id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16267v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16267v2
|
Novel Preprocessing Technique for Data Embedding in Engineering Code Generation Using Large Language Model
| 2023-11-27T19:17:39 | 2024-01-30T08:00:07 |
Yu-Chen Lin, Akhilesh Kumar, Norman Chang, Wenliang Zhang, Muhammad Zakir, Rucha Apte, Haiyang He, Chao Wang, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
We present four main contributions to enhance the performance of Large
Language Models (LLMs) in generating domain-specific code: (i) utilizing
LLM-based data splitting and data renovation techniques to improve the semantic
representation of embeddings' space; (ii) introducing the Chain of Density for
Renovation Credibility (CoDRC), driven by LLMs, and the Adaptive Text
Renovation (ATR) algorithm for assessing data renovation reliability; (iii)
developing the Implicit Knowledge Expansion and Contemplation (IKEC) Prompt
technique; and (iv) effectively refactoring existing scripts to generate new
and high-quality scripts with LLMs. By using engineering simulation software
RedHawk-SC as a case study, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our data
pre-processing method for expanding and categorizing scripts. When combined
with IKEC, these techniques enhance the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
method in retrieving more relevant information, ultimately achieving a 73.33%
"Percentage of Correct Lines" for code generation problems in MapReduce
applications.
|
[
-0.6036162376,
-0.9708188772,
0.5489011407,
0.301990509,
-0.1651160419,
0.4395569563,
-0.2968844175,
-0.1656107008,
0.2563525438,
0.7187222242,
-0.4047169387,
-0.84372437,
-0.2902020514,
-0.016669102,
-0.488994807,
0.6933244467,
-0.2416850328,
-0.1840092987,
-0.4340685904,
0.3963366151,
-0.3216415346,
-0.7701939344,
-0.1716796458,
-0.0827761218,
0.0150803206,
0.5398805141,
0.676404655,
0.7827340961,
0.6166999936,
0.34324646,
0.1587146223,
0.3559474051,
-0.3058100939,
0.2510527372,
-0.0503999703,
-0.3790093362,
-0.6771047115,
-0.2456086427,
0.5799164176,
0.6440556049,
-0.2682801783,
0.0416242182,
-0.0192315336,
0.3679553568,
-0.7038321495,
0.3754789829,
-0.6697283983,
0.0874289498,
-0.0720587522,
-0.5809267163,
-0.6245011091,
-0.470782578,
-0.0530915149,
-0.469468385,
0.2971899509,
0.0307452306,
0.6913892031,
0.2732578814,
-0.2213596851,
-0.2830989659,
-0.7334191203,
1.1223416328,
-0.8291056156,
0.3001122475,
0.3317838013,
0.2183429748,
-0.3891223073,
-0.9178236127,
-0.3923182189,
-0.1103131399,
0.1507256031,
-0.1746624708,
0.1752948165,
0.060271401,
0.4099932015,
0.3199183047,
-0.3331016004,
0.1066121757,
-0.4952756464,
-0.1210130304,
0.8433664441,
0.1083464399,
0.138108179,
-0.0536954924,
-0.1787732244,
-0.3045038879,
-0.9538749456,
-0.525500536,
0.3835997581,
0.2587305903,
0.1902006418,
0.5296853185,
-0.0800119638,
0.6591296196,
-0.3652637303,
-0.0739288628,
0.5070654154,
-0.1827191859,
-0.222828716,
0.0678568184,
0.3292705119,
0.2301501781,
0.3847890198,
0.1371590942,
-0.3846881688,
0.2607453465,
0.6802974343,
-0.6706815362,
-0.2280563861,
0.1384090781,
-0.3652442694,
-0.4906897545,
0.0856156275,
-0.6777037978,
-0.2415627688,
-0.3913955092,
-0.0024520694,
-0.1665958166,
-0.3015154302,
0.1989847571,
0.0798410773,
0.3765301704,
0.1123732626,
-0.2455751151,
-0.0061157751,
0.7437900901,
0.4390153289,
-0.0435936153,
-0.1334761977,
-0.2559651136,
0.3162680864,
-0.6010832787,
0.8161906004,
-0.6550433636,
-0.6014063954,
0.4049982727,
-0.1871795952,
0.3475610018,
-0.692435801,
0.5293495059,
-0.8161776066,
-0.0801559985,
0.1798572987,
-0.677926302,
0.0128160557,
-0.0218192525,
-0.6376566291,
0.8224774599,
0.1391289234,
-0.6901908517,
0.2833746672,
-0.7627074718,
-0.6322209835,
-0.0389861465,
-0.3009364605,
-0.6153533459,
0.0993053317,
0.2307505906,
0.7175700665,
-0.3416958749,
0.3444002569,
-0.4054915011,
-0.1250603497,
0.1664104909,
-0.0126775345,
0.2080200166,
0.4413179159,
0.0482972674,
-0.0756738111,
-0.6863669753,
0.5326016545,
0.0382174142,
-0.23507303,
-0.199515745,
0.1525669545,
-0.0751029849,
0.1867944002,
0.198189497,
-0.4083809853,
0.2578262687,
-0.3358538449,
0.166225031,
0.6338971853,
0.1700050831,
0.2252032161,
-0.2299406677,
0.7456914783,
-0.0059170048,
-0.0711556822,
-0.4255119562,
-0.2922288179,
-0.6348772049,
-0.2514942884,
0.3129531741,
0.3414691389,
-0.9708501101,
0.4637469649,
-0.2825616002,
-0.3759762645,
-0.4638309777,
0.0322498754,
0.4475089014,
0.2667674422,
0.4739517272,
-0.0364537872,
-1.0602890253,
-0.8940169215,
-0.1044532135,
0.1272458583,
-0.0326519534,
-0.0172379147,
0.4079739749,
-0.580966115,
1.0451563597,
-1.1208837032,
-0.0191351939,
-0.3015410304,
0.0901973099,
0.27147457,
0.7239789963,
0.2961676717,
-0.6620823741,
-0.3949735165,
-0.1094387993,
-0.71881181,
-0.1596644819,
0.0784863457,
-0.080624193,
0.3148677647,
0.8720829487,
-0.2954246998,
0.4737323821,
0.5747180581,
-0.1095014662,
0.7286325693,
-0.2565433085,
0.2660699189,
-1.081526041,
-0.1549492031,
-0.1654739082,
-0.2545019984,
-0.5892460346,
0.3895048797,
-0.1245221123,
-0.311719805,
-0.3576698899,
0.347374171,
-0.7775722146,
-0.0460851379,
-0.4795157313,
0.1297816932,
-0.0049968776,
0.2509621084,
-0.0018991081,
0.7828215957,
0.4741499424,
-0.7010362148,
0.3300953805,
0.2101766318,
-0.6344411969,
0.070964776,
-0.610257566,
0.3423384428,
-0.0488737412,
0.2328889519,
-0.6203171015,
-0.1991238296,
-0.3677605391,
-0.1982096583,
0.5108430982,
-0.1100317389,
-0.7690437436,
-0.3877255619,
-0.3700612187,
0.4622286558,
0.7961919308,
-0.6127512455,
0.4370423853,
0.4995719194,
-0.4965038598,
-0.2635046244,
-0.8284550309,
-0.1776860058,
-0.2229944319,
-0.8828941584,
0.531294167,
0.1504652053,
-0.3577340245,
0.0076388605,
0.0143379355,
-0.2290819734,
-0.0416519046,
0.095033288,
0.3185584843,
-0.2083572,
0.1347238123,
0.2671317756,
-0.1439307928,
0.0965585709,
-0.2009373009,
0.7020692825,
0.0857783407,
-0.4487825036,
-0.0744356811,
0.3813090324,
0.344840169,
-0.2842843831,
0.6495774984,
0.1751484573,
-0.3385739625,
-0.650705874,
-0.5606271029,
-0.1926834881,
-0.491969347,
0.4994232655,
-0.4190406799,
-0.6283134222,
0.4189712405,
-0.4979884923,
0.1109673306,
0.2409782708,
0.3500356376,
-0.0607135855,
1.0683913231,
0.7628908753,
0.0154379122,
0.2757104039,
-0.3929076791,
0.3857797086,
-0.6720782518,
0.004342569,
-0.5852518678,
-0.1734019071,
-0.4761843383,
-0.8445683122,
0.2019645721,
0.1725986153,
-0.1971359551,
0.2864250541,
-0.3992037177,
0.4019905329,
0.1665780693,
-0.1317097843,
0.3177749515,
0.3240468204,
-0.1782627702,
-0.0718026385,
-0.5902950764,
-0.5589337945,
1.352620244,
0.41762501,
0.9232985973,
-0.1404637694,
0.8619203568,
0.4202717841,
0.360768944,
-0.2858186066,
0.4983616173,
-0.1050721928,
-0.2818988264,
-0.1614585966,
-0.4631115496,
-0.7217600346,
-0.1029743254,
-0.1176436692,
-0.2762337923,
0.0111239394,
0.1050850227,
-0.1400852799,
0.1979153156,
-0.7985288501,
0.4199599028,
0.0398024619,
-0.0735396668,
-0.4557819366,
-0.1053067595,
0.242766425,
-0.4401625991,
0.3963920772,
0.22640872,
-0.0020199877,
0.6884104609,
-0.6922056675,
0.4409430027,
-0.4255526364,
-0.5338920951,
0.4719982743,
0.0410602354,
0.8640848994,
-0.0664192364,
-0.3096255362,
-0.0564349256,
-0.4068991542,
-0.2362505645,
-0.7424347401,
0.8338963389,
-0.356954664,
-0.6819702387,
0.0321162008,
-0.3467047215,
-0.4066661894,
-0.0169801097,
0.1158862188,
0.3801676929,
0.0986763984,
0.3894749582,
0.5936045647,
-0.5681555867,
0.1783918142,
0.1743330061,
-0.5490124226,
-0.4262426198,
0.7779862285,
-0.0323012993,
0.15768601,
0.2277225554,
-0.2821987867,
-0.170208782,
-0.5410493016,
0.0870917663,
0.2899000645,
-0.5845057964,
-0.5784087777,
-0.6178686023,
-0.3196297884,
-0.4037773311,
-0.5458490252,
-0.5100764632,
-0.4859592021,
0.0027707361,
-0.2961886525,
0.4192177653,
0.6201148033,
0.1924890131,
0.411360085,
-0.9495763183,
0.1528467089,
-0.193784222,
0.4046978056,
-0.0828979909,
-0.2399942875,
-0.5713498592,
0.1483113915,
-0.2915944755,
-0.5322113633,
0.4756072164,
-0.0611370616,
0.4999223053,
0.1457668096,
0.1111070737,
0.7220560908,
-0.5207976699,
0.6541995406,
-0.0426956601,
-0.7426581979,
0.7194252014,
-0.2280431241,
0.1763547361,
0.2458683848,
0.2553564608,
0.0895356983,
-0.4231204093,
-0.7440109253,
-0.992829442,
0.4065924287,
0.1306010038,
0.0100972624,
-0.094307892,
0.2123645842,
-0.2126328051,
0.3473855555,
-0.1548934579,
-0.2142179757,
0.0139625836,
-0.2001056224,
-0.0279731061,
-0.3728800714,
0.0614330657,
-0.0224529728,
0.7221177816,
-0.1123378128,
0.4045857489,
0.1253378987,
-0.151132077,
0.1801410317,
0.2397762537,
0.616671145,
0.7466806769,
0.0050762929,
-0.132674858,
0.1633086652,
-0.397818625,
0.0390750468,
-0.0446796343,
0.0821370929,
0.0273942519,
0.6414361596,
0.4453736544,
0.0919987485,
-0.6723104119,
0.3385059536,
0.1690635234,
-0.1083403751,
-0.4337889254,
-0.007671223,
-0.1067007855,
0.0815749913,
0.3990769982,
-0.1743605733,
-0.0113223679,
-0.3868319988,
0.5218552947,
0.2040994912,
0.1335101575,
-0.1140273139,
0.2420342714,
0.3079981506,
-0.0304541755,
0.724888742,
-0.0942646265,
-0.5223920941,
0.686709106,
0.7347558141,
0.9107989669,
-0.3367515206,
0.0418301262,
0.411573112,
-0.0057168412,
0.0661920533,
0.5292701125,
0.2113064528,
-0.7333502173,
-0.8285509348,
-0.6371466517,
0.0161274131,
-0.055572357,
-0.4768034816,
0.4894292057,
-0.5938448906,
-0.3153252304,
-0.5180886984,
-0.0874885619,
-0.6818201542,
0.1628765166,
-0.1119186282,
0.952240169,
-0.4888212979,
0.8131330609,
0.7358262539,
-0.1765900254,
-1.0293689966,
0.1015625298,
-0.2815102339,
-0.466691941,
0.8409435749,
-0.2316346765,
-0.0801310465,
-0.0297898185,
-0.4933764338,
-0.8056607842,
0.9600152969,
0.1976458132,
-0.5506436825,
-0.0622616224,
0.1679453403,
0.5167671442,
-0.5995227098,
0.0566940345,
0.4434369206,
0.5283963084,
-0.1223092377,
-0.777156353,
0.00870072,
-0.2790613472,
0.3207963407,
0.3416617811,
-0.1299831867,
0.6782531738,
-0.2684335411,
-0.2903394401,
-0.0004465701,
0.6352615356,
0.5787031054,
-0.0914053023,
0.3320272267,
0.4913247228,
0.6753875017,
-0.0121798543,
1.1645792723,
-0.5489272475,
0.3824900687,
1.0469002724,
-0.4808251262,
0.8191492558,
0.3899759054,
-0.1548956782,
0.8213284016,
0.0615835823,
-0.0543849319,
0.5653819442,
0.5108971,
0.001446141,
-0.0178853348,
-0.0059118574,
-0.7812414765,
0.3884457052,
0.3224808872,
-0.5274510384,
-0.1650068313,
0.0609265678,
0.1189229041,
0.217783615,
-0.1170856059,
0.6323893666,
0.1778010726,
-0.5511513352,
0.7814111114,
0.216647163,
0.5977293253,
-0.5664778948,
-0.3821356595,
-0.1074176356,
0.3687323928,
-0.415597409,
-0.7885966897,
0.4947692156,
0.1409640908,
-0.3376325369,
-0.446524024,
0.750897646,
-0.3500244319,
-0.3550638556,
0.3312118053,
0.2385589182,
-0.0056876615,
0.0375729464,
-0.2547979653,
0.29326424,
0.2314834595,
-0.1883458942,
0.1925153881,
0.4805049002,
-0.1068339571,
0.775251627,
0.7946985364,
0.3359647095,
0.1426760405,
0.2395685762,
0.988675952,
-0.712161839,
-0.4288440049,
-0.5187086463,
0.6388895512,
-0.214072004,
0.1471614242,
0.840046525,
0.6847761869,
0.9046136737,
-0.6221602559,
0.847728014,
0.0841092467,
0.594707787,
-0.7578659058,
0.5733479261,
-0.2093372047,
0.5645573735,
-0.7716505527,
-1.1934338808,
-0.3936156034,
0.5735610723,
-0.2579114735,
0.1790254116,
0.7817800641,
1.0425081253,
0.107637085,
-0.1242403463,
0.1616648436,
0.2591136396,
0.5364723802,
0.3292519152,
0.9340767264,
-0.35839957,
0.4008587897,
-0.1153526604,
-0.2496838719,
-0.0876543149,
-0.8792393804,
-0.3988116682,
-0.3419891596,
-0.5111984611,
-0.2408559322,
-0.1970121413,
0.756501615,
0.6980596185,
-0.6937661767,
-0.2125293911,
-0.0684158653,
0.0144270733,
0.0233775042,
-0.2786744535,
0.2975338995,
-0.5696827769,
-0.5406489968,
0.560259521,
0.007328155,
-0.1724196225,
-0.326068908,
-0.284018755,
-0.1206480265,
-0.003868103,
0.7194673419,
-0.0604300462,
-0.2497889847,
-0.2003335953,
-0.1059739068,
0.1095394865,
-0.0583849996,
1.0724977255,
-0.7102344036,
0.2415122986,
0.5818260312,
0.8161327839,
0.2848593891,
0.2953247428,
0.9401586652,
-1.0443921089,
0.0748870298,
0.306135416,
0.3787646294,
0.2141665071,
-0.3770803809,
0.6078330278,
-0.1248131543,
-0.6267565489,
-0.9997920394,
0.2777577937,
-0.4424157739,
-0.3476375043,
1.1635155678,
-0.1231288612,
0.0297135022,
-0.0126430141,
-0.0889191329,
0.0600661337,
-0.2192664891,
0.5109789968,
0.5737299919,
-0.085760802,
0.1706260145,
-0.3294204175,
0.5631985068,
0.1245619208,
-1.0559517145,
0.1139717624,
0.5141839981,
0.1337609887,
0.5084292889,
0.3180131018,
-0.5227547884,
0.0885770544,
0.0370515808,
0.364387393,
-0.1593408436,
-0.5261378288,
-0.0233195145,
0.155898273,
0.1393894553,
-0.0031390372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16258v1
|
An Exploration of Left-Corner Transformations
| 2023-11-27T19:04:37 | 2023-11-27T19:04:37 |
Andreas Opedal, Eleftheria Tsipidi, Tiago Pimentel, Ryan Cotterell, Tim Vieira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DS, cs.FL
|
The left-corner transformation (Rosenkrantz and Lewis, 1970) is used to
remove left recursion from context-free grammars, which is an important step
towards making the grammar parsable top-down with simple techniques. This paper
generalizes prior left-corner transformations to support semiring-weighted
production rules and to provide finer-grained control over which left corners
may be moved. Our generalized left-corner transformation (GLCT) arose from
unifying the left-corner transformation and speculation transformation (Eisner
and Blatz, 2007), originally for logic programming. Our new transformation and
speculation define equivalent weighted languages. Yet, their derivation trees
are structurally different in an important way: GLCT replaces left recursion
with right recursion, and speculation does not. We also provide several
technical results regarding the formal relationships between the outputs of
GLCT, speculation, and the original grammar. Lastly, we empirically investigate
the efficiency of GLCT for left-recursion elimination from grammars of nine
languages.
|
[
-0.1329309344,
-0.9233058095,
0.6000816226,
-0.0088511771,
-0.0537362434,
0.0522757843,
-0.6193342805,
-0.2862749994,
0.0540365651,
0.2687110603,
-0.725785315,
-0.3739115894,
-0.3175505996,
-0.0645959899,
-0.8742176294,
1.2592760324,
-0.1500171572,
-0.113804616,
-0.058367677,
0.0884839147,
0.0134084364,
-0.5543404222,
-0.7235276103,
-0.2250961959,
0.3517295718,
0.0222454481,
0.9362918735,
0.603852272,
0.3773961067,
0.3194715679,
0.1438980103,
-0.4159223735,
-0.3331229985,
-0.3829140067,
-0.3775160611,
-0.3917516172,
-0.5985907912,
0.1911439896,
0.5588926673,
0.5558656454,
-0.4273686409,
0.3241501451,
-0.087682046,
1.2518594265,
-0.4999068081,
0.0051740981,
-0.5716498494,
0.3570260406,
-0.3177707791,
-0.5187512636,
-0.5456495881,
-0.5389767289,
-0.2960489094,
-0.7042456865,
0.1332277954,
-0.1768628061,
0.8025059104,
0.3508855999,
-0.3230670393,
-0.3066160977,
-0.8559999466,
0.991607368,
-0.4451509118,
0.4356739223,
0.0392364264,
0.7446460724,
-0.3155429065,
-0.9828013778,
-0.3889655769,
0.2336705625,
-0.267716676,
0.172339797,
-0.6207219362,
0.243394345,
0.420881927,
0.5645154119,
-0.4027840197,
-0.2585522234,
-0.2979468703,
-0.3625609577,
0.5427491069,
-0.1525241137,
0.7606627345,
-0.0411917157,
-0.1789364815,
0.1460182965,
-1.0389041901,
0.361277163,
0.3149470687,
0.2079277188,
0.1612466127,
0.6390565634,
-0.3852925897,
0.9381891489,
0.3052640855,
-0.2873878181,
-0.0055322605,
-0.6759834886,
-0.5796040297,
-0.3137675226,
0.2741665244,
0.6583541036,
0.5630546212,
-0.2672621906,
-0.081626974,
-0.0807149559,
0.1665471643,
-0.5830046535,
-0.1153274253,
-0.1770676821,
-0.3924978673,
-0.1393353194,
-0.0618494377,
-0.3078713715,
0.0098296469,
-0.3380543292,
0.2098269612,
-0.2136059254,
-0.3009610772,
0.1336111277,
-0.1654503196,
0.468549788,
0.6249445081,
-0.8659567833,
0.3709191382,
0.7211250067,
0.4816195965,
0.0432843566,
0.1301388592,
-0.5301068425,
0.0013530882,
-0.4686717689,
0.3185535967,
-0.6296700239,
-0.0497177131,
0.2696502209,
0.012353329,
-0.315230161,
-0.4915506542,
0.2526171505,
-0.2092812806,
0.6495054364,
-0.3955967128,
-0.0803948641,
-0.1868481636,
0.3496047556,
-0.3113746047,
1.1044514179,
0.5152388215,
-0.7459401488,
0.3357466757,
-0.4394662082,
-0.7048456073,
-0.1024508923,
-0.2381776273,
-0.0725973248,
0.3421924114,
0.1429814547,
0.0672419444,
0.0004935488,
0.0325706713,
0.0552782416,
-0.4084792733,
0.0711347982,
0.0822793394,
1.1642930508,
-0.0146964807,
-0.4945716262,
-0.0258162059,
-0.8921086192,
0.3225090802,
-0.1778315455,
-0.4154339433,
-0.3072991371,
0.0242750403,
-0.391279161,
0.4921635687,
0.2952571511,
-0.7156817317,
0.2684256434,
-0.3148944676,
0.6155486703,
0.5579453111,
-0.0357568935,
0.8367760777,
-0.0894203931,
0.4766723216,
-0.291862309,
0.2398831099,
0.426176995,
-0.1816442013,
-0.9638061523,
-0.2081137449,
-0.0210452229,
0.3571514785,
-0.9629169703,
0.0239801947,
-0.1851294786,
0.0221641697,
-0.2766438425,
-0.0807501599,
0.1056549773,
0.4121619165,
0.5145158172,
0.0874784812,
-0.6479617357,
-1.1987686157,
-0.5118507743,
-0.1324594319,
-0.1772675663,
-0.3182911873,
-0.1654956043,
-0.00137614,
0.8549987078,
-0.1503110975,
-0.0899769738,
-0.4173235893,
-0.0475744791,
0.3555522263,
0.422439307,
0.6580575109,
-0.5967131257,
-0.7643480301,
0.4101657867,
-0.3356132507,
-0.2222057432,
-0.3592424393,
-0.24687998,
0.6381055713,
0.8691006899,
-0.765496552,
0.7715734839,
0.5134652257,
-0.1924947202,
0.4842445552,
0.0152879627,
-0.0722888708,
-0.6725016236,
0.0454609729,
-0.1772228032,
-0.6486597061,
-0.8455066681,
0.257992655,
0.2798402905,
0.3007851243,
-0.3883468807,
0.1361597776,
-0.5958270431,
-0.4204156697,
0.0099743074,
-0.078324832,
-0.3350050151,
0.614944458,
-0.1170555875,
0.7015138268,
0.27750054,
-0.5477259755,
0.1057563648,
-0.4086859822,
-0.0468046889,
0.6892001033,
-0.0418354757,
0.0596117079,
0.0504615046,
0.2876574397,
-0.6029947996,
0.3804868162,
0.5268754363,
-0.2505945861,
0.2701182961,
-0.3537848294,
-0.3530568779,
-0.6113702059,
-0.3972803652,
0.4265283644,
0.7548394799,
-0.2186045647,
0.6974540949,
-0.1877603233,
-0.3622831702,
-0.577249229,
-0.7356114984,
-0.0365182087,
-0.1455608308,
-0.2686755061,
0.3318269551,
-0.1260906756,
-0.4677961469,
0.2089582831,
-0.4103191197,
0.2024455816,
0.1266420782,
-0.0224674251,
-0.1948434561,
0.0636666268,
0.020771984,
0.2209613472,
-0.0759656951,
0.0849902853,
-0.3969302475,
0.385740906,
0.0132793654,
-0.3213124871,
-0.513061583,
0.1008447185,
0.4462722242,
0.0088527221,
-0.0116544599,
0.6253851056,
-0.2816419899,
-0.3450449407,
-0.4552207887,
0.3306720555,
-0.4611709714,
0.4309899807,
-0.3852955997,
-0.754134059,
0.3510121703,
0.1296273023,
0.1704132259,
0.5880820155,
0.576623261,
0.0237325635,
0.8425378799,
0.9252606034,
0.204351902,
0.5479317307,
-0.023087699,
0.5615314245,
-0.7751792669,
-0.0035905337,
-0.518486917,
-0.3572455943,
-0.6324386597,
-0.4265086353,
0.1611609757,
-0.0908466205,
-0.2694754303,
0.4195607603,
-0.4380462468,
0.7443894744,
0.3202503622,
-0.1996051222,
0.4660846889,
0.0709032044,
0.0348979905,
-0.0340912715,
-0.3756670952,
-0.0705951527,
0.8690800071,
0.1794872582,
0.4497675896,
0.1043653116,
0.9221936464,
0.2540451586,
0.3911442161,
-0.8014717102,
0.7726430893,
-0.2975676954,
-0.4599665701,
-0.4835777283,
-0.3966771662,
-0.4427411854,
0.1374152154,
0.1235643625,
-1.0134590864,
-0.1745737493,
0.0061920821,
-0.2680269182,
0.4646482468,
-0.7008051276,
0.522777617,
-0.12909998,
-0.1423535496,
-0.4845842719,
-0.2769789398,
0.1432248056,
0.2490492016,
0.4238623679,
0.0666080564,
0.3634512424,
0.5557433963,
-0.5579075217,
0.7548388243,
-0.516671598,
-0.2163239717,
0.5158780217,
0.6770365834,
0.4801237881,
-0.1010870486,
0.2385509014,
-0.1885638237,
0.0842325836,
-0.5228767991,
-0.7897071838,
0.4352748692,
-0.4508138597,
-0.9758116603,
-0.27842623,
-0.8309526443,
-0.1174463183,
0.4233097136,
-0.0559388213,
0.24174954,
-0.3366909325,
-0.0110754948,
-0.1897426397,
0.1124821678,
0.8494517207,
0.1340997517,
-0.4517627656,
-0.1095983833,
0.5929448009,
0.224923268,
0.4593558908,
0.7127763033,
-0.0211780276,
-0.0639833137,
-0.6874620318,
-0.4549516737,
-0.101169467,
-0.6277781129,
-0.1329919249,
-0.3140552342,
-0.2207449228,
-0.1795499623,
-0.4969233871,
-0.3690544665,
-1.2963527441,
0.1868974417,
-0.490626663,
-0.2970125377,
0.8596363068,
-0.2544384003,
0.070210211,
-0.2641333044,
-0.0933005288,
0.6295257211,
0.0145605179,
-0.1020409837,
-0.1743060201,
-0.4394783378,
0.2615640461,
-0.1871970743,
-0.4667612612,
0.2045089006,
0.1072415709,
0.4796718061,
0.1816282421,
-0.1292474717,
0.7011886239,
-0.4847260118,
0.706058383,
0.3152786195,
-1.1106668711,
-0.0603011437,
-0.3998894095,
0.2515777647,
0.314053297,
-0.072525546,
-0.7690643072,
-0.4666511714,
-0.5786119103,
-0.5374521613,
0.474432677,
0.186976403,
-0.0998329073,
0.2501246631,
0.4147488177,
0.447686255,
0.3478828371,
-0.7814381719,
0.0365077443,
-0.3914484978,
-0.208113119,
-0.0729925409,
-0.0366937518,
-0.245175913,
-0.4776694477,
0.552277565,
-0.2179242373,
0.2952102125,
0.1141275764,
-0.5984373093,
-0.2886312306,
0.6887605786,
0.5549207926,
0.9258422852,
-0.1730447561,
0.3243742585,
0.0026974306,
0.0398982689,
0.0644845366,
-0.0469465069,
-0.4206160009,
-0.2458239049,
0.3608016372,
0.3778608739,
0.3153654933,
0.1806954592,
0.3579651415,
0.167675972,
-0.1824129671,
-0.195574671,
-0.0846844241,
0.0713937506,
0.1373589039,
0.6673994064,
0.0904465914,
0.2161243111,
-0.830291152,
0.1966206729,
0.5922864676,
-0.2856612206,
-0.7884122133,
-0.067939356,
0.1005627885,
-0.0250101294,
0.3860003948,
-0.2761751711,
-0.5563419461,
0.4642431736,
0.724784255,
1.0585128069,
0.067400828,
0.8560443521,
0.5007100701,
0.3370904922,
0.2932870984,
-0.0248147249,
-0.4166573882,
-0.5900548697,
-0.5868507028,
-0.6140370965,
-0.2519866824,
-0.2250338048,
-0.7357966304,
0.060772974,
-0.8115898967,
-0.0965904146,
-0.0551616363,
-0.064674817,
-0.6283640862,
-0.054077033,
0.2197684944,
0.8813849688,
-0.7182226181,
0.8073779345,
1.010437727,
-0.1447735727,
-0.5871118903,
0.1746740192,
0.09944994,
-0.9302677512,
0.4743466079,
0.1040770561,
-0.1522095054,
0.1163276285,
-0.6539809108,
-0.6327223182,
1.018501997,
0.2201095968,
-0.5044362545,
-0.4212591648,
0.3304526508,
0.7560946345,
-0.4218176305,
0.1019758806,
0.7649175525,
0.5611485243,
-0.0353227518,
-1.0265253782,
0.2879113555,
-0.0600941963,
0.0412531011,
0.5421326756,
-0.5807120204,
1.0077040195,
-0.053856235,
-0.9060146213,
0.0803427547,
0.3648307621,
-0.2817094624,
0.2132079899,
0.3520137966,
0.6921312213,
0.5885539055,
-0.3369937539,
0.9842357635,
-0.0924013257,
0.5851765275,
0.7806221843,
0.0008861978,
0.5108402371,
0.7994963527,
-0.4949631691,
1.0066879988,
0.3043856025,
0.5677531362,
0.4419834316,
0.2370360196,
0.0719892606,
-0.4849529862,
0.2715768218,
-0.4337293208,
0.2456211895,
0.1792759895,
0.0461780131,
-0.7556968331,
-0.2673261166,
0.5466501117,
0.2375137955,
-0.652695775,
0.6720018387,
0.0562041812,
-0.6243095398,
0.6587723494,
0.0772534981,
0.3978511989,
-0.4960855842,
0.212568447,
-0.5375380516,
0.3414484859,
-0.4528336823,
-0.6555529237,
0.453640759,
-0.1637214422,
-0.0799524412,
-0.5254318118,
0.735068202,
-0.5803762078,
-0.4829087853,
0.414856106,
0.6877894402,
-0.2014117539,
-0.0014465137,
-0.570194602,
-0.1703647226,
0.4760186076,
-0.2862632573,
0.4412841797,
0.555978775,
-0.3241647184,
0.448287487,
0.6097409129,
0.1564097404,
0.1839928329,
-0.1295374334,
0.8910594583,
-1.0051089525,
-0.5635854602,
-0.7044436336,
0.5146366358,
0.0377788357,
0.3058981597,
0.626894474,
0.4031714797,
1.1059817076,
-0.1057329699,
0.8364278078,
-0.4231458306,
0.215528354,
-0.7229771018,
0.528760016,
-0.5562365651,
-0.446760416,
-0.2682389915,
-1.1749532223,
-0.5096991658,
0.4670998156,
-0.4607538581,
-0.0093973279,
1.1409118176,
0.3617656827,
0.0471690595,
-0.0948511362,
0.3516404927,
0.3328782022,
0.5153663754,
0.729003787,
0.5574985743,
-0.2343575805,
0.4809146523,
-0.4586432874,
-0.3280723393,
0.0246159397,
-0.9775470495,
-0.7798186541,
-0.5723239183,
-0.3954252601,
-0.1652294099,
0.2948839664,
0.7419396043,
0.3801905513,
-0.7969928384,
-0.2308687121,
-0.3374560773,
0.2912844121,
-0.6344609857,
-0.1871809661,
0.3779228628,
-0.3582195342,
-0.7353203893,
0.4123758972,
0.4071508944,
0.0325804353,
0.0848488733,
-0.1595805585,
-0.218170017,
-0.136387825,
0.7900820971,
0.7322989106,
-0.570399642,
-0.6656541824,
-0.2186515331,
-0.0493756793,
0.209291324,
1.1804763079,
-0.6568080783,
0.212653622,
0.5134878755,
0.3834631741,
0.4931160808,
0.3731683791,
0.6515240073,
-0.9876311421,
0.3654895425,
-0.1660540104,
0.2039047927,
0.4751283824,
-0.2717792094,
0.665350318,
0.2750701606,
-0.2563849092,
-0.6033207774,
0.4705760181,
-0.8351178169,
-0.0448636077,
1.2009741068,
0.1241137907,
-0.5120075345,
0.2919059694,
-0.153963238,
0.2365739644,
-0.2241086066,
0.3886354566,
0.8025324941,
-0.2839835584,
-0.1977001429,
-0.0955223516,
0.7469693422,
0.3810123801,
-0.6097249389,
0.2477813065,
0.6206411719,
0.3711239398,
0.4554149806,
0.9878672361,
-0.6541348696,
0.292554915,
-0.4009979665,
0.4330245554,
-0.1935719401,
-0.5007539988,
-0.2141823024,
0.0898718238,
0.0679502711,
-0.1266280264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16254v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16254v2
|
Safe-CLIP: Removing NSFW Concepts from Vision-and-Language Models
| 2023-11-27T19:02:17 | 2024-04-12T09:37:37 |
Samuele Poppi, Tobia Poppi, Federico Cocchi, Marcella Cornia, Lorenzo Baraldi, Rita Cucchiara
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Large-scale vision-and-language models, such as CLIP, are typically trained
on web-scale data, which can introduce inappropriate content and lead to the
development of unsafe and biased behavior. This, in turn, hampers their
applicability in sensitive and trustworthy contexts and could raise significant
concerns in their adoption. Our research introduces a novel approach to
enhancing the safety of vision-and-language models by diminishing their
sensitivity to NSFW (not safe for work) inputs. In particular, our methodology
seeks to sever "toxic" linguistic and visual concepts, unlearning the linkage
between unsafe linguistic or visual items and unsafe regions of the embedding
space. We show how this can be done by fine-tuning a CLIP model on synthetic
data obtained from a large language model trained to convert between safe and
unsafe sentences, and a text-to-image generator. We conduct extensive
experiments on the resulting embedding space for cross-modal retrieval,
text-to-image, and image-to-text generation, where we show that our model can
be remarkably employed with pre-trained generative models. Our source code and
trained models are available at: https://github.com/aimagelab/safe-clip.
|
[
-0.4937611222,
-1.0206627846,
0.3340364695,
-0.0469370261,
-0.5435197949,
-0.0113057587,
-0.0021124333,
-0.7412715554,
-0.1434979588,
0.6228648424,
-0.20961909,
-0.4966459274,
-0.5915094018,
-0.1247020587,
-0.6869613528,
0.7659447789,
0.0720898211,
-0.0731869563,
-0.316699475,
-0.0702305213,
-0.3797289133,
-0.4271668792,
-0.2356526256,
0.2088344246,
0.1935192049,
0.2456268221,
0.9868765473,
0.9510948062,
0.6697304249,
0.1359559,
-0.1406349689,
0.0010704638,
-0.683463037,
-0.0175233725,
-0.4866121709,
-0.2111128867,
-0.2569654882,
0.0483859219,
0.442732513,
0.476529181,
-0.043315351,
-0.1278214753,
0.0406137183,
0.3788178265,
-0.9215160608,
0.1277233958,
-0.802069664,
0.1941646188,
-0.1628483832,
-0.2449857295,
-0.5920683146,
-0.3367469013,
0.2497203946,
-0.6219146252,
0.2268549353,
0.0290366188,
1.039388299,
0.1738308966,
-0.3633295298,
0.2311525643,
-0.530492723,
0.7413582802,
-0.3869213462,
0.4172192514,
0.6020776629,
-0.0226038769,
0.2092842311,
-0.3953659832,
-0.4141844511,
0.1362319887,
0.342474848,
-0.094759509,
-0.2802833319,
0.0270864815,
0.3481597304,
-0.1979345381,
-0.2068269998,
0.0510990545,
-0.5092355609,
-0.1217509061,
0.6243917346,
-0.0200408101,
0.8386024833,
-0.233861357,
-0.4428740442,
-0.3229093254,
-1.0409206152,
-0.179991886,
0.0597434975,
0.1066990495,
-0.0635963753,
0.6465955973,
-0.061179284,
0.4088697135,
0.0002808905,
-0.1728188097,
0.1204480529,
-0.1626121402,
-0.0595111772,
-0.215681389,
0.7445456386,
1.0404920578,
0.3255251944,
-0.2299093306,
-0.0744855255,
0.3750932217,
0.4132162929,
-0.9658586383,
-0.5071561337,
-0.3370907605,
-0.3265878856,
-0.8959906697,
-0.0604910553,
-0.8426461816,
-0.3731870651,
-0.0308613013,
0.628591001,
-0.5756328702,
-0.2156740129,
0.0155736627,
-0.1986780614,
0.0979323909,
0.2766884565,
-0.6791348457,
0.0402141809,
0.343935132,
0.756138742,
-0.2338401675,
-0.1327772141,
-0.2912658453,
0.4527002871,
-0.5476117134,
0.5534700751,
-0.6663435102,
-0.5809783936,
0.1467360109,
0.1741414517,
0.296041429,
-0.527118504,
0.3102750778,
-0.506121397,
-0.0858141929,
-0.1736875176,
-0.151921615,
-0.2821617424,
0.1772083342,
-0.7466615438,
0.7385454774,
-0.2208634019,
-0.838717103,
0.4149492681,
-0.4581103921,
-0.5956529379,
-0.2208898813,
-0.0745257139,
-0.4322085083,
-0.0819430202,
0.4885181487,
0.4783117175,
-0.0231433716,
0.2533257008,
-0.6515986919,
-0.2268738151,
0.3636898398,
-0.4649930894,
0.557266891,
0.0887205452,
-0.1907293051,
0.1053583696,
-0.5143092275,
0.0715337768,
0.2824245393,
-0.0549267307,
-0.7756083012,
0.0875808597,
0.2670043111,
0.3027517796,
-0.1068395153,
-0.7135660648,
-0.3059111536,
-0.3516839147,
0.5349695683,
0.6224705577,
0.0126659386,
0.6266527176,
-0.2911887467,
0.4142414927,
-0.046134565,
0.4750185013,
-0.2583150566,
-0.3955958486,
-0.5185601711,
-0.114764519,
-0.0320246182,
0.499368012,
-1.1323679686,
0.1126245186,
-0.1303516477,
-0.2865322828,
-0.0155233424,
0.0322373062,
0.5986421704,
0.5870281458,
0.3620223999,
-0.5836738348,
-0.3180387318,
-0.8429189324,
-0.0942495093,
0.0408950038,
-0.0450244062,
0.199742347,
0.47081092,
-0.222965762,
0.8832951784,
-0.7337310314,
-0.1329465657,
0.1025497094,
-0.0239899196,
-0.536796093,
0.7428150773,
0.7691734433,
-1.0585690737,
-0.386179924,
-0.3704944253,
-0.7234259844,
0.1017984971,
0.1562713832,
-0.3474471271,
-0.0812561959,
0.7191833854,
-0.4702322483,
0.7676517963,
0.378521502,
-0.382996738,
0.47661677,
0.0286444556,
0.0703370795,
-0.958153367,
-0.0112240044,
0.0635986477,
-0.4215837717,
-0.5409216285,
0.5308129787,
0.2458416522,
-0.52668643,
-0.9503567815,
0.3165364861,
-0.4257080555,
0.2887930572,
-0.3061883748,
0.0698382333,
0.3737232089,
0.2689535022,
0.2974989712,
0.8897401094,
0.641563952,
-0.594058156,
-0.1018689945,
0.6870883703,
-0.4200073183,
0.4386923313,
-0.5877177119,
0.0613881797,
-0.1288359463,
-0.0820052177,
-0.3908507526,
-0.3718207479,
0.2056256235,
-0.2496096939,
0.2312477678,
-0.1970970482,
-0.3840139508,
-0.0951155275,
-0.621615231,
0.7156253457,
0.5971241593,
-0.6167374849,
0.1408147663,
1.0707306862,
-0.2887065411,
-0.5341929793,
-0.896695435,
0.1472384483,
-0.0952512622,
-0.5155454278,
0.4997147024,
0.0183112044,
-0.0558642708,
0.2166208178,
-0.0927955285,
-0.6275129318,
0.2074543387,
0.3553524315,
0.5884353518,
0.1847412586,
0.1449840665,
0.3550467789,
0.1245293915,
0.2022383809,
0.1092843935,
0.1957997829,
-0.0606129728,
-0.2613152862,
-0.0801740363,
0.5690754056,
0.7193622589,
-0.4497040808,
0.6749000549,
0.5272929072,
-0.5970151424,
-0.3132266104,
-0.2349502742,
-0.2146375924,
-0.5085617304,
0.6319267154,
0.1023571119,
-0.9623465538,
0.0841658115,
-0.0217080321,
-0.0673698336,
0.0863674209,
0.2934315503,
-0.0936919525,
1.0725233555,
1.1095427275,
0.3052349389,
0.7681016922,
-0.232714951,
0.3381696045,
-0.8670372367,
-0.3518569767,
-0.1951503903,
0.1691439301,
-0.1940550804,
-1.0369091034,
0.4653576016,
0.1843059808,
-0.066496782,
0.4271280766,
-0.5296506286,
0.890250802,
0.2372815311,
0.542945683,
0.1014197767,
-0.0130456677,
-0.3393387496,
-0.2072430551,
-0.6145349145,
-0.4542796612,
1.0251832008,
0.4138527215,
1.1965641975,
0.0355991311,
0.3594151735,
0.1615013629,
0.275683105,
-0.7810419202,
0.6479564905,
-0.4627957642,
-0.7463213205,
-0.1455014199,
-0.1941625625,
-0.3798047006,
0.3355319202,
-0.5511748791,
-0.7809726,
0.2874934077,
0.2396500111,
-0.258957684,
0.5375974178,
-0.6887381673,
0.6590448618,
-0.2525022924,
-0.7355905175,
-0.2624793947,
-0.4752561748,
0.5427119732,
-0.2641162574,
0.3177562654,
-0.3992099762,
-0.0743078291,
0.7252069116,
-0.3419338167,
1.1198216677,
0.0671874955,
-0.0425252356,
0.3500803113,
0.3997217119,
0.2651125193,
0.0534162559,
0.2580907345,
0.2926571071,
0.1176434681,
-0.0958878621,
-0.367397815,
0.3976150155,
-0.4587841332,
-0.3687710762,
-0.282692194,
-0.7702087164,
-0.4149617851,
0.4186532795,
0.2748601735,
0.5986476541,
-0.5010932088,
0.5071361661,
0.947893858,
-0.6107158065,
0.4650430381,
0.304554224,
-0.2947983742,
-0.5055669546,
0.8404018283,
-0.2222363204,
0.4530316889,
0.3432717621,
-0.0277660899,
-0.4134613872,
-0.5342444777,
-0.323666364,
-0.0190140661,
-0.863943398,
-0.3289162517,
-0.58900702,
-0.1569438428,
-0.2939801216,
-0.3606314361,
-0.4216658473,
-0.3853579164,
-0.4648753107,
-0.2306115627,
0.292743504,
0.4484163821,
-0.1396466643,
0.1295570731,
-1.1220659018,
0.4450368583,
0.2956654429,
0.5352043509,
-0.0803666562,
-0.1425742656,
-0.1397152245,
0.0330765247,
-0.3333446085,
-0.8008966446,
0.7080014944,
0.3431607783,
0.3520332277,
0.6502251625,
0.3966395557,
0.5657352209,
-0.7741863132,
0.6770766973,
0.6889027953,
-1.0971637964,
0.6260153055,
-0.5611765981,
0.1915171444,
0.5222404003,
0.3679621816,
-0.3867027164,
-0.4323212504,
-0.304009527,
-1.0248259306,
0.4511001706,
0.185145244,
0.3930567801,
-0.1980099231,
0.0631683245,
0.0062229582,
0.1589662284,
-0.7458437085,
0.3106758893,
-0.4131635725,
-0.14905186,
0.2560153008,
-0.514945507,
-0.4122492075,
-0.3245073855,
0.4185869396,
-0.2914690971,
0.342905432,
-0.0190238506,
-0.4558667839,
-0.1352366954,
0.2098608166,
0.3020728827,
0.5141251087,
-0.0505798608,
0.2055169344,
0.179185912,
-0.7225593925,
0.0863452032,
-0.2173919976,
-0.6802579165,
-0.1704929471,
0.0345455036,
0.6635279059,
0.5415409803,
-0.8987175226,
0.7856431603,
-0.008815675,
-0.1569489241,
-0.0590742081,
0.142041713,
-0.1528616101,
-0.048047971,
0.01125223,
0.4135137796,
0.1167415753,
-0.5250827074,
0.7158907056,
0.5085617304,
-0.540809989,
-0.3567716479,
0.9155415893,
0.5129589438,
0.0100776721,
0.2061282694,
0.1089856923,
-0.6674051881,
0.5146272779,
0.7659553885,
0.838062644,
0.0223369449,
0.5206224322,
0.2676067054,
0.4338995218,
-0.2088777125,
0.1041855142,
0.1511002183,
-0.8741220236,
-0.274276942,
-0.5544590354,
-0.3458058238,
0.0306252465,
-0.8397484422,
0.0737740099,
-0.7637900114,
-0.3760391474,
-0.1616745889,
-0.7651023865,
-0.3982004523,
0.2334099859,
0.265964061,
0.8227315545,
-0.9435517192,
0.9229009748,
0.6043658257,
-0.3573974371,
-0.8198336363,
0.1546366364,
-0.0076784077,
-0.5136212707,
0.3059045672,
0.2540381551,
-0.2697746754,
-0.3271003067,
-0.6863082647,
-1.0343267918,
0.6495036483,
0.5014750361,
-0.4718048275,
-0.2290345132,
-0.0014512723,
0.2684247196,
-0.1253454089,
-0.3095830977,
0.2119283676,
-0.0095158461,
-0.0002592515,
-0.783583045,
0.3477155268,
-0.400251478,
0.2232962102,
0.1974836886,
-0.4110520184,
0.8000043631,
-0.4064505994,
-0.4359145761,
0.0622752272,
0.2582407892,
-0.0778556913,
0.0631132275,
0.482093364,
0.5295078754,
0.4847645462,
-0.1108576581,
0.8105177879,
-0.1791015714,
0.3138933778,
1.0481313467,
-0.1477298886,
1.0654119253,
0.4428022206,
0.2648926675,
0.2135030925,
0.1095039994,
-0.2490014881,
0.9685539603,
-0.3354608119,
-0.150818482,
-0.4906101823,
-0.4346309006,
-0.2404164076,
0.609551847,
0.4058325291,
-0.4948593378,
-0.2901480198,
0.5156428218,
0.1482275277,
0.1674308479,
-0.149329558,
0.5375368595,
0.2707063556,
-0.1985236406,
0.5109991431,
0.0436735004,
0.7742188573,
-0.2369335145,
-0.1211505607,
0.2854021788,
0.1453507096,
-0.044768095,
-0.8785841465,
0.5971870422,
0.4116077125,
-0.00372303,
-0.282355845,
0.9855948091,
-0.5265216231,
-0.4420461953,
0.2331721336,
0.2022925168,
-0.1879036427,
0.0394755304,
-0.6364473701,
0.0746405274,
-0.0961121246,
0.198088944,
0.467857182,
0.0468280613,
-0.1853792965,
0.7302932143,
0.8136504292,
-0.180256322,
0.0426034592,
-0.0630832389,
1.0251960754,
-0.6329081655,
-0.7324293256,
-0.5915470719,
0.3642407954,
-0.0512318909,
-0.1111008152,
0.5389961004,
0.266851604,
0.9022753835,
-0.3208189607,
0.7384513021,
-0.1872208863,
0.2173783332,
-0.5704231262,
1.3141806126,
-0.4310187399,
-0.0585078374,
-0.7644946575,
-0.5013080239,
-0.516117692,
0.6894141436,
-0.191555053,
-0.4165252745,
0.681840837,
0.8404250145,
-0.0267824307,
-0.0397603288,
0.5062614083,
0.0487852804,
0.4416254759,
0.4829521477,
0.893867135,
-0.2900676727,
0.8472625017,
-0.7781947255,
-0.1915020794,
-0.1292001158,
-1.032073617,
-1.0225101709,
-0.4611541331,
-0.4414960444,
-0.2116590142,
0.1597565562,
0.4928787649,
0.924837172,
-0.5753000379,
0.1997316033,
0.0651649311,
0.0173051879,
0.0322656929,
-0.1630003601,
0.2043896616,
0.2168499231,
-0.594799161,
0.4081014991,
0.2441304773,
0.3758024573,
-0.0389729105,
0.187236622,
0.0335127339,
0.2523542345,
0.9354203939,
0.2845755816,
-0.5847037435,
-0.6958177686,
0.0671901852,
-0.0886718854,
-0.0320222825,
0.4406119883,
-0.5368618369,
0.5235439539,
0.4226698875,
0.5178259611,
0.30643031,
0.0544794351,
0.7316104174,
-0.7251346707,
0.4604341686,
0.2551788092,
0.3687253892,
0.4975616634,
-0.4578085244,
0.3720242083,
0.2664749324,
-0.0201916639,
-0.9739207625,
0.3943329751,
-0.9400728345,
-0.5036737919,
0.9903991222,
-0.2063173205,
-0.4846694171,
-0.030931918,
-0.265373826,
0.2946623862,
-0.2533527017,
1.017546773,
0.2181105018,
0.2996825278,
-0.3210902214,
-0.3126403689,
0.5469918251,
0.2723455131,
-0.8527966142,
0.0937846377,
0.6691012979,
0.6815510392,
0.1343281269,
0.2501153052,
-0.5496621728,
0.6349512935,
0.1316622645,
0.0345239639,
-0.3907026947,
-0.6699867249,
-0.1490663439,
0.3038957119,
-0.0163424686,
-0.4258542359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16101v1
|
How Many Unicorns Are in This Image? A Safety Evaluation Benchmark for Vision LLMs
| 2023-11-27T18:59:42 | 2023-11-27T18:59:42 |
Haoqin Tu, Chenhang Cui, Zijun Wang, Yiyang Zhou, Bingchen Zhao, Junlin Han, Wangchunshu Zhou, Huaxiu Yao, Cihang Xie
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This work focuses on the potential of Vision LLMs (VLLMs) in visual
reasoning. Different from prior studies, we shift our focus from evaluating
standard performance to introducing a comprehensive safety evaluation suite,
covering both out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization and adversarial
robustness. For the OOD evaluation, we present two novel VQA datasets, each
with one variant, designed to test model performance under challenging
conditions. In exploring adversarial robustness, we propose a straightforward
attack strategy for misleading VLLMs to produce visual-unrelated responses.
