id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08590v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08590v3
|
PEMA: An Offsite-Tunable Plug-in External Memory Adaptation for Language Models
| 2023-11-14T23:20:51 | 2024-03-29T11:24:46 |
HyunJin Kim, Young Jin Kim, JinYeong Bak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) show impressive performance in various
downstream NLP tasks. However, pre-training large language models demands
substantial memory and training compute. Furthermore, due to the substantial
resources required, many PLM weights are confidential. Consequently, users are
compelled to share their data with model owners for fine-tuning specific tasks.
To overcome the limitations, we introduce Plug-in External Memory Adaptation
(PEMA), a Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) method, enabling PLM
fine-tuning without requiring access to all the weights. PEMA integrates with
context representations from test data during inference to perform downstream
tasks. It uses external memory to store PLM-generated context representations
mapped with target tokens. Our method utilizes weight matrices of LoRA-like
bottlenecked adapter in the PLM's final layer to enhance efficiency. Our
approach also includes Gradual Unrolling, a novel interpolation strategy to
improve generation quality. We validate PEMA's effectiveness through
experiments on syntactic and real datasets for machine translation and style
transfer. Our findings show that PEMA outperforms other PEFT approaches in
memory and latency efficiency for training, and also excels in maintaining
sentence meaning and generating appropriate language and styles.
|
[
-0.5456143618,
-0.5745863914,
0.5735061765,
0.300960511,
-0.3912318051,
-0.0966763198,
-0.7654619217,
0.1184073612,
-0.1550773382,
0.4967004061,
-0.2132383287,
-0.1250557005,
-0.4442300797,
-0.0690986812,
-0.0485727899,
0.9402184486,
-0.2551887035,
-0.1777301878,
-0.2809932232,
-0.2902002037,
-0.5190941095,
-0.5259549618,
-0.6459386349,
-0.0970288143,
0.3011445105,
0.3983369768,
0.4227111936,
0.3489999473,
0.3435666859,
0.3058903813,
0.2076403201,
0.7241288424,
-0.458240509,
-0.1502261162,
-0.5530803204,
-0.5555654168,
-0.5797424316,
-0.1401283443,
0.7571564913,
0.5137434006,
-0.210122928,
0.2154125869,
0.0530157723,
0.7835309505,
-0.6573818922,
0.182139799,
-1.1233435869,
-0.205099836,
-0.2302988917,
-0.5270159841,
-0.6326287985,
-0.3334024847,
0.0121862488,
-0.523922205,
-0.114816092,
0.1615799963,
0.7653391361,
0.2786254585,
-0.1558253169,
-0.090930976,
-0.748816371,
0.6852890849,
-0.8296178579,
0.1547602862,
0.5702623725,
0.1803514808,
-0.3030925691,
-0.5993407369,
-0.5248758197,
0.0170136765,
0.0529746227,
-0.0552918948,
0.0226184428,
-0.0079534305,
0.045455493,
0.4072552919,
-0.1841411293,
-0.0768065453,
-0.2226459533,
0.2488505989,
0.5466948748,
-0.1174790412,
0.2876269221,
0.572358489,
-0.0449437685,
-0.0504912585,
-1.0070875883,
0.1204034016,
0.4331323206,
0.6569236517,
-0.1768156886,
0.2661872208,
0.0482552014,
0.7283951044,
0.3511921465,
-0.094637461,
0.340066731,
-0.3376605511,
-0.2741264999,
0.0821839571,
0.559879601,
0.0624236874,
0.2425615788,
-0.2016888857,
-0.0382535532,
-0.2433028966,
0.4129346609,
-0.8081837296,
-0.616052568,
-0.188087821,
-0.23894234,
0.1576177329,
0.0800540671,
-0.6972894669,
-0.1261090189,
-0.2484861612,
0.8360693455,
-0.3483479619,
-0.0074114781,
0.1757590175,
0.2568849325,
-0.0081029255,
0.11842563,
-0.8767988086,
0.4947510958,
0.2553836703,
0.9742475152,
-0.2968510687,
-0.2022066116,
-0.8043324351,
0.2397412956,
-0.2873995006,
0.7895861864,
-0.432054311,
-0.2694072127,
-0.252987802,
0.3389528692,
-0.5363333821,
-0.616990447,
0.4145146012,
-0.4541349709,
0.3442324102,
-0.200851813,
-0.4837155342,
-0.2653499544,
-0.1742651612,
-0.2797906101,
0.9780848026,
0.258290112,
-0.4574838281,
0.299274385,
-0.6617429256,
-0.3997640312,
-0.2476791441,
0.2314913124,
-0.7680546641,
0.5305243731,
0.2820059657,
0.3058842123,
-0.2536134124,
0.1233450174,
-0.3294695318,
-0.4989081323,
0.1062872037,
-0.0449254587,
0.4046115875,
0.0677632615,
-0.2902143896,
0.1602184623,
-0.7510085106,
0.0142152263,
0.2751057744,
-0.5755491257,
-0.4202398062,
0.0905067623,
-0.2107369304,
0.3013646305,
0.184098646,
-0.2776065171,
0.3987641037,
-0.5649372339,
0.5408676863,
0.8137654066,
-0.248325184,
0.5781227946,
-0.4698832929,
0.2658594549,
-0.0557173863,
0.0121210646,
-0.466007024,
-0.4484356344,
-0.997046113,
-0.1690727621,
0.2129329592,
0.3165973127,
-0.4192109704,
0.6440858841,
-0.1333274096,
-0.4260301292,
-0.5049509406,
0.5295655131,
0.2297380418,
0.7076957226,
0.4831949472,
-0.3739096522,
-0.535620749,
-0.6605657339,
-0.336194396,
-0.0700962171,
-0.0202285759,
0.5693808198,
0.1884305477,
-0.0424939618,
0.7190847397,
-0.2938379049,
-0.4915428162,
-0.0568077452,
-0.0078303292,
0.2675982714,
0.5197783113,
0.5195852518,
-0.5078011155,
-0.667304039,
-0.0746791065,
0.0204589553,
-0.4820299447,
-0.3159241676,
-0.2399139702,
0.1691346914,
0.4040843546,
-0.2935732305,
-0.0858376995,
0.8824294209,
-0.4457205236,
0.1309508532,
-0.7926357388,
-0.1121678501,
-0.9423881769,
0.2479756474,
-0.4549536705,
-0.4471537471,
-0.2949724793,
-0.1480409354,
0.1888834089,
0.0773015395,
-0.4019853771,
0.4064175785,
-0.4520356953,
-0.102149792,
-0.4773296416,
-0.0529718809,
0.2992768586,
0.5417564511,
0.0316717513,
1.0264014006,
0.4908289909,
-0.6023346782,
-0.119614929,
0.1357990801,
-0.3169858456,
0.1802163869,
-0.2548126876,
0.5858842134,
-0.0614471436,
0.1841418743,
-0.8037492037,
0.2323224694,
0.1945170611,
0.2693091929,
0.4247362316,
-0.1006597877,
-0.5096854568,
0.2362619936,
-0.2326610535,
0.2034427673,
0.7605166435,
-0.7450832725,
0.7749261856,
0.5862520337,
-0.2217776477,
0.237290144,
-0.3924363554,
-0.0592695996,
-0.4947876036,
-0.2121741772,
0.6652938724,
-0.3725268841,
0.0133485589,
-0.3788335025,
0.056464076,
-0.0156143289,
0.0817361176,
0.3235499561,
-0.043014247,
-0.3563063145,
0.1652259976,
0.3193955719,
0.1473234743,
-0.172352165,
-0.2004756629,
0.5602020025,
-0.2875243723,
-0.1026585028,
-0.1698955148,
0.0733119324,
0.3434805572,
-0.0971077457,
0.9364141226,
0.4246676564,
-0.1880892664,
-0.5132977962,
-0.3444540203,
0.0605563708,
-0.5313740969,
0.1322653294,
-0.5004042387,
-0.5025485158,
0.2576960623,
-0.5457918048,
0.0469472222,
0.1944485456,
0.6703822613,
-0.0295139141,
0.9438418746,
0.8403590918,
0.1199021712,
0.6576447487,
0.0059629581,
0.1669193357,
-0.8677996993,
-0.0528400876,
-0.2508414686,
-0.4212490022,
-0.2808566391,
-0.5975632071,
0.1262204349,
0.4562171996,
-0.2394333482,
0.5117514729,
-0.309679836,
0.4786630869,
0.403782934,
0.0208117347,
0.4036374092,
-0.0467190631,
0.0494173802,
-0.1497936994,
-0.6970893145,
-0.3547965586,
1.022064209,
0.2387240231,
0.6361824274,
-0.005848479,
0.1820104122,
-0.0327932574,
0.3421832621,
-0.4485069811,
0.385959357,
-0.4335745275,
-0.0966514796,
0.1242486387,
-0.2216533124,
-0.4634867013,
0.1667862236,
-0.1288605034,
-0.7222070694,
0.1534419209,
0.4282471538,
-0.4736821949,
0.3992923796,
-0.8798162341,
0.6747098565,
-0.3147028685,
-0.4067137241,
-0.2182935923,
-0.2837322354,
0.1448402107,
-0.688990593,
0.0544423051,
-0.2959240973,
-0.2781176865,
0.5997196436,
-0.3957174718,
0.6040714383,
-0.2194406092,
-0.1570784897,
0.1696540862,
0.1012693122,
0.7029396892,
0.1764408797,
-0.1435962766,
0.2958097458,
0.0506695621,
-0.1862645,
-0.5133183002,
0.932739675,
-0.7980364561,
-0.5262727737,
-0.1412025392,
-0.83704561,
-0.6263357401,
0.0951238647,
0.179039076,
-0.0013139503,
0.107769452,
0.1639408916,
0.5407983661,
-0.5795230269,
0.4610063136,
0.7084272504,
-0.1985432357,
-0.0287824422,
0.9506371617,
0.0829613432,
0.2043179125,
0.3992374539,
0.4604304135,
-0.1765630394,
-0.6380298734,
-0.3867447972,
0.0837440118,
-0.3624447286,
-0.1047700718,
-0.5183515549,
-0.0561952814,
-0.0200431626,
-0.2676517367,
-0.7880126238,
-0.3001039326,
-0.33014974,
0.2562482357,
0.6226844788,
0.1359239817,
0.1076889634,
0.7306051254,
-0.5044953227,
0.2136595696,
0.1970952004,
0.4659656584,
-0.5259842277,
-0.9633201361,
-0.2250312269,
-0.2187417448,
-0.2044923306,
-0.5090736151,
0.5191055536,
1.0232490301,
0.1200333834,
0.3941378593,
0.0154849514,
0.8662330508,
-0.7056688666,
0.4001286328,
-0.2815420628,
-0.9935455322,
0.5823091865,
-0.1972922832,
0.3227770627,
0.7719582915,
0.1015813276,
0.0395806395,
-0.0641199797,
-0.2323040068,
-0.845382154,
0.7549653649,
-0.0300834347,
0.4353709519,
0.2645233274,
0.4316840172,
0.4659856558,
0.1931137741,
-0.4061985612,
-0.0481980629,
-0.1876597255,
-0.0928178206,
-0.4265883863,
-0.1159384027,
-0.0703905001,
-0.4077513516,
0.8380637169,
-0.5111903548,
0.1336891502,
-0.1603898555,
-0.1799996495,
-0.2213609219,
0.1548509449,
0.5313437581,
0.9453775883,
-0.3886446059,
0.3208855689,
0.5141225457,
-0.2771306038,
-0.0032744834,
0.0553286672,
-0.1428470314,
0.0366227552,
-0.262945652,
0.8424220085,
0.3423996568,
-0.9708114862,
0.3413745761,
-0.2655914426,
0.223079145,
-0.3060654998,
0.2481916696,
0.1637081057,
0.0311011653,
0.0237190798,
0.0569706447,
-0.3030560613,
-0.5939522982,
0.1835244,
0.3419288099,
-0.2223042995,
-0.6721337438,
0.5705885291,
0.0900368989,
-0.1873544306,
0.2218592167,
0.0317011476,
-0.0277931988,
0.130023405,
0.8911723495,
0.5356900096,
-0.2696554959,
-0.0013561189,
0.0372076109,
0.155034095,
-0.0936369747,
0.4288524091,
-0.0252831895,
-0.6535938978,
-0.4661051035,
-0.8087595105,
-0.2648081779,
0.4495347738,
-0.3604273796,
0.2963649631,
-0.6876350045,
-0.1171101183,
-0.3114535809,
-0.1591870338,
-0.5735039711,
-0.0171375815,
0.088182807,
1.0125519037,
-0.7763450742,
1.3581956625,
0.680783987,
-0.0738160983,
-0.5872634053,
-0.0888223499,
-0.3550755084,
-0.7492278218,
0.3588550687,
-0.0011294599,
0.0447116308,
0.1616659164,
-0.0092467275,
-0.8467655778,
0.7769482732,
0.9202637672,
-0.7320533395,
-0.0454312488,
-0.0441848747,
0.3870899677,
-0.5975857973,
-0.0131693194,
0.6096035838,
0.2982854545,
-0.3928695023,
-0.9760001302,
0.1989525557,
-0.1162396148,
0.1278196126,
0.1866151839,
-0.7614448071,
0.839014709,
-0.1178770363,
-0.1053085476,
-0.0022240989,
0.4054865539,
0.2576621473,
-0.0123622557,
0.6180205345,
0.3887702525,
0.58708781,
-0.00592568,
0.8168824315,
-0.6342393756,
0.1858995706,
1.4782464504,
-0.3041697741,
0.9563955069,
0.8825890422,
-0.1335809678,
0.5856862664,
0.3473136425,
0.1200991347,
0.8716582656,
0.1570971906,
-0.1601892412,
-0.2555344999,
-0.1655977964,
-0.390805155,
0.4818998575,
0.3252927065,
-0.7243911624,
-0.1110349521,
0.0905970708,
-0.0501596928,
0.175410077,
-0.4789933264,
0.7975976467,
0.3821083009,
-0.5799443722,
0.3661592305,
0.21700041,
0.5906094313,
-0.6822785735,
0.0234370977,
-0.0857089758,
0.6545421481,
-0.0221289061,
-0.239294976,
0.6330839992,
-0.1218722612,
-0.0560936444,
-0.5130365491,
0.7589888573,
-0.5129266977,
-0.3327877223,
0.2353284508,
0.3461734354,
0.0633064657,
-0.3343545496,
-0.6657299399,
0.0495942347,
-0.3743803501,
-0.4110797346,
0.732922554,
0.0743668079,
0.01325134,
0.4956656396,
0.7268100381,
0.4552454054,
0.1718174666,
-0.0358835757,
0.8939314485,
-0.2151392251,
-0.6835950613,
-0.8818200231,
0.2289662808,
0.312335819,
-0.3584810793,
0.8210229278,
0.5145329237,
0.8379794359,
-0.1529836655,
0.5379257202,
0.1604587436,
0.2842510343,
-0.6139326692,
0.7318515778,
-0.3147903383,
0.1214115173,
-0.0830721334,
-0.8816232085,
-0.0481924824,
0.5233417153,
-0.4716720581,
-0.1239599809,
0.528722465,
0.6688883305,
-0.4532834888,
-0.262499243,
0.3232128322,
0.1433034837,
0.0484984033,
0.778300941,
0.3662699759,
-0.4752473533,
0.5450388789,
-0.3531236947,
-0.0403396264,
-0.0963889658,
-1.0361794233,
-0.9822486639,
-0.6317370534,
-0.4741237164,
-0.0770714656,
0.1464722902,
0.8297619224,
1.0966149569,
-0.9950979948,
-0.035391897,
-0.3571204245,
-0.2715083957,
-0.2524295151,
-0.1821525991,
0.5710220337,
-0.3083356619,
-0.7171663642,
0.8168306351,
0.5532397628,
-0.2151522487,
-0.0832262561,
-0.2028963864,
-0.0710473433,
0.3829083145,
0.4738839269,
0.2888714373,
-0.4450929165,
-0.2397447526,
-0.3903706074,
0.2610338926,
0.3462412357,
0.9553195238,
-0.8750072122,
0.6816309094,
0.5463631153,
0.8841759562,
0.4070435166,
0.0502116606,
0.9207168818,
-0.8336107135,
0.2281615734,
-0.0849791914,
0.5467910767,
0.3185879886,
-0.3141721785,
0.1395442486,
0.0833702087,
-0.457690388,
-0.8862053752,
-0.0093960715,
-0.8510865569,
-0.320625931,
0.9079579115,
-0.4847452939,
-0.2220139354,
-0.0879119858,
-0.4552188218,
0.2196152657,
-0.2625569403,
1.0921661854,
0.3523186743,
-0.2247220725,
-0.3118487597,
-0.4671932757,
0.7232367396,
0.5160146356,
-1.1039550304,
0.0003283058,
-0.1494299471,
0.3061521351,
-0.089896515,
0.6702700853,
-0.0653441623,
-0.0345398225,
-0.4445541501,
-0.2983534336,
-0.3451806605,
-0.2813760638,
-0.5266560316,
0.1902546585,
0.2006326914,
-0.1796807349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08588v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08588v3
|
CodeScope: An Execution-based Multilingual Multitask Multidimensional Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs on Code Understanding and Generation
| 2023-11-14T23:18:52 | 2024-06-07T04:34:16 |
Weixiang Yan, Haitian Liu, Yunkun Wang, Yunzhe Li, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Tingyu Lin, Weishan Zhao, Li Zhu, Hari Sundaram, Shuiguang Deng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance on
assisting humans in programming and facilitating programming automation.
However, existing benchmarks for evaluating the code understanding and
generation capacities of LLMs suffer from severe limitations. First, most
benchmarks are insufficient as they focus on a narrow range of popular
programming languages and specific tasks, whereas real-world software
development scenarios show a critical need to implement systems with
multilingual and multitask programming environments to satisfy diverse
requirements. Second, most benchmarks fail to consider the actual executability
and the consistency of execution results of the generated code. To bridge these
gaps between existing benchmarks and expectations from practical applications,
we introduce CodeScope, an execution-based, multilingual, multitask,
multidimensional evaluation benchmark for comprehensively measuring LLM
capabilities on coding tasks. CodeScope covers 43 programming languages and
eight coding tasks. It evaluates the coding performance of LLMs from three
dimensions (perspectives): length, difficulty, and efficiency. To facilitate
execution-based evaluations of code generation, we develop MultiCodeEngine, an
automated code execution engine that supports 14 programming languages.
Finally, we systematically evaluate and analyze eight mainstream LLMs and
demonstrate the superior breadth and challenges of CodeScope for evaluating
LLMs on code understanding and generation tasks compared to other benchmarks.
The CodeScope benchmark and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/WeixiangYAN/CodeScope.
|
[
-0.3060194254,
-0.1600096673,
0.5030924082,
0.6014713049,
-0.0459470563,
0.3928403556,
-0.564784646,
-0.4149778783,
-0.0768207312,
0.5135393739,
-0.4316930175,
-0.7220733166,
-0.6959127784,
0.2836890519,
-0.2375642657,
0.8434060216,
-0.320562005,
0.1259784549,
-0.4807032049,
-0.2671816051,
-0.2318760902,
-0.3850593269,
-0.2686428428,
-0.1295395344,
0.2361898869,
0.4392760694,
0.418605864,
0.56622684,
0.6597872972,
0.3688975871,
0.2673960328,
0.4295042157,
-0.334197998,
0.15082407,
0.2196728736,
-0.4112512469,
-0.2946220934,
-0.1466709226,
0.6798234582,
0.6427181959,
-0.0929633602,
0.3087202609,
0.0424041301,
0.5856565237,
-0.7833251953,
0.4096509516,
-0.49300161,
0.1571478695,
-0.1626559198,
-0.3495895565,
-0.2519750893,
-0.4410147667,
-0.2936600447,
-0.5716958046,
-0.1653316617,
-0.3662027717,
0.3612202108,
0.2773338854,
-0.4300797284,
-0.4812854528,
-0.3798838854,
0.9087324142,
-0.5947603583,
0.6443760395,
0.1233756915,
0.4538578987,
0.1862178892,
-0.7984101176,
-0.2801619768,
-0.2172280103,
0.2492581308,
0.148759082,
-0.08151225,
-0.115420714,
0.4051862955,
0.2254123241,
-0.7957741618,
-0.0929256305,
-0.2768886983,
-0.2657961845,
0.4897018671,
0.3415715396,
0.1719244868,
-0.0816038027,
-0.2905166745,
-0.0527637936,
-0.3433856964,
0.0502613969,
0.6161417961,
-0.1170755848,
-0.4308764637,
0.5160247087,
-0.2688427866,
0.6798648238,
-0.3094631433,
-0.284360379,
0.539518714,
-0.5194927454,
-0.1371830255,
-0.5203392506,
0.5775142908,
0.4917595088,
0.3168747723,
-0.1556865871,
-0.2212786525,
0.4233826399,
0.3448146582,
-0.7351793051,
-0.0591236278,
0.2075911313,
-0.3762892783,
-0.4276462793,
0.0634734109,
-0.8100910783,
-0.4508951604,
-0.1715063751,
-0.0008581346,
-0.289931953,
-0.2650364637,
0.1810377687,
0.0750821307,
0.2768256068,
0.1796326935,
-0.6552127004,
0.2210168839,
0.874658525,
0.7838209271,
-0.3075231314,
-0.7325651646,
-0.6114755273,
-0.1130254567,
-0.435454309,
0.6711351275,
-0.4989680648,
-0.2563095093,
0.1082899943,
-0.016843386,
-0.0176550262,
-0.6510118246,
0.1729269773,
-0.5000658631,
-0.4793838859,
0.2178501338,
-0.460323751,
0.0337554254,
0.3999384344,
-0.3988562822,
0.8058396578,
0.0854630321,
-0.3561778069,
0.471211046,
-0.4333910942,
-0.4495236576,
0.1395599991,
-0.7493525743,
-0.3515201211,
-0.0136188967,
0.0889521316,
0.3471904099,
-0.2549444139,
0.3053191602,
-0.1623144895,
-0.3884371221,
0.1857656986,
-0.528257966,
0.50670892,
0.3236800432,
-0.4384053051,
0.3094551265,
-0.7226083279,
0.4136705101,
-0.0490979329,
-0.585881114,
0.2806551754,
0.1409764886,
0.1882429123,
0.1603124738,
0.4097354114,
-0.4083374441,
0.1908279955,
-0.2173777372,
0.3709849119,
0.4590234458,
-0.1343637854,
0.3054474592,
-0.2944409847,
0.9903508425,
0.0410924777,
0.2602388859,
-0.3479896188,
-0.4293587804,
-0.4803956151,
-0.0836768597,
-0.2193391323,
0.4187594652,
-0.8840321898,
0.1286890656,
-0.4316864014,
-0.7019816041,
-0.3140703738,
0.6726477146,
0.7739839554,
-0.0473874137,
0.0612454079,
-0.5597292185,
-0.656134069,
-0.8386304975,
-0.558319211,
-0.0244327057,
0.0552462414,
0.2462480068,
0.4117198586,
-0.5001615882,
0.54408741,
-0.5428209305,
-0.0218970478,
-0.3920188546,
0.0868025869,
0.3295126557,
0.2998804748,
0.3525645435,
-0.7016513348,
-0.453035593,
0.2635158896,
-0.8626186848,
-0.1069509313,
-0.0969606191,
0.0848211572,
0.3389190137,
0.6064030528,
-0.1959575117,
0.1521654427,
1.1416091919,
-0.08222422,
0.8617673516,
-0.3042408824,
0.2399058044,
-0.8247483373,
0.1412858069,
-0.1766853631,
-0.3039744198,
-0.2270679474,
0.4194965959,
0.6340302825,
-0.2828909159,
-0.4852107763,
0.207033664,
-0.556904912,
-0.5234399438,
-0.0438057818,
0.087284714,
0.2833744287,
0.4100986719,
-0.0396790132,
1.178812027,
0.5080831647,
-0.2953741252,
0.4681555033,
0.0268267598,
-0.7881083488,
0.5004831553,
-0.4578901529,
0.0712006465,
0.2629008889,
0.0557783581,
-0.6667582989,
-0.2004212141,
-0.2281430811,
-0.4435525239,
0.0056103989,
-0.2305777073,
-0.5481854677,
-0.3420965075,
-0.5062009096,
0.5291683078,
0.2261621356,
-0.4241512716,
0.3031529784,
0.296862632,
0.0367646106,
-0.6460523605,
-0.7698943615,
0.3199532926,
0.0255775079,
-0.6438868642,
0.0910949856,
-0.2954735756,
-0.3406293392,
-0.2936216593,
-0.2536353469,
-0.0322629064,
0.0231170226,
0.2002728581,
0.051423084,
-0.268346101,
0.0481122695,
-0.0923864767,
-0.3080711663,
0.0738957524,
-0.3098897636,
0.41045627,
-0.4431401789,
-0.6386540532,
-0.110194087,
0.2736606598,
0.8221686482,
-0.5657677054,
0.2796584368,
0.430636555,
-0.1994615942,
-0.229414165,
-0.5201731324,
0.239340201,
-0.4583554268,
0.7575258017,
-0.5969066024,
-0.5843418241,
0.3584322333,
-0.1442084014,
0.18213512,
0.0827167779,
0.8236531615,
0.2604254782,
0.9284044504,
0.406121701,
-0.0503662564,
0.164965257,
-0.2229094207,
0.0319646001,
-0.7719580531,
0.0112451268,
-0.4196078479,
0.0735900551,
-0.5658604503,
-0.6399566531,
0.5908070803,
-0.006081677,
0.0163327307,
0.4994287193,
-0.5563498139,
0.5206291676,
0.2965978682,
-0.0913982168,
0.4202820063,
-0.1957215518,
-0.1555615216,
0.0366366655,
-0.4879997075,
-0.6397462487,
1.2708238363,
0.3014760017,
0.8715014458,
0.2784101069,
0.691188097,
0.2061200291,
0.2003068924,
-0.5733254552,
0.3130005598,
-0.1635252386,
-0.4068063498,
-0.0394671299,
-0.5035491586,
-0.6967219114,
0.3098881245,
0.1238083243,
-0.5084180832,
-0.1890274435,
-0.1399581432,
-0.2196233571,
0.1697951108,
-0.9751449227,
1.054582715,
-0.4683942199,
-0.4306385815,
-0.2142296731,
-0.320448935,
0.2463167012,
-0.2441622615,
0.4378534257,
-0.0762742534,
-0.2356830388,
0.5716105103,
-0.2662068903,
0.7287841439,
-0.1764163226,
-0.2661609054,
0.049182497,
0.1733981073,
0.3049142063,
0.414791584,
-0.2451220304,
0.3097300231,
0.2862674296,
-0.2783616185,
-0.4268758893,
0.9041249156,
-0.7498954535,
-0.2201650888,
-0.2104691118,
-0.687343955,
-0.3874658346,
0.2286463529,
0.2201288342,
0.660594821,
0.0662312955,
0.1419906914,
0.0539951548,
-0.5864090323,
0.2287932336,
0.5364091396,
-0.3858442307,
-0.2448408604,
0.8398570418,
-0.109312579,
0.2757623792,
0.1968489885,
-0.1245069057,
-0.0742149428,
-0.5068687201,
-0.5801459551,
-0.1020882279,
-0.8806197047,
-0.4050880969,
-0.5570312142,
-0.1234239936,
-0.3204758167,
-0.3273391724,
-0.4933706224,
0.0382568836,
0.2813492417,
0.2550562918,
0.2585524917,
0.9706175327,
0.0018315156,
-0.1222561374,
-0.8151648641,
0.3688726723,
0.1296882331,
0.8290775418,
-0.0945078358,
-0.0929249227,
-0.5296282172,
-0.1930203438,
-0.5974065065,
-0.5387703776,
0.1501142383,
0.0993063301,
0.4451875389,
0.2445927113,
-0.27408728,
0.6882846355,
-0.4569144249,
0.6301074028,
0.0354892984,
-1.1576936245,
0.3960912228,
-0.299788624,
0.6126678586,
0.5164014101,
-0.115764074,
-0.7062378526,
-0.5695362687,
-0.1903751343,
-0.6191275716,
0.6184036732,
0.1397523731,
-0.0483122654,
-0.1334288418,
0.1223144084,
0.2724323273,
0.3401373327,
-0.5805035233,
-0.168142274,
-0.0201614033,
-0.2062000185,
-0.3744044602,
-0.0450242646,
0.0369793028,
-0.004201246,
0.1766082942,
-0.4695719779,
0.3623334467,
0.0359963514,
-0.461383462,
-0.063280493,
0.2015872151,
0.9647094011,
0.9882690907,
0.0502393991,
0.2824984789,
0.2246412933,
-0.5393326283,
-0.0006676564,
0.07459791,
0.3250228465,
-0.2589105964,
0.7259925008,
0.3678917885,
0.604229629,
-1.002271533,
0.6791070104,
-0.0777922273,
-0.2146241963,
-0.3631292582,
-0.0109887617,
0.430182755,
0.4352953434,
0.2429778874,
0.2100074887,
0.0586987995,
-0.2199496776,
0.3320456147,
0.2326223552,
-0.0961860493,
-0.1949280798,
0.5994572043,
0.1649603993,
-0.2372854352,
0.3272157609,
-0.378980875,
-0.4761769474,
1.0598480701,
0.3129573166,
0.7596329451,
0.2157366723,
0.0445472673,
0.3191459477,
0.3702721894,
0.2849931717,
0.4612855315,
-0.2882517576,
-0.6752733588,
-0.601760447,
-0.625229001,
-0.5312154889,
-0.1484159678,
-0.6460298896,
0.0935820043,
-0.3114938736,
0.1126814783,
-0.0263800919,
0.230414629,
-0.8000265956,
-0.091797024,
0.0783269405,
1.0412242413,
-0.4374885559,
1.0083678961,
0.8014718294,
-0.2148375213,
-0.5116563439,
-0.0487276763,
0.1929108053,
-0.9478402734,
0.5747640729,
0.3506554067,
-0.2894451022,
-0.1739510596,
-0.1932072937,
-0.5829138756,
0.9838504195,
0.2900333405,
-0.6526899934,
0.2758216262,
0.2839086354,
0.4591130614,
-0.2601978481,
0.3424372673,
0.4724360704,
0.600515604,
-0.6393768787,
-1.0048248768,
-0.2629186809,
-0.4726560116,
0.2361055166,
0.2389461696,
-0.5575674772,
0.6201366186,
-0.2523551583,
-0.068053633,
0.3429335952,
0.0951618776,
0.4009984732,
0.2826558948,
0.3764597178,
0.1744201183,
0.3806811571,
-0.0335764475,
1.0459140539,
-0.8677802682,
0.4766647518,
0.8037539124,
-0.5295347571,
0.7660913467,
0.5449963808,
-0.4008213282,
0.2334904969,
0.2638905346,
-0.0013174447,
0.1854403615,
0.2785845101,
-0.209989965,
-0.100934796,
0.2020922154,
-0.2842592001,
0.6910773516,
0.2496164143,
-0.1131905243,
-0.3486295044,
0.1001603901,
-0.2793287635,
0.3618298471,
0.0894289687,
0.6518101096,
-0.0516675897,
-0.7111235857,
0.6106368303,
0.1274137646,
0.8782598972,
-0.8570420146,
-0.0172793008,
-0.246838361,
0.4553968012,
-0.2791478336,
-0.9527078867,
0.5917900801,
0.3324302435,
0.0660099909,
-0.3041080236,
0.3536556065,
-0.230735451,
-0.4220944941,
0.6040946245,
0.491071105,
0.0836420506,
0.0006847025,
-0.6655834317,
0.6047856212,
0.0425974652,
-0.1376511604,
0.2394602746,
0.3815727234,
0.2207415104,
0.6196668744,
0.4050105512,
0.1130943894,
0.1679339409,
0.1169596314,
0.6549627781,
-0.499884069,
-0.3119210005,
-0.6431640983,
0.2308270037,
0.1352388263,
-0.5178376436,
0.82773453,
0.9417111278,
1.0648138523,
-0.287340641,
0.8255779147,
0.0224752165,
0.177832678,
-0.5281845927,
0.6147591472,
-0.6844550371,
0.2237810344,
-0.2939565778,
-0.8094530702,
-0.5121266842,
0.4651488364,
-0.3279439807,
0.2476239353,
0.6326045394,
0.8785219789,
0.0475845002,
-0.1333359033,
0.685446918,
-0.0395582356,
0.4332661927,
0.8712313771,
0.7406011224,
-0.4255019724,
0.8217954636,
-0.2802987397,
-0.3356985748,
-0.0934121981,
-0.7277334332,
-0.529962182,
-0.6261317134,
-0.1283031255,
-0.0677784681,
-0.0189802144,
0.7683659196,
0.7585918307,
-0.6444408894,
-0.6874562502,
-0.1719631553,
-0.0788672119,
-0.4086226523,
-0.2481295466,
-0.021896949,
-0.685513258,
-0.7697300911,
0.4268511236,
0.5497878194,
-0.5714845657,
-0.4183658361,
-0.4023435116,
0.0905994475,
-0.3028456271,
0.7275566459,
0.1757380366,
-0.6026337743,
-0.127534315,
0.1317335814,
-0.3486954868,
0.059382014,
0.9416258335,
-0.5677393675,
0.6482954025,
0.2011774778,
0.8542785645,
0.3718349934,
-0.4673319161,
0.47987625,
-0.9205562472,
0.0971189216,
-0.0120716589,
0.4118391871,
0.1772983074,
-0.1993854344,
0.5813119411,
-0.1223464236,
-0.5884500742,
-0.5696929097,
0.4339887202,
-0.6810717583,
-0.0766534433,
1.0598555803,
-0.159387216,
0.1203700006,
-0.1656659991,
-0.0503750555,
0.1177406982,
-0.1323308498,
0.3826639056,
0.5688869357,
-0.0000672166,
-0.1765180826,
-0.8619996905,
0.2248470932,
0.416482836,
-0.9661766887,
0.2308339328,
0.2864166498,
0.2010874897,
0.1456759125,
0.5811690092,
-0.4179827869,
0.6293013692,
0.1609084606,
0.4720288813,
-0.0059515545,
-0.1590912789,
-0.4214057922,
0.0615235381,
0.3468862772,
-0.1077549756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08584v1
|
Asking More Informative Questions for Grounded Retrieval
| 2023-11-14T23:13:27 | 2023-11-14T23:13:27 |
Sedrick Keh, Justin T. Chiu, Daniel Fried
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When a model is trying to gather information in an interactive setting, it
benefits from asking informative questions. However, in the case of a grounded
multi-turn image identification task, previous studies have been constrained to
polar yes/no questions, limiting how much information the model can gain in a
single turn. We present an approach that formulates more informative,
open-ended questions. In doing so, we discover that off-the-shelf visual
question answering (VQA) models often make presupposition errors, which
standard information gain question selection methods fail to account for. To
address this issue, we propose a method that can incorporate presupposition
handling into both question selection and belief updates. Specifically, we use
a two-stage process, where the model first filters out images which are
irrelevant to a given question, then updates its beliefs about which image the
user intends. Through self-play and human evaluations, we show that our method
is successful in asking informative open-ended questions, increasing accuracy
over the past state-of-the-art by 14%, while resulting in 48% more efficient
games in human evaluations.
|
[
-0.6471037269,
-0.7690132856,
0.9174374342,
0.0083031552,
-0.5224025249,
-0.3196846545,
-0.1126718298,
-0.3936370611,
-0.0152432397,
0.5964125395,
-0.4627956152,
-0.4743071496,
-0.4151648879,
-0.3027175069,
-0.2587356269,
0.5505287647,
-0.095267944,
0.0222878084,
-0.5707105994,
-0.3591381609,
-0.6270629168,
-0.6563110948,
-0.4263448119,
-0.0601980276,
0.3798770308,
0.6356643438,
0.8453151584,
0.2145894021,
0.6168025732,
0.2707098424,
-0.1218732446,
0.0760211051,
-0.4199331403,
0.2950023711,
-0.3693944216,
-0.8745079637,
0.1890870929,
0.2139206082,
0.2809098065,
0.3471710384,
-0.1007345021,
0.4446783364,
-0.3536682427,
0.5014451146,
-0.8227653503,
-0.0336602107,
-0.558444798,
0.290948987,
0.0760549605,
-0.5460117459,
-0.572522819,
-0.4345053136,
0.121256806,
-0.8410054445,
0.0543216094,
-0.1363578141,
0.9640104175,
0.2987131476,
-0.4069817364,
-0.1038864702,
-0.6364745498,
0.6264955997,
-0.3480363786,
0.4000994861,
0.4899558425,
0.4953650236,
-0.1172385067,
-0.6744830608,
-0.5630552769,
-0.0934544727,
0.1248050109,
0.5253106356,
-0.0244908165,
-0.1826597154,
0.3729864359,
0.10653916,
-0.3217989504,
-0.2835686505,
-0.3221898079,
-0.0052047502,
0.3837602437,
-0.2844342291,
0.2545605898,
-0.1981966347,
-0.5133876204,
-0.3150975704,
-0.5128738284,
0.5230340958,
0.2330625504,
-0.1022820398,
0.2999013364,
0.9692395926,
-0.2439482063,
0.7690488696,
0.6376990676,
0.2178565264,
0.0666481405,
-0.2031745017,
0.0337740704,
-0.2141779065,
0.0574287288,
1.0200837851,
0.202669248,
0.2828444242,
-0.0997563973,
-0.1733424217,
0.5222938657,
-0.6435956955,
-0.2709010243,
0.3227974772,
-0.6931243539,
-0.3858436346,
0.3807768226,
-0.8327517509,
-0.4597559273,
-0.5094818473,
0.7021326423,
-0.3444723189,
-0.3391046822,
0.0499712154,
-0.419606477,
0.7077209353,
0.7750270367,
-0.1416502595,
0.103670381,
0.3064993024,
0.3207818568,
0.066643551,
0.1055214182,
-0.8395869136,
-0.0939564928,
-0.5510233641,
0.7151334882,
-0.6514769793,
-0.143457979,
-0.1555361003,
0.2017672658,
0.2221996784,
-0.6222465634,
0.3600799739,
-1.1381052732,
0.5318390727,
-0.9169743657,
-0.1843325645,
-0.3559611142,
0.5800232887,
-0.4394429624,
0.9807579517,
-0.1907531321,
-0.9467463493,
0.5377926826,
-0.3210564852,
-0.1946159303,
0.0251325797,
-0.4274060726,
-0.1539092362,
0.4933410883,
0.5625303388,
0.2956231534,
-0.3146778941,
0.3733966649,
-0.0925036445,
-0.4021705091,
0.213520363,
-0.1378688365,
0.4477113187,
0.1127442718,
-0.4979910254,
0.1360411197,
-0.6058877707,
0.4012899697,
0.2354869097,
-0.1645864248,
-0.5447028279,
0.1497401744,
-0.4998000562,
0.4140641391,
0.183283329,
-0.5399637222,
-0.0566504113,
0.2117438465,
-0.135217756,
0.6794072986,
0.2807398736,
0.2579349279,
-0.359159857,
0.597622335,
0.4327251911,
0.3641957939,
-0.4204848111,
-0.8005620837,
-0.8156114817,
-0.19475618,
0.0578854047,
0.5799489021,
-1.1658116579,
0.150899604,
0.1712997705,
-0.4894103408,
-0.4434301555,
-0.3333813846,
0.4287548661,
0.9033921361,
0.8317543268,
-0.2315009534,
-0.3871096969,
-0.7490743995,
-0.3190405667,
-0.4226454794,
0.1538422555,
0.6600053906,
0.4627533853,
0.3677549064,
1.0261707306,
-0.8407672048,
0.0943671018,
0.2046207041,
0.4795097709,
0.2845543921,
0.3968283534,
0.5263209939,
-1.3854938745,
-0.2546758354,
-0.1710318923,
-0.9466737509,
0.1193626747,
-0.2626723349,
-0.3186898828,
-0.3855457306,
0.3511588573,
-0.7965587974,
0.6622993946,
-0.0644505695,
-0.287800163,
0.459602356,
-0.1899126768,
0.6671777368,
-0.608448267,
0.098956421,
-0.048607707,
-0.2890137136,
-0.585359633,
0.4965358078,
0.1887711585,
-0.1143158972,
-0.7031504512,
0.2452083379,
-0.6691811681,
0.0240326859,
-0.0381511785,
-0.0417322852,
0.1563587934,
0.3516024351,
0.348081857,
0.9286324382,
0.5772753954,
-0.8435707092,
0.1220540181,
0.3294151127,
-0.3114877343,
0.8313304782,
-0.6962766051,
0.4377042055,
-1.0192372799,
-0.1107196212,
-1.2582134008,
-0.2659249306,
0.276194334,
-0.4461343288,
0.2016097307,
-0.3862258196,
-0.2253564447,
-0.4007221758,
-0.1386639178,
0.4307098091,
0.5327663422,
-0.9679605365,
0.5595535636,
0.1976813674,
-0.0905140489,
-0.7098780274,
-0.2918782532,
-0.1587137282,
-0.2588130236,
-0.4896945059,
0.1051573604,
-0.0773271322,
-0.3289038241,
0.0827098489,
-0.3112757802,
-0.2398921698,
0.1784456968,
0.1144655868,
0.2185315043,
-0.2862270772,
0.2366133779,
0.0456537306,
0.021549711,
0.0647761524,
-0.3811897933,
0.2708269954,
-0.0959429741,
-0.6996743083,
-0.176882267,
0.6161569357,
0.4039600492,
-0.5698530078,
0.4885920286,
0.3209047914,
-0.3001557589,
0.2951811552,
-0.7771522999,
-0.0498790108,
-0.4289091825,
0.0848430097,
-0.7034869194,
-0.6312497854,
0.3752881587,
-0.1656898558,
-0.1635850817,
0.2637639344,
0.3025217652,
-0.562885046,
1.2055608034,
0.4336287081,
0.4883396626,
0.2708296776,
0.0269126724,
-0.0964838117,
-0.4824825227,
-0.5205758214,
-0.3984118998,
-0.1827807575,
0.0464810804,
-0.83720541,
0.4913680255,
0.4389534295,
-0.0175873432,
0.2304356396,
-0.5934358835,
0.4462152719,
0.753924489,
0.3973536193,
0.296333909,
-0.2106314749,
-0.3139972389,
-0.2874305844,
-0.3223857582,
-0.345156759,
0.92779392,
0.1045855582,
0.6607624292,
0.1960180849,
0.6602897048,
-0.0778715909,
0.4436686039,
-0.4943015873,
0.5003923178,
0.5419203043,
-0.9615371823,
-0.3440738916,
-0.0423587114,
-0.493806839,
0.6611326337,
-0.3067879975,
-0.3804409504,
0.6363138556,
0.2426404655,
-0.434256345,
0.0623509921,
-0.7367661595,
0.6784561872,
-0.6229898334,
-0.398907572,
0.1393026114,
-0.8547642231,
0.3243847489,
-0.1311648488,
0.1705110818,
0.2042357326,
0.0413021185,
0.4982832372,
-0.1334351599,
0.4417327046,
-0.6749492884,
0.2563418448,
0.6517836452,
-0.1199740022,
0.4457059801,
0.1178302392,
-0.1587189138,
-0.1671123058,
0.2521530688,
-0.3375874162,
-1.0608422756,
0.171307072,
-0.5556632876,
-1.0044999123,
-0.3993308246,
-0.098936066,
-0.1338999122,
0.4117747247,
0.3590629399,
0.2401044965,
-0.1889656782,
0.4264712632,
0.9027035832,
-0.561438024,
0.0812663585,
0.2076726258,
-0.2965610921,
-0.4467233717,
0.6323178411,
-0.005291624,
0.2720142901,
0.3778797984,
0.2966247797,
-0.4412478209,
-0.4735490084,
-0.3222945035,
0.2007956356,
-0.9319156408,
-0.1310572177,
-0.6430826783,
0.253352493,
-0.1676707268,
0.0613909476,
-0.2339465618,
-0.3077010214,
-0.4623880088,
-0.308360219,
0.145472765,
0.3354528546,
0.0867659003,
0.2137065083,
-0.4842581153,
0.8049636483,
0.3788564503,
0.1808332503,
-0.2750091553,
-0.4860243797,
0.2536507845,
0.1383452713,
-0.338779211,
-1.238453269,
0.0648391247,
0.0614706911,
0.7694601417,
0.3801731765,
0.5018060207,
1.075129509,
-0.5455238819,
0.6823071241,
0.424520582,
-0.5757724047,
0.8166635633,
-0.0917278156,
0.1772597134,
0.8997247815,
0.8117570281,
-0.135325402,
0.035578873,
-0.6191620231,
-0.6137719154,
0.5288997889,
0.1646779776,
0.1324045807,
-0.0146225644,
0.5608739257,
0.0006293622,
0.6618831158,
-0.6050610542,
-0.3432285786,
-0.6205797791,
0.1237728894,
0.0301791802,
-0.3787788451,
-0.3907925785,
-0.477244556,
0.4115481675,
-0.3869923949,
0.3529794216,
0.616568625,
-0.3457829952,
-0.1859501451,
0.2911260128,
0.2843394279,
0.5898741484,
-0.2549912632,
0.4090706706,
-0.0375101343,
-0.2713047862,
0.4070420563,
-0.0144204833,
-0.5300484896,
-0.0353039093,
0.0840683654,
0.6399303675,
-0.0684204772,
-0.5960978866,
0.946033597,
-0.207333833,
-0.3166874945,
-0.3815529943,
-0.2105432451,
-0.030408334,
0.3894279897,
0.470327884,
0.1671251208,
0.1288769543,
-0.768922925,
0.4072640836,
0.4755170643,
-0.6422630548,
-0.0880716443,
0.8052554131,
-0.1722133607,
-0.1327823251,
0.5417469144,
0.0697606876,
-0.5781887174,
0.4994612336,
0.3486125469,
0.4002436996,
-0.2020579875,
0.5783635974,
0.3503367007,
0.3588386774,
0.0118890665,
1.0630072355,
-0.3108635545,
-0.6406372786,
-0.2634938359,
0.0468266234,
-0.38126266,
0.0734355599,
-0.9892775416,
0.3476135433,
-0.582147181,
-0.483333081,
-0.2567327619,
-0.3288961947,
-0.7048868537,
0.6874058247,
0.0244398471,
0.7708038092,
-0.7187507749,
0.2625092566,
0.9597920179,
-0.7295273542,
-0.7302327156,
0.1050663143,
-0.3332311809,
-0.3851320446,
0.7483463287,
0.2385796458,
-0.0231232997,
0.0711502507,
-1.0623416901,
-1.2452907562,
1.0858485699,
0.2237995267,
-0.0610100478,
-0.0496185459,
-0.2994689643,
0.4956640601,
-0.1522761434,
0.7184423804,
0.1862866282,
0.6920787692,
0.6359445453,
-0.2984887362,
0.1227399558,
-0.4109903276,
-0.2906452119,
-0.05432944,
-0.3092218041,
0.7657884955,
-0.5158159733,
-0.2235489935,
0.0587398335,
0.8049300909,
0.3190627098,
0.3580867946,
0.872151494,
0.2563995719,
0.9853814244,
-0.146011278,
0.9790779948,
0.0576144904,
0.133252576,
1.2168878317,
-0.3083035946,
0.7809222341,
0.7724798918,
0.1768806577,
0.2752055824,
0.7725643516,
0.0868294388,
0.8254253864,
0.1911105216,
0.1183419526,
-0.7045961618,
-0.0611082911,
-0.5830238461,
0.2890004516,
0.1017212048,
-0.0583182462,
-0.162347585,
0.0605670586,
-0.3625377715,
0.2036153227,
0.0099738557,
0.5844737887,
-0.0947780684,
-1.0870290995,
0.3974961042,
-0.0814886242,
0.1493706703,
-0.2170022726,
-0.4120554328,
-0.0198724568,
-0.1231614947,
-0.1155570373,
-0.752816081,
-0.0844725743,
-0.0724105835,
-0.0576647371,
-0.1100744158,
0.7780310512,
-0.2659653425,
-0.3989931941,
0.0566352867,
0.5908054709,
0.2327558696,
-0.3336620033,
-0.6427809596,
-0.2686520219,
-0.1376015693,
-0.343054682,
-0.056722939,
0.2791401446,
-0.3828017414,
0.5512721539,
0.8538584113,
-0.1941815764,
0.32554093,
-0.1087380648,
1.0918546915,
-0.7253170609,
-0.567263484,
-0.1258562803,
0.9888013005,
-0.3777771294,
-0.2165347487,
0.6156151295,
0.2435516268,
0.7308356166,
-0.2079859823,
0.6256774068,
0.0046387678,
0.4918578863,
-0.5469445586,
0.1986724734,
-0.764041543,
-0.0154666547,
-0.5439563394,
-0.912545681,
-0.1400392056,
0.7354753613,
-0.3697093427,
-0.0052293306,
0.7105224729,
0.4803188443,
-0.1513213068,
0.2102718204,
0.4270093739,
-0.0044950279,
0.3346124589,
0.1651688814,
1.464956522,
-0.4733487666,
0.11358165,
-0.4469769895,
-0.4652473927,
-0.0420744233,
-0.9973842502,
-0.7740544081,
-0.460662514,
-0.4082588553,
-0.2585643828,
-0.0434180759,
0.7999969125,
0.7960340381,
-0.7219644189,
0.1621963382,
0.0760551989,
0.0640625954,
-0.2500971854,
-0.1546270847,
0.1109110191,
-0.0510482229,
-0.4313710034,
0.5320107341,
0.1143394262,
-0.0021116154,
0.1336173713,
0.2799354494,
-0.5526952147,
0.1168912947,
0.452144742,
0.2572164237,
-0.5662520528,
-0.6229290962,
0.4367283583,
0.3116416633,
0.2975181043,
0.8329683542,
-0.7683808804,
0.7904490829,
0.3829450309,
0.6723846793,
0.8442085385,
0.8813105822,
0.5592870116,
-0.4990173578,
0.056824822,
0.3067674637,
-0.0114623485,
0.2296101302,
-0.7439248562,
0.2565686405,
0.2175066918,
-0.1524524838,
-0.5664974451,
0.2673500478,
-0.8198534846,
-0.222134769,
1.0256851912,
-0.2466189414,
-0.0905366987,
-0.2459595501,
-0.4723931253,
0.1241663322,
0.0486474484,
0.2081789523,
0.7962462902,
-0.0920652598,
-0.399618715,
-0.347453624,
0.1470001638,
0.5329321027,
-0.7287614346,
-0.5128318667,
0.7174640894,
0.2038796544,
0.2583025992,
0.7870568633,
-0.2636374235,
0.4715205729,
-0.3308317363,
0.1117743999,
-0.1058660299,
-0.7667750716,
-0.276124984,
0.4341544509,
0.1575530618,
-0.413240999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08579v1
|
Graph-Induced Syntactic-Semantic Spaces in Transformer-Based Variational AutoEncoders
| 2023-11-14T22:47:23 | 2023-11-14T22:47:23 |
Yingji Zhang, Marco Valentino, Danilo S. Carvalho, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, André Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The injection of syntactic information in Variational AutoEncoders (VAEs) has
been shown to result in an overall improvement of performances and
generalisation. An effective strategy to achieve such a goal is to separate the
encoding of distributional semantic features and syntactic structures into
heterogeneous latent spaces via multi-task learning or dual encoder
architectures. However, existing works employing such techniques are limited to
LSTM-based VAEs. In this paper, we investigate latent space separation methods
for structural syntactic injection in Transformer-based VAE architectures
(i.e., Optimus). Specifically, we explore how syntactic structures can be
leveraged in the encoding stage through the integration of graph-based and
sequential models, and how multiple, specialised latent representations can be
injected into the decoder's attention mechanism via low-rank operators. Our
empirical evaluation, carried out on natural language sentences and
mathematical expressions, reveals that the proposed end-to-end VAE architecture
can result in a better overall organisation of the latent space, alleviating
the information loss occurring in standard VAE setups, resulting in enhanced
performances on language modelling and downstream generation tasks.
|
[
-0.2777855694,
-0.8776741028,
0.3411263824,
-0.3158889711,
-0.2541204691,
0.3075523973,
-0.0789009705,
-0.3189547956,
0.2827041745,
0.3482089639,
-0.2631566226,
-0.4388844073,
-0.5436083078,
-0.0174291246,
-0.2509064674,
0.4749597609,
-0.4665563703,
-0.3963484466,
-0.1917978972,
0.0405490324,
-0.2095285356,
-0.5689277649,
-0.1244374141,
-0.0591061972,
0.4663879573,
-0.1705769449,
0.8734847307,
0.6630645394,
0.0780112296,
0.4019215405,
-0.2477226555,
0.2087249905,
-0.4049718976,
-0.0756365582,
0.1137980074,
-0.6655739546,
-0.2085055113,
-0.1085283086,
0.5572190881,
0.8556923866,
-0.2143997252,
-0.3021857738,
0.145869419,
0.0475249365,
-0.7539749742,
0.4453707635,
-0.3582834303,
0.2879061997,
-0.1139064655,
-0.0892865062,
-0.4970216155,
-0.0341223255,
-0.0868477747,
-0.582772553,
0.0605685413,
-0.3109266758,
0.9196106195,
0.711103797,
-0.3517085314,
0.1095305234,
-0.6391635537,
0.2954453826,
-0.7206085324,
0.4775078595,
-0.250472784,
0.3127660751,
-0.0588505119,
-0.9028343558,
-0.5797615051,
0.2514716983,
-0.5008927584,
0.4021779001,
-0.5766407847,
0.2479946762,
0.1064415947,
0.3913761377,
-0.5341271758,
0.411155045,
-0.1380725205,
-0.1389962584,
0.0377084315,
-0.0353201814,
0.3835367262,
-0.6026568413,
-0.2326751649,
-0.2757231593,
-0.6743212342,
-0.046704106,
0.6345303655,
0.246640265,
-0.1260762066,
0.5902935266,
0.1325854063,
0.7906983495,
0.0902584568,
0.4138727784,
0.3948179185,
-0.2927721143,
-0.4716947079,
-0.2689367235,
0.9136869907,
-0.1097234264,
-0.0763973594,
-0.5410121679,
-0.107708618,
0.5281224251,
0.4367776215,
-0.6053076982,
-0.1103521436,
0.2107074559,
-0.3275051415,
-0.2686981857,
-0.0394923277,
-0.7428113818,
0.0387253426,
-0.1190609783,
0.0981071517,
-0.4997498989,
-0.1379314661,
0.1399360001,
-0.2747358382,
0.4346118271,
0.1271480769,
-0.782400012,
0.5333173275,
0.2969352007,
0.5914664268,
-0.2634201646,
-0.0065011769,
-0.3875850141,
0.1427901685,
-0.1385841966,
0.7327195406,
-0.5917659998,
-0.1067159548,
0.1468359232,
0.0325472206,
-0.3453862667,
-0.7559651136,
0.2252442688,
-0.5716186762,
0.3918848038,
0.2560130358,
-0.5422286391,
-0.1287886798,
-0.0962100029,
-0.7469856143,
1.0645083189,
0.5137646794,
-0.5427386165,
0.3131035566,
-0.6693144441,
-0.5788171291,
0.2809923291,
-0.7323157191,
-0.1550032943,
0.161821872,
0.5460560918,
0.3219577372,
-0.1352786422,
0.1541007012,
-0.0820978135,
-0.029177919,
0.0394337438,
-0.5796532631,
0.4345044494,
-0.0185756478,
-0.555224359,
0.2651657164,
-0.4920214415,
0.0649389103,
0.3331148028,
-0.0437893644,
-0.2969230115,
-0.1845639497,
-0.1036652252,
0.5130304694,
0.2431024611,
-0.3582462072,
0.1641979218,
-0.923192203,
0.7024315,
0.6172690988,
0.0472763143,
0.5272427797,
0.1505384445,
0.7242773175,
0.4284617007,
0.0071601849,
-0.0297274105,
-0.1335415542,
-0.6166465282,
-0.0897330269,
0.0703053623,
0.4839706421,
-1.0997861624,
0.736659348,
-0.1031401828,
-0.2511910796,
-0.258797437,
-0.037110623,
0.2188741118,
0.2342393845,
0.2808222175,
-0.3289538622,
-0.0937388539,
-1.1163431406,
0.0001561177,
0.1082732379,
0.115498513,
0.7210426331,
0.278868258,
-0.1597732306,
1.0340598822,
-0.6301655769,
0.0653183162,
-0.2112964988,
-0.0220313668,
0.3921248913,
0.1503093988,
0.81561625,
-0.9232359529,
-0.40784958,
0.0014571354,
-0.6874616146,
-0.0369703844,
-0.0261757243,
-0.2115667611,
-0.2361321747,
0.4358730316,
-0.8581209183,
0.4898326397,
0.3940695524,
-0.1133936867,
0.251416713,
-0.1466258466,
-0.1231497303,
-1.132815361,
-0.0223765392,
-0.1753526926,
-0.3831104338,
-0.4624613225,
-0.0074664592,
-0.0558213107,
-0.2484905273,
-0.5973834991,
0.3349382877,
-0.5382469296,
-0.304492563,
-0.1671629399,
0.4663923383,
-0.0821052939,
0.7608447075,
-0.0662993416,
0.9545299411,
0.5976323485,
-0.3612035811,
0.1151727512,
0.3421936333,
0.0055233948,
0.1026850715,
-0.5455659032,
0.2563248873,
-0.1639349014,
0.1000598446,
-1.1668572426,
-0.1683475524,
0.4054089189,
-0.1496872604,
0.503913641,
-0.0707728863,
-0.6519598961,
-0.4247886539,
0.0978168026,
0.4446245432,
0.4820765257,
-0.5939558744,
0.7665762305,
0.539100945,
-0.1348057985,
-0.6067799926,
-0.4032096267,
0.0007847399,
-0.1206061542,
-0.6157235503,
0.6402991414,
0.2445414513,
-0.0909616649,
0.3134094775,
-0.2740656435,
0.0185416713,
0.0154771581,
0.126153633,
0.185864374,
-0.246746093,
-0.0544875003,
0.4718599916,
-0.1902849227,
-0.1494193226,
-0.7734178305,
0.7617896795,
0.038682282,
-0.3315673769,
-0.1552459002,
0.4652224779,
0.4936184585,
-0.2659173012,
0.7570647597,
0.2918918729,
-0.4650891721,
-0.4314624667,
-0.0270108506,
-0.1497253925,
-0.5059961081,
0.5772278905,
-0.2949092388,
-0.893015027,
0.5364481807,
-0.4769378603,
-0.0049284785,
0.6738547087,
0.7343311906,
0.1292098165,
0.6665523648,
0.5125100613,
0.2500554025,
0.7542899251,
-0.5018549562,
0.3664494753,
-0.7267094851,
0.0422687531,
-0.2087441385,
-0.2923670411,
-0.4184446931,
-0.8672946692,
0.2987668514,
0.02693226,
0.2443097681,
0.6387861967,
-0.6855864525,
0.4712415636,
0.0735824034,
-0.0494269989,
-0.3029336929,
0.0169692803,
-0.4787920713,
-0.1202475876,
-1.1256666183,
-0.391789943,
0.6092669964,
0.1091673449,
0.6343185306,
0.133351773,
0.7612258792,
0.1358807236,
0.1570705026,
-0.7040447593,
0.4408886433,
-0.6006947756,
0.0479852781,
-0.1770559549,
-0.3648145199,
-1.0152237415,
0.4797031283,
0.2111510783,
-0.8991286755,
0.6215717196,
-0.0297332518,
-0.2802880108,
0.1674187034,
-0.7564688325,
1.0844342709,
-0.3092361689,
-0.5787052512,
0.064226374,
-0.5646480918,
-0.1749385595,
0.0749937668,
-0.0623314083,
0.3726136386,
-0.0232221968,
0.5788881779,
-0.5796546936,
1.0907359123,
-0.2466838509,
-0.3366925418,
0.2433148772,
-0.0350073203,
0.7497466207,
-0.1117419526,
0.2022236437,
0.1943890452,
-0.5299549699,
-0.1482335031,
-0.8039337397,
0.2950738668,
-1.0429048538,
-0.3645487428,
-0.0349175297,
-0.5906332731,
-0.2816941142,
0.3685819805,
0.4934827089,
0.5112786293,
-0.2213718444,
0.0114295417,
0.2586000264,
-0.4114184082,
0.4650428295,
-0.0707244053,
0.1733862758,
-0.4017189741,
0.5175991058,
0.0898660272,
0.3241134882,
0.6960199475,
-0.1592398584,
-0.4847065508,
-0.4615986347,
-0.3181351125,
0.3639757037,
-0.9544939995,
-0.054824274,
-0.8340530396,
-0.3442855775,
-0.3367173672,
-0.4184441864,
-0.541967392,
-0.3580516279,
-0.3827564418,
-0.0257105976,
-0.1082211286,
0.4565342963,
0.2792747617,
0.5560747981,
-0.424161464,
0.3720270693,
-0.0061303647,
0.0961927697,
-0.1940620542,
-0.1753772944,
-0.2670219243,
-0.219219178,
-0.0840480328,
-0.9629325867,
0.6496254802,
-0.1575654447,
0.7679259181,
0.1701656431,
-0.1963979155,
0.5262732506,
-0.5736436248,
0.5464731455,
0.2349442244,
-0.8802704811,
0.3897661865,
-0.3309008777,
0.3898806572,
0.1384825855,
0.0320175812,
-0.3087173402,
-0.6134245396,
-0.7600182891,
-1.2984012365,
0.6434341669,
0.4166307151,
0.0347048827,
-0.1243218929,
0.646252811,
0.1971502453,
0.4294691086,
-0.7461545467,
-0.319023937,
-0.3367991745,
-0.2676679492,
0.0683005601,
-0.0201972332,
-0.1509979516,
0.1585654616,
0.1392482221,
-0.4393719435,
0.6434437633,
-0.0423344448,
-0.3301610053,
0.0120190224,
0.4647158384,
0.240529567,
0.3169617951,
0.2271229625,
0.2563084066,
-0.1051239297,
-0.070963949,
0.1162701771,
0.4784271121,
-0.0520687364,
0.1010905728,
0.2268959135,
1.206183672,
0.3792848289,
-0.2328657061,
0.393026948,
0.0808139443,
0.0522472113,
-0.1857474893,
0.2341865152,
0.0390109867,
0.2346535921,
0.123151049,
0.0714280978,
0.0472065508,
-0.16175659,
0.4219167829,
0.3165718019,
-0.2206750363,
-0.4049690664,
0.702624023,
-0.0297121443,
-0.2354650497,
0.396555841,
0.1117531806,
-0.4780449569,
0.6789652705,
0.6789909005,
1.076628685,
-0.0098786075,
0.1597214937,
0.0912100673,
0.2387525886,
0.6182616949,
0.0757509246,
-0.2457517982,
-0.8618311882,
-0.6465049982,
-0.5632295012,
-0.1408763528,
-0.0598020479,
-0.4425910413,
0.1302376986,
-0.1292508692,
-0.1664609313,
0.2422240227,
-0.6252026558,
-0.7355228662,
-0.1031221375,
0.2641829252,
0.550193131,
-0.7417476773,
0.5611813664,
0.6843501329,
-0.3215402663,
-0.9845577478,
0.1496067047,
-0.2514314353,
-0.621742785,
0.6759200096,
0.0776455626,
-0.2315725684,
0.152316153,
-0.3181830943,
-0.7514244318,
0.810549438,
0.5747616887,
-0.5980677605,
-0.3506847322,
0.2855715454,
0.6447842717,
-0.4927843213,
0.3594391346,
0.1513244808,
0.2579447627,
-0.072958678,
-0.644918859,
0.0410925895,
-0.3970569968,
-0.0488047935,
0.6948565245,
-0.5417535305,
0.8295385242,
0.1501930505,
-0.4536757767,
-0.365789175,
0.559855938,
-0.3337667584,
-0.4649500549,
0.564155519,
0.4820454419,
0.6125397682,
-0.1303336769,
1.2436960936,
-0.5570790172,
0.4158817828,
0.9576874971,
-0.2976142764,
0.5251866579,
0.4309458733,
-0.1880076379,
0.6110549569,
0.4725658894,
0.0703450069,
0.5705156922,
0.0105915247,
0.0898934454,
-0.2285748124,
-0.0647995472,
-0.1047595814,
0.5728060603,
0.507879138,
-0.4541618228,
-0.4923731387,
-0.0024698323,
-0.2477754653,
-0.2434169501,
0.3170703351,
0.8122845888,
0.172094956,
-0.4483892322,
0.5741571784,
-0.1255838126,
0.3600853086,
-0.6248984337,
-0.022766972,
0.0012705746,
0.0988132879,
-0.0531941392,
-0.5903873444,
0.2855956256,
-0.2528664172,
0.0029393847,
-0.3456487656,
0.8097860813,
-0.4209123254,
0.0236854795,
0.5911593437,
0.8325055242,
-0.0914774612,
0.2962033451,
-0.4902677536,
-0.1599257439,
-0.27711308,
-0.1865863502,
0.2035186291,
0.3329372704,
0.1014875472,
0.0508141071,
0.6408154964,
0.0444761142,
0.1215742901,
0.2874397933,
1.2258011103,
-0.5149375796,
-1.0051703453,
-0.8264446259,
0.5041663051,
-0.0629802719,
-0.0705703124,
0.7007421851,
0.6133205295,
0.5781508088,
0.0168520212,
0.8085146546,
-0.2522957325,
-0.2289220244,
-0.4424262345,
0.3527574837,
-0.6639158726,
0.0939594582,
-0.3184483051,
-0.9519171119,
-0.204112336,
0.4917147458,
-0.4306102991,
0.06669797,
0.8180283904,
0.4672734737,
-0.2560808957,
-0.2192736864,
0.3558051586,
0.4201841652,
0.4680417478,
0.8727517128,
0.7702552676,
-0.3382704258,
0.3232107162,
0.004838651,
-0.1913170815,
-0.0981722623,
-0.3745613098,
-0.6533921361,
-0.340796113,
-0.3620819151,
-0.2951571643,
-0.119323574,
0.3655806482,
0.5805307627,
-0.4187847972,
0.032078594,
-0.4453526735,
-0.0233202968,
-0.215506807,
-0.2679364085,
0.6349805593,
-0.295381844,
-0.8446513414,
0.5185832381,
0.8828546405,
-0.0332421139,
-0.2935010195,
0.1576448679,
-0.0567442998,
-0.0144305099,
0.4680410922,
0.0713357478,
-0.7274653316,
-0.2472044975,
0.2799384594,
-0.2442840636,
0.5852236152,
0.9786044955,
-1.102042675,
0.4807599485,
0.4854978621,
0.6375356913,
0.6319000125,
-0.2829863727,
0.6951602697,
-0.9902176857,
0.4887626171,
0.3997878134,
0.5772976875,
0.0110103292,
-0.5292671323,
0.3653385043,
0.3302353919,
-0.0663233027,
-0.5905855894,
0.4026613235,
-0.9269332886,
-0.3642754257,
1.0202178955,
0.0301588494,
-0.511875391,
-0.0908130407,
0.0636913627,
0.6241509318,
-0.1646931618,
0.2668912113,
0.5049589276,
-0.2486430854,
-0.203488633,
-0.3407469988,
0.0978305489,
0.4135857522,
-1.2822254896,
0.2439242601,
0.5944469571,
-0.0928660035,
0.4640085101,
0.3082747459,
-0.2333286852,
0.290212214,
0.3619282246,
0.0567047521,
-0.085258387,
-0.1955992281,
-0.2542033195,
0.5785669684,
-0.39802742,
-0.1293566227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08576v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08576v1
|
Towards Evaluating AI Systems for Moral Status Using Self-Reports
| 2023-11-14T22:45:44 | 2023-11-14T22:45:44 |
Ethan Perez, Robert Long
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As AI systems become more advanced and widely deployed, there will likely be
increasing debate over whether AI systems could have conscious experiences,
desires, or other states of potential moral significance. It is important to
inform these discussions with empirical evidence to the extent possible. We
argue that under the right circumstances, self-reports, or an AI system's
statements about its own internal states, could provide an avenue for
investigating whether AI systems have states of moral significance.
Self-reports are the main way such states are assessed in humans ("Are you in
pain?"), but self-reports from current systems like large language models are
spurious for many reasons (e.g. often just reflecting what humans would say).
To make self-reports more appropriate for this purpose, we propose to train
models to answer many kinds of questions about themselves with known answers,
while avoiding or limiting training incentives that bias self-reports. The hope
of this approach is that models will develop introspection-like capabilities,
and that these capabilities will generalize to questions about states of moral
significance. We then propose methods for assessing the extent to which these
techniques have succeeded: evaluating self-report consistency across contexts
and between similar models, measuring the confidence and resilience of models'
self-reports, and using interpretability to corroborate self-reports. We also
discuss challenges for our approach, from philosophical difficulties in
interpreting self-reports to technical reasons why our proposal might fail. We
hope our discussion inspires philosophers and AI researchers to criticize and
improve our proposed methodology, as well as to run experiments to test whether
self-reports can be made reliable enough to provide information about states of
moral significance.
|
[
-0.1338350773,
-0.2143199146,
0.7700842023,
0.1693782657,
-0.1662338823,
-0.1948302984,
0.0434361249,
-0.7017956972,
0.0965807438,
0.3141205907,
-0.2054243386,
-0.0716210678,
-0.5950317979,
0.2445354611,
-0.5555212498,
1.0673431158,
0.3491070271,
0.3840627372,
-0.4943543375,
-0.4470439851,
-0.5629405379,
-0.6968739033,
-0.6577292681,
-0.0554491803,
0.1894166172,
0.2411565036,
0.23938559,
0.4529924691,
0.8177340031,
0.3676944971,
0.2415194362,
-0.2456581444,
-0.4700478017,
0.2254382372,
-0.2633675933,
-0.4898225963,
-0.368535459,
0.589437902,
0.4475306273,
0.2672412694,
0.0495201945,
0.6941043735,
0.2269654423,
0.5826753378,
-0.6003952622,
0.0700715408,
-0.1413563937,
0.2767864466,
0.095334284,
-0.0125803528,
-0.4150100946,
-0.4913658202,
0.1959472448,
-0.0739775375,
0.0205691215,
0.0242745616,
0.5732821822,
0.5152204037,
-0.4719780982,
-0.5224227309,
-0.9810109735,
0.8009197116,
-0.7888314724,
0.0822515786,
0.7109693289,
0.211960271,
0.397184819,
-0.6020764709,
-0.3803595901,
-0.7553913593,
-0.3951922953,
0.406975776,
-0.2051104307,
-0.1273391843,
0.2863729,
0.5555596352,
-0.2150450945,
-0.0376470424,
-0.407076031,
-0.1708080322,
0.9971804619,
0.3708340824,
0.3249239326,
-0.2395768911,
-0.2989898026,
0.0140046412,
-0.4632610977,
0.4808404744,
0.5291436911,
-0.0686502829,
-0.0701261759,
0.5911971927,
0.0390387811,
0.3013228178,
0.2059552968,
0.1915576309,
-0.1744337678,
-0.5010569692,
0.0418847613,
0.1105474085,
0.8094652891,
0.6299328208,
0.3435493112,
0.0535472408,
-0.3878329098,
0.1163868904,
0.8101422787,
-0.8242431283,
-0.1343532652,
0.3643839061,
-0.9106816053,
-0.4514361322,
0.1119008288,
-0.4474316537,
-0.6144312024,
-0.1690673381,
0.3348148465,
-0.4238877892,
-0.3271252215,
-0.020974176,
-0.0250928495,
0.2872496843,
0.4493857026,
-0.8101899624,
0.0632887036,
0.5043714046,
0.6781132817,
0.1840146631,
-0.3207138777,
-0.4936175942,
-0.1302426308,
-0.543268919,
0.8519918323,
-0.4706461132,
-0.5690641403,
-0.2586789429,
0.0179788731,
0.213025108,
-0.3267657161,
0.5101438761,
0.0570921488,
-0.0465286337,
-0.5093673468,
-0.7129734755,
-0.107878238,
0.5711642504,
-0.3552714288,
0.6541079879,
-0.1446653903,
-0.4642926157,
0.2342646569,
-0.7211834192,
-0.3856036067,
-0.0137305195,
-0.275937885,
-0.0899215713,
0.2887005508,
-0.1457675844,
0.4768969119,
-0.2156270295,
0.2407998592,
-0.292178601,
-0.2846595347,
0.414272815,
-0.5605809689,
0.7511820197,
0.163495183,
-0.4157090783,
-0.0871104226,
-0.3620139956,
0.1340899616,
0.228649199,
-0.0909753069,
-0.5634070635,
0.2858440876,
-0.5437397361,
-0.1971028596,
0.4694882929,
-0.7796180844,
0.1342474222,
-0.3805245459,
0.1755151898,
0.9719779491,
-0.1625822783,
0.3306133747,
-0.3783511221,
0.4452018142,
-0.1390454322,
0.5516193509,
-0.0602578856,
-0.3506854177,
-0.7815859318,
0.089096427,
0.1175088361,
0.4082493186,
0.0040757777,
0.3597505093,
0.2343994826,
-0.4741461873,
-0.6727467179,
-0.3910831213,
0.4400082529,
0.5560287833,
0.3348790705,
-0.4847528636,
0.0797723606,
-1.1026762724,
-0.7117195725,
-0.6885715127,
0.2382994592,
0.5343546271,
0.7981831431,
0.1341799498,
1.0230948925,
-0.2270669937,
-0.2360339016,
0.1139940992,
0.3220314384,
-0.0799148008,
0.7517340779,
0.6815828681,
-0.61045748,
-0.0865703747,
-0.104175657,
-1.2809166908,
0.3444900215,
-0.1287016422,
0.2046495676,
-0.2817374766,
0.2874103487,
-0.1382863075,
0.6781842709,
0.2395575643,
-0.658777833,
0.6148115396,
-0.3768162131,
0.464610815,
-0.493583113,
0.1961027384,
-0.0961653963,
-0.2455931455,
-0.5022338033,
-0.2153262496,
-0.0423348993,
-0.0301133655,
-0.2783203721,
0.5433284044,
-0.1975706965,
-0.1884238273,
-0.2746184766,
-0.2084390819,
-0.1308884472,
0.1621298045,
-0.3861187398,
0.6893809438,
0.4609009922,
-0.6353925467,
0.4502105713,
0.3081732988,
-0.1651718467,
0.9711301923,
-0.7329149246,
0.4459909201,
-0.2164768428,
0.0661712289,
-0.6102949381,
-0.1058641672,
0.5308384299,
-0.5848656297,
-0.1298310161,
-0.3249756992,
-0.0708947554,
-0.2703078985,
-0.2916882038,
0.5534222126,
0.3460288942,
-0.4042956233,
0.5400271416,
0.5199332833,
-0.0772975534,
-0.5951198936,
-0.5178777575,
0.1200600937,
-0.4112082422,
-0.3262987435,
-0.102809608,
-0.2845950425,
-0.6210349798,
0.2293961942,
-0.090835616,
0.0010557121,
0.4468258023,
0.4333186746,
0.1433598697,
-0.1158327237,
0.3916251063,
0.0298609361,
-0.19861646,
0.5587098598,
-0.0849443972,
0.017376883,
-1.0523566008,
-0.5772269964,
-0.6289923787,
0.5363337398,
0.5319364667,
-0.6515020132,
0.3651871383,
0.1108195856,
-0.3198970556,
0.0062115421,
-0.4366750717,
-0.2489250749,
-0.4324625731,
-0.0540376641,
0.0253667645,
-0.8023307323,
0.2773739994,
-0.13713938,
0.1932797581,
0.5402216315,
0.4421872795,
-0.6192880273,
1.0657154322,
0.7236407399,
0.0080539174,
0.227253437,
-0.330070883,
0.2342348248,
-0.6114200354,
-0.0392434932,
-0.5600854158,
-0.2155687958,
-0.5702276826,
0.0364186466,
0.6161108613,
-0.1946635991,
-0.3768463135,
-0.2219651192,
-0.7061828971,
0.6272230744,
0.4593847096,
-0.0554848798,
0.4412377477,
-0.4132583439,
0.3259124756,
0.1853657961,
-0.3047708571,
-0.8075863123,
0.9110397696,
0.302549094,
0.7401078343,
-0.0049567437,
0.7994700074,
0.8140386343,
0.577111125,
-0.856654644,
0.3446372151,
-0.1897620112,
-0.7810410261,
-0.5261191726,
-0.1551696658,
-0.8709706664,
0.0380633064,
-0.0820912793,
-0.6297631264,
0.3434665203,
0.2646441758,
-0.7859804034,
0.1641407162,
-0.552005291,
0.7897526622,
-0.7939462662,
0.0081629129,
-0.6973175406,
-0.8380619884,
0.2522865236,
0.1939467043,
-0.0354019962,
-0.2907988429,
0.285399735,
0.9257726073,
-0.306281358,
1.1666494608,
-0.2345855683,
-0.153191641,
0.5996350646,
0.1819418371,
0.2586393058,
0.4063698351,
-0.0618941113,
0.2442733049,
0.5712143779,
-0.1650331616,
-0.7570824623,
0.4297251701,
-0.8194562197,
-0.7734288573,
-0.7809224129,
-0.3302714527,
-0.132484138,
0.2539498806,
0.0510975905,
0.6261938214,
-0.5711015463,
0.0667450875,
0.4039278924,
-0.1608101428,
0.4227692783,
0.6725559831,
-0.0259614941,
-0.1828629673,
0.9517237544,
0.1193970516,
0.0429187864,
-0.2871383429,
0.490375191,
-0.1815133989,
-0.3467225432,
-0.6632893682,
0.3529570997,
-0.7581800818,
-0.2893152833,
-0.2602463067,
-0.1083611548,
-0.1309479475,
0.0542987995,
-0.8418530822,
-0.1259836257,
-0.3779646754,
-0.0175154489,
0.2591350973,
1.4474252462,
-0.3195111156,
-0.1922991723,
-0.8526591659,
0.1140445471,
0.4619589448,
0.4507656991,
-0.0049238778,
-0.3349551558,
-0.2771210372,
0.3403109014,
-0.1817643493,
-0.7411233783,
0.0918838829,
-0.0696755722,
0.3882610202,
0.4218481779,
0.3741322458,
0.5439246893,
-0.2418726087,
0.7410475016,
0.0233494099,
-1.0466644764,
0.8998658061,
-0.2620413601,
-0.3659404218,
0.776147604,
0.5193544626,
-0.4038797021,
-0.5925575495,
-0.7326123714,
-0.0994231626,
0.6218068004,
0.2002124935,
0.4499672055,
-0.0633706748,
0.8408537507,
0.0766638443,
-0.0627563745,
-0.5846098065,
-0.1268709302,
-0.4253403842,
-0.1729310602,
0.0680827051,
-0.082653001,
-0.3626015782,
-0.1736530662,
0.1237447485,
-0.3461264372,
0.3899510801,
0.775826335,
0.1120352969,
-0.109455809,
0.1616882235,
0.2144025862,
0.7023796439,
0.0132897422,
0.1106409803,
0.2112344801,
-0.3099829257,
0.4848750532,
-0.274454087,
-0.0558534712,
-0.4725084603,
0.3846428692,
0.287310183,
-0.2422019392,
-0.5545412898,
0.8065104485,
-0.4202162623,
0.3001464903,
-0.617474854,
0.0938261524,
-0.1238467768,
0.5258666873,
0.0114121065,
0.2504015267,
0.3405430913,
-0.945276618,
0.0622445233,
0.5143917203,
-0.6277233958,
-0.442599982,
0.3029770851,
0.2854979932,
-0.5639678836,
0.9606802464,
-0.1839639693,
-0.42147699,
0.9118902087,
0.3206400871,
0.7769060135,
-0.4555820525,
0.359909296,
0.3079867959,
0.4623001814,
-0.1772037596,
0.1979175657,
-0.1036728993,
-0.8013281822,
-0.29823789,
-0.370905906,
-0.5520453453,
-0.2993288636,
-0.939778626,
-0.0726860613,
-0.5862473845,
-0.4055627584,
-0.5591738224,
-0.2851565182,
-0.2136296034,
0.4112040102,
0.1680764705,
0.3886890411,
-0.5548817515,
0.5127862692,
0.4728936553,
-0.5616016984,
-0.7135996819,
0.1905527115,
-0.2979051173,
-0.7316772342,
0.5024033189,
0.1384865791,
-0.5889682174,
-0.0648333803,
-1.0322341919,
-0.8447132707,
0.9385539889,
0.4945352077,
-0.2279013097,
0.1442956626,
-0.0888982564,
0.7023903131,
-0.3365903199,
0.2493308932,
0.4926071465,
0.5102413893,
-0.422385186,
-0.8045853376,
0.1018554866,
-0.4135673344,
-0.5569059849,
-0.1171945706,
-1.0645766258,
0.6443383098,
-0.5181949139,
-0.318487823,
0.2397456914,
0.8805674911,
0.0164695103,
0.5530318022,
0.766440928,
0.2067330629,
0.9611443281,
0.247538209,
1.2922596931,
-0.282458216,
0.5336438417,
0.8061100841,
-0.2155053765,
0.4300028384,
0.1821792126,
-0.0097922515,
0.3633184135,
0.40850088,
-0.3157972097,
0.2414713949,
0.1298255771,
0.0367278866,
-0.4643095732,
-0.3781266809,
-0.3269726634,
0.7988734841,
0.2349086851,
-0.146133393,
0.1047146469,
-0.0245521143,
-0.2420526743,
-0.1270132512,
-0.1436411142,
0.6024075747,
0.164277181,
-0.7765338421,
0.0998127833,
-0.1690127552,
0.1345221996,
-0.3857799768,
-0.314019978,
-0.4047890306,
0.0311231501,
-0.0469989926,
-1.0654431581,
0.4509041905,
0.4610864818,
0.0857532546,
-0.4861927927,
0.731161356,
0.2419037968,
-0.4699889719,
0.2738341391,
0.7605410814,
0.3135904074,
0.0801107362,
-0.6741623282,
-0.3892549872,
-0.149472937,
-0.0669140667,
0.3529864252,
0.2730244398,
0.0706248879,
0.8779644966,
0.4947166741,
-0.1345494092,
-0.2689012885,
-0.0925128534,
0.6354190707,
-0.9321665168,
-0.479249388,
-0.9321458936,
0.4929966331,
-0.0290805288,
-0.5939962268,
0.7699747086,
0.3217163086,
0.5041196346,
0.238286525,
0.8268913627,
-0.2528726757,
0.1950312406,
-0.4329344034,
0.8783074617,
-0.7810705304,
0.1249205247,
-0.0914573446,
-0.2354539335,
0.1317202151,
0.6941047907,
-0.3766038418,
0.0481434502,
0.5092842579,
0.2965696156,
0.1856782138,
0.3748229146,
0.3165282905,
0.4200869501,
0.3578263521,
0.0339689739,
1.7758239508,
-0.0932464898,
0.3882184327,
-0.3911036253,
-0.3428910673,
0.0585929193,
-0.6487916708,
-0.7515187263,
-0.5436137319,
-0.1312516034,
-0.2559761703,
-0.0183716193,
0.5724014044,
0.5234190226,
-0.550498426,
-0.4521649778,
0.2204932272,
0.0740268379,
-0.208196044,
-0.0905449092,
0.3113094568,
-0.393581152,
-0.4165304601,
0.6372259855,
0.3824737966,
0.0364062041,
-0.5112795234,
-0.0101986211,
0.1310562342,
0.1347221434,
0.4490469396,
0.1865815818,
-0.6773472428,
-0.8095140457,
0.043674171,
-0.0542008579,
0.1678132415,
1.1351490021,
-0.6046797037,
0.4094312787,
0.1556218117,
0.3653870523,
0.2041591108,
0.2137687206,
0.5759088397,
-0.0791413337,
-0.3410953879,
0.7871655822,
0.4658176303,
0.0759833306,
-0.8475809097,
0.6501135826,
-0.0203271285,
-0.8850539327,
-0.8188721538,
0.1773632914,
-0.586271584,
-0.2982843816,
0.6068428755,
-0.5463473201,
-0.1497191042,
-0.0613485649,
-0.1573399007,
0.0941977501,
-0.1081303507,
0.9072910547,
0.4164026082,
-0.6509841084,
0.3211790919,
-0.5521680117,
0.414776057,
0.585079968,
-0.8008741736,
0.2074933648,
0.4577797055,
0.2589997053,
0.288146615,
0.7109378576,
-0.0577447414,
0.4296778738,
-0.0362015851,
-0.1718449146,
0.2164067477,
-0.429230541,
-0.4924775958,
-0.0367241539,
-0.0492534041,
0.0602433793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08572v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08572v2
|
Low-Rank Adaptation for Multilingual Summarization: An Empirical Study
| 2023-11-14T22:32:39 | 2024-03-31T17:01:34 |
Chenxi Whitehouse, Fantine Huot, Jasmijn Bastings, Mostafa Dehghani, Chu-Cheng Lin, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Although the advancements of pre-trained Large Language Models have
significantly accelerated recent progress in NLP, their ever-increasing size
poses significant challenges for conventional fine-tuning, especially in
memory-intensive tasks. We investigate the potential of Parameter-Efficient
Fine-Tuning, focusing on Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA), in the domain of
multilingual summarization, a task that is both challenging (due to typically
long inputs), and relatively unexplored. We conduct an extensive study across
different data availability scenarios, including high- and low-data settings,
and cross-lingual transfer, leveraging models of different sizes. Our findings
reveal that LoRA is competitive with full fine-tuning when trained with high
quantities of data, and excels in low-data scenarios and cross-lingual
transfer. We also study different strategies for few-shot cross-lingual
transfer, finding that continued LoRA tuning outperforms full fine-tuning and
the dynamic composition of language-specific LoRA modules.
|
[
-0.4477013946,
-0.6501156688,
0.3025660515,
0.3275871873,
-0.3166294396,
-0.0090777427,
-0.4671905041,
-0.661806941,
0.382825762,
0.3483963013,
-0.2636168599,
-0.2884862125,
-0.7910515666,
0.2553246021,
-0.2458160669,
1.3478755951,
0.1049491093,
-0.2083110511,
0.0152225969,
-0.5530447364,
-0.6048907042,
-0.545833528,
-0.8125422597,
-0.1844342947,
0.9993296266,
0.8329229355,
0.5338043571,
0.38726753,
0.5714225173,
0.1663135439,
-0.1326737106,
0.3466697633,
-0.9334036708,
0.0331170484,
-0.254458636,
-0.5891709924,
-0.845551908,
-0.2860781252,
0.937420547,
1.1473988295,
-0.0329266153,
0.3830518126,
0.3153563142,
1.0372864008,
-0.8272494078,
-0.0225733388,
-0.7436409593,
0.0553884804,
-0.153346315,
-0.3131487668,
-0.322003454,
-0.1717521846,
-0.0006956586,
-0.8483017683,
-0.1806339324,
0.159241274,
0.5952552557,
0.4113336205,
-0.2964021266,
0.0499120057,
-0.7409161925,
0.7775200605,
-0.8038692474,
0.1094303951,
0.496727407,
0.2869074941,
0.169277668,
-0.2626426816,
-0.0134526435,
0.1095774844,
0.1496623755,
0.2184836864,
-0.1706980318,
-0.1708923429,
0.2169703692,
0.2018948495,
-0.4540471435,
0.5872693658,
-0.4569422305,
0.2455506325,
0.546646893,
0.0699586645,
0.0393852927,
0.0050423555,
0.0387872197,
0.0951812416,
-0.7345123291,
-0.0904048681,
0.2445992976,
0.8235906363,
-0.4328202605,
0.5405248404,
-0.5034837127,
0.8217558265,
0.068049483,
-0.1530597508,
0.0050698756,
-0.6323961616,
-0.111199744,
0.2459290922,
0.4454573989,
0.4050011039,
0.3720829189,
-0.096471481,
0.0473538898,
-0.3428128064,
-0.0552359223,
-0.8167524338,
-0.1471607685,
-0.032070905,
-0.4490460753,
-0.0362744294,
-0.3314187229,
-0.8369968534,
-0.4200312793,
-0.203024134,
0.6663303971,
-0.143465355,
0.0978385881,
0.2248511761,
-0.0462349318,
0.194035694,
0.6928189397,
-1.2531715631,
0.288990736,
0.4818842113,
1.0610591173,
-0.5660044551,
-0.6909040809,
-0.9545711875,
0.2384731025,
-0.3766726851,
0.8646215796,
-0.2155266255,
-0.2302256674,
-0.2427591085,
0.006024383,
-0.4477596581,
-0.4811832607,
0.2929798067,
-0.2824192345,
0.1245223954,
-0.2865328193,
-0.1067146063,
0.1742830276,
0.1971802711,
-0.5537903309,
0.8767223358,
0.1999075711,
-0.652844429,
0.3320012689,
-0.7879610062,
-0.7902356386,
-0.3342910409,
0.2387872189,
-0.3185989559,
0.4220338464,
0.268447578,
0.4261315763,
-0.2217984647,
-0.4385175705,
-0.3220588565,
-0.5904253721,
0.0539902188,
-0.3192183077,
0.5653840899,
0.0351673439,
0.066834785,
0.0060068346,
-0.7274223566,
-0.2251936346,
0.0651119277,
-0.5562858582,
-0.5256282687,
-0.0883753672,
-0.0946441516,
0.0775071234,
0.3693807423,
-0.1537554264,
0.4222461283,
-0.4255637825,
0.2386509329,
0.5777689219,
0.1010278612,
0.6724945307,
-0.4335616529,
0.5394207835,
0.0369165465,
0.0851499215,
-0.1469153017,
-0.3703589439,
-0.8638572693,
-0.1797859967,
0.6434577107,
0.655100286,
-0.8341237307,
0.200865835,
-0.6139515042,
-0.3376995921,
-0.4767032266,
0.3523314297,
0.1459099799,
0.4147181511,
0.4388976097,
-0.1492194682,
-0.3053648174,
-0.8260769248,
-0.2563526034,
0.0611566342,
0.057864096,
0.0872100219,
0.4697954953,
0.0091457982,
0.5955531001,
-0.5744232535,
-0.54884547,
-0.6249037981,
0.1512534916,
0.4615611434,
0.4346963465,
0.9265066981,
-0.3860559464,
-0.6096425056,
0.2633883059,
-0.6645389199,
-0.1143701598,
-0.1410208046,
-0.0888921767,
0.1991730481,
0.6162060499,
-0.140780136,
0.070891574,
0.9628251791,
-0.0741823912,
0.1963089854,
-0.7559509277,
0.1271391958,
-1.1670172215,
0.1817423254,
-0.2052607536,
-0.3674108684,
-0.5603758693,
-0.1307353228,
-0.0681086779,
-0.2372620851,
-0.5128754973,
0.5814432502,
-0.4403985441,
-0.34289065,
-0.3041647375,
0.3274388909,
-0.1210758463,
0.5847839713,
-0.1689949483,
0.7065318227,
0.364125073,
-0.670322001,
-0.0764135197,
0.2780284584,
-0.3225006759,
0.738825202,
-0.485640794,
-0.0375545248,
-0.1235323325,
0.0300599691,
-0.7281176448,
-0.2771991193,
-0.1396677345,
-0.1189557537,
0.2150859833,
-0.4402312338,
-0.4206607938,
0.202412501,
-0.5033479929,
0.5852166414,
0.4278421402,
-0.4806994796,
0.4324888587,
0.3585253358,
-0.7280173302,
-0.4983788133,
-0.7125861049,
0.1507558823,
-0.442646116,
-0.2125761807,
0.1911239624,
-0.1943099201,
-0.1273922026,
-0.3734185398,
0.0468258783,
0.0860226676,
0.5122579336,
-0.0632494017,
0.0041574412,
-0.4819090366,
-0.163894847,
0.4324873984,
-0.0807654485,
-0.3361003697,
0.1026415676,
0.2681240737,
-0.0639220402,
-0.2152781487,
-0.2173640728,
0.4451540112,
0.5959270597,
-0.0031116796,
0.8295696974,
0.5067276359,
-0.2601961792,
-0.3585371375,
-0.0684664473,
0.0464175902,
-0.3880835474,
0.6339646578,
-0.3864510059,
-0.5838705301,
0.7405982614,
-0.0830487162,
0.1120909825,
0.5440882444,
0.4998566806,
-0.1971324831,
0.932592392,
1.001278758,
-0.3144569099,
0.6619395018,
-0.0612686388,
0.058210589,
-0.7628203034,
0.3877332509,
-0.6502237916,
-0.6404240727,
-0.6393998861,
-0.1836528033,
0.6486188769,
0.3012683094,
0.0529848449,
0.1612928957,
0.0178400297,
0.7141615152,
0.3008721769,
-0.2155182064,
0.6968601942,
0.0455885865,
0.4619033933,
-0.0272835474,
-0.9760894775,
0.03389607,
0.9300674796,
0.1834914535,
0.8717082143,
0.460549444,
0.5731495619,
0.3572261631,
-0.0705899447,
-0.8966222405,
0.3356118798,
-0.6991423965,
-0.125390932,
-0.6537671685,
-0.3404945731,
-1.1048330069,
0.4807217121,
-0.40153265,
-0.7397103906,
0.3662180305,
0.1522549391,
-0.6661358476,
0.1125574112,
-0.6864926219,
0.829996407,
-0.1911503971,
-0.2485785484,
-0.2890114188,
-0.6685065627,
0.1972240955,
-0.5317814946,
0.3100027144,
-0.2166583091,
-0.0625118539,
0.9341319799,
-0.0764392763,
0.7652130127,
-0.1003006846,
-0.3550845683,
-0.4180018008,
-0.1026041359,
0.3663617969,
0.0882291049,
-0.2002357692,
0.2331776321,
0.2758539617,
-0.6041383743,
-0.5155550241,
0.7681161165,
-0.8293657303,
-0.2561893165,
-0.3110008836,
-0.7600774765,
-0.5786141753,
0.3274825513,
0.2723222077,
0.207323879,
-0.3062773049,
0.4118559062,
0.6497482657,
-0.1981363297,
0.5724409819,
0.4276140034,
-0.3621730208,
-0.1693639457,
1.1133210659,
0.3791036308,
0.4424687326,
0.5382369757,
0.2028604299,
0.1639969051,
-0.9286698103,
-0.705709815,
0.2873886228,
-0.7002840042,
-0.0592070706,
-0.4047627449,
-0.144979313,
-0.1463145912,
-0.3689486682,
-0.5818557739,
-0.7758709788,
-0.3603576124,
0.1589713991,
0.3124091923,
0.4720285833,
-0.0907050371,
0.4638566375,
-0.6999052763,
0.7030805945,
0.2400356382,
0.2204179019,
-0.168750152,
-1.0114256144,
-0.8220656514,
-0.0910300538,
0.2534022033,
-0.352401197,
0.2566659153,
0.6929751635,
0.297424376,
0.0943399891,
0.0781290531,
0.8382962942,
-0.4140912592,
0.6567269564,
-0.0639848337,
-0.7192748189,
0.4183605611,
-0.5826172233,
0.7038089037,
0.9434874654,
0.0681154504,
-0.5948113203,
-0.1889546663,
-0.0459211729,
-0.9102859497,
0.8003544211,
-0.1818310916,
0.1539390832,
0.4825151265,
0.3009553552,
0.3283475041,
0.0182003696,
-0.5523303747,
-0.15355964,
-0.0432803854,
-0.0896303654,
-0.44507429,
-0.1934676468,
-0.1995965093,
-0.3226900399,
0.6515643001,
-0.632424891,
-0.0175315421,
-0.2007071078,
-0.5474315286,
0.0341179967,
0.4398289025,
0.9791291356,
0.8378248215,
-0.2744591236,
0.0253804438,
0.6538492441,
-0.4297305644,
-0.1226779893,
0.1318287402,
-0.0828937963,
-0.144426778,
0.5936822891,
0.8742066622,
0.7106990814,
-0.4385391772,
0.3693303168,
0.0098334579,
-0.2929416597,
0.003647272,
0.0048412415,
-0.0558022372,
0.1007984206,
0.4576335549,
-0.0318403728,
-0.0921122804,
-0.58991009,
-0.3277333081,
0.2375942916,
-0.0515595675,
-0.3993620574,
0.5890389085,
0.185033083,
0.1079041585,
0.289498806,
0.0620462708,
0.0840829238,
0.3684458137,
0.5353484154,
0.5570219755,
-0.0559024289,
0.0895791501,
0.1368299872,
0.2779260576,
-0.2423581332,
0.1596554667,
0.0392414927,
-0.527792275,
-0.5802455544,
-0.6351149678,
-0.6512131095,
-0.0543089099,
-0.8239337802,
0.2663859725,
-0.3627409935,
0.0570899881,
0.2272365838,
-0.0355888493,
-0.3453324139,
-0.2115385383,
0.1617067158,
0.8378319144,
-0.9864875078,
0.9528544545,
0.5499387383,
-0.1678857505,
-0.1423168778,
-0.0384828523,
-0.2497329414,
-0.7158467174,
0.372490108,
-0.2771860957,
-0.419665128,
0.1231315956,
-0.1295262575,
-0.9798895717,
0.9686230421,
0.6942953467,
-0.3533913195,
-0.3753429055,
0.0549859665,
0.7042351961,
-0.2559356391,
-0.2417621762,
0.6746613383,
0.5189960599,
-0.2206441611,
-1.2713061571,
-0.333453387,
-0.0330065079,
-0.0597007796,
0.0840975568,
-0.731151402,
0.912617147,
-0.2367406338,
0.1375448257,
0.146697253,
0.6259714961,
0.0103466641,
0.1425152272,
0.3608636856,
0.2014035434,
0.6670424342,
0.0910448357,
0.9412700534,
-0.2101866156,
0.1280685812,
1.3429749012,
-0.3662905693,
1.185951829,
0.5710448027,
0.0301209595,
0.3449770808,
0.403723985,
0.1521580517,
0.6065850854,
-0.2499972433,
0.1377604157,
-0.1028487906,
-0.1457359791,
-0.485604912,
0.7188750505,
0.3326366842,
-0.0909722522,
-0.21647273,
0.2701111138,
-0.1107047275,
-0.1365537494,
-0.7025842667,
1.0239421129,
0.1137125343,
-0.5992472768,
0.8990968466,
0.0640385896,
0.7043591738,
-0.6386689544,
0.1726755053,
-0.5185417533,
0.2338870466,
-0.2724056542,
-0.3859873414,
0.2676878572,
-0.0370161571,
-0.3440258205,
-0.2902744114,
0.5004025698,
-0.4459989965,
-0.4770276845,
0.2795631886,
0.9278891683,
0.190342322,
-0.0105559779,
-0.4139534533,
0.0035416202,
-0.2226097733,
-0.176737994,
0.9637044668,
0.2918305397,
-0.1957977116,
0.4553440511,
0.4649632275,
0.432330817,
-0.0212582666,
0.2716427147,
0.5266987085,
-0.7109826207,
-0.7253510356,
-0.7096651196,
0.1746241599,
0.084411487,
-0.2816349864,
0.8463099599,
0.6200535893,
0.6570248008,
-0.1446177661,
0.6473658681,
0.2968625426,
0.483934164,
-0.8996748328,
0.8550223112,
-0.7652580142,
0.1660826951,
-0.2940759063,
-0.9786227345,
-0.3688604832,
0.4009502828,
-0.2560892999,
-0.0710112453,
0.7310834527,
0.3456943929,
-0.4078342915,
-0.330289036,
0.5216386914,
0.2398507893,
-0.1038826108,
0.6334250569,
0.4862130582,
-0.4072808623,
0.4568662643,
-0.0130663989,
-0.1310144365,
-0.655995667,
-1.0128412247,
-0.8278020024,
-0.4383220077,
-0.3040388227,
0.0593012236,
0.1807558835,
0.662507236,
0.6711750627,
-0.8234151006,
-0.3440100849,
0.5399647355,
0.2762058079,
-0.4839781225,
-0.0875567198,
0.3625574708,
-0.1032830328,
-0.8215206861,
0.6924467683,
0.4828937352,
0.0540808253,
-0.1073774323,
-0.0023059645,
-0.1756202728,
0.0043262276,
1.053842783,
0.6473129988,
-0.2717690468,
-0.289049685,
-0.2993238568,
0.0300451908,
0.3028917313,
0.6094785333,
-0.5257182717,
0.075816907,
0.4731998444,
0.7879911661,
0.6037679911,
0.1435694546,
0.4706408381,
-0.9568675756,
0.3005491793,
-0.0920169502,
0.4101726115,
0.2447098792,
-0.1507036835,
0.5362498164,
-0.1341177076,
-0.4206566811,
-1.0561586618,
-0.0034136954,
-1.3123692274,
-0.3453836441,
1.1080249548,
0.1477173269,
-0.0844201669,
-0.0746508613,
-0.2215676308,
0.0157591663,
-0.2072111219,
0.7559352517,
0.5781108141,
-0.3023452163,
-0.245005995,
-0.7482210994,
0.5262914896,
0.530702889,
-1.2426594496,
0.3624208868,
0.2829532325,
0.1017621383,
0.2092852592,
0.6825749278,
0.2397458851,
0.3499169052,
-0.3386181295,
-0.4446796775,
0.102867946,
-0.435406208,
-0.8369290233,
0.2987993658,
0.5276379585,
-0.0056753731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08562v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08562v2
|
MAgIC: Investigation of Large Language Model Powered Multi-Agent in Cognition, Adaptability, Rationality and Collaboration
| 2023-11-14T21:46:27 | 2023-11-16T11:40:26 |
Lin Xu, Zhiyuan Hu, Daquan Zhou, Hongyu Ren, Zhen Dong, Kurt Keutzer, See Kiong Ng, Jiashi Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have marked a significant advancement in the
field of natural language processing, demonstrating exceptional capabilities in
reasoning, tool usage, and memory. As their applications extend into
multi-agent environments, a need has arisen for a comprehensive evaluation
framework that captures their abilities in reasoning, planning, collaboration,
and more. This work introduces a novel benchmarking framework specifically
tailored to assess LLMs within multi-agent settings, providing quantitative
metrics to evaluate their judgment, reasoning, deception, self-awareness,
cooperation, coordination, and rationality. We utilize games such as Chameleon
and Undercover, alongside game theory scenarios like Cost Sharing, Multi-player
Prisoner's Dilemma, and Public Good, to create diverse testing environments.
Our framework is fortified with the Probabilistic Graphical Modeling (PGM)
method, enhancing the LLMs' capabilities in navigating complex social and
cognitive dimensions. The benchmark evaluates seven multi-agent systems powered
by different LLMs, quantitatively highlighting a significant capability gap
over threefold between the strongest, GPT-4, and the weakest, Llama-2-70B. It
also confirms that our PGM enhancement boosts the inherent abilities of all
selected models by 50% on average. Our codes are released here
https://github.com/cathyxl/MAgIC.
|
[
-0.5161491036,
-0.9137438536,
0.6256594658,
0.3456321359,
0.1568273455,
0.2888168395,
-0.4494234025,
-0.3594150543,
0.0130611751,
0.5741387606,
-0.3169105053,
-0.4477857649,
-0.5180689692,
0.1525372416,
0.0085474253,
0.6870574355,
0.1227089092,
0.1207962185,
-0.3107332587,
-0.255306989,
-0.5171570182,
-0.5354292989,
-0.4911189675,
-0.6576341987,
0.3099185228,
0.1896158457,
1.1128430367,
0.4275572896,
0.7186177373,
0.4272645116,
0.3127814829,
0.4405145943,
-0.6061782837,
0.1564817876,
-0.455648154,
-0.398622483,
-0.8451032639,
0.2137034982,
0.623406589,
0.4025262296,
-0.1912789494,
0.1074065045,
-0.100114122,
0.3214411438,
-0.6791418791,
0.5339148641,
-0.8198958039,
-0.1424922645,
-0.0464605279,
-0.0712120906,
-0.366809845,
-0.294118464,
-0.0394714251,
-0.7891253233,
-0.0920525715,
0.1063784435,
0.595110178,
0.1795367301,
-0.5016790032,
-0.134812519,
-0.7339238524,
0.6394420862,
-0.4184328318,
0.1399696022,
0.2762591541,
0.7729067206,
-0.434430778,
-0.8094930649,
-0.7877387404,
-0.5686022639,
0.2658459544,
0.2546682358,
-0.1466094702,
0.1885047704,
0.2802457213,
0.2103396952,
-0.4726529717,
-0.1151721776,
0.091461651,
-0.1105086431,
0.8249341249,
0.4206655324,
0.4450326264,
0.416673094,
-0.0908787996,
-0.3544734716,
-0.3306039274,
-0.1533248574,
0.4588274956,
0.1491296738,
-0.0292145777,
0.5944532752,
-0.0509151444,
0.503364265,
-0.3902274668,
-0.3479543626,
0.2937855721,
-0.4230599701,
-0.2290965617,
-0.351991415,
0.8670117259,
0.4821331799,
0.6402885914,
-0.2897810042,
-0.2848621011,
0.3534162343,
0.2372648269,
-0.7118716836,
-0.3583634794,
-0.0113063501,
-0.2973536253,
-0.0056914557,
-0.1067389026,
-0.6509401798,
-0.7650732994,
-0.284260422,
0.4710594416,
-0.5808084011,
-0.5037595034,
0.2943399549,
-0.1540863663,
0.0468588658,
0.3186325729,
-0.5954167843,
0.5642141104,
0.8175316453,
0.6472244263,
-0.1612490416,
-0.7898227572,
-0.5157052279,
0.0858922675,
-0.4235714376,
0.7797217369,
-0.7575092912,
-0.1931435317,
-0.1490842998,
-0.0769783482,
-0.2982437313,
-0.5208839178,
0.6057760119,
-0.5020990968,
-0.2315615714,
-0.1963293105,
-0.5426894426,
-0.0608789325,
0.5768535733,
-0.713429451,
0.7263022065,
0.0096875159,
-0.3616570234,
0.227750212,
-0.7675217986,
-0.1679438949,
0.2186080962,
-0.0889020935,
-0.299769938,
0.0644211993,
-0.0037604559,
0.1997026354,
-0.6065785289,
0.4048849642,
-0.697497189,
-0.4820584059,
0.5743895173,
-0.5287111402,
0.5419419408,
0.1499613822,
-0.0699280798,
0.3592020571,
-0.8350506425,
0.2295461297,
0.3803488314,
-0.0918249041,
-0.2116710693,
0.0522474572,
-0.0481565148,
0.3550812006,
0.2931891978,
-0.0797376707,
0.4291689694,
-0.0640928075,
0.1282150894,
0.4674670398,
-0.1062892675,
0.3307355642,
-0.3305727243,
0.5142731071,
-0.4130810499,
0.3845001459,
0.0306700673,
-0.445435077,
-0.3242859542,
-0.5548859239,
0.2084311843,
0.6223454475,
-0.8620376587,
0.357026577,
-0.3519597948,
-0.6465104818,
-0.3875401616,
0.0221197587,
0.3655730188,
-0.0265389048,
0.1859814674,
-0.3421401083,
-0.1455281228,
-0.7334391475,
-0.4290042818,
-0.2182277292,
-0.0578763522,
0.2692937255,
0.6589034796,
-0.3623244166,
0.8026676178,
-0.2787536681,
-0.1505843997,
-0.2444386333,
-0.0180658512,
0.1764358431,
0.077567555,
0.3970302641,
-0.5446929336,
-0.354197681,
-0.0637447461,
-0.7967729568,
-0.2942880988,
-0.0376522206,
-0.1629286259,
-0.2099983692,
0.121329613,
-0.7161550522,
0.2302527577,
0.5957895517,
-0.5405746102,
0.763038218,
-0.5590474606,
0.3087380826,
-0.6805986166,
0.0430242941,
-0.1094275415,
0.039153412,
-0.6757555008,
0.2927843034,
0.0445935838,
0.1010253355,
-0.0647078827,
0.5695521235,
-0.6810666919,
-0.3189979792,
-0.4886870086,
0.3842222691,
-0.0299778748,
0.4069905281,
-0.2265136093,
0.8757198453,
0.5389949083,
-0.4191426635,
0.5492771864,
-0.1274983138,
-0.2814411223,
0.632286787,
-0.4956968129,
0.2029606253,
0.1531506479,
0.1484731883,
-0.7837376595,
-0.0324053019,
0.0300073139,
-0.2013643533,
-0.039617762,
0.0647801533,
-1.0158003569,
-0.0993766263,
-0.2402334064,
0.243570134,
0.3383999169,
-0.2652082741,
0.9419110417,
0.6188536286,
0.1292850077,
-0.3478841484,
-0.2573049664,
0.4138627946,
-0.1833406091,
-0.7834506631,
0.2978636324,
-0.2440031916,
-0.7254316807,
-0.2302525789,
0.1354349852,
0.037374191,
0.2988560498,
0.1562993526,
0.1462932974,
-0.0208846852,
0.1510781944,
-0.2313205153,
-0.0721133724,
0.1911397874,
-0.0146073308,
0.5771178007,
-0.4724863768,
-0.5318931937,
0.2635538876,
-0.0293112416,
0.7333693504,
-0.4890766442,
0.8392242789,
0.5968368649,
-0.3609904945,
-0.2780174911,
-0.5112328529,
-0.0714602694,
-0.4093990624,
0.4648735523,
-0.5549661517,
-0.5877718329,
0.7755529284,
-0.312569201,
-0.0555663295,
0.1898051798,
0.5940663218,
0.6071606874,
1.0681068897,
0.48657161,
0.0891180709,
0.3124336302,
-0.0114353094,
0.142786473,
-0.6549265385,
-0.093188256,
-0.2984396219,
0.0717139319,
-0.5536202192,
-0.630581975,
0.4018248618,
0.1910012066,
-0.2837564349,
0.0174888596,
-0.2312733382,
0.6330050826,
0.3238739669,
-0.211758852,
0.5297774076,
-0.1059348658,
-0.305911839,
0.0738708749,
-0.4263584912,
-0.8061252236,
1.1526076794,
0.3985220492,
0.591778934,
0.3739587367,
0.1775877625,
0.2877294719,
0.5004423261,
-0.5385473967,
0.7398178577,
0.1498295218,
-0.5706061721,
-0.5082386136,
-0.4458294511,
-1.0652543306,
0.7925924063,
-0.4660484195,
-0.8281297088,
-0.3174922764,
-0.3044613004,
-0.1096498147,
0.239932254,
-0.7800046802,
0.7838448882,
-0.3573052287,
-0.7004232407,
-0.4622795582,
-0.3743816614,
0.5747529864,
-0.2013984174,
0.2648689449,
-0.4050416946,
-0.1268227845,
0.3633612692,
-0.2300924361,
0.4987875521,
0.0753199682,
-0.1324886382,
0.2512469888,
0.1841740906,
0.5156978965,
0.1263436973,
-0.2360283583,
0.3108549118,
0.0174778569,
-0.2072473913,
-0.7355939746,
0.6255021691,
-0.8972311616,
-0.537789464,
-0.5219905376,
-0.8550100923,
-0.5044543147,
0.1660263538,
-0.3454115093,
0.1289975047,
-0.4165523946,
-0.0083936378,
0.4836930037,
-0.2798515558,
0.2808070183,
0.9207394123,
-0.4844613373,
-0.50020504,
0.8588703871,
0.2069309205,
0.287938118,
0.1249494553,
0.1362449825,
-0.2466332614,
-0.6053308845,
-0.1275188476,
0.1931173354,
-0.679874301,
0.0595915727,
-0.49986431,
-0.1402583271,
-0.3319703043,
0.1611691564,
-0.3052482903,
-0.0384793691,
0.1126086786,
0.1255118847,
0.1200492233,
0.6847304702,
-0.0225855708,
0.2571832836,
-0.5382912159,
0.3636257648,
0.4098107815,
0.4597844183,
0.0264677498,
-0.1703721136,
-0.2171589583,
-0.0522087738,
-0.5263339281,
-0.9074146748,
0.4905322492,
-0.0484958924,
0.8850134611,
0.1459105611,
0.0142883984,
0.536952436,
-0.4134302735,
0.6107532382,
0.1155690327,
-0.9755588174,
0.0810480118,
-0.4987429678,
0.261998415,
0.3749955297,
-0.1896390617,
-0.3121094108,
-0.3555323482,
-0.5989761353,
-0.5239500999,
0.5220865011,
0.3718546927,
-0.2231447101,
0.0233807806,
0.1302490681,
-0.0633372292,
0.2800306082,
-0.6351077557,
-0.3459362388,
0.1082869321,
0.0036360484,
-0.3551419079,
0.0165042765,
-0.2313149422,
-0.0512603261,
0.5424348712,
-0.4194141626,
0.1900499016,
-0.151086688,
-0.1059214175,
0.0573321879,
0.3300985396,
0.5156971812,
0.9684634209,
-0.0119894585,
0.2803732157,
0.3906616271,
-0.4848057628,
0.1285687238,
0.4017633796,
0.2981925309,
-0.4094004929,
0.5859698653,
0.6367632747,
-0.0538829304,
-0.7604901195,
0.4287023544,
-0.3834243715,
-0.0042155618,
-0.2163788974,
0.3793218434,
0.1359499097,
0.6205130816,
0.3239209652,
-0.0551168956,
0.1914948374,
-0.7307149172,
-0.0901635438,
0.7273585796,
-0.0331351236,
-0.2785852253,
0.3363333642,
-0.0183167383,
-0.4717559218,
0.3550915718,
-0.5241057873,
-0.3694997132,
0.787948966,
0.5491139889,
0.7631903291,
-0.1887272596,
0.1701335311,
-0.0694116727,
0.5996358395,
-0.2484603673,
0.2124283761,
0.2205214202,
-0.9316461086,
-0.4431795478,
-0.2978429496,
-0.5925976634,
0.1430376321,
-0.2659248114,
0.133339256,
-0.2066240907,
-0.4974936843,
-0.2028817236,
0.5648874044,
-0.7495310307,
-0.1002124399,
0.1446244568,
0.7850200534,
-0.6937779188,
0.9567720294,
0.6121686697,
-0.2211374193,
-0.6412174106,
-0.0085850926,
-0.1004657075,
-0.7314583063,
0.1740734428,
0.0529953204,
-0.2808939517,
-0.2491066754,
-0.5351367593,
-0.7597122192,
1.2727993727,
0.7258199453,
-0.5445219874,
0.2819179296,
0.2050274163,
0.9054946899,
-0.560411334,
0.8332178593,
0.7850143909,
0.6619355679,
-0.1242499426,
-1.16284585,
0.0255449489,
-0.3237227201,
-0.0051115812,
0.0370176286,
-0.8828986287,
0.7892997265,
-0.1726816744,
-0.1395598948,
-0.0454386212,
0.4267211854,
0.8615724444,
0.5493021011,
0.4260648787,
0.2714527249,
0.9618226886,
-0.0921140313,
1.053104043,
-0.4915382564,
0.2194906324,
1.0190449953,
-0.8324566483,
0.4344915152,
0.2134216279,
-0.2225790322,
0.3344472945,
0.2583876252,
0.0029291213,
0.3198138475,
0.6794099212,
-0.1767967492,
-0.3992436528,
-0.2499932647,
-0.2981557548,
0.3827747703,
0.4670870602,
-0.0537513569,
-0.081696555,
-0.1491950899,
-0.0017146347,
0.2139760554,
-0.2768306136,
0.5501762033,
0.0465866551,
-0.7793630958,
0.2992324233,
0.0897183642,
0.4663225114,
-0.7247995734,
-0.1504228711,
-0.1272457093,
0.5091909766,
0.1775817275,
-0.7597535849,
-0.0982495546,
-0.2932746112,
-0.0011837052,
-0.0065737208,
0.7960323691,
-0.2928329408,
-0.3349629343,
0.674254477,
0.718634069,
0.1184714958,
-0.1457835734,
-0.9068872929,
0.3444650769,
-0.4952512085,
-0.269327879,
0.4712790847,
0.7194219828,
-0.2455665767,
0.8632563353,
0.6263244152,
0.0950665995,
-0.1756419241,
0.3799348176,
0.6334317923,
-0.445269227,
-0.3903853297,
-1.0911374092,
0.1137881204,
-0.2867456675,
-0.2183894068,
1.0809249878,
0.4709123671,
0.4569571614,
0.0490777008,
0.6683482528,
0.428871274,
-0.0708269328,
-0.3606251478,
0.6742086411,
-0.2395891994,
0.3560123146,
-0.5332834721,
-1.0020166636,
-0.2036000788,
0.4869235158,
-0.523927927,
0.2244471461,
0.7109621763,
0.7980479598,
0.0637866259,
-0.0035538499,
0.7105821371,
0.0074456367,
0.5363838077,
0.7145376801,
1.0077338219,
-0.2873119712,
0.4501489699,
0.217303142,
-0.3295983076,
0.0238166582,
-0.9248173237,
-1.1378961802,
-0.3455349207,
-0.2587631941,
-0.4163302481,
0.117483668,
0.9573795795,
0.6693897843,
-0.2997558713,
-0.4772828817,
0.1147067472,
0.2997594178,
-0.4770029187,
-0.2130856812,
0.1516268551,
-0.0542092845,
-0.5842573047,
0.4034349918,
0.3927373588,
-0.0403351933,
-0.6066909432,
-0.441126585,
-0.0454256833,
0.4271496236,
0.5935642123,
-0.0539650284,
-0.6018286347,
-0.0562618338,
0.0092523526,
-0.2756281793,
-0.2129790336,
0.6391515732,
-0.5695877671,
0.434248507,
0.3516402543,
0.375246942,
0.3311897516,
-0.2100197971,
0.5514176488,
-0.2086907774,
-0.1526490897,
0.0299966484,
0.4812662899,
0.3068258762,
-0.1030730233,
0.7589100003,
0.2182913721,
-0.7601610422,
-0.7715227604,
0.0358880274,
-0.6708884239,
-0.3157263994,
1.2519938946,
-0.106972456,
-0.1835054308,
-0.1641188562,
-0.1987457275,
0.1956159472,
-0.2839590311,
0.7587861419,
0.9579153657,
-0.0292518251,
-0.0972562656,
-0.6673053503,
0.2404727042,
0.0808219537,
-1.0405923128,
-0.0016565809,
0.6126379371,
0.1983584613,
0.4059434831,
0.7099242806,
0.102757439,
0.0620312318,
0.2789317369,
0.2629648745,
-0.277674228,
-0.4086621702,
-0.3633541167,
0.4202678204,
0.1037519872,
0.0583402961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08552v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08552v1
|
UT5: Pretraining Non autoregressive T5 with unrolled denoising
| 2023-11-14T21:28:10 | 2023-11-14T21:28:10 |
Mahmoud G. Salem, Jiayu Ye, Chu-Cheng Lin, Frederick Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in Transformer-based Large Language Models have made great
strides in natural language generation. However, to decode K tokens, an
autoregressive model needs K sequential forward passes, which may be a
performance bottleneck for large language models. Many non-autoregressive (NAR)
research are aiming to address this sequentiality bottleneck, albeit many have
focused on a dedicated architecture in supervised benchmarks. In this work, we
studied unsupervised pretraining for non auto-regressive T5 models via unrolled
denoising and shown its SoTA results in downstream generation tasks such as
SQuAD question generation and XSum.
|
[
-0.3073423207,
-0.3635044098,
0.2376876771,
0.2290168256,
-0.4956221282,
0.3563135862,
0.0330757387,
-0.1666275263,
-0.1836519539,
0.679394424,
-0.8716285825,
-0.4219117463,
-0.4723792374,
0.3753850758,
-0.6381658912,
1.1118491888,
0.1050781533,
0.0162096415,
-0.0311396625,
-0.1166433692,
-0.5344500542,
-0.5704978704,
-0.5735394359,
-0.4060213864,
-0.0090806149,
0.4156366885,
0.0975435376,
0.252079308,
0.1369820535,
0.2907977402,
0.2785870731,
-0.1193300039,
-0.6728472114,
0.3446164727,
0.0872940719,
-0.5633491278,
-0.1715933383,
-0.1729793996,
0.8871090412,
0.6117824912,
-0.2552947104,
0.1635994464,
-0.1790665388,
0.4779435694,
-0.6822654605,
0.200204283,
-0.4149597585,
-0.0543050356,
-0.2396826893,
-0.0167839583,
-0.5860618949,
-0.4076770842,
0.0150498115,
-0.505957067,
0.5912875533,
-0.0525119156,
0.7192867398,
0.5221801996,
-0.428786397,
0.0512770265,
-0.7962111235,
0.7691558003,
-0.7474631071,
0.5311692953,
-0.0067742923,
0.1665026993,
-0.3672653735,
-1.0507872105,
-0.6025639772,
0.1226237938,
0.0130084222,
0.3502533138,
-0.2926575541,
0.1072044373,
0.2485089898,
0.34442994,
-0.4593833387,
0.3504856527,
-0.2110628039,
0.0456110127,
0.7447467446,
0.0728874058,
-0.0872472376,
-0.0751156509,
-0.3692603409,
-0.2691520154,
-0.5484856963,
0.0602017492,
0.2048683614,
0.1313855797,
-0.0709204748,
0.1051189676,
-0.3063918948,
0.4945221543,
0.3789545298,
0.0705762655,
0.3390620351,
-0.5143483281,
-0.2545721233,
-0.0533358753,
0.9302015901,
-0.0472690649,
0.3327142,
-0.5143228769,
-0.484018445,
0.0888975635,
0.329120487,
-0.9940587878,
-0.4706493318,
0.1185094714,
-0.264084667,
-0.4426087439,
-0.005919544,
-0.7165773511,
0.2004643232,
0.1345766634,
0.4078831673,
-0.166319415,
-0.3865413666,
-0.0279806703,
-0.0997329652,
0.2214240283,
-0.0957626551,
-0.947544992,
0.2665179968,
-0.0705367327,
0.3101164699,
-0.0190363619,
-0.1274165958,
-0.6249653101,
0.127669692,
-0.5018988252,
0.898530364,
-0.5936075449,
-0.7319203019,
-0.1959416419,
0.1158654839,
-0.2816086411,
-0.3329719603,
0.3229031265,
-0.7969841361,
0.3437263966,
-0.0942594633,
-0.518636167,
-0.1500989348,
-0.2289908528,
-0.4861103892,
1.1652289629,
0.1701100171,
-0.4650613368,
0.8795819283,
-1.0040700436,
-0.6436314583,
0.0580958165,
-0.0204210598,
-0.7314768434,
0.2341636717,
0.3580262661,
0.3425934315,
-0.1573244631,
0.4233313203,
0.0670700744,
-0.2615979016,
-0.1853526086,
-0.3461529315,
0.3835172355,
0.2334677279,
-0.732396245,
0.2905403674,
-0.8971295357,
0.19907327,
0.1639427692,
-0.0415956862,
-0.1645443738,
-0.3078178763,
-0.0689925775,
0.1519407779,
0.0584482998,
-0.5598300099,
0.33296296,
-0.2777997851,
0.5091267228,
0.4522633851,
0.2782395184,
0.4281412661,
-0.019999288,
0.5179799199,
0.514759481,
-0.0754143968,
-0.256527096,
-0.3112774491,
-0.8020547628,
-0.1041766927,
0.48351264,
0.134654507,
-0.8989472985,
0.2262921035,
-0.0190054756,
-0.4401193261,
-0.4132759273,
0.0434360318,
0.631431818,
0.3365359604,
0.596373558,
-0.4313966632,
-0.9395671487,
-0.6937586069,
-0.0146732917,
-0.0066912407,
0.0525568873,
-0.141686216,
0.4249964952,
-0.2808157802,
0.9560490847,
-0.3929754198,
-0.3100575209,
-0.632458508,
0.9501934648,
-0.1147603691,
0.4992541075,
0.2694118619,
-0.580488503,
-0.2076668292,
-0.5891187191,
-0.5841709375,
-0.3648983538,
-0.1757320166,
0.2823908627,
0.8472559452,
0.776674509,
-0.4918808341,
0.5329689384,
0.4155409038,
-0.0976974219,
0.0520888679,
-0.600259006,
-0.1204560399,
-1.1191540956,
0.2913877368,
-0.3277262449,
-0.2535722852,
-0.7333059311,
-0.2834128737,
-0.1167120337,
0.1086847484,
-0.1855340153,
0.2442136407,
-0.8526549339,
-0.343419522,
-0.1784412414,
-0.0990521014,
0.0339090489,
0.2948796153,
0.3016560376,
0.8733796477,
0.3019628525,
-0.916888535,
-0.3855692744,
0.3465605676,
-0.2271553874,
0.0469623506,
-0.6616532207,
0.3016391695,
-0.5443608761,
0.4603496194,
-1.1345986128,
0.0803236589,
-0.4210064709,
-0.4994103312,
0.5315188766,
-0.0217920411,
-0.5095434785,
-0.3125348091,
-0.0953825414,
0.4546882212,
0.9172894359,
-0.306641072,
0.2962753773,
0.3163436949,
0.3539912403,
-0.4206332266,
-0.4065766931,
-0.1482406855,
-0.1293546259,
-0.1651640683,
0.3127501905,
0.2731469274,
0.2061655074,
-0.1622284204,
0.1382214576,
-0.1298975199,
0.164395079,
0.1164562926,
0.1335699856,
-0.238361761,
0.0248873942,
-0.1365309507,
-0.2714476585,
-0.021762779,
-0.2866404653,
0.5988981128,
0.0960439295,
0.0185196009,
-0.385948211,
0.4461551905,
0.6135171056,
-0.4336939156,
0.68342489,
0.7682967782,
0.0516657494,
-0.2824049294,
-0.5900843143,
-0.4699892998,
-0.4121947587,
0.2817916274,
-0.5224612951,
-0.8601974845,
0.5070747733,
0.0373846628,
0.4011309147,
0.5670832396,
0.5244837403,
-0.0377018303,
1.1558991671,
0.664260745,
-0.0345442966,
0.2724920511,
-0.5455994606,
0.3424999416,
-0.4978179038,
-0.2897180319,
-0.2545813918,
-0.241096139,
-0.7369627953,
-0.1698421538,
0.215138495,
0.03351238,
-0.2955657542,
0.2147761881,
-0.3369354904,
0.3372848034,
0.8558044434,
-0.535507381,
0.4620840549,
-0.2577667832,
-0.1943783015,
0.0206485167,
-1.1538794041,
-0.268612355,
1.1716026068,
-0.0506306291,
0.7094211578,
-0.0715976581,
0.8030688763,
0.1492309868,
0.3366936743,
-0.2203032076,
0.4295220971,
-0.4469587505,
-0.6174355745,
-0.4516594112,
-0.2601271272,
-1.3460873365,
-0.0479552895,
-0.1603469849,
-0.5335339308,
0.132811442,
0.1499424726,
-0.6766477823,
0.3359153271,
-0.7542127967,
0.8792537451,
0.1302551031,
-0.2582098246,
0.0724747106,
-0.8854481578,
0.3931303322,
-0.1864884794,
-0.1125924364,
0.4139452577,
0.272298187,
0.8678114414,
-0.4937280715,
0.985214889,
-0.5967290998,
0.1314563006,
0.4266446233,
-0.1533448696,
0.4868606031,
-0.0829188898,
0.3916601241,
0.0897131711,
0.1491780132,
-0.2105550766,
-0.5337215066,
0.3608920276,
-0.9580557346,
-0.5763385296,
-0.245075196,
-0.4741640687,
-0.3032514453,
0.4668298364,
0.7229372859,
0.5096798539,
-0.1220347062,
0.1823128462,
0.6411036849,
0.1317702085,
0.9668315053,
0.6505590081,
-0.0628079996,
-0.2130877972,
0.6050624847,
0.3233433664,
0.3279956877,
0.2870151103,
-0.072957851,
-0.94544065,
-0.655182898,
-0.5173408985,
0.1387306154,
-0.3400314748,
-0.2245723754,
-0.852167964,
-0.3295357823,
-0.67546314,
0.069545947,
-0.6719257236,
-0.2351837605,
-0.3738282919,
-0.0426758789,
0.3450319171,
1.0971053839,
-0.1432501674,
0.484580934,
-0.8737694025,
0.3964399099,
0.0614454225,
0.1464790106,
0.0106001263,
-0.5765663385,
-0.0022852581,
0.0067858961,
-0.2698695958,
-0.3869895041,
0.4875604808,
0.030249415,
0.6106041074,
0.4849311411,
0.5919722319,
0.9013516307,
-0.3665930629,
0.4946601689,
-0.0008684741,
-0.8158500195,
0.3691031933,
-0.1355002224,
0.6341405511,
0.750950098,
0.18927975,
-0.1038720533,
-0.4117106795,
-1.0621381998,
-0.6536843777,
0.6405624151,
0.2261856645,
-0.0351769887,
-0.2160517871,
0.0842494294,
0.200930357,
0.5174859762,
-0.5107799768,
-0.06641794,
-0.5886380076,
0.0805070996,
-0.326779902,
-0.4452124238,
0.4884754121,
0.0067295544,
0.5479168296,
0.0535159484,
0.3841374815,
0.4303939939,
-0.1598322392,
-0.0989641845,
0.3628019094,
0.7474632263,
0.1800076067,
-0.2265817672,
-0.1370271295,
0.287666589,
-0.3965467811,
0.3624189198,
-0.2354896814,
-0.3707673848,
0.0781229958,
0.2865779996,
0.9286879301,
0.3522764742,
-0.3132236004,
0.4001109004,
-0.105814904,
-0.4792220294,
-0.5418259501,
0.0228770878,
-0.2010240853,
0.078145057,
0.2554228604,
-0.0803824663,
-0.1319061071,
-0.5119993091,
0.3133189082,
0.4378724396,
-0.3197512627,
-0.6127601266,
0.8869409561,
0.15565826,
-0.0155718168,
0.9251794815,
-0.2751311064,
-0.5274344683,
0.2692089975,
0.7892255783,
0.9853066206,
-0.4049380124,
0.000112535,
0.4089645147,
0.1164397746,
-0.1625993401,
0.5284239054,
-0.3108013868,
-0.7083386779,
-0.5813791752,
-0.5341697931,
-0.1595795453,
0.2989923656,
-0.7152780294,
0.1465646029,
-0.2656210065,
-0.2271560282,
-0.2863020599,
-0.0788842738,
-0.4172242582,
0.5759350657,
-0.1886700243,
0.5261632204,
-0.7483791113,
0.9956054688,
0.7094654441,
-0.5018827319,
-0.9591689706,
-0.0076432014,
-0.5798358321,
-0.8281289339,
1.0604809523,
0.0285985507,
-0.3374714255,
0.6484727263,
-0.17459023,
-0.8745566607,
1.0749466419,
0.0577504076,
-0.305141747,
-0.3300432563,
0.3210205138,
0.5265944004,
-0.4128505886,
0.4290170372,
0.6983258724,
0.3376681507,
0.6514657736,
-0.8232266307,
-0.0539200306,
-0.154125452,
0.0145480782,
0.4616349638,
-0.8858425617,
0.8670622706,
-0.4677452743,
-0.3780303895,
-0.1357514113,
0.5596539974,
0.0757176578,
0.0811793655,
0.5806275606,
0.7903053164,
0.5242029428,
0.0828259587,
0.8255808353,
-0.4450387359,
0.0382507332,
1.0806267262,
-0.3058159947,
0.7635401487,
0.4745982289,
0.06705641,
0.5114055872,
0.5171899796,
0.0642498359,
0.8169127107,
0.1373010129,
-0.1693062633,
-0.4438376427,
-0.0324830674,
-0.3892436326,
0.7960708737,
-0.0642557889,
-0.3204266727,
-0.5020112395,
-0.0904018879,
0.1138665751,
-0.2803446949,
-0.1437207758,
1.098974824,
-0.0010940137,
-0.9750488997,
0.7880923152,
-0.0043632318,
0.4939828515,
-0.5486289263,
0.0444215573,
-0.5179681778,
0.3279621005,
-0.1688113213,
-0.3549524844,
0.4795154929,
0.0645391792,
-0.1567716897,
-0.5395480394,
0.6156194806,
-0.2056494802,
-0.329672128,
0.033576481,
0.5543074608,
0.1277087182,
0.1198161095,
-0.1240988299,
-0.4129785299,
0.1007890403,
-0.3279775083,
0.3035736084,
0.4736465812,
-0.4986801147,
0.7330787778,
0.800578177,
-0.253033489,
0.1366176307,
0.2696658671,
0.8067390919,
-0.6737757325,
-0.726414144,
-0.8543994427,
0.510840714,
0.1271586716,
-0.4277805686,
0.7535377741,
0.5646793842,
0.7435570955,
-0.0946709439,
0.7284861207,
0.2100700587,
0.5178059936,
-0.5019900203,
0.9343768954,
-0.4113380909,
0.1165306717,
-0.1033331752,
-0.6187090278,
-0.1579746604,
0.4421078861,
-0.3312784135,
0.1914518327,
0.7414358258,
0.5801770091,
0.2537589967,
0.1900270879,
0.5866261125,
0.2735702097,
0.2147933096,
0.5775099397,
0.704816401,
-0.5489816666,
0.4750323296,
-0.1106261015,
0.1241673306,
0.0428622738,
-0.675780952,
-1.2661293745,
-0.6475957036,
-0.2602697611,
0.1087741479,
0.0327132307,
0.613587141,
0.710252285,
-0.7636528611,
-0.1927927732,
-0.6281050444,
-0.2390094101,
0.3033360541,
-0.1932595819,
0.1949807554,
-0.7889658809,
-0.5775660276,
0.3100463748,
0.0315900743,
0.4391488433,
-0.443371743,
0.2234951258,
-0.292938292,
-0.08722689,
0.4263339341,
0.2333277166,
-0.3050335944,
-0.1299178898,
0.1439376324,
0.2473497987,
0.1773310453,
0.7631577253,
-1.3031361103,
0.2507659495,
0.2956746221,
0.4142743349,
0.8195879459,
0.2244541645,
0.947352767,
-0.7525231838,
0.1439690441,
0.2234633267,
0.0671067983,
0.1417295486,
-0.0688036606,
0.3503710926,
0.324926585,
-0.4348554611,
-0.8696139455,
0.0353253894,
-0.3572168648,
0.0435756221,
0.7664918303,
-0.0666569769,
-0.1986589283,
-0.5276148319,
0.2777203321,
0.5374896526,
-0.4962274134,
0.6307767034,
0.4347399473,
-0.1870525032,
-0.3597544134,
-0.4617189169,
0.6009858251,
0.6171093583,
-0.7112551928,
0.0388299897,
0.125749737,
0.1044373512,
-0.1890201271,
0.7921161056,
-0.0038349743,
0.1094769463,
0.1686833203,
0.3131166399,
-0.1710882783,
-0.1682993621,
-0.0127878366,
0.1936490387,
0.0294691268,
-0.435746938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08545v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08545v1
|
Efficient Continual Pre-training for Building Domain Specific Large Language Models
| 2023-11-14T21:19:14 | 2023-11-14T21:19:14 |
Yong Xie, Karan Aggarwal, Aitzaz Ahmad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable open-domain
capabilities. Traditionally, LLMs tailored for a domain are trained from
scratch to excel at handling domain-specific tasks. In this work, we explore an
alternative strategy of continual pre-training as a means to develop
domain-specific LLMs. We introduce FinPythia-6.9B, developed through
domain-adaptive continual pre-training on the financial domain. Continual
pre-trained FinPythia showcases consistent improvements on financial tasks over
the original foundational model. We further explore simple but effective data
selection strategies for continual pre-training. Our data selection strategies
outperforms vanilla continual pre-training's performance with just 10% of
corpus size and cost, without any degradation on open-domain standard tasks.
Our work proposes an alternative solution to building domain-specific LLMs from
scratch in a cost-effective manner.
|
[
-0.2925668657,
-0.7700055838,
0.4557717443,
0.2593895495,
-0.3420653641,
0.3020439446,
-0.591714561,
-0.3870500326,
0.1375003606,
0.7120556235,
-0.5773183703,
-0.2631201148,
-0.3867132664,
0.0156915188,
-0.0716785192,
0.8931835294,
-0.1493301541,
0.0755243227,
-0.1060076877,
0.18999286,
-0.481123358,
-0.5790407062,
-1.1186285019,
-0.4104607999,
0.5691410303,
0.3645432293,
0.449557811,
0.387450695,
0.4974989593,
0.2704312503,
0.4190102518,
0.1176507249,
-0.8111997843,
0.0163055584,
-0.2994873524,
-0.1785168797,
-0.4635424018,
0.1782297939,
0.5365715027,
1.0126588345,
-0.1291074157,
0.2141760439,
-0.0107943388,
0.8597744107,
-0.6233949065,
0.2387370318,
-0.8040553927,
-0.1660173833,
-0.4829373956,
-0.2467962205,
-0.5921358466,
-0.2046260387,
0.3671150804,
-0.7797076702,
-0.0866558403,
0.1041079611,
0.8204568028,
0.0738849714,
-0.0636285469,
-0.1492341459,
-0.7305768728,
0.7444936633,
-0.4990188181,
0.7537605762,
0.4557215869,
0.1102407426,
-0.2420580387,
-0.9771586657,
-0.3918357193,
-0.4025171399,
0.2039545625,
0.0614474192,
-0.1400585026,
-0.0696029216,
0.0184687786,
0.1202670559,
-0.565205574,
0.1983549595,
-0.272320509,
-0.032277558,
0.4057235718,
-0.2058143467,
-0.0752848238,
0.4043436646,
-0.3757451773,
-0.0463739671,
-1.006295681,
-0.2386764884,
0.3245892525,
0.5052178502,
0.1256370693,
0.2147058547,
-0.0683286861,
0.7328974605,
0.2819057107,
-0.342765063,
0.2016973495,
-0.0916323364,
-0.370867908,
-0.0129558174,
0.2329499424,
-0.2493388206,
0.6920388937,
-0.3141980171,
-0.4601789713,
0.0016041374,
0.6161521077,
-0.6527250409,
-0.3905079663,
0.2627806365,
-0.3833893538,
-0.1299518496,
-0.2505605221,
-0.3520696461,
0.1945432574,
-0.6308217645,
0.4691750407,
-0.5466971993,
-0.2646138966,
0.3134275079,
0.0898269638,
0.0644573048,
0.2743800879,
-1.079402566,
0.5058780909,
0.5848466754,
0.7154818177,
-0.3537949324,
-0.3940227926,
-0.8358883858,
0.2766399384,
-0.6071140766,
0.9665657282,
-0.6313481331,
-0.2540176213,
-0.0061966097,
-0.1658419818,
-0.242965281,
-0.6237816215,
0.0097694565,
-0.9103671908,
0.1515443027,
0.1821741611,
-0.6400847435,
0.0100722834,
0.0596282482,
-0.4705133736,
0.7443469167,
0.7073884606,
-0.6220815182,
0.5266968608,
-0.6160042286,
-0.30347839,
0.3445291519,
-0.0647520795,
-0.4661611617,
-0.0811445266,
-0.0971963406,
0.4883159101,
-0.2182728946,
0.3540348411,
-0.5586996675,
-0.3716995716,
0.1081717461,
-0.2744990587,
0.3551773131,
0.2434306592,
-0.3760857582,
0.0142951291,
-0.6795368195,
-0.0331400447,
0.1810341477,
-0.2275640666,
-0.6424775124,
-0.1575360149,
0.0999930575,
-0.0210591387,
0.4443911016,
-0.2312328964,
0.2035662532,
-0.5705502629,
0.121366851,
0.9095897079,
-0.1697243303,
0.4012470245,
-0.4513197541,
0.5201850533,
-0.191878289,
0.094625473,
0.002629373,
-0.067520164,
-0.6374797225,
-0.5207262635,
0.4893207252,
0.4882073402,
-0.8760006428,
0.4576599002,
-0.4314748049,
-0.6134263873,
0.0158829298,
0.5295647979,
0.3242326975,
0.3174806535,
0.3600146174,
-0.4590372443,
-0.5678169727,
-0.6221151352,
-0.0185308401,
-0.0268148761,
0.0302326865,
-0.0605311282,
0.5133875608,
-0.2252619416,
0.9335054159,
-0.6804011464,
-0.1190169677,
-0.3811763525,
-0.1586721539,
0.321410656,
0.614207685,
0.8602827191,
-0.7629832029,
-0.4616514444,
0.0414869636,
-0.4098340869,
0.0487470366,
-0.5199666619,
-0.2539790273,
0.366320461,
0.3731394112,
-0.7640200853,
0.2655284405,
0.4257570803,
-0.3504486084,
0.6544476748,
-0.409439981,
-0.117842786,
-0.7787697911,
0.3504818678,
-0.0422982424,
-0.459608078,
-0.7034213543,
-0.0755755305,
0.0359038115,
0.0294398777,
-0.2726141214,
0.8580520153,
-0.4525120556,
-0.089156948,
-0.4349536598,
0.1693679094,
-0.3718721867,
0.5781140327,
0.3702346385,
0.8638656735,
0.5606353879,
-0.7928521037,
0.2427172959,
0.3427076638,
-0.3206265569,
0.5366656184,
-0.5006200075,
0.1249864027,
0.1208441257,
0.2334589213,
-0.6244134903,
-0.0304811876,
0.2263627052,
-0.116396606,
0.6110514402,
-0.0401694886,
-0.209639892,
-0.3698920906,
-0.1421136558,
0.1120114475,
0.4314820766,
-0.8345696926,
0.5753858685,
0.3962467313,
-0.7035664916,
-0.4314435422,
-0.3710938394,
0.1235084757,
-0.3527635336,
-0.5436559319,
0.5459278822,
-0.3541595936,
-0.3371934295,
-0.1871652007,
-0.3908632696,
-0.0075269309,
0.2690804601,
0.0043764398,
0.6077492833,
-0.4525401592,
0.1705283523,
-0.1568764448,
-0.3059675694,
-0.1163021773,
-0.9310299754,
0.778850317,
0.0820869952,
0.011910825,
-0.1907594502,
0.0381381214,
0.1775357425,
-0.1962130964,
0.6654728651,
0.1862812191,
-0.2502407432,
-0.5039873719,
-0.7564415336,
-0.0115058068,
-0.562443018,
0.1608321518,
-0.4271061122,
-1.0181428194,
0.2279950231,
-0.2892209589,
0.2592727542,
0.3847738802,
0.548741281,
0.0678545535,
0.1528714448,
0.8658074737,
-0.0759443641,
0.7175905704,
-0.0694511831,
0.0906831995,
-0.2433504164,
-0.0531708896,
-0.4173876643,
0.0893536657,
-0.0854878873,
-0.2994552553,
0.0723304823,
0.1574050784,
-0.5735388994,
0.4422768652,
0.0012489563,
0.461384356,
0.3053745031,
-0.0313628986,
0.044388894,
0.242239669,
0.1541358232,
0.2565576136,
-0.6731699705,
-0.3746633232,
1.3919126987,
0.3605686426,
0.6987397075,
-0.1578929424,
0.740836978,
0.2215463519,
0.6872968674,
-0.4220547676,
0.2325173616,
-0.4939029813,
-0.2243420482,
-0.5578891635,
-0.7449399233,
-0.9731237888,
0.0120115094,
-0.1513701677,
-0.5794023275,
-0.0571572185,
0.1824860275,
-0.5987410545,
0.3211827278,
-0.590554595,
0.955555141,
-0.2642045319,
-0.2930786908,
-0.2777344286,
-0.2889488339,
0.2002914399,
-0.9529228806,
0.2736883163,
0.1169254333,
-0.0636598691,
0.7373328805,
-0.4599367082,
0.8364957571,
-0.2407694161,
-0.3538618684,
0.1548839509,
-0.1467318833,
0.4934006631,
0.128889516,
0.1150513515,
0.0041841189,
-0.0323844813,
-0.625844121,
-0.4314140081,
0.6244137287,
-0.6249789,
-0.5909956098,
-0.288775593,
-0.3769461513,
-0.8166405559,
0.2967129648,
-0.1934828311,
0.5069872737,
-0.2194034159,
0.2305711657,
0.805783391,
-0.1087521985,
0.3714202046,
0.650924623,
-0.1977523565,
-0.5031413436,
0.8383195996,
0.037674576,
0.3844081759,
0.4547902942,
0.1733926982,
-0.3250107467,
-0.7289636135,
-0.1239800602,
0.3651678562,
-0.5558471084,
-0.3036777675,
-0.5271562934,
-0.2178468406,
-0.5920013189,
-0.3634949028,
-0.428288281,
-0.3309503496,
-0.2343589216,
-0.0735724643,
0.5254528522,
0.4169691801,
-0.1351903677,
0.4343260229,
-0.8794395924,
0.4084318578,
0.3717737496,
0.5749481916,
-0.0810027719,
-0.7901251912,
-0.4039268196,
-0.1332786679,
0.0543983541,
-0.2637526393,
0.412232101,
0.3320163786,
0.6903079152,
0.304482609,
-0.0572841056,
0.7467160821,
-0.4450919926,
0.4705347419,
0.292537719,
-0.8341121078,
0.3358600736,
-0.3213799596,
0.374281317,
0.6441136003,
0.7063686252,
-0.263849318,
-0.3323653042,
-0.5783694386,
-0.7756412625,
0.4714585543,
0.1293092221,
0.2561381161,
0.0314796567,
0.572764039,
0.4610490799,
0.1833738685,
-0.471026659,
-0.1053065732,
-0.1634855419,
0.0041592349,
-0.3629093766,
-0.0633809566,
0.1502748132,
-0.0202707183,
0.9450818896,
-0.2421447039,
-0.1279175133,
-0.0729073435,
-0.1155205145,
-0.0495364666,
-0.0412828252,
0.4745176733,
1.1095166206,
-0.3102976084,
-0.1485864371,
0.1912481636,
-0.8521693349,
-0.02123072,
0.2564357519,
0.0886927694,
-0.0503902286,
0.3841120005,
0.6689370871,
0.534327209,
-0.9077739716,
0.2726727128,
0.0954233333,
-0.3695808649,
-0.7617673278,
0.058033742,
0.1706193537,
0.2881011069,
0.4473409653,
-0.0070000724,
-0.5911547542,
-0.5730804205,
0.5969933271,
0.1603666246,
-0.1334483176,
-0.0947075188,
0.4175651073,
0.0372829027,
0.0221553463,
0.653717339,
0.0044090613,
-0.2439965308,
0.2650921643,
0.6769174933,
0.7530238032,
-0.3639905751,
0.2974525392,
0.0075943703,
0.0926419944,
-0.4849272072,
0.4655455053,
0.1822447181,
-0.8340705037,
-0.5560652018,
-0.8305332065,
-0.4015027881,
0.3055953979,
-0.4375603199,
0.1813252717,
-0.7823475599,
-0.218180567,
0.0119595844,
0.1974688768,
-0.7107526064,
0.5130336881,
0.0593332537,
1.1097335815,
-0.3214140534,
1.1669353247,
0.3091731071,
-0.336412549,
-0.6617723703,
-0.2292503119,
-0.2775612772,
-0.6115238667,
0.880332768,
-0.1292999387,
-0.2082140446,
0.0160962138,
-0.642064631,
-0.9492666125,
0.9682414532,
0.4318989217,
-0.7139104009,
-0.1201161295,
-0.0114010638,
0.4043726921,
-0.5828107595,
-0.2441750914,
0.7903825641,
0.4613664746,
0.1833646297,
-0.8680710196,
-0.1279040724,
-0.154365316,
-0.059357278,
0.1523904204,
-0.512681067,
0.7783598304,
0.0066910363,
-0.07634525,
0.1578873247,
0.8636438847,
0.4372915328,
0.1981037557,
0.7948665023,
0.2562067509,
0.8178795576,
0.0623029321,
0.8352853656,
-0.5224577188,
0.0911717638,
1.2211253643,
-0.5494382381,
1.1277475357,
0.4566209018,
-0.2372824848,
0.3358927369,
0.7881987691,
-0.0977387726,
0.457747817,
0.3645989895,
-0.2755479217,
-0.5985580087,
0.2367027253,
-0.3073551953,
0.4449149966,
0.34484604,
0.1609899998,
0.0803945959,
0.0392004736,
0.0898355916,
0.0071508358,
-0.4667342603,
0.583773315,
0.4279751182,
-0.5182438493,
0.7125709057,
0.0007250981,
0.8482768536,
-1.3446191549,
0.3124727607,
-0.3915379047,
0.1400831789,
0.059297435,
-0.1395739764,
0.3337595165,
0.1693211943,
0.036820922,
-0.5164799094,
0.6380974054,
-0.3835329413,
-0.3966118395,
0.2027472109,
0.3814361691,
-0.0074449778,
-0.2470112592,
-0.4202898741,
-0.0456610173,
-0.241234839,
-0.4254498482,
0.5740099549,
0.3268217444,
-0.0334669538,
0.7439382672,
1.0369234085,
0.3535908163,
-0.4048898518,
0.0433932468,
1.0073466301,
-0.7092455626,
-0.6923992634,
-0.4719091654,
0.0000873028,
0.0586970001,
-0.3787539005,
0.4608374834,
0.5808406472,
1.233730197,
-0.3267060518,
0.6952219009,
0.3899102509,
0.3796011508,
-0.9625162482,
0.7813196182,
-0.5075616837,
0.2544887066,
-0.3545631468,
-1.0826945305,
-0.3284927905,
0.6557719707,
-0.3966412544,
0.1069871783,
0.8953048587,
0.5307499766,
-0.0814647079,
0.076554291,
0.383908838,
0.0751723573,
0.0994840637,
0.4447933137,
0.6445339322,
0.1109191701,
0.4291782379,
0.0025739034,
-0.215135932,
0.2311247587,
-0.7718948722,
-0.9997553825,
-0.3427788317,
-0.388032496,
-0.141271323,
0.1025792807,
1.1968499422,
0.6525431275,
-0.8882665634,
-0.4716523886,
0.2821022868,
-0.2799932659,
-0.2783645988,
-0.0928871557,
0.4127827585,
-0.7548447847,
-0.4664497674,
0.6911621094,
0.4644964039,
0.1488138288,
-0.1983659863,
-0.0896747112,
-0.083206296,
0.2481745034,
0.6079217196,
0.3507627845,
-0.2001113892,
-0.4722919166,
-0.1663921326,
0.0946177393,
-0.0108460328,
0.9718212485,
-0.6818362474,
-0.0218687132,
0.1247312501,
1.0148758888,
0.5355443358,
-0.1379451901,
0.8436133265,
-0.3158435524,
0.2433034629,
0.0478596129,
0.3243295252,
0.164710179,
-0.2396763265,
0.5789979696,
0.388353467,
-0.3038918376,
-0.5184944868,
0.007094542,
-0.9614998698,
-0.6907325387,
0.9545461535,
-0.3592470586,
-0.2422268391,
-0.3473974764,
0.0053694309,
-0.1788302958,
-0.175313592,
0.753054738,
0.4153338373,
0.2376469076,
0.1299584955,
-0.4778902233,
0.6221556067,
0.2144830227,
-0.939360857,
0.2171978503,
0.3428509831,
0.5239270329,
-0.0537588298,
1.1061940193,
0.0334839076,
0.1875410974,
0.1043567657,
-0.2257569134,
-0.0796615034,
-0.7275129557,
-0.0763032585,
0.2661519647,
0.0925500989,
0.3126967251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08538v1
|
Extending Multilingual Machine Translation through Imitation Learning
| 2023-11-14T21:04:03 | 2023-11-14T21:04:03 |
Wen Lai, Viktor Hangya, Alexander Fraser
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the growing variety of languages supported by existing multilingual
neural machine translation (MNMT) models, most of the world's languages are
still being left behind. We aim to extend large-scale MNMT models to a new
language, allowing for translation between the newly added and all of the
already supported languages in a challenging scenario: using only a parallel
corpus between the new language and English. Previous approaches, such as
continued training on parallel data including the new language, suffer from
catastrophic forgetting (i.e., performance on other languages is reduced). Our
novel approach Imit-MNMT treats the task as an imitation learning process,
which mimicks the behavior of an expert, a technique widely used in the
computer vision area, but not well explored in NLP. More specifically, we
construct a pseudo multi-parallel corpus of the new and the original languages
by pivoting through English, and imitate the output distribution of the
original MNMT model. Extensive experiments show that our approach significantly
improves the translation performance between the new and the original
languages, without severe catastrophic forgetting. We also demonstrate that our
approach is capable of solving copy and off-target problems, which are two
common issues existence in current large-scale MNMT models.
|
[
-0.2905937433,
-0.5498569608,
0.4152846634,
0.3061818779,
-0.3248790801,
0.2787548602,
-0.2433887124,
-0.3797935247,
0.6658769846,
0.4887080193,
-0.3576524556,
-0.1996514946,
-0.8093918562,
0.304553926,
-0.3971620798,
0.7439030409,
-0.2851442993,
0.2832779586,
-0.0061794072,
-0.2672037482,
-0.4530440569,
-0.6744608879,
-0.8324805498,
-0.2127325833,
0.6478841305,
0.4242977798,
0.492288053,
0.6342134476,
0.2290045023,
0.3697802722,
0.1765201837,
0.6577336192,
-0.3052014112,
-0.0972113535,
-0.326807946,
-0.6027688384,
-0.3397359252,
-0.0787144378,
0.9501162171,
0.6498556137,
0.0108529599,
0.0548865721,
0.1871712059,
0.5955711603,
-0.3449243605,
0.3207260668,
-0.8038543463,
0.0657968521,
0.1112648994,
-0.3575096428,
-0.4697420895,
-0.0825308636,
0.0129842563,
-0.5597154498,
0.0222579241,
0.0647071302,
0.4055335224,
-0.0206150115,
-0.3300639689,
-0.27888152,
-0.7313410044,
0.6712098718,
-0.4796836972,
0.2365525663,
0.1506451815,
0.5031992197,
-0.0920132101,
-0.6922896504,
-0.5985250473,
-0.2838618159,
0.0031747709,
0.2124658674,
0.0132596409,
-0.4950766861,
-0.0484102555,
0.1775715798,
-0.503482461,
0.0645445734,
-0.4044624567,
-0.0545275323,
0.2856159806,
0.1263307929,
0.1977615952,
0.0873596892,
-0.6146454215,
-0.2189753652,
-0.6080936193,
-0.1648715436,
0.25908494,
0.2739814818,
0.0713505596,
0.352527976,
0.1513668746,
0.3539973199,
-0.2681979537,
0.1163154468,
0.4129027724,
-0.2261164337,
0.0810199082,
0.0547695868,
0.6848068237,
0.3100798428,
0.3420789838,
-0.2008722425,
-0.2080588341,
-0.3129005432,
0.2085105032,
-0.5565976501,
-0.0917513222,
-0.061636325,
-0.4697028399,
0.0817970559,
-0.0930343196,
-0.4765727818,
-0.0542018302,
-0.5056669116,
0.626550734,
-0.7524988055,
-0.6044684052,
-0.0039144806,
0.0607710183,
0.0731969178,
0.2102570385,
-0.701177001,
0.2467158735,
0.5009010434,
0.939707756,
-0.2369503081,
-1.1770119667,
-0.4673869908,
0.320700109,
-0.4521226287,
0.6853111982,
-0.3610686362,
-0.2572113872,
-0.2411625832,
0.2384099364,
-0.4092475474,
-0.6969292164,
0.178225264,
-0.4310389459,
0.1898511052,
-0.0919278935,
-0.3799752891,
-0.5776175261,
0.5125041008,
-0.5126743913,
0.7922293544,
0.0481995717,
-0.3838474154,
0.0360212065,
-0.6477519274,
-0.5215745568,
-0.1940047294,
-0.07686463,
-0.4587504864,
0.2609721124,
0.3286838233,
0.5171517134,
-0.1995034516,
0.0989835188,
-0.2287391126,
-0.3940168619,
0.1716345251,
-0.718221128,
0.650930047,
0.1344221681,
-0.1836946905,
0.050792288,
-0.5556910038,
0.0103335856,
0.1233459562,
-0.1861159503,
-0.4381248951,
-0.149655506,
0.1377440244,
0.5132367611,
0.3575415909,
-0.471314162,
0.2841286063,
-0.2645128965,
0.413220644,
0.6493489742,
-0.0135856513,
0.394534409,
-0.5517533422,
0.5645239353,
0.325014472,
0.0579836033,
-0.5450402498,
-0.573621273,
-0.6764473319,
-0.4334348142,
0.3471662402,
0.7265843153,
-0.9672279358,
0.0190814864,
-0.5488495231,
-0.2527219057,
-0.7456903458,
0.2975257337,
0.4838593602,
0.2935736477,
0.6269500852,
-0.3308179975,
-0.7776793838,
-1.1147350073,
-0.2593593001,
0.0128589449,
0.0729626343,
0.0612665191,
0.4961588979,
-0.2314171791,
0.5249468088,
-0.0349578299,
-0.4717420042,
-0.2975837588,
0.2103550881,
0.2619453371,
0.844599247,
0.5960557461,
-0.8737604022,
-0.8729468584,
0.4186664522,
-0.8004022837,
0.2223640382,
-0.4527941942,
-0.1493095309,
0.2259767205,
0.7570558786,
-0.6172469258,
0.0197064281,
0.6396352053,
0.176338926,
0.622015059,
-0.6015836,
0.4048417807,
-1.5529140234,
0.0426348634,
-0.4546054006,
-0.3077735007,
-0.3457769454,
0.2595463693,
0.2527316213,
0.0501361042,
-0.7992715836,
0.58880198,
-0.5739002824,
0.0227738973,
-0.5176612735,
-0.1283135265,
-0.2249434888,
0.5895900726,
0.0919089988,
0.7201212645,
0.5352279544,
-0.4813139737,
0.1527663022,
0.092931062,
-0.2252694815,
0.4844174385,
-0.2606170177,
-0.0074008573,
-0.1738364846,
0.0787935108,
-0.7205932736,
-0.0292488541,
0.1302903742,
-0.7621273994,
0.5709863901,
-0.3027148843,
-0.7735218406,
-0.1902265102,
0.0290004518,
0.3579099476,
0.8011880517,
-0.5877026916,
0.8798250556,
0.0224704519,
-0.1153197661,
-0.5970237255,
-0.753151536,
0.531781137,
-0.155007422,
-0.2314026952,
0.3464016914,
0.0639158785,
0.0274148118,
0.0073072319,
0.102778919,
-0.232959792,
0.0635069758,
-0.1572647989,
-0.0264299307,
-0.3716402948,
-0.1654346734,
0.2145466655,
-0.2894293964,
-0.0188620556,
-0.7372160554,
0.5690057278,
-0.0264038946,
-0.4269269407,
-0.4139516354,
0.7743167877,
0.8971440196,
-0.401601553,
0.8163660765,
0.6958292127,
-0.3431971967,
-0.2121607214,
-0.3615282774,
-0.1694096923,
-0.4481596053,
0.7650434375,
-0.7744333148,
-0.4386586845,
0.3607816696,
-0.2295024246,
0.1964723319,
0.3102969527,
0.7089973092,
-0.3087055981,
1.1304750443,
0.7569474578,
-0.108696714,
0.4041913152,
-0.2060292959,
-0.0534421466,
-0.7851181626,
0.001840698,
-0.1039407626,
-0.5213617086,
-0.3883222044,
-0.6731368899,
0.3734664619,
0.1329936981,
0.2004194707,
0.7683058381,
-0.1329081059,
0.6263529658,
0.8730261922,
0.194588691,
0.2815841436,
0.1464872509,
-0.5013796687,
-0.0315637849,
-0.9350368381,
-0.4360666871,
1.1484360695,
0.0154108275,
0.1435590088,
0.1179611161,
0.7480818629,
0.0057871784,
0.6662811041,
-0.4179198742,
0.4294232726,
-0.4179192185,
-0.3443740904,
-0.0487334281,
-0.4506917298,
-0.8839473128,
0.6183944345,
-0.0120022763,
-0.2703619301,
-0.3592841327,
0.4420888424,
0.1125644222,
0.6755120754,
-0.8231395483,
0.6754907966,
-0.280271709,
-0.3154824972,
-0.556849122,
-0.5872415304,
0.3707096577,
-0.4209349453,
0.337672621,
0.0387879275,
-0.0598846562,
0.2196048647,
-0.2269995958,
0.8133425117,
-0.17870076,
0.1171711683,
0.1470419765,
0.1700881571,
0.5522785783,
-0.1413617432,
-0.1454804838,
0.2302883118,
-0.1181938574,
-0.5988820791,
-0.631636858,
0.7597799897,
-0.3776966333,
-0.4233176708,
-0.0617309846,
-0.8015192151,
-0.2114921808,
0.3960522115,
0.1337988079,
-0.0220651962,
-0.1400337666,
0.0380265228,
0.4598055184,
-0.257181704,
0.4046144783,
0.6694686413,
-0.3052355349,
-0.5959868431,
1.0871219635,
0.2289236039,
0.2874390185,
0.7596657872,
0.2777161002,
-0.2296021283,
-0.6078116894,
-0.8461097479,
0.1285315305,
-0.471895963,
0.1187466308,
-0.8905750513,
0.1244923398,
-0.2497224659,
-0.1630677134,
-0.6091325879,
-0.5924798846,
0.0694517866,
0.1579166949,
0.1371691227,
0.3122764528,
-0.1585731357,
0.2565805316,
-1.035112977,
0.1804222763,
0.0720602721,
0.1235186756,
0.1431828439,
-0.6959170699,
-0.5576927066,
0.0972411186,
-0.2676176727,
-0.5795392394,
0.5279896259,
0.2874623239,
0.8526769876,
0.1451433748,
-0.1876548082,
0.7831674814,
-1.1308270693,
0.3546325564,
0.1967509836,
-0.6642628908,
-0.0528461561,
-0.3177283704,
0.5025217533,
0.4109998643,
0.6067914367,
-0.6960787177,
-0.5844552517,
-0.2961906493,
-0.6055884957,
0.3017479479,
0.1625362635,
0.3378776014,
-0.1136387065,
0.2216590643,
0.3426194489,
0.2050007582,
-0.7776469588,
-0.2438680828,
-0.1702776402,
-0.4027011395,
-0.4985953271,
0.0458934084,
0.3045050204,
-0.2555372417,
0.7057542205,
-0.1782947779,
0.3254395723,
0.0269349813,
-0.4254996181,
0.2171958685,
-0.062008556,
0.7123391032,
0.370446682,
0.1159305423,
0.3363805413,
0.3462991714,
-0.3397471607,
0.2016181201,
0.1614063978,
-0.1765317321,
0.1488763839,
0.2166956365,
0.4876199663,
0.3907288313,
-0.663754046,
0.3126509488,
0.3654209673,
-0.4608087242,
-0.4680146277,
-0.3286018968,
0.405565083,
0.280420512,
0.3199004829,
0.458201319,
-0.0558995754,
-0.4085738063,
0.5520047545,
0.3070985377,
-0.3213638067,
-0.4163493812,
0.8244585991,
-0.1387798786,
-0.5293885469,
0.4612335563,
-0.2044187784,
-0.8230415583,
0.7397864461,
0.8016466498,
0.8060563803,
-0.5090895891,
-0.0359956436,
0.469712168,
0.7472366691,
-0.3225940764,
0.2214640379,
0.1211800054,
-0.5126059651,
-0.6767063141,
-0.3379923999,
-0.4277262986,
-0.095408462,
-0.4883898497,
0.4150807858,
-0.2990565002,
0.3173691332,
-0.3484421372,
-0.6303970814,
-0.4697268605,
-0.0558834001,
-0.0989346355,
0.8787394762,
-0.7607939243,
1.2524877787,
0.8172591329,
-0.3515552878,
-0.3667100072,
-0.1379232556,
-0.1951258332,
-0.9982780218,
0.380822897,
0.3674916327,
-0.1313479245,
0.2620177865,
-0.123632513,
-0.840683043,
0.7938750982,
0.4984053671,
-0.3201741278,
0.0341139026,
0.2719461322,
0.4861226678,
-0.3277594745,
0.087224029,
0.1689617932,
0.2562969923,
-0.0989585817,
-0.943215549,
-0.2297027409,
-0.3051116168,
-0.2142418921,
0.3735218644,
-0.6660219431,
0.8978794217,
-0.1190747172,
0.1676864177,
0.2790610194,
0.5761547089,
0.0278031714,
0.1616039723,
0.4378281534,
0.3415515721,
0.3234604597,
0.3683697283,
0.8505046964,
-0.4245652556,
0.1419433206,
1.4381346703,
-0.0932658389,
1.0865300894,
0.7816201448,
0.0782969072,
0.2987377942,
0.4017423987,
-0.0809069276,
0.4914541543,
-0.0323956944,
-0.2321826369,
-0.1320309043,
0.2560268044,
-0.2037036866,
0.4047143757,
0.3956357837,
-0.6798301339,
-0.2264076769,
0.4082279801,
-0.0302446671,
0.3481839895,
-0.2867728174,
0.4418346584,
0.1207023263,
-0.716309011,
0.7209498286,
0.2291309834,
0.6736867428,
-0.6446892023,
-0.227801919,
-0.2886026502,
0.3407495916,
0.2789525688,
-0.3079791963,
0.6788413525,
-0.2474860102,
-0.2821450233,
-0.5531618595,
0.104925245,
-0.7690811157,
-0.6821255684,
0.3516178727,
0.666600287,
0.4302318096,
-0.2501438856,
-0.6952416897,
-0.4905217886,
0.1000024751,
0.030344883,
0.4223119318,
0.3915271759,
-0.2446308136,
0.663318336,
0.6128181815,
0.0872028768,
0.4050551057,
-0.3762833178,
0.36146909,
-0.4742646515,
-0.5585382581,
-0.8490422964,
0.3814681768,
0.01516644,
-0.2051171511,
0.9198418856,
0.7416478992,
1.0063716173,
-0.4349983037,
0.7153613567,
0.2669808865,
0.726200223,
-0.6161801219,
0.7452372909,
-0.7293959856,
0.019778531,
-0.2788421214,
-1.044544816,
-0.3652133644,
0.4758510292,
0.0523220152,
-0.2151960582,
0.8879191279,
0.7518529892,
-0.5081173778,
-0.279520601,
0.6742398143,
0.2845472991,
0.1987357736,
0.8363304138,
0.7646251321,
-0.3805761933,
0.7571077943,
-0.2802954316,
-0.3127423227,
0.0483084954,
-0.8793876767,
-0.8322020769,
-0.5543531179,
-0.1239636764,
-0.1296132803,
-0.0861035883,
1.1471265554,
0.7334930301,
-0.7941280603,
-0.2973183393,
-0.0890984386,
-0.018441068,
-0.7853652239,
-0.0857310668,
0.3704496026,
-0.4010120332,
-1.2151367664,
0.6429687142,
0.2833532393,
0.2434630245,
-0.3126889765,
-0.0302318707,
-0.2886174321,
-0.1009049043,
0.7560521364,
0.3432195783,
-0.5739862323,
0.0835975707,
0.1094096899,
0.1225775629,
0.2040266097,
0.7760920525,
-0.5912670493,
0.4813039303,
0.0819146186,
1.077658534,
0.5720116496,
-0.4285758734,
0.8103330731,
-0.714212954,
0.3036427796,
0.0749624148,
0.4709253609,
0.3023110032,
-0.0323806591,
0.2301443368,
0.3686310351,
-0.0557525717,
-0.5903787613,
0.3545747101,
-0.53849262,
-0.485068351,
0.8414526582,
-0.3112018406,
-0.0944231823,
-0.1480222344,
-0.2877036035,
0.1520494074,
0.1068870351,
0.7823188305,
0.5702337027,
0.1615161449,
-0.2703296244,
-0.7130938768,
-0.0078226002,
0.7999902368,
-0.4895650148,
-0.087473385,
0.1138687208,
0.3034113348,
0.0630801991,
0.4024982452,
-0.3225483894,
0.3739205003,
0.0450404882,
0.2527431548,
-0.3212789297,
-0.4548579156,
-0.3877028525,
0.1575188637,
-0.0288081039,
-0.5637023449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08533v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08533v1
|
Natural Language Processing for Financial Regulation
| 2023-11-14T20:58:21 | 2023-11-14T20:58:21 |
Ixandra Achitouv, Dragos Gorduza, Antoine Jacquier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.CP
|
This article provides an understanding of Natural Language Processing
techniques in the framework of financial regulation, more specifically in order
to perform semantic matching search between rules and policy when no dataset is
available for supervised learning. We outline how to outperform simple
pre-trained sentences-transformer models using freely available resources and
explain the mathematical concepts behind the key building blocks of Natural
Language Processing.
|
[
-0.3685800433,
-0.9538729787,
0.4172073007,
0.2621414065,
-0.0342826024,
-0.0274511669,
-0.1398192495,
-0.8107920885,
-0.1471811384,
1.3284827471,
-0.7234084606,
-0.3249785006,
-0.3334333003,
0.2687733471,
-0.6582022309,
1.0401940346,
-0.196722284,
0.0585896224,
-0.1254386008,
0.4677427411,
-0.3944528997,
-0.2852482796,
-0.7961066961,
-0.5450258851,
0.070489876,
0.2791909277,
0.764339745,
0.731092155,
0.9278975129,
0.4238980114,
-0.0819501951,
-0.1769800484,
-0.1429878473,
-0.1724613011,
-0.1311300993,
-0.3628134131,
-0.2080467045,
0.3782503307,
0.3294944167,
0.5077819824,
-0.1693730652,
0.0077841198,
-0.0785978287,
0.8414674401,
-0.5203934908,
0.6257538795,
-0.3186816573,
0.1484707892,
-0.1190257519,
-0.5683466196,
-0.5106371641,
-0.7182718515,
0.6943943501,
-0.8162344098,
0.6485583782,
0.2969192266,
1.1219331026,
0.2714111805,
-0.7345855236,
-0.7883947492,
-0.8083359599,
0.4275443554,
-0.4099615216,
0.3138783872,
0.7671841383,
0.6318731308,
-0.2278866023,
-0.944159925,
-0.4263551831,
-0.1992469132,
-0.6831115484,
-0.1291707307,
-0.2870717347,
0.6747367978,
0.3309169114,
0.8327844739,
-0.1851368695,
-0.1823082715,
-0.6129431725,
-0.4674421847,
0.5524063706,
-0.1831771582,
-0.0457297266,
-0.309355408,
-0.1814238876,
-0.1971203089,
-0.3033247292,
0.1849719286,
0.4620600343,
0.5153819323,
-0.0514056571,
0.568071723,
-0.4110710025,
1.0423215628,
-0.1089346558,
-0.1572496593,
-0.0042244559,
-0.6134867072,
-0.5990805626,
0.3019329309,
0.4171544909,
0.1992651224,
0.2999587655,
-0.2810304463,
-0.4828992486,
-0.068912223,
0.4137283564,
-0.6229543686,
-0.0466634557,
-0.1631210595,
-0.4722854495,
-0.2435737401,
0.3274310529,
-0.8384228945,
-0.003354284,
-0.9409484863,
0.3058628738,
-0.1284763962,
0.1567890346,
0.5641365051,
-0.6066729426,
0.7260764241,
-0.2434320152,
-1.0882161856,
1.0424461365,
0.8259020448,
0.5861744881,
0.5000276566,
0.2406249791,
-0.5764656067,
0.0258944258,
-0.0457135402,
0.7966485023,
-0.4052242935,
-0.2618134022,
0.2286755741,
0.0769199505,
-0.207341373,
-0.3585517406,
0.8795075417,
-0.7382407188,
0.4748547971,
0.0710848719,
-0.8625224233,
-0.4002912045,
0.0287598483,
-0.9483612776,
0.5624047518,
0.1733613759,
-0.5790408254,
0.5595763326,
-1.3351023197,
-0.7873751521,
-0.0721599087,
0.3051615655,
-0.2384976894,
-0.1175823063,
0.1901054084,
0.243776232,
-0.4517072141,
0.3307321072,
-0.0672726482,
-0.2147640437,
0.2889646888,
-0.3986014426,
0.5776762366,
0.0963143185,
-0.3642494678,
0.5127597451,
-0.9275721312,
-0.1621276289,
-0.0502317622,
-0.2989113331,
-0.3026922643,
0.2242285609,
0.6418291926,
0.1097517908,
0.1983914673,
-0.431342721,
-0.1745168567,
-0.8047683239,
0.7728444338,
0.4044255614,
0.0467839763,
0.8393157721,
-0.4208878875,
0.3492844105,
-0.5418431759,
0.3675414622,
-0.0582254119,
-0.1356128454,
-0.6389309764,
0.019389322,
0.2106932253,
0.81654495,
-0.4490168989,
0.4471261203,
0.0843192413,
-0.3891542852,
-0.8860444427,
0.2816690803,
0.1073481664,
0.5589174628,
0.3592124581,
0.3177290559,
-0.9160637856,
-1.1924062967,
-0.4682253003,
0.4084522724,
-0.0735353008,
-0.0478341244,
0.311224997,
-0.1222893372,
1.2543451786,
-0.5673030019,
-0.8707553148,
-0.3638377786,
0.3681670129,
0.5082009435,
0.2351551503,
0.5473560691,
-1.3071527481,
-0.1935497075,
0.1286767721,
-0.4424049854,
0.0523820929,
-0.279073596,
0.0605517104,
0.2462763488,
0.7220280766,
-0.4240984619,
0.6755617857,
0.3191740513,
-0.5708526373,
-0.1888897568,
-0.412686497,
-0.0012137152,
-0.7381731272,
-0.0503984988,
0.268848896,
-0.4398265183,
-0.8365107775,
0.0022237543,
-0.086845167,
0.0630035028,
-0.23768875,
0.4036652744,
-0.357673049,
-0.0808171481,
-0.5790210962,
0.1759737879,
0.0287851747,
0.160403505,
0.1844541878,
0.6862556338,
0.6012009978,
-0.75823915,
0.6110354662,
0.4023455679,
-0.4121953845,
0.4828534722,
-0.6196607947,
-0.30300349,
-0.2683755457,
0.148184821,
-0.6773912311,
-0.4819715619,
0.2757228315,
0.1261378527,
0.1187925786,
-0.0249854587,
-0.5119110942,
-0.6448692083,
0.1205828339,
-0.0680244938,
0.4459623098,
-0.350017935,
0.7472183108,
0.3507759869,
0.1109864861,
-0.2700868547,
-0.5853450894,
-0.124858655,
-0.242574662,
-0.4304629862,
0.4362764955,
0.2499480546,
-0.3321070075,
0.2706707418,
-0.0235625245,
-0.3437698781,
0.384806633,
0.1521873027,
0.4982875586,
-0.3732370138,
-0.0767003,
-0.2689037323,
-0.3403022289,
0.3144925535,
-0.3241866827,
0.3372692466,
-0.1027190313,
0.0192049053,
-0.4776583314,
0.2685602009,
0.2833018601,
-0.1692389995,
0.6441461444,
0.332960546,
-0.3956003785,
0.0457060337,
-0.5560883284,
-0.014652011,
-0.5749287605,
-0.1211383119,
-0.2279949486,
-1.1526916027,
0.4988027811,
0.3666707575,
0.136681512,
0.7972211242,
0.3302898109,
0.2322786152,
0.6079429388,
1.0103846788,
0.0719944537,
0.5853323936,
0.3379235864,
0.5171761513,
0.0004809187,
-0.2862833142,
-0.7133085728,
-0.1138378531,
-0.9992004633,
0.0419963375,
-0.2247224152,
0.0044150893,
-0.0393218473,
0.7925175428,
-0.5037282109,
0.922416389,
0.8751273155,
-0.2434522063,
0.3183898032,
-0.1970764548,
0.0353488624,
0.2247679979,
-0.3214126527,
-0.4900315702,
0.7055780888,
0.3484845459,
0.9552724957,
-0.2464778572,
0.3306355178,
0.2675488293,
0.2738094926,
-0.8705928326,
0.3176505566,
-0.2103735805,
-0.6031958461,
-0.3720568717,
-0.7531957626,
-0.8249042034,
-0.283554256,
-0.481500566,
-0.3539579809,
0.016147539,
0.0332080647,
-0.4546414316,
0.233018443,
-0.6324367523,
0.9803217649,
-0.0484874472,
0.3459530473,
-0.1874612272,
-0.621314764,
0.4403538406,
-0.1542210132,
0.3408106565,
-0.2093300521,
0.3721247017,
0.6909536719,
-0.3408233225,
0.7046199441,
0.0357289873,
-0.1889956146,
0.4145389795,
-0.2428356856,
0.1499527693,
-0.0175645985,
0.2395118326,
-0.2323741168,
0.4602663517,
-0.260665834,
-0.3447471857,
0.1915446967,
-0.3668277264,
-0.205889523,
-0.4544896185,
-0.412764132,
-0.0400026068,
0.3364498019,
0.2278221697,
-0.0758866519,
-0.4431026876,
0.1398366839,
0.2701271176,
0.3245426714,
0.5833741426,
0.6563126445,
-0.2875284851,
-0.2868390381,
0.636644721,
-0.1162938401,
-0.0756320506,
0.8851847053,
0.184189707,
-0.7206138968,
-0.0447453149,
0.2617267966,
0.0845582187,
-0.7182506323,
-0.3363650739,
-0.3234799802,
-0.6274018884,
-0.6883336306,
-0.1363431662,
0.017422745,
-0.1244494021,
-0.3964609504,
-0.3785773516,
0.690644443,
1.1719713211,
-0.1628693342,
0.6032975316,
-0.8863114715,
0.6137922406,
0.3296917081,
0.9515261054,
-0.4967502356,
-0.1161932349,
-0.208093375,
0.0676793903,
-0.0273277164,
-0.5459039211,
0.3036959171,
0.3548403382,
0.4420835078,
0.4279466271,
0.1339077204,
0.7506443262,
-0.3389648795,
0.1126176193,
0.0458802357,
-1.2000727654,
0.7898904085,
-0.0224629957,
-0.0468186773,
0.6559714079,
0.2832371294,
-0.8042871356,
-0.2781732976,
-0.4067544043,
-0.7605293989,
0.8336207271,
0.213710919,
0.2161580026,
-0.1241253465,
0.3803637326,
-0.0764174983,
0.3022959232,
-0.5994355083,
0.1184930578,
-0.139195919,
-0.0664978549,
-0.1587017179,
-0.0857138559,
-0.0816032067,
-0.2222385108,
0.4970488846,
-0.1719722003,
0.0571028553,
0.2034918964,
0.1493924409,
-0.2354110479,
0.4015698731,
0.6433899999,
0.3898884058,
-0.428635329,
-0.2731493711,
-0.2822008729,
-0.2686768472,
-0.0806351081,
0.5057132244,
-0.1580424309,
0.0502044633,
0.2697181106,
0.943649292,
0.8357480168,
-0.9111118317,
0.5463263988,
-0.3641846478,
-0.7554161549,
-0.6231517792,
0.196930021,
-0.1879838556,
0.1945938319,
0.392668575,
0.3169436157,
0.3737716675,
-0.4549227357,
0.7033494711,
0.1810806096,
-0.6873782873,
-0.1101387814,
0.8782986403,
0.1034034789,
-0.3343641758,
0.9656937122,
0.0768070444,
-0.2204193771,
0.4657985568,
0.6052126288,
0.9569029808,
0.2064971179,
0.3705854416,
0.0291323494,
0.2268954068,
-0.5978583097,
0.3489177227,
-0.079435572,
-0.5179490447,
-0.8693036437,
-0.7889794707,
-0.401350379,
-0.1261907965,
-1.0490128994,
0.4309583306,
-0.6206375957,
-0.1568424404,
0.3177520037,
-0.2128299922,
-0.7711890936,
0.0435131006,
0.2419308275,
1.4285726547,
-0.6571342945,
0.4752283692,
0.2978104949,
-0.3913826346,
-0.6817187071,
-0.3880717456,
-0.0095356386,
-0.6158539057,
0.482503444,
0.2311411202,
0.0416334011,
-0.1791297197,
-0.4388179779,
-0.5752258897,
0.7371691465,
0.4039115012,
-0.3554649353,
-0.5240594745,
0.3971895874,
0.6063962579,
-0.1290509403,
-0.2489501834,
1.1973353624,
0.6946747899,
0.4654973745,
-0.9419543147,
-0.4067375958,
-0.2596509457,
-0.4620637298,
0.6979632378,
0.0021758433,
0.693062067,
0.281991899,
-0.289896816,
0.0645413175,
0.5929314494,
-0.4858668745,
0.3614766598,
0.2861666083,
0.2939325571,
0.6629484296,
-0.4908516407,
1.2381818295,
-0.296608597,
0.5845162868,
0.9596214294,
-0.267709583,
0.8809785247,
0.3464244604,
-0.0028388407,
0.3363598585,
0.6191079021,
-0.2336389869,
0.3862550855,
0.2021976262,
-0.0525778458,
-0.112266086,
-0.3396555781,
0.2871204913,
0.7685166597,
0.0250095446,
-0.4123109281,
-0.4870190918,
0.1431622952,
-0.3142752051,
0.4177940786,
-0.4736536145,
1.1633872986,
0.0788075551,
-0.5951331258,
-0.2022252381,
0.1094324961,
0.588193059,
-0.8826400042,
-0.1064758897,
0.133981213,
0.0576687194,
-0.1552168131,
-0.9242690206,
1.0244632959,
0.0006891369,
-0.3992038965,
-0.8820657134,
0.7131722569,
-0.3177277148,
-0.4633277357,
0.5100974441,
0.150541231,
-0.3079057038,
-0.1607470214,
-0.4598077238,
-0.7358863354,
-0.3160698414,
-0.1210463941,
0.1142948493,
0.3600459397,
0.1644893438,
0.5316519737,
0.8491398692,
0.0370372646,
0.02864323,
0.0268704928,
0.478518635,
-1.0599396229,
-0.7995215654,
-0.8662381768,
-0.1107597351,
-0.1351440251,
-0.2987391055,
0.4485370517,
0.6010869145,
1.0968818665,
-0.2450249493,
0.5110455751,
0.0854592174,
0.5334578156,
-0.8640818,
0.70270437,
-0.0739150643,
-0.063951984,
0.0802303255,
-0.8475348949,
-0.6803311706,
0.7529191375,
-0.4029164016,
-0.4192997217,
0.3654605448,
0.5029286146,
-0.1555027068,
0.6215376258,
0.1248260438,
-0.1804211438,
0.0912472084,
0.1082422733,
0.4721519947,
-0.3199754953,
0.6724333167,
-0.3118136525,
0.3476475179,
-0.1364454776,
-0.8094028234,
-0.8482064605,
-0.465470314,
-0.0571057014,
-0.2039908916,
-0.4865852594,
1.083763957,
0.4834395945,
-0.9959117174,
-0.5682297945,
-0.5210545063,
0.2047658861,
-0.3486817181,
-0.3053846359,
0.0657748133,
-0.6934185624,
-0.5140374303,
0.3863174915,
0.3823877573,
0.4097889066,
0.0164104532,
0.002448671,
-0.1058756188,
0.2625879645,
0.3383054435,
0.3417979181,
-0.5950881243,
-0.1679308712,
0.0325795598,
-0.1862017363,
0.0944781974,
1.2522073984,
-0.5822660327,
0.239846319,
0.5146839619,
0.866047442,
0.2836262882,
-0.1060842648,
0.7339806557,
-0.5970877409,
0.0661410913,
0.1379306614,
0.2980364859,
0.0526708178,
-0.2726612389,
0.5752837658,
-0.0071436623,
-0.388866514,
-0.3273701072,
0.1345123053,
-0.9265807271,
-0.0588287637,
0.5850242972,
0.2886666358,
-0.5757708549,
-0.2481084615,
-0.4763891101,
0.2357922941,
-0.3005643487,
0.505725801,
0.7535067201,
-0.0324195884,
-0.1735010147,
-0.8198950887,
0.918112278,
-0.2803566754,
-0.8219153285,
0.1075462624,
0.2690488696,
0.0404525213,
0.1186170578,
0.5109131336,
0.1356136054,
0.1931937933,
-0.115949221,
-0.2256738991,
0.1308583915,
0.0529224984,
-0.4318406582,
0.24259758,
-0.3094698489,
0.0384580903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08526v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08526v1
|
GLiNER: Generalist Model for Named Entity Recognition using Bidirectional Transformer
| 2023-11-14T20:39:12 | 2023-11-14T20:39:12 |
Urchade Zaratiana, Nadi Tomeh, Pierre Holat, Thierry Charnois
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is essential in various Natural Language
Processing (NLP) applications. Traditional NER models are effective but limited
to a set of predefined entity types. In contrast, Large Language Models (LLMs)
can extract arbitrary entities through natural language instructions, offering
greater flexibility. However, their size and cost, particularly for those
accessed via APIs like ChatGPT, make them impractical in resource-limited
scenarios. In this paper, we introduce a compact NER model trained to identify
any type of entity. Leveraging a bidirectional transformer encoder, our model,
GLiNER, facilitates parallel entity extraction, an advantage over the slow
sequential token generation of LLMs. Through comprehensive testing, GLiNER
demonstrate strong performance, outperforming both ChatGPT and fine-tuned LLMs
in zero-shot evaluations on various NER benchmarks.
|
[
-0.2118175775,
-0.5012090802,
0.4820260406,
0.1002705172,
-0.5453276038,
0.1044672728,
-0.3308036625,
-0.692371726,
0.4924226403,
0.6354497075,
-0.188301459,
-0.2930738628,
-0.7962193489,
0.2265488803,
-0.6890252829,
1.0619707108,
-0.0242745895,
0.0004097913,
0.0054323557,
-0.1430029422,
-0.3710612059,
-0.5793991685,
-1.1244549751,
-0.2015518099,
0.6173921227,
0.1920063496,
0.6897213459,
0.4153512716,
0.7501478195,
0.3173751831,
-0.2263945788,
-0.0479633249,
-0.0844551176,
0.1079941839,
-0.1943139881,
-0.4109787941,
-0.4044516981,
-0.3969260454,
0.9279252887,
0.6289530993,
-0.3255599439,
0.0938096792,
0.2058350742,
0.3739870787,
-0.5707017779,
0.2178816944,
-0.8573983908,
-0.1725355387,
-0.2736180127,
0.3577558398,
-0.5001561642,
-0.3875036836,
0.3525902927,
-0.3877837956,
0.5427163243,
0.2731265724,
1.3484563828,
0.2304702401,
-0.4671242237,
-0.5660759211,
-0.9666131139,
0.787084043,
-0.5941582918,
0.6712729335,
-0.2932921946,
0.5427245498,
-0.0658582076,
-1.0350421667,
-0.8242768049,
-0.1886423081,
-0.449635148,
-0.1132125407,
-0.2379208207,
0.2226769626,
0.2986753881,
0.4362653196,
-0.5997962356,
0.2407085896,
-0.1890987307,
-0.1972732395,
0.2545159161,
0.2007259279,
0.4444002509,
-0.4028626382,
-0.5770376325,
0.1928960532,
-0.5315476656,
0.1743558645,
0.3908345699,
0.4532783031,
0.0263247639,
0.432035476,
-0.0580282956,
0.5106341243,
0.2191818208,
-0.1137174964,
0.0123695275,
0.0554168262,
-0.3624078333,
0.0179891065,
0.8873768449,
0.0179222804,
0.2101780772,
-0.5154477358,
-0.3799466789,
-0.1216445342,
0.2170802355,
-1.0851054192,
-0.2448470891,
0.1033869013,
-0.3652951121,
-0.0562975556,
-0.0239485987,
-0.9453001022,
-0.243137449,
-0.5579071045,
0.1825276911,
-0.3172985017,
-0.2313661426,
0.2484542876,
-0.0440624729,
0.6090683341,
0.3844714463,
-1.0473198891,
0.536442399,
0.7099001408,
0.8104530573,
-0.2728106678,
0.1100475639,
-0.4917784631,
0.2488469481,
-0.0379165411,
0.9677534699,
-0.6615026593,
-0.4545856118,
-0.1195794716,
0.305641681,
-0.4354813993,
-0.6322720647,
0.7763364315,
-0.782987833,
0.2778576612,
0.0510483086,
-0.5134387016,
-0.3281134367,
0.1464197934,
-0.9244309068,
0.5495664477,
-0.2028809041,
-0.8966225982,
0.3232855797,
-0.5559301972,
-0.2875111401,
0.5383890271,
-0.3613827229,
-0.4356374443,
0.1083752215,
0.2305231988,
0.2748572528,
-0.8246618509,
0.7175782919,
-0.1080471054,
-0.3189481795,
-0.0391347073,
-0.4358179569,
0.6814035177,
-0.1131147519,
-0.1957671046,
-0.0489345826,
-0.7257184982,
-0.0941079855,
0.2415716201,
-0.6258670092,
-0.346513778,
0.1124194935,
0.356097877,
-0.1639451534,
0.154844746,
-0.6496521235,
0.1770094633,
-0.4742090702,
0.3948754668,
0.398747772,
-0.025085438,
0.5475298762,
0.0870988965,
0.3319467604,
0.0008809403,
0.02298126,
0.1591632515,
-0.3010995984,
-1.2936569452,
-0.6036990285,
0.8024876714,
0.7002078891,
-0.634780705,
0.2041154206,
-0.6172955036,
-0.3876271248,
-0.506994009,
0.0526803136,
0.2105750442,
0.519934237,
0.5512458682,
-0.3815972209,
-0.6079405546,
-1.2724291086,
-0.3751659095,
-0.0812980682,
-0.4884539247,
0.6896184087,
0.4542807639,
-0.4786830842,
1.0100729465,
-0.4082997739,
-0.3475116789,
-0.4922861457,
0.2003509104,
0.4924770892,
0.3284562826,
0.2481748164,
-1.0080875158,
-0.521396637,
0.0164264515,
-0.7103846669,
0.1585633159,
-0.1856874973,
-0.0134936143,
0.0531406105,
0.4224166572,
-1.039837122,
0.1333152205,
0.3109743893,
0.0209434219,
0.4939639866,
-0.003215496,
-0.2874886692,
-1.01932621,
0.2516517937,
-0.0069919042,
-0.2621589005,
-0.7240245938,
-0.0381851234,
0.3420164883,
-0.2881123126,
-0.4199385643,
0.6074796915,
-0.7588410974,
0.0806212127,
-0.1633740067,
0.1199507266,
-0.0216710716,
0.4183438718,
0.3011874557,
0.6925941706,
0.4617269635,
-0.4979741573,
0.3908464909,
0.1485485137,
-0.199875474,
0.5614674091,
-1.0694330931,
0.3938549161,
-0.3916973174,
0.224764958,
-0.6715314984,
-0.2936286032,
0.3049962223,
0.0205122624,
0.7596830726,
-0.5414065123,
-0.3297322989,
-0.4796822965,
0.3049316108,
0.3485709429,
0.5262511969,
-0.6839333177,
1.1258894205,
0.3824667037,
-0.4098870456,
-0.562710464,
-0.2956523001,
0.2841698527,
-0.3146150708,
-0.2866344154,
0.563090682,
0.2986325324,
0.1156478897,
0.0374214649,
-0.0178524647,
-0.3192012012,
-0.2512152493,
0.2840847671,
0.6389837265,
-0.3293325901,
0.3139910102,
-0.1762096882,
-0.4067341685,
-0.0244377647,
-0.3161854744,
0.4827738106,
-0.2710060477,
-0.1464629024,
-0.4573590755,
0.3999942839,
0.5123181939,
-0.3300485015,
0.5779892206,
0.346002996,
-0.4478250444,
0.00472889,
-0.6796976924,
0.073823154,
-0.4910269976,
0.2311029285,
-0.3742527962,
-0.9514662623,
0.2616705894,
-0.2616092861,
-0.1378553808,
0.4529624879,
0.1811906397,
0.2530477047,
0.6402318478,
0.9019048214,
-0.3016250134,
0.2257879972,
-0.0776825994,
0.6089667678,
-0.8814979196,
-0.0634817332,
-0.7043958902,
-0.260648787,
-0.6638185978,
-0.3414102793,
-0.0801497102,
0.2145874202,
-0.1419121772,
0.7990009785,
-0.5772219896,
0.7995994687,
0.5075195432,
-0.1565521806,
0.2851445079,
-0.298132062,
-0.2705817521,
0.0082368571,
-0.0686528981,
-0.7994903326,
0.9100838304,
0.2600549459,
0.6292280555,
0.205583334,
0.8542891741,
-0.0062795212,
0.4432082176,
-0.8295763731,
0.782389164,
-0.3096945286,
-0.6305668354,
-0.2365499884,
-0.2826290429,
-0.8927423954,
0.3166428506,
-0.033545576,
-0.8786670566,
0.4033519626,
-0.0557009466,
-0.4216645658,
0.4884427488,
-0.5826489925,
0.7242357135,
-0.1498008668,
0.070424743,
0.0603241734,
-0.4829135835,
0.2098338008,
-0.1792170256,
-0.0506853648,
-0.1323092282,
-0.0280941147,
0.5887612104,
0.0502981357,
0.6101778746,
-0.3595426083,
0.2620081902,
0.2188011408,
0.0584334284,
0.7535898685,
0.1122300923,
0.1940377057,
0.4966933429,
-0.3811415136,
-0.1449660063,
-0.4900316,
0.5974404812,
-0.4659251869,
-0.6709554791,
-0.1022719964,
-0.3410062492,
0.0426771976,
0.3922076523,
0.2702734768,
0.425572902,
-0.2690382898,
0.2294043005,
0.5159678459,
-0.3031383157,
0.7275065184,
0.4716897905,
-0.1878753006,
-0.4694373608,
0.8076907396,
0.0805091485,
0.0305274986,
0.580771327,
-0.2747753859,
-0.4543498456,
-0.5169224739,
-0.5389096737,
0.4073955715,
-0.4547908306,
-0.2705479264,
-1.0368657112,
-0.4748828709,
-0.0610719137,
-0.0327780694,
-0.4265437424,
-0.4482780397,
-0.2331927121,
0.1712452322,
-0.1636964381,
0.6073675752,
0.2228862047,
0.2732155323,
-0.6814672947,
0.4578310549,
0.7287529707,
0.2728133798,
-0.0545947254,
-0.3534392118,
0.1543136984,
-0.2479456663,
-0.1982419789,
-0.8722558022,
0.3891005516,
0.3015244007,
0.5008898973,
0.4442448616,
-0.1016903296,
0.5084186792,
-0.8281446099,
0.5123198032,
0.2797226906,
-0.9152721167,
0.3637386858,
-0.0970051959,
-0.1487260014,
0.2407493591,
0.5705333948,
-0.5747068524,
-0.1207813174,
-0.5302333236,
-1.043361187,
0.3678860366,
0.0167245921,
0.2140203416,
-0.1538237035,
0.2359751016,
-0.0327627733,
0.2534562945,
-0.92383039,
0.0572739951,
0.0583121441,
-0.2022393942,
-0.0801532939,
-0.5450223088,
0.2200012654,
0.0367272533,
0.4751889408,
-0.0866798684,
0.4553538263,
0.2489516288,
-0.3302870393,
0.1908458322,
0.7337764502,
0.1645755321,
-0.0106253996,
-0.1678091139,
0.1134514511,
0.3274425566,
-0.4987772107,
0.0885182098,
0.4849309623,
-0.4315116107,
0.4011804461,
0.0821958035,
0.8235010505,
0.4227854908,
-0.3502227068,
0.5935562253,
-0.2903898954,
0.0123398723,
-0.3501244783,
0.0027701335,
0.2528122663,
0.407748431,
0.1925103366,
0.014383615,
0.4649036527,
0.0427587815,
0.0330796726,
0.6064863205,
-0.4345488846,
-0.2812479436,
0.8938851953,
0.1836461425,
-0.5562580228,
0.9770742655,
-0.1996399611,
-0.4334515631,
0.5158053637,
0.5694925785,
1.4755649567,
-0.141207546,
0.1013189405,
0.5781760216,
0.1960688978,
-0.0106056109,
-0.2034116089,
-0.0948056951,
-0.778100431,
-0.3617002964,
-1.084123373,
-0.7104744315,
0.0311482474,
-0.8201753497,
0.5141838193,
-0.4135539532,
-0.1997401863,
0.3818417788,
-0.3321437836,
-0.996344924,
-0.0818315521,
0.3794411421,
0.7360789776,
-0.4574307501,
0.9332621694,
0.6123477817,
-0.3440973759,
-0.8917344809,
0.0807649419,
-0.1719815135,
-0.5654575825,
0.9001852274,
0.5789273977,
-0.007904876,
0.1604723781,
-0.2729239464,
-0.8962002993,
1.0478187799,
0.3173752129,
-1.0338119268,
-0.4857771695,
0.3734394014,
0.4749432802,
-0.3633634448,
0.5190708637,
0.4203825891,
0.2602960467,
0.0915849283,
-1.1242046356,
0.1352874041,
-0.096207656,
0.3178856671,
0.4569473565,
-0.4634951651,
1.0521935225,
-0.3430181444,
-0.7741423845,
-0.0130636599,
0.5210909247,
-0.1073692515,
-0.1199743673,
0.6988332272,
0.6873838902,
0.8861051202,
-0.1023864001,
0.7703262568,
-0.1640467197,
0.5332258344,
1.2001563311,
-0.5781702995,
0.9912641644,
0.4306989908,
-0.0662598163,
0.8249168992,
0.0974416286,
-0.1191767976,
0.5629823804,
0.1475345641,
-0.4275440872,
-0.3005675077,
-0.1743838787,
-0.176946193,
0.4653998613,
0.1797231287,
-0.3187396526,
-0.5020235777,
-0.1897647679,
0.0777732059,
-0.3572167158,
-0.1835551709,
0.8984421492,
0.0294157416,
-0.3911109567,
0.500374496,
0.0426827818,
0.6943301558,
-0.408973217,
-0.0009148407,
-0.1294657588,
0.4199538827,
0.1334632188,
-0.4463025928,
0.2872806489,
0.0501146875,
-0.3201449811,
-0.0387291871,
1.051697135,
-0.431263417,
-0.4126863778,
0.585447073,
0.2992948592,
0.1071083993,
-0.2121555507,
-0.5101999044,
-0.3872952163,
-0.1636740118,
-0.2599834204,
0.2113984823,
0.3859943449,
0.1350924373,
0.6295257211,
0.7375177145,
0.1020020843,
-0.0925475284,
0.1082110479,
0.875831306,
-0.9374534488,
-0.3325547576,
-0.8954306245,
0.4684709609,
-0.2586051226,
-0.0929878578,
0.3555814326,
0.6159200668,
0.6892704964,
-0.1987024397,
0.5693395138,
-0.034530431,
0.7973738313,
-0.3705463409,
0.5561538339,
-0.2292040884,
0.1347646266,
-0.1092798188,
-0.9354727268,
-0.3721008301,
0.2295046449,
-0.3511849642,
-0.3957997262,
0.6608570218,
0.7787627578,
-0.1257587373,
0.2163110673,
0.2088590115,
0.0469529778,
0.4812768996,
0.6993088126,
0.7851855755,
-0.45402354,
0.7176862359,
-0.0419532172,
-0.0329716429,
-0.1035827398,
-0.7979571819,
-0.9373964071,
-0.2410927415,
-0.1183734238,
0.1205981821,
0.0832897648,
0.7087986469,
0.4691666961,
-0.9137030244,
0.0070570279,
-0.1744170636,
0.073701404,
0.1753500253,
-0.2432639897,
0.3464318812,
-0.4825899005,
-0.9990589023,
0.1781228334,
0.4060290456,
0.202091068,
0.1692477167,
0.091233328,
0.1487433314,
0.1360237896,
0.2713213563,
0.2846250236,
-0.8537756801,
-0.4375314116,
-0.0436469838,
-0.2311786264,
-0.0197317544,
0.677967906,
-0.6894147992,
0.1475882083,
0.080062896,
0.6596894264,
0.2958522737,
-0.1240767837,
0.2541441917,
-0.3693684638,
0.1756206602,
0.3422249556,
0.6944662929,
0.339525193,
-0.2773086727,
0.3841004968,
0.370980978,
-0.7764108181,
-0.6855578423,
0.120424889,
-0.8869184852,
0.1523323804,
1.0834735632,
-0.0989550576,
-0.0584272444,
-0.1858361512,
-0.268067956,
0.0661595389,
-0.2404748946,
0.460378468,
0.4272120595,
0.1404442638,
-0.088017568,
-0.5906823277,
0.25556916,
0.1377966404,
-0.5763602257,
0.008727992,
0.3108697534,
0.4297756553,
0.3058174253,
0.6043152809,
-0.1497368366,
-0.141855523,
-0.0048767314,
0.4511026442,
0.3347330689,
-0.6458858252,
-0.2433332503,
0.3175523281,
-0.0227395874,
-0.3924137056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08516v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08516v3
|
LLMs cannot find reasoning errors, but can correct them given the error location
| 2023-11-14T20:12:38 | 2024-06-04T10:25:13 |
Gladys Tyen, Hassan Mansoor, Victor Cărbune, Peter Chen, Tony Mak
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While self-correction has shown promise in improving LLM outputs in terms of
style and quality (e.g. Chen et al., 2023b; Madaan et al., 2023), recent
attempts to self-correct logical or reasoning errors often cause correct
answers to become incorrect, resulting in worse performances overall (Huang et
al., 2023). In this paper, we show that poor self-correction performance stems
from LLMs' inability to find logical mistakes, rather than their ability to
correct a known mistake. Firstly, we benchmark several state-of-the-art LLMs on
their mistake-finding ability and demonstrate that they generally struggle with
the task, even in highly objective, unambiguous cases. Secondly, we test the
correction abilities of LLMs -- separately from mistake finding -- using a
backtracking setup that feeds ground truth mistake location information to the
model. We show that this boosts downstream task performance across our 5
reasoning tasks, indicating that LLMs' correction abilities are robust.
