078,
1.0172996521,
-0.554410696,
0.2955444753,
-0.2827781439,
0.0331796259,
-0.0391876325,
-0.7500237823,
0.2161320895,
0.3548407853,
-0.0528252125,
-0.37154603,
0.5919418931,
-0.3528918028,
-0.2986295521,
0.5780863166,
0.7926300168,
0.1556719095,
0.2936631143,
-0.5729935169,
0.2989228666,
-0.2462533861,
-0.4899599254,
0.4757147133,
0.4066920877,
-0.1530335099,
0.4369985759,
0.5243143439,
0.4393689036,
0.2556069493,
0.4167436063,
0.753923893,
-0.7265651226,
-0.2596373558,
-0.6537132859,
0.1162307486,
0.0895822719,
-0.5434930921,
0.6397818923,
0.5147331953,
1.0962507725,
-0.0645590276,
0.5501276851,
0.0912860632,
0.7070780396,
-0.4132380486,
0.5763198733,
-0.2898079157,
0.1858537346,
-0.1392851919,
-1.1277661324,
-0.2984531522,
0.4841536582,
-0.3134790957,
0.0634118468,
0.6647498012,
0.5275065303,
-0.0842247233,
-0.2165702581,
0.3503151238,
0.0749072582,
0.0628786534,
0.4964752793,
1.0517020226,
0.0381002538,
0.362557888,
-0.0426199548,
-0.2078593373,
-0.0761890635,
-0.8572542071,
-0.8270583153,
-0.3960707784,
-0.0167937335,
-0.0671867654,
0.1834099889,
1.1164380312,
0.9663692117,
-0.7765518427,
-0.3967991173,
0.0024940155,
-0.3196902573,
0.2069422603,
-0.0932007357,
0.4503449202,
-0.3888620138,
-0.6288437247,
0.4947288334,
-0.1270897985,
0.0050322819,
-0.5521504879,
-0.2982646525,
-0.1743752509,
-0.0233436469,
0.6620010138,
0.0607835501,
-0.4000667036,
-0.5355572104,
-0.1357726157,
-0.4458643496,
-0.0387421809,
0.8590976,
-0.8938880563,
0.1773578674,
0.4554553926,
0.6281209588,
0.7369334102,
-0.0229507349,
0.3511301875,
-0.8055064082,
0.4901138246,
0.259622097,
0.4149782062,
0.435567826,
0.1765351295,
0.4022459388,
0.2885399461,
-0.3578322828,
-0.6772990823,
0.1137742028,
-0.7090981007,
-0.0696483478,
1.0728712082,
-0.4838473797,
-0.0814318061,
-0.2829328477,
-0.0002461923,
0.3673413396,
-0.1788675934,
0.6016895771,
0.5794952512,
-0.0302305929,
0.2668331265,
-0.444821775,
0.4344833195,
0.4775904417,
-0.7979874611,
-0.0633773357,
0.1480171978,
0.3534148633,
0.0179066844,
0.8836627603,
-0.1439871788,
-0.2409602255,
-0.0162723847,
0.1383999586,
0.1166504174,
-0.2563281655,
-0.3038872778,
0.0197029505,
0.4718283415,
-0.2749460042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04664v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04664v2
|
Speech language models lack important brain-relevant semantics
| 2023-11-08T13:11:48 | 2024-06-16T23:52:21 |
Subba Reddy Oota, Emin Çelik, Fatma Deniz, Mariya Toneva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS, q-bio.NC
|
Despite known differences between reading and listening in the brain, recent
work has shown that text-based language models predict both text-evoked and
speech-evoked brain activity to an impressive degree. This poses the question
of what types of information language models truly predict in the brain. We
investigate this question via a direct approach, in which we systematically
remove specific low-level stimulus features (textual, speech, and visual) from
language model representations to assess their impact on alignment with fMRI
brain recordings during reading and listening. Comparing these findings with
speech-based language models reveals starkly different effects of low-level
features on brain alignment. While text-based models show reduced alignment in
early sensory regions post-removal, they retain significant predictive power in
late language regions. In contrast, speech-based models maintain strong
alignment in early auditory regions even after feature removal but lose all
predictive power in late language regions. These results suggest that
speech-based models provide insights into additional information processed by
early auditory regions, but caution is needed when using them to model
processing in late language regions. We make our code publicly available.
[https://github.com/subbareddy248/speech-llm-brain]
|
[
-0.1691340953,
-0.7151913643,
0.6825740933,
0.0004753285,
-0.0037593304,
-0.2993348539,
-0.2401711047,
-0.8157411218,
-0.0756987482,
0.3787760735,
-0.5012018681,
-0.3470785916,
-0.4497847259,
-0.1919746697,
-0.5166687369,
0.9434005618,
0.3540033698,
0.2062164545,
-0.3804120719,
0.0909820274,
-0.4900881052,
-0.4307550788,
-0.4934853017,
-0.8364542723,
0.7219170332,
-0.0341100357,
0.8513349295,
1.0697906017,
0.5616615415,
0.1740514487,
-0.6837449074,
-0.484767884,
-0.2942317724,
-0.086815767,
-0.1612470895,
-0.5787943006,
-0.5785038471,
0.04702539,
0.5901073217,
1.0853797197,
-0.30515486,
0.0671866536,
0.1226370484,
0.4268256128,
-0.5050426126,
0.1981173307,
-0.6222919226,
-0.1631706804,
-0.1969007254,
-0.1201192588,
-0.6638094783,
-0.0090160957,
0.4808779955,
-0.3914467394,
0.1614475101,
-0.0434934646,
1.1618151665,
0.5740501285,
-0.2688482106,
-0.2699131966,
-0.8145660758,
0.6493731141,
-0.7896816134,
0.7239968777,
0.7294795513,
-0.1783655286,
0.0074767168,
-0.4557724595,
-0.6242969036,
0.0564496554,
-0.4051956534,
0.0654423162,
-0.2206031233,
0.2131569237,
0.3830807507,
-0.0618176647,
-0.6026522517,
0.3103156984,
-0.4254688919,
-0.210505724,
0.2932749093,
0.0397927687,
0.4106969237,
-0.3894270658,
-0.0538297556,
0.0026547969,
-0.750208497,
0.1589168161,
0.2592091262,
0.4089668691,
-0.4532571137,
0.8037385941,
0.2745842934,
0.9722300172,
0.1311255544,
-0.4074060917,
0.2169440091,
-0.1276295334,
-0.2024281025,
0.2208014727,
0.6414414644,
-0.0265887696,
0.1734084785,
-0.2468045354,
-0.2496456206,
0.249777928,
-0.1222855821,
-0.3407281637,
-0.2739597857,
0.1786496043,
-0.7135828733,
0.036640428,
-0.3167149425,
-0.1960972697,
-0.6029108167,
-0.5905849934,
0.1708435714,
-0.6862055063,
-0.1927342266,
0.1401943117,
-0.0276757292,
0.487785548,
0.1683166623,
-1.0910439491,
0.1778193414,
0.776694119,
0.6886204481,
-0.2325341254,
-0.1798008829,
-0.2994871438,
0.3467267454,
-0.2698553205,
0.8228540421,
-0.8928127885,
0.0135410177,
-0.2471726239,
0.0516052619,
-0.0507100597,
-0.5985409021,
0.4972838759,
-0.6043167114,
0.2849413455,
-0.3730946779,
-0.5442096591,
-0.2145983577,
-0.3182320297,
-0.7631534934,
0.5251244903,
-0.2584840953,
-0.8930585384,
0.2429120541,
-0.3311753571,
-0.5699132681,
-0.103619121,
-0.4420891702,
-0.1629283279,
0.2639302313,
0.0673137754,
0.2738703489,
-0.0851136297,
0.3780596554,
-0.3365941048,
-0.5806157589,
0.3975002766,
-0.3885846436,
0.6787217259,
0.2211143523,
-0.2396758199,
-0.0709680319,
-0.9517278075,
-0.1038449779,
-0.0221358184,
-0.3457517624,
-0.4541398883,
0.4276086688,
0.1064163595,
0.1473034918,
0.2679372132,
-0.6656259298,
-0.1524868608,
-0.5038232803,
0.5384813547,
0.5144354701,
-0.3087003827,
0.7294850349,
-0.3231602907,
0.1569156796,
0.2354656756,
-0.2573539317,
-0.261056751,
-0.5564233661,
-0.6414358616,
-0.4778105915,
0.3690439761,
0.6802707911,
-0.372019738,
0.207397595,
-0.4485289454,
-0.3113245964,
-0.8160384297,
-0.3627001345,
0.4240830541,
0.7270789742,
0.3158336282,
-0.001534704,
-0.5336241722,
-1.1475197077,
-0.4820793271,
-0.3427871168,
-0.2536233962,
0.0071966732,
0.0943477005,
-0.1646119654,
0.9437260628,
-0.1800818145,
-0.2192073762,
0.0731773227,
0.0595726408,
0.1781714112,
0.3348234594,
0.2849398851,
-0.6070085168,
-0.0463756546,
0.1397491395,
-0.7353591919,
-0.1079742536,
-0.0709689483,
0.2109102011,
0.2116672546,
0.2855020165,
-0.6962227821,
0.5425316691,
0.5392939448,
-0.3623237908,
-0.012621507,
0.0732280836,
-0.0039176703,
-0.5525093675,
0.2450050712,
-0.0101065049,
0.0065533188,
-0.7192137241,
-0.4505622983,
0.2125086337,
-0.1234984696,
-0.2111458033,
0.6137325764,
-0.4607048035,
-0.4404864609,
-0.384773165,
0.2316508442,
0.0622302741,
0.4512190223,
0.418415755,
0.6958894134,
0.3021754622,
-0.4584473073,
-0.3894099593,
0.3517980576,
-0.5316901207,
0.1677011698,
-0.6612075567,
0.179660216,
-0.5645626783,
-0.1866358072,
-1.1600931883,
-0.1897748411,
0.0112620117,
-0.6705369353,
0.5255574584,
0.1034084186,
-0.1656681299,
0.1479801834,
0.3456586897,
0.3733012378,
0.7018570304,
-0.2597093582,
0.7069020271,
0.7178233266,
-0.4527390897,
-0.6821120977,
-1.1679329872,
-0.2338046432,
0.0870786086,
-0.4729181826,
0.6018450856,
0.1868885458,
-0.3705661297,
0.2159378082,
-0.1606885195,
-0.1091667935,
-0.0591885634,
0.4847026765,
0.2791262269,
-0.2301211357,
0.2862089574,
-0.0882304534,
0.0542017631,
-0.0300021749,
0.0504128486,
0.5026119947,
-0.1351628751,
-0.2236833274,
-0.6569557786,
0.193581596,
0.5347029567,
-0.3251016736,
0.7552219033,
0.4810910225,
-0.6217511296,
0.3384110928,
-0.3946065009,
-0.2324245423,
-0.4099594653,
0.5536393523,
-0.4410148859,
-0.9080439806,
0.4525785446,
0.3628555834,
-0.0783239231,
0.2335142642,
0.4562835693,
-0.5301775336,
1.1983636618,
0.7357769608,
0.1912062466,
0.7915461063,
0.1791410446,
0.3913306594,
-0.9755616784,
-0.3619438708,
-0.6487918496,
-0.3065574467,
-0.3922166228,
-0.0784682333,
0.0343025029,
-0.0710258707,
-0.0813942924,
0.1913496852,
-0.4192222357,
0.4610207379,
0.2217255831,
0.1852517873,
0.1490004361,
0.1684214324,
-0.0679994226,
-0.4429750144,
-0.6375405192,
-0.6396608353,
0.923802793,
0.437138021,
0.7641050816,
-0.2156101614,
0.3151489794,
0.075188987,
0.1058023199,
-0.8381438851,
0.5173701048,
-0.1099108681,
-0.4806831181,
-0.1829548031,
-0.328175962,
-0.857177794,
0.2313695401,
-0.3005410731,
-0.7359014153,
0.3927740157,
-0.0077870879,
-0.5325474143,
0.1882627308,
-0.8075890541,
0.6476639509,
-0.1602282226,
-0.2569648325,
-0.1771395653,
-0.4560219944,
0.2711559236,
-0.1163761988,
0.4514715672,
-0.1355097145,
-0.2934108675,
0.7561324239,
0.0195628293,
0.8471865654,
-0.0639234483,
-0.3210542798,
0.0591834188,
0.0593986735,
0.2008190155,
-0.3605479896,
-0.2392834127,
0.450258106,
0.2699576318,
-0.3693156242,
-0.4931648672,
0.6287817359,
-0.8385027051,
-0.3971006572,
-0.3876988888,
-0.5906403661,
-0.185988009,
0.2705767453,
0.362246573,
0.4146211147,
-0.186879009,
0.137995407,
0.7291529775,
-0.2837463617,
0.4968089759,
0.4084630609,
-0.2181916237,
-0.3635976613,
0.6536376476,
0.250027895,
0.1116006896,
0.5964225531,
-0.1250699013,
-0.2320392579,
-0.7892940044,
0.1233527511,
0.5002677441,
-0.7539122105,
0.2784647346,
-0.6187774539,
-0.1419909894,
-0.375761807,
0.2092775851,
-0.2324684262,
-0.4475228488,
-0.3039749861,
-0.2234179974,
-0.0543585531,
0.6153677702,
-0.0275059398,
0.6313809156,
-0.6692971587,
0.3020674884,
0.0021596476,
0.3076490462,
-0.1248877496,
-0.5576868653,
-0.4451274574,
0.3484277129,
0.0712524801,
-0.8862320185,
0.424882412,
0.3226793706,
0.3688591123,
0.2938269377,
-0.3797605634,
0.7288015485,
-0.5890002251,
0.7698938251,
0.2648913562,
-0.9324952364,
0.5093669891,
-0.3710618615,
0.6610863805,
0.2553291619,
0.2046754658,
-0.4790056348,
-0.3317316771,
-0.3876554668,
-0.4594009221,
0.7043875456,
0.0385554507,
-0.2024536282,
-0.153203547,
0.5194862485,
0.1361194551,
0.1914146394,
-0.7939795852,
-0.1563310623,
0.1600358188,
-0.4481929243,
-0.055757124,
-0.2704412043,
0.0017205299,
-0.3014917374,
0.4059298337,
0.1483503878,
0.4553625584,
0.2155309319,
-0.1186459213,
-0.3645685315,
0.1990981698,
0.589343071,
0.4920754135,
-0.2064259797,
0.1108611524,
-0.0806182474,
-0.5895959139,
0.03809046,
-0.0771542266,
-0.5579321384,
0.0391536206,
0.6695910692,
1.0342684984,
0.2592681646,
-0.6386933923,
0.3584287465,
-0.103887178,
0.1269992739,
-0.3040219843,
-0.0382801481,
0.3511553705,
0.2010623366,
0.1324026585,
0.4707007408,
0.0151142366,
-0.4631773233,
0.225274384,
0.3590632677,
-0.6709781885,
-0.653006494,
0.7244125605,
-0.198925212,
-0.3350735903,
0.5455988646,
0.4943648875,
0.0044985758,
0.5811235309,
0.5444890261,
0.7709857821,
-0.2195157111,
-0.2049422562,
0.2788675129,
0.3587384522,
0.1241733059,
0.343877703,
0.1750695258,
-0.8333425522,
-0.6939358115,
-0.6790526509,
-0.0530394018,
0.2403800189,
-0.6935418844,
0.2727965713,
-0.3866661191,
-0.5513076782,
0.4084802866,
-0.3981232345,
-0.6894960403,
0.3435171247,
0.640933454,
0.5602741241,
-0.7048268318,
1.094741106,
0.7407998443,
-0.3272198737,
-0.747500062,
0.0383935161,
-0.0485851169,
-0.4875158072,
0.5617049932,
0.0826003253,
-0.2189127356,
-0.0140861114,
-0.650118053,
-1.2579854727,
0.7246211767,
0.7947955728,
-0.6882693172,
-0.4105791152,
0.0927825421,
0.6178524494,
-0.4194763303,
0.4377996325,
0.4722480178,
0.4003442526,
0.0270266701,
-0.9984330535,
-0.2458477914,
-0.2092011422,
0.0145745408,
0.1868361831,
-0.270097971,
0.9664068818,
-0.2623683512,
-0.563192606,
-0.0023713729,
0.8002915382,
0.0408239849,
0.0868516788,
0.3279834092,
0.6399408579,
0.9651198387,
-0.1826083511,
0.9062654376,
-0.292421639,
0.0608813837,
1.3780394793,
-0.3299981356,
1.2162996531,
0.6869898438,
0.0644551218,
0.6261701584,
0.7454401851,
0.3527071476,
0.8007179499,
-0.1516791135,
0.0762379766,
-0.2357517034,
-0.0879527405,
-0.2555392981,
0.5743308663,
0.4710906446,
-0.3716968596,
0.0960362032,
0.1874488741,
-0.0050808615,
0.0896185264,
-0.0961725116,
0.8427794576,
0.1662974209,
-0.7521662116,
0.7580374479,
-0.1151132584,
0.5594613552,
-0.4996643662,
0.0821646005,
-0.0168302543,
0.1815113872,
-0.3924718201,
-0.6445018053,
0.5256334543,
-0.0712467954,
-0.5502747297,
-0.1782571375,
0.6577234864,
-0.6242928505,
-0.0078198714,
0.5916126966,
0.5115709305,
0.0717801526,
0.1339073181,
-0.5768733025,
0.1820193827,
-0.0361498185,
-0.3394979537,
0.4055989087,
0.2107227594,
0.0477034114,
0.6424296498,
0.62517488,
0.4192317128,
0.0927867368,
-0.0236442201,
0.4136790931,
-0.9021813273,
-0.3488929272,
-0.8211243749,
0.4078292549,
0.154072836,
-0.0269776992,
0.1892816722,
0.4352945983,
0.8085006475,
-0.0807612017,
0.7552536726,
-0.0507145971,
0.5766337514,
-0.5512911677,
0.8677056432,
-0.6286619902,
0.2920157909,
-0.1569923311,
-0.8568506837,
-0.194851175,
0.6969510913,
-0.5872229934,
-0.0592352711,
0.9227075577,
0.7532088757,
-0.0467139371,
0.1771628112,
0.5184774399,
0.456433028,
-0.0191077627,
0.461499244,
0.9075473547,
-0.3858858049,
0.3613662124,
-0.1529085785,
-0.1958579421,
0.1831091195,
-0.7900472283,
-0.6390759349,
-0.6992829442,
-0.4555216432,
-0.2573539615,
-0.1440501362,
0.6841378808,
0.6217898726,
-0.7514879704,
-0.3499167562,
0.0994111225,
0.0657232702,
-0.2230968922,
-0.1610204726,
0.3608363271,
-0.0940703824,
-0.5508012176,
0.531458199,
0.4495357573,
0.1165223196,
0.0612166151,
0.0337073319,
-0.2885345817,
0.1661984175,
0.4049246609,
0.2554685473,
-1.1090698242,
-0.4010924697,
0.2880320251,
-0.6004231572,
0.1848427206,
0.5373858809,
-0.8629813194,
0.2493198365,
0.7347162366,
0.5018532276,
0.3511316478,
-0.1566058099,
0.6854082346,
-0.3332558572,
0.5167238712,
0.4004933834,
0.4691763222,
0.3914299309,
-0.4611895084,
0.3257820308,
0.0502509102,
-0.3447253406,
-0.8175284863,
0.3638983965,
-0.9550043344,
-0.1868697405,
0.990057826,
0.0203321669,
-0.7783735394,
0.0069005461,
-0.1220830753,
0.3773140311,
-0.0472617224,
0.559030354,
1.0700590611,
-0.1740685701,
-0.3610447943,
-0.4594478607,
0.5507101417,
0.6993933916,
-0.3013017774,
0.1448023766,
0.7048089504,
0.1347661912,
0.2027923167,
0.6122437716,
-0.3579389155,
0.0969618559,
-0.0941589996,
0.3857219815,
0.1348215491,
-0.3635277748,
-0.6630660892,
0.1276983172,
0.0297154263,
0.0227841791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04661v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04661v3
|
Massive Editing for Large Language Models via Meta Learning
| 2023-11-08T13:03:06 | 2024-01-25T03:50:57 |
Chenmien Tan, Ge Zhang, Jie Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While large language models (LLMs) have enabled learning knowledge from the
pre-training corpora, the acquired knowledge may be fundamentally incorrect or
outdated over time, which necessitates rectifying the knowledge of the language
model (LM) after the training. A promising approach involves employing a
hyper-network to generate parameter shift, whereas existing hyper-networks
suffer from inferior scalability in synchronous editing operation amount. To
mitigate the problem, we propose the MAssive Language Model Editing Network
(MALMEN), which formulates the parameter shift aggregation as the least square
problem, subsequently updating the LM parameters using the normal equation. To
accommodate editing multiple facts simultaneously with limited memory budgets,
we separate the computation on the hyper-network and LM, enabling arbitrary
batch size on both neural networks. Our method is evaluated by editing up to
thousands of facts on LMs with different architectures, i.e., BERT-base, GPT-2,
T5-XL (2.8B), and GPT-J (6B), across various knowledge-intensive NLP tasks,
i.e., closed book fact-checking and question answering. Remarkably, MALMEN is
capable of editing hundreds of times more facts than strong baselines with the
identical hyper-network architecture and outperforms editor specifically
designed for GPT. Our code is available at
https://github.com/ChenmienTan/malmen.
|
[
-0.2601518631,
-0.8645927906,
0.5969071388,
0.0276973825,
-0.09235432,
-0.1444717646,
-0.6532193422,
-0.1850231886,
0.0968075544,
0.7113201022,
-0.3035854399,
-0.5887771845,
-0.6294056177,
0.2297642231,
-0.2972199619,
1.0760834217,
-0.0336785316,
-0.1308539063,
-0.1147665381,
-0.4037559628,
-0.386212647,
-0.4102301002,
-0.727899313,
0.0821524113,
0.529741168,
0.1704637259,
1.1011360884,
0.9795260429,
0.2839019001,
0.4155365229,
-0.2685447633,
0.7024438381,
-0.3449526131,
0.0391882621,
-0.4589999914,
-0.33545205,
-0.8458854556,
-0.2615638077,
0.8485055566,
0.6490430236,
0.0213593505,
0.4735073149,
0.1315870136,
0.6724151969,
-0.7971310616,
0.3411204219,
-0.8485360742,
-0.144834742,
-0.2427833527,
-0.0035629962,
-0.4231734276,
-0.2269187272,
-0.1799360514,
-0.7164156437,
0.0466079712,
-0.0334537476,
0.7207722068,
0.4659233987,
-0.1099931002,
-0.0579580814,
-0.8056254983,
0.4559202492,
-0.8269757628,
0.5047140121,
0.3818589747,
0.0517632291,
0.0513280071,
-0.6232866049,
-0.5845699906,
0.0999805033,
-0.0312120151,
-0.1505332589,
-0.388052851,
0.1751614213,
0.4785732627,
-0.2217796594,
-0.5322707295,
0.0394823179,
-0.368375957,
-0.131883651,
0.6434191465,
0.3956835866,
0.1711410135,
-0.0666783229,
0.0713790208,
0.1555763781,
-0.6188817024,
-0.3424476385,
0.182031408,
0.2854524851,
0.237921536,
0.581040144,
-0.0989694074,
0.9167914987,
0.1059137657,
-0.0555029511,
0.2340545952,
-0.1821156442,
-0.7399194837,
-0.0956250876,
0.8817308545,
0.3069320023,
0.0748445466,
-0.0104520237,
-0.259303987,
-0.4644480944,
0.209483251,
-0.6919903755,
-0.0675655082,
0.0196009167,
-0.3791371882,
-0.3399974406,
-0.2668101192,
-0.7309410572,
-0.4533527493,
-0.4748135209,
0.5429300666,
-0.1781693548,
0.0043478669,
0.2902374268,
0.1722029299,
-0.2973768711,
0.5173660517,
-0.7705581784,
0.1253967583,
0.5994189978,
0.9371880293,
0.2079731226,
-0.4771099091,
-0.598103106,
0.2662295997,
-0.4885322452,
0.3293077946,
-0.5837544203,
0.014842947,
-0.0997898728,
-0.1189884543,
-0.3107899129,
-0.5122259855,
0.2683157623,
-0.9237066507,
0.0794265568,
-0.1936535835,
-0.521355629,
-0.1755669862,
0.275397867,
-0.7040836215,
0.8998795748,
-0.1740107089,
-0.7026904225,
-0.0132809142,
-0.7349585891,
-0.2517186105,
-0.209996134,
0.1837168187,
-0.4843723476,
0.0740328208,
0.5023837686,
0.5274255872,
-0.1978734583,
0.6002933979,
-0.3633360267,
-0.211693868,
0.2771988511,
-0.4733708203,
0.8138824105,
0.0038057063,
-0.2838768661,
0.3519103527,
-0.8097832203,
-0.2814414799,
-0.0461484008,
-0.5301911235,
-0.4929175079,
-0.1022910625,
0.0001604879,
0.4301416278,
0.2071496397,
-0.3567606509,
0.5597271919,
-0.0632276908,
0.4175373912,
0.9605308771,
0.0045555909,
0.1529962122,
-0.0941245258,
0.3260132968,
-0.2275031954,
0.3476262093,
0.053010039,
-0.236076653,
-0.7771493793,
-0.2034838796,
0.5246759057,
0.5871283412,
-0.6881173253,
0.3342987299,
-0.4668989778,
-0.2572366297,
-0.5681687593,
0.5267591476,
0.320459187,
0.4043876827,
0.7110615969,
0.1166776791,
-0.5916420221,
-0.8318677545,
-0.4639568329,
-0.0059670275,
0.1496175677,
0.2706754208,
0.4501271248,
-0.5263973475,
0.7999649048,
-0.6435307264,
-0.2459771037,
-0.1725114882,
0.103062965,
0.1482404172,
0.2661222816,
0.2744825482,
-0.4398013651,
-0.4508569837,
0.0150912674,
-0.7132837772,
-0.3209446669,
-0.348683387,
-0.2173479795,
0.2869166136,
0.9751951694,
-0.7644155025,
0.1208803505,
0.6971154213,
0.0087227244,
0.7348308563,
-0.2510368228,
-0.0397913195,
-1.3512426615,
0.2136619538,
-0.0907804072,
-0.4237275422,
-0.5114992261,
0.0120285619,
0.2780554295,
-0.1374195814,
-0.38619259,
0.5256485343,
-0.4495338798,
0.0091343299,
-0.3104465902,
0.0407558903,
-0.1761508435,
0.6287635565,
-0.1721925586,
0.6930083632,
0.4026355743,
-0.5553251505,
0.3804678023,
0.3943952918,
-0.2629702985,
0.1967622936,
-0.5440053344,
0.2682066858,
-0.2601850331,
0.4509970248,
-0.6336128116,
-0.0389126986,
0.2334966213,
-0.0962622538,
0.3154741824,
-0.4576732516,
-0.5710220337,
0.0521823987,
-0.0931161195,
0.267631948,
0.0834262148,
-0.4363684058,
0.4803692997,
0.2516408563,
-0.3369263411,
-0.8116468787,
-0.564448595,
0.542560935,
0.0906919464,
-0.4712443054,
0.1040454283,
-0.0041567916,
-0.3139693439,
0.335414052,
-0.0711271241,
-0.0514871664,
-0.058637172,
0.0156671312,
0.3011188209,
-0.3094677329,
0.4399140179,
0.3485872447,
-0.2104199827,
-0.0436247513,
-0.5779101849,
0.3346544802,
-0.036900267,
-0.2337290347,
-0.3805361986,
0.0056772945,
1.083646059,
-0.5741168857,
0.8385029435,
0.6635247469,
-0.37407583,
-0.251750797,
-0.4662493169,
0.1165473685,
-0.4126989245,
0.7741220593,
-0.1982216537,
-1.0743310452,
0.3259343207,
-0.2510115504,
0.3468330204,
0.6950905323,
0.6104626656,
0.1217028126,
0.8836992979,
0.3968913257,
-0.3455504775,
0.3274149895,
-0.1952198744,
-0.0284941383,
-0.9879934192,
0.1068982705,
-0.3888185024,
-0.5106854439,
-0.3464914858,
-0.7546884418,
0.6758117676,
-0.0770408586,
-0.2339965254,
0.3356450498,
0.1944860667,
0.65172261,
0.2527008057,
0.1678881943,
0.3346631825,
-0.2111231089,
-0.0334955193,
0.072317034,
-0.7220327258,
-0.2874602675,
1.2550332546,
0.1890871525,
0.5997232199,
0.1911900938,
0.3808326423,
0.3448764086,
0.3077502549,
-0.5304650068,
0.6285606027,
-0.2764128745,
-0.6903432012,
-0.6071010232,
-0.6077767015,
-0.6795546412,
0.4407374561,
-0.4439898431,
-0.4101521373,
0.1217365786,
0.2775045931,
-0.4208595753,
0.8267657161,
-0.2718140483,
0.8015645742,
0.0290175565,
-0.5681908131,
-0.4115927815,
-0.8179837465,
0.4168714881,
-0.3425017297,
0.3372420669,
0.15588139,
-0.1665221155,
0.6224831939,
-0.5161680579,
0.9844642878,
-0.0233332403,
-0.0256322306,
0.1021282077,
0.3984459937,
0.73566854,
0.2539812326,
-0.2065422088,
0.1069349945,
-0.4055674076,
-0.1890446544,
-0.9169948101,
0.4137325883,
-0.6864401698,
-0.5162045956,
-0.0710436925,
-0.9508641362,
-0.3859580159,
0.1389722228,
-0.0632730126,
0.665094614,
-0.1914319396,
0.2096729875,
0.710850656,
-0.2492683679,
0.4215695858,
0.3908335268,
-0.3124016821,
-0.5722225308,
0.7503683567,
0.308377713,
0.4757083952,
0.5825173259,
0.4021010697,
-0.0962970704,
-0.5694198608,
-0.7789502144,
0.1806852371,
-0.5298067331,
-0.2178302705,
-0.9812651277,
-0.1699557006,
-0.2174942642,
-0.1292601973,
-0.6025452018,
-0.5178693533,
-0.0058664209,
0.0053342213,
0.2042384297,
0.7390520573,
-0.275064528,
0.2178954631,
-1.1063266993,
0.1691045314,
0.5572820306,
0.3265773952,
-0.0774983838,
-0.6766423583,
-0.7088077664,
-0.0104304953,
-0.0417901315,
-0.8790935874,
0.1919920295,
0.1556021422,
0.2177283913,
0.4145746827,
-0.2005023956,
0.7379834056,
-0.523409307,
0.4864552021,
-0.1240455881,
-1.2832727432,
0.1089109108,
-0.4288285077,
0.3401430845,
0.6221550703,
0.3364622891,
-0.9764580727,
-0.3083830178,
-0.5336126089,
-0.5020003319,
0.7402361631,
-0.060445644,
0.2138524503,
0.2328413725,
0.420820415,
-0.0130354706,
0.3311047852,
-0.418687731,
-0.2588058412,
0.1464811414,
-0.0856872872,
-0.2017791569,
-0.3675067127,
-0.1146555468,
-0.51690799,
0.9626914263,
-0.1090267673,
0.0007053993,
0.0762318894,
-0.5124953389,
-0.136614576,
0.4531957507,
1.0215632915,
0.9569532275,
-0.2292719632,
0.3723102212,
0.5838589668,
-0.5088937879,
0.030596843,
-0.0916149989,
-0.2936829925,
0.0973838344,
0.5450639129,
1.067258954,
0.2244264185,
-0.3890839517,
0.3203424215,
0.165572226,
-0.4312252998,
0.4577025473,
-0.0489912108,
0.2338485718,
0.3314074874,
-0.0247042067,
0.531419456,
-0.1116300598,
-0.2421476096,
0.2036998272,
0.0772071928,
-0.2341290414,
-0.3206716478,
0.60655725,
0.075767152,
-0.1281216294,
0.6816018224,
-0.1890028566,
-0.694917202,
0.1727678031,
0.6216797829,
1.010340929,
-0.3442065716,
0.2402873188,
0.4070239663,
0.7113765478,
-0.1310049146,
-0.2722653747,
0.1914577782,
-0.6761847138,
-0.8049977422,
-0.4031388462,
-0.3718416393,
0.5163967609,
-0.2944659293,
0.3214256465,
-0.6708032489,
0.019415617,
-0.0400176644,
-0.3292321265,
-0.441977948,
0.0959935114,
-0.0251628868,
0.6825816035,
-1.0130866766,
0.7874523997,
0.8013701439,
-0.1298838854,
-0.6386213303,
0.1092988253,
0.1572457254,
-0.6339747906,
0.485806495,
-0.3318369389,
0.0260045957,
-0.1284154356,
-0.5760888457,
-0.8855789304,
0.7973989248,
0.6952602267,
-0.8601686358,
0.0086130425,
0.1295834035,
0.3832703233,
0.0721901953,
0.0598545149,
0.2819650769,
0.6403169036,
-0.2116686404,
-0.9244580269,
0.1302956194,
-0.0409675278,
-0.1763331741,
0.3920988739,
-0.6816766858,
0.9411384463,
-0.1536976099,
0.178772971,
-0.549565196,
0.6062175632,
-0.1049619988,
0.0152721517,
0.6494145393,
0.789994061,
0.880361855,
0.5117441416,
0.7072823048,
-0.2066882402,
0.4847915471,
1.2151287794,
-0.1576265991,
0.6529331803,
0.1822495461,
-0.14491795,
0.1476387382,
0.3778171241,
0.0941376165,
0.0452631675,
0.1253482997,
-0.2009007186,
-0.4862425029,
0.320106864,
-0.315751195,
0.5435292721,
0.2019012868,
-0.4790919125,
-0.4054403901,
-0.0114218891,
0.6658506989,
-0.2130215764,
-0.4075978994,
0.6306426525,
-0.1426864266,
-0.2902617753,
0.4740645289,
0.5042474866,
0.3173282146,
-0.5162244439,
0.1014176905,
-0.144134596,
0.0767460987,
-0.2172367275,
-0.6383618116,
0.5240354538,
0.210620299,
-0.2875019312,
-0.2068295926,
0.6495956182,
-0.6165595055,
-0.6504613161,
0.0154493339,
0.5966327786,
-0.0770202801,
-0.267157346,
-0.7449008822,
0.1812299937,
-0.1282272637,
-0.3499777019,
0.3342809677,
0.4778224528,
-0.1967158169,
0.3834096491,
0.8834067583,
0.2216691822,
0.0983242244,
-0.0441404432,
0.81002599,
-0.3730745912,
-0.3229967356,
-1.3236846924,
0.3058381975,
0.0323228985,
-0.3648700416,
0.6230453253,
0.7004209757,
0.6850337386,
-0.2342529744,
0.9243595004,
0.1387688965,
-0.0477755181,
-0.6579464078,
0.833399415,
-0.5238484144,
0.0913406834,
-0.5110983849,
-1.1944326162,
-0.6112553477,
0.2025683224,
-0.4142512083,
-0.2855225205,
0.6772536635,
0.886377871,
-0.3506605029,
-0.0799042135,
0.3971685171,
0.5632324219,
0.324952215,
0.3654277325,
0.4669361115,
-0.2560826838,
0.4473185241,
0.0422903486,
-0.0852348581,
-0.3348909616,
-0.7678134441,
-0.9138101339,
-0.6176261306,
-0.3776358366,
-0.3295294344,
0.3898938894,
1.3232673407,
0.6431106329,
-0.4999243915,
-0.1914157867,
0.1508567333,
0.3183980882,
-0.5299140215,
-0.0819949433,
0.7905015349,
-0.3309719563,
-0.6967612505,
0.5536429286,
0.4104084373,
-0.4352089167,
-0.0325352848,
0.0201051068,
-0.3482114673,
0.2617197335,
0.7397031188,
0.1507780403,
-0.2323600501,
-0.2669847608,
-0.1352271289,
-0.2089921087,
-0.1437921375,
0.8315724134,
-0.3071628809,
0.53387326,
0.6354902387,
1.2507144213,
0.4108917117,
-0.0582964718,
0.3386446238,
-0.6435127854,
-0.201597169,
-0.120077312,
0.2885985076,
0.1772568673,
-0.2516581714,
0.2379904985,
0.5467210412,
-0.6244947314,
-0.6721097231,
0.0444672219,
-0.8139336109,
-0.2663723826,
1.2244161367,
0.1691274792,
-0.2857798934,
-0.0502136052,
-0.2280936986,
0.4916978478,
-0.0671582446,
0.6305841208,
0.6460817456,
0.1067458615,
-0.0997537673,
-0.8313653469,
0.4103524387,
0.4076673687,
-0.8573254943,
0.4447193146,
0.5575453043,
0.3589520156,
-0.0846573338,
0.3654484451,
-0.0836432502,
0.2221681625,
-0.2341208011,
0.3106669784,
-0.6742620468,
-0.5941662788,
-0.4127389193,
0.1435658932,
-0.2384388894,
-0.2692466676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04948v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04948v1
|
Explained anomaly detection in text reviews: Can subjective scenarios be correctly evaluated?
| 2023-11-08T11:51:47 | 2023-11-08T11:51:47 |
David Novoa-Paradela, Oscar Fontenla-Romero, Bertha Guijarro-Berdiñas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a pipeline to detect and explain anomalous reviews in
online platforms. The pipeline is made up of three modules and allows the
detection of reviews that do not generate value for users due to either
worthless or malicious composition. The classifications are accompanied by a
normality score and an explanation that justifies the decision made. The
pipeline's ability to solve the anomaly detection task was evaluated using
different datasets created from a large Amazon database. Additionally, a study
comparing three explainability techniques involving 241 participants was
conducted to assess the explainability module. The study aimed to measure the
impact of explanations on the respondents' ability to reproduce the
classification model and their perceived usefulness. This work can be useful to
automate tasks in review online platforms, such as those for electronic
commerce, and offers inspiration for addressing similar problems in the field
of anomaly detection in textual data. We also consider it interesting to have
carried out a human evaluation of the capacity of different explainability
techniques in a real and infrequent scenario such as the detection of anomalous
reviews, as well as to reflect on whether it is possible to explain tasks as
humanly subjective as this one.
|
[
-0.3591942191,
-0.779563725,
0.7139181495,
0.3154779375,
-0.3913233578,
-0.1689129174,
0.0885318145,
-0.522696197,
0.2951369882,
0.5220369101,
-0.7535500526,
-0.651677072,
-0.4148505926,
0.3982503116,
-0.98877877,
1.4532594681,
-0.0105078341,
-0.2229810357,
-0.2762108445,
-0.0761204585,
-0.2057823092,
-0.5262655616,
-0.5406226516,
0.0352665484,
0.178697139,
0.2653579712,
0.5958411098,
0.6211766005,
0.6216067076,
0.2883698344,
-0.0315701663,
0.1629918367,
-0.3150726855,
-0.0430312045,
-0.3313266635,
-0.7114137411,
-0.6824151874,
-0.2909069657,
0.4038014114,
0.5361804962,
-0.1124041229,
0.0044726888,
0.179138124,
0.7898548841,
-0.3188659549,
-0.1564532518,
-0.534127593,
0.3930966556,
-0.0934977308,
-0.2638955712,
-0.1503621489,
-0.3399267793,
0.2020109892,
-0.6777252555,
0.6695343852,
0.1579749733,
0.7693655491,
0.0946164653,
-0.2047963291,
-0.8095452785,
-0.8874571323,
0.7825086117,
-0.7265626192,
-0.0435607955,
0.169303745,
0.3274149597,
-0.0374401882,
-0.6608358622,
-0.9828051329,
-0.0548194498,
-0.3422154784,
0.2573191226,
-0.705922544,
-0.0670363903,
0.0510202684,
0.5339438319,
-0.7396669984,
0.1562482417,
-0.11956653,
-0.4475301206,
0.6458458304,
0.3840330839,
0.240597859,
-0.6407521367,
-0.5156399608,
0.419928968,
-0.2604971528,
0.2335068285,
1.0586662292,
-0.1739934087,
-0.1114737764,
0.2817805409,
-0.2717203796,
0.4667028487,
0.0336705148,
0.3544251919,
0.1896430999,
-0.5315096974,
-0.0407977551,
-0.1579132974,
0.7062185407,
0.6541767716,
0.1376590133,
-0.0723752603,
-0.3795519769,
0.2578686178,
0.6725136638,
-0.467625469,
-0.2660995722,
0.5323245525,
-1.0547724962,
-0.7014417052,
0.1980520338,
-0.9558398724,
-0.6799833179,
-0.1102350578,
0.5244024992,
0.1609302312,
-0.5267034769,
0.2233372331,
-0.3845180571,
-0.3449685872,
0.3771349788,
-0.6763588786,
0.3961136639,
0.6422331929,
0.4243724048,
-0.450604856,
-0.1924787164,
-0.0772594586,
-0.3947033882,
-0.0565551482,
1.1203260422,
-0.1388429105,
-0.2769239247,
0.000581473,
0.3460824788,
0.1921690851,
-0.4497128129,
0.9333232045,
-0.3134160936,
0.608404398,
-0.0908186436,
-0.5147027969,
-0.6488788128,
0.5465447903,
-0.5140794516,
0.5680831075,
0.1248549819,
-0.9335723519,
0.4523989558,
-0.9219507575,
-0.1649839878,
0.0902915895,
0.4534529746,
-0.5110977888,
-0.0117747625,
0.2852018774,
0.4663792253,
-0.041890718,
0.0169039927,
-0.4184570014,
-0.4927952886,
0.7696953416,
-0.5874259472,
0.7954928279,
0.3066704273,
-0.6029669046,
-0.0066835871,
-0.5578260422,
-0.0263035037,
-0.1198425591,
0.062508136,
-0.1513570994,
0.1258886904,
0.2216915041,
-0.030127747,
0.032464236,
-0.4143526256,
0.0425946899,
-0.7050522566,
0.4665730894,
0.3993398845,
0.6840397716,
0.3253498673,
-0.2559337914,
0.782994628,
0.3745637834,
0.4039725065,
-0.3917261362,
-0.6078026891,
-0.7064812779,
0.0129583292,
0.2264297456,
0.4932828248,
-0.4682941735,
0.5837329626,
-0.0053675496,
-0.3082595468,
-0.501811564,
0.2608104646,
0.4293843806,
0.5598136187,
0.1916488856,
-0.6710618734,
-0.4831055701,
-0.9683555365,
-0.9061521888,
-0.3141500652,
-0.4262430966,
0.1671949774,
0.4380259812,
-0.5367900133,
1.0000604391,
-0.1957420856,
-0.2529566288,
-0.1696576625,
0.4552195966,
0.3808301389,
0.0846804008,
0.4701568484,
-0.7648507357,
-0.0568207428,
0.0485667847,
-0.8527190089,
-0.278752923,
-0.2701021135,
0.3183392286,
0.2918795347,
-0.0022063295,
-0.1674252152,
0.4680960774,
0.3113144338,
-0.3572492301,
0.4159203172,
-0.3345500231,
0.3984004259,
-0.7006880641,
-0.2090644985,
0.3210041523,
-0.3002128899,
-0.6814109683,
0.0164798871,
0.01193457,
-0.0186092425,
-0.2800518572,
0.1079625636,
-0.081917122,
0.1108099595,
-0.5204726458,
0.2907797992,
0.3100770116,
0.3189264238,
-0.2403401881,
-0.0657502711,
0.5376793742,
-0.6943899393,
0.4138793945,
-0.1346867234,
-0.2531197369,
0.7197724581,
-0.5111202002,
0.103035517,
-0.4020605683,
0.3449988365,
-1.2704700232,
-0.4088163972,
0.5623485446,
-0.6938745379,
-0.3244124055,
-0.2492759079,
-0.2764734626,
-0.3961155117,
-0.4004828036,
0.0023581488,
0.2488095164,
-0.7152140141,
0.3398519456,
0.3633526266,
0.1157048047,
-0.459007293,
-0.614320755,
0.1388448179,
-0.798355937,
-0.4902380705,
0.1625003219,
0.0126851788,
-0.3908364475,
0.2203643024,
-0.0687314719,
-0.345027864,
0.3561443985,
0.1937992722,
0.1283828765,
-0.1067382693,
0.0469294004,
0.0409552343,
-0.171886459,
0.5749883652,
-0.244815141,
-0.01619092,
-0.3225905299,
-0.2344116122,
-0.9473875165,
0.1604159772,
0.4862045348,
0.3451164961,
0.2530409396,
0.7518274188,
-0.4638063908,
-0.3900200725,
-0.3862584531,
-0.3127191365,
-0.4142138362,
0.3925374448,
-0.0003007432,
-0.4505220354,
0.7406384945,
0.238548547,
-0.0242078695,
0.8137539029,
0.6630438566,
-0.4190755188,
1.267469883,
0.4576604664,
0.1709542722,
-0.030408293,
-0.0950506032,
0.6668180227,
-0.3838781118,
-0.1938112676,
-0.5220577717,
-0.4112668037,
-0.7790151834,
-0.0439639613,
0.3137315214,
0.0824751556,
0.4920575917,
0.234079197,
-0.6650604606,
0.551409483,
0.1292070895,
0.0118419938,
0.4754430652,
-0.0053387959,
0.2424537838,
-0.0560129397,
-0.3995190859,
-0.737857759,
1.0700029135,
0.5957739949,
0.2894123495,
0.0152005535,
0.3293552995,
0.8545743227,
0.3053382635,
-0.9100215435,
0.1345503032,
-0.0436565839,
-0.72544837,
-0.301676631,
-0.201119259,
-0.88910532,
0.1352873147,
-0.5106863379,
-0.657458961,
0.1534678191,
0.4223481715,
-0.2988598645,
0.0867121145,
-1.0685054064,
0.9258613586,
-0.2492861897,
-0.2148190141,
-0.4121357501,
-0.5473231077,
0.5967100859,
-0.0494570211,
0.7117869854,
0.2266031951,
0.011779543,
0.7474792004,
-0.2303579748,
0.6520258188,
-0.2501366436,
0.1098738164,
0.457021445,
0.1326165497,
0.261221081,
0.2904858887,
0.0158706754,
0.1917486489,
-0.0260994397,
-0.3622489572,
-0.9447445273,
0.6123434901,
-0.4936708808,
-0.5532315373,
-0.2219526023,
-0.0799678192,
-0.0706388876,
-0.0986088738,
0.3136081696,
0.4542443156,
-0.0531970486,
0.1825044751,
0.4832366705,
-0.1044411063,
0.57440871,
0.4682029188,
-0.1696154177,
-0.0918016881,
1.0583461523,
-0.1376064718,
-0.3116287887,
0.2209364325,
0.5764887333,
-0.3924257159,
-0.8487129807,
-0.7171847224,
-0.2430751175,
-0.6798238158,
0.0728423893,
-0.9033199549,
0.1262078136,
0.0478802957,
0.1749593019,
-0.0295044035,
-0.8861836791,
-0.1719854921,
-0.1280634254,
0.1506122053,
1.1015423536,
0.2059295774,
0.2382760048,
-0.7086005211,
0.2336895764,
0.1996792257,
0.2348014563,
0.2466080785,
-0.6202692986,
-0.3632290363,
-0.0228416547,
-0.6454210281,
-1.1456385851,
0.3979354799,
-0.0067147729,
0.4361096323,
1.0151106119,
0.1017391756,
0.3303198814,
0.3036212027,
1.0250560045,
-0.0543780066,
-1.0028918982,
0.4388309121,
-0.5477089286,
0.1001450345,
0.2610891759,
0.7324316502,
-0.2932450175,
-0.7293347716,
-0.83629179,
-0.813663125,
0.6154760718,
0.4757754207,
0.2121718675,
0.2952015102,
0.439810276,
0.6442552805,
0.380761683,
-1.0031440258,
-0.2816395462,
-0.3945073783,
0.1125718951,
0.0709759668,
-0.2626450956,
-0.1175623462,
0.0643474013,
0.4840914905,
0.1800025254,
0.1501919329,
0.3021222353,
-0.0930376276,
-0.0966774449,
0.4505285621,
0.5005152225,
0.9749444723,
-0.0707951039,
0.1214240789,
0.0109890467,
-0.4540264308,
-0.2504172921,
-0.0917426348,
-0.0026070881,
0.1566479951,
0.5413804054,
0.5919522047,
-0.0202317648,
-0.5129657388,
0.6328498125,
-0.3176671267,
-0.374658674,
-0.2120316625,
-0.0031098977,
-0.2140379995,
-0.1471499801,
0.4069409668,
0.4698579609,
0.7964805365,
-0.8481805325,
0.0138189355,
0.2924312949,
-0.5546052456,
-0.6666484475,
0.4599507153,
0.3367827833,
-0.5653238893,
0.2837859988,
-0.5020139813,
-0.8509196639,
0.7468604445,
0.1705946624,
0.9750329852,
0.1377712041,
0.3756548762,
0.1998132318,
0.5768740773,
0.2737701535,
-0.0046204305,
-0.1502805948,
-0.8054767251,
0.0084684268,
-0.423756808,
-0.675842464,
0.2174164951,
-0.6042886376,
0.4181112945,
-0.1903494745,
-0.0023641372,
0.3562305272,
-0.2263381183,
-0.4359634221,
0.4091853499,
-0.2370706797,
0.2703813016,
-1.1092597246,
0.132673651,
0.5581002235,
-0.0759426504,
-0.446593076,
0.4182210863,
0.3388964236,
-0.384583056,
0.047585737,
0.2101327926,
-0.1198259145,
-0.4860836565,
-0.0722577274,
-0.1097702086,
0.3868735135,
-0.0150457248,
-0.3212640882,
0.3234257102,
-0.0626732036,
1.2156991959,
-0.4255946577,
0.7697337866,
0.5172231197,
0.5155230761,
-0.3451804221,
-0.6275581717,
-0.1050667316,
-0.3716645539,
-0.4231383204,
-0.0491164401,
-0.2802454233,
0.3371096253,
-0.0086206784,
-0.1761616617,
-0.0950517729,
0.1638087481,
-0.0984924212,
1.0525026321,
0.9336616993,
0.3582588732,
0.8109034896,
-0.0646260455,
1.2506361008,
-0.1184208617,
0.4466005266,
0.4969135523,
0.0990853906,
0.6228170395,
0.2724942565,
-0.1325400025,
0.9487819672,
0.8197928071,
0.0880075246,
0.2549540102,
0.3455424011,
-0.2134214342,
-0.1659395397,
-0.0038556783,
-0.3436143696,
0.5123873353,
0.2874206901,
-0.4792062342,
-0.0419742763,
0.0271121413,
-0.169239983,
0.2721743286,
-0.4169867635,
0.716842711,
-0.1766583622,
-0.7483212948,
0.356333673,
0.237050131,
0.5574250817,
-0.2002609372,
0.0290457755,
-0.1632010639,
0.3085525334,
-0.7864388227,
-0.77527529,
0.5503690839,
0.3479113579,
-0.3468900025,
-0.5414827466,
0.6543613076,
0.1390535235,
-0.3215835392,
-0.0108327353,
0.4840948582,
0.5092679858,
-0.0054951282,
-0.5255729556,
-0.3074596226,
0.081148915,
-0.0857732296,
0.0827862099,
0.6979800463,
-0.260520488,
0.5064218044,
0.4826014042,
-0.2664677203,
-0.1846661568,
-0.0904737934,
0.5622915626,
-0.387014538,
-0.9851288199,
-0.8414139152,
0.6692357659,
-0.2611775994,
-0.5158835649,
0.9086771011,
0.656509757,
0.5227711201,
-0.4306617379,
0.7179089785,
0.1900214702,
0.8368930221,
-0.4217185676,
0.9204051495,
-0.5798915029,
0.7285426259,
-0.3242943287,
-1.0745044947,
-0.1975656301,
0.3290713429,
-0.0370994732,
-0.2522635162,
1.1846058369,
0.7372121215,
-0.0899844244,
0.6012419462,
-0.0671072155,
0.4810501337,
-0.1136127487,
0.1041557342,
1.1132214069,
-0.3298786581,
0.7101052999,
-0.143987745,
-0.3426522315,
-0.098920621,
-1.1320836544,
-0.9491792321,
-0.4132322073,
-0.4817463756,
-0.4125258625,
-0.0443013534,
0.4452069402,
0.4794251323,
-1.0561734438,
-0.1997515857,
-0.4529913366,
0.5716115236,
-0.4070799947,
-0.3532720208,
-0.08907675,
-0.1421578676,
-0.7695283294,
0.282395035,
0.1939004511,
-0.2826206386,
-0.4739611149,
0.2136612833,
0.4452730417,
-0.0618899986,
0.2918452024,
0.1845657229,
-0.7672005296,
-0.2334281951,
-0.0154367993,
0.5242923498,
-0.0986587703,
1.0220575333,
-0.6533013582,
0.9205598235,
0.552372396,
0.5102155805,
0.5015892982,
0.0953513533,
0.6454004645,
-0.5531035066,
-0.1430982351,
0.3639821112,
0.1317794025,
0.2943922579,
-0.6737101674,
0.1621136814,
0.401451081,
-0.5782372355,
-0.9162021279,
0.0037231427,
-1.0163789988,
0.0081056617,
0.7192267776,
-0.349247694,
0.1801167578,
-0.6836357713,
-0.0166765153,
-0.2734032571,
-0.2333370298,
1.4205207825,
0.9840139151,
-0.4293163717,
0.2587890923,
-0.3937506974,
0.4918079674,
0.3343207836,
-0.9609794617,
-0.2128545195,
0.1042030752,
0.2392513007,
0.1378320307,
0.2311915904,
-0.099816069,
0.6592015028,
-0.3580658436,
-0.3770461977,
0.1370964199,
-0.0952992067,
-0.7572945952,
0.3850714862,
-0.1726642251,
-0.0333213471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04589v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04589v3
|
TEAL: Tokenize and Embed ALL for Multi-modal Large Language Models
| 2023-11-08T10:34:16 | 2024-01-04T07:31:07 |
Zhen Yang, Yingxue Zhang, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite Multi-modal Large Language Models (MM-LLMs) have made exciting
strides recently, they are still struggling to efficiently model the
interactions among multi-modal inputs and the generation in non-textual
modalities. In this work, we propose TEAL (Tokenize and Embed ALl)}, an
approach to treat the input from any modality as a token sequence and learn a
joint embedding space for all modalities. Specifically, for the input from any
modality, TEAL first discretizes it into a token sequence with the
off-the-shelf tokenizer and embeds the token sequence into a joint embedding
space with a learnable embedding matrix. MM-LLMs just need to predict the
multi-modal tokens autoregressively as the textual LLMs do. Finally, the
corresponding de-tokenizer is applied to generate the output in each modality
based on the predicted token sequence. With the joint embedding space, TEAL
enables the frozen LLMs to perform both understanding and generation tasks
involving non-textual modalities, such as image and audio. Thus, the textual
LLM can just work as an interface and maintain its high performance in textual
understanding and generation. Experiments show that TEAL achieves substantial
improvements in multi-modal understanding, and implements a simple scheme for
multi-modal generations.
|
[
-0.2152994573,
-1.0927274227,
0.6743137836,
0.1684056222,
-0.5028466582,
0.1184305921,
-0.4364936352,
-0.0977549702,
0.2715950012,
0.1390524954,
-0.2465525419,
-0.4787835777,
-0.4408704937,
-0.0284127556,
-0.1766173244,
0.7696467638,
0.1047106311,
0.2886869609,
-0.0140294181,
0.0491099991,
-0.7037168145,
-0.5038235188,
-0.6278347373,
-0.147583276,
0.6179144382,
0.2536981702,
0.6559457779,
0.7339138985,
0.0319673158,
0.3575407565,
-0.0744013861,
0.3801354468,
-0.4217893481,
0.423807323,
0.2721059918,
-0.1743259579,
-0.3687255383,
-0.1057960913,
1.096129775,
0.6915953159,
-0.0861735344,
0.1074618697,
0.0335249789,
0.0850168541,
-0.513726294,
0.4905961454,
-0.8643480539,
0.0200103242,
-0.2956567109,
-0.3166276515,
-0.8433127403,
-0.0428632498,
-0.3676275909,
-0.5724794269,
-0.0947938785,
0.4233286381,
0.3294212818,
-0.0081076249,
-0.7883235812,
0.129753679,
-0.6567069888,
0.9273657799,
-0.6882165074,
0.7957251072,
0.3873843551,
0.2409700453,
-0.0921416506,
-0.6502543092,
-0.7110683322,
-0.32330212,
0.0387207493,
0.1410238296,
0.1941604018,
0.0992813483,
-0.1208098456,
0.2629962564,
-0.5036590695,
0.065300554,
0.0160300843,
-0.1893472075,
0.3063973784,
0.1835528314,
0.3511021733,
-0.1806268692,
-0.4206873775,
-0.0742046013,
-0.6117349267,
-0.1809401512,
-0.0669846162,
0.5916213989,
-0.2779765129,
0.6526104808,
0.3862197101,
0.5972456336,
0.0320323221,
-0.0551980808,
0.2680940926,
-0.4690726995,
-0.4894657433,
-0.0661902949,
0.8582625389,
-0.0547747016,
-0.2095896006,
-0.2559298575,
-0.3489376307,
-0.3832683265,
-0.0959387273,
-0.7227210999,
0.0960881859,
0.2498788238,
-0.6966996789,
-0.131772995,
-0.0035609854,
-0.8053830862,
-0.5988525152,
-0.2955441773,
0.4984365404,
-0.6153829694,
-0.5176256299,
0.1204054505,
0.101537101,
0.3543966711,
0.5036487579,
-0.8206964731,
0.0789074376,
0.7357384562,
0.9303228855,
-0.0010112755,
-0.5876226425,
-0.8904154897,
0.6668204665,
-0.3932209909,
0.4212751985,
-0.8228274584,
-0.5046701431,
0.2570396662,
-0.162604779,
-0.2935364842,
-0.1358648837,
0.2412295789,
-0.5993748307,
0.434720993,
-0.1184549928,
-0.5684024096,
-0.0370010659,
0.2104222029,
-0.8134172559,
0.7735020518,
-0.0784377903,
-0.6575690508,
0.2594071627,
-0.8480122685,
-0.5861797929,
-0.0989586115,
-0.1572822034,
-0.5331891775,
0.3151641786,
0.0439824574,
0.6163799167,
-0.4820044339,
0.504855454,
-0.3047352433,
-0.2247886211,
0.6340488195,
-0.8403930664,
0.5511087179,
0.31765306,
-0.1498542875,
0.3524546623,
-0.5336046815,
-0.1140761599,
0.2420375198,
-0.7210977674,
-0.015853392,
-0.0195873659,
0.6745773554,
0.0042621088,
0.187309131,
-0.6694802046,
0.1255367696,
-0.291421473,
0.5916126966,
0.959439218,
-0.1189750955,
0.517908752,
-0.4081659317,
0.3658430278,
0.2539179027,
0.260832727,
-0.5753296614,
-0.3612480164,
-0.8071362376,
-0.7201654911,
0.6002624631,
0.1774389744,
-0.909078002,
0.3267993033,
-0.3551655412,
-0.0532600023,
-0.438876003,
0.0463622361,
0.3929411173,
0.0331570916,
0.2900410593,
-0.2501502633,
-0.3271792531,
-0.6402723193,
0.0432491004,
-0.3695260882,
0.0497924536,
0.1920261085,
0.1438639462,
0.0110390894,
0.8433176279,
-0.3002203107,
-0.2404624075,
-0.3942066431,
0.2623434067,
0.0202818289,
0.5797788501,
0.469052732,
-0.7945654988,
-0.5175712109,
0.1796326786,
-0.2723839879,
0.0366751291,
-0.2939619124,
-0.0532655306,
0.3094916642,
0.5477420688,
-0.7622876763,
-0.083859399,
0.3858639598,
-0.5002571344,
0.2185248882,
-0.1368537992,
0.1270541847,
-1.6244604588,
0.1780773252,
-0.2739804387,
-0.5579186678,
-0.6909819841,
0.0399107076,
0.1145469546,
-0.25902161,
-0.6375878453,
0.6389683485,
-0.6588192582,
0.0267302208,
0.0990258008,
0.0435445681,
0.0648015589,
0.5324462056,
-0.0304103196,
0.7517134547,
0.5070474148,
-0.2054406554,
0.2516853213,
0.1585379243,
0.0769475996,
0.2179794759,
-0.3522323072,
0.1170139238,
-0.2663126588,
0.1688628644,
-1.1961944103,
-0.1182295755,
0.2725227773,
-0.4863008559,
0.7469339371,
-0.2044247538,
-0.7135550976,
0.1364561915,
-0.5849062204,
0.6124462485,
0.3297046125,
-0.5154616833,
1.0959820747,
0.3345890343,
-0.0556823723,
-0.4491150379,
-0.6968140006,
0.3040030003,
-0.1764901876,
-0.2422438264,
0.2000627071,
-0.3687142432,
-0.0278622527,
0.0155291976,
0.3061982691,
-0.1855393946,
0.0964541212,
0.1028837711,
0.3593662083,
-0.3998732269,
0.4323858917,
-0.0855901763,
-0.0288226325,
-0.2258164138,
-0.1765202135,
1.0218414068,
-0.0191647541,
-0.7589371204,
-0.2950135767,
0.5042848587,
0.8959582448,
-0.5710363984,
0.8886781931,
0.6798092127,
-0.2490899265,
-0.1825913936,
-0.627094686,
-0.0056198118,
-0.481102556,
0.4708422422,
-0.5250352621,
-0.9185960293,
0.3721255064,
-0.2025269866,
0.2320367247,
0.1375599355,
0.8116236329,
0.0988828614,
1.0847601891,
0.5819081664,
-0.1407738924,
0.8188397288,
-0.1290050298,
0.3212332726,
-0.7829395533,
-0.3293998837,
-0.1964517981,
-0.1666964591,
-0.3161455989,
-0.7905153036,
0.2787536681,
0.0005858453,
-0.2735162973,
-0.0461384878,
-0.1952330023,
0.7178095579,
0.4730888903,
0.0612120591,
0.3085962236,
-0.0897720084,
-0.2153389305,
0.1545260996,
-0.607673943,
-0.2647944391,
1.0229893923,
0.4035102725,
0.7345837951,
0.5191150904,
0.6251277924,
0.1641834229,
0.1162916124,
-1.0003437996,
0.467440784,
-0.1272974163,
-0.3875878453,
-0.3227848709,
-0.3108527064,
-1.073649168,
0.3985765278,
-0.3446726501,
-0.3737694025,
0.0057762279,
-0.0417184234,
-0.1719820648,
0.5272963047,
-0.654679358,
0.703204453,
-0.0966923907,
-0.353435725,
-0.315913856,
-0.4656137526,
0.4221767783,
-0.3471784592,
0.4091084898,
0.0827278048,
-0.2660906315,
0.409399271,
-0.0714387521,
1.1908534765,
-0.162902087,
-0.0287212804,
0.1505990177,
0.442430526,
0.2885271311,
0.1862571836,
-0.0007612699,
-0.0583346896,
0.1316783279,
-0.261175245,
-0.4404196739,
0.5815528035,
-0.8797594309,
-0.4497332573,
-0.347075671,
-0.5517511368,
-0.2664473951,
0.3225627244,
-0.2964337468,
0.7250353098,
-0.3452925384,
0.3512212932,
0.422309339,
-0.3283948898,
0.8285449147,
0.684478581,
-0.4338333905,
-0.6722733378,
0.915815115,
-0.0047379597,
0.1601843089,
0.5096311569,
0.2505562007,
-0.3691538274,
-0.4443052709,
-0.6904993057,
0.2388275117,
-0.6581383944,
-0.4535862803,
-0.532469511,
-0.2587682605,
-0.4070950449,
-0.077558361,
-0.3446326554,
-0.425917685,
-0.4592761397,
0.0655655116,
0.2987062037,
0.8677838445,
-0.2146678418,
0.4119186699,
-0.8730956912,
0.2228309959,
0.3403248787,
0.3796003163,
0.2498738766,
-0.2843937874,
-0.3952018321,
-0.0469347835,
-0.3090671599,
-0.8559628129,
0.2900606394,
0.5092164874,
0.5158029795,
0.3848155439,
-0.180924207,
0.5767672062,
-0.8063591719,
1.0055201054,
0.5346055031,
-1.3405201435,
0.1937370747,
-0.4107646048,
0.1890752017,
0.1452011317,
-0.0613869727,
-0.8852929473,
-0.2231037021,
-0.2433519661,
-0.7095021009,
0.6729778051,
-0.0744658709,
0.392742455,
-0.1878151,
0.163892597,
0.2924080789,
0.2321396172,
-1.0995084047,
-0.1216375753,
-0.2510845065,
-0.4481273293,
-0.0510020144,
-0.3127808571,
-0.1338282079,
-0.1342229694,
0.4912140965,
-0.3022201359,
0.471909225,
-0.2561793029,
-0.1821865588,
-0.1431574672,
0.4937130213,
0.3483636081,
0.6083789468,
0.1823832989,
0.5400850177,
0.1310251653,
-0.2267498821,
0.107918635,
-0.094130531,
0.0633427575,
-0.0466474034,
0.5023310184,
0.6912269592,
0.281653434,
-0.6237372756,
0.844915092,
-0.1822528839,
-0.0335867889,
-0.1160191894,
-0.3559478223,
0.1442697048,
0.37782377,
0.1090104133,
-0.1509232074,
-0.1441139281,
-0.6797674298,
0.1893494427,
0.6810239553,
-0.0483350903,
-0.4454042017,
0.7478561997,
0.1093688458,
-0.1899166852,
0.4091410637,
-0.1221996993,
-0.4879152775,
0.1983269006,
0.9632627368,
1.1081413031,
-0.1993286312,
0.379013747,
0.0666730627,
0.1567550451,
0.249971807,
0.3587425649,
-0.1805538833,
-0.7578173876,
-0.7090703845,
-0.7802128196,
-0.3002987802,
0.1682367623,
-0.1610638499,
0.4032431543,
-0.5859931111,
-0.0634963959,
-0.1790239215,
-0.2968056202,
-0.5991377831,
-0.0630125478,
0.294056803,
0.5224673748,
-1.0176422596,
1.0265128613,
0.63142097,
-0.6679982543,
-0.7408205867,
0.0661340505,
-0.0640954599,
-1.0508403778,
0.6243498921,
0.0682566166,
-0.0561176874,
0.1101806909,
-0.2927284837,
-0.9386762977,
1.0244421959,
0.5947027206,
-0.2709631622,
0.1797558665,
0.4041540325,
0.2273697704,
-0.2504680157,
0.2386139631,
0.1831564456,
0.654078722,
0.3071151376,
-0.9620833397,
0.1914483756,
-0.2087050527,
0.1858192682,
0.2469823658,
-0.8671534657,
1.1335115433,
0.1615681052,
-0.5369774699,
0.0488105007,
0.4597052932,
-0.0123006953,
0.0037956866,
0.5597390532,
0.4777317643,
0.630531311,
0.0179114994,
0.7535584569,
-0.4599662423,
0.1581740379,
0.9897587895,
-0.24696365,
1.0270401239,
0.5048518181,
0.0008900423,
0.1437864751,
0.7453567982,
0.0945760161,
0.5376102924,
0.0377438553,
-0.4903224111,
-0.5184745193,
-0.430241406,
-0.2622389495,
0.5987507701,
0.1288058609,
-0.284689188,
-0.1247545704,
0.1613077819,
0.130971089,
-0.1045914069,
-0.1097911298,
1.0168902874,
-0.047346279,
-0.2093049735,
0.5322061181,
0.270191133,
0.6083926558,
-0.6082983613,
-0.1315660775,
-0.0742600337,
-0.0803374276,
0.0554457046,
-0.6584283113,
0.1018020809,
-0.3125524223,
-0.1762800813,
-0.3809328973,
0.595864892,
-0.7989132404,
-0.5547235012,
0.2451759726,
0.9557831287,
-0.0383102819,
0.2699094713,
-0.4738669097,
0.284086585,
-0.175174877,
-0.3226214349,
0.3463613093,
0.693498075,
0.1473131776,
0.5143167973,
0.7473469973,
0.2101912946,
0.2014599591,
0.336291641,
1.0601044893,
-0.6028430462,
-0.295494318,
-1.1658662558,
0.490773499,
0.0556193106,
-0.0033987898,
0.5194247961,
0.745985508,
0.5156260133,
-0.0229948647,
0.7272347212,
-0.0717658028,
0.1485161483,
-0.8160136342,
0.6560008526,
-0.7997828722,
0.0938296244,
-0.0199200902,
-1.0865793228,
-0.439550817,
0.464299649,
0.1122580096,
0.0280122254,
0.7866504788,
0.6386726499,
-0.2592254281,
-0.0568381399,
0.6042556763,
0.3837092519,
0.5458709002,
0.4092818499,
0.9436033368,
-0.0604976602,
0.4082133174,
0.1969201118,
-0.2137951702,
0.0165587086,
-0.9589303732,
-0.9993380904,
-0.9148676395,
-0.0053737173,
-0.0981061608,
-0.2086870968,
1.2933199406,
0.7201887369,
-0.7249842882,
-0.369951129,
0.2816159129,
0.0408469327,
0.1169731542,
-0.203995496,
0.4060106277,
-0.5424890518,
-0.9758406878,
0.6262832284,
0.3698728085,
0.1964717805,
-0.521517396,
0.0814181492,
-0.2033095658,
0.2096789479,
0.9227843285,
-0.1559092999,
-0.8563897014,
-0.5927060843,
-0.1444444507,
0.0807755291,
0.1844366342,
0.9369671941,
-0.583109498,
0.4815480709,
0.475425154,
0.8692415953,
0.4928894043,
-0.3779318035,
0.7042609453,
-0.9496904016,
0.1204803586,
0.0798102766,
0.6571463943,
0.377135843,
-0.1510096043,
0.2477572113,
-0.0078939609,
-0.4170391262,
-0.8110285997,
0.3181866705,
-1.0064641237,
-0.553947866,
1.139598012,
0.0750400499,
-0.1833504885,
-0.0596692562,
-0.5092973709,
0.5094858408,
-0.5231932402,
0.6954954267,
0.501765728,
0.0767219812,
-0.3867951035,
-0.2550283372,
0.2086547166,
0.4158235788,
-0.5908876657,
0.5244880319,
0.6717448235,
0.0930971578,
0.0588736497,
0.6235468388,
-0.1214766949,
-0.1122696027,
-0.0844122767,
-0.0979070589,
-0.3996988237,
-0.2043762058,
-0.3641137183,
0.2298900187,
0.4472795427,
-0.3644020855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04563v1
|
Investigating the Nature of Disagreements on Mid-Scale Ratings: A Case Study on the Abstractness-Concreteness Continuum
| 2023-11-08T09:52:58 | 2023-11-08T09:52:58 |
Urban Knupleš, Diego Frassinelli, Sabine Schulte im Walde
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans tend to strongly agree on ratings on a scale for extreme cases (e.g.,
a CAT is judged as very concrete), but judgements on mid-scale words exhibit
more disagreement. Yet, collected rating norms are heavily exploited across
disciplines. Our study focuses on concreteness ratings and (i) implements
correlations and supervised classification to identify salient multi-modal
characteristics of mid-scale words, and (ii) applies a hard clustering to
identify patterns of systematic disagreement across raters. Our results suggest
to either fine-tune or filter mid-scale target words before utilising them.
|
[
-0.8496539593,
-0.5068574548,
0.4806950092,
0.5776061416,
-0.4183557928,
0.1719797254,
-0.2671446502,
-0.8475004435,
0.3377152681,
-0.1699367017,
-0.0298365038,
-0.1703015715,
-0.9891597629,
0.2858202159,
-0.3323537707,
1.2888866663,
0.1650000811,
0.2028436959,
-0.2156813145,
-0.3829005361,
-0.2018735558,
-0.7494033575,
-0.5058392286,
-0.5675213933,
0.9162977934,
0.6013116837,
1.1303107738,
0.2557201385,
0.5374513865,
0.3566898108,
-0.2312779874,
-0.0850054771,
-0.2814964056,
-0.100463517,
-0.3309996426,
-0.4049191475,
-0.5795197487,
0.3283827007,
0.3698953092,
0.8049402237,
0.0331057161,
0.2402735054,
0.1957024038,
0.7487730384,
-0.8861096501,
0.1609712243,
-0.5469232202,
0.1307823062,
-0.3177576065,
-0.3021591902,
-0.1391711384,
0.0196405072,
0.1918658912,
-0.3342781663,
0.4687899947,
0.0067749121,
1.1087875366,
0.1916507483,
-0.5298158526,
-0.4024637043,
-0.728875041,
0.9317136407,
-0.4362083077,
0.2503894567,
0.6899496317,
0.1123650521,
0.1533821672,
-0.6654374599,
-0.7139966488,
-0.3448983133,
-0.307510674,
0.090094775,
-0.2955628335,
0.2084490955,
0.1322844476,
0.5612459779,
-0.148668915,
-0.0007332638,
-0.2647444606,
-0.2304214537,
0.6424180269,
0.1441371441,
0.0340397358,
-0.3399878442,
0.0087352693,
-0.1285354942,
-0.3346096277,
0.4985055625,
0.4149852395,
0.0200767573,
0.0353183448,
0.5057325363,
-0.3871604502,
0.4377065003,
0.4160905778,
0.0957052484,
0.3141199052,
-0.3689747751,
0.0074108164,
0.0721783116,
0.6714227796,
0.718123734,
0.1847730279,
-0.1816088259,
-0.3100477457,
0.5724925995,
0.2800903916,
-0.6241334677,
-0.3425276875,
0.0794400498,
-0.4746209085,
-0.4939524531,
-0.0242622178,
-0.3269188404,
-0.3923844397,
-0.4906455278,
0.2351208776,
0.1304113865,
-0.3009207845,
0.1245100945,
-0.25352934,
0.030194765,
0.3746511638,
-0.7453150749,
0.3412498832,
0.5031739473,
0.7845836282,
0.2037714422,
-0.2031018734,
0.0986763686,
-0.0904220492,
-0.4850223064,
1.0978038311,
-0.567625165,
-0.5091149211,
-0.3161410391,
0.0607592687,
0.1494673193,
-0.6281964183,
0.9194513559,
-0.104413949,
0.051346574,
-0.1263334453,
-0.1037276015,
0.2369695604,
0.8401966095,
-0.5151396394,
1.004324317,
0.0235453937,
-0.9009032249,
0.9517131448,
-0.2928944528,
-0.3534041643,
0.0826703906,
-0.4816482663,
-0.4459920824,
0.188332811,
-0.1617603302,
0.4247309864,
-0.1730738282,
0.2451168746,
-0.4667181075,
-0.2033075541,
0.6648210287,
-0.4258923829,
-0.2064161301,
0.3085707128,
-0.2076209337,
0.0833391175,
-1.0845900774,
-0.1301237047,
-0.3892005086,
-0.3299995065,
-0.7381334305,
0.4231794178,
0.2999425828,
0.60419029,
0.4400455356,
-0.682744801,
-0.0080019441,
0.0737447217,
0.6169947982,
0.5669210553,
0.0580338389,
0.2609894276,
-0.7551516891,
0.0685291961,
0.2356734872,
0.3638706803,
0.5123733282,
-0.4186456501,
-0.8428544402,
-0.2047497481,
0.2170003355,
0.0175772775,
0.0785589665,
0.374189347,
-0.1922564209,
-0.6970461607,
-0.4639392495,
-0.035144113,
0.4769564569,
0.1444609612,
0.4391408265,
-0.5105918646,
-0.4020811617,
-1.0904827118,
-0.3608905375,
-0.5175508261,
-0.0282054394,
0.3517917395,
0.3480485678,
0.0168822352,
1.0246449709,
-0.412080884,
-0.3278908432,
0.2064004093,
0.7471824288,
0.0558707714,
0.6711622477,
0.3452956676,
-0.8868426681,
-0.2646496892,
-0.0093383286,
-0.5563579798,
-0.0323398933,
0.0771591589,
0.0666697398,
-0.3100701272,
0.8368155956,
-0.4033099115,
0.1517156214,
0.3901658058,
-0.3904334307,
0.7370865345,
-0.1010587662,
0.195296213,
-0.7592813373,
0.0175529569,
0.1981920451,
-0.0061494256,
-0.3821324706,
-0.159805119,
-0.2708598077,
0.390280962,
-0.3975693882,
0.1350009739,
-0.3411582112,
0.1942226887,
-0.2270604223,
-0.0302394461,
0.0944624469,
0.3574074209,
0.1705355495,
0.434691757,
0.0460798852,
-0.4648630321,
-0.0649259984,
-0.0213098899,
-0.141978249,
0.8909025192,
-0.7275053263,
0.134916693,
-0.127110675,
0.261677742,
-1.2291624546,
0.0028653902,
-0.2134261578,
-0.4263243377,
0.049710311,
-0.2118525654,
-0.5282977819,
-0.1886836141,
-0.432759583,
0.7167051435,
0.0810922906,
0.0125707183,
0.1009479985,
0.4771241844,
-0.1458820105,
-0.6493035555,
-0.3633812666,
0.2035992444,
-0.2437966019,
-0.4008069336,
0.3479201496,
-0.2066901922,
-0.5527147055,
-0.0387103856,
-0.2830751538,
-0.0542430952,
-0.1732455045,
0.5270479321,
-0.1614407748,
-0.0093810586,
-0.0298792869,
-0.0315997824,
-0.0972214863,
0.2529917955,
0.3745379448,
0.2705985308,
-0.5853471756,
0.0304402504,
-0.0376615636,
0.0895055085,
1.1036051512,
0.1779250205,
0.3670431376,
0.3941725791,
-0.4591443837,
0.1933713555,
-0.6189022064,
-0.0496334881,
-0.4243523479,
0.2548024654,
-0.67243433,
-0.7493177652,
0.5185408592,
-0.3270974159,
0.0747564137,
0.4530153573,
0.6057762504,
-0.4842806756,
1.6034078598,
0.554412663,
-0.099116832,
0.4044386744,
-0.1912994385,
0.2178759724,
-0.9822266102,
-0.2623384297,
-0.8242923617,
-0.7928225398,
-0.7285820246,
-0.0362743251,
0.3129341006,
0.351249069,
-0.2563776076,
-0.0468960926,
-0.4174036086,
0.4325923026,
-0.3822420239,
0.1529921144,
0.5803088546,
-0.2324402332,
-0.1876547039,
-0.1343161166,
-0.3493581116,
-0.6922772527,
0.6469808817,
0.4252995551,
0.6176269054,
0.1537279487,
0.2120327204,
0.6433818936,
0.4834825695,
-1.0596096516,
0.413567096,
-0.1832224578,
-0.6762217879,
-0.3122125268,
-0.1718119085,
-1.2231191397,
0.5597330928,
-0.6609861255,
-0.5038279891,
0.6535021067,
-0.0375392176,
-0.103610158,
0.1709656715,
-0.2153377235,
0.7890515924,
0.3474917412,
-0.287643671,
-0.5214072466,
-0.7310159206,
0.4381985962,
-0.0276852231,
0.7266073227,
-0.2996626198,
0.1367189139,
0.8665932417,
-0.7128391862,
0.7149196863,
0.221446529,
-0.0799923167,
0.0860559866,
0.0971158519,
0.1552817822,
0.3436686397,
0.0850261375,
0.1015647352,
0.2980093658,
-0.8212530017,
-0.502001524,
0.5216013193,
-1.2458868027,
-0.2791875601,
-0.761939466,
-0.4010130763,
-0.329780072,
0.0106530664,
0.5293248892,
0.4185417891,
-0.46549806,
0.1029395014,
0.458396554,
0.4282119274,
0.3118486106,
0.6722258329,
0.0440015085,
-0.1111273989,
0.9359251261,
0.1901778281,
0.256870687,
0.1438382417,
0.4536239505,
-0.1332602948,
-0.5726488233,
-0.425075382,
0.0275861192,
-0.3764764369,
-0.0834537446,
-0.4445727468,
-0.208791405,
-0.0002175167,
-0.4525698125,
-0.528254509,
-0.583994031,
0.1784459949,
0.0283097643,
-0.0503024533,
0.9175433517,
-0.1516229361,
0.280957967,
-0.7199836969,
0.0142318914,
0.2977227271,
0.1609816402,
0.052311711,
-0.5589066744,
-0.3860307038,
-0.1758666635,
-0.4313805103,
-0.4432938695,
-0.2023685724,
0.130313918,
0.1567039937,
0.9002914429,
0.1776585281,
0.6963344216,
-0.1739060432,
0.8638989329,
0.4932310879,
-0.9489158392,
0.2588728964,
-0.185878709,
0.2438207269,
0.862852037,
0.4013331532,
-0.6127275229,
-0.792242229,
-0.7414925098,
-0.8534488082,
0.2471963018,
0.0843117461,
0.0494391471,
-0.1063932553,
0.0499730445,
-0.0822809562,
0.2973837852,
-0.6888844371,
0.0094765536,
-0.1928658932,
0.1589101106,
-0.2579534948,
-0.1262664795,
-0.5091335177,
-0.4050731957,
0.2654256523,
-0.06491898,
-0.4782584012,
0.3310753107,
-0.1358615458,
-0.513804853,
0.7304477692,
0.5260020494,
0.8864572644,
-0.4241615534,
0.7069990635,
0.1258609891,
-0.8558433056,
0.4328078628,
-0.2596438825,
0.0993403271,
0.0755206943,
0.3861773312,
0.1055110171,
0.3648319244,
-0.3135277033,
0.7243736982,
-0.4050463736,
-0.3700588048,
-0.2230274677,
-0.4526374936,
-0.2804484963,
-0.1687416881,
0.1904217303,
0.6237405539,
0.3951921761,
-0.8877939582,
0.2202640474,
0.2804097235,
-0.7496264577,
-0.5252453089,
0.1095114499,
0.2837583721,
0.2011800706,
0.655182302,
-0.349632889,
-0.4702048898,
0.4325788915,
0.2371105701,
0.5584415197,
0.0286473352,
0.1798659712,
0.149914071,
0.368393898,
-0.0774443448,
0.1804918647,
-0.2694121003,
-1.0217385292,
-0.2960559726,
-0.8536723256,
-0.6537795663,
0.0851529837,
-0.920448482,
0.3955773115,
-0.7263528109,
-0.682859242,
0.2585361004,
0.0262774155,
-0.3805135787,
0.4010217488,
0.2018666714,
0.6497396231,
-1.2066968679,
0.6455312967,
1.1355131865,
-0.5494325757,
-0.8229943514,
-0.0881230906,
-0.0939897895,
-0.2945483327,
0.6194189191,
-0.0137464646,
-0.327370435,
-0.4391376972,
-0.5499105453,
-0.4315316081,
0.6253290772,
-0.2160808891,
-0.4133427441,
-0.0113694072,
0.1504795998,
0.7968674898,
-0.087462984,
0.6283993125,
0.7263760567,
0.5371980667,
0.1075449139,
-1.1906485558,
0.0585863069,
-0.6487458944,
-0.2350680083,
0.336391151,
-1.027300477,
0.869826436,
0.0432780869,
-0.1321622282,
-0.2053265125,
0.5825842023,
0.2672326565,
0.7504136562,
0.9511272311,
0.7090672255,
0.448862493,
0.0084184986,
0.4965830743,
-0.494604677,
0.3355004489,
0.8191992044,
-0.124080874,
0.8854151368,
0.5769099593,
-0.4320812225,
0.8676380515,
0.8715987206,
0.1670049429,
0.3687225282,
0.7344469428,
-0.445140332,
-0.2076216489,
-0.4514726102,
-0.378130883,
0.5793372393,
0.6701467633,
0.06683819,
-0.2022617906,
-0.2584282458,
0.1187484339,
0.0060337372,
-0.4624578059,
0.7245397568,
0.3095865548,
-0.4602856934,
0.4566112161,
0.099423036,
0.6906291842,
-0.4098545909,
-0.0331165679,
-0.0939739645,
0.1544489563,
-0.8462869525,
-0.7299460769,
0.3063838184,
-0.1814050823,
-0.6294877529,
0.1016326174,
0.4038980305,
-0.1591060758,
-0.2095293552,
0.3539898396,
0.4501719177,
0.5265616775,
0.024981875,
-0.7064604163,
-0.1282742918,
-0.6762305498,
-0.020861242,
0.6046829224,
0.734657824,
-0.3253760338,
0.2271547616,
0.769749701,
0.3124808371,
0.0357533209,
0.2690195441,
0.7838367224,
-0.4423193932,
-0.5787035227,
-0.6664914489,
0.293777138,
-0.155562222,
-0.8298398852,
0.4965173304,
0.696152091,
0.8036641479,
0.3661282361,
0.5462788939,
-0.1916474551,
0.036747802,
-0.1405712664,
0.561817348,
-0.3706870675,
0.1807581931,
-0.5459365845,
-0.9843114614,
-0.2671519816,
0.5224345326,
-0.1150623262,
-0.1116684824,
0.8883856535,
0.5251110196,
0.0000997504,
0.1792221814,
0.3710094094,
0.3281025887,
0.2357942164,
0.3137344122,
1.2566859722,
-0.1226931363,
0.4631323516,
-0.097943224,
-0.6081870794,
-0.1111364886,
-0.7469191551,
-0.655112505,
-0.6324423552,
-0.362029165,
-0.5697360635,
-0.0850060433,
0.6872555614,
0.7605565786,
-0.6991807222,
-0.4949650168,
-0.0550208353,
0.1039631814,
-0.4037648439,
-0.2591233253,
0.2778817415,
-0.4606139064,
-0.5863380432,
-0.0668290183,
0.1321623325,
-0.2720704377,
-0.3587851226,
-0.1290807128,
-0.0190924089,
0.3608210683,
0.7465017438,
0.310251236,
-0.5091350675,
-0.389887929,
-0.4555428624,
-0.4112623334,
0.1241825968,
1.0504937172,
-0.50165236,
0.1758732349,
0.5997043848,
0.0399007797,
0.5227402449,
0.0419103205,
0.2468064278,
-0.7310682535,
0.0000849479,
0.1761852503,
0.3446652293,
0.2992120087,
-0.2773757577,
0.2831102312,
0.3778250515,
-0.921493113,
-0.7745196819,
0.1536565721,
-1.187335372,
-0.2535098791,
0.6468397379,
-0.0176798943,
0.0508468077,
-0.5838371515,
-0.1673448086,
0.1360710561,
-0.4158585668,
1.1307100058,
1.1412626505,
-0.5486947298,
0.1561018378,
-0.2888801396,
0.7024171948,
0.5913212895,
-0.2071027011,
-0.1479115337,
0.1835034192,
0.325956732,
0.7366021872,
0.6779321432,
-0.3923873603,
0.1042757556,
-0.0439098962,
-0.0039905389,
0.4743638039,
-0.4272962809,
-0.2366647422,
0.3153937459,
0.6162413359,
0.0647218749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04554v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04554v1
|
Assessing Distractors in Multiple-Choice Tests
| 2023-11-08T09:37:09 | 2023-11-08T09:37:09 |
Vatsal Raina, Adian Liusie, Mark Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multiple-choice tests are a common approach for assessing candidates'
comprehension skills. Standard multiple-choice reading comprehension exams
require candidates to select the correct answer option from a discrete set
based on a question in relation to a contextual passage. For appropriate
assessment, the distractor answer options must by definition be incorrect but
plausible and diverse. However, generating good quality distractors satisfying
these criteria is a challenging task for content creators. We propose automated
assessment metrics for the quality of distractors in multiple-choice reading
comprehension tests. Specifically, we define quality in terms of the
incorrectness, plausibility and diversity of the distractor options. We assess
incorrectness using the classification ability of a binary multiple-choice
reading comprehension system. Plausibility is assessed by considering the
distractor confidence - the probability mass associated with the distractor
options for a standard multi-class multiple-choice reading comprehension
system. Diversity is assessed by pairwise comparison of an embedding-based
equivalence metric between the distractors of a question. To further validate
the plausibility metric we compare against candidate distributions over
multiple-choice questions and agreement with a ChatGPT model's interpretation
of distractor plausibility and diversity.
|
[
-0.7809409499,
-0.6606773138,
0.3264469504,
0.3051875234,
-0.1691264212,
0.0512274727,
0.0898483172,
-0.3889176548,
0.0012437446,
0.167768836,
-0.3163061738,
0.1093180403,
-0.6577371359,
0.50280267,
-0.363981396,
0.9535647035,
-0.3453006148,
-0.085558027,
-0.3853133619,
-0.330902189,
-0.8018171787,
-0.1005758494,
-0.6056020856,
0.3077287972,
0.8823758364,
0.2508711219,
0.6975287795,
0.4852693677,
0.7099072933,
0.3836969733,
-0.081006214,
0.1629542559,
-0.2537336051,
0.1133724675,
-0.4393074811,
-0.0434891917,
-0.0262289606,
0.0543410517,
0.4701636434,
0.4142878652,
0.1200970188,
0.2162196487,
0.0791419521,
0.210287258,
-1.0028791428,
-0.2974480391,
-0.3058894575,
-0.0728179365,
0.045987729,
-0.2819216251,
-0.3686842024,
-0.6069441438,
0.3577372432,
-0.380964011,
0.2455829978,
0.132017374,
0.9015206099,
0.8407408595,
-0.58777529,
-0.5806958675,
-0.512626946,
0.8215931654,
-0.1931786984,
0.2624415755,
0.5325072408,
0.4817873538,
0.3823185861,
-0.2602301538,
-0.3422665298,
-0.4417980909,
-0.1749901623,
0.7287380695,
0.2602822781,
-0.2420992702,
0.0174580608,
0.4573861361,
-0.5220031738,
-0.2167385668,
-0.4678215981,
-0.2235297412,
0.8805337548,
0.1644140035,
0.332937777,
-0.2946864069,
-0.4898197353,
-0.0203212649,
0.2210587561,
0.1159250662,
0.4259148836,
-0.1532289833,
0.3905204833,
0.6287779808,
-0.0754464641,
0.6332440972,
0.1889897287,
-0.0877659544,
0.1249488071,
-0.8193902373,
0.0715595558,
-0.203115955,
0.548248589,
0.2082482725,
-0.0316505209,
0.0671940893,
-0.1504265368,
-0.1199634671,
0.6632996202,
-0.5715034008,
-0.227236554,
0.6879044771,
-0.308668226,
-0.0695944354,
0.114099212,
-0.8419507742,
-0.1541514993,
0.0018489228,
0.7519527674,
-0.6858837008,
-0.0491665117,
0.082137838,
-0.6533241868,
0.354745537,
0.2577472031,
-0.6617114544,
0.0805219039,
0.1806230396,
0.6371435523,
-0.6988103986,
-0.6910434365,
-0.4245631993,
-0.1930788457,
-0.3563667834,
1.072065115,
-0.2678467929,
-0.1973629296,
-0.2885191143,
-0.1902761608,
-0.6452195644,
-0.4734705389,
1.0001995564,
-0.5817540884,
0.4936771691,
-0.1734697521,
-0.9019702673,
-0.4540215731,
0.4623017609,
-0.7435534596,
0.972448945,
0.6111929417,
-0.7062415481,
0.7616636753,
-0.67476511,
-0.0876650214,
0.2141252756,
0.303483516,
-0.4298249483,
-0.1970411986,
0.0351866856,
0.0637839809,
0.3338049352,
0.0227841344,
-0.1575204283,
-0.5198555589,
0.8916350603,
-0.5777073503,
0.9199142456,
0.055219613,
-0.034368977,
0.1733347327,
-0.5077177286,
0.0723766461,
-0.3413433433,
-0.4911364019,
-0.2506520748,
0.2718260586,
0.0196358301,
0.4574945271,
-0.0708862171,
-0.442884326,
-0.4879117012,
0.0261047073,
-0.1813233942,
0.5773714185,
0.2736029327,
0.0507531948,
-0.9433504343,
0.4416012168,
0.0939329118,
0.2551077604,
0.0427933075,
-0.4552301466,
-0.8998179436,
-0.8788874149,
0.3157955706,
0.9540962577,
-0.3574409187,
0.7574623823,
-0.022574693,
-0.658710897,
-0.350712657,
-0.0151290139,
0.2172145694,
0.2816742659,
0.4267607927,
-0.4015804231,
-0.1542853117,
-0.3829409182,
-0.5183572173,
0.0759115666,
-0.1597587764,
0.4086628258,
0.9382647872,
0.0145853246,
0.918317914,
-0.367462337,
-0.2900505066,
0.1268766969,
-0.1784300506,
-0.325530827,
0.5731688142,
0.4093709588,
-0.9847865701,
-0.5589674711,
-0.273029089,
-0.4613643289,
-0.0511890613,
-0.3078370094,
-0.2263269275,
-0.0453705713,
0.1043089479,
-0.4333273768,
0.1875421703,
0.0167701468,
-0.5628197789,
1.0843067169,
0.0127145015,
0.3935459256,
-0.5914167166,
0.0998880938,
-0.311345607,
0.0133092543,
-0.4854679406,
0.2367643863,
0.0856597796,
0.3119598925,
-0.6194054484,
0.7909686565,
-0.2059759349,
0.032273829,
0.1919371039,
0.3435249329,
0.0609679371,
0.0099662738,
-0.1073172018,
0.6491655707,
0.4047467113,
-0.6994394064,
0.2786137462,
0.4544618726,
-0.1053762734,
1.0266033411,
-0.4164476097,
-0.1455323845,
-0.0890184119,
0.0353213884,
-1.4311765432,
-0.6117133498,
0.3612321913,
-0.5022499561,
-0.2560375929,
0.4597017765,
-0.2007219642,
-0.6043674946,
-0.3267173171,
0.2726725638,
0.2942532599,
-0.3303185105,
0.5248405933,
-0.2595050931,
-0.401594311,
-0.8572402,
-0.6277873516,
-0.341147542,
-0.5231747627,
-0.4073586762,
0.1166658401,
-0.7243629098,
-0.4063659906,
-0.0146687264,
-0.2383241802,
-0.7421995997,
0.2071321309,
0.0307200328,
0.4126920998,
-0.0678203851,
0.1212645322,
0.1066246331,
-0.1172796786,
0.0483023115,
0.255289346,
0.0338235311,
0.0267825685,
-0.6743913889,
-0.1658110917,
0.2570847869,
0.332105428,
-0.4231516123,
0.232391715,
0.7611182928,
-0.1401988417,
-0.029662542,
-0.7718991041,
-0.0480696447,
-0.4504099786,
0.3934358358,
-0.500520885,
-0.755900383,
0.6981899738,
0.5157161355,
0.3804560006,
0.4285389185,
0.4823395908,
-0.0976080298,
0.8500576615,
-0.1270270497,
0.6704716682,
0.391798228,
0.3071272969,
-0.0558882169,
-0.5437555313,
-0.0439418964,
-0.506166935,
-0.3108963072,
-0.1692225039,
-0.338219285,
-0.0414042696,
0.1138869524,
-0.2755458653,
0.0745562166,
-0.7325620055,
0.8236566186,
0.6348321438,
-0.0714234114,
0.3537047207,
-0.2122220993,
-0.0430928767,
-0.0746572465,
-0.1834567189,
-0.6504032016,
0.9399160743,
0.1223488376,
0.2869820893,
0.2408089787,
0.7784845829,
0.1069345325,
0.6517624855,
-0.9610531926,
0.3342449665,
0.0316702835,
-1.2184920311,
-0.5664160252,
-0.4199073911,
-0.7810754776,
0.7596422434,
0.1243262812,
-0.6512389183,
0.3721792102,
-0.2945179045,
-0.9026700258,
-0.0457536802,
-0.6802289486,
0.987433672,
-0.3375634253,
-0.2211541831,
0.0965367109,
-0.4249998331,
0.5331482291,
-0.3541658223,
-0.0226793326,
-0.1439463645,
-0.4294718504,
0.7397205234,
0.1694403589,
0.46469751,
0.1975458562,
0.3277955949,
0.5884801149,
0.3552646339,
-0.3068973422,
0.1135605052,
-0.4561116099,
-0.1339893788,
0.44690606,
-0.6702910066,
-0.3181746304,
0.0305659957,
-0.876206398,
-0.1942397505,
-0.6647482514,
-0.8753942847,
-0.1581281424,
0.3208029866,
0.20608145,
0.1951243132,
-0.3792118728,
-0.0335059017,
0.2455367744,
0.023175735,
0.5742619634,
0.3802354038,
0.2989097536,
-0.6464758515,
1.057790637,
0.3872941732,
0.4807111323,
0.1007701159,
0.1612518579,
-0.6456069946,
-0.5783401132,
-0.4263868928,
0.054923404,
-0.8103929758,
0.1414953619,
-0.5731957555,
-0.4209911823,
0.1180734485,
-0.5481861234,
0.1568919271,
-0.1094081178,
-0.4244979918,
-0.2432798594,
-0.2416843623,
0.4728978574,
-0.0680198371,
0.2197606713,
-0.5227481127,
0.0440156832,
0.589451015,
0.1692645848,
-0.3847075403,
-0.566411376,
0.0393042192,
-0.375302881,
-0.8064303994,
-0.9280090332,
0.2764576674,
0.0257077496,
0.7006717324,
0.5723453164,
0.2850523591,
0.3726237416,
-0.0954151601,
1.0192760229,
-0.07631623,
-0.9872075915,
0.2280769944,
-0.1838430911,
-0.0347218513,
0.8704302311,
0.4545364976,
-0.2664543688,
-0.8232730627,
-0.6736772656,
-0.2823038399,
0.5454156995,
0.1751768887,
-0.1595919132,
-0.2319190651,
0.0057081608,
0.3627497256,
0.0074867764,
-0.7623131871,
-0.020910643,
-0.5773815513,
-0.3844921887,
-0.1293440014,
-0.1450416148,
-0.196709618,
0.0296067484,
0.436576426,
-0.0811124593,
0.0451180004,
0.4128600359,
-0.255592525,
0.1853598952,
0.7079760432,
0.6090154648,
1.1204061508,
-0.4980745614,
0.3025659323,
0.3628696501,
-0.5563316941,
0.4614657462,
0.3723136783,
-0.3796434999,
0.1293718368,
0.1722858101,
0.1766988635,
-0.1156267598,
-0.7535246611,
0.5334955454,
-0.0928347781,
-0.3124635518,
-0.2386294752,
0.2384449095,
-0.0937448889,
-0.0872768834,
0.2394247353,
0.4100065827,
0.2692801058,
0.0870298371,
0.5292695165,
0.0662999377,
-0.6541669369,
0.0971331522,
0.2265888751,
0.2744004428,
-0.4377021492,
0.4572061896,
-0.6389868855,
-0.3667968512,
0.9395874143,
0.4196961522,
0.6405261755,
-0.5557075143,
0.4079932868,
0.6699947119,
0.5108160377,
0.0505277477,
0.3900109231,
0.1942555904,
-0.71962291,
-0.1817189157,
-0.3194450438,
-0.5557074547,
-0.0247952957,
-0.5183881521,
-0.0962539837,
-0.3542841375,
-0.2827576101,
0.1235542223,
0.2070265412,
-0.360309422,
0.3401643038,
-0.0681774169,
0.8882524967,
-0.6186628342,
-0.0403228551,
0.4915674329,
-0.8793545961,
-0.527169764,
0.1186236292,
-0.0165971611,
-0.1501835734,
0.408190459,
0.3296855688,
0.3934425414,
-0.1736355722,
-0.0499361046,
-0.9889014959,
0.9284399152,
-0.0414985567,
-0.0493002012,
0.2382274717,
-0.0047971746,
0.325800091,
0.0599535815,
1.0563460588,
0.4589670002,
0.6587473154,
-0.0931175053,
-0.6725950837,
0.1090638041,
0.0798799917,
-0.2396024317,
-0.0210002922,
-0.5915229917,
0.8879815936,
-0.3041894138,
-0.2837361395,
0.2067501843,
0.2952068746,
0.5302957296,
0.4320345521,
0.6789354682,
0.2289389372,
1.0248835087,
-0.1073030606,
1.0169596672,
-0.1847944856,
0.3863948882,
1.0093790293,
-0.2689764798,
1.0133433342,
0.5573616624,
-0.0740643591,
0.416531533,
1.0487072468,
-0.2647363245,
0.1771764606,
0.3211570382,
-0.2740866542,
-0.3848686814,
0.0693970472,
0.0232979916,
0.351772964,
0.3009977043,
-0.0963351056,
-0.2660792768,
-0.029986022,
-0.2725361884,
-0.2141438127,
-0.0449203551,
0.5110028982,
-0.0269624963,
-1.1115020514,
0.3688728511,
-0.3180890679,
0.5308600068,
-0.4038976729,
0.4258002639,
-0.3063730597,
0.2653926015,
-0.1911093146,
-1.1120989323,
0.6101040244,
-0.215370819,
-0.0892844349,
0.0415140428,
0.6074674129,
-0.2626760006,
-0.3684236705,
0.2233306319,
0.8593381643,
0.3016784191,
0.0051842835,
-0.9073300958,
-0.3746458888,
-0.2983063757,
-0.1789994091,
-0.0068491562,
0.1654206216,
0.2132777572,
0.7576495409,
0.5510628223,
-0.0453718044,
0.3327540755,
0.0402844697,
0.0251508877,
-0.4231795073,
-0.7081217766,
-0.7522326112,
0.6436387897,
-0.2522006631,
-0.8900478482,
0.9415463805,
0.5701181293,
0.6082424521,
-0.1133134887,
0.5910880566,
-0.0914062262,
0.5656685233,
0.1144497767,
0.6810299754,
-0.4507279694,
-0.4160901606,
-0.1727024317,
-0.7657794356,
-0.2453932017,
0.5522356629,
-0.4457077086,
0.1953634769,
1.1863524914,
0.7358027697,
-0.2663743198,
0.0577830598,
0.306994319,
-0.1792032123,
-0.011164777,
0.5289906263,
1.4207339287,
-0.4730904102,
1.112473011,
0.0198194087,
-0.403060317,
-0.2006608099,
-0.3458101749,
-1.0003025532,
-0.4664383531,
-0.6960083842,
-0.2294615358,
-0.118772015,
0.374250859,
0.7024317384,
-0.7358140349,
-0.1034444794,
0.1675615311,
0.5643230677,
-0.7958645225,
-0.3586496115,
0.3705657721,
-0.5524328351,
-0.5941673517,
-0.0500487462,
0.0635028183,
0.1385881901,
-0.0109878508,
0.0155723123,
-0.2065233439,
0.6257867217,
0.4812103808,
-0.0055892295,
-0.8138928413,
-0.4590580761,
0.0971823037,
-0.3965190351,
-0.0186024699,
0.2691107988,
-0.3061977625,
0.4389457107,
0.7187885642,
0.7306668758,
-0.0229385681,
0.4249691665,
-0.1593907326,
-0.5528674722,
-0.457669884,
0.5992407203,
0.1677300483,
0.2875474095,
-0.1950462908,
0.3476641178,
0.169618994,
-0.7987110019,
-0.6941584945,
0.1353785843,
-0.9516489506,
-0.2483747602,
1.1227419376,
-0.2111452222,
-0.0854211375,
-0.6960344911,
-0.4279220104,
-0.0664700717,
-0.1693264544,
0.7579727173,
1.0762331486,
-0.2720428109,
-0.1164564416,
-0.7552285194,
0.4562170804,
0.6231467724,
-1.1389843225,
-0.1266981512,
0.6009523869,
0.6066270471,
0.8047976494,
0.6531992555,
-0.0386796072,
0.6388856769,
0.4941595495,
-0.1624655277,
0.1475865692,
-0.0729683712,
-0.2114275545,
0.2218391746,
-0.3955256343,
-0.4391033351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04547v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04547v1
|
Large GPT-like Models are Bad Babies: A Closer Look at the Relationship between Linguistic Competence and Psycholinguistic Measures
| 2023-11-08T09:26:27 | 2023-11-08T09:26:27 |
Julius Steuer, Marius Mosbach, Dietrich Klakow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Research on the cognitive plausibility of language models (LMs) has so far
mostly concentrated on modelling psycholinguistic response variables such as
reading times, gaze durations and N400/P600 EEG signals, while mostly leaving
out the dimension of what Mahowald et al. (2023) described as formal and
functional linguistic competence, and developmental plausibility. We address
this gap by training a series of GPT-like language models of different sizes on
the strict version of the BabyLM pretraining corpus, evaluating on the
challenge tasks (BLiMP, GLUE, MSGS) and an additional reading time prediction
task. We find a positive correlation between LM size and performance on all
three challenge tasks, with different preferences for model width and depth in
each of the tasks. In contrast, a negative correlation was found between LM
size and reading time fit of linear mixed-effects models using LM surprisal as
a predictor, with the second-smallest LM achieving the largest log-likelihood
reduction over a baseline model without surprisal. This suggests that modelling
processing effort and linguistic competence may require an approach different
from training GPT-like LMs on a developmentally plausible corpus.
|
[
-0.3614713252,
-0.7277910709,
0.4777289629,
0.0682382584,
-0.215792641,
-0.0998590067,
-0.457952559,
-0.5319426656,
-0.1310072094,
0.3312394917,
-0.3814385533,
0.0179836527,
-0.5947244763,
-0.1538638324,
-0.30090487,
1.0729515553,
0.2017848194,
-0.1132295355,
-0.2120351791,
0.1688250005,
-0.4657050371,
-0.6589634418,
-0.667820394,
-0.3396683335,
0.6580522656,
0.0446637757,
0.790179491,
0.4596391916,
0.398637563,
0.1988630891,
-0.2791225016,
-0.3285838664,
-0.4527622759,
-0.0249330513,
-0.175023675,
-0.3617849052,
-0.7093096972,
0.1547670662,
0.4900021851,
1.0762716532,
-0.2831148207,
0.0602165349,
0.308519423,
0.6143111587,
-0.4217824936,
0.3347475529,
-0.4052642584,
-0.0879701674,
-0.2268078774,
0.1270486116,
-0.5397322178,
-0.1165973991,
0.2466290444,
-0.4671373963,
0.4012758434,
-0.1335868239,
0.7043470144,
0.1913403869,
-0.5880566239,
-0.4484708607,
-0.9537353516,
0.7844178677,
-0.9639714956,
0.5893158317,
0.6914464235,
-0.1034894735,
0.051240366,
-0.5193991661,
-0.6588335037,
-0.8296268582,
-0.2224978954,
-0.0045006289,
0.0215450823,
0.3822397888,
0.4240896702,
0.2277680784,
-0.9772216082,
0.3352270424,
-0.5742860436,
-0.2968444228,
0.7494193316,
0.0961980671,
0.227679342,
0.073689431,
-0.1206271797,
0.1453298181,
-0.714862287,
-0.0760773271,
0.4659458995,
0.3114382625,
-0.2117689103,
0.5695777535,
0.168298021,
0.7406336069,
-0.0325641558,
-0.2515060604,
0.2352111936,
-0.2215913683,
0.0073053166,
-0.1482662261,
0.7359992266,
0.0034516612,
0.6408296824,
-0.1724148393,
-0.1447672099,
0.4132625163,
0.3051478863,
-0.4629290998,
-0.3815942705,
0.0612135157,
-0.2471372485,
0.0812440068,
-0.1351128668,
-0.4267754257,
-0.3081858754,
-0.3333466947,
0.3461642861,
-0.5973465443,
-0.4107635319,
0.3331218362,
0.4036115706,
0.2494956106,
0.024864845,
-1.0113298893,
0.179359287,
0.7015334964,
0.603605628,
-0.2054483145,
-0.2899043858,
-0.2210264951,
-0.0936964303,
-0.4299545586,
0.6073207855,
-0.4164429009,
-0.462531507,
0.0377755538,
-0.0243666004,
-0.520737052,
-0.469381541,
0.5352608562,
-0.5667319298,
0.2094265819,
-0.0714029372,
-0.6775946021,
-0.0351688638,
0.1418080777,
-0.5837777257,
0.6712049842,
0.2897117734,
-0.5826723576,
0.4857214987,
-0.512691319,
-0.6257347465,
0.1577443182,
-0.0094874734,
-0.35791412,
0.2183608711,
-0.1246220022,
0.3898722231,
-0.1590261757,
0.4054198861,
-0.3494769633,
-0.3723462224,
0.3561725318,
-0.4632540345,
0.7587180138,
0.2293981463,
-0.2175183743,
-0.0861958414,
-0.7497898936,
0.173421219,
0.1187167242,
-0.508197248,
-0.1350303143,
-0.0194456801,
-0.0570710748,
0.4037036002,
0.1446500719,
-0.4730992913,
-0.048550766,
-0.453079015,
0.5162521601,
0.2654921114,
-0.1320482194,
0.2034656554,
-0.3407478631,
0.6270275116,
-0.2477109581,
0.211383298,
-0.0359838605,
-0.4144835472,
-0.6470493078,
-0.3631727695,
0.4016382098,
0.4236451089,
-0.5379544497,
0.5682224035,
-0.2414037883,
-0.6181305051,
-0.3259714842,
0.1384806484,
0.6399302483,
0.2626327574,
0.0663653314,
-0.7621021271,
-0.3041335642,
-0.880518496,
-0.3349461854,
-0.4992398024,
-0.2384621948,
-0.0059952848,
0.5716449618,
-0.0190625228,
0.5605175495,
-0.0994819403,
-0.2889246643,
-0.252705574,
0.0602202788,
0.2371129394,
0.3852680027,
0.5136287212,
-0.6614839435,
-0.3656954467,
-0.1519866437,
-0.5312972069,
-0.1681607515,
0.144352451,
0.6308493018,
0.2316737026,
0.4244135022,
-0.8233638406,
0.328797698,
0.5371340513,
-0.5655609965,
0.9000208974,
-0.3091419339,
-0.1168939471,
-0.3703190982,
-0.0073001385,
-0.068877399,
0.0801881179,
-0.910066545,
0.169732511,
0.0472544506,
-0.0249021109,
-0.5942326784,
0.4007424116,
-0.4791505039,
-0.1518419385,
-0.1995288581,
0.0675712898,
-0.1507100761,
0.4019266963,
0.0356233977,
0.7476992011,
0.2809959054,
-0.6111904979,
0.1518496126,
0.0234458782,
-0.3816994429,
0.4183646142,
-0.6281520128,
0.328558296,
0.0291820299,
0.1113537699,
-0.9940629005,
-0.1965005845,
-0.0758598074,
-0.4580737352,
0.5031430721,
0.2256039381,
-0.5550817847,
-0.5292514563,
0.0330098644,
0.4874933362,
0.6706816554,
-0.0752936751,
0.416421324,
0.2114960551,
-0.441267103,
-0.1654015481,
-0.923093617,
-0.0774137527,
-0.2080598772,
-0.348225832,
0.1852682382,
-0.0351299718,
-0.1955484301,
-0.0241837166,
0.0903987661,
-0.1310967952,
-0.0026174416,
-0.0633702353,
0.2225106359,
-0.5238448977,
0.1968392432,
-0.4639232755,
-0.2313521355,
0.0352992341,
-0.1823949516,
0.5392763019,
-0.1807771623,
-0.3292335868,
-0.1359078586,
0.0221402645,
0.4987239838,
-0.1263948381,
0.7272905111,
0.5330300331,
-0.3212515712,
0.1173734069,
-0.4252411127,
-0.2348035872,
-0.3905160427,
0.4242910445,
-0.2921496034,
-0.8898786306,
0.3693202138,
0.4503471851,
-0.1239050999,
0.3839908838,
0.6797779799,
-0.1699438989,
0.9473956823,
0.6218998432,
0.1578432024,
0.4138899446,
-0.1569876075,
0.4326926172,
-0.7655041218,
0.0653656721,
-0.2620793581,
-0.0823307559,
-0.5471298695,
-0.3022677302,
0.137505874,
0.0480870456,
-0.5471469164,
0.2119333297,
-0.3320122063,
0.4127824306,
0.4606551528,
-0.071553193,
0.3626917005,
-0.1780538261,
-0.0427477658,
-0.4129668772,
-0.8461512327,
-0.5353882909,
1.2180236578,
0.3493923545,
0.601052165,
-0.042149134,
0.19568941,
0.0573125742,
0.4687648118,
-0.8079583645,
0.570736289,
-0.2838042974,
-1.0597629547,
-0.2945254743,
-0.2288492173,
-0.8985822797,
0.1750359833,
-0.0862373784,
-0.8607428074,
0.1211755052,
0.182230413,
-0.5057996511,
0.3679855764,
-0.8915495276,
0.7928147316,
-0.3353349566,
-0.3913802803,
-0.2551441789,
-0.5333384871,
0.5234738588,
-0.3404682577,
0.3561348021,
-0.1351290345,
-0.1760434061,
0.7044317722,
-0.1394766867,
0.9806116819,
-0.1268919855,
-0.3000047207,
0.3745132089,
0.3215963244,
0.0936668143,
-0.2582399547,
0.0438739955,
0.0373154841,
0.2046005279,
-0.7299773693,
-0.4654478431,
0.4574501216,
-0.6686581373,
-0.616648078,
-0.6743425131,
-0.6838419437,
-0.5708568692,
0.1330901831,
0.352260679,
0.2455309629,
-0.255645752,
0.325134635,
0.4608828425,
-0.2043100297,
0.2495435029,
0.6425570846,
-0.2051686049,
-0.1294115931,
0.8265985847,
0.3925898075,
0.5800005794,
0.017849626,
0.1252320409,
-0.3816187382,
-0.8924918175,
0.0129926391,
0.4446752667,
-0.3121621609,
0.286441505,
-0.2253080159,
-0.4233528078,
-0.250981003,
0.0423014946,
-0.3900973499,
-0.2141273022,
-0.0243937001,
-0.1024569795,
0.0216104966,
0.7706217766,
-0.1635060459,
0.5845681429,
-0.5965829492,
0.2865332663,
0.3337524235,
0.5213611722,
0.1204676181,
-0.8117159009,
-0.2510353923,
0.0805691332,
-0.4144079983,
-0.6646393538,
0.2887980938,
0.1866789311,
0.2680696547,
0.4301913977,
-0.174083814,
0.3170147538,
-0.4208906591,
1.0615510941,
0.3138860762,
-0.7071534395,
0.1800896078,
-0.5616361499,
0.1900732517,
0.2469128966,
0.39609164,
-0.472889185,
-0.3250269592,
-0.853646338,
-0.7584630847,
0.5371374488,
0.1414412856,
0.1788827926,
0.0160481241,
0.4065926075,
0.3143360615,
0.1697336882,
-0.7976504564,
0.1477449536,
0.1544920355,
-0.1430001408,
-0.6846308708,
-0.4429766834,
0.0210159179,
-0.390981704,
0.678468883,
-0.0063164113,
0.1815116405,
0.0701698437,
-0.2199086547,
0.0563687719,
0.4344199896,
0.5989421606,
0.7413701415,
-0.1797943264,
0.1732867658,
0.2520907819,
-0.6471787691,
0.2863920927,
0.1491831094,
0.0151411509,
-0.2541213632,
0.9331221581,
0.8064827323,
0.2243249416,
-0.6730380654,
0.442687124,
0.1216801181,
-0.3897471428,
-0.3350596726,
0.1008828357,
0.379840672,
0.1584694535,
0.039809674,
-0.2416182011,
-0.1547374278,
-0.6715034246,
0.112851508,
0.1894793659,
-0.473238498,
-0.7436079979,
0.5983948112,
-0.0492610335,
-0.4928322136,
0.4927957058,
-0.2205050141,
-0.3400997519,
0.6937196851,
0.5782827139,
0.6725139022,
-0.4025534391,
0.1546238661,
0.1899579912,
0.5316311121,
-0.0963581577,
0.187013045,
0.2232272625,
-0.7064899206,
-0.5768616199,
-0.5330690145,
-0.2585052848,
0.8387002349,
-0.5568212867,
0.0403399169,
-0.4137265682,
-0.2872473896,
-0.0339796543,
0.0898359045,
-0.9849822521,
0.3961693048,
0.2477826476,
0.5637966394,
-0.8840169311,
0.8285668492,
0.5436070561,
-0.5470637083,
-0.8501054645,
0.027194798,
-0.1209629923,
-0.5834085941,
0.3765687943,
0.0094027715,
0.2277097255,
-0.0119360304,
-0.1332072914,
-0.656278193,
0.649184823,
0.62698102,
-0.9354881644,
-0.4568383396,
0.3245075047,
0.8964212537,
-0.3250123858,
0.2603570521,
1.0643655062,
0.2829819918,
-0.2421017587,
-1.3245579004,
-0.1605141759,
0.0530396923,
0.103965044,
0.0057413098,
-0.4931028187,
0.8636248112,
-0.3793697059,
-0.2108984441,
0.1064701304,
0.314825207,
0.2217891663,
0.3823729157,
0.5900210142,
0.5018941164,
0.442591399,
0.055185955,
1.1343548298,
-0.2647896111,
0.5013020635,
1.073797226,
-0.322211504,
0.8519505858,
0.5645498633,
-0.5670500994,
0.1838035136,
0.725335896,
0.2716294229,
0.3679453731,
0.2764037848,
-0.0408970118,
-0.0949998796,
0.1693068594,
-0.3570539653,
0.2442250103,
0.645380199,
-0.3113657534,
-0.0940250978,
0.1799522787,
-0.0030652825,
0.29166013,
-0.1673749536,
0.624197185,
0.5347758532,
-0.4850732684,
0.7904844284,
-0.3559996784,
0.6834889054,
-0.6300709844,
0.3740015328,
-0.0040808646,
0.2315620631,
-0.0801539645,
-0.9174167514,
0.3891411126,
0.0209531821,
-0.0233645607,
0.0079208128,
0.781442523,
-0.5285024643,
-0.3158448637,
0.5524349213,
0.9323917031,
0.2799106538,
0.0494137108,
-0.6416763067,
-0.0304796584,
-0.2835008502,
-0.5320563912,
0.2755566537,
0.2203302681,
-0.0708220452,
0.5308463573,
0.6515297294,
0.5570115447,
0.1848189086,
0.0981232747,
0.3932736218,
-0.7002459764,
-0.5569050908,
-0.79957515,
0.3659671843,
0.3507778347,
-0.3255259693,
0.3175628483,
0.401564002,
0.8836140633,
-0.328769803,
0.7700440288,
-0.0377127118,
0.5389012694,
-0.3956053555,
0.6858456731,
-0.3774457276,
0.1155960038,
0.032685101,
-1.1286355257,
-0.4284999371,
0.536179781,
-0.877838254,
0.344817847,
0.9307132363,
0.7015839815,
-0.1812852025,
-0.0010265961,
0.5654445291,
0.4396065772,
0.2899298668,
0.8907524347,
0.9427285194,
0.0059540514,
0.3838683963,
-0.0744280219,
-0.1442651302,
-0.1619619727,
-0.720846951,
-0.857329905,
-0.6370354891,
-0.3181137741,
-0.2535248697,
0.1082968041,
0.5769892335,
0.5161898136,
-0.7618690133,
-0.2686119378,
-0.053825099,
-0.3760413229,
-0.1536743641,
-0.2286849916,
0.3360001743,
-0.2464742064,
-0.3864824176,
0.1438696533,
0.0671491399,
0.0840426758,
-0.3414446115,
-0.0503622741,
-0.105639644,
0.22304672,
0.58521837,
0.4411505163,
-0.8998308182,
-0.6034700871,
-0.2918600738,
-0.2137463838,
0.0217818841,
0.7163484693,
-0.6207553148,
0.3111144006,
0.3456668854,
0.4162870347,
0.6215430498,
-0.463014245,
0.5259609222,
-0.5333178639,
0.4143592119,
0.4147901535,
0.3013243079,
0.498842597,
-0.1137801111,
0.5537068248,
0.2309951484,
-0.5229405165,
-0.9189617038,
0.4344880283,
-0.6430056691,
-0.1421868652,
1.0367021561,
-0.1464701295,
-0.2730297744,
-0.1685614884,
-0.2359531373,
0.3003030419,
0.0286285821,
0.763754189,
1.0402994156,
-0.1189669445,
-0.050284788,
-1.1206008196,
0.4676692486,
0.6685500145,
-0.4456961155,
0.1632293314,
0.1965426207,
0.4043718278,
0.2938874364,
0.7567366362,
-0.2801056206,
0.3535135984,
0.1676826477,
0.0942937061,
0.029985562,
-0.2530939579,
-0.5397996306,
0.0238168091,
0.4092467725,
0.047008276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04535v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04535v1
|
RankAug: Augmented data ranking for text classification
| 2023-11-08T08:47:49 | 2023-11-08T08:47:49 |
Tiasa Singha Roy, Priyam Basu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Research on data generation and augmentation has been focused majorly on
enhancing generation models, leaving a notable gap in the exploration and
refinement of methods for evaluating synthetic data. There are several text
similarity metrics within the context of generated data filtering which can
impact the performance of specific Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks,
specifically focusing on intent and sentiment classification. In this study, we
propose RankAug, a text-ranking approach that detects and filters out the top
augmented texts in terms of being most similar in meaning with lexical and
syntactical diversity. Through experiments conducted on multiple datasets, we
demonstrate that the judicious selection of filtering techniques can yield a
substantial improvement of up to 35% in classification accuracy for
under-represented classes.