Moreover, we assess the efficacy of two jailbreaking strategies, targeting
either the vision or language component of VLLMs. Our evaluation of 21 diverse
models, ranging from open-source VLLMs to GPT-4V, yields interesting
observations: 1) Current VLLMs struggle with OOD texts but not images, unless
the visual information is limited; and 2) These VLLMs can be easily misled by
deceiving vision encoders only, and their vision-language training often
compromise safety protocols. We release this safety evaluation suite at
https://github.com/UCSC-VLAA/vllm-safety-benchmark.
|
[
-0.1970641017,
-0.3848320544,
0.4681823552,
0.060706269,
-0.4392934144,
-0.0538086705,
0.3566655219,
-0.6919344664,
-0.2453738153,
0.6981939673,
-0.3391731679,
-0.5548647642,
-0.5372272134,
-0.0161547549,
-0.583943665,
0.5054778457,
0.085040696,
0.2151080072,
-0.3598778844,
-0.2955459058,
-0.3946835399,
-0.4078530371,
-0.3725901544,
0.0831110626,
0.4822989702,
-0.1465668231,
0.7821918726,
0.7790212035,
0.8877109289,
0.2807461321,
-0.2393664867,
0.1296422631,
-0.550907135,
-0.184615314,
-0.1898641288,
-0.3971379101,
-0.2294955552,
-0.0554802194,
0.504381299,
0.4285331666,
-0.0659427196,
0.1032736674,
-0.0331126973,
0.7216798067,
-1.1726499796,
-0.1153339148,
-0.8967602253,
0.3258751333,
-0.0522220358,
0.1402982324,
-0.3850873709,
-0.3897159398,
0.2169047296,
-0.5260044932,
-0.1865882576,
0.2775886655,
0.9278020263,
0.5952860713,
-0.3363874555,
0.0687070265,
-0.1735684723,
0.7969198823,
-0.2538755238,
0.3822508454,
0.0768080056,
0.6512647271,
-0.133083716,
-0.8187626004,
-0.2924532294,
-0.4378923774,
0.3288945258,
0.3854874671,
-0.2691794336,
-0.0584034286,
0.2904051542,
0.1572950929,
-0.5723688006,
0.2068502307,
-0.4699873328,
-0.1837276667,
0.5071382523,
0.2924711406,
0.1645298153,
0.1445712298,
-1.0095056295,
-0.3771652281,
-0.9673839808,
0.0655969605,
0.3156348169,
-0.2873978615,
-0.0199348107,
0.7508619428,
-0.1145194471,
0.7259872556,
-0.3084615171,
-0.0062724035,
0.2472544014,
-0.3005417883,
-0.4766102433,
-0.1418386251,
0.8503593802,
0.9004154801,
0.2307502478,
-0.2035985589,
-0.129655689,
0.3659128845,
0.5903143287,
-0.6901048422,
-0.2356971353,
-0.0258227699,
-0.403881222,
-0.6037246585,
0.0490180142,
-0.8506520987,
-0.8202869892,
0.2030184716,
0.5627776384,
-0.5518370271,
0.1669249088,
0.3223639429,
-0.3773688674,
0.5706278682,
0.3903939128,
-0.5223481059,
-0.00808811,
0.5579123497,
0.5647311807,
-0.4776642621,
-0.4065794945,
-0.422380507,
0.1349389404,
-0.6205592155,
0.7412458658,
-0.0387735143,
-0.4664626718,
-0.1023071632,
-0.0327960998,
-0.0813672692,
-0.8456090689,
0.4511090219,
-0.3537529707,
-0.3138706982,
-0.3058662117,
-0.2015138716,
-0.1412037015,
0.4021136463,
-0.704960227,
0.6185956001,
-0.1620800048,
-0.7139316201,
0.729816854,
-0.3496139348,
-0.0932893902,
0.0377071239,
-0.487200141,
-0.4579355121,
0.0231080167,
0.1508472562,
0.211808145,
-0.2828877866,
-0.1495858133,
-0.7274264693,
-0.4878150225,
0.353230685,
-0.5136403441,
0.9082448483,
0.220049426,
-0.1565945894,
0.0936814994,
-0.7069780827,
0.138032347,
0.2727255225,
-0.2384145707,
-0.2397248596,
0.0944844857,
-0.2354933918,
0.0255899746,
0.2932754755,
-0.4250271618,
-0.1181704551,
-0.1772744209,
0.3272125423,
0.7239313126,
-0.2422842383,
0.1076986492,
-0.0751966983,
0.1653059274,
0.1680906564,
0.7273083329,
-0.0994597599,
-0.6130553484,
-0.9140789509,
-0.3111199737,
-0.0550417043,
0.7314896584,
-1.1028163433,
0.2001217157,
0.1051941216,
-0.2983920872,
-0.2445753366,
0.1988818347,
0.8094565272,
0.4949445128,
0.2420705855,
-0.3867893815,
-0.3000759482,
-1.0119415522,
-0.3610115349,
-0.4144251943,
0.1089474931,
-0.0639708638,
0.6493732929,
-0.3996471763,
0.72315979,
-0.1995155364,
0.0238828175,
0.0580381081,
-0.2547760606,
-0.0769575089,
0.2315819561,
0.8701138496,
-0.7961888909,
0.1174826175,
-0.0506345183,
-1.24870193,
0.1831199378,
0.2371556163,
-0.0766899884,
0.1394134015,
0.3916327953,
-0.4084738791,
0.7580885887,
0.427657336,
-0.3721535802,
0.4801971614,
-0.1599804014,
0.0542344898,
-0.495919317,
-0.2735116184,
0.1911889762,
-0.1398202628,
-0.3579273224,
0.3283995986,
0.2059950531,
0.0824918002,
-1.1091656685,
0.3239607811,
-0.2921706438,
-0.3181162179,
0.0307219047,
0.019980235,
-0.0045129308,
0.022484323,
0.0316911899,
0.7203555107,
0.8045846224,
-0.4958653152,
0.5582324862,
0.0192653257,
-0.6415589452,
0.6859057546,
-0.7522463202,
0.0544701256,
-0.1803271919,
-0.1893129349,
-0.7712122798,
-0.1182027608,
0.365108788,
-0.1196721196,
0.0763198733,
0.0397519432,
-0.4661235213,
-0.4989781082,
-0.6118822694,
0.1635153294,
0.5967826843,
-0.8036425114,
0.2983357906,
0.4422203898,
0.4010666907,
-0.888006866,
-0.9004859924,
0.3459938169,
-0.5398684144,
-0.7687950134,
-0.0064077051,
-0.0714647993,
-0.6195271611,
0.0073357145,
-0.1063535139,
-0.0802663714,
0.3102832437,
0.3664361537,
0.438352406,
-0.0309276693,
-0.2589185536,
-0.270814687,
-0.1557862014,
0.2122146934,
-0.151481688,
-0.0521296486,
-0.702491045,
-0.7224663496,
-0.2091572136,
0.1290694326,
0.4032315016,
0.0782408938,
0.5019174814,
0.4125968218,
-0.309396714,
-0.2292724401,
-0.3974392712,
0.000647201,
-0.4893033206,
0.4376583397,
-0.230625242,
-0.6689398885,
0.1990456581,
0.0162130408,
-0.0297169965,
0.2819570601,
0.4338722527,
-0.2878885269,
0.840780437,
0.6307440996,
0.2141713202,
0.1793643832,
-0.1996805519,
-0.0242747553,
-0.4012460411,
-0.3759950399,
-0.035336338,
-0.0595504716,
-0.3194630742,
-0.4568579793,
0.4305301905,
0.3599134982,
-0.1597627848,
0.3178062737,
-0.3585684597,
0.6806364059,
0.5295547843,
0.1180073544,
0.180062592,
-0.0109668467,
-0.3329776824,
-0.0249231905,
-0.6575195193,
-0.6879298687,
1.1524888277,
0.4495344162,
0.9530164599,
-0.0249581672,
0.5043632388,
0.1144147292,
0.2308167666,
-0.4451467395,
0.821895659,
-0.2814320326,
-0.2828561366,
-0.0650534853,
-0.2779990733,
-0.6956759691,
0.5404844284,
-0.322153002,
-0.8915690184,
0.2702957392,
0.1252088249,
-0.3752782941,
0.2312972546,
-0.798509717,
1.0063719749,
-0.7434113026,
-0.4029320776,
0.0118672717,
-0.7248125672,
0.7879505157,
-0.2125852853,
-0.0482908562,
-0.0857692137,
-0.1989951283,
0.4326135516,
-0.3460043669,
0.7236751914,
0.1534617096,
0.136489436,
0.4630247056,
-0.2889132202,
0.1223356128,
0.0582064055,
0.1744299382,
0.6450734138,
-0.013192568,
-0.2002916634,
-0.3848139048,
0.6367496252,
-0.5368626118,
-0.4310720265,
-0.4845404327,
-0.3778845668,
-0.2453567386,
0.0474382453,
0.5053633451,
0.0271823891,
-0.1630537957,
0.4611397684,
0.8339256048,
-0.4662343264,
0.5388047695,
0.2563573718,
-0.4015423656,
-0.7189280987,
0.7893909216,
0.0245520957,
0.3671557307,
0.1208259538,
-0.126697436,
-0.5000614524,
-0.8541961312,
-0.717056036,
-0.2078952044,
-1.0100250244,
-0.0683353618,
-0.0917435214,
-0.2740016282,
-0.1039611399,
-0.0626471117,
-0.4483113587,
-0.1597037613,
-0.0588250384,
-0.0660527349,
0.1041332185,
0.8338417411,
-0.027745489,
0.1209131256,
-0.4334456027,
0.5792729855,
0.7548321486,
0.19464463,
-0.4895612299,
-0.1329220235,
-0.0897948295,
-0.212375313,
-0.5739922523,
-0.7853705287,
0.1283019632,
-0.187713027,
0.8251094818,
0.5977947712,
0.0890842378,
0.5512501001,
-0.4401165843,
0.7618544698,
0.7544094324,
-0.614931643,
0.4686801732,
-0.1544197351,
-0.0630274713,
0.456508249,
0.0269796178,
0.229991734,
-0.3043333292,
-0.3572752476,
-0.828114152,
0.2092924118,
0.4334730506,
-0.2999304831,
-0.0356093571,
0.1135403067,
-0.0369356126,
0.1789789945,
-0.734962225,
-0.3104698658,
-0.3870111406,
0.0064585879,
0.0879101455,
-0.3133977652,
-0.4469921589,
0.0874585062,
0.1337748617,
-0.0950921401,
0.0235319789,
0.0483733006,
-0.0667253658,
0.2192939371,
-0.0488391072,
0.439984709,
0.7181292176,
-0.1756308228,
0.2342641801,
0.3978858292,
-0.6182470322,
0.0141658336,
-0.0360765047,
-0.3626300693,
-0.2167342603,
0.2365516275,
0.7825688124,
0.0065096538,
-0.9936580658,
0.6777206063,
-0.2949097455,
-0.283621043,
-0.194846645,
0.3337238729,
-0.1006075516,
0.5663255453,
0.3775671422,
0.2497470975,
0.1688218117,
-0.4122341275,
0.0728980526,
0.5961626172,
-0.381152004,
0.0494491383,
0.9570606947,
-0.0622806624,
0.0050638281,
0.1404162198,
-0.082617715,
-0.2272010148,
0.8466736674,
0.1139249653,
0.9371429086,
0.1709350497,
0.0430986322,
-0.1740501374,
0.853593111,
-0.2412403524,
0.4309180975,
0.2928816378,
-0.6495608091,
-0.1541340798,
-0.4600514174,
-0.6711344719,
0.1607659161,
-0.5815176964,
0.3250649571,
-0.6965203881,
-0.307453841,
-0.222070694,
-0.5758760571,
-0.4744744003,
0.5104861856,
0.419352293,
0.855363667,
-0.4177748263,
0.6607849002,
0.8510764837,
-0.1949485987,
-0.2622596622,
-0.1837524176,
0.1391929835,
-1.0296829939,
0.6612048149,
0.3681974411,
-0.4114973843,
-0.4496586025,
-0.8134506345,
-0.6034601927,
1.1716301441,
0.8844513297,
-0.6149423718,
0.3691889644,
0.2923524678,
0.2957613766,
-0.2206262052,
0.0633490309,
0.4618244171,
0.2246833295,
0.2061492205,
-0.7344655395,
-0.2004115731,
-0.1507260501,
0.3375642002,
-0.2521717846,
-0.6737374067,
0.741179049,
-0.6139852405,
-0.1888554245,
0.3308917582,
0.5374872684,
0.6493487358,
0.5411560535,
0.5497513413,
0.9526795149,
0.5134041309,
-0.2785337567,
1.1468681097,
-0.0832382068,
0.1163199171,
0.9176441431,
-0.2752777338,
0.9128089547,
0.7475286126,
-0.1231064796,
-0.1106111258,
0.5765562057,
-0.085777469,
0.8396112919,
0.3074006438,
-0.0218033474,
-0.443685919,
0.0931364,
-0.5318766236,
0.3832381964,
0.1884607822,
-0.3720592856,
-0.2172185928,
0.0145625621,
-0.3483039141,
-0.1143190265,
-0.5656897426,
0.5446749926,
0.2975653112,
-0.1087397859,
0.6872286797,
-0.3471132219,
0.4317316711,
-0.3249877393,
0.0709142089,
-0.0041498118,
0.5370024443,
-0.0501961149,
-1.0713433027,
0.2160093188,
0.1343568414,
0.1400437355,
-0.0799734518,
0.7590942383,
0.1904284209,
-0.6166713238,
0.5123409629,
0.1713451147,
0.309037447,
0.1389930248,
-0.7092947364,
0.2917100191,
-0.2041684091,
-0.1226834655,
0.531104207,
0.2841774225,
-0.1738535166,
0.9160779715,
0.4530634582,
-0.0429360084,
0.5687303543,
-0.0536420047,
0.9058588147,
-0.7412930727,
-0.2455489933,
-0.9118990302,
0.5377374291,
-0.3075925112,
-0.5579882264,
0.9390567541,
0.4408069253,
0.907319665,
-0.1937737316,
0.7620540857,
0.3713521659,
0.0018593351,
-0.7552294135,
0.8123365641,
-0.6513744593,
0.3732829392,
-0.3227511644,
-0.798140347,
-0.4489262104,
0.6230790615,
-0.2896744907,
-0.2901661992,
0.6074371338,
0.5800854564,
0.1894373745,
0.0015465373,
0.7297429442,
0.0409185104,
-0.0071405969,
0.7517384291,
1.5005941391,
-0.5432684422,
0.7861834168,
-0.2734231055,
-0.165891394,
-0.1148472801,
-1.1900024414,
-0.9515711069,
0.1033092216,
-0.4582576752,
-0.3961646855,
0.5279957056,
0.2121670693,
0.7194915414,
-0.5176840425,
-0.1176538691,
-0.088223055,
0.2323025465,
-0.1016239449,
-0.0850213915,
-0.0083631361,
-0.0735711306,
-0.3901722729,
0.6726485491,
0.7342790365,
0.2509181499,
-0.3680903912,
-0.2995156646,
0.5921671987,
-0.0593756102,
0.5999403596,
0.175901413,
-0.8564982414,
-0.2923589051,
-0.1724415272,
-0.1888292134,
-0.0803848952,
0.104953289,
-0.7221617103,
0.549018681,
0.3815290034,
0.611859858,
0.2002913058,
-0.2170833051,
0.367955327,
-0.1086595505,
0.3259105682,
0.0686236024,
0.7579987645,
0.2696265876,
-0.045645643,
0.5741809607,
0.37341699,
-0.3262129724,
-1.0376617908,
0.2388392389,
-1.1115803719,
-0.1731410027,
1.1211175919,
-0.3719131351,
-0.5694966316,
0.0977007076,
-0.0788751245,
-0.2976025045,
0.0038537174,
0.6979653835,
0.2585856616,
0.0493096784,
-0.2273222357,
-0.6551813483,
0.3250564933,
0.0763948187,
-0.851403296,
-0.3572591841,
0.4684748948,
0.2312319577,
0.1547710299,
0.1569787711,
-0.2674518526,
0.5904735327,
0.2934059203,
-0.0635225549,
-0.0460207909,
-0.5092929006,
-0.3723266423,
0.3401738405,
-0.0908315405,
-0.6457851529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03729v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03729v1
|
Cognitive Dissonance: Why Do Language Model Outputs Disagree with Internal Representations of Truthfulness?
| 2023-11-27T18:59:14 | 2023-11-27T18:59:14 |
Kevin Liu, Stephen Casper, Dylan Hadfield-Menell, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Neural language models (LMs) can be used to evaluate the truth of factual
statements in two ways: they can be either queried for statement probabilities,
or probed for internal representations of truthfulness. Past work has found
that these two procedures sometimes disagree, and that probes tend to be more
accurate than LM outputs. This has led some researchers to conclude that LMs
"lie" or otherwise encode non-cooperative communicative intents. Is this an
accurate description of today's LMs, or can query-probe disagreement arise in
other ways? We identify three different classes of disagreement, which we term
confabulation, deception, and heterogeneity. In many cases, the superiority of
probes is simply attributable to better calibration on uncertain answers rather
than a greater fraction of correct, high-confidence answers. In some cases,
queries and probes perform better on different subsets of inputs, and accuracy
can further be improved by ensembling the two. Code is available at
github.com/lingo-mit/lm-truthfulness.
|
[
-0.1990235448,
-0.7811136842,
0.8105176687,
0.2897738516,
0.0806060135,
0.2127752453,
-0.4160395265,
-0.4674775004,
0.0006375926,
0.1449887156,
-0.422339797,
-0.1742076427,
-0.7382306457,
-0.0059437011,
-0.3253374398,
0.5952259898,
0.2526856959,
0.5625813007,
-0.6089295745,
-0.3083069026,
-0.5304460526,
-0.7071866393,
-0.5787858367,
-0.718128264,
0.6445125341,
0.3024490178,
0.9552381635,
0.2021500468,
0.4448266625,
0.3906719685,
-0.0987973362,
0.1416111141,
-0.3350609541,
0.3288182914,
-0.1555510163,
-0.8186210394,
0.0289633516,
0.3651580215,
0.3529998064,
0.8748222589,
-0.1738205999,
-0.1900065988,
0.1121297032,
0.6954979897,
-0.6097072959,
0.1319383234,
-0.6335604191,
-0.1208357885,
-0.0236961767,
0.0647399276,
-0.547033906,
-0.7661530375,
0.3379629552,
-0.2237756401,
0.0864784122,
-0.0615795963,
0.7777587175,
0.4859612882,
-0.5909560323,
-0.7534261346,
-0.8504011035,
0.8302401304,
-0.8794641495,
0.3891736567,
0.5722638965,
0.3740927577,
0.1151574254,
-0.6492517591,
-0.7184969187,
-0.5039559603,
-0.2139616609,
0.2040538341,
-0.1334535927,
0.0936570168,
0.2088014483,
0.6307538152,
-0.5723022819,
0.1354213208,
-0.0547381155,
-0.2358784527,
0.5016018152,
0.1872095317,
0.0099668894,
0.1296315342,
-0.2629904449,
-0.1502662152,
-0.5724003315,
0.0726540834,
0.5353484154,
0.0789336264,
-0.046418339,
0.5706717968,
-0.0266053099,
0.620919764,
0.3391577899,
0.008947039,
0.0766125396,
-0.2255154401,
-0.1038991436,
0.2039554119,
0.7188920379,
0.5012159348,
0.1668714285,
-0.0656032711,
-0.3177701831,
0.5519445539,
0.1366458982,
-0.5518187284,
-0.2452136874,
0.515938282,
-0.4076391459,
-0.2125035077,
0.0987286568,
-0.3936151862,
-0.499717474,
-0.3514343798,
0.2929703593,
-0.400687933,
-0.2922382057,
0.4366840422,
-0.1503968835,
0.0300368331,
0.3195819557,
-0.5596740246,
0.3413884342,
0.6489780545,
0.7276109457,
-0.0212018061,
-0.1271349192,
-0.3491801918,
-0.4236322641,
-0.5479406714,
0.4297732115,
-0.4397334158,
-0.2772789598,
0.1258692145,
-0.3019604683,
-0.0564059876,
-0.7495215535,
0.4436056912,
-0.6399886012,
0.505939126,
-0.6998791695,
-0.8274028301,
-0.2512909472,
0.4424277842,
-0.6826254725,
0.7741471529,
-0.1151972786,
-0.5919100642,
-0.0950032622,
-0.3613902032,
-0.1134631187,
-0.1295577884,
-0.585755229,
-0.0753754005,
0.3073927462,
-0.3832887113,
0.175397262,
-0.4074929059,
0.5192729831,
-0.2362123132,
-0.5165513158,
1.071398735,
-0.6949776411,
0.9688845873,
0.2903856933,
-0.3250952661,
-0.2241174281,
-0.5014805794,
0.0275826734,
0.2240305543,
-0.3607745469,
-0.3557367325,
0.181539312,
-0.4586927593,
0.0814804956,
0.3852108717,
-0.7453828454,
-0.1104909033,
-0.4160355031,
0.2472156286,
0.5919166207,
-0.1716942936,
0.4520669878,
-0.7290536165,
-0.0040411544,
0.4110283852,
0.2252309471,
0.1629804075,
-0.5590796471,
-0.6752750874,
0.2102528363,
0.1548585296,
0.3603420556,
-0.6357690692,
0.1426147521,
-0.0314721316,
-0.725145936,
-0.4022904336,
-0.318497926,
0.5114515424,
0.7133003473,
0.2874161303,
-0.2766169906,
-0.4138915539,
-0.9020238519,
-0.4002991319,
-0.3813564777,
0.3469986618,
0.2174790204,
0.1788471043,
-0.0390401147,
0.7680956721,
-0.4412154853,
0.0519181639,
0.0515447222,
0.3570269644,
0.3986874521,
0.3962238729,
0.4730837941,
-0.8947111368,
-0.460539788,
-0.2725191414,
-0.8919241428,
0.0789175332,
0.0017337984,
0.3002384603,
0.3485088944,
0.3818341792,
-0.7052896023,
0.2974211574,
0.8824890256,
-0.1303198785,
0.6497682333,
-0.0574863106,
0.1128883883,
-0.7724022865,
-0.3288809657,
-0.0545302145,
-0.1087803692,
-0.5685162544,
-0.0586764775,
0.04660137,
0.48783499,
-0.3579323888,
0.1063558757,
-0.6248139739,
-0.0101391058,
-0.2609829903,
0.3348954618,
0.1808461547,
0.2536590993,
-0.1236290783,
0.5984711051,
0.5250295401,
-0.7814041972,
0.8058025241,
0.0528194048,
-0.3319740593,
0.501275003,
-0.6416676044,
0.3786879778,
-0.2686278224,
0.2280487716,
-1.040456295,
-0.0856626108,
0.2380975038,
-0.7677765489,
0.2224519551,
-0.117034018,
-0.3150921464,
-0.0127712516,
-0.2731935382,
0.5067041516,
0.4953283668,
-0.4411995709,
0.3902121484,
0.2276586741,
0.2082571089,
-0.8470634222,
-1.2789593935,
-0.0752388984,
0.0950673968,
-0.4777070284,
0.1746025383,
-0.2726535201,
-0.7315534949,
0.0741474256,
-0.1799390465,
0.0043290379,
-0.0420883074,
0.2727758288,
0.3629625738,
-0.4929190576,
0.3370332122,
-0.3018961847,
0.0461007468,
0.4077653289,
-0.1207384169,
0.7885413766,
-0.347550422,
-0.8366740346,
-0.2332032621,
0.3728068173,
0.4063524306,
-0.093975693,
0.7977349758,
0.2229552567,
-0.5165820122,
0.1146665812,
-0.7222776413,
-0.4135040939,
-0.4880974889,
0.0854699239,
-0.2472191453,
-0.9491346478,
0.5579781532,
-0.2081960887,
-0.0452927798,
0.356725812,
0.57046628,
-0.4355708957,
0.9628099799,
0.2652131319,
0.1726109236,
0.2066743374,
-0.0851124972,
0.1787451059,
-0.630946517,
-0.25077191,
-0.7519472837,
-0.3582463861,
-0.8491564393,
-0.2756012678,
0.3191482425,
-0.2140578032,
-0.2480099648,
-0.1460268497,
-0.4417532086,
0.4885530472,
0.4649605751,
0.049009718,
0.4129341543,
-0.2761787176,
-0.1427413821,
-0.3848220408,
-0.7796497345,
-0.6160249114,
0.8920713663,
0.2760286927,
0.8375735283,
0.4224877059,
0.4869019091,
0.0288235862,
0.2590491176,
-0.9494648576,
0.4604189396,
-0.123142764,
-0.8836548924,
-0.1247834563,
-0.4526861906,
-0.8359768987,
0.1325139254,
-0.1549162865,
-0.6204370856,
0.5619130731,
0.2621585727,
-0.2446175963,
0.3501433134,
-0.6271919012,
0.6549079418,
-0.4711709023,
-0.441967994,
-0.1319915652,
-0.7476918697,
0.43345052,
0.0970648006,
0.0350475721,
-0.0025148401,
0.08037889,
0.3253430128,
-0.2676296234,
1.0211561918,
-0.1355057061,
-0.2759956121,
0.3548291624,
0.3700867295,
0.5013216734,
0.0333696268,
-0.3143301904,
0.1526022106,
0.1116918921,
-0.2937623858,
-0.7067140341,
0.746412158,
-0.7705695629,
-0.7119275928,
-0.7816790938,
-0.525039494,
-0.3197753429,
-0.0030856594,
0.5182250738,
0.5385609865,
-0.4768092632,
0.2618523538,
0.982781291,
-0.0412997976,
0.4365305007,
0.348957479,
-0.3339606524,
0.069821462,
0.7411669493,
0.1636551023,
0.6724361777,
0.2962375879,
0.1579268575,
-0.587816298,
-0.4857753515,
-0.0369465463,
0.2381317019,
-1.0083678961,
-0.1763872802,
-0.2694061399,
-0.3271728754,
-0.2316591293,
0.0956885368,
-0.6496042013,
-0.2766515911,
-0.0545941293,
-0.0140057933,
0.0464814007,
0.8562704325,
-0.1780412793,
0.0812934488,
-0.7360883951,
-0.0007050503,
0.3518840075,
0.1284929961,
-0.1955226213,
-0.3627370894,
-0.201420933,
0.6773362756,
-0.263207227,
-1.2416393757,
-0.0861883312,
-0.0632114708,
0.4670383632,
0.2127480507,
0.2536715269,
0.4211886525,
0.0140082175,
0.8710188866,
0.2205799371,
-0.9171028137,
0.2518055439,
-0.093600221,
0.2141231149,
0.525259912,
0.536793828,
-0.8617554307,
-0.3772433102,
-0.4874778092,
-0.3668685853,
0.459436357,
0.0188843776,
0.2266449779,
-0.0901499763,
0.2525357604,
0.238654241,
0.1762206256,
-0.7001492977,
-0.4419246912,
-0.3302568197,
-0.3718478382,
-0.058626052,
-0.2129330933,
-0.6234866381,
-0.0196225718,
0.4336759746,
-0.2877078056,
0.3661349416,
0.5400092602,
-0.1092999801,
-0.1122914031,
0.0886129141,
0.5900280476,
0.6918185353,
-0.1694737822,
0.6516123414,
0.0803431943,
-0.3670617342,
0.2452452481,
-0.1105939224,
-0.1233713999,
0.3737435043,
0.2657612264,
0.7002601624,
-0.1340060234,
-0.4164256752,
0.7393328547,
-0.3991420865,
-0.2867451012,
-0.4223947525,
0.0524641275,
0.4009540975,
0.4372448921,
0.0986272767,
0.4230872095,
0.0600287803,
-0.8567752838,
-0.2878495157,
0.4961000085,
-0.4099873006,
-0.2330610454,
0.3654464781,
-0.0269013699,
-0.2190425992,
0.8395485282,
-0.0657072291,
-0.3880256414,
0.4857980907,
0.4163676202,
0.6500150561,
-0.3785479069,
0.2079917341,
0.2285926491,
0.4189048111,
-0.2176611274,
0.3601916432,
0.2205520868,
-1.1775573492,
-0.3268894553,
-0.0339746065,
-0.6964719296,
0.1639212221,
-0.7793850899,
-0.1528516412,
-0.4644373059,
-0.3113098443,
-0.1800673008,
-0.1363164932,
-0.4931721985,
0.4095076025,
0.2289573848,
0.7207930684,
-0.5409169197,
0.7545189857,
0.8105698228,
-0.4716167748,
-0.7545009851,
0.2108717263,
0.1403723508,
-0.6470223665,
0.3473510444,
0.0523632355,
-0.3937606812,
-0.2974150181,
-0.8604773879,
-0.7506063581,
0.9966495037,
0.6036190391,
-0.8363950849,
0.0345212258,
0.4609368742,
0.5429333448,
-0.3843547404,
0.3244029582,
0.2560114264,
0.5841134787,
-0.007425948,
-0.8471457362,
0.1703995615,
-0.0060578575,
-0.1339057833,
-0.1523747891,
-0.8093153238,
1.0999090672,
-0.1247637346,
-0.3362774253,
-0.1738285869,
0.4954149723,
0.3816570342,
0.620796442,
0.4502511919,
0.3570905328,
0.9587534666,
-0.5512422323,
1.0768347979,
-0.1657643467,
0.2504275441,
1.2747613192,
-0.3486306071,
0.5698161721,
0.6334970593,
-0.0515909903,
0.5202276707,
0.6631299853,
0.3357804418,
0.4671634436,
0.2152947932,
-0.1696885228,
-0.2418154478,
0.001577666,
-0.3908329606,
0.5230867267,
0.4416107535,
-0.1243021116,
-0.0198288765,
-0.4824962914,
0.0772331581,
0.3344836533,
0.1644842774,
0.6435290575,
0.3292805254,
-0.9735651612,
0.6471405625,
-0.0007845273,
0.6279662251,
-0.5320929289,
0.176795423,
-0.4483177364,
0.3036583662,
-0.3432244062,
-1.0256029367,
0.5385054946,
-0.2498523295,
-0.0679756701,
-0.0948308259,
0.8011854291,
-0.4220594764,
0.1268892884,
0.3137942553,
0.94204849,
0.1713598818,
-0.2395744473,
-0.8049393296,
0.3578390181,
-0.0905430838,
-0.2070877254,
0.1560897231,
0.5511664152,
0.1491895467,
0.5682370663,
0.610784173,
0.0301288944,
0.2311287969,
0.1642267853,
0.8630115986,
-0.4614392221,
-0.0246292278,
-0.9864551425,
0.5731813908,
-0.1713336557,
-0.3321644068,
0.5812370181,
0.5163811445,
1.008256197,
0.0755641609,
0.7707551718,
0.1766418219,
0.26941365,
-0.6726117134,
0.4882440567,
-0.4481281936,
0.3066473007,
0.1139096916,
-0.8646601439,
-0.0510417297,
0.7227600217,
-0.2639378309,
0.136157617,
1.0300469398,
0.7191345096,
-0.1092596799,
0.4169589281,
0.360786885,
0.510828793,
0.1858419329,
0.5753991604,
1.5114041567,
-0.5014297962,
0.2425074726,
-0.238261193,
-0.0675917566,
-0.142969951,
-0.7508715391,
-0.5348303914,
-0.7971454859,
-0.3513081074,
-0.4569620192,
-0.01481653,
0.6914950013,
0.490482688,
-0.5569888949,
-0.3648714125,
-0.1677990258,
0.1610782146,
-0.1170706451,
-0.2183166742,
-0.1964603215,
-0.3223239183,
-0.8160645962,
0.4707691371,
0.0921287015,
0.1594809592,
-0.4234758914,
-0.417881459,
-0.2165253162,
0.4298449457,
0.2408207655,
0.0902440622,
-0.7515391111,
-0.3793020546,
0.2199306339,
-0.5269755125,
0.276856333,
0.6371233463,
-0.5214502215,
0.3718022108,
0.4841688573,
0.6106073856,
0.3726849854,
-0.3122220039,
0.551355958,
-0.6427009702,
0.0010989918,
0.6188846827,
0.4150542021,
0.5623334646,
-0.42930305,
0.3365259469,
0.2655545473,
-0.6847512126,
-0.7656987309,
0.6326448321,
-0.9707915187,
-0.4324703813,
0.9523820877,
-0.0932113305,
-0.1843669266,
-0.1049390212,
-0.1937507242,
0.4436098933,
-0.1962166131,
0.6859146953,
1.0608462095,
-0.1743034571,
-0.0258695967,
-0.4577716887,
0.4886133373,
0.7751482725,
-0.4286666512,
-0.1234705597,
0.6280934811,
0.3209396601,
0.506249249,
0.7253907323,
-0.2188992202,
0.1882216185,
0.0702205077,
-0.0910436288,
0.1567171514,
-0.0679926947,
-0.3283103406,
0.0406148396,
0.3108411431,
-0.3508369923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16087v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16087v1
|
DUnE: Dataset for Unified Editing
| 2023-11-27T18:56:14 | 2023-11-27T18:56:14 |
Afra Feyza Akyürek, Eric Pan, Garry Kuwanto, Derry Wijaya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Even the most advanced language models remain susceptible to errors
necessitating to modify these models without initiating a comprehensive
retraining process. Model editing refers to the modification of a model's
knowledge or representations in a manner that produces the desired outcomes.
Prior research primarily centered around editing factual data e.g. "Messi plays
for Inter Miami" confining the definition of an edit to a knowledge triplet
i.e. (subject, object, relation). However, as the applications of language
models expand, so do the diverse ways in which we wish to edit and refine their
outputs. In this study, we broaden the scope of the editing problem to include
an array of editing cases such as debiasing and rectifying reasoning errors and
define an edit as any natural language expression that solicits a change in the
model's outputs. We are introducing DUnE-an editing benchmark where edits are
natural language sentences and propose that DUnE presents a challenging yet
relevant task. To substantiate this claim, we conduct an extensive series of
experiments testing various editing approaches to address DUnE, demonstrating
their respective strengths and weaknesses. We show that retrieval-augmented
language modeling can outperform specialized editing techniques and neither set
of approaches has fully solved the generalized editing problem covered by our
benchmark.