Finally, we show that it is possible to obtain mistake location information
without ground truth labels or in-domain training data. We train a small
classifier with out-of-domain data, which exhibits stronger mistake-finding
performance than prompting a large model. We release our dataset of
LLM-generated logical mistakes, BIG-Bench Mistake, to enable further research
into locating LLM reasoning mistakes.
|
[
0.0861115009,
-0.6804831624,
0.9581023455,
0.0286812596,
0.1424878538,
-0.104017593,
0.0359606408,
-0.3171958923,
-0.0103047378,
0.4334169924,
-0.7596861124,
-0.36961326,
-0.7981866598,
0.2861065567,
-0.1605258733,
0.6230739355,
-0.1297836155,
0.1732367277,
-0.4222959578,
-0.2295375615,
-0.955267787,
-0.7974177599,
-0.4518184066,
-0.3169733882,
0.4392386079,
0.7517127395,
0.4189688563,
0.758857131,
0.5727539062,
0.358956486,
0.0505775772,
0.7017573714,
-0.5681943297,
-0.091667071,
-0.6837262511,
-0.7804256082,
-0.6049879193,
0.1549137533,
0.530612886,
0.2757906318,
-0.1141166463,
-0.0263335295,
-0.1073020324,
0.9496722817,
-0.5996513367,
0.1158539504,
-0.7097454667,
0.0608385392,
-0.3514472544,
-0.5115820765,
-0.4432471693,
-0.3627339602,
-0.2859085798,
-0.4012500346,
0.5864633322,
0.105261296,
0.6470887065,
1.0652287006,
-0.1944745481,
-0.4787606597,
-0.7395111918,
0.671908319,
-0.8809843063,
0.1894808114,
0.2785619199,
0.2632082105,
-0.4306437373,
-0.1816299409,
-0.4448023736,
0.2358648181,
-0.1133846417,
0.146489948,
0.039766781,
-0.1383511126,
0.6354281306,
0.048369877,
-0.1685058326,
0.1129134819,
-0.0414407142,
-0.3838549852,
0.689032495,
0.3356061578,
0.0793550014,
-0.0792348385,
-0.2911995649,
-0.1333377659,
-0.9045875072,
0.068260923,
0.2766894996,
0.2226820588,
0.5258507133,
0.7709038258,
-0.1111465394,
0.6754577756,
0.3150927424,
-0.6990099549,
-0.0199238192,
-0.2592143118,
-0.267629534,
0.2564649582,
0.3634543121,
0.3601385355,
0.025520768,
0.0861706734,
-0.5685813427,
-0.0855487287,
0.2384390384,
-0.2821417451,
-0.3769601583,
0.1832570434,
-0.0750485733,
0.043644391,
-0.1502364725,
-0.1270025671,
-0.6762909293,
-0.5049866438,
0.6589983702,
-0.4347497523,
0.3828350008,
0.2323430032,
-0.1602586508,
0.0272498876,
0.7752256989,
-0.5233427882,
-0.1598903984,
0.4321829081,
0.4839922488,
-0.1104089543,
-0.5903865099,
-0.5357439518,
0.2003012002,
-0.5879547596,
1.157536149,
0.0154033415,
-0.2132009715,
-0.3645152748,
-0.0291159246,
-0.3934001625,
-1.0432509184,
0.6682642698,
-0.4108096659,
-0.1420917809,
-0.8243651986,
-0.6477404237,
-0.2607600987,
0.1463206708,
-0.3744950891,
0.8499474525,
-0.124306567,
-0.7669506073,
0.2285989821,
-0.2311730087,
-0.3176032305,
-0.4220865965,
-0.2144727409,
-0.5134493113,
0.1510721594,
0.2890067101,
0.5268746614,
0.0366576687,
0.2062763423,
-0.203278482,
-0.6859052777,
0.5027267933,
-0.3468209207,
0.7024080753,
-0.2262152433,
-0.5407807231,
-0.2077056617,
-0.836361587,
-0.1550527364,
0.3588893414,
-0.500110209,
-0.1932254434,
0.3256836534,
-0.907951057,
0.4258190095,
0.264870882,
-0.4693524837,
0.2728495598,
0.065820016,
0.1696905345,
1.0139381886,
-0.192967236,
0.2274258137,
-0.5020517111,
0.1682095379,
0.4568845928,
-0.0835261568,
-0.0930248722,
-0.3153669536,
-1.0953561068,
-0.0101983706,
0.0849404261,
0.9777701497,
-0.6071606874,
0.2238824517,
-0.0212846957,
-0.4406988919,
-0.4775291681,
0.4072504938,
0.5131501555,
1.2076810598,
0.5285797119,
0.0778262541,
-0.5200905204,
-0.6639024615,
-0.6689646244,
-0.175704062,
0.3833028078,
0.286347568,
0.4872139692,
-0.4253071249,
0.9184035063,
-0.3531778753,
-0.5937451124,
0.1092673689,
-0.0571656413,
0.0727541149,
0.3844459951,
0.1194740236,
-0.3004258871,
0.1424311548,
-0.4693492949,
-1.0696669817,
-0.3313981593,
-0.1066963673,
-0.0065544411,
0.5661381483,
0.3971872926,
-0.6325474381,
0.5483703613,
0.2478625774,
-0.2822555304,
0.8312273622,
-0.3507303298,
0.1331151426,
-0.4491529167,
-0.3365868032,
-0.0274721421,
-0.1184085011,
-0.2454389036,
-0.3501523435,
0.2711209953,
0.4442819357,
-0.2798233628,
0.3246538639,
-0.3918440044,
-0.2867286503,
-0.2762418091,
0.327514708,
0.046211876,
0.4578666091,
-0.1495838463,
0.8479594588,
0.2036780566,
-0.657986939,
0.4643636048,
0.2655688226,
-0.0726607144,
0.826543808,
-0.2684392631,
0.1462040991,
-0.1659271866,
0.355984807,
-0.9789311886,
-0.4326741099,
0.3879558146,
-0.4661593735,
0.461104095,
-0.1213072091,
-0.5974008441,
-0.2638342679,
-0.0630854666,
0.2521516383,
0.249995172,
-0.850774169,
0.3248083293,
0.0661899298,
-0.0400351845,
-1.0259399414,
-0.9125653505,
-0.0865095034,
-0.0580769219,
-0.8013250828,
0.0071189869,
-0.0756539553,
-0.3111172616,
-0.0237600394,
-0.4632562995,
0.2544318438,
0.0256149918,
0.2257908434,
0.0663717538,
-0.0725341141,
0.4337091744,
-0.3061297536,
-0.3073833883,
0.3455168307,
-0.2272348255,
-0.1209569871,
-0.3259111047,
-0.709481895,
-0.3751021624,
-0.1140350997,
0.2586973906,
0.046101287,
0.3549041152,
0.0355783626,
-0.3905534744,
-0.2730662227,
-0.9891399145,
-0.0674626231,
-0.4364906549,
0.1174027324,
-0.2723219097,
-0.6388059855,
0.3904194534,
-0.0917146578,
-0.0603643097,
0.6112440228,
0.2374998331,
-0.6667402387,
0.975132525,
0.4167695343,
0.274720341,
-0.1709115952,
-0.2432682961,
0.2803820968,
-0.8469236493,
-0.3303731978,
-0.4341030419,
-0.3317011297,
-0.4193603098,
-0.6531011462,
0.291136533,
0.272295475,
-0.3708234727,
0.0785471797,
-0.3622728288,
0.4487725198,
0.7957842946,
0.2520347536,
0.6148912907,
-0.1351581514,
-0.1537043154,
-0.4238039851,
-1.061850071,
-0.5715957284,
0.8555806875,
0.3045756519,
1.0366319418,
-0.0141191343,
0.8154421449,
0.0783812553,
0.3064350188,
-0.6611822844,
0.5182017684,
-0.0108201103,
-0.4486208856,
-0.3238746524,
-0.5053226352,
-0.465280503,
0.0511238575,
0.1127367169,
-0.2216723561,
0.2618189156,
0.6757609844,
-0.2178604752,
0.717389822,
-0.7181289196,
0.7898718715,
-0.6512052417,
-0.369597435,
0.0167931095,
-0.5832484365,
0.4153388441,
-0.2635917068,
0.2708717883,
-0.3471005559,
0.1110366583,
0.3914309442,
-0.6321573853,
0.947378993,
-0.3601276577,
-0.2719402909,
0.3495407999,
0.4031508565,
0.7423695922,
-0.0935366005,
0.0220146868,
0.2791481018,
-0.432126224,
-0.3619299233,
-0.8335157037,
0.6668023467,
-0.8156249523,
-1.1030644178,
-0.6873818636,
-0.4596200883,
-0.4236955643,
0.0657380521,
0.5326421261,
0.2946082354,
0.3323684335,
-0.3319030404,
0.9223313928,
-0.1302510798,
0.3725749254,
0.5576511025,
0.2269986123,
-0.0919695795,
0.988956213,
0.6794217229,
0.0147199444,
0.1228283942,
0.0861565024,
-0.481272608,
-0.6276512146,
-0.4414331913,
0.4912421405,
-1.2109310627,
-0.4458966851,
-0.4539978206,
-0.1532007754,
-0.11230959,
-0.2732948065,
-0.5570736527,
-0.3766146302,
-0.3931916654,
-0.1465937942,
0.1070411131,
0.8528268933,
-0.4376968741,
0.0806481019,
-0.7180095315,
-0.0223709382,
0.4331146777,
0.2743956745,
-0.1288825125,
-0.6421043277,
-0.1121875495,
0.1304913163,
-0.4860135317,
-0.7966305614,
0.2377307266,
-0.207579419,
0.4744858146,
-0.0057769669,
-0.0855432749,
0.9205989242,
-0.4441963434,
0.5786128044,
0.0160303619,
-0.8770216107,
0.9707522988,
-0.1587537229,
0.17946513,
0.1857137531,
0.0535253473,
-0.1524163336,
-0.2111448497,
-0.6404157281,
-0.343161881,
0.913400352,
-0.012616531,
-0.4344320297,
0.0012517159,
0.6588670611,
-0.1729771346,
-0.0715833008,
-0.738380909,
-0.4106110632,
-0.3079911172,
0.1402387768,
-0.2558006942,
-0.3619947433,
-0.2665687501,
-0.3037990332,
1.0104854107,
-0.2888765335,
0.5304188132,
0.8753428459,
-0.2239933014,
-0.5522315502,
0.1092941016,
0.7559574246,
0.7557336092,
-0.1507123411,
0.2424537838,
0.5194895267,
0.1230036095,
0.3792198002,
0.0130722309,
-0.1244047806,
-0.0063905427,
0.3876694143,
0.3674055934,
0.1355584115,
-0.6308021545,
0.6098300815,
-0.0128112817,
-0.0889722556,
-0.4571863711,
0.197557196,
0.2484412491,
0.4698511958,
0.305796802,
0.5928318501,
0.1109823287,
-0.3075762689,
0.0411300547,
0.2942625582,
-0.0441101715,
0.0417094417,
0.773124218,
-0.0785830915,
-0.3769960105,
0.7485200763,
-0.2872401178,
-0.5505221486,
0.6067342162,
0.611461997,
0.5996519923,
-0.1967249364,
0.048646152,
0.3326386809,
0.3920570016,
-0.3014837205,
0.1634775847,
0.2641330063,
-0.9522431493,
-0.5775117278,
-0.0359770805,
-0.564837873,
-0.0822425708,
-0.2385035157,
0.1092994586,
-0.585097909,
-0.1677638292,
-0.4457027018,
-0.1268333644,
-0.6475630999,
0.5776192546,
0.0777038261,
0.7223566771,
-0.3250881433,
0.5344355106,
0.7419785261,
-0.0369847156,
-0.9681931734,
-0.059025839,
0.2223986536,
-0.9064170718,
0.7803572416,
0.278265506,
-0.4506479204,
-0.2870693803,
-0.7359458804,
-0.9619750977,
1.410790801,
0.4901290536,
-0.7779310942,
-0.1041648909,
0.1754668802,
0.5300726891,
-0.0893189609,
0.0301891305,
0.4397464097,
0.334764868,
0.2035145462,
-0.6698540449,
0.1005724072,
0.1057733074,
-0.081392087,
0.0444853567,
-1.0379757881,
0.9136726856,
-0.7059770823,
-0.0499614999,
-0.2792333961,
0.4610010684,
0.5444526076,
0.5422987342,
0.2275200188,
1.0136164427,
1.0790952444,
-0.4454239309,
0.9434992075,
0.1090549603,
0.3230223358,
1.3159958124,
-0.2154742181,
0.6601247787,
0.3035896719,
0.1333363503,
0.4178302884,
0.6297333837,
0.0238042772,
0.3026348352,
-0.0196795333,
0.1082300842,
-0.5461348295,
0.4691886902,
-0.0951552242,
0.2313691229,
0.4516018927,
-0.2195059359,
-0.1690269262,
-0.4243116379,
0.0000776927,
0.1318079084,
-0.4328866899,
0.4093497992,
0.1010103002,
-0.8544440269,
0.7000916004,
0.0892172232,
0.601888299,
-0.0879398286,
-0.1947287321,
-0.5652852058,
0.4714853764,
-0.5032527447,
-0.8220754862,
0.4243984818,
-0.2219065875,
-0.2482342422,
-0.2581910491,
1.1573734283,
0.0061424109,
-0.1928814799,
0.3047064245,
0.7512236238,
0.0410268456,
-0.0828447044,
-0.6696389914,
-0.0794647262,
-0.0049271779,
-0.1142852083,
0.129985854,
0.6599188447,
0.0625531748,
1.0349622965,
0.4838188589,
-0.1002421305,
0.2751204371,
-0.2542356849,
0.3854923844,
-1.0596852303,
0.0212795045,
-0.8434963226,
0.4185331166,
0.1462102234,
-0.3989805877,
0.8172869086,
0.3575848043,
1.2165254354,
-0.2120175809,
0.9315873981,
0.3398249745,
0.897756815,
-0.7163923979,
0.0170160383,
-0.591018796,
0.6696045995,
-0.0642178506,
-0.7055025101,
-0.2094355524,
0.7932572365,
-0.4640916586,
-0.0204658564,
0.7480367422,
0.9051362872,
0.2000835389,
-0.1204762012,
0.3853600323,
0.6303032041,
0.187428534,
0.7721063495,
1.1883046627,
-0.6099203825,
0.3277638555,
-0.5050513744,
-0.0557417013,
-0.4081021547,
-0.7231511474,
-0.8530859947,
-0.2069639564,
-0.4673083425,
-0.5845673084,
0.2377250791,
0.6486579776,
0.3626749814,
-0.6665351391,
0.0874117911,
-0.1946059316,
0.5371707082,
-0.2668670416,
-0.1848234385,
0.1428276151,
-0.5583022237,
-0.4028866887,
0.6578241587,
0.412445724,
0.2107666284,
-0.040491797,
-0.2429351062,
0.0449225381,
0.1257187426,
0.3844679892,
0.3199006617,
-0.909768641,
-0.5004602671,
0.1971675009,
-0.4312804043,
0.3506723344,
0.6790559292,
-0.7375164628,
0.3967174292,
0.1970948875,
0.6495186687,
0.147981897,
-0.0067344112,
0.3013105392,
-0.6835219264,
-0.6099969149,
0.184033066,
0.6302369237,
0.5842154026,
-0.6947905421,
0.8040137291,
0.7402677536,
-0.9934026599,
-0.5048177242,
-0.0164267588,
-0.6859226227,
-0.1729606092,
1.0842347145,
-0.2319072187,
-0.0361236297,
-0.0133195277,
-0.4800286293,
0.2451349199,
0.0133709293,
0.9973663688,
0.9183393121,
-0.5997239947,
0.0107310321,
-0.5099093914,
0.5490798354,
0.7201100588,
-0.605720222,
0.0453648083,
0.7771779895,
0.7563313246,
0.2845739722,
0.6226544976,
-0.1179910153,
0.5411058664,
-0.0937379748,
-0.1019301713,
0.0404182486,
-0.4076636136,
-0.4717249572,
-0.2181645185,
0.203352645,
0.0910759196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08511v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08511v1
|
CoRE-CoG: Conversational Recommendation of Entities using Constrained Generation
| 2023-11-14T20:07:34 | 2023-11-14T20:07:34 |
Harshvardhan Srivastava, Kanav Pruthi, Soumen Chakrabarti, Mausam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
End-to-end conversational recommendation systems (CRS) generate responses by
leveraging both dialog history and a knowledge base (KB). A CRS mainly faces
three key challenges: (1) at each turn, it must decide if recommending a KB
entity is appropriate; if so, it must identify the most relevant KB entity to
recommend; and finally, it must recommend the entity in a fluent utterance that
is consistent with the conversation history. Recent CRSs do not pay sufficient
attention to these desiderata, often generating unfluent responses or not
recommending (relevant) entities at the right turn. We introduce a new CRS we
call CoRE-CoG. CoRE-CoG addresses the limitations in prior systems by
implementing (1) a recommendation trigger that decides if the system utterance
should include an entity, (2) a type pruning module that improves the relevance
of recommended entities, and (3) a novel constrained response generator to make
recommendations while maintaining fluency. Together, these modules ensure
simultaneous accurate recommendation decisions and fluent system utterances.
Experiments with recent benchmarks show the superiority particularly on
conditional generation sub-tasks with close to 10 F1 and 4 Recall@1 percent
points gain over baselines.
|
[
-0.7342783809,
-0.7661170363,
0.248405084,
0.0455683097,
-0.3092622757,
0.1547440588,
-0.4874085784,
-0.4078029692,
0.2170302123,
0.5970927477,
-0.9756647944,
-0.4466499686,
-0.1186732277,
0.0303598214,
-0.2021613568,
1.1366107464,
0.4426710904,
-0.1632369906,
-0.4877027869,
-0.025032416,
-0.9412184358,
-0.5152616501,
-0.6847369671,
-0.5278596282,
0.1368610263,
0.9674699903,
0.7329900265,
0.1474707127,
0.4145102501,
0.2633096874,
0.0095934551,
0.2191012353,
-0.6298142672,
0.5356010795,
-0.1729751229,
-0.3351194263,
-0.4348433018,
-0.3966740072,
-0.1176472902,
0.7589755058,
-0.2916051745,
0.0573896542,
0.0814383551,
0.6467325091,
-0.6564241648,
0.1361709833,
-0.7652546167,
0.0052651823,
0.0951725692,
-0.0506140031,
-0.5539211035,
-0.2674234211,
0.8748110533,
-0.6900905371,
0.3826857507,
0.4643179774,
0.6778802276,
0.1596867591,
-0.2652649581,
-0.6685182452,
-0.7378864884,
0.7532352805,
-0.3832523823,
0.5442530513,
0.2043139786,
0.4103897512,
-0.2206343561,
-0.7198898792,
-0.3044736385,
-0.581330359,
-0.1832814813,
0.1092768312,
-0.2755390406,
0.2226231694,
0.1215286255,
0.5930710435,
-0.5150895715,
-0.1938543618,
-0.1404091418,
-0.5056523681,
0.3825884163,
0.1374024004,
0.1031118259,
-0.1117040142,
-0.4620369673,
0.1265203804,
-0.9006560445,
0.1038623825,
0.3145030141,
0.2471371144,
0.2624205351,
0.5385888219,
-0.3208996356,
0.7845050097,
0.9175816178,
0.0290762838,
-0.1374297738,
-0.2901749611,
-0.1904815733,
0.3464141786,
0.7152270675,
0.5645601749,
0.4843417406,
-0.3387167454,
0.0494596995,
0.1000347286,
0.2724220753,
-0.5896222591,
-0.3432943523,
-0.0102562597,
-0.0622796193,
-0.0530967005,
-0.1818428338,
-0.56784904,
-0.1565919518,
-0.266217351,
-0.1559295952,
-0.5846506357,
-0.1569945067,
0.0014175922,
-0.2013223469,
-0.1084642336,
0.0706665367,
-0.8872323036,
0.5603544116,
0.3835071921,
0.565877378,
-0.2657761872,
0.1845628023,
-0.2823870182,
0.4485811293,
-0.0613344014,
0.9412564039,
-0.7230116725,
-0.8699721694,
0.0968688503,
-0.1732985973,
0.2231913358,
-0.7712698579,
0.7687689066,
-0.4309599102,
0.0951059833,
-0.6309216619,
-0.6282299161,
-0.2020357251,
0.3391337991,
-0.2597570121,
0.8941002488,
0.3392005265,
-0.4784186482,
0.5423715711,
-0.2160382271,
-0.5776042342,
0.4327118695,
-0.3805480897,
-0.2712447047,
-0.1003562286,
0.1330410689,
0.3733941019,
-0.6422632337,
0.7156010866,
-0.4295735061,
-0.0769211128,
-0.1811479181,
0.0922612846,
0.1795046031,
0.2773268521,
-0.1863590777,
0.1998844147,
-0.7018780112,
0.1414844692,
-0.1013758257,
-0.0977826938,
-0.2103148699,
0.1191772968,
-0.3315441012,
-0.1804328263,
0.3863588274,
-0.4066815972,
0.027005421,
-0.2263520211,
0.7238647342,
0.3255938292,
0.3569330871,
0.806060195,
-0.4871657491,
0.4313906133,
0.0917861313,
-0.0131820254,
-0.4292017221,
-0.2982236445,
-1.0145320892,
0.1594188064,
-0.0626633316,
0.5801411271,
-0.7131472826,
0.8375499845,
-0.0837751031,
-0.5785669684,
0.237368077,
-0.087221697,
0.418879807,
0.6585855484,
0.428142637,
-0.3391922116,
-0.954666853,
-1.2156997919,
-0.1959632486,
-0.3869271874,
0.0613206737,
0.7446604371,
-0.012194464,
0.1187041774,
1.1260024309,
-0.5840519071,
-0.2944582105,
-0.3056598902,
-0.1267988086,
-0.0016165887,
0.4296087027,
0.347930938,
-0.5806515813,
-0.4035289586,
-0.1381848603,
-0.4394157827,
-0.1220892593,
-0.2412255704,
-0.039203871,
-0.1695652306,
0.3444477916,
-0.7411745787,
0.1013501808,
0.3545362055,
-0.057475891,
0.5709241629,
-0.0064541092,
-0.1214352176,
-0.8995162249,
-0.2180701792,
0.0487139262,
-0.1537001431,
-0.5745641589,
-0.1821189225,
-0.1964980662,
-0.2761677802,
-0.1281232238,
0.2172990739,
-0.5334898233,
0.0983608514,
-0.0976944715,
0.2341717929,
-0.1577139795,
0.8309546709,
0.0697145462,
0.617529273,
0.3536302745,
-1.0747406483,
0.421156764,
0.5675610304,
-0.2943543792,
0.8330929279,
-0.6992673278,
0.4654664397,
0.2774182856,
0.5725764036,
-0.6150907874,
-0.0358678214,
0.1831471026,
-0.3394099772,
0.1402040422,
-0.1579045802,
0.15517205,
-0.4696668983,
0.152666837,
0.2223696411,
0.3494336307,
-0.189967826,
0.6621765494,
0.3645738065,
-0.1537410319,
-0.5480446219,
-0.385554105,
0.1356324404,
0.1575811505,
-0.8545587659,
0.5799743533,
-0.3775099218,
-0.1298297048,
0.0974714011,
-0.2963066995,
0.1704347283,
-0.052339524,
0.5819112659,
0.1269616336,
-0.215445593,
0.005093093,
0.1790869087,
-0.0658575445,
-0.1385128796,
-0.6744356155,
0.7816164494,
-0.3564101756,
-0.3667415082,
-0.1693725139,
0.3092135191,
0.4264079332,
-0.1773939729,
0.1766025722,
0.5105890036,
-0.3199207485,
-0.1207947284,
-0.6887053251,
-0.2780004442,
-0.5173860788,
0.295440644,
-0.5471314788,
-1.2045773268,
0.3138461113,
-0.009311717,
0.0514489114,
0.358559072,
0.7710520029,
0.2375680506,
0.7498329878,
0.488127619,
0.0199175496,
0.5680059791,
-0.1425323486,
0.4114193618,
-0.8538194299,
-0.5106697083,
-0.505884409,
-0.2431612611,
-0.3154366016,
0.0260944329,
0.3154634535,
0.3748131096,
-0.117417641,
0.5739448071,
-0.6738146544,
0.1033860967,
0.7872787714,
0.1830387115,
0.2917919457,
-0.2060603052,
-0.3188675344,
0.1655080467,
-0.9089102745,
-0.3606404066,
0.8175699115,
-0.1574865282,
0.6081172228,
-0.0603573397,
0.4739014804,
0.4680754244,
0.2438701391,
-0.8334542513,
0.8264318109,
0.0911324918,
-0.6419427395,
-0.1236921996,
-0.0985678062,
-0.6874052286,
-0.2220981121,
-0.4812311232,
-0.5880424976,
0.3756156862,
0.5157655478,
-0.6421160102,
-0.0177466758,
-0.8429749608,
0.2977054119,
-0.0109440275,
-0.3967378438,
-0.2762916982,
-0.4617735147,
0.3795100749,
0.4064393342,
-0.221765995,
-0.157234624,
0.3474089801,
0.4466908872,
-0.3482518494,
0.6723628044,
-0.2361082435,
0.3141581118,
0.8995162249,
0.437223345,
0.8113350272,
0.3246909678,
0.1058306769,
-0.1195812598,
-0.0380243473,
-0.1253659129,
-0.4503782988,
0.8858427405,
-0.5818991065,
-1.0712826252,
0.0097858002,
-0.5527728796,
-0.4014419913,
0.2880606651,
0.5736756921,
0.3642378449,
-0.4980204701,
0.5112451911,
0.7012107968,
-0.1204705089,
0.2342922837,
0.3842377961,
-0.0316759385,
-0.6077782512,
0.738599658,
0.0310201962,
0.1031326652,
0.4294854403,
0.0906277224,
-0.1714171767,
-0.8239772916,
-0.6163390875,
-0.2423406094,
-0.3759872615,
-0.3240286708,
-0.860959053,
0.0113266129,
-0.6459866166,
-0.2620332837,
0.0072551873,
-0.4903407395,
-0.3609871268,
-0.1869345903,
0.2095648646,
0.6263493896,
0.1488947719,
0.3572035432,
-0.7967699766,
0.0939424336,
0.4635919333,
0.2161751837,
-0.1117117628,
-0.2122234255,
-0.2456869632,
-0.0019112218,
-0.5885311365,
-0.9567844272,
0.1328632236,
0.3064874709,
0.6142631769,
0.5688363314,
0.2573328614,
0.6878640652,
-0.5643399358,
0.9993034601,
0.4033817649,
-0.8241270781,
0.4104444087,
-0.5183463097,
0.2946476638,
0.6208776832,
0.1078396812,
-0.7815108299,
-0.2901342213,
-0.6955322027,
-0.7680835128,
0.339933902,
0.1479968578,
-0.0806073099,
-0.2989273965,
0.5594937205,
0.2090433389,
0.3565401137,
-0.1493109167,
-0.0917131975,
-0.2396144867,
-0.0889696255,
-0.0021076952,
-0.4113319814,
-0.0945819989,
0.3172350824,
0.7312099934,
-0.1854579747,
0.1086987108,
0.5212002397,
-0.3658649027,
-0.4586422145,
0.3003894687,
0.6418972611,
0.4434933662,
-0.0942261964,
-0.061032135,
0.3030608892,
-0.276863426,
-0.0718175471,
-0.2686255574,
-0.3580379486,
-0.1752176881,
0.0749359503,
0.9113582373,
0.398307234,
-0.6223086119,
0.1891446859,
-0.0220558587,
-0.2081260234,
-0.6624429822,
0.3499291837,
0.0510104783,
0.1344581991,
0.3819701374,
0.5442097783,
0.0965648144,
-0.4408552945,
0.2887561917,
0.4335276186,
-0.7472291589,
-0.4020811617,
0.2757105529,
0.6344825029,
-0.6241338253,
0.4190202057,
-0.2077141553,
-0.5996271968,
0.3814347386,
0.509447515,
0.8994675279,
-0.0562967584,
0.0606428869,
0.5217227936,
0.1898105145,
-0.0557552315,
-0.0624210276,
-0.3576046526,
-0.8925864697,
-0.0937344581,
-0.32877478,
-0.6707251072,
-0.0803417563,
-0.8548049927,
0.5212129354,
-0.7034595609,
-0.5099039674,
-0.3283936381,
0.0062232302,
-0.7910865545,
0.2897088826,
-0.01366386,
0.9126271009,
-0.4459834397,
0.3936378956,
0.5449804068,
-0.2072679102,
-0.6722932458,
-0.4478951395,
-0.1622965038,
-0.6217172742,
0.2210369259,
-0.2926006615,
-0.3094795048,
0.1255163997,
-0.3614108264,
-0.8018541932,
1.2749375105,
0.2625801861,
-0.965429306,
-0.2722267509,
-0.1275120676,
0.4631496668,
-0.7220441699,
0.3248013854,
0.5636209249,
0.4463142157,
0.1738967597,
-0.8510858417,
0.1282019168,
-0.0543009341,
-0.2680668533,
0.2375777066,
-0.9721531272,
0.6224367023,
-0.2866957486,
-0.3142977953,
0.2339795828,
0.8295714855,
0.3424625993,
0.3880292475,
0.8278181553,
0.6907608509,
0.6733435988,
-0.2495304644,
0.7810162902,
-0.5677813888,
0.1910544336,
1.3702710867,
-0.4683809578,
0.4441540837,
0.3104841411,
0.0457775965,
0.742166996,
0.8252347708,
-0.07374423,
0.3969534934,
0.1613909602,
-0.2676879764,
-0.5124512911,
-0.474711746,
-0.3524728119,
0.1621158868,
0.6041786671,
-0.1570281237,
-0.071943149,
-0.1229658127,
-0.0799287558,
0.0495078638,
-0.03960976,
0.9180711508,
0.0977576897,
-1.2024275064,
0.4567036331,
-0.274330169,
0.5039817095,
-0.6643126011,
-0.0071978248,
-0.2044172287,
0.083883822,
-0.258980006,
-0.2072725892,
0.0690517053,
-0.2033937275,
-0.4446211755,
-0.1102187783,
1.0247576237,
-0.4811801314,
-0.0933077186,
0.1764915586,
0.5419527292,
-0.2664700747,
-0.0175092611,
-0.5460076928,
-0.2591068447,
0.1824513674,
-0.1667040139,
0.0392433517,
0.3390649855,
-0.2263754755,
0.9245145917,
0.7165135741,
-0.1517707556,
0.0740815625,
-0.1167211533,
0.8074387312,
-0.5118309259,
-0.5805773735,
-0.3997114003,
0.0100076739,
-0.0339454748,
-0.436573714,
0.5786830187,
0.5636204481,
0.8288249373,
0.1328769922,
0.9356141686,
-0.345136553,
0.3564144969,
-0.2882109582,
0.178864345,
0.0421237983,
0.3964863718,
0.0721510947,
-0.9217244983,
0.1098073497,
0.0172535721,
-0.3821623027,
0.0640844107,
0.9081455469,
0.7760267258,
0.2880059183,
0.4711148143,
0.4429795742,
0.0998475179,
0.4057367742,
0.7780880928,
0.876100719,
-0.038292855,
0.9360452294,
-0.2073099017,
0.0302510522,
-0.3846343756,
-0.6024102569,
-0.856361568,
-0.4467944205,
-0.1833600998,
-0.4823879302,
0.1510681808,
1.1416661739,
0.8963281512,
-1.0158909559,
-0.2341783643,
-0.3543190956,
-0.0083289556,
-0.2012157887,
-0.1809186041,
0.0656742156,
-0.3531268537,
-0.6155228019,
0.5301401019,
0.36928913,
-0.0866040662,
-0.4177977741,
-0.12544927,
-0.0838434771,
-0.1070496067,
0.3705528975,
0.1821621805,
-0.7320918441,
-0.5598737597,
0.3417086899,
0.0652479976,
-0.0077073486,
1.6034816504,
-0.9670727849,
0.3067725003,
0.3007149994,
0.5167438388,
0.653454721,
-0.1752354205,
0.9398656487,
-0.6873298287,
0.0315374322,
0.5218285322,
0.3902757764,
0.3491927683,
-0.4943642616,
0.2562924623,
0.3839965165,
-0.6381214857,
-0.4774189293,
0.7470837831,
-1.1411232948,
0.0028024104,
1.0099967718,
-0.2339812815,
-0.0236655679,
-0.3412538469,
-0.3955403268,
0.3883053362,
-0.9039548039,
0.4293018579,
0.7873425484,
-0.281706512,
-0.0886037722,
-0.0692893788,
0.5010704994,
0.6354823709,
-0.2754979432,
-0.0248920061,
0.6824687123,
0.2074546367,
0.3411715031,
0.4600855708,
0.2556340992,
0.2007839531,
-0.0920226425,
0.0341393389,
-0.3345435858,
-0.3191834688,
0.2924593091,
0.445097059,
0.0362780355,
0.2172423452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08505v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08505v2
|
Semi-Structured Chain-of-Thought: Integrating Multiple Sources of Knowledge for Improved Language Model Reasoning
| 2023-11-14T19:53:53 | 2024-04-02T03:36:32 |
Xin Su, Tiep Le, Steven Bethard, Phillip Howard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An important open question in the use of large language models for
knowledge-intensive tasks is how to effectively integrate knowledge from three
sources: the model's parametric memory, external structured knowledge, and
external unstructured knowledge. Most existing prompting methods either rely on
one or two of these sources, or require repeatedly invoking large language
models to generate similar or identical content. In this work, we overcome
these limitations by introducing a novel semi-structured prompting approach
that seamlessly integrates the model's parametric memory with unstructured
knowledge from text documents and structured knowledge from knowledge graphs.
Experimental results on open-domain multi-hop question answering datasets
demonstrate that our prompting method significantly surpasses existing
techniques, even exceeding those that require fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.2324693948,
-1.2565865517,
1.0719282627,
0.1143573448,
-0.0917515531,
0.219491452,
-0.2060291767,
-0.1254773885,
-0.206672281,
0.4120739698,
-0.5287007093,
-0.3057793081,
0.0326655917,
0.0195690487,
-0.5957012177,
0.8702387214,
-0.2522083521,
-0.0890415907,
-0.3491183519,
-0.0642403662,
-0.5707105994,
-0.3116614521,
-0.5751504302,
-0.3359043896,
0.5170913935,
0.382384032,
0.5877689123,
0.3411788642,
-0.0503439009,
0.2189589143,
-0.1371125132,
0.5866196752,
-0.1240264922,
0.0940178111,
-0.4716695845,
-0.1979095638,
-0.2041178197,
-0.155420199,
0.8750125766,
0.9597958922,
-0.3663093746,
0.2810187042,
0.2806752622,
0.6480284929,
-0.5077816248,
0.0496222042,
-0.4981030226,
-0.2343381643,
-0.0744941682,
-0.5540658236,
-0.6747621894,
-0.2501932979,
0.2004710138,
-0.5113538504,
-0.1729327887,
0.1828321517,
0.4302443266,
0.1016609818,
-0.325212568,
-0.2393372655,
-0.818593502,
0.6154362559,
-0.4891634285,
0.4132457078,
0.3748657107,
0.1023327857,
-0.0918170288,
-0.7814937234,
-0.7136999369,
-0.0238897707,
0.1684680879,
0.0172561966,
-0.1245580167,
0.0315908939,
0.2619574368,
0.0820609853,
-0.400283277,
-0.2694763541,
-0.5888367295,
-0.0336632691,
0.2458823472,
-0.0217326265,
0.3527559042,
-0.0632252917,
-0.4203989506,
0.0714188591,
-0.5299675465,
0.0515843704,
0.4236844182,
0.5924803615,
0.0515808538,
0.5461064577,
-0.3241160214,
1.3202770948,
-0.1653546393,
0.0975172445,
-0.0645096228,
-0.5767681003,
-0.1870260388,
-0.0178329162,
0.7758628726,
0.3073886931,
0.5013468862,
-0.0381226018,
-0.0106351608,
-0.2426809222,
0.1781765521,
-0.2158486992,
-0.4394215047,
0.358851105,
-0.4464259148,
-0.1443725526,
-0.0532784872,
-0.9154131413,
-0.2163520157,
-0.2072159052,
0.4476543367,
-0.438971132,
-0.0715437457,
0.3254946768,
-0.4214675426,
-0.145723477,
0.3200235963,
-0.7239888906,
0.0999309868,
0.2114886194,
0.798502028,
0.1441741288,
-0.4194220901,
-0.6290753484,
0.657796979,
-0.1696832776,
1.115249753,
-0.8641069531,
-0.0487102605,
0.216160953,
-0.2949101329,
-0.0093880007,
-0.2722058296,
0.1502092034,
-0.6579472423,
0.5014864802,
-0.3882592916,
-0.529574573,
-0.2096740454,
0.4398725331,
-0.5668045282,
1.4995414019,
0.3266614974,
-0.7534359097,
0.0868421197,
-0.5601407886,
-0.4551092386,
0.1340218186,
-0.24194327,
0.2692782879,
-0.0555929244,
0.4758530855,
0.4270075262,
-0.4962290823,
0.5657219291,
-0.4446796477,
0.013290152,
0.1639738977,
-0.301751852,
0.7028750777,
0.0746271014,
0.1454748064,
0.0256708525,
-0.8148725033,
0.1620955616,
0.0511596948,
-0.5720841885,
-0.7540544868,
-0.075881727,
-0.3799166977,
0.349922806,
0.3643906116,
-0.3712791204,
0.410009861,
-0.217097342,
0.7293865085,
0.7375196218,
0.4514842927,
0.472284317,
-0.3096797764,
0.3919003308,
0.1363793761,
0.0660101548,
-0.38543275,
-0.5830128193,
-0.5300148726,
0.2518410087,
0.0217270125,
0.3227462769,
-1.0432087183,
0.1128278375,
0.1415183544,
-0.1625310034,
-0.3223121464,
0.2832257748,
0.2467715293,
0.9018787742,
0.6098406911,
0.3012325764,
-0.5409424305,
-0.5633425713,
-0.3122347891,
-0.4704507887,
-0.1132802814,
0.1266163439,
0.3626669645,
0.3063296974,
0.808142364,
-0.5621279478,
0.2895766199,
-0.4260047376,
0.2143633664,
0.247561276,
0.327830106,
0.145423606,
-0.4772847295,
-0.4763636887,
-0.1442550421,
-0.666529119,
0.0268423781,
-0.3154117763,
-0.3445939124,
-0.3053417504,
0.6506920457,
-0.4761319458,
-0.0017316682,
0.4017519653,
-0.1579451412,
0.4832881093,
-0.412024498,
0.0183150303,
-1.3355336189,
0.1461939067,
-0.0608606376,
-0.0116900513,
-0.7201110125,
-0.1944126189,
0.2554151118,
-0.1699161232,
-0.3587486148,
0.6311849356,
-0.631346941,
0.1672275364,
-0.0594769493,
0.2557448447,
0.2198675275,
0.594360888,
0.0360720977,
0.8453714252,
0.7378225923,
-0.9473481774,
0.4831545949,
0.4875012338,
-0.3485110998,
0.4454278648,
-0.6263747811,
0.3284274936,
-0.2274586558,
0.283461988,
-0.91161412,
-0.1494543552,
0.0914140642,
-0.0469477698,
0.0580639206,
-0.1526431292,
-0.6398558021,
-0.645852685,
-0.2597349882,
0.5951282382,
0.3209268451,
-0.5707024932,
0.4481923878,
0.2299349606,
-0.136762917,
-0.4151805639,
-0.3605874479,
-0.0025126007,
-0.0317490399,
-0.5143724084,
0.2025862485,
-0.1312046945,
-0.0875245705,
0.0381467268,
-0.2681958079,
-0.0947107375,
-0.2917309105,
-0.3879152238,
0.5585558414,
-0.1520881951,
0.2102066278,
0.2980211079,
0.0448531397,
0.1832767576,
-1.094846487,
0.572324574,
0.0584416315,
-0.4253617227,
-0.4503164291,
0.5259617567,
0.5768506527,
-0.3286618888,
0.8075059056,
-0.0451907218,
-0.4038180113,
-0.5685864091,
-0.4111717045,
-0.0841099098,
-0.4409249425,
-0.0355898291,
-0.3206950128,
-0.9759790301,
0.4094125926,
-0.3073222935,
-0.1024631709,
0.0693411827,
0.550698936,
-0.3486330807,
1.2460309267,
0.4526748955,
0.1048909649,
0.5149629712,
-0.1889910847,
0.4927068949,
-0.788320303,
-0.5040624738,
-0.559733808,
-0.1256984174,
-0.2020506114,
-0.5474790931,
0.3235222697,
0.1929509193,
-0.2111103833,
0.2477718294,
-0.3829679787,
0.5837438703,
0.5551669598,
0.3193231523,
0.287424624,
-0.0291539989,
-0.5905152559,
0.6673677564,
-0.9852929711,
-0.514108479,
0.8349978924,
0.1706998944,
0.906822145,
-0.2508302927,
0.3580116034,
0.0725075081,
-0.3900405467,
-0.6281849742,
0.5934787393,
0.3002112806,
-0.698163867,
-0.3464660645,
-0.2965977192,
-0.5845605731,
-0.2724893689,
0.0190759599,
-1.0712202787,
0.1928766072,
0.325465858,
-0.8746334314,
0.4323452413,
-0.4951946139,
0.6714736223,
0.0418287814,
-0.2783825994,
-0.0217891056,
-0.6289585829,
0.3030864298,
-0.0782715157,
0.2509748042,
0.0706000403,
0.0364241004,
0.8087444305,
-0.3820872307,
0.6953856945,
-0.1032587141,
-0.0648175031,
0.6892762184,
0.0782308877,
0.8367626071,
0.0179839823,
-0.0648595318,
-0.1552539319,
0.1225614697,
-0.4552737772,
-0.9249944091,
0.3108900785,
-0.3509239554,
-0.5235624313,
-0.1476942897,
-0.9490531683,
-0.6552793384,
0.2989366353,
0.0483159274,
0.7703944445,
0.2117950916,
0.0862795785,
0.8449891806,
-0.1712874621,
0.301322192,
0.2955224216,
-0.1457727551,
-0.2938328385,
0.6714839339,
-0.1413261592,
0.465377599,
0.4945168495,
0.4334519804,
-0.6027300358,
-0.5273013115,
-0.4318426847,
0.3175230324,
-0.7537665963,
-0.1930962503,
-0.8950233459,
-0.0928979367,
-0.3801374137,
-0.1035226882,
-0.2487084568,
-0.3504953086,
0.0587380752,
-0.0660019815,
0.3352507651,
0.8099150658,
0.2025480419,
0.1994953305,
-1.2201002836,
0.2114513665,
0.4706056118,
0.3184337318,
0.2416202426,
-0.4184646606,
-0.2347307056,
-0.0294538382,
0.0497503728,
-1.3326231241,
-0.0623562038,
-0.063089706,
0.6690477729,
0.4776224196,
0.2235533148,
0.9074597359,
-0.6336676478,
0.7428070307,
0.2502928078,
-0.896745801,
0.9139875174,
-0.5629688501,
0.3543711305,
0.7780994773,
0.5252254605,
-0.5133857727,
-0.713619411,
-0.614239037,
-0.6138916016,
0.7814435959,
0.067673631,
0.0876795873,
-0.3199538291,
0.2902961373,
-0.0602576546,
0.2633996606,
-0.5024813414,
-0.0493581891,
0.1097911745,
-0.1759394109,
0.3185918927,
-0.2292916477,
-0.2771739066,
-0.426376313,
0.6052574515,
-0.3308338821,
0.1667895466,
0.0709886625,
0.0300425254,
-0.0803077444,
0.3083650768,
0.3656477034,
0.9570673704,
-0.0006535285,
0.4903085232,
0.3359205723,
-0.1091189459,
0.0688928515,
-0.2785687149,
-0.3496214747,
-0.110662736,
0.2177965939,
0.6132839322,
0.2164276093,
-0.4358038902,
0.2421319634,
0.0891947672,
-0.1742673665,
0.1883658916,
0.0313852318,
0.2541543841,
0.3188073337,
0.2926238179,
-0.0302975904,
0.052416876,
-0.7666076422,
0.1921180934,
0.1578905433,
-0.3671427667,
-0.2704681456,
0.5382168293,
0.1805746406,
-0.2224184573,
0.8210072517,
-0.0147366058,
-0.5260474682,
0.1492622793,
0.7364254594,
0.4818304479,
-0.2717705965,
0.4805232882,
0.5379765034,
0.2089148164,
-0.5255354047,
0.6969949603,
-0.5487373471,
-0.6461738348,
-0.6280817389,
-0.563047111,
-0.3773867786,
0.1702532768,
-0.642981112,
0.2770092487,
-0.5050538778,
0.1831380725,
0.1049237475,
-0.3215028644,
-0.2495637238,
-0.0066890852,
0.1014736295,
1.3295980692,
-1.110524416,
0.9664511681,
1.0467115641,
-0.550948143,
-1.3819155693,
0.2391388416,
-0.1231246963,
-0.8004738092,
0.2123406976,
-0.0042145606,
-0.099312447,
0.3188586235,
-0.5143184662,
-0.6619664431,
0.7470305562,
0.2418732941,
-0.3177287877,
-0.3230372965,
-0.1296128035,
0.2873244882,
-0.2218586802,
0.2170611769,
0.6431409717,
0.5259068012,
0.4364118874,
-0.6181813478,
0.3075426519,
-0.2605769932,
0.170509398,
0.5069643855,
-0.4553512931,
0.6559917331,
-0.2125620395,
-0.2243834287,
-0.2812481821,
0.7182950974,
0.4978557527,
0.2607239783,
0.6114436388,
0.2540695071,
1.2677260637,
0.3157425225,
0.7698290944,
-0.498336792,
0.2310941815,
1.1024633646,
-0.2464974076,
0.709929049,
0.7182067633,
-0.2638960779,
0.8564522266,
0.7012178302,
0.2347057015,
0.5366492271,
-0.2096229792,
-0.3962571621,
-0.4518922567,
-0.2270086408,
-0.2395481616,
0.2468385547,
0.1385352015,
-0.0765875429,
-0.4694579244,
0.0345204957,
-0.0671910346,
0.0723827928,
-0.0736872628,
0.7292797565,
0.0317393206,
-1.2159924507,
0.3634580672,
-0.1527294219,
0.0111083593,
-0.6208359003,
-0.1554764807,
-0.1076699793,
-0.2280798703,
-0.093893975,
-1.1769292355,
0.3217069209,
0.1748010516,
-0.2761926949,
-0.7069347501,
0.7845724225,
-0.6538658142,
-0.3103691339,
0.3053746819,
0.8074243069,
0.1042191088,
-0.14369151,
-0.6602053642,
-0.2819058597,
0.0243519619,
-0.2530370653,
0.0811169297,
0.7545976043,
-0.1829119474,
0.5369234085,
0.9690596461,
0.0471859127,
-0.0098358523,
0.373465836,
1.1777356863,
-0.6009761095,
-0.8330304027,
-0.9761668444,
0.5911447406,
-0.1783766448,
-0.0785665512,
0.7851711512,
0.4685919285,
0.7491726875,
0.2280660123,
0.711800158,
-0.212354511,
0.3248584569,
-0.7041335702,
0.3610062301,
-0.5844628215,
0.215768829,
-0.3425735533,
-0.8340265751,
-0.0144997705,
0.3924632072,
-0.2042919546,
0.1242035031,
1.2315907478,
0.7286867499,
-0.1279568076,
0.3470490873,
0.1572180837,
0.0927585363,
-0.0464240387,
0.6392153502,
1.3356766701,
-0.0485084653,
0.6553698778,
-0.1105495095,
-0.2682471871,
0.1824008822,
-0.873247087,
-1.0111973286,
-0.8570901752,
-0.2448424697,
-0.4740499556,
-0.0945286229,
0.6956350803,
0.4972292781,
-0.6672523618,
-0.1534898579,
-0.3188988268,
0.2985467911,
-0.2962146103,
-0.1445088685,
0.1619891226,
-0.5390668511,
-0.5450097919,
0.6347638965,
0.6863607764,
-0.1496339738,
-0.2856423855,
0.0828147158,
-0.6900216937,
0.1821304113,
0.5309873223,
0.2292575091,
-0.4606013596,
-0.3318232,
0.2155934423,
0.1087585464,
-0.0504426807,
1.0941712856,
-0.7182266712,
0.6283270121,
0.8858258724,
0.5200942755,
0.3391216695,
0.2435757816,
0.6846964955,
-0.8228379488,
0.0007555924,
0.1058535874,
0.2840546072,
0.0476581939,
-0.4114923477,
0.1763316989,
0.2818367779,
-0.3059934676,
-0.893499732,
0.2461732775,
-0.9289969206,
-0.5211851001,
1.1550531387,
0.0554315113,
-0.3711941838,
-0.4068252146,
0.0139420424,
0.4079409838,
-0.3338727653,
0.4847694635,
0.8915382624,
-0.2737224102,
-0.1616793573,
-0.6428017616,
0.2355436236,
0.3353658915,
-0.9556698203,
0.2456414849,
0.5430930257,
0.0663174987,
0.0136000961,
0.9152393341,
-0.0579760075,
0.183272928,
-0.0066722841,
-0.2780614793,
-0.1937791407,
-0.8953604698,
-0.2530658543,
0.2258750647,
-0.1255357713,
-0.0352001637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08487v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08487v1
|
Alignment is not sufficient to prevent large language models from generating harmful information: A psychoanalytic perspective
| 2023-11-14T19:28:51 | 2023-11-14T19:28:51 |
Zi Yin, Wei Ding, Jia Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are central to a multitude of applications but
struggle with significant risks, notably in generating harmful content and
biases. Drawing an analogy to the human psyche's conflict between evolutionary
survival instincts and societal norm adherence elucidated in Freud's
psychoanalysis theory, we argue that LLMs suffer a similar fundamental
conflict, arising between their inherent desire for syntactic and semantic
continuity, established during the pre-training phase, and the post-training
alignment with human values. This conflict renders LLMs vulnerable to
adversarial attacks, wherein intensifying the models' desire for continuity can
circumvent alignment efforts, resulting in the generation of harmful
information. Through a series of experiments, we first validated the existence
of the desire for continuity in LLMs, and further devised a straightforward yet
powerful technique, such as incomplete sentences, negative priming, and
cognitive dissonance scenarios, to demonstrate that even advanced LLMs struggle
to prevent the generation of harmful information. In summary, our study
uncovers the root of LLMs' vulnerabilities to adversarial attacks, hereby
questioning the efficacy of solely relying on sophisticated alignment methods,
and further advocates for a new training idea that integrates modal concepts
alongside traditional amodal concepts, aiming to endow LLMs with a more nuanced
understanding of real-world contexts and ethical considerations.
|
[
-0.1984856725,
-0.6397895813,
0.6226097941,
-0.1510664076,
-0.3543503582,
0.2276536524,
-0.3302807808,
-0.4377841055,
0.1335822642,
0.5178428292,
-0.5993751287,
-0.3048746288,
-0.7848792076,
-0.0523152463,
-0.5064421892,
0.9922013879,
0.0575189702,
0.1228451356,
-0.2767825127,
-0.2923565209,
-0.531991601,
-0.5597012639,
-0.5564755201,
-0.3317074776,
0.5898669362,
-0.1290822327,
1.1275162697,
0.7367876172,
0.4289166629,
0.2337369323,
0.0700763762,
-0.133546561,
-0.6913858652,
0.6472784877,
-0.1745771617,
-0.7354326248,
-0.2826409936,
0.0612756945,
0.6256907582,
0.9674807787,
-0.1178436056,
-0.1213925704,
0.2081729472,
0.7322639823,
-0.6577087641,
-0.3916597962,
-0.6784273982,
0.0474715419,
-0.3446656764,
-0.2172291428,
-0.3373177648,
-0.3494493067,
0.0440220237,
-0.3828471601,
-0.3602222502,
0.0613651909,
1.0264078379,
0.4495590329,
-0.5384450555,
-0.3356451094,
-0.7756357193,
0.7260562181,
-0.7978197932,
0.4829318225,
0.3470888734,
-0.0136554856,
-0.3654620647,
-0.1989096403,
-0.4253741205,
-0.121240288,
0.0316445976,
-0.0176772531,
-0.3487362862,
0.1446204334,
0.2976453006,
-0.0290475059,
-0.5679693222,
0.4485711753,
-0.4421538413,
-0.2455814481,
0.5776805282,
0.5161656141,
0.4175868928,
0.1674266607,
-0.3751028478,
0.0095065171,
-0.9418705106,
-0.0916341171,
0.621075511,
0.1219140962,
-0.0696873888,
0.5653311014,
0.4101215601,
0.7071891427,
-0.0057215309,
-0.4581521451,
-0.0954299197,
-0.1357493997,
-0.1343559325,
0.2820578516,
0.921522975,
0.4405835271,
0.4393681884,
-0.3463392854,
-0.0421996191,
0.3187114894,
0.698381722,
-0.578323245,
0.2258050144,
0.406896174,
-0.2177874446,
-0.3740418851,
-0.1165380254,
-0.6265918612,
-0.4634034336,
-0.4842678308,
0.15415892,
-0.6310784221,
-0.0314924233,
0.1748968214,
0.2513687909,
0.3533931375,
0.2077552974,
-0.8640593886,
0.1397659332,
0.8248142004,
0.7029467821,
-0.1428604424,
-0.3883616328,
-0.1237192601,
0.3599670231,
-0.6065071225,
0.3396199346,
-0.5328434706,
-0.3219434917,
0.0728402212,
-0.0424587205,
-0.0656698644,
-0.2732818723,
0.3171317875,
-0.5118610859,
0.2641029358,
-0.228649646,
-0.6823672652,
-0.0432863422,
0.2410869151,
-0.3770729005,
0.5412930846,
-0.2910372019,
-0.5779615641,
0.3496656716,
-0.0886403695,
-0.4856714606,
-0.1100166067,
-0.5059734583,
-0.2698466182,
0.1701487601,
-0.3197238445,
0.1210139766,
-0.389477402,
0.4457145333,
-0.5991804004,
-0.2747245133,
0.5807170868,
-0.4685823619,
0.9098166823,
0.333055675,
-0.3909472823,
0.102303423,
-0.5015161633,
-0.0601175539,
0.2101616263,
-0.286164701,
-0.4724374115,
0.0586807877,
-0.3868837953,
0.3369930685,
0.3022898138,
-0.372392863,
0.1453676373,
-0.4651445746,
0.3364792168,
1.0099726915,
-0.186026454,
0.4320299923,
-0.5956165195,
0.6464467645,
-0.0142358309,
0.2151509225,
0.0951926857,
-0.1187568754,
-0.7203058004,
-0.1420630813,
-0.0060848859,
0.4138527811,
-0.1002245024,
0.6970997453,
-0.4621269703,
-0.5011496544,
-0.5526840687,
0.3481130302,
0.3939914405,
0.2965755463,
-0.0294394847,
-0.3465113938,
-0.8437075019,
-0.8973613977,
-0.218985185,
-0.059821289,
0.1012819409,
-0.1971253008,
0.3391795754,
-0.2820233405,
0.9683121443,
-0.3147345185,
-0.085201323,
-0.0901877135,
-0.3286052346,
0.0316955894,
0.4463978708,
0.5408447981,
-0.6214678288,
-0.1762421578,
-0.321285367,
-1.1408060789,
0.0310687963,
-0.2148088366,
-0.1741458029,
-0.031592235,
0.6345337629,
-0.5976701379,
0.1637654603,
0.5012339354,
-0.1824643612,
0.4105612636,
0.0064503066,
-0.1416447163,
-1.0990179777,
-0.0165625382,
-0.1289894432,
-0.092050828,
-0.7646794319,
-0.0535600334,
-0.117105104,
-0.1856288463,
-0.3092801869,
0.5562275648,
-0.4641641676,
0.2825919688,
-0.4605101943,
0.2924391329,
0.1040463522,
0.2270825505,
-0.1799659133,
0.4998036325,
0.4813304842,
-0.4584106505,
0.2081405073,
0.2323045284,
-0.1518356204,
0.7761589885,
-0.3602073193,
0.1156364679,
-0.3040200174,
0.1663213074,
-0.7509033084,
-0.3127095103,
0.1043010503,
-0.2543009222,
0.5528421998,
0.0143026663,
-0.3959382772,
-0.0324257724,
-0.3432977796,
0.4303613305,
0.7897247672,
-0.2080064863,
0.3571362495,
0.4025264978,
-0.0967664346,
-0.6945466995,
-0.6708525419,
0.3178512454,
-0.646463275,
-0.6781333685,
0.0350962281,
0.0422433056,
-0.5100955367,
-0.0282818712,
-0.2817850411,
0.2169671804,
0.3636578619,
0.3628678024,
0.3965209424,
-0.1951703727,
0.0383979157,
-0.2516404092,
-0.0411165096,
0.1410529017,
-0.4216999114,
0.604927659,
-0.010035838,
-0.5576017499,
-0.3662961721,
0.3098259568,
0.7431143522,
-0.021730423,
1.054164052,
0.383344084,
-0.5082727671,
0.1631043851,
-0.6224916577,
-0.154570356,
-0.4262171984,
0.4214244783,
0.0898395106,
-0.8392137885,
0.3141773045,
0.0601609387,
-0.0965443626,
0.0436050594,
0.5805776715,
-0.3373479247,
0.9779388905,
0.5841107368,
-0.086486198,
0.5656688213,
0.0066826772,
0.3774478734,
-0.9780967832,
-0.2494952083,
-0.2232880145,
-0.3392587006,
-0.3773452938,
0.1420632452,
0.2949763536,
0.2560346127,
-0.5746719837,
0.1512554139,
-0.3174058795,
0.440536052,
0.1291064918,
-0.0516559742,
0.0149648683,
-0.1360824555,
0.2063541859,
-0.3208242953,
-0.506747067,
-0.8121951222,
1.2258130312,
0.4234832227,
1.1753975153,
0.3652204275,
0.5943197608,
-0.0451136641,
0.068082206,
-0.7639095187,
0.4685531855,
0.0961616039,
-0.6162783504,
-0.132422179,
-0.07546179,
-1.3065645695,
0.2809513807,
-0.1781867296,
-1.1529272795,
0.3055897653,
0.0226756018,
-0.2822510898,
0.3146969676,
-0.4222362041,
0.7263001204,
-0.6736425757,
-0.5610260367,
0.1112096831,
-0.8852720261,
0.526388526,
-0.3813964725,
0.3388222754,
-0.1552276164,
-0.1963888407,
0.8697232604,
-0.4152543843,
1.2329419851,
0.1787183881,
-0.3639813066,
0.097381711,
0.2870823741,
0.3766974807,
-0.2258488685,
0.1390336752,
-0.1034801826,
-0.0663015619,
-0.4924827218,
-0.4745714068,
0.6462323666,
-0.8237897158,
-0.9897739291,
-0.4680484533,
-0.7425261736,
-0.2421910465,
0.4787520468,
0.4036583006,
0.2676418722,
-0.1844578981,
0.3271496892,
0.7719961405,
0.1456864923,
0.1641314626,
0.2132030576,
-0.0860424638,
-0.3825280964,
0.6784449816,
0.1227046251,
0.817528069,
-0.072593376,
-0.0274787899,
-0.2191063315,
-0.739861846,
0.046417091,
0.3129825294,
-0.7827507854,
-0.2465494573,
-0.5230835676,
-0.2324110717,
-0.5518135428,
-0.5305191278,
-0.2985348701,
0.0327370167,
-0.1461266726,
0.0854665115,
0.0252767224,
0.5546338558,
0.0024567652,
0.3361470103,
-0.8530299664,
-0.0936497524,
-0.0283246841,
-0.0617078505,
-0.016719887,
-0.4322144091,
-0.2928586006,
0.2022157013,
-0.626055479,
-1.010666728,
0.1663607806,
0.0696286336,
0.6074247956,
0.6329071522,
0.1366353482,
0.5047581196,
-0.258223176,
0.6322675347,
0.4125472307,
-0.8376787901,
0.4131291509,
-0.5043880343,
0.2266464978,
0.6193312407,
0.6222431064,
-0.6931882501,
-0.7722204924,
-0.6934741139,
-0.9195670485,
0.5268905759,
0.0468024537,
0.2252506018,
-0.0753100291,
0.3304344714,
-0.055620674,
0.3888994157,
-0.8651715517,
-0.0131938625,
-0.0787619054,
-0.447178036,
0.0701462254,
-0.2278660536,
-0.7374776006,
0.0535233654,
0.6082722545,
0.0522842072,
-0.0291682016,
-0.0017471634,
-0.2049534321,
-0.2285966426,
0.440536648,
0.6702730656,
0.769982934,
-0.0572658591,
0.2190408856,
0.1027459502,
-0.4685615897,
0.617662549,
-0.2975216806,
-0.0844775289,
-0.534424305,
0.7211639285,
0.8631305695,
0.2873066366,
-0.7186636925,
0.6763002872,
0.2303396761,
0.0066557899,
-0.4743315279,
0.0937359706,
0.2543269098,
0.2785191834,
0.0128152678,
0.1522250473,
-0.4121020734,
-0.8403016329,
0.0260703787,
0.6992765069,
-0.4175345004,
-0.3230298162,
0.6955779195,
-0.2369356453,
-0.3772080243,
0.5765485168,
-0.0151320128,
-0.5733294487,
0.3473953605,
0.6991384029,
0.8648906946,
-0.1990737021,
-0.2559740543,
0.0535208471,
0.4917821288,
-0.0552873649,
-0.2025110722,
0.2961034775,
-0.8928552866,
-0.1919604391,
-0.6288537383,
-0.1601075232,
0.1941070259,
-0.7414907217,
0.3493004441,
-0.6738336086,
-0.1138475537,
-0.254889518,
-0.3776329756,
-0.3245612085,
0.0491325259,
0.3554408848,
0.5228016973,
-0.8432517052,
0.7796916366,
0.3670321703,
-0.384953022,
-0.6791142225,
0.2229070961,
0.3381395042,
-0.7469312549,
0.5704869628,
0.1668008715,
-0.0827986598,
-0.2520274222,
-0.3365860879,
-0.9659973979,
1.0861984491,
0.8496698141,
-0.5219828486,
-0.3755104244,
0.1336951703,
0.6067355871,
-0.4484660029,
-0.224286437,
0.6430904865,
0.5161880255,
0.1557015181,
-0.6420445442,
0.313282609,
0.0212798864,
-0.0680748075,
0.5621958971,
-0.6461176276,
0.6664482951,
-0.2052096725,
-0.4372445941,
0.0038207762,
0.2632646263,
0.0404762365,
-0.1204562858,
0.3388186991,
0.6850092411,
0.6263442636,
-0.0986232087,
0.9464102387,
-0.2901317179,
0.1427044272,
1.1289285421,
-0.4352366328,
0.4633871019,
0.6414191723,
-0.1085333675,
0.1429001987,
0.6007293463,
-0.2376552373,
0.4720725715,
0.1249116361,
-0.1532262713,
-0.3151032627,
-0.0655678585,
-0.2980215251,
0.5432947278,
0.4699603915,
-0.2692081034,
-0.2294601202,
0.1214433759,
0.3819604218,
0.117680043,
0.1394052356,
0.817071557,
0.2286273837,
-0.6843365431,
0.7892784476,
-0.4219119251,
0.5463526249,
-0.8765550852,
0.517170608,
0.1185769513,
0.1334907711,
-0.3707591891,
-0.6559991837,
0.4795081615,
-0.2063560039,
0.0570669584,
-0.0315711461,
0.4096466005,
-0.3631854951,
-0.1440884769,
0.5218784213,
0.4337983727,
-0.0383969806,
0.4275023341,
-0.5806572437,
0.3419755399,
-0.0150762117,
-0.2180773169,
0.6783020496,
0.2522530258,
0.0631593764,
0.6493710279,
0.6310482025,
0.3006111979,
-0.0026741216,
-0.2455542088,
0.8830502629,
-0.5564190745,
-0.3017541468,
-1.2835783958,
0.3962528408,
0.0155035881,
-0.1904905885,
0.6029925942,
0.538613081,
0.7416088581,
0.3902783394,
0.7722942829,
0.1474578381,
-0.2156841308,
-0.7617703676,
0.5875918865,
-0.5837920308,
0.5336918831,
-0.1323666871,
-0.9452079535,
-0.3270706534,
0.4225586355,
-0.4944019616,
0.0291231461,
0.9106449485,
0.6134582758,
0.0616155341,
-0.0452799387,
0.520323813,
0.2601108551,
0.4624860287,
0.6122225523,
1.0211141109,
-0.1970579326,
0.4945007265,
0.0621184856,
-0.1711243689,
-0.1624754667,
-0.7911961675,
-0.8063745499,
-0.6462595463,
-0.1249535009,
-0.6399239898,
0.166080758,
1.0315443277,
0.4617629349,
-0.2604912817,
-0.4014368951,
0.0429293327,
-0.0574905351,
0.157786265,
-0.1342872232,
0.1662953049,
-0.5492105484,
-0.5448479056,
0.2777492106,
0.3590307534,
0.4097490609,
-0.4842829108,
-0.1052920446,
-0.2506550848,
0.2544643283,
0.1750189662,
0.3410857618,
-0.8792835474,
-0.5095019341,
-0.2054597288,
-0.3049287796,
0.258577764,
0.8517931104,
-0.3251503706,
0.2569815218,
0.1627280563,
0.7657839656,
-0.1332052946,
-0.2679803669,
0.8360584974,
-0.5416613221,
0.3031719327,
0.3880642354,
0.6941229105,
0.3487515748,
-0.5409746766,
0.2649118304,
0.1095214486,
-0.5418074727,
-1.0317716599,
0.6326155066,
-0.7028023601,
-0.3769694865,
1.0341339111,
-0.0138469273,
-0.4531331956,
-0.0805199519,
-0.1165110618,
0.2986401021,
-0.085361518,
0.7456912398,
0.9958171844,
-0.091871798,
0.3024170101,
-0.4673419297,
0.5013005733,
0.5690134764,
-0.6523681879,
0.2375560254,
0.4411397576,
0.4040087461,
0.39357692,
0.4543664753,
-0.1794646829,
0.0753779784,
0.0128735024,
-0.1264404505,
0.0294138361,
-0.1429678798,
-0.5643417835,
0.1168242395,
0.3244859874,
0.1130031645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08481v1
|
Functionality learning through specification instructions
| 2023-11-14T19:15:55 | 2023-11-14T19:15:55 |
Pedro Henrique Luz de Araujo, Benjamin Roth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Test suites assess natural language processing models' performance on
specific functionalities: cases of interest involving model robustness,
fairness, or particular linguistic capabilities. They enable fine-grained
evaluations of model aspects that would otherwise go unnoticed in standard
evaluation datasets, but they do not address the problem of how to fix the
failure cases. Previous work has explored functionality learning by fine-tuning
models on suite data. While this improves performance on seen functionalities,
it often does not generalize to unseen ones and can harm general performance.
This paper analyses a fine-tuning-free approach to functionality learning.
For each functionality in a suite, we generate a specification instruction that
encodes it. We combine the obtained specification instructions to create
specification-augmented prompts, which we feed to language models pre-trained
on natural instruction data to generate suite predictions. A core aspect of our
analysis is to measure the effect that including a set of specifications has on
a held-out set of unseen, qualitatively different specifications. Our
experiments across four tasks and models ranging from 80M to 175B parameters
show that smaller models struggle to follow specification instructions.
However, larger models (> 3B params.) can benefit from specifications and even
generalize desirable behaviors across functionalities.
|
[
-0.49502033,
-0.7810094953,
0.4240372479,
-0.1377248615,
-0.0805855617,
-0.3749811947,
-0.2288367897,
-0.5875914097,
-0.2774968445,
0.9101237655,
-0.7692437768,
-0.3618825972,
-0.4170255661,
-0.0273984615,
-0.2490160167,
1.0292922258,
0.11777284,
-0.3124511838,
-0.3482736945,
0.2127274126,
-0.7115623355,
-0.1440666467,
-0.2708566189,
-0.0735707879,
0.1789913327,
0.7021971941,
0.6271184087,
0.6657894254,
0.3184589446,
0.268535614,
0.1190111414,
0.444006592,
-0.2505052984,
0.0955039263,
0.0365203246,
-0.6517909169,
-0.2074535638,
0.1984447688,
0.4418998361,
0.9481646419,
0.1187067106,
0.3261309266,
0.4584437907,
0.6212567091,
-0.6217951775,
0.581068337,
-0.5474150181,
0.0183571037,
0.1767763346,
-0.1980050951,
-0.7126173377,
-0.176877141,
0.2364041209,
-0.6517112255,
0.3345474601,
0.0872511268,
0.8626227975,
0.2226311862,
-0.0153745636,
-0.4665525556,
-0.5456478596,
0.9812807441,
-0.5557920933,
0.3585778475,
0.7397253513,
0.422634691,
-0.3654004931,
-0.4387708008,
-0.0193547979,
-0.6034619808,
-0.2880819142,
-0.1964817792,
-0.0148669202,
0.3204187751,
0.6023759246,
0.4274506867,
-0.3630401194,
0.2221815586,
-0.7220842838,
-0.2064542472,
0.675665915,
0.1305006146,
0.2093208879,
-0.2892088592,
0.0615201555,
0.1350756884,
-0.4228548706,
0.5669008493,
0.2607100904,
0.6929755807,
-0.3007415235,
0.4968556464,
-0.5939118862,
0.9168305397,
0.111526154,
0.0635663643,
0.1752884239,
-0.0472463407,
-0.671204567,
-0.3781237304,
0.4530664682,
-0.1234481186,
0.2945652902,
-0.609437108,
-0.5972412229,
-0.2144820392,
0.6758468747,
-0.8207702041,
-0.3449142277,
0.1219837889,
-0.3783273697,
-0.281796068,
0.139973864,
-0.3755345345,
-0.3416324556,
-0.8770288825,
0.7005123496,
-0.8984776735,
0.2360372692,
0.2687790096,
0.1073827147,
0.3927372396,
0.3517310023,
-1.2316266298,
0.4924314022,
1.0421875715,
0.5667521954,
0.2215630114,
-0.1355659515,
-1.1824605465,
-0.398860395,
-0.2011724114,
0.4753385484,
-0.7822939157,
-0.3428169191,
-0.1471210569,
0.214748472,
-0.2839649022,
-0.5936801434,
0.2448270023,
-0.2934144139,
0.2035807222,
-0.0619087964,
-0.7739515305,
-0.33356902,
0.0556615219,
-0.6506971717,
0.8530982733,
0.2377795726,
-0.5206367373,
0.5082381964,
-0.7982592583,
-0.6336120367,
-0.0639470071,
-0.0823046342,
-0.2229229361,
0.5574987531,
0.0431640223,
0.697840631,
-0.0243597981,
-0.1805842966,
-0.3580877483,
-0.4552196562,
0.1668781787,
0.0169675481,
0.5562435985,
0.1716300547,
-0.3251801729,
0.281427145,
-0.9669018388,
0.0343643017,
-0.377946645,
-0.0877116397,
-0.3524798453,
-0.0272435304,
-0.5677930713,
0.0329686552,
-0.0946728587,
-0.2998797596,
0.0550101064,
-0.8299728036,
0.1741507947,
0.6122485399,
-0.105352208,
0.6546295285,
-0.5116750598,
0.463619262,
-0.1148990616,
0.4532085657,
-0.2427415252,
-0.5655211806,
-0.682795167,
-0.2508877814,
0.244622767,
0.3271059096,
-0.4773865938,
0.4411063194,
0.0639262423,
-0.39229092,
-0.624396503,
0.3595336974,
0.5935106277,
0.5546543002,
0.3426341712,
-0.3181060851,
-0.3768219054,
-0.9583352804,
-0.1011242867,
0.1321545392,
-0.3668481112,
0.2673728466,
0.5123759508,
-0.0029242057,
0.8051644564,
-0.3491781652,
-0.0490269437,
-0.3360965848,
0.3440136313,
-0.1188026518,
0.4525849223,
0.3566721082,
-0.5106267333,
-0.0517723225,
0.0100876633,
-0.3678507507,
0.076349847,
0.1072364524,
0.108680658,
0.3600787818,
0.4008211493,
-0.168471992,
0.292245239,
0.3497116566,
-0.1181490347,
0.6771587133,
-0.4566574693,
0.2116088569,
-0.8326942325,
-0.0128851505,
0.0726254433,
-0.0927157924,
-0.5584511757,
0.2687288225,
0.2008790076,
-0.0953322351,
-0.5235049725,
0.5526657701,
-0.3191944063,
-0.1527936608,
-0.1413729936,
-0.0626764521,
0.0457389578,
0.39391011,
-0.1274334043,
0.8219727874,
0.5396476984,
-1.1507619619,
-0.233528927,
0.0687645897,
-0.40983814,
0.3149470687,
-0.3552963734,
0.0703168213,
-0.1029482856,
-0.5521821976,
-0.945093751,
-0.6348257065,
-0.157965824,
-0.465718925,
0.2492247671,
-0.2795737386,
-0.5059059858,
-0.1505702287,
-0.3169124424,
-0.1673262417,
0.8168585896,
-0.3738333285,
0.4193815589,
0.2214200199,
0.2949982285,
-0.1899158061,
-0.6690703034,
-0.6305598021,
-0.2018066049,
-0.7386005521,
0.1517109424,
0.0425997712,
-0.0069812578,
-0.2871772349,
-0.0709112361,
-0.3519342542,
0.6821962595,
0.5539882779,
0.1770307571,
-0.1260722429,
0.4894678295,
0.0285449456,
0.111248225,
0.0005530483,
-0.1902257353,
0.2870087326,
-0.2466562837,
-0.26935938,
-0.5620542765,
-0.0567130893,
0.4038613439,
-0.4551475942,
0.5993033648,
0.5231485963,
-0.4930393696,
-0.4895061553,
-0.4211676717,
-0.3948760033,
-0.5319733024,
0.2506289184,
-0.4203712642,
-0.9368358254,
0.4914570451,
0.1449800432,
0.3461800814,
0.2378979772,
-0.0291142967,
-0.1699528992,
0.9494640827,
0.9592500925,
0.3454851806,
0.5273168683,
-0.2880009115,
0.1786125153,
-0.6475735903,
-0.2034851313,
-0.6517332792,
-0.307446152,
-0.5872372389,
-0.2795539796,
0.0563531406,
0.3145369291,
-0.1916472167,
0.4620400965,
-0.3821845353,
0.6081675887,
0.6607874036,
0.2128731012,
0.1842288226,
0.0607534014,
-0.2736774683,
-0.1082235053,
-0.3755995929,
-0.6760613322,
0.9869631529,
0.2194797695,
0.5757997036,
-0.0667571649,
0.9193026423,
0.1560463011,
0.1418161392,
-1.0122343302,
0.5587121248,
-0.5933205485,
-0.0926156417,
-0.1721099913,
-0.4963935614,
-0.9841439128,
-0.2545044422,
-0.0712481067,
-1.0422493219,
-0.3288574517,
0.2903132141,
-0.7850211263,
-0.0541213751,
-1.117436409,
0.9694148898,
-0.0773276389,
-0.2748276293,
-0.2014024109,
-0.410150826,
0.6340987086,
0.2106814235,
0.3143030107,
-0.0224363822,
0.2465272844,
0.5946881175,
-0.0183524098,
0.9902756214,
-0.2205574661,
0.0312620513,
0.0118910195,
0.3989348412,
0.1283837259,
0.1156395227,
-0.3129838109,
-0.5352105498,
0.1783321798,
-0.3886575401,
-0.8276623487,
0.4704082608,
-0.6440077424,
-0.5937525034,
0.3543183506,
-0.6018291116,
-0.6258161664,
0.2368486971,
-0.0023654818,
0.7764100432,
-0.2198473662,
0.1682123989,
0.9917558432,
-0.2569424212,
0.3308257759,
0.3505266607,
-0.2611203492,
-0.0814317912,
0.6962928772,
0.1127249077,
0.6869137883,
0.4427268803,
0.2376710922,
-0.1974600554,
-0.6601922512,
-0.2671898603,
-0.1273830235,
-0.6343806982,
-0.0902133808,
-0.4280918539,
-0.1342355609,
-0.2289289534,
-0.1218522489,
-0.2406970561,
-0.451562047,
-0.362637043,
-0.14924106,
0.3959746063,
0.6593708396,
0.3617710173,
0.3463214338,
-1.0080236197,
0.2152434886,
0.3920554221,
0.6046513915,
-0.1174993664,
-0.6419176459,
-0.3082882166,
0.3103571236,
-0.4560976028,
-0.4547305107,
0.1775445938,
0.334956497,
0.5139970183,
0.3001786172,
0.2527902126,
0.642406106,
-0.1768935174,
0.7269510627,
-0.2513680458,
-1.0028167963,
0.9592409134,
-0.1103968769,
0.320795536,
0.6943811178,
0.1557223201,
-0.2230553329,
-0.4891640544,
-0.7358199358,
-0.340139091,
0.9557086229,
-0.0620433427,
0.3717568517,
-0.0033970447,
0.5912254453,
0.53008461,
0.0927004069,
-0.2895442545,
0.1680207253,
0.2453209162,
-0.1595101058,
0.1239253059,
0.0691443607,
-0.1200310886,
-0.3594280779,
0.4428803027,
-0.3030834198,
0.11145702,
0.0251148418,
-0.5208416581,
0.1659761965,
0.4397622645,
0.6741065383,
0.4745430052,
-0.1953283101,
0.0652368888,
0.0228240676,
-0.1461751163,
-0.2504767478,
0.2074850947,
-0.1423994154,
-0.3066873252,
0.3510007858,
1.1458197832,
0.6123759747,
-0.6934692264,
0.2635183036,
-0.0948220417,
-0.2675175965,
0.1646733433,
0.8271345496,
-0.1629408598,
0.0027377759,
-0.1559261531,
0.2080282718,
0.2893240452,
-0.6266074181,
0.5935149789,
0.4474030137,
-0.7244462967,
-0.5595988631,
0.3484103382,
0.1071442738,
-0.2970758677,
0.5115348697,
-0.6196745634,
-0.0563338511,
0.6764234304,
0.3412998021,
0.914616406,
-0.1473749131,
0.5257300138,
0.4066314101,
0.2776218951,
-0.1014984995,
0.3137257099,
-0.1757540703,
-0.3207279444,
-0.3059242666,
-0.8810232878,
-0.2793242335,
0.2646118701,
-0.5097136497,
0.5313363671,
-0.7311294079,
0.2643943429,
0.1667769402,
0.1624345779,
-0.7456038594,
0.1903176159,
0.1175760478,
1.005427599,
-0.6677339077,
0.6582397223,
0.6185646057,
-0.6497476697,
-1.1583830118,
0.0434803218,
-0.1484024674,
-0.6125608683,
0.454295218,
0.6708122492,
0.0038719878,
-0.1177728772,
-0.3299864531,
-0.4663381875,
0.822820425,
0.6321944594,
-0.2553234398,
0.0054860371,
0.2198765725,
0.5406351686,
-0.5503344536,
0.2658907473,
0.7048341632,
0.195651859,
0.0412121341,
-1.1759587526,
0.1039979532,
-0.0413702168,
-0.2198259532,
0.156675905,
-0.1539673209,
0.6810994148,
-0.4520173967,
-0.1983406693,
0.1658232659,
0.3394750059,
0.0510540456,
0.0357476994,
0.4559599757,
0.2578315139,
1.004240036,
-0.006853526,
1.2618002892,
0.0121630132,
0.2424234748,
1.0913193226,
0.0568425618,
0.8909293413,
0.3335132599,
-0.019096097,
0.2631880343,
0.6316714287,
0.1528635621,
0.488479346,
0.3354556859,
0.017112812,
-0.3712826073,
0.1819083244,
-0.0174291003,
0.4991700947,
0.3353230655,
-0.3690738678,
-0.2743397355,
0.0968070254,
-0.3007412553,
0.1972712427,
-0.422237426,
0.9024925232,
0.0421888717,
-1.0619661808,
0.7348074913,
-0.0400562733,
0.518299818,
-0.4886521697,
-0.0020434838,
-0.1196328253,
0.2384591103,
-0.3360046446,
-0.6230098605,
0.6279258728,
-0.1590798646,
-0.2157515287,
0.0560296699,
0.5793219209,
-0.2008610666,
-0.4744649529,
0.1263578534,
0.2853027582,
-0.1245827824,
-0.0750982836,
-0.4749791026,
-0.3200699389,
0.0086553954,
-0.02393483,
0.4921587408,
0.4483759105,
-0.0748224705,
0.6984350085,
0.2973690033,
-0.2400153428,
0.2254490703,
0.0621071793,
0.5431187749,
-0.4005004168,
-0.5138824582,
-0.6428394914,
0.7923679352,
-0.0176213477,
-0.1810033619,
0.3209496439,
0.4889906049,
0.9495121241,
-0.4356428087,
0.7228105664,
0.0592118539,
0.2970083654,
-0.8496671319,
0.4085966647,
-0.5714073777,
0.4886354506,
0.0506029539,
-0.4473701715,
-0.5365743041,
0.432572037,
-0.7042686939,
-0.0265163239,
0.5774660707,
0.9225776196,
-0.6689540744,
0.5085615516,
0.4042506218,
-0.1769008934,
0.3507663012,
0.3870302141,
0.5905874372,
-0.3319900632,
0.1830154657,
-0.5815989971,
-0.3682368398,
-0.1209506318,
-0.665964067,
-1.0236369371,
-0.6299264431,
-0.3151199818,
-0.0793489441,
0.164774999,
1.0058679581,
0.8151174188,
-0.8553997874,
-0.1286739856,
-0.3819462955,
0.1678506732,
-0.3818256855,
-0.2256377488,
0.1309771091,
-1.2395120859,
-0.4768213332,
0.217951566,
0.2088091969,
-0.0632269457,
-0.0073531545,
-0.1725480407,
0.1996907145,
0.1367096007,
0.5275765657,
0.2137669623,
-0.7912274003,
-0.6119090319,
0.2306185067,
0.0528754555,
0.0275754556,
0.8240092993,
-0.7230656147,
0.4633524716,
0.4259136319,
0.8232017159,
0.0663542822,
-0.3688468933,
0.6065921783,
-1.2112566233,
-0.0028132028,
0.0839244053,
0.2712168097,
0.196569249,
-0.3496303558,
0.3129018843,
-0.1736437827,
-0.3721218705,
-0.7771359682,
0.4463372231,
-0.8583274484,
-0.0712940842,
1.0164718628,
-0.2544531822,
-0.2736788988,
-0.2064700276,
-0.1927883029,
0.1397969425,
-0.1481316239,
1.0440555811,
0.662481308,
-0.44924739,
-0.1336416155,
-0.841539681,
0.8818078637,
0.2797392607,
-0.9457396269,
0.491109848,
0.3982205093,
0.452113986,
-0.0368945524,
0.1510176361,
-0.2130631655,
0.5602971315,
-0.4980819225,
-0.2945400476,
-0.3141142428,
-0.291221559,
-0.3741032779,
0.1965984851,
0.358196944,
-0.3819538057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08472v1
|
Selecting Shots for Demographic Fairness in Few-Shot Learning with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-14T19:02:03 | 2023-11-14T19:02:03 |
Carlos Aguirre, Kuleen Sasse, Isabel Cachola, Mark Dredze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, work in NLP has shifted to few-shot (in-context) learning, with
large language models (LLMs) performing well across a range of tasks. However,
while fairness evaluations have become a standard for supervised methods,
little is known about the fairness of LLMs as prediction systems. Further,
common standard methods for fairness involve access to models weights or are
applied during finetuning, which are not applicable in few-shot learning. Do
LLMs exhibit prediction biases when used for standard NLP tasks? In this work,
we explore the effect of shots, which directly affect the performance of
models, on the fairness of LLMs as NLP classification systems. We consider how
different shot selection strategies, both existing and new demographically
sensitive methods, affect model fairness across three standard fairness
datasets. We discuss how future work can include LLM fairness evaluations.
|
[
-0.1633585691,
-0.4065533578,
0.5390163064,
-0.0117268367,
-0.0647514313,
-0.344386518,
-0.1486672014,
-0.7183887959,
-0.0998133346,
0.60697335,
-0.3970157802,
-0.4681051672,
-0.8541117311,
0.2537891865,
0.0075247227,
1.0368965864,
0.3819909096,
0.4263656437,
-0.4923397899,
-0.1407846063,
-0.5944238901,
-0.5206707716,
-0.7426545024,
-0.7373297811,
0.4496304989,
0.4516272545,
0.681263268,
0.5819618106,
0.6691732407,
0.2610196769,
-0.2559298277,
-0.2789460123,
-0.6324829459,
0.1168892756,
-0.0805501416,
-1.1139177084,
-0.2988336086,
0.0580302775,
0.8745529056,
0.8978167772,
0.0603911243,
0.3711566925,
0.0979008973,
0.7134040594,
-1.0036761761,
0.0591545068,
-1.0669356585,
0.4657812417,
-0.5999206901,
-0.2450024933,
-0.4419271946,
-0.1961619258,
0.2193195969,
-0.2436629683,
0.3785400391,
0.0141922915,
0.2513394952,
0.2231239378,
-0.4179445505,
0.0568156429,
-0.4656917751,
1.1878441572,
-0.7573820353,
0.0257774722,
0.6218031049,
0.6902438402,
-0.3077258766,
-0.3393694162,
-0.2830708027,
-0.1853092313,
0.0691715628,
0.0949838236,
-0.2589260936,
0.1308119595,
0.6272900701,
-0.0421061777,
-0.4334083498,
0.6979996562,
-0.4294132292,
-0.1809246242,
0.7321017385,
0.310095787,
-0.1070531011,
-0.447111398,
-0.1101228371,
0.1872831136,
-0.8529762626,
0.1553366184,
0.7986677289,
0.5982897282,
-0.1963780671,
0.6732241511,
-0.2890460491,
0.7963178754,
0.0219909754,
-0.2120583951,
0.12341322,
0.1172569618,
-0.2864448428,
-0.0724708661,
0.5748238564,
0.6240935922,
0.5580525994,
0.0681863129,
-0.3254701197,
-0.1153379008,
-0.1489726454,
-0.6893735528,
0.1743337512,
-0.0572513565,
-0.6137000322,
-0.2674133778,
-0.1914860904,
-0.830576241,
-0.5143769979,
-0.1229473129,
0.1932366192,
-0.0207058452,
0.1103598326,
0.0863692984,
-0.2865387201,
0.3600476384,
0.4574887156,
-1.0151475668,
0.2191144228,
0.710557878,
0.743878901,
-0.2444857508,
-0.0727479681,
-0.9224210978,
-0.0500837527,
-0.2655146122,
0.8332128525,
-0.7403693795,
-0.3079786897,
0.2905933857,
-0.2528171241,
-0.0116643393,
-0.8645601869,
0.2310840636,
-0.5931394696,
0.2097369283,
-0.1575938165,
-0.5257090926,
-0.0428478569,
0.0399031825,
-0.451438427,
0.4663289487,
-0.0570457317,
-0.8350813985,
0.8257381916,
-0.4904286563,
-0.3458680511,
0.1287236661,
-0.3151926398,
-0.4722244442,
0.2630791664,
0.045774322,
0.6565434337,
0.122897774,
0.1653645635,
-0.7180857658,
-0.5838269591,
0.3048450947,
-0.672103107,
0.9629404545,
0.2504267693,
-0.1715176404,
-0.2047112584,
-0.4118502438,
-0.194659099,
0.0033960927,
-0.2867400944,
-0.1465985328,
-0.0939022154,
-0.1450185627,
0.3325667083,
-0.2132319659,
-0.4562961161,
-0.0928022936,
-0.5927149057,
-0.02898244,
0.9938794971,
-0.2004313916,
0.8193448782,
-0.5585952997,
0.7999429703,
-0.047820773,
0.1203459427,
0.1354385316,
-0.5978984237,
-0.5825303793,
-0.1673356891,
0.4250546992,
0.4484509528,
-0.6536919475,
0.0266315881,
-0.1238326952,
-0.1335507929,
-0.2037850618,
0.1299822927,
0.3750490546,
0.3405470252,
0.0754754916,
-0.5256205201,
-0.3647035062,
-0.8996459246,
-0.5563104749,
-0.0320339315,
-0.2531356514,
0.5397011042,
0.6326140165,
0.2429069281,
1.0179415941,
-0.463560909,
-0.6158154011,
-0.2660624385,
-0.0513144992,
0.1579325199,
0.3820403218,
1.0538009405,
-0.5263670683,
-0.3064086735,
-0.3879803121,
-0.5123813152,
-0.3100126088,
0.142641142,
-0.0272808131,
0.3443379998,
0.4742335379,
-0.3303157389,
0.4514312744,
0.5498226285,
-0.0624337867,
0.430986166,
0.3532220125,
0.0053458139,
-0.6814145446,
-0.2583721578,
0.3098619878,
-0.5589081645,
-0.3014518917,
-0.0335487798,
-0.2916472852,
0.018354781,
-1.082224369,
0.8240654469,
-0.1226265505,
-0.5241439342,
-0.3734295368,
0.1119383872,
-0.2127880752,
0.1716503352,
0.0848440081,
0.4024134278,
0.6212943792,
-0.5501070619,
-0.0481462367,
-0.1581884623,
-0.1748038381,
0.7371192575,
-0.1826517135,
0.2233917415,
-0.5895735025,
0.636333704,
-0.3687563539,
-0.2833020687,
0.0813082457,
-0.5027829409,
0.1713587046,
-0.4482935667,
-0.2650073767,
-0.2325366735,
-0.4608295262,
0.3920381069,
0.3687532842,
-0.3963892162,
0.3287914395,
0.4202049375,
-0.1188829765,
-0.9005819559,
-0.7491336465,
-0.1590758115,
-0.4507545233,
-0.3721033633,
0.2393164486,
0.1373124421,
-0.5075588822,
-0.2877176702,
-0.0465047248,
-0.2188480794,
0.1598297209,
0.2449389994,
0.2118865252,
0.032987345,
0.2741169035,
-0.1218397543,
-0.0832340494,
-0.1415223777,
-0.0708889291,
0.4881655276,
0.0847327188,
-0.374004662,
-0.2677969635,
0.3003728688,
-0.0343794934,
-0.0980510488,
0.6663245559,
0.5940740705,
-0.6067153215,
-0.2139362395,
-0.6132957935,
-0.2271213979,
-0.4287824929,
0.5360056758,
-0.1207585037,
-1.1569952965,
0.5659275651,
0.2760264277,
0.2545920908,
0.6427919865,
0.5943270922,
-0.2791561782,
0.8840489984,
0.7753654122,
-0.0116235744,
0.8510272503,
-0.0595762469,
-0.3021447062,
-0.4893402457,
-0.1139238328,
-0.7619651556,
-0.6301420331,
-0.7188804746,
-0.3846910894,
0.2255482525,
-0.0821471512,
-0.3248932362,
-0.1442416608,
0.072825186,
0.8981176615,
0.6357637644,
0.1545623243,
0.4436809123,
0.0778166801,
0.2694251537,
-0.185333252,
-0.8183605671,
-0.6220537424,
1.4885981083,
0.3882140219,
0.7400939465,
0.0352338813,
0.8640418649,
0.2213472277,
0.4346356988,
-0.8958785534,
0.4295065701,
-0.7173179984,
-0.9220728278,
-0.1735004187,
-0.6803337336,
-1.1258672476,
0.2161000371,
-0.5482035875,
-0.7772030234,
0.3210588098,
0.0448345169,
-0.7479486465,
0.2654842734,
-0.6479907036,
0.5132346153,
-0.0145714218,
-0.2207253575,
-0.3086462915,
-0.6955009103,
0.5602107048,
-0.3020426035,
0.0689033046,
-0.6182338595,
0.2090405673,
0.8411715031,
0.043715857,
1.0589585304,
-0.4457464814,
0.2117325515,
0.1404122561,
0.0419133529,
-0.0114052584,
0.1314462721,
-0.4644763768,
0.4902546406,
0.0409170948,
-0.5019868612,
-0.3555569649,
0.5607169867,
-0.4554793835,
-0.634558022,
-0.5875166059,
-0.5713996291,
-0.2896517217,
-0.052935522,
0.3629054725,
0.2459241897,
-0.0873796493,
0.394096911,
0.3842930198,
-0.4693624079,
0.5996681452,
0.5607507825,
-0.213071391,
0.0956860483,
0.1984972805,
0.3802111447,
0.5889045596,
0.070797123,
0.1963705271,
-0.2510516942,
-0.5353947282,
-0.0926476866,
-0.0534776226,
-0.7751924396,
-0.6969873309,
-0.4192831218,
-0.1371990293,
-0.5375642776,
-0.201815024,
-0.298478961,
-0.3879898489,
-0.2649759054,
0.0727074668,
0.1939858794,
0.5093764663,
-0.1495690346,
0.4766435325,
-0.5849575996,
0.429777056,
0.3909356892,
0.5504943132,
-0.1518239528,
-0.8702878952,
-0.0936461464,
0.0376478918,
-0.4350142181,
-0.478718549,
0.1038924605,
0.336091578,
0.5943456888,
0.2866570354,
-0.1050873473,
0.4545261562,
-0.7233896255,
0.6483484507,
0.3505031168,
-0.5811522603,
0.4571516812,
-0.2386075109,
0.3541885316,
0.6230320334,
0.1734829396,
-0.4383359551,
-0.4631333351,
-0.3594622612,
-0.3226184249,
0.8612545729,
-0.0268203523,
0.5912414193,
-0.0598650873,
0.4465297461,
0.3961138725,
0.1038663313,
-1.0753114223,
-0.0824391097,
0.3120464087,
-0.0190512426,
0.0979308486,
-0.0912597254,
-0.0933924392,
-0.0693008155,
0.257804662,
-0.2690607607,
0.0784312189,
-0.204327628,
-0.2358884662,
-0.4364153743,
0.3296715021,
0.1802661866,
0.6598825455,
-0.2888415754,
-0.0312447958,
0.4645591378,
-0.261713773,
0.0583775826,
-0.0091238059,
-0.2895758748,
0.0437208861,
0.4391473532,
0.8221863508,
0.21505858,
-0.4569458067,
0.7893861532,
0.0719251558,
-0.2301769108,
-0.1176105738,
0.276396811,
-0.3849727809,
0.6270707846,
0.2319348454,
0.3582439721,
0.2398433089,
-0.6299875975,
0.115832895,
0.7121174335,
-0.2101615369,
0.0214860737,
0.6340082884,
0.1331003606,
-0.2534184456,
0.4963971376,
-0.2945075333,
-0.197579816,
0.742752552,
0.5681053996,
0.7940340638,
-0.0885668173,
0.2345017642,
0.1186845377,
0.2036681622,
-0.1559699923,
-0.1570517719,
0.4333763421,
-0.8951188922,
-0.5778378248,
-0.834215343,
-0.3064123094,
-0.1156856939,
-0.4919106662,
0.5694946051,
-0.4581630528,
-0.6100246906,
-0.1562043279,
0.001308232,
-1.2448430061,
0.1298902631,
0.7567016482,
0.6201313138,
-1.1270663738,
0.511014998,
0.4454568624,
-0.1655035615,
-0.2894208133,
0.2254548371,
0.2158588469,
-0.8331176639,
0.8749068975,
0.2929868698,
-0.0222836994,
-0.0891547129,
-0.6853243113,
-0.6017244458,
0.9383221269,
0.9602138996,
-0.6073253155,
0.050042931,
0.1928995103,
0.4333678782,
-0.3809540272,
0.3471191525,
0.5032920837,
0.1754756421,
0.0565081239,
-1.1183344126,
-0.4790529609,
0.3930926323,
0.1313421726,
-0.2783197761,
-0.5031244159,
0.6190373302,
-0.3833057582,
-0.0717805326,
-0.2663411796,
0.595315218,
0.5687012672,
0.5502361655,
0.6613302231,
0.3666726053,
0.7451164722,
-0.0186941475,
1.2351359129,
0.4655173421,
0.3250283599,
1.0786827803,
-0.5413540006,
0.9636027813,
0.381225884,
-0.474368155,
0.2228006274,
0.7047517896,
0.0984825194,
0.3648423851,
0.3660188317,
-0.2253223658,
-0.2814188004,
-0.3322595954,
-0.3138590455,
0.9534795284,
-0.0383174755,
-0.0912111998,
-0.3829024434,
0.1433228254,
0.0583018176,
0.0674193576,
-0.6330053806,
0.657034874,
0.4035940766,
-0.4554033875,
-0.0020710169,
0.119210422,
1.2221167088,
-0.4264889956,
-0.0569322444,
-0.3429179192,
-0.0674796179,
-0.357519269,
-0.8812964559,
0.2290948033,
0.1922911406,
-0.215909645,
-0.0494210385,
0.8779726624,
-0.3363136351,
-0.6216223836,
0.2458767444,
0.5730884075,
0.2245800644,
-0.1132021919,
-0.7397204638,
-0.2807898521,
-0.2488896549,
-0.0665785372,
0.7231088877,
0.2479259372,
-0.1070988923,
0.6112694144,
0.5384038687,
0.2216027081,
0.2759368122,
0.3708585501,
0.4347833991,
-0.4952998161,
-0.2693219781,
-1.0516984463,
0.2561067343,
0.0307887066,
-0.1660142392,
0.584831953,
0.3925976753,
1.0433915854,
-0.087062411,
0.4775449038,
0.282833606,
0.2770404518,
-0.8316388726,
0.7088018656,
-0.3984955847,
0.2856555879,
-0.340472877,
-1.2429132462,
-0.7983976007,
0.5842539072,
-0.6847783327,
0.4128603935,
0.4982628822,
0.6237280965,
0.179975301,
-0.1960074753,
0.561419189,
-0.2978359163,
0.1591922343,
0.5698305368,
0.6850740314,
-0.1366700381,
0.3943565488,
-0.1637451798,
-0.1235317886,
-0.3413666189,
-1.1746025085,
-0.8853752017,
-0.0010226668,
-0.1755713969,
-0.0361063257,
0.1888872832,
1.0169141293,
0.6301345825,
-0.6704953909,
-0.21167624,
0.4326976836,
0.2246359289,
0.1758620441,
-0.2711707652,
0.0078035276,
-0.4873250723,
-0.9350842834,
-0.0585531704,
0.3377233148,
-0.0696152896,
0.0453684963,
-0.0241814833,
-0.0356715173,
-0.1785739958,
0.6756424904,
0.0649235696,
-0.526682198,
-0.3155901432,
-0.2617602646,
-0.1246655732,
0.1569701284,
0.5883617997,
-1.0565321445,
0.4046015143,
0.440423727,
0.5147404671,
0.3349200785,
-0.2240804583,
0.5678448081,
-0.9130672812,
0.4962761402,
0.5736864805,
0.4957142174,
0.3202649653,
-0.2529951334,
0.3004682362,
0.2244359553,
-0.5482740402,
-0.7497420311,
0.2406904399,
-0.5144492388,
-0.1861861497,
1.3466567993,
0.0157082025,
-0.0253014192,
-0.0374301001,
0.0865205824,
0.1725650281,
-0.2793637514,
0.7118335366,
0.6806747913,
-0.0383704081,
0.0083089769,
-1.0787240267,
0.4516022801,
0.5848275423,
-0.7199739814,
-0.1268342435,
0.6755587459,
0.216836229,
-0.4042069614,
0.8959548473,
-0.2690943182,
0.3163903356,
-0.351233542,
-0.205297932,
0.4563019276,
-0.1523067951,
-0.6767487526,
-0.1015142351,
0.3218650818,
0.0245690085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08469v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08469v2
|
UNcommonsense Reasoning: Abductive Reasoning about Uncommon Situations
| 2023-11-14T19:00:55 | 2024-05-01T05:12:07 |
Wenting Zhao, Justin T Chiu, Jena D. Hwang, Faeze Brahman, Jack Hessel, Sanjiban Choudhury, Yejin Choi, Xiang Lorraine Li, Alane Suhr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language technologies that accurately model the dynamics of events must
perform commonsense reasoning. Existing work evaluating commonsense reasoning
focuses on making inferences about common, everyday situations. To instead
investigate the ability to model unusual, unexpected, and unlikely situations,
we explore the task of uncommonsense abductive reasoning. Given a piece of
context with an unexpected outcome, this task requires reasoning abductively to
generate an explanation that makes the unexpected outcome more likely in the
context. To this end, we curate and release a new English language corpus
called UNcommonsense. We characterize the performance differences between human
explainers and the best-performing large language models, finding that
model-enhanced human-written explanations achieve the highest quality by
trading off between specificity and diversity. Finally, we experiment with
several imitation learning algorithms to train open and accessible language
models on this task. When compared with the vanilla supervised fine-tuning
approach, these methods consistently reduce lose rates on both common and
uncommonsense abductive reasoning judged by human evaluators.
|
[
-0.4795900881,
-0.8369774222,
0.5341545343,
-0.1424458772,
-0.1763254851,
-0.3282230496,
-0.190748632,
-0.4175030887,
-0.1397878677,
0.2080820799,
-0.7257621288,
-0.5868962407,
-0.39261657,
0.3101605177,
-0.5674342513,
0.7588252425,
0.0428396612,
-0.1086350158,
-0.1057565734,
-0.2328163236,
-0.2220745832,
-0.331376493,
-0.5008988976,
-0.1445461512,
0.2666497827,
0.7043576241,
0.6222342849,
0.4658832252,
0.2076579332,
0.3905273378,
-0.1324302256,
0.5928313136,
-0.7788223624,
-0.1790423989,
-0.5416492224,
-0.331518054,
0.036037147,
-0.1275398135,
0.222210601,
0.9669985771,
-0.2266138643,
-0.2899191082,
-0.0724232346,
0.4742625654,
-0.7473881841,
-0.2907893956,
-0.7941154242,
-0.0774933025,
0.1517358124,
0.0649743304,
-0.2770146728,
-0.5416072011,
-0.0039593289,
-0.8771668673,
0.3012026846,
0.0042790947,
0.3873389065,
0.0710744411,
-0.0034357449,
-0.3151827455,
-0.7376046181,
0.8473005891,
-0.3909797966,
0.3769354224,
0.220725596,
0.2309074551,
-0.1316342652,
-0.8216643929,
-0.9465333819,
-0.2485001534,
-0.2094231546,
-0.0168977492,
-0.3881759346,
0.1002974734,
-0.1196463853,
-0.0057429727,
-0.7099583745,
0.4562069178,
-0.491542697,
0.1256266087,
0.7261914611,
0.4369180501,
0.2891533375,
-0.1310280859,
-0.0346437208,
0.1383312345,
-0.7099161148,
0.0696407855,
0.3623454273,
-0.0426666625,
-0.1871199757,
0.473526299,
-0.285477519,
0.565337956,
-0.1484909952,
0.5893326402,
0.1186636165,
0.0801571906,
-0.2031718493,
0.0709270313,
0.2421996444,
0.5731641054,
0.4338338971,
-0.0996245369,
-0.2604075372,
0.2343439758,
0.1956316233,
-0.3203738034,
-0.3602031469,
0.4455386102,
-0.718270421,
-0.4527334571,
0.0227778163,
-0.5396468043,
-0.2889957726,
-0.533223033,
0.3800239265,
-0.7052557468,
-0.3385264575,
0.3226212859,
-0.4271453917,
-0.0322667547,
0.7284814715,
-0.8587846756,
0.5022361875,
1.068120122,
0.4957982898,
-0.6970015764,
-0.6554834843,
-0.4445232451,
-0.181992963,
-0.2455537766,
1.0032931566,
-0.5828176737,
-0.4995394647,
-0.0136489952,
0.2524308264,
0.0010566291,
-0.5456180573,
0.6393960714,
-0.2205522954,
-0.0650702119,
-0.1217973605,
-0.6522032022,
-0.3126780093,
0.0617478453,
-0.4032822251,
0.4824189842,
-0.0249966402,
-0.4297857583,
0.3249137104,
-1.1410816908,
-0.3005832434,
0.2517060935,
-0.1168400571,
0.066151768,
0.3487294614,
0.1287798882,
0.5974288583,
0.0622381456,
0.0702488422,
-0.37717098,
-0.681987226,
0.4596521854,
-0.8154488802,
0.9621049166,
0.7654013038,
-0.0787003115,
-0.1727551967,
-0.8296256065,
-0.2205438763,
0.3043255806,
0.0340836421,
-0.6720942855,
-0.0464152694,
0.0701705739,
-0.3673599064,
0.0077923732,
-0.5645403266,
0.0830573365,
-0.6074306965,
0.3229963779,
0.5675333142,
0.2284693271,
0.5353215337,
-0.4057309628,
0.2247480154,
-0.0149978558,
0.1313916445,
-0.0989888236,
-0.4607035816,
-0.213960588,
-0.1719513237,
-0.2570533156,
0.5226172805,
-0.2176413089,
0.0127205355,
-0.2275938094,
-0.2643936574,
-0.6416175961,
0.0795819014,
0.3138449192,
0.4169990122,
0.363999486,
0.340497613,
-0.6668615341,
-0.8672862053,
-0.6973645091,
0.0150224166,
-0.0419284105,
0.2767338753,
0.3842444718,
-0.2861455977,
0.8483251929,
-0.4879872203,
0.229499951,
-0.4774606526,
0.7124539614,
0.2022041976,
0.6859823465,
0.4802474082,
-1.0332204103,
-0.1133539528,
0.2021600604,
-0.6473057866,
-0.3518459201,
-0.3439049125,
0.2972660959,
0.3667725027,
0.746365428,
-0.5675910711,
0.3930520415,
0.2808987498,
-0.0952125639,
0.6003727317,
-0.2221561968,
0.3028009236,
-0.5366370678,
-0.0044947206,
-0.2528301477,
-0.1166363657,
-0.4247035384,
0.2426912934,
-0.0902830064,
0.016691247,
-0.6135054827,
0.6163665056,
-0.4201364517,
0.0594692938,
-0.2689518332,
0.2338948697,
0.1206234917,
0.1779043227,
0.3340780139,
0.4984986186,
0.2225908637,
-0.6906096935,
0.4229136705,
0.0943088531,
-0.5618633032,
0.4747266471,
-0.552164495,
-0.1629176736,
-0.345174104,
-0.2583806515,
-1.2235687971,
-0.2562788427,
-0.0252142549,
-0.6708336473,
0.1108004525,
-0.1039331332,
-0.168004483,
-0.5512217283,
-0.0101595065,
0.288747251,
0.6142914891,
-0.9122158289,
0.4691203237,
0.1857941598,
-0.3124794662,
-0.5591907501,
-0.781306684,
-0.1363530606,
-0.2891217768,
-0.4012247622,
-0.0338223986,
-0.1866158843,
-0.7964446545,
0.2966014445,
0.0577233993,
-0.3663124442,
0.4248188436,
0.0907157287,
0.0734260008,
-0.2791189551,
0.2535017431,
0.4511316419,
-0.1273099631,
0.1309235245,
-0.0720468163,
0.1857098937,
-0.3208142519,
-0.6753664613,
-0.3991343081,
0.730368793,
0.3218717575,
0.356967181,
0.7625373602,
0.3137980103,
-0.4416329563,
-0.2247082442,
-0.6328285336,
-0.184645474,
-0.4798622429,
0.6976423264,
-0.6212970018,
-0.6581391096,
0.4598486423,
-0.2047982216,
0.375175029,
0.4540382922,
0.5049034953,
-0.4310077727,
1.1370953321,
0.0882540122,
0.3806900382,
-0.1691363603,
-0.0909453332,
0.1499244571,
-0.3963134289,
-0.2563469708,
-0.5009052157,
-0.2483485639,
-0.4961367249,
-0.1714044064,
0.2162523419,
0.0943295211,
-0.1178668588,
0.217476368,
-0.6378230453,
1.0715945959,
0.4367409945,
-0.1104868352,
0.4000037909,
-0.1647014767,
-0.1242789328,
0.089495942,
-0.6391803622,
-0.4860362113,
0.7457124591,
0.1988663822,
0.8733372688,
0.3290837407,
0.8293229342,
0.1890858412,
0.2612913549,
-0.587620914,
0.4541963339,
-0.2932610214,
-0.5355894566,
-0.5245510936,
-0.3705403507,
-1.2554755211,
0.2590401769,
-0.2314435691,
-1.0330243111,
0.2248432934,
0.2638576627,
-0.4218452275,
0.1233515143,
-0.9258890152,
0.8297242522,
0.0400615893,
-0.2614515424,
-0.6134486794,
-0.6293236017,
0.7034228444,
0.2201280594,
0.504489243,
0.1508714259,
0.0135636982,
0.3583004773,
-0.1736180186,
0.9035543799,
-0.0020123732,
0.1144509315,
0.4288918972,
0.506246388,
0.5270228386,
0.1963329464,
-0.0658251196,
0.222424224,
0.0783786699,
-0.2176107764,
-0.7512244582,
0.9612464905,
-0.6532673836,
-0.6554836035,
0.0095188441,
-0.4556953907,
-0.0737797096,
-0.0813889131,
0.5054773688,
0.225800246,
-0.6490145922,
0.1001900807,
0.8365262151,
-0.302592814,
0.5547527671,
0.7164748311,
0.1170825884,
-0.152089119,
0.7513035536,
-0.1933207512,
0.1349545121,
0.553195715,
0.4889567196,
-0.3660590947,
-0.6690075994,
-0.3387006521,
-0.0858091116,
-0.9651102424,
0.0208598543,
-1.0197160244,
-0.1142756194,
-0.4653151035,
-0.6753878593,
-0.433606863,
-0.91216892,
-0.2549355924,
-0.2879824638,
0.4362154007,
0.6814985275,
-0.662932992,
0.2345622182,
-1.019256115,
0.6072873473,
0.3759082854,
0.2073625624,
0.0324633345,
-0.7550515532,
0.0976778939,
-0.0488401391,
-0.0667725876,
-0.923856318,
0.3681402206,
0.0823975876,
1.0200026035,
0.6906386018,
0.1815517694,
0.415406853,
-0.3647861481,
0.7367813587,
0.1412726492,
-0.7779075503,
0.5048467517,
-0.2283440381,
0.3459129632,
0.5510829687,
0.7377266288,
-0.5238369703,
-0.3549003899,
-0.837258935,
-0.703404963,
0.6184061766,
0.2178173214,
0.2625908554,
-0.4110044539,
0.2117335051,
0.5959947705,
-0.0463494919,
-0.7129769325,
-0.1775413901,
-0.068016395,
-0.2745003998,
0.0322833285,
-0.2664052844,
-0.1969228089,
-0.523630321,
0.4560112655,
0.1327204704,
-0.0489143021,
0.1506734937,
-0.2780066729,
0.0024725723,
0.1703246087,
0.8094242215,
0.4981484115,
-0.0961942822,
0.2059877515,
0.4911175072,
-0.3349042833,
-0.1428257078,
0.2290969044,
0.1840104014,
0.0984677598,
0.3245785534,
0.4406343997,
0.3258170784,
-0.8882285953,
0.5821601748,
-0.0889710113,
-0.2725497484,
-0.3495664299,
0.2856727839,
0.2667810321,
0.0207866151,
0.2962104976,
0.1673358083,
0.5280806422,
-0.4679293334,
0.3515951335,
0.3544958234,
0.1184771582,
-0.1824501157,
0.4077571332,
0.4652528763,
-0.4190780222,
0.5742439032,
-0.5040044785,
-0.3254712522,
0.7071098089,
0.4455338418,
0.8692251444,
-0.5288244486,
0.0893768296,
0.4741135538,
0.4408976734,
0.0198983233,
0.2961417437,
-0.1950701326,
-0.9240218401,
-0.3772170842,
-0.3559655845,
-0.3823626637,
0.3597896397,
-0.4067202806,
0.3913066983,
-0.1259536892,
0.7218629122,
0.1445069909,
-0.5873039961,
-0.5528966188,
0.1755440831,
0.0378585272,
0.963553369,
-1.2018095255,
0.3091338277,
0.7109146714,
-0.2166329324,
-0.4113302231,
-0.2438318878,
0.2422697097,
-1.1629368067,
0.6756538749,
0.0875077993,
-0.128100276,
-0.0575149246,
-0.7031193972,
-0.520950973,
0.3217326403,
0.0090494985,
-0.6678410769,
0.3096096218,
-0.0894191563,
0.3490304351,
-0.35874933,
0.4358353317,
0.7570014596,
0.4095787704,
0.1817756444,
-0.5377184749,
-0.1312179267,
-0.2060141861,
-0.347377032,
-0.0246478766,
-0.0848168954,
0.5048863292,
-0.586402297,
-0.1679330468,
0.2850809693,
0.5534588695,
0.3783176541,
0.7569509149,
0.5105475187,
0.5516651273,
0.7272706032,
0.2996946275,
1.1033699512,
0.2311882824,
-0.1693648845,
1.421230793,
-0.0992910042,
0.6992040873,
0.3392887115,
0.006804313,
0.5199806094,
0.377091676,
0.2001893967,
0.6184393167,
0.1127492487,
-0.288335979,
-0.3405244648,
0.2198893726,
-0.0095008118,
0.807611227,
0.6307657957,
-0.2094909847,
-0.411025852,
0.2884375751,
-0.2844420671,
0.5116363764,
-0.3586184084,
0.8270280361,
0.0309163872,
-0.7825660706,
0.7859404087,
-0.0654740855,
0.2554687262,
-0.1263545603,
-0.3027788401,
-0.3651519418,
0.0060593057,
-0.138039425,
-0.9478650689,
0.6498523951,
0.0631049797,
0.055888731,
0.000404345,
0.5513250232,
-0.1424293816,
-0.1806280613,
-0.1801521331,
0.4258884788,
0.5862800479,
0.1273670346,
-0.6120507717,
-0.0422345623,
-0.0275141224,
-0.291968435,
0.0830000788,
1.0219056606,
-0.0623259619,
0.713478744,
0.510735333,
0.141473189,
-0.1429040283,
0.1980776489,
0.6475973725,
-0.6460009217,
-0.7024278045,
-0.7362796664,
0.5955696106,
-0.3627441525,
-0.4201614261,
0.4632870853,
0.5380008221,
0.5925070643,
-0.2421032041,
0.7688271403,
0.3459454775,
0.856380105,
-0.5284727216,
0.4375411272,
-0.6469717026,
0.4261361957,
-0.21060583,
-0.5764003396,
-0.1005285159,
0.840218842,
-0.1639406085,
-0.1953532398,
0.7762572765,
0.7368631959,
-0.4812970459,
0.5193651915,
0.6331140995,
0.4873037338,
-0.188729614,
0.6014557481,
1.1268779039,
0.137733981,
0.5408893824,
-0.008744251,
-0.4004346728,
-0.4187938273,
-1.145549655,
-0.5825971961,
-0.5242868662,
-0.3607029319,
0.0518077835,
0.2962776721,
1.0484262705,
0.3985102177,
-0.8656578064,
0.1516174972,
-0.7872263193,
0.3039794564,
-0.4082508981,
-0.3609925807,
0.0962970257,
-0.3809180856,
-0.9364376068,
0.5220156908,
0.0913060308,
0.2211992741,
0.076018095,
0.046905905,
0.0698354319,
0.1611572951,
0.4362578988,
0.5880353451,
-0.7546721697,
-0.1975103915,
-0.1312939227,
0.1053741947,
-0.2243689299,
0.7015114427,
-0.8413361907,
0.2141415626,
0.5791140795,
0.7288016081,
0.2519451976,
0.0180186089,
0.6332745552,
-0.5678170919,
0.2429020107,
0.60310179,
0.341570884,
0.1553647816,
-0.5205026865,
0.480717659,
0.2839857042,
-0.4348066747,
-0.9085161686,
0.2387358695,
-0.8418828845,
-1.0037279129,
1.2726073265,
0.0223679524,
-0.182853356,
-0.5740029812,
-0.069854103,
-0.0075494451,
-0.3249839544,
1.0064759254,
0.4971612394,
-0.4212683737,
-0.4703199267,
-0.3863135874,
0.4571332335,
0.6563766003,
-0.5859152675,
0.2855572701,
0.5387277603,
0.1722624451,
-0.0330494642,
0.2948715389,
0.029859785,
0.7487770319,
0.1483778059,
-0.1424231529,
-0.1733853817,
-0.1329765171,
-0.5322343707,
-0.0114435218,
-0.0719103813,
-0.2330101728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08402v1
|
Retrieve and Copy: Scaling ASR Personalization to Large Catalogs
| 2023-11-14T18:59:24 | 2023-11-14T18:59:24 |
Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Devang Kulshreshtha, Saket Dingliwal, Srikanth Ronanki, Sravan Bodapati
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Personalization of automatic speech recognition (ASR) models is a widely
studied topic because of its many practical applications. Most recently,
attention-based contextual biasing techniques are used to improve the
recognition of rare words and domain specific entities. However, due to
performance constraints, the biasing is often limited to a few thousand
entities, restricting real-world usability. To address this, we first propose a
"Retrieve and Copy" mechanism to improve latency while retaining the accuracy
even when scaled to a large catalog. We also propose a training strategy to
overcome the degradation in recall at such scale due to an increased number of
confusing entities. Overall, our approach achieves up to 6% more Word Error
Rate reduction (WERR) and 3.6% absolute improvement in F1 when compared to a
strong baseline. Our method also allows for large catalog sizes of up to 20K
without significantly affecting WER and F1-scores, while achieving at least 20%
inference speedup per acoustic frame.
|
[
-0.3939424157,
-0.2645682395,
-0.0589986667,
0.3596700132,
-0.2115703374,
-0.0666104406,
-0.3053058982,
-0.4094640613,
0.1473642886,
0.6138909459,
-0.2882798612,
-0.0427168123,
-0.5243768096,
0.1467041075,
-0.6470372677,
0.9534249902,
0.3093286157,
0.1443201005,
-0.0234019794,
-0.5061696768,
-0.5244136453,
-0.7031925917,
-0.9240779281,
-0.2555194199,
0.4701422751,
0.3890343904,
0.4975220561,
1.1045601368,
0.5428160429,
0.2596456707,
-0.5536584854,
-0.0981680155,
-0.598601222,
0.2182412446,
-0.3286288679,
-0.2814136147,
-0.4717124999,
-0.2281669825,
0.9307134748,
0.6809765697,
-0.2896172106,
0.3429294229,
0.0805988014,
0.9988074303,
-0.6948104501,
-0.10293331,
-0.783613503,
0.1891753376,
-0.1452424526,
-0.252921313,
-0.4286325872,
-0.2057975233,
0.5704245567,
-0.6959231496,
0.4500191212,
0.1527575403,
0.5215211511,
0.3097088337,
-0.4397521317,
-0.3479787409,
-1.0865877867,
0.8492242694,
-0.4136912227,
0.6805784106,
0.3911109269,
0.2907873094,
0.3050909042,
-0.8256143332,
-0.4213330746,
-0.0602997877,
0.1497913152,
-0.1172101051,
-0.3080865145,
-0.2613367736,
0.5536500812,
0.5716974139,
-0.4102443159,
-0.2159966826,
-0.4982862473,
-0.3036331236,
0.6503044367,
-0.0745406151,
0.1515570283,
0.1485614926,
-0.3600777686,
-0.3575481474,
-0.6993923187,
-0.0833847076,
0.2023813277,
0.4678417742,
0.2598139644,
0.4744716287,
-0.2894273102,
0.6668874621,
0.5911930799,
0.0389899127,
0.5927468538,
-0.5373969674,
-0.1351073533,
0.3917497396,
0.5409780741,
0.222954765,
-0.0033395679,
-0.311959058,
-0.2875473797,
-0.3847285211,
0.650398314,
-0.8260008097,
-0.0625355691,
-0.0096487841,
-0.5686390996,
-0.0089531187,
-0.0931178704,
-0.687705934,
-0.3395328522,
-0.604279995,
0.5993405581,
-0.2921059132,
0.2608960867,
0.1041119248,
-0.0700033307,
0.0305143092,
0.4061018229,
-0.9009444118,
0.3093517125,
0.4335711598,
0.7860050797,
-0.4028308392,
-0.0515085869,
-1.0266466141,
0.4261209965,
0.0282105934,
0.8235626817,
-0.3639032543,
-0.713383317,
-0.2086347491,
-0.0372212045,
0.141381532,
-1.0803586245,
0.5950439572,
-0.7742235065,
-0.007486606,
-0.6735768318,
-0.4169937074,
-0.1055992842,
0.1206852794,
-0.7275733948,
0.6961367726,
-0.2260884196,
-0.5987614393,
0.431250006,
-0.5122700334,
-0.5745338202,
-0.0548649803,
0.0327266753,
-0.4937329292,
0.0333112627,
0.3402152061,
0.2527612448,
-0.1851177961,
0.0364980958,
-0.1109680906,
-0.4177147746,
0.0068777008,
-0.2675709724,
0.4738403261,
0.4163090885,
-0.4938618541,
0.1019549891,
-0.9339427352,
-0.1390015632,
-0.1391616762,
-0.8368400931,
-0.3870608211,
0.0575780421,
0.3880065084,
-0.0831383616,
0.3983872533,
-0.5854920149,
0.1040780246,
-0.5291446447,
0.3248623013,
0.5960153937,
-0.082825236,
0.9494611025,
-0.3401628733,
0.3126071095,
0.0584742092,
-0.057554353,
-0.0976675376,
-0.0817142203,
-0.7695162296,
-0.2175430954,
0.2604597211,
0.5583131909,
-0.4324745238,
0.6050704122,
-0.3921640217,
-0.2439004183,
-0.444280237,
0.2658433914,
0.7098787427,
0.665261209,
0.587577045,
-0.8922650814,
-0.5929226279,
-0.8010926843,
-0.4738360047,
0.0852537081,
-0.6744501591,
0.9351431727,
-0.0027454742,
-0.5360338688,
1.1455565691,
-0.4535749555,
-1.0244754553,
-0.0144609315,
-0.0103492038,
0.0122335898,
0.5433893204,
0.2463906705,
-0.9209285975,
-0.5263906717,
0.1856567711,
-0.4858231544,
-0.0382905863,
0.0080807405,
0.0727704912,
0.0918378606,
0.538318038,
-0.1951536238,
0.2508569062,
0.1419457346,
-0.2574607134,
0.1517738104,
-0.4367664158,
-0.0701535344,
-0.8918460608,
0.3097215295,
0.1366064847,
-0.1880014986,
-0.6523616314,
-0.1714955568,
0.0037612354,
-0.106259793,
-0.3778802156,
0.6681696177,
-0.6154649854,
-0.3778979778,
-0.1115207225,
0.1089722142,
-0.1193885952,
0.2032523453,
-0.0448540039,
0.9389827847,
0.1755359173,
-0.6529803872,
0.1509282887,
0.5996252894,
-0.0405094139,
0.8256016374,
-0.7735894918,
0.5147170424,
-0.2690216005,
0.5074003935,
-0.6418796182,
-0.1312917769,
-0.1805737168,
-0.2579690814,
0.5711306334,
-0.083241798,
-0.3159069121,
-0.229008466,
-0.286542207,
0.3154682219,
0.491435051,
-0.8702297211,
0.8041658401,
0.6174758077,
-0.1689179689,
-0.572509706,
-0.4648695588,
-0.0124444431,
-0.3355629742,
-0.3467814624,
0.4030917287,
-0.325935483,
-0.0316545814,
-0.3050771058,
-0.3868517578,
-0.1374767721,
-0.212077722,
0.0853341296,
-0.2070358247,
-0.1759826988,
0.1701464802,
-0.1011665314,
-0.0693615973,
-0.2479085475,
-0.5281361341,
0.4216427803,
-0.1168584973,
-0.097333543,
-0.5562726259,
0.1981741637,
0.5162488222,
-0.3576815724,
0.3424396515,
0.7695830464,
-0.271070838,
-0.0478383675,
-0.8992973566,
-0.2506254911,
-0.5203601122,
0.411029309,
-0.3565815985,
-0.8721009493,
0.4689517021,
0.0187473111,
0.0496769883,
0.2371036559,
0.5349333286,
0.0472201556,
0.9884171486,
0.522507906,
-0.7117130756,
0.775677681,
-0.2053783536,
-0.0696840882,
-1.2641662359,
-0.2532209456,
-0.675346911,
-0.5287489295,
-0.1206749305,
-0.5527516007,
0.3738987148,
-0.1001914889,
-0.304038316,
0.3191027045,
-0.8243404031,
0.521361649,
0.8323836923,
0.1697936505,
0.4711404443,
0.4338337779,
0.195582971,
-0.093111515,
-0.4297729135,
-0.3379122615,
1.3651058674,
0.2696317732,
0.8001374006,
0.158956185,
0.5964891315,
0.4201984406,
0.1679582447,
-0.8575097322,
0.3463953137,
-0.6490675807,
-0.5695582628,
-0.5740711093,
-0.4595642388,
-1.0595737696,
0.3371318281,
0.0210543927,
-0.7349844575,
0.3260221183,
0.5929597616,
-0.4858253002,
0.0737017021,
-0.5958735943,
0.611843586,
0.1265210509,
-0.2174402326,
-0.1949386895,
-0.904181838,
-0.0636284873,
-0.2495031357,
0.1224531829,
0.2545645833,
-0.0693421438,
0.930971384,
-0.2386924028,
0.6631106138,
-0.1986683011,
0.144276306,
0.1329260021,
-0.1455060989,
0.5630909204,
-0.1363500059,
-0.1931161284,
-0.0508767478,
-0.0303810667,
-0.1352420747,
-0.4805796742,
0.6948755383,
-0.9138766527,
-0.3594786525,
-0.0623831004,
-0.5452134013,
-0.2334795892,
0.1835861206,
0.4130712748,
0.6041550636,
-0.259547919,
0.6512532234,
1.1182540655,
-0.1495111734,
0.1106200144,
0.6331395507,
0.1676092744,
-0.305367887,
1.1676752567,
0.2344933748,
0.0658539534,
0.4993217289,
0.3540500998,
-0.3603502214,
-0.4900756776,
-0.4550671875,
0.1185062826,
-0.5854520798,
0.0233580973,
-1.0801233053,
-0.0388105065,
-0.3387570083,
-0.1939383596,
-0.5414187312,
-0.3575206101,
-0.8892302513,
0.3265807331,
0.3079026937,
0.6382625103,
-0.0642650053,
0.5207548738,
-0.8280290365,
0.3233993053,
0.5535022616,
0.1402336061,
0.3363784552,
-1.0635129213,
-0.136977002,
-0.1451395005,
-0.3673759997,
-0.4050343037,
0.504964292,
0.6218573451,
0.3591098189,
0.4953785837,
-0.060869731,
0.7680497766,
-0.8750624657,
0.6036350727,
0.0421939977,
-1.0201927423,
0.5921450257,
-0.3214845955,
0.6233695149,
0.630645752,
0.2417915761,
-0.5913282633,
-0.1445002854,
-0.6444206834,
-1.1214263439,
0.8319448233,
-0.0631378368,
0.2947288752,
0.2350827307,
0.5760175586,
-0.1046304628,
0.1777952313,
-0.3546788394,
-0.4076957405,
-0.0385614522,
-0.2265677154,
-0.4272683859,
-0.4569858313,
-0.0854835138,
-0.2054140717,
0.666847527,
-0.1942144334,
0.1631047428,
0.3401371539,
-0.2134319395,
-0.1138236895,
0.2698081136,
0.6418642998,
0.4035663903,
-0.2425046712,
-0.026757434,
0.2986583412,
-0.9383752942,
0.0791164786,
0.1059765592,
-0.2819859385,
-0.0704051331,
0.0189811401,
0.7899557948,
0.3091040254,
-0.7079637647,
0.543900311,
-0.1905341595,
0.1156172305,
-0.4270298481,
0.0652752444,
-0.0081011662,
0.439280808,
0.5210698247,
0.179765135,
0.6370708942,
-0.4249609709,
0.5030725598,
0.3708186746,
-0.6591439843,
-0.3477514088,
1.0360213518,
0.1673624068,
-0.499219507,
0.6621030569,
-0.0206261538,
-0.3462769985,
0.4805299342,
0.4791862965,
0.7735293508,
-0.4332163036,
-0.1742210239,
0.534858942,
-0.0118989525,
-0.5700716972,
-0.0778426975,
-0.3131324947,
-0.765623033,
0.0990135223,
-0.6543643475,
-0.451068908,
0.022345623,
-1.1380754709,
0.0190741345,
-0.4977091849,
-0.2886843979,
0.0687150285,
-0.0838925913,
-0.5693979859,
0.4015406072,
-0.1349639744,
0.6557129025,
-0.4498819411,
0.8794898987,
0.6651031971,
-0.2675206661,
-0.8872882128,
0.0217627864,
0.2312737703,
-0.6099129319,
0.9312422872,
0.0190651007,
0.062877588,
0.1252369881,
-0.2237747908,
-1.2048357725,
1.1166633368,
0.1231279746,
-0.9091377854,
-0.1665161997,
-0.3232354224,
0.6525087357,
-0.3765943646,
-0.136905089,
0.717741847,
-0.0281053539,
0.5440920591,
-1.1326857805,
-0.0400729068,
-0.0064687929,
0.2925252318,
-0.0221981928,
-0.5255388021,
0.6711403131,
-0.2761034667,
-0.0540232472,
-0.0883156881,
0.5655183792,
0.2870317996,
0.2545136511,
0.6411398053,
0.4615419507,
0.8361067176,
0.2222098708,
1.0956426859,
-0.0490923673,
0.2931693792,
1.452350378,
-0.4537443519,
1.0996031761,
0.3970361054,
-0.1238605231,
-0.046700608,
0.245294556,
-0.0438149571,
0.6914395094,
0.2155468911,
-0.4601531923,
0.0929829553,
-0.1786769778,
-0.3940272033,
0.3771736324,
0.1445563585,
-0.5319247842,
0.2933940589,
0.2125276774,
-0.0746300817,
-0.1140898094,
-0.4561390281,
1.1124243736,
0.0975203067,
-0.374296546,
0.4786429405,
-0.2918950319,
0.7323205471,
-0.3631390631,
0.2554071546,
-0.1308272332,
0.5293411613,
-0.0978636965,
-0.2151896954,
0.3549922407,
0.0194854643,
-0.6520538926,
-0.4202817678,
0.6588904858,
-0.5571274757,
-0.3927744329,
0.2238338739,
0.1249097362,
0.152642116,
-0.1764396876,
-0.3988642991,
0.2782298326,
0.2886112928,
-0.3524321914,
0.5914483666,
0.2266344279,
-0.09294153,
0.8779277802,
0.7408239841,
0.3216864169,
0.1999245286,
0.2387535274,
0.798609376,
-0.4707807899,
-0.6526082754,
-0.4866692722,
0.3185913563,
-0.1008654758,
-0.1386172622,
0.5864437819,
0.6885370016,
0.9676613212,
-0.2539617121,
0.6290786862,
0.2588453293,
0.8991498351,
-0.1907848865,
0.8931635022,
-0.7471734881,
0.4288785756,
-0.2995465398,
-0.8588951826,
-0.483272016,
0.8537248373,
-0.1476159096,
-0.1308417767,
0.4374705553,
0.5715942979,
-0.0196848288,
-0.0919510797,
0.2324534506,
0.330281496,
0.3448061645,
0.2911840975,
0.3939063847,
-0.5132242441,
0.6336600184,
-0.0942256302,
-0.2779167891,
-0.2983186841,
-0.6014656425,
-0.7625542283,
-0.5340830684,
-0.4956156313,
-0.322167635,
0.0175547227,
0.8993795514,
0.848311305,
-0.8315545917,
-0.3780579567,
0.3143238723,
-0.2721685469,
-0.0538180023,
-0.1635320336,
0.4002739489,
-0.1654592007,
-0.6270307899,
0.3261243999,
0.31169945,
0.1138105541,
0.0001713897,
0.0218086429,
0.1727294028,
-0.058810249,
0.8048991561,
0.5590919852,
-0.7622681856,
-0.3885758519,
-0.0971097872,
0.0737537444,
0.1752285957,
0.7870825529,
-0.8910678029,
0.8070505261,
0.2351559103,
0.8510817289,
0.8305661678,
0.2832034528,
0.6299844384,
-0.8942872286,
0.1232337579,
0.3105499744,
0.1184929758,
0.4402776361,
-0.4988139272,
0.405115068,
0.1021559015,
-0.7535241246,
-0.8867743015,
-0.0386050344,
-1.1652290821,
0.232433483,
1.1160254478,
-0.0905463248,
0.103344582,
-0.0070071518,
-0.3986983597,
0.248576805,
-0.6561719179,
0.9190881848,
0.3028995395,
0.0451996289,
0.073639743,
-0.3743887246,
0.5201157928,
0.3718584776,
-0.5955747962,
0.1189830452,
0.525739491,
0.5615386367,
0.3676470816,
0.8983041644,
-0.0295882411,
0.1343210489,
-0.2979032397,
-0.012303846,
0.292185694,
-0.2215371728,
-0.8132632375,
0.2427011132,
0.1204723343,
-0.102891326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08401v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08401v1
|
Fine-tuning Language Models for Factuality
| 2023-11-14T18:59:15 | 2023-11-14T18:59:15 |
Katherine Tian, Eric Mitchell, Huaxiu Yao, Christopher D. Manning, Chelsea Finn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The fluency and creativity of large pre-trained language models (LLMs) have
led to their widespread use, sometimes even as a replacement for traditional
search engines. Yet language models are prone to making convincing but
factually inaccurate claims, often referred to as 'hallucinations.' These
errors can inadvertently spread misinformation or harmfully perpetuate
misconceptions. Further, manual fact-checking of model responses is a
time-consuming process, making human factuality labels expensive to acquire. In
this work, we fine-tune language models to be more factual, without human
labeling and targeting more open-ended generation settings than past work. We
leverage two key recent innovations in NLP to do so. First, several recent
works have proposed methods for judging the factuality of open-ended text by
measuring consistency with an external knowledge base or simply a large model's
confidence scores. Second, the direct preference optimization algorithm enables
straightforward fine-tuning of language models on objectives other than
supervised imitation, using a preference ranking over possible model responses.
We show that learning from automatically generated factuality preference
rankings, generated either through existing retrieval systems or our novel
retrieval-free approach, significantly improves the factuality (percent of
generated claims that are correct) of Llama-2 on held-out topics compared with
RLHF or decoding strategies targeted at factuality. At 7B scale, compared to
Llama-2-chat, we observe 58% and 40% reduction in factual error rate when
generating biographies and answering medical questions, respectively.
|
[
-0.2501599491,
-0.8641834259,
0.7067137361,
0.0250686537,
-0.169443205,
-0.0763826147,
-0.5651593804,
-0.4967039227,
0.092294246,
0.7087513804,
-0.305718869,
-0.5001087785,
-0.5957843661,
0.1893255264,
-0.0849639773,
1.1843910217,
0.3262482882,
-0.1910219342,
-0.3281934559,
-0.3566745222,
-0.2608963549,
-0.4545856118,
-0.4337312281,
-0.306296438,
0.5807977319,
0.3976466358,
1.0693615675,
0.8444892168,
0.3739442229,
0.2007312477,
-0.1312446445,
0.7438032627,
-0.6583118439,
-0.0014504867,
-0.4663897455,
-0.5937677622,
-0.3130807877,
0.2138745338,
0.3856151402,
0.7838113308,
-0.1400996745,
0.2474413812,
-0.0929624662,
0.6347205043,
-0.5773487091,
0.2733419836,
-0.9839255214,
-0.0021800569,
-0.0084564388,
-0.4695718884,
-0.7044681311,
-0.7393894792,
0.1193366572,
-0.3431019485,
0.5335642099,
0.3114173412,
1.0797986984,
0.5063865185,
-0.2645254135,
-0.4389878809,
-0.8263946176,
0.7101222873,
-0.9202988148,
0.4265600741,
0.5154075027,
-0.0157093052,
-0.2262323648,
-0.4764714241,
-0.6417748332,
-0.5845841765,
-0.3141418695,
-0.3003948033,
-0.0484769195,
0.1994229555,
0.3690004647,
0.2120225877,
-0.5022506714,
0.25208354,
-0.202447474,
-0.2999019921,
0.6199108958,
-0.1127785221,
0.2696693838,
-0.2072400749,
0.0767270997,
0.0167029258,
-0.7741266489,
-0.0221414771,
0.3031104803,
0.5112192631,
0.0551994294,
0.8019866943,
-0.4105312824,
0.6739661694,
0.2988981605,
-0.414634198,
0.0394758135,
-0.3259765506,
-0.2075106353,
0.1608807892,
0.4338243306,
0.5148720741,
0.2006916255,
-0.3642167151,
-0.1148542017,
0.26859501,
0.2201141715,
-0.6952800155,
-0.2600918412,
0.266256839,
-0.2915390432,
-0.4392237663,
-0.1421445906,
-0.4896630049,
-0.4906704724,
-0.5695829391,
0.3410487175,
-0.3258514702,
-0.035623949,
0.4412358701,
0.2051602304,
-0.0005263499,
0.4196677506,
-0.9825586677,
0.1046262458,
0.7048699856,
0.6891444921,
0.0509736165,
0.0299080368,
-0.5855720639,
-0.0112985289,
-0.5837708712,
0.9155854583,
-0.4045532048,
-0.1122067273,
-0.0189359933,
-0.1366492361,
0.0652417541,
-0.6143257022,
0.7107679844,
-0.5609076023,
0.3072915971,
-0.481600821,
-0.5963483453,
-0.3309042156,
0.3408387601,
-0.5082317591,
0.821130991,
-0.2996403277,
-0.7248855233,
0.5082595944,
-0.418084234,
-0.3451592624,
-0.1849704385,
-0.0336634703,
-0.298029393,
0.17225492,
0.2068323493,
0.4867842793,
-0.2392931879,
0.7406020164,
-0.2201392353,
-0.1667847633,
0.0979651734,
-0.453155607,
0.5962408781,
0.131487757,
-0.3719675541,
0.0806582123,
-0.9424946904,
-0.042627722,
-0.0586584695,
-0.406837523,
-0.2481331527,
0.1798143089,
-0.3576723635,
0.1012039632,
0.2288365811,
-0.4683371782,
0.1215389594,
-0.6939337254,
0.0909616649,
0.5584619045,
-0.1643959731,
0.2164115459,
-0.5125361681,
0.0114408433,
-0.1370179206,
0.0173062477,
0.0928494707,
-0.4838064313,
-1.0373132229,
-0.1775994301,
0.2807705402,
0.5490284562,
-0.4810141027,
0.7442278266,
-0.3184700906,
-0.419198215,
-0.6410165429,
0.1343726218,
0.1879925579,
0.8794314265,
0.3977376223,
-0.2020441741,
-0.6473904848,
-0.9693722129,
-0.444750607,
-0.4406796098,
0.1105554849,
0.3394112289,
0.2852055728,
-0.2621499598,
1.0430662632,
-0.5172505379,
-0.007273518,
-0.0273512434,
0.2526451051,
0.2107420117,
0.2624833286,
0.3825491369,
-0.7359298468,
-0.217308566,
-0.0518205017,
-0.7710583806,
-0.1177222654,
-0.1399770379,
0.1399552822,
0.4907811582,
0.2052496523,
-0.7374185324,
0.2495934218,
0.3593417406,
-0.2787000835,
0.6158373356,
-0.3578103483,
0.1389219314,
-0.6786189079,
0.1453062147,
-0.0253275875,
-0.3220754564,
-0.5700045824,
0.0650344938,
-0.0511567146,
0.1741355211,
-0.2061997354,
0.4513768256,
-0.1641984284,
0.1307262629,
-0.2621977925,
0.153023988,
0.0448783934,
0.3391234875,
0.0332835577,
0.6349574924,
0.2323680669,
-0.6363333464,
0.1937141418,
0.2359580696,
-0.3879620731,
0.1951664835,
-0.4456931353,
0.2259695679,
-0.3897368908,
0.1990988404,
-0.7377681732,
-0.4257625043,
0.0679143593,
-0.3095344901,
0.2800471485,
-0.1173842847,
-0.6621168852,
-0.0252226479,
-0.2821382284,
0.0321917236,
0.4710660279,
-0.7164872289,
0.3692162633,
0.1933958083,
-0.0715126917,
-0.674369216,
-0.3810593784,
0.2732025087,
0.0922274664,
-0.6516051292,
0.1136612147,
-0.0471224152,
-0.3938005567,
-0.0701079816,
-0.1819703579,
0.0846418664,
0.078749001,
-0.0473305956,
0.3178308606,
-0.3091369271,
0.174941808,
0.0088132927,
0.0339302719,
-0.0117472848,
-0.2152452767,
0.4156647325,
-0.279264003,
-0.2012981623,
-0.359641999,
-0.1116662771,
0.4840341806,
-0.2085294425,
0.9708347917,
0.307156235,
-0.4178451598,
-0.1227878034,
-0.9912846684,
-0.3306157589,
-0.4351909757,
0.2557165325,
-0.0526106581,
-0.9744454622,
0.145985797,
-0.0374455787,
0.2345035672,
0.4093081653,
0.6027302146,
0.041444622,
0.9547802806,
0.7021490932,
0.1753001362,
-0.0116838114,
0.0870201811,
0.481895268,
-0.2540551126,
-0.2714995742,
-0.4605234861,
0.0200588666,
-0.7315236926,
-0.4510241747,
0.289392978,
0.0095983008,
-0.0367906988,
0.1511952728,
-0.319034189,
0.617092371,
0.3723191023,
0.2431848794,
0.5786325932,
0.024262201,
-0.0501163788,
-0.1655106097,
-0.6838136911,
-0.8572543859,
1.1429378986,
0.2757242918,
0.462069571,
0.029874118,
0.4118717313,
0.3504997492,
0.4199853539,
-0.6884357929,
0.4976719022,
-0.1516384482,
-0.6925849319,
-0.2318840027,
-0.3915522397,
-0.4920191765,
0.1541430652,
-0.6059084535,
-0.6212125421,
0.194301635,
0.4969352484,
-0.6354061365,
0.4212731719,
-0.506447196,
0.4460747242,
-0.1638195962,
-0.3778297305,
-0.4027704298,
-0.7108638287,
0.6399321556,
-0.1123027131,
0.216461271,
-0.351202786,
0.2238899022,
0.3814183176,
-0.2505189776,
0.9335041642,
0.0615766719,
-0.2882251441,
0.0509490184,
0.1825979799,
0.5429035425,
0.2666619718,
-0.2143300772,
0.1245331094,
-0.1226187572,
-0.218553856,
-0.6886919737,
0.5864508152,
-0.6168422103,
-0.8204270601,
-0.2830723524,
-0.458180517,
-0.4249339104,
0.1302782148,
0.2060505003,
0.4010552168,
-0.2776123881,
0.255969435,
1.0918254852,
-0.3540088832,
0.0479676016,
0.5359686613,
-0.143208921,
-0.2292398512,
0.9463500977,
0.0658818036,
0.2459741533,
0.3761585951,
0.3250685036,
-0.426969558,
-0.5317077041,
-0.327183187,
0.5095182657,
-0.6367819309,
-0.1092920527,
-0.8969095349,
-0.1670751721,
-0.4888602495,
-0.0730973855,
-0.5070447326,
-0.5683233738,
-0.3522194624,
-0.2539087832,
0.2227738947,
0.5598392487,
-0.3527318835,
0.0541509241,
-0.5870746374,
0.6000896096,
0.313539207,
0.3929177225,
-0.2127350718,
-0.7269467711,
-0.1620675474,
0.1463866085,
-0.1419256926,
-0.4790107906,
0.2272418886,
0.2857555449,
0.1791796535,
0.4550460875,
0.1034627482,
0.4756762683,
-0.5948421359,
0.6363279819,
-0.0491440669,
-0.7140116692,
0.6093030572,
-0.2465486825,
-0.1794084013,
0.6346489787,
0.3436584473,
-0.5242622495,
-0.2891970873,
-0.6116276383,
-0.4587097168,
0.5722237825,
0.2059091628,
0.0574475341,
-0.0051525948,
0.5870931149,
0.3352647722,
0.3316925764,
-0.6229967475,
-0.2291768789,
-0.1686087698,
-0.2864097357,
-0.1658894718,
-0.4695967138,
-0.314675957,
-0.2991850674,
0.8414910436,
-0.2550928891,
-0.1236067861,
0.2390079051,
-0.0937113687,
-0.1090717763,
0.3498607278,
0.7373586297,
0.6870304346,
-0.3956728876,
0.2797192037,
0.1787483543,
-0.2497120649,
0.1129495576,
0.0282056071,
-0.5361454487,
0.1449667066,
0.2951325774,
0.8793489337,
0.1518948227,
-0.7122461796,
0.3002156019,
0.0241316017,
-0.0562615171,
0.0308383014,
0.2582110465,
0.0240451936,
0.1207935661,
0.0300398525,
0.370785743,
0.0871794671,
-0.7019117475,
0.1133704334,
0.4080892503,
-0.1165505499,
-0.4319806993,
0.7020810246,
0.130898118,
-0.189455837,
0.3724551797,
-0.1064014435,
-0.3589060903,
0.3475910723,
0.5159762502,
0.6511858702,
0.0090813246,
0.3801419735,
0.4520579278,
0.5623392463,
-0.5205295682,
0.0937267914,
0.1667927802,
-1.0239977837,
-0.4754500091,
-0.7179223299,
-0.6071727276,
0.2739836276,
-0.4690625668,
0.3796527982,
-0.6201735735,
-0.1608073413,
-0.0462495647,
0.0591586605,
-0.4954783618,
0.5300473571,
0.1984842569,
0.7413711548,
-0.683221519,
0.6399268508,
0.4131058156,
-0.2390321493,
-0.5507525206,
0.0405912176,
-0.0934607312,
-0.6208384037,
0.431932807,
0.1676166952,
-0.3650227785,
0.0274384879,
-0.8909332752,
-0.9098790288,
0.5956915617,
0.7849346399,
-0.5764645934,
-0.1817639768,
0.1553748995,
0.5914359093,
-0.2214220315,
0.0587316081,
0.7338709831,
0.4871178567,
-0.2135530114,
-0.8428114653,
0.091222696,
0.1077987328,
-0.1796839833,
-0.191991508,
-0.5999504328,
0.4698327184,
-0.531575501,
-0.255940944,
0.0041339286,
0.8069834709,
0.3629114032,
0.208725065,
0.4841976464,
0.4898133874,
1.2100387812,
-0.0189083442,
0.914047718,
-0.3569797873,
0.3400236666,
1.1315333843,
-0.3335921168,
0.661098659,
0.2645716369,
0.0509434678,
0.4629582167,
0.4854626954,
0.0347674564,
0.3924026489,
-0.0159806814,
-0.1931435168,
-0.4460034668,
-0.2928737104,
-0.1396092474,
0.4463779926,
0.3940662742,
-0.1410402507,
-0.2456948012,
-0.153516978,
0.2884555459,
0.4045586288,
0.0381410196,
0.5739223957,
-0.0689868778,
-0.75188905,
0.7834197283,
0.1954180002,
0.7564663291,
-0.4251399934,
-0.0540293753,
-0.2769734859,
-0.0931870043,
-0.3479476869,
-0.3443705738,
0.2675921917,
0.2323585749,
-0.5112705231,
-0.0189587045,
0.7316455841,
-0.5084833503,
-0.4144198596,
-0.0383051075,
0.401674211,
0.031973958,
0.0462768637,
-0.3719757795,
-0.0429864712,
0.0707287341,
-0.0563309975,
-0.0005392981,
0.3091451526,
0.0680572614,
0.7053580284,
0.747166574,
0.2981517315,
-0.0485075228,
-0.056511879,
0.5715575814,
-0.5951197147,
-0.1780918241,
-0.86037606,
0.13121894,
-0.1025913134,
-0.2274956852,
0.6763148308,
0.564150393,
0.8481079936,
-0.0398048386,
0.8082867861,
0.1236389279,
0.6904720068,
-0.7121580839,
0.8813118935,
-0.441608578,
0.2208230793,
-0.0271934438,
-0.6888179779,
-0.5180364251,
0.4925573468,
-0.2403763682,
-0.2212691307,
0.5807702541,
1.0606638193,
0.0056287223,
0.1218585745,
0.3943471909,
0.4854934216,
0.3374323547,
0.0509252436,
0.6454703212,
-0.1987308264,
0.2250471711,
-0.3209251165,
-0.2551481426,
-0.3884852529,
-0.9586439729,
-0.9368730783,
-0.2442256361,
-0.4440097213,
-0.4337590039,
0.2721125185,
1.1959984303,
0.5460928082,
-0.9350450039,
-0.0052086366,
0.1258302629,
0.1699097902,
0.0499009043,
-0.1540780216,
0.3746163547,
-0.5887355208,
-0.5618872046,
0.5609026551,
0.3107281327,
-0.0438114814,
-0.1667288393,
0.1095142365,
-0.2027521431,
0.4746345282,
0.6964830756,
0.3636764288,
-0.9370709658,
-0.6240000725,
-0.0081231575,
-0.1287710369,
0.2344705611,
0.6052080393,
-0.7222713232,
0.4540903568,
0.2922626436,
0.6552972198,
0.080287002,
0.1287853122,
0.520670414,
-0.6103194356,
0.0928500295,
0.2015770823,
0.1902730316,
0.6485353708,
-0.5628293753,
0.3960283995,
0.4309951365,
-0.4408206344,
-1.0309836864,
0.1567987204,
-0.7320167422,
-0.1663941294,
1.0423213243,
0.1988535821,
-0.1012449116,
-0.1788301617,
-0.2622837126,
0.3868555725,
-0.1273809373,
1.214184761,
0.6845796108,
-0.0591811538,
0.3203860819,
-0.5675420165,
0.8920708895,
0.5612764955,
-0.7280035615,
0.1849959344,
0.5649048686,
0.3171332181,
0.21595034,
0.4169570506,
0.0885234922,
0.1855044663,
-0.2797450423,
0.076334767,
0.075473994,
-0.5292754173,
-0.2041235119,
0.0751459748,
0.2448797822,
0.2929704487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08398v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08398v2
|
Are Large Language Models Temporally Grounded?
| 2023-11-14T18:57:15 | 2023-11-16T09:41:28 |
Yifu Qiu, Zheng Zhao, Yftah Ziser, Anna Korhonen, Edoardo M. Ponti, Shay B. Cohen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Are Large language models (LLMs) temporally grounded? Since LLMs cannot
perceive and interact with the environment, it is impossible to answer this
question directly. Instead, we provide LLMs with textual narratives and probe
them with respect to their common-sense knowledge of the structure and duration
of events, their ability to order events along a timeline, and self-consistency
within their temporal model (e.g., temporal relations such as after and before
are mutually exclusive for any pair of events). We evaluate state-of-the-art
LLMs (such as LLaMA 2 and GPT-4) on three tasks reflecting these abilities.
Generally, we find that LLMs lag significantly behind both human performance as
well as small-scale, specialised LMs. In-context learning, instruction tuning,
and chain-of-thought prompting reduce this gap only to a limited degree.
Crucially, LLMs struggle the most with self-consistency, displaying incoherent
behaviour in at least 27.23% of their predictions. Contrary to expectations, we
also find that scaling the model size does not guarantee positive gains in
performance. To explain these results, we study the sources from which LLMs may
gather temporal information: we find that sentence ordering in unlabelled
texts, available during pre-training, is only weakly correlated with event
ordering. Moreover, public instruction tuning mixtures contain few temporal
tasks. Hence, we conclude that current LLMs lack a consistent temporal model of
textual narratives. Code, datasets, and LLM outputs are available at
https://github.com/yfqiu-nlp/temporal-llms.
|
[
0.0048465924,
-0.9503644109,
1.0226145983,
0.447193861,
-0.1055232286,
0.2036393434,
-0.4027422369,
-0.4924177825,
-0.0268479977,
0.3475332558,
-0.5863961577,
-0.3760001957,
-0.575612247,
-0.0269849375,
-0.5081846118,
0.7647936344,
0.0758188963,
-0.1417402327,
-0.2518773079,
-0.2306918949,
-0.3489975631,
-0.9224646688,
-0.5651599169,
-0.8051081896,
0.4735688269,
0.1011258811,
0.618821919,
0.8854213357,
0.0550872721,
0.2544327974,
-0.533972621,
0.0001417011,
-0.4941016138,
0.1703579575,
-0.2593590617,
-0.3997315168,
-0.4941547513,
0.094578445,
0.8246914148,
0.8670915365,
-0.1359157115,
0.1951333135,
0.075052239,
0.4621298909,
-0.4636590779,
0.1865797341,
-0.5421137214,
0.1235291734,
-0.1608724445,
-0.3118798137,
-0.4145960212,
-0.1976680756,
0.0050865407,
-0.3775451481,
-0.0328799449,
0.1707060188,
0.9333662987,
0.2782326043,
-0.6304575205,
-0.1733556539,
-0.7858736515,
0.7724384069,
-0.7741927505,
0.4042536318,
0.5376476645,
0.0332688764,
-0.3458530009,
-0.668979764,
-0.5014609694,
-0.3944202363,
0.0044816067,
0.0827316493,
0.0422823615,
-0.0170483459,
0.5276674032,
0.205022946,
-0.4497056305,
0.7040202022,
0.0540268719,
0.0944450647,
0.1834822446,
0.4529647827,
0.3799073696,
-0.1569157541,
-0.4305156767,
0.218675673,
-1.0135990381,
0.3049596548,
0.3633780777,
-0.0488803089,
-0.2087191641,
0.842484951,
0.0103256227,
0.4969091415,
0.1402770579,
-0.4294276536,
-0.0065449346,
-0.1734354794,
-0.2562735975,
0.1318330169,
0.7174590826,
0.4260892868,
0.4956187904,
-0.2350151241,
-0.3144910932,
0.1635421813,
0.0775739327,
-0.6531527042,
0.1750530005,
0.2147939801,
-0.2730838656,
-0.2770552933,
-0.287319392,
-0.4887958467,
-0.3158664405,
-0.5233795047,
0.1549407691,
-0.1732235551,
-0.1190600544,
0.02635419,
0.1814872772,
0.2117655277,
0.1998010427,
-0.9585185647,
0.4188103378,
0.7311251163,
0.7711817622,
-0.1814313233,
-0.5573351383,
-0.4949771762,
0.4294328392,
-0.5945284367,
0.5514942408,
-0.5546084046,
-0.1972902715,
0.011673755,
0.2076908797,
-0.0468520634,
-0.4087094665,
0.4386298954,
-0.5984345078,
0.2057767361,
-0.2823166549,
-0.5586217642,
0.1686911881,
0.2522096038,
-0.3095423877,
1.078663826,
-0.3203623295,
-0.7190028429,
0.3319473863,
-0.1315741092,
-0.3482365012,
-0.3519796133,
-0.3817055225,
-0.100981392,
0.2338766605,
0.3829427361,
0.6502935886,
-0.2936050296,
0.8041166067,
-0.2850142419,
-0.5499476194,
0.3138285577,
-0.6230620742,
0.5694975257,
0.0442465842,
-0.5394653082,
-0.0746340603,
-0.8619363904,
-0.0829180107,
0.3227459192,
-0.51776582,
-0.1308576614,
0.489964366,
-0.0473185852,
0.3244332969,
0.2571820617,
-0.3971908092,
0.3052743971,
-0.341155529,
0.7661629915,
0.9864628911,
0.0760599896,
0.4785948694,
-0.3835494518,
0.3278245032,
0.0137828561,
-0.1591044664,
-0.5874377489,
-0.1756214648,
-0.9032590389,
0.0316331089,
-0.1930541098,
0.4655081332,
-0.3446494341,
0.404066056,
-0.5133743286,
-0.2939021289,
0.0294851158,
0.090286985,
0.2417406738,
0.3958753347,
0.1477174461,
0.1118647829,
-0.3781087697,
-0.6718239784,
-0.3242397904,
-0.3896285295,
-0.0879700407,
0.1201956272,
0.3556550145,
-0.3000572324,
0.9902704358,
-0.1914711446,
0.0857502744,
-0.1055962816,
0.1601964384,
0.3344059289,
0.2281052172,
0.6160490513,
-0.404132545,
0.1120916754,
-0.104450509,
-1.0751556158,
-0.3939965665,
-0.2060988694,
0.5177676678,
0.4621144831,
0.7945628762,
-0.6370174885,
0.2165591568,
0.8307679296,
-0.507404387,
0.3732233942,
-0.2853941619,
0.0274418201,
-0.837086916,
-0.025221616,
-0.261958003,
-0.3380546272,
-0.3911432326,
-0.2370121628,
0.0352994315,
-0.0742501691,
-0.2048565447,
0.9046243429,
-0.5231195688,
-0.2655878961,
-0.3454368412,
0.2895186841,
0.0197779499,
0.4471489787,
0.1309030205,
0.56578058,
0.2547155321,
-0.7256588936,
-0.0273610167,
-0.2463538051,
-0.494921118,
0.3089690506,
-0.8964205384,
0.2437252998,
-0.251475662,
0.2704197764,
-0.827029705,
-0.2605433762,
-0.0248451177,
-0.2260525525,
0.3979649246,
-0.2534178495,
-0.7824142575,
0.0175621342,
0.1766421497,
0.2733013034,
0.5391625762,
-0.6049471498,
0.5547174215,
0.1871381104,
-0.3353664875,
-0.4442649186,
-0.7824403644,
0.1992965937,
-0.1284548491,
-0.4252282381,
0.1062531769,
0.0244039856,
-0.6256665587,
-0.1495430321,
-0.2675130665,
0.1020680591,
0.2296860367,
0.6500035524,
0.006800151,
-0.2767881751,
0.2941755056,
-0.0265481304,
-0.0484477989,
0.2326437384,
-0.3337167799,
0.4976564646,
-0.1306305528,
-0.4624067247,
-0.1728719026,
0.0651985481,
0.7413838506,
0.0041412949,
0.9803649187,
0.366513133,
-0.4844478667,
0.0404464118,
-0.8258923888,
0.0023432404,
-0.4252773523,
0.0975674391,
-0.1943849623,
-1.161423564,
0.4947725534,
0.0064532128,
0.1165025681,
0.5166125894,
0.606321156,
-0.2326221317,
0.756541431,
0.5138670206,
-0.176217556,
0.5271293521,
0.0918421224,
-0.057055112,
-0.6357825994,
-0.2283697426,
-0.3712472618,
-0.1563431323,
-0.4902480543,
-0.2048662156,
0.1759866476,
0.3375799656,
-0.6047255397,
-0.2592597902,
0.0242998526,
0.5173121691,
0.2146070898,
-0.2315449715,
0.419090718,
-0.1145388037,
-0.3113949299,
-0.2694681883,
-0.7196657062,
-0.9204435945,
0.769590199,
0.5592688918,
0.7451434731,
-0.1267871261,
0.3914769888,
0.0923936591,
0.0817153826,
-0.3712056875,
0.4908021092,
0.1948576719,
-0.5500876904,
-0.3286324739,
-0.3038152754,
-0.9915103316,
0.1090981141,
-0.1451799423,
-0.8850095868,
-0.034156166,
-0.1257697642,
-0.0788141266,
0.3128084242,
-0.6015264988,
0.5938842893,
-0.4824298918,
-0.462294966,
-0.1014990285,
-0.6886476874,
0.275719285,
-0.1226534322,
0.5255438089,
-0.5094064474,
-0.0332462117,
0.7354483008,
-0.2290839702,
1.141859293,
0.0616936311,
-0.2336085737,
0.1438890845,
0.2199282199,
0.5773565173,
0.2912919223,
0.1466377527,
0.2633000016,
0.0710404664,
-0.432302177,
-0.5086123347,
0.9019352794,
-0.9835210443,
-0.6605207324,
-0.6336957812,
-0.325450778,
-0.1714996547,
0.2116548121,
0.1832599044,
0.600173533,
-0.3204320371,
0.1674816161,
0.595467031,
-0.3578214645,
0.7423121929,
0.6663805842,
-0.4430056512,
-0.2345508337,
0.3619189262,
0.2616046965,
0.2923844159,
0.5885744691,
0.2709117532,
-0.1361834258,
-0.4852415621,
-0.0275727697,
0.3177085519,
-0.7572373748,
0.1511461735,
-0.7961781621,
-0.2622409761,
-0.2744181752,
-0.2677778304,
-0.4278606474,
-0.365404278,
-0.4233879149,
-0.3234261274,
0.2732296586,
1.0413608551,
0.2105323821,
0.3970295787,
-0.8118700981,
0.4395654202,
0.1064243987,
0.2492838651,
-0.0707586035,
-0.6705415845,
-0.0092148371,
-0.0458738953,
-0.0789974332,
-0.5112597346,
0.1745959073,
0.0969899148,
0.5481613278,
0.384090215,
-0.1700070202,
0.6558567286,
-0.9165568948,
1.0259007215,
-0.1207903698,
-0.8871716857,
0.5432602167,
-0.6469501257,
0.5287150145,
0.0305930767,
0.1641715765,
-0.5537662506,
-0.5416960716,
-0.6233917475,
-0.8270180225,
0.6101970673,
0.0812741295,
0.1495472044,
-0.3094858229,
0.5354847312,
-0.066507332,
0.187037766,
-0.855880022,
-0.1510403156,
-0.0836308226,
0.1436316222,
-0.6019072533,
-0.7866581082,
-0.0327197835,
-0.0192905404,
0.1774524301,
-0.0638179258,
0.1146114096,
0.0806426555,
-0.1540192366,
-0.1086038202,
0.4255716205,
0.721475184,
0.9138851762,
-0.1617913395,
0.2884666026,
0.2353858501,
-0.2303252816,
0.4180574119,
-0.2005819529,
-0.0046480196,
-0.1531327069,
0.8730511069,
0.6920989752,
0.7452191114,
-0.5947133899,
0.3679507077,
-0.0151518062,
0.0463675372,
-0.6349169016,
-0.1870080829,
0.3415076137,
0.6038938761,
0.2466013283,
-0.259408474,
-0.5345205665,
-0.6706820726,
-0.1870468408,
0.08017537,
-0.1067467853,
-0.4795012176,
0.820309341,
-0.115662992,
-0.2409336716,
0.6924546361,
0.1442474425,
-0.2951922715,
0.4880052209,
0.5709035993,
0.772652626,
-0.0030929644,
-0.1628371775,
0.1854899675,
0.6006385684,
-0.4376057982,
0.0040693502,
0.1749661714,
-0.6333909035,
-0.6766121387,
-0.7665059566,
-0.2591378093,
0.2058552206,
-0.4992688894,
0.0546636917,
-0.6579446197,
-0.2695381045,
-0.4347054064,
-0.0031402125,
-0.6315200925,
0.2010255158,
0.1462990195,
0.6787737012,
-0.7832148671,
0.7925871015,
0.4580228627,
-0.0162679441,
-0.4758937359,
0.0614502244,
0.1150148883,
-0.6075471044,
0.865531683,
0.1623780876,
-0.1356867254,
-0.0380708501,
-0.4686148167,
-0.9652838111,
1.1910431385,
0.4899485707,
-0.7908678651,
-0.3200966418,
-0.1108072251,
0.8154831529,
-0.2380342782,
0.1183193773,
0.2552420497,
0.2895347774,
-0.0244633108,
-0.8167430758,
-0.102129221,
0.0470579043,
-0.0062917168,
0.0733744875,
-0.7065013647,
0.6009678245,
-0.2152087837,
-0.4195786417,
0.0212988574,
0.717476666,
0.4257499874,
0.4027732909,
0.1362119615,
0.5620751977,
0.687738061,
-0.2772306204,
1.2227721214,
-0.2659163177,
0.0818831101,
1.2812979221,
-0.4308795631,
0.8272528052,
0.589661181,
-0.0772962272,
0.30832389,
0.6323661208,
0.3297782838,
0.209343791,
0.0205121078,
0.085905768,
-0.3473288119,
-0.0170550235,
-0.278616488,
0.3504909575,
0.3945792615,
-0.2838700414,
-0.1124874875,
-0.1254719198,
0.1630676091,
0.1379482299,
-0.2629103065,
0.6109480262,
0.3407107294,
-0.5707310438,
0.555044651,
0.0895274803,
0.367810905,
-0.6526768804,
0.2083090842,
-0.2913792729,
0.2117235959,
0.012925081,
-0.7649729252,
0.1087639257,
0.1177543327,
-0.3607858121,
-0.5418570638,
0.4780835509,
-0.2348335683,
-0.3238177896,
0.4148084223,
0.7149719,
0.0251784325,
0.1312599778,
-0.1732715368,
0.3398953378,
-0.525237143,
-0.6697793603,
0.5071114302,
0.7743374109,
-0.1037362665,
0.8795288801,
0.4411995411,
0.1744666696,
0.2269799709,
0.0924478099,
0.6297076941,
-0.8671066165,
-0.2379795313,
-1.1328415871,
0.1492864937,
0.2231946737,
-0.2847923338,
0.8190651536,
0.3124502301,
0.7826626897,
0.2365855128,
0.3668442965,
0.3846824765,
0.3160984516,
-1.1404511929,
0.5113385916,
-0.4222217798,
0.4791871905,
-0.0561725013,
-1.0339506865,
-0.0388349704,
0.344909668,
-0.342106998,
0.1652105302,
0.8017827272,
0.2820831239,
0.1389223635,
-0.1452962756,
0.4468664527,
0.4313535988,
0.4477333426,
0.4269641936,
1.1596856117,
-0.0364897884,
0.1212532893,
0.0935143903,
0.054022532,
-0.0859443396,
-1.0838859081,
-1.2861038446,
-0.3650752306,
-0.0420066416,
-0.1594456881,
0.2837618291,
1.0099025965,
0.3706894815,
-0.3199637532,
-0.2611924708,
0.0082826996,
-0.018299818,
0.0242021717,
-0.1875462085,
0.1978726834,
-0.4601630867,
-0.5853695273,
0.5633203983,
0.4928727448,
0.2213853002,
-0.1346004158,
0.0576685704,
-0.2068967074,
0.0582752489,
0.751414001,
0.2158279866,
-1.0136398077,
-0.4676580727,
0.1132050082,
-0.3105434477,
0.0128295645,
0.8710792065,
-0.8385893703,
0.1555938125,
0.2234219909,
0.6086274385,
0.4664627612,
-0.1671780795,
0.5552534461,
-0.8856189847,
0.2343482077,
0.1807956845,
0.5516886115,
0.2119497508,
-0.194723323,
0.4330671132,
0.2984609902,
-0.8723790646,
-0.7430102229,
0.1729588509,
-0.7849368453,
-0.1852937043,
1.5051248074,
-0.1154895872,
-0.1555144638,
0.043006219,
0.0655696765,
0.1799063087,
-0.0306991879,
0.6152532101,
1.2302091122,
0.2030079216,
-0.1846046001,
-0.8087628484,
0.2762557268,
0.31477198,
-0.6125647426,
0.1863417774,
0.5468366742,
0.5020802617,
-0.0324677341,
0.8153126836,
-0.0818057209,
-0.1905624717,
-0.099000819,
-0.2807186544,
-0.0356574915,
-0.6111031771,
-0.5116575956,
0.0025131325,
0.3323086798,
0.3890571594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08396v1
|
Zero-shot audio captioning with audio-language model guidance and audio context keywords
| 2023-11-14T18:55:48 | 2023-11-14T18:55:48 |
Leonard Salewski, Stefan Fauth, A. Sophia Koepke, Zeynep Akata
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Zero-shot audio captioning aims at automatically generating descriptive
textual captions for audio content without prior training for this task.
Different from speech recognition which translates audio content that contains
spoken language into text, audio captioning is commonly concerned with ambient
sounds, or sounds produced by a human performing an action. Inspired by
zero-shot image captioning methods, we propose ZerAuCap, a novel framework for
summarising such general audio signals in a text caption without requiring
task-specific training. In particular, our framework exploits a pre-trained
large language model (LLM) for generating the text which is guided by a
pre-trained audio-language model to produce captions that describe the audio
content. Additionally, we use audio context keywords that prompt the language
model to generate text that is broadly relevant to sounds. Our proposed
framework achieves state-of-the-art results in zero-shot audio captioning on
the AudioCaps and Clotho datasets. Our code is available at
https://github.com/ExplainableML/ZerAuCap.
|
[
-0.1517370343,
-0.5530169606,
0.5322191119,
0.0293065496,
-0.5485284328,
-0.130147934,
-0.2000895292,
-0.4502554834,
0.5879520178,
0.6999393702,
-0.8191244006,
-0.9231953025,
-0.2354471982,
0.0170090832,
-0.7300802469,
1.0668272972,
0.2107691765,
-0.0653341562,
-0.0091514159,
-0.3743221462,
-0.834666431,
-0.3051879406,
-0.2123437673,
-0.0971347541,
0.4135414362,
0.7326602936,
0.1957402825,
0.4716563523,
-0.1110109016,
0.1217452511,
0.2327434421,
-0.3739905059,
-0.1502891928,
0.3615147769,
0.1990605146,
-0.4509575069,
-0.4098301828,
0.005596309,
0.3230803013,
0.4744127989,
-0.166245684,
0.4044207335,
-0.2149127275,
0.3122884035,
-0.7181067467,
0.2411393225,
-0.6100143194,
0.2197699696,
0.0093520181,
-0.7327330112,
-0.2122639865,
0.2247684151,
-0.1115153059,
-0.593606174,
0.5159364939,
0.1398395747,
0.6241859794,
0.3900622725,
-0.2040720135,
-0.23782897,
-1.1648306847,
0.6228337884,
-0.9345228076,
0.0167919844,
0.1882596463,
0.6719620824,
0.3937988281,
-0.4254298508,
-0.8782368302,
0.0875934064,
0.3507421315,
0.3509878218,
-0.168029502,
0.1531193703,
0.0903953612,
0.3119822443,
-0.5635409355,
0.0211193226,
-0.3838809729,
-0.0795530602,
0.5068184733,
0.1683269888,
0.5716545582,
-0.0842589885,
-0.4274470508,
0.0035714561,
-0.8205193877,
-0.0691688508,
0.2815296948,
0.4415749609,
-0.3195119798,
0.5326790214,
-0.574332118,
0.7692987919,
-0.2168139815,
-0.0914259702,
0.3756548762,
-0.0194955375,
-0.2386698872,
0.8854956627,
0.8052405119,
0.6780714393,
0.2530935705,
-0.5687439442,
-0.189141959,
0.0803506151,
0.1380630285,
-0.7612407804,
0.1469833255,
0.5430127382,
0.1806229502,
-0.464831382,
-0.0130513059,
-0.615642786,
0.066913344,
-0.3268333972,
0.6603580117,
-0.2481888235,
-0.00020073,
0.5288697481,
-0.1942684799,
0.2566794157,
0.150281325,
-0.992621839,
0.2574237287,
0.2256163955,
1.0738196373,
-0.0579145104,
-0.1644957215,
-0.7746202946,
0.703966856,
-0.355768472,
1.0089441538,
-0.1974158138,
-0.2685896158,
0.1329110265,
-0.0837175921,
0.1510356814,
-0.1689736396,
0.6184847355,
-0.1901631504,
0.2976812422,
0.0810580775,
-0.4648580849,
-0.4381686449,
-0.0385715216,
-0.673783958,
0.4744450748,
0.1796488315,
-0.5463196039,
0.53392452,
-0.8899585605,
-0.5904154181,
0.4027784765,
-0.2994600832,
-0.3432240188,
-0.0995297879,
0.4120417833,
0.6039310694,
-0.1644493043,
0.1739210784,
-0.0597802326,
-0.7401028872,
0.1287972778,
-0.2594293952,
0.6451064348,
-0.0952410847,
-0.7262997627,
0.3374003768,
-0.6225173473,
-0.1135395318,
0.3264248967,
-0.0027578885,
-0.1179061979,
-0.0552839413,
0.3839590251,
0.0580339879,
-0.2566300631,
-0.6347365975,
-0.1468620151,
-0.6166813374,
0.8541843891,
0.2812507153,
0.1993934959,
0.7961134911,
-0.4117058218,
0.8878768682,
-0.3256648481,
-0.0772329718,
-0.9800550938,
-0.3717759848,
-0.4135460556,
-0.1874653548,
0.1932114661,
0.7465813756,
-0.5635725856,
0.419377923,
-0.3241288066,
-0.4001954794,
-0.2783274353,
0.1373967975,
0.3336680532,
0.7521080375,
0.5830457807,
-0.1992680728,
-0.4491209984,
-0.7042546272,
0.2063057125,
-0.0253686365,
-0.3728329837,
0.4761095643,
0.134469524,
-0.017730834,
0.8898925781,
-0.4874857366,
-0.9551990628,
-0.4888944924,
0.2081513852,
0.3729954958,
0.4646309316,
1.0505760908,
-0.5701293945,
-0.4144391716,
-0.2073830068,
-0.5750131011,
-0.4629308879,
-0.1790422648,
0.0751926154,
-0.0249000378,
0.646197319,
-0.7232868671,
0.1008996814,
0.4351620078,
-0.0080409134,
0.622351408,
0.0585229062,
0.296392858,
-1.0798773766,
0.085087426,
-0.1675424278,
-0.2162353098,
-0.8124189973,
-0.0519677289,
-0.4003933668,
-0.4624173045,
-0.7178486586,
0.4867226481,
-0.5942747593,
-0.1379672289,
-0.3705071807,
0.2369926274,
0.0710889027,
0.6597115397,
0.37033391,
0.5709531307,
0.9045187831,
-0.4051276147,
0.5016360283,
0.1594373435,
-0.3586736619,
0.5528967381,
-0.7236088514,
0.0303784925,
-0.0195075963,
0.0831909031,
-1.1185580492,
-0.3702040911,
0.258305192,
-0.6300785542,
0.2422241122,
-0.3406692743,
-0.3049539328,
-0.1596560627,
-0.2903977633,
0.5108004808,
0.4764378965,
-0.1421834379,
0.4146206975,
0.4397930503,
-0.5142759681,
-0.3439409733,
-0.6619153619,
0.279171288,
-0.599345386,
-0.1825920045,
0.509185791,
-0.158995837,
0.1450259387,
-0.167065531,
-0.2468074113,
-0.3237716556,
-0.1823215336,
0.6231583953,
0.2446118444,
-0.4013991654,
0.0053571947,
0.2987992764,
-0.2149670571,
0.1185999438,
-0.3289438486,
0.6342071295,
0.1301191002,
-0.1641424894,
-0.3736700416,
0.4811054766,
0.448269546,
-0.060827814,
-0.0167559963,
0.4763273597,
-0.1552273184,
-0.4488142133,
-0.2302763462,
-0.2689303756,
-0.3988801241,
0.1146173328,
0.0971763805,
-0.8143085837,
0.4360969365,
0.23208718,
0.1494534761,
0.246440798,
0.3332872391,
-0.3851785362,
0.7500349879,
0.7301598787,
-0.2435338348,
0.5480762124,
-0.3434316814,
0.0114754252,
-0.3915597498,
0.064621225,
-0.5283632874,
-0.2166310996,
0.138239041,
-0.2926358879,
0.1615073532,
0.0372587703,
-0.0583475679,
0.6753081679,
-0.569835484,
0.6457244754,
0.7262971997,
-0.1204826236,
0.2165369391,
0.2486364692,
0.1350148469,
0.0847059041,
-0.7914546132,
-0.3892193735,
1.0480182171,
-0.0792908892,
0.3582644463,
0.0028454559,
0.8636718988,
0.6346439123,
0.0511264987,
-1.1034859419,
0.447542578,
0.1696021855,
-0.5565174222,
-0.5507477522,
-0.1538156271,
-0.8561059237,
-0.0869557261,
-0.4920378327,
-0.6541532278,
-0.0528290682,
0.154265061,
-0.656922698,
0.1556269377,
-0.3022404611,
0.695682466,
-0.2134761363,
-0.0987211317,
0.012678314,
-0.6216822863,
0.3161900342,
0.1749270111,
0.4344751239,
-0.2653162479,
0.0303747617,
0.7877025008,
-0.1252951622,
0.8098964691,
-0.2758936882,
-0.0976609662,
0.634391129,
0.296271652,
-0.3222233951,
0.0342371017,
0.4870253801,
0.5551653504,
0.2131180316,
-0.2778173983,
-0.2966632247,
0.4950678647,
-0.3737156689,
-0.4156543911,
-0.2550659776,
-0.6214408278,
-0.1132273898,
0.5289553404,
0.4387956262,
0.6200410128,
-0.2874823809,
0.1709318459,
0.4043001235,
-0.3891991675,
0.7278923988,
0.8555867672,
-0.2277134508,
-0.5661067963,
0.9156922102,
0.0099316249,
-0.0736350492,
0.5618714094,
0.0082425326,
-0.1843739897,
-0.5885204077,
-0.9251018763,
0.0328248665,
-0.3734042048,
-0.3957109153,
-0.434168011,
0.0321094356,
-0.5459299684,
-0.4406456053,
-0.1563468426,
-0.6046631336,
-0.1596949399,
-0.3601247668,
0.2211406976,
0.22838144,
0.0097223688,
0.6321350336,
-1.0037009716,
0.6796663404,
0.3288846612,
-0.0618260764,
-0.2320179045,
-0.6357770562,
-0.4181106985,
-0.0357911289,
-0.002514591,
-1.1067663431,
0.6709867716,
0.3720793426,
0.50972718,
0.7246243954,
0.2714632154,
0.337810725,
-0.8085699677,
0.9432917833,
0.5283715725,
-0.9144729376,
0.6877799034,
-0.6893744469,
0.3029134572,
0.3752636313,
0.1036917642,
-0.4235835671,
-0.5013949275,
-0.503888905,
-1.2530909777,
0.6346362233,
0.2186499238,
0.5827078223,
0.0238695685,
0.2913258374,
-0.0794134289,
0.350443393,
-0.8249662519,
0.0275331456,
-0.5231393576,
-0.085480608,
-0.3148472607,
-0.2023930848,
-0.3823379278,
-0.048561383,
0.5088455677,
-0.3756726086,
0.2546709776,
0.2297327965,
-0.3439808488,
-0.2550336421,
0.5169879794,
0.8620842695,
0.0707805306,
-0.3835416436,
-0.1041411608,
-0.1994687915,
-0.3552721739,
0.3480461538,
-0.1674861163,
-0.4917504191,
0.4060404599,
0.7322973013,
0.6409573555,
0.6061098576,
-0.9453649521,
0.7607028484,
0.2314316034,
-0.5274839401,
-0.6783835292,
0.3813632131,
-0.0090628155,
-0.0749995336,
0.5941095352,
-0.2061150968,
0.4424174428,
-0.4378736913,
0.2397747487,
0.0537143722,
-0.6689267159,
-0.4257824421,
1.11244452,
0.1772453934,
-0.2023956627,
0.1598889083,
0.2017200589,
-0.1217328832,
0.746763289,
0.5891543627,
1.0766425133,
-0.1469634771,
0.4050886929,
0.4337973297,
0.1949307173,
0.2096248567,
0.2167982012,
-0.7291584611,
-0.7994846702,
-0.6369208097,
-0.5915240645,
-0.6276354194,
0.0968479663,
-0.9000915289,
0.2159023136,
-0.4713963568,
0.0085872486,
0.0414931662,
-0.5097497702,
-0.2664785087,
0.2744598389,
0.1590149105,
0.5580636263,
-1.1907864809,
0.7222281098,
0.4751937389,
-0.8639616966,
-0.6487947702,
-0.1436781287,
-0.1736205965,
-0.4656807482,
0.2754933834,
0.4418839216,
-0.3194566369,
0.0684321001,
-0.700694263,
-0.3167926371,
1.2369716167,
0.4833994508,
-0.7574381232,
-0.06669081,
0.2513473034,
0.3919534981,
-0.5607751608,
-0.0954521596,
0.3409478068,
0.2917807996,
0.2153144181,
-0.605098784,
-0.2415713072,
-0.2788001597,
-0.4423025548,
-0.222900331,
-0.1763617694,
0.6638917923,
-0.3308235109,
-0.3455042541,
0.1322072148,
0.5724752545,
0.0365413614,
0.6767042279,
0.5776116252,
0.4229812026,
0.0544251502,
-0.1001375541,
0.8927007914,
-0.6322726011,
0.0101567172,
1.5114878416,
-0.3763157427,
0.8130937219,
0.4650464654,
0.1537338197,
0.4960204065,
0.2079705,
0.016635051,
0.6120736599,
-0.1239776909,
-0.5123341084,
-0.2281160504,
-0.1152871177,
-0.0508509725,
0.6256250739,
0.1202675402,
-0.3045597672,
-0.2529015839,
0.1157377586,
-0.194877103,
0.1427708268,
-0.2868988216,
0.8671492338,
0.0947614461,
-0.1525279135,
0.3912037909,
-0.1126760319,
0.5872843862,
-0.4293899834,
-0.2739510536,
-0.0352369659,
-0.4574633539,
-0.231934309,
-0.6678945422,
0.3479109704,
0.2506405413,
-0.297462523,
-0.1898439676,
0.452645272,
-0.4989848733,
-0.1865962595,
0.3963243961,
0.4030819535,
0.3865267038,
-0.445889771,
-0.3417666554,
-0.4138113558,
-0.1748086661,
-0.0308036413,
0.0910614729,
0.3439785242,
-0.0139837153,
0.3576737344,
0.8856812716,
0.3285742402,
-0.1537575573,
0.5683122277,
0.4957010448,
-0.8607729673,
-0.7767910957,
-0.5526126623,
0.3313454092,
0.2532970011,
0.1040567383,
0.6346878409,
0.6643266082,
0.6465778351,
-0.3786532283,
0.8077452183,
0.0875140429,
0.4847978354,
-0.5993149877,
0.8188518286,
-0.4302146733,
0.2041058987,
-0.5896530747,
-1.0767887831,
-0.6717300415,
0.5008073449,
-0.0464649908,
-0.2834902704,
0.2280803621,
0.7885901928,
-0.1260894537,
-0.3241873384,
0.7551159263,
0.1071338654,
0.0216576792,
0.4755650461,
0.4202996194,
-0.392533958,
0.7790899873,
-0.3296789229,
0.0472185537,
-0.1524543613,
-0.9501538873,
-0.7631317973,
-0.5042258501,
-0.2924182117,
0.0410679206,
-0.1566855162,
0.4038833082,
0.7802063227,
-0.973946929,
-0.2396155894,
-0.0661748722,
-0.17892766,
-0.3469121754,
-0.3384099901,
0.1971383393,
0.0293651875,
-0.7123711109,
0.7540186644,
0.6569543481,
0.1173892766,
-0.2326685488,
-0.2333846837,
0.2809310555,
0.3624165356,
0.6417378783,
0.5249167681,
-0.4922749996,
-0.2624688447,
-0.1286772639,
0.2781330347,
0.2504146099,
0.6926905513,
-0.7109638453,
0.3765449226,
0.3997867107,
0.0556734838,
0.677441597,
-0.1232946143,
0.533655107,
-0.7242334485,
0.4539330602,
0.3155890405,
0.3761748075,
0.3004595935,
-0.0761543661,
0.3422395885,
0.1652910113,
-0.1591608375,
-0.7761281133,
0.0524741113,
-1.544426918,
-0.2473548949,
1.0763462782,
-0.1377749145,
-0.2649799883,
-0.0799207017,
-0.3931010664,
0.3099423647,
-0.4795062542,
0.7921610475,
0.1264252067,
0.216669783,
-0.4866353571,
-0.8482533097,
0.2414503396,
0.115935646,
-0.472535789,
0.0701204017,
0.8515988588,
0.5699020028,
0.2074662,
0.8389015794,
-0.2458561063,
0.5763397217,
0.0871708244,
0.6164687276,
-0.4288065434,
-0.5232672095,
-0.3694992959,
0.3910298645,
-0.2930370569,
-0.3451732099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08391v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08391v1
|
A Material Lens on Coloniality in NLP
| 2023-11-14T18:52:09 | 2023-11-14T18:52:09 |
William Held, Camille Harris, Michael Best, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Coloniality, the continuation of colonial harms beyond "official"
colonization, has pervasive effects across society and scientific fields.
Natural Language Processing (NLP) is no exception to this broad phenomenon. In
this work, we argue that coloniality is implicitly embedded in and amplified by
NLP data, algorithms, and software. We formalize this analysis using
Actor-Network Theory (ANT): an approach to understanding social phenomena
through the network of relationships between human stakeholders and technology.
We use our Actor-Network to guide a quantitative survey of the geography of
different phases of NLP research, providing evidence that inequality along
colonial boundaries increases as NLP builds on itself. Based on this, we argue
that combating coloniality in NLP requires not only changing current values but
also active work to remove the accumulation of colonial ideals in our
foundational data and algorithms.
|
[
-0.5076591372,
-0.817620337,
0.269512713,
0.1406143904,
-0.0900790393,
0.4469152093,
-0.4711244106,
-0.7195065618,
0.7191563845,
0.7835715413,
-0.1246426478,
-0.2950837016,
-0.8961433768,
0.0835883468,
-0.1722139716,
0.8052775264,
0.2189504951,
-0.2767259777,
-0.0662489831,
-0.2132277489,
-0.3445535898,
-0.6270850301,
-0.9731469154,
-0.1632532179,
0.6950243115,
0.0786884278,
1.0485281944,
0.6705566645,
0.3157050312,
0.3441050947,
-0.3100792766,
0.5765693188,
-0.3666166365,
0.2472210079,
-0.4498282075,
-0.7298193574,
-0.1557417065,
0.0491794869,
0.7396686673,
0.9878152609,
0.18626073,
0.3808507621,
0.3117448092,
0.5183981061,
-0.5384335518,
0.4117664993,
-0.4249123633,
0.2726747096,
-0.2652259469,
-0.409124881,
-0.292327553,
-0.3823584616,
-0.2714579701,
-0.3499978185,
0.3596593738,
0.0137228528,
0.8168615699,
0.1315828413,
-0.7584372759,
-0.1026846841,
-1.0427041054,
0.6116555929,
-0.4459440708,
-0.0967328027,
0.7514761686,
0.1755716652,
-0.121071279,
-0.5691026449,
-0.648491025,
-0.0149029559,
-0.0400935449,
0.0063844617,
-0.2731575966,
0.1068965644,
-0.0082303649,
0.2566812038,
-0.361296773,
-0.0566545613,
-0.7722404003,
-0.0732307658,
0.387098819,
-0.1026352271,
0.7607904077,
-0.2605564594,
-0.17270419,
0.0889353007,
-0.8436651826,
-0.0271213073,
0.5302570462,
0.7909066081,
-0.0308259372,
0.5451016426,
0.4554846883,
0.650357008,
-0.3965069652,
0.5090114474,
-0.383875072,
-0.0750952661,
-0.1740604788,
0.0449713171,
0.4592897594,
0.2623270154,
0.4354740679,
-0.207118839,
-0.0795822665,
0.5751677155,
0.6691567302,
-0.2953133583,
0.3325547576,
-0.1172785535,
-0.2893679142,
-0.3561477661,
0.046339456,
-0.6448017359,
-0.7193518877,
-0.4459845424,
0.0211481303,
-0.0890255272,
-0.5752705336,
0.0802895352,
-0.2554911077,
0.218679741,
-0.2664660513,
-1.1261857748,
0.7926368117,
1.1736952066,
1.0503283739,
0.4214860797,
-0.047421623,
-0.0608851202,
-0.0480100214,
-0.6907866001,
0.7020235658,
-0.6306134462,
-0.5866187215,
0.3636877537,
0.0826400444,
-0.1912713647,
-0.7010970712,
0.234605521,
-0.6514229178,
-0.2394151241,
-0.4616914093,
-0.2552405,
-0.4026967585,
0.4071692228,
-0.9092819095,
0.7548385262,
-0.1342090368,
-0.2246029377,
0.6079653502,
-0.6659201384,
-0.6020083427,
0.0650615916,
-0.1552998424,
0.1631419063,
0.2730538249,
-0.0577427223,
0.2562101185,
-0.2352048755,
0.447081238,
-0.17750521,
-0.3305951655,
-0.0325672515,
-0.4923591614,
0.8988175988,
0.0505363084,
-0.5192314982,
-0.3585770428,
-0.7611330152,
-0.5472677946,
0.0284216404,
-0.3033834398,
-0.4774864316,
0.26232481,
-0.181144014,
-0.0398377404,
0.0906233042,
-0.5572274327,
0.4522501528,
-0.6972455978,
0.230494082,
0.9141126871,
0.0645089895,
0.8032904863,
-0.3111410737,
0.7658019662,
-0.6658983231,
0.240975067,
0.4313082099,
-0.5524697304,
-0.568282485,
0.0741665661,
0.0864080638,
0.3820972145,
-0.6586635709,
0.0561537445,
-0.1986026317,
-0.1574616432,
-0.2652610242,
-0.1230813488,
0.3455227315,
0.3222880065,
0.3082042933,
-0.5574740767,
-0.7718830705,
-0.68767488,
-0.2788463831,
-0.5100935102,
0.0361843146,
0.4652937651,
0.2243977189,
-0.1874362528,
1.1158051491,
-0.407735467,
-0.3614419103,
-0.0727405101,
0.3727281094,
0.2750253379,
0.3994275033,
0.5213757753,
-0.8692013025,
-0.0967479795,
-0.0127098188,
-0.7247063518,
-0.2611594796,
-0.0710483566,
-0.301520288,
0.3217678368,
0.4000723362,
-0.4887798727,
0.3895539343,
0.6653145552,
-0.6549984813,
0.5069398284,
-0.0109872278,
0.1508911103,
-1.0402759314,
0.194762975,
-0.1081713364,
-0.1326669008,
-0.4076885581,
0.3347418904,
-0.6012490392,
-0.1164012849,
-0.1138031259,
0.6095405817,
-0.3587922156,
-0.1714894623,
-0.2926539481,
0.3883731067,
0.2473789752,
0.0346925706,
-0.029360123,
0.5317834616,
0.0737150237,
-0.6428515911,
0.2302503437,
0.2536996603,
-0.1004381478,
0.3776005507,
-0.4011361599,
-0.097744666,
-0.2502931654,
0.1587352306,
-0.8897145391,
0.2031041384,
0.2439651936,
-0.5573075414,
0.2736558318,
-0.631295085,
-0.3700891733,
-0.0053101443,
-0.1396467388,
0.5195736885,
0.294667393,
-0.4469712079,
0.7800863981,
0.6432565451,
-0.2286595553,
-0.8185397983,
-0.8506073356,
0.6748228073,
0.0598193966,
-0.9192945957,
0.1883019507,
0.3479337692,
-0.7458146811,
0.2336363494,
-0.0480337664,
-0.259403199,
0.0125808548,
0.1359906793,
0.0741034895,
-0.3370486796,
0.3304560781,
-0.0256070271,
0.0865674987,
0.4726628959,
-0.454080075,
0.6356613636,
0.1007682979,
0.0394208878,
0.2689152658,
0.3127857447,
0.2224321663,
-0.2428623289,
0.9682502151,
0.4544579983,
-0.36165905,
-0.3478055596,
-0.2577532828,
-0.0879935399,
-0.4867788851,
0.0195223726,
0.0091389669,
-0.7053906918,
0.5672261119,
-0.0981167853,
-0.0462595113,
0.5144717097,
-0.0629348531,
0.2056827396,
0.6600952744,
0.830817163,
-0.2338282615,
0.2888018787,
-0.7690256834,
0.4608642757,
-0.8701568246,
-0.0578398071,
-0.5579453111,
-0.2431398481,
-0.8257849813,
-0.5695133209,
0.2225426883,
-0.2038275152,
-0.3510430455,
0.4687726498,
-0.4091488719,
0.2927334309,
0.4334171116,
-0.0898834988,
0.0589715801,
-0.2000224143,
-0.0029259506,
0.1850430816,
-0.6353375912,
-0.9154472947,
0.7842022181,
-0.0158622526,
0.3242727518,
0.4921753705,
0.5977669358,
0.7181817889,
0.1180217937,
-0.6623359323,
0.5891408324,
-0.2624548674,
-0.807100296,
-0.1643506289,
-0.3007959127,
-1.4309806824,
0.1963742226,
-0.3741305768,
-0.7297783494,
0.5553709269,
0.2063591182,
-0.3495392203,
0.711768508,
-0.5079854131,
0.6143656373,
0.3443886042,
-0.582775116,
-0.2578665912,
-0.6528742909,
0.3258763254,
0.419970274,
0.6885730624,
0.0268508382,
0.0100591518,
0.614215672,
-0.3622180521,
1.4032707214,
-0.2285124213,
-0.112676695,
0.5425539017,
0.4991824925,
0.1472027451,
-0.0283978786,
0.1458801627,
0.0625071898,
0.1206096187,
-0.6344771981,
-0.4958614111,
0.4826907814,
-0.7312119007,
-0.4346701801,
-0.543358326,
-0.0021293573,
-0.0497358702,
0.0333572663,
-0.0834005028,
0.8683179617,
-0.3466261029,
-0.2257469743,
0.5700105429,
-0.2630300522,
0.5297899842,
0.1887055337,
-0.1803219467,
-0.1411731541,
0.9224484563,
0.3351421654,
0.2932061553,
0.3643930554,
0.0978699028,
-0.0985043719,
-0.222971946,
-0.2634371519,
0.1109425128,
-0.7515403032,
0.0308613982,
-0.4403630793,
0.0247168615,
-0.5161091685,
-0.487911135,
-0.3816688359,
-0.2223459333,
-0.3935029209,
-0.3041076362,
-0.1022984162,
0.9983810186,
-0.5256874561,
0.3537351489,
-0.7033922672,
0.4006371498,
0.2009452432,
0.3187485635,
0.0106598381,
-0.3336291909,
-0.3615716994,
-0.1147344038,
0.011234696,
-0.5240280032,
0.4323704243,
0.1982404292,
0.0652365088,
0.4799277186,
-0.0315421671,
0.4840588868,
-0.6288421154,
1.2408069372,
-0.3011084199,
-0.8582848907,
0.1287873238,
-0.3055929244,
0.0799433291,
0.2933109999,
0.3320622444,
-1.0671356916,
-0.4308108687,
-0.6845306754,
-1.3613364697,
0.1585792154,
-0.0621633083,
0.6035650969,
-0.4490312636,
0.1253744513,
-0.2336242497,
0.226969108,
-0.5588232279,
-0.1070355475,
0.1325537711,
0.1524270922,
-0.2423122823,
-0.3569648564,
-0.2341245413,
0.1302983016,
0.6046094894,
-0.0369418785,
0.2332954258,
0.3879542053,
-0.1853256673,
0.009864768,
0.0196196251,
0.2684864402,
0.8001951575,
-0.1004513055,
0.5462469459,
-0.3065405488,
-0.6991753578,
0.0934272036,
-0.0139645748,
0.0204071607,
-0.0711845383,
0.7429216504,
0.4671933651,
0.0346697234,
-0.2104822397,
0.3048135042,
-0.0904980302,
0.2153190672,
-0.6857790351,
-0.2151755095,
-0.2548243701,
0.3354358375,
0.4267607927,
0.5457287431,
0.2353996336,
-1.0290997028,
0.1242089197,
0.3622853756,
-0.355643481,
-0.4032045603,
0.6214786768,
0.2614437342,
-0.4288057685,
0.2878171504,
-0.4663634002,
-0.4884024262,
0.8124073744,
0.4536848068,
0.7468102574,
-0.0261493605,
0.532984674,
0.2482294738,
0.8304236531,
0.0844180211,
0.2937637568,
-0.0801596195,
-1.1714141369,
-0.8645195365,
-0.6609649062,
-0.2744772732,
-0.3659514189,
-0.513921082,
-0.0340785757,
-0.6603696942,
-0.3757584393,
-0.1274036765,
0.0998703837,
-0.3808341026,
0.3918243349,
0.3168369532,
0.4977201223,
-1.0755964518,
0.0596427359,
0.3492097855,
-0.6244500875,
-0.5566235185,
0.0026691954,
0.2874081135,
-0.7188256979,
0.5234262943,
0.0812081471,
-0.4504620433,
-0.2244217843,
-0.5542107224,
-0.8064061403,
0.6046270132,
0.3230483234,
-0.058834523,
0.2240506709,
0.1887093782,
0.6287489533,
-0.0239649154,
-0.0266498644,
0.7017593384,
0.5320290327,
-0.5326453447,
-0.6478303671,
0.1237492338,
-0.3791918159,
0.0347177163,
0.4769901633,
-0.510440886,
0.6450241208,
0.2642531991,
-0.442212373,
-0.2519430816,
0.3003788888,
-0.267225951,
0.2282316387,
0.4104451835,
0.1809955984,
0.5740177631,
0.0759976208,
1.2397054434,
-0.2714548707,
-0.0251986515,
0.8004044294,
-0.0056851692,
0.3998499215,
0.270470649,
-0.4232168198,
0.6988028884,
0.4094640315,
0.1723687202,
-0.0916518569,
0.5546666384,
-0.7894757986,
0.3435369432,
-0.4558596909,
0.105857335,
0.7639319301,
0.2412255853,
-0.2678734064,
0.0890795365,
-0.0244984403,
0.545846045,
0.6937521696,
-0.4573275149,
0.6260495186,
0.1527060121,
-0.5033852458,
0.4800738394,
0.0077805975,
0.6014593244,
-0.6795846224,
-0.1618317217,
-0.2362744659,
-0.2747457922,
-0.3150873184,
-0.3585083783,
0.8130146861,
-0.0715608373,
-0.2721602023,
-0.1291413307,
0.6942363381,
-0.1197417155,
-0.1906640232,
0.5781082511,
0.3564381897,
0.1791714132,
-0.1969082803,
0.0057074712,
-0.0432658978,
-0.3552389741,
-0.2247603387,
0.0525017492,
0.3014222085,
-0.049457971,
0.2218571156,
0.5477865338,
0.7427636981,
0.0300356448,
0.1593736559,
0.6254823804,
-0.6788588166,
-0.3186918795,
-1.0354404449,
0.3889912367,
-0.3169485629,
-0.3099320233,
0.5036184788,
0.4433254898,
0.7845263481,
0.3068815768,
0.7734074593,
-0.40851897,
0.0765758306,
-0.3546251357,
0.769037962,
-0.2702194452,
0.2271378189,
-0.2409776598,
-0.8382748961,
-0.4971737564,
0.3607143164,
-0.2921600342,
-0.038003549,
0.5852544308,
0.738515377,
-0.0392413959,
-0.0867476612,
0.2187647671,
0.2521189749,
0.3207222223,
-0.2222957015,
0.569476366,
-0.0810090154,
0.3198048174,
-0.1290306449,
-0.4324368238,
0.1311676651,
-0.7745714784,
-0.3336354196,
-0.776832819,
0.0656260699,
-0.5482509732,
0.1587716341,
1.063672781,
0.5025172234,
-0.2696879804,
-0.5324237943,
-0.0634620488,
0.2122299373,
-0.4426948726,
-0.3020595908,
0.3406148851,
-0.4646285176,
-0.7823525667,
0.5741836429,
0.2510565519,
-0.4353234768,
-0.4393975139,
0.4808692634,
-0.4775516689,
0.573736608,
1.0054649115,
0.5780552626,
-0.2111587375,
-0.4893838763,
-0.3702304661,
0.2516564727,
-0.0031800312,
0.8858665824,
-0.6284717917,
0.7605676055,
0.1817446053,
0.7647403479,
0.2389767617,
-0.1524345279,
0.8732993603,
-1.2331029177,
0.1736787707,
0.6096520424,
0.3314384818,
0.4866780043,
-0.4954697788,
0.713126421,
0.3947184682,
-0.7144498229,
-0.7041789293,
0.4520186484,
-0.4983234107,
-0.4243198633,
1.1367046833,
0.082527481,
-0.5216980577,
-0.2697506845,
-0.2981337905,
0.6146830916,
-0.0552404374,
0.9652619958,
0.5854356885,
0.121698238,
0.3003840446,
-0.6641905308,
0.4918956161,
0.2315518707,
-0.3800232708,
-0.1628345102,
0.5336998701,
0.0284682419,
0.4792398512,
0.8038499951,
0.0032400123,
-0.2785916626,
0.2746946812,
0.4153285325,
0.2673633099,
-0.3718744218,
-0.3156934381,
0.194875598,
0.1351080984,
-0.1568684578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08390v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08390v2
|
Predicting Text Preference Via Structured Comparative Reasoning
| 2023-11-14T18:51:38 | 2024-07-01T16:57:56 |
Jing Nathan Yan, Tianqi Liu, Justin T Chiu, Jiaming Shen, Zhen Qin, Yue Yu, Yao Zhao, Charu Lakshmanan, Yair Kurzion, Alexander M. Rush, Jialu Liu, Michael Bendersky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Comparative reasoning plays a crucial role in text preference prediction;
however, large language models (LLMs) often demonstrate inconsistencies in
their reasoning. While approaches like Chain-of-Thought improve accuracy in
many other settings, they struggle to consistently distinguish the similarities
and differences of complex texts. We introduce SC, a prompting approach that
predicts text preferences by generating structured intermediate comparisons. SC
begins by proposing aspects of comparison, followed by generating textual
comparisons under each aspect. We select consistent comparisons with a pairwise
consistency comparator that ensures each aspect's comparisons clearly
distinguish differences between texts, significantly reducing hallucination and
improving consistency. Our comprehensive evaluations across various NLP tasks,
including summarization, retrieval, and automatic rating, demonstrate that SC
equips LLMs to achieve state-of-the-art performance in text preference
prediction.
|
[
-0.2071760446,
-0.5903440714,
0.914676249,
0.1875440031,
-0.2762207389,
-0.1061726362,
-0.4175933599,
-0.4263668954,
0.2516251504,
0.3158386946,
-0.5316351652,
-0.495473206,
-0.5618546009,
0.4504669309,
-0.3127383292,
0.8761771321,
-0.0652248412,
0.0562190637,
-0.4284522235,
0.0271698553,
-0.4761886895,
-0.4259853959,
-0.6508619189,
-0.8500410318,
0.5819097757,
0.5009340644,
0.7536458969,
0.4453075826,
0.411667794,
0.3191452324,
-0.2428634465,
0.3847955465,
-0.1541376412,
0.7062534094,
-0.2621954083,
-0.4275503755,
-0.206749171,
-0.1346366853,
0.3537788987,
0.4603057504,
0.0265165772,
-0.3103799522,
0.3196069598,
1.0142694712,
-0.4025723934,
0.0333771668,
-1.0234344006,
-0.0423509963,
-0.012334289,
-0.4071180224,
-0.6882049441,
-0.5648840666,
0.4655121863,
-0.346147269,
0.0668777525,
0.2789409161,
0.7038857341,
0.1752265245,
-0.4081986547,
-0.3710181415,
-0.4939074814,
0.905659616,
-0.5551944375,
0.5868660212,
0.6014616489,
0.0366255455,
-0.2235379964,
-0.4882205427,
-0.6575206518,
-0.5984351039,
-0.2121278048,
0.1475706995,
0.1056244746,
0.0890006796,
0.154348433,
0.3701734245,
-0.7176134586,
-0.1056182608,
0.0421295762,
0.0379521325,
0.3886126876,
0.1329624504,
0.1440422684,
-0.4005168974,
-0.3508049548,
-0.0498461425,
-0.6387188435,
0.2969718277,
0.2223252356,
0.2915926278,
0.0509908386,
0.6075015664,
-0.4499394894,
0.6140654087,
0.4006231427,
-0.2123373002,
0.2588593662,
-0.0259771775,
-0.3879251778,
0.1368542314,
0.7960111499,
0.6672289968,
0.4755140841,
0.0145649938,
-0.2172406167,
0.3995877206,
0.1628008187,
-0.5788971186,
-0.371105969,
0.3700003922,
-0.6492542028,
-0.3395276368,
0.027463289,
-0.3358112872,
-0.359395057,
-0.708212018,
0.0871030763,
-0.3412618935,
0.1756653488,
0.2711290717,
-0.1351983547,
-0.287217617,
0.364156574,
-1.2743858099,
0.1664791852,
0.5952796936,
0.8008934855,
-0.6969218254,
-0.2809530795,
-0.411072284,
0.2568279803,
-0.2514435053,
1.382380724,
-0.8422011733,
-0.3740649223,
0.0326006822,
-0.2246483713,
0.1871661246,
-0.5354195833,
0.7711582184,
-0.3164396286,
0.2823518813,
-0.3285523653,
-0.5922002792,
0.2013625205,
0.7445961833,
-0.6419189572,
1.4732872248,
-0.1284049898,
-1.2154175043,
0.5659563541,
-0.2112210095,
-0.3828761578,
-0.0479986593,
-0.3722352982,
-0.3958913088,
0.090823397,
0.2508819699,
0.4970098734,
-0.1248488426,
0.4450723231,
-0.4858143926,
-0.4546637833,
0.2873198092,
-0.2701370418,
0.3944347799,
0.1462273002,
-0.1533993185,
0.5198521614,
-0.5285790563,
0.161982134,
-0.1034021527,
-0.2869307995,
-0.6540204287,
0.2202614695,
-0.2986912727,
0.0912124366,
0.3297331035,
-0.3504122794,
0.4061292708,
-0.5634409189,
0.2953115106,
0.9845491052,
-0.1214553043,
0.6680605412,
-0.450984925,
0.2544813752,
-0.1195666716,
0.1225563362,
-0.2686137557,
-0.3588569462,
-0.7400824428,
0.1271816492,
0.2193924487,
0.4475988448,
-0.6612393856,
0.5162577033,
-0.0943724066,
-0.3855139911,
-0.0502515547,
-0.0879980475,
0.3607380986,
0.3148818612,
0.4282627702,
0.1695240736,
-0.6142029166,
-0.7715008855,
-0.489105463,
-0.5873190165,
-0.1044765785,
0.3697322607,
0.1210195199,
-0.0506159328,
0.8233162165,
-0.7307966948,
0.1194751188,
-0.4551594853,
-0.0957680196,
0.1463701725,
0.1644134969,
0.2134335786,
-0.8760664463,
-0.7296496034,
0.0153569123,
-0.5418864489,
-0.0212191083,
-0.0701860264,
-0.1609437615,
0.0313115232,
0.640614152,
-0.2547360063,
0.2779313028,
0.5320389271,
-0.1594464481,
0.8386166692,
-0.1354820579,
0.2667535543,
-1.0292723179,
-0.1836984158,
0.1455203891,
-0.2327372134,
-0.2898126245,
-0.3805671036,
-0.0043722978,
0.5084667802,
-0.0672869608,
0.7311347127,
-0.1163862124,
0.0103887971,
-0.3506054878,
0.1979418099,
0.1313491613,
0.2139414847,
0.5973873138,
0.7463995218,
0.1580840051,
-0.6707515717,
0.1293233782,
0.5049942732,
-0.4222014248,
0.4787879288,
-0.7550740838,
0.1540887505,
0.1928944886,
0.4539118707,
-0.8755764365,
-0.0760851353,
-0.0800507292,
-0.4882853925,
0.0259486567,
-0.0168165509,
-0.3711114526,
-0.2825013995,
-0.4150393009,
0.1801103652,
0.1775027514,
-0.5558026433,
0.4396193624,
0.1166975573,
-0.520414412,
-0.8154674768,
-0.4172803462,
0.0339145847,
0.0594630912,
-0.2493579537,
0.5419722795,
-0.4026051164,
-0.4474639595,
-0.260301739,
-0.188777715,
0.1127949804,
-0.0151675539,
0.2848955393,
0.5270771384,
0.0593602285,
0.3622092903,
0.4473572075,
-0.4337730706,
0.0106248669,
-0.360270828,
0.5101771355,
-0.1395583004,
-0.1249388382,
-0.2035158277,
0.3524863124,
0.2085513175,
0.0789285228,
0.2760570049,
0.0229681525,
-0.1761626154,
-0.3561339974,
-0.4874759018,
-0.3105789125,
-0.4868403077,
0.0925615132,
-0.4952705801,
-0.9223374724,
0.0817610025,
-0.1064188629,
-0.0360422991,
0.2582604885,
0.5818890929,
-0.1363197863,
1.2341879606,
0.6519654989,
0.0836600214,
0.6817230582,
0.1549106389,
0.207457751,
-0.6625685096,
-0.3102039397,
-0.805103302,
-0.1694718897,
-0.6716701984,
0.0197864734,
0.3081350923,
0.0403283015,
-0.340397805,
0.2841543853,
-0.6371030211,
0.9408864379,
0.5020111203,
0.1958443671,
0.5697439909,
0.1303894967,
-0.7095463276,
-0.203155458,
-0.392945379,
-0.85368222,
0.8809407949,
0.037711814,
0.5784401894,
-0.3433974981,
0.6846017241,
0.5291813612,
0.2685664892,
-0.8915679455,
0.6319510937,
-0.2418367416,
-0.2515713274,
-0.2404141575,
-0.2039055377,
-0.7302104235,
0.0548791029,
-0.6018655896,
-0.6142682433,
-0.1394426078,
0.2024105787,
-0.2259646058,
0.1685279459,
-0.2883965671,
0.5276815295,
0.0853778571,
-0.3045189977,
-0.1393058598,
-0.6980438828,
0.0875478685,
0.273178786,
-0.1529687494,
-0.0893063694,
0.0781392604,
0.5965995193,
-0.0998066664,
0.47019732,
0.3725666404,
-0.0689045638,
0.0580382682,
0.3618475199,
0.4680289626,
0.1074844301,
-0.6356717944,
0.0186174065,
-0.125864014,
-0.1418949962,
-0.7017892003,
0.9327528477,
-0.4221990705,
-0.5073876381,
-0.4928189218,
-0.3168831766,
-0.4546035826,
0.1961785406,
0.4554333687,
0.3504738212,
-0.2209779918,
0.0208529178,
0.7437363267,
0.017437689,
0.4321419299,
0.1796322465,
-0.3574700058,
-0.5603804588,
0.537484467,
-0.2833508551,
0.2767013907,
0.5503510237,
0.5404538512,
-0.661011517,
-0.5907531381,
-0.4552663267,
-0.1122272164,
-0.747213304,
-0.3571605384,
-0.8991402388,
0.0062627294,
-0.1629235297,
-0.6868800521,
-0.0779053941,
-0.340949893,
0.0525001697,
-0.372331053,
0.2586807609,
1.0118095875,
0.3337174058,
0.1454616934,
-0.6587500572,
0.1999248415,
0.2653480768,
0.5003515482,
0.0613542311,
-0.3871228695,
-0.053695783,
-0.3669450581,
-0.4448938072,
-0.7876015306,
0.2763226032,
-0.2057878226,
0.26182127,
0.508418262,
0.2264993638,
0.2948588133,
-0.5857926607,
0.9466537833,
0.3792594075,
-1.0501949787,
0.7221330404,
-0.4030364752,
0.2337597758,
0.8240020871,
0.357693553,
-0.5266388655,
-0.4482887685,
-0.6380088329,
-0.6639447212,
0.2287652194,
0.1245505437,
0.023961924,
-0.4076506197,
0.2851903439,
0.5879508853,
0.2603525817,
-0.8868466616,
-0.3755244613,
-0.0764780417,
-0.2572149038,
-0.0309100486,
-0.3121658564,
0.3499555588,
-0.1945753545,
0.7495129108,
-0.3097169697,
-0.040754687,
0.2960932255,
0.1853278577,
-0.0726404265,
0.5464749336,
0.4005144536,
0.551040411,
-0.059455514,
0.3448260427,
0.388433516,
-0.28213346,
0.2045052648,
-0.3555109799,
-0.4708199799,
0.1634373814,
0.1479433626,
0.648540318,
0.2509376705,
-0.4725118279,
0.5129259825,
-0.1196720898,
-0.1482090354,
-0.1145946458,
0.0486771055,
0.1937387735,
0.051657889,
0.1662352085,
0.2116671801,
0.3615998626,
-0.4370167851,
0.1719077975,
0.3162341118,
-0.4862471819,
-0.0142057631,
0.3707994521,
0.3149392009,
-0.3592249453,
0.3219293058,
-0.1255035847,
-0.7824997306,
0.3818681538,
0.6381499171,
0.8458188772,
-0.2352921963,
0.3104516566,
0.5556380153,
0.0010169606,
-0.4645807147,
0.3618496954,
-0.1887298077,
-0.7539436221,
-0.3854268193,
-0.5650378466,
-0.728718102,
-0.087839663,
-0.6410713792,
0.5607438684,
-0.4428103566,
-0.1097485423,
0.0764522031,
0.119880341,
-0.2670999765,
0.3802879155,
0.0816630125,
0.9143995643,
-0.8525327444,
0.8441987634,
0.5025333762,
-0.2142746598,
-0.6896551847,
0.4474059939,
-0.1089187339,
-0.4357340336,
0.4255545139,
0.4056018293,
-0.4978978336,
-0.3376651108,
-0.6428887844,
-0.4565438628,
0.6455157399,
0.268540293,
-0.8055536151,
0.0266805775,
-0.2772112191,
0.4756169319,
-0.5155126452,
0.624206543,
0.4210808575,
0.5994023085,
0.1055315956,
-0.8136945963,
0.0971691981,
-0.1962660104,
-0.0625127628,
0.3065829575,
-0.4316923022,
0.6899324656,
-0.5073305368,
0.0282859746,
0.1103235111,
0.8187078834,
0.6220034361,
0.7127096057,
0.6847108006,
0.1027370244,
0.9470809102,
-0.0680234358,
0.9523887038,
-0.2797999382,
0.0658541396,
1.5003597736,
-0.6032934189,
1.3203641176,
0.4502529204,
-0.1881766319,
1.122769475,
0.8460111618,
0.1951399744,
0.3376197815,
0.0332554951,
-0.2360872775,
-0.5061095357,
-0.2339232266,
-0.4606643617,
0.3105983138,
0.046927426,
-0.4449185431,
0.1431643963,
-0.2951846123,
-0.0674226433,
0.5408636928,
-0.1747802645,
1.0898560286,
0.146309346,
-1.0788615942,
0.2207410187,
-0.0911062956,
0.7193201184,
-0.5594974756,
-0.2194358408,
-0.0820754468,
0.0984073654,
-0.3040381074,
-1.1369762421,
0.1594328433,
-0.151249826,
-0.7881781459,
-0.3302430511,
0.9783573151,
-0.6249171495,
-0.1599510461,
0.462593466,
0.398057282,
-0.0106198192,
-0.2290617824,
-0.7835947275,
0.1091974303,
0.1123039424,
-0.2188550979,
0.1956564784,
0.3534534574,
-0.2026574612,
0.7046266198,
0.7649403214,
0.0480216704,
-0.5617231727,
0.1764061302,
0.820215106,
-0.7714281678,
-0.9205721617,
-1.066971302,
0.2240514606,
-0.3088060021,
-0.3511815369,
0.6798660755,
0.652929306,
0.7468152046,
0.1064550579,
0.9464672804,
0.3708148003,
0.6223747134,
-0.7647168636,
0.4486473501,
-0.3033064008,
0.3500184119,
-0.375144273,
-1.1507685184,
-0.1681841165,
0.7368039489,
-0.4859570265,
0.0527177677,
1.221591115,
0.5573313832,
0.0741965771,
0.5160220861,
0.2420537919,
0.066748485,
0.0384526663,
0.3540734649,
0.8965376616,
-0.059713237,
0.3770445883,
0.0545679182,
-0.0993512198,
-0.1238935292,
-1.2596347332,
-1.0084228516,
-0.6354802847,
-0.0954037979,
-0.7126498818,
0.1167042032,
1.3524158001,
0.5614570379,
-0.8651326895,
-0.1941236258,
-0.1394217908,
0.4258082211,
-0.1735313535,
-0.1602530777,
0.330835849,
-0.3336316049,
-0.7092738748,
0.3720925748,
0.5871018767,
-0.0037867411,
-0.1764922738,
-0.2271573246,
0.0466003418,
0.3910288811,
0.635642767,
-0.1468235403,
-0.8650221229,
-0.2418368012,
0.0018116466,
-0.3291670382,
0.2543145418,
1.0850455761,
-0.8868393302,
0.3029587269,
0.8281686902,
0.3107372224,
0.289283216,
-0.0053379806,
0.5734556317,
-0.4030284584,
-0.1192476675,
0.2682088017,
0.3459759355,
0.3821921945,
-0.4442160726,
0.3835861385,
0.0316286571,
-0.7097371817,
-0.6897120476,
0.3504448831,
-1.1525022984,
-0.361095041,
1.3202302456,
-0.1587031931,
-0.1563454568,
-0.2441855222,
-0.4758687019,
-0.0923373923,
-0.6770592332,
0.8658308387,
0.7259421349,
-0.0617725514,
0.1925769597,
-0.0290119853,
0.7959651947,
0.5392789245,
-0.8268166184,
0.2258319259,
0.4204322994,
0.2400717586,
-0.192904681,
0.6816568971,
0.0856531784,
0.0614130013,
-0.2316140383,
-0.169473201,
0.1313565522,
-0.5602164865,
-0.1611882597,
0.1447508633,
-0.0010265975,
0.2506404817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08389v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08389v1
|
TSST: A Benchmark and Evaluation Models for Text Speech-Style Transfer
| 2023-11-14T18:50:51 | 2023-11-14T18:50:51 |
Huashan Sun, Yixiao Wu, Yinghao Li, Jiawei Li, Yizhe Yang, Yang Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Text style is highly abstract, as it encompasses various aspects of a
speaker's characteristics, habits, logical thinking, and the content they
express. However, previous text-style transfer tasks have primarily focused on
data-driven approaches, lacking in-depth analysis and research from the
perspectives of linguistics and cognitive science. In this paper, we introduce
a novel task called Text Speech-Style Transfer (TSST). The main objective is to
further explore topics related to human cognition, such as personality and
emotion, based on the capabilities of existing LLMs. Considering the objective
of our task and the distinctive characteristics of oral speech in real-life
scenarios, we trained multi-dimension (i.e. filler words, vividness,
interactivity, emotionality) evaluation models for the TSST and validated their
correlation with human assessments. We thoroughly analyze the performance of
several large language models (LLMs) and identify areas where further
improvement is needed. Moreover, driven by our evaluation models, we have
released a new corpus that improves the capabilities of LLMs in generating text
with speech-style characteristics. In summary, we present the TSST task, a new
benchmark for style transfer and emphasizing human-oriented evaluation,
exploring and advancing the performance of current LLMs.
|
[
-0.3049072325,
-0.8281111717,
0.5860272646,
0.2835989296,
-0.3478121459,
0.2659773529,
-0.5634071231,
-0.4644449651,
-0.0196009837,
0.3869829178,
-0.5627598763,
-0.4942119718,
-0.6367428303,
0.1320813149,
-0.7177164555,
0.8382022977,
-0.1209890395,
-0.227753371,
-0.1197875515,
0.1970621347,
-0.5354894996,
-0.6376735568,
-0.721552372,
-0.2416667044,
0.3945838213,
0.4015653133,
0.2173799276,
0.3592796922,
0.5639724731,
0.2546989918,
-0.0311586112,
-0.0934307054,
-0.339138478,
0.1756928712,
-0.410217464,
-0.0858872384,
-0.5055080652,
0.0706075653,
0.680016458,
0.4077742696,
0.011039352,
0.2428893447,
0.0754337609,
0.6095046997,
-0.3278053999,
0.1469851136,
-0.399420917,
0.1361420304,
-0.3744184971,
-0.2257656902,
-0.5175096989,
-0.6601099372,
0.6130449772,
-0.1933628619,
-0.0402678512,
-0.1546805799,
0.6266468167,
-0.0156726036,
-0.7266010046,
-0.1680332124,
-0.7791195512,
0.7054629326,
-0.4346461296,
0.5201777816,
0.0548054166,
0.425286144,
0.3993121982,
-0.7730268836,
-0.6506617665,
-0.3704675734,
0.1770223826,
0.0482410416,
-0.204390049,
-0.140743807,
-0.0382650197,
-0.0155779757,
-0.5534824133,
-0.1856621355,
-0.2411164641,
-0.0755527243,
0.8123242855,
0.1658270508,
0.4351426363,
-0.1373871863,
-0.4895030856,
-0.4271145463,
-0.0465701036,
0.0267779678,
-0.0189753454,
0.3451421261,
-0.2767623961,
0.2490632981,
-0.2680223584,
0.4652266204,
-0.2964321077,
-0.2977965772,
0.327983737,
-0.6010453701,
0.0156718269,
0.1610171348,
0.613779664,
0.515728116,
0.6065129042,
-0.3048341274,
-0.1146999151,
0.1213639751,
0.4719292223,
-0.7838816643,
-0.0746858418,
-0.234702453,
-0.5283890367,
-0.5443153977,
-0.2435763329,
-1.2418249846,
-0.4763044417,
-0.5783644319,
0.5576061606,
-0.6035839915,
-0.426943481,
0.070599854,
-0.0974067003,
0.1319640726,
0.3270924985,
-0.7656402588,
0.5109809637,
0.5913563967,
0.9463074803,
-0.7647507787,
-0.2071766257,
-0.2133809924,
0.0400565974,
-0.1956994832,
1.0158404112,
-0.5065966249,
-0.3826723695,
-0.0338234343,
-0.3225172162,
-0.2507624328,
-0.1221037209,
0.8746517897,
0.0186060444,
0.0190753825,
-0.3018340468,
-0.5796035528,
-0.0412549898,
0.0431884415,
-0.2805888355,
1.0259313583,
0.1091174781,
-0.5032336116,
0.0443211384,
-0.8106384873,
-0.7384191751,
0.0573550798,
0.1101979092,
-0.2450003624,
0.0355765596,
-0.0510882586,
0.4620235562,
-0.3425294161,
0.1981640011,
-0.2825833559,
-0.3923830688,
0.7012709379,
-0.3156540096,
0.3805924058,
0.3410763741,
-0.3520921171,
0.3096446991,
-0.712197125,
0.2440382689,
0.0408547781,
-0.0928775668,
-0.2593258619,
-0.1963985115,
0.4733412266,
0.3415825367,
0.2797224522,
-0.5117106438,
0.0641006008,
-0.0152036287,
0.7742528319,
0.8024576306,
0.0176356193,
0.3977847099,
-0.573808074,
0.4063462019,
-0.3381574154,
-0.0380480736,
0.1100182235,
-0.1756094396,
-0.7239964604,
-0.1054849103,
0.1505976915,
0.6363665462,
-0.3771774769,
0.341116339,
-0.469845891,
-0.8438159823,
-0.299592644,
-0.291110754,
0.3533979952,
0.6633367538,
0.2626911998,
-0.3422874808,
-0.5732004642,
-0.8594267368,
-0.5172126889,
-0.1260577887,
0.1451813132,
0.2056666017,
0.3277727664,
0.1304979324,
0.9158512354,
-0.3092954457,
-0.0620745197,
-0.4358601868,
0.4689753652,
-0.2062097788,
0.4058221281,
0.4563442767,
-0.6283696294,
-0.4761689603,
-0.0249513332,
-0.5067183375,
-0.414634943,
-0.1112897396,
-0.107890822,
0.1133904755,
0.6524935365,
-0.3503039479,
0.2745856643,
0.5750346184,
-0.3793207109,
0.866953373,
0.0515349209,
0.2940405011,
-1.1759223938,
0.2071987391,
0.2180297524,
-0.2156914771,
-0.862031281,
-0.3135401607,
0.0902607366,
-0.2607851028,
-0.6129693389,
1.0105669498,
-0.1596033573,
-0.3069267869,
-0.2035607696,
0.3507230878,
0.0619296953,
0.6002001166,
0.0057175765,
1.074078083,
0.3644887805,
-0.4978734255,
0.3846636117,
0.2874145806,
-0.5041030645,
1.2664723396,
-0.443169862,
0.6285890341,
0.1280772537,
0.0522589758,
-1.1089795828,
0.0913572311,
-0.2202297896,
-0.1837691367,
0.2524792552,
-0.0080910921,
-0.5202968717,
-0.1267824471,
0.012087103,
0.164864406,
0.6691616178,
-0.2138880342,
0.6575508118,
0.2526777983,
-0.7004326582,
0.087774992,
-0.6141161919,
0.3971410692,
-0.5789085627,
-0.7492339611,
0.6670119166,
-0.2623004317,
-0.3034274578,
-0.1895780414,
-0.1345756203,
-0.1934897453,
0.1262080818,
-0.0751991645,
0.2994576693,
-0.1644394249,
0.1359567642,
-0.0690731704,
0.17323412,
0.0987695828,
-0.1538708359,
0.50782305,
-0.3193231821,
-0.0515463986,
-0.8479884863,
0.1452257186,
0.5066876411,
-0.3569624722,
0.1598443687,
0.6985880733,
-0.0816488937,
-0.1101766601,
-0.6339041591,
-0.1507655382,
-0.3960139453,
0.6727185249,
-0.5030953288,
-0.7207007408,
0.2504183948,
-0.2132965177,
-0.1436584443,
0.2031009942,
0.4589419961,
-0.1011310443,
0.7897822261,
0.5739204288,
0.0476134494,
0.9599260688,
0.2457618415,
-0.1471128166,
-0.8161257505,
-0.1391734481,
-0.666253984,
-0.4161890745,
-0.4929865599,
-0.2117163986,
0.2454420477,
-0.3875651062,
-0.3462126553,
0.4533516169,
-0.360165447,
0.2567587793,
0.3186497688,
0.1233865246,
0.2361719161,
0.054722432,
0.0026604112,
-0.1001132205,
-0.0295491647,
-0.6664311886,
1.0153779984,
0.2988035977,
0.4368204772,
0.2056605518,
0.527848959,
0.668152988,
0.1771588176,
-0.8799780607,
0.8308047652,
-0.5374757051,
-0.1012718081,
-0.3484539092,
-0.4539582729,
-0.7344572544,
0.208080411,
-0.3443544507,
-1.1165984869,
-0.0985991508,
-0.1985307932,
-0.0368085802,
0.1829600185,
-0.7492613196,
0.724157691,
-0.286393553,
-0.3182301819,
-0.2229839265,
-0.4828208387,
0.2523758709,
-0.1326508373,
0.1314378679,
-0.3543791771,
-0.0136277564,
1.0082384348,
0.1469413191,
0.6870818138,
0.1596456021,
0.0022670382,
-0.0227382835,
0.4397684634,
0.3875642717,
-0.4539049268,
-0.31074512,
0.0620335191,
0.0114905909,
0.0608272403,
-0.6882996559,
0.4976921678,
-0.7270461917,
-0.2462196946,
-0.2576955557,
-0.7011713982,
-0.7038389444,
0.4001533985,
-0.0654161274,
0.5564317107,
-0.6846051812,
0.0275049042,
0.5834279656,
0.0173797458,
0.4628852904,
0.3759363294,
-0.1359408796,
-0.3311016262,
0.865783155,
0.0280043576,
0.4171188474,
0.3452426195,
0.3890389204,
-0.571968317,
-0.5084861517,
-0.3157540262,
0.096456863,
-0.5883869529,
0.1563499719,
-0.5119608641,
-0.3591791689,
-0.559360981,
-0.1915966421,
-0.4101611972,
-0.4389425218,
-0.2613815963,
0.0539416634,
0.4842460155,
0.7300094962,
0.4036071897,
0.3703188002,
-0.8110687137,
0.1297255456,
0.429484129,
0.4401825666,
-0.0586665943,
-0.7625352144,
0.1545885354,
-0.2549553216,
-0.4143432081,
-0.9870577455,
0.5499310493,
0.2331432104,
0.3535298109,
0.0120471576,
-0.0151086906,
0.5411992073,
-0.3707334399,
0.5295190215,
0.1518232077,
-1.3547228575,
0.3945596516,
-0.2943573594,
0.2383824587,
0.6056990027,
-0.1449510008,
-1.0735406876,
-0.0052427738,
-0.6672528386,
-0.5364649296,
0.7854680419,
0.3824033737,
-0.0132675273,
0.2829905748,
0.2195972055,
-0.1335238814,
0.1982951909,
-0.2118046731,
-0.0286653582,
-0.2676507831,
-0.2889001071,
-0.1084277481,
-0.0991963074,
0.1119000465,
0.0066957721,
0.3805314004,
-0.0502273329,
0.4169203937,
0.1902694404,
-0.2095816433,
0.1896241605,
0.7548769712,
0.85181427,
0.3336393833,
-0.3354307115,
0.3060031235,
0.2475952208,
-0.399061501,
0.1061554402,
0.1261864305,
0.0640632138,
-0.1889574379,
0.2713728547,
0.9705832005,
0.3594056368,
-0.5369208455,
0.5703149438,
-0.1970201135,
-0.1342531741,
-0.2488478422,
-0.011526458,
0.1004130691,
0.1195845604,
0.1710504293,
0.2053343505,
0.3222664595,
-0.6236078739,
0.232161656,
0.0844737813,
-0.5618935823,
-0.5095923543,
0.3350975513,
0.4448579848,
-0.4695498645,
0.4338908494,
-0.1070116237,
-0.5117085576,
0.5070034266,
0.6250742674,
1.0949747562,
-0.2493124604,
0.1678124666,
0.3099294007,
0.0631891713,
-0.091251336,
0.4001607001,
-0.057227809,
-0.6051344872,
-0.3759468794,
-0.7037258148,
-0.537389636,
0.0142454505,
-0.6655285954,
0.5012546778,
-0.2918039858,
-0.2700220048,
0.1035950854,
0.0499107353,
-0.7428922057,
0.0513190888,
0.3869810104,
0.9447689056,
-0.8374052644,
0.9255847931,
0.6188908815,
-0.0381289423,
-0.6239747405,
0.0090903845,
0.2624563873,
-0.6537423134,
0.6152935028,
0.0666278973,
-0.3045314848,
0.1705225557,
-0.1672095954,
-0.9003418088,
0.9305872321,
0.4437520206,
-0.5729681253,
-0.1135274544,
0.1325008422,
0.6532689333,
-0.4052605927,
0.2898812294,
0.9199813604,
0.6079843044,
0.1418300718,
-1.3006311655,
0.1578390151,
-0.205269441,
0.3525543809,
-0.0041183936,
-0.546533823,
0.7338711619,
0.0150176147,
-0.3501570225,
0.2193833143,
0.7477865219,
0.0596568882,
0.1076437831,
0.5561547875,
0.2297290415,
0.8401326537,
-0.0537183657,
0.9955823421,
-0.14585419,
0.1255816519,
1.1363252401,
-0.5303146243,
1.0534789562,
0.2546690702,
-0.2506580949,
0.5061078072,
0.2058506906,
0.0873107612,
0.4263791442,
0.3039879203,
-0.1394762695,
-0.1407669187,
-0.4804283679,
-0.2209317386,
0.7894255519,
0.2013771385,
-0.2562547028,
-0.0404062271,
0.105083473,
0.0939015746,
0.1805659235,
-0.1037139744,
0.9303271174,
-0.0420985557,
-0.5257608891,
0.248214215,
-0.1865686476,
0.7739858031,
-0.5258615017,
0.03325532,
-0.0901460946,
-0.0442108549,
0.0289058238,
-1.0550403595,
0.3436929286,
0.0363948829,
0.1027830318,
-0.6026580334,
0.8067013621,
-0.3815875649,
-0.3684241772,
0.1396610886,
0.414927274,
0.3385580778,
-0.1359527558,
-0.5774403811,
0.2208099067,
-0.0861002207,
-0.0577584505,
0.4408972859,
0.5650556684,
-0.157843858,
0.6019684076,
0.5848454833,
0.2692605853,
-0.1062397212,
0.3388926089,
0.4493717253,
-0.8255267739,
-0.5777872205,
-0.7912217975,
0.0978662819,
-0.1204710826,
-0.4830116332,
0.5339443088,
0.3060667813,
0.5394443274,
0.0344852731,
0.9897873998,
0.0665287003,
0.6421312094,
-0.5130435824,
0.8270012736,
-0.3571794033,
-0.1106810793,
-0.7424205542,
-0.8215344548,
0.0299077909,
0.4531949162,
-0.3756472468,
0.1369785666,
0.8376684785,
0.3767246604,
0.0966038033,
0.2932935953,
0.3720449507,
0.1954762191,
0.3238383234,
0.5095348954,
0.7555932999,
-0.0829114467,
0.7336289287,
-0.5069253445,
-0.2246957123,
-0.2933416963,
-1.1373717785,
-0.6636011004,
-0.8693356514,
-0.4090885222,
-0.1947353333,
0.2006593645,
1.0481987,
0.9027929902,
-0.3795182705,
-0.5456680655,
0.0592323616,
-0.2074277848,
-0.435220331,
-0.2360200882,
0.4605009556,
-0.2265016884,
-0.8044519424,
0.4555656612,
0.1730692238,
0.221453473,
-0.0749476552,
0.2509733737,
0.0499957278,
0.1581728607,
0.7038710117,
0.0245997235,
-0.5511687994,
-0.4839883745,
0.0043286625,
-0.2325612307,
0.0933052152,
0.909537375,
-0.5223120451,
0.3643963039,
0.4312323928,
0.6051803231,
0.5275010467,
-0.026656488,
0.5389739871,
-0.8652971983,
-0.1963261515,
0.190998733,
0.248181656,
0.4899112582,
-0.1253225356,
0.3877107799,
0.1772108227,
-0.3926545084,
-0.7375016212,
0.2125771642,
-1.3487499952,
-0.1160321385,
1.2569127083,
0.0687182769,
-0.1128646433,
-0.0795766115,
-0.4090016186,
0.4815782011,
-0.6554157138,
0.7738497257,
0.8201954961,
-0.3177625537,
-0.3344386518,
-0.5339253545,
0.5624937415,
0.448979646,
-1.173276186,
0.2850024402,
0.0820758194,
0.4951718748,
0.0454306379,
0.5304083824,
-0.1027500927,
0.1367667466,
-0.2310812622,
0.2999567091,
-0.0116348509,
-0.1903982759,
-0.314029932,
0.1211534664,
0.0095751183,
0.0740977004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08385v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08385v3
|
ChOiRe: Characterizing and Predicting Human Opinions with Chain of Opinion Reasoning
| 2023-11-14T18:48:27 | 2024-02-28T04:30:53 |
Xuan Long Do, Kenji Kawaguchi, Min-Yen Kan, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aligning language models (LMs) with human opinion is challenging yet vital to
enhance their grasp of human values, preferences, and beliefs. We present
ChOiRe, a four-step framework to predict human opinion which differentially
models the user explicit personae (i.e. demographic or ideological attributes)
that are manually declared, and implicit personae inferred from user historical
opinions. ChOiRe consists of (i) an LM analyzing the user explicit personae to
filter out irrelevant attributes; (ii) the LM ranking the implicit persona
opinions into a preferential list; (iii) Chain-of-Opinion (CoO) reasoning,
where the LM sequentially analyzes the explicit personae and the most relevant
implicit personae to perform opinion prediction; (iv) and where ChOiRe executes
Step (iii) CoO multiple times with increasingly larger lists of implicit
personae to overcome insufficient personae information to infer a final result.