|
[
-0.477062881,
-0.7863280177,
0.3835573494,
0.0553305931,
-0.3725092709,
0.554063797,
-0.1757046133,
-0.5642825961,
0.3361725509,
0.5250598788,
-0.2734424174,
-0.7890850902,
-0.8744601011,
0.3344998658,
-0.4087866545,
1.0486493111,
0.1439534128,
-0.1950064152,
-0.5117559433,
-0.3035302162,
-0.4055880904,
-0.7439778447,
-0.5816841125,
-0.401707679,
0.4505478442,
0.2865123451,
0.8830864429,
0.5103138089,
0.6611426473,
0.3514283001,
-0.1631154418,
0.3996563852,
-0.5404593945,
0.2343237549,
-0.0030354213,
-0.5686833262,
-0.4712374508,
0.2260819227,
0.5405860543,
0.7974707484,
0.1919566542,
0.1302659214,
0.1866700202,
0.7184542418,
-0.5534222126,
-0.0824143216,
-0.5559741855,
-0.1540076733,
-0.1987762898,
-0.3954058886,
-0.3303662837,
-0.4864066839,
0.0432640351,
-0.6203644276,
0.225290373,
0.3843260109,
0.7034956217,
0.4386753738,
-0.3740606904,
-0.1352606565,
-0.3438094556,
1.0376629829,
-0.6946780682,
0.3753707409,
0.519104898,
-0.0714438856,
-0.0902975947,
-0.6346661448,
-0.6771996021,
-0.1053600684,
-0.406326741,
0.2730740309,
0.0927453488,
0.2394293398,
0.1895106435,
0.832165122,
-0.7910791039,
0.0344157219,
-0.0059912684,
0.1008565202,
0.7660210133,
-0.2021811604,
0.4629853368,
-0.4120329916,
-0.3950822949,
-0.0662804469,
-0.3229409456,
0.1057310179,
0.5183140039,
0.4881275892,
0.3608963788,
0.4404269755,
-0.3582178056,
0.6804524064,
-0.0083559323,
0.101838544,
0.4902482033,
-0.3176706433,
-0.2715120018,
0.2514206171,
0.5104609132,
0.4944861531,
0.1210857853,
-0.2383589596,
-0.0954239443,
-0.0024749872,
0.4866550267,
-0.6214023829,
-0.3210602701,
0.1111661494,
-0.6014612913,
-0.7141304016,
0.1593343019,
-0.4856221676,
-0.6211544275,
-0.4561003745,
0.4940559864,
-0.1158857867,
-0.1742466837,
-0.1175631806,
-0.0821870193,
0.1679995656,
0.1044144481,
-0.9844797254,
0.2656309605,
0.8902061582,
0.8221318126,
-0.6549932957,
-0.1445129514,
-0.5320799947,
-0.1809562892,
-0.4695309997,
1.0692434311,
-0.7548758984,
-0.4397364855,
-0.1704818159,
-0.2380679846,
-0.0989565402,
-0.6367227435,
0.8456366658,
-0.5646976829,
0.396407187,
-0.3238155544,
-0.838748455,
-0.3451374173,
0.3947413862,
-0.6490386128,
1.5828397274,
0.1387718469,
-0.7995296717,
0.9145557284,
-0.6457582712,
-0.569606781,
0.5133852363,
0.0688551143,
-0.4478818476,
0.0049541332,
0.5668876767,
0.3883069158,
-0.1309416741,
0.14049384,
-0.1549929529,
-0.4569686651,
-0.0116742263,
-0.2079611123,
0.6209807992,
0.0884370655,
-0.2154782116,
0.2911881506,
-0.7872119546,
0.0824482292,
-0.1955772042,
-0.3617938459,
-1.0302631855,
-0.1002349481,
0.2113569379,
-0.0953460932,
0.3420061171,
-0.6919737458,
0.2161043137,
-0.7476418614,
0.0788031891,
0.4811885357,
0.1855546683,
0.6717278957,
-0.4333410263,
0.4081988931,
-0.3024472296,
-0.0529042967,
0.0897789896,
-0.7488908768,
-0.6542083025,
-0.0908548459,
0.5495722294,
0.6347853541,
-0.6907590628,
0.7823343873,
-0.4093055427,
-0.3920352161,
-0.6711120605,
0.4182157815,
0.1702583581,
0.326890707,
0.413169086,
-0.2185145766,
-0.4009965658,
-0.7535825968,
-0.7673797607,
-0.3386992216,
-0.1161152571,
0.2689805627,
0.0324186459,
-0.32978037,
0.8491483331,
-0.5254104137,
-0.4323844314,
-0.3309212029,
0.4848752022,
0.0265516844,
0.2804483771,
0.7549652457,
-1.0513451099,
-0.3849896789,
0.0766211152,
-0.7615110874,
-0.2994043529,
-0.0804394484,
-0.3160140216,
0.0544634275,
0.5961968899,
-0.2638012469,
0.248258099,
0.4163954258,
-0.299731195,
-0.0295576453,
-0.1041434556,
0.6310156584,
-1.0178022385,
-0.1328779757,
-0.0484373569,
-0.3279540837,
-0.7018259764,
0.1299598515,
-0.134042263,
0.0607813783,
-0.02910983,
0.6552850604,
-0.0162896309,
0.1374995261,
-0.4953544736,
0.346648097,
0.1697126776,
0.3478283584,
0.0206718929,
0.6963290572,
0.4416588843,
-0.5490938425,
0.3491430283,
0.346326828,
-0.3483817577,
0.594866991,
-0.3020709157,
0.0183932595,
-0.0905506462,
-0.0109000122,
-1.2085701227,
-0.1153628975,
-0.1599751264,
-0.6444198489,
0.0956210271,
-0.1535192132,
-0.590080142,
-0.0586158037,
-0.40524593,
0.4876428545,
0.4543992579,
-0.9515073895,
0.582881391,
0.4660015702,
-0.4009381831,
-0.5168840885,
-0.673525095,
0.1446816325,
-0.3610159457,
-0.4117969275,
0.5145558715,
0.0077404962,
-0.2213188559,
-0.1953839362,
-0.0125311604,
0.1107377931,
0.0729500502,
0.3134446144,
0.1310302317,
-0.0412302539,
0.4132513404,
0.4086559117,
-0.0323885083,
0.0615833886,
-0.1253117621,
0.2999424338,
0.0470543317,
-0.2111119777,
0.007289181,
0.1954894364,
0.4673609138,
-0.2324416488,
0.7489846349,
0.7462913394,
-0.334553659,
-0.2644611895,
-0.4274448752,
-0.0650953576,
-0.4849821925,
0.0150086656,
-0.2460063547,
-0.8178679347,
0.4733788371,
-0.055585444,
0.4004690051,
0.4575610757,
0.2755361199,
-0.156904757,
1.2384209633,
0.4573375881,
-0.2002533227,
0.5712593794,
-0.0729942173,
0.3947176039,
-0.549426496,
-0.1802051067,
-0.382974714,
-0.55006212,
-0.9351405501,
-0.1369764209,
0.1521441042,
0.0915635675,
0.2664228678,
0.1567377895,
-0.7678085566,
0.5290227532,
0.6132802367,
0.0744389072,
0.5077866912,
0.1709399372,
0.167456612,
-0.0907768011,
-0.50976336,
-0.4342444241,
1.1763643026,
0.0118692899,
0.467795074,
-0.0356887951,
0.9926924109,
0.8171863556,
0.3997706175,
-0.8374723792,
0.4775449336,
-0.5214675665,
-0.2794488966,
-0.2644175589,
-0.3875103891,
-0.9723819494,
0.2947701514,
-0.4679737985,
-0.4422073364,
0.1602004617,
0.0256722607,
-0.1842328757,
0.234247148,
-0.7725963593,
0.7279729843,
-0.1882849187,
0.1332276613,
-0.2726018727,
-0.2605035901,
0.2945228815,
-0.0659617782,
0.24355039,
-0.0751578063,
0.0727001429,
0.9918522835,
-0.413351208,
0.2465589345,
-0.1148152798,
0.0286240131,
0.3129197955,
-0.3177959323,
0.1269654334,
0.0813757628,
-0.1564934701,
0.2889243066,
-0.2324627936,
-0.4433452487,
-0.819331944,
1.1842594147,
-0.6018987298,
-0.2625138462,
-0.4418639541,
-0.3682997525,
-0.1728545129,
0.1149580702,
0.256888926,
0.4386610091,
-0.1047063097,
0.2490261942,
0.7194467783,
-0.2010788172,
0.2722828388,
-0.0251730829,
-0.4020278752,
-0.3658642173,
1.1295317411,
0.0102635445,
-0.0309550576,
0.5858076811,
0.0712003782,
-0.5242679119,
-0.5694610476,
-0.4316025376,
-0.0552617796,
-0.5726516843,
-0.2401798368,
-0.7375221848,
-0.2908616364,
-0.3902536333,
-0.2677834332,
0.0114031639,
-0.7126207948,
-0.1527485847,
-0.3883588314,
0.8993518353,
0.6595839262,
0.1093354225,
0.5502960682,
-0.5132558346,
0.7082713842,
0.5054645538,
0.5400286913,
-0.3529554605,
-0.4436011612,
-0.0919478908,
-0.2447603643,
-0.120980382,
-0.524600327,
0.2994195521,
0.3678700328,
0.7569067478,
0.228246659,
0.2331194878,
0.4397678673,
-0.1481883526,
0.9698303938,
-0.236808002,
-0.8010581732,
0.6760419011,
-0.2404563725,
0.4766100049,
0.8937014937,
0.1711675376,
-0.2757505774,
-0.6784968376,
-0.6307703257,
-1.0351747274,
0.5519379973,
0.5861735344,
0.016587466,
0.0879205465,
0.4531535208,
0.2035891265,
0.2734031081,
-0.6152403355,
-0.5520399809,
-0.211436823,
-0.4645080566,
-0.0086632809,
0.0247210376,
0.2211640924,
-0.2984716594,
0.7169260979,
0.0282388944,
0.1081154048,
0.0310489386,
-0.354979068,
-0.0340134911,
0.3033908606,
0.1972613782,
0.3603160679,
-0.2171520293,
0.0694580302,
0.225479126,
-0.8251907825,
-0.1561387032,
0.3907402456,
-0.2981669009,
0.1814890951,
0.2459824234,
0.651073277,
0.1775731593,
-0.5842087269,
0.3132576048,
-0.2486211807,
-0.0536646657,
0.1490000039,
0.2940104008,
-0.4225926995,
-0.0856656432,
0.6657076478,
0.1392449439,
0.5732601881,
-0.4347594678,
0.3228065968,
0.3918983042,
-0.2960603833,
0.1899224967,
0.5633717775,
0.3325416148,
-0.3720362186,
0.3465818465,
-0.3138889372,
-0.7088605165,
0.4118103385,
-0.0738845021,
0.8103639483,
-0.254247576,
0.2432701588,
0.4615629613,
0.2389797717,
-0.0240100324,
0.3189248443,
-0.2807840109,
-0.6042636037,
-0.4333968759,
-0.9262812734,
-0.3085321784,
0.2198397219,
-0.6678434014,
0.2047088444,
-0.359901756,
-0.3022824228,
0.2654511034,
0.2685691416,
-0.3816488683,
0.3991333544,
0.087116681,
0.4321042597,
-0.8900812864,
0.394788295,
0.928994,
-0.0845215395,
-0.501113534,
0.1030145213,
-0.2752183676,
-0.4270152152,
0.3495783508,
0.2712203562,
-0.1426706016,
0.2751164734,
-0.3915540576,
-0.658398211,
0.6963877678,
-0.0239518415,
-0.1373474747,
0.1606530696,
0.1933244765,
0.7761212587,
-0.3509657979,
0.33254987,
0.737308979,
0.4973827004,
-0.1503300816,
-0.8933457732,
-0.226785332,
-0.4392088056,
-0.1143644005,
0.4156638682,
-0.3386510909,
0.4120028019,
0.0885426477,
-0.0347322896,
-0.0005332471,
0.5720059276,
0.2463005185,
0.6071309447,
0.5209450722,
0.7125111222,
0.637927413,
-0.3031616807,
0.864058435,
-0.0912066996,
0.2457083315,
0.6906396151,
0.0179649647,
0.793875277,
0.0733603984,
-0.0435178392,
0.8295429945,
0.6816347241,
-0.0458805226,
0.481831491,
-0.3171798885,
-0.1774231046,
-0.3631007075,
-0.228012085,
-0.1434899867,
0.4678995311,
0.4078474641,
-0.4202602804,
-0.1044897288,
0.3201748133,
-0.3983846307,
0.5195963979,
-0.5148569345,
1.1398205757,
-0.0256718621,
-0.6693270802,
0.5465298891,
-0.1199139282,
0.7420312762,
-0.1854658574,
-0.1872791052,
-0.1542606652,
-0.0744936019,
-0.4224723876,
-1.0119030476,
0.0661986768,
0.0635980666,
-0.3279028833,
-0.4522439539,
0.899412632,
-0.5373947024,
-0.4968611002,
0.191138953,
0.3674330413,
0.142879039,
-0.1976587474,
-0.6715124846,
-0.2238941789,
-0.1023688912,
-0.2142127603,
0.3185435236,
0.1621193588,
-0.1687770188,
0.5355219841,
0.6691225767,
0.0859860927,
0.1411986649,
0.457547754,
0.5754640698,
-0.5140840411,
-0.8870230317,
-0.6051902175,
0.2554654479,
-0.4622429907,
-0.2612595558,
0.8481566906,
0.7351512313,
0.8424735069,
0.2158921361,
0.8220593929,
0.1346357167,
0.8307363391,
-0.338493228,
0.8953027725,
-0.5555436015,
0.2632412314,
-0.3724295199,
-1.2723174095,
-0.3685148656,
0.6658319831,
-0.485750854,
0.1517808586,
0.3784058392,
0.4872159362,
-0.1613755375,
0.1868669689,
0.2448324561,
-0.1221187413,
0.1360100657,
0.0889201835,
0.5879767537,
-0.7273583412,
0.4795201719,
-0.0447316095,
-0.2342852056,
-0.2579244077,
-0.5119356513,
-1.100990057,
-0.5796850324,
-0.4867475033,
0.1914215982,
-0.0635489151,
0.7789616585,
0.6766365767,
-0.9965190291,
0.227865234,
-0.2163232714,
0.348741293,
-0.2926442921,
-0.3396409154,
0.44655931,
-0.3841423094,
-0.8067058921,
0.4126249254,
0.2718843222,
-0.067528829,
-0.0763256922,
0.030977523,
-0.2253092974,
0.1866709292,
0.7973080277,
-0.0217105318,
-0.6037468314,
-0.2164987028,
-0.0036236926,
0.0452472419,
0.0078175543,
0.8405157924,
-1.1868374348,
0.5710235834,
0.7657856941,
0.8111048341,
0.1513228267,
0.6824103594,
0.2367940843,
-1.2117391825,
-0.0797341168,
0.2149468362,
0.0719433203,
0.5572257638,
-0.6179942489,
0.3420085609,
0.0403946452,
-0.8035835624,
-0.954223454,
0.0415083766,
-1.0047158003,
-0.2589686215,
1.1039477587,
0.2387813181,
0.26842314,
-0.2464273274,
-0.3551959991,
0.2157448828,
-0.5332731009,
0.902583003,
0.6249946356,
-0.3164429069,
-0.2455101311,
-0.3637085557,
0.8371616602,
0.4806275666,
-1.032099843,
-0.0319437049,
0.3866219521,
-0.116346471,
0.3424545527,
0.1315127313,
0.2063517421,
0.1050951332,
-0.3124387264,
-0.3199846745,
0.2116993964,
-0.1558028609,
-0.1541266739,
0.2515652478,
0.1460258365,
-0.1590286046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04534v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04534v2
|
Loss Masking Is Not Needed in Decoder-only Transformer for Discrete-token-based ASR
| 2023-11-08T08:45:14 | 2024-02-05T02:42:57 |
Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Qinglin Zhang, Siqi Zheng, Shiliang Zhang, Chong Deng, Yukun Ma, Hai Yu, Jiaqing Liu, Chong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recently, unified speech-text models, such as SpeechGPT, VioLA, and
AudioPaLM, have achieved remarkable performance on various speech tasks. These
models discretize speech signals into tokens (speech discretization) and use a
shared vocabulary for both text and speech tokens. Then they train a single
decoder-only Transformer on a mixture of speech tasks. However, these models
rely on the Loss Masking strategy for the ASR task, which ignores the
dependency among speech tokens. In this paper, we propose to model speech
tokens in an autoregressive way, similar to text. We find that applying the
conventional cross-entropy loss on input speech tokens does not consistently
improve the ASR performance over the Loss Masking approach. To address this
issue, we propose a novel approach denoted Smoothed Label Distillation (SLD),
which applies a KL divergence loss with smoothed labels on speech tokens. Our
experiments show that SLD effectively models speech tokens and outperforms Loss
Masking for decoder-only Transformers in ASR tasks with different speech
discretization methods. The source code can be found here:
https://github.com/alibaba-damo-academy/SpokenNLP/tree/main/sld
|
[
-0.2600939572,
-0.314665854,
-0.0130182868,
0.186665073,
-0.7050395608,
0.3386380374,
-0.0459269769,
-0.0080822697,
0.19188793,
0.3065446019,
-0.5106728673,
-0.3874094784,
-0.9396547079,
-0.0045592003,
-0.5417221189,
1.0805128813,
0.0866012722,
0.08869306,
0.0470358953,
0.0540031306,
-0.4250096977,
-0.6756946445,
-0.9030426145,
-0.5973508954,
0.2907033563,
-0.0719442442,
0.2020775229,
0.7776287198,
0.292630583,
0.241987139,
-0.3589103818,
-0.0191780981,
-0.1960919499,
0.0546159893,
-0.0884637833,
-0.3109163344,
-0.0905046612,
-0.1797408164,
0.6349933147,
0.5521614552,
-0.4621951282,
0.0199757647,
0.1627615839,
0.4663540125,
-0.6263170838,
0.2102010101,
-0.8666321039,
0.3053641021,
-0.2100270391,
0.0245239902,
-0.5171608329,
0.0731629878,
-0.1221258938,
-0.2180175334,
0.3531666994,
-0.177768454,
0.7529029846,
0.8446495533,
-0.3320369124,
-0.2053815573,
-0.9228660464,
0.4148798883,
-0.8344081044,
0.4364186823,
0.2197035104,
0.1767776012,
0.246686846,
-0.9211297035,
-0.5749247074,
0.2749689817,
-0.2754195631,
0.1234435365,
-0.513920486,
0.2678247094,
0.060990192,
0.3632795811,
-0.3605853319,
0.1506533474,
-0.29230088,
-0.3604359627,
0.3230605423,
0.0255474728,
-0.023166554,
0.0163197573,
-0.6421776414,
-0.1984981,
-0.2090870589,
0.0296203438,
0.0168680213,
0.3469372392,
-0.0739761144,
0.2640858591,
0.1727479547,
0.5469995141,
0.4385407567,
-0.2369955778,
0.2012201697,
-0.1590282917,
-0.2613558769,
0.6526637673,
0.7690716982,
-0.0088404957,
-0.1482413411,
-0.3390839994,
-0.3276646137,
0.3461751342,
0.0674407035,
-0.9400762916,
-0.5226712823,
-0.1384676695,
-0.3285565078,
-0.0623239726,
-0.0167494826,
-0.5700719357,
-0.1848881841,
-0.2330590487,
0.6159812808,
-0.1432041079,
-0.1445670426,
0.1973591894,
-0.4362076223,
-0.0477750264,
-0.1219046935,
-0.8587146401,
0.5631366372,
0.4978926182,
0.882324636,
-0.5971583128,
0.0205366593,
-0.6788212657,
0.1758971214,
-0.1997647136,
0.5722344518,
-0.4429447651,
-0.7009019852,
-0.328137368,
-0.1237616763,
-0.1666752696,
-0.5510049462,
0.5983381271,
-0.4409606457,
-0.3214388788,
0.0598998591,
-0.467545867,
-0.0923751891,
-0.1615599245,
-0.6627017856,
0.92771101,
-0.2641250491,
-0.6841340661,
0.4046911001,
-0.6882817149,
-0.5423477888,
-0.009532691,
-0.0798193142,
-0.5226015449,
0.1005754992,
0.297265321,
0.2154770643,
-0.0303192791,
0.7055864334,
0.1791672111,
-0.3201728165,
0.2552468777,
-0.9831107855,
0.6636900306,
0.3819353282,
-0.8038008213,
-0.0868702978,
-0.9446436167,
-0.1469652057,
-0.313167125,
-0.4972361028,
-0.3228416443,
0.0270760451,
0.0724840686,
0.2975193262,
-0.2213951647,
-0.774949491,
0.0415260345,
-0.4271560311,
0.5140752196,
0.7348760366,
-0.1787040234,
0.4420829713,
-0.0945007205,
0.374640435,
0.4059374332,
-0.1030646861,
-0.2064928859,
-0.5178930163,
-0.8695967793,
-0.6180824637,
0.604465425,
0.3247949481,
-0.8543724418,
0.4406649768,
-0.1470645815,
-0.5109648108,
-0.8092674613,
-0.362781167,
0.4255413711,
0.6557561755,
0.3862444162,
-0.4407773316,
-0.7314574718,
-0.6190212369,
-0.1899212748,
-0.1002061442,
-0.121401757,
-0.0677028671,
0.1788868308,
-0.2908624709,
1.0261827707,
-0.5982182622,
-0.5519907475,
0.0239485092,
0.3127345443,
0.1494826227,
0.5826410651,
-0.019256629,
-0.7510030866,
-0.5890550017,
-0.1427313685,
-0.1480649114,
-0.3941008449,
0.0522783734,
0.166384384,
0.4706815183,
0.6043903828,
-0.6672540903,
0.8416265845,
0.5191216469,
-0.416336596,
0.1441537589,
-0.0705857128,
-0.1824508607,
-0.6789726019,
0.1692096442,
-0.1313279718,
-0.3818929791,
-0.9667016268,
-0.3430583775,
-0.1084361002,
-0.2735518515,
-0.5284557939,
0.570692122,
-0.2238690853,
-0.0342515223,
-0.489767909,
-0.2507601678,
0.3648480177,
0.5787619948,
0.1757679731,
0.5810627937,
0.6991462708,
-0.667370379,
0.0214329846,
0.1288529038,
-0.0146767544,
0.4018201232,
-0.7480535507,
0.1097062975,
-0.458512038,
0.5709396601,
-0.9712120891,
0.4926798642,
0.5045220256,
-0.3715190291,
0.791482091,
-0.0460010581,
-0.1807245612,
-0.4159500301,
-0.1366646439,
0.514683485,
0.6448501348,
-0.5986670256,
0.7963289618,
0.3706216812,
-0.11509642,
-0.5914936662,
-0.9357572198,
0.1444960237,
-0.4438153505,
-0.2239607722,
0.817194283,
-0.1828703284,
0.0829255432,
0.0107493829,
-0.4546339512,
-0.1579830199,
-0.2134451866,
0.2001466453,
0.0840325132,
-0.0376427658,
0.1831109524,
-0.0096259937,
-0.4588920772,
-0.1564258039,
-0.5942669511,
0.56993258,
0.1926270127,
-0.2964875102,
-0.7861456275,
0.4371860623,
0.3580650389,
-0.1197532043,
0.4341556132,
0.9162063003,
-0.287356019,
-0.2224169075,
-0.6540493965,
-0.2018371969,
-0.482039839,
0.1805986166,
-0.4355200529,
-0.7788776755,
0.602781117,
0.1431779414,
-0.1204049289,
0.6667712331,
0.4636567235,
0.1158023477,
0.7460188866,
0.6471509337,
-0.2269521803,
0.2607488334,
-0.2874696553,
0.3428086042,
-0.6617949009,
-0.4522718191,
-0.5639009476,
-0.4018565118,
-0.374483943,
-0.6351979375,
0.3074319959,
-0.2140928507,
-0.2544350028,
0.083382763,
-0.9808574319,
0.2750980854,
0.7890375853,
-0.264059782,
0.5511997938,
0.3054206669,
0.1224993691,
-0.0025949564,
-0.8984742165,
-0.0241641868,
0.5800486803,
0.4228240252,
1.1160991192,
-0.326574415,
0.9360300303,
0.4359113574,
-0.0619110353,
-0.7391145229,
0.2771538198,
-0.5363491774,
-0.3369725645,
-0.5091403723,
-0.3465252817,
-0.9380498528,
0.4293845296,
0.3589855731,
-0.588432312,
0.6021809578,
0.1282138675,
-0.2792954445,
0.4362186193,
-0.4557605088,
0.4202682674,
0.1111051291,
0.4556560218,
0.2890628278,
-0.7526597381,
0.068991147,
-0.2596511543,
0.1807482243,
0.161563918,
0.0741973743,
1.0027173758,
-0.8409814835,
0.9571020603,
-0.5069778562,
-0.1210582778,
0.6047749519,
-0.1569491029,
0.566843152,
-0.2963220477,
0.0059738164,
0.4404679239,
0.119863674,
0.0520089716,
-0.5764271617,
0.5430158377,
-0.6719415784,
-0.4291437268,
-0.4222587645,
-0.309302628,
0.2596772313,
0.0448384471,
0.5054773092,
0.5875378251,
0.3095276952,
-0.0657008067,
0.6695061922,
0.0454310849,
0.90210706,
0.4516026974,
0.083444491,
-0.5730528235,
1.0492017269,
0.3138122559,
0.3092313707,
0.2442907244,
0.352879107,
-0.5478538871,
-0.4217920899,
-0.5076693296,
0.0283313673,
-0.768773675,
-0.5690512061,
-0.8016614914,
-0.4746657014,
-0.3385139406,
0.1244017109,
-0.5436118841,
-0.5424515009,
-0.473359108,
-0.0902786106,
0.388400346,
0.5363550782,
-0.3558299541,
0.416570425,
-0.5612356663,
0.5595160723,
0.3008584976,
0.4492621124,
0.1786074489,
-0.6762259007,
-0.0193310957,
0.334546268,
-0.1727737933,
-0.4912044406,
0.5922092795,
0.6454840302,
0.380181849,
0.1730336398,
0.4828529954,
0.9855871201,
-0.6452673674,
0.7474336624,
0.4044567645,
-1.2093344927,
0.1732823104,
0.1276108176,
0.5037728548,
0.4992662668,
0.0644001365,
-0.5901780128,
-0.4222495258,
-0.4392258525,
-1.1511715651,
1.0140538216,
0.2622268796,
0.2380200922,
-0.0380456001,
0.1026857644,
0.2002013177,
0.3151145279,
-0.7949776649,
-0.7563436627,
-0.6831614971,
-0.1624770314,
-0.0915080458,
-0.217883423,
0.1746669114,
-0.4326271117,
0.899500668,
0.203743875,
0.353474617,
0.4048195481,
0.0360581651,
0.043127384,
0.1500786841,
0.4224555492,
-0.0724974796,
0.0251815543,
0.5631814599,
-0.0990532562,
-0.6262919307,
0.6199870706,
0.231323719,
-0.2536036372,
0.6216352582,
-0.262054503,
1.0529929399,
0.2079891413,
-0.3028517663,
0.5592575073,
-0.0579091348,
-0.2671816945,
-0.0300978106,
-0.2686347663,
0.0426599309,
0.0920021161,
0.7496537566,
0.0443849266,
0.4151296616,
-0.2948443294,
0.5581355691,
0.2506034076,
-0.6870737076,
-0.0146830548,
0.9704130292,
-0.0747242272,
-0.5331087112,
0.4871295393,
-0.2691230476,
-0.4734227657,
0.5018256307,
0.9422582388,
1.0416307449,
-0.5438661575,
0.265331924,
0.0151608028,
-0.0589366741,
-0.0926539749,
-0.3486274183,
-0.3185881674,
-0.2978929281,
-0.5097256899,
-0.9471282363,
-0.024967514,
-0.0889026374,
-0.5357869267,
0.1103925183,
0.018234849,
-0.264714241,
0.2523635626,
-0.4642081857,
-0.37387532,
0.35422194,
0.3328422606,
0.5398521423,
-0.7121446729,
0.8021115661,
0.1743213385,
0.0795055628,
-0.7758543491,
-0.0782325119,
-0.3109006882,
-0.5624901652,
0.8803315759,
0.0979405046,
-0.2575431764,
0.2992208898,
-0.0600207075,
-1.1073851585,
0.9020826221,
0.2677123845,
-0.6468791962,
-0.1539170444,
0.4806287289,
0.3171577454,
-0.1926124245,
-0.0040946063,
0.4488858283,
0.2705053389,
0.704402864,
-1.1079627275,
-0.1159593537,
-0.2585714161,
0.3564783335,
0.2685812116,
-0.4526187479,
0.7600842714,
0.2517875433,
-0.4520566165,
-0.3038918674,
0.4815067649,
-0.0407609902,
0.6020507812,
0.5389314294,
0.5068150163,
0.5894446373,
-0.1175434887,
0.6558865309,
-0.2330002189,
0.4456195235,
1.0878287554,
-0.0629593357,
0.5370975137,
0.5536730289,
-0.2702761292,
0.2828879952,
0.2880973816,
0.065934591,
0.9968104362,
0.5537899137,
-0.4054139256,
0.0774450377,
-0.2186858952,
-0.2281657755,
0.6133189201,
0.1419684142,
-0.1709262431,
-0.4557543397,
0.4306557477,
-0.0375112556,
-0.0918624476,
-0.5263242722,
0.9187207818,
0.2525960505,
-0.4424799383,
0.989956975,
0.1377795637,
1.1656838655,
-0.5068928003,
0.1116309166,
-0.0950106233,
-0.0126457652,
-0.1757965833,
-0.1129814237,
0.7930820584,
0.0070899231,
-0.2794656157,
-0.2940180898,
0.7816395164,
-0.7797629237,
-0.676012814,
-0.0014206093,
-0.0302209985,
0.2029403299,
-0.1155342162,
-0.3298301995,
0.3193313777,
0.0249536093,
-0.0031328185,
0.2912250161,
0.2443663031,
0.0899746567,
0.7094965577,
0.3992621601,
-0.1308651417,
0.3879468441,
0.1662604809,
0.8857830763,
-0.3321377337,
-0.635822475,
-1.1953932047,
0.7457177639,
0.1501054019,
0.2119300663,
0.6008328199,
0.6072528362,
0.4293444753,
-0.1068434045,
0.6240680814,
0.1083742008,
0.3515209854,
-0.3232584298,
0.8571671247,
-0.1362938434,
0.1897078902,
-0.4464510381,
-0.7767044306,
-0.4537896812,
0.551202178,
0.2298169285,
-0.1004994288,
0.4503259957,
0.6948416233,
0.1321168244,
-0.3152920306,
0.5045697689,
0.0381310284,
0.3533845544,
0.170914188,
0.5048057437,
-0.7962689996,
0.6837692857,
-0.0844141915,
0.0823518112,
0.0452906042,
-0.7659783959,
-0.6971079111,
-0.7743511796,
-0.7102865577,
-0.102648221,
0.1378859431,
0.4872120917,
0.7335844636,
-0.585622251,
0.0485294461,
-0.2245606035,
0.0366041064,
-0.1010981798,
-0.2751378715,
0.5339432359,
-0.382240057,
-0.7526010275,
0.2990477383,
0.3615690172,
0.2365554869,
-0.095117487,
-0.0113602197,
0.0252820067,
0.1825404316,
0.5562972426,
-0.0150938593,
-0.8625195026,
-0.1039051861,
-0.273311615,
0.1848672032,
0.2837918699,
0.8009807467,
-1.0750484467,
0.6189267039,
0.1078056321,
0.4910537302,
1.0124288797,
0.1195298061,
0.3457313776,
-0.993383646,
0.1794020981,
0.3614778221,
-0.0504130349,
0.3003368974,
-0.3397417068,
0.2020025849,
0.1906968951,
-0.4326384068,
-0.9782794714,
-0.0387055874,
-0.8821073174,
-0.2347455621,
0.9850080013,
-0.1184730679,
-0.0622501299,
-0.2528610528,
-0.2525149584,
0.5200566649,
-0.5202621222,
0.7674376965,
0.4031586051,
0.1059482619,
-0.1363678724,
-0.0176218338,
0.6692613959,
0.1303428859,
-0.1951825619,
0.2284947485,
0.1924609244,
0.2385572195,
0.1722545326,
0.9660602808,
-0.0110043883,
-0.1791311949,
0.1447968781,
0.1550943553,
-0.2303930372,
-0.2908803523,
-0.655606389,
-0.0177453682,
-0.0655445531,
-0.5332162976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04507v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04507v3
|
Conversation Understanding using Relational Temporal Graph Neural Networks with Auxiliary Cross-Modality Interaction
| 2023-11-08T07:46:25 | 2024-01-30T08:01:42 |
Cam-Van Thi Nguyen, Anh-Tuan Mai, The-Son Le, Hai-Dang Kieu, Duc-Trong Le
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Emotion recognition is a crucial task for human conversation understanding.
It becomes more challenging with the notion of multimodal data, e.g., language,
voice, and facial expressions. As a typical solution, the global- and the local
context information are exploited to predict the emotional label for every
single sentence, i.e., utterance, in the dialogue. Specifically, the global
representation could be captured via modeling of cross-modal interactions at
the conversation level. The local one is often inferred using the temporal
information of speakers or emotional shifts, which neglects vital factors at
the utterance level. Additionally, most existing approaches take fused features
of multiple modalities in an unified input without leveraging modality-specific
representations. Motivating from these problems, we propose the Relational
Temporal Graph Neural Network with Auxiliary Cross-Modality Interaction
(CORECT), an novel neural network framework that effectively captures
conversation-level cross-modality interactions and utterance-level temporal
dependencies with the modality-specific manner for conversation understanding.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of CORECT via its
state-of-the-art results on the IEMOCAP and CMU-MOSEI datasets for the
multimodal ERC task.
|
[
-0.4393952787,
-1.1214592457,
0.5201812387,
0.1153290868,
-0.1673995256,
-0.0306806136,
-0.1878164113,
-0.674138844,
0.3312578201,
0.0665234253,
-0.9208955169,
-0.5164062977,
-0.1902969778,
0.0757417977,
0.0470011048,
0.6936563849,
0.1049170941,
0.1077687517,
-0.2641773522,
-0.4337559044,
-0.284617722,
-0.6347401142,
-0.7302650809,
-0.5968996286,
0.5448580384,
0.3353312016,
0.5003891587,
0.0368785039,
-0.0362926498,
0.3573612869,
-0.163584128,
0.2049784362,
-0.4051785469,
0.3124147654,
0.2450512797,
-0.1784303933,
-0.5010768771,
-0.1388658434,
0.5699627399,
0.7086243033,
-0.0585887209,
-0.2037235498,
-0.1758161634,
0.2454463989,
-0.5401340723,
0.6111892462,
-0.4429584742,
0.4463895261,
0.1231853142,
-0.3208398819,
-0.4411428571,
0.0954642147,
0.3073749542,
-0.3082665503,
-0.0644429401,
0.1289474964,
0.7004360557,
-0.0891706496,
-0.9057276249,
0.0785445049,
-0.5775199533,
0.3889223337,
-0.4904243946,
0.6701109409,
0.3685479164,
0.1764543205,
0.153154552,
-0.3655578494,
-0.7663965225,
-0.2076372653,
-0.2254899293,
0.5045911074,
-0.4739134312,
0.2902217805,
0.2374946028,
0.1897049099,
-0.5785036087,
-0.0377243757,
0.0647882968,
-0.2832964361,
0.0692534223,
0.5606752634,
0.4747745097,
-0.5244272947,
-0.3051593602,
0.2013159394,
-0.274510473,
0.1392088532,
0.0967182592,
0.28467381,
-0.366109401,
0.4485211372,
-0.2208196819,
0.5190783739,
0.1437810361,
0.170259431,
0.3479378819,
-0.5545224547,
-0.35660851,
0.1125894412,
0.9640420675,
0.3820695281,
0.0612001941,
-0.1601566523,
0.2809238136,
0.1629508287,
-0.0491518825,
-0.6751530766,
-0.0523538701,
0.1884218305,
-0.5155271888,
-0.1011918858,
-0.2418946028,
-0.6532903314,
-0.1580777764,
-0.4609772265,
-0.0109967217,
-0.4518052638,
-0.3808103204,
-0.4057560563,
0.1873299628,
-0.0585240014,
0.3224501908,
-0.6818130612,
0.3276679814,
0.3790684342,
0.9846044183,
0.1893619448,
-0.2581607997,
-0.4800159931,
0.1182392612,
-0.049157232,
0.5660431981,
-0.7709769607,
-0.6034532785,
-0.1711340547,
0.149002701,
-0.349266082,
-0.1665982306,
0.6657776237,
-0.3612095118,
0.2169351578,
-0.0959696844,
-0.0268334225,
-0.337370187,
0.5342543721,
-0.6656371355,
0.6650577784,
0.0551133938,
-0.6981909275,
-0.0677423254,
-0.4977182746,
-0.6885710359,
-0.176510036,
-0.1453478634,
-0.435167253,
0.2204352617,
0.4244921803,
0.5463488698,
-0.2032030672,
0.0229506884,
-0.4858927131,
0.0002841941,
0.4692016244,
-0.3850926161,
0.5272328854,
0.2765154839,
-0.1238078699,
0.2104946375,
-0.6238932014,
0.1050012261,
-0.1352088302,
-0.0139689781,
-0.377322197,
-0.0947287455,
0.1262405217,
0.4555144012,
-0.0568949059,
-0.7153697014,
-0.1451399475,
-0.0624537803,
0.7293884754,
0.630461514,
0.1400021166,
0.5342417359,
-0.0485987142,
0.4570308924,
0.426938355,
0.1889024377,
-0.3697077632,
-0.3137127161,
-0.7336645126,
-0.0890500769,
-0.0416042432,
0.5221584439,
-0.6454859376,
0.2355944961,
-0.3048736453,
-0.2650714517,
-0.1819178462,
-0.3613930941,
0.5313548446,
0.8992131352,
0.2472888976,
-0.3580124676,
-0.6441830397,
-0.9221277237,
0.0035884741,
-0.4609463513,
0.2157983631,
1.0306524038,
0.1931869984,
-0.2828164101,
0.8507698178,
-0.1181889325,
-0.1824981123,
-0.3536963165,
0.730162859,
0.1363951415,
0.3734603822,
0.3621995747,
-0.7751892805,
-0.3939290047,
0.3236665726,
-0.6280391216,
-0.1869851202,
-0.436155051,
-0.2393827885,
0.1719028652,
0.2248398215,
-0.6381165981,
0.4063262343,
0.5383447409,
-0.5139582157,
0.2469044328,
0.1637210846,
0.6007216573,
-0.9637671709,
-0.1195581555,
0.1159435511,
-0.4554666877,
-0.7567452192,
-0.6395699978,
0.0860923752,
-0.3865710199,
-0.4126158357,
0.3292089403,
-0.5977706313,
-0.0617315918,
0.212223351,
0.1302248091,
0.0243358593,
0.8769249916,
0.2859488428,
0.2752202451,
0.3140279651,
-0.2673743665,
0.3311080039,
0.4651242793,
-0.0213927235,
0.9889420271,
-0.5282891989,
0.4289264679,
-0.0977463126,
0.4549364746,
-0.885173738,
0.0359558016,
0.4238753319,
-0.6243877411,
0.4277882874,
-0.4616458118,
-0.1335470676,
-0.0209522005,
0.2105121911,
0.4377528131,
0.153478846,
-0.3032886386,
1.5912679434,
0.2658476233,
-0.2559625506,
-0.5683068037,
-0.7802238464,
0.0707376823,
0.1464543343,
-0.9505891204,
0.2216631025,
0.0217483137,
0.0151184639,
-0.0099274982,
-0.1787580997,
-0.0543595888,
-0.1369365454,
0.7160513997,
0.2965469658,
-0.0586417615,
0.2582735717,
0.0227591489,
-0.0818740055,
0.3543042541,
0.2264144868,
0.6369941831,
-0.4659878314,
-0.3877904713,
-0.6482312083,
0.6875544786,
0.6636956334,
-0.2979874313,
0.5994650126,
0.8447710276,
-0.3488348126,
0.1307083666,
-0.3736313283,
-0.0807233229,
-0.3594537973,
0.6404166818,
-0.594869256,
-0.8929115534,
0.8068655133,
-0.0554207228,
-0.3320501745,
0.1075303033,
0.6691997647,
-0.1130043641,
1.2525463104,
0.239099279,
-0.1967462003,
0.911811769,
-0.1471004039,
0.3262498975,
-1.051384449,
-0.4912933111,
-0.3072869778,
-0.6908031106,
-0.0031517446,
-0.4055227637,
0.4148037434,
-0.2100878507,
-0.2051934302,
0.052693367,
0.0710304976,
0.3654836416,
0.2285863906,
0.479406476,
0.3724399507,
-0.0702669695,
-0.0434073135,
-0.1238417402,
-0.626203835,
0.1053125262,
0.525801897,
0.2747595012,
0.7150829434,
0.049119506,
0.3800381422,
0.0324845649,
0.2699236572,
-0.9270260334,
0.6551934481,
0.206619963,
-0.4062973559,
-0.0142971454,
-0.9109803438,
-0.6864850521,
0.3201241493,
-0.4195358455,
-0.9848668575,
0.4513978362,
0.1063549817,
-0.1671342254,
0.2233644873,
-0.8008163571,
1.0628339052,
-0.3506140113,
-0.2379523963,
-0.3244999051,
-0.8364928961,
0.2399608493,
0.5027430058,
0.112654157,
-0.3092760146,
0.2325663418,
0.5955113173,
-0.2645774782,
1.0855507851,
-0.0368879102,
0.4416423142,
0.2298664749,
0.4257153869,
0.5350954533,
0.1916866452,
0.2664022744,
0.3054133952,
-0.2033404112,
-0.0689989477,
-0.7900807261,
0.6920374036,
-0.8232152462,
-0.0997048095,
-0.299851656,
-0.7293072939,
-0.446294874,
-0.0192956086,
0.1131782383,
0.7124252915,
-0.5174318552,
0.0534613244,
0.4296497703,
0.0303415116,
0.4643168449,
0.5456638932,
0.0497336388,
-0.5323610306,
0.767531395,
-0.143418327,
0.3272758126,
0.5046266317,
0.2137006372,
-0.1405506432,
-0.0586074889,
-0.1217793375,
0.2102215737,
-0.7925527692,
-0.1849382073,
-1.1596596241,
0.0962792709,
-0.4557769001,
0.0733242705,
-0.2259441763,
-0.4936529696,
-0.4641292989,
-0.1566467881,
0.321839571,
0.3505158126,
-0.1026922986,
0.2364971191,
-1.0987285376,
0.1441789418,
0.4645711482,
0.0403792188,
0.1568456143,
-0.3193032742,
-0.0879976898,
0.148780942,
-0.1187571734,
-1.1941386461,
0.4867927432,
0.4642413855,
0.4679192007,
0.4267152846,
-0.0139054125,
0.7645119429,
-0.3402426839,
0.5029953122,
0.5078410506,
-1.339368701,
0.4605028927,
-0.2478653193,
0.5151127577,
0.2872851193,
0.4473170936,
-1.2373776436,
-0.0102588953,
-0.6097397208,
-0.7880709171,
0.7612679601,
0.2868121266,
0.04274185,
-0.0377497226,
-0.0796163902,
-0.2674067914,
0.1950837523,
-0.5899133682,
-0.1585812271,
-0.3018786311,
-0.3734189272,
0.2106597126,
-0.1567554474,
-0.3691878021,
-0.1031756774,
0.2429762781,
-0.3270415366,
0.6713334918,
0.2662064135,
-0.3713162243,
-0.3670623302,
0.4595716298,
0.4014281332,
0.2272179276,
-0.1551029682,
0.2433729619,
0.349355787,
-0.1957131624,
-0.1609646529,
0.1095238626,
0.4236498177,
-0.0063142567,
0.413485527,
1.1585086584,
0.3977355659,
-0.4542198181,
0.4279517531,
-0.2990725338,
0.148058638,
-0.1678814143,
-0.4757009745,
0.1342978925,
0.609975338,
0.0261319745,
0.1968114525,
0.1919588,
-0.9050117731,
0.0789017156,
0.3350578845,
-0.7617629766,
-0.6012300849,
0.3424395919,
0.483582437,
-0.154290244,
0.8991563916,
0.1872712076,
-0.9846912026,
0.637214005,
0.4545915425,
0.9437571168,
-0.1885975301,
0.2628646493,
0.2537249923,
-0.0271316413,
0.6030279994,
0.4613600373,
-0.5259533525,
-0.9188644886,
-0.2488411218,
-0.1304696053,
-0.7115234733,
-0.4026302993,
-0.6054894924,
-0.1650830656,
-0.3569025397,
-0.4422968328,
-0.2421957701,
-0.4234087765,
-0.8554782867,
0.0408876985,
0.4292735457,
0.2924989462,
-1.0625492334,
0.525464654,
0.5445370674,
-0.4101309776,
-0.7021849751,
-0.527823925,
0.2407015711,
-0.6781996489,
0.8623052239,
0.2009924948,
-0.2217507511,
-0.1764679998,
-0.1460506767,
-0.4677532613,
1.0185554028,
0.1886785626,
-0.5149121881,
-0.1277217865,
-0.0345053114,
0.3825456202,
-0.7070664167,
0.8528998494,
0.3751082718,
0.3501456976,
0.1384193748,
-0.9637000561,
0.1200361922,
-0.5724338889,
-0.1086318791,
0.3904395998,
-0.6821955442,
0.9597825408,
-0.0906506032,
-0.4337136745,
-0.3104262054,
0.6454859972,
-0.1146096513,
0.35958305,
0.8429604769,
0.570492208,
0.5971983671,
-0.4822267294,
0.8862459064,
-0.2447286844,
0.3066985607,
1.2803988457,
-0.3053407669,
0.7153956294,
0.3042005897,
0.024390772,
0.526047051,
0.658257544,
0.3606590927,
0.0928685814,
-0.3184219301,
-0.4814247191,
-0.6784328818,
-0.5219630003,
-0.3371866345,
0.422298044,
0.5095396042,
-0.4527005553,
-0.1554611027,
0.2168036103,
-0.0017763764,
-0.4823763669,
-0.2406809926,
0.8459897041,
0.1846785694,
-0.3120928407,
0.3245410919,
-0.5956985354,
0.2332619131,
-0.6168625355,
-0.0687848404,
-0.1411296278,
0.017975606,
-0.3715868592,
-0.6469649076,
0.1006576717,
-0.3386816382,
-0.0855320618,
-0.2678045332,
0.6135691404,
-0.709053874,
-0.1878611892,
0.4148191512,
0.508490622,
-0.136460498,
-0.1973681599,
-0.699149251,
0.2462423444,
-0.318666935,
-0.4390509725,
0.1558378488,
0.6659607291,
0.282213062,
0.5820363164,
0.4381077886,
-0.2421454936,
-0.1587421596,
0.4294120967,
0.9814389944,
-0.6710478663,
-0.7283718586,
-0.6885931492,
0.5939900875,
-0.190555051,
-0.3899314106,
0.4189271331,
0.1240877956,
0.5190621018,
0.2095963955,
0.5448446274,
-0.255810231,
0.1874684691,
-0.6383292079,
0.5146437883,
-0.5035561323,
-0.1226213351,
-0.3610318899,
-0.6897293329,
-0.0792135298,
0.5902704597,
-0.2985601723,
0.0181551352,
0.9749671221,
0.5705471635,
-0.0389410704,
0.5290632844,
0.3073447347,
0.4205723703,
0.3157204688,
1.0923682451,
1.0921436548,
0.0055234875,
0.77758044,
-0.4969945252,
-0.126021862,
-0.0773373321,
-0.8584412336,
-1.0288383961,
-0.5964031219,
-0.314357847,
-0.5496002436,
-0.0579912141,
1.119838357,
0.7673715949,
-0.6024788022,
-0.1246787757,
0.2228375226,
0.0384195819,
-0.2215787023,
-0.2071157843,
0.0869340226,
-0.016289765,
-0.8584414124,
0.4952758551,
0.4144993424,
0.1064035371,
0.0023146956,
-0.0993677005,
-0.2889778018,
-0.2084746361,
0.6058254242,
0.2872496843,
-0.51666677,
-0.3575466573,
0.0917050838,
0.0398012362,
0.4168895483,
1.4231241941,
-0.8201928735,
0.7141740918,
0.726988852,
0.5675699115,
0.7072352767,
-0.0921157897,
0.8223629594,
-0.8172563314,
0.1072743684,
0.5240504146,
0.7167377472,
0.271312207,
-0.4235506952,
0.4049837887,
0.3796155155,
-0.4802330434,
-0.4836393595,
0.5680894256,
-1.5897115469,
-0.0384172834,
0.7234460115,
-0.1899132133,
-0.3942782581,
-0.101817131,
-0.3600370884,
0.4590191841,
-0.8622016311,
0.3262728453,
0.5860215425,
-0.4939751923,
-0.6978154778,
-0.0404212624,
-0.1897389889,
0.5563520193,
-0.8295446038,
0.1159019917,
0.8267869353,
-0.1219275221,
0.1943710148,
0.5516417027,
0.0602478087,
0.1829187125,
-0.0356072523,
-0.0538050197,
-0.4112353027,
-0.2096619308,
-0.1836295873,
0.1858281046,
-0.6253997684,
0.0312624127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04498v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04498v4
|
NExT-Chat: An LMM for Chat, Detection and Segmentation
| 2023-11-08T07:15:05 | 2023-12-18T12:15:26 |
Ao Zhang, Yuan Yao, Wei Ji, Zhiyuan Liu, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The development of large language models (LLMs) has greatly advanced the
field of multimodal understanding, leading to the emergence of large multimodal
models (LMMs). In order to enhance the level of visual comprehension, recent
studies have equipped LMMs with region-level understanding capabilities by
representing object bounding box coordinates as a series of text sequences
(pix2seq). In this paper, we introduce a novel paradigm for object location
modeling called pix2emb method, where we ask the LMM to output the location
embeddings and then decode them with different decoders. This paradigm allows
us to use different location formats (such as bounding boxes and masks) in
multimodal conversations. Leveraging the proposed pix2emb method, we train an
LMM named NExT-Chat and demonstrate its capability of handling multiple tasks
like visual grounding, region captioning, and grounded reasoning. Comprehensive
experiments show the effectiveness of our NExT-Chat on various tasks, e.g.,
NExT-Chat (87.7) vs. Shikra (86.9) on POPE-Random, NExT-Chat (68.9) vs. LISA
(67.9) on referring expression segmentation task, and NExT-Chat (79.6) vs.
Kosmos-2 (62.3) on region caption task. The code and model are released at
https://github.com/NExT-ChatV/NExT-Chat.
|
[
-0.3654287457,
-1.0976346731,
0.7031858563,
-0.0685094595,
-0.2308604866,
0.0338862129,
-0.118284598,
-0.4097304642,
0.0745845586,
0.6164171696,
-0.5765089989,
-0.8395881653,
-0.4428922534,
-0.3929341435,
-0.3724604547,
0.2830179036,
0.2785075307,
-0.0506612845,
-0.5235543251,
0.0375830047,
-0.9962800145,
-0.7578573227,
-0.6293740273,
0.0143234069,
0.443452388,
0.8188973665,
0.8887552023,
0.4866201878,
0.606436789,
0.3255819678,
-0.0766736269,
0.2950795293,
-0.4550746083,
0.1071341932,
0.0003711256,
-0.9860418439,
-0.3172546923,
-0.1827803999,
0.6455869079,
0.3829373717,
0.111323081,
-0.173236534,
-0.4668312371,
0.3564132154,
-0.4625383615,
0.305763185,
-0.7522938848,
0.2008369267,
-0.2330674082,
-0.2372268438,
-0.5962841511,
0.2089508176,
0.1158747524,
-0.1680160016,
-0.0281428304,
0.309677422,
0.8688150644,
0.2752687931,
-0.3559720516,
-0.0291429125,
-0.3619820178,
0.7901391387,
-0.526704073,
0.7048953772,
0.6399119496,
0.5165164471,
-0.0966854244,
-0.5425941944,
-0.636596024,
0.0070900074,
-0.0325310305,
-0.0058011231,
-0.1273291856,
-0.3259160221,
0.0452212691,
-0.1290789694,
-0.5102992058,
0.3434736431,
-0.2136283815,
-0.1280888021,
0.3323855698,
0.1868630648,
0.4161006808,
-0.0648350567,
-0.3679283857,
-0.1534191817,
-0.5975179672,
0.0550084598,
0.0145027861,
0.1249026656,
-0.0913501754,
0.6446530223,
-0.048700653,
0.7472705245,
-0.1897715032,
-0.5649824142,
0.2487848699,
-0.2921047509,
-0.0239165835,
-0.1954538524,
0.6897381544,
0.8866270185,
-0.0855729505,
0.3255760372,
0.1263550073,
-0.2076504976,
-0.0283553768,
-0.6465585232,
-0.3830356598,
0.3553852141,
-0.6919865608,
-0.0794071481,
-0.2255558819,
-0.4344404638,
-0.3787451088,
-0.1917307973,
-0.0048512602,
-0.5787077546,
-0.4080286324,
-0.0077985576,
0.0794439837,
0.4484255612,
0.431019038,
-0.6983170509,
-0.0424938127,
0.7146965861,
1.1276350021,
-0.1441410333,
-0.1918404251,
-0.5346235037,
0.1380844861,
-0.41705513,
1.2606351376,
-0.8325617313,
-0.3183541,
-0.0939376727,
0.2003489286,
0.0047508148,
-0.4271041453,
0.1715481579,
-0.5840575099,
0.4309923649,
-0.0067816586,
-0.5023987889,
-0.5859532952,
0.4927714169,
-0.2296059728,
0.8207165599,
-0.2116233706,
-0.4275373816,
0.0513918772,
-0.5580489039,
-0.1510749161,
0.0487841256,
-0.1200850308,
-0.5348256826,
-0.0623387881,
0.3457419872,
0.8516026735,
-0.0412346348,
0.067120336,
-0.6451258659,
-0.2289785147,
0.4481426179,
-0.3631255627,
0.2783745825,
0.1197770014,
0.0339770392,
0.2695690095,
-0.3768825829,
0.1298009008,
0.0032115853,
0.2429214269,
-0.3235414326,
0.3604202867,
-0.0312373564,
0.3726065159,
0.1193547025,
-0.2237002552,
-0.1064064652,
-0.126645118,
0.4708114266,
0.2699766755,
-0.0911403149,
0.5631154776,
-0.0550923832,
0.4396870732,
0.0520502552,
0.2298326343,
-1.0534404516,
-0.8032881618,
-0.4192737937,
-0.2789711952,
-0.1771612614,
0.7817639112,
-0.7157139778,
0.3751612902,
-0.2632274628,
-0.4672352076,
0.122496672,
-0.1257657856,
0.5108000636,
0.3693538904,
0.124161236,
-0.2615381181,
-0.4288131297,
-0.8509078026,
0.2293498516,
-0.1898332238,
0.1514435112,
0.3143728673,
0.3268070817,
-0.3432708085,
1.0061516762,
-0.4713498056,
-0.441801399,
-0.3793503344,
-0.2533473969,
-0.0341718607,
0.449365437,
0.4719990492,
-0.9862603545,
-0.5415160656,
0.0587372594,
-0.6362977028,
0.0743796229,
-0.1184698939,
-0.454074055,
0.1030159667,
0.8882246017,
-0.4414692521,
0.3545775712,
0.6352322698,
-0.2217977792,
0.0884186029,
0.0841609687,
0.040665932,
-1.274793148,
-0.3811422586,
-0.1059642136,
-0.7633340955,
-0.6322280169,
-0.0841546282,
0.2630475163,
-0.3315626681,
-0.7907755375,
0.5278136134,
-0.8342234492,
-0.5218371153,
-0.6405718923,
0.474635303,
-0.0288918912,
0.6287770271,
0.4776540101,
0.613147378,
0.6448907256,
-0.3735135198,
0.502789259,
0.5165138841,
-0.4338817596,
0.6601535082,
-0.3991844356,
0.323579669,
-0.1284291148,
0.3856990933,
-1.165378809,
-0.2417432666,
0.2945336699,
-0.7281445861,
0.2843957543,
-0.3151132166,
-0.4701102674,
-0.3035820723,
-0.1656048149,
0.3027958572,
0.4942280948,
-0.4642540812,
0.4252218306,
0.6867319345,
-0.2661227286,
-0.4895989299,
-0.5776934624,
0.3186168671,
-0.3628491461,
-0.7552518845,
0.0302430373,
0.0288259126,
-0.1789655387,
-0.1219008267,
0.0851959661,
-0.1277811378,
-0.043613933,
0.4555000365,
0.1648838073,
0.0051510665,
0.0202496909,
-0.0291174781,
-0.3235677779,
-0.1428463161,
-0.3050769269,
0.8771246076,
-0.052394364,
-0.6241919398,
-0.8282449841,
0.6242995262,
0.3886376321,
-0.4896285534,
0.7315352559,
0.8276459575,
-0.3119553924,
0.2780179083,
-0.6514849663,
-0.2207273692,
-0.4278645813,
1.0149257183,
-0.5004103184,
-1.0576474667,
0.3760975599,
-0.0003588989,
0.1107693166,
-0.0765208229,
0.7866194248,
-0.2473614067,
1.197234869,
0.8093606234,
0.1489156187,
0.8897237778,
-0.1425251812,
0.3827850819,
-0.7041104436,
-0.4809443951,
-0.2697702348,
-0.2345022261,
0.0876773298,
-1.0415267944,
0.3332279325,
0.2528456151,
0.112613678,
0.3054370582,
0.0209335778,
0.9426537156,
0.5083998442,
0.1301310062,
0.0243349243,
0.2360182703,
0.304202348,
-0.1187550575,
-0.7300339937,
-0.5454728603,
0.8510747552,
0.6695535183,
0.5926939845,
0.0830760822,
0.2636433244,
0.0540739,
0.2372678965,
-0.9623293281,
0.7386575937,
0.171506837,
-0.4300139248,
-0.3466671407,
-0.1069556624,
-0.7270542979,
0.5210903883,
-0.0757930875,
-0.9803116918,
0.0285695046,
0.0474230163,
-0.3525393903,
0.4456425309,
-0.8910601735,
0.9047431946,
-0.2234912217,
-0.2742758095,
-0.1412777156,
-0.7703605294,
0.4818499386,
0.0526168197,
0.3854325414,
-0.651673317,
-0.2020787895,
0.3969198465,
-0.138022989,
0.9659438729,
-0.1350976974,
-0.3626088798,
0.3285530508,
0.1508790851,
0.426453352,
0.3217646182,
0.4286228418,
0.3263040185,
-0.0578736961,
-0.2556610703,
-0.5718368888,
0.5432055593,
-0.5624169707,
-0.5183309317,
-0.0674878135,
-0.7155059576,
-0.2540050745,
0.1759254187,
0.1538454294,
0.6613967419,
0.2689340711,
0.5036322474,
0.6814222336,
-0.5276095867,
0.477291733,
0.4446533322,
-0.4766921401,
-0.2688077688,
0.820533514,
-0.4242313206,
0.2777042091,
1.0472779274,
-0.173825115,
-0.578810811,
-0.4827724397,
-0.1065384448,
0.1278091371,
-0.6992726922,
-0.3782998621,
-0.914157629,
0.1508990973,
-0.3117230535,
-0.0867140964,
-0.6315870285,
-0.0432086587,
-0.2622907758,
-0.0059141833,
0.1560122669,
0.1154127494,
0.086672388,
0.6507797241,
-1.0435240269,
0.2276405543,
0.1611392051,
0.0280944351,
-0.2876486182,
-0.5553765893,
-0.3067208529,
0.1064176857,
-0.2171424478,
-0.9504718184,
0.5467469096,
0.07190267,
0.4892792404,
0.5868904591,
-0.2845539153,
0.7582699656,
-0.6335460544,
0.7353761792,
0.5145255327,
-0.6806109548,
0.5927737951,
-0.1868153512,
0.3357835114,
0.043236535,
0.1836398095,
-0.7822019458,
-0.3223921359,
-0.2397199273,
-0.6153070927,
0.8814649582,
0.178193748,
0.3259811699,
-0.1016343236,
0.2003161162,
-0.1027105227,
-0.0872938037,
-0.6195412874,
-0.1868779212,
0.005726289,
-0.049835328,
-0.1888048053,
-0.7562818527,
0.0329392627,
0.0664102882,
0.4630822539,
-0.2344255,
0.7006007433,
-0.09372513,
-0.2705360949,
0.3326650262,
-0.0600552708,
0.8388844132,
0.5973355174,
0.0010487507,
0.0791313797,
0.1296059638,
-0.143448323,
0.0315491781,
-0.1564008594,
0.2540691793,
0.1541396827,
0.4840739369,
1.0163058043,
0.2474955171,
-0.8277137876,
0.6300725937,
-0.1840161681,
-0.0216963664,
-0.4841072261,
-0.0588520207,
0.1519632041,
0.6847316027,
0.1058971509,
-0.0731152818,
-0.0098687401,
-0.6845623255,
0.2275003493,
0.4446109831,
-0.366411984,
-0.2097781599,
0.7244644761,
0.1251434684,
-0.4679690003,
0.4021501243,
-0.1270989478,
-0.6116880774,
0.4591248035,
0.4285758436,
0.5145543218,
-0.2171920836,
0.2039009929,
0.3038527668,
0.1704111099,
-0.0079118134,
0.266538322,
-0.2827240527,
-0.9209652543,
-0.5156666636,
-0.1288873851,
-0.5357282758,
-0.1062411293,
-0.3466068804,
0.3825564384,
-0.0391768254,
-0.362714231,
-0.3789880276,
-0.4154261351,
-0.3338882327,
-0.0242479052,
0.500602603,
0.6512186527,
-0.3407823443,
0.8510118723,
0.8444790244,
0.1855988503,
-0.5732427239,
-0.196313858,
0.1742110997,
-1.0785188675,
0.4987663329,
0.5034644604,
0.0836282074,
-0.3084230423,
-0.6425569654,
-1.1884055138,
1.1291440725,
0.0244400501,
-0.8828670979,
0.0456686094,
0.025810156,
0.185773775,
-0.3092242181,
0.7114322186,
0.3459047973,
0.1309899241,
0.236689344,
-0.910082221,
-0.4746182561,
-0.2641198933,
0.3755842447,
0.0872511044,
-0.7817137837,
0.7169359922,
-0.3747774363,
-0.0616634227,
0.2178191692,
0.829064846,
0.3013712466,
0.3059687614,
0.6248514056,
0.3342242241,
0.4922456443,
-0.2563626468,
0.7869045734,
-0.1738919318,
0.3310852647,
1.3783349991,
-0.1834174991,
0.9440863729,
0.2298294008,
-0.0305767935,
0.377997607,
0.8089302778,
0.1912733316,
0.554867208,
-0.1520196944,
-0.0486601591,
-0.4933762252,
0.028399894,
-0.4635453522,
0.708615005,
0.6623592377,
-0.2021923363,
-0.0481601618,
0.5321757197,
0.2981256843,
-0.0533875786,
-0.2213142216,
0.7529509664,
-0.0351841077,
-0.3815722466,
0.4046566784,
0.2662104368,
0.5538240075,
-0.4678270817,
0.0333661474,
-0.4881600142,
0.2477695048,
-0.0608751737,
-0.9276198745,
0.3343271911,
-0.207043916,
0.0559557937,
-0.2174897492,
0.6603100896,
-0.5335144997,
-0.3018535376,
0.0920817554,
0.4200789034,
0.4275822639,
-0.4093510807,
-0.6634140611,
0.3717130721,
0.0273107756,
-0.1284968108,
0.2035582662,
0.5696430802,
-0.3972427249,
0.9857031703,
0.8047586679,
-0.5739616156,
0.1563415378,
0.2161868811,
0.4585576952,
-0.5960050225,
-0.8655876517,
-0.7796586156,
0.2261217088,
-0.0899027213,
0.1136088222,
0.8248692751,
0.5098371506,
0.8887488246,
0.020439975,
0.355810225,
0.1066309661,
0.4640809,
-0.6015020013,
0.259421587,
-0.671274662,
0.2053333521,
-0.2149891257,
-0.9505568147,
-0.5406314731,
0.6314447522,
-0.2795520723,
-0.2406016439,
0.7406643629,
0.9139128923,
0.0059842393,
-0.1233778149,
0.7221007347,
0.0441624671,
0.6241281629,
0.7945607305,
1.2351686954,
-0.1804150939,
0.7272884846,
-0.2576312423,
-0.1057953611,
-0.2385707945,
-0.5986328125,
-1.2355736494,
-0.6348484159,
-0.3051991463,
0.0078577399,
-0.1882278174,
0.6728717089,
1.2395100594,
-0.4525630474,
-0.2218928188,
0.1365866959,
0.2097087651,
-0.0211436525,
-0.17828013,
0.2313714325,
-0.2433919162,
-1.0878132582,
0.4471724927,
0.5884438753,
0.0891171843,
-0.0747739002,
-0.0521347299,
-0.1722177714,
-0.4325067699,
0.9382799864,
0.1282684505,
-0.7897127271,
-0.2058764994,
-0.065375559,
0.0953738242,
0.1077889204,
0.647570014,
-0.6178866625,
0.3588418365,
0.2749980986,
0.4757914245,
0.3640186787,
-0.0213715322,
0.4168830812,
-0.6190870404,
0.6846554875,
-0.1078807712,
0.5116390586,
0.3894778788,
-0.2362748086,
0.3336901963,
0.2509875596,
-0.2524151206,
-0.8160333037,
0.2552319467,
-0.9183644652,
-0.3450374007,
1.2783941031,
-0.0822227374,
-0.2568462789,
-0.1080378443,
-0.7342707515,
-0.0845348462,
-0.3472155333,
0.2699850798,
0.366289556,
-0.0577603914,
-0.9207162857,
-0.5232577324,
0.0678492114,
0.4632965326,
-0.9542635083,
-0.1926717758,
0.596842289,
0.067345418,
0.1650759727,
0.7411838174,
-0.1718520373,
0.2146214694,
-0.192560181,
-0.033339493,
-0.2950189114,
-0.542455256,
0.0671828017,
0.2889977098,
-0.3891126513,
-0.6133344173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04495v1
|
Multi-label and Multi-target Sampling of Machine Annotation for Computational Stance Detection
| 2023-11-08T06:54:34 | 2023-11-08T06:54:34 |
Zhengyuan Liu, Hai Leong Chieu, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data collection from manual labeling provides domain-specific and
task-aligned supervision for data-driven approaches, and a critical mass of
well-annotated resources is required to achieve reasonable performance in
natural language processing tasks. However, manual annotations are often
challenging to scale up in terms of time and budget, especially when domain
knowledge, capturing subtle semantic features, and reasoning steps are needed.
In this paper, we investigate the efficacy of leveraging large language models
on automated labeling for computational stance detection. We empirically
observe that while large language models show strong potential as an
alternative to human annotators, their sensitivity to task-specific
instructions and their intrinsic biases pose intriguing yet unique challenges
in machine annotation. We introduce a multi-label and multi-target sampling
strategy to optimize the annotation quality. Experimental results on the
benchmark stance detection corpora show that our method can significantly
improve performance and learning efficacy.
|
[
-0.7229281068,
-0.7271322012,
0.567275703,
0.1031969711,
-0.2022975385,
0.0089259017,
-0.3573474288,
-0.4266729355,
0.2569489479,
0.4937044382,
-0.5119683146,
-0.7155309319,
-0.9638721943,
0.1254449487,
-0.1449102461,
1.2596948147,
0.0333052501,
-0.1095304638,
-0.0533528849,
-0.4286821485,
-0.3236295879,
-0.7348448634,
-0.4668510854,
-0.2348524928,
0.5676349401,
0.268329829,
0.9264074564,
0.6008676291,
0.2890231311,
0.2910597026,
0.1057889163,
0.1642801911,
0.0812059566,
0.2590183914,
0.1166489273,
-0.2829916775,
-0.5324535966,
0.3360942602,
1.0356829166,
0.7389037609,
0.3716650605,
0.1655576825,
-0.1538444459,
0.3013494909,
-0.8402840495,
0.0796711966,
-0.5396628976,
-0.0307158846,
-0.4664820135,
0.2264625132,
-0.7183815837,
0.0042180913,
-0.1356083006,
-0.7198844552,
0.0604320578,
-0.0233090054,
0.8071345091,
0.4075146914,
-0.311111331,
-0.2682120502,
-0.427886188,
1.0550535917,
-0.5794573426,
0.3591578305,
0.626429975,
0.1547476649,
0.0873919874,
-0.3390105367,
-0.4770781398,
-0.5228573084,
-0.1004614905,
-0.2664265931,
-0.1291427463,
0.0313307084,
0.6081992984,
-0.1528767645,
-0.2103505135,
0.3566936255,
-0.0567746088,
-0.5252491236,
0.635180831,
-0.2855020761,
0.3783905804,
-0.3237255514,
-0.4441518486,
-0.331153363,
-0.4229891002,
-0.0137372799,
0.6027868986,
0.6438205242,
0.106053628,
0.6679913402,
-0.1076493263,
0.9375163317,
0.2473140359,
-0.1515770555,
0.3775464892,
-0.2753923833,
-0.0984605923,
0.1543504447,
1.0745620728,
0.0096863098,
0.1726462543,
0.0163657758,
-0.1399211884,
0.100590311,
0.4227299988,
-0.6743228436,
-0.2545082867,
0.4040788412,
-0.1564739347,
-0.2253258079,
-0.0860908553,
-0.7960656881,
-0.7176437378,
-0.6845279336,
0.2067393512,
-0.5109983087,
-0.2809882164,
-0.1667293757,
-0.2972272336,
0.2787985504,
0.2113381028,
-0.8855627775,
-0.0316687375,
0.8011398911,
0.7822419405,
-0.2583433688,
-0.188516885,
-0.89378649,
0.0906181484,
-0.3746528029,
0.9019027352,
-0.8519567847,
-0.2941212952,
-0.096831277,
-0.2138265669,
-0.082080707,
-0.374699384,
0.5677574873,
-0.3297432363,
-0.1700734049,
-0.2899307609,
-0.4732124507,
-0.0020129015,
0.6519908905,
-1.0204684734,
1.1770602465,
-0.1267185062,
-0.903549552,
0.7248889208,
-0.7723140121,
-0.5837755203,
0.0001963148,
-0.15748851,
-0.5129870176,
-0.1925292313,
0.3881978393,
0.741011858,
0.0222767219,
0.4094662964,
-0.6099716425,
-0.0617332384,
0.42037341,
-0.2651106417,
0.9971894622,
0.0929092318,
-0.5016320348,
0.3917487562,
-0.6045150757,
-0.1387275159,
-0.1478865594,
-0.2881405652,
-0.5751518607,
-0.1074480861,
0.0983814076,
0.4269626439,
0.0782795623,
-0.383486867,
0.4371220767,
-0.1322555393,
0.1172370389,
0.6372737885,
-0.1731298864,
0.3659991026,
0.090612933,
0.6435185671,
-0.2166655213,
-0.0881631225,
-0.1167898029,
-0.4508582354,
-0.5130881071,
-0.8446787596,
0.3699302077,
0.4564532638,
-0.6028831005,
0.48216483,
-0.0255355239,
-0.4107841849,
-0.7045450807,
0.3835756183,
0.5066372752,
0.2820693254,
0.5580638647,
-0.1912146509,
-0.4179363251,
-1.1279759407,
-0.5134554505,
-0.0710337237,
0.1626652628,
-0.076379925,
0.6024975181,
-0.1641737372,
0.9593034983,
-0.3321161866,
-0.233464703,
-0.1045558453,
0.7854575515,
-0.1708301604,
0.2482809275,
0.6811384559,
-1.016697526,
-0.3733027279,
-0.2326556295,
-0.6483131051,
-0.177914083,
-0.2446055561,
-0.2577783763,
0.3538621664,
0.6262000203,
-0.6062927246,
0.0970268548,
0.4653392136,
0.0292243343,
0.6663014293,
0.1722757071,
0.2169012874,
-0.9563211203,
0.2626573145,
0.5968468189,
-0.2054067552,
-0.8071047068,
-0.0235207248,
-0.0132543994,
0.0213609021,
-0.452627331,
0.4280602038,
-0.4229243398,
-0.0165685695,
-0.4744809568,
0.2643754184,
0.0025974254,
0.3532329798,
0.3968138099,
0.5539721251,
0.4607324004,
-0.577187717,
0.1332116872,
-0.0346203968,
0.092408821,
0.9066103697,
-0.4050532877,
0.3086032271,
-0.1985187382,
0.5714556575,
-1.3065605164,
-0.318662703,
0.4883667827,
-0.4764232039,
0.5517495275,
-0.4130365551,
-0.6969283223,
-0.3079634309,
-0.5539109111,
0.2674190104,
-0.076015465,
-0.4345114529,
0.607126534,
0.8351539969,
-0.0027692781,
-0.9035430551,
-0.5470005274,
0.1294194311,
-0.388566792,
-0.1251502931,
0.2627644241,
0.2093997598,
-0.3493166566,
-0.3897221684,
0.1364656091,
-0.0560676008,
0.0535233207,
0.4755083323,
0.2855876684,
0.1424497217,
0.2611666322,
-0.0296880268,
-0.3870360255,
0.1766855121,
-0.5032320619,
0.4115892053,
-0.0701010227,
-0.5322112441,
-0.6000313759,
0.468942225,
0.8015731573,
-0.3813622892,
0.6758515239,
1.1831579208,
-0.5704723597,
-0.1089223549,
-0.4662368894,
-0.1496436745,
-0.407795608,
0.2540122271,
-0.3154900968,
-0.6940900087,
0.0363852419,
-0.2879362702,
0.3480620086,
0.5589532852,
0.6524702907,
-0.1291320473,
1.285001874,
0.3710378408,
-0.5370087028,
0.3647053838,
-0.163603887,
0.0681691468,
-0.7921354771,
0.1323650181,
-0.9222353697,
-0.3202390373,
-0.4239557087,
-0.6366074681,
0.2959039509,
-0.1050833017,
-0.2337802798,
0.3420345187,
-0.8031758666,
-0.0060280976,
0.6029626131,
-0.1171302274,
0.1184648424,
-0.0684910789,
-0.0981606916,
-0.2158278823,
-0.2969407737,
-0.7624569535,
0.9504155517,
0.2484075874,
0.2125736326,
-0.1661189497,
0.6769574285,
0.4271580577,
0.5443894863,
-0.9885937572,
0.5808491111,
-0.0780755654,
-0.8141336441,
-0.3252077103,
-0.0822383314,
-0.7776908278,
0.3380345702,
-0.3815632463,
-0.7620689869,
-0.1001177579,
0.6071971655,
-0.1127467528,
0.3239105046,
-0.6215777993,
1.1153435707,
-0.2066409439,
-0.2903891504,
-0.0004537209,
-0.6639437079,
0.244687289,
-0.0823211148,
0.5561704636,
-0.1815276444,
0.0311206169,
0.8278055787,
-0.1623737961,
1.4092142582,
-0.5760338902,
-0.287337333,
0.5222590566,
-0.0193785559,
0.572270751,
-0.1784652323,
-0.259896785,
0.0689863116,
-0.2771867514,
-0.3172613382,
-0.1981147081,
0.4312214553,
-0.5858222246,
-0.3649708629,
-0.3533136547,
-0.5753116608,
-0.4553010166,
0.2678401768,
0.1550316811,
0.1819807738,
-0.1412450671,
0.1056579053,
0.5104728341,
-0.1598260254,
0.3000615239,
0.0534844324,
-0.023342859,
-0.3463366628,
0.9713557959,
0.0768616721,
0.241537571,
0.4451724291,
0.1942040324,
-0.5232563615,
-0.3804998696,
-0.5977408886,
0.1213346049,
-0.7775990963,
-0.0759245455,
-0.7802445292,
0.3497603536,
-0.5436551571,
-0.2582342327,
-0.5196604133,
-0.4686180949,
-0.019283209,
-0.1219972074,
0.4782358706,
0.3497753739,
-0.0398414098,
0.2430042922,
-0.5007613897,
0.6064508557,
0.1001010463,
-0.0396751091,
-0.3581093252,
-0.154139027,
0.0681888238,
0.0903167203,
-0.2240696251,
-1.1573345661,
0.1575599015,
-0.0071463687,
0.5861923099,
0.2496480942,
0.1425015181,
0.3417398036,
-0.2007148564,
0.5892620683,
0.1403125823,
-1.0401103497,
0.7360597849,
-0.4691911936,
0.405631125,
0.717055738,
0.7718531489,
-0.2943919003,
-0.5737780929,
-0.3410013914,
-0.8912286162,
0.7512833476,
-0.1326119453,
-0.0257964525,
-0.0271764379,
0.1185955852,
0.0674796924,
0.302493155,
-0.7615668178,
-0.1140529662,
-0.1935511678,
-0.3193067014,
-0.049563475,
0.2273758352,
-0.2668429017,
-0.2075416893,
0.6984930038,
-0.5961716175,
0.0757900849,
-0.1237616017,
-0.314447552,
0.1237543076,
0.4102907777,
0.4408832788,
0.2660059333,
0.1041642725,
0.2524773479,
0.1559731364,
-0.4760546982,
0.1082866862,
0.3436787426,
-0.3758171797,
0.0306390207,
0.2921702266,
0.7928386331,
0.2466840744,
-0.4711070657,
0.321480304,
0.4657071233,
-0.182117939,
-0.1732475162,
-0.0969747305,
0.1529342234,
-0.0711905062,
0.1441570669,
-0.0455410928,
0.3007857203,
-0.4404913187,
0.218669787,
0.8075494766,
-0.6950981617,
-0.0640859529,
0.4607435763,
-0.2409740984,
-0.1834784895,
0.3638696074,
-0.235633269,
-0.6792564988,
0.6830516458,
0.4463171661,
0.6099045277,
-0.1350793242,
0.4702515304,
0.4037647843,
0.2789062262,
-0.1003320366,
-0.1693030894,
-0.1294548512,
-0.6301332712,
-0.5351431966,
-0.4901473224,
-0.6503452659,
-0.1096988767,
-0.7369655967,
0.4227936864,
-0.5378075242,
-0.6086425185,
0.5979810357,
-0.1070689484,
-0.4907041788,
0.1534050405,
0.4707424045,
0.3697187603,
-0.9436801076,
0.7386733294,
1.115971446,
-0.3453927338,
-0.7205225229,
0.0457763299,
0.5217602849,
-0.523403883,
0.6701193452,
0.4331431985,
-0.4710998535,
-0.292406261,
-0.6853660941,
-0.4764060378,
0.6405102611,
0.3581946492,
-0.3003049195,
0.3964902461,
0.09022028,
0.5402249098,
-0.2293176949,
0.0664618462,
0.5759803057,
0.9684102535,
-0.0775643438,
-0.7697765827,
0.1785070002,
-0.0938939899,
-0.4375157356,
0.4599345922,
-0.5066014528,
0.6229101419,
-0.0040977872,
0.1336823106,
-0.510674715,
0.60674721,
0.752124548,
0.331119746,
0.8131520152,
0.4014001489,
0.9482103586,
0.0867095739,
1.0680648088,
-0.0868693292,
0.1286926568,
0.9415374994,
-0.487724781,
0.8866040707,
0.4671597183,
-0.0245164353,
0.3900509477,
0.519248426,
-0.0902043581,
0.0453328304,
0.230018869,
-0.2671142817,
-0.519772768,
-0.2972775698,
0.0191740561,
0.4741922915,
0.7465470433,
-0.3181495965,
-0.0551976413,
0.2197486013,
0.614307344,
0.1526474804,
-0.2377794683,
0.5961680412,
-0.1152368113,
-1.0582653284,
0.5722023249,
0.0516602844,
0.7762585282,
-0.4606221914,
-0.0592127703,
0.5051386356,
0.1205287501,
-0.0986407176,
-0.7726778388,
0.1834155917,
0.2073750198,
-0.1693897247,
-0.4160339534,
0.9145429134,
-0.2457639575,
-0.5433183312,
0.3161951303,
0.159740001,
0.0975538567,
-0.3284461796,
-0.7493466735,
0.1927771717,
-0.1984473765,
-0.2337400764,
0.5477793217,
0.2588891685,
-0.3878712356,
0.4404767156,
0.6974579096,
-0.1791794151,
0.0146261621,
0.1112658083,
0.8051707745,
-0.3545007706,
-0.255107969,
-0.9642470479,
0.4463704526,
-0.3238959014,
-0.3149195313,
0.7076959014,
0.3295463026,
0.6317058802,
0.062279921,
1.049289465,
-0.0705979839,
0.2817028463,
-0.3871487975,
0.5046818852,
-0.3788732886,
-0.1580613703,
-0.5118970275,
-0.7129463553,
-0.7479979396,
0.7592821717,
-0.5430571437,
0.141049698,
0.4867828786,
0.5929024816,
-0.0620244965,
-0.0395007581,
-0.1049859151,
-0.065070115,
0.388130933,
0.362511456,
0.5536884069,
-0.0122962575,
0.526127696,
-0.2212974429,
-0.2120533735,
-0.2500299811,
-1.2073824406,
-1.0589346886,
-0.6188451052,
-0.7604112029,
-0.2664782703,
-0.0974196568,
1.1360044479,
1.0867234468,
-0.901619792,
0.0338117145,
0.2347089946,
0.0032336803,
-0.421118319,
-0.1885323822,
0.4966821671,
-0.6085711122,
-0.8234315515,
0.4195754826,
0.1498736441,
-0.223226577,
-0.3177952468,
0.1332013905,
-0.6460370421,
-0.0747963339,
0.6228702068,
0.5415272117,
-0.7356483936,
-0.3268260658,
-0.0561781786,
-0.2915281057,
-0.0127378982,
0.922377646,
-0.6329321265,
0.474070996,
0.2965034246,
0.8196033835,
0.4463227987,
0.3068158925,
0.3860889971,
-1.1829441786,
0.1803187281,
0.2541234195,
0.3228954971,
0.491940558,
-0.3078698814,
0.2408859879,
0.1300614476,
-0.2737492919,
-0.7571102977,
0.1513795704,
-1.1026682854,
-0.4278048873,
1.3270499706,
-0.1242202818,
-0.1480823755,
-0.4034671187,
-0.467566371,
0.4523520768,
-0.3962782323,
0.4984914958,
0.890930891,
-0.2032919824,
0.0481574312,
-0.8882033229,
0.4876827002,
0.430978179,
-0.8331648707,
0.3356231451,
0.8601885438,
-0.0334720537,
0.6311940551,
0.7030210495,
-0.0161490049,
0.1026455015,
-0.0937686712,
0.2520447969,
0.0831926018,
-0.5455106497,
-0.2000283599,
0.486371398,
0.2351447195,
-0.3355501294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04480v1
|
CLearViD: Curriculum Learning for Video Description
| 2023-11-08T06:20:32 | 2023-11-08T06:20:32 |
Cheng-Yu Chuang, Pooyan Fazli
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Video description entails automatically generating coherent natural language
sentences that narrate the content of a given video. We introduce CLearViD, a
transformer-based model for video description generation that leverages
curriculum learning to accomplish this task. In particular, we investigate two
curriculum strategies: (1) progressively exposing the model to more challenging
samples by gradually applying a Gaussian noise to the video data, and (2)
gradually reducing the capacity of the network through dropout during the
training process. These methods enable the model to learn more robust and
generalizable features. Moreover, CLearViD leverages the Mish activation
function, which provides non-linearity and non-monotonicity and helps alleviate
the issue of vanishing gradients. Our extensive experiments and ablation
studies demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model. The results on two
datasets, namely ActivityNet Captions and YouCook2, show that CLearViD
significantly outperforms existing state-of-the-art models in terms of both
accuracy and diversity metrics.
|
[
-0.4305556417,
-0.5940926671,
-0.1096737981,
-0.1184155867,
-0.2699385285,
-0.330108583,
-0.2988323867,
-0.0177519619,
-0.1184740961,
0.7295834422,
-0.6059447527,
-0.4975693226,
-0.5241293311,
-0.2765288949,
-0.9777894616,
1.4784166813,
-0.0164889675,
-0.1037750095,
-0.2498479635,
0.0230010357,
-0.7352645397,
0.1852716953,
-0.5241768956,
-0.1865117997,
-0.0829725936,
0.5890033245,
0.7020791769,
0.8463720083,
0.5471907854,
0.1879294962,
0.1450321823,
0.2041718066,
-0.6719110012,
0.2478111237,
-0.2143659145,
-0.3101051748,
0.0628607199,
-0.1664473861,
0.496347934,
0.6895756125,
-0.233213827,
0.5189776421,
0.0771945044,
0.3631345928,
-0.9760973454,
0.2266267389,
-0.4912354052,
0.3047735393,
0.1666089445,
0.0371728353,
-0.4866054356,
-0.2434512228,
0.5126951933,
-0.6261432171,
1.0092540979,
-0.317696631,
0.9955596328,
0.4078942239,
-0.2689385712,
-0.1271677017,
-1.3171938658,
0.9077529311,
-0.2799260616,
0.3364081085,
0.4324326515,
0.6180630326,
0.3317351639,
-0.892085135,
-0.4412661195,
0.1934703439,
0.2334248126,
0.251208812,
-0.2389700264,
0.2847652137,
0.1825274229,
0.8473907113,
-0.4362677932,
-0.0884712413,
-1.1380991936,
-0.113256596,
0.4514709115,
0.3689738214,
0.277051121,
-0.2723331749,
-0.404892385,
-0.1735537052,
-0.4043023884,
0.3454868197,
0.1676196158,
0.1187115684,
-0.4140500426,
0.5701458454,
-0.1959073842,
0.4856385887,
-0.1153639704,
-0.3019073904,
0.0281482339,
-0.2633730173,
-0.836838007,
0.0125945993,
0.4332598746,
0.5739779472,
0.1737059802,
0.2481227666,
-0.0758166462,
0.1440475285,
0.5352047682,
-0.9676687717,
-0.7267584205,
-0.0396414883,
-0.574889183,
-0.2395057827,
0.2418386042,
-0.7863844633,
-0.1710420251,
-0.4603529274,
0.4546969235,
-0.5555080175,
-0.1885075569,
0.4221100211,
-0.0746430531,
0.4065753818,
0.3636757433,
-1.130813241,
0.5338458419,
0.356511116,
0.6503263712,
0.0041842493,
0.0177561995,
-0.6428889036,
0.2228821069,
-0.1381783634,
0.3676945567,
-0.5700942874,
-0.1527120471,
0.3934457898,
-0.1382244974,
0.2062762827,
-0.3689488769,
0.3288557231,
-0.2609204054,
0.434931159,
0.2141046971,
-0.3386207223,
-0.7008898258,
0.1744883358,
-1.0232183933,
0.8064543605,
-0.012056401,
-0.4323186576,
0.4693702161,
-0.6715453267,
-0.4221075177,
-0.0178469568,
-0.2062172443,
-0.6941795945,
0.136472553,
0.3426636159,
0.6198372841,
-0.1327269673,
0.4693389535,
0.3935118318,
-0.3239704967,
0.0111871213,
-0.7619105577,
0.3335172534,
0.4631584585,
-0.3379499912,
-0.0424922258,
-0.7426646352,
-0.2895216644,
-0.3176897168,
0.0498610139,
0.1390181929,
0.0426911116,
-0.0806164294,
0.0751184076,
-0.3283297718,
-0.2374573052,
-0.1390693635,
-0.378601402,
0.4279869497,
0.4335393906,
0.1033485979,
0.4475801587,
-0.3847335875,
0.908593595,
0.0776917115,
0.3983350098,
-0.8754689693,
-0.3927914798,
-0.7342957854,
-0.6471540928,
-0.1052736118,
0.3211031258,
-0.6539084315,
-0.1935952306,
-0.2078110874,
-0.0989202335,
-0.6389318109,
0.3710852861,
0.5434449315,
0.677542448,
0.7852093577,
-0.5833565593,
-0.6305814385,
-0.8948860168,
0.5207572579,
-0.0400486067,
-0.2202981114,
0.1026239991,
0.352083236,
-0.0715158135,
0.9092450142,
-0.6842502356,
-0.5871903896,
-0.5072821975,
0.1050211936,
0.0870777443,
0.1606181115,
0.127369687,
-0.9858316779,
-0.2149947733,
-0.1750156581,
-0.7332026958,
0.2432627231,
-0.4547964036,
0.3839191198,
-0.2958157659,
0.3263662755,
-0.3664466143,
0.7591792345,
0.3810909092,
0.163199082,
0.4419618249,
-0.3245921433,
0.0986640379,
-1.0408550501,
-0.2073854059,
0.1358508319,
0.019159358,
-0.7833055258,
-0.0796028897,
-0.2920533121,
-0.2918993533,
-0.9238660336,
0.0926222727,
-0.1882840544,
0.0822879151,
-0.1941992044,
-0.0176412947,
0.3750534654,
0.447691828,
0.0988927707,
0.4339956641,
0.8321686983,
-0.7113927603,
0.5144716501,
0.5798446536,
-0.2701640129,
0.4674420059,
-0.4305103123,
-0.6023436785,
-0.5511907339,
0.117968522,
-1.1229034662,
-0.5541781187,
-0.0535616055,
-0.3237652779,
0.1937326938,
-0.1459539235,
-0.1032297984,
-0.2928613126,
-0.3584979475,
0.6147820354,
0.6462855339,
-0.544695735,
0.3606531918,
0.1456556469,
0.2637882233,
-0.6242492795,
-0.7197522521,
-0.0381221324,
-0.363615334,
-0.5658860207,
0.3971076608,
0.1725317836,
0.0357720293,
0.0241488218,
-0.2085428238,
-0.5233637691,
-0.0854302645,
0.5336654782,
0.3095676601,
-0.2533121109,
0.3839253485,
0.1074028388,
0.1975272149,
0.0211088676,
-0.3770399392,
0.2623836994,
-0.1952397972,
-0.2505788207,
-0.6403726935,
0.3873950839,
0.2560426593,
-0.4808168709,
0.3922329843,
0.7794635296,
-0.4905046523,
-0.5804102421,
-0.3406630456,
-0.2022813708,
-0.4867024124,
0.6553885341,
-0.0095685693,
-0.8593695164,
0.2315351516,
0.1451919675,
0.2578591406,
0.1570038795,
0.3456792235,
-0.0874181688,
0.5470626354,
0.8435503244,
0.4001707435,
0.5870138407,
-0.7205836773,
0.110806331,
-0.6016964316,
-0.6015194654,
-0.0388658009,
-0.2278641462,
-0.3782288134,
-0.4560105801,
0.1454515159,
0.1240347922,
-0.5904370546,
0.3423305452,
-0.7190914154,
0.7224665284,
0.5422806144,
0.0685413927,
0.181029886,
0.2818330824,
0.1653114855,
-0.483080864,
-0.5756171346,
-0.4672701061,
1.1827778816,
0.3845565915,
0.9985527992,
0.2060702294,
0.5630805492,
0.441596657,
0.1559445113,
-0.5975368023,
0.5129908919,
-0.5826510191,
-0.3287357092,
-0.2670327723,
0.0188528914,
-0.9360187054,
-0.1186904311,
-0.4322687387,
-0.3367679119,
-0.2499589622,
0.2658142447,
-0.5304293633,
0.5091062188,
-0.4430691302,
0.7326880097,
-0.068580091,
-0.4146833122,
-0.0130115775,
-0.7980803847,
0.4368929267,
0.1973983198,
0.2529800236,
0.268966049,
0.3284627795,
0.4005092382,
-0.1891709417,
1.083973527,
0.0811324194,
0.1847426146,
0.8078722954,
0.1377280354,
-0.1595709175,
0.1054600179,
0.2983532548,
-0.3068433404,
-0.2887552083,
-0.1670347303,
-0.5501893759,
0.2541908324,
-0.7368447185,
-0.3720351756,
0.2210165858,
-0.4708072245,
0.3301433325,
0.0968174338,
0.3273966312,
0.5871165991,
-0.3022554219,
0.3180206418,
1.2186917067,
-0.3980024457,
0.4504189789,
0.0166683123,
-0.163205266,
-0.6168727279,
0.9190873504,
-0.231645152,
0.4703761637,
0.574477911,
-0.029078519,
-0.080677554,
-0.4690214992,
-0.1272668839,
-0.1962430775,
-0.9020615816,
-0.327342093,
-0.3695538342,
-0.4940286875,
-0.1889899671,
-0.3713718653,
-0.3865937591,
-0.3387309015,
-0.4756317139,
-0.5717019439,
0.0513503067,
0.6354111433,
0.1078450158,
0.6315225959,
-0.5698375702,
0.5375654101,
0.4871307015,
0.3939791322,
-0.2891674042,
-0.7163037062,
-0.3509648144,
0.1421647966,
-0.8936080337,
-0.6616347432,
0.6020293236,
0.6498799324,
0.4185665846,
0.8308006525,
-0.0860775486,
0.6123433113,
-0.415363282,
1.1683915854,
0.6024006009,
-0.9147506356,
0.8161655068,
-0.1491169631,
0.2577208877,
0.4429859817,
0.2281371206,
-0.4057804942,
-0.4674224854,
-0.5501074195,
-0.8919441104,
0.3574530184,
0.2423846871,
0.6839421988,
-0.1344161928,
0.3716960251,
0.2631345093,
0.2725398242,
-0.7887028456,
-0.184909761,
-0.8857591748,
-0.3244256079,
0.2512688935,
-0.0625516325,
-0.1303040385,
-0.1271227002,
0.3976503015,
-0.0835025907,
0.1170072481,
0.1004731283,
-0.2101200968,
0.0157438256,
0.4144369066,
0.8014630675,
0.196994409,
-0.1164731905,
0.3032441437,
0.179773286,
-0.6734257936,
0.0215223599,
-0.3021571338,
-0.2491763681,
0.2237107158,
0.445201546,
0.9819612503,
0.3299752176,
-0.7422201633,
0.775734961,
0.2214266062,
-0.5420729518,
-0.3682819605,
0.3624385893,
-0.4009172618,
0.1858553886,
0.1963024735,
0.2062574625,
0.3834251463,
-0.2330069542,
0.483265847,
0.2439357936,
-0.628495574,
-0.2722766101,
1.1701005697,
0.191740647,
-0.2134353369,
0.8151776195,
-0.0304488875,
-0.1361098737,
0.7500374913,
0.4941726625,
0.9194993377,
-0.1173398793,
0.7257627249,
0.3727919459,
0.3496702909,
-0.4730348587,
-0.0315233618,
-0.1151557639,
-0.444099009,
-0.6715690494,
-0.498247385,
-0.4630954564,
0.213873595,
-1.0236419439,
0.7590864301,
-0.3811733425,
0.0618882887,
0.004430403,
-0.3028431833,
-0.74203825,
0.6126686931,
0.5923519731,
0.6494675875,
-1.0947531462,
0.57472229,
0.5351390243,
-0.8723127842,
-0.8704165816,
-0.3428925872,
-0.1446891576,
-0.2111643255,
0.7066522241,
0.483097434,
-0.0068044434,
-0.3552045524,
-0.6306787133,
-0.584056139,
1.3885037899,
0.580786407,
-0.1805336475,
-0.2659237087,
0.3905199766,
0.5999046564,
-0.60529387,
0.2737007737,
0.0357813239,
-0.0636332929,
0.5721236467,
-0.6089799404,
-0.3709004223,
-0.0418244936,
-0.009697577,
0.0799231082,
-0.273765564,
0.875172317,
-0.5525229573,
-0.3253350854,
-0.1713814288,
0.9499045014,
-0.246479556,
0.4687456787,
0.0913972482,
0.4260413349,
0.6402307153,
0.1634901166,
0.6900372505,
0.1528638452,
0.4873782992,
1.3477635384,
0.1640810966,
0.479115814,
0.3608800471,
0.0728186145,
0.5873382688,
0.1667905301,
-0.6460788846,
0.6204135418,
0.3844576478,
-0.4094182551,
-0.3119584918,
-0.0088822609,
-0.0101539753,
0.5847005844,
0.3432982266,
-0.6247316599,
-0.4516013265,
0.4498840868,
-0.1874361038,
0.5772522688,
-0.6796078086,
0.4992581606,
-0.0454874784,
-0.6555868983,
0.4038876891,
-0.069899641,
0.3408275545,
-0.3759430349,
-0.2966967821,
-0.1837680191,
0.0927201733,
-0.5150621533,
-0.7347069383,
0.5766952634,
0.1079942361,
-0.4265173674,
-0.320137769,
0.329844296,
-0.7970070243,
-0.3607056737,
-0.2520839274,
0.0890155137,
0.0556137264,
0.4839545786,
-0.2185374945,
-0.2489583641,
0.0828427151,
0.2668406069,
-0.0994554833,
0.1580172181,
-0.335957855,
0.8643549681,
0.3484742939,
-0.1501193792,
0.2326567173,
0.0389892906,
0.7452446818,
-0.3608611226,
-0.3238811791,
-0.9174519181,
0.7813498974,
0.1025559232,
-0.1704934686,
0.4149265289,
0.6946684718,
1.0340988636,
-0.2563994229,
0.8806002736,
0.1208332852,
-0.1222438216,
-0.4423294663,
0.3709219694,
-0.1372631937,
0.4653518796,
-0.0958053991,
-0.64634794,
-0.6174961329,
0.4728741348,
-0.0073397313,
-0.1972412169,
0.6006001234,
0.5765863657,
-0.4048859179,
0.2518366575,
0.3635900021,
-0.21515356,
0.5737053752,
0.7211689949,
0.6670930982,
-0.5701850653,
1.0299116373,
-0.3530227542,
-0.1032643244,
-0.0191819519,
-0.8038194776,
-1.1401032209,
-0.4787420034,
-0.671056807,
-0.3161930442,
-0.0135839246,
0.669271946,
0.8518052697,
-0.6893293858,
-0.2582915723,
-0.0952918157,
0.1170558631,
-0.4137745798,
-0.2101686001,
0.2828018069,
-0.3013804853,
-0.5921621323,
0.0055631297,
0.2974538505,
-0.1066092104,
-0.3284930289,
-0.0251430701,
0.0849820673,
0.2368093729,
0.4306977391,
0.3300248981,
-0.5675516129,
-0.3635964096,
0.1441905349,
-0.0110725313,
0.1722042263,
0.7921956182,
-0.6496236324,
0.7789930105,
0.2023697644,
0.4969016612,
0.8220754266,
0.0853346139,
0.3963392973,
-1.006613493,
0.0598097667,
0.0290795248,
0.0918289796,
0.4786909819,
-0.2287045866,
0.3146448135,
-0.077622354,
-0.2847259343,
-0.7172884941,
0.5019893646,
-1.0243586302,
0.0688702166,
1.0370405912,
-0.2285709679,
0.0992518589,
-0.1058639362,
-0.1507958919,
0.4302658737,
-0.0678609237,
0.8210839629,
0.3220458627,
0.1859008521,
-0.4142915905,
-0.9387416244,
0.4352070093,
0.2347783893,
-0.4140686393,
-0.1270626336,
0.649274826,
0.4061392546,
-0.0080272676,
0.1998947412,
-0.0789298862,
0.6883246899,
-0.1953049451,
0.2030574828,
-0.4527958632,
-0.558870852,
-0.4499254227,
0.5249915123,
-0.3458806574,
-0.545755446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04479v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04479v1
|
Twitter Sentiment Analysis of Covid Vacciness
| 2023-11-08T06:16:04 | 2023-11-08T06:16:04 |
Wenbo Zhu, Tiechuan Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
In this paper, we look at a database of tweets sorted by various keywords
that could indicate the users sentiment towards covid vaccines. With social
media becoming such a prevalent source of opinion, sorting and ranking tweets
that hold important information such as opinions on covid vaccines is of utmost
importance. Two different ranking scales were used, and ranking a tweet in this
way could represent the difference between an opinion being lost and an opinion
being featured on the site, which affects the decisions and behavior of people,
and why researchers were interested in it. Using natural language processing
techniques, our aim is to determine and categorize opinions about covid
vaccines with the highest accuracy possible.
|
[
-0.2191880792,
-0.7569332719,
0.1678563058,
0.2170068324,
-0.5000821948,
0.5930874348,
0.0406396762,
-0.6312137842,
0.6270894408,
-0.0806768835,
-0.2329463661,
-0.8708655834,
-0.831225872,
0.1255963743,
-0.2790055871,
0.9071882963,
0.4562906921,
0.2017110437,
0.0501687415,
-0.1361863017,
0.1191249564,
-0.3705241382,
-1.0519402027,
-0.376696378,
0.6716371179,
0.6606844068,
0.7237003446,
-0.1336181611,
0.7566977143,
0.2365761548,
-0.3610911667,
-0.1434941143,
-0.6203523278,
-0.0183699243,
-0.3518874645,
-0.1872507036,
-0.4082084298,
0.248484984,
0.0228582155,
0.2036785185,
-0.1221641302,
0.4711696506,
-0.0902979523,
0.3715396523,
-0.2832213938,
-0.2861110568,
-0.4990925193,
0.069636941,
-0.2781180739,
-0.4915156066,
-0.1686269194,
-0.5582520962,
0.3082164526,
-0.1552250385,
0.3922353089,
-0.0460545793,
0.7947202921,
-0.2801399231,
-0.4183914363,
0.0015042512,
-0.4403628111,
0.8205625415,
-0.7014356256,
-0.0737061203,
0.2531856596,
0.3777281344,
-0.0116093233,
-0.4856185019,
-0.458254993,
0.204425171,
0.2317207605,
0.1511929631,
-0.5023943186,
0.1643498242,
-0.0689165145,
0.5647320747,
-0.7582341433,
-0.1309887171,
-0.4931257069,
-0.0806582421,
0.8048668504,
-0.0675646588,
0.7236382365,
-0.4786781967,
-0.1108855158,
0.0901234969,
-0.2846562266,
0.4093493521,
0.0008862671,
-0.0929948911,
-0.1536532342,
0.6130639911,
-0.3139922321,
0.5405865312,
0.3198870718,
-0.1853042692,
0.4161485434,
-0.31390661,
-0.6136758327,
0.0307305902,
1.0013287067,
0.8400221467,
0.0816001371,
-0.026069859,
0.0134738004,
-0.0673052669,
0.511623621,
-0.9213883281,
-0.2107275873,
0.498714745,
-0.8891845942,
-0.76417768,
0.0026015758,
-0.9086477757,
-0.6162105203,
0.2464576215,
0.4369322062,
-0.2821799517,
-0.3000712395,
0.1838621199,
-0.8295180202,
0.3447408676,
0.4544625878,
-0.7191605568,
0.1407901943,
0.8434839249,
0.7591718435,
-0.1131503135,
0.4926288724,
-0.1849787384,
-0.0522828475,
-0.382304132,
1.055292964,
-0.7396141291,
-0.4287080467,
0.1276011169,
-0.2124211043,
0.0534589067,
-0.3894477487,
0.469137162,
-0.5065286756,
0.0022483976,
-0.4779684544,
-0.5623700023,
-0.1967786551,
0.5516460538,
-0.2071056068,
0.6197965741,
0.0200799219,
-1.1723380089,
0.699300766,
-0.6390560865,
-0.5318062305,
0.3081023097,
-0.1916435808,
-0.4614664614,
0.1747155488,
0.4031254053,
0.7046481371,
-0.4039239883,
0.2724352479,
-0.6363646388,
0.0132589685,
0.1459207237,
0.2099803835,
1.1705874205,
0.2243580669,
-0.0780198947,
0.1857892126,
-0.381809622,
-0.0020806091,
-0.0268357508,
0.0382413194,
-0.43238011,
0.0398909487,
0.147244975,
0.188026607,
-0.0257732049,
-0.8212411404,
0.4423689842,
-0.7008987665,
0.5150757432,
0.2111889273,
1.1373773813,
0.3793036342,
-0.345386982,
0.8320531249,
0.0249567293,
0.7651227713,
0.7049709558,
-1.0165880919,
-0.4218254685,
-0.0338205546,
-0.1104645953,
0.5833878517,
-0.5249764323,
0.1721159667,
-0.1770384312,
-0.7321905494,
-0.5634059906,
-0.0705461502,
0.0127701415,
0.3233373463,
0.2997738719,
-0.0314379632,
-0.665571928,
-0.8908803463,
-0.5562297702,
-0.4939437211,
0.3646189272,
-0.2135804296,
0.5760201216,
-0.1680365056,
0.6334694624,
-0.5588765144,
-0.0537758209,
-0.3265278935,
0.5323268771,
0.2531535029,
0.0374630913,
0.8008345962,
-0.9051244855,
-0.5259340405,
0.2121740431,
-0.3854897022,
-0.1298684329,
0.3422447443,
0.0746777877,
-0.0808349326,
0.3811789453,
-0.3334799409,
0.7840030193,
0.4035602212,
-0.1825452,
0.0614973195,
0.3236997128,
0.6029338837,
-1.4335337877,
-0.051425308,
0.2835608423,
-0.1566503197,
-0.7721577287,
-0.0362905338,
-0.2609598935,
0.1197221652,
-0.6163121462,
0.4307964146,
0.2210721374,
0.2516258359,
-0.0102509661,
-0.3227184117,
0.3106715679,
-0.2952846885,
-0.2227540612,
0.6675839424,
0.5987824798,
-0.3261900246,
0.5109770894,
0.1357530057,
-0.3233621716,
0.3432843387,
-0.5222753882,
-0.2101444304,
-0.0050123725,
0.0667879581,
-1.0928497314,
-0.2207292616,
0.4961870313,
-1.1197166443,
-0.1213487014,
0.0329057425,
-0.3599065542,
-0.5913348198,
-0.6874852777,
0.0688973293,
0.3484553397,
-0.0634871051,
0.2507963181,
0.8257459402,
-0.0108063966,
-0.5177170038,
-0.6250475645,
0.1604228765,
-0.4053867161,
-0.5600975752,
0.4881053269,
0.0342391282,
-0.7551864386,
0.1197503805,
-0.1288187951,
-0.3309614062,
-0.0249771811,
0.1634903848,
-0.138789162,
-0.0013353828,
0.3092778027,
0.0906379148,
0.1328795403,
-0.165667221,
-0.0325938426,
0.3808422983,
-0.0735312924,
0.0772922039,
-0.4329048693,
0.4758998752,
0.5602580905,
0.0203567389,
0.8963749409,
0.8674172759,
-0.6814928055,
0.12102025,
-0.5883027315,
0.1574820429,
-0.4172357023,
-0.0533233881,
0.1143975556,
-0.7747128606,
0.3674577773,
0.2982409298,
-0.169252038,
0.8129368424,
0.6817709208,
-0.4997984767,
1.0421171188,
0.4465195835,
-0.5345371366,
0.3526042402,
-0.217389524,
0.4805702865,
-0.2354498506,
-0.3957692385,
-0.7073625922,
-0.2133546174,
-0.6061677337,
-0.2298557609,
0.3526863456,
-0.0387462415,
-0.1216583028,
0.155409649,
-0.8205737472,
0.2225777656,
0.5256608725,
0.3152131736,
-0.0655707046,
0.1514823437,
-0.086464338,
0.0945138261,
-0.5693659782,
-0.4216294885,
0.714069128,
0.2014573216,
0.4925455749,
0.0438491553,
0.8204607964,
0.7495015264,
0.2656778991,
-1.060736537,
0.534804523,
-0.4136140347,
-0.6065508723,
-0.3515376151,
-0.109968923,
-1.1153591871,
-0.3213717639,
-0.309766382,
-0.9232208133,
0.3562951088,
-0.2655844986,
-0.5930826664,
0.1837521642,
-0.7596922517,
0.7896001935,
0.1597576141,
-0.1710004508,
-0.6362487078,
-0.505384624,
0.134610787,
0.2687882483,
0.0422281213,
-0.26769045,
0.1306660771,
0.9441876411,
-0.6869487762,
0.6511493921,
-0.0675309673,
0.281295687,
0.4051613808,
-0.299126476,
-0.383159548,
0.4647479355,
-0.4092826843,
0.2698920369,
0.1502541155,
-0.5060144067,
-0.0144806737,
0.713049829,
-0.9793678522,
-0.755422473,
-0.8499279022,
0.1354485899,
-0.0703471228,
-0.0189843345,
0.5737488866,
0.3641431034,
-0.3903693557,
0.1556791216,
0.3562962413,
-0.516630888,
0.5023420453,
0.1919592917,
-0.1669158489,
-0.7048367262,
0.5016072989,
0.2173041254,
-0.1044916511,
0.8036334515,
0.5798906684,
-0.1099764407,
-0.5787640214,
-0.0976432934,
0.0534361899,
-0.493476361,
-0.5163676739,
-0.7269026637,
-0.2393175215,
-0.8858116865,
-0.2555968165,
0.0847552642,
-0.3539578617,
-0.3506598771,
-0.329105407,
0.8329039216,
1.0011454821,
-0.1192138046,
0.4368588328,
-0.8353869319,
0.7240655422,
0.4296791553,
0.3168989122,
-0.2422424853,
-0.16255413,
-0.2532573044,
-0.1744968146,
-0.5888847709,
-1.0197731256,
0.6775014997,
0.025712138,
0.2416077405,
0.8608472943,
0.0249742214,
0.8484332561,
0.0294241775,
1.0905115604,
0.3190639317,
-0.8902624249,
0.9316394329,
-0.5512055755,
0.285523057,
0.6155074239,
0.4331355691,
-0.7411074042,
-0.5486611128,
-0.9038818479,
-0.5991948843,
0.5442305207,
0.1656281352,
-0.4803402722,
-0.2475650758,
0.3213964403,
-0.0034040438,
0.1261389107,
-0.0981976464,
-0.2953805625,
-0.1197516918,
-0.0062883282,
-0.1603284031,
-0.5379467607,
-0.1531721503,
-0.7176044583,
0.5462287664,
0.5420371294,
0.3233777881,
0.1309522688,
0.0775578991,
-0.4106170833,
0.2859120071,
0.4905816615,
0.8405607343,
-0.5571889281,
0.1583549231,
-0.0584140383,
-0.5941866636,
0.0757591873,
-0.2090063542,
0.0225154161,
0.1856587678,
0.4236810803,
0.4230614603,
-0.2429525256,
-0.244762376,
0.7949695587,
-0.248155117,
-0.0509336181,
-0.1862653047,
0.0410977118,
0.1879083514,
0.1482658237,
0.5549840927,
0.5683665872,
0.5678299069,
-0.5883518457,
0.4075931311,
0.4651651978,
-0.4424980283,
-0.6183854938,
0.3847264051,
0.2385933697,
-0.3841569424,
0.3687722385,
0.0392182395,
-0.4748185873,
0.8369551301,
0.0451369211,
1.1319431067,
-0.7383113503,
0.6584596634,
0.5740534663,
0.3144302964,
-0.0728689134,
0.4403541088,
0.4049240649,
-0.5968906283,
-0.2893150747,
-0.5987070203,
-0.4662195742,
0.1662965864,
-0.7899456024,
0.4883395433,
-0.4549680054,
-0.8343987465,
0.463645488,
0.1236861274,
-0.5833250284,
0.6447169185,
0.0315908641,
0.9962100983,
-1.1456449032,
0.7906635404,
0.9209421873,
-0.5936978459,
-0.5948875546,
0.522660017,
-0.0970826522,
-0.715346694,
0.5111162663,
0.2164544463,
-0.0289764144,
-0.3071556985,
-0.8186233044,
-0.3896348178,
0.9767555594,
0.0110414047,
0.0515766777,
0.3002801538,
0.0586405545,
0.8289453387,
-0.3697730005,
0.3449498415,
0.3869726658,
0.2248070985,
0.2214883119,
-0.7654345632,
-0.3905687332,
-0.5883578658,
-0.1553124338,
-0.0422610044,
-0.4812858999,
0.4138569236,
-0.0408993661,
-0.1881410927,
-0.4700135291,
0.4160996079,
-0.0142858922,
0.9302441478,
0.296298027,
0.4033370912,
0.5910941362,
0.1412561238,
1.2002806664,
-0.1191530749,
0.4213814437,
0.5585820675,
0.1348921955,
0.9927123189,
0.7350037694,
-0.298638314,
0.2304952741,
0.8455670476,
0.2991394997,
0.5385553837,
0.0647866875,
-0.2490689903,
-0.4111084342,
-0.3621286154,
-0.4566879272,
0.2210295349,
0.7047186494,
-0.2338397652,
-0.0931753889,
0.2115734369,
-0.0082723675,
-0.1446458697,
-0.4867058396,
0.9010158181,
0.1209880859,
-0.4462919235,
0.4022105634,
0.0744836926,
0.3469371796,
-0.1085600182,
-0.052821178,
0.0721290857,
0.025208598,
-0.4177033007,
-1.1415635347,
0.686642766,
0.0536325015,
-0.2231202126,
-0.3441194594,
1.0021724701,
0.1018640622,
-0.5148243308,
0.3602086008,
0.5739533305,
0.0126513643,
-0.0965810493,
-0.9433485866,
0.0558615699,
-0.0440388173,
-0.5137199759,
0.0755751431,
0.294870615,
-0.0170109905,
0.6644420624,
0.3200281858,
0.3080469668,
-0.0421369635,
0.2160329968,
0.539603889,
-0.7761566639,
-0.2356843501,
-1.0996108055,
0.2701376975,
-0.6425523162,
-0.2381302863,
0.7655028701,
0.6622562408,
0.3557100296,
-0.1428747624,
0.9637305737,
-0.1879201084,
0.7864055634,
0.1145395935,
0.9130992889,
-0.5506697297,
0.1158437952,
-0.2336905897,
-0.2482759058,
-0.7841998935,
0.659938395,
-0.5831738114,
-0.2174510658,
0.8088700771,
0.6764640212,
0.2562510073,
0.0438810661,
0.2369299382,
0.3764649928,
0.3100689054,
0.0246731527,
0.6012665033,
-0.4932259023,
0.1917929053,
-0.350558877,
-0.1038528085,
-0.716866076,
-0.7420189977,
-1.064360857,
-0.5084815025,
-0.5467613935,
-0.7181414962,
0.2157068849,
1.4074730873,
0.3932181895,
-1.3121236563,
-0.156937331,
0.0230040327,
0.2504791915,
-0.2880690396,
-0.2838905752,
0.5150637031,
-0.1244302094,
-0.5359351039,
-0.0388728306,
0.679990232,
-0.1652297974,
0.1673389375,
0.3689150214,
-0.4418962598,
0.213814795,
0.7658488154,
0.1576328874,
-0.6662656665,
-0.4678955078,
0.204909116,
-0.5847691298,
0.2583870292,
0.4648883641,
-0.6199322939,
0.6055998802,
1.1954518557,
0.2498669922,
0.32217291,
0.0601848029,
0.5611205697,
-0.4096452296,
-0.2540154457,
0.3372126222,
0.147571519,
0.3021006882,
-0.3347584605,
0.2595390975,
0.2958301306,
-0.4235013723,
-0.4589170814,
-0.0618902259,
-1.5899194479,
-0.0256013051,
1.4638994932,
0.1838043481,
-0.2544063628,
-0.4257813096,
-0.3335150778,
0.4561953247,
-0.897918582,
0.9228000045,
0.6195562482,
-0.1897500604,
-0.2532432377,
-0.471374929,
0.5930006504,
-0.1291767508,
-0.6972410083,
-0.7708030343,
-0.2848148346,
0.1524224132,
-0.2161225826,
1.1146113873,
0.0307086911,
0.1631515771,
-0.3709324598,
0.0856002942,
0.4936469495,
0.2490156293,
-0.3436381519,
0.4486596584,
0.1272132099,
-0.501501441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04467v1
|
RDGCN: Reinforced Dependency Graph Convolutional Network for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2023-11-08T05:37:49 | 2023-11-08T05:37:49 |
Xusheng Zhao, Hao Peng, Qiong Dai, Xu Bai, Huailiang Peng, Yanbing Liu, Qinglang Guo, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) is dedicated to forecasting the
sentiment polarity of aspect terms within sentences. Employing graph neural
networks to capture structural patterns from syntactic dependency parsing has
been confirmed as an effective approach for boosting ABSA. In most works, the
topology of dependency trees or dependency-based attention coefficients is
often loosely regarded as edges between aspects and opinions, which can result
in insufficient and ambiguous syntactic utilization. To address these problems,
we propose a new reinforced dependency graph convolutional network (RDGCN) that
improves the importance calculation of dependencies in both distance and type
views. Initially, we propose an importance calculation criterion for the
minimum distances over dependency trees. Under the criterion, we design a
distance-importance function that leverages reinforcement learning for weight
distribution search and dissimilarity control. Since dependency types often do
not have explicit syntax like tree distances, we use global attention and mask
mechanisms to design type-importance functions. Finally, we merge these weights
and implement feature aggregation and classification. Comprehensive experiments
on three popular datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the criterion and
importance functions. RDGCN outperforms state-of-the-art GNN-based baselines in
all validations.
|
[
-0.6733420491,
-0.7681410313,
0.3564325273,
0.473084867,
-0.4218153059,
-0.1569959372,
-0.0433970615,
-0.4124292731,
0.7096527815,
0.2665085196,
-0.502948463,
-0.6597895622,
-0.8551791906,
0.1375401169,
-0.0619275346,
1.1744743586,
0.0851095468,
0.0337750874,
-0.4152055979,
-0.4805240333,
-0.2391709089,
-0.5353385806,
-0.4560014606,
-0.2919210196,
1.0365695953,
0.1247133017,
0.628942728,
0.2022761256,
0.6240574718,
0.3225611746,
-0.4395398796,
0.3073426187,
-0.2698487639,
0.0451630913,
-0.1802601218,
-0.0136135872,
-0.5094993711,
-0.1687773317,
0.3066240847,
0.8665725589,
0.162716791,
0.0281141922,
0.3299882412,
0.971868515,
-0.6179727912,
0.758470118,
-0.2521455288,
0.1421694309,
-0.0282365959,
-0.0079172663,
-0.1325509548,
-0.3486076593,
0.2531347871,
-0.2720212936,
0.1729952842,
-0.1463863552,
0.9950954914,
0.1873897761,
-0.3295328021,
0.0987395123,
-0.3110364676,
0.5752215385,
-0.6291006207,
0.1438157111,
0.0691034868,
-0.0466420949,
-0.2668814063,
-0.5357463956,
-0.1260637939,
-0.0563209914,
-0.4496667981,
0.276925236,
-0.0647726208,
0.6852402091,
-0.1264711171,
0.5559016466,
-0.4001426101,
0.0305842664,
-0.081188269,
-0.0241730306,
0.3622289598,
0.0253657438,
0.1630543917,
-0.6714088321,
-0.2192641348,
0.079063952,
-0.6731357574,
0.1503747553,
0.2260795385,
0.7256989479,
-0.0720538348,
0.3701830208,
-0.5070773959,
0.7373456359,
0.1942535341,
0.169376567,
0.40108338,
-0.2247340828,
-0.3922172189,
0.1917473376,
0.9318555593,
0.1347698271,
-0.1516320407,
0.1101484895,
0.0662216097,
-0.1146507338,
0.2858577669,
-0.7602795362,
-0.4247121811,
0.2034297884,
-0.6404315829,
-0.4899613857,
0.0494981781,
-0.6289972663,
-0.3041534424,
-0.4103025794,
0.0067150537,
-0.2643603981,
-0.3838353157,
-0.1764242202,
0.1322235912,
-0.2031246722,
0.4141214788,
-0.8262530565,
0.0828340575,
0.8483163118,
1.0598464012,
-0.0310259871,
-0.1162239313,
-0.5192443132,
-0.3264661133,
-0.0098820478,
0.8558363914,
-0.3415101171,
-0.0317603797,
0.060019616,
0.0862956792,
-0.0168169197,
-0.3147722781,
0.4463623464,
-0.4731733799,
0.0287525896,
-0.2101243585,
-0.3441946507,
-0.8441567421,
0.6258080006,
-0.8947800994,
0.8287372589,
0.6577907205,
-1.1307801008,
0.4099753797,
-0.3904188275,
-0.7609882951,
0.1223160997,
-0.25082165,
-0.830720067,
0.0506545603,
0.3317128122,
0.5627040863,
-0.066268608,
0.3401831388,
-0.6993455887,
0.0439534038,
-0.0623706169,
-0.1743387878,
0.6733847857,
-0.0419750363,
-0.283124119,
0.4114089906,
-0.5740767717,
0.0854387656,
-0.34829247,
-0.1952442229,
-0.5019667745,
-0.0225326493,
0.0111769056,
0.3001185954,
0.1457354724,
-0.3346868753,
-0.0446781665,
-0.5336642265,
0.665114224,
0.4610536695,
0.3563500941,
0.145846352,
0.1101579145,
0.5241026878,
0.2915774286,
0.250012815,
0.202501297,
-0.4195292592,
-0.5625331402,
-0.1499701738,
0.1045632809,
0.2432745248,
-0.7164011002,
0.9647216797,
-0.2687039077,
-0.1512746513,
-0.1017986909,
0.1134169772,
0.4076402783,
0.4411884248,
0.1969003528,
-0.7815206647,
-0.748965621,
-0.8163600564,
0.2678833008,
-0.5430767536,
0.4064155817,
0.2863104641,
0.1513596922,
0.0850602761,
1.1448903084,
-0.4012319744,
-0.6315014362,
-0.7051575184,
0.1054515243,
0.2336181998,
0.1493971497,
0.7489370704,
-0.8106430173,
-0.299342066,
0.2664579451,
-0.7000818849,
0.0966328233,
0.1041677445,
-0.0629961044,
0.006665702,
0.0959669128,
-0.6543002725,
0.331635803,
0.6816345453,
-0.2351242006,
0.4540912807,
-0.0007141129,
-0.0848257691,
-1.0021160841,
-0.0269323681,
0.3834802508,
-0.3086595535,
-0.344312191,
-0.2706353068,
-0.2981050909,
-0.0593334287,
-0.4900251627,
0.1626601219,
-0.3392566144,
-0.1680521965,
-0.3470071852,
0.1562155783,
0.3788608909,
0.8550962806,
-0.0113027785,
0.3798157275,
0.3380643427,
-0.3467876613,
0.4895311296,
0.2401754409,
-0.2172290534,
0.5188899636,
-0.4952931106,
-0.1005027294,
-0.039559029,
0.2240823954,
-0.7742447853,
0.1871436983,
0.4013294876,
-0.2987472117,
0.4321308732,
-0.5136402845,
-0.0313111432,
-0.264588356,
-0.2088936567,
0.4492986798,
-0.2197390795,
-0.4107464254,
0.6079807878,
0.3946061134,
-0.2014874667,
-0.8006890416,
-0.4844377041,
0.0386987478,
-0.1103922129,
-0.5805361271,
0.0887563005,
0.5817737579,
-0.1279984415,
0.4203836322,
0.0290015601,
0.0503981411,
0.1635632962,
0.4850499928,
-0.035187196,
-0.1483246684,
0.0359471738,
0.0215242673,
-0.1976324767,
0.2026424557,
-0.5110810995,
0.3000343144,
-0.196505174,
-0.0568244234,
-0.1722453088,
0.3414364755,
0.3327414989,
-0.2147016674,
0.5847671032,
0.3467361629,
-0.0943304524,
-0.3379502594,
-0.1593894064,
-0.0544377603,
-0.4136093855,
1.0038673878,
-0.0428044349,
-1.0732829571,
0.3767882586,
0.0976214707,
-0.3469573259,
0.3615546227,
0.3197643161,
0.140059635,
0.7136900425,
0.5796619058,
-0.6156610847,
0.8426163197,
-0.3324552774,
0.4360791147,
-0.8622356653,
-0.0445981398,
-0.3211892247,
-0.3385559618,
-0.6384657621,
-0.0281094667,
0.43682307,
0.2062691897,
-0.2416267693,
0.2675643265,
-0.7163621187,
0.0890255943,
0.2170935422,
0.3186514378,
0.0715746284,
0.1175812185,
0.2779184282,
0.1018185169,
-0.5293687582,
0.0155472653,
0.7295383215,
0.2878899872,
0.4742134213,
-0.1270386428,
0.3305459023,
0.454430908,
0.5116294622,
-1.1145806313,
0.3956425488,
-0.5464709401,
-0.1050430983,
-0.3750959933,
-0.6834170818,
-0.6875563264,
0.293253988,
0.08883968,
-0.5620898604,
0.2488679141,
0.1483248621,
-0.2569671273,
0.2677949071,
-0.5449735522,
0.9021457434,
-0.0382115878,
-0.1798430383,
-0.2435904741,
-0.5452759266,
0.3036190867,
0.6380089521,
-0.2202472985,
-0.1597675085,
0.4800901413,
0.5246798396,
-0.7522799373,
0.9863756895,
-0.3375846148,
0.2164198011,
0.5369771123,
-0.0153363338,
0.5561308265,
0.2737312317,
0.0774612203,
0.3746071756,
-0.4837622046,
-0.167346701,
-0.8976718187,
0.7399871945,
-0.7849065065,
-0.6508445144,
-0.2528627515,
-0.2633684278,
-0.1338431984,
0.1015511826,
0.0182437059,
0.6079381108,
-0.3086853623,
0.0428017378,
0.4586065412,
0.2155563831,
0.4890244007,
-0.0788217708,
-0.0875550583,
-0.8383436203,
0.9053054452,
0.2420251817,
0.0936667398,
0.6680403948,
0.2162827104,
-0.13527897,
-0.622874856,
-0.583322525,
0.1006948724,
-0.6651080847,
-0.5218271613,
-0.6253505349,
-0.5922935009,
-0.1252273768,
0.0554879345,
-0.3284687102,
-0.5040075183,
-0.2391206473,
-0.5678585172,
0.8950474858,
0.5526244044,
0.1977190375,
0.2018364966,
-0.5326930881,
-0.1765428036,
0.2344591171,
0.4063960016,
0.2906475365,
-0.0847200602,
-0.5611021519,
-0.3447889388,
-0.4645472467,
-0.5465227962,
0.4917697608,
0.0159959029,
0.1634869874,
0.6108742356,
-0.0211370066,
0.3792689145,
-0.1138795391,
0.6185587049,
0.3954266608,
-0.823076725,
0.3654567897,
-0.3129528463,
0.0398635864,
0.6843825579,
0.0979033858,
-0.6196355224,
-0.3962804675,
-0.4970163107,
-0.9922186732,
0.7454656959,
0.260920465,
-0.2009481937,
-0.1255320013,
0.4782532454,
-0.1798453629,
0.2352036685,
-0.5689015985,
-0.4150369167,
-0.5612407923,
-0.4039365947,
0.1816959083,
-0.1848649085,
-0.0433414206,
-0.2209144533,
0.5499067903,
-0.3901444972,
0.0998706818,
0.3644217551,
0.1522883475,
0.1089580208,
0.1483019888,
0.2797304094,
0.4265131354,
-0.1427827626,
0.2883808911,
0.0678601637,
-0.7302512527,
0.1447195858,
0.2785222828,
-0.312674433,
0.1000076532,
0.2606528997,
0.8978681564,
0.1367854774,
0.1507703513,
0.5448651314,
0.0876310989,
0.0967239439,
-0.3688127697,
-0.2441475689,
0.0541230477,
-0.10245464,
-0.1086636856,
0.0742646754,
0.2310428023,
-0.300195843,
0.351762116,
0.3621239662,
-1.1449004412,
-0.4921163023,
0.0539189614,
0.4110121429,
-0.0013494181,
0.506280899,
-0.437698096,
-0.6788791418,
0.9304789901,
0.0983204469,
1.2589558363,
-0.013755667,
0.5545226336,
0.4017158151,
0.0781283602,
-0.0206341818,
0.2010378093,
0.1250197887,
-0.6227098107,
-0.6190074682,
-0.4475391209,
-0.3630798757,
-0.0716823041,
-0.4351475537,
0.1264499426,
-0.759025991,
-0.0998304263,
-0.1885299087,
0.0859934315,
-0.2372109443,
0.3572660387,
-0.2634584606,
0.2498793155,
-0.8508120775,
0.7199414968,
0.6732234955,
-0.7335346341,
-0.9658623338,
-0.2284268737,
-0.0946910903,
-0.3100281358,
0.6582393646,
0.3996365964,
-0.1353701502,
-0.4104236364,
-0.1846395582,
-0.8303870559,
0.9637266397,
0.0871916637,
-0.3314928114,
0.162742734,
0.1378713697,
0.5790813565,
-0.6635314226,
0.6090267301,
0.3347734511,
0.2916434407,
-0.0914078206,
-0.4595148265,
0.1962215751,
-0.2248312235,
0.3118039668,
0.672285974,
-1.0288912058,
0.6725507975,
0.2249228358,
0.0027062711,
-0.3206564486,
1.0332475901,
-0.0094630653,
0.2182768881,
0.5865619183,
0.7631595731,
0.3724689782,
-0.1791748106,
0.7464607358,
-0.192423746,
0.62968117,
1.1165057421,
-0.1333081275,
0.5213420987,
0.2390999794,
-0.287283808,
0.8822690248,
0.681011498,
0.1337733418,
0.5499782562,
0.2887030244,
-0.3229395449,
-0.1822111011,
-0.4231112897,
-0.2175523788,
0.0471641682,
0.4037145972,
-0.4981498122,
-0.4927832484,
0.0029638843,
0.1931717098,
0.0242558327,
-0.3835632801,
0.7810361385,
0.477614969,
-0.4162380993,
0.1629557312,
-0.2504982948,
0.3900265992,
-0.5688823462,
-0.0362326875,
-0.3705136776,
0.2344836891,
-0.5992519259,
-0.8342785239,
0.4655717909,
-0.2952457368,
-0.5743659735,
0.1058081388,
0.5321366191,
-0.2659381628,
-0.5488076806,
0.658095777,
0.1978668272,
-0.2095388174,
-0.3215673566,
-0.5518437028,
-0.2054526508,
-0.0785768107,
-0.4070651829,
0.5560932755,
0.8565947413,
-0.211846903,
0.4701844454,
0.112779215,
0.2218493521,
-0.4843201041,
0.5888662934,
1.0511071682,
-0.5329245329,
-0.739564538,
-0.693565309,
0.2497330606,
-0.1024314612,
-0.3423459828,
0.5862609148,
0.4065066278,
0.5785098672,
0.2696380615,
0.7374516129,
-0.2596478462,
0.2108922154,
-0.4874841869,
0.7370654941,
-0.2082884461,
0.086795114,
-0.3688864112,
-0.8866888285,
-0.590744853,
0.194409132,
-0.4549402297,
0.1098496169,
0.868650794,
0.6798825264,
-0.0683518201,
0.1335358769,
0.0824003741,
0.0447235815,
0.4813364148,
0.7044416666,
0.5213924646,
-0.2569311261,
0.6714497209,
-0.4209976196,
-0.205977425,
-0.1226972789,
-0.9315636754,
-0.8156245947,
-0.4839286208,
-0.5815380216,
-0.6363251209,
0.0028678249,
0.9352251291,
0.7644597292,
-0.8919499516,
0.1299589127,
-0.5113623738,
0.5696288347,
-0.5930588245,
-0.3307326436,
0.8714281917,
-0.528262496,
-0.2809548974,
-0.0352945738,
0.5702492595,
-0.2977968752,
-0.4376660287,
0.1000917405,
-0.0407388099,
-0.5076406002,
0.637832582,
0.2698725164,
-0.5366849303,
-0.631772995,
-0.3883348405,
-0.1415589154,
0.4671418667,
0.9744289517,
-0.7233748436,
0.3573166132,
0.7930583954,
0.6033224463,
0.204869628,
0.3329559565,
0.4942557216,
-0.8839999437,
0.3164594769,
0.2064496279,
0.5164317489,
0.5485921502,
-0.7238965034,
0.2955216169,
0.4374425113,
-0.4955333769,
-0.1057543308,
0.3511882722,
-1.2361414433,
-0.0850315168,
1.1014755964,
-0.6010690928,
-0.5743321776,
-0.3949432373,
-0.1860827357,
0.0998347402,
-0.6600508094,
0.7646128535,
0.5050708652,
-0.1997998506,
-0.2900580168,
0.09680783,
0.5995903611,
0.386456877,
-0.9196418524,
0.1618794799,
0.4963519871,
0.0697857589,
0.190958336,
0.4159553945,
-0.1427419931,
0.0833273083,
-0.280429095,
0.2404787987,
-0.3032706976,
-0.3733167052,
-0.4316910505,
0.4541719556,
0.1209851801,
-0.2394015491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04459v1
|
Improving Pacing in Long-Form Story Planning
| 2023-11-08T04:58:29 | 2023-11-08T04:58:29 |
Yichen Wang, Kevin Yang, Xiaoming Liu, Dan Klein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing LLM-based systems for writing long-form stories or story outlines
frequently suffer from unnatural pacing, whether glossing over important events
or over-elaborating on insignificant details, resulting in a jarring experience
for the reader. We propose a CONCrete Outline ConTrol (CONCOCT) system to
improve pacing when automatically generating story outlines. We first train a
concreteness evaluator to judge which of two events is more concrete
(low-level-detailed). This evaluator can then be used to control pacing in
hierarchical outline generation; in this work, we explore a vaguest-first
expansion procedure that aims for uniform pacing. We further use the evaluator
to filter new outline items based on predicted concreteness. Compared to a
baseline hierarchical outline generator, humans judge CONCOCT's pacing to be
more consistent over 57% of the time across multiple outline lengths; the gains
also translate to downstream stories. All code, data, and models are
open-sourced.