|
[
-0.234872967,
-0.8359132409,
0.3815662861,
-0.1492221057,
0.0997847542,
0.2568157613,
-0.2835378647,
-0.4985181689,
-0.0395592861,
0.8557167649,
-0.4548302591,
-0.6668239236,
-0.5046272874,
0.1936117709,
-0.7378343344,
1.1845954657,
-0.2435698062,
-0.1791725755,
-0.1553427577,
-0.3759013414,
-0.5748668909,
-0.5617175102,
-0.5327928066,
-0.0022029472,
0.3635979593,
0.5957157016,
1.0621123314,
0.5992169976,
0.6710397601,
0.352508992,
-0.3213413656,
0.0876312926,
-0.5090260506,
0.1873837113,
-0.6989349127,
-0.4353819788,
-0.4707193971,
0.0124742966,
0.7345517278,
0.623534143,
-0.2764849663,
0.078517355,
-0.3459182084,
0.8159530759,
-0.8109576106,
-0.140429318,
-0.8068554401,
-0.1469083428,
-0.2688423097,
0.3476433754,
-0.3315376341,
-0.3566964269,
-0.1642751247,
-0.56743747,
0.6947979331,
-0.0376771279,
0.8015608788,
0.4735375941,
-0.1585272849,
-0.3063620031,
-1.0635808706,
0.5173233747,
-0.7998898625,
0.3579154015,
0.1201928705,
0.1265243143,
-0.2966914773,
-0.5901706815,
-0.5800637603,
-0.1284070164,
-0.0633154437,
-0.0196158141,
-0.4539782703,
0.4037686586,
0.5033260584,
0.3478535116,
-0.1333112568,
0.0007357667,
-0.4249977469,
-0.2241096497,
0.8390023708,
0.2023791224,
0.543376565,
-0.2935224175,
0.0364539251,
-0.272429496,
-0.6518445611,
0.2374528497,
0.3624843359,
0.1317768246,
0.3959436417,
0.7231909633,
-0.3605311513,
0.9748138785,
-0.2033655494,
0.2821108401,
-0.0535061061,
-0.2216655016,
-0.2571045756,
0.0361848846,
0.5169722438,
0.5181871653,
0.2172322869,
-0.1311017275,
-0.5226598382,
0.2957383692,
0.5388021469,
-0.4252306819,
-0.2263611257,
0.0840145573,
0.2028936297,
-0.3801042438,
0.2797134817,
-0.8211208582,
-0.3619146943,
-0.2498495877,
0.2604646385,
-0.3463442028,
0.1685380638,
0.5170642138,
-0.2666057944,
-0.4310101271,
0.3869377077,
-0.7406454682,
0.4259187281,
0.5537180901,
0.4160374403,
0.0520629138,
-0.2161168903,
-0.3634249866,
0.1657668203,
-0.4692596793,
0.8758516908,
-0.9422881603,
-0.8182810545,
-0.1674020886,
-0.2141883224,
0.1366474181,
-0.4404273927,
0.9180967212,
-0.5718252659,
0.124888204,
-0.2765055299,
-0.593978107,
-0.4996523857,
0.0095897363,
-0.7185359597,
1.221274972,
0.2519086897,
-0.6137945652,
0.0606840439,
-0.689635098,
-0.1998976618,
-0.5012583733,
0.1440663785,
-0.1875702739,
0.3950203359,
0.4630668759,
0.0514627732,
-0.2735892534,
0.5116888881,
-0.1931038201,
-0.3482976854,
0.3075487018,
-0.2619645596,
0.1975622177,
-0.2482159138,
-0.0575710125,
0.2190009654,
-1.0061144829,
-0.0402162857,
-0.0221691616,
-0.2849333286,
-0.3879511952,
0.0039037431,
0.0256780535,
0.257661432,
-0.0584994555,
-0.7806815505,
0.5990350246,
-0.5311325788,
0.4644318819,
0.846976161,
0.216359362,
0.4097673595,
-0.3502691686,
0.5356487036,
-0.2162208557,
0.1269418448,
-0.0118113048,
-0.2913458943,
-0.8685517311,
0.0967795402,
0.6662252545,
0.6446073651,
-0.5280806422,
-0.0803027153,
-0.2590350211,
-0.6808624864,
-0.8239839673,
0.4523206651,
0.4755479097,
0.6384366155,
0.4780818224,
-0.4260864258,
-0.7285783291,
-1.0439003706,
-0.6522399783,
-0.0141252987,
0.2995494008,
0.2389429957,
0.4776743352,
-0.5815617442,
1.2330431938,
-0.5570577979,
-0.1363859177,
-0.0371509604,
0.1237633675,
0.0288051758,
0.4410971701,
0.4907881916,
-0.7136248946,
-0.007087226,
-0.1940311193,
-0.6783208847,
-0.3203836679,
-0.1169244498,
-0.2456190586,
0.0544211492,
0.5662252903,
-0.3704208732,
0.7246569991,
0.4012314975,
-0.1376726776,
0.5031016469,
-0.5232502818,
0.3542870581,
-0.6758757234,
-0.0384128541,
-0.0688152984,
-0.126458779,
-0.6031036973,
0.1053675562,
0.0681213886,
0.005988209,
-0.3032963872,
0.6028119326,
-0.0819972456,
-0.1395997554,
-0.3707680702,
0.3618364334,
0.2955684364,
0.3467156291,
-0.1254281104,
0.6268520355,
0.2727132738,
-0.5662379861,
0.4496186972,
0.4379624426,
-0.3594259024,
0.3388872147,
-0.8889915943,
0.3599817753,
-0.3552280068,
0.3582105339,
-0.9379733801,
-0.27600196,
0.1831310093,
-0.1171054021,
0.0335885286,
0.0431702845,
-0.2425257266,
-0.2735556662,
-0.1543155909,
0.3826008141,
0.1180311739,
-0.3091587126,
0.514975965,
0.2222989798,
-0.2100538909,
-0.9043816328,
-0.6138758659,
0.2086798549,
-0.0119427145,
-0.6694079638,
0.6490485072,
-0.0590143129,
-0.6371353865,
0.3496799469,
-0.273547262,
-0.0798192322,
0.1371754259,
0.4343580902,
0.4273623526,
0.0124585293,
0.3119103611,
0.208124876,
-0.3408601582,
-0.2590305209,
0.2206280828,
0.0008222787,
0.0894762278,
-0.4846124649,
-0.4364430904,
0.1992072165,
0.4667226672,
-0.5311689377,
0.2124620676,
0.0725750476,
-0.3223837912,
-0.083180815,
-0.6633576751,
0.070179306,
-0.4179270267,
0.4240266681,
-0.4513441622,
-0.8086376786,
0.5353890657,
-0.1408005655,
0.2897263765,
0.7206348181,
-0.0223518293,
0.0317833275,
0.8944030404,
0.7370738983,
-0.1590092033,
0.3316926062,
-0.1473519504,
-0.012715905,
-1.1131112576,
0.1938455403,
-0.7768652439,
-0.4868197441,
-0.4627909958,
-0.4201805592,
0.0268281121,
0.5281211734,
-0.2719015479,
0.4441500604,
-0.6020110846,
0.6929859519,
0.4883273542,
0.0856235921,
0.6400450468,
-0.3395849764,
0.0089422502,
-0.2045867294,
-0.5935179591,
-0.673946619,
1.2116452456,
-0.2558195293,
0.7261635065,
0.3281311095,
0.5442740321,
0.6932724118,
0.395600915,
-0.2943849564,
0.3671322763,
-0.1391783655,
-0.785895884,
-0.2709389925,
-0.1385767013,
-0.7111366987,
0.1979207844,
-0.3185157478,
-0.7025761008,
0.3447755277,
0.1522396803,
-0.4384590387,
0.494112879,
-0.5025497079,
0.9186355472,
-0.2139145583,
-0.2137313634,
-0.3801365793,
-0.418581754,
0.2970693409,
-0.1064992994,
0.6857036352,
-0.148447305,
-0.0353708044,
0.6417350769,
-0.3507167101,
0.6335626245,
0.1209253445,
0.0808634236,
0.3562870324,
0.5236017108,
0.4977450371,
0.2999657989,
-0.4196036756,
-0.081436038,
0.0305822045,
-0.3227396905,
-1.0037529469,
0.557264924,
-0.7296904325,
-0.7321591973,
-0.4234833121,
-0.569370687,
-0.3727373779,
-0.0757969618,
0.10091988,
0.7220267653,
-0.8048637509,
-0.2185425311,
0.3164936006,
-0.29381603,
0.3003895283,
0.5551675558,
-0.6808810234,
-0.2117593139,
0.6984273195,
0.0479289852,
0.4118750095,
0.1379206926,
0.0632295907,
-0.0084496932,
-0.5616241097,
-0.6151755452,
0.023963999,
-0.9644602537,
0.0618242435,
-0.5866934657,
0.005727672,
-0.1671066135,
-0.4612366855,
-0.4290881157,
-0.5396565795,
0.047523737,
-0.178447932,
0.6280155778,
1.3368251324,
-0.4133113623,
0.3474746346,
-0.9262757301,
0.4761500657,
0.2608111799,
0.3090098798,
-0.2908300757,
-0.7134500742,
0.0250115804,
0.3881343007,
-0.1162097156,
-0.8472440243,
0.2152548283,
0.3902156651,
0.3409805,
-0.0436032861,
-0.0799412876,
0.7552540898,
-0.4763189256,
0.6378346682,
-0.3720671833,
-1.243409276,
0.9235806465,
-0.2144943327,
0.0461261421,
0.859890759,
-0.0299190115,
-1.0723044872,
-0.3038094044,
-1.0216718912,
-0.6183881164,
0.721655786,
-0.0870207474,
0.231687814,
0.0972196236,
0.7554410696,
-0.0175143015,
0.3841333389,
-0.2516308427,
-0.0318783708,
0.0358893946,
0.1098789051,
-0.3699135482,
-0.4307983518,
0.0891807899,
-0.5334829688,
1.0011376143,
0.2817040384,
-0.2665858567,
0.2379148453,
-0.4100750089,
-0.1091202945,
0.5043649673,
0.6587647796,
0.6079864502,
-0.3560043275,
-0.2741283774,
0.2407424301,
-0.3178852797,
0.2389892787,
-0.1405096054,
-0.3286813498,
0.2550484836,
0.2615199685,
0.9017968774,
0.8653334975,
-0.7707821131,
0.1149696484,
0.0256280731,
0.113393046,
0.1549746394,
0.4661336839,
-0.1273284107,
-0.0547979251,
-0.0798890293,
0.6694255471,
0.1505455375,
-0.570856452,
0.2983722985,
0.0418407395,
-0.5773671865,
-0.0829500705,
0.564163208,
0.0845231637,
-0.5422117114,
0.8436117768,
-0.0726346448,
-0.5321119428,
0.5081143975,
0.1141323969,
0.493145138,
-0.3629658222,
0.2806205153,
0.5331807733,
0.3241038322,
-0.172279194,
-0.1002452597,
0.4305296838,
-1.0644509792,
-0.4247850776,
-0.4538993537,
-0.7425294518,
-0.3714229465,
-0.7989909649,
0.2322542518,
-0.4994000494,
-0.0224802867,
0.2353983372,
-0.402710855,
-0.6729578376,
0.3950932026,
-0.3278135359,
0.73001647,
-0.6243516803,
0.7472194433,
0.6570448875,
-0.5475752354,
-0.604358077,
-0.4393190742,
0.1867227703,
-0.4735104144,
0.4410388768,
-0.0136583783,
-0.0604535975,
0.1220368743,
-0.5422679782,
-0.8569823503,
0.5784384608,
0.5005357265,
-0.7053022981,
-0.0703905895,
0.1418989152,
0.4633596241,
-0.1816849262,
0.2528335154,
0.9250664115,
0.6230646372,
0.0142178526,
-0.6384623051,
-0.3119139969,
-0.2698055804,
0.111787118,
0.275557816,
-0.2910377383,
0.90845716,
-0.3104417622,
-0.1897463799,
-0.0205517728,
0.6173747182,
-0.3121677041,
-0.1840640754,
0.3258757591,
0.8498822451,
0.9956576824,
-0.3253785968,
1.3846255541,
-0.2170635462,
0.3375706673,
1.5002615452,
-0.3076891899,
0.8498892784,
0.107716918,
-0.1242414862,
0.8309177756,
0.4233431816,
0.1000098959,
0.214309752,
0.3864286244,
-0.328243494,
-0.3544854522,
-0.0905466303,
-0.2126735002,
0.7661576271,
0.4034888744,
-0.1140211076,
-0.4954571724,
0.2672141492,
0.1042808965,
0.5411037207,
-0.2846080661,
0.6657600999,
-0.2881103158,
-0.5690400004,
0.1858019233,
0.5046677589,
0.5477542281,
-0.4086927474,
-0.1619814336,
-0.1136557385,
0.1327168196,
-0.21262604,
-0.8713756204,
0.5663903356,
0.2675982416,
-0.3937270343,
-0.0322105102,
0.731901288,
-0.1362801939,
-0.8731610179,
0.1849716306,
0.4656734467,
-0.0028079597,
-0.3906304538,
-0.7721508741,
0.310230881,
0.168334946,
-0.2739241719,
-0.0162485316,
0.2319063097,
-0.1268486828,
0.6324121952,
0.7263450623,
0.004129034,
-0.1563676149,
0.0298898164,
0.5740261674,
-0.9243530631,
-0.0524050072,
-0.9177030325,
0.675057888,
-0.1767721772,
-0.6225633621,
0.6427007318,
0.4100420177,
0.8895459175,
0.1969167292,
0.975158453,
0.0441898964,
0.5226760507,
-0.3715539277,
0.41678828,
-0.2595744431,
0.1363952905,
-0.4114687741,
-1.0205783844,
-0.3593094647,
0.5073222518,
-0.4858188927,
-0.0749562308,
0.4437378943,
0.9694555998,
0.1060927585,
0.4570500255,
0.1460431814,
0.3500614166,
0.2180578709,
0.5116075873,
0.5544836521,
-0.6897571683,
0.0456966013,
-0.6047409773,
0.0547541082,
-0.0462999493,
-0.7658626437,
-0.5614671707,
-0.4637320936,
-0.3765804768,
-0.334043771,
0.3406639099,
0.8174171448,
0.1602690518,
-0.8701478243,
-0.0613107197,
-0.1445350349,
0.3439462483,
-0.2559244335,
-0.1014885232,
0.4118972719,
-0.1611049622,
-0.7912256718,
0.5903558731,
0.2289200276,
-0.1548511684,
-0.0266758502,
0.2128296345,
-0.3567875028,
0.3178060353,
0.2534154058,
0.437150687,
-0.6425899267,
-0.6617240906,
-0.2512319982,
-0.1311448067,
0.2151262611,
0.6981853843,
-0.9561259747,
0.8689448237,
0.1672346145,
0.8221839666,
0.39131549,
0.1252880543,
0.6505446434,
-0.5812136531,
0.1340356022,
0.0703175366,
0.4251119792,
0.5688942671,
-0.1134420186,
0.7257366776,
0.2654555738,
-0.5513699055,
-0.7118442655,
0.1317981035,
-0.8095338941,
-0.2215464264,
0.986575067,
0.1949110776,
-0.1693316549,
0.0129160052,
-0.7398308516,
0.2897748649,
-0.1856721789,
0.7551677227,
1.1383674145,
0.099210158,
0.1649295241,
-0.8216821551,
0.5890445113,
0.4977858067,
-0.6918093562,
0.1056843773,
0.7823857069,
0.2223469764,
0.0384363867,
0.3045019507,
0.0501631945,
0.4131864011,
-0.1869610101,
0.5296176672,
-0.1204635277,
-0.211122781,
-0.5198433995,
-0.0144579103,
0.1285853088,
0.2967086136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16083v1
|
BERT Goes Off-Topic: Investigating the Domain Transfer Challenge using Genre Classification
| 2023-11-27T18:53:31 | 2023-11-27T18:53:31 |
Dmitri Roussinov, Serge Sharoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While performance of many text classification tasks has been recently
improved due to Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), in this paper we show that
they still suffer from a performance gap when the underlying distribution of
topics changes. For example, a genre classifier trained on \textit{political}
topics often fails when tested on documents about \textit{sport} or
\textit{medicine}. In this work, we quantify this phenomenon empirically with a
large corpus and a large set of topics. Consequently, we verify that domain
transfer remains challenging both for classic PLMs, such as BERT, and for
modern large models, such as GPT-3. We also suggest and successfully test a
possible remedy: after augmenting the training dataset with
topically-controlled synthetic texts, the F1 score improves by up to 50\% for
some topics, nearing on-topic training results, while others show little to no
improvement. While our empirical results focus on genre classification, our
methodology is applicable to other classification tasks such as gender,
authorship, or sentiment classification. The code and data to replicate the
experiments are available at https://github.com/dminus1/genre
|
[
-0.5372607708,
-0.7578169107,
0.6633992791,
0.1331924498,
-0.1606687903,
0.2354646474,
-0.4359512329,
-0.4165315926,
-0.0577539317,
0.4928787649,
-0.6329298019,
-0.2947285473,
-0.973197937,
-0.1226934791,
-0.5870444179,
1.4719207287,
-0.1374778599,
-0.2260018736,
-0.5101465583,
0.0581171103,
-0.3872705102,
-0.9222164154,
-0.4329845607,
-0.2382748723,
0.3698312938,
0.161989972,
0.2480662316,
0.2601748109,
0.8133411407,
0.2057350278,
-0.0121337594,
0.0430599414,
-0.5811907053,
0.213035658,
-0.2643847764,
-0.5435402393,
-0.3285258114,
0.1918605566,
0.534902513,
0.6883404851,
0.180775404,
-0.134242177,
-0.1302499026,
0.6111765504,
-0.2185039073,
0.0863915682,
-0.8492367268,
-0.1415425986,
-0.479652375,
-0.3954698741,
-0.4971217513,
-0.3127234876,
0.6816743016,
-0.4655811191,
0.8552620411,
0.0946767405,
1.1633460522,
0.2401078194,
-0.3651622832,
-0.3790113032,
-0.8644562364,
0.7805796266,
-0.2432119995,
0.1100783497,
0.6324044466,
0.0767485648,
0.0720439032,
-0.7884346843,
-0.6178472042,
-0.0606884025,
0.1915480942,
-0.115576759,
-0.2269874066,
-0.140843153,
0.1407843828,
0.3285279274,
-0.506593585,
-0.0995491147,
-0.5001332164,
-0.0861327201,
0.6412860751,
-0.1054487377,
0.1862241328,
0.085664697,
-0.4756754339,
-0.0372527689,
-0.763217032,
0.1811616719,
0.2910753191,
0.1167088598,
0.1157425791,
0.2796642482,
0.3744949996,
0.7941614389,
0.0849473923,
0.058821518,
0.2393217385,
-0.2494129241,
0.097857818,
0.0291497577,
0.3676975071,
0.1497068107,
0.2037423998,
-0.1441538334,
-0.1007556766,
-0.1760318428,
0.6307815313,
-0.4848988652,
-0.4437260032,
0.2053668499,
-0.3852578998,
-0.0932676643,
0.1799402684,
-0.4561843574,
-0.3249789178,
-0.2399336249,
0.748947978,
-0.554666698,
-0.0237157289,
0.0347170755,
-0.2244368792,
-0.0412156768,
0.6353111863,
-0.9942618608,
0.1949796379,
0.731233716,
0.9340074658,
-0.5016115308,
-0.0987311453,
-0.0769288987,
-0.1020606607,
-0.264708817,
0.9726960063,
-0.3664871156,
-0.2611613572,
-0.0231485032,
0.0222217198,
-0.3642205,
-0.3641934991,
0.4242365658,
-0.5289857984,
0.4104295671,
-0.3948195577,
-0.7888786197,
-0.0713152513,
0.142045185,
-0.4365508556,
1.0796995163,
0.2453819066,
-0.7917796373,
0.4361205399,
-0.7626159191,
-0.5503230095,
-0.2654639482,
0.1250207871,
-0.4405491948,
-0.0240601972,
-0.2365414351,
0.6295744777,
-0.2175346762,
0.4646787047,
-0.3193030059,
-0.5978553891,
0.5612089634,
-0.0422095284,
0.4527043998,
0.2047202587,
-0.5477390885,
0.0109346285,
-0.4863771498,
-0.2902566195,
-0.0854751617,
-0.0874473155,
-0.5773673058,
0.1284325272,
0.1283213049,
0.3058665693,
0.0681254193,
-0.6318381429,
0.3615685701,
-0.1399734467,
0.5191869736,
0.7744178772,
-0.1284530014,
0.5475177765,
-0.7946571708,
0.2990294099,
-0.1471070051,
-0.1996850967,
0.1224271506,
-0.8233702183,
-0.9246658683,
-0.4624798298,
0.858158946,
0.5040861964,
-0.975666523,
0.7859302759,
-0.3130100071,
-0.4902318418,
-0.5222257972,
-0.2222086936,
-0.182194069,
0.3596845567,
0.4536579847,
-0.4553256333,
-0.1814622581,
-0.7081557512,
0.0087158922,
-0.3584633172,
0.0846550912,
0.3997164369,
0.5248966813,
-0.0862869471,
1.2511599064,
-0.6091106534,
-0.5207643509,
-0.3321732879,
0.7948933244,
0.039183259,
0.6618240476,
0.7227814794,
-0.9110507369,
-0.4186003208,
-0.2165541798,
-0.3531925082,
-0.3248689175,
-0.3517840803,
-0.1064210013,
0.4181311131,
0.3342335522,
-0.4762702286,
0.2208911777,
0.3960970044,
-0.1838656962,
0.3280279636,
-0.1926218122,
0.2234992832,
-0.7650055885,
0.1696075201,
-0.0088743092,
-0.2497844994,
-0.7002766728,
-0.3220945001,
-0.1041204706,
-0.0824452043,
-0.3492934704,
0.4260291457,
0.0038367216,
0.0434764288,
-0.4442117512,
-0.0981887877,
-0.1317667663,
0.3989626169,
0.4209530354,
0.7417373657,
0.6798618436,
-0.6657429934,
0.1103261784,
0.2968041003,
-0.4347862601,
0.344078213,
-0.2334057093,
0.4768248796,
-0.2054521739,
0.5160109997,
-1.1429071426,
-0.1041712686,
0.166432023,
-0.4221968949,
0.6277255416,
-0.0729248077,
-0.4934550226,
-0.1509346664,
-0.3694901764,
0.1380701959,
0.8891589642,
-0.2882405519,
0.171036914,
0.2805790305,
-0.5250686407,
-0.3714469373,
-0.6845501661,
-0.1938649118,
-0.3941982985,
-0.5163223147,
0.6821866632,
-0.2012021989,
-0.02619165,
0.3124434948,
-0.1467976421,
-0.6409188509,
0.2465855926,
-0.0407842174,
0.0012944521,
-0.1812274754,
0.4464982748,
0.3057383597,
0.2963830829,
0.1302782893,
-0.2198853791,
0.3428686261,
0.1275042892,
-0.1735246181,
-0.1843576133,
0.1600173712,
0.419500351,
-0.0610494725,
0.7868133783,
0.6652199626,
-0.0772087723,
-0.5710564852,
-0.3369687796,
-0.1592104286,
-0.3699554205,
0.2360828966,
-0.3748147786,
-1.1241824627,
0.3331272304,
-0.1617845595,
-0.0737720355,
0.6069390774,
0.479818821,
-0.5309483409,
0.5496771932,
0.8164376616,
0.1239293888,
0.5091201663,
-0.4308714271,
0.2455954105,
-0.4632843435,
-0.0593164749,
-0.6168857813,
-0.3410240114,
-0.6862565875,
-0.5371468067,
0.262522161,
-0.0072656325,
0.1382562667,
0.3782426119,
-0.1933297366,
0.1949369609,
0.5063577294,
0.116303131,
0.0836543441,
0.1494489759,
0.4250866473,
-0.3590241969,
-0.787027657,
-0.2468599677,
1.1101133823,
0.5879823565,
0.5581173301,
0.3352994919,
0.7172195911,
0.7897994518,
0.7929880619,
-0.7372502089,
0.3308232129,
-0.7383376956,
-0.8918182254,
-0.2202595025,
-0.4000433683,
-0.7838150263,
0.1898782104,
-0.1691465676,
-0.5525223613,
0.4405839443,
-0.0375892371,
-0.1831036806,
0.3431051672,
-0.5063904524,
0.7358233929,
-0.1609406769,
-0.4064031243,
0.0934557021,
-0.712374568,
0.3200961649,
-0.8190714717,
0.2528535724,
-0.2786293328,
0.1657443494,
1.0218391418,
-0.1820773631,
0.7654252648,
-0.1162276566,
-0.2282462716,
0.2304959744,
-0.1138545945,
-0.0168936457,
-0.1065585539,
0.1625336111,
0.3147052228,
-0.0791678205,
-0.4575155675,
-0.6045752168,
0.4952027202,
-0.9403098226,
-0.7804153562,
-0.7519899011,
-0.5443706512,
-0.5458418727,
-0.0795633942,
0.5161177516,
0.2925385237,
-0.1269920617,
0.3711612523,
0.9608171582,
-0.2342873961,
0.2609017491,
0.6455087662,
0.1371463686,
0.1202690452,
1.2205294371,
0.1612181365,
0.3001323938,
0.4812244475,
-0.0704112351,
-0.512282908,
-0.7770438194,
-0.5411304832,
0.0741950795,
-0.6317250729,
-0.119878687,
-0.7069317698,
-0.2642808855,
-0.3455558717,
-0.126393497,
-0.1758100241,
-0.4793832004,
-0.469099015,
0.2741959691,
0.4380217791,
0.7481716275,
0.069450438,
0.3157474697,
-0.8941097856,
0.0305470061,
0.0628039762,
0.3043918312,
-0.3907933831,
-1.0495955944,
-0.0456574336,
-0.3570784628,
-0.447973758,
-0.7714945674,
0.2578243017,
0.4903305471,
0.4621198475,
0.0957309976,
0.3636938632,
0.1972187907,
-0.5830911994,
0.9973691702,
-0.1306774914,
-1.2704740763,
0.5113961101,
-0.4287041724,
-0.1662725061,
0.6440523267,
0.8287196755,
-0.1767843664,
-0.6849437356,
-0.7674820423,
-0.8831940293,
1.0238864422,
0.4541293979,
0.2636986375,
0.0812732279,
0.2933125794,
0.5328075886,
0.3621640801,
-0.6770986319,
-0.324226141,
-0.1586522311,
-0.244853586,
-0.1872162968,
-0.0897945315,
0.0097569106,
-0.2426486611,
0.6201393008,
-0.0975407586,
0.6541991234,
0.4758064151,
-0.2187927216,
0.1523169726,
0.3000964224,
0.9125342369,
0.7693501115,
-0.7139418721,
0.1503589451,
-0.2810124159,
-0.4228434265,
0.3964011967,
0.4088432193,
0.0029086089,
0.2937652469,
0.6309488416,
0.830896914,
0.0734229684,
-0.5840709209,
0.645534575,
0.0447555035,
-0.5273298621,
0.0670141056,
-0.0081758052,
-0.3547792435,
-0.0637380257,
0.4002503157,
0.2073684931,
0.1832725853,
-0.6089785099,
0.492385,
0.0360578857,
-0.4022631943,
-0.3746477664,
0.4668593407,
0.4070576727,
0.0476712547,
0.3459287882,
-0.2619489729,
-0.8903769255,
0.6385163665,
0.5220378041,
0.7821778059,
0.0084962053,
0.4113697708,
-0.1710411906,
0.276309371,
-0.2370710969,
0.0755243525,
-0.0216133539,
-0.795281589,
-0.6498524547,
-0.4873975217,
-0.5443609953,
0.2852011025,
-0.6010596156,
0.1386480182,
-0.2975611687,
-0.3762711585,
0.1418858767,
-0.1404623836,
-0.3350222111,
0.1518409401,
0.1111323759,
0.8238345385,
-1.062468648,
1.2230724096,
1.0549635887,
-0.1230374202,
-0.2028004676,
0.5071837902,
-0.3148119152,
-0.2515441775,
0.9849534035,
0.0730767772,
0.2231012434,
0.0812748447,
-0.2641926706,
-0.7529600859,
0.4933504462,
0.0425493158,
-0.447675854,
0.2150413543,
-0.0488152318,
0.7899888754,
-0.2802184522,
-0.138359189,
0.4362486005,
0.2905578613,
-0.0736354366,
-1.175873518,
-0.1344691217,
-0.0826134384,
-0.1692294031,
0.3264923692,
-0.5196893811,
1.1113733053,
0.0446327105,
0.0745009109,
0.1978119761,
0.4853727818,
-0.0537097044,
0.5711674094,
0.6499768496,
0.3359661996,
0.6798151731,
-0.5423639417,
1.161184907,
-0.0650649965,
0.7766531706,
0.6328557134,
-0.6477336287,
0.7855700254,
0.2360274047,
-0.4107069075,
0.4824361503,
0.9658226967,
-0.1149808913,
0.937926352,
0.4137430489,
-0.2568016052,
-0.1586707383,
-0.0260650273,
-0.6600171328,
0.4880743325,
0.3363282084,
-0.3731095791,
-0.0402830318,
0.2849775255,
-0.1286128908,
0.017190408,
-0.085494861,
0.6663030386,
-0.0926414579,
-0.6057616472,
0.5807134509,
0.1731845886,
0.8842450976,
-0.7966822982,
-0.0446291566,
-0.2492111325,
0.211106509,
0.2523492873,
-0.7743171453,
0.4507789016,
0.01243582,
-0.4152723253,
-0.5360642672,
0.8662673831,
-0.6514879465,
-0.1410386562,
0.0233250335,
0.6196870208,
0.3652667403,
-0.0467388853,
-0.6135165095,
0.1267919093,
-0.0674277171,
0.0423532985,
0.6178945303,
0.5088249445,
-0.2537193894,
0.2857690156,
0.6720018983,
0.1284757406,
-0.1661931723,
-0.1793974936,
0.7746774554,
-0.6042730212,
-0.720318377,
-0.6729135513,
0.053286951,
0.1194151938,
-0.4999458492,
0.5529080629,
0.3329714537,
0.8643651605,
-0.4394978881,
0.8578782678,
-0.3881927133,
0.6196471453,
-0.7581791878,
0.9798301458,
-0.6825532317,
0.2928316593,
-0.1475852579,
-0.7668204308,
-0.1862774789,
0.5278432369,
-0.4119876623,
-0.0035789046,
0.9844254851,
0.1501851827,
0.0030374099,
0.0727563873,
0.1341725737,
0.0048621856,
0.2120453268,
0.4916733205,
1.092438817,
-0.0945030451,
0.2249107212,
-0.3890176713,
-0.2565520704,
-0.2269121408,
-0.8054630756,
-0.9513851404,
-0.7901008129,
-0.5498577952,
-0.366238296,
0.3286456466,
0.8025550246,
0.8432161212,
-0.9128029943,
-0.0783101618,
0.1043675169,
0.0348760821,
-0.1207631677,
-0.3280822039,
0.592822969,
-0.5217007399,
-0.7638840079,
0.1833622605,
-0.1820050329,
0.0286139753,
0.0431674272,
0.3563274443,
-0.2350502163,
0.0086487886,
0.6330116391,
0.0573309883,
-0.7879654169,
-0.3717927039,
0.0497455075,
-0.0153032085,
-0.0978544056,
1.4061309099,
-0.5555427074,
0.2448417395,
0.4399194419,
1.1426215172,
0.4284044206,
0.1680169702,
0.5489549637,
-1.1189361811,
-0.0274070688,
0.3256196976,
0.0844794363,
0.3174734116,
-0.3795244992,
0.3996749222,
0.8442188501,
-0.4333026111,
-0.9674592614,
-0.1749759614,
-1.0714488029,
-0.6891894937,
1.1273577213,
-0.4027772546,
0.006857357,
-0.4701228738,
-0.2157493979,
-0.1242428198,
-0.3526248336,
0.8555364609,
1.2078906298,
-0.5367048979,
0.0332246758,
-0.7157569528,
0.8428477049,
0.6890682578,
-0.9042778015,
-0.1563840508,
0.1628499478,
0.4270830452,
0.4171486199,
0.7762083411,
0.1597826183,
0.3047201931,
-0.3966338634,
0.0679790676,
0.2051995844,
-0.480425179,
-0.4509988725,
0.2045923918,
0.0567127578,
-0.2321659029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16079v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16079v1
|
MEDITRON-70B: Scaling Medical Pretraining for Large Language Models
| 2023-11-27T18:49:43 | 2023-11-27T18:49:43 |
Zeming Chen, Alejandro Hernández Cano, Angelika Romanou, Antoine Bonnet, Kyle Matoba, Francesco Salvi, Matteo Pagliardini, Simin Fan, Andreas Köpf, Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Alexandre Sallinen, Alireza Sakhaeirad, Vinitra Swamy, Igor Krawczuk, Deniz Bayazit, Axel Marmet, Syrielle Montariol, Mary-Anne Hartley, Martin Jaggi, Antoine Bosselut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) can potentially democratize access to medical
knowledge. While many efforts have been made to harness and improve LLMs'
medical knowledge and reasoning capacities, the resulting models are either
closed-source (e.g., PaLM, GPT-4) or limited in scale (<= 13B parameters),
which restricts their abilities. In this work, we improve access to large-scale
medical LLMs by releasing MEDITRON: a suite of open-source LLMs with 7B and 70B
parameters adapted to the medical domain. MEDITRON builds on Llama-2 (through
our adaptation of Nvidia's Megatron-LM distributed trainer), and extends
pretraining on a comprehensively curated medical corpus, including selected
PubMed articles, abstracts, and internationally-recognized medical guidelines.
Evaluations using four major medical benchmarks show significant performance
gains over several state-of-the-art baselines before and after task-specific
finetuning. Overall, MEDITRON achieves a 6% absolute performance gain over the
best public baseline in its parameter class and 3% over the strongest baseline
we finetuned from Llama-2. Compared to closed-source LLMs, MEDITRON-70B
outperforms GPT-3.5 and Med-PaLM and is within 5% of GPT-4 and 10% of
Med-PaLM-2. We release our code for curating the medical pretraining corpus and
the MEDITRON model weights to drive open-source development of more capable
medical LLMs.
|
[
-0.2844367623,
-0.353830874,
0.7634354234,
0.0131482603,
-0.5099140406,
-0.1389993727,
-0.7076749802,
-0.4414199889,
0.0645077154,
0.6390644312,
-0.254655838,
-0.5556396842,
-0.9327938557,
0.258000195,
-0.0336422324,
1.0863243341,
-0.1855914146,
0.6157543063,
-0.0246472415,
-0.2011972219,
-0.1154356077,
-0.7834102511,
-0.563323915,
-0.5704320073,
0.6789992452,
0.4310208261,
0.848823607,
0.9124208093,
0.8966417909,
0.2251996547,
-0.0999192148,
-0.1108747348,
-0.3950069547,
0.0015905001,
-0.216224134,
-0.6035444736,
-1.0394552946,
-0.2112101018,
0.7222391963,
0.5619961023,
-0.2597786486,
0.3328227103,
-0.272360146,
0.8326455355,
-0.3932043612,
0.1654094756,
-0.4135727584,
-0.1193156317,
-0.4442297518,
-0.0246053245,
-0.2172810137,
-0.3810964525,
0.0662536621,
-0.6933759451,
0.1099857762,
-0.1003343239,
0.7001058459,
0.4964066744,
-0.2071059644,
-0.1373468041,
-0.5816438794,
0.5428802967,
-0.7666886449,
0.4854224026,
0.5408572555,
0.4927000105,
-0.0700045601,
-1.0525631905,
-0.1896770149,
-0.3368299305,
0.2840462923,
-0.0098968828,
-0.1519403607,
0.2421710789,
0.1718943864,
0.5271961093,
-0.3758633137,
0.2877846956,
-0.6699435115,
-0.167886436,
0.2987084091,
-0.0514104962,
0.1343035847,
0.0840254873,
0.05167941,
-0.2119758129,
-0.9205648899,
-0.5301312208,
-0.1602486074,
0.0264923088,
-0.2453749776,
0.6339539886,
-0.1302540153,
0.5533587337,
0.0219643768,
0.0206564404,
0.5711066723,
-0.2517298758,
-0.3538867533,
0.1550123692,
0.6713317633,
0.3904220462,
0.3498308361,
0.0379243903,
-0.1086526588,
-0.12240839,
0.45241943,
-1.0720825195,
-0.2491487265,
0.3299328685,
-0.5652243495,
-0.1692622602,
-0.4489946365,
-0.4635619819,
-0.5367393494,
-0.5625445843,
0.4631182551,
-0.3599562943,
-0.43206653,
0.2369796187,
0.1445608586,
0.0592375249,
0.4820384085,
-0.6731171012,
0.2261634916,
0.6695997715,
0.9865791202,
-0.0387038402,
-0.0777705461,
-0.3258150518,
-0.0204492826,
-0.3119677007,
0.686029613,
-0.2947151363,
-0.2170677781,
-0.0558064766,
0.0168478303,
0.2499984354,
-1.0467246771,
0.4556981623,
-0.4673558176,
0.1506245732,
-0.1164451316,
-0.2830040753,
-0.085837625,
0.3212889731,
-0.6547025442,
0.8453420997,
0.2123684138,
-0.690716207,
0.3266423941,
-0.7920530438,
-0.3675831556,
0.0571985207,
-0.3835093975,
-0.2449741066,
0.2186964452,
0.3538215458,
0.5344390869,
-0.8666008711,
0.4080741704,
-0.2331722379,
-0.1834620386,
-0.0416320488,
-0.2272065878,
0.5598610044,
0.2812796235,
-0.3384643793,
0.4114518762,
-0.687296927,
0.0499444529,
0.0726955682,
-0.4865369201,
-0.2187815458,
-0.2745532691,
-0.0602914393,
0.1888489276,
0.2968575656,
-0.4189716876,
0.0913677439,
-0.7373184562,
0.6059895754,
0.7219185829,
-0.3095971346,
0.4512259364,
-0.3570758402,
0.6454642415,
-0.126836583,
0.4814953804,
0.2023091018,
-0.2420483828,
-0.4948601127,
-0.7047293186,
0.3566120863,
0.3671880066,
-0.6970337033,
0.3309059441,
-0.4223297834,
-0.8654484153,
-0.6608669162,
0.1565386057,
0.4245267212,
0.4626075923,
0.422182411,
-0.3646932244,
-0.1825711727,
-0.8913508058,
-0.0084378384,
-0.1532351226,
-0.3933538198,
0.4825573266,
0.269700259,
-0.4911831319,
0.474054426,
-0.4156504273,
-0.4081650972,
-0.3273315728,
-0.2445760816,
0.571916163,
0.4457164705,
0.5113652945,
-0.5356433988,
-0.1305150092,
0.2397047579,
-0.6575434208,
-0.186025694,
0.3808629513,
-0.2817829549,
0.1185936034,
0.6376998425,
-0.3400205076,
-0.0569624193,
0.9900898933,
-0.1821473837,
0.4883117974,
-0.6724767685,
-0.0125379385,
-1.4383962154,
0.2734319568,
-0.1732909232,
-0.3202658296,
-0.3405113518,
-0.0803127289,
0.2903387845,
-0.0306266733,
-0.5865501165,
0.6055602431,
-0.3244232535,
0.0601985455,
-0.3220550418,
-0.0016231263,
-0.2888973355,
0.0288029294,
-0.0018027073,
0.7085937858,
0.526716888,
-0.6214751005,
0.2703895569,
0.1458370835,
-0.136257723,
0.4795510769,
-0.9873459339,
0.1124018207,
-0.0200154874,
0.4996817112,
-0.3825009465,
-0.4380960166,
0.1310637444,
-0.2935214341,
0.212046355,
-0.1639493555,
-0.5754679441,
-0.246273309,
-0.1610706896,
0.6775685549,
0.5747228861,
-0.4672621787,
0.822766602,
0.4411791861,
-0.288416177,
-0.4312612116,
-0.459415108,
-0.1086049899,
0.0701547638,
-0.5756403804,
0.1875566691,
-0.0839373544,
-0.1441351473,
-0.1011725515,
-0.1969756931,
-0.1019826084,
-0.1144724637,
0.4976592958,
0.3403254151,
-0.5033066273,
0.387778759,
0.2048449218,
-0.1396863759,
0.2476567924,
-0.3520508111,
0.7176712751,
-0.0495472439,
-0.2651279867,
-0.1451606303,
-0.0346337669,
0.7753686905,
-0.3712257743,
0.658506155,
0.5043477416,
-0.4854912162,
0.0460580364,
-0.6404709816,
-0.3212921023,
-0.4461740553,
0.7455745339,
-0.1166142821,
-1.0466046333,
0.1651774347,
-0.6559621692,
0.2249657065,
0.6159136891,
1.0284739733,
0.2412459105,
0.6495434046,
0.6395392418,
-0.1731794327,
0.464341104,
0.0583196171,
-0.3407419324,
-0.8672997355,
-0.2304504514,
-0.583147347,
-0.2556041777,
-0.3606370986,
-0.8360208273,
0.7245966792,
-0.1077827066,
-0.5975325704,
0.0082372166,
-0.4444879889,
0.4791463315,
0.6185010672,
0.5031161308,
0.3483330011,
0.059677247,
-0.2381182164,
0.1800971478,
-0.7709418535,
-0.4278658032,
1.6991411448,
0.4966019392,
0.8749856949,
0.0888381675,
0.69849509,
0.0674475208,
0.9700128436,
-0.6924702525,
0.3061925471,
-0.4489529729,
-1.0238919258,
-0.0985538438,
-0.6011785269,
-0.764991641,
0.0661417767,
-0.3624108434,
-0.2253521681,
-0.2890554368,
0.3663054109,
-0.3224518597,
0.2692521811,
-0.6631211638,
0.7254087925,
-0.3149937987,
-0.087310493,
-0.5311798453,
-0.7399395704,
0.2322674543,
-0.557795763,
0.3581701219,
-0.1997837275,
-0.2085016668,
0.8255738616,
-0.4629699588,
0.7685723305,
-0.0462082177,
-0.050074432,
-0.2116711289,
-0.0877345428,
0.2022732347,
0.1490874887,
-0.0685893744,
0.5680766106,
0.1540821344,
-0.4186194241,
-0.3069237769,
0.5963317752,
-1.0699851513,
-0.4919785261,
-0.4347717166,
-0.544518888,
-0.3504324257,
0.4102292061,
0.349371314,
0.4926876426,
-0.1567206234,
0.3415896893,
0.6878315806,
-0.4529060721,
-0.0375608578,
0.4906435907,
-0.2576328218,
-0.8065181971,
0.4229411483,
0.0039476315,
0.5100977421,
0.1840500832,
0.4153948426,
-0.2356032729,
-0.6281057596,
-0.604177177,
0.7439803481,
-0.5942228436,
-0.3271034062,
-0.4100188315,
-0.1875039637,
-0.2092204839,
-0.1464942396,
-0.5867872834,
-0.2891250551,
-0.2462197393,
0.0150098177,
0.52026546,
0.8610049486,
-0.1328537762,
0.5933773518,
-0.9406676888,
0.2915062904,
-0.1882077903,
0.5638017058,
-0.1565261781,
-0.7847183943,
-0.3336211741,
-0.2410765737,
-0.1092492789,
-0.7440925241,
0.1359135509,
-0.0170386769,
0.3082908392,
0.3474304378,
-0.0707802549,
0.3929053843,
-0.8209300637,
0.4976305962,
0.503829062,
-0.688749373,
0.5167357326,
-0.4579511583,
0.4726979136,
0.6002697945,
0.4451214075,
-0.348867774,
-0.3138323426,
-0.5123875737,
-0.835175097,
0.5156692863,
-0.0400747396,
0.231244266,
0.2196922749,
0.6768026948,
0.0288925339,
0.1857738346,
-0.4792222977,
-0.1984559,
-0.0012853759,
-0.6076294184,
-0.3963463306,
-0.1821268946,
-0.4750477672,
-0.3697862327,
0.6432617307,
-0.0517896339,
0.1320536584,
0.343334049,
-0.0497510992,
0.0381953493,
0.2070241123,
0.6016812921,
0.9233844876,
-0.2425309271,
0.244167313,
0.1552798152,
-1.0552456379,
0.0890694857,
0.3881289959,
0.2684564292,
-0.1335624605,
0.4203645587,
0.4226565063,
0.0113756806,
-0.9431764483,
0.4434058666,
-0.1184676066,
-0.4388400912,
-0.2200852931,
-0.0356732756,
0.1708006412,
0.5470422506,
0.0455752239,
-0.1224860922,
-0.1912429035,
-0.2306302637,
0.2045367956,
0.0137888324,
-0.4171242416,
-0.3606341779,
0.8661554456,
0.2874654531,
0.0093594752,
0.5462378263,
0.301250875,
-0.2918078303,
0.4472222626,
0.6035324931,
0.5209834576,
-0.310613513,
-0.0863001496,
0.4608078003,
0.5255842805,
-0.4523949921,
0.3630412221,
0.339278698,
-0.4937833846,
-0.7281702757,
-0.5532303452,
-0.5788472891,
0.1422070116,
-0.5014653206,
0.2866214812,
-0.8073208332,
-0.5665750504,
-0.1364625692,
-0.1498536021,
-0.8157119155,
0.304104358,
-0.0367083289,
1.0360116959,
-0.5302522779,
0.932377398,
1.0295879841,
-0.3321785629,
-1.1037687063,
-0.2018260807,
-0.0396942683,
-1.0914851427,
0.5821301937,
-0.1345222443,
0.1787605137,
-0.0049853311,
-0.319498688,
-0.8148364425,
1.249907732,
0.8001155853,
-0.8689464331,
-0.2199989855,
0.0275440551,
0.490237087,
-0.1194517091,
0.2390631586,
0.3710555136,
0.2860987782,
-0.1032867208,
-1.4185727835,
0.2562819719,
0.0255725645,
-0.3810255229,
0.2880120277,
-0.5461219549,
0.8299389482,
-0.2612440884,
0.3662903905,
-0.122038655,
0.3448902071,
0.333025068,
0.1955069602,
0.3948796988,
0.4782163501,
0.8230348229,
0.0271929353,
1.2058230639,
-0.4212770164,
0.0397784896,
1.0544561148,
-0.100024417,
1.0069406033,
0.41150406,
-0.1079482585,
0.2182337493,
0.5186303854,
0.3589819372,
0.1924646199,
0.3290496767,
-0.4590881169,
-0.2812668085,
-0.1226605549,
-0.8253672719,
0.2344767451,
0.2532975674,
-0.8085787296,
-0.1508894861,
0.0071756504,
0.5261465907,
-0.1926895976,
-0.6160231829,
0.6892879605,
0.3821651936,
-0.2531703711,
0.6673047543,
-0.0367342569,
0.4889757037,
-0.7845360637,
0.1606918871,
-0.1916935742,
0.5151849985,
-0.1822064072,
-0.3765944242,
0.0471566059,
0.1972838044,
-0.1081960127,
0.0347348936,
0.569052279,
-0.0497334339,
-0.5513343811,
0.315423131,
0.6292070746,
0.3312979043,
-0.3928857446,
-0.4355776608,
0.224630788,
-0.2231593281,
-0.2781688273,
0.4634595811,
0.5538301468,
-0.0003524283,
0.5774193406,
0.7469343543,
0.6226614118,
0.0219400115,
0.3136108816,
1.2376192808,
-0.5390233397,
-0.1103621572,
-0.8955963254,
-0.0509637296,
0.1121233031,
-0.4435811639,
0.2879324555,
0.5189689994,
0.7253787518,
-0.0012661783,
0.5800924301,
0.0581138469,
0.4245790243,
-0.4815613925,
0.9221982956,
-0.6579124331,
0.0191237144,
-0.0297535565,
-0.8529855609,
-0.6132281423,
0.4509527683,
-0.4021039903,
0.0363677889,
0.8211910725,
0.6039259434,
-0.1076524779,
-0.3554238677,
0.2819464207,
0.3346367478,
0.3790148497,
0.6350151896,
0.4034379125,
0.0067971493,
0.6423044205,
0.0465861894,
-0.6594224572,
-0.1452874392,
-0.789362669,
-1.0445172787,
-0.2203181237,
-0.1040168926,
-0.5337989926,
0.133233428,
1.3184998035,
0.9550001621,
-0.4687013626,
-0.1861606389,
0.2257552147,
-0.3986412585,
0.0026018731,
-0.0276957285,
0.4962262511,
-0.1182854176,
-0.4527716041,
0.2012618482,
0.1956068277,
-0.1665198356,
-0.1793088615,
-0.1694608927,
0.2848612368,
0.0410797447,
0.6048725247,
0.0806033835,
-0.5720137358,
-0.1136777103,
0.0098276818,
-0.2128876299,
0.1624036431,
0.7737936378,
-0.501052916,
0.2901463509,
0.2225130498,
0.9866375923,
0.3649834394,
-0.2067557722,
0.6835382581,
-0.3195516169,
0.2146179527,
0.3733907342,
0.3043146729,
0.1745834947,
-0.0145192314,
0.5380193591,
-0.0338299833,
-0.7522286773,
-0.6871669292,
0.097326465,
-1.1053153276,
-0.2379189581,
1.3514322042,
0.0723190382,
-0.1987769157,
0.1727146059,
-0.5536506772,
0.3709873259,
-0.3211554885,
0.5790616274,
0.495102644,
0.0366400406,
0.1447281688,
-0.9010433555,
0.4597047567,
0.4637345076,
-1.0688358545,
-0.0170618575,
0.6275863051,
0.5556781888,
-0.0993369371,
1.1060986519,
-0.5496787429,
0.2636532784,
-0.4143094122,
0.2755300403,
-0.2195926756,
-0.2496024966,
-0.3639728129,
0.0641511381,
0.5554897189,
-0.0878426433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16075v1
|
BioLORD-2023: Semantic Textual Representations Fusing LLM and Clinical Knowledge Graph Insights
| 2023-11-27T18:46:17 | 2023-11-27T18:46:17 |
François Remy, Kris Demuynck, Thomas Demeester
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In this study, we investigate the potential of Large Language Models to
complement biomedical knowledge graphs in the training of semantic models for
the biomedical and clinical domains. Drawing on the wealth of the UMLS
knowledge graph and harnessing cutting-edge Large Language Models, we propose a
new state-of-the-art approach for obtaining high-fidelity representations of
biomedical concepts and sentences, consisting of three steps: an improved
contrastive learning phase, a novel self-distillation phase, and a weight
averaging phase. Through rigorous evaluations via the extensive BioLORD testing
suite and diverse downstream tasks, we demonstrate consistent and substantial
performance improvements over the previous state of the art (e.g. +2pts on
MedSTS, +2.5pts on MedNLI-S, +6.1pts on EHR-Rel-B). Besides our new
state-of-the-art biomedical model for English, we also distill and release a
multilingual model compatible with 50+ languages and finetuned on 7 European
languages. Many clinical pipelines can benefit from our latest models. Our new
multilingual model enables a range of languages to benefit from our
advancements in biomedical semantic representation learning, opening a new
avenue for bioinformatics researchers around the world. As a result, we hope to
see BioLORD-2023 becoming a precious tool for future biomedical applications.
|
[
-0.0767508149,
-0.6306415796,
0.7865993977,
-0.1632398963,
-0.1734923124,
0.1948030442,
0.1172098815,
-0.7556664944,
0.3391189575,
0.8466134071,
-0.313911587,
-0.8605682254,
-0.8345658183,
0.5977939963,
-0.053393472,
0.9883491397,
-0.1749834865,
0.563264668,
-0.5902856588,
-0.4221911728,
-0.36941275,
-0.6235885024,
-0.2460710108,
-0.8544760346,
0.7333475351,
-0.1822588146,
0.6254980564,
0.821008563,
0.5197165608,
0.3329650164,
-0.169537887,
0.0834062323,
-0.5778113604,
0.2216720134,
-0.2547603548,
-0.1264006793,
-0.8302023411,
-0.1020277068,
0.5427752137,
1.0229072571,
-0.0534679145,
-0.1286267936,
0.0046547507,
0.6022757292,
-0.2878426909,
0.4969582558,
-0.4694360495,
0.037221808,
-0.0525201485,
-0.0412893817,
-0.4977478683,
0.0595146716,
0.2772487998,
-0.7415691614,
-0.1404174417,
0.1920651197,
0.662879467,
0.1539010108,
-0.6912033558,
-0.1729077846,
-0.2853732109,
0.5999637842,
-0.7048722506,
0.657104373,
0.1644310057,
0.2592923939,
-0.1735166609,
-1.1265912056,
-0.309142828,
-0.2239024937,
-0.1406686306,
0.3659979701,
-0.2951570153,
0.2841356397,
-0.020830119,
0.2294837236,
-0.4833814204,
0.2445967644,
-0.6378108859,
-0.4872453809,
0.5455655456,
0.3554444611,
0.2695025206,
-0.3708451986,
-0.460049361,
-0.0678454787,
-0.8107459545,
-0.5373973846,
-0.2426664084,
0.0848135501,
-0.2111723423,
0.6759390235,
0.1639956981,
0.5362404585,
-0.3762197495,
-0.0651823729,
0.5212910771,
-0.3333757818,
-0.2307056338,
0.1614381671,
1.110519886,
0.3573537171,
0.0271310806,
-0.2516041696,
0.1763259917,
0.0814774781,
0.3858036697,
-0.9302150011,
-0.1879890114,
0.5282198787,
-0.5903981924,
-0.3226493299,
-0.2950517237,
-0.6953983903,
-0.70005548,
-0.1939486116,
0.3793584704,
-0.8720042109,
0.1379382908,
0.5443159938,
-0.1756152213,
-0.1223437563,
0.279915452,
-0.7442830205,
0.0868413076,
0.4437325597,
0.6875583529,
-0.3349458277,
-0.2749570906,
-0.2673865855,
0.6914954185,
-0.1399458349,
0.7443477511,
-0.2922035754,
-0.5684427619,
-0.0160161946,
0.1406439245,
-0.0012780451,
-0.6269801855,
0.1349640787,
-0.5843122005,
0.1052371487,
-0.090182364,
-0.848159492,
-0.2615421116,
0.1458685696,
-0.9053330421,
0.6783204079,
0.1567055434,
-0.791377306,
0.1552619487,
-0.7135319114,
-0.2426009476,
0.3752968609,
-0.3204933107,
-0.3818333149,
-0.1602639109,
0.0994676948,
0.6451232433,
-0.3118491769,
0.4898698926,
-0.453248173,
0.0262773596,
0.044601921,
0.0390481465,
0.7675768137,
0.0383901149,
-0.034006495,
0.2085784823,
-0.4063734114,
-0.2558175325,
0.1202226877,
-0.1146556512,
-0.3102575243,
0.066003032,
-0.0880537778,
0.025205845,
0.4756790996,
-0.789157629,
0.16128546,
-0.7578332424,
0.5709795356,
0.4758815169,
-0.0901377425,
0.2156971097,
-0.1838292181,
0.4660021663,
0.1399860829,
0.1581999958,
-0.1586121321,
-0.6768666506,
-0.1043497771,
-0.239186123,
0.3558848202,
0.6113397479,
-0.6791823506,
0.3971959949,
-0.410828501,
-0.4396634996,
-0.6418433785,
0.1642746478,
0.3673449457,
0.5833604932,
0.7793916464,
-0.115786925,
-0.5611068606,
-0.9285471439,
-0.0117351236,
-0.3233923912,
0.0545571484,
0.0409789607,
0.8788452148,
-0.8777553439,
0.6729739308,
-0.4849664569,
-0.3718924224,
-0.6227337122,
0.0501668639,
0.2875742614,
0.1561504453,
0.5199779868,
-0.6339395046,
-0.1804997176,
0.3102507293,
-1.1293765306,
0.095055066,
0.4971953034,
-0.1437749565,
-0.0455617085,
0.8395422697,
-0.1943913847,
0.2819272578,
0.8993826509,
-0.4808826447,
0.5646016598,
-0.530395925,
-0.0600188188,
-1.3739620447,
0.165983215,
-0.2331912816,
-0.528771162,
-0.4128288031,
0.0941624343,
0.153105557,
-0.1667710841,
-0.4398557246,
0.7700172067,
-0.3179859817,
0.4470570683,
0.0060686409,
0.23008582,
0.1659520417,
0.0555003583,
-0.1310836077,
0.570302844,
0.4847112894,
-0.4056700766,
0.4679492712,
0.7133613825,
-0.0366020575,
0.3409213722,
-0.9260967374,
-0.2844784558,
-0.37663728,
0.4805479348,
-0.6482598186,
-0.4405420423,
-0.0340831019,
-0.4620358348,
0.2868172824,
0.0164755043,
-0.5729575753,
-0.5610233545,
-0.3338541687,
0.2845371962,
0.5290161371,
-0.1283215582,
0.7920414209,
0.7821567655,
-0.1347605139,
-0.2889667749,
-0.8742598891,
0.0498002283,
-0.007661616,
-0.693431139,
0.8256825805,
0.171499297,
-0.0589195527,
0.06338045,
0.2591837049,
0.2162934393,
-0.0878799111,
0.0742324144,
0.578843534,
-0.1183642447,
0.3042188287,
0.2138758302,
-0.327899158,
0.2316661328,
-0.4178057909,
0.5014336109,
0.010593419,
-0.3883458376,
-0.2750636637,
0.4886807501,
0.6796683669,
-0.2747329175,
0.9637857676,
0.5222694278,
-0.4375957847,
0.2178418189,
-0.3456107974,
-0.1200774983,
-0.3943462074,
0.7417775393,
0.1404345483,
-1.0325036049,
0.5999969244,
-0.339323163,
0.0581886843,
0.7890951633,
0.7556199431,
-0.4289019108,
1.1648836136,
0.6551229358,
0.1888123006,
-0.0181696974,
-0.3702792823,
-0.0412794165,
-0.9275209308,
-0.5720305443,
-0.2559609115,
-0.0315368995,
-0.6760772467,
-0.5859777331,
1.072172761,
-0.166090548,
-0.297442019,
0.2255166471,
-0.2001829445,
0.1024083719,
0.1824235767,
0.3340058029,
0.2853024602,
0.1385800391,
-0.7890812755,
-0.0612710752,
-0.6844187379,
-0.5859631896,
1.1464437246,
0.3596753478,
0.5997790694,
-0.0044212448,
0.7656964064,
0.2548754215,
0.5410638452,
-0.5948578119,
0.3729683459,
-0.6074827909,
-0.6832671762,
-0.2168110758,
-0.3548379838,
-1.3384395838,
0.2326954454,
-0.4109678268,
-0.7170038819,
-0.1098960564,
0.0944299474,
-0.3319490254,
0.5154340863,
-0.4554371536,
1.1734164953,
-0.0827315971,
-0.4100939035,
-0.264552474,
-0.853177309,
0.015353078,
-0.1187301129,
0.4465069771,
-0.2054852396,
-0.1020627841,
0.8393644094,
-0.5868792534,
0.8878971934,
0.0276897419,
-0.2756688595,
0.0350084826,
-0.0196958184,
0.3000281155,
-0.0129241608,
-0.3020844758,
0.3087549508,
0.4217136204,
-0.4225952625,
-0.2837619483,
0.3393890262,
-0.725579977,
-0.366338551,
-0.4358659983,
-0.4212534428,
-0.5276486278,
0.397567004,
0.2888052166,
0.7355721593,
-0.4101805389,
0.145705387,
0.6532475352,
-0.708634913,
-0.1494903266,
0.4413174391,
-0.570091486,
-0.7356899977,
0.6465498209,
-0.2407558262,
0.3702802956,
0.4871061742,
0.2006554902,
-0.4814404547,
-0.6039706469,
-0.4379118979,
0.7601433396,
-0.7418025732,
-0.4020320773,
-0.9663357735,
-0.2368045896,
-0.5405488014,
-0.0255285483,
-0.1614048928,
-0.0264936909,
-0.2967977822,
-0.0465723015,
0.728987813,
1.1945902109,
0.0511121526,
0.1820048988,
-1.1633827686,
0.4139129817,
-0.0876548812,
0.3581553102,
-0.2470349967,
-0.4071293771,
-0.4273846447,
0.0729080737,
-0.4558069706,
-1.2066608667,
0.5477160215,
0.2057909966,
0.6020025611,
0.1021013334,
-0.3114258647,
0.5899689794,
-0.7823414207,
0.6390243173,
0.2758434415,
-0.6732975841,
0.486577332,
-0.5771989822,
0.3715974391,
0.705334723,
0.5846782923,
-0.6104329228,
-0.5366571546,
-0.5646708012,
-0.7643948197,
0.262726754,
-0.1011366919,
0.1284114271,
-0.2970973253,
0.30948928,
0.2556198239,
0.0926521868,
-0.4933560491,
-0.4019421935,
0.0537427925,
-0.5421285033,
0.0237600133,
-0.2276146263,
-0.0262613166,
-0.564919591,
0.4586140811,
-0.3305463493,
0.540012002,
0.2202949226,
-0.0655896366,
0.2423994988,
0.126587376,
-0.013471487,
0.4376324415,
-0.2422192097,
0.0770383328,
0.3130286038,
-0.7038481236,
-0.1633246243,
0.3688761592,
0.1777865291,
-0.0695627779,
0.822938323,
0.6348564625,
0.4876077473,
-0.8342940211,
0.5826516151,
0.3472493291,
-0.2392583489,
-0.1144080758,
-0.3541243672,
0.4224278033,
0.1020614952,
0.0578178838,
-0.0879576132,
0.3349405229,
-0.5204190612,
0.332521528,
0.2866129875,
-0.7108996511,
-0.2695355415,
1.0478372574,
0.138348937,
0.495745033,
0.5874933004,
-0.003218286,
-0.5854978561,
0.3570364416,
0.6434509754,
0.5046751499,
-0.2367805839,
0.2848272622,
0.4365673959,
-0.1076304689,
0.0771012828,
0.3091194034,
0.4091485739,
-0.7299211621,
-0.6866841912,
-0.847394526,
-0.4310493171,
-0.1872445941,
-0.4932973087,
0.3765755594,
-0.0523706675,
-0.3839784563,
0.1673632413,
-0.2643945217,
-0.6113995314,
0.0507327504,
0.2093640566,
0.7940517068,
-0.5265368819,
0.8546587229,
0.8980021477,
-0.4111944139,
-0.5790035129,
-0.5572853088,
0.0928183198,
-1.0667285919,
0.5476821661,
0.0283543505,
-0.0434149317,
0.0098915854,
-0.4446541369,
-0.7147122025,
1.3646917343,
0.4909642637,
-0.5271345973,
-0.4237063229,
0.1915105879,
0.8129925132,
-0.3496304452,
0.035341315,
0.4479887486,
0.3597354889,
0.1662534028,
-0.84772861,
0.0393729098,
-0.2909072936,
-0.1970249414,
0.1727322638,
-0.2416681498,
0.5809759498,
-0.3530125618,
-0.1661605388,
0.1896152347,
0.5629426837,
0.4761993289,
0.1481834501,
0.0688906759,
0.490409404,
0.8386207223,
-0.050978072,
1.4643580914,
-0.541945219,
0.263577193,
0.6512298584,
-0.4407523572,
0.762527287,
0.3414687514,
-0.4625133574,
0.8509359956,
0.3085606992,
-0.0316076353,
0.180015415,
0.01566891,
-0.1216074228,
-0.3275146782,
-0.337208271,
-0.5009890795,
0.3397728205,
0.545778811,
-0.5811499357,
-0.2707576752,
0.2884149253,
0.1832158715,
0.0473665781,
-0.156599313,
0.9258164167,
0.2408717573,
-0.2395234704,
0.5799270272,
-0.0891247541,
0.4809630811,
-0.8288347125,
-0.1472872645,
0.0398076549,
0.1394296885,
0.0310274679,
-0.7999456525,
0.3198269308,
-0.1758168936,
0.0624591894,
-0.4204534888,
0.6296391487,
-0.4551925659,
-0.7022103667,
0.9031778574,
0.5874706507,
0.1457425356,
0.1837664545,
-0.6714839339,
0.0507358722,
-0.1511322856,
0.3308436871,
0.040672671,
0.5348474979,
-0.0502571836,
0.6519014239,
0.314357549,
0.4249150753,
-0.2259331942,
0.1516961902,
0.9102067947,
-0.7079173923,
-0.3048482239,
-0.9066179395,
0.3462167084,
-0.0771207139,
-0.0788799599,
0.5108574629,
0.5728447437,
0.4483059645,
-0.1710636914,
0.7527029514,
0.148153618,
0.4715842009,
-0.5731469393,
1.0126843452,
-0.7449680567,
0.0200247262,
-0.32722193,
-0.3259525299,
-0.5456182957,
0.1706380993,
-0.2263063341,
0.064589709,
1.0452605486,
0.3691863418,
0.1345945001,
0.1075600982,
0.3739877641,
0.5938155055,
0.2524395585,
0.5748710036,
0.5331757665,
-0.4911910295,
0.204293251,
0.0807472989,
-0.1772028655,
-0.074019216,
-0.8074817657,
-0.796346426,
-0.5861470699,
-0.2327294797,
-0.5762636065,
0.1374190152,
0.8464609385,
0.5303265452,
-0.8564915657,
-0.0912766755,
0.1785025299,
-0.1005950123,
0.0216720402,
-0.0513622537,
0.4518634677,
-0.2675616443,
-0.364508301,
0.2860689163,
0.6479112506,
0.213493228,
-0.4400838017,
-0.1295832694,
0.0088909948,
-0.0621907078,
0.9549524188,
-0.0157717951,
-0.6726424098,
0.0677000284,
0.0999606997,
-0.2655970454,
0.1568403244,
0.6859076023,
-1.0975841284,
0.5637298226,
0.3470737636,
0.5582631826,
0.5125682354,
-0.3612472713,
0.8531452417,
-0.190350756,
-0.0183755811,
0.39426139,
0.6812024713,
0.5281513333,
-0.0514716841,
0.352552861,
0.3216151297,
-0.3296539485,
-0.4605056942,
0.220104441,
-1.0535522699,
-0.3364127576,
1.0556492805,
0.1507229358,
-0.4619125426,
-0.377609998,
-0.1432839334,
0.3685582578,
-0.0548693798,
0.5528994799,
0.5168223977,
-0.0625914484,
0.3872843385,
-0.8492575288,
0.4987546504,
0.2458235174,
-0.9742352962,
0.1090483516,
0.5083417296,
0.1443877369,
0.0645352229,
0.6618414521,
-0.9625338912,
0.1437274665,
-0.3788267374,
0.1561205089,
0.0682470202,
-0.0340056866,
-0.0922124535,
-0.0766389295,
-0.2414968163,
0.480880022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16502v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16502v4
|
MMMU: A Massive Multi-discipline Multimodal Understanding and Reasoning Benchmark for Expert AGI
| 2023-11-27T17:33:21 | 2024-06-13T15:02:39 |
Xiang Yue, Yuansheng Ni, Kai Zhang, Tianyu Zheng, Ruoqi Liu, Ge Zhang, Samuel Stevens, Dongfu Jiang, Weiming Ren, Yuxuan Sun, Cong Wei, Botao Yu, Ruibin Yuan, Renliang Sun, Ming Yin, Boyuan Zheng, Zhenzhu Yang, Yibo Liu, Wenhao Huang, Huan Sun, Yu Su, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
We introduce MMMU: a new benchmark designed to evaluate multimodal models on
massive multi-discipline tasks demanding college-level subject knowledge and
deliberate reasoning. MMMU includes 11.5K meticulously collected multimodal
questions from college exams, quizzes, and textbooks, covering six core
disciplines: Art & Design, Business, Science, Health & Medicine, Humanities &
Social Science, and Tech & Engineering. These questions span 30 subjects and
183 subfields, comprising 30 highly heterogeneous image types, such as charts,
diagrams, maps, tables, music sheets, and chemical structures. Unlike existing
benchmarks, MMMU focuses on advanced perception and reasoning with
domain-specific knowledge, challenging models to perform tasks akin to those
faced by experts. The evaluation of 14 open-source LMMs as well as the
proprietary GPT-4V(ision) and Gemini highlights the substantial challenges
posed by MMMU. Even the advanced GPT-4V and Gemini Ultra only achieve
accuracies of 56% and 59% respectively, indicating significant room for
improvement. We believe MMMU will stimulate the community to build
next-generation multimodal foundation models towards expert artificial general
intelligence.