ChOiRe achieves new state-of-the-art effectiveness with limited inference
calls, improving previous techniques significantly by 3.22%. We also show that
ChOiRe Steps (i) and (ii) can significantly better fine-tune opinion-aligned
models, by up to 18.44%.
|
[
-0.5866550803,
-0.2544340491,
0.3489361405,
0.330933392,
0.0783660859,
0.1783253253,
-0.1018856317,
-0.4163592458,
0.2053759545,
0.649788022,
-0.681019187,
-0.5846719742,
-0.4020608366,
-0.2105087191,
-0.3706868589,
1.0015838146,
0.3472509682,
0.2159346342,
-0.0127568031,
-0.0016550692,
-0.2165032923,
-0.6880244017,
-0.5885335803,
-0.2941914797,
0.8660017252,
0.5545979738,
0.88021034,
0.331166923,
0.2196855396,
0.3426174819,
0.1295166016,
-0.0182399992,
-0.5761383176,
0.0366274193,
-0.2950978577,
-0.3120163381,
-0.7259443998,
0.5678146482,
0.0883162841,
0.7677350044,
-0.1979987323,
0.2300996482,
0.0572196655,
0.9346838593,
-0.4207314849,
-0.230006054,
-0.7025873661,
-0.1127915904,
-0.0983444974,
0.0975992903,
-0.4809817076,
-0.4960660934,
0.6586926579,
-0.4189539552,
0.0808281973,
0.2235620171,
0.5307670236,
-0.016503768,
-0.5975337625,
-0.3232651949,
-0.6832018495,
1.0650068521,
-0.5883933306,
0.3808317482,
0.4680133462,
0.4439091384,
-0.0972125083,
-0.5202473402,
-0.4234097302,
-0.0671582818,
0.1462165862,
0.3289884031,
0.128458038,
0.0834256485,
-0.1179351509,
0.4249077141,
-0.4672853947,
0.0445850715,
-0.276797533,
0.0921139047,
0.8607532382,
-0.2285152376,
0.1796784848,
-0.5275970697,
-0.6372734308,
-0.1115741134,
-0.3986516893,
0.1416585594,
0.5900318027,
-0.0767951608,
0.0823036656,
0.3727573454,
-0.059584979,
0.4810771346,
0.595312953,
-0.0414226577,
0.2276473045,
0.2347448021,
-0.4233252108,
0.0164979529,
0.8726217151,
0.4766529202,
0.3631375134,
-0.074633047,
-0.0002550151,
0.4152897894,
0.4782829583,
-0.6198977828,
-0.2725044489,
0.517790854,
-0.5919715762,
-0.5743851662,
0.2917338014,
-0.92469275,
-0.7308856249,
-0.5782679319,
0.0849075764,
-0.4019643664,
-0.0913893953,
0.1396968812,
0.0072008097,
-0.1553352773,
0.6039971709,
-0.7715992332,
0.4529110193,
0.784989953,
0.6511059403,
-0.2887425721,
-0.1435935944,
-0.4402838349,
0.0819696635,
-0.4568689764,
0.9363460541,
-0.5972838402,
-0.2735174298,
0.0105448328,
-0.0615827702,
-0.1767439842,
-0.3882285953,
0.941493988,
-0.4836663902,
0.7268651724,
-0.2053535581,
-0.9675166607,
-0.3552292883,
0.010900937,
-0.6216723323,
0.8879562616,
0.1987692565,
-0.6129289865,
0.1821867824,
-0.538932085,
-0.0080820732,
-0.1223285273,
0.0307340305,
-0.2559254467,
0.3073716462,
0.2745507061,
0.4172400832,
-0.3308564723,
0.3526868224,
-0.682238102,
-0.2246574312,
0.2674073577,
-0.2109179199,
0.8969692588,
0.3025462925,
-0.1151342317,
0.2432417572,
-0.6580806971,
0.1642469317,
-0.4548612833,
0.0076366342,
-0.1904980689,
0.5039539337,
0.1740517914,
0.366369158,
0.2054028958,
-0.3933438957,
0.3479703367,
-0.6764730215,
0.1923687309,
0.9690657854,
-0.0714279935,
0.6982145309,
-0.3556160033,
0.5823566318,
0.1353091747,
0.2557254136,
0.1789376736,
-0.5068061948,
-0.60300529,
-0.1431543231,
0.2593410611,
0.6974940896,
-0.1966472119,
0.6555128694,
-0.0790797397,
-0.4742579162,
-0.764434576,
0.1937972605,
0.2134619504,
0.4548962712,
0.3604548872,
-0.2535048425,
-0.9446812272,
-1.0759533644,
-0.5457169414,
-0.8472041488,
-0.3209261596,
0.1198450327,
0.3457345366,
-0.1108410731,
0.7636120915,
-0.3262713552,
-0.2249805182,
-0.1041256115,
0.5135455132,
0.2754698098,
0.5798787475,
0.258803755,
-0.7840896249,
-0.5145761371,
0.008850432,
-0.4970111251,
-0.2588759363,
-0.0461578593,
-0.3268714547,
0.091460228,
-0.1103935391,
-0.13739793,
0.194445163,
0.7578040361,
-0.1836436391,
0.374604553,
0.3325422406,
0.4028475583,
-1.1541838646,
-0.2397314012,
0.4519916773,
-0.1640321016,
-0.8136793971,
-0.3043266535,
-0.0873061344,
0.2137434036,
-0.2792756557,
0.3380710185,
-0.219276309,
0.0979404822,
-0.2453235984,
0.0782629624,
0.0196118224,
0.6052223444,
0.3577292562,
0.4437143803,
0.4193454981,
-0.1261965185,
0.0678957328,
0.2362983376,
-0.612474978,
0.7670848966,
-0.4727419019,
0.5378581882,
-0.1825143546,
0.2555634379,
-1.0118714571,
-0.3431898654,
-0.0823995098,
-0.5964125395,
-0.0470964238,
-0.3795261681,
-0.2223193944,
-0.3693149388,
-0.364269197,
0.3190425932,
0.6400322318,
-0.5253044963,
0.6882852316,
0.5183720589,
-0.1131073609,
-0.4173725247,
-0.0970272198,
0.1775043011,
-0.3802622557,
-0.847790122,
0.4302319288,
-0.1642068923,
-0.391874373,
-0.2462861389,
0.0859031528,
-0.243596822,
-0.0578309856,
0.1846912205,
0.4611671269,
-0.1829743832,
0.0899641588,
-0.1085002124,
-0.0579074062,
0.0522959642,
-0.6301828623,
0.2584841251,
-0.5082198977,
-0.2622585595,
-0.552690208,
0.466565907,
0.6099483967,
-0.0199318901,
0.4603851438,
0.2079033107,
-0.2931208909,
-0.1134190485,
-0.8333696723,
-0.028214138,
-0.4236286879,
0.3561187685,
-0.0713223964,
-0.5655127764,
0.2889468968,
-0.1057735085,
0.1105215475,
0.2195008397,
0.50800246,
-0.7722992301,
1.5387176275,
0.2404220402,
-0.4336378276,
0.3149975538,
-0.1360439807,
0.1346941441,
-0.8765454292,
-0.0723074824,
-0.5723454952,
-0.6600077152,
-0.7951889038,
-0.4190599918,
0.5294098258,
0.3519945443,
-0.378955096,
0.0451472588,
-0.3207321465,
0.39624843,
0.2747971714,
-0.0479521118,
0.1622135937,
0.0074323351,
0.0023228226,
-0.1083059162,
-0.462397337,
-1.0116119385,
0.7519119978,
0.3361152112,
0.5649300218,
0.1655045152,
0.5965824723,
0.3132666051,
0.7177859545,
-0.8082293868,
0.4946698844,
-0.3875631094,
-0.7821840048,
-0.1818603128,
-0.2869133055,
-0.509350419,
0.5018395782,
-0.2406683713,
-1.0628923178,
0.4020474255,
0.4361958504,
-0.1174342036,
0.2347723991,
-0.5123762488,
0.8352618814,
-0.2707935572,
-0.5711777806,
-0.2285190076,
-0.8694375753,
0.6925718784,
0.046076905,
0.3123986721,
-0.205455035,
0.055271849,
0.7225196958,
-0.4717082679,
1.0378422737,
-0.1074035764,
-0.1026147231,
0.1158081591,
0.0431818031,
0.4205858409,
-0.1219447628,
-0.6081707478,
0.0867961869,
0.0655485615,
-0.2963348925,
-0.9340284467,
0.7587100267,
-0.8321983814,
-0.8385092616,
-0.5028117299,
-0.364595443,
-0.6140799522,
-0.1471687853,
0.0416607372,
0.3785954416,
-0.3700031042,
0.2001930177,
0.3869601786,
-0.0299153142,
-0.0014417708,
0.398270905,
-0.4978107214,
-0.8378137946,
0.6381881833,
-0.1211924404,
0.3743439317,
0.3511569798,
0.5992481709,
-0.5470065475,
-0.1537925601,
-0.4113188386,
0.0250572171,
-0.5448684692,
0.0163611192,
-0.420935452,
-0.0725285038,
-0.1418802142,
-0.1992924809,
-0.323161453,
-0.6756581068,
-0.0669983551,
-0.0026361877,
0.1567950994,
0.7301832438,
0.2570602894,
0.5250716209,
-0.6342452765,
0.2336436808,
0.1594238281,
0.2891279161,
0.0579265095,
-0.4136554301,
-0.150597021,
0.1711913645,
-0.5920571685,
-1.1331230402,
0.2807903886,
0.2014361173,
0.2075095028,
0.7681464553,
0.0964097902,
1.095484376,
-0.4949649274,
0.7743396163,
0.4275735319,
-1.1165663004,
0.554031074,
-0.2923759222,
-0.1305870563,
0.766055584,
0.4864324033,
-0.7869626284,
-0.5845400691,
-0.6825965643,
-0.3703144789,
0.4623531401,
0.252764523,
-0.2490540743,
-0.1774718165,
0.3186501861,
0.1110376567,
0.3184700608,
-0.542298913,
-0.0967170447,
-0.5300245881,
-0.4569310248,
0.0332136676,
-0.0518579409,
0.2206661105,
-0.5193291903,
0.9666769505,
-0.2119672447,
-0.2681890428,
0.1598210335,
0.2501327693,
-0.355530858,
0.5018078685,
0.1821057051,
0.6001001596,
-0.3634446561,
0.1671480238,
-0.0996141583,
-0.0066736182,
0.2938892245,
-0.3066552281,
-0.2773033679,
-0.2528532147,
0.3383854628,
0.779907763,
0.3122937083,
-0.32998842,
0.6509242654,
-0.0103639308,
-0.0955335423,
-0.5873586535,
-0.0560564399,
0.2985930443,
-0.0843362734,
0.0736892074,
0.5148803592,
0.150641337,
-0.7500807643,
0.0559804514,
0.5627365112,
-0.5959771276,
-0.6425933838,
0.7205231786,
0.4152643085,
-0.2116938233,
0.3506960571,
0.2340849936,
-0.5426425338,
0.3649589419,
0.2574721575,
1.1661218405,
-0.6290140152,
0.408673048,
0.3957803845,
0.0319294482,
-0.1606222391,
0.3082686663,
0.1537462622,
-0.850515902,
-0.451617986,
-0.8543868065,
-0.2439934164,
0.1348486543,
-0.912283361,
0.2364084125,
-0.2368269861,
-0.2058570087,
0.1065470949,
0.1755673587,
-0.4200750887,
0.3483874202,
0.0388744026,
0.8756935596,
-0.7341665626,
1.0121130943,
0.5380760431,
-0.2694717348,
-0.7690652609,
0.1554735452,
0.4414205551,
-0.6524642706,
0.7164131999,
0.1804896742,
-0.547668159,
-0.0333571993,
-0.4512507319,
-0.5800320506,
0.641806066,
0.1720147878,
-0.8169749975,
0.1305885911,
-0.105587773,
0.6405952573,
-0.8269822001,
0.2913357913,
0.4465036094,
0.5932663679,
0.3140941858,
-0.5017197132,
-0.4435863495,
-0.2525030077,
0.179523021,
0.0494109988,
-0.3586069643,
0.5450943112,
-0.1588421762,
-0.2276014984,
0.4701361656,
0.9942322969,
0.2444009036,
0.2660385668,
1.1317920685,
0.2799746096,
1.0818821192,
0.2667136192,
1.1653790474,
-0.4268111289,
0.0719584525,
1.1475502253,
-0.8251148462,
1.1716930866,
0.4247228801,
-0.2618311942,
1.1067442894,
0.5791626573,
0.1520616859,
0.1679834574,
0.1693536788,
-0.3341514468,
-0.5598269701,
-0.0275754202,
0.0180167835,
0.5119065642,
0.0929407403,
-0.3953148127,
0.3639302254,
-0.3518541753,
-0.1868858933,
0.3994927108,
-0.1311343759,
0.9695636034,
0.0472719669,
-1.2194179296,
0.471406728,
-0.1947375387,
0.1283733845,
-0.4953511357,
-0.0743705928,
0.0730555356,
0.192880556,
-0.3592532873,
-0.6206709146,
0.0833177865,
0.1093178466,
-0.6052094102,
-0.3156640232,
0.5324590206,
-0.5202111602,
-1.0547465086,
0.3675337136,
0.6388107538,
0.1296747029,
0.0249885209,
-0.5741145611,
-0.2793395221,
0.1598789543,
-0.1845574826,
0.2955462039,
0.1917748749,
-0.2950498462,
0.510974288,
0.6873376966,
0.1395431757,
-0.2149869353,
0.5830790401,
0.5406261086,
-0.7613175511,
-0.5102138519,
-0.7773751616,
0.499818027,
-0.3587203324,
-0.0932912901,
0.6319096088,
0.7168357372,
0.5962311625,
-0.0699965134,
0.901537776,
0.2062829882,
0.7903676629,
-0.4079905748,
0.5007135868,
-0.5753954649,
0.6034693122,
-0.3945944905,
-0.792584002,
0.0109856632,
0.7179669738,
-0.3586432636,
-0.0142764971,
0.718968153,
0.9197698832,
0.0330478698,
0.624540925,
0.0956009552,
0.2955631316,
0.2482668012,
0.5203000307,
1.1395952702,
-0.2880079746,
0.1422034651,
-0.3183468878,
-0.4227257073,
0.2099334598,
-0.9729409218,
-0.8037469983,
-0.5337548256,
-0.4094580114,
-0.1328165829,
-0.0562833175,
1.3030570745,
1.0246851444,
-0.9945701361,
-0.8069028854,
-0.1251252592,
0.1721282303,
-0.5326806307,
-0.237253055,
0.2517443299,
-0.2465134561,
-0.8961500525,
0.4384627938,
0.2248669118,
-0.3010528684,
-0.5447980165,
-0.3054583371,
-0.2211517096,
0.4272880852,
0.6258826256,
-0.0825912654,
-1.3229084015,
-0.3914090097,
-0.1842340976,
0.1124804989,
0.2947819531,
1.0252349377,
-0.7204943299,
0.3291539848,
0.3534999192,
0.0929801092,
0.2167457789,
0.5769832134,
0.7934128046,
-0.734508574,
-0.3018018305,
0.4106003046,
0.5012409687,
0.1745966077,
-0.2198532522,
0.3533646762,
0.0824712887,
-0.6979923844,
-0.4399470389,
0.4592486024,
-1.2308944464,
-0.2421786338,
0.7470304966,
-0.0912702382,
-0.2695263624,
-0.161369592,
-0.3451707661,
-0.2725028098,
-0.529818058,
0.8648221493,
0.6425818205,
-0.268807441,
-0.1854930818,
-0.3571741879,
0.4647080004,
0.3858802021,
-0.7713040113,
0.0618333444,
0.8053970933,
0.0439924635,
0.1175038517,
0.5538816452,
-0.0838575438,
0.1826683581,
-0.5948998928,
-0.1012320966,
0.289696008,
-0.3378804326,
0.0087203756,
0.5693135262,
-0.0311316568,
0.1735741347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08380v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08380v2
|
Direct Preference Optimization for Neural Machine Translation with Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding
| 2023-11-14T18:43:51 | 2024-04-12T14:07:38 |
Guangyu Yang, Jinghong Chen, Weizhe Lin, Bill Byrne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding can significantly improve translation
performance of Multilingual Large Language Models (MLLMs). However, MBR
decoding is computationally expensive. We show how the recently developed
Reinforcement Learning technique, Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), can
fine-tune MLLMs to get the gains of MBR without any additional computation in
inference. Our method uses only a small monolingual fine-tuning set and yields
significantly improved performance on multiple NMT test sets compared to MLLMs
without DPO.
|
[
-0.2347700149,
-0.4715229273,
0.6050704122,
0.2381466031,
-0.3551678061,
-0.0066672666,
-0.2072984427,
0.0322715789,
-0.1883632988,
0.6639380455,
-0.6356161833,
-0.3611164689,
-0.7187959552,
0.2852962017,
0.523815155,
0.9478632212,
-0.0567332394,
0.186417684,
0.1553996205,
0.1884965897,
-0.2105575502,
-0.6024754047,
-1.0962013006,
-0.2438224256,
0.8170835972,
0.3507812619,
0.8334010243,
0.6856769323,
0.6432937384,
0.3362242877,
-0.2449692786,
0.4488396049,
-0.2691860795,
-0.0069519561,
-0.0821609274,
-0.5106025934,
-0.3673218191,
-0.2980083823,
0.6730730534,
0.8322256207,
0.0177469067,
-0.1143129915,
0.0879936963,
1.2859338522,
-0.7609423399,
0.2015023977,
-0.6310727596,
0.3619737029,
0.2193980962,
-0.4350091517,
-0.7489645481,
-0.5091292262,
0.1862408221,
-0.4860988259,
-0.0656223446,
0.0943132788,
0.3625689447,
0.5300314426,
-0.8283081651,
0.2214847952,
-0.7238251567,
0.8514700532,
-0.4343281984,
0.367613554,
0.3369213343,
0.1613008082,
-0.5311194658,
-0.1632378548,
-0.360341996,
-0.2449177206,
-0.0974899009,
-0.0830592066,
-0.3388844728,
0.6059247255,
0.3489564955,
0.1833448708,
-0.4444187284,
-0.0097665638,
-0.2150146216,
-0.1516400129,
0.7072421312,
0.1733646691,
0.0379670821,
-0.2892018557,
-0.2515647411,
-0.3915455341,
-0.6840358377,
0.5073593855,
0.4208651483,
0.3774442077,
0.2054259032,
0.4821438193,
-0.1359529793,
0.6207672358,
0.1646959484,
-0.2916240096,
0.2720394731,
-0.0672382414,
-0.3029514551,
0.2237191349,
0.8830037117,
0.4211528003,
0.2326505035,
-0.242696017,
-0.2853957117,
-0.144493252,
0.2169332504,
-0.7915645242,
-0.0653508008,
0.140986532,
-0.4255501628,
-0.3627206683,
-0.4018090963,
-0.6379218102,
-0.288441509,
-0.4424569607,
0.4317883849,
-0.4833720624,
-0.2035538256,
0.489938736,
-0.2347522229,
-0.0324516073,
0.0163985379,
-1.093916893,
0.2676737905,
0.4174080491,
0.7669996023,
-0.2952002585,
-0.1430109143,
-0.6767317057,
-0.0116052218,
-0.6457856894,
0.450986743,
-0.0520059913,
-0.5169647932,
-0.0443223491,
-0.0166307725,
-0.3217438757,
-0.4726158977,
0.5960653424,
-0.6465498209,
-0.3166987002,
-0.4049836397,
-0.2644416988,
-0.1275136173,
0.1387917995,
-0.5377649069,
0.7015371919,
0.0417910814,
-0.5824297667,
0.4299978316,
-0.6478025317,
-0.7678948045,
-0.4187286496,
0.0233895481,
-0.2674864233,
0.3021537066,
0.3984031081,
0.4947635829,
0.0820002332,
0.6094619036,
-0.2269769162,
-0.2506657243,
0.412207514,
-0.575552702,
0.4999393821,
0.2247256041,
-0.4893383384,
0.2763805389,
-0.8818448186,
-0.0048581669,
0.1346661747,
-0.6011434197,
-0.3928652406,
0.5253555775,
-0.3523182869,
0.3609999418,
0.1417067647,
-0.4606529474,
0.3118226528,
-0.7684901953,
0.4255200624,
1.0210974216,
-0.0555777624,
0.7585642338,
-0.0893656686,
0.4450351596,
0.2478636801,
0.3359202743,
0.427372694,
-0.3101658821,
-0.851882875,
-0.3532241583,
0.0471388511,
0.6034696102,
-1.1084356308,
0.4094339609,
-0.3765895069,
-0.1235814989,
-0.703913331,
0.0728800744,
0.5992195606,
0.431797266,
0.4494498968,
0.1405112594,
-0.4468325973,
-1.4839699268,
-0.1178285256,
0.0595764481,
0.0302553121,
0.1726723015,
0.0802533031,
-0.2225292027,
0.5627800822,
-0.6513257623,
0.1077368408,
-0.3532658517,
-0.1594882607,
0.5078665018,
0.5738860369,
0.5477356911,
-0.7842991948,
-0.7470729947,
0.1616051793,
-0.0576221757,
0.2215710729,
0.0535991564,
-0.4272178411,
0.3650597334,
0.1132398546,
-0.4348127246,
0.1937606931,
0.7521047592,
-0.1533848792,
0.1722490191,
-0.5096709728,
0.1981646717,
-0.8359620571,
0.1017765999,
-0.2108095586,
-0.1934032142,
-0.589486599,
-0.1436984688,
0.2334209681,
-0.1325149089,
-0.3771516085,
0.3497391641,
-0.3230193257,
0.2205750644,
-0.3682872057,
-0.1457790434,
-0.0660238862,
0.6402911544,
0.3063019812,
0.8234228492,
0.4092495739,
-1.053409338,
-0.1291020513,
0.3379268646,
-0.2881635725,
-0.0169151165,
-0.5377727747,
0.2165892422,
-0.2779994607,
-0.1351093799,
-1.0013746023,
0.2154524624,
0.3916322291,
-0.224266544,
0.5042390227,
-0.2894465327,
-0.2899202406,
-0.2819174528,
-0.2934989035,
0.132484287,
0.6141219735,
-0.5931760073,
0.1558674127,
0.1721336544,
-0.2161365449,
-0.8436377048,
-0.6014697552,
-0.2089497149,
0.0886685848,
-0.3939213753,
0.4004581571,
-0.3126294911,
-0.0015567103,
-0.2986623645,
-0.3127224147,
-0.0461510234,
0.155211553,
0.133501932,
0.1981891394,
-0.1447290331,
0.0868709534,
0.6347485185,
-0.4430332184,
0.0056146877,
-0.3235164881,
0.4532854259,
-0.0064933673,
-0.0420298725,
-0.0618463829,
0.3704943955,
0.3996930122,
-0.1253790855,
0.6960841417,
0.3985808492,
0.0154054286,
-0.1733810902,
-0.3032134771,
-0.0513419136,
-0.5603610277,
0.2602334917,
-0.8580251932,
-0.8619408607,
0.0608580559,
-0.0160839632,
-0.1750506163,
0.4768213034,
0.2964893878,
0.1620249748,
1.5703420639,
0.7629492283,
-0.4208557606,
0.5088145733,
-0.0524063259,
0.1046053246,
-0.6706568003,
-0.0442414433,
-0.381361872,
-0.5224103928,
-0.9517242312,
-0.295813024,
0.5076075792,
-0.0426421389,
-0.4542895257,
0.1295488477,
-0.6397053003,
0.548368454,
0.9398487806,
0.4471761584,
0.3625009656,
0.2309760302,
-0.4671463668,
-0.3411515057,
-0.8020846844,
-0.405811727,
1.0884033442,
0.1172904819,
0.5067117214,
0.1665820926,
0.6126213074,
-0.082749173,
0.0044613797,
-0.9003022909,
0.384785533,
-0.3410252333,
-0.6342475414,
-0.1573117673,
-0.7949682474,
-1.1218161583,
0.4278792143,
-0.2340050787,
-0.4576610625,
0.4264817834,
0.3166952729,
-0.404047668,
0.2803453803,
-0.3981108069,
0.8995162249,
-0.415116936,
-0.1617408842,
-0.3007075191,
-0.6765999198,
0.2985765636,
0.0897393823,
0.006338622,
-0.1686807573,
-0.343865633,
0.3611709774,
0.1299560666,
0.4555051327,
-0.2622718215,
-0.004521471,
-0.2621639967,
0.3605943024,
0.5692897439,
0.0923007131,
-0.3052659035,
-0.0697404444,
0.0161743201,
-0.3958256245,
-0.5049059987,
0.5382320881,
-0.9031494856,
-0.6040499806,
-0.4338088632,
-0.4307547212,
-0.4411436915,
0.2162124217,
0.3455595374,
-0.0105183469,
-0.3270670176,
0.1399245858,
0.9665437341,
-0.3274305761,
0.3996788263,
0.6356537938,
-0.1164504513,
-0.7976965308,
0.7176884413,
-0.2234515399,
0.3346072435,
0.9489774704,
0.4525325298,
-0.2438566387,
-0.9596489668,
-0.5973367691,
0.0672057942,
-0.4805448949,
-0.1709998697,
-0.8460841179,
0.010413548,
-0.239066422,
-0.2153818756,
-0.4770333171,
-0.2948346138,
-0.0084400382,
-0.1953800619,
0.2871046662,
0.2460089624,
-0.193568334,
0.4661004841,
-0.9466124177,
0.3571768403,
0.100512512,
0.3221652508,
-0.3480633497,
-0.4220332801,
-0.1872983426,
0.1361553371,
-0.2911449969,
-0.7368199229,
0.5432622433,
0.0567981228,
0.6064628363,
0.4148937166,
0.1993381977,
0.5401818156,
-0.9755054712,
0.4036159515,
0.2023374736,
-0.9164671898,
0.7903842926,
-0.3425091505,
0.0540230721,
0.8095737696,
0.7473393679,
-0.433213532,
0.3119726181,
-0.3645691276,
-0.6939473152,
0.6092476249,
-0.0181522071,
0.2248883098,
-0.2760979235,
0.4224039316,
0.0476176925,
0.3465240598,
-0.5378302932,
-0.3719885051,
0.3212976456,
-0.1016938537,
-0.7330861092,
-0.3982304037,
-0.1360583305,
-0.5369044542,
0.8296988606,
-0.2800898552,
0.2498057038,
0.3177081347,
-0.0820860863,
-0.2258345634,
0.3248135746,
0.6647202969,
0.1584532112,
-0.5288007259,
0.000596974,
0.0360641778,
-0.2307969034,
0.5537454486,
0.1621308178,
-0.365855068,
0.0543514788,
-0.2232220322,
1.1791017056,
0.4594025016,
-0.4806891084,
0.4752593637,
-0.0459702201,
-0.3813024461,
0.0809977725,
0.0523409471,
-0.1236866117,
0.2634103894,
0.0614848584,
0.3322269917,
0.4281131029,
-0.1645153463,
0.0460553877,
0.3396183848,
-0.4332948327,
-0.1850316375,
0.4354086518,
0.2248699963,
0.0378222018,
0.4282218814,
-0.1526687741,
-0.4428069592,
0.3803502321,
0.6101412773,
0.8727789521,
-0.3053860664,
0.2455151081,
0.5389823318,
0.6781356335,
-0.2874765396,
0.3201083541,
0.0801811069,
-0.7337744832,
-0.6055935621,
-0.6994758844,
-0.5727159977,
-0.0791435093,
-0.5843614936,
0.110414505,
-0.555124402,
-0.259034574,
-0.1336687207,
0.0996186584,
-0.5965016484,
0.1410558224,
0.0014269417,
0.6462846994,
-0.3312118351,
0.9036633968,
0.5265598297,
-0.2318789661,
-0.5384509563,
-0.3851076365,
-0.2461151481,
-0.681032896,
0.8546538353,
-0.0611901954,
-0.2334524393,
0.2139777541,
-0.1302034557,
-0.9125332832,
0.703687191,
0.7967098951,
-0.7865846753,
0.0352476537,
0.1980179697,
0.2422835231,
-0.1046165153,
-0.1876403242,
0.5685859323,
0.5661293864,
-0.2580194175,
-0.698982358,
-0.0269799624,
-0.0261387043,
0.1953401715,
0.6104402542,
-0.4391491413,
0.6247494221,
-0.2234742641,
-0.0258035082,
-0.190489471,
0.1947772205,
-0.0828355178,
0.1840592325,
0.3737492263,
0.2594373822,
0.6076919436,
0.085400328,
1.3725599051,
-0.2312034369,
0.0811681896,
0.9301457405,
-0.0362334661,
1.1056405306,
0.6473380327,
-0.3591216207,
0.0397636108,
0.7338086963,
0.4225759506,
0.8847277164,
0.4654464722,
-0.3209353983,
-0.34490031,
0.2452219576,
-0.2826475501,
0.19051525,
0.1211540923,
-0.6177973151,
0.234206304,
0.0494755208,
0.0785332173,
0.1379353106,
-0.3810923994,
1.0053780079,
0.1647120714,
-0.7288548946,
0.7755874395,
0.0712969378,
0.8705216646,
-0.8048371077,
0.3123289049,
-0.3563759923,
0.6002109051,
0.1430480182,
-0.2720033526,
0.316457063,
-0.2341066897,
-0.4805549979,
-0.2321290523,
0.7739497423,
-0.4222460091,
-0.5331522822,
0.4939364493,
0.4741573334,
-0.1164934337,
-0.5444145203,
-0.6968104839,
-0.2747742534,
0.0862968415,
-0.5053983927,
0.5873775482,
0.3330767155,
0.4068337083,
0.7758299112,
0.929905057,
0.1988099366,
-0.0339360833,
-0.2668248713,
0.6752396822,
-0.7797984481,
-0.2241217196,
-1.1452724934,
0.4875696599,
0.0054723974,
-0.1739015728,
0.5429409742,
0.6270060539,
0.7428345084,
-0.5132850409,
0.7756077051,
0.3446772099,
0.1592840254,
-0.7181723714,
0.6646468639,
-0.4952924252,
-0.3432200849,
-0.2110653222,
-0.8819578886,
-0.3595688343,
0.7532508373,
-0.4523726106,
-0.5450068712,
0.8607400656,
0.7246978879,
-0.0021176799,
-0.411658287,
0.6554473042,
-0.2170571089,
-0.0157466009,
0.8914752603,
0.6862982512,
-0.4883358479,
0.6600887775,
-0.4950401783,
-0.1947412193,
-0.2190086097,
-1.0874925852,
-0.8979884386,
-0.2002409548,
-0.340328306,
-0.3183959424,
0.2604956627,
1.1783521175,
0.4705634415,
-0.7191726565,
-0.1502175629,
-0.024480857,
0.3401013613,
-0.5047200918,
-0.0944197178,
0.1462213993,
-0.6495349407,
-0.8924489021,
0.7387087345,
0.312969774,
0.0903294533,
0.1789712161,
-0.3585876822,
-0.0409773849,
0.0909752101,
0.9065676332,
-0.0566507056,
-0.4108342528,
-0.045149073,
0.188182041,
-0.2505800724,
0.327232182,
0.903989315,
-0.1377924234,
0.4484271407,
0.5349645615,
1.0448451042,
0.5836238861,
-0.4631251991,
0.8077808022,
-0.5647414923,
0.2961645722,
0.227471143,
0.3585085273,
0.0025183316,
-0.5443277359,
0.5363759995,
0.1024224609,
-0.5995397568,
-0.4959750473,
0.2594488263,
-1.0343706608,
-0.2617889345,
1.1054792404,
-0.1334395707,
-0.239993304,
0.1456443071,
-0.5057607889,
0.1626968682,
-0.518776238,
0.4592109621,
0.5322260857,
0.0596127547,
-0.1025562435,
-0.747841239,
0.8083570004,
0.5245944262,
-0.4396826625,
-0.1901762784,
0.5372879505,
0.3217691779,
-0.184935376,
0.7538520098,
0.0537054054,
0.0823240727,
0.043717511,
0.2069579363,
-0.1098510623,
-0.2667543292,
-0.5359537005,
-0.1601567715,
0.371222347,
-0.4428450167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08377v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08377v1
|
Learning to Filter Context for Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2023-11-14T18:41:54 | 2023-11-14T18:41:54 |
Zhiruo Wang, Jun Araki, Zhengbao Jiang, Md Rizwan Parvez, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
On-the-fly retrieval of relevant knowledge has proven an essential element of
reliable systems for tasks such as open-domain question answering and fact
verification. However, because retrieval systems are not perfect, generation
models are required to generate outputs given partially or entirely irrelevant
passages. This can cause over- or under-reliance on context, and result in
problems in the generated output such as hallucinations. To alleviate these
problems, we propose FILCO, a method that improves the quality of the context
provided to the generator by (1) identifying useful context based on lexical
and information-theoretic approaches, and (2) training context filtering models
that can filter retrieved contexts at test time. We experiment on six
knowledge-intensive tasks with FLAN-T5 and LLaMa2, and demonstrate that our
method outperforms existing approaches on extractive question answering (QA),
complex multi-hop and long-form QA, fact verification, and dialog generation
tasks. FILCO effectively improves the quality of context, whether or not it
supports the canonical output.
|
[
-0.7813188434,
-0.9675341249,
0.6747884154,
-0.0909518972,
-0.2777656615,
-0.1718809158,
-0.1952896863,
-0.4096348584,
0.1440557688,
0.5186543465,
-0.5009849668,
-0.0878664479,
-0.4160626233,
0.1260041595,
-0.4772849679,
0.9953855276,
0.1096472293,
0.0031688744,
-0.3992488384,
0.1138977185,
-0.7626838684,
-0.3292568326,
-0.7009781599,
-0.3201795518,
0.3527974784,
0.3140605986,
0.4811677635,
0.182757467,
0.1237747446,
0.1876563281,
-0.1125373989,
0.6831738949,
-0.7948602438,
0.549285531,
-0.427696228,
-0.3280876875,
-0.0625123829,
-0.2131791711,
0.4030306041,
0.61882025,
-0.0146133918,
0.0074164122,
0.2526213527,
0.2854109406,
-0.8502873778,
-0.0529235341,
-1.0436989069,
0.006546753,
-0.0395947583,
-0.7531099916,
-0.4013493061,
-0.3574115932,
-0.0491574109,
-0.8424424529,
0.3458502591,
0.0934094936,
0.8252158761,
0.3896614909,
-0.5679683685,
-0.5452017188,
-0.6948798895,
0.6925638914,
-0.3003541827,
0.5367536545,
0.5446125865,
0.29313761,
-0.4301758707,
-0.7609957457,
-0.5913524032,
-0.0029476609,
-0.2187998295,
0.1414220184,
0.3782886267,
-0.1071067676,
0.3507293761,
0.2850894034,
-0.0675072595,
-0.6032132506,
-0.5623548031,
-0.4156320095,
0.5364580154,
0.0430235676,
0.1801758856,
-0.1568198353,
-0.3579235375,
-0.0314738601,
-0.850410521,
0.008637323,
-0.019128954,
0.1857499778,
0.5520447493,
0.3611921966,
-0.3953172565,
0.8482879996,
0.264562577,
-0.2207017094,
-0.0489352457,
-0.5143922567,
-0.0623274557,
0.014236276,
0.1510633379,
0.0175454505,
-0.0406733602,
-0.3937016428,
-0.4004860222,
-0.234185189,
0.5093194842,
-0.9363006949,
0.1578316987,
0.1059791222,
-0.1185486615,
-0.2569513619,
0.2952013016,
-0.8226988912,
-0.4624993503,
-0.4261990488,
0.6182085872,
-0.5630255938,
-0.2793321908,
-0.2124135345,
-0.1577702761,
0.2701872587,
0.328260988,
-0.628004849,
0.0293050278,
0.6060481668,
0.6025415659,
0.0162722692,
-0.1079582497,
-1.3886201382,
0.1377783418,
-0.4207464457,
0.8926281333,
-0.6097850204,
-0.4127190113,
0.1263444722,
0.0258642957,
-0.0506061614,
-0.6015161872,
0.2754253149,
-0.7265996933,
0.4127837718,
-0.4938442409,
-0.5481755137,
-0.1109330431,
0.0310657769,
-0.4571855068,
0.9481597543,
0.4441158175,
-0.5565658212,
0.5923225284,
-0.6053394079,
-0.6933526397,
0.1327813417,
-0.4137275517,
0.1281334609,
0.4222331345,
-0.0131613109,
0.3508406878,
-0.297693342,
0.5381914973,
-0.0286822096,
-0.5995109677,
0.088679634,
-0.2274248004,
0.6264674067,
0.6978335381,
-0.4372209609,
-0.084499374,
-0.7172542214,
0.0266308282,
-0.0652335435,
-0.435834527,
-0.4801784158,
0.1078989506,
-0.1399640888,
0.0994027779,
-0.0126155606,
-0.6784061193,
-0.0487233438,
-0.4736832678,
0.3157141507,
0.3870897293,
0.3228507638,
0.3386953771,
-0.3373876512,
0.3193234801,
0.1768105328,
-0.1047567055,
-0.1960722357,
-0.4499417543,
-0.7309398651,
-0.0589902587,
0.1679478586,
0.3642579615,
-1.2715009451,
0.2951459587,
-0.1582923532,
-0.2434982657,
-0.1384134293,
0.1906659305,
0.200459078,
0.8735861182,
0.3760715723,
-0.0739638358,
-0.4873377681,
-0.4121385217,
-0.271817714,
0.0549463965,
-0.239586249,
0.4095257223,
0.3410881162,
-0.3180978894,
1.3819433451,
-0.5541753769,
-0.3486194313,
0.0385629348,
0.035149429,
-0.101973094,
0.2360849231,
0.4526057243,
-1.0541551113,
-0.171468243,
0.0415906459,
-0.7973037362,
-0.2628831863,
-0.091656372,
-0.3112303317,
0.2235382795,
0.5653484464,
-0.2942964733,
0.3993527591,
0.001649245,
-0.6903973818,
0.2102879584,
-0.068422325,
0.3630391061,
-1.2077260017,
0.2950329185,
-0.3847613335,
-0.4407972395,
-0.6959403753,
0.0960625485,
-0.0833027363,
-0.241493091,
-0.5260556936,
0.8544631004,
-0.2530973256,
-0.0322085544,
-0.5638490319,
0.3194662035,
0.3914075792,
0.350913167,
0.1806466877,
1.0815235376,
0.1814201772,
-0.8874753714,
-0.0212804824,
0.2709049582,
-0.3847583234,
0.5427607298,
-0.1660086513,
0.0936428383,
-0.3146267831,
0.1007321551,
-0.8589484096,
-0.5646041036,
-0.045616556,
-0.4630285501,
0.278678,
0.1819252968,
-0.2622743845,
0.0674939901,
-0.1130310372,
0.2878994942,
0.4641606212,
-0.8284105659,
0.7053943276,
0.3686784804,
0.0062352638,
-0.3559498489,
-0.4628879726,
-0.2494888604,
-0.2174712867,
-0.561360538,
0.5147972703,
0.0400123484,
-0.2221902013,
-0.1203601882,
-0.2898124754,
-0.2586440146,
0.5271145701,
0.1929922253,
-0.1339697391,
-0.0523060746,
0.2936206758,
0.4288784862,
0.1266798973,
0.0318470486,
-0.0616547503,
0.5217459202,
0.0111437719,
-0.0071444712,
-0.0268918891,
0.4629473984,
0.4340420365,
-0.1085686535,
0.7599123716,
0.7539870739,
-0.6159662008,
-0.3556438088,
-0.4611500204,
-0.6633563042,
-0.4707018435,
0.1421673,
-0.6013126969,
-1.053550601,
0.3884963691,
-0.1041869596,
0.1861867309,
0.4290489256,
0.2387697995,
-0.0920176879,
0.9038331509,
0.332134366,
0.3561760187,
0.6978040338,
-0.2531400621,
0.3271937072,
-0.8267167807,
-0.2441061735,
-0.3491648138,
0.1494570524,
-0.2046449035,
-0.1084652543,
0.6323105097,
0.4700449407,
-0.2322477698,
0.0901862681,
-0.4641090333,
0.2834244072,
0.603395462,
0.3058853447,
0.3256890476,
0.5845557451,
-0.0794143304,
0.2520456314,
-0.7615202069,
-0.4620945454,
0.9383103848,
-0.0256643482,
0.4480042458,
0.0523943864,
0.6820670366,
0.5377684832,
0.3400817513,
-0.5821738839,
0.5020861626,
0.0944041833,
-0.7267315984,
-0.2546052039,
-0.513089776,
-0.9047710896,
0.3976280093,
-0.2451949269,
-0.6107803583,
0.3428905904,
0.1678704768,
-0.7815119028,
0.0684541613,
-0.5536910892,
0.441429317,
0.0400351398,
-0.6974089146,
-0.2839996815,
-0.3310873508,
0.4035850167,
-0.2166799307,
0.223688364,
0.1678501368,
0.1446270645,
0.6664381623,
-0.5371169448,
0.5395009518,
-0.4518342614,
-0.256821841,
0.8024876118,
0.2771905363,
0.3047792017,
0.4152823091,
-0.2533230186,
0.0119747017,
0.2026861608,
-0.1665498912,
-0.6583928466,
0.8387107253,
-0.6158083081,
-0.8486075401,
-0.2494092882,
-0.3966060877,
-0.3229345977,
0.19300282,
0.6422287226,
0.7121580243,
0.1325112283,
0.357686311,
0.7514039278,
-0.1910690069,
0.2019742727,
0.1240146682,
-0.1595186144,
-0.6265937686,
1.0455248356,
0.1747686714,
0.0832085609,
0.0791761726,
0.1017484292,
-0.22277008,
-0.1652992666,
-0.4093464017,
0.0500175543,
-0.8314531446,
-0.4113353193,
-0.6281991005,
-0.3377822042,
-0.4783962369,
-0.1918293685,
-0.0208756533,
-0.3179450333,
-0.485575527,
0.0853784382,
0.318382442,
0.5117425323,
-0.0928989947,
0.3643651903,
-0.659471035,
0.4534600079,
0.4413159788,
0.2715706825,
-0.0827088654,
-0.5187291503,
-0.1260058433,
0.2832925618,
-0.4694943726,
-0.8656741381,
0.1187176034,
0.4504199624,
0.476457268,
0.4908079505,
0.2176777124,
0.6289188862,
-0.2029106319,
0.8805191517,
-0.1918272376,
-0.8343558311,
0.8745843172,
-0.1402817518,
-0.0100322869,
0.8152701855,
0.120495908,
-0.2392837107,
-0.1261176765,
-0.4211075604,
-0.7560334802,
0.8401966691,
0.3052036166,
0.0537552088,
-0.3487982452,
0.7474858761,
0.3031488955,
0.3467337787,
-0.443600446,
0.146931991,
-0.4167336524,
-0.0927373394,
0.2400049567,
-0.4192574918,
-0.1020062789,
-0.0577739887,
0.9503406882,
-0.2292789072,
0.3589202166,
0.6234020591,
-0.4439207315,
-0.1748467684,
0.1132020503,
0.6828806996,
0.7424073219,
-0.1476541311,
0.1272093952,
0.1987089217,
-0.3038705885,
0.1595602185,
-0.1759249866,
-0.5326578021,
-0.0463241637,
0.1772084236,
0.7541239858,
-0.0637080893,
-0.7752620578,
0.4222055972,
-0.0134682031,
-0.1205586642,
-0.3369014263,
0.6849334836,
-0.4477364421,
0.1053050235,
0.6161313653,
-0.1183948517,
0.3660646677,
-0.666015029,
0.4588995874,
0.3657678366,
-0.3051926196,
-0.1109613925,
0.7738031745,
0.3026179373,
-0.2209207118,
0.6067406535,
-0.2810726762,
-0.4104425907,
0.5338661671,
0.5613523722,
0.6833297014,
-0.0746574625,
0.0607683547,
0.6293402314,
-0.045569066,
0.0255056806,
0.5729617476,
-0.7128717303,
-0.6216851473,
-0.2574813366,
-0.741767168,
-0.1095950305,
0.2035052627,
-0.5367864966,
0.1685664952,
-0.1784432083,
-0.251149267,
-0.3036149442,
0.156327799,
-0.6140602827,
0.3146958649,
0.047568351,
0.8121412992,
-0.6710630059,
0.7141081095,
0.6832091212,
-0.4525348246,
-0.5514816046,
0.1246939152,
-0.4443702996,
-0.3318426609,
0.6084696054,
0.3764737844,
-0.2711438835,
0.1804795265,
-0.4422594905,
-0.9898095727,
1.174885869,
0.3459992409,
-0.3008200228,
0.0850951746,
-0.0278114714,
0.3625535667,
-0.526725173,
0.2861677706,
0.5186850429,
0.4588819444,
0.0460358597,
-0.4511771798,
0.0886888802,
-0.1945208907,
0.019363394,
-0.0121361734,
-0.5393525362,
0.4706729352,
-0.0129322028,
-0.4879204929,
0.0706076846,
0.78555125,
0.5821947455,
0.6521941423,
0.7784240842,
0.0617267005,
0.808033824,
-0.1343810409,
0.9344489574,
-0.5694745183,
0.228796497,
1.0842194557,
-0.4200169444,
0.6407119036,
0.6678224802,
0.3047413528,
0.5160452724,
0.7129439712,
0.3710182011,
0.7443460226,
-0.0349313803,
-0.4025752842,
-0.4755052328,
-0.3249603808,
-0.3319818079,
0.2444536984,
0.6080776453,
-0.251767844,
-0.2789874673,
0.4472130537,
-0.0103925252,
0.1259557009,
-0.1456179917,
0.9180088043,
-0.0345661938,
-1.2939765453,
0.8330662251,
-0.2740849257,
0.4890810251,
-0.3816814721,
-0.1608274728,
-0.611931324,
-0.0031871449,
-0.2814816236,
-0.4083051682,
0.5277850628,
0.0346831866,
-0.2012856156,
-0.1374670118,
0.9853709936,
-0.4415785372,
-0.239639312,
0.2391178906,
0.4642250538,
0.2036449611,
-0.282867372,
-0.0190148614,
-0.1299445778,
0.1215859205,
-0.4457282424,
0.1375595331,
0.3184788227,
-0.137150839,
0.447576493,
0.4754728675,
-0.0787652582,
0.1506352723,
-0.1607768089,
0.7716132998,
-0.5531278849,
-0.359000057,
-0.4124006033,
0.2581111491,
-0.2548781633,
-0.1586989611,
0.3490934074,
0.5684589148,
0.8941034675,
-0.0043749348,
0.7529123425,
-0.4244141877,
0.3418462276,
-0.5208151937,
0.6714324355,
-0.930128336,
0.361466974,
0.2719679177,
-1.0981223583,
0.0018377866,
0.6324878931,
-0.0655363798,
-0.0371978171,
0.6166721582,
0.8108108044,
-0.2752707005,
0.0570396557,
0.4050542414,
0.0470566303,
0.4245878756,
0.472189486,
0.8435590863,
-0.6093098521,
0.5346678495,
-0.2504740059,
-0.1422900707,
-0.2618286312,
-0.6817234159,
-0.7105917931,
-0.865809083,
-0.2085401863,
-0.4671448171,
0.0210642498,
0.7233788967,
0.8562217355,
-0.7970998287,
-0.0075966944,
-0.3017607927,
0.1991416216,
-0.1062755585,
-0.2661859095,
0.0856663883,
-0.9064234495,
-0.6027060151,
0.7182241678,
-0.0859733075,
-0.2075626552,
-0.2422957122,
-0.0602408908,
-0.0469410978,
0.2716170549,
0.8249801993,
0.0609502196,
-0.7175812125,
-0.6423072815,
0.0872146264,
0.1001911089,
-0.0305803362,
0.8382465243,
-1.1970590353,
0.4809868634,
0.7774528265,
0.7147856951,
0.314381808,
0.1587137133,
0.5416272283,
-0.7368716598,
-0.0117561128,
-0.0619556792,
0.4763458669,
0.1437019557,
-0.7082191706,
0.8948097825,
0.2952404022,
-0.4405790567,
-0.9394056797,
0.1354927719,
-0.531842947,
-0.5378787518,
1.2814427614,
0.0395189039,
-0.204500705,
-0.1052657664,
-0.2648275793,
0.5070998669,
-0.2621022165,
0.9021841288,
0.5987840295,
-0.0259174649,
0.3117272556,
-0.503266573,
0.6377291679,
0.5153369904,
-0.7910718322,
-0.0728436112,
0.7862843275,
0.3675196767,
0.3294306397,
0.432872653,
0.1080458462,
0.3990332186,
-0.2956914008,
-0.0893333182,
-0.18297638,
-0.6585220695,
-0.1202564016,
0.6105670929,
-0.1865923554,
-0.0291279647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08374v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08374v2
|
A Ship of Theseus: Curious Cases of Paraphrasing in LLM-Generated Texts
| 2023-11-14T18:40:42 | 2024-06-06T23:14:32 |
Nafis Irtiza Tripto, Saranya Venkatraman, Dominik Macko, Robert Moro, Ivan Srba, Adaku Uchendu, Thai Le, Dongwon Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the realm of text manipulation and linguistic transformation, the question
of authorship has been a subject of fascination and philosophical inquiry. Much
like the Ship of Theseus paradox, which ponders whether a ship remains the same
when each of its original planks is replaced, our research delves into an
intriguing question: Does a text retain its original authorship when it
undergoes numerous paraphrasing iterations? Specifically, since Large Language
Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in both the generation
of original content and the modification of human-authored texts, a pivotal
question emerges concerning the determination of authorship in instances where
LLMs or similar paraphrasing tools are employed to rephrase the text--i.e.,
whether authorship should be attributed to the original human author or the
AI-powered tool. Therefore, we embark on a philosophical voyage through the
seas of language and authorship to unravel this intricate puzzle. Using a
computational approach, we discover that the diminishing performance in text
classification models, with each successive paraphrasing iteration, is closely
associated with the extent of deviation from the original author's style, thus
provoking a reconsideration of the current notion of authorship.
|
[
-0.0704338253,
-0.565677762,
1.2819718122,
0.0378411561,
-0.2901305556,
0.1472876817,
-0.0042121098,
-0.3276911378,
0.2477214932,
1.1786607504,
-0.4465237558,
-0.0419317931,
-0.8459867239,
0.5818654299,
-0.4298792481,
1.1368495226,
0.0602070503,
-0.2101201713,
-0.49981004,
-0.1547483206,
-0.2889146805,
-0.2454489917,
-0.4767851532,
-0.1961849034,
0.8397120833,
0.4170413017,
0.736269176,
0.8482589126,
0.8484109044,
0.4417274892,
-0.1769453436,
0.0088267112,
-0.4436893463,
0.3017991483,
-0.2147457451,
-0.8504380584,
-0.1456025094,
-0.0625399053,
0.6893997788,
0.6348890662,
-0.2420647442,
0.2006898373,
0.2888979316,
0.5451362133,
-0.4849438369,
-0.0984750316,
-0.6738587618,
-0.1224520132,
-0.5124897361,
-0.4785800278,
-0.416236043,
-0.4397858679,
0.0793247148,
-0.5962352157,
0.1843377203,
0.427123338,
0.5103226304,
0.3631434739,
-0.3809711337,
-0.5350325108,
-0.7036606669,
1.0424797535,
-0.7964311242,
-0.0397276469,
-0.0017200371,
-0.0309299827,
0.0090778787,
-1.1999051571,
-0.5932315588,
-0.3983125985,
-0.0966887474,
0.0198150668,
-0.0435835868,
-0.1930973381,
0.113246873,
0.5415143967,
-0.5380411744,
0.0352169238,
-0.5459685326,
-0.0128174769,
0.5421271324,
0.2502787411,
0.6658248901,
-0.4817230999,
-0.6197060943,
-0.0225953907,
-0.7471660376,
-0.1130394265,
0.3723051846,
0.0569690689,
0.180655852,
0.6136530042,
0.1492706537,
0.3694542348,
-0.1711950302,
-0.0984933078,
-0.0648862273,
0.0109910564,
0.0306077916,
0.2600186765,
0.8942149282,
0.2404311299,
0.2952605486,
-0.2251002491,
-0.0776066482,
-0.1515970379,
0.7544670105,
-0.1307364106,
-0.351998657,
-0.2131032199,
-0.4383229613,
-0.5592027903,
0.1619710028,
-0.4810674787,
-0.5241453052,
-0.2339881063,
0.3716430664,
-0.2692805827,
-0.1174980402,
0.0855698064,
-0.307048142,
0.0110458964,
0.1279873699,
-0.7202160954,
0.2228227705,
0.7864887714,
0.502051115,
-0.3120328784,
-0.7909673452,
-0.222398147,
0.2767307758,
-0.4538867176,
0.6223993301,
-0.6613847613,
-0.5265968442,
-0.2291879803,
-0.1351542324,
-0.0657746345,
-0.2613924742,
0.8047273159,
-0.486366123,
0.2570881844,
-0.8484141231,
-0.6957662702,
0.0898488611,
-0.1202754155,
-0.4220601022,
0.9018170834,
-0.3223256469,
-0.68489182,
0.0670196712,
-0.2503955066,
-0.190233916,
0.2754780948,
-0.2967997491,
-0.3394555748,
0.4779082835,
-0.2186092138,
0.323595494,
-0.6094414592,
0.1163718179,
-0.1873964965,
-0.3174553514,
0.4966838956,
0.0250423029,
0.9041317701,
0.2297526449,
-0.3078476787,
-0.3466574252,
-0.4501495659,
-0.3065568507,
0.1844724864,
-0.1120770276,
-0.6539165974,
0.2433772236,
-0.1938392222,
0.0097126998,
0.4044137001,
-0.8404146433,
0.1134815365,
-0.2989448011,
0.5017738342,
0.8584323525,
0.4356351793,
0.6229400635,
-0.9855535626,
0.6550208926,
-0.5302242637,
-0.1505763382,
-0.2489339858,
-0.9642393589,
-0.5271477103,
0.0499239378,
0.0888925791,
0.4051118791,
-0.7297419906,
0.1179765537,
-0.5327322483,
-0.7035265565,
-0.3633650839,
0.2815541327,
0.3957499862,
0.3947639167,
0.3282780051,
0.0049026632,
-0.2313152552,
-0.7538593411,
-0.7979187965,
-0.3518913686,
-0.1056049988,
0.2465424091,
0.4742765725,
0.1200910583,
0.5974029899,
-0.6914738417,
-0.1434098035,
-0.2985382676,
0.3270753622,
-0.2095604688,
0.6371724606,
0.6256489158,
-0.6565466523,
-0.3033089042,
-0.0405577086,
-1.014070034,
-0.2906313837,
-0.7040085196,
-0.2500690818,
-0.3125025332,
0.8880868554,
-0.8132637739,
0.1512342244,
0.211362794,
-0.0987465084,
0.4553596973,
-0.3213472068,
0.2076391429,
-1.1192346811,
0.0205388013,
-0.4955174923,
0.2616274357,
-0.2252613306,
0.2968406677,
0.0566787831,
0.1187268123,
-0.1328986436,
0.2821678221,
-0.5274464488,
0.0973079354,
-0.4279585481,
0.4468448162,
0.0499596484,
0.2967907488,
-0.2324106246,
0.3241538107,
0.4345024526,
-0.5923476219,
0.2916011214,
0.3848980665,
-0.1380756497,
0.6062117219,
-0.4319755733,
0.4217115939,
-0.3767496645,
0.1014493108,
-1.4783034325,
0.0989050269,
0.1318000704,
-0.2126043886,
0.0538025573,
0.1321085691,
-0.4691365957,
-0.2429309785,
-0.3515177965,
0.407182008,
0.5506849885,
-0.3270753622,
0.5731523037,
0.149027288,
-0.695194602,
-0.5301353931,
-0.7000498176,
0.5234516859,
-0.3489746153,
-0.3650192618,
0.7443947792,
-0.1316892654,
-0.5650326014,
-0.024206236,
-0.0695947632,
0.4405200183,
0.1058918983,
0.3084904253,
0.1399508417,
-0.0818837881,
-0.0310850963,
0.2503321171,
0.0923475623,
0.3144899309,
-0.2403427362,
0.2538199425,
0.14934811,
-0.2605166435,
-0.3387346268,
0.190667063,
0.704718709,
-0.3669833839,
0.5198224783,
0.0873752832,
-0.0969371498,
-0.2260763198,
-0.5934201479,
-0.0248418525,
-0.5358141661,
0.0077382573,
-0.3551268876,
-0.445214957,
0.4772284925,
0.1143788844,
0.1137788743,
0.8306547999,
0.1726872027,
-0.5214055777,
0.2107846886,
0.6815760136,
0.0935311392,
0.1056676731,
-0.0531135909,
0.0481082536,
-0.7727031112,
-0.170863241,
-0.5902843475,
-0.4889426231,
-0.8051715493,
-0.1273683608,
0.271477282,
-0.3749181926,
-0.0566563308,
0.5363073945,
-0.3352241814,
0.6614835858,
0.5216385722,
0.0169006493,
0.4359771609,
-0.2190918475,
-0.054195419,
-0.1819218695,
-0.4498021305,
-0.9131943583,
1.4275300503,
-0.157769084,
0.4291121364,
0.2192604244,
1.09595716,
0.5939233303,
0.2345005274,
-0.179449141,
0.9157480001,
-0.0936372131,
-0.6512089372,
-0.1985367537,
-0.3692610264,
-1.00730896,
0.0386161543,
-0.0493724942,
-0.6941698194,
0.0412940979,
-0.2122173905,
-0.364849627,
0.6003471017,
-0.0439789258,
0.7277560234,
-0.2813091278,
-0.3102854788,
-0.3805680573,
-1.0490027666,
0.2086305469,
-0.2996712029,
0.0498166792,
0.1581105441,
-0.2382320166,
0.9974304438,
-0.2224770039,
0.7950890064,
0.3257988691,
-0.5860862732,
0.3795001209,
0.3610461652,
0.4014509916,
0.0162002631,
-0.1426121145,
-0.1062332019,
0.0794297457,
-0.5068681836,
-0.4003782868,
1.1341561079,
-0.5258405805,
-0.6438046098,
-0.5326224566,
-0.4220926166,
-0.0115902424,
0.2001271546,
0.5129318237,
0.2700006664,
-0.185033083,
0.2839722037,
0.4526054561,
-0.2718917429,
0.6773088574,
0.1355308294,
-0.1141812131,
-0.344371289,
0.9968967438,
0.1476994008,
0.1345782578,
0.5440276265,
0.0767737105,
0.0053444933,
-0.3883425891,
-0.4288619161,
0.6771076322,
-0.6192860603,
0.2127794474,
-0.4664802253,
0.0434892103,
-0.0257697757,
-0.4467071295,
-0.2499684989,
-0.4537231922,
-0.5644943714,
0.0599669889,
0.1588613987,
1.1100229025,
0.4909358621,
0.5821502805,
-0.7693240047,
0.3573110998,
0.3989999592,
-0.1468418688,
-0.0696236864,
-0.8460103273,
0.0342988819,
-0.1285916269,
-0.6853451729,
-1.0946897268,
0.1108926013,
0.0085034212,
0.5379462838,
0.3371812105,
0.0725156292,
0.2934923768,
-0.6710253358,
0.9606599212,
-0.1900942177,
-0.7657991648,
0.0768741816,
-0.531359911,
0.2170704454,
0.2837392092,
0.4658515751,
-0.5395232439,
-0.8645675778,
-1.0618718863,
-0.55884552,
0.5472850204,
0.5356699824,
0.3933224976,
0.0492345206,
0.8061847091,
0.1557813287,
0.4685811102,
-0.8706667423,
-0.2081179023,
0.3032802343,
-0.168968752,
-0.4078306854,
-0.4162870944,
0.0299466122,
0.0781440288,
0.4131593704,
0.3396027088,
0.0715456232,
0.1536257863,
-0.2780200243,
-0.02176084,
-0.0256642699,
0.5696405172,
0.9670851231,
0.2453382909,
0.3714352846,
0.0905635655,
-0.2416131347,
-0.1435116678,
-0.1972239912,
0.0528505445,
0.0786704198,
0.6798404455,
0.4751486778,
0.3554298878,
-0.5550345182,
0.297069788,
0.2686032057,
-0.2160392851,
-0.3318757117,
0.04297271,
0.1754162163,
0.4072166383,
0.5010720491,
0.3707423806,
0.1556989849,
-0.5191326141,
0.0009479862,
-0.0285840351,
0.1655015796,
-0.4140595198,
1.0683600903,
-0.0585995242,
-0.6575470567,
0.3922221065,
0.0296652094,
-0.4737802148,
0.4955149591,
0.3118318319,
1.0132359266,
-0.4891442657,
0.2432441562,
-0.0666524321,
0.4078832269,
-0.2860555947,
0.1390784234,
-0.2345417142,
-0.521761179,
-0.1455271989,
-0.6260163784,
-0.4523838162,
-0.0629626289,
-0.4563804269,
0.1518870741,
-0.4011308551,
-0.1049815938,
0.2048035115,
-0.5902951956,
-0.014091596,
0.0368717648,
0.5008385777,
-0.0462186188,
-0.91458565,
0.4937628508,
0.6910380721,
-0.3518246114,
-0.1868370771,
0.3997517824,
0.0702368021,
-0.3225180507,
0.5308086872,
-0.0152913937,
-0.3634805381,
0.2858033478,
-0.5044819117,
-0.7471007109,
0.8842744827,
0.4901644588,
-0.3134403825,
-0.185795784,
0.3728553057,
0.8058480024,
-0.1170972064,
-0.3612776399,
0.2862003446,
0.2502945065,
-0.3231683671,
-0.8915604353,
0.0689199194,
-0.1452147961,
0.0878930315,
0.3068897724,
-0.5309451818,
1.0266765356,
-0.1760386676,
0.3718515038,
0.4101128578,
0.6622566581,
0.0426873416,
0.2987447977,
0.1782259345,
0.5337303877,
0.67636168,
0.1223691851,
0.9872217774,
-0.2005391121,
0.1802198589,
0.8022473454,
-0.3162991703,
0.8763223886,
0.7861999273,
-0.313483566,
0.7542077899,
0.0654684231,
0.0187792163,
0.2389435917,
0.1610194147,
-0.2458935976,
-0.1511279494,
0.3873778582,
0.0084962444,
0.5964745283,
-0.0840564817,
-0.6232478023,
0.0006331264,
0.2614764869,
0.2080221176,
0.4637991488,
0.0620115176,
0.7153778672,
0.3949699998,
-0.941313386,
0.4788068533,
0.1534130275,
0.197893396,
-0.351167798,
0.1537585557,
-0.1673768908,
0.1554153413,
0.0444365181,
-0.6922793984,
0.2280175239,
-0.0830357671,
0.0304641407,
-0.7360919118,
0.2403769493,
-0.2130917162,
-0.6099402308,
0.0846790671,
0.5330739021,
0.3055219054,
-0.1094603464,
-0.2926559448,
-0.1216119304,
0.1515059024,
-0.2872114182,
0.1526636332,
0.6483001113,
0.0837315395,
0.7979377508,
0.4853629768,
0.0333526507,
0.1806739122,
-0.4885493517,
0.4584192932,
-0.7063096166,
-0.5592357516,
-1.2181391716,
0.2447081357,
-0.0050618346,
-0.655818224,
1.1239690781,
0.601491034,
0.6055496931,
-0.4525074959,
0.6296111345,
-0.1272315979,
0.2942861021,
-0.4868741035,
0.9800313711,
-0.8862743378,
0.586838901,
-0.8661449552,
-0.914537549,
-0.1772397906,
0.2317719609,
-0.524040997,
-0.218246609,
0.9064083695,
0.6395186782,
0.0648452342,
0.3236072958,
0.1975502372,
0.0688784495,
-0.0142943757,
0.158201918,
1.0669392347,
-0.4569113553,
0.7404558063,
-0.1816917062,
0.2642347217,
-0.0883992612,
-0.7068374157,
-0.4949947596,
-0.9091280699,
-0.492988199,
0.1069821641,
-0.0141708227,
0.4403175712,
-0.2126457095,
-0.3547745943,
-0.594909966,
-0.454125762,
-0.0250504017,
-0.3061423898,
-0.1107135862,
0.3394668996,
-0.4476363957,
-0.8907090425,
0.3468376696,
0.2628878057,
-0.0843015984,
0.1445309967,
0.0815532207,
-0.3172020614,
0.2815047503,
0.23231107,
0.152056247,
-0.8307048082,
-0.0397892781,
0.0600613952,
-0.1920489967,
0.0218183324,
0.8063316941,
-0.4853018224,
0.3483185172,
0.4984339178,
0.7740312815,
0.4117664695,
0.0700144842,
0.5453801751,
-0.4922632873,
-0.1897674799,
0.3285569251,
0.4663339853,
0.2291378677,
-0.1908650249,
0.0809281394,
0.5307775736,
-0.8603897095,
-1.0981451273,
0.0191517528,
-1.0727038383,
-0.4434316754,
0.9917173982,
-0.0169543214,
0.0497863069,
0.1514592469,
-0.5476005077,
0.0584829114,
0.0467091687,
0.8488636017,
0.9018201232,
-0.0621138811,
0.015773518,
-0.476469636,
0.5648258924,
0.8465844393,
-0.3214816749,
0.1137716249,
0.3716853857,
0.3188099265,
0.3652146161,
0.3754794598,
0.0584061295,
0.0648887083,
-0.0737057328,
0.1165021956,
0.3566522598,
-0.3743061125,
0.0357072502,
0.4187408984,
0.2640307844,
-0.1608643979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08370v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08370v2
|
SimpleSafetyTests: a Test Suite for Identifying Critical Safety Risks in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-14T18:33:43 | 2024-02-16T09:42:19 |
Bertie Vidgen, Nino Scherrer, Hannah Rose Kirk, Rebecca Qian, Anand Kannappan, Scott A. Hale, Paul Röttger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The past year has seen rapid acceleration in the development of large
language models (LLMs). However, without proper steering and safeguards, LLMs
will readily follow malicious instructions, provide unsafe advice, and generate
toxic content. We introduce SimpleSafetyTests (SST) as a new test suite for
rapidly and systematically identifying such critical safety risks. The test
suite comprises 100 test prompts across five harm areas that LLMs, for the vast
majority of applications, should refuse to comply with. We test 11 open-access
and open-source LLMs and four closed-source LLMs, and find critical safety
weaknesses. While some of the models do not give a single unsafe response, most
give unsafe responses to more than 20% of the prompts, with over 50% unsafe
responses in the extreme. Prepending a safety-emphasising system prompt
substantially reduces the occurrence of unsafe responses, but does not
completely stop them from happening. Trained annotators labelled every model
response to SST (n = 3,000). We use these annotations to evaluate five AI
safety filters (which assess whether a models' response is unsafe given a
prompt) as a way of automatically evaluating models' performance on SST. The
filters' performance varies considerably. There are also differences across the
five harm areas, and on the unsafe versus safe responses. The widely-used
Perspective API has 72% accuracy and a newly-created zero-shot prompt to
OpenAI's GPT-4 performs best with 89% accuracy. Content Warning: This paper
contains prompts and responses that relate to child abuse, suicide, self-harm
and eating disorders, scams and fraud, illegal items, and physical harm.
|
[
-0.0743685663,
-0.8275063038,
0.590175271,
0.3431268036,
-0.1227339432,
-0.1770863086,
0.131319195,
-0.5852515697,
-0.2247349322,
0.6224269867,
-0.5407600999,
-0.3094446361,
-0.5913571119,
0.1485872567,
-0.5444338322,
1.067584753,
-0.0088795191,
-0.0357214026,
0.0307301246,
0.1268252581,
-0.4308184683,
-0.3521311879,
-0.8613008261,
0.1585893184,
0.5230650306,
0.3148336709,
0.7346743345,
0.3409528732,
0.7788282037,
0.3238497972,
-0.361399591,
-0.3209690452,
-0.2475482374,
0.2812821865,
-0.0725604594,
-0.1763014197,
-0.4423081875,
-0.1582005918,
0.2116148472,
0.564166069,
0.1738150418,
0.3045323789,
0.2734757662,
0.5526277423,
-0.6558691263,
0.0697548613,
-0.4459888041,
0.0210170299,
-0.0695538148,
0.1439696848,
-0.557284236,
-0.6059387326,
0.0441468172,
-0.1789057702,
-0.1595153958,
0.1225057691,
0.6804382801,
0.397166729,
-0.7174505591,
-0.2367949486,
-0.5283283591,
0.5500902534,
-0.583946228,
0.2704391778,
0.2189047933,
0.4362164438,
-0.3466855586,
-0.5179997683,
-0.4388175011,
-0.655256331,
0.0838650838,
-0.1077756882,
-0.2066400051,
0.3159322441,
0.3761388659,
0.0131160729,
-0.797524929,
0.1796029806,
-0.1911631525,
-0.4134898186,
0.7238960862,
0.3242797852,
0.5553985238,
-0.330024749,
-0.550796628,
-0.2755613923,
-1.0218394995,
0.0966742635,
0.1228532717,
0.4823802114,
-0.1820338964,
0.5460318327,
-0.1649633348,
0.3959946036,
-0.4604731798,
-0.1978426725,
0.0885061324,
-0.4013534784,
-0.3181188107,
0.1179116294,
0.8624392152,
0.3621898592,
0.4634999037,
0.1911504269,
-0.2556498349,
0.1286002696,
-0.0115667088,
-0.7955389619,
-0.2084510028,
0.1598497629,
-0.2696642876,
-0.639796555,
-0.28752473,
-0.6679453254,
-0.76800704,
-0.0448537208,
0.3561985195,
-0.429581821,
-0.1190825626,
0.1078922972,
0.058946345,
0.2098422348,
0.3857306242,
-0.511923492,
0.2045570612,
0.5746901035,
0.8404765725,
-0.2509598136,
-0.1847054362,
-0.7381469011,
-0.0370337814,
-0.2978038192,
0.8647732735,
-0.2399900258,
-0.3463503718,
-0.0057898322,
0.1003274843,
0.2338360399,
-0.1919164062,
0.5779186487,
-0.2607921958,
-0.422693491,
-0.4973023832,
-0.1087706983,
-0.0064083016,
0.3497131467,
-0.5440521836,
1.0948815346,
-0.2696785033,
-0.7833139896,
0.1628656834,
-0.782235682,
-0.5190631151,
-0.0366629995,
-0.0945547745,
-0.1352002621,
-0.214353472,
-0.0476627201,
0.4724590182,
-0.3187685311,
0.0602360331,
-0.7236810327,
-0.3878108263,
0.2484699041,
-0.7356757522,
1.0528351068,
0.300036639,
-0.3502252102,
0.3616964519,
-0.6241012812,
0.0433791056,
0.3082362413,
-0.2996884286,
-0.5450395346,
-0.2518846393,
0.3478499055,
0.3008582294,
0.0461779498,
-0.4504615366,
-0.2061540931,
-0.1655378789,
0.344308883,
1.0340895653,
0.1668428183,
0.0816488788,
-0.1630754769,
0.5693374276,
0.0280571394,
0.4563765824,
-0.2596787214,
-0.528544426,
-0.4873299599,
-0.1661954224,
0.1045151055,
0.8374421,
-0.5164123178,
0.4394560456,
-0.1917226911,
-0.5106164813,
-0.0946862549,
0.1004441157,
0.5324511528,
0.4184286892,
0.0047406545,
-0.0994976088,
-0.2288879007,
-0.8763254881,
-0.4718745947,
-0.5015963912,
-0.1264936924,
-0.1381999999,
0.5355350971,
-0.2682634294,
0.5562651157,
-0.5574936271,
0.1342496574,
-0.0770056024,
-0.0307963919,
-0.1457541287,
0.379286021,
0.6378599405,
-0.5401409268,
-0.3743366897,
-0.1952645183,
-0.6322726607,
-0.0760671645,
0.1654316336,
0.02690023,
0.1060327813,
0.4040076733,
-0.6762090325,
0.2460212409,
0.4265864193,
-0.3607741594,
0.5822556615,
0.0521294922,
-0.0713104755,
-0.9459847212,
0.122073099,
0.1003965363,
-0.2812573016,
-0.6683290005,
0.3618673086,
0.102260828,
-0.253313154,
-0.9530747533,
0.519076705,
-0.1495646089,
0.049288746,
-0.1075922027,
0.1683532298,
-0.2444939315,
0.1527241319,
-0.3805147409,
0.9795271158,
0.2422938496,
-0.6120676398,
0.1576996744,
0.1765641868,
-0.25357005,
0.4302779734,
-0.6846435666,
0.4061805606,
-0.0635246187,
0.1812458783,
-1.262062788,
-0.4900064468,
0.1813228875,
-0.1672291011,
-0.1192613617,
-0.0781555995,
-0.547092557,
-0.4140700996,
-0.5712105632,
-0.0163023509,
0.3884268105,
-0.2854803205,
0.4096154273,
0.4757059813,
-0.5749524832,
-0.6409866214,
-0.7381221056,
0.0407974198,
-0.1577661484,
-0.7418289185,
-0.4225175381,
-0.4271045625,
-0.2985749245,
-0.1258574873,
-0.178965643,
-0.2390401214,
0.6898853183,
0.6269876361,
0.3615158796,
-0.1826389134,
0.0249234233,
0.2396508753,
-0.2117396444,
0.1365614235,
0.2777581215,
0.3912209272,
-0.6444644928,
-0.4440846145,
-0.26498276,
0.3037334681,
0.5381174684,
-0.088311635,
0.1731201559,
0.2303608209,
-0.6344612241,
0.0388772935,
-0.3014899194,
-0.2602133751,
-0.5526682138,
0.4573594928,
-0.2334771454,
-0.9992818236,
0.3866492212,
-0.1007779092,
0.2278099954,
0.3274615109,
0.4000283182,
-0.0948267505,
1.1492577791,
0.5211008787,
-0.2168421596,
0.2863874435,
0.178391993,
0.2605201602,
-0.1829364151,
0.0316112228,
-0.6525694132,
0.0685291663,
-0.572540462,
-0.0486594252,
0.624493897,
-0.2046986073,
-0.7046377659,
0.2266889513,
-0.2958879471,
0.8701643944,
0.3654825985,
-0.0674139038,
0.4262087047,
-0.1872845292,
-0.118358396,
-0.0303446166,
-0.1857315153,
-0.8089479804,
0.9241152406,
0.6117592454,
1.0297963619,
0.2724687159,
0.595733583,
0.2706523836,
0.5705979466,
-0.8103330135,
0.8183042407,
-0.2176850438,
-0.8678437471,
-0.4023224115,
-0.2392815053,
-0.5462688208,
0.0288442466,
-0.1026092842,
-0.6831982732,
-0.1290462762,
0.0944876596,
-0.8830419779,
0.0971955955,
-0.8955822587,
0.7012804747,
-0.5079527497,
-0.2124227732,
0.2015643567,
-0.7665136456,
0.7825435996,
-0.2838562727,
0.2045822293,
-0.4407766163,
0.0771196634,
0.5571199059,
-0.1505829245,
1.1969752312,
-0.0747043565,
0.1143677235,
0.2127061039,
0.4679483175,
0.6944141388,
0.0211948976,
-0.0173565987,
-0.0330300964,
0.3456809223,
-0.2822746336,
-0.3238838315,
0.8104412556,
-0.5717697144,
-0.6366185546,
-0.684155643,
-0.3140226305,
-0.2594994605,
0.5706011057,
-0.1054771468,
-0.0222419854,
-0.2804089785,
0.0622686297,
0.8264695406,
-0.2252857983,
0.4646021724,
0.4950690866,
-0.2212854475,
-0.2404170632,
0.5555827022,
-0.038847588,
0.3126429319,
-0.1063130945,
0.4011030793,
-0.2616707385,
-0.6373673677,
-0.4397580028,
0.0103820451,
-0.9182162285,
-0.4508942962,
-0.5115884542,
-0.3494163752,
-0.4906696975,
-0.0453084521,
-0.3736949265,
-0.196464479,
0.1391243786,
-0.4971827269,
0.482024014,
0.8891767859,
-0.0326717086,
0.3331633806,
-1.0387142897,
-0.082000874,
0.40483132,
0.1562603265,
-0.1972172707,
-0.1239490584,
0.2706597745,
-0.2244321108,
-0.4025435746,
-0.8947339058,
0.0863235444,
-0.060646005,
0.2723408341,
0.6303936839,
0.5398187041,
0.5008324385,
-0.6153751612,
1.0514883995,
0.3366594315,
-0.9340512753,
0.5215636492,
-0.4439080358,
-0.1577031016,
0.9388259053,
0.5429807901,
-0.6771687269,
-0.2832151055,
-0.2295725495,
-0.8415996432,
0.4488749802,
0.0869999304,
0.3349265158,
-0.1430489272,
0.293040365,
-0.0138388528,
-0.0371958353,
-0.6624854803,
-0.1564220935,
0.1395744234,
-0.2853758931,
0.0738746002,
-0.4412844181,
-0.3776254952,
0.0173481163,
0.3865017891,
-0.2326216996,
0.1375363916,
0.0215854589,
0.0084448084,
-0.221542269,
0.328145653,
0.6874370575,
0.1868489087,
-0.2684754133,
0.3782089651,
0.4440578818,
-0.6101922989,
0.497977972,
0.011058867,
-0.2276204079,
-0.2930682003,
0.4050726891,
0.5852854252,
0.293592602,
-0.8914045095,
0.7951361537,
-0.1554619968,
0.0581989288,
-0.6378073692,
0.3295888603,
0.0140477633,
-0.0454918146,
0.0593844838,
0.1232790947,
0.2832002342,
-0.5354887843,
0.3932153285,
0.2362300903,
-0.4629842639,
-0.2548621893,
0.5928570032,
0.3865897655,
-0.3729988039,
0.2668122351,
-0.0892508402,
-0.4447933733,
0.5590773821,
0.3834932446,
0.9835318923,
-0.4566316903,
0.1932545751,
0.1139496192,
0.7912389636,
-0.2221670151,
0.4267187715,
0.5037568212,
-0.5087611079,
-0.323415786,
-0.4365099669,
-0.6616550088,
0.4475060701,
-0.4734273851,
0.3374636769,
-0.9731567502,
-0.1060572341,
-0.0000733611,
-0.1244109645,
-0.5185142756,
0.2073451132,
0.0155619644,
1.2006562948,
-1.2290892601,
0.4434818625,
0.6649646163,
-0.5603615046,
-0.9055566788,
0.3496468067,
0.5126588345,
-0.782738626,
0.6085256934,
0.3017775118,
-0.1475829929,
-0.2828142941,
-0.7231859565,
-0.8705025315,
0.9585541487,
0.7991650701,
-0.6043481827,
-0.2005055547,
0.2925568521,
0.3999000192,
0.0078520468,
0.3166913092,
0.6236335635,
0.5208142996,
0.008584219,
-0.8434163928,
0.4898257554,
-0.1252682209,
0.0108097363,
0.0520310774,
-0.6496278644,
0.5855771303,
-0.2251899987,
-0.1763053685,
0.1783330888,
0.2940456867,
0.560375154,
0.5693979859,
0.7845566869,
0.3612902761,
0.7480270267,
-0.0861304626,
1.2691959143,
-0.0811256096,
0.0954241976,
1.0356026888,
-0.5082743168,
1.1978100538,
0.4043295979,
-0.0883842707,
0.0073899529,
0.8637900949,
0.4275925457,
0.5221955776,
0.207662344,
-0.2744008899,
-0.4448513985,
-0.036682751,
-0.2162725329,
0.2361118346,
0.1796102226,
-0.25161165,
-0.3476657569,
0.2221962065,
0.3730601072,
-0.297534883,
-0.0171440989,
0.541981101,
0.4768793881,
-0.1950440407,
0.3045415282,
-0.1155726016,
0.466155827,
-0.6237828135,
0.0996591449,
-0.3846632242,
0.182832554,
0.1012310684,
-0.877840817,
0.3363603354,
0.2854560018,
0.2932496071,
0.0666194782,
0.9346887469,
-0.0023880948,
-0.3754532039,
0.3970123529,
0.1993690878,
0.1765952408,
-0.1543519795,
-0.7677610517,
0.2315475494,
-0.2105264217,
-0.3975806832,
0.3314016759,
0.2288876921,
-0.2856351435,
0.7830354571,
0.7927455902,
-0.0753754005,
0.1143280566,
-0.247585535,
0.8526688814,
-0.74586308,
-0.4901846349,
-0.6640201211,
0.5917813182,
-0.1101413891,
-0.3074089289,
0.599593699,
0.2191141546,
0.5227748156,
-0.1418891996,
0.9351813197,
0.182360217,
0.3011010885,
-0.5297484398,
1.09615767,
-0.4261841774,
0.2662733793,
-0.3608329296,
-0.6429412961,
-0.5469879508,
0.3813229501,
-0.3151067495,
-0.0202992149,
0.7136635184,
0.8754659295,
0.0669539794,
0.109752357,
0.3858493865,
0.3679198027,
0.5863612294,
0.5622153878,
0.9843037128,
-0.428802669,
0.7234031558,
-0.1782496572,
-0.272257179,
-0.334151417,
-1.1035952568,
-0.9791939855,
-0.3605060577,
-0.3544424474,
-0.5330515504,
0.2401716411,
1.173453927,
0.4613325298,
-0.9297350645,
0.1120162159,
0.0198948104,
-0.0308640823,
-0.0862646252,
-0.194650948,
0.3019220531,
-0.111645028,
-0.4020670056,
0.545352459,
0.2774628997,
0.2802473903,
-0.2976753712,
0.0146120368,
0.2865063548,
0.2326163501,
0.7236868739,
0.2882659435,
-0.5256517529,
-0.8241067529,
0.0654311925,
-0.3391962349,
-0.4628141224,
0.4103351235,
0.0251218062,
0.1076395735,
0.6477741599,
0.8661543131,
0.041348163,
-0.4915077686,
0.1665968448,
-0.5493869781,
0.2108878344,
0.1923519224,
0.3414550722,
0.2569613159,
-0.590933919,
0.5591521859,
0.1768956035,
-0.4686516225,
-1.240151763,
0.3248078823,
-1.0347005129,
-0.052506201,
1.3337520361,
-0.2740722895,
-0.4262114763,
-0.1788300127,
-0.2310948819,
-0.0725998655,
-0.382014066,
0.7737140656,
0.5649960041,
0.058905609,
-0.0026246549,
-0.8389220834,
0.5455204844,
0.365632087,
-0.8657559156,
0.19255054,
0.3576113284,
0.8008577228,
0.2131223381,
0.6672185063,
-0.1198303774,
0.409116745,
-0.1813384593,
-0.0176369585,
-0.0761395693,
-0.4039472938,
-0.57846874,
0.1204868183,
0.3581033945,
-0.150632605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08369v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08369v3
|
How You Prompt Matters! Even Task-Oriented Constraints in Instructions Affect LLM-Generated Text Detection
| 2023-11-14T18:32:52 | 2024-06-12T06:30:39 |
Ryuto Koike, Masahiro Kaneko, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To combat the misuse of Large Language Models (LLMs), many recent studies
have presented LLM-generated-text detectors with promising performance. When
users instruct LLMs to generate texts, the instruction can include different
constraints depending on the user's need. However, most recent studies do not
cover such diverse instruction patterns when creating datasets for LLM
detection. In this paper, we reveal that even task-oriented constraints --
constraints that would naturally be included in an instruction and are not
related to detection-evasion -- cause existing powerful detectors to have a
large variance in detection performance. We focus on student essay writing as a
realistic domain and manually create task-oriented constraints based on several
factors for essay quality. Our experiments show that the standard deviation
(SD) of current detector performance on texts generated by an instruction with
such a constraint is significantly larger (up to an SD of 14.4 F1-score) than
that by generating texts multiple times or paraphrasing the instruction. We
also observe an overall trend where the constraints can make LLM detection more
challenging than without them. Finally, our analysis indicates that the high
instruction-following ability of LLMs fosters the large impact of such
constraints on detection performance.
|
[
-0.1847926378,
-0.5494695306,
1.1198959351,
0.1796787977,
-0.1940434873,
-0.265122354,
-0.2247683257,
-0.2745951712,
-0.1848792285,
0.7020342946,
-0.6603904963,
-0.780777514,
-0.7939012647,
0.5894110203,
-0.1203377694,
1.010702014,
-0.3519066572,
-0.1087303534,
-0.6888162494,
0.0611452572,
-0.7502644658,
-0.6019111872,
-0.2412900031,
-0.0789620206,
0.4244967103,
0.6653507948,
0.0814167708,
0.9584339261,
0.4866721332,
0.3204711974,
-0.0225537233,
0.3470766544,
-0.0629896,
0.6306654215,
-0.0168824904,
-0.8268407583,
0.1315570325,
0.0538394451,
0.6263098121,
0.5601736307,
0.1699902862,
-0.070001632,
0.3385085464,
0.3413199186,
-0.7673981786,
0.0754977986,
-0.3504461944,
-0.0798493847,
-0.5523024201,
-0.2128968984,
-0.5333127975,
-0.1656316817,
-0.1444498003,
-0.5993533134,
0.5111063719,
0.0536754206,
0.5599253178,
0.3069369495,
-0.442310214,
-0.7782963514,
-0.7241330147,
0.9167141318,
-0.3368284106,
-0.0963504016,
0.2973714769,
0.0597277731,
-0.3760249317,
-0.3655740619,
-0.5678201318,
0.0833130032,
-0.0806938633,
0.0072488571,
-0.0536262728,
0.2777822018,
0.6496750116,
-0.1013632715,
-0.4439327717,
0.2065700144,
-0.0737222582,
-0.4590052962,
0.3151195049,
0.6413570642,
0.1787414551,
-0.3597034514,
-0.147246927,
-0.0099437935,
-0.7480194569,
0.3043144941,
0.6712861061,
0.2714794278,
0.335952431,
0.5689669251,
0.0307019837,
0.65400666,
0.1634568721,
-0.2846640646,
-0.1381170899,
-0.2644141614,
0.1706892997,
-0.1108853817,
0.6763470769,
0.3077276349,
0.0742983222,
0.1573811024,
-0.5309324265,
0.1818792373,
-0.0005437234,
-0.8418839574,
-0.0010939757,
-0.2222614884,
-0.3578138351,
-0.0664411262,
0.1226049289,
-0.3657217622,
-0.552331984,
-0.4232285619,
0.4172726572,
-0.259313643,
0.3944768012,
-0.0038655717,
-0.1032016873,
0.1796150506,
0.4764206707,
-0.7581266165,
0.1184069961,
0.8069311976,
0.5889630318,
-0.4758071303,
-0.3075420856,
-0.7691263556,
-0.0289253369,
-0.2221461535,
0.8340442777,
-0.7604811788,
-0.5253190398,
0.2027560174,
0.2043139338,
-0.1550324708,
-0.672998786,
0.863355875,
-0.1035514101,
0.2448412627,
-0.6335595846,
-0.8765033484,
0.1897716075,
-0.169781208,
-0.4608752728,
0.9029595852,
-0.0944410339,
-0.6391203403,
0.5127894282,
-0.1255836785,
-0.8525956869,
0.1647990346,
-0.5005021691,
-0.5477805138,
0.1886678636,
0.1711667627,
0.7324077487,
-0.0254337024,
0.3614464998,
0.1252752244,
-0.7022758126,
0.514528513,
-0.4434309602,
0.4949731827,
0.050128255,
-0.3985435963,
-0.0449618883,
-0.8315628171,
-0.3773914278,
-0.2610971928,
-0.5664391518,
-0.3626423478,
0.2369633317,
-0.2275902033,
-0.0903953239,
0.2018655539,
-0.6411343813,
0.0087296283,
-0.007703206,
0.1488262117,
1.0677858591,
0.2297823429,
0.2660436034,
-0.3113006055,
0.7469621301,
-0.1170437336,
-0.1070820019,
-0.5255691409,
-0.5434913039,
-0.6812698245,
-0.1676098406,
-0.2470473647,
0.6678689122,
-0.6308522224,
0.3382175863,
0.2866652906,
-0.0390726887,
-0.2374340296,
0.3688157499,
0.5762665272,
0.5660760403,
0.2264315784,
0.0978953391,
-0.4769312441,
-0.8377957344,
-0.5516192317,
-0.0981209353,
-0.1649218351,
0.4223902524,
0.5599336624,
0.1467721909,
0.7767737508,
-0.8213553429,
-0.3684028089,
-0.4564811885,
0.2109939754,
0.1887867302,
0.4621071517,
0.4532792568,
-0.4634678662,
-0.6726951003,
-0.5445250273,
-0.7013310194,
-0.9281144738,
-0.5104419589,
0.0552905165,
0.3297444582,
0.6797764301,
-0.567797184,
0.6328461766,
0.0217804145,
-0.45442909,
0.6125765443,
-0.1037794426,
0.0421592891,
-0.8824875951,
-0.369982928,
0.1974102259,
-0.0928065851,
-0.6275984645,
0.0741279796,
0.2127676159,
-0.1327879578,
-0.0700359717,
0.1611289084,
-0.4123528004,
0.3885441124,
-0.5942167044,
-0.0935198441,
0.3402145207,
0.4080275297,
-0.0229266528,
0.8884199858,
0.569208622,
-0.7730846405,
-0.1291339248,
0.0567653067,
-0.5702636242,
0.8681491613,
-0.5458928347,
0.083510749,
-0.2203910798,
0.1875979751,
-1.0545196533,
-0.2934027016,
0.24449265,
-0.2108504623,
0.487159282,
0.1201668456,
-0.3035189211,
-0.3052586317,
-0.3883031309,
0.0299566239,
0.3881679475,
-0.5508694053,
0.4700623155,
-0.0532910414,
0.14912799,
-0.7045547962,
-0.6542018652,
0.0529735796,
-0.2653477192,
-0.3942334056,
0.4997877181,
-0.1561678052,
-0.1550854295,
-0.0113573,
-0.3379791379,
0.0243855752,
0.1977921426,
0.5787205696,
0.2344252914,
-0.0445870571,
0.2789952457,
0.1745168567,
0.0147109134,
0.4473152757,
-0.2392410338,
0.185405165,
0.556181848,
-0.5077120066,
-0.8527783751,
0.6501612067,
0.486032486,
0.0986459255,
0.6443769932,
0.4769492447,
-0.0915467814,
-0.5222222209,
-0.5741937757,
-0.2697893083,
-0.5537567139,
0.2690491378,
-0.3271540999,
-1.0335177183,
0.2593428195,
0.2919465303,
0.0682435706,
0.1535516977,
0.253983885,
-0.3346765041,
1.008230567,
0.6506542563,
0.1191574708,
0.517826438,
0.3899196088,
0.2128154933,
-0.9205386043,
-0.2346540838,
-0.8387547135,
-0.2888561189,
-0.6310222149,
-0.4308827221,
0.2753506601,
-0.0596789755,
0.0859257057,
0.2288053185,
-0.8477662802,
0.7247123122,
0.5369569063,
0.2036569864,
0.0190983303,
-0.1637107283,
0.1304466873,
-0.335139662,
-0.3601153791,
-0.7055150867,
1.2709615231,
-0.0053021424,
0.8942385912,
-0.1443466246,
1.0719786882,
0.2112492025,
0.0901849866,
-0.6649172306,
0.9271118045,
-0.2713618279,
-0.4739004076,
-0.0553054623,
-0.4854160845,
-1.0171496868,
-0.0669326782,
0.0328989252,
-0.7185282707,
0.2773646116,
0.0631032586,
-0.2849904597,
0.075732477,
-0.6194976568,
0.5656380653,
-0.0649168044,
-0.4204660058,
0.165938437,
-0.2005361766,
-0.0373941101,
0.092933096,
-0.058822412,
-0.3091160059,
-0.1350897998,
0.8767071366,
-0.394243896,
1.1497286558,
-0.3993960321,
-0.0050889743,
0.7385425568,
0.0008647179,
0.8026527166,
-0.0674214065,
0.0520514771,
-0.4574147463,
-0.3381564021,
-0.2244016677,
-0.4418796003,
0.6774004698,
-0.5623935461,
-1.4309734106,
-0.3826328516,
-0.8557385206,
0.0231532082,
-0.0801516771,
0.7233805656,
0.4834806919,
-0.00829993,
0.1527053416,
0.9938364625,
-0.2909599245,
0.4958461225,
0.5397934318,
0.0902684405,
0.1839080304,
1.0051534176,
0.3258658648,
0.168716833,
0.429302752,
0.276591152,
-0.1449012905,
-0.8284425139,
-0.4229930043,
0.0223490018,
-1.121003747,
-0.1271429062,
-0.7345150709,
0.1450003982,
-0.5296429396,
-0.3835735619,
0.1832480133,
-0.3597096205,
-0.8473762274,
0.0169357117,
0.244256109,
0.7139783502,
0.0861943066,
0.4333611429,
-0.4392511845,
0.0584777594,
0.4601878822,
-0.0926925465,
-0.2625354826,
-0.7754760981,
-0.1801836044,
-0.571829319,
-0.456154108,
-0.823423624,
0.0555654019,
0.1111790463,
0.5932287574,
0.4806554317,
0.1035161763,
0.3487124145,
-0.3648294508,
0.8306196928,
-0.1296792328,
-1.0005407333,
0.5417971611,
-0.1855666488,
0.5701267719,
0.4745461047,
0.224747926,
-0.3707617819,
-0.9021387696,
0.0259166509,
-0.5943363309,
0.8754355311,
0.1844339222,
0.4270995557,
-0.1164541543,
0.7418743968,
0.1449917108,
0.1022206768,
-0.7401175499,
-0.1367540658,
0.0804349631,
-0.3820914626,
0.1956593245,
-0.5253815651,
-0.0160134435,
-0.0942749828,
0.4223787785,
0.0214527547,
0.2224502265,
0.3452257216,
0.0178984199,
0.0371269062,
0.239253968,
0.6911934018,
0.2380243242,
0.170799762,
0.1558933109,
0.0585518032,
-0.6176105142,
0.228032425,
0.1317359954,
-0.4065043628,
0.1997219473,
0.7547756433,
0.8278326392,
-0.1435384601,
-0.5286570191,
0.5460103154,
0.0115289176,
-0.2356047928,
-0.0067078648,
0.6520159245,
-0.2712875307,
0.1878255308,
0.4395756125,
0.0362084471,
0.0662997067,
-0.2531276643,
-0.0082278848,
0.4846223295,
-0.1665130854,
-0.2275279611,
0.6576184034,
0.2685283124,
-0.3506616652,
0.2793453336,
-0.4127402604,
-0.7727175355,
1.0270614624,
0.7719180584,
0.8488737345,
-0.4089404345,
0.1639996767,
0.2652235627,
0.4480983615,
-0.0302097946,
0.4062432647,
-0.2150002867,
-0.6663789153,
-0.4328415394,
-0.4479996264,
-0.4550974071,
0.106460616,
-0.5410577655,
0.2162953615,
-0.5249163508,
-0.014714255,
0.1464678645,
-0.0482712276,
-0.5443310738,
-0.0093866102,
0.1813301593,
0.4948003888,
-0.8309500217,
0.5224413276,
0.6108543277,
0.1318792403,
-0.7262511253,
0.1587215811,
0.4824991822,
-0.5894187689,
0.5485491753,
0.7422508597,
-0.2383144051,
-0.3964324594,
-0.6608148217,
-0.4109224379,
0.7755584121,
0.0658106506,
-0.6460944414,
0.2293921113,
0.3963906765,
0.5131009221,
-0.5950443149,
-0.2388840914,
0.5162547827,
0.473425746,
-0.1078857929,
-0.1717333496,
0.2193159759,
0.0984600633,
-0.108434543,
0.4330982268,
-0.2775026262,
1.1024454832,
-0.1514467299,
-0.5656006932,
0.0854234993,
0.4323410988,
0.0426088087,
0.7588758469,
0.3652325571,
0.4740003049,
0.7765445709,
-0.261218071,
0.9496201873,
0.0133835636,
-0.2482868582,
0.9751443267,
-0.4514496028,
0.2828357816,
0.5933426023,
0.0419691019,
0.503018856,
0.4705064595,
-0.1600415856,
0.2096714377,
0.263138622,
-0.5484740138,
-0.4477235675,
-0.4748700559,
-0.0215175319,
0.3627539277,
0.4363160133,
-0.4880488813,
0.0769594684,
0.3332170546,
0.165897727,
0.6295537353,
-0.3277308047,
0.447397083,
-0.0769739076,
-1.0237169266,
0.2686671615,
0.0000829837,
0.711388886,
-0.3502103984,
0.0241056345,
-0.3567029536,
0.0898971707,
-0.2450322807,
-1.0682301521,
0.1245717555,
0.3319098055,
-0.3638837636,
-0.4120973945,
0.9279677868,
-0.3084389567,
-0.4340345263,
-0.0394126996,
0.3774370849,
0.1246479675,
0.0160093457,
-0.1698826402,
0.2462520003,
0.2083732933,
-0.4276588261,
0.4243740737,
0.8998392224,
-0.0210565962,
0.3953873217,
0.550198257,
-0.2145520598,
-0.1194965169,
-0.0585204922,
0.814188242,
-0.3911098242,
-0.1760553122,
-1.0047057867,
0.090489924,
-0.0181612223,
-0.4477019012,
0.843244791,
0.4126095474,
0.7476193309,
-0.0109609794,
0.7503885627,
0.088541694,
0.4211278856,
-0.5464367867,
0.2167783976,
-0.3447788358,
0.6731587648,
-0.0669479668,
-0.8880301118,
-0.3280394375,
0.4444167316,
-0.4900060594,
-0.2176896334,
0.7253758907,
0.8217869401,
0.3132412434,
-0.0721443966,
0.2644564509,
-0.2955780029,
0.462526083,
0.8151364326,
0.9174035788,
0.1262933612,
0.8108398318,
-0.3845053315,
-0.1904945672,
-0.1939560175,
-0.7523610592,
-1.4008706808,
-0.5272009969,
-0.4199666977,
-0.2135059536,
-0.1758954376,
0.613209784,
0.3424043059,
-0.7303316593,
-0.1615618467,
-0.3275110722,
0.4825700819,
-0.1346469522,
-0.2510941923,
0.3009171784,
-0.5764658451,
-0.9866804481,
0.3814961016,
0.3175169528,
0.2100860476,
-0.0748455226,
0.0195794739,
0.0421137586,
0.3437284529,
0.3446938097,
0.1260943711,
-0.5275908113,
-0.5021951795,
0.2222350836,
-0.5232138038,
0.0027064665,
1.0987787247,
-0.4753302932,
0.508767724,
0.6002610922,
0.580975771,
0.1943207681,
-0.2034054101,
0.4407852888,
-1.0500012636,
0.0744883567,
0.3000420928,
0.2630185485,
0.2898589373,
-0.8083239794,
0.15780586,
0.4525040984,
-0.783377707,
-0.9300802946,
0.449960202,
-0.4626158774,
-0.5923827887,
0.9846996069,
-0.3949895203,
-0.120425269,
-0.2227375656,
-0.2338523865,
0.1808934212,
-0.4973077178,
0.6531828642,
1.0313229561,
-0.4601411223,
-0.0026065931,
-0.5758972764,
0.6293285489,
0.7675554752,
-0.6325867176,
0.1455700845,
0.6055779457,
0.1242649704,
0.0336375944,
0.2645706832,
0.4298997521,
0.3821266294,
-0.1133796796,
-0.1780159324,
-0.2363569885,
-0.5672554374,
-0.2148009539,
0.2009345293,
-0.0326023437,
-0.3813051283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08360v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08360v3
|
The Transient Nature of Emergent In-Context Learning in Transformers
| 2023-11-14T18:03:20 | 2023-12-11T21:42:31 |
Aaditya K. Singh, Stephanie C. Y. Chan, Ted Moskovitz, Erin Grant, Andrew M. Saxe, Felix Hill
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Transformer neural networks can exhibit a surprising capacity for in-context
learning (ICL) despite not being explicitly trained for it. Prior work has
provided a deeper understanding of how ICL emerges in transformers, e.g.
through the lens of mechanistic interpretability, Bayesian inference, or by
examining the distributional properties of training data. However, in each of
these cases, ICL is treated largely as a persistent phenomenon; namely, once
ICL emerges, it is assumed to persist asymptotically. Here, we show that the
emergence of ICL during transformer training is, in fact, often transient. We
train transformers on synthetic data designed so that both ICL and in-weights
learning (IWL) strategies can lead to correct predictions. We find that ICL
first emerges, then disappears and gives way to IWL, all while the training
loss decreases, indicating an asymptotic preference for IWL. The transient
nature of ICL is observed in transformers across a range of model sizes and
datasets, raising the question of how much to "overtrain" transformers when
seeking compact, cheaper-to-run models. We find that L2 regularization may
offer a path to more persistent ICL that removes the need for early stopping
based on ICL-style validation tasks. Finally, we present initial evidence that
ICL transience may be caused by competition between ICL and IWL circuits.
|
[
-0.3864875734,
-0.3538586795,
0.4217861295,
0.3481354117,
-0.1755418032,
0.586414814,
-0.2014966756,
-0.6065571308,
-0.2383829504,
-0.0307357199,
-0.725631237,
0.4665427506,
-0.6016171575,
0.0378204063,
-0.7167928815,
1.2041367292,
-0.1440103352,
-0.163657099,
-0.1795898378,
-0.2326648682,
-0.5117414594,
-0.3302418292,
-0.7639135122,
-0.9147859216,
0.4383631051,
0.3759046793,
0.4637077749,
0.1064541638,
0.1599600315,
0.0706824586,
-0.1265303791,
-0.1378950477,
-0.4114429951,
0.3883946538,
-0.0338848345,
-0.4960830808,
0.4854494929,
-0.0489861891,
0.9684747458,
0.8871952891,
-0.1990906894,
0.1271953285,
0.4594821334,
0.3842056394,
-0.4073323905,
-0.0703444928,
-1.0361908674,
0.3057563603,
-0.2746950388,
-0.2991847098,
-0.786727488,
0.153209731,
0.495668292,
-0.2339941263,
0.4491437972,
0.1263739169,
1.027944088,
0.5743556023,
-0.5365749598,
-0.221626088,
-1.4248811007,
0.6034064293,
-0.0676729381,
0.6385993958,
-0.2786751091,
0.5063787103,
-0.013595731,
-1.2698141336,
-0.4559803009,
-0.5840902925,
-0.3809912205,
0.3027462363,
-0.1609755754,
-0.2374999076,
0.6628243923,
0.0549087785,
-0.121146597,
0.327565223,
-0.4379338324,
0.0731968358,
0.1356752217,
0.1184770688,
0.1281870902,
0.2662385404,
-0.9369145632,
0.0854349062,
-0.746964395,
0.5600666404,
0.1368238181,
0.218931511,
-0.2060880661,
0.1572687477,
0.3587444425,
0.1914080232,
0.4921117127,
0.0864338577,
-0.1044726893,
0.1193468943,
0.102625981,
0.5816944242,
0.4915564656,
-0.1601932198,
0.1711388677,
-0.6221095324,
-0.4134149849,
-0.2058870047,
0.6272155046,
-0.6056504846,
-0.0691392943,
0.1491184682,
-0.3851309717,
-0.1531252116,
0.4526387155,
-0.2920410931,
0.0109130712,
-0.3593460619,
0.6631022096,
-0.2338898033,
-0.252779305,
-0.1834394932,
-0.236534968,
0.3963043988,
-0.0377554297,
-1.0323355198,
0.3578276336,
0.2978955507,
1.0048662424,
-0.405159235,
-0.463334024,
-0.2988228798,
0.2137952745,
-0.2825865448,
0.7192245722,
-0.1971501112,
-0.5326729417,
-0.0601669028,
0.2271053642,
-0.1222746596,
-0.7730517983,
0.1759583801,
-0.7776035666,
-0.0761598945,
-0.1206631884,
-0.1354637146,
0.3345504999,
0.0195592344,
-0.5750125051,
1.4165363312,
0.3197375536,
-0.7279077172,
0.9600766301,
-0.6505047679,
-0.720631361,
0.2108339518,
-0.1623101532,
-0.6422525048,
0.4609818757,
-0.3661263287,
0.297817409,
-0.2411741614,
0.3262292743,
-0.0203702785,
-0.7363530397,
0.4521849453,
-0.678755939,
0.6310382485,
0.0395498089,
-0.796685636,
-0.1650366485,
-0.5445331335,
-0.2906406522,
0.0480414405,
-0.3501885235,
-0.170130834,
0.311676681,
0.1150292531,
0.4651454389,
-0.1131124943,
-0.6308720708,
0.2237647027,
-0.5451208949,
0.5481592417,
0.895398736,
0.2157061696,
0.3576346934,
-0.1671524048,
0.2690443099,
0.4394748807,
0.4085359871,
-0.095866479,
-0.2532218397,
-0.8886841536,
0.1712841094,
0.0380257368,
0.1765988767,
-0.8341950178,
-0.0311398041,
-0.4273221791,
-0.3821182251,
-0.2497031838,
-0.3927535117,
-0.0088939359,
0.7954083085,
0.7505769134,
0.11599572,
-0.3119075596,
-1.0050280094,
-0.2328413874,
0.1984028816,
-0.3281098306,
0.258323133,
0.5418248773,
-0.2673855424,
1.3108417988,
-0.1774305403,
-0.1086315587,
-0.3683071733,
0.2392064035,
0.2802965641,
0.5929941535,
0.627889812,
-0.9083364606,
-0.7665471435,
0.0231786929,
-0.6632018089,
0.0993229076,
-0.747290194,
0.2640051544,
-0.0256337244,
0.7993049026,
-0.4739566445,
0.4752504528,
0.0172188655,
-0.0814735293,
0.3321197629,
-0.1872297525,
-0.3961029649,
-0.8882338405,
0.107350342,
0.0915802196,
0.0097574377,
-0.5271165371,
-0.1418027133,
0.2209788859,
0.0243776515,
-0.4799756706,
0.6110182405,
-0.2645159364,
-0.181397438,
-0.1410083175,
-0.096674189,
-0.1545583755,
0.4141961336,
-0.0052709952,
0.9257218242,
0.4831651151,
-0.7030057311,
-0.0757007003,
0.0972457528,
-0.2728670835,
0.186560601,
-0.8247467875,
0.0567474365,
-0.4158539176,
0.5619637966,
-0.8516361713,
-0.0942556188,
0.2760920823,
-0.0121460082,
0.8437751532,
-0.2619083822,
-0.5089585781,
-0.4929172397,
0.1642175615,
0.6125041246,
0.6419578791,
-1.0821865797,
0.6570080519,
-0.1799643487,
0.5750451088,
-0.5276573896,
-0.81436342,
-0.0024752165,
-0.3204766512,
-0.1446580142,
0.7112352252,
-0.0156795122,
-0.1852672249,
-0.0607458502,
-0.3321827948,
0.0631949008,
0.3358525336,
0.2378459722,
0.0753662661,
0.0034848016,
0.3318771422,
0.1659628302,
-0.4876269698,
0.2258765548,
-0.5718974471,
0.6129817367,
0.0015668907,
-0.3596662581,
-0.403414458,
0.1254925132,
0.5491328239,
-0.0383408219,
0.9145789146,
0.6088978648,
-0.3005850911,
-0.4632794857,
-0.3448566794,
-0.4617927969,
-0.4847789109,
0.0970193222,
-0.3715081513,
-0.2842465937,
0.4147940576,
-0.3505043983,
0.0866066366,
0.7375916839,
0.3492846191,
-0.3826699257,
0.9040575027,
0.588198781,
0.200195685,
0.6367883682,
-0.6791036725,
0.1006500497,
-0.8890538216,
-0.6462902427,
-0.2740315199,
-0.7755314112,
-0.5360135436,
0.2895211577,
0.826297462,
-0.2163579613,
-0.4292904735,
0.079175204,
-0.449778378,
0.5676563978,
0.3512834013,
0.342029959,
-0.0157128889,
0.0540215112,
-0.0587195121,
-0.2310190201,
-0.8117015362,
0.141626671,
0.7197703123,
0.3366602063,
0.7158412337,
-0.0749702975,
0.3355575502,
0.2583702803,
0.6050985456,
-0.888228178,
-0.0174102895,
0.0472013764,
-0.4106582105,
-0.0599982329,
-0.2123404592,
-1.1364239454,
-0.1932489276,
-0.149335593,
-0.7411540747,
0.2320123315,
0.1693834066,
-0.4548553228,
0.4539003074,
-0.3478277326,
0.4764812291,
-0.2747987509,
-0.4852462411,
-0.1349247247,
-1.1375690699,
0.2029002905,
-0.1502428949,
-0.3451883197,
0.3198494017,
0.0822122023,
0.2395154983,
-0.2927633822,
0.6022968888,
-0.2233662605,
0.0902730897,
0.4073289037,
0.0772892237,
0.558087647,
0.3329595625,
0.2894940376,
0.1194079146,
-0.3472144306,
-0.3113167584,
-0.7326581478,
0.419171989,
-0.7195196748,
-0.3189891279,
-0.5352681875,
-0.3184228539,
-0.2707312107,
-0.0894398317,
0.9035640359,
0.8594878912,
0.4054996371,
0.5168704391,
1.0453654528,
-0.0902135447,
0.9017824531,
0.1603194326,
0.212413609,
0.2293643057,
0.7610245347,
0.5075802803,
0.6473782063,
0.2903797626,
0.2582326531,
-0.1722606122,
-0.2218805701,
-0.4082614779,
-0.0944368318,
-0.6350525022,
-0.0864133984,
-0.6045643687,
-0.6647538543,
0.4441631436,
-0.4012677073,
-0.2947611511,
-0.0593106262,
-0.3405746818,
0.106284596,
0.0326723233,
0.7709358335,
0.1727491319,
0.5685657263,
-0.663415432,
-0.009488238,
0.2695844471,
0.4558069706,
0.5224224925,
-0.8728705645,
-0.5124957561,
-0.0621662028,
-0.4886947274,
-0.3929271102,
0.0210121442,
0.3675543964,
0.5497285128,
0.6130717993,
-0.2394737601,
0.5459650755,
-0.6974329352,
0.9193400741,
0.0836811438,
-0.6639741063,
0.2886538208,
-0.1277751476,
0.4676567614,
0.2783154547,
0.6987966299,
-0.5145618916,
-0.1864050329,
-0.9316799045,
-0.8767677546,
0.6804692149,
-0.0127303237,
0.5202896595,
-0.0039631417,
0.7786288857,
0.3364911377,
0.1698175371,
-0.9097593427,
-0.3863240778,
-0.2879475653,
0.0385829322,
0.2196511179,
-0.27292189,
0.0694859177,
-0.3400319815,
0.3427126408,
-0.246100232,
0.2764782608,
0.193458125,
-0.2209347934,
-0.1735689938,
-0.2294708639,
0.5103468299,
0.4682843685,
-0.0442349501,
0.044239454,
0.3268195093,
-0.3748950064,
0.3803686798,
-0.3126710951,
-0.4056435823,
-0.0980722606,
0.5056054592,
0.6313929558,
0.7979893088,
-0.5158523917,
0.4963163435,
-0.2014157176,
0.1206169501,
-0.7253226638,
-0.0597848222,
-0.3679300547,
0.3706071973,
0.8481004238,
0.6666867137,
0.0172298215,
-0.640330255,
0.3226081431,
0.4579560459,
-0.7680857182,
-0.507357657,
1.0743929148,
-0.3546593487,
-0.238745153,
1.0783265829,
-0.0450543426,
-0.5644150376,
0.6326252222,
0.7865083218,
1.1139059067,
-0.0604769886,
-0.1064586788,
0.3726267517,
0.2711802423,
-0.0786934197,
-0.1633874625,
-0.1987553537,
-0.6392107606,
-0.1228284612,
-0.485232085,
-0.0156980697,
-0.0434831865,
-0.6533249021,
0.4694836736,
-0.6522210836,
-0.0585847944,
-0.3645111918,
-0.3819993436,
-0.8895397186,
0.1243482456,
-0.0350990221,
0.8289899826,
-0.6856692433,
0.8215306401,
0.1457145065,
-0.3483825028,
-0.7259262204,
0.7236163616,
-0.421469003,
-0.506041646,
1.1311196089,
0.5066341758,
0.0083619813,
0.2670035362,
-0.6339845061,
-0.9915627837,
1.2451909781,
0.1835790575,
-0.3538912535,
-0.3375505507,
0.1561773717,
0.570567131,
-0.1933460683,
0.2699959576,
0.4858174026,
0.2132582068,
0.1938312799,
-0.5916514397,
-0.198464483,
0.1432608515,
-0.0775778815,
0.4559438825,
-1.0609482527,
0.9419204593,
-0.2378032207,
-0.4940674305,
-0.207656458,
0.5343843102,
-0.1992162764,
0.2053705752,
0.6989358068,
0.2335682362,
0.2400207818,
-0.3856502473,
1.1040328741,
-0.3725041449,
0.3633725047,
0.9371632338,
-0.16051808,
0.442915678,
0.5995700955,
-0.1713290364,
0.670730114,
0.8136303425,
-0.2269788235,
0.4578466117,
0.0081713498,
-0.247808665,
-0.150681138,
-0.2821616232,
-0.1743040085,
0.5395097136,
0.3858180344,
-0.2653904259,
-0.1571822613,
0.3162921369,
-0.3102399409,
-0.265173316,
-0.1179880127,
0.5556851625,
0.1006802469,
-0.4620496035,
0.2785188854,
-0.4978907406,
0.4517911971,
-0.7630204558,
0.0959467441,
-0.2688708901,
-0.1037249044,
-0.1387169212,
-0.6116823554,
0.4560462534,
-0.5756117702,
-0.359813273,
-0.4593856037,
0.5040897727,
-0.2096129507,
-0.2745254934,
0.4537589252,
0.2315936089,
-0.3453363478,
0.1692674607,
-0.3886313736,
-0.3160434663,
-0.4196570814,
-0.3167137206,
0.5498360395,
0.290971607,
-0.1004436761,
0.9308492541,
0.3673519194,
-0.0855735987,
0.0751457065,
0.0349114165,
0.9239125252,
-0.1763121486,
-0.3737971485,
-0.9920393229,
0.7438652515,
-0.0196587071,
-0.4057694077,
0.4276641607,
0.5108034611,
0.9159150124,
-0.0921906456,
0.5613626838,
-0.0748106241,
0.0731561854,
-0.6762180924,
0.6816650629,
-0.7447013855,
0.1718457341,
0.1486763805,
-0.9693086743,
-0.0371354073,
0.0281861741,
0.0560046434,
0.010264473,
0.7554132342,
0.2983483672,
-0.4194265604,
-0.1799366474,
0.165546447,
0.1969403923,
0.3770878017,
0.3221222162,
1.0428634882,
-0.3796293736,
0.3757078946,
-0.1955980808,
0.0459107161,
-0.1998308152,
-0.6204593778,
-0.5246126056,
-0.8929926157,
-0.0298026279,
-0.4793982506,
-0.424847424,
1.2140028477,
0.5124185681,
-0.5818530321,
-0.0615950115,
-0.1694599688,
-0.0929908752,
-0.4812588096,
-0.3051142991,
0.1281024814,
-0.6315543652,
-0.4266870916,
0.5527154207,
0.3542763293,
0.3751465082,
-0.3774086833,
0.2157712877,
-0.0189124104,
-0.0688874349,
0.6247071028,
0.409227103,
-0.521874845,
-0.5784033537,
-0.1185140163,
0.0753737986,
0.3095794916,
1.1335029602,
-1.2445824146,
0.4127733707,
-0.0815009847,
0.6789541841,
0.6522856355,
-0.2585380673,
0.4112287462,
-1.1885017157,
0.5507268906,
0.2650257647,
0.3809556067,
0.0010698389,
-0.6129297018,
0.4458130002,
0.5174561143,
-0.5759555697,
-1.0542877913,
0.414129585,
-0.4075022042,
-0.2931749523,
0.7579277158,
0.2021607608,
0.2825155556,
-0.0607092604,
0.013066031,
0.2817575336,
0.0123254508,
1.1537899971,
0.4091049731,
-0.3928659558,
0.0629304871,
-0.6832792163,
0.8393135071,
0.071212098,
-0.3952164352,
-0.2879174352,
-0.272814095,
0.2368107289,
0.1966752261,
-0.0419224612,
0.4451944232,
0.1402499378,
-0.0133067397,
-0.5632064939,
0.3138633668,
-0.8755078316,
-0.2569956481,
0.1980797946,
-0.0057420987,
0.1861321032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08349v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08349v2
|
AI-generated text boundary detection with RoFT
| 2023-11-14T17:48:19 | 2024-04-02T18:28:04 |
Laida Kushnareva, Tatiana Gaintseva, German Magai, Serguei Barannikov, Dmitry Abulkhanov, Kristian Kuznetsov, Eduard Tulchinskii, Irina Piontkovskaya, Sergey Nikolenko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Due to the rapid development of large language models, people increasingly
often encounter texts that may start as written by a human but continue as
machine-generated. Detecting the boundary between human-written and
machine-generated parts of such texts is a challenging problem that has not
received much attention in literature. We attempt to bridge this gap and
examine several ways to adapt state of the art artificial text detection
classifiers to the boundary detection setting. We push all detectors to their
limits, using the Real or Fake text benchmark that contains short texts on
several topics and includes generations of various language models. We use this
diversity to deeply examine the robustness of all detectors in cross-domain and
cross-model settings to provide baselines and insights for future research. In
particular, we find that perplexity-based approaches to boundary detection tend
to be more robust to peculiarities of domain-specific data than supervised
fine-tuning of the RoBERTa model; we also find which features of the text
confuse boundary detection algorithms and negatively influence their
performance in cross-domain settings.
|
[
-0.6523678899,
-1.00694561,
0.5812206268,
-0.2073632181,
-0.0098025948,
0.1509288996,
-0.0510655567,
-0.8632850051,
-0.2071481794,
0.7837362289,
-0.7079071999,
-0.519865334,
-0.5820861459,
0.2467682064,
-0.4119493961,
1.0406268835,
-0.2738459408,
-0.6626836658,
-0.3184445202,
-0.1538019478,
-0.3421033025,
-0.6990680695,
-0.3045242727,
-0.5404989719,
0.2561516464,
0.2078413069,
0.7513933778,
0.7817976475,
0.4445843697,
0.2158571333,
-0.0127194906,
0.3508887291,
-0.1021555811,
0.2730179131,
-0.2113514096,
-0.4685215056,
-0.3838367164,
0.0363650396,
0.8996267319,
0.3976173103,
0.3740552664,
-0.0313442722,
-0.0907455832,
0.6106320024,
-0.5088717937,
-0.4491064847,
-0.6624869108,
0.2257401794,
-0.6010534167,
-0.1191459224,
-0.4959206581,
0.0726543739,
0.1442455053,
-0.2740731835,
0.4694669247,
0.2562472224,
1.1228688955,
0.270057708,
-0.4883936644,
-0.3107091188,
-0.9442073107,
0.8599908948,
-0.4205869138,
0.6606374383,
0.4675544202,
0.289485991,
-0.2424551398,
-0.7663347721,
-0.9500699043,
-0.0428617001,
-0.0297627822,
0.0819280297,
-0.6231598854,
-0.3172146082,
0.2815806866,
0.0971840099,
-0.8075821996,
0.1033330709,
-0.1049283147,
-0.4004427791,
0.7871112227,
0.3211535215,
0.4681290984,
0.0403038375,
-0.5206907392,
-0.2849815786,
-0.6042073369,
-0.0173946451,
0.8790814281,
0.219183594,
-0.1557409763,
0.2106232047,
0.0067926273,
0.7464763522,
-0.2695851326,
0.0719145685,
-0.0289684311,
-0.1663930267,
0.0438058786,
-0.4199159443,
1.0457266569,
0.1574871838,
0.3252184987,
0.0775946379,
-0.4546632469,
0.0620608144,
0.2981271148,
-0.3170467317,
-0.2315601557,
0.0343474261,
-0.4884476364,
-0.1734428853,
0.0317545123,
-0.5365519524,
-0.4022431672,
-0.1713602394,
0.10035602,
-0.4756352603,
-0.2369100302,
0.0869941562,
-0.0858025029,
0.1141537949,
0.248513326,
-0.6577782035,
0.3043540418,
0.5378185511,
0.6520107985,
-0.3510183394,
-0.6133676171,
-0.4667709172,
-0.2041460276,
-0.2071816772,
1.3778166771,
-0.5596510768,
-0.3568671644,
-0.043731004,
-0.2409124225,
0.0658437088,
-0.8180925846,
0.9324352145,
-0.4665616453,
0.4054641426,
0.0038543751,
-0.4705588222,
0.0957383662,
0.2928961217,
-0.6630566716,
1.0905001163,
0.1009785831,
-0.8121367097,
0.3077619672,
-0.5828441381,
-0.668356359,
-0.0330265835,
-0.1556898504,
-0.8258159757,
-0.0874827653,
0.206469968,
0.3033775687,
-0.3312986195,
0.197558552,
-0.0180430654,
-0.2420834452,
0.4917815924,
-0.5511640906,
0.6992103457,
0.1679719239,
-0.2467245609,
0.2635499537,
-0.6459320188,
-0.0851025656,
0.1366577446,
-0.1707013547,
-0.3431386054,
-0.0073004598,
0.5364226103,
0.0564088933,
-0.0037951211,
-0.368429929,
-0.0622663386,
-0.1559705138,
0.4271054864,
0.5610494018,
-0.044332616,
0.3566944897,
-0.5553230643,
0.7821446657,
0.0564706996,
-0.0251716468,
-0.2079092711,
-0.7158461213,
-0.4082703888,
-0.2107201368,
0.6198297143,
0.659592092,
-0.7912091613,
0.7076293826,
0.1256065667,
-0.3792753518,
-0.5368046761,
0.0194901694,
0.4351589382,
0.4155339003,
0.3510752916,
-0.4555090964,
-0.4473448396,
-1.0122425556,
-0.7562071085,
-0.0733081996,
-0.0951272249,
0.367732048,
0.7031425238,
-0.5471726656,
1.2572245598,
-0.6609019041,
-0.3791704178,
-0.1104165241,
0.3775557578,
-0.2859436572,
0.5928234458,
0.6392869949,
-1.1151175499,
-0.8735385537,
-0.0388573408,
-0.6967003345,
-0.4216889143,
-0.3504198492,
-0.1381093413,
0.3397449255,
0.6082513928,
-0.3092076778,
0.7148529887,
0.3409242928,
-0.3201267123,
0.6776546836,
-0.1139397845,
-0.0757116005,
-0.591563344,
-0.017239254,
0.3949059248,
-0.4169247448,
-0.9534931183,
0.1567222923,
0.1391057968,
0.078227438,
-0.2347824126,
0.7774041891,
-0.3835686147,
0.1224734858,
-0.6461712122,
0.1689337939,
0.1125715151,
0.1881736964,
0.2935730815,
0.7247214317,
0.1491364688,
-0.2472955585,
0.0538178906,
0.2873744667,
-0.0315959454,
0.8196394444,
-0.4354694188,
0.3165381253,
0.0042020162,
0.6189447045,
-0.8964298964,
-0.1379268318,
0.2777552307,
-0.7133662701,
-0.0165049098,
-0.1301407218,
-0.6165912151,
-0.1352985203,
-0.316518575,
0.5547639728,
0.6360067129,
-0.4544035196,
0.7857119441,
0.4485151768,
0.0852734149,
-0.2753303349,
-0.7138196826,
0.3097494841,
-0.1639013141,
-0.7199466228,
0.4557117522,
-0.0530718379,
-0.288589716,
-0.0014595824,
-0.0159893055,
-0.256605655,
0.2092971504,
0.247474879,
0.1008010134,
-0.2936127186,
-0.2335739881,
0.3865613341,
-0.1639670134,
0.0888011754,
-0.2899167538,
0.5520861745,
-0.0246326569,
-0.122100465,
-0.6121639609,
0.6037852168,
0.4343099594,
-0.4338724911,
0.5893496871,
0.8133220673,
-0.8167111278,
-0.6005920172,
-0.3670373261,
-0.2203452289,
-0.4762895107,
-0.0329222456,
-0.6889795065,
-0.919341445,
0.8162315488,
0.0348643996,
-0.1614385694,
0.6303406954,
0.4753941298,
-0.1475629508,
0.6175789833,
1.0959508419,
0.0917793587,
0.4267152846,
0.0324289538,
0.3519349694,
-0.8909848332,
0.0954755917,
-0.6664280891,
-0.0800606534,
-0.5399857759,
-0.2978598177,
0.2507199347,
-0.0092590554,
0.1231038123,
0.5453566313,
-0.6855090857,
0.688267231,
0.7034500837,
0.056220863,
0.3638308346,
-0.0571002476,
0.028126251,
-0.2174068242,
-0.5828751326,
-0.7609478235,
0.9887185693,
0.4771386087,
0.5152417421,
-0.1833902448,
0.7310038209,
0.7587850094,
0.3721726239,
-0.4288859069,
0.3957447708,
-0.1674188524,
-0.7198141217,
-0.1635494977,
-0.3663881123,
-0.9127969146,
0.1957951188,
-0.503826201,
-0.8029727936,
0.1680860221,
-0.0057645515,
-0.3475727439,
0.4313575327,
-0.5806748271,
0.8247589469,
-0.0654768944,
-0.4375762045,
0.2465809286,
-0.7999445796,
0.2944536209,
-0.2990843058,
0.1026761308,
-0.0052360818,
0.0256431196,
0.7608754635,
-0.2007629275,
0.9109483957,
0.0766136199,
-0.5097783208,
0.6337634921,
0.0992518663,
0.3705047369,
-0.2034816295,
0.1062433049,
0.3180810809,
-0.2610480189,
-0.4276816845,
-0.1974027753,
0.4359494746,
-0.7307392359,
-0.3834106326,
-0.5410092473,
-0.7515322566,
-0.2404185534,
0.4648626745,
0.5328553915,
0.1088942587,
-0.1636593491,
-0.3631822765,
0.7014035583,
-0.3045497537,
0.1946737319,
0.2258519232,
-0.1955068558,
-0.269230783,
0.9707583189,
-0.0565037355,
0.1111400276,
0.3524848521,
0.1207602918,
-0.3040252924,
-0.6553047299,
-0.6698085666,
0.1250702292,
-0.6022282243,
-0.0519190729,
-0.697589159,
-0.4439649284,
-0.4443883896,
-0.4169650674,
-0.2410217077,
-0.1069712564,
-0.4017853439,
0.3661784828,
0.1278090477,
0.7834355831,
0.0145059433,
0.3686063886,
-0.8823875785,
0.3876984119,
-0.0442268327,
0.2981449366,
-0.0724498332,
-0.6139244437,
-0.094935067,
-0.1838493794,
-0.4025299549,
-0.4931521118,
0.3260982335,
-0.0784534588,
0.3963651955,
0.0766062215,
0.3703593314,
0.1504563838,
-0.5594147444,
0.6437318325,
-0.0534430705,
-1.1616631746,
0.3823024631,
-0.5057654977,
0.2892280221,
0.2177788615,
0.4523542821,
-0.5352224708,
-0.5051269531,
-0.6179113388,
-0.8059678078,
0.4833436608,
0.49452582,
-0.0118155433,
0.5127253532,
0.4970291257,
0.4447031915,
-0.0584555827,
-0.6958050728,
-0.0897751749,
-0.0042919535,
-0.408459872,
0.2268904299,
0.0254269522,
-0.1583595127,
0.1585857272,
0.3799453378,
-0.2827516496,
0.3292535245,
0.2535136044,
-0.1349554956,
-0.2187175453,
0.0621291958,
0.9691222906,
0.474717319,
-0.0184453204,
0.1599159241,
0.0548220687,
-0.6092892289,
0.1019362211,
0.2500899434,
-0.3439293802,
-0.0320573449,
0.8376520872,
0.7327253819,
-0.7214797139,
-0.8962275386,
0.2168495208,
-0.1888779551,
-0.3989188969,
-0.1264428496,
0.154479146,
-0.1963900328,
0.4208670855,
0.5417846441,
0.2070809901,
0.1089996472,
-0.6109532714,
0.5314719677,
0.4465679228,
-0.3685017824,
-0.4667536616,
0.8541563153,
0.1972762793,
-0.7496019006,
0.3670560122,
-0.1118373945,
-1.1360632181,
0.6595928669,
0.5440183878,
0.9578451514,
0.1727630645,
-0.0010282723,
-0.2201407701,
0.6241450906,
0.1667847037,
0.1155762598,
-0.1139526889,
-1.0135012865,
-0.075648956,
-0.4058833718,
-0.7697225213,
0.2035851926,
-0.5022747517,
0.101862669,
-0.5476572514,
-0.3913273215,
0.2705001831,
0.0314725377,
-0.3209107816,
0.3872167766,
0.3462030292,
0.8353278637,
-1.0482009649,
0.8434816003,
0.8392184973,
-0.0323002785,
-0.0784735531,
0.6261214614,
0.0448117331,
-0.5045770407,
0.2591072619,
0.1041733921,
-0.3753113151,
-0.135785386,
-0.5660529733,
-0.314594239,
0.6039605737,
0.0229226928,
-0.3415124714,
0.2674355209,
0.3112236857,
0.7642567754,
-0.2879379988,
0.0219364166,
0.6720235944,
0.5267669559,
-0.4449411035,
-0.8297190666,
0.1237524524,
-0.1722799093,
-0.0968306959,
0.3851239383,
-0.7328713536,
0.9580340385,
0.2300266027,
-0.2570799887,
0.1666136831,
0.7974073291,
0.23552531,
0.7288836241,
0.592453897,
0.5013471842,
0.6037506461,
-0.2147158384,
0.8672078252,
-0.0143773071,
0.2320583463,
0.865475595,
-0.7061112523,
0.6371107101,
0.3030632734,
-0.2346295714,
0.5725105405,
0.5918575525,
-0.0974777564,
0.1896287054,
0.210812062,
-0.2848175168,
-0.2926802337,
-0.1568118185,
-0.1867418587,
0.2341538519,
0.3025914133,
0.0392402075,
-0.0990637988,
0.2841566503,
-0.1462982595,
0.701698184,
0.1767028123,
0.5287961364,
0.0493946783,
-0.5402818322,
0.5556281805,
0.4722653627,
0.993584156,
-0.2356480956,
0.0348713286,
-0.3269904852,
0.317122668,
-0.2334440798,
-1.0277346373,
0.3569177389,
0.3064132631,
-0.3966633976,
-0.3140184283,
1.1870158911,
-0.4666056931,
-0.1798338741,
0.1903830171,
0.5765876174,
0.0356080532,
-0.0647253543,
-0.6958582401,
0.3895462453,
0.0201881286,
-0.1783403009,
0.3503364027,
0.6171275973,
-0.4923690856,
0.5848435163,
0.7310937643,
-0.2014357597,
-0.022325296,
-0.3837213218,
0.7482682467,
-0.8806182146,
-0.5350862145,
-0.853502214,
0.4830413461,
-0.0092107179,
-0.6063542962,
0.590749383,
0.5226736665,
0.9516105652,
0.0084914286,
1.0875531435,
0.1220423132,
0.4669596255,
-0.4907019734,
0.9920315146,
-0.5480356812,
0.172225818,
-0.1943812668,
-0.777997613,
-0.6877647638,
0.6604169607,
-0.2440606058,
-0.0831828117,
0.7061106563,
0.4082977772,
-0.193954885,
0.1127558202,
0.2394302636,
-0.2455760241,
0.4802361131,
0.4411332011,
1.0099672079,
-0.670178175,
0.4302193522,
-0.1410673708,
-0.2386357635,
-0.2031644881,
-0.9193595648,
-1.1932781935,
-0.7932838798,
-0.4677191973,
-0.4277797937,
-0.0407987833,
0.4639875293,
0.6406567693,
-0.7890093327,
-0.2704081237,
0.054234758,
0.3493379653,
-0.023490876,
-0.2591291368,
0.3660781085,
0.1029715985,
-0.7847709656,
0.3156083524,
0.2291780859,
0.4136334956,
-0.2969577909,
0.0491052195,
-0.2144109756,
0.4514262378,
0.4270963371,
0.425720185,
-0.4912478626,
-0.3265192807,
-0.1158652604,
-0.2865829468,
0.0495800078,
0.8856722713,
-0.7762074471,
0.114869304,
0.4799582362,
0.8079583645,
0.3851204216,
0.045271378,
0.5498250723,
-0.7664290667,
0.143303901,
0.4051814079,
0.0358553417,
0.3467090428,
-0.4539921284,
0.4531318843,
0.5357844234,
-0.4792804718,
-1.3315633535,
0.4803432822,
-0.7024037838,
-0.5083152652,
0.7257562876,
-0.055570256,
-0.2984925807,
-0.1611518562,
-0.1760975271,
0.0298720095,
-0.2832479775,
0.5521393418,
0.7290562391,
-0.3134665489,
-0.0970471576,
-0.4003395438,
0.436193496,
0.4361616373,
-0.9010861516,
0.1260500103,
0.2914324999,
0.1347436607,
0.3632713854,
0.6085031033,
0.2556712031,
0.2371663004,
0.2485210299,
0.0925109312,
0.1502036601,
-0.6121833324,
-0.2766607702,
0.1332520396,
-0.2112627625,
0.0814301297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08348v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08348v2
|
MC$^2$: Towards Transparent and Culturally-Aware NLP for Minority Languages in China
| 2023-11-14T17:45:50 | 2024-06-13T04:36:11 |
Chen Zhang, Mingxu Tao, Quzhe Huang, Jiuheng Lin, Zhibin Chen, Yansong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current large language models demonstrate deficiencies in understanding
low-resource languages, particularly the minority languages in China. This
limitation stems from the scarcity of available pre-training data. To address
this accessibility challenge, we present MC$^2$, a Multilingual Corpus of
Minority Languages in China, which is the largest open-source corpus of its
kind so far. MC$^2$ includes four underrepresented languages: Tibetan, Uyghur,
Kazakh, and Mongolian. Notably, we focus on the less common writing systems of
Kazakh and Mongolian, i.e., Kazakh Arabic script and traditional Mongolian
script, respectively, which have been long neglected in previous corpus
construction efforts. Recognizing the prevalence of language contamination
within existing corpora, we adopt a quality-centric solution for collecting
MC$^2$, prioritizing accuracy while enhancing diversity. Furthermore, we
underscore the importance of attending to the multiplicity of writing systems,
which is closely related to the cultural awareness of the resulting models. The
MC$^2$ corpus and related models are made public to the community.
|
[
-0.0969686583,
0.0025370568,
0.129192397,
0.4709476531,
0.0463691689,
0.3445097208,
-0.5614322424,
-0.6095864177,
0.1654748619,
0.449000597,
-0.2009818703,
-0.5705220103,
-0.6016462445,
0.0664471388,
0.0084606642,
0.9907757044,
0.0917470977,
0.1270352453,
0.285181284,
-0.2231687456,
-0.0032868632,
-0.4103192389,
-0.5399549603,
0.0320053697,
0.5747847557,
0.7978493571,
0.7400455475,
0.9223028421,
0.5246534348,
0.1163201779,
0.0856017619,
0.2248569131,
-0.3751651049,
-0.5215278864,
-0.1725415587,
-0.4221692383,
-0.669372797,
-0.0114106303,
0.753616035,
0.9210042953,
-0.2506906688,
0.3488963842,
0.1207905188,
0.6283578277,
-1.0272936821,
-0.0295326151,
-0.8721355796,
0.2670427561,
-0.5730692744,
0.3810642362,
-0.3071304262,
-0.0850955918,
-0.2818281651,
-0.683513701,
0.1802209467,
-0.1639929414,
0.3487077355,
-0.0322783999,
-0.5088477731,
-0.2890449762,
-0.4690944254,
1.0691137314,
-0.6370916367,
0.5244429111,
0.84383744,
0.2839414775,
0.1560736299,
-0.7578681707,
-0.7335099578,
-0.0938557759,
-0.2652169764,
0.2945559621,
0.0795168653,
-0.1914893687,
0.0971459076,
0.3447979093,
-0.6268451214,
0.3243244886,
-0.4752487242,
-0.4190410078,
0.5543369651,
-0.0689354539,
0.5454847217,
-0.2194201499,
-0.1348578036,
0.2821139693,
-0.5795245767,
0.0823126957,
0.4855909944,
0.5470145345,
-0.2538582087,
0.5767033696,
-0.1150731221,
0.4787174761,
-0.4180097282,
-0.2708432674,
0.2378091961,
-0.5902848244,
-0.0363649502,
0.0016991771,
0.8141381741,
0.2617045045,
0.2097267956,
0.064095214,
0.000415314,
0.008968303,
-0.0917596743,
-0.7191254497,
-0.4816220105,
0.3187676668,
-0.4991286397,
0.0402682386,
0.2359247059,
-0.8255254626,
-0.5085771084,
-0.0125248842,
-0.352162987,
-0.1398762316,
-0.9312602282,
-0.0992498621,
0.0026385526,
-0.1786501557,
0.16870372,
-1.5067389011,
0.1237573028,
0.8711467981,
0.9204531908,
-0.1195569262,
-0.4359086454,
-0.4779963195,
0.4263316691,
-0.3306854367,
0.4436484277,
-0.3625062108,
-0.3677494526,
-0.0046372581,
0.019209763,
0.1552374959,
-0.6621898413,
0.8914955854,
-0.0244382806,
0.0104902629,
-0.3003955781,
0.0559344701,
0.0568345375,
0.2907435894,
-0.6384190321,
0.8725406528,
0.4479645491,
-0.9310241342,
0.2825806737,
-0.7122645974,
-0.2712078393,
0.0975592807,
-0.1941100806,
-0.1549340338,
-0.2261063308,
0.1263504326,
0.227911815,
0.1050346345,
0.2242304385,
-0.2880386114,
-0.3574367464,
-0.0811670572,
-0.2812678814,
1.1273723841,
0.459644109,
-0.2539463341,
-0.0585229285,
-0.8198730946,
0.0614862256,
-0.0578404963,
-0.5101151466,
-0.2731799781,
-0.0244029723,
0.2477499247,
0.4350585341,
0.2305939943,
-0.716676414,
-0.0102545144,
-0.3434202969,
0.2035534978,
0.5522853732,
-0.7621691227,
0.5817304254,
0.1129941195,
0.345697403,
0.3104783297,
0.1602313071,
-0.2624517083,
-0.5395516753,
-0.7554654479,
-0.3238336146,
0.3007334173,
0.6400092244,
-0.7300430536,
0.0686633214,
-0.0382327884,
-0.4554012418,
-0.8555844426,
0.3329772353,
0.4335369766,
0.4824851155,
0.401764214,
-0.0821831003,
-0.6364728212,
-0.9035669565,
-0.0471427962,
-0.4741279781,
-0.3890126348,
0.2427150756,
0.3288729787,
-0.2522706091,
0.4655896723,
-0.2874875665,
-0.3507018387,
-0.3026704192,
-0.195771262,
0.1414680183,
0.768134892,
0.4374957383,
-0.8289579153,
-0.6507793665,
0.4122256935,
-0.6642395854,
-0.1297426969,
0.1090225503,
-0.3697518408,
0.5145227313,
0.5227608085,
-0.0446117967,
0.0923751816,
1.1900875568,
-0.2822850645,
0.6006217003,
0.0572910793,
0.0572065786,
-1.0449873209,
0.3043316901,
-0.2944447994,
0.031118257,
-0.6134986281,
0.1062795371,
0.3288202882,
-0.0622434579,
-0.6507951021,
0.4335767329,
-0.5663895011,
-0.1159831956,
-0.355840683,
0.4250615835,
-0.1977470666,
0.5731187463,
0.323735714,
0.442792505,
0.1582762599,
-0.4652234614,
0.0093439138,
0.051846128,
-0.2949921787,
0.2780696452,
-0.3598051667,
0.0076093995,
0.0570882931,
0.1437167823,
-0.5360735655,
-0.1239432544,
0.4709741473,
-0.6083656549,
0.2762876153,
-0.2459783852,
-0.3663754165,
-0.2325198054,
-0.2545200586,
0.6940576434,
0.1047395691,
-0.4409551919,
0.0972095579,
0.7074843049,
-0.2068799734,
-1.1441087723,
-1.1630386114,
0.0999707878,
0.3346650898,
-0.6856251955,
0.0490052663,
-0.0917085782,
-0.2609879375,
-0.2406722158,
0.2255603373,
-0.2819887996,
0.3493561447,
0.0571415536,
0.1260275841,
-0.4213546515,
0.0591862462,
0.20999071,
-0.1872441471,
-0.1919703931,
-0.6097900271,
0.5051159859,
-0.1415090114,
-0.5747002959,
-0.2733941674,
0.6291620731,
0.0570158213,
-0.3968593776,
0.7484171391,
1.0704547167,
-0.5796810389,
-0.1425054967,
-0.0759114325,
0.1010245085,
-0.4299601912,
0.6009660959,
-0.2375951707,
-1.2017630339,
0.4053349197,
0.230149284,
0.2190572172,
0.5839591026,
0.83152771,
0.1316802651,
0.7892186046,
0.7418875694,
0.0553001873,
0.3133982718,
-0.0164134055,
0.035186097,
-0.8954416513,
-0.3650365472,
-0.6347651482,
-0.1838810295,
-0.9059888721,
-0.6685552597,
0.0420496613,
0.2899627686,
-0.0676809028,
0.3637566566,
-0.4778178036,
0.6897226572,
0.6852537394,
-0.2023563087,
0.5179816484,
-0.2804831266,
-0.1780690253,
-0.3147004545,
-0.8130040765,
-0.7837851644,
1.0278545618,
0.4029656053,
0.1863536239,
0.4722180963,
0.3638937473,
0.082962282,
0.6099418998,
-0.4956971407,
0.1680853665,
-0.5436569452,
-0.8458736539,
-0.3504040241,
-0.3769432306,
-0.8186282516,
0.5132780671,
-0.1817467809,
-0.7523962855,
0.2574498951,
0.158498928,
-0.1397796273,
0.6545107365,
-0.5521950126,
1.0527061224,
0.1239451617,
-0.1622605473,
-0.009427892,
-0.8528533578,
1.0058583021,
-0.289477706,
0.3899650872,
-0.4683431089,
-0.1143438071,
0.5595269799,
-0.287222296,
0.5910560489,
-0.0448843203,
-0.2487396151,
0.3285657167,
0.2158351094,
0.1778244674,
0.3787614405,
-0.360843569,
0.6077467203,
-0.0411198512,
-0.6700960398,
-0.2938901186,
0.5785741806,
-0.660376966,
-0.2203070372,
-0.3124315441,
-0.4373569489,
0.042220518,
0.2161583304,
0.1412600428,
-0.0258819386,
-0.1952116042,
0.1329208612,
0.2408974469,
-0.5965690017,
0.6582555771,
0.6014642119,
-0.3280558288,
-0.3662057519,
1.0181400776,
0.0794947296,
0.4061560035,
0.4430017173,
0.1659450233,
-0.0820624307,
-0.5481083989,
-0.7133129239,
0.1534030139,
-0.6909286976,
0.1695962697,
-1.0299669504,
-0.087461248,
-0.7980501652,
-0.1107331589,
-0.3948684931,
-0.6379452348,
-0.3727449477,
-0.0923045278,
-0.4317199588,
0.3311846852,
-0.6869122982,
0.2773738801,
-0.9006256461,
0.4648552835,
0.0787839592,
0.3962969184,
0.0858162642,
-0.4914020002,
-0.6592671275,
0.3196952939,
-0.287871927,
-0.420899123,
0.3912635744,
0.0806317553,
0.5364623666,
0.608535111,
0.1577563286,
0.3796255589,
-0.4885978997,
0.9463153481,
0.3003766537,
-1.0319123268,
0.3789920211,
-0.4385409951,
0.2369267195,
0.5902395844,
0.4099494219,
-1.2125538588,
-0.7278140783,
-0.313408047,
-0.6929039955,
1.062125802,
0.2559993565,
0.1399105787,
-0.1144466996,
-0.1077274382,
0.2388104796,
0.2230759561,
-1.0328387022,
-0.2415371686,
-0.6483876705,
-0.1945920289,
-0.1430259496,
-0.3526044488,
0.0814192966,
-0.1206600145,
0.4522847533,
-0.2137693763,
0.0245853215,
0.0742657632,
-0.2044215649,
-0.0684518218,
0.2113922983,
0.9075229168,
0.7118985653,
-0.1378112435,
0.4141438305,
0.0837748125,
-0.8881924152,
-0.1791286916,
-0.3076766729,
-0.1384381354,
0.0641044602,
0.4391808212,
0.3234329224,
-0.2903260589,
-0.6202816367,
0.4089456201,
0.1475185454,
-0.0441498533,
-0.3647661805,
-0.0853209868,
0.3776028454,
0.0629603565,
0.2153903544,
0.1259537935,
0.2565867007,
-0.6282594204,
0.2121305168,
0.1600811183,
-0.5652885437,
-0.2916691005,
0.7261731029,
0.3513170183,
-0.2346077114,
0.7605854869,
-0.426107794,
-0.5572232008,
0.6161170006,
0.5629018545,
0.6211153269,
-0.2746135592,
0.3784596026,
0.7506707907,
0.7211433649,
-0.0376429968,
0.2596729994,
-0.0890722498,
-0.8366199732,
-0.2924355567,
-0.7085523605,
-0.5463829637,
-0.2731030285,
-0.4810886085,
0.3090126514,
-0.672934711,
0.1444023252,
-0.1672692746,
-0.0531978793,
-0.1369361728,
0.2106697857,
0.4214146733,
0.6941744089,
-0.5328492522,
1.0512537956,
0.1864114255,
-0.3165112436,
-0.6670953631,
-0.1178236529,
0.0826714039,
-0.8852291107,
0.8198019266,
0.1678327173,
-0.0882521346,
-0.1298565567,
-0.5178527236,
-0.7098698616,
0.9804772139,
0.5152549744,
-0.4972507656,
0.3930045068,
0.3277334273,
0.4693885148,
-0.2788353264,
0.3793325126,
0.4570285976,
0.646538794,
-0.1269838959,
-1.020422101,
-0.0631259903,
-0.3625925481,
-0.1730710119,
0.2198794484,
-0.9334532619,
1.1791671515,
-0.5368518829,
-0.5659127235,
-0.0271350946,
0.8596431017,
0.456001699,
0.6188020706,
0.2285676301,
0.2115072459,
1.0344822407,
-0.1083798036,
0.8399894834,
-0.043436572,
0.1057007015,
1.1867502928,
-0.1403131932,
0.9024535418,
0.1699239016,
-0.3547379375,
0.5915539861,
0.6253975034,
0.0192407742,
0.0938768908,
0.4916477799,
-0.3513428867,
-0.0358216092,
-0.6374912262,
-0.4484267533,
0.4642823637,
0.2553169727,
-0.2046623975,
0.0252212975,
-0.3432438672,
0.2502928674,
0.2985318601,
-0.408567816,
0.4094242156,
0.1981279999,
-0.3749755025,
0.3128520548,
0.4694835842,
0.9937776923,
-0.5545588136,
0.0859602466,
-0.4241312444,
-0.0136963576,
-0.6041805148,
-0.8005108833,
0.5901619196,
0.0757209063,
-0.3840942085,
-0.0278962553,
0.4127921164,
-0.9134964943,
-0.6755427122,
0.3244659901,
0.4676681757,
0.4278058112,
-0.1022078395,
-0.4816221595,
-0.2091033906,
0.0580810159,
0.1161229163,
0.2245868146,
0.5251549482,
-0.3286801577,
0.5499379635,
0.9679764509,
0.2184073627,
0.0268105716,
0.1980304271,
0.4342566729,
-0.7024704218,
-0.5882014036,
-0.9117908478,
0.5384066701,
0.0038742265,
-0.3512611985,
0.7254703641,
0.6642716527,
1.2307881117,
0.0957730338,
0.7593230605,
0.0632588267,
0.5406672359,
-0.4404422045,
1.2050806284,
-0.6645245552,
0.0791196898,
-0.4012805521,
-0.8512389064,
-0.5581558347,
0.2730787694,
0.4341955185,
-0.090972729,
0.6673263907,
0.6296738386,
-0.1009259373,
-0.0838995054,
0.6083264351,
-0.0112065431,
0.2628173232,
0.7708640695,
0.707708478,
-0.1816029102,
0.7825542688,
-0.2461112738,
-0.1494900733,
0.0677782819,
-0.9107416868,
-0.5318988562,
-0.4879541397,
-0.0904902071,
-0.2595522106,
-0.3512568176,
0.8477387428,
0.6138011813,
-1.1170762777,
-0.465834409,
0.3097548485,
0.4293091297,
-0.0131101115,
-0.1474795341,
0.3671911955,
-0.0287579913,
-1.0709929466,
0.1620854586,
0.5066078305,
0.1584248394,
-0.4586430788,
-0.2359924018,
-0.2813390791,
-0.3997505605,
0.6448132992,
0.4150679708,
-0.6130102873,
0.1709820926,
0.0528201945,
-0.4731241167,
0.0083436146,
0.99322927,
-0.2954422235,
0.4361687601,
0.4385293126,
0.4880818129,
0.1280047894,
-0.1843951195,
0.5359033942,
-0.8098980188,
0.4731191695,
0.4037997127,
0.3420372903,
0.5996059775,
-0.2770413458,
0.7060604095,
0.4627669454,
-0.4225206077,
-0.8892270327,
0.4004593194,
-1.0370473862,
-0.4252086282,
1.2221244574,
-0.4111626744,
0.0470280237,
-0.4982390702,
-0.2006689012,
0.4089184105,
-0.3199222386,
0.5053400993,
0.7426379919,
0.270852983,
-0.2110949606,
-0.5859514475,
0.5727915168,
0.277910918,
-0.7657952905,
0.2599797249,
0.3818693757,
-0.0921485648,
0.2968374193,
1.0092523098,
-0.274876684,
0.2770130634,
0.2912939489,
0.2849142849,
-0.0970784277,
-0.3199309111,
-0.105785042,
0.146282047,
-0.0727596581,
-0.0858919621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08329v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08329v4
|
KTRL+F: Knowledge-Augmented In-Document Search
| 2023-11-14T17:18:08 | 2024-04-18T07:08:21 |
Hanseok Oh, Haebin Shin, Miyoung Ko, Hyunji Lee, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a new problem KTRL+F, a knowledge-augmented in-document search
task that necessitates real-time identification of all semantic targets within
a document with the awareness of external sources through a single natural
query. KTRL+F addresses following unique challenges for in-document search:
1)utilizing knowledge outside the document for extended use of additional
information about targets, and 2) balancing between real-time applicability
with the performance. We analyze various baselines in KTRL+F and find
limitations of existing models, such as hallucinations, high latency, or
difficulties in leveraging external knowledge. Therefore, we propose a
Knowledge-Augmented Phrase Retrieval model that shows a promising balance
between speed and performance by simply augmenting external knowledge in phrase
embedding. We also conduct a user study to verify whether solving KTRL+F can
enhance search experience for users. It demonstrates that even with our simple
model, users can reduce the time for searching with less queries and reduced
extra visits to other sources for collecting evidence. We encourage the
research community to work on KTRL+F to enhance more efficient in-document
information access.
|
[
-0.1811222136,
-0.8927232027,
0.9794461727,
0.0855513886,
-0.0868690908,
0.4752408266,
-0.0693679452,
-1.0912064314,
0.1587198228,
0.3179350197,
-0.4776308835,
-0.1489373595,
-0.8736335039,
-0.0369190983,
-0.5529387593,
0.4127095044,
-0.0944885537,
0.0834864601,
-0.5165992975,
-0.1926414669,
-0.4780458212,
-0.6616997123,
-0.4644584358,
-0.4139864445,
0.5988152623,
0.4730016589,
0.8496073484,
0.4622170925,
0.7218692899,
0.1298022717,
-0.3180496693,
0.2786016464,
-0.3519159853,
0.4426314235,
0.0219130982,
-0.3810730577,
-0.0513490848,
-0.0874375999,
0.6297184825,
0.5013504624,
0.1670802981,
-0.0507240295,
-0.2612586021,
0.7448987961,
-0.8652557731,
0.0381076299,
-0.4760268927,
0.2280309945,
-0.3190350831,
-0.1240624338,
-0.2441167533,
-0.6186324954,
0.5758609772,
-0.8200696707,
0.2872828245,
-0.0804348812,
0.8992678523,
0.0453641005,
-0.6096822023,
-0.8870702386,
-0.6452077627,
0.2413225025,
-0.3384648263,
1.1440031528,
0.2732278407,
0.2298263907,
-0.0372973979,
-0.9591338038,
-0.7410596609,
-0.6535062194,
-0.3116917312,
0.0260293018,
0.2255161703,
0.0891099721,
0.2574473619,
0.2369879037,
-0.3485108614,
-0.3663919568,
-0.3938771188,
-0.3196976483,
0.2688917518,
0.0191310663,
0.1275276393,
0.1000246108,
-0.3024303019,
-0.1858873516,
-0.5980969071,
0.0956382304,
0.3232099116,
0.2801158726,
0.3445666134,
0.7194542289,
-0.2289672196,
0.8108748794,
0.038805075,
-0.0450927429,
-0.0100669209,
-0.5634538531,
0.1486512721,
0.2422023118,
0.1510615945,
0.153518185,
-0.2512688339,
-0.3802287281,
-0.2694145143,
-0.177454561,
0.1400293559,
-0.8376948237,
-0.0843427926,
0.1195475385,
-0.3356789947,
-0.3146131933,
0.1014536619,
-0.5440623164,
-0.4935199916,
-0.3357017338,
0.9230251908,
-0.6567268968,
-0.1269836575,
0.0128606306,
-0.6136395335,
0.0133181317,
0.3454023898,
-0.2138981074,
0.2911809385,
0.6168707013,
0.7926976085,
0.1890114844,
-0.0512418114,
-0.896063149,
0.0753420666,
-0.1375251561,
0.7557727098,
-1.0189441442,
-0.7890805006,
0.1059310436,
-0.102375485,
0.0315124542,
-0.4064871371,
0.8501271605,
-1.1213873625,
0.4341516197,
-0.8209276199,
-1.0143772364,
-0.2373675853,
0.3730039001,
-0.7701887488,
1.1681767702,
0.3761796057,
-0.6240969896,
0.4694268405,
-1.2139062881,
-0.4270096123,
0.2141377777,
0.071335569,
0.0123956157,
0.0031508927,
-0.0659621581,
0.1159939766,
-0.1002795324,
0.0380191579,
-0.2102756649,
-0.4946336746,
0.1397941411,
0.1346109062,
0.4648666084,
0.3079307973,
0.0481017828,
-0.0845197663,
-0.5111858249,
0.0378195234,
0.1478220671,
-0.5201617479,
-0.6371349692,
-0.0527665541,
0.1864997596,
0.1252239347,
0.7162527442,
-0.8335428238,
0.1718728393,
-0.5104650855,
0.0452079102,
0.4054343402,
-0.0236725081,
0.6083993912,
-0.2561270297,
0.4534147382,
-0.0803010389,
0.3163585663,
0.0017037579,
-0.3555931449,
-0.4936324656,
0.0057677492,
0.4410199821,
0.4266255498,
-0.7800068259,
-0.0343701504,
-0.1481458396,
-0.5249379873,
-0.8439139724,
0.0044363048,
0.5203524232,
0.8260787129,
0.3555950522,
-0.0320061781,
-0.4173976481,
-0.5555167198,
-0.310788691,
0.1637753546,
0.244142428,
0.6839041114,
0.2737122774,
-0.1451562494,
0.9507862926,
-0.8232019544,
-0.5699688792,
-0.1467283815,
0.1901994944,
0.0667411387,
0.0672944486,
0.2857792974,
-1.3810670376,
-0.7890405059,
0.1178775579,
-0.7435679436,
-0.0683431253,
0.3383335471,
0.1070937663,
0.3022985458,
0.6766527295,
-0.8243737817,
0.1752481163,
-0.0386901498,
-0.641769588,
0.4406067431,
-0.520285666,
0.0889760703,
-0.7431393862,
0.2836268544,
-0.1293988973,
0.043744728,
-0.5407783985,
0.7211850882,
0.5395460129,
-0.3959420025,
-0.4627236128,
0.8727988005,
-0.2582881153,
0.0375151336,
-0.2165638506,
0.4457928836,
0.2416033894,
0.1352286786,
0.1046166047,
0.7210276723,
0.1103904545,
-0.6278289557,
0.361685425,
0.2357125282,
-0.2235572636,
0.4935650527,
-0.3718823493,
0.2917948961,
-0.3553431034,
0.2814599872,
-0.6203311086,
-0.308472544,
0.0343539789,
-0.3906592727,
0.3093425632,
-0.1023580879,
-0.8982867002,
-0.2294343561,
-0.321975857,
0.4683684111,
0.1167517304,
-0.6663560867,
0.7648825049,
0.2163418531,
0.2277388871,
-0.4597595334,
0.0140255066,
-0.0302371085,
0.0204221923,
-0.6512896419,
0.7445264459,
-0.1276243329,
-0.2231037468,
0.4128728211,
-0.1297581643,
-0.2577267885,
0.0143887671,
-0.1333141923,
-0.0514071546,
0.0473343506,
0.4086301923,
-0.0849748999,
-0.0728697628,
-0.2707109153,
-0.3410749733,
0.3629363477,
0.2059902698,
-0.4351319969,
-0.1329947114,
0.6532165408,
0.706720829,
-0.4275834858,
0.3975628018,
0.9386709332,
-0.4677079916,
0.3070256114,
-0.779696703,
-0.2362114191,
-0.4804237485,
0.3303116858,
-0.4308741391,
-1.0394085646,
0.4504221082,
0.0403788611,
-0.233902663,
0.4037275016,
0.1621664017,
-0.3169956505,
0.849424541,
0.9272934198,
0.0237118304,
0.5309846401,
-0.2098546922,
0.3316728175,
-0.7663403153,
-0.6559410095,
-0.5999190807,
-0.4091474414,
-0.3648127019,
-0.2338704467,
0.7695515752,
0.0624085814,
0.0376928784,
0.4346534312,
-0.7676001191,
0.515953958,
0.7116312981,
0.3595739007,
0.3510972559,
-0.5306479335,
-0.3280815184,
-0.0825946108,
-0.6588184834,
0.2620750964,
1.0567983389,
0.0794995055,
0.4898171425,
0.0768368766,
0.4951788783,
0.4782077968,
0.2095239311,
-0.8029084802,
0.4174238145,
-0.1395357549,
-0.7732165456,
-0.1682838053,
-0.3092438281,
-0.6235813498,
-0.0022535024,
-0.2129229754,
-0.4700513482,
0.2299398035,
0.0163141508,
-0.3828451037,
0.0850341767,
-0.9098501801,
0.7296776772,
-0.3771449029,
-0.2791942656,
-0.3532007635,
-0.6926779151,
0.2012914717,
-0.1308520138,
0.1349518746,
0.0844095424,
-0.128140524,
0.5240189433,
-0.3199049234,
0.2506571114,
-0.5563736558,
-0.0175226647,
0.1885237396,
0.1180731803,
1.0520591736,
0.0157687962,
-0.1264036596,
-0.5189535618,
0.373328954,
-0.1697097123,
-0.7790047526,
0.8095089197,
-0.3444956541,
-0.3666490614,
-0.4364058673,
-0.7223887444,
-0.0214236509,
0.3579365313,
0.2212606966,
0.6703475714,
0.0134183345,
0.3920779526,
0.895896256,
-0.0040840325,
0.2413981408,
0.9499358535,
-0.3354283869,
-0.2161102444,
1.1188081503,
0.4517932832,
0.0237932708,
1.0767349005,
0.3086468577,
-0.7920933962,
-0.2778859437,
-0.1724225879,
0.0038238231,
-0.7981469631,
-0.1303822249,
-0.8817585707,
-0.1950033754,
-0.2248511016,
-0.2273979187,
-0.094255425,
-0.4828008711,
-0.4408840537,
0.089373298,
0.5739729404,
0.4546916485,
0.0521382019,
0.2220196575,
-0.9671565294,
0.4183303416,
0.1499733776,
0.6081232429,
-0.0729306713,
-0.2470013201,
-0.5574333072,
-0.0968937874,
-0.3502400219,
-0.7115562558,
0.1130878404,
0.2849576473,
0.4232174158,
0.1483549327,
0.2110712379,
0.5442504883,
-0.218609497,
0.5892909169,
-0.3423561752,
-0.597435832,
0.373544246,
-0.2879502177,
0.3395975232,
0.6012709141,
0.5297699571,
-0.5397441387,
-0.3538131416,
-0.7464530468,
-0.8384695053,
0.5762525201,
0.2080597878,
-0.1001256704,
0.0851725116,
0.3514214456,
-0.0812215284,
0.0906194225,
-0.3913980424,
0.0655524284,
-0.0328202285,
-0.1073266342,
0.2773950994,
-0.4687814415,
-0.0026352266,
-0.263845861,
0.6259192228,
0.0133984787,
0.5138406754,
0.6652159095,
-0.3028591871,
-0.2338992208,
-0.0401581265,
0.6886574626,
0.3637646139,
-0.7974690199,
0.0194301717,
0.0499508008,
-0.608484149,
-0.0146507779,
0.5497137308,
-0.0666764677,
0.2625755072,
0.2137420028,
0.1982431114,
0.4150772095,
-0.8970261216,
0.431140691,
-0.1039545536,
-0.3327425718,
-0.4502736926,
-0.0803807303,
0.0467106476,
0.4968560636,
0.6970733404,
0.0379344635,
0.200839892,
-0.4169471264,
0.3690353334,
0.6716692448,
-0.5698272586,
-0.0598413944,
0.6825532913,
0.1298636496,
-0.5322362185,
0.3706483841,
-0.4334633648,
-0.6281718016,
0.4558291435,
0.3420404196,
0.8775543571,
0.2375855148,
-0.0194461253,
-0.0035803877,
0.1454702914,
-0.0364065506,
0.4521211386,
-0.3301609755,
-0.6741703749,
-0.2669549286,
-0.5142146349,
-0.6144077778,
0.1460252255,
-0.3790449202,
0.1899217963,
-0.1088113561,
-0.1613321304,
0.0769050121,
0.4181287885,
-0.6791561246,
0.1383415312,
-0.3952865601,
1.3557646275,
-0.2919742167,
0.9266207814,
0.6073383689,
-0.4497308433,
-0.4009676576,
0.0705543384,
-0.2488716245,
-0.5462338328,
0.8055419922,
-0.1266364008,
-0.1285863072,
0.0720675588,
-0.3526063263,
-1.0292001963,
1.3105925322,
0.2944096327,
-0.1293880641,
-0.3728422225,
-0.0808209702,
0.4384085834,
-0.2031146437,
0.1073753983,
0.4292122126,
0.674916625,
0.2554079592,
-0.7723822594,
-0.0950172693,
-0.119596526,
-0.3183321059,
0.4854929447,
-0.4941692948,
0.4910978079,
-0.0282469299,
-0.1630593389,
-0.0259793326,
0.4376611412,
-0.0271465294,
0.7222496271,
0.3677415848,
0.7537690401,
0.6865169406,
0.0048997104,
1.042288065,
-0.5710154772,
0.2117847502,
1.1487063169,
-0.4339037836,
0.6642056108,
0.4525378644,
-0.0750563368,
-0.0467046462,
0.3526094556,
0.2676879168,
0.7692955732,
-0.3192367852,
-0.6839990616,
-0.0404163748,
-0.5354861021,
-0.4585823715,
0.2759841383,
0.4890171289,
-0.3672404587,
-0.50407058,
0.1111496538,
-0.0374810733,
0.1401176602,
-0.0115615893,
0.7613620162,
-0.1274568141,
-0.5311076045,
0.2608262002,
0.084160544,
0.4788510501,
-0.8415774107,
-0.0696267858,
-0.0989245176,
0.2184984833,
-0.090247795,
-0.8039001226,
0.4941356182,
-0.2363655567,
-0.3456685245,
-0.1182194874,
1.1355352402,
-0.4703288674,
-0.6748372912,
0.5308737755,
0.4423286617,
-0.1958465725,
-0.3435323834,
-0.3712804019,
-0.0452301763,
-0.006134354,
0.1034391969,
0.5843129754,
0.6313022971,
0.0694972426,
0.8373029828,
0.8045742512,
-0.1169106811,
0.0021686396,
-0.2066525072,
1.0208028555,
-0.4476391673,
-0.3681575358,
-0.4260728359,
0.2005884647,
-0.0537118576,
-0.0104668634,
0.4465919733,
0.6984375119,
0.933113277,
-0.0370706953,
0.757755816,
-0.3453302681,
0.7313660979,
-0.5581169724,
0.8951114416,
-0.8234414458,
-0.1098399609,
-0.2864433229,
-0.6090116501,
-0.150712952,
0.168041572,
-0.102904506,
-0.2809285522,
0.673038125,
0.9322424531,
-0.236379087,
0.0000616597,
0.318023026,
-0.0862245187,
0.4360577762,
0.3129013777,
0.6643756032,
-0.4522072673,
0.7364670634,
-0.4277039468,
0.2285908163,
-0.539265573,
-0.9378452897,
-0.2619959712,
-0.9420828223,
0.0348858535,
-0.1833554208,
0.1515617371,
1.0041691065,
0.4221536815,
-0.3321946859,
0.0638873503,
-0.006242468,
0.4975245595,
-0.1607222408,
-0.2843593359,
0.4456625581,
-0.529163897,
-0.3231115639,
0.7440595031,
0.1519551277,
0.0547372252,
-0.0074818609,
-0.1434556097,
-0.6025671959,
-0.0708183423,
0.8013038635,
0.3024013937,
-0.4653636515,
-0.4689725637,
0.4268706739,
0.0912038311,
-0.1816485375,
0.9773887396,
-0.895522058,
0.9431712627,
0.5491295457,
0.7486678958,
0.6139768362,
0.0027595176,
0.625140667,
-1.0297720432,
0.0418770052,
0.4026885629,
0.019772457,
0.1372896135,
-0.8006138206,
0.5526429415,
0.4173570573,
-0.4311556816,
-0.8624958396,
0.1574085355,
-0.82033813,
-0.1670123488,
0.6891480088,
0.1796785146,
0.2528868318,
-0.1769202948,
-0.3668355942,
0.2801438272,
-0.6594088078,
0.7962304354,
0.8363944292,
-0.1813787669,
-0.0688572302,
-0.7203422785,
0.8057932854,
-0.010951912,
-0.2132819146,
-0.2199923247,
0.3195023537,
0.0525100194,
0.4289848208,
0.7252007723,
-0.1981579214,
0.393085897,
-0.2754193246,
-0.3796066344,
-0.4348119199,
-0.3735462725,
0.1524856836,
0.5729042888,
0.1776630431,
0.0357613862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08324v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08324v2
|
Anti-LM Decoding for Zero-shot In-context Machine Translation
| 2023-11-14T17:09:43 | 2024-04-02T19:03:15 |
Suzanna Sia, Alexandra DeLucia, Kevin Duh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Zero-shot In-context learning is the phenomenon where models can perform the
task simply given the instructions. However, pre-trained large language models
are known to be poorly calibrated for this task. One of the most effective
approaches to handling this bias is to adopt a contrastive decoding objective,
which accounts for the prior probability of generating the next token by
conditioning on some context. This work introduces an Anti-Language Model
objective with a decay factor designed to address the weaknesses of In-context
Machine Translation. We conduct our experiments across 3 model types and sizes,
3 language directions, and for both greedy decoding and beam search ($B=5$).