|
[
-0.1406275034,
-0.551535964,
0.7868534923,
0.7856702805,
-0.4399472475,
0.3077552319,
-0.1697923541,
-0.7300269604,
0.321985811,
0.1965123117,
-0.6345235705,
-0.5788319707,
-0.6118654013,
0.1113624424,
-0.23320961,
0.9547970891,
-0.5762328506,
-0.3648431003,
0.0866436586,
-0.1382012516,
-0.3656626046,
-0.1378588378,
-0.8161865473,
-0.6355140805,
0.7625476122,
0.6861136556,
0.9492393732,
0.873439312,
0.4258846343,
0.1037015244,
-0.0378762186,
0.5709738731,
-0.3580597341,
0.263168782,
0.0947851241,
0.0150776645,
-0.8505395651,
-0.329591006,
0.5616034865,
0.815487802,
-0.196302712,
-0.1358794272,
0.1780650914,
0.8666317463,
-0.6542095542,
0.0025557897,
0.0564241409,
0.0859462917,
-0.0166722033,
-0.619720161,
-0.2210412025,
-0.3413726091,
0.145437479,
-0.8044360876,
0.390008539,
0.2912636101,
0.3754121363,
-0.0094282515,
0.0113884564,
-0.556209147,
-0.8871049285,
0.3189064264,
-0.322796911,
0.3509010971,
0.3099352121,
0.0616819412,
-0.4286640286,
-1.0361256599,
-0.2257059515,
-0.5917870402,
0.0104742916,
0.2500929236,
-0.0185729545,
0.421053797,
0.3231277764,
0.0650255531,
-0.634513557,
0.3366169631,
-0.3257259429,
-0.0768495277,
0.8141345978,
0.5730675459,
0.0689968392,
0.1285402626,
-0.3382087052,
0.1985061169,
-0.6792994738,
0.4550221264,
0.3577405512,
-0.2338677198,
-0.2136790305,
0.7091298699,
-0.6723167896,
0.4680046141,
0.4627447128,
-0.2340927422,
0.039814204,
-0.0783278346,
-0.2144033015,
0.44965747,
0.5635569096,
0.7783104777,
0.3617833853,
-0.3792475462,
-0.1818486601,
0.1094025746,
0.1799963117,
-0.7980746031,
-0.3211820424,
0.522064805,
-0.3887473047,
-0.1033379063,
-0.2159588635,
-0.3037515879,
-0.6443003416,
-0.4683283567,
-0.0262896568,
-0.7907908559,
0.3313012719,
0.3635131121,
-0.4539236426,
0.0030552875,
0.7117934227,
-1.1740663052,
0.7522834539,
0.5717757344,
1.0109572411,
-0.4016121924,
-0.5592874289,
-0.5676560402,
0.5266336203,
-0.5114399791,
0.9795630574,
-0.1035447866,
-0.4578872323,
-0.0962196887,
-0.2371074855,
0.3483830094,
-0.4722453952,
0.4653762877,
-0.0279917121,
-0.1484289914,
0.4746878743,
-0.4048660398,
0.6673657894,
0.2855523527,
-0.4860055447,
0.9680358171,
0.0619826056,
-0.6453130841,
0.6210002899,
-0.4096440673,
-0.7120150328,
-0.1235508695,
-0.1437525451,
-0.4764455557,
0.1935047656,
0.3061520457,
0.4895807505,
0.1528656036,
0.3617905974,
0.0255141575,
-0.6809025407,
-0.1291431487,
-0.1958435476,
0.0202245526,
0.1220912933,
-0.3335756958,
0.3409363627,
-1.0831521749,
0.0917470679,
-0.4244809151,
-0.2241825312,
-0.0118015036,
0.2172315568,
-0.1285806596,
0.0474112369,
0.063003093,
-0.331813544,
0.4107242525,
-0.1771413833,
0.1519991755,
0.6189338565,
0.5086552501,
0.6699542999,
-1.0654997826,
0.6742554903,
-0.3549798131,
0.2771115005,
-0.2500329912,
-0.282985419,
-0.8969740868,
-0.3365259171,
-0.2667748928,
0.1532897949,
-0.2962802351,
0.3652815223,
-0.1621108502,
-0.6037281752,
0.0447958447,
-0.0790382624,
0.1149104163,
0.2001570612,
0.4586400986,
-0.3945642114,
-0.5338577032,
-0.5670673847,
0.0743637234,
-0.1183146611,
-0.2165798694,
-0.22381109,
0.1927399337,
0.1730832011,
0.8379298449,
-0.3786934316,
0.057046406,
-0.4757524729,
0.4788936675,
0.0131954402,
0.5592395067,
-0.123239316,
-0.4697756767,
-0.5208804607,
-0.3966625631,
-0.1742451638,
-0.2993841171,
-0.7487149835,
-0.1462418884,
0.1250025183,
0.7996282578,
-0.7762235999,
0.778811872,
0.1124987751,
-0.4137910306,
1.0461868048,
-0.4315217137,
-0.0032998277,
-0.6335996985,
0.2506046593,
-0.3694536984,
-0.2521297634,
-0.4045580924,
-0.2495232373,
0.2109256238,
0.1058071107,
-0.4691164196,
0.5513806939,
-0.4756992161,
0.2714715302,
-0.2579044104,
0.2622932494,
0.27483356,
0.6584100723,
0.2711838782,
0.3211737871,
0.0692528039,
-0.8611936569,
0.0719516948,
0.1646978706,
-0.4120471776,
0.3807355464,
-0.7233794928,
0.1233474612,
-0.2496244013,
0.6564593911,
-0.9402433634,
-0.1571248025,
0.072350122,
-0.3827350438,
0.3430603147,
0.080194518,
-0.5506520867,
-0.1136312634,
-0.4827940464,
-0.2313292772,
0.4547486007,
-0.2333627194,
0.3435648382,
-0.4053432643,
-0.3733658493,
-0.3815188706,
-0.4173798561,
0.0385713242,
-0.0544462204,
-0.5241147876,
0.7687693834,
-0.4778739512,
-0.2800755501,
-0.3106989861,
-0.4429367185,
-0.2509922683,
-0.0431122929,
0.5434535146,
-0.0137687111,
0.0989121571,
0.1927145571,
0.3321558535,
-0.1450315267,
-0.0789008886,
-0.1318434477,
0.7444393635,
0.5885155797,
0.0744255632,
-0.7908352017,
0.5750610232,
0.8580611944,
-0.0313590541,
0.2744198143,
0.1958220601,
-0.1972392201,
-0.4307748675,
-0.3040988445,
0.1599306762,
-0.3900871277,
0.2761209309,
-0.4160677195,
-0.5739537477,
0.5065612197,
-0.2590836883,
0.1090012714,
0.4110394418,
0.2851506174,
-0.4653219581,
0.9658077359,
1.1020462513,
0.112925142,
0.4413996637,
-0.4875935614,
-0.20920977,
-0.9707167745,
-0.4150984287,
-0.356069684,
-0.4875282645,
-0.2415874451,
-0.1611863226,
0.0353891402,
0.6014272571,
-0.3556360006,
0.1170816123,
-0.268334806,
0.4577610493,
0.1101381853,
0.0747604519,
0.5959159732,
-0.2973001897,
-0.3589765131,
0.0226989072,
-0.7160836458,
-0.5295998454,
0.756201148,
0.5445708632,
0.9747431874,
-0.1231054738,
0.788397491,
0.2915188968,
0.3893531859,
-0.6384356022,
0.1824041158,
-0.036465805,
-0.2508713603,
-0.5331023932,
0.1813637167,
-0.8467131257,
-0.2516023219,
-0.1563185751,
-0.8569636941,
0.4193868637,
0.4068888426,
-0.7605095506,
0.0263584908,
-0.3871470988,
0.3778796494,
-0.2023077756,
-0.4516268075,
-0.0815761909,
-0.5865643024,
0.0613456406,
-0.1196946278,
-0.2639141977,
-0.1560382992,
-0.2482833117,
0.3982973993,
-0.6032293439,
0.6133291125,
0.2143056095,
0.0436633714,
0.4119466245,
0.2166651934,
1.0204757452,
0.0650719851,
0.0149743054,
-0.2079473883,
-0.5179834366,
-0.3627716899,
-0.8740654588,
0.3620114625,
-0.5293257833,
-0.1418179274,
-0.2963828743,
-0.6474708319,
-0.1860690117,
-0.0131489253,
0.6672874093,
0.6226528883,
-0.5000295043,
-0.0944022238,
0.4454836547,
0.2487251461,
0.6288486123,
0.5248103738,
0.0707422271,
-0.4270706177,
0.1697732508,
0.0929232612,
0.6609559655,
0.5121393204,
0.1075035855,
-0.3007068336,
-1.1455715895,
-0.5245530605,
-0.1009993926,
-0.1471726596,
-0.0916033685,
-0.8381302357,
-0.2263229191,
-0.45809865,
-0.8165156841,
-0.1700940877,
-0.7735837102,
-0.1287926286,
-0.1557415128,
0.1133883223,
0.7147117853,
0.1321881711,
0.7656040788,
-0.2234933823,
0.4708340466,
-0.23955369,
0.4641006887,
-0.1675127596,
-0.4295684695,
-0.1610582918,
-0.4312390387,
-0.5556516051,
-0.3578802645,
0.3683150113,
0.0027363661,
0.1717927903,
0.4153343439,
0.0552157797,
1.1600772142,
-0.950155735,
0.4635011256,
0.5453388691,
-0.6223041415,
0.4915637076,
-0.2731213272,
0.7063478231,
0.6661260724,
0.4537873864,
-0.7619493604,
-0.8462767601,
-0.8382313848,
-0.8652288318,
0.4268345535,
0.5275805593,
-0.2699787021,
0.1000945121,
0.4428831935,
0.0720463544,
0.0768089443,
-0.2906762958,
-0.0912091583,
-0.0653745532,
-0.1095227227,
-0.2550197244,
-0.2836980224,
0.2491203994,
-0.0340140574,
0.3131298721,
0.0232718065,
-0.0603649765,
0.8124467134,
-0.0568629801,
-0.4468507171,
0.2550851703,
0.8724550009,
1.2775204182,
-0.6030935645,
0.2215925008,
0.1395542175,
-0.7387071252,
0.2542306185,
0.341558814,
-0.1965084672,
0.0802460834,
0.7794871926,
0.391263485,
0.1116740331,
-0.6157567501,
0.2154126912,
-0.0262790993,
-0.3013765216,
-0.6623057723,
0.3522237837,
0.0043664081,
0.1104107276,
0.2660810649,
0.1224917844,
0.1163273752,
-0.5313696861,
0.3466910124,
-0.2322274297,
-0.6173495054,
0.0820258334,
0.4299386442,
0.2358640432,
-0.5065359473,
0.5485219955,
-0.1674468219,
-0.1814984977,
0.8970780373,
0.8161591887,
0.7903192639,
-0.1008204296,
0.1439472139,
0.254073441,
0.4863942862,
-0.0195741281,
0.2329319715,
-0.2292969525,
-0.304782182,
-0.5159976482,
-0.4311321378,
-0.3818823397,
0.2856426537,
-0.2452594191,
0.5505458117,
-0.97202456,
0.1587107778,
0.0118717039,
0.4556652904,
-0.2951517403,
0.342558831,
0.1794495732,
1.583671689,
-0.5314927697,
0.7957776785,
0.4018185437,
-0.1585469544,
-0.636300087,
-0.0244588871,
-0.2847250104,
-0.3178803325,
0.3614296913,
0.2701257467,
-0.3836619556,
-0.1121266708,
-0.4756447971,
-0.6418301463,
1.3924208879,
-0.2220989019,
-0.9746421576,
-0.1593381613,
0.0342685618,
0.6143305302,
-0.5934957862,
0.1532641947,
0.4189312458,
0.3046254516,
0.1721779257,
-0.7470813394,
-0.2454848588,
-0.08291886,
-0.344720751,
0.5159603357,
-0.6416077614,
0.4535991251,
-0.5256549716,
-0.3692081869,
0.6119799614,
0.7173950076,
0.4057847559,
0.8217786551,
0.274232924,
0.4439829588,
0.8476571441,
0.3040212095,
1.1375751495,
-0.2392361611,
-0.1344943047,
1.7516325712,
-0.282772541,
0.5492627025,
0.344779104,
0.1571189165,
0.6897300482,
0.7487666011,
0.3600399196,
0.4566556215,
0.5391429663,
-0.3154124618,
-0.0254722908,
-0.1233522445,
-0.0049639521,
0.0879875198,
0.2691052258,
-0.4022078812,
-0.1695321351,
-0.3759357333,
0.3944878578,
0.1915231645,
-0.5324180126,
0.4258301556,
-0.0124188513,
-0.8308005333,
0.4846574366,
0.1469326764,
0.3426369131,
-1.1441134214,
-0.1790103018,
-0.4975061715,
0.0053768931,
-0.161862731,
-0.6632449031,
0.0600524023,
0.0321122929,
-0.4661606252,
-0.3600666523,
0.4461789131,
-0.500344038,
-0.0902462378,
-0.048017621,
0.2620597184,
0.0554137006,
-0.2204557508,
-0.4115232527,
-0.029788062,
-0.1658693254,
-0.0179560613,
-0.1028303131,
0.5130398273,
-0.6235418916,
0.6994068623,
0.5639994144,
0.2838739753,
0.1017371789,
0.2352251709,
0.7148032784,
-0.7840842009,
-0.708388567,
-0.7936002016,
0.6219809651,
-0.3546084762,
-0.9084386826,
0.2670424581,
0.8433127403,
0.4585942626,
0.2970117331,
0.4254058599,
-0.0142280711,
0.1579830945,
-0.6717430353,
0.6338083744,
0.0356645659,
-0.1421322823,
-0.1283864081,
-1.0497727394,
-0.3888549805,
0.0740906969,
0.1526306123,
-0.3414923549,
1.2651457787,
0.5101363659,
0.0157308206,
-0.3873625994,
0.3214854598,
0.0757649392,
0.3051480949,
0.8032578826,
1.1391694546,
0.0887002945,
0.3162993193,
-0.4772543013,
-0.3884664774,
0.0203964673,
-1.0310279131,
-0.7208473682,
-0.2218200862,
-0.226995647,
-0.1907114089,
0.4833902121,
0.6586251259,
0.879104197,
-0.270897001,
-0.3645522296,
-0.2921023667,
-0.0547537245,
-0.2409896851,
-0.1026781872,
0.6367511749,
-0.5424892902,
-0.5076531768,
0.4065077305,
0.4688438773,
0.1793991774,
0.0377408527,
-0.4246047735,
-0.1177646518,
0.0329625234,
0.4800648391,
0.3007101119,
-0.2743199766,
-0.2366919816,
-0.1561539769,
-0.3381107152,
0.2462304384,
1.2571099997,
-0.6628529429,
0.4592235088,
0.2498021424,
-0.1991691738,
0.6669229865,
0.2287915051,
0.6059396863,
-0.6965407133,
0.2116642594,
0.4668506384,
0.1563390046,
-0.0289259478,
-0.6549957395,
0.5772386193,
-0.1266478896,
-0.6003634334,
-0.1479696035,
0.2912350893,
-1.2413896322,
-0.1129881144,
0.9471988678,
0.102034688,
-0.2284799069,
-0.3428063989,
-0.4245978892,
0.1557370275,
-0.4657415748,
0.7539387941,
0.5990759134,
-0.9404999614,
0.062470872,
-0.4740398824,
0.8446326852,
-0.0286415573,
-0.7009215355,
0.1970248967,
0.5640361309,
0.3301743865,
0.0694304481,
1.1525070667,
-0.0784493983,
0.6346781254,
-0.1722795963,
0.2869986892,
-0.1641256064,
-0.7931386828,
-0.2369359285,
0.0814706385,
0.0719124973,
0.0483428761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04453v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04453v2
|
Lewis's Signaling Game as beta-VAE For Natural Word Lengths and Segments
| 2023-11-08T04:34:30 | 2024-04-02T07:53:07 |
Ryo Ueda, Tadahiro Taniguchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As a sub-discipline of evolutionary and computational linguistics, emergent
communication (EC) studies communication protocols, called emergent languages,
arising in simulations where agents communicate. A key goal of EC is to give
rise to languages that share statistical properties with natural languages. In
this paper, we reinterpret Lewis's signaling game, a frequently used setting in
EC, as beta-VAE and reformulate its objective function as ELBO. Consequently,
we clarify the existence of prior distributions of emergent languages and show
that the choice of the priors can influence their statistical properties.
Specifically, we address the properties of word lengths and segmentation, known
as Zipf's law of abbreviation (ZLA) and Harris's articulation scheme (HAS),
respectively. It has been reported that the emergent languages do not follow
them when using the conventional objective. We experimentally demonstrate that
by selecting an appropriate prior distribution, more natural segments emerge,
while suggesting that the conventional one prevents the languages from
following ZLA and HAS.
|
[
-0.3758156002,
-0.9583226442,
0.980322063,
0.2343980819,
-0.4525764287,
0.0941672251,
-0.332160145,
-0.5479803681,
0.8529301882,
0.0104311416,
-0.4771321714,
-0.1939159185,
-0.4149702787,
0.1838727295,
-0.3941830397,
0.915279448,
0.3077801168,
-0.2035837322,
0.1654805243,
0.0699355528,
0.2767481208,
-0.5688649416,
-0.7123277783,
-0.1555794626,
0.8324834108,
0.0369216017,
0.9282934666,
0.8435165882,
0.3753932416,
0.2936817706,
-0.5069551468,
-0.0282535478,
-0.3742158115,
0.3095955551,
0.1035097539,
-0.4779897928,
-0.2582455575,
-0.2363639623,
0.6764296293,
0.6905719042,
-0.0798006877,
-0.1617756188,
-0.1314364374,
0.8300577998,
-0.6395955682,
0.0104027446,
-0.3833481669,
-0.2081963718,
-0.2715988457,
-0.5428062677,
-0.4255564809,
-0.6928754449,
0.3569456041,
-0.517234087,
-0.1122905985,
0.0019196894,
0.7335647941,
-0.1497566104,
-0.3634308875,
-0.6832967401,
-1.0337600708,
0.2937469482,
-0.765212059,
0.2553853095,
0.2481902838,
0.3570769131,
-0.160822317,
-0.5003777742,
-0.4689705074,
-0.2432285547,
0.1321002841,
-0.1414163858,
-0.3912144601,
0.2293969542,
0.159787938,
0.0286649615,
-0.5185906887,
0.0670088455,
-0.9236018062,
0.1144211218,
0.8310692906,
0.0027764263,
0.253831923,
0.0524407364,
-0.3073167205,
-0.1170815304,
-0.775323987,
0.0589355975,
0.7946687937,
0.4626071453,
-0.1522266269,
0.2349334806,
-0.0759145692,
0.679469049,
-0.1329512149,
0.3651079535,
0.2996466756,
-0.1824759543,
-0.2248213291,
0.188010633,
0.571674943,
0.0039737467,
0.5339269042,
-0.2612527609,
0.1175092757,
-0.0444993898,
0.1683961004,
-0.3637851179,
-0.3924919665,
0.2108748853,
-0.3226498365,
-0.1357245445,
0.5341495275,
-0.6329059005,
-0.1148997471,
0.0445806757,
0.2185169905,
-0.5133450627,
-0.3346780837,
-0.1099497676,
-0.2356982976,
0.3641780615,
-0.1467157304,
-1.1390929222,
0.4302098751,
0.5604356527,
0.8294804692,
0.3921457827,
-0.2414986789,
-0.4940825999,
-0.0098416153,
-0.5800765157,
0.8319525719,
-0.6387185454,
-0.6068416238,
0.1474354565,
-0.110735625,
-0.0984448567,
-0.1626808643,
0.3732507229,
-0.7958678007,
-0.3127541244,
-0.4410594404,
-0.4767378867,
-0.2521262765,
-0.4017203152,
-0.3195583224,
0.4791357219,
-0.1480919421,
-0.3419366777,
0.6406798959,
-0.5922340155,
-0.6101678014,
0.3755099773,
-0.0931060389,
-0.1800443977,
0.4410490394,
-0.1362508684,
0.0933686942,
0.212760523,
-0.4022696018,
-0.389241606,
-0.3227652907,
0.3182223141,
-0.1841911823,
0.7738273144,
0.3465897441,
-0.1569449902,
0.1595487446,
-0.7691267133,
0.614053309,
-0.1746676266,
-0.2251579612,
-0.7635261416,
0.6293104887,
-0.301707685,
0.1436974853,
-0.180972591,
-0.4554921985,
0.215256691,
-0.3661607504,
0.6339120865,
0.7148280144,
0.3183042407,
0.8764410019,
-0.1839744896,
0.3127760887,
-0.0841877386,
0.4259724617,
-0.2459435165,
-0.672719717,
-0.6034430265,
-0.2863446176,
0.2082466036,
0.3291049898,
-0.3883958161,
0.447604239,
-0.2172376662,
-0.4439429045,
-0.4416117072,
-0.080430232,
0.0185804311,
-0.2859011292,
0.1395613998,
-0.280705899,
-0.6307672858,
-0.9595370293,
0.2262510061,
-0.6674644947,
0.1074822247,
0.1870902926,
0.3224216998,
-0.2073832601,
0.8593844771,
-0.4834920764,
0.3405023515,
-0.0485466495,
0.3999145031,
0.0679045022,
0.037949875,
0.6247080564,
-0.5616021156,
-0.3100909591,
-0.0089495126,
-0.3192816675,
-0.3871567249,
-0.1926374882,
-0.0533367544,
-0.0800802633,
0.4434040487,
-0.1718961746,
0.5374260545,
0.5801936984,
-0.3745788634,
0.725784719,
-0.3971453011,
-0.0487902723,
-0.642208457,
-0.3224806488,
-0.088886328,
-0.1651557833,
-0.7355223298,
0.08924409,
0.1960716248,
0.3748468161,
-0.461301595,
0.3046637475,
-1.0077396631,
-0.266369164,
-0.7249116302,
0.1142648906,
-0.3776143193,
0.1999958754,
0.316108346,
0.6197938323,
0.798297286,
-1.1497051716,
0.091106534,
0.0455591232,
-0.0815005749,
0.3910415769,
-0.6371929049,
0.0350873247,
-0.323710531,
-0.0279230941,
-0.6407182813,
0.3670625389,
0.1150978059,
-0.3909794092,
-0.2506849468,
-0.1159277037,
-0.2835374475,
-0.5866562724,
-0.1532783657,
0.2186193615,
0.8211098313,
-0.251070112,
-0.1647628248,
0.0526055135,
-0.0151119502,
-0.0720330924,
-0.4779750407,
-0.1192870066,
-0.2780036032,
-0.8326844573,
-0.2040536404,
-0.3301009238,
-0.4000112414,
-0.01639851,
0.0595619306,
-0.0566346608,
-0.1349165589,
0.0883877352,
-0.0830162317,
-0.3788112104,
0.0341020823,
0.039081227,
0.1252904683,
0.2252949774,
-0.4014089406,
0.4683875442,
-0.1180539727,
-0.4600944519,
0.1111457869,
0.5567224026,
0.4661688507,
-0.0606167018,
0.8949472308,
0.2095795572,
-0.0035625298,
-0.4455982447,
-0.1681700796,
-0.4310646057,
-0.4889847338,
0.1319759637,
-0.2765630484,
-0.5092876554,
0.6599038839,
0.0153588885,
-0.0499355532,
0.0841332674,
0.3786114454,
0.0030800176,
0.7248253226,
0.7803028822,
0.3439232111,
0.6582954526,
-0.1098044366,
0.3332973719,
-1.0754535198,
-0.0828996152,
-0.422049284,
-0.3812498152,
-0.4910385013,
-0.3380852938,
0.3121819496,
0.3086503744,
-0.2140596658,
0.5175539255,
-0.1882481128,
0.4887641668,
0.59405756,
-0.0690097883,
-0.022023052,
0.081564486,
-0.2050871998,
-0.0385820568,
-0.5866234303,
-0.5082924366,
0.8734743595,
0.2800732255,
0.8123413324,
0.3315131664,
0.945114255,
0.3315880001,
0.2296310514,
-0.5907593966,
0.4427930713,
0.4005876482,
-0.4668454528,
-0.2661833465,
-0.3893783391,
-1.2274968624,
0.1719036102,
-0.1671533734,
-1.336103797,
0.8008013964,
-0.1342330426,
-0.3712257147,
0.1763598621,
-0.8246901631,
0.3164524138,
-0.2412354201,
0.001915938,
0.1522884667,
-0.5445716977,
0.2022334635,
0.051116541,
0.306843698,
0.0094768181,
-0.0351035222,
0.771753788,
-0.7459965944,
0.649933517,
0.4871349633,
-0.0579202995,
0.6668058038,
0.1625146419,
0.5356319547,
0.1466523856,
0.0438663475,
-0.2426650375,
0.0056392183,
-0.511199832,
-0.6738878489,
0.2929285169,
-0.595631361,
-0.5287799239,
-0.6627572179,
-0.1801670641,
0.1172147393,
0.1155580729,
0.455596596,
0.3504955769,
-0.503464222,
0.0603519715,
0.2111825049,
0.1339723468,
0.8481605053,
0.8592681885,
-0.1966542304,
-0.2232621908,
0.6839094758,
0.0738316551,
0.6963673234,
0.1088648513,
0.0936326161,
-0.4009310305,
-0.6299802661,
-0.0158532094,
0.3093106747,
-0.4463521242,
0.1431897581,
-0.2324029505,
-0.5778623223,
-0.2528985739,
-0.5066995621,
-0.0475995243,
-0.1107258275,
0.0284347516,
-0.3709968328,
0.3335066736,
0.9600517154,
-0.6747435927,
0.6319662333,
-0.6665008068,
-0.2885425687,
0.2539122105,
0.1503087729,
0.00512368,
-0.2961797416,
-0.2012057453,
0.1818243265,
-0.1495760381,
-1.6022920609,
0.3672497869,
0.2950977385,
0.6492449045,
0.8280673027,
-0.0704061687,
0.4899435937,
-0.5908180475,
0.614695251,
0.3516702056,
-0.6966697574,
0.3511463106,
-0.4397865832,
0.2023966908,
0.1735003591,
0.19420816,
-0.7281486988,
-0.5339887738,
-0.9532785416,
-1.0484967232,
0.3661695719,
0.6334975362,
0.2037941664,
-0.473185569,
-0.0028952088,
-0.067147404,
0.2707999051,
-0.658428371,
-0.660454452,
0.2633937597,
0.3771291077,
-0.1632509679,
-0.4413071871,
-0.1205106005,
-0.0017618241,
0.4092664123,
0.2211309224,
0.38812837,
0.4354067147,
-0.0056884657,
-0.2826839685,
0.6598907113,
0.892340064,
0.9205405116,
-0.1907081902,
0.2059846818,
-0.3022789061,
-0.7778242826,
0.2967249751,
0.2299817801,
-0.6012403369,
0.1285936385,
0.3719254136,
0.9050543308,
0.0885051787,
-0.4623127282,
0.0212128237,
0.2473516017,
-0.1796219498,
-0.2183101773,
0.0452278703,
0.0653964356,
0.2382559925,
0.8318919539,
-0.0152081093,
0.1370490044,
-0.7808056474,
0.4106159508,
0.4148447216,
-0.4782105684,
-0.6870512962,
0.6519029737,
0.3134160936,
-0.7343279123,
0.3144097626,
-0.8467597961,
-0.4034107327,
0.8487180471,
0.6324452162,
0.8748505712,
-0.321844101,
0.8436960578,
0.2974769175,
0.7604316473,
0.019561233,
0.4558081925,
0.0626577586,
-0.5548190475,
-0.1639048308,
-0.6432381868,
-0.0492153652,
-0.0017482376,
-0.4689102173,
0.0350628868,
-0.3770163655,
-0.2935339808,
-0.0552409925,
-0.0868998393,
-0.4244838953,
-0.0396118835,
0.5281732678,
0.8083580136,
-0.9746260643,
0.5116919279,
0.6292230487,
-0.4107139409,
-0.8437740803,
-0.0182645656,
0.0762657002,
-0.4394236207,
0.6458610296,
-0.3424864709,
0.1829795539,
0.0444579907,
-0.2483277917,
-1.1629798412,
0.7757561803,
-0.0397043861,
-0.5509411097,
0.1467393637,
-0.135140866,
0.7331909537,
-0.5620538592,
0.646725595,
0.3667957187,
0.4967347383,
0.1273549944,
-0.8327084184,
-0.2215184867,
-0.2667480409,
0.017481776,
0.3383370638,
-0.4352811873,
0.7065284252,
-0.702364862,
-0.4946627319,
0.1284918487,
1.0736379623,
0.2236757576,
0.1862628013,
0.2765572071,
0.0085938182,
0.7864299417,
-0.0701729357,
0.9368437529,
-0.1620594263,
0.2041626275,
0.6353714466,
-0.3052178621,
0.8196095228,
0.4163268805,
-0.3006359935,
0.7785537243,
0.6206700802,
0.2704454362,
0.5564325452,
0.7547861934,
-0.271376729,
0.1356125474,
0.5000886917,
-0.4998042583,
0.1356492192,
0.4525416791,
-0.4461994469,
-0.4591004848,
-0.3024117351,
-0.0849700198,
0.1259128004,
-0.2843388319,
0.607768476,
0.2169450074,
-0.1808817685,
0.4991534054,
-0.3033909798,
0.5375339389,
-0.9698343873,
0.3134267032,
0.012701463,
-0.148260057,
-0.1064500511,
-0.6230050325,
0.1912929863,
-0.3493510187,
-0.0229984298,
0.3000319004,
0.2505183518,
-0.5021758676,
-0.4635537565,
0.3435998261,
0.7304468155,
0.4744114876,
0.3245658875,
-0.5103459358,
0.2424184531,
-0.4132594168,
-0.3927930593,
-0.1038056016,
0.4381368458,
-0.0587282479,
0.7168108225,
0.5094020963,
0.6751995683,
0.7183560729,
0.0290181823,
0.4756877422,
-0.4603078663,
-1.2268369198,
-0.8307683468,
0.1992917508,
-0.3330840468,
-0.2834512889,
0.882943511,
0.4600308836,
0.3711204827,
-0.1309196353,
0.7905828357,
-0.2742367387,
-0.082295239,
-0.5218638778,
0.5567099452,
-0.1108677313,
0.2356960922,
-0.4609090984,
-1.3100069761,
0.2248195559,
0.5024137497,
-0.6781579852,
0.2846503556,
1.1618852615,
0.541439712,
-0.0157736484,
0.17915003,
0.3352350891,
0.2679415047,
0.1950962394,
0.7668918967,
0.6220192909,
-0.1991715878,
0.6224823594,
0.1136358157,
-0.2820326388,
-0.1678555757,
-0.7585551143,
-0.7073833942,
-1.0268906355,
-0.3618654609,
-0.2570048273,
0.5406476259,
0.66583848,
0.9646187425,
-0.4095716774,
-0.1783966273,
-0.1931098849,
0.1442845166,
-0.6836100817,
-0.1999226958,
0.3106896877,
-0.3482736647,
-0.607624948,
0.3886618912,
0.2629640102,
0.2577694952,
-0.1637998223,
-0.1958198249,
-0.3400488496,
0.5524333715,
0.6065256,
1.1699074507,
-0.4141322076,
-0.3927687407,
0.0011903926,
-0.0937984735,
0.0133864628,
1.087208271,
-0.6823012233,
0.3128626645,
0.5680371523,
0.1304045171,
0.0583362728,
0.1120982617,
0.8732001185,
-0.7202157378,
0.3240312934,
0.0408981778,
0.2871092558,
0.0080214702,
-0.4348781109,
0.2063470632,
0.220330894,
-0.4667057991,
-0.6763529181,
0.6417649984,
-0.8582012057,
-0.3295992911,
1.626960516,
0.3229964375,
-0.6681323051,
-0.2972485721,
-0.0923379958,
-0.2051815242,
-0.5394998193,
0.4819799066,
0.6979327202,
-0.0363914222,
-0.2837775946,
-0.2629863322,
0.7573248744,
-0.0283628125,
-0.5003515482,
-0.1865920126,
0.3335203826,
0.1582348198,
0.4208648801,
1.1541261673,
0.1735408157,
0.3268516362,
0.1004013345,
-0.1047140285,
-0.0018352102,
-0.304007858,
-0.0693920255,
-0.0132861175,
-0.0445709005,
-0.2262576073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04449v1
|
Recursion in Recursion: Two-Level Nested Recursion for Length Generalization with Scalability
| 2023-11-08T04:20:56 | 2023-11-08T04:20:56 |
Jishnu Ray Chowdhury, Cornelia Caragea
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Binary Balanced Tree RvNNs (BBT-RvNNs) enforce sequence composition according
to a preset balanced binary tree structure. Thus, their non-linear recursion
depth is just $\log_2 n$ ($n$ being the sequence length). Such logarithmic
scaling makes BBT-RvNNs efficient and scalable on long sequence tasks such as
Long Range Arena (LRA). However, such computational efficiency comes at a cost
because BBT-RvNNs cannot solve simple arithmetic tasks like ListOps. On the
flip side, RvNNs (e.g., Beam Tree RvNN) that do succeed on ListOps (and other
structure-sensitive tasks like formal logical inference) are generally several
times more expensive than even RNNs. In this paper, we introduce a novel
framework -- Recursion in Recursion (RIR) to strike a balance between the two
sides - getting some of the benefits from both worlds. In RIR, we use a form of
two-level nested recursion - where the outer recursion is a $k$-ary balanced
tree model with another recursive model (inner recursion) implementing its cell
function. For the inner recursion, we choose Beam Tree RvNNs (BT-RvNN). To
adjust BT-RvNNs within RIR we also propose a novel strategy of beam alignment.
Overall, this entails that the total recursive depth in RIR is upper-bounded by
$k \log_k n$. Our best RIR-based model is the first model that demonstrates
high ($\geq 90\%$) length-generalization performance on ListOps while at the
same time being scalable enough to be trainable on long sequence inputs from
LRA. Moreover, in terms of accuracy in the LRA language tasks, it performs
competitively with Structured State Space Models (SSMs) without any special
initialization - outperforming Transformers by a large margin. On the other
hand, while SSMs can marginally outperform RIR on LRA, they (SSMs) fail to
length-generalize on ListOps. Our code is available at:
\url{https://github.com/JRC1995/BeamRecursionFamily/}.
|
[
-0.0481101014,
-0.6012426019,
0.1218238324,
0.3040518165,
-0.1005934402,
0.3877445459,
0.1645209044,
-0.6204208136,
-0.3212970495,
0.3021733165,
-0.4734120071,
-0.2407324463,
-0.4843411744,
0.00292742,
-0.5115215182,
1.1078660488,
0.0476417243,
-0.0349654108,
-0.0320837572,
-0.4153888524,
-0.5355946422,
-0.0616179109,
-0.4910856783,
-0.5525261164,
0.4923989177,
0.3678024113,
0.6632830501,
0.6571401954,
0.7482072115,
0.263804853,
-0.1778123379,
0.1866697669,
-0.7020411491,
0.2339483798,
-0.2214490771,
-0.4738085568,
-0.3056987822,
-0.7351464629,
0.9684366584,
0.6287869811,
-0.3880287409,
0.1315988898,
-0.1108026728,
1.2632561922,
-0.3540003896,
0.1830913126,
-0.5261644125,
0.2326150686,
-0.104301095,
-0.0987418443,
-0.4957228303,
-0.2015004605,
0.2602438629,
-0.3516879678,
0.1908656359,
0.241661936,
0.8609617949,
0.4088959098,
-0.322534591,
-0.0731244013,
-0.9698677063,
0.7544032931,
-0.6840027571,
0.6081336737,
-0.2393654138,
0.2456089705,
-0.2661169469,
-0.7197033763,
-0.1162155569,
-0.0872232318,
-0.1822519302,
0.1926732957,
-0.4857307971,
0.4245283306,
0.5414817333,
0.6090019941,
-0.7995995283,
0.1707538515,
-0.4321805239,
0.3164976835,
0.273094207,
0.3364075422,
0.0739552304,
-0.2037476897,
-0.2930875719,
-0.0250162091,
-0.7145814896,
0.4073350728,
-0.0336564966,
0.3677658439,
-0.1044907793,
0.744410038,
-0.1808116138,
0.7824927568,
0.3673593998,
-0.2313137203,
-0.0253819879,
-0.5290514827,
-0.3110261261,
-0.1263125092,
0.4941940308,
0.2198721319,
0.2084256113,
-0.1316103488,
-0.2434469759,
0.111293532,
0.2624918818,
-0.9954094291,
-0.0762883499,
0.2683734298,
-0.6086327434,
-0.1140723675,
-0.2143941969,
-0.5561000705,
-0.2869085371,
-0.0210572258,
0.5196561217,
-0.3342810869,
-0.2430455685,
0.1065624654,
0.0546626486,
0.3979178071,
0.0769466534,
-0.8666154146,
0.6845832467,
0.7486488223,
0.9852451086,
0.1634656042,
0.0833417401,
-0.35326913,
-0.158600986,
-0.3878124058,
0.4464575052,
-0.3755466342,
-0.2189164907,
-0.327867955,
-0.3062802553,
-0.039313823,
-0.3807803392,
-0.0453576334,
-0.7404857278,
0.3423438668,
0.2797373831,
-0.5752040148,
-0.2153737694,
0.0235152896,
-0.5786094666,
1.1423429251,
0.5042190552,
-0.9284475446,
0.298253566,
-0.7548012137,
-0.6307079196,
0.1343625337,
-0.1872949898,
-0.8242000341,
0.0680062473,
0.0367940366,
0.1433715522,
-0.2673034668,
0.326952517,
-0.045548752,
-0.4265735745,
-0.177310288,
0.0268546641,
0.7194453478,
0.3528310359,
-0.4917804599,
0.478836149,
-0.5647309422,
-0.0008818265,
0.0191947352,
-0.3506812453,
0.0367631875,
0.4056405425,
-0.4215919375,
-0.0221429709,
0.1139730588,
-0.641427815,
0.1144998819,
-1.0651357174,
0.6508379579,
0.401442796,
-0.0022812167,
0.7670636773,
-0.3122661114,
0.4786216915,
-0.1196252108,
0.1115180552,
-0.2492308319,
-0.3845883608,
-0.5221245885,
-0.2431160361,
0.2691613138,
0.686019659,
-0.2709764242,
0.3931864798,
-0.3304865062,
-0.4454618692,
-0.38399297,
-0.1072213054,
0.6665987372,
0.2817713022,
0.2578373849,
-0.4048933387,
-0.8400650024,
-0.9081180692,
0.1609478146,
-0.0948630646,
0.1791509837,
0.1006063148,
0.3376573622,
-0.1685242802,
1.0295441151,
-0.0648686588,
-0.0556374863,
-0.3314360976,
0.0311201885,
0.7440314293,
0.5065749288,
0.0988679379,
-0.7756492496,
-0.4391655624,
0.4433751404,
-0.5675661564,
0.1722661257,
-0.2000309378,
0.157671392,
0.3410609961,
0.1644360721,
-0.814037919,
0.5010425448,
0.4788537323,
0.0069375094,
0.3108052909,
-0.0540092103,
-0.1297984123,
-1.0825144053,
0.1252409369,
-0.2222284973,
-0.4016931057,
-0.5414715409,
0.4642439485,
-0.0998473465,
-0.0290437937,
-0.1609249115,
0.2198744714,
-0.4207069874,
-0.7125442028,
-0.2566966414,
0.1063388139,
0.0351270512,
0.4350637496,
-0.0770536214,
0.4775373936,
0.3297859728,
-0.3687580824,
0.3904056549,
-0.0135545749,
-0.3465375006,
0.3419911563,
-0.7752605081,
-0.1402158588,
-0.2275406867,
0.5823982954,
-1.1105777025,
0.2605801523,
0.1908079535,
-0.5985088944,
0.5144370794,
-0.3223266602,
-0.3696312606,
-0.4806891382,
-0.1553095877,
0.7470979691,
0.4357367158,
-0.4231601655,
0.7238444686,
0.046804186,
0.0917451084,
-0.9892416596,
-0.5899472833,
-0.124612011,
-0.0687606931,
-0.8363287449,
0.5665733814,
-0.2441371381,
-0.2341334373,
0.1848330051,
-0.3182200491,
0.26467821,
-0.1020664424,
0.47220999,
0.1901726127,
-0.5743073225,
-0.0211550053,
-0.0649571642,
-0.1642916948,
-0.1382182539,
-0.5499699712,
0.3981500566,
-0.6840021014,
-0.3178412318,
-0.3925537467,
0.3037693501,
0.4635137022,
-0.2115222216,
0.5797455907,
0.4621729553,
-0.6097835898,
-0.1779529005,
-0.3968729377,
-0.115786761,
-0.4274582863,
0.765681386,
-0.5311484337,
-1.3068681955,
0.3712946773,
0.1253348291,
0.6097786427,
0.2541261613,
0.6477043033,
-0.0987368077,
0.9503850341,
0.3542700112,
-0.0268509649,
0.368547678,
-0.4237835109,
0.7413322926,
-0.7069801688,
-0.1796673089,
-0.4500217736,
-0.5499340892,
-0.8710868955,
-0.5096595883,
0.1238932684,
0.2007080168,
-0.4798570275,
0.516197741,
-0.7882981896,
0.5433859825,
0.4840946496,
-0.146593973,
0.1855074465,
-0.0348530076,
-0.0388940759,
0.0574367493,
-0.9564906955,
-0.0551738143,
0.7272578478,
0.7202112675,
0.7755297422,
0.0935324654,
0.7557899952,
0.2076269686,
0.2585587204,
-0.9763418436,
0.3879530728,
-0.1992660314,
-0.5976107121,
-0.6106150746,
-0.5871388316,
-1.2437871695,
0.3408355713,
-0.0216155928,
-0.7967450023,
0.0658753514,
0.1361471266,
-0.4365951419,
0.5913574696,
-0.4457648396,
0.6315842271,
-0.1746596843,
-0.3298360705,
-0.5274942517,
-1.0552856922,
0.3104857206,
0.3101405501,
0.1851518303,
0.2106786221,
0.3551391661,
0.5306293368,
-0.1748360693,
0.7610083818,
-0.0329127237,
0.2418046743,
0.4105599821,
0.4807510376,
0.5732770562,
-0.1628415585,
0.3541944921,
-0.098152414,
0.1318401396,
-0.3897707462,
-0.5715785027,
0.748670876,
-0.765249908,
-0.4912113547,
-0.4956462979,
-0.757681787,
-0.0281236153,
0.3348600268,
0.0444621108,
0.5994775295,
0.0136189461,
0.6925218701,
0.6841554642,
0.0660995767,
0.3799000382,
0.1980670989,
-0.3500784039,
-0.4218574464,
0.7348073125,
0.0225964356,
0.3334293962,
1.0955545902,
0.2230205834,
-0.3844645023,
-0.7654685974,
-0.399472028,
0.1141624823,
-0.416285038,
-0.5278477669,
-0.3143860996,
-0.6125691533,
-0.1614560485,
-0.2468473911,
-0.4949511588,
-0.5932297111,
0.0992410779,
-0.6183080077,
0.1636873633,
1.0206387043,
-0.203456223,
0.0002996037,
-0.6356196404,
0.2924297452,
0.1833000481,
0.394990474,
0.2943018377,
-0.525196135,
-0.3273300529,
-0.1022605896,
-0.3130702376,
-0.4370696843,
0.0978160053,
-0.1098358184,
0.2520816624,
0.2865470946,
-0.2495616078,
0.8334009647,
-0.4845288396,
0.4702758789,
0.4335652292,
-0.6666314006,
0.1645988822,
-0.3597883582,
0.3688613474,
0.2485419065,
-0.0197440311,
-0.5009503961,
-0.2319618613,
-0.4708245993,
-0.9537635446,
0.7468255758,
0.2619330883,
-0.0924082026,
0.1149129644,
0.2131399512,
-0.0365559421,
0.0215920769,
-0.9922671318,
-0.0828007832,
-0.2869850993,
-0.2077098042,
0.2584936321,
-0.3493022323,
-0.0821869522,
-0.1177299246,
0.5047007203,
0.2066164762,
0.1678288728,
0.3079660237,
-0.0281240363,
-0.5597426891,
0.3685207963,
0.6558074951,
0.8671033382,
-0.551195085,
-0.0086614909,
0.2497413456,
0.081780903,
0.1655966789,
-0.0727373585,
-0.1717672199,
-0.3243969977,
0.4705840945,
0.8568247557,
0.7126204967,
-0.5009404421,
0.2035689503,
0.2618230879,
-0.3901578188,
-0.1002908796,
-0.1289925873,
0.3922989666,
0.4774202406,
0.2252766192,
0.1351427436,
-0.0034821357,
-0.2085203081,
0.3834764659,
0.4401407242,
-0.1696632206,
-0.1694533974,
0.3523580134,
0.131288439,
-0.6436809301,
0.8819304109,
0.0055338787,
-0.2391671687,
0.4897863567,
0.7415601015,
0.663004756,
-0.0590770096,
0.0471600369,
0.7427490354,
0.4085085988,
0.0384032167,
0.044135049,
-0.192342788,
-0.7339666486,
-0.6491072774,
-0.7540875673,
-0.2728208601,
-0.1176875904,
-0.6749252677,
-0.1571675092,
-0.8642556071,
-0.0689877421,
-0.2876304388,
0.0952833146,
-0.4501981437,
0.0541401915,
0.1206333861,
0.9428472519,
-0.3099830449,
0.5740384459,
0.2508568764,
-0.0778351128,
-0.6467539072,
-0.5087006688,
-0.1791298687,
-0.649818182,
0.6727042794,
0.2615922987,
-0.4770464003,
0.0420002006,
-0.1949975193,
-1.0076676607,
1.3318070173,
-0.2308885157,
-0.9409368634,
-0.4344005585,
0.1017558724,
0.6520586014,
-0.4691360593,
0.2040886283,
0.4212094247,
0.4222401381,
0.1559252143,
-0.8221751451,
-0.1076031551,
-0.0531969815,
0.2068737447,
0.6275115609,
-0.5110147595,
0.5672979355,
-0.5069615841,
-0.4314518869,
0.337757051,
0.9457907081,
0.5295177698,
0.3916091919,
0.4790120125,
0.9465165138,
0.4068841338,
0.0561900102,
0.8830382824,
-0.2133176327,
0.4070740938,
1.189136982,
-0.192566663,
0.8132522702,
0.3691945076,
-0.5431796908,
0.79470402,
0.5517622232,
0.0032711681,
0.3198613226,
0.5027604699,
-0.0009440584,
-0.0147790806,
0.1474263817,
-0.2703707516,
0.0259358473,
0.3729422987,
-0.0914101079,
-0.3894420564,
-0.3950156271,
-0.1359402388,
0.2161462754,
-0.3492624164,
0.5629330873,
0.2218928337,
-0.5450463295,
0.3585388064,
0.1542940885,
0.5392004251,
-0.8009318113,
-0.0991741866,
-0.0993160307,
0.3174014091,
-0.4955193698,
-0.8310208321,
0.3045583665,
-0.1505126655,
-0.4997297227,
-0.1581593156,
0.5119149685,
-0.2093238831,
-0.3478548527,
0.5791641474,
0.2409905195,
-0.2224327326,
0.3192654848,
-0.7900493741,
-0.080916509,
0.0458843857,
-0.1145564988,
0.44174546,
0.2267554104,
-0.1979863346,
0.7657976747,
0.4582850337,
-0.2267062068,
0.1430919021,
0.3101113439,
0.6398805976,
-0.7008923888,
-0.2480736524,
-0.7689625025,
0.6157790422,
0.2560964823,
-0.0228433255,
0.423320055,
0.6799707413,
0.8366932869,
0.1443698257,
0.2147784233,
-0.1823688447,
0.5303119421,
-0.330925107,
0.1513234824,
-0.4142973125,
-0.0039866995,
-0.0978389904,
-0.9874116778,
-0.5084019899,
0.6251551509,
-0.1273756027,
0.1625748724,
0.7196902037,
1.0008919239,
0.051473815,
-0.108629331,
0.2687609792,
0.4303521812,
0.3673830032,
0.7837784886,
0.7643208504,
-0.332243681,
0.5910618305,
-0.2036163658,
-0.3499544561,
-0.15406847,
-0.6932125092,
-0.6990922689,
-0.4803543985,
-0.1214344725,
-0.4121758044,
0.2212379873,
0.7164672017,
0.8444486856,
-0.8611980081,
-0.6200836301,
-0.4303560257,
0.3081302941,
-0.3171042204,
-0.3600361347,
0.152855292,
-0.2446697056,
-0.2814100683,
0.5928514004,
0.5602229834,
-0.2520744801,
-0.2394190878,
-0.224423483,
-0.3675502241,
0.0027891258,
0.7422993183,
0.5826750398,
-0.8896144032,
-0.3195951283,
-0.0200439543,
-0.0162268505,
0.2400634736,
0.7153021097,
-0.6252481937,
0.5213703513,
0.6431061029,
0.6772508025,
0.6953151822,
0.2517999709,
0.4671816528,
-0.6726033688,
-0.213514939,
0.4522875249,
0.3023804426,
0.2649773061,
-0.3278974295,
0.6365379691,
0.0718932375,
-0.7907674313,
-0.7225549221,
0.4905636609,
-1.1067318916,
-0.2423023582,
0.7408002615,
0.1068588272,
-0.1159217805,
0.1253663898,
-0.1956608742,
0.0951509252,
-0.3314589858,
0.6058956385,
0.560862124,
-0.4501906335,
-0.4324423075,
-0.0510121472,
0.3126221299,
0.4770777822,
-0.3223494887,
0.0983662456,
0.3812662363,
0.3277871907,
0.2963141799,
0.6282256842,
-0.4081206322,
0.4324582815,
-0.0650793165,
0.0619073212,
-0.1551597714,
-0.5631819963,
-0.3023875356,
0.1220271289,
0.251865834,
-0.0782729536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04939v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04939v1
|
LooGLE: Can Long-Context Language Models Understand Long Contexts?
| 2023-11-08T01:45:37 | 2023-11-08T01:45:37 |
Jiaqi Li, Mengmeng Wang, Zilong Zheng, Muhan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs), despite their impressive performance in various
language tasks, are typically limited to processing texts within context-window
size. This limitation has spurred significant research efforts to enhance LLMs'
long-context understanding with high-quality long-sequence benchmarks. However,
prior datasets in this regard suffer from shortcomings, such as short context
length compared to the context window of modern LLMs; outdated documents that
have data leakage problems; and an emphasis on short dependency tasks rather
than long dependency tasks. In this paper, we present LooGLE, a Long Context
Generic Language Evaluation benchmark for LLMs' long context understanding.
LooGLE features relatively new documents post-2022, with over 24,000 tokens per
document and 6,000 newly generated questions spanning diverse domains. Human
annotators meticulously crafted more than 1,100 high-quality question-answer
pairs to meet the long dependency requirements. These pairs underwent thorough
cross-validation, yielding the most precise assessment of LLMs' long dependency
capabilities. The evaluation of eight state-of-the-art LLMs on LooGLE revealed
key findings: (i) commercial models outperformed open-sourced models; (ii) LLMs
excelled in short dependency tasks like short question-answering and cloze
tasks but struggled with more intricate long dependency tasks; (iii) in-context
learning and chaining thoughts offered only marginal improvements; (iv)
retrieval-based techniques demonstrated substantial benefits for short
question-answering, while strategies for extending context window length had
limited impact on long context understanding. As such, LooGLE not only provides
a systematic and comprehensive evaluation schema on long-context LLMs, but also
sheds light on future development of enhanced models towards "true long-context
understanding".
|
[
-0.3832093775,
-0.8180347085,
0.8799542189,
0.3331951201,
-0.2174122185,
-0.0740540326,
-0.6201538444,
-0.94785887,
-0.0178358983,
0.6743440628,
-0.4128724039,
-0.5405443311,
-0.5672453046,
0.0355010554,
-0.4039511085,
0.8038907051,
-0.1088150591,
-0.2930852175,
-0.4807280302,
-0.3497202992,
-0.494307518,
-0.2754721642,
-0.3139264882,
-0.3010562658,
0.53949368,
0.0532690212,
0.2847537994,
0.366979748,
0.2278866619,
0.2521199584,
-0.5149487257,
-0.0672068745,
-0.6681774855,
-0.0764156282,
-0.3970878124,
-0.0620121099,
-0.692122519,
-0.0236245748,
0.8344621062,
0.9329019189,
-0.0668481886,
0.19383578,
0.4111146033,
0.7758925557,
-0.7683926225,
0.059693899,
-0.4188053906,
-0.1819669902,
-0.1673384011,
0.1621612459,
-0.5092886686,
0.1027769893,
0.2405289412,
-0.3426817954,
-0.2460117787,
-0.0218130387,
0.5651814938,
0.1998613775,
-0.8179906607,
-0.3809823692,
-0.4539422691,
0.9280581474,
-0.8197319508,
0.3928186595,
0.2906413972,
0.4841895103,
-0.3685911596,
-0.670578897,
-0.1900223792,
-0.2999377549,
-0.166052267,
-0.0367821604,
0.0600133203,
-0.0149809187,
0.3308787048,
0.3113429546,
-0.4362906516,
0.2800770402,
-0.4016670883,
0.0681347623,
0.4318330884,
0.0499547198,
-0.1350990683,
-0.3448028564,
-0.6466747522,
0.4363330305,
-0.7117453218,
0.1411087811,
-0.0926799774,
0.1304094642,
-0.1869375259,
0.3123514056,
-0.4292545915,
1.0218877792,
-0.1723389328,
-0.3584826887,
0.246105656,
-0.1174452752,
-0.3521118164,
-0.172783792,
0.5728956461,
0.2431744039,
0.1482784599,
-0.211260885,
-0.2484534234,
-0.3157365918,
-0.1715725809,
-0.8142461181,
0.3918225467,
0.4004864097,
-0.2891145051,
-0.0525517389,
-0.2257792652,
-0.6926221848,
-0.3982053399,
-0.2876588106,
0.1744141132,
-0.3254587948,
0.1283351481,
0.2851043642,
0.0291088987,
0.1725082397,
0.5789448023,
-0.5554606318,
0.3917068839,
0.9239311218,
0.742634654,
-0.54708606,
-0.4971374869,
-0.6972695589,
0.2397831678,
-0.0384057201,
0.8666971922,
-0.4950104654,
-0.2697379887,
0.0326653831,
0.1828879267,
0.0723703951,
-0.7366199493,
0.4588754773,
-0.3956948221,
0.3166062236,
-0.1987130493,
-0.8002232909,
-0.0623653308,
0.3036903143,
-0.6859677434,
0.8688408732,
0.2779400945,
-0.603771925,
0.2845087945,
-0.6706630588,
-0.3842528164,
0.1974404752,
-0.2509689033,
0.1321891248,
0.1216857061,
0.0129011851,
0.4558394551,
-0.4801185131,
0.3314503431,
-0.3110824823,
-0.5455781817,
0.1209108979,
-0.2959824204,
0.7529489994,
-0.0098674726,
-0.2942945957,
-0.0152716273,
-0.7703540921,
0.1413809806,
0.0385784917,
-0.6325372458,
-0.2642111182,
0.0144065833,
0.0442960262,
0.1549477875,
0.4802057445,
-0.5148943067,
0.2079667896,
-0.1604694128,
0.6187562943,
0.7501305342,
-0.2846054435,
0.3800198138,
-0.1014534533,
0.4530001283,
-0.1213573366,
0.0574782006,
-0.3063677549,
-0.2952038944,
-0.4866072237,
-0.2839074135,
0.1052258387,
0.3711140454,
-0.2748555541,
0.4549402297,
-0.5816797614,
-0.0546706095,
-0.0107059926,
0.4196459651,
0.3798778653,
0.5447160602,
0.3054142594,
-0.2354718596,
-0.2719127536,
-0.8509017229,
-0.2142823339,
-0.0248603728,
-0.009481906,
0.6126008034,
0.6162801385,
-0.4682955146,
1.0016800165,
-0.4367000759,
-0.162347734,
-0.3398430347,
0.0165972877,
0.4726213515,
0.0818296075,
0.3397178352,
-0.4545989633,
-0.4023349583,
-0.0744808391,
-0.6843397617,
-0.0872889385,
0.2404501289,
0.07386069,
0.3169991672,
0.6599808335,
-0.6903306246,
0.1527792662,
0.8842808008,
-0.4532853365,
0.6646885276,
0.0364587978,
-0.1903380156,
-0.9237408042,
0.3009984195,
-0.3480900526,
-0.6081537604,
-0.457095474,
0.1340335608,
0.2886675,
-0.0419696197,
-0.7950054407,
1.1429138184,
-0.3918955624,
-0.1892182976,
-0.3227006197,
0.4866739213,
0.231647864,
0.3244173825,
0.0705058947,
0.6374619007,
0.2697426081,
-0.3324156404,
0.3645769358,
-0.0686263666,
-0.8830176592,
0.4608683586,
-0.5635389686,
0.2328519821,
-0.1176143065,
0.6656289101,
-0.6102688909,
-0.3554444611,
-0.0848022699,
-0.0286070816,
0.1877003163,
-0.4964414537,
-0.3889606595,
-0.3440664411,
-0.0529381819,
0.6974503398,
0.4975812137,
-0.6331272721,
0.5143179893,
0.0812139586,
-0.0147048067,
-0.7870534658,
-0.5073319674,
0.1834424734,
-0.3383860886,
-0.8109045625,
0.1158969551,
-0.0460892506,
-0.3967184126,
-0.1075862646,
-0.0277541,
-0.1227263287,
0.1809626073,
0.2613087595,
-0.0255015474,
-0.2868055701,
0.433069557,
-0.3551416993,
0.0038700684,
0.0730761886,
-0.2608148158,
0.5106412172,
-0.3311086893,
-0.2485724688,
0.0051722988,
0.3391014636,
0.5929345489,
-0.0973321497,
0.571686089,
0.3716468215,
-0.2043994218,
-0.4867677391,
-0.6974275708,
0.1615088731,
-0.4492734671,
0.6039720178,
-0.3178760707,
-1.2395615578,
0.4356912374,
-0.2768512666,
-0.0024877628,
0.2141588628,
0.3013109267,
-0.2104123533,
0.4524565041,
0.6244720817,
-0.3895224929,
0.3696299493,
-0.0374867097,
0.0635231286,
-0.9165727496,
0.059334565,
-0.0979040489,
-0.0694185197,
-0.4140079319,
-0.5508593917,
0.2394782305,
0.3662745953,
-0.1100301817,
0.1754781455,
0.0617460273,
0.7838572264,
0.0858259872,
-0.0743885934,
0.3375437558,
-0.2134368718,
0.2453829348,
0.437954396,
-0.296928674,
-0.545470655,
0.8879380226,
0.5983134508,
0.7389101982,
0.0173690394,
0.7425231934,
0.2070503235,
0.2361301333,
-0.815951705,
0.6567686796,
-0.1579562873,
-0.656381309,
-0.5279486775,
-0.279181093,
-0.9961640239,
0.1477740556,
0.2877029479,
-1.0109585524,
-0.1212476194,
0.1384327114,
-0.2624965012,
0.0569307208,
-0.4833640456,
0.9686140418,
-0.3792530596,
-0.434589237,
-0.133569181,
-0.4395427704,
0.4162403047,
-0.1247018129,
0.2963823676,
-0.359003365,
-0.0960077718,
0.7368231416,
-0.2822202146,
0.6858862638,
-0.0776855424,
-0.4916312993,
0.4179669917,
0.0002116651,
0.6712982655,
0.1083746701,
-0.0781845376,
0.1600916982,
0.1097031608,
-0.68885988,
-0.6714888215,
0.892876029,
-0.2295719981,
-0.8270097375,
-0.2145834267,
-0.4899799228,
-0.4167986214,
0.2804284692,
0.1648251265,
0.3546395898,
-0.3848489225,
0.2182032466,
0.5230156183,
-0.2400294989,
0.4496456087,
0.4851056337,
-0.6619089842,
-0.1141343117,
0.4866476953,
-0.2639504671,
0.5681999922,
0.18729496,
0.1434411108,
-0.0757726282,
-0.2828920484,
-0.350259304,
0.4269905984,
-0.9631162286,
0.1273970753,
-0.3601627052,
-0.1644448936,
-0.2943926156,
-0.1387527585,
-0.4095209837,
-0.2582310736,
0.0420320407,
0.0348279215,
0.1386167109,
0.9146175981,
0.24537839,
0.1644925475,
-0.7286877632,
0.1134291664,
0.4451385438,
0.5273054242,
0.0440323427,
-0.4886932373,
-0.4898583889,
-0.1419065446,
-0.0785588175,
-0.4852593839,
0.0347546041,
0.111203596,
0.180079937,
0.4541365206,
-0.2720931172,
0.6156218648,
-0.6475265026,
0.8520595431,
0.0412102304,
-0.9019790292,
0.3952976167,
-0.5127310753,
0.6088005304,
0.5069679022,
0.0928563848,
-0.6436361074,
0.0506115966,
-0.2497703135,
-0.719030261,
0.4238262475,
-0.0190582387,
0.0097770737,
-0.1058754027,
0.2799791396,
0.1989361495,
0.1215410382,
-0.8237351775,
0.1409090608,
0.1780734658,
0.1162914485,
-0.4147388935,
-0.4426737428,
-0.1342979819,
0.0301747713,
0.2013002187,
-0.2147521526,
0.1781937331,
-0.0249230042,
-0.2410521209,
0.0632076189,
0.6680421233,
0.5313571095,
1.0824724436,
-0.6185008883,
0.090298079,
0.4918046594,
-0.2250417173,
-0.0275451243,
-0.0726838857,
0.3233734667,
-0.0567427985,
0.7270132303,
0.6090896726,
0.1819157451,
-1.0930308104,
0.7066227198,
0.1237718686,
0.1132223755,
-0.546967864,
-0.0069404664,
0.4379658401,
0.1921194643,
0.1819935739,
-0.5430966616,
0.0857693553,
-0.8563202024,
-0.0323253013,
0.4280140996,
-0.487274617,
-0.1361893564,
0.1619687974,
0.2152757943,
-0.0202444289,
0.5673115253,
-0.0705299899,
-0.3642389476,
0.5343881845,
0.5199538469,
0.6302189827,
0.0574811213,
-0.2696081102,
0.1274256408,
-0.1396228075,
-0.1479751021,
0.2195292413,
-0.2176250666,
-0.2620804608,
-0.6597189903,
-0.6935157776,
-0.2275735885,
0.5438884497,
-0.6749785542,
0.2988272607,
-0.2714897692,
-0.0741934851,
-0.2606621087,
-0.0297697484,
-0.6405820847,
0.2198556662,
0.14576298,
1.1022731066,
-0.5354655981,
1.0399502516,
0.4001802802,
0.1817056388,
-0.1404114962,
0.0499519333,
-0.0707198605,
-0.7084903121,
0.9228268266,
0.5399329066,
-0.2126221359,
-0.3267247975,
-0.5415998697,
-0.9234930873,
1.1537430286,
0.1466806382,
-0.8723446727,
-0.3225337267,
0.2482870817,
0.4914304018,
-0.4131955802,
0.0923724025,
0.6615151763,
0.4093091786,
-0.2918024361,
-1.092000246,
0.1724739224,
-0.1067037955,
-0.228238225,
0.3473624885,
-0.7232379317,
0.7067243457,
-0.1045679525,
-0.2067490667,
0.3346318007,
0.5022976995,
0.2466558069,
0.3693659902,
0.6489965916,
0.5609862804,
0.581353128,
0.2070986629,
1.0906831026,
-0.3234649301,
0.3164491355,
1.6184456348,
-0.3589378893,
1.1155588627,
0.5027800798,
-0.097759068,
0.5720435381,
0.3384054303,
0.3401126266,
0.2773528099,
0.3804746568,
-0.346547991,
-0.3308895826,
-0.1232777536,
-0.3255333006,
0.3260942101,
0.3965441585,
-0.3066210747,
-0.224649474,
0.0513251983,
-0.1012195796,
-0.1256930679,
-0.0402827598,
0.5565925837,
0.4263603985,
-0.7790790796,
0.7801122069,
-0.1397283822,
0.5303112268,
-0.5066045523,
0.1343851835,
-0.3117441833,
0.1591117382,
-0.0781897977,
-0.8293271661,
-0.1009060293,
0.0733610541,
-0.1952839047,
0.0434855521,
0.5055884123,
-0.2152035683,
-0.2800206244,
0.7726806402,
0.5554722548,
0.2300836444,
-0.1635670364,
-0.3419041932,
0.1194650829,
-0.2669863105,
-0.3384692073,
0.5269021392,
0.3612414896,
-0.145846799,
0.7614231706,
0.134268418,
0.0293687899,
-0.1143677831,
-0.0173303895,
0.7356374264,
-0.9128194451,
-0.2754067481,
-0.7535848618,
0.3228124082,
-0.0600256585,
-0.2741551697,
0.5712049007,
0.5762759447,
0.8333361745,
0.1592143476,
0.7328371406,
0.0893624574,
0.61574018,
-0.744413197,
0.4127646387,
-0.7250378132,
0.3576081693,
-0.0399160869,
-1.082698822,
0.0672405809,
0.1158768013,
-0.5336748958,
0.0857904851,
0.8611167669,
0.4482726157,
-0.3291901648,
-0.2456958294,
0.3797972798,
0.4021078646,
0.3173930049,
0.90055722,
1.0868484974,
-0.2166549861,
0.3944920301,
-0.159869194,
-0.2234312892,
-0.3488826752,
-1.0856341124,
-1.0473381281,
-0.4850701392,
-0.0186284706,
-0.3122710288,
0.305225879,
0.8822484612,
0.7413743734,
-0.5984359384,
-0.5234405398,
0.1745226979,
0.0871427581,
0.1923518926,
-0.1830773503,
0.470687598,
-0.319737643,
-0.624992907,
0.7409921288,
0.3588083088,
-0.1139685735,
-0.1877396852,
-0.2502880096,
0.0387222767,
-0.0468917079,
0.9163361192,
0.3392695785,
-0.9644446373,
-0.4228529334,
-0.2316936851,
-0.1197921187,
0.1799391508,
0.6664354205,
-0.8694095016,
0.1685696393,
0.491782546,
0.3329967558,
0.4293655455,
0.1026982889,
0.3291918635,
-0.4020478427,
0.1640909016,
0.1863831282,
0.5820367336,
0.1891327947,
-0.1814832836,
0.5486010909,
-0.0919118673,
-0.6920443773,
-0.8144277334,
0.3795307279,
-1.0362854004,
-0.6472613811,
1.4922845364,
-0.3011368215,
-0.4652422667,
-0.0328524075,
-0.0796574578,
-0.254260689,
-0.3240847886,
0.6022636294,
0.6940424442,
-0.1081135571,
0.0316178389,
-0.6453443766,
0.3727345169,
0.450489223,
-0.8175835609,
0.3766365647,
0.5709491372,
0.3915184438,
0.0969389081,
0.5296466351,
0.0622099042,
0.2079474628,
-0.5055243373,
-0.2782877088,
0.0705727115,
-0.3977427781,
-0.3223094344,
0.0575051233,
0.3332856596,
0.3317012191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04420v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04420v1
|
Data Factors for Better Compositional Generalization
| 2023-11-08T01:27:34 | 2023-11-08T01:27:34 |
Xiang Zhou, Yichen Jiang, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent diagnostic datasets on compositional generalization, such as SCAN
(Lake and Baroni, 2018) and COGS (Kim and Linzen, 2020), expose severe problems
in models trained from scratch on these datasets. However, in contrast to this
poor performance, state-of-the-art models trained on larger and more general
datasets show better generalization ability. In this work, to reconcile this
inconsistency, we conduct an empirical analysis by training Transformer models
on a variety of training sets with different data factors, including dataset
scale, pattern complexity, example difficulty, etc. First, we show that
increased dataset complexity can lead to better generalization behavior on
multiple different generalization challenges. To further understand this
improvement, we show two axes of the benefit from more complex datasets: they
provide more diverse examples so compositional understanding becomes more
effective, and they also prevent ungeneralizable memorization of the examples
due to reduced example repetition frequency. Finally, we explore how training
examples of different difficulty levels influence generalization differently.
On synthetic datasets, simple examples invoke stronger compositionality than
hard examples do. On larger-scale real language datasets, while hard examples
become more important potentially to ensure decent data coverage, a balanced
mixture of simple and hard examples manages to induce the strongest
generalizability. The code and data for this work are available at
https://github.com/owenzx/data4comp
|
[
-0.3088754117,
-0.5852047801,
0.5180903673,
0.3530195355,
-0.0903348923,
0.1701146215,
-0.4369269013,
-0.2659245729,
-0.2968097329,
0.2521973252,
-0.3420156538,
-0.5484688878,
-0.6834713221,
0.1493074745,
-0.3633599579,
1.1209381819,
-0.1029693857,
0.1603315324,
-0.4902606606,
-0.2688535452,
-0.6751626134,
-0.4962810576,
-0.4791788161,
-0.7218910456,
0.4344261885,
0.3579903841,
0.5162354112,
0.7944232821,
0.7971069813,
0.2744966745,
0.0453528129,
0.0945264325,
-0.5777774453,
0.2251789123,
-0.0354635231,
-0.8436304331,
-0.2029194087,
0.0220032372,
0.3369909823,
1.1378647089,
-0.2422511131,
-0.0858984962,
-0.0920808613,
0.792183578,
-0.4350165129,
0.5052466989,
-0.4182373285,
0.196900323,
0.1726631075,
0.1240214184,
-0.3800173998,
-0.1692081988,
0.353572607,
-0.8750821948,
0.816549778,
-0.0969574153,
0.6467323899,
0.2873668969,
-0.7066682577,
-0.3712302744,
-1.3589169979,
0.9742972851,
-0.3659431636,
0.5279357433,
0.2191104293,
0.3850223422,
0.0267753657,
-0.8852500319,
-0.4430006146,
-0.0014025737,
-0.3570573628,
0.1867188513,
-0.3299638033,
0.0688341036,
0.5011037588,
0.8076948524,
-0.4736242592,
-0.0026356624,
-0.4794068038,
-0.1914550215,
0.585316658,
0.5588440299,
0.3292616904,
0.1770348847,
0.1264256835,
-0.5636758208,
-0.6971625686,
0.241340667,
0.3357994556,
0.1989973485,
-0.3331520855,
0.3091185689,
-0.2373544127,
0.8388280869,
0.3299958408,
-0.1537270099,
0.4768015444,
-0.5541783571,
-0.0961969569,
-0.3807189763,
0.4291380346,
0.2278465033,
0.4134562016,
-0.4793296754,
-0.1099404395,
0.087365903,
0.3351807594,
-0.8195286989,
-0.4512327313,
0.2246675491,
-0.4469360113,
-0.2590918839,
0.4343932271,
-0.5185813308,
-0.3028168082,
-0.9181151986,
0.2102511376,
-0.3480887413,
-0.2359027117,
0.2975622118,
-0.2035918683,
0.4713829756,
0.0257005729,
-1.0821615458,
0.3312497437,
0.8205402493,
0.6202899814,
-0.3556374311,
-0.0497340485,
-0.2174946815,
0.1057465598,
-0.5024099946,
0.6663876772,
-0.7763828635,
-0.3585564196,
-0.1528040916,
0.0589766875,
-0.4595054984,
-0.9317780733,
0.5765856504,
-0.2366218418,
0.4137835205,
-0.4476273656,
-0.6478978992,
-0.2498224527,
0.1353753805,
-0.9963209629,
0.8440517187,
0.5009026527,
-0.6245768666,
0.6731337309,
-0.5443011522,
-0.682703197,
-0.24407731,
-0.4200774431,
-0.7447561026,
0.4504766762,
0.3203703165,
0.6179969311,
-0.2483810931,
0.4440522194,
-0.2581655085,
-0.3060290813,
0.122845985,
-0.1163438633,
0.2345413119,
0.0430905558,
-0.3853293359,
0.012339402,
-0.7911959291,
-0.1919523478,
0.2641717196,
-0.3319965005,
-0.3351252377,
0.0054200394,
-0.2299880236,
-0.0408996902,
-0.2017522007,
-0.271181643,
0.2327937633,
-0.3520538509,
0.2977593243,
0.5486181378,
0.1790399849,
0.7130087614,
-0.5061597824,
0.711787641,
0.4432575703,
0.0455528125,
-0.3756262958,
-0.3010797799,
-0.8615993857,
-0.2846145928,
0.4765027165,
0.3776838481,
-0.6725895405,
0.4153692126,
-0.5354322791,
-0.5641788244,
-0.3199247122,
0.2426812649,
0.3240574598,
0.4207908213,
0.4144619703,
-0.201611802,
-0.6837130189,
-1.050417304,
0.0057136649,
0.2819624841,
-0.4558560848,
0.3506369889,
0.2380914986,
-0.2770549953,
0.9971506,
-0.7651003003,
-0.118520841,
-0.43072173,
0.0376787409,
0.3842375278,
0.4471236169,
0.5900447369,
-0.9428887367,
-0.5134868622,
0.0256423056,
-0.8211425543,
0.0281826705,
-0.1483402699,
0.0624814667,
-0.1299370974,
0.4688234031,
-0.2988795936,
0.1138424203,
0.4883820415,
-0.1702687889,
0.220908463,
-0.2362332493,
-0.0906546935,
-1.0875062943,
-0.0414797887,
0.227559045,
0.0027877819,
-1.0650622845,
0.0271780882,
-0.0484688617,
-0.0687559322,
-0.0684340447,
0.0222707614,
-0.2329785973,
0.1321763992,
0.0045509385,
-0.6495659351,
0.1168869063,
0.5020734072,
-0.0837908834,
0.7861263156,
0.6830695271,
-0.7597825527,
0.3731298745,
0.1184501797,
-0.2734957039,
0.4929728806,
-1.0772720575,
0.1376328617,
-0.3153308928,
0.5491669774,
-0.9805301428,
-0.4488839209,
0.0014267826,
0.1238447577,
0.4584017098,
0.0798890665,
-0.282112807,
-0.2997704148,
-0.2627470791,
0.4165191054,
0.4557615519,
-0.5652672648,
0.9074715972,
-0.1193918139,
0.0920788422,
-0.2525030077,
-0.660969317,
-0.236188218,
-0.4699765742,
-0.6591850519,
0.4364350736,
-0.3190592229,
-0.2384406179,
-0.2810622156,
-0.3855163753,
-0.08858338,
0.0440551452,
0.2285304517,
0.0834047124,
-0.297653228,
0.3206234276,
0.0195137002,
-0.3122194111,
0.0411604494,
-0.0642029494,
0.6889213324,
-0.2573311031,
-0.3930445015,
-0.2039706409,
0.3588369489,
0.4633735716,
-0.0520942286,
0.6222570539,
0.7365097404,
-0.1488088667,
-0.2933783829,
-0.350030899,
-0.3536132574,
-0.4576124847,
0.2308103591,
-0.4071098864,
-0.7938395143,
0.5886717439,
0.0343852527,
0.0427948274,
0.4720210135,
0.3990344703,
-0.0886867344,
0.9910776019,
0.5288822651,
-0.264670074,
0.4054720998,
-0.7546777725,
0.2826626897,
-0.7433211803,
-0.4555169344,
-0.3426710963,
-0.5413331389,
-0.8123379946,
-0.3525548577,
0.3030706346,
-0.3489047289,
-0.0332862623,
0.1382172704,
-0.4789988995,
0.6082524657,
0.4146499038,
0.4251253605,
0.3251564205,
0.2158032507,
0.0818551257,
-0.0753458217,
-0.7157407403,
-0.1823458076,
1.5440214872,
0.3242020011,
0.8170435429,
0.0609771907,
0.5374352932,
0.245342657,
0.1338419914,
-0.9135255814,
0.0762100145,
-0.5827168822,
-0.4536454976,
-0.1717469543,
-0.5127558708,
-1.2251472473,
0.2947410941,
-0.1423635334,
-0.049816452,
0.5455986857,
0.2416041791,
-0.1486738473,
0.005856053,
-0.9349357486,
0.6279517412,
0.1421350837,
-0.0190107208,
-0.0108055137,
-0.5503266454,
0.2810225487,
-0.2155437768,
0.1067234352,
0.2907148302,
0.177245155,
0.6225720048,
-0.144225806,
0.879519403,
-0.1645255685,
-0.1972674876,
0.1327636987,
-0.1794735789,
0.4909402728,
-0.1912993938,
0.1576354504,
-0.0244918931,
-0.2651823759,
-0.5706998706,
-0.8513282537,
0.2332820445,
-0.8773614168,
-0.4677110612,
0.0325404406,
-0.6151830554,
-0.4043281078,
-0.3562070131,
0.5406482816,
0.6894206405,
-0.0594220683,
0.8794314861,
1.0570818186,
0.118376039,
0.273414433,
0.4053013623,
0.2598750889,
-0.1988513619,
1.0791201591,
0.2001216859,
0.2514375746,
0.3130515218,
0.3783324957,
0.0295968615,
-0.5216548443,
-0.1533673406,
0.0722674802,
-0.6581516862,
-0.1850065291,
-0.7038265467,
-0.0457300916,
-0.2235460728,
0.0108621921,
-0.1163376272,
-0.4368264377,
-0.2974922955,
-0.3870581686,
0.0984379128,
0.7969474196,
0.0928741395,
0.5029768944,
-0.3560009301,
0.5147051811,
0.6988001466,
0.3767867386,
0.088023439,
-0.5254260302,
-0.3843345344,
-0.073653236,
-0.4330351949,
-0.4904395342,
-0.1705525368,
0.4680958092,
0.7487877607,
0.5146762729,
-0.2835655808,
0.4309819341,
-0.1277943105,
0.6095289588,
-0.0648874119,
-0.8564376235,
0.2020881474,
-0.4375331998,
0.3146881759,
0.6542341113,
0.3800757229,
-0.6117092371,
-0.3127650321,
-0.6416812539,
-0.7781667709,
0.5495968461,
0.2416003048,
0.3159146607,
0.3118205369,
0.5500824451,
0.3725064695,
0.0557486601,
-0.6438424587,
-0.3292286396,
-0.3440136313,
-0.5144981742,
-0.2634584904,
-0.1256669909,
-0.1739776731,
-0.6196029186,
0.4554935396,
-0.1857910454,
0.2063055634,
-0.0411251336,
-0.207962513,
0.0810405761,
0.2694091797,
0.7073649168,
0.6370760798,
0.0562239699,
0.2125663161,
0.2017068863,
-0.5714175701,
0.3709937334,
-0.1504525989,
-0.0657259375,
-0.2596109211,
0.9159033895,
0.984832406,
0.0684794933,
-0.2447190136,
0.516952157,
-0.1348178536,
-0.4694231749,
0.0518051758,
0.5280713439,
-0.0745818391,
0.1236562729,
0.4133124053,
-0.1649224013,
0.2260373533,
-0.4006098211,
0.0454443581,
0.0575423501,
-0.0854015797,
-0.5776506066,
0.1567088813,
0.1610967368,
0.092936255,
0.6246208549,
-0.0080179116,
-0.5058141947,
0.9504978657,
0.554651022,
0.661485672,
-0.3725240231,
0.1969955862,
0.3547438979,
0.235341385,
-0.1886404455,
0.1007441059,
-0.1162826568,
-0.8172995448,
-0.4538516998,
-0.2831147611,
-0.5369061828,
0.3911758065,
-0.7508474588,
-0.0365985557,
-0.3860151172,
0.1236465424,
-0.0110949278,
-0.046266526,
-1.0564571619,
0.5470485687,
-0.2048924416,
0.4922658205,
-1.4261040688,
0.3871481717,
0.6148707867,
-0.2766252458,
-0.9843680859,
0.020196123,
-0.4523186386,
-0.5672392845,
0.4421335757,
0.2173608691,
0.416180104,
-0.2311262041,
-0.7108774185,
-0.7127363086,
1.1576857567,
0.3590827584,
-0.601159513,
0.0673236698,
0.6225783229,
0.9567066431,
-0.6643664241,
0.0361289792,
1.0696513653,
0.6609598398,
0.1615775526,
-0.4821144938,
0.0623667389,
-0.1961484998,
0.1155588999,
0.1209730431,
-0.4345591068,
0.8336901665,
0.0199535023,
-0.1541260034,
-0.3835443258,
0.4666517973,
-0.027400177,
0.6229714155,
0.5366485715,
0.7514666915,
0.719802618,
-0.3848148584,
1.1575723886,
-0.1090885475,
0.2602124214,
1.2065842152,
0.1185557023,
0.183822602,
0.3593306243,
-0.4772503078,
0.7236974835,
0.5602212548,
-0.4936492741,
0.5531399846,
0.3300441504,
-0.1864397079,
-0.323507309,
0.103493169,
-0.532603085,
0.6400768161,
0.2590303719,
-0.5233765841,
-0.2313738018,
0.2392450124,
-0.056059815,
0.0643885583,
0.0089956736,
1.0944496393,
-0.1916931123,
-0.4675164819,
0.5120275617,
-0.0575942025,
0.5557630062,
-0.5177795291,
0.0965092182,
-0.5274066329,
0.0164266825,
-0.4287063181,
-0.4930615723,
0.3962039053,
-0.2094172537,
-0.5544516444,
0.0480279364,
0.6167357564,
-0.4152138829,
-0.5400444269,
-0.0828827545,
0.5073459744,
-0.203423053,
-0.1708635688,
-0.2717553675,
-0.0301762763,
-0.0777324736,
-0.2762346268,
0.1700416058,
0.3548624516,
-0.0453539677,
0.48980847,
0.7178615332,
-0.2109633535,
0.061670959,
0.3417792916,
0.9821161032,
-0.5126833916,
-0.2438385785,
-0.7465191483,
0.4160849452,
-0.0871344507,
-0.018271286,
0.4977840483,
0.6848753691,
0.8364284635,
-0.2935192287,
0.7995148301,
0.1322250068,
0.2651194334,
-0.4610517323,
0.1697037816,
-0.1795871109,
0.1971091628,
0.027296735,
-1.1627306938,
-0.4125963151,
0.4234761,
-0.3747499883,
0.4112144411,
0.6109606624,
0.613740623,
-0.3849703074,
0.021492118,
0.3195977211,
-0.0827852637,
0.6445398927,
0.5175613761,
0.6000827551,
-0.4236848652,
0.4199019074,
-0.4395651221,
-0.0306122378,
-0.1172307506,
-0.7180364728,
-0.9570616484,
-0.6503543854,
-0.2047469616,
-0.088932544,
-0.372816205,
0.7451655865,
0.8655670881,
-1.0120887756,
-0.0208470114,
-0.4347164035,
0.0472189076,
-0.1121589094,
-0.2433357388,
0.2478313297,
-0.4030595422,
-0.6612576246,
0.2426754683,
-0.1195826381,
0.3491627574,
-0.125042364,
0.0276886076,
0.4809326828,
0.1996316612,
0.7236621976,
0.0938723385,
-0.265207082,
-0.2475821823,
0.0367915705,
0.0454435088,
0.3008268476,
1.3165915012,
-0.5368926525,
0.4969168603,
0.395068109,
0.6558820605,
0.6298083067,
0.1084541306,
0.6321696043,
-0.9354554415,
-0.0412308834,
-0.1206109449,
0.3518009484,
0.5310109854,
-0.3744015992,
0.8445286155,
0.3904093802,
-0.2994043827,
-0.5669741631,
0.2918569744,
-0.8972155452,
-0.1279877871,
1.1180957556,
-0.0214359518,
0.0715662315,
-0.0762304664,
-0.0190276038,
0.2569875121,
-0.2865047455,
0.8921491504,
1.0008069277,
-0.1760318577,
0.1772359461,
-0.1971525997,
0.337593168,
0.4853801131,
-1.0414004326,
0.0551370308,
0.3485613763,
0.499936074,
0.1347816288,
0.0175665505,
0.1241365671,
0.1445578933,
-0.2352274507,
-0.2478235215,
-0.2192590535,
-0.4298245907,
-0.7142908573,
0.2388237268,
-0.2411911488,
0.0765224025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04378v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04378v2
|
Watermarks in the Sand: Impossibility of Strong Watermarking for Generative Models
| 2023-11-07T22:52:54 | 2023-11-15T00:21:29 |
Hanlin Zhang, Benjamin L. Edelman, Danilo Francati, Daniele Venturi, Giuseppe Ateniese, Boaz Barak
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Watermarking generative models consists of planting a statistical signal
(watermark) in a model's output so that it can be later verified that the
output was generated by the given model. A strong watermarking scheme satisfies
the property that a computationally bounded attacker cannot erase the watermark
without causing significant quality degradation. In this paper, we study the
(im)possibility of strong watermarking schemes. We prove that, under
well-specified and natural assumptions, strong watermarking is impossible to
achieve. This holds even in the private detection algorithm setting, where the
watermark insertion and detection algorithms share a secret key, unknown to the
attacker. To prove this result, we introduce a generic efficient watermark
attack; the attacker is not required to know the private key of the scheme or
even which scheme is used. Our attack is based on two assumptions: (1) The
attacker has access to a "quality oracle" that can evaluate whether a candidate
output is a high-quality response to a prompt, and (2) The attacker has access
to a "perturbation oracle" which can modify an output with a nontrivial
probability of maintaining quality, and which induces an efficiently mixing
random walk on high-quality outputs. We argue that both assumptions can be
satisfied in practice by an attacker with weaker computational capabilities
than the watermarked model itself, to which the attacker has only black-box
access. Furthermore, our assumptions will likely only be easier to satisfy over
time as models grow in capabilities and modalities. We demonstrate the
feasibility of our attack by instantiating it to attack three existing
watermarking schemes for large language models: Kirchenbauer et al. (2023),
Kuditipudi et al. (2023), and Zhao et al. (2023). The same attack successfully
removes the watermarks planted by all three schemes, with only minor quality
degradation.
|
[
-0.2704230547,
-0.9420930743,
0.5876921415,
0.2654101849,
-0.476582706,
0.0849221796,
0.1352934539,
-0.6170709133,
0.0153538361,
0.7046599984,
-0.2031487077,
-0.2202204913,
-0.8281087875,
-0.3017766774,
-1.0383433104,
0.7939380407,
0.1720350534,
-0.1344044954,
-0.0964124352,
-0.3151400983,
-0.1829634607,
-0.7045438886,
-0.4253092408,
-0.1693760306,
0.166596815,
-0.2529036999,
1.0187559128,
0.8479348421,
0.6009019613,
0.3015594184,
-0.3821656108,
-0.2515648007,
-0.5083126426,
0.4513282776,
-0.0890425593,
-0.4241296649,
-0.0544003844,
-0.1907436997,
0.6845930219,
0.5850545168,
0.1020306796,
-0.1386970878,
0.0071871667,
0.668931663,
-1.0949412584,
-0.0210601501,
-0.7855935693,
0.1249601468,
-0.5535029769,
0.1257247031,
-0.4909013808,
-0.1282566041,
-0.2044375539,
-0.4027301669,
0.0879881978,
-0.0760229155,
1.3443399668,
0.1728414297,
-0.1116871312,
-0.1196759045,
-1.3406401873,
0.7117294669,
-0.8008486032,
-0.105280064,
0.5760714412,
0.429949373,
-0.2175085396,
-0.6296564341,
-0.5547787547,
-0.1082673371,
0.2858281136,
0.0929618701,
-0.4800614715,
0.0908810496,
0.5120794773,
0.8216179013,
-0.2048989534,
-0.2382404357,
-0.0351790786,
-0.1217760891,
0.6401047111,
-0.0097222365,
0.3174976408,
0.0599850006,
-0.5249595046,
-0.3840978444,
-0.740585506,
0.1102058217,
0.7088556886,
0.0815012231,
-0.1079666093,
0.5451461077,
0.0809803978,
0.5841030478,
-0.089181602,
-0.0358400829,
-0.3631225824,
-0.1094023511,
-0.147634089,
-0.2172071338,
0.7996742725,
-0.1850809306,
0.2699755728,
-0.2253201306,
-0.499417454,
0.1746167541,
0.2199681103,
-0.5413175225,
-0.3694627285,
0.273920089,
-0.4529018998,
-0.3962867558,
0.3264871538,
-0.7688369751,
-0.6641917825,
0.3106517792,
0.803516984,
-0.2462287098,
-0.4957021475,
0.0493879616,
-0.2485699952,
0.2131012827,
0.1214066669,
-0.7131242752,
0.4728828073,
0.6037621498,
0.5901827216,
0.0276115425,
0.0962651744,
-0.3860709667,
0.3104176521,
-0.513033092,
0.614610374,
-0.737825036,
-0.4588542581,
0.0217021257,
-0.2374686301,
0.2286942005,
-0.6255267262,
0.038410522,
-0.8264523149,
-0.0729873329,
-0.1408499628,
-0.6724846363,
-0.108180441,
-0.0141299535,
-0.8704884648,
0.7291802764,
0.0797378197,
-0.7323232889,
0.0034613679,
-0.3916009665,
-0.5106960535,
-0.1011762246,
0.0095652742,
-0.7222471237,
0.1827365458,
-0.1104798168,
0.287884593,
-0.2662851512,
0.1500611454,
-0.6878812313,
-0.277764976,
0.7102159262,
-0.7230877876,
0.7910504937,
0.0678199381,
-0.7090417147,
-0.1283168793,
-0.9552502632,
0.1074834093,
0.6444950104,
-0.1130584031,
-0.4108722508,
0.1472760439,
-0.1033075526,
-0.0428503081,
0.1966083795,
-0.4248007834,
0.098140724,
-0.3035649955,
0.3915474415,
0.9551480412,
0.3469041288,
0.3125498593,
-0.1087149009,
0.5836284161,
-0.1348925531,
0.3321317732,
-0.1898608059,
-0.5580590367,
-0.7113179564,
-0.3853116632,
0.6421542764,
0.3479002416,
-0.5573354959,
0.0313699394,
-0.0758648738,
-0.579754293,
-0.3730108142,
0.2746379972,
0.7234887481,
-0.0051870765,
0.4232667387,
-0.3941936195,
-0.0542141199,
-0.9395118356,
-0.3823718429,
-0.2124150395,
0.1036342606,
0.227963075,
0.5206538439,
0.3126872182,
0.8598915935,
-0.4832654297,
-0.041941233,
-0.1437933743,
0.0704746544,
0.1525987238,
0.6316866875,
0.4839724898,
-0.9636257291,
-0.2837214172,
-0.2737077773,
-0.8589578271,
-0.0348984338,
-0.0380219147,
0.0908259824,
-0.2471938431,
0.3753581047,
-0.6504873037,
0.6520223618,
0.7493630648,
-0.3221438527,
0.5085623264,
-0.2431368828,
-0.0880684555,
-0.7680225968,
-0.042534925,
-0.0743253604,
-0.0643243492,
-0.712444365,
0.4192929268,
-0.0269267093,
-0.4273033142,
-0.3735899627,
0.554138422,
-0.1401072741,
0.0340485722,
-0.4957048297,
-0.5921451449,
-0.0199328791,
0.3913808167,
-0.2746442258,
0.5018063784,
0.6147961617,
-0.4859294295,
0.1049588174,
-0.1599753946,
-0.2287583947,
0.5220131874,
-0.9574402571,
0.177553609,
-0.0593790859,
0.0748888627,
-1.0846475363,
-0.2148986608,
0.3923471272,
-0.1570841521,
0.4761661291,
-0.4447314739,
-0.5172680616,
-0.0438007079,
-0.0968734846,
0.3327893615,
0.6234720349,
-0.6339536309,
0.5627169609,
0.1882515103,
0.1747106463,
-0.5052304864,
-0.6561949253,
0.221416831,
-0.2349967659,
-0.6554342508,
0.4441943467,
0.0463869013,
-0.4296226799,
0.2230741382,
-0.2844147682,
-0.3689852953,
0.4556573033,
0.6187176108,
0.0012035593,
-0.0774556771,
-0.3022617102,
-0.0883907676,
-0.3673362732,
0.06358926,
-0.1792801172,
0.393745333,
0.1877949536,
-0.9157283902,
-0.567794323,
0.555360198,
0.8072126508,
-0.3714375496,
0.6388633251,
0.3724058867,
-0.7287401557,
-0.2293007225,
-0.4579091966,
-0.1940687001,
-0.5037158132,
0.0677550435,
-0.3204031587,
-0.5486635566,
0.5626999736,
0.0544610396,
0.0855431184,
0.4634755552,
-0.0640117228,
-0.2473892272,
1.1062561274,
0.4634743929,
-0.1435236186,
0.4500920177,
-0.461176157,
0.2665271759,
-0.635084331,
0.096837081,
-0.6156754494,
-0.1850215048,
-0.4021659791,
-0.1256564558,
-0.0419901609,
0.3988268673,
-0.2430446893,
0.2593117356,
-0.3764980435,
0.4637258351,
0.6113343835,
0.1770189553,
0.1881249398,
0.036640577,
0.0501250848,
-0.1151610911,
-0.5224641562,
-0.4923091233,
1.0075199604,
0.303242743,
0.8814202547,
0.1951578856,
0.6986707449,
0.6461612582,
0.1202032119,
-0.186369285,
0.6279367208,
0.0129329273,
-0.7558381557,
-0.2122647911,
-0.3544763029,
-1.0164908171,
0.2805142999,
-0.4563884139,
-0.6344791651,
0.3510249853,
0.2763088346,
-0.2983294129,
0.7066216469,
-0.5746261477,
0.8326507807,
-0.2452935427,
-0.7747089863,
-0.2597918212,
-0.3974242508,
0.248594746,
-0.1451553106,
0.3056739569,
-0.2444316894,
0.2299514562,
0.5933842063,
-0.5637683868,
0.857467711,
-0.6013087034,
-0.0233663507,
0.4015006423,
0.4069187641,
0.6991354227,
-0.0166843813,
0.2663444877,
0.1281188875,
-0.1643775851,
-0.7872804403,
-0.7303587198,
0.2762674689,
-0.6076892018,
-0.8230726719,
-0.5527316332,
-0.0091159185,
-0.1206878871,
0.1236056611,
0.1232626587,
0.3881858289,
-0.008313043,
0.2015800774,
0.7085348368,
-0.2313828617,
0.5642225146,
0.2069112211,
0.0768197551,
-0.3915317655,
1.3153141737,
0.128278017,
0.6155388355,
0.0751431808,
0.1587486863,
0.0100723812,
-0.9408050776,
-0.1904332489,
0.1062244102,
-0.639965415,
-0.1532642841,
-0.350635618,
-0.4327661991,
0.1577950418,
-0.0718420446,
-0.6884952188,
-0.3171327412,
0.0292016771,
0.2897922993,
0.2003032714,
0.796607852,
0.1007723436,
0.3939301372,
-0.4316683114,
0.438244462,
0.7849719524,
0.3101941049,
0.1975348592,
-0.4747122824,
0.0481924452,
0.1286711246,
-0.5000329018,
-0.9595390558,
0.1221720651,
0.0319315083,
0.312941879,
0.9622661471,
0.0777367577,
0.6099105477,
-0.2047736794,
0.8889315128,
0.1598103493,
-0.9891106486,
0.54452914,
-0.316916585,
0.1904717535,
0.379460454,
0.1097446457,
-0.0034805157,
-0.7808856964,
-1.1618121862,
-0.9987062216,
0.1894914508,
0.4954786003,
0.4289562404,
0.1912220716,
0.3639930785,
-0.0568189137,
0.1400045455,
-0.8690747023,
-0.3533500731,
-0.3253602386,
0.1222118959,
0.2616999745,
-0.5235800743,
-0.130529061,
0.0429696217,
0.7673458457,
0.2302275449,
0.3313390613,
0.0547408238,
0.0266752634,
-0.0392076522,
0.2808780372,
0.3314966857,
0.4823778868,
-0.0655955598,
0.2625826895,
-0.2206559032,
-0.2785465419,
0.371286571,
0.0490946062,
-0.4647774398,
0.0114491256,
0.5594838262,
0.6764919758,
0.2606067955,
-0.4465962052,
0.7195516229,
-0.0730920583,
-0.07297647,
-0.3624579906,
0.3786700666,
0.0775280744,
0.2092939913,
0.6008903384,
0.2206471264,
-0.2400045246,
-0.3038949966,
-0.1427737623,
0.7237046957,
-0.4469123483,
-0.3462017179,
0.9475624561,
-0.1407268196,
-0.2699468136,
0.4319470525,
-0.207614392,
-0.3758728206,
0.6395881176,
0.6743748188,
0.6824796796,
-0.2819916904,
-0.0865613073,
0.1977553219,
0.3060324788,
-0.2772065997,
0.0802634731,
-0.0722581446,
-0.7312773466,
-0.2211673558,
-0.5553915501,
-0.5795176029,
0.4305938184,
-0.574891448,
-0.2611631155,
-0.972238481,
-0.3121826351,
0.1848584116,
-0.3516653478,
-0.2210635245,
0.1293891072,
0.1916978061,
0.4378739297,
-0.854434073,
0.6163858175,
0.3216776848,
-0.3436609209,
-0.4671429694,
0.0053211148,
-0.1181318536,
-0.6095756292,
0.1639024466,
-0.1436056942,
0.2060869187,
-0.1944449991,
-0.7986332774,
-0.9943115711,
0.6112212539,
0.7135979533,
-0.2515413463,
0.2721006274,
0.2599615753,
0.4111189544,
0.1427458823,
-0.3234564662,
0.2011941522,
0.59292382,
-0.2215297669,
-0.4496083856,
0.1809017062,
-0.4153332114,
0.0434510782,
0.1911456287,
-0.5086176395,
0.7272846699,
-0.0820216984,
-0.3878334165,
0.2618493736,
0.8114075065,
0.1282515675,
0.028802488,
0.5093098879,
0.7261735797,
0.5650809407,
-0.421528995,
1.3981951475,
-0.3029694855,
0.1651529074,
0.8827793002,
-0.1035502255,
0.8312684298,
0.461168319,
-0.4512712657,
0.3686222732,
0.3112238646,
-0.397405684,
0.5870471001,
0.2845151424,
-0.5547379851,
-0.3680138588,
-0.0933823884,
-0.533328414,
0.4069035947,
0.2344782799,
-0.3365980089,
0.0489143878,
0.0067078131,
0.0445131883,
0.3191174865,
-0.0969041958,
0.7004814744,
0.1478712559,
-0.1803479046,
0.6166772246,
0.1528748423,
0.4866317511,
-0.8018917441,
-0.084508948,
-0.0757000297,
0.1876130104,
-0.1686680168,
-0.6020468473,
0.0474577025,
-0.0635050833,
-0.2246692479,
-0.1603233516,
0.7663578391,
-0.0765793175,
-0.2839569449,
0.2877243161,
0.3117349744,
0.0109088439,
-0.2611423433,
-0.6957352161,
0.22620368,
-0.1943156421,
-0.3136067688,
0.5309900045,
0.1191378608,
-0.0288099628,
0.7855715156,
0.8727767467,
0.3414756954,
0.0496180095,
-0.0798517764,
0.6080673933,
-0.5105785728,
-0.3473273814,
-0.9760302901,
0.2677773833,
-0.2832053602,
-0.0820735022,
0.7491357327,
0.4018737376,
0.5886229277,
0.0405746065,
0.9231889844,
0.1434375793,
-0.1246644482,
-0.3483310044,
0.7374104261,
-0.2478355914,
0.1980358213,
-0.5760621428,
-0.8785623312,
-0.3310782313,
0.5040051341,
-0.1664284319,
0.040573556,
0.5248077512,
0.7333782911,
-0.0754978061,
0.0920895562,
0.1995898634,
0.1719385386,
0.5145637393,
0.3726922572,
0.9442407489,
-0.4469013512,
0.6530966163,
-0.5379207134,
-0.1900040954,
0.0947480425,
-0.8410134912,
-0.6422570348,
-0.5413565636,
-0.4896482527,
-0.7952929139,
0.5270344019,
0.3381865919,
0.6956198215,
-0.8954316378,
-0.0062046223,
-0.1051811874,
0.2321021408,
-0.4516391456,
-0.2209302187,
0.641014576,
0.1912088543,
-0.430931896,
0.2573716938,
0.3445459008,
0.5811215043,
-0.3937180936,
0.0577134266,
0.0776247084,
0.2516075075,
0.0980022252,
0.7811856866,
-0.5206950307,
-0.2789271772,
-0.4056636691,
-0.1283908337,
0.0004300176,
0.5707505345,
-0.4323044717,
0.5405967832,
0.1394035816,
0.8484348655,
0.5993227363,
-0.0254119206,
0.3752730191,
-0.5207856297,
0.119497247,
0.2743538916,
0.4131093025,
0.4372893572,
-0.1450750381,
0.236286059,
0.6327872276,
-0.1304599196,
-0.8740354776,
0.1357094795,
-0.7690351009,
-0.3770450056,
1.1439653635,
-0.3735849857,
-0.4417940974,
-0.1824781299,
0.0538902916,
-0.1741864234,
-0.2089970708,
1.0335963964,
0.7860158682,
0.2600229681,
0.2885291278,
-0.4957845509,
0.3703771532,
0.5007588267,
-0.6551594138,
0.1050206795,
0.1106562018,
0.2425651401,
0.2129625976,
0.4464447796,
-0.4462876022,
0.4734929502,
0.1570207477,
-0.0408038385,
-0.1058463231,
-0.1415787488,
-0.3671469688,
0.844915688,
0.2439190596,
-0.1669925153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04368v1
|
Evaluating multiple large language models in pediatric ophthalmology
| 2023-11-07T22:23:51 | 2023-11-07T22:23:51 |
Jason Holmes, Rui Peng, Yiwei Li, Jinyu Hu, Zhengliang Liu, Zihao Wu, Huan Zhao, Xi Jiang, Wei Liu, Hong Wei, Jie Zou, Tianming Liu, Yi Shao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
IMPORTANCE The response effectiveness of different large language models
(LLMs) and various individuals, including medical students, graduate students,
and practicing physicians, in pediatric ophthalmology consultations, has not
been clearly established yet. OBJECTIVE Design a 100-question exam based on
pediatric ophthalmology to evaluate the performance of LLMs in highly
specialized scenarios and compare them with the performance of medical students
and physicians at different levels. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS This
survey study assessed three LLMs, namely ChatGPT (GPT-3.5), GPT-4, and PaLM2,
were assessed alongside three human cohorts: medical students, postgraduate
students, and attending physicians, in their ability to answer questions
related to pediatric ophthalmology. It was conducted by administering
questionnaires in the form of test papers through the LLM network interface,
with the valuable participation of volunteers. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Mean
scores of LLM and humans on 100 multiple-choice questions, as well as the
answer stability, correlation, and response confidence of each LLM. RESULTS
GPT-4 performed comparably to attending physicians, while ChatGPT (GPT-3.5) and
PaLM2 outperformed medical students but slightly trailed behind postgraduate
students. Furthermore, GPT-4 exhibited greater stability and confidence when
responding to inquiries compared to ChatGPT (GPT-3.5) and PaLM2. CONCLUSIONS
AND RELEVANCE Our results underscore the potential for LLMs to provide medical
assistance in pediatric ophthalmology and suggest significant capacity to guide
the education of medical students.
|
[
-0.3952025771,
-0.9646787643,
0.7150877714,
0.0013575363,
-0.1573792249,
0.2092770338,
-0.3729006648,
-0.6640067697,
-0.0220993757,
0.3092601001,
-0.2000464797,
-0.4461907148,
-0.4265888333,
0.4031007886,
-0.1814970672,
0.7310724854,
-0.1917515844,
0.557972908,
-0.1379834563,
0.0988654941,
-0.1697282642,
-0.3415290713,
-0.9871658683,
-0.0579092428,
0.5451384187,
0.3813871741,
0.399820745,
0.0644049123,
0.9962372184,
0.2901830077,
-0.3402372003,
0.0534877367,
-0.3094465733,
-0.1543452144,
-0.3025504351,
-0.3574344218,
-0.721463263,
0.125998795,
0.6027182937,
1.1673924923,
-0.3820001185,
0.0509959869,
0.1288372427,
0.500512898,
-0.333052367,
-0.0272155385,
-0.2117781341,
0.3019360304,
-0.0124741178,
-0.0049393568,
-0.4728007019,
-0.2467743307,
0.7692148685,
-0.5710386634,
-0.1050705761,
0.2063476443,
0.5315972567,
-0.306381464,
-0.5898563266,
-0.1803091764,
-0.358500272,
0.600024879,
-0.8533768654,
0.1003271937,
0.1359840482,
0.2778016925,
0.1872121245,
-0.6195880175,
-0.5245113373,
-0.5635119081,
0.0355724134,
0.5363845825,
0.1249307096,
0.3722155094,
0.1957297325,
0.265301466,
-0.8795452118,
0.2842002809,
-0.7604928613,
0.0256006625,
0.4472127259,
0.3164694607,
0.3243606985,
0.0913026929,
-0.4609296322,
-0.182617113,
-0.5083930492,
0.0178460982,
0.3613475561,
0.1277053505,
-0.1253031194,
0.5913283229,
-0.2083529085,
0.9048193693,
0.1313153058,
-0.3464225531,
0.1730223298,
-0.4674190581,
-0.2006534785,
-0.2254868001,
0.8383680582,
0.5324468017,
0.5801621675,
0.0944461375,
-0.0759869218,
-0.266636312,
0.2537225187,
-0.5901109576,
-0.0301421694,
-0.0443782881,
-0.6695612073,
-0.4069255888,
0.1537274271,
-1.1028693914,
-0.2037713081,
-0.2011735439,
0.4679518342,
-0.0776649714,
-0.3533046842,
0.540651381,
0.1550593674,
0.3841330111,
0.4209116101,
-1.1749486923,
0.5700833797,
0.4690607488,
0.6828681827,
-0.6097115874,
-0.4970960319,
-0.0292573068,
-0.0722273439,
-0.5915111899,
0.5707334876,
-0.5608302951,
-0.6849021912,
0.0356027707,
-0.0567450151,
-0.5946503878,
-0.8416358829,
0.251673609,
-0.5082018971,
0.3020601869,
-0.0250580385,
-0.3380557001,
-0.0741326287,
0.4573637843,
-0.1518635452,
0.5470843911,
0.3297018111,
-0.535379231,
0.2844949961,
-0.40218997,
-0.2547159195,
0.1215741783,
-0.3980412781,
-0.281594336,
0.1057065725,
0.3523928225,
0.3944518268,
-0.3696706891,
0.4140963554,
-0.3854573071,
-0.2090659142,
0.3008413017,
-0.5241044164,
0.5252364874,
-0.321233511,
-0.0986419395,
0.0560124665,
-0.4453484416,
0.0624038838,
0.1652944833,
-0.5799482465,
-0.0271444414,
-0.2520151436,
0.0679006279,
0.1179864779,
0.1989739239,
-0.7021496296,
0.6818311214,
-0.4670107365,
0.3129218221,
0.5434451699,
0.399395138,
0.1066711023,
-0.2358455509,
0.7869402766,
0.189191848,
0.5593357086,
-0.180065617,
-0.7812819481,
-0.7840792537,
0.1108812764,
0.0322404467,
0.524014473,
-0.8344088793,
-0.1184498817,
-0.176251471,
-0.3571291864,
-0.1520020962,
-0.0908663496,
0.5213488936,
0.771360755,
0.149101004,
-0.6564206481,
-0.2045584619,
-1.0941178799,
-0.0056234626,
-0.3550890386,
0.16311948,
0.6842800975,
0.825635612,
-0.1213811785,
0.6219900846,
-0.6116060019,
-0.3599137068,
-0.2876291871,
-0.0193760451,
0.3548256755,
0.3097422421,
0.7220680118,
-0.7572834492,
-0.8332867026,
0.2421432436,
-0.5416771173,
-0.0390754677,
0.152594313,
0.5178663135,
0.3083803952,
0.3897284865,
-0.4597407877,
0.2780155838,
0.8817813993,
-0.2507587671,
0.6998298764,
-0.3749345243,
0.4969792962,
-0.6628195047,
0.2839472592,
-0.0224785414,
-0.1920605451,
-0.5324283242,
0.0114498287,
-0.0610976964,
-0.1566391289,
-0.4279506207,
0.4887397885,
-0.3435029685,
-0.1365171522,
0.1564129144,
0.3018610775,
-0.3279540241,
0.218483761,
-0.0516735166,
0.8970315456,
0.8632634282,
-0.2103950381,
0.430667311,
0.0210125521,
-0.5274495482,
0.6325526834,
-0.9153636098,
-0.0614128895,
0.0179704353,
0.2756919563,
-1.0341455936,
-0.4701659977,
0.3512104154,
-0.3857746422,
0.489338547,
-0.0638974831,
-0.5330533981,
-0.7439479828,
-0.1631376445,
0.4881920516,
0.3860331476,
-0.3246045709,
0.408580035,
0.160068959,
-0.6008315086,
-0.391048342,
-0.4769600332,
0.1189734563,
-0.206378296,
-0.5317714214,
-0.0173152555,
-0.1106598973,
-0.3363799751,
-0.0642083287,
-0.1310944706,
-0.3628964722,
-0.2166815549,
-0.1111587957,
0.5536004305,
-0.5089869499,
-0.0523625538,
-0.1997868121,
-0.0644270703,
-0.1440683603,
0.1845820099,
0.5062946677,
-0.3972329199,
-0.6711341143,
-0.3881175816,
0.0817458034,
0.6059623957,
-0.1047689617,
0.3925814331,
0.4938952923,
-0.0760631561,
0.0728722587,
-0.631914556,
-0.4069015682,
-0.4683026075,
0.4463838637,
-0.1821030825,
-0.9502871633,
0.3662758172,
0.0668636709,
-0.0120903235,
0.2877302766,
0.5994830728,
-0.0739148855,
0.7235047817,
0.300572753,
0.2406035811,
0.1401425153,
-0.2341408879,
0.2243703008,
-1.0457882881,
-0.3234761953,
-0.0606540814,
-0.1697214991,
-0.2187729776,
-0.6064052582,
0.7426882982,
-0.2313199341,
-0.039602045,
-0.0661238804,
-0.405670166,
0.451659888,
0.3011576831,
0.1469831318,
0.374037832,
0.0619135275,
-0.1632537842,
-0.1034914479,
-0.7012322545,
-0.4633904994,
1.5293592215,
0.4901025295,
0.7756954432,
0.2693306804,
0.2677428126,
-0.1860461384,
0.4956528246,
-0.9418231845,
0.7000118494,
-0.4156354666,
-0.7610476613,
-0.2700124085,
-0.3173743784,
-0.9002014399,
0.5984606743,
-0.1764801145,
-0.9962799549,
0.1666000485,
-0.0961547792,
-0.5785664916,
0.1927986741,
-0.723336041,
0.6652725935,
-0.2484329641,
-0.4749404192,
-0.3469652534,
-0.7137978077,
0.5075845122,
-0.5730541945,
-0.0010511358,
0.0779355541,
-0.5275723338,
0.7718333602,
-0.0222508833,
1.0296316147,
0.1039451659,
-0.1801388711,
0.2125266343,
-0.3068473339,
-0.2268248498,
0.2992259562,
0.0922440737,
0.1641881317,
0.1821027398,
-0.1350833327,
-0.2812886238,
0.8454591036,
-0.7023854256,
-0.8081210256,
-0.837169528,
-0.3637150824,
-0.5087398291,
0.2482767552,
-0.0588597879,
0.7231075764,
-0.0568288937,
0.5485990047,
0.6300863624,
-0.4878824353,
0.5384580493,
0.9372701645,
-0.5790621042,
-0.5703933835,
0.3592277765,
0.0809904486,
0.6468137503,
0.303810358,
0.3994541764,
-0.1755640656,
-0.5627244711,
-0.6703802943,
0.3722676635,
-0.6175299883,
0.1351373345,
-0.4402014911,
-0.1957322359,
-0.3060373366,
-0.1102443337,
-0.1397172213,
-0.0125348205,
-0.010327585,
0.2212232202,
-0.1342542619,
0.7322667837,
0.2626173496,
0.3086661994,
-0.6882892251,
0.1735369563,
0.4646811187,
0.28328076,
0.0028917189,
-0.4934979379,
0.0839269981,
-0.1715589166,
-0.4742478728,
-0.7432613373,
0.082024239,
0.2674696743,
0.5536860228,
0.6120554805,
-0.2620899081,
0.8034376502,
-0.6951647401,
1.0802730322,
0.511993289,
-0.6862450838,
0.2631947696,
-0.4868154228,
0.1580634713,
0.492270261,
0.3358482122,
-0.3424055874,
-0.1791382581,
-0.32572788,
-0.8249780536,
0.7897811532,
-0.076223053,
0.2382507771,
0.1368380189,
0.1798239648,
-0.0766280964,
0.2094749808,
-0.6159638762,
-0.2323263437,
0.3066559434,
-0.0260619409,
-0.3005602658,
-0.3984200358,
-0.2395796925,
-0.2342073172,
0.2004306763,
-0.1257047951,
-0.0906050801,
0.3462792933,
0.4145718217,
-0.1099314615,
0.43598634,
0.8210192919,
1.1093604565,
-0.1249891445,
-0.043593917,
0.371229589,
-0.8900139332,
-0.0104135303,
-0.1029909626,
0.0354801863,
-0.0869196802,
0.6573219299,
0.3118546605,
0.5640591383,
-0.8972924948,
0.8753178716,
-0.1256457865,
-0.4195773005,
-0.0846002251,
0.1174653694,
0.0740566626,
0.0559700094,
0.4026370049,
-0.0070718927,
0.1626048684,
-0.5609562397,
-0.007214711,
0.1456392556,
-0.2732077539,
-0.1789208651,
0.3706445098,
0.1092415676,
0.1895879507,
0.3976582289,
0.4116567373,
-0.3897613585,
0.7830828428,
0.6411488056,
0.2932568491,
-0.3192320764,
0.2113738656,
0.5468449593,
0.3909887969,
-0.1720716953,
0.3400788009,
0.3667807579,
-0.5549555421,
-0.396659106,
-0.4043507576,
-0.7138130069,
0.1538891494,
-0.7061713934,
-0.0813864246,
-0.437959224,
-0.3844722211,
0.0549149439,
0.0646873415,
-0.3839006424,
0.3877770901,
-0.0980828926,
1.055462122,
-0.5006706715,
0.5832677484,
1.2914210558,
-0.5655388832,
-0.6186835766,
0.1961342394,
-0.0117845442,
-1.0235745907,
0.8429682255,
0.0588768981,
-0.055168882,
-0.0666373819,
-0.3239910603,
-0.7406999469,
0.9254171848,
0.0306298006,
-0.7904811502,
-0.202221781,
0.1523222923,
0.6880756617,
-0.2166624665,
0.2539435029,
0.340688467,
0.2925851643,
0.0622788034,
-1.5531346798,
-0.379560262,
0.035792809,
0.0774234831,
-0.0351901092,
-0.6568350196,
0.791438818,
-0.4120391011,
-0.0153471157,
0.3049461842,
-0.0352328643,
0.4548585713,
0.2816391587,
0.4290134907,
0.2162655741,
0.2565591931,
-0.154783532,
1.0492706299,
-0.5188257694,
0.5972443819,
0.5450944304,
-0.2285002768,
1.2414082289,
0.7624290586,
-0.5097451806,
0.0201307144,
0.6647880077,
0.0801976398,
0.3614600599,
0.3160589635,
-0.4280599356,
-0.1962976158,
0.0592509471,
-0.5728169084,
0.2169539034,
0.3153051138,
-0.2556832135,
0.0946498811,
0.1745286882,
-0.0559996367,
-0.1059704348,
-0.4468331635,
0.6869866848,
0.4560855329,
-0.7067645788,
0.4295072556,
-0.0772298053,
0.5872244239,
-0.6993075609,
0.2403549105,
-0.1578432024,
0.4507170022,
-0.2816802263,
-1.1060729027,
0.1115613729,
0.0280195605,
0.0407055877,
0.0035058793,
0.3729514778,
-0.2968557477,
-0.5329582691,
0.195107758,
0.4395010173,
0.1933878362,
0.3944144249,
-0.5740901232,
0.0420930684,
-0.1677577049,
-0.466386646,
0.2604423761,
0.0991667137,
0.1607120335,
0.9814939499,
0.6203041673,
0.4869456291,
-0.0693516359,
0.1166189611,
0.8619459867,
-0.1570046544,
0.0078036366,
-0.7686914206,
0.155834958,
-0.018039383,
-0.5841068625,
0.7328182459,
0.5592250824,
0.855920732,
-0.4756698012,
0.4686790109,
0.1414268762,
0.3884100318,
-0.5536743402,
0.4888338745,
-0.7142084241,
0.1597578824,
-0.4232042432,
-0.8956019878,
-0.6284169555,
0.936389327,
-0.5887619853,
0.2505914569,
0.9021181464,
0.5038577318,
-0.21611996,
-0.0530388504,
0.6751657128,
0.1801276654,
0.2276067585,
0.7681406736,
0.9245753288,
-0.0771523193,
0.2855682373,
-0.1476589888,
-0.342132628,
-0.443718344,
-0.3562639654,
-1.0539311171,
-0.109704867,
-0.2202884704,
0.035767749,
-0.0136940172,
0.7897322774,
0.7871561646,
-0.5833937526,
-0.2643295825,
0.3609837294,
-0.374229461,
0.0710306913,
-0.1676070392,
0.494328171,
0.0178357176,
-0.7671592832,
0.3180297613,
0.5222909451,
0.2961710691,
-0.5409000516,
0.1796382368,
0.2657963336,
-0.077844955,
0.7585780025,
-0.0004594927,
-1.010274291,
-0.0602070168,
0.2419700325,
-0.4409319162,
0.0454041846,
0.4593586326,
-0.3747912943,
0.5626426339,
0.2142766863,
0.3912713826,
0.2174165547,
0.0065375576,
0.3907263279,
-0.040603254,
-0.0542012341,
0.3016806245,
0.4820641279,
0.2176580727,
0.0853531808,
0.5552307963,
0.3414724469,
-0.6142933369,
-0.5705589652,
0.2350622416,
-1.2432953119,
-0.1171778813,
1.3159993887,
-0.4665730298,
0.1877443492,
-0.0860096812,
-0.7071346045,
-0.4225947559,
-0.3131210208,
0.5417053699,
0.6781300902,
-0.1425726414,
-0.4133606851,
-0.9764558077,
0.0299134869,
0.3452915847,
-1.0251954794,
-0.4242971539,
0.3663370907,
0.3791439235,
0.0077063148,
0.8131364584,
-0.4324208498,
0.228758201,
-0.1011267155,
-0.3752942681,
0.0804879144,
-0.1408300698,
-0.2291112095,
0.1710948795,
0.077568911,
-0.0768910497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04364v1
|
Syntax-Guided Transformers: Elevating Compositional Generalization and Grounding in Multimodal Environments
| 2023-11-07T21:59:16 | 2023-11-07T21:59:16 |
Danial Kamali, Parisa Kordjamshidi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Compositional generalization, the ability of intelligent models to
extrapolate understanding of components to novel compositions, is a fundamental
yet challenging facet in AI research, especially within multimodal
environments. In this work, we address this challenge by exploiting the
syntactic structure of language to boost compositional generalization. This
paper elevates the importance of syntactic grounding, particularly through
attention masking techniques derived from text input parsing. We introduce and
evaluate the merits of using syntactic information in the multimodal grounding
problem. Our results on grounded compositional generalization underscore the
positive impact of dependency parsing across diverse tasks when utilized with
Weight Sharing across the Transformer encoder. The results push the
state-of-the-art in multimodal grounding and parameter-efficient modeling and
provide insights for future research.