|
[
-0.6403566003,
-1.0822426081,
0.6581947803,
-0.0317277685,
0.1340344697,
-0.1221284419,
0.1102643013,
-0.5494500995,
-0.0345557667,
0.2125853896,
-0.7120261788,
-0.2301858515,
-0.515599668,
0.0709305108,
0.0440373011,
0.5317491889,
0.2254182696,
-0.1102535948,
-0.6752699018,
-0.5249423385,
-0.5762879252,
-0.2992360592,
-0.4084298909,
-0.2129986435,
0.458386004,
0.428445667,
0.7119150758,
0.5698425174,
0.5875120163,
0.4890010655,
0.2010037452,
0.4953312278,
-0.3086954355,
-0.2212655693,
-0.091288276,
-0.2639945447,
-0.7194783688,
0.3747465014,
0.6786928773,
0.8111109734,
0.0422242284,
0.2353698909,
-0.2192533016,
0.5280307531,
-0.8434016705,
0.1974612474,
-0.5371289253,
-0.0582409799,
-0.0849756151,
-0.140133366,
-0.3811490536,
-0.0892341956,
0.1278804392,
-0.921199739,
-0.0586813763,
-0.1528030485,
0.8694678545,
0.6232957244,
-0.9577869773,
0.321638763,
-0.3323277831,
0.8952665925,
-0.3049454093,
0.7114322782,
0.1662911922,
0.6502051353,
-0.2007845342,
-0.5444101095,
-0.5318763256,
-0.365680337,
0.2238235623,
0.43148157,
-0.3427978754,
-0.1123501435,
0.1766171604,
0.2707899809,
-0.4678125679,
0.0004137628,
-0.2044358701,
-0.1214479506,
0.6648970246,
0.3537628949,
-0.0925711915,
0.0335984454,
-0.4045880437,
0.0572948679,
-0.3449299634,
0.1374116689,
0.2206586003,
-0.3151955605,
-0.0260881223,
0.5192157626,
-0.3501143456,
0.7342393398,
-0.0087330323,
-0.1711772084,
0.2960928082,
-0.3897189498,
-0.3713451028,
-0.6201548576,
0.9547530413,
0.5083310008,
-0.0053776097,
-0.1337642074,
0.1279065609,
0.3296741545,
0.5314776897,
-0.5593058467,
-0.2956047654,
0.2269791663,
-0.2213431299,
0.0770644546,
0.0330005549,
-0.5305238962,
-0.2857848704,
-0.5779743195,
0.4553975463,
-0.549955368,
-0.487675637,
-0.1248578727,
-0.0583304279,
0.2412773967,
0.642523706,
-0.5351171494,
0.0564334393,
0.7672151327,
0.3973079324,
-0.3108154237,
-0.6400113702,
-0.3141121268,
0.1339661032,
-0.1954323202,
0.8216201067,
-0.6651105285,
-0.5473711491,
-0.4765946865,
-0.128202796,
-0.258143574,
-0.5590213537,
0.5971261263,
-0.1849678308,
0.0103337243,
-0.2918498814,
-0.3899188638,
-0.3203842938,
0.5477394462,
-0.6802175045,
1.1610509157,
0.3106368184,
-0.4088956416,
0.618727088,
-0.9270076156,
-0.2036383152,
0.1437620819,
-0.4613828361,
-0.2337376922,
0.0890419409,
0.2818080485,
0.6348391175,
-0.2630631924,
0.4822152555,
-0.5942059159,
-0.0415414795,
0.5250818729,
-0.4546463788,
0.3794486821,
0.4887073338,
-0.1871180981,
0.4214519858,
-0.9049695134,
0.0651626885,
-0.00042968,
-0.2277532667,
-0.189274326,
-0.2093340456,
0.1502253413,
0.2792808712,
0.2366954386,
-0.4154520333,
0.3450298309,
0.357560873,
0.449698329,
0.869176805,
-0.3626003861,
0.2781873047,
-0.2109553665,
0.142617777,
0.2388857752,
0.4506751597,
-0.2502805889,
-0.8831319809,
-0.6347593665,
-0.3825149536,
-0.0912541151,
0.3439185321,
-0.6418063641,
0.2182009071,
-0.1324148178,
-0.6583096385,
-0.7810775638,
0.0385550447,
0.386841923,
0.6628004313,
0.6073220968,
-0.3016126156,
-0.2048834562,
-1.1158424616,
-0.1232331172,
-0.1021102816,
0.0003617555,
0.6563416123,
0.6330456734,
-0.6983053088,
0.9768149853,
-0.3976079822,
-0.3610481918,
-0.0070896698,
0.5085945129,
0.016005151,
0.4124210179,
0.6359256506,
-1.0693715811,
-0.0467984676,
0.1925475299,
-1.1941729784,
0.0809403881,
-0.017880071,
-0.2650465965,
0.0788711682,
0.2153012156,
-0.8227289319,
-0.021916708,
0.3447125554,
-0.6148999333,
0.8395896554,
-0.2455373257,
0.6111177206,
-1.0210279226,
0.2044190913,
0.4406872988,
-0.0034766241,
-0.4901733994,
0.8000158668,
0.280177027,
-0.0552070811,
-0.5183858275,
0.4203258455,
-0.5846965909,
0.0310121961,
-0.1163414046,
-0.2148733139,
0.0038189844,
0.3338478804,
-0.1942041963,
0.7921000123,
0.7160776258,
-0.7060414553,
0.4231532812,
0.0193428472,
-0.1882813424,
1.0829497576,
-0.5440021753,
0.1559669077,
0.0483136326,
0.0839266926,
-0.8557911515,
-0.2580674589,
-0.2280502319,
-0.4403576851,
0.2389733046,
-0.0129766995,
-0.168649435,
-0.5874519348,
-0.0524826273,
0.5407392383,
0.2154874504,
-0.1820568591,
1.2739264965,
0.5772986412,
0.370469749,
-0.9697383642,
-0.4760751426,
0.1044730917,
-0.1284754127,
-0.7197743058,
-0.0372625254,
-0.4427872896,
-0.3829415143,
0.0728900954,
-0.1584154665,
-0.2073550671,
0.4520705938,
0.4067871571,
0.4444995522,
-0.5264322758,
-0.3675807714,
-0.1113868877,
-0.2105246484,
0.2970626354,
-0.2678254247,
0.1542446166,
-0.5244278312,
-0.6003654599,
-0.5383024216,
0.453456074,
0.9235499501,
-0.2770425677,
0.3027485609,
1.1105840206,
-0.3002271056,
0.3270443976,
-1.0025272369,
0.0928995237,
-0.5008233786,
0.4664729834,
-1.0546811819,
-0.8765674233,
0.4027792513,
-0.1412930042,
0.2977339327,
0.748011291,
0.6827337146,
0.0864666179,
0.9736338258,
0.5133684278,
-0.3419751823,
-0.1012374163,
-0.5575315952,
-0.4486823082,
-0.5386350155,
-0.4904542267,
-0.3568742275,
-0.3325355351,
-0.273870647,
-0.6278555989,
0.4338273108,
-0.2834811807,
-0.0140797105,
0.1193061098,
-0.3074256182,
0.4281303585,
0.7973157763,
0.1889610738,
0.3031407893,
-0.4234968424,
-0.1871061921,
-0.0154740699,
-0.4154473543,
-0.1983168125,
1.1869996786,
0.3587343693,
0.6485529542,
0.2623853981,
0.2224919051,
0.344886899,
0.571064949,
-0.8858648539,
0.6887323856,
0.0589399263,
-0.7271922827,
-0.1698150337,
-0.6564041376,
-0.7369410992,
0.4803295135,
-0.4330812991,
-0.4752897918,
-0.0363735892,
0.1683624238,
-0.188855201,
0.4246747792,
-0.8666501641,
0.9919204712,
-0.0402166657,
-0.6107589006,
-0.299980849,
-0.6253455877,
0.5815941691,
-0.0873144642,
0.4287341833,
-0.3772373796,
-0.1020795107,
0.6266272068,
-0.1648961902,
0.3813203871,
-0.1956464797,
0.0686661527,
0.2694112062,
0.019160185,
-0.058300674,
0.0676022172,
-0.0633786246,
0.3009642959,
-0.1537591368,
-0.5557712317,
-0.3241307139,
0.8104597926,
-1.2327373028,
-0.6268207431,
-0.3997952938,
-0.9783279896,
-0.3644517958,
0.167698279,
0.0398917906,
0.5724408627,
-0.4971269667,
0.1138376296,
0.6898129582,
0.2395422608,
0.2348562479,
0.5400984883,
0.2845425606,
-0.2729854286,
0.9581148624,
-0.161799252,
-0.0830347613,
0.4153830409,
0.2917401493,
-0.5084549785,
-0.604549408,
-0.9098588228,
0.1160550565,
-0.7161794901,
-0.1806518584,
-1.1253044605,
0.1940334141,
-0.5089292526,
-0.000169484,
-0.4840711653,
-0.1886199266,
-0.2056953758,
0.0093405461,
0.1512881219,
0.7787086964,
0.0327619277,
0.0972134396,
-0.7195816636,
0.6565034389,
0.5535307527,
0.2401566952,
-0.232885018,
-0.3391070366,
-0.1279427707,
-0.1251960546,
-0.713997364,
-0.5756688714,
0.0127126398,
0.4103117883,
0.9363698959,
0.9664889574,
-0.1720215231,
0.9514639974,
-0.6102938056,
0.7334163785,
0.3516295552,
-0.8038557172,
0.4805015922,
-0.4055385888,
0.4819707274,
0.6951340437,
0.9406226873,
-0.1110199168,
-0.4418158233,
-0.5169990063,
-0.6743158102,
0.4038593173,
-0.0628067702,
-0.0414649621,
-0.0074396352,
0.1109294966,
0.5078350902,
0.0899466202,
-0.5237849951,
-0.5487294197,
-0.3187479973,
-0.0828443021,
-0.1639618576,
-0.1143549308,
-0.2511591315,
-0.5091274381,
0.4129269421,
-0.3919209838,
0.3097807169,
-0.0921412185,
-0.2060100436,
-0.1770524085,
0.4350132942,
0.4389910698,
1.0395104885,
-0.2978945374,
0.0507533997,
0.195325315,
-0.693297863,
0.1177500561,
0.4139080048,
0.1302748322,
-0.2752768099,
0.1049416587,
0.6006105542,
0.2066200674,
-0.5942177773,
0.2791169286,
-0.0868884549,
-0.5943146348,
-0.1989711225,
0.1882093698,
-0.1167268232,
0.2423959821,
0.8178911805,
0.1689425409,
0.4875301123,
-0.8133436441,
0.3946514726,
0.5561386943,
-0.3838597238,
-0.2699770927,
1.1840658188,
0.2014810741,
0.2981680334,
0.4726049602,
0.0605279133,
-0.1050398722,
0.5725080371,
0.2604165673,
0.5044717789,
-0.3895008862,
0.0736996159,
0.2353164703,
0.2610262632,
0.0767720491,
0.400314033,
-0.1532488316,
-0.6364523172,
-0.4241690636,
-0.5450757146,
-0.9049983025,
0.1462571919,
-0.6562969089,
0.0369279347,
-0.2572014928,
-0.4228049815,
0.4209782481,
0.0558826141,
-0.8167771101,
0.5599828362,
0.1053995863,
0.9456921816,
-0.8151909113,
0.7818778753,
1.178888917,
-0.2486094236,
-0.6440479159,
-0.6437467933,
0.3889012635,
-0.7169998288,
0.3303253353,
0.5470122695,
-0.1727992445,
-0.0519182682,
-0.4155768752,
-0.5174618363,
1.1512212753,
0.1538270861,
-0.3552754223,
0.146191135,
0.1397431493,
0.2618694305,
-0.2253809273,
0.93295753,
0.7541896701,
0.7174043655,
0.1826502979,
-0.9154995084,
-0.1163375527,
-0.8069892526,
-0.5138679147,
0.2280898839,
-0.7091103196,
1.0987541676,
-0.4130483568,
0.1530862451,
0.0917032883,
0.9345349669,
0.3070389628,
0.9224042892,
0.5196757913,
1.0184775591,
0.6635423303,
-0.5382002592,
0.9775491357,
0.0653364807,
0.0683978349,
0.6655704379,
-0.1436041296,
0.6456161737,
0.3749161661,
-0.2885379195,
0.311773777,
0.643913269,
-0.2056274116,
0.1963426471,
-0.2388292402,
-0.0984078646,
-0.4045467377,
-0.1909724176,
-0.7539647222,
0.5808912516,
0.4044157267,
0.2924799025,
0.0786673501,
0.1870941669,
-0.1575615704,
-0.0125731714,
-0.4630790651,
0.7430936694,
-0.0953497291,
-0.6121618152,
0.4811940193,
0.069419384,
0.8970041275,
-0.7180449367,
0.1118213609,
-0.2468201369,
0.3194226623,
-0.1360044479,
-0.7832049131,
0.044696629,
-0.3500448167,
0.1331592351,
0.0403683335,
0.5430963039,
-0.1042580903,
-0.499315083,
0.1781691462,
0.9095751643,
0.3075864613,
-0.343649596,
-0.8818225265,
-0.0629658252,
-0.4303046465,
-0.261708647,
0.3430660069,
0.73605901,
0.054474283,
0.9681359529,
0.7041285038,
-0.4778443575,
0.0859638676,
0.1644448936,
0.9971547127,
-0.6517495513,
-0.5638742447,
-0.7040067911,
0.569704473,
-0.0051065856,
-0.6409825683,
0.8577268124,
0.6986253858,
0.8158571124,
-0.2039391696,
0.6141438484,
0.0398043729,
-0.0754918605,
-0.3506678939,
0.6936203837,
-1.156973362,
-0.4070139825,
-0.5005428195,
-0.7878656387,
-0.1340813488,
0.3035168946,
-0.1334526241,
0.1593884528,
0.6288427711,
0.312111944,
-0.4134610295,
0.1318425536,
0.6841478944,
0.0716567934,
0.0642059296,
0.6966466308,
0.992633462,
-0.2041839957,
0.4625530243,
-0.2554013133,
-0.5517625809,
-0.2882213593,
-0.6433790922,
-0.9170084,
-0.5903300047,
-0.4878796637,
-0.080805026,
-0.1293985248,
0.7837078571,
0.9899559021,
-0.7373079062,
-0.2539955378,
0.3948130012,
-0.20406726,
-0.5075572729,
-0.2579331398,
0.125245735,
0.1224096194,
-0.7213699818,
0.6438669562,
0.2769015729,
-0.1385461688,
-0.3778023422,
-0.0821697339,
-0.2540903986,
-0.1543750167,
0.9065461159,
0.1292657405,
-0.77727741,
-0.0433786102,
0.2252227366,
-0.0190605037,
0.2842591107,
0.8080118299,
-0.733052671,
0.3402811587,
0.1269962341,
0.8145116568,
0.2256679833,
-0.008222566,
0.1931154132,
-0.526782155,
0.1358935684,
0.0588908605,
0.6614637375,
0.2109033465,
-0.3313022256,
0.6775546074,
0.5333529115,
-0.5408246517,
-0.5561382174,
0.161329329,
-1.508156538,
-0.4130479097,
0.7591654658,
-0.1475088,
-0.2685825825,
-0.3498466611,
-0.0880682319,
0.1776986569,
-0.6129019856,
0.7112193108,
0.4375805855,
-0.1463534832,
-0.4466314018,
-0.7125445008,
-0.053237278,
0.4598585963,
-1.0965536833,
-0.3634896576,
0.8807052374,
0.1841732413,
0.2763246596,
0.5410041809,
-0.0539527722,
0.6492317915,
0.0636842623,
0.0566093475,
-0.6380563974,
-0.6400974393,
0.1268518418,
0.4446641505,
-0.1927978098,
-0.1391351372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15983v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15983v2
|
SPIN: Sparsifying and Integrating Internal Neurons in Large Language Models for Text Classification
| 2023-11-27T16:28:20 | 2024-06-05T17:15:47 |
Difan Jiao, Yilun Liu, Zhenwei Tang, Daniel Matter, Jürgen Pfeffer, Ashton Anderson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Among the many tasks that Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized is
text classification. Current text classification paradigms, however, rely
solely on the output of the final layer in the LLM, with the rich information
contained in internal neurons largely untapped. In this study, we present SPIN:
a model-agnostic framework that sparsifies and integrates internal neurons of
intermediate layers of LLMs for text classification. Specifically, SPIN
sparsifies internal neurons by linear probing-based salient neuron selection
layer by layer, avoiding noise from unrelated neurons and ensuring efficiency.
The cross-layer salient neurons are then integrated to serve as multi-layered
features for the classification head. Extensive experimental results show our
proposed SPIN significantly improves text classification accuracy, efficiency,
and interpretability.
|
[
-0.3418347836,
-0.6499853134,
0.5821189284,
-0.0168433934,
-0.2011407763,
0.1279337853,
-0.521238625,
-0.4234074652,
0.2789002657,
0.3588211536,
-0.3336286247,
-0.3056931198,
-0.6757773161,
-0.0414480045,
-0.6613152623,
1.2996290922,
0.3517091572,
0.2043379247,
-0.3023223877,
0.1877700239,
-0.06105363,
-0.7417234182,
-0.7030127048,
-0.6728109121,
0.83966887,
0.3853717744,
0.6207897067,
0.0413913354,
0.4644374549,
0.3486059606,
-0.4307876229,
0.5312081575,
-0.1735071838,
0.4000239074,
-0.3027544916,
-0.4090375602,
-0.3620708287,
0.0045141894,
0.6961342096,
0.6989480853,
0.1152731851,
0.009301845,
0.1988979131,
0.6610996127,
-0.494058758,
-0.1720282137,
-0.5681087375,
0.1943164319,
-0.1329073012,
-0.2724933326,
-0.6403552294,
-0.0876207501,
0.1910927743,
-0.2092285603,
0.3107155561,
0.1644648463,
0.664385438,
0.0628494546,
-0.2209239453,
-0.3033024669,
-0.6230885983,
0.5570057631,
-0.4872407317,
0.3618552387,
0.2583904266,
-0.0529608019,
-0.0277069025,
-0.4894455373,
-0.6848134398,
-0.5100687146,
-0.0030239716,
-0.0446442962,
-0.141580224,
0.1552655995,
-0.1220148355,
0.3605167866,
-0.2207630724,
0.175406754,
-0.3074849546,
0.1790966541,
0.3048214018,
-0.0912533998,
0.5089731216,
0.0824397653,
-0.3492752314,
-0.1093315184,
-0.3695263267,
-0.2684777975,
0.3085300028,
0.5561941266,
0.0209587235,
0.8361982703,
0.198040694,
0.5754414201,
0.2407458723,
0.1355592608,
0.1703248471,
0.1165294424,
-0.1784582436,
0.3632185459,
0.7371347547,
-0.0394658223,
0.2040498108,
-0.4586520195,
-0.2942644954,
-0.169910416,
0.6055002809,
-0.640760541,
-0.0419044122,
0.1623911262,
-0.3979655206,
-0.5369415283,
-0.0118468869,
-0.834204495,
-0.7744247913,
-0.2318682671,
0.4544898868,
-0.366933316,
-0.4561937451,
0.1632221788,
-0.1464917511,
-0.0027990248,
0.4346310794,
-0.8294081092,
0.5335466862,
0.7337554097,
1.1504887342,
-0.4778598547,
-0.3868229389,
-0.3569258451,
0.3172696829,
-0.4990111291,
0.9542503953,
-0.4885814488,
0.0078386711,
-0.0453475565,
-0.2359824479,
0.1316926777,
-0.3039861917,
0.512542665,
-0.7974963188,
0.3880428374,
-0.0254570395,
-0.3567326069,
-0.3571546674,
0.3579700589,
-0.6140012145,
1.1722695827,
0.0700060576,
-0.9982622266,
0.021918714,
-0.6039577127,
-0.5920321345,
0.0045464681,
-0.0185983721,
-0.4299208522,
0.5011199713,
-0.1415871531,
0.7852002978,
-0.6294666529,
0.1882831752,
-0.3766454756,
-0.4028795958,
0.8406637907,
-0.3378100395,
0.383856833,
0.2006370425,
-0.3823924661,
0.256829977,
-0.60093081,
0.2226763517,
-0.1040634066,
-0.196224004,
-0.5530331135,
0.0013059445,
0.2854774892,
0.049966678,
0.0953594074,
-0.3395167589,
0.2189863026,
-0.2425709367,
0.423458904,
0.6998873949,
-0.3773781359,
0.8478489518,
-0.1067135856,
0.2247273475,
0.2329252809,
-0.3781691194,
0.0365438275,
-0.4534029961,
-0.9460498095,
-0.4883562624,
0.4152685404,
0.4165887237,
-0.5005495548,
0.8133020401,
-0.341376394,
-0.2033587694,
-0.3092340231,
-0.0391176939,
0.200924173,
0.2662148178,
0.4079960287,
-0.0837007836,
-0.1735199392,
-0.7067763805,
-0.1872643828,
0.0366068892,
0.1297151893,
-0.091525346,
0.4982135296,
-0.4138901234,
0.6224923134,
-0.2299338579,
-0.3689937294,
-0.6224559546,
0.3508892357,
0.2194185108,
0.3993590772,
0.1914410293,
-0.5905364752,
-0.4987665117,
0.5461682677,
-0.5381094217,
-0.1190674379,
-0.279805392,
-0.2585692108,
0.1378960609,
0.4975910485,
-0.8472241759,
0.3145496845,
0.419490993,
-0.2318543494,
0.3207640052,
-0.3191727102,
0.0881308764,
-1.002980113,
0.0567081198,
0.1982694417,
-0.194234699,
-0.7488010526,
-0.2299821824,
0.22084032,
0.0326072834,
0.3406534493,
0.7015939951,
-0.6407372952,
-0.2850552797,
-0.8646087646,
0.2288089693,
-0.0161144957,
0.3308488131,
0.0917381868,
0.8912398219,
0.4716859162,
-0.7127016187,
0.1321575046,
-0.0867640674,
-0.3433436155,
0.353292495,
-0.4761345685,
0.1547689289,
-0.232041955,
0.1198133379,
-0.8961565495,
-0.3431177139,
0.318610549,
-0.685182631,
0.6228418946,
0.0322621018,
-0.6062337756,
-0.0133248381,
-0.1835699677,
0.2970545888,
0.3439824879,
-0.7024047375,
0.8904551864,
0.6355885863,
-0.1231820509,
-0.7443513274,
-0.9570232034,
0.0734769329,
0.0286068004,
-0.2719628215,
0.5095482469,
0.2550041676,
-0.068125464,
0.1440895498,
-0.0900563896,
-0.3011024892,
-0.0807663351,
0.1291657984,
0.151288107,
-0.1155016199,
0.4285240471,
0.3022618294,
-0.1049977541,
-0.156458497,
-0.2429375798,
0.7586266398,
-0.1311212033,
-0.3166563809,
-0.4490572512,
0.5132908821,
0.7591878772,
-0.1636635363,
0.69534266,
0.6012479067,
-0.3528099358,
-0.8377611637,
-0.5665410757,
-0.1838872433,
-0.4865022302,
0.6758832335,
-0.2375565022,
-0.9733941555,
0.1196782961,
-0.1282324642,
-0.3824609518,
0.3213030994,
0.3257941902,
-0.3511648178,
0.8562836647,
0.7737190127,
-0.1625974625,
0.6003388762,
-0.0251259152,
0.4522418678,
-1.0389101505,
-0.2887263,
-0.5977808237,
-0.3142061532,
-0.2287363559,
-0.6319306493,
0.4395132065,
0.1929675788,
-0.3152865469,
-0.1136570647,
-0.772349596,
0.6527282,
0.4234207571,
0.2342469692,
0.0675321892,
0.4061374962,
-0.1222058982,
-0.0834185928,
-0.6209806204,
-0.4161727428,
0.6651554108,
0.5448943377,
0.9997491837,
-0.1856046468,
0.3658827841,
0.4064573348,
0.3469131887,
-0.8413870931,
0.6278389692,
-0.3929808438,
-0.52181077,
-0.0371317565,
-0.4990225732,
-0.4649652243,
0.4826176763,
-0.3743343651,
-0.5035050511,
0.1352379173,
0.0052168784,
-0.2181792557,
0.6652646661,
-0.6788804531,
0.3315282166,
-0.6865504384,
-0.3536065221,
-0.4598645866,
-0.2062428743,
0.1749589741,
0.0487814657,
0.074886784,
-0.0996672064,
-0.3889169991,
0.5490283966,
0.1267130524,
1.1009953022,
0.0736760125,
0.1426635087,
0.1443542242,
0.173902452,
0.3494979441,
-0.080650419,
-0.0430727825,
0.2971694469,
-0.6433054805,
0.0918983147,
-0.4720463157,
0.8318807483,
-0.8080905676,
-0.2957486808,
-1.0283229351,
-0.5609058142,
-0.1963500828,
0.3486645222,
0.0665490627,
0.2224841118,
0.1134669706,
0.1913875192,
1.1455745697,
-0.3467526734,
0.2351386249,
0.0671492368,
-0.3806113899,
-0.6657444835,
0.75839293,
-0.0925712064,
0.003711368,
0.416934669,
0.0998836234,
-0.2238181233,
-0.7916266918,
-0.2564170361,
0.3216351569,
-0.9092525244,
-0.4762639999,
-0.8284992576,
-0.7305983901,
-0.2523298264,
-0.2958519459,
-0.4438506067,
-0.3508332968,
-0.5884407759,
-0.069981508,
0.5033951402,
1.0966101885,
-0.069811143,
0.6768220663,
-0.5668251514,
0.2874063551,
0.0903822854,
0.6671332717,
0.1865565628,
-0.7454382181,
-0.4684681892,
-0.2503349781,
-0.0108879292,
-0.7546648979,
0.5475203991,
0.1699459404,
0.7103356123,
0.2528414726,
-0.3024788201,
0.6535275578,
-0.6952697039,
0.5283994079,
0.6336883307,
-1.1807154417,
0.1248273551,
-0.0558300242,
0.2489176989,
0.4808997214,
0.5204385519,
-0.7626440525,
-0.1954997629,
-0.0897955,
-0.8962008953,
0.9064309001,
-0.1735231429,
0.3419740796,
-0.0849560797,
0.528672874,
0.192263931,
0.202627033,
-1.0712649822,
-0.0461382419,
0.0894196779,
-0.4129857719,
0.0831994712,
-0.4948237538,
-0.0833650976,
-0.2601590753,
0.6310110092,
-0.189039439,
0.5871213675,
0.2750494778,
-0.3539716601,
-0.0527774617,
0.154072538,
0.4587617517,
0.3021768332,
0.0551877618,
0.5519683361,
0.1208309457,
-0.5583817959,
0.0696279109,
-0.3102251589,
-0.3895924687,
0.0829485655,
0.3039954603,
0.6017742157,
0.4529151917,
-0.2284861803,
0.4329940379,
0.1038156971,
-0.0241596773,
-0.3540894985,
0.0615655184,
0.0496311411,
0.4915558994,
0.4164589942,
0.3618790805,
0.1705574542,
-0.2606937289,
0.0868962556,
0.6041526198,
-0.3754787743,
-0.2869346142,
0.3082316518,
0.0932531282,
-0.2598877251,
0.4885705709,
-0.0069038551,
-0.8469879627,
0.1847929507,
0.6692348123,
1.2889363766,
-0.2078164816,
0.2698595226,
0.4147695601,
0.4305382073,
-0.3906003237,
0.0388155952,
-0.0230815858,
-0.8930398226,
-0.4730174839,
-0.6936699748,
-0.4714155793,
-0.0366750844,
-0.3725094199,
0.1984366477,
-0.7636291981,
-0.3604569733,
-0.1068135798,
-0.273865521,
-0.0023416092,
0.1521383077,
0.5691909194,
0.8110145926,
-0.5914056301,
1.0714733601,
0.6111608148,
-0.3456359208,
0.0593743287,
0.2459583879,
-0.4274822474,
-0.4169133306,
1.0365275145,
0.4532595575,
-0.8418978453,
-0.2459738404,
-0.8820329309,
-1.0533033609,
0.5571958423,
0.1306516826,
-0.2134344131,
-0.0935252234,
0.0467551909,
0.5920911431,
-0.5872963667,
0.4502268732,
-0.0684398785,
0.2891378403,
0.0254914407,
-0.5823885202,
-0.1662675291,
-0.3618768454,
0.3644013703,
0.1256857216,
-0.4912967384,
1.0883738995,
-0.1716280282,
-0.1758269072,
-0.155737251,
0.9790373445,
0.0675056428,
0.0146026127,
0.4408952594,
0.4696743488,
0.9345587492,
-0.1334572136,
0.8883215189,
-0.109954223,
0.0753348023,
1.1536755562,
-0.3905647397,
1.0023819208,
0.4083158374,
0.0863931328,
0.5297482014,
0.412139535,
0.004110679,
0.7332701683,
0.2023432404,
-0.4279532731,
-0.2435787022,
0.2200547308,
-0.3931774199,
0.2541143894,
0.6509805322,
-0.2922908962,
-0.0131990081,
0.0687414855,
0.1565770954,
0.0756765977,
-0.4006701708,
0.6809745431,
0.050898768,
-0.4769699574,
0.0478742905,
0.275854975,
1.2555708885,
-0.6432341933,
0.0517581776,
0.0018105332,
0.6337213516,
-0.2167732865,
-0.9835796356,
0.3439195454,
0.0709577501,
-0.5136139989,
-0.3331450522,
1.0063840151,
-0.6389479637,
-0.4534817934,
0.6670842767,
0.0805881619,
-0.139258787,
-0.2479916215,
-0.6299663782,
0.1744071841,
-0.2910028398,
-0.3481711447,
0.5089403391,
0.7107883692,
0.1361988485,
0.5869554877,
0.6693934202,
0.2109624892,
0.1583857834,
-0.1390677989,
1.1040290594,
-0.8274209499,
-0.443431139,
-0.6825873256,
0.5627562404,
-0.4933651686,
-0.3618826568,
0.6554839611,
0.4066937864,
0.679790318,
-0.0942523181,
0.7804540396,
0.0015526327,
0.7774879336,
-0.3753235638,
1.2176191807,
-0.6173298359,
0.0847182125,
-0.0428041816,
-0.6521731019,
-0.4928277731,
1.0987329483,
-0.2147153318,
0.1815231442,
0.9354094863,
0.5253507495,
-0.2415147871,
0.1061086357,
0.2564103305,
0.1773623526,
-0.0341105573,
-0.0233906172,
1.012234211,
-0.2789697051,
0.2779509425,
-0.3636268973,
-0.2179440707,
-0.1743232012,
-0.7629070282,
-1.1991701126,
-0.6463162899,
-0.2168686241,
-0.449947238,
0.0223033968,
1.0351264477,
0.6693328023,
-0.9279299974,
-0.5567448735,
0.1431916207,
0.1788265556,
-0.0254754424,
-0.2287418991,
0.2456093729,
-1.03690207,
-0.6074565649,
0.4245224893,
0.4822392464,
-0.1434838325,
-0.2654739022,
0.1036375463,
-0.2624863684,
0.0163309388,
0.7749759555,
-0.0605131052,
-0.5510491729,
0.1133409217,
0.1191509441,
-0.4958652854,
0.0188815109,
0.9258473516,
-0.3828753233,
0.1444956064,
0.5484811664,
1.0288319588,
0.3892560005,
-0.5455205441,
0.4417360425,
-0.5811156631,
0.2197354734,
0.437018007,
0.1508591473,
0.3049893379,
-0.4720015824,
0.2287114859,
-0.1161107942,
-0.5837539434,
-1.0670180321,
-0.1251177043,
-1.1980394125,
-0.6053559184,
1.2511792183,
0.0967617109,
-0.567692101,
0.0555135123,
-0.1685481668,
0.055792015,
-0.2654642165,
0.7602063417,
0.7349591255,
0.0613464229,
-0.4733929634,
-0.5308323503,
0.4449509978,
0.4854211807,
-0.8717728257,
0.0627287403,
0.4366044402,
0.0460174605,
0.4182160497,
0.4710712135,
-0.161566183,
0.1373498589,
-0.2407544106,
0.5195451379,
0.0827475861,
-0.8233997226,
-0.6083871126,
0.2944507897,
-0.0389688537,
0.1115410179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15964v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15964v3
|
Efficient Pre-training for Localized Instruction Generation of Videos
| 2023-11-27T16:07:37 | 2024-05-23T13:24:33 |
Anil Batra, Davide Moltisanti, Laura Sevilla-Lara, Marcus Rohrbach, Frank Keller
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Procedural videos, exemplified by recipe demonstrations, are instrumental in
conveying step-by-step instructions. However, understanding such videos is
challenging as it involves the precise localization of steps and the generation
of textual instructions. Manually annotating steps and writing instructions is
costly, which limits the size of current datasets and hinders effective
learning. Leveraging large but noisy video-transcript datasets for pre-training
can boost performance but demands significant computational resources.
Furthermore, transcripts contain irrelevant content and differ in style from
human-written instructions. To mitigate these issues, we propose a novel
technique, Sieve-&-Swap, to automatically generate high quality training data
for the recipe domain: (i) Sieve filters irrelevant transcripts and (ii) Swap
acquires high quality text by replacing transcripts with human-written
instruction from a text-only recipe dataset. The resulting dataset is three
orders of magnitude smaller than current web-scale datasets but enables
efficient training of large-scale models. Alongside Sieve-&-Swap, we propose
Procedure Transformer (ProcX), a model for end-to-end step localization and
instruction generation for procedural videos. When pre-trained on our curated
dataset, this model achieves state-of-the-art performance on YouCook2 and Tasty
while using a fraction of the training data. Our code and dataset will be
publicly released.
|
[
-0.0892655328,
-0.6850166917,
0.2881186008,
0.0310786795,
-0.3438933194,
-0.1195673868,
-0.1202311516,
0.2231686413,
0.3563717902,
0.886100769,
-0.8336890936,
-0.6194207072,
-0.7123373151,
-0.2703690529,
-0.6452649832,
0.8303628564,
-0.1518384367,
0.2771801949,
-0.1896387786,
0.1522101015,
-0.3292351365,
-0.4328229129,
-0.3922216296,
-0.0282090977,
0.0017751846,
0.5963254571,
0.5027732849,
0.8826428056,
0.2972404361,
0.3916157782,
0.4142142236,
0.228180334,
-0.6290326118,
0.2817837596,
-0.0980961248,
-0.3255331516,
-0.2104364634,
-0.0242720377,
0.3652653396,
0.5557122231,
-0.1321739554,
0.4416472018,
-0.1616685241,
0.4670804739,
-0.7025634646,
0.1058382392,
-0.7492537498,
0.3312221766,
-0.2955811918,
-0.5236493945,
-0.5133139491,
-0.6188755631,
-0.0401550494,
-0.8101655841,
0.6285020709,
-0.5721895099,
0.4716178477,
0.5592460036,
-0.1753018349,
-0.0979218557,
-0.7330799699,
0.5771714449,
-0.667863965,
0.2734111249,
0.4243007004,
0.5126721263,
-0.2836286128,
-1.0729422569,
-0.3659119606,
0.2231316268,
0.1303795427,
0.2014723718,
0.1625473797,
-0.2776772678,
0.3114307225,
0.1520841122,
-0.600527823,
0.0548722185,
-0.3744454682,
-0.3466174901,
0.3464736044,
0.2068292797,
0.2616004348,
0.1057601646,
-0.0936604962,
-0.4945240021,
-0.5597445369,
0.1701857895,
0.3687625229,
0.1607102007,
0.1207724884,
0.4061737955,
-0.1919678301,
0.5169562101,
0.2877557576,
-0.3618418574,
0.3363045156,
-0.2033753991,
-0.3553125858,
0.3031870723,
0.7820760012,
0.2580563128,
0.0639705732,
0.0738232732,
0.0925140902,
0.0065806294,
0.533675313,
-1.2907162905,
-0.3754192889,
-0.0944972709,
-0.1936949641,
-0.1564610153,
0.3258199692,
-0.6617024541,
-0.2326944768,
-0.4796592295,
0.414317131,
-0.2393600941,
0.0074862996,
0.026453888,
-0.1169104651,
0.1718876362,
0.3050476611,
-1.0509690046,
0.4283697307,
0.5259389281,
0.6264571548,
-0.0287464615,
-0.3478896022,
-1.2565939426,
0.2281016558,
-0.4184603095,
0.772937417,
-0.6106815934,
-0.3779602051,
-0.0405214168,
0.304757297,
-0.1233701855,
-0.678193748,
0.1403903365,
-0.2408523262,
0.0564894639,
-0.1559268981,
-0.4494942129,
0.1009596288,
-0.2443400174,
-0.5546702147,
0.9481322169,
0.1857559234,
-0.3803746998,
0.4361565709,
-0.2612454891,
-0.8072546124,
-0.0283462238,
-0.4977441132,
-0.4551020265,
0.0358106568,
0.4911423922,
0.4918478131,
-0.2053590268,
0.1746672392,
0.2416827381,
-0.5145022273,
-0.0811797753,
-0.6109959483,
0.322122097,
0.037312381,
-0.6344307065,
0.2282660753,
-0.7148685455,
0.0860023871,
-0.0674716011,
0.0832694173,
0.0651870146,
-0.1692050695,
-0.363273859,
0.1371153593,
-0.0608651191,
-0.1154854819,
0.3863923252,
-0.2961706817,
0.5285479426,
0.8037225604,
0.118987225,
0.8707793951,
-0.0035792273,
0.8398907781,
0.0763344541,
0.4298487306,
-0.7412618399,
-0.3030332923,
-0.4558959901,
-0.312939465,
0.1947425753,
0.5748159885,
-0.7636734843,
0.1769671142,
-0.1492653787,
-0.5589976311,
-0.5094209313,
0.2594150007,
0.3845420778,
0.7695447803,
0.5619717836,
-0.4280979931,
-0.3494722545,
-0.5813066363,
0.1555680782,
0.4988606572,
-0.2652612329,
-0.0453791991,
0.3366467059,
-0.1055866182,
0.7140251994,
-0.6078837514,
-0.1552081257,
-0.0112426477,
0.4939825833,
0.1759587824,
0.4375878572,
0.217098698,
-0.6947833896,
-0.7631003261,
-0.0417712741,
-0.5371544957,
-0.0738846362,
-0.5417833924,
-0.2439278215,
-0.0392244421,
0.6656044722,
-0.3743370175,
0.6066394448,
0.4256458282,
0.1693159938,
0.5266996026,
-0.4205068648,
0.5873810053,
-1.0345232487,
-0.4912275076,
-0.1905015558,
-0.1072033271,
-0.4821914434,
-0.3212435246,
0.0736038163,
-0.1691823155,
-0.9711931348,
0.4993779361,
-0.3941686451,
-0.1410787553,
0.0986453965,
-0.2378326952,
0.0251486134,
0.5011412501,
0.4257654846,
0.9910963774,
0.6035785675,
-0.641936183,
0.203874737,
0.1964050084,
-0.3087261617,
0.4184281528,
-0.3500396609,
0.1268169284,
0.109254241,
0.1801185608,
-0.6327880025,
-0.5026895404,
0.2996743917,
-0.3741113544,
0.3619510531,
-0.5629553795,
-0.2871837318,
-0.2469304502,
-0.3698858917,
0.1215980053,
0.6896671653,
-0.6496838331,
0.5363397598,
0.1807005405,
-0.1474498063,
-0.4931276441,
-0.3774242103,
-0.2817315757,
-0.1217423752,
-0.5098423958,
0.4929193258,
-0.1366278082,
0.2762293816,
-0.2939676344,
-0.5016552806,
-0.4345296025,
-0.337756604,
0.5268095136,
-0.0568868555,
-0.1113329753,
-0.232120946,
0.4178822637,
-0.2608539164,
0.0235282388,
-0.5526217818,
0.544403255,
0.236232549,
-0.3824999332,
-0.7769159079,
0.2838103771,
0.5188138485,
-0.3526605964,
0.5299568772,
0.8874989152,
-0.2066184133,
-0.3162540495,
-0.4148786068,
-0.4982995689,
-0.5268782377,
0.4502394795,
-0.2160634995,
-0.3681911826,
0.1983179748,
-0.3147293031,
0.064853318,
-0.090701066,
0.492778033,
-0.2830452919,
0.8594824672,
0.1032393351,
0.3422011435,
0.5424701571,
-0.5920908451,
0.2003106475,
-0.3134232461,
-0.2175685018,
-0.4401139915,
-0.1130271032,
-0.284183383,
-0.8605204821,
0.4328048527,
0.0317404903,
-0.5477269888,
0.4587412477,
-0.5313108563,
0.9294865727,
0.7309907079,
0.1490038484,
-0.1237551942,
0.4628475904,
-0.0292037148,
-0.4684345126,
-0.6306852698,
-0.5488420129,
0.8456240892,
-0.0685365573,
0.8905531764,
-0.3785503805,
0.9708726406,
0.4115881622,
-0.2585209012,
-0.5948040485,
0.6746184826,
-0.4152864218,
0.3242610097,
-0.5159026384,
-0.4229286611,
-0.7856122255,
-0.1515300572,
-0.0935152918,
-0.471195966,
-0.2756548822,
0.4177577198,
-0.2758275867,
0.4865031838,
-0.9467605352,
1.1617683172,
-0.4096375108,
-0.5846146345,
0.1243404448,
-0.7255086899,
-0.0344393626,
-0.0413226895,
0.2001782209,
0.3935941458,
0.3826376796,
0.5359380841,
-0.9962206483,
0.8448818326,
-0.2635130584,
0.0469746701,
0.4481540322,
0.5900257826,
0.5709734559,
0.051386524,
0.1856384724,
0.0683588088,
-0.149145335,
-0.2564216852,
-0.9797106981,
0.5014452338,
-0.6329929829,
-0.4366557598,
-0.1734200716,
-0.1179954261,
0.0791815892,
0.1180993766,
0.5201290846,
0.6577721834,
0.1415169686,
0.1520520598,
0.9011672735,
-0.2372807264,
0.1631511003,
0.1963077039,
0.3091474771,
-0.4620449245,
1.2538509369,
0.1341855824,
0.2231885493,
0.6115802526,
0.1941528767,
-0.0268874243,
-0.2655741274,
-0.6305319071,
-0.0960756466,
-0.6119884849,
-0.274733603,
-0.4029969871,
-0.2978766263,
-0.5406504273,
-0.6545807123,
-0.7735411525,
-0.3555788994,
-0.44504866,
-0.0803051889,
0.1636260301,
0.4093728364,
0.0402775481,
0.6097856164,
-0.9021068215,
0.4330965579,
0.4556087255,
0.0483643971,
-0.2122491002,
-0.6587823033,
-0.3179955781,
0.1357067674,
-0.3424952626,
-0.9154067039,
0.6688773632,
0.048400674,
0.4387644231,
0.5225542784,
-0.0725862384,
1.0680756569,
-0.8161640763,
0.9745051265,
0.3217079937,
-0.9110108614,
0.8876144886,
-0.0508947633,
0.450728029,
0.5368278027,
0.7529227734,
-0.2498435527,
-0.2281855345,
-0.4916981757,
-1.170296669,
0.8360251784,
0.0860625729,
0.2440996766,
-0.1883370131,
0.3041812479,
0.5857830644,
0.2199453861,
-0.2904990315,
0.030165581,
-0.6761331558,
-0.124513559,
0.2850397527,
0.0775307268,
0.1435689479,
-0.4143269956,
0.8427371979,
-0.2061918974,
0.1144826934,
-0.0887426734,
-0.4303918481,
-0.0652928054,
0.0726679564,
0.5180425644,
0.6156277061,
-0.0995225534,
0.0277680885,
-0.0126900161,
-0.7936106324,
0.2671373487,
-0.3194329739,
-0.2559039295,
-0.1165605634,
0.5028965473,
0.7758777142,
0.4724506438,
-0.6935681701,
0.5683302879,
-0.2076435983,
-0.3149371147,
-0.4085239172,
0.4104064405,
-0.0934764892,
0.1048933268,
0.032183513,
0.0818286836,
0.1218742505,
-0.3780120313,
0.3494005501,
-0.1405514628,
-0.0966895148,
-0.3324589431,
0.6273229122,
0.0825146735,
-0.4982513487,
1.0600609779,
-0.2993493676,
-0.3267607093,
0.6858503222,
0.4815645814,
0.6502929926,
-0.3216445148,
0.8512181044,
0.6955755353,
-0.0781275854,
-0.2591246665,
-0.1064050049,
-0.399289012,
-0.2515604198,
-0.3513280451,
-0.6044898629,
-0.3539820313,
0.1440418661,
-0.8037692904,
0.41914469,
-0.2273253351,
0.0636419281,
-0.2083667517,
-0.4030110836,
-0.757560432,
0.0800923109,
-0.0653335303,
0.5606114268,
-0.9017794132,
0.7539544702,
0.437533915,
-0.5129368305,
-0.7552466393,
-0.0815797523,
-0.0669765025,
-0.4936651587,
0.7753901482,
0.2347475886,
-0.0504402742,
-0.2833988667,
-0.4554081559,
-0.4760197401,
1.1414232254,
0.5877739787,
-0.7499549985,
-0.3302550912,
0.4168814719,
0.3165281713,
-0.2845420539,
0.581146419,
0.6115886569,
0.1836189032,
0.6829932928,
-0.5816376805,
-0.4163457751,
-0.1804244518,
-0.1158494204,
0.1805846095,
-0.331251055,
0.673294127,
-0.1875121295,
0.0614010468,
-0.1474957168,
0.5016694665,
-0.1176855713,
0.2000723183,
0.2709038258,
0.423334837,
0.7299035192,
-0.0016916549,
0.7728507519,
0.04994018,
-0.1923391223,
1.8041576147,
-0.3027787507,
0.6563184261,
0.335454762,
-0.0175472125,
0.3378981948,
0.7382794619,
-0.0489200354,
0.7124207616,
0.2597087622,
-0.1238419488,
-0.3952964842,
0.2028643191,
-0.2032037973,
0.4734353125,
0.2418390512,
-0.3266141117,
-0.2766914666,
-0.0011557798,
0.0672748014,
0.3548638523,
-0.2982470393,
0.8164986968,
-0.4036468565,
-0.6169074178,
0.4653985202,
-0.329397589,
0.2294604182,
-0.8650003672,
-0.5156257153,
-0.3941959441,
-0.0145458905,
-0.2299000472,
-0.5226465464,
0.1802550703,
0.1298680454,
-0.2096826732,
-0.5685715675,
0.2177331597,
-0.3423955441,
-0.4719753563,
-0.0294731073,
0.20111835,
0.4001805186,
-0.0356346071,
-0.42825827,
-0.0512685664,
-0.0469784401,
-0.2491713762,
0.5050703287,
0.5355270505,
-0.3521856666,
0.3549591005,
0.615852952,
0.1745341271,
0.3712156713,
0.5085585117,
0.8105604649,
-0.3236825764,
-0.4629758596,
-0.56858325,
0.6420749426,
-0.0545539111,
0.0225443225,
0.4138543904,
0.6184741259,
1.2295818329,
-0.476906538,
0.5271651149,
0.1930325031,
0.0379554816,
-0.7901250124,
0.4249408543,
-0.2354561538,
0.1659582406,
-0.2509177923,
-0.8448536396,
-0.0435121395,
0.8203952909,
-0.3753392398,
-0.0998847932,
0.6961504817,
1.0292698145,
-0.3960539401,
-0.0404190496,
0.305057615,
0.1733157337,
0.3375616968,
0.2515529692,
0.5053528547,
-0.4067498744,
0.4596019387,
-0.402402401,
-0.2206267118,
0.0194585398,
-0.9964074492,
-0.860714972,
-0.6334062219,
-0.3895326853,
-0.0061128242,
0.1042123213,
1.0406446457,
1.1648921967,
-0.6169781089,
-0.3464883566,
-0.1836898774,
-0.1598611325,
-0.4724846482,
-0.2092533708,
0.4333233535,
-0.3845102489,
-0.6684827209,
0.4985945821,
0.251063168,
-0.0705631599,
-0.02342158,
-0.1678561866,
0.1312570572,
0.0576632023,
0.6193130016,
0.3158592582,
-0.377259165,
0.1634227633,
0.1339434534,
0.3857192099,
0.2381830215,
1.1445550919,
-0.8031369448,
0.7658260465,
0.2717365324,
0.6324836612,
0.9983742833,
-0.0995328277,
0.3559447527,
-0.9046570659,
0.2566928566,
0.0600105114,
0.1612436473,
0.1504651904,
-0.5159838796,
0.62003088,
-0.0432495922,
-0.395149976,
-0.5427126288,
0.1178256199,
-0.8206000328,
-0.0708105713,
0.7447448969,
-0.1702512354,
-0.3472557664,
0.4610191584,
-0.3095653057,
0.4923841059,
-0.38550964,
0.7555319667,
0.214705348,
-0.1641695648,
-0.0578685142,
-0.5954182744,
0.4900384247,
-0.0367711112,
-0.8787372708,
0.019897081,
0.4648962915,
0.2820980847,
-0.1112893149,
0.7227345109,
-0.170374155,
0.5250875354,
0.0393731408,
-0.023986524,
-0.3365572691,
-0.9007914662,
0.0797841176,
0.0865327567,
-0.4596171379,
-0.1333987266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15954v1
|
A Quantitative Approach to Understand Self-Supervised Models as Cross-lingual Feature Extractors
| 2023-11-27T15:58:28 | 2023-11-27T15:58:28 |
Shuyue Stella Li, Beining Xu, Xiangyu Zhang, Hexin Liu, Wenhan Chao, Leibny Paola Garcia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
In this work, we study the features extracted by English self-supervised
learning (SSL) models in cross-lingual contexts and propose a new metric to
predict the quality of feature representations. Using automatic speech
recognition (ASR) as a downstream task, we analyze the effect of model size,
training objectives, and model architecture on the models' performance as a
feature extractor for a set of topologically diverse corpora. We develop a
novel metric, the Phonetic-Syntax Ratio (PSR), to measure the phonetic and
synthetic information in the extracted representations using deep generalized
canonical correlation analysis. Results show the contrastive loss in the
wav2vec2.0 objective facilitates more effective cross-lingual feature
extraction. There is a positive correlation between PSR scores and ASR
performance, suggesting that phonetic information extracted by monolingual SSL
models can be used for downstream tasks in cross-lingual settings. The proposed
metric is an effective indicator of the quality of the representations and can
be useful for model selection.