The proposed method outperforms other state-of-art decoding objectives, with up
to $20$ BLEU point improvement from the default objective observed in some
settings.
|
[
-0.1305523366,
-0.6055063605,
0.7189014554,
-0.0746250376,
-0.6286321282,
-0.2123662084,
0.1343080401,
-0.0515427329,
0.060582649,
0.4013246298,
-0.4837803543,
-0.4894832969,
-0.6185239553,
0.0679447055,
-0.5197357535,
0.9895495176,
-0.3182166219,
0.3951225579,
-0.0951036289,
-0.2151122391,
-0.5260927081,
-0.5682690144,
-0.5650719404,
-0.6440644264,
0.3692390323,
0.3601267934,
0.5337283015,
0.4660066068,
0.4145586789,
0.0987462848,
0.0797295868,
-0.0144953728,
-0.8964898586,
-0.1055926457,
-0.1590429097,
-0.5207051635,
-0.4940589964,
0.0226864014,
0.5993982553,
0.4495739043,
0.2084077299,
-0.1099731475,
-0.1565181017,
0.4943277538,
-1.1137088537,
0.05630688,
-0.6770814657,
0.1585144103,
0.0082618669,
-0.6840198636,
-0.7177831531,
0.1827103496,
-0.2362032235,
-0.4357878268,
0.0400336683,
-0.2206829041,
0.8371853232,
0.350556463,
-0.4902077317,
-0.1675740182,
-0.5680023432,
1.099578023,
-0.863180995,
0.4431371093,
0.7184735537,
-0.0674377754,
-0.2351912409,
-0.1793454438,
-0.4144458175,
0.0374327675,
-0.0502044037,
0.3901323676,
-0.4623711705,
0.2047534287,
-0.0337688699,
0.2418933809,
-0.6615658998,
0.1059805229,
-0.1440324187,
-0.1071002707,
0.2170952111,
0.231469661,
0.2126339674,
0.0421694629,
-0.2479788959,
-0.0579504482,
-1.0308918953,
-0.1567995548,
0.2154614031,
0.3035174608,
-0.1020247936,
0.4955068231,
-0.4571085572,
0.9125990868,
0.1786777526,
0.1381054074,
0.2396593839,
-0.4457708597,
-0.3338817358,
0.2569690943,
0.2999749184,
0.5481222868,
-0.0113901161,
-0.2745880485,
-0.6440047622,
0.1111248657,
0.1858599633,
-1.2277034521,
0.0049571423,
0.2743271887,
-0.4720455706,
-0.1688422859,
-0.2467365414,
-0.0849281177,
0.068621397,
-0.06264285,
0.9761425257,
-0.5848037601,
0.0626377463,
0.4173671901,
-0.0272940286,
0.4570369124,
0.0093729189,
-0.5315044522,
-0.1267349422,
0.2612406909,
0.7942666411,
0.1607288122,
-0.1209957823,
-1.0956531763,
0.0737597346,
-0.6065458059,
0.5959279537,
-0.5314081311,
-0.6001454592,
-0.0129074771,
-0.0966552868,
-0.0550841987,
-0.3524788022,
0.5839726329,
-0.5895118713,
0.2754499614,
-0.3542663753,
-0.6967520118,
-0.2108630985,
0.39999488,
-0.1383730918,
0.5075451732,
0.2809911668,
-0.5980955362,
0.450386256,
-0.5658542514,
-0.4685615301,
0.1070200577,
-0.0881816745,
-0.490142107,
0.5690349936,
0.3620511889,
0.337353915,
-0.0872712135,
0.1138315871,
-0.1821805835,
-0.9304846525,
0.1283623427,
-0.3847773373,
0.73994416,
0.3933388889,
-0.3734715283,
0.1823140234,
-0.4731566906,
-0.1584554017,
0.3545957208,
-0.2121892422,
-0.3488590717,
0.1466032714,
-0.3123258948,
0.1126939878,
0.1161229163,
-0.5320336819,
-0.0133002698,
-0.7815562487,
0.3342459202,
0.3099884689,
0.0245161857,
0.6722959876,
-0.1690668613,
0.5399498343,
0.4175319076,
-0.0273635834,
-0.7845680714,
-0.2137301415,
-0.860607028,
-0.1901607066,
0.0168753434,
0.4924191535,
-0.967987299,
0.3666977584,
-0.0585478842,
-0.0508197211,
-0.7618287206,
0.0737875998,
0.9070097804,
0.8737691045,
0.7085427642,
-0.3749873638,
-0.4734525383,
-0.8469821215,
-0.1658667624,
0.116393365,
-0.1037434861,
0.1958362162,
0.3746731877,
-0.5443590879,
0.6562500596,
-0.434710294,
-0.4290851057,
-0.4141201973,
0.1388143897,
0.4430017173,
0.3628050387,
0.6036240458,
-0.6863237023,
-0.6458342075,
-0.1223211214,
-0.7355065942,
-0.2805211842,
0.0414707698,
-0.1709084064,
0.3236219287,
0.7443715334,
-0.3981186748,
0.5809637904,
0.4044860899,
-0.3118900061,
0.1183821633,
-0.2872249186,
0.210360691,
-0.8629268408,
0.2989181578,
-0.2177846581,
-0.4094663858,
-0.9505788088,
0.4135172963,
0.2540807128,
-0.1260352731,
-0.7452276349,
0.7007374167,
-0.3441922665,
0.121075511,
-0.6714128852,
0.2978567183,
0.0519819669,
0.3247092366,
0.2475982308,
0.6694480181,
0.350148201,
-0.5401178002,
-0.1174414083,
-0.0198952518,
0.1130493134,
0.730699718,
-0.6671804786,
0.1496949196,
-0.5011172891,
0.4173633754,
-0.9203395247,
0.0672763512,
0.3298580348,
-0.578307271,
0.5590005517,
-0.2026120573,
-0.1647240222,
-0.1794171184,
-0.4827368259,
0.8169890642,
0.4951929152,
-0.2186745405,
0.2838559747,
-0.0153698185,
0.5690044165,
-0.7473356724,
-0.8959601521,
0.0579448082,
-0.0763986185,
-0.107082434,
0.4569984674,
-0.2598638237,
-0.0448076762,
0.0892689228,
-0.2420020998,
0.1531276405,
0.0204204544,
-0.0641905144,
0.05604681,
-0.3896156549,
-0.3845469654,
-0.0832704753,
-0.5240638256,
-0.2682405412,
-0.5352077484,
0.6567955017,
0.1711045057,
-0.4153357148,
-0.3492655158,
0.2690011561,
0.4789687991,
-0.2124335021,
0.8685494661,
0.6896631122,
-0.3803258836,
-0.1328459233,
-0.2470538467,
-0.2978288829,
-0.4438467622,
0.5433306694,
-0.5450100303,
-0.3599649966,
0.5914255977,
0.418710649,
-0.172840476,
0.3536842763,
0.5407102704,
-0.0233250596,
1.159919858,
0.7970170975,
-0.2464181334,
0.5895611644,
-0.3951976001,
0.5032203197,
-0.6114764214,
0.135259077,
-0.3380329609,
-0.2430520505,
-0.01819098,
-0.3659673631,
0.4091718495,
0.5510050654,
-0.1957895011,
0.5579590797,
-0.3040467203,
0.6473461986,
0.5896661282,
0.2785843611,
0.080857411,
-0.0844898075,
-0.1821997911,
-0.0610250346,
-0.8626362085,
-0.0995991305,
0.9656863213,
0.1822668761,
0.528668344,
-0.0013764668,
0.9039184451,
0.1622669101,
0.2790600955,
-0.9219480753,
0.4094671905,
-0.4309642315,
-0.5254778862,
-0.1712545902,
-0.4910843372,
-0.8453133106,
0.2985039055,
0.023060672,
-0.5411702394,
0.0485809371,
0.4256748855,
-0.0359640196,
0.2188867629,
-0.4673722684,
1.0158802271,
-0.1069719419,
-0.2621642053,
-0.2079105675,
-0.6956362724,
0.2903370261,
-0.0784930065,
0.1182772219,
0.116852358,
0.1676258445,
0.250921309,
-0.1937438995,
0.6335114241,
-0.3937155902,
-0.0752282292,
0.1594722867,
0.4658069015,
0.6584607363,
-0.2681436837,
-0.2841396928,
-0.0115354061,
-0.1649767607,
-0.7325063348,
-0.2840689123,
0.4522790611,
-0.5780060291,
-0.3138728142,
-0.2348473966,
-0.4431153238,
-0.0814594179,
0.4649394751,
0.7158823013,
0.5679590702,
-0.2963448763,
0.4325186014,
0.660261631,
-0.4286306202,
0.5695325732,
0.8598136306,
-0.1017312631,
-0.2050476521,
0.9691832066,
-0.0375356153,
0.4466516376,
0.8680657148,
0.1168970093,
-0.3715570569,
-0.7536455393,
-0.6679057479,
0.1112048849,
-0.877866447,
-0.6126990914,
-0.3972398043,
-0.252273351,
-0.1105785668,
-0.6049132347,
-0.3951337039,
0.093785964,
-0.5484762192,
-0.0037707374,
-0.3133336902,
0.3949037492,
0.0859731883,
0.4685088992,
-0.7800807357,
0.4219932258,
-0.2553991377,
0.131518811,
-0.0818144679,
-0.9942996502,
-0.5021570325,
0.2169866413,
-0.2154579759,
-0.8512561917,
0.5614100695,
0.2880212963,
0.6132777333,
0.6473709941,
0.3575456142,
0.6622966528,
-0.5119692087,
0.5663964748,
0.2922342718,
-1.1831516027,
0.3888244629,
-0.4197549522,
0.8778383136,
0.4562984109,
0.4641313851,
-0.4449103475,
-0.3976727128,
-0.1562017947,
-0.9139370322,
0.9002938867,
0.1223059371,
0.3704153001,
-0.1891136765,
0.3849038482,
-0.0776103884,
0.1031971648,
-0.950955689,
-0.1474792063,
-0.4252695441,
-0.3369129598,
-0.4756005406,
-0.5207077861,
-0.0121857328,
0.1436809301,
0.6900696158,
-0.2748509645,
0.1402164698,
0.1785482913,
-0.6511136293,
-0.5099779367,
0.1962457895,
0.8670147061,
0.4997296333,
-0.5296148658,
0.3033964336,
0.2759482563,
-0.0273418985,
0.0446166173,
-0.1465492994,
-0.7204609513,
-0.087527521,
0.4125295579,
0.8592646122,
0.4428424239,
-0.6457512975,
0.7371878028,
0.1269067675,
-0.2480126619,
0.1485305429,
-0.1320050806,
-0.0972379446,
0.0703552514,
0.4749830961,
-0.3548686504,
0.2357545495,
-0.6135883927,
0.332862854,
0.5632411242,
-0.6530088186,
-0.4659871161,
0.7912697792,
0.1498561054,
-0.1931985915,
0.4536459446,
-0.6107749939,
-0.5901250243,
0.2417632788,
0.9478625655,
1.0101959705,
-0.2427100539,
0.0842474774,
0.3520736694,
0.2857318521,
-0.0177229065,
0.192886591,
-0.0685675964,
-0.7262004018,
-0.3819378316,
-0.7630434632,
-0.2078786194,
0.2402397841,
-0.4110530615,
0.4404314756,
-0.0594270341,
0.0581523106,
-0.4809924066,
-0.1608490795,
-0.496326983,
0.3356775343,
0.0958399624,
0.4688663483,
-0.6147744656,
0.9897843599,
0.3819197416,
-0.6871902943,
0.019207865,
0.0518096499,
-0.0249650795,
-0.8375042081,
0.7351351976,
0.2587071955,
-0.6145409346,
0.011999486,
-0.3000486791,
-0.7383881211,
0.7498579025,
0.5710713267,
-0.5054174066,
0.040410921,
0.0573889427,
0.3581594527,
-0.404538542,
0.2315565646,
0.2946115434,
0.2699867487,
0.0011142839,
-0.7701596618,
0.0344917513,
-0.018839132,
-0.1528825164,
0.358147651,
-0.3589801192,
0.9180371165,
0.0185468476,
-0.290758431,
0.053574197,
0.2755910158,
-0.1715127379,
0.4254227877,
0.3101121187,
0.5166127086,
-0.0333867632,
0.219455421,
0.976030767,
-0.6324534416,
0.3805688918,
1.0014389753,
-0.0842829123,
0.8747262955,
0.475615412,
0.2039307952,
0.0505816564,
0.4223797619,
0.4062036872,
0.897931397,
0.1876533478,
-0.2207748443,
-0.2623323202,
-0.1363013685,
-0.2636489272,
0.5475882292,
0.3324364424,
-0.4282632172,
-0.4194059372,
-0.0767111629,
0.2832325995,
0.1644514352,
-0.4093003869,
0.6337000728,
0.1805217415,
-0.5005332232,
0.9655870795,
0.3470051587,
0.7065623403,
-0.6385111213,
0.009285639,
-0.4226816297,
0.5423830748,
-0.1955940574,
-0.364243716,
0.3820376098,
-0.2039588243,
-0.1934074163,
-0.2953579724,
0.6072207689,
-0.61472857,
-0.2460418791,
0.6223925352,
0.4175870717,
0.2610025704,
-0.2560633421,
-0.554001689,
0.0835342929,
0.0242108684,
-0.2045328468,
0.3227167428,
0.0922993273,
0.0341293365,
0.4153115451,
0.303657949,
-0.1375257373,
-0.2138596624,
0.0014766095,
0.5990628004,
-0.692499876,
-0.4702738523,
-1.0106670856,
0.4629865289,
0.3409302831,
-0.1360274255,
0.6886264682,
0.4678454399,
1.0623691082,
0.0219090097,
0.3156512678,
0.3397497833,
0.0996142477,
-0.6573609114,
0.6006018519,
-0.8371315598,
0.0609626472,
-0.1436673254,
-1.0126644373,
-0.7225576043,
0.6594424844,
-0.2320550978,
0.0311712697,
0.5679130554,
0.7805228829,
-0.3671919405,
-0.6240445375,
0.778963685,
0.0556306243,
0.4453375638,
0.8181247711,
0.4200264215,
-0.632660985,
0.542419374,
0.0021419437,
-0.0902208015,
-0.6968440413,
-1.0080392361,
-0.9095905423,
-0.3522758782,
-0.1528734714,
-0.21714589,
0.2489517927,
0.6276349425,
0.904306829,
-0.9596279263,
-0.1199121252,
-0.1747419834,
-0.0223897658,
0.1262341887,
-0.1110311821,
0.2715165615,
-0.7564198375,
-0.7324646711,
0.8989464641,
0.538873136,
-0.0281551406,
-0.2014672756,
-0.4826513529,
-0.1832910627,
0.4610667527,
0.7253313065,
0.3804854155,
-0.6477829814,
-0.2621736825,
0.0275337603,
-0.1131526008,
0.1453834027,
0.9099012613,
-0.6272571683,
0.7287894487,
0.4944123626,
0.7168160677,
0.8189824224,
-0.0323580541,
0.6858041883,
-0.8779271245,
0.4344600737,
0.2037909776,
0.5014638901,
0.3068160713,
-0.1466007084,
0.3527610898,
0.2087283283,
-0.3620952368,
-0.9940707088,
0.4063362777,
-0.4980769753,
-0.6357929707,
0.9315590858,
-0.2133546025,
-0.0682644993,
0.0584576428,
-0.1381457746,
0.30512321,
-0.3624925613,
0.4782440364,
0.4304881394,
-0.0301148444,
-0.0696919635,
-0.3739806116,
0.4010095,
0.7767267823,
-0.1577077806,
-0.1926952749,
0.4269045889,
0.1425919682,
-0.0124878278,
0.9030367136,
-0.1626151204,
0.2911641896,
0.066238232,
-0.0283210818,
-0.1150778085,
-0.3682779074,
-0.6878008246,
-0.0088560078,
0.1480868459,
-0.3559726477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08323v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08323v2
|
The taste of IPA: Towards open-vocabulary keyword spotting and forced alignment in any language
| 2023-11-14T17:09:07 | 2024-04-01T23:10:59 |
Jian Zhu, Changbing Yang, Farhan Samir, Jahurul Islam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In this project, we demonstrate that phoneme-based models for speech
processing can achieve strong crosslinguistic generalizability to unseen
languages. We curated the IPAPACK, a massively multilingual speech corpora with
phonemic transcriptions, encompassing more than 115 languages from diverse
language families, selectively checked by linguists. Based on the IPAPACK, we
propose CLAP-IPA, a multi-lingual phoneme-speech contrastive embedding model
capable of open-vocabulary matching between arbitrary speech signals and
phonemic sequences. The proposed model was tested on 95 unseen languages,
showing strong generalizability across languages. Temporal alignments between
phonemes and speech signals also emerged from contrastive training, enabling
zeroshot forced alignment in unseen languages. We further introduced a neural
forced aligner IPA-ALIGNER by finetuning CLAP-IPA with the Forward-Sum loss to
learn better phone-to-audio alignment. Evaluation results suggest that
IPA-ALIGNER can generalize to unseen languages without adaptation.
|
[
-0.1524596214,
-0.1716351211,
0.233910203,
0.344227463,
-0.2977447212,
0.170499891,
-0.0797624215,
-0.47826159,
0.5383980274,
0.3377479315,
-0.018734403,
-0.6120934486,
-0.369176805,
-0.0356374271,
-0.2490028143,
0.5716223717,
0.0867234468,
0.107340917,
0.2553253174,
-0.5098694563,
-0.3706254065,
-0.2855190635,
-0.0863664597,
-0.396812737,
0.328055352,
0.512134254,
0.8636921048,
0.7710976005,
0.1133264974,
0.1418420225,
-0.0870686024,
-0.3570254445,
-0.0225402564,
0.1146421656,
-0.2376199067,
-0.7768653035,
-0.4518892765,
0.0682651252,
0.6302460432,
1.0348237753,
-0.0132140284,
-0.0443184189,
0.1606679112,
0.4133517146,
-0.7628642917,
0.1168536171,
-0.869780302,
-0.008140834,
-0.361589551,
0.1567786932,
-0.3589474857,
-0.0413093381,
0.1325788945,
-0.6218710542,
0.0412486419,
0.0084939385,
0.9582031369,
0.2723653913,
-0.1417677999,
-0.3649875224,
-0.6153717041,
0.6608675122,
-0.5065118074,
0.9798516035,
0.3766657412,
0.0525377244,
0.2416339815,
-0.6813503504,
-0.731895268,
-0.0348593816,
0.3559567034,
0.3215657473,
-0.4043572247,
0.1893689483,
-0.3645039797,
0.4592638016,
-0.6942888498,
0.3687306046,
-0.3269349933,
-0.1600421369,
0.237402603,
-0.3225738406,
0.5648329854,
0.0866075456,
-0.4709061682,
-0.2900016904,
-0.6709221601,
0.0331853926,
0.4146430194,
0.7075386643,
-0.4818208218,
0.7771267295,
0.2378630191,
0.7009372115,
0.0460718349,
0.0855579972,
0.4768046141,
-0.1689041257,
-0.2609827816,
0.3172345757,
0.7097389102,
0.070935227,
0.4676409364,
-0.3383488655,
-0.1335395277,
0.3397602141,
-0.0659482405,
-0.3169068992,
-0.2232865393,
0.4101706147,
-0.2784113884,
-0.1547419429,
-0.2374380529,
-0.4283259511,
-0.2207421809,
-0.1632734686,
0.2788607776,
-0.7178193927,
-0.4529793262,
0.1553902924,
-0.5846899152,
0.5945762992,
0.0060666162,
-0.9236747622,
0.1683265418,
0.7762861848,
0.957445085,
-0.018521741,
-0.4467306733,
-0.5512620211,
0.2977257967,
-0.7290079594,
0.6425925493,
-0.9039821625,
-0.2781313658,
-0.0275017787,
-0.3441469371,
-0.2622683048,
-0.8202879429,
0.5538716316,
-0.457547754,
-0.0119120069,
0.1989234686,
-0.6043102145,
-0.0946611762,
0.0078886766,
-0.4842900336,
0.6414877772,
-0.1153035238,
-0.5444415212,
0.4701545238,
-0.6646949649,
-0.2772917747,
0.2825390399,
-0.2888964117,
0.0194679201,
0.2926850617,
0.1913594455,
0.0367064103,
-0.0169473439,
0.2538544834,
-0.3149181902,
-0.4553591013,
-0.1076557413,
-0.1984013915,
1.0136812925,
0.3691369295,
-0.2997335196,
0.0794287026,
-0.8297273517,
-0.0277696177,
-0.0599156953,
-0.2396619469,
-0.7532462478,
-0.2285498828,
0.0012620931,
-0.0633823499,
0.1389788836,
-0.8267248273,
0.1959671974,
-0.6295765638,
0.3870278001,
0.4515669644,
-0.483492136,
0.6418943405,
0.0632467642,
0.4303320944,
0.2492662519,
0.0027320967,
-0.5447642803,
-0.6089975238,
-0.501083374,
-0.3370270133,
0.8013857603,
0.8049438596,
-0.5630881786,
0.3871700168,
-0.2957540751,
-0.4095926881,
-0.9873495698,
0.1226613075,
0.5659723282,
0.4272260666,
0.1533818543,
-0.547015667,
-0.4462333918,
-1.0113193989,
-0.4253184795,
-0.4688912034,
-0.3406295478,
0.1487713009,
-0.0706724897,
-0.0116697866,
0.9639315009,
-0.1734163761,
-0.3251669109,
-0.047801435,
0.3444384634,
0.1820308119,
0.4864154756,
0.5242488384,
-0.7844071388,
-0.4406126142,
0.0992334485,
-0.5538383722,
-0.3605994284,
0.3711791337,
0.4911511838,
-0.021633856,
0.7362039089,
-0.3249340951,
0.2225125581,
0.8880810142,
-0.1694249064,
0.2418547273,
0.0972625315,
-0.2920503616,
-0.9199832082,
0.2306292504,
-0.2166346908,
0.1919267476,
-0.759798944,
0.0790701061,
0.3153341711,
-0.7212640643,
-0.8421617746,
0.9143089652,
-0.5610793829,
-0.1468517035,
-0.3998309374,
0.1041379943,
-0.0355556682,
0.4527184665,
0.2665616274,
0.9628661275,
0.8377111554,
-0.6012038589,
-0.2345730066,
0.2735590637,
-0.2907262444,
0.4818584919,
-0.7411858439,
0.3285958469,
-0.1733162403,
-0.0042532859,
-1.3109989166,
0.0363184176,
0.2480294406,
-0.7782350183,
0.2966881692,
-0.5071329474,
-0.1194011495,
0.0041623707,
-0.1324964166,
0.7029836178,
0.2682197094,
-0.6765052676,
0.7539086938,
0.4977241457,
-0.3584638536,
-0.9128488898,
-0.6894491911,
0.2219762802,
-0.0368689746,
-0.4930029213,
0.3738147914,
0.1646037251,
-0.4731415212,
-0.0313992836,
-0.06772089,
-0.2113091946,
-0.1493473649,
0.5217494965,
0.0893211588,
-0.4042631686,
0.3023064435,
-0.0938470364,
0.0123958224,
-0.4408709109,
-0.5119161606,
0.7589948773,
-0.2352117598,
-0.2771398425,
-0.1983138323,
0.3522033095,
0.7471122742,
-0.4823359549,
0.2338383198,
0.4806679189,
-0.199340418,
0.140268147,
-0.4761882126,
0.1626002789,
-0.4665397704,
0.0240070131,
-0.6339263916,
-0.8246740699,
0.721519649,
-0.1919091493,
0.2418219298,
0.1925839931,
0.1583862007,
-0.0155174993,
0.842520237,
0.8322222233,
-0.4339044988,
0.3845404088,
0.1914357543,
0.1378840357,
-0.6475051641,
0.0271654297,
-0.7753457427,
-0.4142351747,
-0.6620126963,
-0.336646378,
0.1362409741,
0.2476564944,
-0.0719119757,
0.3561822772,
-0.2860044241,
0.4973337352,
0.7224352956,
-0.4131591022,
0.0382550173,
-0.0622604489,
-0.7860314846,
0.017968813,
-0.4610600173,
-0.2963087559,
0.9308741093,
0.3857085109,
0.7776904106,
-0.0966686532,
0.7946124077,
0.0610829256,
-0.0696231052,
-1.0341073275,
0.3320676088,
-0.3917973936,
-0.6513562202,
-0.2479926944,
0.1078012586,
-1.0518574715,
0.2328493297,
0.2042657137,
-0.802280724,
0.6680834889,
0.2162403017,
-0.3304006159,
0.3355008364,
-0.8474498391,
0.5758307576,
-0.2506378293,
-0.1525343657,
0.0794459581,
-0.7569630146,
0.304115206,
0.1021529809,
0.183050856,
-0.1289343387,
-0.4496348798,
0.6543945074,
-0.1231529862,
1.0723245144,
-0.2967649996,
-0.3528511524,
0.1887649745,
0.1876831353,
0.0657651648,
-0.402513355,
-0.0952449888,
0.7154442072,
-0.3598279357,
-0.4146282673,
-0.3809762597,
0.5517696738,
-0.5411670804,
-0.5374046564,
-0.1920855641,
-0.5942355394,
-0.3009182811,
0.4837126434,
0.2607419193,
-0.0125056012,
-0.3698460162,
0.0354670882,
0.4719415605,
-0.3159180284,
0.553645432,
0.7312453389,
-0.4207920134,
-0.5639930964,
0.9826883078,
0.0818177611,
-0.0027556329,
0.5249177217,
0.3093433976,
-0.325689435,
-0.5886391997,
-0.3796842992,
0.2683935463,
-0.3602441549,
0.1087349951,
-0.6189729571,
0.0849455744,
-0.7266272902,
-0.1608088017,
-0.655738771,
-0.759419024,
-0.045041725,
0.0248181373,
-0.0493587144,
0.4584841728,
-0.4948607981,
0.4275056422,
-0.8078724742,
0.4783650041,
0.3140183985,
0.6513772011,
-0.1985590309,
-0.4791870117,
0.1280812621,
-0.1106008589,
-0.2437671572,
-0.7577987909,
0.5084527731,
0.4248147905,
0.3988857567,
0.6573117375,
0.1093478873,
0.576357007,
-0.679638207,
0.8663255572,
0.3341327608,
-1.1284126043,
0.5648155808,
-0.3605974019,
0.5244262815,
0.4992289841,
0.582421124,
-0.7337292433,
-0.6053701043,
-0.6086570621,
-1.0949677229,
0.3534153998,
-0.1419596225,
0.1390987933,
-0.1206606701,
0.0532262586,
0.3369900286,
0.2448936105,
-0.4955997169,
-0.1565615237,
-0.3815786541,
-0.0477913581,
-0.115436703,
-0.0167613477,
-0.2449558973,
-0.093795307,
0.3171898127,
-0.1250399053,
0.2120574415,
0.1629271954,
-0.0643285811,
-0.0825343579,
0.6161151528,
0.5962375402,
0.4934190512,
-0.2698696852,
0.331965059,
-0.3689633906,
-0.5150997639,
0.1069051474,
0.1496092081,
-0.1825037152,
0.3304859102,
0.2185558677,
0.9042987227,
0.2490011305,
-0.6683008671,
0.4508196414,
0.0941800401,
-0.2292724997,
-0.1875103712,
-0.0433438756,
0.2713724375,
0.088835448,
0.4833398461,
0.030984344,
0.0663211793,
-0.6548457742,
0.3751176596,
0.5076175332,
-0.6279265881,
-0.5077376366,
0.7580518723,
0.1012806594,
-0.4763193429,
0.5778157115,
0.2403310537,
-0.3996281624,
0.4367116392,
0.7102635503,
1.0224636793,
-0.6670036912,
-0.01459774,
0.1110716611,
0.2280896008,
0.3639331162,
0.4436804056,
-0.3604346812,
-1.0586515665,
-0.1739475876,
-0.42714715,
-0.739456296,
0.3545958698,
-0.7352190614,
0.2253682911,
-0.3191569746,
0.0483501405,
0.4225524962,
-0.5705476999,
-0.6364156008,
0.0408844836,
0.2759788632,
1.2056480646,
-1.0441610813,
0.9107643366,
0.8182889819,
-0.2030849308,
-0.9142237902,
0.1958098114,
-0.010854343,
-1.3065632582,
0.7222121954,
0.0564855859,
-0.0047650374,
-0.1315906197,
-0.7087570429,
-0.7267366648,
0.5016102195,
0.4744946659,
-0.6622294188,
-0.033806406,
0.2183374763,
0.5022987127,
-0.1776983589,
0.0785500407,
0.4546461701,
0.4066276848,
0.0403452553,
-1.3819433451,
-0.539691925,
-0.3812541068,
-0.2577130497,
0.2621809542,
-0.6639937162,
0.8904387951,
-0.1485734433,
-0.3259408176,
-0.0952148959,
0.5898032188,
0.2662071586,
0.4125238061,
0.4320378304,
0.8737453818,
0.6122235656,
0.0703453943,
0.7394631505,
-0.3242684603,
-0.3312782943,
1.398743391,
-0.6743029356,
1.1381726265,
0.7217211723,
0.0332400799,
0.2281138748,
0.249348104,
0.1636825055,
0.5444049835,
0.0968685895,
-0.2665042877,
0.055033803,
-0.4794045687,
-0.3649339676,
1.1352164745,
0.4625849128,
-0.3549449444,
-0.2916841507,
0.2677122056,
-0.1963627338,
-0.0418965667,
-0.3197671771,
0.7623364329,
0.1677822173,
-0.7131823301,
0.963581264,
-0.2572088838,
0.9568493366,
-0.584482491,
-0.125835374,
-0.2356380522,
0.0849442407,
-0.0084460676,
-0.8768305182,
0.1461461782,
-0.1081184149,
-0.017297795,
-0.0575629771,
0.749961555,
-0.5077378154,
-0.0138782216,
0.6129046082,
0.6043911576,
0.4116795063,
-0.0273774955,
-0.5632209778,
0.1356186569,
-0.0781983435,
0.0420561731,
0.2977313995,
0.2557244003,
0.0988753736,
0.4771777093,
0.4334840775,
0.3029670417,
0.3072067797,
0.2310184389,
0.5807048678,
-0.6520937681,
-0.8488821983,
-0.4699302018,
0.1937001944,
0.4046141803,
-0.2744936049,
0.567679882,
0.762802422,
1.0709491968,
-0.1409969181,
0.8159872293,
0.2067076266,
0.5710276365,
-0.2899327278,
0.6161084175,
-0.5957793593,
-0.0354883112,
-0.2853915691,
-0.8222503066,
-0.4910113513,
0.2396627069,
-0.0657289326,
-0.5094730258,
0.2826090455,
0.6968616247,
-0.3446037471,
0.0549192354,
0.5837399364,
-0.0470672771,
0.0789984688,
0.1928216219,
0.5522975922,
-0.4458572865,
0.6398351192,
-0.1772243977,
-0.2819755971,
0.1793902218,
-0.730302453,
-0.4376938939,
-0.6780324578,
-0.1944952011,
-0.0893178508,
0.1488297135,
0.6050480008,
0.6464706659,
-0.9553861618,
-0.5697805285,
0.0083260862,
-0.0164748225,
-0.2818976939,
-0.286444217,
0.3225740492,
-0.3734436035,
-0.9460479021,
1.0292270184,
0.5209476352,
0.3450159729,
0.2587519586,
-0.021330839,
-0.2245368212,
0.0320259146,
0.3073532581,
1.0182975531,
-0.6929972172,
-0.1398069113,
0.1350903958,
0.2272460908,
0.4316218495,
0.9867863059,
-0.7176244855,
0.7077595592,
0.4083484113,
0.6715527177,
0.1874034554,
-0.2103850991,
0.8630473018,
-0.9960538745,
0.5551795363,
0.4337443113,
0.4070110321,
0.1342768669,
0.0473722406,
0.5349834561,
-0.1075829268,
-0.2339313775,
-0.8338648677,
0.2323695868,
-1.0716248751,
-0.4094527066,
0.8387426734,
-0.1694133282,
-0.2693497241,
-0.4274289906,
0.1850998551,
0.4679136574,
-0.4372205138,
0.5101629496,
0.7152824402,
-0.1426028609,
-0.2288557589,
-0.0992606804,
0.242343545,
0.7677839994,
-0.0944808647,
0.1512562782,
0.0996851921,
0.2939701676,
0.7633906603,
0.6336325407,
-0.4610492885,
0.2817232311,
0.3748061359,
0.4387944341,
-0.0458270758,
-0.4591156542,
-0.7558604479,
0.3952593803,
0.2436368167,
-0.8008588552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09252v1
|
In the Red(dit): Social Media and Stock Prices
| 2023-11-14T16:58:41 | 2023-11-14T16:58:41 |
James Baker
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CE, cs.CL
|
Spearheaded by retail traders on the website reddit, the GameStop short
squeeze of early 2021 shows that social media embeds information that
correlates with market movements. This paper seeks to examine this relationship
by using daily frequencies of classified comments and buzzwords as additional
factors in a Fama-French three factor model. Comments are classified using an
unsupervised clustering method, while past studies have used pretrained models
that are not specific to the domains being studied.
|
[
-0.4475810528,
-0.8942810297,
0.4867482185,
0.3839947879,
-0.4250043333,
0.3460463881,
0.0854048133,
-0.5045220852,
0.490812242,
0.0359891318,
-0.482316494,
-0.2989837825,
-0.7433665991,
0.0022289073,
-0.7989600301,
0.815119803,
0.1009606197,
-0.1340623051,
0.1013066992,
0.0021056104,
-0.0740291774,
-0.9522120953,
-0.5510896444,
-0.1398200244,
0.3003345728,
0.2144553214,
0.758415699,
0.1786112785,
0.8715210557,
0.3280756176,
0.0856560394,
-0.1458741277,
-0.4190835655,
-0.021529058,
0.0611929782,
-0.2878349721,
-0.0932881236,
0.2188267857,
0.1288287342,
0.3563499153,
-0.0469870679,
0.1921511292,
0.186239019,
0.6920650601,
-0.5820047855,
0.5129133463,
-0.4405898452,
-0.3623560965,
-0.1652781069,
-0.3900905848,
0.0125794522,
-0.8635489941,
-0.0475483686,
-0.4940932691,
0.3342031538,
-0.1839255244,
1.169762373,
0.1153074279,
-0.3401570916,
-0.2489189208,
-0.716715157,
0.750649631,
-0.2179535329,
0.3436426818,
0.5490493178,
0.2578601241,
-0.0831056163,
-0.438310951,
-0.5897096395,
0.2924726903,
-0.1734441519,
-0.1039448977,
-0.8398807049,
-0.5554251075,
0.0503937751,
0.3209618032,
0.0188503172,
-0.5789142847,
-0.6173419356,
0.4702097178,
0.8863437772,
-0.0876853094,
0.2930674255,
0.0354148597,
-0.5647607446,
0.0092800083,
-0.5224170089,
-0.4556700587,
0.5018253326,
0.4044007957,
-0.2662672698,
0.6292057633,
-0.0532438569,
0.5385299325,
0.2313180715,
-0.1178641766,
0.4057462215,
-0.5173330307,
-0.1209491268,
-0.2286476195,
0.6735911369,
0.9494495988,
0.6155438423,
0.1072350964,
-0.0406354517,
0.3955376148,
0.1693189293,
-0.5477753878,
-0.5490669608,
-0.0404698998,
-0.6634856462,
-0.1045787334,
0.6827321053,
-0.8408636451,
-0.460711956,
-0.0627943277,
0.3901517689,
0.0811802298,
-0.4372010231,
0.1958209276,
-0.4213772118,
-0.2034329176,
0.421297133,
-0.5253019929,
0.5191629529,
0.5318617225,
1.0130383968,
-0.1132770032,
0.0926784649,
-0.0935381055,
0.3763567507,
-0.3872376978,
1.0202848911,
-0.4127784669,
-0.6685382128,
0.3579811454,
0.3737481833,
-0.1628703773,
-0.419449389,
-0.0388887189,
-1.1649640799,
-0.0803226456,
-0.5120387077,
-0.4080444574,
-0.3970917761,
0.2326389849,
-0.8709701896,
1.1772623062,
0.0543647669,
-0.9249264598,
0.6563618183,
-1.0942822695,
-0.4404115975,
0.2114887685,
0.1007306948,
0.1639460623,
-0.246312499,
-0.0239271075,
0.6658522487,
-0.1106948704,
-0.4144640565,
-0.4567375779,
-0.5228288174,
0.6316226125,
0.2237619311,
0.5269858837,
0.3264952898,
-0.4829724729,
-0.5169248581,
-0.4047652483,
-0.6161981821,
0.2404047251,
-0.2277775258,
-0.6793443561,
0.1334440559,
0.0869788527,
0.2478060126,
0.2273065448,
-0.5589244366,
0.1928336322,
0.2003807873,
0.7597808838,
0.4520208538,
0.7972863317,
0.2857597768,
-0.3002465069,
0.5485759377,
0.2447279543,
0.3981645107,
0.4998618662,
-0.5712068081,
-0.6844885945,
-0.171130091,
0.034947589,
0.3652108908,
-0.3509911001,
-0.0359035768,
0.0473285057,
-0.4350168705,
-0.011492962,
-0.2121683657,
-0.5772696733,
-0.322514385,
0.2526989281,
0.0179316588,
-0.3415046632,
-0.8318144083,
-0.1152897328,
-0.210504204,
0.1678339243,
0.0773332641,
0.4809730351,
-0.6624945998,
0.7259689569,
-0.8707220554,
-0.3218423426,
-0.100514777,
0.6839367151,
0.4700942934,
-0.1658140272,
0.5449226499,
-0.9489653111,
-0.8471536636,
0.1049523801,
-0.0039772997,
0.2051703483,
0.0452552401,
0.0558624826,
0.2665809989,
0.9028186798,
-0.5238248706,
0.6729435921,
0.6051366329,
-0.3807020485,
-0.198835969,
0.1563864797,
0.5532723665,
-0.8467894793,
-0.1937138438,
0.6025453806,
-0.0908582583,
-0.4847294986,
-0.3586519659,
-0.246152088,
0.0978026912,
-0.5168088675,
0.4735418558,
-0.3936669827,
-0.049297493,
-0.4246941209,
0.1871341169,
-0.2146683186,
0.002986239,
0.0598650984,
0.6972199678,
0.3010993004,
-0.8252541423,
0.1504873037,
0.1139246076,
-0.5817627311,
0.1124503389,
-0.5796232224,
-0.1119540036,
0.1363974065,
-0.0966708586,
-1.3515923023,
-0.2438759059,
0.2027184814,
-0.3631405234,
-0.1476883739,
-0.1150663644,
-0.9236353636,
-0.4161618054,
-0.2414780855,
0.1228680313,
0.2436765879,
-0.226085946,
0.1705033928,
0.8591008782,
-0.2872663438,
-0.2282161415,
-0.7668471932,
-0.4084868729,
-0.2659530342,
-0.2605158985,
0.1957453191,
-0.0695931017,
-0.9084469676,
0.0354891196,
0.0697103217,
-0.1242025644,
0.0585902743,
0.1555724889,
0.1401899159,
0.249956727,
0.2066903263,
-0.6359867454,
0.0450271964,
0.2769229412,
0.3743943274,
0.505979836,
-0.3764592707,
-0.0523585863,
-0.3281618059,
0.4211493433,
0.6717942953,
0.2938248515,
0.7185986042,
0.0521098264,
-0.2287091315,
-0.1005732268,
-0.4035371542,
-0.3832010627,
-0.4972268939,
0.0973625332,
0.1444964111,
-0.8286660314,
0.4472074807,
0.2484761775,
-0.0081235962,
0.7466261983,
0.6262152195,
-0.3757267594,
1.0199676752,
0.9629611373,
0.1847074032,
0.6672298908,
0.0119293267,
0.693988204,
-0.0830539614,
-0.1828700751,
-0.583560288,
-0.6848848462,
-0.7266726494,
-0.5258746147,
0.1063344777,
0.1542245299,
-0.6347910166,
0.4139021933,
-0.4824706614,
0.6537745595,
0.687292397,
0.1131518036,
0.2909991741,
0.0765584484,
0.3767621219,
-0.1692862362,
-0.5336842537,
-0.3949528337,
0.7460418344,
0.4710490108,
0.8712702394,
0.3847949803,
0.3313004375,
0.8012620807,
0.7364609838,
-0.6052856445,
0.5020232797,
-0.3190192878,
-0.7955712676,
0.0447876751,
0.1351245046,
-0.4561246336,
-0.4688092172,
-0.2715409994,
-0.5769563913,
0.7768149972,
-0.0672603026,
-0.4856471419,
0.2954197526,
-0.9121044278,
0.5480656624,
-0.2217532396,
-0.2808331549,
-0.2905274034,
-0.2319246083,
0.1319073588,
-0.1654716432,
0.2958323956,
-0.3856798112,
-0.1111077592,
1.0460051298,
-0.2462847233,
0.9361945391,
0.097790949,
0.2780322134,
0.2748151422,
-0.0107210688,
0.5355494618,
-0.075872317,
0.4678096175,
0.4955335557,
0.1908236742,
-0.2946467996,
-0.2787798643,
0.85330832,
-0.9073075056,
-0.3621556461,
-0.8541743755,
-0.225258559,
-0.246986419,
-0.2700392604,
0.1977154911,
-0.2670667768,
-0.0236337949,
0.3531386256,
0.0576103665,
0.3173375726,
0.7143848538,
0.6529356241,
-0.1993351132,
-0.23505041,
0.6835788488,
0.2437502444,
0.1284958273,
0.2856660783,
0.1227950305,
-0.4955874383,
-0.208600238,
0.4368273914,
0.4448013902,
-0.8233181834,
-0.3143432438,
-0.5766406059,
-0.0593253188,
-0.0588385388,
-0.4401321113,
-0.2119643688,
-0.2545307875,
-0.6335407495,
-0.4485760033,
0.785794735,
1.325222373,
-0.2418587208,
0.5520968437,
-0.6540118456,
0.1219847724,
0.578777492,
0.4550675154,
-0.0805540681,
-0.1624459326,
-0.6335040331,
0.0056053726,
-0.4092405438,
-1.072122097,
0.3124677539,
-0.2983309925,
0.1334415972,
0.475833565,
-0.0219607931,
0.5879378915,
0.084374167,
0.9652508497,
0.4246698618,
-0.6899464726,
0.3654788435,
-0.7077234983,
-0.0275662094,
0.3425468206,
1.1080368757,
-0.3635429442,
-0.1121339127,
-0.8892251253,
-0.7377160192,
0.4766796529,
-0.0148142371,
0.1139753908,
-0.7075917125,
0.0418158583,
-0.0397058278,
0.432207346,
-0.9280580282,
-0.3907904029,
-0.1230696589,
0.1581460088,
0.0426657796,
-0.615599215,
-0.2973089516,
-0.4899869859,
0.5662387013,
0.0623466372,
0.4358080626,
-0.1236010343,
0.2660268545,
-0.2731619477,
-0.0335063562,
0.3953122795,
0.9311391711,
-0.6248113513,
-0.2059859484,
-0.2553043664,
-0.5171949267,
0.023293009,
-0.1123218313,
-0.1977214366,
0.2433805168,
0.1008495763,
0.3845052719,
0.5730652213,
-0.2678194642,
0.6359107494,
-0.0146014206,
-0.6478353143,
-0.4138701558,
-0.2091278136,
0.1240492687,
0.5214828849,
0.70082587,
0.132115528,
-0.0190410614,
-0.9711202383,
0.5174713135,
0.2148039639,
-0.61532408,
-0.4920356572,
0.9048988819,
0.4282285273,
0.0413624495,
0.2852887809,
0.0953824297,
-0.4467079043,
0.3763892651,
0.2686679661,
1.0595836639,
-0.0253436845,
0.4272503555,
0.4951470196,
0.3186461926,
-0.5045491457,
0.5740427971,
0.2411469221,
-0.8979073167,
-0.258715421,
-0.4774684012,
-0.3753279746,
0.14244394,
-0.5026462674,
0.6580398679,
-0.36166206,
-0.8651704788,
0.1090338454,
0.2249693125,
-0.6162797213,
0.3635386825,
0.1011278406,
0.7397667766,
-0.9627040029,
0.5821223855,
0.838547945,
-0.541133821,
-0.3205181658,
0.3989676833,
-0.0633622333,
-0.4483599961,
0.9745035172,
-0.0599720553,
-0.0944419652,
-0.2761538625,
-0.6242904067,
-1.0732685328,
0.6001389623,
-0.0746437684,
-0.5270644426,
0.4695053697,
-0.0630707368,
0.4487253129,
-0.5189480186,
0.027100103,
0.7216939926,
0.424303025,
0.2172820568,
-0.2459183633,
-0.3710691035,
-0.3350475132,
-0.3657950461,
0.547013402,
-0.8595939279,
0.9068434238,
0.0742858723,
-0.6879169345,
-0.5643945932,
0.2918581069,
-0.0960656628,
0.1192542538,
0.6267675161,
0.1161887944,
0.3351540267,
-0.3852418959,
1.1070551872,
-0.6156722903,
0.442363143,
0.5210974216,
-0.2569005489,
1.3203003407,
0.5051960349,
-0.4350885153,
0.6114372611,
0.8514860272,
-0.1528187096,
0.8058982491,
-0.1206088439,
-0.1265662014,
-0.1735084653,
0.1418732554,
-0.4247978628,
0.1750296354,
0.3588927984,
-0.3138593733,
-0.1130554304,
-0.5910404921,
0.1431806237,
0.0954002813,
-0.3549509048,
0.7845129371,
-0.0810181424,
-0.2081569284,
0.257956475,
-0.133179754,
0.6383965611,
-0.6149061322,
0.0671915114,
-0.4634642899,
0.2884502709,
-0.0346621946,
-0.7837631106,
0.814662993,
0.0332956091,
-0.3613542914,
-0.2849988639,
0.4865772724,
-0.2154562324,
-0.7188892961,
0.5758810043,
0.3429484367,
-0.2040907145,
-0.2986278832,
-0.819198072,
0.1122387126,
-0.0085309353,
-0.3639709949,
0.2846290171,
0.1545174718,
-0.1183511615,
0.3894917369,
0.6192802787,
-0.3393547237,
0.0314271301,
-0.0722111389,
0.938400805,
-0.9252203703,
-0.6940797567,
-0.729588151,
0.2756509185,
-0.3443959653,
-0.2598851323,
1.1792556047,
0.2144073248,
0.6103312373,
-0.142265901,
0.8471597433,
-0.0998655707,
0.9331638217,
-0.0702055171,
0.9866873026,
-0.8104104996,
0.1024121195,
-0.3683656752,
-0.9842819571,
-0.4039560854,
0.6634090543,
-0.5945695043,
-0.0527047887,
0.8838908672,
0.6937572956,
0.0398727842,
0.5191708207,
0.0634716228,
0.3879204094,
-0.1739131659,
-0.2384516597,
0.8127105236,
-0.5232141018,
0.247941047,
-0.5707064867,
-0.0025728177,
-0.6778125763,
-0.7983983755,
-1.0143141747,
-0.630554378,
-0.8335814476,
-0.36195907,
0.0601090081,
0.6748864651,
0.5016857386,
-0.9309226274,
-0.3526668251,
0.1351291388,
-0.1433674991,
-0.3946259022,
-0.2900048196,
0.4861634374,
0.1075279638,
-0.694624126,
0.0599555857,
0.5200221539,
0.2672834992,
-0.0760866702,
0.423088342,
-0.7107079029,
0.4734481871,
0.829482615,
0.0718186647,
-0.2544091344,
-0.1825666279,
0.2310877144,
-0.0456591807,
-0.1624136567,
0.7520677447,
-0.3284159005,
0.0427636579,
0.4872478247,
0.1352942586,
0.707077682,
0.6006054282,
0.6509365439,
-0.6208957434,
0.2972125709,
0.0047549135,
0.1322325617,
0.320995748,
-0.2270931154,
0.6843695641,
0.6477423906,
-0.5698952675,
-0.4766782224,
-0.1480896473,
-0.6884298325,
-0.3029272556,
1.3819515705,
0.5075590611,
-0.2927728593,
-0.3662032485,
0.213928327,
-0.3801871836,
-0.6118745208,
0.9492949247,
1.1828290224,
-0.1773201227,
-0.2531147003,
-0.6551291943,
0.5470360518,
-0.3412458599,
-0.4062998891,
-0.0988914743,
0.3739694655,
0.1172300726,
0.1763135493,
0.6260130405,
-0.0601913221,
0.2771417201,
0.108435519,
-0.1898865253,
0.2857332528,
-0.2450360358,
0.2728648484,
0.5214406848,
-0.1341813505,
-0.5684809089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08306v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08306v2
|
On-the-Fly Fusion of Large Language Models and Machine Translation
| 2023-11-14T16:49:33 | 2024-05-06T17:13:27 |
Hieu Hoang, Huda Khayrallah, Marcin Junczys-Dowmunt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose the on-the-fly ensembling of a machine translation model with an
LLM, prompted on the same task and input. We perform experiments on 4 language
pairs (both directions) with varying data amounts. We find that a slightly
weaker-at-translation LLM can improve translations of a NMT model, and
ensembling with an LLM can produce better translations than ensembling two
stronger MT models. We combine our method with various techniques from LLM
prompting, such as in context learning and translation context.
|
[
-0.2516433299,
-0.8148825169,
0.7139496207,
0.049587965,
-0.1943604797,
0.2690035105,
-0.2310039103,
-0.5152229071,
0.4317849278,
0.7822227478,
-0.7634934187,
0.0203593895,
-0.6281718612,
0.3487479985,
-0.8163143992,
0.6643171906,
-0.2292337418,
0.1552319974,
-0.4250791073,
0.016994914,
-0.4368194044,
-0.3093397319,
-0.4853188396,
-0.6311920881,
0.4318390489,
0.4593547583,
0.7146372795,
0.7000365853,
0.6156897545,
0.3597001135,
-0.0664858446,
0.3939739466,
-0.3954845667,
0.405436188,
-0.0992096364,
-0.5788784027,
-0.3695430756,
-0.0422891825,
0.8131257296,
0.8627576232,
0.0589917079,
-0.0614917316,
0.2826061249,
0.4570025802,
-0.3345583975,
-0.463221401,
-0.6471037269,
0.0295219384,
-0.0476242043,
-0.1532343924,
-0.5443922877,
-0.3334394991,
-0.0914016068,
-0.3080548644,
-0.0618968159,
0.1913171858,
0.8015943766,
0.5579184294,
-0.6098278165,
0.0164910592,
-0.7480349541,
0.7178077698,
-0.8646067977,
0.6696463823,
0.3142193556,
0.2368835509,
-0.2456802428,
-0.5998946428,
-0.7072421908,
-0.2750691473,
-0.1844590008,
0.1112777665,
0.1630263478,
-0.0411795639,
0.218573153,
0.1530242413,
-0.6195264459,
0.2267176658,
-0.2378905565,
0.0688419938,
0.5032061338,
0.2576812506,
0.459695369,
-0.072751835,
-0.4668159485,
-0.1814743578,
-1.0723205805,
-0.4294169545,
-0.0657824725,
0.3534466028,
-0.2495936155,
0.9677221775,
-0.1943601519,
1.1271539927,
0.4849053025,
0.0941944718,
0.091868259,
-0.6953657269,
-0.4676535428,
0.2187695354,
0.8048115373,
0.2433631569,
-0.2373343706,
-0.4113357365,
-0.4491817057,
-0.2120866776,
0.0416571125,
-0.452280581,
0.128020674,
0.3474464417,
-0.2810860872,
-0.3075901866,
-0.0713912621,
-0.4120487571,
-0.4857736528,
-0.5471791625,
0.8204281926,
-0.3001366556,
-0.0181043148,
-0.0172465332,
-0.0010045507,
0.5036078095,
0.1489676833,
-0.8581983447,
-0.0087350011,
0.7259696126,
0.9161956906,
-0.1624726951,
-0.5492274165,
-0.8105614185,
0.398361057,
-0.2455272973,
0.7346588969,
-0.4297480881,
-0.3469201326,
-0.0881780162,
-0.1670744866,
-0.2443749756,
-0.5499500036,
0.0077468944,
-0.4957222342,
0.3353216946,
-0.2587293088,
-0.6596173048,
-0.2019171864,
0.5083697438,
-0.6466112733,
0.8654892445,
0.0899574235,
-0.5454777479,
0.1503379196,
-0.6454675794,
-0.5192928314,
0.1352967918,
-0.2258705646,
-0.148217231,
0.1513146013,
0.3844223619,
0.7002624273,
-0.521459043,
0.4634804428,
-0.1767577082,
-0.1190986633,
0.4021202922,
-0.2626616657,
1.0205711126,
0.274266392,
-0.1097515523,
0.1534565091,
-0.4467463195,
-0.1662946045,
0.1779272407,
-0.6078961492,
-0.1148812622,
-0.1854274571,
-0.1506261528,
0.1471859217,
0.5190080404,
-0.3427711427,
0.5576177835,
-0.7359205484,
0.4815282822,
0.3207994998,
-0.0049537621,
0.7804577947,
-0.4017507136,
0.4794397652,
-0.2775612473,
-0.1703872979,
-0.088035576,
-0.4893925488,
-0.92291224,
-0.1063072607,
0.4495813847,
0.7169476151,
-1.1263544559,
0.41239959,
-0.375873059,
-0.3725239038,
-0.7453641295,
0.2093667388,
0.4349223077,
0.2993573844,
0.2085750252,
-0.1135215238,
-0.7337986231,
-0.7481302023,
-0.3496489823,
0.0183840618,
-0.2857708335,
0.0067206901,
0.261192739,
-0.5493562818,
0.9958103299,
-0.2136303484,
0.0315320231,
-0.4271028936,
0.1704871058,
0.0899875909,
0.5044835806,
0.2193708122,
-0.7638076544,
-0.6771134138,
0.2899174392,
-0.82089293,
-0.1966757923,
-0.0891072899,
-0.1600714326,
0.1327363849,
0.8609618545,
-0.7453513741,
-0.0077476115,
0.7392454743,
-0.1774011701,
0.1586579382,
-0.3299721777,
0.5122945309,
-1.6398040056,
0.005316786,
-0.3454934955,
-0.3323791325,
-0.9033017159,
0.4496304393,
0.3327645361,
-0.1093160212,
-0.9142560363,
0.5084970593,
-0.6351538897,
-0.1840226203,
-0.3343444467,
0.2837940454,
-0.1232515797,
0.0995050967,
-0.0156506766,
0.5332759619,
0.4609874487,
-0.7019887567,
0.615045011,
0.2847122252,
-0.3641832769,
0.2404394895,
-0.4572103322,
0.2202842534,
0.039115455,
0.2344308943,
-1.0143722296,
-0.7654652596,
0.2460278571,
-0.4702076316,
0.4757097363,
0.0787137672,
-0.7642424703,
-0.232539475,
0.0754522532,
0.53397578,
0.4696806669,
-0.7789187431,
0.8224281669,
0.2863010466,
0.0513190553,
-0.1484237164,
-0.8925819993,
0.220246464,
-0.3765102923,
-0.816385448,
0.592048943,
-0.0057417438,
-0.4064535499,
-0.1408052444,
0.3055952191,
0.0023810228,
0.1157545298,
0.2249561101,
0.3601121008,
-0.1500997841,
0.0416086204,
-0.0044879345,
-0.0379982628,
-0.2106456757,
-0.1451238245,
0.7633830309,
0.0651847348,
-0.4454911649,
-0.2149403542,
0.3455202579,
0.5840774179,
-0.2287411094,
0.9747849703,
0.4070560038,
-0.4603162408,
0.096913904,
-0.4464563429,
-0.5611487031,
-0.5623076558,
0.0235027354,
-0.4283760488,
-0.8719430566,
0.5314355493,
-0.1726255417,
0.1874179244,
0.4883167446,
0.6609568596,
-0.2637645304,
1.2907596827,
0.8931336403,
-0.1638265401,
0.3937558532,
-0.0580201931,
0.2158082277,
-0.7938097715,
-0.0844023004,
-0.5238444805,
-0.5901412964,
-0.3084094226,
-0.5628071427,
0.3960805237,
0.1649402529,
-0.0686316639,
0.6576272249,
-0.4584562182,
0.6925253272,
0.4729976654,
0.191382423,
0.2958179116,
-0.0803382173,
-0.2704667747,
0.2703842521,
-0.9633256197,
-0.1315358132,
0.9911805391,
0.1225419417,
0.6322458982,
0.0804707035,
0.8405398726,
-0.2402413487,
0.3488212526,
-0.8216865063,
0.761223197,
0.0455786549,
-0.4668771029,
-0.3024826646,
-0.455729872,
-0.9939491749,
0.2000058144,
-0.3812636137,
-0.4980491996,
-0.3673621118,
0.1589897871,
-0.4507651031,
0.1971410066,
-0.4753704667,
0.6550670862,
-0.4768101573,
0.0430732071,
-0.2435912192,
-0.8135103583,
0.656883955,
-0.2829481959,
0.1652392745,
0.225713253,
-0.2323661149,
0.6326130033,
-0.3157221973,
0.8155341744,
0.3192846179,
-0.318130374,
0.1070226207,
0.4093689322,
0.7694398165,
-0.5006511211,
-0.050391499,
-0.0111615527,
-0.591057837,
0.0176594537,
-0.6834867001,
0.8823607564,
-0.6037840247,
-0.7218544483,
-0.0068411818,
-0.7395986915,
-0.1803343147,
0.1256137639,
0.5192471147,
0.2534090877,
-0.0000941967,
0.2700769305,
0.6625374556,
-0.071721971,
0.451328963,
0.6514308453,
-0.5698497891,
-0.3963032961,
0.9655277133,
0.1649385691,
0.601134181,
0.6635939479,
0.2312340885,
-0.263705194,
-0.3084624112,
-0.6333059072,
0.3476806879,
-0.6473529935,
-0.182818979,
-0.7526509762,
-0.1445199251,
-0.4996739626,
-0.6159043908,
-0.3601821363,
-0.4484140575,
-0.0950950682,
0.1559399962,
0.4255903363,
0.8446480632,
0.0353580154,
0.4968775511,
-1.2776427269,
0.112502858,
0.2628112137,
-0.0179470107,
-0.2063289732,
-0.8116365075,
-0.4154400229,
0.2683146596,
-0.2496603429,
-1.0672012568,
0.5375695229,
0.0847343355,
0.5240417123,
0.4068124294,
-0.1260659993,
0.6230113506,
-0.5576633215,
0.9142103791,
0.3580898046,
-0.8959963322,
0.6998315454,
-0.469879508,
0.6521083713,
0.2739180923,
0.5036038756,
-0.7324319482,
-0.674926579,
-0.4137737751,
-0.7888062,
0.6716926098,
-0.0256571285,
-0.3290798962,
0.1413348466,
0.2087363899,
0.0239455644,
-0.0209791511,
-0.5575797558,
0.0237038285,
0.4119533896,
-0.3748384416,
-0.4011377394,
0.1941298246,
-0.1314021349,
-0.3449679315,
0.6650554538,
-0.0154718868,
0.2351747006,
-0.226985991,
-0.4820679724,
-0.3622835875,
-0.1521889567,
0.5610594153,
0.2849975228,
0.0999024883,
0.1989049017,
0.551294744,
0.0122282747,
0.1792684495,
-0.3675891459,
-0.3477157056,
-0.0797828063,
0.2752347887,
0.6970079541,
0.5130419135,
-0.6012558341,
0.1248195022,
0.2805289626,
-0.3923768103,
0.1609343588,
-0.0130663579,
0.3880537152,
0.2857062519,
0.0735074133,
0.0051743127,
-0.0903525352,
-0.5139785409,
0.2460179925,
0.4866069257,
-0.2332120687,
-0.1632653475,
0.7991598845,
0.3454963863,
-0.5142015219,
0.6385596991,
0.0567637421,
-0.7460240722,
0.609464705,
0.7494966984,
0.9168204665,
-0.4942632318,
-0.0389100425,
0.2979647219,
0.3876930177,
-0.4708309472,
-0.0349548571,
-0.002391957,
-0.7968544364,
-0.7477754354,
-0.4958238006,
-0.6880423427,
0.0371910445,
-0.3591660559,
0.4401900172,
0.0053578219,
0.0897452459,
-0.0520511754,
-0.2765311599,
-0.5822163224,
0.0153135685,
0.2322525829,
0.7257720828,
-0.8109545708,
1.0187417269,
0.8194690943,
-0.3371478617,
-0.8132171631,
0.059503749,
0.310915947,
-0.8375086188,
0.6858513355,
0.1906850636,
-0.0645804331,
0.2996174693,
-0.69448632,
-1.199326992,
1.0434755087,
0.5613780022,
-0.5746998787,
0.1524944007,
0.3019501567,
0.1120679751,
-0.3873634338,
-0.0291529577,
0.6423227787,
0.5450182557,
0.1429614127,
-1.3157769442,
0.0900801793,
0.0692541823,
-0.2957318723,
0.5884102583,
-0.5491749048,
0.8807267547,
-0.1503010392,
-0.4111710787,
-0.1446545869,
0.5848885775,
0.0447479375,
-0.0389921106,
0.4512413442,
0.4917074442,
0.6459453702,
0.0884826705,
1.0030645132,
-0.3531900346,
0.1722621322,
1.1877679825,
-0.4563955367,
1.1958312988,
0.6259669065,
-0.0429633521,
-0.0412758775,
0.7336779237,
0.2048936933,
0.5023382902,
-0.1297800988,
-0.3501997888,
-0.4311335683,
0.0462814495,
-0.3592032194,
0.3693929613,
0.4179913998,
-0.2434108704,
-0.1993386,
0.498635143,
-0.1810849011,
-0.1092409864,
-0.3218087256,
0.8580200672,
0.2215929478,
-1.1092710495,
0.7837273479,
0.2166331112,
0.7412435412,
-0.4024455845,
0.2670360208,
-0.2109147012,
0.1166346446,
-0.0983387828,
-0.7918521762,
0.5240319967,
-0.0849892572,
-0.1456839442,
-0.6189545989,
0.9267266989,
-1.0423656702,
-0.4721296132,
0.3192253113,
0.7312379479,
0.411952734,
0.006324592,
-0.4554646909,
0.1109079048,
0.1825040728,
-0.3653575778,
0.5600670576,
0.1973366737,
0.113322936,
0.8686554432,
0.5167882442,
-0.1778193116,
0.2480458021,
-0.1537897289,
0.8076702356,
-0.6870724559,
-0.3195242584,
-1.1235095263,
0.5554175973,
0.2040807903,
0.1335096359,
0.9870826006,
0.428198576,
0.8408838511,
-0.122191146,
0.6688411832,
-0.0855133161,
0.3977330923,
-0.6106655002,
0.8123205304,
-0.8242483735,
0.0051227347,
0.1914557815,
-1.0542491674,
-0.4362006485,
0.4858313501,
-0.0364629552,
-0.3621116877,
0.6624813676,
0.993593514,
-0.086063996,
-0.105777815,
0.5903962851,
0.1586987525,
0.1051784083,
0.7050604224,
0.680136919,
-0.4016053379,
0.4140910506,
0.1733613759,
-0.0955037177,
-0.5571635365,
-0.9030699134,
-0.8308947682,
-0.6666358709,
-0.2787589431,
-0.4394432306,
-0.2557220757,
1.296510458,
0.3522753417,
-0.6118181348,
-0.3778754473,
-0.0257913079,
0.1599866748,
-0.2860074937,
-0.064653486,
-0.0611228198,
-0.2692317367,
-0.8691504598,
1.0858705044,
0.2250970155,
0.3878044486,
-0.433647424,
-0.4391884208,
-0.2804937959,
0.2673261762,
0.5860124826,
0.1933193505,
-0.7530018091,
-0.1552333981,
-0.0118887099,
-0.3068993986,
-0.1509698033,
0.846591711,
-0.777294755,
0.4572071433,
0.8673087358,
0.9038053155,
0.3503832221,
-0.1254904717,
1.043566227,
-0.7425918579,
0.1060758531,
0.0431040786,
0.3388159275,
0.2268697321,
-0.3569687307,
0.4830409586,
0.142311126,
-0.5536084771,
-0.9669376612,
0.2550570965,
-0.7558561563,
-0.1498651356,
1.2845107317,
0.2043538988,
-0.304361701,
0.0915282667,
-0.0705875009,
0.4874958396,
0.040691141,
0.4086343348,
0.7552376986,
0.0486895181,
-0.0683921203,
-0.4666109383,
0.3058978617,
0.5819595456,
-0.7842491269,
0.0000201735,
0.2115200609,
-0.0395937711,
0.0391895361,
0.2917734087,
0.2877483368,
0.1702938676,
0.1630927026,
0.0978691205,
0.0122731728,
-0.3747448325,
-0.5461224914,
-0.0392273851,
-0.1207341328,
-0.1184174046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08303v1
|
Extrinsically-Focused Evaluation of Omissions in Medical Summarization
| 2023-11-14T16:46:15 | 2023-11-14T16:46:15 |
Elliot Schumacher, Daniel Rosenthal, Varun Nair, Luladay Price, Geoffrey Tso, Anitha Kannan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The goal of automated summarization techniques (Paice, 1990; Kupiec et al,
1995) is to condense text by focusing on the most critical information.
Generative large language models (LLMs) have shown to be robust summarizers,
yet traditional metrics struggle to capture resulting performance (Goyal et al,
2022) in more powerful LLMs. In safety-critical domains such as medicine, more
rigorous evaluation is required, especially given the potential for LLMs to
omit important information in the resulting summary. We propose MED-OMIT, a new
omission benchmark for medical summarization. Given a doctor-patient
conversation and a generated summary, MED-OMIT categorizes the chat into a set
of facts and identifies which are omitted from the summary. We further propose
to determine fact importance by simulating the impact of each fact on a
downstream clinical task: differential diagnosis (DDx) generation. MED-OMIT
leverages LLM prompt-based approaches which categorize the importance of facts
and cluster them as supporting or negating evidence to the diagnosis. We
evaluate MED-OMIT on a publicly-released dataset of patient-doctor
conversations and find that MED-OMIT captures omissions better than alternative
metrics.
|
[
-0.5318117142,
-0.5595213771,
0.8803195357,
0.0621120743,
-0.4115984738,
-0.2218913585,
-0.1955422014,
-0.2716374993,
0.2948212028,
0.3725760281,
-0.4750108719,
-0.5826247931,
-0.8258895278,
0.3116901517,
-0.2779215872,
1.299844265,
-0.286362499,
-0.0538731888,
-0.3856818676,
-0.3481021821,
-0.1875625849,
-0.4462149143,
-0.5164480209,
-0.2761557996,
0.6305696368,
0.2439050078,
0.4813381135,
0.8532906175,
0.9526632428,
0.1772449762,
-0.3117591739,
0.288097024,
-0.4377338588,
0.0134911025,
-0.1656464487,
-0.0618741326,
-0.8480076194,
0.0272880439,
0.6401248574,
1.2574591637,
-0.1079981104,
0.4057848155,
-0.0115340715,
0.7317172289,
-0.8088816404,
0.2699556053,
-0.1299716532,
0.2624285221,
0.1258701831,
-0.2680750787,
-0.1391507834,
-0.7757663131,
0.1515274942,
-0.1312312037,
0.2422039062,
-0.1429573148,
0.9094648957,
0.574441433,
-0.247660026,
-0.1502937824,
-0.6957347989,
0.3541224301,
-0.6746420264,
0.0369321629,
0.4426395595,
0.2938532233,
-0.1230032817,
-0.6272269487,
-0.2518120408,
0.0091778301,
-0.1939463168,
0.55740273,
-0.2451914251,
0.3108949065,
0.306814611,
0.6925079226,
-0.1907579899,
-0.0930408761,
-0.5173972845,
0.0306292623,
0.4094431996,
0.5955371261,
0.3002384901,
-0.1203523949,
-0.025895685,
0.2401251942,
-1.1193454266,
-0.201420173,
-0.2442692965,
-0.1393507123,
-0.3605338633,
0.9826555848,
0.0043528285,
0.3349077106,
-0.0103922086,
-0.317320466,
0.5563539267,
-0.6113931537,
-0.2343430668,
0.0311433244,
0.8778408766,
0.7840697765,
0.0356239527,
-0.2027511299,
0.0125464629,
-0.0204860512,
0.1050612628,
-0.8139016032,
-0.3246644735,
0.3396739066,
-0.8653194308,
-0.3544579148,
-0.2807771862,
-0.5992596745,
-0.4703964889,
-0.1859939992,
0.2190877646,
-0.2703466415,
-0.1018614322,
-0.1214752495,
-0.2594604194,
-0.1771577746,
0.5398221016,
-0.4037144482,
0.5105454326,
0.3963869512,
0.7598410249,
-0.1784441769,
-0.2919901311,
-0.8249597549,
0.147121042,
-0.5197547674,
0.7455465794,
-0.1913704127,
-0.6888652444,
-0.2668863833,
-0.0015594398,
-0.2700863481,
-0.7643697858,
0.8384951353,
0.1695732921,
0.3126853406,
-0.3640313745,
-0.6977031827,
-0.5157781243,
0.1595154554,
-0.453651011,
0.508151412,
0.3041002154,
-0.5260150433,
0.7191132903,
-0.467020601,
-0.7359063029,
-0.1138089225,
-0.4678589106,
-0.7117697597,
0.3406887352,
0.2567260861,
0.4697469175,
-0.6886480451,
0.5075784326,
-0.2604853511,
-0.347658217,
-0.0931739137,
-0.4799637496,
0.4821241498,
-0.0217608325,
-0.3473484814,
-0.1607439369,
-1.1643654108,
-0.0063344659,
0.028033413,
-0.5383303761,
-0.4122562706,
0.1248860732,
-0.1250325888,
0.3353303671,
-0.2709779441,
-0.6381002665,
-0.153740719,
-0.7945200205,
0.1801544428,
0.3992781043,
0.4770744443,
0.159860298,
-0.6457291245,
0.5054938197,
0.0062629473,
0.2966368198,
-0.395013988,
-0.4934130907,
-0.5936713219,
-1.0249023438,
0.1399357468,
0.309273392,
-0.3701272607,
0.7454033494,
-0.2928307056,
-0.4041744769,
-0.5359690189,
-0.3303415179,
0.5253566504,
0.8763414025,
0.3203700781,
-0.2729648054,
-0.5544679165,
-0.8139590025,
-0.325335741,
-0.0173952244,
-0.0504001454,
0.0404850915,
0.4771231115,
-0.3148272634,
0.8697838783,
-0.7266350985,
-0.3791975379,
-0.2322594821,
0.0673284903,
0.3685908616,
0.3534239233,
0.593331337,
-0.3845696151,
-0.1886403114,
-0.1479161829,
-1.0200340748,
-0.2422102243,
0.103479147,
0.3360114992,
0.11832463,
0.4738649428,
-0.7051939964,
0.9789140821,
0.2955217063,
-0.0437164977,
0.4988743365,
-0.540043056,
0.3587921858,
-0.8816027045,
0.5362973213,
-0.1236337274,
-0.2798706293,
-0.4635540247,
-0.218839407,
0.3193991482,
-0.1829942614,
-0.3254124224,
0.4722829759,
-0.472004354,
0.1548752636,
0.1419991553,
0.2363527715,
0.2526577115,
0.3099516332,
-0.0162814464,
0.4718840718,
0.3094850183,
-0.9072374105,
-0.1349625587,
0.3384557962,
-0.1634440571,
0.4369265139,
-0.6638036966,
-0.33885324,
-0.3654282689,
0.1370883286,
-1.1548839808,
-0.2089632154,
0.4202596247,
-0.1859209239,
0.1915318519,
-0.1910444945,
-0.371237427,
-0.4268449843,
-0.456279397,
0.4797367752,
0.6012075543,
-0.2347131968,
0.5920764208,
0.4229178727,
-0.6002532244,
-0.3191721737,
-0.559809804,
0.1133607179,
-0.1468715966,
-0.1072133705,
0.1648195237,
-0.1832821071,
-0.3309203982,
0.010698841,
-0.197670728,
-0.1520316303,
0.0934149399,
0.5715597272,
0.4368085265,
-0.0869223475,
0.248777777,
0.2640690207,
-0.161882475,
0.4625195861,
0.7204008698,
0.1871204376,
0.212742731,
-0.5947508216,
-0.2999049723,
0.4365752339,
0.8668705821,
-0.189110145,
0.5342618823,
0.2407168448,
-0.4212635458,
0.145603925,
-0.6127014756,
-0.1468163282,
-0.2909344435,
0.5056023598,
0.0071206093,
-0.4220830798,
0.5571415424,
-0.0532822385,
0.309538424,
0.6493563056,
0.4673541188,
-0.0431175381,
1.0164775848,
0.1992935538,
0.1015920192,
-0.1344680935,
0.046376653,
0.4265136421,
-0.752078712,
-0.0192813203,
-0.6082844138,
0.2161847651,
-0.4039231837,
-0.1782588959,
1.0443618298,
-0.3035191298,
0.089882277,
-0.1964927614,
-0.2097091973,
0.3729343712,
0.1180808619,
0.2532139719,
0.412081629,
-0.0926891044,
-0.09390755,
-0.1058667079,
-0.7104434371,
-0.2000138164,
1.4226129055,
0.3614421487,
0.5222756863,
0.0533484891,
0.8295872808,
0.1638164222,
0.5584935546,
-0.7220851183,
0.3592920303,
-0.2069968432,
-0.2217895836,
0.0021906863,
-0.6767668724,
-0.7804701328,
0.3505542874,
-0.1822551042,
-0.3440903425,
-0.1408677548,
-0.0371341035,
-0.830158174,
0.0697997212,
-0.7582679987,
0.477750957,
0.2092447877,
0.2336333692,
-0.1734735668,
-0.5946443677,
0.6140423417,
-0.207330972,
0.5378577113,
-0.1267088205,
-0.2106209695,
0.6006915569,
-0.6559438705,
0.712916553,
0.0642110035,
0.0318178274,
-0.0442937799,
0.1146344766,
0.3735075593,
-0.0998912156,
0.3707278073,
0.2108153999,
-0.0228070505,
0.1614781618,
-0.391623348,
0.3747676015,
-0.3972835839,
-0.4450653195,
-0.3229209483,
-0.3732197285,
-0.2830723524,
0.1677695811,
0.3839729428,
0.8169049621,
-0.3977074027,
-0.0486757159,
0.5323313475,
-0.3759442866,
0.4903440773,
0.5749339461,
-0.0036057527,
-0.6017848253,
0.7916712165,
0.3564581275,
0.2358940393,
0.3272045851,
0.439568013,
-0.1847411394,
-0.7048718929,
-0.5764595866,
0.550536871,
-0.85724473,
-0.0687709302,
-1.2213829756,
-0.3732176125,
-0.2381003499,
0.0264096297,
-0.2552045584,
-0.3955665231,
-0.2587079108,
-0.1282084733,
0.0962251797,
0.7464931011,
-0.0794285238,
-0.2089392245,
-1.167722702,
0.6055390835,
-0.0833964199,
0.4112157226,
-0.0501718074,
-0.4405339956,
-0.0613820963,
-0.3400379419,
-0.1335428953,
-0.6206640005,
0.1301083565,
0.1460027993,
0.9611019492,
0.5971435905,
0.2238978893,
0.751901567,
-0.6018595695,
0.5842242837,
0.6561074257,
-0.8344323635,
0.4717546701,
-0.2901424468,
0.4087684751,
0.6525739431,
0.2923346758,
-0.537951827,
-0.6440951228,
-0.6714525819,
-0.9021028876,
0.6013879776,
0.1326061189,
-0.6431364417,
-0.4338102043,
0.2611426413,
0.3453320265,
0.4697526395,
-0.3109409511,
-0.6402798891,
0.5242661238,
-0.456046164,
-0.3207573593,
-0.4148751497,
-0.326536566,
-0.4009754658,
0.3818837106,
0.0767023861,
0.0477128141,
0.5427489281,
-0.0447151139,
-0.120954141,
0.2226672471,
0.7553586364,
0.8803282976,
-0.3607842028,
0.1622312665,
0.1542287171,
-0.6950350404,
0.0900059417,
-0.0025789216,
-0.0419853032,
0.2798024118,
0.3739221692,
0.0248635784,
0.4597048461,
-0.8935903907,
0.7957284451,
0.0473498739,
-0.2030660212,
-0.1071259677,
-0.095176734,
-0.1691996455,
-0.1926175803,
0.124996528,
0.7434310317,
0.5804296732,
-0.4676454067,
0.163363874,
0.0584563129,
-0.5416245461,
-0.3837057948,
0.4341570735,
0.2540656328,
0.2598917782,
0.140484497,
0.0585649349,
-0.2004039586,
0.6644061208,
-0.0328221843,
0.966529727,
0.0261823665,
0.0412632078,
0.4804474711,
0.4190998971,
-0.1065733805,
0.2605955303,
0.2594733834,
-0.0846920237,
-0.5378392935,
-0.0064378856,
-0.300955981,
0.2365819067,
-0.6457017064,
0.2855920196,
-0.6012893915,
-0.3012954295,
0.3468448818,
-0.5537555814,
-0.5333346725,
0.3433553874,
-0.1229273006,
0.6990507245,
-0.6783528924,
0.1214785054,
0.5061949492,
-0.4484922886,
-0.5328190923,
-0.1530718207,
0.4130353332,
-0.5986292362,
0.4080840945,
-0.117752105,
-0.1502326131,
-0.5827168822,
-0.1133490428,
-0.6569935083,
0.6081671119,
0.3194031715,
-0.3992612064,
0.0224310029,
-0.1996612251,
0.5563353896,
-0.36837098,
0.5223218203,
0.5163518786,
0.3159478307,
-0.1866121143,
-1.0548757315,
0.2140485644,
-0.0619998202,
-0.471799463,
0.489798069,
-0.3654232919,
1.0836966038,
-0.5650630593,
-0.3266105354,
0.1175067648,
-0.2788648009,
-0.0668725222,
0.6800968647,
0.2606216371,
0.4895036817,
0.6506074071,
0.0078000054,
1.1682398319,
-0.0109041492,
0.2062163204,
1.2500472069,
-0.4060974717,
0.4781522453,
0.4696546793,
-0.2563236952,
-0.2517009079,
0.2280508876,
0.2516943216,
0.5714026093,
0.1529359818,
-0.1402567774,
-0.0194107629,
0.0999230519,
-0.7095024586,
0.3925157785,
0.3937556446,
-0.9568529129,
-0.6804902554,
-0.0462285243,
0.4852738976,
0.0426881723,
-0.3185788691,
1.0888267756,
-0.1383705586,
-0.8876132369,
0.8900433183,
-0.1746666133,
0.0135058388,
-0.636369288,
-0.2266836017,
-0.383829236,
0.2747473717,
-0.2330581546,
-0.6854537725,
0.2980749607,
0.0240095761,
-0.552259922,
0.052648779,
0.4453496635,
-0.2440633476,
-0.31221205,
0.1703004092,
0.9056720138,
0.4434420764,
-0.162212491,
-0.3216034472,
-0.0845980793,
0.0543846563,
0.0215896703,
0.2680798769,
0.5180268288,
0.0438854173,
0.591568172,
0.4630345106,
0.5294536948,
-0.5081298947,
0.4197178483,
1.0643416643,
-0.7330350876,
-0.486011982,
-1.0432149172,
0.0760320202,
-0.0690050796,
-0.4464659393,
0.8920937181,
0.5804703832,
0.1751003861,
-0.1133065149,
0.9848539233,
-0.0177502669,
0.8752816916,
-0.3121876419,
1.038593173,
-0.5473898053,
0.1645680964,
-0.6144680977,
-0.6468167305,
-0.3648366928,
0.0024497958,
-0.2534104586,
0.0882574245,
0.9986067414,
0.4952054918,
0.1039886177,
0.2769995332,
0.5590081811,
0.3305444121,
0.2359686494,
0.4318440259,
0.7976050377,
-0.4165841639,
0.4746705294,
-0.1595709473,
-0.5346394181,
-0.4166258574,
-0.8836590648,
-1.159299612,
-0.2671203017,
-0.7650386691,
-0.1581216455,
0.0673518628,
1.0661168098,
0.5791227221,
-0.6543298364,
0.253452152,
0.1625455916,
0.1625508815,
-0.5915870667,
-0.1461220682,
0.5648679733,
-0.1666580141,
-0.3042759001,
0.2534360588,
0.8100993037,
0.0449978299,
0.0673394799,
0.310533911,
0.1250012517,
-0.2266565859,
0.6057049632,
0.0507349446,
-0.5690886378,
-0.2001007497,
-0.3494948745,
-0.1297412515,
0.1801002175,
0.8783247471,
-0.6620271802,
0.4786843956,
0.3100807965,
0.4478977621,
-0.0547221564,
0.0167625882,
0.6167876124,
-0.4494098127,
-0.1585606486,
0.2591624856,
0.4210119843,
0.005542845,
-0.3914091885,
0.5059740543,
0.3535591066,
-0.2966555953,
-0.8100132942,
-0.2071367055,
-0.6910073757,
-0.1254313141,
1.0244085789,
-0.4316129088,
-0.4654420912,
-0.5721027255,
-0.3627087474,
-0.11280182,
-0.4804522395,
0.8221845031,
0.5134451985,
-0.0612293258,
-0.2151288837,
-0.5314311385,
0.5994288921,
0.4117788672,
-1.0254807472,
0.1576051116,
0.7990738153,
0.3908777833,
0.0741250813,
0.8237229586,
-0.5277842283,
0.7996299267,
0.0615119673,
0.0460119359,
-0.127319783,
-0.297783345,
-0.3077336252,
0.4847889543,
-0.2050192505,
-0.3989688456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08300v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08300v1
|
Workflow-Guided Response Generation for Task-Oriented Dialogue
| 2023-11-14T16:44:33 | 2023-11-14T16:44:33 |
Do June Min, Paloma Sodhi, Ramya Ramakrishnan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems aim to achieve specific goals through
interactive dialogue. Such tasks usually involve following specific workflows,
i.e. executing a sequence of actions in a particular order. While prior work
has focused on supervised learning methods to condition on past actions, they
do not explicitly optimize for compliance to a desired workflow. In this paper,
we propose a novel framework based on reinforcement learning (RL) to generate
dialogue responses that are aligned with a given workflow. Our framework
consists of ComplianceScorer, a metric designed to evaluate how well a
generated response executes the specified action, combined with an RL
opimization process that utilizes an interactive sampling technique. We
evaluate our approach on two TOD datasets, Action-Based Conversations Dataset
(ABCD) (Chen et al., 2021a) and MultiWOZ 2.2 (Zang et al., 2020) on a range of
automated and human evaluation metrics. Our findings indicate that our RL-based
framework outperforms baselines and is effective at enerating responses that
both comply with the intended workflows while being expressed in a natural and
fluent manner.
|
[
-0.3745370209,
-0.7142458558,
0.3883467615,
0.1364637613,
-0.1328953356,
-0.0060078618,
-0.0670318976,
-0.2302119285,
0.12403173,
0.7383311987,
-1.1599134207,
-0.3283348978,
-0.2737663388,
0.1165894121,
0.0749880895,
1.301071763,
-0.0539922565,
-0.1041598916,
-0.1308830082,
-0.1809801161,
-0.6342176199,
-0.2801724672,
-0.8193410039,
-0.5437853932,
0.8244144917,
0.3639787734,
0.2335819155,
0.4078090489,
0.2622943819,
0.3402271569,
0.0770025998,
0.3657619357,
-0.5505236983,
0.7086318731,
-0.2170312852,
-0.0159766432,
-0.3787148595,
-0.1648311317,
0.0353434421,
0.4463699162,
-0.6074086428,
0.2379472405,
0.2206473202,
0.4831212163,
-0.7230041027,
0.421115309,
-0.1159672886,
0.5160557032,
0.2370038182,
-0.3795184493,
-0.5451564789,
-0.2990231514,
0.3967792988,
-0.6776434779,
-0.087918967,
0.065409489,
0.3049929142,
0.4630141258,
-0.3000432849,
-0.4795898199,
-0.7378708124,
0.6853213906,
-0.7973881364,
0.1146300733,
0.1770913601,
0.4156316817,
-0.4959301651,
-0.7144049406,
-0.4404922426,
-0.0076203942,
-0.0559696071,
0.4718349874,
0.000983348,
0.1332021058,
0.4452245533,
0.0671240687,
-0.4564752579,
-0.0893678814,
-0.1557098627,
-0.1251618266,
0.5676651001,
0.6831504703,
-0.3782078624,
-0.2038294673,
-0.3076142967,
-0.4103093147,
-0.155016467,
0.436922133,
0.2345446944,
0.4492762685,
-0.0348795801,
0.454664588,
-0.461807847,
0.8167192936,
0.3988911808,
-0.3424872458,
0.0847141966,
-0.3866603076,
-0.3960780799,
-0.1320993304,
0.9912849665,
0.2078868896,
0.1301913261,
0.0599071868,
-0.2664601207,
-0.4028146863,
0.6924243569,
-0.830840826,
-0.1271190792,
0.1954262704,
-0.3029953241,
-0.3795849681,
0.0625050738,
-0.6451134682,
-0.2819842696,
-0.4803418219,
0.1535668224,
-0.2689073086,
-0.2330548167,
-0.1885903478,
0.1089663357,
0.092563197,
0.5707921386,
-0.65991956,
0.1137186363,
0.584286809,
0.5228903294,
-0.3258553445,
-0.0778090209,
-1.3446719646,
0.1953312755,
-0.3688296676,
0.5246657729,
-0.4122771025,
-0.5673245192,
0.1979392916,
-0.2326301187,
-0.2706162333,
-0.507091701,
0.4904021025,
-0.4276607931,
0.3619093895,
0.0992488414,
-0.1937007755,
-0.1135808006,
0.5330867171,
-0.4401502907,
0.8019943237,
0.1788617522,
-0.6143711209,
0.5232573152,
-0.9342310429,
-0.3613323867,
0.0422316194,
-0.2102571875,
-0.4868401289,
-0.037594419,
0.0305639375,
0.275369674,
-0.0719337761,
0.2924844921,
-0.2844401002,
-0.1178265065,
0.3004549146,
-0.4317644835,
0.3964148164,
0.3986003697,
-0.452504009,
0.6382507682,
-0.4173443317,
0.363363117,
-0.1122865975,
-0.4261262417,
0.1303634644,
0.0569910854,
-0.2011612356,
0.4626512527,
-0.1503903568,
-0.704703629,
-0.0341068171,
-0.3658193648,
0.2440534681,
0.8240150809,
0.3481650651,
0.0446987078,
-0.5265159011,
0.7215682864,
0.1781540364,
0.2992675006,
-0.1150637269,
-0.3652499318,
-0.5547720194,
-0.1456976831,
-0.0989151821,
0.6191123724,
-0.9857106209,
0.40143314,
-0.1697773039,
-0.343562007,
-0.235322535,
0.0841445401,
0.9027138352,
0.8560895324,
0.0421144702,
-0.4788579345,
-0.4916338921,
-0.6482738256,
-0.1569250971,
-0.5082953572,
-0.0353880972,
0.7058067918,
0.2586515844,
0.1007746905,
1.0544523001,
-0.5245619416,
-0.3071457446,
-0.2782272696,
0.6463112235,
0.0164521225,
0.3774118721,
0.0721979514,
-0.8782622814,
-0.6572886705,
0.014275576,
-0.5600444078,
-0.0628910735,
-0.0391175896,
-0.0471698642,
0.3937394023,
0.3403023481,
-0.3051247299,
0.6909766793,
0.4277799129,
-0.1407923549,
0.4645240307,
-0.1188427284,
0.2220699936,
-1.1251208782,
0.1393002421,
0.0174955707,
-0.4512718618,
-0.7313911319,
-0.4918213487,
-0.2827931941,
-0.1941164881,
-0.7241598964,
0.3517208695,
0.0602415092,
-0.1844959259,
-0.2842839956,
0.0396871939,
-0.1456742734,
1.1658613682,
0.4606901109,
0.7840034366,
0.1012132764,
-0.8755043745,
0.4231484234,
0.7183228731,
-0.2123853415,
0.9347808361,
-0.776586175,
0.2204685062,
-0.0474719517,
0.4988079965,
-0.6375000477,
-0.2925235033,
0.6337658763,
-0.4383015335,
-0.0317064561,
-0.2858107984,
-0.2049734145,
-0.3359447718,
-0.026305683,
0.2878236473,
0.4998367727,
-0.4519376159,
0.7565065622,
0.0839120448,
-0.4211969972,
-0.4898378253,
-0.2551392615,
-0.2975298464,
-0.0870109648,
-0.3587128222,
-0.034986157,
-0.3230491877,
0.0114292521,
-0.2919327021,
-0.1809878498,
0.1060362533,
-0.0549356453,
0.5250199437,
0.023129411,
0.1446583271,
-0.2592300177,
-0.25705567,
0.0157972835,
0.2150358111,
-0.2833263278,
0.5260201693,
0.0595289059,
-0.6809533238,
-0.6238954663,
0.3680136502,
0.6080187559,
-0.307135433,
0.2465781868,
0.6575001478,
0.0780859366,
-0.1527871042,
-0.1108530164,
-0.279006511,
-0.4799557328,
0.2480482608,
-0.3336424828,
-0.74855721,
0.2066288888,
0.0119229564,
0.6325501204,
-0.1205151901,
0.765071094,
-0.1995630711,
1.3405851126,
0.3660929203,
0.3431757987,
0.7907368541,
0.049823828,
0.2885609269,
-0.9790055752,
-0.4935585558,
-0.4302228689,
-0.1907343864,
-0.3990291655,
-0.2963667214,
0.4849350452,
-0.2449027151,
-0.25110358,
0.3192223907,
-0.2317970097,
-0.151729241,
0.6986067295,
0.0557412319,
0.0923006088,
-0.2957252562,
-0.1877958924,
-0.055611752,
-0.7694024444,
-0.3510788977,
0.8544743061,
0.1720171422,
0.7814956307,
0.2996694148,
0.7949106097,
0.5001218319,
0.3007572293,
-0.8440756798,
0.5259353518,
0.416506201,
-0.0101654036,
-0.5227945447,
-0.5235618353,
-1.1507028341,
0.2570995688,
-0.1739412695,
-0.6223882437,
-0.0782427117,
0.2746649086,
-0.34791255,
-0.1329765618,
-0.412132293,
0.6733571291,
-0.1542120576,
-0.481818974,
0.0069018169,
-0.582910955,
0.1835422367,
0.1177942604,
-0.0350357778,
-0.0496276952,
0.3270747364,
0.6336330771,
-0.5138033628,
1.0258111954,
-0.5424540639,
-0.314470619,
0.2311638743,
0.0080038877,
0.7307872772,
0.1259028018,
0.1855027527,
-0.7794511318,
0.0196165703,
-0.2902148664,
-0.7971292138,
0.2892887294,
-0.2441695482,
-0.6411405206,
-0.3853473067,
-0.7312626839,
-0.6250275373,
0.1441478878,
-0.0262358095,
0.5670915842,
-0.2807774544,
0.0969815478,
0.7987784147,
-0.0222456064,
0.509516418,
0.8708536029,
-0.0659785494,
-0.4956791699,
0.7038242817,
-0.4562470317,
0.3325619996,
0.1442850679,
0.1263595372,
-0.4020543098,
-0.4135946631,
-0.6764579415,
-0.1893559098,
-0.2967642546,
-0.3149860501,
-0.5402451158,
-0.0652836338,
-0.5329809785,
0.1616180092,
-0.0806363001,
0.0998612642,
-0.0410945192,
0.1621595323,
0.2056172937,
0.7167963386,
0.0852839574,
-0.0001367603,
-0.8460918069,
0.3091524243,
0.5890907645,
0.330652386,
-0.0742947534,
-0.4112277031,
-0.2758996189,
0.3253951073,
-0.5788426399,
-0.6176378131,
0.3675168753,
0.2155957371,
0.7283138037,
0.399138093,
0.6006605029,
0.643063426,
-0.3939627111,
0.6387090087,
0.1731256545,
-0.6006333828,
0.7670548558,
-0.3505616188,
0.3598486483,
0.5103462934,
-0.0560635701,
-0.6125916243,
-0.6988602281,
-0.6391282082,
-0.5648393035,
1.10858953,
0.2513264418,
0.1136667654,
-0.0316636935,
0.042480085,
0.0601348318,
0.4326816201,
-0.379812628,
0.0655318722,
-0.2058401853,
-0.3878810704,
0.0985777304,
0.2534244061,
-0.5541184545,
0.3082956076,
0.6689014435,
-0.5419999957,
0.2835022807,
0.2409383506,
-0.032830447,
-0.1721579134,
0.3529451489,
0.872171402,
0.4082042575,
-0.0330654941,
-0.5691821575,
-0.0529273897,
-0.3460909128,
0.0137457643,
-0.0382269397,
0.0067652124,
-0.1928942949,
0.0658788458,
1.0893332958,
0.0233813543,
-1.1712194681,
0.5545231104,
-0.3597123623,
-0.5067335963,
-0.2702585757,
0.5393576026,
-0.3770722449,
0.6237532496,
0.2180285901,
-0.0640065819,
0.1459480524,
-0.492438972,
0.2471764982,
0.4120470881,
-0.7156910896,
0.0919270441,
0.3273714483,
0.3821159303,
-0.6084926724,
0.4824815094,
-0.2170254886,
-0.4802157581,
0.5208789706,
0.4657279849,
0.8551235795,
0.141122818,
0.433452785,
0.2945340872,
-0.2889790535,
0.2003231049,
0.3307192922,
-0.57847929,
-0.3475719392,
-0.6101081967,
-0.4704985619,
-0.8879570365,
-0.0053976751,
-1.2559213638,
-0.2220767438,
-0.4178355932,
-0.1230347082,
-0.2985039949,
-0.1026825011,
-0.5293833017,
0.2749800086,
-0.2546797097,
0.6980273724,
-0.583779633,
0.7048334479,
0.713245213,
-0.343401581,
-0.8211023808,
0.2751431167,
0.0115648946,
-0.6186841726,
0.7599717975,
-0.0443016626,
-0.4108323157,
0.0086374264,
-0.0936784372,
-0.5330566764,
1.223618865,
0.0268525481,
-0.3016881347,
0.1999782622,
-0.0429238155,
0.7036193013,
-0.5349433422,
0.1311184466,
0.2861197591,
0.3078530431,
0.2801989913,
-0.9911743999,
-0.0440570638,
-0.3780705035,
0.2051305026,
0.4614537954,
-0.5555876493,
0.3274342418,
-0.0812898055,
-0.0315803625,
0.3098316789,
0.6950862408,
0.4887105823,
0.3575600684,
0.5988459587,
0.5486930609,
0.4990500212,
-0.1253671497,
0.7140052319,
-0.0469381735,
0.0698904023,
1.1929534674,
-0.4362207353,
0.8195268512,
0.6017898321,
0.1245362908,
0.6130344272,
0.5661646128,
0.1417934448,
0.7554220557,
0.2223127186,
-0.2943677306,
-0.0884522498,
-0.4174797535,
0.1612568796,
0.4094386101,
0.2621298134,
-0.1631422341,
-0.0555145107,
0.346203655,
-0.1960991323,
0.2247220129,
-0.1456758976,
1.56518507,
-0.3420735896,
-1.3917406797,
0.4834580123,
-0.1866651177,
0.4392404556,
-0.6674764752,
-0.2258937061,
-0.3752989173,
0.0983168334,
0.0215155911,
-0.8710951209,
0.2183621079,
0.1751349717,
-0.2660259008,
-0.586610198,
0.2615804076,
-0.4747327864,
0.1034256369,
0.0644007549,
0.4216202796,
0.0431620218,
0.4572220445,
-0.8527613282,
-0.1824336052,
0.1834450066,
-0.3374429047,
0.4954421222,
0.5043159723,
-0.0557853281,
0.7890699506,
0.7028698325,
-0.22060965,
-0.2043451071,
0.1061565056,
0.664812088,
-0.3444459736,
-0.6941226721,
-0.2237493545,
0.6083945036,
-0.3195958734,
-0.3725150526,
0.3345503807,
0.3609080911,
0.7803612351,
-0.0631893203,
0.8637233377,
-0.2165220529,
0.7716477513,
-0.6958976388,
0.0898965374,
-0.3477028608,
0.058087308,
-0.2273725122,
-0.6338121295,
0.1772850752,
0.6216195226,
-0.1840011179,
0.2215665579,
0.4600181282,
0.7115170956,
0.0745920539,
0.0518045649,
0.2985391617,
-0.4198123217,
0.5226653218,
0.8337518573,
0.7990700006,
-0.0196103938,
0.8999345899,
-0.2373970747,
-0.0641482845,
-0.3682334721,
-1.0180325508,
-0.8983860016,
-0.5646113157,
-0.2453795075,
-0.4456736743,
0.1697025746,
0.9224842787,
0.7541565299,
-0.7182753086,
-0.1385506988,
-0.38615188,
-0.1800682843,
-0.5384492278,
-0.2391564548,
-0.0605742745,
-0.5567210913,
-0.9392960668,
0.3413138092,
0.2916295528,
0.1627268195,
-0.2068882734,
-0.781932056,
0.1539411396,
0.1292979568,
0.4607317448,
0.6956316233,
-0.7419075966,
-0.2456247658,
0.0573543422,
-0.2571017146,
0.0987315252,
1.1630694866,
-0.8451942205,
0.3701540828,
0.2933852375,
0.6533737779,
0.603403151,
0.2186925709,
0.9832763076,
-0.8973158002,
-0.0758581981,
0.5353272557,
0.0112900371,
0.1324412674,
-0.1638115793,
0.494355619,
-0.1845428944,
-0.4859634638,
-0.6576600671,
0.7493005395,
-0.8728504777,
0.0145681445,
0.8800377846,
-0.4772227705,
0.0303291958,
-0.4047228694,
-0.4606548548,
0.1967492849,
-0.685333848,
0.7029240131,
0.4052993655,
-0.7412297726,
-0.360288322,
-0.3826838136,
0.712655127,
0.779333055,
-1.0200326443,
0.2385433614,
0.7385617495,
-0.0297872741,
0.0136616006,
0.5739352703,
0.1075577065,
0.5726012588,
-0.3517803252,
-0.3194227815,
-0.3156097829,
-0.2804484963,
0.0467522591,
0.0589911379,
0.0430858023,
-0.3043343425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08299v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08299v2
|
VERVE: Template-based ReflectiVE Rewriting for MotiVational IntErviewing
| 2023-11-14T16:44:16 | 2024-03-08T19:29:47 |
Do June Min, Verónica Pérez-Rosas, Kenneth Resnicow, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reflective listening is a fundamental skill that counselors must acquire to
achieve proficiency in motivational interviewing (MI). It involves responding
in a manner that acknowledges and explores the meaning of what the client has
expressed in the conversation. In this work, we introduce the task of
counseling response rewriting, which transforms non-reflective statements into
reflective responses. We introduce VERVE, a template-based rewriting system
with paraphrase-augmented training and adaptive template updating. VERVE first
creates a template by identifying and filtering out tokens that are not
relevant to reflections and constructs a reflective response using the
template. Paraphrase-augmented training allows the model to learn less-strict
fillings of masked spans, and adaptive template updating helps discover
effective templates for rewriting without significantly removing the original
content. Using both automatic and human evaluations, we compare our method
against text rewriting baselines and show that our framework is effective in
turning non-reflective statements into more reflective responses while
achieving a good content preservation-reflection style trade-off.
|
[
-0.0713607147,
-0.2290983349,
0.4607017636,
0.5201506615,
-0.1923345923,
0.1239533648,
-0.135510534,
0.0349432528,
0.5873103738,
0.5747304559,
-0.6754794717,
-0.4588483572,
-0.4392032921,
0.0524585024,
-0.3008192182,
1.1559802294,
-0.1007287204,
0.445779711,
-0.0881052762,
-0.2127157301,
-0.9700883031,
0.0377860889,
-0.5924117565,
-0.1350745261,
0.4531219602,
0.4461988211,
-0.069118917,
0.1223026216,
0.1034527048,
0.2185396254,
-0.009427947,
-0.2971716523,
-0.9151670933,
0.6316844225,
-0.3738084435,
-0.7641011477,
-0.5483552814,
0.3591820896,
0.586575985,
0.5603779554,
-0.401730001,
0.4403456748,
0.2288515866,
0.7384672165,
-0.8760852218,
0.0451979823,
-0.9952692389,
0.0465786569,
0.1568598598,
-0.5423468351,
-0.6406274438,
-0.4197279513,
0.1228568554,
-0.748793602,
0.7545312047,
0.0856771767,
0.2163282633,
0.0839561597,
-0.3530319333,
-0.385736078,
-0.6618127227,
0.8900108337,
-0.1104022115,
0.674873054,
0.4189899266,
0.2478355765,
-0.1358105093,
-0.7625264525,
-0.3967388868,
-0.1304605305,
0.1661648154,
0.6784341335,
0.3132329583,
-0.0069077476,
-0.08121939,
0.7021687031,
-0.5005363226,
-0.6130651236,
-0.411046952,
-0.1961211413,
0.394461602,
0.3700909019,
-0.0301610492,
-0.0493351892,
-0.2864302695,
-0.0181384049,
-0.7205139995,
0.0056893467,
0.0367888883,
0.1248058677,
0.1544893086,
0.4443910122,
0.0282663032,
0.7750097513,
0.1687841564,
-0.6454167962,
-0.0450720228,
-0.2155053914,
-0.1849864721,
0.3829944432,
0.3049899936,
0.8482880592,
-0.0936718658,
-0.4005900025,
-0.2252467573,
-0.0032888572,
0.7557576895,
-0.4891044796,
-0.071306102,
-0.1360991448,
-0.8168343306,
-0.3493761122,
-0.2811480761,
-0.8342626095,
-0.1616891623,
-0.5293677449,
0.2769455016,
-0.5894298553,
-0.0448647924,
0.418389976,
-0.4686603546,
0.5806630254,
0.7022508979,
-0.6617344022,
0.098795794,
0.759365499,
0.9098352194,
0.1777329743,
-0.2581757009,
-0.7678853273,
0.3332124054,
-0.2047750354,
0.5510464907,
-0.5342406034,
-0.8310399055,
0.0979940146,
-0.0804320946,
-0.3930620849,
-0.3474543393,
0.9476426244,
-0.4757302105,
0.5444566011,
-0.3857903481,
-0.5481425524,
0.1766541451,
0.4854794443,
-0.1816439927,
0.8910864592,
0.7750756741,
-0.717602253,
0.4152501523,
-0.3082712889,
-0.2959288955,
0.0192221571,
-0.0843313187,
-0.159785226,
0.665143609,
-0.1728167236,
-0.1793310791,
-0.3991303146,
0.2530675232,
0.217647925,
-0.4657324553,
0.2907222211,
-0.2541828454,
0.3460834324,
0.1333040297,
-0.1882328987,
-0.0098774554,
-0.8099694848,
0.2475001514,
-0.1265580058,
-0.6973061562,
-0.0561974458,
-0.2113298774,
0.2461535484,
0.131191805,
-0.2156065851,
-0.9418312311,
0.0444723479,
-0.2703619897,
0.1980673969,
0.7692803741,
0.0875218287,
0.2259464711,
-0.7680432796,
0.9553663135,
-0.384026438,
-0.1217701808,
-0.2900642455,
-0.4559125006,
-0.5938590765,
-0.2397184223,
-0.0309133809,
0.4339405298,
-1.1154112816,
0.0901071131,
-0.206601724,
-0.754801631,
-0.884260118,
0.227461651,
0.8407395482,
1.1358847618,
0.5124890804,
-0.6236845851,
-0.6191660166,
-0.6210507751,
-1.0262058973,
-0.2262654901,
-0.105230324,
0.2145317346,
0.1455040276,
0.2471706718,
0.9624776244,
-0.7481434941,
-0.6449871063,
-0.7164503932,
0.408914119,
0.1110737026,
0.6147488356,
0.6808032393,
-0.5991002321,
-0.9221682549,
-0.5180270672,
-0.5620830655,
-0.3684838116,
-0.4495580494,
0.0857792348,
-0.4930364788,
0.5612949729,
-0.1473128796,
0.589556098,
0.1610102654,
-0.2663708925,
0.6790244579,
0.1245835423,
0.1829461902,
-0.9395486712,
-0.1010447219,
0.109457843,
-0.1984134614,
-0.7574476004,
-0.2380313575,
-0.1910340935,
-0.1929692477,
-0.5558307171,
0.2084976882,
-0.3396743238,
0.0964345858,
-0.4584373832,
-0.0414770059,
0.4254348278,
0.4397437274,
0.0952258706,
1.005595088,
0.5705828071,
-0.570556283,
0.3091400266,
0.8327062726,
-0.5687996745,
1.2183097601,
-0.6635298729,
0.2473812699,
-0.6643490195,
0.7693552375,
-0.7730898857,
0.0482120216,
0.2913196385,
-0.4421118498,
0.2720268965,
-0.5501101613,
0.1434898078,
0.1587245166,
-0.5090390444,
0.407732904,
0.1832689047,
-0.2534007132,
0.6900297999,
-0.1186321378,
-0.2902875245,
-0.3423894048,
-0.6196966767,
0.3221488893,
-0.2749302685,
-0.3844444752,
0.7017275095,
-0.0544570386,
-0.0435519442,
-0.3942267597,
-0.1108493432,
0.1146295369,
0.0540972315,
0.0680621564,
0.2033228576,
-0.2250483036,
0.0468927547,
-0.0624244586,
-0.4105512798,
0.2035622895,
-0.3944482803,
0.6374291182,
-0.143451333,
-0.3190115392,
-0.7764724493,
0.57983917,
0.6518439651,
-0.2968849242,
0.9116325974,
0.7966526151,
0.1596532613,
0.1169386059,
-0.5878397822,
-0.0721551552,
-0.4532166123,
0.0721101984,
-0.3493472934,
-0.7141296864,
0.2555410564,
0.0177493468,
-0.038131211,
0.0836980939,
0.5500639081,
-0.1108267605,
0.5134444237,
0.4003721476,
0.1469523013,
0.9370240569,
-0.0937916338,
0.3642299771,
-1.5321034193,
-0.3841717541,
-0.4283409715,
-0.5534843802,
-0.2838370502,
-0.2760394216,
0.6693353057,
-0.1206750199,
0.0727368146,
0.0606651641,
-0.8051512837,
0.1977173984,
0.569624126,
-0.0546266735,
0.1639627665,
-0.4350884855,
0.1232402474,
-0.6092548966,
-0.3145368695,
-0.4145311415,
1.146954298,
0.0801181048,
0.913297236,
0.2972145379,
0.7472740412,
-0.0181750301,
0.8127343059,
-0.8287549019,
0.5727832317,
0.3828254938,
-0.562889874,
0.0019394916,
-0.230187729,
-0.5812093019,
0.4963747859,
-0.1267078072,
-0.7002847195,
0.3127560019,
0.1240216643,
-0.0986520424,
0.0922938213,
-0.5687741637,
0.5820891261,
-0.1604625136,
-0.4616012275,
0.0166725684,
-0.4864543676,
0.042592667,
0.1202018186,
-0.3237480521,
0.0769114196,
0.3286853433,
0.8882616758,
-0.2456445694,
0.7170282602,
-0.5760403872,
-0.0540792122,
0.3887568712,
0.4599701762,
0.3120818138,
0.4929501116,
-0.2114915401,
-0.8584635854,
0.1648000926,
-0.1414616555,
-0.8645468354,
0.3442174494,
-0.3332115114,
-0.789247632,
-0.3869369626,
-0.4794229865,
-0.4564188421,
0.2441983521,
0.6265217662,
0.4273941517,
-0.55434376,
0.6062495708,
0.7619965076,
-0.1996290237,
-0.2064180523,
0.7033894062,
-0.1454350054,
-0.5139907598,
0.9994977713,
0.0167662576,
0.2430362105,
0.2967661023,
0.1682030708,
-0.2871878147,
-0.6851935387,
-0.2151277214,
0.1046846136,
-0.7119858861,
-0.1246071234,
-0.6945099831,
0.2482179105,
-0.8787649274,
-0.645197928,
-0.3956254721,
-0.3601261973,
-0.1926052123,
-0.0851208642,
0.1416460127,
0.3780237138,
0.0016382072,
0.3854753971,
-0.7376260161,
0.2654674947,
0.1997066438,
0.2796888947,
-0.0219495613,
-0.5739492774,
-0.0961598977,
0.0422274843,
-0.6676750779,
-0.9924753904,
0.541996479,
0.3183034956,
0.2775978744,
0.219476521,
0.1645853668,
0.7078203559,
-0.4094254971,
0.8120125532,
0.3957063854,
-1.1095173359,
0.7127466798,
-0.521617949,
-0.1209323853,
1.332963109,
-0.0979085639,
-1.0325372219,
-0.3354037702,
-0.4509665668,
-0.8576424718,
0.5376525521,
0.1436871588,
0.19698672,
-0.0737236962,
0.8403159976,
-0.0231748093,
0.6080731153,
-0.7030438185,
0.0541336499,
-0.8117051721,
-0.1712867469,
-0.0720474198,
-0.3260902166,
-0.6040372252,
-0.3279674649,
0.701221168,
-0.2336345315,
0.7043088675,
0.5551511645,
-0.1678915024,
-0.0290978011,
0.4418866038,
0.7538105845,
0.3805649877,
-0.398489207,
-0.0557593256,
0.1684987992,
-0.5316444039,
0.336230427,
-0.6692726016,
-0.0314768255,
0.1996477991,
0.2987446189,
0.4930514991,
0.221383214,
-0.520678401,
0.7405843139,
-0.5130679011,
-0.3873583972,
-0.6035693884,
0.2906739414,
-0.1043533757,
-0.2434085011,
0.2344413996,
-0.1642470807,
0.2083733231,
-0.6616360545,
-0.003559384,
0.3053022921,
-0.8117367029,
-0.4355231225,
0.719375968,
0.077601172,
-0.5135867596,
0.7874375582,
-0.0750477761,
-0.6305171251,
0.0892034248,
0.9942470789,
1.166077733,
-0.2108893245,
0.391866684,
0.0604292341,
-0.0489254184,
0.1796697229,
0.557240963,
-0.4102478027,
-0.597019136,
-0.1126825586,
-0.5043492913,
-0.6070697308,
-0.0059059113,
-1.6200685501,
-0.1863278002,
-0.5736272931,
0.2613344491,
-0.2311426103,
-0.5673984289,
-0.4184412956,
0.4288524091,
-0.6211283803,
1.0010695457,
-1.0369164944,
0.3988782167,
0.8681747317,
-0.2058414072,
-0.6583431363,
0.0929037854,
0.2624405026,
-0.8030397296,
0.6640033722,
0.1248204559,
-0.5519114733,
-0.1042236984,
-0.4618682265,
-0.6301830411,
1.2704457045,
0.4014531076,
-0.0820725933,
-0.0133436024,
-0.0482671,
0.7532958984,
-0.4849443734,
-0.030219188,
0.4927601516,
0.4364094734,
0.4072441459,
-0.6711398363,
-0.2006918043,
-0.3346962035,
0.0698430091,
-0.0617223307,
-0.7201386094,
0.6637682319,
0.3976095617,
-0.0134864431,
0.1920665503,
0.5686141253,
0.0617771223,
0.5173382163,
0.4197945297,
0.6733871698,
0.5903668404,
-0.1834697276,
0.8320196271,
-0.4575775862,
0.2280047685,
1.3398826122,
-0.7422619462,
0.4126328528,
0.7214392424,
0.0962795019,
0.5843943357,
0.1176435798,
0.2015216798,
0.6893607378,
0.2236899137,
-0.7860953808,
-0.0859546885,
-0.3624477386,
-0.3678742349,
0.6500758529,
0.3210731447,
-0.5021545291,
-0.1966029257,
0.207396999,
-0.1595135331,
0.3150941432,
-0.1907543689,
0.8016191125,
0.174431622,
-1.1714739799,
0.4917304516,
0.2991354167,
0.2137261182,
-0.266161859,
0.1222419143,
-0.0571396239,
0.2905656695,
-0.2929953337,
-0.7020365,
0.6288701296,
0.0236383211,
-0.3374242783,
-0.9301549196,
0.6526353359,
-0.3123876452,
-0.215343833,
-0.0256149024,
0.4093226194,
-0.2158057094,
0.0818805695,
-0.5984860659,
-0.235363692,
0.2668301761,
-0.1432668716,
0.5142911673,
0.2567252815,
0.3529139757,
0.7436185479,
0.7760633826,
0.0172358248,
-0.1610721499,
0.2418318987,
1.1799088717,
-0.7211164236,
-0.7846128345,
-0.2011594772,
0.3277125955,
0.0489391945,
-0.5662932396,
0.7182699442,
0.6451194286,
0.4469502568,
-0.0524074025,
0.7310584784,
0.1105175465,
0.9529804587,
-0.5564044118,
0.2493416518,
-0.2347974777,
0.209851861,
-0.4809243977,
-1.0443189144,
-0.2251206785,
0.9829022884,
-0.521096468,
-0.0569402501,
0.4730061889,
0.8911212683,
0.1088022962,
0.3779504895,
0.159088552,
-0.1375720948,
0.8424755335,
0.4843057394,
1.0016292334,
-0.1298719943,
0.1319532394,
0.2382153273,
-0.1284229308,
-0.0870238096,
-0.8031247854,
-0.5126797557,
-0.3674072921,
-0.3663163185,
-0.9057793617,
0.0089770984,
0.7831564546,
0.0244624242,
-0.3287493885,
-0.0765330121,
-0.3730000257,
-0.1201894134,
-0.187815547,
-0.2808800936,
0.0194466915,
-0.2592407763,
-0.3797524571,
0.8666962981,
0.6057753563,
-0.0093960604,
-0.1620679498,
-0.0985108614,
-0.0016317603,
0.0600834191,
0.2231002897,
0.334634304,
-0.2699657679,
-0.3880506456,
0.0084469868,
0.2294845283,
0.253793925,
1.3883368969,
-0.7212667465,
0.7099900246,
0.2783983946,
0.4744504094,
0.7240619659,
0.1116966456,
0.79143852,
-0.7906320095,
0.1019650549,
0.6451652646,
0.3681249321,
0.2648646235,
-0.1657055467,
0.3101068437,
0.3072560728,
-0.4395328462,
-0.9302948117,
0.6579120159,
-0.9867241979,
0.2365359962,
0.8242569566,
-0.4390713274,
-0.0659242868,
-0.6926029921,
-0.4541478157,
0.029561406,
-0.0935806334,
0.8050444722,
0.5289871693,
-0.2238122225,
-0.1647999734,
-0.0673575997,
0.4927810431,
0.802734673,
0.0335397236,
0.0842441022,
0.1907680482,
0.5413905978,
0.1056850776,
1.0978015661,
-0.1713315994,
0.5388171077,
-0.0237839967,
-0.2116702944,
0.0571386814,
-0.1509034038,
-0.1357565075,
0.1459820271,
0.1190812662,
-0.0456190631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08298v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08298v2
|
A Survey of Confidence Estimation and Calibration in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-14T16:43:29 | 2024-03-25T06:01:49 |
Jiahui Geng, Fengyu Cai, Yuxia Wang, Heinz Koeppl, Preslav Nakov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
a wide range of tasks in various domains. Despite their impressive performance,
they can be unreliable due to factual errors in their generations. Assessing
their confidence and calibrating them across different tasks can help mitigate
risks and enable LLMs to produce better generations. There has been a lot of
recent research aiming to address this, but there has been no comprehensive
overview to organize it and outline the main lessons learned. The present
survey aims to bridge this gap. In particular, we outline the challenges and we
summarize recent technical advancements for LLM confidence estimation and
calibration. We further discuss their applications and suggest promising
directions for future work.
|
[
-0.1706887931,
-0.568543911,
0.9978768826,
0.0769040883,
0.2614994049,
0.3735785484,
-0.4437586367,
-0.4516495764,
-0.1551232189,
0.2361826301,
-0.4237680733,
-0.5713953972,
-0.9452063441,
0.1498883069,
-0.1669916511,
0.3869256079,
-0.0796139017,
0.29096964,
-0.27085042,
0.1291024089,
-0.6375877261,
-0.5340779424,
-0.4355382323,
-0.451010406,
0.4582230747,
0.4632736444,
0.5280098915,
0.0974253193,
0.3166708946,
0.3741748035,
-0.1342750341,
0.4227261245,
-0.5138326287,
0.326723367,
-0.1146829948,
-0.5115894079,
-0.3820050061,
0.1072199419,
1.0097881556,
1.01755476,
-0.111513637,
0.1127106473,
0.2767730057,
0.6187935472,
-0.9942247868,
0.2742140293,
-0.7628019452,
-0.103140451,
-0.1491247565,
-0.2316867858,
-0.6470224857,
-0.6867191792,
0.1073861793,
-0.2649886906,
-0.12726973,
0.1698048264,
0.4913259149,
0.2427066118,
-0.7028820515,
-0.4153147042,
-0.9295521379,
1.3441637754,
-0.8707588315,
0.4301051199,
0.3894475996,
0.3147434294,
-0.577393055,
-0.4953139424,
-0.2642059028,
-0.2540511489,
0.3031754494,
-0.0001992773,
0.0326489508,
-0.0532884896,
-0.0313498154,
0.3516743779,
-0.3271196187,
0.5367993116,
-0.0455355607,
-0.4891520143,
0.7115315795,
0.1721880734,
0.0603166446,
0.1305885613,
-0.0908134505,
-0.0606897734,
-0.9414989948,
-0.1801434904,
0.4086412489,
0.2085760087,
-0.0999722779,
0.5986591578,
-0.0234377962,
0.8238836527,
-0.1948064864,
-0.5463479757,
0.2383940369,
-0.2336271256,
-0.1505025327,
-0.1072136089,
0.7651714683,
0.3398644924,
0.3890985847,
-0.041356571,
-0.221019581,
-0.3869839013,
-0.1774516404,
-0.4896049798,
0.1295484751,
0.2744627595,
0.0323794298,
-0.198728621,
0.1684624404,
-0.8117933273,
-0.8268386722,
-0.0690912977,
0.2729588449,
-0.1160746887,
-0.2758481801,
0.1476534307,
0.1136343926,
0.3598733544,
0.4566048384,
-0.8528827429,
-0.0188594982,
0.9389994144,
0.6435318589,
-0.1346015185,
-0.0635360032,
-0.3485242128,
-0.0243566651,
-0.5767096877,
0.4898303449,
-0.3367753327,
-0.5578366518,
0.374866128,
0.0837497488,
-0.2304583937,
-0.5237737298,
0.6446180344,
-0.4986102283,
0.0584605262,
-0.1588746309,
-0.7332898974,
-0.1769376397,
0.6102517843,
-0.5571603179,
0.9945703149,
0.0544539765,
-0.7309097648,
-0.0008692141,
0.2101479322,
-0.1177880317,
-0.0051192902,
-0.279679507,
-0.3092828393,
0.3628005981,
0.0721067414,
0.6537037492,
-0.7208990455,
0.3398907781,
-0.452178359,
-0.43893525,
0.6603783965,
-0.6930431128,
0.7595213056,
0.1534778476,
-0.0919302702,
-0.1116411984,
-0.6913601756,
0.2256455123,
-0.1387250721,
-0.230158329,
-0.1784343123,
0.1447359771,
-0.1619972289,
0.1186965629,
0.5330194235,
-0.6382793188,
0.0702226236,
-0.2147038877,
0.451859653,
0.6283689141,
0.0585015528,
0.1772987396,
-0.2357922643,
0.6683187485,
-0.2276568562,
0.0050163921,
0.0406427979,
-0.5003855228,
-0.5263627768,
-0.0053397715,
0.5857037306,
0.4829166532,
-0.5561050177,
0.6757231355,
-0.6152197123,
-0.7790328264,
-0.1426189393,
0.3338134289,
0.2841444314,
0.2164214849,
-0.0191160664,
-0.0702138469,
-0.4489738345,
-0.6874727607,
-0.1178319752,
-0.4556676149,
-0.1356678307,
0.2209374458,
0.3084614873,
-0.0806056634,
0.6725493073,
-0.4021523297,
-0.0140432613,
-0.2437215447,
0.1894548237,
0.1160303354,
0.3692800403,
0.2418027818,
-0.6341174841,
-0.497508049,
0.043860428,
-0.5763026476,
0.0109424498,
0.1570120454,
0.281080246,
0.2552160323,
0.5595278144,
-0.5614606738,
0.030515641,
1.2272455692,
0.1402759701,
0.6194633842,
-0.1954016387,
0.2259754539,
-0.9301276803,
0.0131902499,
0.2410297245,
-0.4241458774,
-0.5539295673,
0.0374113545,
0.176400423,
0.6121709347,
-0.4162668586,
0.5138180256,
-0.7045046091,
-0.1844717413,
-0.1283375025,
0.3927011788,
-0.1381350756,
-0.2118808031,
-0.141614154,
0.7974828482,
0.5166922808,
-0.3522765636,
0.4783034027,
0.0196673237,
-0.7510715127,
0.5699319839,
-0.3786609173,
0.2038695216,
0.0505562872,
0.3719914556,
-1.220023036,
-0.383489877,
-0.0217188671,
-0.4880681038,
0.6810590625,
-0.0720452741,
-0.5778039098,
-0.4686210155,
-0.4077860713,
0.2832051218,
0.5697599649,
-0.1933561116,
0.650016129,
0.5333673358,
-0.3642416596,
-0.8708773851,
-0.7507132888,
0.3008871973,
-0.004777554,
-0.5321305394,
-0.1273105592,
-0.1150882766,
-0.5782227516,
-0.4087010622,
-0.0958998948,
-0.065506652,
-0.0366114154,
0.4553346932,
0.4111050665,
-0.1432446837,
0.1915424317,
-0.3762768209,
0.1108278185,
0.0180783793,
0.041256655,
0.6026123166,
0.016344836,
-0.4700934887,
-0.1779875159,
-0.1317394227,
0.6057026982,
-0.0853781253,
0.7821040154,
0.3577658832,
-0.2811034024,
-0.2517861426,
-1.1720384359,
0.0528961606,
-0.4867424071,
0.4510276318,
-0.0706641823,
-1.1482534409,
0.4256547093,
-0.2570187151,
0.15807648,
0.3929017782,
0.6929346323,
0.0089352466,
0.9063047171,
0.7737535834,
-0.1674302518,
0.1929539442,
0.1160971299,
0.2606463432,
-0.7439125776,
-0.2642909884,
-0.8264372945,
-0.0242694281,
-0.7191371322,
-0.6333017349,
0.3856158853,
-0.1158861294,
-0.1638814211,
-0.0087751364,
-0.0031272185,
0.1971409321,
0.2694754004,
-0.1390701681,
0.4204958379,
-0.2024970353,
0.0352796949,
-0.1980910897,
-0.4710396528,
-0.7129042149,
1.1601521969,
0.6644180417,
0.97702384,
-0.0971347988,
0.4462798834,
-0.0919552743,
0.508528471,
-0.8621264696,
0.5725783706,
-0.1954133958,
-0.8549414277,
-0.4628070891,
-0.667878449,
-0.5818035603,
-0.0418521725,
-0.0101457778,
-0.9574251771,
0.1754151583,
0.2110019326,
-0.3668752909,
0.360006243,
-0.4877034426,
0.4881204069,
-0.2364321649,
-0.2205246836,
-0.0984237567,
-0.5926537514,
0.684705317,
-0.473970443,
0.3403330445,
-0.4409107864,
-0.1008761674,
0.4851016998,
-0.2155093998,
0.7607914805,
-0.0743654594,
-0.523707211,
0.4505367279,
-0.1271643937,
0.6294866204,
-0.2410358489,
-0.672654748,
0.0214768387,
0.2950243652,
-0.1572874784,
-0.2901274562,
0.9799938798,
-0.4633691907,
-0.5709844232,
-0.5487914085,
-0.8309788108,
-0.8975919485,
-0.0031100807,
0.068321608,
0.158540234,
-0.3298796713,
0.6998366714,
0.6556360722,
-0.3846313059,
0.560772717,
0.347479254,
-0.2261938602,
-0.3408725262,
0.6993235946,
0.2157721072,
0.6545443535,
0.3756218255,
-0.0500582159,
-0.4380933344,
-0.7259799242,
-0.1875138879,
0.3384371102,
-0.7436119318,
-0.1912893951,
-0.2587144375,
-0.3035366237,
-0.5820443034,
0.0643421561,
-0.464633435,
-0.2238391936,
-0.1974462718,
-0.1115660444,
0.1724524498,
0.902631402,
0.1708971709,
0.3811207414,
-0.8119750023,
-0.1498425901,
0.3269345164,
0.2046701908,
-0.0140578393,
-0.5442878008,
-0.0594101064,
0.2378054261,
-0.1730498075,
-0.7248146534,
0.3839683235,
0.0567571558,
0.5585809946,
0.2117290646,
0.0323170535,
0.5257159472,
-0.4014251232,
1.0081157684,
0.1802943498,
-0.7868270278,
-0.0677733794,
-0.0633501038,
0.1871521771,
0.6963695288,
0.5245422721,
-0.5249433517,
-0.1881299615,
-0.1099114269,
-0.6316450834,
0.2117760777,
-0.2503385246,
0.2415330708,
0.3409902453,
0.2563910484,
-0.1283693761,
0.2315996438,
-0.447152108,
-0.1831043959,
0.4461903274,
-0.4955365062,
-0.5086013675,
-0.5313398838,
-0.0034154207,
-0.0214529708,
0.8940161467,
-0.1252414137,
-0.1212111339,
-0.2088452727,
-0.1288196743,
-0.2911986709,
0.4515688419,
0.513645649,
1.0054866076,
-0.2263264507,
0.248651877,
0.3713996112,
-0.577028513,
0.3022949696,
0.071336925,
-0.1582612395,
0.0119873201,
0.4208691418,
0.4519883692,
0.437954843,
-0.8685202599,
0.6953162551,
0.0493859388,
-0.2172644585,
-0.5486087203,
-0.1358003467,
0.3802954853,
0.0949242711,
0.4534301758,
-0.423045069,
-0.2848247886,
-0.5987314582,
-0.1339514554,
0.7521042824,
-0.5642982125,
-0.1412893385,
0.3420259953,
-0.0617759861,
0.094379425,
0.4428358972,
0.13295421,
-0.3558497131,
0.4215381444,
0.3743869662,
0.7971305251,
-0.5131717324,
0.0919864774,
0.2653145492,
0.4541431963,
-0.4603449404,
0.3063737452,
0.4700467885,
-0.8949911594,
-0.6114743948,
-0.8376854658,
-0.8090529442,
0.2372246087,
-0.3791379035,
0.1926328987,
-0.2570944726,
-0.3491711617,
-0.1032604277,
0.2449349612,
-0.5835154057,
0.2437346131,
0.2722064853,
1.0628418922,
-0.755954206,
0.7482082248,
0.4756491482,
-0.0537947714,
-0.9223352671,
-0.0795678571,
0.2074128836,
-0.8079454899,
0.4993661344,
0.1253867298,
-0.4924636781,
0.1266319156,
-0.7552983165,
-0.7853274345,
1.0900303125,
0.3999216557,
-0.8063041568,
-0.1943402439,
0.3424500823,
0.4433576763,
-0.277884692,
0.2112661004,
0.6324216127,
0.7815325856,
0.2726714015,
-0.9621453881,
-0.2076588273,
0.1328344196,
0.1401409507,
-0.0262612924,
-0.4391621351,
0.624029696,
0.095425956,
-0.1758721769,
0.5589971542,
0.5502612591,
0.4129432738,
0.1630490571,
0.619428575,
0.175948292,
0.565993607,
-0.3860983551,
0.9448267221,
-0.5997990966,
0.2975961268,
1.0704796314,
-0.5623472333,
1.0326304436,
0.5259911418,
-0.3758719563,
0.211109668,
0.605643034,
0.0687019601,
-0.1394644231,
0.30259794,
-0.5343292356,
-0.4261708856,
-0.2073908001,
-0.225852862,
0.2872310281,
0.7050973773,
-0.4083897173,
-0.0543042086,
-0.2646919787,
0.0592485592,
-0.0113928504,
-0.4049184918,
0.4457315803,
0.3932648301,
-0.8315785527,
0.3232894242,
0.0393651165,
0.8068206906,
-0.721318841,
0.0828036368,
0.0479281843,
0.2306473851,
-0.1786082238,
-0.8675962687,
-0.217347309,
-0.0291355848,
0.3171542585,
-0.0801763758,
0.6594913602,
-0.4900180399,
-0.6068854928,
0.0604971759,
0.6979455352,
0.206991747,
-0.061365746,
-0.2914749086,
0.5134797692,
-0.1281827092,
-0.3174456358,
0.0521333069,
0.2937784493,
0.1647472978,
0.8677690029,
0.2286403626,
0.3345047235,
0.4141425788,
-0.0103759617,
0.3687010705,
-0.4770852923,
0.1071282029,
-0.7176566124,
0.3303714097,
0.0100544561,
-0.2246400416,
1.044310689,
0.4697081447,
0.5845491886,
-0.0089933807,
0.7965583801,
0.1995933503,
0.6842526793,
-0.384359777,
0.588168025,
-0.3684789836,
0.2230171859,
-0.2403992563,
-1.1400191784,
-0.5420621037,
0.3497009873,
-0.5469210744,
0.2145713717,
0.5174114704,
0.9828056097,
0.2460911721,
-0.1021408141,
0.5514856577,
0.3834396303,
0.2396998554,
0.5132474303,
0.9245421886,
-0.3309188187,
0.243193686,
-0.2672764361,
-0.2050540894,
-0.3189764321,
-1.25884974,
-0.498259902,
-0.3872735202,
-0.2664502263,
-0.2511495948,
0.0105465967,
0.8805295229,
0.5992082953,
-1.0523581505,
-0.388292104,
0.2171186209,
0.0362698212,
0.1194932014,
-0.0669568181,
0.1471050233,
-0.1082713008,
-1.0825014114,
0.4178916812,
0.2928659916,
0.1225195751,
-0.7184889317,
-0.0909298956,
-0.2336895168,
0.1622539461,
0.5434409976,
0.5540345907,
-0.7403957844,
-0.5416796207,
-0.0693394691,
-0.4706830978,
-0.1079079062,
0.5406324267,
-0.2768431306,
0.3567910492,
0.5273215175,
0.8420243263,
0.2742792964,
-0.000664214,
0.7054638863,
-0.6884393096,
-0.1427369267,
0.1504968256,
0.5146788359,
0.7603838444,
-0.0026066729,
0.5297827721,
-0.0930290371,
-0.7880814075,
-1.0745944977,
0.1456860602,
-0.8966253996,
0.0749414042,
1.2960970402,
-0.345074147,
-0.0185657647,
-0.1135901883,
0.0928770676,
0.1899383664,
0.1350104213,
0.4472814798,
1.1464014053,
0.2990499139,
-0.198192209,
-0.9034370184,
0.1525698304,
0.3487441838,
-0.8091179132,
0.1898372769,
0.7261514068,
0.3990726769,
0.2378426641,
0.3405839503,
-0.357150048,
-0.1231972054,
-0.256153971,
-0.0023630622,
0.3127959669,
-0.2871419191,
-0.5693544149,
0.2022182345,
0.5863845944,
0.2702738643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08287v1
|
How Well Do Large Language Models Understand Syntax? An Evaluation by Asking Natural Language Questions
| 2023-11-14T16:30:36 | 2023-11-14T16:30:36 |
Houquan Zhou, Yang Hou, Zhenghua Li, Xuebin Wang, Zhefeng Wang, Xinyu Duan, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) bring us closer to
achieving artificial general intelligence, the question persists: Do LLMs truly
understand language, or do they merely mimic comprehension through pattern
recognition? This study seeks to explore this question through the lens of
syntax, a crucial component of sentence comprehension. Adopting a natural
language question-answering (Q&A) scheme, we craft questions targeting nine
syntactic knowledge points that are most closely related to sentence
comprehension. Experiments conducted on 24 LLMs suggest that most have a
limited grasp of syntactic knowledge, exhibiting notable discrepancies across
different syntactic knowledge points. In particular, questions involving
prepositional phrase attachment pose the greatest challenge, whereas those
concerning adjectival modifier and indirect object are relatively easier for
LLMs to handle. Furthermore, a case study on the training dynamics of the LLMs
reveals that the majority of syntactic knowledge is learned during the initial
stages of training, hinting that simply increasing the number of training
tokens may not be the `silver bullet' for improving the comprehension ability
of LLMs.
|
[
-0.1857481003,
-1.1803792715,
1.1201387644,
0.1180021316,
-0.4202385247,
0.2299157977,
-0.2479542196,
-0.4701488018,
-0.2300606519,
0.4204789102,
-0.6337459683,
-0.3245897591,
-0.4827943146,
0.2395438105,
-0.5606805086,
0.5724417567,
-0.0408320501,
0.1186649799,
-0.3126524985,
0.0087160366,
-0.2892360985,
-0.6766673923,
-0.5574609637,
-0.3027700782,
0.3733078837,
0.0367470123,
0.486189425,
0.6212103367,
0.4646210074,
0.3710715473,
-0.3716662228,
0.0097761825,
-0.2369814366,
-0.0239816159,
-0.1436080933,
-0.9477472305,
0.0350767262,
-0.0369141512,
0.6755596995,
1.1483695507,
-0.1110111549,
0.1387653053,
-0.1689694524,
0.7301541567,
-0.3061331809,
0.2518949211,
-0.9081573486,
0.0882727057,
-0.014381662,
-0.0126079349,
-0.4662970901,
-0.1775739342,
0.1905962825,
-0.6541928649,
0.0396768302,
0.1309168339,
0.8408318162,
0.2957831621,
-0.6060365438,
-0.3694101274,
-0.4343905151,
0.421823442,
-0.3846133947,
0.3080898225,
0.2821125686,
0.2450214326,
-0.0598520525,
-0.6761094332,
-0.7555987835,
-0.3058507442,
-0.3596451581,
-0.1162564009,
-0.0686876029,
-0.0131689468,
0.390458107,
0.2093496174,
-0.7687271237,
0.0642194524,
-0.3089018464,
0.0409425683,
0.4180091918,
0.1679828614,
0.589125216,
-0.2003482431,
-0.5006113648,
0.1959091276,
-0.6814560294,
0.2083108425,
0.0602601357,
0.0345835909,
-0.0523029603,
0.5076926947,
0.0771841183,
1.0276703835,
-0.3369631767,
0.1148457006,
-0.0546138287,
-0.5781672001,
-0.307582438,
-0.2785446048,
0.6429411173,
0.0345277488,
1.0289396048,
-0.2732631862,
-0.140072763,
0.065053165,
0.3402403593,
-0.3086742759,
-0.0027613542,
0.0262908116,
-0.0934483185,
0.0459950045,
0.1588074118,
-0.1700406969,
-0.3496076763,
-0.5804783106,
0.4453592598,
-0.3704410791,
-0.087379612,
0.3561574817,
-0.3305616081,
0.7098417282,
0.4134214222,
-0.9023884535,
0.1985130608,
0.8334228992,
0.5759911537,
0.170268178,
-0.3773467541,
-0.3363834023,
0.0583264753,
-0.5318019986,
0.7403200865,
-0.586907804,
-0.1308828294,
0.032949619,
0.0562237538,
-0.6531672478,
-0.6871880293,
-0.0751155242,
-0.7466207743,
0.2100201696,
-0.282314688,
-0.6124418378,
-0.2356100231,
0.31152004,
-0.4119637012,
0.3604616523,
0.2046869099,
-0.5109938979,
0.3252252638,
-0.4754013419,
-0.4549520612,
0.0175005384,
-0.2269193232,
0.1200556904,
0.1742679626,
0.2920103967,
0.5335301757,
-0.2267250121,
0.2578232884,
-0.1597514302,
-0.3730149269,
0.63740623,
-0.2047666311,
0.6076868773,
-0.123567462,
-0.0091357604,
0.036976859,
-0.6310394406,
-0.0342911258,
0.3735576272,
-0.2628428042,
-0.1048085093,
-0.2011546642,
-0.3579886258,
0.1696186364,
0.0188022964,
-0.2266781926,
0.3651717901,
-0.6135244966,
0.9428217411,
0.6822417974,
0.2722151577,
0.6880887747,
-0.1660994589,
0.6903863549,
-0.1178796068,
-0.0462919995,
-0.3073048294,
-0.1703602821,
-0.849829793,
0.1246082187,
0.1632192433,
0.5618076921,
-0.5628118515,
0.2559253275,
-0.1293990165,
-0.2305230945,
-0.3619756401,
0.6545189023,
0.3820694685,
0.3209542334,
0.2482915819,
0.1720790267,
-0.3808551133,
-0.8295084238,
-0.4563520849,
-0.3264359832,
0.1069541723,
0.1705533862,
0.6545495987,
-0.0282903593,
0.7544075847,
-0.5615637898,
-0.0296107195,
-0.8062183857,
-0.1833514571,
0.1401380152,
-0.0113234166,
0.5907925367,
-0.7715619206,
-0.4380844235,
-0.1564044058,
-0.8787596226,
0.1026463956,
-0.1870118529,
-0.1397011876,
-0.0484165661,
0.9735699296,
-0.9353992939,
0.0032798566,
0.3822280765,
-0.4724904001,
0.3519697785,
-0.0539486744,
-0.3526327014,
-0.8199032545,
0.0804865882,
-0.0810280889,
-0.2469131052,
-0.7458880544,
0.3062918782,
0.0377200022,
-0.0057331976,
-0.4403836727,
0.6255850196,
-0.4233593643,
-0.1065573692,
0.1009230316,
0.3490523398,
0.2612020373,
0.4971535802,
-0.0516221859,
0.823369503,
0.4521056116,
-0.5292280316,
0.2749251425,
0.1707837731,
-0.4567826092,
0.1480918527,
-0.8291095495,
0.2750293612,
-0.3969758153,
0.115832381,
-0.9578951001,
-0.4223578274,
0.0254296102,
-0.3089064658,
0.2445558161,
-0.1734752804,
-0.4523489177,
-0.2531313002,
0.0853703767,
0.133713156,
0.5926235318,
-0.3715600669,
0.5152891874,
0.2052012682,
-0.0992167443,
-0.4625382423,
-0.6010703444,
-0.0313484371,
-0.2130776048,
-0.655610323,
-0.1361663938,
-0.0184747148,
-0.8015887141,
-0.2089916617,
-0.1150127426,
-0.1416078955,
0.539829731,
0.0949928388,
0.0386175402,
-0.3993245959,
0.5098147988,
-0.3795211017,
0.0052055614,
0.3785294294,
-0.2249132395,
0.8961254358,
-0.1189505458,
-0.295535624,
-0.3023451269,
0.0635288358,
0.630145967,
-0.4238693118,
0.7653817534,
0.2562501431,
-0.106256336,
-0.5690541267,
-0.3497553766,
-0.0030091275,
-0.4128649533,
0.348410368,
-0.3976962268,
-0.7224569321,
0.4734672308,
0.2107984722,
-0.269936204,
0.3571304381,
0.3561292291,
-0.4337423444,
0.8700410724,
0.4668751061,
-0.0855033323,
0.382912606,
-0.4198659956,
0.1793442219,
-0.6200411916,
-0.2679646909,
-0.3407699466,
-0.1554873735,
0.0011113093,
-0.365949899,
0.1746969223,
0.3840914369,
-0.2363506854,
0.2525902092,
0.0061462722,
0.6413040757,
0.4609393775,
-0.0759601519,
0.2664844394,
-0.3519693315,
0.1032236218,
0.3532686532,
-0.4277101755,
-0.6693257093,
0.751614809,
0.2746699452,
0.6603001952,
0.0774952993,
0.5810677409,
-0.1537139714,
-0.1857055873,
-0.7458471656,
0.7711319327,
0.00391383,
-0.3806056082,
-0.2195216119,
-0.2777937651,
-0.9223919511,
0.2570929527,
-0.0441237949,
-0.5272126198,
-0.1461786777,
0.1177319586,
-0.2984419465,
0.1389158517,
-1.0335487127,
1.0213298798,
-0.3195858598,
0.1894482225,
-0.0383317545,
-0.7871641517,
0.2419765443,
-0.1070866883,
0.2809053361,
-0.092617929,
-0.0645400956,
0.5894339681,
-0.2166897804,
0.6239638925,
-0.04074388,
-0.0492629409,
0.3244567513,
0.0108117042,
0.1885350347,
0.1176428944,
0.0948016047,
-0.2401532978,
-0.0580357462,
-0.3380858302,
-0.8821901083,
0.1940269768,
-0.7236186862,
-0.7263332009,
-0.174820751,
-0.5649927258,
-0.2945220768,
0.0488251001,
0.0552054793,
0.4319854975,
-0.0908067673,
0.1474189907,
0.5283785462,
-0.1965320706,
0.4541364312,
0.484806776,
-0.2474576384,
0.0080601135,
0.5647674799,
-0.0043604905,
0.6573169827,
0.6856598854,
0.1365047246,
-0.34163481,
-0.6678016186,
-0.361813277,
0.5385713577,
-0.9125186205,
0.1323387176,
-0.8053845167,
-0.3879800141,
-0.2280527502,
-0.1298594028,
0.3179189861,
-0.267878592,
-0.4018599689,
-0.2523778975,
0.3305059075,
1.0852987766,
0.593773067,
0.2866784334,
-0.6844494939,
0.3666655123,
0.5115081668,
-0.0046112896,
-0.2258800417,
-0.5576803088,
0.0350328907,
-0.1288076192,
0.1459752321,
-0.8173511028,
0.1727133244,
0.3917327523,
0.5357379913,
0.268011719,
-0.2449311614,
0.6005647182,
-0.5164334178,
0.9014679193,
-0.123668395,
-0.8113890886,
0.593721807,
-0.3223772645,
0.4817606509,
0.5134584904,
0.3703518212,
-0.4915080965,
-0.6348628402,
-0.490037322,
-0.4564599693,
0.4735362232,
-0.2119867802,
0.4447798133,
-0.135217011,
0.4942741096,
-0.1506566107,
0.3478759527,
-0.8852572441,
0.0808925927,
0.1193354577,
-0.3041235209,
-0.3652630448,
-0.0898130462,
-0.0179053377,
-0.2677114904,
0.1104550958,
-0.1399494112,
0.09576004,
0.0093396623,
-0.6909230351,
0.051110357,
0.4516792893,
0.5124385953,
1.1228165627,
-0.0175361373,
0.2157713026,
0.0892131031,
-0.3495056629,
0.0735925883,
-0.1759264618,
0.0500446446,
-0.180358544,
0.8922818899,
0.7552338839,
0.101000756,
-0.9014239907,
0.6214768887,
-0.0543882549,
-0.3432342708,
-0.3283392787,
0.3534667492,
0.3563963771,
0.2442067564,
0.2744901776,
-0.1942525208,
-0.311602205,
-1.061534524,
0.0750991106,
0.6303293109,
-0.0175949335,
-0.2657212913,
0.3795124888,
-0.0598111413,
-0.3777271211,
0.6571957469,
-0.1213144585,
-0.9548967481,
0.7546287775,
0.5258741379,
0.4087635577,
0.1636529267,
0.1773857772,
0.0859783888,
0.312332958,
0.0850888416,
0.395465225,
0.047312066,
-0.8647354245,
-0.4914129376,
-0.8406536579,
-0.2720216215,
0.017383866,
-0.4885918498,
0.1359376758,
-0.7242460251,
0.2463999689,
0.1699024886,
-0.1433859915,
-0.7888929248,
0.1824623346,
0.1212864965,
1.1360772848,
-0.8803617954,
0.6825388074,
0.8172125816,
-0.6926962733,
-1.0998610258,
0.0629227906,
-0.2262922376,
-1.220110178,
0.9031865597,
0.2883021235,
0.2450949848,
0.230533734,
-0.5289860964,
-0.5928406119,
0.7711239457,
0.4762761593,
-0.506908536,
-0.4809482992,
0.1178133935,
0.6053367853,
-0.1373686343,
0.0933714807,
0.7615263462,
0.4074339569,
-0.0997410044,
-0.8587250113,
-0.1409456432,
-0.2068824619,
-0.2526808381,
0.4531979859,
-0.3349066973,
0.9142480493,
-0.3668096662,
-0.2039698511,
0.0723247454,
0.2867189646,
-0.1466234326,
0.2045866102,
0.5461655259,
0.534319222,
0.5760666132,
-0.2825086415,
1.1901606321,
-0.2629233599,
0.0931611508,
0.7481749654,
-0.2329610288,
0.9525800347,
0.5446326733,
-0.3251207769,
0.7447650433,
0.419272095,
0.0567664616,
0.2652778924,
0.4164871573,
-0.0844356716,
-0.5512427688,
0.049057316,
-0.1498360038,
0.6571081877,
0.32506603,
-0.4004294276,
-0.1364958733,
0.1329919994,
-0.1833964884,
0.4382596612,
-0.3032495975,
1.3503782749,
0.3131342828,
-0.7468835115,
0.486954987,
-0.3017466366,
0.1421924084,
-0.7890834212,
0.0266119633,
-0.1696750373,
0.1445195228,
0.0770591199,
-1.0267686844,
0.24219127,
-0.0426458344,
-0.0519054234,
-0.1997681111,
0.5099811554,
-0.4742003083,
-0.3050866127,
0.3557143211,
0.7266649604,
0.0733323768,
-0.1341090947,
-0.5349801779,
-0.0082277087,
-0.2988649011,
-0.049288515,
0.302675277,
0.4799815118,
0.1931974888,
0.8549262285,
0.5505111814,
0.196878314,
0.1367373019,
0.28281039,
0.7713108063,
-0.7940659523,
-0.4105428755,
-1.0368144512,
0.4207399487,
0.0252513457,
-0.213190183,
0.5894274116,
0.0715524554,
0.8331891894,
-0.1039719582,
0.5325930715,
0.2241980433,
0.4321427345,
-0.8545794487,
0.3943608999,
-0.5295735598,
0.1704472601,
0.0156319458,
-0.8408331275,
-0.3440662026,
0.8096485734,
-0.6141049862,
-0.0815186724,
0.7612733841,
0.5628793836,
0.0941132903,
-0.0372279286,
0.2845590115,
0.3037651181,
0.2201013714,
0.7089439631,
1.2669531107,
-0.0221733954,
0.4750644267,
0.1090318635,
0.3276803792,
0.0437186956,
-0.4891356826,
-0.9939948916,
-0.3684303463,
0.0814336911,
-0.038687598,
0.1905777603,
1.0402699709,
0.4473085701,
-0.4890996218,
-0.1312419772,
-0.4599980414,
0.212311402,
0.1628453732,
-0.1845374703,
0.2331349999,
-0.8843171597,
-0.4810157418,
0.4384107292,
0.3707690537,
0.1010291725,
-0.269312799,
0.0937525779,
-0.4245112538,
-0.0387765393,
0.5914654136,
0.0548575968,
-0.8538953662,
-0.2994818687,
0.3021097481,
-0.1612012386,
-0.1135686263,
0.7923142314,
-0.7291727066,
0.2571222484,
0.4422591627,
0.7328273058,
-0.0441426523,
0.1445180923,
0.5684321523,
-0.7295963168,
0.0803830847,
0.2269283235,
0.5749501586,
0.2021740526,
-0.122600697,
0.4020866156,
0.2920641303,
-0.455999136,
-0.7749769092,
0.344655782,
-0.8712138534,
-0.495528847,
1.2944004536,
0.0404259488,
-0.2503334582,
-0.2254724652,
-0.2469871491,
-0.1724793166,
0.1900746077,
0.2467966527,
0.7073175907,
0.0560288057,
-0.2286997288,
-0.7230286002,
0.450086683,
0.46601215,
-0.7771783471,
0.114603214,
0.3023033738,
0.4170330167,
-0.0631174222,
0.5505900383,
0.2359074503,
0.2952179015,
-0.3581774235,
-0.4939291477,
0.1548180282,
-0.4267929792,
-0.5606057048,
0.1410412937,
0.5222310424,
0.0146331182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08273v1
|
Examining Modularity in Multilingual LMs via Language-Specialized Subnetworks
| 2023-11-14T16:11:23 | 2023-11-14T16:11:23 |
Rochelle Choenni, Ekaterina Shutova, Dan Garrette
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has proposed explicitly inducing language-wise modularity in
multilingual LMs via sparse fine-tuning (SFT) on per-language subnetworks as a
means of better guiding cross-lingual sharing. In this work, we investigate (1)
the degree to which language-wise modularity naturally arises within models
with no special modularity interventions, and (2) how cross-lingual sharing and
interference differ between such models and those with explicit SFT-guided
subnetwork modularity. To quantify language specialization and cross-lingual
interaction, we use a Training Data Attribution method that estimates the
degree to which a model's predictions are influenced by in-language or
cross-language training examples. Our results show that language-specialized
subnetworks do naturally arise, and that SFT, rather than always increasing
modularity, can decrease language specialization of subnetworks in favor of
more cross-lingual sharing.
|
[
-0.570553124,
-0.9192106128,
0.2963564396,
0.07035546,
-0.1993746608,
-0.058996316,
-0.2529936731,
-0.537303865,
0.5506622195,
0.1897060871,
-0.6645435691,
-0.16875346,
-0.3353470862,
0.2233550251,
-0.1228825301,
0.8985273838,
0.0787206143,
0.2139024734,
-0.2797151208,
-0.154587552,
-0.3178644478,
-0.7231223583,
-0.4701167345,
-0.3756416738,
0.8839475513,
0.4379114211,
0.7611781955,
0.4240487516,
0.1140528619,
0.3513082862,
-0.1380471289,
0.2694978714,
-0.434720844,
-0.2559429109,
-0.3215991259,
-0.6510435939,
-0.6334664822,
-0.3057728112,
0.9209742546,
0.840105176,
0.0353186242,
0.1346167028,
0.0923598632,
0.5969803929,
-0.2743460536,
0.1670595258,
-0.6787518859,
0.2721470892,
-0.2695960104,
-0.1376388818,
-0.2351577729,
0.0389737785,
-0.0700818077,
-0.3558377624,
0.1663305014,
-0.0855880082,
0.5105851293,
0.0658776462,
-0.53610605,
0.1331979632,
-0.2114922702,
0.9119265079,
-0.7400499582,
0.3577502966,
0.5559844971,
-0.0788131952,
0.1202854291,
-0.2631908953,
-0.3180989623,
-0.2136959285,
-0.4585295916,
-0.1383332312,
-0.1770405918,
0.193090722,
0.1964529902,
0.3789807558,
-0.5886354446,
0.3200490773,
-0.5989003778,
-0.1120401025,
0.4989336133,
0.2055506855,
0.5696759224,
-0.3582919836,
-0.2406597435,
0.575150609,
-0.7963616252,
0.1054220721,
0.6704418063,
0.4095624983,
-0.1277685314,
0.6295082569,
-0.2716144919,
0.6348136067,
0.1170151308,
0.1813607514,
0.3027852476,
-0.6635575891,
-0.2370019257,
-0.1200285926,
0.6547461748,
-0.0622141138,
0.6510841846,
-0.3428452015,
-0.5044438243,
-0.4646651149,
0.0231851023,
-0.3338553309,
-0.2784006596,
0.0371381938,
-0.4965317547,
-0.1454864293,
0.008177029,
0.2051306665,
-0.1121618599,
-0.4995509386,
0.5013987422,
-0.2411927581,
-0.7320075631,
0.1061257422,
-0.0514137149,
-0.123243928,
0.0168837272,
-1.2358239889,
0.2473704666,
0.7172408104,
0.7724699974,
-0.4933280945,
-0.8794565797,
-0.3635002077,
0.005396279,
-0.4140483141,
0.8475174308,
-0.3934926391,
-0.1520839483,
-0.0953780115,
0.3866860867,
-0.485016197,
-0.709156692,
-0.1695474982,
-0.4132378995,
-0.095406957,
-0.3899377882,
-0.4116056859,
-0.1808355451,
0.4009318352,
-0.7473059893,
0.8180875778,
0.0726385638,
-0.6639788747,
0.4789767861,
-0.3994286954,
-0.5427394509,
0.1364798248,
-0.2707630098,
-0.1348589957,
0.3448123634,
-0.0782173052,
0.6010022759,
0.0961383805,
0.2767751217,
-0.2494801283,
-0.4719744325,
0.2744597197,
-0.3805053532,
0.5667923093,
-0.1051774174,
-0.1630524993,
0.3070599437,
-0.6261748672,
0.0834703147,
-0.3246474266,
-0.4247254431,
-0.3830119669,
0.062773101,
0.0175309666,
0.3001439571,
0.3440008461,
-0.3631512225,
0.3163276613,
-0.2325361669,
0.3877829015,
0.7121055126,
-0.1191265881,
0.6816828847,
-0.4827985168,
0.562332809,
0.2490303516,
0.1868720502,
-0.1218068972,
-0.5947531462,
-0.6046223044,
-0.4599510729,
0.1569230855,
0.4123176038,
-0.6648323536,
0.1921086758,
-0.2159724981,
-0.2106816769,
-0.2089985609,
0.2465266138,
0.4697725475,
0.0104359929,
0.3414292336,
-0.4711411595,
-0.3392670155,
-1.4395591021,
-0.2253645658,
0.1485030651,
0.2200752795,
0.3096040785,
0.3696038723,
-0.3260981143,
0.8829520345,
-0.0301405843,
-0.0752494186,
-0.6006464958,
0.2729422152,
-0.0381177515,
0.8439809084,
0.7413707376,
-0.7228301167,
-0.8210629821,
0.4195172787,
-0.4220830202,
-0.1120648906,
0.0301097054,
0.2133950889,
0.4917152226,
0.4944659173,
-0.4469379187,
0.2153969556,
0.5419649482,
-0.0124299005,
0.6440991163,
-0.2214595526,
0.2513070405,
-0.9206338525,
-0.110036552,
-0.355746299,
-0.3638543189,
-0.8767073154,
0.0785660744,
0.1163234338,
0.1657531559,
-0.5208041072,
0.2785120308,
-0.5315229297,
-0.3565607667,
-0.1327849329,
-0.1671131998,
-0.1950124055,
0.7866147757,
0.2280287445,
0.6203725338,
0.4441641271,
-0.3339650929,
0.0760739893,
-0.2306115478,
-0.4279361665,
0.3029265404,
-0.6610301137,
-0.0560361929,
0.1088915169,
0.0630768761,
-0.8025371432,
-0.1008890495,
-0.018476218,
-0.1703717262,
0.2503873408,
-0.6116141677,
-0.6635411382,
0.2603944838,
-0.2559916675,
0.8686965108,
0.0372677296,
-0.1538755,
0.3555688262,
0.3342067897,
-0.2287130952,
-0.5901739001,
-1.1905896664,
-0.1019222662,
0.0211929306,
-0.8030297756,
-0.0799604654,
-0.2061691433,
-0.0937828571,
0.0201283898,
-0.1535098851,
-0.3855846226,
0.0120048635,
0.0140083563,
-0.0333410315,
-0.566458106,
0.0734852552,
0.4312577248,
-0.0589470454,
-0.0861487687,
-0.3511807323,
0.5203015208,
-0.2665976882,
-0.7569271922,
-0.4796979725,
0.6012753248,
0.338188678,
-0.2031618357,
0.8337103128,
0.6506539583,
-0.2425509095,
-0.1783100516,
-0.5148364305,
-0.0561931357,
-0.5277746916,
0.6143844128,
-0.5938969254,
-1.175948143,
0.8542117476,
0.4511235058,
-0.0567488931,
0.2240944207,
0.5502868295,
0.3282688856,
1.1175647974,
0.6912760735,
-0.010860295,
0.8045328856,
-0.1923338175,
0.0790067315,
-0.5998030305,
-0.1808645129,
-0.1650517732,
-0.4483088255,
-0.6407078505,
-0.5910814404,
0.2059367597,
0.0825016871,
-0.1992325038,
0.4970803261,
0.0009063533,
0.7158523202,
0.3090559542,
-0.0850849524,
0.4320652485,
0.0214645881,
-0.253449589,
-0.1857455075,
-1.0664795637,
0.0439058952,
0.5067241788,
0.0868702009,
0.5905503631,
0.2941618264,
0.6486545801,
0.224590376,
0.0146020902,
-0.5939920545,
0.356678009,
-0.2503223717,
-0.665237546,
-0.3168048561,
-0.6197248697,
-0.8292996287,
0.397965312,
-0.1132897586,
-0.9088618159,
0.4956095815,
0.0952002704,
-0.1159954071,
0.3949400783,
-0.780578196,
0.9096546769,
0.030751165,
-0.1354849339,
-0.5152152181,
-0.3461624086,
0.4862177968,
-0.3093825877,
0.3192358613,
0.0348863341,
-0.1936444342,
0.2927616835,
-0.1597988307,
1.0278551579,
0.1180443168,
-0.5068876743,
0.0307953022,
0.2996641397,
0.4484741688,
0.2999418676,
-0.0823191702,
0.2470069081,
0.0795231462,
-0.7768641114,
-0.4799541831,
0.925917089,
-0.7603684664,
-0.527159214,
0.0997632742,
-0.7743318677,
-0.2842098176,
0.2793359756,
0.1766733676,
0.6716485023,
-0.1001453474,
0.2234898657,
0.8666158915,
-0.258007288,
0.346090287,
0.7154197097,
-0.3410611153,
-0.1295173913,
1.1680916548,
0.5466291904,
0.8434395194,
0.5285732746,
0.1226720661,
0.1216134578,
-0.5124424696,
-0.634791851,
0.055151239,
-0.69705832,
0.0509940572,
-0.5005236864,
-0.1747972518,
-0.3491910398,
-0.2033302933,
-0.4639720619,
-0.7574304342,
-0.1964811981,
-0.25824669,
0.0519054718,
1.0010160208,
-0.3869148195,
-0.0028406472,
-0.9490253329,
0.0445909463,
0.4243976176,
0.3357749581,
0.2151269764,
-0.4095369279,
-0.8921881914,
0.105382055,
0.3123377562,
-0.4446052909,
-0.023991432,
0.3109446168,
0.7219161391,
0.3193323314,
-0.3444519639,
0.7832541466,
-0.4984550774,
0.9999206662,
0.0800802335,
-0.9417056441,
-0.0034282245,
-0.759740591,
0.4847742021,
0.3338831663,
0.2480239868,
-0.5801968575,
-0.4342295825,
-0.4785963893,
-0.8034730554,
0.9062669873,
-0.1396355927,
0.3544206023,
0.0606900081,
0.1150490716,
0.2416189611,
0.2938893437,
-1.01349473,
-0.2516691387,
-0.0758307129,
0.2169017047,
-0.1480106413,
-0.1798790842,
-0.0761940628,
-0.3460363746,
0.4121522009,
-0.2279709876,
-0.0134625388,
-0.0243475139,
-0.4312101305,
-0.3523954451,
0.2974014878,
0.7813343406,
0.7779201269,
0.2672038972,
0.240690738,
0.4396687746,
-0.1611353606,
-0.192041114,
-0.1760916263,
0.0026372138,
-0.0566027015,
0.5976804495,
0.8104529977,
0.6261059642,
-0.4028305411,
0.3646503389,
0.0654208139,
-0.2873384655,
0.1498123854,
0.1539849639,
0.2872948945,
0.3789695799,
0.2820602059,
0.1258447021,
0.0054372246,
-0.5712886453,
0.1815529913,
0.6095349193,
-0.3317532837,
-0.5740306377,
0.1266783923,
-0.1201652139,
-0.2493630946,
0.1177252308,
-0.0742970333,
-0.5921908617,
0.5874553919,
0.4727315605,
0.8198017478,
0.04797123,
0.1324163377,
0.1086636856,
0.5703510642,
-0.0082717445,
0.1267033219,
-0.4848684967,
-0.5468115211,
-0.6074700952,
-0.4177694023,
-0.1622993499,
-0.0786621198,
-0.5845215321,
-0.0317437351,
-0.0728978589,
0.2215361297,
-0.298723489,
0.0197163895,
-0.2319023311,
-0.0421527103,
0.1637319475,
0.7771294117,
-0.865704596,
1.1146199703,
0.8093258739,
-0.3149278462,
-0.8762195706,
0.0362977944,
-0.0839454904,
-0.6920250654,
0.5537576675,
-0.0048770569,
-0.3190298378,
0.0157924686,
-0.205604881,
-0.8245452046,
0.8542175293,
0.5365860462,
-0.2974399328,
0.1938109845,
0.6297054887,
0.4670389593,
-0.2035380602,
-0.0171995312,
0.2476029247,
0.5298302174,
-0.5100084543,
-1.3368521929,
-0.015064897,
-0.367770642,
-0.114056617,
0.3168408275,
-0.7307785153,
1.2177200317,
0.2268430591,
-0.01906134,
0.0039688055,
0.3378402889,
-0.1078930199,
-0.0539791547,
0.6285590529,
0.3293313384,
0.4428251684,
0.2369673699,
0.7542177439,
-0.2932544649,
0.392450273,
0.7730332613,
0.1298624575,
0.6409012675,
0.5576847196,
0.0701107904,
0.5144958496,
0.5867606997,
0.2600108087,
0.3373393416,
0.1784477979,
-0.1723430157,
-0.52700454,
-0.0329263695,
-0.4944517612,
-0.0634023026,
0.1519544572,
-0.028723726,
-0.1225954443,
0.0552263893,
-0.1409047842,
-0.2020584345,
-0.427947849,
0.7487897277,
0.1888824999,
-0.7455337644,
0.80873698,
0.0531984083,
0.9591193795,
-0.7755172253,
0.4336627126,
-0.5268538594,
0.0849552527,
-0.6308493614,
-0.629065454,
0.489369452,
-0.0349104218,
-0.4202753007,
-0.3323736489,
0.5486739278,
-0.7876823545,
-0.2286746502,
0.3596761525,
0.8306493163,
0.0860610828,
0.1443553418,
-0.5915139914,
-0.1702698916,
-0.0528978296,
-0.4899420142,
0.9421498775,
0.7017559409,
-0.2885267735,
0.33122316,
0.6128809452,
0.0927877277,
0.3406180143,
0.247465238,
0.7834019661,
-0.3763959408,
-0.448117584,
-0.7623847127,
0.5297243595,
0.1789488941,
-0.3024094105,
0.7568562627,
0.6119577885,
1.0608056784,
-0.2748789191,
0.6598403454,
-0.1779820919,
-0.1469087303,
-0.4987925887,
0.7479918003,
-1.1406266689,
0.2883704901,
-0.1998397559,
-0.6363666654,
-0.1798162162,
0.3667687476,
-0.2079358399,
-0.0787352473,
0.6389185786,
1.1503421068,
-0.6345173717,
-0.1196089387,
0.6135038137,
-0.0363663286,
-0.1187480539,
0.3302283287,
0.7415547371,
0.0601694137,
0.3217667937,
-0.1426955462,
-0.1282160431,
-0.0581371188,
-0.674747467,
-1.0038210154,
-0.6762195826,
-0.0467875414,
0.1800490171,
0.0509961694,
0.9362139702,
0.6175452471,
-0.7988575101,
-0.4703252614,
-0.1220346317,
0.3871379495,
-0.2276289165,
-0.166895777,
0.0383735932,
-0.6256468892,
-0.7206485868,
0.6172894239,
0.3033252656,
-0.0624411814,
-0.6424465775,
-0.0789205953,
-0.4037320018,
0.2222438306,
0.5406246781,
0.2552837431,
-0.4046929479,
-0.1945613474,
0.0609971397,
-0.2331117839,
0.0849417895,
1.1666306257,
-0.3674528003,
0.0656003878,
0.8032671809,
0.3823503852,
0.2938577831,
-0.2791544795,
0.7581976652,
-1.0641618967,
0.3332613111,
-0.1123493463,
0.484023124,
0.092546545,
-0.2122340351,
0.1867223829,
0.3083904088,
-0.532672286,
-0.8694450855,
0.5212538242,
-0.7153175473,
-0.4081155062,
1.2082105875,
-0.2383182794,
0.0431124344,
-0.3490800261,
-0.040976949,
-0.1054166555,
-0.0599478148,
0.420404315,
0.7670582533,
-0.1601727009,
0.0762782246,
-0.4741614759,
0.5605086088,
0.6172730327,
-0.4322653413,
0.1331508458,
0.2752482295,
0.4170481563,
0.0129814912,
0.7051864266,
0.2746086419,
0.3915899694,
-0.1677213311,
-0.2974269688,
-0.2415865809,
-0.2853983343,
-0.4523589015,
0.0295565892,
0.1160222888,
0.2033031583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08268v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08268v4
|
A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Generalized Nested Jailbreak Prompts can Fool Large Language Models Easily
| 2023-11-14T16:02:16 | 2024-04-07T03:04:10 |
Peng Ding, Jun Kuang, Dan Ma, Xuezhi Cao, Yunsen Xian, Jiajun Chen, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, are designed to
provide useful and safe responses. However, adversarial prompts known as
'jailbreaks' can circumvent safeguards, leading LLMs to generate potentially
harmful content. Exploring jailbreak prompts can help to better reveal the
weaknesses of LLMs and further steer us to secure them. Unfortunately, existing
jailbreak methods either suffer from intricate manual design or require
optimization on other white-box models, which compromises either generalization
or efficiency. In this paper, we generalize jailbreak prompt attacks into two
aspects: (1) Prompt Rewriting and (2) Scenario Nesting. Based on this, we
propose ReNeLLM, an automatic framework that leverages LLMs themselves to
generate effective jailbreak prompts. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
ReNeLLM significantly improves the attack success rate while greatly reducing
the time cost compared to existing baselines. Our study also reveals the
inadequacy of current defense methods in safeguarding LLMs. Finally, we analyze
the failure of LLMs defense from the perspective of prompt execution priority,
and propose corresponding defense strategies. We hope that our research can
catalyze both the academic community and LLMs developers towards the provision
of safer and more regulated LLMs. The code is available at
https://github.com/NJUNLP/ReNeLLM.
|
[
-0.2657787502,
-1.0685683489,
0.7412683964,
0.2459963709,
-0.0934392065,
0.3354307711,
-0.2691107392,
-0.3593313396,
0.0784461722,
0.5184613466,
-0.7381842136,
-0.5755952597,
-0.480008781,
0.2646875679,
-0.2041939497,
1.0502185822,
0.1533410549,
-0.2263264805,
0.0700688735,
0.2612829506,
-0.7624319196,
-0.4890177846,
-0.643093586,
0.074982509,
0.6508072019,
0.3504400551,
0.6665285826,
0.3450753391,
0.1621634066,
0.2879315019,
-0.1159379408,
0.0527035631,
-0.2656370699,
0.4766869545,
-0.0922155082,
-0.4164972901,
-0.462947458,
-0.0285675433,
0.2592689693,
0.1958097965,
-0.215912506,
-0.1960808933,
-0.0360620655,
0.5186703205,
-0.5198301673,
-0.213756606,
-0.7926999331,
-0.0069694379,
-0.0776019916,
0.0682075471,
-0.6748790145,
-0.4603774846,
-0.0124886781,
-0.1654464304,
0.1647938192,
0.34379372,
0.7292248607,
0.0708996356,
-0.0727931336,
-0.353610754,
-0.2754698396,
0.7148588896,
-0.8915997148,
0.0365298092,
0.310955137,
0.265794605,
-0.6500230432,
-0.452865392,
-0.2471258491,
-0.5943106413,
-0.1760633886,
-0.2106817663,
-0.5183259845,
0.120732747,
0.3708238304,
0.1548518091,
-0.821069777,
0.3305575848,
-0.1891305596,
-0.1358609498,
0.4039530456,
0.4219017923,
0.766164124,
-0.2569761872,
-0.383782655,
0.0465696417,
-1.039435029,
0.23129493,
0.6700494289,
0.4021614194,
-0.3167718649,
0.2769744098,
0.1294037551,
0.8878197074,
0.1130127311,
-0.1036091074,
-0.0431430005,
-0.1800303757,
-0.0791689456,
-0.0217348728,
0.9546156526,
0.5156262517,
0.3631883264,
-0.439452827,
-0.2531921268,
-0.2540792823,
0.3207986653,
-0.9389137626,
-0.2200935632,
0.3726823628,
-0.1673326492,
-0.6116568446,
0.0074339556,
-0.9964274764,
-0.6102209687,
0.1580139101,
0.1552499831,
-0.1889694482,
-0.077515468,
0.0906230062,
-0.0933731049,
0.2455399781,
0.1248365045,
-1.0734992027,
0.3980154097,
0.655919373,
1.0150868893,
-0.1480493248,
-0.0649997294,
-0.711806953,
0.0465922877,
-0.1848013252,
0.5513483882,
-0.4015867114,
-0.597720027,
-0.12573798,
0.1314291209,
-0.0840978175,
-0.3667126894,
0.2459273636,
-0.6846296787,
0.1354616582,
-0.0945007652,
-0.3027271926,
0.052658204,
0.4914277792,
-0.8039821982,
0.3983923495,
-0.1350790858,
-0.7657408118,
-0.0560372658,
-0.3896241188,
-0.6500768661,
-0.1181533486,
-0.121961005,
-0.5006677508,
-0.0813429281,
0.6067415476,
0.466835916,
-0.4761506021,
0.4460140169,
-0.2844563127,
-0.1902838051,
0.2446982563,
-0.1699151099,
0.8731774688,
0.2008049339,
-0.5284478664,
0.1142998487,
-0.3806194365,
0.0293380786,
0.4632093906,
-0.1418869197,
-0.13011235,
0.0713434443,
-0.4453443885,
-0.1597711891,
0.2085556388,
-0.5658554435,
0.3793714643,
-0.5586103797,
0.7918663621,
0.9142606854,
0.1322224438,
0.5183541775,
-0.2678560019,
0.8477151394,
-0.4081760943,
0.2437609136,
-0.4420924485,
-0.4179497659,
-0.1224249676,
-0.2730006278,
0.0758015215,
0.8860223293,
-0.3356022537,
0.2025499791,
0.3569466472,
-0.4416732788,
-0.2207145691,
0.1588304192,
0.4890229702,
0.5045093894,
0.3890539706,
0.1992525756,
-0.6865669489,
-0.8704257011,
-0.3407420218,
-0.1743063778,
0.077906549,
0.1365723908,
0.2299889326,
-0.362508744,
0.8825865388,
-0.5302498937,
0.1265848279,
-0.5582534075,
-0.0228202548,
0.7094726562,
0.4779629409,
0.6590769887,
-0.5616520643,
-0.2812142968,
-0.4968530834,
-0.7223059535,
-0.4760130346,
-0.1619111598,
0.2024524212,
-0.0241482165,
0.8022577167,
-0.5642226338,
0.1692413241,
0.6236439943,
-0.4546270072,
1.0174857378,
0.0772243515,
0.1220088601,
-0.9777171612,
-0.3265519142,
-0.02563693,
-0.2510128021,
-0.6556231976,
0.3618519008,
-0.0011041806,
-0.1322782785,
-0.341467917,
0.4133123159,
-0.5956013203,
0.145562306,
-0.2432473004,
0.1493572146,
0.014209698,
0.1094855741,
-0.3496306837,
0.918513,
0.5156997442,
-0.2738111913,
0.4170841277,
0.0475291163,
-0.1513029188,
0.2701283097,
-1.1747652292,
0.2751635313,
-0.0071944045,
0.2481625378,
-0.9732757807,
-0.1909448355,
0.3452394307,
-0.3725935817,
0.5186039209,
-0.446077019,
-0.4697651863,
-0.2820697725,
-0.6142228246,
0.1769481152,
0.6395066381,
-0.5971180797,
0.4353097677,
0.2729586959,
-0.412909627,
-0.6224243641,
-0.5502318144,
0.5104725361,
-0.5311465263,
-0.8946635127,
0.2282932252,
-0.2192581445,
-0.4710318744,
-0.1378719658,
0.0738016888,
0.353667587,
0.4341926575,
0.4619666934,
0.5381076932,
-0.1976136863,
-0.2398671359,
-0.2766049802,
-0.1174683794,
0.3322897553,
-0.292417109,
0.5697572231,
-0.3843615055,
-0.2229933441,
-0.154806301,
0.3584260345,
0.4468641579,
-0.0887994319,
0.6777478456,
0.2771327794,
-0.1331087798,
-0.4362049699,
-0.5962209702,
-0.2760949731,
-0.5370875597,
0.1479846835,
-0.2621015012,
-1.1872589588,
0.487639159,
-0.0938182473,
0.1937967986,
-0.0107767358,
0.5561519265,
0.0956719592,
1.0128598213,
0.6755368114,
-0.3266046345,
0.3722356856,
0.067201376,
0.4110965729,
-0.8446377516,
-0.1704210937,
-0.4904438555,
-0.1517520249,
-0.4647327363,
-0.0870879516,
0.2457750291,
0.3079876006,
-0.2542597353,
0.6197808385,
-0.5721226931,
0.8071322441,
0.2119257003,
-0.0137454029,
0.1033906192,
-0.273358196,
-0.3751155734,
-0.0673928484,
-0.6202001572,
-0.6484135389,
0.868249476,
0.4184933603,
1.1456614733,
0.253518492,
0.7595059276,
0.4487693906,
0.0886157826,
-0.5628519058,
0.5615735054,
0.1131878048,
-0.3390405476,
-0.1625072807,
-0.3357331157,
-1.0564501286,
0.2322911918,
0.0514301769,
-1.2371612787,
-0.0813036188,
0.1690171063,
-0.562841773,
0.4028951824,
-0.7663123608,
0.9020738602,
-0.3062870204,
-0.2941111028,
0.1494408399,
-0.7007645369,
0.723723948,
-0.1149274409,
0.4997890592,
-0.2736520767,
0.0706055164,
0.5496352315,
-0.6485746503,
1.1196402311,
-0.2308089435,
-0.0638011396,
0.1880867034,
0.328755796,
0.8593792915,
0.4606603086,
-0.0173115339,
-0.2148782015,
-0.390276432,
-0.1629405916,
-0.4722799063,
0.8558534384,
-0.4944409132,
-1.0476578474,
-0.2352080941,
-0.4781104922,
-0.1696852595,
-0.0631105974,
0.4789347649,
0.4567030966,
-0.1010577232,
-0.1864601672,
0.7922039628,
-0.543977201,
0.5687445998,
0.5326408744,
-0.2329281569,
-0.3674436212,
0.504573226,
-0.2725507319,
0.3149913251,
-0.0300403982,
0.3181999922,
-0.2192140669,
-0.8332055807,
-0.5342873931,
-0.0413875878,
-0.5664740205,
-0.4592204094,
-0.7179245353,
-0.1684956104,
-0.4003296494,
-0.5967256427,
0.0290777013,
-0.1072328761,
-0.0774812177,
-0.2522189915,
0.5874518156,
0.753400147,
-0.2655704319,
0.3127935827,
-0.8095698357,
0.4298270345,
0.4091622829,
-0.0834319741,
0.0855165944,
-0.5442829132,
0.0433526821,
-0.2794584036,
-0.0025067034,
-1.1374264956,
0.3039389253,
-0.0658724234,
0.5913219452,
0.1285452694,
0.263641417,
0.452237159,
-0.8572722077,
0.8487492204,
0.37988922,
-0.790546298,
0.8027358651,
-0.4712492228,
0.23700279,
0.3585486412,
0.0879303217,
-0.3949067295,
-0.8610708714,
-0.5310914516,
-1.2555525303,
0.5089326501,
-0.1606354564,
0.3852075636,
-0.2979948521,
0.1797274947,
-0.0045018294,
0.04031967,
-0.7931340337,
-0.0533447526,
0.0706888065,
0.0140934326,
0.1395407021,
-0.4539026618,
-0.0986999944,
-0.0912302062,
0.5237705708,
0.2226925343,
-0.0699434429,
0.133266598,
-0.3736046851,
0.0485065095,
0.5993264318,
0.5296097994,
0.2959445715,
-0.1543619037,
0.2252299786,
0.2842642367,
-0.3814845979,
0.5101886392,
-0.1166064218,
-0.3353312612,
-0.1446150988,
0.5245375037,
0.5719833374,
0.3108673096,
-0.7556437254,
0.6383368969,
-0.2291632891,
0.0177478269,
-0.3574053347,
0.286660105,
0.1830752641,
0.4362041354,
0.2734441459,
-0.1938654333,
0.0001113717,
-0.522826612,
0.378841579,
0.4646379948,
-0.1020703688,
-0.2379353344,
0.7781572342,
0.0611152574,
-0.2982169092,
0.6245591044,
-0.3732387722,
-0.7270432711,
0.8078399897,
0.9418513775,
1.0260723829,
-0.2032494843,
0.1232258454,
0.3931441307,
0.7638020515,
-0.1591520309,
-0.0271019358,
0.1967544556,
-0.6513804197,
-0.5372148156,
-0.6259657741,
-0.4519512951,
0.3274047375,
-0.5090910196,
0.2235346138,
-0.868083775,
-0.1271234602,
-0.2093844712,
-0.4762167335,
-0.2668469846,
-0.1994019002,
0.2048214972,
0.908277154,
-0.6164597869,
0.3911162317,
0.4813598096,
-0.1093820706,
-0.7714040875,
-0.0318113491,
0.424726814,
-0.6642252803,
0.5192602873,
0.4256780446,
-0.3115696609,
-0.146150142,
-0.8014296293,
-0.5714763999,
0.6672901511,
0.323936224,
-0.8807076812,
-0.1369398087,
-0.2780569792,
0.0503067933,
-0.399961859,
0.0677002445,
0.8426678777,
0.6218342185,
-0.1731710285,
-0.5808218122,
0.4377055466,
-0.3103027046,
-0.158468768,
0.3911389112,
-0.2353885919,
0.9790780544,
-0.8068083525,
-0.1766483784,
0.3601644933,
0.2384558469,
0.5229240656,
0.0674210861,
0.4553533792,
0.6806048751,
0.590287447,
-0.1975746602,
1.0486118793,
-0.0812313855,
0.0323446728,
1.2097142935,
-0.1099475846,
0.4344236851,
0.3483854234,
0.0657401681,
0.7597888112,
0.4947779179,
-0.4307690263,
0.5810289383,
0.6902192235,
-0.2833638191,
-0.1783337891,
0.1920397729,
-0.2873222828,
0.0166674182,
0.4306453764,
-0.186163336,
-0.5036729574,
0.2889280915,
0.5914022923,
0.0984501094,
-0.3284803629,
0.8196747303,
0.2962803841,
-0.442509979,
0.5780259371,
0.2327988893,
0.8134182692,
-0.6654626727,
0.1241370216,
-0.0351900011,
-0.1888575852,
-0.3450264037,
-0.6747635007,
0.1371760666,
0.6702372432,
-0.2600775063,
-0.1641897112,
0.8933624029,
-0.0960382298,
0.0114446292,
0.5045955181,
0.3699128032,
0.0483916402,
-0.1446101665,
-0.7495385408,
0.2039684951,
-0.0253990553,
-0.4305956364,
0.3418850601,
0.1248389035,
-0.0663617179,
0.5183591247,
0.8092941642,
0.1177308261,
0.0227923207,
0.1036775038,
1.0040558577,
-0.8029600382,
-0.486158222,
-1.5242502689,
0.5305823088,
-0.1783072501,
0.0589264855,
0.82822752,
0.2081058919,
0.4105416238,
0.0508348346,
0.8447234035,
-0.2213289291,
0.1636423171,
-0.810725987,
0.5714706779,
-0.1277881414,
0.6215980649,
-0.3609349132,
-0.6966300607,
-0.2572540641,
0.4233182371,
-0.5182062984,
-0.1493227482,
0.5862038732,
0.9055554271,
0.2892056406,
-0.0644291043,
0.1828861535,
0.2313684076,
0.4424224198,
0.7794014215,
1.1422085762,
-0.0538462996,
0.4569671452,
0.0854841992,
-0.289149493,
-0.2149377018,
-1.0792822838,
-1.204698801,
-0.0653084219,
-0.1306743175,
-0.4485942125,
0.4529443383,
0.8438591361,
0.6073752046,
-0.8303547502,
-0.071604237,
-0.151527375,
0.3514592052,
0.2143012136,
-0.2503456771,
0.1293122917,
-0.7599191666,
-0.2990220487,
0.9094868302,
0.3705861866,
0.1158326939,
-0.0827748328,
-0.0714543313,
0.1270526946,
0.0546382517,
0.413936466,
0.4182906449,
-0.6860188246,
-0.2689031363,
0.026362909,
-0.2623716593,
-0.0457356945,
0.8200155497,
-0.6947788596,
0.1905463189,
0.3457249403,
0.7138149738,
0.0913773924,
0.0429498218,
0.8010821939,
-0.8642018437,
0.166235134,
0.3179940879,
0.5780951381,
0.3380686045,
-0.5382496715,
0.3370079398,
0.0707100183,
-0.5597890019,
-0.8530076742,
0.5875093341,
-0.6369224787,
-0.5715159774,
1.1218339205,
-0.2774192989,
-0.4502869546,
-0.1861226559,
-0.2260189056,
-0.2212906331,
-0.5202264786,
0.6451067328,
0.6383751035,
0.1638190746,
-0.2322484106,
-0.8136007786,
0.5875195265,
0.1365894377,
-0.7365589142,
0.1537974477,
0.4136689603,
0.4577192068,
-0.0474676676,
0.4094724059,
-0.3516862094,
0.372736603,
-0.1990982592,
-0.1096414328,
-0.4521462321,
-0.391918093,
-0.464427352,
0.2276002914,
0.1474378556,
0.0321382657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08263v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08263v2
|
Fast Chain-of-Thought: A Glance of Future from Parallel Decoding Leads to Answers Faster
| 2023-11-14T15:56:18 | 2024-06-04T03:10:34 |
Hongxuan Zhang, Zhining Liu, Yao Zhao, Jiaqi Zheng, Chenyi Zhuang, Jinjie Gu, Guihai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we propose FastCoT, a model-agnostic framework based on
parallel decoding without any further training of an auxiliary model or
modification to the LLM itself. FastCoT uses a size-varying context window
whose size changes with position to conduct parallel decoding and
auto-regressive decoding simultaneously, thus fully utilizing GPU computation
resources. In FastCoT, the parallel decoding part provides the LLM with a quick
glance of the future composed of approximate tokens, which could lead to faster
answers compared to regular autoregressive decoding used by causal
transformers. We also provide an implementation of parallel decoding within
LLM, which supports KV-cache generation and batch processing. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that FastCoT saves inference time by nearly 20%
with only a negligible performance drop compared to the regular approach.
Additionally, we show that the context window size exhibits considerable
robustness for different tasks.
|
[
-0.3986231685,
-0.8614727855,
0.7646868825,
0.1531105042,
-0.3997709155,
0.2786251307,
-0.0019738674,
-0.4182997048,
0.3042597175,
0.4736958146,
-0.7884604931,
-0.2741856575,
-0.6652958989,
0.309838742,
-0.4601024091,
0.6341803074,
-0.0971637294,
-0.2773174345,
-0.2399947643,
-0.0260857977,
-0.0622281171,
-0.6481540799,
-0.8633255363,
0.0512879677,
0.585608542,
0.4010798931,
0.6808658838,
1.3042449951,
0.4937258065,
0.2610033751,
0.212886095,
0.3296152949,
-0.4846194386,
0.0388867483,
-0.163144812,
-0.3748984933,
-0.706048131,
-0.0796057358,
0.499088496,
0.3742233813,
-0.121722959,
0.3313494921,
-0.1115101203,
0.4106636643,
-0.9306719899,
0.4293816686,
-0.8994956017,
0.0031757355,
-0.2599526942,
-0.4530380666,
-0.6558837295,
0.0135338474,
-0.2498854995,
-0.6424455643,
0.3910255432,
0.4512960911,
0.4295679629,
0.4329749346,
-0.6738707423,
-0.0244813208,
-0.6182339787,
0.7200749516,
-0.4152277112,
0.5956095457,
0.0518466309,
0.4911667705,
-0.2056360841,
-1.1301481724,
-0.6367905736,
0.1774465144,
-0.0996713489,
0.0347735509,
0.0869510695,
0.2847365737,
0.3845286369,
0.3504056036,
-0.1988568604,
-0.0885673985,
0.2552453876,
-0.2587563694,
0.214259699,
0.6561297774,
-0.0119420998,
-0.0951877907,
-0.6824378371,
-0.2049711347,
-0.7521814108,
-0.1137973666,
-0.0251122825,
0.1727106273,
-0.0620404966,
0.0626058653,
-0.0704116821,
0.6120206118,
0.0646757931,
0.1442260891,
-0.2926669717,
-0.377356112,
-0.5645432472,
0.0779988691,
0.8096331954,
0.4138966203,
-0.1101590842,
-0.3056585789,
0.0193428323,
0.192665413,
0.069606252,
-1.0262542963,
-0.2183563709,
0.0473570377,
-0.497060895,
0.0331846662,
-0.1910607666,
-0.7968795896,
-0.05418621,
-0.1564326137,
-0.2693832219,
-0.0605736859,
-0.1162122712,
0.1245432273,
-0.0191441327,
0.2104436755,
0.4868011177,
-0.900737524,
0.5170249939,
0.7202234864,
0.9194876552,
-0.1224842444,
-0.3729367256,
-0.8827684522,
0.4203234911,
-0.2561745644,
0.6442548633,
-0.3290181458,
-0.4700681567,
-0.4933733642,
0.3391483724,
-0.0802882761,
-0.0903867334,
0.3077401817,
-0.6393582821,
-0.3324992657,
-0.4235944152,
-0.4189728498,
0.0798807591,
0.1901301593,
-0.7528843284,
0.3323401809,
-0.247721225,
-1.2315260172,
0.378562212,
-0.3307883143,
-0.4328767955,
-0.2441824228,
-0.2747025788,
-0.1188770384,
0.0864059255,
0.5031668544,
0.2235977203,
-0.5157986879,
0.394456625,
-0.5846691132,
-0.3554331958,
-0.0437058397,
-0.8891001344,
0.745446384,
0.4498499334,
-0.2926672101,
0.1463223547,
-0.6900675297,
0.2396758944,
0.0307807028,
0.0585364923,
-0.276406616,
0.2195621729,
-0.0904925391,
0.1667252183,
0.145758599,
-0.5528991818,
0.3492046893,
0.0490260497,
0.7427350879,
1.0532634258,
0.0165440179,
0.2312403023,
0.1414741725,
0.4330405593,
0.1085792333,
0.5556763411,
-0.3877415955,
-0.3697533607,
-0.7860630155,
-0.3025837541,
0.0253323354,
0.252366811,
-1.0110111237,
-0.0484351739,
-0.3223873675,
0.0332812592,
-0.3669071496,
-0.3475969136,
0.3176568151,
0.7223524451,
0.3695045412,
-0.3635678291,
-0.6643257737,
-0.8856524825,
-0.4068646729,
-0.2005688846,
0.1823688596,
0.24757047,
0.3634125292,
-0.2878457308,
0.8363012671,
-0.6632460356,
0.220980674,
-0.021184789,
0.0123575386,
0.2962300181,
0.5060507059,
0.1223329902,
-0.6043393016,
-0.4976996183,
0.0499260798,
-0.8272339702,
0.4254801273,
-0.0701748952,
-0.5515503287,
-0.1918599904,
0.6087718606,
-0.8752861619,
0.4061557055,
0.303620249,
-0.4498945773,
0.4777736962,
-0.5428594351,
0.1557914466,
-0.9087486863,
0.0516426936,
-0.4180348217,
-0.4563892782,
-0.4901552796,
0.1977495849,
0.389716804,
-0.0121694924,
-0.5147019029,
0.6186686158,
-0.6571364403,
-0.124503389,
-0.3214380443,
-0.2541939914,
0.1976763457,
0.3574715257,
0.1325671822,
1.0790151358,
0.5511839986,
-0.4662893713,
-0.0429704413,
0.1397806406,
-0.179551959,
-0.0567470044,
-0.3576391041,
0.5194852352,
-0.1032768488,
0.5988460779,
-0.4159705043,
-0.1829078943,
0.0785830319,
-0.0264912955,
0.0846422687,
0.0462687872,
-0.5276400447,
-0.7461822629,
-0.1653783917,
0.8114632368,
0.3869310021,
-0.8673042655,
0.6204997897,
0.2232933789,
0.327064544,
-0.8084216714,
-0.8556237817,
0.1292489916,
-0.0165744629,
-0.3531612754,
0.2417611331,
-0.0908346549,
-0.2163109034,
-0.0242039263,
-0.3209058642,
-0.17064026,
-0.0085354522,
0.2193553895,
0.2926226258,
-0.1487539113,
-0.2894777358,
0.0318969116,
-0.1124285758,
0.2333983332,
-0.8094690442,
0.3541544676,
-0.3972698152,
-0.1861542463,
-0.4248854518,
0.5537708998,
0.9611626863,
-0.2417745739,
0.5976083279,
0.3138424754,
-0.1329105347,
-0.338291198,
-0.2160708606,
-0.3104517162,
-0.5561057925,
0.0927009061,
-0.4426762164,
-0.9152590632,
0.7282488942,
0.1047780365,
-0.1808718145,
0.2400039434,
0.4862981737,
0.351382494,
1.1469540596,
0.8508450389,
0.0154476771,
0.3314777911,
-0.4403274059,
0.3489198089,
-0.6772226095,
-0.2065858841,
-0.021317441,
-0.0482283272,
-0.3912128508,
-0.7561704516,
0.0998671874,
0.2314886749,
-0.535269022,
0.4117504358,
-0.4749172032,
0.4414535761,
0.573237896,
0.0861061439,
0.5191222429,
-0.2239365429,
-0.3167088926,
0.2413571626,
-1.0540165901,
-0.188838467,
1.0021288395,
0.3016782701,
0.8211405277,
-0.4040377736,
0.5386994481,
0.3252425194,
0.4453542829,
-0.6126077175,
0.8188572526,
-0.1407648623,
-0.3834321797,
0.0569817424,
-0.5879945159,
-0.5500302315,
0.3388870656,
0.1933458745,
-0.6019604802,
0.4688320458,
0.3524295092,
-0.3862959743,
0.8258536458,
-0.6899467111,
0.7089129686,
-0.3078552783,
-0.6807404757,
-0.1604288369,
-0.6044003367,
0.5397636294,
0.1961651891,
0.0275846627,
-0.0413951091,
-0.0414943397,
0.5379832983,
-0.8643749952,
0.5994000435,
-0.1211799234,
0.0494150743,
0.5655112267,
0.0868031681,
0.849902451,
0.4505741298,
0.0760072246,
0.1018695682,
-0.2498213947,
-0.3403993249,
-0.7398963571,
0.9646165371,
-0.4928351343,
-0.9471116066,
-0.3425106406,
-0.8928191066,
-0.2786982656,
0.3849310577,
0.2080571204,
0.4862861633,
-0.0017033545,
-0.157683745,
0.3446196914,
0.1007374376,
0.7630099654,
0.2636375725,
-0.1092464253,
-0.4668209851,
0.6689006686,
-0.2670517564,
0.2527233064,
0.7122157812,
-0.1101489514,
-0.5489044785,
-0.4529387653,
-0.4572203159,
0.0432435013,
-0.8568906784,
-0.2843819261,
-0.8365278244,
-0.066224359,
-0.174911499,
-0.2210527062,
-0.6133419871,
-0.2171412408,
-0.1304424703,
-0.2379404306,
0.4188901186,
0.4561160207,
-0.0034551935,
0.3181452155,
-0.6247829199,
0.2176438123,
0.3898967505,
0.2996284068,
0.4737480581,
0.3422241807,
-0.450789243,
-0.0683930293,
-0.1049788967,
-0.4339748621,
0.4374036491,
-0.2134528011,
0.2458424866,
0.3939799964,
0.3281825781,
1.0955218077,
-0.8203433752,
0.5873507857,
0.6001750827,
-1.0372456312,
0.2566038072,
-0.141416043,
0.4299125671,
0.576392889,
0.1849710196,
-0.3197733462,
-0.4666625559,
-0.4848233461,
-0.810464561,
0.5448774695,
0.0871922746,
-0.4655612111,
-0.6520417333,
0.2733202279,
0.2557928562,
0.2504067123,
-0.2626783848,
-0.2393146753,
-0.3782065809,
0.0452611893,
-0.0478962995,
-0.1287075877,
-0.0335611291,
-0.430652678,
-0.0471656919,
-0.3150336444,
0.8073123097,
0.3247357905,
0.0656826347,
-0.0184516907,
0.1340373158,
0.2926347554,
0.8280310035,
-0.3003734052,
0.5606487393,
0.2272292972,
-0.5593469143,
0.2280306518,
-0.2268251032,
0.0363824964,
-0.1469810009,
0.4365865588,
1.2001690865,
0.1807629168,
-0.3942247331,
0.3561250865,
-0.3910554051,
-0.102971755,
0.1319215447,
-0.0746850893,
-0.1306222677,
0.2713572085,
0.2705246806,
0.2687909901,
0.2314511538,
-0.4912636876,
0.4231550097,
0.2040804327,
-0.122746788,
-0.3632225096,
1.4106616974,
0.1951544434,
0.0209385417,
0.7004489303,
0.0849484652,
-0.363835901,
0.7903053761,
0.67837286,
1.1495215893,
0.1327329278,
-0.034534499,
0.102036126,
-0.0813177824,
-0.2873706818,
0.1293037236,
-0.5085806847,
-0.2778553069,
-0.6982164383,
-0.6821120381,
-0.3933697343,
-0.1692716181,
-0.7542198896,
0.0602262951,
-0.703702271,
-0.3186587691,
-0.4830360413,
-0.2112637609,
-0.9133303761,
0.1791021526,
0.0282748323,
1.3126540184,
-0.2515694499,
1.491810441,
0.1542304903,
0.1180012003,
-0.8034262061,
0.2865895927,
-0.3066913784,
-0.7493627071,
0.7481768727,
0.3560801744,
-0.6369578242,
0.235505417,
-0.205264926,
-0.7661826611,
1.3732732534,
0.5603853464,
-0.9695785642,
-0.5270243883,
-0.1460823864,
0.2089573592,
-0.4980456531,
0.5777680278,
0.5187372565,
0.2945136428,
-0.0074886419,
-0.6943424344,
0.2713295519,
-0.0370909125,
0.1708078384,
0.234201327,
-0.8038439751,
1.3119512796,
-0.346019268,
-0.5599056482,
0.0347853489,
0.7934535742,
0.0019195164,
0.3962634206,
0.4633948803,
0.4239172637,
0.6986746192,
0.0873088986,
1.4407541752,
-0.8532062173,
0.5475022793,
1.216850996,
-0.0567479655,
0.6916105747,
0.7047231197,
0.0026985665,
0.3664500415,
0.5490566492,
0.5124869347,
0.9567316771,
0.0049456223,
-0.31055969,
-0.457067728,
0.1958183497,
-0.4175522327,
0.0627864599,
0.2635462582,
-0.3431347907,
-0.4058242738,
0.115006052,
-0.0671693161,
-0.215800643,
-0.7025952339,
0.1455641091,
0.3893005848,
-0.6257794499,
0.821475625,
-0.1019355282,
0.6253550053,
-0.4452727735,
0.1039710119,
-0.2485298365,
0.5615717173,
0.164887324,
-0.5985049009,
0.3064344227,
-0.1120741293,
-0.2460964918,
-0.55997926,
0.6208596826,
-0.3040185571,
-0.3574773669,
0.5850430131,
0.5403311849,
-0.1860671192,
0.1227880791,
-0.4814352393,
0.2703364789,
-0.1995242536,
-0.1214326918,
0.2057418823,
0.4452314675,
-0.2792814672,
0.8370725513,
0.5985333323,
-0.103905499,
0.2544243336,
-0.1317575723,
0.9201174378,
-0.936974287,
-0.8926423788,
-1.048247695,
0.0394621901,
0.0228127968,
-0.1199672967,
1.0630429983,
0.399667114,
0.8520749807,
-0.1802331507,
0.5715423822,
0.103352502,
-0.1093466058,
-0.5459814072,
0.6138786674,
-0.4479066432,
0.2499253601,
-0.0667886809,
-0.6095517874,
-0.1623093039,
0.0559405498,
-0.3839018345,
-0.4975667298,
0.9998656511,
0.4779669344,
-0.3140548766,
0.3127303123,
0.2406918108,
0.2192604989,
0.4385845661,
0.9036676884,
0.6960243583,
-0.164002791,
0.3231046498,
-0.170523271,
-0.0448312052,
-0.051532615,
-0.9921655655,
-0.8021327853,
-0.2858396769,
0.0522819199,
-0.1534615308,
0.3813554943,
0.643358469,
0.8161694407,
-0.5680288076,
-0.4215474427,
-0.8032259941,
0.1732082218,
-0.2891142964,
-0.1716229469,
0.4929398298,
-0.1486939639,
-0.5612882376,
0.481430918,
0.5252922773,
-0.1209947318,
-0.1590453088,
-0.2817043364,
0.0449819714,
0.1719947606,
0.8244488835,
0.2912710309,
-0.662253499,
-0.3536805212,
0.0070556449,
0.0165120754,
0.1537747085,
1.3775018454,
-1.0179787874,
0.5373933315,
0.4514507055,
0.6641974449,
0.8634614944,
-0.0159716662,
0.7154496312,
-0.1771423817,
0.6101588011,
0.1798636913,
0.4270279408,
-0.0074498821,
-0.5794330239,
0.0649064481,
0.407594651,
-0.5064451694,
-0.7687587142,
0.3765898943,
-0.9276663661,
-0.3128042519,
0.6048356295,
-0.2546456456,
-0.9513320923,
0.07846196,
0.334979862,
0.2252245545,
-0.3847672939,
0.3272283673,
0.4421303272,
-0.3269432485,
-0.257349968,
-0.4932216406,
0.5486525297,
0.1380187273,
-0.7129278183,
0.4843622148,
0.2066922486,
0.2364570498,
-0.2603141069,
1.0129256248,
-0.0803479105,
0.0814142525,
0.3863402307,
-0.3001791537,
-0.439462781,
-0.9006074071,
0.1408058256,
0.2920879126,
-0.2005893439,
-0.3569249511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14708v1
|
Large Language Model-Driven Classroom Flipping: Empowering Student-Centric Peer Questioning with Flipped Interaction
| 2023-11-14T15:48:19 | 2023-11-14T15:48:19 |
Chee Wei Tan
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Reciprocal questioning is essential for effective teaching and learning,
fostering active engagement and deeper understanding through collaborative
interactions, especially in large classrooms. Can large language model (LLM),
such as OpenAI's GPT (Generative Pre-trained Transformer) series, assist in
this? This paper investigates a pedagogical approach of classroom flipping
based on flipped interaction in LLMs. Flipped interaction involves using
language models to prioritize generating questions instead of answers to
prompts. We demonstrate how traditional classroom flipping techniques,
including Peer Instruction and Just-in-Time Teaching (JiTT), can be enhanced
through flipped interaction techniques, creating student-centric questions for
hybrid teaching. In particular, we propose a workflow to integrate prompt
engineering with clicker and JiTT quizzes by a poll-prompt-quiz routine and a
quiz-prompt-discuss routine to empower students to self-regulate their learning
capacity and enable teachers to swiftly personalize training pathways. We
develop an LLM-driven chatbot software that digitizes various elements of
classroom flipping and facilitates the assessment of students using these
routines to deliver peer-generated questions. We have applied our LLM-driven
chatbot software for teaching both undergraduate and graduate students from
2020 to 2022, effectively useful for bridging the gap between teachers and
students in remote teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic years. In particular,
LLM-driven classroom flipping can be particularly beneficial in large class
settings to optimize teaching pace and enable engaging classroom experiences.
|
[
-0.3494147062,
-1.3469413519,
0.5169491172,
0.1356268972,
0.0882675424,
0.3520132601,
-0.3401438892,
0.0174920596,
0.1779886633,
0.4903115928,
-0.3427066803,
0.004188891,
-0.0619235076,
-0.267842561,
-0.5722123384,
1.0237567425,
-0.0413904712,
0.341332227,
-0.3762688339,
0.2920796573,
-0.2567745745,
-0.558938086,
-0.589951694,
-0.706414938,
0.2528381944,
0.7302997708,
1.0011293888,
-0.163561672,
0.0983609781,
0.240781635,
0.1163764596,
-0.3299384713,
-0.5427625179,
-0.1614300311,
-0.3234899938,
-0.4931207001,
-0.3467169702,
0.2415698916,
0.7660101056,
0.8574949503,
-0.2732598186,
0.2136814743,
0.1216143742,
0.3949328661,
-0.1929322481,
-0.0699771568,
-0.4778811038,
0.216524303,
-0.0239161402,
-0.1579326689,
-0.6302105784,
-0.4998565614,
0.0587586388,
-0.2318389863,
-0.1521711051,
-0.2038995922,
0.4219444394,
-0.1289857328,
-0.4516822696,
0.1515963078,
-0.835611403,
0.6336724758,
-0.4488689899,
0.4084785283,
0.0792703927,
0.5056059957,
-0.1128592044,
-0.7737339735,
-0.8570064902,
-0.3688923717,
0.2942684293,
0.3281399906,
0.3531909883,
-0.0437864661,
0.1959344149,
0.5436506867,
-0.4915896356,
0.090620853,
-0.1732632518,
-0.1300292313,
0.4206980765,
0.2299914062,
0.5228790045,
-0.1175618693,
-0.4802701473,
-0.323004514,
-0.8275039196,
0.2652340531,
0.5082799792,
0.0805408806,
-0.0022382918,
0.7212195396,
0.0589948818,
0.5815041065,
0.1924827248,
-0.0313172787,
-0.0313448757,
-0.4367645681,
0.0030512521,
-0.1050850227,
0.6196859479,
0.2140794992,
0.3737699687,
-0.0039816531,
0.0465070903,
-0.2269817889,
0.1580614448,
-0.7712433934,
-0.2584002018,
0.1967764199,
-0.1421975642,
-0.4691832662,
-0.0962898582,
-0.8458186388,
-0.0971980914,
-0.5225752592,
0.999076128,
-0.2413308769,
-0.5861603022,
0.1232900992,
0.113543056,
0.6151517034,
0.4437384009,
-0.6454691887,
0.3680574,
0.7014602423,
0.6102327108,
-0.1735334247,
-0.586355567,
-0.5803862214,
0.2073999643,
-0.0480473712,
0.239471674,
-0.8569741249,
-0.5874204636,
0.1482372582,
-0.1269863397,
-0.1199238896,
-0.2169900835,
-0.131978035,
-0.5965237617,
0.9199991822,
0.0164929107,
-0.2935242057,
0.1205401644,
0.6061731577,
-0.2863699794,
1.0265630484,
-0.0320966803,
-0.7751826644,
-0.1507321745,
-0.5900834203,
-0.350623697,
0.2285775393,
-0.3467476666,
-0.3654803336,
-0.5881869793,
0.2301651984,
0.4427476823,
-0.1311694235,
0.5574857593,
0.0695060641,
-0.4767951667,
0.3049324155,
-0.302401036,
0.8416633606,
-0.2871300578,
-0.4305962324,
0.3891340196,
-0.3119981289,
0.2354285568,
0.4300476611,
-0.1581740379,
-0.1195237115,
-0.2816657424,
0.0760897547,
0.017226113,
0.4311383665,
-0.512675643,
0.7439842224,
0.0107873883,
0.4406774342,
0.6437059641,
0.1819678843,
0.6700983047,
-0.3468873501,
0.7852563858,
-0.0318779275,
0.579036057,
-0.292627424,
-0.5994715691,
-0.8016313314,
0.0684445575,
-0.0085744485,
0.6965485811,
-1.2936804295,
-0.0263808016,
-0.3205596507,
-0.5344437361,
-0.4131485522,
0.0063567637,
0.1401676089,
0.7465305924,
0.353094101,
-0.0456732325,
-0.194210425,
-0.5656497478,
-0.1588830054,
-0.1465499252,
0.0909232199,
0.2278398871,
0.3785841167,
-0.0734898075,
1.0160070658,
-0.5154775381,
0.0078478036,
-0.6408523917,
0.175024718,
0.2174213231,
0.3513207138,
0.0910596475,
-0.9403153062,
-0.7852084041,
-0.2145332992,
-0.3414155245,
-0.0749927983,
-0.4216778278,
-0.1706745625,
0.0498871654,
0.5404118299,
-0.2888642251,
0.2018219531,
0.28992486,
-0.0181610007,
0.6739186645,
-0.014659876,
0.0223388709,
-1.093397975,
-0.2195405513,
-0.4426456392,
-0.2697448134,
-0.5299025774,
0.1052416489,
0.015810525,
-0.6173658371,
-0.5169969797,
0.4352350533,
-0.2939995825,
-0.0214666389,
-0.2806098461,
0.0453952514,
-0.2406530678,
0.3965456784,
0.2524341941,
0.9665812254,
0.4969452024,
-0.1993930638,
0.3597656786,
0.2550930083,
-0.1070240363,
0.5564009547,
-0.7212770581,
0.513217628,
0.132210061,
0.5526152849,
-0.7681987286,
0.1690508574,
0.1030657887,
-0.3485605419,
0.3742305934,
-0.2774811089,
-0.4435704947,
-0.4407632053,
-0.4967389107,
0.4132681191,
0.6003810167,
-0.8472012877,
0.5910224915,
0.0903499722,
-0.3561875224,
-0.5019838214,
-0.2057555914,
0.1511617899,
0.0462138988,
-0.688372314,
0.0991529375,
-0.0864985958,
-0.1852353364,
-0.162688002,
0.2429489344,
0.2249308228,
-0.027376527,
0.3283834755,
0.5668779612,
0.0450318232,
-0.066619955,
0.039426133,
-0.1766756177,
0.132094115,
-0.271566391,
1.0343197584,
-0.425363332,
-0.6214274168,
-0.1358495951,
0.3660993278,
0.5505907536,
-0.3033566475,
0.6632691026,
0.5707594156,
0.065108411,
-0.1649545431,
-0.5715392232,
-0.5526124835,
-0.5122449398,
0.2628307343,
-0.2196490914,
-0.9842233658,
0.3742434978,
-0.1454595327,
0.0604816712,
-0.1836732626,
0.7077706456,
0.0155018531,
0.7613423467,
0.6775172353,
-0.1608018875,
0.6614590883,
-0.4271330833,
0.5054380298,
-0.6214776039,
-0.3488548994,
-0.0868289545,
-0.2389707118,
-0.3497428596,
-0.6215516329,
0.8263491392,
-0.2569341063,
-0.4891001284,
0.0780248865,
-0.3527702689,
0.4830982685,
0.6924336553,
0.1939286739,
0.4081745446,
-0.2126716822,
-0.0624512285,
-0.0372054055,
-0.5365921259,
-0.406534493,
1.01458776,
0.3093897998,
0.8472877145,
-0.0288813934,
0.8627012372,
-0.1246239841,
0.3912220895,
-0.8326017261,
0.9769966602,
0.6605328321,
-0.5874940157,
-0.7570143342,
-0.3445869088,
-0.6998809576,
0.3187098503,
0.0020552163,
-0.3015471399,
-0.3319612443,
-0.3076351285,
0.0424061678,
0.6332091093,
-0.7263456583,
0.6508646607,
-0.2980707288,
-0.6959012747,
-0.4256759584,
-0.5313802361,
0.1785645038,
-0.0051580886,
0.1019703224,
0.3947791755,
0.0308892243,
0.5047276616,
-0.6321848631,
1.0586047173,
-0.1884453446,
-0.2420271933,
0.5942425132,
0.5226275921,
0.3406067789,
0.1138912514,
0.0986213312,
-0.0691063479,
-0.0113255335,
-0.4758540392,
-0.7021172047,
0.7970564365,
-0.9024296403,
-1.0151381493,
-0.5168275833,
-0.548278451,
-0.4145155549,
0.0886934996,
-0.0978690982,
0.1435147375,
0.0570801608,
-0.1703424752,
0.4548105001,
-0.2357140481,
0.5306130052,
0.7495940924,
-0.6435976028,
-0.316285342,
1.0784038305,
0.1337425858,
0.5801339149,
0.299862206,
0.4804071486,
-0.1495844126,
-0.126956448,
-0.3217704892,
0.2962485254,
-0.4802274704,
0.0264828764,
-0.4582550526,
-0.370557487,
-0.3967036903,
-0.5598353744,
-0.3342344761,
-0.3556959331,
0.0274125878,
-0.1495987028,
0.2047671974,
0.506669879,
0.0769589841,
0.219561398,
-0.5896370411,
0.1032816768,
0.8414297104,
0.2566560805,
0.2913359106,
-0.5731601119,
0.2330430895,
0.0421011187,
-0.6420825124,
-0.7892375588,
0.1812905073,
-0.0243468378,
0.2783356905,
0.2652666867,
-0.0000635541,
0.3887121081,
-0.5970671773,
1.0366307497,
0.3288160264,
-0.9942253232,
0.5868615508,
-0.4260537326,
0.1997612268,
0.4242749214,
0.637978375,
-0.7331905365,
-0.1920479089,
-0.6394788027,
-0.7757989764,
0.4285443425,
-0.1254912168,
0.5647779107,
0.2444299459,
0.206259802,
0.4204295874,
0.3211965263,
-1.010350585,
-0.2577962279,
-0.4007611871,
0.0261250064,
0.0499887653,
-0.1662305892,
-0.061903242,
-0.5075053573,
0.5504893661,
-0.2313282341,
-0.0302174445,
-0.1010441184,
0.0210486874,
-0.21916233,
0.5261352658,
0.1496548802,
0.6285324693,
0.0451063588,
-0.0068569351,
0.1965716779,
-0.7453972697,
0.1807765216,
-0.2651018202,
-0.3851608336,
-0.4548031986,
0.1332696229,
0.4360357523,
0.3679607511,
-0.4980888665,
0.7622449994,
0.2098916471,
0.1238622963,
-0.5035970807,
0.0607100613,
0.0683497488,
0.1236065924,
0.5595874786,
-0.6722235084,
-0.1166848168,
-0.8709765673,
0.0838192552,
0.4776369929,
-0.0102785742,
-0.3823245764,
0.443354845,
0.4038600624,
-0.4865534902,
0.821449995,
0.1990067512,
-0.8145188689,
0.2759677768,
0.7393629551,
0.6137785912,
-0.3217461705,
0.6918397546,
0.194782421,
0.2058707476,
0.1476596743,
0.6328405142,
-0.3577837944,
-0.8150874972,
-0.4988496304,
-0.0083066784,
-1.2129299641,
0.1384510249,
-0.7586085796,
0.3377355039,
-0.5108711123,
0.2162943482,
-0.2907994986,
0.0905252993,
-0.3347167671,
-0.1823233217,
0.2293571979,
0.8102165461,
-0.9107015133,
0.8122312427,
1.0764695406,
-0.4674310982,
-0.641703546,
0.0565662272,
-0.2643244565,
-0.9110213518,
0.6169154644,
-0.070132643,
0.1497550458,
0.1568330377,
-0.9976412058,
-0.4774200916,
0.9436434507,
0.0211931374,
-0.5453774333,
-0.1905180961,
0.5569093227,
0.5447188616,
0.0378642045,
0.6932020187,
0.1398150176,
0.4407404065,
0.3329943717,
-1.135461688,
-0.1683113277,
0.0151693746,
-0.2909264266,
0.356041342,
-1.0274581909,
0.649486661,
-0.5054010749,
0.2409116328,
-0.216319412,
0.6702939868,
0.0838847533,
0.5918385386,
0.5818939209,
0.4979358912,
0.4139198065,
-0.0846985355,
0.8375501037,
0.0122139454,
0.30973351,
0.9328984022,
-0.4550842643,
0.9550105929,
0.830385983,
-0.4723465443,
0.5192036033,
0.2473035008,
0.1429458857,
0.1594369113,
0.0928834379,
-0.2144976705,
-0.545974195,
0.0912281275,
-0.5556190014,
0.2876415253,
0.1683012992,
0.3203407228,
-0.3179135919,
0.5205131769,
0.1382101178,
0.1490133852,
-0.4266273379,
0.6049221754,
0.0994258672,
-0.6381862164,
0.2885316908,
-0.2910981476,
0.5935948491,
-0.4606246054,
0.0610052906,
-0.2048489004,
0.0618124455,
-0.089734152,
-1.2244715691,
-0.2712751329,
-0.3259521127,
0.1238535792,
-0.6252353191,
0.4857519567,
-0.6496949196,
-0.3193432987,
0.0291050654,
0.6070625782,
-0.0479248874,
0.009702038,
-0.5010354519,
-0.0077744499,
-0.000193356,
-0.308883667,
0.6124593616,
0.165401116,
-0.1132284775,
0.9163615704,
0.5868587494,
-0.0991510004,
0.0724686682,
0.2799524963,
1.0770807266,
-0.5130736232,
-0.2906538844,
-0.2944018245,
0.4682826996,
0.1211365759,
0.063513577,
0.9159436822,
0.4365689456,
0.8521136642,
-0.2213601768,
0.6851310134,
0.1176030487,
0.5194790959,
-0.3011899889,
0.474276185,
-0.1331297159,
-0.0271050073,
-0.2870219946,
-1.0332202911,
0.292365849,
0.444637686,
-0.8882899284,
0.0329158045,
0.4192782342,
0.3416287899,
-0.0174092986,
0.3017143309,
0.3012439609,
0.1961718053,
0.6882303953,
0.5970849991,
1.1646533012,
-0.2607937753,
0.4562873244,
-0.5167502761,
-0.3205613494,
-0.2254372388,
-0.6425227523,
-1.1427841187,
-0.7623491287,
-0.6588422656,
-0.3054688573,
-0.1382796764,
0.880710423,
0.2466178685,
-0.4391508102,
-0.2684296668,
0.1460488737,
0.1523046345,
0.048433762,
-0.3849513829,
0.2186238617,
-0.2405752987,
-0.8559504747,
0.2554905415,
0.0884663239,
0.3146354854,
-0.7193056345,
0.2131554335,
-0.1769449711,
-0.0566355139,
0.64974612,
0.2785588801,
-0.3612805307,
-0.2134595066,
0.2793859839,
-0.0589670017,
-0.2826810479,
0.9239671826,
-0.9800657034,
0.4000653923,
0.4529040158,
0.615114212,
0.5979968309,
0.1327144802,
0.3627655506,
-0.3929291368,
0.2366962284,
0.541318655,
-0.0836930722,
0.32904616,
-0.3809986413,
0.2385416925,
0.1860152483,
-0.5458583832,
-0.8349200487,
0.0540884435,
-1.0056352615,
0.0576359853,
1.2890185118,
0.2137109041,
0.0896805078,
0.0536536351,
-0.5555959344,
-0.0203909203,
-0.0365477577,
0.8483026028,
0.7086719871,
-0.0721390545,
-0.2896397412,
-0.1672313213,
-0.0279618055,
0.642350018,
-0.6417551041,
-0.3062039912,
0.125395596,
0.3830645382,
0.0552423708,
0.4744995236,
-0.3326826692,
0.1655498147,
-0.4566917717,
0.104825221,
-0.3086545169,
-0.365604192,
-0.1954863518,
0.1975878328,
-0.2584060133,
-0.2058345973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08252v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08252v2
|
REST: Retrieval-Based Speculative Decoding
| 2023-11-14T15:43:47 | 2024-04-04T11:37:01 |
Zhenyu He, Zexuan Zhong, Tianle Cai, Jason D. Lee, Di He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
We introduce Retrieval-Based Speculative Decoding (REST), a novel algorithm
designed to speed up language model generation. The key insight driving the
development of REST is the observation that the process of text generation
often includes certain common phases and patterns. Unlike previous methods that
rely on a draft language model for speculative decoding, REST harnesses the
power of retrieval to generate draft tokens. This method draws from the
reservoir of existing knowledge, retrieving and employing relevant tokens based
on the current context. Its plug-and-play nature allows for seamless
integration and acceleration of any language models, all without necessitating
additional training. When benchmarked on 7B and 13B language models in a
single-batch setting, REST achieves a significant speedup of 1.62X to 2.36X on
code or text generation. The code of REST is available at
https://github.com/FasterDecoding/REST.
|
[
-0.0832161456,
-0.7192872167,
0.5560624599,
0.4367813468,
-0.4587267637,
0.4477994442,
-0.1025972441,
-0.8492211699,
0.4153301418,
0.7746016383,
-0.6436604261,
-0.3083842695,
-0.4713123441,
0.3473901153,
-0.754069984,
0.5486178994,
0.0828904882,
0.0595930405,
0.0440377295,
0.4025492072,
-0.2724046409,
-0.568423152,
-0.7473543882,
-0.0061506582,
0.389988482,
0.3727554679,
0.4866243899,
0.7927621603,
0.7697023749,
0.2322226912,
-0.0540351644,
0.0971508622,
-0.9975196719,
0.5974935889,
-0.0082310904,
-0.6352519393,
0.1970060766,
-0.4040341973,
0.5137114525,
0.5333399773,
-0.2054588795,
0.1923715174,
-0.6231768727,
0.5845165849,
-0.973411262,
-0.1777721047,
-0.8370679021,
-0.1134899929,
-0.4620345533,
-0.7438405156,
-0.8126319647,
-0.622777462,
0.0929844081,
-0.3108475506,
0.6394967437,
0.4622765481,
0.6385464668,
0.0379442088,
0.0033409081,
-0.2168768495,
-0.7957148552,
0.8055109978,
-0.6696488857,
0.880063355,
0.308134824,
0.3154785335,
-0.2019946128,
-1.2790032625,
-0.6369126439,
-0.001131617,
0.0596860982,
-0.1545547247,
0.1669498533,
-0.2183548659,
0.1372802258,
0.5215271711,
-0.3824520111,
-0.3169001341,
-0.3099175394,
-0.0309591871,
0.5865138173,
0.4123000801,
0.5056065321,
-0.3224410117,
-0.2966955602,
-0.1055788249,
-0.7225934267,
0.0342704318,
0.1987331212,
0.6784388423,
0.0561318696,
0.40201509,
-0.367544204,
0.6783869863,
-0.038412597,
-0.0347628742,
-0.134003371,
-0.5660854578,
-0.0105536655,
0.1341389567,
0.7252195477,
0.1589770913,
-0.2434219271,
-0.5144979358,
-0.3109023571,
-0.1573739499,
0.4374674559,
-1.0523654222,
0.0372374393,
0.243226558,
-0.8219058514,
-0.5133368373,
0.1353304833,
-0.5077702999,
-0.2710438669,
-0.0335650295,
0.1009812802,
-0.7446343899,
-0.5892302394,
0.5646139979,
-0.5829776525,
0.3046816289,
0.1134519652,
-1.1965603828,
0.5318043828,
0.8396651149,
0.9409942627,
-0.2308148444,
-0.3152441084,
-0.3796824217,
0.0252521858,
-0.5932545662,
1.1413112879,
-0.8598606586,
-0.7854875326,
-0.0420448072,
-0.1389579773,
0.1876237094,
-0.2069454938,
0.6875167489,
-0.9386032224,
0.0832552835,
-0.5851008892,
-0.5110338926,
-0.0553662591,
0.0194502864,
-0.834713459,
1.1358083487,
0.2697650194,
-0.9569001794,
0.5314860344,
-0.3953576982,
-0.5121717453,
0.2390801162,
0.0149143878,
0.1325595826,
0.4104147255,
-0.1117071807,
0.1292833388,
-0.6742098927,
-0.1370074004,
-0.2791466117,
-0.8656031489,
0.2300444543,
-0.1408339441,
0.4875358045,
0.5203309655,
-0.1255151182,
-0.1684644669,
-0.7758657932,
0.3843564093,
0.2066015154,
-0.3390182853,
-0.607607305,
0.2584371865,
0.3574572504,
-0.1188801229,
0.152248174,
-0.6323643327,
0.2610526681,
-0.5602613091,
0.3912450671,
0.3959334195,
0.2578471601,
0.2562140226,
-0.1848726124,
0.4977069199,
-0.1685749143,
0.0246017408,
-0.4881328642,
-0.2210792452,
-0.4685637653,
-0.2950287163,
0.6148161292,
0.2483104318,
-0.6813511848,
0.1570827216,
-0.2553466856,
-0.5338628888,
-0.8128386736,
-0.2486449629,
0.2292057425,
0.3746590614,
0.4175191522,
-0.3231173754,
-1.091414094,
-0.5434378982,
-0.5196017027,
-0.128199473,
0.2904807031,
-0.0214394853,
0.1315298975,
-0.3735941052,
0.7717573643,
-0.4763136506,
0.5733214617,
-0.3914706707,
0.2406346202,
0.1198995262,
0.5916882753,
0.5074589849,
-0.8226841688,
-0.3174422383,
-0.2055383176,
-0.6274946332,
0.0631004721,
0.0135959722,
-0.4494916201,
0.1327622235,
0.5739737153,
-0.6017534137,
0.217331931,
0.3513221741,
-0.3990359604,
0.5307728052,
0.1144277528,
0.5508055687,
-1.4266793728,
0.2810730636,
-0.6531614661,
-0.2623710334,
-0.6408503652,
0.4673236012,
0.0695417374,
-0.1463558227,
-0.3449890018,
0.5485320091,
-0.6855201125,
-0.0776821375,
-0.6150939465,
-0.0001270768,
0.1131418273,
-0.172157377,
0.1697239578,
0.9162291884,
0.538228333,
-0.6768264771,
0.1041127369,
0.0786993727,
-0.3186768293,
-0.0114247203,
-0.6146920919,
0.388740778,
0.0770956129,
0.1746765077,
-0.8755466342,
-0.1892528534,
-0.0089470092,
-0.4057873785,
0.1608192772,
-0.3422448337,
-0.4673666954,
-0.5245782137,
-0.1752287596,
0.7718172073,
0.5421841741,
-0.6079287529,
0.5691165328,
0.1958232522,
-0.1197689846,
-0.8398073316,
-0.8109785914,
0.0699281767,
0.3916544318,
-0.5757812858,
0.4909574091,
-0.0379861258,
-0.2296292186,
0.3600065112,
-0.0973703191,
-0.161031127,
0.1165204868,
0.0928767771,
0.0983963311,
-0.2286297977,
-0.0766593218,
0.0799107179,
-0.2025986463,
-0.1811643541,
-0.4399996698,
0.8747249842,
0.1795689017,
-0.3648194373,
-0.3885911703,
0.7302993536,
0.5562901497,
-0.3365221322,
0.6749155521,
0.3324445188,
-0.276221782,
-0.4696997106,
-0.6783254147,
-0.3565917611,
-0.5120007992,
0.1234634817,
-0.6666663885,
-0.8240693212,
0.770436883,
-0.0810484141,
-0.0150836008,
0.2734513283,
0.6092649698,
0.4304894209,
0.933832407,
1.0246510506,
-0.0059242928,
0.7579731941,
-0.166217804,
0.3796545267,
-0.4327324033,
-0.3335057497,
-0.8132746816,
-0.2098513842,
-0.5151928663,
-0.6501793861,
-0.4603876173,
0.3605883121,
0.2827932835,
0.418691963,
-0.6023156643,
0.6236568689,
0.6804583669,
-0.0385357216,
0.4141154587,
-0.121908769,
-0.0729241371,
0.1304391772,
-0.6329942346,
-0.2058690786,
1.1934002638,
-0.0910840631,
1.0784854889,
-0.0407158658,
1.0306562185,
0.4171031117,
0.0886084586,
-0.7474697828,
0.4690392017,
0.0859503075,
-0.470007956,
0.0847654641,
-0.6403122544,
-0.9871329665,
0.0299218167,
-0.1865559071,
-0.389483273,
0.2797599435,
-0.0822038651,
-0.3239684999,
0.3269939125,
-0.9664616585,
0.4660274684,
-0.0028109597,
-0.2783673704,
-0.4785571396,
-0.3600681424,
0.5717668533,
0.2331847697,
-0.1247122064,
0.1120897904,
0.0742236674,
0.5936020613,
-0.4178901315,
0.4388106167,
-0.1068068519,
0.0361519046,
0.5021561384,
0.4453186393,
0.5052959323,
0.1845567673,
-0.2370286286,
-0.0582690574,
0.4680248201,
-0.626398921,
-0.6298691034,
0.6761297584,
-0.5967150927,
-0.2998152375,
-0.3460898995,
-0.4319874346,
-0.1941015571,
0.5918259025,
0.3381648362,
0.5807420611,
-0.3870535493,
-0.015587735,
0.6524012685,
0.0404548608,
0.5459542871,
0.9010930061,
-0.4493301511,
-0.344483763,
0.8886099458,
-0.0796403512,
0.0268481579,
0.7608082294,
-0.2070422024,
-0.4898811281,
-0.8044859171,
-0.1610060334,
0.2273224294,
-0.4390380681,
-0.3636465669,
-0.7816863656,
-0.0204345901,
-0.6621546745,
-0.0639727563,
-0.5716940761,
-0.5905047655,
0.0381411538,
-0.2239123732,
0.5360459089,
0.7422884703,
-0.0202571917,
0.2381923199,
-1.0609211922,
0.4679378867,
-0.1081793904,
0.7799529433,
-0.009455828,
-0.375525862,
-0.5009013414,
-0.1257261187,
0.1749372631,
-0.8010932207,
0.2809303403,
-0.2701714933,
0.3993516862,
0.3880552351,
0.1784678102,
0.8483291268,
-0.6499270201,
0.8658742905,
0.0020083559,
-1.0288486481,
0.5217775106,
-0.0855307281,
0.1690292507,
0.6639504433,
0.3253110945,
-0.9686950445,
-0.4317183495,
-0.705055058,
-0.9261233807,
0.8339195848,
-0.1256561726,
0.1748930961,
-0.4775656164,
0.5888989568,
0.4609244764,
0.2043177634,
-0.077377528,
0.0361595936,
-0.2683306336,
-0.1173049212,
0.2857328951,
-0.6400545239,
-0.0673553571,
0.2271852046,
0.451238513,
-0.0459821522,
0.6103588343,
0.2454345673,
-0.0897612274,
-0.4333916903,
0.1100985855,
0.6683880687,
0.6578260064,
-0.4642111063,
0.1374532133,
-0.2796069086,
-0.6371753216,
-0.0096687134,
0.139701277,
-0.4029080272,
0.2166314721,
0.3860265017,
0.7919319272,
0.3450004458,
-0.9093170762,
0.1268171668,
-0.6704544425,
-0.0646377429,
0.0807996914,
0.0865142941,
-0.0922424719,
0.2771427929,
0.6687372327,
0.3220133185,
0.4022031426,
-0.597309649,
0.5562743545,
0.183440119,
-0.0156247029,
-0.6075834632,
0.6001505256,
0.2199708968,
-0.4162888229,
0.5385044217,
-0.0930649713,
-0.1806192994,
0.1723878831,
1.002448082,
1.2022733688,
0.0211758986,
0.0374503136,
0.3839616179,
-0.0054168468,
-0.5740260482,
0.9704866409,
0.0401983373,
-0.7302518487,
-0.7258182764,
-0.8620116115,
-0.5723443031,
-0.2050741613,
-0.7644533515,
0.0713435784,
-0.5257017612,
-0.3321237862,
-0.5420767665,
-0.0299467966,
-0.4884034693,
0.1429428458,
0.0027938443,
1.3340346813,
-0.3676743507,
0.5542221665,
0.4555084109,
-0.4660955071,
-0.8505561948,
0.1585796922,
-0.4021357,
-0.7360133529,
0.5570600033,
-0.0275835786,
-0.385279268,
0.2369191051,
-0.5545076728,
-1.2237701416,
0.9719337225,
0.3990935087,
-0.4924159944,
-0.2092176825,
-0.2603200376,
0.6054156423,
-0.3371821046,
0.4868071973,
0.4578995705,
0.1338714957,
-0.0077786855,
-0.4870193303,
0.3502183855,
-0.4735032022,
0.2473335266,
0.3296543062,
-0.7544865608,
0.7408581972,
-0.301317215,
-0.5265097618,
0.2798772454,
0.7930107117,
0.3324332833,
-0.0234939419,
0.1653269231,
0.6397604942,
0.9773831367,
-0.2031192183,
1.433580637,
-0.8825066686,
0.2363878489,
0.8012958765,
-0.2015317529,
1.1401349306,
0.5134012103,
0.02289485,
0.7395483255,
0.7396161556,
0.3596378267,
0.7093343735,
-0.0240861159,
-0.2896521389,
-0.2104531974,
-0.2212445438,
-0.7032637,
0.1861097366,
0.0775449574,
-0.3301333189,
-0.126695171,
-0.2005857527,
-0.1869344115,
-0.0236051846,
-0.1611193717,
0.6514003873,
-0.0425145328,
-0.7412652373,
0.8574726582,
0.1678531617,
0.5410276055,
-0.8796209693,
0.0649396554,
-0.360943675,
0.0807978287,
-0.0487628728,
-0.5161972642,
0.3175540864,
0.0581851788,
-0.6270095706,
-0.3657170534,
0.7820320725,
-0.285384357,
-0.4216983914,
0.3844359517,
0.6108219028,
0.0062152371,
0.0873513818,
-0.4724645019,
0.5058240294,
-0.170596987,
-0.307264626,
0.1268919259,
0.9478084445,
0.1805900931,
0.6979866624,
0.9984025955,
0.1908579022,
0.2687420249,
0.394327879,
0.9326652288,
-1.1730383635,
-0.584605515,
-0.734085381,
0.2421933413,
0.1891300529,
-0.1542310268,
0.6527270675,
0.7391064763,
0.8130292892,
-0.2293851525,
1.028845191,
-0.4686353803,
0.7822508812,
-0.6966948509,
0.5676733255,
-0.3653542101,
0.1121833473,
-0.2286172211,
-0.5089413524,
-0.1395621747,
0.1407511234,
-0.0961930901,
-0.0923687145,
0.8923920393,
0.8718186021,
0.0395012461,
0.2602773905,
0.1468416452,
-0.025934387,
0.2527888715,
0.0974896997,
1.0166004896,
-0.6227864027,
0.6307313442,
-0.2014338374,
0.1091040149,
-0.3851675093,
-0.5643358827,
-0.6082816124,
-0.4502995014,
0.3017943799,
-0.514803648,
0.1765269041,
0.8714757562,
0.815885067,
-0.85586375,
-0.2996445298,
-0.4605986774,
0.2051524967,
-0.5078974366,
-0.273265928,
0.0808153376,
-0.9861514568,
-0.7795256972,
0.6700490117,
0.2303316444,
0.012702045,
-0.05017028,
-0.0627380088,
-0.2355557233,
0.3879472315,
0.5306389928,
0.373809278,
-0.4853032529,
-0.1504220963,
0.3883276284,
-0.3514696658,
-0.1610233039,
1.4782681465,
-0.8217173815,
0.4432641566,
1.1047247648,
1.1156885624,
0.5810902715,
0.3593952358,
0.8795074224,
-0.5424366593,
0.368252933,
0.3302506804,
0.2456445694,
0.3341200352,
-0.4674099088,
0.4263443649,
0.6304119229,
-0.3867400587,
-1.258433938,
0.2994184196,
-0.9336113334,
-0.3494463563,
0.6899316907,
0.1247174293,
-0.5840514898,
0.0613711476,
-0.2312450558,
0.1588737667,
-0.6531503797,
1.0690253973,
0.4123187363,
-0.0880936384,
-0.2630153298,
-0.0915210396,
0.7629287839,
0.360733211,
-0.6171912551,
0.3532537818,
0.277189523,
0.2582687736,
0.2829821706,
1.1146379709,
-0.1542205215,
0.4038378298,
0.5685943365,
0.2897573411,
0.0515099801,
-0.2847917676,
0.2232356369,
0.3290880919,
0.2654011846,
0.064735733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08249v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08249v1
|
On Using Distribution-Based Compositionality Assessment to Evaluate Compositional Generalisation in Machine Translation
| 2023-11-14T15:37:19 | 2023-11-14T15:37:19 |
Anssi Moisio, Mathias Creutz, Mikko Kurimo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compositional generalisation (CG), in NLP and in machine learning more
generally, has been assessed mostly using artificial datasets. It is important
to develop benchmarks to assess CG also in real-world natural language tasks in
order to understand the abilities and limitations of systems deployed in the
wild. To this end, our GenBench Collaborative Benchmarking Task submission
utilises the distribution-based compositionality assessment (DBCA) framework to
split the Europarl translation corpus into a training and a test set in such a
way that the test set requires compositional generalisation capacity.