|
[
-0.2859122455,
-0.7621175647,
0.7903909683,
0.5465345979,
0.032874316,
0.112998195,
-0.3190223575,
-0.1170463935,
0.073193185,
0.2735063434,
-0.4593835175,
-0.5288600922,
-0.709068656,
-0.0284630153,
-0.3212456405,
0.7779248357,
-0.0713940784,
-0.0497109964,
-0.5756247044,
-0.2759409845,
-0.8842150569,
-0.5749264956,
-0.1364565939,
-0.2507890463,
0.3988035619,
0.0900950804,
0.7232704759,
0.585270822,
0.5259273648,
0.416267097,
-0.0090584075,
0.1356264502,
0.0223993119,
0.5492230654,
-0.203779757,
-0.7727438211,
-0.0582076758,
-0.0832012072,
0.7402021885,
0.8513325453,
-0.0878616422,
-0.0833347365,
-0.1319889128,
0.6294527054,
-0.727273643,
0.6199356914,
-0.3913638294,
0.2473384589,
0.1249306872,
-0.1208570004,
-0.6700015068,
0.2329838723,
-0.1616814286,
-0.6851496696,
0.2564975321,
-0.150483802,
0.6606160402,
0.7582234144,
-0.297225982,
0.0277427547,
-0.8330428004,
0.8220052123,
-0.1620929092,
0.7070245743,
0.1352204084,
0.4175957441,
0.3825966418,
-0.8008544445,
-0.4586755037,
-0.0540377684,
-0.4897297621,
0.2492399961,
-0.2117549628,
0.3844616413,
0.5121610761,
0.4185686111,
-0.2936022282,
-0.3931660056,
-0.1442913264,
-0.1421175897,
0.0313870199,
-0.065787062,
0.6319797635,
-0.0746135339,
-0.3609637618,
-0.3383431733,
-0.1785508692,
0.161048308,
0.0935956612,
0.0932292938,
-0.2121231407,
0.5169694424,
-0.3527873158,
0.7978785634,
0.2718794048,
-0.0250788238,
0.3077284694,
-0.5674540997,
-0.0970231667,
-0.1740812063,
0.4779251218,
0.4907579422,
0.247834444,
-0.4593733847,
-0.0679161251,
0.6065425277,
0.4966432154,
-0.4865074456,
-0.2510830164,
0.051902473,
-0.3344814777,
-0.2434337884,
0.1746252477,
-0.8465868831,
-0.2529280186,
-0.5687176585,
0.2370779514,
-0.3061473072,
0.0284056012,
0.1559328735,
-0.4101617336,
0.2919783592,
0.3316225708,
-1.1814088821,
0.1637350917,
0.5289792418,
0.7400575876,
0.0979381502,
-0.2405738384,
-0.3633243144,
0.5437533259,
0.0387849286,
0.8114292622,
-0.7494911551,
0.0518289134,
-0.1485562176,
0.0067419596,
-0.3647508621,
-0.3659358919,
0.4911170304,
-0.2758455276,
0.3349846601,
-0.0788246095,
-0.1382021159,
-0.1658635437,
0.3987249434,
-0.8110043406,
0.7340109944,
0.2705010176,
-0.5346203446,
0.3221959472,
-0.5899918079,
-0.6968488693,
-0.0546576232,
-0.4373030663,
-0.2893485129,
0.3085477948,
0.6660180688,
0.3330473602,
-0.0490730256,
0.6796617508,
0.050758943,
-0.0572169237,
0.0365330167,
-0.3366660774,
0.3551640809,
-0.05177534,
-0.6034789681,
0.3698076308,
-0.7799125314,
-0.0584036522,
0.0165260751,
-0.2870853245,
-0.252880007,
0.1405599713,
0.1758141816,
0.4261304438,
0.0440996774,
-0.3263546824,
-0.0795052573,
-0.4284786582,
0.5686164498,
0.6331771016,
-0.1263018548,
0.8963688612,
-0.3936670423,
0.6175628901,
0.0315100513,
0.0174197797,
-0.911790967,
-0.3957200944,
-0.7754366994,
-0.287492007,
0.1560471207,
0.4929485619,
-0.7461476922,
0.5752091408,
-0.2139574736,
-0.3137415648,
-0.5578718781,
0.0137652336,
0.3243544698,
0.5087156892,
0.5962279439,
0.0132992016,
-0.6941759586,
-1.1367493868,
-0.370438844,
0.0565059744,
0.076243557,
0.1574989706,
-0.1369459629,
-0.2714586258,
0.9946000576,
-0.624502182,
-0.4372124672,
-0.5147668719,
-0.1495803744,
-0.0791704208,
0.7379631996,
0.6149772406,
-1.1150559187,
-0.5490295291,
-0.1271436512,
-0.9756742716,
-0.1855732948,
-0.2813782096,
-0.1943948865,
-0.3895138502,
0.5898592472,
-1.1446179152,
0.1158776432,
0.5532488227,
-0.2480800748,
0.1376224309,
0.1348735541,
-0.0063965465,
-0.9940507412,
0.0634322315,
-0.0610206202,
-0.3716779351,
-0.819111228,
0.7045795321,
0.0487427078,
-0.3731716871,
-0.2885697782,
0.2034884989,
-0.4815498888,
0.2117779702,
0.0026880635,
-0.1640045792,
0.4790179431,
0.701194942,
-0.1132290736,
0.7596477866,
0.7235609293,
-0.348926723,
0.3599590063,
0.2675378621,
0.0467517562,
0.3925338984,
-0.7580965757,
0.0723476633,
-0.4481932521,
0.4369914532,
-1.0820833445,
-0.224873051,
0.1941665858,
-0.2363238931,
0.1955131739,
-0.1107742488,
-0.5951856971,
0.1729674339,
-0.2606275082,
0.7777987123,
0.4401326776,
-0.3638076782,
1.1693387032,
0.3390842676,
0.0392617472,
-0.2984714806,
-0.6306552887,
0.050626535,
-0.3755598068,
-0.81269449,
0.6389089227,
-0.068539694,
-0.4126885831,
-0.3429463208,
-0.3160957098,
0.1400378197,
0.1558974981,
0.2786356807,
-0.1183865294,
-0.3380554914,
0.1655010581,
0.025370596,
-0.3563407063,
0.3400902152,
-0.3324469328,
0.8074930906,
-0.0205241125,
-0.3408684134,
-0.3910625875,
0.628805697,
0.6594577432,
-0.466709286,
0.6350545287,
0.6986805201,
-0.3892231882,
-0.3133015633,
-0.6011795402,
-0.1200853959,
-0.5294151902,
0.2187815905,
-0.2743341923,
-0.6957488656,
0.4077453911,
-0.03301185,
-0.3550895154,
0.4974910915,
0.4532314241,
-0.1107094809,
1.1766890287,
0.8709079623,
0.0676371753,
0.7110753059,
-0.1296393871,
0.1305259764,
-0.6055349708,
-0.3622300923,
-0.3667931557,
-0.4775965512,
-0.3858554661,
-0.5191680193,
0.4407506883,
-0.2168729305,
0.4535616338,
0.2777588665,
-0.549926877,
0.7296668887,
0.5391628146,
0.316072613,
0.1234415025,
0.0407852419,
-0.0713609233,
-0.1885790974,
-0.3873360753,
-0.1106965914,
0.8145452142,
0.2303984463,
0.7204052806,
0.1423154473,
0.2978051603,
0.2757906914,
-0.0853776485,
-0.8112184405,
0.3465408981,
-0.1484696716,
-0.330223918,
-0.0485691987,
-0.1534056067,
-0.5752128363,
0.5504074693,
0.0144654773,
-0.4123761356,
0.1455995739,
0.1341168135,
-0.236883685,
-0.0461112075,
-1.0778964758,
0.9662560225,
0.1160132065,
-0.2009199262,
-0.168149218,
-1.0335536003,
0.1434215009,
0.1885984391,
0.1095965207,
0.1477544755,
0.1502860934,
0.4034685493,
0.024943186,
0.9705374241,
-0.3437782526,
-0.1480926126,
0.081473574,
-0.1890955865,
0.3781627417,
0.1304567903,
0.2499639392,
-0.0524810068,
-0.4646886885,
-0.3450617194,
-0.9990394711,
0.4367676079,
-0.6311014891,
-0.7508866191,
-0.0708034784,
-0.6903941035,
-0.369535774,
0.3071172237,
0.0467837863,
0.4912692606,
0.1510985643,
0.3433611393,
0.8070662022,
-0.0913774297,
0.4336592555,
-0.0609178022,
0.0491572395,
-0.3603634238,
0.8530526161,
-0.2982893586,
0.2899773419,
0.973347187,
0.2390472889,
-0.2244044989,
-0.26093027,
-0.494125247,
0.1069757268,
-1.1058695316,
-0.249595046,
-1.2619030476,
-0.0610078387,
-0.4587880969,
-0.335652411,
-0.1743205339,
-0.6336925626,
-0.2011059523,
-0.3691187501,
-0.2374849766,
0.5972931385,
0.3931132853,
0.5264042616,
-0.6850333214,
0.6902712584,
0.283734113,
0.1384906322,
-0.2285511196,
0.0115451114,
-0.2696471214,
-0.1782137901,
-0.4657259583,
-0.8051144481,
0.0791121051,
0.2231797129,
0.7138870955,
0.1707338989,
-0.1535466164,
0.738325417,
-0.4837094843,
0.7259962559,
0.178986907,
-1.1547909975,
0.763341248,
-0.401461482,
0.5416611433,
0.5299348831,
-0.1011951268,
-0.5581767559,
-0.5028758049,
-0.5361385345,
-0.8958379626,
0.6022150517,
0.2909107804,
0.3745179474,
0.0828391984,
0.0642392337,
0.0669871122,
0.3883857429,
-1.0377751589,
-0.2324111611,
-0.3635923862,
-0.4373477101,
-0.219958812,
-0.1162307933,
-0.1444737017,
-0.3880737424,
0.0158927236,
-0.219647333,
0.3471578658,
0.1204709932,
-0.6362271905,
0.177353099,
0.3195264339,
0.8948566914,
0.3975158036,
0.2304810584,
0.5919032693,
-0.2604550123,
-0.2536640763,
0.3130678236,
0.1190029085,
-0.1837015599,
0.1498151571,
0.4367128909,
0.7568209767,
0.2951412499,
-0.6426923871,
0.620649457,
0.1285055131,
0.0818108544,
-0.1004255265,
0.1607874334,
-0.1268917471,
0.1801016033,
0.2109013498,
0.5678397417,
0.1678011864,
-0.3902948201,
0.3033021986,
0.2981507778,
-0.1417083144,
-0.6526966095,
0.7274138927,
0.1818220913,
0.0042904941,
0.267550081,
0.1875509024,
-0.6817682981,
0.7376855612,
0.6963273883,
0.9094591141,
-0.1563732624,
0.0580685362,
0.1038378924,
0.4196048975,
0.0863361806,
-0.0153369466,
-0.438696593,
-0.6998667717,
-0.5088255405,
-0.4973224998,
-0.2075895816,
-0.3793258369,
-0.4229613841,
0.2942768633,
-0.6196250319,
0.0162093882,
0.0917851552,
-0.8410554528,
-0.6671971679,
0.2098001838,
0.2326222807,
0.384752512,
-0.9191594124,
0.3795045912,
0.9863693714,
-0.447378844,
-0.6197654605,
0.1924074292,
-0.3256912231,
-0.8186089396,
0.7187665105,
0.6537083983,
-0.0915699974,
0.0820013508,
-0.4821092188,
-0.856913507,
0.894746244,
0.5645934939,
-0.0177971441,
-0.4308854938,
0.2248225808,
0.5353851914,
-0.4175767899,
0.2461787015,
0.3936298788,
0.691219449,
-0.2930285633,
-0.6129000783,
0.2188020498,
-0.4523640573,
0.0507028624,
0.3472552001,
-0.7337032557,
0.971989274,
0.1841228306,
-0.3780287802,
-0.378572017,
0.3815857172,
-0.1656480134,
0.2381307036,
0.4992497861,
0.8312536478,
0.1760879606,
-0.2128608376,
0.8267857432,
-0.3956818581,
0.1338474602,
0.8310123086,
-0.0624782667,
0.0847047195,
0.6043230891,
-0.1320196539,
0.7469704151,
-0.1551037729,
-0.11967507,
0.6595708728,
-0.1039830968,
-0.2795221806,
-0.1533103585,
-0.3615907729,
-0.3517197371,
0.6936740279,
0.3390798867,
-0.5994303823,
-0.4066935778,
0.1887541562,
-0.2694255412,
0.4023991525,
0.0433970466,
1.0795155764,
-0.188008979,
-0.7338938117,
0.251113236,
0.2860993743,
0.5664877295,
-0.5137254596,
-0.2649466693,
-0.1178500429,
0.0789810419,
-0.2171494812,
-0.398327291,
0.5145270824,
-0.3676401675,
-0.5758096576,
-0.8489208817,
0.8168400526,
-0.4321345389,
-0.2808296978,
0.2897367775,
0.4812909961,
-0.4955962598,
-0.4268568754,
-0.1896211654,
0.0961102471,
-0.1352256984,
0.0494789146,
0.1768347621,
0.3752778172,
0.0291274525,
0.5094326735,
0.6914902329,
-0.365590632,
0.266153425,
0.289911896,
1.205283165,
-0.7792292237,
-0.9397637248,
-1.1038510799,
0.7966939211,
0.124394387,
0.0030946238,
0.7222050428,
0.4380681515,
0.7282791138,
-0.3396362066,
0.7076150775,
-0.0668202341,
-0.0953547955,
-0.7177090645,
0.4843964279,
-0.2453940362,
-0.0298553724,
-0.3550831079,
-1.1130818129,
-0.5664586425,
0.6100931764,
0.0975671411,
0.0476290099,
0.8667629361,
0.4642504156,
-0.2246333063,
-0.1253030598,
0.4260912836,
-0.1688936055,
0.4244221449,
0.4465978742,
1.0241574049,
-0.3581668139,
0.3248945177,
-0.3983072937,
-0.0718164369,
0.1964747906,
-0.5427900553,
-0.9170668721,
-0.4756873548,
-0.132635355,
-0.0431459062,
-0.1201195791,
0.7959550023,
0.8988667727,
-0.685105741,
0.1296735257,
-0.433434844,
0.1368676424,
-0.2941128016,
-0.3065128922,
0.0444000997,
-0.6746222973,
-0.7521397471,
0.6700105071,
0.4437816143,
-0.0385881066,
-0.378637135,
0.3112259209,
-0.0675234348,
-0.2570463717,
0.7781003714,
-0.280154556,
-0.8474392295,
-0.1906663477,
0.0698671937,
-0.0314887948,
0.3641953766,
1.1505993605,
-0.9376035929,
0.3893321753,
0.4599969983,
0.9184452891,
0.1640866399,
0.3881442845,
0.6728674173,
-1.4022049904,
0.4593192339,
0.2294732332,
0.4442543983,
0.4526041448,
-0.4806495905,
0.4364613891,
0.5993717909,
-0.1500385553,
-0.5513869524,
0.4208970368,
-1.0744159222,
0.0009119451,
1.0487316847,
0.0440195724,
0.065843761,
-0.0353883877,
-0.2842798233,
0.1749695092,
-0.3669618666,
0.4898442626,
0.9347872734,
0.1594735086,
-0.5356577039,
-0.2152327299,
0.2538511157,
0.7566646934,
-0.9731910229,
-0.0199530851,
0.5188052058,
0.0261461269,
0.5557876229,
0.3287034929,
0.1268962622,
0.1449936032,
0.0402441137,
-0.0051657204,
-0.0726173446,
-0.6785122156,
-0.4699972868,
0.543566525,
-0.2505559325,
-0.2263987809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04354v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04354v2
|
Uncovering Intermediate Variables in Transformers using Circuit Probing
| 2023-11-07T21:27:17 | 2023-11-17T15:15:17 |
Michael A. Lepori, Thomas Serre, Ellie Pavlick
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural network models have achieved high performance on a wide variety of
complex tasks, but the algorithms that they implement are notoriously difficult
to interpret. In order to understand these algorithms, it is often necessary to
hypothesize intermediate variables involved in the network's computation. For
example, does a language model depend on particular syntactic properties when
generating a sentence? However, existing analysis tools make it difficult to
test hypotheses of this type. We propose a new analysis technique -- circuit
probing -- that automatically uncovers low-level circuits that compute
hypothesized intermediate variables. This enables causal analysis through
targeted ablation at the level of model parameters. We apply this method to
models trained on simple arithmetic tasks, demonstrating its effectiveness at
(1) deciphering the algorithms that models have learned, (2) revealing modular
structure within a model, and (3) tracking the development of circuits over
training. We compare circuit probing to other methods across these three
experiments, and find it on par or more effective than existing analysis
methods. Finally, we demonstrate circuit probing on a real-world use case,
uncovering circuits that are responsible for subject-verb agreement and
reflexive anaphora in GPT2-Small and Medium.
|
[
-0.7139534354,
-1.124815464,
0.7201185226,
-0.0919349566,
0.0089772204,
-0.1064882204,
-0.0687278882,
-0.0274638031,
0.037257012,
0.5667293668,
-0.8137011528,
-0.1364839375,
-0.4622037411,
0.0328355879,
-0.6232022047,
0.7043785453,
0.0937901735,
-0.3364076316,
-0.1138301641,
0.0041746548,
-0.3024522364,
-0.4088719785,
-0.6688386798,
-0.5823563933,
0.5974123478,
0.4407227635,
0.62577039,
0.3910945654,
0.8209122419,
0.4395160079,
-0.1097453386,
0.0885543302,
-0.0561420843,
0.1387066692,
-0.262006104,
-0.7039006352,
-0.125816226,
-0.0878920257,
0.5469689369,
0.865072608,
0.0494364724,
0.5023694634,
-0.2317579985,
0.6797633767,
-0.6025362015,
0.2196746469,
-0.6815888286,
-0.0434902571,
-0.2187084407,
-0.469741255,
-0.8204837441,
0.037470594,
-0.0762192011,
-0.0364776999,
0.7227482796,
0.110874027,
1.0709652901,
0.3188515306,
-0.7818212509,
-0.0579117686,
-1.1530437469,
0.4370024204,
-0.4616583884,
0.3882834911,
0.2671292722,
0.2600060701,
0.0389982276,
-0.8879135251,
-0.7416910529,
-0.2476421446,
-0.6117411852,
-0.0497884899,
-0.5049805641,
0.4046318233,
0.5920146704,
0.221334368,
-0.3213970363,
-0.0380000845,
-0.5844952464,
-0.3901181221,
0.0930151343,
0.3325841427,
0.3520621061,
-0.4403856397,
-0.139421761,
-0.1923967153,
-0.7223533988,
0.112938188,
0.6975066662,
0.2755430341,
0.0933547392,
0.8502057195,
0.0555240251,
0.4421815276,
0.3624215424,
0.5756888986,
-0.0470931008,
-0.3785684407,
-0.2637761831,
-0.0737720951,
0.6660277247,
0.0175911523,
0.1316194981,
-0.0317556374,
-0.2267312407,
0.137514621,
0.436548084,
-0.7353125811,
-0.6825014949,
0.1025208607,
-0.4077119529,
-0.3509796858,
-0.0290740635,
-0.5835067034,
0.0896305665,
-0.4107956886,
0.5017960668,
-0.1635162681,
-0.2535094619,
-0.1873282939,
-0.159641996,
0.3630402684,
-0.2606992424,
-1.3009918928,
0.6381498575,
0.6808456779,
0.8168954253,
0.2891584337,
-0.3161354363,
-0.7069506049,
-0.2845130861,
-0.3323934972,
0.8327488899,
-0.4254061282,
-0.0545982569,
-0.1808791757,
0.0554629155,
-0.1528536677,
-0.56798774,
0.283735007,
-0.719774127,
-0.122063145,
-0.192587018,
-0.3086749315,
-0.0161130298,
0.1228181347,
-0.9466213584,
1.1557654142,
0.1160627529,
-0.8777420521,
-0.0927605107,
-0.6046100259,
-0.2933422029,
-0.4911189675,
-0.4560424089,
-0.5893711448,
0.6995545626,
0.292583555,
0.2698879242,
-0.3327386677,
0.2242076546,
0.0377495326,
-0.3729423285,
0.4276383221,
-0.739975512,
0.8038259745,
-0.2947266102,
-0.5044240952,
0.271589756,
-0.5807420015,
-0.1362922341,
0.0330112129,
0.3086507916,
-0.0144394152,
0.1291022599,
-0.3956563175,
0.1248005107,
-0.0815284997,
-0.4415873289,
0.0769254118,
-0.5717814565,
0.3267274201,
0.8067837954,
0.3079166114,
0.4817606807,
-0.0786677077,
0.4120976329,
0.1139686406,
0.1131415963,
-0.3926382959,
-0.4576494992,
-1.1681824923,
0.370893687,
0.2506023049,
0.1603581607,
-0.7907996774,
0.3892064989,
-0.0473046601,
-0.4586758018,
-0.3062061071,
-0.1035779119,
0.3868228197,
0.8740393519,
0.4665659666,
-0.1226628274,
-0.1950911731,
-1.2795476913,
-0.2861452997,
-0.5615702868,
-0.3075526953,
0.3132590353,
0.5847131014,
0.0993281081,
0.7717900872,
-0.8283728957,
0.0763867795,
-0.1895457208,
0.6049159765,
0.4363562167,
0.3931761086,
0.2445389628,
-0.7364119887,
-0.2128187716,
0.0292410385,
-0.4028482139,
-0.0539266393,
-0.3029266298,
-0.2360535264,
-0.5167890191,
0.8349890709,
-0.6466526985,
0.3721303046,
0.3887034059,
-0.3825297952,
0.7975269556,
-0.2073491216,
-0.0139659969,
-0.4648848176,
0.1190984547,
0.144439131,
0.099199079,
-0.9787450433,
0.1519260556,
0.4908165038,
0.0273773149,
-0.4085303545,
0.1526228637,
-0.4364712536,
-0.1542083174,
-0.386757493,
-0.1956937313,
0.0435806625,
0.7235335708,
-0.1764848828,
0.8624970913,
0.4170859158,
-0.4290442765,
0.2527176738,
0.1231137142,
-0.1099100485,
0.0911815986,
-0.6629927158,
0.3779063821,
-0.1622688323,
-0.1751324981,
-1.1870228052,
-0.140832901,
0.2916490734,
-0.6014247537,
0.1549700946,
-0.3873535693,
-0.6994737983,
-0.2081065029,
0.1434554011,
0.7069889307,
0.5297406912,
-0.5963636637,
0.8850081563,
0.0218701381,
-0.0212820657,
-0.2386739403,
-0.3436981738,
-0.2294025421,
-0.1797814965,
-0.5673238635,
0.2480500191,
0.2750060856,
-0.4441512227,
-0.3065910339,
-0.3969976604,
-0.2635600567,
0.1586510092,
0.115200676,
0.5010792613,
-0.4683672786,
0.2387887686,
0.407697916,
-0.3974620402,
0.8822925687,
-0.0803787485,
0.737234354,
-0.3901082575,
-0.6798214912,
-0.539204061,
0.0898354873,
0.4636719227,
-0.4657887518,
0.1380813122,
0.5977513194,
-0.5175708532,
-0.1578552872,
-0.5316619277,
-0.5505226851,
-0.6574122906,
0.2431290001,
-0.3663727939,
-0.3226060867,
0.5871651769,
-0.2984424829,
-0.4167192876,
0.7074065804,
0.5194604397,
-0.0358648188,
1.0476839542,
0.6205160022,
0.14816311,
0.4322527945,
-0.3505207896,
0.5361430049,
-0.7649143338,
-0.1981299222,
-0.7002021074,
-0.4126344025,
-0.6733850837,
-0.2910045087,
0.5543364882,
-0.1591720879,
-0.2791542411,
0.3596229553,
-0.2079309225,
0.788508296,
0.5036483407,
0.3991895318,
0.3071428239,
-0.0624449886,
-0.1455398649,
0.0460758843,
-0.2720960379,
-0.2069466114,
0.981967926,
0.3565319777,
0.4610414207,
-0.0595045239,
0.4460912049,
-0.023555059,
0.2386253774,
-1.0180382729,
0.4679499865,
-0.0176036842,
-0.7404957414,
-0.3933928311,
-0.448540926,
-0.6606168151,
0.2278192192,
0.1588711143,
-0.8887293339,
0.5184471607,
0.1775074452,
-0.4929150343,
0.4196845889,
-0.6932528615,
0.6525697112,
-0.1597195566,
-0.4129000306,
0.059235774,
-0.6627707481,
0.4508191943,
0.0316380821,
-0.2033349723,
0.2138119638,
0.2282253653,
0.5680075884,
-0.3717694581,
0.8173487186,
-0.1255001575,
-0.1200219765,
0.4066889584,
0.3355355263,
0.5638133883,
0.0804737285,
0.1410191059,
-0.0537058078,
-0.4439993203,
-0.3557555377,
-0.9097771645,
0.5937062502,
-0.4286610484,
-0.691473484,
-0.2572119534,
-0.2885466516,
-0.3090496957,
0.3226435483,
0.2930773497,
0.4493251145,
0.1569927484,
0.1357587427,
0.8266063929,
0.1258212328,
0.4518468082,
0.1552078277,
0.0222305804,
0.2165344805,
0.8037765026,
-0.1968451738,
0.4030802548,
0.3444330394,
0.3538365066,
-0.0600862429,
-0.5319333673,
-0.271689117,
0.2376138866,
-0.6675516963,
-0.1760381758,
-0.5087953806,
-0.2986168265,
0.1325159669,
0.1227187663,
-0.7506911755,
-0.3767035604,
-0.1561797112,
-0.3453013897,
-0.0764996484,
0.4064653516,
0.1116685793,
0.6506412625,
-0.6621067524,
0.5165418983,
0.3808851838,
0.1521929801,
0.0571405888,
-0.3302674294,
-0.1605748981,
-0.0373049304,
-0.4833630323,
-0.8458654284,
0.4463230968,
-0.0826898813,
0.1647582352,
0.5895340443,
-0.2210497558,
0.6277357936,
-0.6035373807,
0.5122819543,
0.3000951707,
-1.1933617592,
0.649969697,
-0.3171532452,
-0.0550888069,
0.586478889,
0.2743689716,
-0.1988691837,
-0.2771339715,
-0.6860818267,
-0.9718459845,
0.4557938874,
0.6222434044,
0.2332543284,
-0.1271714717,
0.5373814702,
-0.1322381645,
0.0048764516,
-0.5356265903,
-0.5109459162,
0.1785701513,
-0.0239478983,
0.0867922381,
0.0883382186,
-0.2742900252,
-0.3667885959,
0.049536515,
-0.2400859892,
0.7117058635,
0.153879568,
-0.1834555268,
-0.1661559194,
0.0125219692,
0.3333838582,
0.6226819158,
-0.347599268,
0.5249492526,
0.1184479892,
-0.5378529429,
0.3291920125,
-0.062184453,
-0.0626290888,
0.2919690907,
0.527151227,
0.5796780586,
0.1856723726,
-0.3091548681,
0.593098402,
-0.285558939,
-0.3065823019,
-0.4094488621,
0.2033577114,
-0.0041609746,
0.432467103,
0.3492442369,
0.4170165062,
0.3971223533,
-0.5998414159,
0.3779807389,
0.1798222065,
-0.6424823403,
-0.6724928617,
0.4126473665,
-0.0698695779,
-0.4438119829,
1.1130064726,
0.0491153449,
-0.5295047164,
1.1458040476,
0.4415669441,
0.9569592476,
-0.1777511686,
0.2882647216,
0.2258163095,
0.6646296978,
-0.0020244995,
0.0306752361,
-0.0432554185,
-0.6362267137,
-0.4242888391,
-0.1788239032,
-0.4477908313,
-0.0753807053,
-1.15376091,
0.3314979672,
-0.2156033218,
-0.0787700191,
0.3979752362,
-0.158334583,
-0.9320394397,
0.160774529,
-0.134551838,
0.704955101,
-1.2519420385,
0.7124251127,
0.1717400253,
-0.4820628464,
-0.6556992531,
0.3480363488,
-0.2223182619,
-0.6657626033,
0.9525392652,
0.1968257427,
-0.200280264,
0.1101601496,
-0.4267879725,
-0.7170751691,
1.0696618557,
0.2331633419,
-0.5700055957,
-0.4423505366,
0.1222361177,
0.5789427161,
-0.0532792695,
0.8903437853,
0.753410399,
0.4902108908,
-0.2469696105,
-0.5768398046,
0.2480963916,
-0.3721894026,
-0.376227051,
0.7062442303,
-0.5460131168,
1.2008615732,
-0.2266016155,
-0.194498837,
-0.0560874492,
0.8226158023,
-0.0602423958,
0.5000790358,
0.6470233798,
-0.0098784156,
0.6463513374,
-0.3140856922,
0.7568076253,
-0.3773268163,
0.6322217584,
1.0466755629,
-0.0717654973,
0.7365954518,
0.8479975462,
-0.1634255201,
0.401581049,
0.3274338543,
-0.1827838123,
0.4754407704,
0.4739245772,
-0.1513725072,
-0.2542972863,
0.2988114059,
-0.0364599787,
0.5212052464,
0.5699110627,
-0.4128288329,
-0.2012715042,
-0.0868453905,
-0.2965480089,
-0.2817134857,
-0.1096830592,
0.5547140837,
-0.0980006158,
-0.616071105,
0.2791172266,
-0.0592896082,
0.1371295005,
-0.4412072897,
-0.2004916221,
-0.3889928162,
0.1435512751,
-0.0301971473,
-0.4676959813,
0.5270308852,
-0.1883666664,
-0.0497826375,
-0.0844783336,
0.8336163759,
0.0198826529,
-0.626740098,
0.2960247695,
0.5440686941,
-0.1969660819,
-0.2904706597,
-0.1202122942,
-0.1170219406,
-0.2258316725,
-0.4710401297,
0.0702498555,
0.5034149885,
0.1534048766,
0.4989620447,
0.5739599466,
0.0696935132,
0.0629955083,
0.0313935913,
1.1976853609,
-0.8826904893,
-0.047587283,
-1.0111148357,
0.6418868303,
-0.0240824223,
-0.4185542762,
0.5090458989,
0.5765498281,
0.9228999019,
0.079128094,
0.5497677326,
0.3177213371,
-0.0386451595,
-0.7356473207,
0.4216433167,
-0.1356264651,
0.5086904168,
0.0144518083,
-0.8572403789,
-0.2851811349,
0.3659102023,
-0.2174690366,
-0.1702963412,
1.2165102959,
0.8591275215,
-0.5502513647,
0.212250784,
0.1463166177,
0.4006562829,
0.5299025178,
0.0658962876,
0.9225218892,
-0.5135594606,
0.6020070314,
-0.7268946171,
-0.296572119,
0.0049841935,
-0.5401485562,
-1.0251867771,
-0.5104549527,
-0.0880547985,
-0.284171313,
-0.0988293365,
0.407558918,
0.2675560117,
-0.6230579019,
-0.2953465581,
-0.638691783,
0.1439475268,
-0.3089446425,
-0.239203766,
0.6448730826,
-0.3475795984,
-0.5911297202,
0.4965357482,
0.2062378675,
-0.2956646383,
-0.4608058035,
0.5182778835,
-0.0363280028,
0.2254184484,
0.4054211974,
-0.016542403,
-0.4865483642,
-0.5064377189,
0.5174067616,
0.2019914985,
0.1623092592,
1.3806326389,
-0.525847435,
0.4019545615,
0.7256215811,
0.4418100119,
0.8213998079,
-0.0562093034,
0.5552119613,
-0.7720245123,
-0.200235635,
0.2991729677,
0.403339386,
-0.1710384488,
-0.4711888134,
0.1381230056,
0.0583561435,
-0.5468347073,
-0.9109629393,
0.4248526394,
-0.6925948262,
-0.1380658448,
0.7673168182,
0.0168828797,
-0.3816399872,
0.0044646785,
-0.0541608408,
0.4518868029,
0.0335560851,
0.9534559846,
0.6663461924,
-0.4576667845,
-0.0419672765,
-0.7397329807,
0.0930783227,
0.620018959,
-0.6554643512,
0.0920959041,
0.1577090919,
-0.0009085322,
0.3404756188,
0.3466243446,
0.0774540678,
0.2917158604,
0.2757096887,
-0.3155624568,
-0.0308527462,
-0.717081666,
-0.2467669547,
0.2248592973,
-0.1752580255,
-0.2880397141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04348v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04348v1
|
Evaluating the Effectiveness of Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models in Scientific Document Reasoning
| 2023-11-07T21:09:57 | 2023-11-07T21:09:57 |
Sai Munikoti, Anurag Acharya, Sridevi Wagle, Sameera Horawalavithana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Despite the dramatic progress in Large Language Model (LLM) development, LLMs
often provide seemingly plausible but not factual information, often referred
to as hallucinations. Retrieval-augmented LLMs provide a non-parametric
approach to solve these issues by retrieving relevant information from external
data sources and augment the training process. These models help to trace
evidence from an externally provided knowledge base allowing the model
predictions to be better interpreted and verified. In this work, we critically
evaluate these models in their ability to perform in scientific document
reasoning tasks. To this end, we tuned multiple such model variants with
science-focused instructions and evaluated them on a scientific document
reasoning benchmark for the usefulness of the retrieved document passages. Our
findings suggest that models justify predictions in science tasks with
fabricated evidence and leveraging scientific corpus as pretraining data does
not alleviate the risk of evidence fabrication.
|
[
-0.12350633,
-0.4257040918,
1.0543841124,
-0.0308450647,
-0.2015435398,
-0.0127605963,
-0.4169426262,
-0.630949676,
0.2314711213,
0.7007030249,
-0.1533544362,
-0.4815546572,
-0.7129660249,
0.5482500196,
-0.6956109405,
0.6275591254,
-0.0688649938,
0.3220375776,
-0.4907255471,
0.2599294186,
-0.1475294083,
-0.5426422954,
-0.0907294527,
-0.4607273638,
0.4995444119,
0.0944261923,
0.5179775953,
0.4749397039,
0.7182556391,
0.2653112113,
-0.1070912182,
0.5153821111,
-0.4035636187,
0.1297307611,
-0.4100140333,
-0.5358864069,
-0.1683214456,
0.13170214,
0.7481140494,
0.9463597536,
0.0394412018,
-0.0495629236,
-0.0676478893,
0.3011855185,
-0.5179354548,
0.1536199749,
-0.8186137676,
-0.1531998813,
0.0363302641,
-0.3507463634,
-0.8797910213,
-0.3115732372,
0.2581987083,
-0.6895386577,
0.3723783791,
0.245107919,
0.7194868326,
0.0366201401,
-0.2525145411,
-0.5540159345,
-0.6446573138,
0.7493731976,
-0.725163281,
0.6016508341,
0.624792099,
0.0161988698,
-0.3649228215,
-0.9174848199,
-0.5012057424,
-0.7778317332,
-0.1606441289,
-0.1067099124,
0.265257597,
0.021391904,
0.6222274899,
0.226637587,
-0.4248264432,
0.1069226041,
-0.4569113255,
-0.3092330694,
0.5193437338,
0.0016242136,
0.0639593303,
-0.3472365141,
-0.1250698864,
-0.1470617205,
-0.656838119,
-0.3779575527,
0.2627598047,
0.4522928894,
0.2781836092,
0.9178510308,
-0.201158911,
0.6629510522,
0.0561932772,
-0.1842016131,
0.1642195135,
-0.2996425033,
-0.1531313807,
0.1937542856,
0.4546616673,
0.1883221716,
-0.0928051695,
-0.5331726074,
-0.2635550499,
0.1116173044,
0.4962061644,
-0.9459807873,
-0.0427029468,
0.1258449703,
-0.4787302613,
-0.0981818885,
-0.0825111717,
-0.6038562655,
-0.607470572,
-0.4800414145,
0.5224488378,
-0.5847290158,
-0.0450807475,
0.1471270919,
-0.2865221202,
-0.0920350254,
0.6367958188,
-0.8640148044,
0.00580084,
0.7945472598,
0.9123849869,
-0.2648938298,
-0.2686348557,
-0.3620015681,
0.1277482957,
-0.4943600893,
1.0404213667,
-0.8198675513,
-0.7130548358,
-0.1160245538,
0.1443609595,
-0.0998571739,
-0.6345868707,
0.7056213617,
-0.5409287214,
0.031697318,
-0.561814785,
-0.6337614059,
-0.2128154188,
0.2374482453,
-0.6467221975,
0.8413003683,
0.0714414418,
-0.6943190098,
0.4559220374,
-0.3283262551,
-0.4079909325,
0.2213318348,
-0.2502114475,
-0.0706478953,
0.2395799905,
0.0202319156,
0.295776695,
-0.412536025,
0.3960205615,
-0.5063709617,
-0.4503364265,
0.1898090839,
-0.3530725241,
0.2538496852,
0.1613836884,
-0.2029552162,
0.0883871093,
-0.8226423264,
-0.1007724628,
-0.0758798122,
-0.2972507775,
-0.4889467955,
0.0006951557,
-0.2605772018,
-0.0240618978,
0.2587028742,
-0.6887030005,
0.2567408979,
-0.3374261856,
0.2283720374,
0.4985064566,
-0.1414491981,
0.3243599236,
-0.3221921921,
0.2587820888,
-0.2660139799,
-0.1273686439,
-0.1305809617,
-0.2903785408,
-0.3743595183,
-0.2750174105,
0.1186123565,
0.1066448241,
-0.7873741388,
0.1349318773,
-0.2248940915,
-0.6642083526,
-0.4205335379,
-0.0176256336,
0.2377953082,
0.9428197145,
0.4835804105,
0.0755462348,
-0.6214556098,
-0.6753225923,
-0.2726067603,
-0.1056030914,
-0.0098340828,
0.3387981951,
0.8585889935,
-0.2876424193,
0.5831627846,
-0.1159924939,
0.1750547439,
0.0252735037,
0.3160497248,
0.238704443,
0.2295322716,
0.2278853506,
-0.6779313684,
-0.1811115146,
-0.0042773597,
-1.1496858597,
-0.039659299,
-0.02264308,
0.1107271388,
0.3389970958,
0.376601547,
-0.9162414074,
0.437020272,
0.2602972984,
-0.1656950712,
1.0869258642,
-0.4155198336,
0.5086954236,
-0.4437832236,
0.2604011297,
-0.0808307752,
0.007149878,
-0.589253068,
0.090415813,
0.1839892566,
0.0183923114,
-0.3069525063,
0.628718853,
-0.6088580489,
-0.2349181473,
-0.638389945,
0.2415911257,
0.1782497019,
-0.1132635325,
0.4850691855,
0.8319973946,
0.3960442543,
-0.4584043324,
0.1904163659,
0.1844150126,
-0.7130625248,
0.3779641688,
-0.5404426455,
0.2076573372,
-0.2950306237,
0.3007802367,
-0.6198738217,
-0.407371074,
-0.1734743863,
-0.2541407347,
0.3046630621,
0.2013653815,
-0.7264819145,
-0.5280783772,
-0.1530159116,
0.0933569074,
0.2588570714,
-0.7748073936,
0.7810181379,
-0.0207418185,
0.0320584998,
-0.5754755139,
-0.4776266217,
0.105600819,
-0.1695560217,
-0.5848146677,
0.464905113,
-0.0428401195,
-0.409003973,
-0.041189421,
-0.3450422585,
0.2981787324,
-0.0237887446,
0.3836700022,
0.4586654902,
-0.1727045476,
0.1659577936,
-0.0617574379,
0.2162365466,
0.225042969,
-0.0500085652,
0.4221699834,
-0.0040826281,
-0.5128769279,
-0.209392488,
0.125086531,
0.6039671302,
0.1036216244,
0.9994056821,
0.2498558462,
-0.6089863181,
-0.0423957556,
-0.9219466448,
-0.5061347485,
-0.4224004447,
0.3990483284,
-0.4224334955,
-0.7811238766,
0.5375753045,
-0.1706519127,
-0.1620847136,
0.4656148255,
0.5226172209,
-0.0986241326,
0.9527306557,
0.1035963297,
0.4350508451,
0.1961410791,
-0.1621239483,
0.1155364066,
-1.007963419,
-0.711709857,
-0.6891630292,
0.3002969325,
-0.1972076148,
-0.5347701311,
0.2868744731,
0.2041181922,
-0.1416046619,
0.3344801962,
-0.5830273628,
0.2875628173,
0.4090654552,
0.2236897945,
0.3859930038,
0.0664962679,
-0.2093974948,
0.034120176,
-0.4920603335,
-0.8978331685,
1.2258878946,
0.2021525651,
0.7579305172,
-0.3235168755,
0.4641609788,
0.1924142838,
0.4319021702,
-0.6172792315,
0.5970975757,
-0.0575805828,
-0.6085948944,
-0.2459447533,
-0.3998894989,
-0.8283964396,
0.4627931714,
-0.3453837037,
-0.8307670355,
0.2281657755,
-0.2011688352,
-0.242992416,
0.0890277624,
-0.7275291085,
0.5354970694,
-0.4625701904,
-0.5183555484,
-0.4618837833,
-0.350941658,
0.4281134009,
-0.4240099788,
0.2366564721,
0.1558642983,
0.2153215557,
0.8573336601,
-0.4232764244,
0.692879498,
-0.1331963986,
-0.1945327967,
0.3380976021,
0.1007138118,
0.7225679159,
0.0770420879,
-0.6283571124,
0.116555199,
0.3382299244,
-0.1956583112,
-0.6716313958,
0.8094063401,
-0.6373387575,
-1.0688924789,
-0.5040491819,
-0.732855618,
-0.2671096027,
0.3170072138,
0.1902187169,
0.2941880226,
-0.0009193742,
0.3526642919,
0.5921880603,
-0.1460086107,
0.137351945,
0.800778389,
-0.3027238846,
-0.2551602721,
0.6672899127,
0.2140316367,
0.2865704596,
0.2160943002,
0.0677116439,
-0.5257120728,
-0.9569585323,
-0.0684939474,
0.4923385978,
-0.8785492182,
0.0126047088,
-0.6742629409,
-0.2517485619,
-0.5970448256,
0.0054458841,
-0.2537176907,
-0.236696437,
-0.5239936709,
-0.2301198095,
0.2888617218,
0.6665027142,
0.0134601984,
-0.0181089751,
-0.7476945519,
0.3063122928,
-0.1292533875,
0.1996657252,
0.044465553,
-0.8220769763,
-0.3300104439,
0.1729548573,
0.0219880901,
-0.867110312,
0.3483062387,
-0.1926261634,
0.7523184419,
0.2189883292,
-0.0663754642,
0.634319067,
-0.5491604209,
0.7038745284,
0.0037756404,
-0.6311430335,
0.5046166778,
-0.246987164,
-0.0212984625,
0.4616352916,
0.6020219922,
-0.0656859055,
-0.2215239108,
-0.4220102429,
-0.5029334426,
0.5044742227,
-0.179949373,
-0.1459594816,
-0.1847771555,
0.5829923749,
0.4226539135,
0.3117502332,
-0.4516085684,
0.2807200551,
-0.3269992173,
0.0314629152,
-0.0024214138,
-0.1792884022,
-0.0928895548,
-0.2652982771,
0.6746617556,
-0.1533535123,
0.1788222492,
0.3529692292,
-0.2574638724,
-0.1399684101,
0.1496310085,
0.7399113178,
0.8215585947,
-0.3767042458,
0.3037748337,
0.0887051895,
-0.5789803863,
-0.0772092566,
0.3139149547,
-0.2119161338,
-0.0065779756,
0.6010284424,
0.8976108432,
0.1207047477,
-0.8874468207,
0.1390846521,
0.1747466326,
-0.3397361338,
-0.1994425356,
0.0420898087,
0.0654713959,
0.3430004716,
0.5358753204,
0.0657604262,
0.1607572138,
-0.6068894267,
0.0911314413,
0.7365235686,
0.0125693483,
-0.3410822451,
0.6198132634,
-0.214052096,
-0.1756984144,
0.6986284852,
-0.0895201936,
-0.4230487347,
0.5467433929,
0.7969604135,
0.4136399925,
-0.0437372588,
0.3385031521,
0.3781146109,
0.3917694986,
-0.5321481824,
0.2181421965,
0.0954937115,
-0.5596550107,
-0.6594800353,
-0.8340762258,
-0.5287023187,
0.2913359702,
-0.3745490313,
0.300234586,
-0.3259166181,
-0.1990999579,
0.049487751,
-0.0355424173,
-0.4677602649,
0.2191223353,
0.1126300171,
1.0333247185,
-0.6689818501,
0.8599179983,
0.4235783815,
-0.5027608871,
-0.7553320527,
-0.2874755561,
-0.3085310459,
-0.7495961785,
0.9179772735,
0.101211518,
-0.1291152835,
-0.2666107714,
-0.5526529551,
-1.0926939249,
0.9806554914,
0.5253920555,
-0.7114311457,
-0.3040044606,
0.0741845071,
0.7898615003,
-0.4090903103,
0.5768705606,
0.3919638097,
0.677523613,
0.5761597157,
-0.8235214949,
0.3222287297,
-0.1252619475,
-0.2131390721,
-0.1262576282,
-0.3405033052,
0.7337793708,
-0.3898423016,
-0.1876577437,
0.1450423449,
0.7458546758,
0.5905081034,
0.4682478905,
0.2532795668,
0.4273746908,
1.1455734968,
0.0930438489,
1.2275184393,
-0.3285591602,
0.0496040061,
1.0357106924,
-0.7912621498,
0.9067705274,
0.6043981314,
-0.057490699,
0.566224575,
0.6590676308,
-0.3556390107,
0.620424509,
0.0967621282,
-0.1728281826,
-0.2722331882,
-0.4244940877,
-0.5362710357,
0.2205355912,
0.6115134954,
-0.5864362121,
-0.0670388639,
0.2025996596,
-0.167518124,
0.126197353,
-0.3316731751,
0.3886372149,
0.1574418843,
-1.0223593712,
0.7218469977,
-0.0890024006,
0.461861968,
-0.3578947484,
-0.0853703544,
0.0823024064,
0.0033906926,
-0.4586587548,
-0.5795696974,
0.322461307,
0.109533079,
-0.2536688447,
-0.1118024513,
0.7948897481,
-0.2800963819,
-0.4355697334,
0.2433140427,
0.1689560264,
0.3657645583,
-0.167264536,
-0.2769802213,
0.124915719,
-0.2046550959,
-0.2853398621,
0.4185420275,
0.2295479327,
-0.1360959262,
0.6250082254,
0.7464125752,
0.3654375672,
0.0439569987,
0.2162622511,
0.7479763627,
-0.5067844987,
0.0170246605,
-0.7605387568,
0.1453823894,
-0.0487035848,
0.2026442736,
1.0277907848,
0.6431764364,
0.590505898,
-0.1813272685,
0.7381299138,
0.20119524,
0.6463139057,
-0.6192492843,
0.6224207282,
-0.3794003427,
0.4088693857,
-0.1377569586,
-0.8704321384,
-0.133259505,
0.5679838061,
-0.741513133,
0.2635523081,
1.1093512774,
0.8338903189,
0.0683973134,
0.3963658214,
0.2099611163,
0.3194246292,
0.1694841385,
0.183896035,
0.9942440391,
-0.1073941663,
0.2148992121,
-0.1112745181,
-0.0971355215,
-0.1839508712,
-0.9572812319,
-1.07797122,
-0.4361693263,
-0.2660836875,
-0.509105742,
0.1072862074,
0.799252212,
0.5329933763,
-0.6849070191,
0.059037935,
-0.085585691,
0.0027107599,
0.1183568537,
-0.1786228269,
0.5982527733,
-0.3349115252,
-0.5201049447,
0.8769732118,
0.2029602975,
-0.0049575609,
-0.2653221488,
-0.1267106831,
-0.2669531107,
0.2903859019,
0.5931779742,
0.1937114298,
-0.8845369816,
-0.4314279556,
0.3316486776,
-0.1901239157,
-0.1199716553,
0.6802486777,
-0.8227154613,
0.5394585133,
0.4917941988,
0.5887976885,
0.8251786828,
-0.0346478075,
0.3518498838,
-0.2238517106,
0.0170027278,
0.2503366172,
0.5032157302,
0.5022203326,
-0.4268331528,
0.490844965,
0.3079371154,
-0.644620657,
-1.2780789137,
-0.1790154874,
-0.7238551378,
-0.4131876826,
1.1813585758,
-0.2249047458,
-0.3556179404,
0.0648305342,
-0.0164788514,
0.2779010534,
-0.1620101184,
1.0554747581,
0.9663398862,
-0.1942432523,
-0.0579348356,
-0.516418457,
0.3398422003,
0.4440182447,
-0.8718702793,
0.0133612268,
0.5871213078,
0.1086800098,
0.4871162176,
0.2746056616,
-0.1760627031,
0.1813938767,
0.1671342403,
-0.0765166581,
-0.2262507975,
-0.4751715064,
-0.1405185312,
0.2379652411,
0.1678146422,
0.363035202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04345v1
|
A Taxonomy of Rater Disagreements: Surveying Challenges & Opportunities from the Perspective of Annotating Online Toxicity
| 2023-11-07T21:00:51 | 2023-11-07T21:00:51 |
Wenbo Zhang, Hangzhi Guo, Ian D Kivlichan, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Davis Yadav, Amulya Yadav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Toxicity is an increasingly common and severe issue in online spaces.
Consequently, a rich line of machine learning research over the past decade has
focused on computationally detecting and mitigating online toxicity. These
efforts crucially rely on human-annotated datasets that identify toxic content
of various kinds in social media texts. However, such annotations historically
yield low inter-rater agreement, which was often dealt with by taking the
majority vote or other such approaches to arrive at a single ground truth
label. Recent research has pointed out the importance of accounting for the
subjective nature of this task when building and utilizing these datasets, and
this has triggered work on analyzing and better understanding rater
disagreements, and how they could be effectively incorporated into the machine
learning developmental pipeline. While these efforts are filling an important
gap, there is a lack of a broader framework about the root causes of rater
disagreement, and therefore, we situate this work within that broader
landscape. In this survey paper, we analyze a broad set of literature on the
reasons behind rater disagreements focusing on online toxicity, and propose a
detailed taxonomy for the same. Further, we summarize and discuss the potential
solutions targeting each reason for disagreement. We also discuss several open
issues, which could promote the future development of online toxicity research.
|
[
-0.6818807125,
-0.6018915176,
0.5101104975,
0.2322204113,
0.0309714433,
0.0408061035,
0.014291849,
-0.7132754326,
0.0415554345,
0.2811995149,
-0.4310799539,
-0.1101832613,
-0.7855071425,
0.2415796071,
0.1580474824,
1.3493206501,
-0.0502977483,
-0.0407344885,
-0.4534776211,
-0.3543738723,
-0.4368825853,
-0.9278380275,
-0.8710275292,
-0.2375653237,
1.3489018679,
0.3313499093,
0.3325119913,
0.274050355,
0.9444081187,
0.4142733812,
-0.4156358242,
-0.0529101826,
-0.3463841379,
0.4545266628,
-0.0067872065,
-0.5736944079,
-0.4529870749,
-0.0804201216,
0.078678064,
0.4675170779,
-0.1533957124,
0.2190839499,
-0.065273419,
0.7729025483,
-0.8644937873,
0.2070629448,
-0.580068171,
0.4816352129,
-0.2640655637,
-0.125322178,
-0.3523776829,
-0.3760912418,
0.0818285123,
-0.6377311945,
0.1138967797,
-0.410882473,
0.83897084,
0.6144351363,
-0.7669294477,
-0.3573041558,
-0.7039352059,
0.5978229046,
-0.658721745,
0.0591071695,
0.2858175635,
0.3711443841,
0.0589671806,
-0.6408532262,
-0.4386006594,
0.2015649378,
-0.2506247461,
0.1684847623,
-0.4817517698,
0.0004792958,
0.4075729251,
0.1781703681,
-0.1535838544,
0.211758852,
-0.2999311984,
-0.4575940073,
0.5637230277,
0.2950409055,
0.0885610729,
-0.1759721637,
-0.1517563611,
0.1837195754,
-0.4088581204,
0.1884351969,
0.6409686208,
0.2356427312,
0.1835656017,
0.344987154,
-0.0124819735,
0.4710565507,
-0.0136131886,
0.3948108256,
0.2185441405,
0.0079688756,
0.2206200063,
0.284270525,
0.9460119605,
0.8917714953,
0.0790679902,
0.1434524208,
-0.1677227914,
0.4536190033,
0.5776853561,
-0.9051840305,
-0.2531261146,
0.622322619,
-0.4089870453,
-0.5500289798,
0.0594184659,
-0.9676133394,
-0.7262923121,
-0.0389249772,
0.5012025833,
0.3052123487,
-0.5188276172,
-0.3670643568,
-0.4347054362,
-0.2708586454,
0.237737909,
-0.4886041582,
-0.0759828389,
0.7592610717,
1.0074055195,
0.0501021445,
0.1733907759,
-0.3019447327,
-0.3298513293,
-0.348228842,
1.005872488,
-0.2310809493,
-0.2259166986,
0.0944136083,
-0.1148593575,
0.198412478,
-0.5749105811,
0.7378958464,
-0.5498415232,
0.4032069147,
-0.4891584516,
-0.5455138087,
-0.0161459781,
0.5937616825,
-0.6334013343,
0.8324742317,
-0.1341531277,
-1.2427712679,
0.6481725574,
-0.8651061654,
-0.0904876813,
0.1566329449,
0.3013254702,
-0.6180747151,
0.0061957277,
-0.1609567553,
0.3675383329,
0.0475723818,
0.3961414993,
-0.462759614,
-0.1586831957,
0.5927637219,
0.004338129,
0.7574238181,
0.6457201242,
-0.0793494135,
0.4642317891,
-0.605066359,
-0.0996686593,
-0.0738794282,
-0.3209206164,
-0.6021649241,
0.408500433,
0.1055932716,
0.4553709924,
-0.0745828077,
-0.7507774234,
-0.2011649907,
0.0368765369,
0.8636636138,
0.7957680225,
0.3091175556,
0.0581001416,
-0.7121511102,
0.2479983717,
0.2189589888,
0.6354102492,
-0.0523949154,
-0.5983365774,
-0.7009252906,
-0.0359389558,
0.2241994292,
0.0765584335,
-0.3342802823,
0.1595785022,
-0.2578496039,
-0.8016627431,
-0.6515269279,
-0.3310084939,
0.3377461731,
0.5856035948,
0.5926944017,
-0.5274363756,
-0.498701334,
-0.5793138146,
-0.4769596159,
-0.4938736856,
0.0928121433,
0.4998840392,
0.1639097929,
-0.2426988631,
1.2277907133,
-0.2867072523,
-0.8351504803,
0.1568667293,
0.4043858945,
-0.0669600293,
0.3784346879,
0.2194129527,
-0.9941573143,
-0.6225361228,
-0.1059270054,
-0.7108482122,
-0.3824577034,
0.0881018117,
0.0718618035,
0.2005669177,
0.2540465891,
-0.1472687572,
0.0605202205,
0.4059205651,
-0.0285643227,
0.1930382997,
-0.0082465438,
0.2872418463,
-0.7353245616,
-0.056638483,
0.4630764723,
0.3243433833,
-1.0491957664,
0.160090521,
-0.0995981172,
0.3437022567,
-0.7451902032,
0.286917448,
0.0296258498,
0.3017724454,
-0.042244941,
-0.1140406281,
-0.203224346,
0.1544034183,
0.1368843466,
0.4162439108,
0.0984086841,
-0.6096190214,
0.3453892767,
0.4149257839,
0.1904934049,
0.7073242068,
-0.5035203099,
0.1045252457,
-0.3647243977,
0.601752162,
-0.7756047845,
-0.3301825523,
0.5587792993,
-0.5277485251,
-0.1133322492,
-0.7412694097,
-0.2335573733,
-0.386859715,
-0.3834372461,
0.5055786967,
0.268953383,
-0.2808323205,
0.4316220582,
0.7541519403,
-0.1197468564,
-0.7324411869,
-0.5762717128,
0.1008685082,
-0.669618547,
-0.5319532752,
0.190319404,
0.0152542535,
-0.7275637984,
-0.043342378,
0.0465989113,
-0.2705056071,
0.0996439755,
0.478682816,
-0.0814247727,
-0.2148204595,
0.3788968921,
-0.2977153063,
-0.4881772697,
0.5793600678,
0.2407556027,
0.3210602999,
-0.1858493537,
-0.1241663247,
-0.1454132795,
0.1582044661,
0.2689684331,
-0.1601162255,
0.5617499352,
0.477420032,
-0.3616036475,
0.011067152,
-0.5413483381,
0.246476993,
-0.4799011648,
-0.0372530408,
-0.0726786032,
-0.9017934799,
0.7595791221,
-0.128677994,
0.2173119187,
0.7585782409,
0.6033755541,
-0.3341250718,
0.923755765,
0.4479070306,
0.2029989213,
0.3384671807,
-0.0033885087,
0.1198319569,
-0.6903445721,
-0.4036047757,
-0.5494513512,
-0.4311875105,
-0.8258461356,
-0.2885327935,
0.4292398393,
-0.3304845393,
-0.6767030358,
0.038017001,
-0.6561770439,
0.3709075451,
0.0689285919,
0.1484391093,
0.4961723983,
-0.2679130733,
0.185239777,
-0.3122311234,
-0.6967695951,
-0.5165702701,
0.7229250669,
0.6360471249,
0.3731431067,
0.2184899449,
0.4078658223,
0.4585255384,
0.897505939,
-0.893529892,
0.2329645008,
0.0512134284,
-1.2560122013,
0.1007574499,
-0.7510331869,
-0.8566803336,
0.3065116405,
-0.1090061441,
-0.4307237566,
0.3852805793,
0.2461724579,
-0.2033323497,
0.5250826478,
-0.4802904725,
1.2269490957,
-0.3137800395,
-0.4602240324,
-0.0426465347,
-0.9793925881,
0.3731077313,
-0.2746295035,
0.6526040435,
-0.2517997921,
0.1324278712,
0.7876841426,
-0.6661729217,
0.8840923905,
-0.3274973631,
-0.2940504551,
0.4623376131,
0.0019840985,
0.082032159,
-0.2558254898,
0.0178823136,
0.4744769037,
0.2034119815,
-0.1812105477,
0.1860006005,
0.4533952177,
-0.7072277665,
-0.0348309651,
-0.7751225233,
-0.0562803969,
-0.3038780391,
-0.1312351674,
0.429232657,
0.0175803807,
-0.2326841652,
-0.1368879378,
0.5921473503,
-0.5122321248,
0.3136000931,
0.2934150696,
-0.3017539978,
-0.2831595838,
1.2271764278,
0.0391316451,
0.3012860715,
0.0724190697,
0.3328872025,
-0.1427982599,
-0.2144687027,
-0.263689369,
-0.2041272521,
-1.0249860287,
-0.4434594214,
-0.7718684673,
-0.2384449244,
0.0304649286,
-0.0615515597,
-0.2073854953,
-0.0947720408,
-0.3022850156,
0.0533604883,
0.6577000022,
1.0465484858,
-0.3244259357,
0.3748223484,
-1.061437726,
-0.1336557418,
0.0745235533,
0.588295579,
0.1319117546,
-0.2240252793,
0.1178061068,
0.0860725343,
-0.2359748781,
-0.9569659233,
0.2366742641,
-0.0693744868,
0.350871563,
0.519220829,
0.2519584,
0.8716003299,
-0.2130389661,
0.7703616619,
0.1810275018,
-0.6537508965,
0.4308172166,
-0.3468644917,
-0.4837779701,
0.5550060868,
1.0210753679,
-1.3153713942,
-0.4482744336,
-0.3939058483,
-1.0301066637,
0.5525718927,
0.0501218289,
0.0994255096,
-0.0931743085,
0.1138971671,
0.2216050774,
0.0639020428,
-0.7735934854,
-0.2318941951,
-0.2862316072,
-0.0718574375,
0.0158274062,
-0.2025623471,
-0.2854938209,
-0.090623036,
0.5170325637,
-0.0156234689,
-0.1257371008,
-0.0138509097,
-0.2366031557,
-0.7159211636,
0.576381743,
0.1812684834,
0.4896837175,
-0.251776278,
0.3040805161,
0.0040314393,
-0.3041388094,
0.3486616313,
0.1338811517,
-0.3063343167,
-0.2030025721,
0.3185137212,
0.3529900312,
0.1367583424,
-0.6168113351,
0.6689550281,
-0.2221375853,
-0.2032190412,
-0.2944091856,
-0.2876054645,
-0.1091870517,
0.1207249165,
0.4195258319,
0.2859047949,
-0.027211694,
-0.5423920155,
0.3626836836,
0.2302105278,
-1.0414139032,
-0.0195735842,
0.6544542909,
0.2784673274,
-0.2024639696,
0.4439517856,
-0.1997215599,
-0.8260066509,
0.6073152423,
-0.0281500965,
0.5029072762,
0.0943996087,
0.4566451311,
0.4942781031,
0.0958255306,
0.1056263521,
0.0615036935,
0.3155305982,
-0.7364750504,
-0.2372179329,
-0.7276937366,
-0.6114801168,
-0.1713382304,
-0.6446605921,
0.1070731282,
-0.5370017886,
-0.6386471987,
0.1223556548,
-0.2583227754,
-0.4736118913,
-0.1183044314,
0.2249990851,
0.4018544555,
-0.9900914431,
-0.0494879335,
0.8115689754,
-0.9575434327,
-0.4715455174,
0.0052410485,
0.3874721527,
-0.2313439548,
0.8085364699,
0.2702043355,
0.2765596211,
-0.0968305618,
-0.3431551456,
-0.2950420082,
0.7557703853,
-0.2854626179,
-0.4474393725,
0.1770515293,
0.1818557978,
1.0287739038,
-0.1310850829,
0.6513186097,
0.1400105059,
0.5248419046,
0.1540472955,
-0.8044112921,
0.0936657563,
-0.2464957833,
-0.0021711702,
0.303904593,
-0.7878991961,
0.7943818569,
-0.1675428152,
-0.3918695748,
-0.3642786443,
0.2447184175,
-0.1514325589,
0.737107873,
0.5461505055,
0.7282797098,
0.2897332907,
-0.3443026245,
0.681007266,
0.1989803016,
0.585954845,
0.6806753278,
-0.3852964342,
0.8647701144,
0.307846725,
-0.578024447,
0.5712570548,
1.2865533829,
-0.0879372805,
0.2543797493,
0.4648007154,
-0.3458363414,
-0.3468347788,
-0.5367674232,
-0.4564394355,
0.0751110017,
0.431883812,
-0.0751810148,
-0.4140451252,
-0.1197405085,
-0.1564711034,
-0.0632641688,
-0.3403158486,
1.2085393667,
0.0127885137,
-0.5022259951,
-0.1566080749,
-0.0399274006,
0.9380595684,
-0.313313067,
-0.0603242517,
-0.1611658633,
0.2234600335,
-0.6364853978,
-0.9410233498,
0.3943512142,
0.2341230363,
0.2270911783,
-0.2806434631,
0.7962729931,
-0.1209954396,
-0.225251317,
0.3298347294,
0.6390129924,
0.263435334,
-0.2216346413,
-0.7045407891,
0.2599372864,
-0.5047292709,
0.0138886021,
0.4886550009,
0.6032472849,
-0.0679979995,
0.6024677157,
0.744645834,
0.1488037556,
0.2445883304,
0.106276691,
0.8676285744,
-0.2205756754,
-0.2852486372,
-0.7366285324,
0.7042813897,
-0.03676337,
-0.5039444566,
0.4540577531,
0.4218935668,
0.8908332586,
0.2303130031,
0.6953710914,
-0.3990798593,
0.5241081119,
-0.0375099182,
1.0188251734,
-0.5774850249,
0.2164018899,
-0.2723603547,
-0.9000843763,
-0.5894820094,
0.7021465302,
-0.2163566202,
0.0547814369,
0.3942593336,
0.4109924436,
0.2009088546,
-0.0249962788,
-0.2363980711,
0.2491539717,
0.543230474,
0.4852299094,
1.4533365965,
-0.3173931837,
0.7737817764,
-0.4612044096,
0.0064609563,
-0.2796326578,
-1.0853676796,
-0.6123958826,
-0.7157090306,
-0.4669599533,
-0.6354874372,
-0.0191078,
1.0390847921,
0.0666214675,
-0.9242020249,
0.0671144426,
-0.0109610371,
0.2286307961,
-0.1211601943,
-0.2573331892,
-0.1282496601,
-0.3959654272,
-0.2157627046,
-0.4049299359,
-0.0589509532,
-0.2009435445,
-0.1108958647,
-0.1042841896,
0.0535285398,
-0.2954083979,
0.6042950749,
0.5255759358,
-0.7697317004,
-0.2726210356,
-0.3441240788,
-0.2433740646,
0.3242226839,
0.891502142,
-0.5247558355,
0.6159363389,
0.4500108063,
0.6470119357,
0.3249317706,
0.0371069014,
0.1485416442,
-0.6280411482,
-0.5547341704,
0.41947335,
0.1443440616,
0.4515888393,
-0.3532712162,
0.5218571424,
0.2901702523,
-0.588973105,
-0.8927723765,
0.140278399,
-0.822630465,
-0.3435302675,
0.9416865706,
-0.1884071678,
0.2638741434,
-0.3462278545,
-0.0729695559,
0.3403794467,
-0.3458215594,
1.1096503735,
0.8596231341,
-0.2835152745,
0.0282517541,
-0.683126688,
0.6322443485,
-0.0054233456,
-1.0248965025,
0.3112083077,
0.7788977027,
0.2956591249,
0.4427872002,
0.7692722678,
-0.1575792134,
-0.0854468942,
-0.1328583509,
0.0700362325,
0.2020653188,
-0.206624642,
-0.3858942389,
0.3143069744,
-0.0085069854,
0.3922193944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04335v1
|
Sub-Sentence Encoder: Contrastive Learning of Propositional Semantic Representations
| 2023-11-07T20:38:30 | 2023-11-07T20:38:30 |
Sihao Chen, Hongming Zhang, Tong Chen, Ben Zhou, Wenhao Yu, Dian Yu, Baolin Peng, Hongwei Wang, Dan Roth, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce sub-sentence encoder, a contrastively-learned contextual
embedding model for fine-grained semantic representation of text. In contrast
to the standard practice with sentence embeddings, where the meaning of an
entire sequence of text is encoded into a fixed-length vector, the sub-sentence
encoder learns to produce distinct contextual embeddings corresponding to
different atomic propositions, i.e. atomic units of meaning expressed within a
text sequence. The sub-sentence embeddings are contrastively learned to
recognize (inferred) semantic equivalence between propositions across different
text sequences. Our experiments show the effectiveness of sub-sentence encoders
in applications, such as retrieving supporting facts for fine-grained text
attribution or recognizing the conditional semantic similarity between texts.
In practice, we demonstrate that sub-sentence encoders keep the same level of
inference cost and space complexity compared to sentence encoders.
|
[
-0.1422503144,
-0.769477427,
0.6275708675,
-0.2538575232,
-0.5760010481,
-0.3348670006,
-0.0700180084,
-0.206704855,
0.2109269202,
0.2799104154,
-0.3983893692,
-0.3833657801,
-0.5119808912,
0.1181093603,
-0.4810509682,
0.7978952527,
0.1216880828,
0.0875036344,
-0.7282131314,
0.0168440193,
-0.4093298316,
-0.3729586601,
-0.3131879568,
-0.6077954173,
0.3542787731,
0.3659997284,
0.7720434666,
0.6263996959,
0.6081879139,
0.3236196041,
0.0704137459,
-0.1372857988,
-0.3044061065,
0.0012337873,
-0.5381598473,
-0.5465201735,
0.1711536795,
-0.3179148734,
0.3898304999,
0.7022281289,
-0.034706451,
-0.243738994,
0.0324568786,
0.4913934767,
-0.7994621992,
0.2481344044,
-0.6818800569,
0.4008230567,
0.047006391,
-0.2751381695,
-0.5598381758,
-0.1774393022,
0.3287605941,
-0.688663125,
0.3027484417,
0.0425688736,
0.7821211219,
0.4358355999,
-0.502874136,
-0.4683884382,
-0.3486687541,
0.7995997071,
-0.4176984131,
0.5437828898,
0.1026096046,
0.0689714924,
0.1038807482,
-0.8579397798,
-0.7214353085,
-0.1929717064,
-0.4941772521,
0.3844088614,
-0.2501261532,
0.0864366591,
-0.008327961,
0.6550795436,
-0.4698237181,
0.0318302102,
-0.0929648131,
-0.1007886305,
0.1702231169,
0.2099566311,
0.1413484514,
-0.3446094692,
-0.5248954892,
-0.1166195199,
-0.5769196749,
-0.1226932257,
-0.055767335,
0.1322373897,
-0.1223752946,
0.8178606033,
-0.3218765259,
0.257416755,
0.1213935912,
0.0832171068,
0.3243040442,
-0.2645103633,
-0.3292534351,
0.2923597395,
0.6348293424,
0.4394855499,
0.2857876718,
-0.1980696917,
-0.123072423,
0.5351356864,
0.2225941569,
-0.9109969735,
-0.34184286,
-0.0496695936,
-0.608171165,
0.1169566512,
0.3198694885,
-0.6188123226,
-0.3942854404,
-0.1899686605,
0.5627727509,
-0.6836140752,
0.3749375343,
0.3605971336,
-0.4278834164,
0.4189257324,
0.1649605334,
-0.8776469231,
0.5057484508,
0.5173155069,
0.6681004167,
0.0292706024,
-0.2410692126,
-0.4179414511,
0.2785697579,
-0.3393665254,
0.7066529989,
-0.9653144479,
-0.4218996167,
0.1482723206,
-0.0365238748,
0.0669902116,
-0.5984280109,
0.3075423837,
-0.6623566151,
0.1387192905,
-0.1902256757,
-1.084629178,
-0.0192660205,
0.3366470933,
-0.5563473105,
0.7175825238,
0.069168441,
-0.8759531975,
0.3792501986,
-0.4217070043,
-0.4011224806,
0.0444186851,
-0.4255445898,
-0.2248747349,
0.3599641323,
0.2871802449,
0.5163285732,
-0.3443712592,
-0.0543483384,
0.0369017348,
-0.3922794759,
0.3421303332,
-0.4661565423,
0.1564784497,
0.146165818,
-0.0181250609,
0.1542990059,
-0.5431666374,
-0.391795665,
0.1399058551,
-0.5035187602,
-0.715207994,
0.0379888788,
-0.0145419408,
-0.0555626526,
0.4672953784,
-0.9459447265,
-0.1118292138,
-0.5369253159,
0.5443793535,
0.4159987271,
0.1479163468,
0.6492307186,
-0.1272357106,
0.1469385475,
0.5420600176,
-0.290004462,
-0.5543182492,
-0.1190678477,
-0.9249978065,
-0.0178706385,
0.4331774116,
0.6917322278,
-1.0143315792,
0.6027091146,
-0.2976178229,
-0.1222478822,
-0.443570435,
-0.0914427638,
0.6407988667,
0.5881088972,
0.6913601756,
-0.2801002264,
-0.4721776247,
-1.0676879883,
-0.2124184221,
0.0749594644,
-0.0464581065,
0.1029445007,
0.9001970887,
-0.4911976755,
0.9876224995,
-0.6410894394,
-0.2951955497,
-0.2118294686,
0.1495171487,
-0.2807771862,
0.7900636196,
0.3422082961,
-1.1479794979,
-0.3841362894,
0.1874378771,
-0.8380793333,
0.1521946341,
-0.145797044,
0.0585720055,
0.1367080957,
1.0646791458,
-0.6408035159,
0.4486987591,
0.2115048021,
-0.3651410341,
-0.0123546012,
-0.4330744147,
0.077202104,
-1.1892591715,
-0.5837655663,
-0.0685140863,
-0.2893925905,
-0.208576262,
0.0990871713,
0.0224230476,
0.118448779,
-0.5252968073,
0.292922765,
-0.2040953934,
-0.1828600615,
-0.2192608863,
0.3964008391,
0.0459679812,
0.4181402922,
0.3177644908,
0.7125372887,
0.2778672278,
-0.4557704031,
0.4445218444,
0.2799018025,
-0.3327840865,
0.6438791752,
-0.6675304174,
-0.0170354061,
-0.3175826669,
0.3627847433,
-0.8090854883,
-0.2016180009,
-0.0140387947,
-0.1717075258,
-0.0763559937,
0.1095716804,
-0.3156042695,
0.0187076032,
-0.1496614665,
0.5171166658,
0.5611556172,
-0.5949361324,
0.6416730285,
0.2909789383,
0.1011201292,
-0.3164626062,
-1.1500076056,
-0.3143630624,
-0.1134251803,
-0.0584663488,
0.6665748358,
0.3327100873,
-0.0632129163,
0.6478083134,
0.0003232645,
0.0852109864,
-0.2914532125,
0.1820566803,
-0.111650385,
-0.3630568087,
0.3960344791,
0.2415738702,
-0.4994188547,
-0.0975264758,
-0.4739500582,
0.5452192426,
-0.4242245555,
-0.4347128272,
-0.352586925,
0.698073864,
-0.0124294059,
-0.1136485934,
0.8104471564,
0.4371940196,
-0.6345065236,
-0.0859520137,
-0.0312673189,
-0.1445701718,
-0.4362677634,
0.4755380452,
-0.666367352,
-1.0817998648,
0.3678090274,
-0.2899789512,
-0.4098598063,
0.6162520051,
0.3569845855,
-0.0848538578,
0.6116283536,
0.7925409079,
0.2372746617,
0.5316752195,
-0.2140453905,
0.0072656474,
-0.7102277875,
-0.4667670727,
-0.2866095603,
-0.2245700955,
-0.7239738703,
-0.605063796,
0.0295719374,
0.0898847505,
-0.5709731579,
0.3111668527,
-0.2166472673,
0.9381777644,
0.7267016172,
0.3522383571,
0.1658774912,
-0.265958637,
-0.246962443,
-0.2291620821,
-0.6158059835,
-0.5888303518,
0.4842889905,
0.1212429479,
0.9982262254,
0.1226797029,
0.8719306588,
0.3853220642,
-0.1972920746,
-1.0929228067,
0.4839800596,
-0.7568596005,
-0.007682208,
-0.0103036612,
-0.3276614249,
-0.7429380417,
0.4090196788,
-0.3694027662,
-0.5841202736,
0.4433846176,
0.0423224419,
-0.2314717472,
0.0569531806,
-0.7527828217,
1.2374750376,
0.1323162615,
0.0023611069,
-0.2782221138,
-0.7305576205,
-0.2269475013,
0.2649629712,
-0.2311849892,
0.2336834371,
-0.2908026874,
0.7184814215,
-0.3370281756,
0.9972903132,
-0.0187940206,
0.1672521681,
0.1963473409,
0.0516062714,
0.2586407065,
0.0030243553,
0.1054497287,
-0.171431765,
-0.0176233295,
-0.4532108009,
-0.7272443771,
0.524923861,
-0.6804385781,
-0.3441307843,
-0.4207039773,
-0.5026826262,
-0.0617030971,
0.2051286548,
0.4511094987,
0.6381176114,
-0.4972977042,
0.6533888578,
0.7932355404,
-0.2395045906,
0.4934563935,
0.1386601776,
0.0950747281,
-0.3716170788,
0.7420960665,
-0.2235135883,
0.2039003223,
1.3211714029,
0.3437155187,
-0.3120007217,
-0.2723641992,
-0.0576500371,
-0.1246149018,
-1.0969735384,
-0.2439621985,
-0.6308460236,
-0.174311772,
-0.1237044781,
-0.6676597595,
-0.4853123128,
-0.2708861828,
-0.3819412291,
-0.3476385772,
0.314833343,
0.7634060979,
0.0817858353,
0.4545795619,
-0.7824258208,
0.3851457536,
0.4070034027,
-0.0629951507,
-0.2632052898,
-0.3464197516,
-0.3241139948,
-0.1139976308,
-0.0837435201,
-0.5811737776,
0.2786334157,
0.3465910852,
0.3850950301,
0.3855065703,
0.3217766583,
0.5841550827,
-0.7220205069,
0.9636765718,
0.1624999791,
-1.2869968414,
0.6942172647,
0.0154163241,
0.476777643,
0.5759574175,
0.502264142,
-0.4048522115,
-0.1084795818,
-0.4588237703,
-0.8007589579,
0.343947649,
0.0299698301,
0.5050315261,
-0.4413571954,
0.3981236517,
0.2782659531,
0.1346033961,
-0.7579376698,
0.059160322,
-0.5522614717,
-0.7266885638,
-0.1373237818,
-0.4219396114,
0.0226021763,
-0.0100150248,
0.3839343488,
-0.3861543238,
0.4449278712,
0.4816336036,
-0.4031924307,
0.3739362061,
0.6360357404,
0.2170381695,
0.2073388696,
-0.1518534124,
0.8082151413,
0.3892689049,
-0.3424764574,
-0.0633722022,
0.0499516055,
-0.165290907,
-0.1353466511,
0.686747551,
0.8054065704,
0.5076205134,
-0.6341318488,
0.6313455105,
0.0900824815,
-0.0009519123,
-0.1285776943,
-0.0947583765,
0.0551186129,
0.4981886148,
0.0124697285,
-0.1783034503,
0.3302606046,
-0.8262086511,
0.3300495446,
0.16226767,
-0.6951202154,
-0.0408109166,
0.4839375913,
0.2426178306,
-0.0928789377,
0.5531844497,
-0.1110897362,
-0.6544286013,
0.4646146595,
0.8749068379,
0.7886750698,
0.1925271004,
0.1416935027,
0.0239847954,
0.1573390365,
0.0290138517,
0.2073869556,
-0.1776472628,
-1.057343483,
-0.0167955384,
-0.5973592997,
-0.6136498451,
-0.3797237575,
-0.9400079846,
-0.3113065362,
-0.1758144349,
0.2114751488,
0.0113787986,
-0.223257944,
-0.5151580572,
0.3596458137,
0.0630470812,
0.9506039023,
-0.9171641469,
0.7890478969,
0.7796577811,
-0.6566261649,
-0.257404387,
0.1978691667,
-0.2316636145,
-0.4466744959,
0.651034534,
0.2869143188,
-0.3783376217,
-0.0914286971,
-0.3773857057,
-0.4721657634,
1.1392731667,
0.523699224,
-0.5161044598,
0.1598050147,
0.2963065505,
0.6872289181,
-0.8572235703,
-0.0651705712,
0.4846350253,
-0.0327154659,
0.0557367057,
-0.3984368742,
0.2833723128,
-0.1620982438,
0.3988156319,
0.1421821564,
-0.3635444045,
1.035479784,
0.0531837195,
-0.1640205234,
0.1501954943,
1.0964850187,
0.0391864255,
0.3318569064,
0.2507502735,
0.7570088506,
0.5385942459,
-0.2786085904,
1.2393152714,
-0.0316909514,
0.4022689462,
1.2355706692,
-0.0314658321,
1.2720402479,
0.5659829974,
0.1645342112,
1.0420113802,
0.4183020294,
0.1871371567,
0.9686979651,
-0.0566183031,
-0.2010875195,
-0.4748909175,
-0.2543846965,
-0.2239522487,
0.3442000151,
0.4686110318,
-0.5214279294,
-0.2352964133,
0.3213086426,
-0.2969879508,
0.5760027766,
-0.3301774859,
1.0392854214,
0.2863631546,
-0.289578259,
-0.0445054881,
0.0625694022,
0.8228518367,
-0.4683146775,
-0.1867313832,
-0.1006097943,
0.7064250112,
-0.1381328702,
-1.0518305302,
0.4535697699,
-0.1950376332,
-0.4117900133,
-0.1346011758,
0.7748317122,
-0.5797837973,
-0.1792978346,
0.3332768679,
0.2079436183,
-0.0365903415,
0.1516610086,
-0.4511756301,
-0.1005292833,
-0.5189201236,
-0.0525588915,
0.1608325988,
0.8001278639,
0.0535380244,
0.3228712082,
0.2934269011,
-0.5648339391,
0.0368310697,
0.2520063818,
0.9291087985,
-1.0041538477,
-0.6752497554,
-0.8647925258,
0.3186838627,
0.0571979061,
-0.310597986,
0.6824189425,
0.631925106,
1.2928637266,
-0.2912165523,
0.6446008086,
-0.0822180435,
0.0630916953,
-1.0152704716,
0.0821339861,
-0.4606525898,
0.0941425711,
-0.0772878304,
-0.6313109398,
-0.3068553805,
0.9459797144,
-0.4213404953,
-0.1794491112,
0.984951973,
0.6187854409,
-0.1739760637,
0.2841398716,
0.2043617815,
0.0506517813,
-0.0290429834,
0.8153703809,
0.9785438776,
-0.6077861786,
0.3690008819,
-0.2289742827,
-0.0363630131,
-0.0096610822,
-0.8336145878,
-0.8827713132,
-0.6816116571,
-0.2760659456,
-0.0249778572,
0.0856513679,
1.0375487804,
0.4249535501,
-0.8926981091,
0.1345044076,
-0.6247112751,
0.0750086755,
-0.1805533171,
-0.2549027801,
0.365175575,
-0.2609733045,
-0.742076695,
0.2759153545,
0.2388812453,
0.0842263475,
-0.0387820452,
-0.1021671593,
-0.2949106693,
0.4638994336,
0.843482554,
-0.0000800299,
-0.7795003057,
-0.6709975004,
-0.3949120939,
-0.4132412672,
0.0156280138,
0.7684541941,
-0.9469143152,
0.198910296,
0.7771059275,
0.9153520465,
0.5385609865,
0.0304122288,
0.2963752449,
-0.8481577039,
0.3435478508,
0.0669347346,
0.6314451098,
0.4562299848,
-0.2393037379,
0.4247724712,
0.2046476156,
-0.1906034201,
-0.2718427181,
0.5042226911,
-0.9767707586,
-0.5723401308,
1.0224810839,
-0.2857652605,
-0.2533698976,
0.0502416492,
-0.2182163447,
0.1778212488,
-0.3824010491,
0.2209765762,
0.3884195685,
-0.2355543226,
-0.2495466024,
0.0607778244,
0.2923049927,
0.2841624022,
-0.8634110093,
-0.1977065802,
0.5282349586,
0.0010646953,
0.5112501383,
0.4180908203,
-0.0786892027,
0.1764744669,
0.7479208112,
-0.3481638432,
0.0299074147,
-0.4492532015,
-0.3461563885,
0.399672538,
-0.4109244347,
-0.4670317769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04329v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04329v2
|
Formal Aspects of Language Modeling
| 2023-11-07T20:21:42 | 2024-04-17T07:31:01 |
Ryan Cotterell, Anej Svete, Clara Meister, Tianyu Liu, Li Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have become one of the most commonly deployed NLP
inventions. In the past half-decade, their integration into core natural
language processing tools has dramatically increased the performance of such
tools, and they have entered the public discourse surrounding artificial
intelligence. Consequently, it is important for both developers and researchers
alike to understand the mathematical foundations of large language models, as
well as how to implement them. These notes are the accompaniment to the
theoretical portion of the ETH Z\"urich course on large language models,
covering what constitutes a language model from a formal, theoretical
perspective.
|
[
-0.4415544271,
-1.0899198055,
0.6554003358,
0.3512530923,
0.1043876857,
-0.1301660389,
-0.3017519116,
-1.0637843609,
0.0450411476,
0.6293234229,
-0.0884716883,
-0.2053675801,
-0.237468347,
-0.1500329375,
-0.9304603934,
0.7292712927,
0.1172138155,
0.011067817,
0.010566514,
0.1167225763,
-0.1921134293,
-0.804279983,
-0.4979366362,
-0.5318179727,
0.4090291858,
-0.0236586519,
0.9037079215,
0.6072666645,
0.5970907807,
0.4322340488,
-0.1688175201,
-0.4552373588,
0.1687902361,
0.0594413988,
-0.2288082242,
-0.7233418226,
-0.452932924,
0.1009505913,
1.0848963261,
1.170481205,
-0.2684495449,
0.0773118213,
-0.1645918041,
0.6125769019,
-0.226411283,
0.4654376209,
-0.3961988389,
0.1124990806,
-0.4212172031,
-0.1634016037,
-0.523768127,
-0.1795384437,
0.4558211267,
-0.4133538306,
-0.0170287397,
-0.1415633708,
0.6884675026,
-0.3131166399,
-0.4964183569,
-0.3592372239,
-1.262660861,
0.867269218,
-0.9307558537,
0.4194094837,
0.4196242094,
0.4231885374,
-0.2944265902,
-0.8957210779,
-0.4967547953,
-0.5268121362,
-0.0569079444,
-0.4355992973,
0.0303431135,
0.4626041651,
0.4988692999,
0.4726226628,
-0.2417680621,
0.3608072996,
-0.2844209373,
0.1023844406,
0.9252153039,
0.2384005934,
0.6296982169,
-0.0220759884,
0.2209730744,
0.4655463099,
-0.6082703471,
-0.1732483655,
0.2914450169,
0.2572143972,
-0.1450472772,
0.6190446615,
-0.1673495173,
1.1545301676,
-0.3553502262,
-0.0698254555,
-0.0397957712,
-0.4622593522,
-0.2347700894,
-0.0478379428,
0.5390802026,
-0.1245431527,
0.4497614205,
-0.0028559754,
-0.1482563615,
-0.0816679746,
0.1378795803,
-0.4737924337,
-0.278939575,
0.2190868556,
-0.1925792843,
-0.2618852258,
-0.06146238,
-0.4177128077,
-0.1671077013,
-0.8119114041,
0.085608229,
-0.164041087,
-0.2457256615,
0.3257383108,
0.1028553098,
0.5021471977,
0.5037460327,
-1.0802316666,
0.7015979886,
1.1394103765,
0.6834024191,
0.4078302383,
-0.359538734,
-0.1763522923,
-0.0024601058,
-0.6575116515,
0.7136573195,
-0.6626673341,
-0.1406468153,
0.3690534234,
-0.0339182504,
0.1452284008,
-0.0713231564,
0.5673000216,
-0.6881027222,
0.4195119739,
-0.0628574491,
-0.6805809736,
-0.4759766757,
0.0603198297,
-0.5818173289,
0.8428788781,
0.0456527881,
-0.6493257284,
-0.0385859348,
-1.0432617664,
-0.6120779514,
0.2285404205,
-0.1464385241,
-0.165818274,
0.326202035,
-0.2414918691,
0.5813294649,
-0.6287296414,
0.5291674137,
-0.215099588,
-0.1790358424,
0.4446801245,
-0.1530877054,
1.0995993614,
0.0689791963,
-0.2376748472,
0.2027507871,
-0.9370394945,
0.0828815624,
0.1374323815,
-0.2608733475,
-0.5340048075,
0.2546934783,
0.3647646606,
0.3375608325,
0.1361172944,
-0.2169208229,
0.2904522121,
-0.5879091024,
0.9431068897,
0.3072521687,
-0.0393032767,
0.7661501765,
-0.1084969267,
0.3681733608,
-0.5300933719,
0.1711026132,
-0.2271026522,
-0.6267781258,
-0.6825124025,
-0.1288659126,
0.5750846267,
0.4470874071,
-0.1276932657,
0.5770879984,
0.1342129558,
-0.5311886072,
-0.0976982489,
0.1900240034,
0.1983883083,
0.1381767094,
-0.0884821713,
0.0426158905,
-0.4759754241,
-0.8665190935,
-0.0589997508,
-0.2407542467,
-0.0929071829,
0.1867444068,
0.6023726463,
-0.119918637,
0.7739521861,
-0.3697863221,
0.1968332976,
-0.3326607347,
0.3371815979,
0.2243611515,
0.5064980984,
0.7028047442,
-0.817794323,
-0.209155634,
0.0449370034,
-0.7102752924,
-0.1168418378,
-0.0153765697,
0.0695489421,
0.1299351752,
0.5436182618,
-0.6736236811,
0.2410243899,
0.5245338082,
-0.2795850337,
0.6877990365,
-0.2422235757,
-0.0180393383,
-0.9500920177,
0.1544765681,
0.1583905965,
-0.2549827993,
-0.857924819,
0.5242756009,
-0.1339084208,
-0.3207780719,
-0.3611513972,
0.5210341215,
-0.5272413492,
-0.3950831592,
-0.3015111387,
0.2078910023,
-0.0490019247,
0.0903411806,
0.0399773233,
0.1170258671,
0.7118199468,
-0.9013748765,
0.5361604095,
-0.1375163347,
-0.560385406,
0.3554392755,
-0.9832650423,
0.0986375809,
0.0076385937,
0.1623044461,
-0.6920110583,
-0.5891136527,
-0.1088350862,
-0.1020479873,
0.430799365,
-0.0864096731,
-0.6161043048,
-0.3582726419,
0.0019051182,
0.3384865224,
0.3072431386,
-0.0968585908,
0.864615202,
0.6946438551,
-0.2200353593,
-0.3614853919,
-0.8233359456,
0.1865463257,
0.0000513234,
-0.77806288,
0.1355118603,
0.0843937621,
-0.7685436606,
-0.0870470181,
0.5739631653,
-0.3382797837,
0.5293411613,
0.1366414428,
0.172982648,
-0.5540297627,
0.3249463737,
-0.1987410784,
-0.1585483253,
0.3025398254,
-0.1982126832,
0.7178345323,
-0.2895478904,
-0.471352756,
-0.8731256127,
0.3632388413,
0.768157959,
-0.214783296,
0.730439961,
0.0886781365,
-0.6607105732,
-0.2968155146,
-0.4636259377,
-0.1157036573,
-0.4004830122,
0.6537107825,
-0.1862010807,
-0.7996200919,
0.5373163819,
0.092566289,
0.4115359783,
0.494315058,
0.4243965149,
-0.0610842481,
1.1304050684,
0.9206219316,
-0.1651746035,
0.687959969,
-0.216992259,
0.4215413332,
-0.6582038999,
0.0056593004,
-0.9561039209,
-0.0485425517,
-0.5008342266,
-0.3211463988,
-0.1889359504,
0.1986865699,
-0.2760181725,
0.2510023713,
-0.1640032381,
0.4743080139,
0.5607036352,
-0.3850516677,
0.4065431654,
-0.1495202333,
0.2094058096,
-0.0169491787,
-0.5160175562,
-0.5534320474,
0.8963351846,
0.8108756542,
0.7547770143,
0.0561310723,
0.359161824,
0.1650744379,
0.1693136841,
-0.9557403326,
0.6795199513,
0.1540497392,
-0.8085759282,
-0.4170857072,
-0.1835570186,
-0.7062219381,
-0.098682344,
-0.335609138,
-0.774538219,
0.062804684,
0.2251061797,
-0.2304117233,
0.1821087301,
-0.5573956966,
0.6424480677,
-0.2725996375,
-0.0179607458,
-0.4683018625,
-0.6338164806,
0.6458527446,
-0.1916414946,
0.4467410743,
-0.0852855146,
0.0809095055,
0.7521173954,
-0.1658888459,
0.8274430037,
0.1101651788,
-0.3583679497,
0.3954148889,
0.2046792656,
0.4920476079,
-0.075216189,
-0.0362413302,
0.1336993575,
-0.0025140864,
-0.2370675057,
-0.8696235418,
0.5699928403,
-0.6427103877,
-0.5424336791,
-0.3589198887,
-0.5957544446,
0.0452173203,
0.0510266759,
-0.1830933839,
0.6112098694,
-0.2359439135,
0.2433933318,
0.573145926,
-0.2854086161,
0.4748602808,
0.5040501356,
-0.7817554474,
-0.0846132264,
0.5373699069,
0.2734953165,
0.4422203898,
0.4297036827,
0.4142775238,
-0.1469879299,
-0.5106442571,
-0.0444474518,
0.4413871467,
-0.8296407461,
0.3676048815,
-0.9261139631,
-0.6682727337,
-0.2785779238,
-0.3487394452,
-0.43970263,
-0.7889874578,
-0.073025696,
-0.0222488623,
0.2307026088,
1.1543608904,
-0.0976992697,
0.3646125793,
-0.7262430787,
0.2834461033,
0.4393192232,
0.3575479388,
0.1902062595,
-0.5180059075,
-0.230083406,
0.0171214379,
0.0858348086,
-0.5296652317,
0.1133464202,
0.2506349087,
0.53745538,
0.456720978,
-0.3225360513,
0.3425768614,
-0.5443590879,
0.8612340093,
0.032335639,
-1.11401546,
0.4533150792,
-0.4818396866,
0.2273063362,
0.0837281421,
0.3220490515,
-0.7913990021,
-0.3221350014,
-0.6043497324,
-0.720985055,
0.5530844927,
-0.0402557552,
0.317743063,
0.1404614598,
0.3514163792,
-0.2980982363,
0.2421859056,
-0.83964926,
-0.2546024323,
0.2300148308,
-0.0380086638,
-0.0708784014,
-0.6042176485,
-0.0511411689,
-0.4513111115,
0.6165851355,
0.1843122095,
0.1631362289,
-0.2496353239,
-0.0031789234,
-0.042210985,
0.3642580509,
0.8341971636,
1.2031958103,
-0.0334898271,
0.167085439,
-0.2119871229,
-0.3154863417,
-0.0281003676,
0.0225793142,
-0.2294552773,
0.0515346713,
0.5658789873,
0.434117347,
0.657181561,
-0.3949169517,
0.187959522,
0.2653633058,
-0.1929205358,
-0.5081514716,
-0.1084646136,
0.1741416603,
0.1698643714,
0.2958110869,
-0.0975399464,
0.2469464242,
-0.9549124241,
0.2075994909,
0.3565536439,
-0.3246336877,
-0.551889956,
0.3564768434,
0.3339125216,
-0.5645278096,
0.5107452869,
0.1072302982,
-0.7041112781,
0.5245417953,
0.7241298556,
0.9093357325,
-0.4349640906,
0.3112199306,
0.2691967785,
0.3608332574,
-0.4168503582,
0.1489065289,
0.0815663114,
-0.530317843,
-0.7972565293,
-0.6786617041,
-0.2992492318,
0.1229018271,
-0.231535241,
0.393871814,
-0.6541672945,
-0.2148927003,
0.4791617095,
-0.1320440024,
-0.373075068,
-0.0926218331,
0.2096738964,
0.8281989694,
-0.948866725,
0.6912243366,
0.6940392256,
-0.2139879018,
-0.6297585368,
-0.4437783062,
0.0442131795,
-0.451751709,
0.8939495683,
-0.1512138546,
-0.0872420222,
-0.068115823,
-0.7346726656,
-0.9377585649,
0.3434653878,
0.2743723392,
-0.6658673882,
-0.445879966,
0.2510705292,
0.6720997095,
-0.3898079097,
0.0951252058,
0.3377916515,
0.3963069916,
-0.1733039916,
-1.058929801,
-0.131184116,
-0.0239386875,
0.2043045014,
0.5221375227,
-0.2359647155,
0.8740989566,
-0.0359740369,
-0.1724808365,
0.0227590054,
0.5924060941,
0.0709002092,
0.1355842799,
0.0775041655,
0.2541209757,
0.6071489453,
-0.0129503794,
1.1423654556,
-0.4693272412,
0.1562785655,
1.1268539429,
-0.2288541198,
0.8794836998,
0.129396528,
-0.3511047065,
0.4949461818,
0.2405496091,
0.0836686566,
-0.1286025196,
0.444660604,
-0.2565844059,
-0.132126376,
-0.1551484764,
-0.4818692803,
0.5914763212,
0.6073598266,
-0.6638886333,
-0.1372200549,
-0.0411116555,
0.1313194185,
0.2509185672,
-0.4220698178,
0.6551864743,
0.2239957005,
-0.3795235455,
0.0919602141,
0.2373529673,
0.2921299338,
-0.7419999838,
-0.3254645169,
0.282666415,
0.1232828125,
-0.2423940599,
-0.8015871644,
0.3462393582,
-0.3083136678,
-0.134771347,
0.0735792592,
0.5281306505,
-0.3898674846,
-0.7373863459,
0.1597409993,
0.1887835562,
0.1217524484,
0.1008723602,
-0.6473275423,
0.0319982767,
-0.4627334774,
-0.2324196845,
0.1033105552,
0.4883670509,
-0.103357397,
0.7711628079,
0.5646665692,
0.1905194223,
0.2534311116,
0.1958217919,
0.5742955208,
-0.913318038,
-0.4055318534,
-0.8383786082,
0.4564937055,
-0.0712430477,
-0.1009168103,
0.8375141025,
0.3814399838,
0.49746117,
0.0391751826,
0.6217035651,
-0.1701633632,
0.3585154116,
-0.5727001429,
0.7084780335,
-0.1458675265,
0.2849665582,
-0.5695168376,
-1.1738197803,
-0.5949190259,
0.6836423278,
-0.3535862565,
0.1269986033,
0.6206956506,
0.2632181644,
0.1063531265,
0.2136842608,
0.385310024,
0.3395011723,
0.5635501742,
0.2008795887,
0.9905452132,
-0.2894739211,
-0.1722459197,
-0.4619193971,
-0.2004243135,
-0.2514292002,
-1.0003458261,
-0.8631100059,
-0.7676587105,
-0.4586755037,
-0.192204684,
-0.1042161882,
0.8566464782,
0.7242622375,
-0.8231642842,
-0.5277449489,
-0.2344805151,
0.2264508456,
-0.0651473254,
-0.2901547849,
0.205077365,
-0.3414458632,
-0.7077587247,
0.012288128,
0.4941257834,
0.275280416,
-0.6496854424,
0.273599565,
-0.6185596585,
0.2320943028,
0.8363758326,
0.6304373145,
-0.700722158,
-0.1635922045,
-0.2161974311,
-0.163341552,
-0.1416881233,
1.00839746,
-0.3199872673,
0.2596322298,
0.5798818469,
0.6168891191,
0.1505687088,
-0.3199359477,
0.9822743535,
-0.4017384648,
0.4639881253,
0.2836056352,
0.4730707109,
0.3369983435,
-0.1738491952,
0.4401527941,
0.2536642253,
-0.707487464,
-1.0635836124,
0.406170845,
-0.7425633073,
-0.2385988832,
0.9305617213,
0.0626036003,
-0.3969033659,
-0.4001788497,
-0.053924609,
-0.0190022793,
-0.0251409542,
0.7604281306,
0.9317652583,
0.0428079851,
-0.195811972,
-0.9905555844,
0.4667336047,
-0.0578110591,
-0.8876699209,
0.1090948731,
0.3935321271,
0.0561349615,
0.4982327521,
0.3091900051,
-0.2846879661,
0.1748830229,
-0.0046897489,
0.036055021,
0.2547881007,
-0.5799027681,
-0.2547620237,
0.1506286412,
0.4924398661,
0.3458472788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04936v1
|
A comparative analysis between Conformer-Transducer, Whisper, and wav2vec2 for improving the child speech recognition
| 2023-11-07T19:32:48 | 2023-11-07T19:32:48 |
Andrei Barcovschi, Rishabh Jain, Peter Corcoran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems have progressed significantly in
their performance on adult speech data; however, transcribing child speech
remains challenging due to the acoustic differences in the characteristics of
child and adult voices. This work aims to explore the potential of adapting
state-of-the-art Conformer-transducer models to child speech to improve child
speech recognition performance. Furthermore, the results are compared with
those of self-supervised wav2vec2 models and semi-supervised multi-domain
Whisper models that were previously finetuned on the same data. We demonstrate
that finetuning Conformer-transducer models on child speech yields significant
improvements in ASR performance on child speech, compared to the non-finetuned
models. We also show Whisper and wav2vec2 adaptation on different child speech
datasets. Our detailed comparative analysis shows that wav2vec2 provides the
most consistent performance improvements among the three methods studied.
|
[
0.0296271387,
0.086985521,
-0.0033923853,
0.0034957388,
-0.0635366365,
0.1290311962,
-0.2088197321,
-0.8028416038,
-0.8402791619,
0.1900721043,
-0.4315483272,
0.0478921011,
-0.8669956326,
-0.1239696369,
-0.4171820283,
0.3166691065,
0.010342259,
0.2441506684,
-0.0092206951,
0.026769869,
-0.4701364338,
-0.3651191592,
-0.9593862295,
-0.2722730637,
0.0366753004,
0.2732229531,
0.1560555696,
0.5760907531,
0.2797608674,
0.3087815344,
-0.2852446437,
-0.1299148202,
-0.4200853109,
0.2790937722,
-0.2138217539,
-0.14733091,
-0.4622829854,
-0.114144206,
0.815629065,
0.429894805,
-0.2192245424,
-0.0423224233,
0.4936628938,
0.6774453521,
-0.5229358077,
0.4466746151,
-0.6333460808,
-0.305691421,
-0.1299231499,
0.1885451227,
-0.3383315802,
-0.2035195231,
0.6671682,
-0.6111284494,
0.609424293,
-0.3548120856,
0.3512683809,
0.3475291133,
-0.3086604178,
-0.6499608159,
-1.1770995855,
0.7411315441,
-0.7380697727,
1.0382184982,
0.1384312958,
0.3729173243,
0.0635505319,
-0.8530178666,
-0.4139352441,
0.0340846181,
-0.0041767554,
0.2178885639,
-0.5976085067,
-0.1312602162,
-0.0230102874,
0.0247387383,
-0.5207641125,
0.1852035224,
-0.902284205,
-0.4317106903,
0.6309267879,
0.0064963135,
-0.1158466935,
0.3350092769,
-0.1960971355,
-0.4149494171,
-0.3845770955,
0.5993636847,
-0.0161623508,
0.5981158614,
-0.2730931342,
0.0087271743,
-0.0822511315,
0.716604352,
0.3432968557,
-0.5698773861,
0.1594465822,
-0.1335805058,
0.2052219957,
0.4272007346,
0.3694161177,
0.3374169469,
0.5531760454,
-0.071290493,
-0.2101937532,
0.2262887508,
0.1441563517,
-0.8158326745,
-0.3919163942,
-0.1634917855,
-0.6671633124,
0.1336599588,
0.3157803714,
-0.4130248427,
-0.2549941838,
-0.5923514962,
0.4189627469,
-0.4313509762,
-0.3680154383,
0.1398584545,
-0.421299994,
0.5098694563,
0.3889581263,
-0.867636025,
0.7344680429,
0.8326420188,
0.7061924934,
-0.4416385889,
0.1280072629,
-0.4601283669,
0.4450946748,
-0.0458186381,
1.1107274294,
-0.6741210818,
-0.8361765146,
-0.190070048,
0.0489534587,
-0.3642058074,
-1.0223897696,
0.5984975696,
-0.2339346707,
-0.1493706107,
-0.0035688528,
-0.4577471018,
-0.1581194997,
-0.4004352093,
-0.5257467031,
0.7253261805,
0.1881824434,
-0.1913961619,
0.4323174655,
-0.3803821802,
-0.7326257825,
-0.1095832884,
0.3549703062,
-0.5907889605,
0.1129998267,
0.2926591039,
0.210045442,
-0.0098237637,
-0.4065709114,
0.24034217,
-0.4298240244,
0.2834700048,
-0.5021421909,
0.5530847907,
0.2352133542,
-0.0474665947,
-0.0764349177,
-0.7348703146,
0.0907629877,
-0.2158599794,
-0.4531138837,
-0.0450365432,
0.2180360258,
0.2103184164,
0.157925114,
-0.1574364603,
-0.6789712906,
-0.2348081768,
-0.4588522315,
0.8381732702,
0.3419554532,
0.021904273,
0.3085812628,
-0.5342416167,
0.167642355,
0.0476236865,
0.4546286464,
0.1136979237,
-0.5072168112,
-0.8042400479,
-0.3826146722,
0.5053316951,
0.3505224288,
-0.2256395668,
0.1690777242,
-0.2382715493,
-0.4684544802,
-0.8400627375,
-0.2883614302,
0.6030750275,
0.5426230431,
0.5718631148,
-0.3151134551,
-0.7511732578,
-0.5281962156,
-0.3404248059,
-0.5164399147,
-0.1931190938,
0.4305898845,
-0.1038362831,
0.0004350461,
0.5580781102,
-0.085352242,
-0.3981275856,
0.0307736043,
-0.1956503689,
-0.0900504887,
0.6132557988,
0.3051519394,
-0.7580673695,
-0.6622911692,
-0.1345921904,
0.0868072361,
-0.1062166542,
0.2215803862,
0.5816490054,
0.2628671229,
0.2555075884,
0.0122842938,
0.6250700951,
0.6469048262,
-0.2521383762,
0.2130119056,
0.0347645469,
0.1404693723,
-0.285877347,
-0.2881070673,
-0.1225574613,
-0.5316151381,
-1.0756179094,
-0.4050657749,
0.1936101317,
0.0490814224,
-0.6879132986,
0.092913121,
-0.4937241375,
-0.1377668381,
-0.2701290548,
0.0354444049,
-0.1570304632,
-0.2143698782,
0.291939348,
1.1978263855,
0.7797771692,
-0.7058361769,
0.3425876796,
0.3940244615,
0.0901037604,
0.3976644576,
-0.9626578093,
0.56999892,
0.1071267352,
0.2939943373,
-1.0301177502,
0.1437966824,
-0.0943179131,
-0.8468001485,
0.8294264078,
-0.2986892164,
-0.1220417172,
-0.4869350493,
-0.4271818697,
0.1922589839,
0.9065139294,
-0.7253892422,
0.5802583694,
0.3911150992,
-0.4229052067,
0.0779055953,
-0.5441647172,
-0.0709762946,
0.1356385946,
-0.5486760736,
0.5329377055,
0.1341599971,
0.1139865294,
-0.1771739721,
-0.5160898566,
0.0016709826,
-0.2210018933,
0.2856792212,
0.2135397047,
-0.4777441323,
-0.1751044989,
0.1525475532,
-0.5597709417,
-0.0607691444,
-0.3733510971,
0.248982206,
-0.1837967187,
0.0700460002,
-0.868142128,
-0.0124591952,
0.2238805443,
0.0324006304,
0.2511691153,
0.3299458921,
-0.3821623325,
-0.275534153,
-0.5515549779,
-0.210597381,
-0.4546899498,
-0.117871426,
-0.6037253141,
-0.7467672825,
0.0484900996,
-0.212979123,
-0.1735431552,
0.4767815173,
0.6012943983,
-0.4049951136,
0.6923059225,
0.3949995637,
0.0543142222,
0.3157790601,
-0.3417378068,
-0.1404954344,
-1.320140481,
-0.5026904941,
-0.7719396949,
-0.0792837217,
-0.4686602652,
-0.4478833973,
0.2523021996,
-0.1955672204,
-0.0075854883,
0.4766204953,
-0.9283466339,
-0.0388368145,
0.3994859755,
0.002451956,
0.3669168651,
-0.1235811561,
0.2778501809,
-0.1887823492,
-0.6220078468,
-0.5899270773,
0.9753762484,
0.3137693405,
0.831992507,
0.3201419115,
0.1333400011,
0.3807345033,
0.1302827001,
-0.8351746202,
0.2128666639,
-0.724543035,
-0.6219997406,
-0.3102143705,
0.0038934078,
-0.8741021156,
0.2534173131,
-0.1420116425,
-0.7567561865,
0.7712951899,
0.1913876683,
-0.3507045209,
-0.0314899087,
-0.7473278642,
0.1179944053,
0.1464554071,
-0.0150728095,
-0.0831266195,
-0.5189757943,
-0.1592006534,
-0.1950596124,
-0.0456519239,
0.2609342933,
-0.2517119348,
0.8948774934,
-0.4225839972,
0.6113846302,
-0.5101832151,
-0.1068187132,
0.6621944308,
-0.1807779223,
0.390326798,
-0.2928599715,
-0.3252387941,
0.2014291734,
0.3515289724,
-0.0224337298,
-0.4039311111,
0.723644495,
-1.0373547077,
-0.4503184557,
-0.3048133254,
-0.3260086179,
-0.46179986,
-0.1738643795,
0.1535852998,
0.6608954668,
-0.0151450634,
0.3871855438,
0.5739521384,
0.2819448411,
0.5263952017,
0.7633684874,
0.334215641,
-0.3930058479,
0.8596875072,
0.4703443646,
0.3829224408,
0.055660408,
0.3093210161,
-0.6064404249,
-0.7249629498,
-0.3354251087,
0.2591525316,
-0.3456056118,
-0.1152650043,
-0.6313575506,
-0.609208703,
-0.8204036951,
-0.1810814589,
-0.3289295733,
-0.7167102098,
-0.3658916652,
0.1364941448,
0.482485652,
0.7279843092,
-0.3024623692,
0.3985686302,
-0.4908068776,
0.5400474072,
0.6327652931,
0.1591107249,
0.1533617824,
-1.1949962378,
0.1536467075,
-0.0245123468,
-0.3412635028,
-0.4724643528,
-0.0263942853,
0.7307171226,
0.3237981498,
0.1217299029,
0.025519494,
0.8805688024,
-0.6270281076,
0.6708158851,
0.0704458058,
-1.1184073687,
0.5711311698,
-0.0867387354,
0.0391572081,
0.3192005157,
-0.3052215278,
-0.3992831409,
-0.1204817221,
-0.4551419318,
-0.4564123154,
0.9375058413,
0.363422066,
0.0128916465,
0.8636101484,
0.5245904326,
0.3567079008,
-0.1557235718,
0.0227132794,
-0.1861266345,
-0.5506851077,
-0.4005220532,
0.0307760108,
-0.1758508831,
0.2476962805,
-0.7022176385,
0.7288681269,
0.1070817783,
0.3403146267,
0.3121645153,
-0.0682136416,
-0.3455640376,
0.1993222684,
0.3655596375,
0.3729221523,
-0.0193713494,
0.0447108708,
0.468903482,
-0.9134508371,
0.3693316579,
0.3710575998,
-0.3169882894,
-0.0214107856,
0.902971983,
0.695314765,
-0.0237244312,
-0.220690012,
0.5882087946,
-0.1803044528,
-0.3891132176,
-0.3844346404,
0.6615146995,
0.2574258149,
0.499714762,
0.4797230661,
-0.0437935069,
0.5018390417,
-0.4602640867,
0.2128955424,
0.2198365331,
-0.7667252421,
-0.4223833978,
0.8027875423,
0.2083617151,
-0.8980526328,
0.4081539512,
0.5141906738,
-0.4810152948,
0.4348703325,
1.0844087601,
0.795149982,
-0.8928055167,
-0.1354411095,
0.2420354486,
0.199520871,
0.2465274483,
0.3025537133,
-0.2829094231,
-0.4215113521,
-0.0607194901,
-0.1230503023,
-0.4349348843,
0.0493231118,
-0.9161521792,
0.1471391767,
-0.2950124145,
-0.2030813396,
0.3375774324,
-0.092037566,
-0.5750101805,
0.5175113082,
0.4166146517,
0.64925915,
-0.4051030278,
0.9291914701,
0.6192135215,
0.2811454535,
-0.6989967227,
0.3459289074,
0.1038386896,
-0.5769295096,
0.242569074,
0.1812338233,
-0.8097385168,
0.2959640622,
-0.254265666,
-0.7894315124,
1.2103987932,
-0.1504546851,
-1.0899608135,
0.2502007782,
0.3082204461,
0.6582467556,
-0.3093833625,
-0.1027987003,
0.8827459216,
0.5218240619,
0.2207154632,
-1.2235888243,
-0.1527739763,
0.0988494009,
0.4584109187,
-0.1029919535,
-0.7528225183,
0.3316434324,
-0.3473279476,
-0.2911404669,
0.1586934924,
0.7595689297,
0.2687117457,
0.5351800919,
0.857407093,
-0.1193973348,
0.466498822,
-0.1785799563,
0.4668825567,
-0.0594409443,
0.2484145463,
0.8869526982,
-0.2986742854,
0.9863985181,
0.2220618129,
-0.6358953118,
0.3638564944,
0.2455911785,
0.054253906,
0.7706028819,
-0.042925965,
-0.2951783538,
0.067788966,
0.1113986,
-0.2448894233,
0.423194319,
0.600757122,
-0.0694206432,
0.0734158605,
0.1419334412,
-0.1941665709,
0.2493020445,
-0.2950894535,
1.3197848797,
0.2897756696,
-0.1831490099,
0.839202702,
-0.0717579275,
0.6215421557,
-0.2039182186,
0.0194492768,
0.3284395337,
0.4910578132,
-0.2955696583,
-0.6123612523,
0.3254901767,
0.3954295218,
-0.3083500564,
-0.0480405241,
1.0931739807,
-0.2798991203,
-0.4996275604,
0.3995783031,
0.0939370915,
0.0555905364,
0.1803825498,
-0.6862617731,
0.193391785,
-0.1344256401,
-0.0699820518,
-0.1900366545,
0.0645681024,
0.0900362432,
0.4672337174,
0.7294971943,
0.2269277424,
0.2657386959,
0.3301941156,
0.9073304534,
-0.3741922677,
-0.2888913155,
-0.4346981347,
0.5981690884,
0.2495791167,
-0.0923995748,
0.3901242316,
0.6917392015,
0.657546699,
-0.057259649,
0.7397652268,
0.1288966388,
1.3645923138,
-0.3486071229,
0.5108540058,
-0.1564526409,
0.0230292603,
-0.1275452673,
-0.764852345,
-0.2779693902,
0.8881446719,
-0.0296058748,
0.1079611555,
0.3392026126,
0.8089465499,
-0.221682936,
0.1973382086,
0.1947960109,
0.4002943635,
0.4717965722,
0.4818798006,
0.962262392,
-0.7900223732,
0.517678678,
-0.218199864,
-0.3357723057,
-0.1954402626,
-0.2429936081,
-0.6902860403,
-0.6891685128,
-0.3862999678,
-0.2031810284,
0.6325534582,
0.519352138,
1.0686836243,
-1.2003536224,
-0.0843916759,
0.2235094607,
-0.46177423,
-0.4605445266,
-0.1483748406,
0.2552776635,
0.2310355008,
-0.7717657685,
0.7109605074,
0.1094853953,
0.2489228249,
0.1200883836,
-0.249917537,
0.4363152087,
0.3840665221,
0.4567218721,
0.173111558,
-0.8354430199,
-0.566734612,
-0.2509836555,
0.0520380996,
0.2310959548,
0.7729821205,
-1.0403403044,
0.5686452389,
0.202626884,
0.0743047446,
0.9519094229,
0.3826013505,
0.3305039406,
-0.3146961927,
0.0924556479,
0.2584063113,
-0.0871184543,
0.5380945206,
-0.1905963123,
0.3624678254,
0.0518040396,
-0.349452585,
-0.573900342,
0.0892001018,
-1.0286390781,
-0.0162168033,
1.1781651974,
-0.1031996012,
0.0397399962,
-0.5977202654,
-0.3684604466,
0.4562242925,
-0.7427841425,
0.3571746051,
0.2020645589,
-0.2306359559,
-0.1744526476,
-0.1944762468,
0.4317060113,
-0.2353182584,
-0.2787595987,
0.1310114563,
0.2341592908,
0.7251418233,
-0.1326650083,
0.2553654909,
-0.3120648265,
0.3851184547,
0.0744407475,
-0.2003871799,
-0.2309288234,
-0.3587183356,
-0.8108068705,
-0.0630381182,
0.1919542402,
-0.4212004244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04292v1
|
Aspect-based Meeting Transcript Summarization: A Two-Stage Approach with Weak Supervision on Sentence Classification
| 2023-11-07T19:06:31 | 2023-11-07T19:06:31 |
Zhongfen Deng, Seunghyun Yoon, Trung Bui, Franck Dernoncourt, Quan Hung Tran, Shuaiqi Liu, Wenting Zhao, Tao Zhang, Yibo Wang, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-based meeting transcript summarization aims to produce multiple
summaries, each focusing on one aspect of content in a meeting transcript. It
is challenging as sentences related to different aspects can mingle together,
and those relevant to a specific aspect can be scattered throughout the long
transcript of a meeting. The traditional summarization methods produce one
summary mixing information of all aspects, which cannot deal with the above
challenges of aspect-based meeting transcript summarization. In this paper, we
propose a two-stage method for aspect-based meeting transcript summarization.
To select the input content related to specific aspects, we train a sentence
classifier on a dataset constructed from the AMI corpus with pseudo-labeling.
Then we merge the sentences selected for a specific aspect as the input for the
summarizer to produce the aspect-based summary. Experimental results on the AMI
corpus outperform many strong baselines, which verifies the effectiveness of
our proposed method.
|
[
-0.3855316341,
-0.7694228888,
0.7123688459,
0.1804873794,
-0.3188040257,
0.0244834516,
0.0743182227,
-0.5933815837,
0.5666453838,
0.5098158121,
-0.6106464863,
-0.5099854469,
-0.492913425,
-0.0087770633,
-0.5097519755,
1.5628092289,
-0.2208455056,
0.0696003884,
-0.3931853175,
-0.2046345621,
-0.2257549465,
-0.8051710129,
-0.4296603799,
-0.3095649779,
0.1720902622,
0.8012378812,
0.3525775969,
0.3726598024,
0.6955291033,
0.2474287152,
-0.5927968025,
0.3007931411,
-0.0883538947,
0.1544809192,
-0.0116826277,
-0.5489546061,
-0.9720532298,
0.2542580366,
0.6883397102,
1.0712757111,
0.0607518628,
0.1251340508,
0.3315038681,
0.4404138029,
-0.108733587,
0.2570610344,
-0.3098912537,
0.1523482203,
-0.1406789571,
-0.0193218645,
-0.0581914037,
-0.0137341693,
0.1393498033,
-0.2310497165,
0.4861901402,
0.2360226661,
0.6916108727,
-0.2319074422,
-0.4753932357,
-0.0568966493,
-0.7572507858,
0.6666660309,
-0.7201339602,
0.1352891326,
0.7356052399,
-0.1234081089,
0.0308685172,
-0.7766335011,
-0.5240305662,
0.0541407056,
-0.2825870216,
0.2196883112,
0.2084077746,
0.4187377393,
0.0198534466,
0.7766539454,
-0.3167311847,
0.1403918713,
-0.482943207,
-0.2746430635,
0.3783951998,
0.1795021147,
0.1702984273,
-0.6001439691,
-0.1524380744,
0.0495192371,
-0.538682282,
0.006043829,
0.0808080137,
0.5726389885,
-0.0745675191,
0.7895516753,
-0.5378859639,
0.0053507965,
0.1952067465,
-0.2626221478,
0.0985870659,
-0.8291931152,
0.1314840168,
0.2049900293,
0.7625538111,
0.8017287254,
-0.7144175768,
-0.2856286466,
-0.338719368,
-0.2967012525,
0.181768015,
-0.7939618826,
-0.1731101871,
0.6226716638,
-0.7597171068,
-0.2389712036,
0.061153315,
-0.9730037451,
-0.1677006483,
-0.3888113201,
0.4634723663,
-0.2679621875,
-0.0734172314,
-0.8327421546,
-0.1273883134,
0.0249286294,
0.4147870541,
-0.6653948426,
0.2987940311,
0.8593853116,
1.3114241362,
-0.0113291563,
-0.5143038034,
-0.8079523444,
-0.0994535163,
-0.0090682982,
0.7577493787,
-0.1235855743,
-0.5419469476,
-0.037995901,
-0.239874348,
0.2712347209,
-0.3562267721,
0.4403425157,
-0.0198065899,
0.6491702795,
-0.1437030435,
-0.5470470786,
-0.232426241,
0.3105398715,
-0.2421380281,
0.9161215425,
0.3721937835,
-0.6929172277,
0.4652532339,
-0.4917903841,
-0.7379543185,
-0.1041624919,
-0.2992344797,
-0.7813948989,
0.2412825525,
0.4005124867,
0.4629894197,
0.3555303514,
0.097687684,
-0.1849339157,
-0.1609844118,
0.1553241313,
0.1332572103,
0.2459992766,
0.0265771449,
-0.1836810112,
0.4988281727,
-0.7012251019,
-0.1454519778,
-0.3629429936,
-0.2279152274,
-0.287170738,
0.2631527185,
0.1771119982,
0.3869564533,
0.3798126578,
-0.2991433442,
0.2396464497,
-0.4710956812,
0.3022390008,
0.2730686963,
0.4444790184,
0.7379270196,
-0.5159410238,
0.3267282844,
0.410536617,
0.396481514,
-0.3710631132,
-0.4340614974,
-1.0438063145,
-0.0746806413,
0.0340096056,
0.5863213539,
-0.9751704931,
0.7982155085,
0.0466613322,
-0.541924715,
-0.5844368339,
0.213434726,
0.7178285122,
0.4462581277,
0.7065525055,
-0.5095805526,
-0.4505390823,
-0.9092929959,
-0.0889404416,
-0.6635609269,
-0.1192759499,
0.0788898841,
0.4997296035,
0.3553114533,
0.7526859641,
-0.2762721181,
-0.7672423124,
-0.9688057899,
0.7243695259,
0.1348875612,
0.5738027096,
0.421793282,
-0.7250705957,
0.0391403139,
-0.1257831603,
-0.589461267,
-0.0219907146,
-0.3550372124,
-0.1522711664,
0.0163443983,
0.5473688245,
-0.0905743539,
0.5340339541,
0.3101087213,
-0.4688071907,
0.3899731636,
-0.0712676123,
0.4841503501,
-1.4176337719,
-0.3532085419,
-0.113251701,
-0.5348213315,
-0.6998137832,
0.0499184094,
0.0897354111,
-0.158722207,
-0.5330426097,
-0.1183036789,
-0.3632640839,
0.034064088,
-0.7033608556,
0.1999922395,
0.1183556616,
0.7896231413,
0.1929085702,
0.5224938393,
0.5352279544,
-0.6701009274,
0.0884638131,
0.6772542596,
-0.02083846,
0.693138361,
-0.4230762124,
0.2328733057,
-0.1976035833,
0.5247790813,
-0.7248698473,
-0.3210286796,
0.2852761745,
-0.24075903,
0.3054856062,
-0.332585901,
-0.2340905666,
-0.2270469368,
-0.7289739251,
0.3172187507,
0.200796932,
-0.2412422597,
0.7561187148,
0.2739536166,
-0.6376233697,
0.0422572866,
-0.8461303115,
0.3458373547,
-0.2913701832,
-0.1822296381,
0.4100543559,
0.2084601223,
-0.2080562264,
0.0579376742,
-0.4239806533,
-0.3598130047,
-0.1828330904,
0.6211212873,
0.3457459509,
-0.0964016244,
-0.2568354309,
0.4070855677,
0.0980070755,
-0.0980195105,
-0.2180384099,
0.2243480384,
-0.0428075753,
-0.2480307072,
-0.9907687902,
1.0521732569,
0.3849453628,
-0.0445053577,
0.8617979884,
0.3420707881,
-0.3330379426,
0.1181321591,
-0.2665864527,
-0.087087743,
-0.3181785345,
0.6189495921,
-0.1085623428,
-0.8437832594,
0.6394619346,
-0.0215413459,
0.4152521193,
0.4171276987,
0.2756537497,
-0.3653677106,
0.7710309625,
0.8710311055,
-0.1504108757,
0.8411719203,
-0.1241071224,
0.2932426333,
-1.1607100964,
-0.4490607381,
-0.5882213712,
-0.4443588257,
-0.1537267119,
-0.2789310217,
0.4020223022,
0.6242064238,
0.337705195,
0.6200751662,
-0.3000590801,
0.2792424858,
0.8308512568,
0.2922576666,
0.3366920054,
-0.4153794646,
0.4189787805,
0.0297702961,
-0.4750184715,
-0.7479622364,
0.8722712994,
0.2403242588,
0.234844774,
0.2668127716,
0.9892575145,
0.0824691132,
0.2280148268,
-0.8163405657,
0.6045227051,
-0.0182260536,
-0.2758194208,
-0.3101255,
-0.762809515,
-0.2368790954,
0.3464758396,
-0.4329385757,
-0.8390012383,
0.2989339828,
0.1728708297,
-0.318982631,
0.2327836752,
-0.8691098094,
0.6454334259,
-0.0967741385,
0.169252634,
-0.1396703422,
-0.7522972822,
0.3906382322,
-0.1969125122,
0.4556887448,
-0.0388928838,
0.1864965558,
1.2581205368,
-0.7349122763,
0.7083032131,
0.0112728765,
0.3445319831,
0.4278090596,
-0.0318559147,
0.2553305626,
0.299690485,
0.1668910533,
0.2359685749,
0.0369209088,
-0.3404423594,
-0.618789196,
0.352378428,
-0.5339876413,
-0.4888782501,
-0.344900161,
-0.2986443937,
-0.3701989055,
0.1780111492,
0.5498854518,
0.7762950659,
-0.1370953023,
-0.1850134879,
0.0971664935,
-0.0513599403,
0.5243288875,
0.4124204218,
-0.5112048984,
-0.6361200809,
0.6866127253,
0.0063752327,
0.4063634872,
0.3887310922,
-0.1214561611,
0.0640590191,
-1.0744954348,
-0.0728283003,
0.018862769,
-0.4282846451,
-0.3565251231,
-0.7023721337,
-0.213674888,
-0.5840080976,
0.0105618555,
-0.4385051131,
-0.7699365616,
-0.2424514294,
-0.0790290907,
0.0842537805,
0.7159963846,
0.0632797107,
0.6973096728,
-0.8817955256,
0.5068016052,
0.0688107684,
0.2412679344,
-0.2678897679,
-0.4677556455,
-0.3051466048,
0.0325560383,
-0.6996810436,
-0.8724002242,
0.02478512,
0.4376409054,
0.2860588133,
0.5878311992,
0.2026201934,
0.6505225301,
-0.3086614013,
1.1816040277,
0.5927547216,
-1.0659611225,
1.2562992573,
-0.002510356,
0.1529140174,
0.9132772088,
-0.0309130307,
-0.4763969779,
-1.3500254154,
-0.5825148821,
-1.5371648073,
1.2579557896,
0.5997756124,
-0.0958309174,
0.0438340604,
0.4318598807,
0.1277754754,
0.2225297689,
-0.5856302977,
-0.4487088919,
-0.4715681374,
-0.1669856161,
0.0603290945,
-0.383356899,
-0.2637158632,
-0.1123524308,
0.759629786,
0.137993142,
0.1396763325,
0.5157141685,
-0.1540306211,
0.0077269021,
0.5832520127,
0.4452010393,
0.7783221602,
-0.406617552,
0.2852315009,
0.2084042728,
-0.6202959418,
-0.1582651734,
0.0906394944,
-0.1511815637,
0.0958284065,
0.8570555449,
0.8267421722,
0.1593537182,
-0.1712911278,
0.7413618565,
-0.1812896729,
-0.4711069465,
0.1243470386,
-0.0198295899,
-0.3647046089,
0.4905922115,
0.4535029829,
0.0550802015,
0.4030182064,
-0.9299429655,
0.361676544,
-0.2103634179,
-0.5065157413,
-0.4469485879,
0.9006797671,
0.4167678654,
-0.4624451995,
0.5513637066,
-0.5091388822,
-0.6798952818,
0.3317235708,
0.2230330259,
0.8654648066,
0.0367955342,
0.1180460006,
0.2545490861,
0.0625021458,
0.0073596356,
0.1685689986,
-0.1325017661,
-0.0962883234,
-0.6523909569,
-0.6247828603,
-0.7725952268,
0.0613808073,
-0.9788569212,
0.0002828836,
-0.3516110182,
-0.2009818852,
0.0695097074,
-0.1323307008,
-0.2004519552,
0.0226306468,
0.0159420613,
0.4673682153,
-0.8353413343,
0.3916868269,
1.0625663996,
-0.8584753871,
-0.6132512093,
0.3536523283,
0.0091062412,
-0.1201407611,
-0.2182563394,
0.194016099,
0.4567074478,
-0.5874562263,
-0.2487648129,
-0.334711194,
0.9078221321,
-0.2824052572,
-0.6666597724,
-0.2385805845,
-0.1975929886,
0.3663545549,
-0.1071212813,
0.0008209334,
0.379365623,
0.1664064825,
0.2278966755,
-1.2287002802,
-0.1150772721,
-0.0018226078,
-0.2073934823,
0.400306195,
-0.4996391535,
0.4952087104,
0.0459328592,
-0.1515764445,
0.096807152,
1.526070714,
-0.1498878896,
0.7199440002,
0.5696594119,
0.1681455225,
0.6114109755,
-0.1515387148,
0.5827749372,
-0.156563133,
0.4546302855,
1.5931482315,
-0.0303248968,
0.8816816807,
0.5618793368,
-0.3492797315,
0.193250671,
0.4764582813,
0.3151042461,
0.6784158349,
-0.2551569045,
-0.2632453442,
-0.0528793745,
-0.1974586993,
-0.1873612255,
0.4893655479,
0.0940899625,
-0.1785982251,
-0.3789592087,
0.1554507464,
0.0776331052,
-0.0096764201,
-0.6020182967,
1.2113114595,
0.3901568353,
-0.7255054712,
-0.4599229097,
0.0316284038,
0.5241872072,
-0.4429248869,
0.0290061682,
-0.4143130779,
-0.0542092212,
-0.442040056,
-0.9528878927,
0.61800915,
0.2672275305,
-0.2624355853,
-0.4302794933,
0.1490807235,
-0.7893654108,
-0.5113216639,
-0.2647278309,
0.437748462,
0.2554956377,
-0.2844550908,
-0.1679578871,
-0.3387254179,
-0.1948993355,
-0.1814898103,
0.5302898288,
0.5660177469,
-0.1658106893,
0.1444478482,
0.1585331857,
0.1166505218,
-0.4115960598,
0.4245552719,
0.8880725503,
-0.7549795508,
-0.976765275,
-0.622666657,
0.3996051848,
-0.0965123475,
-0.5968751907,
0.5646478534,
0.8620632291,
0.3304582536,
0.5940977931,
0.6702168584,
-0.3647220135,
0.5183535814,
-0.7414637804,
0.5235514045,
-0.5189990401,
0.2215670347,
-0.3128883243,
-0.9733096957,
-0.2606220245,
0.4374860525,
0.0360026769,
-0.0283640586,
1.1437659264,
0.3588207662,
-0.0818954855,
0.2040690482,
-0.1078834385,
0.1219173148,
0.4905659556,
0.5065805316,
0.7440873384,
-0.2547125518,
0.6513917446,
-0.5685957074,
-0.6009221673,
-0.1817329228,
-0.781671226,
-1.0201252699,
-0.9505674243,
-0.8251517415,
-0.5672933459,
-0.2309778035,
0.911221683,
0.5611943007,
-0.886156857,
0.2225345373,
-0.0335256457,
-0.0851234049,
-0.3304003179,
-0.2587759793,
0.5670807958,
-0.2915499806,
-0.6675049663,
0.4320827127,
0.4915215373,
0.1871297807,
0.0392432399,
0.413321346,
0.0251536481,
-0.1823039502,
0.5311751366,
-0.0078343693,
-0.5427642465,
-0.4040752947,
-0.6102345586,
-0.0869084373,
0.0120711988,
0.8934099674,
-0.2859733999,
0.1047517732,
0.2366434932,
0.0618870892,
0.6157802939,
0.24223198,
0.5594058633,
-1.1306490898,
0.1505987346,
0.3128247261,
0.4115867019,
0.2483181506,
-0.543158412,
0.2569426894,
-0.0050754603,
-0.4595772922,
-0.5840209723,
0.1843072027,
-1.5098291636,
-0.269184202,
1.1147022247,
-0.2371089607,
-0.0871065184,
-0.2593622208,
-0.3175625801,
0.5252889395,
-0.4490731657,
0.8639701605,
0.8210894465,
-0.5530536771,
0.1152870432,
-0.186223954,
0.4226291478,
0.2023065686,
-1.0082491636,
-0.0002628378,
0.5919321775,
-0.0934114605,
0.1785835773,
0.8192169666,
-0.0728596598,
0.1657298505,
-0.1612596512,
-0.0093998155,
-0.1951966137,
-0.3892092407,
-0.2345490754,
0.2075485885,
0.0537161678,
-0.4575427473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04284v1
|
CRAB: Assessing the Strength of Causal Relationships Between Real-world Events
| 2023-11-07T19:00:44 | 2023-11-07T19:00:44 |
Angelika Romanou, Syrielle Montariol, Debjit Paul, Leo Laugier, Karl Aberer, Antoine Bosselut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Understanding narratives requires reasoning about the cause-and-effect
relationships between events mentioned in the text. While existing foundation
models yield impressive results in many NLP tasks requiring reasoning, it is
unclear whether they understand the complexity of the underlying network of
causal relationships of events in narratives. In this work, we present CRAB, a
new Causal Reasoning Assessment Benchmark designed to evaluate causal
understanding of events in real-world narratives. CRAB contains fine-grained,
contextual causality annotations for ~2.7K pairs of real-world events that
describe various newsworthy event timelines (e.g., the acquisition of Twitter
by Elon Musk). Using CRAB, we measure the performance of several large language
models, demonstrating that most systems achieve poor performance on the task.