|
[
-0.3846006095,
-0.2021708488,
0.1504376233,
0.2977131307,
-0.1435761005,
0.1468662769,
-0.2568440437,
-0.4139151871,
0.3729356229,
0.2656558752,
-0.1052933335,
-0.3933924139,
-0.6026514769,
0.1358386874,
-0.5023086667,
0.7214090228,
0.0812800601,
0.4938038886,
-0.1040569991,
-0.0935007259,
-0.3732281625,
-0.7798146009,
-0.4881839752,
-0.0350584872,
0.4805370569,
0.0652067736,
0.4617664516,
0.6734859943,
0.5772957802,
0.3321036398,
0.09839724,
-0.1938926578,
-0.1911321282,
-0.0768060237,
-0.3256212175,
-0.3575105965,
-0.3340564966,
0.2041136324,
0.8454794884,
0.768784821,
-0.078421995,
0.3755480945,
0.402856946,
0.3640365303,
-0.3043263853,
0.2726236284,
-0.4948660433,
0.2856994867,
-0.1705328971,
-0.2614158392,
-0.1317589581,
-0.0727423429,
0.343288064,
-0.7084267735,
0.3826165795,
0.0088351266,
0.8901832104,
0.2189270556,
-0.2342820168,
-0.4772999883,
-0.7017069459,
0.9047567248,
-0.5360798836,
0.8907213807,
0.1863799393,
0.5186624527,
0.3715464175,
-0.6701670289,
-0.224635765,
-0.045779828,
-0.5193477273,
0.1982931048,
-0.2154504508,
-0.3931766152,
-0.1590901315,
0.4738875628,
-0.7008792162,
0.1469670087,
-0.7995579839,
-0.4586428404,
0.8720706105,
0.0082491897,
0.4678004682,
-0.3576232195,
-0.2925826013,
-0.1344182342,
-0.4223348498,
0.2982356846,
0.3482500017,
0.5949142575,
-0.2762283385,
0.3894091249,
0.0368119739,
0.1360978335,
0.1794469208,
-0.211760819,
0.3601535261,
-0.485637188,
-0.0583980158,
0.1317886859,
1.1267820597,
-0.2646147311,
0.5148503184,
-0.3980398178,
-0.2569796443,
-0.0312952511,
0.2121389061,
-0.5971791148,
-0.5007591844,
-0.0843017772,
-0.5521590114,
-0.1281715184,
0.1141857728,
-0.542193532,
0.3308405578,
-0.5368079543,
0.3190341294,
-0.6114561558,
-0.568048358,
-0.1757106632,
-0.2254483104,
0.2081993818,
0.0703692362,
-0.842369318,
0.5275530815,
0.5949696898,
0.7206971049,
-0.460809052,
-0.3614874482,
-0.4365358651,
0.0152096329,
-0.4951406717,
0.3402601779,
-0.4472492337,
-0.4609800577,
-0.1245542765,
0.1832719445,
-0.2604772151,
-0.611019671,
0.1545992941,
-0.3758949339,
0.3679513335,
-0.1670414805,
-0.5425482392,
-0.1809489578,
-0.1751104146,
-0.8683950901,
1.031699419,
0.0801672414,
-0.7183358669,
0.4589972198,
-0.2454990894,
-0.5473020673,
0.2345549464,
-0.4817002118,
-0.223967731,
0.0875245705,
0.351642549,
0.5274516344,
-0.2579655051,
0.3155517876,
-0.3088989556,
-0.1530778855,
0.3038616478,
-0.3051012456,
0.8521628976,
0.2794928849,
-0.0645337552,
0.0031198866,
-0.8791213632,
0.0214796886,
-0.0175203737,
-0.2611845136,
-0.5727214813,
-0.1829534471,
0.0989535004,
0.2911100686,
0.4295361936,
-0.5695495009,
-0.4875415564,
-0.1703400016,
0.2748386562,
0.418551892,
-0.2445911914,
0.6377441287,
0.1328477412,
0.6996232867,
0.0116880937,
-0.1136079207,
0.1535380483,
-0.1474253982,
-0.468845576,
-0.7897790074,
0.691750586,
0.522980392,
-0.3104221821,
0.6319850683,
-0.4379586279,
-0.4520023763,
-0.885217905,
0.47757864,
0.7076340914,
0.3119578362,
0.3213367164,
-0.5104209781,
-0.4045942128,
-0.8156708479,
-0.1783361435,
-0.3224589527,
-0.3615785837,
0.203747943,
0.2331550717,
0.2010086477,
1.0223591328,
0.0101528671,
-0.5309607983,
-0.3720397353,
0.304975003,
-0.162250787,
0.4703564644,
0.5155169368,
-0.7308800817,
-0.6142362356,
0.2305122167,
-1.070874691,
-0.2774867415,
0.1030768976,
0.102125749,
0.1106437966,
0.6049373746,
-0.2877963781,
0.0687036365,
0.5613151789,
-0.0308180377,
0.5218429565,
-0.0923762321,
0.0568581484,
-0.7490149736,
0.1153214425,
0.3472377956,
-0.056891799,
-0.4145622849,
0.0808505341,
0.264192313,
-0.169863224,
-0.3962207437,
0.5762854815,
-0.6481311321,
-0.5432449579,
0.2847878337,
0.3313366473,
0.1408059746,
0.3846470416,
0.4839064181,
0.7937754393,
0.6316773891,
-0.4279162586,
0.031823907,
0.0583823584,
-0.0590305887,
0.367267549,
-0.8652831316,
-0.1462282389,
0.1289964765,
-0.194335714,
-1.1802018881,
-0.0428169705,
-0.1410078704,
-0.7291423678,
0.5170387626,
-0.3176507354,
-0.3561575711,
-0.2060841173,
0.0708207488,
0.3811838031,
0.554035902,
-0.5005412698,
0.6487793326,
0.5807628632,
-0.3200750947,
-0.1498218775,
-0.7568508983,
-0.3341748118,
-0.4556078911,
-0.6306492686,
0.288449496,
0.3200814128,
-0.0746925697,
0.090782173,
-0.0353007726,
-0.0492171794,
-0.0982265249,
0.157957986,
0.183659479,
-0.5909220576,
0.0690843835,
0.0777970105,
-0.1970374882,
0.4091731608,
-0.2272040695,
0.3467161953,
-0.0797575563,
-0.2147715688,
-0.4946351051,
0.3067066073,
0.264392823,
-0.6981337667,
0.1924734712,
0.8422105312,
-0.1076638624,
-0.0077451649,
-0.469247818,
-0.1272501349,
-0.4670239091,
0.4243100584,
-0.874741137,
-0.7679204345,
0.8085015416,
0.1467586607,
-0.4325875342,
0.6745597124,
0.2759667933,
-0.1468494833,
0.9284290075,
0.6124078035,
-0.2577393055,
0.2917106152,
-0.3173084259,
0.2016940415,
-0.8252292871,
-0.2366577983,
-0.2919816971,
0.0473571867,
-0.7936780453,
-0.2764054835,
0.3319469094,
0.3290145695,
-0.0537023544,
0.520387888,
-0.421901077,
-0.0984612852,
0.5658931136,
-0.1729859561,
0.004701504,
0.1540993899,
-0.2357710153,
-0.3201010823,
-0.5965068936,
-0.3494212329,
0.8621582389,
0.6420372725,
0.7548085451,
0.0574522987,
0.8737891316,
0.1265168041,
-0.2320695817,
-0.638209343,
0.4371532798,
-0.5488015413,
-0.4395467937,
-0.6342042089,
-0.623334229,
-0.7488720417,
0.3870827556,
0.1027747691,
-0.5074596405,
0.3146394491,
0.0267604608,
-0.4253742397,
-0.0910418779,
-0.5988750458,
1.1176279783,
-0.5171667337,
-0.0234257784,
-0.1769198328,
-0.5388098359,
0.0184713192,
-0.2619875073,
0.2113439441,
-0.1464163661,
0.0017395486,
0.794934392,
-0.1143521294,
0.7896985412,
-0.0836845115,
-0.1171751469,
0.1896871328,
0.3532165587,
-0.0158259999,
-0.1825338304,
-0.0828840584,
0.7550597787,
0.1198014393,
-0.0984632373,
-0.7428643107,
0.5063083172,
-0.953145504,
-0.3974328041,
-0.1291497797,
-0.3491273224,
-0.1029772833,
-0.123091571,
0.3417463899,
0.5669581294,
-0.2503260672,
0.0476553403,
0.1220159978,
-0.2694872618,
0.3732012212,
0.5811067224,
-0.2011296898,
-0.4476023316,
1.1358436346,
0.5006363392,
0.4386059344,
0.4760112464,
0.3239191473,
-0.5319568515,
-0.4248854816,
-0.4534445405,
0.1955548525,
-0.7129044533,
0.0888886452,
-0.6965740919,
-0.6389375925,
-0.6991477609,
0.0488148071,
-0.4565586746,
-0.544996798,
-0.4567573667,
0.0255732201,
0.1527501643,
0.5091157556,
-0.3761609793,
0.1703376919,
-0.5695018768,
0.2765321732,
0.3313929439,
-0.0521059297,
-0.1363808513,
-1.0414972305,
-0.3244725168,
-0.2497409731,
0.2159352303,
-0.4657638967,
0.9657745361,
0.3417349458,
0.7036647201,
0.2393772602,
-0.1560868323,
0.7200058103,
-0.5726123452,
0.7098479867,
0.1833542883,
-0.8583425879,
0.5743581057,
-0.0850612149,
0.0954691991,
0.1936290413,
0.7428411245,
-0.2325267345,
-0.6361775398,
-0.3707440197,
-0.5980375409,
0.3666449189,
0.0689196885,
-0.0455746725,
-0.0662002563,
-0.010960266,
0.2359141409,
-0.0377979539,
-0.6462863684,
-0.1437923312,
-0.4808517098,
-0.2967829406,
-0.1684185117,
-0.2126648426,
0.2244546264,
-0.3306392133,
0.4363090694,
-0.094959259,
0.0128545696,
0.2128790766,
-0.2950273156,
0.0303233266,
0.190699175,
-0.1442696601,
0.5633959174,
-0.1076378897,
0.2231087238,
0.0994613245,
-0.1708185524,
-0.0794395953,
0.3365405202,
0.0645053536,
0.1676470786,
0.5484660268,
0.4739395976,
0.3683981299,
-0.2253561765,
0.4556594491,
-0.0123986602,
0.1515768319,
-0.4605943561,
-0.0902659222,
-0.1809226573,
0.246433109,
0.3758840561,
-0.3134964406,
0.6071813703,
-0.5038295984,
0.5029011965,
0.4720103145,
-0.5985305309,
-0.5314827561,
0.5448614955,
0.1463264376,
-0.1269640923,
0.3929581046,
-0.3559374809,
-0.6558192372,
0.5619215965,
0.604124248,
0.9046618938,
-0.4715439379,
0.1771759838,
0.6187539697,
0.1071589887,
0.1921997815,
0.0873123854,
-0.049709212,
-0.608456254,
-0.3682729602,
-0.8723775148,
0.0224141032,
-0.1971193552,
-0.9463029504,
0.2905100286,
-0.184843272,
0.0995083749,
0.4495258033,
-0.0304540172,
-0.7548068762,
0.3936614096,
0.2743543386,
0.5047388077,
-0.8523867726,
1.1334404945,
0.2262646556,
-0.576226294,
-1.1791694164,
-0.2016430199,
0.124015592,
-0.7807948589,
1.228525281,
0.0260780528,
-0.2456756234,
-0.2860121727,
0.1586343348,
-1.1375240088,
0.8989886045,
0.3334890306,
-0.7239667773,
-0.1321504116,
0.5161705017,
0.7743381262,
-0.6813542247,
0.2481736243,
0.5095414519,
-0.0281274095,
-0.0341869965,
-1.2960721254,
0.016679531,
-0.418261379,
0.2156914175,
-0.0492042676,
-0.3751968145,
0.9283097982,
0.0337828919,
-0.3670423329,
-0.0537995622,
0.8136308789,
0.0615804158,
0.0350871347,
0.4461041391,
0.2280651778,
0.5772568583,
0.1530615538,
1.0530309677,
-0.5857165456,
0.2700200975,
1.1222531796,
-0.1871429086,
1.0389789343,
0.3529219627,
-0.1266972423,
0.4146502614,
0.5872833729,
-0.1440552771,
0.6885375381,
0.1413425356,
0.2479439229,
-0.2757064998,
0.0310888644,
-0.2708100677,
0.7435524464,
0.3362129629,
-0.5537137389,
0.1705084741,
0.0273461808,
-0.3758543134,
0.0057097911,
-0.2449734658,
0.8497220278,
0.3623369634,
-0.4528619349,
0.5393702388,
-0.2657724321,
0.592433691,
-0.4550026655,
0.0879588351,
-0.1837765872,
0.1267843843,
-0.1064301133,
-0.7784796357,
0.3607755899,
-0.1971442103,
-0.2690576315,
-0.0958028436,
0.547198236,
-0.8359856009,
-0.8039535284,
0.9284199476,
0.5407863259,
0.3749273419,
-0.0070423069,
-0.6990060806,
-0.0049205078,
-0.2314814031,
0.101945132,
0.2335464954,
0.9470897317,
-0.0539344214,
0.5304528475,
0.4314821959,
0.4236116707,
0.2562458217,
0.3663507998,
0.4880466461,
-0.6449456811,
-0.659855485,
-0.7479444146,
0.4200596809,
-0.1062485278,
-0.2072996497,
0.9586737156,
0.7100132108,
1.1293398142,
-0.0136520267,
0.7358781099,
0.1532458663,
0.7699276805,
-0.4548664093,
0.6517493129,
-0.6314221621,
0.3002708852,
-0.2241489589,
-0.6099493504,
0.0905416012,
0.625993073,
-0.3547484279,
-0.0726893023,
0.5030031204,
0.8132187128,
-0.4627009928,
-0.1678281575,
0.5501179695,
-0.0765670016,
0.0662289411,
0.0873345956,
0.782808125,
-0.491773963,
0.6339716315,
-0.3837106228,
0.0387052111,
0.1115246043,
-0.3665311337,
-0.9058754444,
-0.7329615355,
-0.5124902725,
-0.0358665995,
0.0665928647,
0.6213982105,
0.9319161177,
-0.9512092471,
-0.5603116155,
0.3231131732,
-0.1789482087,
-0.170384407,
-0.285600841,
0.5399866104,
-0.6991125345,
-0.5067184567,
0.3626255691,
0.1704406738,
-0.1617880017,
-0.6482550502,
-0.2848481536,
0.1997081786,
-0.0404337309,
0.5183189511,
0.1763005257,
-0.9957863092,
-0.2463134527,
0.0544674098,
-0.3515592515,
0.1647138447,
0.6968332529,
-0.6515013576,
0.359536171,
0.2600962222,
0.4866762161,
0.5201334953,
-0.2278008759,
0.8060275316,
-0.9537755251,
0.0021044626,
-0.0099423779,
0.5441371799,
0.5651651025,
-0.3105244935,
0.7192142606,
0.1267797649,
-0.2898958623,
-0.5967610478,
-0.13281326,
-0.8392528296,
-0.1801915616,
1.2136620283,
-0.5109148026,
-0.214804396,
0.0238118898,
0.1875434965,
0.2396986485,
-0.3773608208,
0.5986529589,
0.4721682668,
0.0424959883,
-0.3529102802,
-0.4118957818,
0.5071128607,
0.3353587389,
-0.4536846876,
-0.0052492223,
0.2623878717,
0.4867137969,
0.5788244009,
0.3909315765,
-0.4649421275,
0.2194717675,
0.0952824354,
0.1865272075,
0.2544405162,
-0.5346139669,
-0.4364207387,
0.1238271371,
-0.1355701089,
-0.3058721125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15946v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15946v1
|
Leveraging deep active learning to identify low-resource mobility functioning information in public clinical notes
| 2023-11-27T15:53:11 | 2023-11-27T15:53:11 |
Tuan-Dung Le, Zhuqi Miao, Samuel Alvarado, Brittany Smith, William Paiva, Thanh Thieu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Function is increasingly recognized as an important indicator of whole-person
health, although it receives little attention in clinical natural language
processing research. We introduce the first public annotated dataset
specifically on the Mobility domain of the International Classification of
Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF), aiming to facilitate automatic
extraction and analysis of functioning information from free-text clinical
notes. We utilize the National NLP Clinical Challenges (n2c2) research dataset
to construct a pool of candidate sentences using keyword expansion. Our active
learning approach, using query-by-committee sampling weighted by density
representativeness, selects informative sentences for human annotation. We
train BERT and CRF models, and use predictions from these models to guide the
selection of new sentences for subsequent annotation iterations. Our final
dataset consists of 4,265 sentences with a total of 11,784 entities, including
5,511 Action entities, 5,328 Mobility entities, 306 Assistance entities, and
639 Quantification entities. The inter-annotator agreement (IAA), averaged over
all entity types, is 0.72 for exact matching and 0.91 for partial matching. We
also train and evaluate common BERT models and state-of-the-art Nested NER
models. The best F1 scores are 0.84 for Action, 0.7 for Mobility, 0.62 for
Assistance, and 0.71 for Quantification. Empirical results demonstrate
promising potential of NER models to accurately extract mobility functioning
information from clinical text. The public availability of our annotated
dataset will facilitate further research to comprehensively capture functioning
information in electronic health records (EHRs).
|
[
0.128347829,
-0.6668895483,
0.6225715876,
0.2151931822,
-0.356826365,
-0.2810666263,
-0.2906646729,
-0.7665557861,
0.4148158729,
0.5579027534,
-0.3446767628,
-0.5714322925,
-0.5391631126,
0.0933461264,
-0.4333868325,
1.1516555548,
0.0534891859,
0.0340583697,
-0.2523144186,
-0.5384263396,
-0.2749664187,
-0.4980039001,
-0.322116673,
-0.0747263506,
0.6393931508,
0.5864467025,
0.673699379,
0.5487675071,
0.9103748798,
0.1552597433,
-0.1993887573,
0.1603559554,
-0.1165871322,
0.140787065,
0.2791679502,
-0.1074685603,
-0.9481572509,
-0.1644979417,
0.7253586054,
0.8460611701,
-0.0469049998,
0.1812586486,
-0.180383265,
0.4527399838,
-0.6356267929,
0.175771296,
-0.2736606896,
0.1307266504,
-0.4399802387,
0.1809576601,
-0.1394284964,
-0.2885202169,
0.3164297938,
-0.6026919484,
0.2209339291,
-0.3139822781,
1.0759152174,
0.3838400841,
-0.7582895756,
-0.4614072442,
-0.5722489357,
0.247404784,
-0.4733843207,
0.4290715456,
0.7615727186,
0.1053250283,
0.2337833047,
-0.924554944,
-0.5034783483,
-0.4097161889,
-0.255226016,
0.2709040344,
0.1139360666,
0.3796384037,
0.1814502776,
0.4992541969,
-0.3665431142,
0.2227185965,
-0.7118630409,
-0.20909293,
0.8504100442,
0.2515970767,
0.3786942065,
-0.168472901,
-0.1264849156,
0.2117095292,
-0.5263463855,
0.0724886656,
-0.0756914765,
0.4861930907,
-0.4687859714,
0.810254097,
-0.0454082973,
0.5008423924,
-0.3086478412,
-0.1154678166,
0.6237541437,
-0.3342006207,
-0.1997870952,
0.2649025023,
0.7349047065,
0.3181868494,
-0.0202449355,
-0.4086593688,
-0.301504612,
-0.4252101481,
0.3104247451,
-0.7573164105,
-0.3167817295,
0.1062338948,
-0.6887361407,
-0.0347231403,
0.2893252969,
-0.6335858107,
-0.690556407,
-0.2086552233,
-0.0630102232,
-0.3698533773,
-0.3719724417,
0.1175070032,
0.3640912771,
-0.0148756504,
0.2459088415,
-0.8101710081,
0.3250259459,
0.6726564765,
1.0590168238,
-0.1420857459,
0.0775271654,
-0.7362591028,
-0.0610189028,
-0.0098121427,
0.7354694009,
-0.4494770467,
-0.3593096435,
0.2215766013,
0.5454279184,
-0.4006840885,
-0.5298122168,
1.1375550032,
-0.1741863936,
-0.1509979069,
-0.1604956388,
-0.3211553395,
0.0010658741,
0.1486241221,
-1.0831401348,
1.05402565,
0.1699414253,
-0.7803285122,
0.5282053351,
-0.9492841959,
-1.0977715254,
0.1946569681,
0.1370404065,
-0.8289015889,
0.2011247277,
0.0169967897,
0.4292988181,
-0.0878398195,
0.1406944096,
-0.4875458479,
-0.1475069225,
0.207324937,
-0.1718409657,
0.7191641331,
0.0328053273,
-0.0353837982,
0.0337578021,
-0.966799438,
-0.254060775,
-0.2277017832,
-0.6312966347,
-0.4006487429,
0.1706059575,
0.3026319742,
0.2637821138,
0.0836509094,
-0.6801556349,
0.0268302765,
-0.4562506676,
0.3424257636,
0.3227573037,
0.1687562913,
0.4479787946,
-0.1363588721,
0.5695285201,
-0.0193709806,
0.1397966594,
-0.1404505223,
-0.7155836225,
-0.5607019067,
-0.4942089617,
0.4482442141,
0.6751464605,
-0.0916827098,
0.5425029993,
-0.4799639285,
-0.1060338542,
-1.009580493,
-0.0509542935,
0.1803525239,
0.7273800969,
0.6164519191,
-0.0776008144,
-0.24026528,
-0.8119499087,
-0.0450033098,
-0.3257039189,
-0.0110945757,
0.4266708493,
0.4130655527,
-0.2865461111,
0.604390204,
-0.2507384419,
-0.8459294438,
-0.4105992317,
0.1012711599,
-0.2045940459,
0.2681181729,
0.343857348,
-0.9305564165,
-0.3933265805,
0.0683650821,
-0.6773222685,
-0.1021980047,
-0.219781056,
0.0579024516,
-0.1615655273,
0.2003498077,
-0.6543949246,
0.5354567766,
0.308291465,
-0.5924584866,
-0.2586145699,
-0.352637589,
-0.1630137563,
-0.8210189939,
0.5396854877,
0.2995141745,
-0.1986706257,
-0.5176490545,
-0.2160101384,
0.1025524959,
-0.2667843401,
-0.1270129979,
0.5417273045,
-0.5624836683,
0.0715339258,
-0.1443734765,
0.2514644563,
-0.3266252577,
-0.1422713548,
-0.1344748586,
0.3406253457,
0.3548691869,
-0.4426102638,
0.0204311982,
0.3988459706,
-0.3079487383,
0.1017515957,
-0.4951993227,
-0.0138914613,
-0.39995116,
-0.0067984867,
-0.8708891869,
-0.5193165541,
0.1902312338,
-0.2742837071,
0.1957164407,
-0.3664152026,
-0.4717524946,
-0.2651187778,
0.2324233949,
0.0152367195,
0.2408279628,
0.0171109829,
0.4963495433,
0.9886179566,
-0.0302004479,
-0.2252529413,
-0.7666795254,
0.0698253065,
-0.115718171,
-0.6075853109,
0.5526082516,
0.4145905375,
-0.2504248619,
0.1016439423,
-0.0738201365,
-0.500605464,
0.5495347977,
0.5175940394,
0.2626467645,
-0.1468734294,
0.4860799611,
0.0833905861,
-0.0892979726,
0.1405915022,
0.1381567121,
-0.0715811998,
0.0883868933,
-0.2524894774,
-0.6556655169,
0.2798776925,
0.661033988,
-0.5320503116,
0.5579814315,
0.7335205078,
-0.6533302069,
0.2038917542,
-0.1385570168,
-0.0914800614,
-0.3477216065,
0.3891635537,
0.0262825172,
-0.7759929895,
0.5288124681,
0.1535250843,
0.291443944,
0.460655123,
0.3135511279,
0.0120613016,
1.0032145977,
0.7739970088,
0.1943921447,
0.4599348307,
-0.0398004949,
0.3091337085,
-0.8202776313,
-0.4895579815,
-0.2971683145,
-0.4233574271,
-0.5947329998,
-0.4905860424,
0.3727783263,
0.1655187458,
0.1215523109,
-0.0325324088,
-0.5170851946,
0.0367922261,
0.0285870899,
0.4772894084,
-0.0062909168,
-0.1875012666,
-0.0217342619,
-0.0224256814,
-0.2343586832,
-0.5975531936,
1.1854156256,
0.4906372428,
0.4461291432,
0.1695071906,
0.556794405,
0.4653506875,
0.8750566244,
-0.849701941,
0.5222358704,
-0.4884563982,
-0.6236915588,
-0.2361353487,
-0.3195789158,
-1.1691881418,
-0.1206648201,
-0.3358716667,
-0.6790004969,
0.1987335384,
0.1132568568,
-0.7519027591,
0.140023917,
-0.5485925674,
0.906000495,
-0.5885037184,
-0.2207054943,
-0.0592442602,
-0.9889695048,
0.1930893809,
0.0437926911,
0.0498962514,
-0.5429620743,
-0.1298324019,
0.7313107252,
-0.3084189892,
0.7661288977,
-0.3266376853,
0.1977341175,
0.3516350389,
-0.2896983325,
0.3273350596,
0.3314702213,
-0.2687981129,
-0.15582937,
-0.1885069311,
-0.2780946195,
-0.2960767448,
0.6711124182,
-0.5778602362,
-0.1792687327,
-0.4064931273,
-0.029064009,
-0.2976813316,
0.3137200773,
-0.3071463704,
0.4560713768,
-0.2402972281,
0.3111594319,
0.5668014884,
0.0903327838,
0.5629931688,
0.5865473747,
0.2871729434,
-0.5575915575,
0.7161168456,
0.270893544,
-0.1646704823,
0.6554191113,
0.0430475362,
-0.3945925534,
-0.6764303446,
-0.4321711659,
0.3591802418,
-0.5817486048,
-0.1012381464,
-1.0563143492,
-0.0549654961,
-0.3234841526,
0.244803682,
-0.2133692801,
-0.5805079341,
-0.7232099771,
-0.4953885376,
0.2169935405,
0.7491652369,
0.020408541,
0.0820667371,
-0.8529530168,
0.3348553181,
0.0721893609,
0.3385406137,
-0.1436185837,
-0.2790174186,
-0.6573307514,
0.0491194725,
-0.3675560951,
-0.9595646262,
0.1824205369,
0.4038552642,
0.8334876895,
0.5619078875,
0.4579748511,
0.8018928766,
-0.1950137019,
0.8166421056,
0.190621987,
-0.510194838,
0.6311253309,
-0.0515182801,
-0.0912502706,
1.0556151867,
0.3392055631,
-0.3598546684,
-0.0792150721,
-0.536673665,
-1.1787600517,
0.4933584929,
0.1796537638,
0.0331242643,
-0.3920195699,
0.5470710993,
-0.2838867903,
-0.1486335397,
-0.8338366151,
-0.2115648091,
-0.1183641553,
-0.6221192479,
0.1879192293,
-0.1081892624,
-0.1329479665,
-0.3912138939,
0.4680525064,
-0.3258512616,
0.4472703636,
0.7040589452,
-0.2467627227,
-0.1804135442,
-0.0267495736,
0.8433062434,
0.5477933288,
-0.2524537444,
0.1417486817,
0.1323283762,
-0.8297854662,
-0.036501836,
0.4718764424,
-0.0135337673,
0.2758798003,
0.6008213758,
0.8093749285,
0.133723408,
-0.8907653093,
0.9884251952,
-0.1268911362,
-0.0529121608,
-0.6742814779,
0.1115156487,
-0.0299545825,
0.0005014345,
0.2638394535,
-0.0258878525,
0.2069962621,
-0.2964262366,
0.4083249271,
0.2305928618,
-1.3289314508,
-0.823877871,
0.9120023251,
0.4802734256,
-0.5289422274,
0.9521456957,
-0.1986243725,
-0.0523086749,
0.5262494683,
0.2143235803,
1.0638244152,
0.0777029768,
0.1332191676,
0.4143616259,
0.304679662,
-0.1722435504,
0.4461791217,
-0.0245479736,
-0.3519492149,
-0.4433820844,
-0.4122497439,
-0.0380241908,
0.2220170796,
-0.9464246035,
0.5685965419,
-0.2876752317,
-0.4833869934,
0.0363145694,
0.0075892317,
-0.5912403464,
0.3903519809,
0.4242494404,
0.8384020329,
-0.9208353758,
1.0383946896,
1.3240894079,
-0.6602306962,
-0.5118765831,
0.5230343938,
-0.1779089868,
-0.4225865602,
0.6852318048,
0.3961920142,
0.312023133,
-0.3458140194,
-0.2555097044,
-0.6124154925,
1.2447514534,
0.3175934255,
-0.3546931744,
-0.3344846368,
0.1133631989,
0.6967621446,
-0.4222713113,
0.2621790469,
0.2257881016,
0.4070524871,
-0.2184124887,
-1.094188571,
0.2574739158,
-0.3071374893,
-0.5187696815,
0.4264604747,
-0.8277094364,
0.4855828285,
-0.4554588199,
-0.3144695759,
-0.002738032,
0.6036401391,
0.0715722963,
0.6547992229,
0.564468801,
0.5792809129,
1.1464740038,
0.0105385305,
0.799306035,
-0.4721651673,
0.269421041,
0.9177267551,
-0.5277517438,
0.6507111192,
0.2397835553,
0.1710039824,
0.525595367,
0.5276187658,
0.1440538019,
0.7582531571,
0.1205026805,
-0.6268032193,
-0.4163232446,
-0.0215770062,
0.0183535758,
0.3875566721,
0.3942224383,
-0.9132841229,
-0.1283966899,
0.1500962228,
0.1831677556,
-0.1953213215,
-0.0791484416,
0.9402996302,
0.1663663834,
-0.7317227721,
0.2094908804,
0.0621566772,
0.0053880727,
-0.4408340752,
-0.1971320659,
-0.1118182167,
0.1890211999,
-0.2542020679,
-0.8409026861,
0.4000688195,
-0.1765550226,
-0.2232203782,
-0.4101012349,
0.7849538326,
-0.1826763302,
-0.6182278395,
0.2876091301,
0.2524594069,
0.1709073037,
0.1932574213,
-0.7027766109,
-0.2756317854,
0.016318012,
-0.1352146715,
0.4453796446,
0.9009753466,
-0.2426739782,
0.5762808323,
0.5284810662,
0.2777748406,
0.0058040367,
0.0015807631,
0.9685200453,
-0.7760850787,
-0.5534648299,
-0.6391471028,
0.8472664952,
-0.4499101937,
-0.9788327813,
0.1975705922,
0.8192333579,
0.2220540792,
0.4315689504,
0.8619533777,
-0.2941504717,
0.6603838801,
-0.2864937782,
0.6601347923,
-0.6147679687,
0.3732982278,
0.1897478998,
-0.0950825661,
-0.5649138689,
0.8561273217,
-0.3352159262,
-0.3893883526,
0.4756433368,
0.5361341834,
-0.3991131186,
0.015820086,
0.0208850931,
0.0073580504,
0.3726076484,
0.3035786152,
0.4940153658,
-0.4735917747,
0.5831246972,
-0.2659266889,
-0.0543726534,
-0.4398606718,
-0.7716618776,
-0.9255367517,
-0.5500081182,
-0.6417140365,
-0.5512732267,
0.2048068941,
0.9219437242,
0.9920901656,
-0.6240669489,
0.0830392912,
-0.1959734559,
0.1044919044,
-0.2526032329,
-0.2155851573,
0.5611832142,
-0.1857491136,
-0.128359735,
0.4571444988,
0.2129825354,
0.0842916146,
-0.0721909925,
0.0856182575,
-0.2094154358,
-0.3534562886,
0.4758853912,
0.2759195566,
-0.3828049004,
-0.0756347924,
0.0789482519,
-0.29534477,
0.1322050989,
1.102763772,
-0.5471801758,
0.2808543444,
0.3297741413,
0.5651497841,
0.4870664477,
0.216634959,
0.2430345118,
-0.5354385376,
0.0864346325,
0.9802216291,
0.2443346232,
0.3623770773,
-0.3480749726,
0.5274415016,
0.3830089271,
-0.6356807947,
-1.0474139452,
-0.0513957888,
-1.087796092,
0.0223009661,
1.3594183922,
-0.4545859396,
-0.2811021805,
-0.6147083044,
0.0837323889,
0.3009003699,
-0.3293207288,
0.7923895717,
0.2304754406,
-0.5040168762,
-0.2867362201,
-0.8715194464,
0.5796297193,
0.0680003613,
-0.8072993755,
0.3191879392,
0.327057302,
0.2074387223,
0.0368794315,
0.9051756859,
-0.1030734777,
0.1833423674,
-0.5780076981,
-0.0547034964,
-0.0132181635,
-0.2454804331,
-0.1369810998,
0.3563196957,
-0.1411446929,
-0.1977612674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15941v1
|
Tell2Design: A Dataset for Language-Guided Floor Plan Generation
| 2023-11-27T15:49:29 | 2023-11-27T15:49:29 |
Sicong Leng, Yang Zhou, Mohammed Haroon Dupty, Wee Sun Lee, Sam Conrad Joyce, Wei Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
We consider the task of generating designs directly from natural language
descriptions, and consider floor plan generation as the initial research area.
Language conditional generative models have recently been very successful in
generating high-quality artistic images. However, designs must satisfy
different constraints that are not present in generating artistic images,
particularly spatial and relational constraints. We make multiple contributions
to initiate research on this task. First, we introduce a novel dataset,
\textit{Tell2Design} (T2D), which contains more than $80k$ floor plan designs
associated with natural language instructions. Second, we propose a
Sequence-to-Sequence model that can serve as a strong baseline for future
research. Third, we benchmark this task with several text-conditional image
generation models. We conclude by conducting human evaluations on the generated
samples and providing an analysis of human performance. We hope our
contributions will propel the research on language-guided design generation
forward.