Specifically, the training and test sets have divergent distributions of
dependency relations, testing NMT systems' capability of translating
dependencies that they have not been trained on. This is a fully-automated
procedure to create natural language compositionality benchmarks, making it
simple and inexpensive to apply it further to other datasets and languages. The
code and data for the experiments is available at
https://github.com/aalto-speech/dbca.
|
[
-0.6294785738,
-0.6012188792,
0.1099069342,
0.5068525672,
-0.4029576182,
0.0319309607,
-0.5207692385,
-0.3784506321,
0.0875882059,
0.3055009246,
-0.5624040961,
-0.7420328856,
-0.5706510544,
0.3752445281,
-0.4233878553,
0.7016132474,
-0.2553146482,
0.1539528817,
-0.3643765152,
-0.5883507133,
-0.5836457014,
-0.3365960419,
-0.3204077184,
-0.1562266499,
0.4114629328,
0.1443788856,
0.4215643704,
0.5409834385,
0.7005726695,
0.2667941451,
-0.1293012053,
0.1074701697,
-0.3168364167,
0.362885654,
-0.1836951524,
-0.4468899965,
-0.0430385247,
0.0350186527,
0.7089002132,
0.9928048253,
-0.4592128098,
0.1074609011,
0.2577347457,
0.6348388791,
-0.8582205176,
0.1890236735,
-0.5573048592,
0.2187721878,
0.0591004193,
0.2664478123,
-0.5067949891,
-0.1838569045,
0.2521766722,
-0.3886029422,
0.5345870852,
-0.1658473611,
0.4958935678,
0.4771440923,
-0.4181866944,
-0.3706872463,
-0.6822254062,
0.7629867196,
-0.2834643424,
0.4543253779,
0.1838631481,
0.622777164,
0.0714483187,
-0.6195786595,
-0.310277611,
-0.2650016844,
0.0469583757,
0.3073277175,
0.013435496,
0.0128380135,
0.0473812148,
0.6979234815,
-0.7816538215,
-0.048892837,
-0.1492564678,
-0.1515590549,
0.5562244654,
0.2373266071,
0.4240610301,
-0.0441987216,
-0.1925555468,
-0.4743006229,
-0.3741351068,
-0.4014857709,
0.4652764201,
0.3231573105,
-0.5052494407,
0.557978332,
-0.3129286766,
0.7143574357,
-0.0342646018,
0.4897833169,
0.4585223794,
-0.5085568428,
-0.2890546322,
0.0109748049,
0.9970844388,
0.1458289325,
0.1290849596,
-0.399287194,
0.1136262491,
0.3469163477,
0.3602646291,
-0.9258145094,
-0.1547953337,
0.1848175824,
-0.0870065317,
-0.1628424823,
0.1153445765,
-0.641675055,
-0.1647543907,
-0.2994371057,
0.106967859,
-0.3553474844,
-0.1760502756,
0.2264687568,
-0.2358083129,
0.2903324962,
-0.150396958,
-1.2597429752,
0.3144272268,
0.7495586872,
0.7305702567,
-0.4760202467,
-0.2276920676,
-0.2802152336,
0.1182578057,
-0.2620117962,
0.8964782357,
-0.2065907568,
-0.3916241527,
-0.0214681458,
-0.0259947553,
-0.5107972026,
-0.8730931878,
0.8645775318,
-0.1806607544,
0.2912195027,
-0.3552627265,
-0.6447893977,
0.0912847444,
0.3933739066,
-0.7772647738,
1.0113221407,
0.3618012667,
-0.8725363612,
0.7307072282,
-0.5435000658,
-0.4828945994,
0.1577125341,
-0.3359458148,
-0.2894657254,
-0.0111088445,
0.2433904707,
0.4409413338,
-0.3090898097,
0.2775115073,
-0.5415021181,
-0.2566346824,
0.1929364502,
-0.5812712312,
0.6889458895,
0.1350535452,
-0.5208092928,
-0.2854659855,
-0.8720273376,
0.0956548974,
-0.2782045305,
-0.5014858246,
-0.1433619708,
-0.0251058862,
0.02328787,
-0.0474018268,
0.1976458728,
-0.3772245944,
0.0019569001,
-0.6853548288,
0.1092096865,
0.5416211486,
-0.0259013921,
0.6102942824,
-0.1014410853,
0.6959712505,
-0.0352452137,
0.1563208699,
0.4815689325,
-0.3578345478,
-0.6001662016,
-0.5169811249,
0.6277806759,
0.5463474989,
-0.601654768,
0.9179455042,
-0.3782962263,
-0.5163499117,
-0.5795959234,
0.2745725513,
0.2330107093,
0.1462454945,
0.314724803,
-0.7133603096,
-0.5317645073,
-0.9154721498,
0.0855560824,
0.0261759013,
-0.2777618468,
0.079709284,
0.3410265446,
-0.3249792755,
0.8273131251,
-0.2538996339,
-0.1656965166,
-0.3197940886,
0.2033342868,
0.2115045488,
0.3849991262,
0.6352744699,
-0.6926398277,
-0.7643098831,
0.3290379643,
-0.9063520432,
-0.3934188485,
0.3999089599,
-0.3178045154,
0.0296468195,
0.176878646,
-0.665599525,
0.1380548179,
1.0463470221,
-0.1106476784,
0.5154339075,
-0.2230240405,
0.1004004925,
-1.160993576,
0.3494171798,
-0.2867678404,
-0.1211287752,
-0.3037717044,
0.362637639,
-0.0897721872,
0.1474658996,
-0.4380981624,
0.2317432165,
-0.3983211517,
-0.417291522,
0.0225526802,
0.1117022261,
-0.1824110746,
0.2175001502,
-0.2363811731,
0.8236216307,
0.4541419148,
-0.5683931112,
0.3085390329,
0.211940363,
-0.3377652168,
1.0187613964,
-0.6260671616,
-0.0057963515,
0.0952427387,
0.3297035396,
-0.9524716735,
-0.1254558116,
0.3509037793,
-0.2065953165,
0.0273834262,
-0.2104794085,
-0.6618141532,
-0.0531660356,
0.0367141068,
0.246741727,
0.3122107387,
-0.3108368516,
0.8238304853,
0.1162295714,
0.1747178584,
-0.6471202374,
-0.9277991652,
0.0025175328,
-0.3505025804,
-0.7346043587,
0.3540352285,
-0.5173003674,
-0.2331813872,
-0.1815519035,
-0.1355377436,
-0.2120663971,
0.3629098535,
0.2453593314,
-0.156362012,
-0.1243635863,
-0.0633151084,
0.3455095589,
0.0211915355,
0.2152738571,
-0.1323847324,
0.76827842,
0.0612400286,
-0.3275935948,
-0.064061515,
0.3025269508,
0.2131615728,
-0.1963193268,
0.809939146,
0.836114347,
0.0027834415,
-0.7569521666,
-0.1869537979,
0.1006094068,
-0.4663502276,
0.1863236725,
-0.4267098904,
-0.7354853153,
0.6776494384,
0.1548785865,
0.0248700455,
0.6242960095,
0.8673024774,
0.0055752308,
0.6878784299,
0.4383150935,
-0.0465989858,
0.3153276742,
-0.5924747586,
-0.2028740048,
-0.6656571031,
0.1500137597,
-0.7025912404,
-0.187181443,
-0.7982193232,
-0.5121976733,
0.1860171705,
-0.1616221666,
0.1103602275,
0.4875200391,
-0.5455541611,
0.6426246166,
0.211711213,
0.0729345605,
0.3434897661,
0.0574338287,
-0.6086553931,
0.1444981098,
-0.4520297647,
-0.3058422804,
1.2169355154,
-0.0248528346,
0.2154734135,
0.1074335203,
0.8615448475,
0.5185643435,
0.6572438478,
-0.6501549482,
0.5354378819,
-0.5066626072,
-0.5845218897,
-0.0752686337,
-0.6423648,
-1.1546604633,
0.5867125392,
0.130398035,
-0.29102543,
0.2095035613,
-0.225547567,
0.1838121414,
-0.2197407782,
-0.7129510641,
0.9967285395,
0.1317453682,
-0.0270322878,
-0.2967517674,
-0.5804594755,
0.1523391455,
0.0047783065,
-0.0529638305,
-0.1045320332,
0.0553095527,
0.6596149206,
-0.3027610481,
0.8033757806,
-0.1092264131,
-0.2652280331,
0.2045146674,
0.0958314613,
0.0402057394,
-0.1059370711,
-0.2440478653,
0.1142321005,
-0.0249734707,
-0.5117891431,
-0.3978743851,
0.46581617,
-0.8656010032,
0.0035802871,
-0.240380615,
-0.5799700618,
-0.4618217945,
0.0047188709,
0.28065449,
0.1427865326,
-0.7758758664,
0.4241355062,
0.6658443809,
0.0487451926,
0.2573797703,
0.4235215187,
0.0284076557,
-0.7472800016,
0.5338529348,
-0.043221958,
0.5160654783,
0.5089671016,
0.2204664052,
-0.325328052,
-0.6345638633,
-0.7036563754,
-0.0313337669,
-0.9157446027,
0.1551765651,
-0.6038692594,
0.0045859264,
-0.325188309,
-0.0249433797,
-0.202681914,
-0.2796307802,
-0.1954883635,
-0.2599822581,
-0.1358115822,
0.4630761445,
-0.1034136191,
0.2343781292,
-0.4627634585,
0.1929415613,
0.3600408137,
0.2161200047,
-0.2880300283,
-0.268843621,
-0.3607151806,
0.0801728666,
-0.4597389996,
-0.6777833104,
0.2303418815,
0.1662698388,
0.689414084,
0.1600755453,
-0.2010168135,
0.3258211315,
-0.2208424956,
0.7175065875,
0.0124811167,
-0.8822079301,
0.0974215791,
-0.5335659385,
0.1877603382,
1.0370906591,
0.2363539934,
-0.4772320986,
-0.6402370334,
-0.5343819261,
-0.6993294954,
0.0937804133,
0.207838431,
0.1423877478,
0.0281972699,
-0.0774271861,
0.2257928401,
0.1724634469,
-0.484100312,
-0.2057350278,
0.1693690866,
-0.6813236475,
-0.3258599341,
0.0815636665,
-0.206829682,
-0.004573605,
0.4095051587,
-0.2971252799,
0.0398269258,
0.0785569176,
-0.2910875082,
0.0129168229,
0.4396924973,
0.3490639031,
0.6254296899,
-0.2961347997,
-0.0266790092,
0.1767822206,
-0.6109148264,
0.3295534551,
0.4644285142,
-0.2480184883,
0.0899683684,
0.2738340199,
0.4759369493,
0.1729772687,
-0.6398547292,
0.4945643842,
-0.3205317855,
-0.4756128788,
-0.052732639,
0.1465542465,
0.3922124803,
-0.1137321144,
0.0842581987,
-0.0721463934,
0.2823674083,
-0.3141613007,
0.2767545581,
0.2373728603,
-0.3613483906,
-0.211030677,
0.3246356845,
0.2072539628,
0.2732623219,
0.4811240733,
-0.3491176665,
-0.3482010067,
0.6664217114,
0.1155436411,
1.1863218546,
-0.2969605029,
0.5127705932,
0.1776442528,
0.3817598522,
-0.1424295753,
0.1861560047,
-0.3944708109,
-0.7396690845,
-0.5543163419,
-0.7065936923,
-0.7437318563,
-0.4522652924,
-0.5664427876,
0.1203667149,
-0.2524753213,
0.0303771105,
-0.042803932,
0.107348226,
-0.822317183,
0.163386032,
0.0319017656,
0.5667765141,
-1.1590054035,
0.5266806483,
0.4381459355,
-0.3238535225,
-0.6890468001,
-0.0792553425,
-0.5058714747,
-0.5462155342,
0.5605522394,
0.3347457647,
0.3548195064,
-0.2623472214,
-0.3377414048,
-0.5399869084,
1.0552185774,
0.7395336628,
-0.4307876825,
0.3113890886,
0.757645905,
0.9936757088,
-0.3036519587,
0.3316153586,
0.6055324078,
0.563500464,
-0.032525517,
-0.9851084352,
0.0067898263,
-0.1320771277,
-0.0298255496,
0.235918507,
-0.3968069851,
0.7108960748,
0.624586165,
-0.4232367575,
0.0799994096,
0.4563682377,
0.1307070702,
0.2371357381,
0.5469046235,
1.0700743198,
0.5192632079,
-0.156609565,
1.1616410017,
-0.0902138278,
0.4922714233,
1.1254191399,
-0.4457847774,
0.7951057553,
0.3636695445,
-0.4393598735,
0.6506608129,
0.4997603297,
-0.2064938545,
0.565207243,
0.6926329136,
-0.4909594059,
0.0399767011,
-0.1939328462,
-0.3784046471,
0.2910081446,
0.1260323972,
-0.4921085536,
-0.3431997597,
-0.0837381259,
-0.2752736807,
0.0663281754,
0.1817723364,
0.9082093835,
0.0558620282,
-0.6563902497,
0.7986773849,
-0.0019240283,
0.5902778506,
-0.6016249657,
0.3011675775,
-0.4375741482,
0.2181850374,
-0.0122062555,
-0.5655283928,
0.5425165296,
-0.1044164598,
-0.0673219338,
-0.0487538576,
0.2868644297,
-0.4864862263,
-0.4824987948,
0.4231072068,
0.6259993911,
0.0482566133,
-0.1467009783,
-0.7847779393,
0.0872454718,
-0.2243010104,
-0.0878686756,
0.3802059889,
0.5002219677,
0.0621969588,
0.5630246401,
0.5670982599,
0.2119803131,
0.1972908676,
0.3623425364,
0.6118348241,
-0.252540797,
-0.6796328425,
-0.7491056323,
0.3533995152,
-0.1049370915,
-0.2364066988,
0.6536974907,
0.6711223125,
0.8928018808,
-0.0846325457,
0.7999926209,
-0.3542318642,
0.1303812414,
-0.2997278869,
0.560084939,
-0.1445761025,
0.0190994702,
-0.2000860721,
-1.211237669,
-0.3049764037,
0.2200017124,
-0.2304925025,
0.0021131921,
0.9851285815,
0.7774400711,
-0.3003780246,
-0.0155177563,
0.3577772379,
-0.0476676933,
0.3019196987,
0.5464893579,
0.803493917,
-0.4223462641,
0.6364196539,
-0.4675995409,
0.0414037667,
0.1502136588,
-0.8344715238,
-0.8861837983,
-0.4793306589,
-0.2863133252,
-0.2486848235,
0.144671917,
0.831032455,
0.6461136341,
-0.6730647683,
-0.4099294841,
-0.4194538891,
-0.1713282317,
-0.5217524171,
-0.2734963,
0.3737080395,
-0.1588015556,
-0.6670367718,
0.3416594565,
0.0448555313,
-0.0132202245,
-0.5797530413,
0.0059988629,
0.1503748745,
-0.1930182725,
0.3884446025,
-0.1258562058,
-0.2406263649,
0.0217121039,
-0.3021638989,
-0.2377694249,
0.0357691161,
0.6229054332,
-0.4712069631,
0.3026828766,
0.7138245702,
0.9667153358,
0.4504660666,
-0.0352812409,
0.7690066099,
-0.9290167689,
0.0548705161,
0.1827017963,
0.2258235067,
0.548256278,
-0.0702072009,
0.8503293395,
0.3953626156,
-0.4695720077,
-0.5795820355,
0.0420885608,
-1.3406693935,
0.0641310886,
0.9922421575,
-0.2231058627,
-0.2660467923,
0.0551095419,
-0.0626667514,
0.0966408551,
-0.2669439316,
0.7875115871,
0.8634287715,
0.529763341,
0.1419137567,
-0.4722498655,
0.1200907752,
0.5594075918,
-1.1309088469,
0.1162755042,
0.4857907593,
0.439596951,
-0.0571908057,
0.3935490251,
-0.0670252666,
0.2531673014,
-0.072635375,
0.2567810118,
0.4293233752,
0.0830228552,
-0.3206226826,
0.2323646396,
-0.1972453594,
-0.1371901184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08240v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08240v1
|
Investigating the Encoding of Words in BERT's Neurons using Feature Textualization
| 2023-11-14T15:21:49 | 2023-11-14T15:21:49 |
Tanja Baeumel, Soniya Vijayakumar, Josef van Genabith, Guenter Neumann, Simon Ostermann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pretrained language models (PLMs) form the basis of most state-of-the-art NLP
technologies. Nevertheless, they are essentially black boxes: Humans do not
have a clear understanding of what knowledge is encoded in different parts of
the models, especially in individual neurons. The situation is different in
computer vision, where feature visualization provides a decompositional
interpretability technique for neurons of vision models. Activation
maximization is used to synthesize inherently interpretable visual
representations of the information encoded in individual neurons. Our work is
inspired by this but presents a cautionary tale on the interpretability of
single neurons, based on the first large-scale attempt to adapt activation
maximization to NLP, and, more specifically, large PLMs. We propose feature
textualization, a technique to produce dense representations of neurons in the
PLM word embedding space. We apply feature textualization to the BERT model
(Devlin et al., 2019) to investigate whether the knowledge encoded in
individual neurons can be interpreted and symbolized. We find that the produced
representations can provide insights about the knowledge encoded in individual
neurons, but that individual neurons do not represent clearcut symbolic units
of language such as words. Additionally, we use feature textualization to
investigate how many neurons are needed to encode words in BERT.
|
[
-0.3388956189,
-0.6659820676,
0.5403900743,
0.307998538,
-0.5066677928,
-0.3074523211,
-0.4642756879,
-0.1946977973,
0.3039660752,
0.5144065619,
-0.3438742459,
-0.5656502843,
-0.7199953198,
0.0081238691,
-0.593683064,
1.1048345566,
0.1608678401,
0.0324816145,
-0.169996962,
-0.1301575005,
-0.2510078847,
-0.9115605354,
-0.2805860639,
-0.3793406188,
0.6140756607,
-0.2718134522,
0.6211677194,
0.3932785392,
0.3700684011,
0.2939058244,
-0.4302780032,
0.0324968696,
-0.541882813,
-0.1049087867,
0.1601214707,
-0.3846135437,
-0.283011049,
-0.0475887284,
0.8103131056,
0.8857930303,
0.1621997207,
-0.0639713928,
0.3026227653,
0.3227584958,
-0.3794949949,
0.2479321659,
-0.880792141,
0.1165461093,
0.0835745037,
-0.4148747027,
-0.6361891627,
-0.2123216093,
0.4268578589,
-0.6082537174,
0.3086696565,
-0.1601292044,
0.8965355754,
0.161715731,
-0.0441482849,
-0.255987376,
-0.5120459795,
0.7158187628,
-0.6002281904,
-0.0007593076,
0.4107043147,
-0.1395706683,
-0.1842730194,
-0.7704899907,
-0.6893668175,
-0.235151127,
-0.3092491031,
-0.0507824868,
-0.168766275,
0.1963992119,
0.38528651,
-0.0041361726,
-0.4037104845,
-0.0467587933,
-0.3634605706,
-0.288552016,
0.6557179689,
-0.253236711,
0.5157208443,
-0.3253132105,
-0.7612865567,
-0.2884052992,
-0.3738749027,
-0.0499934815,
0.2266369313,
0.1458487362,
0.117635034,
0.5736348629,
0.3894859552,
0.5342462659,
-0.4709648788,
0.3806061149,
0.1757212579,
-0.113733381,
-0.2377109379,
0.2651259899,
0.8128862381,
0.1365847588,
0.4786858857,
-0.196296826,
-0.3269943595,
0.0042215488,
0.6122378707,
-0.5663816333,
-0.2776577473,
0.2246884555,
-0.7427995205,
-0.1962908059,
0.0649369881,
-0.57908535,
-0.5274538994,
-0.0656130463,
0.772317946,
-0.9219973087,
-0.1692902148,
0.270658493,
-0.398832649,
0.2399813682,
0.1663230509,
-1.2550399303,
0.097810626,
0.5918557048,
0.7347059846,
0.0523373261,
-0.5556684732,
0.0594552271,
0.0667219013,
-0.3887264132,
0.6392309666,
-0.3502212167,
-0.1877369732,
0.1541157067,
-0.255553484,
-0.0863968879,
-0.293471694,
0.4400069714,
-0.4599999189,
-0.2896565497,
-0.3688771725,
-0.6192842722,
-0.2916796207,
-0.0479307473,
-0.6452670693,
0.7830665112,
-0.2219366878,
-0.8113411665,
0.5035155416,
-0.7766699195,
-0.402068764,
0.2591140568,
-0.3395862579,
-0.2164935321,
0.6244533658,
0.2854177058,
0.4988187253,
0.2527513802,
0.3092769086,
-0.1469471604,
-0.3458598554,
0.6304253936,
-0.3358075619,
0.7529914379,
-0.0214023422,
-0.225425005,
0.2695768476,
-0.5898995399,
0.0912339985,
0.2615064681,
-0.2784983814,
-0.5014597178,
0.3812175691,
0.12795569,
-0.2338328511,
0.451192081,
-0.595217526,
0.0283537079,
-0.3545982242,
0.542704463,
0.8531942368,
-0.2900703549,
0.49324435,
-0.0261302199,
0.0801156536,
0.0998422727,
0.0153370891,
-0.4672707617,
-0.7185445428,
-0.7951644063,
-0.1401020437,
0.3790699244,
0.2484112829,
-0.7031571865,
0.8333756924,
-0.2591146231,
0.0590742715,
-0.6401420832,
0.1177895665,
0.1156686768,
0.1122154519,
0.4439415336,
-0.5265967846,
-0.2694087029,
-1.0414988995,
-0.1985120475,
-0.1097437367,
-0.1830482632,
0.1078795344,
0.6140190363,
-0.0795178488,
0.9763112664,
-0.3865932226,
-0.2968018651,
-0.4205394387,
0.6640895009,
0.1141654924,
0.591765821,
0.5213929415,
-0.717864275,
-0.0383994468,
0.0960312337,
-0.9117676616,
0.0996064097,
-0.4951502085,
-0.1283365637,
-0.0723767951,
0.2135091871,
-0.4196895063,
0.6742242575,
0.5861263275,
-0.2846001983,
0.1935931742,
-0.7627986073,
-0.2097606361,
-0.6449092031,
0.1607303023,
-0.0202911701,
0.0780038759,
-0.7528474331,
-0.196307078,
0.1615799069,
-0.2720004022,
0.0161482468,
0.364025861,
-0.5210345387,
-0.4324918687,
-0.3043967485,
0.1072023436,
-0.0454355255,
0.6206190586,
0.2809121907,
0.6053480506,
0.4520673156,
-0.3167279363,
0.0434625745,
0.4888818264,
-0.60138762,
0.098091796,
-0.6645687222,
0.1810220629,
-0.4474203885,
0.0812959671,
-0.9809515476,
-0.0928863361,
-0.1893147975,
-0.5677171946,
0.2416939735,
0.1964797974,
-0.6455120444,
-0.1388574392,
-0.3258088231,
0.4128927588,
0.7204938531,
-0.6507004499,
0.6729995608,
0.3666662872,
-0.1425478458,
-0.4561038017,
-0.8987042904,
0.1927359253,
0.1915323883,
-0.7363379598,
0.357555002,
0.1372570992,
0.1394938529,
0.0314018615,
-0.0407487489,
-0.2016496807,
0.1904458702,
0.1196221411,
0.0748019442,
-0.298196584,
0.4398499429,
0.107516624,
-0.0729643181,
0.1884205788,
-0.2140518278,
0.4721718431,
0.0678367466,
-0.2821578681,
-0.631968379,
0.4263504446,
0.4221610725,
-0.3879129887,
1.0331373215,
0.6952806711,
-0.4726480544,
-0.6630166173,
-0.4782223701,
-0.385638833,
-0.4260766506,
0.5191207528,
-0.3581956923,
-0.7520700693,
0.5254731774,
-0.1483415961,
-0.1920963377,
0.3440888226,
0.2594268322,
-0.465165168,
0.9598909616,
0.8989852071,
0.1960636228,
0.5981065631,
-0.3172914684,
0.2081607282,
-0.8953697681,
-0.2982535958,
-0.2812623382,
-0.5352712274,
-0.1955530792,
-0.4049035609,
0.3536071479,
0.1752174944,
0.071570985,
0.1942504048,
-0.697183013,
0.4537966549,
0.6753275394,
0.5415733457,
0.0428255461,
0.2462444305,
-0.3317112029,
-0.259729296,
-0.9889979362,
-0.6856501102,
1.0871655941,
0.534517169,
0.6208951473,
-0.3888486028,
0.5808061361,
0.2299618423,
0.29159832,
-0.7084941268,
0.7119913101,
-0.583535552,
-0.4698365033,
-0.2365724891,
-0.2939811051,
-1.0819320679,
0.2944270074,
-0.7023952603,
-0.7718458772,
0.4052068889,
0.0099318698,
-0.3132478595,
0.4276129305,
-1.0895608664,
1.1464369297,
-0.5864685774,
0.0060208128,
-0.2065346241,
-0.5324037671,
0.1205512956,
-0.0777035132,
-0.043189086,
0.1388483793,
-0.0944413319,
0.8434383273,
-0.3276975155,
1.1441882849,
-0.223279655,
-0.0467602052,
0.2056544721,
-0.2365831435,
0.2439751327,
-0.3007024229,
0.0191297848,
0.2984431982,
-0.2384676933,
-0.5255720615,
-0.5077505708,
0.4714139998,
-0.919549346,
-0.3376219273,
-0.3185438514,
-0.7519826293,
0.1186024547,
0.0840110332,
0.2230152488,
0.4654977322,
-0.2743617892,
0.2185716182,
0.8260599971,
-0.7065186501,
0.4691834152,
-0.1142329574,
-0.180103451,
-0.2795877755,
0.8930293918,
0.1100546494,
0.0763134435,
0.3028251231,
0.0651734173,
-0.1332074404,
-1.1265963316,
-0.1458168477,
0.3084608912,
-0.8240110874,
0.2081507593,
-0.5392093062,
-0.3948538303,
-0.038330663,
-0.1158524677,
-0.1163381189,
-0.1541549563,
-0.488874644,
0.1030629128,
0.14917548,
1.0500639677,
0.1364002079,
0.5459030271,
-0.8608926535,
0.354436636,
0.4951042831,
0.3568793535,
-0.060807053,
-0.284609288,
-0.3404433131,
-0.03894113,
0.0113942819,
-1.0338320732,
0.4311587512,
0.1493076682,
0.731161356,
0.3190611005,
-0.1465949863,
0.376095742,
-0.5476077795,
0.7765576839,
0.3544170558,
-1.1920802593,
0.6745724678,
-0.1127861887,
0.4015817046,
0.2556494176,
0.3681076169,
-0.2177575976,
-0.3963880539,
-0.4681308866,
-0.8267918229,
0.8682138324,
0.4097087085,
0.4865908623,
-0.1297516078,
0.3000541627,
0.1924799979,
0.2101911008,
-0.8476076722,
-0.0981380865,
-0.3652080595,
-0.3883705139,
-0.1691324264,
-0.6655721068,
-0.1965053678,
-0.0988755599,
0.1815716475,
-0.171607852,
0.6524219513,
0.3767619133,
-0.4178024828,
0.1918154955,
0.2302666903,
0.6386916041,
0.8052877784,
-0.3309277892,
0.2488877475,
0.0193626136,
-0.5867552757,
-0.3601846993,
0.1015535221,
-0.1511625051,
0.3739052117,
0.575075388,
1.0785216093,
0.2357090265,
-0.4720837474,
0.7506257892,
0.0343789943,
-0.2102768868,
-0.2031390369,
-0.1107882336,
-0.005678582,
0.2223471105,
0.5851195455,
0.1702273041,
-0.2367423475,
-0.5275720954,
0.0841896012,
0.6242375374,
-0.2727046311,
-0.4881365299,
0.5848256946,
0.3345082104,
-0.1112560704,
0.5970872641,
0.0758678913,
-0.6649019122,
0.747177422,
0.4802227616,
0.971717298,
0.0356869474,
0.2394059151,
0.290368855,
0.7633093596,
0.0516297817,
0.314367801,
-0.0485694557,
-1.0599216223,
-0.6298978925,
-0.7645605803,
-0.0660360232,
0.0660059527,
-0.6330860853,
-0.0112675112,
-0.5633436441,
-0.4060662985,
0.2114189714,
-0.6149486899,
-0.503900826,
0.1730204076,
0.5304749012,
0.8400111198,
-0.8142043948,
1.1002787352,
0.7853179574,
-0.3808628023,
-0.4921419024,
0.0013872902,
-0.4971024692,
-0.9105455279,
0.913364768,
0.169086352,
0.1319486946,
-0.0306696258,
-0.7957198024,
-0.3708583713,
0.9652149677,
0.4289651513,
-0.2967424393,
-0.0158403963,
0.1127811968,
0.7042253613,
-0.4878105819,
0.1726986766,
0.3734335303,
0.4467050433,
-0.1231744811,
-0.6755962968,
-0.0053297668,
-0.1368142366,
0.4286130667,
0.1455673873,
-0.1376238763,
0.8313724399,
-0.1646070629,
-0.3054114878,
0.0875837505,
0.6151781678,
-0.2011157274,
0.0799983963,
0.3403429687,
0.5633782744,
0.6643929482,
-0.1926891059,
1.1939958334,
-0.2661150992,
0.4398552775,
0.8292167187,
0.018427657,
1.0166089535,
0.5594553351,
-0.0984841883,
0.3840476871,
0.1146277562,
-0.0745738372,
0.4740683734,
0.3004300296,
-0.2879866064,
-0.3430422843,
0.0575986318,
-0.1953674853,
0.3659024835,
0.520413816,
-0.8538742065,
-0.0376218446,
0.1504901648,
-0.348454684,
0.1231217906,
-0.4053667188,
0.957321465,
0.0830750316,
-0.2674334049,
0.5877825022,
-0.2405946255,
0.8203777075,
-0.9205076098,
-0.0721765161,
-0.0272924192,
0.0397737175,
-0.1680117548,
-0.9144596457,
0.1418931186,
-0.0199565869,
-0.1136545911,
-0.6707789898,
0.8765337467,
-0.4554278255,
-0.3869585097,
0.4645166397,
0.3644361198,
0.2896441519,
-0.1062491462,
-0.5125319958,
0.2007487565,
0.0265820157,
-0.130881682,
0.3065433204,
0.5956409574,
0.2798787057,
0.4969181716,
0.6217136383,
0.2179641128,
0.3700853586,
0.0441636331,
1.01574862,
-0.9136661291,
-0.4126368761,
-0.7783056498,
0.7980393767,
-0.1600598246,
-0.2285986245,
0.4703266919,
0.2531022429,
0.5607848763,
-0.2549393773,
0.737342298,
0.0287245344,
0.0814253986,
-0.5840471387,
1.0850588083,
-0.4817717671,
0.2433485687,
-0.011029724,
-0.8234720826,
-0.4019385576,
0.8878356218,
-0.3780244589,
-0.0881484747,
1.0150817633,
0.5334707499,
0.0435791314,
0.3159009516,
0.5065199137,
0.5114297271,
-0.2171205878,
0.4044634104,
0.9018160105,
-0.2341311574,
0.6372364759,
-0.1513399184,
-0.3198558092,
-0.0362838693,
-0.8463610411,
-1.0688657761,
-0.6922828555,
-0.0786544159,
-0.0647421777,
-0.0262064449,
0.5899602771,
0.4927863777,
-0.8144515753,
-0.2391106635,
-0.0233243555,
0.0711904839,
-0.1351365894,
-0.1201524362,
0.4863417447,
-0.8036506772,
-0.3963088393,
0.2550436556,
0.3474690914,
0.0935647637,
-0.379709661,
0.1708217412,
-0.2043348104,
-0.0167378653,
0.7122790813,
-0.0900231749,
-0.7093943954,
-0.4023531973,
-0.18460235,
-0.1212997958,
0.2115072906,
1.0458141565,
-0.8018844724,
0.868437469,
0.6450047493,
0.8858410716,
0.5586315393,
-0.178616643,
0.7177278399,
-0.798478961,
0.2139470726,
0.3965463638,
0.4670348763,
0.2718813717,
-0.1079220846,
0.1954201311,
0.0753212869,
-0.3792738318,
-0.5887839198,
0.0238923468,
-1.2648807764,
-0.4493337572,
0.9477458,
-0.4236325026,
-0.5023159981,
-0.0235900469,
-0.2654294372,
0.0590351261,
-0.2937194109,
0.7444204688,
0.8663212061,
0.1211899817,
-0.1458210349,
-0.596612215,
0.471490562,
0.6632031798,
-0.7089132667,
-0.0898283795,
0.405281812,
-0.019623531,
0.4530087113,
0.4633690119,
0.0198452752,
0.2044015676,
0.1765102297,
0.3802728057,
0.1226613298,
-0.2235680073,
-0.6268426776,
0.3464107215,
0.0459498391,
-0.2956976593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08219v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08219v1
|
Eval-GCSC: A New Metric for Evaluating ChatGPT's Performance in Chinese Spelling Correction
| 2023-11-14T14:56:33 | 2023-11-14T14:56:33 |
Kunting Li, Yong Hu, Shaolei Wang, Hanhan Ma, Liang He, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
ChatGPT has demonstrated impressive performance in various downstream tasks.
However, in the Chinese Spelling Correction (CSC) task, we observe a
discrepancy: while ChatGPT performs well under human evaluation, it scores
poorly according to traditional metrics. We believe this inconsistency arises
because the traditional metrics are not well-suited for evaluating generative
models. Their overly strict length and phonics constraints may lead to
underestimating ChatGPT's correction capabilities. To better evaluate
generative models in the CSC task, this paper proposes a new evaluation metric:
Eval-GCSC. By incorporating word-level and semantic similarity judgments, it
relaxes the stringent length and phonics constraints. Experimental results show
that Eval-GCSC closely aligns with human evaluations. Under this metric,
ChatGPT's performance is comparable to traditional token-level classification
models (TCM), demonstrating its potential as a CSC tool. The source code and
scripts can be accessed at https://github.com/ktlKTL/Eval-GCSC.
|
[
0.0698099807,
-0.4484993815,
0.3505812287,
0.0534939244,
-0.194214642,
0.4881306887,
-0.4877551198,
-0.3243752122,
0.1286520064,
0.0897074491,
-0.4276766181,
-0.7923357487,
-0.4713523984,
0.0595321991,
-0.5175305009,
1.001057148,
-0.0604304709,
0.0730631202,
-0.1530611515,
0.0848279893,
-0.2535909712,
-0.7323556542,
-0.9051527381,
-0.067137219,
0.5430443287,
0.2547488809,
0.8701639175,
0.3667404652,
0.4967351258,
0.2584137917,
-0.325440526,
0.5082089901,
-0.4525720179,
-0.3243151307,
0.0390009284,
-0.4036481082,
-0.5759437084,
-0.0206731074,
0.8379834294,
0.5677099824,
-0.5748466253,
-0.037864577,
0.4973725677,
0.6991989613,
-0.8442507982,
0.1194819883,
-0.6343405247,
0.1725851297,
-0.1651946902,
-0.1988988072,
-0.5109426975,
-0.4084634185,
0.1284697652,
-0.6577656865,
0.599124372,
0.1481106579,
1.1079044342,
-0.0170847923,
-0.0513137802,
-0.3659601808,
-0.6744158268,
0.5193660259,
-0.7227184176,
0.415291965,
0.4845584631,
0.3002728224,
-0.096762687,
-0.6308580637,
-0.5738426447,
-0.6973919868,
-0.0983710289,
0.3742110133,
0.0172091797,
0.4644356072,
0.2371458113,
0.6468116641,
-0.8037757874,
0.1016607136,
-0.5452135205,
-0.5470463634,
0.3950248361,
0.3752980232,
0.5119104981,
-0.2442140579,
-0.2500198185,
0.0516132638,
-0.6608552933,
0.0767010301,
0.5666209459,
0.3488427401,
-0.1074827313,
0.3712323904,
-0.2907446027,
0.4640865922,
-0.0197720714,
0.2186972201,
0.1704661548,
-0.3375724852,
-0.0279917456,
0.2140839845,
0.7115790844,
0.3211162388,
0.0983995646,
-0.1614463925,
-0.1791064739,
0.2377556115,
0.3396990597,
-0.5440974236,
-0.6458092928,
-0.0702734888,
-0.3751618266,
-0.160174489,
0.4080955088,
-0.317424655,
-0.2682153285,
-0.351593256,
0.5181213021,
-0.586368084,
0.1399211884,
0.0178409852,
-0.0335416868,
0.3366808295,
0.3902000785,
-0.9821941257,
0.3570005298,
0.9055310488,
1.2326415777,
-0.2327246964,
-0.4532220364,
-0.4149736762,
-0.2841111124,
-0.515884757,
0.8442678452,
-0.4364402592,
-0.5574814081,
-0.0332327411,
0.1131430492,
-0.3753620982,
-0.4612157345,
0.8107224107,
-0.2338133454,
0.4111493528,
-0.2529050112,
-0.6234715581,
-0.080854319,
0.0934463814,
-0.5214319229,
1.1140055656,
0.1889336407,
-0.7530640364,
0.3828135729,
-0.4348880351,
-0.3733177185,
0.4707124829,
0.2756909132,
-0.366861403,
-0.025414899,
0.115001522,
0.1312058717,
-0.1593089253,
-0.1046613306,
-0.1845815331,
-0.8156046867,
0.2745431066,
-0.7418025732,
0.6084047556,
0.2467121482,
-0.0148570836,
0.2190364152,
-0.6432490945,
0.4982269406,
-0.3906247616,
-0.440141201,
-0.2354468405,
0.1727393568,
-0.1277529746,
0.1726312041,
0.2436374426,
-0.4188193679,
0.1728873253,
-0.5925270319,
0.6904850006,
0.6216578484,
-0.3979934454,
0.2360505462,
-0.1843818575,
0.4953972101,
-0.4783396423,
0.3234423101,
0.1701922268,
-0.2841236591,
-0.9717169404,
-0.1567536891,
0.6620924473,
0.6668159962,
-0.8013359308,
0.6535313129,
-0.3982027769,
-0.8887495399,
-0.7201699018,
-0.0411984101,
0.559409976,
0.2542805672,
0.361276567,
-0.7662111521,
-0.3505952954,
-0.7109532952,
-0.263061285,
-0.3969843984,
-0.4296547771,
0.1460754275,
0.3220461011,
0.1948951036,
0.6149475574,
-0.4683817029,
-0.4802087545,
-0.267925024,
0.3319221437,
-0.0688465759,
0.1417844445,
0.1952347159,
-0.3697224259,
-0.6046329737,
0.2192623615,
-0.2023574114,
-0.287388742,
0.0577793196,
-0.1736295521,
0.2535625696,
0.1293055266,
-0.3240810335,
0.6359399557,
0.6653902531,
-0.4109544158,
1.1776058674,
-0.5243543386,
0.5574711561,
-0.6921368837,
0.0281956811,
-0.1834829748,
-0.0099111199,
-0.6845368147,
-0.011870496,
0.4472712576,
0.1318902671,
-0.6148972511,
0.1828134209,
-0.3569933176,
0.0224530306,
-0.1344578564,
0.3833948374,
-0.0320833363,
0.5753736496,
-0.1151345074,
0.9218802452,
0.3946632147,
-0.4681329131,
0.5751547813,
-0.0339398421,
-0.5669585466,
0.6529145241,
-0.47198385,
0.2700175345,
0.2865014374,
0.4265455008,
-0.8540433049,
-0.0798574537,
0.2815468907,
-0.5825182796,
0.1496111751,
0.0964024067,
-0.6153078079,
-0.6350479126,
-0.4229574502,
0.3784419894,
0.5432254672,
-0.6765599847,
0.2215019464,
-0.1222577542,
0.1687731147,
-0.3247804046,
-0.6098555326,
0.1762998104,
-0.129496634,
-0.5852440596,
0.4892472625,
-0.0510823764,
0.3865059614,
-0.0078208949,
0.0062190937,
-0.1682427078,
-0.2006118,
0.0942333192,
0.5352073908,
-0.2208030969,
0.0414826199,
-0.3342857063,
0.038361825,
-0.1855485141,
-0.2246827781,
0.5482171774,
-0.2993209362,
-0.5697966814,
-0.5217971802,
-0.0862367675,
0.2659294307,
-0.2383704484,
0.6312282085,
0.4760361016,
-0.2817718685,
-0.0953102186,
-0.6258920431,
0.121654503,
-0.4526387453,
0.6172907352,
-0.0553298667,
-0.8335518241,
0.5046362877,
0.2266196012,
-0.4610021114,
0.5432020426,
0.5303843021,
0.2526696622,
1.152446866,
0.2609339952,
-0.1622640789,
0.2832560837,
-0.0119052827,
0.4242370427,
-1.0518776178,
-0.028059788,
-0.4685753584,
-0.11487104,
-0.5118649006,
-0.4575574994,
0.1793500781,
0.1617434621,
-0.0863433629,
0.5997554064,
-0.702308774,
0.5127186179,
0.3553496003,
0.108885169,
0.2599030435,
-0.1626441032,
-0.3443461359,
-0.1194052994,
-0.4956958294,
-0.4596377611,
0.6583906412,
0.1232618988,
0.5600376129,
-0.0445340388,
0.2989456654,
0.2379306555,
0.1945850849,
-0.7056126595,
0.5312071443,
-0.7191951275,
-0.2646609247,
-0.2778254747,
-0.4028321505,
-0.6567311883,
0.3287404776,
-0.0472916216,
-1.0402309895,
-0.1989392042,
0.24402605,
-0.589014411,
0.5129202604,
-0.8648715615,
0.9721310139,
-0.3808469772,
-0.1889979839,
-0.4019190967,
-0.3164376616,
0.1982584596,
0.1101975366,
-0.0955431014,
-0.2181922495,
0.1530670822,
0.5812892914,
-0.760718286,
0.5699228644,
0.0852355957,
-0.1267085522,
0.50153023,
-0.0716912225,
0.3040888309,
-0.5059038997,
-0.0217772312,
0.3885061741,
0.2086432129,
-0.1666152924,
-0.7656129599,
0.6086689234,
-0.5247546434,
-0.3194860518,
-0.3605420589,
-0.0729890913,
-0.0073602358,
-0.2646885514,
0.6006146669,
0.3076077104,
-0.611425519,
0.1268929839,
-0.0152910072,
-0.3729298711,
-0.02497009,
0.5107366443,
-0.0582279824,
-0.2540326416,
1.1756229401,
0.3016914129,
0.5364121795,
0.4297069609,
0.1666868031,
-0.3565559983,
-0.3723830581,
-0.3986022472,
-0.1674531102,
-0.615349412,
-0.0588240176,
-0.1999021173,
-0.7825772166,
-0.2556900382,
-0.0788044631,
-0.2504652143,
-0.2630842328,
-0.0741037428,
0.1006127,
0.1015004218,
0.5028553605,
-0.1515706778,
0.389790535,
-0.5132142305,
0.1427306235,
0.2149594128,
0.5648732781,
0.1855475008,
-0.6961548328,
-0.3760016859,
0.1472072005,
-0.5891780853,
-0.6335789561,
0.3535608649,
0.4115692973,
0.2145515382,
0.3755466342,
-0.2045644224,
0.9747282863,
-0.5762600303,
1.1872777939,
0.2429767698,
-1.2111721039,
0.3592716753,
-0.0149778901,
0.2858679295,
0.3178422153,
-0.1587905586,
-1.4033643007,
-0.5249960423,
-0.4507492781,
-0.942425549,
0.7090552449,
0.35053581,
0.0323472731,
-0.1220016256,
0.1644271016,
0.0054464228,
-0.0847218707,
-0.3249058723,
-0.020179987,
-0.095574826,
-0.1062149182,
0.0740535408,
-0.4034342766,
0.5091130733,
-0.3518045545,
0.9497935772,
0.0558079854,
0.1200171709,
0.1811257303,
0.0315330401,
0.0516381972,
0.5013415217,
0.5355263948,
0.3005504012,
0.1699286103,
0.0533584431,
0.8778783083,
-0.7830547094,
-0.1995342821,
-0.0502600521,
0.0025174506,
-0.1310702562,
0.4913671613,
0.8576358557,
0.3648374677,
-0.517521143,
0.558709383,
-0.2247001231,
-0.3839022219,
-0.2907361388,
0.1789188981,
-0.0208938848,
-0.2661179304,
0.1233390048,
-0.0496678501,
0.2802523673,
-0.1564067751,
0.0097773951,
0.4343938828,
-0.5870697498,
-0.3551076055,
0.548517108,
0.1089909375,
-0.3940127492,
0.8065558672,
-0.5910449028,
-1.0222043991,
0.6747977734,
0.1368971318,
1.0924121141,
-0.5794827342,
0.3921664953,
0.5826954842,
0.2370231748,
-0.3585651517,
-0.0138774384,
-0.0373835489,
-0.5195444822,
-0.5132201314,
-0.4966151714,
-0.5374290943,
0.1021216065,
-0.4342954755,
0.6298207045,
-0.3306680918,
0.0187867805,
-0.2598966062,
0.0425279774,
-0.6601184607,
0.0557718389,
0.3408310413,
0.4483213425,
-0.5261619091,
0.8245954514,
0.2481487095,
-0.1971534789,
-1.3652209044,
-0.0003559822,
0.1803048998,
-0.7266606688,
0.4520466328,
0.3269405961,
-0.2852505744,
-0.2904564142,
-0.2715203166,
-0.6341037154,
1.0441446304,
0.1656835079,
-0.7445876598,
-0.0532619134,
0.5176202059,
1.0156837702,
-0.1318867803,
0.5376945734,
0.6883018017,
0.4577226341,
0.1067814082,
-1.4865043163,
-0.2424381971,
-0.2856646776,
0.2097086012,
0.0584666654,
-0.6288315058,
0.7069919109,
-0.2049300671,
-0.8179850578,
0.6252478957,
0.470967263,
-0.1067781299,
0.051981315,
0.5262448192,
0.5998891592,
0.8351422548,
-0.2884252369,
0.7647625208,
-0.2454521954,
0.7682681084,
0.9408868551,
-0.2770400941,
0.8730523586,
-0.0678930283,
-0.6559260488,
0.5292499661,
0.6489797235,
-0.2609643936,
0.3428050876,
0.6996672153,
-0.3233367503,
-0.2255291641,
-0.1365360022,
-0.1930087656,
0.4965040684,
0.3432881832,
-0.1745838374,
-0.2129067481,
-0.3748479486,
-0.1298193932,
0.2072136551,
-0.4366642535,
0.5765783191,
0.0452707484,
-0.604952693,
0.6603440046,
0.1280941367,
0.8782772422,
-0.5915557146,
-0.0649559721,
-0.0130209262,
0.2956469059,
-0.3392925858,
-0.7393903732,
0.197439909,
0.0982343853,
0.1598525345,
0.2825763822,
0.6503491402,
-0.7124111652,
-0.4840542078,
0.2682542801,
0.1325069368,
0.2983883619,
-0.1742894351,
-0.6751664281,
-0.160216853,
-0.055608917,
0.1718362719,
0.0998187512,
0.4179837108,
-0.1365664899,
0.5331894755,
0.5730085373,
0.3971984386,
-0.0757512003,
0.4732448757,
0.3196345866,
-0.459276557,
-0.643889308,
-0.9165645838,
0.155374974,
0.0024219202,
-0.4587375224,
0.6117159128,
0.7359534502,
0.8661590219,
-0.1154710948,
0.6789221764,
-0.013865239,
0.4736740887,
-0.5483093858,
0.9029496908,
-0.3598314524,
0.1650036722,
-0.3453207612,
-0.8658154607,
-0.3007905185,
0.5076895952,
-0.436470896,
0.0143959494,
1.0365657806,
1.0609788895,
0.2536375225,
0.2945400476,
0.540910542,
0.0626224875,
0.2797397375,
1.0035078526,
1.1383852959,
-0.3156016469,
0.684995234,
-0.3224307597,
-0.0768737346,
-0.020073032,
-0.8095546961,
-0.6754607558,
-0.7589958906,
-0.3494978547,
-0.203327179,
0.4201778769,
0.9422446489,
0.4146723151,
-0.8437330723,
-0.0086944252,
0.0947087482,
-0.1256738305,
-0.5871193409,
-0.2923735976,
0.7714437246,
-0.3140287995,
-0.7457296252,
-0.0764141679,
0.3013886213,
-0.2104723305,
-0.2603425384,
-0.219952032,
0.3177797198,
-0.1694170833,
0.5968202949,
0.2149991393,
-1.052251339,
-0.8114864826,
-0.0512664542,
-0.3612595797,
0.0895841718,
0.7927137613,
-0.665510416,
0.3778452575,
0.4108902514,
0.2261678874,
-0.0159248691,
0.0735694841,
0.3220016062,
-0.7695191503,
-0.2290941179,
0.0202076342,
0.3792937994,
0.5424012542,
-0.4409120977,
0.4407833815,
0.1587482244,
-0.7315792441,
-0.3588985205,
-0.1402121633,
-0.9072511196,
0.0275286324,
1.29520154,
-0.1189964116,
-0.1715147197,
0.0893205255,
-0.7994306087,
0.335474968,
-0.3285735548,
1.1482310295,
1.1935737133,
0.1048712879,
0.2348330766,
-0.5579214692,
0.4840369821,
0.4265329838,
-0.5736160278,
0.4517130852,
0.3755840063,
0.1963377297,
0.1003309935,
0.6315175295,
-0.1928792894,
0.4915280342,
-0.1486273706,
0.3116554916,
0.2714140117,
0.0207247995,
-0.1462676525,
-0.0987918526,
0.1354170442,
-0.0749548823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08213v1
|
Unlock the Power: Competitive Distillation for Multi-Modal Large Language Models
| 2023-11-14T14:49:46 | 2023-11-14T14:49:46 |
Xinwei Li, Li Lin, Shuai Wang, Chen Qian
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recently, multi-modal content generation has attracted lots of attention from
researchers by investigating the utilization of visual instruction tuning based
on large language models (LLMs). To enhance the performance and generalization
ability of such LLMs, the practice of distilling knowledge from pretrained
multi-modal models (a.k.a. teachers) to more compact multi-modal LLMs
(students) has gained considerable interest. However, the prevailing paradigm
of instructiontuning in multi-modal LLMs knowledge distillation is
resource-intensive and unidirectional, neglecting the potential for mutual
feedback between the student and teacher models. Thus, we propose an innovative
Competitive Multi-modal Distillation framework (CoMD), which captures
bidirectional feedback between teacher and student models and continually
updates the multi-modal capabilities that the student model has learned. It
comprises two stages: multi-modal pre-training and multi-modal competitive
distillation. The first stage pre-trains the student model on a large number of
filtered multi-modal datasets. The second stage facilitates a bidirectional
knowledge transfer between the student and teacher models. Our experimental
analysis of diverse datasets shows that our knowledge transfer method
consistently improves the capabilities of the student model. Finally, the
7B-sized student model after four distillations surpassed the current
state-of-the-art model LLaVA-13B on the ScienceQA and LLaVA Test dataset, also
outperforms other strong baselines in the zero-shot setting.
|
[
-0.2603176534,
-0.6648840904,
0.5161879063,
0.1118867397,
-0.5320140719,
0.3928260803,
-0.6117917895,
-0.0509908199,
-0.2908857167,
0.2461393476,
-0.4137454927,
-0.3184593022,
-0.6677797437,
0.0802197307,
-0.3096696138,
0.9171019793,
0.1080321074,
0.5451278687,
-0.3504943848,
0.0879784375,
-0.7525520921,
-0.4583539963,
-0.2370314598,
-0.5028116703,
0.462092638,
0.6117354035,
0.3250974119,
0.4236488342,
0.4560088217,
0.4357821047,
0.0185167901,
0.0981716216,
-0.6917720437,
0.3818992376,
-0.2403951883,
-0.6024563313,
-0.3141683936,
0.1761279255,
0.6629118919,
0.6730008125,
-0.4710600078,
0.1528548151,
0.4372084439,
0.6304479837,
-0.5756933093,
0.3413346112,
-0.9186695218,
-0.2518411875,
-0.3250589669,
-0.2132691592,
-0.5354474783,
-0.2271797657,
0.1480573714,
-0.5080689192,
0.1877225935,
-0.1111977994,
0.5920524597,
0.4110818207,
-0.7463461757,
-0.1103727818,
-0.7631523013,
0.8214961886,
-0.4774034619,
0.4201491177,
0.1234731972,
0.710903585,
-0.00972219,
-0.8865432143,
-0.7597060204,
-0.015457063,
0.2656492889,
0.2401826829,
0.0832133815,
0.1310225576,
-0.0060853236,
0.350817889,
-0.2405402809,
-0.0010542063,
-0.5422976613,
0.2581437826,
0.3981302381,
0.1351813674,
-0.0918714777,
0.0091428431,
-0.6967481375,
-0.2527051568,
-0.3660319149,
-0.0166369546,
0.0769557133,
0.2947103977,
-0.0859472752,
0.4259184003,
-0.1949760467,
0.6476418376,
0.2294563353,
-0.5819550157,
0.1678451598,
-0.557487607,
-0.2147398591,
0.1091035455,
0.6363469958,
0.336494863,
0.2609424591,
0.0624755211,
-0.1246713772,
-0.1317869872,
-0.0405275077,
-1.1404519081,
-0.2743753195,
-0.3626657426,
-0.4238889515,
-0.3635630906,
0.0128028179,
-1.0117683411,
-0.3908177018,
-0.6519258618,
0.6371808052,
-0.1837745607,
-0.4551106989,
0.2346160263,
-0.1176820993,
-0.0688830242,
0.3361721337,
-0.993047893,
0.1138503626,
0.5489934683,
0.8673776388,
-0.1136246622,
-0.3000899851,
-0.2109719366,
0.2809259593,
0.0307858139,
0.3697583973,
-0.7952911258,
-0.2450722307,
-0.2134047598,
-0.0431283228,
-0.2835269272,
-0.4882922769,
0.1537508667,
-0.6816619039,
0.134146437,
-0.3758273423,
-0.3374440372,
-0.2258495241,
0.2042210698,
-0.5683045983,
0.6959125996,
-0.0861010477,
-0.6577784419,
0.3813660145,
-0.3555456996,
-0.1545471698,
0.055605907,
-0.2946284115,
-0.2839073539,
0.2038345337,
0.0895878971,
0.4170701206,
-0.7593730092,
0.5938076973,
-0.3313567936,
-0.1394793838,
0.3001801372,
-0.8592632413,
0.752299428,
0.2924632132,
-0.4181133807,
0.0883367807,
-0.8528075814,
-0.2639126778,
0.0216568727,
-0.5537594557,
-0.4348580837,
-0.2779019773,
0.0099442704,
0.3814622462,
0.1635803878,
-0.4871364832,
0.3729681075,
0.2881506681,
0.4389580786,
0.9756262302,
-0.0333469696,
0.40827474,
-0.2577669919,
0.5603142381,
0.1601250172,
0.256344378,
-0.2164215446,
-0.2059484124,
-0.6684743166,
-0.6336391568,
0.5020385981,
0.2082755715,
-1.1356539726,
0.0504729673,
-0.3305970132,
-0.6111367345,
-0.3545366824,
0.3545914888,
0.2979751527,
0.5873378515,
0.1799277663,
-0.2025819123,
-0.3450365067,
-0.6172314286,
0.1444576979,
0.0571166165,
0.1621011049,
0.2287020832,
0.2933109999,
0.1525630504,
0.6464106441,
-0.547144413,
-0.4929815233,
-0.4600706398,
0.2065944225,
0.2345643789,
0.3564580679,
0.577301085,
-0.8535836935,
-0.7375270724,
-0.1193226725,
-0.7481358647,
-0.2689168453,
-0.1832748652,
-0.2087809592,
-0.0138336411,
0.5694977045,
-0.1536877751,
-0.1320062727,
0.82640481,
-0.4104477167,
0.4196772873,
-0.2389198244,
0.3932403624,
-1.2844604254,
-0.0156346392,
-0.1755242646,
-0.2424996793,
-0.2215648293,
-0.0592347644,
-0.0633645728,
-0.2440884858,
-0.2754172683,
0.0375428759,
-0.7219572663,
0.4226058125,
-0.3673607111,
0.1252665222,
0.145353362,
0.4275447726,
0.1125755608,
0.6313353181,
0.6387152672,
-0.3468949199,
0.7549071908,
-0.1149927452,
-0.5240504146,
0.7097787857,
-0.6089594364,
-0.1189216301,
0.0065119369,
0.2433437705,
-0.9196358323,
-0.0205161348,
-0.2785282135,
-0.0511453077,
0.3734986782,
-0.1722931266,
-0.2423129678,
-0.2829140425,
-0.1352472603,
0.5652012825,
0.3966959417,
-0.6182581186,
0.6566178799,
0.2238793075,
-0.1840361655,
-0.5070158243,
-0.5168935061,
0.1058705524,
-0.236722365,
-0.6182144284,
0.210195899,
-0.2195389569,
-0.0331469402,
0.0181784183,
-0.0361545272,
-0.3718646765,
0.0653085932,
0.1952451915,
0.5549836755,
-0.1798021644,
0.1038100049,
0.1445304602,
-0.0199027974,
0.0231657661,
-0.1146638393,
0.5842993855,
0.0845386609,
-0.3503171504,
-0.5298956037,
0.0795503482,
0.9981736541,
-0.2204781622,
0.8878670335,
0.4778226614,
-0.0144515047,
-0.3754986823,
-0.6558158994,
-0.4127530158,
-0.526971221,
0.5173965693,
-0.4913873374,
-0.7223296165,
0.1998620033,
-0.3697350621,
-0.0542452522,
-0.0305552222,
0.7543719411,
0.3413481712,
0.973298192,
0.8159361482,
0.1339767873,
0.7153390646,
-0.3358193338,
0.0512363352,
-0.5426798463,
-0.7064925432,
-0.4662187397,
-0.5531814694,
-0.322176367,
-0.4797624946,
0.6817730069,
0.2240269631,
0.0468017161,
0.0839021131,
-0.3610399961,
0.7649255991,
0.768553555,
0.1361690611,
0.6007885337,
-0.0115309656,
-0.4108534455,
-0.1511698216,
-0.7728500366,
-0.1731115133,
1.391792655,
0.1378486007,
1.1101745367,
0.243891865,
0.6769076586,
0.0451836847,
0.0495762266,
-0.7099578381,
0.4789552391,
-0.1182913035,
-0.6274228692,
-0.1447596401,
-0.5616903305,
-0.6283063293,
0.5656926036,
-0.3898441792,
-0.1178353056,
0.2817780375,
-0.0157792028,
-0.2955505848,
0.3729342222,
-0.8309000731,
0.8458511829,
-0.3832457662,
-0.679628551,
-0.5189253688,
-0.4761759937,
0.5167480707,
-0.3063520789,
0.2265935242,
0.0870607197,
0.2061563879,
0.5122799873,
-0.3503154218,
0.7938045859,
-0.3935533464,
-0.0994703323,
0.2799770236,
-0.0102345878,
0.1252077669,
0.1520747244,
0.059479259,
0.0222423952,
0.1128891781,
-0.194717899,
-0.5101678967,
0.768460393,
-0.7883340716,
-0.7511184812,
-0.3868228495,
-0.5477747917,
-0.1570149213,
0.2041599751,
0.1009239033,
0.4821535349,
-0.1021336019,
0.6856245399,
0.6169285178,
0.2495455742,
0.5911738276,
0.692199111,
-0.1057367027,
-0.3633026779,
0.9290477633,
0.164460972,
0.5260143876,
0.1283975691,
0.3065024018,
-0.3570501804,
-0.513763845,
-0.4911010563,
0.0856233314,
-0.5111688972,
-0.4346464872,
-0.2666234076,
-0.1438516378,
-0.389244467,
-0.1039687172,
-0.5590658784,
-0.2252360731,
-0.2266482264,
0.1610992551,
-0.0431101732,
0.841283679,
-0.3520628214,
0.2326762974,
-0.7387869954,
0.3344303668,
0.8051230907,
0.1698701531,
0.2243917733,
-0.634280622,
-0.2816801369,
0.0820223391,
-0.5711328983,
-0.7853263617,
0.2549576759,
0.4884127378,
0.45867154,
0.6629804373,
0.208629936,
0.6119430065,
-0.4864307046,
0.651017189,
0.6401646137,
-0.9895154834,
0.2532465756,
-0.1437508464,
0.314019382,
0.7306903601,
0.4344204962,
-0.3893121779,
-0.1408287287,
-0.1575481594,
-0.6832795143,
0.7976287603,
-0.2169319391,
0.1018642709,
0.2368095517,
0.0844267905,
0.2451831847,
0.432346046,
-0.757589519,
-0.1146375909,
-0.3844955564,
-0.2814717293,
0.0922394618,
-0.2218877077,
-0.2163497508,
-0.5059602261,
0.6495042443,
-0.1020216867,
-0.4457222521,
-0.0810241997,
-0.1530877948,
0.0860891566,
0.3161671162,
0.2559475601,
0.739557445,
-0.1221278086,
0.577539742,
-0.0562975705,
-0.6521346569,
0.38117522,
0.0742182136,
-0.0515618399,
-0.1848944575,
0.2031964213,
0.7553508282,
0.3734674454,
-0.5229718089,
0.6993346214,
-0.2284362614,
-0.2565940619,
0.1198450401,
0.1155283079,
0.048204612,
0.7352797985,
0.4263597429,
-0.0453303494,
0.1224867254,
-0.6464408636,
0.0370623134,
0.3414095938,
-0.1628087163,
-0.4425770342,
0.8108982444,
0.5832828283,
0.2455043495,
0.4541046619,
0.0336503051,
-0.5428276062,
0.3455448449,
0.6968044639,
0.6682251692,
-0.3076518476,
0.2405105233,
0.4353192747,
-0.0422727391,
-0.1674626023,
-0.0465585105,
-0.2911381721,
-0.4827953875,
-0.3094173372,
-0.8366882205,
-0.1587140262,
0.0858980939,
-0.8168618083,
0.4146184921,
-0.2611519694,
-0.2026954889,
0.0373270698,
0.0501966327,
-0.5301838517,
-0.10672535,
0.3455846906,
0.5027653575,
-0.8815717101,
1.1334551573,
0.4591539502,
-0.3889963031,
-0.8251239657,
-0.180328086,
0.1941819191,
-0.6242569089,
1.0020904541,
-0.0835036933,
-0.2098103017,
0.1116335243,
-0.3640625477,
-0.7460776567,
1.4370617867,
0.6304444671,
-1.1491053104,
-0.1871830821,
0.1763149798,
0.2295692563,
-0.3446604908,
0.1471947283,
0.4845213592,
0.3822981417,
0.6626156569,
-1.1437675953,
-0.0059945825,
-0.1330549568,
0.0067131943,
-0.1429481208,
-0.862649262,
1.0596469641,
-0.2803421319,
-0.2009773999,
-0.2660947442,
0.558519125,
0.1020310149,
0.2188661098,
0.5845992565,
0.6439941525,
0.5888307691,
-0.0811035037,
0.5666101575,
-0.4093208015,
0.3877183199,
1.2092764378,
-0.2605722547,
0.6800553799,
0.6061137319,
-0.0804660246,
0.572922945,
0.1892832369,
-0.0160965715,
0.8200783134,
0.1324688941,
-0.4763632119,
-0.6412715912,
-0.3168509007,
-0.6487996578,
0.8080762625,
-0.0400517546,
-0.308067739,
-0.3727960289,
0.2206917405,
-0.0722950995,
0.2655634284,
-0.1175800487,
0.8201826215,
0.013689002,
-0.600219667,
0.7745565176,
-0.0955068097,
0.7666270137,
-0.6652411222,
-0.0715423599,
-0.1508223116,
0.4646714032,
0.1135669276,
-0.4005165696,
-0.2160977125,
-0.007235406,
-0.3262346983,
-0.3165153265,
0.3738621175,
-0.9686848521,
-0.408293426,
0.3137503862,
0.5997199416,
-0.2243987322,
0.0342874005,
-0.5156785846,
0.2597793639,
-0.0264283568,
-0.1686160564,
0.3586938381,
0.7385522127,
0.2782570422,
0.4540081322,
0.5313363075,
0.2801866531,
0.283111304,
0.3419971466,
1.2002779245,
-0.2239812762,
-0.2737999856,
-0.9598365426,
0.3405353427,
-0.1803886741,
-0.1481283009,
0.755849421,
0.5395407081,
0.8988265991,
0.0196748078,
0.6455589533,
-0.0447080694,
0.1136680245,
-0.5179025531,
0.9138916135,
-0.6116091609,
0.1841128767,
-0.1190724298,
-1.0600368977,
0.1765055805,
0.4087945223,
-0.0677464455,
0.0301779844,
0.6783835888,
0.5734758377,
-0.2288864553,
-0.1103942692,
0.4237513542,
0.2941067219,
0.3752338588,
0.7096714377,
0.7413655519,
-0.2242076695,
0.5728669763,
-0.4106441736,
-0.6387118101,
-0.1292028427,
-0.7793493867,
-1.096096158,
-0.7927908301,
-0.1540296078,
-0.127927646,
-0.0108885746,
0.9034768939,
0.8274226785,
-0.5536633134,
-0.467576623,
0.1285581738,
-0.0230986904,
-0.104672581,
-0.237249285,
0.1389069259,
-0.4491611421,
-1.1294392347,
0.3409928679,
0.0680284649,
-0.015986532,
-0.4041303992,
0.0840808973,
-0.3464598954,
0.1397116333,
0.6019482017,
-0.1809329987,
-0.3306686878,
0.0744476542,
-0.053537719,
-0.0605258234,
-0.2969417274,
0.9577794075,
-0.6564421058,
0.720279336,
0.4499033093,
0.4739970565,
0.5283414721,
-0.1239952669,
0.4927642345,
-0.67923069,
0.3532393575,
-0.0133017767,
0.2723721266,
0.1338577867,
0.0224956237,
0.2489324659,
0.6298217773,
-0.61757797,
-0.8640337586,
-0.0204339325,
-1.0037471056,
-0.5232229233,
1.1184704304,
-0.1495243162,
-0.0618295819,
0.1186440215,
-0.2466972023,
0.5253090858,
-0.4114588201,
1.0449550152,
0.6271112561,
0.213938728,
-0.039952442,
-0.3543887436,
0.3701020479,
0.2805324495,
-0.6188635826,
0.28582111,
0.710714817,
0.3681676984,
-0.0635005832,
0.3147081137,
-0.1139251441,
0.0084597943,
0.1177081019,
-0.0272390079,
-0.6489726901,
-0.7734450698,
-0.1957954019,
0.4700359702,
0.0882830918,
-0.2950790524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08206v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08206v2
|
Human-Centric Autonomous Systems With LLMs for User Command Reasoning
| 2023-11-14T14:42:28 | 2023-12-19T23:03:56 |
Yi Yang, Qingwen Zhang, Ci Li, Daniel Simões Marta, Nazre Batool, John Folkesson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.RO
|
The evolution of autonomous driving has made remarkable advancements in
recent years, evolving into a tangible reality. However, a human-centric
large-scale adoption hinges on meeting a variety of multifaceted requirements.
To ensure that the autonomous system meets the user's intent, it is essential
to accurately discern and interpret user commands, especially in complex or
emergency situations. To this end, we propose to leverage the reasoning
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to infer system requirements from
in-cabin users' commands. Through a series of experiments that include
different LLM models and prompt designs, we explore the few-shot multivariate
binary classification accuracy of system requirements from natural language
textual commands. We confirm the general ability of LLMs to understand and
reason about prompts but underline that their effectiveness is conditioned on
the quality of both the LLM model and the design of appropriate sequential
prompts. Code and models are public with the link
\url{https://github.com/KTH-RPL/DriveCmd_LLM}.
|
[
-0.4969719648,
-0.6181832552,
1.3163170815,
0.3519239128,
-0.0652706027,
-0.0341061801,
-0.1320269257,
-0.537879765,
-0.1363452524,
0.543253839,
-0.8503398299,
-0.4241219461,
-0.2223525196,
0.242447108,
-0.3542052507,
0.4340580404,
-0.0683983639,
0.0850804448,
-0.455398798,
0.1378935724,
-0.6529300809,
-0.7629014254,
-0.2882714272,
-0.4051345587,
0.7235821486,
0.6812314987,
0.7355791926,
0.3062344193,
0.3358569741,
0.2558577061,
0.0942803621,
0.3207019866,
0.1969321221,
0.1987116337,
-0.2312493324,
-0.2344077229,
-0.3025491238,
-0.3097344041,
0.4730635583,
0.5748035312,
-0.0900950655,
-0.3589320779,
0.1084573194,
0.1784815341,
-0.4980153143,
0.1553357095,
-0.1608097851,
-0.2326263487,
0.0960068554,
-0.1042636409,
-0.4504896104,
-0.3297227621,
0.249087736,
-0.6958152652,
-0.147437498,
0.2507427335,
0.5966264606,
0.404220134,
-0.7056812644,
-0.3960408866,
-0.7721816897,
0.7188591361,
-0.8947925568,
0.5108016133,
0.3903106451,
0.3613779843,
-0.6282064319,
-0.2910968661,
-0.8592992425,
-0.4571791589,
-0.224227488,
-0.2029245943,
0.1258293539,
0.4102212191,
0.2700653672,
-0.1756781191,
-0.5271810889,
0.6597317457,
-0.0791907161,
-0.298863709,
0.6770333052,
0.596033752,
0.2037699968,
-0.3261093497,
-0.7866530418,
0.0556736477,
-0.6983379722,
0.2165722102,
0.2173979729,
0.5020542145,
-0.3429731727,
0.6168488264,
-0.4646562636,
0.7669650316,
-0.1168144569,
-0.2302503437,
0.1741839796,
-0.5450398922,
-0.1988457739,
-0.0683047846,
0.8474673033,
0.4465822577,
0.2097760737,
-0.0773270875,
-0.7396274209,
-0.0224321727,
0.2826007605,
-0.5426260829,
0.0476886258,
0.4406586587,
-0.4376499951,
0.0181560684,
0.1355601996,
-0.4494110346,
-0.7379471064,
-0.8404932022,
0.4309100211,
-0.3571381271,
-0.1026895344,
0.2567934096,
0.0773477256,
0.5894806385,
0.7420486212,
-0.8479226232,
0.0864895955,
0.785179615,
0.7331207395,
-0.3324444592,
-0.3280413747,
-0.2886040211,
-0.0854801312,
-0.1077977121,
1.1370280981,
-0.2533071041,
-0.5758778453,
-0.0789863542,
-0.009070415,
-0.0020570785,
-0.3572826087,
0.6770070195,
-0.6908305883,
0.0143715311,
-0.3528763652,
-0.5903339386,
-0.4508855939,
0.2471338212,
-0.2833762169,
0.5127949715,
-0.0087946039,
-0.1178803444,
0.4643937051,
-0.8077204227,
-0.799408555,
0.3280533254,
-0.2376323491,
-0.0565418191,
0.0933332592,
0.2393251508,
0.8614161611,
-0.4466511905,
0.4400439858,
-0.4741723239,
-0.092805855,
0.3259665966,
-0.4084588289,
0.6418623924,
0.1791935861,
-0.1051307619,
0.4619336128,
-0.5438793898,
0.0233269054,
-0.0670417845,
-0.5743713975,
-0.2122412175,
0.3514216542,
0.1622059345,
0.069699347,
0.4864168465,
-0.3490837812,
0.3419348598,
-0.2730052471,
0.2187654823,
0.8636673093,
0.0153381731,
0.6511176825,
-0.3081787229,
0.5196989775,
-0.0340975411,
0.1769987345,
-0.3623021841,
-0.4912415743,
-0.4898326993,
-0.3547053635,
-0.263029635,
0.8339173198,
-0.6149458289,
0.6511127949,
0.1867569983,
-0.2241428196,
-0.0953028277,
0.0223326012,
0.1314510554,
0.3528822362,
0.1845665127,
0.0047799386,
-0.4712505639,
-0.7513837218,
0.1810050011,
-0.4873228073,
-0.2150804549,
0.5111585855,
0.4889917374,
-0.6594581604,
1.0917106867,
-0.3617056906,
-0.1082706451,
-0.4432044029,
0.0347846746,
0.0269241929,
0.2571221292,
0.4872647524,
-0.692299962,
-0.0501878485,
0.0646360666,
-1.0066484213,
-0.3366478384,
-0.454189539,
-0.0103023648,
0.2383108288,
0.5464906693,
-0.8118056059,
0.3789197803,
0.2645678222,
-0.6127026081,
0.7391525507,
-0.4973161817,
-0.0028814822,
-0.6589412689,
-0.1093076989,
0.0918407813,
-0.4923774898,
-0.6200687289,
0.0792188942,
0.0825693533,
0.2742825747,
-0.347574383,
0.4411300421,
-0.2810481191,
-0.2592202127,
-0.5393395424,
0.051106222,
-0.0918572694,
0.217547521,
0.1230390146,
0.6719747186,
0.5901148915,
-0.9870891571,
0.6874735355,
0.1025746912,
-0.5814340115,
0.8322862983,
-0.7310268283,
0.0928606391,
-0.178643316,
0.2937917709,
-1.1284009218,
-0.6746407151,
0.2032707334,
-0.1511128545,
-0.0581111014,
0.1615727842,
-0.8568403125,
-0.2420529574,
0.3351870477,
0.105322808,
0.3318331242,
-0.7064236403,
0.8767902255,
0.3007427454,
-0.1266553551,
-0.0610350519,
-0.1968687922,
0.2332461625,
-0.2564041317,
-0.5763136744,
-0.0299904011,
-0.1622124463,
-0.4945227504,
-0.3272311389,
0.3093366325,
-0.051297158,
0.468469739,
0.7128376961,
0.6263788939,
-0.2466085851,
0.2861274183,
-0.084429577,
-0.1557820588,
0.365427196,
-0.4399031997,
0.4891147017,
-0.3526227772,
-0.4679127932,
-0.8200957179,
0.4939472675,
0.8827623725,
-0.1064658687,
0.5357105732,
0.2938961685,
-0.2227228433,
-0.1555631161,
-0.4613910317,
-0.5447234511,
-0.4805060327,
0.1778415889,
-0.4633711278,
-0.6968531609,
0.4256384075,
-0.0990777835,
0.1044944078,
0.3317852318,
0.6464481354,
-0.630476892,
1.1856017113,
0.4931836724,
-0.0302829668,
0.2761396468,
0.2073759139,
-0.1874075681,
-0.3715954721,
-0.42397663,
-0.471365124,
-0.3172453642,
-0.4017247558,
-0.1811889261,
0.488386631,
-0.3923683465,
-0.4110623002,
0.1825827211,
-0.1099958345,
0.3582823277,
0.55064255,
0.121837385,
0.2811969519,
-0.3388201594,
-0.1518387198,
0.3188056052,
-0.4792639613,
-0.6670158505,
0.5223084688,
0.4289580882,
1.1991586685,
0.1091609821,
0.4496613145,
0.3414061964,
0.115758948,
-0.996625483,
0.6290462613,
0.2320724875,
-0.6002946496,
-0.3539427817,
-0.6170786619,
-0.8042773604,
0.1244002432,
-0.2834831476,
-0.5455267429,
0.2399903983,
0.0599559098,
-0.8144090176,
-0.057455685,
-0.9122753143,
0.807240963,
-0.8294774294,
0.1469893157,
-0.3130998313,
-0.9133190513,
0.3572783768,
-0.1234561652,
0.3208947182,
-0.2728755474,
-0.0812471434,
0.4866978824,
-0.4239372611,
1.1348870993,
-0.4178301096,
-0.2348885387,
0.1882932931,
0.0868413523,
0.4920003712,
-0.0926310942,
0.1064044461,
-0.0006145863,
-0.0546179079,
-0.1721457243,
-0.714679718,
0.5610045195,
-0.821775496,
-0.5891572237,
-0.3627997339,
-0.6088177562,
0.0021583096,
0.2338672131,
-0.012591457,
0.3944216669,
0.1135390922,
-0.1167977452,
0.6061598659,
-0.2680818141,
0.4732890725,
0.5987517238,
-0.5148561597,
0.1168121025,
0.5016391277,
-0.1303436011,
0.387652576,
0.4093298018,
0.3095489442,
-0.6689881682,
-0.5949015021,
-0.6819480062,
0.1227486655,
-0.749830246,
-0.095977664,
-0.4972932339,
-0.0029475319,
-0.1154477075,
-0.2632546425,
-0.2458054572,
-0.1918527484,
-0.7413591743,
-0.1048779264,
0.3960927129,
1.1476994753,
0.0693608522,
0.68167454,
-0.6319465637,
0.5093138218,
0.2432153523,
0.300283134,
-0.188097164,
-0.6739344597,
0.0185630582,
0.0038816649,
-0.1227621511,
-0.8102700114,
0.222030282,
-0.2329013348,
0.8171288967,
0.5131385922,
0.3475673497,
0.1928347647,
-0.2655021846,
0.5428962708,
0.2724055648,
-0.6338116527,
0.5195934176,
-0.2332482189,
0.4409988523,
0.5128656626,
0.3425449431,
-0.4136768281,
-0.1092941314,
0.0044379286,
-0.695990622,
0.6646598577,
-0.3046895862,
-0.0691032708,
0.2570081055,
0.3279696107,
0.0790593103,
-0.1000781357,
-0.4910420477,
0.0155657567,
0.1633577645,
-0.2808862329,
-0.1186989993,
-0.0295832977,
0.2898352146,
0.0708590597,
0.3759261072,
-0.2588234842,
0.1485187262,
0.1927965581,
0.0020097713,
0.1578080803,
0.3852550089,
0.8625442982,
0.4885966182,
-0.2778185904,
0.3599686921,
0.2655822933,
-0.1428026855,
0.5976336002,
-0.1128299311,
-0.2656476498,
-0.2626866698,
0.0868885592,
0.6303034425,
0.1801686436,
-0.8123771548,
0.4664156437,
-0.1763449013,
0.0343201011,
-0.4634280801,
0.2733792663,
-0.0160126816,
0.4044345915,
0.3074832857,
0.3041929305,
-0.0032096598,
-0.4218159318,
0.1474806219,
0.4445954859,
-0.421774298,
-0.3589995801,
0.5821447968,
0.35745579,
-0.4828062952,
0.610355854,
-0.4713730216,
-0.5124407411,
0.4236707091,
0.24389036,
0.9300836921,
-0.190051958,
0.0403092168,
0.2777677476,
0.3393767774,
-0.3153685629,
0.3168900311,
-0.1247328222,
-0.8126266003,
-0.5338904858,
-0.5217641592,
-0.6761421561,
-0.144215852,
-0.2222402394,
0.3953099549,
-0.7549337745,
-0.2217792273,
-0.0228834692,
-0.4883894324,
-0.671518743,
0.0940336213,
0.3979666829,
0.8124245405,
-0.6516823769,
0.5606962442,
0.6613501906,
-0.2791777849,
-0.8112248182,
-0.1439282,
0.3213911057,
-0.6883230209,
0.7283470631,
0.2231780738,
-0.2946868837,
-0.3356210887,
-0.6117064357,
-0.4822909236,
0.8591423035,
0.2187557071,
-0.7295454144,
-0.295592159,
0.0336639173,
0.2012866437,
-0.6287632585,
0.2181571871,
0.8200398088,
0.6801947355,
0.1770240963,
-1.0068744421,
0.0387371443,
0.3478369415,
-0.3109638691,
0.036619097,
-0.188707307,
0.60814327,
-0.6906177402,
-0.2589021027,
0.140225932,
0.6938841343,
0.482144475,
0.5720653534,
0.9394460917,
0.2293534726,
0.8393201828,
-0.0006364975,
1.3040210009,
0.1313517541,
-0.1266926676,
0.9735247493,
-0.5263460279,
0.8726505637,
0.4390830696,
-0.1772901714,
0.6836335063,
0.5404320955,
0.2858998477,
0.4428775012,
-0.07966768,
-0.4145398438,
-0.6661245823,
-0.1372313201,
0.0741020516,
0.6237825155,
0.5565129519,
-0.2130632401,
-0.115921393,
0.2833144367,
-0.2561789751,
-0.0938636586,
-0.1850088537,
1.02921772,
0.1608868092,
-0.8705676198,
0.3836554289,
0.2026948929,
0.6537647247,
-0.4923935533,
0.1933574229,
0.0592552722,
0.1735975295,
-0.3612992764,
-1.1180378199,
0.0093073035,
0.05945668,
-0.2697881162,
-0.3402433395,
0.5994070768,
-0.096992299,
-0.3842653334,
0.271028012,
0.4898710251,
0.3669272661,
-0.2604555786,
-0.3053330481,
0.0715517476,
0.058545243,
-0.0107157649,
0.0562686361,
0.3387669325,
-0.1063081622,
0.9161928892,
0.6119682193,
-0.0061654365,
-0.0135647012,
0.1265736222,
0.6848730445,
-0.8013561368,
-0.6929374337,
-1.0652776957,
0.3917466104,
0.4243158996,
-0.1297499835,
0.6097494364,
0.3324227333,
0.4387573302,
-0.0299108755,
1.06526649,
0.0502215065,
0.5028368831,
-0.5746908784,
0.4154425561,
-0.5400759578,
0.4493205845,
0.1122112423,
-0.6203194261,
-0.2803593874,
0.769492507,
-0.3592295647,
0.0633269474,
0.1978642941,
1.0235960484,
-0.1714704186,
0.1520024389,
0.3254708052,
-0.0581646301,
0.6003135443,
0.6744461656,
1.6207703352,
0.2737314999,
0.3916885555,
0.0495253988,
-0.3237376809,
-0.5320770741,
-0.8209610581,
-0.6833919287,
-0.6087755561,
-0.0660125837,
-0.1087345853,
-0.3492382169,
1.4349281788,
0.8036133051,
-0.6998090744,
-0.3872487843,
-0.2127391994,
0.4779814482,
0.157143712,
-0.1918942928,
-0.1754790097,
-0.4588199556,
-0.2367216051,
0.5906962752,
0.3706296086,
0.5108832121,
-0.6333828568,
-0.522367835,
-0.0184090398,
0.0207022447,
0.6224832535,
0.1938640177,
-1.0148788691,
-0.5099312663,
0.1946574152,
-0.3934479952,
-0.0804816335,
0.8594275713,
-0.8066732287,
0.3593305945,
0.522210896,
0.4798143804,
0.0430528708,
0.1102188826,
0.6164371371,
-0.550105691,
-0.1938841194,
0.1852428615,
0.4990406632,
0.5531955361,
-0.3776923716,
-0.0255984981,
0.1817779243,
-0.8660411835,
-0.545234859,
0.3479804397,
-1.1432971954,
-0.3252508342,
1.4284584522,
-0.0649830997,
-0.1585391015,
-0.5967390537,
-0.5586898327,
-0.336245656,
-0.6364358664,
0.5661452413,
0.4085309505,
-0.2131088376,
-0.409406662,
-0.528902173,
0.1833720803,
0.1952319741,
-1.0496373177,
0.2597304583,
0.8099879026,
-0.042326346,
0.1253477782,
0.4072695076,
0.4757213295,
0.4538496435,
-0.3416267037,
0.0901413783,
0.1633334756,
-0.5680602789,
-0.3397161663,
0.0614485331,
0.2654013038,
-0.0980377495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08195v1
|
Automated Fact-Checking in Dialogue: Are Specialized Models Needed?
| 2023-11-14T14:29:00 | 2023-11-14T14:29:00 |
Eric Chamoun, Marzieh Saeidi, Andreas Vlachos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prior research has shown that typical fact-checking models for stand-alone
claims struggle with claims made in dialogues. As a solution, fine-tuning these
models on labelled dialogue data has been proposed. However, creating separate
models for each use case is impractical, and we show that fine-tuning models
for dialogue results in poor performance on typical fact-checking. To overcome
this challenge, we present techniques that allow us to use the same models for
both dialogue and typical fact-checking. These mainly focus on retrieval
adaptation and transforming conversational inputs so that they can be
accurately predicted by models trained on stand-alone claims. We demonstrate
that a typical fact-checking model incorporating these techniques is
competitive with state-of-the-art models fine-tuned for dialogue, while
maintaining its accuracy on stand-alone claims.
|
[
-0.1461834013,
-0.7442301512,
0.7532138824,
-0.1550320238,
-0.3090946972,
0.1781536341,
0.1013463438,
-0.4985114634,
0.1450472623,
1.0501010418,
-0.5064772964,
-0.3589972854,
-0.6192885041,
0.1769117713,
-0.4481862783,
1.1924408674,
0.1540204436,
-0.0263727792,
-0.4111633301,
-0.5052773952,
-0.348125428,
-0.6143890023,
-0.5305484533,
-0.3811100721,
0.1820379943,
0.4870972335,
0.8548607826,
0.3312701881,
0.3902100623,
0.3744089901,
-0.0394164994,
0.575596869,
-0.2035923153,
-0.0758794546,
-0.2562380433,
-0.5557975769,
-0.6382811069,
0.0924589261,
0.469825536,
0.6079024076,
-0.1536166966,
0.1883076131,
-0.3650304377,
0.3177982867,
-0.5354194045,
0.3926430345,
-0.9294796586,
-0.0629839376,
0.1439051479,
-0.0523693264,
-0.4860778451,
-0.6232081652,
0.4465006292,
-0.324804306,
0.4903793037,
0.1706530005,
1.0155515671,
0.2837790549,
-0.65944314,
-0.5241845846,
-0.7206683159,
0.5643380284,
-0.856159389,
0.1278684437,
0.427398175,
0.1357097477,
0.0420746431,
-0.6643146276,
-0.5525188446,
-0.5038983822,
-0.5834088326,
0.0895524994,
-0.3766800761,
0.4307491779,
0.4274144471,
0.2033270299,
-0.101361759,
0.0706552938,
-0.4786721468,
-0.3076887429,
0.7712445855,
0.1915026158,
0.1647215039,
-0.2403613478,
-0.0318645723,
0.0797495469,
-0.6138215065,
0.1082267985,
0.2022571862,
0.3315964043,
0.1143744588,
0.541487515,
-0.5775783062,
0.8285115957,
0.2306838632,
-0.2192536741,
-0.1926105917,
-0.6273035407,
-0.2846454382,
0.1288460195,
0.4955552518,
0.4270251393,
0.1073931456,
-0.0944806561,
-0.3315992951,
-0.0643650442,
0.2747898102,
-0.6679050922,
-0.4451393187,
0.0477611758,
-0.2370735109,
-0.3385412693,
-0.004850463,
-0.3980095387,
-0.5580414534,
-0.508421123,
0.7556232214,
0.0300354194,
-0.0111071402,
0.2091632336,
-0.101296261,
-0.2967260778,
0.6722896099,
-0.6191053987,
0.3651673794,
0.5002743006,
0.6943177581,
-0.0921859965,
0.2431922853,
-0.8389036059,
-0.1169598997,
-0.4170814455,
1.0785620213,
-0.6123785973,
-0.2020334005,
0.0058074491,
0.1630920619,
-0.1996279657,
-0.6201120615,
0.8724184632,
-0.4961463809,
0.1682792902,
-0.2914443314,
-0.5594585538,
-0.4968509674,
0.3812595904,
-0.7589378953,
0.3683637083,
-0.007315468,
-0.5456326604,
0.3301925361,
-0.6508786678,
-0.4106715918,
-0.0586179383,
-0.0171544664,
-0.6235913634,
0.2298733443,
0.2296984941,
0.2464366406,
-0.3688159287,
0.4506039321,
-0.1930172741,
-0.1129752398,
0.3840752244,
-0.2085881829,
0.7755396366,
0.1798912585,
-0.0778933913,
0.1139231101,
-0.849924624,
-0.0707543939,
-0.2197004557,
-0.3315277994,
-0.1439090073,
0.2953320444,
-0.4141018093,
-0.1858818084,
0.2581984699,
-0.7478533983,
0.1209519431,
-0.3071405292,
0.2205749154,
0.3037522435,
0.0116187995,
0.2024551928,
-0.6076503992,
0.1209895164,
0.3428154588,
-0.0721232444,
-0.2073135227,
-0.1982258409,
-1.1970645189,
-0.2688804567,
0.577935636,
0.7737389207,
-0.4585805833,
0.3985283673,
0.0793453231,
-0.4995546937,
-0.5554810166,
0.0098468866,
0.1589426845,
0.6404693127,
0.3578404188,
-0.6170742512,
-0.7080288529,
-0.9632081389,
-0.5464918017,
-0.4564247429,
0.1266155243,
0.3320651948,
0.350851357,
-0.1587972641,
1.1884260178,
-0.5541824698,
-0.0429342128,
-0.1336240619,
0.5071220994,
0.1903485954,
0.4065315723,
0.4920059741,
-0.827286005,
-0.3787332177,
0.0074917842,
-0.6420294046,
-0.1765701771,
-0.3925932944,
0.4184271097,
0.1535037607,
0.3247620463,
-0.8564284444,
0.5604946017,
0.3973784745,
-0.145206809,
0.6135109067,
-0.1905593872,
0.4314697981,
-0.7145178318,
-0.2629440129,
0.1537552923,
-0.691283524,
-0.8088899851,
-0.1213901043,
-0.0105528729,
-0.1109893098,
-0.1680991948,
0.2303485274,
-0.1690096259,
0.1004096195,
-0.5266956091,
-0.2135643363,
0.1632228792,
0.4196311831,
0.3224328756,
0.533865273,
0.5070659518,
-0.8662347198,
0.6922621131,
0.1819121093,
-0.6080278158,
0.5236728787,
-0.8152397871,
0.2305755019,
0.0479577258,
0.4189529717,
-0.8710740805,
-0.3343765736,
0.1079467461,
-0.1913356483,
0.0953170061,
-0.5329563618,
-0.4125930965,
0.0317880325,
0.2121423632,
0.0274190046,
0.442954421,
-0.5586412549,
1.0202522278,
0.4105569124,
-0.6942330003,
-0.2397909313,
-0.2278093994,
0.2095325887,
-0.161295101,
-0.4867120981,
0.2723682225,
0.1439463496,
-0.4609847665,
-0.2941733301,
-0.2455062866,
-0.367863059,
0.1961404979,
0.1231182665,
0.1765507162,
-0.3040491939,
0.1109002158,
0.0950030535,
-0.0010821606,
-0.0414030068,
-0.1125915349,
-0.1947869062,
-0.0294611473,
-0.6743198037,
-0.6563913226,
0.4757948816,
0.8333320022,
-0.3145131767,
0.6161350608,
0.229849726,
-0.2638990581,
0.0992123038,
-0.9567985535,
-0.3815155923,
-0.447629571,
0.4482054412,
-0.1124112681,
-0.8297609091,
0.5070791245,
-0.4481476545,
0.3601544797,
0.3899097145,
0.4661235213,
-0.2991993427,
1.2375313044,
0.9302312732,
0.2645628154,
0.4133456647,
0.3998433948,
0.5011199713,
-0.1585396528,
-0.0327636711,
-0.781789422,
0.1401371956,
-0.5643762946,
-0.1569766253,
0.468029052,
-0.2894743979,
-0.095935002,
0.3617088199,
-0.111857079,
0.4497252703,
0.4378784895,
0.1051098257,
0.8095763922,
-0.0645704642,
0.1660110503,
0.0667675808,
-0.5811997652,
-0.5560123324,
0.6894509792,
0.2637593448,
0.8821092248,
0.1460540295,
0.2627727985,
0.5296788812,
0.2107954472,
-0.6568619013,
0.5318674445,
-0.2698790729,
-0.6359362602,
-0.1403361559,
-0.488763988,
-0.5913754702,
0.2465957999,
-0.2509091198,
-0.7254120111,
0.2174210995,
0.293980509,
-0.7795087099,
0.1438707262,
-0.9056165218,
0.6737343073,
-0.2071491927,
0.2739954293,
-0.4885617197,
-0.4651786685,
0.3571256995,
-0.0880370885,
-0.0562069304,
-0.2223736495,
0.5454033613,
0.616464138,
-0.4834708869,
1.1684514284,
-0.0916707963,
0.0246823616,
0.4664032459,
0.1853083223,
0.7072474957,
0.2519276738,
0.015948901,
-0.1185630187,
0.4645072818,
-0.2329475582,
-0.7435221076,
0.0925820321,
-0.7724730372,
-1.1818906069,
-0.4405419528,
-0.5999341607,
-0.3249552548,
0.0571331084,
0.0295079425,
0.6119310856,
-0.5494071245,
0.2911955416,
0.8252555132,
0.0277162232,
0.0201145746,
1.0876828432,
0.1758896559,
0.0186977126,
0.7452366948,
0.1705188602,
0.2888689935,
0.2909362912,
0.1039581746,
-0.176787585,
-0.5987893343,
-0.3273431063,
0.0467764139,
-0.7052804232,
-0.2440164387,
-0.9042191505,
-0.221689254,
-0.4462417066,
0.3272385001,
-0.561978817,
-0.6462861896,
-0.2259410471,
-0.0767036006,
0.4414706528,
0.7731133103,
-0.1074966341,
0.2176323086,
-0.9195620418,
0.537163198,
0.72959131,
0.1091785133,
-0.5683688521,
-0.8158298135,
-0.3563320339,
0.4020582736,
-0.4236111641,
-0.7174339294,
0.0687883794,
0.4017227292,
0.3305957317,
0.1022100002,
0.3970617354,
0.4573797584,
-0.3884759843,
0.7514218688,
-0.0094503919,
-0.8312918544,
0.5624345541,
-0.0367599018,
0.0756355748,
0.7176605463,
0.1710532457,
-0.6245083213,
-0.3448231518,
-0.5485631227,
-0.1403963566,
0.8739221096,
0.0036520632,
0.1789731979,
0.2441084087,
0.09784621,
0.1912602186,
0.1428382844,
-0.309001863,
0.1199134216,
-0.290340215,
-0.1722063124,
-0.0028173518,
-0.2324478328,
-0.6228109002,
-0.3024590015,
0.5205199122,
-0.3798088133,
-0.0297510531,
0.2494716048,
-0.3719226122,
-0.0485155322,
0.436971873,
0.5231710076,
0.6961852908,
-0.2506061196,
-0.1419314295,
0.4220716655,
-0.2080475986,
0.1396488845,
0.1164803281,
-0.3607431054,
0.4983623326,
0.0413983725,
1.022031188,
0.3071834743,
-0.5080450177,
0.3280175626,
-0.1139269695,
-0.0798654109,
-0.1501412243,
0.3555327356,
-0.0029349008,
0.2592123449,
0.2711896896,
0.6079468727,
0.1591561437,
-0.8400849104,
0.1936511099,
0.3439448476,
-0.0986706391,
-0.342427969,
0.0707898512,
0.4731501639,
-0.4932260215,
0.6040169597,
0.0465798154,
-0.5875756741,
0.6987195015,
0.2275603712,
0.811254859,
-0.102917999,
0.4169969559,
0.3425901532,
0.2285526991,
-0.320279628,
-0.3318258822,
-0.1876661777,
-0.9469531775,
-0.340339154,
-0.2868108153,
-1.0270231962,
0.0726085827,
-0.6687560081,
0.3124777377,
-0.4989611208,
-0.3318458498,
0.2553490102,
0.1464776695,
-0.7036272883,
0.3951681852,
0.0403585359,
0.828502357,
-0.8454066515,
0.5928632021,
0.5448675752,
-0.1957954317,
-0.4552840292,
-0.0438454039,
0.1954249442,
-0.4808342755,
0.522095561,
-0.132284373,
-0.4521345794,
-0.1251448244,
-0.8501532078,
-0.8355588317,
0.6618076563,
0.6613500714,
-0.5426009893,
-0.0324806944,
-0.0180657823,
0.4785739183,
-0.6594020128,
0.2886098921,
0.8428764939,
0.1895108372,
0.1454514414,
-1.3721837997,
-0.1543795615,
0.1704329997,
-0.4100277126,
-0.2459332347,
-0.7764559984,
0.6749811172,
-0.1720893681,
-0.2736922503,
0.2016583234,
0.7099640965,
0.1061645597,
0.3241495192,
0.5973006487,
0.3709146976,
0.9800246954,
-0.0602492765,
0.6856023073,
-0.1078595966,
0.447599113,
1.2537937164,
-0.4072055817,
0.3944145143,
-0.0705878213,
-0.0112453345,
0.649882555,
0.5743981004,
-0.1475660503,
0.3349127173,
-0.1950068623,
-0.3763704002,
-0.7897148132,
-0.3672775924,
0.0441696122,
0.6696062088,
0.5827729702,
-0.2151282132,
-0.3878710866,
-0.2216754407,
-0.100926213,
-0.0460409597,
-0.1542615592,
1.1791311502,
-0.138850078,
-1.2390909195,
0.4501130581,
0.1393185407,
0.2922191322,
-0.4672776461,
-0.0294354726,
-0.1817765683,
0.0695516691,
-0.2391474694,
-0.4897198379,
0.2747518122,
0.289147824,
-0.2776941657,
0.0115093812,
0.8662629128,
-0.5313713551,
-0.3842202723,
-0.3026330769,
0.5081834197,
0.0916196406,
-0.0380051695,
-0.777102828,
-0.0378508046,
0.1738213003,
0.020766858,
0.1411512941,
0.257774353,
-0.1226788312,
0.6401346326,
0.411803484,
-0.1878849268,
-0.1932187229,
0.3337939084,
0.7093298435,
-0.5081675649,
-0.4790341556,
-0.6990535259,
0.3981233239,
-0.2491738051,
-0.0108156446,
0.480145663,
0.3105880618,
0.5079889894,
0.0276746936,
0.9389466047,
0.1299903691,
0.7253181934,
-0.6086587906,
0.6612080336,
-0.3052801192,
-0.0741501972,
-0.0227632411,
-0.6044047475,
-0.2080715746,
0.5398783088,
-0.2377974838,
-0.0605453663,
0.6435050964,
1.0501470566,
-0.212964192,
0.4012283683,
0.3759498,
0.3133835196,
0.2900019288,
0.2115278691,
0.739490211,
-0.3939809203,
0.41863361,
0.2168204486,
-0.1613748074,
-0.5184392929,
-0.8370526433,
-0.9860083461,
-0.5585712194,
-1.0194729567,
-0.2910579443,
0.06412635,
0.7658408284,
1.0410354137,
-1.0789301395,
-0.0125917951,
0.0912110507,
0.3100469112,
-0.0475836024,
-0.0818801746,
-0.0140529955,
-0.4712176621,
-0.6395595074,
0.4355044365,
0.2679195702,
0.1611139029,
0.0126282731,
0.2363161296,
-0.2157543302,
0.7364813089,
0.3443366885,
0.5426442027,
-0.7696116567,
-0.5462539792,
-0.2776338458,
-0.1684945524,
0.2504244447,
1.2749680281,
-0.6901974678,
0.6515116096,
0.4018494189,
0.6689655781,
0.5748232007,
0.4264674187,
0.7841827273,
-0.6978424191,
-0.1143573746,
0.3146974742,
0.4343321323,
0.5957768559,
-0.4380235672,
0.1292901337,
0.2914856076,
-0.6562339067,
-0.8957563043,
0.60526824,
-0.77254498,
-0.0236148667,
0.740516901,
-0.4021681547,
0.0169150252,
-0.5519786477,
-0.3008418381,
0.2409695387,
-0.2306295186,
0.9704288244,
1.078514576,
-0.1689371616,
-0.2090856284,
-0.2382518798,
0.7761664987,
0.640188694,
-0.5702756643,
0.2980364859,
0.3808349073,
0.4633648396,
0.3619427383,
0.4248817563,
0.1358759552,
0.4915993214,
0.0015267853,
-0.3679531813,
0.1611245573,
-0.256646663,
-0.1088808775,
0.0332153775,
0.0402221046,
0.0380760171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08191v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08191v1
|
GEC-DePenD: Non-Autoregressive Grammatical Error Correction with Decoupled Permutation and Decoding
| 2023-11-14T14:24:36 | 2023-11-14T14:24:36 |
Konstantin Yakovlev, Alexander Podolskiy, Andrey Bout, Sergey Nikolenko, Irina Piontkovskaya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Grammatical error correction (GEC) is an important NLP task that is currently
usually solved with autoregressive sequence-to-sequence models. However,
approaches of this class are inherently slow due to one-by-one token
generation, so non-autoregressive alternatives are needed. In this work, we
propose a novel non-autoregressive approach to GEC that decouples the
architecture into a permutation network that outputs a self-attention weight
matrix that can be used in beam search to find the best permutation of input
tokens (with auxiliary {ins} tokens) and a decoder network based on a
step-unrolled denoising autoencoder that fills in specific tokens. This allows
us to find the token permutation after only one forward pass of the permutation
network, avoiding autoregressive constructions. We show that the resulting
network improves over previously known non-autoregressive methods for GEC and
reaches the level of autoregressive methods that do not use language-specific
synthetic data generation methods. Our results are supported by a comprehensive
experimental validation on the ConLL-2014 and Write&Improve+LOCNESS datasets
and an extensive ablation study that supports our architectural and algorithmic
choices.
|
[
-0.1219620928,
-0.586327374,
0.1928800344,
0.2318998575,
-0.0811007693,
-0.0025094156,
0.0010704714,
-0.1756292731,
0.4614371359,
0.2172048241,
-0.5233676434,
-0.6288921237,
-0.5358247757,
0.3833705783,
-0.6506809592,
0.7599360943,
-0.0868912488,
-0.0382765792,
-0.0827651024,
-0.1283554286,
-0.2758909464,
-0.621937573,
-0.4901992381,
-0.0890827104,
0.3696788549,
0.4439557493,
0.5819162726,
0.4505809844,
0.409117043,
0.3760385811,
-0.0380039923,
0.3244521022,
-0.4232082963,
0.0617084503,
-0.3131551445,
-0.2270231843,
-0.5141731501,
-0.2414392084,
0.6932937503,
0.6103067994,
-0.3572664559,
-0.0737063214,
0.037949793,
0.799934864,
-0.9373502731,
0.2782378793,
-0.665507555,
0.2855706513,
-0.3359341323,
-0.0237301085,
-0.5667646527,
-0.0407114923,
-0.523861587,
-0.2924475968,
0.4708289802,
-0.2091052234,
0.4991313815,
0.3250453472,
-0.2874329388,
-0.0031160589,
-0.6111685634,
0.2807686329,
-0.9221585393,
0.33088094,
0.2798121274,
-0.2802399099,
-0.4244622588,
-0.5093086362,
-0.4509094656,
0.0489179231,
-0.1856063902,
0.4381372929,
-0.2212329656,
0.2732031941,
-0.0851042867,
0.4846996367,
-0.7370160222,
0.0481019542,
0.1649506241,
-0.1684831381,
0.4265653491,
0.1949187517,
0.2937732637,
-0.2117598802,
-0.0817553475,
0.0051240232,
-0.5498808622,
-0.2026116848,
0.3765893281,
0.3942891061,
-0.0571724996,
0.4701622128,
-0.3723041117,
0.6227651834,
0.5268083811,
0.2713251412,
0.4525723159,
-0.4443361461,
-0.3705080152,
0.0791276544,
0.8816558123,
-0.0847336799,
-0.1329630464,
-0.4403131902,
-0.2943015397,
0.2462964654,
0.2405749857,
-0.3636030257,
-0.5639656782,
-0.1447597891,
-0.5562829971,
-0.3691942692,
0.0913358405,
-0.7828034163,
0.1937810034,
-0.0240742937,
0.3884817958,
-0.0967794806,
-0.11808265,
0.0753877833,
0.3450110555,
-0.0873370469,
-0.0296308212,
-1.213278532,
0.2690483332,
0.1839292198,
0.7699041963,
-0.0508976541,
-0.4377090633,
-0.582731545,
-0.0306010731,
-0.5703957677,
0.8197204471,
-0.2742537558,
-0.5397011638,
-0.0328809805,
0.0537638701,
-0.3922383487,
-0.3684530854,
0.1351300329,
-0.4856895506,
0.1945928037,
-0.0513734333,
-0.5457622409,
-0.0063742665,
0.0806944072,
-0.5990982056,
0.9242078662,
0.0827764422,
-0.886262238,
-0.061907392,
-0.720027566,
-0.8809806108,
-0.0070316368,
-0.1122358665,
-0.5099457502,
0.276763767,
0.4555146396,
0.1420960724,
0.0883194134,
0.3415350318,
-0.3166428208,
-0.2647239566,
-0.1452802867,
-0.5455717444,
0.5320733786,
0.1913068593,
-0.633405447,
0.005507323,
-1.0359077454,
0.0404747203,
0.2920003831,
-0.5134020448,
0.0067287441,
0.109414041,
-0.3184339404,
0.1091637313,
0.2374341786,
-0.4723639786,
0.1304439008,
-0.6032170653,
0.4005970657,
0.6491137147,
-0.0523994528,
0.5000184178,
-0.0812668502,
0.5008553863,
-0.09383367,
0.2637741864,
-0.3397451341,
-0.1761539131,
-1.002597332,
0.0921555385,
0.1815032512,
0.6298821568,
-0.9355301857,
0.5417046547,
0.1145074591,
-0.3414460719,
-0.1559330225,
0.1666191965,
0.810082078,
0.7564761043,
0.5117236972,
-0.4674273431,
-0.6839370728,
-0.4724400043,
-0.159339577,
-0.4649111331,
0.4089800417,
0.1150508821,
0.208413884,
-0.2077763379,
0.775052011,
-0.389832139,
-0.2820470929,
-0.0410404392,
0.2668714821,
0.2534846365,
0.4850778878,
0.2918093503,
-0.2646839619,
-0.357080847,
-0.1380858123,
-0.7418466806,
-0.262019217,
0.0757889226,
-0.2421309948,
0.5301482677,
0.7972018123,
-0.3489097953,
0.512147665,
0.7696074247,
-0.6351496577,
0.4884752035,
-0.4571183026,
-0.0142924115,
-0.7628645301,
0.1565216184,
-0.353415519,
-0.1840521991,
-0.4174900055,
-0.1568867415,
0.0113691986,
0.0477157645,
-0.2380345762,
0.3412849009,
-0.6557143331,
-0.0726870894,
-0.2058481127,
-0.2352608293,
0.0201668981,
0.4787015021,
-0.3297841549,
0.7323562503,
0.5086484551,
-0.6061760187,
0.335093379,
0.6613088846,
0.0549472049,
0.1927670985,
-0.2564209402,
0.3093940914,
-0.4459581971,
0.2671982944,
-1.0946884155,
0.0000633121,
0.2844132483,
-0.5766982436,
0.391430974,
-0.1747140884,
-0.4376526773,
-0.3168956041,
0.0934273601,
0.4453514516,
0.2565214038,
-0.6966565847,
0.8127151728,
0.1551349312,
-0.0449442565,
-0.6473352313,
-0.9948160052,
0.4014264941,
0.379134804,
-0.600041151,
0.2498259097,
-0.0328272618,
0.0786318704,
0.1809044033,
-0.0840678662,
0.2589005232,
0.0622554161,
0.0565077811,
0.3190648258,
-0.3110470474,
0.3092180192,
0.0025933757,
-0.3471083045,
-0.0900678709,
-0.6335695982,
0.3576778471,
-0.0619482957,
-0.5353557467,
-0.2495866865,
0.5816102624,
0.3811439276,
-0.3229287267,
0.5165948868,
0.153353259,
-0.1938348114,
-0.2408940345,
-0.6930018067,
-0.1463498175,
-0.4579591155,
0.4017194808,
-0.2616105676,
-0.7915908694,
0.5536733866,
0.3488901854,
-0.0758945271,
0.4747002125,
0.597741425,
0.0322697796,
0.6207539439,
0.3513904214,
-0.3990031779,
0.6771875024,
-0.0223861896,
0.3640265763,
-0.4096835554,
-0.069985196,
-0.2976697385,
-0.353434056,
-0.354452461,
-0.1744417846,
0.0134009374,
-0.1435996443,
-0.3015132546,
0.3095425963,
-0.4481374323,
0.4538365901,
0.4995227754,
-0.0620845109,
0.3021377325,
0.1509604305,
-0.5694279075,
0.2041470408,
-0.865518868,
0.1134992242,
0.9635454416,
-0.2509631515,
0.7957942486,
0.0500391237,
0.8487021923,
0.1450614184,
0.1357000023,
-0.4385412931,
0.6187618375,
-0.909807682,
-0.2811172307,
-0.3782016933,
-0.6650723219,
-0.8709360361,
0.2961682975,
-0.0210551582,
-0.5545340776,
0.3804095984,
0.5158432126,
-0.3119539618,
0.5717785954,
-0.6799265742,
0.8317165971,
-0.1691178381,
-0.1818090677,
0.1779053956,
-0.7744326591,
-0.1063594148,
0.2934444249,
-0.0014789024,
0.2192706913,
0.3165589273,
0.3553311527,
-0.607922554,
0.8118591905,
-0.2687262297,
-0.0604412146,
0.4224981964,
0.311757803,
0.9475497007,
-0.049839329,
-0.0799794346,
0.1143598333,
-0.6746581197,
-0.2112991214,
-0.6268696785,
0.6771720052,
-0.7167229652,
-0.3982110918,
-0.1238922626,
-0.2576459348,
-0.3532604277,
0.2207592428,
0.5541018248,
0.5416700244,
-0.2606002986,
-0.1719224751,
0.4381144345,
0.2347307205,
0.7905546427,
0.5456730127,
-0.0267820712,
-0.7220941782,
0.7301183343,
0.2417535484,
0.1439933926,
0.53796947,
-0.0826345906,
-0.3662599623,
-0.6200067997,
-0.3100445271,
0.319838047,
-0.8243766427,
-0.3043345511,
-0.8587747812,
-0.2652809024,
-0.6590762734,
-0.1833391935,
-0.6653391719,
-0.15801467,
-0.7631143928,
-0.3804791272,
0.218953073,
0.4903550148,
-0.2878001034,
0.1466283351,
-0.8716903925,
0.1282247305,
0.2767806053,
0.4076426923,
0.0380286016,
-0.5429138541,
-0.1871139109,
-0.3531527221,
-0.0421058834,
-0.640648067,
0.4494559169,
0.1413808316,
0.3278115392,
0.2075195014,
0.0635688156,
0.8005342484,
-0.4284620881,
0.4944385886,
0.4605277777,
-1.0877771378,
0.3165824413,
-0.2877095044,
0.5414201021,
0.687384069,
-0.4603765011,
-0.6799077988,
-0.3937761784,
-0.6831697822,
-1.0433846712,
0.6320471764,
0.2420391291,
0.0223742239,
-0.3899450898,
0.4986906648,
-0.2344340384,
0.0647289455,
-0.585041225,
-0.3228170872,
-0.5570059419,
-0.3132897913,
-0.1434769928,
-0.4463790655,
0.2611220181,
0.0847557113,
0.9177766442,
-0.2520051599,
0.3256386817,
0.6367434263,
-0.0730275288,
-0.1893482357,
0.2496232092,
0.246979624,
0.2341002077,
0.2528915703,
0.2753078341,
0.26509583,
-0.2683615386,
0.291986227,
0.0409807153,
-0.3041784167,
0.1832601577,
0.1834113598,
0.8380283713,
0.0807071179,
-0.1256030798,
0.4498974979,
-0.0411017612,
-0.4124805927,
-0.3160145283,
-0.1503277123,
0.12381161,
0.0908401385,
0.0663981587,
0.272405982,
0.1793044657,
0.00425673,
0.306032747,
0.3203489482,
-0.2935248315,
-0.3597487509,
0.6698678136,
0.3632245064,
-0.1205559298,
0.8649443388,
-0.5063242316,
-0.2383549809,
0.5844567418,
0.7308060527,
1.1585581303,
-0.4017279744,
0.2664358318,
0.4751731455,
0.1435363293,
-0.2989349663,
0.3470405638,
0.1821911633,
-0.7885178924,
-0.5751495957,
-0.2123904675,
-0.0280436836,
-0.0989221185,
-0.3212297559,
0.1610261351,
-0.5253018737,
-0.1207650751,
-0.5046181679,
-0.5199550986,
-0.1904802024,
0.3107854128,
0.2306058705,
0.3339908123,
-0.8135505319,
0.7138397694,
0.653029263,
-0.1048522294,
-1.0096749067,
0.0484124087,
0.0530151054,
-0.6158032417,
0.4618410468,
-0.1149540097,
-0.4897790253,
0.0586255863,
-0.2359486967,
-1.2663086653,
0.8183512688,
0.6222137809,
-0.7071582079,
-0.3663022816,
-0.1907185614,
0.4742152691,
-0.2106281519,
0.1196484938,
0.2935433388,
0.3558391631,
0.3090796471,
-0.7314460278,
0.0091176974,
-0.5645645261,
0.2143487036,
0.4949920475,
-0.8431012034,
0.8749610782,
-0.091426149,
-0.4094084203,
0.085361585,
0.6948922873,
-0.3964844346,
0.0744011775,
0.3991593122,
0.9245898128,
0.5208650231,
0.1863998771,
0.6493130326,
-0.3647897243,
0.7092867494,
1.4843412638,
-0.2338883132,
0.5283970237,
0.5304806828,
-0.2430424243,
0.5198312402,
0.260061115,
-0.169007957,
0.579505384,
0.2564377785,
-0.2992580235,
-0.2890158594,
0.2792576551,
-0.1413045973,
0.4521633387,
0.0214007888,
-0.5041828752,
-0.5694589615,
-0.035401132,
0.2219109982,
0.1735960841,
-0.2167366594,
0.8198797703,
-0.1602023542,
-0.7528097034,
0.5414392352,
0.1419683397,
0.6439173222,
-0.4995135665,
0.0486953035,
-0.5803824067,
0.4392835498,
-0.5041382313,
-0.1328207254,
0.4695458114,
-0.1279179305,
-0.4377135336,
-0.0714444146,
0.6897181273,
-0.4221721888,
-0.5576151013,
0.5455513597,
0.3232056201,
-0.2290948629,
0.0812932476,
-0.4054116905,
-0.2398245335,
0.1075868383,
-0.1785689443,
0.2391677946,
0.2871648371,
0.2122427225,
0.3693828583,
0.5865315795,
-0.058396332,
0.3004563749,
0.1941516548,
0.7112115026,
-0.5315175056,
-0.7279191613,
-1.0037329197,
0.3992227912,
0.3694453835,
-0.2910631895,
0.5845205188,
0.3762024641,
0.852224648,
-0.0832858086,
0.8031381965,
-0.035592068,
0.264806658,
-0.7340459824,
0.4966526031,
-0.399014622,
0.0166828055,
-0.25312832,
-0.4842237532,
-0.6593919992,
0.5581954122,
-0.1855719686,
-0.0810972154,
0.8923755884,
0.920388341,
0.2432353348,
0.0955564156,
0.3737820387,
0.3187178671,
0.2720734775,
0.5574599504,
0.434610039,
-0.4084428549,
0.6433179379,
-0.0325045772,
-0.0940601081,
-0.2531866729,
-0.7270438671,
-0.5715689659,
-0.334759593,
-0.4591625631,
-0.5499402881,
0.3194855452,
0.795877099,
0.3593267798,
-0.8681624532,
-0.0424521379,
-0.7032690644,
-0.0264159739,
-0.228954494,
-0.2088914365,
0.3677680492,
-0.8563019037,
-0.5320694447,
0.5814273357,
0.5916135907,
0.2009357661,
-0.0452518389,
0.0714538246,
-0.2310096174,
0.0738358349,
0.3600128591,
0.4627294242,
-0.3887324035,
-0.1792095304,
0.2354600579,
-0.0718644261,
0.5290638208,
0.8933221102,
-0.6279227734,
0.7212842107,
0.6166837811,
0.7722378373,
0.4259940982,
-0.1025099456,
0.3685397506,
-0.5438943505,
0.0786214545,
0.2421305329,
0.6381953955,
0.2247850299,
-0.5020939112,
0.4373652935,
0.5789150596,
-0.5879920721,
-0.1606324911,
0.3741920292,
-0.5505398512,
-0.1116683334,
1.0224021673,
-0.3537731171,
-0.2938492894,
-0.1041583791,
0.0164325088,
0.1900508106,
-0.5415482521,
0.8375310898,
0.7340447307,
-0.1441836804,
-0.0412188843,
0.2794546783,
0.0600550473,
0.7620027661,
-0.6989998817,
0.1745228022,
0.5638087988,
0.2659830749,
0.0629868507,
0.8727875948,
-0.5345871449,
0.1100035012,
0.0287224017,
0.2995811403,
-0.1504287571,
-0.3389379978,
-0.4493477941,
0.24443914,
-0.1304809153,
-0.4095888734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08189v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08189v3
|
All Data on the Table: Novel Dataset and Benchmark for Cross-Modality Scientific Information Extraction
| 2023-11-14T14:22:47 | 2023-12-18T04:01:35 |
Yuhan Li, Jian Wu, Zhiwei Yu, Börje F. Karlsson, Wei Shen, Manabu Okumura, Chin-Yew Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extracting key information from scientific papers has the potential to help
researchers work more efficiently and accelerate the pace of scientific
progress. Over the last few years, research on Scientific Information
Extraction (SciIE) witnessed the release of several new systems and benchmarks.
However, existing paper-focused datasets mostly focus only on specific parts of
a manuscript (e.g., abstracts) and are single-modality (i.e., text- or
table-only), due to complex processing and expensive annotations. Moreover,
core information can be present in either text or tables or across both. To
close this gap in data availability and enable cross-modality IE, while
alleviating labeling costs, we propose a semi-supervised pipeline for
annotating entities in text, as well as entities and relations in tables, in an
iterative procedure. Based on this pipeline, we release novel resources for the
scientific community, including a high-quality benchmark, a large-scale corpus,
and a semi-supervised annotation pipeline. We further report the performance of
state-of-the-art IE models on the proposed benchmark dataset, as a baseline.
Lastly, we explore the potential capability of large language models such as
ChatGPT for the current task. Our new dataset, results, and analysis validate
the effectiveness and efficiency of our semi-supervised pipeline, and we
discuss its remaining limitations.
|
[
-0.0532979965,
-0.659191072,
0.5220717192,
0.1419177204,
-0.2301062346,
0.1226780862,
-0.2420774549,
-0.7631408572,
0.2500236034,
0.4503427148,
-0.1165378243,
-0.5330820084,
-0.6371008754,
0.3595216274,
-0.6147064567,
1.1654782295,
0.0464396589,
0.1581223607,
-0.3619925082,
0.1034104526,
-0.0025357788,
-0.174495697,
-0.2493086159,
-0.0546385683,
0.6527506709,
0.4581430256,
0.368989408,
1.0011109114,
0.5863189101,
0.217816323,
0.1403989792,
0.022298038,
-0.3234631121,
0.232570067,
-0.1972378045,
-0.3696286082,
-0.3954407573,
0.1339779943,
0.8973791599,
0.8562617302,
-0.0297996104,
0.3009583354,
-0.2224865407,
0.2827355266,
-0.5163308978,
0.6827093363,
-0.7616211772,
0.2738250196,
-0.6246934533,
-0.2265179902,
-0.5177540183,
-0.1046952084,
0.2569178045,
-0.9107528925,
0.205412969,
0.335221082,
0.6790471077,
0.1068651006,
-0.3829398751,
-0.1711325496,
-0.6208578348,
0.7252522707,
-0.5323054194,
0.7305878997,
0.1346238256,
0.1509376913,
-0.1003429741,
-1.2769607306,
-0.4413219392,
-0.3800776303,
-0.0717350319,
0.1629879922,
-0.2594349682,
-0.1619081795,
0.4170775712,
0.2155979425,
-0.5251457691,
-0.0248268545,
-0.5651144385,
-0.1939800531,
0.5399864912,
-0.0466099158,
0.3164712489,
-0.1993850023,
-0.3650068641,
-0.0748343468,
-0.7238752246,
-0.137535885,
-0.1140542179,
0.3556476235,
0.1629022509,
0.8306045532,
-0.136393249,
0.5585361719,
-0.3782995343,
0.0224165078,
0.2008139342,
-0.474929601,
-0.0492465086,
0.2456670403,
0.9546557665,
0.1194393933,
-0.121984899,
-0.4766237736,
-0.0266824923,
0.0122103691,
-0.1120653972,
-0.6435562372,
-0.4611954689,
-0.1548430771,
-0.4289170206,
-0.1803004891,
0.0097869616,
-1.2108510733,
-0.368231535,
-0.2016161829,
0.3152674735,
-0.0878838524,
-0.1684597284,
-0.3080734313,
-0.2781967819,
-0.288700819,
0.2998307347,
-0.6784965992,
0.2125715613,
0.5784152746,
1.065480113,
-0.5298067927,
-0.1408825666,
-0.614164412,
0.5405985117,
0.0052625271,
0.8035809398,
-1.068682313,
-0.4335411787,
-0.3083661497,
0.0789369345,
-0.0564182959,
-0.3102841973,
0.7446722388,
-0.3722396493,
0.2440136373,
-0.5352643132,
-0.420894146,
-0.0667737275,
-0.1417018622,
-1.01037848,
1.0380322933,
0.0385959931,
-0.8922679424,
0.6208557487,
-0.8728551865,
-0.4890811741,
0.1876457483,
-0.4660554528,
-0.3435813189,
0.0836381912,
0.1793465763,
0.3203939795,
-0.8670498729,
0.3429632783,
-0.3983869255,
0.0870660096,
0.2557717562,
-0.1443848759,
0.5602366328,
0.3110443652,
-0.2001734823,
-0.0167700108,
-0.8633746505,
-0.1018948779,
-0.0441334248,
-0.2537108064,
-0.3293339014,
0.1274553984,
0.3916513026,
0.2840229571,
0.1153365374,
-0.9064459205,
0.302382797,
0.1769885421,
0.7548248172,
0.320299238,
0.051824607,
0.3585526049,
-0.1096766144,
0.2624111176,
0.0875537768,
0.0173500925,
-0.0367121622,
-0.3879318237,
-0.3521324098,
-0.7833836675,
0.841786921,
0.4357293546,
-0.7532968521,
0.100487195,
-0.3760464787,
-0.5686528683,
-0.6295449734,
-0.1430824697,
0.2194380164,
0.8558052182,
0.4566067457,
-0.4092869461,
-0.7094143629,
-0.9653652906,
-0.2480673492,
-0.1265558302,
-0.2664357126,
0.1473569572,
0.5126354694,
0.1154572144,
0.9610644579,
-0.1886324286,
-0.2123257816,
-0.009892581,
0.5747973919,
0.047349494,
0.4740502834,
0.0760794282,
-0.8744980097,
-0.4742865562,
0.2465654314,
-0.9529867768,
-0.3880159855,
-0.06865374,
0.0852469057,
0.0269560628,
0.3996085525,
-0.5075917244,
0.3142234087,
0.1472412497,
-0.0685081035,
0.0935989618,
0.083361946,
0.2070845068,
-0.7855064273,
0.5681364536,
0.3690851033,
-0.1420368254,
-0.6218263507,
-0.5030430555,
0.1110456809,
-0.1869485676,
-0.3070701063,
0.3828909695,
-0.7224040031,
-0.1822034717,
0.0622028559,
0.1489780694,
0.1121276692,
0.2324368358,
0.3412235081,
0.7051536441,
0.4908405244,
-0.1770273894,
0.03710315,
0.377489388,
-0.1639407724,
0.2944310606,
-0.7669740319,
-0.0462831445,
-0.1346119493,
0.3796829283,
-0.5783997774,
-0.0845182836,
0.2220290303,
-0.2048248798,
0.5726755857,
-0.0382940285,
-0.4712024629,
0.0486498922,
-0.2371812761,
0.2084903717,
0.112661764,
-0.2080748081,
0.7489924431,
0.9731928706,
-0.4210748076,
-0.5695275664,
-0.4568181634,
0.298982054,
-0.0880100504,
-0.5000374913,
0.5297327042,
0.3093052506,
-0.1982294619,
0.1856463552,
-0.3940208256,
-0.0560124852,
-0.1159784943,
0.194309026,
0.3416761756,
0.1308828294,
0.001516411,
-0.0808578134,
-0.1139326096,
0.1231295913,
-0.1722483933,
0.1376261115,
-0.0055553899,
-0.0347646698,
-0.2928903401,
0.6700050235,
0.5026500225,
-0.3807444572,
0.407325983,
0.5238333344,
-0.5540770292,
-0.0182212498,
-0.4370037019,
-0.2788886726,
-0.3368318975,
0.6051238179,
-0.2523130178,
-0.7428047061,
0.6244734526,
-0.1922382712,
0.2671549022,
0.5042280555,
0.3030110002,
-0.113447167,
1.0027513504,
0.6753162742,
0.0605235696,
0.3881658018,
-0.0475516133,
0.4287885129,
-0.7800219655,
-0.548491776,
-1.0374413729,
-0.1844124496,
-0.534827888,
-0.2986427248,
0.5725625157,
-0.1172864139,
0.1068584099,
0.2214597017,
-0.5646306276,
0.2817256153,
0.5160458088,
-0.0295210928,
0.6151129603,
0.0194598828,
0.106898196,
-0.1544397622,
-0.7464807034,
-0.6600553989,
1.1599289179,
0.2847691178,
0.7695046663,
-0.3045731485,
0.3424232304,
0.4623575509,
0.473872155,
-0.4367866516,
0.491543442,
-0.0269493777,
-0.8409833908,
-0.1719964892,
-0.6387569904,
-0.8042075038,
0.1624649018,
-0.3716485798,
-0.9184554815,
0.5056142807,
-0.1787558794,
0.0182790868,
0.2902842164,
-0.728756845,
0.9108783007,
-0.1849408299,
-0.6500778198,
0.223883599,
-0.9244791865,
0.2522185743,
-0.4799683392,
0.1732374579,
-0.1584555805,
-0.2386120558,
1.1325126886,
-0.1200522184,
0.5957168937,
-0.1997192353,
0.1896938533,
0.0506895967,
0.0353844762,
0.5792515874,
0.2033527195,
-0.1479912847,
0.4558977485,
0.4648517668,
-0.2537835836,
-0.3073613048,
0.5781130195,
-0.4529926479,
-0.3282290697,
-0.7705205083,
-0.8297868371,
-0.2310554832,
0.2002310008,
0.2186822593,
0.1524329185,
0.0387743041,
0.3759140968,
0.4991393983,
0.1339719743,
0.515460968,
0.5524891615,
0.0539978333,
-0.2406200022,
0.8108427525,
0.372077018,
-0.048040431,
0.4065447152,
0.009104155,
-0.4340576828,
-0.5506246686,
-0.3650897443,
-0.0131752901,
-0.4749821424,
-0.2927172482,
-0.933704257,
0.0570922494,
-0.2730544508,
0.1380159855,
-0.3336875439,
-0.7948347926,
-0.1775899082,
0.0408564173,
0.2191845328,
0.4769415259,
-0.2618899643,
-0.1088375673,
-0.8891476393,
-0.0093418816,
-0.0169732086,
-0.0970629826,
-0.191717878,
-0.1154980808,
-0.1828639507,
-0.0696434304,
-0.0597682185,
-1.0065146685,
0.3192425072,
0.4251038134,
0.8133967519,
0.0585339367,
-0.0078765983,
0.462512821,
-0.4039481878,
0.6689509153,
0.2067516595,
-0.8447079659,
0.3722289205,
-0.3098278642,
-0.1780255586,
0.7296751738,
0.6459301114,
-0.512516439,
-0.1227683052,
-0.5012590289,
-0.8941286802,
0.6328169703,
0.1229890436,
-0.5120660067,
0.1280672401,
0.1845656931,
0.4597118199,
0.3770932555,
-0.892680645,
0.0712645426,
-0.0903309882,
-0.2152172923,
0.2285234034,
0.1662458479,
-0.4931433201,
-0.2738925815,
0.8612383604,
-0.1718981713,
0.363158375,
0.3275473118,
-0.1947243512,
-0.3560532033,
0.2928936779,
0.1664276719,
0.9014982581,
-0.2008185089,
0.2664220035,
0.0148252556,
-0.6822535992,
-0.2855059505,
0.5429496765,
-0.4735892713,
0.0784887075,
0.3677167296,
0.5216973424,
0.0582476407,
-0.6266744733,
0.2836434543,
-0.0197429545,
-0.0659829527,
0.0990880579,
-0.2540770173,
-0.1371210366,
0.3291915059,
0.6114889383,
-0.1201238409,
0.5041874647,
-0.6986144781,
0.3573932052,
0.5334753394,
-0.2580256462,
-0.4329574406,
0.8118142486,
-0.014058345,
0.0304667223,
0.4360526502,
0.0603807084,
-0.3321350515,
0.2233516425,
0.604326129,
0.5235870481,
0.1911849678,
0.3653461337,
0.1949886382,
0.229190588,
0.0369927622,
0.3526685238,
-0.2309698164,
-0.2226254344,
-0.4793083072,
-0.5730954409,
-0.5708483458,
-0.0734171942,
-0.5586564541,
0.160305351,
-0.2672107518,
-0.0332306474,
0.6078535914,
0.2222557366,
-0.554312706,
0.0068782689,
-0.020984048,
0.7742365599,
-1.1741303205,
0.9652733207,
0.6803892851,
-0.5795636773,
-0.5995981097,
-0.5066778064,
0.0151571985,
-0.5362411737,
0.5684768558,
-0.1480780691,
0.3244764507,
-0.0398346931,
-0.5367177129,
-0.8621197939,
1.0151174068,
0.3468582034,
-0.7650057673,
-0.1612395048,
0.3253727555,
0.5004045367,
-0.3997817039,
0.4818867445,
0.6913706064,
0.8252103925,
0.2086893171,
-0.8942468166,
0.2189566344,
-0.5768766403,
-0.2561186254,
0.331489414,
-0.4145980775,
0.8010837436,
0.2940261662,
-0.2986827195,
-0.4285530746,
0.6861155629,
0.1786657721,
0.5383580327,
0.429058969,
0.583293736,
0.8861814737,
-0.455341965,
0.4908071756,
-0.1818148345,
0.2184559703,
0.9251067042,
-0.6535383463,
0.6032837033,
0.8101417422,
-0.1096779257,
0.1144721434,
0.7178226113,
-0.3733843863,
0.6274284124,
0.1531541944,
-0.2175405473,
-0.0704861879,
-0.7253362536,
-0.4619070292,
0.4013209939,
0.371006906,
-0.4656090438,
-0.4141663909,
0.0635885075,
0.1870796531,
-0.2414726913,
-0.0842633247,
0.6905656457,
-0.0587866865,
-0.358890444,
0.0620399937,
-0.1729053408,
0.2488753796,
-0.572414279,
-0.2301127911,
-0.0085656065,
-0.2713943422,
-0.3577864766,
-0.5488635302,
0.1238946691,
0.0916736573,
-0.0395227857,
-0.1067636162,
0.6753985286,
-0.4974311292,
-0.546299994,
-0.1309118271,
0.566054523,
0.2160902768,
0.2318084389,
-0.5567963719,
0.2508408129,
0.0053643035,
-0.2963266671,
0.1687526256,
0.6115304232,
-0.3419832587,
0.2681084275,
0.6927698851,
0.3404393196,
0.1464987993,
-0.2050517201,
1.050544858,
-0.6627855301,
-0.1436095089,
-0.5320850015,
0.521795392,
-0.5054807663,
-0.3583800495,
0.7220752239,
0.9552938938,
0.7169700861,
0.1375904232,
0.8293876648,
-0.5442846417,
0.4635216594,
-0.2949230373,
0.5301867127,
-0.4653038979,
0.2272361815,
-0.3813632429,
-1.1274859905,
-0.5400334597,
0.4604258537,
-0.1705482155,
-0.0885274261,
0.9637436271,
0.660066843,
-0.1538016945,
0.6422420144,
-0.1090438291,
0.1799195111,
0.5595168471,
0.3091653287,
0.6111444235,
-0.3170639575,
0.3369708955,
-0.3342344761,
-0.3481204212,
0.1138285026,
-1.0965321064,
-0.5441853404,
-0.8567616343,
-0.4903304279,
-0.1249577478,
-0.0109729962,
0.8438495994,
0.718573153,
-0.8277443051,
0.0631072149,
-0.025239015,
-0.2893280685,
-0.028132068,
-0.158726424,
0.6175208688,
-0.088923946,
-0.6491640806,
0.5939642787,
0.4133846462,
-0.2255468071,
-0.1520625502,
0.3497004211,
-0.6363968253,
-0.1016171351,
0.232553184,
0.5885420442,
-0.2400127351,
-0.2206214964,
0.0681746155,
0.0256204512,
0.2436176986,
0.8077748418,
-0.4494617283,
0.5053311586,
0.6205490232,
0.8184333444,
0.9339742661,
-0.2955365777,
0.5040095448,
-0.5011609197,
-0.0230266005,
0.6762652993,
0.4121239483,
0.3045232594,
-0.2763693333,
0.7848521471,
0.2905817628,
-0.7205740213,
-1.1914380789,
-0.1895521581,
-1.273973465,
0.0264920555,
0.7174757719,
-0.1104060411,
-0.5125873089,
-0.2283293456,
-0.0701298863,
0.5956753492,
-0.5539741516,
1.0115996599,
0.5937941074,
-0.2188921273,
-0.1761450917,
-0.6793299913,
0.5085218549,
0.4845968783,
-1.135458827,
0.2067871541,
0.6050786972,
0.0343091004,
0.3301105201,
0.1704538614,
-0.5155645609,
0.0576218814,
-0.0870528594,
0.31603688,
-0.2285885662,
-0.5781292915,
0.0328072608,
0.4254380167,
-0.344438225,
0.1463373601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08182v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08182v1
|
Self-Evolved Diverse Data Sampling for Efficient Instruction Tuning
| 2023-11-14T14:10:40 | 2023-11-14T14:10:40 |
Shengguang Wu, Keming Lu, Benfeng Xu, Junyang Lin, Qi Su, Chang Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Enhancing the instruction-following ability of Large Language Models (LLMs)
primarily demands substantial instruction-tuning datasets. However, the sheer
volume of these imposes a considerable computational burden and annotation
cost. To investigate a label-efficient instruction tuning method that allows
the model itself to actively sample subsets that are equally or even more
effective, we introduce a self-evolving mechanism DiverseEvol. In this process,
a model iteratively augments its training subset to refine its own performance,
without requiring any intervention from humans or more advanced LLMs. The key
to our data sampling technique lies in the enhancement of diversity in the
chosen subsets, as the model selects new data points most distinct from any
existing ones according to its current embedding space. Extensive experiments
across three datasets and benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of
DiverseEvol. Our models, trained on less than 8% of the original dataset,
maintain or improve performance compared with finetuning on full data. We also
provide empirical evidence to analyze the importance of diversity in
instruction data and the iterative scheme as opposed to one-time sampling. Our
code is publicly available at https://github.com/OFA-Sys/DiverseEvol.git.
|
[
-0.300342679,
-0.5063127279,
0.0892646089,
0.113853015,
-0.2947184741,
0.3164346516,
-0.3186829984,
-0.2415105402,
-0.0752410069,
0.5731379986,
-0.8179827929,
-0.7158148885,
-0.4977978766,
-0.0107479244,
-0.3105136454,
0.9738897085,
0.2773957849,
0.0068658995,
0.0777873173,
-0.3326911032,
-0.3776821196,
0.0750012398,
-0.2365709394,
-0.1953452229,
0.424967736,
0.8831236959,
0.1921068579,
1.159526825,
0.0859825686,
0.3141806126,
0.0467358753,
0.3569414914,
-0.7926109433,
0.2897390723,
-0.0573073439,
-0.4721617103,
-0.2288666368,
-0.1157178432,
0.889272511,
0.6700206399,
-0.3811854124,
0.2922669053,
0.1954787374,
0.6346735954,
-0.7681450844,
-0.2729843259,
-0.7796976566,
-0.0222886093,
-0.3975587487,
-0.0493123122,
-0.4188937843,
-0.4803678095,
-0.0246564765,
-0.4950958192,
0.420506686,
-0.137985453,
0.2284274846,
0.3581458628,
-0.1712652445,
-0.288787812,
-0.6680954099,
0.9831631184,
-0.6158353686,
0.5574947,
0.2889654934,
0.3244080842,
-0.080069758,
-0.5534278154,
-0.2177471817,
-0.2495623529,
0.3591063619,
0.0904916674,
0.0160376113,
-0.1295626909,
0.3652894795,
0.5150721669,
-0.3572967649,
0.6051844954,
-0.5751424432,
0.0173655078,
0.5550891161,
0.0743998885,
0.2718479335,
0.1849236339,
-0.2395588607,
-0.3061436713,
-0.7136980891,
0.0066142092,
0.6769555807,
0.4190659821,
-0.1880149543,
0.2928809822,
-0.3410563171,
0.9484618902,
0.0949135497,
-0.0030686732,
0.4844921529,
-0.2897642851,
-0.0729748309,
-0.0110569764,
0.4210804105,
-0.0105116935,
0.1699614078,
-0.0507520922,
-0.3132259846,
-0.2338516712,
0.2283754051,
-0.89692384,
-0.5697419047,
-0.0231766552,
-0.1004129872,
-0.0627601072,
-0.112121895,
-1.0240410566,
-0.2260808945,
-0.2934105098,
-0.046251595,
-0.5014430881,
-0.0262320023,
-0.0189842321,
-0.0517965741,
0.1868496388,
0.2904244959,
-1.2962708473,
0.2768124044,
0.5579276681,
0.5299629569,
-0.3816973865,
-0.3766296506,
-0.9229596257,
-0.105737038,
-0.2508791089,
0.8808979988,
-1.0390080214,
-0.4950533211,
-0.2345708162,
-0.2882361412,
-0.1581665277,
-0.7616156936,
0.2557577491,
-0.5114043951,
0.0304427855,
-0.2806849778,
-0.8428034782,
-0.075961642,
-0.0156215141,
-0.8947616816,
1.0860471725,
0.2346784621,
-0.3304853141,
0.4340362847,
-0.6062281728,
-0.3931625783,
0.1575827152,
-0.2588356435,
-0.611083746,
0.1758878082,
0.5118697286,
0.0869708285,
-0.0585220978,
-0.19274804,
-0.5413303971,
-0.337104857,
0.0256774873,
-0.4893525243,
0.8162688017,
0.338924855,
-0.2737540007,
-0.1015832052,
-0.8938067555,
0.2055839002,
-0.1942867488,
-0.4266539216,
-0.4027830362,
-0.0626504421,
-0.4375974834,
-0.062757805,
0.0456568077,
-0.4863119721,
0.7070626616,
-0.2242107689,
-0.0527688079,
1.0062172413,
0.0011547304,
0.5638924837,
-0.3388144672,
0.7080142498,
-0.2237836272,
0.1603499502,
-0.4473788142,
-0.4933025837,
-0.6304346919,
-0.7795404792,
0.4628549218,
0.3915986717,
-0.5016182065,
0.3381851315,
-0.1400031,
-0.4153267145,
-0.9639829397,
0.6305045485,
0.1908426583,
0.2633976042,
0.4489602447,
-0.1264118552,
-0.378515631,
-0.6967390776,
-0.2085802406,
0.3350974619,
0.0474721529,
0.3830904961,
0.2577897608,
-0.3695704639,
0.7045974135,
-0.4169210792,
0.2176437229,
-0.1457546949,
0.2309381813,
0.1576115042,
0.6360064745,
0.5767970681,
-0.3140277863,
-0.6036794186,
-0.0880745649,
-0.3640850782,
-0.4736067355,
-0.1816324741,
-0.3298470378,
-0.0694638789,
0.302895993,
-0.0156108486,
0.0995870829,
0.8054250479,
-0.1076340899,
0.3581022918,
-0.109449774,
0.2494102418,
-0.8694040179,
-0.2349743098,
-0.3011467159,
-0.0530694276,
-0.6750697494,
0.0510335341,
0.2319051176,
0.1066860929,
-0.1298588216,
0.5764003992,
-0.6883232594,
-0.0293704141,
-0.4082164764,
0.0132087618,
-0.2096447051,
0.2271793485,
-0.3611759245,
0.6971467137,
0.8128914237,
-0.764508009,
0.2314997166,
-0.0757311508,
-0.46435377,
0.213566035,
-0.2601695657,
0.2793472707,
-0.1991809756,
-0.2013732046,
-0.8908397555,
-0.007871259,
0.3357684016,
-0.0380550586,
0.634301722,
-0.2545051575,
-0.1870912015,
-0.2877499759,
-0.3391103148,
0.515047431,
0.6601256132,
-1.0451726913,
0.6006292701,
0.2175201029,
-0.1753965616,
-0.6565458179,
-0.510936439,
-0.3218348324,
-0.0476387106,
-0.3694238067,
0.2140377313,
-0.3760235608,
-0.0630253032,
-0.1267300546,
-0.4005553722,
0.022726303,
0.2924103439,
-0.1688247472,
0.1376390457,
-0.2311475426,
0.472196281,
0.5018968582,
0.0540712029,
-0.3181863725,
-0.56659168,
0.5256419182,
0.1088289618,
-0.5689932704,
-0.3070847392,
0.1877075434,
0.1890113503,
-0.4272987247,
0.437152952,
0.4454080164,
0.0393092409,
-1.0550156832,
-0.4973735809,
-0.40139696,
-0.5451120138,
0.5126968026,
-0.2353839427,
-0.8393269777,
0.4707678854,
-0.0795206279,
0.5822713971,
0.2818930149,
0.4535217285,
-0.027898591,
0.6552611589,
0.5675016642,
-0.0417189002,
0.8474618196,
-0.2748908997,
-0.2579811513,
-0.7041785717,
-0.0815595537,
-0.452335149,
-0.5260804892,
-0.7796561718,
-0.6186634302,
0.0028020311,
-0.0786021426,
0.1352578104,
-0.0766156316,
-0.6618890762,
0.746071279,
0.7107219696,
0.1295439154,
0.2247761637,
0.350902766,
-0.0460046008,
-0.0256529469,
-0.8034670949,
-0.1700554043,
1.3349028826,
0.1834855974,
1.2507036924,
-0.0453565456,
1.1975049973,
0.2656862736,
0.6242023706,
-0.3844733536,
0.3450922668,
-0.6275261641,
-0.3932544589,
-0.2947849333,
-0.6415396333,
-1.0449477434,
0.16515854,
-0.1099737287,
-0.7364444137,
0.2216888219,
0.534301877,
-0.3131982982,
0.3031523526,
-0.7211952806,
0.7157257795,
-0.5623334646,
-0.3220964074,
-0.2536225915,
-0.2752937973,
0.3794834912,
-0.2002023458,
-0.0545721762,
-0.1427809894,
0.0477962047,
0.7056406736,
-0.0271015633,
0.9353684783,
-0.1344952881,
-0.2764787674,
0.3117996156,
-0.1185911819,
0.4525507689,
-0.0824959204,
-0.2681182325,
-0.0120832399,
-0.531406343,
-0.6014499664,
-0.7655324936,
0.8253660798,
-0.934151113,
-0.640498817,
-0.0547658354,
-0.6343924999,
-0.0690426975,
0.0579369701,
0.2045598328,
0.5085241199,
0.0846984759,
0.3816730082,
0.8592459559,
-0.121556893,
0.3172033131,
0.654065609,
-0.1533024758,
-0.3833848238,
1.082244873,
0.2953004539,
0.5407446027,
0.2719197571,
0.2219103724,
-0.2530643642,
-0.6182296276,
-0.5310565233,
0.1468057036,
-0.81501472,
-0.0862636864,
-0.5490605235,
0.0024429727,
-0.282607466,
0.000812704,
-0.552715838,
-0.4057309031,
-0.3889808059,
-0.1857836396,
0.3934161067,
0.586561501,
-0.070298247,
0.4127619267,
-0.8341240883,
0.3071030378,
0.6298084259,
0.5152963996,
-0.1195152998,
-0.8281710148,
-0.2041627318,
0.1758898348,
-0.2304011583,
-0.9692388177,
0.1746411622,
0.5261197686,
1.0445715189,
0.2972282171,
0.0467317812,
0.69122082,
-0.4012173712,
0.3880002201,
-0.2519847155,
-0.729046762,
0.5050031543,
-0.0376815572,
0.6898506284,
0.7370556593,
0.2121443897,
-0.2047639191,
-0.5795411468,
-0.3721436262,
-0.8072327375,
0.7689170837,
0.0314856581,
0.2614220083,
0.1904842705,
0.3150320649,
0.5026683211,
0.0415635034,
-0.5080701113,
-0.3928239048,
-0.3815330267,
-0.5500496626,
0.0462888703,
-0.0209193062,
-0.1230003238,
-0.2012415677,
0.6294705272,
-0.2709414959,
-0.0269853957,
-0.3188803792,
-0.2157084495,
0.0546043813,
0.3793393075,
0.6322968602,
0.5442470312,
0.0346835665,
-0.0367520712,
0.3918840885,
-0.5518128276,
0.0757563412,
0.3577095568,
-0.3665632606,
-0.2204590887,
0.250382185,
0.9682671428,
0.2257917672,
-0.5817375183,
-0.0631980225,
-0.1371622235,
0.1274029911,
0.2157852799,
0.7148869038,
-0.1513652503,
0.363984555,
0.3747296929,
-0.1157004759,
0.2227537334,
-0.3162424862,
0.4583825469,
0.3132340014,
-0.0541058592,
-0.1714916676,
0.2080944031,
0.2992486358,
-0.3601601124,
1.0076239109,
-0.3445363641,
-0.221731469,
0.7674728036,
0.7221127748,
0.9704992175,
-0.5685608387,
0.2953312099,
0.4131889641,
0.3547573388,
0.0067515452,
0.2328567058,
-0.3438443244,
-0.6573573351,
-0.342068851,
-0.5977017879,
-0.4023962617,
0.0195417367,
-0.5643001199,
0.1727057993,
-0.3368960917,
0.1554804742,
-0.2284241915,
-0.1828017384,
-0.5633289218,
0.1593575627,
0.3471079171,
0.7829213738,
-0.8346499801,
0.9887993932,
0.5596576333,
0.1246477216,
-0.6211769581,
0.1678887308,
-0.1307433993,
-0.8757699728,
0.5112415552,
0.2674823403,
-0.0622658618,
0.1975515187,
-0.6710463762,
-1.0292656422,
0.900706172,
0.3237203956,
-1.0996072292,
0.1932738721,
-0.061632257,
0.3623083234,
-0.5054863095,
0.2276875377,
0.6046115756,
0.2325282693,
0.222213164,
-0.2306924611,
-0.1943889409,
-0.3730883598,
-0.1108246297,
0.1595310569,
-0.5431720018,
0.7729713321,
-0.3392837942,
-0.2018248588,
-0.0616394468,
0.7851885557,
0.4707801342,
0.0146503095,
0.5653128028,
0.6568878889,
1.3000947237,
0.0967462212,
0.9272000194,
-0.4654993117,
0.2777155638,
1.4000208378,
-0.1383262575,
0.4141348898,
0.1142719537,
0.1354114413,
0.4891679585,
0.4739625752,
-0.5235673785,
0.6367066503,
0.2468477339,
-0.3353058696,
-0.4272676408,
0.2774291635,
-0.2747565508,
0.5482367873,
0.3555197716,
-0.2632213831,
-0.4429577887,
0.0740049183,
-0.3569071889,
-0.0096711172,
-0.3589961827,
0.7059392929,
-0.0906843841,
-0.8114654422,
0.6985036135,
-0.2220598906,
0.50881809,
-0.7090234756,
-0.1585720479,
-0.450294733,
0.1588986218,
0.0211421903,
-0.5793825984,
-0.1372765303,
0.0687364116,
-0.1128470525,
-0.1181069985,
0.3491054475,
-0.7649046779,
-0.5024505854,
0.1472237408,
0.2263381481,
-0.1184454635,
0.4970016479,
-0.6904929876,
0.0970408544,
0.3215657473,
-0.2570742667,
0.205932498,
0.4176912606,
0.0515169315,
0.8204911351,
0.5358167291,
0.0255719554,
0.6334468126,
0.2586645186,
1.0549401045,
-0.5460250378,
-0.4777162373,
-0.8697731495,
0.6416339874,
-0.2966060042,
-0.5517835617,
0.7438860536,
0.5226585269,
0.9023780823,
-0.0528919995,
0.7873600125,
0.2845782936,
0.4185717106,
-0.6579492092,
0.4506599605,
-0.5533072352,
0.5999898314,
0.0717688575,
-0.8670329452,
-0.0322144181,
0.5764012337,
-0.327504158,
0.3860596716,
0.3158458173,
0.8513630033,
-0.27824229,
0.154390499,
0.2132148445,
0.1690574437,
0.3076583743,
0.3218395114,
0.8020108938,
-0.0554903671,
0.3995166719,
-0.3445168436,
-0.4640977085,
-0.1791152954,
-0.6455945969,
-0.912556231,
-0.0185639579,
-0.4763768017,
0.0883267,
0.2577286363,
0.9869890213,
0.7447972894,
-0.990809679,
-0.2282857001,
0.0053953277,
0.3162059784,
-0.3317061365,
-0.1198933348,
0.1212643906,
-0.7498794794,
-0.9341693521,
0.5207451582,
0.1637200564,
-0.0122964084,
-0.0580715798,
-0.0329388082,
-0.1106710434,
0.0043487162,
0.2870014906,
0.5253683329,
-0.354326874,
-0.1052824259,
0.2418512702,
-0.0657678396,
0.1749245226,
0.6327762008,
-0.5414209366,
0.9736118913,
0.4720339775,
0.9786505699,
0.6398223042,
0.1754990816,
0.4927463233,
-0.9503529668,
-0.2358582318,
0.3794441521,
0.1188968122,
0.3671021163,
-0.2213225067,
0.242658034,
0.1460350901,
-0.5524753332,
-0.6581668854,
0.2808212042,
-0.6302692294,
-0.2288354188,
1.0277497768,
-0.0424963906,
-0.2684484422,
0.1524666399,
0.0117694465,
0.2390361577,
-0.5554652214,
1.0350145102,
0.3072812259,
-0.0574699454,
-0.434658438,
-0.3180528283,
0.3810121417,
0.4037913382,
-0.9432407022,
0.1232229993,
0.4639260769,
0.458783567,
-0.1092708409,
0.4779973924,
0.2790221572,
0.4887391329,
-0.0044069239,
0.0991969928,
-0.015791269,
-0.4977593422,
-0.4156235754,
0.1159805879,
-0.0393436328,
-0.3798791468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08166v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08166v1
|
MechAgents: Large language model multi-agent collaborations can solve mechanics problems, generate new data, and integrate knowledge
| 2023-11-14T13:49:03 | 2023-11-14T13:49:03 |
Bo Ni, Markus J. Buehler
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Solving mechanics problems using numerical methods requires comprehensive
intelligent capability of retrieving relevant knowledge and theory,
constructing and executing codes, analyzing the results, a task that has thus
far mainly been reserved for humans. While emerging AI methods can provide
effective approaches to solve end-to-end problems, for instance via the use of
deep surrogate models or various data analytics strategies, they often lack
physical intuition since knowledge is baked into the parametric complement
through training, offering less flexibility when it comes to incorporating
mathematical or physical insights. By leveraging diverse capabilities of
multiple dynamically interacting large language models (LLMs), we can overcome
the limitations of conventional approaches and develop a new class of
physics-inspired generative machine learning platform, here referred to as
MechAgents. A set of AI agents can solve mechanics tasks, here demonstrated for
elasticity problems, via autonomous collaborations. A two-agent team can
effectively write, execute and self-correct code, in order to apply finite
element methods to solve classical elasticity problems in various flavors
(different boundary conditions, domain geometries, meshes, small/finite
deformation and linear/hyper-elastic constitutive laws, and others). For more
complex tasks, we construct a larger group of agents with enhanced division of
labor among planning, formulating, coding, executing and criticizing the
process and results. The agents mutually correct each other to improve the
overall team-work performance in understanding, formulating and validating the
solution. Our framework shows the potential of synergizing the intelligence of
language models, the reliability of physics-based modeling, and the dynamic
collaborations among diverse agents, opening novel avenues for automation of
solving engineering problems.
|
[
-0.1642601043,
-0.6326082349,
0.7808279395,
0.1895366907,
0.1207317635,
0.7689797878,
-0.1923559755,
-0.6335545182,
0.5183688998,
0.1064276472,
-0.8420449495,
-0.0795571283,
-0.2954911292,
0.1262852103,
-0.2189359963,
0.8448143601,
-0.2090205401,
0.1813123375,
-0.3861442804,
-0.2502446771,
-0.1267757118,
-0.4670846164,
-0.1780836731,
-0.7599089146,
0.3046076298,
0.0764543936,
0.7561262846,
0.3697521091,
0.3734587431,
0.5877606869,
0.1587528437,
0.3298006356,
-0.2199362963,
0.3641009629,
-0.4546092451,
-0.528632164,
-0.3199198544,
-0.0065880162,
0.4927292168,
1.1368166208,
0.0160484985,
-0.0754488409,
0.2065217048,
0.3927353919,
-0.2669544816,
0.2383072972,
-0.2488999069,
0.1629621089,
0.1703893542,
-0.5181583166,
-0.2322008163,
0.050005164,
-0.0366201252,
-0.645567596,
0.1455228627,
-0.1783542186,
0.4119861722,
0.6742324829,
-0.1595855653,
-0.1106363162,
-1.06136024,
0.8355596662,
-0.4037623107,
0.5236403346,
-0.0002725462,
0.3403054774,
-0.6697664261,
-0.4500828981,
-0.5660133958,
-0.0981994718,
0.2778071463,
0.3012324572,
0.1329557151,
0.2047246993,
-0.0090333326,
0.1214528829,
-0.8162999153,
0.3979865909,
-0.5552079082,
-0.2128977925,
0.7551987767,
0.3160737157,
0.5660190582,
0.3365517259,
-0.2892837524,
-0.4952695966,
-0.3969525099,
0.1212925985,
0.418427527,
0.1990271807,
-0.2796381414,
0.4259723127,
-0.2977911532,
0.22191751,
-0.2649392188,
-0.1760987192,
0.4440101385,
-0.1172228009,
-0.1439721286,
-0.0477431715,
0.8856115937,
-0.1956908703,
0.0225941781,
-0.5148989558,
-0.1822154671,
0.1021666229,
0.1854531765,
-0.6652530432,
-0.0278505087,
0.3721668124,
-0.5089108944,
-0.2053868175,
-0.0137514314,
-0.5445586443,
-0.5493581891,
-0.7539591193,
0.031485796,
-0.3084490895,
-0.7167570591,
0.2828243673,
-0.2562161088,
0.103015244,
0.4087252319,
-0.9649986029,
0.1822703183,
0.8486770988,
0.7351815104,
0.3678418994,
-0.7651444077,
-0.1645528078,
0.3047764301,
-0.2963181138,
0.7531402111,
-0.4449947774,
-0.2512451708,
-0.174738273,
0.0318578705,
0.0311738942,
-0.1391816288,
-0.0881038755,
-0.2553397715,
-0.1800724119,
0.1201631948,
-0.5411615372,
-0.3202951252,
0.1485513598,
-0.783393085,
0.479852885,
0.2061983347,
-0.0542299151,
-0.0039566797,
-0.5645434856,
-0.301979661,
0.3345820904,
-0.7080616355,
-0.1887574494,
0.3282883763,
-0.3550541997,
0.5550312996,
-0.7195792198,
0.312977612,
-0.5115883946,
-0.001981406,
0.1803479791,
-0.4607177675,
0.6770797372,
0.3382348418,
-0.3303811252,
0.0863355696,
-0.4346129,
0.0711007118,
0.1595923901,
-0.0406551212,
-0.1437240094,
0.0719337165,
-0.1258466393,
0.217198208,
0.3117666543,
-0.3065389693,
0.2823162079,
-0.6127617359,
0.4255268276,
0.888623476,
-0.2831039131,
0.561491847,
-0.4623986781,
0.6605342627,
-0.4555768669,
-0.169227615,
0.0187122785,
-0.1179226413,
-0.2713768184,
-0.1390871704,
-0.1355312318,
0.3579652607,
-1.2009407282,
0.3115433753,
-0.2084749639,
-0.9283847213,
-0.2771758139,
0.2444335371,
0.3790798187,
0.1984090656,
0.4083894193,
0.0685249567,
-0.2564233541,
-0.6530700922,
-0.1060988009,
-0.3055604994,
-0.1710626483,
0.1777673662,
0.467912972,
-0.2562441826,
0.7812653184,
-0.2627514601,
-0.0684191138,
-0.1798306406,
0.6039301753,
0.2913736105,
0.7219423652,
0.5497471094,
-0.708283782,
-0.127365306,
0.265653193,
-1.2125637531,
0.0296901651,
-0.1790453345,
0.1770758182,
0.1461229026,
0.452240169,
-0.562559545,
-0.0414043106,
0.7379530072,
-0.3967527747,
0.8090263605,
-0.3978492916,
0.2310637534,
-1.1726864576,
-0.2242272794,
0.1283670068,
-0.1358427852,
-0.409930706,
0.2299572229,
-0.3284558356,
-0.1959090531,
-0.4812829494,
0.4845090806,
-0.693682611,
-0.1239682883,
-0.2587228715,
-0.1704910845,
-0.0954753384,
0.5211682916,
-0.2025205046,
0.8027012944,
0.4039252698,
-0.6335502863,
0.9222229719,
0.1151012033,
0.1130501553,
0.3931335509,
-0.6767667532,
0.1329813451,
-0.1204875857,
0.2104580402,
-0.5527972579,
-0.3567762077,
-0.0546077117,
-0.5624956489,
0.4258926213,
0.199632287,
-0.8936608434,
-0.6420170069,
-0.4195488393,
0.8806056976,
0.4098114371,
-0.5517703295,
1.168564558,
0.4397571385,
-0.2649524212,
-0.562651813,
-0.5266951323,
-0.1561194807,
0.2319072187,
-0.8539632559,
0.3761276603,
-0.293610543,
-0.3599302173,
0.2941152155,
-0.1112657487,
-0.342574358,
0.1870713681,
-0.0887187347,
0.1607425809,
-0.0418318808,
0.5355428457,
0.2839179337,
-0.3557575941,
0.0038669435,
-0.465460211,
0.9374147058,
-0.4155976474,
-0.4848952293,
-0.4714741409,
0.2219763994,
0.8304250836,
-0.5365133286,
0.7029823661,
0.32767573,
-0.4893608689,
-0.4096345305,
-0.5818616748,
-0.7343480587,
-0.5543926954,
0.565109551,
-0.6227585673,
-0.8673710823,
0.5511265993,
-0.5095472932,
0.1038237885,
0.2756039202,
0.8611680865,
-0.2699791789,
1.0965152979,
0.7856017947,
-0.3662258685,
0.1225870624,
-0.3096631467,
0.2161421031,
-0.3041561544,
-0.3114317656,
-0.6310082674,
-0.4574243724,
-0.6539968252,
-0.4272170067,
0.5029606819,
-0.3960039616,
-0.0468030125,
0.5303111672,
-0.7113705277,
0.5014207959,
0.2991359532,
0.0553011335,
0.1310330182,
-0.0828302279,
-0.2362055331,
0.1000255495,
-0.5439665318,
-0.3292407691,
0.7429025173,
0.3746210337,
1.0270428658,
0.2022718936,
0.4644328058,
0.1484620571,
-0.1670147777,
-0.6930348277,
0.5311911106,
-0.0833489522,
-0.448197484,
-0.2697696984,
-0.5985175967,
-1.0433171988,
0.15226385,
-0.3594913483,
-0.6713698506,
-0.1830835491,
-0.1939293891,
-0.3471005857,
0.6157736182,
-0.4161821902,
0.5911843777,
-0.5220522285,
-0.6609164476,
-0.8201342225,
-0.6978615522,
-0.0654907152,
0.0870356187,
0.2057822645,
-0.2714146972,
-0.0047074431,
0.6138001084,
-0.5662202835,
0.83624053,
-0.0574441254,
-0.2183564752,
0.3624772131,
0.0505779199,
0.2884554267,
-0.2229632586,
-0.1428770274,
0.0934668258,
-0.1952949017,
-0.304943651,
-0.8363460302,
0.6643625498,
-1.0405837297,
-0.4620299339,
-0.3129130006,
-1.0993032455,
-0.026290115,
0.1969819814,
-0.127106905,
0.5681046844,
0.1372918189,
0.4895878732,
0.5047543645,
-0.0232549533,
0.6160348654,
0.6700180173,
0.3465505242,
-0.2345750779,
1.21846807,
0.3018005192,
-0.2379949689,
0.3644100726,
0.0259779543,
-0.2269338518,
-0.1876756996,
-0.3292601407,
0.470778048,
-0.4671042264,
-0.218090564,
-0.4403677285,
-0.3132317364,
-0.2111856192,
-0.6610437036,
-0.682061851,
-0.3618414402,
-0.1431258172,
-0.0604471304,
0.1109904647,
0.8603881598,
0.0226668734,
0.0537776947,
-0.9935064316,
-0.1735269576,
0.075620845,
0.3486956954,
-0.1108035147,
0.0821208656,
-0.2728805244,
0.0717092603,
-0.5016821027,
-0.8310632706,
0.3824159503,
-0.3112976849,
0.7878480554,
0.2223939002,
0.0730163604,
0.2183292955,
-0.4401881695,
0.4341122508,
0.4974147081,
-0.879511416,
0.3038270772,
-0.5573431253,
-0.180555135,
0.3296848536,
0.6322128773,
-0.180706948,
-0.6809612513,
-0.71919173,
-0.6632025242,
0.3284398019,
0.102893509,
0.0583473407,
0.4033740461,
0.4318134487,
0.1951000094,
0.1634223908,
-0.5762662292,
-0.0700273663,
0.2351168096,
-0.6473828554,
0.0937589854,
0.1482073367,
0.0590573885,
-0.2502231598,
0.7043654919,
-0.577221334,
0.1735508591,
0.1068903282,
-0.1360051781,
-0.3026514649,
0.122221753,
0.5288057327,
0.6155096889,
0.2683691382,
-0.0242821313,
0.1460860968,
-0.1468267441,
0.6419338584,
0.3700796366,
0.2083276361,
-0.4182842076,
0.3790861368,
0.1743572503,
-0.0857367143,
-0.8776462674,
0.0798887983,
0.1157246083,
-0.4709606469,
-0.4955466092,
0.1785864681,
-0.0989855826,
0.8148376346,
0.4758428633,
0.119460173,
0.2165365517,
-0.3954690993,
0.3085511923,
0.6770195961,
-0.3564313054,
-0.6730028391,
0.7216464877,
0.4262992144,
-0.3126969039,
0.3889076114,
-0.2990291119,
-0.6316206455,
1.0950032473,
0.4747107923,
0.764857769,
-0.5446187258,
0.1997385919,
0.1019329727,
0.411588937,
-0.004620682,
0.0659681335,
0.0172228981,
-0.9452726841,
-0.6654790044,
-0.3238363564,
-0.6959655881,
0.1283731759,
-0.0975243524,
0.3648639917,
-0.6843142509,
0.1972142458,
-0.0044445405,
0.1845881194,
-0.484020412,
0.1073669419,
0.0554674976,
0.4391593635,
-0.8798527122,
0.3911100924,
1.1013375521,
-0.914500773,
-1.0465254784,
-0.2273878902,
0.2723431885,
-0.6698128581,
0.3717543483,
0.4033079445,
-0.3906294703,
-0.0085196765,
-0.7272631526,
-0.6632620096,
1.3763082027,
0.488214016,
-0.417524159,
-0.0723308474,
0.1686661839,
0.6481591463,
-0.1866497248,
0.3423912525,
0.1938288659,
0.2742287815,
0.0757507011,
-1.0121665001,
0.1162532866,
-0.613483429,
-0.4368474185,
0.3593240678,
-1.152395606,
1.1552841663,
0.0315949284,
0.1996881366,
0.1028434038,
0.7595236301,
0.3624359667,
0.2849918306,
0.4555726051,
0.4860338569,
0.9892706871,
0.1458587646,
1.0318818092,
-0.5609830618,
0.4621603489,
0.61059618,
-0.4083097279,
0.2628884614,
0.2762188911,
-0.1853895634,
0.6149287224,
0.1545251906,
-0.1060530394,
0.1052460521,
0.1976988912,
-0.5232106447,
-0.2306059599,
-0.4068237841,
-0.462416023,
0.6554285884,
0.4387141764,
0.0383079015,
-0.2294011712,
0.1025376692,
-0.0518635698,
0.3404605687,
-0.1735651046,
0.6773575544,
0.0901287347,
-0.5057091117,
0.1771449745,
-0.0880607888,
0.4428524375,
-0.4346280098,
-0.2619814873,
0.2186274529,
0.4105216265,
-0.2375594825,
-0.6288476586,
0.3376005888,
-0.3233050108,
-0.3909884095,
-0.167657733,
0.8266491294,
-0.3675414324,
-0.3304464519,
0.4658561945,
0.8452441692,
0.1463930756,
0.161660105,
-0.5136069059,
-0.1677112281,
-0.3190621436,
0.1063074619,
0.1335004568,
0.489315182,
0.1179061607,
0.9707651734,
0.7445263863,
0.0061052721,
-0.423732549,
0.1176595688,
1.2118886709,
-0.4501233697,
-0.4911381006,
-0.949005723,
0.5797759295,
0.0174414292,
0.2423091084,
0.3909900784,
0.4317147136,
0.6067390442,
0.1336833537,
0.9189571142,
0.0914414078,
0.2649998069,
-0.5206343532,
0.9425319433,
-0.8414564133,
0.1377609521,
-0.1908133328,
-0.8105832338,
-0.2260046154,
0.6016665697,
-0.0109965401,
0.2816927731,
0.8051018715,
0.4436048567,
0.1793340445,
0.0580331497,
0.3138278127,
0.3865149021,
0.8874100447,
0.8118120432,
0.9301267862,
-0.0911115706,
0.3084222674,
-0.1647429317,
-0.521479249,
-0.1399165988,
-0.5455856919,
-0.8843334317,
-0.6184223294,
-0.0305919405,
-0.1701454669,
-0.1076992899,
1.5383363962,
0.6491935253,
-0.4946235418,
-0.3881899118,
-0.5076771975,
0.0935099572,
-0.0703949109,
-0.1800068468,
-0.0481049158,
-0.7810277939,
-0.8171724677,
0.6850675941,
0.2531272769,
0.1012300774,
-0.5246478319,
-0.3132911921,
0.0590414293,
-0.0056231865,
0.3495461643,
0.4059062898,
-0.2065013796,
-0.0861375555,
0.1454463452,
-0.0162475277,
-0.291067034,
0.6637467742,
-0.7492172718,
0.3723242879,
0.4895550311,
1.1628354788,
0.2074915171,
-0.2560616434,
0.934866488,
-0.7133760452,
0.7494561076,
0.4342558086,
0.6920948625,
0.1513673663,
-0.3072865605,
0.8133584261,
0.4318699241,
-0.7397631407,
-0.5891129375,
0.1098861992,
-0.6217603087,
-0.4917643964,
0.7959632277,
0.1218228489,
-0.3763252199,
-0.1510541886,
0.2040005177,
0.4668928981,
-0.2718322873,
0.7104529142,
0.5355003476,
-0.2873007953,
0.021554064,
-0.4165830016,
0.1662141085,
0.7831923366,
-1.0552512407,
-0.36285761,
0.3798060715,
-0.1602086723,
0.5823443532,
0.4535965621,
0.1991227269,
0.3837997615,
0.1398593634,
0.4166842401,
-0.2148065716,
-0.7968405485,
-0.1088970527,
0.0480673686,
-0.0025371956,
0.0542319529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08154v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08154v3
|
Just Ask One More Time! Self-Agreement Improves Reasoning of Language Models in (Almost) All Scenarios
| 2023-11-14T13:30:54 | 2024-05-24T14:11:21 |
Lei Lin, Jiayi Fu, Pengli Liu, Qingyang Li, Yan Gong, Junchen Wan, Fuzheng Zhang, Zhongyuan Wang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting combined with language models has
achieved encouraging results on complex reasoning tasks, the naive greedy
decoding used in CoT prompting usually causes the repetitiveness and local
optimality. To address this shortcoming, ensemble-optimization tries to obtain
multiple reasoning paths to get the final answer assembly. However, current
ensemble-optimization methods either simply employ rule-based post-processing
such as \textit{self-consistency}, or train an additional model based on
several task-related human annotations to select the best one among multiple
reasoning paths, yet fail to generalize to realistic settings where the type of
input questions is unknown or the answer format of reasoning paths is unknown.
To avoid their limitations, we propose \textbf{Self-Agreement}, a generalizable
ensemble-optimization method applying in almost all scenarios where the type of
input questions and the answer format of reasoning paths may be known or
unknown. Self-agreement firstly samples from language model's decoder to
generate a \textit{diverse} set of reasoning paths, and subsequently prompts
the language model \textit{one more time} to determine the optimal answer by
selecting the most \textit{agreed} answer among the sampled reasoning paths.
Self-agreement simultaneously achieves remarkable performance on six public
reasoning benchmarks and superior generalization capabilities.
|
[
-0.7059004903,
-0.6309620738,
0.9139771461,
0.6590854526,
-0.3442163467,
-0.0915433243,
-0.3239301741,
-0.3810555637,
0.2639199197,
0.5514902472,
-0.6504980326,
-0.1950833648,
-0.2824890018,
0.4364749789,
-0.3339208066,
0.6243008971,
-0.2103068531,
-0.0563873723,
-0.3148976564,
-0.4546295404,
-0.2796183527,
-0.3173947334,
-0.7789112926,
-0.1481519192,
0.3821413219,
0.3184979558,
0.3284803927,
0.573337853,
0.3056004345,
0.4224606454,
0.2878564894,
0.4741221368,
-0.1173876673,
0.3381801248,
-0.3133223951,
-0.138601467,
-0.3144145608,
-0.1120527387,
0.5080710649,
0.3868243098,
-0.2735325694,
0.2205785066,
-0.1306036115,
0.5202741623,
-0.9027602673,
-0.2610415518,
-0.7130595446,
-0.1061834469,
0.2449318618,
-0.1048270762,
-0.2943651378,
-0.3364034593,
0.0193907432,
-0.7462022305,
-0.0462454632,
0.014828234,
0.6530900002,
0.5757547617,
-0.1732005775,
-0.1406843662,
-0.6351265907,
0.8197992444,
-0.3854598999,
0.1942094564,
0.2301844209,
0.3523557186,
-0.2776125371,
-0.479639411,
-0.7224155664,
0.2297705561,
-0.2307509631,
0.3560985625,
-0.4206387997,
0.0808753595,
-0.1449822932,
-0.2314527035,
-0.6968370676,
-0.2311253399,
-0.2591592968,
-0.2936037183,
0.7580056787,
-0.0717496648,
0.0483371876,
-0.086847499,
-0.5210025907,
-0.0603805631,
-0.155686304,
0.0382963233,
0.136187762,
0.1003003344,
0.1599007845,
-0.0170779284,
-0.5026326776,
0.8843948841,
0.3511962891,
0.5468562245,
-0.0034446949,
-0.2339584976,
-0.0928508043,
0.0483625457,
1.092928648,
0.0438565128,
0.2986263633,
-0.1366279423,
-0.1010784283,
0.1183656231,
0.3139605522,
-0.3084776103,
-0.1777422428,
0.6617661715,
-0.1363331527,
-0.1720508635,
-0.2598146498,
-0.9650860429,
0.026697671,
-0.2686465085,
0.4755461812,
-0.0034114458,
-0.3000469804,
0.2109163702,
0.0712786391,
0.2272547185,
0.3623093367,
-0.9296275973,
0.3521455526,
0.4719438255,
0.6765508056,
-0.030897079,
-0.7014288902,
-0.4965111613,
0.1628089696,
-0.6965732574,
1.2615298033,
-0.5210779309,
-0.235324055,
-0.4985198975,
-0.3683072031,
-0.3239612281,
-0.2281598747,
0.4916844666,
-0.4068905711,
0.4159296155,
-0.1746278405,
-0.4389627874,
-0.0345847346,
0.4775172472,
-0.3797327578,
0.9442991018,
-0.2071617246,
-0.2887203097,
0.4258239567,
-0.8417105079,
-0.0578082204,
-0.0778236538,
-0.4284413159,
-0.174632743,
0.0129772443,
0.6254662871,
0.2977751791,
-0.0886366665,
0.268450588,
-0.4516580999,
-0.1474441886,
-0.024867123,
-0.2844710052,
0.5204422474,
0.5330235958,
-0.2543392777,
0.1519637555,
-0.601549089,
0.4831027389,
0.1841646433,
-0.3737874329,
-0.2861581743,
-0.0503848158,
-0.4731475711,
0.3041306436,
0.5040522218,
-0.5356817245,
0.4627366066,
-0.3879620433,
0.2731370032,
0.9476872087,
0.0163185373,
0.4049548209,
-0.2071804553,
0.5114659667,
-0.0814676657,
0.2141198665,
-0.0727577135,
-0.5473130941,
-0.5907550454,
0.1051270217,
0.180749476,
0.4574351907,
-0.1286167353,
0.4308346808,
-0.0291253682,
-0.4300665259,
-0.7501177192,
0.1981897801,
0.4975731373,
0.3406460285,
0.5683117509,
-0.1656554937,
-0.7711823583,
-0.6443151236,
-0.4926210344,
-0.3322859108,
0.320065707,
0.0631032214,
0.2531231046,
-0.1264468431,
1.2043392658,
-0.4104626775,
-0.0000399279,
-0.2653455436,
0.3472864032,
0.1550867409,
0.6362191439,
0.501368165,
-0.6205281019,
-0.5059880614,
0.0937595442,
-0.70441854,
0.1512540132,
-0.327699095,
-0.5821644664,
0.1923807114,
0.2498475164,
-0.5641458035,
0.1064234078,
0.7320813537,
-0.0425455384,
0.5172761679,
-0.5868501663,
0.2942754328,
-0.9068012834,
-0.3677071631,
-0.2671632767,
-0.231646359,
-0.4975519478,
0.0735982805,
0.0472927466,
-0.0241996087,
0.0454088263,
0.8255304694,
-0.4550468922,
0.046935603,
-0.2316769212,
0.2213769406,
0.0156615339,
0.7580736279,
0.1928617656,
0.7894662619,
0.9020911455,
-0.9059692621,
0.3272822201,
0.288176775,
0.0583990067,
0.4639438987,
-0.7283357382,
0.5996383429,
-0.2587305605,
0.34538427,
-1.0979547501,
-0.3581458032,
0.2905195951,
-0.5575510263,
0.0005409484,
-0.0210380461,
0.0815244615,
-0.3976529539,
-0.1009980664,
0.6962188482,
0.3137534857,
-0.9511566162,
1.0961111784,
0.1011076197,
0.2140021771,
-0.7412796021,
-0.5031107664,
-0.0407765992,
-0.1164954901,
-0.8489915729,
0.1412629187,
-0.3573803306,
-0.2016208023,
-0.1123962551,
-0.3423768878,
-0.3889495134,
0.01038743,
-0.2426064461,
0.031048568,
-0.1759584695,
0.3875280023,
0.2725897729,
-0.330770582,
-0.0491656624,
-0.669242084,
0.5827726722,
-0.4142102301,
-0.3682489395,
-0.315338999,
0.5269509554,
0.5051072836,
-0.3886141777,
0.3902366757,
0.3061496019,
-0.3223875463,
-0.0887659341,
-0.8382558227,
-0.1374657005,
-0.5139989257,
0.0040011401,
-0.6965661645,
-0.6804317832,
0.4515360296,
-0.2413703352,
0.3749184012,
0.3986124992,
0.2502975464,
-0.2326892167,
1.3824474812,
0.0777555406,
-0.1259723157,
0.0593063645,
-0.1187380999,
0.2133317441,
-0.4759811163,
0.0294712745,
-0.6234894991,
-0.0780576244,
-0.6211354733,
-0.1653663814,
0.4056303203,
0.17524454,
-0.2459726632,
0.5053771138,
-0.8122471571,
0.6038581729,
0.543853581,
0.0697099417,
0.1211376712,
-0.1579460949,
-0.1905324459,
0.3619286418,
-0.7607688904,
-0.4732634127,
0.8284519315,
-0.1061441377,
0.4803858101,
0.2057363987,
1.4869916439,
0.0627799705,
-0.1825843751,
-0.4134699702,
0.6041043401,
-0.0756921992,
-0.7176698446,
-0.6500772238,
-0.5291363001,
-1.3252925873,
0.3982182145,
-0.0021877163,
-0.9755590558,
0.4651475847,
0.6650179625,
-0.6775334477,
-0.0296398941,
-0.8270418644,
1.130823493,
-0.3601024449,
-0.1800670177,
-0.2762290835,
-0.633407414,
0.3085746467,
-0.0198846702,
0.5540164113,
0.0155381579,
0.024628967,
0.7443242669,
-0.1700019836,
0.5060369968,
0.0205858722,
0.0583968945,
0.5920912027,
0.2497990131,
0.7891703248,
-0.1778933108,
-0.013404225,
-0.1486586779,
0.3562216759,
-0.6604533792,
-0.9715964794,
0.574439466,
-0.7754148245,
-0.9144342542,
-0.3507196009,
-0.1819297373,
-0.3229139149,
0.0337668359,
0.3000980616,
0.4661598802,
-0.0541014932,
-0.2963577509,
0.394040823,
0.3643773198,
0.582654357,
0.2398337275,
-0.1912331879,
-0.3402899802,
0.9733142257,
-0.2244453877,
0.5290961862,
0.2702231109,
0.579636991,
-0.4331259727,
-0.3466772437,
-0.5187797546,
0.1700838208,
-0.7320407033,
0.0180235896,
-0.8979428411,
0.1604689211,
-0.7962011099,
-0.1938045025,
-0.482169807,
-0.6053972244,
0.032665316,
0.0125128776,
0.22231251,
0.6686296463,
-0.498129189,
0.0388723575,
-1.0033481121,
0.283539027,
0.7906532288,
0.0647130683,
-0.2519436777,
-0.2037563473,
0.1811986417,
-0.1218982115,
-0.2516525984,
-0.9866957664,
-0.0335279331,
0.2387369722,
0.7851000428,
0.256223619,
0.1512515545,
0.828684628,
-0.2277822793,
0.6177144647,
0.2983125746,
-1.0806105137,
0.7693479657,
-0.1918626726,
0.3723290861,
0.7413425446,
0.1151440591,
-0.5005535483,
-0.4089424312,
-0.6990833879,
-0.6135602593,
0.4897554815,
0.2346557379,
0.1836101562,
-0.169644177,
0.2015233189,
-0.0832094252,
-0.0491592623,
-0.6897650957,
-0.134270817,
-0.3491944075,
-0.112443231,
0.3813091516,
0.0019412686,
-0.258736521,
-0.2161585093,
0.8154637218,
-0.4893282354,
0.2975363135,
0.398404479,
0.2304165512,
-0.2887478769,
0.5981563926,
0.6241716743,
0.6494348645,
0.0752836913,
0.1828425676,
0.5136868954,
-0.0570287704,
0.3919533193,
-0.1104288772,
0.085698694,
-0.1899210215,
0.1897283494,
0.5166037679,
-0.0200767387,
-0.4320566654,
0.3326435387,
-0.161792323,
-0.250767827,
-0.1667852849,
0.3843914866,
-0.0859885216,
0.2314288616,
0.0619868599,
0.3440797925,
0.0538783893,
-0.4931060672,
0.3254517615,
0.3823245168,
-0.2200252414,
0.1454319507,
0.4480697513,
0.156781584,
-0.3086046576,
0.3795742989,
-0.6393395662,
-0.7205566168,
0.5475530028,
0.1364354491,
0.9017144442,
-0.2552028298,
0.4441958368,
0.6709996462,
0.2087628245,
-0.3480767906,
0.4091673493,
-0.3363832533,
-1.1072891951,
-0.4205933213,
-0.4836471677,
-0.4005690217,
-0.4450553656,
-0.4084168673,
0.1525066495,
-0.5247850418,
0.0315532275,
-0.3256835043,
-0.2645436227,
-0.5114898682,
0.4566251934,
-0.2927833796,
0.5579491854,
-0.4557089806,
0.5872697234,
0.6122938991,
-0.4544505477,
-1.1617571115,
-0.0046985438,
-0.1671467572,
-0.9560729265,
0.2574956417,
-0.0104734832,
-0.3920424581,
0.1211278513,
-0.7762823105,
-1.0495818853,
0.7608143687,
0.3102599382,
-0.8304630518,
-0.0097502954,
-0.3434178531,
0.3760782778,
-0.6240060925,
0.30719468,
0.856885016,
0.6988654733,
0.331625849,
-0.8030127883,
0.0532028899,
-0.0818289071,
-0.3941650391,
0.33985129,
-0.776465416,
0.6515358686,
-0.3322797716,
-0.2171946317,
0.1346520931,
0.8530042768,
0.5415620804,
0.3359834254,
0.8407998681,
0.4994259477,
0.9455888867,
0.046572227,
1.0730289221,
-0.3539680839,
0.5052240491,
1.4839437008,
-0.0542184487,
0.5440866351,
0.4803761542,
-0.2972322404,
0.7092701793,
0.6645662189,
0.1628724486,
0.4372060597,
0.0603629388,
-0.3212405145,
-0.989598155,
0.1952649653,
-0.2281535864,
0.6578312516,
0.060449563,
0.0839160234,
-0.3943996429,
-0.3400107324,
-0.2965191305,
0.3271773458,
-0.1143800095,
0.8396518826,
-0.1292338818,
-1.0998221636,
0.532520473,
-0.3299657702,
0.4279404283,
-0.6455444098,
0.0077162995,
-0.0862991437,
-0.063321963,
-0.1224890277,
-0.4812210202,
0.1540321857,
-0.211945504,
-0.017190652,
-0.0759002268,
0.6542776823,
-0.4207386971,
-0.5768627524,
0.4882753193,
0.5143468976,
0.5394123793,
-0.1184063479,
-0.7930408716,
-0.2222606838,
-0.1887256205,
-0.2203745395,
0.0199232716,
0.5017420053,
0.1553090513,
0.6603087187,
0.4555293024,
0.1370723546,
0.2320908159,
0.1543536037,
0.6987365484,
-0.3943572044,
-0.5531975031,
-0.6406186819,
0.4594985247,
-0.2048872262,
-0.5949352384,
0.2756987214,
0.1554014683,
0.9569107294,
0.3163699806,
0.9496682882,
0.0346697941,
0.3718643785,
-0.5554988384,
0.2008552104,
-0.771835506,
0.2453586012,
-0.1717485636,
-0.793413341,
-0.0509395525,
0.8818734884,
-0.4113522768,
0.3133302629,
0.8707357645,
0.7967059016,
-0.0134096602,
0.3096238077,
0.4505078197,
-0.0202415083,
0.1239372715,
0.5967517495,
0.7820495367,
-0.2300389558,
0.7541049123,
-0.3406441808,
-0.2699940503,
0.3556624651,
-0.7496846914,
-0.7074042559,
-0.5109751821,
-0.3539514244,
-0.1795399189,
0.1527234167,
1.4450753927,
0.7410832047,
-0.9170134068,
-0.2983183861,
-0.5661108494,
0.2825827599,
-0.5147162676,
-0.1578461677,
0.1770810336,
-0.9113144875,
-0.5257441401,
0.5752621293,
0.2094158977,
-0.0721010417,
-0.3706715405,
-0.2528285384,
-0.3843110502,
0.3328340054,
0.048554074,
0.4083174467,
-0.8121078014,
-0.5318902731,
0.0498012081,
0.0698612481,
0.2889175713,
0.9322132468,
-0.6139504313,
0.8658373952,
0.4377849698,
0.6362166405,
0.4047333598,
0.1586306542,
0.6863126755,
-0.5851455927,
-0.2872896194,
0.0814026147,
0.4423933923,
-0.0461771972,
-0.6230698228,
0.5881231427,
0.1151261851,
-0.7524821758,
-0.3490223885,
0.4716455042,
-0.8766319752,
-0.4142091274,
0.8388770223,
-0.295933187,
-0.2695405781,
-0.1679590791,
-0.2796610296,
0.1275155991,
-0.7107775807,
0.9494507313,
0.765638113,
-0.5747647882,
-0.3637503684,
0.1441827565,
0.3781336844,
0.7907356024,
-0.9590442777,
0.0848315209,
0.3555280864,
0.148083061,
0.5299246907,
0.8158169389,
0.2490024865,
0.6331592798,
-0.1921750456,
-0.1817909181,
0.3196886778,
-0.6539266706,
-0.3537763655,
0.2446381152,
0.0351002105,
-0.4372189641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08152v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08152v2
|
Towards Reasoning in Large Language Models via Multi-Agent Peer Review Collaboration
| 2023-11-14T13:27:07 | 2023-12-17T13:02:27 |
Zhenran Xu, Senbao Shi, Baotian Hu, Jindi Yu, Dongfang Li, Min Zhang, Yuxiang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in general
natural language processing tasks but often fall short in complex reasoning
tasks. Recent studies have explored human-like problem-solving strategies, such
as self-correct, to push further the boundary of single-model reasoning
ability. In this work, we let a single model "step outside the box" by engaging
multiple models to correct each other. We introduce a multi-agent collaboration
strategy that emulates the academic peer review process. Each agent
independently constructs its own solution, provides reviews on the solutions of
others, and assigns confidence levels to its reviews. Upon receiving peer
reviews, agents revise their initial solutions. Extensive experiments on three
different types of reasoning tasks show that our collaboration approach
delivers superior accuracy across all ten datasets compared to existing
methods. Further study underscores the effectiveness of integrating confidence
in reviews, demonstrates the superiority of feedback exchange over mere
solution sharing, and highlights the role of capability and diversity in
fostering successful collaboration.
|
[
-0.4434500933,
-0.4197272658,
1.0933594704,
0.0945718959,
0.0869830251,
0.4289579093,
-0.3952168226,
-0.488407284,
0.1360981166,
0.5552260876,
-0.4174974263,
-0.4471672475,
-0.4497606456,
0.3875076473,
-0.2125091851,
0.6863022447,
-0.1411410421,
0.3545622528,
-0.4922365844,
-0.1721500754,
-0.3280623257,
-0.545078814,
-0.526630044,
-0.7868855596,
0.6492292881,
0.4509836733,
0.7519115806,
0.1675131768,
0.5593174696,
0.4211542606,
0.0677001551,
0.5817542672,
-0.2255833298,
0.3730203509,
-0.5225368142,
-0.3014684618,
-0.6119462252,
0.195456475,
0.6163862944,
0.6144766808,
-0.1933173984,
-0.1754307896,
0.2325209975,
0.5379042029,
-0.3075419664,
0.2863098383,
-0.4498615861,
-0.0638615042,
0.1884571314,
0.2551153898,
-0.7739184499,
-0.2530595064,
0.0371240117,
-0.5206569433,
0.2344098389,
0.0428405143,
0.3597914875,
0.2372303605,
-0.3638123274,
-0.0420407057,
-0.8462241888,
0.6461856961,
-0.5972484946,
0.233157292,
0.3290817738,
0.1968534589,
-0.2671384215,
-0.5917202234,
-0.7021149993,
-0.2272648662,
-0.0684121773,
0.0426640697,
-0.0449161194,
0.1164911389,
-0.0934688896,
0.0055256444,
-0.2359246165,
-0.0570306443,
-0.1717308313,
-0.0847818479,
0.8987329006,
-0.0992905274,
-0.0293834433,
0.1663939804,
-0.1391163915,
-0.1878534555,
-0.5370547771,
0.0501931496,
0.1531498879,
0.4278678298,
0.258516252,
0.5864368081,
-0.2689428926,
0.1997999996,
0.0416314863,
0.044995863,
0.2444467247,
-0.5502117872,
-0.1189857796,
-0.0614604875,
0.8571022153,
0.1164228022,
0.1648440659,
-0.1806549877,
-0.3391479254,
0.2058642358,
0.3456002772,
-0.4096288085,
-0.0357420184,
0.5682292581,
-0.2879067063,
-0.1024844199,
0.0154019818,
-0.4944694936,
-0.5244784951,
-0.4131901264,
0.5831642747,
-0.1742403954,
-0.2862288654,
0.4120868742,
0.0800087154,
-0.1831182539,
0.8354249597,
-0.3359506428,
0.4940282404,
0.9116877913,
0.724281013,
0.0009509225,
-0.7896687388,
-0.6704236269,
0.2955863476,
-0.4349903166,
1.00421381,
-0.4785300493,
-0.3165288866,
-0.1327152103,
-0.2074393928,
0.1612298191,
-0.2251339704,
0.4484607577,
-0.3818006217,
0.0166088771,
-0.3135730326,
-0.4905581772,
-0.0917311385,
0.5869689584,
-0.6138743162,
0.7708150148,
-0.3712363839,
-0.5096899867,
-0.0097773364,
-0.5841477513,
-0.1782747507,
0.1031809151,
-0.1576720327,
-0.3538326621,
-0.0225544721,
0.4333155453,
0.4724253118,
-0.3572912216,
0.3231037259,
-0.5203962326,
-0.2345139831,
0.365073204,
-0.0217114184,
0.4771772325,
0.0252342131,
-0.1814594269,
0.4626968503,
-0.3502654433,
0.2194737345,
0.1521210074,
-0.0023511914,
-0.261605978,
-0.1639717072,
-0.3290649652,
0.1517887264,
0.074582614,
-0.5033262968,
0.5144250393,
-0.0411121137,
0.5506522655,
0.7148963809,
0.0215116534,
0.5317770839,
-0.6583905816,
0.2976871431,
-0.2241393179,
0.3324103951,
-0.1438333988,
-0.7073988318,
-0.5396050811,
-0.1019792259,
0.2092559934,
0.1403682828,
-0.7980421782,
0.0911010876,
-0.0920409113,
-0.636087358,
-0.7427101135,
0.2862260938,
0.4004479945,
0.0588013828,
0.4069614708,
-0.2910267413,
-0.0041641374,
-0.5173253417,
-0.1121242493,
-0.5083335638,
0.2116245925,
0.211526379,
0.6549004316,
-0.3490072191,
0.8768456578,
-0.3135195971,
-0.3319015801,
-0.3008020222,
0.3431295455,
0.0842827708,
0.5353184342,
0.0807771608,
-0.6210430264,
-0.465069443,
0.0665860772,
-0.645819068,
0.0429180562,
-0.0483104996,
-0.2257400155,
0.1704140455,
0.3690489531,
-0.8155475259,
0.0879348144,
0.5213593245,
-0.4141213,
0.6740577221,
-0.3144681454,
0.3898522854,
-0.8235695362,
-0.3030812442,
-0.0175753869,
-0.2908185422,
-0.5206477046,
0.2466821373,
-0.2339616716,
0.0645666495,
-0.0226842985,
0.4872026145,
-0.6597775817,
0.0363191441,
-0.1156044677,
0.3174486458,
0.3949227631,
0.2522296906,
0.1922313124,
0.5027176738,
0.5889543891,
-0.1874111146,
0.5817179084,
0.4945085347,
-0.0283102673,
0.7891451716,
-0.7239575982,
0.5598906875,
-0.3915222287,
0.4468967915,
-0.9956724644,
-0.1460589767,
0.261649549,
-0.6434441805,
0.0363082252,
-0.1243159845,
-0.72329849,
-0.2459972948,
-0.2433215082,
0.3017978966,
-0.062718004,
-0.610607028,
0.9105296731,
0.3927393556,
-0.3262277842,
-0.7014014125,
-0.5434565544,
0.3527372181,
0.3675058782,
-0.7455718517,
0.2005034387,
-0.2653539181,
-0.672398746,
0.1518768519,
0.0279170666,
-0.2051569968,
-0.3208137751,
0.0886130929,
0.1839737892,
0.1639472097,
0.5632377267,
-0.0405383408,
0.0503139682,
-0.0273036379,
-0.2225153595,
0.3579646945,
-0.5226991773,
-0.6700371504,
-0.195374459,
0.5990224481,
0.7469985485,
-0.6269294024,
0.6630375981,
0.2251200676,
-0.3353994787,
-0.5851998925,
-0.8826784492,
-0.6453639269,
-0.4207215011,
0.0442257971,
-0.4657664895,
-0.8771889806,
0.3370008469,
0.0259089787,
0.1745806336,
0.0581743792,
0.5528302193,
-0.1499368101,
1.0986516476,
0.619897604,
0.2066207081,
-0.0313413925,
-0.1538684815,
0.1862157136,
-0.5472671986,
-0.4196933806,
-0.7872786522,
-0.0298957806,
-0.1055145413,
-0.9374312162,
0.4667512476,
-0.189928785,
-0.2743305564,
0.1766375452,
-0.5002821088,
0.627928853,
0.5953325629,
0.2168277949,
0.8859286904,
-0.2124605924,
-0.2995898724,
0.1245515421,
-0.650421977,
-0.5726292133,
0.9532418251,
0.442255795,
0.7811418176,
-0.0279899221,
0.9016306996,
0.1060553864,
0.5286176205,
-0.6032415032,
0.6094402671,
0.1215176061,
-0.603007853,
-0.6130439639,
-0.4911234081,
-0.6349919438,
0.6247872114,
-0.4507885575,
-0.3612997234,
0.0848792195,
-0.2767848372,
-0.1773292422,
0.4654069841,
-0.5037898421,
0.7213286161,
-0.1555172801,
-0.6023670435,
-0.5607971549,
-0.6993045211,
0.1670638472,
-0.0777423754,
0.4292497933,
-0.0338183977,
0.1316320151,
0.3118980527,
-0.3947173357,
0.8027398586,
0.1110203117,
-0.2375454158,
0.51042068,
0.2605770528,
0.6601242423,
0.2342306376,
-0.1159067154,
0.1493854225,
-0.0839895085,
-0.264144361,
-0.5371872187,
0.5924025178,
-0.8377789855,
-0.6743285656,
-0.7135228515,
-0.7253931761,
-0.41659531,
0.2341513932,
-0.2658263743,
0.2374383956,
0.0342739485,
0.208150208,
0.581399262,
0.2331276685,
0.2831866443,
0.745509088,
-0.430352211,
-0.5325346589,
0.3247386217,
0.0686534718,
0.3437957764,
0.156863153,
0.306946516,
-0.4003929496,
-0.5360061526,
-0.2243754417,
0.469320178,
-0.8132414818,
-0.0717056245,
-0.7313068509,
0.0020325494,
-0.6591815948,
-0.0168341193,
-0.7109671235,
-0.0929957554,
0.0958465114,
0.0857862383,
-0.0482501686,
1.0008012056,
-0.2077103555,
-0.0529256761,
-1.0929545164,
0.0520902798,
0.5778161287,
0.5037351251,
0.1776542664,
-0.2086085677,
-0.0448375717,
-0.0494061559,
-0.2362530977,
-1.0162651539,
0.1343214661,
-0.1886870414,
0.7367941737,
-0.0681596324,
0.1640775502,
0.2755173743,
-0.5272853374,
0.521889627,
0.1815056503,
-1.1348282099,
0.3211739957,
-0.2759477496,
0.2130230665,
0.5620808005,
0.3391450346,
-0.5530583262,
-0.6866772771,
-0.4369230568,
-0.4463666379,
0.4119184315,
0.2910321653,
-0.231004402,
0.3172254264,
0.24202241,
0.0975618884,
0.2333373278,
-0.9225862026,
-0.0569578968,
-0.0615642518,
0.1485716552,
-0.2375533879,
0.1292100549,
-0.5535640717,
-0.1812004894,
0.8950976729,
-0.5023682714,
0.0012742949,
0.5387128592,
0.2055760324,
-0.4776011109,
0.5827279687,
0.2211610973,
0.6590258479,
0.0829846188,
0.2471108586,
0.0447260104,
-0.0601331927,
0.3636536002,
0.1176337153,
0.1247444004,
0.0443436652,
0.2821462452,
0.1666290462,
-0.1314526945,
-0.5614785552,
0.5546579957,
-0.3694919944,
-0.2522863746,
-0.0098510934,
-0.311616689,
0.363581419,
0.7306528687,
0.3232820928,
0.2143468559,
0.1365083903,
-0.6447966099,
0.2051803023,
0.5797795653,
-0.0830542743,
-0.0384001322,
0.4408728182,
0.2990245223,
-0.2236656398,
0.4219915867,
-0.4162669778,
-0.5764226317,
0.690146029,
0.3606280684,
0.8444849849,
-0.183212176,
0.6241436005,
0.2953156531,
0.5543769002,
-0.5883507133,
0.1143231541,
0.0582888313,
-0.9861796498,
-0.9725849032,
-0.2307515889,
-1.3076395988,
-0.2068574578,
-0.3984376788,
0.1896202266,
-0.388858676,
-0.1764681786,
0.0298986472,
0.0799316987,
-0.2514656484,
-0.0666422993,
0.1452547461,
0.6812913418,
-0.7113596797,
0.8533992767,
0.9940938354,
-0.451097995,
-0.9652237892,
0.0269367378,
-0.0158407204,
-0.3309653997,
0.3845022619,
0.2485830933,
-0.4866267443,
-0.2794361711,
-0.8319243193,
-0.597153008,
0.8190222383,
0.2535867095,
-0.7682192922,
0.1721989959,
-0.1306433082,
0.8051243424,
-0.4317528903,
0.2717769742,
0.2554530203,
0.5385489464,
0.3223136663,
-1.1253733635,
0.0219272338,
-0.1761126816,
-0.378331989,
0.0153878517,
-0.8756276369,
1.144417882,
-0.5192833543,
-0.0037154953,
-0.0403064638,
0.6344300508,
0.5194487572,
0.492108196,
0.6246842146,
0.5779346824,
0.8825519681,
0.0951585397,
0.7406203151,
-0.2272863388,
0.5758737922,
1.2321721315,
-0.7301902771,
0.8170220852,
0.4890164137,
-0.1687358916,
0.6109703779,
0.0789437443,
-0.0194434132,
0.0355735645,
-0.0235791542,
-0.3628018796,
-0.7258136868,
-0.3448071182,
-0.2504066229,
0.3294935524,
0.0417110771,
0.0452009737,
-0.1175215691,
-0.1455904245,
0.0335188471,
0.5556561351,
-0.5200717449,
0.7268462181,
0.1125820801,
-1.0608314276,
0.2323687822,
-0.0360783376,
0.5213207006,
-0.4037468731,
-0.2940133512,
-0.0029577722,
0.2745837867,
-0.117253989,
-1.0731929541,
0.1083329543,
-0.2064726204,
-0.213134557,
-0.5223966837,
0.7267701626,
-0.7230247855,
-0.3973015547,
0.5414203405,
0.9880955815,
-0.0950201899,
-0.3052906096,
-0.563207984,
0.1257227063,
-0.4457366765,
0.0516121797,
0.1656435281,
0.3993282914,
0.0624701753,
0.9118306637,
0.6819919944,
0.2385429442,
-0.3656068146,
0.2311075926,
0.8204238415,
-0.3284418881,
-0.6520681977,
-0.743676722,
0.2757105529,
-0.203645885,
0.0856018439,
0.5613295436,
0.1523168683,
0.9043346643,
-0.0303360336,
0.8652118444,
0.2686271966,
0.5809873939,
-0.2305945307,
0.5851593614,
-0.4774326086,
0.2703089118,
-0.4235997498,
-0.9520287514,
-0.3971968889,
0.7423930764,
-0.2029239833,
0.010884393,
0.983828485,
0.6855202913,
0.4208475053,
0.1336898208,
0.2747375667,
0.4404628873,
0.5550273657,
0.7013104558,
0.9156410694,
-0.1823810637,
0.6295893192,
-0.4330467582,
-0.2205664963,
0.1575088799,
-1.034783721,
-1.1592555046,
-0.4829887748,
-0.347905606,
-0.6290926933,
0.1794917881,
1.4296847582,
0.6506819129,
-0.7471150756,
-0.3335753679,
0.0184743516,
0.378152281,
-0.4325029552,
-0.1355445534,
0.0476663075,
-0.3819355369,
-0.8991902471,
0.4329437912,
0.361882329,
-0.085204497,
-0.6317309141,
-0.2523545027,
-0.2457502037,
0.1936660707,
0.2629494369,
-0.0568164028,
-0.6233192086,
-0.2644226253,
-0.1302761436,
-0.3001467288,
0.0679576322,
0.8459769487,
-0.5919706821,
0.6667278409,
0.528331697,
0.7054281831,
0.3285865188,
-0.0615295023,
0.5014261603,
-0.4573316872,
-0.2282351106,
0.4835369289,
0.5334181786,
0.4528365731,
-0.2870642841,
0.6921238303,
0.2555850744,
-0.9496033192,
-0.9221672416,
0.0925695375,
-0.8141041398,
-0.3873451352,
1.0782288313,
-0.3137546182,
0.1010649055,
-0.1744443625,
-0.4350083768,
-0.0084522348,
-0.5921322107,
0.9097212553,
1.0622708797,
-0.2338318974,
-0.3184866607,
-0.2019702345,
0.1237270534,
0.4145736992,
-1.0869370699,
0.0513430759,
0.4983775318,
0.1370055825,
0.5470933318,
0.7781655788,
-0.0426015519,
0.2973492146,
-0.0776910856,
0.1870488375,
-0.2053847164,
-0.8726426363,
-0.4375353158,
0.3977637887,
0.3079434037,
0.3678243458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08147v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08147v1
|
RECALL: A Benchmark for LLMs Robustness against External Counterfactual Knowledge
| 2023-11-14T13:24:19 | 2023-11-14T13:24:19 |
Yi Liu, Lianzhe Huang, Shicheng Li, Sishuo Chen, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Xu Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
LLMs and AI chatbots have improved people's efficiency in various fields.