Motivated by classical causal principles, we also analyze the causal structures
of groups of events in CRAB, and find that models perform worse on causal
reasoning when events are derived from complex causal structures compared to
simple linear causal chains. We make our dataset and code available to the
research community.
|
[
-0.2827686965,
-0.7551603913,
0.9770999551,
0.3795630336,
-0.3857097328,
-0.0153492549,
-0.0402609408,
-0.7785875201,
0.3571842015,
0.3246512711,
-0.3862437308,
-0.201868847,
-0.7115444541,
0.0954136252,
-0.1674695462,
0.6012854576,
0.2295674682,
-0.1910300404,
-0.1169809103,
-0.3286342919,
-0.6295623183,
-0.0812952146,
-0.862618804,
-0.0148077207,
0.8495194912,
0.0825407505,
0.7051193118,
0.8790615201,
0.9245908856,
0.2427531034,
-0.177657038,
0.1851677746,
-0.4260134101,
0.1941999048,
-0.860507071,
-0.3217798769,
-0.4309929609,
0.1300530136,
0.4466921687,
0.8593090177,
0.1519200057,
0.6617087722,
-0.2588661909,
0.4500163496,
-1.0199695826,
0.3401339352,
-0.4154850841,
-0.1597531587,
-0.0754443854,
-0.1517061442,
-0.496942848,
-0.5794432759,
0.0741451681,
-0.6127271652,
0.0131394984,
0.1908519417,
0.6809083223,
0.28429389,
-0.9473295212,
-0.0709099919,
-0.6352725625,
0.6583137512,
-0.5263886452,
0.2134985626,
0.3931700885,
0.4745841324,
-0.2243285179,
-0.8831964135,
-0.7054148912,
-0.3372009099,
-0.0730419382,
0.2666190267,
-0.1209215894,
-0.0655717999,
0.3170989156,
0.1769434959,
-0.6147350073,
-0.206586957,
-0.4407435954,
0.1590244025,
0.8590146303,
0.380410552,
0.3424132764,
-0.3987269402,
-0.4911221862,
-0.3467974365,
-0.6527228951,
0.2091159672,
0.0420946106,
0.2852928042,
-0.2882035971,
0.4624091387,
-0.0859998837,
0.6804276705,
-0.1282745302,
-0.1900799125,
-0.0734724402,
-0.2105663866,
-0.3132057488,
0.2199665904,
0.4835800827,
0.7435324192,
0.058784619,
-0.1273640096,
0.2821723521,
0.4075043797,
0.4404426813,
-0.4482474625,
0.0963742509,
0.2231943756,
-0.5708622336,
-0.2951102257,
0.4535690248,
-0.4414443076,
-0.9381666183,
-0.1597632915,
0.497444123,
0.07449314,
-0.4168554544,
0.3741627932,
-0.5189366341,
0.1978047937,
0.0749607012,
-0.2699740827,
0.2345281094,
0.9691149592,
0.7168989778,
0.0324607305,
-0.3317795098,
-0.6295506954,
0.437071681,
-0.5688509941,
0.8376429081,
-0.4629224837,
0.0773778856,
-0.2216098756,
0.0270704664,
-0.2116096765,
-0.2976044118,
0.9217259884,
-0.2249788493,
-0.203078717,
-0.3646756113,
-0.55145365,
-0.6477565169,
0.1890077889,
-0.6751114726,
0.7030091882,
-0.0987091064,
-0.7906869054,
0.6677225828,
-0.2249380499,
-0.5141724348,
-0.0607392825,
-0.1737180352,
0.0324739926,
0.4657092988,
0.0223827884,
0.7897794247,
-0.8761255741,
1.0548785925,
-0.6548691392,
-0.5231921673,
0.0865352899,
-0.0511403233,
0.6992372274,
0.1085779592,
-0.5580479503,
-0.0856295228,
-0.9515330195,
-0.4526042342,
0.1564599574,
0.0741342902,
-0.6476463675,
0.4704470336,
-0.2587603033,
0.4289291501,
-0.3623995483,
-0.4955544174,
0.3824696839,
-0.2089205682,
0.2298039794,
0.6224417686,
0.4729057252,
0.090816386,
-0.4486584365,
0.363738209,
-0.0318479463,
0.1682898551,
-0.3389464915,
-0.484811306,
-0.5460951328,
-0.1144068837,
-0.3157714307,
0.4056285918,
-0.6186205149,
0.2192940414,
-0.3989969492,
-0.9928332567,
0.0360445715,
-0.4999729395,
0.5523521304,
0.6844278574,
0.421785444,
-0.3976632357,
-0.5650159121,
-0.8771223426,
-0.8995864987,
-0.6971720457,
-0.0161836464,
0.3182830215,
0.416223526,
-0.1082469746,
0.8643908501,
-0.4784132242,
0.1476544589,
-0.1353420168,
0.2714535296,
0.3567901254,
0.459803611,
0.4361201227,
-0.7342424393,
-0.0923704132,
-0.0543745644,
-0.8890528679,
-0.229402855,
-0.5542272925,
0.0183539763,
-0.3003466725,
0.6736111045,
-0.4611571729,
0.5053983331,
0.504244864,
-0.9598363638,
0.7001059055,
0.2679964006,
0.343025744,
-0.8443694711,
0.3277359903,
0.2333509922,
-0.1083986238,
-0.3997246623,
0.1874797791,
-0.0076626982,
0.1279079616,
-0.5821776986,
0.7981672883,
-0.2258152217,
-0.0665340126,
0.0362759382,
0.3709080517,
0.0146495057,
0.3843500614,
0.0097799208,
0.2630371749,
0.182376951,
-0.7774959207,
0.4836441875,
-0.0009279855,
-0.378131628,
0.7702450752,
-0.6721789837,
-0.4137592614,
-0.0214327276,
0.468250066,
-0.9779240489,
-0.2994857728,
0.1353578866,
-0.4902220368,
-0.364577204,
-0.0247219335,
-0.3501728177,
-0.3173063993,
-0.1806447059,
0.4621113539,
-0.087519668,
-0.5732185841,
0.8053774238,
0.3457994163,
0.0316513292,
-0.3740149736,
-0.5109624267,
0.283392489,
-0.4050991833,
-0.8058789372,
-0.051737655,
0.2620971203,
-0.7360284925,
-0.067880325,
-0.3610025346,
-0.291259706,
0.2956221104,
0.5818516016,
-0.1404437423,
-0.464063108,
0.3607708812,
0.1722492576,
-0.4244358838,
0.4270884395,
-0.177393958,
0.0544380359,
0.0097576044,
-0.3057010472,
-0.4384316802,
-0.127318427,
0.7831238508,
0.0326484703,
0.9187662005,
0.4753984213,
-0.4198386371,
0.1478211135,
-0.8183782697,
-0.1388406307,
-0.3520725965,
0.2037110329,
-0.4034075141,
-0.7123495936,
0.4226433635,
-0.3391826153,
-0.0056591178,
0.7509368658,
0.1713138968,
0.1343796849,
0.8412870765,
0.3148700893,
-0.0716702491,
-0.0784229636,
0.2400352508,
0.2449120879,
-0.6626525521,
-0.1684189886,
-0.3798331618,
-0.2008674145,
-0.5022844672,
-0.3170956373,
0.0597115532,
0.2391130477,
-0.6797450781,
0.6568126678,
-0.2284092456,
0.5208750367,
0.4199851155,
0.0387596674,
0.6539623737,
-0.4810070992,
0.0492719822,
0.0447284766,
-0.4869146347,
-0.7028163671,
0.7182577848,
0.1318801045,
0.4247722328,
0.2716869116,
0.1480119824,
0.4024640322,
0.1435282826,
-0.040603634,
0.4991277158,
0.109797664,
-0.7007651925,
0.0077940715,
-0.5160970688,
-0.8891014457,
0.3783826828,
-0.5078570843,
-0.8332163692,
0.4425038099,
0.0045518144,
-0.3929804564,
0.2914144993,
-0.7410735488,
0.8916834593,
-0.0863630101,
-0.636290431,
-0.3801454306,
-0.8745853901,
0.6623305082,
0.0689561591,
0.369720459,
-0.3557778001,
-0.0570501462,
0.6848211884,
-0.0420095101,
0.856785655,
-0.0927681476,
0.1829226911,
0.3595890105,
0.4893634617,
0.464463532,
0.4949863851,
-0.1150859371,
0.0033584912,
0.1992126703,
-0.5005583167,
-0.6118724942,
0.3865532577,
-0.3407143652,
-0.3529567719,
-0.465845108,
-0.1637399048,
-0.2462745756,
-0.0535967052,
-0.0938175768,
0.3978745639,
-0.2622947395,
0.266199261,
0.053948842,
-0.2814133167,
0.346290499,
0.4785384238,
-0.0514798127,
-0.1916268468,
0.7376603484,
-0.2416604757,
0.1223689616,
0.2808270752,
0.3557264507,
0.0313856266,
0.0028754582,
-0.2367307693,
0.3024506569,
-0.4338821471,
-0.2669914961,
-0.6313843131,
0.2652047575,
-0.1044398993,
-0.5345929265,
-0.4809758961,
-0.5941839218,
0.2700924277,
-0.4000013471,
0.0976561904,
0.883344233,
-0.2188433409,
0.2935917079,
-0.8604028821,
0.3644747734,
0.1381698847,
0.2708192468,
0.3370458186,
-0.2010595948,
-0.3370522261,
-0.2052407712,
-0.189080283,
-0.897469759,
0.1443678141,
-0.0940637514,
0.3388538063,
0.7444734573,
0.2333209664,
0.8737065792,
-0.1663154066,
0.7918740511,
0.2249274105,
-0.9706420898,
0.5947306752,
-0.7010058165,
0.2205324322,
0.5139940977,
0.5050711036,
-0.8051260114,
-0.5708656311,
-0.9111768007,
-0.8316171169,
0.5113037229,
0.1357459575,
-0.3004213274,
-0.3000870645,
0.6585049629,
-0.1116170958,
0.0261212569,
-0.8205664754,
-0.1049878299,
0.4084896147,
0.0672546104,
-0.3234649599,
-0.4431626201,
0.2291683555,
-0.2694849372,
0.4661981165,
0.1902853549,
-0.2304075211,
0.2779446542,
-0.2995367348,
-0.1074911952,
-0.2224880308,
0.5078968406,
0.911613524,
-0.3041017652,
0.5059279799,
0.1126012355,
-0.6025620103,
0.1024169326,
-0.124999404,
0.3547985852,
-0.3712599576,
1.1757229567,
0.4693188965,
0.5255596042,
-0.9283765554,
0.5769133568,
-0.2244231403,
0.2528187037,
0.0485155284,
0.1176811457,
0.0870953202,
0.5769045353,
0.4831913412,
-0.0738064349,
0.1926813871,
-0.4986490905,
0.170423612,
-0.2542662621,
-0.5177229643,
-0.3803471625,
0.5695755482,
0.2903405726,
0.1167799085,
0.542239666,
-0.1552942544,
-0.3307469785,
0.9136884212,
0.41952461,
0.7199700475,
-0.1832720339,
0.17111063,
0.9369434118,
0.7944554687,
-0.0945877656,
0.0053350748,
0.1426314265,
-0.4332410097,
-0.5596646667,
-0.3994543552,
-0.4479960203,
-0.2213458121,
-0.7343316674,
0.2077661753,
-0.311825484,
-0.1206838638,
-0.064876467,
0.0146282567,
-0.3346578181,
0.4274237454,
-0.2899911404,
0.7563754916,
-1.3528081179,
0.1606185138,
0.5385023355,
-0.7671579123,
-0.7824804187,
-0.1502895057,
0.2327894717,
-0.3884225786,
0.6652165055,
0.3193001747,
0.0165223572,
-0.3017208278,
-0.400223881,
-0.7714813948,
1.0162111521,
0.3837981522,
-0.4572612643,
0.3123041689,
0.0200363453,
0.4859631062,
-0.276322037,
0.3533763885,
0.5098275542,
0.6390392184,
-0.2615813613,
-0.6728393435,
0.3951154947,
-0.1765981019,
-0.1148629859,
0.1817156225,
-0.4499925375,
0.7401490211,
-0.1569792926,
-0.3276935518,
-0.2436845303,
0.6243162751,
0.4329712987,
0.8157400489,
0.5193282366,
0.4614336789,
0.6655228734,
-0.0809370577,
1.2633903027,
-0.1543309838,
0.2551256418,
1.2107044458,
-0.1233352125,
0.7368326783,
0.4225251377,
-0.1523987651,
0.4893004596,
0.6865488291,
0.2052197456,
0.1153312996,
0.3314518034,
-0.0078629246,
-0.4695640504,
-0.1037418619,
-0.3249925077,
0.4869515896,
0.2394934893,
-0.1541645825,
-0.1472163647,
-0.0724917576,
0.1868035942,
0.2697954178,
-0.2007094324,
0.5080649257,
0.2000167519,
-0.6809029579,
-0.00065494,
0.012808688,
0.1813158244,
-0.4357389212,
-0.1305124909,
-0.2935386598,
0.3075127602,
-0.1316229105,
-0.5147434473,
0.7041444778,
-0.0819206461,
-0.142486766,
0.3437171578,
0.600266397,
0.1327394247,
-0.4269144535,
0.5376976132,
0.5898876786,
0.1478350759,
-0.4212541878,
-0.31035918,
0.2553355098,
-0.4832460582,
-0.3172074556,
-0.0425838828,
0.4509779513,
-0.3205037415,
0.7113827467,
0.6946181059,
-0.1049808711,
-0.0719543546,
-0.2057865113,
0.4856477082,
-0.9973049164,
-0.428243041,
-1.095618248,
0.4177418053,
-0.1256123483,
-0.5230230093,
0.8937151432,
0.5349542499,
0.5735588074,
0.1326875687,
0.2129046172,
-0.1132498309,
0.5543133616,
-0.2490011454,
0.6489002109,
-0.6836723685,
0.0988277793,
-0.5899962783,
-0.9266983867,
-0.6179583073,
0.6195222735,
-0.2323924601,
-0.190336138,
0.8845542073,
0.367567718,
-0.0336962193,
0.3401049376,
0.1316845417,
0.4211391807,
0.1982491612,
0.6050931811,
1.0802896023,
-0.276012212,
0.2252334207,
-0.0652972907,
-0.3372614086,
-0.1327197999,
-1.1872457266,
-0.873855412,
-0.8192646503,
-0.2210371792,
-0.2153611183,
0.4137593806,
0.7146568894,
0.4774185717,
-0.3957680762,
-0.3994985521,
-0.2194486707,
0.2938599288,
-0.5890346766,
-0.2037849575,
0.6814619303,
-0.1847856641,
-0.1665216088,
0.2859225273,
0.4682521224,
-0.6559640169,
0.1552251428,
0.1398812979,
-0.5260233879,
0.326027751,
0.9173707962,
0.2327608168,
-0.5832260847,
-0.4139496684,
-0.2713817656,
-0.1130758747,
-0.4278499782,
0.9282871485,
-0.8024027944,
0.5134093165,
0.5011360049,
0.6250574589,
0.3697089851,
-0.0613978505,
0.5809957981,
-0.371401459,
0.172101438,
0.038368322,
0.2916381359,
-0.1141735613,
-0.1572582424,
1.0356516838,
0.4801864326,
-0.3811809123,
-0.9402153492,
-0.0431855731,
-1.1083722115,
-0.4106318355,
0.7997400165,
-0.049384281,
-0.0797872916,
-0.2046206892,
-0.1016351134,
0.2461268008,
-0.00026101,
0.9291930795,
0.5006805062,
-0.0726155117,
0.1423344314,
-0.5615640879,
0.1069801673,
0.2231790125,
-0.7117477059,
0.088023968,
0.5718666911,
-0.3486416638,
0.1294178963,
0.5169432163,
0.1142561436,
0.53436625,
0.2485507131,
-0.0572700426,
-0.0432408936,
-0.4580995739,
-0.0350831226,
0.1140351072,
-0.2469955683,
0.2299344987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04205v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04205v2
|
Rephrase and Respond: Let Large Language Models Ask Better Questions for Themselves
| 2023-11-07T18:43:34 | 2024-04-18T23:49:56 |
Yihe Deng, Weitong Zhang, Zixiang Chen, Quanquan Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Misunderstandings arise not only in interpersonal communication but also
between humans and Large Language Models (LLMs). Such discrepancies can make
LLMs interpret seemingly unambiguous questions in unexpected ways, yielding
incorrect responses. While it is widely acknowledged that the quality of a
prompt, such as a question, significantly impacts the quality of the response
provided by LLMs, a systematic method for crafting questions that LLMs can
better comprehend is still underdeveloped. In this paper, we present a method
named `Rephrase and Respond' (RaR), which allows LLMs to rephrase and expand
questions posed by humans and provide responses in a single prompt. This
approach serves as a simple yet effective prompting method for improving
performance. We also introduce a two-step variant of RaR, where a rephrasing
LLM first rephrases the question and then passes the original and rephrased
questions together to a different responding LLM. This facilitates the
effective utilization of rephrased questions generated by one LLM with another.
Our experiments demonstrate that our methods significantly improve the
performance of different models across a wide range to tasks. We further
provide a comprehensive comparison between RaR and the popular Chain-of-Thought
(CoT) methods, both theoretically and empirically. We show that RaR is
complementary to CoT and can be combined with CoT to achieve even better
performance. Our work not only contributes to enhancing LLM performance
efficiently and effectively but also sheds light on a fair evaluation of LLM
capabilities. Data and codes are available at
https://github.com/uclaml/Rephrase-and-Respond.
|
[
-0.5008147955,
-0.8961369991,
0.5971516967,
0.2035531104,
-0.2129540145,
0.3674506247,
-0.3890653253,
-0.4950066209,
0.0465199687,
0.5333954096,
-0.6205791831,
-0.0810014904,
-0.3843563497,
0.2748536766,
-0.1010832191,
0.526194334,
-0.0800217614,
0.1572033465,
-0.4708526731,
-0.3672293127,
-0.7359156013,
-0.5514056087,
-0.8401091695,
-0.6247366071,
0.9369938374,
0.5004575849,
0.5925710797,
0.3835677803,
0.5232715607,
0.3596871197,
-0.2970523238,
0.2820943296,
-0.4508661032,
0.556505084,
-0.324695915,
-0.4355767965,
-0.2734312415,
-0.2768080831,
0.5371276736,
0.835731566,
-0.2999719977,
0.309535265,
0.1642563641,
0.7865441442,
-0.6788106561,
-0.2775342166,
-0.475019753,
-0.0939916521,
0.2110088617,
-0.284406811,
-0.6816176176,
-0.3996886313,
-0.0532197654,
-0.3854810596,
0.2378756106,
0.1900456399,
0.4482167363,
0.1980692148,
-0.0431316532,
-0.1686379462,
-0.6844975352,
0.5790984631,
-0.6886512041,
0.3463824987,
0.0508097783,
0.4393015802,
-0.2160050869,
-0.9005571604,
-0.6461437345,
-0.4441674948,
-0.2120446712,
0.002699811,
-0.2703979313,
-0.1557207406,
0.4750007093,
0.3335955143,
-0.5680589676,
0.0350826383,
-0.3566843271,
-0.1199636087,
0.5047339797,
0.4368550777,
0.3184189498,
0.1345404834,
-0.2871800959,
-0.3324170709,
-0.8265029788,
0.1327737272,
0.3684427738,
0.245838061,
0.0924645886,
0.4876392484,
-0.1431141496,
0.7726913095,
0.1584798247,
0.0839449018,
0.0356489941,
-0.2528069317,
-0.0804295614,
-0.3275367916,
0.5734744072,
0.341014415,
0.0967626274,
0.0774157718,
-0.2408482879,
-0.1909080446,
0.3537832797,
-0.7183503509,
-0.1554834694,
0.2262640893,
-0.3302949667,
0.0514043681,
-0.0921065882,
-0.8307142258,
-0.3756115735,
-0.42966488,
0.4088786542,
-0.1868139356,
-0.3005752563,
0.2540891469,
-0.2399811298,
0.3422228098,
0.5969879627,
-0.6331142187,
0.3118331134,
0.7402668595,
0.5051385164,
0.1481261253,
-0.1748557687,
-0.76794523,
-0.0829682648,
-0.420219779,
0.9543111324,
-0.6256472468,
-0.4493593276,
-0.1138659492,
-0.1545505226,
0.0225268118,
-0.7538247108,
0.3837683201,
-0.7492309213,
0.4256674051,
-0.8056650758,
-0.3846212924,
0.0018784723,
0.4246428013,
-0.7378618717,
0.8928840756,
0.0662587062,
-0.9953323603,
-0.1037760302,
-0.5714321136,
-0.2756652236,
-0.0126286503,
-0.2815530598,
-0.0407323912,
0.1576203853,
0.548576057,
0.1424891055,
-0.4996927381,
0.1326549947,
-0.1514452249,
-0.2051834911,
0.5437192321,
-0.4881438911,
0.4879603386,
0.3903096318,
0.1195282564,
0.1956102699,
-0.3984847367,
0.4026798904,
0.1054494157,
-0.4036218226,
0.0267193168,
-0.2603431344,
-0.0924270228,
0.0497558005,
0.2126521021,
-0.4629119039,
0.1879247129,
-0.5949981213,
0.4302548766,
0.7762053609,
0.0496302657,
0.3471959233,
-0.7342662215,
0.8210189939,
-0.2133329511,
0.038305521,
-0.4083772004,
-0.1913798451,
-0.5258754492,
-0.1155624166,
0.0724555477,
0.3614755273,
-0.9336653352,
0.0150686149,
-0.2548927665,
-0.4466564059,
-0.9647362232,
0.1620698571,
0.5856006145,
0.6756922603,
0.5876315236,
-0.2313451767,
-0.6737033725,
-0.7671263218,
-0.6552178264,
-0.3777540028,
-0.0691836923,
0.1895264387,
0.263792485,
0.1036105081,
1.0002233982,
-0.54103899,
0.3433494568,
-0.6334241629,
0.30228585,
-0.0549835674,
0.3628205359,
0.1332273036,
-0.581807971,
-0.4121257067,
-0.1323809773,
-0.4697157443,
-0.2398466766,
0.0284646042,
0.0296962298,
0.1754277498,
0.5454668999,
-0.4345022738,
0.236879319,
0.2315290868,
-0.0559841171,
0.598837018,
-0.4566734135,
0.3871271908,
-1.1310200691,
0.2671616077,
-0.4224445522,
-0.2985656261,
-0.5332331061,
0.4119978547,
-0.032419797,
0.0378813595,
-0.5332638621,
0.7749223709,
-0.4038356543,
-0.127515927,
-0.5748747587,
0.2951795161,
0.243486315,
0.1545297056,
-0.1568503231,
1.0146642923,
0.3324372172,
-0.5610860586,
0.5578436852,
0.3031615317,
-0.3904351592,
0.5036861897,
-1.0619363785,
0.466036886,
-0.5932992697,
0.5479989052,
-1.2717293501,
-0.2725567222,
0.3505067527,
-0.4948548377,
0.2033687979,
-0.1004015356,
-0.5240869522,
-0.5928949714,
-0.2967447937,
0.7032498717,
0.6180502772,
-0.8030751944,
0.6300501227,
0.0155706713,
-0.3458198309,
-0.7481407523,
-0.7784910798,
0.1635061651,
-0.2555060983,
-0.6889848709,
0.155387491,
-0.444157511,
-0.3914780319,
-0.1490298212,
-0.0915593877,
-0.0329192802,
-0.0531510748,
-0.0366178639,
0.1927516162,
-0.2998906672,
0.2682418823,
-0.2216409147,
-0.1642510891,
0.123128444,
0.1863132715,
0.8941498399,
-0.0644687414,
-0.4476733804,
-0.5426051617,
0.5139248967,
0.4674373567,
-0.3753953576,
0.5939724445,
0.4460372329,
-0.0140127447,
-0.0165772159,
-0.7982164025,
-0.4520642459,
-0.4973684549,
0.0052287499,
-0.4498142302,
-1.0988672972,
0.5598326325,
-0.0664136633,
0.1211991161,
0.0817731619,
0.5978247523,
-0.1501982063,
0.8917063475,
0.6283773184,
-0.0461733453,
0.1974426359,
0.0669067875,
0.3639143407,
-1.1186037064,
-0.2692827582,
-0.725691855,
-0.394187957,
-0.2550735772,
-0.6177034378,
0.0838967338,
0.015259455,
-0.186328873,
0.2265871018,
-0.4503569007,
0.6049820185,
0.1652689576,
0.0151451705,
0.3384849727,
-0.007034672,
-0.1535071135,
0.0077140769,
-0.6594846249,
-0.7679778934,
0.7025411725,
0.342300117,
1.1217393875,
0.2046952248,
0.6738605499,
0.0322534703,
0.5544928908,
-0.4940527976,
0.5727415085,
0.2608620226,
-0.4075435698,
-0.0919726565,
-0.5326464772,
-1.0157485008,
0.4785316288,
-0.0431611389,
-0.6298298836,
0.0635277927,
0.3116328418,
-0.5873010755,
0.2764381766,
-0.6294141412,
0.5645124316,
-0.0524469987,
-0.2302664071,
-0.3369640112,
-0.5745172501,
0.1667234451,
0.1109554619,
0.2106066495,
-0.0209873207,
-0.0838434696,
0.5567898154,
-0.3715961277,
0.6937149763,
0.0430426188,
-0.3056339025,
0.3680983484,
0.1072007343,
0.4996387959,
0.1235498711,
-0.2834035158,
-0.3467349708,
-0.0054602516,
-0.3135707676,
-1.0336223841,
0.6917901039,
-0.4880580306,
-0.9909003973,
-0.0654814169,
-0.6122367382,
-0.2131851017,
-0.0554711334,
0.2114815265,
0.5259230137,
-0.1137264594,
0.0555159748,
0.6240240335,
-0.4382207394,
0.4112331867,
0.6933757067,
-0.4142473638,
-0.5789484382,
0.3234781027,
-0.1316351742,
0.5052703023,
0.4003271163,
0.2373799831,
-0.5074537396,
-0.0316278264,
-0.3209365904,
0.3230167329,
-0.8896668553,
-0.2948153019,
-0.7953596711,
-0.0793869123,
-0.570069015,
-0.1489215046,
-0.200702697,
-0.3469049335,
-0.004993665,
-0.1472966522,
0.5731641054,
0.770437777,
-0.2870315611,
0.2381136566,
-0.5987727046,
0.4593892395,
0.4043467045,
0.1581395566,
0.3090813458,
-0.7785491347,
0.1828937083,
0.3157038391,
-0.2969442606,
-0.7073458433,
0.1698593944,
-0.2628265321,
0.5099873543,
-0.1357379407,
0.2658878863,
1.1337572336,
-0.6687147617,
0.6521003246,
0.2923814058,
-0.7366763353,
0.596578002,
0.102966547,
0.3141545653,
0.6681073904,
0.1613023579,
-0.7015180588,
-0.5585850477,
-0.5209435225,
-1.0443878174,
0.521150589,
-0.0244671926,
0.4445985854,
-0.2731074989,
0.4822835624,
0.0812408403,
0.1470100135,
-0.5159870386,
-0.1606094688,
0.2007426172,
-0.0705441684,
0.0212587267,
-0.3704165816,
-0.2260097265,
-0.1856882274,
0.404482156,
0.0399196558,
0.1671601534,
0.5332149267,
-0.0800689161,
-0.3387752473,
0.6098226309,
0.4972086847,
1.0444386005,
0.0985141769,
0.2617267966,
0.3705377281,
-0.0528050661,
0.3002179861,
-0.3747911453,
0.128099367,
-0.1368626505,
0.4985366166,
0.4363202453,
0.0566000454,
-0.8437175751,
0.2727611959,
-0.3039971888,
-0.1233823821,
-0.0476083308,
0.1850715876,
0.2567836642,
0.3626227379,
0.1544029117,
-0.0244583692,
-0.1991611272,
-0.6327955723,
0.2187702358,
0.2474844754,
-0.1007148474,
0.0491801575,
0.462703377,
0.1249402165,
-0.5916917324,
0.5788139105,
0.1189713329,
-0.3436855674,
0.5549668074,
0.6727254987,
0.6754879951,
-0.268150866,
0.25515306,
0.5409370661,
0.3050821424,
-0.3071388006,
0.492815733,
-0.014185789,
-0.6290218234,
-0.7019301057,
-0.3223264515,
-0.4410029948,
0.1849355251,
-0.9830746055,
-0.1221577153,
-0.6270791888,
-0.1388558149,
-0.1142278463,
0.0030621125,
-0.569116652,
-0.0144810462,
-0.1663065404,
1.1982678175,
-0.5340718031,
0.6423543692,
0.8721036911,
-0.5839303136,
-1.0253818035,
0.269705236,
-0.4132169187,
-0.7509317994,
0.5702195168,
0.2841664255,
-0.3820833266,
0.0444608033,
-0.6364181042,
-0.6157551408,
0.9512107968,
0.4790084064,
-0.6250834465,
0.2858772278,
0.0538029559,
0.7373268008,
-0.334458679,
0.4348816276,
0.4507237971,
0.5638984442,
0.3956188262,
-0.7572516799,
0.2472537607,
-0.1189315617,
0.2616357505,
0.0525594838,
-0.3758843243,
0.7349707484,
-0.5533387661,
-0.3341679871,
0.5531573892,
0.7471487522,
0.4456984699,
0.3016327024,
0.3568355441,
0.521705687,
1.0103769302,
0.0258675758,
1.0310468674,
-0.1644702405,
0.197268784,
1.355999589,
-0.4818886518,
1.0321800709,
0.5638393164,
-0.1303818077,
0.4626412094,
0.4433775246,
0.3031850755,
0.2973102033,
0.6401798725,
-0.4335392118,
-0.4296371341,
-0.0409708433,
-0.5655629039,
-0.0032883342,
0.1131484509,
0.0333326943,
-0.5422309041,
0.2052754909,
-0.0482345037,
0.7037360072,
-0.1909256876,
0.8177583814,
0.1217360646,
-0.8930136561,
0.625706315,
0.1545302719,
0.4878228903,
-0.3460062146,
-0.0274755806,
-0.5155145526,
0.0114860004,
0.0197935794,
-1.0096654892,
0.2898468673,
0.2516001761,
-0.3321304023,
-0.2881956995,
0.487501353,
-0.563742578,
-0.4146555662,
0.312338531,
0.5375041366,
0.0847003311,
0.0699489936,
-0.89670223,
0.3538834453,
-0.1553183943,
-0.0455616973,
0.1193563864,
0.4052666128,
0.0298081301,
1.1655453444,
0.6486005783,
-0.1012058854,
-0.1956462711,
0.3116578162,
1.1539342403,
-0.7477884889,
-0.2780070305,
-0.9299634695,
0.5116576552,
-0.1427705437,
0.0432481132,
0.5584313869,
0.3494562805,
0.6316217184,
0.0588754006,
0.5263534188,
-0.0411561243,
0.8188624978,
-0.4929867387,
0.4828747511,
-0.4236644804,
0.5917087793,
-0.0340135321,
-0.7492384315,
-0.1838624626,
0.7071321607,
-0.4142121077,
0.1939310431,
0.6571572423,
1.1318800449,
0.1963972151,
-0.1161991581,
0.2633297741,
0.2295430005,
0.420062542,
0.5198566318,
1.2331175804,
-0.3241919875,
0.3851168454,
0.049437657,
0.0654527396,
-0.1085999459,
-0.8342573643,
-0.7863335609,
-0.37190485,
-0.2596718967,
-0.3393583596,
0.2022630721,
1.1214692593,
0.3469850719,
-0.3733570576,
-0.2340478152,
0.0267316531,
0.4152172506,
-0.1260177493,
-0.2091586143,
0.0668726265,
-0.5740078092,
-0.4201992154,
0.4487725794,
0.108201243,
-0.0663668811,
-0.1266320348,
-0.1963356584,
-0.0115787843,
0.2823901176,
0.4882231653,
0.2964679897,
-0.847887516,
-0.3396762908,
0.0239939783,
-0.0932058617,
0.1298968196,
0.9509538412,
-0.8855279684,
0.4539089501,
0.5715530515,
0.7934770584,
-0.0104136821,
0.3419518471,
0.6745088696,
-0.8024218678,
-0.0153402919,
0.3283026218,
0.1576843262,
0.538738966,
-0.319214046,
0.1900213808,
-0.1731742024,
-0.4674462676,
-0.7678738832,
0.5566967726,
-0.8053456545,
-0.5123082995,
1.0183333158,
-0.1314438283,
-0.1609116644,
-0.1200560629,
-0.5319491625,
-0.0349672064,
-0.2006542385,
0.7301460505,
0.6812257171,
-0.0053775404,
-0.3761127293,
-0.3629243672,
0.2607373893,
0.5810592175,
-0.7815898657,
0.575609982,
0.459279269,
0.5576245189,
-0.1331657767,
0.9747525454,
-0.2157564312,
0.3579158187,
-0.4266317785,
-0.0782856569,
0.0202092025,
-0.2962659299,
-0.3401108086,
0.0918666646,
0.3308701217,
0.0793431997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04199v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04199v1
|
Exploring Recommendation Capabilities of GPT-4V(ision): A Preliminary Case Study
| 2023-11-07T18:39:10 | 2023-11-07T18:39:10 |
Peilin Zhou, Meng Cao, You-Liang Huang, Qichen Ye, Peiyan Zhang, Junling Liu, Yueqi Xie, Yining Hua, Jaeboum Kim
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have demonstrated impressive performance
across various vision and language tasks, yet their potential applications in
recommendation tasks with visual assistance remain unexplored. To bridge this
gap, we present a preliminary case study investigating the recommendation
capabilities of GPT-4V(ison), a recently released LMM by OpenAI. We construct a
series of qualitative test samples spanning multiple domains and employ these
samples to assess the quality of GPT-4V's responses within recommendation
scenarios. Evaluation results on these test samples prove that GPT-4V has
remarkable zero-shot recommendation abilities across diverse domains, thanks to
its robust visual-text comprehension capabilities and extensive general
knowledge. However, we have also identified some limitations in using GPT-4V
for recommendations, including a tendency to provide similar responses when
given similar inputs. This report concludes with an in-depth discussion of the
challenges and research opportunities associated with utilizing GPT-4V in
recommendation scenarios. Our objective is to explore the potential of
extending LMMs from vision and language tasks to recommendation tasks. We hope
to inspire further research into next-generation multimodal generative
recommendation models, which can enhance user experiences by offering greater
diversity and interactivity. All images and prompts used in this report will be
accessible at https://github.com/PALIN2018/Evaluate_GPT-4V_Rec.
|
[
-0.3884245455,
-0.461007148,
0.9410216212,
0.2357331365,
-0.5441254973,
-0.2663410306,
-0.0909783766,
-0.63276577,
-0.0039731869,
0.3908929229,
-0.6692079902,
-0.5701134801,
-0.4791689217,
0.1285107136,
-0.2260223776,
1.2773008347,
-0.2332957387,
0.0748377144,
-0.3789101243,
-0.3265548944,
-0.9156912565,
-0.3558907211,
-0.460156858,
-0.125360176,
0.5677452087,
0.5049970746,
0.3841851354,
0.3452343941,
0.7504798174,
0.2918437123,
0.3594579399,
-0.0379252695,
-0.4531535208,
0.0995359793,
0.0030098839,
-0.3049710095,
-0.4130422175,
0.1953367442,
0.6068636775,
-0.0133618591,
-0.1602669805,
0.0998085216,
0.1078072712,
0.4164279997,
-0.6229339242,
0.3883313537,
-0.3667663634,
0.0975511521,
-0.3992569149,
-0.1791425049,
-0.0951075777,
-0.0381140895,
0.6235630512,
-1.0012319088,
0.3309641182,
0.2778430879,
0.8494354486,
0.2390019894,
-0.4065333605,
-0.2237558812,
-0.9352622628,
0.6301442385,
-0.4769768715,
0.4497412741,
0.5256924033,
0.6549743414,
0.197605446,
-0.9871484041,
-0.4589604139,
-0.5526091456,
0.18941769,
0.3198390901,
-0.4485515654,
0.0797564164,
0.3499073088,
0.4879440367,
-0.6489416361,
-0.16852431,
-0.3862854838,
-0.2895693779,
0.0535705388,
-0.0833962411,
0.4089262784,
-0.0963363796,
-0.5752722025,
-0.0973105952,
-0.6084217429,
0.1055780053,
0.5471602082,
-0.0068127038,
-0.1305643469,
0.8254443407,
-0.311994344,
0.8362078667,
-0.17074956,
0.129504323,
0.2188548744,
-1.1681575775,
-0.1423829347,
-0.1595176607,
0.6749829054,
0.7704563141,
0.1786235273,
0.0191239491,
-0.0851914361,
-0.1494812369,
0.4868328273,
-0.9554427862,
-0.3203299046,
-0.2362833768,
-0.4322246611,
0.0690958723,
0.1012252122,
-0.6724560857,
-0.4504838586,
-0.1093135476,
0.650456965,
-0.7081361413,
-0.2275613099,
-0.0379529968,
-0.4420652986,
0.0927771106,
0.4543202817,
-0.8367019892,
0.1708912551,
0.2655276358,
1.0346956253,
-0.2209371924,
-0.3873856962,
-0.4205412269,
0.0328369997,
-0.0156307947,
0.9262915254,
-0.6346379519,
-0.4462052286,
-0.0367551036,
0.0312581137,
0.2681678832,
-0.4144426882,
0.6498116255,
-0.2326110452,
0.1035724059,
-0.5318159461,
-0.2601699531,
-0.5186845064,
0.6477163434,
-0.6318903565,
0.5836902261,
0.249829486,
-0.6668602228,
0.7176448107,
-0.6971888542,
-0.046882268,
0.4495860934,
-0.4104912579,
-0.3918512166,
-0.1224780604,
0.3429106474,
0.5211499333,
-0.4895396233,
-0.0131845968,
-0.5729714036,
-0.4370746017,
-0.0432172231,
-0.4758909643,
0.1460819244,
0.1284195781,
-0.3124680519,
0.5963498354,
-0.5707432032,
-0.2427193522,
0.0693966299,
0.0034981812,
-0.4524593949,
-0.3339982033,
0.102882266,
-0.0342183597,
0.2361277342,
-0.6320104003,
0.3254489303,
-0.0424843542,
0.4887163341,
0.7532798648,
0.1345088631,
0.4110358357,
-0.2772278786,
0.7908830047,
0.1988137513,
0.3511117399,
-0.3020250797,
-0.9170213342,
-0.6113345623,
-0.3210338354,
0.1252522171,
0.2337957323,
-1.3195809126,
-0.2270420045,
-0.0539505072,
-0.2658857107,
-0.4657219648,
0.1073114797,
0.3731404543,
0.2844440639,
0.275955379,
-0.3168795407,
-0.529573679,
-1.2080562115,
-0.1099057421,
-0.1903845966,
0.0419972911,
0.541882515,
0.4762766957,
-0.4347316921,
0.7187951803,
-0.2814788222,
-0.5790833235,
-0.1990083307,
-0.1245120838,
0.2772633135,
-0.0471132062,
0.7515960336,
-0.717530787,
-0.2857180536,
0.0272702314,
-0.7944175601,
0.189286992,
0.1171009615,
0.0412708372,
-0.4152106345,
0.1378450841,
-0.3109207749,
0.417817533,
0.7261840105,
-0.5387442112,
0.5393362641,
-0.6285351515,
0.5389720201,
-1.1211434603,
-0.2609323859,
0.5565362573,
-0.1998433173,
-0.4443532526,
-0.1528024673,
0.1069176495,
-0.147925362,
-0.2481589615,
0.4152728319,
-0.2504982054,
-0.1612329632,
-0.1537437141,
0.0634030551,
-0.2966435254,
0.4347952902,
-0.2252638191,
0.8888226748,
0.6587792635,
-0.3694875836,
0.652626276,
0.2585908771,
-0.5678862333,
0.8703735471,
-0.7430918813,
-0.0158257913,
0.0454492196,
0.1980458051,
-1.1324964762,
-0.1612732708,
0.4854317307,
0.0940490738,
-0.1628376395,
-0.4523692429,
-0.5235378146,
-0.2099112421,
-0.4334354997,
0.6725507975,
0.2013618201,
-0.5115922093,
0.5836821198,
0.0000439707,
-0.2439956367,
-0.5029529929,
-0.3689208925,
0.2222087085,
-0.2722941339,
-0.6139413118,
0.4743009806,
-0.4523480833,
-0.0429416969,
0.1864589304,
0.0587140061,
0.134525761,
-0.1857607961,
0.6758990884,
0.3885822892,
-0.1131292358,
-0.1012142003,
-0.1985667348,
-0.1296771169,
-0.3114029467,
-0.5885948539,
0.1262454838,
-0.6516479254,
-0.5518093705,
-0.3895300329,
0.0169849526,
0.5525867939,
-0.3083804548,
0.2143732458,
0.9356673956,
-0.0835815445,
0.0234239586,
-0.589268446,
-0.0711271614,
-0.4556957185,
0.4999075532,
-0.5273480415,
-0.9509720206,
0.1974815279,
0.1145107448,
-0.1173043475,
0.2107807249,
0.6617360115,
0.0698870122,
0.6468559504,
0.7431623936,
0.0588731021,
0.6841792464,
-0.4430956841,
0.2262994796,
-0.8708202839,
-0.3076395392,
-0.0005392891,
-0.2429550141,
-0.5299432874,
-0.4418981969,
0.7023676634,
-0.3479674757,
0.068026647,
0.1826872528,
-0.2764012814,
0.2742834687,
0.8448454142,
0.2023438066,
0.5057854056,
-0.1050313339,
-0.1641431898,
0.0923685208,
-0.546012938,
-0.1403693855,
1.0612658262,
0.2787317634,
0.6134826541,
0.2751603127,
0.0999454409,
0.51642102,
0.1699774265,
-0.8436970115,
0.528552711,
-0.1347994953,
-0.3889415562,
-0.2423106432,
-0.2122124434,
-0.7980815172,
0.2739062309,
-0.3324588239,
-0.5815243721,
0.0481964946,
0.2427836955,
-0.442730546,
0.2430620939,
-0.6481294632,
0.9630642533,
-0.2960759997,
-0.2821600139,
-0.0631980076,
-0.4622696042,
0.4318751395,
-0.10456644,
-0.1879069805,
-0.0865590051,
0.1361186355,
0.6740120053,
-0.0862224251,
0.5562832355,
-0.2095774561,
-0.0323779844,
0.1565072984,
-0.1035476327,
0.3380139768,
0.2177570611,
0.0062563615,
0.3840925097,
0.1207061559,
-0.0060632704,
-0.6298331022,
0.9976304173,
-0.9376460314,
-0.6428179741,
-0.5110145211,
-0.5880656242,
-0.2680475116,
0.4305086732,
0.316254288,
0.5827771425,
-0.2119653672,
0.3882661164,
0.3432449698,
-0.165298894,
0.3423051238,
0.4655920267,
-0.3736075461,
-0.6477453113,
1.0490176678,
0.1320898384,
-0.1478009373,
0.0810528547,
0.2152463049,
-0.4163203239,
-0.8955073357,
-0.8926025629,
0.241926387,
-0.6482462883,
0.0070377113,
-0.4565793574,
0.1677925438,
-0.32569471,
0.2251323611,
-0.1201976389,
-0.0821797475,
-0.0203355495,
-0.2908000052,
0.3920983672,
1.1739652157,
0.2282219976,
0.2383742183,
-0.4466225207,
0.3836740851,
0.4146582782,
0.586255312,
-0.3246355355,
-0.3485208154,
-0.311599046,
-0.0943287462,
-0.2724683285,
-0.6698702574,
0.1557962596,
0.0948752537,
0.5745522976,
0.6246638298,
-0.1194581613,
0.548982203,
-0.6742293239,
1.0482983589,
0.2375358492,
-0.4090350568,
0.329841435,
-0.6647946835,
0.4585048854,
0.500731349,
0.4725517929,
-0.2573416531,
-0.0746518373,
-0.3299393952,
-0.5854417086,
0.6346308589,
0.5207577944,
-0.1059473231,
0.4101622105,
0.4623438418,
0.2682735324,
0.3165307343,
-0.5446882248,
-0.1226209253,
-0.5914853215,
-0.0010179701,
-0.5429219604,
-0.4554742575,
-0.1159368381,
0.1119056344,
0.4801290035,
-0.0467069522,
0.2460461855,
0.10623537,
0.1556741148,
0.1315741241,
0.1674438566,
0.768330574,
0.7178890705,
-0.3622998893,
0.063278079,
0.0004734026,
-0.4903774858,
0.1475384086,
0.3330743611,
0.0053679859,
-0.3217531741,
0.2131061554,
1.2041769028,
0.0201908741,
-0.3343662918,
0.8175107241,
-0.5771757364,
-0.3314323425,
-0.427300036,
-0.1216436252,
-0.2220724076,
0.3877874613,
0.0743161067,
0.2241114527,
0.3697418869,
-0.7233492732,
0.0538631268,
0.3146108687,
-0.778260231,
-0.5062671304,
0.6369659305,
0.3714134395,
-0.0485073477,
0.8871282935,
0.0297576282,
-0.1010865271,
0.1652313918,
0.5375922918,
0.8223232627,
0.1973354816,
0.28196311,
0.0191043951,
0.2404557765,
-0.2037653327,
0.0720716119,
-0.309446305,
-0.8518027067,
-0.1926917136,
-0.3470138013,
-0.385520041,
0.1409972161,
-0.4883286357,
0.259961158,
-0.4252263606,
-0.4038687348,
-0.2004721165,
-0.3766539097,
-0.8977755308,
-0.043126937,
0.0547185205,
0.3608045876,
-0.6346562505,
0.7666733861,
0.9143615961,
-0.780562222,
-0.5418530107,
0.0221702177,
0.1946945488,
-0.6685233712,
0.619918406,
0.1300847232,
-0.3419286907,
-0.0395836569,
-0.2402570397,
-0.5998836756,
1.3031915426,
0.3718622029,
-0.3940668404,
-0.0696894825,
-0.0504124984,
0.4595465064,
-0.2452396303,
0.5255648494,
0.1183899865,
0.663857162,
0.1949692369,
-0.8915397525,
0.1034030095,
-0.4869038165,
0.2390062064,
-0.0065518776,
-0.6760290265,
0.6449596882,
-0.2998673022,
0.0411875322,
0.4222055972,
0.6488113403,
0.3375025094,
0.4031742215,
0.7152144313,
0.524330914,
0.4015301466,
-0.0146470359,
1.50357306,
-0.0217502434,
-0.0735249892,
0.8466213942,
-0.426286459,
0.4835883975,
0.5386136174,
0.0305331424,
0.5607256889,
0.8289126754,
-0.3036672771,
0.7327323556,
0.0925622061,
-0.3638767004,
-0.0967034474,
-0.2983183861,
-0.2316115499,
0.3933591247,
-0.0217929501,
-0.0814497769,
-0.1200942397,
0.5121745467,
-0.5198203921,
-0.4381402433,
-0.1551334858,
0.7693768144,
-0.0034700376,
-0.6947494745,
0.0962689742,
-0.0876480192,
0.6992146373,
-0.9085242152,
-0.6558157206,
-0.0119601274,
0.1902464181,
0.0513035096,
-0.7094059587,
-0.3784326315,
-0.0303986315,
-0.2537176311,
-0.3268269897,
0.5972575545,
-0.3266240358,
-0.3591819704,
0.2349069118,
0.4745732248,
0.2784298658,
-0.2736016214,
-0.3932887912,
-0.0288708974,
0.1984209567,
0.140029341,
0.45907709,
0.405415684,
-0.0668585375,
0.8381302953,
0.5589393973,
0.1352485865,
-0.0716027096,
0.1760831028,
0.6267316937,
-0.4138236046,
-0.4304832518,
-0.7571189404,
0.3808326125,
0.0373746008,
-0.5588338971,
1.1361461878,
0.3750278354,
0.9886617661,
-0.2187911719,
0.9555247426,
0.131069541,
-0.1204800457,
-0.5945180058,
0.4189347625,
-0.5531191826,
0.4291685522,
-0.278023392,
-1.1707450151,
-0.229369536,
0.2527956069,
-0.3105502129,
0.3534302413,
0.7896527052,
0.6228436232,
-0.2660692036,
0.0999127626,
0.7503432035,
0.071214214,
0.5732414722,
0.2400087714,
1.083191514,
-0.178490296,
0.8367918134,
-0.1692709476,
-0.274050653,
-0.1515105963,
-0.7834076285,
-0.8197032213,
-0.9451757669,
-0.1211596131,
-0.1515298188,
0.2818365693,
0.712138176,
0.8025802374,
-0.505541563,
-0.1050584465,
0.1286879331,
-0.2716909945,
-0.1423210055,
-0.1145101562,
0.1921918839,
0.1651956886,
-0.7022116184,
0.6695051193,
0.4881709218,
0.1238997802,
-0.4260841906,
0.0029028191,
-0.0564380437,
-0.4624361992,
0.6676710844,
-0.0888519585,
-0.7725389004,
-0.3030804694,
-0.0526122302,
0.4298761785,
-0.1063391641,
1.1070232391,
-0.6405564547,
0.9297015667,
0.3410832882,
0.5707703829,
0.7428510189,
0.0251141507,
1.0540474653,
-0.5929777622,
-0.0588892438,
-0.1245252192,
0.7196387649,
0.3142790198,
-0.3302558064,
0.5538004041,
0.288654387,
-0.6916247606,
-0.4392664135,
0.3414019942,
-1.2136133909,
0.1095588356,
1.3885760307,
-0.3886370063,
0.2189654112,
-0.0706672519,
-0.6372128725,
-0.0038483005,
-0.6845333576,
0.3873431385,
0.772629559,
-0.3193370402,
-0.415643245,
-0.8404932022,
0.3233925104,
0.0579057597,
-0.492204994,
-0.3292707205,
0.5129782557,
0.3978828192,
-0.0710275322,
0.6395782232,
-0.0205678176,
0.2695946693,
-0.2143851966,
0.0401797891,
-0.5212602615,
-0.4455690682,
-0.4233024716,
0.0308272541,
0.3037608564,
-0.3304629326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04196v1
|
JPAVE: A Generation and Classification-based Model for Joint Product Attribute Prediction and Value Extraction
| 2023-11-07T18:36:16 | 2023-11-07T18:36:16 |
Zhongfen Deng, Hao Peng, Tao Zhang, Shuaiqi Liu, Wenting Zhao, Yibo Wang, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Product attribute value extraction is an important task in e-Commerce which
can help several downstream applications such as product search and
recommendation. Most previous models handle this task using sequence labeling
or question answering method which rely on the sequential position information
of values in the product text and are vulnerable to data discrepancy between
training and testing. This limits their generalization ability to real-world
scenario in which each product can have multiple descriptions across various
shopping platforms with different composition of text and style. They also have
limited zero-shot ability to new values. In this paper, we propose a multi-task
learning model with value generation/classification and attribute prediction
called JPAVE to predict values without the necessity of position information of
values in the text. Furthermore, the copy mechanism in value generator and the
value attention module in value classifier help our model address the data
discrepancy issue by only focusing on the relevant part of input text and
ignoring other information which causes the discrepancy issue such as sentence
structure in the text. Besides, two variants of our model are designed for
open-world and closed-world scenarios. In addition, copy mechanism introduced
in the first variant based on value generation can improve its zero-shot
ability for identifying unseen values. Experimental results on a public dataset
demonstrate the superiority of our model compared with strong baselines and its
generalization ability of predicting new values.
|
[
-0.1566153467,
-0.7798732519,
0.1952833682,
-0.0798312947,
-0.0568454154,
0.1193568334,
-0.0239208024,
-0.9930913448,
0.0307588968,
0.5218819976,
-0.7753367424,
-0.3282998502,
-0.6582098007,
-0.1947926283,
0.0055406303,
1.3256082535,
0.0716701373,
-0.2676160038,
-0.2208324671,
0.0087956963,
-0.6924196482,
-0.2678189874,
-0.4003129601,
0.0346721932,
0.502317369,
0.4616460502,
0.2657567859,
0.1510869265,
0.5180298686,
0.2672213316,
0.204013899,
0.1351217926,
-0.3241137266,
0.6880692244,
-0.1453858763,
-0.5294654965,
-0.4829954505,
0.2081818581,
0.2094979435,
0.3018800318,
0.0868957862,
0.6309818625,
0.1091018245,
0.2394325435,
-0.9724463224,
0.4609401226,
-1.0561854839,
0.0233067609,
-0.1596041918,
0.1463141441,
-0.3329928517,
-0.1969197541,
-0.0708942935,
-0.6442199349,
0.4572920799,
0.2411045581,
1.4202127457,
0.0853522494,
-0.0151419193,
0.1739685237,
-0.6108864546,
1.1985937357,
-0.3925571442,
0.2724997997,
0.2081145793,
0.3207962811,
-0.0380829498,
-0.439891845,
-0.8501855731,
-0.0767056122,
0.1252741963,
0.2765165567,
0.1652722955,
-0.1838429123,
0.1769155264,
0.2705489397,
-0.2851924896,
-0.0821548402,
-0.5297114849,
0.1627935171,
0.5345565081,
0.1095955521,
0.3127310276,
-0.5167761445,
-0.768668294,
-0.204991281,
-0.5391943455,
0.3654989898,
0.0712947547,
0.679688096,
0.2097541988,
0.6038393378,
-0.3402899802,
0.4737786353,
0.2617704272,
-0.6852197051,
0.4844324589,
-0.3785795271,
-0.3831672966,
-0.0483644381,
0.6927887797,
0.3819257021,
0.0063403659,
-0.2059078366,
-0.2140626758,
-0.0163994618,
0.3526532352,
-0.6584050059,
0.0308324378,
0.0394648649,
-0.5265772343,
-0.5564083457,
0.0623633675,
-0.8783633709,
-0.1146552563,
-0.2812350392,
0.3696399033,
-0.3020861149,
-0.2027819604,
-0.1265448332,
-0.2732394934,
-0.0390738919,
0.4092711806,
-0.8849173784,
0.1296337247,
0.3376752734,
0.7174162865,
-0.3977369964,
-0.372576654,
-0.2640638351,
0.5168253183,
0.3474093676,
0.9001962543,
-0.6552138925,
-0.171179235,
-0.52350986,
0.0997942835,
-0.1029212102,
-0.1685740948,
0.4510672688,
-0.7143915892,
0.1813867241,
-0.1621004641,
-0.376975745,
-0.2882553637,
0.5147933364,
-0.7959981561,
0.8071742654,
0.4496809244,
-0.8011121154,
1.0652080774,
-0.877956748,
-0.4037265182,
0.5963180065,
-0.0313125178,
-0.9666210413,
0.2148975134,
0.2991092801,
0.5768284202,
-0.5133247375,
0.2401573658,
-0.6519987583,
-0.1873143017,
0.2626776397,
-0.539401412,
0.5887553692,
0.3382585645,
-0.2561542392,
-0.2007886618,
-0.6114667058,
0.3497119248,
0.4693102837,
-0.1510041505,
-0.2911915183,
-0.2406424731,
0.2584102154,
0.4286250174,
0.2480881661,
-0.8941736221,
0.4155871868,
0.0378330611,
-0.0498866849,
0.6676155925,
0.3614123762,
0.2710540593,
-0.1976651102,
0.8384281397,
0.0321301855,
0.3626826108,
-0.2341661155,
-0.4724560976,
-0.4081949294,
-0.3142610192,
0.4033385515,
0.5396783948,
-0.3741046488,
0.3175911009,
-0.3077407479,
-0.4595496655,
-0.5506513119,
0.0131434305,
0.2808758914,
0.6072211862,
0.5433810949,
-0.2194517553,
-0.3668932319,
-0.7789298892,
-0.0840856582,
-0.0728455707,
-0.0780118555,
0.3528580666,
0.2828775048,
0.1536510587,
0.9061117768,
-0.8798855543,
-0.4922188222,
-0.6658132076,
0.5838985443,
0.1144760475,
0.3249137402,
0.3746055663,
-1.0250370502,
-0.4318169057,
-0.0957655162,
-0.54934901,
-0.0377321839,
-0.2631705999,
-0.0788435191,
0.0911120102,
-0.2197298408,
-0.6762198806,
0.5870377421,
0.1983879805,
-0.0324918367,
0.4360707402,
0.2320709676,
0.4334810972,
-1.3866326809,
0.1399536878,
0.4202232659,
0.1900541633,
-0.3957848847,
0.1594590843,
0.0917620659,
-0.2174954563,
-0.5291782618,
0.3166289628,
-0.3995443881,
-0.0520530082,
-0.2449860275,
-0.1892543137,
0.3662894368,
0.597859621,
0.0972451568,
0.8237920403,
0.1508114487,
-0.6944721341,
0.2214523703,
0.4383676946,
-0.5254184008,
0.8072363734,
-0.3942212462,
-0.2949110568,
-0.2889159024,
0.0025055376,
-0.8418006897,
-0.1600445807,
0.2283094078,
-0.6042761207,
0.5474981666,
-0.2322474271,
-0.3014511168,
-0.4459120929,
-0.1626298875,
0.1673053652,
0.4171199799,
-0.3784407973,
0.3621838987,
0.6578262448,
-0.4632474184,
-0.6745123863,
-0.5191782713,
-0.2635067403,
-0.3352309167,
-0.4114853442,
0.4634719491,
-0.0852759778,
0.301089853,
0.0104861902,
0.0428022295,
-0.1610018015,
0.2887969017,
0.4410962164,
0.7966614962,
0.1174453348,
0.3992603123,
0.2267803699,
-0.1656514108,
-0.1621214598,
-0.1080091372,
0.1762594581,
0.2706719339,
-0.1839831471,
-0.1223787144,
0.3399010897,
0.4046889842,
-0.4409894943,
0.6737397313,
0.544438839,
-0.3753443658,
-0.4155603647,
-0.4359460175,
0.0516167693,
-0.4287099242,
0.3876027465,
-0.691870451,
-0.5255135298,
0.1143050715,
-0.0648769438,
-0.0223741606,
0.5969145298,
0.2765600085,
-0.1241157576,
1.0967781544,
0.746006608,
-0.0823458657,
0.4964202344,
-0.168160826,
0.4441687465,
-0.8489283919,
-0.5553334951,
-0.4595036805,
-0.450949043,
-0.4569452703,
-0.0214282796,
0.3993391395,
0.2542638183,
-0.1267635673,
0.6562674046,
-0.7691430449,
0.5848460197,
0.7744100094,
0.2902997732,
0.051060386,
0.3431230187,
0.1029878482,
-0.1906087399,
-0.2788046598,
-0.0701096803,
1.237651825,
0.0402380675,
0.7385848761,
-0.2409767061,
0.5368105769,
0.2739581764,
0.3147511184,
-0.7221650481,
0.3751507998,
0.0308613908,
-0.657743752,
-0.2770674229,
-0.3484444916,
-0.7171201706,
0.0718736053,
-0.3687894046,
-0.9735750556,
0.1448064893,
0.0062520406,
-0.5343493819,
0.364087522,
-0.5850976706,
0.8999006152,
-0.5899192095,
-0.6756260991,
0.0615784228,
-0.621493578,
0.4434659183,
0.0225075018,
-0.196907267,
-0.4112923145,
0.2953685224,
0.5215988755,
0.017883664,
0.5303342938,
-0.1936007291,
0.2539886236,
0.3193165958,
-0.115107283,
0.3176704645,
-0.1950613707,
0.1029253528,
-0.0131673431,
-0.1330457032,
-0.2171305269,
-0.5999871492,
0.7032033205,
-0.6552024484,
-0.3313863873,
-0.34757936,
-0.4256090522,
-0.2929339707,
0.2939706445,
0.2682411075,
-0.1748736352,
-0.1168323457,
-0.0157000162,
0.5079931021,
-0.1319158971,
0.4892393649,
0.2796551883,
0.1149779186,
-0.4003899097,
1.1400215626,
0.1354655772,
0.2283216864,
0.5833953023,
-0.0387073867,
-0.2825830579,
-0.2952801585,
-0.4813223183,
-0.2380046397,
-0.5037631392,
-0.7536497116,
-0.8581083417,
-0.1477165222,
-0.5479513407,
-0.1017859578,
-0.1590359807,
-0.4487808645,
-0.1126900241,
-0.2905723453,
0.3742955625,
0.5632811189,
0.1713677645,
0.105938606,
-0.9891077876,
0.5011237264,
0.2716110647,
0.3773561418,
0.0170630086,
-0.0161880832,
-0.3694660068,
0.1508738697,
-0.8026938438,
-0.8961445689,
0.6316967607,
-0.0605359413,
0.4238916039,
0.276587218,
0.1207173765,
0.7909162045,
-0.1044787988,
0.8333132863,
0.429789871,
-0.8456967473,
0.6175902486,
-0.0300015323,
0.2049879283,
0.7512423396,
0.5388845205,
-0.481652081,
-0.1802876294,
-0.8170260191,
-0.8489357829,
0.8047213554,
-0.0461084358,
-0.2155693322,
0.0517310537,
-0.0155909061,
0.560731113,
0.4034450054,
-0.9331365228,
0.1918759495,
-0.2248837799,
-0.2414280176,
0.2480307966,
-0.087825574,
0.3858109415,
-0.1921738535,
0.6879891157,
-0.1463291049,
0.3459308445,
-0.1897193491,
-0.1822315007,
-0.4300424457,
0.5315784812,
0.0474249572,
0.3385443389,
-0.3559959233,
-0.1727208644,
0.1049623191,
-0.3160139322,
0.0620689392,
0.2077285498,
-0.4554449022,
-0.3791695833,
-0.2015579045,
0.8681998849,
-0.0462780781,
-0.4989337921,
0.7558583021,
0.1788267791,
0.0644568875,
-0.2871465087,
0.108009249,
-0.3139972687,
0.1588939726,
0.1803927124,
0.3006356657,
0.4810346663,
-0.4131702781,
0.3095363677,
0.4618294835,
-0.1238819361,
-0.3476869166,
0.8413621783,
0.0124225412,
0.1928646863,
0.8276481628,
-0.3611611724,
-0.4721549153,
0.6361327171,
0.7613692284,
0.9798602462,
-0.2077913433,
0.3622148633,
0.3562067151,
-0.0227369871,
0.1455222517,
0.3549862206,
-0.2302691638,
-0.8442721367,
-0.3251255155,
-0.8630366921,
-0.3284194469,
0.3831706941,
-0.6900411248,
0.4184721112,
-0.2956839204,
-0.2040549666,
0.1505674869,
0.0823484361,
-0.9597041011,
0.5609404445,
0.2274496108,
0.2394827455,
-1.1064333916,
0.696541369,
0.330224812,
-1.1319121122,
-0.5690826178,
-0.0924839079,
-0.3076631725,
-0.7318828702,
0.9255647659,
0.4945447147,
0.1431601495,
-0.4806754589,
-0.5747100115,
-0.9664806128,
1.2143648863,
0.0470681787,
-0.3216457069,
-0.2615202367,
0.138805896,
0.131914407,
-0.3903841376,
0.5174558759,
0.2590649426,
0.4806278944,
0.3506365418,
-0.6527009606,
0.0907442346,
-0.407225281,
0.1120835617,
0.4676656127,
-0.5555933714,
0.8723509312,
-0.1650485098,
-0.2691669166,
-0.1139216349,
0.3334486783,
0.349756062,
0.3291124105,
0.3520124555,
0.6928395629,
0.5691991448,
0.0376319364,
0.9774618745,
-0.209319979,
0.3553177416,
1.1769537926,
-0.6216419935,
0.959965229,
0.1580253392,
-0.2830971181,
0.4095263481,
0.4065230787,
-0.4120658934,
0.8209575415,
-0.0842871591,
-0.2814720273,
-0.2042729706,
-0.2940194905,
-0.1105196103,
0.4669781327,
0.3874205053,
-0.5506320596,
-0.0606040582,
0.2075925022,
-0.0551950037,
-0.29825899,
-0.2042795122,
0.8459730744,
-0.4614182413,
-0.6622745991,
0.2703741789,
0.0128629953,
0.5130694509,
-0.480630815,
-0.32239452,
0.1587780416,
0.3201657534,
-0.0131068863,
-0.6013633013,
0.0377338082,
-0.1997620314,
-0.5361022949,
-0.4874671102,
1.0430498123,
-0.3650146127,
-0.8014876842,
-0.0360678993,
0.35129565,
-0.1796337962,
-0.1773793846,
-0.9122210145,
-0.2485424727,
0.0371726006,
-0.3660462499,
0.5465037823,
0.1808511019,
-0.0846465155,
0.517916441,
0.5863865018,
0.1793988198,
-0.0064367359,
-0.3200855553,
0.6168785691,
-0.7241553068,
-0.4908921421,
-0.5084818602,
0.7160627842,
-0.4486148357,
-0.3604428172,
0.5695680976,
0.5160641074,
0.9531204104,
-0.246243909,
1.2155714035,
-0.1788359135,
0.7991636395,
-0.2487517446,
0.5836781859,
-0.4539210796,
-0.1069668159,
-0.3770248592,
-0.890738368,
-0.161463201,
0.404130578,
-0.1218302399,
0.1048673093,
0.6659221053,
0.4902444482,
-0.2338723093,
0.1082328707,
0.2803648412,
-0.1341738701,
0.1461229324,
0.741293788,
0.3921356201,
-0.518283844,
0.4301584363,
-0.2292203456,
-0.257712543,
-0.0603395887,
-0.7197546363,
-0.4890222847,
-0.5070362687,
-0.3445238471,
-0.1451229006,
0.0726983026,
0.9033235908,
0.8734037876,
-0.8429372907,
0.1275375932,
-0.2036228031,
-0.1390661001,
-0.5076065063,
-0.3363850117,
0.1817139685,
-0.4928334951,
-0.832782805,
0.3045419753,
0.283354342,
0.2592515945,
-0.0585371554,
0.4039218426,
-0.1369980872,
-0.0306103528,
0.4046857655,
0.2830528319,
-0.5508500934,
-0.2054472715,
0.0566047691,
0.2602882683,
0.168249175,
0.5721466541,
-0.987906158,
0.4458702505,
0.501373589,
0.6424499154,
0.6107632518,
0.1056476235,
0.5323401093,
-0.7481456995,
-0.1327838004,
0.2093265504,
0.3618190289,
0.1700306535,
-0.6541443467,
0.1939469576,
0.2292468995,
-0.4904202521,
-0.4305500686,
0.4497908056,
-0.9822618961,
-0.3478120267,
0.7300187945,
-0.3667862415,
-0.423923403,
0.2201375812,
-0.1605425924,
0.3844890594,
-0.6096803546,
1.0289582014,
0.3178830147,
0.1100151241,
-0.492423743,
-0.2923781574,
0.1263938248,
0.1367822886,
-0.9729229212,
0.0929245874,
0.5252809525,
0.3084942102,
0.2315473557,
0.1008645594,
0.0000685657,
0.1198340282,
0.0600133426,
0.532400012,
-0.2539882958,
-0.5230075717,
0.0779554471,
0.759277761,
0.0843493342,
-0.6263524294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04192v1
|
JaSPICE: Automatic Evaluation Metric Using Predicate-Argument Structures for Image Captioning Models
| 2023-11-07T18:33:34 | 2023-11-07T18:33:34 |
Yuiga Wada, Kanta Kaneda, Komei Sugiura
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Image captioning studies heavily rely on automatic evaluation metrics such as
BLEU and METEOR. However, such n-gram-based metrics have been shown to
correlate poorly with human evaluation, leading to the proposal of alternative
metrics such as SPICE for English; however, no equivalent metrics have been
established for other languages. Therefore, in this study, we propose an
automatic evaluation metric called JaSPICE, which evaluates Japanese captions
based on scene graphs. The proposed method generates a scene graph from
dependencies and the predicate-argument structure, and extends the graph using
synonyms. We conducted experiments employing 10 image captioning models trained
on STAIR Captions and PFN-PIC and constructed the Shichimi dataset, which
contains 103,170 human evaluations. The results showed that our metric
outperformed the baseline metrics for the correlation coefficient with the
human evaluation.
|
[
-0.474788785,
-0.3809741735,
0.4701713026,
0.3219360113,
-0.7189574242,
-0.0319111347,
-0.0150095047,
-0.1397967637,
0.1457690597,
0.4610361159,
-0.4878243804,
-0.5394543409,
-0.5903552175,
0.4466658533,
-0.2601907551,
0.7439233661,
-0.1896328181,
0.2695253491,
-0.8438585997,
-0.1591149122,
-0.6428637505,
-0.0066499757,
-0.3174111843,
0.1649206728,
0.3040343225,
0.4055804014,
0.9545730948,
0.3541909754,
0.6703757048,
0.4140684307,
0.5531246662,
0.2319148481,
0.1764515638,
-0.0532801263,
-0.1532031447,
-0.3729687035,
-0.1154992953,
0.0790924057,
0.8415406346,
0.611613512,
0.2991478443,
0.1164987609,
-0.0988370255,
0.8597656488,
-0.5529831648,
0.7039898634,
-0.2707131803,
0.3013029695,
-0.0693305582,
-0.338650316,
-0.2839993238,
-0.3848395944,
-0.0144876754,
-0.7868591547,
0.0429092944,
0.5465323925,
1.4373710155,
0.3572633564,
0.0720337778,
-0.2036088407,
-0.1876687109,
0.5990977883,
-0.592246294,
0.1318300068,
0.1903553158,
0.621337533,
-0.1344651431,
-0.5666515231,
-0.2774737775,
-0.6937722564,
-0.4904409945,
0.3442712426,
-0.2776869237,
-0.0620920509,
0.2269558907,
0.3291753829,
-0.5875272155,
-0.1188302636,
-0.2810283899,
-0.407997787,
0.5346667171,
0.2348347008,
0.7866288424,
-0.8474855423,
-0.1766151488,
-0.2411466092,
-0.4005496502,
-0.2651070654,
0.2547271848,
0.2338610142,
-0.0449564233,
0.561901629,
-0.2755556703,
0.7848336697,
-0.2146663517,
-0.0621645302,
0.4503555,
-0.2930602431,
-0.1084713638,
-0.208542645,
1.248047471,
0.6446255445,
0.3944138885,
-0.2944508493,
0.0478493348,
0.0446495414,
0.2089694887,
-0.9008466005,
-0.5403310061,
-0.2858156264,
-0.4541063011,
-0.2523816526,
0.3998891115,
-0.7954563498,
-0.322255075,
-0.1475411505,
0.8305891752,
-0.5190595388,
0.0875275955,
-0.2696819603,
-0.3991546333,
0.0873069838,
0.3943245113,
0.0772223622,
0.5888956785,
0.1510691792,
1.0273166895,
-0.2209524661,
-0.4686908126,
-0.5300961733,
-0.1887599677,
-0.5181209445,
0.9097226262,
-0.6379871368,
-0.3903897405,
-0.4381612837,
0.2993253171,
-0.1169904321,
-0.5176872611,
0.495565176,
-0.1918166131,
0.4491735697,
-0.1239618659,
-0.5615447164,
-0.0641776398,
0.1298631132,
-0.7519463301,
0.5572307706,
0.1040547639,
-0.8163823485,
0.3305074573,
-1.0129401684,
-0.6805947423,
0.3828202486,
-0.2642384768,
-0.7276194096,
0.1764493585,
0.7317533493,
0.3875314593,
-0.5650694966,
0.3219764829,
-0.0145535516,
-0.4769132435,
0.3716066182,
-0.1125868484,
0.4582725763,
0.3187550306,
-0.1962918341,
0.0845862925,
-0.4566919208,
0.008393974,
0.3569643199,
0.428978622,
-0.5735165477,
0.0524673834,
-0.3175039887,
-0.0053233323,
0.1867849082,
-0.5399642587,
-0.2051402032,
-0.3746974766,
0.1925250292,
0.3052643239,
0.2339840531,
0.2851394713,
-0.100040473,
1.0012916327,
0.2774340808,
0.2325289845,
-0.5815810561,
-0.6614847183,
-0.594370842,
-0.2740085125,
0.2701400816,
0.2189466655,
-0.7605451345,
0.5198177695,
-0.5428476334,
-0.6452066302,
-0.3495950103,
-0.0938287824,
0.7053645849,
0.5626060367,
0.1208478138,
-0.7738190293,
-0.4342823923,
-1.3025062084,
-0.3182371855,
-0.0446645804,
0.1633136719,
0.5478587747,
0.4176197946,
0.2413439304,
0.9556063414,
-0.7624166608,
-0.4852376282,
-0.2347729206,
0.3069673181,
0.2171685249,
0.271624893,
0.5522745252,
-0.6254288554,
-0.6915981174,
-0.0833214521,
-0.450827539,
-0.3522515893,
-0.1563402265,
-0.3262833059,
-0.1486181468,
0.3759602606,
-0.3208394349,
0.2555718422,
0.1709827483,
-0.1356353164,
0.8662243485,
-0.083073467,
0.6853111982,
-1.2702704668,
0.03535074,
0.3869057894,
-0.3297389746,
-0.0237734392,
0.2585656345,
0.010025505,
-0.4905466735,
-0.5090019703,
0.6701471806,
-0.5952462554,
-0.6287221313,
-0.0332572125,
0.406044811,
0.3859987259,
0.4369257689,
0.2544200718,
0.8232582808,
0.6242541075,
-0.1324662864,
0.4740011096,
0.2014611959,
-0.8040604591,
0.6811652184,
-0.6342325807,
-0.1050567776,
-0.1166051254,
0.2970080078,
-1.4066588879,
-0.4403573275,
0.2692085505,
-0.5563293099,
0.0760485977,
-0.3428695202,
-0.7282998562,
-0.5497483015,
-0.1840337366,
0.1096088141,
0.5974309444,
-0.3707088828,
0.2809204459,
0.3631714284,
-0.1312835813,
-0.3355092108,
-0.4970365465,
0.416318804,
-0.3601054251,
-0.3735085726,
0.1024468094,
0.2359264344,
0.0998078659,
0.2049889863,
0.0173373614,
-0.3345911801,
-0.066408962,
0.5626312494,
0.3918843567,
-0.0625392869,
-0.075031288,
0.1079336181,
-0.1318828315,
0.1173211038,
-0.1216132641,
0.4045206606,
-0.389039129,
-0.300319165,
-0.5703373551,
0.0140213668,
0.4488248229,
-0.2913062871,
0.2827536464,
0.4773553312,
-0.2545293272,
0.1100281551,
-0.2291324735,
0.2132989019,
-0.4218718112,
0.6742469072,
-0.5982360244,
-0.4515697062,
0.3732203543,
-0.2502202988,
-0.1956813633,
0.5252283812,
0.2140363902,
-0.2943539023,
0.9924191236,
-0.1005462706,
-0.0627140477,
0.2654123902,
-0.0732317716,
0.1523955166,
-0.630323112,
0.0720500797,
-0.607314229,
-0.1907279342,
-0.4240515232,
-0.5317819715,
0.5624758005,
-0.1564378887,
-0.1266429722,
0.6691616178,
-0.5194160938,
0.8468223214,
0.119516246,
0.055270914,
0.1893344969,
0.2976621091,
-0.1793366969,
-0.3111569583,
-0.5854598284,
-0.4609780312,
0.6693246365,
0.2428598851,
0.7680407166,
-0.1486728936,
0.7683791518,
0.5249480605,
0.3793722987,
-0.883433044,
0.8470141888,
-0.6564640403,
-0.4678741693,
-0.2962979972,
-0.5225772858,
-0.8905891776,
0.2081935704,
0.0078283539,
-0.5908899307,
-0.2234715521,
0.0506692342,
-0.056507498,
-0.0654232129,
-0.6761012673,
1.2450785637,
-0.4579259753,
-0.1028785557,
-0.0651058257,
-0.5463756919,
0.3423335552,
0.1637548059,
0.4058435261,
-0.1134199053,
0.0922550187,
0.9221247435,
-0.53969419,
0.6182445884,
-0.4483470023,
0.441031903,
0.3830111325,
0.2139515132,
0.0210571755,
-0.3162539601,
0.1560188234,
0.1259301901,
0.1534833014,
-0.1972039193,
-0.9267259836,
0.6210978031,
-0.8382736444,
-0.4182281494,
-0.2494536042,
-0.3849950135,
-0.1912592053,
0.3063671887,
0.285551846,
0.7469924092,
-0.1401696503,
0.0780566558,
-0.0699582398,
-0.6128265262,
0.1141579822,
0.3896475434,
-0.3593268394,
-0.7109472156,
1.0978958607,
-0.0287250709,
0.0226535238,
0.3873120546,
0.6730922461,
-0.5180371404,
-0.1956408173,
-0.8769638538,
0.1509422362,
-0.8647122383,
-0.3356600404,
-0.403650105,
-0.21371077,
-0.0517336801,
-0.1867620647,
-0.3905504942,
-0.4620637,
0.2543399036,
0.3042433262,
0.1588063687,
0.4767924547,
0.4892814457,
0.0944995806,
-0.8966049552,
0.3746214211,
-0.0648275986,
0.4615067542,
0.0122067295,
-0.6243905425,
-0.450684607,
-0.2924276292,
-0.1516687572,
-1.0084388256,
0.4780986607,
0.3638919592,
0.5419571996,
0.2448803037,
0.1437571049,
1.1681993008,
-0.5615876317,
0.9006613493,
0.4920780957,
-1.0042870045,
0.8854092956,
-0.089237377,
0.2872492671,
0.6832857132,
0.4675933719,
-0.1732295454,
-0.6594728827,
-0.5355598927,
-0.590803802,
0.5751755238,
0.2055312991,
0.1389956772,
-0.179777056,
0.2841283679,
0.1148541644,
0.1661984175,
-0.8927549124,
0.139189139,
-0.3656835556,
-0.3752106726,
-0.071259968,
0.2917353511,
-0.0240465067,
-0.5281990767,
0.3237451613,
-0.1035325527,
0.1837061942,
0.2588274777,
-0.5266129971,
-0.0380681492,
0.189697355,
0.0150968358,
0.4613753259,
-0.0370266922,
-0.1340708286,
-0.0962719321,
-0.2165384889,
0.3251948655,
0.0449200124,
-0.0955197215,
0.2950421572,
0.390193522,
0.980690062,
0.3522044718,
-0.7556140423,
0.7570689917,
-0.0555525944,
-0.1149137244,
-0.4448714256,
0.1102084666,
-0.1210721955,
-0.2739312351,
-0.0139881913,
-0.0590239018,
0.3896004856,
-0.5706401467,
0.3059965372,
0.4189624488,
-0.3618670702,
0.0360626206,
0.4664703906,
0.2668800354,
-0.1877028495,
0.3983153701,
-0.4849281013,
-0.4468595684,
0.8668178916,
0.4497151375,
1.1323589087,
0.0587255619,
0.5002195239,
0.7045605183,
0.2582216561,
0.1341821402,
-0.1016998589,
-0.221917212,
-0.5748378634,
-0.4680592716,
-1.0004761219,
-0.5221799612,
-0.0864252746,
-0.7095079422,
0.3078549504,
-0.5102644563,
-0.0126197282,
0.142889604,
0.1089709029,
-0.6575495005,
0.4824901819,
0.0962057263,
0.6265814304,
-1.2855820656,
0.6290542483,
1.2613854408,
-0.7496260405,
-0.612457931,
0.1487365961,
-0.363415271,
-0.3635924757,
0.83550632,
0.5062886477,
-0.2063235641,
-0.1857440472,
-0.263284713,
-0.6878042817,
0.846540153,
0.0772890896,
-0.6075905561,
0.3323890567,
0.1135633513,
0.6893405318,
-0.603439033,
0.5022794604,
0.4056863189,
0.6175420284,
0.1515973508,
-0.6858620644,
0.1262828559,
-0.5500326157,
0.1451814771,
0.0229370948,
-0.4315602481,
0.2303687036,
-0.0846507996,
-0.3386205137,
0.4711149335,
0.447815448,
0.1455845237,
0.3179738224,
0.857725203,
0.5343933702,
0.0970549136,
-0.1579785794,
1.2361263037,
-0.2147445977,
0.1186793819,
1.2180280685,
-0.1265376955,
0.6183571219,
0.0694173127,
-0.6956126094,
0.7383628488,
0.6385855079,
-0.3401750028,
0.4535118043,
0.3065752685,
0.4081384838,
-0.2863727212,
0.0769660249,
0.2381911725,
0.4524953663,
0.2865228355,
-0.3199924231,
-0.2446718365,
-0.0090540107,
-0.0019395883,
0.3531950712,
-0.0768455043,
0.7402089238,
-0.0224994831,
-1.0483812094,
0.3710983396,
-0.0214143023,
0.1740606129,
-0.5189105868,
0.1192621291,
-0.2211838067,
-0.2601958811,
-0.2704140842,
-0.9326349497,
0.3879884779,
0.3736678958,
0.1644096375,
0.3194638491,
0.5416548252,
-0.1906301677,
-0.818431139,
0.0697453022,
0.3264840841,
0.6460558176,
0.0509129725,
-1.0077543259,
-0.0834545046,
-0.0495561734,
0.0523701869,
0.2494715005,
0.0647407249,
-0.264301002,
0.4645103812,
0.3365503848,
0.0061754971,
-0.1532945782,
0.6914437413,
0.6389636993,
-0.5322780609,
-0.6916376352,
-0.6976870298,
0.5121458769,
-0.4472679198,
0.0039804955,
0.8784614205,
0.6661328673,
0.2529407442,
-0.2938506007,
0.77121979,
-0.1740814447,
0.2371664643,
-0.373950541,
0.5599848032,
-0.8498021364,
-0.0009000819,
-1.0522309542,
-1.2496067286,
-0.530082047,
0.758143127,
-0.4459359646,
-0.0476815552,
0.7167660594,
0.8604735732,
-0.0823689401,
-0.2158756107,
0.3330607712,
0.1309168339,
0.2113034874,
0.3601860106,
0.9333278537,
-0.4559018016,
0.4194203019,
-0.2742930651,
-0.3009320498,
-0.021073902,
-1.1166801453,
-0.7473396659,
-0.7816409469,
-0.7847032547,
-0.0937045664,
0.1833661497,
0.6257192492,
0.5899038315,
-0.7663229108,
-0.298201859,
-0.0403482988,
-0.0674459487,
-0.1116285697,
-0.2994242609,
0.5812162161,
-0.5480129123,
-0.8048990369,
0.1527371705,
0.5477547646,
-0.2921057045,
-0.3985962868,
-0.1976181567,
0.2243383974,
0.0874499455,
0.4645330608,
-0.01180181,
-0.7087958455,
-0.1245309561,
-0.3731175363,
0.1785311997,
0.1866091043,
0.4976519942,
-0.6440686584,
0.8715362549,
0.5532791615,
0.309351027,
0.3551696539,
0.4361361563,
0.4706504941,
-0.8365795016,
0.2871484458,
-0.1255361289,
0.6303275228,
0.5854025483,
-0.0241351966,
0.3849143386,
0.3151324391,
-0.3111020923,
-0.5373111367,
0.1103542075,
-0.7986630797,
-0.3595219254,
0.852612257,
-0.586058557,
-0.4535194337,
0.3356857598,
-0.2744650543,
0.0517325811,
-0.0839566663,
0.6625548601,
0.7846885324,
-0.1011970267,
-0.4708665311,
-0.2143607438,
0.1929562986,
0.4160163403,
-0.9412524104,
-0.2549880445,
0.8686095476,
0.4047099054,
0.4319697022,
0.4785378575,
-0.7567145824,
0.502020359,
-0.0805125311,
0.0524664447,
-0.2655515969,
-0.4637756944,
-0.0647062436,
-0.0404353403,
0.1320108622,
-0.5697730184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04189v1
|
SpaDeLeF: A Dataset for Hierarchical Classification of Lexical Functions for Collocations in Spanish
| 2023-11-07T18:32:34 | 2023-11-07T18:32:34 |
Yevhen Kostiuk, Grigori Sidorov, Olga Kolesnikova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In natural language processing (NLP), lexical function is a concept to
unambiguously represent semantic and syntactic features of words and phrases in
text first crafted in the Meaning-Text Theory. Hierarchical classification of
lexical functions involves organizing these features into a tree-like hierarchy
of categories or labels. This is a challenging task as it requires a good
understanding of the context and the relationships among words and phrases in
text. It also needs large amounts of labeled data to train language models
effectively. In this paper, we present a dataset of most frequent Spanish
verb-noun collocations and sentences where they occur, each collocation is
assigned to one of 37 lexical functions defined as classes for a hierarchical
classification task. Each class represents a relation between the noun and the
verb in a collocation involving their semantic and syntactic features. We
combine the classes in a tree-based structure, and introduce classification
objectives for each level of the structure. The dataset was created by
dependency tree parsing and matching of the phrases in Spanish news. We provide
baselines and data splits for each objective.
|
[
-0.3222252131,
-0.9276462197,
0.0318667553,
0.6453908682,
-0.0508201458,
0.2343723178,
0.1059785187,
-0.4071646333,
0.1345619559,
0.3060674071,
-0.3969234824,
-0.8069765568,
-0.4263127148,
0.1650574356,
-0.731451571,
1.1251850128,
0.4696760774,
0.0840662569,
-0.3833397627,
0.0614479817,
-0.3958745301,
-0.5776263475,
-0.4787520766,
-0.1764817536,
0.5583701134,
0.4980585277,
1.0861139297,
0.5962588787,
0.6995828748,
0.2993616164,
-0.0800025836,
-0.0272462349,
-0.2128921747,
-0.0539101362,
-0.389465481,
-0.1407334208,
-0.3621059656,
-0.6149901748,
0.8994660974,
1.1200275421,
-0.326974839,
0.040229544,
-0.0157879442,
0.6149199605,
-0.4316792786,
0.4717983902,
-0.5426421165,
0.1851448864,
-0.3076784611,
-0.4013035297,
-0.2101752311,
-0.5917931199,
0.0388915055,
0.0250927825,
0.457393378,
0.2447076738,
1.3166992664,
0.1787055582,
-0.5486115813,
-0.4212332666,
-0.4480645955,
0.650567174,
-0.1078064293,
0.5845916867,
0.5276075006,
0.0828717202,
-0.5474609733,
-0.3806917667,
-0.1134506762,
-0.1554437578,
-0.1795808673,
-0.1241005436,
-0.1230455339,
0.3299781978,
-0.1955712289,
0.6154709458,
-0.686352253,
0.1694220901,
-0.2798919678,
-0.0326584093,
0.4364295304,
0.0943437368,
0.1503836811,
-0.5150654912,
-0.2182530165,
-0.2423325777,
-0.4669103324,
0.1968481392,
0.2777268589,
0.636852324,
-0.011031338,
0.4865531623,
-0.0910506174,
0.9828455448,
-0.1715443283,
-0.5731329322,
0.3827688098,
-0.2647485435,
-0.4301944673,
0.2512605786,
0.7101435661,
0.2129513174,
0.3145960271,
-0.3979332745,
0.0576102994,
-0.1291685998,
0.0684077069,
-0.719994247,
-0.1731113344,
0.4343533218,
0.0633124411,
-0.725283742,
0.3598591387,
-0.7053098083,
-0.1290192306,
0.1060727537,
-0.2383066714,
-0.285676688,
0.0300419349,
0.3391138315,
0.1577277333,
0.0684985518,
-0.0520167165,
-0.8366937637,
0.8753457069,
0.3954468071,
0.8449673057,
-0.1676661372,
-0.1932105869,
-0.7723045945,
0.1066118926,
-0.2769023478,
0.8468349576,
-0.2986184955,
-0.4314014912,
0.257622242,
0.1879097223,
-0.3125328422,
-0.5131515861,
0.6974099278,
-0.3971981406,
0.1964202076,
-0.1200833619,
-0.3878551126,
-0.4056707025,
0.2426675707,
-0.8634701967,
1.2633368969,
0.2446944267,
-1.1498800516,
0.2932651341,
-0.2033405751,
-0.7680695057,
0.276375562,
-0.2777067125,
-0.4479586184,
-0.235250026,
0.2660014033,
0.7162181139,
-0.3776217103,
0.8394886851,
0.0075355894,
0.2187190205,
0.0974679217,
0.1185393408,
1.0159167051,
-0.0064377068,
0.0206449069,
-0.0716359019,
-0.7294264436,
-0.2091744691,
-0.2966485023,
-0.2177513987,
-0.4234184027,
0.3225468993,
0.1498373598,
0.3652244508,
0.1479643881,
-0.4169607162,
-0.0591278821,
-0.5783644915,
-0.1946217567,
0.0961562544,
0.27689749,
0.2440094054,
-0.3454765677,
0.628364861,
0.2173691243,
-0.1111501977,
0.0009244489,
-0.4666646719,
-0.4086800814,
-0.4023325741,
0.3351247013,
0.9125103951,
-0.441337496,
0.7306928635,
-0.2853073776,
-0.3909982741,
-0.0860426947,
0.1339151412,
0.2382276952,
0.7815883756,
0.214771688,
-0.0123432558,
-0.6527454853,
-0.8685756326,
0.2961865962,
-0.2898588777,
0.3348474205,
0.0785749853,
0.424411118,
0.0588131472,
1.2082880735,
-0.4348073304,
-0.8161950707,
-0.1867583841,
0.140955314,
0.3678953946,
0.026709564,
0.721011281,
-0.7623634934,
-0.1197765619,
0.563722074,
-0.5361913443,
-0.3698353469,
-0.104562059,
-0.0255154055,
0.1750143766,
0.7198670506,
-0.177210778,
0.1547694951,
0.5346756577,
-0.4775610268,
0.4726807177,
-0.0277964044,
0.0860873461,
-0.8795468807,
0.1021352708,
0.0148178749,
-0.4759080708,
-0.362128526,
0.1515780538,
-0.1386022717,
0.3594586849,
-0.7117856741,
0.5712055564,
-0.2286967039,
-0.1347987652,
0.1324488819,
0.2582137585,
-0.2656441033,
0.3441134095,
0.4061861932,
0.270396769,
0.9823798537,
-0.6519923806,
0.5335723162,
0.3048001826,
-0.181025207,
0.4396425486,
-0.7447677851,
-0.5914478898,
-0.2050487995,
-0.2193555534,
-0.9901887178,
-0.133667931,
-0.0249309726,
-0.2177451849,
-0.1481379718,
-0.0673701093,
-0.9708823562,
-0.4463280737,
-0.2747429311,
-0.0195443425,
-0.0003197532,
-0.3231545091,
0.1688556224,
0.6883387566,
-0.1495168358,
-0.69878757,
-0.6191371083,
-0.2747517824,
-0.162020728,
-0.8130369186,
0.4671373367,
0.5075019598,
-0.1787514389,
0.1453892142,
0.010567232,
-0.2676336467,
-0.1232612133,
0.5308032036,
0.1689848006,
0.1330615729,
0.5266677141,
0.2399426848,
0.3531965911,
-0.1032616869,
0.0726680979,
0.658624649,
-0.5120431185,
0.1937062442,
0.1044859067,
0.1648719758,
0.2759115398,
-0.0274636075,
0.7669878006,
0.5140941143,
-0.4336934984,
-0.1564255059,
-0.2665239275,
0.1346427649,
-0.4075922966,
0.6526459455,
-0.4563811123,
-0.7951969504,
0.5853838325,
0.3350348771,
0.2584413886,
0.3184421062,
0.6369386911,
-0.0247751046,
0.6111960411,
0.6940070987,
-0.1795234978,
0.3478282392,
0.004945362,
-0.0285219401,
-0.1593257189,
-0.5601199865,
-0.7851433158,
-0.0855376497,
-0.5878459811,
-0.4453970194,
0.0590322763,
0.1790383458,
-0.0479244217,
0.5360950232,
-0.2924587429,
0.4765169024,
0.1500002444,
-0.3939447105,
0.4996964931,
0.2758582532,
-0.2702844739,
0.0614887178,
-0.8490373492,
-0.2111889273,
0.4213836193,
0.424767077,
0.6538214087,
0.0882819071,
0.7939793468,
0.1878429502,
-0.1797870696,
-1.2565219402,
0.6318770647,
-0.5319364071,
-0.4648422897,
-0.2472481132,
-0.4617866278,
-1.4194850922,
0.2784233987,
-0.1560550928,
-0.855031848,
0.3229216933,
0.0118140215,
-0.153373152,
0.036905311,
-0.5487964153,
0.9281982183,
-0.0353269577,
-0.1084565967,
0.0104988934,
-0.4417707324,
0.323330909,
0.0131524866,
0.6637420058,
-0.116044946,
-0.0284260213,
0.9608706236,
-0.540017724,
0.7707758546,
0.1374749988,
-0.1449503154,
0.3925415576,
0.3276124597,
0.1864487976,
-0.0368014611,
0.1482611448,
-0.0052119573,
0.5075451732,
-0.1720273495,
-0.2659470141,
0.5305808187,
-0.5541312099,
-0.1082902849,
-0.780007422,
-0.511331439,
-0.3317908347,
0.1527455598,
0.175012514,
0.4377290606,
-0.4909713268,
0.3086756468,
0.3020474017,
0.1842575967,
0.6332138181,
0.1612701118,
-0.8541480899,
-0.0563188568,
0.8383105397,
0.0247384794,
-0.0139644453,
0.6252707839,
0.1817413718,
-0.3929920793,
-0.321637094,
0.0175853726,
0.3313210309,
-0.5126336813,
-0.3722935617,
-0.6626299024,
-0.335125953,
-0.2368531376,
-0.2384514213,
-0.1689281166,
-0.5605742931,
-0.1925869882,
-0.1603575349,
0.3641991913,
0.5195086002,
0.1328237802,
0.5958834291,
-0.7630906701,
0.415322572,
0.0092339385,
-0.0505754612,
-0.1744371504,
-0.404514581,
-0.3066786528,
-0.3044924438,
-0.3105905056,
-1.0684646368,
0.7949616909,
0.5678642392,
0.3178561032,
0.3103279471,
-0.153861329,
0.7311884761,
-0.4062357545,
0.2048806101,
0.288379699,
-0.7544699907,
0.587644279,
-0.372502774,
0.287293762,
0.4529983401,
0.6596096158,
-0.8078270555,
-0.6690083146,
-0.7405990958,
-1.0375202894,
0.699259758,
0.1050554067,
-0.2390530258,
-0.522737205,
-0.0974131897,
-0.0965436921,
0.2996250093,
-0.7845337987,
-0.1538399309,
0.0959934145,
-0.2995092273,
0.3649047613,
0.075315997,
0.1047245264,
-0.4927001894,
0.5840989947,
-0.0446159504,
-0.2120209485,
0.0947240293,
-0.3154888451,
-0.1680207253,
0.0843812376,
-0.0311924051,
0.3665523827,
-0.4412685633,
0.3519912362,
-0.0333289579,
-0.7690562606,
-0.1285365075,
0.0400329642,
0.0212347545,
0.2525821626,
0.4735843837,
0.3574991524,
0.5366008878,
-0.7459734678,
0.52862221,
0.3814139068,
-0.1909390241,
-0.3921607137,
0.0341450125,
0.1293368787,
-0.1537108272,
0.2206560671,
-0.1373107582,
0.4411973655,
-0.6279533505,
0.6017247438,
0.2721158862,
-0.1781202555,
-0.0603052229,
0.104265742,
-0.0009372687,
0.0583261736,
0.4037797451,
-0.5453265309,
-0.3183601499,
0.6716040969,
0.3947166502,
0.5602981448,
-0.3321892917,
0.7557025552,
0.681501925,
0.1596094668,
-0.1368988752,
0.1985066235,
0.1155829281,
-0.9695412517,
-0.3472628891,
-1.2050449848,
-0.1333470494,
-0.0898621678,
-0.6761547327,
0.7273326516,
-0.5686913133,
-0.0450185612,
0.2314198166,
0.0111743324,
-0.5109188557,
0.2715030015,
0.0334655419,
0.6029623151,
-1.088060379,
0.9480447769,
0.6556407213,
-0.2382008433,
-0.3912810385,
-0.3651710749,
-0.0505267866,
-0.6672576666,
0.9732586741,
-0.1483079791,
-0.4777030051,
0.0108155366,
-0.1525160223,
-0.8868246078,
0.8272027373,
0.1078221947,
-0.7245630622,
-0.3192353547,
0.3371439278,
0.6274582744,
-0.4269833565,
0.1428404003,
0.7163116932,
0.3282678425,
0.6778372526,
-0.9447386861,
-0.1180158332,
0.0147647019,
0.092218563,
0.2551653981,
-0.1493260264,
0.5610097647,
-0.0861516669,
-0.2650515735,
-0.2214740366,
0.5911975503,
0.1518167704,
-0.1940740645,
0.3097767234,
0.4450410008,
0.8700029254,
-0.2264554948,
0.9508314133,
-0.0273967087,
0.617862165,
1.2946857214,
0.2253447324,
0.9632385373,
0.5332448483,
-0.2841692865,
0.6955190301,
0.7155287862,
-0.1567098051,
0.5216093659,
0.2754520178,
-0.1091616079,
0.0443755277,
-0.2399046272,
-0.0035977096,
0.3917916119,
0.6614860892,
-0.1911153942,
-0.8009535074,
0.158077985,
0.2938418686,
0.0020970621,
-0.4478537738,
0.4982074797,
-0.1582282484,
-0.452285111,
0.6603823304,
0.1163366884,
0.4341707528,
-0.3133768439,
0.1302385628,
-0.1392885149,
0.0140376454,
-0.8818990588,
-0.95266366,
0.67963624,
-0.2002199292,
-0.0208687633,
-0.0213026237,
0.4832489491,
-0.6137796044,
-0.6817364097,
0.2894363105,
0.616116941,
0.3986067772,
0.0237896387,
-0.5135666728,
-0.0673216283,
-0.0969632268,
0.0228573568,
-0.1029882729,
0.4782370031,
-0.3728863299,
0.6781936884,
0.2803649306,
0.3133881688,
0.3326085806,
0.3761050105,
0.4622375965,
-0.7975605726,
-0.6591694951,
-0.6962407231,
0.3795393705,
0.0021696778,
-0.3668478429,
0.5564603806,
0.5516397953,
0.6456682086,
-0.0728197545,
0.2356786877,
-0.6369140744,
0.3918116391,
-0.3309711814,
0.3158011138,
-0.2979304492,
0.1330501884,
-0.397831738,
-0.9919795394,
-0.8866618872,
0.7967146039,
-0.3452588022,
-0.0443446487,
1.1116884947,
0.9472908974,
0.0341562666,
-0.0691798702,
0.4853787124,
0.2847272158,
0.1455382109,
0.5312952995,
0.3758023083,
-0.3508795798,
0.532813251,
-0.5386465788,
-0.2980870306,
-0.4001719356,
-0.9073309302,
-1.1043118238,
-0.9811519384,
-0.7122322321,
-0.0614009537,
0.0429344401,
0.9314579964,
0.657140255,
-1.0006588697,
-0.7725223303,
-0.6346706748,
0.3872466385,
-0.2264400572,
-0.3272728622,
0.6824054122,
-0.7554557323,
-0.6935880184,
-0.0516871959,
0.2177552432,
-0.0994881317,
0.0944041088,
0.1713307053,
-0.6048672199,
-0.2718656659,
0.7346141338,
0.4559623301,
-0.3764954209,
-0.160671398,
-0.0092106257,
-0.2304439396,
0.2263799757,
0.4587406516,
-1.0419362783,
0.1853674054,
0.5003606081,
0.3588841558,
0.4377974272,
-0.0960034952,
0.1129120961,
-1.2220873833,
0.4673934281,
0.3411673009,
0.3184455037,
0.3091840744,
-0.2581665516,
0.5632870197,
0.180733338,
-0.3171553612,
-0.7773928046,
0.1750833988,
-1.3848052025,
-0.1750538647,
1.1712790728,
0.2897440195,
-0.5267729163,
-0.3923005164,
-0.3585632145,
-0.0086591356,
-0.317931056,
0.5921934843,
0.9079045057,
-0.3583494425,
-0.3584295511,
-0.4197440743,
0.6569190621,
0.1171745434,
-1.0030096769,
0.0426609553,
0.5416402817,
0.0007070914,
0.3094177544,
0.4223836362,
-0.5725821257,
0.2812193036,
-0.1100511029,
0.0245358348,
0.1313647628,
-0.679292798,
-0.1060316339,
0.4338883758,
0.1228455454,
-0.2686668336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04934v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04934v2
|
Prompt Cache: Modular Attention Reuse for Low-Latency Inference
| 2023-11-07T18:17:05 | 2024-04-25T15:45:19 |
In Gim, Guojun Chen, Seung-seob Lee, Nikhil Sarda, Anurag Khandelwal, Lin Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Prompt Cache, an approach for accelerating inference for large
language models (LLM) by reusing attention states across different LLM prompts.
Many input prompts have overlapping text segments, such as system messages,
prompt templates, and documents provided for context. Our key insight is that
by precomputing and storing the attention states of these frequently occurring
text segments on the inference server, we can efficiently reuse them when these
segments appear in user prompts. Prompt Cache employs a schema to explicitly
define such reusable text segments, called prompt modules. The schema ensures
positional accuracy during attention state reuse and provides users with an
interface to access cached states in their prompt. Using a prototype
implementation, we evaluate Prompt Cache across several LLMs. We show that
Prompt Cache significantly reduce latency in time-to-first-token, especially
for longer prompts such as document-based question answering and
recommendations. The improvements range from 8x for GPU-based inference to 60x
for CPU-based inference, all while maintaining output accuracy and without the
need for model parameter modifications.
|
[
-0.2688567936,
-0.9086999297,
0.8684346676,
0.3211958706,
-0.1356039345,
-0.1094014347,
-0.3172731698,
-0.1365948766,
0.268429786,
0.3705992103,
-0.6750333309,
-0.2735816836,
-0.1848027706,
0.0570002571,
-0.2998558283,
0.4172292352,
0.1172577292,
-0.11901851,
-0.5867691636,
0.0990840867,
-0.6052361727,
-0.2535468638,
-1.0814805031,
-0.1024563387,
0.9817564487,
0.5295864344,
0.3950370848,
0.5810455084,
0.0157849509,
0.2963074744,
-0.1704172045,
0.198941052,
-0.418694675,
0.5048891902,
-0.2619000375,
-0.5656844974,
-0.5575897694,
-0.2231571823,
0.7634927034,
0.6730130911,
-0.08453466,
0.0255026426,
-0.2048298866,
0.3287789524,
-0.9789226651,
0.10702537,
-0.5399118662,
0.0157911628,
-0.2016325295,
-0.0749180242,
-0.8513948917,
-0.2936247587,
0.2420002669,
-0.7130464911,
0.3665545881,
0.1459466368,
0.3447799385,
0.5686601996,
-0.093346864,
0.2359977514,
-0.3289260268,
0.7400884032,
-0.7791528106,
0.2474854439,
0.3345439732,
0.313896358,
-0.390401572,
-0.8944877386,
-0.6346065402,
0.0077849636,
-0.0405663587,
0.2101468444,
-0.2010595649,
0.2516568899,
0.4835151136,
0.2892404497,
-0.3147302866,
0.1750207543,
0.1170214936,
-0.4070307314,
0.063504383,
0.4961423278,
0.2744032443,
-0.0315814652,
-0.2559981942,
0.1547031552,
-0.9036802649,
0.1444186121,
0.1120229438,
0.4304437339,
0.0948576108,
0.3766362369,
-0.5325897932,
0.8119040132,
0.3023736775,
0.0643624738,
0.050871551,
-0.2975149453,
-0.2646329999,
0.1687379479,
0.515894711,
0.1523677558,
-0.1700589359,
-0.0922270641,
-0.1858078688,
-0.0526442043,
0.1623853594,
-0.8548951745,
-0.2421673089,
0.2512531281,
-0.3653187454,
0.2899579704,
-0.3126074374,
-0.8185310364,
-0.4629329145,
-0.2493032068,
0.0555405207,
-0.0806536749,
0.2196048796,
0.116386272,
-0.0152278878,
0.033162538,
0.7087560892,
-1.0049564838,
0.2565636635,
0.7686738372,
0.8609494567,
-0.557005465,
-0.1224506795,
-1.0605963469,
-0.0111850938,
0.0626671165,
1.0279891491,
-0.7543119192,
-0.4578545988,
0.0071257968,
0.3724327087,
-0.0811228529,
-0.3346590698,
0.5254637003,
-0.7153660059,
0.2778098285,
-0.4787011743,
-0.7055549026,
-0.015911052,
0.0680457205,
-0.9405581355,
1.2472029924,
-0.0053585204,
-0.6771872044,
0.1439512372,
-0.3018402457,
-0.4792028964,
0.0680861026,
-0.0340429135,
-0.1465733945,
0.2692022324,
0.4176935852,
0.2675364912,
-0.4610002339,
0.1092800647,
-0.2578400671,
-0.6208178997,
-0.1143163145,
-0.5399865508,
0.490724653,
0.0486114956,
-0.1640663594,
0.3615483344,
-0.6431577206,
-0.0939049572,
-0.284848094,
-0.6405446529,
-0.2542903125,
0.1151331961,
-0.1005648002,
-0.1335536987,
0.5531724691,
-0.5077229142,
0.2731333971,
-0.352022171,
0.5123050809,
0.7171141505,
0.0307283197,
0.6543621421,
-0.0480644479,
0.5996516943,
0.1310939938,
0.0430137143,
-1.0744514465,
-0.6319236159,
-0.8374224901,
-0.375872612,
0.0745632872,
0.574908793,
-0.7716578841,
0.2363714874,
-0.1351866424,
-0.2811717391,
-0.4467908144,
-0.2110266089,
0.3442997932,
0.86313802,
0.296667546,
-0.1878338158,
-0.2037775069,
-0.9175748229,
-0.2296552658,
-0.3246313632,
-0.0328867771,
0.4659955204,
-0.0279468168,
-0.0573260784,
1.144708395,
-0.5903193355,
0.4629748166,
-0.1405140311,
0.1108698547,
0.2281072289,
0.4022076726,
0.2130685002,
-0.3437413573,
-0.2850342989,
-0.3234041631,
-0.2522049844,
-0.4945508838,
-0.2505877912,
-0.2111830264,
0.3464665115,
0.5355927944,
-0.740473628,
0.43053931,
0.1379173249,
-0.4155055583,
0.7158945799,
-0.1398189515,
0.3222233057,
-0.9297960401,
0.1024106368,
-0.2698248625,
-0.3956836164,
-0.5416052341,
-0.2086102962,
0.3205066025,
-0.1214421317,
-0.5194940567,
1.2480397224,
-0.4383311868,
-0.2743142545,
-0.329139322,
0.3282791078,
0.2586575747,
0.5330883861,
-0.0485057347,
1.3346304893,
0.4226896465,
-0.52514714,
0.2657806277,
0.1442899108,
-0.2809743583,
0.5742052794,
-0.6776186824,
0.3617067933,
0.0578094088,
0.3576592207,
-1.1855473518,
-0.0941148475,
0.2333969921,
-0.2374436259,
0.1506120712,
-0.075649105,
-0.6493184566,
-0.311724335,
-0.152841121,
0.5165380239,
0.3453599215,
-0.6081948876,
0.6115071774,
0.0982643291,
-0.3429628909,
-0.7075203061,
-0.5005550981,
0.1079703495,
-0.0531638004,
-0.5014613867,
0.2868854403,
-0.127149865,
0.0337119028,
-0.0159994978,
-0.1843157709,
-0.1008785218,
0.210204944,
0.2929601669,
0.1694069207,
-0.5024502873,
0.4888563156,
0.2842056155,
-0.2182339281,
-0.1048058048,
-0.5333496928,
0.6310768127,
0.1883483529,
-0.3849018812,
-0.6705344915,
0.6752027869,
0.4792008102,
0.0016903718,
0.5378379226,
0.3629273772,
-0.4559827149,
-0.0674917251,
-0.7469204068,
-0.4971901178,
-0.4873537123,
0.2256078422,
-0.2918782532,
-1.0442708731,
0.797703743,
-0.1018196866,
0.0589004792,
0.1234031767,
0.7112186551,
0.1628386378,
0.6850212216,
0.5271406174,
-0.2963384092,
0.9405178428,
0.3757715225,
0.0520642586,
-0.8771976233,
-0.0468602665,
-0.5739113092,
-0.3013713956,
0.1891234666,
-0.9052957892,
-0.1019508541,
-0.0853583142,
-0.3466786742,
-0.0292273033,
-0.1082260162,
0.6905619502,
0.5469243526,
0.1051038131,
0.3084916472,
0.0201493893,
-0.2005435079,
-0.1879405081,
-0.7300618291,
-0.4757938385,
0.5994656682,
-0.051212348,
0.9219557047,
-0.2648814917,
0.3512796164,
0.4400280714,
0.1000034958,
-0.8119353056,
0.7222000957,
-0.0559836701,
-0.4487053156,
-0.1129646748,
-0.3792103827,
-0.8315101266,
0.0785594359,
0.2352193445,
-0.9850035906,
0.1755970567,
0.3742915392,
-0.7491371036,
0.2871321738,
-0.8144130111,
0.8013317585,
0.2738304734,
-0.6517559886,
-0.3301185071,
-0.5072460175,
0.1501746625,
0.042370975,
-0.4837425053,
0.0299433451,
-0.3303538263,
0.7210794687,
-0.3661968112,
1.1723468304,
-0.2754577696,
-0.0757999718,
0.3070639372,
-0.0481323861,
0.6676309705,
0.216700688,
-0.2875981629,
-0.2215494812,
-0.40740031,
-0.52710706,
-0.8030283451,
0.8971487284,
-0.5375726819,
-0.9248179197,
-0.102518715,
-0.5173826218,
-0.1968157738,
0.3549621701,
-0.0636365488,
0.6669240594,
-0.1248687804,
-0.1289120317,
0.9787930846,
-0.3554752171,
0.5442678928,
0.5588856936,
-0.0046552103,
-0.2395374775,
0.5137982368,
-0.2174032629,
0.3915925324,
0.4761331677,
-0.0862071663,
-0.222554177,
-0.3351297975,
-0.5211690664,
0.1582541019,
-0.9596489072,
-0.08702299,
-0.9774223566,
0.1807500422,
-0.1760285646,
-0.2052956969,
-0.3269177675,
-0.6329086423,
-0.7044766545,
0.0325668156,
0.4204975069,
0.2926211059,
0.2446256578,
0.9631646276,
-0.55049932,
0.0489808656,
0.229889676,
0.0818494931,
0.3007300794,
-0.4828309119,
-0.2308675498,
-0.4596776366,
-0.0025174171,
-0.7396404147,
0.0673501641,
0.1277816296,
0.7192105651,
0.5512325168,
-0.0248392504,
0.6919269562,
-0.6975995302,
1.0104471445,
0.1024029255,
-0.9413547516,
0.4094933271,
-0.2037235349,
0.8182936907,
0.6786865592,
-0.0491706654,
-0.7929599881,
-0.2479073256,
-0.2533589602,
-0.9650509953,
0.7127755284,
-0.3295937181,
0.1152932346,
-0.4562030733,
0.7609952688,
0.1852679551,
0.2295074761,
-0.0815216079,
-0.1620757729,
0.2134956717,
-0.2048527747,
0.0381866135,
-0.6066978574,
-0.0183435082,
-0.0538044684,
0.4118615985,
-0.3507374823,
0.5763429999,
0.2171513289,
-0.1263377517,
0.1182601899,
0.1385674477,
0.5767556429,
0.5095981956,
0.1219093949,
0.4220493436,
0.3021626174,
-0.567853272,
0.044282876,
-0.1050911769,
-0.1921658069,
-0.1309610158,
0.2268836051,
0.7523781061,
0.6976544857,
-0.6249067783,
0.1828837693,
-0.4320880175,
0.5108548403,
0.0130545972,
0.1274104714,
0.3923223615,
0.4336157739,
0.1486235112,
-0.0920272693,
0.045467291,
-0.2491531074,
0.3172852099,
0.1349017322,
-0.4759410322,
-0.3603035808,
0.6720148921,
0.3997267485,
-0.3353648186,
0.756842792,
-0.0308089182,
-0.437753886,
0.5283774734,
0.6442220211,
0.9848605394,
-0.212179631,
0.0997498035,
0.3997324705,
0.0911246464,
-0.1094084531,
0.3669016957,
-0.3735309839,
-0.4608033597,
-0.6229134202,
-0.3742920458,
-0.4953471422,
-0.2802758515,
-0.441462189,
0.1192940846,
-0.5230522752,
-0.3101057708,
-0.2832621336,
-0.0141443852,
-0.4177080691,
-0.0980188102,
0.2225872576,
1.3123619556,
-0.6830989718,
0.8567699194,
0.4722316861,
-0.040168006,
-0.4342877567,
0.0115400553,
0.1947678924,
-0.7501292825,
0.5502423644,
0.2904521823,
-0.3028495014,
0.1110545769,
-0.472486347,
-0.6961326003,
1.1035832167,
0.40350613,
-0.6722948551,
0.0710882843,
-0.4459017217,
0.2759262323,
-0.5303397179,
0.4509334266,
0.6231815219,
0.4099243879,
0.1322479993,
-0.4209335744,
0.3725591004,
-0.1702947319,
-0.156486243,
0.0435580127,
-0.5689967275,
1.1270258427,
-0.3090101182,
-0.5434084535,
0.4431056082,
0.8909083009,
0.490164876,
0.3195974231,
0.4676071107,
0.6167933345,
1.2325347662,
-0.1682286859,
1.0889174938,
-0.234342292,
0.1764633209,
1.4226025343,
-0.321344465,
0.8317674398,
0.6421334743,
0.0495897457,
0.4095784128,
0.9439954162,
0.3319165111,
0.5627652407,
0.1480783075,
-0.6352168918,
-0.5332215428,
-0.2479224205,
-0.2270970643,
-0.3148042262,
0.3888640702,
-0.0506940372,
-0.267028898,
-0.2639897466,
0.2620877922,
-0.3451061249,
-0.2524522841,
0.6188043356,
0.081928581,
-0.9443989396,
0.1193899438,
-0.24961932,
0.4517982602,
-0.3932563961,
0.0446164496,
-0.5896438956,
0.1976967752,
0.0362809859,
-0.5869112611,
-0.042148713,
-0.0026915635,
-0.7415274382,
-0.0750704855,
0.7445052266,
-0.3396843076,
-0.161458388,
0.1611203104,
0.4451432526,
0.1514627486,
-0.0512931272,
-0.3929071426,
0.0873231217,
-0.1548254341,
-0.520639658,
0.1869903952,
0.5831042528,
-0.162994042,
0.7032880187,
0.623282969,
0.0320747569,
0.4102695584,
0.237655893,
1.1339132786,
-0.6917179823,
-0.685618341,
-0.8281853795,
0.5257991552,
-0.1629378945,
-0.2405568808,
0.5922678113,
0.4604925215,
0.123214528,
-0.0797091946,
0.6390054226,
0.1448652595,
0.0815940574,
-0.6406114101,
0.5313107371,
-0.4575004876,
0.265999347,
0.0418482237,
-0.8998294473,
-0.3400349319,
0.2698557675,
-0.4153748155,
-0.1702235788,
0.8265089393,
0.8550347686,
-0.0738639161,
0.1438994855,
0.1895429343,
0.0696748719,
0.4437650144,
0.7084361911,
0.9309623837,
0.0343277939,
0.1444340646,
0.3675366044,
-0.2064585388,
-0.3767693937,
-0.950789392,
-0.9323654771,
-0.3414983153,
-0.2147169709,
-0.1094050929,
0.0717028156,
0.7241044641,
0.6664034724,
-0.7058294415,
0.1333033442,
0.1945850104,
0.3171776533,
0.0093809282,
-0.2023528367,
0.3841758072,
-0.685077548,
-0.8224282861,
0.5374670625,
0.6583954096,
-0.1366127133,
-0.3530680537,
0.0970824882,
-0.1409565955,
0.2736046016,
0.4996255934,
0.379647553,
-0.9480004907,
-0.4411498308,
0.2511294782,
-0.1746735871,
0.0995750725,
1.0898126364,
-1.1241024733,
0.6268120408,
0.9214054346,
0.9947015047,
0.4119936526,
0.004404664,
0.7014834881,
-0.8524625897,
0.3530656695,
-0.0086093331,
0.598094821,
0.3900430799,
-0.3825840652,
0.1735788882,
0.1504435092,
-0.6719170213,
-0.6905719638,
0.3229311109,
-1.2342655659,
-0.1046829075,
0.9414125681,
-0.5468895435,
-0.5678741336,
-0.1683156192,
-0.2739234269,
0.148006618,
-0.8864198327,
0.5872904658,
0.7264095545,
0.0348605476,
-0.3560433686,
-0.5898553133,
0.3939425349,
0.6215862036,
-0.9428111911,
0.4718869627,
0.6195628643,
0.1200101748,
0.1222223118,
0.7908161879,
0.1235715672,
0.3559596241,
-0.067580983,
-0.0501522459,
0.1397019029,
-0.4647749364,
-0.4374556243,
0.0212611295,
-0.3487060666,
-0.0104696769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04177v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04177v1
|
Enhancing LLM Intelligence with ARM-RAG: Auxiliary Rationale Memory for Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2023-11-07T18:03:23 | 2023-11-07T18:03:23 |
Eric Melz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are smart but forgetful. Recent studies, (e.g.,
(Bubeck et al., 2023)) on modern LLMs have shown that they are capable of
performing amazing tasks typically necessitating human-level intelligence.