|
[
-0.2174198478,
-0.4066284895,
0.5639832616,
0.2802541256,
-0.0734577402,
-0.2662207782,
-0.0670482442,
-0.4202521741,
-0.0317262188,
0.8348868489,
-0.7137103677,
-0.6434683204,
-0.2717480958,
-0.0382944085,
-0.1850766838,
0.2936567664,
-0.208099708,
-0.1958010048,
-0.0839489773,
0.1108550653,
-0.8400853872,
0.1643367559,
-0.4684803188,
0.2194598615,
0.1085229665,
0.801284194,
0.7850295305,
0.6759828329,
0.251478374,
0.1954099983,
0.3460434079,
0.1774977893,
-0.1667560637,
0.0922858194,
0.058463037,
-0.2770821452,
-0.2920334935,
-0.0734346062,
0.2431483567,
0.8277390599,
-0.0575442687,
0.0611387342,
-0.0669229031,
1.2509567738,
-0.3530378342,
0.3864096999,
-0.279171586,
0.4184826016,
-0.100394085,
-0.2522819638,
-0.6310901642,
-0.6291177273,
0.0059236242,
-0.7048963308,
0.4670071304,
0.2652519047,
0.6407850981,
0.3698830307,
-0.3365381062,
-0.5929191113,
-0.8912675381,
0.3486999273,
-0.7078253627,
0.4898957014,
0.4167091548,
0.3961235583,
-0.3056101203,
-0.7672320604,
-0.3954792023,
-0.1665697843,
-0.3207713366,
0.1324414611,
-0.1400854439,
0.0008867979,
0.6203467846,
0.2320105284,
-1.1391183138,
-0.0897189826,
-0.5880429149,
-0.11565198,
0.7824136019,
0.164712593,
0.5517808199,
-0.4108625054,
-0.576828301,
-0.1769170761,
-0.9306118488,
0.0789971426,
0.4522927701,
0.1139161214,
-0.2383247912,
0.7400687337,
-0.4782565534,
0.6569669247,
-0.2220135778,
0.0344453491,
0.0290609598,
-0.4953943491,
0.0334343575,
0.0003876067,
0.5869649053,
0.6571703553,
0.1619032919,
-0.3252949417,
-0.3652472496,
0.2968468666,
0.353813827,
-1.0466042757,
-0.5542965531,
0.1311380267,
-0.571259737,
-0.2889177203,
0.022025777,
-0.8958550692,
-0.4402759671,
-0.7453970313,
0.0908092633,
-0.2947017252,
-0.3945153356,
0.3687029481,
-0.3674706817,
0.3110164404,
0.0488023572,
-0.7386881113,
0.5502557158,
0.5207125545,
0.5385421515,
-0.0009145843,
-0.153997764,
-0.2267896533,
0.1524183452,
-0.9755975008,
0.8569312692,
-0.244698748,
-0.6428660154,
0.1460769027,
-0.491111815,
0.5424722433,
-0.6291015148,
0.6800019741,
-0.2728631794,
0.6444609165,
-0.5372366309,
-0.406282872,
0.1362415552,
-0.2844507098,
-0.8518276215,
0.6756230593,
0.4784387946,
-0.917267859,
0.4786595702,
-0.7389636636,
-0.7286247015,
0.3401690125,
-0.6980221272,
-0.4739752412,
0.4190475643,
-0.0498387553,
-0.0417760424,
-0.4066475332,
0.4241397083,
0.0699494854,
-0.1403467953,
-0.1533260345,
0.0020870841,
0.5875307322,
0.5344023108,
-0.6216031313,
0.0169452447,
-0.8754279613,
0.3955934346,
0.4306175411,
-0.2730436623,
-0.0055333022,
0.3056343198,
0.0476494469,
0.4587258101,
0.0848984346,
-0.3968610764,
0.0434187204,
-0.2548832297,
0.0628500432,
0.4185656309,
0.0141881611,
0.6816875935,
-0.5807057619,
0.5582342744,
-0.4314641356,
-0.2241478711,
-0.0598085932,
-0.5615180731,
-0.6712319255,
0.0519510582,
0.0896557271,
0.3602005839,
-0.8740018606,
0.2534089386,
-0.2585219145,
-0.1969965845,
-0.0919233933,
-0.1879169196,
0.4362026453,
0.4646120071,
0.0043932325,
-0.3172617257,
-0.8240135908,
-1.1915053129,
-0.0255068801,
-0.1303551197,
-0.3957292736,
0.4440063238,
0.1018806696,
0.1219266281,
1.1349723339,
-0.9579956532,
-0.2101870328,
-0.2161072642,
0.3172113299,
0.0702486485,
0.2024811208,
0.8929325938,
-0.7192690372,
-0.6369959116,
-0.3295863867,
-0.7870880365,
-0.4093145132,
-0.2051313072,
-0.3996061981,
0.1802480817,
0.2775737643,
-0.839364171,
0.8068322539,
0.4001993835,
-0.6035172939,
0.4913358092,
-0.2885827422,
-0.1384775788,
-1.3244036436,
0.0462516025,
0.0566057302,
0.325384438,
-0.6328242421,
-0.1378018409,
-0.0122082513,
-0.7130060792,
-0.0613401383,
0.6627591848,
-0.6710885763,
-0.3565840125,
-0.4759233296,
-0.2118450254,
0.3276664317,
0.6196155548,
0.6806970835,
0.5964347124,
0.4559696615,
-0.4579721689,
-0.0070400271,
0.6006315947,
-0.8682968616,
0.6151016951,
-0.753430903,
0.3752197921,
-0.2345348448,
0.5347011685,
-1.0726733208,
-0.5461441875,
0.3551818728,
-0.289952755,
0.1064737216,
0.0145595279,
-0.667566359,
-0.631734252,
-0.2563317418,
0.0715306327,
0.5877595544,
-0.5494807959,
0.1654085964,
0.1923662573,
-0.4596142471,
0.1180558726,
-0.6060040593,
0.2730326653,
-0.1197331101,
-1.0236603022,
0.7020932436,
-0.1772820204,
-0.4795717001,
0.0133503517,
-0.1589709967,
-0.0558160283,
-0.2126466334,
0.5461727381,
0.1546272337,
-0.2455037981,
0.011588878,
-0.1663127244,
-0.2658506036,
0.3215458095,
-0.4382900894,
0.4266352355,
0.4296301305,
-0.2809487581,
-0.4716227353,
0.7879496813,
0.4054397345,
-0.2472589761,
0.1468987912,
0.1263107955,
-0.5339395404,
-0.6346175075,
-0.2405540794,
0.1020190418,
-0.5390110612,
0.2921399474,
-0.7184944153,
-0.24698551,
0.2244480997,
-0.1366560161,
0.38668257,
0.3266896605,
0.4729155898,
-0.2181856781,
0.9391824007,
0.8094775677,
0.4522077739,
0.37482059,
-0.3574917018,
0.2492304444,
-0.5286433697,
-0.3136698604,
-0.5910342932,
-0.5564365387,
-0.4906732738,
-0.4753266871,
0.143977806,
-0.0517404713,
-0.1923812777,
0.5274350643,
-0.6241229773,
0.3144806623,
0.601968348,
0.0500052609,
0.0126998732,
0.10057877,
0.0439418964,
-0.1062921658,
-0.5008999705,
-0.625664711,
1.002671361,
0.1323013604,
0.6633209586,
0.3056878448,
0.503282845,
0.3355973065,
-0.0815300792,
-0.4881905317,
0.5448614359,
-0.1041350737,
-0.4748122096,
-0.1876133978,
-0.3261680007,
-0.9097560048,
-0.1690802872,
0.1603091061,
-0.2271624506,
0.44415012,
0.011273141,
-0.1554426849,
0.0608728305,
-0.7834060192,
0.581874609,
-0.6517114043,
-0.1866704673,
-0.0082430551,
-0.5294415951,
0.3772532046,
-0.0807141438,
0.1442541778,
-0.1706593931,
0.221384272,
0.642631948,
-0.5592226386,
0.7151424885,
-0.5055280328,
-0.2039612234,
0.4466729462,
0.2262855917,
0.7922005057,
0.0955101773,
-0.3767662644,
-0.3891026676,
-0.4377528727,
-0.3528707325,
-0.3033037484,
0.4463874698,
-0.6335871816,
-0.370133847,
0.1699625105,
-0.4945117533,
-0.4473981261,
0.0983667001,
0.7291940451,
0.6198338866,
-0.3586169779,
-0.0227198675,
0.349588275,
-0.3704568446,
0.3931718469,
0.3680197001,
-0.1299085915,
-0.3237312734,
0.905397296,
-0.129297033,
0.1513723433,
0.3632667661,
0.2483802587,
-0.4726370275,
-0.6020600796,
-0.6320894957,
-0.1735002846,
-0.5525830984,
-0.0232891943,
-0.1191616803,
-0.3405199647,
-0.3853067756,
-0.2244466245,
-0.2915139198,
-0.5601478815,
-0.0098881675,
-0.0586790219,
0.0756480098,
1.1801208258,
-0.0894200802,
-0.1302369088,
-0.2735547423,
0.7408080697,
0.482580483,
0.5368835926,
-0.2591575384,
-0.2091615051,
0.0739640445,
0.178598538,
-0.2130527347,
-0.6487096548,
0.3821989596,
0.0218411572,
0.5536679626,
0.2907526195,
0.460032016,
0.189470917,
-0.8412026763,
0.4130799472,
0.2366106361,
-0.3093572855,
0.9220170379,
-0.3789634705,
0.3478185833,
0.5302727222,
0.149484545,
-0.4771058857,
0.0391035713,
-0.7946754098,
-0.6467265487,
0.7518675923,
0.5367336273,
0.1244952157,
0.2094198316,
0.2390301079,
0.3454575241,
0.1331687868,
-0.3645374477,
-0.0718832463,
-0.3979774714,
-0.0303034913,
0.3122051656,
-0.4641359448,
-0.2436200082,
0.1284368038,
0.1663725227,
-0.0876868218,
0.5236330628,
-0.1316307932,
0.1032656133,
-0.3343376815,
0.0663007498,
0.8722117543,
0.7861597538,
-0.0335295834,
0.0904420093,
-0.1839241982,
-0.0385758728,
0.0476093851,
0.0851118118,
-0.3111031651,
0.2661673725,
0.3929873109,
1.2358781099,
-0.2116298676,
-0.4096809924,
0.4837439656,
-0.2471041083,
-0.7505053282,
-0.3280430436,
0.0611307546,
0.0100343684,
0.1760019213,
0.2272762507,
0.1622652709,
0.1580043137,
-0.4414831996,
0.5041227937,
0.1194715872,
-0.0773740187,
-0.5921484232,
0.8640727997,
0.5098599792,
-0.7909578681,
0.7810860276,
-0.4313269258,
-0.1983396113,
0.8565579653,
0.5711007714,
0.951932013,
0.3025618792,
0.3470417857,
0.4685553014,
-0.0211761575,
0.1182542741,
0.5409212708,
-0.2078385204,
-0.4974153638,
-0.1523327529,
-0.5414938331,
-0.398833096,
0.093006894,
-0.4901608825,
0.5304546952,
-0.4382808506,
0.1457006782,
-0.1069384888,
0.1306915134,
-0.6143226624,
0.3856692612,
0.6131392121,
0.9563483,
-0.7415774465,
0.6724530458,
0.6180967689,
-0.1126512364,
-0.6423053741,
0.3537602127,
0.138356328,
-0.6668754816,
0.7592114806,
0.192706883,
-0.0164743923,
-0.1886219233,
-0.4197534323,
-0.5481726527,
0.9701700807,
0.1938477606,
-0.5653917789,
-0.4004173279,
0.6188969016,
0.4313405454,
-0.3030415177,
-0.3280251324,
0.2421157956,
0.6409436464,
0.4496247172,
-0.4465844035,
0.085706979,
-0.5204733014,
0.2435315251,
0.0842083618,
-0.4000560045,
0.4709395766,
-0.5469373465,
-0.496532619,
0.3866745532,
0.5484745502,
0.478640914,
0.264478147,
0.5152819157,
0.6443694234,
0.602727294,
-0.1573964506,
0.9567483664,
-0.5294403434,
-0.072318472,
1.2679494619,
-0.2296273112,
0.6854953766,
-0.0045876401,
-0.1859275401,
0.1895370185,
0.6301932931,
0.0490083173,
1.0886608362,
0.541520834,
-0.1894604415,
0.0343046896,
-0.0406177826,
-0.5845093131,
0.4318561256,
0.3744172454,
-0.1953786761,
-0.2761670649,
-0.249101311,
-0.156427443,
0.2020023763,
0.4004469514,
0.8339378834,
-0.0075620757,
-0.8464087248,
0.3226273656,
0.0988681838,
0.2798623145,
-0.4577910006,
-0.2751735449,
-0.6874572039,
-0.0178468917,
-0.1088621765,
-1.0453275442,
0.5414839387,
-0.1640143394,
-0.2350958735,
-0.8215315938,
0.586047709,
-0.2985159755,
-0.4768670499,
-0.1340619028,
0.3223134577,
-0.1020151228,
-0.0683564246,
-0.3426876664,
-0.0227661822,
0.2246978283,
-0.1472993493,
-0.001065915,
0.8306004405,
-0.146078229,
0.335431397,
0.5006934404,
-0.031321682,
-0.0252251159,
0.0708546191,
0.6791775227,
-0.6788928509,
-0.4396588504,
-0.2599414289,
0.5766872168,
-0.1206920817,
-0.3605567217,
0.2435879111,
1.0221991539,
0.6472944021,
-0.2233264744,
0.9587917328,
-0.3317358196,
0.4024675488,
-0.6754036546,
0.5318161845,
-0.2490284592,
0.2659866214,
0.0443700105,
-0.8278107047,
-0.0398860797,
0.4239705503,
-0.0649180487,
-0.2155230343,
0.5868472457,
0.8034610748,
0.1660997719,
0.1253846735,
0.0969599932,
-0.2077580243,
0.5478509068,
0.6792846322,
1.076757431,
-0.1949083656,
0.5483289361,
-0.6617607474,
-0.0492723919,
-0.146438852,
-0.7010847926,
-0.7293288708,
-0.8552548289,
-0.4303188622,
-0.1890079081,
-0.1328608394,
0.3936204314,
0.8743363023,
-0.6880353689,
-0.20849742,
-0.6977187395,
-0.156291008,
0.1348643452,
-0.1414251924,
0.6274895072,
-0.1425412297,
-0.4862756133,
0.4943140745,
0.2154227346,
0.0519827865,
-0.256005168,
-0.4602829516,
0.4463940263,
-0.0932991654,
0.5202480555,
0.2954796553,
-0.5388140678,
-0.1340048164,
0.0150839379,
-0.4967080653,
0.4113477468,
0.9112154841,
-0.7467309237,
0.2970519364,
0.7347921133,
0.3564634919,
0.3412843049,
0.0151979225,
0.9291554689,
-1.0528628826,
0.1901378334,
0.1081492603,
0.2192793638,
0.3031844497,
-0.163961038,
0.935334444,
-0.0137187354,
-0.1799990833,
-0.3129064739,
0.493168205,
-0.8089857697,
-0.2655057609,
1.0928788185,
0.3013020456,
0.2519887686,
0.0927011222,
-0.5743633509,
-0.0296672992,
-0.1108537167,
0.804105103,
0.2666655183,
-0.3048110008,
-0.0838234574,
-0.8369238377,
0.7899770141,
0.0966904908,
-1.1272354126,
0.2577666044,
0.8040131927,
0.0888524204,
0.1018017605,
0.6479402781,
0.0428506583,
0.4643122554,
0.2918837368,
0.1853819489,
-0.0315451361,
-0.4556617737,
0.3582994044,
0.2302363813,
0.4058367014,
-0.473612994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03728v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03728v1
|
Real Customization or Just Marketing: Are Customized Versions of Chat GPT Useful?
| 2023-11-27T15:46:15 | 2023-11-27T15:46:15 |
Eduardo C. Garrido-Merchán, Jose L. Arroyo-Barrigüete, Francisco Borrás-Pala, Leandro Escobar-Torres, Carlos Martínez de Ibarreta, Jose María Ortiz-Lozano, Antonio Rua-Vieites
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), as the case of OpenAI ChatGPT-4 Turbo, are
revolutionizing several industries, including higher education. In this
context, LLMs can be personalized through a fine-tuning process to meet the
student demands on every particular subject, like statistics. Recently, OpenAI
has launched the possibility to fine-tune their model with a natural language
web interface, enabling the possibility to create customized GPT version
deliberately conditioned to meet the demands of a specific task. The objective
of this research is to assess the potential of the customized GPTs that have
recently been launched by OpenAI. After developing a Business Statistics
Virtual Professor (BSVP), tailored for students at the Universidad Pontificia
Comillas, its behavior was evaluated and compared with that of ChatGPT-4 Turbo.
The results lead to several conclusions. Firstly, a substantial modification in
the style of communication was observed. Following the instructions it was
trained with, BSVP provided responses in a more relatable and friendly tone,
even incorporating a few minor jokes. Secondly, and this is a matter of
relevance, when explicitly asked for something like, "I would like to practice
a programming exercise similar to those in R practice 4," BSVP was capable of
providing a far superior response: having access to contextual documentation,
it could fulfill the request, something beyond ChatGPT-4 Turbo's capabilities.
On the downside, the response times were generally higher. Lastly, regarding
overall performance, quality, depth, and alignment with the specific content of
the course, no statistically significant differences were observed in the
responses between BSVP and ChatGPT-4 Turbo. It appears that customized
assistants trained with prompts present advantages as virtual aids for
students, yet they do not constitute a substantial improvement over ChatGPT-4
Turbo.
|
[
-0.5326030254,
-1.0259933472,
0.4173331857,
0.1986581087,
-0.1738864183,
0.2849675715,
-0.602188766,
-0.6183996201,
0.467184335,
0.2426888049,
-0.4738852978,
-0.1661558449,
0.0871132016,
0.2671462893,
0.0326366238,
1.2762200832,
0.092452094,
0.1324076355,
-0.0439568684,
0.0569654964,
-0.7243635058,
-0.6633285284,
-1.0692293644,
-0.3414655924,
0.3718724251,
0.2671348453,
0.6583317518,
0.3757929802,
0.6293528676,
0.3525474966,
0.1326186061,
-0.3917789161,
-0.6391169429,
0.1449671984,
0.0044720494,
-0.4738289118,
-0.664137423,
0.1035343111,
0.5260523558,
0.5418396592,
-0.1717833281,
0.2602311075,
0.1850048602,
0.5296038985,
-0.25270316,
0.3614799082,
-0.3555524647,
0.0817956775,
-0.0763764605,
-0.5017379522,
-0.2993465662,
-0.4969714284,
0.5733644366,
-0.6546515226,
0.1794729829,
-0.2769820988,
1.0825028419,
0.1262938231,
-0.0537444763,
-0.3282978237,
-1.2157132626,
0.6846895814,
-0.7665757537,
0.3975795209,
0.0513312407,
0.9758194089,
-0.2145885378,
-0.7318217158,
-0.1995199025,
-0.445774436,
0.0514262915,
0.4963724613,
-0.0842370689,
0.1956564784,
0.3094648421,
0.5445433259,
-0.5536060333,
0.2270241678,
-0.603634119,
-0.1301141828,
0.3777368367,
0.2057628185,
0.3471288085,
0.2937583923,
0.0412330031,
-0.00332107,
-0.7142330408,
0.1004177034,
0.6258462071,
0.3136183619,
-0.0775422081,
0.4779681265,
-0.4626873434,
0.6707888842,
-0.122221522,
-0.1119506955,
0.1634247154,
-0.2037284523,
-0.5819324851,
-0.0474535897,
0.567568481,
0.0275982041,
0.9130943418,
-0.1553028375,
0.0275739431,
-0.1483437866,
0.3559116125,
-0.934877634,
-0.5405042171,
0.1327206343,
-0.2670598626,
-0.2567088306,
-0.1844251156,
-0.5395612717,
0.1791655719,
-0.6674929857,
0.2131081671,
-0.2674994767,
-0.2620274723,
-0.0210223291,
-0.0219588783,
0.3175777793,
0.4847539663,
-0.9402192235,
0.3361344635,
0.6811721325,
0.9602992535,
-0.2819476128,
0.1151485294,
-0.2507902384,
-0.0701918527,
-0.2430554032,
0.823105514,
-0.8317036629,
-0.4305749834,
0.0580569096,
-0.3383404315,
0.1563001871,
-0.4785063267,
0.2059086263,
-0.6858463883,
0.391353935,
-0.4295301735,
-0.5622848868,
0.0817782059,
0.5835905671,
-0.2376771569,
0.5546563268,
0.1466589868,
-0.4818755686,
0.4682454169,
-0.7626163363,
-0.1022165492,
0.5443153381,
-0.3615801036,
-0.243914485,
-0.3280099928,
0.0264563058,
0.3174257874,
0.1230191737,
-0.0617372617,
-0.46546489,
-0.504242599,
0.4908621013,
-0.4935233891,
0.4508312643,
0.3472537994,
-0.2602581084,
0.0941662937,
-0.7829262018,
0.2354767472,
-0.0929591581,
-0.7577573657,
-0.2075349391,
-0.3157969415,
-0.1291560829,
-0.0297312029,
0.1582514644,
-0.3513891399,
0.3932656944,
-0.582152009,
0.1915379018,
1.0282194614,
0.0187621191,
0.38436836,
-0.2364646941,
0.9957815409,
-0.5210800171,
0.1448973864,
-0.2113744617,
-0.9452331662,
-0.6507974863,
-0.5335395336,
0.2778998315,
0.5196141005,
-0.4151862562,
-0.1338220537,
-0.1742114276,
-0.4199987352,
-0.4492622614,
0.0033081707,
0.2100650072,
0.4741855562,
0.169571951,
-0.3682679832,
-0.448595345,
-0.7540854812,
-0.5419427156,
-0.0329553299,
-0.2473580092,
0.4353321195,
0.1279139519,
-0.1701877266,
1.1595087051,
-0.7918614745,
-0.4089714587,
-0.3625898659,
-0.2139504999,
0.1030834764,
0.125563249,
0.9698973894,
-0.5693992376,
-0.8998680115,
0.2052197456,
-0.4689643085,
-0.2936906517,
-0.1842401475,
0.0723995268,
0.081390053,
-0.0155725572,
-0.3549744487,
0.5279589295,
0.3617583513,
-0.0501235388,
0.8042680025,
-0.6640770435,
0.2309345305,
-1.0483140945,
-0.2147313356,
0.3227448761,
-0.2697321773,
-0.7209220529,
0.0122166416,
-0.3619811237,
-0.2369014621,
-0.2813975513,
0.5312769413,
-0.3874224424,
-0.3214946091,
-0.5005592108,
0.0494329333,
-0.5696149468,
0.5555573702,
0.0261105262,
0.9896362424,
0.4728449881,
-0.736241281,
0.4352796972,
0.2980958819,
-0.3581614792,
0.6317903399,
-0.9768778682,
0.3154265881,
-0.0288528539,
0.2926235199,
-0.9678506851,
-0.4556290507,
0.3662093878,
-0.423516959,
0.1526844651,
-0.3571637571,
-0.2029704005,
-0.285077244,
-0.1894574165,
-0.1095194593,
0.9003548026,
-0.3633570671,
0.1491918117,
0.055795256,
-0.2787578404,
-0.3435525894,
-0.6620784998,
0.1767353266,
-0.1779455841,
-0.5813301206,
-0.0610301308,
-0.3002898991,
-0.1932570636,
-0.2052007318,
0.0909903795,
-0.1643479615,
0.051954709,
0.0485014506,
0.2181725055,
-0.5106063485,
-0.0779450163,
-0.1622280031,
-0.0844240487,
-0.1633204967,
-0.2269633263,
0.4516099691,
-0.2497680336,
-0.3500571251,
-0.5812336802,
-0.0397442244,
0.0699340403,
-0.1383634806,
0.6033272147,
0.7071123719,
-0.0929582641,
0.0239917617,
-0.5802400708,
-0.3175699711,
-0.6332591176,
0.1729936749,
-0.4999195039,
-1.0664904118,
0.3277405798,
0.0547901168,
0.4344818592,
-0.2179714143,
0.8159912229,
0.0395604782,
1.0670928955,
0.7280923724,
0.0562271029,
0.8500311971,
-0.2036800086,
0.476934433,
-0.4558204114,
-0.2926369011,
-0.5387074351,
-0.2683539987,
-0.8040477633,
0.0480210334,
0.3459519744,
-0.4592104852,
-0.2979672849,
0.235188067,
-0.5467807651,
0.6156498194,
0.6187661886,
-0.0569765307,
0.2520447671,
0.261399895,
0.4667350948,
-0.3281541169,
-0.4103592932,
-0.7223453522,
0.9623739719,
0.3930918574,
0.9086742401,
0.4494841099,
0.4954123199,
0.1124724746,
0.5735675097,
-0.8869302273,
0.6149908304,
0.0957236364,
-0.3566919267,
-0.2655642033,
-0.6518911123,
-1.0277428627,
0.3445281684,
-0.1008055657,
-0.9139944911,
-0.1590073109,
0.5431960225,
-0.2255257666,
0.2061213255,
-1.0124156475,
0.7855624557,
-0.1144780219,
-0.1694172174,
-0.1425997615,
-0.1999318898,
0.2802483737,
-0.1617336571,
0.0845469609,
0.0078030829,
0.024609087,
0.6272723079,
-0.4977580011,
0.8727440238,
0.0085710622,
0.0284006558,
0.0286565013,
0.1099560335,
0.4436486065,
-0.0248965826,
-0.0537303314,
-0.3192817271,
0.0915509984,
-0.522841692,
-0.6830384135,
0.979108274,
-0.7873153687,
-0.9167046547,
-0.3034262657,
-0.2104432136,
-0.4008656442,
0.293072015,
0.0465963371,
0.385250479,
-0.3923074007,
0.1039112359,
0.4960529208,
-0.4525748193,
0.185748443,
0.6114267707,
-0.0727481022,
-0.0962299481,
1.0122756958,
0.2072537243,
0.4285350144,
0.2009095848,
0.6307656765,
-0.0985090807,
-0.4223230779,
-0.4368952215,
0.3021438718,
-0.7163524628,
0.1664403081,
-0.7818561792,
-0.0071316417,
-0.8304117322,
-0.3746544421,
-0.1569608152,
-0.3112513423,
-0.3239066303,
-0.1667584032,
0.3198347986,
0.7988315225,
0.1172619313,
0.6257727742,
-0.5580246449,
-0.0154000688,
0.3896413147,
0.3902505636,
-0.2152426392,
-0.6263171434,
-0.1174055934,
0.1871356368,
-0.4833125174,
-0.6958196163,
0.3348691463,
0.149841249,
0.528319478,
0.5560972095,
-0.2241425365,
0.6864174604,
-0.4426735938,
0.9135817885,
-0.0248694513,
-0.4305678606,
0.4053304493,
-0.5589441061,
0.2251963615,
0.2566082478,
0.5754470229,
-0.4854046106,
-0.5585087538,
-0.5937833786,
-0.5331413746,
0.7637024522,
0.2972919047,
0.7106662393,
0.2870364189,
0.5357962251,
0.031033352,
0.3704880774,
-0.6115074754,
-0.2787324488,
-0.2396550775,
0.0160375964,
0.0109092686,
-0.2445980459,
0.2480028123,
-0.211113736,
0.5947239399,
0.0680746511,
0.2296359241,
-0.2225830406,
0.4227471948,
0.1680987924,
0.5046495795,
0.7251686454,
0.9603875875,
-0.4054742455,
-0.365577668,
0.1719059795,
-0.6140378714,
-0.0721870512,
-0.3973549008,
-0.1248652562,
0.1037375703,
0.0381706096,
0.830871284,
-0.011170337,
-0.4842161536,
0.4658582509,
-0.0442528389,
-0.0693348274,
-0.5562447906,
0.3631120622,
-0.2190898508,
0.0910364464,
-0.0203734525,
-0.0876609311,
0.2406733185,
-0.8545164466,
-0.0794697404,
0.4060154855,
-0.3431578875,
-0.679818213,
0.8085960746,
0.3215827644,
-0.6402255893,
0.5257343054,
0.0939442441,
-0.390638411,
0.4513309896,
0.7086247206,
0.8194611073,
-0.3001946211,
0.610365212,
0.271183908,
0.1765113324,
-0.1503980905,
-0.0578273907,
-0.2084114552,
-0.4841597676,
-0.448151201,
-0.3998666406,
-0.8891456127,
0.188933,
-0.3552395999,
0.5763328671,
-0.6302738786,
-0.2489339709,
0.0904540047,
-0.3031959534,
-0.8262925744,
0.2806999385,
-0.1644633859,
0.7186629772,
-0.527518034,
0.8410824537,
1.031286478,
-0.5120518208,
-0.8237237334,
-0.0772780105,
-0.1055095047,
-0.6975269914,
0.6713434458,
-0.1103136316,
0.1520723104,
-0.1293238401,
-0.34344396,
-0.581687808,
0.7069730759,
0.4266196787,
-0.4664293826,
-0.1996754557,
0.4792250097,
0.9894763231,
-0.066645734,
0.6164960861,
0.5713979602,
0.2898876071,
0.2021729797,
-0.9939280152,
-0.1831004024,
0.0630400628,
0.0031641845,
0.061625421,
-0.7508918643,
0.5951767564,
-0.1255389303,
-0.1110284701,
-0.1123327315,
0.526645422,
-0.1023726538,
0.2059884369,
0.1395742595,
0.0674429685,
0.6917715073,
-0.0856811553,
1.2494949102,
0.0390133709,
0.2472663224,
1.0477267504,
0.041523058,
0.5690505505,
0.384706676,
-0.4077199101,
0.3061137199,
0.7265867591,
0.0121011082,
0.4238770604,
0.3544940352,
-0.2246362567,
-0.1414567381,
0.3443052769,
-0.4149462879,
-0.0318884961,
0.3333981335,
0.0773296952,
-0.1799811274,
0.2228668332,
0.0980617851,
-0.0588540845,
-0.0241952799,
0.7685932517,
0.1569485962,
-0.562363863,
0.3729662895,
0.0728690401,
0.7924235463,
-0.821525991,
0.0725003332,
-0.2934164405,
0.364955157,
-0.3951668739,
-0.6915281415,
0.2785494328,
0.1928604096,
0.4250166118,
-0.3420736194,
0.6436696053,
-0.1833040714,
-0.2568894029,
-0.1828060895,
0.1753151864,
0.6517816186,
-0.0060483138,
-0.578789115,
-0.0554351807,
0.0707169175,
-0.446262151,
0.4290100932,
0.2526241243,
0.0333957374,
0.9700776339,
0.745216012,
0.348115623,
0.1703023762,
0.3115438223,
0.6664597392,
-0.3398630023,
-0.5852659941,
-0.6857143641,
0.1396471709,
-0.1656739861,
-0.4689011574,
1.0841636658,
0.5876835585,
1.1596531868,
-0.3213942647,
0.9409899712,
0.1747903526,
0.3436448574,
-0.3597242236,
0.251845032,
-0.4180314541,
0.6286929846,
-0.4006384015,
-1.0979446173,
-0.0564147718,
0.5066691041,
-0.5558274388,
0.3568849862,
0.2990825474,
0.6421263814,
-0.3230190873,
0.0787178725,
0.5548247099,
-0.0691492185,
1.0059427023,
0.1355787218,
0.6654323339,
0.1355838031,
0.7724810243,
-0.2356638014,
-0.4691402912,
-0.3840958476,
-0.4273700714,
-1.3798594475,
-0.2678325772,
-0.6604994535,
-0.3203366101,
0.128606692,
1.0438154936,
0.4815366864,
-0.6438075304,
-0.2953231931,
0.1385010779,
-0.3537094593,
-0.0777078569,
-0.2883399725,
0.0660336763,
-0.5775091648,
-0.8602719903,
0.175352037,
0.2550771832,
0.5120340586,
-0.4050923884,
0.0652439296,
0.5069069266,
0.2755986452,
0.6651648283,
0.5413805246,
-0.3821001649,
-0.3629043102,
0.1719103009,
-0.0124159176,
0.185244292,
1.1040973663,
-0.6229720712,
0.3891872466,
0.661241293,
0.7837649584,
0.6567410827,
-0.0339062139,
0.7247541547,
-0.5363508463,
0.2673020661,
0.1148039699,
0.1971862614,
0.3219161034,
-0.4694866836,
0.4937674999,
0.1515998393,
-0.6610456705,
-0.762943089,
0.2752173841,
-1.0677531958,
-0.064841643,
1.3274626732,
-0.1411766857,
0.0037556805,
-0.2407739013,
-0.6337913275,
-0.058291439,
-0.5310773253,
0.8292186856,
0.6509355903,
-0.3214699328,
0.0239197873,
-0.9683131576,
0.6740028858,
0.285384059,
-0.7946673632,
-0.3435977697,
0.2350599915,
0.7189923525,
-0.2514706552,
1.0921677351,
0.1574551761,
0.1028387547,
-0.5281430483,
-0.2664148808,
-0.2755239904,
0.145792827,
-0.0442702845,
-0.0881819129,
0.2468154728,
-0.3329496682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15930v1
|
WorldSense: A Synthetic Benchmark for Grounded Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-27T15:38:17 | 2023-11-27T15:38:17 |
Youssef Benchekroun, Megi Dervishi, Mark Ibrahim, Jean-Baptiste Gaya, Xavier Martinet, Grégoire Mialon, Thomas Scialom, Emmanuel Dupoux, Dieuwke Hupkes, Pascal Vincent
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose WorldSense, a benchmark designed to assess the extent to which
LLMs are consistently able to sustain tacit world models, by testing how they
draw simple inferences from descriptions of simple arrangements of entities.
Worldsense is a synthetic benchmark with three problem types, each with their
own trivial control, which explicitly avoids bias by decorrelating the abstract
structure of problems from the vocabulary and expressions, and by decorrelating
all problem subparts with the correct response. We run our benchmark on three
state-of-the-art chat-LLMs (GPT3.5, GPT4 and Llama2-chat) and show that these
models make errors even with as few as three objects. Furthermore, they have
quite heavy response biases, preferring certain responses irrespective of the
question. Errors persist even with chain-of-thought prompting and in-context
learning. Lastly, we show that while finetuning on similar problems does result
in substantial improvements -- within- and out-of-distribution -- the finetuned
models do not generalise beyond a constraint problem space.
|
[
-0.4074519575,
-1.0157678127,
0.7362085581,
0.3373988867,
0.0782088265,
-0.0573474504,
-0.2685570121,
-0.4320180714,
-0.1704043597,
0.1898285449,
-0.4003204405,
-0.3442699015,
-0.2517348528,
0.1838595569,
-0.3846139014,
0.6465728879,
0.0289883241,
0.0515289828,
-0.6216468215,
-0.347549051,
-0.2850692868,
-0.3833339214,
-0.5400236249,
-0.2913661301,
0.342857033,
0.3418952227,
0.5618667006,
0.3585433066,
0.3369648755,
0.3055541813,
-0.4609660506,
0.534022212,
-0.4700728655,
0.3058531284,
-0.4433450401,
-0.4066560566,
-0.304535687,
0.2426365316,
0.4413546324,
0.7993966341,
-0.2317806333,
0.1394282877,
0.2304689884,
0.4779565632,
-0.7730592489,
0.0761251077,
-0.6769138575,
0.0398341902,
0.2452028543,
0.1802915186,
-0.3750050366,
-0.4261176884,
0.1086947471,
-0.8499272466,
0.0827136263,
0.4170248508,
0.8968601227,
0.3577433228,
-0.5545591712,
-0.0115153911,
-0.4878256917,
0.8440572619,
-0.6425306201,
0.6269987226,
0.2192750424,
0.4081393778,
-0.4358022511,
-0.6782790422,
-0.7369244099,
-0.4632095397,
0.2697131038,
0.267372489,
-0.1004550904,
0.0040179831,
0.4885641038,
0.1750936955,
-0.190303579,
0.1058947891,
-0.1513415724,
-0.3596990108,
0.6060746908,
0.0571756549,
0.100063242,
0.0512133688,
-0.6154080629,
-0.0463182442,
-0.9754664898,
-0.2449764311,
0.0962390974,
0.0311904028,
-0.2682652175,
0.4706807733,
-0.3702531457,
0.7459902167,
0.1124142557,
-0.3053340018,
-0.0342261307,
0.059297327,
-0.1553995162,
-0.3679627478,
0.5607898831,
0.6439090371,
0.3844390512,
-0.0169304013,
-0.27521348,
0.2001268119,
-0.100704439,
-0.5536455512,
-0.1175217107,
0.3974755704,
-0.2445704043,
-0.256718874,
-0.3506124914,
-0.5915141702,
-0.625467658,
-0.5367394686,
0.2906882167,
-0.1525741667,
-0.2834908664,
-0.0769393519,
-0.1527948231,
0.3169966936,
0.417501986,
-0.6027869582,
0.7807976604,
1.0275111198,
0.8131359816,
-0.5212338567,
-0.3565680683,
-0.6634970903,
0.090473488,
-0.5009673834,
1.0380579233,
-0.2311230302,
-0.2328160852,
0.0246295687,
-0.2088505328,
0.191816166,
-0.8009298444,
0.5712561607,
-0.3819121718,
0.0325717852,
-0.4416736364,
-0.9497112036,
0.1144237444,
0.7893589139,
-0.6143541336,
1.1351624727,
-0.0225321371,
-0.6373092532,
0.3242935538,
-0.3824514151,
-0.1707511395,
-0.0858605281,
-0.3856312037,
-0.0197002348,
0.2569075823,
0.1192380562,
0.5029225349,
-0.637105763,
0.5810502768,
-0.6962481141,
-0.4249368608,
0.4299282432,
-0.6617305279,
0.4993111193,
0.1136334091,
-0.3032114506,
-0.0043910984,
-0.9831376076,
0.3319334686,
0.0829938278,
-0.0876889229,
-0.3938087523,
0.2309517264,
0.1529525369,
0.294105798,
-0.0062381504,
-0.5961253643,
0.1835097671,
-0.2041633576,
0.6214445233,
0.8700913191,
0.0223583244,
0.2148596793,
-0.3620361388,
0.1269835979,
0.1025166139,
0.0072735855,
0.233265996,
-0.5026461482,
-0.8084290624,
-0.2764089108,
0.2377331853,
0.4254793525,
-0.6678209305,
0.148663193,
-0.3116719425,
-0.3523008227,
-0.1668357253,
-0.08818914,
0.5555990338,
0.522823751,
0.3702186644,
0.1102646142,
-0.2992905974,
-1.0828509331,
-0.3993988633,
-0.062507011,
-0.0068109753,
0.3832190633,
0.5520374775,
0.0973976031,
0.997140646,
-0.4454861879,
0.0328107476,
-0.1624787301,
-0.1262575835,
-0.0074677025,
0.4863593876,
0.1434183121,
-0.8817940354,
-0.462767601,
-0.0313045494,
-0.9600713253,
-0.3485863805,
0.0017316563,
-0.0187136717,
0.1686443537,
0.5465356708,
-0.7455914617,
0.1278565228,
0.6648483872,
-0.2812953293,
0.4694778621,
-0.0558706,
-0.1636702567,
-0.914363265,
-0.1558023393,
0.019092666,
-0.367500186,
-0.2965815365,
0.26445207,
0.2370527536,
-0.107899949,
-0.6771192551,
0.9929438233,
-0.447311461,
-0.2669784427,
-0.0200310145,
0.5459332466,
0.2551161349,
0.5657606125,
-0.0162090473,
0.9353635907,
0.4243602157,
-0.7305316329,
0.4097389877,
0.0722563639,
-0.3722966313,
1.0798215866,
-0.985050261,
0.2564707696,
0.0246325359,
0.3581658602,
-1.019281745,
-0.2854411006,
-0.174273625,
-0.071527712,
-0.1646840274,
-0.1922594905,
-0.4162417948,
-0.2365620434,
-0.2094472945,
0.2295068353,
0.5193852186,
-0.8352259398,
0.5443260074,
0.2405961901,
0.3801823854,
-0.4298264682,
-0.5322967172,
-0.023338927,
-0.2729279995,
-0.5847962499,
0.278288573,
-0.2048183531,
-0.7154588699,
-0.0485008545,
-0.4244088233,
-0.0789096057,
0.2247585505,
0.1290770322,
0.0344817974,
-0.1520397365,
0.1063717827,
0.0470358767,
-0.1489280462,
0.0580805875,
-0.5909029245,
0.3336434066,
-0.4000614583,
-0.5645726919,
-0.348387152,
0.2536274791,
0.5670800209,
0.1422890872,
0.5756040215,
0.0463322215,
-0.4389354587,
-0.5860865712,
-0.788995564,
0.0033815328,
-0.4914680719,
0.2021150738,
-0.6820638776,
-0.7700433135,
0.6741568446,
-0.2765958607,
0.0845707655,
0.2735391855,
0.407114923,
-0.2550634444,
0.9468716383,
0.1313572675,
0.1685137004,
-0.0800288618,
-0.2292731255,
-0.0952228829,
-0.9424750209,
-0.0141040059,
-0.2431705147,
-0.1490619034,
-0.6847259998,
-0.5347681642,
0.454018116,
0.1307135075,
-0.3751457036,
0.075756833,
-0.1538889557,
0.742832005,
0.4767223299,
-0.0416496322,
0.3008978367,
-0.2731961906,
-0.3741264939,
-0.094672516,
-0.6220219135,
-0.6593735814,
1.0236276388,
0.1488259137,
0.8300148249,
0.197656855,
0.6561666131,
0.4105741978,
0.4972594976,
-0.6852394342,
0.7294473052,
0.2319476306,
-0.644726634,
-0.0336238891,
-0.3376576602,
-0.5664045811,
0.7989837527,
-0.0830853134,
-0.5876218677,
-0.0293092318,
0.5982065201,
-0.1618212759,
0.2643960118,
-0.6570974588,
0.7645929456,
-0.1603964567,
-0.9659254551,
-0.0262763277,
-0.3150048852,
0.5049334764,
0.1707455069,
0.2201243341,
-0.3954927027,
-0.1343276799,
0.5984778404,
-0.4510592222,
0.9520244598,
-0.2108729184,
-0.3132831454,
0.5082657933,
0.1734906435,
0.7809463143,
0.2460451275,
0.0364370793,
0.096631363,
0.1892078817,
-0.5077650547,
-0.7849264145,
0.7666718364,
-0.6887267232,
-0.7494318485,
-0.4276855886,
-0.3544251621,
-0.8369958997,
0.156719923,
0.0558638461,
0.6973209977,
-0.4919051826,
0.1263097525,
0.8657441139,
-0.0075137168,
0.1338846833,
0.4147006571,
-0.175881654,
-0.3551450372,
0.684650898,
-0.0299853329,
0.6876128912,
0.1989751458,
0.4224951267,
-0.3607513011,
-0.3629002869,
-0.5275457501,
0.0332241319,
-0.9840582609,
-0.3032156229,
-0.3859333396,
-0.0207649302,
-0.086187385,
0.0414600931,
-0.5642505884,
-0.4975874722,
0.1423283368,
-0.1283123493,
0.1241032109,
0.6849248409,
0.0026895246,
0.1088933572,
-0.6041099429,
0.3754813075,
0.5261316895,
0.5001993775,
0.0137243308,
-0.4702066481,
0.0653693154,
0.1069415286,
-0.4076593518,
-0.6040892005,
-0.0033503333,
0.2411551476,
0.6362050772,
0.3186003864,
0.1052677929,
0.6721792817,
-0.8029634356,
0.9316835999,
-0.0222740024,
-1.0951002836,
0.2871486545,
-0.537394762,
0.0491402857,
0.3876985908,
0.1922372282,
-0.7645673752,
-0.3276433051,
-0.7966616154,
-0.4017380774,
0.1483002007,
0.090835847,
0.1395848542,
-0.3462619781,
0.2591340542,
-0.0323699005,
0.0695389509,
-0.6592891812,
-0.0929457992,
0.0289433599,
-0.2400804013,
0.3289571404,
-0.4169632792,
-0.3682773411,
-0.0166013595,
0.4665558934,
-0.4754472375,
0.3410606682,
0.2110259831,
-0.1770221889,
0.1606806964,
0.3267273009,
0.6903239489,
0.788500011,
0.1082592383,
0.45079723,
0.4830090702,
-0.1361852735,
0.2888023555,
-0.2093619704,
-0.0866625607,
-0.4001087546,
0.5844509006,
0.5898903608,
0.3682441413,
-0.8811867237,
0.552770555,
0.092681244,
-0.3169983029,
-0.3211113513,
0.2136731744,
0.2170196027,
0.3312267065,
0.1310447454,
-0.0833849087,
0.1223212481,
-0.4310724735,
0.040293958,
0.3479829133,
-0.2151814848,
-0.3753430545,
0.7074046135,
0.385312736,
-0.2207128853,
0.5312438607,
-0.3983549178,
-0.574804306,
0.6747974157,
0.9477456212,
0.7249957323,
0.2826552093,
-0.0563014038,
0.3463275433,
0.0441753902,
-0.368632257,
0.4516939521,
-0.1902829111,
-1.0375653505,
-0.3580999076,
-0.2670240998,
-0.796276927,
0.1012360454,
-0.7557125092,
-0.0865697339,
-0.5593380332,
0.0216387995,
-0.2239026427,
-0.1011180878,
-0.5949294567,
0.1893513203,
0.2720283568,
1.1263701916,
-0.9741110206,
0.5714800954,
0.5162205696,
-0.0801010206,
-0.5263391733,
0.0821920708,
0.3239823282,
-0.7680501938,
0.7569843531,
0.1478585005,
-0.203988567,
-0.1091989428,
-0.9261246324,
-1.1946356297,
0.84490484,
0.0394608676,
-0.6972246766,
0.3366522491,
-0.2192637622,
0.6118135452,
-0.1590494812,
0.0871352106,
0.5684248209,
0.3472385406,
-0.0690995753,
-0.934646666,
0.0445931479,
-0.2542936802,
0.2734098136,
0.0325857624,
-0.8780105114,
0.7967634797,
-0.0909920856,
-0.1391764134,
0.1088756919,
0.9268011451,
0.8475782275,
0.2773816288,
0.6803178787,
0.5272259712,
0.8755801916,
-0.2769993246,
1.0721802711,
-0.1265449226,
0.4279721975,
1.2680299282,
-0.7141234875,
0.9501479864,
0.6932758093,
-0.429132849,
0.3370477259,
0.5196992159,
0.2501107752,
0.4785297513,
0.5690539479,
-0.0835450739,
-0.3664025366,
-0.0869986936,
-0.225859344,
0.2945895493,
0.5848019719,
0.3530284762,
0.0048371619,
0.0768862888,
0.0025003084,
0.3497039974,
-0.0592962839,
0.6542463899,
0.1524157226,
-0.8934692144,
0.8086736798,
-0.1328090578,
0.5655249953,
-0.2529218495,
-0.2090281099,
-0.5910536051,
0.3609466851,
0.0520600528,
-0.6458814144,
0.0558605827,
-0.0464719124,
0.1048173457,
-0.18107903,
0.5409480333,
-0.2717706859,
-0.2885754704,
0.0901088417,
0.5059302449,
0.1495259702,
0.0928167477,
-0.6364951134,
0.3138158917,
-0.2808188796,
-0.3834080994,
0.0994740054,
0.5926876664,
-0.4980210066,
0.9441418052,
0.5883213878,
0.0902545154,
0.1322087795,
0.1559526771,
0.7354056239,
-0.6132019758,
-0.5250164866,
-0.6562407017,
0.2413450181,
-0.5408697128,
-0.5265644193,
0.7783101797,
0.4530647099,
0.8081062436,
0.1241098121,
0.7166402936,
-0.105545789,
0.5610798597,
-0.7499181032,
0.2493517995,
-0.5597655773,
0.3122957647,
-0.1351263821,
-1.0290430784,
-0.1478671134,
0.6402758956,
-0.2023486793,
0.0664746016,
0.8037806153,
0.595205307,
-0.3120451272,
-0.0326608568,
0.4648348391,
0.1885195822,
0.4228913188,
0.4101822972,
1.3299651146,
-0.3943166137,
0.2012714595,
-0.2300772369,
-0.0505857579,
-0.1155375242,
-0.9920831323,
-0.9744603038,
-0.3808251023,
-0.2601312995,
-0.5428808928,
0.1069298387,
1.2074192762,
0.7709855437,
-0.8682829738,
-0.0784140974,
-0.2002553493,
0.2410690933,
-0.4841023684,
-0.155681029,
0.4318883121,
-0.4317498803,
-0.8410382271,
0.4224382043,
0.0960138738,
0.0202825572,
-0.4061268568,
-0.0141999349,
0.034321852,
0.0808233321,
0.7144776583,
0.1722003073,
-1.0876306295,
-0.5904271007,
0.1221412793,
-0.2960688174,
-0.1290393621,
0.7008827329,
-0.7326104045,
0.1391202807,
0.2838906348,
0.6950481534,
0.3727683723,
-0.0443492979,
0.4890144467,
-0.7585150599,
0.4049197137,
0.1149196103,
0.4459837377,
0.4208508134,
-0.047424227,
0.7312936187,
0.3263002932,
-0.3880886436,
-0.8524093032,
0.320499301,
-0.8047990203,
-0.091566287,
1.4200208187,
-0.141630426,
-0.2595365047,
-0.1144194677,
-0.0864777267,
-0.1800742149,
-0.1234756261,
0.5370223522,
0.7642211914,
-0.0161173865,
0.0322683007,
-0.7501941919,
0.5472612977,
0.5778336525,
-0.899543643,
0.2652767897,
0.7194674015,
0.5377176404,
-0.0006920016,
0.5561308265,
0.2187103927,
0.2764052749,
0.1287684143,
-0.1259594709,
0.0149210524,
-0.3261259794,
-0.0881233141,
-0.0092573771,
0.147049576,
-0.0752434134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03727v1
|
Content-Localization based System for Analyzing Sentiment and Hate Behaviors in Low-Resource Dialectal Arabic: English to Levantine and Gulf
| 2023-11-27T15:37:33 | 2023-11-27T15:37:33 |
Fatimah Alzamzami, Abdulmotaleb El Saddik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Even though online social movements can quickly become viral on social media,
languages can be a barrier to timely monitoring and analyzing the underlying
online social behaviors (OSB). This is especially true for under-resourced
languages on social media like dialectal Arabic; the primary language used by
Arabs on social media. Therefore, it is crucial to provide solutions to
efficiently exploit resources from high-resourced languages to solve
language-dependent OSB analysis in under-resourced languages. This paper
proposes to localize content of resources in high-resourced languages into
under-resourced Arabic dialects. Content localization goes beyond content
translation that converts text from one language to another; content
localization adapts culture, language nuances and regional preferences from one
language to a specific language/dialect. Automating understanding of the
natural and familiar day-to-day expressions in different regions, is the key to
achieve a wider analysis of OSB especially for smart cities. In this paper, we
utilize content-localization based neural machine translation to develop
sentiment and hate classifiers for two low-resourced Arabic dialects: Levantine
and Gulf. Not only this but we also leverage unsupervised learning to
facilitate the analysis of sentiment and hate predictions by inferring hidden
topics from the corresponding data and providing coherent interpretations of
those topics in their native language/dialects. The experimental evaluations
and proof-of-concept COVID-19 case study on real data have validated the
effectiveness of our proposed system in precisely distinguishing sentiments and
accurately identifying hate content in both Levantine and Gulf Arabic dialects.