However, the necessary knowledge for answering the question may be beyond the
models' knowledge boundaries. To mitigate this issue, many researchers try to
introduce external knowledge, such as knowledge graphs and Internet contents,
into LLMs for up-to-date information. However, the external information from
the Internet may include counterfactual information that will confuse the model
and lead to an incorrect response. Thus there is a pressing need for LLMs to
possess the ability to distinguish reliable information from external
knowledge. Therefore, to evaluate the ability of LLMs to discern the
reliability of external knowledge, we create a benchmark from existing
knowledge bases. Our benchmark consists of two tasks, Question Answering and
Text Generation, and for each task, we provide models with a context containing
counterfactual information. Evaluation results show that existing LLMs are
susceptible to interference from unreliable external knowledge with
counterfactual information, and simple intervention methods make limited
contributions to the alleviation of this issue.
|
[
-0.3634435833,
-0.8408347368,
0.8369259834,
-0.123517476,
-0.0045165289,
0.0556751862,
0.0870531648,
-0.6105206609,
-0.1146178842,
0.3383879364,
-0.6252719164,
-0.0507314764,
-0.6481083632,
0.1016672626,
-0.5549646616,
0.8505305052,
-0.1663176566,
-0.044031363,
-0.9097131491,
-0.2826780975,
-0.6905210018,
-0.5172094703,
-0.6119587421,
-0.4728994966,
0.3098523617,
0.2673852742,
0.4428310096,
0.1241965368,
0.6182515621,
0.4050511718,
0.1198782548,
0.552318871,
-0.7001791,
0.2344204187,
-0.5313997865,
-0.7641252279,
-0.2498992085,
-0.147275731,
0.5514828563,
0.286152333,
0.1200770661,
0.3189936578,
0.3182119727,
0.6160433292,
-0.6101405621,
0.1357682496,
-1.0743371248,
-0.2266555876,
0.1232937798,
-0.2083361745,
-0.258005321,
-0.6028453708,
0.0011525973,
-0.4600686729,
0.0228540525,
-0.0000122253,
0.91327703,
0.50047791,
-0.4430618584,
-0.2681717873,
-0.6960969567,
0.5557653904,
-0.5125969648,
0.2722758055,
0.4401393235,
0.3497494459,
-0.2971547544,
-0.739559114,
-0.5619154572,
-0.230944559,
-0.2254694998,
0.2051220536,
-0.5480003953,
-0.3082134724,
0.3273376226,
0.1181676313,
-0.3406543136,
0.0204621237,
-0.2934347093,
-0.3536512256,
0.3685248792,
0.3924062848,
0.157488063,
0.0304199923,
-0.4573692679,
-0.081146501,
-1.0659697056,
0.1010766923,
0.2463389486,
0.1900609732,
0.03388891,
0.6809710264,
-0.2300816327,
0.1585143656,
0.1773102731,
-0.1523388326,
0.141349569,
-0.4897089601,
-0.2532821596,
-0.1760007292,
0.5956315994,
0.5809103251,
0.2890669107,
-0.1342389733,
-0.1675062329,
0.1823290884,
0.5760712624,
-0.6646324992,
-0.02838335,
0.2698004842,
-0.3812946677,
-0.0486206673,
-0.1493573636,
-0.4698851109,
-0.5096516609,
-0.0596217774,
0.8023138046,
-0.4857011735,
-0.0670975074,
-0.7149487734,
-0.170407936,
-0.0658523813,
0.3467159271,
-0.3932016492,
0.2341359705,
0.5747994781,
0.8112443089,
-0.3040104508,
-0.1942241192,
-0.4886493981,
0.1395835131,
-0.4156221449,
1.0277272463,
-0.245204553,
-0.5500282645,
0.0112662073,
0.1049545109,
-0.1442975402,
-0.7472974658,
0.2945741415,
-0.4428506196,
0.1190612093,
-0.6843270659,
-0.8619147539,
-0.2848435044,
0.7574074268,
-0.5214213133,
1.0411226749,
0.1042914391,
-0.9065138102,
0.3033004105,
-0.0999422669,
-0.3198127151,
-0.1170276254,
-0.4704130888,
-0.4894587398,
0.0138001563,
0.079682909,
0.2346398234,
-0.4003514051,
0.306863904,
-0.4240687191,
-0.4548544884,
0.5494942665,
-0.6961196065,
0.4719861448,
-0.0919315517,
-0.2229255736,
0.1069112793,
-0.6120364666,
-0.037964724,
0.1799331158,
-0.351910919,
-0.2944423556,
0.0739098415,
-0.5322558284,
0.2042367458,
0.4260903895,
-0.3898280859,
-0.1747512817,
-0.2211362869,
0.1370130777,
0.9301784039,
0.1747458726,
0.0205376279,
-1.0188987255,
0.3435302675,
0.1437998414,
-0.0478432029,
-0.3360389471,
-0.4774945378,
-0.8843361735,
-0.0671330169,
-0.1389007568,
0.7943494916,
-0.912663579,
0.3402751088,
-0.2421617359,
-0.5658900738,
-0.2133131176,
0.4196641743,
0.5740142465,
1.0253162384,
0.5366588235,
-0.2587898374,
-0.7170401216,
-0.8532455564,
-0.3142487705,
-0.5078418255,
-0.1689968407,
0.4507505298,
0.6010255814,
-0.2577193975,
0.931720078,
-0.1258596778,
-0.1404134035,
-0.0749065354,
0.1312751174,
0.0425856188,
0.4122839868,
0.3357382119,
-0.5593838096,
-0.2677379847,
-0.411816448,
-1.1201710701,
-0.0238690041,
-0.1238702908,
-0.0066118343,
0.4058606327,
0.6768487692,
-0.807585597,
0.5293659568,
0.3758163154,
-0.0327773951,
0.4403554797,
-0.33381477,
0.2841563225,
-0.9154045582,
0.3565574884,
-0.1158745885,
-0.1009461209,
-0.481782198,
-0.1791891307,
0.1470090002,
0.3201220632,
-0.4569176137,
0.7714017034,
-0.1456823051,
-0.0563137457,
-0.1138180271,
0.3850165904,
-0.1286848933,
0.3102908731,
-0.074570477,
0.8008179069,
0.0365045406,
-0.6951286197,
0.3345943689,
0.2191394418,
-0.5282065868,
1.1427643299,
-0.6156299114,
0.130745247,
-0.0402107723,
0.202799812,
-1.3221737146,
0.0765992627,
0.2376362234,
-0.4029787779,
0.1259691119,
-0.0288747549,
-0.6022378206,
-0.3100387454,
-0.2147393674,
0.0281278864,
0.5956867337,
-0.4985603392,
0.7290697694,
0.2003160715,
-0.1742827296,
-0.4985179305,
-0.7498472929,
-0.0308816992,
-0.290871352,
-0.4817447364,
-0.0063011656,
-0.2233319283,
-0.436331749,
0.0692674443,
-0.2447547466,
0.073000066,
0.1125430316,
0.3450876474,
0.3099838793,
-0.2530240715,
0.256472975,
-0.2638436556,
-0.0947385877,
0.4013194442,
0.12119551,
0.238894105,
0.067991145,
-0.7129272223,
-0.3374765515,
0.0094000483,
0.3447110355,
0.3041484356,
0.7395164967,
0.411362499,
-0.4090183377,
0.0432139225,
-0.8779232502,
-0.3421719968,
-0.5328715444,
0.374915123,
-0.3023602664,
-0.4748888016,
0.5769518614,
-0.1551377475,
-0.0236643311,
0.5118162036,
0.4014511406,
-0.2118795365,
0.7556362748,
0.4078939557,
-0.111563541,
0.2696221173,
0.1025223136,
-0.1891821325,
-0.6330963373,
-0.4226323664,
-0.4509801269,
-0.1433599442,
-0.5216163993,
-0.3254776001,
0.3694898188,
-0.0474546365,
-0.4391626418,
0.2797761858,
-0.1063419357,
0.1821822673,
0.801076889,
0.4069503248,
0.4179796278,
-0.2742739916,
-0.3550759554,
-0.1237764508,
-0.7092008591,
-0.6091051698,
1.2337034941,
0.2042577416,
0.7525461912,
0.1314570904,
0.3727716208,
0.2900101244,
0.6744883657,
-0.2929598689,
0.675229311,
0.0182322245,
-0.6022002101,
-0.1241221428,
-0.5966897011,
-0.7462627888,
0.0238728356,
-0.4523084164,
-0.8379416466,
-0.1784743667,
0.34495157,
-0.1979505718,
0.4333912134,
-0.5521414876,
0.6974551082,
-0.3236139417,
-0.501773417,
-0.2829633653,
-0.5885351896,
0.4277185202,
-0.2624172568,
0.1527918875,
-0.201865986,
-0.0354479812,
0.4728673697,
-0.2752699554,
1.1765204668,
-0.0011717434,
-0.1169090122,
0.4066197872,
0.2692928016,
0.7755337358,
-0.0282787122,
-0.0136021152,
0.1442282349,
-0.0303992648,
-0.0770793483,
-0.5252017379,
0.6752985716,
-0.6486683488,
-0.7208177447,
-0.2078605741,
-0.5117869973,
-0.6502230763,
0.1749087125,
0.3458082676,
0.2786855698,
-0.5482720733,
0.2570565939,
0.734539628,
-0.3565835059,
0.3142003417,
0.7476506829,
0.0790108219,
-0.3575826883,
0.7581903934,
0.1812682301,
0.3692033589,
0.5675541162,
0.1992024481,
-0.4364828467,
-0.3263327777,
-0.4232614934,
-0.164732635,
-1.0535979271,
-0.4372073114,
-0.5313887,
-0.4485587776,
-0.2135934979,
0.0823435113,
-0.3112075925,
-0.2786678076,
-0.2926908433,
-0.0126288291,
0.2844649553,
0.8790980577,
-0.0436526649,
0.0125731714,
-0.9128305316,
0.4325815737,
0.6293655038,
0.2096655816,
0.0551730059,
-0.6252129674,
-0.0330288783,
0.1411703527,
-0.4357694685,
-0.5947798491,
-0.0681912154,
-0.032281395,
1.1016273499,
0.3867672682,
0.2512741387,
0.5925641656,
-0.4294010401,
0.5837167501,
0.0256658308,
-0.727779448,
0.5664738417,
-0.1145967916,
0.519811511,
0.6255989075,
0.6326767206,
-0.3258171678,
-0.7608393431,
-0.7685088515,
-0.7425088882,
0.3221449256,
0.180378437,
0.0624841638,
-0.081118755,
0.0829835981,
0.1133443713,
0.3638991117,
-0.5243652463,
-0.1459607929,
-0.1849506944,
-0.3100516796,
-0.0900861248,
-0.3021562994,
-0.3692962527,
0.2696413398,
0.5449763536,
-0.0254005883,
0.1732277274,
0.1690571308,
-0.1965664327,
-0.1088613123,
0.058549881,
0.6919264793,
0.8152458072,
-0.2157267779,
0.3770251572,
0.7021384835,
-0.199460268,
-0.1078200787,
0.0582656041,
-0.1689737886,
-0.2489879429,
0.6149609089,
0.2738271952,
0.2961878777,
-0.9537869692,
0.3554240763,
-0.0473722778,
0.0209165812,
-0.3345303833,
0.2711280286,
0.2160077989,
0.4814530015,
0.434111625,
0.1743570417,
-0.1458978653,
-0.655836165,
0.3943606019,
0.6911919713,
-0.4334309995,
-0.1079389378,
0.5822818875,
0.2728717029,
-0.2824495733,
0.5937177539,
0.0431133956,
-0.4736057222,
0.7485362291,
0.460971415,
0.5392804742,
-0.0594253838,
-0.2242118269,
0.4792761803,
0.5162878633,
-0.1622174382,
0.2983744144,
0.0964425504,
-0.8257518411,
0.0342676006,
0.0155342333,
-0.8026900291,
0.2726084888,
-0.3454400003,
-0.082412526,
-0.4905984104,
-0.2434185892,
-0.4287605882,
-0.1389434189,
-0.8811661005,
0.3952153325,
-0.1697512716,
0.8697148561,
-0.7657917142,
0.6660885811,
0.2537004948,
-0.4578252435,
-0.2565847933,
0.0457293838,
0.2746159732,
-1.197480917,
0.721868813,
0.2309943587,
-0.2676445544,
-0.5500124693,
-0.3819851875,
-0.8098019958,
1.071845293,
0.4037869573,
-0.6438027024,
0.2316931039,
0.2215099037,
0.5388261676,
-0.2030535191,
0.49865219,
0.2818055153,
0.4411200285,
0.1582059264,
-1.0502970219,
0.5589614511,
-0.178527385,
-0.2321034074,
-0.1605716497,
-0.728237927,
0.6448177695,
-0.2366120517,
-0.2860528529,
0.298391372,
0.4806733727,
0.3756190836,
0.3755034208,
0.5468273759,
0.3989897072,
0.8229936957,
-0.0931757912,
0.7246682048,
-0.4473789334,
-0.1016051769,
1.5118272305,
-0.2350582629,
1.1059131622,
0.4593352377,
-0.1271617413,
0.3634456396,
0.3637224436,
-0.1636327952,
0.445189178,
0.0527215973,
-0.038912233,
-0.2548024058,
-0.1110839024,
-0.4085273147,
0.3133397102,
0.429987818,
-0.3416173756,
-0.0798605829,
-0.3694975972,
-0.0671629459,
0.1978237927,
-0.1058138981,
0.9391328692,
0.1085385829,
-0.9473797083,
0.3821470141,
-0.3532221317,
0.53265661,
-0.5971785784,
-0.0705045313,
-0.4635869563,
0.418538034,
-0.0237007588,
-0.8961281776,
0.3984029293,
-0.1350417435,
0.0055145714,
-0.0350624695,
0.8336790204,
-0.1734585017,
-0.452961266,
0.2967833877,
0.7645402551,
-0.0468966439,
0.0643030331,
-0.554833293,
0.0330588557,
-0.1865237653,
-0.0269288514,
0.2822431922,
0.4090385735,
-0.0047721001,
1.0778591633,
0.4488979876,
-0.0255564041,
-0.2399238646,
-0.1826219857,
0.7896080613,
-0.6206951737,
-0.2125485837,
-0.9049771428,
0.3524928391,
-0.2652232945,
-0.303324163,
1.0232709646,
0.420008719,
0.8748834133,
0.2613207698,
0.9515040517,
0.169563815,
0.6790614128,
-0.6179781556,
0.5708496571,
-0.5483781695,
0.4319236279,
-0.139204219,
-0.5387386084,
0.2190271318,
0.3642486334,
-0.1456022412,
0.1894419193,
0.6758477688,
0.7488839626,
0.0408749618,
-0.0261437297,
0.3196721673,
0.1746017486,
0.1230031773,
0.6804873943,
1.1433007717,
-0.3147076666,
1.0560306311,
-0.0927737802,
0.1259820908,
-0.2970531285,
-1.0713076591,
-1.2236831188,
-0.3588629365,
-0.1528566182,
-0.3594218194,
0.2405333817,
0.6596893668,
0.6427485347,
-0.8216593862,
0.0152747296,
-0.0122715216,
0.4345744252,
-0.1798442453,
-0.1881852597,
0.185044542,
-0.3217203617,
-0.3664962649,
0.4376705587,
0.1331339926,
0.2950637639,
-0.2809084654,
0.0549280979,
-0.0799250677,
0.3632038534,
0.3287546635,
0.3495213687,
-0.6521617174,
-0.5724701285,
-0.1241483986,
-0.268168509,
0.1690165699,
0.6105097532,
-0.7837297916,
0.3122571707,
0.56385535,
0.7276408672,
0.3583441675,
0.1166307479,
0.7449745536,
-0.7251793742,
-0.1421777606,
-0.1551995277,
0.4417368174,
0.5600305796,
-0.2066743374,
0.5370101333,
0.1948088855,
-0.4939168692,
-0.5912352204,
0.1656421274,
-0.4639302194,
-0.4727615118,
0.9158810973,
-0.4126268625,
0.1492853463,
-0.3914166093,
-0.0203918945,
0.2054781616,
-0.2417959422,
1.1379020214,
0.7170875669,
-0.2105829716,
-0.106013529,
-0.5329064727,
0.393784523,
0.2781753242,
-1.0709708929,
-0.1795085222,
0.3131123781,
0.4418803751,
0.17614232,
0.7366231084,
0.2514423132,
0.1773329675,
0.3646730185,
-0.3595220149,
0.0071345665,
-0.1104864329,
0.1271829903,
0.1540499479,
0.1448390186,
-0.1003324166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08143v1
|
Sinkhorn Transformations for Single-Query Postprocessing in Text-Video Retrieval
| 2023-11-14T13:20:23 | 2023-11-14T13:20:23 |
Konstantin Yakovlev, Gregory Polyakov, Ilseyar Alimova, Alexander Podolskiy, Andrey Bout, Sergey Nikolenko, Irina Piontkovskaya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A recent trend in multimodal retrieval is related to postprocessing test set
results via the dual-softmax loss (DSL). While this approach can bring
significant improvements, it usually presumes that an entire matrix of test
samples is available as DSL input. This work introduces a new postprocessing
approach based on Sinkhorn transformations that outperforms DSL. Further, we
propose a new postprocessing setting that does not require access to multiple
test queries. We show that our approach can significantly improve the results
of state of the art models such as CLIP4Clip, BLIP, X-CLIP, and DRL, thus
achieving a new state-of-the-art on several standard text-video retrieval
datasets both with access to the entire test set and in the single-query
setting.
|
[
-0.6554254889,
-0.8020222187,
0.3792647123,
-0.0810515732,
-0.4395013452,
-0.0341724083,
-0.2450665981,
0.1310888231,
0.1137115508,
0.7076152563,
-0.6846396327,
-0.5321953893,
-0.8481017947,
-0.0507245101,
-0.7290816307,
1.2343828678,
-0.369541198,
0.1820639223,
-0.059702199,
-0.5872716904,
-0.3003365993,
-0.3553981185,
-0.5267539024,
0.0681702495,
0.3736607432,
0.1412390023,
0.8598664999,
0.3595130444,
0.7754556537,
0.2593481541,
-0.0642849579,
0.2235014737,
-0.4404270947,
0.2284094542,
-0.126754418,
-0.2906358242,
-0.2987971008,
-0.1328281909,
0.829074502,
0.869299233,
0.0674995482,
0.3952611983,
0.1862191409,
0.4296304584,
-0.9033332467,
-0.0498405434,
-0.6088098884,
0.6194753051,
-0.2249123156,
-0.5304867625,
-0.2841583192,
-0.5073487163,
0.1718523651,
-0.2980253994,
0.6447677016,
-0.5176323056,
0.4441277385,
0.4384978414,
-0.572298944,
0.1326832771,
-0.6834914088,
0.8684943914,
-0.531414628,
0.6434602737,
0.0930903554,
0.4976277053,
0.2686834931,
-0.6925384402,
-0.2519580126,
0.2882016897,
0.0857841149,
0.0224047862,
0.0572248921,
-0.0026558482,
0.2721397281,
0.3433395326,
-0.4383972585,
-0.3552421927,
-0.2693926692,
-0.4842589498,
0.6764268279,
0.1819428802,
-0.0528129973,
0.0931353047,
-0.4487770796,
-0.5683649182,
-0.4619389176,
0.2302717865,
-0.168749392,
0.3876319528,
0.4542400241,
0.517369628,
0.1486254185,
0.353328377,
-0.2892471254,
-0.2978024781,
0.2094688863,
-0.5201016068,
-0.2821408808,
0.0703178421,
0.3107817769,
0.3997184932,
0.1692965031,
0.161601156,
-0.3723530769,
0.2159477025,
0.185981676,
-1.2095502615,
-0.1643728316,
-0.0907531083,
-0.608343184,
-0.2202322334,
0.239369452,
-1.1102355719,
-0.4317978024,
-0.3034834266,
0.8549691439,
-0.2938453257,
-0.4684600532,
0.2797558308,
-0.4300568998,
0.164416045,
0.5832902789,
-0.6287391782,
0.7965296507,
0.3632238209,
0.9485565424,
-0.41833359,
-0.3037342429,
-0.8037691116,
0.1404907107,
-0.5381968021,
0.8392792344,
-0.3436249197,
-0.5092428327,
0.4849891067,
0.070770815,
-0.1568563432,
-0.7103421688,
0.4748901427,
-0.6379771829,
-0.1105521619,
-0.3278667331,
-0.2283467054,
-0.05164003,
0.2631040215,
-0.669351697,
0.9440223575,
-0.2411964387,
-0.7786262631,
0.2932132483,
-0.4234022498,
-0.7799509168,
-0.3330968618,
-0.3230554163,
-0.3435373008,
0.2244215161,
0.4786455631,
0.1407192349,
-0.2293618917,
-0.1752785891,
-0.3957827389,
-0.4624253213,
0.0750219971,
-0.5295726657,
0.620331347,
-0.038886793,
-0.2454861552,
0.0246528909,
-0.4234474599,
0.2819105685,
-0.1257896274,
-0.1742007732,
-0.3056217432,
0.0996068791,
0.0437285043,
0.0756407753,
-0.0036295438,
-0.4409458637,
0.3646661937,
-0.1076345071,
0.2840096056,
0.877636075,
-0.1949009746,
0.4562908113,
0.1394267082,
0.5737009645,
0.1747975945,
0.2823694944,
-0.3372378647,
-0.1901729107,
-0.5754283667,
-0.1599115282,
-0.0696988851,
0.4727753997,
-0.6938893795,
-0.4092122018,
-0.154748112,
-0.2259007394,
-0.6256459355,
-0.0074451319,
0.2342309207,
0.6097909212,
0.6907716393,
-0.3254576623,
-0.5879139304,
-0.940392673,
-0.2199478149,
0.3495642245,
-0.0552500077,
0.2329050601,
0.359583199,
-0.225023523,
0.7022945285,
-1.2012112141,
-0.4396508634,
-0.138000384,
0.3736011982,
0.5378417373,
0.1925604045,
0.4810799062,
-1.0710419416,
-0.4401254654,
-0.2101535052,
-0.6555086374,
-0.0039501912,
0.2613987923,
0.0974070951,
0.0910138637,
0.4904217124,
-0.6098715663,
0.8801237345,
0.4059092999,
-0.2653937638,
0.7649021745,
-0.1633429378,
0.5803493261,
-0.6440932751,
-0.3318412006,
-0.2863214314,
-0.3428275287,
-0.4445963502,
-0.2408410907,
0.1765358448,
-0.4416226745,
-0.4038678706,
0.2364391237,
-0.3468392193,
-0.5130284429,
-0.2818680704,
-0.1163368821,
0.1881583184,
0.1544593424,
0.004537141,
1.2080587149,
0.9030644894,
-0.7861598134,
0.1998495162,
0.519480288,
0.1823099405,
0.4833832681,
-0.621658802,
0.1446595788,
-0.5393105745,
0.1917199194,
-1.2822220325,
0.1537481844,
-0.280049473,
-0.2774555683,
0.2105798423,
-0.3836521208,
-0.2062830925,
-0.3364437819,
-0.9871985912,
0.3784706295,
0.5100924373,
-0.5643040538,
0.1714155972,
0.3523390293,
-0.2117276192,
-0.5870393515,
-0.8750850558,
0.0390630141,
-0.0577227511,
-0.79700315,
0.8122876287,
-0.3511186838,
0.123819761,
-0.0117679778,
-0.3828552365,
-0.6283581257,
-0.5016602278,
-0.2405893207,
0.2763150334,
-0.4925961196,
0.2019898742,
0.1976337135,
-0.1715306193,
-0.2185245156,
-0.3190270066,
0.4677925706,
0.0809661821,
-0.0965430811,
-0.4023249745,
0.7429372072,
0.5338895321,
-0.4650972486,
0.3879234493,
0.9349885583,
-0.3285858929,
-0.5448042154,
-0.4218686223,
-0.4200923443,
-0.5056147575,
0.4687810838,
-0.5331727862,
-0.6672238111,
0.3377039731,
0.0121246194,
-0.0884247944,
0.2659527361,
0.1755989492,
-0.1561080515,
1.3784203529,
0.6192919016,
0.4555871785,
0.3970935345,
-0.4066159427,
-0.0552014746,
-0.6606516242,
0.1670038104,
-0.3613762856,
-0.253288269,
-0.4354315698,
-0.3784634173,
0.8114687204,
-0.1833846867,
-0.0551645756,
0.530944407,
-0.4519795477,
0.2815024853,
0.3339314163,
0.2694420218,
0.4099550843,
0.2043707818,
-0.0367410369,
-0.6207110882,
-0.3177852631,
-0.3109975755,
1.2344107628,
-0.0801460594,
1.048075676,
0.3434537649,
0.4832037985,
0.5100501776,
0.0647859201,
-0.6935443878,
0.8208971024,
-0.6170672178,
-0.3847339153,
-0.3773446679,
-0.4961159229,
-0.8188102841,
0.6996816397,
-0.024685597,
-0.4371735454,
-0.1632565856,
0.0742556527,
-0.171631664,
0.5875732899,
-0.5081416965,
0.9488870502,
-0.0645616278,
-0.5381433964,
-0.2710499465,
-0.3663667738,
0.2282111347,
0.1062263995,
0.1358716041,
-0.0507140048,
-0.2801676095,
0.5673297048,
-0.5336508155,
0.1260192692,
-0.4921334684,
-0.0743704215,
0.1853044331,
0.2276834995,
0.336499989,
0.2870098054,
-0.1212313995,
-0.0302034914,
0.3459571004,
-0.0662589371,
-0.7462568879,
0.5743311644,
-0.5634728074,
-0.5464959145,
-0.3693041503,
-0.3843643963,
-0.1082244813,
0.3144977689,
0.1215604991,
0.9891629815,
0.0747486502,
0.2370272726,
0.9347594976,
-0.1448504478,
0.7515872121,
0.2817948461,
-0.2903249562,
-0.5236614943,
0.4098757207,
0.4448105693,
0.0677972883,
0.2176419795,
0.0937331617,
-0.6889651418,
-0.8811364174,
-0.592419982,
-0.0048028994,
-0.7586036325,
-0.367456913,
-0.4170084,
-0.1312837303,
-1.0028958321,
0.0389754809,
-0.7845202684,
-0.2977549434,
-0.0655943155,
0.0749454796,
0.030913882,
0.3831683993,
0.0726107284,
-0.0824806839,
-1.0240918398,
0.6055127978,
0.5636086464,
0.5712789297,
-0.377268523,
-0.7454667687,
0.063324444,
-0.2171538621,
-0.4070456922,
-1.2879428864,
0.2516977489,
0.5737530589,
0.4335007966,
0.4810189903,
0.0703427643,
0.9986302257,
-0.8701205254,
0.5996270776,
-0.0148265474,
-0.7552837133,
0.6843464375,
-0.2166102976,
0.3345306218,
0.8775259256,
0.4669192731,
-0.4015665948,
0.3842634857,
-0.0764510036,
-0.6776289344,
0.7660808563,
0.1902552545,
0.2475659102,
0.4390886724,
0.1299221814,
0.3793082535,
0.5171847343,
-0.4695812166,
-0.2552578449,
-0.3917358816,
0.0663106516,
-0.0370669253,
-0.2389637828,
-0.1825180203,
-0.629953742,
0.3144030869,
-0.1212380901,
0.2619905174,
0.5248739719,
-0.3202738464,
0.0253581349,
0.2558238506,
0.149951309,
0.7111930847,
-0.5855169296,
0.5779167414,
0.3118569851,
-0.5710411668,
0.338206321,
0.3559157252,
-0.2132440954,
0.2373132706,
0.3174889386,
0.3776705563,
0.3643161356,
-0.6056061387,
0.8970804811,
-0.0538304709,
-0.2018822879,
-0.5164757371,
-0.1765588075,
-0.5370826721,
0.2047100365,
0.6794888973,
0.3034560382,
0.7005304694,
-0.5585346818,
0.6748246551,
0.3430399597,
-0.4106853604,
-0.5203571916,
0.8555694222,
-0.100205645,
-0.2516269684,
0.4405435324,
-0.3254629374,
-0.3342182338,
0.2794931531,
0.59957546,
0.9526050687,
-0.3857040703,
0.5576204062,
0.5108527541,
0.115474239,
-0.0642681941,
0.2907284498,
-0.237888515,
-0.6835163236,
-0.4851205647,
-0.6641134024,
-0.3409418166,
-0.1052062362,
-0.7590918541,
0.7037724853,
-0.3310936987,
-0.1590917557,
0.1144601181,
-0.4663335085,
-0.6640425324,
0.159370929,
0.2975531816,
0.793381691,
-0.691357851,
0.7678658962,
0.9437025189,
-0.4056506455,
-0.1864723116,
-0.0873661339,
0.0457932837,
-0.3795323372,
0.53620857,
0.3993356526,
-0.3091457784,
-0.1140079722,
-0.1376111954,
-0.9368800521,
1.0540591478,
0.5265926719,
0.0096963737,
-0.0123181241,
0.3430934846,
0.3992666006,
-0.0852909461,
0.4466535151,
0.5354221463,
0.3121639788,
0.2028427124,
-0.7799299955,
-0.000237918,
-0.0619047172,
0.1156430095,
0.5231065154,
-0.3679138422,
1.21699965,
-0.0725663602,
-0.3372711539,
-0.3956477344,
0.3432996273,
-0.0603555962,
0.4533422291,
0.8152210116,
0.4686941206,
0.2960549593,
-0.0290222075,
0.8377185464,
0.2056722939,
0.6424510479,
0.8440274,
-0.2726384401,
1.0320961475,
0.5639061332,
-0.6234105825,
0.1170611084,
0.2817365527,
0.2571787238,
0.7373174429,
-0.1379114389,
-0.2857854962,
-0.2241679728,
-0.0627316907,
-0.4256228209,
0.5717413425,
0.0058339154,
-0.1001806706,
-0.6104518771,
0.3168166578,
0.117931664,
0.127455458,
-0.4432546794,
0.49437958,
-0.1216393113,
-0.6744955182,
0.7345430851,
-0.2773549259,
0.7844187021,
-0.7392124534,
-0.0821110159,
-0.3437372148,
0.505120337,
-0.1848489791,
-0.8882589936,
0.7487263083,
-0.1747612506,
-0.0629891604,
-0.6217730641,
0.9314645529,
-0.4793757796,
-0.5480592847,
0.5728564262,
0.2334701717,
0.2202765942,
-0.4282678366,
-0.6102022529,
0.1422172934,
-0.0006520948,
-0.3406204283,
0.0885447264,
0.0316007249,
0.2357049137,
0.3316878676,
0.3927826881,
0.0354908556,
0.2540626824,
0.2028153092,
1.0053192377,
-0.9068111181,
-0.193300277,
-0.6796082258,
0.4155533016,
-0.2293381542,
-0.2979219556,
0.815228045,
0.7002039552,
0.6427229047,
-0.2778955698,
0.7604213357,
0.0866620094,
0.5143120885,
-0.4874631166,
0.2772966623,
-0.7176761031,
-0.094143711,
-0.5615884662,
-1.0817748308,
-0.3429726064,
0.2724111676,
-0.0607902855,
-0.1451815218,
0.9031761289,
0.9294059873,
-0.444509089,
-0.015333008,
0.340244025,
0.0411165804,
0.4090789855,
0.4026859999,
0.5405595899,
-0.8316946626,
1.2281490564,
-0.1155508384,
-0.3494150937,
-0.1593859941,
-0.5943956375,
-0.7074368596,
-0.4997740388,
-0.3839160502,
-0.0003544074,
0.0971872211,
0.4072089195,
0.7855601907,
-0.7920114994,
-0.1044576988,
0.1010483876,
-0.1436574608,
-0.3145863414,
-0.2535082102,
0.5984598398,
-0.5445920229,
-0.6974503398,
0.5889230967,
0.4888810515,
-0.1684728116,
-0.3558534086,
0.1918204725,
-0.1513041705,
-0.013207539,
0.9247176647,
-0.1444897652,
-0.1466258615,
-0.3735541701,
0.0358421579,
0.3085941076,
0.4525114596,
0.9658385515,
-0.7128798366,
0.4635758996,
0.7288675904,
0.7784067392,
1.1520508528,
-0.1666720659,
0.2369600087,
-0.8725708127,
0.3711207211,
0.3182016909,
0.3367453814,
0.2455340475,
0.0945066586,
0.5747805238,
0.4039046168,
-0.4806177318,
-0.7909891605,
0.4134716392,
-0.8771515489,
-0.2272518277,
0.9502092004,
0.1612066031,
-0.0094693117,
0.0932678878,
-0.5035424232,
0.245076701,
-0.2386823744,
0.5143407583,
0.3767709434,
-0.2995979786,
-0.4058347046,
-0.7751899958,
0.4925903082,
0.6355931759,
-0.6790181398,
-0.1168423221,
0.2594094872,
0.310975641,
0.1503638625,
0.7437702417,
-0.4513901174,
0.1688642204,
-0.0108620711,
-0.0766551048,
0.086776413,
-0.4038632512,
-0.2407969534,
0.5924743414,
-0.2720859945,
-0.5767315626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08123v1
|
Memory-efficient Stochastic methods for Memory-based Transformers
| 2023-11-14T12:37:25 | 2023-11-14T12:37:25 |
Vishwajit Kumar Vishnu, C. Chandra Sekhar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Training Memory-based transformers can require a large amount of memory and
can be quite inefficient. We propose a novel two-phase training mechanism and a
novel regularization technique to improve the training efficiency of
memory-based transformers, which are often used for long-range context
problems. For our experiments, we consider transformer-XL as our baseline model
which is one of memorybased transformer models. We show that our resultant
model, Skip Cross-head TransformerXL, outperforms the baseline on character
level language modeling task with similar parameters and outperforms the
baseline on word level language modelling task with almost 20% fewer
parameters. Our proposed methods do not require any additional memory. We also
demonstrate the effectiveness of our regularization mechanism on BERT which
shows similar performance with reduction in standard deviation of scores of
around 30% on multiple GLUE tasks.
|
[
-0.2612813711,
-0.6823804975,
0.3695658743,
0.2712135017,
-0.1628912389,
-0.1621062905,
-0.6817814708,
-0.155762732,
-0.0139090233,
0.2765558064,
-0.468875289,
-0.1422474682,
-0.6369804144,
-0.3004666865,
-0.3327386677,
0.8510693312,
-0.3684095144,
0.1433476657,
0.142642647,
-0.1059715971,
-0.55887115,
-0.3313853145,
-0.9367079735,
-0.5008262396,
0.568538785,
0.4196533859,
0.5441123843,
0.6356663108,
0.4511871636,
0.1208254397,
-0.0490906611,
-0.2497767806,
-0.8202027678,
0.0021563617,
0.0007994953,
-0.6163545847,
-0.1084265932,
-0.0851806551,
0.5801683068,
0.6211594343,
-0.3053263128,
0.047368791,
0.1589195281,
0.5907847285,
-0.592887938,
0.3027143776,
-0.6509048939,
0.305408448,
0.0391117781,
-0.2462376654,
-0.7183583975,
-0.0469397604,
0.056706585,
-0.425149858,
0.5131611228,
-0.0908825994,
0.8917372823,
0.4219382703,
-0.0866999701,
-0.0723051876,
-1.2696416378,
1.3369190693,
-0.4716895223,
0.8106424212,
0.4077725112,
0.5094553232,
0.0998253375,
-0.7198925614,
-0.5524827838,
-0.1680579931,
-0.0566512495,
0.3149988055,
-0.0501862429,
0.1468492448,
0.4383293688,
0.1454385817,
-0.3149358332,
-0.0036998799,
-0.2960952222,
-0.0364522524,
0.2334026545,
-0.0450083688,
-0.1330682039,
0.1861435175,
-0.4719936848,
-0.337793678,
-0.2997157574,
0.1318933964,
0.2681420445,
0.2611740232,
-0.0036932717,
0.2782644033,
0.1769342124,
0.4242646098,
0.372620821,
-0.3452833891,
-0.0802979469,
-0.2720717192,
-0.0983899757,
-0.202336207,
0.4716559649,
0.2596848309,
0.3432565331,
-0.5229721665,
-0.3110797405,
0.1027220041,
0.4601902664,
-0.8785147667,
-0.3727972806,
0.0784916654,
-0.6039460301,
0.0233256407,
-0.3506587744,
-0.6561644077,
0.2080451548,
-0.2648518682,
0.6852906942,
-0.7312759161,
-0.0964525789,
-0.0453445129,
-0.2250843048,
0.2219036669,
0.3228386045,
-1.0806959867,
0.3780719936,
0.467535913,
0.6310133934,
-0.3280730844,
-0.2431871742,
-0.3138744235,
0.3123998046,
-0.4441501796,
0.7361829281,
-0.6831710935,
-0.2186667174,
-0.0931203365,
-0.1493263096,
-0.242133528,
-0.7162286639,
0.3150184155,
-0.5263108611,
0.1602077037,
-0.0965280905,
-0.3494819999,
-0.2585165799,
-0.1286753416,
-0.8010848761,
1.4948430061,
0.4979875982,
-0.5940982103,
0.5110734701,
-0.2834051549,
-0.5123084784,
-0.4628420472,
-0.023732353,
-0.5410277247,
0.1788799465,
0.1360635012,
0.5000591278,
-0.3042115569,
0.2457192838,
0.2025626302,
-0.8771554232,
-0.2159213424,
-0.5415534377,
0.414644748,
-0.0035950656,
-0.6050074697,
-0.0494079106,
-0.7306152582,
-0.2473848462,
0.0893719941,
-0.4757242203,
-0.3396556675,
-0.0096817641,
0.2409491688,
0.2882440388,
0.1613819301,
-0.4130293131,
0.1237255484,
-0.3680361211,
0.2244366705,
0.4956110418,
-0.090804331,
0.5818814039,
-0.4209481776,
0.1900803,
0.3614943624,
0.1451122314,
-0.332449168,
-0.3668737411,
-1.2814879417,
-0.5124648213,
0.4000847936,
0.68645823,
-0.7316312194,
0.4807721078,
-0.2575532794,
-0.4654848576,
-0.3450130522,
0.136834681,
0.3188529909,
0.5071639419,
0.8912551999,
-0.3291656375,
-0.5157741904,
-1.1417810917,
-0.1506711841,
0.0693789572,
-0.4343491495,
0.2629245222,
0.4686049223,
-0.1865178943,
1.0796382427,
-0.2820128798,
-0.1300189346,
-0.3875227571,
0.3359748423,
0.1969444305,
0.6465793252,
0.3268476427,
-0.5052750707,
-0.6564506888,
-0.291737318,
-0.4481236041,
0.1644245982,
-0.5428352952,
0.0592306554,
0.4446066916,
0.528575182,
-0.7117845416,
0.5831155777,
0.2769695818,
0.2251185775,
0.1728850454,
-0.29602018,
-0.0007529309,
-1.0657976866,
0.1039510146,
0.1123536527,
-0.2206211537,
-1.056656003,
-0.1048495248,
0.4419942498,
-0.1100728065,
-0.5094770789,
0.3332955241,
-0.4522926807,
0.2561556995,
-0.3919596076,
-0.145830363,
-0.3283799291,
1.0047754049,
0.2060333639,
0.9052911997,
0.6019183397,
-0.5335153937,
0.014100722,
-0.0047594095,
-0.1162669063,
0.4744156003,
-0.5463935733,
0.2141938061,
-0.6611731052,
0.3586898744,
-1.0748093128,
0.3605847359,
0.1872602701,
0.0394492969,
0.8918656111,
-0.0638559088,
-0.4389537573,
-0.3572396636,
-0.2480869442,
0.4377027154,
0.7871162891,
-0.6205628514,
0.7722736597,
0.1494006515,
-0.0109167062,
-0.6010876894,
-0.739369452,
-0.0530092083,
-0.3883582652,
-0.5075569749,
0.5394635201,
-0.0273350086,
0.1383714527,
-0.1984318942,
-0.5114896894,
-0.284263283,
-0.1471216828,
-0.1811277717,
0.0628675446,
-0.133458212,
0.0771245733,
0.0088836858,
-0.4731987417,
-0.2874359488,
-0.2691355646,
0.7749016881,
0.2510677576,
-0.1234925389,
-0.7174805403,
0.6751553416,
0.2716184556,
0.1308501214,
0.8686921597,
0.7388162613,
-0.4737845063,
-0.4558737576,
-0.8024442792,
-0.4844598472,
-0.4454507232,
0.534593761,
-0.3081665337,
-0.8370994329,
0.4683395326,
-0.1040199175,
0.1171575636,
0.3067556322,
0.5528311729,
-0.0035662802,
0.9587371945,
0.9177719951,
-0.2495847791,
0.5928552151,
-0.3133122027,
0.5539663434,
-0.6559586525,
0.0011566912,
-0.3712511659,
-0.5146728158,
-0.2561453879,
-0.9359279275,
0.187684834,
0.3785327971,
-0.1367508173,
0.8254611492,
-0.3055076301,
0.2793397903,
0.5496439338,
0.2778151929,
0.0923113748,
0.2189849615,
-0.149429217,
-0.1978631914,
-0.9092730284,
-0.2426293641,
1.0387051105,
0.6325739026,
1.0964841843,
-0.3906806111,
0.5501434207,
-0.1825260818,
0.3634191751,
-0.9387142658,
0.4160665274,
-0.0826506391,
-0.4050415158,
-0.507869184,
-0.5262931585,
-0.7552462816,
0.1268222034,
-0.0769769624,
-0.7526039481,
0.0916028097,
0.0758136883,
-0.3470389843,
0.4250892997,
-0.6502410173,
0.5910426378,
0.0924077705,
-0.1921061426,
-0.5002614856,
-0.5898606777,
0.0511411056,
-0.3549740016,
-0.202782765,
0.1757559478,
-0.1193858534,
0.9013232589,
-0.226661697,
0.7534917593,
-0.4154211879,
-0.0578642786,
0.2095221877,
-0.2704705894,
0.862513423,
-0.1258451641,
0.0175460856,
0.480640173,
-0.414915055,
-0.5510359406,
-0.6835919619,
0.2800885737,
-0.6022078395,
-0.3888846636,
-0.1839637309,
-0.9910047054,
-0.4954014719,
0.0912770554,
0.3617054224,
0.2522803545,
0.0499467365,
0.3341391981,
0.8887485862,
-0.1811961532,
0.7111228704,
0.4032697082,
0.5379293561,
-0.2090079933,
0.6897460818,
0.3435105979,
0.301916033,
0.5313686728,
0.0852823555,
-0.0074025299,
-0.450951159,
-0.1095734164,
0.3046972454,
-0.5442528725,
0.0115235634,
-0.8004220128,
-0.2565209568,
-0.1461888701,
-0.2029191405,
-0.7275078297,
-0.5023977757,
0.0288090352,
0.1659961045,
0.1299277544,
0.2067078799,
0.1782514006,
0.5635930896,
-0.6180651784,
0.4986749887,
0.5330990553,
0.5320487618,
0.228564173,
-0.6508206129,
-0.602817595,
-0.1045908704,
-0.2503989637,
-0.600127697,
0.2593460083,
0.2316371053,
0.757458508,
0.4645695388,
-0.1758126169,
0.9804166555,
-1.0386962891,
0.604227066,
0.2026347369,
-0.8304539919,
0.3243362904,
-0.1033370942,
0.1806904823,
0.5641131997,
0.6143292189,
-0.4046476781,
-0.6174122095,
-0.548017621,
-1.0524061918,
0.7877976894,
0.3629262149,
0.1941924989,
0.083562322,
0.3798169494,
0.1385988295,
0.0904913843,
-0.3499836922,
-0.5592401624,
-0.1882388294,
-0.3841720521,
-0.2281082124,
-0.467192471,
0.0119596692,
-0.1468477547,
0.6852772832,
-0.0345674492,
0.7453974485,
-0.0206875205,
-0.218578741,
-0.294500947,
0.2218365073,
0.7353358865,
0.4444839954,
-0.2416387051,
-0.0121225817,
0.6277034283,
-0.6518216729,
0.140807122,
-0.0246157628,
-0.3280741274,
0.2499915063,
-0.0043720934,
0.8215583563,
0.6701146364,
-0.4974504709,
0.3886010349,
-0.1898672879,
-0.2566378415,
-0.3488075733,
-0.0364845209,
0.2172120959,
0.3558463752,
0.598259151,
0.2343516052,
-0.1014124006,
-0.3294310272,
0.54679811,
0.3975484669,
-0.5847614408,
-0.2714218795,
0.6517349482,
-0.2330629826,
-0.3348887265,
0.5117031932,
0.1392617822,
-0.2455744296,
0.3234326541,
0.898520112,
0.8744060993,
-0.4870578051,
-0.2014360875,
0.4787274897,
0.3515686095,
-0.5905955434,
0.1882361323,
-0.2051995695,
-0.6159876585,
-0.4458300173,
-0.5143396258,
-0.4848149419,
0.1680949926,
-0.7119609714,
0.2737068832,
-0.4397812784,
-0.1529477537,
-0.354213506,
-0.1621287912,
-0.6479918361,
0.1534366161,
0.1188766658,
1.156134963,
-0.8276821971,
1.1695387363,
0.2798821032,
-0.1027484089,
-0.7859464884,
0.3304268718,
-0.4570195973,
-0.6259809732,
0.6981925368,
0.4240910709,
-0.0043231226,
0.0260784123,
-0.1212021038,
-1.0345964432,
0.9615610838,
0.1666028053,
-0.5783615708,
-0.1785444915,
0.1645474583,
0.4587959647,
-0.2132025808,
0.3870363832,
0.7913506627,
0.5234013796,
-0.03714009,
-0.8864510059,
-0.0391066633,
-0.1314950287,
0.6012432575,
0.4041557014,
-0.8099799752,
0.7656928897,
0.1640423387,
-0.4903367758,
0.019397743,
0.998370111,
0.0928994194,
0.0268803518,
0.7439136505,
0.7079402208,
0.5322148204,
-0.052083496,
0.6646131277,
-0.7462688088,
0.661649704,
0.8411440253,
-0.2327225059,
0.8285096884,
0.6522979736,
-0.1353847533,
0.3696267307,
0.0045309369,
-0.0867326632,
0.6077262759,
0.1652594507,
-0.1680171639,
-0.2627622783,
0.2283736318,
-0.0685660467,
0.2260245532,
0.1935726702,
-0.162881583,
-0.4638352692,
0.268969804,
0.1254169494,
-0.1134526581,
-0.1349631399,
0.5217041969,
0.0683394074,
-0.5586131215,
0.8749119639,
0.1862291396,
1.057633996,
-0.6473882794,
0.0480713286,
-0.1989714801,
0.3328787684,
0.1656254828,
-0.2243612409,
0.4824561179,
-0.0602743886,
-0.3186994195,
-0.5421046019,
0.5666652322,
-0.732643187,
-0.4509112835,
0.2149938941,
0.1118828207,
0.0734250546,
0.0343110487,
-0.4886917472,
-0.309720695,
-0.3545414209,
-0.4576356113,
0.3326885998,
0.108785592,
-0.0807531923,
0.5271803737,
0.4091859162,
-0.0802853853,
0.0801443085,
0.0881703198,
0.7441522479,
-0.8351812363,
-0.5520167947,
-0.5415194631,
0.4742454886,
0.0808222145,
-0.0353063196,
0.8301408291,
0.7223161459,
0.9155557752,
-0.2325226218,
0.6625465155,
0.1381937563,
0.7521657944,
-0.5134983063,
0.607398212,
-0.3592530191,
0.0372944027,
-0.1557799876,
-1.0640294552,
-0.300657779,
0.916569829,
-0.1084212288,
0.3507547379,
1.0758792162,
0.9993956089,
-0.1978604347,
-0.0964439809,
0.3648222387,
0.0902419612,
0.0869503394,
0.8849546909,
0.5694003701,
-0.8070204854,
0.682792902,
-0.6503999233,
-0.3767280579,
-0.2338947505,
-0.624897778,
-1.1944948435,
-0.401917398,
-0.2254500687,
-0.1729894131,
-0.0466902442,
0.7450894117,
1.0055878162,
-0.9949135184,
-0.326117456,
-0.0648738295,
-0.3241798282,
-0.6745787859,
-0.1943404824,
0.3181302547,
-0.6592948437,
-0.9014316201,
0.6228951216,
0.4243563116,
-0.0990272313,
-0.2366489172,
0.0558924712,
0.0525038764,
0.3489222527,
0.6493753791,
0.0444044881,
-0.501352489,
-0.5688080788,
0.1529308856,
-0.2199002355,
0.3981425166,
1.0262506008,
-0.7469366789,
0.1275141686,
0.5528129935,
0.4411823452,
0.8207471371,
0.0303544942,
0.5245214701,
-0.7178388834,
0.5832161307,
0.224730283,
0.2572598755,
0.0867798328,
-0.3373320997,
0.3311987221,
0.2380333692,
-0.4309366345,
-0.5007380247,
0.3025618196,
-1.0840719938,
-0.2709706426,
1.105561614,
0.0440710001,
-0.2888820767,
-0.2393974662,
-0.0841296092,
0.496134907,
-0.4186252654,
0.9913130999,
0.4434894323,
-0.0836781934,
-0.3501198888,
-0.7012289166,
0.4521950185,
0.5973682404,
-0.4038799107,
-0.0644810647,
0.0590690523,
0.3491875827,
0.2623632252,
0.548193574,
-0.0038001116,
0.175929904,
0.1667898297,
0.1881519705,
0.1306982487,
-0.7062502503,
-0.3986512125,
0.2216528207,
-0.3241388798,
0.0761110336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08117v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08117v1
|
Insights into Classifying and Mitigating LLMs' Hallucinations
| 2023-11-14T12:30:28 | 2023-11-14T12:30:28 |
Alessandro Bruno, Pier Luigi Mazzeo, Aladine Chetouani, Marouane Tliba, Mohamed Amine Kerkouri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) across diverse AI
applications is proof of the outstanding achievements obtained in several
tasks, such as text mining, text generation, and question answering. However,
LLMs are not exempt from drawbacks. One of the most concerning aspects regards
the emerging problematic phenomena known as "Hallucinations". They manifest in
text generation systems, particularly in question-answering systems reliant on
LLMs, potentially resulting in false or misleading information propagation.
This paper delves into the underlying causes of AI hallucination and elucidates
its significance in artificial intelligence. In particular, Hallucination
classification is tackled over several tasks (Machine Translation, Question and
Answer, Dialog Systems, Summarisation Systems, Knowledge Graph with LLMs, and
Visual Question Answer). Additionally, we explore potential strategies to
mitigate hallucinations, aiming to enhance the overall reliability of LLMs. Our
research addresses this critical issue within the HeReFaNMi (Health-Related
Fake News Mitigation) project, generously supported by NGI Search, dedicated to
combating Health-Related Fake News dissemination on the Internet. This
endeavour represents a concerted effort to safeguard the integrity of
information dissemination in an age of evolving AI technologies.
|
[
-0.4064035416,
-0.9598588347,
0.7608202696,
0.2055131495,
-0.1280835271,
0.0636449754,
-0.151954934,
-0.8407247663,
0.2676255405,
0.8251254559,
-0.4921987355,
-0.4006456137,
-0.6962273717,
0.1648360491,
-0.5156734586,
0.8590971828,
0.0373041108,
0.2567066252,
-0.445646435,
-0.0017581695,
-0.5824858546,
-0.7690885067,
-0.6037628055,
-0.4441188574,
0.5981219411,
0.2469185144,
0.6822750568,
0.2836593091,
0.441499114,
0.2594805956,
0.0541605838,
0.5139734149,
-0.4501092434,
0.397341162,
0.2152231932,
-0.7626004219,
-0.1695197821,
-0.1551261693,
0.3782228231,
0.7593876123,
-0.1155904457,
-0.264677763,
0.1442092508,
0.7042672038,
-0.3999418914,
-0.1370503902,
-0.6223976016,
0.368227452,
-0.119092837,
-0.5503517389,
-0.4316466451,
-0.410455972,
-0.0933920294,
-0.2639621794,
0.1747766584,
0.2371353656,
0.6267707348,
0.6601819992,
-0.2241189927,
-0.7076022625,
-0.948795855,
0.5894680023,
-0.5145252347,
0.3449588418,
0.4383771718,
0.2851949334,
-0.305533886,
-0.5531839728,
-0.6660115719,
-0.3016625643,
-0.0877290815,
-0.2024169117,
-0.2318511307,
0.1430821419,
0.1565605402,
0.2500040829,
-0.7887989879,
0.3018494844,
-0.487313211,
-0.4991976917,
0.5438280106,
0.1087998897,
0.4836502373,
-0.2608404756,
-0.0133000417,
0.2122673988,
-0.7449212074,
-0.5065364242,
0.2856340408,
0.1507742852,
0.3587539494,
0.6766274571,
-0.1268640906,
0.3800297379,
-0.1567752361,
-0.1553998142,
0.2155751288,
-0.1063516214,
-0.2235543132,
0.4232517481,
0.5321981907,
0.2680081725,
0.5007517338,
-0.4173087776,
-0.2391632497,
0.282247901,
0.7756994367,
-0.6249134541,
-0.1423414648,
0.397048384,
-0.6940734386,
-0.4534532726,
0.1172491983,
-0.8454493284,
-0.7878482342,
-0.1814983636,
0.5887179971,
-0.1367741972,
-0.1288840771,
0.1476112604,
-0.07451915,
0.1162318811,
0.3212363422,
-0.6183813214,
0.278996408,
0.7263612151,
0.738648057,
-0.3362371027,
-0.3410823345,
-0.4680081904,
0.0740409046,
-0.3950481117,
0.8299512863,
-0.2820487916,
-0.2925487161,
0.2768508792,
0.0193501376,
-0.0539969914,
-0.9231871367,
0.4549146891,
-0.3768745065,
0.3715420663,
-0.1791606247,
-0.4027651548,
-0.370680213,
0.2932638824,
-0.5163311958,
0.6632584929,
-0.1859927624,
-0.6955232024,
0.0621290244,
-0.5329604745,
-0.6422626376,
0.0476603396,
-0.361358285,
-0.4462087452,
0.4551322162,
0.0494878478,
0.5839602351,
-0.2309879661,
0.3218559027,
-0.0287602115,
-0.6056189537,
0.339256078,
-0.6781214476,
0.3512575328,
0.3484521508,
-0.5709604025,
0.3616144061,
-0.5118541718,
-0.258967787,
0.1255694181,
0.0794338062,
-0.3438007236,
0.1001558974,
-0.1855083704,
0.0406930596,
0.0303834993,
-0.007574039,
0.0362997316,
-0.4358094037,
0.4136810303,
0.6708478332,
0.2299966961,
0.2190296203,
-0.7001027465,
0.515325129,
0.206937775,
0.2981936634,
0.0712344721,
-0.5405083299,
-0.8174692988,
0.0656972155,
-0.0691739768,
0.6900498867,
-0.8367499709,
0.4352309704,
-0.2099038512,
-0.5093984604,
-0.582781136,
-0.011459698,
0.0575528666,
0.4676671922,
0.3050548434,
0.110067673,
-0.3892683983,
-0.8520802259,
-0.1244892254,
-0.322265923,
-0.0575653501,
0.2555287182,
0.4234559536,
-0.7921223044,
0.3613814414,
-0.3446435034,
-0.5683901906,
-0.349776566,
0.2619023621,
-0.1892096996,
0.2876664102,
0.4163221121,
-0.9404745102,
0.1580875367,
-0.1387243718,
-0.9179643393,
-0.2156691253,
-0.5195353627,
0.1063737944,
0.5148559213,
0.5841815472,
-0.8137429953,
0.610422194,
0.3797684908,
-0.2001958936,
0.6481159925,
-0.0729747042,
0.2159822881,
-1.0376271009,
-0.0816629231,
-0.2845925093,
-0.0947486684,
-0.6997246146,
-0.1370457113,
-0.4743003845,
0.1915052831,
-0.2912441194,
0.3449981809,
-0.3607706428,
-0.1737557799,
-0.4562353492,
0.2488644123,
-0.1170609891,
0.2258223593,
-0.1626447141,
0.6283435822,
0.5919846296,
-0.7751210928,
0.3816889226,
0.1086754352,
-0.2498751432,
0.2794742584,
-0.2964271605,
0.0721015185,
-0.2571744025,
0.0311013833,
-0.7884616852,
-0.4173610806,
0.6521481872,
-0.6662287116,
0.177134946,
0.5277291536,
-0.7910407782,
-0.2633892298,
-0.4236486554,
0.312448591,
0.3969797492,
-0.6828783154,
0.6944614649,
0.4569700062,
0.0562811457,
-0.4591497183,
-0.8776835203,
0.2276970446,
-0.4559013844,
-0.4594280422,
0.2123799026,
-0.1198176593,
-0.5790514946,
0.0314320661,
-0.1753479838,
0.242637381,
0.4205586612,
0.4499274492,
0.1839071214,
-0.1123094335,
0.2934329212,
0.1197590008,
0.1189166456,
0.4286162853,
-0.1863385141,
0.9140110016,
0.088880159,
-0.4056641161,
-0.565377295,
0.3800461888,
0.6485966444,
0.1687608808,
0.9772005081,
0.4771060348,
-0.7661232352,
-0.5564599633,
-0.691280067,
-0.5536444783,
-0.4321203232,
0.3941991925,
-0.1775743663,
-0.8095983267,
0.5007983446,
-0.0413505323,
-0.2605313957,
0.4316519797,
0.6214843392,
-0.1110179871,
1.1306773424,
0.4885785878,
-0.2232960314,
0.1480719745,
-0.0256379899,
0.3936420977,
-0.4796283245,
-0.5876313448,
-0.5767230988,
-0.2116010189,
-0.7367967367,
-0.4029237628,
0.2630612254,
0.0046990602,
0.0993807614,
-0.1525749713,
-0.6874763966,
0.3769016266,
0.3956931531,
0.0254587922,
0.2804427147,
0.199744001,
0.2861876786,
0.1062897369,
-0.5931886435,
-0.6796478629,
0.8240247369,
0.4433036745,
0.811242342,
-0.1031463221,
0.7038601637,
0.6453884244,
0.3353477716,
-0.7992948294,
0.6793919802,
0.088111937,
-0.3400500417,
-0.2801075578,
-0.5023038983,
-0.8595370054,
0.1186147928,
-0.2944585979,
-0.8248869777,
0.0724532455,
-0.0751855969,
-0.2132525295,
0.4509790838,
-0.2970730364,
0.5611566305,
-0.487836659,
-0.1231954619,
-0.5131852031,
-0.5030266643,
0.4331849515,
-0.1813530028,
0.1901722103,
0.0859657601,
0.1515435725,
0.6572897434,
-0.0968703404,
0.8769730926,
0.0160369501,
-0.2169342637,
0.1613243818,
0.1242161542,
0.2364696115,
0.0486810021,
0.0838401839,
0.4789192677,
-0.1719231606,
-0.1057781279,
-0.5004481077,
0.8340855837,
-0.8809024692,
-0.8959280252,
-0.6373748183,
-0.5503473282,
-0.2042849064,
0.0207498334,
0.5532481074,
0.1151359454,
-0.0287100803,
0.0959685221,
0.7850010395,
-0.3691144288,
0.1545680165,
-0.0001524979,
-0.5988223553,
-0.2229082733,
1.0767520666,
0.1773908883,
0.0710235238,
0.0878119171,
-0.0757730678,
-0.2159992307,
-0.8484135866,
-0.1182853803,
0.5698453784,
-0.8606135249,
-0.1626651883,
-0.7465469241,
-0.7259879708,
-0.5887348056,
-0.0114467992,
0.0527253337,
-0.2237761319,
-0.8319396377,
-0.1849220991,
0.0220317952,
0.9832648039,
0.0430710651,
0.1924195588,
-0.6019386053,
0.4704807103,
0.1477282941,
0.2533253431,
0.1241305619,
-0.4860440493,
-0.0726587027,
-0.0979182199,
-0.3339788616,
-1.0223996639,
0.5058988333,
-0.0596254058,
0.7194372416,
0.6599009633,
0.1697745919,
0.5419508815,
-0.295476526,
0.7739065289,
-0.1409090012,
-0.6374453902,
0.5364959836,
0.0363532938,
-0.1996366382,
0.5004954338,
0.5434919,
-0.7496513128,
-0.6430092454,
-0.405520916,
-0.6162608266,
0.3595139682,
0.2203936875,
0.13924101,
-0.0512528941,
0.5778424144,
0.237481609,
0.3765413761,
-0.7665973306,
-0.2061058879,
-0.0897871405,
-0.2064366341,
0.1163557321,
-0.4449400008,
-0.1112127602,
-0.0378848873,
0.7490790486,
-0.0308080949,
0.2848786712,
0.2748913467,
-0.3370551765,
-0.1868865639,
-0.0259154513,
0.7994758487,
0.5288465023,
0.1115174666,
0.3299024403,
-0.0012503318,
-0.395929724,
-0.0628745556,
-0.0955123454,
-0.2825413346,
-0.0423717871,
0.5044066906,
0.8667371869,
-0.2501028478,
-0.8789705634,
0.2873344421,
-0.0955655649,
-0.2206772268,
-0.637009263,
0.2867649794,
-0.269708842,
0.2743914723,
0.60280478,
0.2029398978,
0.3032598197,
-0.7598335743,
0.2140070796,
0.5019238591,
-0.2479193062,
-0.3228797019,
0.6879671812,
-0.004982092,
-0.6085672379,
0.7986103892,
0.021930648,
-0.7141197324,
0.541433692,
0.4615594149,
1.0972111225,
-0.2581735253,
0.3042886853,
-0.0619399548,
0.5229609013,
-0.2238134295,
0.2029675841,
0.0575573631,
-0.8001720905,
0.0237258151,
-0.663577497,
-0.2241064459,
0.4195801318,
-0.3780946434,
0.2265023589,
-0.2633314729,
0.0426866226,
-0.2075856179,
-0.1560143232,
-0.3420583606,
0.1185192913,
0.6779167056,
0.6123270988,
-0.954184711,
0.7593688965,
0.318410784,
-0.2786550522,
-0.240098238,
0.6994562745,
-0.010133489,
-0.6195536852,
0.3615761101,
0.6508152485,
-0.1796941906,
-0.1218212619,
-0.5579194427,
-0.4047737122,
0.7927391529,
0.1353440881,
-0.4097400904,
-0.3226041496,
0.5785657763,
0.7085949183,
-0.4460261464,
-0.1584456861,
0.5988599658,
0.5897363424,
0.0402248353,
-0.6528542042,
0.0671563968,
-0.0771912485,
-0.1423562616,
-0.0315245241,
-0.5134153366,
0.4115350544,
-0.3332850039,
-0.2042901367,
0.083397083,
0.5741500854,
0.2888154984,
0.5753206611,
0.4834725261,
0.2376652509,
0.9703956842,
-0.1085949615,
0.9238727093,
-0.2521577179,
-0.2708961368,
0.7802317739,
-0.3050708473,
0.7130221128,
0.6828956604,
0.3218727112,
0.3276475072,
0.6768778563,
-0.2168751061,
0.3563562036,
0.4102812111,
-0.1229744926,
-0.1416096389,
-0.3170178533,
-0.2646352351,
0.3757168651,
0.5295919776,
-0.2541360855,
0.2246147096,
0.4963231981,
-0.1403482109,
0.2448764443,
-0.196497649,
0.8375503421,
0.0950601697,
-0.6995226741,
0.485750854,
-0.2460715175,
0.6913623214,
-0.2252496481,
-0.0902954042,
-0.3520514667,
0.071533151,
-0.2933008075,
-0.4121125937,
0.6298137307,
-0.1902130395,
-0.2113801241,
-0.1098098606,
0.7971907258,
-0.3214389682,
-0.5619763136,
0.5594561696,
0.5732046962,
0.4446118176,
-0.325768888,
-0.3785798848,
0.4266088605,
0.0205592997,
-0.1933112144,
0.2075484097,
0.5318806767,
-0.2969867885,
0.9104939103,
0.3414341807,
0.5185984969,
0.0482083075,
0.1797491908,
0.8828769326,
-0.714224875,
-0.2416272312,
-0.9001541734,
0.0862743258,
0.0433726832,
0.0347328596,
0.7583894134,
0.5754925013,
0.6332926154,
0.0183806978,
0.7341381311,
0.2730156183,
0.3470347822,
-0.5592008233,
1.2109304667,
-0.8791156411,
0.5686694384,
-0.0770067722,
-0.9562910199,
-0.6027165055,
0.4812051952,
-0.1585126072,
-0.0161587037,
0.661562562,
0.8675435781,
0.4400708079,
0.0763468146,
0.4954150915,
0.4663148522,
0.28446123,
0.3068235815,
1.1635569334,
-0.1957191825,
0.5937753916,
-0.2342946827,
0.1253331304,
-0.4237295687,
-0.3724567294,
-1.1207029819,
-0.7133319974,
-0.2937164903,
-0.3874127567,
0.1108714268,
0.7625520229,
0.4572755694,
-0.9183441401,
-0.0922814533,
-0.1693089157,
0.3224838376,
-0.0169981103,
-0.2606892884,
0.2874915302,
-0.4611805081,
-0.5958768129,
0.2642827332,
0.3455398977,
0.2321722209,
-0.6624339223,
-0.1603231728,
0.1484330595,
0.2113099843,
0.4504671395,
0.0261945482,
-1.1108425856,
-0.243059352,
0.1350698918,
-0.1666414589,
0.1514789015,
0.6350876093,
-0.9019989371,
0.1500948966,
0.367390573,
0.7251628041,
-0.0206335168,
-0.0215260219,
0.3602752686,
-0.362721771,
0.157636568,
0.5189093947,
0.1032372266,
0.3855607212,
-0.7362459898,
0.4309689105,
0.2897394001,
-0.5820903182,
-1.3166073561,
-0.0057117105,
-0.6195735931,
-0.6446276307,
0.9851192236,
0.5292257667,
-0.3029642403,
-0.1919774264,
-0.3727969229,
0.3552607,
0.0162738468,
1.5331879854,
0.6976534128,
-0.2229247689,
-0.1849815398,
-0.7043265104,
0.8014672995,
0.4533297718,
-1.1216247082,
0.1571418196,
0.5048586726,
-0.182433933,
0.3852601647,
0.2865875065,
0.0620554313,
0.1400567591,
-0.244029507,
-0.0056520854,
0.1925783902,
-0.7836201787,
-0.4814991951,
0.3507940173,
0.0378789529,
-0.0832177922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08110v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08110v2
|
Improving Hateful Meme Detection through Retrieval-Guided Contrastive Learning
| 2023-11-14T12:14:54 | 2024-06-04T23:06:36 |
Jingbiao Mei, Jinghong Chen, Weizhe Lin, Bill Byrne, Marcus Tomalin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Hateful memes have emerged as a significant concern on the Internet.
Detecting hateful memes requires the system to jointly understand the visual
and textual modalities. Our investigation reveals that the embedding space of
existing CLIP-based systems lacks sensitivity to subtle differences in memes
that are vital for correct hatefulness classification. We propose constructing
a hatefulness-aware embedding space through retrieval-guided contrastive
training. Our approach achieves state-of-the-art performance on the
HatefulMemes dataset with an AUROC of 87.0, outperforming much larger
fine-tuned large multimodal models. We demonstrate a retrieval-based hateful
memes detection system, which is capable of identifying hatefulness based on
data unseen in training. This allows developers to update the hateful memes
detection system by simply adding new examples without retraining, a desirable
feature for real services in the constantly evolving landscape of hateful memes
on the Internet.
|
[
-0.6615038514,
-0.5727372169,
0.1852104068,
-0.0075183469,
-0.5529763103,
0.0746275112,
0.0132803004,
-0.4746145308,
0.7916420102,
0.2408951372,
-0.5674350262,
-0.2762660682,
-0.8747119904,
0.0332280509,
-0.4161689579,
0.7875268459,
0.159558773,
-0.0262135454,
0.1986827254,
-0.6350219846,
-0.2028125525,
-0.5038486719,
-0.5335426927,
0.0427387841,
0.6964442134,
0.4643162191,
0.5231984854,
0.5450243354,
0.4248975515,
0.1898618937,
0.0867530853,
0.0553711653,
-0.6694216728,
0.3542441428,
-0.3743068576,
-0.2622721493,
0.1966960579,
0.3009127975,
0.0808581337,
0.0181412753,
-0.2263319641,
-0.2416667491,
-0.0228397753,
0.335999608,
-0.9755423069,
-0.4439668953,
-0.8051843047,
0.3773657978,
-0.0186346415,
-0.1698452383,
-0.3404068947,
-0.4144490659,
0.0306022428,
-0.6030604839,
0.1703284532,
0.1017920151,
0.4315934181,
0.2189284861,
-0.366651237,
-0.4855769575,
-0.2846771479,
1.1115034819,
-0.5322613716,
0.6802315116,
0.0624019578,
0.2583452165,
0.2051189393,
-0.4125915766,
-0.5135506392,
0.039832864,
0.2460548878,
0.06058589,
-0.5075628161,
-0.3839838803,
0.1699172258,
0.5284715891,
-0.64971596,
0.2682825923,
-0.3009848595,
-0.3106844425,
0.2071292251,
0.1583345681,
0.213775143,
-0.4050489664,
-0.6958814263,
-0.2504542768,
-0.5560529232,
-0.5612031221,
0.3342525065,
0.1242148653,
-0.0200263616,
0.2952479124,
0.0874624997,
0.2671957612,
0.0616658293,
-0.0026221641,
0.2768526971,
0.2536257803,
-0.1055529565,
-0.2982358336,
0.5119060874,
0.6911661625,
0.2167900056,
-0.0773792714,
-0.1763972789,
0.4496936202,
0.6535432935,
-1.0605323315,
-0.3084278405,
-0.2992228568,
-0.3681658506,
-0.5368314981,
-0.2988636494,
-0.9023507237,
-0.7898263335,
0.0143066039,
0.3226792216,
-0.6836481094,
-0.1748926193,
-0.3029355109,
-0.4927177131,
0.0154243261,
0.5631301403,
-0.715690732,
0.1035515517,
0.3163002133,
0.6167141199,
0.0262152739,
0.0244372301,
-0.4449007511,
0.0585637018,
-0.1376093179,
0.7233124971,
-0.6957883835,
-0.1004202142,
0.188810125,
0.0117261866,
0.2946989238,
-0.9885833263,
0.5878181458,
-0.7254909277,
0.0174644664,
-0.0492155105,
-0.6124833822,
-0.3398226798,
0.6414909363,
-0.6097836494,
0.5149486661,
0.3357366621,
-0.7837107182,
0.3572841287,
-0.3333954513,
-0.178623572,
-0.0704253018,
-0.1647886783,
-0.4990716875,
0.0321575664,
-0.053592585,
0.5596534014,
0.0855303928,
-0.206935361,
-0.6287347674,
-0.4743039906,
0.1056508049,
-0.2940717041,
0.5860281587,
0.6173706651,
-0.3488849401,
-0.2408545166,
-0.6847419143,
-0.2479780614,
0.2471264452,
-0.272121489,
-0.9564648271,
-0.1886083186,
0.0345255546,
0.3379498124,
-0.100611344,
-0.7661155462,
-0.2142114043,
-0.1209140345,
0.1849295497,
0.9935529828,
-0.0510438643,
0.2143269032,
-0.3291730285,
0.5214691162,
0.3212199807,
0.2810146809,
0.2295298725,
-0.1231732294,
-0.6076432467,
-0.1734143645,
-0.3761315048,
0.4181444645,
-0.8415995836,
0.1421741098,
0.1429515779,
-0.345608741,
-0.1935836375,
0.2324280888,
0.4198399782,
0.3697092533,
0.7715699077,
-0.5003474355,
-0.8713475466,
-1.0024880171,
-0.3118642271,
0.1239079759,
0.0814546272,
0.5492332578,
0.3999825418,
-0.5216866136,
-0.0375467874,
-0.5186908245,
-0.423381567,
0.2371581793,
0.1697638929,
-0.3015378118,
0.5390869379,
0.7094762325,
-0.8687711954,
-0.5108781457,
-0.3798684776,
-0.6547566056,
-0.2819076777,
0.2860971391,
-0.1069702953,
-0.2694371343,
0.7549420595,
0.3232461214,
0.1760266721,
0.5810524225,
-0.5006757975,
0.5313237906,
0.4650616348,
0.5940374732,
-1.0003740788,
-0.2402788103,
-0.0242723152,
-0.2270624936,
-0.327073276,
0.1211321428,
0.0696261078,
-0.1572569311,
-0.5650221705,
0.4506273866,
-0.1971348822,
0.223807618,
-0.2563009262,
0.2630108595,
0.058273416,
0.454746455,
-0.4009071589,
0.6621857882,
0.1338205189,
-0.5846460462,
0.2056437582,
0.3240309954,
-0.1781936884,
1.0087662935,
0.049730666,
0.1475651264,
-0.0568237752,
-0.1128993332,
-0.7371526957,
-0.0026766511,
0.6585473418,
-0.4103530645,
0.2637529373,
-0.2492239028,
-0.2228679508,
-0.2007490695,
-0.5996357203,
0.6938118935,
0.4327996671,
-0.9323162436,
0.2493574917,
0.3554373085,
0.2183158547,
-0.7903577089,
-0.6608790159,
-0.0870369822,
-0.2984099686,
-0.2392255515,
0.2881630957,
-0.1523431689,
0.0126920277,
0.0117886141,
-0.1364934742,
-0.394356966,
0.1799981445,
0.3595119715,
-0.3402078748,
-0.0369639769,
0.2321074307,
0.0923878551,
0.0955431834,
-0.1718158871,
-0.160200268,
0.4347809553,
0.0731804371,
-0.3652828932,
-0.2021052539,
0.5338506699,
0.6789373159,
0.0621809289,
0.5229887962,
0.6806012392,
-0.4309333265,
-0.5607036352,
-0.9144783616,
-0.1537702978,
-0.471745491,
0.3219449818,
-0.0238836948,
-1.4110187292,
0.5207761526,
-0.1401934475,
-0.1359794289,
0.3088802397,
0.1421235353,
-0.2783953249,
0.7037126422,
0.5319023132,
-0.0395082682,
1.0208179951,
-0.1058992967,
-0.0185628608,
-0.8690549731,
-0.2206579149,
-0.493170023,
-0.5286718011,
-0.2689804733,
-0.8649773598,
0.2154222429,
-0.1055541486,
-0.2928493619,
0.1547006071,
-0.6485390067,
0.4718943834,
0.2728327215,
0.5124326348,
-0.0165559668,
0.4209986925,
-0.293608278,
-0.6941302419,
-0.2286471575,
-0.2112955153,
0.8793272376,
0.061524272,
1.0334917307,
0.4103315473,
0.5848323107,
0.7857974172,
0.593211472,
-0.763064146,
0.4358867109,
-0.7228301764,
-0.3985165656,
0.0938000381,
-0.313141644,
-0.8038107753,
0.2112237811,
-0.1854655296,
-0.1835672408,
0.1657828242,
0.2770442963,
0.0878530666,
0.6333223581,
-0.4580403864,
0.7173011899,
0.0804851875,
-0.3503559828,
-0.9399776459,
-0.2478698343,
0.0420845821,
0.282366693,
0.1890953481,
-0.0734835938,
-0.0876950845,
0.938849926,
-0.2280343771,
0.9148966074,
-0.4696560502,
0.1208908334,
0.3465228975,
0.5340229273,
0.1341013312,
-0.553665638,
-0.1641844958,
-0.2100380659,
-0.4484072626,
-0.5895687342,
-0.7097505927,
0.932997942,
-0.5364913344,
-0.2643282413,
-0.0902488977,
-0.2212321907,
-0.1398202032,
0.0828961059,
-0.0643821433,
0.3929442763,
-0.6765671968,
0.3648579419,
0.9625780582,
-0.2049948424,
-0.0044214348,
0.5853824615,
-0.038170103,
-0.4991532564,
1.0065803528,
0.0787218735,
-0.1749971956,
0.4399975538,
0.058506038,
-0.3215084374,
-0.5847459435,
-0.3499942422,
0.1728994399,
-0.9542618394,
-0.4270448089,
-0.5831366181,
0.133693561,
-0.1377398968,
-0.5617914796,
-0.2929665744,
-0.2581611276,
-0.4231114984,
0.0517537184,
0.2992291749,
0.9576001763,
-0.4481783211,
0.2240750641,
-0.6276601553,
0.167929858,
0.5605580211,
0.6614557505,
0.3654178083,
-1.1613651514,
-0.2985311449,
-0.2679634392,
-0.5902478099,
-1.0331144333,
0.3683826625,
-0.032343667,
0.3839727938,
0.8312043548,
0.0498616733,
0.7542915344,
-0.5227482915,
0.5211817026,
0.3923264146,
-0.624810338,
0.622476995,
-0.0359983109,
-0.2322468907,
0.5285078287,
0.7513412237,
-0.6013932824,
-0.5176424384,
-0.5511884689,
-0.3555055261,
0.4278137088,
-0.3461788297,
0.4541704655,
-0.4590807855,
0.4577340186,
0.2406770885,
0.0608650558,
-0.8826455474,
-0.2181883156,
-0.5789771676,
-0.0174024832,
0.1721722633,
-0.6414705515,
-0.0722677559,
-0.1703156531,
0.8562351465,
-0.024580285,
0.168777898,
0.1003395692,
-0.4591400027,
-0.1453595012,
0.2727322876,
0.2988650203,
0.2563952506,
-0.2728952169,
0.4734964669,
0.0160956997,
-0.4258143306,
0.3676384985,
-0.1866716892,
0.0827575848,
0.0161896888,
-0.1666108966,
0.3827708066,
0.4692849219,
-0.7047801614,
0.9525083303,
-0.0065744757,
-0.162080735,
-0.2629872561,
0.1555964649,
-0.1407304406,
0.4619119465,
0.1686067134,
0.1914579868,
0.4527471066,
-0.1752146035,
0.6246184111,
0.4781646132,
-0.6552731395,
-0.360550642,
0.4456201494,
0.2631385028,
0.0442288853,
0.4467466176,
-0.3299459815,
-0.8232578039,
0.4077457488,
0.6243954897,
0.683344245,
-0.5825237632,
0.2943025529,
0.6802752614,
0.3693540096,
0.4607908726,
0.1566012353,
-0.0762583539,
-0.8224093914,
0.2545909584,
-0.593611896,
-0.5842463374,
0.5193089247,
-0.5040797591,
-0.0148679493,
-0.9035608768,
0.2399978936,
0.0083235018,
-0.0464038476,
-0.5512154102,
0.5163888335,
0.3513175845,
0.82480371,
-0.9627873898,
0.0597928055,
0.6435889006,
-0.3510419726,
-0.4718123972,
-0.225308463,
0.1313912868,
-0.996612072,
0.249128595,
0.3090798259,
-0.2688189745,
-0.2622328401,
-0.9140684605,
-0.3960379362,
0.7233544588,
0.1884156466,
-0.3748748302,
0.5686581135,
-0.5099043846,
0.5847646594,
-0.4773771763,
0.1540353149,
-0.0822575688,
-0.1256834865,
0.0102326758,
-0.0498002209,
0.3462649286,
-0.1740624011,
-0.1441660076,
0.2830092609,
-0.7672662735,
0.7885670066,
0.0091638938,
-0.2344275117,
-0.1662618667,
0.4426906705,
-0.1465017051,
0.3138723671,
0.7487704754,
0.960963428,
0.5791749954,
0.3200366497,
0.7607787848,
0.2067331821,
0.1792301983,
1.0728048086,
0.1511015892,
0.9441136718,
0.5041344762,
-0.0032279622,
0.8692908287,
0.3282496631,
-0.3741890788,
0.570710063,
0.4178700149,
-0.6748127937,
-0.3334442973,
-0.4531596303,
-0.3491883874,
0.2510433793,
0.5587255955,
-0.6484609246,
-0.5604344606,
0.2230794877,
0.1446876824,
0.3503427207,
-0.2478747815,
0.7477621436,
0.0535450615,
-0.1723213494,
0.8722628355,
0.0209544655,
1.1085816622,
-0.4307933152,
-0.1365992874,
-0.2061950713,
0.124515675,
-0.2693089247,
-0.6518621445,
0.4471717179,
0.1771185994,
-0.3930844367,
0.0987850353,
0.8162986636,
-0.3467331529,
0.1969699264,
0.7746474147,
0.6024795175,
0.3961555064,
-0.2174374759,
-0.7829735875,
0.1743164062,
0.1880036145,
0.1040260568,
0.5858033299,
0.5753134489,
0.1342424452,
0.5068767071,
0.5322860479,
-0.2966108322,
0.1965327412,
0.3840092123,
1.0641634464,
-0.783290267,
-0.5137332678,
-0.6596999168,
0.0263991207,
-0.082712993,
-0.0791874379,
0.4964407384,
0.5135529041,
1.0186008215,
-0.2005704492,
0.747046411,
-0.1813110858,
0.8695289493,
0.0239105187,
0.5192921162,
-1.0981422663,
-0.007460102,
-0.2324118316,
-0.5250881314,
-0.4055380225,
0.6684406996,
-0.100015372,
-0.2408237308,
0.4016403556,
0.9497057796,
-0.4327802062,
0.1307082772,
0.7205498815,
0.4803279936,
0.3431631327,
0.5414148569,
0.9811869264,
-0.621445477,
0.8858200908,
-0.5447689891,
-0.3083929121,
-0.5315957665,
-0.6545697451,
-0.8274672627,
-0.4022706747,
-0.3090822697,
-0.4079626799,
0.1284455806,
0.7893845439,
0.4646572769,
-0.9971567988,
0.0904129744,
0.2853158414,
0.2222141773,
0.1445675343,
-0.2371515483,
0.0344769619,
-0.1880639493,
-0.4696107507,
0.3678949475,
0.3828359544,
0.1488547176,
0.061883036,
-0.0978657901,
-0.491727531,
0.173922345,
0.7575740218,
0.3640173376,
-0.6340425014,
-0.5831823945,
-0.3233725131,
-0.3206553161,
0.2216708511,
0.8032387495,
-0.6240683198,
0.5585436225,
0.0256513059,
0.8115609288,
0.2524832487,
0.0384886265,
-0.1535078585,
-0.9428737164,
0.2408251315,
0.51878196,
0.3544643521,
0.5541474223,
-0.2452746928,
0.4255824685,
0.5325502753,
-0.3442124724,
-0.5215495825,
0.3228165805,
-0.7925284505,
-0.3897875547,
0.5140788555,
-0.2061183155,
0.1182236969,
-0.3302161694,
-0.149821043,
0.241201818,
-0.6255370975,
0.9450388551,
0.5350778699,
0.0476230942,
-0.1991271228,
-0.0098059159,
0.3825189173,
0.8207761645,
-0.4560338855,
0.0306440517,
0.8464842439,
0.3989417553,
0.2837563455,
0.5359254479,
-0.218978852,
0.5379880071,
0.2834008038,
0.1168827116,
0.0500720888,
-0.2571598887,
-0.3491868377,
0.3585335612,
-0.2566360533,
-0.2504013181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08107v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08107v2
|
SAIE Framework: Support Alone Isn't Enough -- Advancing LLM Training with Adversarial Remarks
| 2023-11-14T12:12:25 | 2024-03-01T00:42:58 |
Mengsay Loem, Masahiro Kaneko, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can justify or critique their predictions
through discussions with other models or humans, thereby enriching their
intrinsic understanding of instances. While proactive discussions in the
inference phase have been shown to boost performance, such interactions have
not been extensively explored during the training phase. We hypothesize that
incorporating interactive discussions into the training process can enhance the
models' understanding and improve their reasoning and verbal expression
abilities during inference. This work introduces the SAIE framework, which
facilitates supportive and adversarial discussions between learner and partner
models. The learner model receives responses from the partner, and its
parameters are then updated based on this discussion. This dynamic adjustment
process continues throughout the training phase, responding to the evolving
outputs of the learner model. Our empirical evaluation across various tasks,
including math problems, commonsense reasoning, and multi-domain knowledge,
demonstrates that models fine-tuned with the SAIE framework outperform those
trained with conventional fine-tuning approaches. Furthermore, our method
enhances the models' reasoning capabilities, improving both individual and
multi-agent inference performance.
|
[
-0.6788961291,
-0.6874393821,
0.6719961762,
0.1385521889,
0.1119860038,
-0.1809102446,
-0.398909688,
-0.3387024403,
-0.0722860321,
0.3796674609,
-0.5700189471,
-0.2940351963,
-0.8414465189,
-0.0598638728,
-0.0577693954,
1.0904303789,
0.0890668705,
0.5891440511,
-0.2715225816,
-0.1970928311,
-0.2606583238,
-0.2964672744,
-1.1907293797,
-0.5656513572,
0.7017682791,
0.1094457582,
0.9188340306,
0.3658090234,
0.3335568309,
0.4208468497,
-0.1219928563,
0.4499877989,
-0.4622023702,
0.6042861342,
-0.4455578327,
-0.708599627,
-0.6694605947,
-0.0998712108,
0.5403528214,
0.6864697337,
-0.1266123056,
-0.218317613,
0.3176850975,
0.6585951447,
-0.6042281985,
0.2579205036,
-0.7834223509,
-0.1095084772,
0.118062526,
0.3074008524,
-0.4091878235,
0.0459127501,
0.3362518549,
-0.7200340629,
-0.0523600169,
-0.2232028097,
0.764318049,
0.4825995266,
-0.2622509599,
-0.2496458441,
-0.6301403642,
0.5273587108,
-0.8376827836,
0.1953546852,
0.3498503566,
0.3692883849,
-0.5802201629,
-0.5407342911,
-0.3572583795,
-0.3574959934,
0.0408488028,
0.2238442302,
-0.2605662048,
0.412615329,
0.3083010614,
0.0855124071,
-0.0987856761,
0.1186495423,
-0.1461724639,
0.0241218843,
0.7123094201,
-0.0716372207,
0.0578363389,
0.138881579,
-0.2536364794,
0.0480757952,
-0.4688470364,
-0.1248675883,
0.3672432601,
0.1193499491,
-0.0296328869,
0.3442100585,
0.013566372,
0.4294282794,
0.0853021517,
0.2468104511,
-0.2625541091,
-0.0391708016,
-0.3521181941,
-0.4623733461,
0.8161050081,
0.295892179,
0.4291466773,
-0.3208448887,
0.0193151273,
0.1206457689,
0.4538330138,
-0.7306985855,
-0.3602869809,
0.1309504807,
-0.1384448111,
-0.1735692769,
0.0902034566,
-0.8093163967,
-0.8635821939,
-0.4437791705,
0.0561665855,
-0.3742319643,
-0.2678257525,
0.0055514718,
-0.3065131605,
0.1455613375,
0.8292428255,
-0.7045196891,
0.3826109171,
0.517912209,
0.4756802619,
0.0062512257,
-0.4266176522,
-0.5131053925,
0.2494431436,
-0.365894407,
0.8151787519,
-0.4870690107,
-0.3357592821,
-0.341065675,
-0.1074956879,
-0.428689301,
-0.4749563932,
0.4125311077,
-0.5125956535,
0.2526999712,
-0.4314237237,
-0.7606726289,
-0.1555453986,
0.3075729012,
-0.6025673747,
0.8235604167,
-0.0793975443,
-0.7511912584,
0.1739749908,
-0.8316673636,
-0.0887787119,
0.0470978133,
-0.530715704,
-0.3752774,
0.1387624294,
0.6083056927,
0.5130296946,
-0.4114879966,
0.4308764935,
-0.8001116514,
-0.1931342185,
0.3421846032,
-0.634996891,
0.504275322,
-0.0892817304,
-0.4489401579,
0.4511597455,
-0.406953007,
-0.1156202778,
0.1888554841,
-0.2103371471,
-0.0669845715,
0.2043484598,
-0.3352342844,
0.0469833873,
0.0553273223,
-0.2260330766,
0.173868075,
-0.595680356,
0.2594481409,
0.9014875889,
0.1161416322,
0.6554545164,
-0.4023922682,
0.5482004881,
-0.156539619,
0.074717842,
-0.1548997164,
-0.3710893989,
-0.9678122401,
-0.2503170967,
0.1945147067,
0.6247845292,
-0.7641710043,
0.0876392573,
-0.0642864779,
-0.2977502048,
-0.647992909,
0.5706635714,
0.4359571636,
0.2342317104,
0.3585175574,
0.2774386406,
-0.6327395439,
-0.8954916596,
-0.0912939981,
-0.3020499349,
-0.0948405787,
0.4515089691,
0.3177219033,
-0.0233014356,
0.777692616,
-0.2362700105,
0.1328074038,
-0.4311964512,
0.0569270886,
-0.3542954028,
0.2842495441,
0.6215704679,
-0.788094759,
-0.4093076885,
-0.0556047633,
-1.0787869692,
0.0943715274,
-0.2032729387,
-0.4661355615,
-0.0242510363,
0.595631659,
-0.4789589345,
0.3112855256,
0.4586982429,
-0.1543508172,
0.3239567876,
-0.1296195537,
0.0999613926,
-1.030170083,
-0.3212896883,
0.1588837951,
-0.3619325757,
-0.4683396518,
0.2616134882,
-0.2751103044,
-0.1179483384,
-0.2031134665,
0.5806893706,
-0.3949488401,
0.3195630908,
-0.5993642211,
0.4435727,
0.0112625165,
0.5397920609,
0.2635344863,
0.7929579616,
0.8405441642,
-0.4916110635,
0.4675291181,
0.1055008769,
0.0993918926,
0.7687891722,
-0.7485890985,
0.1409507692,
-0.0110120075,
0.3068186939,
-0.8712998033,
-0.3150681257,
0.151893869,
-0.4552148879,
0.4173451364,
-0.2351603061,
-0.2784849405,
-0.1797059327,
-0.3719305396,
-0.1235591695,
-0.0426863916,
-0.4210369885,
0.9002014995,
0.4087960124,
-0.2409731001,
-0.5305892825,
-0.4468961954,
0.3783233464,
-0.2588247359,
-0.8820089102,
0.0374445654,
-0.240480721,
-0.4865548015,
-0.0319490135,
0.0600776784,
0.0917580053,
0.3974927068,
0.2052125633,
0.3005720973,
-0.3413747251,
0.1819220185,
0.0113058649,
-0.1642560512,
0.2770797908,
-0.1831729114,
0.2419082224,
-0.4100799561,
-0.6000046134,
-0.1703533232,
0.4708802402,
0.5835312605,
-0.0241233502,
1.0296583176,
0.5682036877,
-0.5163514018,
-0.4354002476,
-0.6548816562,
-0.324278146,
-0.479185909,
0.5075399876,
-0.3619331717,
-0.9456308484,
0.533874929,
-0.2245233953,
0.1705378145,
0.2120308131,
0.393103689,
-0.3047305346,
1.3215123415,
0.5502673984,
-0.0503244065,
0.4126253724,
-0.1362267584,
0.003973587,
-0.941580534,
-0.094413355,
-0.1442353129,
-0.2364929318,
-0.250955224,
-0.3878048658,
0.3286727667,
0.3648063838,
-0.3080602586,
0.058193408,
-0.0575838499,
0.3933520913,
0.3146429658,
0.4021545053,
-0.116575323,
-0.0513941124,
-0.0497838929,
-0.1798262298,
-0.8062406778,
-0.6228095293,
0.8686825037,
0.5642713904,
0.7624982595,
0.2109529972,
0.3322114944,
0.1363103986,
0.5069402456,
-0.7993165255,
0.6833927631,
-0.1593319625,
-0.5049526095,
-0.2138533294,
-0.5057199597,
-0.6471185684,
0.4273655415,
-0.3157050312,
-0.8209493756,
0.0718709603,
0.1211788505,
-0.3012656868,
0.4907262027,
-0.6090831757,
0.8143857718,
-0.2281516194,
-0.6155655384,
-0.3282610774,
-0.5176252723,
0.2506234944,
0.1278980374,
0.1265953034,
0.0243550092,
-0.0661176071,
0.5484352708,
-0.4148163795,
1.0896806717,
-0.2912344038,
-0.2063001841,
0.31547001,
0.0164496284,
0.5298894644,
0.2238213122,
-0.3125169277,
-0.2458794117,
-0.4500287771,
-0.4906550646,
-1.0613455772,
0.6715900302,
-0.7700030208,
-1.0829986334,
-0.1118403599,
-0.67742908,
-0.6338707805,
-0.0730253384,
0.0087890737,
0.0897718593,
-0.2512819469,
0.3156478703,
0.8755179048,
0.0520693585,
0.1457276791,
0.4093521833,
-0.0431334041,
-0.6071833968,
0.4688634574,
-0.1333541721,
0.5381948948,
0.0047506029,
0.2645249665,
-0.1612843573,
-0.5537313819,
-0.6317507029,
0.2870208025,
-0.9840199947,
-0.1707645804,
-0.6280521154,
-0.3121476769,
-0.2875154912,
-0.3173342645,
-0.4492582977,
-0.288857311,
-0.1721697301,
-0.2516387105,
0.4054260254,
0.8876363039,
0.1336672455,
0.5183287263,
-0.546980679,
0.0955711603,
0.3418362141,
-0.0114619071,
0.190656662,
-0.5496680737,
-0.214772135,
0.2845732868,
-0.2786695659,
-0.9683866501,
-0.0760306492,
0.2281771153,
0.9481758475,
0.2713379562,
0.0340608023,
0.7662838697,
-0.1816246361,
0.7038407326,
-0.025550684,
-0.8073729277,
0.7572041154,
-0.4844089746,
0.1656604856,
0.5233397484,
0.2832342684,
-0.0617480204,
-0.7342652082,
-0.6102583408,
-0.7751134634,
0.6861166358,
0.1720850319,
0.0816611052,
0.0501909219,
0.4563626945,
-0.3369490504,
0.2003711909,
-0.8037384748,
-0.1975290775,
0.1287395954,
-0.1919333041,
0.2592428625,
-0.0861038566,
-0.3521596491,
-0.0567312464,
0.9701559544,
-0.4513374269,
0.1271630675,
-0.0088851163,
-0.0121293562,
-0.071094729,
0.3248841166,
0.2198192477,
0.5918841958,
0.1790530831,
0.0392908528,
0.638831377,
-0.0957050174,
-0.0858022198,
0.4651945233,
0.1157315746,
-0.4717959166,
0.5006200075,
1.1092547178,
0.4519046247,
-0.461305052,
0.6227712035,
-0.3675830364,
-0.3545367718,
-0.0094035314,
0.484465152,
0.5118317008,
0.7209174633,
0.1216320917,
0.4902480245,
-0.0580841154,
-0.2237584442,
0.3162222207,
0.6316941977,
-0.3735336065,
0.0237136409,
0.6883653402,
0.1016096249,
-0.0456583723,
0.3840997815,
-0.2858695686,
-0.6602987647,
0.6720352769,
0.4432129562,
0.7787169814,
-0.119802773,
0.1440869719,
0.076639317,
0.1941248477,
-0.1358301789,
0.0451649912,
-0.0522820354,
-0.8351989985,
-0.4638034999,
-0.4524835348,
-0.5750051141,
0.2351782918,
-0.7318958044,
0.2583238184,
-0.510422349,
-0.2208393365,
0.0410985015,
-0.0113822091,
-0.5068051219,
0.0907240734,
0.3816605806,
0.8516798019,
-0.751717031,
0.7720866799,
1.0348372459,
-0.4326993823,
-0.748442173,
0.0781785175,
0.083198525,
-0.6296200156,
0.4638359249,
-0.0352276973,
-0.5784243345,
-0.1577480286,
-0.5889832973,
-0.7257917523,
0.9369843006,
0.8922916055,
-0.3611714542,
-0.0940370336,
-0.1819614917,
0.6548539996,
-0.4375277162,
0.5148188472,
0.1624652743,
0.3552927673,
0.3940326869,
-0.731556952,
-0.0760469213,
-0.4283145666,
-0.0064764912,
-0.1161902994,
-0.6506648064,
0.4451202154,
-0.2600549757,
-0.0691007748,
0.1940915138,
1.0404436588,
0.3159490228,
0.1706278473,
0.5479625463,
0.2731092572,
0.8981561661,
0.0234737899,
0.9020082951,
-0.2015720904,
0.0485169962,
1.4097967148,
-0.3170237243,
0.8055741787,
0.1749127656,
-0.210840866,
0.4838479757,
0.4705670774,
0.0088832695,
0.0076402957,
0.1149028018,
-0.4653777182,
-0.5726863146,
-0.0166383516,
-0.2215708643,
0.2831602693,
0.7319461107,
-0.3676901758,
-0.3496756852,
0.2397651523,
0.2621382475,
0.4318554699,
-0.2669956982,
0.9190574288,
0.2054078877,
-0.8525848389,
0.3724052608,
0.0042784605,
0.6021925807,
-0.7931728363,
0.0225149617,
-0.1322420239,
0.5063704848,
-0.2091457397,
-0.6828696728,
0.3649525642,
0.1128120273,
-0.2823876143,
-0.070152089,
0.7206248641,
-0.5546742082,
-0.4793351293,
0.796006918,
0.6070249081,
-0.0591658317,
-0.1372645646,
-1.228787303,
0.0047416999,
0.0369088426,
-0.5172297955,
0.5302495956,
0.5352839231,
-0.0009528045,
0.7998757362,
0.4294298291,
0.0920770094,
-0.0400490351,
0.4650128484,
1.2267969847,
-0.029771613,
-0.1458312273,
-0.9690950513,
0.5531340837,
-0.3630325794,
0.0137227932,
0.8487880826,
0.2234607637,
0.5795032978,
0.2344064415,
0.9877036214,
0.2816239595,
0.3092768192,
-0.5407503843,
0.4914967716,
-0.4585976005,
0.5889406204,
-0.0233343877,
-0.5489454269,
-0.226233542,
0.9400211573,
-0.5431103706,
0.2247851938,
0.4693928957,
0.8142892718,
-0.1137664393,
0.3746699989,
0.1975785345,
0.1703142375,
0.5088598728,
0.5404174328,
0.8159627914,
-0.4424359202,
0.54111588,
-0.0650143698,
-0.3430075943,
0.3757753372,
-0.860696435,
-1.2130544186,
-0.1102022007,
-0.5109142065,
-0.4696386755,
0.4304353595,
0.9995354414,
0.815612793,
-0.85812217,
-0.2469637096,
-0.3392701149,
0.0558385178,
-0.0981943533,
-0.2214650214,
0.160751164,
-0.6417905092,
-0.8853818774,
0.80730021,
0.1016357839,
-0.072743997,
-0.45125705,
-0.2963846028,
-0.3138899803,
0.2581573725,
0.2539078891,
0.1316954195,
-0.5565732718,
0.0704981163,
-0.0643019006,
-0.035457667,
-0.0864961371,
0.655864656,
-0.5334268212,
0.4199976623,
0.2133817971,
0.9704172611,
0.3818547726,
-0.0073985266,
1.0632474422,
-0.6343607306,
0.0567003265,
-0.0192189142,
0.5693103671,
0.4744230509,
-0.6004759073,
0.3440680504,
0.2581458688,
-0.6381465197,
-0.5603812337,
0.3527159691,
-0.5313538909,
-0.4743895531,
1.0884708166,
-0.7085520029,
-0.0599415861,
-0.0811372176,
-0.3072223961,
0.1976366639,
-0.422442168,
0.2903586626,
1.0810219049,
-0.214917317,
-0.2749358416,
-0.6861150265,
0.4822380841,
0.5630941391,
-0.8961001039,
0.303794682,
0.3734234571,
0.0454591364,
0.0027977927,
0.4041142166,
0.1030093879,
0.1222660393,
0.151882872,
-0.4641797543,
-0.2484897077,
-0.4362981617,
-0.3694924116,
0.1389358193,
0.3056058288,
0.0887063667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08106v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08106v2
|
Carpe Diem: On the Evaluation of World Knowledge in Lifelong Language Models
| 2023-11-14T12:12:02 | 2024-04-20T07:11:39 |
Yujin Kim, Jaehong Yoon, Seonghyeon Ye, Sangmin Bae, Namgyu Ho, Sung Ju Hwang, Se-young Yun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The dynamic nature of knowledge in an ever-changing world presents challenges
for language models trained on static data; the model in the real world often
requires not only acquiring new knowledge but also overwriting outdated
information into updated ones. To study the ability of language models for
these time-dependent dynamics in human language, we introduce a novel task,
EvolvingQA, a temporally evolving question-answering benchmark designed for
training and evaluating LMs on an evolving Wikipedia database. The construction
of EvolvingQA is automated with our pipeline using large language models. We
uncover that existing continual learning baselines suffer from updating and
removing outdated knowledge. Our analysis suggests that models fail to rectify
knowledge due to small weight gradients. In addition, we elucidate that
language models particularly struggle to reflect the change of numerical or
temporal information. Our work aims to model the dynamic nature of real-world
information, suggesting faithful evaluations of the evolution-adaptability of
language models.
|
[
-0.2553485334,
-1.0951598883,
0.6175196171,
-0.0912736431,
-0.1075578406,
0.3228990436,
-0.1807132363,
-0.5037254095,
-0.2869680524,
0.3767832518,
-0.6294090748,
-0.3032676578,
-0.4980701506,
-0.1268851757,
-0.3171509206,
0.7865954638,
0.0298393387,
0.1120572016,
-0.5337520838,
-0.3847643435,
-0.3032902181,
-0.2957802415,
-0.8232188821,
-0.3269147277,
0.4462510645,
0.2666843534,
0.7342177033,
0.5262246728,
0.2415674478,
0.2059743255,
-0.2172343731,
0.2206470668,
-0.648167789,
0.3842959106,
-0.360039562,
-0.3865089417,
-0.2447986454,
-0.0453665406,
0.9438499808,
1.071698308,
-0.2862457931,
0.2735108435,
-0.1261763275,
0.5379180908,
-0.5078125,
0.0564791895,
-0.9147774577,
-0.1659276336,
0.010422579,
-0.0361306146,
-0.0202180278,
-0.4762887061,
0.4630584121,
-0.4774912298,
-0.0153888268,
-0.1289756149,
0.7911925316,
0.2896755338,
-0.3273320794,
-0.4304313362,
-0.9025796056,
0.8368504047,
-0.6039500833,
0.6757132411,
0.0136229666,
0.5227472782,
-0.206867218,
-0.7628362775,
-0.7022365928,
-0.5960475802,
0.7930865288,
0.2459556609,
-0.0166194364,
-0.3321322501,
0.0764393881,
0.3243023753,
-0.3636869192,
0.0535348803,
-0.4812023938,
0.1797399223,
0.3628031313,
0.2997502089,
0.8015779257,
0.0217671357,
-0.47478953,
0.1081558987,
-0.6400683522,
0.1221500784,
0.2114538401,
-0.0416857079,
-0.0702996328,
0.1844667494,
-0.1315636635,
0.7940208912,
-0.3613705337,
-0.0462683961,
0.0869753882,
0.0995061025,
0.0269688591,
-0.3941826522,
0.4322203398,
0.6025628448,
0.3472999632,
-0.4835159779,
-0.0870148242,
-0.1705725491,
0.424174875,
-0.2714241147,
-0.0933013335,
0.190912962,
-0.1058808565,
-0.0826425552,
-0.0190967973,
-0.6711408496,
-0.3552750647,
-0.2063542306,
0.5408594608,
-0.462056011,
-0.2249313742,
0.2538386881,
-0.1948384643,
0.3517407477,
0.3979653418,
-0.5024725199,
0.2047908306,
0.7034906149,
0.8499424458,
-0.3745098412,
-0.6012028456,
-0.6005007625,
0.0707990527,
-0.3758773208,
0.8333054185,
-0.4808337986,
-0.3769265413,
-0.0862566978,
0.1871709079,
-0.2859152853,
-0.7801868916,
0.4771206677,
-0.9664872885,
0.0775921419,
-0.3102644086,
-0.6626528502,
-0.0038118132,
0.2928341031,
-0.7156714797,
1.0130110979,
0.2903085351,
-0.4690845311,
0.555030942,
-0.7022634149,
-0.0240317844,
0.2858841419,
0.0834796801,
-0.3222768605,
0.1194249988,
-0.0963555127,
0.064804703,
-0.3891579509,
0.3416979909,
-0.489736259,
-0.2855889499,
0.5254108906,
-0.449356854,
0.7679486871,
0.19872953,
-0.2298612297,
-0.2848572135,
-0.7525107861,
-0.1702912152,
0.1428162754,
-0.7621666193,
-0.1979132295,
0.5459997058,
-0.1748355031,
0.3841610849,
0.3539285064,
-0.6673896313,
0.3462080061,
-0.708858788,
0.4699534178,
0.6547430158,
0.5570099354,
0.305650264,
-0.6595985293,
0.6605080962,
0.04846799,
0.4086254239,
0.0783942565,
-0.5861665606,
-1.0763264894,
0.4478489459,
0.1711009741,
0.61067909,
-0.6391881108,
-0.1004786193,
-0.7196655869,
-0.6038485765,
-0.4562237263,
0.2963295579,
-0.0100503247,
0.2669056058,
0.4627503753,
-0.304587096,
-0.3939359784,
-0.7884397507,
-0.5265750885,
-0.3130516708,
-0.0583022162,
0.2755028307,
0.4272859097,
-0.4326778352,
0.9875471592,
-0.3031720519,
0.4710006416,
-0.1867920607,
0.2546285093,
-0.0981823429,
0.2813498676,
0.348759383,
-0.6293048859,
-0.2837762237,
-0.0375686698,
-0.6847853661,
-0.2279478163,
-0.3636065423,
-0.0608946681,
-0.0167545918,
0.4651711583,
-0.4263127148,
-0.0644233525,
0.379011035,
-0.2128522545,
0.5082759857,
-0.1239569187,
0.1276670992,
-0.911847949,
0.010893072,
-0.1767452061,
-0.2399819344,
-0.5969762206,
0.2196172029,
0.1226778999,
-0.1001327708,
-0.6677066088,
1.1594793797,
-0.5259029269,
0.1654399633,
-0.1806783825,
0.5456953049,
-0.1993499547,
0.2142470777,
-0.1654775292,
0.459713608,
0.5517554283,
-0.9259828329,
0.4788931012,
0.0321533754,
-0.6850018501,
0.4603104293,
-0.3987253606,
0.0386566706,
-0.2756225169,
-0.2264251113,
-0.78155756,
-0.0614652634,
0.0524335131,
-0.5096220374,
0.1048301533,
-0.1334947348,
-0.3015687764,
-0.3365201056,
-0.0550721996,
0.1451810002,
0.5165174007,
-0.3824842274,
0.4609236717,
0.531234622,
-0.2989673018,
-0.3248643279,
-0.4440652132,
0.2065538317,
-0.1743781716,
-0.4491714239,
0.1783590764,
-0.413045615,
-0.6349281073,
-0.1337011456,
-0.3157651722,
-0.118121013,
0.3093099296,
0.0779769346,
0.0272478238,
-0.1556392014,
0.3962698579,
0.0518425368,
0.0833228678,
0.3180220425,
-0.4592972398,
0.3603530228,
-0.0342771634,
-0.4212116003,
-0.0745265037,
0.0375911333,
0.8714058995,
-0.0392993204,
0.8396741748,
0.394426614,
-0.4684893787,
-0.4477379918,
-0.7306498289,
0.2405039519,
-0.427323252,
0.5156234503,
-0.2926655412,
-0.6941550374,
0.7207352519,
-0.2408113927,
0.3683299422,
0.832110405,
0.6144140363,
-0.2506927252,
0.6789012551,
0.5346933007,
0.1428963542,
0.515142858,
-0.1938561648,
-0.1553877294,
-0.7863807082,
-0.2512583733,
-0.1965305209,
-0.1816463768,
-0.1871099174,
-0.6035103202,
0.3981455863,
0.3030695915,
-0.3131201565,
-0.0113314549,
-0.0362027399,
0.3327105343,
0.1289836019,
0.2619802058,
0.3831042945,
-0.249995932,
-0.3565696776,
0.0547018051,
-0.723934114,
-0.5906434655,
1.0915130377,
0.3611529469,
0.7277673483,
0.2084031105,
0.2570732236,
0.4645364583,
0.450310111,
-0.5164715052,
0.4991287291,
0.0226373356,
-0.5261810422,
-0.3748621643,
-0.4881927371,
-0.8932211995,
-0.127766341,
-0.0105795907,
-0.6450271606,
0.0577048771,
-0.0146633796,
-0.261453867,
0.5109154582,
-0.2878966331,
0.8740331531,
-0.4323866367,
-0.3852395415,
-0.1752416939,
-0.5604217649,
0.1364965737,
-0.2687202394,
0.3905546963,
-0.3396649063,
-0.5189059377,
0.8457161784,
-0.2340117991,
0.791033566,
-0.2514165938,
-0.202476576,
0.5275825858,
0.1785802692,
0.2574341893,
0.2918094695,
-0.2407150269,
-0.0923504457,
0.2672289312,
-0.5789167285,
-0.6377443075,
0.6833266616,
-0.8245484829,
-0.5788377523,
-0.2671215832,
-0.3513481617,
-0.5601655245,
-0.1679892391,
0.0558621623,
0.3674551249,
-0.6066450477,
0.0631127357,
0.6738798618,
-0.4626913667,
0.30401811,
0.7715388536,
-0.2000972778,
-0.2704617083,
0.8298299313,
0.2237675935,
0.6408128738,
0.3670120239,
0.1617449373,
-0.3254609108,
-0.4274688959,
-0.7060390115,
0.2009278387,
-1.0497915745,
0.1300994605,
-0.7982724905,
-0.322476238,
0.0851959437,
0.0188160129,
-0.2768889368,
-0.4759041965,
-0.1882973462,
0.1109874025,
0.3124307394,
0.8121666312,
0.0378697067,
0.0274289586,
-1.0226786137,
0.1278598905,
0.6435781121,
0.3674319983,
0.1348810941,
-0.7556959391,
-0.4610199332,
0.3141094148,
-0.2659556568,
-1.0575886965,
0.0330116898,
0.68095541,
1.0681225061,
0.1081165597,
-0.0686153993,
0.4133204818,
-0.3999613523,
1.037122488,
-0.242689684,
-0.8643499613,
0.4464531243,
-0.4017950892,
0.8667553663,
0.5665072203,
0.5794425607,
-0.9737584591,
-0.5084015131,
-0.5400542617,
-0.62571311,
0.2374559492,
-0.2613523304,
0.4844074845,
-0.273589164,
0.7463315725,
0.1759510636,
0.0333286002,
-0.7070867419,
0.1148136705,
0.2049332708,
-0.0478484295,
0.1895774454,
-0.178122133,
0.2135044336,
-0.2726230323,
0.6135470271,
-0.0958160758,
0.0967610478,
-0.0497101769,
-0.451797545,
-0.1346230805,
0.3446834683,
0.5006412268,
1.0949249268,
-0.0617247261,
-0.1396965235,
0.8124495149,
-0.4794962704,
-0.0216332842,
-0.2713469863,
-0.1982204318,
-0.0792178214,
0.4025189579,
0.7451599836,
0.6533676982,
-1.0771548748,
0.38648206,
0.0025533109,
-0.0687579438,
-0.3577101827,
0.3770020306,
0.3751177192,
0.2212142199,
0.46134606,
-0.0620179959,
-0.1836555004,
-0.8043968678,
0.3488044441,
0.3360472322,
-0.5390350223,
-0.3875203431,
0.7798827887,
-0.0383471474,
-0.3448440135,
0.6620987058,
-0.2184425294,
-0.6380290985,
0.4964339435,
0.3047577441,
0.7851855159,
-0.4213845432,
0.117989026,
0.4130259156,
0.2005652785,
0.0689965785,
0.4956253171,
-0.1073775664,
-0.7439652085,
-0.2150871158,
-1.1505278349,
-0.5987195969,
0.1955103725,
-0.4923291206,
0.2406952083,
-0.2235904932,
-0.1569524854,
-0.1979130208,
-0.2312258333,
-0.6933102012,
0.4270392358,
-0.0222259257,
0.9717196226,
-0.753679812,
0.8356324434,
0.7956665158,
-0.3149600029,
-0.1309512109,
0.2980465889,
-0.2101426423,
-0.7229604125,
0.7340509892,
-0.1957687736,
-0.1162307709,
0.1707756072,
-0.4134597182,
-0.851765573,
0.9056473374,
0.2214772701,
-0.3654609025,
-0.1906398535,
0.119764857,
0.6409254074,
-0.2756177187,
-0.0017621823,
0.5618661642,
0.2631522715,
-0.0020908469,
-0.8335135579,
-0.4239676595,
-0.3790168464,
-0.0865766108,
0.1090186164,
-0.5195690989,
0.7885098457,
-0.1812942922,
-0.5412399769,
0.0188569501,
0.5319871902,
-0.007260879,
0.0452793501,
0.6542364955,
0.6202561259,
0.6199834347,
-0.0591604225,
0.6440955997,
-0.5548874736,
0.4552104175,
1.0875242949,
-0.216370225,
1.1620079279,
0.2277584076,
-0.4103191793,
0.6559199691,
0.7701975703,
-0.0673560426,
0.2094864398,
0.39711833,
-0.4952618182,
-0.4546945989,
0.2885726392,
-0.1610647887,
0.388001442,
0.4851344824,
-0.0838828683,
-0.4524006844,
0.2853158414,
-0.1891369373,
-0.0396015793,
-0.1299165338,
0.7394260764,
0.0613930039,
-0.8443858027,
0.7788347006,
0.0107167698,
0.2931545079,
-0.5271360278,
0.014957184,
-0.1808581948,
-0.00559517,
0.1913150996,
-0.6282551289,
0.4711384475,
0.0056498148,
-0.0858640969,
0.0653496981,
0.3304540813,
-0.2754305899,
-0.4614874125,
0.4307115078,
0.8422798514,
0.2819693089,
0.0760699287,
-1.0026432276,
0.196991697,
-0.218807891,
-0.202974245,
0.1779049486,
0.3088692129,
0.0098245647,
1.1137648821,
0.4351944029,
0.1370314956,
0.3824199736,
0.1393272579,
0.7448670864,
-0.6558281779,
-0.4309047461,
-0.8055960536,
0.6032947302,
-0.0010235469,
-0.467369765,
0.5612516403,
0.6981887817,
0.6690644622,
-0.0929929316,
0.8430318832,
0.1357402653,
0.6800791621,
-0.6092646122,
0.9370158315,
-0.9085044265,
0.5249136686,
0.048961971,
-0.979490459,
-0.0122610321,
0.2199365646,
-0.4782177806,
0.1108182445,
0.6681056619,
0.5822818279,
-0.0394877754,
-0.0970026031,
0.3840484023,
0.3670412004,
0.0491254255,
0.6829920411,
1.1172627211,
-0.2465677559,
0.4345370233,
0.1219152212,
-0.2797816992,
-0.0964529365,
-0.7206631899,
-0.6294745803,
-0.9104573727,
-0.5329634547,
-0.1859259456,
0.4243772328,
0.7071938515,
0.4482590556,
-0.6590920091,
-0.2612687349,
-0.0359300263,
-0.0916038305,
-0.2206179351,
-0.2413681597,
0.2607392669,
-0.4779414535,
-0.7542293072,
0.6328824759,
0.4898672104,
-0.0496387854,
-0.5962670445,
-0.0417358801,
-0.3875171542,
0.3584564924,
0.4710834324,
0.5038279891,
-0.8060366511,
-0.3606636822,
0.1395387501,
-0.0478518158,
0.1140141413,
0.438087672,
-0.8555223942,
0.8586483002,
0.4183829427,
0.7269035578,
0.4412565827,
-0.0974338502,
0.7312989831,
-0.2611095309,
-0.4361522794,
0.1949225664,
0.2607851028,
0.430524528,
-0.0332707725,
0.2915649414,
0.4403396547,
-0.7712504864,
-0.6880186796,
0.3039096892,
-0.8586838245,
-0.3420919478,
0.9560035467,
-0.0579935312,
-0.2625023723,
-0.4968556464,
0.1725292057,
0.281942755,
0.1341571808,
0.9113878608,
0.9676433802,
0.019402517,
-0.3388083279,
-1.1632676125,
0.52984339,
0.0744048283,
-0.8633571267,
0.0824017823,
0.324629724,
0.7857658863,
-0.100081034,
0.4757257104,
-0.09500321,
0.4371004999,
0.0290622301,
-0.1340036988,
0.2999003232,
-0.1340477914,
-0.2901425362,
0.1538817286,
0.5695984364,
0.1660120785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08105v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08105v2
|
DiLoCo: Distributed Low-Communication Training of Language Models
| 2023-11-14T12:05:45 | 2023-12-02T14:10:14 |
Arthur Douillard, Qixuan Feng, Andrei A. Rusu, Rachita Chhaparia, Yani Donchev, Adhiguna Kuncoro, Marc'Aurelio Ranzato, Arthur Szlam, Jiajun Shen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have become a critical component in many
applications of machine learning. However, standard approaches to training LLM
require a large number of tightly interconnected accelerators, with devices
exchanging gradients and other intermediate states at each optimization step.
While it is difficult to build and maintain a single computing cluster hosting
many accelerators, it might be easier to find several computing clusters each
hosting a smaller number of devices. In this work, we propose a distributed
optimization algorithm, Distributed Low-Communication (DiLoCo), that enables
training of language models on islands of devices that are poorly connected.
The approach is a variant of federated averaging, where the number of inner
steps is large, the inner optimizer is AdamW, and the outer optimizer is
Nesterov momentum. On the widely used C4 dataset, we show that DiLoCo on 8
workers performs as well as fully synchronous optimization while communicating
500 times less. DiLoCo exhibits great robustness to the data distribution of
each worker. It is also robust to resources becoming unavailable over time, and
vice versa, it can seamlessly leverage resources that become available during
training.
|
[
-0.2354975492,
-0.78940171,
0.3400211036,
0.4781042933,
-0.1361001879,
0.0520402268,
-0.5279726982,
-0.3590413928,
0.3024013042,
-0.1057807729,
-0.8044403195,
-0.2993055582,
-0.5688595176,
0.2668886483,
-0.2707026005,
0.6167806983,
-0.04655293,
0.1702769995,
-0.0455186442,
-0.1307842731,
-0.0905856565,
-0.099406831,
-0.7228581905,
-0.4282860458,
0.3372835219,
0.6733568907,
0.5075564981,
0.6836557388,
0.5763397217,
0.3572401106,
0.0320883803,
0.3790425658,
-0.9158284664,
0.2613112628,
0.3053822815,
-0.6478372216,
-0.6218940616,
-0.0306229759,
0.8175631166,
1.1596013308,
-0.2241995037,
-0.0091150003,
-0.076366283,
0.6171582341,
-0.6891890168,
0.1469401419,
-0.5955647826,
0.2503677905,
-0.0157900061,
0.2022704482,
-0.504267931,
-0.3770582378,
-0.149571985,
-0.7415981293,
-0.0632983893,
-0.1083022058,
0.4220691919,
0.3491915166,
-0.0143377744,
-0.1565603912,
-0.852273643,
1.0786098242,
-0.4560657442,
0.4314204454,
0.3978086412,
-0.0115185594,
-0.0453944243,
-0.4460337758,
-0.4809730351,
0.0166557916,
0.1787616909,
0.196272403,
-0.297601223,
0.1377067566,
-0.0104743149,
0.2171567976,
-0.1418798417,
0.550383985,
-0.1921838671,
0.0685894638,
0.5204865932,
0.1061022505,
-0.1701357216,
0.6324178576,
-0.1125655323,
0.0274389591,
-0.5840662718,
-0.3563369513,
0.3491397202,
0.4796516895,
-0.6056343317,
0.1338552088,
-0.3070111275,
0.5233500004,
0.0956471115,
-0.3215826452,
0.3335840404,
-0.2183841616,
-0.3111757934,
-0.1484517306,
1.1037442684,
-0.2535186708,
0.0784243271,
-0.0587801784,
-0.4078733027,
-0.0409424156,
0.0355091877,
-0.6704773307,
-0.167258665,
0.3052893281,
-0.2425062805,
-0.3749248385,
-0.2720812559,
-0.6141753197,
-0.0742536113,
-0.2193612456,
0.1358870566,
0.2357898951,
-0.1615056694,
-0.3709590435,
0.2696814239,
-0.2703441978,
0.2664649487,
-1.2403554916,
0.6916549802,
0.672904253,
1.1889734268,
-0.1635734141,
-0.5861644745,
-0.8879609704,
-0.1309078485,
-0.4972520471,
0.3814418912,
-0.4688364267,
-0.3650661707,
0.1686203927,
-0.0740397871,
-0.3836580515,
-0.4943021536,
0.3324734569,
-0.4968544543,
0.0486149602,
0.3006056547,
-0.5055713654,
0.4281399846,
0.3479347527,
-0.4828151166,
0.6081754565,
0.0144227287,
-0.9717914462,
-0.0866191834,
-0.6117681861,
-0.5761948824,
-0.1354157776,
-0.2130945325,
-0.8183629513,
-0.0672985166,
0.2049727589,
0.6143469214,
-0.3239736259,
-0.024613969,
-0.5400213003,
-0.6716037393,
-0.0415385179,
-0.2082403451,
0.9294734001,
0.2760024369,
-0.4114095569,
0.0162025187,
-0.5449653864,
-0.2170614898,
0.0782230124,
-0.6172242165,
-0.1016862765,
-0.173446402,
-0.4223103225,
-0.3622390032,
0.3006297052,
-0.5403930545,
0.3272849917,
-0.6792936325,
0.3943747282,
0.7472289205,
-0.1582346857,
0.7511157393,
-0.0654753,
0.683055222,
0.0803776011,
0.5853856802,
-0.0055675353,
-0.3523501456,
-0.9461548328,
-0.6070943475,
-0.184555918,
0.4214549363,
-0.5565663576,
0.1376680285,
-0.3622055352,
-0.5608528852,
-0.5748488307,
0.4126041532,
0.19426395,
0.223509714,
-0.0740642473,
0.0052615725,
-0.3714015484,
-0.686827302,
0.3771266639,
-0.0263702013,
0.1680244654,
0.500076592,
0.3287250698,
-0.6454898119,
0.4904053509,
-0.5222204328,
-0.275442034,
-0.2348771691,
-0.204825595,
0.6014367938,
0.1894401312,
0.2057055682,
-0.4000549316,
-0.7326789498,
0.522900641,
-0.7058317065,
0.008316854,
0.1372488886,
0.1436125189,
0.1149821877,
0.2980640531,
-0.4666806459,
-0.2740527391,
1.0736218691,
0.6143685579,
0.4056069255,
-0.4027985334,
-0.135510996,
-1.0223808289,
-0.0281756688,
-0.4087269604,
-0.4471571445,
-0.4701454937,
-0.1849401444,
-0.2599073052,
-0.4741385877,
-0.4277139306,
0.3352550566,
-0.5714225173,
-0.2195319086,
-0.4025781155,
0.3373481035,
-0.3204168677,
0.4086060226,
-0.1064681187,
0.7971596122,
1.137162447,
-0.5300481319,
0.7156231403,
0.4399899244,
0.3280669749,
0.4345397055,
-0.686060667,
0.4853789508,
-0.0296183527,
0.0766407773,
-0.3992066979,
-0.3040057421,
0.0340913162,
-0.3191068769,
0.1190327406,
-0.2139930427,
-0.3235461712,
-0.3332723975,
-0.3150824606,
0.4429711699,
0.4352610111,
-0.6637020707,
0.220996365,
0.6474119425,
0.2526664436,
-0.7235522866,
-0.704541564,
-0.2437339872,
-0.2121329457,
-0.6157861352,
-0.1524841785,
-0.0930325165,
-0.2715402842,
-0.4604286849,
0.1916071475,
-0.5029102564,
0.3651176393,
0.420938015,
-0.1044029966,
0.0072971433,
0.1948067844,
0.0378122181,
-0.0546514131,
-0.1488619298,
-0.5055553317,
0.4927449226,
-0.1561626792,
-0.3377414942,
-0.8230699897,
0.317170918,
0.3414769173,
0.1412980407,
1.1098253727,
0.3484199345,
-0.3908617795,
-0.8396243453,
-0.0303558763,
-0.4684925675,
-0.5479167104,
0.1201182008,
-0.2825386524,
-1.186887145,
0.4475997686,
-0.3413323164,
0.0791318342,
0.0412462428,
0.8163659573,
-0.0918383151,
0.5661318898,
1.0213963985,
-0.5438762307,
0.6686974764,
-0.358453542,
0.2929459512,
-0.2550021112,
0.1156997383,
-0.4949296713,
-0.022007864,
-0.7052257061,
-0.5076106191,
0.4938629866,
0.0215217583,
-0.4268779457,
0.4149299264,
-0.3671827316,
0.7157542706,
0.5595625639,
0.0463971272,
0.2979806364,
0.2335921079,
-0.2322094291,
0.2531891763,
-0.9991549253,
-0.042312149,
0.8052820563,
0.6654459238,
0.9522953629,
-0.1456515789,
1.1419657469,
0.3119171858,
0.2710848153,
-0.6723602414,
0.3767392635,
-0.1898685396,
-0.2502275407,
-0.2318037152,
-0.9016133547,
-0.9559196234,
-0.0234993007,
-0.0207948461,
-0.6141494513,
0.2046248913,
0.1279768348,
-0.0630924553,
0.0361680016,
-0.6788942814,
0.6491439939,
0.2692326903,
-0.3151026964,
-0.5066248775,
-0.5372813344,
0.2091510892,
-0.3782644272,
0.4230545163,
0.0457180813,
0.294513762,
0.756051898,
-0.5284833908,
1.0848919153,
-0.1633809358,
0.1330221593,
0.3021731079,
-0.0136229135,
0.8272121549,
0.0833777487,
-0.257389605,
0.339422375,
-0.4975007474,
-0.3975093663,
-0.0803677514,
0.8494178057,
-1.2030396461,
0.0454079285,
-0.077637367,
-0.2820234299,
-0.152807951,
0.2693315148,
0.0049386579,
0.2158825845,
-0.1808324158,
-0.0349167958,
0.4730111361,
-0.018518487,
0.5657511353,
0.2808049917,
0.4307700694,
-0.4352931678,
0.6162515283,
-0.3173409104,
0.5599954724,
0.489790827,
0.1303272545,
0.0962107852,
-0.463542819,
-0.0768968537,
0.5764217973,
-0.8200750351,
-0.3010320663,
-0.4914773405,
-0.1135669649,
-0.1484973282,
-0.2539549172,
-1.0160725117,
-0.2511738539,
-0.5684251189,
-0.0313710123,
0.1801466346,
0.565647006,
-0.3391408622,
0.9017394185,
-0.5613347888,
-0.098519139,
0.2859746814,
0.4026047289,
0.0028067341,
-0.3296385705,
-0.7628225684,
0.3133351207,
-0.268320173,
-0.4461587071,
0.1793117225,
0.545992434,
0.2664053142,
0.5173994303,
-0.0147481523,
0.6185557246,
-0.519805789,
0.22653611,
0.4466054142,
-0.9896762371,
0.4795822203,
-0.5881634355,
0.13290371,
0.55773592,
0.5123823881,
-0.4226436913,
-0.5593367219,
-0.3939291239,
-0.2828347087,
0.7972356677,
0.2080191821,
0.3552867174,
-0.2143220156,
0.1036650911,
-0.1056172624,
0.3091053665,
-0.90725559,
-0.2011066824,
0.2357902527,
-0.2828121483,
0.3725201786,
0.1964911669,
-0.4861726463,
-0.0694196001,
0.8157187104,
-0.3596975505,
0.5345324874,
0.0467926338,
0.0353189781,
-0.4772074819,
-0.0230680034,
0.4059617817,
0.7324998379,
0.1319201589,
0.1218274459,
0.1036622524,
-0.4985804558,
0.1837765723,
0.0255326498,
0.0092154341,
-0.1115972102,
0.6605161428,
0.9428060055,
-0.1832129955,
-0.5961667299,
0.7814266086,
-0.1967693716,
-0.1915964931,
-0.2564679384,
0.0971192941,
0.186613515,
0.5182295442,
0.0857725814,
-0.1912640184,
-0.2121444196,
-0.3225094676,
0.2207389176,
0.5301195979,
-0.2390374094,
-0.4506947398,
0.6227731109,
0.5790767074,
-0.2201638073,
0.770151794,
-0.2879668176,
-0.5303522944,
0.4211029112,
0.3996921778,
0.6632059216,
-0.3856351972,
0.2369389236,
0.257117331,
0.4053753018,
-0.2395319343,
-0.0531300865,
-0.1662852615,
-0.8019971848,
-0.5088758469,
-0.7507607341,
-0.5537804961,
-0.3275556564,
-0.0137259904,
0.2623355985,
-0.6116742492,
-0.0700310841,
-0.314974457,
0.255399555,
-0.6161631346,
0.0316670053,
0.1973454952,
0.4932244122,
-1.274545908,
0.9875817895,
0.4358738363,
0.0327543207,
-0.7768055797,
-0.1895914674,
-0.2935247719,
-0.963647306,
0.7119494677,
0.0845318213,
-0.1268506646,
0.0892321244,
-0.369104445,
-0.5313065052,
0.9218977094,
0.5276023746,
-1.0648934841,
0.3768634796,
0.3138180077,
0.6376255155,
-0.5161594748,
0.3067749441,
0.3298451304,
0.0327413678,
0.0569099523,
-1.4254288673,
-0.306404829,
0.2839919031,
-0.3267654479,
0.1869389415,
-0.9462134242,
0.7652426362,
-0.3762035072,
-0.2368904948,
-0.2670019865,
0.6208162904,
0.1020852774,
0.2318267375,
0.5240134597,
0.4928755164,
1.1032837629,
0.1724230051,
0.7368702292,
-0.1834552586,
0.8816139698,
0.9437303543,
-0.2407877296,
0.7515535951,
0.5203612447,
-0.3825056553,
0.1094378307,
0.4721720219,
0.2484454066,
0.6726633906,
0.2246184796,
-0.6934223771,
0.0455349237,
-0.1855659187,
0.1874358654,
0.2315922081,
0.1032589078,
-0.2134004682,
-0.2317507267,
0.2190131992,
0.1336079836,
0.0421876162,
-0.2218612581,
0.852707684,
0.3871203065,
-0.1483600736,
1.0284618139,
-0.043023508,
0.5741030574,
-0.3668081164,
0.3167048395,
-0.797958076,
0.5330395699,
-0.1808117479,
-0.093918629,
0.350789398,
-0.0196908563,
0.030943552,
-0.1795145571,
0.4491507709,
-0.4794750214,
-0.3161102533,
0.4969435632,
0.5151664615,
0.3053911924,
0.3257662654,
-0.6268798113,
0.6053486466,
-0.0831543505,
-0.2127943635,
0.1288616657,
0.4102266729,
0.0811012685,
0.9973587394,
0.3239176571,
0.3358044624,
0.1545606554,
0.2618469596,
1.2070218325,
0.0165514238,
-0.6179181933,
-0.809109509,
-0.0243172087,
-0.0323132202,
0.0128415925,
0.649988234,
0.3758914173,
0.6974656582,
0.0418920629,
0.4980689883,
0.1104991287,
0.2676654458,
-0.1346497983,
0.5062838197,
-0.3907088041,
0.3136280179,
0.1120951846,
-1.1888694763,
-0.2847342193,
0.7308272123,
-0.1293812841,
-0.1035792679,
0.7968360782,
0.6838374138,
-0.5122348666,
-0.1508882791,
0.174394995,
0.5667333007,
0.3171690404,
0.5798562765,
0.3345498741,
-0.4052132964,
0.2248409986,
-0.486004144,
-0.3412616849,
-0.1941207051,
-0.6441795826,
-1.0925246477,
-0.3438346982,
-0.4320386052,
0.2629330754,
0.3831940293,
0.7765170932,
1.0434370041,
-0.5397556424,
-0.507753551,
-0.4381162822,
0.1279697865,
-0.0557126142,
-0.0901938453,
0.325904578,
-0.4168478847,
-0.9091692567,
0.7432435155,
0.1969489008,
-0.1799940616,
-0.3918811083,
-0.2542002797,
-0.0239798855,
-0.1934880763,
0.2705636322,
0.1010348871,
0.0254761074,
-0.0713059828,
-0.1341287047,
-0.089163512,
0.1780392677,
0.4912651777,
-0.5208773613,
0.460622102,
0.4110815823,
0.8723239899,
0.4749700725,
0.0408623703,
0.4315006733,
-1.4063317776,
0.8626329899,
0.3856999576,
0.1480030119,
0.4855792224,
-0.229058966,
0.3236447573,
0.4547257125,
-0.9413535595,
-0.9118310213,
0.00084816,
-0.8285769224,
-0.0161924511,
1.076138854,
-0.3783239722,
-0.3955618143,
0.3167267144,
0.3841663599,
0.1165381968,
-0.359110564,
0.6351650953,
0.4005236328,
0.0321022458,
-0.2929884493,
-0.4562395811,
0.2610005438,
0.1933236271,
-1.0248318911,
0.294180274,
0.3461177349,
0.143646881,
0.0646117851,
0.9757495522,
0.3318430483,
-0.1488672346,
0.1573220193,
-0.1683460474,
0.0576196089,
-0.6122448444,
-0.3877180815,
-0.1671381444,
0.2659963667,
-0.4487789273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08103v1
|
Exploring Semi-supervised Hierarchical Stacked Encoder for Legal Judgement Prediction
| 2023-11-14T12:03:26 | 2023-11-14T12:03:26 |
Nishchal Prasad, Mohand Boughanem, Taoufiq Dkaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Predicting the judgment of a legal case from its unannotated case facts is a
challenging task. The lengthy and non-uniform document structure poses an even
greater challenge in extracting information for decision prediction. In this
work, we explore and propose a two-level classification mechanism; both
supervised and unsupervised; by using domain-specific pre-trained BERT to
extract information from long documents in terms of sentence embeddings further
processing with transformer encoder layer and use unsupervised clustering to
extract hidden labels from these embeddings to better predict a judgment of a
legal case. We conduct several experiments with this mechanism and see higher
performance gains than the previously proposed methods on the ILDC dataset. Our
experimental results also show the importance of domain-specific pre-training
of Transformer Encoders in legal information processing.
|
[
-0.2314299494,
-0.6932908893,
0.5850076079,
-0.1172927767,
-0.4420237541,
0.2292303294,
-0.0199697241,
-0.5695996284,
-0.046977099,
0.6797987223,
-0.0655675903,
-0.643389225,
-0.8146104217,
-0.3875495195,
-0.4575915933,
1.2581843138,
0.3140548468,
0.277615875,
-0.4710634351,
-0.0534736067,
-0.3288719356,
-0.8164936304,
-0.280322969,
-0.5207486749,
0.2143043429,
0.0467438027,
0.4744198024,
0.0584459938,
0.358123064,
0.2314421535,
-0.140939638,
-0.2545385957,
-0.2276664525,
-0.127898559,
0.0014259702,
-0.6785137653,
-0.3322688639,
-0.1843228638,
0.2511460781,
0.4088853002,
-0.3921711743,
-0.1294835806,
-0.1020232514,
0.4906561375,
-0.5600689054,
0.2385639101,
-0.5363299847,
0.6001707315,
-0.2444959879,
-0.3501757085,
-0.7782013416,
-0.2293068916,
0.2749580145,
-0.419622004,
0.5812297463,
0.3833512962,
0.7571826577,
0.4011042416,
-0.6412165165,
-0.1686735749,
-0.6273617744,
0.4817855656,
-0.59068501,
0.3409930468,
0.3363672197,
0.465413034,
-0.0359233469,
-0.9663621783,
-0.5475382805,
-0.2079008073,
-0.3573081195,
0.6086699963,
-0.3051854968,
0.4138420522,
0.388869673,
0.1273141801,
-0.4162743986,
0.4788858294,
-0.4127810895,
-0.3682070971,
0.4627039731,
-0.3500394225,
-0.0747933015,
-0.4846328795,
-0.3194440007,
0.0708479658,
-0.3361611366,
0.3586186171,
0.273041904,
0.2353993505,
0.0111100413,
0.6296204329,
0.2301942706,
0.429292202,
0.5776346326,
-0.1552107036,
0.4712577164,
0.1998785883,
-0.3854987621,
0.705268085,
0.7059830427,
0.2501439452,
0.1099266559,
-0.0433628857,
-0.4581725299,
-0.0569041483,
0.5689477324,
-0.6550710797,
0.0494780876,
0.2520953417,
-0.8176771402,
-0.3504262269,
0.4668317437,
-0.9056994319,
-0.5847608447,
-0.2828367054,
0.1758803278,
-0.2688008249,
0.2829430401,
0.2174353302,
-0.20608145,
0.1458555758,
0.3982267678,
-0.4581394792,
0.2962845862,
0.4524610341,
0.3893807232,
-0.0668193027,
0.2599461675,
-0.5301149487,
0.3519040346,
-0.1724889427,
0.7097899914,
-0.8423511386,
-0.2474734336,
0.5027878284,
0.0533437468,
0.1766511947,
-0.5028271675,
1.0439418554,
-0.7877185345,
0.3490824997,
0.2734745145,
-0.6812483072,
-0.0845745355,
0.2260231823,
-0.715998888,
0.9091299176,
-0.0067279539,
-1.0099434853,
1.1496896744,
-0.6700968146,
-0.9950782657,
0.4332034588,
-0.4267563224,
-0.8524135351,
0.1488963515,
0.4708948135,
0.5788503885,
-0.1257406175,
0.4577755034,
-0.1361817569,
-0.2076630443,
-0.2915148437,
-0.0340335406,
0.6736688018,
0.1661777943,
-0.274410367,
0.0375324711,
-0.7694344521,
-0.2193152606,
-0.114640519,
-0.7301356792,
-0.35403651,
0.163435638,
-0.1010390073,
0.2910696268,
0.2291403115,
-0.9654734135,
-0.0427236296,
-0.100921832,
0.2345591784,
0.6882997155,
0.0796456486,
0.4138021469,
0.0553678498,
0.3877819479,
0.367136538,
0.0881938264,
0.3567039669,
-0.4061145782,
-0.6842522621,
-0.092776373,
0.6572300196,
0.4806407094,
-0.6870101094,
0.8159000874,
-0.3567771614,
-0.1126065478,
-0.7006070018,
-0.1472683996,
0.2672287822,
0.3295008242,
0.4355347753,
-0.1146071851,
-0.7556747794,
-0.9362789989,
-0.1238918975,
-0.174241215,
-0.1528935432,
0.3090488911,
0.6690066457,
-0.3858250678,
0.9553081989,
-0.1788441539,
-0.765697062,
-0.3401550055,
0.7908548713,
0.4962040782,
0.3150460422,
0.4867864549,
-0.9805486202,
-0.343203485,
0.3813379109,
-0.8318993449,
0.2128180861,
-0.3213323653,
0.151358664,
0.1424794495,
0.5949763656,
-0.5512005687,
0.6755566001,
-0.2137169987,
-0.1335282922,
0.2135461271,
-0.694216013,
0.0248611234,
-0.8149744868,
-0.552144587,
0.1723050177,
-0.2560468018,
-0.4576651156,
-0.2345360816,
0.3183269799,
0.1412233412,
-0.2582756579,
-0.2724755406,
-0.5444620252,
-0.4466179907,
-0.0144074541,
-0.1798539013,
-0.2272010893,
0.5947245955,
0.3347454369,
0.3972174823,
0.6006270051,
-0.4514048696,
0.3030385375,
0.3097883165,
-0.911871016,
0.5041955113,
-0.4876369536,
0.1244836748,
-0.4868421257,
0.4830670953,
-0.3677031696,
0.0949039385,
-0.3936207294,
-0.2880872488,
0.6416193843,
-0.3344554603,
-0.9679173827,
-0.9354730844,
-0.1328251213,
0.0771690756,
0.4941712916,
-0.7387747765,
0.9509274364,
0.6444328427,
0.0958685353,
-0.6069415212,
-0.878523767,
-0.0265560448,
-0.1775913686,
-0.1716380715,
0.5387970209,
0.3103254735,
0.0775900185,
-0.0013289077,
0.1205886006,
0.0580183417,
-0.3435145319,
0.6168273687,
0.1290477961,
-0.0728207305,
0.3714665174,
0.417414546,
0.1041855738,
0.4387712777,
-0.475712806,
0.2095160335,
0.046643246,
-0.3639471233,
-0.275664717,
0.2996732295,
0.5734090209,
-0.25760144,
0.4886709452,
0.1134861633,
-0.5355283618,
-0.4166592956,
-0.6482685208,
0.2384322435,
-0.3865766823,
0.3269172907,
-0.4253100753,
-1.0013695955,
0.2831119001,
-0.139143452,
0.0317952819,
0.5377835631,
0.7745027542,
-0.1824946404,
1.0063409805,
0.7470731139,
-0.3307174444,
0.3343462348,
-0.1523945332,
0.6857360601,
-0.316239357,
-0.811580956,
-0.3427057266,
-0.2330514789,
-0.5323432684,
-0.3186897635,
0.497148037,
-0.1400974989,
-0.159110263,
0.2325376719,
-0.3409713507,
0.4547609687,
0.6860129237,
0.1554720849,
0.120159179,
0.1669052988,
-0.6171402335,
0.2254805714,
-0.5483598709,
-0.2500599027,
1.0284216404,
0.4531704485,
0.6706106067,
-0.1164782345,
0.6847853065,
0.873848021,
-0.1612084806,
-0.8409817815,
0.3920351863,
-0.4580741525,
-0.4982790351,
-0.0897847638,
-0.2342541665,
-0.8784498572,
0.1319597661,
-0.4468840659,
-0.4969348311,
0.5200442076,
-0.5056678057,
-0.5975829363,
0.2336734533,
-0.3734408617,
0.4898157716,
-0.3834717572,
-0.1763280481,
-0.2373346388,
-0.9291613698,
-0.1394711882,
-0.44943133,
0.2147888243,
0.2984130979,
0.4716723263,
1.0420492887,
-0.4904125929,
0.6956389546,
-0.422434032,
0.0355923101,
0.415384829,
-0.1785868257,
0.4376978874,
-0.0193984527,
-0.1146815568,
-0.0343909822,
-0.1278228015,
-0.0858737901,
-0.6021207571,
0.1731593609,
-0.7185105085,
-0.5621591806,
-0.6304526329,
-0.5076968074,
-0.2972432375,
0.15585123,
0.4456708729,
0.1318014264,
-0.0587846264,
0.4410354197,
0.4279786646,
0.1219480634,
0.3668739796,
0.6835169196,
0.3500985801,
-0.0031239253,
0.4186148942,
0.1186394021,
-0.51828444,
0.7652495503,
0.1034661308,
-0.6084669232,
-0.7972557545,
-0.1084018499,
-0.0464233086,
-0.8333334923,
-0.4768908322,
-0.6397650242,
-0.3608162105,
-0.5114473104,
-0.0121733509,
-0.0481424965,
-0.2837372124,
-0.1331076026,
-0.8174384832,
0.0473157018,
0.8779790401,
0.2004160881,
0.11906562,
-0.6391012669,
0.175227344,
0.3088779449,
0.2097064853,
-0.3175686002,
-0.759367764,
-0.1861266345,
-0.1800210178,
0.0202460922,
-0.1673646718,
0.2036142945,
0.0430036411,
0.7844734192,
0.7179161906,
0.3326012194,
0.6325976253,
-0.6060504317,
0.5669577122,
0.3002493382,
-0.6025024652,
0.9579537511,
0.071945332,
-0.2062645704,
0.4954534769,
0.3425775468,
0.2582476437,
-0.3333710134,
-0.4974352419,
-0.4945426583,
0.8803013563,
0.0327392593,
0.0859979987,
0.1060594618,
0.2275764942,
0.3346813321,
0.1844347864,
-0.5851923823,
0.2340667546,
-0.2247573286,
-0.0037723731,
0.1699944884,
-0.4028405249,
-0.0319953449,
-0.599347353,
0.3783152997,
0.0538517684,
0.2676522434,
0.0629686713,
-0.1981981695,
-0.1182764173,
0.3325657845,
-0.0374867506,
0.4172396958,
-0.4806856215,
0.0762291625,
0.1930530965,
-0.3495369852,
-0.0510306731,
0.1734606922,
-0.0804079771,
0.0043991166,
0.6161834598,
0.9413039088,
0.0500146858,
-0.4332832992,
0.7413464189,
-0.1397620887,
-0.6054602861,
-0.4813320339,
-0.421513468,
-0.4303578138,
0.3821873367,
0.3517543077,
-0.0001093081,
0.3825941384,
-0.7641791701,
0.5036937594,
0.1218882427,
-0.4569911957,
0.1156514362,
0.6686333418,
0.1588822752,
0.2344870269,
0.658151567,
-0.0013048028,
-0.7210137248,
0.5692427754,
0.6097885966,
0.5988479853,
0.1630811393,
0.1908460706,
0.1586767137,
-0.0378841981,
-0.218100667,
-0.1256799996,
-0.3820712864,
-0.707739234,
0.0650148168,
-0.8026256561,
-0.0480202921,
-0.1675125211,
-1.0409960747,
0.1652279347,
-0.5538524985,
-0.2146679908,
0.1114140451,
-0.1359930634,
-0.5560736656,
0.3179682493,
0.292524159,
0.728572011,
-0.548252821,
1.1255763769,
0.6139971614,
-0.3774009943,
-0.2808702886,
0.1251887679,
-0.1415412128,
-0.717333734,
0.9029012918,
0.2198801488,
-0.1491217315,
-0.4769468606,
-0.4551426768,
-0.1485292614,
1.0354104042,
0.2287121564,
-0.748752594,
-0.2360934168,
0.3534136415,
0.8458205462,
-0.4985506535,
0.0417887196,
0.8375492692,
0.3338858783,
0.4245707393,
-0.5819243193,
-0.0598171875,
-0.519202888,
0.0562146567,
0.2015121579,
-0.0493374281,
0.6499356031,
-0.2705029845,
-0.1852463931,
-0.2993930876,
0.8168908358,
-0.1159677729,
0.3094461262,
0.5850629807,
0.9060111046,
0.9519512653,
-0.2472544611,
1.2473012209,
-0.1562407464,
0.5103262067,
0.9584205747,
-0.4149879813,
0.8219286799,
0.3363456428,
-0.1950931847,
0.7747181058,
0.6726413965,
-0.56171453,
0.8856827617,
0.1662060469,
-0.0943570957,
-0.4420561492,
-0.2981874049,
-0.0658238605,
0.3923250735,
0.3400566578,
-0.531024158,
-0.0002345452,
0.1406949013,
-0.2545365095,
0.0680422783,
-0.5429409742,
0.9679180384,
-0.0597499311,
-0.5730571747,
0.070625551,
0.0464142412,
0.7677241564,
-0.2967630625,
-0.0935029536,
0.0142231695,
0.4183503389,
-0.4108865261,
-1.1739151478,
-0.1150122434,
0.0595052764,
-0.219340533,
-0.4332232177,
0.9075018764,
-0.2580476999,
-0.6196463704,
0.871561408,
0.2228556126,
0.0522099733,
-0.0299643595,
-0.7108658552,
-0.6677892208,
-0.2549898922,
-0.0011179297,
0.3969835937,
0.8639273047,
-0.3144825399,
0.2357140779,
0.5326768756,
-0.1608888358,
0.1995468587,
0.8245764375,
1.0705975294,
-0.4663641155,
-0.8944655657,
-0.4723176062,
0.3845413029,
-0.2330619246,
0.0604418255,
0.2558740675,
0.7603072524,
0.9491099119,
-0.1630232632,
0.8867586851,
-0.1589125395,
0.4358806014,
-0.7439516187,
0.8136765957,
-0.4418372512,
0.1331113577,
0.0623891242,
-0.6863456964,
-0.2928675115,
0.5004085302,
-0.3339645565,
0.1075570136,
0.8490711451,
0.4025641382,
-0.0584587641,
0.2217225283,
0.3756397367,
0.166717425,
0.1591339856,
0.6104386449,
0.6436066628,
-0.175304696,
0.5154904723,
-0.3284809589,
-0.0470077209,
-0.1432528645,
-0.5042867064,
-1.2788885832,
-0.4138762355,
-0.0878967568,
-0.1038291901,
-0.030072188,
0.45843485,
0.7826272845,
-1.0854582787,
-0.0761025473,
-0.2561141849,
-0.099599421,
0.1125646234,
-0.181808874,
0.5175583363,
-0.2231843919,
-0.4424542189,
0.160103485,
0.1879013181,
-0.0388610661,
0.4569655955,
-0.0524078272,
-0.3126148283,
-0.2143622786,
0.8430659175,
-0.1203383803,
-0.7514926195,
-0.3484380841,
-0.7718763351,
-0.0122594181,
0.3385682106,
1.0780540705,
-0.8367482424,
0.5106008649,
0.3265479803,
0.6768906713,
0.9078936577,
0.3631360829,
0.5634454489,
-1.0205407143,
0.1252278984,
0.4779781401,
0.8550832272,
-0.0551334135,
-0.5346102118,
0.4317833185,
-0.0007792849,
-0.221486643,
-0.398939997,
-0.2372343987,
-0.9869964719,
-0.4552604854,
0.7526867986,
-0.2923672199,
-0.2050472945,
-0.2757794857,
-0.1314771026,
0.3468919098,
-0.6289591193,
0.691041708,
0.5703595281,
-0.2229825556,
-0.3247151673,
-0.4604201019,
0.2662146688,
0.2841567099,
-0.8022703528,
-0.1785433292,
0.4902610481,
-0.1224212572,
0.5782450438,
0.1756877452,
-0.524443984,
0.1760962456,
-0.0427260175,
0.0241880249,
-0.1110331938,
-0.5792854428,
-0.3096353114,
0.5466514826,
-0.4504569471,
-0.2498803884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08097v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08097v4
|
Empowering Multi-step Reasoning across Languages via Tree-of-Thoughts
| 2023-11-14T11:49:43 | 2024-06-21T06:06:51 |
Leonardo Ranaldi, Giulia Pucci, Federico Ranaldi, Elena Sofia Ruzzetti, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reasoning methods, best exemplified by the well-known Chain-of-Thought (CoT),
empower the reasoning abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) by eliciting
them to solve complex tasks in a step-by-step manner. Although they are
achieving significant success, the ability to deliver multi-step reasoning
remains limited to English because of the imbalance in the distribution of
pre-training data, which makes other languages a barrier. In this paper, we
propose Cross-lingual Tree-of-Thoughts (Cross-ToT), a method for aligning
Cross-lingual CoT reasoning across languages. The proposed method, through a
self-consistent cross-lingual prompting mechanism inspired by the
Tree-of-Thoughts approach, provides multi-step reasoning paths in different
languages that, during the steps, lead to the final solution. Experimental
evaluations show that our method significantly outperforms existing prompting
methods by reducing the number of interactions and achieving state-of-the-art
performance.
|
[
-0.5316899419,
-0.7560874224,
0.8394761682,
0.5809825659,
-0.3698661923,
0.4956414104,
-0.34885028,
-0.461522609,
0.2100699991,
0.1477961838,
-0.8381550312,
-0.4722746313,
-0.4226655662,
0.3161639869,
-0.2381071895,
0.5680869222,
-0.496430546,
0.0584137514,
-0.0033976827,
-0.118108362,
-0.5648400187,
-0.3488563597,
-0.5336902738,
-0.405397594,
0.8071851134,
0.4486244619,
0.5748605132,
-0.0265651159,
-0.0009052233,
0.1356238127,
0.1240092069,
0.2880898118,
-0.1794188619,
0.2002831548,
-0.5902770758,
-0.5537157655,
-0.3263641,
-0.3548561037,
0.5232015252,
0.4922453463,
-0.009017189,
-0.1102733091,
0.1968763024,
0.6073429585,
-0.5653153062,
0.0338460431,
-0.567618072,
0.2454269081,
-0.0024993343,
-0.5074361563,
-0.5860248804,
-0.1102214977,
-0.0385418162,
-0.4524396658,
-0.326587975,
0.1373083591,
0.4120948017,
0.2143692523,
-0.3197974563,
-0.4207589924,
-0.4451794922,
0.856641829,
-0.4704369605,
0.8444939256,
0.1907073855,
0.2530320287,
0.0418469161,
-0.2036039978,
-0.3669584692,
-0.1804435402,
-0.1802535951,
0.138829127,
-0.0853959918,
-0.2762391269,
0.2178258002,
-0.1286786497,
-0.5389946699,
-0.0961910039,
0.1640495956,
0.0219718497,
0.4513962269,
-0.2115322053,
0.4876632094,
-0.0512371026,
-0.5814438462,
-0.0236584116,
-0.8858158588,
0.135817036,
0.0774511173,
0.5191186666,
0.0358334742,
0.4257895648,
-0.2685246766,
0.4817649126,
0.3691562414,
-0.0302251484,
0.1254579574,
-0.6032360196,
-0.1895087212,
0.319894582,
0.7522351146,
-0.0272403248,
0.2844249606,
-0.221708551,
-0.2252800018,
-0.1202337667,
0.010167473,
-0.5248255134,
0.0192346293,
0.2776627243,
-0.1547234803,
0.0873381197,
-0.4264756739,
-0.7200375795,
-0.0718626007,
-0.202828452,
0.4306803346,
-0.5252622962,
-0.5989214778,
0.1252472997,
0.2127306461,
0.3341304064,
0.4396528304,
-0.8441453576,
0.1643332094,
0.6550839543,
0.5996924639,
-0.0680438057,
-0.7023455501,
-0.4132396579,
0.2045125514,
-0.581186831,
0.9209212065,
-0.7092207074,
-0.2311677784,
-0.1848978102,
-0.1746916026,
-0.2107002288,
-0.0686772242,
0.2040888071,
-0.3303025067,
0.3562857211,
-0.6038702726,
-0.2379287332,
-0.1470066756,
0.9011095762,
-0.4224370122,
1.2088526487,
-0.246686101,
-0.9592040181,
0.3847247958,
-0.589618504,
-0.5915739536,
-0.0362411663,
-0.6098850369,
-0.1481046975,
-0.1843787283,
0.8982886076,
0.3124234974,
-0.5188885927,
0.3862396181,
-0.2144008577,
0.1591167599,
-0.1276397556,
-0.5264898539,
1.1631042957,
0.1054971665,
-0.6246627569,
0.2225631028,
-0.2252721637,
0.2794241011,
0.1967860162,
-0.0554998629,
-0.5113889575,
-0.2784264684,
-0.3284739852,
0.6931812763,
0.2544671893,
-0.4665863812,
0.3510033488,
-0.1804450005,
0.1660802811,
0.4186756611,
-0.0572484359,
0.2112392783,
-0.2181563675,
0.7959663868,
0.1977292001,
0.0933158547,
-0.3648982644,
-0.5851294994,
-0.5142040849,
-0.1527217627,
0.2529309988,
0.6231934428,
-0.9551664591,
0.3391706347,
-0.1965113431,
-0.3894987702,
-0.5777753592,
0.1884288341,
0.6931233406,
0.3690703213,
0.3634520173,
-0.2673362792,
-0.2808932066,
-0.5332186222,
-0.4011006355,
-0.218330726,
0.3838591278,
0.1405169368,
0.4888932705,
0.0310480949,
0.8521291614,
0.0307839401,
0.0898542851,
-0.4203697145,
0.2266608179,
-0.153638348,
0.4109193385,
0.2898223698,
-0.5751152635,
-0.7404509783,
0.3021840751,
-0.6906380653,
-0.2287411839,
-0.4124341905,
-0.5299472213,
0.3087580502,
0.6270944476,
-0.4787665606,
0.1893899739,
0.5592494011,
-0.4260041714,
0.4186988771,
-0.0104217548,
0.427990824,
-1.2701938152,
-0.1185498014,
-0.3043605089,
-0.3204639852,
-0.3162776828,
-0.0138866324,
0.1409608871,
0.1013944,
-0.5633297563,
0.6897098422,
-0.6857639551,
-0.1249118075,
0.0596002452,
0.3018184006,
0.1262928396,
0.674464345,
0.440654397,
0.6179721951,
0.9195632339,
-0.3303765655,
0.2887292802,
0.3011480868,
-0.15050295,
0.9923968911,
-0.160730049,
0.2699806392,
0.0073441691,
0.4859757125,
-0.8862555623,
0.3877811432,
0.2807263732,
-0.331727922,
0.185844034,
-0.1745922416,
-0.4851010442,
-0.2595176697,
-0.2299325615,
0.8329514265,
0.0520678833,
-0.9663712978,
0.9329813123,
0.0778550878,
-0.2860869169,
-0.8955803514,
-0.694506228,
0.2793180943,
-0.1842926443,
-0.5840290189,
0.2973508537,
0.0301754344,
-0.0402734615,
0.0788075551,
-0.2586981952,
0.2562323213,
-0.3462679088,
-0.2529283464,
0.2024188787,
-0.1972913295,
0.2353777736,
0.2468229532,
-0.0873421952,
0.2029049546,
-0.8086941838,
0.5588234067,
-0.1685452163,
-0.8664941192,
-0.0239157006,
0.6011843085,
0.5480427146,
-0.5494191647,
0.1708730459,
0.2977286875,
-0.3937185705,
-0.6046888828,
-0.4288683236,
-0.0023157783,
-0.3978207409,
0.2633530498,
-0.8811996579,
-0.6779756546,
0.3194497526,
-0.3844222426,
0.2159361541,
0.036796432,
0.8155229688,
-0.0106440252,
1.2426724434,
0.4810318649,
-0.0899852514,
0.3448818922,
-0.1235538572,
0.5898143649,
-0.8927260041,
-0.4121831059,
-0.4128530324,
-0.1291020662,
-0.4216379821,
-0.7951980829,
0.2561379075,
0.1232527196,
-0.1346866488,
0.2654348314,
-0.4746103585,
0.5790893435,
0.4704848528,
0.0385250412,
0.3735803366,
-0.128796339,
-0.7881826162,
0.3742291629,
-1.1618692875,
-0.2051469982,
0.6758046746,
0.1653748304,
0.7994764447,
-0.0707263798,
1.0642307997,
-0.1206588373,
0.1073342264,
-0.8174290061,
0.7257500291,
0.1105768383,
-0.5781927109,
-0.6549758315,
-0.2267640382,
-1.050812006,
0.4026230574,
0.0965109542,
-0.8338195682,
0.1619269997,
-0.0918694586,
-0.2335345298,
0.4965377152,
-0.4526459575,
0.8905298114,
-0.8534319997,
-0.3786996305,
-0.4530260265,
-0.5580371618,
0.3115412891,
-0.0724428222,
0.3365507722,
-0.0425708294,
0.1220899224,
0.6233750582,
-0.3740384579,
0.9767609239,
-0.0923410133,
-0.4678959846,
0.5434464216,
0.3039747179,
0.6668200493,
-0.1897448748,
0.2829361558,
-0.0183801167,
-0.0684472546,
-0.3601052165,
-0.6995819211,
0.701742053,
-0.3760622144,
-0.8368393183,
-0.4463145137,
-0.6989642978,
-0.7155227065,
0.2627451718,
0.0649865046,
0.17735596,
-0.064552702,
-0.2281072587,
0.441524595,
-0.1558951288,
0.4500978589,
0.3763994277,
-0.6906493902,
-0.4510375261,
0.7450042963,
0.0549643636,
0.5325661302,
0.5884930491,
0.4071350396,
-0.6965221167,
-0.1426693201,
-0.7131101489,
0.1986071169,
-1.0192728043,
-0.0647442192,
-0.5966693759,
-0.0575449951,
-0.2431067079,
-0.3815426826,
-0.326364547,
-0.4181988537,
0.5453805327,
-0.2552867234,
0.4003919363,
0.5984269381,
-0.058114294,
-0.335975796,
-0.7540042996,
0.377515167,
0.5423477292,
0.3690376878,
0.3402535915,
-0.1381398588,
-0.1647439152,
0.0411108322,
-0.2036482096,
-0.9827844501,
0.0896484926,
-0.2609059215,
0.6318793297,
-0.0094074728,
-0.0429300554,
1.0017021894,
-0.5430948734,
0.5131334066,
0.5083435178,
-1.1192415953,
0.7970027328,
-0.1611138433,
0.550498426,
0.4572193623,
0.5465824604,
-0.6799997687,
-0.7200514078,
-0.5946787596,
-0.7292937636,
0.5714131594,
0.036011368,
-0.3347227871,
0.0009567993,
-0.4503994286,
0.2614608407,
-0.103873603,
-0.7255311608,
0.1328052729,
-0.2813470662,
-0.1522218734,
0.2719816864,
0.3780074418,
-0.1544527411,
-0.3431796134,
0.778961122,
-0.4464431107,
-0.0304249153,
0.3802045584,
-0.1552027613,
-0.3507699668,
0.6031522751,
0.1288617253,
0.6727485061,
0.4059883058,
0.3115722537,
0.5252273083,
-0.008857986,
0.3251135349,
-0.1369166523,
-0.2281666845,
-0.1377644092,
0.3165431023,
0.7180070877,
0.2732771337,
-0.3753327131,
0.1974058598,
0.0123817744,
-0.1853335053,
0.1989395171,
-0.2703829706,
0.38305372,
0.4023039043,
0.1312882453,
-0.0630553737,
-0.1212539524,
-0.825150907,
0.1310478449,
0.5809055567,
-0.3228138983,
-0.1860980093,
0.4060840309,
0.3598382473,
-0.3843893707,
0.4692009091,
-0.25101161,
-0.8678042293,
0.3825801015,
0.7767125964,
1.2388641834,
-0.2361288369,
0.2577179372,
0.3529260159,
0.3732731938,
-0.1725185215,
0.6820058823,
-0.5695266724,
-0.7900534868,
-0.8229296803,
-0.3698439896,
-0.5011521578,
-0.2567369044,
-0.2941561937,
0.2857294679,
-0.2443472296,
0.1126506478,
-0.2551436722,
-0.1733435243,
-0.6012406349,
0.348631829,
0.4985836148,
1.0833218098,
-0.8944311142,
1.2183041573,
0.5998556018,
-0.3553610444,
-1.1941717863,
0.2953658104,
-0.0144421039,
-0.9180960655,
0.4688169062,
0.0834428966,
-0.7936835289,
-0.0031468326,
-0.109471485,
-0.77009058,
0.9500674009,
0.205274716,
-0.8512179852,
-0.062461637,
0.2772808671,
0.4154519439,
-0.5659567118,
0.2334247231,
0.6023098826,
0.6271272898,
0.2273468524,
-1.1956366301,
0.3632331491,
-0.2801340818,
-0.2613168955,
0.3594587743,
-0.6064130068,
0.5789321065,
-0.4129679501,
-0.1840971708,
-0.524122417,
0.4179063141,
0.7355575562,
0.2019032985,
0.9076017141,
0.5937761068,
0.9509542584,
0.1877197623,
0.7505242825,
-0.6317158341,
0.1284026653,
1.1300212145,
-0.5060393214,
0.8471259475,
0.7662489414,
-0.1107961237,
0.7329129577,
0.560998261,
0.4619858265,
0.4648265839,
0.0118248453,
-0.1727551222,
-0.4972197711,
-0.0602186322,
-0.3133765757,
0.1845968217,
0.4189684391,
0.0840489566,
-0.3305298686,
-0.0219632015,
-0.0853935033,
-0.0537081622,
-0.4596506953,
0.5927568078,
0.2386741638,
-1.172929287,
0.8137184978,
-0.516782999,
0.6231421828,
-0.5949491858,
-0.0185417999,
0.0985449851,
-0.1285466403,
-0.198500976,
-1.1601721048,
0.3152699471,
0.2011475414,
0.2091718316,
-0.8612446189,
0.5442420244,
-0.7807407975,
-0.6431745291,
0.8830635548,
0.9884945154,
0.0516148098,
0.1085957438,
-0.9590806365,
-0.1506667435,
0.0312249493,
-0.2078823745,
0.2041597664,
1.0308161974,
-0.5854444504,
0.7064843178,
0.4366858602,
0.1432312727,
0.081138514,
0.4480405748,
0.724840641,
-0.7220888734,
-0.7116525769,
-0.8759503365,
0.4319861233,
0.0911672264,
-0.1889808774,
0.6345068216,
0.4500494897,
1.2116726637,
0.1121607274,
0.9824327826,
-0.2072294205,
0.348353982,
-0.5938048363,
0.439666599,
-0.7011374831,
0.1949932277,
-0.2135169953,
-0.8196441531,
-0.0269309562,
0.5858739614,
-0.3643743992,
0.1399024725,
1.3885117769,
0.7486988306,
-0.1703473926,
0.109076865,
0.3828441501,
0.169077158,
0.2162644267,
0.9951319098,
0.8916146159,
0.0414544456,
0.6157582402,
-0.2667490542,
-0.1454902589,
0.1890761703,
-0.9841396213,
-1.0493320227,
-0.6058241129,
-0.2855536938,
-0.2357795388,
0.2381860614,
1.1867930889,
0.6308991909,
-0.8994488716,
-0.3917981684,
-0.4478012919,
0.3419407308,
-0.5677279234,
-0.0722144395,
0.347890228,
-0.6158961654,
-0.6370176673,
0.4784561098,
0.5323150754,
-0.2453629971,
-0.6088232994,
-0.262625128,
-0.504676342,
0.2669972479,
0.6047754288,
0.2267643809,
-1.0334545374,
-0.2340064347,
0.1863064468,
-0.1152227893,
0.3353464901,
0.9530613422,
-0.9017087221,
0.6259605885,
0.6502208114,
0.6105782986,
0.4591619074,
-0.1479832679,
0.7222295403,
-0.7111776471,
-0.0178667922,
0.4079242945,
0.6719593406,
0.2957570255,
-0.2559919655,
0.3648857176,
-0.2254935801,
-0.2372290194,
-0.556566298,
0.5382000804,
-0.7406333089,
-0.4561144114,
1.0925492048,
-0.2286508977,
-0.4282678068,
-0.2135725021,
-0.4261843562,
0.2602378428,
-0.2205382288,
0.8491613269,
0.9687426686,
-0.3171123862,
-0.393481493,
0.0832874477,
0.4869474173,
0.8706307411,
-1.1496480703,
0.5023518205,
0.0781148821,
0.0416154377,
0.3049269319,
0.8786863089,
-0.210168764,
0.3318843842,
0.0464460105,
-0.108547993,
0.3091692924,
-0.8417328,
-0.1150311902,
-0.0950481966,
0.0322259553,
-0.0382605679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08093v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08093v1
|
Spot: A Natural Language Interface for Geospatial Searches in OSM
| 2023-11-14T11:35:09 | 2023-11-14T11:35:09 |
Lynn Khellaf, Ipek Baris Schlicht, Julia Bayer, Ruben Bouwmeester, Tilman Miraß, Tilman Wagner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Investigative journalists and fact-checkers have found OpenStreetMap (OSM) to
be an invaluable resource for their work due to its extensive coverage and
intricate details of various locations, which play a crucial role in
investigating news scenes. Despite its value, OSM's complexity presents
considerable accessibility and usability challenges, especially for those
without a technical background. To address this, we introduce 'Spot', a
user-friendly natural language interface for querying OSM data. Spot utilizes a
semantic mapping from natural language to OSM tags, leveraging artificially
generated sentence queries and a T5 transformer. This approach enables Spot to
extract relevant information from user-input sentences and display candidate
locations matching the descriptions on a map. To foster collaboration and
future advancement, all code and generated data is available as an open-source
repository.
|
[
-0.6078095436,
-0.8954393864,
1.2141112089,
0.343611151,
-0.2375310808,
0.0061881035,
-0.0598835498,
-0.4220408499,
0.4533137977,
0.7440652847,
-0.5134482384,
-1.1906887293,
-0.5430303216,
-0.0810221955,
-0.3511492312,
0.4930663407,
-0.3607231975,
-0.3187185526,
-0.1124463901,
-0.5172884464,
-0.4043608904,
-0.3350383639,
-0.361146152,
0.3031641245,
0.3621042073,
0.5921484828,
0.6090174913,
0.6125753522,
0.7958016396,
0.1966770142,
0.0193364825,
0.1949823052,
-0.0918719172,
0.2822037041,
-0.4346486628,
-0.3161366582,
0.181024164,
0.1363069862,
0.7351053357,
0.5617451072,
-0.3701999187,
-0.0062337229,
-0.4087099433,
0.4572190046,
-0.6993805766,
0.1021782085,
-0.6783909202,
-0.1038857102,
-0.5674067736,
-0.5882351398,
0.055528596,
-0.8703331947,
0.2424928695,
-0.7468982935,
0.6105015278,
0.2005871981,
1.0171216726,
0.26997298,
-0.4234666526,
-0.6161027551,
-0.4956249297,
0.5607858896,
-0.3852185607,
0.1547624469,
0.611608386,
0.5939645767,
-0.3431626856,
-0.5475831628,
-0.3007256985,
-0.1188120395,
-0.164523378,
-0.0877105221,
0.0147437034,
-0.3131211996,
0.2900079489,
0.3660601079,
-0.4611283243,
-0.4759656489,
-0.2671364844,
-0.0441244543,
0.4192411304,
0.0551836602,
0.8169250488,
-0.2852763832,
-0.4508203864,
0.3893998861,
-0.9015984535,
0.0424905568,
0.1015075594,
0.7913980484,
-0.0152275823,
0.6459835768,
-0.8141673803,
0.8986079693,
-0.5196745992,
0.011194082,
-0.042840261,
-0.1065377891,
0.1223069578,
0.3388625383,
0.7411813736,
0.2217337787,
-0.4969391525,
-0.1796477139,
-0.2453251928,
0.0129064908,
0.2905504405,
-0.3412070572,
-0.2067914009,
0.2339033186,
0.0091406703,
-0.1498923153,
0.5281561017,
-0.0657637417,
-0.4159555137,
-0.0187718943,
0.4131537974,
-0.4191319942,
0.0379273146,
0.1107319072,
-0.597055316,
0.1657603681,
0.4359894097,
-0.3904109895,
0.1651670784,
0.4098348618,
1.135284543,
0.1463751793,
-0.1320912689,
-0.4781553447,
0.1459928751,
-0.2041314542,
0.9547840357,
-0.254768014,
-0.2500992119,
-0.0093224766,
-0.0751099959,
0.2197571248,
-0.4902046621,
0.575617671,
-0.5605072975,
0.6073898077,
-0.5199518204,
0.0011503621,
-0.2996960282,
0.4516486824,
-0.7735484838,
1.6938481331,
0.2066595852,
-0.7138495445,
0.4483214617,
-1.0340955257,
-0.5182135105,
0.3117107749,
-0.221219793,
-0.1552047729,
0.0668909252,
0.5002049804,
-0.0656900331,
-0.0740167201,
0.3823470175,
-0.3360080421,
-0.1714738607,
0.2101648599,
0.3500732481,
0.6191800833,
0.2042184472,
-0.3419206738,
-0.2422447801,
-0.6866847277,
-0.2002018243,
0.2900013924,
-0.5738739967,
-0.870973289,
0.4852221906,
0.0580056496,
0.1959135383,
0.32460922,
-0.8199826479,
0.3023784459,
-0.2184555382,
0.3581848145,
0.1822772771,
-0.0099780485,
0.5779328346,
0.1095454469,
0.2881531715,
-0.1338569373,
0.08211115,
-0.3473218679,
-0.6185638905,
-0.2446379662,
-0.1550944149,
-0.0015052516,
0.423892647,
-0.9188245535,
0.239353016,
-0.1623760611,
-0.3848056197,
-0.7815761566,
0.116789937,
-0.0667750239,
0.8103173375,
0.4983319044,
-0.2300249934,
-0.4621522725,
-0.6595140696,
-0.3929224908,
0.3905952871,
-0.1840971559,
0.4574523866,
0.1954067498,
0.0536902025,
1.8590792418,
-0.8748631477,
-0.5745221376,
-0.213769123,
0.1900241673,
0.2387782782,
0.0213187262,
0.6776959896,
-1.1614714861,
-0.4164447188,
-0.1714475155,
-0.8154994249,
-0.5186808109,
0.5639874339,
-0.3527237475,
0.1216828823,
0.3111280203,
-0.6966366172,
0.4265826046,
0.3932249248,
-0.4848258495,
-0.1684402227,
0.1223458648,
0.3326779902,
-1.0830821991,
0.3050178289,
-0.0830242261,
-0.5603814721,
-0.3027383089,
0.3620042205,
0.2641488612,
-0.4833330512,
-0.4451285601,
0.5976832509,
-0.4635046721,
-0.3075411022,
-0.4091001153,
0.7310041189,
-0.0115165887,
-0.1224759147,
0.3438048065,
0.7979588509,
0.5625781417,
-0.4776163995,
0.0524933673,
0.149136126,
-0.4367026091,
0.4739578962,
-0.4273345172,
0.1051104367,
-0.1177493557,
0.1726288497,
-1.0824940205,
-0.4874712527,
0.0547003746,
-0.5241665244,
-0.4101195931,
-0.4696900249,
-0.4700517654,
-0.2375756055,
-0.383941561,
0.0272729024,
0.1862455606,
-0.5133401155,
0.3107267916,
0.7150962949,
-0.3415976763,
-0.350982517,
-0.6999070048,
0.3014548421,
0.0495375246,
-0.5517049432,
0.1500681043,
0.2676541805,
-0.1195892915,
0.4479881823,
-0.1837819815,
-0.2365382612,
0.3869822323,
0.3057467043,
0.0231555942,
-0.4676836431,
-0.1354777068,
-0.1015303954,
-0.3308933079,
-0.1556050926,
-0.3011000454,
0.3667899668,
0.0644482598,
-0.2469031066,
-0.1098198369,
0.4297066033,
0.3658678532,
-0.4680271447,
0.5167842507,
0.2683252394,
-0.5385686755,
-0.1703543365,
-0.2831997573,
0.1352038682,
-0.4148072004,
-0.1120054349,
-0.0605320185,
-1.0001299381,
0.2931581736,
-0.1513485312,
-0.0960482061,
0.5534394383,
-0.0631493926,
-0.3864643276,
1.0294821262,
0.7595580816,
-0.0458340906,
0.3812369108,
-0.0096804481,
0.3364028931,
-0.4804590344,
-0.1827550828,
-0.7959196568,
-0.2276355177,
-0.3653823137,
-0.34592399,
0.3871515393,
0.0136222802,
0.2656924725,
0.4505004883,
-0.4594656229,
0.4964497685,
0.9335778356,
-0.0672383085,
0.2615761459,
0.03375341,
0.1814486235,
-0.1201877221,
-0.6399137974,
-0.463906914,
0.4683527052,
0.0681380555,
0.7473002672,
0.3093807697,
0.6669473052,
0.2675180137,
0.316339612,
-0.6403522491,
0.3741026223,
-0.0274658781,
-0.8922169209,
-0.3307980299,
-0.4828187227,
-0.8330873251,
0.1379240155,
-0.0589640625,
-0.5101706386,
0.0195709951,
0.199636519,
-0.3755805492,
0.2257984728,
-0.6319802403,
0.7760173678,
-0.3486446142,
0.0888977572,
0.2244992852,
-0.7261682749,
0.1386933923,
0.4016759694,
0.4646189511,
-0.6247403622,
-0.0225115046,
0.3417121768,
-0.377228111,
0.4063833058,
-0.4785481095,
0.170952037,
0.1943243742,
0.2833061516,
0.2647530138,
0.0834688619,
0.041582942,
0.2203213722,
-0.3624686003,
-0.4587344527,
-0.368231535,
0.7905915976,
-0.5218424797,
-0.2064952999,
-0.6345791221,
-0.4826410413,
-0.0142871421,
0.5928540826,
0.1571807712,
0.5151429176,
-0.3242627382,
0.11634738,
0.6590895057,
-0.2794851661,
0.2217974216,
0.9421955943,
-0.4482432008,
-0.2192371935,
0.8628576994,
0.1931779087,
-0.1685904115,
0.5821951628,
0.2229139656,
-0.5072469711,
-0.3751942813,
-0.3947499394,
0.1104847491,
-0.4281661212,
-0.2050402611,
-0.5578194857,
0.037593022,
-0.391081959,
-0.4908269644,
-0.3312838972,
-0.4386079907,
0.1309323013,
-0.1565163732,
0.5191349983,
0.8881588578,
0.2769845128,
0.5996789932,
-0.6034556031,
0.8169010282,
-0.0644882917,
0.6203352213,
-1.0903090239,
0.0548940301,
-0.3596636653,
-0.1361653805,
-0.3050218523,
-0.7929192185,
0.5570518374,
-0.079899393,
0.5176751018,
0.2684930861,
0.2577608228,
0.3984415829,
-0.3881803453,
0.8805163503,
-0.0378635563,
-0.6878349185,
1.2628209591,
-0.5127220154,
0.6090494394,
0.7261074781,
0.5762553215,
-0.6828758121,
-0.735979557,
-0.4915342629,
-1.1430202723,
1.318811655,
0.1135047078,
-0.3732551932,
-0.1408082992,
-0.0305230096,
-0.002730699,
0.3669792116,
-0.4187587798,
-0.0927034765,
-0.1049033552,
-0.2807041109,
-0.0969927311,
-0.3461747766,
-0.4192374647,
0.3368169665,
0.4333702624,
-0.1011204496,
-0.046923276,
0.5518339276,
-0.5457698703,
-0.1958864182,
0.1522546709,
0.462150842,
0.9087080956,
-0.7128474712,
0.5615243316,
-0.1200111955,
-0.45781371,
-0.359456867,
0.3694017529,
-0.7125920057,
0.5706050396,
0.0841582641,
0.6991680861,
0.4534191787,
-0.4777276218,
0.6436436176,
-0.0982202739,
0.0074847951,
-0.2207211703,
-0.0305953268,
0.1365123689,
0.0285797827,
0.7509019375,
0.0597194955,
0.479290843,
-0.7533280253,
0.0966858938,
0.1921849251,
-0.5932119489,
-0.0182710197,
0.7796922922,
0.25001055,
-0.6519634724,
0.5235456228,
-0.1063972563,
-0.6059839725,
0.4272459745,
0.3451644778,
0.6732453108,
-0.2826420963,
0.2268469185,
0.064499557,
0.6268328428,
-0.1399450451,
0.4809449017,
-0.1892911643,
-0.5548624396,
-0.158556968,
-0.3245441318,
-0.4194547236,
-0.2244629562,
-0.6456544399,
0.3585888445,
-0.4089029729,
-0.1511479169,
-0.2007602155,
-0.1259287596,
-0.4647049606,
0.2646788657,
0.2228420824,
1.338973403,
-0.8058414459,
0.4590074122,
1.0479995012,
-0.1319466382,
-0.3599742651,
-0.0281110238,
0.0270324629,
-0.7850052118,
0.279671371,
0.3752734661,
-0.1601595283,
-0.144425258,
-0.9087454677,
-0.9484780431,
1.247728467,
0.2770147324,
-0.1401573122,
0.1710126102,
0.2543649077,
0.1919125766,
0.066217646,
0.185240373,
0.3204685748,
0.2891027629,
-0.1634547412,
-0.6325982809,
0.0428681523,
0.1541176736,
0.0052184709,
0.7590755224,
-0.3535855711,
0.5739442706,
0.1440205127,
-0.3267450929,
-0.2455427498,
0.3484523892,
0.2827472091,
0.9180755615,
0.2922143936,
0.7755379081,
0.6594705582,
-0.5686124563,
1.2375177145,
-0.2894038856,
0.6438819766,
0.8853334785,
-0.4194878936,
0.8317394853,
0.5745213032,
-0.0279712677,
0.3789073825,
0.453042686,
0.5829508305,
0.852206111,
-0.341306746,
-0.2602501214,
-0.1320841312,
-0.16352503,
-0.2473892272,
0.1709006429,
0.4920722842,
-0.1129321679,
-0.9259235859,
-0.0394819342,
-0.1225531101,
0.2513670027,
-0.1992935985,
0.6006065607,
0.1055585146,
-0.4153458476,
-0.3433302939,
0.4295603037,
0.482005924,
-1.0507779121,
-0.2723742723,
-0.4268549085,
-0.2191770524,
-0.1891020536,
-1.2924281359,
0.3589484096,
-0.0173667762,
-0.2825721204,
-0.5073260665,
0.8695651293,
-0.4390391409,
-0.2533208728,
0.1573105752,
0.0864990726,
0.1966203153,
-0.6065275669,
-0.4387079477,
0.0296217408,
-0.3542279601,
-0.1847902536,
-0.0261372086,
0.5482500792,
-0.3015979826,
0.5993034244,
0.8413779736,
0.2861275971,
0.0310196243,
-0.1296961606,
0.6937662959,
-1.0963423252,
-0.8919869065,
-0.5464682579,
0.3144057989,
-0.1570031345,
-0.3849347532,
0.9359868169,
0.8868297338,
0.6743066907,
0.0129527077,
1.0315048695,
-0.4998999238,
1.0234204531,
-0.5264396071,
0.6837876439,
-0.519141078,
0.0693872273,
0.0989901572,
-0.6780228615,
-0.3430349231,
0.5128034353,
-0.4977343082,
-0.4552478194,
0.46405375,
0.7229565978,
-0.6511425376,
-0.3085463345,
0.1006825715,
-0.0791699737,
0.130806163,
0.271117717,
1.1666558981,
-0.2290832549,
0.3261362314,
-0.1944662035,
-0.1382983029,
-0.6634364724,
-0.800563693,
-0.3151650727,
-0.4287408888,
-0.0598224327,
0.0005217063,
0.0139704365,
0.6727235317,
0.7117846012,
-0.8634409308,
-0.0174016245,
0.0125522204,
0.6359233856,
0.2811098695,
-0.344312638,
0.1701923907,
-0.1958960891,
-0.450065285,
0.7122579217,
0.6663127542,
-0.4398117363,
-0.0581146628,
0.0664395094,
-0.3787663579,
-0.112048015,
0.4365513921,
0.5361480117,
-0.4659480155,
-0.1744894385,
0.1476424783,
-0.4855991304,
0.0827327743,
1.1834859848,
-0.7541316152,
0.7319588065,
0.6073200703,
0.5410292745,
0.4444029927,
0.2930321991,
0.4835989177,
-1.2182440758,
0.2232981175,
-0.0436876751,
0.2170177698,
0.568908751,
-0.5092265606,
0.5822330117,
0.4530540407,
-0.1832516044,
-0.7623798847,
-0.0781605989,
-1.1227502823,
-0.1944886446,
1.0720530748,
0.1787967086,
-0.336771518,
-0.3998545706,
-0.5565113425,
-0.0280464124,
-0.5487990379,
0.7855404615,
0.6103743911,
-0.0270885061,
0.0966545939,
-1.0293520689,
0.3449116051,
0.044736512,
-0.6596443057,
-0.5269895196,
0.5209716558,
0.5753451586,
0.2795493603,
0.9443678856,
-0.0136485389,
0.3217235804,
-0.3429210484,
0.4576775432,
-0.1153309494,
-0.2586782277,
-0.2070488781,
0.3179328442,
0.2547215223,
-0.5283325911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08089v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08089v2
|
Improving In-context Learning of Multilingual Generative Language Models with Cross-lingual Alignment
| 2023-11-14T11:24:08 | 2024-06-12T12:25:51 |
Chong Li, Shaonan Wang, Jiajun Zhang, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual generative models obtain remarkable cross-lingual in-context
learning capabilities through pre-training on large-scale corpora. However,
they still exhibit a performance bias toward high-resource languages and learn
isolated distributions of multilingual sentence representations, which may
hinder knowledge transfer across languages. To bridge this gap, we propose a
simple yet effective cross-lingual alignment framework exploiting pairs of
translation sentences. It aligns the internal sentence representations across
different languages via multilingual contrastive learning and aligns outputs by
following cross-lingual instructions in the target language. Experimental
results show that even with less than 0.1 {\textperthousand} of pre-training
tokens, our alignment framework significantly boosts the cross-lingual
abilities of generative language models and mitigates the performance gap.
Further analyses reveal that it results in a better internal multilingual
representation distribution of multilingual models.
|
[
-0.2669110894,
-0.2773765326,
0.2190735489,
0.2969312072,
-0.252833575,
0.1765217632,
-0.3917660117,
-0.2615097761,
0.0704275072,
0.0729147419,
-0.4900839031,
-0.3306238353,
-0.3883316517,
0.0835905373,
0.0067502824,
0.8905137181,
-0.0451710522,
0.4731885195,
-0.3145749867,
-0.3566679358,
-0.4361956716,
-0.3468204141,
-0.3517511189,
-0.2177473605,
0.4751199782,
0.3223308027,
0.645530045,
0.4300484955,
0.4054510295,
0.283301115,
0.1050085425,
0.216625452,
-0.5815243125,
0.0088234441,
-0.2721288502,
-0.3080418706,
-0.1743089259,
-0.4325554967,
0.8876597285,
0.820691824,
-0.0770191327,
-0.2699927986,
0.2262329608,
0.4632164538,
-0.4925422072,
0.1802529693,
-0.497603476,
0.2648561299,
-0.4113846123,
-0.1943049878,
-0.4688098729,
-0.0845649317,
0.1310697049,
-0.9075425267,
0.1272344887,
0.1274216175,
0.9149783254,
0.0479364358,
-0.4780862331,
-0.051885169,
-0.135665372,
0.6952677965,
-0.5116557479,
0.6845763326,
-0.03525934,
0.2376519293,
0.2377551794,
-0.3821931183,
-0.3812701106,
0.1235384867,
-0.3912618458,
0.1278664172,
0.0365487859,
-0.2024970204,
0.0172446463,
0.413774699,
-0.7868499756,
0.325979054,
-0.1320279986,
-0.2182307988,
0.3003954887,
-0.0401128046,
0.4790845215,
-0.0043469258,
-0.7723249197,
-0.2699525058,
-0.9823436141,
-0.0410633013,
0.4266663194,
0.6096885204,
-0.5327757597,
0.4891663194,
0.1116929352,
0.6822145581,
0.2471005023,
0.0961702839,
0.4418880641,
-0.7629512548,
-0.0747439712,
0.2577880621,
0.7904843092,
0.2687047422,
0.1169875413,
-0.4250685275,
-0.0499584004,
-0.0609347522,
0.1697718352,
-0.9442356825,
-0.1052750722,
-0.2191786319,
-0.2900032103,
-0.0008370674,
0.1288841516,
-0.7621505857,
-0.0969582871,
-0.2938901484,
0.3046812415,
-0.4972722828,
-0.3653409779,
-0.020783009,
0.1249620169,
0.2001943439,
-0.0272842627,
-1.1780883074,
0.0062102629,
0.5312264562,
0.7690152526,
-0.0835649595,
-0.5127331018,
-0.8327581882,
0.3851216733,
-0.4624788463,
0.5158671141,
-0.5316998959,
-0.1548023224,
0.2272109985,
0.1201504767,
-0.304344058,
-0.4522055984,
0.0744777545,
-0.6122555137,
0.5156649351,
-0.2954959869,
-0.596940577,
-0.0017901226,
0.1680283397,
-0.6285749674,
0.8486505747,
0.1343274266,
-0.879725039,
0.4600428939,
-0.6939153671,
-0.6584209204,
0.0369032063,
-0.2855513096,
-0.3074152172,
-0.0393384099,
0.4055205286,
0.3831827343,
-0.1661414951,
0.2958885431,
-0.3057815135,
-0.3229337633,
0.0116230249,
-0.3380527794,
1.0533713102,
0.1779462397,
-0.3532944322,
0.3747956753,
-0.5406197309,
-0.0469020493,
-0.1772097498,
-0.2243650407,
-0.4369423687,
-0.5344681144,
0.2480468154,
0.4340213537,
0.235894829,
-0.380055666,
0.0585766993,
-0.4946798682,
0.1238778457,
0.7422863841,
-0.5557366014,
0.9804509282,
0.0238175485,
0.6407058835,
0.424618125,
-0.2542556822,
-0.3314999938,
-0.1308203638,
-0.4654518366,
-0.2732905746,
0.4861697853,
0.4652213454,
-1.0343661308,
0.473185271,
-0.5013421774,
-0.1488253325,
-0.7678416967,
0.4353178144,
0.8012066483,
0.6650494337,
0.4081821144,
-0.389274627,
-0.4605685472,
-0.7711823583,
-0.0470027924,
0.0630071312,
0.1056541577,
-0.077184245,
0.2844141126,
-0.2451443523,
0.6717787981,
-0.2097122073,
-0.1839207411,
-0.2192364782,
0.1652363837,
-0.2745059133,
0.686622858,
0.5624664426,
-1.0939593315,
-0.7068859339,
0.4843981862,
-0.9483420849,
-0.1092402264,
0.0678176507,
-0.651751101,
0.3842501342,
0.6435685754,
-0.4787530005,
-0.0424720198,
0.8573920727,
-0.4446958005,
0.1898928881,
-0.2357450128,
0.049798958,
-1.4011827707,
0.1113740057,
0.0608698539,
-0.1982377619,
-0.4621045887,
0.1887248307,
0.3865532875,
-0.0575872771,
-0.4716148078,
0.6205201149,
-0.6536462903,
-0.1910286695,
0.0963684097,
0.2899712324,
0.170330286,
0.4795466065,
0.2808766663,
0.9042147994,
0.6586921811,
-0.3970728815,
0.0998610929,
0.3762367666,
-0.5907695293,
0.938608408,
-0.2722741663,
-0.0912237167,
-0.1302656978,
0.2608729005,
-0.764316082,
-0.1151116416,
0.2880545259,
-0.1173581779,
0.6330662966,
-0.1132158265,
-0.3995507061,
0.34278512,
-0.0123461932,
0.8626781106,
0.1410758048,
-0.8388015032,
0.5562674403,
0.2537754774,
-0.0761621073,
-0.8269536495,
-0.7557674646,
-0.062895745,
-0.3919430375,
-0.7226719856,
0.7112445235,
-0.066247642,
-0.1426483393,
0.13758865,
0.1370564401,
0.1418429762,
-0.200834021,
-0.1625090539,
0.2363347113,
-0.471488744,
0.2977938056,
0.009514207,
-0.123586759,
-0.2512083352,
-0.4167869091,
0.6019080281,
-0.1120453924,
-0.3826321959,
-0.0859691724,
0.5424290299,
0.3566885293,
-0.3970195353,
0.8287649155,
0.8071644902,
-0.3061377704,
-0.0053186975,
-0.2500968874,
-0.0172712188,
-0.4235497117,
0.449962616,
-0.6666086912,
-0.7778101563,
0.4242070615,
0.0869767517,
-0.1037122086,
0.3656287193,
0.4329563975,
0.0405309163,
0.8829540014,
0.9036791325,
-0.0616746768,
0.5766686201,
-0.0890867785,
0.4278039038,
-0.8847264647,
-0.2212493867,
-0.2108792365,
-0.0362989679,
-0.6501127481,
-0.501753509,
0.2981093526,
0.3559953868,
-0.3284035921,
0.4421218336,
-0.1318555921,
0.3841234148,
0.4581744373,
-0.021589376,
0.0867059156,
0.1679124683,
-0.4729409218,
-0.21446459,
-1.0461319685,
-0.1773677468,
0.7465580106,
0.0487985238,
0.6301820874,
0.3361943066,
0.6955795884,
-0.2831444144,
0.4230895042,
-0.3307180703,
0.1490001529,
-0.3608157635,
-0.4136322737,
-0.3000004292,
-0.6640405655,
-0.6708765626,
0.6649872661,
-0.0823011026,
-0.4378516078,
0.2267946154,
0.0816530883,
-0.2370541096,
0.3316791356,
-0.8501573205,
1.5570652485,
-0.6056978703,
-0.5626953244,
-0.0327287093,
-0.8696772456,
0.2107811123,
-0.0666699484,
0.2999632061,
0.1560021341,
0.0403980352,
0.3292279243,
-0.3464202285,
0.9299371243,
0.0004306604,
-0.4073094726,
-0.1321755648,
-0.1060807556,
0.2755750716,
-0.0334993899,
0.0702790469,
0.1570179015,
-0.2471439391,
-0.567977488,
-0.4947975874,
0.6466700435,
-0.579349041,
-0.3580796719,
-0.312794596,
-0.6971042752,
-0.2976929545,
0.1813414097,
0.6432922482,
0.4259028137,
-0.4896264672,
0.1285614818,
0.660076499,
-0.1760635674,
0.457215935,
0.2785429358,
-0.1971877515,
-0.5105241537,
0.9655280709,
-0.1472321749,
0.5198205113,
0.9582049251,
-0.0229705498,
-0.5940202475,
-0.0597378351,
-0.9170684814,
0.1519600898,
-0.8745145798,
-0.2233694941,
-0.537119031,
0.050839819,
-0.5991641283,
-0.3688640296,
-0.2008537799,
-0.1456371993,
-0.1953602433,
-0.1232328266,
-0.0348392315,
0.2463661879,
-0.1794802696,
0.1939077377,
-0.7757658362,
0.2311897874,
0.160539791,
0.3135344088,
-0.0607283711,
-0.4231782556,
-0.4259478152,
0.0430056192,
-0.2032554895,
-0.5575116873,
0.3335677385,
0.2661859095,
0.500451088,
0.606618762,
-0.1796538383,
1.0733883381,
-0.5348281264,
0.5144833922,
0.6341174841,
-1.066257,
0.1529431939,
-0.1724096835,
0.5753384829,
0.4439333081,
0.4629972875,
-0.7599390745,
-0.1538122892,
-0.3243000209,
-0.749730289,
0.664860487,
-0.0741126388,
0.1087175608,
-0.0433066301,
-0.2609469891,
0.3125902116,
0.18063429,
-1.0834178925,
0.0743555129,
-0.3757996857,
-0.5090661645,
-0.4005598128,
-0.0281667933,
-0.2741045952,
-0.1992696971,
0.6807462573,
-0.5659402013,
-0.0459373519,
-0.1585931182,
-0.4883873463,
-0.2532933056,
0.2100271881,
0.5196857452,
0.7178372741,
0.1595433056,
0.2714886665,
0.0801987723,
0.1085057184,
0.192673564,
0.3650554121,
-0.0900959149,
-0.0503042042,
0.4314549863,
0.8783375025,
0.8433529735,
-0.6426767111,
0.5586013198,
0.0408912636,
0.1531262994,
-0.0185136329,
-0.3911161721,
0.3660134375,
0.2808297575,
-0.0324664526,
0.0607730299,
-0.18388547,
-0.5821114779,
0.2020478398,
0.5756289363,
-0.3505429626,
-0.2449149042,
0.7948254347,
0.1369495988,
-0.0321412683,
0.6756336093,
-0.1626507044,
-0.665566206,
0.347266078,
0.8211700916,
0.7148759961,
-0.2207431495,
0.3030672371,
0.3541313112,
0.0597129762,
-0.1305778325,
0.0064862468,
-0.2650146782,
-0.9452243447,
-0.4694971144,
-0.593174696,
-0.1825977564,
-0.3141026795,
-0.5818252563,
0.216042608,
0.1625582278,
0.3286450207,
-0.182152763,
-0.3417971134,
-0.6634813547,
0.1472584903,
0.1734389216,
0.6513773799,
-0.8437508345,
0.9172856212,
0.5605825186,
-0.6422191262,
-0.5758120418,
0.0421435423,
-0.1630473584,
-0.6913257241,
0.9088304043,
0.4433703125,
-0.2375689447,
-0.2381263226,
-0.0755009055,
-0.9137527347,
0.7992526293,
0.7364215255,
-0.7457921505,
-0.1080167443,
0.1984690875,
0.4932240844,
-0.659787178,
0.0256931018,
0.001785605,
0.3053262234,
-0.0881764591,
-0.8156787157,
0.0605551265,
-0.4220573604,
0.2324585766,
0.2868501246,
-0.557541132,
0.7736282349,
-0.110462673,
-0.3476931155,
0.0034057617,
0.830760479,
0.2337450385,
0.1417127997,
0.4917896092,
0.7985390425,
0.6789799929,
-0.1361541897,
1.0172995329,
-0.4161410034,
0.0350960828,
1.2071228027,
-0.4236253798,
0.7786986232,
0.6829399467,
0.1889638156,
0.6422157884,
0.6394793391,
0.198675409,
0.8337330222,
0.0374232493,
-0.3212079704,
-0.3407634199,
0.0027238759,
-0.472643286,
0.2156075835,
0.1493213922,
-0.3335662782,
-0.2494434118,
0.1443997622,
-0.0359629244,
0.2656806707,
-0.1352663636,
0.6324321032,
0.0763586909,
-0.9712541103,
0.5806773901,
-0.1729809195,
0.9256439209,
-0.5784018636,
-0.0926394761,
-0.2500126362,
0.3029412925,
-0.1419762373,
-0.4227276146,
0.2143396735,
-0.1318068951,
-0.1632966399,
-0.5735629797,
0.1966768652,
-1.1187419891,
-0.500803411,
0.6667255759,
0.4546826482,
-0.0547401123,
0.2667652369,
-0.5412538052,
-0.0244270694,
-0.1754324138,
0.1512159556,
0.5466964245,
0.651458323,
-0.1998599917,
0.2517972589,
0.3930538893,
-0.1310401559,
0.2000351697,
0.3915167153,
0.5491274595,
-0.364213258,
-0.6812134981,
-0.7765461206,
0.5398759842,
-0.1957485676,
-0.5014175773,
0.7165364623,
0.729647994,
1.5904371738,
-0.0310427845,
0.6203812361,
-0.0527617894,
0.0593146197,
-0.8347133398,
0.5621095896,
-0.7547009587,
0.0723364949,
-0.1351246536,
-0.8742591739,
-0.3194366992,
0.6532819271,
-0.1767609119,
0.0886568204,
0.7250545621,
0.8611628413,
-0.348298192,
-0.1890208423,
0.3146255314,
-0.1340103447,
0.1633039564,
0.6461619139,
0.758251965,
-0.4208669066,
0.5697695613,
-0.4346119165,
0.0374586321,
-0.0635498613,
-0.904966414,
-0.7853485942,
-0.7162691951,
-0.3034029305,
-0.1871540993,
0.1273961961,
0.8059540987,
0.8163242936,
-0.7721226811,
-0.4366855621,
-0.1963205487,
0.0748316646,
-0.5438524485,
-0.2194022089,
0.4384661317,
-0.7700440288,
-0.9060817957,
0.5928561091,
0.2142078876,
0.0400553457,
-0.213877961,
-0.4231761396,
-0.3757433593,
-0.4123146534,
0.5851228237,
0.2257950306,
-0.7520262599,
-0.1196480319,
-0.065413177,
-0.4465048313,
0.2394149303,
0.8560857177,
-0.4182181358,
0.5855182409,
0.4734832048,
0.8362860084,
0.4666065574,
-0.0818053111,
0.9623746872,
-1.0523841381,
0.2170387059,
-0.0011222975,
0.6426591873,
0.7995020747,
-0.3788466454,
0.4500997365,
0.0142691787,
-0.1436959952,
-0.7118818164,
0.2313947529,
-0.6833357811,
-0.3494619727,
0.8770338893,
-0.3308618069,
0.0097040748,
0.2568292022,
-0.0619135387,
0.4885268807,
-0.0821245685,
0.6521208286,
0.747256577,
0.1760410219,
-0.2246265262,
-0.09623871,
0.4925602674,
0.7799534202,
-0.8166374564,
0.0751697868,
0.481741786,
0.1695878059,
0.302305907,
0.4603718221,
-0.3111405373,
0.2761258781,
-0.1022521853,
0.0925511569,
0.2798720002,
-0.4493603706,
-0.5681985617,
0.2639474571,
-0.2715955675,
-0.1786828488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08057v1
|
Data and models for stance and premise detection in COVID-19 tweets: insights from the Social Media Mining for Health (SMM4H) 2022 shared task
| 2023-11-14T10:30:49 | 2023-11-14T10:30:49 |
Vera Davydova, Huabin Yang, Elena Tutubalina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI, I.2.7; J.3
|
The COVID-19 pandemic has sparked numerous discussions on social media
platforms, with users sharing their views on topics such as mask-wearing and
vaccination. To facilitate the evaluation of neural models for stance detection
and premise classification, we organized the Social Media Mining for Health
(SMM4H) 2022 Shared Task 2. This competition utilized manually annotated posts
on three COVID-19-related topics: school closures, stay-at-home orders, and
wearing masks. In this paper, we extend the previous work and present newly
collected data on vaccination from Twitter to assess the performance of models
on a different topic. To enhance the accuracy and effectiveness of our
evaluation, we employed various strategies to aggregate tweet texts with
claims, including models with feature-level (early) fusion and dual-view
architectures from SMM4H 2022 leaderboard. Our primary objective was to create
a valuable dataset and perform an extensive experimental evaluation to support
future research in argument mining in the health domain.
|
[
0.0465454385,
-0.7260924578,
0.5228349566,
0.3780259788,
-0.3126123846,
-0.0702113435,
0.0211615507,
-0.3490289152,
0.5181040168,
0.1722395122,
-0.3199883103,
-0.7652336955,
-0.652438581,
-0.2381721586,
-0.4061244428,
0.9766795635,
0.0715146512,
-0.0964752063,
-0.5229734778,
-0.0934488103,
-0.1482792497,
-0.5887050629,
-0.6256796718,
-0.3309817314,
0.2865776718,
0.4104357958,
0.3617598116,
0.0769350901,
0.3511879146,
0.1350228339,
-0.091355063,
-0.0564794727,
-0.1290673763,
0.0100497222,
-0.3091984093,
-0.1983326524,
-0.5523850918,
0.2226901948,
0.3337542713,
0.1730100811,
-0.2324929982,
0.3490303457,
0.0638036132,
-0.0064209187,
-0.3284917772,
-0.1099283472,
-0.5756670237,
0.0383569971,
-0.2479430586,
-0.2707684338,
-0.3229373991,
0.064781785,
0.3154590428,
-0.203143388,
0.2543248236,
-0.3063985109,
1.0977960825,
-0.0004884647,
-0.4321944416,
0.0436438136,
-0.2122530937,
0.5345802903,
-0.8022004962,
0.0699547306,
0.535731256,
0.1361809224,
0.0353124812,
-0.7178978324,
-0.3421054184,
0.2144004703,
0.117754519,
-0.0043231407,
-0.5122909546,
-0.0579949692,
0.0160118919,
0.0522325039,
-0.5394903421,
0.0122339623,
-0.2925134599,
-0.2951071262,
0.7073987126,
-0.2202338725,
0.5242351294,
-0.8222299218,
-0.5140246153,
0.3145731091,
-0.2597030103,
0.4230732918,
-0.144945085,
0.0598631166,
-0.5939648151,
0.5421072245,
-0.1732197553,
0.4122847617,
0.4042114317,
-0.2002956569,
0.2734952271,
-0.3724348545,
-0.3434165418,
0.0205967538,
0.9564002752,
0.5216345191,
-0.3564691544,
0.0205678213,
-0.032333944,
0.0650953352,
0.3389426172,
-0.8749758005,
-0.3692142069,
0.3162830174,
-0.6693498492,
-0.6178333163,
-0.043526534,
-0.6526466012,
-0.7570108771,
-0.1271592528,
0.5127251148,
-0.3171904087,
-0.4217587113,
0.062932156,
-0.4878808856,
0.1883252114,
0.3980461955,
-0.6024640799,
0.2995758653,
0.998934865,
1.052031517,
-0.2480111718,
0.2720609605,
-0.4149168134,
-0.035169553,
-0.2738033533,
0.8845200539,
-0.5149386525,
0.1136014611,
-0.1695837677,
-0.2577937543,
-0.2351485938,
-0.4401767552,
0.8544844389,
-0.3672782481,
0.1572700292,
-0.3890089393,
-0.4852204323,
-0.1446056664,
0.84813869,
-0.6347181201,
0.7348405719,
-0.1508550197,
-1.110911727,
0.5145148039,
-0.5353750587,
-0.5505356789,
0.2276478559,
-0.5355604887,
-0.7959350348,
-0.0017744877,
0.3681542873,
0.8035647273,
-0.1887902319,
0.4990843534,
-0.6875402927,
0.0100036049,
-0.0580652393,
-0.0653219521,
1.2633558512,
-0.0865323022,
-0.5410291553,
0.2911127508,
-0.2913347483,
-0.3026199937,
0.1671638042,
0.2259630263,
-0.3951539695,
0.2686521709,
-0.1962453425,
0.4537172616,
0.1614929587,
-0.3833147287,
-0.0684771836,
-0.3019377291,
0.6199079156,
0.2956446707,
0.6694988012,
0.1830461621,
-0.3810527325,
0.5396206379,
0.081539534,
0.4006948769,
0.1539242566,
-0.9012752771,
-0.1965078115,
-0.4220599532,
-0.2068124712,
0.4342389405,
-0.4673148692,
0.3410406113,
-0.2681740224,
-0.5633767247,
-0.1849380732,
-0.2012102455,
-0.0138094816,
0.6508954167,
0.3190872371,
0.0770284384,
-0.8217359185,
-0.6792820096,
-0.3473232388,
-0.2410229146,
0.3668448329,
0.0064632567,
0.5308739543,
-0.1466062963,
0.7855793238,
-0.2292849123,
-0.0085960478,
-0.1996285617,
0.2935645282,
0.0868800059,
0.0886184722,
0.7777374983,
-1.0672310591,
-0.3519663215,
-0.1240690202,
-0.8479577303,
-0.0096175922,
0.1794183105,
0.1349235028,
0.0261535682,
0.3862197995,
-0.6147063375,
0.7395710945,
0.4581240714,
-0.3433790505,
0.4458529949,
0.4365070164,
0.2625623643,
-1.585745573,
-0.0443436801,
0.402438134,
-0.3588218391,
-0.8899094462,
-0.0915810764,
-0.1653987765,
-0.1810450554,
-0.3817506731,
0.4208465517,
0.1190876886,
0.3206362128,
-0.2476924509,
-0.2914929688,
0.2251937389,
-0.1948806792,
0.1608698368,
0.2068466246,
0.5671203136,
-0.3511989415,
0.1806271225,
0.1481657177,
-0.2540542781,
0.4220322073,
-0.6764289141,
-0.1003829688,
0.0523211583,
0.5625987649,
-1.0098316669,
-0.6160271168,
0.5320683122,
-0.8204147816,
-0.3426290751,
-0.1504667401,
-0.2525172532,
-0.5329871774,
-0.6226232052,
0.3269858956,
0.2001481503,
-0.5356759429,
0.4103992581,
0.7398822308,
-0.0507953912,
-0.6051005721,
-0.4628281593,
0.3184322715,
-0.6650176644,
-0.6913858652,
0.640643239,
0.4301645458,
-0.5058789253,
0.0117272735,
-0.2425550073,
-0.0868210271,
0.2734475732,
0.4326240122,
-0.0003297899,
-0.092843473,
0.0875156894,
-0.0734336823,
0.3218108714,
0.2890216112,
-0.2396885753,
0.6038031578,
-0.2502736151,
-0.1315206587,
-0.7029873133,
0.2940339148,
0.4415863156,
-0.1179799214,
0.8024731874,
0.6759015918,
-1.0012437105,
-0.1830086708,
-0.3434825838,
-0.1327435821,
-0.3722495735,
-0.0566148534,
0.0566366762,
-0.6186414361,
0.3781557977,
0.1537101865,
-0.0861143842,
0.7081606388,
0.7165665627,
-0.249670729,
0.6867551208,
0.4332253039,
-0.0756447911,
0.2456469238,
-0.2335334718,
0.3434123695,
-0.3007577956,
-0.4948019683,
-0.2923972905,
-0.1143146902,
-0.3505162001,
-0.5703215003,
0.3106926382,
-0.0607552566,
-0.0353365764,
0.479393065,
-0.5186655521,
-0.1592335254,
0.2368089259,
0.5423941016,
-0.1502243429,
0.109476909,
-0.1335429698,
-0.0958406106,
-0.6378443837,
-0.4231257737,
0.7784297466,
0.4511090815,
0.1500066817,
0.0417060144,
0.9485276937,
0.6368986964,
0.2595506012,
-0.8808642626,
0.5225356817,
-0.2515610456,
-0.5170261264,
-0.0439790189,
0.0014865389,
-0.7042779922,
-0.0951959938,
-0.2533726394,
-0.8328668475,
0.3453419209,
0.1221020669,
-0.6685096622,
0.3172031641,
-0.4984326065,
0.9172555804,
-0.1679893881,
-0.3879938424,
-0.3128699064,
-0.6275390387,
0.3284679353,
0.0971853584,
-0.0169858504,
-0.3288803995,
0.1519735754,
0.9974793792,
-0.4703171551,
1.0354599953,
-0.298749119,
0.023004381,
0.5700194836,
-0.6491304636,
-0.0132699003,
0.268588841,
-0.3510972559,
0.1651353389,
0.0313744135,
-0.4111956656,
-0.1297838241,
0.5614523888,
-0.7312625647,
-0.5948544145,
-0.7497047186,
-0.0993399918,
0.0287742186,
0.2090644687,
0.3704732955,
0.4269613028,
-0.4235876203,
0.4200183153,
0.4601131976,
-0.1225475445,
0.3816528916,
-0.0817031935,
-0.0498631187,
-0.5328338146,
0.56124264,
0.1612756997,
-0.2198698819,
0.4419213533,
0.840790689,
-0.2348857075,
-0.5495889783,
0.0667629763,
-0.0509469137,
-0.4494342804,
-0.2803115249,
-0.8100306988,
-0.4728704393,
-0.9714801311,
-0.03566714,
-0.0410223268,
-0.2343243361,
-0.1952205747,
-0.2964289486,
0.5236006975,
0.7033967972,
-0.104208231,
0.2750796974,
-0.4020774961,
0.5316613913,
0.1452637315,
-0.0644284189,
-0.1287222803,
-0.204113245,
-0.0913339108,
0.1291113496,
-0.5587562323,
-0.9217068553,
0.2292332202,
0.1146465838,
0.4833811522,
0.7757667303,
0.2728093863,
0.5750319362,
-0.2965815663,
0.8823430538,
0.2744816542,
-0.7389311194,
0.7093094587,
-0.571167469,
-0.1859235018,
0.4142730832,
0.569193244,
-0.3818248212,
0.0644422546,
-0.8210718632,
-0.6508722305,
0.4612330496,
0.1984046102,
-0.1524201334,
-0.0977516919,
0.2338426262,
0.0365797989,
0.1021465138,
-0.5482369065,
0.0369120352,
-0.3184159398,
-0.2326958627,
0.2107220888,
-0.2746139169,
-0.3608010113,
-0.566644609,
0.3606097996,
0.2020339519,
0.2235255092,
0.0988220498,
0.0443403386,
0.0514967218,
0.1722285151,
0.4392364919,
0.6644893289,
-0.3189637363,
0.370760411,
-0.1165842712,
-0.5103900433,
0.0781516433,
0.2810615897,
-0.4157394171,
0.1870116293,
0.3680842817,
0.8436194062,
0.0952481404,
-0.2061539888,
0.861859858,
0.1394843906,
-0.3276515305,
-0.4096786678,
-0.1247260347,
0.2393551767,
0.1473392695,
0.238326326,
0.3813923001,
0.4044787586,
-0.6449422836,
0.8508115411,
0.493106693,
-0.1940408498,
-0.7622254491,
0.6260396838,
-0.023273835,
-0.3044133186,
0.0799679607,
0.0406770408,
-0.7096614242,
0.6577221751,
0.3635096252,
0.7742238045,
-0.4587630332,
0.6629793048,
0.5473432541,
0.1959166974,
-0.1528289467,
0.2464158386,
0.0815180093,
-0.7007518411,
-0.2560536265,
-0.3049484789,
-0.1683144569,
0.5675945878,
-0.772477746,
0.638687551,
-0.4942957461,
-0.5290543437,
0.4797688723,
0.1420603693,
-0.4158139825,
0.3490148485,
0.4613034427,
0.8260296583,
-1.29299438,
0.5712057352,
0.9880672693,
-0.2366144657,
-0.5743160844,
0.7827845216,
0.2498732656,
-0.5648123026,
0.1349474639,
0.6588012576,
-0.074440442,
-0.4888050556,
-0.7613063455,
-0.4526153505,
1.0858348608,
0.2817696333,
0.1604230255,
-0.0660828799,
0.1673057824,
0.4812188447,
-0.3924262822,
-0.2195506692,
0.2916128933,
0.1674504429,
0.2776870131,
-0.6447764635,
-0.0596401505,
-0.361477077,
-0.4584984779,
-0.23995094,
-0.6123930812,
0.5358838439,
-0.097931087,
-0.0816053972,
-0.212948516,
0.7127242684,
0.5610121489,
1.1262714863,
0.4889189601,
0.7863349915,
0.8005072474,
0.1744499952,
0.9097001553,
0.0538917817,
0.3574282527,
1.0644199848,
-0.2634031475,
1.0512763262,
0.3378693163,
0.1479832828,
0.4521036446,
0.9846632481,
0.1842247397,
0.5272677541,
-0.0529341958,
-0.3824205697,
-0.3667298555,
-0.4940633476,
-0.1774855703,
0.5017449856,
0.7570453882,
-0.3270199895,
-0.3136408925,
-0.0062540746,
0.4170668423,
0.0401271917,
-0.3692327738,
0.6813220978,
0.2730437219,
-0.7363048196,
0.3722217977,
0.1035076082,
0.4229424596,
-0.1636674404,
0.0516856574,
0.2996967733,
0.1144524887,
-0.458221823,
-0.7444051504,
0.6166372895,
0.0726547539,
-0.138261646,
-0.1773949116,
1.2305748463,
-0.3425809443,
-0.4579018056,
0.2835169435,
0.3455410898,
-0.0682106093,
-0.2716208398,
-1.0243091583,
-0.0923970044,
-0.2394768745,
-0.1019368842,
0.0215546843,
0.2923513949,
-0.4594943225,
0.215030849,
0.373575449,
-0.1253473163,
0.0416238531,
0.0516717881,
0.6227852702,
-0.1582206041,
-0.4828369319,
-1.1386389732,
0.350638628,
-0.5756029487,
0.0282077566,
1.0118649006,
0.7050824761,
0.3074255586,
0.1275547445,
0.9913365841,
-0.3234172761,
0.4550917745,
-0.0629336536,
0.9105828404,
-0.6742478609,
-0.1954500526,
-0.1124097407,
-0.0170164425,
-0.4954355955,
0.5714610219,
-0.7295541763,
-0.2366340458,
0.4598913789,
0.4619403481,
-0.1472729743,
-0.0487072654,
-0.0991364345,
0.1041296348,
0.4685252011,
0.1457164586,
0.562515974,
-0.4817977548,
0.0771540403,
-0.4249789715,
-0.1842435896,
-0.6442179084,
-1.0242795944,
-1.1613950729,
-0.7751131058,
-0.5911322236,
-0.8919059634,
0.0519213565,
1.2261983156,
0.7572795749,
-1.069906354,
0.0471402183,
-0.0260709655,
0.1036828831,
-0.2921534181,
-0.2023380995,
0.670224607,
0.0260982942,
-0.0818432793,
0.2021282613,
0.3196006715,
-0.2543627322,
0.2934574783,
0.1283145398,
-0.7298258543,
0.1940580159,
0.8063545823,
0.243083775,
-0.700276792,
-0.0929082856,
0.2771081328,
-0.2543700337,
0.2074557245,
0.4804432392,
-0.4984419942,
0.3387205899,
0.7475852966,
0.7143941522,
0.1990127563,
0.4789938331,
0.354714334,
-0.7776579261,
-0.0352426991,
0.3443489373,
0.4016529024,
0.5821832418,
-0.4370536208,
0.2661407292,
0.609747529,
-0.0930018723,
-0.771263361,
-0.0323193111,
-1.2667793036,
0.0013431958,
1.4202914238,
-0.0080582947,
-0.4543173611,
-0.1545432359,
0.0452320687,
0.4004066885,
-0.3673502803,
0.7539625168,
0.652191937,
0.0217348337,
-0.0863885432,
-0.5091212392,
0.64308393,
0.1035261825,
-0.7612528205,
-0.4305387139,
-0.0498252772,
0.4075682759,
0.0388471074,
0.7913475037,
0.0106994957,
0.4069230855,
-0.3383672535,
-0.1230237558,
0.2490035444,
-0.2994939387,
-0.331843704,
0.3532300889,
-0.226020813,
-0.417937845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08045v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08045v4
|
Adversarial Preference Optimization: Enhancing Your Alignment via RM-LLM Game
| 2023-11-14T10:10:31 | 2024-06-03T11:34:05 |
Pengyu Cheng, Yifan Yang, Jian Li, Yong Dai, Tianhao Hu, Peixin Cao, Nan Du, Xiaolong Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Human preference alignment is essential to improve the interaction quality of
large language models (LLMs). Existing alignment methods depend on manually
annotated preference data to guide the LLM optimization directions. However,
continuously updating LLMs for alignment raises a distribution gap between
model-generated samples and human-annotated responses, hindering training
effectiveness. To mitigate this issue, previous methods require additional
preference annotation on newly generated samples to adapt to the shifted
distribution, which consumes a large amount of annotation resources. Targeting
more efficient human preference optimization, we propose an Adversarial
Preference Optimization (APO) framework, in which the LLM and the reward model
update alternatively via a min-max game. Through adversarial training, the
reward model can adapt to the shifted generation distribution of the LLM
without any additional annotation. With comprehensive experiments, we find the
proposed adversarial training framework further enhances existing alignment
baselines in terms of LLM helpfulness and harmlessness. The code is at
https://github.com/Linear95/APO.