However, unlike humans, frozen LLMs do not improve over time; they neither
acquire new knowledge nor learn from their successes or failures. Some
approaches to improving the intelligence of LLMs include fine-tuning models
based on problem-solving performance (Zelikman et al., 2022), and building
bigger and more sophisticated models (Bubeck et al., 2023). However, these
methods have the drawback of requiring substantial data and computational
resources to retrain existing models. In this paper, we explore the use of
Retrieval Augmented Generation, also known as RAG (Lewis et al., 2021) to
improve problem-solving performance. We propose ARM-RAG (Auxiliary Rationale
Memory for Retrieval Augmented Generation), a system that learns from its
successes without incurring high training costs. We demonstrate that the
storage and subsequent retrieval of reasoning chains have a positive influence
on performance in grade-school math problems.
|
[
-0.4871487021,
-0.7369900942,
0.5706375837,
-0.2691845,
-0.1834324598,
0.5480573177,
-0.1269803643,
-0.3488613963,
0.3698449135,
0.6362860799,
-0.3539331555,
-0.1706054211,
-0.4969894588,
0.0406808257,
-0.1529613137,
0.9364997149,
-0.1161427647,
0.0875638872,
-0.3228223026,
-0.1870248169,
-0.5410997868,
-0.5922928452,
-0.9815610647,
-0.4480486214,
0.5485508442,
0.5983441472,
0.4654106498,
0.8338728547,
0.5754611492,
0.3167263567,
-0.1720885485,
0.6609238386,
-0.5372614861,
0.2619127333,
-0.4003591835,
-0.5808118582,
-0.6398979425,
-0.0867519006,
0.5914292932,
0.695343852,
-0.1471759975,
0.2592895627,
-0.1911124736,
1.00912714,
-0.7115784883,
-0.0590460896,
-0.8790572286,
-0.1516392082,
-0.1127082407,
-0.3820373416,
-0.4288859963,
-0.1091277972,
-0.1754149497,
-0.7168765664,
0.2334998101,
0.3381128311,
0.6073747873,
0.3712234795,
-0.1010500565,
-0.4468545318,
-0.6604368687,
1.0099058151,
-0.496643126,
0.2574084699,
0.4933178723,
0.1355021447,
-0.5204749703,
-0.2965577245,
-0.5614062548,
-0.3447380066,
0.2869185507,
0.0976623893,
0.0808035433,
-0.1181679815,
0.5534594655,
0.2297841907,
-0.2177571803,
-0.1611088067,
-0.3361488581,
0.0434902087,
0.6557779908,
0.233779937,
0.2678994834,
-0.1294450909,
-0.2685469389,
-0.1386743039,
-0.7222291827,
-0.0994862765,
0.2282832414,
0.1786051989,
0.3621096611,
0.7593349814,
0.0065647215,
0.4350408912,
0.0008059434,
-0.4579688609,
0.1270556301,
0.1296332031,
0.1520371139,
-0.1834007055,
0.1935613751,
-0.0351324454,
0.2747579515,
-0.2382964343,
-0.4689721465,
0.1311191469,
0.369766593,
-0.6096593738,
-0.2113804072,
-0.0926999152,
-0.209643811,
0.0722230077,
-0.3211174011,
-0.3586168587,
-0.376976043,
-0.6626771688,
0.4962225556,
-0.6889196634,
-0.1684329957,
-0.2004119456,
-0.4371646345,
0.1320870072,
0.3080141544,
-0.778360188,
0.4383080602,
0.9150862098,
0.5494577289,
-0.3707064986,
-0.1225124225,
-0.6723718047,
0.1768928915,
-0.7011836767,
0.9831011891,
-0.5795804858,
-0.3273106217,
-0.4200431705,
-0.3432776928,
0.0162294507,
-0.976146102,
0.6091892719,
-0.6697121263,
-0.1758718938,
-0.279912889,
-0.6722345352,
-0.1133666262,
0.3166221082,
-0.4742166698,
0.9169074297,
0.0030854945,
-0.6228896379,
0.0297135394,
-0.3664131463,
-0.3953454792,
0.0422613509,
-0.2225781083,
-0.4103569388,
0.4581467807,
0.2753330469,
0.2196315676,
-0.5622112155,
0.134876579,
-0.2255642563,
-0.3439501822,
0.274556309,
-0.4203630984,
0.5277765989,
0.2628181875,
-0.0730121508,
-0.1680110246,
-0.7814766169,
-0.0075279414,
0.1643048525,
-0.4356316626,
-0.5072190762,
0.0803492591,
-0.6099839211,
-0.1839827895,
0.3982123137,
-0.3853276968,
0.1840239018,
-0.4495655,
-0.2047186643,
0.7944505215,
-0.0442007408,
0.5297665596,
-0.8474273682,
0.5341727734,
-0.0560017228,
-0.3226499557,
-0.1111381426,
-0.3158174455,
-0.9976255894,
-0.2513709962,
0.1661987901,
0.6647749543,
-1.197989583,
-0.1709292531,
-0.0246139932,
-0.323585242,
-0.2393527925,
0.4241081774,
0.5135501027,
0.7276387811,
0.4436766505,
-0.2217914164,
-0.5984033942,
-0.749438405,
-0.5110487938,
-0.1170776635,
-0.0519446209,
0.5908618569,
0.3078651428,
-0.1467041373,
0.7185374498,
-0.4036541283,
-0.0135262543,
-0.3508010209,
0.2164152414,
0.3223522305,
0.4659018219,
0.1344702393,
-0.6870975494,
-0.2268844247,
-0.0266855415,
-0.5204879045,
-0.1787457168,
0.0217904504,
-0.2320321798,
0.5147548318,
0.3540442586,
-0.7432602644,
0.4017263949,
0.2935764194,
-0.2366024256,
0.7717111111,
-0.3894408345,
0.0035466987,
-1.0635277033,
0.0084419837,
-0.118689999,
-0.1704243571,
-0.4593558311,
-0.0155784395,
-0.0597760715,
-0.1586486399,
-0.2749732137,
0.86543715,
-0.5734946132,
-0.1748705506,
-0.6120014787,
0.177165091,
-0.0931943133,
0.4265348911,
-0.1333114505,
1.093210578,
0.3004012704,
-0.7356114388,
0.1075481698,
-0.0882862136,
0.0570575222,
0.389432013,
-0.4121370316,
0.2464508414,
-0.3956203163,
0.0161375292,
-0.5655447841,
-0.3523293138,
0.0321239606,
-0.569175601,
0.6557235122,
0.1071521565,
-0.3198136985,
-0.1838129014,
-0.3103958666,
0.4481204748,
0.7343133688,
-0.6709575057,
1.0124796629,
0.6276105046,
-0.2006364763,
-0.6828898787,
-0.298286438,
-0.0840881616,
-0.2683359981,
-0.4414600432,
0.3167288005,
-0.1372591853,
-0.4892250896,
0.1165527403,
-0.3870944977,
-0.0601917692,
0.0866824612,
-0.0719747692,
0.5159133673,
-0.0983419046,
0.446075201,
0.0295234732,
-0.3415053189,
0.0516502857,
0.0149245756,
0.4418795407,
-0.1845813394,
-0.295830965,
-0.0112415161,
0.338983953,
0.4484621882,
-0.2338979542,
0.6540914774,
0.3042510748,
-0.3799936771,
-0.4218910336,
-0.7628747821,
-0.2775322795,
-0.45749861,
0.2993557453,
-0.3575564027,
-0.9006881118,
0.5267819762,
-0.5164389014,
0.049381651,
0.3687882721,
0.3943426311,
-0.253271699,
1.1581332684,
0.4380586743,
0.0913784429,
0.4569702744,
-0.3397635818,
0.0442057289,
-1.264467597,
-0.001179763,
-0.3141978681,
-0.2386879921,
-0.5012130737,
-0.7258935571,
0.4058647156,
0.5099013448,
-0.5834411383,
0.1171770617,
-0.505138278,
0.7735033035,
0.5119994879,
0.0337867364,
0.2769005001,
0.1135464162,
-0.1143269315,
0.0643073395,
-0.89523983,
-0.5667412281,
1.1563931704,
0.2988543212,
0.820197463,
0.1214106083,
1.0444562435,
-0.0517474562,
0.6386785507,
-0.6982111931,
0.7981342077,
-0.4774131179,
-0.5678387284,
-0.2138261348,
-0.7954758406,
-0.9931811094,
0.0934671685,
-0.2621091902,
-0.634395659,
-0.0621798299,
0.2928805351,
-0.1491219252,
0.3423260152,
-0.7289421558,
0.2702625692,
-0.4509103,
-0.5392519236,
-0.4795242846,
-0.0820480511,
0.3422900736,
-0.0381124318,
0.3853555024,
-0.3047111332,
-0.2712213993,
0.7619614601,
-0.4520513415,
0.5094562173,
-0.081787087,
0.239554882,
0.4482980967,
0.1761390865,
0.6242175698,
0.1302910894,
-0.0836281404,
-0.2532390356,
-0.3142888546,
-0.3915118277,
-0.7278194427,
0.8258969784,
-0.8116933107,
-1.1571575403,
-0.4525569081,
-1.0499587059,
-0.4290578961,
0.1313343048,
-0.2566178441,
0.4527306259,
0.2858994901,
0.1222729906,
1.0245037079,
-0.1754084378,
0.3280318081,
0.3234096169,
-0.3973253965,
-0.669134438,
1.2438817024,
0.3389854133,
0.3104959428,
0.0795740634,
0.3073154092,
-0.0487457439,
-0.4096322954,
-0.3549685478,
0.4413376749,
-0.6876788735,
-0.5174767375,
-0.4563264847,
-0.2752609551,
-0.1322544962,
-0.2236763835,
-0.3671436012,
-0.7089235783,
-0.3900195062,
0.2684956491,
0.7148486376,
0.6427820325,
-0.2525810301,
-0.0112933172,
-0.6983324885,
0.7120558023,
0.3445429206,
0.2835146785,
0.1409223974,
-0.5725693703,
-0.2330662161,
0.0741697475,
-0.4356242716,
-0.5523197055,
0.4739398658,
-0.0016629477,
0.6493029594,
-0.2164360732,
0.0576841347,
0.7652686238,
-0.6588499546,
0.3275474906,
0.0369267203,
-0.7442218661,
0.2256251723,
-0.231907472,
0.3665086329,
0.3559682667,
0.2490693331,
0.020217292,
-0.2249621898,
-0.7112687826,
-0.8647966981,
0.5488219261,
-0.1022311449,
0.0529046394,
-0.1814929098,
0.6557617784,
-0.2347821742,
0.0786177963,
-0.264592886,
-0.1503923535,
0.1566482931,
-0.0865544528,
0.0380211696,
-0.2129620463,
-0.0374787226,
-0.4377704859,
1.0213139057,
-0.0958380252,
0.1768978536,
0.1596057564,
0.1761068553,
-0.1300797611,
0.2326820344,
0.4787658453,
0.6564135551,
0.0208558608,
0.112032555,
0.6994075775,
-0.4620003402,
0.1100767404,
0.0254443157,
-0.0423221067,
-0.1299752891,
0.228374362,
0.5825332403,
0.1079455838,
-0.9034638405,
0.0206365157,
0.0194107369,
-0.0535296723,
-0.6546651721,
0.3338769078,
0.3169800639,
0.4212657213,
0.6839122772,
0.2763119638,
0.0251165517,
-0.6462266445,
0.2199643105,
0.6511218548,
0.1006721109,
0.1983932406,
0.4048980474,
-0.1600205749,
-0.6560989022,
0.4035333991,
-0.3432614803,
-0.6206247807,
0.755764544,
0.8389182687,
0.7278207541,
-0.20738931,
-0.001762213,
0.3841175437,
0.1544418633,
-0.1904100031,
0.4002908766,
-0.0109235533,
-0.7604793906,
-0.7642188668,
-0.6827987432,
-0.6067914963,
-0.1237946898,
-0.368188858,
0.1173325479,
-0.6520138979,
-0.2055452317,
-0.3357495964,
0.2491332591,
-0.5272885561,
0.1427809894,
0.0735601857,
0.8989787102,
-0.2600986362,
0.7338752747,
0.7249765396,
-0.1470383406,
-1.1879823208,
-0.1826027483,
-0.2526882291,
-0.7295026183,
0.796562016,
0.0840433165,
-0.3020127118,
0.0516792275,
-0.3960713446,
-1.1503852606,
1.1032286882,
0.4552564025,
-0.4110577106,
0.0600089021,
-0.0835666135,
0.5953969955,
-0.5432749391,
0.1385610253,
0.4803046584,
0.2384991348,
0.4730992317,
-0.6796377301,
-0.2382658571,
-0.2681865096,
0.2553221583,
0.4239926636,
-0.431971699,
1.1411105394,
-0.4177874625,
-0.2134895176,
0.0551717021,
0.7212508917,
0.924039185,
0.5205091238,
0.3091804385,
1.0278508663,
0.8087767959,
0.1151159555,
1.1332030296,
-0.1733266264,
0.0349307433,
1.1890044212,
-0.1975472122,
1.2310812473,
0.5500486493,
0.1179999858,
0.4836716354,
0.0375526026,
0.4885214865,
0.2365222871,
0.2600132823,
-0.4971697032,
-0.5156790614,
-0.1926250607,
-0.1555440277,
0.2506659031,
0.6854627132,
-0.1427736878,
-0.1790736467,
0.0434177034,
-0.0091067366,
0.3718726933,
-0.7490420341,
0.8174319267,
0.3048208058,
-0.7426041365,
0.862490952,
-0.1809569001,
0.5236881375,
-0.2843898833,
-0.4090287983,
-0.2372437268,
0.4317167401,
-0.0508644879,
-0.4731318355,
0.5298008323,
0.1528689265,
-0.3343933821,
0.0009173196,
1.0395407677,
-0.2654209137,
-0.8033276796,
0.0652177632,
0.6282240152,
0.1229829788,
0.3889254332,
-0.6233659387,
0.2007669359,
-0.2046052516,
-0.2854395807,
0.4672947228,
0.5790002942,
-0.1979414225,
0.9894058108,
0.9374457598,
0.1309852153,
-0.0825245008,
-0.2285790294,
1.1006717682,
-0.6275843978,
0.0474731773,
-0.6441255212,
0.3507805765,
-0.1488551944,
-0.1312186867,
0.7754958868,
0.5680511594,
0.7676005363,
0.1855434924,
0.5332533121,
0.1523519009,
1.1746622324,
-0.4611019492,
0.5413862467,
-0.58279109,
0.6160661578,
-0.0556972995,
-0.8675921559,
-0.2880604863,
0.6646763682,
-0.5134993792,
0.0347943641,
0.4954046011,
0.8250544071,
0.1301339567,
-0.200476259,
0.3124113381,
0.0852847621,
0.2205679715,
0.5315127373,
0.7690615654,
-0.2610559165,
0.3486714065,
-0.2307364792,
-0.3605730236,
0.0284586027,
-0.7508243322,
-1.0605825186,
-0.3592584431,
-0.0827018544,
-0.2217009664,
0.3142458797,
1.0396915674,
0.1815181226,
-0.5887701511,
-0.317186147,
-0.2256373316,
0.3547102511,
0.0197170563,
-0.1792644411,
0.2170017958,
-0.7522203326,
-0.4813502729,
0.4912797511,
0.1553725898,
-0.0753986463,
-0.1344694346,
-0.2692002058,
-0.2535238564,
0.4103507996,
0.6244434118,
0.5402350426,
-0.6476011276,
-0.2645906806,
0.1980787665,
0.0541934371,
-0.0902321264,
0.6730188727,
-1.1318286657,
0.3502451479,
0.4705664814,
1.0692975521,
0.441180408,
0.1404635906,
0.4349968135,
-0.3896937668,
0.1052508578,
0.5084254146,
0.4169531465,
0.2785116136,
-0.1639827192,
0.4659561217,
0.1637952626,
-0.8881704807,
-0.7457550168,
0.1573054641,
-0.6071105003,
-0.407181561,
1.0049641132,
0.02722992,
-0.5333565474,
-0.0800026357,
-0.4217609763,
0.2262517959,
-0.4000606835,
0.8416811228,
0.4823734164,
-0.4043254554,
-0.3376382887,
-0.6083393693,
0.442535162,
0.746733129,
-0.7334809899,
0.0257779155,
0.5589825511,
0.0422202423,
0.4562572241,
0.4411349297,
0.0304162446,
0.3983640075,
0.0398601592,
-0.0751646459,
-0.1543568075,
-0.5635485649,
0.0706637427,
0.0495057963,
0.2711146474,
0.1978078485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04166v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04166v2
|
Perturbed examples reveal invariances shared by language models
| 2023-11-07T17:48:35 | 2024-06-14T18:36:36 |
Ruchit Rawal, Mariya Toneva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rapid growth in natural language processing (NLP) research has led to
numerous new models, outpacing our understanding of how they compare to
established ones. One major reason for this difficulty is saturating
benchmarks, which may not well reflect differences in model performance in the
wild. In this work, we introduce a novel framework to compare two NLP models by
revealing their shared invariance to interpretable input perturbations
targeting a specific linguistic capability. Via experiments on models from the
same and different architecture families, this framework offers insights about
how changes in models (e.g., distillation, size increase) affect linguistic
capabilities. Furthermore, our framework enables evaluation of invariances
between commercial black-box models (e.g., InstructGPT family) and models that
are better understood (e.g., GPT-2). Across experiments, we observe that large
language models share many invariances encoded by models of various sizes,
whereas the invariances by large models are only shared by other large models.
Possessing a wide variety of invariances may be key to the recent successes of
large language models, and our framework can shed light on the types of
invariances retained or emerging in new models. We make the code publicly
available.
|
[
-0.1973901093,
-0.5407271385,
0.7660523057,
0.4982787371,
0.0453861766,
0.1592303514,
-0.252817601,
-0.35861063,
-0.2527865767,
0.6328835487,
-0.2318642884,
-0.2758514583,
-0.9496589303,
0.1454994231,
-0.4825563431,
0.9311336875,
-0.1109906137,
0.0782195181,
-0.3927076161,
-0.246155113,
-0.4254766703,
-0.7601395845,
-0.2570047975,
-0.5315716267,
0.2461924702,
0.1412172914,
0.9422408938,
0.1502570957,
0.567458272,
0.2488487363,
-0.2687249184,
-0.1841123402,
-0.3903898597,
0.2297725081,
-0.2901622355,
-0.3099544346,
-0.2106280178,
-0.1857152581,
0.8909943104,
0.6915437579,
-0.0169708692,
0.2185413688,
0.504951179,
0.144609198,
-0.6193827987,
0.3051990867,
-0.8337909579,
-0.1505402774,
-0.1963128299,
-0.1014997885,
-0.3954509199,
-0.1038446352,
0.1100607961,
-0.1792616546,
0.1197732165,
-0.2998226285,
0.8912994266,
0.5641620755,
-0.2750946581,
-0.1471583247,
-0.8091453314,
0.8402028084,
-1.1991138458,
0.3345154226,
0.3662763238,
0.2532553971,
-0.4893818796,
-0.5710141659,
-0.7947339416,
-0.2531764209,
-0.2525292039,
-0.2215374559,
-0.4302015305,
-0.0198622644,
0.3280419111,
0.3676531911,
-0.5332331061,
0.2487998605,
0.2230212241,
-0.046494659,
0.4679480195,
-0.060753569,
0.2113179862,
-0.125416711,
-0.2302136123,
-0.3658089936,
-0.6173846126,
0.0615303405,
0.4861077666,
0.2734590173,
-0.1753700972,
0.5642937422,
-0.1515208781,
0.7125481367,
-0.0157455634,
0.2648530006,
0.2642603219,
-0.327922821,
-0.3199017942,
-0.1674530208,
0.9173818827,
-0.0745714903,
0.038453754,
-0.2095566541,
-0.3071547747,
0.0024165499,
-0.0315421373,
-0.6542933583,
-0.0289252922,
-0.0752128959,
-0.3486540616,
-0.2149408609,
-0.0864019468,
-0.9513876438,
-0.6199918389,
-0.0695321783,
0.5913690925,
-0.140013054,
-0.428272754,
0.5959486961,
-0.1379866302,
0.1331578493,
-0.1281510144,
-1.1378002167,
0.5781803131,
1.0690329075,
0.818377316,
-0.161632359,
-0.4421167672,
-0.455098927,
-0.1721640229,
-0.0495609231,
0.5885332227,
-1.0087970495,
-0.0393237844,
0.0643527806,
-0.468187809,
0.035839133,
-0.7189667225,
0.5685114264,
-0.3792016208,
-0.0752894059,
-0.1520201415,
-0.6330005527,
-0.1566628814,
0.1113237068,
-0.6025762558,
1.0327278376,
0.1827839762,
-0.9257331491,
0.4808080494,
-0.7182543278,
0.1004180536,
0.0376553759,
-0.4783079326,
-0.4711335003,
0.6685935259,
0.0537315533,
0.5330637097,
-0.5176020861,
0.2325055003,
-0.6144101024,
-0.300611943,
0.4134522676,
-0.5107858181,
0.8337765932,
-0.2507732511,
-0.2499940395,
0.0930356309,
-1.0152441263,
-0.1433443874,
0.1515658796,
-0.3901676834,
-0.531393528,
0.1002541631,
-0.0349056311,
0.2063162923,
0.2845445573,
-0.5238613486,
0.1855185926,
-0.3503750563,
0.4252741039,
0.4726185203,
0.1224043593,
0.2063941956,
-0.1143511832,
0.4987265766,
-0.0665084347,
0.0393827669,
0.0710959807,
-0.4382016361,
-0.5011411309,
-0.2134872377,
0.2218222618,
0.1655013412,
-0.3632327318,
0.1534770876,
-0.2421224713,
-0.2948429286,
-0.5189579129,
0.229439646,
0.4766920209,
0.1857832521,
0.4712799489,
-0.3383191824,
-0.4502550662,
-1.028132081,
-0.5395457149,
-0.1276642233,
-0.3149839044,
0.1580736786,
0.404130578,
-0.2637911439,
0.8260720968,
-0.273042053,
0.1676455885,
-0.1973100156,
0.3011607528,
0.4397295713,
0.3842900097,
0.6641308665,
-0.5195284486,
-0.5590795279,
0.134358108,
-0.5511806607,
-0.2024092525,
-0.0306391064,
0.0280466042,
-0.0892923698,
0.4277702272,
-0.3146447539,
0.2960139215,
1.0583580732,
-0.6239618063,
0.6623126268,
-0.2226423323,
-0.1630887985,
-0.7933569551,
-0.3309339583,
-0.1009052768,
-0.1822602004,
-0.618270278,
0.3552359939,
0.0455121137,
0.2573575974,
-0.1748804897,
0.4275846481,
-0.2252909988,
-0.2934699059,
-0.1796355546,
-0.2325742692,
-0.0721414313,
0.4727803767,
-0.1202038899,
0.6718862057,
0.5271232128,
-0.4271097481,
0.0451238751,
0.21819444,
-0.329546541,
0.1182579994,
-0.8360815644,
0.2196948081,
-0.0956786126,
0.0357679278,
-0.9477789402,
-0.1586502343,
-0.0353421569,
-0.3402695954,
0.5160577297,
-0.3195486367,
-0.8129627705,
-0.0577412732,
-0.2315153778,
0.4734560251,
0.2991275191,
-0.5857439041,
0.7515404224,
0.2670193315,
-0.1041460633,
-0.6084614992,
-0.6665846705,
0.0390438698,
-0.2357289046,
-0.4650455117,
0.2448664904,
-0.001943017,
-0.3889539242,
-0.0183935091,
-0.2357868999,
-0.1832607836,
0.2485864609,
0.2944032252,
0.0955330208,
-0.3873950243,
0.2783299387,
0.1066357642,
0.06189733,
0.1119734719,
-0.2989085913,
0.8141847253,
-0.286152035,
-0.3435221016,
-0.2716189325,
0.238388598,
0.6545311213,
-0.3210857511,
0.8884496093,
0.291710943,
-0.2999342382,
-0.2567319274,
-0.5404560566,
-0.130208537,
-0.4804053903,
0.5894863605,
-0.3900066912,
-0.853395164,
0.51828897,
0.0733639374,
0.2735779881,
0.363158226,
0.5681816936,
0.21079956,
0.92201823,
0.8505530357,
-0.0503533594,
0.5293033719,
-0.0911843404,
0.0704433993,
-0.8045735359,
0.2404812127,
-0.655762732,
-0.1163643897,
-0.6635897756,
-0.4181937575,
0.0461564027,
0.154484719,
-0.3902633786,
0.4928548038,
-0.2569539845,
0.6000140905,
0.2721895576,
-0.3341187835,
0.4943853617,
0.0204014722,
-0.4041866958,
-0.1275018454,
-0.725928545,
-0.7234123945,
1.344720006,
0.4111173451,
0.4616980255,
0.2622893751,
0.5910525918,
0.0709854513,
0.2409903854,
-0.3865442276,
0.3271263242,
-0.682323277,
-0.555480957,
-0.1335608363,
-0.488802433,
-0.7756897807,
0.4108019471,
-0.5276870131,
-0.9495424628,
0.4809722304,
0.2075231969,
-0.2875518203,
0.3338154554,
-0.7322102189,
0.8307335377,
-0.1591223776,
-0.6006777287,
-0.2622186244,
-0.189468354,
0.2255796045,
-0.17639862,
-0.0308620408,
-0.0419791602,
0.1711636037,
0.3595185876,
-0.0066263559,
0.8078716397,
-0.0557184406,
-0.1636371464,
-0.1543315351,
0.1848504096,
0.4058067203,
0.1992603987,
-0.36647892,
0.4183231294,
0.1027837321,
-0.3602076173,
-0.8157230616,
0.7950630188,
-0.7334336042,
-0.5241699219,
-0.1864796579,
-0.6247672439,
-0.4663498998,
0.0957418531,
0.1728310883,
0.3886606097,
-0.0823707879,
0.451475352,
0.5835470557,
-0.4911621809,
0.3555008769,
0.4608954489,
-0.4423726797,
0.1902142465,
0.5083618164,
0.0121142669,
0.4280582964,
0.4891190231,
0.3798055351,
-0.0406076014,
-0.8309103251,
-0.0574465431,
0.3067917526,
-0.520476222,
-0.0968732461,
-0.5811199546,
-0.0299226269,
-0.2328760475,
0.1098652855,
-0.4699371755,
-0.2288308889,
-0.005243293,
0.0026146539,
0.2560048401,
1.1199923754,
0.1536570787,
0.383010149,
-0.4982829392,
0.0437541045,
0.3804904819,
0.7100205421,
0.0998906568,
-0.4970473945,
-0.0087115914,
0.069918111,
-0.2745350599,
-0.9998162389,
0.2088726908,
0.0788143352,
0.648347795,
0.2495102137,
-0.1860125214,
0.4245357811,
-0.2808098197,
0.7340300083,
0.0311557073,
-1.1966230869,
-0.0344799347,
-0.253739655,
0.4263301492,
0.5633931756,
0.1843715459,
-0.4483645558,
-0.6065943241,
-0.5911394954,
-0.8408156633,
0.4529258907,
0.257129401,
0.178140536,
0.2981449068,
0.4011183679,
0.4277777672,
0.2637408972,
-0.8709751964,
-0.0559962653,
-0.1972630173,
-0.1451828778,
-0.2332980186,
-0.5267938972,
0.1243366748,
-0.0395482592,
0.5000764728,
0.0731930658,
0.1234333962,
-0.1298287511,
-0.0958281532,
0.1386795789,
0.3541949987,
0.4112075865,
0.4235069752,
-0.2959748805,
0.2959265411,
0.2901921272,
-0.4743581116,
-0.1423120946,
0.1527468264,
-0.1815633774,
0.1144412681,
0.5226771235,
0.9490908384,
0.4290558696,
-0.6284220815,
0.4090422392,
-0.3627753854,
-0.2146263868,
-0.0371565446,
0.0519496985,
0.143703118,
0.4295771718,
0.1581315547,
0.2828296125,
0.188151136,
-0.5962706804,
0.1509806216,
0.444786787,
-0.3584734797,
-0.4825045764,
0.4140422642,
-0.2712372541,
-0.3604183197,
0.1680070907,
-0.3678212464,
-0.4906573594,
0.4670270085,
0.5625597239,
0.8433376551,
-0.0346031599,
0.1760817617,
0.2117910087,
0.1727832407,
-0.2465234697,
-0.0897819474,
-0.0438352413,
-0.9264574051,
-0.5553836226,
-0.7719422579,
-0.3092264235,
0.5452337265,
-0.7105429173,
0.0956194177,
-0.4770491719,
-0.0681937188,
0.1980625093,
-0.0053706076,
-0.7674354911,
-0.3527134359,
-0.0163958576,
0.4908322096,
-0.8800041676,
0.8370788097,
0.7497864962,
-0.3701860011,
-0.894026041,
0.5221514702,
-0.1594302356,
-0.4174605608,
0.5022501349,
-0.2098467648,
-0.2268750668,
-0.3388671279,
-0.505489707,
-1.0746324062,
0.6450722218,
0.792408824,
-0.7009959817,
0.0752503499,
0.2270956188,
0.843059361,
-0.3606923819,
0.1171382219,
0.8602281809,
0.3982948661,
-0.1861608177,
-1.0318166018,
0.0743596628,
-0.1029520631,
0.0160404053,
0.1186022386,
-0.2742318809,
0.9325649142,
0.1768567711,
-0.2707978785,
-0.1365540177,
0.4006463587,
0.2646751702,
0.0652336925,
0.3279423118,
0.3481339514,
0.5739709139,
0.0727473199,
1.0977050066,
-0.1989856362,
0.4938970208,
1.7098196745,
-0.2678680122,
1.0855413675,
0.5929960012,
-0.4072359502,
0.4035162032,
-0.0217281263,
0.0593236648,
0.2790448666,
0.371942699,
-0.21148628,
-0.1326504946,
0.1701199859,
-0.2848287523,
0.6652081013,
0.340041697,
-0.3630684316,
-0.3073334992,
-0.1001511812,
0.1573212296,
0.4676622152,
-0.0035217693,
0.6071085334,
-0.1476080865,
-0.5326172709,
0.6661744714,
-0.067900382,
1.0214757919,
-0.7199807167,
-0.0836789757,
-0.1093875915,
0.3911049068,
-0.1301106662,
-0.7279528379,
0.4088636637,
0.1433271319,
-0.2274003327,
-0.3009212017,
0.4341387451,
-0.3462383151,
-0.4855147302,
0.7644123435,
0.1937642843,
-0.0945486948,
-0.0741996467,
-0.4673686326,
0.1699491739,
0.103120558,
-0.1514575928,
0.4425033331,
0.2794524431,
0.0532030873,
0.4765321314,
0.4638446569,
0.3403777778,
0.3657591641,
0.0128788529,
0.7229158282,
-0.1971872151,
-0.095358558,
-0.9337177873,
0.2343163341,
-0.1790771186,
-0.5098679066,
0.8323941827,
0.385851264,
1.0647354126,
-0.1133592054,
0.6419668794,
0.166240707,
0.4774187207,
-0.3092330694,
0.7438462973,
-0.5738051534,
0.5663001537,
-0.3150058687,
-0.8902632594,
-0.5571732521,
0.6167131066,
-0.4961514473,
-0.2368263006,
0.5461607575,
0.8371300697,
-0.0621836372,
-0.2186237276,
0.4309443831,
0.6337968707,
0.5323897004,
0.2936067879,
0.6912145019,
-0.2591953874,
0.343267113,
-0.1990647763,
-0.2239168435,
-0.1747821569,
-1.0209846497,
-0.5805582404,
-0.6852645874,
-0.1657471359,
-0.2205968946,
0.1989310384,
0.8524211049,
0.4695889652,
-0.8820688128,
-0.301230669,
-0.322637558,
0.0713040009,
-0.4531489313,
-0.1766699851,
0.1768592298,
-0.1469365358,
-0.623272419,
0.3722170293,
0.2890273929,
-0.0567207076,
-0.3285808265,
0.0105483215,
-0.2327317446,
0.4302982688,
0.4136499763,
0.2749013603,
-0.5132369995,
-0.2632866502,
-0.3032938242,
0.1459155679,
0.0943376571,
0.906221509,
-0.6012473106,
0.413043201,
0.6537512541,
0.6650820971,
0.4755836725,
-0.3936118484,
0.8166789412,
-0.8340117931,
0.1575307101,
0.2464328706,
0.599276185,
0.2857634127,
-0.3078559041,
0.2332811654,
-0.2903499007,
-0.5762578249,
-1.0090689659,
0.5133554935,
-0.720962584,
-0.3173117042,
1.2211974859,
-0.2009820193,
0.3013784289,
-0.1447943598,
0.0937643051,
0.1855382472,
-0.4003908038,
0.8546970487,
1.048756361,
0.0497968271,
0.0806411132,
-0.7351518273,
0.6451807618,
0.6841463447,
-0.4309867024,
0.2922146022,
0.1535664201,
0.3407375813,
0.1323140711,
0.2095103413,
-0.278219372,
0.0023811697,
0.1617129743,
-0.01288707,
-0.0718916431,
-0.1289613694,
-0.811116457,
0.321549803,
0.2919739485,
0.0648667738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04155v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04155v3
|
Black-Box Prompt Optimization: Aligning Large Language Models without Model Training
| 2023-11-07T17:31:50 | 2024-06-21T06:06:07 |
Jiale Cheng, Xiao Liu, Kehan Zheng, Pei Ke, Hongning Wang, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive success in various
applications. However, these models are often not well aligned with human
intents, which calls for additional treatments on them; that is, the alignment
problem. To make LLMs better follow user instructions, existing alignment
methods primarily focus on further training them. However, the extra training
of LLMs is usually expensive in terms of GPU computing; even worse, some LLMs
are not accessible for user-demanded training, such as GPTs. In this work, we
take a different perspective -- Black-Box Prompt Optimization (BPO) -- to
perform alignments. The idea is to optimize user prompts to suit LLMs' input
understanding, so as to best realize users' intents without updating LLMs'
parameters. BPO leverages human preferences to optimize prompts, thus making it
superior to LLM (e.g., ChatGPT) as a prompt engineer. Moreover, BPO is
model-agnostic, and the empirical results demonstrate that the BPO-aligned
ChatGPT yields a 22% increase in the win rate against its original version and
10% for GPT-4. Notably, the BPO-aligned LLMs can outperform the same models
aligned by PPO and DPO, and it also brings additional performance gains when
combining BPO with PPO or DPO. Code and datasets are released at
https://github.com/thu-coai/BPO.
|
[
-0.1990415156,
-0.6682835817,
0.8830682635,
0.1138409674,
-0.2886235118,
0.242285639,
-0.1970872432,
-0.2943015695,
-0.1950403601,
0.3465508223,
-0.8558327556,
-0.3290899694,
-0.3262931705,
0.1085435599,
0.2532688379,
1.0375380516,
0.0302068572,
-0.0122564984,
-0.2458964735,
0.2845019102,
-0.9348908663,
-0.312482655,
-0.8497875929,
-0.3433963358,
0.4287239313,
0.291834414,
0.8221834302,
0.7673085332,
0.1723224521,
0.3251668811,
-0.1234669164,
0.2426003367,
-0.5172089934,
0.2209640741,
-0.1798223257,
-0.2722631693,
-0.4016907811,
-0.2110542059,
0.4771287441,
0.469853431,
-0.1593649834,
-0.1247360483,
0.0700943768,
0.4973135889,
-0.5364120603,
-0.0282583851,
-0.5624824166,
-0.0034005323,
0.0971628129,
-0.1916179657,
-0.393751204,
-0.5167292953,
0.2496065497,
-0.7726282477,
0.0437072814,
0.4347398579,
0.9901812673,
0.4491516054,
-0.1998554617,
-0.0575668216,
-0.5518154502,
0.8818387389,
-0.8127441406,
0.1618683636,
-0.154800728,
0.3692630529,
-0.4647814333,
-0.0095901825,
-0.6591318846,
-0.1371388584,
0.0614714436,
0.1876719743,
-0.3117410243,
0.3314282,
0.322637856,
0.1105195582,
-0.8023249507,
0.601683259,
-0.1315170079,
-0.2154881358,
0.5521842241,
0.1585858762,
0.2663348913,
-0.1241889223,
-0.5389279723,
0.0764104128,
-0.5552946925,
0.2388396114,
0.5048652887,
0.4007034302,
-0.0644968227,
0.7589440942,
0.1482137889,
0.9557640553,
0.4148192406,
-0.1694809645,
0.1226485968,
-0.3881162703,
-0.1644623429,
0.1882174164,
0.9436116815,
0.4939483702,
0.4363533854,
-0.2643226981,
-0.4507113397,
0.2026236802,
0.4516093731,
-0.8431898355,
0.1918095499,
0.3882748783,
-0.0867678598,
-0.2457081228,
-0.2925220728,
-0.8008375764,
-0.5520871878,
-0.5810970664,
0.4265342951,
-0.2594323456,
0.0207497142,
0.0645114258,
-0.1107218638,
0.3315416873,
0.4782401025,
-0.9430491924,
0.0408001952,
1.0721697807,
0.9815063477,
-0.1757960171,
-0.0578071773,
-0.9276052713,
0.0930039808,
-0.3758710623,
0.6509080529,
-0.6302105784,
-0.3823996484,
0.1084088758,
-0.1122470424,
0.0302016903,
-0.264809072,
0.6699244976,
-0.4789824486,
0.4769496918,
-0.2235552967,
-0.6784310341,
0.0649272427,
0.1465408504,
-0.2998004854,
0.9027941823,
-0.0222304538,
-0.4745247066,
0.17645289,
-0.6439080238,
-0.1250129789,
0.1548290849,
-0.2853017151,
-0.5439938903,
0.2702960968,
0.389008075,
0.3813266754,
-0.3622550368,
0.3654237092,
-0.4473246634,
-0.4918330312,
0.2566706836,
-0.1158039868,
0.762994647,
0.1812621802,
-0.4313177466,
0.361190021,
-0.5102243423,
-0.1628764123,
0.0500041284,
-0.0206572842,
-0.1656312943,
0.0224832557,
-0.3128015101,
0.2312478721,
0.3817225695,
-0.6470752954,
0.6203097105,
-0.5629777908,
0.3465072513,
1.0741889477,
-0.2189808637,
0.585203886,
-0.3296328187,
0.7896223664,
-0.1937912852,
0.1992160678,
0.0153056793,
-0.6002848148,
-0.273057431,
-0.414398104,
0.097400479,
0.8641063571,
-0.5142660141,
0.7452645898,
-0.2341760844,
-0.254357338,
-0.7685409784,
0.1982670873,
0.3702743351,
0.9268255234,
0.0512591749,
-0.1643951684,
-0.279842943,
-1.0198140144,
0.0740294382,
-0.151811108,
-0.1545925736,
0.3033788204,
0.0276309904,
-0.2048575133,
0.976983428,
-0.7106351256,
-0.0675295144,
-0.0493959375,
-0.1268089116,
0.4499280453,
0.4590678811,
0.4960025251,
-0.3863016069,
-0.4383987784,
0.2511042058,
-0.5052091479,
-0.5155340433,
-0.0987716764,
-0.33380422,
0.3660061955,
0.2312265784,
-0.7570002079,
0.1084014326,
0.6148821115,
-0.1475291848,
0.686468482,
-0.2409867793,
0.0455560721,
-1.0972708464,
0.1186272576,
0.1857410371,
-0.2771051228,
-0.6270594001,
-0.3245772421,
0.101042822,
-0.6208903193,
-0.0640579015,
0.8429013491,
-0.6507788897,
-0.0037972536,
-0.4786420763,
0.3892385662,
0.0617938638,
0.6939218044,
0.0436328948,
1.0862078667,
0.647865057,
-0.2968301475,
0.2683347166,
0.3030485809,
-0.0420150459,
0.741586864,
-0.798488915,
0.372458756,
-0.2914290428,
0.0065837768,
-1.2537316084,
0.0933779255,
0.4333946407,
-0.3748758137,
0.4860614538,
-0.3591946363,
-0.3153866231,
-0.268024981,
-0.351095289,
0.306224674,
0.7385254502,
-0.5618527532,
0.4599743485,
0.2190623432,
-0.3052006662,
-1.0169302225,
-0.1508609951,
-0.1351809651,
-0.3039258122,
-0.5237956643,
0.1958211958,
-0.1622460783,
0.0632538423,
-0.2013954371,
-0.2080851644,
0.2706220746,
0.1051690802,
0.1595238,
0.6523940563,
-0.2260148972,
0.0988433808,
-0.0659051687,
-0.139124915,
-0.15472655,
-0.6413656473,
0.4962187409,
0.0026669626,
-0.1617498398,
-0.6772943139,
0.3690116704,
0.2010997683,
-0.1838134229,
0.6379817128,
0.3982309103,
-0.2048406005,
-0.0981581286,
-0.6980311275,
-0.0141912363,
-0.5383399725,
0.163528949,
-0.2387732714,
-0.7973614335,
0.2381334454,
0.027115874,
0.2569903433,
0.0031488675,
0.4798379242,
-0.144650206,
1.2028361559,
0.6561291218,
-0.1849856824,
0.7468181252,
0.2968737185,
0.2990306616,
-0.7318400145,
-0.0350278579,
-0.6231598854,
-0.3338807523,
-0.526137054,
-0.1473777592,
0.176396504,
0.1619228423,
-0.3169955611,
0.3634120226,
-0.7798574567,
0.4511421323,
0.536093533,
0.004754059,
0.1013524756,
0.0041224128,
-0.0122210383,
-0.0496079586,
-0.6460331082,
-0.7283229232,
0.9689669609,
0.2616998553,
0.7762930393,
0.0418081954,
0.6871897578,
0.1048791483,
0.0910999924,
-0.8925936818,
0.489592582,
0.1173234433,
-0.3539175689,
-0.3423535526,
-0.6357167363,
-1.2453268766,
0.0883074179,
-0.2729683518,
-1.0171093941,
0.1307059079,
0.4430274665,
-0.4951441884,
-0.0005865726,
-1.095279336,
1.1712315083,
-0.4642010331,
-0.4086786807,
0.1462872177,
-0.5344512463,
0.157744661,
-0.1386564523,
-0.0314747244,
-0.1847456098,
-0.3685376346,
0.3383284509,
-0.4420708716,
0.7520521879,
-0.2743216157,
-0.2275627553,
-0.0808375478,
-0.1115305126,
0.7812440991,
-0.1192321628,
0.0564943887,
-0.1018000022,
-0.2286700606,
-0.6108699441,
-0.8259862065,
0.7207165956,
-0.8657134771,
-0.9279423356,
-0.4584873021,
-0.70569098,
-0.2967214882,
0.1311900765,
0.0605745129,
0.4140528738,
0.0057841903,
-0.3471150696,
0.5903813839,
-0.2344504893,
0.3906105757,
0.3217859566,
-0.0967719927,
-0.4700416327,
0.7799789906,
-0.2357793003,
0.3476566076,
0.6038489938,
0.3067337871,
-0.5833420157,
-0.775939405,
-0.6343325377,
0.5561876893,
-0.3211118877,
-0.2519537508,
-0.41858235,
0.069205232,
-0.4098060727,
-0.398422718,
-0.0582782179,
-0.2748344839,
-0.3227989078,
0.09883596,
0.2478681356,
0.4022372961,
0.2286066711,
0.7348816395,
-0.5651528835,
0.0839733928,
0.2282376885,
0.3381561935,
-0.1115880534,
-0.453260839,
-0.0443225019,
-0.0925106406,
-0.6197129488,
-0.998583436,
0.2997077107,
-0.1101636142,
0.568636477,
0.4564954937,
-0.0119692273,
0.849429965,
-0.7208047509,
0.492010206,
0.3710751235,
-1.0018345118,
0.5984047651,
-0.3735499382,
0.3345579207,
0.5612354875,
0.4791635275,
-0.5343592763,
-0.2078107893,
-0.4437764883,
-0.5267374516,
0.8879185319,
0.1190064177,
-0.0311535783,
0.318602711,
0.5284684896,
0.1042022482,
0.3600152135,
-0.6222243905,
-0.0603072196,
-0.1075584963,
-0.5404956937,
-0.2645511031,
-0.1468847096,
-0.2291852087,
0.3007693887,
0.8500181437,
-0.2602769732,
0.2203503251,
-0.0579462759,
-0.0239443481,
-0.1378970593,
0.3471848071,
0.6871666908,
0.7425366044,
-0.2720849216,
-0.261420846,
-0.1132794097,
-0.1965663135,
0.3505171239,
0.5664202571,
-0.3483375907,
-0.2295081913,
0.0517133325,
0.9629246593,
0.1008711234,
-0.7513014078,
0.6705699563,
-0.0047269301,
0.1654281318,
-0.0276995227,
0.1417493522,
-0.0003434961,
0.4588691592,
0.2100082338,
-0.1502908617,
-0.0036505186,
-0.2822760642,
-0.1036674753,
0.8798757195,
-0.2364142686,
-0.272970289,
0.6814930439,
0.4227096438,
-0.699403882,
0.584094584,
-0.1293442696,
-0.4258110821,
0.2615402639,
0.5845931768,
0.9193527699,
-0.2648870349,
0.1366685182,
0.2905405164,
0.220810771,
0.0154515989,
0.0425442494,
-0.0208430234,
-0.6726629138,
-0.7333801985,
-0.4600933194,
-0.5823070407,
0.118702203,
-0.2742393613,
0.6853047609,
-0.4898039401,
-0.2443279624,
0.1080021635,
0.3794797659,
-0.5389558077,
-0.1732794344,
0.236349076,
0.67781353,
-0.7616984248,
0.5393129587,
0.6538285017,
-0.2634249628,
-0.6724672914,
-0.1801421195,
0.1013892218,
-1.0118587017,
0.1829265505,
0.2761527896,
0.1927437335,
0.0187186655,
-0.4170955718,
-0.6453374624,
0.8849381804,
0.6534301043,
-1.024471879,
-0.2733699977,
-0.1020955369,
0.3626132011,
-0.3519539237,
0.4049915671,
0.3344271183,
0.3814847469,
0.0930288881,
-0.9546897411,
0.192104876,
-0.006002469,
0.1549744755,
0.5217436552,
-0.4570326507,
0.2994213402,
-0.2005181909,
-0.3561617732,
0.059803322,
0.5639874935,
0.6711004376,
0.1659489423,
0.5503017306,
0.4417926073,
0.8997144103,
-0.1778408438,
1.1113350391,
-0.1021492034,
0.0678821802,
0.9377017021,
-0.364700079,
0.4041020274,
0.4838011265,
-0.0785184652,
0.1974482238,
0.8277646899,
-0.1150205433,
0.2927619219,
0.2515026629,
-0.1169143543,
-0.2148504257,
-0.0351327211,
-0.2375088036,
0.0409717038,
-0.0634985268,
0.0290929247,
-0.1481418461,
-0.263843447,
0.1903204024,
0.1892810315,
-0.2686519325,
0.9109871387,
-0.0091799274,
-0.9732701182,
0.7119873166,
-0.3304507732,
0.7081081271,
-0.8195153475,
0.1952241659,
-0.2436423749,
0.0788135901,
-0.0632317439,
-0.7122748494,
-0.0961554796,
0.1421234608,
-0.1750629246,
-0.1727413088,
0.3568019867,
-0.5092365742,
-0.3685365319,
0.0909283385,
0.4065650105,
0.0942110792,
-0.0573432334,
-0.8026751876,
0.0748184994,
0.066454567,
0.010709784,
0.3689351976,
0.5913515687,
-0.0213916656,
0.6235699058,
0.6447895765,
0.2061326057,
-0.1424731165,
0.0523399077,
0.5991643071,
-0.6701097488,
-0.4782549441,
-1.0639201403,
0.4547235072,
-0.2513348758,
-0.3363812864,
0.5269178748,
0.7135212421,
0.5260381699,
-0.0529140942,
0.6747136116,
0.4154336154,
0.2114227712,
-0.5593516827,
0.1848458499,
-0.5994102359,
0.1837141067,
-0.4554773569,
-1.1555874348,
-0.0859145746,
0.2831132412,
-0.4552481771,
-0.124104619,
0.3779113293,
1.0250571966,
0.028254712,
-0.0813774541,
0.2537407875,
-0.129712373,
0.4292758405,
0.7199027538,
0.9716414213,
0.0289989784,
0.7070342302,
-0.0183842219,
-0.5594432354,
-0.206024304,
-1.2103409767,
-0.9464034438,
-0.4289640486,
-0.3403455913,
-0.2789191306,
0.1950846612,
1.1640105247,
0.6719893217,
-0.6216678023,
-0.3947003782,
0.1181025207,
0.2288376391,
-0.3263975978,
-0.2086461782,
0.2674805522,
-0.6675745249,
-1.0411040783,
0.2528059483,
0.26325652,
0.4179801345,
0.0282837525,
-0.0895847008,
-0.0597624443,
0.0733985007,
0.425625205,
0.3682166934,
-0.8237584829,
-0.3167296648,
0.1574733704,
-0.066270411,
0.4145794511,
0.6641770005,
-0.6090137362,
0.4159263968,
0.4307110906,
1.1162037849,
0.370616138,
0.4960521758,
1.0571266413,
-0.777493,
0.004775322,
0.1994291544,
0.3764252067,
0.4855544567,
-0.6162337065,
0.2311376333,
-0.0031113729,
-0.8674527407,
-0.8512388468,
0.2299550623,
-1.40704,
-0.2464228272,
1.0422012806,
0.2128022164,
-0.429656148,
0.06512288,
-0.5737142563,
0.1712025404,
-0.9198992252,
0.8051273227,
0.7643288374,
-0.2262174636,
-0.2470246553,
-0.4387872815,
0.5760003328,
0.5391797423,
-0.7648413181,
0.132294625,
0.7095195651,
0.1302311718,
0.0598769672,
0.50976789,
0.1697065234,
0.1523745507,
-0.4515901506,
0.1743623614,
-0.1705615371,
-0.0004016392,
-0.6992576122,
0.010794377,
0.1010271683,
-0.3866717815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04142v1
|
What is Lost in Knowledge Distillation?
| 2023-11-07T17:13:40 | 2023-11-07T17:13:40 |
Manas Mohanty, Tanya Roosta, Peyman Passban
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deep neural networks (DNNs) have improved NLP tasks significantly, but
training and maintaining such networks could be costly. Model compression
techniques, such as, knowledge distillation (KD), have been proposed to address
the issue; however, the compression process could be lossy. Motivated by this,
our work investigates how a distilled student model differs from its teacher,
if the distillation process causes any information losses, and if the loss
follows a specific pattern. Our experiments aim to shed light on the type of
tasks might be less or more sensitive to KD by reporting data points on the
contribution of different factors, such as the number of layers or attention
heads. Results such as ours could be utilized when determining effective and
efficient configurations to achieve optimal information transfers between
larger (teacher) and smaller (student) models.
|
[
-0.2686145008,
-0.4734531343,
0.7412288189,
-0.0359869748,
-0.2066170871,
0.0448439196,
-0.1566497833,
-0.0615573339,
-0.1872106045,
0.2102196813,
-0.4903433323,
-0.021093376,
-1.0882905722,
-0.0060678232,
-0.6974911094,
1.0296481848,
0.0436918549,
0.073449038,
-0.5255654454,
0.2257496119,
-0.7569254637,
-0.7012227774,
-0.9155952334,
-0.8069294691,
0.6978697181,
0.3379690349,
0.16096057,
0.3789733648,
0.6423581839,
0.2518089116,
-0.4684783816,
-0.1430801451,
-0.7753405571,
0.1385779232,
-0.2961496711,
-0.8350583315,
0.0787798762,
0.1606279016,
0.0977705866,
1.0654617548,
-0.1976121068,
0.329153955,
0.588010788,
1.233678937,
-0.683283031,
0.2253399491,
-0.5583665371,
0.2346964628,
0.2924512625,
-0.1830181777,
-0.334785223,
-0.1374712288,
0.5077364445,
-0.2453480065,
0.5114593506,
-0.3892439604,
0.5492705107,
0.8781223893,
-0.4715230465,
-0.3487392962,
-0.8776637912,
0.4538613856,
-0.6811626554,
-0.0121975075,
0.4381256998,
0.349984467,
-0.1989326477,
-0.7870607972,
-0.5886039138,
0.1323480755,
-0.1661898792,
0.0181271099,
-0.216813609,
-0.0461496823,
0.338049233,
0.4883847833,
-0.1325069666,
-0.0830092132,
-0.4825152755,
0.2220602781,
0.4904810488,
0.05857132,
-0.0643707439,
-0.0292889234,
-0.3639350235,
-0.4884309769,
-0.2993931174,
0.1180352867,
0.4218201041,
0.165317297,
0.0762099922,
0.4528343379,
-0.2756896317,
0.7271146774,
0.3013674915,
-0.3906831741,
-0.2154458016,
-0.1855296344,
-0.3092437983,
0.3584104478,
0.3811815381,
0.5832551122,
0.3445531428,
-0.0011850516,
-0.102663599,
-0.1917103529,
0.2048010677,
-1.009393096,
-1.0374547243,
-0.2429301441,
-0.5888254642,
-0.6484092474,
-0.1970125437,
-0.2107022256,
-0.7059306502,
-0.6988049746,
0.5546111465,
-0.1581014842,
-0.2821691036,
0.4310391545,
-0.8058351874,
-0.6028831601,
0.4149453938,
-0.8900980949,
0.3083387315,
0.332759589,
0.8696882725,
-0.2125227898,
-0.0031778601,
0.0414812192,
-0.1735986918,
-0.058627259,
0.1530906558,
-0.2444001883,
-0.1885236949,
-0.5718904734,
-0.0765232816,
-0.1510965526,
-0.6728119254,
0.3026153445,
-0.4745767415,
0.0701993853,
-0.6986489892,
-0.7451064587,
-0.5779480934,
0.0311637316,
-0.7947182059,
0.8341200352,
0.1914395243,
-1.0161246061,
0.4549187124,
-0.2112063468,
-0.1706497669,
-0.2089796066,
-0.0520406216,
-0.153146863,
0.5138320327,
-0.1264225692,
0.6942232251,
-0.2536732852,
0.313551873,
-0.2320177257,
-0.2919781208,
0.4190448225,
-0.525287807,
1.0126879215,
0.0856713802,
-0.2485693395,
-0.6607731581,
-0.9157070518,
-0.2642451823,
0.2352777719,
-0.6630991697,
-0.8797259927,
0.0360009857,
-0.183405295,
0.17196244,
-0.052386079,
-0.5205102563,
0.7000555396,
0.2758331001,
0.6425376534,
0.6571748257,
0.2207935005,
0.4768643975,
-0.3444984257,
0.3308027387,
0.4203658104,
-0.1047338396,
0.2901931703,
-0.5444675088,
-0.8936270475,
0.1489929557,
0.4566897452,
0.3458179235,
-0.8812861443,
-0.0321312323,
-0.1394547075,
-0.4747588336,
-0.4537325203,
0.1658833921,
0.1468205899,
1.0649102926,
0.09430971,
-0.0655423328,
-0.4287312925,
-0.8577154875,
-0.0768849105,
-0.1833780408,
-0.0960876718,
0.0368737876,
0.5129839778,
0.2696843743,
0.832033515,
-0.8114306927,
-0.3875032663,
-0.2210155129,
0.2899750769,
0.4350365102,
0.5887729526,
0.8550539613,
-0.799721241,
-0.4987170696,
-0.2632713616,
-0.5284561515,
0.0623437017,
-0.3281117082,
0.081696786,
-0.2536813319,
0.4781737328,
-0.5235285759,
0.772957921,
0.6379435658,
-0.1324915737,
0.3589919209,
-0.2461175174,
0.2537815273,
-0.9458188415,
-0.0746036693,
-0.1795648336,
-0.0557690598,
-0.6313028336,
-0.3157252669,
-0.069529593,
-0.0191023685,
-0.2629565597,
-0.1199427471,
-0.4079397619,
0.0585255474,
-0.5592222214,
-0.1176145598,
0.5403025746,
0.5939148068,
0.0211202763,
0.6139714122,
0.4762710333,
-0.8748847842,
0.5637644529,
0.0664497241,
-0.4253016412,
0.5534199476,
-0.8343672752,
0.3498947024,
-0.4398559332,
0.079737924,
-1.0631204844,
-0.0645730123,
-0.002566362,
-0.3600485325,
0.5467416644,
-0.4630073905,
-0.2972836494,
-0.4055530131,
-0.0774222612,
0.3423449397,
0.5637938976,
-0.4024859667,
0.1709573716,
0.085713543,
0.0303456746,
-0.4944574237,
-1.2415007353,
-0.0164815858,
-0.4743034542,
-0.4661926329,
0.4266128242,
-0.0028911454,
-0.2123362869,
0.3937438726,
-0.3287384212,
-0.4035099149,
0.5356860161,
0.2103922665,
-0.0453557745,
-0.1082810014,
0.3913656771,
0.0986092389,
0.3014152944,
0.2894358933,
-0.4603449404,
0.3968624175,
0.2535329461,
-0.2009391189,
-0.7650502324,
0.1988674998,
0.3970320821,
0.3342627287,
1.0261253119,
0.3109508455,
-0.2769105136,
-0.4912073016,
-0.3851051033,
-0.4426470995,
-0.4522928596,
0.3309400678,
-0.3542740047,
-0.5785973668,
0.5147177577,
-0.1015090123,
-0.210811764,
0.3918830454,
0.1972681582,
-0.290815413,
0.7416884303,
0.804485321,
-0.0788392946,
0.286101371,
-0.4900905192,
0.1423158348,
-0.6572881937,
-0.3777802587,
-0.5499629974,
-1.023175478,
-0.2227699161,
-0.1442558318,
0.323407203,
0.5073312521,
0.0617542937,
0.3804044724,
-0.9228919148,
0.702837348,
1.0183922052,
0.1789106131,
0.3432084918,
-0.1110121235,
0.290836364,
0.0166759044,
-1.1192961931,
-0.204761669,
1.0314360857,
0.1477703303,
0.981492281,
0.0456955582,
0.9241373539,
0.2750696838,
-0.2631752789,
-0.8135463595,
0.2937413454,
-0.2684721351,
-0.5680975914,
-0.3216257393,
-0.5516629815,
-0.7594220042,
-0.0396888778,
-0.1012596041,
-0.4908216,
0.5772174597,
0.2684203982,
-0.5181547403,
0.4696669579,
-0.9807469249,
0.6854140162,
-0.0554876812,
-0.0414592251,
0.0627784953,
-0.510320425,
0.5447662473,
-0.1555510312,
-0.2565235496,
-0.0740462989,
0.5164756775,
0.9274700284,
-0.4648410082,
0.7920432687,
-0.4592346251,
0.0599284731,
0.3193382025,
0.1826430708,
0.2363494188,
0.0026254009,
0.1586145461,
-0.0248550531,
0.0919388607,
-0.1966153085,
-0.9082680345,
0.6189401746,
-0.7548771501,
-0.7225579619,
-0.2454917878,
-0.6785968542,
0.2230825722,
-0.108156085,
0.3345046639,
0.2133259177,
0.345957309,
0.5453807116,
0.8803145885,
-0.0434017032,
0.6560752988,
0.2222299576,
0.1059036851,
0.3279565275,
0.5595772266,
0.6075635552,
0.3426968157,
0.1556353271,
0.4014847875,
-0.0519937128,
-0.7555438876,
-0.3883320093,
-0.1975207627,
-0.8883211613,
-0.3662101328,
-0.3854762018,
-0.1786316484,
-0.5335190892,
0.124434948,
-0.456033498,
-0.7785347104,
-0.8673720956,
-0.2043913603,
0.5507822037,
0.9016256332,
0.0535444766,
0.3404782712,
-0.6450697184,
0.240453735,
0.6065542102,
0.0585958995,
0.2926880121,
-0.6808282733,
-0.1289701313,
0.2605654895,
-0.159466818,
-0.9578542113,
0.2519766986,
0.5327128768,
0.3271434605,
0.4677549005,
0.5750082731,
0.6793521643,
-0.2329317778,
0.7071584463,
0.2941494584,
-0.6419733167,
0.5380676985,
0.0695540681,
0.4527175725,
0.8818668127,
0.513174355,
-0.5036587119,
-0.0965262055,
-0.5288378596,
-0.6711553931,
0.773966074,
0.1439231187,
0.1548620164,
0.2340321392,
0.6236459017,
0.1834391952,
0.3200902343,
-0.5060258508,
-0.4586741328,
-0.1299358755,
-0.127039969,
0.0557125993,
-0.3458161354,
-0.1563150734,
-0.4460214972,
0.4897940159,
0.2629493475,
-0.0940642506,
0.4376832843,
-0.0243254341,
0.3919349015,
-0.1673343778,
0.3068607748,
0.4591101408,
-0.1721429825,
0.6830157638,
-0.0372981094,
-0.6847474575,
0.4646977484,
-0.126026094,
-0.2802110016,
0.1731175333,
0.3837284446,
1.0616458654,
0.0377889238,
-0.1743758768,
0.5457491279,
-0.2701334357,
-0.4696798027,
-0.1625803113,
0.3589800298,
0.3851131201,
0.4306226671,
0.5024669766,
0.3146263659,
0.5127952695,
-0.5863255262,
0.0557287075,
-0.1531262696,
-0.2415227592,
-0.1602450311,
0.7346740961,
0.0847829431,
-0.0449895188,
0.8640032411,
-0.1750990599,
-0.5296596289,
0.7462969422,
0.1397782415,
0.6933107376,
-0.1424788684,
0.2016431689,
0.3188341558,
0.185026601,
-0.4101033211,
-0.0632900521,
-0.1582228243,
-0.4742243588,
-0.3281442821,
-0.5583786964,
0.0252325144,
0.241570279,
-0.9566264153,
-0.0251104869,
-0.1843791157,
-0.5512126088,
0.434507072,
-0.1444885284,
-0.8809147477,
0.1554662734,
0.0216672085,
0.6097164154,
-0.9268679023,
0.8637459278,
0.4591593444,
-0.2622800767,
-1.1108244658,
-0.4190053344,
-0.0159777142,
-0.3898575902,
1.3212339878,
-0.0364941694,
0.095212996,
-0.0579550304,
-0.3354157209,
-0.9457399249,
1.1090416908,
0.6309021711,
-0.8578770161,
-0.3256721199,
0.2370455414,
0.4229351878,
-0.1225276366,
-0.2045155913,
0.6683576107,
0.2632186711,
0.2705594301,
-0.9277532697,
-0.0468729027,
-0.2070746273,
0.1284167618,
-0.0403600596,
-0.2957260907,
1.325887084,
-0.1189837381,
-0.3923608661,
-0.4912078083,
0.2125483602,
-0.433755517,
0.5319525599,
0.5527585745,
0.7584002614,
0.7589128017,
-0.2024846524,
0.9916709065,
-0.0187228471,
0.3309066594,
1.3558773994,
0.0461784191,
0.4225893915,
0.7483127713,
-0.2758292556,
0.1533862948,
0.5256231427,
-0.0442804173,
0.7681772709,
0.5367183685,
-0.1410289407,
0.0163920019,
-0.0279229917,
-0.3176244199,
0.5266678929,
-0.1376456171,
-0.4293942451,
-0.0056174225,
0.3351599276,
0.0553913526,
0.0136772785,
-0.3208777905,
0.8983767033,
0.1380214393,
-0.7705804706,
0.8391306996,
-0.2737343013,
0.4534784853,
-0.0865847692,
-0.0551922731,
-0.3099255562,
0.331179589,
-0.2115247548,
-0.6863532066,
0.3808914125,
-0.3186296225,
-0.50165236,
-0.3318660259,
0.7729178667,
-0.6937396526,
-0.4065931439,
0.0797602832,
0.2904981375,
0.2957996428,
-0.4471335113,
-0.3739342988,
-0.0764496475,
0.1458186507,
-0.5025772452,
0.3848911524,
0.5587238073,
0.3108889759,
0.6327030063,
0.3551315665,
0.1086463109,
0.3218761384,
0.0959870145,
1.1347301006,
-0.1273813397,
-0.0837350786,
-0.7931793332,
0.369469583,
-0.2701249421,
-0.3534394801,
1.0156271458,
0.2144217342,
0.9825374484,
-0.4043177068,
0.6007984877,
-0.0038584175,
0.28881675,
-0.5669732094,
0.9474656582,
-0.4500944912,
0.313397646,
-0.152048707,
-0.9470997453,
0.2330245823,
0.4645397663,
0.1676771492,
-0.2264439911,
0.6690273285,
0.2026570737,
0.0538133979,
-0.050704807,
0.2690358162,
-0.0417710952,
0.1637254208,
0.840801239,
0.8200950623,
-0.418335855,
0.350091517,
-0.9461885095,
0.0051709684,
-0.2808795571,
-0.8690539598,
-1.0818635225,
-0.8886022568,
-0.6491620541,
-0.0132164443,
-0.0328191221,
0.2785329223,
0.8339847326,
-0.3962744474,
0.09486527,
-0.3539431095,
0.0260075256,
-0.2154522836,
-0.2004066855,
0.3803635836,
-0.1281130612,
-0.7414808869,
0.3001230061,
-0.2647534907,
0.4572757185,
-0.2282672971,
0.3329854012,
-0.1422868371,
-0.1932742745,
0.3840773702,
-0.2331735194,
-0.278773576,
-0.2671729326,
0.0133204591,
0.122182101,
-0.3776830733,
0.889010191,
-0.7527371645,
0.44006899,
0.7263222337,
0.6952233315,
0.6682722569,
-0.0703007951,
0.3508820832,
-1.1456904411,
0.3195440769,
0.3304995,
0.1675664783,
0.2175744623,
-0.5739020705,
0.6052328348,
0.2686652541,
-0.6660817862,
-0.8944641352,
-0.0301250573,
-0.8836073279,
-0.6905135512,
0.9350631237,
-0.4713431597,
-0.1276808083,
0.033616446,
-0.2607888281,
0.368394196,
-0.2624921501,
1.0480473042,
1.0590586662,
-0.1343093365,
-0.0882390067,
-0.7108981013,
0.8098653555,
0.2476541698,
-0.2771750093,
0.1626264304,
0.4957540035,
0.3730908036,
0.2169237733,
0.2972738445,
0.5123543143,
0.0065831705,
0.3012515604,
-0.1027846262,
-0.4696192443,
-0.5596762896,
-0.2080024779,
0.3106660843,
-0.0153140007,
-0.3842062056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04139v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04139v1
|
Modelling Sentiment Analysis: LLMs and data augmentation techniques
| 2023-11-07T17:12:39 | 2023-11-07T17:12:39 |
Guillem Senabre Prades
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper provides different approaches for a binary sentiment
classification on a small training dataset. LLMs that provided state-of-the-art
results in sentiment analysis and similar domains are being used, such as BERT,
RoBERTa and XLNet.
|
[
-0.5200226903,
-0.7222604752,
0.3707219958,
0.2325643301,
-0.399255842,
0.277030468,
0.0316597298,
-0.4185217023,
0.358861655,
0.5601738691,
-0.8883708119,
-0.5736340284,
-0.5287478566,
0.1797036082,
-0.3223137558,
0.9642786384,
0.0758272335,
0.8982437253,
-0.7364802361,
-0.3402205706,
-0.2402133346,
-1.0822373629,
-0.7190824151,
-0.385251224,
0.5615316629,
0.4564096332,
0.6886182427,
-0.095768407,
0.7720673084,
0.3130950928,
-0.2226178646,
0.1417129487,
-0.4043831527,
-0.0230710395,
-0.0073598302,
-0.8508527279,
-0.6646618247,
0.2276373357,
0.4562948942,
0.971061945,
0.3054368496,
0.2449013442,
-0.1610631496,
0.6498460174,
-0.2705455422,
0.087562114,
-0.2555111051,
0.3326170743,
0.0822461247,
-0.2375859767,
-0.1450821906,
-0.639285028,
0.025452869,
0.2616335154,
0.0060247448,
0.1662371755,
0.4284645021,
0.1578446925,
-0.3693326712,
-0.4978874028,
-0.6675763726,
1.2872903347,
-0.9732738137,
0.1296373457,
-0.0923282951,
0.2241680622,
0.1532750279,
-0.6802193522,
-0.529058516,
-0.1633431911,
-0.0557043217,
0.2626313567,
0.0267361198,
0.1354676187,
0.2936378419,
0.7885365486,
0.0061917496,
0.3524773121,
-0.5016163588,
0.0770276636,
0.977478683,
0.6182158589,
0.0363092981,
-0.3610579371,
-0.6402640939,
0.0528520159,
-0.8545464873,
0.0506741479,
0.662772119,
0.2612968385,
-0.0143663222,
0.5967714787,
0.1339157522,
0.9734218717,
-0.0479351617,
-0.2478787005,
0.5045747757,
-0.0421794131,
-0.5187656283,
-0.089820236,
0.6329758167,
0.5903923512,
-0.0354562365,
0.0291061979,
-0.6224085689,
0.4389415383,
0.2261212915,
-0.5211827159,
0.0179082863,
0.4615276158,
-0.7594212294,
-0.8799935579,
0.0706450716,
-0.6158493757,
-0.4611629248,
-0.6998769045,
0.3211488128,
-0.1591022015,
-0.3403217494,
-0.0154709872,
-0.3653212786,
0.5351250172,
0.2146712691,
-0.556882441,
0.4931896031,
0.8671861887,
0.7760515809,
-0.4883244932,
0.211508885,
0.1544691473,
-0.5136580467,
-0.6050836444,
0.7719506025,
-0.7704260945,
-0.5527328849,
-0.0112443883,
-0.047216747,
0.2606565952,
-0.6014664769,
0.6052802801,
-0.7306307554,
0.4647938609,
-0.2303763181,
-1.0638903379,
-0.7034159303,
0.5381209254,
-0.7637316585,
1.3387572765,
0.4497074187,
-0.7789373994,
0.1970496327,
-0.861667335,
-0.1290022433,
-0.253824383,
0.014905449,
-0.3456267715,
0.5491871834,
-0.0223633088,
0.6965369582,
-0.1169585139,
-0.130472824,
-0.6099392176,
-0.3456219435,
0.701044023,
-0.2933970392,
0.7157540917,
0.3854281604,
0.1539788991,
0.1776497364,
-0.7779485583,
0.0596011542,
-0.1575991362,
-0.1742752343,
-0.2558046877,
0.1576426923,
0.0652452931,
0.2824859023,
0.3626953065,
-0.6746342182,
0.3316206634,
-0.6703619957,
0.3730581403,
0.6727707982,
0.2599070072,
0.3250025809,
-0.5833075643,
0.6776660681,
0.326172173,
-0.0079880711,
-0.0246662963,
-0.3261889815,
-0.9632337093,
-0.0930213854,
0.4862640798,
0.674626708,
-0.6850478053,
0.5252023339,
-0.4849390984,
-0.3682943583,
-0.6186742783,
0.2663226128,
-0.2224964499,
0.276353687,
0.0786234364,
-0.474481374,
-0.8853991032,
-0.8028081059,
0.0040237978,
0.024333287,
0.1946480721,
0.1391533613,
0.2023021728,
-0.3842140734,
0.890402317,
-0.2959047258,
-0.05094143,
-0.4455865026,
0.2462079078,
0.4692365229,
0.1973452866,
0.6034493446,
-0.7888597846,
-0.3864322901,
-0.2601980567,
-0.8608262539,
0.0849383101,
0.0868420005,
0.2527804971,
0.4940430522,
0.4274151325,
-0.2233312428,
0.3416235745,
0.4826196432,
0.2059893906,
0.3659703135,
0.2154885381,
0.1254239231,
-1.1188085079,
-0.5246732831,
0.0816104114,
-0.5863002539,
-0.8527665138,
0.0716166496,
-0.2556768358,
0.0959971994,
-0.6890128255,
0.3734390736,
-0.5771388412,
-0.4637179673,
-0.7706810832,
0.0393602476,
-0.1107042879,
0.2412324399,
0.1483167261,
0.5599149466,
0.8031798005,
-0.4087772667,
1.1674628258,
0.0428635143,
-0.2229878157,
0.5596691966,
-0.5023689866,
0.4270327091,
-0.3374456763,
-0.0735962838,
-1.4709481001,
-0.1640264094,
0.2187425494,
-0.7446705699,
0.4153822958,
-0.0598955303,
-0.7535198331,
-0.5598763227,
-0.9024412632,
-0.0582286492,
0.6365363002,
-0.6449277401,
0.6330220699,
0.2304349244,
-0.35276407,
-0.6898285151,
-0.7923585773,
0.160978213,
-0.634647727,
-0.6828318238,
0.146343857,
-0.0242328569,
-0.6235360503,
0.1628035903,
0.2180027068,
-0.0683839023,
-0.0649116263,
0.3133986294,
0.6636690497,
-0.0922384188,
0.2224819511,
0.0255299266,
0.0634958595,
0.3985352516,
0.0031077655,
0.4719972908,
-0.1587096453,
-0.124091588,
-0.0877561942,
0.4336589575,
0.3694309592,
0.535004735,
0.5625944734,
0.78196913,
-0.2079334259,
-0.1649135351,
-0.5033636093,
-0.1164961904,
-0.4735442102,
0.1590127051,
-0.1124229059,
-0.8012224436,
0.271065861,
-0.1337902993,
-0.0375741869,
0.146515578,
0.7710026503,
-0.5047119856,
1.0141466856,
0.7091687918,
-0.6349387765,
0.563262701,
-0.2838616371,
0.1546668112,
-0.9447372556,
0.0668763444,
-0.113269411,
-0.5020171404,
-0.7173797488,
-0.4223940969,
0.2263160795,
-0.0678815991,
0.0377778485,
-0.2564392984,
-0.5341588855,
0.0990796909,
0.6135839224,
0.3294942081,
0.0780796558,
0.2992919385,
0.0266824029,
-0.010260351,
-0.5829469562,
-0.6370398998,
1.2603422403,
0.4767813385,
1.1350278854,
-0.0509364456,
0.8058664203,
0.7468263507,
0.4796521664,
-1.1892263889,
0.7264485955,
-0.220318839,
-0.6507921219,
-0.1116226241,
-0.3006479442,
-0.632969141,
0.0653750673,
-0.3950648308,
-0.3310658038,
0.1496662498,
-0.1434215307,
-0.107195124,
0.2523110211,
-0.5176023245,
0.2252949923,
-0.3862603605,
-0.0698631331,
-0.2207697928,
-0.4986033738,
0.3651927114,
0.0538950861,
0.2019531429,
-0.0004092436,
-0.2990731597,
0.7291409969,
-0.3060773909,
1.1610668898,
-0.4353362918,
-0.1347216517,
0.5360215902,
-0.2187609971,
0.3447650373,
-0.238153711,
-0.1924063414,
0.1399439871,
-0.0581066944,
-0.2551261187,
-0.7253721356,
0.7118346095,
-0.8140330911,
-0.503768146,
-0.3813278973,
-0.5397577286,
-0.472717911,
-0.3803353012,
0.0252534058,
0.3012545109,
-0.0134360641,
0.0695521012,
0.6617386937,
-0.1189400628,
0.4239300191,
0.2645350993,
-0.2264359444,
-0.6273903251,
0.7024782896,
0.1156600043,
0.2803636193,
0.3002306223,
0.1259726286,
-0.6351124644,
-0.6654315591,
-0.0308724698,
0.0555669367,
-1.1372051239,
-0.4009268284,
-0.3292561471,
-0.3904848993,
-0.4739001393,
-0.0448377021,
0.1715356708,
-0.7794425488,
-0.2822389901,
-0.6392716765,
0.8743349314,
0.7446556687,
-0.3026293516,
0.77003932,
-0.9951093197,
0.2262382805,
0.223846823,
0.1773244292,
-0.2250309289,
-0.4403900206,
-0.0924293473,
0.0163159985,
-0.2486214042,
-1.0300494432,
0.6915245056,
0.0190158766,
0.6459358931,
0.2776027322,
-0.3341027498,
0.3631864786,
0.0019082124,
1.144774437,
0.4309562147,
-0.7702226043,
0.5730211735,
-0.0718463436,
-0.4541455209,
0.1981584132,
0.7534360886,
-0.3719705045,
0.0966469571,
-0.5865454674,
-0.5608170629,
0.6068405509,
-0.3010866046,
0.3654593229,
0.2315206826,
0.6648727655,
0.2612888515,
0.3307300806,
-0.815335691,
-0.4926399887,
-0.0863095075,
-0.618667841,
-0.1349531263,
-0.4998694062,
-0.2121705264,
-0.4208070636,
0.6378253102,
-0.0359185524,
0.6133844256,
-0.0750043467,
-0.2063008547,
0.0129722115,
0.2372148335,
0.1363375932,
0.4286777079,
-0.2738651931,
-0.1569833755,
0.428391546,
-0.0994355902,
0.3914994895,
-0.2347566783,
-0.0707504153,
0.1231173426,
0.3396398127,
0.8950039148,
0.0883282423,
-0.2905278206,
0.4996598065,
0.1801540554,
-0.3491088748,
-0.5157763958,
0.3010523319,
0.2448974997,
0.017698599,
0.1300413609,
-0.0832689926,
0.3289103806,
-0.80989182,
-0.0350352973,
0.537399292,
-0.781000793,
-0.2844597697,
-0.0839003474,
0.0214608423,
-0.0844138935,
0.3729536831,
-0.067138806,
-0.4462534189,
0.3623111546,
0.1770681888,
0.7643261552,
-0.1273624599,
-0.0000838931,
0.0914616659,
0.0144037139,
0.0913431719,
0.9670681953,
0.0735270083,
-0.9519064426,
-0.5035096407,
-0.5747727752,
-0.812512219,
-0.1091225818,
-0.9351770878,
0.3493539095,
-0.5412137508,
-0.4103382826,
0.1979071349,
0.3714970052,
-0.6440508366,
0.6459676027,
0.3569710851,
1.0611748695,
-0.8627302647,
0.8106075525,
1.1393126249,
-0.3692110777,
-0.354193002,
-0.5470467806,
0.0126623744,
-0.91665411,
0.9694381952,
-0.0127168726,
-0.0640875176,
-0.2073560357,
-1.0425034761,
-0.641307056,
1.0017795563,
-0.3320819438,
-0.3053565919,
0.2256712765,
0.3731656671,
0.6578999758,
-0.6822243333,
0.2558567524,
0.7054010034,
0.4236161411,
0.0401504673,
-0.184610486,
-0.2325395793,
-0.201527223,
0.0503330007,
-0.179016605,
-0.6107969284,
0.8631612659,
0.1863891184,
0.0506158918,
0.1154444367,
0.7356712818,
-0.0179925468,
0.2353850752,
0.6218860745,
0.6025688648,
0.6591145396,
-0.3125323951,
0.8964351416,
-0.2165449262,
0.5238307714,
0.8332192302,
-0.3649708629,
0.8050075173,
0.3486911058,
-0.5844857097,
0.7314964533,
1.0354580879,
-0.1701618433,
0.3834314048,
0.345276475,
-0.3412168026,
-0.1525690854,
0.2147264779,
-0.2747604251,
0.2481991798,
0.9705204368,
-0.3476969898,
0.0127541246,
0.2560320795,
-0.2149760574,
-0.197725445,
-0.787559092,
1.1305571795,
0.4142635167,
-0.1938592196,
0.3237183094,
0.1063577309,
1.0098593235,
-0.3775607646,
0.0923114419,
-0.1969228536,
0.0575677343,
-0.494759202,
-1.0853415728,
0.5458503366,
-0.0619875118,
-0.2887093723,
0.0873192996,
1.2316324711,
0.0023558226,
-1.0032372475,
0.3014600575,
0.5159645677,
0.1906704307,
0.2577511668,
-0.9077822566,
0.2057991922,
-0.104028821,
-0.1985400915,
0.1540062428,
0.4845227003,
0.2099227756,
0.8008903861,
0.4956481755,
0.4212932885,
0.2651785016,
0.2771357,
1.0307530165,
-1.1496351957,
-0.2152726352,
-0.8577663302,
0.1131891012,
-0.389164269,
0.2020082027,
1.0917211771,
0.3605410159,
0.4403584599,
-0.1888874322,
1.2559659481,
0.1913515776,
1.1276541948,
-0.5836122632,
-0.0842847675,
-0.2288817018,
0.3441053927,
-0.1272777915,
-0.8795358539,
-0.4291170537,
0.5166507959,
-0.4462234378,
0.202908814,
0.3279231191,
0.8544783592,
0.1989142299,
0.2884869874,
0.3031597137,
0.0874230042,
-0.0221149512,
0.1481372863,
1.561205864,
-0.3517448306,
-0.0487294495,
-0.298697114,
-0.2124808133,
-0.3171555996,
-0.779900074,
-1.0982118845,
-0.0359180383,
-0.2133153528,
-0.2829097509,
-0.0983588919,
1.1296368837,
0.8941947818,
-0.7708811164,
-0.2208301276,
0.2151320279,
0.1770250499,
-0.1008194461,
-0.3370201588,
0.1474467069,
-0.9137507677,
-0.7738260627,
0.1742423177,
0.1327554584,
0.1576814204,
-0.8196941614,
0.0523296706,
0.2660258114,
0.4419228733,
0.8756310344,
-0.3045715988,
-0.4910612404,
-0.258857131,
0.0701581314,
0.1965340674,
0.4046419561,
0.7481347919,
-0.6771973968,
0.264403522,
0.6292274594,
0.4380964935,
0.3422941566,
0.3785513937,
0.3263410628,
-0.9999546409,
0.0436868742,
0.3093235195,
0.5346824527,
0.6471492052,
-0.4559972584,
0.3547134399,
0.1333301216,
-0.3902744353,
-0.6117169261,
0.1813175529,
-1.1958465576,
-0.3216108084,
1.2090290785,
-0.1091411859,
-0.411687851,
-0.0101279812,
-0.2356101573,
-0.2939918339,
-0.0955270305,
0.4549141824,
0.8372144103,
-0.4615985155,
-0.2471030354,
-0.2574871778,
0.2359671146,
0.0053778226,
-0.9054620862,
-0.4171017706,
0.5478242636,
0.4644221961,
0.0582896173,
0.516335845,
-0.3830749393,
-0.0827976242,
-0.0125575634,
0.0257084407,
0.0739510283,
-0.0690187886,
-0.5787899494,
0.130429849,
0.2344363183,
-0.250574559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04131v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04131v3
|
Interpreting Shared Circuits for Ordered Sequence Prediction in a Large Language Model
| 2023-11-07T16:58:51 | 2024-02-22T17:07:39 |
Michael Lan, Fazl Barez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
While transformer models exhibit strong capabilities on linguistic tasks,
their complex architectures make them difficult to interpret. Recent work has
aimed to reverse engineer transformer models into human-readable
representations called circuits that implement algorithmic functions. We extend
this research by analyzing and comparing circuits for similar sequence
continuation tasks, which include increasing sequences of digits, number words,
and months. Through the application of circuit analysis techniques, we identify
key sub-circuits responsible for detecting sequence members and for predicting
the next member in a sequence. Our analysis reveals that semantically related
sequences rely on shared circuit subgraphs with analogous roles. Overall,
documenting shared computational structures enables better prediction of model
behaviors, identification of errors, and safer editing procedures. This
mechanistic understanding of transformers is a critical step towards building
more robust, aligned, and interpretable language models.
|
[
-0.4453807473,
-0.2461608946,
0.7456754446,
0.1091993377,
-0.0555147789,
0.2161085457,
0.2709672153,
-0.4462610781,
0.1838995963,
0.7016045451,
-0.83706671,
-0.1909788847,
-0.6292381287,
0.1645980328,
-0.8505910039,
0.7420917153,
0.028722873,
-0.1439359188,
-0.0686635002,
0.085283637,
-0.6211535335,
-0.5752052665,
-0.1798548549,
-0.8461996913,
0.4171319306,
0.2789796293,
1.0059337616,
0.326733917,
0.4883999527,
0.4094405174,
0.0474580154,
-0.1633369327,
-0.2237576395,
0.079264991,
-0.0336528011,
-0.3708480895,
-0.3552311957,
-0.3006821871,
0.1892270893,
0.9156262279,
0.1138550118,
0.0822208598,
-0.2101597488,
0.5161319971,
-0.1206092313,
0.4823871851,
-0.4673445523,
0.0583703071,
-0.1445531845,
-0.4308516383,
-0.8862778544,
-0.1589241475,
0.1167527214,
-0.1960939467,
0.4312768281,
0.0978235677,
0.5857031941,
0.0420106426,
-0.2312388569,
-0.1574135423,
-0.8771649003,
0.6078287363,
-0.2865186334,
0.6124820709,
0.1461634785,
0.3460119367,
-0.2920349836,
-0.9775518775,
-0.7153021693,
-0.053727705,
-0.5767967105,
0.1330029964,
-0.2816668451,
0.1608811021,
0.3518205583,
0.3668988347,
-0.5956612825,
0.013820909,
-0.7928668857,
-0.2109892219,
0.5698759556,
0.2899907529,
0.67776227,
-0.3575812876,
-0.0457895622,
-0.1155975088,
-0.6489943266,
-0.0890997574,
0.4332354069,
0.0425047465,
-0.1455778033,
0.6649703979,
-0.1133118495,
0.4400747716,
0.027091179,
0.5029280782,
0.3363711238,
-0.2079084218,
-0.2250347733,
0.263341397,
0.7836333513,
0.1757447422,
0.6880938411,
-0.2573169172,
-0.1921908557,
0.021120593,
0.5330963731,
-0.5146112442,
-0.4982506335,
0.0000212917,
-0.5110977888,
-0.2979886532,
0.266622901,
-0.6708589196,
-0.2309227884,
-0.3638746142,
0.1343969852,
-0.2178410888,
0.0836388171,
0.2382381111,
-0.1201329231,
0.0554580018,
-0.047584977,
-1.1803210974,
0.7074505091,
0.9356832504,
0.8173044324,
-0.1810093671,
-0.460557282,
-0.3437171578,
-0.1989139169,
-0.0640428588,
0.6061778665,
-0.5946373343,
-0.3979511857,
-0.2714918852,
0.4079215527,
-0.0158047769,
-0.2827797234,
0.588303268,
-1.1090068817,
-0.0236554984,
-0.1103079021,
-0.3527555168,
-0.0746983588,
-0.3342876732,
-1.1344048977,
0.6947544217,
-0.0264163408,
-0.9744346738,
0.0290227495,
-0.4276146591,
-0.6048547029,
-0.0230876748,
-0.3165690899,
-0.3720799983,
0.3714509308,
0.2137650996,
0.5290985703,
-0.1050151587,
0.3935579658,
-0.1164874211,
-0.547039032,
0.3776649237,
-0.5032528043,
0.6961264014,
0.0900589302,
-0.233540535,
0.643335402,
-0.5544410348,
-0.3469567895,
-0.0416766964,
0.2855643928,
-0.1134181246,
0.2687909305,
-0.1312929392,
0.184620887,
0.0294625666,
-0.5038231611,
0.1065290272,
-0.6017062068,
0.6381294131,
0.7655153275,
0.1263052225,
0.4115375876,
-0.0875464454,
0.5684238672,
-0.1026539281,
0.1408591717,
-0.5619989038,
-0.8352040648,
-0.5502132177,
0.2138237655,
0.1813646108,
0.6848589778,
-0.5296384692,
0.4900281429,
-0.5707355738,
-0.5350892544,
-0.2583221197,
-0.2548451424,
0.2719556391,
0.1822200119,
0.5411080122,
-0.5005204678,
-0.6883724332,
-0.9700533152,
-0.1170263439,
-0.2505805492,
-0.1502310783,
-0.0064698746,
0.4210342765,
-0.2088012248,
0.6491929889,
-0.7215621471,
0.5096984506,
-0.5435339808,
0.3623823822,
0.5608160496,
0.2714941502,
0.0352083109,
-0.7672127485,
-0.2236240506,
0.2835862041,
-0.5339140296,
-0.1271007359,
-0.2872014046,
-0.0540516563,
-0.2352686524,
0.7302690148,
-0.5281432867,
0.6087728739,
0.5233723521,
-0.201638028,
0.4737863243,
-0.080028154,
0.2534691691,
-0.7069647312,
-0.1820497513,
-0.4309699833,
-0.1464912891,
-0.6191304922,
0.0016047915,
-0.0940145701,
-0.1712099463,
-0.0753313377,
0.2117508352,
-0.3559078276,
-0.6860826612,
-0.1424596757,
-0.3366273046,
-0.1171362996,
0.3590772748,
0.081061624,
0.8399788141,
0.3206872642,
-0.2556430697,
0.2413433939,
0.1909792572,
-0.4408168197,
-0.2450770438,
-0.9532828927,
0.1325756013,
0.0475761779,
-0.1589015573,
-1.0271710157,
-0.296808809,
-0.0520435572,
-0.5331001282,
0.2857673168,
0.1001021042,
-0.6114121079,
-0.6431716084,
0.0091081932,
0.5977169275,
0.5027933717,
-0.6485638618,
0.6705209017,
0.2499848306,
-0.1595176309,
-0.3720777333,
-0.5571614504,
-0.2492238432,
0.1550676823,
-0.8088893294,
0.4843197465,
0.2971348763,
-0.2431973368,
-0.0365125053,
-0.176916182,
-0.1296600997,
0.1616017073,
0.6950823665,
0.5118436217,
-0.0991777033,
0.2195495665,
0.178356111,
-0.3376967311,
0.190444544,
-0.1970796883,
0.9340847135,
-0.2191407681,
-0.5487242937,
-0.4895429313,
0.3732008934,
0.8646634221,
-0.3601350784,
0.599627614,
0.1541054398,
-0.3449667096,
0.1840002835,
-0.172885552,
-0.2360162884,
-0.5535509586,
0.2859489918,
-0.4924230278,
-0.7685207725,
0.6444782615,
0.1120449305,
-0.1800712496,
0.6390696764,
0.5717051029,
-0.0662057102,
0.9511585832,
0.730843246,
-0.2284888178,
0.4379259944,
0.0035363792,
0.7284865379,
-0.3055284619,
-0.2640455067,
-0.2976050377,
-0.3263080716,
-0.7365576029,
-0.3502265513,
0.1776571572,
0.0029826493,
-0.2434101403,
0.8796618581,
-0.4343953729,
0.7207151055,
0.5076614022,
-0.0018421379,
0.4127029479,
0.1836169064,
-0.2611420751,
0.0181365442,
-0.2725890279,
-0.4523398578,
0.7662367225,
0.1963098794,
0.8399928212,
-0.2534941733,
0.7575964928,
0.3633927107,
0.1850972027,
-0.9021634459,
0.4308895767,
-0.2888472378,
-0.4105471671,
-0.1167066172,
-0.1167170256,
-0.8996026516,
-0.1669810116,
0.080905728,
-0.9737858176,
0.1893215328,
-0.0965894088,
-0.3468244672,
0.1382427514,
-0.7503046989,
0.9778364897,
-0.0737463832,
0.1143471524,
-0.4612706304,
-0.7602379918,
0.420937717,
0.0645587221,
0.1205827072,
0.4906935692,
0.5292880535,
0.6072948575,
-0.407361269,
0.7092642784,
0.5131967664,
0.2977035344,
0.4586773515,
0.1553135514,
0.1395734102,
-0.3284165561,
-0.2550472915,
0.2548455596,
0.0213861223,
-0.1294993609,
-0.6986359358,
0.7545196414,
-0.6933740973,
-0.5083034635,
-0.2798010409,
-0.4483288527,
-0.0545351543,
0.1930303872,
0.4116779864,
0.6581013203,
0.0819549039,
-0.0966902673,
0.4161496758,
-0.1881064326,
0.5471687317,
-0.2220023125,
-0.3148253858,
-0.2372017354,
0.7275213003,
-0.0254906714,
0.2754660845,
0.6441049576,
-0.011819494,
-0.1737123281,
-0.5222008824,
-0.1868683547,
0.1663542986,
-0.757796824,
0.0347610749,
-0.8018611073,
-0.3593325913,
-0.2659569979,
-0.3226996064,
-0.2463167161,
-0.7228668928,
-0.1036114171,
-0.4662328959,
0.20687069,
1.114449501,
0.3880740702,
0.5997370481,
-1.1449371576,
0.3758535683,
0.2645783126,
0.4205196798,
0.2348006517,
-0.3291007578,
-0.0691696256,
-0.5692340136,
-0.4860450327,
-1.119659543,
0.3672090769,
-0.158948347,
0.45673123,
0.0389432237,
-0.1554572433,
0.7812508345,
-0.8427294493,
0.6475662589,
0.3059564531,
-1.3889348507,
0.5141526461,
0.1003337279,
0.1177624017,
0.2996161282,
0.4749963582,
-0.63741678,
-0.1366830468,
-0.7566587329,
-0.813739419,
0.6702148318,
0.385299921,
0.1397161782,
-0.1170123592,
0.2910265923,
0.0951528475,
-0.0150951231,
-0.6823188663,
-0.2773087323,
-0.1538338065,
-0.4262058735,
-0.0186853427,
-0.1871538311,
0.1769880056,
-0.1698682308,
0.305408746,
0.0423362441,
0.4597790539,
0.0110265883,
-0.0432282053,
-0.225184381,
0.4433549047,
0.4650451839,
0.5356405377,
-0.0385007896,
0.2087134868,
-0.028334694,
-0.5152091384,
-0.1208801568,
0.0348560214,
-0.1130302176,
0.1369194388,
0.8280408382,
0.756801486,
0.2647085488,
-0.6756211519,
0.435782969,
-0.1228952482,
0.292788744,
-0.2145628184,
-0.078399539,
0.2359823585,
0.3455738127,
0.0514432564,
0.3490471244,
0.5822393894,
-0.7413844466,
0.748803854,
0.0460320562,
-0.5747458339,
-0.7880826592,
0.3439330161,
0.0299696364,
-0.4593609869,
0.7053482533,
-0.074491486,
-0.9518273473,
0.9123870134,
0.4220745564,
0.9116357565,
-0.2474708557,
-0.0233572647,
0.3654564619,
0.4379186928,
-0.2682083845,
0.2716138959,
-0.0066607175,
-0.5647297502,
-0.5417248607,
-0.6100575924,
-0.1759818047,
-0.228939712,
-0.8703979254,
0.5346532464,
-0.3912471533,
0.1147564873,
0.3389518261,
-0.4569940269,
-0.5042990446,
0.0900260583,
0.1104075089,
0.7697761655,
-1.0420159101,
0.889300108,
0.2476747185,
-0.3228520751,
-0.941788137,
0.0862955973,
-0.0980336592,
-0.8578675985,
0.9647704363,
0.4640150964,
-0.279081136,
-0.1981849521,
-0.1495310366,
-0.70425421,
1.0596101284,
0.0306015536,
-0.7896006703,
-0.2231540829,
0.0090046208,
0.8053385019,
-0.3670601249,
0.4026673734,
0.6486978531,
0.1319516748,
0.4311768413,
-1.0095658302,
0.1930553317,
-0.1390752792,
-0.2763397396,
0.7132940292,
0.0085769063,
0.8982285857,
-0.3586773574,
-0.3886740804,
0.2756002545,
0.6472263336,
-0.164699316,
0.5495951772,
0.4578900039,
0.2178303897,
0.6457946897,
-0.0150765423,
1.1959756613,
-0.3443475068,
0.4248285592,
1.4553165436,
-0.0996109024,
0.9400655627,
0.3730176091,
-0.3054699898,
0.7141990066,
0.3794254661,
-0.1488730758,
0.5820304751,
0.2777723968,
-0.0095523661,
-0.3666160405,
0.0942323804,
-0.2280069441,
0.2650857866,
0.3974117935,
-0.8278129101,
-0.0088057937,
-0.2586528659,
-0.4938393235,
-0.0508806966,
-0.3481790125,
0.4706656933,
0.1490280777,
-0.7933656573,
0.0268243998,
-0.1548270285,
0.2574737668,
0.0158708841,
-0.1889853328,
0.093527019,
0.1186934412,
-0.3629981577,
-1.1393872499,
0.8162790537,
-0.0599097684,
-0.3568530381,
-0.2952450812,
0.8025203347,
-0.0352345221,
-0.5771686435,
0.5772792101,
0.2649780512,
-0.0249809884,
0.0839478001,
-0.2729644477,
0.1892563403,
-0.0384036377,
0.0200975239,
-0.1500265151,
0.1527040452,
-0.3862468302,
0.5855633616,
0.3320633769,
-0.2341946363,
0.3173320591,
0.382550627,
0.8316711783,
-0.8306455016,
-0.2248081565,
-1.0094366074,
0.507044673,
-0.0071542393,
0.0794980377,
0.3130396307,
0.3375996649,
0.8950203657,
-0.2206290215,
0.5652419329,
0.0707173347,
0.1725206375,
-0.4047650397,
0.3868312836,
-0.1416734457,
0.57211411,
-0.1013329104,
-0.6345257163,
-0.449001044,
0.3638072014,
-0.5877480507,
-0.3023508787,
0.7518134117,
0.7512124181,
-0.286880523,
0.6108718514,
0.2909954786,
0.2796260417,
0.3473347723,
0.4010471702,
0.9784127474,
-0.6146349907,
0.3921270669,
-0.4483042061,
-0.0389378071,
0.0387063958,
-0.4982643723,
-0.8867281675,
-0.5894600749,
-0.0115629556,
-0.2698021233,
-0.1895750314,
0.8000503182,
0.3964420855,
-1.1982752085,
-0.2458973229,
-0.6246199608,
0.4053349793,
-0.1192069575,
-0.2258898467,
0.2612278759,
-0.009015427,
-0.5861230493,
0.1136647239,
0.4855879843,
-0.2070055604,
0.0011842179,
0.1055408046,
0.0554625094,
0.1302656531,
0.5696074963,
0.1306246072,
-0.9363206625,
-0.4053212702,
0.3465000093,
0.0798785016,
0.0290780589,
1.1349043846,
-0.6817921996,
0.4788292646,
0.9680651426,
0.5384986997,
0.4622989893,
-0.0964318514,
0.8130174279,
-0.3986542523,
-0.2904125154,
0.0819192678,
0.7202447057,
0.1466544867,
-0.3822419345,
0.4707308114,
0.226239875,
-0.5443348885,
-0.6304516196,
0.5557536483,
-1.2607067823,
-0.0722959563,
0.5260075331,
-0.3290797174,
-0.0695989802,
-0.2191613615,
-0.1191074103,
0.4986261725,
-0.1484600306,
0.6622812748,
0.7484822273,
-0.4692156911,
-0.232971549,
-0.3272603154,
0.0609403066,
0.2515336275,
-0.6188989282,
0.1105816662,
0.1573928148,
0.055359941,
0.6803608537,
0.2722752392,
-0.1924979538,
0.3350516558,
-0.132148996,
-0.2162913531,
0.1745188236,
-0.5947299004,
-0.4244947433,
0.257969588,
-0.0332225263,
-0.0103005609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04124v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04124v1
|
Unveiling Safety Vulnerabilities of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-07T16:50:33 | 2023-11-07T16:50:33 |
George Kour, Marcel Zalmanovici, Naama Zwerdling, Esther Goldbraich, Ora Nova Fandina, Ateret Anaby-Tavor, Orna Raz, Eitan Farchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
As large language models become more prevalent, their possible harmful or
inappropriate responses are a cause for concern. This paper introduces a unique
dataset containing adversarial examples in the form of questions, which we call
AttaQ, designed to provoke such harmful or inappropriate responses. We assess
the efficacy of our dataset by analyzing the vulnerabilities of various models
when subjected to it. Additionally, we introduce a novel automatic approach for
identifying and naming vulnerable semantic regions - input semantic areas for
which the model is likely to produce harmful outputs. This is achieved through
the application of specialized clustering techniques that consider both the
semantic similarity of the input attacks and the harmfulness of the model's
responses. Automatically identifying vulnerable semantic regions enhances the
evaluation of model weaknesses, facilitating targeted improvements to its
safety mechanisms and overall reliability.
|
[
-0.2630717456,
-1.2833292484,
0.5064736605,
-0.3091439605,
0.0896821916,
-0.0516993552,
0.0968995839,
-0.3335126936,
-0.2542913258,
0.8353655934,
-0.3884529769,
-0.5157563686,
-0.7457729578,
-0.4281947017,
-0.9326199293,
0.8373583555,
0.0795925707,
-0.2377861887,
-0.1220041215,
-0.02360842,
-0.42501387,
-0.9062143564,
-0.7743897438,
-0.0544672646,
0.5867171288,
0.1283167154,
0.9830334187,
0.5596072078,
0.6465783119,
0.4644795954,
-0.034850657,
-0.305136025,
-0.3199386895,
0.1001484394,
-0.0122728944,
-0.625944376,
-0.229915604,
-0.3197683692,
0.6932867765,
0.6852655411,
-0.0205303654,
0.1746953577,
-0.0875938237,
0.3024667203,
-0.7610005736,
-0.1718970835,
-1.1423697472,
0.0671263263,
-0.3011724353,
-0.2770308554,
-0.4953282475,
-0.6255342364,
-0.0294879396,
-0.3130322695,
-0.0006549758,
-0.1176560596,
0.6492115855,
0.4654245675,
-0.7092023492,
-0.2874948382,
-0.6311331987,
0.846707046,
-0.6813699007,
0.0384933315,
0.4206510186,
0.6100801229,
-0.6719526649,
-0.4078803957,
-0.4994683266,
-0.0095704738,
-0.2172027677,
-0.4756441712,
-0.5885121226,
-0.1101962328,
0.0990592912,
0.0010213959,
-0.8977057338,
0.2598240077,
-0.2538579106,
-0.2394808531,
0.7227486372,
0.4631507397,
0.7456704378,
-0.1124692336,
-0.1872501522,
-0.401842773,
-0.9254212379,
0.059946049,
0.5937099457,
0.4878469408,
0.2392261475,
0.496221453,
0.1248229444,
0.6722707152,
-0.3904595375,
0.0198734012,
0.1780814677,
-0.2661382556,
-0.1776144058,
0.0057757609,
0.9558267593,
0.2374153286,
0.1916634291,
-0.2631808817,
-0.1816267669,
0.0313162133,
0.6669921875,
-0.3594254255,
-0.2220383734,
0.4164714813,
-0.1601984203,
-0.8236051798,
0.009581591,
-0.7353578806,
-0.7156885266,
0.362273097,
0.5348943472,
-0.32506302,
-0.1554552466,
0.0091306139,
-0.048583746,
0.1559485793,
0.0788393393,
-0.5995784998,
0.3873861432,
0.5840459466,
0.3001274765,
-0.1260831356,
-0.2538090348,
-0.5573132634,
0.2186155319,
-0.3966906965,
0.8413805366,
-0.5325773954,
-0.4924277663,
0.0555077605,
0.2856090069,
0.0463319793,
-0.6041372418,
0.3952969313,
-0.710778892,
0.1122275218,
-0.1859538257,
-0.0411871523,
-0.3854826093,
0.3753592074,
-0.8165017366,
0.7398298979,
-0.0711082071,
-0.997710526,
0.2001994103,
-0.6440700889,
-0.4414529502,
-0.2066430002,
-0.0598789528,
-0.696888864,
-0.1175975055,
0.1354183406,
0.4582081735,
-0.2571964264,
0.1437162757,
-0.5267538428,
-0.0624066889,
0.7072414756,
-0.5707770586,
1.0666264296,
0.065366976,
-0.183870405,
0.6371990442,
-0.8029512167,
0.3308784962,
0.4712320566,
-0.154501617,
-0.677005589,
0.027766604,
-0.0080738999,
0.213316381,
-0.0329207778,
-0.3490295708,
-0.0694439337,
-0.5986991525,
0.4137529731,
0.7170325518,
0.2578196824,
0.3586293161,
-0.2038289756,
0.6621795297,
0.1921469867,
0.4005526006,
0.182295084,
-0.3433716297,
-0.6388697028,
0.1038117856,
0.314414829,
0.7851889133,
-0.8718113303,
0.6345745325,
-0.0612079427,
-0.8317800164,
-0.1269435585,
-0.119432196,
0.6217055321,
0.46124053,
0.1976938993,
-0.0824040547,
-0.3507475257,
-1.1338361502,
-0.1324052066,
-0.435235858,
-0.0880267844,
0.1819313765,
0.6693416238,
-0.2949539125,
0.5053811073,
-0.6173074841,
0.1408444345,
-0.0380099528,
0.1298987716,
-0.2875542343,
0.5121663809,
0.7952027321,
-0.8284194469,
-0.1312188357,
-0.1391186565,
-0.7861877084,
0.165822655,
0.1216293424,
-0.3528413773,
0.0343430378,
0.6365600228,
-0.4090912044,
0.4623926282,
0.4469599724,
-0.5497244,
0.5244127512,
0.084659867,
0.1666719764,
-1.0472257137,
0.1369160861,
-0.2774285972,
-0.0940899104,
-0.7611371875,
0.3981396258,
0.060532894,
-0.276710391,
-0.7716722488,
0.4038067162,
-0.063105464,
0.0294101126,
-0.1012127623,
-0.0627897382,
-0.0682005957,
0.2110435814,
-0.2884587646,
0.5226257443,
0.6743276119,
-0.6040868163,
0.6982431412,
0.2732168138,
-0.3382402658,
-0.1961414367,
-0.8758103251,
0.0513618626,
0.0597321987,
0.1917953938,
-0.7781584263,
-0.3556232452,
0.2416798919,
-0.5825164914,
0.2326644361,
-0.1015073806,
-0.5746926069,
-0.29861781,
-0.4690305293,
0.4559626281,
0.2657337487,
-0.3468564749,
0.4187211096,
0.9198199511,
-0.3769934773,
-0.7687202096,
-0.7242032886,
-0.0110545056,
-0.8380048275,
-0.6494789124,
-0.0175142735,
0.1578621864,
-0.391828984,
0.0723700821,
0.4146226048,
-0.3580432236,
0.7790568471,
0.3860040605,
0.2469780147,
-0.0797426105,
0.105049476,
-0.0718992874,
-0.1967857033,
0.3817036748,
0.2266747057,
0.5310747623,
-0.2557891309,
-0.4495954514,
-0.0891741663,
0.8345997334,
0.6573380828,
-0.3495310843,
0.8240003586,
0.2299003452,
-0.8113637567,
-0.2799283862,
-0.007309875,
-0.3217566609,
-0.4854616225,
0.7879008055,
-0.1570449919,
-0.7911783457,
0.7827611566,
0.3755357265,
-0.0377147086,
0.4079601765,
0.6900712252,
0.2750957012,
1.2127552032,
0.7522075772,
-0.3031600714,
0.2856052816,
-0.0501500666,
0.4368782341,
-0.2031686008,
-0.21062316,
-0.7693372965,
0.1855430454,
-0.4564689696,
-0.3849133551,
0.6907016635,
-0.1855132878,
-0.3115986586,
0.5238027573,
-0.271459043,
0.6198964119,
0.332095325,
-0.2354640067,
0.0921360031,
-0.0458331555,
-0.1213442236,
0.1649054438,
-0.714076817,
-0.7668855786,
0.9779843688,
0.639669776,
1.0435361862,
0.5282087922,
0.3218488097,
0.1956785619,
0.0693464801,
-0.7747253776,
0.5762374997,
-0.1486823261,
-0.82899791,
-0.6893401742,
-0.4936026931,
-1.0639379025,
0.1054295152,
-0.4028632343,
-0.9567933083,
0.0577990673,
0.1498170644,
-0.7633573413,
0.2734099329,
-0.9063333869,
1.0034099817,
-0.3026126325,
0.0510483943,
-0.005607829,
-0.6252219081,
0.6137990952,
-0.4439258575,
0.2026775777,
0.1016228348,
0.2296307534,
0.7339198589,
-0.2859406173,
0.8860313296,
0.0518687591,
-0.2857412696,
0.2224486619,
0.2725059986,
0.3563582003,
-0.0821878538,
-0.016472986,
-0.0510892831,
0.0269607361,
-0.2658856213,
-0.7358108759,
0.8578150272,
-0.6275373697,
-0.4928093553,
-0.4364359677,
-0.4402484596,
-0.6106613278,
0.2977845669,
0.2040403932,
0.666074574,
-0.1739581227,
0.1430032849,
0.845941782,
-0.8632665873,
0.3043234646,
0.5016443729,
-0.2304676026,
0.0431920625,
0.9544295669,
0.0500537567,
0.2206870168,
0.0559466928,
0.0260406919,
-0.332501471,
-0.7324726582,
-0.4021959305,
-0.0408810787,
-0.9293398857,
-0.494922787,
-0.6258547902,
-0.3173462451,
-0.5066346526,
-0.2081652582,
-0.4878304899,
-0.3939713538,
0.101810798,
-0.2507564127,
0.2011441737,
0.7598653436,
0.4412912428,
0.2201067507,
-1.0154838562,
-0.0201490838,
0.4840602279,
0.1729117185,
0.0452692136,
-0.3154783547,
-0.0899027735,
-0.1776267737,
-0.2845551074,
-0.8761327267,
0.4532322288,
-0.0726418123,
0.7544981241,
0.230331704,
0.445189625,
0.2702489197,
-0.548122108,
0.7472749949,
0.0169555936,
-0.6939290166,
0.7884780765,
-0.4373012185,
0.1355877072,
0.4578002989,
0.6742787957,
-0.238294214,
-0.6813380718,
-0.7170754671,
-1.2047945261,
0.4647494256,
0.1688894629,
0.0123044206,
-0.0596980713,
0.0654597729,
0.0405383669,
-0.0985834375,
-0.5893275738,
-0.2395827621,
0.0325832963,
-0.1796228439,
0.0628765598,
-0.259753406,
-0.5543736815,
0.0340550691,
0.8676080704,
-0.104752548,
0.1869970411,
-0.3595166802,
-0.1048109904,
-0.2785900533,
0.3614809811,
0.2892372608,
0.4365671575,
0.1155827492,
0.3653308749,
0.2622973621,
-0.2416007221,
0.2106771171,
0.0176047981,
-0.0277834479,
-0.331033498,
0.6148410439,
0.5120413303,
0.0378185101,
-0.8850870132,
0.6412525773,
-0.4697053432,
0.070686847,
-0.6107142568,
0.3681007326,
-0.1452382058,
0.1175259873,
0.1037433222,
-0.1942990273,
0.4611121714,
-0.7444184422,
0.3928451836,
0.6734569669,
-0.4275015593,
-0.0119937332,
0.312315017,
0.1120825857,
-0.02819084,
0.3844200969,
0.1528957188,
-0.9388088584,
0.8734269738,
0.4047010243,
0.6969141364,
-0.3466903865,
0.0617352799,
0.2822252512,
0.5003018975,
0.3896757066,
0.1341001242,
0.5420466661,
-0.8319920301,
-0.0663993284,
-0.4532955885,
-0.1786085516,
0.4022676349,
-0.8247994184,
0.0975400582,
-0.4725669026,
-0.3492975831,
0.2644509971,
-0.2791153789,
-0.0782166272,
0.3683016002,
0.1901347339,
0.5444658399,
-1.2897156477,
0.7786698341,
0.9092448354,
-0.127355814,
-0.8253663182,
0.1275585592,
0.3306438625,
-0.7612782121,
0.5018392205,
-0.1591988504,
-0.1455008239,
-0.2639250457,
-0.4669065773,
-0.89771384,
0.7801104784,
0.354336828,
-0.1572493911,
0.1008069739,
0.3807713687,
0.3273034692,
-0.0639131665,
0.0515387766,
0.6758950353,
0.3205856979,
-0.1888093203,
-0.9846661687,
0.3515906334,
-0.5435960889,
-0.0081902035,
0.4432107806,
-0.4399413168,
0.7328251004,
-0.0812366903,
-0.2428627163,
-0.0893437937,
0.3646369874,
0.1615907103,
-0.0842289105,
0.8364320993,
0.3951039314,
0.6974223852,
-0.233858794,
1.0918720961,
0.0803010389,
0.1132507324,
0.9672916532,
0.1209757179,
0.9047468901,
0.2305942327,
-0.1386874467,
0.1175805703,
0.4113871753,
0.0684840009,
0.6353490353,
0.439991653,
-0.2155667543,
-0.2678825259,
-0.0116960108,
-0.31478706,
0.645222187,
0.5897430182,
-0.3706130981,
-0.2881003022,
0.2783574462,
0.2047020942,
0.0140876956,
-0.2425133437,
0.8438647985,
-0.1116889119,
-0.3208613694,
0.6380113959,
0.2061573863,
0.4470486343,
-0.6820966005,
0.0369350016,
0.0353619978,
0.3137837946,
-0.0984564945,
-0.8726891875,
0.7954819202,
0.2182020545,
-0.1789244264,
0.2419042587,
0.792860508,
-0.2085510343,
-0.5780145526,
0.454470247,
0.2238116115,
0.0267578773,
-0.0343790427,
-0.786346972,
0.1951017529,
-0.1423520297,
-0.274743408,
0.5871917009,
0.5588939786,
-0.4877594113,
0.971472621,
0.275564909,
-0.1691720784,
0.1164756566,
0.0045479224,
1.1352423429,
-0.6117162704,
-0.464492768,
-0.6380452514,
0.6071223617,
-0.0412306376,
-0.2101431489,
0.8653681874,
0.1591370255,
0.657805562,
0.1218560189,
0.9489908218,
-0.0294766184,
0.5605528355,
-0.5251927972,
1.2291452885,
-0.556671381,
0.4918586612,
-0.3717700243,
-0.4682038426,
-0.5324028134,
0.381179899,
-0.4049467742,
-0.1089648753,
0.7383465767,
1.0743942261,
0.2116232365,
-0.1961406469,
0.4000558555,
0.4447774589,
0.4948901832,
0.6735092402,
0.8197309375,
-0.4925040007,
0.7698777914,
-0.4320969284,
-0.2710004449,
-0.0414989553,
-0.8133193851,
-1.0588972569,
-0.7080495954,
-0.3595167994,
-0.514959991,
0.2356012017,
0.5586730838,
0.5234852433,
-1.1323328018,
0.1610198468,
0.2936841249,
0.0730764493,
0.3020432591,
-0.2407323718,
0.4926953912,
-0.0094214734,
-0.3946852982,
0.4733340442,
-0.1058172509,
0.2247783691,
-0.507207036,
0.4221355915,
0.188132897,
0.0217931755,
0.4169517756,
0.2300377786,
-0.5385632515,
-0.5701325536,
-0.3393513262,
-0.1291240752,
-0.6027247906,
0.6611968875,
-0.3649771214,
0.0554303043,
0.4025346041,
0.7670704126,
-0.3390515149,
-0.1242321804,
0.8663084507,
-0.6988497972,
0.2972290218,
0.3940005302,
0.3080665469,
0.2972256839,
-0.7131403685,
0.1893388927,
-0.1446689963,
-0.4141769111,
-0.9406006932,
0.4458194971,
-0.8129069805,
-0.5536779165,
1.1229541302,
-0.3544615805,
-0.5626129508,
-0.3868082166,
0.0634592772,
0.1415574104,
-0.20939973,
0.9640812278,
0.6935031414,
0.1532325745,
0.2420379817,
-0.6990451813,
0.5636916757,
0.2027458698,
-0.92889148,
0.3455959857,
0.3872119784,
0.2711361647,
0.0765464157,
0.1898064613,
-0.6426522136,
0.2501948774,
0.2258425653,
-0.1976837963,
0.0462217219,
-0.417221576,
-0.4663051069,
0.4346804619,
0.1972078234,
0.025631126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04933v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04933v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models in Ophthalmology
| 2023-11-07T16:19:45 | 2023-11-07T16:19:45 |
Jason Holmes, Shuyuan Ye, Yiwei Li, Shi-Nan Wu, Zhengliang Liu, Zihao Wu, Jinyu Hu, Huan Zhao, Xi Jiang, Wei Liu, Hong Wei, Jie Zou, Tianming Liu, Yi Shao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Purpose: The performance of three different large language models (LLMS)
(GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and PaLM2) in answering ophthalmology professional questions
was evaluated and compared with that of three different professional
populations (medical undergraduates, medical masters, and attending
physicians). Methods: A 100-item ophthalmology single-choice test was
administered to three different LLMs (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and PaLM2) and three
different professional levels (medical undergraduates, medical masters, and
attending physicians), respectively. The performance of LLM was comprehensively
evaluated and compared with the human group in terms of average score,
stability, and confidence. Results: Each LLM outperformed undergraduates in
general, with GPT-3.5 and PaLM2 being slightly below the master's level, while
GPT-4 showed a level comparable to that of attending physicians. In addition,
GPT-4 showed significantly higher answer stability and confidence than GPT-3.5
and PaLM2. Conclusion: Our study shows that LLM represented by GPT-4 performs
better in the field of ophthalmology. With further improvements, LLM will bring
unexpected benefits in medical education and clinical decision making in the
near future.
|
[
-0.3628363013,
-1.0732415915,
0.9806424379,
0.0075912355,
-0.2458370924,
0.0209810324,
-0.4633051455,
-0.9273852706,
0.0350403152,
0.3028504252,
0.0799872503,
-0.6738669276,
-0.4565161765,
0.3879738748,
-0.0356642269,
0.7356093526,
-0.2247627378,
0.7523519397,
0.1459509432,
-0.0631728768,
-0.2798221409,
-0.2979303598,
-0.7616218328,
-0.1181065366,
0.4403861761,
0.3462257981,
0.7051036954,
0.3721002638,
1.045135498,
0.3388521075,
-0.0848239735,
-0.0946402252,
-0.2316457331,
-0.134293288,
-0.1625115126,
-0.5159461498,
-0.6812496185,
0.1891600043,
0.5654309988,
0.9974211454,
-0.4395892918,
0.2873490453,
0.0239183269,
0.6643009186,
-0.4099915922,
-0.0006749746,
-0.168816328,
0.1345655918,
-0.1956184953,
-0.1778393686,
-0.4048506916,
-0.4398646653,
0.6751510501,
-0.7463541627,
-0.080652155,
0.2254264057,
0.7041242123,
-0.2706095874,
-0.3393182755,
-0.1706804186,
-0.2727007568,
0.3937341571,
-0.8432206511,
0.1076688692,
0.2537720203,
0.3718232214,
0.4114423394,
-0.4501438737,
-0.573195219,
-0.3286102116,
0.13122949,
0.3539853394,
-0.0614117347,
0.2834600806,
0.1242415756,
0.3713237345,
-0.8367068172,
0.5219156742,
-0.7665224075,
0.0009836088,
0.5519407988,
0.3540922701,
0.1079595312,
0.2354369164,
-0.3392885327,
-0.0060804235,
-0.649094224,
-0.1569179147,
0.3898423314,
0.0124946544,
-0.056362804,
0.5665410161,
-0.1958520263,
0.9168986678,
0.0373909548,
-0.2779691517,
0.3625486493,
-0.3879732788,
-0.3205485642,
-0.1753112525,
0.8857543468,
0.7605344057,
0.6699267626,
0.0905846208,
-0.1329752654,
-0.2605024576,
0.1790796518,
-0.5787254572,
-0.0639233515,
0.1133636385,
-0.662037611,
-0.3825134933,
0.0994479507,
-0.8519530892,
-0.2608487606,
-0.212864697,
0.5740659237,
-0.1490036696,
-0.346432358,
0.563737154,
0.1205223799,
0.5376868844,
0.6142299771,
-1.0503604412,
0.5172604322,
0.4904167056,
0.9398454428,
-0.5838193893,
-0.4467173517,
-0.1703046411,
-0.1024460718,
-0.7128373981,
0.4889762402,
-0.4697896838,
-0.569993794,
0.1834513694,
-0.2821907997,
-0.2821003795,
-0.9806221128,
0.1171288416,
-0.5674911737,
0.259478271,
-0.2199678868,
-0.452897042,
-0.3003094494,
0.3132044077,
-0.3578005433,
0.6938781142,
0.3477368653,
-0.4684337378,
0.2379660308,
-0.6066920161,
-0.176448822,
0.2416798472,
-0.565095067,
-0.2403976172,
0.1059796587,
0.131511867,
0.5217299461,
-0.5144738555,
0.320761025,
-0.4197438955,
-0.3436431587,
0.4550620019,
-0.2457895279,
0.5142661333,
-0.2531927824,
-0.28910622,
0.0811824352,
-0.5512924194,
0.0520829,
0.1648457795,
-0.4820692241,
-0.0449746661,
-0.1290424317,
0.1476558745,
0.2016545385,
0.1693265736,
-0.8657403588,
0.5466853976,
-0.469291091,
0.3472158015,
0.9246011376,
0.065492399,
0.1552458555,
-0.1759954691,
0.6681842804,
0.2323820293,
0.2461058497,
0.1528283805,
-0.7924897075,
-0.7542793155,
0.2006381452,
0.0334691592,
0.7344635725,
-0.751506567,
-0.1642211378,
-0.3205314577,
-0.408079356,
-0.3685679138,
-0.0096370103,
0.4651161134,
0.6525779963,
0.3614397645,
-0.3788251281,
0.0239295699,
-1.24971807,
-0.2677398622,
-0.2122776657,
0.0544162393,
0.4179358184,
0.8270948529,
-0.0361083783,
0.6610031724,
-1.0129827261,
-0.476967454,
-0.3381375074,
-0.0902255177,
0.4068050981,
0.1499563605,
0.678642869,
-0.6671024561,
-0.7704966068,
0.1786430478,
-0.6578913331,
-0.0649758652,
0.2793156803,
0.3499672413,
0.52714324,
0.337841332,
-0.5054900646,
0.386998117,
0.6764392257,
-0.4009017944,
0.9453061223,
-0.3152353764,
0.4046756625,
-0.7286947966,
0.2988373041,
0.1541514695,
-0.2117457837,
-0.537825346,
0.0459567718,
-0.0661317408,
-0.0427257791,
-0.324279964,
0.5094988942,
-0.3813436329,
-0.2049333453,
0.0048586535,
0.209738493,
-0.3816367388,
0.2544946969,
0.0599080361,
0.9577206373,
0.9543741345,
-0.3898344636,
0.2907596231,
0.1661410779,
-0.8167821169,
0.3464968503,
-0.9137216806,
-0.2249667645,
0.1401980221,
0.0494801141,
-0.9241683483,
-0.393684715,
0.2838349938,
-0.3623732626,
0.3020429313,
0.2376066744,
-0.5360691547,
-0.6808212996,
-0.1681498289,
0.4536525905,
0.5288826823,
-0.1922789067,
0.3677499294,
0.0773276687,
-0.5057234764,
-0.3460903168,
-0.6905438304,
-0.0070701381,
-0.1727357358,
-0.5626720786,
0.0011812277,
-0.1892947108,
-0.4915662706,
-0.2819870412,
-0.136545226,
-0.0810272023,
-0.0805947334,
-0.0463323444,
0.5468463302,
-0.5147408843,
0.0805804655,
-0.5902684927,
-0.0224105213,
0.0407369994,
0.1482238024,
0.3753355145,
-0.3461778164,
-0.5226920247,
-0.4090874195,
0.2039021999,
0.4716257751,
-0.2644697726,
0.5548493266,
0.5546025634,
0.0182873886,
0.1279351562,
-0.8487607837,
-0.4393866062,
-0.4992608726,
0.4916570783,
-0.2831682861,
-1.1398465633,
0.4808791876,
0.256860882,
0.002349176,
0.3618565202,
0.6575721502,
0.0317269191,
0.6938914657,
0.3667313457,
0.1903803945,
0.1377431452,
-0.128960371,
0.2356639355,
-0.911172688,
-0.1235359237,
-0.078543447,
-0.2595328391,
-0.3940153718,
-0.5110765696,
0.8087877631,
-0.0903923288,
-0.1521594673,
-0.1738957614,
-0.4132716358,
0.3880617321,
0.36417225,
0.2462879121,
0.2917373776,
0.0657684505,
-0.016708523,
0.1467053145,
-0.5350890756,
-0.5555083156,
1.6371728182,
0.6145398021,
0.5517528653,
0.4741119146,
0.1784008145,
-0.1482116133,
0.457670182,
-0.726677537,
0.7599543333,
-0.35450688,
-0.7017922401,
-0.3510762453,
-0.3126428425,
-0.7964454889,
0.5934653282,
-0.1499471664,
-1.0818333626,
0.0251420513,
0.1454109699,
-0.6130358577,
0.2952090204,
-0.6203637719,
0.7513751388,
-0.151363045,
-0.5014952421,
-0.1760786623,
-0.7430102229,
0.4320054054,
-0.4143411815,
0.193315953,
-0.0517033972,
-0.4820777178,
0.7654623389,
0.03060841,
0.795927763,
0.0080360491,
-0.3807930052,
0.1728934348,
-0.0350331441,
-0.1064092368,
0.249432385,
-0.1496958584,
0.4680917859,
0.0587321073,
-0.0504753739,
-0.2810658813,
0.7374586463,
-0.7321454883,
-1.0052057505,
-0.805912137,
-0.3502358496,
-0.3467955887,
0.3129360378,
0.1289034486,
0.7778403759,
0.0501109399,
0.4334890842,
0.5263842344,
-0.4366597533,
0.5182378292,
1.1391061544,
-0.561499536,
-0.5438932776,
0.3541452289,
0.2447843254,
0.6622313261,
0.4152789712,
0.3941057622,
-0.1165445447,
-0.790723443,
-0.6360940337,
0.3517205417,
-0.715321064,
-0.0255194604,
-0.5486012697,
-0.0375099815,
-0.3464496136,
-0.0020587135,
-0.1439877301,
0.0630810037,
-0.0841271207,
-0.0450284258,
0.0948281661,
0.7877035737,
0.1675171107,
0.291566968,
-0.7037733197,
0.2508542836,
0.2033207417,
0.5609440207,
-0.2395502329,
-0.3254165649,
-0.2310014963,
-0.1226986423,
-0.566889286,
-0.9689908624,
0.1969580501,
0.2449491471,
0.4120779932,
0.4811315835,
-0.4079988897,
0.6369552016,
-0.8163874745,
1.2116146088,
0.4832049608,
-0.8165096641,
0.1437128484,
-0.6126284003,
0.3656594157,
0.5305104852,
0.3242176175,
-0.2137084603,
-0.2359251678,
-0.1231029257,
-0.8219460845,
0.6660690904,
-0.0169163495,
-0.1681335866,
-0.0390666276,
0.3153238893,
0.0643834025,
0.2853656113,
-0.8122420907,
-0.3979553878,
0.2908227742,
0.0061518969,
-0.5925655365,
-0.3391568959,
-0.2045782954,
-0.3544069231,
0.2582435608,
-0.1844196618,
0.1313251853,
0.3232426345,
0.2282180041,
-0.2067938,
0.4650356472,
0.8876716495,
1.3078446388,
-0.1644938141,
-0.0580852963,
0.3193532825,
-0.8256343603,
-0.029721383,
-0.1397423893,
0.1289196014,
-0.046099849,
0.5930083394,
0.6490578651,
0.3956365883,
-0.8297063112,
0.8479734063,
0.2712001503,
-0.6536464691,
-0.3010481,
0.0730394199,
0.0260810312,
0.0092241168,
0.5878735185,
0.0097316699,
0.3959621191,
-0.5141845345,
-0.1619404852,
0.1641063094,
-0.1645119935,
-0.1615266353,
0.5113642812,
0.0725765303,
0.2736374736,
0.4121460319,
0.4339368045,
-0.5013782382,
0.610008955,
0.589179039,
0.3745966256,
-0.3957510889,
0.1517919004,
0.5823646188,
0.3333836794,
-0.2688373029,
0.4984257221,
0.4297751784,
-0.6235504746,
-0.3748283088,
-0.6522974372,
-0.4132874906,
0.1278660893,
-0.8760008216,
-0.0729769021,
-0.2303613871,
-0.4015535414,
0.2364280522,
-0.0266617779,
-0.5348854661,
0.4470818043,
-0.0752724335,
1.2063498497,
-0.5067412853,
0.6154004335,
1.0641920567,
-0.5155422091,
-0.7353189588,
-0.0019802221,
0.0430072136,
-0.9339236021,
0.8906443119,
0.3624549508,
-0.0836574212,
-0.0166131593,
-0.3135857582,
-0.7638876438,
1.226631403,
0.1980883181,
-0.824108839,
-0.1670669019,
0.1883618683,
0.6468074322,
-0.1328486502,
0.2234085053,
0.3994061649,
0.4129958153,
-0.2398443967,
-1.6511454582,
-0.2405535728,
-0.1363102794,
-0.0140064908,
0.2487800121,
-0.6272052526,
0.9621169567,
-0.4013154805,
-0.0511844531,
0.3223352432,
0.0396584272,
0.4334549308,
0.2188612074,
0.3028250635,
0.4278832972,
0.2226132154,
-0.2796925604,
1.1388914585,
-0.4506147802,
0.3760672808,
0.6556586027,
-0.43020913,
1.3739327192,
0.6844446659,
-0.4253448844,
0.2733648121,
0.648211062,
0.0228090994,
0.1966493726,
0.3350518346,
-0.247412011,
-0.3164438903,
0.3883979917,
-0.77835536,
0.5360421538,
0.127813682,
-0.4298000634,
0.1779293865,
0.2137340009,
-0.0962679386,
-0.0085946759,
-0.538226366,
0.7678857446,
0.2814174891,
-0.7928711772,
0.4660792649,
0.0189492833,
0.4690538645,
-0.7613087893,
0.1844705492,
0.0908650085,
0.5113450885,
-0.254660517,
-1.3359019756,
0.0489866622,
-0.0828736201,
-0.0286033843,
-0.0347752161,
0.1022120714,
-0.3465127051,
-0.4027425647,
0.3206413686,
0.3091061413,
0.2470461577,
0.1162241772,
-0.3694365919,
0.1322454214,
-0.1558949798,
-0.5122435093,
0.1970997602,
0.017670121,
0.1791781634,
1.0005195141,
0.4848080575,
0.4454727769,
-0.1097569168,
-0.011821745,
0.8141242862,
-0.3924382329,
-0.4183036983,
-0.9794252515,
0.1676461548,
-0.0874942839,
-0.5857744217,
0.84835428,
0.7428668141,
0.7859122753,
-0.5529689789,
0.5482620001,
0.2753147781,
0.4366708696,
-0.7017694116,
0.5187866688,
-0.6487205029,
0.2085949928,
-0.4923794866,
-0.9652473927,
-0.5647078753,
0.8422877192,
-0.7208741307,
0.3117564321,
0.9102742076,
0.4967081547,
-0.00539986,
0.0490994863,
0.6296426654,
0.2863102555,
0.0879475996,
0.7098457217,
0.5364633203,
-0.0675036982,
0.1726700664,
-0.0373617746,
-0.2915282845,
-0.5062211752,
-0.4117333293,
-0.8678649664,
-0.2613207102,
-0.3220968544,
-0.1572659165,
-0.0502220057,
0.784250617,
0.6199831367,
-0.6243453026,
-0.3346277177,
0.2728230953,
-0.6199060678,
-0.0166620594,
-0.1598908454,
0.4846787453,
0.1039386839,
-0.4669398069,
0.2108631581,
0.5775335431,
0.1152432784,
-0.4690736234,
0.0100350929,
-0.0124236345,
-0.0857363418,
0.7373749018,
-0.047998134,
-1.1248190403,
-0.2445767671,
0.1371166855,
-0.3284840584,
0.1312967986,
0.430423826,
-0.3417065144,
0.4952482581,
0.1418453455,
0.2652592361,
-0.0042631314,
0.0510770157,
0.5247842073,
0.0539649725,
-0.1403219402,
0.175878644,
0.4420704544,
0.3054242432,
-0.0549384579,
0.592807591,
0.1867506653,
-0.7112326026,
-0.589196384,
0.3211996555,
-1.2916371822,
-0.370549202,
1.4490866661,
-0.2077326328,
0.0773444548,
-0.0694443136,
-0.5525995493,
-0.2388109714,
-0.1953954101,
0.4398809373,
0.7650612593,
-0.074735947,
-0.4032891393,
-1.0516115427,
0.2893081307,
0.3081811965,
-0.9032825232,
-0.3183342814,
0.5372980833,
0.614058435,
0.0507542677,
0.9037021399,
-0.3868831992,
0.5106883049,
-0.257130295,
-0.168001771,
-0.1441268325,
-0.0122096604,
-0.1719124913,
0.4184520245,
0.1397614479,
-0.1098996997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04088v1
|
Personality Style Recognition via Machine Learning: Identifying Anaclitic and Introjective Personality Styles from Patients' Speech
| 2023-11-07T15:56:19 | 2023-11-07T15:56:19 |
Semere Kiros Bitew, Vincent Schelstraete, Klim Zaporojets, Kimberly Van Nieuwenhove, Reitske Meganck, Chris Develder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In disentangling the heterogeneity observed in psychopathology, personality
of the patients is considered crucial. While it has been demonstrated that
personality traits are reflected in the language used by a patient, we
hypothesize that this enables automatic inference of the personality type
directly from speech utterances, potentially more accurately than through a
traditional questionnaire-based approach explicitly designed for personality
classification. To validate this hypothesis, we adopt natural language
processing (NLP) and standard machine learning tools for classification. We
test this on a dataset of recorded clinical diagnostic interviews (CDI) on a
sample of 79 patients diagnosed with major depressive disorder (MDD) -- a
condition for which differentiated treatment based on personality styles has
been advocated -- and classified into anaclitic and introjective personality
styles. We start by analyzing the interviews to see which linguistic features
are associated with each style, in order to gain a better understanding of the
styles. Then, we develop automatic classifiers based on (a) standardized
questionnaire responses; (b) basic text features, i.e., TF-IDF scores of words
and word sequences; (c) more advanced text features, using LIWC (linguistic
inquiry and word count) and context-aware features using BERT (bidirectional
encoder representations from transformers); (d) audio features. We find that
automated classification with language-derived features (i.e., based on LIWC)
significantly outperforms questionnaire-based classification models.