Our findings shed light on the importance of considering the unique nature of
dialects within the same language and ignoring the dialectal aspect would lead
to misleading analysis.
|
[
-0.5587181449,
-0.7715314627,
0.2081638426,
0.2735229731,
-0.3314905167,
0.3697054982,
-0.4529125988,
-0.2457913905,
0.5979668498,
0.4225311577,
-0.3638795316,
-0.7684118748,
-0.553347826,
-0.173856616,
-0.1530554295,
1.279276967,
0.1410026699,
0.2671402693,
0.1240201592,
-0.4100053608,
-0.1661826372,
-0.6732901931,
-0.9316508174,
-0.0718894452,
0.5074031353,
0.4207161963,
0.7630622387,
0.077565603,
0.4766211212,
0.2886700034,
-0.1684044749,
0.0477818362,
-0.4076674879,
-0.0465492234,
-0.3369007111,
-0.0418455638,
-0.1443834454,
-0.525993526,
0.1742884368,
0.4582188427,
-0.1907224357,
0.1521670967,
-0.0682801604,
0.6679074764,
-0.5171061754,
0.0430962481,
-0.5612998605,
0.0498582609,
-0.1991630346,
0.0909781232,
0.1683128476,
-0.4563127458,
-0.0331162587,
-0.0248139817,
0.3337715566,
-0.327206552,
0.5027704239,
0.1873892993,
-0.5404691696,
-0.3287280202,
-0.68254143,
0.992656827,
-0.76579386,
0.2781637907,
0.2849363387,
0.161786586,
-0.0261759497,
-0.1401406378,
-0.6403536797,
0.1401422769,
-0.1529315412,
0.0896884724,
-0.2530226707,
-0.1224310175,
-0.1795448214,
0.2125765234,
-0.479688406,
-0.1158415303,
-0.3651706278,
-0.3721173406,
0.8575494289,
-0.0098176179,
0.4064490497,
-0.6289010048,
-0.1258475929,
0.2135198414,
-0.4967530668,
0.2126381844,
0.3333350718,
0.4884739816,
-0.4091382027,
0.2106732428,
-0.3754941523,
0.2099926323,
0.1223246753,
-0.1271709651,
0.4043611586,
-0.218349427,
0.0302694906,
0.3796335459,
0.8645610213,
0.2476455718,
0.1714215726,
-0.1722444743,
-0.3382116258,
0.1426801234,
0.3227064312,
-0.8024583459,
0.1010973901,
0.2512770593,
-0.653991878,
-0.3947664797,
-0.3623712957,
-0.7084621191,
-0.7861011028,
-0.0500791185,
0.2123876661,
-0.3965312839,
-0.3452738523,
-0.0235875864,
0.1102128103,
0.0629011169,
0.2877032459,
-0.8359428644,
0.4107245803,
0.3499906957,
0.9819948077,
-0.3666342497,
0.1438457072,
-0.1465267837,
-0.091964297,
-0.210069567,
0.4319114685,
-0.2871342599,
-0.2663057446,
0.231598109,
-0.2311050892,
0.1945604086,
-0.6935654879,
0.53180933,
-0.8075883985,
-0.2209381759,
-0.208038941,
-0.0063798712,
-0.3649183214,
0.3727814853,
-0.6553895473,
0.9245878458,
0.2374147177,
-0.7215088606,
-0.1319395304,
-0.6790350676,
-0.7452112436,
-0.1406724602,
0.0457753502,
-0.3613035977,
0.2437690645,
0.2879342139,
0.5401654243,
-0.086492613,
0.3271666467,
-0.1093844324,
-0.2397072762,
0.3589380383,
-0.2865816057,
0.7526469231,
0.6137756705,
-0.7403843999,
0.1138301715,
-0.6479907632,
-0.148011744,
0.1336161345,
-0.2508360744,
-0.4812580645,
0.3158545792,
0.4562686384,
0.2302473187,
0.4448902309,
-0.7615535855,
-0.1575341821,
-0.4124335051,
0.1610941142,
0.5999441147,
0.1023240611,
0.5252351761,
-0.1195768937,
0.599285543,
0.3791900277,
0.119081676,
0.3985935152,
-0.2443149239,
-0.8286575079,
-0.0948714688,
-0.2676340938,
0.5584512949,
-0.9526674747,
0.1198132038,
-0.1084428951,
-0.6378887892,
-0.3263703287,
0.2751989365,
0.2641226053,
0.2272164077,
0.4750244319,
-0.5038069487,
-0.8255264163,
-0.7236850858,
-0.1766855419,
-0.0423755795,
0.3737255335,
0.1997056901,
0.1678300053,
-0.4039311409,
0.7997838855,
-0.2016098946,
-0.3863470256,
-0.6329795122,
0.2568495274,
0.2164038271,
0.1248488277,
0.6549550891,
-0.8714097738,
-0.8546776175,
0.2421899885,
-0.5018299818,
-0.3000954986,
-0.1336961538,
-0.0352139622,
0.4901332557,
0.3926626444,
-0.1700158119,
0.5026291013,
0.6361514926,
-0.3223921359,
0.165992707,
0.3297511935,
0.324202776,
-1.1980420351,
-0.1908574551,
0.1372144222,
-0.12900877,
-0.6512519121,
-0.0940026939,
-0.4507555664,
-0.1086605117,
-0.6424341798,
0.5049530864,
-0.0558984801,
0.0167447496,
-0.3226811886,
-0.1336465776,
-0.2623690963,
0.4784606695,
0.3021947742,
0.5741709471,
0.1487628073,
-0.2710881829,
0.6149732471,
0.0062690102,
-0.4463508129,
0.4194609821,
-0.3981587589,
-0.0087073268,
-0.3248747289,
0.0129099553,
-0.7066844106,
0.1003067791,
0.3992764354,
-0.4236793816,
-0.2225196064,
-0.2028093189,
-0.2967216969,
0.0665362254,
-0.1874961555,
0.5286978483,
0.400431335,
-0.2223332226,
0.4825925231,
0.4096682072,
-0.4544838965,
-0.5368593931,
-0.4568683803,
-0.1183475405,
-0.3325821757,
-0.4318775237,
0.1968441308,
-0.0132362926,
-0.6150792837,
0.0436529554,
0.1777496487,
-0.402654916,
0.1046614945,
0.5256055593,
0.0559742488,
-0.2474185973,
0.0439751893,
0.1019885093,
0.2463073134,
0.0058698934,
-0.3635617495,
0.740375936,
-0.3269268274,
-0.1197094098,
-0.1888984591,
0.5213266015,
0.6928111911,
-0.3505252004,
0.9444449544,
1.1362631321,
-0.3620502353,
-0.108167164,
-0.4662479162,
-0.0274546947,
-0.4945451319,
0.5972090364,
-0.0827515274,
-0.8389484882,
0.6176531315,
0.1538046002,
-0.3955156505,
0.2919825912,
0.6928111911,
-0.1421474516,
0.8230534792,
0.4816819131,
-0.6079124212,
0.6164786816,
-0.2072520703,
0.4284950197,
-0.3537423909,
-0.1330763102,
-0.3866068125,
-0.4913756549,
-0.6791169643,
-0.3926410079,
0.6290257573,
-0.1025321633,
-0.3845979869,
0.1233377233,
-0.2192592025,
0.3522287607,
0.4095996022,
0.1155247539,
-0.0083518736,
0.5267022252,
0.0927733183,
-0.4238163829,
-0.7099066973,
-0.3359519541,
0.6883320808,
0.18218261,
0.6864685416,
0.5193886161,
0.8595309854,
0.9934948087,
0.4082648754,
-1.105109334,
0.4081883132,
-0.2793467045,
-0.4137229919,
-0.2743502855,
-0.3733584583,
-0.8393828869,
0.0143845519,
-0.1498481184,
-0.6173315644,
0.2106842101,
-0.1518868804,
-0.4749254882,
0.432000041,
-0.4322570562,
0.858982265,
-0.3476271033,
-0.4062636793,
-0.6111768484,
-0.226414308,
-0.0980357155,
-0.0528590977,
0.7089710832,
0.169324711,
0.2632064223,
0.7219151855,
-0.4758290946,
1.0880326033,
-0.2672851682,
-0.1163618937,
0.6456715465,
0.3083013892,
0.3240411282,
-0.090828456,
-0.2440950572,
0.5151420236,
-0.0048797769,
-0.5711152554,
-0.4961941242,
0.836374402,
-1.1837935448,
-0.2440222204,
-0.4854474068,
-0.3990884423,
-0.0750454888,
0.1035166979,
0.0988713279,
0.4115031064,
-0.3667189777,
-0.0558595322,
0.5332682133,
-0.4495733082,
0.4871596992,
0.828769505,
-0.0479195341,
-0.5241481066,
1.4277532101,
0.1889498681,
-0.0571411885,
0.3174417913,
0.1294380128,
-0.078899309,
-0.6333069801,
-0.4718379676,
0.0716277584,
-0.5945281386,
-0.1269319504,
-0.4200034738,
-0.1098359302,
-0.5926321745,
-0.461587429,
-0.5286474824,
-0.0622832812,
0.0333451256,
0.1449999064,
0.2168475837,
0.9607551098,
-0.2708894312,
0.4831218421,
-0.9374104142,
0.1181478128,
-0.0379482955,
0.0491158962,
0.0190625247,
-0.5294497609,
-0.7987817526,
0.0303976778,
-0.3796925843,
-1.057633996,
0.7337974906,
-0.0552437678,
-0.0151214246,
0.6195286512,
0.3196833134,
0.3983850479,
-0.3393423557,
0.7037401795,
0.0720742196,
-1.000901103,
0.5277929902,
-0.4329601526,
0.0601080619,
0.3760794401,
0.7210878134,
-0.9749712348,
-0.2421639264,
-0.4206297398,
-0.8177245855,
0.684147656,
-0.0424279012,
0.3820423484,
-0.3863229156,
0.1253394783,
-0.0131469518,
0.3128941357,
-0.7141361237,
-0.3048259318,
-0.3585441709,
-0.5025841594,
0.0421739891,
-0.282043308,
0.1175473332,
-0.2215708047,
0.8819352388,
-0.0880973339,
0.0763788223,
0.1064829975,
-0.1971178949,
-0.2350626588,
0.4338871539,
0.1290690154,
0.1724279821,
-0.3026835918,
0.1638114899,
0.1482210457,
-0.4732061028,
0.1665905267,
-0.125282228,
-0.4662483633,
0.1739335656,
0.1579755247,
0.5081803203,
-0.0565819591,
-0.6745566726,
0.7291824222,
0.1365328282,
0.5123489499,
-0.6854227185,
-0.2541936636,
0.0283031873,
0.3766813874,
0.2186844349,
0.3305364251,
0.1860699207,
-0.7403072119,
0.0341155715,
0.5715559721,
-0.7452774048,
-0.4308679998,
0.1017028242,
0.4070493579,
-0.1376856118,
0.4226670861,
-0.6395509839,
-0.8708387613,
0.7638271451,
0.4307758808,
0.6696876287,
-0.1824444234,
0.7159724236,
0.4399386942,
0.2829229832,
0.4678820968,
0.4510961175,
-0.1494600028,
-1.0817381144,
-0.3281758726,
-0.8851901889,
-0.1484439373,
0.2489681542,
-0.7019492984,
-0.0129702436,
-0.7209743261,
-0.1059620306,
-0.2664825916,
0.1328987479,
-0.5950528383,
0.4885363281,
0.5154716969,
0.4842271805,
-0.8572405577,
0.6845626235,
1.0916171074,
-0.3107246757,
-0.5329027176,
0.0973324478,
0.0941987783,
-0.6607752442,
0.8730154634,
-0.1674910486,
-0.2983848751,
-0.0973900706,
-0.5400743484,
-0.8522770405,
0.6143318415,
0.0777749121,
-0.1954449564,
0.4326415658,
0.4575970471,
0.6938331127,
-0.1641555279,
0.3724981248,
0.210040465,
0.1986840516,
-0.1576270908,
-0.6473358274,
0.0714142323,
-0.2596139014,
-0.2032213956,
0.1198759899,
-1.0276266336,
0.7787210345,
-0.1394243091,
-0.0911141559,
-0.1263776571,
0.6534454823,
-0.4478370547,
0.4624351561,
0.3433314264,
0.4208039045,
0.2847899497,
0.0887011141,
0.7145518661,
-0.3525036573,
0.3238404989,
0.8866180778,
-0.1728940457,
0.8568560481,
0.4790519774,
-0.1777889282,
0.7740306258,
0.4263347089,
0.3686857224,
0.7042066455,
0.3085146546,
-0.8568230867,
-0.2045248449,
-0.8627502322,
-0.0490393564,
0.6233913302,
0.4262970686,
-0.2162457705,
-0.1812166572,
0.0302526318,
0.2644257843,
0.2940405011,
-0.560205996,
0.73429811,
-0.0620877892,
-0.3840768337,
0.5450845957,
0.6368866563,
0.8381736875,
-0.6112360358,
0.2784677446,
-0.5146185756,
0.0710948259,
-0.4902497828,
-0.4149431288,
0.7599675655,
0.1955934465,
-0.3319504857,
-0.2062458545,
0.7427973747,
-0.3468946815,
-0.4164617062,
0.4612387121,
0.6156322956,
0.0988591313,
-0.3602390885,
-0.5892882347,
0.1751274765,
0.1350076348,
-0.1259704679,
0.4222279787,
0.5675025582,
-0.3130707145,
0.3076838255,
0.5668308139,
0.4919824302,
-0.1254628599,
0.2135832012,
0.7492669821,
-0.7065416574,
-0.437875241,
-0.8089545965,
0.1616961658,
0.1171738803,
-0.0393049642,
0.6981009245,
0.5072892308,
1.0790327787,
-0.0778260157,
1.1352257729,
-0.3358356953,
0.3620863259,
-0.1470042318,
0.997310102,
-0.6470338702,
0.129280597,
-0.207681179,
-0.6285916567,
0.0321914554,
0.6650793552,
-0.5212571621,
-0.323881954,
0.5511884689,
0.9063871503,
-0.0937054455,
-0.2132365108,
0.3161207438,
0.3628477156,
0.0462957062,
0.4353564084,
0.6045351028,
-0.340465039,
0.5264328122,
-0.4881615341,
-0.0724171996,
-0.0850869343,
-0.4919820428,
-0.9298902154,
-0.4463564157,
-0.3428379595,
-0.7708765268,
0.0844950676,
1.3006956577,
0.456982553,
-1.2351988554,
-0.4123998284,
0.1316301823,
0.3912876844,
-0.0185621642,
-0.3443560302,
0.291010648,
-0.1969047189,
-0.6413895488,
0.2178553641,
0.1843584776,
-0.1777059436,
-0.3298365772,
-0.3122729659,
0.0260780752,
0.28944242,
0.7548545003,
0.2995318174,
-0.464656204,
-0.2706765234,
-0.1186428294,
-0.4024457335,
-0.0644350499,
0.7571004033,
-0.8261634707,
0.2896749675,
0.4160538316,
0.7008303404,
0.1169730052,
-0.1082131043,
0.1208131835,
-0.8554165959,
0.2815922201,
0.1231493428,
0.2907961309,
0.5848065615,
-0.4144766331,
0.2438001186,
0.5862083435,
-0.1925683916,
-0.2499217987,
0.4717306793,
-0.7197044492,
-0.0455413274,
1.2323352098,
-0.1370665878,
-0.1897576898,
-0.269810915,
-0.445512861,
0.4959405065,
-0.7358421683,
1.2794556618,
0.5871189833,
0.1817613989,
-0.0503687374,
-0.3946102858,
0.4997349083,
0.728511095,
-0.6119333506,
-0.5028232336,
0.5010834932,
0.1174220517,
0.2292689383,
0.7827733159,
0.1251526922,
0.1015360281,
-0.3648878336,
0.2465643883,
0.2616167068,
0.0200266391,
-0.2248425484,
0.0816239342,
-0.1492903531,
-0.011896627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16483v1
|
ChartLlama: A Multimodal LLM for Chart Understanding and Generation
| 2023-11-27T15:20:23 | 2023-11-27T15:20:23 |
Yucheng Han, Chi Zhang, Xin Chen, Xu Yang, Zhibin Wang, Gang Yu, Bin Fu, Hanwang Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Multi-modal large language models have demonstrated impressive performances
on most vision-language tasks. However, the model generally lacks the
understanding capabilities for specific domain data, particularly when it comes
to interpreting chart figures. This is mainly due to the lack of relevant
multi-modal instruction tuning datasets. In this article, we create a
high-quality instruction-tuning dataset leveraging GPT-4. We develop a
multi-step data generation process in which different steps are responsible for
generating tabular data, creating chart figures, and designing instruction
tuning data separately. Our method's flexibility enables us to generate
diverse, high-quality instruction-tuning data consistently and efficiently
while maintaining a low resource expenditure. Additionally, it allows us to
incorporate a wider variety of chart and task types not yet featured in
existing datasets. Next, we introduce ChartLlama, a multi-modal large language
model that we've trained using our created dataset. ChartLlama outperforms all
prior methods in ChartQA, Chart-to-text, and Chart-extraction evaluation
benchmarks. Additionally, ChartLlama significantly improves upon the baseline
in our specially compiled chart dataset, which includes new chart and task
types. The results of ChartLlama confirm the value and huge potential of our
proposed data generation method in enhancing chart comprehension.
|
[
-0.247339204,
-0.8089301586,
0.5695982575,
0.1599464417,
-0.3634156585,
0.1287349164,
-0.3833013177,
-0.2037012428,
-0.2130926102,
0.6020451188,
-0.6475692987,
-0.8857166171,
-0.6045844555,
-0.2768048346,
-0.2144300789,
0.8745766878,
-0.0623740628,
0.133185342,
0.1403028816,
0.13346304,
-0.9033766985,
-0.2652180195,
-0.6789363027,
-0.0120143946,
0.5209438801,
0.9250099063,
0.6575820446,
0.6312582493,
0.4840092063,
0.3267297447,
0.5731442571,
0.7328336239,
-0.7816315293,
0.4189020991,
0.3475968242,
-0.4818440676,
-0.7687968016,
0.1343926042,
0.5991863012,
0.5704242587,
-0.0691554248,
0.1244534999,
-0.1079851687,
0.7214867473,
-0.4689047039,
1.0068202019,
-0.6153978109,
-0.028722275,
-0.4097321332,
-0.4865938425,
-0.6558049917,
-0.5069791675,
-0.0357575566,
-0.9136184454,
0.3059906662,
0.2701739073,
0.7797194123,
0.2303684503,
-0.8339978456,
-0.5652640462,
-0.4338950813,
0.7262948751,
-0.5619719625,
0.4986655712,
0.5673875809,
0.6167584658,
0.0412060283,
-0.9564980865,
-0.378023088,
-0.2115336806,
0.2334854752,
0.4166690707,
0.0533231981,
-0.1114570126,
0.1050712392,
0.3318036199,
-0.6517780423,
0.0179949719,
-0.5141377449,
-0.1028448343,
0.4882739186,
0.4876903594,
0.2920464575,
-0.2175805271,
-0.2953161597,
-0.3615375459,
-0.9383506775,
-0.0134745156,
0.3065535724,
0.3906642795,
-0.1195601076,
0.3274726868,
0.2331397235,
0.8474139571,
0.0981427133,
-0.4233149588,
0.2751476467,
-0.4672375321,
-0.3008846641,
-0.0929365158,
0.4605242312,
0.4309905171,
0.3003492653,
-0.0252290778,
-0.1109130904,
-0.0250970367,
0.4409681559,
-0.7534141541,
-0.4734105766,
-0.3452644348,
-0.1114562452,
-0.1589353979,
-0.0396083146,
-0.7019658685,
-0.3590521812,
-0.6577031612,
0.2866044343,
-0.6555825472,
0.0624539442,
0.0119794859,
0.2551434636,
0.0832106024,
0.6234773397,
-1.0861905813,
-0.0955457091,
0.5629118681,
0.5866081715,
-0.0754029155,
-0.307477206,
-0.6110386848,
0.4762371778,
-0.8861920834,
0.6553362608,
-0.7380970716,
-0.1597171724,
-0.1246562004,
-0.0008662004,
-0.4459086955,
-0.4589738548,
0.1978860497,
-0.6424533129,
0.2352467179,
-0.2207506299,
-0.7223356366,
-0.7708585858,
0.1553267092,
-0.763905406,
0.8034553528,
0.2714051008,
-0.2258647382,
0.5546247363,
-0.6616254449,
-0.4449427128,
0.1851142943,
-0.5517429113,
-0.3599440157,
-0.0801700652,
0.522821486,
0.5142855048,
-0.4833649397,
0.0390699841,
0.0058406247,
-0.1355151087,
0.1065221801,
-0.5601685643,
0.3731840551,
0.2582107484,
-0.5002739429,
0.2756384313,
-0.5199120045,
0.2197142094,
0.0385744087,
-0.3831018806,
0.1318508834,
-0.0713468641,
0.3869418502,
0.0987478197,
0.2356480956,
-0.0767625645,
0.177229166,
-0.1089103818,
0.408488214,
0.8879163861,
0.0129237669,
0.1367721856,
-0.3163524568,
0.9354660511,
0.13042216,
0.175641641,
-0.4856521785,
-0.7138867378,
-0.914509654,
-0.3667654395,
-0.0402538069,
0.2400859296,
-0.8270406723,
0.0626904964,
-0.335424006,
-0.5072353482,
-0.1986115575,
0.4403286278,
0.2839128375,
0.7615956068,
0.2950605452,
-0.2760720551,
-0.1967376322,
-0.7805338502,
0.4193987548,
0.1887977719,
0.1659312248,
0.3633048236,
0.0166994911,
-0.1317303181,
0.5793797374,
-0.6191705465,
-0.2253599316,
-0.3822892904,
0.3278709054,
0.1662733257,
0.2610811591,
0.7033280134,
-0.6343499422,
-0.6029945016,
-0.015397856,
-0.6296861768,
0.0754396617,
-0.1990203559,
-0.3606649339,
0.1143098623,
0.2979737818,
-0.2200316489,
0.2215816975,
0.7067279816,
-0.4398367703,
0.3744224012,
-0.2889774442,
0.5216519833,
-1.2024903297,
-0.2128185928,
0.0050727646,
-0.2819882631,
-0.5886439085,
0.1685241163,
0.3919789791,
-0.2933902144,
-0.186917156,
-0.0169171467,
-0.6079906225,
-0.0467053317,
-0.3593461514,
0.1908340156,
0.1943891793,
0.435875982,
-0.1418919265,
1.0324234962,
0.7142528296,
-0.362418294,
0.6506645679,
0.2072575986,
-0.5768338442,
0.4339216948,
-0.27400437,
0.2166493982,
0.0229566358,
0.0751073062,
-1.0855585337,
-0.2723270059,
0.3517922163,
0.0727980211,
0.6206686497,
-0.1032904536,
-0.4733317792,
-0.1734089404,
-0.1622314304,
0.2934928536,
0.3114075959,
-0.5485005379,
0.347713232,
0.4294311702,
-0.3207690716,
-0.2868581712,
-0.42997244,
0.1656738669,
-0.2415843308,
-0.8073610067,
-0.0012177086,
-0.2126947939,
0.1631368548,
-0.4338509142,
-0.1645514667,
-0.1823592186,
-0.1924823523,
0.3919675648,
0.4321891665,
-0.5834152102,
0.2711470425,
0.033863917,
-0.2340728492,
-0.0612720922,
-0.0416344814,
0.4816969037,
-0.1768835634,
-0.5868450403,
-0.4305635989,
0.1098287627,
0.5879454017,
-0.2815914452,
0.1552852392,
0.6807598472,
-0.081712462,
-0.3245100975,
-0.2991065383,
-0.0814606696,
-0.5623306036,
0.4531500936,
-0.2321283966,
-0.5571998358,
-0.0019951125,
-0.0411888622,
0.2728848159,
0.2013663054,
0.8561433554,
-0.0895960182,
0.8970471025,
0.3258058727,
0.0860916302,
0.3975966871,
-0.3841022849,
0.2747132778,
-0.4312602282,
-0.1087299734,
-0.1733124256,
-0.510868609,
-0.2833324671,
-0.7792623043,
0.7240564227,
-0.0791465566,
-0.1173631996,
0.1668679416,
-0.3927719295,
0.29459095,
0.5550234318,
0.2537774742,
0.3787792027,
0.1131457016,
0.2460716665,
-0.3511890471,
-0.6130927205,
-0.5502884984,
1.4938367605,
-0.0108353253,
1.0379736423,
0.094545275,
0.2984622419,
0.1079619154,
0.2886282802,
-0.6604078412,
0.4226992428,
-0.1953083873,
-0.4809360802,
-0.2926289439,
-0.4085617363,
-1.1204071045,
0.1781577617,
-0.0587286986,
-0.4529076517,
-0.1963131577,
0.2966196537,
-0.121542491,
0.0316094458,
-1.0684899092,
1.0642135143,
-0.5000908375,
-0.1231718659,
-0.4243423641,
-0.3091983497,
0.5023198724,
-0.3345781863,
0.3112109303,
-0.3065063357,
-0.0415488966,
0.5903879404,
-0.2767946124,
0.8322955966,
-0.0550063327,
-0.436311543,
0.1913091093,
0.1524259746,
0.2815309465,
0.1638235152,
0.1027981415,
-0.1791180819,
-0.1202697381,
-0.3198169172,
-0.6658562422,
0.7950379848,
-0.778504014,
-0.5130060315,
-0.0952432379,
-1.2022246122,
-0.4408204257,
-0.0319328755,
-0.0262989178,
0.7849771976,
0.3273832798,
0.3027720153,
0.2174651176,
-0.095852159,
0.2330346256,
0.4180310071,
-0.137724489,
-0.2166403234,
1.197688818,
0.1127568185,
0.2461043596,
0.2448402196,
-0.0341158509,
-0.271487236,
-0.4667944312,
-0.6018312573,
-0.0112588843,
-0.95759058,
-0.143825829,
0.1103759706,
-0.0296700671,
-0.3680537343,
-0.1033706963,
-0.2816593349,
-0.4077674747,
-0.2315010279,
-0.0529200509,
0.5257502198,
1.003508091,
0.0243275333,
0.4032702744,
-0.6739941835,
0.3697761893,
0.5398080945,
-0.1023036391,
-0.0035871363,
-0.3619506061,
-0.4797881246,
0.0221395157,
-0.7447003126,
-0.9658446908,
0.3888221681,
0.442546159,
0.4272111356,
0.7531516552,
-0.3073979318,
0.8752109408,
-0.5028441548,
0.6540823579,
0.2411009818,
-0.8717842102,
0.4912545383,
-0.3631595969,
0.3513725102,
0.1223074198,
0.233253926,
-0.4346708357,
-0.575116396,
-0.2123131156,
-0.9082033634,
0.8635960221,
0.0730253235,
0.0517598875,
0.178100273,
0.144647643,
0.4899189472,
0.2182296365,
-0.5675090551,
-0.2898855209,
-0.6281704307,
-0.486836195,
-0.5664963126,
0.1596303731,
-0.3255648911,
-0.3708851635,
0.5245650411,
-0.4252158105,
-0.0678213462,
-0.4980038106,
-0.4056482315,
-0.1427165121,
0.1387875974,
0.7478692532,
1.3632876873,
0.0266254134,
0.2430231422,
-0.126134187,
-0.7392383814,
0.0293575171,
0.1320083737,
0.0017544185,
-0.164866969,
0.5582002997,
1.0869837999,
0.715133965,
-0.7654223442,
0.3052150309,
0.0299109407,
-0.075649485,
-0.0703813285,
0.3526518345,
0.3454140425,
0.3560507596,
0.4989002049,
-0.2723665237,
-0.1198587865,
-0.3272310495,
0.2409721613,
0.2158005834,
-0.0296515264,
-0.3542976081,
0.8373849988,
0.0774604082,
0.0680437759,
0.6868835092,
0.1077959836,
-0.0789553151,
0.8079332113,
0.5499051213,
0.4396087229,
-0.0750009492,
0.4360072315,
0.2450630069,
0.4124146998,
0.5943241715,
0.4460920393,
-0.0210659131,
-0.4730277658,
-0.4026466906,
-0.3194972277,
-0.446983844,
0.3498739302,
-0.5953341722,
0.068143189,
-0.2651911676,
-0.1764565706,
0.0833134428,
-0.1107920185,
-0.9095029235,
0.1348347217,
0.2136659026,
0.4219587147,
-0.6116714478,
0.9332164526,
0.6620538235,
-0.5271944404,
-1.0022480488,
0.0090601956,
0.1421548426,
-1.3060917854,
0.8201915026,
0.1990791708,
-0.0295035988,
0.1086263359,
-0.3263557553,
-0.7653310895,
1.3124024868,
0.6319664717,
-0.6821010113,
-0.1503917575,
0.2996447682,
0.2644017041,
-0.4267292619,
0.24704054,
0.472553581,
0.7715923786,
-0.0116090737,
-0.6829485893,
0.0596071035,
0.021259496,
0.0552308038,
0.0133341178,
-0.5309609771,
1.1650826931,
-0.1222227514,
-0.1798261106,
-0.2510514557,
0.4339144528,
0.1815024614,
0.1882804334,
0.5018573999,
0.4292560518,
0.7704766393,
-0.1529612988,
0.7766463161,
-0.698292613,
0.3542191386,
1.0791651011,
-0.1101495996,
0.5296381712,
0.2553362548,
0.1086246595,
0.3983923495,
0.8423541188,
-0.0082108118,
0.4220621288,
-0.0726638436,
-0.0708368197,
-0.6028093696,
0.435752362,
-0.5691853762,
0.6447973847,
0.5724346042,
-0.3822105527,
-0.6423743367,
0.0746637583,
-0.1044085547,
-0.0461230986,
-0.2358741164,
0.5189688802,
-0.0970361456,
-0.4070590436,
0.8553850651,
-0.1265293658,
0.0835130811,
-0.8086503744,
-0.1125379577,
-0.2063947916,
0.0382937938,
0.1240107864,
-0.7573899031,
-0.1816457659,
-0.1444363743,
-0.0533867143,
-0.3712213933,
0.1574515849,
-0.6411675215,
-0.5936619639,
-0.0959934667,
0.749727726,
0.0925537273,
0.240865618,
-0.6706833243,
0.1119165346,
-0.037577454,
-0.3830541074,
0.233372122,
0.5585272908,
0.096561715,
0.6263560653,
0.5208100677,
0.0460465476,
0.4717050493,
0.3394963741,
0.7056254745,
-0.5218313336,
-0.5089167953,
-0.3560258448,
0.2450376451,
0.1160534471,
-0.4003441334,
0.8832793832,
0.7200306654,
0.5711490512,
-0.2602132857,
0.7376940846,
0.2398008853,
0.2606350183,
-0.8668861389,
0.7773943543,
-0.6625309587,
0.0203953367,
-0.1725052297,
-0.7261397839,
-0.0985140949,
0.5380369425,
-0.3587903976,
0.0777042881,
0.8987666965,
0.9028165936,
-0.3327284455,
0.2399985343,
0.3751194477,
0.1759606004,
0.4469029307,
0.8052843213,
0.6522785425,
-0.2681678236,
0.7507737875,
-0.1703395844,
-0.2832761109,
-0.1920816302,
-0.5571553111,
-0.8107286096,
-0.9655675292,
-0.1291766614,
0.2162443697,
-0.090661414,
0.516241014,
1.0881273746,
-0.7739703059,
-0.5028128028,
0.1077309176,
-0.0272331908,
-0.3071683049,
-0.2498802096,
0.5243964195,
-0.9696701169,
-1.0397291183,
0.8590456843,
0.4363979399,
-0.1768774092,
-0.3252322078,
-0.2392222136,
0.0957367122,
-0.1421135366,
0.6862155199,
-0.0387751199,
-0.6099177599,
-0.3604876995,
-0.1984051466,
-0.1548107862,
0.3964097798,
0.955203414,
-0.3177067637,
0.7873250842,
0.1240654141,
0.5238004327,
0.8332766294,
-0.1720484793,
0.6333729625,
-0.6437932849,
0.0864825025,
0.0017343336,
0.4319769442,
0.2025548667,
-0.1447023749,
0.4200488925,
0.0647831038,
-0.5496111512,
-0.4415521622,
0.2053238451,
-1.0368931293,
-0.2217344642,
0.8002132177,
-0.014583692,
0.047152549,
-0.0059773456,
-0.4525607824,
0.2752406299,
-0.4362373948,
0.961628139,
0.6917914152,
-0.3898463845,
-0.3280270696,
-0.859277308,
0.2957424521,
0.1207912862,
-1.1525521278,
0.0318237878,
1.0071583986,
0.1821472645,
-0.0921746567,
0.5323990583,
0.0617221743,
0.4944711626,
-0.0445706584,
-0.1907494813,
-0.2331580222,
-0.4132128358,
0.2230954617,
0.4066735804,
0.1904221326,
-0.3931091726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15896v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15896v1
|
Data Generation for Post-OCR correction of Cyrillic handwriting
| 2023-11-27T15:01:26 | 2023-11-27T15:01:26 |
Evgenii Davydkin, Aleksandr Markelov, Egor Iuldashev, Anton Dudkin, Ivan Krivorotov
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a novel approach to post-Optical Character Recognition
Correction (POC) for handwritten Cyrillic text, addressing a significant gap in
current research methodologies. This gap is due to the lack of large text
corporas that provide OCR errors for further training of language-based POC
models, which are demanding in terms of corpora size. Our study primarily
focuses on the development and application of a synthetic handwriting
generation engine based on B\'ezier curves. Such an engine generates highly
realistic handwritten text in any amounts, which we utilize to create a
substantial dataset by transforming Russian text corpora sourced from the
internet. We apply a Handwritten Text Recognition (HTR) model to this dataset
to identify OCR errors, forming the basis for our POC model training. The
correction model is trained on a 90-symbol input context, utilizing a
pre-trained T5 architecture with a seq2seq correction task. We evaluate our
approach on HWR200 and School_notebooks_RU datasets as they provide significant
challenges in the HTR domain. Furthermore, POC can be used to highlight errors
for teachers, evaluating student performance. This can be done simply by
comparing sentences before and after correction, displaying differences in
text. Our primary contribution lies in the innovative use of B\'ezier curves
for Cyrillic text generation and subsequent error correction using a
specialized POC model. We validate our approach by presenting Word Accuracy
Rate (WAR) and Character Accuracy Rate (CAR) results, both with and without
post-OCR correction, using real open corporas of handwritten Cyrillic text.
These results, coupled with our methodology, are designed to be reproducible,
paving the way for further advancements in the field of OCR and handwritten
text analysis. Paper contributions can be found in
https://github.com/dbrainio/CyrillicHandwritingPOC
|
[
0.2125072628,
-0.621065557,
0.4510848224,
-0.2986502349,
-0.3524157107,
0.0872667879,
-0.1274609566,
-0.3776331246,
0.0686184466,
0.456164062,
-0.4610735774,
-0.7929286361,
-0.3757980764,
0.2935271561,
0.0361112989,
0.9708317518,
-0.4817495942,
0.5290902853,
0.0802550614,
0.1214645281,
-0.0070286132,
-0.4299398661,
-0.2289021164,
0.3115908206,
0.4913299084,
0.8049061298,
0.2274218649,
0.3668491244,
0.7485700846,
0.2266633809,
0.1721777171,
0.1518000364,
-0.3257464468,
0.0862891898,
0.2255113125,
-0.246299386,
-0.820481658,
-0.1569761336,
0.9987338781,
0.5082380772,
-0.4165463448,
0.0690063313,
-0.0879572108,
0.5678510666,
-0.765951395,
-0.165029183,
-0.3848999441,
0.0990892425,
-0.5296567082,
-0.0084124748,
-0.5897595882,
-0.7816752791,
0.0532313623,
-0.6875859499,
0.3145928383,
0.1428406984,
0.774415791,
-0.1868916452,
-0.0079487097,
-0.7603209019,
-0.9509404302,
0.7593542933,
-0.4887427986,
0.1951470524,
0.4463787377,
0.3875696063,
-0.1159584299,
-0.754930079,
-0.6377724409,
0.0165951811,
0.1387699991,
0.3855936825,
0.2176326364,
-0.0625544712,
0.3462371528,
0.5375878215,
-0.5458475947,
-0.1404668689,
-0.6793661118,
-0.3782359064,
0.3350163102,
0.2137408704,
0.2785710096,
0.2284374088,
0.1005450487,
-0.1096870154,
-0.8608167171,
-0.0217944328,
1.0899572372,
0.1280853301,
0.0241805501,
0.796864748,
-0.0805111602,
0.765222013,
0.2089372724,
-0.274432987,
0.2030615807,
-0.5016586185,
0.000764442,
0.3599046767,
0.6957691908,
0.0591457188,
0.1610858589,
0.0565952435,
0.1082704589,
0.0530139282,
0.3528813422,
-0.9298589826,
-0.1905080527,
-0.2162024975,
-0.4500834346,
-0.3060883582,
0.2227619886,
-0.9048993587,
-0.2663273513,
-0.2270788699,
0.2834481299,
-0.4187582135,
-0.0980117917,
0.3218043149,
0.0576969758,
0.1486694813,
0.5072908998,
-1.0177330971,
0.1111215651,
0.2831884027,
0.8485084176,
0.3224377632,
-0.3233245611,
-0.5830916166,
-0.0587511808,
-0.4588169754,
0.7362636328,
-0.3982802033,
-0.2683345079,
0.2089972943,
-0.229559347,
0.0283799469,
-0.2492570579,
0.5633072853,
-0.2569086552,
0.5326080918,
-0.1526307017,
-0.0719034895,
0.4421646595,
-0.0141557185,
-0.4945459664,
0.9934674501,
0.3927841187,
-1.0829265118,
0.5903648734,
-0.3190184832,
-0.6174638271,
0.1620820165,
0.1517643481,
-1.0111899376,
0.0715267062,
-0.2030238509,
0.2136781961,
-0.4700654149,
-0.1887764633,
-0.2813937366,
-0.3949072063,
0.1584837884,
0.0749187917,
0.8190328479,
0.3761995435,
-0.248201251,
0.0973558053,
-1.0974103212,
0.1081294268,
-0.2887926996,
-0.5695836544,
-0.1352378428,
-0.1464082748,
0.1889795363,
0.1435955018,
0.3742205799,
-1.1979649067,
0.3667337298,
-0.3234487176,
0.3721870482,
0.3721224666,
-0.258500576,
0.5804691911,
-0.1703191549,
0.5232889652,
-0.3512544632,
0.2532244325,
-0.178456977,
-0.3210447729,
-0.5660663247,
-0.4355488718,
0.6196739078,
0.5862002373,
-0.9896932244,
0.5985227823,
-0.0765523463,
-0.7135812044,
-0.6273154616,
-0.2538156509,
0.5532002449,
0.6719591022,
0.1118896753,
-0.4597371221,
-0.7593868971,
-0.5273253322,
-0.1558874696,
-0.3289526105,
-0.1111537367,
0.0931568071,
0.5092568994,
0.3871363401,
0.4744621217,
-0.4641850591,
-0.6525757909,
-0.2528409958,
0.4057067931,
-0.0307550356,
0.5163525343,
0.1729706675,
-0.3985667527,
-1.0097162724,
0.1617722511,
-0.5558001399,
-0.1208316907,
0.0574009158,
-0.3175179958,
0.8357049823,
0.3913911879,
-0.3593880236,
0.754345715,
0.2038791031,
-0.588588357,
1.05656147,
-0.7107331157,
0.6336450577,
-0.9360990524,
0.4923675954,
-0.3130465746,
0.1075413227,
-0.8852632642,
-0.1744246185,
0.1821460128,
-0.1711304933,
-0.3173724115,
0.0178117771,
-0.7220342755,
-0.1678047627,
0.0703150705,
-0.23519665,
-0.3656863868,
0.2334767729,
0.2176369727,
0.5464470983,
0.50285393,
0.0090107853,
0.2841260135,
0.3155582547,
-0.8214295506,
0.8897693157,
-0.3443388641,
0.4112144709,
-0.1238130629,
0.0035684681,
-1.1529554129,
-0.2754820883,
0.5587460995,
-0.7150259614,
0.4238185287,
-0.1484258324,
-0.8255748153,
-0.2779116035,
-0.0520129763,
0.1818782389,
0.770604074,
-0.1361141056,
0.7833253741,
0.1333009154,
-0.2334498763,
-0.4508746266,
-0.5816625953,
0.0443322025,
0.0365968086,
-0.9177058935,
0.4598093927,
-0.0551372953,
0.0694079325,
-0.2255593836,
0.1979381442,
-0.1332888454,
-0.1388224065,
-0.0399052612,
0.4317474365,
-0.3009568751,
-0.3168646991,
0.0343150906,
0.0948492214,
-0.2696373761,
-0.4722643197,
0.5707845092,
0.0667026266,
0.110025309,
-0.6916733384,
0.1894033104,
0.658177495,
-0.3937691748,
0.8411380053,
0.5093438029,
-0.3500585258,
0.0493938327,
-0.3392558098,
0.0348573923,
-0.3999875784,
0.0450765677,
-0.443593204,
-0.5084258914,
0.7038618922,
0.3157367706,
-0.1305783838,
0.1448473632,
0.5332236886,
-0.0913341045,
0.6095240116,
0.3631163836,
0.389289856,
0.5610354543,
-0.119388938,
0.3628482521,
-0.7164409161,
-0.2971322834,
-0.760546267,
-0.1131525114,
-0.3892909884,
-0.1778106242,
0.1717958301,
-0.0050271954,
-0.0070406967,
0.3193215728,
-0.362342447,
0.3958091438,
0.4877470136,
0.0042018425,
0.0988395587,
0.3963913918,
-0.3108227849,
-0.2423857152,
-0.429487884,
-0.4483563304,
1.2208046913,
-0.0505184419,
0.5848619342,
-0.1511932462,
0.6132642031,
0.0314991847,
0.2235300392,
-0.5230721831,
0.3892171979,
-0.3342848718,
-0.5482324362,
-0.5314010978,
-0.4066700339,
-0.6603009701,
-0.149818927,
-0.468329668,
-0.6012126803,
0.1391292959,
0.5308382511,
-0.2798080146,
0.4158353806,
-0.5476311445,
1.1295480728,
-0.0541626215,
-0.8128775358,
0.0378833935,
-0.6777526736,
-0.2623684108,
0.1268660426,
-0.1839858294,
0.535662055,
0.2939552367,
0.5562538505,
-0.6825637817,
0.5573077202,
-0.4215610623,
-0.1930091381,
0.4889011979,
0.0077542551,
0.6256294847,
-0.7382221818,
-0.1947444677,
0.144024834,
-0.3041275144,
-0.3562704921,
-0.3529948592,
0.3942316175,
-0.5798032284,
-0.0853195116,
-0.7522069216,
-0.1935555637,
0.2688415647,
0.3817276955,
0.703265965,
0.626074791,
-0.2907492518,
0.1622717083,
0.3077162504,
-0.1844337732,
0.0904435068,
0.7252061367,
-0.0453015789,
-0.7939181328,
1.01704216,
0.4880228341,
0.2945365608,
0.4020665884,
0.0688291714,
-0.1520746499,
-1.0216602087,
-0.7737595439,
0.3516054451,
-0.4435916245,
0.0988102034,
-0.2528133392,
0.2100653499,
-0.7562058568,
-0.2479069233,
-0.1278737485,
-0.2422214001,
-0.5075063705,
0.1791338474,
-0.0218664818,
0.8130934834,
0.0109894779,
0.5787582397,
-0.3537090421,
0.0216130689,
-0.3117524385,
0.3036647141,
-0.1925520599,
-0.4828223884,
-0.4226176143,
-0.0252272487,
-0.4233101606,
-0.7490486503,
0.5602983236,
0.1596383899,
0.034821067,
0.0217243843,
-0.0253556687,
0.6221456528,
-0.7416645288,
0.5097927451,
0.3462123275,
-1.0475043058,
0.3381552994,
-0.6120938063,
0.3843269348,
0.5613437891,
0.3269900978,
-0.6223146915,
-0.3596531451,
-0.4862430692,
-0.6262472868,
1.1639487743,
0.4851800203,
-0.5380156636,
0.3491746783,
0.5771510005,
0.1868067086,
0.3021760285,
-0.3041805625,
-0.0174349155,
-0.453933984,
-0.7663782835,
-0.03232456,
-0.3972326219,
0.538133502,
0.0308708772,
0.7499768734,
0.041290801,
0.2027275562,
0.4891252518,
-0.2511188686,
-0.4605229497,
0.1174876839,
0.8868612051,
0.6742691398,
-0.2394916266,
-0.0101180226,
-0.0061120326,
-1.039998889,
0.0411879234,
0.0009101948,
-0.4442721009,
-0.1718383133,
0.1926746517,
0.6226527095,
-0.2127041519,
-0.4956748784,
0.3890219927,
-0.2476753145,
-0.5126109123,
-0.7711526752,
-0.3133201301,
-0.2842835486,
-0.2452864349,
0.4936166108,
0.288290292,
0.1780342311,
-0.6501581669,
-0.0314025171,
0.2161159962,
-0.3644128144,
-0.6182386875,
0.2765156329,
0.1328734607,
-0.614436388,
0.6897912621,
-0.3699161112,
-0.5707353354,
0.5556173325,
0.504496634,
0.479198277,
-0.7485736012,
0.5139397979,
0.7493060231,
0.2814103961,
-0.1617700607,
0.5311834216,
-0.1168601066,
-0.3612840772,
-0.2567412853,
-0.6151179671,
-0.2386793792,
0.1244521737,
-0.6356856227,
0.7082525492,
-0.816708982,
0.1124941409,
0.0079213586,
0.0315215886,
-0.0860216022,
0.1284075677,
-0.0331381522,
0.2925295532,
-0.8153677583,
0.8099563122,
0.6059655547,
-0.2454773784,
-0.4139382243,
-0.0689115077,
-0.1504175514,
-0.4162691832,
0.9078955054,
0.1609946936,
-0.2687054574,
0.0590635277,
-0.1496302485,
-0.7405725121,
0.9027894139,
0.1955643147,
-0.675792098,
-0.1046988964,
0.4563610852,
0.9925005436,
-0.4814909399,
0.2868821323,
0.3839016259,
0.4175244272,
0.2911662161,
-0.8598619103,
-0.0110484445,
-0.2947983444,
-0.1854672581,
0.5211930871,
-0.3125938177,
0.8139526248,
-0.1069312915,
-0.383174181,
0.6778718829,
0.3927860856,
-0.0294188689,
0.3406585157,
0.0901435241,
0.5950948,
0.5783482194,
-0.1341699958,
0.7481101155,
0.0500394329,
0.047601115,
0.8443772197,
-0.5367662907,
0.8327845335,
0.4919474125,
-0.1423166096,
0.7260382771,
0.4136950672,
-0.1592318416,
0.6387631297,
0.4793633223,
-0.28391698,
-0.0847647265,
0.1569274068,
0.060298834,
0.3113432825,
0.0613957159,
-0.436242193,
0.0555893518,
0.1206175089,
0.0477325246,
0.2232197821,
-0.2638844848,
0.8671320081,
-0.4428161681,
-1.0327615738,
0.5095529556,
0.107926771,
0.3340521455,
-0.6900793314,
-0.1770306975,
-0.0181511622,
0.6626756191,
-0.2069222927,
-0.4523970485,
0.3550515175,
0.1602184027,
-0.2272199541,
-0.299431175,
0.6949563622,
-0.8595005274,
-0.7640067935,
-0.2133715749,
-0.3021551371,
0.3817118406,
0.2043392807,
-0.1865546405,
0.064117521,
0.2148803324,
0.3987271786,
0.1690387726,
0.4493871331,
0.2560079098,
-0.0981404409,
0.5813728571,
0.4294165671,
0.0284118988,
-0.2166599482,
0.3624228239,
-0.4007785022,
-0.6220402122,
-0.6632128358,
0.698921442,
-0.0636163205,
-0.649930656,
0.7038266659,
0.8304259181,
0.7895208597,
-0.5333990455,
0.8531500101,
-0.2135721743,
0.6859932542,
-0.8479942083,
0.9466620088,
-0.3417525589,
-0.1685129255,
-0.4441266954,
-0.7074580193,
-0.5501310825,
0.9819990396,
-0.628952682,
-0.1061487794,
1.0212471485,
0.8304222822,
0.1208381355,
0.0256033465,
0.242476806,
0.2540239692,
0.1313225031,
0.5244859457,
0.9489623904,
-0.6930802464,
0.6930251718,
-0.0673315525,
-0.2906644344,
-0.4112358391,
-0.6954313517,
-1.0461237431,
-0.8734095097,
-0.3538228273,
-0.6099036336,
0.3607821465,
0.4137046337,
0.1891556978,
-0.6650244594,
-0.3586908877,
-0.4239419997,
-0.1657686681,
0.0500033349,
-0.0730060712,
0.4553742111,
-0.0186914746,
-0.7180789113,
-0.2333396822,
0.1790041775,
0.3060457706,
-0.1286814809,
-0.1691552699,
-0.0426390618,
-0.3372383416,
0.1807868481,
0.1709531993,
-0.4230233133,
-0.0634385943,
0.3131714761,
0.0956334621,
0.2526949048,
1.224620223,
-0.1922826171,
0.6241829991,
0.7592064142,
-0.0113377096,
0.6866178513,
-0.1982137412,
0.5167012811,
-0.4314417243,
-0.0162908528,
0.2383860201,
0.3223849833,
0.6739761829,
-0.4068337679,
-0.0038167196,
0.3587931991,
-0.583735466,
-0.8905198574,
0.3284038007,
-0.7270483375,
0.0117691373,
0.8893303275,
-0.5166996121,
-0.6590097547,
-0.3285339177,
-0.7221738696,
0.2990339696,
-0.4345473051,
0.9948693514,
0.9867166877,
0.3101292849,
-0.0747204795,
0.296354264,
0.6514824033,
0.1916514933,
-0.7585132122,
0.5213316083,
0.8474388719,
0.20886603,
0.3638575971,
0.6738512516,
-0.4341731071,
0.6741042137,
0.2597678602,
0.4881655872,
-0.2511172295,
-0.7293791175,
-0.3379114866,
0.189234972,
-0.0054451241,
0.0880050883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15786v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15786v4
|
YUAN 2.0: A Large Language Model with Localized Filtering-based Attention
| 2023-11-27T13:01:59 | 2023-12-18T08:08:32 |
Shaohua Wu, Xudong Zhao, Shenling Wang, Jiangang Luo, Lingjun Li, Xi Chen, Bing Zhao, Wei Wang, Tong Yu, Rongguo Zhang, Jiahua Zhang, Chao Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
In this work, we develop and release Yuan 2.0, a series of large language
models with parameters ranging from 2.1 billion to 102.6 billion. The Localized
Filtering-based Attention (LFA) is introduced to incorporate prior knowledge of
local dependencies of natural language into Attention. A data filtering and
generating system is presented to build pre-training and fine-tuning dataset in
high quality. A distributed training method with non-uniform pipeline parallel,
data parallel, and optimizer parallel is proposed, which greatly reduces the
bandwidth requirements of intra-node communication, and achieves good
performance in large-scale distributed training. Yuan 2.0 models display
impressive ability in code generation, math problem-solving, and chatting
compared with existing models. The latest version of YUAN 2.0, including model
weights and source code, is accessible at Github.