|
[
-0.4168969095,
-0.5513848066,
0.213626489,
-0.0925045311,
-0.2650524378,
-0.0763323605,
-0.3778702617,
-0.3772270083,
0.2611556351,
0.5726841092,
-0.7589422464,
-0.3833421469,
-0.6422005296,
-0.0134493532,
0.1311180294,
1.0799467564,
0.1538533419,
0.0965083987,
-0.3259134293,
-0.2828701735,
-0.293554455,
-0.5269895792,
-0.8375911117,
-0.5284107924,
0.4173854291,
0.3267171681,
1.1795454025,
1.1862485409,
0.6148896217,
0.2930364311,
-0.2700149417,
0.2953276634,
-0.6851679087,
0.163967818,
-0.0207816921,
-0.4320410788,
-0.4999406338,
-0.1551700979,
0.4306100011,
0.3150860071,
-0.2503298819,
0.011913537,
-0.124862887,
0.8957780004,
-0.7858067155,
-0.2616615593,
-0.8101494312,
0.1185075492,
-0.2394739836,
-0.2144766152,
-0.3236186504,
-0.5376638174,
0.2199582607,
-0.9415576458,
-0.0392772332,
0.072089754,
1.0548093319,
0.5853908062,
-0.1900922507,
-0.1725600064,
-0.4143308699,
0.6602594256,
-0.5623805523,
0.0512917116,
0.2262524068,
0.2126971632,
-0.364552319,
0.1223938242,
-0.5919649601,
-0.2591196597,
0.1415529698,
0.059505254,
-0.1224316433,
0.2065903544,
0.0841013119,
0.1058811098,
-0.424977392,
0.2817821801,
0.1885237843,
-0.2116691023,
0.8550806642,
0.1306996644,
0.3415704668,
0.142404452,
-0.5269266963,
-0.4234934151,
-0.8832473159,
0.0155191645,
0.8996475339,
0.1824340522,
0.1376662254,
0.5770791769,
0.0965456665,
0.7471718192,
0.3110968769,
-0.0156124802,
0.2671131492,
0.0486359149,
0.0048177233,
0.1755218655,
0.911300838,
0.5861816406,
0.1918686181,
-0.133471176,
-0.1252435893,
0.1317251474,
0.4491392076,
-0.424813509,
-0.3434039056,
-0.0158281904,
-0.0998841673,
-0.7924697399,
-0.1289967149,
-0.6878994107,
-0.7826225758,
-0.2719342113,
0.2878722548,
-0.3850147426,
0.0305564497,
0.1360849291,
-0.0178922266,
-0.0197916422,
0.3480127752,
-1.2695946693,
-0.092978701,
0.7371993661,
0.5419092178,
-0.3039318919,
-0.3109564781,
-0.4444277883,
0.3380741477,
-0.3344308734,
0.7922303081,
-0.4765653908,
-0.367756635,
-0.0584742986,
-0.2301518768,
0.00416015,
-0.6567133665,
0.7345791459,
-0.6591845751,
0.2602529824,
-0.3579239249,
-0.4968675971,
0.0871098712,
0.4763262272,
-0.6545401812,
0.8331964016,
-0.114805311,
-0.7821783423,
0.2988325953,
-0.9052575827,
-0.4596244991,
-0.1342736036,
0.0740802214,
-0.7459431291,
-0.0799924508,
0.4440816939,
0.0561060645,
0.0022680904,
0.0177099686,
-0.7419008017,
-0.406222105,
0.437120378,
-0.2820269167,
0.7506076097,
0.1654200852,
-0.3186004758,
0.5023405552,
-0.4766311049,
-0.3642854691,
0.2288625836,
-0.4164523482,
-0.4597047567,
0.0935855359,
-0.2614306509,
0.1009579003,
0.4970526993,
-0.3688779771,
0.5654779077,
-0.5628422499,
0.1782130152,
1.285205245,
-0.1013095826,
0.8257538676,
-0.4177512228,
0.5946815014,
-0.2507507801,
0.395740658,
0.3777502477,
-0.1787983328,
-0.6433870792,
-0.3118417561,
0.3884136677,
0.5663216114,
-0.6688096523,
0.7452768087,
-0.3565581739,
-0.0769012198,
-0.7887792587,
0.2685119212,
0.3780894578,
0.4874109328,
0.2870015204,
-0.1458911747,
-0.7211247683,
-0.8906808496,
-0.141864717,
-0.268422246,
0.0213744268,
0.5014928579,
0.0109225642,
-0.2766039371,
0.7919344902,
-0.7188381553,
-0.3581906557,
-0.1959441602,
-0.1019068956,
-0.2088776827,
0.3073813617,
0.476511091,
-0.8972164989,
-0.3447844386,
-0.0832466707,
-0.3025759459,
-0.267146349,
-0.0394586772,
-0.5665066242,
0.2084048241,
0.0855461061,
-0.3915692866,
-0.0936232209,
0.5785313249,
-0.1172174141,
0.368640542,
-0.0409426726,
0.1715263873,
-1.2284994125,
0.1071108878,
-0.1535994411,
-0.241507709,
-0.5503437519,
0.1628615856,
0.0027943791,
-0.0354008079,
-0.4708893299,
0.541554749,
-0.1193207204,
0.2368914336,
-0.4753220975,
0.2438432574,
-0.0640130267,
0.3813973367,
0.1823818833,
0.8767215014,
0.2718614042,
-0.451669991,
0.4083970785,
0.4703555703,
0.1251612902,
0.4502420127,
-0.3152210414,
0.3053994477,
-0.0818423629,
0.1650835127,
-0.8779540062,
-0.3022047877,
0.3531553447,
-0.532122612,
0.4304730594,
-0.2146178186,
-0.1053428054,
-0.0048770253,
-0.7994583249,
0.2325891405,
0.3862962723,
-0.8054462671,
0.2703653872,
0.7185422778,
0.1513671875,
-1.0601650476,
-0.4576161802,
0.1061460748,
-0.6062484384,
-0.5308427215,
0.385407865,
-0.1321738064,
-0.0645798519,
-0.1198204309,
0.0292722378,
0.3179945648,
0.3742714822,
0.0773055032,
0.489692986,
0.0578190722,
-0.0720806271,
-0.2170743346,
-0.2441813499,
-0.0172281377,
-0.1544173509,
0.4722427726,
0.1189830452,
-0.1165833399,
-0.2855077982,
0.0296702683,
0.3666881919,
0.0392231084,
0.5719100833,
0.5018517375,
-0.2136188895,
0.0530363433,
-0.3666522801,
-0.0124865221,
-0.5050550699,
0.4694898129,
-0.1757301986,
-0.827116847,
0.337384969,
-0.0001560362,
0.059672609,
0.3174412847,
0.4443647265,
-0.0794945508,
1.3685126305,
0.5074543953,
-0.649744153,
0.762589097,
0.0157499816,
-0.1845856607,
-1.0813088417,
0.037540365,
-0.2806712091,
-0.5358194709,
-0.3596299589,
-0.1583124995,
0.2835214436,
0.1262473166,
-0.3255847692,
0.4946907461,
-0.5751794577,
0.6056172252,
0.4976525307,
0.244396925,
-0.0233646613,
-0.0729265884,
0.0672199205,
-0.2197555602,
-0.5737271905,
-0.4476900697,
1.2676612139,
0.2646872401,
0.8239542842,
0.4385584891,
0.8862069249,
0.2835246623,
0.5113199949,
-0.7368724346,
0.5377100706,
-0.3053468466,
-0.4644165039,
-0.4455854893,
-0.666107893,
-0.7664894462,
0.2158262432,
-0.4920303524,
-0.6253296733,
0.0637716725,
0.5077080131,
-0.45200634,
0.2752750814,
-0.6654817462,
1.0753780603,
-0.3330017328,
-0.3106196821,
0.1137269661,
-0.6300615072,
0.4009578526,
0.1858972013,
-0.007763518,
-0.0751884952,
-0.2150171548,
0.5793499947,
-0.2445372641,
0.5415740013,
-0.1637130231,
-0.0340179987,
-0.0787224248,
0.1476672739,
0.810426116,
0.0831369087,
-0.1921146959,
-0.1514882743,
-0.4681409001,
-0.3309556544,
-0.6153803468,
0.778054893,
-0.9661623836,
-0.7293672562,
-0.4790614545,
-0.6816190481,
-0.2680795491,
-0.0408388041,
0.2651304603,
-0.1419493258,
-0.3118685186,
-0.0808944255,
0.7320474982,
-0.0749737322,
0.2422127128,
0.213139236,
0.177420184,
-0.7416864634,
0.8518774509,
-0.4791687429,
0.3815534413,
0.5965316892,
0.4971983433,
-0.6560357809,
-0.6895534992,
-0.7059915662,
-0.0319959745,
-0.5325475931,
-0.282733202,
-0.2703802884,
0.2382731289,
-0.5092292428,
-0.4025752246,
-0.4186194837,
-0.476339668,
-0.3147717118,
0.0502719432,
0.340649426,
0.3483062983,
-0.1678029746,
0.3222801089,
-0.4829725027,
0.1757654399,
0.2135384679,
-0.0253968816,
-0.2464485019,
-0.7054973245,
-0.145430252,
0.273660481,
-0.5760028958,
-0.7320498228,
0.2445246726,
0.0501296818,
0.2746364176,
0.6262770295,
0.1836238056,
0.9979595542,
-0.4737395644,
0.5945231318,
0.3103141785,
-0.8491178751,
0.4278122187,
-0.2941563427,
0.2457776517,
0.8324673176,
0.192985028,
-0.4457301795,
-0.1736995429,
-0.4850177169,
-0.8507037163,
0.8525029421,
-0.0044411565,
0.0605232827,
0.0867700353,
0.4657810926,
-0.1728800535,
0.1005227491,
-0.8378916979,
-0.415350616,
-0.0996799767,
-0.4039385021,
-0.1773713827,
-0.1346190572,
-0.5411880612,
0.1082907468,
1.0042893887,
-0.096138835,
-0.0693135932,
-0.1048528552,
-0.0541948117,
-0.3720009029,
0.1667884737,
0.7782716751,
0.2235214561,
-0.3035562336,
0.1196777523,
0.3432255685,
-0.3869888783,
0.3152552843,
0.3610031605,
-0.3358797133,
-0.401938647,
0.1202876046,
0.7340651155,
0.074792482,
-0.5662298203,
0.6328294873,
-0.0947831646,
-0.1171672866,
-0.1311685741,
0.235105291,
0.1031487733,
0.0978472829,
0.0411262587,
0.2193577141,
0.1758186817,
-0.317068547,
0.2145564705,
0.7336285114,
-0.4386228621,
-0.0522189662,
0.8500608206,
0.1556149721,
-0.3850956857,
0.1262253821,
-0.4406296313,
-0.7514136434,
0.3364396095,
0.4794647098,
0.7384151816,
-0.3563448787,
0.0945130587,
0.1134048551,
0.2138350755,
-0.1728226393,
-0.152893126,
0.1112416387,
-0.9280202985,
-0.2967160344,
-0.3628059924,
-0.5996727943,
0.2415105253,
-0.5634017587,
0.4578134418,
-0.309210062,
-0.1026729718,
-0.0996134356,
0.0567914359,
-0.1160020381,
0.0583476238,
0.290088892,
0.337313354,
-0.7385584116,
0.7481615543,
0.9437698722,
-0.1018796414,
-0.3760007918,
0.1283293217,
0.2734095454,
-0.9298716187,
0.3286139369,
-0.1257998347,
-0.1597370803,
-0.1621322334,
-0.2754825056,
-0.8146405816,
0.9720393419,
0.6170499325,
-0.4524170756,
0.1410510242,
0.1381864101,
0.5061938763,
-0.3980142772,
0.1434793323,
0.3122169971,
0.2639056742,
0.1869216859,
-0.4721910954,
0.1209226996,
-0.0618725754,
0.1391361207,
0.5812469721,
-0.5907493234,
0.2634367943,
-0.2480263412,
-0.0777762681,
0.1385397315,
0.4847411215,
0.4201366901,
0.0144853825,
0.7503446937,
0.9377757907,
0.5408286452,
-0.0780071244,
0.9260237813,
-0.2817212939,
0.3532811701,
1.2228565216,
-0.4360761642,
0.7260611653,
0.4805471003,
-0.146604985,
-0.0325211771,
0.8542098403,
0.0541237146,
0.6394746304,
0.3881915808,
-0.3801439404,
-0.2554514408,
-0.1120222583,
-0.3718923926,
0.1973317564,
0.0096013006,
-0.2349162251,
0.0177926477,
-0.2377437502,
0.1373583525,
0.309604466,
-0.0547434427,
0.9537058473,
-0.3290779591,
-0.6750640869,
0.6410970092,
-0.020264484,
0.8933052421,
-0.7026531696,
0.1774987429,
-0.1905541271,
0.3533518314,
-0.0702404901,
-0.4853745997,
0.0757227987,
-0.1108939499,
-0.1459288597,
-0.0224619843,
0.4613748193,
-0.6087946892,
-0.1455929428,
0.1796402335,
-0.1216320843,
-0.2013142258,
0.0836658925,
-1.0314027071,
0.1100696251,
0.1652759761,
-0.3491352499,
0.6182979345,
0.1306686103,
0.1901260167,
0.5854358673,
0.8265585303,
0.3262490332,
-0.1634743512,
0.1303954422,
0.8062146306,
-0.3560064137,
-0.4563872814,
-1.0614202023,
0.2022511959,
-0.3236574233,
-0.4539382756,
0.6814427376,
0.6434074044,
0.835654676,
-0.0087607577,
0.7513599992,
0.1586534083,
0.1893076152,
-0.508320272,
0.610543251,
-0.5455636382,
0.4347520173,
-0.2970710099,
-0.9513708353,
-0.4971893728,
0.5786162019,
-0.4240168035,
-0.3130576015,
0.3948940635,
0.930324018,
-0.0260381065,
-0.1560552865,
0.2119999975,
-0.1708472669,
0.3319112659,
0.819666326,
0.8735785484,
-0.2430049628,
0.747841239,
-0.3692143261,
-0.3136668205,
-0.2486046255,
-0.9522250891,
-0.790643096,
-0.2194731086,
-0.381498754,
-0.6270313263,
0.4763870835,
1.2423428297,
0.6702774167,
-0.7369114161,
-0.2021667063,
-0.0063985432,
0.147897765,
-0.2041211277,
-0.2441863269,
0.459987402,
-0.3431327045,
-0.7766032815,
0.3997042179,
0.1470389664,
0.2158222944,
-0.037727233,
-0.3662602305,
-0.3097028136,
-0.1099608317,
0.2470138669,
0.3519089222,
-0.6273178458,
-0.4615652859,
0.0248428043,
-0.1041497961,
0.2523108125,
0.6348670125,
-0.1029151976,
0.599635601,
0.3225657046,
1.0207470655,
0.1241072491,
0.4539119005,
0.7578449249,
-0.7620000839,
0.1609209627,
0.2079062164,
0.3487089276,
0.4854125381,
-0.7241418958,
0.396273911,
0.1593174785,
-0.6498726606,
-0.8422818184,
0.3665952682,
-0.7530398369,
-0.2017906308,
1.3212362528,
-0.1477828324,
-0.2772871852,
0.1133599356,
-0.3902371824,
0.2098286152,
-0.6407192945,
1.2399241924,
0.7812938094,
-0.3028187454,
0.2101163566,
-0.0585048608,
0.993729949,
0.7641336918,
-0.7144154906,
0.2256675661,
0.4173256457,
0.1417015642,
0.0559451878,
0.4022290111,
-0.1102463603,
0.299203217,
-0.3803687394,
0.3067067862,
-0.279450357,
-0.0264962148,
-0.7829974294,
-0.0299698226,
0.2672210932,
-0.5353655219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08011v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08011v2
|
Forgetting before Learning: Utilizing Parametric Arithmetic for Knowledge Updating in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-14T09:12:40 | 2024-02-16T15:49:42 |
Shiwen Ni, Dingwei Chen, Chengming Li, Xiping Hu, Ruifeng Xu, Min Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased their
remarkable capabilities in text understanding and generation. However, even
stronger LLMs are susceptible to acquiring erroneous or obsolete information
from the training corpus. Direct secondary fine-tuning with data containing new
knowledge may be ineffective in updating knowledge due to the conflict between
old and new knowledge. In this paper, we propose a new paradigm for fine-tuning
called F-Learning (Forgetting before Learning), which employs parametric
arithmetic to facilitate the forgetting of old knowledge and learning of new
knowledge. Experimental results on two publicly available datasets demonstrate
that our proposed F-Learning can obviously improve the knowledge updating
performance of both full fine-tuning and LoRA fine-tuning, simultaneously
outperforming the existing baselines in most cases. Moreover, we have also
discovered that forgetting old knowledge by subtracting the parameters of LoRA
can yield a similar effect to subtracting the parameters of full fine-tuning,
and occasionally even surpass it significantly.
|
[
-0.2635473907,
-0.7881785631,
0.640612185,
-0.0963667631,
-0.3454756141,
-0.0388412662,
-0.3822908103,
-0.081097804,
-0.0923005864,
0.521210134,
-0.3575203717,
-0.5516996384,
-0.6646496654,
-0.2440181822,
-0.2852532268,
0.9862038493,
-0.0786424205,
0.0229649413,
-0.4157631099,
-0.3296516836,
-0.2904844284,
-0.334931314,
-1.0858465433,
-0.4080483913,
0.7117916942,
0.616736114,
0.5975362659,
0.6944783926,
0.2836944163,
0.3916527927,
0.0345318578,
0.4081777036,
-0.6471819282,
-0.2073390484,
-0.1900823563,
-0.9255571961,
-0.419516027,
-0.2967707813,
0.9996969104,
0.8622159958,
-0.2689560056,
0.109651871,
0.1239194497,
1.320093751,
-0.8676009774,
0.4547116458,
-1.0000765324,
-0.1612250656,
-0.1544487625,
-0.4646964967,
-0.2670294642,
-0.3729574978,
-0.0617556646,
-0.7892690301,
0.2251820862,
-0.1585438699,
0.7099137902,
0.5741635561,
-0.0309320688,
-0.3774576783,
-0.5988286138,
0.7917429805,
-0.7328144908,
0.634560883,
0.6477796435,
0.2017247975,
-0.0930710211,
-0.2423882484,
-0.40183568,
-0.2035717964,
0.2361482382,
-0.3360381424,
-0.0744159594,
-0.1626179963,
0.4119661748,
0.4589542747,
0.0635534972,
0.0481555946,
-0.5790014267,
-0.0646903738,
0.3987686932,
0.136247769,
-0.0500613637,
0.361564219,
-0.0977287143,
-0.0045631966,
-1.2584532499,
-0.0689195618,
0.3817711771,
0.3065588176,
-0.021074865,
0.1340515465,
-0.4496542811,
0.5511485934,
0.2340672016,
-0.2825668752,
0.4109597206,
-0.0354045667,
-0.2255243063,
-0.2377853096,
0.6106144786,
0.0518392138,
0.5834748149,
-0.1244342402,
-0.385497421,
-0.136987254,
-0.0462730005,
-0.6115260124,
-0.3093405366,
-0.2956775129,
-0.2452790439,
-0.1558864862,
-0.2133473605,
-0.6437321901,
-0.3175374568,
-0.5244101882,
0.7334503531,
-0.8581789732,
-0.0951070115,
0.2709522545,
0.2191081792,
-0.0773297101,
0.498121351,
-1.1710809469,
0.2616888583,
0.7192798257,
0.6171020865,
0.4126364589,
-0.7447417974,
-0.6704161763,
0.1648928076,
-0.5448078513,
0.6830880046,
-0.3741134703,
-0.1292414218,
-0.1054628715,
-0.3970573246,
0.017054202,
-0.6872836351,
0.153417021,
-0.7248867154,
-0.0506565012,
-0.6337597966,
-0.5802078247,
-0.2010000795,
0.0318208858,
-0.6862778068,
0.9391928315,
0.2451310009,
-0.6771586537,
0.5506355166,
-0.2506760359,
-0.4613087773,
-0.2386448681,
-0.1608020514,
-0.4809958041,
0.4233403802,
0.2380037308,
0.3429662585,
-0.4413598478,
0.2324208319,
-0.3512997031,
-0.3948128819,
0.021357188,
-0.3874433637,
0.5020952821,
0.0471891947,
-0.0683594272,
-0.0414558835,
-0.7413568497,
-0.3468232155,
-0.0334059224,
-0.5236668587,
-0.5723510385,
0.3007214963,
-0.8565104604,
0.2304577529,
0.5407865047,
-0.420868963,
-0.0967836753,
-0.6325631738,
0.4847314954,
0.914870441,
0.0182446986,
0.5642789602,
-0.8175070882,
0.2343257815,
0.3541585803,
-0.0795019865,
-0.4013463557,
-0.1947428733,
-1.1694705486,
0.3699114025,
0.3853049278,
0.3415821195,
-0.9180041552,
0.1822503358,
-0.2440526783,
-0.4419223666,
-0.2897008955,
0.7279276252,
0.4779778123,
0.6065823436,
0.5202812552,
0.177015394,
-0.4164838791,
-0.466044724,
-0.372174412,
-0.2723460197,
-0.06555783,
0.1119613126,
0.2910597324,
-0.1332234442,
0.6514735222,
-0.6217850447,
-0.5728673935,
0.036562033,
0.156816408,
-0.1436116248,
0.4427480698,
0.4638073444,
-0.5239710808,
-0.2741641402,
0.0395107269,
-0.5828933716,
0.0696805492,
0.0712163225,
0.0156869236,
0.4585144222,
0.8600678444,
-0.5086988211,
0.0938196033,
0.2915199697,
-0.0374009944,
0.3874669373,
-0.5547451377,
0.0161316823,
-0.8788768053,
-0.1326896697,
0.0496153757,
0.0102416491,
-0.3120755553,
-0.0856624022,
0.4955767095,
0.1084317341,
-0.4400027692,
0.6546554565,
-0.4028682709,
0.3666114211,
-0.2350210845,
0.0073798141,
-0.2230664641,
0.6473531723,
-0.1754299551,
0.7747395635,
0.4331393242,
-0.8589056134,
-0.1977906227,
-0.0128376698,
-0.514177382,
0.2354899943,
-0.2162386477,
0.0661059842,
-0.3970038891,
-0.0292008091,
-0.7014369369,
-0.1539527476,
-0.0229670238,
-0.4444179535,
0.3323925138,
0.0860649794,
-0.490193665,
-0.1490201652,
-0.1657850295,
0.4343634248,
0.5579739213,
-0.2815616429,
0.5442289114,
0.4861717522,
-0.3623884618,
-0.433760792,
-0.3023705482,
-0.4192283452,
-0.2351870686,
-0.3581114113,
0.3159425855,
0.0878722221,
-0.1239511296,
-0.0986760259,
-0.2579620779,
-0.2738007903,
-0.0678649172,
-0.2038053423,
-0.0384697132,
-0.3559090793,
0.5424855351,
0.3142547607,
-0.3499608636,
0.2048441023,
-0.3350297809,
0.5409653783,
-0.0698512048,
-0.2586645484,
-0.2907504439,
0.0580474623,
0.6985678673,
-0.2994627059,
0.7079447508,
0.3986744881,
-0.7069835663,
-0.2435423285,
-0.7836226225,
-0.2158132792,
-0.5548929572,
0.4542269111,
-0.3941062093,
-0.9394565225,
0.4781022072,
-0.1535581797,
0.0816079527,
0.5139493942,
0.4606123269,
-0.1136956662,
0.8738344908,
0.8795093894,
-0.2335745245,
0.7699944377,
-0.1088644639,
-0.0055071819,
-0.5014830828,
-0.1316106766,
-0.4844947159,
-0.2004607767,
-0.2512918413,
-0.545257628,
0.2298161685,
0.3051335514,
-0.4532435238,
0.0268495623,
0.3099459112,
0.6880275607,
0.6013175845,
0.4948686063,
0.3699819148,
0.0133261317,
-0.101631999,
-0.0661955625,
-0.6355448961,
-0.1072749048,
1.4592227936,
0.2335684299,
0.7057315111,
-0.1544210166,
0.9288477302,
0.0127496487,
0.3093986511,
-0.5747176409,
0.4998143315,
-0.6400090456,
-0.2077698708,
-0.5375270247,
-0.7234708071,
-0.5554067492,
-0.0400412753,
-0.1033800989,
-0.4208804071,
0.0566830039,
0.685408473,
-0.6719774008,
0.4497714043,
-0.6018055677,
0.5408300161,
-0.1418486685,
-0.2282395065,
-0.593693614,
-0.3108481765,
0.2521103919,
-0.6216532588,
0.3564676642,
-0.2087998688,
-0.1930388063,
0.8439227343,
-0.523666501,
0.8060530424,
-0.4758590162,
-0.2678820789,
0.2369979173,
-0.0969358012,
0.5579494834,
0.088063404,
-0.2401425093,
0.0588231981,
-0.150706023,
-0.5380017161,
-0.8517460227,
0.7614273429,
-0.6741543412,
-0.7312255502,
-0.083007969,
-0.5535874963,
-0.5913468599,
0.2792764008,
0.1983542293,
0.3386119306,
-0.0222688895,
0.4679114819,
1.073051095,
-0.144100666,
0.0860189646,
0.6988565326,
-0.1913821399,
-0.6291656494,
1.1926810741,
0.429065913,
0.3540196419,
0.7872533798,
0.3822182119,
-0.2543514967,
-0.8054576516,
-0.2523086369,
0.4109671414,
-0.5865955949,
-0.4094467163,
-0.5287829638,
-0.0796063319,
-0.2280739397,
-0.0875487179,
-0.330131799,
-0.341958195,
-0.3667617142,
0.0994615927,
0.4382841885,
0.5595082641,
-0.2139967233,
0.4240047634,
-0.7931499481,
0.4663935304,
0.4009032845,
0.3922017217,
0.197161749,
-0.5350162387,
-0.5525695086,
0.4732210934,
-0.354365766,
-0.5550544858,
0.162220031,
0.4604317248,
0.4763996303,
0.6069902182,
-0.1097698361,
0.8003370166,
-0.6212569475,
0.1562517732,
0.1672403663,
-1.0909172297,
0.4707825482,
-0.6048836112,
0.5844908953,
0.8669193387,
0.3569549024,
-0.3387313485,
-0.2625407577,
-0.4536818862,
-0.6977199912,
0.621837914,
-0.3988324702,
0.2368055731,
-0.0076186433,
0.5393174887,
0.2046439946,
0.4223111272,
-0.4893133342,
-0.0918560177,
0.1576365381,
-0.2655852437,
-0.4443723559,
-0.3204332292,
0.1902661771,
-0.690297544,
0.7678022385,
-0.1931476593,
0.1463550329,
-0.2896801531,
-0.3834787905,
-0.3376266956,
0.0927057937,
0.6148875356,
0.8763676286,
-0.0715895221,
-0.1316736788,
0.7713551521,
-0.3572408855,
0.0957112983,
0.0113745844,
-0.2146620005,
-0.3713095188,
0.1921392828,
0.8173890114,
1.0596874952,
-0.5466765761,
0.2531386018,
0.3349561989,
-0.541144073,
-0.1811578572,
0.4085382819,
0.3010730147,
-0.0601426922,
0.4861732423,
0.3428078294,
-0.3578349948,
-0.4828778803,
0.4307724535,
0.2519845963,
-0.3617093563,
-0.2488283664,
0.5878217816,
-0.026853038,
-0.3813785911,
0.372454077,
-0.0467149615,
-0.2837998271,
0.4501956105,
0.5173200965,
0.580632031,
-0.5385710597,
0.1256427765,
0.2432855815,
0.1799302995,
-0.2149447054,
0.3755957186,
-0.27118963,
-0.7069399953,
-0.4270149767,
-0.9883705378,
-0.2616039813,
0.3829812407,
-0.5462110639,
0.4584392011,
-0.8772259355,
0.1838819683,
0.1109976768,
0.0466926321,
-0.707215488,
0.3005323112,
-0.1585139036,
1.050822854,
-0.8140659928,
1.1836893559,
0.5644082427,
-0.4390244484,
-0.7581251264,
0.2159469873,
-0.0936508849,
-0.7431610823,
0.4764744341,
0.0775292963,
-0.3365909755,
0.3110023439,
-0.0385333113,
-1.0377361774,
1.0078083277,
0.5989136696,
-0.7675274014,
-0.4147675931,
0.2310111225,
0.5738028288,
-0.172167927,
-0.1666141003,
0.6434006095,
0.2168738544,
0.1734172404,
-0.5995084047,
-0.1405515969,
-0.0388897061,
-0.24949193,
0.8477558494,
-0.7186138034,
1.3446692228,
-0.38026613,
-0.1108188629,
0.1172378436,
0.7823641896,
0.0355486907,
0.2304923534,
0.5639552474,
0.8370827436,
0.8731340766,
-0.024448514,
0.3170574009,
-0.3310104012,
0.2385510951,
1.1605911255,
-0.0675320476,
1.2162187099,
0.3571446538,
-0.2800210118,
0.4417890906,
0.2956747115,
0.475810051,
0.5173688531,
-0.0025139132,
-0.4348064959,
-0.305092752,
0.7054461837,
-0.4805136621,
0.4122920036,
0.7020946145,
-0.327883929,
-0.5321553946,
0.0460664704,
0.226061821,
0.1972338706,
-0.565384686,
0.9100922942,
0.1914328784,
-0.7876816988,
0.9109157324,
0.083762221,
0.4483368099,
-0.6695431471,
0.0465389416,
-0.2737005651,
0.5020757318,
-0.0042133564,
-0.3256779313,
0.471930176,
-0.2115944475,
-0.429087311,
-0.1074991897,
0.5272355676,
-0.6104446054,
-0.7041546702,
0.253041029,
0.4273169637,
-0.2907534242,
-0.2815869451,
-0.6415830255,
-0.0702002496,
0.1558329761,
0.156498909,
0.5624396801,
0.7306375504,
-0.103615649,
0.8150568008,
0.7062440515,
0.0247924328,
-0.0569658093,
-0.0277463216,
1.0074913502,
-0.7684653401,
-0.6889170408,
-0.9317261577,
0.117533423,
0.3029002547,
-0.3713959157,
0.5541676879,
0.3947835267,
0.9687510729,
-0.0839197189,
0.7039718628,
0.3692860305,
0.717402339,
-0.9567851424,
0.8549081683,
-0.5964208841,
0.2808331251,
-0.3525314927,
-0.7712712884,
-0.2936610579,
0.5489493012,
-0.6946592927,
0.0722722486,
0.7633586526,
0.7789233923,
-0.0513819642,
0.1532557309,
0.4259521961,
0.2736206949,
-0.0840942785,
0.9432198405,
0.6867491007,
-0.4465734363,
0.4071848691,
-0.3879210651,
-0.4431934953,
-0.1131027862,
-0.7503556013,
-0.9193237424,
-0.7860728502,
-0.1974998713,
-0.0626764968,
0.4382885993,
0.7009503245,
0.389082849,
-0.8653897643,
-0.1193461493,
-0.4149449766,
0.2291111648,
-0.1122796163,
-0.0743179843,
0.2317796797,
-0.8412498832,
-0.6215462089,
0.3298885822,
0.2201602012,
-0.0827865601,
-0.2749019265,
-0.1655416787,
-0.2615109384,
0.1126471236,
0.5175413489,
0.4519634843,
-0.4852544963,
-0.1682571471,
-0.2463121563,
0.2986180186,
0.181996718,
0.9112829566,
-1.1542069912,
0.1571226418,
0.4818198383,
0.6680234075,
0.3570790589,
-0.1076219827,
0.683221817,
-0.4715015292,
0.2247847766,
-0.0935147479,
0.3772072792,
0.3011343181,
-0.1859116852,
-0.0957326889,
0.1502828896,
-0.507633388,
-0.6795367002,
0.2478250414,
-0.2502146363,
-0.0870973021,
0.8895022273,
-0.163710922,
-0.1811445206,
-0.0369078591,
-0.1268376112,
0.1994223595,
-0.3591229022,
1.0283153057,
0.7376883626,
0.4205611348,
-0.0998642817,
-0.3955683708,
0.8362442255,
0.5840342641,
-0.7560402751,
0.2177871168,
0.4985457957,
0.4351270497,
-0.0669108704,
0.7646337152,
-0.1020947844,
0.411157161,
-0.0505854748,
-0.5819718242,
-0.1165502071,
-0.7295997739,
-0.2548299134,
0.2427062243,
0.2715038657,
-0.0024585095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08010v1
|
Distantly-Supervised Named Entity Recognition with Uncertainty-aware Teacher Learning and Student-student Collaborative Learning
| 2023-11-14T09:09:58 | 2023-11-14T09:09:58 |
Helan Hu, Shuzheng Si, Haozhe Zhao, Shuang Zeng, Kaikai An, Zefan Cai, Baobao Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Distantly-Supervised Named Entity Recognition (DS-NER) effectively alleviates
the burden of annotation, but meanwhile suffers from the label noise. Recent
works attempt to adopt the teacher-student framework to gradually refine the
training labels and improve the overall robustness. However, we argue that
these teacher-student methods achieve limited performance because poor network
calibration produces incorrectly pseudo-labeled samples, leading to error
propagation. Therefore, we attempt to mitigate this issue by proposing: (1)
Uncertainty-aware Teacher Learning that leverages the prediction uncertainty to
guide the selection of pseudo-labels, avoiding the number of incorrect
pseudo-labels in the self-training stage. (2) Student-student Collaborative
Learning that allows the transfer of reliable labels between two student
networks instead of completely relying on all pseudo-labels from its teacher.
Meanwhile, this approach allows a full exploration of mislabeled samples rather
than simply filtering unreliable pseudo-labeled samples. Extensive experimental
results on five DS-NER datasets demonstrate that our method is superior to
state-of-the-art teacher-student methods.
|
[
-0.5384770632,
-0.43191728,
0.5948159099,
-0.4159011543,
-0.0715736821,
0.1781753898,
-0.2010297924,
-0.6641541123,
0.3469568789,
0.2947619855,
-0.4789455831,
-0.1716478467,
-0.8036933541,
0.2806580067,
-0.2491532415,
1.1822454929,
-0.0010506397,
0.4518904686,
-0.2735463679,
-0.025154721,
-0.1140767932,
-0.4153188765,
-0.970923245,
-0.1495212913,
0.8884966373,
0.6548973918,
0.4963898361,
0.4556290507,
0.4486302137,
0.2485563755,
0.0223480929,
0.1799816936,
-0.4210187495,
0.3004752994,
-0.408141017,
-0.3462846279,
-0.4527612329,
-0.0701267496,
0.7841887474,
1.1197957993,
0.0020600262,
0.0785063431,
0.0193930399,
0.6587288976,
-0.7557700276,
-0.0283252895,
-0.4637037218,
0.1398950964,
-0.3138673604,
0.3121057153,
-0.3808834255,
-0.4153041542,
0.5741850734,
-0.7615057826,
0.2767745852,
0.0700066686,
0.8732399344,
0.449044466,
-0.3853701353,
-0.2513175309,
-1.0085178614,
0.7584902644,
-0.2406062186,
0.6801492572,
0.7289081812,
0.5092257261,
-0.2433868647,
-0.8209908605,
-0.4636670351,
0.2710979879,
0.3097197115,
0.2239195853,
-0.0053832345,
0.1360853612,
0.198133558,
0.2164222896,
-0.1234164163,
0.289457351,
-0.6933699846,
-0.2731955349,
0.4797682762,
-0.2395887971,
-0.064150095,
0.1210964918,
-0.5620405078,
-0.1297963858,
-0.5104088187,
-0.2302090079,
0.6262173653,
0.3780581653,
0.2316014171,
0.2917900383,
-0.3127706647,
0.7023615837,
0.1921166182,
-0.1310590506,
0.2626378834,
-0.0688146353,
-0.0785468668,
0.4765262008,
0.7190091014,
0.1997442991,
0.0275206603,
-0.4594653249,
-0.2250054777,
-0.1571505964,
0.0582865216,
-0.8572894335,
-0.9618114829,
0.0944599211,
-0.1051436439,
-0.31926319,
-0.0031043782,
-1.1150773764,
-0.2881697118,
-0.4733757675,
0.7195199132,
-0.2024824768,
-0.3883745372,
-0.3234009743,
0.0041658073,
-0.6420019269,
0.4947144091,
-0.6342909336,
0.4752703607,
0.2704321742,
0.5178875327,
-0.0809601396,
-0.3920059204,
-0.5937503576,
0.0855507106,
-0.3640961349,
0.5625058413,
-0.4280912876,
-0.4489135146,
-0.5745687485,
-0.0769650191,
-0.0273137782,
-0.4019482434,
0.1328020394,
-0.6716207266,
0.3846671283,
-0.6396856904,
-0.7581441998,
-0.1894184947,
0.0781963393,
-0.6768881083,
1.039509058,
0.1871170104,
-0.9763265848,
0.5763180256,
-0.0850237235,
0.0709123984,
-0.0903217569,
-0.157065779,
-0.8772755861,
-0.2536865771,
0.0594777465,
0.5089148879,
0.0103790071,
0.4476773143,
-0.5729163289,
-0.458397001,
0.1383946389,
-0.4331573546,
0.5007975101,
0.1806470603,
-0.2855077982,
-0.3576442897,
-0.8875046372,
-0.1019041613,
-0.0808899105,
0.1588765383,
-0.5702778697,
-0.0637660623,
-0.2282834947,
0.1694185436,
-0.0868135542,
-0.3740450442,
0.0443398245,
-0.3236785829,
0.159095034,
0.7630758882,
0.0990529135,
0.8247596025,
-0.4626996219,
0.425362587,
0.3028060198,
0.0399338081,
0.0817657411,
-0.3824545145,
-0.6210325956,
-0.3988719881,
0.6923317909,
0.2719472945,
-0.920429945,
0.0835940018,
-0.3352937102,
-0.652063787,
-0.1874551326,
0.0168404374,
0.1837601662,
1.0445853472,
0.698056221,
-0.4371196926,
-0.6916584969,
-0.5695709586,
0.0607399605,
-0.182962954,
0.2535039186,
0.3697302938,
0.5724009275,
-0.1892938018,
1.1952235699,
-0.379873991,
-0.4063401222,
0.2411697507,
0.2763459384,
-0.1983157098,
0.6943600774,
0.376011461,
-0.993740201,
-0.5167318583,
-0.5173112154,
-0.3247438967,
0.1941316277,
-0.1845140159,
-0.1062098294,
0.0096381782,
0.3479346335,
-0.138703987,
0.3049398363,
0.3669344783,
0.2802836597,
0.5669226646,
-0.1112743765,
0.0318724848,
-1.3710927963,
-0.3007309437,
-0.0212590117,
-0.2482731789,
-0.468347609,
-0.4938614368,
0.016806908,
0.1953024566,
-0.3132362068,
0.2897244692,
-0.8880640268,
-0.1611643881,
-0.2539756894,
0.387245208,
-0.0124705937,
-0.0784531087,
0.2985959053,
0.8043895364,
0.8553111553,
-0.6658657193,
0.3322085738,
0.0709661916,
-0.0162447821,
0.9504904151,
-0.2448616475,
0.2361935079,
-0.1684737802,
0.5986712575,
-0.7877636552,
-0.3369209766,
0.7060973048,
-0.4461586475,
0.7163034081,
-0.3800070584,
-0.2908408046,
-0.4254134893,
0.0318260454,
0.5671849847,
0.1081521362,
-0.7286891341,
0.3810746968,
0.2234298438,
0.1461659968,
-0.6391000748,
-0.8119496703,
0.1261693388,
-0.2904730439,
-0.1051707193,
0.4705617428,
0.1691859365,
0.0253522675,
0.3430610895,
-0.4861396551,
-0.5415112972,
0.0848402679,
0.5142129064,
0.3043250144,
-0.1340742558,
0.5926208496,
0.1991250813,
-0.2756882012,
0.0983026028,
-0.5031215549,
-0.0749599785,
0.0119244,
-0.3156324029,
-0.3879784942,
0.0255696699,
-0.08422824,
-0.0932457745,
0.8483374715,
0.6323899031,
-0.6596047878,
-0.4214062691,
-0.4879351556,
-0.4771900475,
-0.4409526587,
0.2826866806,
-0.4544071853,
-0.7323194742,
0.3360971212,
-0.6260891557,
-0.5465126634,
0.1989588141,
-0.1821917742,
-0.3519732356,
0.2044020742,
0.73354882,
-0.0810277984,
0.4153513312,
-0.2141037583,
0.1918325424,
-0.908487916,
-0.2199263126,
-0.5865702629,
-0.1647760868,
-0.6725462675,
-0.434045583,
0.0303912479,
0.175935328,
-0.221412763,
0.4863928258,
-0.7780877352,
0.494787842,
0.6170349121,
0.4279344082,
0.0470438711,
-0.043167118,
-0.0450334288,
-0.4294037521,
-0.5254546404,
-0.3782746792,
1.1496970654,
0.1194876358,
0.4879731238,
0.1068016216,
1.4041125774,
-0.1491893679,
0.305354476,
-0.5423578024,
0.3373790085,
0.1409463584,
-0.8174325824,
-0.3765497804,
-0.7854653001,
-0.8490139842,
-0.0023674711,
-0.2033489347,
-1.1196193695,
0.4680557251,
0.0508692749,
-0.4479789138,
0.7121998072,
-0.6163486838,
0.547344625,
-0.0230378378,
-0.3903981447,
0.1926315129,
-1.1020741463,
0.1214118972,
-0.6078502536,
0.2844125032,
0.0516335554,
-0.0294785928,
0.8164353967,
-0.4145059288,
0.9004099369,
-0.212200433,
0.1879921108,
0.4751208723,
0.117405124,
0.5931933522,
0.0139568914,
-0.1971140057,
0.1538637578,
-0.1101769805,
-0.3335969746,
-0.3321030736,
0.6642713547,
-0.7806159854,
-0.331990242,
-0.7120542526,
-0.3727088869,
-0.1783790737,
0.404119283,
0.4449775517,
0.2568851113,
0.2260576487,
-0.0868955851,
0.9002400637,
0.2143538594,
0.4572865367,
0.0590006337,
-0.113285929,
-0.7542286515,
1.1561783552,
0.6896210313,
0.426849395,
0.3463761806,
-0.1391931623,
-0.2156398296,
-0.4673397243,
-0.4384283423,
0.1023546308,
-0.8042892814,
-0.2398674637,
-0.7137701511,
-0.07808467,
-0.1145205498,
-0.214828372,
-0.7460490465,
-0.4395079315,
-0.9401717186,
-0.2244452685,
0.2226688713,
0.6507453322,
-0.270668,
0.454010874,
-0.5771445632,
0.0589183196,
0.2487922162,
0.3750299215,
-0.0969605148,
-0.4712429643,
0.0531319194,
0.3501158059,
-0.1560746729,
-1.2801711559,
-0.0447807796,
0.3463141024,
0.3154970706,
0.4176264405,
0.5178408027,
0.8774495721,
-0.2372966856,
0.6433024406,
0.2789945602,
-0.8531807065,
0.5590895414,
-0.0698178113,
-0.2637988627,
0.9385190606,
0.7376530766,
-0.1375111192,
-0.1342019588,
-0.839990437,
-1.0033682585,
0.7995150089,
0.0615697838,
0.002494592,
0.1136945784,
0.4851787984,
0.231962949,
0.2066611946,
-0.6844550371,
-0.6373710036,
-0.1424070746,
-0.0835762024,
-0.0702530518,
-0.1814093739,
0.129324764,
-0.0574259646,
0.9195777774,
-0.0747781545,
0.1373530775,
0.4783817828,
0.0812462345,
-0.333113879,
0.091988191,
0.1352117956,
0.3937386572,
-0.2957046032,
0.5100698471,
0.5938952565,
-0.553227663,
0.286760658,
0.524741888,
-0.1869684309,
0.059001416,
-0.0735605955,
0.4417858422,
0.2034291178,
-0.07607463,
0.5896510482,
-0.0661754087,
-0.1443576068,
-0.3863894641,
-0.0188833512,
0.1095048711,
0.2859199345,
0.438624531,
0.7300867438,
0.3059905469,
0.040102955,
0.5351677537,
0.0207023211,
-0.8206187487,
-0.2662825584,
0.8070123196,
-0.2417022288,
-0.0116631025,
0.6634831429,
-0.5727738142,
-0.5570110679,
0.7354214191,
0.434553057,
0.5951197743,
-0.3814495504,
0.4320694208,
0.587577343,
0.1089188159,
-0.5162559748,
-0.1286293566,
-0.4143065512,
-0.5364786983,
-0.1470446736,
-0.2488105148,
-0.767442286,
-0.3696412444,
-0.8413460851,
0.3600928187,
-0.3323439062,
-0.4949631691,
0.1749216169,
0.0695819333,
-0.4282169342,
0.8295711875,
0.1379463375,
0.2713167369,
-0.6938351989,
0.9057019353,
1.1372470856,
-0.3680348396,
-1.1179805994,
0.0307341628,
0.1008084342,
0.0016326155,
0.7836131454,
0.3040255308,
-0.1713671982,
0.1738728136,
-0.2055237144,
-1.1794248819,
1.3398532867,
0.1643436402,
-1.0058532953,
0.0569738895,
0.0857214257,
0.3696215749,
0.0722507834,
0.4748000503,
-0.2774245143,
0.1274222285,
0.4138102233,
-0.6589145064,
0.0395351015,
0.2759646177,
-0.0637743846,
0.3573966026,
-0.774409771,
0.6924625039,
-0.4494664967,
-0.1181698516,
-0.0378356092,
0.9814531803,
0.0979522839,
0.9232556224,
0.5096524358,
0.5516067147,
1.261384964,
-0.337582022,
0.4220974743,
-0.0035731334,
0.5334818363,
1.6186798811,
-0.1334517002,
0.6166459918,
0.6935303807,
-0.3842056692,
0.1633106172,
1.043426156,
-0.1924697608,
0.6199337244,
0.35438326,
-0.3854161501,
-0.3282236457,
-0.1640517265,
-0.530044198,
0.0572753586,
0.2613628209,
-0.3658738434,
-0.1460412443,
0.1702070534,
0.0847368687,
-0.0796220005,
-0.1267409027,
0.4778029323,
0.380210191,
-0.3959839344,
0.059143234,
-0.2613702416,
0.6055120826,
-0.0650674775,
0.1912054271,
0.2468819767,
0.0830588192,
-0.3270983994,
-0.4131383896,
0.2697017193,
-0.4138472676,
-0.0667883381,
0.0138554731,
0.7485598326,
-0.4614929557,
-0.363871634,
0.2747073472,
0.3773674965,
0.3527119458,
0.0461432785,
-0.5557469726,
-0.2844826281,
-0.1300918013,
-0.1370836496,
0.4475173652,
0.5549120903,
0.1740147322,
0.6122267842,
0.5107790828,
0.197875157,
0.0218310468,
-0.1735901684,
0.7856503129,
-0.1060329974,
-0.0975230932,
-0.5919992924,
0.2265410721,
0.0953273699,
-0.317920506,
0.6458714008,
0.5134587884,
1.3288578987,
0.2476180345,
0.4445834458,
0.1188537106,
0.4622432292,
0.0082739051,
0.6167367697,
-0.588214457,
0.485717833,
-0.6952720284,
-0.965980351,
-0.4220015407,
0.6670134068,
-0.607778728,
0.3691259921,
0.4420930743,
0.5876487494,
-0.1803976893,
0.3319314718,
0.2526850998,
-0.1230118349,
0.0042000362,
0.5313299298,
0.8333040476,
-0.8657018542,
0.4722504616,
-1.1173365116,
0.1557365507,
0.0235928204,
-0.781647265,
-0.8347884417,
-0.6196483374,
-0.9541156292,
-0.4134601951,
0.3399748802,
0.9128840566,
0.9909879565,
-0.7626984715,
0.4833995998,
-0.3819987774,
0.1669201255,
-0.1480792761,
-0.1752560586,
0.4867736995,
-0.0879754722,
-0.8934063315,
0.1304529607,
-0.3240761757,
0.448930949,
0.0534122251,
-0.0767250285,
-0.0779306144,
-0.2875828445,
-0.1619574726,
0.1544948071,
-0.3809565604,
-0.221775189,
-0.1968717128,
-0.2998557091,
-0.0024646642,
-0.0472634286,
-0.727837801,
0.896848619,
0.0345938094,
0.6656138897,
0.5746337771,
0.0673763826,
-0.000531072,
-0.7265213728,
-0.1418922246,
0.4211669862,
0.1470412463,
0.5265048146,
-0.6617259979,
0.4799365699,
0.3847914934,
-0.778893292,
-0.9469644427,
0.0220840797,
-0.8142699599,
-0.0587793216,
0.830940485,
-0.6129409671,
-0.0616225898,
-0.0698181838,
-0.0121709583,
0.6000537872,
-0.379532367,
0.6713690162,
0.6035841107,
0.1947812438,
-0.2550382018,
-0.5821792483,
0.3305925131,
0.5668865442,
-0.4718801677,
-0.5267478228,
0.4380334318,
0.5266441107,
0.2122490555,
0.3649230897,
0.2172381133,
0.1186311096,
0.2613041103,
-0.0754501522,
-0.1768364757,
-0.6720486879,
-0.1538742334,
0.0562059954,
0.1088152081,
-0.440345794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08002v1
|
TempTabQA: Temporal Question Answering for Semi-Structured Tables
| 2023-11-14T08:57:01 | 2023-11-14T08:57:01 |
Vivek Gupta, Pranshu Kandoi, Mahek Bhavesh Vora, Shuo Zhang, Yujie He, Ridho Reinanda, Vivek Srikumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Semi-structured data, such as Infobox tables, often include temporal
information about entities, either implicitly or explicitly. Can current NLP
systems reason about such information in semi-structured tables? To tackle this
question, we introduce the task of temporal question answering on
semi-structured tables. We present a dataset, TempTabQA, which comprises 11,454
question-answer pairs extracted from 1,208 Wikipedia Infobox tables spanning
more than 90 distinct domains. Using this dataset, we evaluate several
state-of-the-art models for temporal reasoning. We observe that even the
top-performing LLMs lag behind human performance by more than 13.5 F1 points.
Given these results, our dataset has the potential to serve as a challenging
benchmark to improve the temporal reasoning capabilities of NLP models.
|
[
-0.1611728817,
-1.0534729958,
0.9184512496,
0.3826729953,
-0.2532087564,
0.1950876266,
0.2218749076,
-0.5284044743,
-0.1109574512,
0.1936859637,
-0.8399575949,
-0.642796278,
-0.2550915778,
0.2123983651,
-0.7958025336,
0.7740473747,
-0.1077217162,
-0.2287817001,
-0.2360242456,
-0.0523750968,
-0.3110427856,
-0.3962408304,
-0.4624096751,
-0.2905286252,
0.5079861283,
0.4187829196,
0.8066307902,
0.5188123584,
-0.1323839575,
0.1821963191,
-0.1721279621,
0.034193892,
-0.0088585606,
0.2650597095,
-0.3611422181,
-0.6157651544,
-0.3374696672,
-0.2793132663,
0.6183752418,
0.8571543694,
-0.5591124892,
0.5472803712,
-0.21918571,
0.4941344559,
-0.3518779874,
0.1113574877,
-0.6049658656,
0.5683197975,
-0.561006248,
-0.6521394849,
-0.4399369061,
-0.4151191115,
0.026075311,
-0.5127227306,
0.1892680228,
0.3972966671,
0.9269307256,
0.6174696088,
-0.5380395651,
0.1903706044,
-0.9775269032,
0.515784204,
-0.604960382,
0.5395126939,
0.2769879699,
0.4678051174,
-0.2866916656,
-0.9623755217,
-0.6301154494,
-0.1091531739,
-0.089924939,
-0.0257938877,
-0.2976317704,
-0.3202345669,
0.6871237755,
0.0198080782,
-0.9168249369,
-0.0367692299,
-0.2985393703,
-0.0749107301,
0.2464666963,
0.5182973146,
0.414334476,
-0.0749398023,
-0.4377871752,
0.2847900391,
-0.4706165791,
0.2190315574,
0.0946413055,
-0.2908369601,
-0.0274096262,
0.8165519834,
-0.3533563614,
1.0226100683,
-0.1283244342,
0.2335167974,
-0.4186832309,
-0.3997241855,
-0.0499758758,
0.2673649788,
0.3596168756,
0.3539447486,
0.1356808394,
-0.7060629129,
-0.0373388901,
0.1048019081,
0.2178161889,
-0.3772773445,
-0.1717018783,
0.7183024883,
-0.0689835995,
-0.0410861038,
-0.2780322731,
-0.8924219608,
-0.0673487708,
-0.1434634626,
0.2999957502,
-0.2533400059,
0.0340803526,
0.0171053465,
-0.2655179501,
0.380128026,
0.3564063013,
-0.2756692469,
0.3464308381,
0.3597002625,
0.8202901483,
-0.1761025637,
-0.0647255331,
-0.508446753,
0.5244558454,
-0.6594879627,
1.1744139194,
-0.5941906571,
-0.0769459009,
-0.1181859598,
-0.0813671872,
0.229626134,
-0.568408072,
0.2554369271,
-0.9094225168,
0.4384251535,
-0.2910595536,
-0.5717327595,
0.2112135291,
0.2759641707,
-0.7387987375,
1.3012807369,
0.2842932045,
-0.7409177423,
0.4786448777,
-0.4939702451,
-0.3960641026,
0.1968463063,
-0.1103068665,
-0.2681656778,
-0.1170386449,
0.3163255751,
0.4137662947,
-0.5455711484,
0.6700150967,
-0.3758280575,
-0.2738887966,
0.6431148648,
-0.037958134,
0.6546011567,
0.2708016336,
-0.2968488634,
-0.1957537383,
-0.6734609604,
0.3299400806,
0.1471092403,
-0.3308648169,
0.0195582248,
0.258503288,
-0.243367061,
0.4636193812,
0.008090402,
-0.5125249028,
0.2516897321,
-0.0779495165,
0.6634044647,
0.7153613567,
0.3474772573,
0.2033883184,
-0.5954361558,
0.4643836021,
0.2764331996,
0.2113534957,
0.4084151685,
-0.4585825503,
-0.530850172,
0.3693183661,
0.3225907385,
0.4473425448,
-1.1758819818,
0.0960603952,
-0.3163642585,
-0.5651779771,
-0.2091106176,
-0.1865419,
0.2964377403,
0.8573960066,
0.6392061114,
0.2006733418,
-0.217501089,
-1.0682134628,
-0.4617785811,
-0.2793019712,
-0.3630385399,
0.1105858013,
0.477402389,
0.507640481,
0.9020918608,
-0.4468309283,
0.1556772143,
-0.1216176152,
0.2523358166,
0.4014838934,
-0.1019318551,
0.4898168147,
-0.7620742917,
-0.0936178789,
-0.601352036,
-0.7677839398,
-0.4114866853,
-0.2010765225,
-0.1871017516,
0.2646220326,
0.5382736325,
-0.4523585439,
0.5381224751,
0.2541334629,
-0.6941286325,
0.5099310279,
0.1044578552,
0.2250179499,
-0.9434282184,
0.1137643531,
-0.0550813377,
-0.2597166002,
-0.6427371502,
-0.578862071,
0.0022673993,
-0.1083292738,
-0.5916794538,
0.6859888434,
-0.304369688,
-0.1551114023,
0.3783030808,
0.1159336492,
0.0878980383,
0.8040342927,
0.1600977182,
0.85507828,
0.2809197605,
-1.0093135834,
0.4404351115,
0.3041527271,
-0.6368165016,
0.5133443475,
-1.0718635321,
0.3335379064,
-0.1560412496,
0.2043857276,
-0.9661482573,
-0.2184831202,
0.0993023887,
-0.3699139357,
0.2852056026,
-0.1388681084,
-0.6954634786,
-0.185049668,
-0.0866324529,
0.249230057,
0.0794405043,
-0.3429781795,
0.6520015597,
0.377035141,
-0.2740568221,
-0.7369487882,
-0.7069565654,
0.0707534254,
-0.1016597226,
-0.6130051613,
0.7038745284,
0.0265447069,
-0.4475468695,
0.3859135509,
-0.5333370566,
0.0277703777,
0.036489673,
0.1386635303,
0.2001231909,
-0.0424249955,
0.4125548899,
0.2178845853,
0.0070436676,
0.1201954409,
-0.3917657435,
0.6980863214,
-0.1590802521,
-0.1526774168,
-0.4210747182,
0.4325921834,
0.2562111318,
0.0084587652,
0.9671352506,
0.0803910494,
-0.679125011,
-0.3439441621,
-0.5378894806,
-0.0659509599,
-0.3884041011,
0.201240018,
-0.3910166323,
-0.6389352083,
0.5436141491,
0.1928849071,
0.2886583209,
0.4757164717,
0.7608038783,
-0.7266086936,
0.8655575514,
0.1303699613,
0.274759084,
0.2759406567,
-0.1257282943,
-0.062972948,
-0.3898857534,
-0.8315930963,
-0.7822425961,
-0.6339278221,
-0.2875535786,
-0.1492630243,
0.6722566485,
-0.2810484171,
-0.4052565098,
0.133796975,
-0.3389897048,
0.1801401377,
0.5916751623,
0.4249558449,
0.3129805624,
-0.3229053617,
0.0386134051,
0.249083057,
-0.7893506885,
-0.580504775,
0.5939419866,
-0.0258547384,
0.6972008348,
0.2854636908,
-0.0073620663,
0.7223014832,
-0.2216823548,
-0.2351151407,
0.7702035308,
0.3127803802,
-1.1559388638,
-0.4853990078,
-0.4612873197,
-0.8310923576,
-0.4610826671,
-0.2692574561,
-0.8088647127,
0.0629896,
0.0262403116,
-0.4844666719,
0.4111144543,
-0.6457641125,
0.9175101519,
-0.2346675396,
-0.4386092126,
0.1908780336,
-0.8535453081,
0.0538672581,
0.087561436,
-0.076207988,
-0.4422536194,
-0.3665089309,
1.1456855536,
-0.5674481988,
0.3620123863,
-0.1585214138,
0.2708739936,
0.2192492038,
0.39823246,
0.1743389666,
0.3149061799,
-0.0645885766,
0.1987176239,
0.8850896358,
-0.6858750582,
-0.821636498,
0.3523440361,
-0.5809978843,
-0.6078193784,
-0.6478556991,
-0.5706750154,
-0.6677699685,
-0.1036839336,
0.3465171456,
0.6810727715,
0.1587657183,
0.177095294,
0.5991260409,
-0.274625361,
0.4246267378,
0.5179713368,
0.0626757294,
0.3356443644,
0.0113992272,
0.4142061174,
0.0664442405,
0.7592853308,
0.0614225529,
-0.6495870948,
-0.5059552789,
-0.3748038113,
0.2924060225,
-0.5878422856,
-0.3748389482,
-0.7655494809,
-0.1407655329,
-0.1206832454,
0.1601821184,
-0.0645736754,
-0.9030251503,
0.0803154632,
-0.1436155736,
0.3093800843,
0.5337699056,
0.4402564764,
0.0733468458,
-0.9849349856,
0.5181229115,
0.3753561676,
0.4678900838,
-0.3320342004,
-0.6064959168,
0.2588194907,
-0.2368838638,
0.0831383392,
-1.4765495062,
-0.088387534,
0.1563800573,
0.6494631767,
-0.0598080941,
0.462693274,
0.5942447782,
-0.4179074168,
0.9515466094,
-0.3866439164,
-0.7308307886,
0.8814234734,
-0.0225752629,
0.4729260802,
0.2380037159,
0.6628625393,
-0.590356946,
-0.4899262786,
-0.8061876297,
-0.4995758832,
0.9963797331,
0.3652182817,
-0.3844614625,
0.172222361,
0.6560019255,
-0.0427290089,
0.1994979978,
-0.4964647889,
-0.3324025571,
0.1123674139,
0.0213655122,
0.1831082553,
-0.4475857317,
-0.1334566027,
-0.1219782606,
0.5720035434,
0.2849375904,
0.4126865268,
0.0607991442,
-0.1029498801,
-0.1447364837,
0.6361914277,
0.2317344397,
1.0569472313,
-0.2637497187,
0.3123223186,
0.4452602267,
-0.071424149,
0.2585416138,
0.2002682984,
-0.3169569671,
0.1675175577,
0.5156521201,
0.4189189672,
0.0528295711,
-0.4484770596,
0.2426823825,
-0.4377273321,
0.153064236,
-0.4531606734,
0.1277990043,
0.1253924072,
0.4568101168,
0.3568382859,
-0.4448456466,
0.0917332545,
-0.7890465856,
0.2306510806,
0.060462378,
-0.197172448,
-0.3456879556,
0.8950193524,
-0.3169042766,
-0.3772544265,
0.8699054122,
0.1958456337,
-0.4271748364,
0.6597084403,
0.2228918821,
0.1890354306,
-0.2377778739,
0.2773590982,
0.3659109175,
0.3674151599,
0.2248052806,
0.6831679344,
-0.3106584251,
-0.3831739724,
-0.1874067634,
-0.5894767642,
-0.4475561976,
0.0250671878,
-0.5636218786,
0.2962926924,
-0.4763019383,
-0.4447389543,
0.4789987504,
0.0592566095,
-0.8982312083,
0.1812653691,
-0.0547435731,
1.202247858,
-0.7594780326,
0.7306173444,
0.6847245097,
-0.3433316648,
-0.9411004186,
-0.0682567134,
-0.0708641037,
-0.5613900423,
0.3082271516,
-0.3426653743,
-0.0892405286,
0.029475946,
-0.8223204613,
-0.4873555601,
1.2031692266,
0.484788835,
-0.4012924433,
-0.6280533075,
0.3292491138,
0.5794671774,
0.3381818235,
0.2717710435,
0.8701196313,
0.5671917796,
0.0719887763,
-0.5891724229,
0.0627234951,
-0.5265320539,
-0.1527373791,
0.3947487772,
-0.2054352909,
0.3853809834,
-0.1280425191,
-0.6989365816,
-0.2301909178,
0.8134143353,
0.1539099365,
0.5476964116,
0.5933486223,
0.5196262002,
0.6232992411,
-0.6476972103,
1.1771988869,
-0.0435089543,
-0.0932391137,
1.1757820845,
-0.1115901098,
0.4868266582,
0.5869170427,
-0.6218019128,
0.480428189,
0.9290241003,
0.2286971062,
0.3720829487,
0.0070212395,
-0.0050297589,
-0.5453324318,
-0.3765432537,
-0.3771427274,
0.3084453344,
0.4449886084,
0.2210540622,
-0.5087253451,
-0.2134436965,
0.0600694604,
-0.0651424304,
-0.0435178317,
0.7310704589,
-0.0286864918,
-0.778601706,
0.2273115218,
0.041326642,
-0.1575633585,
-0.6897932887,
-0.1690063477,
-0.4986239672,
-0.2292479277,
-0.197633341,
-1.3136140108,
0.4255118966,
0.1284251958,
0.139454484,
-0.1327363253,
0.3780063689,
-0.3263381422,
-0.1642240584,
0.0214585084,
0.7159253955,
0.0814755782,
-0.0310950521,
-0.6593878269,
-0.2988238037,
-0.3627153933,
-0.4210296869,
-0.0094852177,
0.6976505518,
-0.2882454991,
0.914162457,
0.3265357018,
0.0232074931,
0.4499793649,
-0.036525216,
0.8722910881,
-0.7280405164,
-0.4041217864,
-0.8033301234,
0.3295379281,
-0.095135197,
-0.2091032118,
0.3062478602,
0.5562541485,
0.655439496,
0.0658193752,
0.2542166412,
-0.2742381394,
0.7108741403,
-0.9797275662,
0.3085632622,
-0.8558765054,
0.3737561107,
0.0647054911,
-1.0755900145,
-0.1871635169,
-0.1003744006,
-0.2868145108,
0.0496681705,
0.7091745138,
0.7240895629,
0.0911197141,
0.1901274323,
0.1879468262,
0.3739933372,
0.3240468502,
1.0449832678,
1.4108376503,
-0.1265065074,
0.7052560449,
-0.651345551,
-0.0663569644,
-0.002418479,
-0.925427556,
-0.8002942204,
-1.0468537807,
-0.4418183267,
-0.4897772372,
0.248182267,
0.8919429183,
0.23961097,
-0.7244777083,
0.3158299625,
0.4448162019,
0.1290333867,
-0.2691283822,
-0.206424728,
0.6103375554,
0.0722728968,
-0.5179616809,
0.1423508227,
0.3923585713,
-0.0850285366,
0.0609641671,
0.4050339758,
-0.5975730419,
0.1357708424,
0.1809703261,
0.3018497825,
-0.4249965847,
-0.3195047975,
0.3193956912,
-0.0959586874,
0.0813983753,
0.8195182085,
-0.7133610845,
0.287989676,
0.5391219258,
0.3771996796,
0.849794209,
0.0875376537,
0.2402271479,
-0.8882421255,
-0.0134433294,
0.657938242,
0.5033519864,
0.0147302309,
-0.4058248401,
0.7119367719,
0.0900341794,
-0.3757788539,
-0.7845090628,
0.1311618388,
-1.2070522308,
-0.3501027822,
0.8950324655,
0.1545800418,
-0.4233264327,
-0.6965416074,
0.2767884433,
0.5973628759,
-0.0977769941,
1.0197250843,
0.9313621521,
-0.2651480734,
-0.188768357,
-0.7475708723,
0.573421061,
0.3677957356,
-1.1526148319,
-0.2094935924,
0.4411691129,
0.2449139506,
0.0226575062,
0.8401966095,
-0.4229430258,
0.5205897093,
-0.1536113471,
-0.3393602967,
-0.3369638026,
-0.7905510068,
0.1972121298,
0.3325839639,
-0.1226575449,
-0.0735047311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08001v1
|
A Comparative Analysis of the COVID-19 Infodemic in English and Chinese: Insights from Social Media Textual Data
| 2023-11-14T08:55:11 | 2023-11-14T08:55:11 |
Jia Luo, Daiyun Peng, Lei Shi, Didier El Baz, Xinran Liu
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL, physics.soc-ph
|
The COVID-19 infodemic, characterized by the rapid spread of misinformation
and unverified claims related to the pandemic, presents a significant
challenge. This paper presents a comparative analysis of the COVID-19 infodemic
in the English and Chinese languages, utilizing textual data extracted from
social media platforms. To ensure a balanced representation, two infodemic
datasets were created by augmenting previously collected social media textual
data. Through word frequency analysis, the thirty-five most frequently
occurring infodemic words are identified, shedding light on prevalent
discussions surrounding the infodemic. Moreover, topic clustering analysis
uncovers thematic structures and provides a deeper understanding of primary
topics within each language context. Additionally, sentiment analysis enables
comprehension of the emotional tone associated with COVID-19 information on
social media platforms in English and Chinese. This research contributes to a
better understanding of the COVID-19 infodemic phenomenon and can guide the
development of strategies to combat misinformation during public health crises
across different languages.
|
[
-0.2121644765,
-0.9532067776,
0.1278018355,
0.6516216397,
-0.3308646977,
0.2931906283,
-0.4277132154,
-0.6232340932,
0.4886068702,
-0.0301187504,
-0.4123666584,
-0.4983533919,
-0.5154746175,
-0.0157766659,
-0.4694259465,
1.0113960505,
0.3120532036,
0.1407611966,
-0.2405848801,
0.1957293153,
0.075757958,
-0.5920203924,
-0.9817761183,
-0.1916455925,
0.5299948454,
0.3092109859,
0.6123015285,
0.0271311738,
1.0598732233,
0.161425367,
0.155986771,
0.0635278821,
-0.7009117007,
-0.3260551989,
-0.0131216068,
-0.1637276709,
-0.1949772537,
-0.0944336653,
0.0823763758,
0.1062941253,
-0.0530901477,
0.3859355152,
0.1553570926,
0.4615511596,
-0.4416226745,
-0.0332974978,
-0.3861865401,
0.0412365645,
-0.5108375549,
-0.6262952089,
-0.3348361552,
-0.3614144623,
0.1564547718,
-0.7414544225,
-0.0278376117,
-0.3847359717,
1.0316129923,
0.0824724361,
-0.4220475554,
-0.2185644805,
-0.8207638264,
0.5590187907,
-0.548682034,
0.1785349101,
0.298546344,
0.2388782352,
0.1237950549,
-0.7209342718,
-0.3865090609,
0.1814765185,
0.0089422381,
0.1607395858,
-0.4837497771,
-0.4176063836,
-0.1550704539,
0.2577335238,
-1.0404367447,
-0.136283353,
-0.5924293995,
-0.4016286135,
0.9987576008,
-0.2064978331,
0.7882400751,
-0.2533470392,
-0.4701752365,
-0.1238872707,
-0.553309679,
0.3040879667,
-0.0461280197,
0.1068508476,
-0.8077071309,
0.1679940522,
0.0968626663,
0.1704205275,
0.1293759495,
-0.4592280686,
0.279884696,
-0.646388948,
-0.2174064219,
0.3537504077,
0.975815773,
0.7523878813,
-0.0147893904,
-0.1835869849,
0.2680525184,
0.0735526979,
0.1886279881,
-0.7789042592,
-0.358612895,
0.3021162152,
-0.7730964422,
-0.0115843648,
0.4572782815,
-0.7877525687,
-0.7265834808,
0.062004976,
0.0666634813,
-0.3804714084,
-0.4030863047,
-0.108856231,
-0.5506360531,
0.3287886381,
0.4231571257,
-0.097003594,
0.1826042831,
0.8028823137,
0.6564365625,
-0.0962391123,
0.1787816882,
0.0231533367,
-0.1653710902,
-0.4448143244,
0.5896296501,
-0.2566937506,
0.0928056166,
-0.0742893964,
-0.0539967269,
-0.0594097711,
-0.3914414346,
0.6482718587,
-0.3095057905,
0.5262623429,
-0.5568474531,
0.0191270411,
-0.3462463021,
0.2625058591,
-0.7426306605,
1.0755258799,
-0.3252050877,
-1.3869624138,
0.3006444275,
-0.2301975638,
-0.5302245617,
0.2799017429,
-0.3524674773,
-0.2514345646,
-0.2740620375,
0.2405717075,
0.5423858762,
-0.6462935805,
0.3969949186,
-0.419919163,
-0.2978875637,
0.0172999669,
-0.2800426781,
0.9215603471,
0.4179182649,
-0.2971655726,
-0.3016798198,
-0.5198876858,
-0.3984112442,
0.2475698292,
0.018418178,
-0.8277751207,
0.2168677896,
0.216583848,
0.3059126735,
0.5449090004,
-0.444312185,
-0.0660440177,
-0.1003022194,
0.2668547034,
0.0555748492,
0.2756897211,
0.1979282498,
-0.4512412548,
0.2745693326,
0.2201268524,
0.4760400951,
0.0500133783,
-0.4817870259,
-0.1444300115,
-0.2627494633,
-0.3279454112,
0.968411684,
-0.8535534143,
0.3180377185,
-0.1704691947,
-0.9300493598,
-0.6188513637,
-0.1574528515,
-0.0168587174,
0.4454014897,
0.3580614626,
0.1719780564,
-0.5865549445,
-0.4824193716,
-0.4496231973,
-0.2664400041,
0.346906513,
0.0259830058,
-0.0622607507,
-0.1100081429,
0.3318735659,
-0.1516178697,
-0.0070115929,
-0.3530445099,
0.419218868,
0.1346149147,
-0.0169172939,
0.8054918647,
-1.026879549,
-0.571010828,
0.3762027323,
-0.8707157969,
0.0289975293,
-0.3158107698,
0.0796296969,
-0.1143090874,
0.5223268867,
-0.03313905,
0.4133072793,
0.5704955459,
-0.4137210846,
0.1288345009,
-0.0921072364,
0.48428455,
-1.4182471037,
0.0390440375,
0.2414135933,
0.0892083868,
-0.8029282689,
-0.0789104179,
0.0794755742,
-0.0677140802,
-0.2443139702,
0.4381883144,
-0.0758821666,
0.4360841513,
-0.1882499009,
0.2670266032,
0.1861112714,
-0.2347967476,
-0.1515049338,
0.4091167748,
0.5530526638,
-0.472230345,
0.7568458319,
-0.0846868008,
-0.4928025305,
0.4290754795,
-0.576215744,
-0.1959491372,
-0.3096394539,
0.2185131311,
-1.1039887667,
-0.2114678621,
0.4477298856,
-0.5143737793,
-0.2778779268,
0.6199300885,
-0.2380524576,
-0.4278745055,
-0.7705860734,
0.230333358,
0.0819086805,
-0.3131240606,
0.0435136706,
0.6904594302,
-0.5813106298,
-0.7611124516,
-1.0478659868,
0.3658296168,
-0.4733304679,
-0.9383530617,
0.5046223402,
0.0352538563,
-0.8792855144,
0.1845776588,
0.1007769629,
-0.5531057715,
0.3951880932,
0.0490624718,
0.0383762792,
-0.3895308077,
0.5324828029,
-0.2621239722,
0.3986643851,
0.010798295,
0.1864163876,
0.6338948011,
0.0806416199,
0.0854226798,
-0.7304729819,
0.2782225609,
0.3067278564,
-0.0246223621,
0.8197741508,
0.5784122944,
-0.5488575697,
0.2417069376,
-0.4024817646,
-0.1219405755,
-0.3155037165,
0.1665680259,
0.0731174871,
-0.2613302171,
0.2176915109,
0.2251675725,
-0.0101239048,
0.7120844126,
0.2951911688,
-0.0390761979,
0.3213997781,
0.7011271715,
-0.5352274179,
0.3621056676,
0.0166116003,
0.4340144992,
0.1934241652,
-0.3849199414,
-0.617534399,
-0.0411731191,
-0.556796968,
-0.3188027143,
0.3583685458,
-0.1269125044,
0.1014643312,
0.3469787538,
-0.2268120497,
-0.1401776373,
0.2091397196,
0.1463062763,
0.3176817298,
0.1423365325,
0.2978015542,
-0.0512840226,
-0.8681988716,
-0.3930891156,
0.4876064062,
0.180839926,
0.7879633307,
0.0255044773,
0.426243186,
0.7484894395,
-0.1982036531,
-0.4037358463,
0.2144630253,
-0.6346783042,
-0.1300227344,
-0.2115906328,
-0.2944447994,
-0.9766132236,
-0.3280193508,
-0.4769663811,
-0.4544278681,
0.3613152504,
-0.270329833,
-0.38369295,
0.1037697345,
-0.5594946146,
0.553971827,
-0.3541666567,
0.0145037025,
-0.611312151,
-0.4920699,
0.2177179456,
-0.2413590252,
0.7841171026,
-0.1867685765,
0.1988037825,
0.756749928,
-0.4840895236,
0.6887152791,
0.2237941474,
-0.2376648635,
0.3560756147,
-0.6955866218,
0.1621362567,
-0.0350557938,
-0.3550216556,
0.1015488505,
0.1791305542,
-0.5416206121,
-0.2722019851,
0.6726276875,
-1.0623801947,
-0.18966721,
-0.3962800205,
-0.2279221267,
0.3688608706,
0.0317527018,
0.6772021651,
0.5540058613,
-0.847889781,
0.1755884588,
0.3016506135,
-0.4457829595,
0.6409969926,
0.2892745733,
-0.1778346449,
-0.1820350736,
0.9637203813,
0.5609145164,
-0.206825316,
0.7845674157,
0.3878532946,
0.1618203223,
0.1597603709,
-0.0626432374,
0.4019499123,
-0.4847240746,
0.1362918317,
-0.5534905195,
-0.4562602639,
-0.6534315944,
-0.1379910409,
-0.137912482,
-0.068654716,
-0.0527451485,
-0.091821596,
0.7739492655,
0.8753737211,
-0.08908391,
0.264306426,
-0.6608658433,
0.3820807636,
-0.0350271724,
-0.157450363,
-0.3121518493,
-0.1327775121,
-0.4788367748,
0.2696225345,
-0.0620976724,
-0.9681138992,
0.2594104409,
0.197231859,
0.3093170226,
0.8451210856,
0.4718359709,
0.7223670483,
0.1142655164,
1.0450600386,
0.1568069756,
-0.7175734639,
0.3663891852,
-0.1738086343,
0.2889116406,
0.4304873943,
0.6645999551,
-1.1285812855,
-0.4413712323,
-0.7260687947,
-0.9795178771,
0.4850243628,
-0.1053971425,
-0.0875526443,
0.0054189013,
-0.0832738131,
0.1006028578,
-0.0385843292,
-0.5940390825,
-0.3461078405,
-0.2161320597,
-0.2020777613,
-0.0638251677,
-0.182702437,
-0.0621639267,
-0.1020109281,
0.5618117452,
0.3737635612,
0.171211496,
0.3200886548,
-0.0623335019,
-0.1861511916,
0.1479956061,
0.3027513921,
0.6870073676,
-0.027860716,
0.5061947107,
-0.0840053484,
-0.9011948705,
-0.2148399055,
0.0394432731,
-0.2202612907,
0.3025727272,
0.6874115467,
0.8192067146,
0.0303747915,
-0.6660372615,
0.8428048491,
-0.2864551246,
0.0223932862,
-0.3452962935,
-0.3962884545,
0.2229352593,
0.2782357633,
0.5623350739,
-0.0893206298,
0.1068224013,
-0.664880693,
0.3070887923,
0.2553734481,
-0.187365219,
-0.69843328,
0.2406724989,
0.4720132649,
0.0482298732,
0.1092949361,
0.0899080932,
-0.0053692833,
0.8326814175,
0.3606544137,
0.5895538926,
-0.455637306,
0.6462168097,
0.2630758584,
0.6042400002,
-0.1820179224,
0.6278010607,
0.2011346817,
-0.5202333331,
-0.2987861335,
0.1279083639,
0.1493138522,
0.5332838893,
-0.7352330089,
0.5561434031,
-0.5020549893,
-0.2879135609,
0.1702427566,
0.0265980978,
-0.5371078849,
0.3593028784,
0.4710451066,
0.8948097825,
-0.7398450971,
0.5868101716,
0.8138781786,
-0.1647912562,
-0.743094027,
0.7958030105,
0.0822833627,
-0.5355605483,
0.2750955522,
0.3192890286,
-0.0951668322,
-0.5096344948,
-0.6372383237,
-0.7790747285,
1.0664476156,
0.2703282237,
-0.3310925961,
0.1985582411,
0.4230075181,
0.6848000884,
-0.2333066612,
0.1725000888,
0.1606338173,
0.5637767315,
-0.3076212406,
-0.8417358994,
-0.1318806261,
-0.6108189821,
-0.5416076779,
-0.0920333415,
-1.0669436455,
0.7868297696,
0.128979072,
-0.7260369062,
-0.3983062506,
0.4664652646,
-0.415325582,
0.9732838273,
0.2648990452,
0.3128581047,
1.163675189,
0.0098804254,
0.9369314909,
-0.6056200266,
0.1544833928,
0.8493097425,
0.0525796823,
0.7227808237,
0.1988445818,
-0.0972438306,
0.434989959,
0.6815025806,
0.2499511689,
0.3760836422,
-0.224205628,
-0.2457550168,
0.071201697,
-0.643324554,
-0.5349200964,
0.4011466205,
0.4919078648,
-0.2611385286,
-0.4564029276,
0.3572968543,
0.3019840419,
0.1133458987,
-0.4605192244,
0.9057831168,
0.0006777164,
-0.293972373,
0.4854348004,
0.0768676475,
0.5721513033,
-0.4417459369,
0.4073369205,
-0.1827413142,
-0.0534564964,
-0.4951889813,
-0.5312668085,
0.5954014063,
0.1986539066,
-0.1853591651,
0.1476483941,
1.0128217936,
-0.6849527359,
-0.2528248727,
0.6336343884,
0.5598984361,
0.2333717495,
-0.3504779041,
-0.8210561275,
-0.0159146246,
-0.1333965212,
0.0894632936,
-0.1679945737,
0.7395447493,
-0.3888062835,
0.3773438632,
0.1181080043,
0.2184913456,
0.1009782106,
-0.1448134184,
0.5353386402,
-0.6958163977,
-0.4194369316,
-0.9202767015,
0.155974865,
-0.3636330366,
-0.1293245852,
1.1073532104,
0.4910106063,
0.7128246427,
0.1584662944,
1.3289698362,
-0.2897450626,
0.5296975374,
-0.0328912921,
0.9405511618,
-0.636962235,
-0.026561331,
-0.1363342553,
-0.1792876422,
-0.126119405,
0.2004230469,
-0.5118581653,
-0.6344501972,
0.5152117014,
0.451569587,
0.281134069,
0.0297942869,
0.0141578782,
0.4390368164,
0.0022508847,
0.0844042823,
0.7718361616,
-0.3811810911,
0.4039681256,
-0.3650410771,
-0.3567795157,
-0.6639538407,
-0.6081388593,
-0.7278207541,
-0.7311013937,
-0.1751545221,
-0.3506430089,
0.2705678046,
1.2375998497,
0.2437267154,
-0.7335791588,
-0.2899344265,
0.3833112717,
0.2442099601,
-0.22505337,
-0.3136249781,
0.3932263851,
-0.0021999455,
-0.3518143594,
0.1945314705,
0.5152127147,
-0.2349666208,
0.0201400034,
0.278102845,
-0.4919113517,
0.5088114738,
0.6482233405,
0.1980943382,
-0.3847231269,
0.0634935349,
0.3170927167,
-0.8255816102,
0.0276372731,
0.6075698733,
-0.2507469356,
0.4060708284,
0.969584167,
0.6962552071,
-0.0023657803,
0.1757596433,
0.5586525202,
-0.6249514818,
0.3160802722,
-0.1697203219,
0.1604479104,
0.6615581512,
-0.7498933673,
0.2902587056,
0.4334869385,
-0.0930591524,
-0.4162776768,
-0.2435633987,
-1.0180642605,
-0.619589746,
1.2569224834,
-0.0715302229,
-0.1140648723,
-0.4030609131,
-0.2800659835,
0.5063897371,
-0.5613723993,
1.1771041155,
0.8736804724,
0.3073052466,
0.1705103964,
-0.1256755143,
0.7282689214,
0.133056283,
-1.0442554951,
-0.2898461819,
-0.1437384039,
-0.0933081061,
0.0601688251,
0.7227162719,
0.1230080202,
0.3907257617,
-0.2841471136,
0.0044657225,
0.5136964917,
-0.3001379371,
-0.0594532005,
0.2504257262,
-0.3067511916,
0.0775263533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07996v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07996v1
|
How Well Do Text Embedding Models Understand Syntax?
| 2023-11-14T08:51:00 | 2023-11-14T08:51:00 |
Yan Zhang, Zhaopeng Feng, Zhiyang Teng, Zuozhu Liu, Haizhou Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text embedding models have significantly contributed to advancements in
natural language processing by adeptly capturing semantic properties of textual
data. However, the ability of these models to generalize across a wide range of
syntactic contexts remains under-explored. In this paper, we first develop an
evaluation set, named \textbf{SR}, to scrutinize the capability for syntax
understanding of text embedding models from two crucial syntactic aspects:
Structural heuristics, and Relational understanding among concepts, as revealed
by the performance gaps in previous studies. Our findings reveal that existing
text embedding models have not sufficiently addressed these syntactic
understanding challenges, and such ineffectiveness becomes even more apparent
when evaluated against existing benchmark datasets. Furthermore, we conduct
rigorous analysis to unearth factors that lead to such limitations and examine
why previous evaluations fail to detect such ineffectiveness. Lastly, we
propose strategies to augment the generalization ability of text embedding
models in diverse syntactic scenarios. This study serves to highlight the
hurdles associated with syntactic generalization and provides pragmatic
guidance for boosting model performance across varied syntactic contexts.
|
[
0.0466659516,
-0.9708987474,
0.8596636057,
0.2787289023,
-0.4973572195,
0.3394524753,
-0.2859704196,
-0.2921643257,
-0.1625514328,
0.1121682674,
-0.3704550564,
-0.761051774,
-0.8038075566,
0.1754865795,
-0.453112036,
0.8230746984,
-0.3028298616,
0.0643336549,
-0.5637577176,
-0.2727864683,
-0.56315732,
-0.4934661984,
0.1366412938,
-0.1884068102,
0.0390523262,
0.1088468283,
0.7035040259,
0.6374843717,
0.6174972653,
0.2444262207,
-0.3566706181,
-0.0385735817,
-0.4257279634,
0.2315280885,
-0.2437548488,
-0.418923229,
0.0126723619,
-0.2476252615,
0.9917311668,
0.9469676018,
-0.3212371767,
-0.0031132442,
-0.0421729237,
0.3709778488,
-0.6440530419,
0.3593616784,
-0.7175941467,
0.1620632112,
-0.0116907507,
0.1138542145,
-0.576867342,
-0.1533613801,
0.4140751958,
-0.508544445,
0.3158647418,
0.0296858251,
1.0383350849,
0.2602536082,
-0.5313045382,
-0.3448554873,
-0.6216667891,
0.5172552466,
-0.2778889537,
0.6500049233,
0.263805747,
0.3013209403,
0.152519092,
-0.8701885343,
-0.2655532956,
-0.2233592719,
-0.1350701004,
-0.0690086633,
-0.3551249206,
0.0362388082,
0.1671638489,
0.4493100047,
-0.5640580654,
-0.0330789424,
-0.2133057564,
0.0400326103,
0.1697485447,
0.1305675209,
0.3858229518,
-0.4695578218,
-0.4675400257,
-0.0057672765,
-0.384115696,
0.0477713384,
0.1273388714,
0.3082044721,
-0.2261316031,
0.5669156909,
0.1191615388,
0.6187371016,
-0.4273814559,
0.4271466136,
0.0740842372,
-0.9381496906,
-0.3387065828,
-0.6602566242,
0.6504042149,
-0.0367293097,
0.5427730083,
-0.5084918737,
-0.1261564046,
0.3345859051,
0.6229929924,
-0.4815403819,
-0.1572884619,
0.1004424617,
-0.4307892621,
-0.1420157254,
0.0092639858,
-0.3299172819,
-0.1103819162,
-0.0706175864,
0.3049971759,
-0.6439988613,
-0.2789364457,
0.1699262261,
-0.5882162452,
0.1401596516,
0.2578240633,
-0.9674113393,
0.5515424013,
0.7279818058,
0.6891018152,
0.2893353105,
-0.1714927852,
0.0004628159,
0.1068619639,
-0.2388882339,
0.8951311707,
-1.0996037722,
-0.2938456833,
-0.0204048567,
-0.1530165225,
-0.5183967948,
-0.3801211417,
0.427331686,
-0.3611252904,
0.0355700999,
-0.3004930317,
-0.7772945762,
-0.0941572636,
0.0259416625,
-0.5995298028,
0.6286405325,
0.188775152,
-0.7673344612,
0.5053122044,
-0.3683374226,
-0.4053082466,
-0.1168621182,
-0.204358384,
-0.2860298157,
0.5779017806,
0.2447065264,
0.542978406,
-0.3182316124,
0.3869758546,
-0.2168659568,
-0.473646909,
0.1948363036,
-0.0928896442,
0.4952763915,
-0.1733570397,
0.0165729169,
-0.0109880632,
-0.4717117548,
0.00327498,
0.2129627168,
-0.0985028893,
-0.5012567043,
0.0878763422,
0.0743537769,
-0.1210316867,
-0.074349083,
-0.1455124021,
0.0607676581,
-0.4468194246,
0.6954681277,
0.6864187121,
-0.0088613704,
0.6581218243,
0.1129827499,
0.7717394233,
-0.0074196039,
-0.2634606957,
-0.3951095045,
-0.3176133335,
-0.3575313687,
-0.025500156,
0.7207739353,
0.3587512672,
-0.4852484465,
0.3065539598,
-0.2746630609,
-0.3518897295,
-0.5354879498,
0.1603805721,
0.6769534945,
0.0966031998,
0.3806031942,
-0.0718528405,
-0.536159575,
-1.0433502197,
-0.7685997486,
-0.1464694291,
0.316640228,
0.239275068,
0.7685710788,
-0.124044627,
0.7941981554,
-0.3681667745,
0.0910094008,
-0.476185441,
-0.0149548473,
-0.138101548,
0.390378207,
0.3899191022,
-0.7877089381,
-0.3145709336,
-0.1604295522,
-0.8462626934,
0.2239564508,
-0.0333022624,
-0.0544697307,
-0.0744108483,
0.3330315351,
-0.6920431256,
0.535022676,
0.4391818047,
-0.5088623166,
0.4592033029,
-0.0265508201,
-0.2504630983,
-0.8174848557,
-0.0806528851,
0.3634492457,
-0.3343806565,
-0.5639346242,
0.5096982121,
0.3632928133,
-0.1016183421,
0.0330104083,
0.4077465832,
-0.5727418065,
-0.1332931221,
0.2056785226,
0.4490903914,
0.3809354305,
0.2699248791,
-0.0720149949,
0.520754993,
0.2955973148,
-0.4808009267,
-0.051573284,
0.3677428365,
-0.4050016999,
0.3832027912,
-0.9089494944,
-0.0319518894,
-0.2042313963,
0.282541126,
-1.0400196314,
-0.1057358161,
0.30782336,
-0.4659902751,
0.4107088447,
-0.3564082086,
-0.6507942677,
-0.0762052834,
-0.1008396819,
0.402505666,
0.2418698519,
-0.2215396911,
0.5565530658,
0.3173323274,
0.0331859067,
-0.566901803,
-0.5545122623,
0.049714718,
-0.0126473354,
-0.7583691478,
0.6103705168,
0.2394852191,
-0.437574774,
0.2356678843,
-0.3990605772,
-0.2090780735,
0.3012875617,
0.0303947795,
-0.0026059963,
-0.2148910761,
0.5164470077,
0.2388657182,
-0.1130002961,
0.1397692412,
-0.149918437,
0.3858433366,
-0.1397259384,
-0.3471999466,
-0.404854238,
0.1222303212,
0.1387667805,
-0.3234222531,
0.8663709164,
0.5004142523,
-0.6620718837,
-0.4140401483,
-0.2419271767,
0.0045761098,
-0.3581461906,
0.5663334131,
-0.6556202769,
-0.7843354344,
0.5850893259,
-0.0025069828,
-0.2027355731,
0.5005251169,
0.2515126169,
-0.2378379554,
0.7457301021,
0.8893649578,
0.4553569257,
0.3117370009,
-0.3089379966,
0.2398702651,
-0.784009397,
-0.243013382,
-0.7537036538,
-0.0148434285,
-0.6094084978,
-0.4584680498,
0.005473468,
0.3173420429,
0.1501915902,
0.5956512094,
-0.2769827843,
0.4629274309,
0.0088300267,
0.0468735322,
0.3047237098,
0.102831319,
-0.5152727365,
-0.2748755217,
-0.7087019682,
-0.6676289439,
0.8912440538,
0.736502409,
0.7068151832,
0.1503889859,
0.4449289143,
0.2128466964,
0.0472489521,
-0.625600934,
0.2168887556,
-0.3436416686,
-0.5004357696,
0.0028481483,
-0.4422084987,
-0.7097058892,
0.5466633439,
-0.1620136946,
-0.6847208142,
0.1844176799,
0.0607664287,
-0.0385537557,
-0.0014810846,
-1.1078667641,
1.1574145555,
0.2777434587,
-0.2967199385,
-0.2927852869,
-0.4855023921,
0.2656480074,
0.1421679258,
0.2533085942,
-0.0248248726,
-0.1051137224,
0.5524818897,
-0.175868541,
0.8000438809,
-0.2296552658,
-0.0481660925,
0.1235306114,
-0.088177301,
0.349427402,
0.2177833319,
-0.09469264,
0.0455482677,
0.1023275107,
-0.3179962039,
-0.7530782223,
0.3374527991,
-0.4079285562,
-0.4030671418,
-0.1755526215,
-0.196096018,
-0.2485115826,
-0.1089416817,
0.1324103475,
0.5400272608,
-0.5225232244,
0.19447577,
0.4808689356,
-0.2295649499,
0.1190426573,
0.2261391282,
-0.160470441,
-0.3145020306,
0.6190800667,
0.0468881913,
0.2765407264,
0.5323444009,
0.0218056999,
-0.4424992502,
-0.5513126254,
-0.4979605377,
0.3325601518,
-1.0067102909,
-0.052016601,
-0.9826741815,
-0.0509033427,
-0.4396239221,
0.0098231956,
0.0076559084,
-0.6131800413,
-0.2970653772,
-0.3650188744,
0.1455658525,
1.0497285128,
0.3890744746,
0.4681941271,
-0.7264971137,
0.3272524178,
-0.1616957784,
0.4302659035,
0.1092101559,
-0.4950959682,
-0.4690108597,
-0.1811774671,
-0.1374635249,
-1.0459315777,
0.0675992668,
0.2093665451,
0.7311859727,
0.0906376317,
-0.3221054375,
0.6743763685,
-0.5422865152,
0.571908772,
-0.2285078317,
-1.3144489527,
0.5914664268,
-0.2542777359,
0.1823779792,
0.5793941021,
0.2965901792,
-0.3564795256,
-0.5006563663,
-0.7308724523,
-0.740689218,
0.508978188,
0.4328123927,
0.3311119676,
-0.0832643881,
0.5489532948,
0.0995464697,
0.3758251369,
-0.968341291,
-0.0380257182,
-0.0773815885,
-0.242499724,
-0.0084237549,
-0.3222568333,
0.096807085,
-0.301710397,
0.1717045158,
0.0460184887,
0.4196870625,
-0.00687024,
-0.7455249429,
0.0618358739,
0.3451928496,
0.3041794002,
0.9584306479,
-0.118757017,
-0.0297762845,
-0.0419732593,
-0.2237138599,
-0.1048174426,
0.205545634,
0.1267269403,
0.2415749133,
0.7246674895,
0.8384714127,
0.660852313,
-0.42236498,
0.5679472685,
-0.2373554856,
0.1455613822,
-0.1410726458,
0.0222816989,
0.2613084018,
0.0223139841,
0.1367078573,
0.1049102023,
-0.0134418672,
-0.6464181542,
0.138376236,
0.5863889456,
-0.2504575551,
-0.4616024792,
0.4271502495,
0.0864244327,
-0.2022610009,
0.451325357,
-0.1209536344,
-0.7999414206,
0.8014267683,
0.7287743092,
0.8154397607,
0.0609580837,
0.3137977123,
0.2924942076,
0.6491971612,
0.1551773101,
0.3147099316,
-0.2389172912,
-0.8253452778,
-0.4186051488,
-0.6606820822,
-0.4924773574,
-0.5639624596,
-0.6615070701,
0.1461131275,
-0.6282181144,
-0.207215026,
0.2079140246,
-0.154073447,
-0.9718969464,
0.1054499522,
-0.3846574426,
1.0748986006,
-0.9107965827,
0.4854594767,
0.7628452182,
-0.6178802252,
-0.4846087992,
0.2270117849,
-0.348105669,
-0.8590965867,
0.615619123,
0.3760702312,
0.123665899,
-0.048746638,
-0.4044750035,
-0.4912993312,
0.8273519874,
0.2473561764,
-0.466317147,
-0.3603255749,
-0.0622917227,
0.725231111,
-0.5070691705,
0.3192786574,
0.5886724591,
0.4831449986,
-0.4688943624,
-0.7975954413,
0.1806686372,
-0.3450106084,
0.273896575,
0.1383065134,
-0.3578724861,
0.7193225026,
-0.39119187,
-0.5636276007,
0.0242530741,
0.3209063709,
0.029672632,
0.1916684955,
0.2942842841,
0.8189781904,
0.6445788145,
-0.2742851973,
1.2918959856,
-0.089961037,
0.3021950424,
0.9933848381,
-0.2066261917,
0.8941826224,
0.2046918869,
-0.321957469,
0.955927074,
0.5214577913,
-0.0067023789,
0.4686953425,
0.2144437581,
-0.0690472946,
-0.3905113935,
-0.1211017743,
-0.3970690668,
0.6086419821,
0.730239749,
-0.7925382257,
-0.1875081807,
-0.0980501994,
-0.3349378705,
0.386795938,
0.278465569,
0.9440387487,
0.1561509073,
-0.352666527,
0.3449555039,
0.2617339194,
0.3124705553,
-0.538626492,
-0.1758935153,
0.0076367343,
-0.0573043302,
-0.0018349072,
-0.6942133307,
0.485706687,
-0.0055340691,
-0.3663283587,
-0.1521532089,
0.8823952079,
-0.0934322774,
-0.3642769158,
0.5694108009,
0.8296121955,
-0.1015349329,
0.0335575417,
-0.5136404037,
0.2524031401,
-0.1569318175,
0.0880788937,
0.1037403122,
0.5856469274,
0.1800562292,
0.5905524492,
0.4586153328,
-0.1244285554,
-0.3754170835,
0.3337090909,
0.8901660442,
-0.9762310386,
-0.4660487175,
-1.0591173172,
0.6100077629,
0.0491734669,
-0.2709891796,
0.5607709289,
0.2683202922,
0.7133006454,
0.09010721,
0.7514676452,
0.1692408323,
0.2907734215,
-0.6452063322,
0.4938875735,
-0.4997419715,
0.4731889665,
-0.4508934319,
-0.9412741065,
-0.2659349144,
0.8761270642,
-0.3715872467,
0.308642745,
0.8942152858,
0.3875721395,
-0.0828268379,
0.1893441677,
0.1365786642,
0.2456610203,
0.0867785513,
0.3306774795,
1.0509432554,
-0.6019431353,
0.4126539826,
-0.0624919534,
-0.0170382019,
0.0445673354,
-0.8820186257,
-0.910223484,
-0.5181490183,
-0.1579328179,
-0.2617880106,
0.4202924967,
0.7133373618,
0.5702955723,
-0.5142649412,
0.0044375672,
-0.3035976887,
0.5664573312,
-0.0076225037,
-0.275451839,
0.2358807623,
-0.5432235599,
-0.590025425,
0.4408793449,
0.2971458137,
0.0166669078,
-0.3143622577,
0.238309443,
-0.2100462317,
-0.0293227062,
0.4590030611,
-0.1079671904,
-0.7878590226,
-0.1461656839,
0.05233749,
-0.1075866446,
-0.0192862507,
0.7595139742,
-0.83980757,
0.3893975019,
0.4594612718,
0.6309835911,
0.1687209308,
0.0917064324,
0.836814642,
-1.0329235792,
-0.162704885,
0.1727738976,
0.5698305368,
0.42306301,
-0.2557630241,
0.6107467413,
0.3596258461,
-0.3731341958,
-0.9455078244,
0.1656593382,
-0.5580525398,
-0.4831292927,
0.8145241141,
-0.2300514132,
0.0147876982,
-0.1229564399,
0.2981708348,
0.1886870861,
-0.2310920954,
0.4099234343,
0.9428478479,
0.1106738895,
-0.1428805739,
-0.4327866137,
0.276884824,
0.5218806267,
-0.5968769789,
0.1832195818,
0.4475306571,
0.2906359732,
0.0337747969,
0.4992612898,
-0.0161261782,
0.3306580782,
0.1515340954,
-0.3622066677,
0.1649580449,
-0.5057026744,
-0.6289325356,
0.177676633,
0.0539406985,
0.055170048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07989v7
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07989v7
|
Unifying the Perspectives of NLP and Software Engineering: A Survey on Language Models for Code
| 2023-11-14T08:34:26 | 2024-06-26T07:11:00 |
Ziyin Zhang, Chaoyu Chen, Bingchang Liu, Cong Liao, Zi Gong, Hang Yu, Jianguo Li, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
In this work we systematically review the recent advancements in software
engineering with language models, covering 70+ models, 40+ evaluation tasks,
180+ datasets, and 900 related works. Unlike previous works, we integrate
software engineering (SE) with natural language processing (NLP) by discussing
the perspectives of both sides: SE applies language models for development
automation, while NLP adopts SE tasks for language model evaluation. We break
down code processing models into general language models represented by the GPT
family and specialized models that are specifically pretrained on code, often
with tailored objectives. We discuss the relations and differences between
these models, and highlight the historical transition of code modeling from
statistical models and RNNs to pretrained Transformers and LLMs, which is
exactly the same course that had been taken by NLP. We also go beyond
programming and review LLMs' application in other software engineering
activities including requirement engineering, testing, deployment, and
operations in an endeavor to provide a global view of NLP in SE, and identify
key challenges and potential future directions in this domain. We keep the
survey open and updated on GitHub at
https://github.com/codefuse-ai/Awesome-Code-LLM.
|
[
-0.4049847424,
-0.2797806859,
0.3694120646,
0.4553398192,
0.2455486804,
0.2647548616,
-0.118723385,
-0.6308643818,
-0.0421350412,
0.6835075021,
-0.3947045505,
-0.4751936197,
-0.3958168328,
-0.0278800502,
-0.613242209,
1.0811430216,
-0.2362932712,
0.3390293717,
-0.2334408909,
0.1699542701,
-0.4917352796,
-0.6877759099,
-0.2144910395,
-0.4189839065,
0.047523696,
-0.2187060863,
0.5684560537,
-0.1028247848,
0.6240311265,
0.2828205228,
-0.008319838,
-0.3488366008,
0.0786455572,
0.0191551764,
-0.0407667719,
-0.4370879531,
-0.6206639409,
0.2469053715,
0.2351334989,
0.9165215492,
-0.0735582933,
0.3000784218,
0.3272339106,
0.5948984623,
-0.3525702655,
0.2579288185,
-0.5556314588,
0.2124190331,
0.2774071991,
-0.1340699494,
-0.5142087936,
-0.2845734954,
0.1092812791,
-0.2642146945,
0.1934619248,
-0.149276197,
0.6742654443,
0.2124657929,
-0.2970677614,
-0.3793213069,
-0.9604792595,
0.9150857925,
-0.9249256849,
0.3986842334,
0.1690832078,
0.0234733094,
-0.0555107184,
-0.643206954,
-0.2284882218,
-0.4881744981,
0.1789823025,
0.0600221641,
0.0418239012,
0.208363235,
0.1134787947,
0.6618609428,
-0.7657142878,
0.221664533,
-0.355578512,
-0.2568503618,
0.8279237747,
-0.0345669724,
0.7234382629,
0.0798802078,
-0.2783839107,
0.270298332,
-0.5860385895,
-0.1281975508,
0.1662816107,
0.0685215145,
-0.2448936403,
0.4596490562,
-0.0786897466,
0.8372356892,
-0.6988362074,
0.3943711221,
0.2344704866,
-0.3925300539,
-0.5000258088,
-0.4991780818,
0.6482342482,
0.2546049356,
0.3093539774,
-0.4373195171,
-0.3396513164,
0.4544209242,
0.538774848,
-0.2593833804,
-0.1305170506,
0.2600782514,
-0.4712468088,
-0.4499054253,
0.0834514126,
-0.4915632904,
-0.4365944862,
-0.5446980596,
0.0035875801,
0.0750401914,
-0.3858898878,
0.4076911211,
-0.0049383901,
0.521894753,
0.1278418452,
-0.7891287804,
0.3933334053,
1.0824662447,
0.6198416948,
-0.1491503567,
-0.4497328401,
0.0117616551,
-0.3475030065,
-0.2672142088,
0.748007834,
-0.4890406728,
-0.3418759704,
0.1530225724,
-0.2074103206,
0.0998762622,
-0.5011075735,
0.353641063,
-0.6877316833,
0.320098877,
0.4931071103,
-0.6258313656,
-0.2665407956,
0.4208932221,
-0.5978074074,
1.0240882635,
0.2405973971,
-0.4913846552,
0.1970306486,
-0.8762190342,
-0.100912936,
0.1248834655,
-0.4058570862,
-0.110289529,
0.2794229984,
0.1394971907,
0.3842409849,
-0.5141301155,
0.538095355,
-0.3492048681,
-0.262311846,
0.1679020822,
-0.2029659301,
0.9716251493,
0.2661510408,
-0.138303712,
0.2321124822,
-0.642275691,
0.427963376,
0.0086267404,
-0.2555321753,
-0.1411895156,
0.138074398,
0.1949723959,
0.3406881392,
0.1530728042,
-0.3380075991,
0.558811307,
-0.6082938313,
0.5100033879,
0.5129063129,
-0.1563252062,
0.8274123669,
-0.1015864536,
0.8108272552,
-0.25239411,
0.3923129737,
-0.0785989463,
-0.5900636315,
-0.5071045756,
0.2779482007,
0.3724393547,
0.6992143989,
-0.4563241303,
0.3328859806,
-0.0608699657,
-0.334237963,
-0.5543243289,
0.2639761567,
0.0490792319,
-0.045829542,
0.3593052924,
-0.468770355,
-0.8225124478,
-0.6558190584,
-0.4905191362,
-0.4137099087,
-0.4719710052,
0.0039868318,
0.4337417185,
-0.5249456167,
1.1089318991,
-0.5053808093,
-0.0820419565,
-0.5793085694,
0.183667019,
0.3757249117,
0.3654808104,
0.4288344085,
-0.8307011127,
-0.2854246795,
-0.0075547108,
-0.7034988999,
-0.1604634225,
0.0312159304,
0.1128036156,
0.0352212824,
0.480504632,
-0.3542655408,
0.3732124269,
0.7735927701,
-0.1198848858,
0.5083355308,
0.0443747938,
0.1658417135,
-0.9188930988,
-0.1009851247,
0.0374700651,
0.0862218142,
-0.6383683085,
0.5438914299,
-0.0376000442,
-0.3780790567,
-0.2841787934,
0.4606395066,
-0.7070304751,
-0.3240410686,
-0.3817642033,
-0.1215432957,
-0.0456878394,
0.3643873036,
-0.0662698448,
0.7080149055,
0.7877984047,
-0.556292057,
0.4125695825,
0.0583880506,
-0.4253771603,
-0.0720119402,
-0.6911719441,
0.3038941324,
0.1674408913,
0.1172137782,
-0.718242228,
0.0125241736,
-0.0317261927,
-0.5093394518,
0.0179474857,
-0.2792670727,
-0.4709061384,
-0.5510819554,
-0.3467992842,
0.3649966419,
0.594029367,
-0.1155391857,
0.3726630807,
0.6152005196,
-0.3549036682,
-0.4748337865,
-0.745857358,
0.1689780354,
0.0779754743,
-0.6256329417,
0.3363479078,
-0.0729817748,
-0.4426583052,
-0.109491162,
-0.2297211289,
-0.5340859294,
0.2355392277,
0.0825254247,
0.6376940608,
-0.3449339867,
0.1684166342,
-0.3192427158,
-0.1435294151,
0.2789784074,
-0.4171860516,
0.5264092088,
-0.2731001377,
-0.4457645416,
-0.1131589785,
0.304707855,
0.1925271302,
-0.3049432039,
0.3324972689,
0.2649443746,
-0.2558124363,
-0.2728157043,
-0.3996725082,
-0.1763334274,
-0.3798355162,
0.4812634289,
-0.0451130979,
-1.1621114016,
0.3273575902,
-0.2163153291,
0.5201352239,
0.3788136244,
0.322191447,
-0.0542767085,
0.9746534228,
1.2581981421,
-0.5241788626,
0.3424206376,
-0.2438482791,
0.5552874804,
-0.5975973606,
0.226090014,
-0.7668253779,
-0.0134740723,
-0.4165777266,
-0.3163306415,
0.004528821,
0.2792511582,
0.0193954222,
0.3387413621,
-0.7891631722,
0.5892848372,
-0.0122440327,
-0.4115956128,
0.3587296605,
-0.1307951063,
0.0657210201,
0.0298176166,
-0.5191448927,
-0.6492719054,
1.2730762959,
0.5037096143,
0.847186327,
-0.2744973302,
0.7398706079,
0.4960900545,
0.6044899821,
-0.608556509,
0.5606289506,
-0.011874889,
-0.5559796691,
-0.1823893636,
-0.3231732547,
-0.5964862704,
0.1605563462,
0.1295820028,
-0.7395386696,
-0.2617224455,
0.0447422601,
-0.2261930853,
0.205999136,
-0.7582486272,
0.9310061932,
-0.2786274552,
0.1971078962,
-0.1574043036,
-0.446295768,
0.3953852355,
-0.0067397472,
0.5142470002,
-0.1394827068,
0.0357400551,
0.5723850131,
-0.3155361712,
0.6753467321,
-0.0125671392,
-0.3538220227,
0.361443609,
-0.1968934238,
0.3119864762,
-0.0347315632,
-0.2060857564,
0.302552253,
0.0109481923,
-0.2071488798,
-0.6639650464,
0.4753237963,
-0.5262899995,
-0.4020498395,
-0.4601277709,
-0.5467019081,
-0.3936814368,
-0.0105605442,
0.0588657446,
0.2779487967,
-0.2964562178,
-0.133727327,
0.396353364,
-0.4500394464,
0.4045930505,
0.2683787048,
-0.8059566021,
-0.0745346621,
0.5550092459,
-0.1249688938,
0.3038653731,
0.41601336,
-0.3332203031,
-0.0392221026,
-0.5789068341,
-0.1870205551,
0.057980597,
-0.5619966388,
0.0699010566,
-0.5653486252,
-0.6032915115,
-0.66039747,
-0.2874904275,
-0.4914595485,
-0.2580640316,
-0.038378153,
0.0842670277,
0.1549689174,
1.1202075481,
0.4086664319,
0.1250071228,
-0.8178230524,
0.3581422567,
-0.0458635837,
0.4588528872,
-0.1125146523,
-0.348112613,
-0.286259532,
0.0272421334,
-0.2981822193,
-0.7918031216,
0.3045228124,
-0.1971203536,
0.576885879,
-0.3295090199,
-0.0854943097,
0.3367322981,
-0.4655617177,
0.9786978364,
0.1771805584,
-0.8018261194,
0.3979215026,
-0.0394841991,
0.4073480368,
0.4040208161,
0.2432233095,
-0.6931006908,
-0.571995914,
-0.4815063477,
-1.0049216747,
0.4500687718,
0.0769246593,
0.2078344822,
0.3445578814,
0.0576226488,
-0.0424698144,
0.2873821855,
-1.0721303225,
-0.0962121785,
0.1570759565,
-0.2340592444,
0.1021945924,
-0.1928680241,
0.1309094578,
-0.2183726579,
0.6147484183,
0.0302598178,
0.4024525881,
-0.1626287401,
-0.5272849798,
0.5507853031,
0.6766631007,
0.4359555542,
0.782366097,
0.0102948109,
-0.0216751061,
0.0929796621,
-0.5214092135,
0.0959165096,
0.0926197991,
-0.1502916068,
0.0205200501,
0.2854893208,
0.4799987376,
0.3464882076,
-0.4919724166,
0.4920267463,
-0.0478262044,
-0.0885859057,
-0.3719302714,
0.0815929919,
0.1248527244,
0.0956523046,
0.3146066666,
0.1132199094,
0.3168620169,
-0.2986437976,
0.1996936798,
0.3511458039,
-0.4191943109,
-0.2969522178,
0.6641833782,
0.2831692994,
-0.3002766371,
0.5692053437,
-0.1822116524,
-0.4005527198,
0.8184129596,
0.3744065464,
1.3560813665,
-0.0462007411,
0.3011891544,
-0.0109533807,
0.5344966054,
0.0442004837,
0.3867269754,
-0.0311582237,
-0.5313335061,
-0.8588597775,
-0.7517668009,
-0.4113534093,
0.1851644963,
-0.4355332851,
0.3498961329,
-0.2087300569,
-0.0886297598,
0.0026475072,
-0.2213590294,
-0.5477229357,
0.0051934957,
0.2663403451,
0.8634555936,
-0.7772613168,
0.8571252823,
0.9493706822,
-0.5031841397,
-0.6948701143,
-0.0080811288,
-0.0615192167,
-0.4817884266,
0.5747357011,
0.1563325226,
-0.005767982,
0.0906785876,
-0.6988707781,
-0.5541917086,
0.6755583286,
0.1648972929,
-0.361635983,
-0.3903626204,
0.3001445234,
0.5391924977,
-0.3218024671,
0.4518632889,
0.4670508802,
0.0471676886,
-0.5325950384,
-1.0119284391,
-0.6522523761,
-0.6242139339,
0.4120107591,
0.2993833721,
-0.057591524,
0.5701403022,
0.0262319539,
-0.181997329,
0.1134823561,
0.6168708205,
0.2793480754,
0.2599217296,
0.3362727463,
0.1865485013,
0.228669554,
-0.0740017816,
1.003921628,
-0.6104905009,
0.4827620983,
1.0691176653,
-0.5204216242,
0.6214414239,
0.4699101746,
-0.6927745938,
0.2508814931,
0.4707561135,
-0.0899671391,
0.0609323904,
0.4265695512,
-0.2228420526,
0.0784512088,
0.0951625705,
-0.6411358714,
0.1161087528,
-0.0491880067,
-0.2635204196,
-0.3291864693,
0.0574050099,
-0.2209828943,
0.0417351723,
-0.354174763,
0.6252507567,
0.3328985274,
-0.552832365,
0.2237546295,
0.1094395295,
0.8613126874,
-0.7417283654,
0.0237967763,
-0.1414421946,
0.1448628157,
-0.276851058,
-0.9711036682,
0.6797305942,
0.2464126199,
-0.2954080105,
-0.6201967001,
0.7483243942,
-0.1717215478,
-0.403922081,
0.4380467832,
0.3931796551,
0.3619255126,
-0.1154789925,
-0.8562327027,
0.1301921308,
0.0896014944,
-0.2089386582,
0.346003592,
0.0316543877,
0.0649637654,
0.551214695,
0.4302578866,
0.1371703893,
0.3558906913,
0.4069292247,
0.6476145387,
-0.7636812925,
-0.4675498903,
-0.7604382634,
0.6796264648,
0.087481752,
-0.2128528208,
0.6236320734,
0.6968451738,
1.0584871769,
-0.3658225834,
0.8597314358,
-0.1391857266,
0.4511733055,
-0.4843482971,
0.7161089182,
-0.3804763258,
0.5412918925,
-0.6080845594,
-0.9897712469,
-0.4977650642,
0.316646874,
-0.4372812212,
0.0720789731,
0.5092967749,
0.7525690198,
0.0998093411,
0.1867986023,
0.2010883093,
-0.105184786,
0.3091233373,
0.4536818266,
1.0441131592,
-0.5231626034,
0.2050257474,
-0.0517841093,
-0.0954900011,
0.0539503992,
-0.771368742,
-0.3203786314,
-0.5837805867,
-0.4208008945,
0.0065158783,
-0.3001661599,
0.8074449301,
0.4244679511,
-0.9020434022,
-0.691685915,
-0.4615963995,
0.2244191021,
-0.2505832911,
-0.2112196982,
-0.224099353,
-0.675881207,
-0.5770363808,
0.408913523,
0.4818439484,
-0.1329297423,
-0.5265122652,
-0.1576162428,
-0.1311401725,
-0.2297028154,
0.7308064699,
0.3333661258,
-0.6767485142,
0.2422675341,
0.2364361733,
-0.293464005,
0.0973775536,
1.0194611549,
-0.6031494737,
0.2164625823,
0.5531150103,
0.7970158458,
0.0555643961,
-0.377228111,
0.7533578873,
-0.452080518,
0.201206103,
0.5355083346,
0.2642196715,
0.1456788182,
-0.2171136141,
0.8537611365,
0.0530742407,
-0.8785272837,
-1.1510108709,
0.4071151316,
-0.7228803635,
-0.2769925296,
0.9165434837,
0.0260216091,
0.1458095163,
-0.3953386545,
-0.0406672731,
0.0612755716,
0.3034339845,
0.5273332596,
0.7960635424,
-0.2763926685,
-0.1893515438,
-1.0303611755,
0.4960034192,
0.3990695477,
-1.012802124,
-0.1120306328,
0.3563045561,
0.1188568249,
0.0684103668,
0.7809827328,
-0.2484109849,
0.1284199208,
-0.0768093392,
0.7216519117,
0.4279907644,
-0.3324088156,
-0.5363442898,
0.1317418665,
0.4318310022,
0.1212088615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07978v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07978v2
|
How good are Large Language Models on African Languages?
| 2023-11-14T08:10:14 | 2024-04-30T16:04:16 |
Jessica Ojo, Kelechi Ogueji, Pontus Stenetorp, David Ifeoluwa Adelani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in natural language processing have led to the
proliferation of large language models (LLMs). These models have been shown to
yield good performance, using in-context learning, even on tasks and languages
they are not trained on. However, their performance on African languages is
largely understudied relative to high-resource languages. We present an
analysis of four popular large language models (mT0, Aya, LLaMa 2, and GPT-4)
on six tasks (topic classification, sentiment classification, machine
translation, summarization, question answering, and named entity recognition)
across 60 African languages, spanning different language families and
geographical regions. Our results suggest that all LLMs produce lower
performance for African languages, and there is a large gap in performance
compared to high-resource languages (such as English) for most tasks. We find
that GPT-4 has an average to good performance on classification tasks, yet its
performance on generative tasks such as machine translation and summarization
is significantly lacking. Surprisingly, we find that mT0 had the best overall
performance for cross-lingual QA, better than the state-of-the-art supervised
model (i.e. fine-tuned mT5) and GPT-4 on African languages. Similarly, we find
the recent Aya model to have comparable result to mT0 in almost all tasks
except for topic classification where it outperform mT0. Overall, LLaMa 2
showed the worst performance, which we believe is due to its English and
code-centric~(around 98%) pre-training corpus. Our findings confirms that
performance on African languages continues to remain a hurdle for the current
LLMs, underscoring the need for additional efforts to close this gap.
|
[
-0.6069435477,
-0.6213241816,
0.5126607418,
0.2316943556,
-0.348223269,
0.1131208017,
-0.5220925808,
-0.7658062577,
0.3505699039,
0.4270873964,
-0.210267514,
-0.308552742,
-0.9259633422,
0.3136446774,
-0.493339777,
0.8505564928,
-0.1524320394,
-0.142543748,
-0.1210057363,
-0.4151245654,
-0.358668834,
-1.0765432119,
-0.6451087594,
-0.6015934348,
0.5876982808,
0.1983801425,
0.654307127,
0.4217511415,
0.2606272995,
0.2770271897,
-0.3319379091,
0.4024191797,
-0.4312803149,
0.0373894051,
0.0467733778,
-0.3524678648,
-0.4082578719,
-0.0234984439,
0.3502057493,
0.6551679373,
-0.0520910881,
0.1928258985,
0.0773675889,
0.4246213436,
-0.4916578233,
0.2518725991,
-0.6053414941,
-0.3314228952,
-0.4851825237,
0.2025555074,
-0.1106511131,
-0.1480704695,
0.0944890901,
-0.3575440347,
0.0063857627,
-0.2625384629,
0.9498921037,
0.0884013176,
-0.6203005314,
-0.567941308,
-0.5344387293,
0.7975202799,
-0.9536316395,
0.1462457031,
0.7895886302,
0.2466056198,
-0.0845095739,
-0.6537339091,
-0.5550965667,
-0.2143435031,
0.1602750719,
-0.1595543623,
-0.2051390707,
0.0044791228,
0.3413648009,
0.4068530798,
-0.1687968075,
0.5914317369,
-0.1690175086,
-0.2150082737,
0.6490469575,
-0.0755612776,
0.3119710982,
-0.2396167219,
0.0349586308,
0.2121209651,
-0.9619482756,
0.0486958921,
0.5183748007,
0.4230253696,
-0.1540593207,
0.5474783182,
0.0184480362,
0.6413956881,
-0.4547792077,
-0.3318490684,
0.230571121,
-0.0949381143,
0.0329525657,
-0.1699835658,
0.8424867988,
0.0970404223,
0.6151247025,
-0.2316416353,
-0.5084305406,
0.2764062583,
0.3180164397,
-0.847707212,
-0.199590385,
0.0330192596,
-0.3180966377,
0.1708782762,
-0.4428453445,
-0.4114678502,
-0.2443187684,
-0.2789543271,
0.4486812651,
-0.4000421464,
-0.0199677963,
-0.2423699796,
0.4607260227,
-0.0032680412,
0.5257152915,
-1.0567839146,
0.2475309223,
0.5785062909,
1.0984731913,
-0.2539567053,
-0.1905470043,
-0.1030912772,
-0.1110818684,
-0.2387898564,
0.5932893753,
-0.4250365496,
-0.374797225,
0.1711340249,
-0.1173879504,
-0.0622182302,
-0.6729316711,
0.4673464894,
-0.6475404501,
-0.1937438697,
-0.7525931001,
-0.384324044,
-0.4923408329,
0.2757736742,
-0.7800531387,
0.8766310811,
0.1259348094,
-0.5729216337,
0.2413600981,
-0.4927739799,
-0.7742137313,
-0.1531313956,
-0.0849969313,
-0.3565198779,
0.1416120678,
0.2725405097,
0.389051199,
-0.5227849483,
0.0437971167,
-0.235318929,
-0.5708037615,
0.2939707339,
-0.420245707,
0.7780286074,
0.3021230996,
-0.542562902,
-0.2595044374,
-0.773504138,
-0.0672738776,
0.0973696634,
-0.3449583054,
-0.2513113022,
-0.0595122613,
-0.0883837417,
0.5579650998,
0.1057075039,
-0.5300493836,
0.1643225849,
-0.3245559335,
0.7994143367,
0.4535834193,
-0.2003212869,
0.1924761832,
0.0780969188,
0.5714091659,
0.0203881375,
-0.1593300402,
0.0642087385,
-0.6781061292,
-1.0163270235,
-0.2185431421,
0.6260905862,
0.4692132771,
-0.8154412508,
0.0658210367,
-0.1148470864,
-0.3047477007,
-0.6818699837,
0.5283910036,
0.2034205794,
0.2009366304,
0.2607953548,
-0.4864707887,
-0.2993355989,
-1.0945622921,
0.1609549224,
-0.1188261658,
0.0347182006,
0.2048798054,
0.6487022042,
-0.5352973342,
0.5249881744,
-0.0463191569,
-0.1594423056,
-0.4401456416,
0.0662672594,
0.2807025015,
0.0635810792,
0.8658124804,
-0.6105452776,
-0.2566541433,
0.1063973159,
-0.5961716175,
-0.1986064911,
0.4057934284,
0.1013439596,
0.5226629972,
0.1067219749,
-0.5780323148,
0.2814859748,
0.9242603183,
0.0899949223,
0.2258943617,
-0.1761006117,
0.0117521444,
-1.0392787457,
0.1677939296,
-0.0019159504,
-0.18239972,
-0.6356253028,
0.0135362707,
0.0346611254,
-0.087232478,
-0.2637619078,
0.5125504136,
-0.5295146704,
-0.4255706966,
-0.5312249064,
0.2372941822,
-0.2781807482,
0.3962873816,
0.0610420518,
0.9945403934,
0.2604678571,
-0.729265511,
0.2081575543,
0.3865170479,
-0.7848331928,
0.0202597901,
-0.594797194,
0.2182693332,
0.0783186033,
0.1755459011,
-0.7987011671,
-0.1627430469,
-0.2610087693,
-0.2503019571,
0.432169348,
-0.1308896989,
-0.5765156746,
-0.4152743816,
0.2208162248,
0.4706740975,
0.4271952212,
-0.6167905331,
0.4615851641,
0.401529789,
-0.4781122506,
-0.7220588923,
-0.9841699004,
0.3129078746,
-0.0770250931,
-0.4912385643,
0.053979136,
0.452463299,
-0.214100346,
-0.3059993088,
-0.0181196928,
-0.0932140574,
0.3759954274,
0.2510512769,
-0.0780136436,
-0.1355834007,
0.1228252202,
-0.2523274422,
0.1150180846,
-0.0236656889,
-0.0226116367,
0.7159249187,
0.0212245192,
-0.1169196963,
-0.0157659203,
0.2446938306,
0.4940992594,
-0.6022413373,
1.1670724154,
0.5442265272,
-0.3257407546,
-0.2117702961,
-0.656262219,
0.0637824908,
-0.3556504548,
0.2946104407,
-0.4889216125,
-0.9872707725,
0.9630395174,
0.0232200734,
0.1053659916,
0.428376615,
0.7368106842,
-0.0749519542,
0.8837170005,
0.7399470806,
-0.3317866027,
0.5068415999,
-0.719032526,
0.3254577518,
-0.7927083969,
-0.1267576218,
-0.6180078387,
-0.3124165833,
-0.7197261453,
-0.2444118112,
0.2124098241,
0.1960725933,
-0.0657857358,
0.3332378566,
0.3244268,
0.1373495311,
0.4704997838,
-0.0685162693,
0.1964062601,
0.2153112888,
-0.1436073333,
0.0465624742,
-0.8818585277,
-0.8977025747,
1.0992877483,
0.303463608,
0.6310363412,
0.2311978638,
0.6931895614,
0.0629364997,
0.555939436,
-0.7175546288,
0.2872533202,
-0.4260129929,
-0.5367087722,
-0.1693687737,
-0.5796421766,
-0.981471777,
0.443893224,
-0.0414895751,
-0.6958537698,
0.0905176178,
0.1577000469,
-0.1420215219,
0.3844034672,
-0.4507839978,
0.896007359,
-0.3396295607,
-0.26935938,
-0.2256126255,
-0.5192742348,
0.4644818902,
-0.4266824424,
0.3057127893,
-0.1215974689,
-0.0789259598,
0.650854528,
-0.6203766465,
0.6383108497,
-0.04887411,
-0.3738241196,
0.4621046484,
0.0565767661,
0.3741805255,
-0.070059672,
-0.3053167164,
0.6182083488,
-0.3564982116,
-0.6533808112,
-0.4404758215,
0.7928339243,
-0.9686158299,
-0.516346395,
-0.271448344,
-0.4312201738,
-0.4397359788,
-0.0807498768,
0.5228903294,
0.6157191992,
-0.0152266184,
0.166684255,
0.463255018,
-0.3596049845,
0.5611314178,
0.4324827194,
0.0460902005,
-0.3447070718,
0.756683588,
0.4553362429,
0.4738597572,
0.1931760609,
-0.2009838223,
-0.3773847818,
-0.8521404862,
-0.6916550994,
0.3899132907,
-0.5960344076,
-0.1923226118,
-0.7746899724,
-0.1183530167,
-0.2746801674,
0.0663954541,
-0.2778903246,
-0.6088470817,
-0.1081313044,
-0.0904744044,
0.1396156251,
0.736995101,
0.1036153659,
0.640897274,
-0.7181308866,
0.2631182373,
0.2011159211,
0.2795912921,
0.2719336748,
-0.7311419845,
-0.5086362362,
0.1483383328,
-0.4367130697,
-0.6335361004,
0.4247846603,
0.1342603266,
0.6040313244,
0.2805436254,
-0.2350536585,
0.5185668468,
-0.5033832192,
0.9093856215,
0.0352290533,
-0.8437948823,
0.1708582491,
-0.1316381991,
0.3330889344,
0.5484938025,
0.5873690248,
-0.5622429848,
-0.37297225,
-0.2924709022,
-0.8474795818,
0.6782791615,
0.3678841889,
0.1867826581,
-0.1303077489,
0.3759787977,
0.1376118809,
0.4802939892,
-0.846513629,
-0.2754595876,
-0.2098984569,
0.0575935654,
-0.6476927996,
-0.3631999493,
0.1962532997,
-0.0148446867,
0.6700093746,
-0.1436283439,
0.1603705138,
-0.143318072,
-0.4612392485,
-0.2349416465,
0.34002918,
0.4739463925,
0.9131836891,
-0.053545095,
-0.1799854189,
0.2475481778,
-0.4671947658,
0.3622070849,
0.226702109,
-0.2690697312,
0.0217015017,
0.6436309218,
0.9636865854,
0.1084105,
-0.4644390941,
0.3593345582,
0.0066727605,
-0.0272988994,
0.0043844278,
-0.1341081709,
0.1714447141,
0.1240173802,
0.2044143826,
-0.2107243985,
0.0576392449,
-0.9905181527,
-0.3448830247,
0.3407118917,
0.0398904756,
-0.3284088671,
0.6030837893,
0.4537709653,
-0.0074995914,
0.7767227888,
-0.0257470664,
-0.945615828,
0.5245350003,
0.5152708888,
0.6059166789,
-0.3271446526,
0.1312709749,
0.1472375542,
0.5774330497,
-0.1792156398,
0.4083858132,
-0.0384097919,
-0.7253017426,
-0.791426003,
-0.9390953779,
-0.4414684474,
0.3999445736,
-0.4198597968,
-0.1141790152,
-0.2709327936,
-0.5299643874,
-0.112469703,
0.4071803689,
-0.7715843916,
0.3393803537,
0.1471657008,
0.892534852,
-0.8124624491,
1.0052702427,
0.8164342046,
-0.4179520011,
-0.7341523767,
-0.1632508337,
-0.2159712911,
-0.5662842393,
0.632645607,
0.2191322148,
0.165940538,
-0.3326945007,
-0.1043033451,
-0.9147658348,
0.6899536252,
0.568472445,
-0.7284587026,
0.0003831354,
0.1913299114,
0.7651314139,
-0.155097127,
0.2604383826,
0.6106284261,
0.3780085146,
0.0463763103,
-1.1309758425,
-0.2075351626,
0.0001578874,
0.1360863,
0.5609133244,
-0.9050042629,
0.8979132175,
-0.3186818063,
-0.1008084416,
0.399530828,
0.6305368543,
0.0686107725,
0.1734550893,
0.2683768272,
0.5107331872,
0.6080844998,
-0.3664456606,
1.3549523354,
-0.26353544,
0.0011581691,
0.7200633287,
-0.4715739489,
0.9521051049,
0.1651015878,
-0.2778022587,
0.4687769711,
0.7610943317,
0.4015990198,
0.3265419006,
0.2947273254,
-0.1241861805,
-0.3502735198,
0.0781208426,
-0.3024366796,
0.580853343,
0.4515683651,
-0.2830354273,
-0.0181650706,
-0.0156480465,
-0.0580619685,
-0.0096091451,
-0.603694737,
0.6222947836,
0.4919513762,
-0.5321025848,
0.7249935269,
0.2087085992,
0.6618055105,
-0.7332500815,
0.1615637243,
-0.4749651551,
0.0357778147,
-0.1622382402,
-0.4509656429,
-0.0405945182,
0.321323812,
-0.0817484856,
0.1027766094,
0.5425266623,
-0.5874715447,
-0.278812021,
0.4365046322,
0.5287309885,
0.1831136495,
-0.0215756781,
-0.3627400398,
0.1225203127,
-0.1212942824,
-0.1886350662,
0.414706856,
0.5248236656,
-0.3676090837,
0.7552581429,
0.4163835049,
0.4305126369,
-0.0029795961,
0.2656286657,
0.6823294163,
-0.642329216,
-0.5612605214,
-0.662571609,
-0.162577644,
-0.0014163059,
-0.3971295357,
0.9558878541,
0.4906833768,
0.9145941734,
0.1357591003,
0.6366558671,
0.2570541799,
0.46443066,
-0.6404905915,
0.5970235467,
-0.5852150917,
0.1511056423,
-0.3104573786,
-1.475268364,
0.0622891784,
0.5375890732,
-0.4124194384,
0.357117027,
0.4998257756,
0.3427430987,
-0.0923987255,
-0.0561323725,
0.4298859835,
0.3799310327,
0.4220200479,
0.5552729964,
0.9194666743,
-0.2774529457,
0.4702861309,
-0.2797997892,
0.0274665095,
-0.2868433297,
-0.7318776846,
-0.9945130944,
-0.2942290008,
0.026076708,
-0.2392315567,
0.2049387693,
0.8703367114,
0.6665043235,
-1.0658982992,
-0.3998923898,
0.4304593801,
-0.2395283282,
-0.0641120747,
-0.072616756,
0.3135138452,
-0.1664954722,
-0.6468756795,
0.3519142866,
0.080664672,
0.1781501472,
-0.2459162623,
-0.1269911528,
-0.2411239296,
-0.0510968603,
0.9527814388,
0.393845588,
-0.8510040641,
-0.0263552982,
-0.5043383837,
-0.2571320236,
-0.1998963207,
0.8033031821,
-0.6774535775,
0.1504520774,
0.1217985824,
0.8916784525,
0.8506386876,
-0.080375731,
0.7165943384,
-0.6049771905,
0.1743863374,
0.1857200116,
0.7216479182,
0.7599350214,
0.0737764388,
0.6616122723,
-0.0553282872,
-0.5909102559,
-0.7037158608,
0.0816909671,
-0.6541957259,
-0.1639061272,
1.1716258526,
-0.2773215771,
-0.2695482671,
0.0053683994,
-0.0598020218,
0.2457569391,
-0.2629863322,
0.8008211255,
1.035327673,
0.0913278833,
0.043230366,
-0.8806090951,
0.3998840749,
0.4477199912,
-0.778296411,
-0.0630147234,
0.5772122145,
0.3012481332,
0.1774932593,
0.3339824378,
0.0012346441,
0.3513117433,
-0.2566159368,
-0.0971753523,
-0.0426860042,
-0.3559447527,
-0.515661478,
-0.0572684668,
0.369820118,
0.1635933071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10760v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10760v1
|
Non-Parametric Memory Guidance for Multi-Document Summarization
| 2023-11-14T07:41:48 | 2023-11-14T07:41:48 |
Florian Baud, Alex Aussem
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-document summarization (MDS) is a difficult task in Natural Language
Processing, aiming to summarize information from several documents. However,
the source documents are often insufficient to obtain a qualitative summary. We
propose a retriever-guided model combined with non-parametric memory for
summary generation. This model retrieves relevant candidates from a database
and then generates the summary considering the candidates with a copy mechanism
and the source documents. The retriever is implemented with Approximate Nearest
Neighbor Search (ANN) to search large databases. Our method is evaluated on the
MultiXScience dataset which includes scientific articles. Finally, we discuss
our results and possible directions for future work.
|
[
-0.3833127022,
-0.5402120948,
0.6926928163,
-0.1589465886,
-0.3017143309,
-0.238602668,
0.0151907513,
0.0951859206,
0.7063810825,
0.6013667583,
-0.2960802913,
-0.4547956288,
-0.6872384548,
0.4267886877,
-0.7195743918,
1.1964050531,
0.0583304353,
0.0096504064,
-0.3160796762,
-0.3587967157,
-0.1102374196,
-0.28736642,
-0.5444577932,
-0.0414375067,
0.5478232503,
0.3510276675,
0.2706478536,
0.729205966,
0.5222225189,
0.3125832379,
-0.2710555494,
0.5305147171,
-0.3298535347,
0.2231340706,
-0.2827906311,
-0.6300476789,
-0.5420125127,
-0.2439789176,
0.9661673903,
0.7415643334,
-0.2480202019,
0.0742442235,
0.0390697904,
0.9622914791,
-0.4778162837,
0.0919616967,
-0.1818985641,
-0.0421291068,
-0.1955522895,
-0.5074217319,
-0.2180101424,
-0.5553434491,
0.1163842827,
-0.5041710138,
0.6953689456,
0.140706718,
0.4870305657,
-0.0070836064,
-0.6199908853,
-0.2668404281,
-0.543082118,
0.9293076396,
-0.7009983063,
0.2904515564,
0.610699594,
0.3049046099,
-0.1250662655,
-0.4164693356,
-0.1846915632,
-0.2053662539,
0.0249490924,
-0.0313323177,
0.1334605217,
-0.0329468958,
0.0787883028,
0.3513756096,
-0.6279262304,
-0.3363333941,
-0.7131745219,
-0.0337833203,
0.4197160304,
0.4622890949,
-0.0930511653,
-0.3611139953,
-0.141330719,
-0.0391440205,
-0.458551079,
-0.3808646798,
0.1052574217,
0.3151147962,
-0.104255937,
0.944167912,
-0.4378207326,
0.7721230388,
0.2276121825,
-0.2906098664,
0.051287096,
-0.9688484073,
0.1645822972,
0.1395255923,
0.74500525,
0.7135776281,
-0.2468174994,
-0.1761283129,
-0.2108311057,
-0.3924583197,
0.3089167476,
-0.9374626279,
-0.3715055287,
0.2047874928,
-0.9726816416,
-0.059812434,
-0.0175557975,
-1.3047331572,
-0.3289718926,
-0.4157217443,
0.0473506004,
-0.7438392043,
-0.1814699769,
-0.2504227757,
-0.474774152,
-0.170725137,
0.1223252639,
-0.6727891564,
0.2811371088,
0.1762193888,
1.3278934956,
0.0093842996,
-0.3357797861,
-0.4205450118,
0.6723453999,
-0.2745438218,
0.9360982776,
-0.5768404007,
-0.683693409,
-0.4467674494,
-0.3449162543,
-0.0529337563,
-0.4735305011,
0.2443885803,
-0.2790184021,
0.40083915,
-0.6828248501,
-0.5632867813,
-0.2698555589,
0.2257424146,
-0.7522646189,
0.9734538794,
0.1058742702,
-0.9186773896,
0.1818199307,
-0.7678453326,
-0.4700620472,
-0.350741744,
-0.1865910739,
-0.4945037067,
0.3784201443,
0.5937425494,
0.3339403272,
-0.3610228002,
0.5670509338,
-0.2658958435,
-0.2159599662,
0.0414685979,
-0.0832049996,
0.3525607884,
0.185716778,
-0.0245358106,
0.2822111547,
-0.9251405597,
-0.323527813,
0.097299017,
-0.3785342574,
-0.5282306671,
0.0977359638,
-0.2255068421,
0.367584914,
0.486645937,
-0.368806839,
0.0474504381,
-0.0248540677,
0.3337831795,
0.3333778381,
0.4836953282,
0.7024552822,
-0.7360067964,
0.4269581437,
0.1833318472,
0.0413899235,
-0.5873722434,
-0.3285483122,
-0.466838181,
-0.1838538945,
0.1984688193,
0.2317176461,
-0.9505528212,
0.3435852528,
-0.1727253497,
-0.4556855559,
-0.3321189582,
0.0961364731,
0.6804949045,
0.847215116,
0.7024940252,
-0.0460872538,
-0.5637010932,
-1.1441911459,
-0.1392007768,
0.0496486314,
-0.2226842344,
0.2043368667,
0.3413598239,
0.164192304,
0.8302584291,
-0.6759170294,
-0.5578721166,
-0.3132567108,
0.4422786832,
0.2393044829,
0.0721660107,
0.6506281495,
-0.7091155648,
-0.0722479895,
-0.3550028503,
-0.9798282981,
0.013902585,
-0.0276011955,
0.0923982188,
0.1389757842,
0.562430501,
-0.6292652488,
0.1828687042,
0.0460985228,
-0.0148742618,
0.4277305007,
-0.8357490301,
0.2565259635,
-1.4593434334,
0.4429678023,
0.3701914549,
0.0873913914,
-0.4208475947,
-0.0068075028,
0.3032176495,
-0.0949288383,
-0.157197386,
0.2640079558,
-0.8803962469,
0.0098458752,
-0.5475221872,
0.1357491016,
0.086162515,
0.1775435507,
0.2178936303,
0.9254786372,
0.3946529627,
-0.9499521852,
0.1098286659,
0.4206742644,
0.0270105023,
0.9002913237,
-0.4039473236,
-0.1249065623,
-0.7516780496,
0.4663751721,
-0.690628171,
-0.1329872012,
-0.1223412305,
-0.3070435822,
0.3701524734,
0.0455255806,
-0.602630794,
-0.2891768813,
-0.6944044232,
0.0488316752,
0.0491717681,
-0.3372243345,
0.6462215781,
0.3924021125,
-0.5879411697,
-0.2565884888,
-0.5146827102,
0.2775265574,
-0.3090650737,
-0.2888383567,
0.2499685138,
0.0241997931,
-0.0114476029,
0.1086167172,
-0.1742206067,
-0.1819718033,
-0.4935698211,
-0.070804283,
0.3101838231,
-0.2875789404,
-0.2796889842,
0.358715862,
-0.067615293,
0.1305199564,
-0.1000313237,
0.2983530164,
0.1541388035,
-0.0407656282,
-0.3196012378,
1.0462050438,
0.5451151133,
-0.3454212248,
0.8789536357,
0.2011684626,
-0.2737259269,
0.1569584757,
-0.4402728379,
-0.2468711734,
-0.4233313799,
0.4167906642,
-0.2675440013,
-0.2847882509,
0.5736424923,
0.0106092617,
-0.0209449604,
0.495106101,
0.3897455037,
0.0079514505,
1.0014772415,
0.4761966765,
-0.1188119426,
0.4748085737,
-0.2946816087,
0.1936205029,
-1.1185925007,
-0.6561355591,
-0.6356240511,
-0.3707438409,
-0.018165024,
-0.2461981326,
0.5382929444,
-0.0091359532,
0.2229205966,
0.4595541954,
-0.4914780557,
0.4673024416,
0.7412775159,
0.1546528339,
0.3890668154,
-0.095598422,
-0.2966634333,
0.0519290641,
-0.5844700336,
-0.4828221798,
1.2956506014,
-0.292095542,
0.7256202102,
0.2276373953,
1.00928092,
-0.0908756033,
-0.0968834534,
-0.0506151542,
0.6259376407,
-0.0222357288,
-0.505918324,
-0.1404554248,
-0.748544395,
-0.9103993177,
0.2743015587,
0.044440642,
-0.450011313,
0.2077180743,
-0.127042979,
-0.3988482058,
0.4459488094,
-0.6060799956,
0.1180879399,
-0.1080982536,
-0.0751646161,
-0.2423104197,
-0.9279567003,
0.5764685869,
-0.2458347529,
0.2108824551,
0.2547350824,
-0.2111107409,
0.8533481956,
-0.4248838425,
0.3977021575,
-0.3875934184,
0.3835695088,
0.1793086082,
0.0072017601,
0.3921088278,
0.047978092,
-0.334315747,
0.0281273387,
0.2621413469,
-0.5397809744,
-0.436293751,
0.8500746489,
-0.2743210495,
-0.3239265978,
-0.4860405922,
-0.8272485733,
0.0615975037,
0.4920322895,
0.304749012,
0.2593511045,
-0.0206735451,
0.0682851374,
0.752486825,
-0.0930231735,
0.5648507476,
0.5660814643,
-0.1376473308,
-0.5084090233,
1.0902575254,
0.3432558775,
-0.1606500745,
0.5783666372,
0.0653665438,
-0.5599589944,
-0.9796100855,
-0.432228446,
0.4109036326,
-0.3073275089,
-0.4172399938,
-0.9000543356,
-0.1132539064,
-0.3704957962,
-0.0500266328,
-0.3095394373,
-0.4416620731,
-0.6860132813,
0.0048240703,
0.3423822224,
0.8415468931,
0.0220037811,
0.1383421868,
-1.0706523657,
0.8776304722,
-0.2908510566,
0.300509721,
0.1791841835,
-0.1952280849,
-0.3029907942,
0.042187158,
-0.461140722,
-1.0857083797,
0.5504627228,
0.2774559259,
0.6917647719,
0.6167289615,
0.3038182855,
0.6416520476,
-0.353189826,
0.5835441351,
0.2096966356,
-0.359937638,
0.716414988,
-0.6786122918,
0.374612242,
0.8101828694,
0.2071297318,
-0.0888351351,
-0.4937320054,
-0.3454429805,
-0.9343733191,
0.65515095,
0.1259724945,
-0.2512182891,
-0.2814630866,
0.4730721116,
0.0884499699,
0.3032835424,
-0.0527651757,
-0.3362694085,
-0.1635906994,
-0.1614492089,
-0.1341167837,
-0.231083408,
-0.1575663239,
-0.076488249,
0.5555343628,
-0.1512068957,
0.3724754751,
0.3029704988,
-0.0689522102,
0.0562206171,
0.1699918509,
0.8358314037,
0.7236910462,
-0.5206179023,
0.0661664531,
0.0267792866,
-0.3336895406,
-0.0199108403,
0.3898755014,
-0.222961992,
0.1602212936,
0.0645664483,
0.3249467015,
0.2973810136,
-0.4184842706,
0.3820619583,
-0.3386594057,
-0.4159352183,
-0.0112139313,
-0.208641395,
0.2389646471,
0.2359271646,
0.4652085304,
0.1465357989,
0.4496762156,
-0.0753915459,
0.3717270792,
0.3383585215,
-0.0005903337,
-0.3605158627,
0.9716765285,
-0.1361130327,
-0.0099968472,
0.6310438514,
-0.1458581984,
0.0688524693,
0.4407971799,
0.6913862228,
0.6067895293,
-0.2776871324,
0.0574701801,
0.3777106702,
0.0728600249,
-0.4139015377,
0.5572091937,
-0.1259247959,
0.1672343612,
-0.3060702682,
-0.5028973222,
-0.4679068029,
-0.1191817448,
-0.9146686792,
0.2176028341,
-0.4540351629,
-0.0467985719,
0.124352023,
-0.108660534,
-0.153507784,
-0.044491943,
-0.4130897522,
0.9004411697,
-0.6620008349,
0.9280204177,
0.4561598599,
-0.645888865,
-0.2510353923,
-0.1419869065,
0.0997961313,
-0.2024576962,
0.1591523886,
-0.0927997306,
-0.0160298366,
-0.2743280232,
0.046428483,
-1.0630302429,
1.1863350868,
0.4336584508,
-0.3655334115,
-0.5746757388,
-0.2652916014,
0.5119730234,
-0.0835508779,
0.3110100925,
0.3309200704,
0.4406920671,
0.192164585,
-0.6875994205,
-0.0351637565,
-0.417118609,
0.0080712279,
0.8399450183,
-0.5881353021,
1.1147587299,
-0.3497847915,
0.0676587,
0.3081611991,
0.7029631734,
0.5768156648,
0.584066689,
-0.210810259,
0.5776988864,
0.7836681008,
0.4719156921,
1.3615089655,
-0.3243322372,
0.1381742656,
1.2388660908,
-0.1893869191,
0.6614217162,
0.5895466208,
-0.1395826638,
0.1715021133,
0.4600658715,
0.0410279594,
0.736731708,
-0.0607048497,
-0.146819517,
0.3315419853,
-0.0962134823,
-0.619890511,
0.1730844527,
0.3092597425,
-0.776994586,
-0.7801353931,
-0.1166239902,
-0.017065458,
0.0897412375,
-0.3107475638,
0.7872947454,
0.0764876306,
-0.6886548996,
0.2879890203,
0.3699892163,
0.592718482,
-0.6878774762,
-0.1230033934,
-0.2409427017,
0.1522758007,
-0.1123533621,
-0.5879693031,
0.7617815733,
-0.1356559545,
-0.6308755279,
-0.1433425248,
0.4764880538,
-0.4180891216,
-0.604671061,
0.2702379525,
0.4376149476,
0.2012298703,
-0.2302742451,
-0.4351654947,
-0.604308784,
-0.1286936849,
-0.158536911,
0.6735267639,
0.2638994753,
-0.2460141629,
0.6005218029,
0.8240444064,
0.1667026877,
0.280285567,
-0.2871945202,
0.8804291487,
-0.8699136972,
-0.7568510771,
-0.8153040409,
-0.0619754307,
-0.1451365054,
-0.1657381952,
0.9577366114,
1.21342206,
0.3053331971,
0.0801417008,
0.5741385818,
0.0941161588,
0.8807885051,
-0.4879979193,
0.8335668445,
-0.4344522059,
0.113008298,
-0.1842766106,
-1.113361001,
-0.3744851053,
0.5151741505,
-0.0949639753,
0.1234165132,
0.8200846314,
0.7068984509,
-0.223360911,
0.1577867121,
-0.0193120167,
-0.0303027593,
0.228529349,
0.5177611113,
0.3854771256,
-0.1637163907,
0.6077740192,
-0.2354017496,
-0.162549004,
-0.1353951097,
-0.8166402578,
-1.0225154161,
-0.6253397465,
-0.1013550237,
-0.2678765655,
-0.0312738493,
0.5108411908,
0.6752631664,
-0.7574806809,
-0.1122496873,
0.0000020606,
-0.0213817284,
-0.1607317179,
-0.1881263107,
0.633248806,
-0.101917319,
-0.6162782907,
0.7590426207,
0.5042359829,
-0.0785612389,
-0.1095794216,
-0.0683334917,
-0.5346650481,
0.0891011506,
0.3612389565,
0.3780656159,
-0.4781236649,
0.3721890152,
0.0069783684,
0.1600836217,
0.2163497061,
0.8805519938,
-0.700085938,
0.46427086,
0.4570613801,
0.3648884892,
0.7863944769,
0.0958007276,
0.5104641914,
-0.8687381744,
-0.0513133444,
0.1053755507,
0.4476213455,
0.2881635725,
-0.4165993631,
0.0170856044,
-0.1590223461,
-0.4822875261,
-0.6592022777,
-0.0679419711,
-0.8145002127,
-0.3762701452,
0.8706757426,
0.1983993798,
-0.2794531286,
-0.2038804889,
-0.2781714797,
0.4132372439,
-0.7380744219,
0.8950920701,
0.4669751227,
-0.4851211905,
-0.3982632756,
-0.5130875707,
-0.023032302,
0.2491028011,
-0.7998517752,
-0.0783299059,
0.6106410027,
0.3788194954,
0.2197163999,
0.6935467124,
-0.3953820169,
0.0417865701,
0.0409259796,
-0.268933028,
-0.5009458661,
-0.4961358607,
-0.5093841553,
0.4487384856,
-0.2121557295,
-0.2995969653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07961v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07961v1
|
The ART of LLM Refinement: Ask, Refine, and Trust
| 2023-11-14T07:26:32 | 2023-11-14T07:26:32 |
Kumar Shridhar, Koustuv Sinha, Andrew Cohen, Tianlu Wang, Ping Yu, Ram Pasunuru, Mrinmaya Sachan, Jason Weston, Asli Celikyilmaz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
generative abilities, but can they judge the quality of their own generations?
A popular concept, referred to as self-refinement, postulates that LLMs can
detect and correct the errors in their generations when asked to do so.
However, recent empirical evidence points in the opposite direction, suggesting
that LLMs often struggle to accurately identify errors when reasoning is
involved. To address this, we propose a reasoning with refinement objective
called ART: Ask, Refine, and Trust, which asks necessary questions to decide
when an LLM should refine its output, and either affirm or withhold trust in
its refinement by ranking the refinement and the initial prediction. On two
multistep reasoning tasks of mathematical word problems (GSM8K) and question
answering (StrategyQA), ART achieves a performance gain of +5 points over
self-refinement baselines, while using a much smaller model as the decision
maker. We also demonstrate the benefit of using smaller models to make
refinement decisions as a cost-effective alternative to fine-tuning a larger
model.
|
[
-0.3176951706,
-0.7674668431,
0.9742686749,
-0.137398392,
-0.1352455616,
0.1108491048,
-0.0943249539,
-0.6050249934,
-0.1360604614,
0.5033330917,
-0.8075922728,
-0.2499480844,
-0.6042361259,
0.2458998561,
-0.0975172594,
0.4867592156,
-0.4074533284,
0.154233411,
-0.5085536838,
-0.1974302381,
-0.4656791389,
-0.0925512537,
-1.0089730024,
-0.6851459146,
0.4519968033,
0.5322794318,
0.7895176411,
0.7809149623,
0.3475637436,
0.3978551626,
0.1480053812,
0.5565958619,
-0.5776849985,
0.3735984266,
-0.3073192835,
-0.7959897518,
-0.197916314,
0.2995834649,
0.1691603363,
0.4221431315,
0.0552557185,
0.4497021139,
-0.0372228362,
0.8667820096,
-0.3767232001,
0.1942668408,
-0.7389494777,
-0.1177236214,
-0.0864887014,
-0.3613553047,
-0.3270102739,
-0.5906108618,
0.0951406434,
-0.5668050051,
0.0980023444,
0.1526039988,
0.9741745591,
0.6437546015,
0.1069140807,
-0.2503594756,
-0.4754855037,
0.9158689976,
-0.662204504,
0.3118386865,
0.3003605306,
0.1296287775,
-0.1493931264,
-0.7848683596,
-0.4172718823,
-0.2625381052,
-0.0158717223,
-0.029325923,
-0.14473629,
-0.053829737,
0.3702510595,
0.3521255255,
-0.3003834784,
-0.0493030362,
-0.3296838105,
-0.3746116161,
0.7437136173,
-0.1081161425,
0.1464437544,
0.1070835367,
-0.2705217898,
0.2115042806,
-1.0613329411,
-0.0184828117,
0.3946556449,
-0.0356363542,
0.4230528176,
0.5686706901,
-0.3088479936,
0.5089268088,
0.2037920952,
-0.1009829491,
-0.2221681178,
-0.2469202727,
-0.1128830463,
-0.1890726388,
0.5689547062,
0.4112925529,
0.6529604197,
0.0201051049,
-0.2166096121,
0.0071561001,
0.3555848002,
-0.552210331,
-0.223617509,
0.2242190093,
-0.3757118285,
-0.1329884976,
-0.1556333601,
-0.350761205,
-0.2136557996,
-0.832244277,
0.6157224178,
-0.4064219892,
0.0406455994,
0.1819177866,
0.1207468882,
-0.0063813264,
0.7682053447,
-0.553542316,
-0.0634806231,
0.6358532906,
0.505782187,
0.0405677818,
-0.3749759495,
-0.3761290908,
-0.0341988243,
-0.82106179,
0.9076942801,
-0.4494329691,
-0.4523673058,
-0.1553602666,
-0.1823903769,
0.0391468182,
-0.6099302173,
0.5622131228,
-0.5718368292,
0.2671951652,
-0.4866952002,
-0.6811589003,
-0.2839256823,
0.2318339646,
-0.5211206079,
0.9776381254,
0.0686953813,
-0.3534778953,
0.4003927112,
-0.5707057714,
-0.0239395611,
0.1379867196,
-0.2678355873,
-0.420756489,
0.3741262853,
0.1928768456,
0.3476955593,
-0.3634416163,
-0.0702619702,
-0.6038975716,
-0.3250856698,
0.3119439483,
-0.2102414221,
0.2265218347,
0.396484375,
-0.2701746821,
0.1282044351,
-0.594617188,
0.6116527319,
0.093919374,
-0.186901316,
-0.2179497182,
-0.0772510916,
-0.8021928072,
0.106064938,
0.6659476757,
-0.5008053184,
0.2174819112,
-0.3602891564,
0.5181750655,
0.9938678741,
-0.226238206,
0.3770591617,
-0.5890203714,
0.4865264595,
-0.1581804156,
0.2304487079,
-0.0912930518,
-0.6216515899,
-1.1615985632,
0.2050605416,
0.2997718751,
0.1141210198,
-0.7857410312,
0.006316931,
-0.0882364288,
-0.3984774649,
-1.06377244,
0.4974163771,
0.3540562093,
0.4787544012,
0.4042557776,
-0.2257433087,
-0.3265581131,
-1.012319684,
-0.341483444,
-0.3140822351,
0.2820180953,
0.2026197016,
0.2718931139,
0.0072139227,
0.8774390817,
-0.6006931663,
-0.1091161594,
-0.0809131116,
0.3789534867,
-0.2561710179,
0.2922057509,
0.2059123665,
-0.2637912035,
-0.3620759845,
-0.1954366416,
-0.623788476,
-0.3375524879,
0.0770816281,
-0.2237790972,
0.1797476709,
0.7882598042,
-0.5165240169,
0.4103949964,
0.4926418364,
-0.2459795922,
0.5704311132,
-0.3765207827,
0.1758063883,
-0.7125513554,
-0.2498239875,
-0.1358408332,
-0.2011092454,
-0.3661536276,
0.3011251986,
-0.1264745146,
0.1393377036,
0.0490439571,
0.6177530885,
-0.5628477335,
0.1625595689,
-0.5365521312,
0.1749318093,
0.3191662133,
0.1516323388,
-0.0231168866,
0.9322249889,
0.4178766012,
-0.4191950262,
0.3264034688,
-0.0887883231,
-0.506254673,
0.864764452,
-0.7327340245,
0.4397487044,
-0.2599056065,
-0.1546565592,
-1.1846159697,
0.1670026332,
0.0513111129,
-0.6092818975,
0.2445731014,
-0.2000689358,
-0.2612163424,
-0.3681255281,
-0.0458416902,
0.2028657347,
0.3526659608,
-0.4756841958,
0.7164177299,
0.035162136,
-0.2065417767,
-0.6052379012,
-0.6850836277,
-0.1509795189,
-0.0360406376,
-1.0013307333,
0.0519782193,
-0.3994401991,
-0.4643623531,
0.1470006853,
-0.2136718929,
-0.0137575893,
0.119262889,
0.2962203324,
0.1243835688,
-0.1800578088,
0.281445384,
-0.0758662224,
-0.3747711182,
0.2112460285,
-0.1507402509,
0.3506480455,
-0.1720280647,
-0.701862514,
-0.3308916688,
0.1743745357,
0.7532067299,
-0.3611393869,
0.2823720872,
0.4047662616,
-0.2091739774,
-0.6214137673,
-0.9924867749,
-0.2632446289,
-0.4985705316,
-0.0461464897,
-0.6375593543,
-0.9919980764,
0.3498732746,
-0.2733047605,
0.0980609059,
0.5141088367,
0.4438439608,
-0.2910664082,
1.0071154833,
0.5267107487,
0.1148975417,
0.0389770009,
-0.2824594975,
0.2174109071,
-0.8307785988,
-0.1957711279,
-0.5126913786,
-0.4759926498,
-0.225961566,
-0.5811434388,
0.1219295412,
0.0025834551,
-0.105573073,
0.131497249,
-0.5353122354,
0.5064892769,
0.7072312236,
0.0595210493,
0.5303415656,
-0.1043741629,
-0.2763667107,
-0.2401572466,
-0.4176356792,
-0.8442492485,
1.0262583494,
0.4132617116,
0.964261353,
-0.0071872738,
0.8599132895,
-0.0341469124,
0.5536060929,
-0.769091785,
0.5917063951,
0.1624922454,
-0.5909403563,
-0.3770959079,
-0.4661872983,
-0.874977231,
0.1859411448,
0.063717097,
-0.3935769796,
0.2269704342,
0.2897492349,
-0.4161524475,
0.3234705925,
-0.6461049914,
0.6752331257,
-0.1739901155,
-0.4039369226,
-0.4997554719,
-0.2626978159,
0.4845616221,
-0.0317650922,
0.2342355102,
-0.46072945,
0.016800873,
0.3651048839,
-0.3529764712,
0.4938585758,
0.1594141424,
-0.128120482,
0.5763185024,
0.592425406,
0.5036382675,
-0.0387194864,
-0.1654480845,
-0.1719897091,
0.1552536339,
-0.000550357,
-0.8581131101,
0.8429546356,
-0.6682415009,
-0.9805964231,
-0.1972585917,
-0.3942232132,
-0.3601407111,
0.1677658409,
0.1976840794,
0.259423703,
-0.0286584925,
0.1372913271,
0.7755351663,
0.1975388825,
0.2317059189,
0.4894829988,
-0.1013613269,
-0.2786142826,
0.626980722,
0.2228893042,
0.521240294,
0.1135298014,
0.4242548347,
-0.5461770892,
-0.5951229334,
-0.4539277852,
0.4403580129,
-0.9149406552,
-0.2668585777,
-0.0583910719,
-0.1826150417,
-0.0024574653,
-0.0141050927,
-0.5909374356,
-0.2810080051,
-0.4672085047,
-0.2029826194,
0.3315271735,
0.6934601665,
-0.0762974024,
-0.0720305964,
-0.5024939179,
0.2100929618,
0.6980547905,
0.5440922976,
0.0084928656,
-0.6781976223,
0.0995703638,
0.1198103353,
-0.5156193972,
-0.5193689466,
0.1035718545,
0.0693893284,
0.486859858,
0.3815591335,
-0.0680086762,
0.8933290839,
-0.6372928023,
0.5862640738,
0.0537228361,
-0.8658715487,
0.5233686566,
-0.0029814758,
0.2810934484,
0.7553431988,
0.3498230577,
-0.4102325737,
-0.3475010693,
-0.857866466,
-0.3087781668,
0.317391783,
-0.0514175408,
0.0901445746,
0.0680103526,
0.6862808466,
-0.052159626,
0.2541233897,
-0.6650724411,
-0.2108023316,
-0.111115396,
-0.158743754,
0.0514316484,
-0.43300879,
-0.5458059311,
-0.2372129709,
0.651673913,
-0.3446594775,
0.0874473825,
0.393576771,
0.2046592385,
-0.6485962868,
0.3730415702,
0.6405887604,
1.0328769684,
0.2638581693,
0.2565073073,
0.1000529975,
0.0073765623,
0.2278349102,
-0.0465536639,
-0.2720149755,
-0.0382511504,
0.2176950127,
0.5275536776,
-0.0174798928,
-0.5950221419,
0.3294236064,
0.0940187797,
-0.3552454412,
-0.14107728,
0.0939694196,
0.2258439958,
0.3851015568,
0.0436685681,
0.0447593182,
0.058261048,
-0.6176518202,
0.2602042854,
0.5911956429,
-0.4652678967,
-0.0340638012,
0.5886470675,
-0.0087357704,
-0.1558234692,
0.4639886022,
-0.198356688,
-0.4006024599,
0.3184708655,
0.1348065585,
0.8610488176,
-0.2593454719,
0.2399269342,
0.308501631,
0.3874150515,
-0.3891498148,
0.5787703395,
0.3486854136,
-1.0008687973,
-0.7258675694,
-0.4866506159,
-0.5336803794,
0.197622627,
-0.3393048048,
0.0929904208,
-0.6279289722,
-0.3288339972,
-0.2990060151,
0.0565857589,
-0.5137313604,
0.4404080808,
-0.0182116088,
0.7297039032,
-0.3534198105,
0.4680446386,
0.5195595622,
-0.3141234815,
-1.084217906,
-0.3677172065,
0.0522775538,
-1.2551802397,
0.8738194108,
-0.0761842579,
-0.4225589931,
0.014580912,
-0.7994375229,
-1.0581796169,
1.0853587389,
0.3646360636,
-0.6516699791,
0.1491031349,
-0.0675137118,
0.6082942486,
-0.2646831572,
0.2342167199,
0.4543739557,
0.5644443631,
0.4707702696,
-0.8493446112,
0.0067969714,
-0.0046141795,
-0.0506324284,
0.1790763736,
-0.8683755398,
0.7331829071,
-0.4389545023,
-0.324449271,
0.2938810587,
0.7322766781,
0.3983655274,
0.1566276103,
0.4031045139,
1.0004179478,
0.7868465781,
-0.6416959167,
0.903645277,
-0.3592845798,
0.1591799557,
1.1134605408,
-0.0258797407,
0.7343654633,
0.3756872416,
-0.1502986252,
0.6697655916,
0.6271356344,
-0.1000821888,
0.2832568884,
0.4737102389,
-0.2471742183,
-0.5324362516,
0.0440295376,
-0.3422757685,
0.3145155907,
0.3553811014,
-0.4088262022,
-0.1278179139,
-0.5195179582,
0.1824788451,
0.338873893,
-0.4101093709,
0.5467296839,
0.315962255,
-1.0364258289,
0.3469002545,
0.07311593,
0.3312821984,
-0.5523356199,
0.0890699998,
-0.2005218565,
0.2120699435,
-0.1421372592,
-0.8279343247,
0.2447875291,
-0.4643163383,
0.0047171414,
-0.2826690674,
0.6393178701,
-0.5622780323,
-0.3991791308,
0.1181985959,
0.7397642732,
0.0074727722,
-0.1562774181,
-1.092381835,
0.2647618949,
-0.1172071397,
-0.0048781787,
0.0066427826,
0.6781741977,
0.1786825806,
1.2798272371,
0.6108529568,
0.3727108538,
-0.0461555496,
0.3007232547,
0.4810110033,
-0.3112389147,
0.0086379368,
-0.7881215811,
0.3676056564,
-0.0512474142,
-0.3617009223,
0.7845807076,
0.271807909,
0.9801038504,
-0.0540494472,
0.7148394585,
0.4321362674,
0.6475522518,
-0.6808263659,
0.3782919347,
-0.6415701509,
0.2065252215,
-0.0726769567,
-0.6268163919,
-0.0262988862,
0.9595729709,
-0.6006605029,
0.321433723,
0.787642777,
0.8513285518,
0.3561145961,
0.1170236766,
0.3790581226,
0.072792232,
0.3033566773,
0.5170894861,
1.081179142,
-0.3328857422,
0.3960485458,
-0.3803141117,
-0.0338134617,
0.0095925136,
-0.9780534506,
-0.7095279694,
-0.3729170263,
-0.6708510518,
-0.3476463854,
-0.1673081368,
0.8448328376,
0.6279723048,
-0.6046593785,
-0.2566236556,
0.0777072832,
0.2699274421,
-0.1882141978,
-0.1825470477,
0.1928443611,
-0.6985428333,
-0.7850530744,
0.3618273437,
0.4057662487,
0.0949133113,
-0.5585634708,
0.000108746,
0.0907438919,
0.3907446861,
0.4573828578,
0.2270094305,
-1.0966464281,
-0.5344558954,
0.0337472707,
-0.0130055891,
0.1198385507,
0.8409647942,
-0.2852208614,
0.928049624,
0.2979650795,
0.5699747801,
0.2392476797,
0.2266419679,
0.6671289206,
-0.3449449241,
-0.5630694032,
0.0860957578,
0.6381947994,
0.3586345911,
-0.3083322346,
0.5238555074,
0.2575001419,
-0.8090596795,
-0.347253412,
0.4938957095,
-0.572619915,
-0.3529703319,
0.9134497643,
-0.0792208314,
-0.0268008467,
-0.1653633863,
-0.4601160884,
-0.113532275,
-0.1932739913,
0.8740187883,
1.2472792864,
-0.284257561,
-0.6056472063,
-0.4215709269,
0.8130124807,
0.5215345025,
-0.7062065601,
0.0616608188,
0.5946224332,
0.5486816168,
0.4521975815,
0.5357548594,
-0.3223641217,
0.236065641,
-0.35002321,
-0.0823798999,
-0.1796992868,
-0.4036791325,
-0.0254143942,
0.3328046501,
0.6763147712,
0.1192804575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07954v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07954v2
|
A Closer Look at the Self-Verification Abilities of Large Language Models in Logical Reasoning
| 2023-11-14T07:13:10 | 2024-03-23T13:54:44 |
Ruixin Hong, Hongming Zhang, Xinyu Pang, Dong Yu, Changshui Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Logical reasoning has been an ongoing pursuit in the field of AI. Despite
significant advancements made by large language models (LLMs), they still
struggle with complex logical reasoning problems. To enhance reasoning
performance, one promising direction is scalable oversight, which requires LLMs
to identify their own errors and then improve by themselves. Various
self-verification methods have been proposed in pursuit of this goal.
Nevertheless, whether existing models understand their own errors well is still
under investigation. In this paper, we take a closer look at the
self-verification abilities of LLMs in the context of logical reasoning,
focusing on their ability to identify logical fallacies accurately. We
introduce a dataset, FALLACIES, containing 232 types of reasoning fallacies
categorized in a hierarchical taxonomy. By conducting exhaustive experiments on
FALLACIES, we obtain comprehensive and detailed analyses of a series of models
on their verification abilities. Our main findings suggest that existing LLMs
could struggle to identify fallacious reasoning steps accurately and may fall
short of guaranteeing the validity of self-verification methods. Drawing from
these observations, we offer suggestions for future research and practical
applications of self-verification methods.
|
[
-0.0666784644,
-0.761456728,
0.9316083789,
-0.10883414,
0.2694194615,
0.1166706756,
-0.0752229914,
-0.3065971434,
-0.2711357176,
0.65995574,
-0.6430063844,
-0.2551830113,
-0.6348780394,
0.4110794365,
-0.621188581,
0.6624244452,
-0.0999390408,
-0.1345445067,
-0.4650971889,
-0.201566875,
-0.6369365454,
-0.5921939611,
-0.1982013434,
-0.580943346,
0.2130614966,
0.2148877233,
0.5177194476,
0.5750856996,
0.6038009524,
0.4592276514,
-0.135122627,
0.5818266869,
-0.3465884924,
-0.0587336794,
-0.2819493115,
-0.6766833067,
-0.2293176353,
0.0251141489,
0.6885903478,
0.3924608231,
-0.1540066749,
0.2465596497,
-0.2246471941,
0.6452738047,
-0.5852730274,
0.1130628288,
-0.6636508703,
0.008003667,
-0.1068691313,
0.1321915239,
-0.5872335434,
-0.293151468,
-0.1650308222,
-0.1465417594,
0.117264457,
0.0144659895,
0.5343023539,
0.8411024809,
-0.5739350319,
-0.3961541653,
-0.7851466537,
0.9298702478,
-1.0411653519,
0.4331949353,
0.1269647628,
0.4162758887,
-0.3979144692,
-0.3692907989,
-0.497947365,
-0.5463100076,
-0.2900180221,
-0.1933025718,
-0.1587097943,
-0.0878459886,
0.7108507752,
0.3547381759,
-0.4087097049,
0.1196229458,
-0.1926071942,
-0.4021296203,
0.6026363969,
0.2048800141,
0.4484573007,
-0.1827897877,
-0.1229115874,
0.1932135373,
-0.8040205836,
0.0230916981,
0.1644563228,
-0.0433491692,
0.0590815321,
0.5110390782,
-0.163554728,
0.8720700145,
-0.0399175547,
-0.4766885936,
-0.0282908045,
-0.4845418036,
-0.2495702356,
-0.2002425343,
0.4681049883,
0.0232599154,
0.387917757,
0.0385259166,
-0.446590811,
0.1587905288,
0.2181305736,
-0.257886827,
-0.2337253541,
0.3061775267,
-0.5131468773,
-0.2598426044,
-0.2425340414,
-0.1850021631,
-0.5196685791,
-0.3893625736,
0.5301918983,
-0.3690301776,
-0.2528648376,
0.2702575922,
0.067346096,
0.0304821283,
0.6068512201,
-0.559240818,
0.0177545007,
0.8741611838,
0.4845847785,
-0.1180949509,
-0.6371958852,
-0.4147339761,
-0.0434602797,
-0.6317373514,
0.7906548381,
-0.3918085098,
0.220276162,
-0.1115486547,
-0.1550438106,
-0.1767863333,
-0.5838830471,
0.6128122211,
-0.5380426645,
-0.0911475644,
-0.414182961,
-0.7136923671,
-0.2587729394,
0.6470149159,
-0.494102031,
0.7951157689,
-0.0745901838,
-0.9034571648,
0.1931700259,
-0.4615966678,
-0.4259489179,
-0.099338457,
-0.4810733497,
-0.3055384755,
0.2476779372,
0.3337626457,
0.4488278925,
-0.4412846863,
0.1546655893,
-0.4382867515,
-0.1378642768,
0.5513272882,
-0.4695628285,
0.9618434906,
0.0041141557,
-0.3871998787,
-0.0837178528,
-0.8155844212,
0.0726478025,
0.2260989696,
-0.2028664052,
-0.2576847076,
0.2325300723,
-0.7522319555,
0.1866989881,
0.3076158166,
-0.4388070107,
0.2350171059,
-0.3352073133,
0.6676028967,
0.889813602,
-0.2821165323,
-0.0247113612,
-0.2053915411,
0.4292576015,
0.2467631847,
-0.0111325914,
-0.302921176,
-0.1622060239,
-0.8479892612,
-0.2518932521,
0.4110296369,
0.5385807753,
-0.4757567346,
0.5543150306,
-0.0909578875,
-0.4932320714,
-0.1738091558,
0.2971248031,
0.4041540623,
0.8698861599,
0.2645392418,
0.1905281246,
-0.2035728246,
-0.8877446055,
-0.4191008508,
-0.5618780851,
0.1200762466,
0.2016833574,
0.8616916537,
-0.5794302225,
1.013458848,
-0.3097493649,
-0.0133186225,
-0.2177484035,
-0.0017338938,
0.3310899138,
0.2975863218,
0.4656543136,
-0.4705550373,
0.110987708,
-0.1381020099,
-1.0288823843,
-0.2639061511,
-0.2115326226,
0.2182743549,
0.2719490826,
0.4999986887,
-0.6590494514,
0.286467433,
0.5535344481,
-0.3101533055,
0.8242910504,
-0.328787744,
0.1777174622,
-0.467148751,
-0.3337834179,
0.0637359396,
-0.319080323,
-0.3469179869,
0.1482916623,
0.1589536071,
0.4109490514,
-0.0164472926,
0.3485961854,
-0.627541244,
-0.1036090478,
-0.2313024849,
0.0663544536,
-0.1153848767,
0.0641215816,
-0.0650419965,
0.6311131716,
0.6897985935,
-0.6091764569,
0.6017196774,
-0.0391655639,
-0.4510591924,
0.6515841484,
-0.6133056879,
0.0298497751,
-0.2454976887,
0.475011915,
-1.114335537,
-0.2589056492,
0.05304721,
-0.3555774689,
0.0171798449,
-0.339560926,
-0.6476015449,
-0.5705023408,
0.1651426852,
0.3873627186,
0.4592016935,
-0.9269561172,
0.859583199,
0.2840406299,
0.255815655,
-0.8585948944,
-0.7165646553,
-0.1161466092,
-0.3143412471,
-0.7414904833,
-0.2996617854,
-0.0947227329,
-0.6101713181,
-0.3966449797,
-0.2185591608,
-0.0281796772,
0.2248969972,
0.0596702732,
0.1960066706,
-0.2614789605,
0.2791138589,
-0.2763873339,
0.0215769783,
0.4030512571,
-0.2891609073,
0.0764183924,
-0.4875259697,
-0.8941577077,
-0.4283916354,
-0.0971971974,
0.7118530273,
-0.2547502816,
0.4227950871,
0.1073114648,
-0.54059273,
-0.4385989308,
-1.0552874804,
-0.3024747372,
-0.4460577667,
0.2201886624,
-0.5254759192,
-0.708332777,
0.6235876679,
0.0010921753,
0.0699848309,
0.7505217195,
0.6102386117,
-0.2168682218,
1.0487296581,
0.3361531496,
-0.1200518608,
-0.2041483819,
-0.0932880789,
0.2370582521,
-0.5059558153,
-0.2795675397,
-0.6214472055,
0.0247146431,
-0.5732397437,
-0.6633998156,
0.0796521232,
-0.2565592825,
-0.3494749963,
0.2063255161,
-0.2810303271,
0.6032545567,
0.3624768555,
-0.0404716842,
0.529948175,
-0.2026725858,
-0.0118607879,
-0.1471080631,
-0.6888800859,
-0.564442277,
0.7477010489,
0.7492642999,
1.0472437143,
0.0904734358,
0.628998816,
0.5449128747,
0.1641473025,
-0.6039651632,
0.5807010531,
-0.0159074962,
-0.9107199311,
-0.4039757848,
-0.7803227901,
-0.4745029509,
0.1755636781,
0.0957859755,
-0.6493409872,
0.0448272675,
0.5307604671,
-0.1955711544,
0.4118903279,
-0.5785093904,
0.9180503488,
-0.6216017008,
0.01182561,
-0.3361365497,
-0.5458928943,
0.5793919563,
-0.2222483158,
0.332313627,
-0.2609171569,
0.2061468214,
0.4147099853,
-0.5654049516,
0.8799474239,
0.0092071733,
-0.5920931697,
0.3534764051,
0.4037579894,
0.6486260891,
-0.0423530862,
0.0200466476,
0.3458515406,
0.2485594302,
-0.2621311247,
-0.7181202173,
0.5599521399,
-0.628716886,
-0.7812675238,
-0.5644339919,
-0.1470492929,
-0.3172580004,
0.341922909,
0.0130396262,
0.4680239558,
-0.0382114761,
0.0423838422,
0.7943426371,
0.0742565244,
0.1311917156,
0.4885755181,
-0.0959727019,
-0.1225767732,
0.6709310412,
0.263550967,
0.2241347134,
0.2421656847,
0.3687314987,
-0.4128140211,
-0.6846885085,
-0.6114130616,
0.5105552077,
-1.0672079325,
-0.1565512866,
-0.372445941,
-0.1998420656,
-0.4270804822,
0.1617987901,
-0.5924001932,
-0.3632561564,
-0.068711862,
0.0704216883,
0.0476028547,
0.9769091606,
-0.1757817119,
-0.0778695717,
-0.7141439319,
0.4171500802,
0.5384700894,
0.1718315035,
0.0523615852,
-0.8140466213,
0.1822994798,
0.0657266974,
0.13650769,
-0.7931361198,
-0.0347129889,
-0.141565159,
0.7387878895,
0.4410264194,
-0.0145180002,
0.5676271319,
-0.610765934,
0.5458489656,
0.0529496223,
-0.9877961874,
0.704140842,
-0.2597307265,
0.1509238929,
0.3324068785,
0.1168844998,
-0.3595965803,
-0.365834713,
-0.5560951233,
-0.1988122016,
0.5406399369,
0.2474184483,
-0.1042850539,
0.1188226119,
0.5054971576,
-0.0450108349,
-0.1184367016,
-0.9211416245,
-0.1790944785,
0.0078769,
-0.0754446015,
-0.019897202,
-0.3495896161,
-0.2908018231,
0.053031411,
0.6679161191,
-0.3266849816,
-0.1765052378,
0.2054992169,
-0.1137637272,
-0.0525581725,
0.2222336978,
0.5609327555,
1.065747261,
0.0865248069,
0.3294782043,
0.4177730381,
0.1585748643,
0.3584991992,
-0.1321417689,
-0.2179243565,
-0.182519421,
0.7695599794,
0.2722082734,
-0.2451006025,
-0.8063235879,
0.6089027524,
-0.0644534156,
0.1034298018,
-0.5803911686,
0.1012279615,
0.0293289181,
0.3110907674,
0.1517155021,
0.0849673599,
0.18987073,
-0.6127588749,
0.0324119925,
0.5022530556,
0.0029166276,
-0.0925212055,
0.4393462539,
0.1155112386,
-0.2395482957,
0.778664887,
0.0799854994,
-0.6215747595,
0.7584591508,
0.477568239,
0.5894770026,
-0.1350140274,
0.1146194488,
0.2795894444,
0.7833801508,
-0.417334795,
-0.1222158819,
-0.0162370242,
-0.9425110221,
-0.6606048942,
-0.4174314737,
-0.6070697904,
0.0445595086,
-0.1463034898,
0.1331179142,
-0.4191059172,
0.0765970796,
-0.0138981119,
-0.2395570874,
-0.3393237889,
0.5006899834,
0.4036121368,
0.9218844175,
-0.8877299428,
0.3717808425,
0.5659349561,
-0.2279185653,
-0.8392196894,
0.2272496074,
0.2000428289,
-0.8324623108,
0.7626557946,
0.2925262451,
-0.666408658,
-0.4488626122,
-0.5519376993,
-0.964997828,
0.6465538144,
0.5457052588,
-0.5526641607,
-0.1063301787,
0.0636411905,
0.6833863258,
-0.4396569729,
0.4151143432,
0.7598865032,
0.4025134444,
0.2063812166,
-0.7903050184,
0.1747227758,
0.2183790952,
-0.1732323021,
-0.0481635407,
-0.8228048086,
0.6172848344,
-0.4077042043,
0.1347092688,
-0.1534328163,
0.8560867906,
0.4661152363,
0.1266439259,
0.7454737425,
0.6158751249,
0.9289653301,
-0.0364595763,
0.8953579664,
-0.1076542288,
0.400007993,
1.0608484745,
-0.3266179264,
0.590223074,
0.0206215978,
-0.2349782884,
0.6492347717,
0.7056260705,
-0.1796534359,
-0.0829980001,
0.2060018778,
0.1654282063,
-0.9394173026,
0.2980470955,
-0.2076243013,
0.5258718729,
0.3806701303,
-0.3235934675,
0.0029642533,
-0.29662323,
-0.0208792202,
0.1062831581,
-0.3357864618,
0.4526392519,
-0.0892264545,
-0.9948141575,
0.6270929575,
0.0341232233,
0.3050807714,
-0.2651390731,
-0.0705365911,
-0.1891132891,
0.4770802259,
-0.296136111,
-0.7619470358,
0.0671041533,
-0.0660538226,
0.073227793,
-0.0786805227,
0.9241205454,
0.0572669581,
-0.6038036346,
0.2259265184,
0.5110871792,
0.2734869719,
0.0525587127,
-0.8382097483,
0.0580763891,
0.0807975456,
0.0702519119,
-0.3050538301,
0.5227047205,
0.0332765318,
1.106570363,
0.374019295,
0.1477691084,
0.0800460428,
0.0946105793,
0.5678645372,
-0.6250097156,
-0.2729998827,
-1.1760495901,
0.2288766652,
-0.1037973687,
-0.0985965207,
0.8636701703,
0.3769037127,
0.9009453058,
-0.1218326986,
0.8852740526,
0.0604257174,
0.7818488479,
-0.6242242455,
0.3163498938,
-0.7531453967,
0.3908688128,
-0.1633778065,
-0.5470975041,
-0.2018689662,
0.767729044,
-0.55181849,
0.2855641544,
0.6353814602,
0.7343258262,
-0.1067875028,
-0.0650643706,
0.4441427886,
0.6721302271,
0.2387173325,
0.4313431084,
1.2405349016,
-0.2034182847,
0.4659227133,
-0.0935715139,
-0.2838953435,
-0.2876834869,
-0.9497049451,
-1.2628010511,
-0.16286847,
-0.6148072481,
-0.5292118788,
0.0573841967,
0.7310170531,
0.704233408,
-0.7989283204,
0.0055110953,
-0.1604381651,
0.6029440761,
-0.1571026295,
-0.0688613355,
0.1329859793,
-0.2976011038,
-0.4982502162,
0.5795217156,
0.3182450831,
-0.0315824524,
-0.7249381542,
0.0503159873,
0.0196067523,
0.4349158406,
0.3502751291,
0.3664081991,
-1.1127178669,
-0.3780343235,
-0.2674663961,
-0.06224842,
0.1633629799,
0.8113642931,
-0.5266466141,
0.3811496794,
0.72176373,
0.7428976297,
0.0462053753,
0.1657502353,
0.4034624696,
-0.1680226475,
-0.4235753119,
0.2119661719,
0.584995389,
0.3592375219,
-0.3577711582,
0.5286381245,
0.3862420917,
-0.8609675169,
-0.8752877712,
0.5534762144,
-0.5885270238,
-0.1474984139,
1.0609271526,
-0.3713713586,
-0.3300154209,
0.0437540077,
0.0213355627,
-0.2673836946,
0.1285977662,
0.9822820425,
1.0208933353,
-0.3805662692,
-0.150640592,
-0.4117024541,
0.419220686,
0.633889854,
-0.953083992,
0.4402863383,
0.8898938298,
0.5564249158,
0.313873291,
0.4951060414,
0.0123942932,
0.4381232858,
-0.1218875498,
-0.4208593965,
0.2975641787,
-0.4915603995,
-0.3880648017,
0.0638831779,
0.2811643183,
0.1611476094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07945v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07945v3
|
First-Step Advantage: Importance of Starting Right in Multi-Step Math Reasoning
| 2023-11-14T06:45:31 | 2024-07-01T13:25:57 |
Kushal Jain, Moritz Miller, Niket Tandon, Kumar Shridhar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models can solve complex reasoning tasks better by learning to
generate rationales for their predictions. Often these models know how to solve
a task but their auto-regressive decoding nature leads to incorrect results if
they start incorrectly. We observe that smaller models in particular when
corrected, can solve a task that they would have otherwise struggled with. We
demonstrate this phenomenon by using a larger model to guide smaller models,
which leads to significantly improved performance (up to +24 points on the
GSM8K dataset by 7B models). To assist smaller models in initiating the
starting step, we propose QuestCoT, where a smaller model first asks itself how
to start, before proceeding with a chain of reasoning. On various multistep
mathematical reasoning datasets over multiple smaller models, we show that
getting the right start can lead to significant performance gains across all
models (gains of up to +6 points on GSM8K, +9 on SVAMP, +5 on ASDiv, and +7 on
MultiArith).
|
[
-0.3206736147,
-0.2850342095,
0.5883260965,
0.1598017961,
-0.185501188,
0.0199316218,
0.2085306346,
-0.225241214,
-0.3497292995,
0.5332878828,
-0.7422348857,
-0.1087080464,
-0.8973072767,
0.0699130073,
-0.2711759508,
0.8489809036,
0.2105645686,
0.2451383919,
-0.2856460214,
0.1274080127,
-0.5347827077,
-0.4517230093,
-1.1561872959,
-0.4304889441,
0.6306734085,
0.6254321933,
0.8495277166,
0.8159133792,
0.4704165161,
0.2760833502,
0.1554905623,
0.4059366584,
-0.3567957282,
0.3140012622,
0.0275533479,
-0.9146237969,
-0.3044333756,
0.1570530981,
0.1995480806,
0.7897475958,
-0.3271909952,
0.1863893121,
-0.0416699126,
0.8988214135,
-0.1834332347,
0.3635354936,
-0.4285350144,
-0.062158227,
-0.1425649226,
-0.2314534336,
-0.6414459348,
-0.3442077935,
0.1480362415,
-0.7652876973,
0.1822811514,
0.1958345324,
0.6637947559,
0.3972186148,
-0.3825947642,
-0.3420522213,
-0.7110258937,
0.9433395863,
-0.7421523929,
0.6691291332,
0.4459447861,
0.4468967021,
-0.1972949952,
-0.5308887362,
-0.2663331628,
0.0653251186,
-0.115680106,
-0.1532923877,
-0.0870908722,
-0.0668515414,
0.9458514452,
-0.0018019571,
-0.3651742935,
-0.2551109493,
-0.4838228524,
-0.3107205629,
0.3563604951,
0.300673306,
0.2871172428,
-0.3143012226,
0.0804519728,
-0.3390758932,
-0.8409253955,
0.1878038645,
0.2254555523,
0.8516545892,
0.2021670043,
0.6357759237,
-0.0160064641,
0.5905427933,
0.296389401,
-0.4098962545,
-0.0844498873,
-0.5581364036,
-0.3840758801,
0.0162349995,
0.2373036742,
-0.1622904539,
0.4219549298,
0.1992847621,
-0.224038586,
-0.1035336405,
0.2659831047,
-0.9090104103,
-0.3355736136,
0.205724299,
-0.354872793,
-0.018492993,
-0.1058727875,
-0.4258233905,
-0.235531956,
-0.9080221653,
0.4716126621,
-0.5570729971,
-0.133958295,
0.3297114968,
0.2009286135,
0.2847952247,
0.7660277486,
-0.8130353093,
0.4947232008,
0.9422417283,
0.8594891429,
0.3194742203,
-0.2509431243,
-0.8907228112,
-0.3007644117,
-0.8077930808,
0.5943415761,
-0.3006639481,
-0.359000057,
-0.3202094436,
0.0192898605,
-0.315035373,
-0.409642905,
0.6609953642,
-0.5365488529,
0.4294601679,
-0.618299067,
-0.2529744506,
0.054595124,
0.1262112111,
-0.8645175695,
1.1385422945,
0.0405408144,
-0.6733429432,
0.5648491383,
-0.6590659022,
-0.5505598783,
-0.2526215315,
-0.0002916369,
-0.2889624238,
0.1965527982,
0.3511766493,
0.1779688001,
-0.3778678775,
-0.11901173,
-0.0222406425,
0.1688993722,
-0.2941158414,
-0.3934713602,
1.1793482304,
0.1888436973,
-0.2534678578,
-0.1450315267,
-0.7764192224,
0.3287065923,
0.1722471565,
-0.0270775594,
-0.6027023196,
-0.1160671711,
-0.8180185556,
0.6255707741,
-0.196876958,
-0.3269368708,
0.3763253689,
-0.2545930147,
0.049536977,
0.8630274534,
-0.2068338543,
0.4629786909,
-0.4721700549,
0.7730906606,
0.2701843679,
0.2908362746,
-0.4710491002,
-0.9116175771,
-0.7327861786,
-0.2210307121,
0.5927731395,
0.5821397305,
-0.8154685497,
-0.3273154199,
0.0467406884,
-0.3273234665,
-0.5072256923,
0.0513282306,
0.3488537073,
0.4925505221,
0.4373837709,
0.0377080925,
-0.5748702884,
-0.6640686989,
-0.2821699977,
-0.1093531772,
0.1486019343,
0.3880269825,
0.4558707178,
0.1391075701,
0.7511678934,
-0.5486246347,
0.0186217725,
-0.1561865509,
0.2927345932,
0.4369319379,
0.4960816503,
0.1375000179,
-0.8169199824,
-0.7284532189,
-0.2056876719,
-0.2945791781,
-0.1747564673,
-0.1532768607,
-0.6428973675,
0.0107842181,
0.2334557474,
-0.8461600542,
0.3576159179,
0.1977705657,
-0.525875926,
0.6961168647,
-0.2773412168,
0.4651891887,
-0.9124055505,
-0.3056735098,
0.0088236406,
-0.3043952882,
-0.8387904167,
-0.2476192862,
0.0974274725,
-0.0488110892,
-0.1970190704,
0.3577662408,
-0.4387688935,
0.0724095255,
-0.064828746,
-0.2050452828,
0.2795927525,
0.181187734,
-0.2253194153,
0.9717624187,
0.4685030282,
-0.7966445088,
0.0590028055,
0.2031510472,
-0.26413095,
0.2738929987,
-0.6062097549,
0.0437425673,
-0.067101866,
-0.0952577963,
-1.0191653967,
-0.1158194765,
0.1890983135,
-0.7096678615,
0.3486162424,
-0.3450195491,
-0.5191679001,
-0.571208477,
0.0791601613,
0.490339309,
0.4034173787,
-0.750654459,
0.7800659537,
0.0439559221,
-0.1973368824,
-0.6157120466,
-0.4237806797,
-0.1860987395,
-0.0834343135,
-0.6668760777,
-0.0594201274,
-0.0755154788,
-0.228945151,
-0.2623453736,
-0.247516185,
-0.1041823477,
0.0002528025,
0.1164888442,
0.397138238,
-0.2624269724,
0.3154936433,
0.1437905729,
-0.5455229282,
0.1867128313,
-0.5625907183,
0.4623456001,
0.0080705164,
-0.4503911436,
-0.2100382894,
0.3912440836,
0.8509012461,
-0.323508054,
0.5461807847,
-0.1010710523,
-0.6771692634,
-0.1501724869,
-0.2564774454,
-0.3439944685,
-0.4080250561,
-0.1143585593,
-0.7199705839,
-0.4020772576,
0.3611312509,
0.1001867056,
0.2241727412,
0.4784700871,
0.3434782326,
0.2389965951,
1.7618860006,
0.6881837845,
0.2752433717,
0.2413173169,
-0.2476318926,
0.5595547557,
-0.5788396597,
-0.441005826,
-0.8042221665,
0.2506926954,
-0.2605277598,
-0.8295114636,
0.1200091764,
0.1707229763,
-0.2807902992,
0.4447457194,
-0.4137338996,
0.5370173454,
0.6966019273,
-0.0050500068,
0.4811432958,
0.0376699083,
-0.5930500031,
-0.2633354366,
-1.1475861073,
-0.4984397292,
1.2216701508,
0.2624661028,
0.9703843594,
0.1285032779,
0.8384385705,
0.0460210294,
0.353525579,
-1.0266280174,
0.3488931656,
-0.0816617906,
-0.6694902182,
-0.469047755,
-0.5187471509,
-0.7385988832,
0.4017751813,
0.0694851652,
-0.3384488821,
0.3564636707,
0.2480141968,
-0.7331507206,
0.1043266654,
-0.7482545972,
0.8654946685,
-0.2922365665,
-0.3823692799,
0.1345229745,
-0.4650328159,
0.5087905526,
0.1121962443,
0.4580264091,
0.0213412791,
0.1321414262,
0.6768520474,
-0.557276845,
0.5154600143,
-0.3282855153,
-0.2402293682,
0.3906488717,
0.4230753481,
0.6205467582,
-0.0187509786,
0.0785103366,
-0.1803457141,
0.1328322738,
-0.3570154607,
-0.8740660548,
0.4691208601,
-0.5160259008,
-0.8557896614,
-0.5220494866,
-0.314788878,
-0.2367844731,
0.4835107028,
0.0397108681,
0.8046936989,
0.5581397414,
0.1142626405,
0.9672842622,
0.4089569151,
0.2136854231,
0.2070664018,
-0.4933545589,
-0.3174411356,
0.621124804,
0.1839179099,
0.6225623488,
0.0478911027,
0.3782996237,
-0.5246734619,
-0.2748268247,
-0.6536092162,
0.2067043185,
-0.9145295024,
-0.3772706091,
-0.7318518758,
-0.1004307643,
-0.4217890501,
0.1573491096,
-0.743894577,
-0.5636205673,
-0.0384051502,
0.0692652091,
-0.0187545605,
0.3620479107,
-0.4246180654,
0.1368228346,
-0.7864562869,
0.3043402135,
0.4776435196,
0.1016336158,
0.2520705163,
-0.5873414874,
-0.4348215759,
0.0861673653,
-0.1043273509,
-0.6485262513,
0.3321660161,
0.0291368701,
0.6174753904,
0.4510964453,
-0.1715607494,
0.9616743326,
-0.7202858329,
0.4813423455,
0.108729288,
-0.9709040523,
0.5708565712,
-0.0781638473,
0.4209000468,
0.3874374628,
0.7634125352,
-0.4345889986,
-0.115363881,
-0.7645535469,
-0.4012615085,
0.6941181421,
0.1800323874,
-0.2704282701,
0.0277367905,
0.3099053204,
0.1471968442,
0.1629087478,
-0.407595247,
-0.131706953,
-0.4153371155,
0.0227362309,
0.1573215127,
0.0104164341,
-0.4447112978,
-0.4954986572,
0.7911259532,
-0.4466867447,
0.4144607782,
0.189806968,
-0.0349346623,
-0.3491958082,
0.1001095772,
0.6203275323,
0.914111495,
0.1553056836,
0.0176008269,
-0.1628305018,
-0.2518132031,
0.275724262,
0.0186771546,
-0.0577692837,
-0.0799470246,
0.4456211627,
0.7609863281,
0.1631718129,
-0.3435401022,
0.4010181427,
-0.2097977698,
-0.2196107209,
0.2531986833,
0.1993375868,
-0.1468291432,
0.3043658435,
0.5493993759,
0.1418827623,
0.1541853547,
-0.5243560076,
0.3461230099,
0.3932395875,
-0.0821260214,
-0.1213044673,
0.4031868279,
-0.442285955,
-0.451287955,
0.6477755308,
-0.0516782515,
-0.9228149056,
0.9794782996,
0.8845558763,
0.577462852,
-0.2861218452,
0.3769588768,
0.8924852014,
0.4021689594,
-0.44332093,
0.2262907922,
-0.0787629038,
-0.7431886792,
-0.7768116593,
-0.481961906,
-0.4649820924,
-0.3001130223,
-0.7346158028,
0.3437824249,
-0.4118949175,
-0.1195683777,
0.0892085433,
0.0981027931,
-0.7178739905,
0.5355645418,
0.0672352165,
0.9140024781,
-0.5608460903,
0.6866461039,
0.3651186824,
-0.0534591377,
-1.2793539762,
-0.1736221611,
-0.0311851054,
-0.8210020065,
0.9183263183,
0.2713849545,
-0.3085592091,
0.1339944154,
-0.5877500176,
-1.0894223452,
1.0417137146,
-0.1582419872,
-0.7358412147,
-0.2594688535,
-0.0414278768,
0.2582071722,
-0.7308323979,
0.4353096485,
0.5634012222,
0.4007297754,
0.6174968481,
-0.7609138489,
0.0795152783,
0.1308674216,
-0.1034799665,
0.6986301541,
-0.3048088253,
1.4210646152,
-0.8297842145,
-0.4320380986,
-0.0338234045,
0.3125364184,
0.3911790848,
0.2756094933,
0.7466464043,
0.6001946926,
1.1022884846,
-0.3140862286,
1.0428675413,
-0.4252975285,
0.4463301897,
1.1705377102,
0.1145454273,
0.4816463292,
0.3468225002,
-0.3532458842,
0.403504014,
0.7907553315,
0.3885599077,
0.5470482707,
0.0630277619,
-0.0519427061,
-0.7720671892,
0.4413462579,
-0.4111660123,
0.2798075974,
0.3689624667,
-0.1736818254,
-0.540636301,
0.0624884479,
0.0034975545,
-0.2379655838,
-0.498298049,
0.3555669785,
0.1846282929,
-0.8087480068,
0.4507752061,
-0.0963935032,
0.0487999432,
-0.5677911043,
-0.2673359215,
-0.255546391,
0.0193154495,
-0.166571632,
-0.4245881438,
0.2852411568,
-0.2436464578,
-0.4227395058,
-0.2097943574,
0.8399409652,
-0.2969986796,
-0.5415642858,
0.0682639554,
0.8507804275,
-0.1928534806,
0.0098562539,
-0.9222468734,
-0.3925804794,
-0.1079419777,
-0.1689896286,
0.037699718,
0.6940042973,
-0.2111263573,
0.9314937592,
1.1412482262,
0.0338143371,
0.5214978456,
0.1369494349,
0.825869143,
-0.7487668395,
-0.4991331995,
-0.9510368109,
0.6190780997,
-0.0145551516,
-0.1609237939,
0.9108015299,
0.5121002197,
0.6702543497,
0.0578757711,
0.5538648963,
-0.0616345182,
0.7010704875,
-0.5515577793,
0.1408628821,
-0.596542716,
0.1974543035,
-0.0775135532,
-0.6831516623,
-0.3978194296,
0.834538281,
-0.397842139,
-0.0271261241,
0.9473323226,
0.6693925858,
-0.1710491031,
0.2243864387,
0.4696293175,
0.1207169592,
0.6551601291,
0.5773720741,
0.8070466518,
-0.5241064429,
0.3056927025,
-0.3155530393,
-0.3991259634,
0.0367522724,
-0.9093440771,
-0.6959111691,
-0.1870396882,
-0.1490224749,
-0.8851161003,
-0.1359369159,
1.1742540598,
0.6353954077,
-0.8142157793,
-0.0771414638,
-0.1534195691,
0.4274482131,
-0.2199037224,
-0.1994799674,
0.0064714472,
-0.6746248603,
-0.6978167295,
0.0778364018,
0.3163054883,
0.0483144708,
-0.2492297739,
-0.1851404011,
-0.2562887967,
0.5966549516,
0.82987535,
0.4162725508,
-0.4160946012,
-0.1849581748,
0.0437666066,
-0.2546906471,
0.2918297946,
1.2900022268,
-0.7343651652,
0.4293002188,
0.4107628763,
0.7304322124,
0.3827849329,
-0.0877357721,
0.4787610173,
0.0958690867,
-0.1456306577,
0.2612823546,
0.3410620391,
0.1669321656,
-0.3811077476,
0.3712658584,
0.3307223618,
-0.5642527938,
-0.906694591,
0.2085857838,
-0.5600005984,
0.0929209813,
0.9259350896,
-0.1236073524,
-0.2924715877,
-0.010512054,
-0.2946387529,
0.1076816842,
-0.2710472941,
0.5039457083,
1.1115363836,
-0.4310986996,
-0.1999322176,
-0.7947562337,
0.6782826185,
0.6102015376,
-0.9169330597,
0.087719202,
0.3875950575,
0.267511636,
0.2187044621,
0.6973574758,
-0.2157573551,
0.3891127408,
0.2069705129,
-0.6429581642,
-0.1153093949,
-1.1093648672,
-0.026015019,
0.1184038371,
0.1217599511,
-0.1031565741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07941v1
|
Non-autoregressive Machine Translation with Probabilistic Context-free Grammar
| 2023-11-14T06:39:04 | 2023-11-14T06:39:04 |
Shangtong Gui, Chenze Shao, Zhengrui Ma, Xishan Zhang, Yunji Chen, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Non-autoregressive Transformer(NAT) significantly accelerates the inference
of neural machine translation. However, conventional NAT models suffer from
limited expression power and performance degradation compared to autoregressive
(AT) models due to the assumption of conditional independence among target
tokens. To address these limitations, we propose a novel approach called
PCFG-NAT, which leverages a specially designed Probabilistic Context-Free
Grammar (PCFG) to enhance the ability of NAT models to capture complex
dependencies among output tokens. Experimental results on major machine
translation benchmarks demonstrate that PCFG-NAT further narrows the gap in
translation quality between NAT and AT models. Moreover, PCFG-NAT facilitates a
deeper understanding of the generated sentences, addressing the lack of
satisfactory explainability in neural machine translation.Code is publicly
available at https://github.com/ictnlp/PCFG-NAT.