Furthermore, the best performance is achieved by combining LIWC with the
questionnaire features. This suggests that more work should be put into
developing linguistically based automated techniques for characterizing
personality, however questionnaires still to some extent complement such
methods.
|
[
-0.6592376828,
-0.9405882955,
0.5681151152,
0.2158843428,
0.0964692459,
0.3255482912,
-0.4358573258,
-0.4552180767,
0.3713013828,
0.4026265442,
-0.7470135689,
-0.567409277,
-0.736205101,
0.3186866045,
-0.3731534481,
0.8994156718,
-0.0128078386,
0.4691058695,
-0.1607582271,
-0.2026263028,
-0.4913875759,
-0.7615048289,
-0.7315818667,
-0.5253239274,
0.5236132145,
0.3618742228,
0.7045362592,
0.4790915251,
0.3324143887,
0.3317332566,
0.0430567861,
0.0541375466,
-0.0196802523,
0.1695538759,
0.0793275237,
-0.3300459087,
-0.3124221265,
0.2134873122,
0.2244033217,
0.9206869006,
-0.0079697771,
0.119653292,
0.1240502968,
0.7113552094,
-0.2738415003,
0.1229364499,
-0.1164195314,
0.3807584941,
-0.2129130363,
-0.1479634643,
-0.3306868374,
-0.5217495561,
0.3398418725,
-0.0991372094,
0.2188460976,
-0.1378457695,
0.6545835137,
0.3487062454,
-0.4825416803,
-0.5579984188,
-1.0237364769,
0.6221315861,
-0.5247828364,
0.1678121686,
0.7274385095,
0.5321629643,
0.1301741302,
-0.2379363328,
-0.5852577686,
-0.047252845,
-0.37161538,
-0.1407048255,
-0.3319871128,
0.0485906005,
0.2544394732,
0.4083517492,
-0.911752522,
0.3363996744,
-0.2058983296,
-0.1995754987,
0.8519070148,
0.2315620929,
0.1898627132,
-0.1997956634,
0.2168278545,
-0.100343883,
-0.2371214032,
-0.0337191261,
0.3478149474,
0.0656359792,
0.0364571549,
0.5005680919,
-0.2129432708,
0.4629701674,
0.351674825,
-0.3632756174,
0.3043475449,
-0.0542134158,
-0.1202721521,
0.3914504945,
0.7305626273,
0.1952887028,
0.4776574671,
-0.1546847373,
0.0944638029,
0.2096564174,
0.328086704,
-0.5875605941,
-0.4435252249,
0.6171471477,
-0.7247848511,
-0.2675389051,
-0.1524666697,
-0.8311696053,
-0.609818399,
-0.6772646904,
0.0038700774,
-0.6738200784,
-0.2379998416,
-0.2144467682,
-0.1425992846,
0.3047128022,
0.2753244936,
-0.8453767896,
0.3855504692,
0.4213155508,
0.7869834304,
-0.335016638,
0.0406795777,
-0.3037819862,
-0.2042861581,
-0.3257645667,
0.8107299209,
-0.4970340729,
-0.3886311948,
0.167287603,
-0.0090766931,
-0.0092155067,
-0.7632701397,
0.3959200382,
-0.018096121,
0.458628267,
-0.2327007502,
-0.6122378707,
-0.080857195,
0.1463659406,
-0.5335430503,
0.6205878854,
0.4241139591,
-0.6699655652,
0.3911728859,
-0.6030849814,
-0.5236884952,
0.1208294034,
-0.2118960768,
-0.480710119,
-0.0537373237,
-0.0421637706,
0.735730648,
0.0392487459,
0.215836525,
-0.5091665983,
-0.153929919,
0.5461434126,
-0.1428851932,
0.805606842,
0.2835295498,
-0.2402316183,
0.1166303977,
-1.0245610476,
0.0472445004,
0.0585550778,
-0.2017500848,
-0.4219924212,
0.1158661619,
0.2734787762,
0.2619301081,
0.058611881,
-0.5350595117,
0.070822008,
-0.3123053312,
0.3226270974,
0.6268420219,
-0.0345139541,
0.2289693207,
-0.3887190819,
0.4514803886,
0.0895196795,
0.0138473408,
0.134771958,
-0.4493145943,
-0.5484003425,
-0.6982987523,
0.1519414186,
0.8680090904,
-0.2987999916,
1.1409168243,
0.2161076814,
-0.6973193288,
-0.6012552381,
-0.0099342829,
0.4425616264,
0.4856829643,
0.5204808116,
-0.4451237023,
-0.8716935515,
-0.9449457526,
-0.0801867098,
-0.0907960907,
-0.2340857387,
0.5308890939,
0.3459271491,
-0.5263596773,
1.0501127243,
-0.5852459073,
-0.1922149509,
-0.3951487541,
0.4456135929,
0.0031097289,
0.5096197724,
0.5134350657,
-0.6690967679,
-0.4891134799,
-0.0711525902,
-0.7154641151,
-0.2362151146,
0.0718229488,
0.2217818052,
0.2648682892,
0.4017161429,
-0.2291934043,
0.5450740457,
0.3381755352,
-0.4947084486,
0.6735469699,
-0.1203849837,
-0.2061954141,
-0.8708038926,
0.1048400477,
0.1450544596,
-0.3117820024,
-0.7494440675,
-0.6068320274,
-0.3103667498,
-0.0867289528,
0.11983338,
0.3384052217,
-0.1342434883,
-0.1587199122,
-0.2506478131,
-0.1793463677,
-0.1083612517,
0.4157307148,
0.2784227133,
0.3006224632,
0.621103406,
-0.7345812917,
0.5194490552,
0.4557180703,
-0.2640886605,
1.1483169794,
-0.5019339323,
0.352784723,
-0.3645786345,
0.3287578523,
-1.1697635651,
-0.2930898964,
0.1531179398,
-0.4498650134,
0.3748658001,
-0.0258882567,
-0.4824619591,
-0.2129808068,
0.0744028389,
-0.0860592723,
0.5598929524,
-0.1712010652,
0.5259118676,
0.3524310589,
-0.4516825676,
-0.073812224,
-0.6540453434,
0.0106674433,
-0.5169354081,
-0.2976951301,
0.3560985625,
-0.3150996268,
-0.5498828292,
-0.3504080474,
0.1809377819,
-0.4490655959,
0.3722735345,
0.2930577695,
0.3374140263,
0.0323086083,
0.2090436667,
0.2592324615,
-0.0546627231,
0.2135098428,
0.1305007488,
0.9669823647,
-0.2076448798,
-0.0294537488,
-0.6901555061,
0.6666065454,
0.5099756718,
-0.2950346768,
0.6871240735,
0.8690736294,
-0.2413647622,
-0.0391298123,
-0.4552242756,
-0.3097526133,
-0.3483752906,
0.2418838292,
-0.2389765531,
-0.6618455052,
0.4478011131,
-0.1197714433,
-0.254763335,
0.1322260648,
0.6665677428,
-0.3725391626,
1.4069547653,
0.7013605237,
-0.0981860831,
0.5042632222,
-0.2205174565,
0.1581997573,
-0.687163353,
-0.0088850157,
-0.5826895833,
-0.6025664806,
-0.9282236099,
0.1340985894,
0.2891002595,
-0.3993575275,
-0.2798138261,
0.1995818615,
-0.6220476031,
0.0490617268,
0.3077217638,
0.1923034191,
0.2122299522,
-0.4102889001,
0.0970773101,
-0.1994099617,
-0.0674888194,
-0.6735160351,
1.1680372953,
0.4841255248,
0.4540379047,
0.1677757353,
0.8503918052,
0.4773931801,
0.4139338434,
-1.0236327648,
0.3731839955,
-0.1647755653,
-0.5171728134,
-0.1387654692,
-0.2660496235,
-0.668600738,
-0.0183153823,
-0.2082091123,
-0.7859279513,
0.5743453503,
0.048637148,
-0.3808232546,
-0.2112414241,
-0.6407902241,
0.9074148536,
-0.2080513984,
0.2984194458,
-0.1974470168,
-0.9382898211,
0.1654363871,
-0.0920283869,
0.1242136136,
-0.0592785031,
0.174156785,
0.7372320294,
-0.2554381192,
0.7218756676,
-0.2256392986,
0.0232114401,
-0.3209342062,
0.2460013181,
-0.0071999258,
-0.0201203469,
0.0100455247,
0.0860552117,
0.4536335468,
-0.0917204618,
-0.7647433877,
0.3121241629,
-0.8900691867,
-0.12217585,
-0.4589159191,
-0.398304671,
-0.6291143298,
0.0993342698,
0.3851999342,
0.477502197,
-0.6186504364,
0.0615320317,
0.7762160301,
-0.2010775357,
0.2448989898,
0.6490998864,
-0.2613039911,
-0.2510688901,
0.7082700729,
0.0814415216,
0.2169829458,
0.2141079754,
0.4511737823,
-0.1338041425,
-0.4618724585,
-0.1760309488,
0.3774193823,
-0.5625509024,
0.1995479912,
-0.7136947513,
-0.1869808882,
-0.553835094,
-0.1565615535,
-0.1613211632,
-0.3855721056,
-0.3513338268,
0.0194916185,
0.1836065799,
0.5252925754,
0.0821406841,
0.1200833544,
-0.3169680536,
0.2610275447,
0.2351360172,
-0.0264766309,
-0.2083310038,
-0.4285912812,
0.0753444955,
-0.1989063025,
-0.4967603683,
-1.0822604895,
0.7124711871,
0.4641091526,
0.2480400056,
0.8915560842,
-0.0517219752,
0.3532208502,
-0.4606505632,
0.4905749857,
-0.0632618442,
-0.8364346623,
0.8142430186,
0.0399231426,
-0.0075816792,
0.6831863523,
0.9372455478,
-0.8601698875,
-0.3685920238,
-0.7724175453,
-0.3187872767,
0.5674346089,
-0.0746810958,
-0.1669311076,
-0.2791733444,
0.3736352623,
0.2323549837,
0.3177223802,
-0.2878842056,
-0.5847321749,
-0.3780227602,
-0.6181368828,
-0.3053377569,
0.0123132206,
-0.3763450086,
-0.5622141957,
0.2940670252,
-0.477168411,
0.6022219658,
0.4877047539,
-0.0150311813,
0.0502981283,
0.4053112268,
0.4182804525,
0.5245954394,
-0.479055196,
0.0925399736,
-0.1392815411,
-0.3522320092,
0.0616595335,
0.3820842505,
0.0270582512,
0.3324146271,
0.2004381567,
0.6386289001,
-0.18635571,
-0.8732790947,
0.521525085,
-0.1972258836,
-0.1044476032,
-0.724907577,
0.0142518012,
-0.2536176443,
0.2511496544,
0.0638193563,
0.1476366669,
0.4451005459,
-0.9140605927,
0.1308159828,
0.4941228926,
-0.6599285007,
-0.3454188406,
0.0609941483,
-0.1455644518,
-0.5630730987,
0.5494675636,
-0.2387762815,
-0.4223711789,
0.4540895224,
0.4378249347,
1.0700833797,
-0.3958432972,
0.4767614901,
0.1834165007,
-0.3295273483,
0.1671314836,
0.2730362415,
-0.2422999144,
-0.8203698993,
-0.0015067725,
-0.6655081511,
-0.6544302106,
0.0475291014,
-0.8541353345,
0.2191814333,
-0.8261743188,
-0.0621631444,
0.3244019747,
0.063781105,
-0.7318174243,
0.2531878054,
0.4337606728,
0.482183367,
-0.8850592971,
0.7462356687,
0.850456059,
-0.2162418813,
-0.4515776932,
-0.0113292066,
0.502796948,
-0.6405513287,
0.689453125,
0.3481949866,
0.2238006443,
-0.0281814616,
-0.5142740607,
-0.653422296,
0.8879324794,
0.0079200212,
-0.2073172331,
-0.1246340275,
-0.0103901895,
0.869301796,
-0.6185629964,
0.3013314903,
0.898630321,
0.5068857074,
-0.015691096,
-1.0829876661,
-0.0454023667,
-0.1811970919,
0.015884595,
0.0452035107,
-0.1410908997,
0.695112884,
-0.0812850744,
-0.1602152735,
0.1836156696,
0.4583376646,
0.0617559366,
0.3535075188,
0.5984683633,
0.4508428276,
1.0665837526,
-0.0804295316,
1.0060881376,
-0.1989612728,
0.1344335228,
0.793059051,
-0.4090548456,
0.7500346303,
0.0622263663,
-0.2488554269,
0.9920303226,
0.5667369366,
-0.1049047709,
0.5331956744,
0.2588334382,
-0.2122134715,
0.0393335074,
-0.1879671365,
-0.036908526,
0.8182861209,
0.4176369905,
-0.5830463171,
0.1412089616,
0.4808427393,
0.4018861353,
0.1075231805,
-0.0687154904,
1.0390001535,
-0.0787775591,
-0.6171332598,
0.4922603667,
-0.0309465211,
0.715711534,
-0.5818529129,
0.163150236,
-0.033452522,
0.3605491221,
-0.3318205476,
-0.6460713744,
0.6942760348,
-0.0337538533,
-0.3173371851,
-0.3849709332,
0.551869452,
-0.4251413643,
-0.3635742664,
0.1120789126,
0.4310549796,
0.2554939687,
-0.3049969673,
-0.6475583911,
-0.2484169006,
-0.2926310599,
0.0984125957,
0.4984644949,
0.2524442375,
0.2432958335,
0.6441733241,
0.4235322475,
0.214642331,
-0.3456480503,
0.0797738805,
0.599732697,
-0.6881430745,
-0.5223717093,
-0.8447191119,
0.1793946773,
-0.1493596882,
-0.5557798147,
0.5858772397,
0.266078949,
0.5218750834,
0.0204185992,
0.7076154351,
-0.1951427013,
0.9727346897,
-0.3079247475,
0.5949732661,
-0.3101536334,
-0.2106328458,
-0.5623409748,
-0.5818703771,
-0.179745391,
0.8243396878,
-0.4357803166,
0.0220693722,
0.8240547776,
0.4563150108,
0.2753323615,
0.1628233641,
-0.0000805358,
0.2846029103,
0.4476340711,
0.464116931,
0.4976410866,
0.0418369584,
0.0983589515,
-0.5280781388,
-0.6161670685,
-0.1997624189,
-0.5052406192,
-0.8291788101,
-0.855025351,
-0.5116222501,
-0.3924599588,
-0.2262930274,
1.0541902781,
0.617632091,
-0.722900331,
-0.2004451901,
0.0771627948,
0.0906032696,
-0.6167367101,
-0.3396624625,
0.2119890898,
-0.1590789109,
-0.6288784146,
0.2851829827,
0.298985064,
-0.0034681291,
-0.7670125365,
0.0795796812,
-0.1139164194,
-0.0138230501,
0.6032934785,
0.3838685453,
-0.660866797,
-0.1995891184,
-0.0903596058,
-0.0338337086,
0.2704431713,
0.9489428997,
-0.8247640729,
0.2651670277,
0.2464746386,
0.4862305224,
0.0230261032,
0.0831389353,
0.4424177706,
-0.5413162112,
-0.0737007782,
0.7275564671,
0.3327391744,
0.4239249229,
-0.544718504,
0.1763669103,
0.3942426145,
-0.6398081183,
-0.7169200778,
0.3852184713,
-1.1519082785,
-0.3599409759,
1.0230265856,
0.0020282539,
-0.1694414467,
-0.6814144254,
-0.4748556614,
0.0729376301,
-0.1837530732,
0.8219506145,
0.7254198194,
-0.7283193469,
-0.136160776,
-0.364395529,
0.7494699359,
0.2157944441,
-0.8360631466,
0.053295061,
0.4232867658,
0.3218889534,
0.4380559623,
0.4872911274,
-0.2489434481,
0.1652873605,
-0.5403588414,
0.0698080063,
0.2370454073,
-0.0750805438,
-0.3643409014,
0.0812424943,
-0.1430110335,
0.0958319902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04076v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04076v5
|
Do LLMs exhibit human-like response biases? A case study in survey design
| 2023-11-07T15:40:43 | 2024-02-06T04:16:17 |
Lindia Tjuatja, Valerie Chen, Sherry Tongshuang Wu, Ameet Talwalkar, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As large language models (LLMs) become more capable, there is growing
excitement about the possibility of using LLMs as proxies for humans in
real-world tasks where subjective labels are desired, such as in surveys and
opinion polling. One widely-cited barrier to the adoption of LLMs as proxies
for humans in subjective tasks is their sensitivity to prompt wording - but
interestingly, humans also display sensitivities to instruction changes in the
form of response biases. We investigate the extent to which LLMs reflect human
response biases, if at all. We look to survey design, where human response
biases caused by changes in the wordings of "prompts" have been extensively
explored in social psychology literature. Drawing from these works, we design a
dataset and framework to evaluate whether LLMs exhibit human-like response
biases in survey questionnaires. Our comprehensive evaluation of nine models
shows that popular open and commercial LLMs generally fail to reflect
human-like behavior, particularly in models that have undergone RLHF.
Furthermore, even if a model shows a significant change in the same direction
as humans, we find that they are sensitive to perturbations that do not elicit
significant changes in humans. These results highlight the pitfalls of using
LLMs as human proxies, and underscore the need for finer-grained
characterizations of model behavior. Our code, dataset, and collected samples
are available at https://github.com/lindiatjuatja/BiasMonkey
|
[
-0.5977373123,
-0.667137742,
0.5814117789,
0.052856233,
-0.154200539,
-0.1406604797,
-0.2665644288,
-0.5017066002,
0.3215441108,
0.4300047457,
-0.9175242186,
-0.2929034829,
-0.3287169933,
0.3861719072,
-0.1463351399,
0.9285312891,
0.2076775879,
0.4658502936,
-0.4129580855,
-0.0923931897,
-0.2465207726,
-0.8149467111,
-0.4247233272,
-0.5360665917,
0.8356257677,
0.4091826081,
0.7139332294,
0.2014185935,
0.2651754022,
0.0902456418,
-0.1869265586,
-0.070650138,
-0.4069064558,
0.3489791751,
-0.0369164124,
-0.7824674249,
-0.454518795,
0.2763541639,
0.3151400089,
0.9566358924,
0.1129909232,
0.5529580116,
0.3620277941,
0.7036347985,
-0.471038729,
0.0026081307,
-0.2136749327,
0.118157357,
-0.315998584,
-0.0576972403,
-0.2286172211,
-0.5021961927,
0.2331976891,
-0.4081084728,
0.6783158779,
0.1935604066,
0.3629407585,
0.1704322547,
-0.338519007,
-0.3750437796,
-0.4401938319,
0.7504166961,
-0.6280717254,
0.3757502139,
0.507442832,
0.0667131543,
-0.3909395635,
-0.1783963144,
-0.4389101863,
-0.4237306118,
-0.0753940418,
-0.0035307347,
0.1416070908,
0.0516986288,
0.5225944519,
0.0069163805,
-0.6880047917,
0.3241191506,
-0.0722477436,
-0.2939459383,
0.6212249994,
0.5651971102,
0.1343000233,
-0.2883821726,
-0.3349337578,
-0.1224661097,
-0.9117138982,
0.5487612486,
0.6177253723,
0.394551754,
-0.1827471256,
0.5390994549,
-0.1832880229,
0.857483387,
0.173702538,
0.0474232733,
-0.0742488876,
0.0365694426,
0.0321627036,
-0.1283424497,
0.5853589177,
0.715185523,
0.6179799438,
0.0408535786,
-0.2792814672,
0.1232133061,
0.0628329962,
-0.590575695,
-0.1783290505,
0.0512905642,
-0.627809763,
-0.4059112072,
0.0187544376,
-0.6968581676,
-0.9387013912,
-0.294323951,
-0.1279842705,
0.4205290377,
-0.1804971397,
0.1872420609,
-0.0447475538,
0.4627006948,
0.3196023405,
-0.7785452604,
0.3724333346,
0.4869015813,
0.4732881784,
-0.3958641887,
-0.2166442871,
-0.431213975,
-0.4487915039,
-0.2937440872,
0.9388380647,
-0.5879101157,
-0.935608089,
0.0145967426,
0.0051877056,
0.2387450188,
-0.8844217062,
0.5200191736,
-0.5681192279,
0.4212699234,
-0.9629095793,
-0.1860137731,
0.2236923873,
0.4625303745,
-0.4481467307,
0.8263673782,
0.0548784845,
-0.9655433893,
0.2876160145,
-0.3790898025,
-0.2432962209,
-0.2502968311,
-0.436060518,
-0.2999035418,
0.1266878098,
0.0961531699,
0.2352300584,
-0.5690934658,
0.1211208254,
-0.6109589338,
-0.6097815037,
1.0992398262,
-0.4441505969,
0.9320859313,
0.0744285733,
-0.1449603587,
0.1275177002,
-0.4292468727,
-0.2270001769,
0.1654521376,
-0.5358425975,
-0.3863294125,
0.1399643123,
-0.0229497962,
0.2918107808,
0.0319093838,
-0.5935277939,
0.3276222348,
-0.2371258587,
0.2528861165,
0.9886935353,
-0.077101104,
0.4422676563,
-0.5293586254,
0.819242835,
-0.0997696593,
0.1708693206,
0.048696477,
-0.6495485306,
-0.5523837209,
0.0820983201,
0.0864472389,
0.3582832813,
-0.3276343048,
0.1522385627,
0.0708325058,
-0.047948759,
-0.3344689608,
0.0725458488,
0.3790079653,
0.5841299295,
-0.0006148182,
-0.2229858339,
-0.439236939,
-1.0968774557,
-0.5949167013,
-0.3901743293,
-0.6059259772,
0.5360565186,
0.1824153066,
-0.0955315977,
1.1441437006,
-0.6628848314,
-0.082680352,
-0.1382866204,
0.1479631364,
0.1960206926,
-0.0542655773,
0.5157242417,
-0.4925534427,
0.0579276979,
-0.7851098776,
-0.4364822507,
-0.7311656475,
0.1484250277,
-0.104938522,
0.0137502383,
0.3917397559,
-0.5528140664,
0.195458442,
0.3363730311,
-0.4371129274,
0.8341020942,
0.3058470786,
-0.1786901206,
-0.9067795277,
-0.1626827717,
0.2378351688,
-0.1054605991,
-0.4105332494,
-0.0034061032,
-0.0720044598,
0.078492105,
-0.5463593602,
0.782420218,
-0.5240921974,
-0.3255479336,
-0.3036376238,
0.1815910786,
0.0000737404,
0.3727399111,
0.1418776214,
0.862349987,
0.25824821,
-0.7633662224,
0.3245860636,
0.2193605155,
-0.0230292082,
0.8885375857,
-0.7273710966,
0.4898465872,
-0.5233027935,
0.6828894019,
-1.0535675287,
-0.4310346544,
0.6777167916,
-0.5360264182,
-0.1276371032,
0.0600720085,
-0.332514286,
-0.6235319972,
-0.7941014767,
0.2377517074,
0.4229162335,
-0.3385220766,
0.2860391736,
0.2825880051,
-0.203944549,
-0.3241192997,
-0.7942476869,
0.0310368985,
-0.2946969867,
-0.3690236211,
-0.0604349039,
-0.3176760972,
-0.5456825495,
-0.2664485574,
-0.2272178531,
-0.0043380139,
0.0707303807,
0.3512430489,
0.4751512706,
0.025490148,
0.0709948614,
-0.3419034779,
0.1412680149,
0.6206361055,
0.176874578,
0.5818135142,
0.1347928941,
-0.6379631162,
-0.3639467061,
0.2307589203,
0.5113122463,
0.0933188573,
0.1965925097,
0.3077559173,
-0.1830040365,
-0.001145797,
-0.6322209835,
-0.7141299844,
-0.4265814126,
0.2794939578,
-0.2402773052,
-1.0051642656,
0.6206252575,
0.2323174328,
0.1160258949,
-0.0694694296,
0.5887641907,
-0.4824517071,
1.1405718327,
0.0487074666,
-0.2600563765,
0.5090064406,
0.1826584935,
-0.1281286925,
-1.0657821894,
-0.197981745,
-0.8240046501,
-0.6292493343,
-0.6397740245,
-0.2713172734,
0.4355721176,
-0.3731486797,
-0.3992831409,
-0.4164045155,
-0.3490687907,
0.2918510437,
0.5501127243,
0.2671557665,
0.1055729911,
-0.0689891949,
0.2257063687,
-0.2558734417,
-0.6020839214,
-0.5415976644,
1.106205225,
0.302567631,
1.2959206104,
0.10122329,
0.5578914881,
0.5342885256,
0.5114944577,
-0.8254902959,
0.7145638466,
0.2524386644,
-0.7245290279,
-0.2421646416,
-0.1888973266,
-1.1065679789,
0.2562422752,
-0.2446402907,
-0.5796859264,
0.2892129421,
0.2974720597,
-0.292824626,
-0.0383680426,
-0.4740680754,
0.3233290315,
-0.2946218848,
-0.5439237952,
0.1937467605,
-0.7463277578,
0.4035032392,
0.0600039363,
0.240462482,
-0.1366951764,
-0.0464493446,
0.7489785552,
-0.1303281933,
1.4127107859,
-0.3813671172,
-0.3652940989,
0.3312449157,
0.1807771325,
0.6652764082,
0.1710445583,
-0.083953768,
-0.2113778591,
-0.3213787377,
-0.4883295,
-0.4761839807,
0.531529665,
-0.7696450949,
-0.8298974633,
-0.4242157936,
-0.4645840228,
-0.4481228888,
-0.0887932256,
0.1875673681,
0.2858349383,
-0.372944355,
-0.1455861181,
1.0119274855,
-0.2766648829,
0.25024575,
0.7854293585,
-0.3707647324,
0.116567038,
0.350673914,
0.0235738512,
0.2417588383,
-0.013990717,
0.3155018389,
-0.5856654644,
-0.1069647521,
-0.667750299,
0.2298829556,
-0.4477294385,
-0.0559335276,
-0.2347481102,
0.1564243734,
-0.4046773016,
-0.0012687014,
0.0662368014,
-0.0602539815,
-0.6562330723,
-0.0272694174,
0.1876596957,
1.0609550476,
0.2889763117,
0.0301132798,
-0.5526495576,
0.5137963891,
0.6710591316,
0.3277161121,
0.044935666,
-0.632332623,
0.1723462641,
0.2946687043,
-0.118210867,
-1.100497365,
-0.0308220703,
-0.1448875368,
0.5565833449,
0.3627219498,
0.2965556085,
0.3476223052,
-0.1573956907,
1.0791316032,
-0.0439058952,
-0.4237659872,
0.2293473631,
-0.5966569185,
0.5522421002,
0.315872997,
0.1993816793,
-0.8451862335,
-0.3425600827,
-0.1845249981,
-0.4594393075,
0.8080987334,
-0.4323163927,
0.3462416828,
-0.1430217922,
0.492428273,
0.1265655458,
0.2601933181,
-0.6224960685,
-0.2495492697,
-0.032921277,
0.1771386415,
0.086777471,
-0.606090188,
-0.1214624345,
0.0518961325,
0.2387392372,
-0.1188538745,
0.0736713409,
0.3133474886,
-0.1031532511,
-0.2578248382,
0.558655858,
0.7106916904,
0.5815511942,
-0.2781140208,
0.3543480039,
0.2845363915,
-0.4179244637,
0.3962635696,
-0.1772075444,
-0.399325341,
-0.1451737732,
0.2354314774,
0.3633215725,
0.2501709759,
-0.6324685216,
0.5200257897,
-0.2261281013,
-0.1295429915,
-0.2243100554,
0.0719614625,
0.3299233615,
0.1195605844,
0.3840352595,
-0.0672982633,
0.2573914528,
-0.5464631319,
-0.4353595376,
0.6896274686,
-0.3155549467,
-0.5850760937,
0.7745933533,
0.4061708748,
-0.6583801508,
0.5124191642,
-0.2618547976,
-0.3915176094,
0.448869288,
0.485117346,
0.8867558241,
-0.2078581452,
0.2031546533,
0.0103382226,
0.2196541131,
-0.0762655661,
0.4381643236,
-0.1481942981,
-0.7543746829,
-0.1374113113,
-0.4467086494,
-0.6192035675,
0.1842465103,
-0.7805661559,
0.0353143848,
-0.3890885413,
-0.5382015109,
-0.4798436463,
-0.320304513,
-0.8759920597,
0.080512315,
0.436973542,
0.8676517606,
-1.1358517408,
0.4656917751,
1.1761944294,
-0.1087357029,
-0.4697063267,
0.4224916399,
0.3630202711,
-0.6404887438,
0.6784363985,
0.0009097085,
-0.3631201088,
-0.380224973,
-0.6965836287,
-0.6940971017,
0.7109259367,
0.3614497185,
-0.5343366265,
-0.1507308334,
0.5021645427,
0.5246884227,
-0.1203676611,
0.2057284713,
0.6604114771,
0.4650555551,
-0.3457329869,
-0.7820272446,
0.0827750936,
-0.0407933891,
0.1842637658,
-0.1685023606,
-0.7449178696,
0.7981081009,
-0.1489712447,
0.0012060991,
-0.1362921596,
0.4717498422,
0.5988783836,
0.5119515657,
0.6381855607,
0.30602476,
0.6168007255,
0.0250779912,
0.9974094033,
0.0688597858,
0.0716899708,
1.0593645573,
-0.5911159515,
0.5389181972,
0.5485264659,
-0.5583726764,
0.3674036562,
0.8462606668,
0.5685499907,
0.1355375648,
0.752133131,
-0.417735368,
-0.2031861693,
-0.4216013551,
-0.2322812229,
0.2416801304,
0.2906424999,
-0.1968286037,
-0.233122021,
-0.031732019,
0.1041215807,
0.0611719042,
-0.364802748,
0.611230731,
0.1210477203,
-0.7871564031,
0.4523935318,
-0.1605347991,
0.9959527254,
-0.4121211171,
0.1558247507,
-0.6244528294,
-0.2521568537,
-0.2770156264,
-0.9415047169,
-0.133231774,
0.1261158139,
-0.4697157145,
-0.3179160357,
0.6701235771,
-0.0411744043,
-0.3174984157,
0.0754578114,
0.7344998121,
0.2320950627,
-0.0538051985,
-0.5472272038,
0.1420340538,
0.1375287175,
-0.6701588631,
0.6439296603,
-0.011299165,
-0.4330305755,
0.6465488672,
0.6178411245,
0.2040636241,
0.0815769285,
0.446444571,
0.915749073,
-0.6382315755,
-0.2155537903,
-0.8079963326,
0.1737063974,
0.1065217331,
-0.30944556,
0.6003884673,
0.4297962785,
0.7333652973,
-0.202268824,
0.841407001,
0.3319011331,
0.8214950562,
-0.3069362938,
0.3926577568,
-0.182992965,
0.4210731089,
-0.187853992,
-1.0786538124,
-0.1539216638,
0.3558361828,
-0.4431553185,
0.1051005349,
0.1705070436,
1.029515624,
0.1606310755,
-0.0455338955,
0.0859069377,
0.0297782924,
0.2991034985,
0.3258360922,
1.2754508257,
0.4580057561,
0.2730147541,
0.1198533103,
-0.2321666926,
-0.3386085629,
-0.6572338343,
-0.9989452958,
-0.2332333177,
-0.0387816653,
-0.3137976527,
0.0958634987,
1.2221956253,
0.3758838177,
-0.5518728495,
-0.3101830781,
0.2020143718,
0.1309909821,
0.2994058728,
-0.2839912176,
0.0683543086,
-0.0621737018,
-0.656665206,
0.0987410396,
-0.1400992274,
0.1121761054,
-0.7365520597,
-0.0241135638,
0.2012990415,
0.1119215339,
0.5084155798,
0.3644514084,
-0.9518917203,
-0.4341841638,
0.4957767725,
-0.2071376741,
-0.0594786331,
1.0322088003,
-1.0526689291,
0.2989949584,
0.5213342309,
0.2948616147,
0.0730035678,
0.3360377848,
0.3544586599,
-0.8430117369,
0.1019233838,
0.2296771854,
0.1686444581,
0.5165858269,
-0.3924362063,
0.2138684839,
0.1351108551,
-0.696372509,
-0.7867224216,
0.529210031,
-0.6496328115,
-0.2169540375,
1.2229474783,
0.2003514022,
-0.1444112957,
-0.1415800005,
-0.5945754051,
-0.0205063038,
-0.5315902233,
1.0549179316,
0.8243153095,
-0.5252783298,
-0.0435792878,
-0.5819045305,
0.3627920449,
0.4175956249,
-0.521232307,
0.2714439332,
0.8449727297,
0.4483525455,
-0.1767809987,
0.9188108444,
0.0957926512,
0.3537474573,
-0.5019044876,
0.0443427637,
0.1192312762,
0.0648704246,
-0.5543548465,
-0.1446750313,
0.6813411117,
-0.1391879469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04260v1
|
Fully Automated Task Management for Generation, Execution, and Evaluation: A Framework for Fetch-and-Carry Tasks with Natural Language Instructions in Continuous Space
| 2023-11-07T15:38:09 | 2023-11-07T15:38:09 |
Motonari Kambara, Komei Sugiura
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper aims to develop a framework that enables a robot to execute tasks
based on visual information, in response to natural language instructions for
Fetch-and-Carry with Object Grounding (FCOG) tasks. Although there have been
many frameworks, they usually rely on manually given instruction sentences.
Therefore, evaluations have only been conducted with fixed tasks. Furthermore,
many multimodal language understanding models for the benchmarks only consider
discrete actions. To address the limitations, we propose a framework for the
full automation of the generation, execution, and evaluation of FCOG tasks. In
addition, we introduce an approach to solving the FCOG tasks by dividing them
into four distinct subtasks.
|
[
-0.1865520626,
-0.9346882105,
0.7600212097,
0.4382956028,
-0.0200618301,
0.0200870298,
-0.1289231181,
-0.3094860315,
-0.1078966707,
0.7302228212,
-0.8375689387,
-0.4438330829,
-0.5985007286,
-0.0012535183,
-0.4910344481,
0.7455441356,
-0.2150504291,
-0.3779065311,
-0.4768453836,
0.006883502,
-0.698395431,
-0.1879526228,
-0.362693727,
-0.3143709302,
0.0290739052,
0.6129053831,
0.927516222,
1.0608202219,
0.7492850423,
0.371784389,
0.3151536286,
-0.0517284647,
-0.2097860128,
-0.2837650776,
-0.517878592,
-0.422557652,
-0.115465343,
-0.1047561318,
0.6311455965,
0.6617578268,
-0.1877102405,
0.1629956812,
-0.4145050049,
0.8104444146,
-0.6577695012,
0.3653663695,
-0.2279228419,
0.2987689376,
0.1785028428,
-0.2549546659,
-0.3423653245,
-0.0235336795,
0.1077047735,
-0.9370377064,
0.0105043873,
0.2382447422,
0.982539773,
0.3428002596,
-0.3468313515,
-0.5287434459,
-0.5419335961,
0.9995843768,
-0.3575015366,
0.1845027655,
0.1979544461,
0.5056653023,
-0.1387521476,
-0.6942939758,
-0.6732577085,
-0.5656768084,
-0.3962739408,
0.1974243373,
-0.1482984871,
0.3793845475,
0.1722370535,
0.3485468328,
-0.5110209584,
-0.0845809057,
-0.1606785953,
-0.0320136882,
0.538418889,
0.3013193905,
0.6894515157,
-0.2404571027,
-0.8257961273,
-0.2085560411,
-0.1378761828,
0.0163363479,
0.0466027446,
0.0945648775,
-0.1956426948,
0.7786868811,
-0.6629061103,
0.8958322406,
0.1242333353,
0.0884459913,
0.1137818694,
-0.4561984241,
-0.6516312957,
-0.3093982339,
0.7901717424,
0.4578396976,
0.177202031,
-0.3054929376,
-0.2216946334,
0.2860118449,
0.6523969769,
-0.29718858,
-0.1398676485,
0.290130794,
-0.4381604791,
-0.4869078994,
0.2193947285,
-0.9718114138,
-0.1694821715,
-0.6324414611,
0.4670032263,
-0.4825227857,
-0.1178101897,
0.3630200922,
-0.2144442499,
0.2897866666,
0.5273432136,
-0.7446567416,
0.5093178749,
0.5104250312,
0.6285791993,
-0.2280142158,
-0.4450291693,
-0.925311923,
0.303407222,
-0.1451572627,
0.7910040617,
-0.6068961024,
-0.2008462697,
0.114130348,
0.3956791162,
-0.3194662333,
-0.4251667559,
0.2591138184,
-0.1660317779,
0.3479627371,
0.0234173201,
-0.2654772699,
-0.670527339,
0.3360352814,
-0.4827132821,
0.923800528,
0.2635660768,
-0.257976532,
0.1713369638,
-0.9835577607,
-0.8070779443,
0.3026976287,
-0.2135532498,
0.0778533965,
-0.0875698477,
0.1522911638,
0.7627145052,
-0.240601629,
0.3533097506,
-0.0470390804,
-0.3344199657,
-0.3859094381,
0.0793012008,
0.5587056279,
0.0697029456,
-0.9354227781,
0.5477787852,
-0.6914383173,
-0.0233014002,
0.1696031839,
-0.2162432969,
0.1949525625,
0.1733348072,
0.1017879099,
0.2754788995,
0.3978640139,
-0.2712503076,
0.1641190201,
-0.1620190591,
0.1591802835,
0.5192282796,
-0.1346705407,
0.8846281171,
-0.4482975602,
0.7896150947,
-0.1992431581,
0.2612439096,
-0.4400008023,
-0.3295119703,
-1.0117412806,
-0.4869847894,
-0.3751485348,
0.9086688757,
-0.6382318139,
0.565590024,
-0.1079394966,
-0.4397435486,
-0.1387885362,
0.2817641795,
0.5648028851,
0.4565115571,
0.2979824543,
-0.2029126734,
-0.2227361351,
-1.0303077698,
0.377066344,
-0.0506850258,
0.0448819064,
0.2725334764,
0.4851206839,
-0.4594236016,
0.8140344024,
-0.2226302326,
-0.4955998957,
-0.248073712,
0.5891430974,
0.1889227182,
0.7258023024,
0.5233512521,
-0.9005346894,
-0.0353571065,
0.419244498,
-1.1223573685,
-0.1975695342,
-0.5304421186,
-0.5255364776,
0.0939311907,
0.2876030207,
-0.974386096,
0.4306679666,
0.4574122727,
-0.1397613138,
0.460339278,
-0.0411991179,
0.3492821157,
-0.6518349051,
0.4319964051,
-0.0027099138,
-0.3864815235,
-0.5770679116,
0.4717049301,
-0.0118670445,
-0.2400161177,
-0.6543177366,
0.620911479,
-0.5944456458,
-0.1796831638,
-0.3399635255,
0.3098761141,
0.1223486066,
0.7676998973,
0.3577525616,
0.3501556516,
0.488873899,
-0.7165532708,
0.5954364538,
0.1402495652,
-0.0923150182,
0.5091635585,
-0.4612809122,
0.0020171574,
-0.3023586869,
-0.0392205715,
-1.0643978119,
-0.5018457174,
0.4209526479,
-0.200707525,
0.1775504798,
-0.088823691,
-0.6031529307,
-0.3950470388,
-0.0394618995,
-0.2627000511,
0.5266125798,
-0.4618611038,
0.5968117118,
0.2217484862,
0.0750987902,
-0.5300993323,
-0.3774605393,
-0.1625705063,
-0.0947220698,
-0.6951468587,
0.25306952,
0.0233288556,
-0.3146328628,
0.1683428437,
-0.2586022615,
-0.0299634784,
0.2832037508,
0.3269296288,
0.1078067943,
0.148390308,
-0.0831610188,
0.0516864955,
-0.0654343963,
0.0971384495,
-0.2098764479,
0.3999152482,
-0.2619674206,
-0.4334985614,
-0.742364943,
0.3904570043,
0.828807652,
-0.1495599002,
0.2834070921,
0.6039609909,
-0.566695869,
-0.0189669542,
-0.3743768036,
0.0871640295,
-0.5117025971,
0.2260324806,
-0.2473239899,
-0.7365919948,
0.1429554671,
-0.245414868,
0.4023127854,
0.4269638658,
0.5706030726,
-0.3795212209,
0.9696677327,
1.0717550516,
-0.0207101256,
0.4418107867,
-0.1425156593,
0.0554341972,
-0.3935863078,
-0.2722577453,
-0.3336066902,
-0.3064448833,
0.0409012251,
-0.6835696697,
-0.0715209618,
0.5457695127,
-0.0436318852,
0.5101149678,
-0.8314545155,
0.347014755,
0.2464630008,
-0.1628445834,
0.0985067338,
-0.0586729832,
-0.1304433495,
0.3425060809,
-0.5435621142,
-0.9419587255,
0.4135932326,
0.1454221606,
0.6344178319,
-0.2212662697,
0.3857076764,
0.5542892218,
0.4147694111,
-0.8598214984,
0.7112669945,
0.045308765,
-0.5120791197,
-0.264963448,
-0.2410636693,
-0.6664623022,
0.2507664263,
-0.0745946094,
-1.072412014,
-0.2001425475,
0.1514465809,
-0.0751096755,
0.0341215357,
-0.7311738133,
1.1582918167,
-0.452783674,
-0.2441864014,
-0.3282009065,
-0.8456404805,
0.5143241882,
0.2372469604,
0.3713317513,
-0.2874889374,
0.0603364296,
0.5157380104,
-0.0200057663,
0.7042010427,
-0.4937872589,
0.0799147636,
0.4252727032,
0.2333809733,
0.4236718118,
0.018368423,
-0.0187349208,
-0.165128082,
0.0507189669,
-0.371360451,
-0.734505713,
0.4168015122,
-0.3580247462,
-0.3519080579,
-0.2822879255,
-0.535934031,
0.0575587749,
0.4090744555,
-0.1583756506,
0.1265793741,
-0.0799582973,
0.2623207569,
0.3751935363,
-0.4197993875,
0.5772519112,
0.4390593171,
-0.358086735,
-0.0369641036,
0.704052031,
-0.4856980741,
0.2523125112,
0.8048143983,
0.0305045899,
-0.2875620723,
-0.1861598194,
-0.8727174401,
-0.1019781455,
-0.6271275878,
-0.1328985691,
-0.8078109026,
0.1261624694,
0.028190244,
-0.8224638104,
-0.267950654,
-0.1623004675,
-0.3131195605,
0.0465043113,
0.3046485484,
0.7106547356,
0.0749230534,
0.6239019036,
-0.8637417555,
0.6336905956,
0.2941986918,
0.1701819599,
-0.0809669048,
0.0205415934,
-0.1344382167,
0.2324637622,
-0.2843464315,
-0.6143568754,
0.2836230993,
0.0782519206,
0.6304574609,
0.2316639721,
-0.2316934317,
0.8683256507,
-0.5132779479,
0.8831702471,
0.3386859894,
-1.0328118801,
0.7526594996,
-0.5927203298,
0.4498758912,
0.4709675312,
0.2648260593,
-0.3208266795,
-0.4444967508,
-0.4523834884,
-0.7841406465,
0.9551960826,
0.3100706339,
-0.0173626039,
-0.0519294292,
-0.0105603226,
-0.0959249437,
0.4270818233,
-0.6193600893,
0.2588223815,
-0.2082448751,
-0.4049492478,
0.0248741135,
0.2467267662,
-0.3428360224,
-0.0585405305,
0.3258056641,
-0.452203989,
0.6624445319,
0.1312733591,
-0.4744834006,
-0.2825299799,
0.2156451941,
0.6350300312,
0.6025810838,
-0.1243417412,
-0.2214958817,
-0.0641569272,
-0.2124476731,
0.0894894451,
0.0123197604,
0.1061062142,
-0.1420547664,
0.3131349385,
0.6390963793,
0.4076936841,
-1.1353881359,
0.5624483228,
0.1691349149,
-0.348726213,
-0.3322918713,
0.211742878,
-0.0136513226,
0.118978776,
0.3423522711,
0.104681626,
0.0729914084,
-0.6278091669,
0.5903910398,
0.2915581167,
-0.3365834653,
-0.2682682276,
0.7144320607,
0.0582126081,
-0.1852416545,
0.4877730012,
-0.2960508466,
-0.3943764865,
1.0014117956,
0.4578560293,
0.7258469462,
0.3473404944,
0.4468221664,
0.1038228869,
0.4666338861,
-0.2366390675,
0.5349814892,
-0.3098207116,
-0.538435638,
-0.5808787346,
-0.9201024175,
-0.5477039814,
0.0027730959,
-0.6443772316,
0.0670880824,
-0.9274712801,
0.3144167364,
-0.176107958,
-0.2707103789,
-0.7350667119,
0.6543980241,
0.194609344,
0.626906693,
-0.5242987871,
0.5598957539,
1.1146787405,
-0.2869380414,
-0.5372713208,
-0.0911627784,
0.1951591372,
-0.5928055644,
0.7335811257,
0.604146421,
-0.3995999694,
-0.003559974,
-0.5065090656,
-0.7939350605,
0.9825463891,
0.0519341901,
-0.4336525202,
0.1201094016,
-0.0408236645,
0.4810472727,
-0.3862253428,
0.0549162813,
0.3314320147,
0.7870246172,
-0.1056196466,
-0.9054951668,
0.0811472759,
-0.4835460186,
-0.1825427115,
0.2651480734,
-0.6134796739,
0.3599618673,
0.1777861416,
-0.5197136402,
0.37950629,
0.4993926883,
0.2423876077,
0.1306849271,
0.626670301,
0.646853447,
0.4214324057,
-0.1995088458,
1.018828392,
-0.2642275393,
0.2704865336,
0.8037176728,
-0.452260077,
0.5322148204,
0.3510698974,
0.0307333916,
0.3885613084,
0.2227924466,
-0.080749169,
0.5627795458,
0.2052707225,
-0.0532062165,
-0.1696491688,
-0.0962103456,
0.3111754954,
0.6619628072,
0.3616136014,
-0.0982034579,
-0.306328088,
0.2578852177,
-0.0307470951,
0.3272735775,
-0.2417526245,
0.6307339072,
-0.2718916833,
-0.8896328211,
0.4555875361,
0.157641843,
0.5907067657,
-0.609562993,
-0.3599362373,
0.14774324,
-0.0095255626,
-0.2621063888,
-0.8971172571,
0.6186228991,
0.1733402014,
-0.1827694625,
-0.7359597087,
0.7535607815,
-0.1420130581,
-0.4019807279,
0.4179597497,
0.261477977,
0.0012103221,
0.1133004948,
-0.718167603,
0.0048176101,
0.0480829403,
-0.2537800074,
0.2210483998,
0.2323999107,
-0.2435569763,
0.9453440905,
0.7036365271,
-0.383440733,
0.3226687908,
-0.1483721286,
0.5633450747,
-0.7576114535,
-0.3450773358,
-0.6188727021,
0.997380197,
-0.0169479046,
-0.0469316132,
0.5245121717,
0.3201607168,
0.8119074702,
-0.3900436163,
0.7709586024,
-0.7814885378,
0.0739519298,
-0.610343039,
0.4974473417,
-0.6372866631,
-0.4443576932,
-0.3806255758,
-0.7477878928,
-0.3205899,
0.9282339215,
0.1606803387,
-0.2744716108,
0.7498421669,
0.558229804,
-0.1755402237,
-0.0695371628,
0.347394079,
-0.3951382339,
0.2246804237,
0.5549430251,
0.802801609,
-0.1660649925,
0.4361156225,
-0.4554411173,
-0.3539683819,
-0.0877494216,
-0.955296278,
-0.7855257392,
-0.3146229088,
-0.3298711181,
0.3322945237,
0.0430628248,
0.6562817693,
1.0396584272,
-0.5782366991,
-0.4737202823,
-0.504000783,
0.0070202462,
-0.5761266351,
-0.3621540964,
-0.0689656585,
-0.6953322887,
-0.9018598199,
0.7782962322,
0.678045094,
-0.2397399694,
-0.0827312097,
0.082424812,
-0.4503186047,
-0.3260717392,
0.7099930644,
0.3743554056,
-0.8029521108,
-0.5739375353,
0.1057595611,
-0.0832449868,
-0.0681113079,
0.5043324232,
-0.6986784935,
0.598254621,
0.4002147317,
0.8247057796,
0.4036417902,
0.1961137652,
0.987993896,
-0.7800209522,
0.3185107708,
0.1491094828,
0.2709873021,
0.199898988,
-0.5867049694,
0.686311841,
0.2436546087,
-0.4369055033,
-0.4481416047,
0.2252595574,
-1.3227497339,
-0.0592681393,
1.0645842552,
-0.1513102204,
-0.3096473217,
0.1701629758,
-0.3365020156,
0.2775344849,
-0.2068855166,
0.4099131227,
0.730702877,
-0.1766408682,
-0.4177883565,
-0.861853838,
0.2591989338,
0.4962430298,
-1.1361430883,
0.0067384429,
0.7177261114,
0.1198957115,
0.3562012315,
0.5602651238,
-0.1141627431,
0.4029699862,
-0.1686229855,
0.3660373688,
0.1248383522,
-0.6493861675,
-0.2521393299,
0.2751821876,
-0.4746861756,
-0.4583927393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04072v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04072v2
|
Beyond Imitation: Leveraging Fine-grained Quality Signals for Alignment
| 2023-11-07T15:36:40 | 2024-04-15T15:25:53 |
Geyang Guo, Ranchi Zhao, Tianyi Tang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Alignment with human preference is a desired property of large language
models (LLMs). Currently, the main alignment approach is based on reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF). Despite the effectiveness of RLHF, it is
intricate to implement and train, thus recent studies explore how to develop
alternative alignment approaches based on supervised fine-tuning (SFT). A major
limitation of SFT is that it essentially does imitation learning, which cannot
fully understand what are the expected behaviors. To address this issue, we
propose an improved alignment approach named FIGA. Different from prior
methods, we incorporate fine-grained (i.e., token or phrase level) quality
signals that are derived by contrasting good and bad responses. Our approach
has made two major contributions. Firstly, we curate a refined alignment
dataset that pairs initial responses and the corresponding revised ones.
Secondly, we devise a new loss function can leverage fine-grained quality
signals to instruct the learning of LLMs for alignment. Extensive experiments
have demonstrated the effectiveness of our approaches by comparing a number of
competitive baselines.
|
[
-0.4188503027,
-0.89323318,
0.5387603641,
-0.2444320172,
-0.3430875242,
0.1725188345,
-0.2081690878,
-0.4103132486,
0.3756985366,
0.5215668082,
-0.801549077,
-0.3071160316,
-0.4504069984,
-0.1761655658,
-0.3436265886,
0.8583203554,
-0.0272616111,
0.3313862085,
-0.0955255479,
-0.2525084019,
-0.738622129,
-0.2077779472,
-0.8284059167,
-0.4645121694,
0.5252090096,
0.5333224535,
1.0368857384,
1.0419228077,
0.3450336754,
0.316966027,
0.0171331465,
0.6083706021,
-0.6697167158,
-0.2217712998,
-0.4334472418,
-0.3824362457,
-0.2352853268,
0.1118117049,
0.582233727,
0.579288125,
-0.2010564655,
0.0189178232,
0.2086380422,
0.760879457,
-0.3321715891,
0.2046400756,
-0.5896924734,
-0.0981722474,
-0.110968098,
-0.2885297239,
-0.3872701228,
-0.3153963983,
0.0246228222,
-0.7607506514,
-0.1069849804,
0.2654295564,
1.2724996805,
0.4357771575,
-0.1897087693,
-0.1724321544,
-0.591429472,
0.7716529965,
-0.7633994818,
0.5074586272,
0.3092436492,
0.1613969505,
-0.6683787107,
-0.1169220358,
-0.5330632925,
-0.1049206406,
-0.2266611755,
-0.0744821951,
0.1717474312,
-0.0403751247,
-0.1657239795,
0.2671327293,
-0.4203040302,
0.5061390996,
0.0864565745,
-0.2858120799,
0.599516511,
0.1027525067,
0.2677455246,
0.0960531831,
-0.3897159696,
-0.4152421653,
-0.6633271575,
0.2501640916,
0.4706400931,
0.6007017493,
0.0664058253,
0.5186994672,
-0.2168471366,
0.7995068431,
0.6556018591,
-0.2042408437,
0.1702160835,
-0.1701512635,
-0.1589618921,
0.2275529355,
0.8206313848,
0.4007867873,
0.1027004793,
-0.1611041576,
-0.430827409,
-0.0146113606,
0.3530841768,
-0.5875095129,
0.0351828821,
0.0522827581,
-0.4815176129,
-0.2279779911,
0.2428327352,
-0.63563627,
-0.4424126446,
-1.0203502178,
0.67961514,
-0.7243556976,
0.1177330911,
0.0513046794,
0.2855301499,
0.6398216486,
0.3720399737,
-1.2389554977,
0.3073986173,
1.2139643431,
0.6790940762,
-0.297793299,
-0.4837426543,
-0.9411551356,
-0.0307442434,
-0.5524827838,
0.8760760427,
-0.491237402,
-0.0183858164,
-0.1202272102,
0.0439279042,
0.0639715642,
-0.4809663296,
0.6043602228,
-0.6085124016,
0.3129474521,
-0.3339380026,
-0.7150409818,
-0.1817881167,
0.0803695247,
-0.5268924832,
0.8981655836,
0.2656550109,
-0.4763652384,
0.5143271089,
-0.3715407252,
-0.4397787452,
-0.3394215107,
-0.266243875,
-0.6165587902,
0.186206907,
0.5731512904,
0.4443027377,
-0.0148849459,
0.2875986695,
-0.391494751,
-0.5890208483,
0.3811510801,
-0.4481192231,
0.3364636004,
0.345066905,
-0.2370486259,
0.5105707049,
-0.658541739,
0.0116967522,
-0.0066367765,
-0.1806345433,
-0.4775231481,
0.160056904,
-0.2167533636,
0.1966156065,
0.1585731804,
-0.3413760662,
0.3188513219,
-0.7362775803,
0.3253732324,
0.9484156966,
-0.1176038608,
0.6984388828,
-0.6070198417,
0.3046130538,
-0.2320624441,
0.0913433582,
0.144778356,
-0.0716630891,
-0.5741946697,
-0.2824288309,
0.4084477723,
0.2035989314,
-0.5685796738,
0.6931601763,
-0.3761701882,
-0.2829945087,
-0.9762296677,
0.2472834587,
0.4847415984,
0.5221546888,
0.3809092045,
-0.6097002029,
-0.4344877899,
-0.7795748711,
-0.1789314598,
-0.1059936062,
0.0608192571,
0.1209094897,
-0.0530157909,
-0.1393856406,
1.0356924534,
-0.4330492616,
-0.4470500648,
-0.0228111558,
0.2122687995,
0.1428183764,
0.6220481396,
0.4602838457,
-0.5971746445,
-0.2048379183,
0.3006966114,
-0.1664385051,
-0.2079167515,
-0.3428142071,
-0.4410715103,
0.3091312647,
0.5556774139,
-0.474483937,
-0.0513212457,
0.660402596,
-0.4593134224,
0.4045101702,
0.0334634893,
0.4433759153,
-1.29494977,
-0.0901614279,
-0.0716952831,
-0.4576535225,
-0.5041921735,
0.1579557806,
-0.1172935069,
0.2539739311,
-0.4048761427,
0.617539525,
-0.2441540211,
-0.3127799928,
-0.4858432412,
0.0724733844,
-0.0444060043,
0.6397867799,
0.0507310666,
0.9904615879,
-0.0098745385,
-0.3848773539,
-0.0874472484,
0.4867464006,
-0.3805484474,
0.7538377047,
-0.3568636179,
-0.0998539478,
-0.2157393098,
0.1677073836,
-1.0136908293,
-0.439217329,
0.307346493,
-0.4507007003,
0.5812827349,
-0.0574739873,
-0.3499805927,
-0.0208560955,
-0.3065438867,
0.2197455466,
0.5155814886,
-0.7585209012,
0.5590828061,
0.3542865813,
-0.0310860835,
-0.6223599911,
-0.3779178858,
-0.1535317898,
-0.3291482329,
-0.3582489192,
0.3389189243,
0.1176886111,
0.0726227984,
-0.2465468347,
-0.2307617515,
0.0666273236,
0.1874229759,
0.1181841269,
0.2629959881,
-0.3442671895,
0.042665787,
0.0807637349,
-0.1518384963,
-0.2335816324,
-0.3430712223,
0.7723766565,
-0.0133148953,
-0.4183425903,
-0.9434376955,
-0.0222613346,
0.5022628903,
-0.3045423031,
0.4399356544,
0.7381332517,
-0.0899548382,
-0.0443564989,
-0.4941940308,
-0.3364464641,
-0.4901085794,
0.2575597763,
-0.1375138611,
-0.9729408026,
0.3219785988,
-0.0397933424,
0.0299991407,
0.3281444311,
0.4012090266,
-0.3336842954,
1.1299523115,
0.5858586431,
-0.3648774028,
0.8662499189,
0.0883252919,
0.0516354069,
-0.7410273552,
-0.0382255279,
-0.4960996509,
-0.5884011984,
-0.5792870522,
-0.4047435224,
-0.0789963529,
0.4078585505,
-0.5463175774,
0.5803843141,
-0.3899821341,
0.6112507582,
0.7022162676,
0.256893605,
0.21861054,
0.0159298349,
0.0608194098,
-0.043166291,
-0.5533562899,
-0.6040130854,
0.7063088417,
0.4704474211,
1.0919233561,
0.0494808257,
0.8578877449,
0.0264136884,
0.3577234745,
-1.0526570082,
0.3440864086,
-0.3065725565,
-0.0714571029,
-0.6728746295,
-0.4442578554,
-0.9072182178,
0.1506045312,
-0.3543301821,
-0.8952438235,
0.0476095565,
0.4893040359,
-0.5186595321,
-0.005709534,
-0.6059691906,
0.9384482503,
-0.4620644152,
-0.383069545,
-0.0710508525,
-0.7207909822,
0.396166712,
-0.1393379271,
0.2131049484,
-0.1391043514,
0.2241070271,
0.6507158279,
-0.4658988118,
0.9453359246,
0.0370775573,
-0.3657595515,
0.1308975965,
0.1298011243,
0.7101716399,
-0.0953143686,
0.0412166417,
-0.2121154368,
0.1069751233,
-0.2874214351,
-0.6646319032,
0.7725394368,
-0.8649705052,
-0.418189615,
-0.1594258547,
-0.5555224419,
-0.5043621659,
0.3220847249,
-0.0106432447,
0.2788193524,
-0.3299289942,
-0.0296826772,
0.6606020331,
-0.0731658116,
0.2854542434,
0.4523575604,
-0.2476658225,
-0.5825753212,
1.0456082821,
-0.2481191903,
0.3570892811,
0.7444013357,
0.4655387402,
-0.43640697,
-0.5527248383,
-0.5649217367,
0.1890060008,
-0.2923182547,
-0.4235097468,
-0.2487316132,
0.1038867384,
-0.3463636637,
-0.3521111012,
-0.550173223,
-0.129834339,
-0.6004246473,
0.0481725447,
0.0938846394,
0.5297377706,
0.107575953,
0.6386309862,
-0.8791061044,
0.2414147407,
0.1913183182,
0.6018747091,
-0.0697605312,
-0.6711925864,
-0.0630406886,
0.3024302423,
-0.4124551117,
-0.4923209846,
0.3943416476,
0.2271762788,
0.4120698869,
0.6810458899,
-0.0918299556,
1.0642541647,
-0.5224321485,
0.6391123533,
0.2225727439,
-0.995640099,
0.1992322206,
-0.3332444429,
0.2420945615,
0.861245513,
0.256569922,
-0.4811790586,
-0.3282628953,
-0.4284698963,
-0.5198693275,
0.7619677186,
-0.0623973384,
0.0691320598,
0.1497111768,
0.4133368731,
0.3204310536,
0.0572075322,
-0.438424468,
0.0858046785,
-0.0939561054,
-0.5711603165,
-0.2705946863,
0.1630835831,
-0.1972762346,
-0.1227162331,
0.9241061211,
-0.5209585428,
0.0565650202,
-0.0843597203,
-0.0225073304,
-0.3773649931,
0.2809537351,
0.6411102414,
0.3648028374,
-0.1095381379,
-0.0536586791,
-0.1139662117,
-0.0255326629,
0.3085837066,
0.0619612783,
-0.2843699753,
-0.4466601312,
0.3418943882,
0.8563526869,
0.3423101008,
-0.5823732615,
0.6023413539,
0.1363609433,
-0.1020979509,
0.1518070996,
0.1946653128,
0.0168163422,
0.2736726701,
-0.1244449317,
-0.1347703189,
-0.0045929151,
-0.6938477755,
0.6167913675,
0.7790198326,
-0.7444352508,
-0.1597012132,
0.627481997,
0.0079340795,
-0.30766204,
0.4851601422,
-0.1228692979,
-0.3732825816,
0.3984921575,
0.5413956642,
0.671993196,
-0.21078372,
0.3654883504,
0.191073671,
-0.0632083714,
-0.494367063,
0.1102079973,
0.111665681,
-0.7791793942,
-0.7385931611,
-0.9202907681,
-0.2400027961,
0.0582536794,
-0.6124221683,
0.4365327954,
-0.3481072485,
0.0575804897,
0.0277174581,
-0.0645309985,
-0.3034495711,
0.0788428783,
0.0608353503,
0.5853883028,
-0.8301730156,
0.7546999454,
0.561729908,
-0.4777177572,
-1.116387248,
0.1641224921,
0.1425050795,
-0.9640238881,
0.2950704992,
0.1495070755,
-0.1475941986,
-0.026764933,
-0.6843236089,
-1.1100735664,
0.9899706244,
0.455886662,
-0.6522908807,
0.0678029582,
0.1143581942,
0.6827642322,
-0.4382070899,
-0.0146387648,
0.9124202728,
0.4430059791,
0.3159581125,
-0.8096473813,
-0.010208806,
0.3664932251,
-0.033068303,
0.5784112811,
-0.898227334,
0.3530799448,
-0.0471407063,
-0.2393465489,
0.5283899307,
0.8813098073,
-0.0055083958,
0.1196643263,
0.4121923149,
0.731926918,
0.5559529066,
-0.1989099234,
0.6998206377,
-0.1546749473,
0.3779425025,
1.5952037573,
-0.1366036236,
1.0828152895,
0.7681639194,
-0.0244319215,
0.3388274014,
0.8017083406,
0.0455286652,
0.5548117757,
0.2402986288,
0.2835134864,
-0.3967531919,
-0.1896482408,
0.1440765709,
0.6563417912,
0.172043696,
-0.2819956243,
-0.1161702797,
-0.2537757754,
-0.1381020546,
0.5270866752,
-0.2902225554,
1.1763423681,
-0.0674819052,
-0.9736869335,
0.620457232,
-0.0959854051,
0.6522028446,
-0.5400461555,
-0.1632049978,
-0.2983618379,
0.0165320206,
-0.2489894331,
-0.8122180104,
0.1670328677,
-0.5277373791,
-0.0543533377,
-0.1131160632,
0.2797089219,
-0.6505113244,
-0.1536970437,
0.0540602095,
0.1732879281,
-0.0899730176,
0.2069700509,
-0.6377716064,
0.0899995938,
0.0886092335,
0.0007583544,
0.5439517498,
0.2201098949,
-0.2233308703,
0.5421333909,
0.6243726015,
-0.0132386163,
-0.215955615,
0.0407897085,
0.63098979,
-0.5634020567,
-0.4295335114,
-0.6382722259,
0.179310292,
-0.0151679199,
-0.364985615,
0.312889874,
0.3650232852,
1.0547587872,
-0.1118603572,
0.3455963433,
0.1996532083,
0.3921928704,
-0.9222506881,
0.5018487573,
-0.5669500232,
0.2270272523,
-0.5399926305,
-1.1237264872,
-0.3762344122,
0.5122419596,
-0.0563847609,
-0.2140308619,
0.5288453102,
1.0928308964,
-0.3074737787,
-0.1155820265,
0.3654430807,
0.0529433675,
0.4623202682,
0.3897225857,
0.7835585475,
-0.3457027972,
0.3321469426,
-0.0786751211,
-0.2865893245,
-0.304890424,
-0.8614457846,
-0.5650956631,
-0.5432897806,
-0.1412119567,
-0.3434248567,
0.0975698531,
1.5008205175,
0.6461380124,
-1.0063455105,
-0.1306167692,
-0.1753104329,
-0.000666303,
-0.6488678455,
-0.2040451169,
0.6789390445,
-0.5975699425,
-0.863253653,
0.3934690654,
0.104101792,
0.394027859,
-0.0910632983,
-0.3442357481,
-0.1690174043,
0.1808462292,
0.4718550742,
0.477429986,
-0.8867121935,
-0.8061777353,
-0.2301006466,
-0.2319575995,
0.2061226517,
0.6605007648,
-0.6004519463,
0.2562063038,
0.5376322269,
1.1169428825,
-0.0489879809,
0.601693213,
0.8259350657,
-0.6203424931,
-0.2382674813,
0.0125493119,
0.3564694226,
0.3511039615,
-0.4038087726,
0.3910820484,
-0.2300564796,
-0.6427493095,
-0.3995729983,
0.3245362341,
-1.2355934381,
-0.2739230096,
1.2699428797,
0.1679938138,
-0.3699810207,
0.2222236395,
-0.6683562994,
0.3177837133,
-0.7616617084,
1.0415961742,
0.6234868169,
-0.2965860963,
0.1432568133,
-0.0435915627,
0.7220948339,
0.580731988,
-0.8347055316,
0.1979652047,
0.7596476674,
0.2810669243,
0.044420667,
0.3815588951,
-0.1596733928,
0.2256322652,
-0.5191569328,
-0.0986635759,
0.1137927324,
-0.2200884074,
-0.6009294391,
-0.0318463333,
0.5200269222,
-0.2088752836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04064v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04064v2
|
KPI Extraction from Maintenance Work Orders -- A Comparison of Expert Labeling, Text Classification and AI-Assisted Tagging for Computing Failure Rates of Wind Turbines
| 2023-11-07T15:25:52 | 2023-12-06T17:17:00 |
Marc-Alexander Lutz, Bastian Schäfermeier, Rachael Sexton, Michael Sharp, Alden Dima, Stefan Faulstich, Jagan Mohini Aluri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.7
|
Maintenance work orders are commonly used to document information about wind
turbine operation and maintenance. This includes details about proactive and
reactive wind turbine downtimes, such as preventative and corrective
maintenance. However, the information contained in maintenance work orders is
often unstructured and difficult to analyze, presenting challenges for
decision-makers wishing to use it for optimizing operation and maintenance. To
address this issue, this work compares three different approaches to calculate
reliability by performance indicators from maintenance work orders. The first
approach involves manual labeling of the maintenance work orders by domain
experts, using the schema defined in an industrial guideline to assign the
label accordingly. The second approach involves the development of a model that
automatically labels the maintenance work orders using text classification
methods. Through this method, we are able to achieve macro average and weighted
average F1-Scores of 0.75 and 0.85 respectively. The third technique uses an
AI-assisted tagging tool to tag and structure the raw maintenance information,
together with a novel rule-based approach for extracting relevant maintenance
work orders for failure rate calculation. In our experiments the AI-assisted
tool leads to a 88% drop in tagging time in comparison to the other two
approaches, while expert labeling and text classification are more accurate in
KPI extraction. Overall, our findings make extracting maintenance information
from maintenance work orders more efficient, enable the assessment of
reliability key performance indicators and therefore support the optimization
of wind turbine operation and maintenance.
|
[
-0.3445625305,
-0.3092949688,
0.3609910309,
0.2930407822,
-0.454105109,
0.4841962457,
-0.0860922188,
-0.8869187236,
-0.0567118749,
-0.0698295534,
-0.2365492433,
-0.1389452964,
-0.5529607534,
0.0178216156,
0.0307792891,
1.1239818335,
-0.1403200775,
0.0074407682,
-0.4844306111,
0.1407327056,
-0.5580866337,
-0.4061554074,
-0.6694047451,
-0.29999277,
0.5001727939,
0.2389678955,
0.7341741323,
0.7846415043,
0.9437044263,
0.3213449717,
-0.2474178523,
0.3459561765,
-0.0707936659,
0.0445751473,
0.0161230993,
-0.1498819888,
-0.6651576161,
0.0498231426,
0.1468682289,
0.5628558397,
-0.0608533248,
0.3284213543,
0.2521493435,
0.6308359504,
-0.6091625094,
0.9373697042,
-0.448844403,
0.0464149453,
-0.1133190468,
-0.3448660672,
-0.2325223684,
-0.4314192235,
-0.0400289707,
-0.372400105,
-0.1485390067,
-0.0458201915,
1.1064647436,
0.300034076,
-0.1459650099,
0.0188939348,
-0.7838531733,
0.9644079208,
-0.4360734522,
0.3231982887,
0.3683921695,
0.2821386456,
-0.2473070621,
-0.3392376602,
-0.1698334515,
-0.3218048513,
-0.3184327185,
0.3854926229,
-0.4123553932,
0.1861295551,
0.1225378439,
0.2056554854,
-0.273763448,
0.3852603734,
-0.4685842097,
-0.2558806241,
0.9557373524,
-0.056326557,
0.0221256707,
-0.3723140657,
-0.5138963461,
-0.2291707993,
-0.1396319568,
0.1146916822,
0.3789635301,
0.1687678546,
0.4491129816,
0.2045726478,
-0.1850135475,
0.4910457134,
0.1099980921,
-0.9089553952,
0.4465461671,
-0.1300446838,
-0.4380050004,
-0.1444592625,
0.6823154092,
0.4857268035,
0.3173859417,
-0.5306238532,
-0.4656228721,
-0.2110628486,
0.4822542667,
-0.1009228975,
-0.3268828392,
-0.1354510784,
-0.7036308646,
-0.5350843668,
0.3006265461,
-0.6167163849,
-0.1533162147,
-0.2402299792,
0.5907918811,
-0.3428536952,
-0.4614552557,
-0.4375159144,
-0.5327936411,
0.0635196939,
0.353091687,
-0.2558488846,
-0.2817871273,
0.5349479318,
0.7333130836,
-0.206963703,
-0.2573536038,
-0.4299722314,
0.1995243728,
-0.4803747535,
0.8034815788,
-0.3145025671,
-0.5174527764,
-0.0186430831,
-0.1191821396,
-0.332233578,
-0.6596384048,
0.6541498899,
-0.7834086418,
-0.0088571887,
0.2468873411,
-0.4187970161,
-0.3689656258,
0.026470229,
-0.5416443348,
1.235227704,
0.4896596074,
-0.7180728912,
0.4154444933,
-0.5682085156,
-0.7544765472,
0.2466482818,
0.1067935973,
-0.5059475303,
0.2512535751,
-0.5500705242,
0.5670704842,
-0.2828331292,
0.0929683819,
-0.5534771681,
-0.0672405958,
0.0748702586,
-0.4763095677,
0.2503051162,
0.3234516084,
-0.3871673942,
-0.3093382716,
-0.8008767366,
0.5354566574,
-0.3381274343,
-0.5752110481,
-0.3378463686,
0.3429469764,
-0.0493008196,
0.3959220052,
0.429649204,
-0.3839048445,
-0.1143524274,
-0.6640222669,
0.0608175136,
0.7721759081,
0.362806052,
-0.0159285795,
-0.3501059413,
0.7096419334,
-0.179151997,
0.1753878146,
0.2831827998,
-0.4509345591,
-0.4946094751,
-0.2006760091,
0.3976155519,
0.5862580538,
-0.5940273404,
0.6113184094,
-0.1662734747,
-1.0096701384,
-0.3296643794,
-0.1104397252,
0.8854572177,
0.773563385,
0.4089035392,
-0.2028512806,
-0.4628311694,
-0.7984682918,
-0.3644654751,
-0.8727274537,
0.0399591066,
0.0355351977,
0.3631179929,
0.1859589964,
0.8292187452,
-0.9004396796,
-0.1590685695,
-0.0880011767,
0.4682700634,
0.1475252062,
0.2977379262,
0.3980990052,
-0.7777590156,
-0.7248295546,
0.3813028932,
-0.7254513502,
0.1767190546,
0.3654462397,
0.0157680828,
0.9202547669,
0.1851462573,
-0.5412793756,
0.9266895652,
0.1476043314,
0.0358123295,
0.9298833609,
-0.2192852348,
0.3863091171,
-0.3927260339,
0.1685325503,
0.0188552439,
0.0331391767,
-0.6131023765,
-0.2661295831,
-0.4362537265,
0.0068603884,
-0.1106929928,
0.1344988644,
-0.3818570077,
0.0053620632,
-0.5338371396,
-0.3106737435,
-0.0127080586,
0.5671128631,
-0.1193620414,
0.6026204824,
0.036319375,
-0.5557062626,
0.0619004481,
-0.0279854201,
-0.1103519872,
0.4916927516,
-0.6102315784,
0.035539344,
0.0331711471,
-0.4512845874,
-0.9602191448,
-0.1499065608,
0.2676744759,
-0.6654248238,
0.4790101647,
-0.3550740778,
-0.3971800208,
-0.3394038677,
-0.295858264,
-0.2735466659,
0.877815485,
-0.1784548908,
0.7468123436,
0.6231335402,
-0.2964919806,
-0.4253103435,
-0.3115461767,
-0.4246536791,
-0.2554939091,
-0.5502621531,
0.374240756,
0.2197045684,
-0.2287994772,
0.1240112707,
-0.6952977777,
-0.4744838774,
0.4563398361,
0.5461045504,
0.2485278994,
0.125068292,
0.3495067358,
-0.0856501237,
-0.4534055889,
0.3004712462,
-0.023686463,
0.2998169363,
0.0727386847,
-0.0530178808,
-0.7777059078,
0.4853610992,
0.7008274794,
-0.3813354969,
0.6232836246,
0.3706389964,
-0.4298309982,
0.256767869,
-0.4697498381,
0.1863771379,
-0.443780452,
0.1471227854,
-0.3307330012,
0.002649667,
0.1369799078,
-0.1779621989,
0.1941680908,
1.1246100664,
0.1316050738,
-0.922975719,
1.2131565809,
1.0315278769,
-0.2853860259,
0.4226497412,
-0.0849700868,
0.2927192152,
-0.0073687476,
-0.4028477967,
-0.9013053179,
-0.0146997748,
-0.5041051507,
0.0611479469,
0.5854408741,
0.4573731124,
-0.1369638294,
0.1617975831,
-0.509072721,
0.1090595499,
0.3592033088,
0.0373193063,
0.3709071875,
0.2834544182,
0.314639926,
0.0627661124,
-0.5188654065,
-0.6813004613,
0.433668077,
0.1896694601,
0.3861616254,
-0.1843990088,
0.6750745773,
0.780603528,
0.3657929003,
-0.6778824329,
0.2762674391,
-0.1615211219,
-0.1949919909,
-0.3840135038,
-0.3050919473,
-0.8686290383,
-0.1680709571,
0.0239058826,
-0.4897105098,
0.0945519432,
0.4801771045,
-0.0865624696,
0.1243776456,
-1.0534797907,
0.7735270262,
-0.2906543016,
0.6008039713,
-0.1324307919,
-0.4825471342,
0.0854212791,
-0.1124809161,
0.2115686983,
-0.0486997254,
-0.0781068653,
1.0290157795,
-0.9293695688,
0.752843082,
-0.4521334469,
-0.0548411533,
0.4636248648,
-0.4025166035,
0.71689713,
-0.5274579525,
-0.2544076145,
0.1831830442,
0.1673647165,
-0.0266555473,
-0.5625827909,
0.2972341776,
-0.852463603,
-0.2261584252,
-0.7460161448,
-0.0047580465,
-0.328312546,
0.1492681652,
0.0623675287,
0.2557995319,
0.4191578031,
-0.0965139717,
0.1759134829,
0.208846584,
0.8248113394,
0.4458787143,
0.234979555,
-0.5705548525,
1.2399172783,
0.6606812477,
0.1532713026,
0.3846609294,
-0.0215860102,
-0.0346349701,
-0.5164213777,
-0.0424613468,
-0.1033620536,
-0.8338319659,
-0.862655282,
-0.5620183945,
-0.3349390328,
-0.0569678061,
-0.1197633594,
-0.2511149049,
-0.5011383891,
-0.4437877536,
-0.267994523,
0.6002423167,
0.517588675,
0.0118169915,
0.4122435153,
-0.8195819259,
0.2429336756,
-0.0617731847,
0.4000252485,
0.2176480442,
-0.1927877665,
-0.3782188892,
-0.0508658066,
-0.3819535673,
-1.2050273418,
0.2505346239,
0.2114072442,
0.7859421968,
0.3734878004,
0.128701508,
0.9305483699,
-0.1904571056,
0.5494027138,
0.272567302,
-0.8233146667,
0.462474972,
0.0084573934,
-0.0452327132,
0.6101462245,
0.7152027488,
-0.1298588812,
-0.2669591606,
-0.8625489473,
-0.9867424369,
0.5295487046,
-0.2043257207,
-0.6858807206,
-0.0068259812,
0.3908364773,
0.0956516415,
0.3749633431,
-0.03085378,
-0.2857485712,
-0.0053984839,
-0.2877211869,
-0.0104211066,
0.0675063431,
0.1146515831,
-0.1831424683,
0.9925091267,
-0.1833554953,
0.3046161532,
-0.0386322178,
-0.335752368,
-0.0645763278,
0.0754885748,
0.2254635841,
1.1764093637,
-0.1462153047,
-0.0936486796,
0.3448391259,
-0.5236250162,
0.1345550418,
0.1377963275,
-0.4033400118,
0.2684824467,
0.5888009071,
0.2590712607,
-0.0305857565,
-0.4887281954,
0.0669439435,
0.3572764993,
0.1437311023,
-0.3953594863,
0.2303740084,
-0.2445358336,
0.0604478754,
0.5552261472,
0.2789199948,
0.3335072696,
-0.3197106421,
0.0852980688,
0.2855999768,
-0.6657048464,
-0.1864584684,
0.17911838,
0.1665714383,
-0.5463565588,
0.1954195946,
-0.2232138813,
-0.448241204,
0.8645308614,
0.0602619797,
1.0274010897,
0.0292983912,
0.339235723,
0.1518639475,
0.3383714557,
-0.0455043018,
0.7193841934,
0.3273253739,
-0.1204762831,
-0.4963137507,
-0.686019361,
-0.2895356715,
-0.0893116966,
-0.9199010134,
0.0271110181,
-0.3579368889,
-0.3494708836,
0.272085309,
0.396420151,
-0.6458488703,
0.5910174251,
-0.3755128682,
0.958711803,
-0.8891397715,
0.1795620173,
0.8315598965,
-0.6049619913,
-1.1825371981,
-0.1425673366,
-0.3285445273,
-0.4364406466,
0.6359069943,
0.0994339958,
-0.3293996155,
-0.0654251501,
-0.0681681409,
-0.8295199871,
1.1512972116,
0.0545514449,
-0.534673512,
0.2070013136,
-0.2187056094,
0.7274939418,
-0.1085558683,
0.4304919243,
0.5062376261,
0.8992301822,
-0.2173649073,
-1.2582081556,
-0.0917696953,
-0.0720189363,
-0.0384159014,
0.6679773331,
-0.9459207654,
0.1791839153,
0.030007055,
-0.2293212712,
-0.0325538255,
0.7309638858,
0.0547449253,
0.6723473668,
0.8758391142,
0.2947294116,
0.7955564857,
-0.2275672108,
0.9265728593,
-0.2894901335,
0.2285151035,
0.6899470687,
0.032748092,
0.9720170498,
0.4017055035,
-0.3401596844,
0.4163920283,
0.5465252399,
-0.3750829995,
0.5053904653,
-0.1739867479,
-0.0792936683,
-0.2165542394,
-0.1738240272,
-0.5327322483,
0.6392590404,
-0.3478977084,
-0.2203343362,
-0.1764723957,
-0.023611851,
0.4326359034,
-0.2001203299,
-0.3637274206,
1.0119373798,
-0.1186417192,
-0.8745462894,
0.4370287657,
0.2448251396,
0.2052940875,
-0.3751899302,
-0.1735274941,
-0.0265283585,
0.1617662907,
-0.4173303246,
-0.5228475332,
0.3224469721,
0.1375787258,
-0.8957753778,
-0.3410039842,
1.0501955748,
-0.009021149,
-0.6670333743,
-0.014024606,
0.3340991437,
0.3298002481,
0.1484490335,
-0.4039623439,
-0.0944030285,
-0.1356159151,
-0.0017689079,
0.3560721874,
-0.1079215631,
-0.2986194193,
0.4988704622,
0.4096693397,
-0.0737283602,
-0.1172984913,
-0.2458865792,
0.8529214859,
-0.701967001,
-0.078364715,
-0.6109516025,
0.6507448554,
-0.2469907403,
-0.3950096965,
0.7706705332,
0.3920893967,
0.7034645081,
-0.1286979914,
1.1368246078,
-0.229326725,
0.5056854486,
-0.333037734,
0.8484674692,
-0.4864153266,
-0.0827534944,
-0.3412475288,
-0.3800913692,
-0.0402625166,
0.2199613154,
-0.0658343136,
0.1414349526,
0.5043002963,
0.1978677809,
0.343534708,
-0.1087933183,
-0.0004241262,
0.2017035037,
0.353821069,
0.0839169547,
0.7384219766,
-0.3688018322,
1.0334769487,
-0.4635978639,
-0.3160889745,
-0.2235334367,
-0.9576894641,
-0.4628366232,
-0.0367472433,
-0.7841926217,
-0.2998883426,
0.097191304,
0.6114994884,
0.4064038992,
-0.5675886273,
0.015347898,
0.403335005,
0.3765920103,
-0.8975985646,
-0.2465994358,
0.5911053419,
-0.6738134623,
-0.2746756673,
0.2746961713,
0.3603355885,
0.0527788214,
-0.1064809784,
0.1787261367,
-0.0977909416,
-0.2912123501,
0.4680379033,
0.38357535,
-0.4154953361,
-0.7122973204,
-0.0035787923,
0.2306757271,
0.0407518148,
0.1146403551,
-0.3961580396,
-0.0004162551,
0.7858635187,
0.4036955535,
0.1678429246,
0.1249404624,
0.4117211998,
-0.5782386661,
-0.566691339,
0.1191530526,
0.1398965716,
0.0621679798,
-0.3650496304,
0.5106389523,
0.5014976859,
-0.5802728534,
-1.0382510424,
0.0993284807,
-0.8834719062,
0.0455892012,
0.6799075603,
-0.5849374533,
-0.2125968635,
-0.3971189857,
-0.0434879586,
0.1223092228,
-0.1437616348,
0.7625397444,
0.6680381894,
-0.4917678237,
0.4539831877,
-0.3824269176,
0.5236427784,
0.068644613,
-0.9946187735,
-0.3483513594,
0.2513808608,
0.3366724849,
0.5853737593,
0.3842218816,
0.1759566218,
0.3776061535,
-0.2135000378,
0.1423381567,
-0.2100633979,
-0.6185002327,
-0.2449850589,
0.6739138961,
0.1427441686,
-0.4008378088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04046v1
|
Reinforcement Learning Fine-tuning of Language Models is Biased Towards More Extractable Features
| 2023-11-07T15:00:39 | 2023-11-07T15:00:39 |
Diogo Cruz, Edoardo Pona, Alex Holness-Tofts, Elias Schmied, Víctor Abia Alonso, Charlie Griffin, Bogdan-Ionut Cirstea
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Many capable large language models (LLMs) are developed via self-supervised
pre-training followed by a reinforcement-learning fine-tuning phase, often
based on human or AI feedback. During this stage, models may be guided by their
inductive biases to rely on simpler features which may be easier to extract, at
a cost to robustness and generalisation. We investigate whether principles
governing inductive biases in the supervised fine-tuning of LLMs also apply
when the fine-tuning process uses reinforcement learning. Following Lovering et
al (2021), we test two hypotheses: that features more $\textit{extractable}$
after pre-training are more likely to be utilised by the final policy, and that
the evidence for/against a feature predicts whether it will be utilised.
Through controlled experiments on synthetic and natural language tasks, we find
statistically significant correlations which constitute strong evidence for
these hypotheses.
|
[
-0.7360960245,
-0.7371720672,
0.5906614661,
0.1035489142,
0.0375366732,
-0.2114110589,
-0.6591172814,
-0.5706495047,
-0.1351377666,
0.8001838326,
-0.7444859147,
-0.1161813885,
-0.6614311337,
0.2220284939,
-0.3049738109,
1.3085339069,
0.0746246725,
0.0015452476,
-0.1497564465,
-0.0368232019,
-0.4257055223,
-0.5199972987,
-0.5224158764,
-0.6647090912,
0.6525958776,
0.4607601464,
0.7450818419,
0.6963452697,
0.2515159547,
0.2576758862,
-0.0762820318,
0.2308213264,
-0.2541988194,
0.1904814541,
-0.473780334,
-0.5430133939,
0.0233575869,
0.3641131818,
0.31185624,
0.3924807906,
-0.0214160401,
-0.0698393732,
0.3586892188,
0.5189981461,
-0.6192038059,
0.3202963471,
-0.6871111393,
-0.2027623504,
-0.103325583,
-0.3686738312,
-0.2552082837,
-0.3051382303,
0.2972236574,
-0.5611838698,
0.3738838136,
0.0861238018,
1.1038954258,
0.5363512039,
-0.2547465563,
-0.4462509751,
-0.7294331193,
0.7717332244,
-0.7389915586,
0.1945220977,
0.5706014633,
0.1830319166,
-0.3822388947,
-0.3667865992,
-0.409748435,
-0.677021265,
-0.4159509242,
-0.2321696728,
0.3485174775,
0.3520363867,
0.4194354117,
0.4976494908,
-0.0060498426,
0.6535384059,
-0.1231430694,
-0.0486838967,
0.7392106652,
0.0083513893,
0.1432877183,
-0.1108743548,
-0.0970405489,
-0.2023867965,
-0.8437515497,
0.338613987,
0.4886007309,
0.710439682,
-0.0670881197,
0.5036382079,
-0.5258948207,
0.3489361107,
0.3291537166,
-0.0209834371,
0.1709520966,
-0.3813543022,
-0.1566361785,
0.131503433,
0.8303487897,
-0.0405848958,
0.748182714,
-0.1863721907,
-0.4648203552,
0.0868173391,
0.2850429118,
-0.6350177526,
-0.4779413044,
0.0791867897,
-0.1728268713,
-0.5140055418,
0.0551981032,
-0.2143199593,
-0.2009939253,
-0.5545350313,
0.254458487,
-0.3852258623,
-0.2887195647,
0.0569709167,
-0.0123627447,
0.2606095672,
0.1448100805,
-1.4104677439,
0.3127005696,
0.9554904699,
0.3211060166,
-0.4402620494,
-0.4418211579,
-0.6806581616,
-0.2270448953,
-0.3663159609,
0.8914602995,
-0.7433718443,
-0.0745507553,
0.2387233227,
0.4226615429,
0.1768396795,
-0.849517405,
0.4680745006,
-0.3582634628,
0.2467371374,
-0.4557083845,
-0.4906908572,
0.050912261,
0.0546356812,
-0.689869225,
0.9760582447,
0.0932231098,
-0.5638087392,
1.0876578093,
-0.452396065,
-0.6633391976,
-0.3169348538,
-0.4579727352,
-0.7056234479,
0.1878516823,
0.4125199616,
0.5083518624,
-0.2383549064,
0.3179097772,
-0.6237334013,
-0.229647398,
0.4692077041,
-0.4017422497,
0.3891379833,
0.2518297136,
-0.4968294501,
0.2428559661,
-0.7919591665,
-0.1141317785,
-0.0657125339,
-0.5772491693,
-0.3803839982,
0.274272114,
-0.2681298554,
0.3858230412,
0.0386873707,
-0.4223330021,
0.1888031662,
-0.5551016331,
0.3683710992,
0.7407305241,
0.0842388719,
0.6986273527,
-0.2869827449,
0.3352783918,
0.0819367543,
0.0143162161,
-0.0628474429,
0.0517111346,
-0.8297932744,
-0.248142451,
0.4588203728,
0.2231154442,
-0.441806972,
0.3514314592,
0.2856582105,
-0.0347922631,
-0.5662482977,
0.4330281019,
0.6774033308,
-0.0958225802,
0.2025802881,
-0.2753075659,
-0.3986648917,
-0.996671021,
-0.4305425584,
0.1087059826,
0.0911540017,
0.3265126944,
0.3205384612,
-0.1164634749,
0.78504318,
-0.1333088726,
-0.1804699749,
-0.3138184547,
0.2054332197,
0.0234916694,
0.6401213408,
0.3033603728,
-0.4438683093,
-0.2859637141,
0.1914106011,
-0.5605635643,
-0.149973616,
-0.333563596,
0.0703476593,
0.3178668916,
0.7224860787,
-0.5900450945,
0.3027757704,
0.295776546,
0.0118193645,
0.4977121651,
-0.3916535676,
-0.226115644,
-0.5539581776,
-0.3590432703,
0.2289730012,
-0.2791035473,
-0.2901023924,
0.0112460591,
0.0118567999,
0.5304689407,
-0.1306183338,
0.210262239,
-0.4993912876,
-0.1983528435,
-0.5075437427,
-0.0007076152,
-0.0424492843,
0.4985358715,
0.1159494445,
0.8329242468,
0.2635042071,
-0.9769820571,
-0.0097407792,
0.0098599074,
-0.5394748449,
0.0913361013,
-0.6843115091,
-0.1556730121,
0.0386016555,
-0.1868261248,
-0.6101671457,
-0.1479252279,
-0.0417955033,
-0.2921889424,
0.4652938247,
-0.0401532762,
-0.4206165075,
-0.0770078674,
-0.0299597327,
-0.0957608894,
0.4405793548,
-0.5712168217,
0.1271607876,
0.4298328757,
-0.0829004496,
-0.4809879065,
-0.3649145067,
-0.5236492157,
-0.2510542572,
0.0202838965,
0.2267419547,
0.2563972175,
-0.27249071,
-0.0718407705,
-0.0319172181,
0.2405398786,
0.49453789,
0.4141053855,
-0.0762592554,
0.0024165038,
0.2322894633,
0.1198563054,
-0.2185305357,
0.228253901,
-0.2123985291,
0.5843708515,
0.0256265495,
-0.2483081222,
-0.320004046,
-0.061093837,
0.3528291285,
-0.2925034761,
0.538293004,
0.6713104248,
0.0052431999,
-0.5031526685,
-0.5423036814,
-0.5813471079,
-0.5161903501,
0.4633341134,
-0.5193119645,
-1.2049975395,
0.3475530148,
-0.2935946286,
0.0975027606,
0.504029274,
0.6872951388,
-0.3362021148,
1.2252212763,
0.9647826552,
-0.1143903434,
0.8087338805,
-0.1274222136,
-0.0291308314,
-0.8386924863,
-0.1830797642,
-0.6788831949,
-0.0817699507,
-1.3744891882,
0.1244067699,
-0.0989407301,
0.1628557891,
-0.3118520081,
0.2594699264,
-0.3329942226,
0.451405108,
0.8491126299,
0.0731318444,
0.17895253,
-0.0620589443,
-0.2964902818,
0.0479371846,
-0.6084260941,
-0.2451239377,
0.8803409338,
0.2918029428,
0.9008439779,
-0.3272590637,
0.6614044905,
0.1596349627,
0.0871417522,
-0.6015418172,
0.1692889184,
-0.0531892367,
-0.6572496891,
-0.5116715431,
-0.1721190661,
-1.0955965519,
0.1872586459,
-0.6508036256,
-0.4758832753,
0.2027992606,
0.3366979659,
-0.3148662448,
-0.0375218242,
-0.5384464264,
0.6843200326,
-0.3618449271,
-0.487108469,
-0.3794261813,
-0.3556229174,
0.2124496102,
0.111103721,
-0.0314866118,
-0.2262155116,
0.4072894454,
0.4932239354,
-0.3573677838,
0.8154961467,
-0.0817311481,
-0.2319471389,
0.0398946218,
0.071384199,
0.6649906039,
0.1860016435,
0.2071112394,
-0.1602386832,
0.0877429992,
-0.3585350513,
-0.6280704141,
0.6628893614,
-0.9697883725,
-0.8295664787,
-0.3763940334,
-0.4610905051,
-0.380494386,
-0.0033115409,
0.1709037721,
0.2671046853,
-0.1863074154,
0.1855284572,
0.8805849552,
-0.3418360949,
0.358525008,
0.503004849,
-0.4191108048,
0.0458104722,
0.8546681404,
0.0346458144,
0.4699760079,
0.2429779768,
0.3124403059,
-0.0158696305,
-0.887093246,
-0.1097911373,
0.196404621,
-0.3177397549,
0.1317616105,
-0.3695515394,
-0.3299533129,
-0.3100326359,
0.0836149231,
-0.4991599023,
-0.3126740456,
-0.3345585465,
-0.4577503502,
0.4193829,
0.9484938979,
-0.169903338,
0.2775675058,
-0.3643862903,
0.2386960238,
0.5247889757,
0.3800874949,
-0.2663740516,
-0.5803185701,
-0.4825433791,
-0.0097990185,
-0.1623292863,
-0.277626425,
0.3953689933,
0.1437252909,
0.6391608715,
0.5813279748,
-0.1512180865,
0.4834784269,
-0.4134082198,
0.5372362137,
-0.1287016273,
-0.4162294567,
0.5949204564,
-0.3997252285,
0.2527955472,
0.7383601069,
0.3489998877,
-0.0684009716,
-0.5228822231,
-0.5653450489,
-0.563485682,
0.6859019399,
-0.1589888036,
0.146539405,
-0.1761924177,
0.4320975542,
0.4648028314,
0.3390922248,
-0.678122282,
-0.0963797942,
0.1334447712,
0.0549280494,
-0.310777694,
-0.5050739646,
0.0348873287,
-0.3454775214,
0.5716295838,
-0.1506780833,
-0.0281889066,
-0.0691545457,
-0.2141445726,
-0.0149519425,
0.4555929899,
0.4730466604,
0.3581739664,
-0.3167465031,
0.0704897866,
0.141218856,
-0.1071745083,
-0.066127196,
0.024132181,
-0.3310567439,
-0.306594491,
0.2700042725,
1.1587783098,
0.305462718,
-0.4533012211,
0.3413227797,
0.0016084631,
-0.2689630389,
-0.4317316711,
0.5876742005,
-0.2434064597,
0.5470818281,
-0.0321164504,
-0.0121415509,
0.0849562287,
-0.6966875196,
0.3755706251,
0.6877039075,
-0.7095817924,
-0.3865464032,
0.4230471551,
0.0721891224,
-0.1510956436,
0.425519377,
-0.271856904,
-0.4599376321,
0.4113783836,
0.4800209701,
0.799782455,
0.1317568868,
0.1181897521,
0.2726883292,
0.3404825926,
-0.2396174669,
0.130399242,
-0.2127943337,
-0.698495388,
-0.6426354647,
-0.7377319336,
-0.2611793876,
0.2090753913,
-0.7698708177,
0.1625312418,
-0.4871480465,
-0.0109946914,
0.0685272291,
0.1128582582,
-0.7302464247,
0.2484718412,
0.2445992082,
0.5605643988,
-0.7604468465,
1.1369003057,
0.2706007361,
-0.5702695251,
-0.982753098,
-0.0661067441,
-0.2376953363,
-0.7746294141,
0.7453711629,
0.0049570138,
-0.0632355213,
-0.2309235185,
-0.636452198,
-0.961715579,
0.7283248305,
0.3177870512,
-0.6434705257,
-0.2044090927,
0.1830326468,
0.4602002203,
-0.4932554066,
0.3322112858,
1.053101182,
0.1838570386,
-0.2476010174,
-1.1234306097,
-0.0404218435,
0.021254709,
0.0524296165,
0.183406502,
-0.4419579208,
0.9829289317,
-0.2584687769,
-0.1493445784,
-0.1839811355,
0.7467162013,
-0.0268980861,
-0.1115458459,
0.3854379654,
0.5179061294,
0.648236692,
-0.1909709424,
1.2342389822,
-0.194199577,
0.1985575259,
1.3652982712,
-0.0128212422,
0.8204945922,
0.440024823,
-0.11291527,
0.7658556104,
0.7808849216,
0.1817110777,
0.9074380398,
0.2686440051,
0.1457278579,
-0.3268274963,
-0.120098561,
-0.1078609228,
0.5505509973,
0.4795604944,
-0.5382739902,
0.0619093552,
0.0018068786,
0.141336903,
0.0471741073,
-0.4363851845,
1.2062119246,
0.1516563594,
-1.0965943336,
0.5750058889,
-0.1655351222,
0.8869544864,
-0.4980735183,
0.0491246469,
-0.1677256078,
0.3004925549,
-0.2327456325,
-0.6231412888,
0.0240679346,
-0.3164497912,
-0.2425213754,
-0.1955948919,
0.6775217652,
-0.5010254979,
-0.09387701,
0.3360831141,
0.4227876067,
-0.1568780392,
-0.1332547516,
-0.5650001764,
-0.0575956143,
0.0407483764,
-0.4008859694,
0.8380870819,
0.5762981772,
-0.0425272658,
0.6799306273,
0.614806354,
0.4333183765,
0.1902041286,
0.2536939681,
0.8822680116,
-0.6623694897,
-0.3486374915,
-0.9534010887,
0.2478608787,
-0.0892438516,
-0.3091822565,
0.8129637241,
0.1220714077,
1.1966034174,
0.1315981746,
0.9870787859,
0.3183207512,
0.4315083325,
-0.843167901,
0.4319447279,
-0.304889977,
0.2045316249,
-0.105867669,
-0.7600014806,
0.1360126287,
0.7162392735,
-0.5706902146,
0.0299458019,
0.727651,
0.8370918632,
0.0589692891,
-0.0706605092,
0.2058513016,
0.1140415967,
0.2925489545,
0.2772264183,
0.9273329973,
-0.0517785437,
0.2195178717,
-0.3928699195,
0.0843688548,
-0.2808306217,
-0.7301983237,
-1.1271585226,
-0.5465089083,
-0.1740394831,
-0.4423463643,
0.0713086277,
1.1408239603,
0.6014395952,
-1.1057213545,
-0.1488195211,
-0.3179329932,
0.1782131344,
-0.255125314,
-0.1758740842,
0.0930823907,
-1.0179975033,
-0.6178076863,
0.1981957406,
0.2060079873,
-0.1361469328,
-0.5213122368,
-0.2523615062,
-0.1490827352,
0.051863458,
0.3880299032,
0.5667191744,
-0.7614323497,
-0.5210422873,
-0.2044451684,
-0.2995420694,
0.1556836367,
0.9288507104,
-0.9664594531,
0.2726768255,
0.2901192904,
0.6207132936,
0.7286509871,
-0.1795807779,
0.7072982788,
-0.569857657,
0.2758130431,
-0.164142713,
0.2652368844,
0.094253771,
-0.2360947579,
0.2681483924,
-0.102650784,
-0.7528930306,
-0.7141368389,
0.3641232252,
-0.5846776366,
-0.1898025274,
1.2018723488,
-0.0130221499,
-0.2977808416,
-0.0921942517,
-0.1011877656,
0.262006253,
-0.3649581373,
0.9478986263,
0.549202621,
-0.1494705677,
-0.3282094896,
-0.6494971514,
1.1826695204,
0.4374117851,
-0.6547328234,
0.1574120075,
0.3476464748,
0.4160771668,
-0.0908908248,
0.3487485051,
0.0345878452,
0.2221942395,
-0.225178048,
-0.0108137513,
-0.0702418908,
-0.5365062952,
-0.427364558,
-0.0524842329,
0.7261587977,
0.0636210516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04044v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04044v3
|
PrivLM-Bench: A Multi-level Privacy Evaluation Benchmark for Language Models
| 2023-11-07T14:55:52 | 2024-06-01T14:04:21 |
Haoran Li, Dadi Guo, Donghao Li, Wei Fan, Qi Hu, Xin Liu, Chunkit Chan, Duanyi Yao, Yuan Yao, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The rapid development of language models (LMs) brings unprecedented
accessibility and usage for both models and users. On the one hand, powerful
LMs achieve state-of-the-art performance over numerous downstream NLP tasks. On
the other hand, more and more attention is paid to unrestricted model accesses
that may bring malicious privacy risks of data leakage. To address these
issues, many recent works propose privacy-preserving language models (PPLMs)
with differential privacy (DP). Unfortunately, different DP implementations
make it challenging for a fair comparison among existing PPLMs. In this paper,
we present PrivLM-Bench, a multi-perspective privacy evaluation benchmark to
empirically and intuitively quantify the privacy leakage of LMs. Instead of
only reporting DP parameters, PrivLM-Bench sheds light on the neglected
inference data privacy during actual usage. PrivLM-Bench first clearly defines
multi-faceted privacy objectives. Then, PrivLM-Bench constructs a unified
pipeline to perform private fine-tuning. Lastly, PrivLM-Bench performs existing
privacy attacks on LMs with pre-defined privacy objectives as the empirical
evaluation results. The empirical attack results are used to fairly and
intuitively evaluate the privacy leakage of various PPLMs. We conduct extensive
experiments on three datasets of GLUE for mainstream LMs.
|
[
-0.220911786,
-0.5751094222,
0.4949076176,
0.2403287143,
-0.0443228558,
0.0189304501,
-0.0944962576,
-0.0894359201,
-0.6747570634,
0.5519269109,
-0.4421364069,
-0.806543231,
-0.4656293094,
-0.3072321713,
-0.5038862228,
0.7710508108,
0.3055973947,
0.1097886488,
-0.212459743,
-0.1508773118,
-0.3717730641,
-0.6347468495,
0.1171405166,
0.2037897855,
0.4111092389,
0.0049120737,
0.4859984815,
0.5816633105,
0.4073338211,
0.2982476652,
0.0683982298,
-0.0475923121,
-0.3547025919,
0.2448287606,
-0.2218314111,
-0.2746474445,
-0.5288539529,
0.0235118009,
0.7980592251,
0.68251127,
-0.1559154838,
0.4769812524,
0.1998620778,
0.9168203473,
-1.273013711,
0.1143364981,
-0.6401831508,
0.0711099356,
-0.4014232457,
0.2280189246,
-0.6569492221,
-0.4298745394,
0.0080732452,
0.0450774729,
-0.0380151011,
0.139088273,
0.7009376884,
0.3599810004,
-0.1971317977,
0.2775227129,
-0.6173946857,
0.910472095,
-0.757396698,
0.7544971704,
0.5302256942,
0.4156626463,
-0.034178108,
-0.6445307136,
-0.292920053,
-0.3758033216,
-0.2138185501,
-0.1353675723,
-0.1120752394,
-0.0595985763,
0.1913536638,
0.412640661,
-0.5927407742,
-0.0079683829,
0.007848951,
-0.1400041282,
0.6832768321,
0.1781387329,
0.0244636405,
-0.0656682178,
-0.6114557385,
-0.1427491754,
-0.5585783124,
0.1711548865,
0.5157756209,
0.2564040422,
-0.179394275,
0.3394811153,
-0.1286028326,
0.8977880478,
-0.3435041904,
-0.2340371609,
0.3658547997,
-0.2421545684,
-0.3480381668,
-0.3186521828,
0.9027934074,
0.3972319067,
0.2141486853,
-0.4167930484,
0.1129417419,
-0.2467939407,
0.152312085,
-0.5918347836,
-0.2079429179,
0.3982245326,
-0.4540636837,
-0.3454782069,
0.0680319667,
-0.9356908798,
-0.8826807141,
-0.1731343269,
0.2781213224,
-0.2612190545,
-0.3793033957,
0.1689000428,
0.0480758213,
0.1171623468,
0.0042567006,
-0.5273297429,
0.6627926826,
0.9159409404,
0.5384438038,
-0.2221695632,
-0.4400979877,
-0.6144795418,
0.2506964207,
-0.1053043306,
0.3480479717,
-0.6111366153,
-0.3453636765,
-0.1570590585,
-0.0736742616,
-0.1484141648,
-0.4390110373,
0.5420036316,
-0.2366998941,
0.2467666417,
-0.173588708,
-0.5641910434,
0.0134669626,
0.2727366686,
-0.5384259224,
0.8373138905,
-0.0875086561,
-0.9229607582,
0.2736975551,
-0.5353111029,
-0.0735469759,
0.002668676,
-0.173189044,
-0.6468088031,
0.1349731535,
0.2662580907,
0.4575825036,
-0.1634605676,
0.2977858186,
-0.572301209,
-0.1800060719,
0.4220984578,
-0.4121848643,
0.8708752394,
0.1747313142,
-0.3342094719,
0.0955380946,
-0.9071891904,
0.1919900924,
0.0780881941,
0.0866665542,
-0.6391109228,
-0.06147331,
-0.3839741647,
0.2052423805,
0.4390352368,
-0.6506411433,
-0.149064675,
-0.3711766601,
0.1081949398,
0.8764457703,
-0.0574585274,
0.4162430167,
-0.1585928649,
0.3458683789,
-0.0580281653,
0.7510045171,
0.0229307972,
-0.3028487265,
-0.429325372,
-0.546861887,
0.5687358379,
0.4459975958,
0.1444329619,
0.3664924204,
-0.0912092179,
-0.5779675245,
-0.7194893956,
0.0619073771,
0.6119291782,
0.4543067813,
0.1640082747,
-0.2753357291,
-0.1335819662,
-1.2651643753,
-0.8686152697,
0.1467842758,
0.0192103479,
0.6661027074,
0.1343786567,
0.2574074864,
0.8742460608,
-0.2987398803,
-0.3135451376,
0.2627899647,
-0.0578023605,
0.0324082263,
0.5779359341,
0.4240767956,
-0.6809498668,
-0.6675447226,
-0.2976461351,
-0.6395756006,
-0.1932392269,
0.2360744625,
-0.1679251194,
-0.0489912108,
0.2110413164,
-0.3145724237,
0.5032926202,
0.8653498888,
-0.2210418582,
0.3630112112,
-0.2278834134,
-0.1372970343,
-0.5479651093,
0.1612425894,
-0.2265265584,
-0.4275200963,
-0.5027685761,
0.1512494832,
0.5576287508,
-0.2190113515,
-0.7720365524,
0.5280995369,
-0.6162198186,
-0.3038802147,
-0.0491193458,
-0.101534687,
0.1860828698,
0.4726818502,
-0.1911100149,
0.4908886552,
0.8798620105,
-0.4533407688,
0.0661081895,
-0.1393754631,
-0.2747575641,
0.1736630499,
-0.4240885675,
0.5053828955,
-0.0766431168,
0.0510507748,
-0.8189899325,
0.1546265483,
0.28450647,
-0.148424536,
0.3845595717,
-0.2211613506,
-0.646838665,
-0.0179058649,
-0.6446986794,
0.152652666,
0.531044662,
-0.310425669,
0.5986770391,
0.7264180779,
-0.1217633039,
-1.0336711407,
-0.6076693535,
0.0640521944,
-0.2474321723,
-0.4711779952,
0.2364505529,
-0.1220407039,
-0.5670147538,
0.0858007595,
-0.2348623872,
-0.1753312945,
0.3039615154,
0.4768299758,
0.057999149,
-0.0120854629,
-0.1973904818,
-0.0999007672,
-0.217010349,
0.0739189088,
0.0159683488,
0.5869669318,
-0.5597555041,
-0.6941011548,
-0.5773512125,
0.2777223587,
0.4868533313,
-0.5375996828,
0.9161727428,
0.2968740761,
-0.1832192391,
-0.2251236141,
-0.7373386621,
-0.04063287,
-0.4326926172,
0.1085341573,
-0.4245849848,
-0.4659932852,
0.3848762214,
-0.2269381881,
0.3078486323,
0.0855543241,
0.5628526211,
0.2656842172,
0.8917191029,
0.7332658768,
0.0257304981,
0.2690842748,
0.0794158801,
0.1805307716,
-0.7782621384,
-0.2666927874,
-0.5457594991,
-0.1603170782,
-0.5159897804,
-0.390319258,
0.1151811853,
0.2357961684,
-0.0571849123,
0.2987881303,
-0.5018210411,
0.658803761,
0.370872587,
-0.0671585426,
0.5632009506,
-0.3733462989,
-0.1095434353,
-0.2626423836,
-0.2894074619,
-0.4975614548,
1.2762316465,
0.4721466303,
0.7575834394,
0.1933507472,
0.8411245942,
0.0868163034,
0.3898789883,
-0.1640103161,
0.6184321046,
-0.2653852105,
-0.7198005915,
-0.2493804097,
-0.2283188999,
-0.7341611385,
0.6735746861,
0.1285142601,
-1.0082702637,
0.3376735449,
-0.0335700028,
-0.2611579597,
0.1395701915,
-0.7615777254,
1.0374788046,
-0.4067722261,
-0.8155668378,
-0.0184192993,
-0.8399136066,
0.5899685621,
-0.2268284559,
0.5716568232,
-0.5015428066,
-0.1767667532,
0.2741158903,
-0.3638937473,
0.7360242605,
-0.4670353234,
-0.0452627093,
-0.2371505052,
0.2477087677,
0.3862128854,
0.3550542295,
-0.1993887573,
0.3739506304,
-0.0399142019,
-0.2011068165,
-0.4335812628,
0.8961826563,
-0.5963609219,
-0.5607548952,
-0.4678743184,
-0.6309776902,
-0.5817171335,
0.2838055789,
-0.3159459829,
0.2087235153,
-0.2631416619,
0.4633361101,
0.5381861925,
-0.4816512465,
0.4082611799,
1.1125315428,
-0.4590605199,
0.0828547552,
0.6324246526,
-0.1070714071,
0.0943119526,
0.3884590268,
0.4669392705,
-0.5087074637,
-0.7075211406,
-0.2307573855,
0.131633997,
-0.5386852026,
-0.0061870692,
-0.7628179789,
-0.1700093895,
-0.4606746733,
0.3840527534,
-0.8012342453,
-0.2475149632,
0.3860110044,
0.0636667535,
0.0965876356,
0.418830812,
-0.2762331367,
-0.2841722369,
-0.7116210461,
0.3253306448,
0.323042959,
0.5306523442,
-0.2125761807,
-0.1429297924,
0.2507091165,
-0.0652219802,
-0.112112008,
-0.7862739563,
0.3149393499,
0.0463187359,
0.835588932,
-0.0076997266,
0.3410068154,
0.5180311799,
-0.7010238171,
0.7347339988,
-0.163866967,
-0.9904965162,
0.357611537,
-0.1976381987,
0.0203250051,
0.7418262959,
0.0647939965,
-0.1138211191,
-0.5432628393,
-0.756880343,
-0.8944835067,
0.7270033956,
0.233178854,
0.0924329311,
0.44552356,
-0.0654086843,
0.4532124102,
0.5949120522,
-0.8117939234,
-0.4680351913,
-0.2036049664,
0.0957477093,
0.1575196832,
-0.0921349749,
-0.2986280322,
-0.3020825982,
0.3857426345,
0.3485523462,
-0.2442150265,
-0.2706949115,
-0.1740299016,
0.3027134836,
0.5400926471,
0.4161603749,
0.8345349431,
-0.4828606546,
0.1196143404,
0.147434026,
-0.2715486288,
-0.1263945848,
0.3740913868,
-0.0582306944,
0.1208074316,
-0.0383243114,
0.6449599862,
0.1324403733,
-0.6622014642,
0.8488988876,
-0.4492128193,
-0.0103212167,
-0.2575864196,
0.0332381092,
0.3089111149,
0.072921589,
0.061903473,
0.0440616347,
0.1788518727,
-0.3444299996,
0.2435715497,
0.4374255538,
-0.3395460844,
-0.0712219998,
0.6410193443,
0.1103497222,
-0.3371973634,
0.1940388978,
0.0900322795,
-0.0933112726,
0.1083235666,
0.0458135232,
1.0041255951,
-0.3786872923,
0.0963998735,
-0.0932128504,
0.3138269186,
0.130061999,
0.1873278022,
-0.2802015841,
-0.3613689244,
-0.3315552175,
-0.7376922369,
-0.4942781031,
0.6335992813,
-0.9105873704,
0.0105662998,
-0.5044257045,
0.0449095219,
-0.0371503085,
-0.1944716722,
-0.6341735721,
-0.1474829018,
0.2646495998,
0.6559304595,
-0.5599976778,
1.0327458382,
0.265517056,
-0.1038368866,
-0.488258779,
0.1679948121,
0.1833243817,
-0.8237604499,
0.6082276106,
0.0509485453,
-0.1095084623,
-0.2775193155,
-0.2949804664,
-0.6453408599,
0.7712295651,
0.6694115996,
-0.9694624543,
0.2649168968,
0.4952553213,
0.4757713974,
-0.0157145038,
-0.205650568,
0.5558739901,
0.6626895666,
-0.5551553965,
-1.0325052738,
0.019597467,
-0.1045163944,
-0.1475773305,
0.1305176914,
-0.6495043635,
1.2176538706,
0.2150138021,
-0.1408620775,
-0.0430083536,
0.1254157722,
0.3660133481,
0.1194918305,
0.6128414869,
0.4672631323,
0.6870824099,
0.1030218527,
1.3122988939,
-0.5690360665,
0.4249105752,
1.2582377195,
-0.6240225434,
0.8396644592,
0.2855293751,
-0.2729078233,
0.3250715137,
0.0796078295,
0.0468302146,
0.8729243875,
0.4756048322,
-0.1148352399,
-0.1091729626,
-0.0780413896,
-0.6418435574,
0.3109564483,
0.0979406461,
-0.460539341,
-0.4850490391,
-0.0565338954,
0.1181893796,
0.1814409792,
-0.0796495005,
0.8482708931,
0.1551105827,
-0.3778076768,
0.4321110845,
0.062182907,
0.3689997196,
-0.6985757947,
0.3173274994,
-0.0256166589,
0.7099245191,
-0.0577709787,
-0.6546638012,
0.2296010703,
0.2530445755,
0.0345505401,
-0.4667525887,
0.8251048326,
-0.3535718024,
-0.2267286628,
0.3858509064,
0.7867589593,
0.1885157079,
-0.3238117397,
-1.1045328379,
0.2763696015,
-0.3061124086,
-0.4642627239,
0.7622922659,
0.2469958067,
0.105206728,
0.4202264249,
0.5460285544,
-0.0063205808,
0.2466704398,
0.5458968282,
0.7583812475,
-0.4718069434,
-0.4476741254,
-1.2225675583,
0.681234777,
-0.327583313,
-0.3165790141,
1.2354507446,
0.7231420875,
0.6041786075,
-0.0017242396,
0.84452492,
0.2052518129,
0.8492950201,
-0.4517852366,
0.827716887,
-0.4252706766,
0.3507274687,
-0.3705948293,
-0.8155713081,
-0.2860584557,
0.4257189929,
-0.4610174894,
-0.1749254465,
0.7443186045,
0.7354077101,
0.0010766007,
0.0683612972,
0.4308074415,
0.3050025702,
0.1649875641,
0.4420940876,
0.9322677851,
-0.3207997382,
0.441983223,
-0.7794810534,
-0.2099604756,
0.0899958909,
-1.1539187431,
-0.9661544561,
-0.3670936823,
-0.3517949283,
-0.1630186737,
0.2615867257,
0.1979703009,
0.8618510365,
-0.8006884456,
-0.167165339,
-0.1584078521,
-0.0413640887,
-0.2881942987,
-0.1901194602,
0.4984891713,
-0.1287850589,
-0.8137747645,
0.6561484337,
0.3593089581,
-0.2440796643,
-0.6618339419,
0.1626763642,
-0.0746945888,
-0.0929178819,
0.1862794757,
0.1141251177,
-0.6838716865,
0.0155597758,
-0.1055110246,
-0.1206145063,
-0.0563124977,
0.7534900904,
-0.7005887628,
0.4628755748,
0.4843516648,
0.5608529449,
0.5520409942,
0.1424329132,
0.5952627659,
-1.1128736734,
0.384921968,
0.4555664659,
0.3385195434,
0.4637717307,
-0.1405159682,
0.3706820309,
-0.1070193499,
-0.4824664295,
-1.3463118076,
0.1548882574,
-0.6364525557,
-0.5592660904,
0.959467113,
-0.4101151824,
-0.4145736098,
-0.3188668489,
0.0209594294,
-0.1242652759,
-0.3835398555,
0.5881843567,
0.6325295568,
0.011921769,
-0.1307334602,
-0.6713296771,
0.6511209011,
0.3676334023,
-0.6625355482,
0.623403132,
0.2920266092,
0.4017063081,
0.0577842407,
0.5061968565,
-0.5514680743,
0.0158600658,
0.0205531176,
-0.2946792543,
-0.5196460485,
-0.3415561616,
-0.3046174049,
0.5357780457,
-0.0216625296,
-0.4794123173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04257v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04257v2
|
mPLUG-Owl2: Revolutionizing Multi-modal Large Language Model with Modality Collaboration
| 2023-11-07T14:21:29 | 2023-11-09T01:56:51 |
Qinghao Ye, Haiyang Xu, Jiabo Ye, Ming Yan, Anwen Hu, Haowei Liu, Qi Qian, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have demonstrated impressive
instruction abilities across various open-ended tasks. However, previous
methods primarily focus on enhancing multi-modal capabilities. In this work, we
introduce a versatile multi-modal large language model, mPLUG-Owl2, which
effectively leverages modality collaboration to improve performance in both
text and multi-modal tasks. mPLUG-Owl2 utilizes a modularized network design,
with the language decoder acting as a universal interface for managing
different modalities. Specifically, mPLUG-Owl2 incorporates shared functional
modules to facilitate modality collaboration and introduces a modality-adaptive
module that preserves modality-specific features. Extensive experiments reveal
that mPLUG-Owl2 is capable of generalizing both text tasks and multi-modal
tasks and achieving state-of-the-art performances with a single generic model.
Notably, mPLUG-Owl2 is the first MLLM model that demonstrates the modality
collaboration phenomenon in both pure-text and multi-modal scenarios, setting a
pioneering path in the development of future multi-modal foundation models.
|
[
-0.1166037172,
-0.9052824378,
0.429117322,
0.2986691594,
-0.1191412657,
-0.2838380337,
-0.4309579134,
-0.6359146833,
-0.0321620926,
0.2273635268,
-0.4354161322,
-0.2707281113,
-0.5570892096,
0.1908665746,
0.0092539694,
0.8668931127,
0.2873675823,
0.2438012809,
-0.2984960675,
-0.0993581861,
-0.5903810263,
-0.4860277772,
-0.4895500541,
-0.4482030272,
0.7544423342,
0.0520544425,
0.7546982765,
0.5664377213,
0.4644709826,
0.3223055005,
0.0202448722,
0.3781118095,
-0.3237568736,
0.0894800276,
-0.1083445251,
-0.3152656555,
-0.9683849216,
-0.0288616437,
0.8563480377,
0.7271821499,
-0.0481787808,
-0.0246048067,
0.2035922706,
0.2790326774,
-0.5352165699,
0.5314519405,
-0.5775082111,
-0.1591314971,
-0.0371781662,
-0.1078840494,
-0.7545418143,
0.3206287622,
0.0918607414,
-0.7331272364,
-0.3154674768,
-0.0675943047,
0.2905973792,
0.1790212691,
-0.8496229649,
-0.1970833242,
-0.6456319094,
0.9202551842,
-0.5920613408,
0.5449002981,
0.6036381721,
0.0902217925,
-0.0754675716,
-0.7581032515,
-0.4556511343,
-0.3453266621,
-0.1522321999,
0.196483776,
0.0202674735,
0.2964041829,
-0.0438278168,
0.1748408079,
-0.7009183764,
0.150591284,
-0.2100581527,
-0.2415675521,
0.3955137432,
0.1800628603,
0.2152615339,
-0.0128222685,
-0.6301497221,
0.2122684419,
-0.2476470768,
0.1722680777,
0.0993660316,
0.2974321246,
-0.0947630778,
0.5752871037,
-0.1042709425,
0.7831498981,
-0.2809264064,
-0.4753375649,
0.2263885736,
-0.5795458555,
-0.2557855844,
-0.3390400112,
0.8707635999,
0.3123241067,
-0.4889445305,
-0.2746372223,
-0.191474393,
-0.0040248809,
-0.0231822114,
-0.7647245526,
-0.034179993,
0.0237103254,
-0.7976382971,
-0.2205776721,
0.016985625,
-0.441629082,
-0.2616649866,
-0.4724947512,
0.7817023993,
-0.3432376683,
-0.6996396184,
0.2994808853,
0.1204754189,
0.136957109,
0.6523988247,
-0.8314467669,
0.1607787311,
1.1180100441,
0.7737337351,
-0.1867470443,
-0.777717948,
-0.8599046469,
0.4603947401,
0.0247907732,
0.4219494164,
-1.0514934063,
-0.1777106822,
-0.0919696316,
0.1575879604,
-0.4285570681,
-0.1508615017,
0.4072018266,
-0.3114661574,
0.740765214,
-0.2653199136,
-0.3403286338,
-0.3863863349,
0.5816765428,
-0.7718812227,
1.0422874689,
-0.0285536274,
-0.7403781414,
0.0315117687,
-0.9580853581,
-0.5140929222,
-0.0312016942,
-0.0816360414,
-0.1019102931,
0.1320558488,
-0.3055105805,
0.4175791144,
-0.552062273,
0.1340443492,
-0.1932884306,
-0.303060472,
0.3038929105,
-0.5903666019,
0.5391415954,
-0.0031192806,
-0.1744436622,
0.4621602297,
-0.6275733709,
-0.0832942948,
-0.2024353445,
-0.8896021843,
-0.3267093301,
0.205781728,
0.58276546,
0.4340073466,
0.5443576574,
-0.3730189204,
0.4317673445,
-0.030393213,
0.4624530673,
0.5138883591,
-0.6014971733,
0.5331345201,
-0.4599291086,
0.2567968965,
-0.1107703447,
0.4336905479,
-0.4338883758,
-0.7098150253,
-0.5304789543,
-0.3346387744,
0.1087836921,
0.4686180055,
-0.7716429234,
0.4437172711,
-0.0508695543,
-0.0885047168,
-0.323718369,
0.0789129883,
0.3229936957,
0.2564017177,
0.2404916137,
-0.1138203964,
-0.197139889,
-0.7703188658,
0.2953602672,
-0.2877544761,
-0.0203648973,
0.372068584,
0.1741867065,
-0.595472157,
0.6073188186,
-0.1089423224,
-0.4126955867,
-0.2361849546,
0.3713032603,
0.0606984161,
0.594517827,
0.4136608839,
-0.9767452478,
-0.3900082111,
0.321837008,
-0.5000193715,
0.0372669473,
0.0392362624,
-0.0641379803,
0.445225507,
0.3315428495,
-0.5609674454,
-0.1456041336,
1.0607016087,
-0.5924127102,
0.752677381,
-0.1829127818,
0.1261003315,
-1.5641460419,
0.2901698351,
-0.5240563154,
-0.2287516594,
-0.6704347134,
0.2910890877,
-0.0182429478,
-0.1855546534,
-0.2315189242,
0.2398588508,
-0.3538940549,
0.052665621,
-0.5498564839,
-0.0735235959,
0.1988003254,
0.3715929091,
0.0876470357,
0.7202156782,
0.8462674618,
-0.1816534102,
0.353271693,
-0.0725395381,
0.1231992096,
0.2551467121,
-0.5619118214,
0.1968824863,
0.0178494025,
0.3750623465,
-0.9049389958,
-0.2636544406,
0.1485962123,
-0.1563723236,
0.2739918232,
-0.1975651234,
-0.5396710634,
-0.0419785753,
-0.2988280952,
0.6673855186,
0.1370915174,
-0.2837797999,
1.1736392975,
0.1088546962,
-0.0314050056,
-0.6139168739,
-0.6957808137,
0.3907862306,
0.1258067191,
-0.8462026119,
0.1548387408,
-0.4033479989,
-0.0269199423,
-0.0920616239,
0.1762517691,
-0.2710905373,
0.0227893796,
0.1437305212,
0.2542148829,
-0.5131085515,
0.4884687066,
-0.0921384618,
-0.2653411031,
-0.0093786549,
-0.3477287292,
0.7548247576,
-0.2280120105,
-0.2908774316,
-0.5008327365,
0.7739872932,
1.0639922619,
-0.7381448746,
0.8995748758,
1.1594774723,
-0.3529248536,
-0.0512649156,
-0.6260517836,
-0.3725683093,
-0.4835289121,
0.601338625,
-0.4069488943,
-1.1873469353,
0.2482736707,
-0.1112382486,
0.1470517516,
-0.1290866286,
0.6385054588,
0.2077374607,
1.0912570953,
0.8171098828,
0.0929586738,
0.5750918388,
-0.1453604996,
0.1468493938,
-1.0099506378,
-0.4788424969,
-0.1048825383,
-0.2665845454,
-0.2976156473,
-0.8919588327,
0.4291181564,
0.199136883,
0.3319521844,
0.2905586064,
-0.3398628235,
0.4353109598,
0.4537131786,
0.31322366,
0.4590438902,
-0.1913462579,
-0.0374323986,
0.1360570788,
-0.7127284408,
-0.3719540834,
0.9634395838,
0.3380564451,
0.7080610394,
0.4812978506,
0.248486042,
0.1373128593,
0.1928037107,
-1.0623581409,
0.6026126146,
-0.2303576618,
-0.5053447485,
-0.343526423,
-0.3360028863,
-0.7824488282,
0.6467077732,
-0.4444772601,
-0.6244853735,
-0.1039332449,
0.0325553752,
-0.0834412724,
0.2230243981,
-0.6752780676,
0.9492708445,
-0.0757493228,
-0.6137341857,
-0.5269986391,
-0.4695030451,
0.4236464202,
-0.0252749436,
0.1981938183,
-0.1346387565,
-0.4638512731,
0.3460479081,
-0.1325454414,
0.8005440831,
0.1831734776,
-0.2304578125,
0.1142871305,
0.2582529783,
0.5080333948,
0.1316545904,
-0.3301664889,
-0.0447298437,
-0.0597046241,
-0.3351940513,
-0.4343325198,
0.8530858755,
-0.6984934807,
-0.4371763468,
-0.165324837,
-1.0661861897,
-0.0111450143,
0.3023925424,
-0.0849653631,
0.9244292974,
-0.1357300729,
0.6980878711,
0.4532705545,
0.088636905,
0.9147562981,
0.6182935834,
-0.2448210716,
-0.4443894923,
0.7657253146,
-0.0905670375,
0.4902697504,
0.564527154,
0.545373261,
-0.2063287795,
-0.4354511499,
-0.2654777467,
0.0906280428,
-0.4537971616,
-0.0792520717,
-0.8573439121,
0.0901112258,
-0.3494600356,
-0.0925920159,
-0.4444241822,
-0.2255166769,
-0.3420849442,
0.3653370142,
0.100370869,
0.8586741686,
-0.1391284764,
0.1071552187,
-0.7379581928,
-0.0106745958,
0.7454093099,
0.4195505977,
0.011646267,
-0.2197531164,
-0.1909753531,
0.0975719839,
-0.1332750916,
-0.7133129835,
-0.1784542799,
0.263815999,
0.4202371836,
0.4174298644,
-0.0628229976,
0.1120225191,
-0.4516689181,
0.7663429976,
0.5277636051,
-0.9363705516,
0.1391359419,
-0.8683158755,
0.4440537393,
0.2326238751,
0.0677765012,
-0.6192846298,
0.0077547077,
0.0353058353,
-0.641807735,
0.9213889241,
0.2046813816,
0.1010854468,
0.1710433364,
-0.0450014286,
0.283637166,
0.0636607558,
-1.128002882,
0.1093526259,
-0.2528990507,
-0.0318567082,
0.1676869988,
-0.388753891,
-0.4207516909,
-0.2711200118,
0.3106378913,
-0.5014160872,
0.313338697,
-0.0520836711,
-0.0551680475,
-0.0014729584,
0.3919896185,
1.0013440847,
0.9704163671,
0.0703934133,
0.425755322,
0.1649707854,
-0.4325056672,
-0.1062536687,
0.2992725968,
0.0182688348,
-0.1072084606,
0.5247632265,
0.7192706466,
0.3300859928,
-0.5376749635,
0.6702914238,
-0.0395810567,
-0.0770986676,
0.0288635939,
-0.0556788146,
0.4133706093,
0.4436184466,
0.38838166,
0.1645975113,
0.1600776613,
-0.7957940698,
0.1892663091,
0.4395850897,
-0.2025943398,
-0.4686002135,
0.6625501513,
0.4241175652,
-0.6059235334,
-0.0334006771,
-0.1684359759,
-0.5178508759,
0.3338416815,
0.847358942,
0.8469493389,
-0.2665430307,
0.2865722477,
0.1887260824,
0.3993419409,
-0.1139514446,
0.1742441952,
-0.2220871896,
-0.4404845536,
-0.7055677176,
-0.6028019786,
-0.253601253,
0.3185766041,
-0.4843052328,
0.3049069643,
-0.357242763,
-0.1697306633,
-0.261775732,
-0.1856413782,
-0.2771996558,
-0.1698499471,
0.1969759762,
0.5654652715,
-0.5988887548,
1.1182115078,
1.0695016384,
-0.1862469912,
-0.6986098289,
0.0594444796,
0.037009012,
-0.4318045378,
0.3991988897,
0.4329321682,
-0.3367956579,
-0.0669483915,
-0.0324314646,
-0.7963087559,
1.3719800711,
0.1786928773,
-0.5706221461,
-0.1046666205,
0.253254056,
0.3390484154,
-0.5378561616,
0.2921380997,
-0.0050740484,
0.561606586,
0.1393527091,
-1.354624033,
0.0110304207,
-0.171344623,
-0.0778324157,
0.0894033313,
-0.9878827333,
1.1303369999,
0.083746165,
0.0913858414,
0.1109027267,
0.3855372071,
-0.0398258045,
0.2025878727,
0.6037484407,
0.3740547895,
0.4548168778,
-0.1404386908,
0.7459034324,
-0.4578467309,
0.3946687579,
1.0294322968,
-0.2430979311,
1.0016921759,
0.3040297627,
0.1657322794,
0.2532585859,
-0.0605980009,
0.2064629793,
0.1636812687,
-0.4172205925,
-0.6806157827,
-0.5929181576,
-0.3795200586,
-0.5282446742,
0.8608809114,
0.1477727592,
-0.313752681,
-0.3525225222,
0.2759158313,
0.2104442716,
0.0513535626,
-0.1542904675,
0.8020710945,
-0.3170641065,
-0.4364284277,
0.468662411,
0.196623385,
0.8860154152,
-0.8487829566,
-0.0889609978,
0.04136841,
0.2492579818,
-0.0668957382,
-0.5364533663,
0.1226970851,
-0.5054268241,
-0.5468119979,
-0.1619168818,
0.5894629955,
-0.9808459282,
-0.4881154895,
0.5737249851,
0.2933503985,
-0.285420239,
-0.0841165632,
-0.6267855763,
0.5589137673,
-0.3418106437,
-0.1181465611,
0.3062834144,
0.2429437339,
0.2125684321,
0.4444291592,
0.729682982,
-0.3938972652,
0.1285917163,
0.090193212,
0.93865031,
-0.1999222338,
-0.4104485512,
-0.758913219,
0.6393549442,
0.0394239277,
-0.2872064412,
0.5999532342,
0.8728384376,
0.5889057517,
-0.1251631677,
0.5088135004,
-0.2518897355,
0.0516245514,
-0.5439014435,
0.8162668943,
-0.8159799576,
-0.0106209414,
-0.0831889957,
-1.0916050673,
-0.1731126755,
0.5806685686,
0.0814474076,
-0.0602566898,
0.8868176937,
0.8831255436,
-0.2816839814,
0.0181048177,
0.6073215604,
0.2628344893,
0.5374944806,
0.756657958,
0.7635449171,
-0.5128815174,
0.7000223398,
-0.2051611096,
-0.5310992002,
-0.3566307425,
-0.9449660778,
-1.1239967346,
-0.8461869955,
-0.0855250731,
-0.2142008841,
-0.2055639327,
1.1797196865,
1.0055999756,
-0.5374723673,
-0.41353935,
0.1461236328,
-0.0196450949,
-0.1350138038,
-0.2661477327,
0.0756878704,
-0.2869484127,
-0.9185780287,
0.7279286981,
0.6018029451,
-0.210025087,
-0.4802587628,
-0.2414611876,
-0.4246334434,
0.0204188786,
1.1941179037,
-0.1446787119,
-0.9537125826,
-0.3066076636,
0.1042438745,
-0.2275099456,
-0.1809215844,
1.0913091898,
-0.3276526332,
0.5788488388,
0.6584640741,
0.5626143813,
-0.0125054885,
-0.178822726,
0.5632054806,
-0.4104437232,
0.4158965051,
0.1073882356,
0.3235136569,
0.1849850714,
-0.2246747911,
0.3368569314,
0.4737711847,
-0.5598964095,
-0.7724643946,
0.4498229623,
-1.3137751818,
-0.4339303076,
1.4849073887,
0.0423862301,
0.0826064125,
-0.1143503189,
-0.6171705127,
0.0294717066,
-0.2991977334,
0.737349391,
0.6768388748,
0.0018567871,
-0.2542082071,
-0.3709662855,
0.1928981692,
0.3756142259,
-0.829562664,
0.2341781706,
0.673797369,
0.2171018571,
0.2482260764,
0.3818073869,
0.078192085,
0.4069752991,
-0.0065471269,
-0.1235460341,
-0.7619432211,
-0.5682492256,
-0.1464016438,
0.3818464875,
-0.0251978021,
-0.1102135032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04020v1
|
Analyzing Film Adaptation through Narrative Alignment
| 2023-11-07T14:18:03 | 2023-11-07T14:18:03 |
Tanzir Pial, Shahreen Salim, Charuta Pethe, Allen Kim, Steven Skiena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Novels are often adapted into feature films, but the differences between the
two media usually require dropping sections of the source text from the movie
script. Here we study this screen adaptation process by constructing narrative
alignments using the Smith-Waterman local alignment algorithm coupled with
SBERT embedding distance to quantify text similarity between scenes and book
units. We use these alignments to perform an automated analysis of 40
adaptations, revealing insights into the screenwriting process concerning (i)
faithfulness of adaptation, (ii) importance of dialog, (iii) preservation of
narrative order, and (iv) gender representation issues reflective of the
Bechdel test.
|
[
-0.0955839604,
-0.3916460276,
0.6037198305,
-0.3788025379,
0.002847387,
0.1363486201,
0.1393441707,
-0.2808607221,
0.0599998049,
0.7598871589,
-0.7144340873,
0.0912724137,
-0.4548883438,
0.2773839831,
-0.3193563521,
1.1859235764,
-0.7006107569,
-0.033892151,
-0.061825864,
-0.3987723589,
-0.6944930553,
0.1325126588,
0.1666467637,
-0.184244886,
0.1712042689,
0.0885322988,
0.9031718969,
0.8626079559,
0.8578482866,
0.3440358341,
0.2575086653,
0.0490208901,
-0.4086499512,
0.4011143148,
-0.5927842855,
-0.6427774429,
0.1517073363,
-0.0667673573,
1.025044322,
0.6141335368,
0.3509830832,
0.4582943916,
0.2250697166,
0.7847754359,
-0.8137271404,
-0.3170419931,
-0.2456394732,
0.2429578751,
-0.0312662162,
-0.3683186769,
-0.3893690109,
-0.7604198456,
0.478574574,
-0.649260819,
0.6206917763,
0.1606426835,
0.8655437231,
0.2193810791,
-0.1587661207,
-0.4346848428,
-0.9688319564,
0.7088481784,
-0.577901721,
-0.2030084282,
0.0972329974,
0.3472648263,
-0.20255211,
-0.1077621132,
-0.4086037576,
-0.0697054639,
-0.0857656002,
0.1611597687,
-0.1954781115,
-0.1525095403,
0.0783008784,
0.496551007,
-0.7836748362,
-0.1400434226,
-0.4717000425,
-0.1146655157,
0.7407152057,
0.3140927255,
0.6095199585,
-0.2984603345,
-0.4254939854,
-0.2403565496,
-0.2391873449,
0.162498191,
0.2752679586,
0.1164053753,
-0.0918957442,
0.459736824,
0.3896832168,
0.3067630231,
0.2191435695,
-0.0872395411,
0.080953531,
-0.580100596,
-0.1093217358,
0.5570620298,
0.4839292765,
0.9586635232,
0.366089046,
0.1483739763,
0.1791329086,
-0.157864809,
0.6403440237,
-0.5891280174,
0.2233234197,
-0.1554959118,
-0.6122291684,
0.0166088566,
0.0210226756,
-0.5641031861,
-1.0824196339,
-0.2056037635,
0.8964731097,
-0.5766810179,
0.0304720365,
-0.2971805036,
-0.8915302157,
0.7160139084,
0.4295294583,
-1.0044273138,
0.3292033672,
0.3337363899,
0.7313115001,
-0.3724131286,
-0.429097563,
-0.1210273951,
0.5895505548,
-0.7794343233,
0.8927224278,
-0.2984509766,
-0.1023152024,
-0.0633031204,
0.2093536854,
-0.5091400146,
-0.2346565723,
0.3047738671,
-0.0683863014,
0.2273800671,
-0.1851258576,
-0.5660077929,
-0.4369306564,
0.039220389,
-0.8273386359,
0.5869647264,
0.5050861835,
-0.5820562243,
0.1848575473,
-0.1889772564,
-0.3062021434,
-0.2810566127,
-0.1677344292,
-0.1874873191,
0.5174454451,
0.3510122001,
0.0046693822,
-0.4202466607,
0.0204103719,
-0.1423365176,
-0.5916401744,
0.5842702985,
-0.1548880786,
0.5789903998,
0.1265120506,
-0.1624085456,
-0.0856610462,
-0.4933670759,
-0.0887946486,
-0.1604605764,
0.1703221351,
-0.4090281427,
0.0901288986,
-0.112070553,
-0.4611772597,
0.1325555891,
-0.1140955016,
0.2870943248,
-0.2476243526,
0.3173868358,
0.669182241,
0.3153106868,
1.0244919062,
-0.7544654012,
0.7673572302,
-0.2292562425,
-0.0227155555,
-0.6071212292,
-0.0425628833,
-0.5726168752,
0.0977248475,
0.1415600777,
0.8315886855,
-0.5810132027,
0.2464381009,
-0.1065323576,
-0.6044125557,
-0.4387220442,
0.0958716869,
0.418948859,
0.188170284,
-0.2109436244,
-0.6911175847,
-0.3712390363,
-0.7667406797,
-0.6918054223,
-0.1830072105,
0.0806615502,
-0.1173450947,
0.3356436491,
-0.0929663405,
1.0389422178,
-0.6261283159,
-0.2273841798,
-0.3512951434,
-0.0926162601,
0.3864668608,
0.5393785834,
0.8734077215,
-0.4866109788,
-0.4615020752,
0.3363117278,
-1.0476772785,
-0.1908926815,
-0.4679895043,
-0.2262295932,
0.1311120093,
0.425843358,
-0.1324182004,
0.7931190729,
0.4809488356,
-0.6900208592,
0.5916497111,
-0.4447472095,
0.7020584941,
-1.0876792669,
-0.2421892434,
0.1093974486,
-0.068041116,
-0.4780421555,
-0.1425212026,
-0.1225206703,
-0.2423092425,
0.223873809,
0.4450206757,
-0.4365136027,
-0.3125736415,
0.0311567187,
0.2591882646,
0.4555722177,
0.2430927753,
-0.1500694454,
0.6654120684,
0.0777726173,
-0.3430534601,
0.2611069679,
0.3482764959,
-0.4715194702,
0.6331173778,
-0.0780030265,
0.0806686953,
-0.3245176077,
-0.0049813488,
-1.5715367794,
-0.2266350389,
0.2551762164,
-0.1871396005,
0.0226313695,
-0.0746792406,
0.1279027611,
0.1437087506,
-0.5965617895,
0.3875644505,
0.3630308211,
-0.0035628953,
0.7847992182,
0.1768186539,
-0.7569019198,
-0.1958360523,
-0.5833585262,
-0.2204021215,
-0.4888233244,
-0.4541185796,
0.4997868836,
-0.101334475,
-0.5016994476,
0.085672982,
-0.1314130574,
-0.4712109864,
-0.248435691,
0.3820813596,
0.1541925222,
-0.5500879884,
-0.2057929039,
0.4849779308,
0.1051822677,
-0.4057341814,
0.3061148822,
-0.0713142604,
0.3181518316,
0.017349923,
-0.5586528778,
0.5265469551,
0.5864124298,
0.2478441745,
0.411740005,
0.5459086299,
-0.2500963211,
-0.1340626776,
-0.173523277,
0.1959681362,
-0.4102964401,
0.2494555712,
-0.2914332449,
-0.5326111913,
0.4797382057,
0.0630096644,
0.0550969876,
0.3901485503,
0.2414271533,
-0.4713781476,
0.4096909463,
0.8156370521,
0.0609800778,
0.8169587255,
0.1393493712,
0.3998493552,
-0.6973994374,
0.3036150634,
-0.6808946133,
-0.5535213947,
-0.5227563381,
-0.3794489801,
0.0772388205,
0.3931848705,
-0.226688996,
0.7770313621,
-0.4708158076,
0.8288652897,
0.2400843352,
-0.1380258799,
0.2458422035,
-0.0224695057,
0.1092790142,
-0.6775267124,
-0.2361016423,
-0.7076482773,
0.8560273647,
0.3621620536,
0.5207594633,
0.4125677049,
0.3392004073,
0.8315782547,
0.1966775954,
-0.4235239029,
0.2367356122,
-0.2949545979,
-0.6505308747,
-0.4934847653,
0.0928208828,
-0.7012446523,
0.0944110453,
-0.2432529628,
-0.8461819887,
0.5503615141,
-0.2122411877,
-0.59706074,
-0.2540940642,
-1.0579234362,
0.8663399816,
-0.1102235094,
-0.194841668,
-0.1874902248,
-0.5385172963,
0.0727649778,
-0.4479752779,
0.3015086949,
-0.2255525887,
0.2489579171,
0.8742762208,
-0.1189571023,
0.5340053439,
0.0328719355,
0.0489260554,
0.6439648867,
0.5532918572,
0.0458890535,
-0.3883801997,
-0.4492939413,
-0.1743080169,
0.6655054688,
-0.1518230736,
-0.7838265896,
0.2509433925,
-0.7528911829,
-0.4326553047,
-0.6195581555,
-0.9790976644,
0.1019688919,
0.0468796939,
0.0721605122,
0.5068076253,
-0.4683506787,
-0.2712597251,
0.158456862,
-0.4242311418,
0.6999691725,
0.2483628094,
-0.5310316086,
-0.8760524988,
0.5649992824,
0.3336004615,
0.3590715528,
0.3404256701,
0.2521923482,
-0.1980087012,
-0.5438994169,
-0.5608823299,
0.1063338816,
-0.6853304505,
-0.0484509207,
0.0703830123,
-0.2363184541,
-0.4367212057,
-0.8839084506,
-0.0978878438,
-0.2942640781,
0.0689900145,
-0.0404969603,
0.5917688608,
0.7308602929,
0.2167742103,
0.6285894513,
-0.815729022,
0.443426162,
0.1301404238,
-0.0658641607,
-0.4578532875,
-1.0216941833,
-0.4366095662,
-0.4431711733,
-0.6750571728,
-0.8731198311,
0.3709608018,
0.5016471744,
0.3469030261,
0.4699731469,
0.2683532834,
0.8966667056,
-0.5323109031,
0.8099330068,
0.3029607832,
-0.9991152287,
0.6003722548,
-0.5567073226,
0.3721528351,
0.9934000373,
0.324093461,
-0.3601633608,
-0.0297252275,
-0.2682279944,
-0.2819914818,
0.6913248301,
0.2959229052,
0.2375789285,
0.6251216531,
0.5083574653,
0.5469021797,
0.1012649685,
-0.5061056018,
0.3436760902,
0.054802265,
-0.5393138528,
-0.2206407934,
0.1854496002,
-0.01688472,
-0.498272121,
0.1652186662,
-0.1505426615,
0.2961782515,
0.3868746758,
-0.5461368561,
-0.2403700948,
0.0945095271,
0.2166138142,
0.860237956,
-0.2117524147,
-0.0309393201,
0.0684161112,
-0.6858432889,
0.3040535748,
-0.1898858249,
-0.1631754935,
0.3078638017,
0.837959528,
0.7269651294,
0.3086631894,
-0.6337122321,
0.3010750413,
0.1743464917,
-0.1507792473,
-0.1642337441,
0.3811422288,
-0.2208473086,
0.7227467895,
0.4957850873,
0.0264658462,
0.1528266519,
-0.9884297252,
0.0750502869,
-0.0149459252,
-0.4685983956,
-0.067416124,
0.1976404041,
0.2423742861,
-0.7779659033,
0.449750483,
0.1653359681,
-0.336235404,
0.8359885216,
0.6754428148,
0.9371973872,
-0.5707056522,
0.4407742321,
0.3612063229,
0.4106945097,
-0.0880618691,
-0.1432234794,
0.1663041562,
-0.8028228283,
-0.3745573461,
-0.7568343878,
-0.4916955829,
-0.4253422618,
-0.6116999984,
0.194720611,
-0.6281806231,
0.0389103629,
0.2692609727,
-0.1667149514,
-0.0623155832,
-0.1242689341,
0.2265262604,
0.5964313745,
-1.1716114283,
0.495229423,
0.5113994479,
-0.323746711,
-0.5585386753,
0.1506076604,
0.1625413746,
-0.4371686876,
0.1214384288,
0.4381398857,
0.0727048516,
-0.0266264789,
-0.1964698434,
-0.8579875827,
1.3734704256,
0.699993968,
-0.4988082647,
0.044850003,
0.1340769827,
0.5584292412,
-0.7319597602,
0.1061158031,
0.9080510736,
0.2548226118,
-0.3507244885,
-1.131814003,
-0.0575799383,
-0.1668940037,
0.1858015209,
0.4803369939,
-0.2396696955,
0.4468486011,
-0.1481384337,
-0.1255769879,
0.3652738035,
0.3176362514,
0.321877867,
0.7466798425,
0.2667292058,
0.0514039285,
0.6281219721,
0.0553330816,
0.7768300772,
0.2029107064,
0.178740114,
0.877723217,
-0.5886922479,
0.7443691492,
0.518140018,
-0.4252702594,
0.8601516485,
0.5648875833,
-0.0947722122,
0.5489239693,
0.0454623476,
-0.0779773518,
0.1993870139,
-0.0937292576,
-0.0256730914,
0.421182394,
0.1422776431,
-0.742602706,
-0.1483584344,
0.0919212401,
-0.2192784697,
0.68028301,
-0.3987480998,
0.7809891105,
0.1593936235,
-0.9338662028,
0.2867947519,
-0.364371419,
0.0292660091,
-0.6148630977,
-0.2329779565,
-0.1643936932,
0.3475030661,
-0.1292281002,
-0.7306629419,
0.3185330927,
0.1248111725,
-0.7910587192,
-0.1519371271,
0.7276152372,
-0.2341616601,
-0.6013968587,
0.1542697251,
0.1648376584,
0.3964462876,
0.2906702161,
-0.6358053088,
0.2426247597,
0.1914851218,
-0.0064731799,
0.2745350301,
0.4092618525,
-0.3335134089,
0.1433559358,
0.2189997286,
-0.1334193349,
0.1770870388,
0.003746249,
0.1082499549,
-1.0415636301,
-0.4662145078,
-0.8541688323,
0.505654335,
-0.0437746756,
-0.5298710465,
0.7227728963,
0.3055128157,
0.2979324162,
-0.3141740859,
0.7653492093,
-0.1088110358,
0.1439939439,
-0.6054350138,
0.6908570528,
-0.032827083,
-0.1150627434,
-0.8219357729,
-1.5156377554,
-0.0291744284,
0.7922535539,
-0.3236743808,
-0.3995667696,
1.1577986479,
0.7971035242,
0.1922120601,
0.203941673,
0.0376507714,
-0.2663095891,
-0.2517785132,
0.5917485356,
0.7812256813,
-0.8421329856,
0.3541427255,
0.2989015877,
-0.3742362559,
-0.147353515,
-1.0352715254,
-0.6750301719,
-0.5714222789,
-0.7180047631,
-0.1175174713,
0.2468655854,
0.5788380504,
0.0978720039,
-0.5570053458,
-0.5553478003,
0.2378285229,
0.1283380687,
-0.6562520862,
-0.2053494155,
0.4191704988,
0.1045652851,
-0.6213219166,
0.1814151406,
0.4252952337,
-0.0038801604,
-0.0379453562,
-0.1298118234,
-0.0902889892,
0.2424101084,
0.2178843468,
0.083292529,
-0.414342165,
-0.4548888803,
-0.3659670949,
0.033390943,
0.0605295859,
0.9213784337,
-0.3822285235,
0.6816607714,
0.6317447424,
0.7395381927,
0.4416880608,
0.084951207,
1.1743702888,
-0.4444066882,
0.0092954189,
-0.1081623137,
0.0538017377,
0.1699653417,
-0.5298791528,
0.4788201451,
0.1441979408,
-0.6582353711,
-0.9454038143,
0.1334013492,
-1.2512685061,
-0.3874890804,
0.9619069695,
-0.0870975405,
-0.46891132,
-0.2263155431,
-0.5000447631,
0.3197645545,
0.021884013,
0.4207838774,
1.1882703304,
-0.3721323311,
-0.327757448,
-0.5585862398,
0.1450756192,
0.1345945448,
-0.6698132157,
0.3107488155,
0.3924399614,
0.4419477284,
0.5379946232,
0.4625715017,
-0.0996009037,
0.2558854222,
0.1727644354,
0.0829999745,
0.4565766752,
0.0346083231,
-0.6205266118,
0.0603448823,
0.0079953494,
-0.1410790384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06303v1
|
MatNexus: A Comprehensive Text Mining and Analysis Suite for Materials Discover
| 2023-11-07T14:14:36 | 2023-11-07T14:14:36 |
Lei Zhang, Markus Stricker
|
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL, physics.chem-ph, H.4; H.5; I.5; I.7; J.2
|
MatNexus is a specialized software for the automated collection, processing,
and analysis of text from scientific articles. Through an integrated suite of
modules, the MatNexus facilitates the retrieval of scientific articles,
processes textual data for insights, generates vector representations suitable
for machine learning, and offers visualization capabilities for word
embeddings. With the vast volume of scientific publications, MatNexus stands
out as an end-to-end tool for researchers aiming to gain insights from
scientific literature in material science, making the exploration of materials,
such as the electrocatalyst examples we show here, efficient and insightful.
|
[
-0.2249591649,
-0.5209434032,
0.9072023034,
0.0712062046,
-0.1611991674,
0.3673381209,
0.0017890608,
0.020070171,
0.5047748685,
0.5513827801,
-0.55959934,
-0.8147728443,
-0.4815300405,
0.2941936553,
-0.4973142445,
0.7464770079,
-0.2407703102,
-0.0515416861,
-0.5247488022,
-0.2234829217,
-0.1220530942,
-0.180971384,
-0.7587370276,
-0.5411874056,
0.5199113488,
0.7473211288,
0.6414914131,
0.4860666096,
0.377961576,
0.3257658184,
-0.0302038323,
0.1497760564,
-0.2297462672,
0.1949160099,
-0.4640530348,
-0.9003319144,
-0.3943043649,
0.2157313228,
0.7385135293,
0.7472370863,
-0.2033506483,
0.3255096078,
-0.0209074654,
0.4404952824,
-0.3888105154,
-0.0621660426,
-0.4644823074,
0.4798713326,
-0.410071969,
-0.5727673173,
-0.4486502409,
-0.2847952843,
-0.1990046203,
-0.7607310414,
0.391040653,
0.2639622092,
0.767817378,
0.2080238611,
-0.4056681097,
-0.1192149818,
-0.4666253328,
1.0011292696,
-0.3720992208,
0.2653241754,
0.3119562864,
0.1995034963,
-0.2766773999,
-1.0937703848,
-0.5579965711,
0.1084769368,
-0.2371632308,
0.2373703271,
-0.0006004539,
-0.0275288001,
0.3043607473,
0.430760622,
-0.8186737895,
-0.0828553736,
-0.4071410298,
-0.0465652756,
0.6457402706,
0.3637533188,
0.7032191753,
-0.0425732732,
-0.3499370813,
-0.408708632,
-0.3361672163,
-0.1089652628,
0.4229103327,
-0.2637522221,
0.150675118,
0.8306896687,
0.1470689178,
0.2715678811,
-0.8356490731,
0.3284459114,
0.5044130683,
-0.2389166057,
-0.2083390802,
0.5044213533,
0.8965725303,
0.2872522175,
-0.2978829145,
-0.2013398856,
-0.322052598,
0.090754658,
0.2904801369,
-1.0706372261,
-0.3465629816,
0.5072318316,
-0.8717798591,
-0.5167993903,
0.3223795593,
-0.8875100017,
-0.5276373625,
-0.4803206027,
0.3133455515,
-0.0400991775,
-0.7075817585,
0.1983482093,
-0.9111762643,
-0.2830754519,
0.3680073917,
-0.466802001,
0.8967272639,
0.689224422,
1.1938738823,
-0.4502168894,
-0.1862386465,
-0.5571935773,
-0.2869702876,
-0.2563875616,
0.9112945199,
-0.8119689226,
-0.6684222817,
-0.5523651838,
0.4238356054,
-0.0939424932,
-0.6110969186,
0.9713874459,
-0.2411884665,
0.0094771059,
-0.1604431719,
-0.4317067862,
-0.510398984,
-0.030597575,
-0.7390210629,
1.3431353569,
0.1641906649,
-1.0010846853,
0.1110530496,
-0.7144144773,
-0.0898399726,
0.0915742442,
-0.0949663445,
-0.4976502061,
0.3800445795,
-0.252897352,
0.4980889857,
-0.4513709843,
-0.0296207629,
-0.2951303124,
-0.1222110167,
0.5230314732,
0.18522726,
0.4665352404,
0.5935096741,
-0.3333958983,
0.261331439,
-0.8951352239,
-0.1143305823,
0.2336112708,
0.1313243359,
-0.8237704039,
0.2944167852,
0.5142424107,
0.1991098225,
-0.2107544988,
-1.0331937075,
0.0092354584,
-0.0565193109,
0.6395380497,
0.5697104335,
-0.0571276397,
0.6025214791,
-0.2717187107,
0.6474652886,
-0.3692505062,
-0.2982453108,
-0.5477399826,
-0.44655931,
-0.5852559209,
0.0692646578,
0.4159375727,
0.6472074389,
-0.2570832968,
-0.0875607431,
-0.0484784432,
-0.6922059655,
-0.1292696595,
0.2159800529,
-0.226695329,
0.3086284697,
0.1375279278,
-0.1499683559,
-0.5484880805,
-0.8659819961,
-0.052208595,
0.3384932578,
0.1563881338,
0.4338802993,
0.6703759432,
-0.4586539865,
0.8469738364,
-0.8208275437,
0.010216943,
-0.020218458,
0.4691301882,
0.487700671,
0.4440843761,
0.2845304906,
-1.0886942148,
-0.5308657289,
0.5300815701,
-0.7526674867,
-0.2057993263,
-0.2643485665,
-0.2955166399,
-0.300018549,
1.1088422537,
-0.2806161344,
0.1788962483,
0.2399565876,
-0.5607987642,
0.4613392651,
-0.1551211476,
0.1725925505,
-1.186653614,
0.6697077751,
0.0079361368,
-0.4978145957,
-0.4888988733,
-0.2207617611,
0.0396852642,
-0.4867845178,
-0.2146142274,
0.5900478363,
-0.4267895818,
-0.0393062904,
-0.5242906213,
0.3150893152,
0.2184516191,
-0.0732801333,
0.1639337689,
0.8113029003,
0.1758239567,
-0.5832377672,
0.1439588815,
0.3542020619,
-0.1017318144,
0.4473363161,
-0.6408217549,
-0.1193868294,
-0.2208172232,
-0.105342336,
-0.7872204185,
0.1541933417,
-0.2050530314,
-0.4757200778,
0.3526632488,
0.2326789647,
-0.481295526,
-0.2754459679,
-0.4529491961,
0.146287173,
0.0206009112,
-0.3530965447,
0.8457878828,
0.4594902396,
-0.594430387,
-0.4305219948,
-0.3516762257,
0.3240006864,
-0.2453514189,
-0.6443006992,
0.6638643742,
-0.4790479839,
-0.5999222994,
0.288713038,
-0.3106139004,
-0.0765453056,
0.3833224475,
0.5943087339,
0.2145253122,
-0.0443798788,
0.2920893431,
0.1691518724,
-0.3601985574,
0.304441452,
-0.2169899344,
0.8296345472,
-0.0542920232,
0.3217671812,
-0.2632234395,
0.2976555228,
0.6852207184,
0.0496312864,
0.2364432067,
0.6046522856,
-0.4146378338,
-0.5947791934,
-0.2096407712,
-0.3469051123,
-0.4530502856,
0.1742565632,
-0.3107563853,
-0.2463653833,
0.4415385723,
-0.4295784533,
0.0200687665,
0.839918673,
0.0868275315,
-0.0903504565,
1.1018931866,
0.6826910377,
0.2402273864,
0.1396108121,
-0.4435415268,
-0.2213661671,
-0.8854954243,
-0.6512787342,
-0.9457989931,
-0.4629307985,
-0.2671512067,
-0.1622315496,
-0.0944165587,
-0.1082090959,
-0.0656983405,
0.4149992466,
-0.9214909077,
0.5304963589,
0.5312705636,
-0.0396524221,
0.3261255026,
0.185121879,
-0.3853543997,
-0.1363208592,
-0.546795547,
-0.6349425912,
1.1024718285,
0.1689332128,
0.8098029494,
-0.2832419276,
0.7612268329,
0.6061497927,
-0.0036062773,
-0.7387742996,
0.4794400632,
0.0966172218,
-0.5379055738,
0.1517327726,
-0.38446787,
-1.1241048574,
0.1220455691,
-0.4947774112,
-0.5589651465,
0.4856019616,
-0.6068975925,
-0.1962684691,
0.5805703998,
-0.5712906718,
0.920217216,
-0.2597470284,
-0.3315466344,
-0.5319929123,
-0.2391971201,
0.2140170932,
-0.2551914454,
0.4537764788,
-0.1200589612,
-0.3519655764,
1.0517499447,
-0.4139305353,
0.3363506496,
0.2592882812,
0.1902683824,
0.1535913497,
0.3730065227,
0.186604023,
0.3878010213,
-0.1337004006,
0.0446885824,
0.3362692595,
-0.3770838678,
-0.284466058,
0.9366406202,
-0.6417430043,
-0.1544723958,
-1.1071140766,
-0.3729903996,
0.4470885694,
0.3491385281,
0.1213644594,
0.2497255206,
-0.2423555553,
0.2118307948,
0.889623642,
-0.3528346419,
0.892221868,
0.329767853,
-0.3934322,
-0.6373988986,
1.2878314257,
-0.0664839074,
-0.2811740339,
0.4619331956,
0.1793034524,
-0.1397808194,
-0.6638317704,
-0.3158222437,
0.1312674135,
-0.5006394982,
-0.2035383135,
-1.0137691498,
-0.2730246484,
0.3439561725,
-0.3053854704,
-0.2566669285,
-0.7731667757,
-0.5786064863,
-0.2607365251,
0.2244481742,
0.8508218527,
-0.0382056683,
0.3788384795,
-0.9625998735,
0.3065933883,
0.0711547509,
0.4252804518,
-0.28252092,
0.2873421311,
-0.1331180632,
-0.3519796133,
-0.4076478481,
-0.8652741313,
0.527037859,
0.195192337,
0.7381725907,
0.4035459757,
-0.0704421625,
0.0128048528,
-0.3986430764,
0.6669873595,
0.3617610335,
-0.7874920368,
0.9622801542,
-0.210274905,
-0.1588316262,
0.4648765028,
0.551604569,
-0.5791995525,
0.2033421099,
-1.1786986589,
-0.9999794364,
0.8904225826,
0.6095147133,
-0.2519188225,
0.218058899,
0.3923889697,
0.3521925211,
0.1875451952,
-0.6820204258,
-0.4079043269,
-0.2030093819,
-0.3589183092,
-0.1734164804,
-0.1358129233,
-0.2278235257,
0.0620376319,
1.0365459919,
-0.0440950654,
0.0191069879,
0.4440531135,
-0.5163252354,
0.0787488446,
0.1389598846,
0.6321982741,
0.5696988702,
-0.4405720532,
0.4889337718,
0.2208821774,
-1.0284097195,
-0.0076082572,
0.3762200177,
-0.0994232073,
0.4469381869,
-0.1973377615,
0.558150053,
-0.1399344802,
-0.8412515521,
0.1534654498,
-0.4352607727,
-0.2897511721,
-0.432552278,
0.1626601219,
-0.1918134689,
0.2767730951,
0.5212987065,
0.4706180394,
0.598932147,
-0.4486166537,
0.4328767061,
0.3297608793,
-0.6937198639,
-0.3791973591,
0.8090826869,
0.0825636312,
-0.2991346717,
0.2394117266,
-0.090142116,
-0.5503700376,
0.8328244686,
0.4430261254,
0.7030580044,
-0.1721626371,
0.6819281578,
0.4736734033,
0.4061044157,
-0.1310618967,
0.3414413035,
-0.2888733447,
-0.3762226701,
-0.0881386101,
-0.8932422996,
-0.4855727553,
-0.0480721705,
-0.2404643148,
0.6688165069,
-0.417562604,
-0.1204003096,
0.3533400595,
0.277261883,
-0.1078880727,
0.1856820136,
0.1145176366,
0.9806230068,
-0.9114583135,
0.3688373566,
0.8027094603,
-0.4437436461,
-0.2276479155,
-0.8157836795,
0.1128421202,
-0.2511397004,
0.8219645619,
0.3356517255,
0.0160781331,
0.0969101861,
-0.454031527,
-0.7615154386,
1.2448806763,
0.1423390657,
-0.3276616335,
0.4490334094,
0.161126256,
-0.10457775,
-0.3001799583,
0.7285619378,
0.4536679685,
0.7146589756,
-0.2088245004,
-0.4266930223,
0.2683949471,
-0.962200582,
-0.4030356705,
0.5021469593,
-0.3738950491,
0.8022069931,
0.2626568973,
-0.2978168726,
-0.044982858,
0.3265424967,
-0.0533319414,
0.9043835402,
0.5071136355,
1.0453982353,
1.0161495209,
-0.3870587945,
0.9063231945,
-0.1242710724,
0.257103771,
0.6316180825,
-0.0486754104,
0.5432385206,
0.1670531482,
-0.0722270161,
0.9316818714,
0.8617298603,
-0.325337559,
0.0229177345,
0.0903391764,
-0.2561658025,
-0.3876948357,
-0.1315359473,
-0.3516851664,
-0.0082581863,
0.7394621968,
-0.4803472757,
-0.2520723343,
0.102844663,
0.3165844977,
0.2262645364,
-0.5399865508,
0.5941486359,
0.4020970762,
-0.3810068369,
0.1477297693,
0.1038627923,
0.432967335,
-0.6712913513,
-0.334007591,
0.1201899946,
0.3458932638,
-0.6574853659,
-0.9531462193,
0.3476732075,
-0.5670413971,
-0.3408926129,
-0.2389203161,
0.9644001722,
0.1839257628,
-0.6332594752,
0.2577630579,
0.1883856654,
0.0757717267,
-0.2527865767,
-0.5626057386,
-0.1760262698,
0.0088948105,
-0.0758197159,
0.0527933836,
0.123615928,
-0.0034747655,
0.5369096398,
1.1755799055,
-0.0150506692,
-0.1389880478,
-0.3358863592,
0.714602232,
-0.9655976892,
-0.3300504088,
-0.7217878699,
0.5437899828,
-0.8779040575,
-0.3438514173,
0.839808166,
1.2671803236,
0.2694961429,
0.1700147837,
0.8966364264,
0.1703352928,
0.3123134077,
-0.2978442907,
0.8515332341,
-0.7338920832,
0.1704519391,
-0.2404078841,
-1.2252012491,
-0.5246840715,
0.5166909099,
0.3355450034,
-0.5980731249,
1.320784688,
0.6359456182,
-0.4345085323,
0.5504770279,
-0.0627798513,
0.2302015126,
0.1764692217,
-0.3230346441,
0.6157396436,
-0.4029460549,
0.5687149763,
-0.1906325221,
-0.2269156277,
-0.0899781883,
-0.6631902456,
-0.8352611065,
-0.6149137616,
-0.3944182396,
-0.61940521,
-0.2853243053,
0.7610749006,
0.5956760049,
-0.7906520963,
-0.4685564637,
-0.6196929216,
0.3677096367,
0.0140864234,
-0.2426562011,
0.6641958952,
-0.7205975056,
-0.9351608753,
0.4788780808,
0.4058161378,
-0.1748828143,
0.0798916519,
-0.0058822697,
-0.2224515826,
0.2275924683,
0.5679006577,
0.3093476295,
0.2056325823,
0.5784543753,
0.3557617068,
0.1955799609,
0.1286311597,
0.9753034115,
-0.7943900228,
0.4784592986,
0.9474896193,
0.5070845485,
1.1847602129,
-0.5235613585,
0.5328439474,
-0.293540746,
0.0780358985,
0.3123824,
0.7296998501,
0.1529885679,
-0.2453108877,
0.8358663321,
0.4182054698,
-0.6974452138,
-1.0034651756,
-0.1273562312,
-1.477175355,
-0.7350575328,
1.2050420046,
0.3869144917,
-0.5516189933,
-0.1362293065,
-0.7880941033,
-0.0854832307,
-0.360494107,
0.2612366676,
0.4724045992,
0.2469529063,
-0.0464308783,
-1.1323999166,
0.2698870003,
0.3677667379,
-0.8215984702,
-0.3342988789,
-0.0044450373,
0.2985848188,
0.5361904502,
0.1034459323,
-0.1222411767,
0.198200047,
0.0186787397,
0.1624580026,
0.0410485268,
-0.1300928444,
-0.0297965333,
0.3178472221,
-0.1953985989,
0.2209971249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14693v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14693v1
|
Benefits and Harms of Large Language Models in Digital Mental Health
| 2023-11-07T14:11:10 | 2023-11-07T14:11:10 |
Munmun De Choudhury, Sachin R. Pendse, Neha Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC
|
The past decade has been transformative for mental health research and
practice. The ability to harness large repositories of data, whether from
electronic health records (EHR), mobile devices, or social media, has revealed
a potential for valuable insights into patient experiences, promising early,
proactive interventions, as well as personalized treatment plans. Recent
developments in generative artificial intelligence, particularly large language
models (LLMs), show promise in leading digital mental health to uncharted
territory. Patients are arriving at doctors' appointments with information
sourced from chatbots, state-of-the-art LLMs are being incorporated in medical
software and EHR systems, and chatbots from an ever-increasing number of
startups promise to serve as AI companions, friends, and partners. This article
presents contemporary perspectives on the opportunities and risks posed by LLMs
in the design, development, and implementation of digital mental health tools.
We adopt an ecological framework and draw on the affordances offered by LLMs to
discuss four application areas -- care-seeking behaviors from individuals in
need of care, community care provision, institutional and medical care
provision, and larger care ecologies at the societal level. We engage in a
thoughtful consideration of whether and how LLM-based technologies could or
should be employed for enhancing mental health. The benefits and harms our
article surfaces could serve to help shape future research, advocacy, and
regulatory efforts focused on creating more responsible, user-friendly,
equitable, and secure LLM-based tools for mental health treatment and
intervention.
|
[
-0.3242964447,
-0.8440993428,
1.1065360308,
-0.0648189932,
-0.027079735,
-0.0597947463,
-0.1499368101,
-0.8442599177,
0.1754092872,
0.497543484,
-0.7212184668,
-0.3339107633,
-0.784833312,
0.0415578261,
-0.5084047914,
0.8705362082,
0.0367523804,
0.1484557837,
-0.2971437871,
0.2573041916,
-0.4810388386,
-0.7982623577,
-0.8499915004,
-0.4073505998,
0.8267971873,
0.0216163192,
0.8917427063,
0.2762961984,
0.583656013,
0.3819455802,
-0.0740233734,
-0.129412055,
-0.5143731236,
0.0691230521,
0.0110565964,
-0.500131011,
-0.6322120428,
-0.1837073714,
0.3014065921,
0.6803632379,
-0.3894272745,
0.2327258289,
-0.215326488,
0.6048211455,
-0.3598725498,
0.1749520749,
-0.4368439317,
0.2085113078,
-0.3126022816,
-0.0503027588,
-0.1783559769,
-0.3112357557,
-0.183093816,
-0.6018787026,
-0.2150506824,
-0.1996439844,
0.6944642663,
0.5487467051,
-0.5064330101,
-0.343672812,
-1.1702467203,
0.6144974828,
-0.7193428278,
0.2548751533,
0.5693162084,
0.4340642989,
-0.5033271909,
-0.7602114081,
-0.5735360384,
0.2588323355,
0.0447059534,
0.0248054489,
-0.6587985158,
0.2738988101,
0.3644030392,
0.4755154848,
-0.1092466712,
0.4813837111,
-0.496610254,
0.0881927833,
0.9420236945,
0.6929542422,
0.7299432158,
0.0791288465,
0.2890564203,
0.1545960456,
-0.5771056414,
-0.070452407,
0.1644561589,
0.0539145097,
-0.2118033469,
0.8859251142,
0.2683165371,
0.4318699241,
-0.0222729966,
-0.3828921616,
-0.1111266389,
-0.0923382491,
-0.1552875787,
-0.0184990652,
0.7062720656,
0.4623242319,
0.289621979,
-0.0583278574,
-0.1562539339,
0.3058813214,
0.7073164582,
-0.6387959123,
-0.1277686059,
0.7065526843,
-0.4896850586,
0.1056151465,
-0.2110574841,
-0.6093981266,
-0.7335448265,
-0.5962989926,
0.1325136721,
-0.4403020442,
-0.3360891342,
0.3515583873,
0.0122549925,
0.0680660531,
0.4066475332,
-0.9370261431,
0.3725472689,
1.0309938192,
0.8489969373,
0.0837108716,
0.1575481147,
0.0689614862,
0.1125856638,
-0.3999647796,
0.4683636129,
-0.3618523479,
-0.6605502963,
0.1551695913,
-0.0498701334,
0.0643989146,
-0.5959562659,
0.2893542945,
-0.2018728256,
-0.0675311014,
-0.4158007801,
-0.3958773017,
0.0769190118,
0.028050961,
-0.6693799496,
0.3041328788,
0.1586371809,
-0.7770932317,
0.1258339435,
-0.8751821518,
-0.5467418432,
0.3329052627,
-0.0176840574,
-0.1452614069,
0.3642855287,
-0.0613035411,
0.5217178464,
-0.2151375115,
0.3779658377,
-0.7003402114,
-0.3166131377,
0.5134546757,
-0.4321550727,
0.9608678818,
0.2310417742,
-0.2075894624,
0.2009440213,
-0.3483151495,
-0.0686000735,
0.3060280979,
-0.2757249177,
-0.4093334079,
0.2583420277,
0.3257614374,
0.3300365508,
0.1359182447,
-0.4614927173,
-0.3047858775,
-0.3714123964,
0.8117380142,
0.7745141983,
0.0088755405,
0.0564880893,
-0.6523131132,
0.6155389547,
-0.1590049118,
0.4218543172,
-0.1171384975,
-0.4225122631,
-0.1012163311,
-0.9421262145,
-0.0517374054,
0.4208004177,
-0.4867455363,
0.6235678196,
-0.3193190992,
-0.5322540998,
-0.6859103441,
-0.0018267961,
-0.3266564906,
0.0245422348,
-0.0746541023,
0.0132366437,
-0.3540454209,
-0.7520462871,
-0.0751856267,
-0.0437871739,
-0.1687231064,
0.5121724606,
0.4045443833,
-0.8343702555,
0.8153262734,
-0.4587508142,
-0.315331012,
-0.230663538,
-0.333322525,
-0.0064369361,
0.0597072728,
0.2327968925,
-0.799266994,
-0.2260462791,
-0.0407654643,
-0.9833670855,
-0.0304131676,
-0.1229981482,
0.0899031833,
-0.147721231,
0.1659974009,
-1.0852384567,
0.0753499046,
0.6140437126,
-0.1025895178,
0.3910992742,
-0.2828801572,
-0.1478087753,
-1.1480505466,
0.1420241147,
0.140714258,
-0.1129635796,
-0.6664742231,
0.0589970909,
-0.4336378872,
-0.3186344206,
-0.2375268787,
0.5328022838,
-0.1213645265,
0.1392068863,
-0.2907418907,
0.0972526968,
-0.3077076972,
-0.2251639813,
-0.2901740968,
0.7459959984,
0.2722581923,
-0.3283878565,
0.3731885552,
0.1029171646,
-0.2201407999,
0.7814585567,
-0.6701942682,
0.112063989,
-0.2514574826,
0.5446466804,
-0.4404828548,
-0.3496462107,
0.1776352376,
-0.2432008982,
0.2059242427,
0.688747108,
-0.8466813564,
-0.646489799,
-0.1597186774,
0.3497919738,
0.3349556625,
-0.2542290986,
0.3024882674,
1.0179896355,
-0.6563127041,
0.0652105808,
-0.5327499509,
0.5049602389,
-0.5083692074,
-0.4811927974,
0.3027942181,
-0.0985597149,
-0.8644727468,
0.0276825707,
0.1251694411,
0.035162352,
0.5122892261,
0.6789031029,
0.3724118471,
0.0392850414,
0.3521597385,
0.0437773243,
-0.3226395547,
0.4498170316,
-0.3639802933,
0.5921413898,
-0.1817125827,
-0.4714616239,
-0.3823580742,
0.9521303773,
0.738306284,
-0.0838255882,
0.7272624373,
0.2828562558,
-0.8655605316,
0.1603130102,
-0.4174962044,
-0.1869700551,
-0.4511087239,
0.3814457953,
0.0526407026,
-1.0269960165,
0.2561691701,
-0.1330931038,
0.1345597655,
0.2854363918,
0.6467425823,
-0.4431843162,
1.1723041534,
0.7809311748,
-0.1060947031,
0.4450339973,
-0.0844505206,
0.6952875257,
-0.6784101725,
-0.2303677946,
-0.2614918351,
-0.1209809706,
-0.7269075513,
-0.1668063253,
0.5073367953,
-0.2531474829,
-0.6525638103,
-0.0912747309,
-0.3110724986,
-0.181442678,
0.2717212141,
0.3756789565,
0.4757251441,
-0.2068818659,
0.2141395956,
-0.5045006871,
-0.5122823119,
-0.7965490222,
0.9316535592,
0.6142895222,
0.906047225,
0.1193396896,
0.451754719,
0.4957081676,
0.3596789241,
-1.0055650473,
0.3292673826,
-0.1093296558,
-0.7357211709,
-0.2926272452,
-0.3044806719,
-1.0907120705,
-0.1098761559,
-0.2697041631,
-1.1022348404,
-0.0493667349,
-0.0127822282,
-0.4082672596,
0.4795906544,
-0.3587604463,
0.4522970915,
-0.7662343979,
-0.1361370385,
-0.5775099397,
-0.4714589417,
0.4726478159,
-0.6194350719,
0.4769726992,
-0.1048150361,
0.1341467947,
0.3364465833,
-0.2054610997,
0.8513899446,
0.25957793,
-0.3794746995,
-0.0147588337,
-0.2164604366,
0.1616563648,
-0.0973058864,
0.1437289566,
0.3960678875,
0.353566587,
-0.1703837663,
-0.321873039,
0.6776691079,
-0.9115149379,
-0.9953953028,
-0.3525530696,
-0.6719418168,
-0.2887119353,
0.3117299378,
0.0205249209,
0.0945129544,
-0.2262481749,
0.0071808193,
0.6728307605,
-0.7077206969,
0.1325361282,
0.2097393572,
-0.3813300133,
-0.3498251736,
0.7563771009,
0.1576185375,
0.20463036,
0.0875902921,
0.1797750741,
-0.2032003105,
-0.2596538067,
0.0909623802,
0.5383462906,
-0.5985956192,
0.0457572043,
-0.8131429553,
-0.4836584032,
-0.2391957045,
-0.3750812411,
-0.3278335929,
0.1468302011,
-0.4200272858,
-0.1735831946,
0.3611327112,
0.9318327904,
0.0240494553,
0.1425038874,
-0.762691915,
0.3596848547,
0.2036579996,
0.4144014716,
0.2758412659,
0.2287859321,
-0.1937665492,
0.2595334053,
-0.2267503142,
-0.7149091363,
0.3801853061,
-0.2304991782,
0.5423291326,
0.6263600588,
0.1337763965,
0.650404036,
-0.6497382522,
0.4912833869,
0.38588503,
-0.6216596365,
0.3921481073,
-0.6407022476,
0.2773633003,
0.3819341362,
0.5989058614,
-1.0204921961,
-0.2731987834,
-0.4795178473,
-0.9391903281,
0.3973125517,
-0.1578579992,
0.6238824725,
-0.0767977536,
0.2826776803,
0.0999659896,
0.3124066591,
-0.5580302477,
-0.1659705788,
0.0538767129,
-0.4295282662,
-0.1650827974,
-0.20353432,
-0.3805631399,
-0.1519494057,
0.417361021,
0.0253422223,
0.6576821208,
-0.0399808846,
0.3401112854,
-0.3137977123,
0.3627310991,
0.3264269233,
0.3745603263,
-0.0425675698,
0.1649599671,
-0.1182428747,
-0.3319526315,
0.2401985675,
0.1143093929,
-0.2229415029,
-0.26777789,
0.2046905309,
0.5619620085,
0.1349622756,
-0.9287829995,
0.173368752,
0.0550857894,
-0.0458623283,
-0.599219501,
-0.023722358,
0.5440393686,
0.5071085095,
-0.0552231967,
-0.3603318632,
0.0901190266,
-0.6716529727,
-0.1415444016,
0.7098482251,
-0.3739515543,
-0.3448737562,
0.6434280872,
-0.0220085923,
-0.8020327687,
0.6824462414,
0.3758055866,
-0.0867463425,
0.4110456109,
0.8120085597,
0.8028388619,
0.2173132002,
0.1478645653,
-0.1844739169,
0.213059172,
-0.0309848879,
-0.0028987727,
0.244716391,
-0.5996245146,
-0.0203581881,
-0.3603087366,
-0.4695302248,
0.4541820288,
-0.5181876421,
0.2091092318,
-0.5758954883,
-0.7685539126,
0.0270356014,
-0.0474745631,
-0.7098516822,
-0.0723543614,
0.5892114043,
0.6762238741,
-0.6969837546,
0.6097201705,
0.7815430164,
-0.1170649379,
-0.537451148,
0.2641682625,
0.5299933553,
-0.4262394905,
0.1358855367,
0.1553508639,
-0.1347223222,
-0.1022394225,
-0.3602907658,
-0.9112151265,
1.189904809,
0.5947706699,
-0.5619150996,
-0.2697613835,
0.2786819041,
0.8451129198,
-0.1877920181,
0.1121960506,
0.3712213039,
0.5718904734,
-0.1658272147,
-0.7469477654,
0.0758800581,
-0.3037682772,
0.3502628207,
0.1396467984,
-0.5290084481,
0.5419299006,
-0.3732727468,
-0.4875779748,
-0.0050564273,
0.1393770725,
0.2960114777,
0.1584106535,
0.1079722568,
0.3971900642,
0.9180591702,
0.1990833133,
1.3198500872,
-0.20023866,
0.1263915747,
0.748488605,
-0.5165787339,
0.8321484327,
0.3951478601,
-0.4721519053,
0.1575193405,
0.8259537816,
0.0287022274,
0.2804736197,
0.4600244164,
-0.5962455869,
-0.0307889301,
-0.4133077562,
-0.2389699072,
0.2319430262,
0.830910027,
-0.2294992954,
-0.079077892,
0.1380616277,
0.3910520673,
0.2037916183,
-0.1269438863,
0.7145370841,
0.7690228224,
-0.2297430634,
-0.0129299704,
0.1257043779,
0.5350885391,
-0.4769875109,
0.0516121797,
0.133276239,
0.2296455652,
-0.2030903697,
-0.5565049648,
0.6033539772,
0.0451098047,
-0.2006701678,
-0.3068484366,
0.8502517343,
0.0401961207,
-0.8167901635,
0.6541057825,
0.5960047245,
-0.0310715158,
-0.1508952826,
-0.5816563964,
-0.0701522455,
-0.5662426353,
0.0431722179,
0.6101635695,
0.376642257,
-0.1739466041,
0.9726805687,
0.667896688,
0.5363854766,
-0.3032907248,
-0.1902463436,
0.6608841419,
-0.787330687,
-0.1431354284,
-0.9384880662,
0.1887106299,
0.1613304317,
-0.1458245516,
0.4035989344,
0.1394175589,
0.5099041462,
0.1485132724,
0.9221545458,
0.003162456,
0.1477916986,
-0.1655484885,
1.0012236834,
-0.5725671649,
0.1646197289,
-0.1475557387,
-0.5499863029,
-0.4238128662,
0.3173660338,
-0.5525402427,
0.0189703759,
0.4241792262,
0.4916512966,
0.4117029011,
0.0183741432,
0.4131372273,
0.22725375,
0.5415909886,
0.5190529227,
0.9401233196,
0.1245398745,
-0.098228313,
-0.0794831067,
-0.0375378132,
-0.1375733465,
-0.5500169992,
-0.6894206405,
-0.4586341679,
-0.1099284589,
-0.0900434703,
0.0989163145,
1.1998859644,
0.3553139567,
-0.5230094194,
-0.1926751584,
0.148359403,
0.1472961307,
-0.1497693956,
-0.2361403406,
-0.0994649529,
0.0721611157,
-0.4401257634,
-0.0293261986,
0.6111071706,
0.0005422889,
-0.5186815262,
0.1245577633,
-0.0703080893,
0.0723422691,
0.8138585687,
0.2458443195,
-0.9096241593,
-0.1823366284,
0.0109945685,
-0.4599954784,
0.1121525466,
0.521481216,
-0.4349503815,
0.2085049003,
0.02233175,
0.8035460711,
0.1873422563,
-0.1552660018,
0.8658494949,
0.4033919275,
-0.3334132731,
0.3592244685,
0.4399968386,
0.4393463731,
-0.6513364911,
0.1978221536,
-0.0841840357,
-0.3622314334,
-0.6684453487,
0.1948764622,
-0.5877717137,
-0.3859448433,
1.0019735098,
-0.1017228141,
-0.0992682874,
-0.2274611741,
-0.2763515711,
0.1966447383,
-0.1448669285,
1.2141664028,
0.6380015612,
-0.1403729916,
-0.3409713209,
-1.0420844555,
0.1152532622,
-0.0304416083,
-1.1713782549,
0.0358673148,
0.5101439357,
0.1613694429,
-0.0864979476,
0.8218837976,
-0.4435283542,
-0.0508602299,
-0.0008756281,
0.1473661661,
0.1475453526,
-0.0369246006,
-0.5399737954,
-0.1770324558,
0.2517817318,
0.2775017321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03998v1
|
Exploring Jiu-Jitsu Argumentation for Writing Peer Review Rebuttals
| 2023-11-07T13:54:01 | 2023-11-07T13:54:01 |
Sukannya Purkayastha, Anne Lauscher, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In many domains of argumentation, people's arguments are driven by so-called
attitude roots, i.e., underlying beliefs and world views, and their
corresponding attitude themes. Given the strength of these latent drivers of
arguments, recent work in psychology suggests that instead of directly
countering surface-level reasoning (e.g., falsifying given premises), one
should follow an argumentation style inspired by the Jiu-Jitsu 'soft' combat
system (Hornsey and Fielding, 2017): first, identify an arguer's attitude roots
and themes, and then choose a prototypical rebuttal that is aligned with those
drivers instead of invalidating those. In this work, we are the first to
explore Jiu-Jitsu argumentation for peer review by proposing the novel task of
attitude and theme-guided rebuttal generation. To this end, we enrich an
existing dataset for discourse structure in peer reviews with attitude roots,
attitude themes, and canonical rebuttals. To facilitate this process, we recast
established annotation concepts from the domain of peer reviews (e.g., aspects
a review sentence is relating to) and train domain-specific models. We then
propose strong rebuttal generation strategies, which we benchmark on our novel
dataset for the task of end-to-end attitude and theme-guided rebuttal
generation and two subtasks.
|
[
-0.4451949,
-0.7452344298,
0.5730851889,
-0.0142163178,
-0.5346326828,
0.0684227049,
-0.0364043489,
0.0436143801,
0.6122094393,
0.1255373955,
-0.3666225672,
-0.392511785,
-0.5188385844,
0.1464626044,
0.0262999758,
1.6465038061,
-0.4855254591,
0.1192583367,
-0.3601360619,
-0.4193945527,
-0.6674330235,
-0.2671020627,
-0.4289698005,
-0.5684730411,
0.7528831959,
0.5496481061,
0.6577736139,
0.0361323804,
0.269579798,
0.1396912634,
-0.0412872806,
-0.2756894231,
-0.3039234579,
0.6386497021,
-0.3030026555,
-0.502664268,
-0.543797493,
0.0810217187,
0.6155329347,
0.5572195053,
-0.0791178718,
-0.0125233997,
-0.1221060455,
0.9148510098,
-0.6253458261,
-0.0238613877,
-0.5226691365,
0.3999277949,
-0.2634270787,
0.1390466988,
-0.1898141801,
-0.5719269514,
0.1588585675,
-0.6628953218,
0.2412178218,
-0.0546780005,
1.028244853,
0.0818835944,
-0.4228852987,
-0.1474691033,
-0.4134458899,
0.2648269236,
-0.4274524748,
0.0474467464,
0.1203163192,
0.2283521444,
-0.0244125016,
-0.3141556978,
-0.3479314446,
0.0320562422,
0.0265704412,
0.4360103309,
0.0067743543,
-0.0034547541,
0.1982614845,
0.3360700011,
-0.5871613622,
-0.2762184739,
-0.2508818209,
0.2293172032,
0.9100525975,
0.0566371083,
-0.3228111863,
-0.4263477027,
-0.2220979482,
-0.1731525213,
-0.7819526792,
0.3676940799,
0.4288330972,
-0.2198244333,
0.3418310583,
0.4984286427,
-0.4633051753,
0.2808849514,
0.4296819866,
-0.1662933528,
0.1137480289,
-0.2095814198,
0.1267895848,
0.1809379458,
0.8214398623,
0.6353268027,
0.4184257686,
-0.0194287859,
-0.2203329951,
-0.0155893611,
0.8066138625,
-0.7544890642,
-0.4159715474,
0.2741780579,
-0.7385472655,
-0.7444084287,
0.0101868408,
-0.7529229522,
-0.5164060593,
0.0393975377,
0.4066368341,
-0.1771206856,
-0.4748132825,
0.0216086265,
-0.170194611,
0.4412105083,
0.191223979,
-0.2798129618,
0.0861976147,
0.9256252646,
0.818805635,
-0.1399334222,
-0.0230990052,
-0.3505134284,
0.107158415,
-0.5032581687,
1.1292864084,
-0.9435442686,
-0.6776124239,
0.0350071564,
0.0275999345,
0.4207500517,
-0.1762377322,
0.899385035,
-0.2793995738,
0.2065068781,
-0.2997437119,
-0.5315743089,
-0.1298121065,
0.491735965,
-0.2107784152,
0.5670974851,
-0.2039093822,
-0.6600975394,
0.5381612778,
-0.6440069675,
-0.9348747134,
0.1061044782,
-0.3090445399,
-1.04340446,
0.6272690296,
0.318223834,
0.4182620347,
-0.400223285,
0.5419085026,
-0.3607715368,
-0.1008568332,
0.3090182841,
0.1188277304,
0.4364592731,
0.3274681866,
-0.3560160398,
0.1209526807,
-0.4605374932,
0.0276605524,
0.57468009,
0.0284821466,
-0.5801351666,
0.3179240525,
-0.5759595633,
-0.144875139,
-0.0912763402,
-0.8172600269,
0.2965066731,
-0.2027660608,
0.2958729267,
0.6809823513,
0.5135390759,
0.1104803681,
-0.3595339358,
0.7821241021,
0.05116193,
0.0648169667,
-0.3956034184,
-0.7441046834,
-0.4459182322,
0.5213416815,
0.3009981811,
0.0930282474,
-0.8631035089,
0.0665728822,
-0.3575028777,
-0.8909191489,
-0.4724323153,
-0.1477537453,
0.7336533666,
0.5229595304,
0.0227768514,
-0.784986794,
-0.3010291457,
-0.9081471562,
-0.7255555391,
-0.5119668245,
0.2418776155,
0.1603979915,
0.3707431555,
0.3565122485,
1.0095891953,
-0.8996539712,
-0.0522369035,
-0.0563663244,
0.4187369943,
-0.032818798,
0.5471367836,
0.2352306247,
-0.662997067,
-0.4208983779,
-0.347394526,
-0.9408317804,
-0.2845895886,
-0.3521830738,
-0.3104513586,
-0.237339437,
0.3770243526,
-0.2661349177,
0.3320411146,
-0.1010952666,
-0.2091797143,
0.6837159395,
0.3075208664,
0.1867870539,
-1.0124133825,
-0.0939598307,
0.5202346444,
-0.1178536564,
-0.4436810911,
0.3307504058,
-0.253258884,
-0.556737721,
-0.0788383633,
0.091961734,
-0.2661925554,
0.2033898234,
-0.4590567648,
0.0040011629,
0.4056090415,
0.4445330501,
0.5012091994,
0.3426125944,
0.4080744088,
-0.1648695618,
0.2179590166,
0.202072382,
-0.1778773963,
1.2998613119,
-1.1503543854,
0.3369169235,
-0.2505965531,
0.5695958138,
-1.161170125,
-0.0057389182,
0.3141099215,
-0.4778742492,
0.3599205613,
-0.7417016625,
-0.0303988084,
-0.2134842277,
-0.5058315396,
0.2105341554,
0.273332715,
-0.2367539406,
0.5245589018,
0.6732606292,
-0.4580777287,
-0.3836186826,
-0.2412120551,
0.3284444809,
-0.3392043114,
-0.4474006891,
0.3948087692,
0.0233957134,
-0.2594562769,
-0.2091651559,
-0.2008978128,
0.130733639,
0.1069271415,
0.5795814991,
-0.1071342006,
-0.2333720773,
0.0079563987,
0.403096199,
-0.2837346494,
0.6427102089,
-0.0320929289,
0.0229856912,
-0.3915443718,
-0.2617785335,
0.063487798,
0.7711637616,
0.2666576803,
-0.1805336624,
0.3014275134,
0.3083954453,
-0.1313395053,
0.1811603606,
-0.4172854125,
-0.1243802458,
-0.3922991157,
0.1429844946,
-0.5836254358,
-0.4269934297,
-0.0115074459,
-0.2710645497,
0.6010505557,
0.0957566872,
0.6296021342,
-0.2865062356,
0.7807784081,
-0.0146871917,
0.1834274083,
0.5118167996,
0.018431494,
0.334069401,
-0.8887957335,
-0.0665031075,
-0.4228319824,
-0.7244078517,
-0.2358508855,
-0.1954543293,
0.4995064735,
-0.1118361354,
-0.2792916596,
0.1676690578,
-0.6977775693,
0.5669345856,
0.1013939083,
0.0276797898,
0.1578425169,
0.1085270122,
-0.0569780879,
-0.4700071216,
-0.5495177507,
-0.6061860323,
1.2631933689,
0.6110110879,
0.8409197927,
0.0094867451,
0.9675649405,
0.1637804657,
0.8976242542,
-0.8260508776,
0.6628872752,
0.1285345405,
-0.6367822289,
0.2625508606,
-0.2292582542,
-0.8549816608,
0.4270120561,
-0.346233815,
-0.0243561268,
0.133962661,
-0.1115191728,
-0.1842802614,
0.2419204712,
-0.6040071249,
0.6838274598,
-0.1068505123,
-0.6175406575,
0.0177582521,
-0.7413935661,
0.5016639829,
0.1971744001,
-0.0336753614,
0.22198385,
0.1672190577,
1.1195505857,
-0.3061934114,
0.7360847592,
-0.573748529,
-0.3777504563,
0.5620196462,
0.3541280627,
0.2919434905,
0.4044820964,
0.1420907229,
0.0561756529,
-0.1712488383,
-0.0666827559,
-0.6002370715,
0.6217473149,
-0.7505754232,
-0.9791818857,
-0.4624437988,
-0.1136751771,
-0.2947761118,
-0.0140438145,
-0.0150984833,
0.2743300498,
-0.2713623643,
0.3534798026,
0.712659657,
0.1158646941,
-0.0401226319,
0.7253850102,
-0.1891676188,
-0.654710114,
1.021827817,
0.1007486433,
-0.083323814,
0.0406788811,
0.5235822797,
-0.0446073376,
-0.6441144347,
-0.5321384072,
0.0486353338,
-0.6344560385,
-0.3934407234,
-0.5361112356,
0.2199554443,
-0.2146208137,
-0.3478211164,
-0.5545098782,
-0.4735556245,
0.5113977194,
-0.02599122,
0.2179850787,
0.8772234321,
0.2414448708,
0.190966934,
-0.372961551,
0.2712620795,
0.2376252711,
0.383667022,
-0.0986000746,
-0.2774845362,
-0.0830594376,
-0.1427820325,
-0.8663605452,
-1.177456975,
-0.0544714369,
-0.0091416687,
0.2843650877,
0.3574901521,
0.1556770951,
0.6377726197,
-0.4988878071,
1.0490576029,
0.2252769917,
-0.7619487047,
1.0751749277,
-0.2193420678,
-0.0789146274,
0.6798094511,
0.566860199,
-0.431090951,
-0.3730025291,
-0.772939682,
-0.7617274523,
0.1976519376,
0.0452321917,
-0.0803557932,
-0.0270064194,
0.8833812475,
0.3092726767,
0.2884581983,
-0.9206840992,
-0.1404741406,
-0.687123239,
0.0640410781,
0.113551423,
-0.0065535549,
-0.4508568943,
-0.2008659095,
0.6705241203,
-0.4416231513,
0.1725587845,
0.3032804728,
-0.0060767881,
-0.4688093066,
0.3842053115,
0.3649825454,
0.2078214884,
-0.0094967308,
0.0500596017,
-0.0207653884,
-0.3918016255,
0.5412635803,
-0.2597636878,
-0.3642603159,
0.0847989023,
0.0296304282,
0.4405444264,
0.1580023021,
-0.1685492992,
0.522110343,
-0.2337746024,
-0.4404807091,
-0.190160349,
0.0105646858,
0.1680717915,
0.0199729316,
0.1335733831,
-0.1252490431,
-0.0622520074,
-0.4345217645,
0.0830921307,
0.5143099427,
-0.3589256704,
-0.3264688849,
0.5944061875,
0.5290387869,
-0.2699506581,
-0.0258164536,
-0.2920948863,
-0.6491805911,
0.2325890809,
0.3635689318,
1.0276093483,
0.1924975216,
0.2485355288,
0.4543807209,
0.1176089719,
0.3131696582,
0.1657243669,
-0.1990063787,
-0.4846008718,
-0.1848434806,
-0.3102335334,
-0.7366527319,
-0.1961475313,
-0.9124822021,
0.091413483,
-0.8861089945,
-0.2052605152,
-0.1191544011,
0.4032529891,
-0.0833830908,
0.1156630069,
0.2023150176,
0.5663585067,
-1.064432025,
0.5631835461,
1.2700970173,
-0.5391391516,
-0.2697109282,
0.4889188409,
-0.0135840382,
-0.4842690825,
0.5374071002,
-0.0385212712,
-0.3372684717,
-0.5302019715,
-0.7651820779,
-0.2847499549,
0.8424389362,
-0.0988422781,
-0.4670245647,
0.2817515731,
-0.401900351,
0.394017905,
-0.5824304819,
0.165314436,
0.2104991376,
0.3636476099,
-0.0777094662,
-0.2912431061,
0.2333534062,
-0.4681173563,
0.1129907295,
-0.0715664923,
-0.8919330835,
0.6299507618,
-0.1436024457,
0.0516615361,
-0.3440673053,
1.157541275,
0.5592921376,
0.3261241317,
0.661259234,
0.6194210052,
0.3337000012,
-0.1573241055,
1.0518932343,
-0.1277924627,
0.1116090864,
0.8853768706,
-0.6776247621,
0.761290133,
0.4374707639,
-0.1533784717,
1.008754015,
0.4677093327,
0.0553514548,
0.3403732181,
0.2959983349,
0.0825296715,
-0.3628010452,
-0.1274615377,
-0.5041943192,
0.3163507283,
0.3291070163,
0.0614611134,
-0.1414206922,
-0.1199576631,
0.4188212156,
0.334135741,
-0.2647996247,
0.9396612048,
0.0243508033,
-1.162525773,
0.5040616989,
0.2210412025,
0.6446796656,
-0.4833653867,
0.1354038119,
-0.25088799,
0.042140916,
-0.2046393007,
-1.4072793722,
0.378187567,
0.4375677705,
-0.1042192727,
-0.5112862587,
0.898769021,
-0.0648806989,
-0.2672099471,
-0.3491326272,
0.3440545201,
0.1873802692,
0.105153814,
-1.0075836182,
-0.0154532082,
-0.1118283942,
-0.5745110512,
0.4295081198,
0.4607993662,
-0.0253768396,
0.2890953422,
0.514257133,
-0.125432089,
-0.4291654825,
0.0549921691,
0.9621824026,
-0.6412440538,
-0.5311346054,
-0.5293483734,
0.2593944669,
-0.2118333131,
-0.639195621,
0.5552230477,
0.3642531633,
0.491171509,
0.1216151714,
0.720435977,
-0.1661443859,
0.3358435929,
-0.2998973727,
0.5745190978,
-0.5784611106,
-0.1691695303,
-0.6926426888,
-0.7279180288,
-0.1460802108,
1.1292955875,
-0.4504437149,
0.1808348745,
0.652146101,
0.4789347351,
0.2765124738,
0.4926735163,
-0.0768236443,
0.1423032731,
0.7949541807,
0.828245759,
0.7787421942,
-0.6008949876,
0.3892170489,
-0.2293227762,
-0.152784273,
-0.1418725848,
-1.1542111635,
-0.7935400605,
-0.4770964682,
-0.9795640111,
-0.8043767214,
0.0228339918,
0.7960341573,
0.4036384523,
-0.6418938637,
-0.1495317668,
0.0152234584,
0.3233486116,
-0.2086289674,
-0.2205231339,
-0.1088092253,
-0.3065361977,
-0.3268117905,
0.3441560268,
0.1191594526,
-0.3965664506,
-0.5527607203,
-0.1269097328,
-0.156123817,
-0.0552985035,
0.3598258197,
0.3886955976,
-0.4583801627,
-0.3915863633,
-0.3114854991,
0.1822519004,
0.3516100943,
1.3288388252,
-0.9074934721,
0.4817169905,
0.370031625,
0.5044132471,
0.2301163077,
0.0620424487,
0.7662242055,
-0.9325793386,
-0.3080393672,
0.2052266449,
0.5407829285,
0.3514361084,
0.0041737268,
0.567705512,
0.5300632715,
-0.4911403954,
-0.9113380313,
0.2999923825,
-0.8603741527,
-0.3225120306,
1.0407749414,
-0.4059753418,
-0.3537622392,
-0.1628220975,
-0.4290706217,
-0.0574239641,
-0.4050814211,
0.7295301557,
0.9055613875,
0.0029663173,
-0.0859077126,
-0.097906895,
0.23765935,
0.8746207952,
-0.5927957892,
0.3648305237,
0.199219957,
0.4231908321,
0.3443532288,
0.3762974739,
-0.2257107347,
0.4384006262,
0.1250537783,
-0.0994646549,
-0.1851404607,
-0.347683996,
-0.4199413955,
0.5402604938,
0.1082415879,
0.1020329595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03969v1
|
Factoring Hate Speech: A New Annotation Framework to Study Hate Speech in Social Media
| 2023-11-07T13:08:55 | 2023-11-07T13:08:55 |
Gal Ron, Effi Levi, Odelia Oshri, Shaul R. Shenhav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work we propose a novel annotation scheme which factors hate speech
into five separate discursive categories. To evaluate our scheme, we construct
a corpus of over 2.9M Twitter posts containing hateful expressions directed at
Jews, and annotate a sample dataset of 1,050 tweets. We present a statistical
analysis of the annotated dataset as well as discuss annotation examples, and
conclude by discussing promising directions for future work.
|
[
-0.7214866281,
-1.0627968311,
0.0773499608,
0.3410035372,
-0.4201276004,
0.3846191466,
-0.0640827417,
-0.6663250923,
0.6414280534,
0.5480366945,
-0.6202267408,
-0.563964963,
-0.9077228904,
0.1233838499,
-0.7606412768,
1.1193560362,
0.4341011345,
0.3187550306,
0.3599052727,
-0.4037157893,
-0.0618939139,
-0.5597920418,
-0.767926991,
-0.1139266491,
0.9751921296,
0.2576858401,
0.7320107818,
0.3258843124,
0.6254110932,
0.2250124812,
0.0431391336,
-0.117180191,
-0.5658923388,
0.3006911874,
-0.2120723873,
-0.1017790139,
-0.0710383132,
0.0921027213,
0.4258576035,
0.4668821692,
0.254255563,
0.4855936766,
-0.3544920087,
0.2819532156,
-0.4997306764,
-0.0567767955,
-0.7698130608,
-0.0778222606,
-0.4376785159,
-0.261010915,
-0.1811992377,
-0.6927173734,
0.0676043108,
-0.4471485913,
0.4397578537,
0.1680563539,
0.3690985441,
0.1691134423,
-0.3859055042,
-0.4079675376,
-0.7155097723,
0.6151635647,
-0.4555329084,
0.1095812172,
0.6398903131,
0.2291948348,
0.2791458368,
-0.2509162724,
-0.7488268018,
0.0555262305,
-0.1660868227,
-0.2528062463,
-0.4234027267,
-0.1531312019,
0.4645877779,
0.278218925,
-0.3510351479,
0.0709310919,
-0.535433948,
-0.215249002,
1.1026054621,
-0.0685964674,
0.4172158837,
-0.3144329786,
-0.1747080535,
0.1364077628,
-0.3968912065,
-0.4662241042,
0.5827622414,
0.5898103118,
0.0310964063,
0.7445701361,
-0.1626334637,
0.3295555711,
0.1515451968,
-0.0428789891,
0.4512965679,
0.0511789694,
-0.2311875969,
0.3242222369,
0.7853896022,
0.8381751776,
0.655775249,
-0.2242000252,
-0.0517750606,
0.6116126776,
0.4833929241,
-0.9224067926,
-0.1506928056,
0.0898473039,
-0.3646087945,
-0.7548535466,
-0.1996234357,
-1.144759059,
-1.1797456741,
0.0799868405,
0.0931455418,
-0.5792668462,
-0.4326769114,
-0.39801085,
-0.5150054693,
0.0052599311,
0.3100852966,
-0.7086482644,
0.328736335,
0.5533745885,
0.6029802561,
-0.0450268611,
0.0705828667,
-0.572358191,
0.0041583735,
-0.4120619595,
0.9000249505,
-0.8351314068,
-0.250069648,
0.5803143978,
-0.2054744214,
0.4358959198,
-0.4437538683,
0.8101331592,
-0.6293805838,
-0.1826052219,
-0.2796770334,
-0.6701460481,
-0.5956318974,
-0.0778922886,
-0.7373357415,
0.9434518218,
0.2690088451,
-0.8682550788,
0.6834486723,
-0.697060287,
-0.6456620693,
0.5086771846,
-0.2327834219,
-0.3834873736,
0.2249031067,
-0.0504726544,
0.4737405479,
-0.1796773374,
0.2215378881,
-0.7150117159,
0.023010375,
0.311942488,
0.1036399826,
1.0775612593,
0.2977520525,
-0.779951036,
0.4288974106,
-0.9320701957,
-0.4999007583,
0.2778547406,
0.2045905739,
-0.5522500873,
0.2415982932,
0.4283492565,
0.346137464,
-0.4208708107,
-1.0603431463,
-0.1632063985,
-0.1808104515,
0.432423681,
0.7551426291,
0.3038753569,
0.1134038642,
-0.4494431913,
0.4113072455,
0.0320605822,
0.057680022,
0.4996373951,
-0.3862225413,
-0.741371274,
0.0612377189,
-0.2664466202,
0.3763392568,
-0.74944067,
0.0775101632,
0.0912398845,
-0.6146170497,
-0.5616793036,
0.0549376346,
0.2505981922,
0.1225468665,
0.4728026688,
-0.0435971171,
-1.1654318571,
-1.1488413811,
-0.0788136199,
-0.4431423247,
0.3321998119,
-0.106923908,
0.6501543522,
0.0586860068,
0.7191192508,
-0.1191828027,
-0.288282454,
-0.1454189569,
0.6275292635,
-0.7087746859,
0.2514388561,
0.969730258,
-1.0937312841,
-0.5238582492,
-0.4603611529,
-0.2813615799,
-0.3989381194,
0.1271130443,
-0.2329965681,
0.1729041785,
0.551502049,
0.103281185,
0.6391969323,
0.4532564878,
-0.5479375124,
0.2708919048,
1.0440993309,
0.3286518455,
-0.8688384295,
-0.4412208498,
0.409422487,
-0.1748991311,
-0.6722524762,
-0.0909470841,
-0.3880856037,
0.1973603964,
-0.7473983765,
0.1814006567,
0.2062395513,
0.4349072576,
-0.2257984728,
0.1936374158,
-0.5927107334,
0.3112637103,
-0.0682492852,
0.3465459645,
0.2856509686,
-0.2162254751,
0.5412439108,
0.3605145216,
-0.2647026181,
0.7318361402,
-0.2648300827,
-0.0010985732,
-0.3337428272,
0.2632068694,
-1.2416555882,
-0.2337948084,
0.5463277698,
-0.6101337075,
-0.3085253239,
-0.2117220759,
-0.700802505,
-0.3269799948,
-0.6268743277,
0.4056296945,
0.1802752912,
-0.1865087003,
0.5482439995,
0.8954278827,
-0.0013724165,
-0.2214491665,
-0.6130630374,
0.1061986536,
-0.6641814113,
-0.3695464432,
0.4847297668,
-0.2316502482,
-0.7670427561,
0.0166661218,
0.3361598849,
-0.1312199086,
0.0596009791,
0.6309559941,
0.0039814371,
0.0779907405,
0.0786730796,
-0.1837096065,
0.2587245107,
0.2248161882,
0.1578161269,
0.724344492,
0.1814537644,
0.2002331913,
-0.2054811716,
0.6825485229,
0.2676828206,
0.0181241445,
0.6319566965,
1.1771410704,
-0.6171905994,
-0.3179470003,
-0.9500858784,
0.0052562193,
-0.3643945456,
0.2264278084,
0.0349778235,
-1.3443089724,
0.6130014658,
0.4857737124,
0.2519999146,
0.8330959678,
0.7998105884,
0.0863428414,
0.9871749878,
0.5176255107,
-0.1179852784,
0.6385433674,
0.1546973139,
0.3138197958,
-0.2669473886,
-0.0460264571,
-0.7047073841,
-0.1117002293,
-0.8969485164,
-0.3623944223,
-0.2315365076,
-0.0394906476,
-0.3595197499,
0.3007536232,
-0.4949657917,
0.1426015049,
0.4446787238,
-0.2145664245,
-0.0736734867,
0.2551478446,
0.1705186814,
-0.0249919761,
-0.2242984474,
-0.3992641568,
0.8076653481,
0.3701550961,
0.1667576432,
0.447170049,
0.5467720032,
0.6788184047,
0.8909023404,
-0.731934309,
0.7307304144,
-0.2647083104,
-1.2111500502,
-0.3402297199,
-0.2328464091,
-0.3788181245,
-0.0115203336,
-0.3791891038,
-1.0287060738,
0.0054918672,
-0.0542626269,
-0.406654954,
0.5165657997,
-0.3821896315,
0.3666872382,
0.1408472359,
-0.2383469641,
-0.3328897655,
-0.2972137928,
0.3673296869,
-0.1798540056,
0.4496847689,
-0.5300301909,
0.0870047435,
1.4581477642,
-0.2369071543,
1.2215825319,
-0.287537396,
-0.0335988663,
0.5163186789,
0.1763887703,
-0.0576252602,
-0.2926290333,
-0.2714373469,
0.2335014343,
-0.1252791286,
-0.25266096,
-0.2127452046,
0.3963909745,
-0.4361766875,
-0.2352131456,
-0.2302582413,
-0.4047210515,
-0.232604757,
0.0811988637,
-0.0071325507,
0.3615223169,
-0.3108219802,
0.265714556,
0.1868282259,
-0.1068532914,
0.5309660435,
0.4258320928,
-0.5157099962,
-0.7037715316,
1.0094879866,
0.3492076397,
-0.0730808824,
0.2041487545,
0.1417684555,
-0.1410871148,
-0.8282776475,
-0.3050246835,
0.1076516435,
-0.5884858966,
-0.2164404243,
-0.5345644951,
-0.0503740832,
-0.8015340567,
-0.2466497123,
-0.0419342928,
-0.5272690654,
0.1926911771,
-0.4458861947,
0.5501339436,
1.1173824072,
-0.2237311453,
0.7010503411,
-0.1684741825,
0.2207746506,
-0.0031857027,
0.4454466701,
-0.0864766687,
-0.4382432103,
-0.1833165735,
-0.2082869411,
-0.323443979,
-1.1929001808,
0.2502083182,
-0.2652508318,
0.2917282283,
0.3358072042,
0.4083087146,
0.673640132,
-0.4424310327,
0.9845366478,
0.3548313081,
-0.6973254085,
0.6743751764,
-0.4307423234,
-0.4606418908,
0.5729147196,
0.7893630862,
-0.5639616847,
-0.806588769,
-0.9688544273,
-0.7515995502,
0.5443958044,
0.2444699705,
0.0408171974,
-0.6130031943,
0.1226648763,
0.0821366608,
0.2006826997,
-0.7530058026,
-0.8104578257,
-0.1845224053,
-0.0528903306,
-0.2811870873,
-0.8423727155,
-0.4841588438,
-0.4745872021,
0.801263392,
0.2117345482,
0.249520734,
-0.1458307803,
-0.2196145505,
-0.423394531,
-0.1008616164,
0.6448341608,
0.8405852914,
-0.4053920805,
0.2117950469,
-0.0492243357,
-0.3796691895,
0.0001542463,
0.22429052,
-0.3126961291,
0.315343678,
0.4780639112,
0.7247732878,
-0.0707226247,
-0.249730736,
0.3454431295,
0.1413045824,
-0.6455243826,
-0.7577939034,
-0.0915202647,
0.0116295712,
0.3126523197,
0.5012212396,
-0.297224015,
0.1245090365,
-0.3632831573,
0.504388988,
0.1246676669,
-0.5264598131,
-0.3842678666,
0.5473905206,
0.2614905238,
-0.5051128864,
0.0253524967,
-0.3381156921,
-0.8279417753,
0.1411941797,
0.3181346357,
1.0365905762,
-0.453142345,
0.7657535076,
0.6257649064,
0.2436153442,
0.5497699976,
0.0709119812,
0.0098457271,
-0.9087205529,
-0.297410965,
-0.9146267176,
-0.1924526542,
0.3356851935,
-0.5331821442,
0.0953596085,
-0.7565538883,
-0.2099195719,
0.9488736987,
0.244287461,
-0.639477253,
0.3429295123,
0.6980273128,
0.6048674583,
-1.0885976553,
0.5816123486,
0.5730525255,
-0.8809095025,
-0.589486599,
-0.0985194072,
0.4375658929,
-0.9557534456,
0.8297886848,
-0.0119185774,
-0.1186773703,
-0.196343556,
-0.8052107692,
-0.5087903738,
0.4179403186,
-0.1734022945,
-0.2570835948,
0.2953260243,
0.4705896378,
0.5505657792,
-0.7030591369,
0.1434062719,
0.6630176902,
0.3729689419,
0.1402995437,
-0.5419625044,
0.3694746196,
-0.396184653,
-0.1044553593,
0.2025060356,
-0.6011757851,
0.5559545159,
0.2750566602,
-0.3115731478,
-0.429671973,
0.4879022837,
-0.3709837198,
0.3123293817,
0.8933033347,
0.3812206388,
0.476187408,
0.0767498016,
0.7931081653,
-0.0366900526,
0.2913400531,
1.1694409847,
-0.0175508745,
0.7684767246,
0.3827444315,
-0.1604131609,
0.3794772625,
0.5503253937,
-0.144195348,
0.2559854686,
0.6506733298,
-0.555955708,
-0.163617298,
-0.7317310572,
0.0318625495,
0.3118579686,
0.6072148085,
-0.5007916689,
-0.4107220471,
0.1946884692,
0.3446362913,
0.1559052765,
-0.3565165997,
0.8250578642,
-0.1929630786,
-0.3268901706,
0.1341784894,
0.2234105021,
0.7289298773,
-0.2362727225,
-0.0226040464,
0.1562574059,
-0.219405815,
-0.4821635187,
-0.7476442456,
0.7703334093,
0.2371570617,
-0.1001234576,
-0.0531552508,
0.6443750858,
-0.300214082,
-0.5135584474,
0.5806316733,
0.2142286301,
0.1302651316,
-0.2029649168,
-0.7764701843,
0.5619543791,
0.3565229475,
-0.2452031821,
0.2792949677,
0.3906781673,
-0.1516368091,
0.4245106876,
0.5584940314,
0.0515556894,
0.2226152718,
0.5667790174,
0.7460223436,
-0.731744349,
-0.047626216,
-1.0773915052,
0.3752309978,
-0.3737547994,
-0.5137297511,
0.8485404253,
0.5244002938,
1.1903282404,
0.492610842,
1.0025577545,
-0.506785512,
1.15713346,
0.1562406868,
0.3526381552,
-0.323672533,
-0.2461235076,
-0.7498883009,
-0.5859478116,
-0.7177763581,
0.88826859,
-0.7536394,
-0.1628243029,
0.6685255766,
0.961789012,
0.4246460497,
0.5622913837,
0.4638950229,
0.5074733496,
0.6057563424,
-0.1088451818,
0.6827380657,
-0.2922513187,
0.3987434506,
-0.9323742986,
0.0070520709,
-0.4051338732,
-0.6413717866,
-1.0713657141,
-0.9531606436,
-0.665286839,
-0.8433253765,
0.0385463275,
1.0637830496,
0.5729007125,
-0.9671013355,
-0.1107284948,
0.1780229062,
0.025458727,
0.0134564862,
-0.3081925213,
0.2407332957,
-0.1842067987,
-0.6403098702,
-0.1317777485,
0.0324056223,
-0.2994223535,
-0.2548213303,
0.2384341806,
-0.6130895019,
0.1244812012,
1.0723614693,
-0.1297859848,
-0.7434478998,
-0.8236803412,
-0.6461328864,
0.0926070735,
-0.1717552692,
0.8939524889,
-0.2368435711,
0.0645283535,
0.102710478,
0.541195333,
0.390539825,
0.1027483046,
0.0978129655,
-0.5172006488,
0.0347047336,
0.4350870252,
0.2055064291,
0.3287633061,
-0.0462927036,
0.5972018242,
0.5209105015,
-0.3072965443,
-0.7578119636,
0.1850698441,
-1.2366622686,
-0.1362119615,
1.3159179688,
0.1998608559,
-0.1868713945,
-0.3219513595,
-0.1700616777,
0.3384973705,
-0.886395514,
0.6914955378,
0.9953042269,
-0.1801943779,
-0.1525099128,
-0.7624409199,
0.6927621961,
0.2025112957,
-0.3911857009,
0.2210267037,
0.8722129464,
0.2396726012,
0.4266941547,
0.8461734056,
0.0166303795,
-0.00953402,
0.3077594638,
0.1639283895,
0.0763093084,
-0.0554474741,
-0.0848058164,
0.6053016782,
-0.2480049133,
-0.1218005568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03963v1
|
An Expectation-Realization Model for Metaphor Detection
| 2023-11-07T13:03:54 | 2023-11-07T13:03:54 |
Oseremen O. Uduehi, Razvan C. Bunescu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose a metaphor detection architecture that is structured around two
main modules: an expectation component that estimates representations of
literal word expectations given a context, and a realization component that
computes representations of actual word meanings in context. The overall
architecture is trained to learn expectation-realization (ER) patterns that
characterize metaphorical uses of words. When evaluated on three metaphor
datasets for within distribution, out of distribution, and novel metaphor
generalization, the proposed method is shown to obtain results that are
competitive or better than state-of-the art. Further increases in metaphor
detection accuracy are obtained through ensembling of ER models.
|
[
-0.2924591899,
-0.5986593366,
0.7235228419,
0.2118066996,
-0.6749411821,
-0.5840535164,
0.1803738326,
-0.7098923326,
0.5815346837,
0.2742660046,
-0.3094179332,
-0.3427167833,
-0.6057516336,
0.1366872191,
-0.6030999422,
0.4328645766,
-0.1444343626,
-0.0414013304,
0.0994441062,
-0.002604652,
-0.8130083084,
-0.2551552355,
-0.7737820745,
-0.4671842754,
0.3012174666,
-0.1414614767,
0.2725125551,
0.9259045124,
0.1637960374,
0.2876814008,
0.3724717498,
0.131577462,
0.0104638599,
0.2127377838,
0.1072438061,
-0.6110586524,
-0.3845904171,
0.2371409088,
0.7439849377,
0.3365269601,
-0.52525419,
0.2096740007,
-0.1270227432,
0.1867984384,
-0.846819818,
0.3287673295,
-0.9624580145,
0.4725140929,
0.0398227833,
-0.6402116418,
-0.6426448226,
0.2798905075,
0.0504220873,
-0.6273348927,
-0.1001020074,
0.8111563325,
0.9427925348,
-0.110441722,
-0.1662611812,
-0.3394321501,
-0.4237141907,
0.9014614224,
-0.0737024844,
0.6799272895,
0.2063946128,
0.704353869,
-0.2139578164,
-0.8544206023,
-0.5054315925,
0.0416599214,
-0.0908717513,
0.320266664,
-0.5168065429,
0.0743863881,
0.0387995914,
0.1027095094,
-0.3853048086,
-0.0254159719,
0.0237436369,
0.0016755216,
0.0278451331,
0.2958785295,
0.3984677494,
-0.1244601533,
-0.6086785793,
-0.0340232849,
-0.546499908,
-0.5104191899,
0.3231599331,
0.1405575275,
-0.1477430016,
0.1818780601,
0.1882657111,
0.7294441462,
-0.4223216176,
0.2556216419,
0.4879007936,
0.2202007324,
-0.7196925879,
0.2232754529,
0.1320422888,
0.2307376117,
0.272929579,
-0.2291340828,
-0.7161704898,
0.6055009365,
0.5524716377,
-0.3650192618,
-0.0075534917,
-0.0271469224,
-0.7077888846,
-0.3388503492,
0.3227908313,
-0.3979658484,
-0.1922638863,
-0.4274376631,
0.8101764917,
-0.5807603598,
-0.340180546,
0.6711426973,
-0.8286165595,
0.361925751,
0.355913043,
-0.5490061641,
0.4907667637,
0.8400604129,
0.8103703856,
0.2956150472,
-0.3315999508,
-0.4465328157,
0.5062039495,
-0.4691725671,
1.1006848812,
-0.5893974304,
0.1065016463,
0.1532410532,
-0.319627434,
-0.149298504,
-0.4913910627,
0.6498686671,
-0.5621323586,
0.1747131646,
0.0747198686,
-0.9644259214,
-0.4122557938,
0.6809535027,
-0.5873795748,
0.7250732183,
0.0653899461,
-0.9532198906,
0.4647132754,
-0.5965476036,
0.0018150762,
0.2090753913,
-0.5548610687,
-0.151023671,
0.5343582034,
0.0628715008,
0.4250399768,
-0.3104431033,
-0.1112969294,
0.0724491775,
-0.6834096909,
0.1714408249,
-0.3144246936,
0.5207291245,
0.4384202659,
-0.0913699269,
-0.2361632288,
-0.4601546824,
0.0891468823,
0.3933574259,
-0.0552997738,
-0.9448895454,
0.28006652,
0.3738567829,
0.001228116,
-0.0638147518,
-0.5546876192,
-0.1907554865,
-0.4232715368,
0.197709024,
0.8280043006,
-0.1548819244,
0.1023062095,
-0.5282768607,
0.511566937,
0.47385934,
-0.0348405987,
-0.5539374352,
-0.4307187498,
-0.8037887812,
-0.6277154088,
0.0414017662,
0.3028372526,
-0.5188135505,
0.7864230871,
-0.3952610493,
-0.0671708435,
-0.3781481981,
-0.5285685062,
0.4088358283,
0.4875993133,
0.3806568682,
-0.4404212832,
-0.9720845222,
-1.1620447636,
-0.6328164339,
-0.3449368775,
-0.3831615448,
0.1057567298,
0.7753002048,
0.0225854032,
0.8632367253,
-0.5158289671,
-0.4976659119,
-0.2626998425,
0.4283406138,
0.1668558419,
0.2692901492,
0.8404433131,
-0.9829357266,
-0.110499464,
-0.2776676416,
-0.8066231012,
0.1106119975,
-0.0140177608,
-0.1403109133,
-0.2367084175,
0.3713573515,
-0.2886061668,
0.4736100435,
0.1967692077,
-0.452458173,
0.5124632716,
-0.0639693066,
0.0983549803,
-1.3317801952,
-0.402564019,
0.1473525614,
-0.0786851719,
-0.8148912191,
0.42076689,
0.0609793365,
0.4384714663,
-0.4292225242,
0.511290729,
-0.6068613529,
-0.2508335412,
-0.1900134683,
0.0497183017,
0.1252872497,
-0.0240157787,
0.4690010548,
0.3763743639,
0.6888446212,
-0.5130793452,
0.1890202016,
-0.0717999414,
-0.7841798067,
0.5786529183,
-0.5513603091,
0.0852148607,
-0.6037299037,
0.2208826542,
-0.9377904534,
-0.2578544915,
0.4749186039,
-0.3132085502,
0.0135749346,
-0.0176338553,
-0.7996900082,
-0.2627911866,
-0.2748982906,
0.5404483676,
0.8296076059,
-0.6360991001,
0.8344509006,
0.370269388,
0.7372967005,
-0.5105117559,
-0.9604116082,
-0.0114576807,
-0.5021662116,
-0.3130562305,
0.3639221191,
0.4900653064,
-0.2381707579,
0.0060816458,
0.1202590615,
-0.2222923785,
0.0276944712,
0.0367307551,
0.1843861639,
-0.108493939,
0.3937060535,
-0.1942174584,
0.1967166662,
0.2485276908,
-0.527965188,
0.6667330265,
-0.0944092199,
-0.5211780667,
-0.1764780432,
0.3732492924,
0.3479194939,
0.029379271,
0.6510221958,
0.5574810505,
-1.130749464,
-0.4464679658,
-0.5782362819,
-0.0942876339,
-0.4638499618,
0.4403173327,
-0.6121957302,
-0.2727932632,
0.4704352617,
0.0432285853,
-0.016494032,
-0.0122734327,
0.2241176367,
-0.1575485617,
0.8895969391,
0.5595704317,
0.0474928096,
0.5633301735,
-0.1413751841,
0.2047497481,
-0.9644266963,
-0.1617655158,
-0.4992720187,
-0.4636093676,
-0.1997392923,
-0.5191736221,
0.4098181427,
-0.2256958187,
-0.3459711671,
0.4122158587,
-0.5104355812,
0.3784413338,
0.3685346842,
0.2108195126,
0.1649817675,
0.3935959339,
-0.2779165208,
0.0205039494,
-0.5630931258,
-0.6784489751,
0.7003246546,
0.499688983,
0.4689975679,
-0.0479327478,
0.8885864019,
0.2427215576,
0.4995149076,
-0.8876382709,
0.5186738968,
0.1978796124,
-0.4875312746,
0.1066887155,
-0.2148620784,
-0.9187133908,
0.485589534,
-0.0694009438,
-0.9816387296,
-0.0179870408,
0.2882446349,
0.1753761321,
0.4752454758,
-0.5813561678,
0.5369000435,
0.1079452634,
0.4134088457,
-0.4968003631,
-0.3361584246,
0.3909728825,
0.1835440397,
0.3085352778,
-0.0136938486,
-0.2501850724,
0.6102900505,
0.1385394335,
0.525962472,
-0.1904745251,
0.2613734901,
0.4627554715,
0.1697518975,
0.4676001072,
-0.4514692426,
-0.037337061,
0.1248908713,
-0.2233777791,
-0.2297469079,
-0.5888003707,
-0.0617357269,
-0.3554644287,
-0.3991793692,
-0.5977839231,
-0.5438171625,
0.071264118,
-0.1091729105,
0.5138801336,
0.1934960932,
-0.512159884,
-0.2942603827,
0.5345535278,
-0.2864878178,
0.0724516585,
0.2546407282,
-0.2447566688,
-0.0908827633,
0.473531723,
0.009477553,
-0.123065725,
0.6147559285,
0.1162625849,
-0.317725122,
-0.3120965362,
-0.0693437383,
0.0343988836,
-0.7760673165,
-0.2040020227,
-0.523616612,
-0.3233808875,
-0.1117271557,
-0.1237337589,
-0.059716139,
0.0118524646,
-0.0058090352,
-0.2186747789,
0.1338211298,
0.5276246071,
0.2197671086,
0.3568679988,
-0.6333662271,
0.1951010376,
0.1632487476,
0.2204430699,
0.2368757874,
-0.7100247145,
-0.1239840016,
-0.0489204377,
-0.1844094545,
-0.9743921757,
0.5198526382,
0.2095966935,
0.4378966093,
0.7962505221,
-0.3306776583,
0.6122156978,
-0.9524852633,
0.4799836576,
0.5863900185,
-0.8422560692,
0.5809937119,
-0.2680304945,
-0.1736464351,
-0.0794091672,
0.1036633402,
-0.7842472196,
-0.2082566619,
-0.6325240135,
-0.4683154821,
0.442940712,
0.3726288676,
0.509183526,
-0.6035847664,
0.2918915749,
-0.0597995743,
0.4194946587,
-0.4435070157,
-0.2258719951,
-0.0506143644,
-0.2631987333,
0.2231632918,
-0.226964131,
-0.1353788972,
-0.1955298483,
0.308329016,
0.1646577418,
1.0049308538,
-0.1351826638,
-0.008825372,
-0.0301303938,
0.383412689,
0.1632698625,
0.3656313419,
-0.0751239955,
0.4091089666,
-0.0438571833,
-0.3719041348,
0.1166016087,
-0.2217013538,
-0.1527523398,
0.4081602693,
0.3222876191,
0.7654747963,
0.2644408047,
-0.5902498364,
0.3918434978,
0.0864551961,
-0.0335226133,
-0.7778691053,
0.0178485867,
0.0620853901,
0.1396673322,
0.3927020431,
-0.104877308,
0.6229849458,
-0.7392426729,
0.2548084855,
0.4783618152,
-0.0972034931,
-0.4855237901,
0.6407507658,
-0.25418365,
-0.3062859774,
0.810904026,
-0.2745251358,
-0.6484439373,
0.965683639,
1.0247449875,
1.1711438894,
-0.2127969712,
0.099963285,
0.2346428484,
0.3185346127,
-0.3121539056,
0.6369937062,
0.1317649037,
-1.5203409195,
0.2044387758,
-0.8956995606,
-0.0090478323,
0.1952971667,
-0.8566179276,
0.5912874937,
-0.0743325651,
-0.1674133539,
0.1072636545,
-0.7424314022,
-1.0083117485,
0.2707288861,
0.3240172863,
1.2835197449,
-1.2368574142,
0.7252728343,
1.2953839302,
-0.2399687767,
-0.9457084537,
-0.0479769781,
-0.0864761472,
-0.9328246117,
0.8213056922,
0.6450989246,
-0.2700586915,
-0.0356568955,
-0.3089909852,
-0.3727285564,
1.2280578613,
0.5962158442,
-0.3145565391,
-0.1659842879,
-0.165557608,
0.512978971,
-0.8912437558,
0.2774904072,
0.6084324121,
0.5110422373,
-0.2624185681,
-0.5578677058,
-0.1402374655,
-0.1317123026,
0.2571431696,
0.2841425538,
-0.2770846188,
0.8104031086,
0.3091805279,
-0.4681163728,
0.1704173982,
0.6638532281,
0.5630665421,
0.4510201514,
0.950851202,
0.996796906,
0.3367805779,
-0.1805888116,
0.8935621977,
-0.0920527577,
0.1854694933,
1.0683054924,
-0.0880313963,
0.8006045222,
0.7436403632,
-0.0910729319,
0.5047022104,
0.6951560974,
0.0877510682,
0.6149725914,
0.2921142876,
-0.5132658482,
-0.5247121453,
-0.4021683037,
-0.3414049447,
0.6026076674,
0.7833629251,
-0.9894068241,
-0.3728504181,
-0.1850887239,
-0.4319536686,
0.0274507385,
-0.4336612225,
0.2834933698,
0.3580511808,
-0.324799031,
0.1580097526,
0.3046700358,
0.4456772208,
-0.4927316606,
-0.5550935268,
0.3990714252,
0.0828690305,
0.0958476663,
-0.3625992537,
0.1985705942,
-0.2456358224,
0.0919713974,
-0.1152034551,
0.7461913228,
-0.2429533899,
-0.2998491824,
0.4763810635,
0.6610648036,
0.5780534148,
0.1027678698,
-0.521381259,
0.0021708047,
-0.6437071562,
-0.2970281243,
0.2447631508,
0.518171072,
-0.0302622747,
0.4693499207,
-0.0390945598,
0.1415770501,
0.1480368376,
0.2029088736,
0.5716044307,
-0.1927176863,
-0.9205480218,
-0.7117682099,
0.2452500314,
-0.0791627243,
-0.1046234071,
0.3080490828,
0.364603579,
1.0333292484,
-0.4004576504,
0.7522053719,
-0.2239754796,
0.0404648297,
-0.5464984775,
0.328758657,
-0.6382765174,
0.2232991159,
-0.380035162,
-0.9617401361,
-0.396300137,
1.1776635647,
-0.1389186829,
0.1014334559,
0.7433183789,
0.4784498811,
-0.5458744168,
0.3384768069,
0.6152777076,
0.0301461145,
-0.1143089086,
0.4918056428,
0.9158682227,
-0.6788848042,
-0.1275738925,
0.0630354881,
-0.1569307297,
-0.0095734783,
-0.9722044468,
-0.5938663483,
-0.668749094,
-0.0628013536,
-0.0532227196,
0.2993047535,
1.265432477,
0.6360983253,
-0.6483025551,
-0.2902233303,
-0.5270776153,
-0.1535721421,
-0.6526837945,
-0.254249543,
0.3069016039,
-0.4090037644,
-0.8184078336,
0.1662138551,
0.398992449,
0.0604827963,
-0.0596071966,
-0.0322946794,
-0.0804387182,
0.474585712,
0.5808612704,
-0.1760560125,
-0.7979409099,
-1.000618577,
-0.2356140465,
0.1020726338,
0.0509023704,
0.7353255153,
-0.7215602398,
0.5486912727,
0.3608247936,
0.5463910103,
-0.0532523692,
-0.1136080027,
0.6437544823,
-1.0465695858,
0.4332973957,
0.2035755813,
0.9689656496,
-0.0388086326,
-0.2767643631,
0.6061545014,
0.2817630768,
0.0192699004,
-1.0160421133,
0.8229981661,
-0.4724595249,
-0.14131549,
0.7708852291,
-0.4998516738,
-0.2197675407,
-0.1120358333,
0.3122680187,
0.4728317261,
-0.1726030111,
0.9834250212,
0.7887738347,
-0.2275438607,
0.0164579526,
-0.5409798026,
-0.0068287565,
0.2278645784,
-0.5412392616,
-0.2222644091,
0.5547364354,
0.3494227231,
0.1795974821,
0.5866166353,
-0.1499793679,
0.4477401674,
0.2176047713,
0.1506940126,
-0.0701566711,
-0.5470604897,
-0.2957527041,
0.1664979905,
-0.0921368524,
-0.6279740334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03952v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03952v2
|
An Analysis of Dialogue Repair in Voice Assistants
| 2023-11-07T12:50:11 | 2024-02-07T22:10:35 |
Matthew Galbraith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.RO
|
Spoken dialogue systems have transformed human-machine interaction by
providing real-time responses to queries. However, misunderstandings between
the user and system persist. This study explores the significance of
interactional language in dialogue repair between virtual assistants and users
by analyzing interactions with Google Assistant and Siri, focusing on their
utilization and response to the other-initiated repair strategy "huh?"
prevalent in human-human interaction. Findings reveal several
assistant-generated strategies but an inability to replicate human-like repair
strategies such as "huh?". English and Spanish user acceptability surveys show
differences in users' repair strategy preferences and assistant usage, with
both similarities and disparities among the two surveyed languages. These
results shed light on inequalities between interactional language in
human-human interaction and human-machine interaction, underscoring the need
for further research on the impact of interactional language in human-machine
interaction in English and beyond.
|
[
-0.3694426715,
-0.8397818804,
0.6479575634,
0.0633717477,
0.29351753,
0.4880062044,
0.2824907303,
-0.8199145198,
0.7523027062,
0.4124237001,
-0.720156312,
0.5596928596,
-0.163014248,
0.1188876852,
0.0178631973,
0.6282739043,
0.2295313478,
0.2923417985,
-0.3195133805,
-0.1968713701,
-0.7159493566,
-0.8804857135,
-0.9804338813,
-0.076416716,
0.3775463104,
0.4172800183,
0.955593884,
0.1714870781,
0.336432606,
0.5146234035,
0.0641930252,
0.202757746,
-0.2709485888,
0.4234528542,
0.2929955125,
-0.4840133488,
-0.4479919672,
-0.2900280356,
0.349543035,
0.7697533369,
-0.3201218843,
-0.5711869597,
0.1924406737,
0.5887696147,
-0.3810879886,
-0.0856014192,
-0.5852198601,
-0.1063135043,
0.1037532613,
-0.2520315349,
-0.0364599004,
-0.4453486204,
0.2210418433,
-0.646502018,
0.1416985244,
0.1765799373,
0.6522915959,
0.3751069009,
-0.0404260978,
-0.3839827776,
-0.9333568811,
0.6451041698,
-0.7579749227,
0.264667958,
0.4554941058,
0.3200962842,
-0.5370693803,
-0.3055520952,
-0.9841536283,
-0.3311246037,
-0.2301843166,
0.1042933911,
-0.3375259638,
0.1423693746,
0.2960404456,
0.0936083496,
-0.3023569584,
0.0491032712,
-0.3723947704,
-0.2403701544,
0.4629969001,
0.2404096425,
1.0386720896,
-0.0703044608,
0.0284074917,
-0.0532867312,
-0.6095449328,
0.189063102,
0.4485258162,
0.1308837682,
0.0125901988,
0.3267242908,
-0.0217121001,
0.7482325435,
-0.0910871699,
-0.347821027,
0.1148927361,
-0.4013231993,
-0.4411813915,
0.2319729477,
0.5895929337,
0.500862658,
0.1782699823,
-0.3889333904,
0.2877543867,
-0.1682208329,
0.4634496868,
0.0662112534,
-0.1166586727,
0.0385214202,
0.0237093922,
-0.1060912237,
0.2418039441,
-0.201267451,
-0.4869734943,
-0.2659935355,
0.3999063075,
0.1128428727,
-0.509860456,
0.1546195596,
-0.1924311519,
0.1402232498,
0.3951953053,
-0.7369206548,
0.258292973,
0.5595157146,
0.4622610509,
0.2537558377,
-0.4285380542,
-0.6323788166,
0.0478752367,
-0.2218716592,
0.7493280172,
-0.3595873713,
-1.0324859619,
0.0653603375,
0.2593928277,
-0.5534234047,
-0.91886127,
0.4892349243,
-0.3056291044,
0.599388957,
-0.655856967,
0.1084659621,
0.0053168056,
0.1355105788,
-0.5930212736,
0.7393182516,
0.1061207727,
-0.565608561,
0.0297961831,
-0.661005795,
-0.5849559903,
-0.1278210431,
0.0419870093,
-0.4064490199,
-0.1268148571,
0.0172083005,
0.222505793,
-0.1387339234,
-0.0028200119,
-0.2567671835,
-0.3348550498,
0.5450031161,
-0.2537782788,
0.709112227,
-0.1396239996,
-0.4235443175,
0.1784043908,
-0.8068313003,
0.0733388886,
-0.0139293578,
-0.1995694637,
-0.3460962176,
0.0988009572,
-0.1178927422,
0.4542217851,
0.2213598192,
-0.6509032249,
0.243951574,
-0.7653796077,
0.7249080539,
0.5116072297,
0.0809528902,
0.3645071685,
-0.3112975359,
0.6542232633,
-0.1958875507,
0.0548417158,
-0.1998280436,
-0.546004653,
-1.0618416071,
-0.0096935136,
-0.2978209555,
0.6666691899,
-0.8965935707,
-0.1442589909,
-0.0293722712,
-0.132916525,
-0.8762333989,
-0.000016128,
0.8846393824,
0.7481658459,
0.2235605717,
-0.125416398,
-0.8089213967,
-1.0947333574,
-0.0887271315,
-0.7368657589,
-0.3804535866,
0.6826012135,
-0.2996866405,
-0.3974038064,
0.8557200432,
-0.2220591456,
-0.1364694834,
-0.1833545417,
0.111992307,
-0.3443462551,
0.2009751797,
0.5286687016,
-0.6963660717,
-0.4969549179,
0.1236402839,
-0.5704845786,
-0.2748072743,
-0.0878222883,
0.1386556327,
0.5112986565,
0.6985812783,
-0.3168066144,
0.4085121453,
0.3939683139,
-0.2544542849,
0.3096583784,
-0.3285364211,
0.7496989965,
-1.0746142864,
-0.2472400367,
-0.1550948769,
-0.1857895106,
-0.9145826697,
-0.2911858857,
-0.5701032281,
-0.1656819433,
-0.5510482192,
0.4355442524,
-0.4155322313,
-0.2723945081,
-0.3946988285,
0.1102566868,
-0.1525704414,
0.3375017643,
-0.0366146266,
1.2535732985,
0.2116223425,
-0.5858399868,
0.0852299631,
0.3859484494,
0.2788495719,
0.8017369509,
-1.2117298841,
0.4621362686,
0.1917966306,
-0.1217865348,
-1.3301268816,
-0.4433240891,
0.4955140054,
-0.5307335854,
-0.108599253,
0.0910251662,
-0.3227515519,
-0.1020451859,
-0.1904454529,
0.3004389703,
0.1909654289,
-0.5414125323,
0.6218378544,
0.6669915915,
-0.5594828129,
-0.1291787177,
-0.3491055369,
0.3518862724,
-0.1701673716,
-1.0419023037,
-0.040426977,
-0.3937733769,
-0.6270320415,
-0.394315064,
0.112270765,
-0.2088619024,
0.3741095364,
0.5807699561,
0.3502929211,
-0.0200544633,
-0.1939848065,
-0.1177600697,
-0.0538362227,
0.0743106008,
0.4830985367,
0.5238411427,
-0.1240362301,
-0.6204785109,
-0.5134897232,
0.4641656578,
0.7662291527,
0.1318210214,
0.5504512787,
0.1929942816,
-0.0136120832,
0.8279923797,
-0.7448983192,
-0.1711334735,
-0.4729882181,
0.0943020657,
-0.4529790878,
-0.8821721077,
0.4987874031,
0.2646841407,
-0.003557553,
0.3339913189,
0.3462136388,
-0.6383810043,
1.5036385059,
0.5571208,
-0.4177097678,
0.1755635589,
0.2656713426,
0.5738233328,
-0.917855382,
-0.4431034625,
-1.0379756689,
-0.100812234,
-0.3283641338,
0.138051033,
0.5639434457,
0.0053085578,
-0.0178604443,
0.5695284009,
-0.231775105,
-0.0270099938,
0.7900524735,
-0.1132591739,
0.2598671019,
-0.3327798545,
0.4242062569,
-0.1994501054,
-0.6283418536,
-0.4697675705,
0.2466733903,
0.3411949575,
0.5596166253,
0.5356991887,
0.6558542252,
0.2467015237,
-0.252640903,
-0.662671268,
0.5310361981,
0.4756138325,
0.1421693563,
-0.545161128,
-0.0837646723,
-1.4457411766,
0.100153625,
-0.2176725119,
-0.9448324442,
0.0003959055,
0.4877174199,
-0.3236793578,
0.0050623519,
-1.2155276537,
0.5165598392,
-0.0348279402,
0.0396927632,
-0.1869358867,
-0.6477838755,
-0.0119806696,
0.423268348,
0.3078203797,
0.448882699,
0.3667017817,
0.4934153259,
-0.701063931,
0.8590499163,
-0.1318755001,
-0.2562853694,
-0.022202244,
0.1071264371,
0.4374379516,
-0.0127735911,
0.283259362,
-0.0427876338,
0.045813024,
-0.3556287885,
-0.7206356525,
0.7118757963,
-0.6179889441,
-0.9443690777,
-0.5279523134,
-0.3606597483,
-0.6003124714,
-0.1526624262,
-0.0796078742,
0.2704155743,
-0.3658640981,
-0.2100116313,
0.6724299788,
-0.1698506027,
0.6095318198,
0.8209433556,
0.1080128029,
-0.0094054677,
0.9157502651,
-0.2379426956,
0.402089864,
0.1719840914,
-0.1252941489,
0.0722583607,
0.0658257008,
-0.6689971089,
0.2387803793,
-0.0627706274,
0.185553208,
-0.7566062808,
-0.3088867664,
-0.3417140841,
-0.4406054616,
0.0636221692,
-0.4455821514,
-0.3647011817,
0.1124803573,
-0.0973383486,
0.6176199317,
0.185195908,
0.3429622352,
-0.920733273,
0.4485409856,
0.841036737,
0.0157828797,
0.2142798901,
-0.1742675751,
-0.0939272568,
0.3433068097,
-0.1814666539,
-0.8571054935,
0.1383854449,
0.1303392649,
0.6140765548,
0.1611173749,
-0.3741886914,
0.650731504,
-0.6459977031,
1.1076110601,
0.4536154568,
-0.6649948955,
0.5513584018,
-0.217649743,
0.4426706433,
0.2993738353,
-0.0682412088,
-0.9815770388,
-0.5121559501,
-0.790160656,
-0.7148541212,
0.6823818684,
0.1114236489,
0.2136760205,
-0.0613462776,
-0.1007397249,
-0.257483542,
0.1647953987,
-0.1832759529,
-0.2030593902,
-0.0827471241,
0.1207135767,
0.2653864622,
-0.453897208,
-0.1822731048,
0.0821216926,
0.7840791345,
-0.0352304652,
0.4198323488,
0.1500158608,
-0.1846910268,
-0.2440193444,
0.5760221481,
0.833042264,
0.5113297105,
-0.0417587012,
-0.4402650893,
-0.0312538743,
-0.3273624182,
-0.0162398145,
-0.0031878585,
0.0457209386,
-0.210136652,
0.239429757,
0.7375090122,
0.474121213,
-1.004368782,
0.1749025881,
-0.3939289451,
0.0905535966,
-0.3076432347,
0.3322891891,
0.0602443703,
0.1435628831,
0.2184519321,
0.2585350573,
0.5649520755,
-1.1400066614,
-0.1671497077,
0.7816901207,
-0.6213943362,
-0.5229712129,
0.5576897264,
0.5025445819,
-0.9302999973,
0.2650150657,
0.0157662593,
-0.6776943803,
0.4109497964,
0.2934529185,
0.9913342595,
-0.4282764494,
0.50621593,
0.1809100658,
-0.069190979,
0.2058811039,
0.4100081623,
-0.042515371,
-0.6875495911,
-0.0044024349,
-0.0562500842,
-0.6008853316,
0.1271082759,
-0.5374366045,
-0.2122095525,
-0.3535636365,
-0.0414353386,
0.3458772004,
-0.4620897174,
-0.5268552899,
0.1282475144,
-0.3285402358,
0.0818815455,
-0.6539481878,
0.3406104445,
0.7513042092,
-0.6212038994,
-0.7574740052,
0.1771699935,
0.1770436019,
-0.8809897304,
0.5479251742,
-0.3448041379,
-0.5293715,
-0.4765670598,
-0.3258611858,
-0.506695509,
0.5780518651,
0.1768793613,
-0.5093001723,
-0.0419153012,
0.3360632956,
0.904186666,
0.0358769856,
0.4269695878,
0.7118809223,
0.3698347509,
-0.3019318879,
-1.709839344,
-0.2267942131,
-0.4278437495,
0.0678608567,
0.4384974837,
-0.7602704763,
0.1678521633,
-0.1282639503,
-0.1478196084,
0.5344535708,
0.2573254108,
-0.0449158028,
0.4789839089,
0.6165009141,
0.5086971521,
0.5101093054,
-0.1989405304,
1.0388870239,
0.0485338718,
-0.320348084,
1.0103970766,
-0.1613580137,
0.7282810807,
0.6152717471,
-0.4274027944,
0.4289566576,
0.1103494391,
0.5424980521,
0.1875513941,
-0.0647222847,
-0.3372085989,
0.0235626791,
-0.2897111475,
-0.3555335701,
0.3861698508,
0.0130293602,
0.0215909854,
0.1589991152,
0.4526218772,
0.2599138021,
0.2760769129,
-0.0635782555,
1.5415416956,
-0.3318913579,
-0.7596499324,
0.6214131117,
-0.213647306,
0.3739590645,
-0.2903298438,
-0.2301681787,
-0.1127441153,
-0.3246260881,
-0.349958539,
-0.6027746201,
0.3462666571,
-0.1727903783,
-0.5486408472,
0.117782712,
0.6954632401,
-0.4295840561,
-0.0947445333,
0.0782891512,
0.4694979787,
0.0852149725,
-0.0230533853,
-0.6057627797,
0.1058350652,
0.3029592037,
0.2765045166,
0.4563962817,
-0.1056369543,
-0.1264568865,
0.7157926559,
0.6054933667,
0.020158859,
0.1231967509,
0.4980946779,
0.7512863874,
-0.309550494,
-0.2557660937,
-0.349910289,
0.7181099057,
-0.2761367857,
-0.1142253205,
0.7804626822,
0.3837392628,
0.6869863868,
-0.1368385702,
1.0098462105,
0.0160572678,
1.0904836655,
-0.4933082759,
0.3510408998,
-0.5477331877,
0.4382275343,
-0.5308494568,
-0.7991636395,
0.2514600158,
0.3594416976,
-0.1241933927,
-0.0421002731,
0.2970114946,
0.8554393053,
-0.0723812357,
0.0983213261,
0.3802178204,
0.2503787577,
0.4219912589,
0.0622604452,
0.8388878107,
-0.3063455224,
0.43186903,
0.175224036,
-0.2445143163,
-0.2057827413,
-0.2680015862,
-0.5100541711,
-0.939150095,
-0.2191323638,
-0.3440370858,
0.3265853822,
0.6064257026,
0.4405613542,
-0.6493110061,
-0.1064536944,
0.054976806,
0.0358285606,
-0.1517913193,
-0.3187100291,
0.0108571025,
-0.3750789165,
-1.0337637663,
0.8268657327,
0.4370889366,
0.0971922055,
-0.4627038836,
-0.3197986484,
0.1250339597,
0.2446657717,
0.5571309924,
1.2113777399,
-1.0087622404,
-0.4450194538,
0.3060379326,
0.0092155226,
0.2151008248,
0.9934260845,
-0.6998428106,
0.8361467123,
0.3365658224,
0.7555345893,
0.0183415022,
0.0034126944,
0.9212898016,
-0.7098379135,
0.1109403446,
0.0742359087,
0.3301553428,
0.7077540755,
-0.5674026608,
0.2344900668,
0.0007406086,
-0.6722601056,
-0.7954775691,
0.3636096716,
-0.8835315108,
-0.0271417648,
0.9295336604,
-0.0093161976,
0.2076949328,
-0.4619452655,
-1.092066884,
-0.02665939,
-0.3791673481,
1.113589406,
0.6956034899,
-0.3287231028,
-0.2406180501,
-0.2487372011,
0.6921798587,
0.5215035081,
-0.9036739469,
-0.5051963329,
0.604563117,
-0.0558294021,
0.4750663936,
0.9751946926,
0.2569859028,
0.5379197001,
-0.4783955812,
-0.2702349424,
0.0861077681,
-0.1890065521,
-0.0890169889,
-0.1450939178,
0.2881750762,
-0.1875834614
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.