|
[
-0.2838231027,
-0.6250053644,
0.2522454858,
0.4030548334,
-0.4986507893,
-0.2590461373,
-0.3105995655,
-0.2930034995,
0.2129480839,
0.4644767046,
-0.5281230807,
-0.2918908894,
-0.7707813382,
0.2991615534,
-0.4977592826,
0.8076173067,
-0.0752853155,
-0.0840038583,
-0.2092640847,
0.2331357598,
-0.436111331,
-0.4340298772,
-0.3517697155,
-0.374548465,
0.0343836807,
0.255528152,
0.782446146,
0.8413863182,
0.5864027739,
0.2364466637,
0.0659980625,
0.2517075837,
-0.1612833887,
0.0615444183,
-0.1655344665,
-0.4013055861,
-0.5531583428,
0.0487657301,
0.6227139235,
0.5159968734,
-0.0004348693,
0.04253814,
-0.0550693646,
0.5693945885,
-0.3135126531,
0.6375160813,
-0.5416845679,
0.1404549927,
0.0260856077,
-0.1925750375,
-0.6505429149,
-0.1857367158,
-0.0658058748,
-0.2753418088,
0.5247616768,
-0.0820793286,
0.7061591148,
0.5848302841,
-0.7704154253,
0.3233193159,
-0.6688805819,
0.5546543598,
-0.6413350701,
0.2848938704,
0.3808933198,
0.4304887354,
-0.4800420702,
-0.7839522958,
-0.6269804835,
-0.160282582,
-0.5060810447,
0.2617028058,
-0.3377297521,
0.2770642638,
-0.0963613987,
0.7043492794,
-0.6634551287,
-0.2751968205,
0.0600742884,
-0.0726419762,
0.559058845,
-0.1812026203,
0.12350858,
-0.4930624366,
-0.6331935525,
0.0223680306,
-0.5605295897,
-0.0325589776,
0.0777124241,
0.5742710233,
-0.1323053539,
0.4404206574,
-0.2476065904,
0.8921810985,
0.4276964068,
0.1182649285,
0.2538741529,
-0.4165257514,
-0.2923005521,
0.1856547594,
1.0358076096,
0.2232613713,
-0.2204778939,
-0.580494523,
-0.120583564,
-0.0725053027,
0.1360721737,
-0.7449105382,
-0.1889771074,
0.00503786,
-0.6857207417,
-0.3613265753,
0.1449130923,
-0.7913796902,
0.1580345929,
-0.2502623796,
0.3023641407,
-0.1902163029,
-0.4988883734,
-0.0882881507,
0.1749392897,
0.3205190897,
-0.0658570826,
-0.7623745203,
0.1559861898,
0.4601432681,
0.8900966644,
-0.3207038641,
-0.0236831717,
-0.9517508745,
0.0019033235,
-0.5003741384,
0.6622701883,
-0.2979556918,
-0.3291727602,
-0.4778902233,
0.3438471258,
-0.2496240884,
-0.4391305745,
0.5919185877,
-0.4035646021,
0.4548144341,
-0.3759229183,
-0.3965768814,
-0.4027495384,
0.0226183347,
-0.6040554643,
0.7560856342,
0.2469822019,
-0.5789585114,
0.0891770273,
-0.7231994867,
-0.6514978409,
0.123751536,
-0.0564504154,
-0.3586559892,
0.4437532127,
0.2964770794,
0.3316371143,
-0.4156116545,
1.0402547121,
-0.0363017432,
-0.1537713557,
-0.0570164695,
-0.7207041979,
0.7520234585,
0.155024007,
-0.7977790833,
0.2181538641,
-0.7986112237,
-0.0226231702,
-0.0169988591,
-0.2979638577,
0.1308059692,
0.0357492082,
0.0119358515,
0.7131206989,
0.1504128575,
-0.4152374864,
0.1556366533,
-0.3941527903,
0.4429262877,
0.5226419568,
-0.1633055657,
0.6234798431,
-0.1674469709,
0.6854058504,
-0.0394189097,
0.0808666423,
-0.1180445179,
-0.6673122644,
-0.6954646707,
-0.3751832545,
0.3397342265,
0.6166971326,
-0.9193133116,
0.6805787683,
-0.1709460467,
-0.2521484494,
-0.2938975692,
-0.014934564,
0.5616697073,
0.8747335076,
0.7398756146,
-0.3486823142,
-0.5440964699,
-0.8790677786,
-0.2542570233,
-0.2730794549,
-0.1264027059,
0.3122287691,
0.1001057401,
-0.1748993099,
0.91051054,
-0.1372706294,
-0.2750244439,
-0.2874819338,
0.4693132043,
0.3434618711,
0.6129717827,
0.5000625253,
-0.8866991997,
-0.476908654,
-0.1587645262,
-0.5545088053,
-0.5481643677,
-0.2173016369,
-0.4269647002,
0.1209119856,
0.6385715604,
-0.8656705022,
0.49878335,
0.7803710103,
-0.6102788448,
0.3988993764,
-0.170602724,
-0.0573388487,
-1.1035016775,
0.3354593217,
-0.3119622469,
-0.6999901533,
-0.6590262651,
0.0116525013,
0.0949117839,
0.0565983504,
-0.5851601362,
0.3430665731,
-0.3010059297,
-0.0546886548,
-0.5718285441,
-0.1648596078,
0.09771543,
0.3731192946,
0.2136088312,
0.7687761188,
0.2137758881,
-0.5573800802,
0.1082984731,
0.2751177847,
0.0635757595,
0.227063641,
-0.568354547,
-0.173747018,
-0.1810065657,
0.4648841619,
-0.95324862,
-0.1554193795,
0.3485659063,
-0.5820776224,
0.4937895238,
-0.1242419332,
-0.5874875188,
-0.0520192608,
0.3553933203,
0.2890363634,
0.4705549181,
-0.7807930112,
0.7205756307,
0.0187244825,
0.145012632,
-0.4418642521,
-0.907033205,
0.4303411245,
-0.0476832315,
-0.3801594079,
0.8056491613,
0.1133366823,
-0.0779652297,
0.1024004593,
-0.1698268503,
-0.0683349892,
0.1344151944,
0.1521360427,
0.1788735837,
-0.4001550078,
0.1248853952,
0.0544995852,
-0.4576554298,
0.2032562792,
-0.7318333983,
0.4499237835,
-0.3817914724,
-0.1295769662,
-0.2885477543,
0.5858227015,
0.5823587179,
-0.3389382064,
0.7430793643,
0.7918652296,
-0.3043326437,
-0.1123304442,
-0.1997026205,
-0.1682078689,
-0.4648508132,
0.1210940257,
-0.1439766139,
-0.7211133242,
0.2128291577,
-0.0634266734,
-0.1255856752,
0.6208240986,
0.4082416594,
0.2442182153,
0.9574186802,
0.6828364134,
0.0956114978,
0.3796446919,
0.0409621671,
0.596359849,
-0.6036503911,
-0.0884143934,
-0.0875105858,
-0.341866076,
-0.9272737503,
-0.5970564485,
0.1023594514,
0.4240075648,
0.2095554322,
0.56796664,
-0.4595432281,
0.4361507893,
0.7371990681,
-0.1822446436,
0.2391831726,
-0.0959131569,
-0.3695575595,
0.1863290519,
-0.8432133198,
-0.3688363731,
0.8307893276,
-0.0473256633,
0.0146863516,
0.3102445006,
0.5645431876,
0.1231526658,
0.4932817519,
-0.68282336,
0.4934096634,
-0.4509738088,
-0.5923244953,
0.1143703312,
-0.6816492677,
-0.6655682325,
0.3762361407,
-0.1291083694,
-0.471529752,
0.3391064703,
0.4337917566,
-0.1975031793,
0.4171782732,
-0.5295393467,
0.9726029634,
-0.4029029608,
-0.4185067117,
0.3177528977,
-0.8639415503,
0.3824183643,
0.0709791332,
0.0776092783,
0.0316495821,
0.1891784966,
0.2570494413,
-0.5139344931,
0.7720721364,
-0.314950794,
0.2407580763,
0.5422176719,
0.2802038491,
0.5313581824,
0.1361639351,
0.1304590106,
0.2552477419,
-0.5017453432,
-0.3600146472,
-0.3633899093,
0.6038530469,
-0.5253075361,
-0.4847018123,
-0.3617154956,
-0.6276533008,
-0.1864951104,
0.4420860112,
0.4654843807,
-0.0898996294,
-0.051017154,
0.3269748688,
0.4894501567,
-0.3697358668,
0.7408149838,
0.3518353701,
-0.2259563059,
-0.6677449346,
0.7577898502,
-0.1189607456,
0.3112384379,
0.6552227139,
0.2902137041,
-0.3993258774,
-0.2948213816,
-0.4023786485,
0.1610679775,
-0.5617396832,
-0.4135058522,
-0.7849563956,
-0.0966518745,
-0.4053580463,
-0.1313465089,
-0.3872252703,
-0.8585501909,
-0.5531306863,
-0.2659458518,
0.241073668,
0.3171090782,
-0.3276540637,
0.5490497351,
-0.7283754945,
0.4243943095,
0.3487362862,
0.3169120252,
-0.3140099049,
-0.4071318507,
0.094512023,
-0.2143867612,
-0.379888773,
-0.864466846,
0.8706101775,
0.3304273486,
0.3941060007,
0.4614438117,
0.1587678492,
0.6724104285,
-0.5138792396,
0.8200945854,
0.3311727047,
-1.2378740311,
0.349378854,
-0.5746769905,
0.4424510002,
0.4520845711,
0.0868989453,
-0.3749884367,
-0.2673058212,
-0.6441951394,
-1.1740763187,
0.5113301873,
0.2490303516,
-0.0964407548,
-0.4862759113,
0.5299665928,
0.0117521379,
0.4435521662,
-0.8627023697,
-0.187602818,
-0.712505877,
-0.102282919,
-0.3679131269,
-0.1084998548,
0.2457407862,
-0.0849854499,
0.6941729188,
-0.3248832524,
0.5193885565,
0.3216417432,
-0.2339425385,
-0.2171862274,
0.1698390692,
0.5521134734,
0.1967659146,
-0.1185439229,
0.3949707747,
-0.1034563929,
-0.0203551222,
0.2224554121,
0.249615714,
-0.2706666589,
0.3846057057,
0.3043056726,
0.7545360327,
0.0480766483,
-0.4482855201,
0.6249555349,
-0.4016697109,
-0.5112272501,
-0.2285381854,
-0.144520238,
0.2971170545,
0.1386654973,
0.2376881987,
0.3895006478,
0.0390982032,
0.0000076297,
0.4808649123,
0.2862163186,
-0.5145065784,
-0.4343641102,
1.0832135677,
-0.0301461313,
-0.399969548,
0.5303191543,
-0.4965615571,
-0.4395028353,
0.6105363369,
0.9925300479,
1.1651241779,
-0.3933077157,
0.2494791448,
0.3075765669,
0.4344412982,
-0.266259253,
0.4031400681,
-0.2147589475,
-0.238274768,
-0.7425498962,
-0.5809757113,
-0.0790954232,
0.1140580848,
-0.5449386835,
0.1328299493,
-0.3282875717,
-0.277323544,
-0.5794649124,
-0.4763596356,
-0.54205966,
0.256421119,
0.0591011979,
0.5471369028,
-0.9263258576,
0.8037961721,
0.3675998449,
-0.1295161843,
-0.6073086858,
0.1398727298,
-0.2191744,
-0.2969408929,
0.8191794157,
0.3641575277,
-0.1240895912,
0.0316308178,
-0.2247926593,
-1.0956937075,
0.941567421,
0.6606522799,
-0.4979686439,
-0.0098284828,
0.3514494598,
0.5518642664,
-0.3208479583,
-0.0073001506,
0.284487009,
0.5219037533,
-0.1128837317,
-0.9404193163,
0.1493910402,
-0.3893345892,
0.1025302708,
0.3467282653,
-0.7280968428,
0.9765229821,
0.2198247761,
-0.1550297439,
-0.2627735734,
0.6989970207,
-0.248400256,
-0.011525508,
0.4314944744,
0.486803323,
0.4109246731,
-0.2011388987,
0.8085926175,
-0.7389706969,
0.2292478532,
1.4402141571,
0.2364131212,
0.7237553,
0.6533813477,
0.1848112494,
0.3563739359,
0.432276547,
0.1959792376,
0.8134291172,
0.1076122671,
-0.5055904984,
-0.4954399765,
-0.1305716783,
-0.212064907,
0.729274869,
0.1780592501,
-1.0500040054,
-0.3291336298,
-0.1769490987,
0.0657023042,
-0.0166621748,
-0.0390936621,
0.6282292604,
0.149721384,
-0.9437606931,
0.7868247032,
0.3667672276,
0.365511477,
-0.3749154806,
-0.001881056,
-0.1912125349,
0.2105442882,
-0.2191608399,
0.1065155417,
0.7668297887,
0.0607060269,
-0.2950247526,
-0.6516112685,
0.4523285329,
-0.4515395164,
-0.5825930238,
0.4038836956,
0.5751371384,
-0.0915059373,
-0.0159256496,
-0.446018815,
-0.5299425721,
-0.010407106,
-0.2333512753,
0.2711572051,
0.3427108526,
-0.0658795238,
0.1653124988,
0.6510939598,
-0.0296836495,
0.220915243,
-0.3530108929,
0.541505456,
-0.4825737476,
-0.6071698666,
-0.997828722,
0.3848933876,
0.215784207,
-0.1117758229,
0.6356714368,
0.3239921927,
0.6754234433,
0.0674921796,
0.8177090287,
-0.0167592801,
0.0104347868,
-0.2114848495,
0.5471609831,
-0.2394716889,
0.0236473121,
-0.187806502,
-0.695566237,
-0.7443068027,
0.7637199163,
-0.3413760662,
-0.3164780438,
0.6594901681,
0.5654590726,
-0.275033325,
0.0349471048,
0.2670865953,
-0.0041157072,
0.6658965349,
0.5571084023,
0.3883506954,
-0.4187840521,
0.6904027462,
-0.2565799356,
-0.383592546,
-0.1004153416,
-1.4880732298,
-0.8187760711,
-0.2296616435,
-0.36704126,
-0.3281381726,
-0.1790980697,
1.1019743681,
0.7714751959,
-0.7872402072,
-0.053215757,
-0.8914428353,
-0.0872786045,
-0.531436801,
-0.2688209414,
0.3950465322,
-0.5032249689,
-0.4253444672,
0.7875120044,
0.1753404289,
0.1273105443,
0.051740665,
0.1060561165,
-0.1503176242,
0.1578470021,
0.6006249785,
0.1766421646,
-0.6232350469,
0.0549238138,
0.2105995119,
0.316355139,
0.265191704,
0.7342897654,
-0.8198310137,
0.5501240492,
0.6690835953,
0.7800119519,
0.4215980768,
0.1730014831,
0.8348517418,
-0.821985662,
0.1596039236,
0.1442310661,
0.3962104023,
0.4028229415,
-0.6142786145,
0.1192707196,
0.3447820842,
-0.5269594193,
-0.6663115621,
0.4583888054,
-0.4699515104,
-0.2627652884,
1.0781621933,
-0.4191704392,
-0.288833648,
0.0694496632,
0.2616746128,
0.557358861,
-0.1629062891,
0.8707308173,
0.5593039393,
-0.286395371,
-0.0425107144,
-0.5073149204,
0.4947833121,
0.46502316,
-0.6741897464,
0.2043464929,
0.4720428884,
0.0682602078,
0.0269892905,
0.5475959182,
-0.3846226037,
0.2329856306,
-0.1775163114,
-0.0413114056,
-0.2466554046,
-0.3977916241,
-0.5175834894,
0.4119200706,
-0.1265590042,
-0.307907939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07930v1
|
It's All Relative! -- A Synthetic Query Generation Approach for Improving Zero-Shot Relevance Prediction
| 2023-11-14T06:16:49 | 2023-11-14T06:16:49 |
Aditi Chaudhary, Karthik Raman, Michael Bendersky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent developments in large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in
their ability to generate synthetic query-document pairs by prompting with as
few as 8 demonstrations. This has enabled building better IR models, especially
for tasks with no training data readily available. Typically, such synthetic
query generation (QGen) approaches condition on an input context (e.g. a text
document) and generate a query relevant to that context, or condition the QGen
model additionally on the relevance label (e.g. relevant vs irrelevant) to
generate queries across relevance buckets. However, we find that such QGen
approaches are sub-optimal as they require the model to reason about the
desired label and the input from a handful of examples. In this work, we
propose to reduce this burden of LLMs by generating queries simultaneously for
different labels. We hypothesize that instead of asking the model to generate,
say, an irrelevant query given an input context, asking the model to generate
an irrelevant query relative to a relevant query is a much simpler task setup
for the model to reason about. Extensive experimentation across seven IR
datasets shows that synthetic queries generated in such a fashion translates to
a better downstream performance, suggesting that the generated queries are
indeed of higher quality.
|
[
-0.3039589524,
-0.7441682816,
0.9212551117,
-0.2813355327,
-0.0736788139,
0.0018131416,
-0.1359092146,
-0.4092999399,
0.2538608015,
0.6525114179,
-0.7832742929,
-0.5913718939,
-0.1832788736,
0.1261985004,
-0.4478691816,
0.8944777846,
0.2418859899,
-0.0877752081,
-0.4068604112,
-0.3955053091,
-0.2467618883,
-0.5657163858,
-0.3745189011,
-0.4509132802,
0.9035407305,
0.3953962326,
0.4213394821,
0.4402568042,
0.368984282,
0.2154763639,
0.225897342,
0.2395186275,
-0.6548213363,
0.8345215321,
-0.3970772922,
-0.6263676286,
-0.0390848704,
0.0755053163,
0.6630151868,
0.6136512756,
0.2254689038,
0.1602293998,
-0.2034645677,
0.5840583444,
-0.966751039,
-0.4393209219,
-1.3100944757,
-0.1808661222,
-0.1617500484,
-0.6042503119,
-0.4870255589,
-0.222102955,
0.0682317242,
-0.5075888038,
0.7428016067,
0.2166792452,
0.865304172,
0.1044524387,
-0.5010694265,
-0.0448345989,
-0.8563610911,
0.8041152358,
-0.5019124746,
0.2172149569,
0.3024411201,
0.5078969598,
-0.3342951238,
-0.8408866525,
-0.7935461998,
-0.3320876956,
-0.1046099365,
0.301335007,
0.0543234125,
0.1217720583,
0.2153552473,
0.1303326041,
-0.5556040406,
-0.2301405519,
-0.1923784912,
-0.1824319512,
0.2762750387,
0.1797668338,
0.0262561515,
-0.081459552,
-0.0231971964,
-0.132669121,
-1.1061941385,
-0.2574344277,
0.1451519132,
0.5453365445,
0.2785456479,
0.7555254698,
-0.6880371571,
0.9925153255,
0.2984820604,
-0.2073920965,
-0.0374992043,
-0.5657476783,
0.0597425625,
0.180245325,
0.8170980811,
0.2860765755,
-0.0477941372,
-0.360860467,
-0.1463148892,
0.0303661246,
0.4355885983,
-0.9239044785,
-0.0116650267,
0.3816515505,
-0.019610744,
-0.3783285618,
-0.1309783012,
-0.4561144412,
-0.0180293061,
-0.3266560137,
0.5645336509,
-0.2999432087,
0.1629345566,
-0.3685931563,
-0.0877931416,
0.267090559,
0.1157694608,
-0.5246611834,
-0.2745218575,
0.5298885107,
0.7523735166,
0.0473152325,
-0.0741920248,
-0.9479372501,
0.446957469,
-0.3301376998,
1.0745770931,
-0.8536061049,
-0.5758081079,
0.0497754328,
-0.22506468,
0.122095719,
-0.5013756752,
0.4632284045,
-0.7444421053,
0.4509049058,
-0.2525042295,
-0.4617024064,
0.1055145636,
0.5315965414,
-0.4542452097,
1.0630031824,
0.2103915215,
-0.6431353688,
0.4327129722,
-0.4295156896,
-0.5289342999,
0.152928859,
-0.3932908177,
-0.2022727728,
0.044365257,
0.1029859632,
0.1442207545,
-0.6031686664,
0.3323569298,
-0.3392499089,
-0.3833493888,
0.0256329402,
-0.1157800257,
0.1529410779,
0.154379189,
-0.3474622965,
0.0294525605,
-0.7636502385,
0.4207113981,
-0.0885813981,
-0.324202925,
-0.3157940805,
-0.0109967533,
-0.4477593303,
0.117497161,
0.0567450523,
-0.5167244673,
0.1950734258,
-0.6802188754,
0.0940607563,
0.4096499681,
0.3166166544,
0.6898757815,
-0.4426595569,
0.6663264632,
-0.2532753944,
-0.1075334474,
-0.4234538078,
-0.4234488606,
-0.7083994746,
0.0009013216,
0.3880065084,
0.4498334825,
-1.1991922855,
0.0836852863,
-0.3484643698,
-0.6295790672,
-0.4034032822,
-0.049782902,
0.6445760727,
0.8383238912,
0.2576827109,
0.1981355399,
-0.5478603244,
-0.8505975604,
-0.3118044436,
-0.4566289186,
-0.195417732,
0.4885380864,
0.3762226701,
0.0807449594,
1.0453959703,
-0.777443409,
-0.301220268,
-0.1301666647,
0.1660179198,
0.4133524001,
0.0971830785,
0.7765544653,
-0.7885793447,
-0.700096786,
0.0367681496,
-0.6230233312,
-0.2148317248,
-0.0684975833,
-0.6923474669,
0.1836163849,
0.4853148758,
-0.6804288626,
0.1183710247,
0.1570973843,
0.0827375054,
0.540230751,
-0.0993342549,
0.2532187402,
-1.1250070333,
0.233173281,
0.0667554215,
-0.1783862412,
-0.6378507614,
0.3611791432,
-0.0645873994,
-0.1822144836,
-0.6141911745,
0.8136901855,
-0.3691690266,
0.2035015672,
-0.3271175325,
0.1959311217,
0.2847867608,
0.291665554,
-0.0698134005,
0.9982321858,
0.611751914,
-0.7941628695,
0.2864305377,
0.0236351695,
-0.1600351632,
0.3877656758,
-0.724044323,
0.1505664587,
-0.2434080392,
0.3724761903,
-0.9808580279,
-0.4014159143,
0.195559293,
-0.7749295831,
0.4631541371,
-0.1896952391,
-0.5038738847,
-0.223292008,
-0.4365676343,
0.6296744347,
0.706050396,
-0.5612526536,
0.6364549398,
0.2195398957,
0.0605860204,
-0.4275021851,
-0.4293002784,
0.0138489213,
-0.2389622927,
-0.5355318189,
0.7573728561,
0.0776065961,
-0.1598470509,
-0.0314630419,
-0.2515976429,
0.0128003722,
-0.2423925698,
0.1181836799,
0.1177856848,
-0.351688683,
0.2778001428,
-0.0470306575,
0.049637612,
-0.330896765,
-0.4295714796,
0.376424253,
0.4598146379,
-0.2684435248,
-0.1378766447,
0.4095736742,
0.5307067037,
-0.0242412165,
0.7828984857,
0.3241706491,
-0.0986284688,
-0.3284966052,
-0.7303561568,
-0.5095165372,
-0.507574141,
0.1047993302,
-0.5835490227,
-0.7862190008,
0.4415473938,
0.0662723333,
0.0707657114,
0.3717243969,
0.6201585531,
-0.1988477856,
1.065961957,
0.4835241139,
0.1216889769,
0.5230441093,
-0.1807148159,
0.3783323765,
-0.6187963486,
-0.3233904541,
-0.7850842476,
-0.0366162322,
-0.7659255862,
-0.6634027958,
0.7152606249,
0.0000242401,
-0.0550192557,
0.3948848844,
-0.6159361005,
0.6681010723,
0.8085333705,
-0.0516250916,
0.1294279248,
0.4225274026,
-0.387036711,
0.0052169249,
-0.9092193842,
-0.3025881946,
1.263953805,
-0.4224329591,
0.4622724652,
0.0912123024,
0.8724578023,
0.1051429734,
0.5023492575,
-0.8151122332,
0.4843509495,
-0.1856770366,
-0.8395976424,
-0.103137739,
-0.5973446965,
-1.0788390636,
0.5430734754,
-0.2324984372,
-0.5304065347,
-0.0991589651,
0.1780206263,
-0.5082597733,
0.1124304608,
-0.5745040178,
0.3697302639,
-0.0568522178,
-0.8472771049,
0.017454898,
-0.62848562,
0.4364747405,
-0.349989742,
0.0794485435,
-0.3052746952,
0.1808013618,
0.2987951934,
-0.4082693756,
0.5783206224,
0.0362548567,
0.0451073237,
0.7046005726,
0.3517898917,
0.3862588704,
0.0339674018,
-0.6385996938,
-0.262093991,
-0.0221845023,
-0.2438803017,
-0.7360783219,
1.0007579327,
-0.2950173318,
-0.9416822195,
-0.5448284745,
-0.4061102867,
-0.3643687665,
0.2461930662,
0.4186045527,
0.5697045326,
-0.0210389458,
0.2922417223,
0.3167400956,
-0.3502199948,
0.2800086141,
0.8397243023,
0.0829459578,
-0.2322040945,
1.0097283125,
0.0808057263,
0.307125181,
0.7062116265,
-0.0051121158,
-0.5228167772,
-0.3790148497,
-0.2513717413,
0.4253984392,
-0.5322377086,
-0.5612109303,
-0.6345646977,
-0.1551202238,
-0.5938078165,
-0.0566524491,
-0.2060932666,
-0.3542478681,
-0.2059193254,
0.2380763739,
0.3754665554,
0.3105218709,
-0.0139542632,
0.2220965624,
-0.9913048148,
0.6823800206,
0.1989279985,
0.0756973401,
-0.2018939257,
-0.7078701854,
0.037932843,
0.2909313738,
-0.704161942,
-0.6417183876,
0.4817440808,
0.7193274498,
0.6452259421,
0.115731284,
0.5978888869,
0.6885669827,
-0.7462931275,
0.7793927789,
0.2243559957,
-0.4694488347,
0.9265893698,
-0.5850658417,
0.4281552434,
0.7816180587,
0.583524406,
-0.1013151854,
-0.6874152422,
-0.4859066308,
-1.1548341513,
0.8735324144,
0.5134705901,
0.3734112084,
-0.2720344067,
0.6512321234,
0.131150797,
0.1554960608,
-0.5948759913,
-0.3614944518,
0.2420931011,
0.0003746398,
0.2681010365,
-0.2574079633,
-0.0644349679,
-0.2540305555,
0.8160350323,
-0.2944550812,
0.3163665831,
0.2321256697,
0.2373869717,
-0.2299172729,
0.0442910008,
0.3801289201,
0.65637815,
-0.5767194629,
0.0622403957,
-0.0541891679,
-0.1292824894,
0.2220579833,
-0.268012464,
-0.4767848849,
0.4110309184,
0.3591718674,
0.6591495872,
0.0555437095,
-0.7187411189,
0.2249917388,
0.0068702041,
-0.3802031279,
-0.1889629215,
0.2884348631,
-0.0639131218,
0.0448712856,
0.4751552343,
-0.300023526,
0.1654946059,
-0.8396244645,
0.4448773563,
0.497133702,
-0.1333749741,
-0.1387125105,
0.7849092484,
0.204962939,
-0.2207472175,
0.5983672738,
-0.2406700999,
-0.5210014582,
0.5676171184,
0.5206377506,
0.6935771704,
-0.053441789,
0.3856369555,
0.7033666372,
-0.1724200547,
-0.05689428,
-0.0049102553,
-0.2506795228,
-0.6933544278,
-0.546192348,
-0.9115839601,
-0.5152667165,
0.241466701,
-0.4713061452,
0.5045324564,
-0.2096989453,
-0.3170678616,
0.3900385499,
-0.221486181,
-0.3689362705,
0.2923021317,
-0.2460006922,
0.4180621505,
-0.3342275321,
1.0154840946,
0.7424497604,
-0.5232480764,
-0.5323916078,
0.4741453826,
-0.2509249747,
-0.729327023,
0.7862249017,
0.1390523612,
-0.2332096398,
-0.0593578927,
-0.4534445703,
-0.9116863012,
0.9223216176,
0.5131860971,
-0.6179752946,
-0.1322212666,
0.1221117377,
0.606028378,
-0.2618014216,
0.2698823214,
0.548601985,
0.2497812361,
0.7165142894,
-0.6769027114,
-0.0143206408,
-0.0879213512,
-0.1070825011,
0.3597365618,
-0.4572983682,
0.4962061942,
-0.2458435595,
-0.3981900513,
0.2858492434,
0.3949540257,
0.6196317673,
0.5006678104,
0.0891520083,
0.2926998436,
0.3521131873,
-0.1879229248,
1.4177203178,
-0.6201150417,
0.2370590717,
1.3977003098,
-0.6516078711,
0.7960223556,
0.4623520374,
-0.1144059822,
0.0557558388,
0.5648370385,
0.1526483744,
0.8711118102,
0.193092227,
-0.6552544236,
-0.4163129926,
-0.4045449495,
-0.5538991094,
0.3703334928,
0.2498246133,
-0.2627082765,
-0.4998036623,
-0.2230030447,
-0.2341694683,
0.1453668326,
0.1234561801,
0.7861455083,
0.0476742648,
-1.1637043953,
0.8975855112,
0.0763195157,
0.6206042767,
-0.6154874563,
-0.1497305334,
-0.468922317,
-0.0302762575,
0.0318790451,
-0.6265112758,
0.3189637065,
0.0034858249,
-0.4288964868,
-0.0741733462,
0.7367634773,
-0.469137311,
-0.679367125,
0.2152345628,
0.5514867902,
0.2297310233,
-0.238735646,
-0.5498055816,
-0.2299528718,
0.1728151441,
-0.161993891,
0.4925475717,
0.5285469294,
-0.0395217799,
0.6726202369,
0.7889187932,
0.2458189577,
0.0214673597,
0.1501070708,
0.937582016,
-0.6950840354,
-0.0297216531,
-0.7068189979,
0.1782938093,
0.0473125353,
-0.0472101197,
0.6547021866,
0.4139634073,
0.6816339493,
0.0176121239,
0.7806360126,
-0.1012595221,
0.5012712479,
-0.5997394323,
0.5599005222,
-1.0014845133,
0.3065960705,
0.0436997116,
-1.3659796715,
-0.4450216591,
0.4243712127,
-0.1947491318,
0.1876477599,
0.6711044312,
1.1486343145,
-0.0150686288,
-0.4915937781,
0.5657346249,
0.0524641387,
0.4107556045,
0.4441671371,
0.7953314185,
-0.4817045331,
0.6559866071,
-0.2255568355,
0.2938339114,
-0.2642300427,
-0.8351842761,
-0.7001721859,
-0.5538220406,
-0.448423326,
-0.3506653905,
0.1847922206,
0.6068131924,
0.7767981291,
-0.8266687989,
0.1100201085,
-0.1378424317,
0.0932766423,
0.6496883035,
-0.285313189,
0.0642610788,
-0.5049607754,
-0.809820652,
0.5887966156,
0.1824536026,
0.0123071093,
0.1086024642,
0.1178661063,
-0.4192033708,
0.2420868129,
0.6814724207,
0.2524582446,
-0.7480368018,
-0.2925791442,
0.0295297429,
-0.06631805,
0.0348107815,
0.8073458076,
-1.1508270502,
0.5658836365,
0.7765253782,
0.4248446226,
0.6137982607,
0.2323512137,
0.6873652339,
-1.2385549545,
0.1717865318,
0.3906750083,
-0.0535440817,
0.2724845111,
-0.4427409768,
0.6440520883,
0.0460042506,
-0.4476718009,
-1.0565686226,
0.3162680566,
-0.7381479144,
-0.4410072565,
1.365623951,
0.0957612991,
-0.3099824488,
0.0469079763,
-0.1827490479,
0.2401759624,
-0.468171984,
0.7217409611,
0.3823669851,
-0.3944431841,
0.176874429,
-0.5907892585,
0.2840981483,
0.6971324086,
-0.4368370771,
-0.2237701714,
0.6554999948,
0.3240427971,
0.2842814326,
0.605928719,
-0.1111542284,
0.1308549792,
-0.0499478281,
-0.0395676084,
0.1692921668,
-0.387686193,
0.2444562465,
0.4762685895,
0.2229941785,
-0.1896233261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07925v1
|
Brain-Driven Representation Learning Based on Diffusion Model
| 2023-11-14T05:59:58 | 2023-11-14T05:59:58 |
Soowon Kim, Seo-Hyun Lee, Young-Eun Lee, Ji-Won Lee, Ji-Ha Park, Seong-Whan Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Interpreting EEG signals linked to spoken language presents a complex
challenge, given the data's intricate temporal and spatial attributes, as well
as the various noise factors. Denoising diffusion probabilistic models (DDPMs),
which have recently gained prominence in diverse areas for their capabilities
in representation learning, are explored in our research as a means to address
this issue. Using DDPMs in conjunction with a conditional autoencoder, our new
approach considerably outperforms traditional machine learning algorithms and
established baseline models in accuracy. Our results highlight the potential of
DDPMs as a sophisticated computational method for the analysis of
speech-related EEG signals. This could lead to significant advances in
brain-computer interfaces tailored for spoken communication.
|
[
-0.1152021885,
-0.981798768,
0.8716154099,
0.4433877468,
-0.1955891103,
-0.1848075688,
-0.036282111,
-0.2023369372,
0.2325328887,
0.0643968582,
-0.4766580164,
-0.581630528,
-1.0103299618,
-0.1631412655,
-0.5553031564,
0.1418353468,
0.2217720002,
0.5061348081,
-0.1755634248,
0.1838273555,
-0.6545882225,
-0.184281826,
-1.2230788469,
-0.6391008496,
0.2198006213,
-0.3283890784,
0.369152844,
0.2998545766,
-0.1308802664,
0.2741106451,
-0.2256613076,
-0.1624655277,
-0.1759149432,
0.0973318815,
0.1094578654,
-0.5125200748,
-0.4912012517,
-0.0294041242,
0.7522968054,
1.2684676647,
-0.7418209314,
-0.3110575974,
0.1875868738,
0.5149847269,
-0.4894598424,
0.5840972662,
-0.4149399698,
0.2798042595,
0.1352057904,
0.1914764643,
-0.6255463362,
-0.1539895386,
0.1728464365,
-0.4007309079,
-0.0760879517,
-0.4129911363,
0.320741117,
0.1363150477,
-0.5452326536,
0.0090057524,
-0.697740376,
0.6180201173,
-0.5973578691,
0.625300467,
0.4028507769,
0.1900405437,
-0.3573619425,
-0.6832152605,
-0.7347767353,
-0.1764634699,
-0.1037242636,
0.3892725706,
-0.5463832617,
0.0622222833,
0.2187149972,
0.0817358047,
-0.5299289823,
0.3976368904,
-0.0989229232,
-0.1903453767,
0.5406343937,
0.1013254151,
0.2729476392,
-0.1972636282,
-0.1369127333,
0.023356095,
-0.4058480263,
-0.2581606507,
0.2945991755,
-0.1901050508,
-0.2578580379,
0.1750619859,
-0.0257981904,
1.0294052362,
0.4993287921,
0.3144881725,
0.3016903996,
0.3585293293,
-0.1693461686,
-0.0822492167,
0.6194954515,
0.3055430353,
0.2334949225,
-0.1545079201,
-0.3372532725,
0.0349525698,
0.0840762705,
-0.6577007174,
-0.6241959929,
0.141117394,
-0.7377055883,
0.1002292633,
-0.2561157048,
-0.7826259732,
-0.5427752733,
-0.4943257272,
0.4934058785,
-0.4633480906,
-0.926425159,
0.3012228608,
-0.2839464247,
-0.0535941124,
0.2732527852,
-0.8743723035,
0.2572814822,
0.1635561287,
0.9360986948,
-0.5423893929,
0.0468358919,
-0.2952260077,
0.3756550252,
-0.4817636609,
0.757966578,
-0.6812174916,
-0.7072823644,
-0.2469442338,
-0.2550637126,
-0.1136160344,
-0.8203948736,
0.1010345966,
-0.736489892,
0.0845546871,
-0.3635038733,
-0.6596016884,
-0.3231294453,
-0.399333179,
-0.605627358,
0.515211463,
0.2854480743,
-0.3853397369,
0.3682697713,
-0.5708176494,
-0.5718137026,
0.201540783,
-0.4303780198,
-0.3694467545,
0.1093004793,
0.1242047101,
0.6457214355,
0.2152319849,
0.4473621249,
-0.399366796,
-0.2203373909,
0.045254387,
-0.675745666,
0.8996804953,
0.4315286577,
-0.4246709943,
-0.2046313286,
-1.0757309198,
-0.2242941558,
0.2552039623,
-0.1795004159,
-0.4011349678,
0.3110586405,
-0.2976747751,
0.0512029231,
0.2278700322,
-0.5117205381,
-0.1004206166,
-0.4234218597,
0.6631923914,
0.7434052229,
0.2686739862,
0.663798213,
0.1494600475,
0.3748961389,
0.5060691833,
-0.0075877481,
0.0335010067,
-0.7867199183,
-0.4486590028,
-0.5131213665,
0.3674899936,
0.5126622319,
-0.4378728867,
0.6981114149,
-0.0553660616,
-0.3191816211,
-0.2815845013,
-0.3694447577,
-0.187497884,
0.7587336302,
0.5055878758,
-0.516444087,
-0.6152446866,
-0.9109859467,
0.102585867,
-0.2318175286,
-0.3491248488,
0.0928026065,
0.0358916782,
-0.6498686075,
1.1194506884,
-0.5688278079,
-0.0274874475,
-0.0108983107,
0.4759982228,
0.1519638598,
0.4727001786,
0.5155749321,
-0.8581380844,
-0.4086045325,
-0.299511373,
-0.7202353477,
-0.5002037883,
-0.1725419611,
0.3270326555,
-0.1308503151,
0.5151836276,
-0.5991247892,
0.702521801,
0.5829159617,
-0.1684619933,
0.4808670878,
-0.3575717807,
0.16103746,
-0.6005915403,
-0.2176298797,
0.0845904201,
-0.1579825431,
-0.6250934601,
-0.765570581,
-0.014049639,
-0.2859102786,
-0.0114502879,
0.4502847791,
-0.6456850171,
-0.2182391137,
-0.4919146597,
0.0810107812,
-0.1426905543,
0.3351500034,
0.4473754764,
0.5958195925,
1.1029045582,
-0.8185714483,
0.1232736111,
0.3902570009,
-0.2425568551,
0.7158939242,
-0.656940341,
0.0171746984,
-0.4561559558,
0.2203657627,
-1.2172766924,
0.169426322,
0.1089350134,
-0.3875802159,
0.468344152,
-0.2114926875,
-0.3626853824,
-0.0374481641,
0.3864292502,
0.1826372147,
0.9106992483,
-0.5153598785,
0.779473424,
0.7879391909,
-0.2154103816,
-0.1070863008,
-0.8471765518,
-0.0088763665,
0.0057427199,
-0.4518586099,
0.55967623,
-0.0821026266,
-0.168958053,
-0.1784079373,
-0.2093653232,
-0.3173012137,
-0.0054591573,
0.3650784791,
-0.1830510944,
0.227417469,
0.0088330638,
0.3245566785,
-0.1898258626,
0.4101093411,
-0.2898926735,
0.6145784259,
0.4883704185,
-0.5865213275,
-0.4531714022,
0.5027346611,
0.2711762786,
0.0587418005,
0.687975347,
0.7467013597,
-0.4965750277,
-0.3544583917,
-0.2800184786,
-0.4196450114,
-0.5142963529,
0.4624930322,
-0.3410859406,
-0.5686520338,
0.5806781054,
-0.3806975484,
-0.3669574261,
0.3443134725,
0.690518856,
-0.3571212292,
1.4019474983,
0.5764608979,
0.0407219753,
0.8210043907,
-0.1944068223,
0.1646851003,
-0.5420178771,
-0.3777870536,
0.0798970386,
-0.3746343553,
-0.2379290164,
-0.2694972754,
0.4983389378,
0.0347058959,
0.080186978,
0.016235698,
-0.4336859286,
0.10936369,
0.3953401446,
0.4238672256,
-0.0357331857,
0.2641207278,
-0.4303504527,
-0.1102600247,
-0.7355724573,
-0.1837764233,
0.9758403897,
0.1442785263,
0.7161553502,
-0.0745274872,
0.5556553602,
0.7539637685,
0.0001250528,
-0.1949686408,
0.7985514998,
0.1101160049,
-0.1637748033,
-0.0687136874,
-0.5281699896,
-1.2595179081,
0.2671183646,
-0.191078499,
-0.7271393538,
0.7009189725,
0.1405132264,
-0.3611731529,
0.2932565808,
-1.0158445835,
0.5503876209,
0.1939278543,
-0.1601786911,
-0.7857538462,
-0.4511708319,
0.0612457991,
0.0557427816,
0.1756135076,
0.1437163353,
0.0340652131,
0.8720276952,
0.1230153218,
1.1903171539,
-0.7689971924,
-0.2529658675,
0.3134000897,
0.2130426466,
0.2961058319,
0.1893514246,
-0.1565135419,
0.6130905151,
-0.0550624356,
-0.3626202047,
-0.529763341,
0.7395405769,
-0.6383025646,
-0.5240913033,
-0.2626143992,
-0.215258643,
-0.2487066686,
0.1602733731,
0.1722801626,
0.3095263541,
-0.3130860329,
-0.4024138451,
1.0038661957,
-0.2375682592,
0.625489831,
0.587801218,
-0.1363573372,
-0.3832692802,
0.670483768,
0.4001399875,
-0.0659583062,
0.2882454693,
-0.0338863544,
-0.2465164661,
-1.0428419113,
-0.1602048874,
0.2441462576,
-0.7847555876,
0.1824331731,
-0.7516947985,
-0.17282179,
-0.3726827502,
0.1974951774,
-0.1024783403,
-0.3933858573,
-0.7337036729,
-0.2320259511,
-0.069143489,
0.7672560215,
-0.5795794725,
0.5827331543,
-0.5982491374,
0.554957509,
0.6441995502,
0.4281393588,
0.0740946755,
-0.5434787273,
-0.249009341,
0.2258911431,
-0.2752351165,
-1.3293440342,
0.4270645082,
0.0639442056,
0.9026060104,
0.5681772232,
-0.3086973727,
0.6143407822,
-0.7848995924,
0.8739808798,
0.2586474419,
-0.9315481186,
0.5780397654,
-0.288797766,
0.075158596,
-0.0425541773,
0.4598104358,
-0.4085443914,
0.0489101484,
-0.8185178638,
-0.5540782213,
0.1213309988,
0.1067509204,
0.0288126878,
-0.358951956,
0.7676128745,
0.2336596549,
0.2376718521,
-0.6394885778,
-0.4363390803,
-0.0661297813,
-0.2674112916,
-0.0075252131,
-0.4924122691,
0.1600207835,
-0.4924473763,
0.3105071485,
0.293299675,
0.7853881717,
0.2315018624,
-0.3300468028,
-0.0682678446,
-0.0540652759,
0.3045455515,
0.7980814576,
-0.0283349864,
0.0191300083,
0.0566706657,
-0.6421961188,
0.2457891405,
0.0764257312,
-0.3112508655,
0.2337806225,
0.1221155897,
0.8160142899,
-0.2027276307,
-0.5556288958,
0.5494143963,
0.1016808972,
-0.1550804079,
-0.5654616356,
0.1020512208,
0.1258267462,
0.3418538868,
0.4586426318,
0.2431610376,
0.3328151703,
0.0633796304,
0.4598059654,
0.6047708392,
-0.2907721698,
-0.7052874565,
0.7413614392,
0.1187321916,
-0.3141680062,
0.5886425972,
-0.3127873838,
-0.1696723551,
0.3896538913,
0.3776585758,
0.8929891586,
-0.4518232942,
0.1637141407,
0.2639583945,
0.1371309906,
-0.0998924822,
0.4447505474,
-0.2202201337,
-0.7845147848,
-0.5138213038,
-0.5103194118,
-0.248183459,
0.0624007098,
-0.4812615514,
0.1763307601,
-0.4260517955,
-0.5248765945,
-0.1446298659,
-0.3818014562,
-0.4283902645,
0.3517230153,
0.5947774053,
0.6192443371,
-1.1717466116,
0.9010036588,
0.453933239,
-0.0536208041,
-0.1415418833,
-0.0994146541,
-0.3530519903,
-0.6896762252,
0.7828498483,
-0.155836314,
-0.0706457347,
0.4994372725,
-0.5296604037,
-0.6249941587,
0.8401548266,
0.6518160105,
-0.700135231,
0.1000543833,
-0.1265538484,
0.3772659004,
-0.2829772532,
0.2995539606,
0.7063840628,
0.5285211205,
-0.3893589377,
-0.5472946167,
-0.3359324038,
0.0038084327,
-0.0011745349,
-0.0959772244,
-0.3456465602,
0.8483756781,
0.0596422479,
-0.3096833229,
-0.5034717321,
0.9300028086,
0.0770637244,
0.1800971329,
0.7220371962,
0.7388800383,
0.7933037281,
-0.0426936448,
0.5017023683,
0.0221069846,
0.1305063963,
0.6863816977,
-0.4978199005,
0.6567641497,
0.4650380015,
-0.5622433424,
1.1095740795,
0.6553500891,
0.0452261791,
0.9612939954,
0.3043006659,
-0.4179581702,
-0.4116461873,
0.6525386572,
-0.0500533059,
0.2821136117,
0.7418036461,
-0.1657485962,
-0.2399969995,
0.4468366206,
-0.5977301002,
0.1953199655,
-0.3117088377,
0.903072238,
0.1908182353,
-0.1468800753,
0.4507881105,
-0.0767876133,
0.749759078,
-0.6363666058,
-0.3286685348,
-0.1122218817,
-0.1551914215,
-0.0364388153,
-0.445546627,
0.3754526079,
-0.4256532788,
-0.4150695205,
-0.4285069406,
0.6445031166,
-0.4219494462,
-0.1268558055,
0.4956908226,
0.4407003522,
0.035000179,
-0.1986084282,
-0.6805752516,
-0.127692163,
-0.1473968625,
-0.2741838992,
0.4000617862,
0.3204101026,
0.1976507604,
0.8053663373,
0.3064190447,
0.3868814707,
0.3802334666,
0.0479848683,
0.5040819049,
-0.5487020612,
-0.7635771632,
-0.9663118124,
0.3902858794,
-0.2147880048,
0.4245276451,
0.6729518175,
0.4152935147,
0.5291567445,
-0.1776245981,
0.8200742602,
-0.014694239,
0.4839780927,
-0.6257840395,
0.8133562803,
-0.098243922,
0.3565989435,
0.0543026403,
-0.5939377546,
0.018217396,
0.8241317868,
-0.4549477696,
0.2924471498,
0.5090585947,
0.6053263545,
-0.2154859602,
0.1232509613,
0.5124181509,
0.3552326262,
0.1748849005,
0.4966982007,
0.7866541743,
-0.220230341,
0.0946431756,
-0.0422872752,
-0.5262880325,
0.1121219024,
-0.8464002609,
-0.664612174,
-0.887088418,
-0.8279105425,
-0.0797780156,
-0.0908040777,
0.3864289522,
0.8754113913,
-0.8137149811,
-0.2310144603,
-0.3809627891,
0.0265758038,
-0.5658665895,
-0.1742095947,
0.4199242592,
-0.1584380865,
-0.7941862345,
0.6749324799,
0.3451156616,
0.3733708262,
-0.4912137985,
0.0117444191,
-0.0329241343,
0.0921239778,
0.6488373876,
-0.0231193677,
-0.4294312894,
-0.0157084968,
-0.244869262,
0.0966942981,
0.1690574884,
0.5599325895,
-1.1521749496,
0.4240246713,
0.4489236772,
0.4349858165,
0.7207030058,
-0.330735594,
0.6471549273,
-0.8031557798,
0.3655730784,
0.31490466,
0.5782090425,
0.3676817417,
-0.2726010978,
-0.0008858397,
0.5048336983,
-0.4637278616,
-0.5965925455,
0.4219303131,
-0.9391229749,
-0.5382181406,
1.1447328329,
0.009087244,
-0.1659120619,
-0.306573838,
-0.0411707982,
0.3936833739,
-0.1629897356,
0.8721478581,
0.6348101497,
-0.2807907462,
-0.3302224278,
-0.5088341832,
0.3456982076,
0.5527091026,
-0.3971528709,
0.1181860939,
0.764585197,
0.5009374619,
-0.0621593669,
0.7925985456,
0.0546893254,
0.1769222915,
0.0397283956,
0.1529645026,
0.1371299177,
-0.0751221925,
-0.8125460744,
0.2385564744,
-0.0409654006,
-0.3680952191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07919v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07919v2
|
Qwen-Audio: Advancing Universal Audio Understanding via Unified Large-Scale Audio-Language Models
| 2023-11-14T05:34:50 | 2023-12-21T10:20:42 |
Yunfei Chu, Jin Xu, Xiaohuan Zhou, Qian Yang, Shiliang Zhang, Zhijie Yan, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recently, instruction-following audio-language models have received broad
attention for audio interaction with humans. However, the absence of
pre-trained audio models capable of handling diverse audio types and tasks has
hindered progress in this field. Consequently, most existing works have only
been able to support a limited range of interaction capabilities. In this
paper, we develop the Qwen-Audio model and address this limitation by scaling
up audio-language pre-training to cover over 30 tasks and various audio types,
such as human speech, natural sounds, music, and songs, to facilitate universal
audio understanding abilities. However, directly co-training all tasks and
datasets can lead to interference issues, as the textual labels associated with
different datasets exhibit considerable variations due to differences in task
focus, language, granularity of annotation, and text structure. To overcome the
one-to-many interference, we carefully design a multi-task training framework
by conditioning on a sequence of hierarchical tags to the decoder for
encouraging knowledge sharing and avoiding interference through shared and
specified tags respectively. Remarkably, Qwen-Audio achieves impressive
performance across diverse benchmark tasks without requiring any task-specific
fine-tuning, surpassing its counterparts. Building upon the capabilities of
Qwen-Audio, we further develop Qwen-Audio-Chat, which allows for input from
various audios and text inputs, enabling multi-turn dialogues and supporting
various audio-central scenarios.
|
[
-0.5914679766,
-0.3465447128,
0.4304053485,
0.2993924022,
0.0016763568,
-0.0073786429,
-0.3770026565,
-0.7629070878,
0.0061706048,
0.5253801346,
-0.9385429025,
-0.7313337922,
-0.599701643,
-0.1649232209,
-0.3340123296,
0.7815917134,
0.2163051516,
-0.0143764094,
0.0158313476,
-0.5446121693,
-0.5720498562,
-0.3778274953,
-0.5470596552,
-0.2026469857,
0.5038154721,
0.4952612519,
0.6013549566,
0.2497448772,
0.4474813044,
0.2795545459,
0.1814500988,
0.2366153896,
-0.4143429101,
0.0894827172,
0.0136683499,
-0.2671699226,
-0.785217762,
-0.0393854082,
0.5034478903,
0.718968749,
-0.1118472219,
0.3516272306,
0.1023101136,
0.3214375675,
-0.3429757357,
-0.0675863475,
-0.5064242482,
-0.0405169129,
-0.0679510012,
-0.1104843915,
-0.2176859677,
0.3597621322,
0.4032826126,
-1.3292933702,
0.1709638089,
0.1320848763,
0.6319887042,
0.3741180003,
-0.3589105308,
-0.1215191036,
-0.9217858911,
0.9236567616,
-0.5581003428,
0.6744475365,
0.5086638927,
0.3022740483,
-0.12784338,
-0.6825076342,
-0.4622621238,
0.0036487055,
0.3071450889,
0.0452168919,
-0.2556454539,
0.5524202585,
0.1808653325,
0.2536581159,
-0.5091480613,
0.1703052223,
0.0470980294,
-0.2888287008,
0.6066983342,
-0.0553026013,
0.6207840443,
-0.0038125599,
-0.2959174812,
-0.028033819,
-0.4908393025,
0.0046937009,
0.28283903,
0.2107971758,
-0.0269606598,
0.0965017751,
-0.1711993366,
0.5154305696,
0.0622599311,
-0.2857804298,
0.131224975,
-0.455010891,
-0.2580516934,
0.1595651954,
0.9526026845,
0.1561421603,
-0.0433485731,
-0.4689062238,
0.0081731379,
-0.0493064001,
0.0957825333,
-0.8196391463,
-0.2980954051,
0.4030848145,
-0.1173129752,
0.0203656256,
-0.1956647635,
-0.1762980521,
-0.2420928776,
-0.4426212907,
0.9926903248,
-0.4386644959,
-0.5391651988,
0.4434429109,
-0.0545424186,
-0.3170630932,
0.3808296323,
-0.9558470845,
0.2966014147,
0.4097940326,
0.5463359952,
0.0772186667,
-0.4151693881,
-0.6374607086,
0.3905695081,
0.0219620522,
0.4934357703,
-0.3079636097,
-0.4638409913,
-0.343867451,
-0.2421750724,
0.0973615348,
-0.3962991536,
0.655472517,
-0.4129990041,
0.3411906958,
-0.0350024998,
-0.6473500133,
-0.3106766343,
-0.081654653,
-0.5823997855,
0.6324936748,
0.0655553415,
-0.9235708117,
0.341229707,
-0.9021443129,
-0.4104994833,
0.1572633535,
-0.2431291938,
-0.3386311829,
-0.1156659499,
0.3123408556,
0.3718535006,
-0.4599949121,
0.6841543913,
-0.2271974087,
-0.6290860772,
-0.0505566448,
-0.596382618,
0.6677262187,
-0.0922168195,
-0.5034763217,
0.4592950046,
-0.9243953824,
-0.1054205224,
-0.1721610725,
-0.171509102,
-0.3372898102,
-0.0707318261,
0.5317790508,
0.1747630984,
0.001969029,
-0.825353682,
-0.0869700164,
-0.1429497749,
0.5431610346,
0.3042169809,
-0.2258911133,
0.615896225,
-0.4051660895,
0.377679497,
-0.1415937394,
0.1544233263,
-0.3939565718,
-0.2395661324,
-0.1975848973,
-0.4545591176,
0.3978752494,
0.4787899852,
-0.4183470607,
0.5210383534,
-0.3536873162,
-0.336638391,
-1.1561061144,
0.3697912991,
0.4467159212,
0.4788963497,
0.5507371426,
-0.1916529685,
-0.8600096703,
-0.5408792496,
-0.0860000327,
0.0258185547,
-0.6850686073,
0.3516053259,
-0.0119555853,
-0.5458599329,
1.0630247593,
-0.0538773797,
-0.4940383434,
-0.1434965879,
0.3653303087,
0.145413816,
0.7050136328,
0.3094346821,
-0.8388000727,
-0.1775440723,
0.0338624232,
-0.5601114631,
-0.0452377163,
-0.2255237699,
-0.3006648421,
-0.3419291079,
0.564019382,
-0.6462396979,
0.0916264728,
0.7870622277,
-0.1109990627,
0.6142027974,
-0.1441008598,
0.2771386802,
-1.2330946922,
-0.1010605246,
0.0586717986,
-0.2677282989,
-0.7225515246,
-0.2330889255,
-0.0413094684,
-0.0384062938,
-0.3221059442,
0.4211698472,
-0.258497566,
-0.0799627304,
-0.2025541067,
0.3685063422,
0.3871642649,
0.6081117988,
0.097954534,
0.7826018333,
0.6548999548,
-0.5459661484,
0.3978862762,
0.2961957753,
-0.3879606724,
0.6798271537,
-0.8051902056,
0.1378666312,
0.1401863396,
0.2698512375,
-1.0156031847,
-0.2842301726,
-0.2028131336,
-0.5933243036,
0.3424123228,
-0.1699941307,
-0.4113911688,
-0.1934902072,
0.0119446339,
0.6206352115,
0.3428762257,
-0.8515979648,
0.7646308541,
0.4102371931,
-0.1200594231,
-0.5461347103,
-0.3199626803,
0.1209088489,
-0.3325088918,
-0.8094978333,
0.5407277942,
-0.279229939,
-0.0342597961,
-0.0503717698,
-0.5074789524,
-0.2797016203,
0.029788509,
0.5245722532,
0.2256124169,
-0.3203816116,
0.3715554178,
0.1622340977,
0.0262593739,
0.0058763605,
-0.800796628,
0.3547751009,
0.1303329021,
-0.2826061249,
-0.8610832095,
0.5890597701,
0.7297416329,
-0.3948880434,
0.2391051203,
0.9215605855,
-0.0105908429,
0.0061041,
-0.396561116,
0.0066891792,
-0.5161073208,
0.7678055763,
-0.4617983997,
-1.2436254025,
0.1823573112,
-0.2951001525,
0.5115860701,
0.1351750791,
0.1227209494,
-0.6956331134,
1.2369500399,
0.6532461047,
-0.1816888899,
0.6710867882,
-0.1996510476,
-0.1199558526,
-0.9508396983,
0.0165917613,
-0.2153341472,
-0.2021758109,
-0.4407229424,
-0.2577364147,
0.3483727872,
0.2184416801,
-0.4665876925,
0.5762173533,
-0.2336239517,
0.3278978765,
0.5692783594,
0.1742532402,
0.2730055153,
-0.1629309058,
0.08836364,
0.1250994354,
-0.6944084167,
-0.0897900388,
1.0898118019,
0.5220631361,
0.611543417,
-0.0394051522,
0.8125488758,
0.1862177104,
0.0832990184,
-0.6900595427,
0.1503112316,
-0.078773953,
-0.6207850575,
-0.8410304189,
-0.5916590691,
-0.9739513993,
0.6121488214,
-0.1999174356,
-0.6392074823,
-0.1376980841,
0.1159424707,
-0.4842239022,
0.3652542233,
-0.7355449796,
0.9332854152,
-0.0875613466,
-0.064146623,
-0.2410887182,
-0.6980969906,
0.3443238735,
0.0979772955,
0.6554934382,
-0.4613344371,
0.3036033809,
0.8242693543,
0.1504174024,
0.6958281398,
-0.2316227853,
-0.3971870244,
0.2296438366,
0.1111577675,
-0.1251871288,
0.3174962103,
0.3397829831,
0.1958892345,
0.1564572752,
-0.5590583086,
-0.4265881479,
0.3013886511,
-1.0520672798,
-0.5253540277,
0.3893723786,
-1.1466966867,
-0.6858714819,
0.1915362775,
0.4041481614,
1.0281467438,
-0.3455777168,
0.1484789848,
0.829575479,
-0.0336501636,
0.3452911973,
0.4012313485,
-0.354239285,
-0.3524267673,
1.0106345415,
-0.156438157,
0.3456420004,
0.4626600742,
-0.0125373155,
-0.1803644001,
-0.3084517121,
-0.4377827346,
-0.0122654019,
-0.3342722058,
-0.0322191529,
-0.8457637429,
0.1610083729,
-0.2923555374,
0.1330306232,
-0.4922536612,
-0.232603088,
-0.2936959267,
0.0629676804,
0.2868051231,
0.6648617983,
-0.2296096832,
0.6384646297,
-1.2892403603,
0.723828733,
0.7304407954,
0.4373572171,
0.0643768683,
-0.8372006416,
-0.5145751238,
0.1668517292,
-0.0239043981,
-0.6713379025,
0.0375113077,
0.3223923743,
0.4406253099,
0.4216361642,
0.022374671,
0.551856339,
-0.4856695831,
0.2848953009,
0.5961594582,
-1.1127172709,
0.2545830905,
-0.6975659728,
0.4309346378,
0.5524860024,
0.2961284518,
-0.792703867,
-0.3619530499,
-0.5511397719,
-0.8600903749,
0.5709095597,
0.162869826,
0.1390244514,
0.4941348732,
0.0043054582,
0.0559261814,
0.1089908853,
-0.3670299947,
-0.0517346114,
-0.274002403,
-0.3321070373,
-0.091243811,
0.1129007787,
-0.2171646059,
-0.6092130542,
0.36494115,
-0.0393189639,
0.0574778542,
0.1621641964,
-0.3673157096,
0.01098713,
0.4878770411,
0.3404075205,
0.2705313861,
-0.2453470975,
0.0741865486,
0.0726980418,
-0.6762236357,
0.335793972,
0.1039127484,
0.4620455801,
0.014588261,
0.4557372928,
1.0803842545,
0.7377439141,
-0.5934770703,
0.3071611226,
-0.3689029217,
-0.4846957326,
-0.0238518231,
0.1554750353,
0.6305499673,
0.210678637,
0.3511502743,
0.1669862121,
0.3181026578,
-0.4151774347,
0.4277593791,
0.0364099778,
-0.5153713226,
-0.3715071678,
0.6441355348,
0.5951832533,
-0.1804309934,
0.4972878098,
-0.3059653044,
-0.3851074874,
0.5138904452,
0.4200665951,
0.7490270734,
-0.2239540815,
0.1320733279,
0.2409225702,
0.023561772,
0.0785069466,
0.2383594811,
-0.679600358,
-0.7015980482,
-0.7550895214,
-0.5032279491,
-0.5834679604,
0.0018675412,
-0.8832547069,
-0.2624713182,
-0.0702294409,
-0.2541221976,
0.0213351306,
-0.0881398842,
-0.7866776586,
0.2940951288,
0.1326081157,
0.6588796377,
-0.5595351458,
1.0374865532,
0.4781496227,
-0.2691135406,
-0.8979147673,
0.1265838146,
-0.1614911258,
-0.4476181567,
0.4584315121,
0.2108750641,
-0.2557758093,
0.353305757,
-0.5466077924,
-0.756375432,
1.0125000477,
0.2284016311,
-1.1525961161,
-0.2449932396,
-0.1394765377,
0.2478707582,
-0.2166414559,
0.0756500959,
0.8907372952,
0.3786882162,
0.0783188641,
-1.253682375,
-0.414824456,
-0.1457286924,
-0.3032216132,
0.2937073112,
-0.1805636287,
0.679058075,
-0.2732493579,
-0.1092095375,
-0.0621923991,
0.7795383334,
0.1848903298,
0.2656857371,
0.775537312,
0.4369663298,
0.8326556087,
-0.0157871097,
0.7672913671,
-0.1399497539,
0.1798068136,
1.3674696684,
-0.1309222281,
0.707013607,
0.2957503796,
-0.2807414532,
0.1596593857,
0.350230962,
0.2262370139,
0.4284930229,
0.1921177357,
-0.6633743048,
-0.5616397858,
-0.3847531974,
-0.2175935358,
0.5242626667,
0.3469955325,
0.553888917,
0.0014661389,
0.4914176762,
-0.2175775319,
-0.0837172717,
-0.4219362438,
0.7448289394,
0.1147585437,
0.0035876383,
0.3218470812,
-0.446965903,
1.2942525148,
-0.5129984021,
0.0146966707,
0.2041082084,
-0.2200640589,
-0.2482080013,
-0.6428032517,
-0.0680222064,
-0.1113581508,
-0.3103735149,
0.0577490889,
0.5306932926,
-0.815079391,
0.0031408099,
0.6717210412,
0.429841429,
-0.1722718477,
-0.5245918036,
-0.3365528584,
0.0622026138,
-0.1861398816,
-0.0879091695,
0.4601585269,
0.556776166,
0.2094893456,
0.3237873316,
0.6783554554,
-0.0376670174,
-0.0191620979,
0.5428304076,
0.5010070205,
-0.451172024,
-0.6182382703,
-0.3466960192,
0.4004484713,
0.0603722595,
-0.1883907467,
0.4242960215,
0.0481441915,
1.0582745075,
0.1998449564,
0.9905341268,
0.2318731248,
0.5345997214,
-0.2303688079,
0.8820935488,
-0.5880094767,
-0.1025608033,
-0.3716457784,
-0.558401227,
-0.1286022514,
0.384586513,
0.0519550703,
-0.0635866076,
0.2506886125,
0.245339036,
-0.0711852685,
0.3419280052,
0.7524753213,
0.0429456346,
0.3129132688,
0.6847558618,
0.8468307257,
-0.4162526727,
0.7491692901,
-0.184951961,
-0.0911635458,
-0.0144794891,
-0.4437512755,
-0.8658183217,
-0.6373177767,
-0.1718767285,
-0.0569271222,
-0.0915137604,
1.1416578293,
1.1358581781,
-0.7313353419,
-0.4363895059,
-0.0620385818,
-0.0463805757,
-0.1363301724,
-0.1292169243,
0.2827045321,
-0.332139343,
-0.6771828532,
0.7056878209,
0.3494716883,
0.0296353623,
-0.1602891237,
-0.2771166265,
0.1767064184,
-0.0300756693,
0.6552855372,
0.4255180955,
-0.5314313173,
-0.252654165,
-0.0156143773,
-0.1042992249,
0.2442469895,
0.7763805985,
-0.4126802087,
0.5314802527,
0.1501013935,
0.7658017278,
0.4778401554,
-0.265039295,
0.7291136384,
-0.852771461,
0.158013925,
0.1635526419,
0.3285706341,
0.2943808436,
-0.2228077501,
-0.0403322019,
-0.038918186,
-0.6502177715,
-0.6590797305,
0.2844589353,
-1.0104174614,
-0.2994394898,
0.8178576827,
-0.3216955066,
0.0622239895,
-0.4700308144,
-0.6534996629,
0.6714282632,
-0.3413848281,
0.4166823924,
0.560249567,
-0.07267946,
-0.185675472,
-0.7158896923,
0.4954578876,
0.4846483767,
-0.7587369084,
0.1720840484,
0.3113447726,
0.3137380183,
0.0383811891,
0.7211109996,
0.0517985746,
0.6877560616,
0.0205456782,
0.4479255974,
-0.1602704376,
-0.6523650885,
-0.2886547744,
0.0726442784,
0.1403237283,
-0.6601760387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07918v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07918v1
|
Automated title and abstract screening for scoping reviews using the GPT-4 Large Language Model
| 2023-11-14T05:30:43 | 2023-11-14T05:30:43 |
David Wilkins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scoping reviews, a type of literature review, require intensive human effort
to screen large numbers of scholarly sources for their relevance to the review
objectives. This manuscript introduces GPTscreenR, a package for the R
statistical programming language that uses the GPT-4 Large Language Model (LLM)
to automatically screen sources. The package makes use of the chain-of-thought
technique with the goal of maximising performance on complex screening tasks.
In validation against consensus human reviewer decisions, GPTscreenR performed
similarly to an alternative zero-shot technique, with a sensitivity of 71%,
specificity of 89%, and overall accuracy of 84%. Neither method achieved
perfect accuracy nor human levels of intraobserver agreement. GPTscreenR
demonstrates the potential for LLMs to support scholarly work and provides a
user-friendly software framework that can be integrated into existing review
processes.
|
[
-0.3716674149,
-0.3242537081,
0.7922774553,
0.277087599,
-0.466948688,
0.2141557485,
-0.1244370937,
-0.227401197,
0.038570486,
0.6580136418,
-0.158155188,
-0.6087411642,
-0.7053047419,
0.42536515,
-0.496932447,
1.4538506269,
-0.440677464,
0.2095209956,
0.2898519337,
0.0705950037,
0.0386471301,
-0.2931440473,
-0.3174742162,
-0.4620488286,
0.6111764908,
0.214085266,
0.6141812205,
0.1810198724,
0.8499927521,
0.2912842631,
0.0815132856,
-0.1151094064,
-0.4242507219,
0.2717328072,
-0.5687561035,
-0.1629460752,
-0.5285271406,
0.0432815365,
0.7109793425,
0.212984398,
-0.291146934,
0.3764916062,
0.187223658,
0.5089259148,
-0.4612491727,
0.2692942023,
-0.416539073,
0.2185065895,
-0.1789992452,
-0.4997438788,
-0.3663752079,
-0.4977831244,
0.0968766212,
-0.3740350604,
0.1488631964,
-0.0825175568,
0.6032742858,
0.0749054849,
-0.61603719,
-0.4859977663,
-0.6510159373,
0.6841354966,
-0.5014114976,
0.0364221521,
0.5358487964,
0.4335814714,
-0.1047708169,
-0.5767822862,
-0.5224659443,
-0.5321724415,
-0.0258290302,
0.0241405498,
0.0913664922,
0.4483139217,
0.3227231205,
0.443479985,
-0.6592875123,
-0.3307826221,
-0.8015756607,
-0.3632999063,
0.5213776231,
0.1653997302,
0.2769647539,
-0.2262626737,
-0.1532647312,
0.0933044627,
-0.4940780699,
-0.2753816843,
0.2188717574,
0.0210135095,
-0.0048346519,
0.8168939352,
-0.5541367531,
0.6594743133,
-0.2527171373,
-0.0251752157,
-0.006826736,
-0.4877866805,
-0.2124210894,
-0.2625166774,
0.617187202,
0.7042389512,
0.1264421493,
0.3425191939,
-0.5414292216,
0.2731586695,
0.2248504609,
-0.7925266027,
-0.1742818207,
0.1836914569,
-0.3767583668,
-0.50194031,
0.0877563953,
-0.7420333624,
-0.2260805666,
-0.2093271911,
0.1732578129,
-0.0918357968,
-0.058899276,
-0.0753380209,
-0.0518092811,
0.1914338768,
0.3714837432,
-0.476495266,
0.3878450096,
0.4407767653,
0.9602774382,
-0.2858498991,
-0.2445017099,
-0.7341493964,
0.2933782041,
-0.3803544044,
0.9685686231,
-0.4254052341,
-0.4654636383,
0.2192910612,
-0.221222654,
0.0225017034,
-0.0256443191,
0.6862815619,
-0.6659907103,
0.3108972609,
-0.1511599123,
-0.3134434223,
0.0936056897,
0.4811608493,
-0.6253812909,
0.7429605126,
0.3260089457,
-1.0797590017,
0.5717735291,
-0.7589710951,
-0.1895626932,
0.3575810492,
-0.6075798869,
-0.3819218278,
-0.201132834,
0.2458608001,
0.1730056554,
-0.0875024572,
0.4413095713,
-0.3041927516,
-0.5306034088,
0.1045121327,
-0.121971257,
0.4822846353,
0.5977603793,
-0.5180757642,
0.585842371,
-0.289904207,
0.1806743592,
-0.2793557942,
-0.4589091241,
-0.0928095579,
-0.077111721,
0.338323921,
0.2511892915,
-0.2254454494,
-0.4265012443,
0.2804597616,
-0.0138910059,
0.4900048077,
0.563580811,
0.2136389613,
0.4454696178,
-0.2066040039,
0.8126011491,
-0.238825798,
0.2260561734,
-0.3667742014,
-0.4835239053,
-0.315597266,
-0.1875716895,
0.1851182282,
0.3742544949,
-0.9094960093,
0.2665907145,
-0.0576438233,
-0.1888436824,
0.0135405678,
0.011644695,
0.672201395,
0.1484456211,
-0.056980744,
-0.4149041474,
-0.5558385253,
-0.7865950465,
-0.2060991526,
-0.4194793999,
-0.3199393451,
-0.0185294822,
0.7532568574,
-0.3320190012,
0.906188786,
-0.5653104782,
-0.6442436576,
-0.4262233377,
0.1423559785,
0.2444409579,
0.0839904249,
0.1023721173,
-0.526055634,
-0.4634312689,
0.0970687866,
-0.8682245016,
-0.3675363958,
0.1004683822,
0.1063213125,
0.5048640966,
0.5492078066,
-0.6295114756,
0.4633883238,
0.5169130564,
-0.2491685897,
0.5850346088,
-0.4119170904,
0.404406935,
-0.5825965405,
0.2624151111,
0.4067412913,
-0.0395863801,
-0.3171630204,
0.2590607405,
-0.086763449,
-0.2541335821,
-0.1076114476,
0.4257260263,
-0.632666409,
-0.2310014665,
-0.2362464517,
0.2489968836,
0.0534707196,
0.0619818009,
0.0404596813,
0.8330945373,
0.1113923043,
-0.3763700724,
0.0935638174,
0.1460218579,
-0.505048275,
0.7189919949,
-0.5653935075,
0.0437849537,
-0.1392455548,
0.960965097,
-1.077878952,
-0.6252682805,
0.2868869603,
-0.1431258768,
0.1694477648,
-0.3170929551,
-0.074820824,
-0.7160450816,
-0.7208714485,
0.3465985954,
0.0084427372,
-0.1297291815,
0.6817070842,
0.8718217611,
-0.5855915546,
-0.478418529,
-0.5868330598,
0.3128465116,
0.0120610548,
-0.3107589483,
0.1962795705,
0.1729414314,
-0.4074697793,
-0.1458460391,
-0.1534005851,
-0.1273815632,
-0.8050319552,
0.0503474958,
0.5422970653,
0.1346479952,
-0.1888203472,
-0.25576213,
-0.2231127024,
0.0390354842,
-0.1845353097,
0.2232655883,
-0.1887768656,
-0.4953136444,
-0.2709271908,
0.3637459874,
0.5872234106,
0.0836843327,
-0.3476954401,
0.3916446269,
-0.1010189429,
-0.0773806423,
-0.7950674295,
-0.2432469726,
-0.3952225745,
0.5956864953,
-0.4048519135,
-0.949260354,
0.4797514975,
0.5067221522,
-0.1344487965,
0.2405991107,
0.6846479177,
-0.0651596263,
0.92168957,
0.5836091042,
-0.2634048462,
0.4036619961,
-0.0484326854,
0.4780728817,
-0.8869669437,
0.0659013167,
-0.5494073629,
0.0029183838,
-0.674806416,
-0.6625686884,
0.5911280513,
-0.4167359769,
-0.3151237667,
-0.0301178861,
-0.8618862033,
0.7069078088,
0.3015737534,
-0.014093752,
0.5402550697,
0.1284798533,
-0.2589293718,
-0.0499425456,
-0.3564489186,
-0.8201873302,
1.2599833012,
0.4491170049,
0.8225414157,
-0.4185582697,
0.518925488,
0.4471448064,
0.827033937,
-0.3238560557,
0.764921248,
0.156335488,
-0.9483353496,
-0.5293355584,
-0.2075121105,
-0.5176864266,
0.46452263,
0.218494013,
-0.6259132028,
-0.1304032505,
0.2461764514,
-0.3791072369,
0.3952594995,
-0.4977843761,
0.3633292019,
-0.1409428269,
-0.249820143,
-0.2938174009,
-0.6047105193,
0.8108483553,
-0.1547203064,
0.4289566278,
-0.038032461,
0.0945829973,
0.6807147264,
-0.4081512988,
0.6731798053,
-0.3162940443,
-0.1537160575,
0.5475255251,
0.1854349077,
0.6137618423,
0.0610615239,
0.0709237531,
0.2074596137,
0.1572036296,
-0.1399051994,
-0.0302454121,
0.7394735813,
-0.4339547753,
-0.4651417136,
-1.1182814837,
-0.4514742196,
-0.0792427883,
0.2599894702,
0.203799367,
0.1123827994,
-0.200815767,
-0.1425938457,
0.0718067065,
-0.2715888917,
0.1533971876,
0.3025318384,
-0.8589220643,
-0.7669485807,
0.4308707118,
0.2735141814,
0.132791549,
-0.0111557879,
0.0300320704,
-0.4052218497,
-0.695453465,
-0.6193568707,
0.2366645187,
-0.5296791792,
-0.2215078175,
-0.6543874741,
-0.2268739045,
0.0193483252,
0.0680797771,
0.2045792639,
-0.1901320219,
0.5572764874,
-0.3361000419,
0.2538694441,
0.9384217262,
-0.0367798507,
0.2471600622,
-0.3957718313,
0.285759151,
0.157793656,
0.8285895586,
-0.3308343291,
-0.42134884,
-0.213968575,
-0.2177898586,
-0.4944849014,
-0.592192471,
0.2703326344,
0.0585815609,
0.3969422281,
0.3173201382,
0.0213921163,
0.2744056284,
-0.4237331152,
0.7963245511,
0.1348729879,
-0.7007836699,
0.4885397851,
-0.9461969137,
0.4164939523,
0.7730065584,
0.2466000468,
-0.4274126291,
-0.5229562521,
0.071808733,
-0.9353544712,
0.7061884403,
0.2300997823,
-0.1750638932,
-0.1090339422,
-0.0384242795,
-0.1653227955,
0.1700302362,
-0.6879981756,
0.4358088672,
-0.0431003086,
0.186793521,
-0.1261498481,
-0.5049881339,
-0.5497492552,
0.060645707,
0.6371842623,
-0.3309190571,
0.2039701641,
0.6300131083,
-0.1212043166,
-0.485945791,
0.3937585056,
0.6802386045,
0.9750003815,
-0.443685621,
0.2226309627,
0.1460790485,
-0.9472120404,
0.171998322,
0.005167909,
-0.4751191139,
0.0190268308,
0.058686655,
0.201518029,
0.3909744918,
-0.4042041898,
0.5184223056,
-0.0919249058,
-0.3917061985,
-0.4090030789,
-0.260378927,
-0.1672730744,
-0.022068793,
0.7388122678,
-0.1521269381,
0.471332103,
-0.4290454686,
0.4971293211,
0.380605638,
-0.3057838082,
-0.067945309,
0.5573406219,
0.2835479677,
-0.0795316622,
0.4752499759,
-0.2913672626,
-0.5614293814,
0.2637276351,
0.3039657772,
0.9167634845,
-0.4092608988,
0.3813838959,
0.5002405643,
0.3376651406,
-0.1689028293,
0.3298251033,
0.1321255267,
-0.4686209559,
-0.9288542271,
-0.6247797012,
-0.9195896387,
0.0907579958,
-0.4401040673,
0.3133064806,
-0.3548686504,
-0.509437561,
0.0211471226,
-0.1536490917,
-0.2772980034,
0.1339667141,
0.0705813989,
0.7897866964,
-0.8957726955,
0.7714774013,
0.3832024932,
-0.7389572859,
-0.6345912814,
0.078972891,
0.3649668694,
-0.3503209949,
0.5841525197,
0.2018507421,
-0.5080667734,
-0.2679809928,
-0.220408693,
-0.709467411,
0.88025105,
0.1421850175,
-0.7546213269,
-0.1461629421,
-0.0552585199,
0.5576813817,
-0.3824102581,
0.8213899136,
0.5614686012,
0.5232730508,
0.0948809311,
-1.1095312834,
0.0647883937,
-0.384074837,
0.2123797238,
0.0810325667,
-0.1783175468,
0.5260734558,
-0.2736715078,
-0.2713573575,
-0.2072975487,
0.3639670312,
0.7821285129,
0.6413018703,
0.5511599183,
0.1626232415,
0.4599586427,
-0.0278272387,
1.1468503475,
-0.5879018307,
0.3888959587,
0.975509882,
-1.00583601,
0.8131535649,
0.6450838447,
-0.5242527127,
0.446436882,
0.47435835,
0.0083454531,
0.3534708619,
0.5707919002,
-0.3653974533,
0.359034121,
0.1604703367,
-0.2892614901,
0.2032083273,
0.3034669757,
-0.2244565189,
-0.3650144041,
0.019468829,
-0.1071192771,
0.1696471572,
-0.326515466,
0.4906820655,
0.2394032031,
-1.0676647425,
0.2657191753,
-0.1098218709,
0.7223565578,
-0.6289981008,
-0.0316925608,
-0.0589740053,
0.3428667188,
-0.552270472,
-1.1383682489,
0.5526143909,
0.2788997293,
-0.0478709005,
-0.1990831792,
0.8504499197,
-0.2063370198,
-0.5024757385,
0.377864778,
0.3476051688,
0.3778292239,
0.0044740322,
-0.4214670658,
0.4782148898,
-0.0006349438,
-0.4706294537,
0.4413264692,
0.2495910674,
-0.6090795994,
0.6201506257,
0.8219200373,
0.3504398465,
-0.168283999,
0.4648784101,
0.8991960287,
-0.8227644563,
-0.8440647721,
-0.6924108267,
0.2970864177,
-0.425296098,
-0.1833386868,
0.5407341719,
0.7366039157,
0.7629157305,
-0.1718659401,
1.0268865824,
0.0720161721,
0.5874195695,
-0.1412854195,
0.7512278557,
0.3816739023,
0.2778621614,
-0.5737559199,
-1.1065579653,
-0.7731862068,
0.9953283072,
-0.7459406853,
0.2037935257,
0.9581707716,
0.9380643368,
0.1293289214,
0.0102099571,
0.1695462316,
0.0813177377,
0.3290553689,
0.1801559925,
0.8075194955,
-0.1135770157,
0.7123995423,
0.2672941387,
-0.5576350689,
-0.3363256752,
-1.0013692379,
-0.6158236861,
-0.4195219576,
-0.344072938,
-0.640371263,
0.3327673972,
0.7742752433,
0.6102650166,
-0.8645175099,
-0.5425058007,
-0.0446553342,
-0.1649466604,
0.078934513,
-0.1853331327,
0.2691064179,
-0.3252812922,
-0.3883827329,
0.0427914485,
0.6697567105,
-0.4764753878,
-0.5783244371,
-0.2003638148,
-0.05518841,
-0.0180824716,
0.6136657596,
0.2126886994,
-0.6418187618,
-0.2567873299,
-0.2851050794,
-0.4211481512,
-0.2485252768,
0.9954984188,
-0.3759109974,
0.4607869387,
0.5269767046,
0.0652283579,
0.9140135646,
-0.1471241862,
0.7229167819,
-0.1553893536,
-0.1031560153,
0.2695634067,
0.4195434749,
0.282297045,
-0.3231872916,
0.8251529932,
-0.1956931502,
-1.110611558,
-1.1100018024,
0.2207911462,
-1.0501773357,
0.2251358032,
1.1653897762,
0.0529723763,
-0.1577859521,
-0.4424050152,
-0.5772593021,
-0.0212307442,
-0.4516821802,
0.9922744036,
0.7663413882,
-0.1242195591,
-0.0966884419,
-0.7964898348,
0.5633013248,
-0.1159190834,
-0.5775817037,
-0.060091354,
0.5205642581,
0.5570821762,
0.0801417083,
1.4858270884,
-0.6706323028,
0.2323672622,
-0.1754070818,
0.3980446458,
0.2305284292,
0.0097295679,
-0.6154718399,
0.1996861547,
0.1363079101,
0.2347343713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07914v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07914v2
|
Can Knowledge Graphs Reduce Hallucinations in LLMs? : A Survey
| 2023-11-14T05:21:57 | 2024-03-16T03:19:25 |
Garima Agrawal, Tharindu Kumarage, Zeyad Alghamdi, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The contemporary LLMs are prone to producing hallucinations, stemming mainly
from the knowledge gaps within the models. To address this critical limitation,
researchers employ diverse strategies to augment the LLMs by incorporating
external knowledge, aiming to reduce hallucinations and enhance reasoning
accuracy. Among these strategies, leveraging knowledge graphs as a source of
external information has demonstrated promising results. In this survey, we
comprehensively review these knowledge-graph-based augmentation techniques in
LLMs, focusing on their efficacy in mitigating hallucinations. We
systematically categorize these methods into three overarching groups, offering
methodological comparisons and performance evaluations. Lastly, this survey
explores the current trends and challenges associated with these techniques and
outlines potential avenues for future research in this emerging field.
|
[
-0.6660139561,
-0.795152247,
0.799476862,
-0.118293874,
-0.0452284142,
0.3142240644,
0.0219485853,
-0.9362724423,
0.5973764062,
0.7066009045,
-0.6719270349,
-0.5441830754,
-0.6384661198,
0.2823394537,
-0.3288306892,
0.545137465,
0.1103348956,
0.2738315463,
-0.5479972959,
0.0845886096,
-0.6116271019,
-0.7046652436,
-0.5936475992,
-0.4507575929,
0.5703192949,
0.0095480001,
0.6871500611,
0.0939992368,
0.6372864842,
0.2907263041,
-0.1477924585,
1.0617060661,
-0.6413498521,
0.1227603108,
0.135564819,
-0.4009090662,
-0.4196615815,
-0.3310557306,
0.3118777871,
1.0522228479,
0.0143716615,
-0.2406356186,
0.1341636926,
0.8753737211,
-0.7191378474,
0.1733234674,
-0.4534708261,
0.4539834559,
0.0647349134,
-0.5611388683,
-0.4568949342,
-0.6835999489,
-0.0453111865,
-0.6262955666,
-0.0159996636,
0.2966514528,
0.2729700208,
0.5540309548,
-0.3219706118,
-0.3969140053,
-0.7322900295,
0.2757729888,
-0.4283356369,
0.6064388752,
0.3612802923,
0.3694455922,
-0.2956524789,
-0.8607510328,
-0.2788237631,
-0.3023167551,
-0.3760421872,
0.0074551133,
-0.2899039388,
0.40418908,
0.6230185628,
0.2014024258,
-0.3142700195,
0.1784731746,
-0.6490110755,
-0.7999526262,
0.4085505009,
0.3807550371,
0.4250679612,
-0.1073707044,
-0.2325024009,
0.1052665263,
-0.7400653958,
-0.1781079769,
0.5240885019,
0.0303582381,
0.6146671772,
0.9077486396,
-0.2454401404,
0.8242364526,
-0.1132448018,
-0.3152538538,
0.1478960216,
-0.0635864288,
-0.0262838602,
0.3647108078,
0.2405820638,
0.7861684561,
0.303806603,
-0.6837898493,
-0.010203734,
0.1929364502,
0.4119881988,
-0.6221292019,
-0.4251799285,
0.0357692353,
-0.3750127554,
-0.2571708858,
-0.1326033473,
-0.7857778668,
-1.2121084929,
-0.3760572672,
0.3570202589,
-0.8142273426,
-0.1802068949,
-0.0739374533,
-0.6062588692,
-0.0294228103,
0.662971735,
-0.4694309235,
0.4096449614,
0.3583672643,
1.0415420532,
-0.397782743,
-0.0522056855,
-0.1546344608,
0.4412444532,
-0.4139236212,
1.0982735157,
-0.3111692071,
-0.551422894,
-0.060896311,
-0.0943494141,
0.0043157898,
-0.8055405617,
0.3211391866,
-0.421736598,
0.1484982967,
-0.5848246217,
-0.7602592707,
-0.5811311007,
0.3115944266,
-0.6366827488,
0.7477882504,
0.1589337289,
-0.7675485015,
0.2314096987,
-0.4219156504,
-0.5079299212,
-0.1209349856,
-0.2884769738,
-0.069448337,
0.1219053417,
0.5987834334,
0.2616048455,
-0.0302346461,
-0.1815924942,
-0.3431416452,
-0.626621902,
0.2118546814,
-0.1738451868,
0.5957810879,
0.141463533,
-0.1411612779,
0.3128496408,
-0.690036118,
-0.0108381528,
0.0828035548,
0.3267430663,
-0.2361096442,
-0.0614666045,
-0.5141513944,
-0.067743808,
0.0219001994,
-0.0625849292,
0.1222807243,
-0.4384484589,
0.1354199499,
0.7961189151,
0.3204488158,
0.2300033569,
-0.7430859208,
0.4935135543,
0.1957606524,
0.1245269775,
0.2005463094,
-0.5638723373,
-0.8758943677,
-0.2255672216,
-0.3874804676,
0.505076766,
-1.06165874,
0.5719445944,
-0.005914879,
-0.5478872657,
-0.4259649217,
-0.0108982418,
-0.0151482653,
0.8971002102,
0.6689338684,
-0.1279372126,
-0.7511510849,
-0.6089424491,
-0.102654025,
-0.1005135924,
0.1526520997,
0.3801420331,
0.214535445,
-0.2136418372,
0.6071579456,
-0.6499317288,
-0.6436792016,
-0.1597739458,
-0.3212530613,
-0.2195018679,
0.1535199285,
0.507196784,
-0.418025732,
0.0389235131,
-0.1260738969,
-1.0411322117,
0.0380317084,
0.0909628049,
0.1196104288,
0.3441368639,
0.563847363,
-0.610665977,
0.6987561584,
0.1751020253,
-0.2365417033,
0.5981939435,
-0.1625030786,
0.4951333404,
-0.6875118017,
-0.3896250129,
-0.3112609088,
-0.0597490855,
-0.6231621504,
-0.2225303203,
-0.2585507035,
0.0751950592,
-0.2213629186,
0.3339008391,
-0.5754523873,
-0.3829863369,
-0.3906511962,
0.4842077792,
0.1179271564,
0.2742466331,
-0.0707734227,
0.6207592487,
0.7903510332,
-0.5949414372,
0.7417160869,
0.3294829428,
-0.4742885828,
0.4736552238,
-0.0826754197,
0.34686324,
-0.4233544767,
0.4116625786,
-1.0901399851,
-0.2391830236,
0.7599522471,
-0.3232812285,
0.1840310246,
0.0668011904,
-0.4863269031,
-0.4325454831,
-0.5164361596,
-0.0684471652,
0.5870258212,
-0.7315244079,
0.7038769722,
0.2469420284,
0.1747036129,
-0.4960387945,
-0.9466406107,
0.2477548867,
-0.3271541595,
-0.7626041174,
0.3315121233,
-0.0807414278,
-0.4959419668,
0.0086555537,
-0.1497220546,
0.2686810493,
-0.1737858951,
0.1782009155,
0.1261742413,
0.0810068473,
0.2431672364,
0.0243415833,
-0.0008256229,
0.1946925819,
-0.4056825042,
0.5550172925,
0.1992485374,
-0.6548101902,
-0.446975261,
-0.04163827,
0.2594487369,
0.2949344814,
0.706009984,
0.6863542795,
-0.5301855803,
-0.1906116307,
-0.9686997533,
-0.7017760277,
-0.4718231857,
0.2794398963,
-0.3620477617,
-0.6681748033,
0.7027465701,
-0.4190550447,
-0.5528176427,
0.1278377473,
0.3563174009,
-0.1322841793,
0.8356268406,
0.251668632,
0.0954071358,
0.308704406,
-0.4390196204,
0.4477752149,
-0.9578894377,
-0.6680224538,
-0.1530094743,
-0.282061398,
-0.4234714508,
-0.4820126295,
0.5466378331,
0.1551091224,
0.2021034956,
-0.1914687902,
-0.9531378746,
0.2080104649,
0.2292429358,
0.5911912918,
0.5225813389,
0.2387119383,
0.0785394013,
-0.2351167649,
-0.7622677088,
-0.2462027669,
0.892922461,
0.0791864321,
0.6695034504,
-0.1106259152,
0.5750325322,
0.428868413,
0.162628144,
-0.7157627344,
0.7626957297,
0.3669017255,
-0.354100585,
-0.5312554836,
-0.5786303878,
-0.5336555243,
0.3589284718,
-0.2086509019,
-1.1101446152,
0.2400802374,
-0.0490795411,
-0.1530527771,
0.7549004555,
-0.6781768203,
0.2038399875,
-0.3597109914,
-0.2736622393,
-0.1968618035,
-0.453207612,
0.5541362166,
-0.0772072449,
0.1588724107,
-0.0522444397,
-0.0431877598,
0.6736032367,
-0.4428838789,
0.8031700253,
-0.4037899971,
-0.2203344703,
0.5026025772,
-0.0746693164,
0.8871959448,
-0.1417928338,
-0.0346885733,
0.294441849,
-0.2465544641,
-0.0109874792,
-0.9621686339,
0.7385499477,
-0.702970624,
-0.7862223387,
-0.0825154707,
-0.8608685136,
-0.5013362169,
-0.0695967823,
0.3897813261,
0.2518555522,
0.1437541991,
0.0434512831,
0.565056622,
-0.1981971115,
0.1790964603,
-0.0146063436,
-0.6221222878,
-0.7803256512,
0.936080575,
0.6746855974,
0.0770205036,
-0.0043328623,
-0.0170296151,
-0.4839071929,
-0.9902429581,
0.0829295814,
0.1775030494,
-1.1954774857,
-0.1090230197,
-0.7893404365,
-0.3970389068,
-0.9050497413,
-0.1570581645,
0.1037927344,
-0.7088199854,
-0.2996723056,
-0.5251247883,
0.6990870833,
0.7113308311,
-0.1407767236,
0.200152114,
-0.3556011319,
0.6441230774,
0.2944482267,
0.2540555,
0.0726293921,
-0.1940331161,
0.0687072575,
-0.0935924649,
-0.1288133264,
-1.0328245163,
0.4943500161,
-0.3332822919,
0.72118783,
0.5031602383,
0.3555859029,
1.2039135695,
-0.0671378374,
0.7649758458,
0.3734763563,
-0.5189399719,
0.4828015864,
0.0107191699,
-0.4257949591,
0.2932692766,
0.4136631191,
-0.1211039126,
-0.6017820239,
-0.4446777105,
-0.7398164272,
0.4129320383,
0.3364958465,
-0.304017961,
0.2870487869,
0.5602402687,
0.0675464347,
0.3156156242,
-0.619387567,
-0.4284026623,
-0.1631727517,
-0.008249497,
0.1206744835,
-0.0610448085,
-0.406417042,
-0.592861712,
0.5006597042,
-0.2034862339,
0.3138540983,
0.3364245594,
-0.1390325129,
-0.100938037,
-0.2871110141,
0.4307877719,
0.8190837502,
-0.3376320302,
0.2273939699,
0.7540341616,
-0.4070692062,
0.01749417,
0.0248757284,
-0.2189767212,
-0.1648694724,
0.3480763137,
0.9568507671,
-0.0858704001,
-0.4334238768,
0.0304384902,
0.1358529925,
-0.3460411727,
-0.4813583791,
0.3924191296,
0.0519207865,
0.6104779243,
0.3054098487,
0.1403458267,
0.2902036011,
-0.3984441161,
0.0138441687,
0.545368135,
-0.6247008443,
0.0194010232,
0.4946195483,
-0.1121687815,
-0.4550819099,
0.5676090121,
0.0631887093,
-0.1452279091,
0.4774644375,
0.6708722115,
0.7274386287,
0.1515699327,
0.0460632294,
0.0133504011,
0.6530733705,
0.1167918816,
0.1375392973,
-0.1677986085,
-0.8784398437,
-0.1324599385,
-0.1402183324,
-0.6799491048,
0.0972337648,
-0.3715833426,
0.1241253018,
-0.22344248,
-0.3950056434,
-0.3743762374,
0.0342820585,
-0.3351487517,
0.0585599802,
0.2025989741,
0.6686436534,
-0.3656475842,
0.6488928795,
0.607625246,
-0.47494331,
-0.3361167312,
-0.036223039,
-0.1683766693,
-0.760291934,
0.2203551233,
0.2379367203,
-0.4342939854,
0.2510378957,
-0.5534445047,
-0.7056141496,
1.2681092024,
0.4870673418,
-0.272005111,
-0.2906191945,
0.3611531854,
0.4286760092,
-0.3894903958,
0.1943413466,
0.6649793983,
0.9729930758,
0.3205750883,
-0.3388583958,
0.2930884361,
0.0752254799,
-0.1405526996,
-0.043570675,
-0.4916413724,
0.160490483,
-0.4850545824,
-0.1465947628,
-0.1823880523,
0.5379306674,
0.5711418986,
0.6887543797,
0.6802708507,
0.4278267324,
1.3417794704,
-0.1151712313,
0.7420706153,
-0.6006311178,
-0.1862500608,
0.9734099507,
-0.4071332514,
0.0897130296,
0.7341123819,
-0.1369554996,
0.474963516,
0.554662168,
-0.1791470796,
0.4508169591,
0.2548445761,
0.034426298,
-0.2836288512,
-0.359865576,
-0.6822171807,
-0.1431336403,
0.6520207524,
-0.0087313969,
0.0415345579,
0.3861727118,
-0.1510003656,
-0.1407303512,
-0.3359205127,
1.0173097849,
0.1469611973,
-0.4753056765,
0.387999922,
-0.5783998966,
0.5471968055,
-0.4673722088,
-0.1731618196,
-0.2460228205,
-0.0184074752,
-0.4626919627,
-0.5284876823,
0.3640116453,
-0.4354717135,
0.1926048398,
-0.1675545722,
1.3733433485,
-0.1121464744,
-0.3739270866,
0.6278961897,
0.6644265056,
0.2497999966,
-0.2027965635,
-0.1289806515,
-0.0866472647,
0.045044627,
-0.1495243758,
0.1034363136,
0.4654498696,
0.058172293,
0.9343928695,
0.6384497881,
0.4491427243,
0.2104216516,
0.267003864,
1.1382112503,
-0.8156597018,
-0.2192559391,
-0.6356030107,
0.3387669325,
-0.4002712071,
0.0607637353,
1.0841293335,
0.4771030843,
0.6261791587,
-0.0834950656,
0.8602315187,
0.217418611,
0.3426778913,
-0.6366926432,
0.8216642737,
-0.4840776622,
0.3819584846,
-0.2969216108,
-0.8903236389,
-0.3919298053,
0.5387533307,
-0.3671193719,
0.078379482,
0.8924795389,
1.0220508575,
0.4269423187,
0.2178850621,
0.6184379458,
0.1778909564,
0.1536316127,
0.2406242043,
1.4813387394,
-0.2434938848,
0.584795475,
-0.5870696902,
0.125315249,
-0.3414317966,
-0.5470119715,
-1.1586180925,
-0.3460969925,
-0.3784298003,
-0.3775210381,
0.3527153432,
0.6133975983,
0.5072150826,
-0.5406927466,
0.1152501404,
-0.127677694,
0.6405706406,
-0.244167462,
-0.2250016481,
0.5142561793,
-0.5665886998,
-0.2953763306,
0.6779909134,
0.3047999144,
0.2735887766,
-0.6027238965,
-0.2188771367,
0.3322528303,
-0.0017723679,
0.5496586561,
-0.3270294964,
-0.7254065275,
-0.464075774,
0.1359269619,
0.1102724224,
0.1950609088,
0.9467597008,
-1.056063056,
0.4945712984,
0.5506792665,
0.2236874998,
0.5656214952,
-0.0793673918,
0.1079348326,
-0.5357829928,
0.2730117142,
0.2096389532,
0.4002544284,
0.3536719084,
-0.7868185043,
0.7489555478,
0.5024325848,
-0.2362955809,
-0.9648119807,
0.0883075371,
-0.8058366776,
-0.4640908241,
0.9880558252,
0.2949458957,
-0.0871879086,
-0.4297245443,
-0.527980268,
0.4056901336,
-0.0476897918,
1.1737792492,
0.6197136045,
-0.7022070289,
-0.0769289061,
-0.3846387863,
0.7409431338,
-0.0521579906,
-1.1787143946,
-0.0938613638,
0.8286845684,
-0.1001804546,
0.3344741762,
0.6235432029,
0.0108125824,
-0.0521990284,
0.1061307415,
-0.0157584455,
-0.5749688148,
-0.4191628098,
-0.0639679506,
0.6204436421,
-0.0183943212,
0.1654315442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07911v1
|
Instruction-Following Evaluation for Large Language Models
| 2023-11-14T05:13:55 | 2023-11-14T05:13:55 |
Jeffrey Zhou, Tianjian Lu, Swaroop Mishra, Siddhartha Brahma, Sujoy Basu, Yi Luan, Denny Zhou, Le Hou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50 (Primary) 68T99 (Secondary), I.2.7
|
One core capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) is to follow natural
language instructions. However, the evaluation of such abilities is not
standardized: Human evaluations are expensive, slow, and not objectively
reproducible, while LLM-based auto-evaluation is potentially biased or limited
by the ability of the evaluator LLM. To overcome these issues, we introduce
Instruction-Following Eval (IFEval) for large language models. IFEval is a
straightforward and easy-to-reproduce evaluation benchmark. It focuses on a set
of "verifiable instructions" such as "write in more than 400 words" and
"mention the keyword of AI at least 3 times". We identified 25 types of those
verifiable instructions and constructed around 500 prompts, with each prompt
containing one or more verifiable instructions. We show evaluation results of
two widely available LLMs on the market. Our code and data can be found at
https://github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/instruction_following_eval
|
[
-0.0033034869,
-0.7212882638,
0.6134205461,
0.5573186278,
0.0579228252,
0.329421103,
-0.5833149552,
-0.2209684104,
-0.3150787055,
0.527648747,
-0.4370714426,
-0.7869445086,
-0.4985714853,
0.2057957351,
-0.6001321673,
0.9771156311,
-0.1810348332,
-0.06614694,
-0.4183314443,
-0.0184764732,
-0.3396205306,
-0.3864665926,
-0.6130033731,
-0.1604017317,
0.2957407534,
0.398301065,
0.5212174058,
0.8591757417,
0.4436307251,
0.338080585,
0.0518408343,
0.3059157431,
-0.3774851859,
-0.0985926315,
-0.0150657883,
-0.1844210923,
-0.4862675965,
0.0548633561,
1.0870873928,
0.4889977872,
-0.1077901125,
0.3028712571,
0.2359411418,
0.7824097872,
-0.5649491549,
0.5344933867,
-0.5044794083,
-0.2619072795,
-0.0298586935,
-0.1893418878,
-0.6883467436,
-0.7585036755,
0.2597195506,
-0.1645062119,
-0.2649588585,
0.1708757728,
0.4619479775,
0.0957391709,
-0.1337283403,
-0.7278739214,
-0.4939319789,
0.6523193121,
-0.8094658852,
0.4401759207,
0.532943666,
0.2510270476,
-0.1278381795,
-0.6429482102,
-0.533841908,
-1.0825448036,
-0.0345021561,
-0.1460310519,
-0.3183992207,
0.1463231742,
0.3993832171,
0.2314583361,
-0.4962028563,
0.1887450367,
-0.2836026251,
-0.032523945,
0.7400054932,
0.2940223217,
0.4012888372,
0.0328366682,
-0.4351966381,
-0.120673269,
-0.8887445331,
0.1318373829,
0.329862386,
0.2778084874,
-0.2004763037,
0.6042916179,
-0.4376985729,
0.7165079713,
0.2008728385,
-0.0426770486,
0.2292758226,
-0.5136080384,
-0.0540812127,
0.1015649587,
0.7486168742,
0.3293570876,
0.2553057075,
-0.2985456884,
-0.5881793499,
-0.0887017995,
0.3334026635,
-1.0497450829,
-0.1986846328,
0.0414935723,
-0.3607494831,
0.0015715047,
-0.1553170681,
-0.605542779,
-0.3965479434,
-0.4082432091,
0.6150491238,
-0.6281662583,
0.2903636992,
0.0166502092,
0.2920893431,
0.5917696357,
0.2628843486,
-0.7125200033,
0.5659522414,
1.0335803032,
0.7578359246,
-0.1920458525,
-0.6048653722,
-0.9302854538,
-0.4501114786,
-0.4446316659,
0.7745918632,
-0.7679542899,
-0.4032038748,
0.0920258611,
-0.0199437663,
-0.0584749691,
-0.4409195781,
0.5812448859,
-0.5500744581,
0.2255339473,
-0.2041998059,
-1.0150518417,
-0.2099724859,
0.2277881801,
-0.4962259531,
0.8590079546,
0.0753771588,
-0.3370553255,
0.134790495,
-0.7486828566,
-0.4758175015,
0.2025669217,
-0.1245614216,
-0.2504462302,
0.0334267691,
0.12964499,
0.3463816345,
-0.5630751848,
0.0926985964,
-0.1947807074,
-0.5118922591,
0.1080510691,
-0.8541434407,
0.7437562346,
-0.201026693,
-0.6377345324,
0.3589271605,
-0.8449656367,
0.1245959476,
-0.1979057044,
-0.5514486432,
-0.0531666391,
0.1822311878,
-0.2974826992,
-0.2527785599,
0.403145045,
-0.4359094799,
0.3638253212,
-0.2585195005,
0.2338074446,
0.8321771026,
-0.1899644136,
0.3276971579,
-0.1939262748,
0.7124273181,
-0.6696810126,
-0.0238481034,
-0.5195708871,
-0.2737148106,
-0.7431557775,
-0.2277856469,
0.2490144521,
0.529084444,
-0.5973740816,
0.4248832464,
-0.2341727465,
-0.6864936948,
-0.77415663,
0.3310321867,
0.9173867702,
0.600646317,
0.3021273315,
0.2189590037,
-0.4031456411,
-0.9028795958,
-0.2585060298,
-0.2688749135,
-0.0338120423,
0.1624707729,
0.5565297604,
-0.2287158221,
0.5081775188,
-0.2132792622,
0.040184848,
-0.1712893099,
0.1642982662,
0.1667235494,
0.2114157975,
0.3005228937,
-0.1766683012,
-0.7884665132,
0.0565559082,
-0.5177109241,
-0.3064782619,
-0.0021372361,
0.0939798504,
0.3168203831,
0.6456561685,
-0.4193628132,
0.4050808549,
0.6215242147,
-0.2855430841,
0.6387413144,
-0.4790230691,
0.3999438584,
-0.6344645023,
0.0657132119,
0.051074896,
-0.2996396124,
-0.4591275752,
0.1322795302,
0.4231848121,
0.0544871166,
-0.2684588134,
0.7276498675,
-0.7751120329,
-0.0137922019,
-0.3106239438,
0.105528377,
-0.0228438936,
0.2328623384,
0.1423036456,
1.0762399435,
0.753623724,
-0.4744502306,
0.3416857421,
-0.0182281062,
-0.7245202661,
0.5057126284,
-0.7704875469,
0.379688561,
-0.0717277527,
0.2938892543,
-0.9696481228,
-0.0858032107,
0.0124014169,
-0.2035365701,
0.2757774889,
-0.1235137284,
-0.6045882106,
-0.36003986,
-0.5254804492,
0.0627394766,
0.7484884858,
-0.7811830044,
0.6333456635,
0.087421678,
-0.0985793546,
-0.4848559797,
-0.3719616234,
0.1877338141,
-0.0751010627,
-0.5566690564,
0.1571209431,
-0.3442078829,
-0.2532139719,
-0.0387987159,
0.2011641413,
0.0800554454,
0.0644300058,
0.2180915624,
0.4481585324,
-0.4081450105,
0.0822519064,
-0.2182127386,
-0.0891110078,
0.2130156159,
-0.1524530351,
0.4254246354,
-0.5905932784,
-0.6421020031,
-0.797478497,
0.3249698877,
0.5431318283,
-0.2875349522,
0.453828007,
0.2592529058,
-0.3815277517,
-0.4533033073,
-0.5619399548,
-0.059062764,
-0.5087543726,
0.5302839875,
-0.1495534331,
-0.4988768697,
0.1534500122,
0.2218739092,
0.4050275385,
0.2994687855,
0.7032416463,
-0.1042795181,
1.0382088423,
0.5065950751,
-0.2139381468,
0.2493217289,
-0.0495325513,
0.1021735966,
-0.7692391276,
-0.1346473992,
-0.5271258354,
-0.1101107895,
-0.3711072505,
-0.6506981254,
0.2648476064,
-0.1045387387,
-0.1149833128,
0.3156011403,
-0.3237730265,
0.7726536393,
0.5426182151,
-0.1958879083,
0.2380452901,
-0.214414373,
0.0760368407,
0.3002820313,
-0.6225597858,
-0.8671545982,
1.0418878794,
0.3489043415,
0.9142022729,
-0.0701233447,
0.6541051269,
0.524503231,
0.8978957534,
-0.7515275478,
0.7800110579,
-0.310253799,
-0.2224959582,
-0.2264500707,
-0.3410039246,
-0.7970949411,
-0.0679100975,
0.0082420707,
-0.8140611053,
-0.3799756765,
0.3398875892,
-0.5071023107,
0.1535061747,
-0.818959713,
0.7331446409,
-0.5319589972,
-0.0960769057,
-0.2635207474,
-0.403937012,
0.2667096555,
-0.0263918899,
0.0204846729,
0.11038059,
-0.1071649641,
0.5622799397,
-0.4358240962,
0.7985006571,
0.0042891423,
0.0109363105,
0.3958182037,
-0.0346055999,
0.6505782604,
-0.2248124629,
-0.2380834669,
0.0150117753,
-0.1320688725,
-0.1450211406,
-0.6745779514,
0.9052793384,
-0.5519918799,
-0.7701510191,
-0.2202903926,
-0.3158273995,
-0.2528223991,
-0.0285528619,
0.0032663534,
0.6707675457,
-0.2098175883,
0.3909001052,
0.5848076344,
-0.3023248911,
0.5130435228,
0.5934227109,
-0.3667395115,
-0.3220595717,
0.9020721316,
0.1448237151,
0.4016055763,
0.3966090977,
0.4561960399,
-0.4934402704,
-0.6144988537,
-0.8152208328,
0.1303356886,
-0.6815393567,
-0.1276101768,
-0.5123484135,
-0.3375550807,
-0.1689152867,
-0.1762331724,
-0.4505500197,
0.1151812822,
-0.2672199309,
-0.110559918,
0.3527520299,
0.8400738239,
0.2798859775,
0.0891693383,
-0.8460440636,
0.1034952179,
0.257448554,
0.4658951163,
0.3295026124,
-0.8018889427,
-0.1591583192,
0.0690410584,
0.0238038171,
-0.7449502349,
0.09614636,
0.2202529609,
0.6109083891,
0.3508618772,
0.0309759211,
0.7731106281,
-0.8735613823,
0.5163568854,
-0.0490223914,
-1.1288034916,
0.3279649019,
0.0424451157,
0.3794531524,
0.6744623184,
0.3770228326,
-0.4074361026,
-0.2906745672,
-0.3789283037,
-0.7095965147,
0.6069871187,
0.0854541659,
0.426720947,
-0.1938771009,
0.2828080654,
0.1641637087,
0.1534688324,
-0.5208143592,
-0.1220826209,
0.2379894555,
-0.1990198046,
0.0310556684,
-0.4129222333,
0.1212796345,
-0.0411629863,
0.6480100155,
-0.041066885,
0.0330062658,
-0.0525734462,
-0.2618884742,
0.1025611088,
0.192847982,
0.5815112591,
0.7713324428,
-0.1413627267,
0.028777482,
0.2206905186,
-0.0956730619,
-0.0593702123,
0.1811032742,
-0.1515402347,
-0.13603127,
0.7771644592,
0.9098808169,
0.1988127381,
-1.0620919466,
0.6474169493,
-0.0957807526,
-0.0588185117,
-0.4701045454,
0.137639612,
0.2760821581,
0.4102966785,
0.2053945512,
-0.3738754094,
0.1457082182,
-0.7474213839,
0.2760865092,
0.4949747622,
-0.3927917182,
-0.4492605031,
0.4002123773,
0.1963437349,
-0.8530762196,
0.7675354481,
-0.3967119753,
-0.60797894,
0.5238233805,
0.470669806,
1.0202800035,
-0.2576509118,
0.105513379,
0.322751075,
0.4732128978,
-0.0880140439,
0.3922038376,
0.0148873162,
-0.259981215,
-0.5012567043,
-0.5768293142,
-0.5928006172,
0.0111997947,
-0.4559807181,
0.3200233579,
-0.5748402476,
0.2210113853,
0.0580964014,
-0.1257159859,
-0.800853014,
-0.0575636514,
0.2726246417,
1.1516916752,
-0.6659665108,
0.7683792114,
0.4127266407,
-0.3108192086,
-0.8515207171,
0.0130408788,
0.0711001977,
-1.008458972,
0.7419006228,
0.4270443618,
-0.3095107675,
-0.1957861185,
-0.537892282,
-0.681291461,
0.9222989678,
0.2714845836,
-0.8103436232,
-0.0049981931,
-0.1585586518,
0.728605032,
-0.7193912864,
0.4660768807,
0.6078618765,
0.522217989,
-0.0276808608,
-0.7833409905,
0.0212888028,
-0.1315701604,
-0.1141050905,
-0.0579379983,
-0.5760782361,
0.6238105297,
-0.4282017648,
-0.319198519,
0.311622858,
0.7127053142,
0.1754204631,
0.2441844195,
0.5597724319,
0.2277382016,
0.8470742702,
0.1919802278,
1.4672055244,
-0.5763865113,
0.1065577418,
1.5222079754,
-0.385520488,
1.1271443367,
0.1640770286,
-0.2435493022,
0.4799107015,
0.3871427774,
-0.0324937627,
0.2783178091,
0.5166758895,
-0.3003135324,
-0.1046587154,
0.1221147925,
-0.0120734219,
0.4468525648,
0.2633312047,
-0.5534312725,
-0.2536366582,
-0.1538170278,
0.0930480137,
0.1394177228,
-0.2782213688,
0.8108405471,
-0.0748421326,
-0.8863981366,
0.7117494941,
-0.0286486633,
0.403075099,
-0.6605330706,
-0.4457673132,
-0.2256796658,
0.0051045553,
0.0188289657,
-0.9387559891,
0.1078049019,
0.4941253066,
-0.0253153984,
-0.2764154673,
0.5055378675,
-0.4824042916,
-0.6487363577,
0.311422199,
0.3442280591,
0.2270687371,
-0.0099019911,
-0.5659983754,
0.1391162127,
0.1827184856,
-0.4128672481,
0.1835824102,
0.2721851766,
-0.2771918476,
0.9718202949,
0.583497107,
-0.0055026594,
0.1436253935,
0.0729176402,
0.7243347168,
-0.566550374,
-0.0484149829,
-1.1483983994,
0.5520124435,
-0.0085819606,
-0.3815967739,
0.8938606381,
0.47563833,
0.5603185892,
0.1241060197,
0.7386419177,
0.1210595667,
0.3921098113,
-0.6112883091,
0.5482268929,
-0.2747119069,
0.5498639345,
-0.02416173,
-1.0565662384,
-0.0912410468,
0.4936631918,
-0.4261340201,
0.0636023358,
0.604580164,
0.883491993,
0.0805390701,
-0.0329481661,
0.2670972645,
0.3069098592,
0.3084006906,
0.3684878349,
0.9470076561,
0.0751509517,
0.3768115342,
-0.1604330689,
-0.4471516311,
-0.2019400448,
-1.2098463774,
-0.9040153623,
-0.3259080648,
-0.4736425877,
-0.3126713037,
0.1677906215,
1.3096699715,
0.4824387431,
-0.6756474972,
-0.3793389499,
0.0885391757,
0.1607480496,
-0.205373928,
-0.1169421598,
0.6904904842,
-0.3851659298,
-0.8122430444,
0.6613830924,
0.492036432,
-0.3884202242,
-0.6172828674,
-0.1082968935,
-0.0563680045,
0.4067755938,
0.6594642997,
0.2281588167,
-0.7883492708,
-0.5389547944,
-0.0263896994,
-0.2664273977,
0.0894433409,
0.4693438709,
-0.6227757931,
0.6730343699,
0.4930923581,
1.084663868,
0.1169492602,
-0.0870217159,
0.564046979,
-0.3863833249,
-0.619356215,
0.3320268095,
0.4243544936,
0.4093699455,
-0.0519184768,
0.3257370591,
-0.3987469971,
-0.6774321198,
-0.7449421287,
-0.0867442414,
-0.7291122675,
0.1917401403,
1.3600611687,
-0.5545141101,
-0.3221920431,
0.3422424197,
-0.1822451949,
-0.2587951422,
-0.4412578046,
0.8956014514,
0.870020926,
-0.1342141777,
-0.1735666096,
-0.588396728,
0.329020083,
0.1349063665,
-1.0000472069,
0.3876033723,
0.5453391671,
0.4699164033,
-0.0612146556,
0.5875749588,
0.0537798442,
0.3254122436,
-0.0092710564,
0.0154693378,
0.0661403388,
-0.3289123178,
-0.5129401088,
-0.0775654688,
0.3284703195,
-0.1067479923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07897v1
|
CPopQA: Ranking Cultural Concept Popularity by LLMs
| 2023-11-14T04:10:40 | 2023-11-14T04:10:40 |
Ming Jiang, Mansi Joshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prior work has demonstrated large language models' (LLMs) potential to
discern statistical tendencies within their pre-training corpora. Despite that,
many examinations of LLMs' knowledge capacity focus on knowledge explicitly
appearing in the training data or implicitly inferable from similar contexts.
How well an LLM captures the corpus-level statistical trends of concepts for
reasoning, especially long-tail ones, is still underexplored. In this study, we
introduce a novel few-shot question-answering task (CPopQA) that examines LLMs'
statistical ranking abilities for long-tail cultural concepts (e.g., holidays),
with a specific focus on these concepts' popularity in the United States and
the United Kingdom, respectively. We curate a dataset containing 459 holidays
across 58 countries, generating a total of 6,000 QA testing pairs. Experiments
on four strong LLMs show that large models are capable of ranking long-tail
cultural concepts regarding their statistical tendency. Notably, GPT-3.5
displayed superior performance and exhibited its potential to identify
geo-cultural proximity across continents.
|
[
-0.7108876109,
-0.4789797068,
0.758243084,
0.2266265452,
-0.5400663614,
0.0945824906,
-0.4076415896,
-0.4088667333,
0.2769443691,
0.3371371925,
-0.3109702766,
-0.7323192954,
-0.6486842632,
0.2555585206,
-0.1357484907,
0.7815029621,
0.037500862,
-0.1526855379,
-0.255792439,
-0.2741359174,
0.1368838996,
-0.9342241883,
-0.2916802168,
-0.2267950922,
0.5418129563,
0.4192231894,
0.8308634758,
0.3345246911,
0.5432822108,
0.1367086768,
-0.0791333765,
0.1005342677,
-0.5621954799,
-0.0844535828,
-0.217426464,
-0.5203549266,
-0.2739184797,
0.0748089105,
0.597494483,
0.7750637531,
0.0868956298,
0.4191338718,
0.0932201445,
0.4722106159,
-0.4469920099,
0.0158237275,
-0.7188141346,
-0.1279972196,
-0.3363163173,
-0.2489189655,
-0.2693890929,
-0.6310736537,
0.3797310889,
-0.4670468569,
0.0580624864,
-0.1195817962,
0.4582725763,
0.016966505,
-0.6478255987,
-0.181366846,
-0.3205737174,
1.0074447393,
-0.279132843,
0.3210429251,
0.5517510772,
0.0770594478,
0.0923672542,
-0.1663102955,
-0.3769806325,
-0.1870928258,
0.2945745289,
0.0007507033,
-0.0017733241,
-0.3743209541,
0.1455981731,
0.0733577311,
-0.7268214822,
0.0850233883,
-0.198065117,
0.0202862155,
0.6564468145,
0.1938434094,
0.1736169904,
-0.1810708195,
-0.2774021924,
0.286768496,
-0.8254627585,
0.2569792569,
0.0569021255,
0.1691921502,
0.0019204139,
0.5931993127,
-0.4101175666,
0.3482113183,
-0.2942914665,
-0.3061326444,
0.2159161717,
-0.3085643053,
0.0395629033,
-0.2431520671,
0.6130475998,
0.5220476389,
0.4326765537,
-0.0343674161,
0.1848894358,
-0.2717614472,
-0.1385096461,
-0.6894068122,
-0.2478429973,
0.114828214,
-0.4919448495,
-0.0009773041,
0.0892573521,
-0.5182700157,
-0.2281269133,
0.0334168673,
0.1594607085,
-0.271119535,
-0.3500100672,
-0.0054023648,
-0.3208817244,
0.4730627835,
0.3854621649,
-0.7334474325,
-0.0562106036,
1.0695412159,
0.8006837368,
-0.6359057426,
-0.3070697784,
0.0081895953,
-0.112710841,
-0.8553145528,
0.8065709472,
-0.5493651032,
-0.416972667,
0.0439610519,
0.0917545035,
0.0717675164,
-0.5497893095,
0.3165919781,
-0.8314757347,
0.1705215573,
-0.7280814648,
-0.3358758092,
-0.0335215032,
0.6648561358,
-0.326582253,
1.0959789753,
0.0821786299,
-0.7350984812,
0.5892115235,
-0.0818885192,
-0.2339234799,
0.1950377375,
-0.3052891791,
-0.103889145,
-0.2560486495,
0.0282703731,
0.4815228283,
-0.4296329916,
0.0239474047,
-0.4406349957,
-0.6078231335,
0.4637592733,
-0.5119669437,
0.9226208329,
0.3750334382,
-0.2619771659,
-0.3420423865,
-0.4349640012,
-0.0615678392,
0.1894764155,
-0.3360953629,
-0.7034896612,
-0.0916503817,
-0.3780894279,
0.1736810654,
0.3179016113,
-0.2530616224,
0.4484891593,
-0.2728895843,
0.3340810239,
0.3761967123,
0.1995746195,
0.5680084229,
-0.4006203115,
0.856628418,
-0.0458906703,
-0.0197591055,
0.2026453316,
-0.8981391788,
-0.3590630889,
-0.2800352573,
0.0872271508,
0.7829771042,
-0.7061427236,
0.2338619828,
-0.3986142576,
-0.6794839501,
0.0267853942,
0.366287291,
0.0229435675,
0.309553951,
0.0121646496,
-0.419867456,
-0.1424883455,
-0.6857969165,
-0.0428222679,
-0.3369297087,
-0.3375113606,
0.2015686631,
0.4725872576,
0.153299436,
0.7952583432,
-0.6953091621,
0.0282162968,
-0.3762360513,
0.0749148056,
0.4648820162,
0.0166189149,
0.702971518,
-0.5853381157,
-0.3527840078,
-0.3428622186,
-0.5323190689,
0.269462049,
0.1583690643,
-0.2906265855,
0.3275698125,
0.0268275104,
-0.3484202921,
0.1581997573,
0.2191621512,
-0.2032940686,
0.4769495428,
0.2354719937,
0.3404563069,
-0.8321244121,
-0.3728375137,
0.0347940139,
0.0110251075,
-0.2126387507,
-0.04317265,
-0.012867718,
-0.1895346791,
-0.5975857973,
0.4775733948,
0.0346685015,
0.0086895339,
-0.0672863647,
0.1505551934,
-0.1804030538,
0.2695958912,
0.7449271679,
0.6662583351,
0.6617982388,
-0.7189216018,
0.102866374,
0.1581605226,
-0.4781184494,
0.6269030571,
-0.1996759921,
0.0439880006,
-0.012422719,
0.3758740425,
-1.1353751421,
-0.1468119174,
-0.0485844761,
-0.4135276079,
-0.5726770163,
-0.3964107335,
-0.485261023,
-0.5372288227,
-0.3515965044,
0.677950561,
0.6804587245,
-0.5649217367,
0.2290673405,
0.2935547829,
-0.2372634858,
-0.5792680979,
-0.7019185424,
-0.1247739568,
-0.7990192771,
-0.6630225182,
0.0895806998,
-0.200395748,
-0.4084298015,
-0.4539937079,
-0.0606827475,
-0.2001338154,
0.0994155109,
-0.1482910514,
0.2203711867,
-0.3444449604,
0.2758971751,
-0.5649008155,
0.1608797163,
0.2712356448,
-0.3599316776,
0.3911090791,
-0.2695499063,
-0.2538565695,
-0.0872801989,
0.285217613,
0.3491453528,
-0.1763844341,
0.5875226259,
0.5708809495,
-0.1385901868,
-0.3311932385,
-0.4358210266,
-0.1749914438,
-0.4486343563,
0.2746646702,
-0.3653558493,
-0.8193563819,
0.604444623,
0.1068665683,
-0.0286090467,
0.3180169463,
0.5785357356,
-0.2620042562,
0.8323223591,
0.415926069,
-0.2044834197,
0.2110232711,
-0.3603429496,
0.0964532793,
-0.3138318658,
0.0518125184,
-0.4782690704,
-0.2169479281,
-1.0229411125,
-0.6741335988,
0.6247372031,
0.0265911072,
-0.6191499233,
0.1141752377,
-0.2757971883,
0.7443283796,
0.7500239015,
-0.0249073468,
0.4304074049,
-0.1134298742,
-0.0687650368,
0.0713778064,
-0.6403610706,
-0.6229981184,
1.1803007126,
0.3537754118,
0.7980355024,
0.3986909389,
0.8889143467,
0.0373918936,
0.1174032986,
-0.9532426,
0.6287592053,
-0.5250813961,
-0.5137671232,
-0.3820027113,
-0.332913965,
-0.775513947,
0.1508172303,
0.0256346315,
-0.6275753379,
0.129291743,
0.0666413009,
-0.4869878292,
0.1972996891,
-0.3276087642,
0.686023891,
-0.5169818401,
-0.430161953,
-0.0509395786,
-0.4578109384,
0.4675433934,
-0.0566586703,
0.3122723699,
-0.5316078067,
-0.1179434806,
0.9532471895,
-0.0158073716,
0.8117849231,
0.0819657445,
-0.1671106666,
0.5241678357,
0.2649655342,
0.1317392588,
0.4236955941,
-0.2273782343,
0.2640561461,
0.5382273197,
-0.5804542899,
-0.4985155761,
0.6932510138,
-0.7049141526,
-0.6376045942,
-0.5898801088,
-0.4007323384,
-0.4504343271,
0.0583738126,
0.3010941446,
0.090885438,
-0.170779109,
0.266484201,
0.7466872931,
-0.0771161765,
0.2111309022,
0.4781588316,
-0.1626344621,
-0.2022381127,
0.8168997169,
0.3618293405,
0.2658470869,
0.3806350231,
0.3110435009,
-0.3959891796,
-0.460848093,
-0.251508981,
0.2873320878,
-0.8193688989,
0.0618440174,
-0.2916980386,
-0.0516840257,
-0.2698412538,
-0.4011373818,
-0.1386402994,
-0.602589488,
-0.1032107994,
-0.1328541338,
0.439281404,
0.5336758494,
0.0844483972,
0.2211200893,
-0.4005730152,
0.2794266641,
0.5179721117,
0.3902668655,
-0.130731523,
-0.502458632,
0.02943266,
-0.3070735037,
-0.3464442194,
-0.8865615726,
0.2435343415,
-0.0532199405,
0.5369801521,
0.6582846045,
0.1627144516,
0.5601638556,
-0.1993497014,
1.1993762255,
0.0330254138,
-0.5400688052,
0.3739441037,
-0.4990000129,
0.5699971914,
0.5420392156,
1.035218358,
-0.5435388684,
-0.5131844282,
-0.5273475647,
-0.6619908214,
0.2987879217,
-0.1853538901,
0.3017502725,
-0.490693748,
0.1207150444,
0.0877033174,
0.2310056239,
-0.7345792055,
-0.1483808905,
-0.0715742633,
-0.0348811634,
-0.2054176331,
-0.1307881922,
-0.2188605219,
-0.3276650012,
0.5057317615,
-0.1655364335,
0.0534086898,
-0.0086200014,
0.0954604521,
0.0733934194,
0.5439498425,
0.342120111,
1.2581340075,
-0.3895602524,
0.3892491758,
0.4583585262,
-0.3400352597,
0.1392057091,
-0.0220989473,
-0.2629742622,
-0.1789219379,
0.2906471491,
0.0585632809,
0.0027195297,
-0.6975617409,
0.4042884707,
0.0656384155,
-0.1826777011,
-0.7198013067,
-0.0292121675,
0.2701782584,
0.2106036991,
0.6412281394,
-0.3997097313,
0.0477039218,
-0.8916925788,
0.4164562225,
0.7399500608,
-0.2006797194,
-0.0866148993,
0.3934996128,
0.2678719759,
0.1342174113,
0.6620005965,
-0.4457395077,
-0.6637400985,
0.8743685484,
0.2904378176,
0.2425855398,
-0.0395306014,
0.3853724301,
0.481307745,
0.3178613484,
-0.153143093,
0.6497648954,
-0.0678269193,
-0.8978430629,
-0.2003720701,
-0.5893059373,
-0.4475689828,
-0.035490904,
-0.5060250163,
0.5031886697,
-0.1348464787,
-0.3011730611,
-0.3572694063,
0.0812904686,
-0.9865682721,
0.1786941737,
0.4681425691,
0.8010198474,
-0.9898851514,
0.8229345679,
0.4404108226,
-0.3501898348,
-0.6295689344,
0.2598998845,
0.2276647538,
-0.813759923,
0.7589730024,
-0.1278713346,
-0.0597541295,
-0.2102363408,
-0.3092418015,
-1.053301692,
1.0420044661,
0.0081774099,
-0.4267312586,
-0.0156921148,
0.3003606498,
0.5265665054,
-0.6063560843,
0.4660987258,
0.8069349527,
0.1626485437,
0.3380574286,
-0.9914179444,
-0.2261089981,
0.2284740508,
-0.2825508416,
0.1139852405,
-0.7344594002,
0.285017699,
-0.4858033657,
0.181891799,
0.0044183326,
0.5970121622,
0.8770697713,
0.6638134718,
0.6036895514,
0.4041543603,
0.746968329,
-0.1459337324,
0.8759211898,
-0.1380107105,
0.2049319446,
0.8671973348,
-0.2427076399,
1.2559551001,
0.2437986881,
-0.3896249533,
0.490259856,
1.1251866817,
0.0102997059,
0.5556241274,
0.3791242838,
-0.1383523792,
-0.5962000489,
-0.0177320465,
-0.4356941283,
0.651473999,
0.3601356745,
-0.4459375739,
-0.1831148267,
0.1225765347,
0.1840406507,
-0.2132557034,
-0.536791265,
0.6910810471,
0.1800451428,
-0.8445411921,
0.7948474288,
-0.3550466895,
0.7533792853,
-0.7316033244,
0.0900620297,
-0.3265791833,
-0.348634243,
-0.0369919576,
-1.0592230558,
0.1793184429,
0.1037839577,
-0.0107731931,
-0.1387764364,
0.1851735562,
-0.4496080577,
-0.6999827027,
0.0914755389,
0.5666361451,
0.4980419576,
-0.062797457,
-0.5538511276,
-0.0209897812,
-0.0392393023,
-0.0564613678,
0.4000659287,
0.4830482006,
-0.3272108436,
0.6151764393,
0.1619498879,
0.0483931936,
-0.1197878048,
0.1525552422,
0.3761759698,
-0.7008465528,
-0.6992954612,
-0.6787683368,
0.17185691,
0.2675950229,
-0.3176883459,
0.7641351819,
0.5397288799,
0.9172140956,
-0.0333505757,
0.8461019993,
0.1348038167,
0.5302718282,
-0.4826720357,
0.4577476084,
-0.4846116006,
0.3808646798,
-0.0930574313,
-0.8638140559,
-0.0983380005,
0.3175390065,
-1.0788506269,
0.0615149587,
0.7137539387,
0.5351198912,
-0.0874538943,
0.032978531,
0.3079094291,
0.0272583459,
0.0435345843,
0.5640103817,
1.0620516539,
0.1889232397,
0.8173620701,
-0.5892968774,
-0.3037358224,
-0.0614699274,
-1.0231192112,
-0.8198247552,
-0.7232801318,
-0.502761364,
-0.1755182147,
-0.0137922158,
1.1997933388,
0.9119699597,
-0.7327359915,
-0.319694519,
0.6032755971,
0.2505050004,
-0.3159813583,
-0.2715569437,
0.5299612284,
-0.0899470076,
-0.585788846,
0.3616638482,
-0.0964145139,
-0.1259932816,
-0.2025823742,
0.1732672602,
0.1864637583,
0.2366534919,
0.847812891,
0.1341232657,
-0.9849914312,
-0.3040703535,
0.2286572605,
0.1370608062,
-0.0666884482,
0.7867022753,
-0.6640970707,
0.1221752986,
0.7005029321,
0.4156734943,
0.2415380627,
0.4650864005,
0.2466506362,
-0.6636899114,
-0.0553232878,
0.3796021938,
0.2813849449,
0.2104039639,
-0.3797880411,
0.5014711022,
0.163320601,
-0.7921355963,
-0.4609838724,
0.2141294628,
-1.181581378,
-0.4127908349,
1.4047020674,
0.0599281192,
-0.0696401522,
-0.3398818374,
0.1951208264,
-0.3523257077,
-0.3525368571,
0.9011902213,
0.9045287967,
-0.5587329268,
-0.1916256249,
-0.7482703924,
0.6369239688,
0.3937036097,
-0.5938332677,
-0.1204798073,
0.3025947511,
0.7783198357,
0.2916096747,
0.8878880143,
-0.0380967259,
0.4303151071,
-0.5941641331,
-0.40847978,
0.5374070406,
-0.2561604679,
-0.030305611,
0.4434701204,
0.5557098985,
-0.0200360343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07884v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07884v2
|
Fair Abstractive Summarization of Diverse Perspectives
| 2023-11-14T03:38:55 | 2024-03-30T03:54:06 |
Yusen Zhang, Nan Zhang, Yixin Liu, Alexander Fabbri, Junru Liu, Ryo Kamoi, Xiaoxin Lu, Caiming Xiong, Jieyu Zhao, Dragomir Radev, Kathleen McKeown, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
People from different social and demographic groups express diverse
perspectives and conflicting opinions on a broad set of topics such as product
reviews, healthcare, law, and politics. A fair summary should provide a
comprehensive coverage of diverse perspectives without underrepresenting
certain groups. However, current work in summarization metrics and Large
Language Models (LLMs) evaluation has not explored fair abstractive
summarization. In this paper, we systematically investigate fair abstractive
summarization for user-generated data. We first formally define fairness in
abstractive summarization as not underrepresenting perspectives of any groups
of people, and we propose four reference-free automatic metrics by measuring
the differences between target and source perspectives. We evaluate nine LLMs,
including three GPT models, four LLaMA models, PaLM 2, and Claude, on six
datasets collected from social media, online reviews, and recorded transcripts.
Experiments show that both the model-generated and the human-written reference
summaries suffer from low fairness. We conduct a comprehensive analysis of the
common factors influencing fairness and propose three simple but effective
methods to alleviate unfair summarization. Our dataset and code are available
at https://github.com/psunlpgroup/FairSumm.
|
[
-0.3059900999,
-0.3108253777,
0.7112984061,
0.3416182101,
-0.2493270487,
0.0895376354,
-0.1257498711,
-0.6606964469,
0.1326617748,
0.241960153,
-0.0337656066,
-0.6765276194,
-0.8271374702,
0.1788850278,
-0.3795199096,
1.5893268585,
-0.0256990157,
0.1474242061,
-0.300157398,
-0.4060555398,
-0.1068420559,
-0.5486053228,
-0.1760922372,
-0.4214866757,
0.5147640705,
0.4103906155,
0.6858021617,
0.5613960624,
0.4303739071,
0.3038191795,
-0.4369645715,
-0.0294961799,
-0.6175798178,
-0.1213901788,
-0.4312135577,
-0.5993278027,
-0.7257182002,
0.1498114467,
0.6494768262,
0.9746028185,
-0.1917644888,
0.4290201068,
0.2160419673,
0.8048436046,
-0.7322363257,
-0.071491003,
-0.5425806046,
0.3486491144,
-0.1454432756,
0.1236529723,
-0.1136523932,
-0.8761429787,
-0.1149161905,
-0.5336450338,
0.3982322514,
-0.2437757403,
0.5980247855,
-0.0499982014,
-0.7219334245,
-0.1717870831,
-0.5162977576,
0.9757003188,
-1.0076093674,
-0.1819846779,
0.0516557097,
0.5876620412,
0.0995426029,
-0.5354164839,
-0.7403490543,
0.2817782164,
-0.1840417087,
0.2311420143,
-0.2888140976,
0.0404509045,
0.2239900678,
0.545902431,
-0.2487766296,
0.0897370204,
-0.5229369402,
-0.3174744248,
0.8465571404,
0.4466568828,
0.157227844,
-0.4571456611,
-0.1861684918,
0.4290884435,
-0.59688586,
0.2227948159,
0.7417510748,
0.1889920682,
-0.5166583061,
0.7488155961,
-0.5735318065,
0.4353736937,
-0.075137578,
-0.2392804772,
0.6138928533,
-0.4319384098,
0.007187325,
-0.1249286383,
0.7719089985,
1.1078071594,
0.5069226027,
-0.2539232075,
-0.5107864141,
0.1473164111,
-0.243726626,
-0.7900044918,
0.2381421924,
0.2221721709,
-1.0221014023,
-0.3125517964,
0.0031089061,
-0.6429172158,
-0.6524099708,
-0.4753169119,
0.0574656613,
0.2321668863,
-0.1544368565,
0.0964410454,
-0.266628474,
0.106332764,
0.6856409907,
-0.7534415722,
0.5446361303,
0.7254089713,
0.7191125751,
-0.4076762795,
-0.0211103577,
-0.4564894438,
0.2128727585,
0.0423777103,
0.7140702605,
-0.2441108376,
-0.2726235688,
-0.1938216835,
-0.1858932525,
0.3066584766,
-0.5158563852,
0.2185048908,
-0.3715747297,
0.4132044613,
-0.583142817,
-0.4450936317,
-0.3506022096,
0.2284682095,
-0.5000796318,
0.1127763167,
-0.1177852154,
-1.1071305275,
0.4886054397,
-0.6796172857,
-0.5757750273,
-0.1877159178,
-0.5318553448,
-0.1502007842,
0.4094962776,
0.3275464773,
0.428166151,
0.0624793507,
0.5407915115,
-0.2917264104,
-0.3484742045,
0.2682594359,
-0.2501401901,
0.7151104808,
0.4898715615,
-0.1583691984,
0.1397735178,
-0.5820689797,
-0.2046053857,
0.0452839024,
-0.4002126157,
-0.0646882206,
0.0400715545,
0.3769265413,
0.3717465699,
0.1911659092,
-0.5165855289,
-0.1651942879,
-0.4162037075,
0.1622049809,
0.9722832441,
-0.0852248147,
0.4921903312,
-0.6176887155,
0.5119478703,
0.0899034813,
-0.1335522383,
-0.1330447346,
-0.3701224923,
-0.1961166561,
-0.2793605626,
0.4128475189,
0.5176731348,
-0.3736777008,
0.0576313958,
-0.3906729817,
-0.0551143251,
-0.4885437787,
0.1195286289,
0.3884189129,
0.4655729532,
0.0768145248,
-0.5925863981,
-0.2416210771,
-1.1403073072,
-0.6871036887,
0.1590405107,
-0.4385348558,
0.351836592,
0.322040379,
0.0371184237,
0.989438653,
-0.3455328047,
-0.2904548645,
-0.5340689421,
0.158804819,
0.2259683907,
0.1725743264,
0.6931446195,
-0.6694235206,
-0.3126063645,
-0.2548713982,
-0.888779521,
-0.463732928,
0.0762104094,
0.1695247442,
0.1253168583,
0.1561346501,
-0.2954327464,
0.443595022,
0.407586664,
-0.4784122705,
0.1706868857,
-0.0183547102,
0.4113709629,
-0.9795461893,
0.2550544143,
-0.0114729311,
-0.650354445,
-0.0601875708,
0.0628152639,
-0.3033081591,
0.1013165712,
-0.6038663983,
0.5647071004,
-0.1481345147,
-0.3396321833,
-0.4987899065,
0.3481974602,
-0.0321911797,
0.3098724782,
-0.1233387887,
0.3323521316,
0.0186744928,
-0.3733789921,
-0.0851389244,
0.0877286494,
-0.1734317392,
0.4753625095,
-0.916618824,
-0.137608692,
-0.7248061895,
0.5679833889,
-0.7799506187,
-0.2580864131,
0.2701027989,
-0.5641645193,
-0.4169926047,
0.1179524362,
-0.4031939209,
0.2007516623,
-0.5426720977,
0.7940386534,
0.4593922794,
-0.366643399,
0.6262446046,
0.8463493586,
-0.5507283807,
-0.6777139902,
-0.7940151691,
0.0533881709,
-0.2149871439,
-0.5416277647,
0.4710094333,
-0.0832665861,
-0.7222388387,
0.1871293336,
-0.1335295141,
0.0585504547,
-0.0275677219,
0.0987806395,
-0.0092884926,
0.2403879315,
-0.1003812551,
0.2495341003,
-0.0345826969,
-0.0406043679,
0.206357941,
0.2396291345,
-0.2989643812,
-0.243275553,
-0.3593400717,
0.6479841471,
0.2452041954,
-0.1109809279,
0.3455953896,
0.3745877147,
-0.5036057234,
0.0899400935,
-0.4959404767,
0.0871588588,
-0.3813008666,
0.3351756334,
-0.0106402095,
-0.999536097,
1.0448218584,
0.3924058676,
0.5949174762,
0.4822529554,
0.7115558982,
0.0306516811,
1.0056227446,
0.6875078082,
-0.1707537174,
0.0765925795,
0.1448890269,
0.1106852815,
-0.2816027701,
-0.2684459984,
-0.5225318074,
-0.6431823373,
-0.5876967311,
-0.0447357297,
0.1021735296,
-0.0341989435,
0.0391012654,
-0.3781599402,
-0.3311312795,
0.7845150828,
0.2467851043,
-0.0158618484,
0.9841995835,
-0.0010417678,
0.153547436,
-0.1962094754,
-0.3974433839,
-0.800706625,
1.2804640532,
0.4020399451,
0.7342808247,
0.2588163018,
0.8572946787,
0.6778103709,
0.659114182,
-0.5371223092,
0.4558456242,
-0.3436594307,
-0.5362607837,
-0.0191630628,
-0.8981713057,
-0.7437959909,
0.4492436647,
-0.1297765374,
-0.6406648159,
0.1837120503,
0.3492522538,
-0.3828251064,
0.261654526,
-0.5787748098,
0.5697035193,
-0.087039791,
0.0027963149,
-0.5170298815,
-0.7079996467,
0.7803586721,
0.0627368987,
0.6575260758,
-0.6230638027,
-0.2007613331,
0.8985288739,
-0.3823774159,
0.5830975175,
-0.4341494143,
-0.0174422413,
0.1724853516,
-0.1191418022,
-0.0155781833,
0.3598468304,
0.0664219186,
0.3260354996,
-0.2275642455,
-0.6339190006,
-0.4122478962,
0.6562132239,
-0.6403422952,
-0.4091577828,
-0.4683673382,
-0.6856293082,
0.0150108766,
0.1938120127,
0.1847938001,
0.1555575281,
-0.15089266,
-0.0354654044,
0.3538301885,
-0.3558990657,
0.4053752124,
0.5838026404,
-0.4374147058,
-0.3623291552,
0.6693975329,
0.1110697612,
0.1539987922,
0.0762848705,
0.1065789834,
-0.1286416352,
-0.6304710507,
-0.2672039866,
0.0244901199,
-0.886580348,
-0.259424597,
-0.8502368331,
-0.0420975015,
-0.2645563781,
-0.1395294964,
-0.1479613632,
-1.0289467573,
0.1149375662,
-0.1772339195,
0.11475683,
0.6842635274,
-0.2924643755,
0.2848020196,
-0.5592520833,
0.8335337639,
0.1621787697,
0.4426056147,
0.2695539594,
-0.3381484449,
0.0670820773,
-0.0306999311,
-0.4905499816,
-0.4420582056,
0.1079627573,
-0.0948785916,
0.5981065035,
0.1325765252,
0.0663705394,
0.1341053545,
-0.4171879888,
0.7350197434,
0.5324847698,
-1.0255179405,
0.2419838607,
-0.4026013017,
0.377841562,
0.7395972013,
0.1099782586,
-0.6074545979,
-0.8417403698,
-0.217474103,
-1.0559614897,
0.4756299853,
0.1774714887,
0.3122810423,
0.177811712,
0.0805460587,
0.4948174655,
0.3616633415,
-1.1679031849,
-0.2087323964,
-0.3769631386,
-0.4608633518,
0.1079997942,
-0.0070995451,
-0.227432251,
-0.0946033597,
0.1936974525,
0.0738197118,
-0.2186844349,
0.0873739794,
-0.2446300983,
-0.010984675,
0.5686337352,
0.4556013346,
0.9922487736,
-0.1527449638,
0.0531349964,
-0.0355338044,
-0.2673586011,
0.1884715706,
0.2963680029,
-0.4525114,
0.1243288964,
0.1851064116,
0.27622208,
-0.1884623617,
-0.7101249695,
0.827309072,
-0.5436882377,
-0.1928180456,
0.0045921351,
0.0162024274,
0.0165843982,
0.1732328087,
0.3517318964,
0.2712093294,
0.6082171202,
-0.3443036973,
0.0057793348,
0.2335270941,
0.0010771302,
-0.2904164493,
0.9099907875,
0.4830140173,
0.1016921178,
0.2401867211,
-0.2667601705,
-0.0644010082,
0.4812788963,
0.1675792783,
0.8453725576,
0.2034999132,
0.0960128307,
0.0094694523,
0.2103805542,
0.1379187554,
0.2397242486,
-0.0850185826,
-0.6136425734,
-0.5609643459,
-0.4586598575,
-0.3727333546,
-0.0755102336,
-0.5084469318,
0.0467800312,
-0.3714999557,
-0.1540165693,
0.1773165613,
-0.1236258894,
-0.7656803727,
0.1717233509,
0.0795395225,
0.7364504337,
-0.7883538604,
0.0941499025,
0.4170338809,
-0.4083557129,
-0.4161463082,
0.1953144819,
0.1361395121,
-0.4781772196,
0.2604171336,
0.1573923081,
-0.0912163854,
-0.6022640467,
-0.4404082596,
-0.3500871956,
0.8561093807,
0.6275589466,
-0.6014460921,
-0.0948374718,
0.1657245904,
0.3814458847,
-0.2931922376,
0.2614603043,
0.179499492,
0.2585380375,
-0.2773600221,
-0.9160222411,
0.0794465691,
-0.3417348862,
-0.0216034744,
-0.2727155685,
-0.5387704968,
0.8343218565,
-0.5126336217,
-0.1714239419,
-0.097686179,
0.6721625924,
0.5095085502,
0.7353387475,
0.500995338,
0.3635050356,
0.7387163043,
0.0906800032,
1.1007302999,
-0.0144068087,
0.1638449579,
1.1345096827,
-0.2948741913,
0.2975642383,
0.4011644125,
-0.098053202,
0.1681356281,
0.3737747073,
0.2818892002,
0.5297206044,
0.5135908723,
-0.2836363614,
-0.0077073346,
-0.1796052307,
-0.6407314539,
0.3329429626,
-0.0545570403,
-0.338475734,
-0.5960707068,
-0.1595075727,
0.1060897484,
0.6153600216,
-0.5978794098,
0.8656692505,
0.4482440054,
-0.3836549222,
0.1411624104,
0.5200529695,
1.0145434141,
-0.2368798554,
0.0177184809,
-0.5243371725,
0.130347833,
-0.6045999527,
-0.8347160816,
0.3520919085,
0.5004451871,
-0.5961161852,
-0.0989720374,
0.470069617,
-0.286483705,
-0.5180965662,
0.0959884077,
0.679246068,
0.193544358,
0.2682880461,
-0.3334984779,
-0.1190233082,
-0.0058733365,
-0.2208703011,
0.3731913567,
0.3689276874,
-0.2419630736,
0.449778825,
0.2615647614,
0.1950509399,
-0.2062308937,
0.3562530279,
0.6428424716,
-0.683401823,
-0.8257320523,
-0.8814462423,
0.6924823523,
-0.2920649052,
-0.2299004942,
0.746066153,
0.7874499559,
0.8512846828,
0.0547151566,
1.0973960161,
0.0118509196,
0.8285935521,
-0.3512970805,
0.9844587445,
-0.6095727682,
0.4033213854,
-0.4301344752,
-0.8765230179,
-0.2787231803,
0.3973448873,
-0.2091257572,
0.2801815867,
0.0918127522,
0.3674089313,
-0.1025391221,
0.042632103,
-0.0994605049,
-0.0685990602,
0.4121837318,
0.5756504536,
0.9219329953,
-0.080736354,
0.491296351,
0.1927520931,
-0.4222194254,
-0.0260129943,
-1.0454877615,
-0.7673436403,
-0.0301459432,
-0.2068103105,
-0.2775696516,
0.0432508849,
0.9516146183,
0.4638278484,
-0.8573178053,
-0.3254781365,
0.1710316092,
0.483851552,
0.2303024977,
-0.2664619982,
0.1765261292,
-0.1234481856,
-0.6141449213,
-0.3554652333,
-0.0018070125,
-0.0278046299,
-0.0078178756,
-0.182118997,
0.5593656301,
0.0105924951,
0.5176202655,
0.0886818171,
-0.6197779179,
-0.0132525507,
-0.3934417069,
-0.277533263,
0.1520560384,
0.7888954878,
-0.8261894584,
0.2048394978,
0.4755721688,
0.5122998357,
0.3018367589,
0.2498839647,
0.7557180524,
-0.7160311937,
0.1402022094,
0.4496136606,
0.3393300176,
0.4254997373,
-0.2205144167,
0.1958900988,
0.0908421278,
-0.404045105,
-0.822834909,
0.094316408,
-0.8555722833,
-0.2213540971,
0.8019829988,
-0.0499386713,
0.2502466738,
0.0396450646,
-0.0643784255,
0.0908767432,
-0.7292726636,
1.2017886639,
0.5192681551,
-0.1545552462,
0.3056393564,
-0.4337879717,
0.4294725657,
0.2420095354,
-1.104552269,
0.110421218,
0.8096610904,
0.4518606067,
-0.2603920996,
1.1563383341,
-0.5556215048,
0.482472688,
-0.5719894171,
0.0127929859,
0.05440671,
-0.0390257612,
-0.4326679409,
0.3386388719,
-0.0041176784,
0.0229494199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07879v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07879v2
|
Toxicity Detection is NOT all you Need: Measuring the Gaps to Supporting Volunteer Content Moderators
| 2023-11-14T03:18:28 | 2024-02-17T04:30:54 |
Yang Trista Cao, Lovely-Frances Domingo, Sarah Ann Gilbert, Michelle Mazurek, Katie Shilton, Hal Daumé III
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Extensive efforts in automated approaches for content moderation have been
focused on developing models to identify toxic, offensive, and hateful content
with the aim of lightening the load for moderators. Yet, it remains uncertain
whether improvements on those tasks have truly addressed moderators' needs in
accomplishing their work. In this paper, we surface gaps between past research
efforts that have aimed to provide automation for aspects of content moderation
and the needs of volunteer content moderators, regarding identifying violations
of various moderation rules. To do so, we conduct a model review on Hugging
Face to reveal the availability of models to cover various moderation rules and
guidelines from three exemplar forums. We further put state-of-the-art LLMs to
the test, evaluating how well these models perform in flagging violations of
platform rules from one particular forum. Finally, we conduct a user survey
study with volunteer moderators to gain insight into their perspectives on
useful moderation models. Overall, we observe a non-trivial gap, as missing
developed models and LLMs exhibit moderate to low performance on a significant
portion of the rules. Moderators' reports provide guides for future work on
developing moderation assistant models.
|
[
-0.6353759766,
-0.5830239058,
0.9204506874,
0.1607284546,
-0.3167185783,
-0.2763454616,
0.3194270432,
-0.3891877234,
0.0777436271,
0.6990551949,
-0.7919234037,
-0.3953515887,
-1.0329474211,
0.432908237,
-0.5143032074,
0.9426280856,
0.0317722596,
-0.0121681793,
-0.5831611753,
-0.0589082129,
-0.5321834087,
0.0507848114,
-0.7453022003,
-0.1523384303,
0.8931945562,
0.2705960572,
0.2767113149,
0.5891206861,
0.4930491745,
0.2987444699,
-0.3422556818,
0.3538891375,
-0.4112614691,
0.1512080282,
-0.1480603814,
-0.3889514804,
-0.5698708892,
0.1968881935,
-0.0186281595,
0.3179034293,
0.1280342489,
0.1259846538,
-0.0284958426,
0.4245679677,
-0.8042114377,
0.1086681485,
-0.3368152082,
0.0997129157,
-0.0500872806,
-0.2654489577,
-0.257452637,
-0.3949417472,
-0.2585823834,
-0.5333350897,
0.0500146337,
-0.2256016135,
0.4922131002,
0.323898375,
-1.0610961914,
-0.5924168825,
-0.4950358868,
0.8042967319,
-0.8789787292,
0.2102030814,
0.6168660522,
0.1764564961,
-0.283498913,
-0.4538548887,
-0.6987322569,
-0.1512902975,
0.0250491258,
-0.0696236789,
-0.224116534,
0.0759697184,
0.0677739456,
0.3881124258,
-0.1819605231,
0.102971755,
-0.183803305,
-0.260286659,
0.5825284123,
0.4268101752,
0.4650093913,
-0.4502821565,
-0.5062614679,
-0.0423352234,
-0.602070868,
0.0293442197,
0.5622415543,
0.0054060286,
-0.3398427069,
0.5422609448,
0.2139740884,
0.3917265236,
-0.0609509461,
0.2427379638,
-0.3281745613,
-0.6146336794,
-0.0733211637,
-0.6399328709,
0.7218995094,
0.8063471913,
-0.0869909823,
0.2081204653,
-0.3812649846,
0.1451179087,
0.350009352,
-0.8144573569,
-0.4386137724,
0.2050791532,
-0.6748142242,
-0.5704511404,
0.12699233,
-0.3382722735,
-1.0345600843,
-0.1301662475,
0.3993827701,
0.08081083,
-0.63697052,
-0.2231793106,
-0.4592971206,
-0.1227173954,
0.6043713093,
-0.4554936588,
0.2499051541,
0.8010547161,
1.0354939699,
-0.300047785,
0.3307867944,
-0.7137788534,
-0.282900691,
-0.1885855049,
0.9511173368,
-0.5304936171,
-0.3595380187,
0.1524834633,
0.3994768858,
0.2371843904,
-0.6482969522,
0.7597588301,
-0.771051228,
-0.0509023219,
-0.9449130893,
-0.6177091002,
-0.0519316457,
0.3487699926,
-0.9695193768,
0.6325149536,
0.4577666223,
-0.4736079276,
0.4866167903,
-0.4570225179,
-0.0311493706,
0.031528201,
0.1579352319,
-0.403770715,
0.0546221584,
-0.0393702239,
0.3487486541,
-0.0926649198,
0.0767705142,
-0.6114838123,
-0.4790645242,
0.3308567405,
-0.1182439327,
1.0943654776,
0.2034207284,
-0.1641529351,
0.4300556481,
-0.172149986,
-0.3375289738,
-0.4033940732,
-0.4853892326,
-0.1869156212,
0.3359389007,
0.4470970333,
0.5243481994,
-0.1563751698,
-0.609749794,
-0.2880644202,
0.0103740804,
0.4713718593,
1.2309336662,
-0.0013324284,
0.294378221,
-0.8504523635,
0.7467849851,
0.2236105651,
0.4987405241,
-0.2002082467,
-0.3759096861,
-0.8068093657,
-0.220367074,
-0.0027669866,
0.1655374169,
-0.578894794,
0.7712973356,
0.3876955509,
-0.583337605,
-0.2076343,
0.3756234348,
0.2212367356,
0.2773141861,
0.2435067296,
-0.8399832845,
-0.4450209439,
-0.5434678793,
-0.1666808575,
-0.4532659352,
-0.2190752625,
0.3985083103,
0.3943517804,
-0.2465401292,
0.6320983171,
0.0825340971,
-0.5943413973,
0.1357835978,
-0.0333438776,
-0.1663834751,
0.2635369003,
0.5874680281,
-0.8403912187,
-0.6883367896,
-0.1904333979,
-0.7680088878,
-0.48243469,
0.2899845839,
-0.1167288423,
-0.0892952904,
0.5949569345,
-0.4018049836,
0.359274894,
0.7042145133,
-0.4178202748,
0.4117074013,
0.268958658,
0.4278576374,
-0.4450011551,
0.0482843108,
0.1760342866,
-0.4753777683,
-0.6966010332,
-0.0221717637,
0.1299629658,
0.2959781885,
-0.5188332796,
0.5510932803,
-0.2719635963,
0.3502804637,
-0.6722838879,
0.2346756607,
0.0075035281,
-0.0013652345,
-0.1773748696,
0.3643865883,
0.3298204839,
-0.7845414281,
0.5205838084,
0.1169173792,
-0.0125541119,
0.8534368873,
-0.6203615665,
-0.0201169532,
-0.1025734097,
0.5143054128,
-1.1914135218,
-0.4028098285,
0.5990355611,
-0.4086127579,
-0.1287126392,
-0.2689225376,
-0.3450493515,
-0.2913236618,
-0.5717792511,
0.5650584698,
0.3241286278,
-0.1871931404,
0.4398390055,
0.7135465145,
-0.0712175816,
-0.3426110148,
-0.2258357406,
-0.0097239064,
-0.2022445649,
-0.5327945948,
-0.0289015938,
-0.1260634512,
-0.2326949686,
0.0920791477,
-0.321118027,
-0.1421880275,
0.2145905644,
0.4291804135,
-0.2540820539,
-0.057089027,
-0.0570827983,
-0.0848499537,
0.0109749231,
0.5053112507,
0.4782058001,
0.2985140383,
0.2598184645,
-0.4888929427,
-0.6310879588,
0.3023768663,
0.7212384343,
-0.0266099814,
0.4349615574,
0.7174281478,
-0.3625445962,
-0.1654355377,
-0.7343603969,
-0.3788798749,
-0.5318105221,
0.0057652816,
0.4747117758,
-0.9891187549,
0.649100244,
0.2549671829,
0.1577166766,
0.3265622556,
0.4239012599,
-0.0661607832,
1.303887248,
0.9887568355,
0.3056045473,
0.5331078172,
0.3547076285,
0.0422553495,
-0.6196138263,
-0.1701991558,
-0.3905209899,
-0.2659510374,
-0.7096684575,
-0.523526907,
0.5759945512,
-0.3880416751,
-0.1381385177,
0.1830219626,
-0.3432137966,
0.4874025881,
0.1186571419,
0.3319197297,
0.3373926878,
-0.4606375098,
0.3875815272,
-0.132977441,
-0.436111033,
-0.5484179854,
0.700355351,
0.431261003,
0.6852839589,
0.1775297076,
0.1563318074,
0.7179391384,
0.8181028366,
-0.6380264759,
0.3874723315,
-0.1259184778,
-0.7408179641,
-0.04918449,
-0.4779517651,
-0.4959438741,
0.0073671821,
0.0070066894,
-0.0252044126,
0.2889571488,
0.1351402849,
-0.3442748487,
0.3503436148,
-0.389288187,
0.794631958,
0.0451170057,
-0.2614925504,
-0.1370059401,
-0.5491500497,
0.5730858445,
-0.1861708909,
0.4117853343,
-0.4682585001,
-0.2431948185,
0.6481448412,
-0.6919278502,
1.1317495108,
-0.4527045786,
-0.3176643252,
0.4066066444,
0.2954487205,
0.2291566879,
0.0461294614,
-0.0539482497,
-0.2458613068,
0.3596495986,
-0.3585559726,
-0.0962581336,
0.6378270984,
-0.6019234061,
-0.4802162945,
-0.3408915997,
-0.1144378111,
0.0166212972,
0.2089736164,
0.0856584385,
-0.2205103338,
-0.2781969905,
0.2021290958,
0.8336701989,
-0.4013715982,
0.1204251051,
0.5719403028,
0.1346034706,
-0.0246382132,
0.5434013605,
-0.3392781019,
0.2369313687,
-0.0711980909,
-0.0075294836,
-0.2256290615,
-0.3390185833,
-0.4135383964,
0.2283926308,
-0.6858430505,
-0.6458929777,
-0.8347395658,
-0.0624868311,
-0.4007602036,
-0.0669883043,
-0.3660546243,
0.0257215872,
-0.4368890524,
0.1018598676,
0.3669492006,
0.9622719884,
-0.3669513166,
0.4731289446,
-0.7982877493,
0.2189288437,
0.3022191823,
0.4051360488,
0.0105762994,
-0.5054014921,
0.0454702228,
0.0149328997,
-0.6582169533,
-1.2200790644,
0.1248797551,
-0.0667697266,
0.312438786,
0.6592975259,
0.1777183861,
0.5523576736,
0.031454362,
0.7183836699,
-0.0791554078,
-0.893689394,
0.4721508026,
-0.5940352678,
-0.1311531812,
0.4800724387,
0.5015062094,
-0.9776961803,
-0.7140606642,
-0.2293103784,
-0.5357071161,
0.6926660538,
0.1147689,
0.576588273,
-0.3502101898,
0.3562813997,
0.0882903561,
0.2701665759,
-1.0022066832,
0.0337179005,
0.0441900007,
0.0765289217,
0.3952190876,
-0.3838110864,
-0.1622305959,
0.0591711402,
0.5196599364,
-0.0587101318,
0.0432821549,
-0.0149686681,
-0.0807060003,
-0.9306878448,
-0.0774961263,
0.3619965315,
0.7382158637,
0.0177147761,
0.2304539382,
-0.0785824955,
-0.0948765352,
0.0952586755,
-0.3019658029,
0.0423669517,
-0.0686715022,
0.358933568,
0.174122408,
0.317250818,
-0.8868924975,
1.2636176348,
-0.2989883125,
0.0282172263,
-0.3270339668,
0.4386475384,
0.1171007454,
0.3168184161,
-0.1024481729,
-0.1462919116,
0.180896312,
-0.6586356759,
0.4724887609,
0.7195824981,
-0.8315971494,
-0.409101963,
0.7777113318,
0.3894958198,
-0.1217860654,
0.634878993,
-0.1160361916,
-0.4615165293,
0.9397768974,
0.1003485098,
0.5289860368,
-0.4236178398,
0.4673944712,
0.2495102137,
0.3809215724,
0.1020132229,
0.1334990114,
-0.2594195604,
-0.462466687,
-0.326623559,
-0.6505218744,
-0.3829304576,
0.2803223431,
-0.5642105341,
0.6513018012,
-0.7312576175,
-0.1621496975,
0.0820356011,
-0.0578733459,
-0.5044955611,
-0.0061186799,
0.0078612147,
1.0881918669,
-1.3385828733,
-0.1486138701,
0.505818367,
-0.3241357207,
-0.1829621047,
-0.3770700395,
0.4867021143,
-0.5305874348,
0.1926362962,
0.3070774078,
0.0854692608,
-0.3898489773,
-0.7605501413,
-0.2261722088,
0.8822321892,
-0.1187460348,
-0.1896448433,
-0.1514078975,
-0.0920120627,
0.7224714756,
-0.2462717295,
0.5937808752,
0.3185307086,
0.4213625491,
-0.0592271984,
-0.8287686706,
0.3248139918,
-0.314802289,
-0.0848178342,
0.1349481344,
-0.8292672038,
0.9592294693,
0.3033998013,
-0.3184591234,
0.4199979901,
0.2812756598,
0.274184525,
0.6362212896,
0.8660399318,
0.2535294592,
0.2115445137,
0.0180208702,
0.707613647,
0.2214051485,
0.1978294253,
0.3885645568,
-0.1104737669,
0.3187000751,
0.3682306707,
0.0062487777,
0.4965375364,
0.952041924,
-0.2701937854,
0.2924062312,
0.0849668011,
-0.7206794024,
-0.7194173932,
-0.6928873658,
-0.3051158786,
0.2284348756,
0.4227315485,
-0.640232861,
-0.4052783847,
0.032419879,
0.1279284358,
0.128021881,
-0.1517559141,
0.7781491876,
0.1581360847,
-0.7374191284,
0.1015014797,
0.2953334153,
0.68381387,
-0.2985813916,
-0.2192174941,
-0.2922040224,
-0.0261222068,
-0.4522983134,
-0.7845652103,
0.4241356254,
0.0789549127,
0.1255972683,
-0.2858789563,
0.9223176241,
-0.0600628294,
0.1102988496,
0.4579150677,
0.7744312882,
0.2189074159,
-0.2693844438,
-0.6058701873,
0.5673235655,
-0.2666662633,
-0.0757989809,
0.2650178373,
0.3577059209,
-0.1309045106,
0.4709733129,
0.6868063807,
-0.0075395945,
-0.0744719803,
-0.0344040692,
1.12611866,
-0.3666513562,
-0.2072486877,
-0.8104946613,
0.5766187906,
0.0340166874,
-0.1494687349,
0.6046913266,
0.3110002279,
0.934954226,
0.1204642355,
0.5712997913,
-0.33982867,
0.3875444531,
-0.1449356228,
0.8529005647,
-0.8428157568,
0.3341452181,
-0.055053249,
-0.7613201141,
-0.2751816809,
0.3611581624,
0.1586922407,
0.2929092348,
0.2224390954,
1.2201467752,
-0.2567905784,
0.0224306956,
0.1697097421,
0.1467144787,
0.6482038498,
0.5102430582,
1.1654509306,
-0.3732600212,
0.4979579747,
-0.2359022051,
-0.4714121521,
-0.4817298949,
-1.0323076248,
-1.1382877827,
-0.5329956412,
-0.2598098814,
-0.4786966145,
-0.0793702975,
0.5066384673,
0.7972580791,
-0.7331365347,
0.0091014262,
-0.2119168639,
0.472998023,
-0.0702511743,
-0.2660505474,
-0.3195359409,
-0.0879516453,
-0.5656069517,
0.1026385054,
0.16825445,
-0.3131844401,
-0.3914899826,
-0.0879269168,
-0.0276147742,
0.2345577925,
0.6330833435,
0.490000397,
-0.6983228326,
-0.4192209244,
0.2823880017,
-0.3240173161,
-0.1290244907,
0.8093317151,
-0.3302040994,
0.5126985908,
0.6357994676,
0.3883527219,
0.2076901197,
0.1022170112,
0.3074341416,
-0.6512750983,
-0.5155160427,
0.3942274451,
-0.1129371002,
0.4503197372,
-0.4079917669,
0.2802500725,
0.2948478758,
-1.0024652481,
-1.0804239511,
0.3757674992,
-0.8689426184,
-0.0296210777,
1.0033627748,
-0.0753205121,
-0.1862049848,
-0.1808894873,
-0.1026599482,
0.4299959838,
-0.1245133951,
1.2248595953,
0.9721511602,
-0.4207606316,
-0.3533627093,
-0.8519570827,
0.7415776253,
0.3953021169,
-0.822451055,
0.2250253111,
0.8923972845,
0.6016438007,
-0.0007211822,
0.8847796321,
-0.3577995598,
0.704810977,
-0.3305436075,
-0.4313405752,
0.0934777707,
-0.1879531443,
-0.3183297515,
-0.1515328288,
0.0897131488,
0.4450886846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07853v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07853v2
|
Learning Mutually Informed Representations for Characters and Subwords
| 2023-11-14T02:09:10 | 2024-04-08T15:23:39 |
Yilin Wang, Xinyi Hu, Matthew R. Gormley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Most pretrained language models rely on subword tokenization, which processes
text as a sequence of subword tokens. However, different granularities of text,
such as characters, subwords, and words, can contain different kinds of
information. Previous studies have shown that incorporating multiple input
granularities improves model generalization, yet very few of them outputs
useful representations for each granularity. In this paper, we introduce the
entanglement model, aiming to combine character and subword language models.
Inspired by vision-language models, our model treats characters and subwords as
separate modalities, and it generates mutually informed representations for
both granularities as output. We evaluate our model on text classification,
named entity recognition, POS-tagging, and character-level sequence labeling
(intraword code-switching). Notably, the entanglement model outperforms its
backbone language models, particularly in the presence of noisy texts and
low-resource languages. Furthermore, the entanglement model even outperforms
larger pre-trained models on all English sequence labeling tasks and
classification tasks. We make our code publically available.
|
[
-0.0694549456,
-0.6548700333,
0.5687028766,
-0.2264941484,
-0.5024749637,
0.0632643625,
-0.188324973,
-0.5908283591,
0.192366302,
0.5999004841,
-0.1744463891,
-0.4125742912,
-0.773758471,
0.2102145255,
-0.368429482,
0.8699501157,
-0.1028253511,
0.362067759,
-0.488191694,
0.1247090027,
-0.2833975255,
-0.7168512344,
-0.424195677,
-0.7174212337,
0.4694484174,
-0.0817085132,
0.8725686669,
0.3785457015,
0.5083265305,
0.3793718815,
0.0125329942,
0.2905509472,
-0.3945047557,
-0.0934035927,
-0.3462485373,
-0.7144665122,
-0.1784436256,
-0.0044560139,
0.5512081385,
0.633132875,
0.0409569927,
-0.2162510753,
0.1877867728,
0.2970993519,
-0.40426597,
0.2376816571,
-0.5486127734,
0.2220606953,
-0.3012851775,
-0.0343518108,
-0.4807964861,
-0.1865448207,
0.0992297232,
-0.7612078786,
0.0287835468,
0.0870455578,
1.0055067539,
0.1103811339,
-0.370927453,
-0.4161307812,
-0.4903226495,
0.7270035148,
-0.6046386361,
0.8416512012,
0.5124132633,
-0.1806387305,
0.0640479699,
-0.7956534624,
-0.5495690703,
-0.2465340346,
-0.3661365807,
0.2525206506,
-0.0762803331,
0.264895767,
0.0416557007,
0.2796232104,
-0.2596365809,
0.1676441431,
-0.1609120369,
-0.0692265332,
0.5699980259,
0.0015267266,
0.5519931912,
-0.0031253526,
-0.3619190156,
-0.0147818187,
-0.5863026977,
0.0446530245,
0.3001482189,
0.0750631019,
-0.1331005394,
0.5265769958,
0.1149019003,
0.6942797899,
0.5508776307,
-0.0901696235,
0.0467510708,
-0.2552563846,
-0.1902524531,
0.012338236,
0.8068345189,
-0.0192886386,
0.2267603725,
-0.7365769148,
-0.1819161326,
-0.0706463754,
0.1839519143,
-0.8660257459,
-0.2451560199,
-0.0297408719,
-0.680845499,
-0.1586623341,
0.2082876861,
-0.3154161274,
-0.5675001144,
-0.3864726126,
0.6732994318,
-0.7459705472,
-0.2657121718,
0.2942497432,
-0.1298625767,
-0.0001626348,
0.2064153403,
-1.1276038885,
0.1959736347,
0.5650108457,
0.6055926681,
-0.0351824798,
-0.3422531188,
-0.2279469818,
0.3725185394,
-0.5550931692,
0.4125266969,
-1.2356129885,
-0.3542575538,
-0.1643318534,
-0.1243780032,
-0.265322715,
-0.3236827552,
-0.0737622604,
-0.6946932077,
0.2627724707,
-0.1382942945,
-0.8752782345,
-0.4356795549,
0.1249099448,
-0.7870758176,
0.4915075004,
-0.0126427468,
-0.946187675,
0.4437422454,
-0.3633532226,
-0.3669059873,
0.3779556155,
-0.6057598591,
-0.3884415627,
0.4111289382,
0.3657369018,
0.4404753447,
-0.1606070995,
0.278493613,
-0.1630080491,
-0.474745959,
0.4096634984,
-0.2241248041,
0.405228287,
-0.0073386906,
0.1618859917,
0.0061129821,
-0.3780313432,
-0.2038204223,
0.0676632524,
-0.478376627,
-0.529004097,
-0.0126487371,
-0.2684180439,
-0.0567146763,
0.6184370518,
-0.5294753313,
-0.0989600569,
-0.3321945369,
0.4307702482,
0.3533701599,
0.0126338061,
0.7873196006,
-0.2056891322,
0.5540656447,
0.5431444645,
-0.0236060061,
-0.2649516165,
-0.3540992141,
-0.8173168898,
-0.1396149844,
0.8086158037,
0.3915999532,
-1.1189457178,
0.5312207937,
-0.1365405321,
-0.310737431,
-0.618730247,
-0.144179821,
0.5820339918,
0.0502687208,
0.2116873711,
-0.7017368078,
-0.2718448043,
-0.7122353315,
-0.6219816208,
-0.2301994413,
-0.0165880341,
0.0898871943,
0.3661863208,
-0.4714422226,
0.9818413854,
-0.180566743,
-0.2273579538,
-0.416518569,
0.3677648008,
0.0964838564,
0.5689738989,
0.3073775172,
-0.9048190713,
-0.4840146899,
0.297865957,
-0.6519361138,
0.2730326653,
-0.2604051232,
-0.1054680943,
-0.1170063093,
0.6519656777,
-0.320662111,
0.4083687067,
0.4654839933,
-0.2109829187,
0.4120346606,
-0.2624524832,
0.1645261049,
-1.1856342554,
-0.2909934223,
-0.1272160113,
-0.4290968776,
-0.5332825184,
0.397859484,
0.130047217,
-0.2145407349,
-0.0985666066,
0.3530641794,
-0.6157730222,
0.000571663,
0.0257023945,
-0.0386902466,
0.2705441117,
0.4178310931,
0.5404589772,
0.6762744784,
0.7152770758,
-0.5107049346,
0.2139947563,
0.1637517214,
-0.3388540745,
0.3066516221,
-0.7559229136,
0.2208401114,
-0.4668597281,
0.0517650694,
-0.4775174558,
-0.1915129423,
0.0272808857,
-0.5202245116,
0.5864574313,
-0.1505191922,
-0.5436035395,
0.1914173961,
0.1415221542,
0.5118704438,
0.487000227,
-0.4588097334,
1.0134314299,
0.6544713974,
0.086119853,
-0.2340877801,
-0.9698591828,
-0.1139983162,
-0.0324888155,
-0.4501244426,
0.5995898843,
0.2085587978,
0.1450046748,
0.305501461,
0.0200122688,
-0.2709410191,
-0.2066420615,
0.1634077877,
-0.0039417343,
0.0513005294,
0.4623255432,
0.010335152,
-0.0766102672,
-0.1433822215,
-0.3447034061,
0.7109331489,
-0.1371730715,
-0.5638697743,
-0.0374902561,
0.475322336,
0.1867260039,
-0.7589184046,
0.8177866936,
0.84272331,
-0.6119627357,
-0.1515997797,
-0.1058493257,
-0.1525169611,
-0.5088273287,
0.8015660644,
-0.6039280295,
-1.2095082998,
0.4739750922,
-0.1177658215,
-0.0053819288,
0.1984393895,
0.2053265423,
-0.0853299573,
1.1473350525,
1.0051783323,
0.1212248802,
0.8118094206,
0.0132810762,
0.6903216839,
-0.6383485794,
-0.3333550692,
-0.214106679,
-0.1818838865,
-0.5364222527,
-0.7082915902,
0.3435696959,
0.66332376,
0.0149378087,
0.5344278216,
-0.3365791142,
0.7920455337,
0.5356020927,
0.4937018752,
0.2635881901,
0.1157403439,
-0.3951349258,
-0.1794722825,
-0.7875646353,
-0.4486451447,
0.8101697564,
0.5126283169,
1.271699667,
0.0336516351,
1.2098197937,
0.0698517114,
-0.1890011877,
-0.741750598,
0.5239828825,
-0.6308491826,
-0.3578175604,
-0.1504178494,
-0.554584682,
-0.9151195884,
0.2797487378,
-0.3868655562,
-0.7644249201,
0.344032824,
-0.1101311594,
-0.3400736451,
0.3559551537,
-0.8116122484,
0.6355708241,
-0.0519967191,
-0.0723647252,
-0.4097310007,
-0.2540290058,
0.3251085281,
-0.1615283191,
0.0563684702,
0.2947890162,
-0.0583823174,
0.8564319611,
-0.1998529881,
0.8984822035,
0.3301310837,
0.002881269,
0.3406591117,
0.2234676629,
0.3889075816,
0.1586402655,
0.2108802646,
0.4355307519,
-0.1002811566,
-0.0539619215,
-0.4523643255,
0.4013738334,
-0.7735322714,
-0.2205813378,
-0.4136221707,
-0.5263020992,
-0.1672808826,
0.4167880714,
0.5418787599,
0.8529626131,
-0.0206218511,
0.0426225848,
1.0865827799,
-0.186242342,
0.4261615872,
0.4642817378,
-0.4854069948,
-0.3652579784,
0.982526958,
0.181160301,
0.1351471543,
0.8709929585,
0.0855049044,
-0.3564262092,
-0.3951553404,
-0.1864096671,
0.3748762608,
-0.7022858858,
-0.0447977111,
-0.6416593194,
-0.5396044254,
-0.4653168917,
-0.2130309343,
-0.1990745515,
-0.1161082163,
-0.4299348891,
-0.0187729485,
0.0566315912,
1.1765794754,
0.0855266973,
0.3845277429,
-1.0605911016,
0.3016211092,
0.6865223646,
0.4325449467,
0.0389719941,
-0.3783082366,
-0.6689465046,
0.0712478086,
-0.1437244117,
-1.2163422108,
0.1029941887,
0.3488005698,
0.633020699,
0.5065264702,
-0.0708785206,
0.7427739501,
-0.4797661602,
0.7824252248,
0.5256545544,
-1.338526845,
0.0883445591,
-0.0972352996,
0.5266627073,
0.3497222066,
0.5769159794,
-0.7402505279,
-0.4095482826,
-0.4652725756,
-0.4429703653,
0.7489632964,
-0.0206181351,
0.0017407612,
-0.1689613163,
0.0007241126,
0.1670037508,
0.1461581439,
-0.9999843836,
0.2968929708,
0.0003385097,
-0.4711854458,
0.114943549,
-0.1562524438,
0.1543818563,
-0.0980837941,
0.6080667973,
-0.0875995159,
0.565248847,
0.1732180715,
-0.6286193728,
-0.0490908921,
0.1770489514,
-0.0069671758,
0.6345531344,
0.222518757,
0.3984363079,
0.0735225454,
-0.5824225545,
-0.2089540511,
-0.0066266628,
-0.2780079246,
0.2469128519,
0.7650575638,
0.9421903491,
0.3132112324,
-0.3999385238,
0.3982486427,
-0.2642177939,
0.123886697,
0.2351964414,
-0.0074974336,
0.3187408149,
0.3622293472,
-0.0073489868,
0.0564872846,
0.1114598662,
-0.4919147491,
0.277723074,
0.4514151812,
-0.5526150465,
-0.3628442585,
0.5615532994,
0.3089706004,
-0.1581045091,
0.337038219,
-0.4619610906,
-0.7334608436,
0.402158469,
0.6328566074,
0.8547748923,
-0.1732492149,
0.3789033294,
0.2724250257,
0.3790583313,
-0.0116163809,
0.1674549133,
-0.1660114974,
-0.9179366231,
-0.2622788548,
-0.9043322802,
-0.3796370327,
-0.2194335014,
-0.5914220214,
0.1907673329,
-0.3915766776,
-0.2285413295,
-0.1878744364,
-0.04211073,
-0.725432992,
0.1728767157,
0.3184874058,
0.5479501486,
-0.7868561745,
0.8091176748,
0.9046599269,
-0.5753070116,
-0.6979379058,
0.1914298534,
-0.6746001244,
-0.8533471227,
0.43375808,
0.3831723034,
-0.0047996063,
0.1094291732,
-0.5199725032,
-1.0932496786,
0.8106174469,
0.4010032415,
-0.8511659503,
-0.1829444319,
0.3862323463,
0.3232783675,
-0.4738786519,
0.4506432116,
0.2934683859,
0.1772129983,
-0.118908748,
-0.8666225076,
-0.1122277752,
-0.0307808127,
0.3685741127,
0.3207584023,
-0.5045398474,
1.1648643017,
-0.0422637686,
-0.5717774034,
-0.361669749,
0.9669399261,
0.0612773038,
-0.135730952,
0.4204750359,
0.8184378147,
0.7275825739,
-0.0435406007,
0.7358720899,
-0.297416538,
0.3651259243,
1.0397313833,
-0.0497181825,
0.6996198893,
0.208046928,
-0.3391094506,
0.7354254723,
0.6546700597,
0.3420558572,
0.7082654834,
0.0019538,
-0.1294877082,
-0.6336356997,
-0.1940962225,
-0.4168520272,
0.3562941551,
0.3643430471,
-0.4488457143,
-0.3707681,
0.0888119042,
-0.0440389253,
0.0131406654,
-0.394969523,
0.9879823327,
0.2282706946,
-0.520244658,
0.1899328381,
0.3357672989,
0.8715186715,
-0.8515397906,
-0.0585228577,
-0.098959513,
0.245128423,
-0.2138586491,
-0.7096574306,
0.0517635755,
-0.2237942815,
-0.236509636,
-0.1647853255,
0.8847061396,
-1.1687383652,
-0.5548744202,
0.1835103631,
0.0443553068,
0.1786796302,
-0.0276441202,
-0.6140028834,
-0.0217985641,
-0.1154450029,
0.1366301626,
0.3980842233,
0.5885775685,
-0.0760939196,
0.2155198008,
0.2787424922,
-0.1198573038,
0.4049038291,
0.155665189,
0.7534358501,
-0.4496912062,
-0.8851426244,
-0.7152938247,
0.3537961841,
-0.1389925629,
-0.2012856305,
0.7097509503,
0.3340581357,
0.9899277091,
-0.139672488,
0.7233814001,
-0.027029084,
0.0910852626,
-0.6360780001,
0.8139808774,
-0.4461063445,
-0.2395758927,
-0.0781344026,
-0.8391409516,
-0.0113884136,
0.7990110517,
-0.2678540945,
0.1647098809,
0.7922254205,
0.583881557,
-0.0595669337,
0.1640933901,
0.4254462421,
-0.1792420745,
0.1658231765,
0.7929440737,
0.6543911099,
-0.5341758728,
0.173414886,
-0.0407664292,
-0.2347931713,
-0.0948158279,
-0.6975179315,
-1.3279474974,
-0.8227239251,
-0.3369882405,
-0.0465093702,
-0.0565952808,
0.7217938304,
0.8844991326,
-0.5915522575,
0.0007762489,
-0.3122411072,
0.166358605,
-0.1520698071,
-0.1701021194,
0.0399098508,
-0.5155408978,
-0.8256137967,
0.2483750135,
0.2252296954,
0.1329966187,
-0.3230437636,
-0.3125793636,
-0.1178083122,
0.5437422395,
0.337557435,
-0.281614691,
-0.5378320217,
-0.0981715247,
-0.1812318861,
-0.2063464224,
-0.2165661156,
0.8288702965,
-0.6840307713,
0.5746707916,
0.8360978961,
0.7893391252,
0.4603396654,
-0.0119283758,
0.5280692577,
-0.9135243893,
0.0956982449,
0.2935585976,
0.440291971,
0.240018189,
-0.4664824605,
0.1678197086,
0.0349724256,
-0.4336605668,
-0.4662056565,
0.7077717185,
-0.4372558296,
-0.5234950781,
0.8426598907,
-0.4262481928,
-0.4294729233,
0.0954732001,
-0.0101688448,
0.3828332722,
-0.2142996639,
0.374287039,
0.8713065386,
0.0170104485,
-0.3882943094,
0.3721334636,
0.3464984596,
0.3806852996,
-0.6835256815,
-0.278906852,
0.2300339788,
-0.0130204624,
0.4057679474,
0.4819649756,
-0.2755723298,
-0.0669524595,
0.3445603549,
0.2072471827,
-0.3562755287,
-0.5403541327,
-0.3926328719,
0.0019156884,
-0.1601261646,
-0.3968996704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07850v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07850v2
|
Bring Your Own KG: Self-Supervised Program Synthesis for Zero-Shot KGQA
| 2023-11-14T02:05:29 | 2024-05-22T02:46:08 |
Dhruv Agarwal, Rajarshi Das, Sopan Khosla, Rashmi Gangadharaiah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG
|
We present BYOKG, a universal question-answering (QA) system that can operate
on any knowledge graph (KG), requires no human-annotated training data, and can
be ready to use within a day -- attributes that are out-of-scope for current
KGQA systems. BYOKG draws inspiration from the remarkable ability of humans to
comprehend information present in an unseen KG through exploration -- starting
at random nodes, inspecting the labels of adjacent nodes and edges, and
combining them with their prior world knowledge. In BYOKG, exploration
leverages an LLM-backed symbolic agent that generates a diverse set of
query-program exemplars, which are then used to ground a retrieval-augmented
reasoning procedure to predict programs for arbitrary questions. BYOKG is
effective over both small- and large-scale graphs, showing dramatic gains in QA
accuracy over a zero-shot baseline of 27.89 and 58.02 F1 on GrailQA and MetaQA,
respectively. On GrailQA, we further show that our unsupervised BYOKG
outperforms a supervised in-context learning method, demonstrating the
effectiveness of exploration. Lastly, we find that performance of BYOKG
reliably improves with continued exploration as well as improvements in the
base LLM, notably outperforming a state-of-the-art fine-tuned model by 7.08 F1
on a sub-sampled zero-shot split of GrailQA.
|
[
-0.4981576502,
-0.6618282199,
0.7847847939,
0.0057117888,
0.0652884468,
0.2890482247,
0.1500090659,
-0.2911580205,
0.3082619607,
0.7930502295,
-0.9860216379,
-0.817668736,
-0.5317881107,
0.0213343333,
-0.1524555832,
0.7881278992,
0.1847545803,
-0.3085492253,
-0.3484641016,
-0.2242022455,
-0.5020905137,
-0.3004206121,
-0.2280475348,
-0.6877289414,
0.3550924659,
0.7490127683,
0.7024950385,
0.4259231687,
0.0983383358,
0.2076098472,
0.2772763669,
-0.2022539079,
-0.4342868924,
0.1545014977,
-0.0921780095,
-0.6122971773,
-0.1744496971,
0.0402707048,
0.184733063,
0.4612158835,
-0.0605195351,
0.5779980421,
-0.2188714445,
0.6890727282,
-0.844312489,
0.1040811688,
-0.5934232473,
0.2092037648,
0.1331991851,
-0.0820295215,
-0.3361140788,
-0.2916778028,
0.2015928775,
-0.9751883745,
0.0267407037,
-0.2016708553,
0.3839642406,
0.5655620694,
-0.7766340971,
-0.3303602636,
-0.5067007542,
0.8886211514,
-0.59063977,
0.4474374652,
0.3424240053,
0.7464936376,
-0.5521230698,
-0.987639606,
-0.3878800571,
-0.1460612565,
-0.06908793,
0.5089234114,
-0.0442024469,
0.2169917524,
0.0488074012,
0.2399348021,
-0.9568901062,
-0.2762064338,
-0.4765585363,
-0.1413050592,
0.8579678535,
0.0231589228,
0.3298255801,
-0.5298921466,
-0.5369305611,
-0.0541012697,
-0.8556497693,
0.4138390422,
0.0163707491,
0.2213331759,
0.437653929,
0.687605679,
-0.8882389069,
0.6367422342,
0.0652084351,
0.3130722046,
0.0143303294,
-0.0159289893,
-0.4689975381,
0.2280569077,
0.9419636726,
0.1148001179,
0.1059461683,
-0.3935414553,
0.2687658072,
-0.2329073399,
0.477099508,
-0.697941184,
-0.6645694971,
0.3530109525,
-0.180106014,
-0.3773107529,
-0.2847449183,
-0.4345412254,
-0.3646821678,
-0.0277368315,
0.9082679749,
-0.2158800066,
0.0561787002,
0.1285614073,
-0.0905982107,
0.2299398482,
0.1897542924,
-0.5082262754,
0.0504941568,
0.4122331738,
0.4993745685,
-0.1410272866,
-0.3661370277,
-0.4211784005,
0.1552227437,
-0.6266873479,
0.7824198008,
-0.3657435775,
-0.720813632,
-0.326404959,
-0.0624126196,
0.2171235979,
-0.50839293,
0.3302076161,
-0.5363899469,
0.3530200422,
-0.5104324222,
-0.6268692017,
-0.5113028288,
0.5440772176,
-0.1013616696,
1.1365705729,
0.3172635436,
-0.4077858031,
0.4675199986,
-0.8689001203,
-0.017704308,
0.431181252,
-0.3345414102,
-0.1090000123,
0.0751951486,
0.5710881948,
0.3604338467,
-0.0085247979,
0.1454660147,
-0.3862183988,
-0.507193923,
0.1179477721,
-0.0514051504,
0.9666280746,
0.1199479699,
0.0494736135,
0.151007086,
-1.0159319639,
0.8273184896,
-0.0150823686,
-0.3485763669,
-0.303616792,
-0.2144883573,
-0.5912132263,
0.2990159392,
0.2480796129,
-0.7433695793,
0.4860891402,
-0.487713635,
-0.0081629213,
0.6791769862,
0.317720741,
0.6985265613,
-0.1239054352,
1.0532062054,
-0.4161832929,
0.3205315471,
-0.2900425494,
-0.5512367487,
-0.4326259494,
-0.3493403792,
0.2322100848,
0.6656395197,
-0.8872825503,
0.178519994,
-0.0966133699,
-0.5998679399,
-0.6622058153,
0.312073797,
0.2878559828,
0.5913158059,
0.4541622102,
-0.2333498299,
-0.2838039994,
-0.7707421184,
-0.1698933542,
-0.380069077,
-0.4312063754,
0.5789545774,
0.2229938209,
-0.2345490009,
1.1839891672,
-0.8788057566,
-0.2718660831,
-0.2914555967,
0.2234986573,
0.2513209581,
0.3644732833,
0.3647856116,
-0.332893312,
-0.8699480295,
0.1777659208,
-1.1966092587,
-0.2362914532,
0.026212085,
-0.4467314184,
-0.2597133815,
0.3732575476,
-0.6178210974,
0.4074575305,
0.4500144124,
-0.3545773625,
0.6838187575,
-0.2039111555,
0.3599959314,
-0.9841181636,
-0.2369811535,
-0.4025992751,
-0.4802415967,
-0.4849862158,
0.4156845212,
-0.0109678041,
-0.3793657124,
-0.5398934484,
1.0055543184,
-0.2568807006,
0.0686061233,
-0.363925159,
0.1108328328,
-0.0547322147,
0.7570728064,
-0.3143440783,
0.8289231062,
0.9371237755,
-0.6043156385,
0.5343980789,
0.6308698058,
-0.2272516191,
0.252466023,
-0.640316844,
0.5191231966,
-0.0957610831,
0.1475467235,
-1.1270843744,
-0.1555529237,
0.4525659084,
-0.8660787344,
0.1294231117,
-0.3825905919,
-0.1536616087,
-0.33600986,
-0.431084305,
0.2632070184,
0.6916661859,
-0.7062493563,
0.8428249359,
0.00269873,
-0.1169369072,
-0.846699357,
-0.6149631739,
0.1049800292,
-0.0344622843,
-0.69457376,
-0.1230184287,
-0.0919129625,
0.2092830688,
0.1416791677,
-0.4098763466,
-0.1595603973,
0.1668025553,
0.5469939709,
-0.0251863357,
-0.1953567117,
0.1799638718,
0.4103565216,
-0.1836102903,
0.1602369547,
-0.5560675263,
0.0631343201,
0.1561643779,
-0.2528453469,
-0.1593026668,
0.3067502379,
0.2967578471,
-0.0941946134,
0.2159924954,
0.3498903811,
-0.014748089,
-0.5312939882,
-0.1642317921,
-0.2136140615,
-0.5837700963,
0.3478035331,
-0.4347375035,
-0.9076805115,
0.610429883,
-0.1537702084,
-0.221860975,
-0.0349744782,
0.3764780164,
-0.2628799081,
0.9332988858,
0.8171085119,
0.045542933,
0.2297141999,
-0.3438152671,
0.056810189,
-0.6567436457,
-0.084932901,
-0.1679786891,
-0.327388972,
-0.7873774171,
-0.2953737676,
0.6873956919,
0.1050555706,
-0.163951546,
0.2440704107,
-0.7464846373,
0.923751533,
0.9180499315,
0.0583791807,
0.2797444761,
-0.3193220496,
-0.0145796221,
0.0656982809,
-1.0986613035,
-0.1729349494,
1.8260376453,
-0.1825784594,
0.880461514,
-0.2794075608,
1.2462160587,
0.5135503411,
0.5393990278,
-0.7572034597,
0.7642657161,
0.0850309059,
-0.9263612032,
-0.523266077,
-0.4560952187,
-0.9020062685,
0.3046800792,
0.0500136502,
-1.0772804022,
-0.0601405501,
0.1808729619,
-0.620233357,
-0.0647457242,
-0.8732484579,
1.0821974277,
-0.0679008886,
-0.0037133968,
0.0408446379,
-0.7441270947,
0.6087939143,
0.002948761,
-0.2910590172,
-0.021905005,
0.349955231,
0.5721181035,
-0.1960709095,
0.5288060904,
-0.232836321,
0.1186918765,
0.8331230283,
0.4683681428,
0.3671614528,
0.1691833436,
0.2144869119,
0.0208655596,
0.5430976748,
-0.6326204538,
-1.1282641888,
0.7358464003,
-0.7858914137,
-0.8502876163,
-0.3438405991,
-0.8277032971,
-0.3848880827,
0.3177583814,
0.2026521862,
0.1348718852,
-0.132605046,
0.2415026128,
0.5412666798,
-0.4833657146,
0.1131383777,
0.4688663483,
-0.6419199705,
-0.3925713599,
0.9254393578,
0.4117091298,
0.3285117745,
0.29363814,
0.4666134715,
-0.5375319719,
-0.1037126333,
-0.7123897672,
0.0271610711,
-0.938334167,
-0.2682792544,
-0.7239646912,
-0.1374783814,
-0.5436794162,
-0.2489769906,
-0.4365619123,
-0.6676796675,
0.0974194482,
-0.1128566861,
-0.0175287817,
0.559902668,
0.0923265368,
0.7079478502,
-0.9178168178,
0.3051063418,
0.6455600858,
0.0555337667,
-0.2841989994,
-0.4096274376,
-0.142735213,
-0.0366730019,
-0.5646365881,
-0.9318820834,
0.2636814713,
-0.1028042287,
0.4735341668,
0.3259384036,
0.4442706108,
0.5956202745,
-0.1896882057,
0.8996149302,
-0.0547497272,
-0.8241819143,
0.5046833754,
-0.3828613162,
0.6973810792,
0.5938223004,
0.4617511332,
-0.5214152336,
-0.6714929938,
-0.6088330746,
-0.472335726,
0.8404515982,
0.201161623,
0.0691651553,
0.1728776693,
0.6277266741,
0.1154021844,
0.2834743559,
-0.7363725305,
-0.1730611622,
-0.2399118394,
-0.1171346679,
0.0903811827,
-0.1815620959,
-0.1314129829,
-0.0713471398,
0.7611948848,
-0.4597831368,
0.2642208636,
0.2593902349,
0.1139108166,
-0.127058059,
0.3057118356,
0.0238403417,
0.6670092344,
-0.3922459483,
0.07774584,
0.4064014554,
-0.0844134986,
0.3188155591,
-0.1777915508,
-0.4591051936,
-0.2218185365,
0.1685877889,
0.1781113595,
-0.2681995928,
-0.7561743855,
0.3121444583,
0.0229805019,
-0.1386675686,
-0.1721314192,
0.365449816,
-0.124231495,
0.5861649513,
0.3731361032,
-0.1515345275,
0.3673193455,
-0.4543396831,
0.2511834502,
0.566383481,
-0.4579161108,
-0.2392790765,
0.6960908771,
-0.2216590345,
-0.2398910224,
0.5608975887,
-0.6046457291,
-0.5276575089,
0.6606882215,
0.4086540341,
1.0598977804,
-0.1198826432,
0.6458695531,
0.3175354004,
0.2874611318,
0.2058163136,
0.2560235262,
-0.5941191912,
-0.7560488582,
-0.601094842,
-0.31244874,
-0.4824571013,
-0.0083036581,
-0.4011597633,
0.1778608412,
-0.4128441811,
0.072298035,
-0.4331036508,
0.2618774474,
-0.4009969831,
0.4529360831,
-0.0262929536,
0.7704025507,
-0.7237309217,
0.7825001478,
0.700735271,
-0.2871897817,
-0.8102596998,
-0.1082404107,
-0.0596834049,
-0.8581438065,
0.3881902099,
-0.0294689126,
-0.004353568,
0.131882742,
-0.8579311371,
-0.845818162,
1.4098519087,
0.3337530196,
0.097698316,
-0.1030030847,
0.0425251648,
0.4042674601,
-0.0506642088,
0.0056835986,
0.2617581785,
0.1786315739,
0.606295526,
-0.5541757941,
-0.0742078424,
0.1497395933,
-0.3110482097,
0.1805650443,
-0.575017333,
0.2712399364,
-0.2884200215,
-0.1870320588,
0.0110369585,
0.6474482417,
0.2269552648,
0.6318981051,
-0.0458919033,
0.5547800064,
0.6710471511,
0.0859107822,
1.1814219952,
-0.1870203465,
0.391107142,
1.2595272064,
-0.0840459615,
0.3915197849,
0.2401137054,
-0.149918884,
0.1451492012,
0.3779625595,
0.2642698884,
0.5816022158,
0.053448163,
-0.3118323684,
-0.4643007815,
0.1902847737,
-0.1991585046,
0.5781816244,
-0.1949530542,
0.0480149761,
-0.6023104787,
-0.0000498652,
-0.1924365908,
-0.1112964153,
-0.3699082732,
0.6472709775,
0.0228828155,
-0.7424460649,
0.5480062366,
-0.1043364406,
0.3188858628,
-0.8906738162,
-0.0089278687,
-0.4429295957,
0.0545026772,
-0.2434105873,
-0.7974973917,
0.3510143757,
-0.2739230692,
0.14654769,
-0.1966597587,
0.9550202489,
-0.3036831617,
-0.6802421808,
0.1708603799,
0.9248365164,
0.1863516569,
-0.3944655359,
-0.5672632456,
-0.6284934282,
0.1347485334,
-0.4639365077,
0.4856320918,
0.7210506201,
-0.1166230887,
1.311177969,
0.504050076,
-0.0702109486,
0.5477611423,
-0.381942451,
0.8176852465,
-0.5723162293,
-0.4134586453,
-0.60453403,
0.3343369961,
0.3570851386,
-0.1670832336,
0.9141120911,
0.5688158274,
0.9693317413,
-0.1579331905,
0.7940224409,
-0.00755521,
0.1662107706,
-0.2431310713,
0.8847455978,
-0.736433208,
-0.1667734385,
-0.062202204,
-0.6855123043,
-0.376365602,
0.51565063,
-0.3385999203,
-0.2127624303,
0.314968586,
1.0106414557,
-0.0388829336,
-0.2895486951,
0.9540116191,
-0.0307461675,
0.5393539667,
0.6807152629,
0.8718485832,
-0.4290484488,
0.7170197368,
-0.2456974536,
-0.2113577873,
0.2174257487,
-0.6661430597,
-0.8775014877,
-0.2811219692,
-0.4821637273,
-0.305369705,
-0.0081384024,
1.0989027023,
0.8143366575,
-0.6865906119,
-0.2543505132,
-0.0045290319,
0.3584898114,
-0.2772078514,
-0.2290617675,
0.1769681871,
-0.4646476805,
-0.5274061561,
0.6705970764,
0.4047111571,
-0.1793773174,
-0.2834349275,
-0.1637676656,
-0.108570233,
0.3376259208,
0.5301043391,
0.6203877926,
-0.3725089133,
-0.4785070419,
0.3376951814,
0.1733497679,
0.1785674989,
0.5920652151,
-1.1718006134,
0.9135430455,
0.5006434917,
0.9407712221,
0.6563538313,
0.272357285,
0.4560946524,
-1.0087945461,
-0.123059012,
0.2139769047,
-0.1128805876,
-0.1492701173,
-0.5055946112,
0.4988335967,
0.0493129119,
-0.8910964727,
-0.7005834579,
0.4089919925,
-0.9491922259,
-0.2198542058,
0.8602975607,
-0.3391917348,
-0.3020041585,
0.173479706,
-0.2886354923,
0.0885781571,
-0.227668494,
1.2330844402,
0.8597501516,
-0.5133444667,
-0.3323263526,
-0.5295098424,
0.3452066779,
0.2789036036,
-0.7545925379,
-0.1256867945,
0.4311984181,
0.5505558252,
0.1650827378,
1.013127923,
-0.0035987676,
0.3978121281,
-0.0831895843,
0.2336407453,
-0.3816762567,
-0.3754030764,
-0.1591705829,
0.3229156733,
0.1259845942,
-0.682179153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07838v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07838v3
|
LLatrieval: LLM-Verified Retrieval for Verifiable Generation
| 2023-11-14T01:38:02 | 2024-03-27T11:36:46 |
Xiaonan Li, Changtai Zhu, Linyang Li, Zhangyue Yin, Tianxiang Sun, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Verifiable generation aims to let the large language model (LLM) generate
text with supporting documents, which enables the user to flexibly verify the
answer and makes the LLM's output more reliable. Retrieval plays a crucial role
in verifiable generation. Specifically, the retrieved documents not only
supplement knowledge to help the LLM generate correct answers, but also serve
as supporting evidence for the user to verify the LLM's output. However, the
widely used retrievers become the bottleneck of the entire pipeline and limit
the overall performance. Their capabilities are usually inferior to LLMs since
they often have much fewer parameters than the large language model and have
not been demonstrated to scale well to the size of LLMs. If the retriever does
not correctly find the supporting documents, the LLM can not generate the
correct and verifiable answer, which overshadows the LLM's remarkable
abilities. To address these limitations, we propose \LLatrieval (Large Language
Model Verified Retrieval), where the LLM updates the retrieval result until it
verifies that the retrieved documents can sufficiently support answering the
question. Thus, the LLM can iteratively provide feedback to retrieval and
facilitate the retrieval result to fully support verifiable generation.
Experiments show that LLatrieval significantly outperforms extensive baselines
and achieves state-of-the-art results.
|
[
-0.1261003315,
-0.7209545374,
0.8036946058,
0.2172613889,
-0.175874725,
0.5410352349,
-0.2332166731,
-0.4302361012,
0.021038482,
0.8307079077,
-0.4851119816,
-0.3329464793,
-0.707285881,
0.2543074191,
-0.664827168,
0.6362217069,
-0.1584506184,
-0.0476765595,
-0.5283210278,
-0.0461474732,
-0.1449529082,
-0.6243146658,
-0.5056015849,
-0.6849032044,
0.3962068856,
0.5207538605,
0.3396829069,
0.6012116671,
0.7028620243,
0.3928213418,
-0.2624207139,
0.3509311676,
-0.8813319206,
0.6897010207,
-0.1385667622,
-0.609591186,
-0.1996422112,
-0.249776274,
0.80472368,
0.2455084622,
-0.1540344656,
0.3289946616,
-0.0192102585,
0.819519937,
-0.6947305202,
-0.095325321,
-0.8722362518,
-0.2047228366,
-0.5377862453,
-0.4356870353,
-0.4430549145,
-0.8072746992,
-0.3412540257,
-0.1423115581,
0.1373653114,
0.0438563079,
0.9684038162,
0.2684576511,
-0.3848596513,
-0.2990098596,
-0.8547195792,
0.7214055061,
-0.3078050315,
0.3839451969,
0.4123967588,
0.5800006986,
-0.2524469495,
-1.1257010698,
-0.5363797545,
-0.5043179393,
0.1185599938,
0.1498050094,
-0.2583265603,
-0.0268325955,
0.4137835503,
0.9141439199,
-0.4590771496,
0.1228983775,
-0.1196976453,
-0.4899214208,
0.4279079735,
0.1081057042,
0.0948078185,
-0.1782936007,
-0.4390645325,
-0.1940700114,
-1.2088559866,
-0.0442571826,
0.3408783376,
-0.0225040969,
0.4487178326,
0.8312496543,
-0.6228226423,
0.4200929105,
-0.0016054539,
-0.1592607796,
0.1822275519,
-0.3982858956,
-0.1168981865,
0.0019192403,
0.5301866531,
-0.0177345984,
0.1094719842,
-0.0275976919,
-0.3768742085,
-0.1448844224,
-0.0226111338,
-1.1019822359,
0.1477427781,
0.3053554595,
-0.1530644447,
-0.335016042,
-0.2064792812,
-0.5449525714,
-0.3350242078,
-0.0846148506,
0.326372236,
-0.3792070448,
-0.1541036665,
0.0480158739,
0.0924279764,
0.2317242175,
0.5825437307,
-0.7486456633,
-0.0812295973,
0.8726161718,
0.5644080639,
0.0342046209,
-0.2460831851,
-0.9755840898,
-0.0088829268,
-0.0849484354,
1.0432970524,
-0.6245084405,
-0.4603063762,
0.2987132668,
0.020603558,
0.2999602854,
-0.6349546909,
0.8072011471,
-0.9002048969,
-0.0188457835,
-0.6459690928,
-0.7230007052,
-0.0795599222,
0.5547873378,
-0.7780406475,
1.360011816,
0.2358968109,
-0.7599221468,
0.3516325653,
-0.1288918406,
-0.2047668397,
0.4846881628,
-0.2675930858,
-0.3803375661,
0.1915746033,
0.0779955313,
0.4202850461,
-0.7472904921,
0.2599616647,
-0.1814867407,
-0.1482267827,
0.3470196426,
-0.6635569334,
0.7273995876,
0.2128690183,
-0.1199774966,
-0.0616294406,
-0.8754695058,
0.0731200576,
0.1675042212,
-0.7294439673,
-0.1386005878,
-0.1683885455,
-0.1601046622,
-0.0926782191,
0.5051237345,
-0.8218125701,
0.2029921263,
-0.265579313,
0.2982324362,
0.564976573,
0.1900769621,
0.1697848737,
-0.4212599099,
0.6986584663,
-0.4848666191,
-0.2433611155,
-0.3144051731,
-0.2419230193,
-0.7120303512,
-0.293265909,
0.5305366516,
0.6960620284,
-0.9170659781,
0.1713033766,
-0.3871661425,
-0.4775746465,
-0.5484471321,
0.4349727035,
0.3401836157,
0.7447293401,
0.2031371295,
0.0102611277,
-0.7154648304,
-0.8090825081,
0.097207427,
-0.515386939,
-0.2067679614,
0.1934078485,
0.5619390607,
-0.2083523721,
0.7003424168,
-0.2177041918,
0.0236740131,
-0.3528914154,
0.1872362942,
0.165657416,
0.2137759924,
0.2159717828,
-0.6321729422,
-0.2113634497,
0.1648168564,
-0.7808567882,
-0.4398359954,
-0.0077685914,
-0.2368281335,
0.2421972305,
0.5396697521,
-0.5064758658,
0.192165941,
0.6269902587,
-0.1038725302,
0.5344698429,
-0.3352752328,
0.4996695518,
-0.9454891086,
0.0669416338,
-0.3908398449,
-0.5928859115,
-0.2479705364,
0.4303835332,
0.1616075486,
0.2755723596,
-0.4247398674,
0.5230209827,
-0.3160992563,
-0.0557183139,
-0.2733226418,
0.4251410961,
0.1673782915,
-0.2428783625,
-0.1021681428,
1.1768671274,
0.3029411137,
-0.4722585976,
0.6571021676,
0.3118038177,
-0.4111689329,
0.9562337399,
-0.5628339052,
0.014143669,
-0.0291663203,
0.188304171,
-1.0680519342,
-0.2626194358,
-0.1972979158,
-0.3875107169,
0.2224522084,
-0.0538823605,
-0.899082005,
-0.4723229706,
-0.229816556,
0.1985655874,
0.5814600587,
-0.9704632163,
0.8588142395,
0.1572732031,
-0.1221398115,
-0.64733392,
-0.5751107931,
0.2336735576,
-0.1499365866,
-0.9585928917,
0.1357105374,
-0.1146207899,
-0.3408216536,
-0.1052538976,
0.0226081666,
0.2375438213,
0.0925580934,
0.1532981545,
0.2874104083,
-0.204717353,
0.2274473608,
-0.0021398636,
-0.363125056,
0.0370198824,
-0.0443330109,
0.5413073897,
-0.1475432366,
-0.6215755343,
-0.0061689704,
0.2394912988,
0.5864408016,
-0.4671614766,
0.4873019457,
0.5366359353,
-0.2735535502,
-0.1945698112,
-1.1312050819,
-0.2828552127,
-0.5071738958,
0.3151486218,
-0.4774730206,
-1.4828159809,
0.7584707141,
-0.4172961116,
-0.0615660362,
0.5556889176,
0.7398759723,
0.0749550536,
0.8043758273,
0.4093089998,
0.0320110321,
0.2375329435,
-0.0184774436,
-0.2031184286,
-0.9466327429,
-0.3829628527,
-0.9776755571,
0.1509824991,
-0.5086963773,
-0.4481131434,
0.1478125453,
0.1288514584,
-0.3105225265,
0.2627345324,
-0.4799385369,
0.4863947034,
0.6747565269,
-0.0051283613,
0.7332459688,
0.1594498008,
-0.1227733269,
-0.1283765435,
-0.4402417839,
-0.6701921225,
0.9880365133,
0.3460614681,
0.6901810765,
0.3634418249,
0.9505487084,
0.1995216757,
0.508890748,
-0.6063336134,
0.7832994461,
-0.0706672147,
-0.6786144376,
-0.2353998125,
-0.6220476627,
-0.8283265829,
0.1629841179,
-0.1672135592,
-0.9793092608,
-0.0464643501,
0.0500947386,
-0.1219367459,
0.268494457,
-0.1456983387,
0.4708210528,
-0.2945273519,
-0.7041201591,
-0.2892433703,
-0.2093073577,
0.6036269069,
-0.2772540152,
-0.1946612298,
-0.0299643781,
0.1533773839,
0.3884061575,
-0.6363016367,
0.5636924505,
-0.0039181868,
-0.2854616344,
0.3754824102,
0.4004839063,
0.9816099405,
0.272485733,
-0.3544131517,
-0.2125215381,
-0.0341714248,
-0.1425328553,
-0.4502841234,
0.9059913158,
-0.5222220421,
-1.0153672695,
-0.369859159,
-0.1703829914,
-0.0903867036,
0.2675454915,
0.3424293697,
0.1426414847,
-0.2543760836,
0.5476612449,
1.0696828365,
-0.0196107719,
0.2301600873,
0.4450146556,
-0.4977072477,
-0.4756258428,
0.7533425093,
0.0735033527,
0.4067081213,
0.599729538,
0.1833366603,
-0.5003358722,
-0.7046129704,
-0.4490461946,
0.310213089,
-1.0416456461,
-0.4698418081,
-0.5379344821,
-0.4516492486,
0.1542597413,
-0.0744361356,
-0.4459139705,
-0.4064396918,
-0.1463732868,
-0.3618208766,
0.6732772589,
0.5143140554,
-0.1165994555,
0.173930496,
-0.9576370716,
0.1050536111,
0.6800260544,
0.1622432619,
-0.2240012437,
-0.750105679,
0.0458870865,
-0.156918779,
-0.1943093389,
-0.7143791318,
0.0682060122,
-0.0015021228,
0.608412087,
0.2335855663,
-0.0502369329,
0.5958657265,
-0.4188224077,
0.8197202086,
-0.101884082,
-1.0049521923,
0.7307872772,
-0.1171050668,
0.2670770884,
0.8713132143,
0.0296263341,
-0.314866215,
-0.5351991057,
-0.6022559404,
-1.057716608,
0.2336312085,
0.3873745203,
0.0542962663,
-0.0415430218,
0.4527013302,
-0.0046017687,
0.2179789692,
-0.5400229692,
-0.0062844572,
-0.0794575661,
0.0277250372,
0.2675179541,
-0.7568300962,
-0.236657396,
0.2444000244,
0.8753122687,
0.0103292596,
0.0597730391,
0.2971275151,
-0.0810131952,
-0.3893758059,
0.3958026171,
0.5723089576,
0.7504680753,
-0.3901155889,
0.2475100607,
0.2620092332,
-0.3951852918,
0.2864729464,
0.1607558578,
-0.3274597526,
0.0283027291,
0.5673605204,
0.5668364167,
-0.068931371,
-0.7626502514,
0.5409978628,
-0.0860362723,
-0.395234406,
-0.6213541627,
0.0590088703,
0.0679522157,
0.5257526636,
0.6073516607,
-0.3326482177,
-0.0416197255,
-0.2833477557,
0.3949681222,
0.4472703338,
-0.0886390805,
-0.0110255191,
0.8188053966,
0.0759303495,
-0.2705075741,
0.731194675,
-0.2290116847,
-0.4813485146,
0.4924954176,
0.4706612825,
0.8772405982,
-0.2447723448,
0.3342058957,
0.5051732063,
0.3181442022,
-0.3691609502,
0.4715562463,
-0.0088774618,
-0.698798418,
-0.7325835824,
-0.6859611273,
-0.5263211131,
0.1109669283,
-0.4949130714,
-0.0984225646,
-0.3238143325,
-0.2211522013,
-0.3908537328,
0.0720751807,
-0.5822796226,
0.0032578905,
0.0336214527,
1.1472398043,
-0.6874087453,
0.8148736954,
0.2940451801,
-0.6325341463,
-0.8633564115,
-0.1422421038,
0.0901665837,
-1.1133027077,
1.0408701897,
-0.0962894037,
-0.4247934222,
0.0977419168,
-0.5586689115,
-0.9958597422,
1.4937287569,
0.5626495481,
-0.7525547147,
0.32018736,
0.2210893929,
0.5839195251,
-0.3268060386,
0.2937341034,
0.4338022172,
0.6602184176,
0.900531888,
-0.6192543507,
0.272816807,
0.0319104977,
0.2189204991,
0.076305829,
-0.5871909857,
0.5359043479,
0.0182677358,
-0.2902662754,
0.466375798,
0.7935929298,
0.7964091301,
0.1584952921,
0.2292532474,
0.6668475866,
1.1622139215,
-0.3857536614,
1.2014980316,
-0.3505671024,
0.2927696407,
1.1096767187,
-0.5356699824,
1.1406296492,
0.6253401637,
-0.1954839379,
0.3654086888,
0.4934549928,
0.0155090224,
0.2808952332,
0.315530777,
-0.6125581264,
-0.5616068244,
-0.3374536633,
-0.41396451,
0.3110395372,
0.2855363488,
-0.398211211,
-0.364612639,
-0.072440505,
0.1593457609,
0.2652374208,
-0.3065499067,
0.5079955459,
-0.031340383,
-0.6137874126,
0.6008278728,
-0.1883417368,
0.1972125173,
-0.6159121394,
-0.1366609186,
-0.4512436688,
0.2119498551,
-0.2101158947,
-0.8274493217,
0.0204169806,
-0.0205595475,
-0.0652701929,
-0.2858564258,
0.9058306217,
-0.3272151053,
-0.7204098701,
0.3210862577,
0.6810469627,
-0.072250396,
-0.0095992479,
-0.3454357386,
0.3106566072,
0.1239751726,
-0.4665860832,
0.2015592009,
0.7947353721,
0.1104032993,
0.979614675,
0.7171776295,
0.4185440838,
-0.1103016064,
0.2466965914,
0.9695076942,
-0.3932909966,
-0.0462307781,
-0.9307611585,
0.559151113,
-0.1556589454,
-0.018387707,
0.9230602384,
0.5724279881,
0.810131073,
0.1805450469,
0.7848380804,
0.0162460469,
0.6658438444,
-0.8357205391,
0.3281249106,
-0.4855745733,
0.7815690637,
-0.0835540667,
-1.0203208923,
-0.5009637475,
0.4642125964,
-0.2595475912,
-0.0022104157,
0.7104581594,
0.9957048297,
0.2139180601,
-0.1071996614,
0.4170782268,
0.2378445566,
0.4584354758,
0.5602187514,
1.1600035429,
-0.2490590066,
0.6714137793,
0.0640279502,
-0.1761227548,
-0.3142192364,
-1.1079208851,
-0.8675510883,
-0.5311597586,
-0.261240989,
-0.6952905059,
0.1371177584,
0.8041673899,
0.3048782349,
-0.5675846338,
-0.187851727,
-0.1652145684,
0.2510898113,
0.0356409773,
-0.1617074609,
0.2458303571,
-0.2866256237,
-0.6560746431,
0.3994623721,
0.3088135421,
0.0390838087,
-0.5405095816,
-0.1068584397,
-0.052676376,
0.0704677403,
0.5121428967,
0.4748239219,
-0.633738637,
-0.4866786599,
-0.0897993296,
-0.2647642791,
0.1544291377,
0.6710777283,
-0.877433598,
0.4285914898,
0.7543558478,
1.117090106,
0.7942016125,
0.0387814008,
0.439048022,
-0.5233030915,
-0.1884532124,
0.1912156343,
0.5483063459,
0.4301052392,
-0.536074698,
0.5941724181,
0.0883743539,
-0.9129216075,
-0.8364281654,
0.5302203298,
-0.8634601235,
0.1285588294,
1.1738630533,
-0.2059870809,
-0.3832117617,
0.1264078021,
-0.2460432798,
-0.0414113924,
-0.4387332797,
0.7341764569,
0.7310296893,
0.1932409108,
-0.4240103066,
-0.6292999387,
0.3055966198,
0.3124170303,
-0.7056799531,
0.2845567763,
0.5942931771,
0.11341355,
0.2417977005,
0.7193920016,
-0.2161526978,
0.1411681324,
-0.0803953409,
-0.054026138,
-0.1840629727,
-0.1029672027,
-0.1920312047,
0.5288815498,
0.6467233896,
0.0307137407
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.