|
[
-0.3978095651,
-0.9711242318,
0.3172593713,
0.5951651335,
-0.119543992,
-0.0083220033,
-0.5228703022,
-0.8156633973,
0.1584279686,
0.8166376352,
-0.3648456037,
-0.102887623,
-0.4626570642,
-0.0259261802,
-0.3186396658,
0.9730178714,
-0.1106941178,
0.2370906621,
0.1212611198,
-0.0363608152,
-0.4179958403,
-0.5600742698,
-1.0859447718,
-0.4388144612,
0.5936732292,
0.5347355604,
0.7838138938,
0.5809668303,
0.7987046242,
0.2656193972,
-0.0769461915,
-0.1612551957,
-0.8549396992,
-0.3049715757,
-0.1146064922,
-0.5865575075,
-0.7926163077,
-0.0710486546,
0.9309840202,
0.6565587521,
-0.1063676253,
0.3293132782,
-0.1655049324,
0.8981477618,
-0.2656404972,
0.1752109379,
-0.5842860341,
0.1289091706,
-0.3177473545,
0.3989560604,
-0.4698223174,
-0.2784889638,
0.0839556158,
-0.5701901913,
0.1988065839,
-0.1371686012,
0.9105017185,
0.3516931832,
-0.3388682604,
0.0919219702,
-0.637706995,
0.9465578794,
-0.7295649052,
0.5175637603,
0.6577805281,
0.3218876123,
-0.162894994,
-0.8573119044,
-0.2915301621,
-0.3421358466,
-0.111503683,
-0.075941138,
0.0006823367,
0.0734267011,
0.2185198516,
0.6184617877,
-0.4759787023,
0.1238040999,
-0.3469148576,
-0.0194399823,
0.658931613,
0.0321834423,
0.1923023909,
0.3230196536,
-0.1405584663,
0.2344926,
-0.9067186713,
-0.0578989312,
0.3422559798,
0.2873569429,
-0.4446084499,
0.1601785868,
-0.7270629406,
0.609180212,
0.3124773204,
-0.0138803814,
0.1482792199,
-0.2796222568,
-0.3698472977,
-0.147317946,
0.6552023888,
-0.0821960941,
0.4848026931,
-0.1104367375,
-0.2686287761,
-0.261588186,
-0.0449292362,
-0.9085611701,
-0.2087009549,
0.206695199,
-0.581040144,
-0.3303025365,
-0.1819098741,
-0.5604449511,
-0.138726905,
-0.600620687,
0.2595480978,
0.3487634659,
-0.6235288978,
0.2688137293,
0.540848434,
-0.1095722392,
0.1467448473,
-1.2135720253,
0.408636421,
0.4984180629,
0.7334280014,
-0.1707167625,
-0.1086903512,
-0.6885821819,
-0.0604876615,
-0.4772774577,
0.7187455893,
-0.1617231369,
0.0511074364,
-0.0969103277,
0.0636534393,
0.1334029436,
-0.7416190505,
0.3276537955,
-0.7845283747,
0.0271403305,
-0.0444642529,
-0.1662404984,
-0.0734698772,
0.0700998083,
-0.7996301055,
1.4185029268,
0.3723166585,
-0.8344116211,
-0.1967899948,
-0.4983735979,
-0.5414145589,
0.1050657853,
0.1191934943,
-0.1510006189,
-0.1100615337,
0.1901541054,
0.2166965455,
-0.68987602,
0.7018951178,
-0.3502877951,
-0.4819167852,
-0.2376060933,
-0.2608599663,
0.8538150787,
0.450989455,
-0.4003139436,
0.3166523576,
-0.5872935057,
-0.0654312074,
0.218853116,
-0.5771515965,
0.3005851507,
-0.0643952861,
0.2881164253,
0.2631856501,
0.7054563761,
-0.4330721796,
-0.0651678964,
-0.8108495474,
0.4244147539,
0.5839387774,
-0.3077867031,
0.5994409919,
0.1736479104,
0.3064910769,
0.0366932601,
0.3914969563,
-0.1265981346,
-0.3118107915,
-0.9377577305,
-0.1183388382,
0.2974538803,
0.3995445967,
-0.5029660463,
0.2154973298,
-0.1523859799,
-0.6373093128,
-0.2466547489,
0.3963695765,
0.4604378045,
0.1948726475,
0.0478740744,
-0.0363713205,
-0.4206359684,
-0.9486973286,
0.0644715279,
-0.0470454842,
-0.0442807674,
0.3318753839,
0.1766679734,
-0.2672129273,
0.9470267296,
-0.6418710947,
-0.3744402528,
-0.6083225608,
-0.1284138858,
0.3966264427,
0.2931125164,
0.4903300405,
-0.6452476382,
-0.8730347157,
0.4755001068,
-0.6290246844,
-0.0886155739,
0.0151751647,
-0.3240217268,
0.4527653456,
0.7573645115,
-0.4884336889,
-0.0996330753,
0.6800328493,
-0.1349835396,
0.4846350253,
-0.1780233383,
-0.3100347519,
-1.2490155697,
0.1603345871,
0.1000299603,
-0.2788612247,
-0.6596344113,
0.3251561522,
0.122660026,
-0.1479264349,
-0.3807555139,
0.9679843783,
-0.5327075124,
-0.129569903,
-0.5545322299,
0.1436708719,
-0.207063958,
0.8008463979,
0.3438562453,
0.3939485252,
0.7334057093,
-0.446557343,
0.7643657327,
-0.0484081656,
-0.4702242613,
0.0393720493,
-0.7892617583,
0.3213797212,
-0.016495131,
0.3057925403,
-0.5937633514,
-0.4265426099,
0.1601411551,
-0.4345300198,
0.3147888184,
0.0450167172,
-0.5778673291,
-0.5659021735,
-0.1577796191,
0.4086482525,
0.2218007296,
-0.6233947277,
0.186329782,
0.5162006617,
-0.4695657492,
-0.4538342655,
-0.5129737854,
0.1524051428,
0.0603204183,
-0.5559800863,
0.0481773727,
-0.1755024046,
-0.2840376496,
-0.0922654867,
0.2473040968,
-0.3502210677,
0.0581986122,
-0.0482914485,
0.0923522785,
-0.510894835,
0.203295514,
-0.1892726868,
-0.2023016959,
-0.0382999666,
-0.223226279,
0.6098544598,
0.1128988042,
0.086767599,
-0.5526797175,
0.4297454059,
0.4488816261,
-0.6674951911,
0.6603915691,
0.6985089183,
-0.7375270724,
-0.2835802436,
-0.4825841784,
-0.1981654912,
-0.5111166239,
0.9326964021,
-0.1972415745,
-1.1263065338,
0.5134096146,
0.2594611049,
0.075690791,
0.200423345,
0.7465013862,
0.4857280254,
1.2730523348,
0.8801814914,
-0.7552782893,
0.8557543755,
0.1028299704,
0.4561803043,
-0.4812198281,
0.1163818687,
-0.5171833038,
-0.0534843057,
-0.3110364676,
-0.4157874286,
0.0635876879,
0.4237699807,
-0.6598517299,
0.1514263302,
-0.40542081,
0.5676544905,
0.7061474323,
-0.0339329727,
0.0369123295,
0.0651922449,
0.3723579347,
0.1619468182,
-0.3725011647,
-0.184445262,
0.9226417542,
0.6852887273,
0.6676825285,
0.0384237319,
0.1152582392,
0.0669679791,
0.4339878559,
-0.7650948167,
0.3504858315,
-0.0988363326,
-0.7085832953,
-0.5415296555,
-0.4815957546,
-0.4753581583,
0.0190038327,
0.1164874956,
-0.7193077803,
-0.3463703096,
0.0781113207,
-0.2486944199,
0.2866623998,
-0.7228865027,
1.0173721313,
-0.0701056197,
-0.2922973931,
-0.5052616596,
-0.4729755819,
0.4172823429,
-0.3806506097,
0.0382588953,
-0.2004105151,
0.4989474714,
0.633374393,
-0.1455847323,
0.864831388,
-0.1824989766,
-0.3819785714,
0.5019638538,
-0.2075926214,
0.8964138031,
0.1884177774,
-0.0753991902,
0.3216544688,
-0.2455978543,
-0.3540206552,
-0.216968596,
0.8176212311,
-0.7609151602,
-0.6837692857,
0.0806954354,
-0.5421012044,
-0.1952412128,
0.42811957,
0.0600122772,
0.3408147097,
-0.0420205407,
0.2094691247,
0.63397789,
-0.3565602303,
0.4622626901,
0.6506025791,
-0.3331854939,
-0.5621753931,
0.9692836404,
0.0387891233,
0.2207534462,
0.5249950886,
0.066616632,
-0.0837269649,
-0.3888421059,
-0.5530100465,
0.3792140782,
-0.4746099412,
-0.2209204286,
-0.5839611888,
-0.5212614536,
-0.6811237335,
0.050838653,
-0.6376891732,
-0.0233534724,
-0.2654435337,
0.0509311929,
0.3557128012,
0.9870121479,
0.0301934183,
0.4666518867,
-0.7907579541,
0.4686158299,
0.1936918497,
0.7236982584,
0.2772872746,
-0.6071957946,
-1.1410998106,
0.000386416,
-0.2837661505,
-0.4396291971,
0.262154907,
0.1026890129,
0.4003139436,
0.6812935472,
-0.1248323545,
0.3295480311,
-0.5571064353,
0.6315096617,
0.0455542244,
-0.9144257307,
0.5375978947,
-0.7034154534,
0.3859620094,
0.138696447,
-0.0946272835,
-0.6765689254,
-0.5764238834,
-0.0806955993,
-0.583141923,
1.4163175821,
-0.0144651439,
0.3598335981,
-0.0544877723,
0.4546530545,
-0.311150223,
-0.1491144747,
-0.8996523619,
-0.2711919248,
0.1812735647,
-0.3301568925,
-0.2453320324,
-0.471989125,
0.3062158227,
-0.2465397269,
0.7962667942,
-0.1742479056,
0.1554198414,
0.0443110391,
0.1305104941,
-0.4790698886,
-0.1682344377,
0.4288070798,
0.2822926044,
-0.0192691796,
-0.1634442955,
0.1460031122,
-0.7821928263,
-0.2235928476,
0.0869300514,
-0.195742175,
-0.1508654058,
0.1391935349,
0.8034018874,
0.1606853604,
-0.6583981514,
0.2962696552,
0.1823499948,
-0.0948548391,
-0.1425787657,
-0.1002662256,
0.4555229247,
0.2241508961,
0.1386788338,
-0.2899817228,
0.1071204841,
-0.2935959399,
0.0669128448,
0.261839658,
-0.4142505825,
-0.5484747887,
0.7745730281,
0.3451220691,
-0.1340660304,
0.4482314289,
-0.0085969456,
-0.5088350773,
0.8851656914,
0.6700459719,
0.6453559995,
-0.4729654491,
0.3567195237,
0.930788517,
0.2854797244,
-0.4623994231,
0.2053808123,
-0.1723128408,
-0.6625191569,
-0.3528776467,
-0.7408573627,
-0.2274739891,
0.2745111287,
-0.4702987969,
0.3753684163,
-0.4378808737,
0.0276194401,
-0.0999799743,
0.3209318519,
-0.142618835,
0.4836308658,
0.2537273765,
0.6990859509,
-0.5578533411,
1.243710041,
0.7092854381,
-0.1332892776,
-0.985081315,
-0.1014995947,
-0.4323139787,
-0.4941169918,
0.8222689629,
0.2905041277,
0.0026642522,
0.1949226558,
-0.4253320694,
-1.457906127,
0.7095022798,
0.5688202381,
-0.6543192267,
0.0908591151,
0.3745772541,
0.6640349627,
-0.1111886054,
0.1149765179,
0.5004796386,
0.2992773056,
-0.1221321598,
-1.2553601265,
-0.2861144543,
-0.3260020018,
-0.1570336074,
0.4750189185,
-1.1558561325,
1.0695928335,
-0.3508746028,
-0.1493577063,
0.0886128247,
0.6400529742,
-0.0015970091,
0.0236418825,
0.1681884229,
0.5051199794,
0.4974356592,
0.0142098693,
0.6568340063,
-0.3703485131,
0.5044810176,
1.39945364,
-0.4829392433,
1.1285248995,
0.1184249669,
-0.2072782516,
0.1465384215,
0.9108406305,
0.1073409766,
0.5077088475,
0.1733156443,
-0.3845687211,
-0.1780403852,
-0.3679580986,
-0.2364331037,
0.1636800766,
0.0336748697,
-0.3179083169,
-0.0715229437,
-0.0988139585,
-0.0558908693,
-0.0569068193,
-0.4124597013,
0.7496400476,
0.0995725095,
-0.796775043,
0.5830444098,
0.465068996,
0.5388704538,
-0.3688954711,
0.0951320156,
-0.6298656464,
0.4885327816,
-0.0703315958,
-0.5342324972,
0.1163694635,
0.2419148535,
-0.4974852204,
-0.0023294347,
0.5915045142,
-0.5484322906,
-0.6382560134,
0.5425806642,
-0.0019112405,
0.1316143125,
-0.4334519207,
-0.4971434772,
-0.0559282042,
0.2508023381,
-0.7162487507,
0.2942152619,
0.3937334716,
-0.4509468675,
0.5833423138,
0.5996437073,
0.108320348,
-0.0413660929,
0.4256279767,
0.611336112,
-0.5715205669,
-0.6821318865,
-0.5416550636,
0.0885805488,
0.1431421936,
-0.2227550596,
0.4207270741,
0.5936106443,
0.9078209996,
-0.0398008674,
0.5310800076,
0.1769267023,
0.5297762752,
-0.1650081724,
0.9122697115,
-0.6502613425,
-0.1329825372,
0.1339317709,
-0.9501734972,
-0.3307446837,
0.2955859601,
-0.1310829669,
0.1530599594,
0.5323929787,
0.8812249303,
0.1037296206,
-0.2314411551,
0.386154145,
0.3378620446,
0.1766494215,
0.8334149718,
0.3423382044,
-0.5383521914,
0.4059007168,
-0.1620274633,
-0.1936405301,
-0.1414635032,
-0.3306696415,
-0.9542408586,
-0.362970382,
-0.0485016629,
0.1045687348,
-0.3365144432,
0.7114384174,
0.8643878102,
-0.8992280364,
-0.2501736283,
-0.2670483887,
0.0177665986,
0.2012906224,
-0.2068546265,
0.5331889987,
-0.4912489355,
-1.0275918245,
0.1453624815,
0.4192590415,
-0.0725084543,
-0.3548696339,
-0.2632534802,
0.0710311085,
0.0109324409,
0.6139152646,
0.1077550799,
-0.748492837,
0.0160658415,
0.0978552178,
-0.5166996717,
0.0454676487,
0.4393182993,
-0.4463367462,
0.2720662951,
0.4361614585,
0.4069263637,
0.333761692,
-0.2545105517,
0.5321806073,
-0.5596616864,
0.5760235786,
-0.1889433414,
0.3674339354,
0.3308549225,
-0.6690462232,
0.5089368224,
-0.0397423431,
-0.7244182229,
-0.7852199674,
0.2056498975,
-0.6514074206,
-0.1073427573,
1.2701448202,
-0.1952572316,
-0.1036289558,
-0.0339920223,
-0.4214908481,
0.3827536702,
-0.2413746268,
0.7185613513,
0.7876933813,
0.3620864749,
-0.1193324104,
-0.7542905807,
0.5294010639,
0.5300133824,
-0.9938533306,
0.5543928146,
0.4714079201,
0.2010533959,
-0.1007844806,
0.8839471936,
-0.1708981991,
0.3914529383,
0.0683774501,
0.2835295796,
0.312607795,
-0.4374044836,
-0.2755106091,
-0.1791562289,
0.2449433357,
0.0637831241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15781v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15781v1
|
Increasing Coverage and Precision of Textual Information in Multilingual Knowledge Graphs
| 2023-11-27T12:54:47 | 2023-11-27T12:54:47 |
Simone Conia, Min Li, Daniel Lee, Umar Farooq Minhas, Ihab Ilyas, Yunyao Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent work in Natural Language Processing and Computer Vision has been using
textual information -- e.g., entity names and descriptions -- available in
knowledge graphs to ground neural models to high-quality structured data.
However, when it comes to non-English languages, the quantity and quality of
textual information are comparatively scarce. To address this issue, we
introduce the novel task of automatic Knowledge Graph Enhancement (KGE) and
perform a thorough investigation on bridging the gap in both the quantity and
quality of textual information between English and non-English languages. More
specifically, we: i) bring to light the problem of increasing multilingual
coverage and precision of entity names and descriptions in Wikidata; ii)
demonstrate that state-of-the-art methods, namely, Machine Translation (MT),
Web Search (WS), and Large Language Models (LLMs), struggle with this task;
iii) present M-NTA, a novel unsupervised approach that combines MT, WS, and
LLMs to generate high-quality textual information; and, iv) study the impact of
increasing multilingual coverage and precision of non-English textual
information in Entity Linking, Knowledge Graph Completion, and Question
Answering. As part of our effort towards better multilingual knowledge graphs,
we also introduce WikiKGE-10, the first human-curated benchmark to evaluate KGE
approaches in 10 languages across 7 language families.
|
[
-0.5965272188,
-0.6404060721,
0.4804753363,
0.0170717817,
-0.1637919098,
0.2128607929,
-0.177809149,
-0.78481251,
0.5207638741,
0.3717411458,
-0.2316897959,
-0.7411966324,
-0.8177866936,
0.4569731057,
-0.1895520985,
0.5819309354,
-0.2195738703,
-0.0666205883,
-0.2814846337,
-0.3817589581,
-0.4563312531,
-0.2385623008,
-0.4240413606,
-0.3433445096,
0.6983625889,
0.3102550209,
0.7896572948,
0.5371974111,
0.2629036307,
0.3236860931,
0.09498889,
0.7123502493,
-0.3309402466,
0.028156139,
-0.0601029322,
-0.3534616828,
-0.3073103726,
-0.2214708328,
0.8257337213,
1.0588902235,
0.263956666,
0.0078825792,
0.0737700313,
0.833925128,
-0.767277658,
0.4081780314,
-0.2656907141,
-0.1681869179,
-0.255692035,
-0.0694544166,
-0.4697153866,
-0.1834042668,
0.0590468124,
-1.0503809452,
-0.2033292651,
-0.1218125895,
0.8615204692,
-0.0014506901,
-0.9394342303,
-0.2622703612,
-0.5687476993,
0.5526222587,
-0.4469235241,
0.814035356,
0.5147948265,
0.0754520819,
-0.1872927994,
-0.716571331,
-0.4516482353,
-0.1727713048,
-0.3348637223,
0.0178539976,
-0.2534101903,
-0.102276504,
0.1071700826,
0.0733453259,
-0.40694502,
-0.0224535689,
-0.4586678743,
-0.4740345478,
0.5422129035,
-0.0696386695,
0.4331395924,
-0.1923505217,
-0.0480532721,
-0.1256448328,
-0.5751676559,
-0.0294929035,
0.3976922631,
0.0274576917,
0.1506682634,
0.7670398355,
-0.5841075778,
0.8679580092,
-0.3814277351,
-0.1794858575,
0.2986642122,
-0.4003512561,
0.0611572638,
0.0481540523,
0.8211861849,
0.5310086012,
0.2062807828,
-0.4661668241,
0.1693148017,
0.0216136556,
0.1113984287,
-0.7656900883,
-0.2169550806,
-0.0581127852,
-0.2466253638,
-0.2747083306,
-0.0043469663,
-0.6403873563,
-0.2678841352,
-0.3212114275,
0.4460085034,
-0.4841781259,
-0.3409861028,
-0.0590991899,
-0.3262308836,
-0.1078714952,
0.2901573777,
-0.5472737551,
-0.0558077469,
0.2438908666,
0.5593402386,
-0.0168475453,
-0.5238280296,
-0.0801024064,
0.5499910712,
-0.7548800707,
0.7984883189,
-0.3779978454,
-0.2946221232,
-0.2640080452,
0.1210397035,
0.0897973254,
-0.171442315,
0.3488688171,
-0.7345474958,
0.3254332542,
-0.4156249464,
-0.762008965,
-0.4274896979,
0.4432120025,
-0.7467741966,
1.1316987276,
0.2244929671,
-0.8560265303,
0.4070073962,
-0.5710272789,
-0.5772849917,
0.0512804873,
0.015774684,
-0.0627403408,
-0.0708488896,
0.3992664814,
0.2390696406,
-0.274882853,
0.1524845362,
-0.1648141891,
-0.1007883698,
-0.0099387504,
-0.3969153464,
0.6007947326,
-0.0144116189,
-0.1986523718,
-0.2249071747,
-0.6946957111,
0.3899461627,
0.1311899871,
-0.2882237732,
-0.7277902961,
-0.2521625757,
-0.1225050762,
0.0460822396,
0.4920874834,
-0.46333161,
0.126271084,
-0.4344221652,
0.2196816653,
0.3840100467,
-0.0199778676,
0.6067327857,
-0.0313644782,
0.2547935843,
-0.1057336628,
0.0766443163,
-0.2241222709,
-0.7200804353,
-0.4103500843,
-0.005365408,
0.6017124057,
0.5765631795,
-1.2270013094,
0.3178646564,
-0.541324079,
-0.6008967161,
-0.5183534622,
0.210285604,
0.4933305383,
0.6061195135,
0.4161125422,
-0.3178398013,
-0.3799514771,
-0.9485108256,
-0.223779276,
-0.1266380996,
-0.0666025206,
0.3826153576,
0.1954400986,
-0.292555958,
0.7582276464,
-0.6635311246,
-0.2338220924,
-0.1072167158,
0.1616275162,
-0.0835611299,
0.1167168915,
0.4792133868,
-0.9075362682,
-0.9419144392,
0.4108357728,
-0.9261559248,
-0.1228350028,
0.3375855982,
-0.4029735923,
0.3113640845,
0.3446497321,
-0.584866643,
0.2811406553,
0.5007711053,
-0.3872137964,
0.501003921,
-0.3195020258,
0.6332958341,
-1.2541856766,
0.0420239307,
-0.1301918626,
-0.1823788583,
-0.7585793138,
0.098142162,
0.4099220037,
-0.0269670729,
-0.2009385973,
0.6483870149,
-0.5441095233,
0.0580021404,
-0.2703590989,
0.4773160815,
0.3626344204,
0.2948670387,
-0.1683235765,
0.7574448586,
0.3379034102,
-0.5562461615,
0.3550109267,
0.2557660937,
-0.1898991019,
0.7037380338,
-0.1994302571,
-0.0707222074,
-0.1453924775,
0.0670915544,
-0.6228788495,
-0.275816828,
-0.052165702,
-0.7228770852,
0.5187466741,
-0.179855302,
-0.5536808372,
-0.350217253,
-0.1490390897,
0.3267139196,
0.1149883121,
-0.4949732125,
0.5619471669,
0.5799161196,
-0.0129698217,
-0.8171368241,
-0.4143320322,
0.55638659,
0.1113708988,
-0.9077952504,
0.4762455225,
0.1637577564,
-0.1557177603,
0.2147056311,
-0.037031211,
-0.3868013322,
0.0192675572,
-0.3088824749,
0.1287578195,
-0.1866883636,
0.2201404423,
0.208076328,
-0.2506400943,
-0.0616537109,
-0.6745081544,
0.4145670235,
0.1873653978,
-0.1488232464,
-0.3644807041,
0.357310921,
0.4079408348,
-0.316627413,
0.799265027,
0.609767735,
-0.5550042391,
0.1278644502,
-0.568567276,
-0.1075314656,
-0.4394143522,
0.5803556442,
-0.4880359769,
-0.6684159636,
0.2902187705,
-0.014337183,
-0.1181675941,
0.7216256261,
0.1595997214,
-0.2617596388,
0.9381737709,
0.7545788288,
-0.2043419778,
0.271527797,
-0.1855531931,
0.2269061953,
-0.5078332424,
-0.2640066147,
-0.5647824407,
-0.1779646277,
-0.6588859558,
-0.4019271731,
0.4727631509,
0.3017190993,
0.1238060966,
0.5163853765,
-0.4696383178,
0.7244436741,
0.445084691,
-0.0436592773,
0.5444994569,
0.1217619106,
-0.2379205078,
-0.2832403779,
-0.6993073225,
-0.457167089,
1.2133921385,
-0.0967209563,
0.3112232387,
0.1231314391,
0.4330284894,
0.2217300683,
0.332089901,
-0.5070617795,
0.2974027097,
-0.3221566677,
-0.4127545655,
-0.5529559255,
-0.7461803555,
-1.0324642658,
0.3394385278,
-0.1452505887,
-0.4472137392,
-0.0398331136,
-0.039615225,
0.3057445288,
0.4554846883,
-0.8264667988,
0.8168629408,
-0.0620671809,
-0.1034573093,
-0.1740403473,
-0.5479751825,
0.1619477272,
-0.1167935655,
0.3934924603,
-0.0434732549,
-0.1510388702,
0.6908504963,
-0.298830539,
0.5939403176,
-0.2781358659,
-0.2976612747,
0.2786972523,
0.0968555436,
0.698836565,
-0.014136144,
0.1064350978,
0.3007800579,
0.1209239364,
-0.5830929875,
-0.7789587379,
0.5889618397,
-0.6729309559,
-0.2434230149,
0.0655997321,
-0.783369422,
-0.3806400597,
0.6051175594,
0.1970295757,
0.4342608154,
-0.2333950102,
0.1672892869,
0.6163992882,
-0.1995054334,
0.1358883083,
0.6562918425,
-0.1476732343,
-0.6568047404,
0.9495740533,
0.6195541024,
0.3381642401,
0.7009603977,
0.1036312357,
-0.5230076909,
-0.4282081723,
-0.8711125255,
0.230301246,
-0.8471977115,
-0.2830320001,
-0.9065148234,
-0.0650241077,
-0.4513651133,
-0.0374006927,
-0.1943503469,
-0.7275985479,
0.0316042453,
-0.151062876,
0.4450143278,
0.8166834116,
0.1297796667,
0.0856433287,
-0.8498375416,
0.2524910569,
0.0972531438,
0.3102575541,
-0.0797966346,
-0.0894744769,
-0.4168377221,
0.1579263359,
-0.1648140252,
-1.1033148766,
0.2513514459,
0.0601695292,
0.5666673183,
0.1034651846,
0.1588437259,
0.5883216262,
-0.4301625788,
0.4311572611,
0.1881250441,
-0.6538016796,
0.3344859481,
-0.3137445152,
0.3350653052,
0.4567958117,
0.396546334,
-0.9065270424,
-0.6853667498,
-0.4529726207,
-0.8694853783,
0.3946991563,
0.3041269779,
0.1355720162,
-0.0455002896,
0.4009080231,
-0.0541299991,
0.1240615845,
-0.6319389939,
-0.36056301,
-0.1412538886,
-0.3818661869,
-0.1230390221,
-0.1728046983,
-0.0291469786,
-0.0928776711,
0.8760601282,
-0.4195715189,
0.0763935149,
0.2568255365,
-0.4441459775,
0.0928862095,
0.3096581399,
0.3152184188,
0.5746433735,
0.3116451502,
0.2967830002,
0.5207768679,
-0.7350698113,
0.1120507866,
0.1937880516,
-0.4674342871,
0.100113295,
0.4999507666,
0.5936603546,
0.2215212882,
-0.3382116556,
0.3022214472,
0.0298802108,
-0.1665079743,
0.0749966279,
-0.2083668411,
0.3357572854,
-0.0659440085,
0.3321400881,
-0.1853383183,
0.093441695,
-0.1100639105,
0.2504849732,
0.433079958,
-0.3963095844,
-0.1156591699,
0.4296479225,
0.1700224727,
-0.0066013103,
0.503082633,
-0.4649410546,
-0.4157828689,
0.7495102286,
0.4013931155,
0.3226440847,
-0.1048315689,
0.3134496808,
0.4802091122,
0.6731948256,
0.1646301001,
0.3253434598,
-0.0053299642,
-0.766505599,
-0.6713736057,
-0.3629771769,
-0.273188889,
-0.3318016231,
-0.4704696238,
0.2569869161,
0.0636455193,
-0.0930788293,
0.1161907911,
0.3509540856,
-0.4171551168,
0.1403544247,
-0.3049907684,
1.0462090969,
-0.6901468635,
0.941349268,
0.63854146,
-0.3288694322,
-0.8033450246,
-0.2426044792,
-0.3197286427,
-0.5924953818,
0.3917884529,
0.1280483156,
-0.0627896637,
0.2370323688,
-0.0189671293,
-0.9716434479,
1.2691496611,
0.4571657777,
-0.2871532142,
0.1372880936,
0.4614082575,
0.4878670871,
-0.0320148543,
0.1426558793,
0.3511039019,
0.8540440798,
-0.1770327836,
-0.9112174511,
-0.162373051,
-0.2219770551,
-0.1322634071,
0.7475013137,
-0.4848363996,
0.1988641769,
-0.1155603752,
-0.1403390169,
-0.2150040418,
0.6647158861,
-0.0842247978,
0.3674572706,
0.4474999607,
0.7116762996,
1.0441467762,
-0.2063053101,
1.0922181606,
-0.5203460455,
0.1910943091,
0.8916947842,
-0.1615416855,
0.5466113687,
0.3537570536,
-0.2838742733,
0.294089824,
0.5233841538,
0.1215013042,
0.2543823421,
-0.2913787365,
-0.3033012748,
-0.0383149981,
-0.3633317649,
-0.3075469434,
0.189683497,
0.2487094998,
-0.2865690589,
-0.2599162459,
0.0553386323,
0.1796798706,
0.0957518816,
-0.2389982939,
0.8493070602,
-0.1597555727,
-0.5301086903,
0.452305764,
0.3319354057,
0.4034678042,
-0.6946168542,
0.1171386689,
-0.1987055093,
-0.1902602017,
-0.2011154741,
-0.8437841535,
0.4909931719,
-0.1284511834,
-0.4173775315,
-0.0501392372,
0.95202595,
-0.4693753719,
-0.6462067366,
0.6470894217,
0.6510588527,
0.0104840081,
-0.0717773959,
-0.3385297358,
-0.4509622455,
0.0454963669,
-0.1325258017,
0.242910549,
0.687528789,
-0.4098553061,
0.5141758323,
0.7323490977,
-0.0589930303,
0.3035252094,
0.1208660752,
0.7065122128,
-0.4910720885,
-0.4814141989,
-0.6452270746,
0.2854109406,
-0.2423411459,
0.0069708102,
0.8616278768,
0.787825346,
1.0338300467,
0.1201565415,
0.6724694967,
-0.1557945609,
0.2084844559,
-0.4561725259,
1.0124241114,
-0.6354788542,
-0.2592486441,
-0.1685754657,
-0.8805664778,
-0.3965201676,
0.1692689508,
-0.134707585,
-0.0963067636,
0.7640383244,
0.7215892673,
0.0623146184,
-0.026720468,
0.5217991471,
0.193290785,
0.193085745,
0.3403235972,
0.4833382368,
-0.5556390285,
0.9085556269,
-0.504099369,
-0.1919627041,
0.3017585278,
-0.7384520173,
-0.6123125553,
-0.6188735366,
-0.1553053111,
-0.3621243238,
-0.0510305092,
0.5646039844,
0.6814424992,
-0.6056422591,
0.0008150362,
0.1047427729,
0.3245822489,
-0.1938623786,
-0.1650292873,
0.4709512889,
-0.4618932903,
-0.7348865271,
0.5052642226,
0.397795558,
0.1142506897,
-0.2512639463,
-0.2523725331,
-0.0844606832,
-0.0486277863,
0.6407916546,
0.0791516379,
-0.36110425,
-0.0135486387,
0.1976105422,
-0.1324492693,
0.0904330313,
0.6982332468,
-0.5765640736,
0.673463881,
0.4819680452,
0.7461124063,
0.5185630322,
-0.3552173376,
0.5764911771,
-0.9744896889,
0.0734420046,
-0.0659511462,
0.3570622504,
0.4015789926,
-0.4647223651,
0.6148334146,
0.3814969957,
-0.2630319893,
-0.61564821,
0.345385015,
-0.3476487696,
-0.3678053617,
0.8516885042,
-0.0310052373,
-0.2691434324,
-0.3058871627,
-0.2016835809,
0.3690105677,
-0.0977118313,
0.7671218514,
0.9468204379,
0.2033752948,
-0.008127436,
-0.7626386881,
0.2754107118,
0.1609712839,
-1.0823292732,
0.0223229155,
0.4907640517,
0.2275507748,
0.4136606455,
0.6960496306,
-0.2398755252,
0.3023615479,
-0.1413103193,
0.1980762184,
-0.1658771038,
-0.3789227903,
0.0943062901,
0.2083311081,
0.1149790362,
0.1242989302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15766v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15766v2
|
Knowledge Unlearning for LLMs: Tasks, Methods, and Challenges
| 2023-11-27T12:37:51 | 2023-12-08T01:23:56 |
Nianwen Si, Hao Zhang, Heyu Chang, Wenlin Zhang, Dan Qu, Weiqiang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have spurred a new research
paradigm in natural language processing. Despite their excellent capability in
knowledge-based question answering and reasoning, their potential to retain
faulty or even harmful knowledge poses risks of malicious application. The
challenge of mitigating this issue and transforming these models into purer
assistants is crucial for their widespread applicability. Unfortunately,
Retraining LLMs repeatedly to eliminate undesirable knowledge is impractical
due to their immense parameters. Knowledge unlearning, derived from analogous
studies on machine unlearning, presents a promising avenue to address this
concern and is notably advantageous in the context of LLMs. It allows for the
removal of harmful knowledge in an efficient manner, without affecting
unrelated knowledge in the model. To this end, we provide a survey of knowledge
unlearning in the era of LLMs. Firstly, we formally define the knowledge
unlearning problem and distinguish it from related works. Subsequently, we
categorize existing knowledge unlearning methods into three classes: those
based on parameter optimization, parameter merging, and in-context learning,
and introduce details of these unlearning methods. We further present
evaluation datasets used in existing methods, and finally conclude this survey
by presenting the ongoing challenges and future directions.
|
[
-0.1490575224,
-0.8117427826,
0.5561901331,
-0.4577557445,
-0.246558547,
0.3505348563,
-0.3457587957,
-0.3352107406,
-0.4779853225,
0.8763194084,
-0.5605403185,
-0.3429131806,
-0.6130675077,
-0.2159824073,
-0.3925748169,
1.0222560167,
-0.1460905522,
0.1640346795,
-0.6980103254,
0.0086001894,
-0.5447007418,
-0.5407253504,
-0.7205591202,
-0.5550522208,
0.4828890562,
0.6504001617,
0.2457263619,
0.4599666595,
0.2844744623,
0.314961046,
-0.3204394877,
0.4795503914,
-0.6549345255,
0.4019944668,
-0.0858836919,
-0.530813098,
0.064456284,
-0.0023877705,
0.4472128749,
1.1557445526,
-0.4107954204,
0.1382580996,
0.4153020084,
0.8321031928,
-0.7820914388,
-0.0276207533,
-0.8971979618,
0.0126687782,
-0.1520506442,
-0.2755596638,
-0.3854724765,
-0.2258580774,
0.0996437073,
-0.6044402719,
0.0526302531,
0.0490991175,
0.3387830257,
0.4444437921,
-0.6373624206,
-0.3680797219,
-0.899864018,
1.085578084,
-0.6125600934,
0.5850024819,
0.3829475939,
0.309038341,
-0.3273179531,
-0.6983951926,
-0.3996548653,
0.0480200984,
0.1035525054,
-0.0480194017,
-0.295075655,
0.0268921629,
0.0673828647,
0.3324446678,
-0.269004792,
0.4204544127,
-0.6616101861,
-0.2462776005,
0.5080254674,
0.1446792334,
0.188589707,
-0.0305798855,
-0.5254246593,
0.2042146921,
-0.9692125916,
-0.068864949,
0.3492951989,
-0.0743427277,
0.3845589757,
0.4984091818,
-0.2748596966,
0.7421197891,
-0.3577716053,
-0.4124901891,
0.1597639918,
0.180767253,
-0.18733643,
-0.3050670028,
0.5912917256,
0.2330871075,
0.3112855852,
-0.6473398209,
-0.3299503028,
-0.5574092269,
0.3051113784,
-0.2484550029,
0.0725864545,
0.0732985809,
-0.3135695159,
-0.2780922949,
-0.2155682445,
-0.7697159648,
-0.6261895299,
-0.5940234661,
0.4167976081,
-0.6288618445,
-0.1219232529,
-0.061594218,
-0.0352948494,
0.2290301919,
0.4912840128,
-0.6148152947,
0.1840610653,
0.6112506986,
0.2805497646,
-0.3398141861,
-0.2603834271,
-0.2113830894,
0.2763865292,
-0.1776359975,
0.5014005899,
-0.295242846,
-0.4314113259,
0.0717497021,
-0.0697438419,
-0.0428808965,
-0.8543031812,
0.4553695023,
-0.7372533083,
0.3345095515,
-0.2045638561,
-0.8827586174,
-0.5242626667,
0.252620995,
-0.2244130969,
0.8810430169,
0.0685468018,
-0.5576482415,
0.3812509179,
-0.4400134981,
-0.3556709588,
0.0320587121,
0.1446164548,
-0.3385738432,
0.1203629896,
-0.0036420354,
0.6194499135,
-0.5222420096,
0.4452326894,
-0.1671215594,
-0.1903219223,
0.1111120731,
-0.6012003422,
0.8359004259,
0.5459181666,
-0.0979603007,
0.038154766,
-0.6939140558,
-0.0838088691,
0.2510311604,
-0.370567292,
-0.5099547505,
0.0003019718,
-0.4663204849,
0.1051056311,
0.4012738466,
-0.5211353302,
0.0166074429,
-0.3905334473,
0.4795643687,
0.7470175624,
0.3902222216,
0.563701272,
-0.3978586197,
0.3702941239,
0.133959502,
0.3736540377,
0.1145248413,
-0.3405470252,
-0.8000325561,
-0.0094720926,
-0.0650167614,
0.4928263426,
-0.9735319614,
0.2881287038,
0.0907832906,
-0.645198226,
-0.4811431468,
0.7361311316,
0.6300692558,
0.7318576574,
0.4659523368,
0.2380239367,
-0.5101397634,
-0.6452203989,
-0.4299174845,
-0.0961982384,
-0.038024988,
-0.0087801693,
0.327986449,
-0.2642422915,
0.7748308778,
-0.4703759551,
-0.2835547328,
-0.3638317883,
0.0471730828,
-0.2022199631,
0.3691533804,
-0.1588971913,
-0.6863861084,
-0.0693862885,
0.0091169523,
-1.0974724293,
0.1577047408,
0.1609507501,
0.2602955997,
0.4418631494,
0.9501305223,
-0.3574464619,
0.2608257532,
0.2161240131,
0.2544506788,
0.4667288661,
-0.389041245,
-0.098839134,
-1.0958855152,
0.0383534469,
-0.2500060201,
0.0047300062,
-0.8210653067,
0.1222205833,
-0.0944368392,
0.0352326035,
-0.6713917851,
0.6058480144,
-0.7916968465,
0.2504739463,
-0.3458851874,
0.1699714065,
-0.06258405,
0.6628966928,
-0.2082747817,
0.4901726842,
0.3325121701,
-0.6817814112,
0.5655617118,
0.0644893199,
-0.226327166,
0.192183882,
-0.2953160405,
0.1999101043,
-0.454585731,
-0.1383402944,
-0.8366085291,
0.1571008712,
0.1727828383,
-0.2589678168,
0.4373187125,
-0.0635397956,
-0.5875467658,
-0.2124725878,
-0.2241744697,
0.4539949596,
0.7667378187,
-0.5301463604,
0.4189727902,
0.4821504354,
-0.0047709765,
-0.7705843449,
-0.3875187337,
-0.1050306931,
-0.5778561234,
-0.257786423,
0.1027873158,
0.1574709564,
-0.3375963569,
-0.0174941402,
-0.1810728908,
-0.1393193752,
0.1164815277,
0.3016327918,
0.1254915893,
0.1793002188,
0.24547261,
0.0573834069,
-0.2687744498,
0.1188464761,
-0.2357972264,
0.4024672806,
0.2543436289,
-0.631487906,
-0.1399026811,
0.1913110614,
0.4660256803,
-0.1844971031,
0.8362169266,
0.4732849002,
-0.5904045105,
-0.2699941695,
-0.8379109502,
-0.0571809746,
-0.449382782,
0.4158744812,
0.0372799002,
-1.070981741,
0.4002807438,
-0.3932265043,
0.3679174185,
0.1606031656,
0.357039243,
-0.2532601655,
0.6301586032,
0.7120532393,
-0.2371862382,
0.2053563893,
-0.3031882942,
0.3820510209,
-0.9249942303,
-0.6794189215,
-0.3770274222,
-0.0356096365,
-0.312843293,
-0.2758795619,
0.3507524729,
0.4282850921,
-0.2875652015,
0.0872777328,
-0.1506871581,
0.4538125992,
0.5561079979,
0.1935233325,
0.5757734179,
0.0080747567,
-0.0356939211,
0.0398494788,
-0.6609603763,
-0.4944685102,
1.3475431204,
0.3203886151,
0.7099483013,
0.0718547851,
0.7510856986,
0.0317663103,
0.278630048,
-0.7091463208,
0.5728317499,
-0.0808062851,
-0.4505675733,
-0.5826078653,
-0.6355871558,
-0.935685873,
0.0986853614,
-0.08512225,
-0.8583450317,
-0.1332732588,
0.1327026933,
-0.2379415929,
0.7479439974,
-0.6559479237,
0.5963606834,
-0.1769045144,
-0.3451017737,
-0.1585998535,
-0.7272039056,
0.6416189671,
-0.3976976275,
0.2212379724,
0.0019458202,
-0.0454428457,
0.919901967,
-0.3258634508,
0.9454090595,
-0.2905521989,
-0.3870286644,
0.2348923236,
0.0041382019,
0.5120071173,
-0.1306574941,
0.0237817932,
0.0156674329,
0.0703362823,
-0.2570623457,
-0.5906739235,
0.4277772307,
-0.7444216013,
-0.7562448382,
-0.1549860537,
-0.6868025661,
-0.7153633237,
0.1939277202,
0.3908605278,
0.2710208595,
-0.2019133866,
0.1180624962,
1.0304160118,
-0.348438561,
0.4134205878,
0.6435745955,
-0.1702741981,
-0.2359504551,
1.1705749035,
0.0205152873,
0.3061702251,
0.5386567712,
-0.0139191616,
-0.4249112308,
-0.8634460568,
0.029295275,
0.2417352498,
-0.8324371576,
-0.3286094368,
-0.4650290012,
-0.3122609258,
-0.3708167076,
-0.0544740967,
-0.1639807224,
-0.0729704574,
-0.5334543586,
-0.0957669318,
0.2543765604,
0.8251954317,
0.0902003273,
0.3274929225,
-0.761151731,
0.2603207231,
0.4341568649,
0.2893892229,
0.2219918221,
-0.7664135695,
-0.0953449309,
0.0649100542,
-0.3409118056,
-0.6345680356,
0.4774404466,
-0.0873014852,
0.8485776782,
0.625151813,
0.2527518868,
0.4780275524,
-0.3179453611,
0.5495476127,
0.2233377546,
-0.5274626613,
0.3108848035,
-0.2871902883,
-0.1360820532,
0.6024861932,
0.531231463,
-0.7194258571,
-0.3950223923,
-0.6812475324,
-1.0419974327,
0.4929518998,
-0.2362835258,
-0.0396058522,
0.2352577597,
0.5643832088,
0.2675547004,
0.4333238006,
-0.3156378269,
-0.3261759877,
0.1855392158,
-0.0757450536,
-0.3523287475,
-0.5598526597,
-0.1552881598,
-0.3653594851,
0.9013643861,
0.1996644735,
-0.1042424664,
-0.3080197871,
-0.576076448,
-0.1024221554,
0.4603361487,
0.3091695607,
0.6278641224,
0.0061941775,
0.1626329869,
0.5458421707,
-0.2007573396,
0.1502208561,
-0.2760693133,
-0.2421863824,
-0.5107135773,
0.3013497293,
0.4106759727,
0.377943784,
-0.8012259603,
0.4735403061,
0.1991391331,
-0.3662786186,
-0.4955599606,
0.1222467497,
0.1543798745,
-0.0770419762,
0.3726325929,
-0.0951193124,
0.0335078239,
-0.5406204462,
0.1948905736,
0.5973245502,
-0.5506603122,
-0.0428284854,
0.4794685841,
0.2072697133,
0.0187661145,
0.6632482409,
-0.1736497432,
-0.3387356997,
0.1850887388,
0.5129344463,
0.5642843843,
-0.216346547,
0.0174978785,
-0.0304226391,
0.297752738,
-0.0161792058,
-0.009637787,
-0.0572245531,
-0.8487214446,
-0.3324515224,
-0.6339849234,
-0.4314659238,
0.5467702746,
-0.6670506597,
-0.1072983667,
-0.4279550016,
0.4630966485,
-0.239677906,
0.1224758476,
-0.4195421636,
0.1281767786,
-0.1816629171,
0.6984167099,
-0.8055599928,
0.7066859007,
0.87354213,
-0.3493094146,
-0.7316605449,
-0.0236744061,
0.4376899004,
-1.0183119774,
0.4658145905,
-0.2147050053,
0.004237181,
0.1017255113,
-0.3617877662,
-0.561276257,
0.9837869406,
0.5828849673,
-0.3478306234,
0.086716719,
0.3631470203,
0.2582706511,
0.0514542311,
-0.0388822779,
0.7258390784,
0.3334522545,
0.1297142655,
-0.5791788101,
-0.0361212716,
-0.1438042223,
-0.1004635245,
0.3332873583,
-0.4278312624,
0.5956980586,
-0.1930514425,
0.0133460574,
0.0452560857,
0.577118516,
0.1027312353,
0.3057283759,
0.6108298898,
0.5287086368,
0.8959415555,
0.0117583238,
0.3653047383,
-0.010712075,
0.0797915012,
0.8669294119,
-0.306306541,
0.572124362,
0.753223002,
-0.1343600154,
0.0868262053,
0.4021345377,
0.2113582939,
0.30973804,
0.3725038469,
-0.522821784,
-0.3452658057,
-0.0620302968,
-0.1263439059,
0.5615584254,
0.2687345743,
-0.0203113817,
-0.5179772973,
0.339166224,
0.311104387,
0.2116143256,
-0.2073479295,
1.199460268,
0.1215061396,
-0.6259519458,
0.4055376053,
0.0056793047,
0.7008461952,
-0.5451360345,
-0.0948899388,
-0.3129517734,
0.2409994006,
-0.26420632,
-0.5881245136,
0.3254291713,
0.0082505783,
-0.1875732541,
-0.3510910869,
0.8566945195,
-0.5218103528,
-0.131739974,
0.3823288977,
0.8555532098,
0.2603273988,
-0.1539286524,
-0.464640528,
-0.3714576066,
0.1912664324,
-0.1606808007,
0.6533899307,
0.6206245422,
-0.0737153813,
1.0966790915,
0.7089318037,
0.0719747543,
0.0619152524,
0.0341674127,
0.8885262609,
-0.5929412246,
0.016621301,
-0.5642659664,
0.3824736476,
0.1226665303,
-0.2101848722,
0.8211410642,
0.5211926699,
0.8005290627,
0.1386540979,
0.7826574445,
0.3245046735,
0.8650150895,
-0.7453761101,
0.930395484,
-0.6947434545,
0.6393911242,
-0.0868684351,
-0.6801026464,
-0.1777616739,
-0.1274400204,
-0.2550649345,
0.2111656964,
0.5739322305,
0.6131831408,
0.1309099495,
0.0622393824,
0.618914485,
-0.0783419535,
0.1506660432,
0.47424981,
0.9849077463,
-0.1582978368,
0.7266094089,
-0.4724107683,
-0.0989287496,
-0.0953510329,
-0.6317677498,
-0.6533281207,
-0.8243555427,
-0.1119763851,
0.0878844559,
0.3136140108,
0.5395655036,
0.3486545086,
-0.6508997679,
-0.1811166406,
-0.1115242168,
0.4142278433,
-0.0927694067,
-0.1606751084,
0.1885711551,
-0.647377789,
-0.439371407,
0.6010847092,
-0.0357458629,
-0.0180528201,
-0.217567116,
-0.0729252845,
-0.1072845757,
-0.3200317919,
0.6053781509,
0.6690256,
-0.6402975321,
-0.1447060257,
-0.1355712861,
0.1124477461,
-0.3365074694,
0.8333774209,
-0.7781371474,
0.1070043445,
0.2700614929,
0.792250514,
0.2441535592,
-0.1838439107,
0.4955935776,
-1.0860257149,
-0.0550165661,
0.0602739751,
0.4779170454,
0.3529161811,
-0.3357152641,
0.3257783055,
0.2277291566,
-0.4992964268,
-1.0560139418,
0.2138473541,
-0.6225928664,
-0.6271005869,
1.235462904,
-0.0101436898,
-0.1393064559,
-0.6018327475,
0.0136216767,
0.537506938,
-0.1312796324,
0.6243948936,
0.3213435113,
-0.1135426015,
-0.2163178027,
-0.6335301399,
0.5609262586,
0.5196775198,
-0.9359062314,
0.4943574667,
0.4632813632,
0.5459864736,
-0.0330383182,
0.3943727314,
-0.3074797094,
0.0021739751,
-0.4188604951,
0.2804039419,
-0.4281327128,
-0.462349236,
-0.4609974027,
0.2009172887,
0.2476231903,
-0.1058870777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15759v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15759v1
|
Towards Vision Enhancing LLMs: Empowering Multimodal Knowledge Storage and Sharing in LLMs
| 2023-11-27T12:29:20 | 2023-11-27T12:29:20 |
Yunxin Li, Baotian Hu, Wei Wang, Xiaochun Cao, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Recent advancements in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have achieved
significant multimodal generation capabilities, akin to GPT-4. These models
predominantly map visual information into language representation space,
leveraging the vast knowledge and powerful text generation abilities of LLMs to
produce multimodal instruction-following responses. We could term this method
as LLMs for Vision because of its employing LLMs for visual-language
understanding, yet observe that these MLLMs neglect the potential of harnessing
visual knowledge to enhance overall capabilities of LLMs, which could be
regraded as Vision Enhancing LLMs. In this paper, we propose an approach called
MKS2, aimed at enhancing LLMs through empowering Multimodal Knowledge Storage
and Sharing in LLMs. Specifically, we introduce the Modular Visual Memory, a
component integrated into the internal blocks of LLMs, designed to store
open-world visual information efficiently. Additionally, we present a soft
Mixtures-of-Multimodal Experts architecture in LLMs to invoke multimodal
knowledge collaboration during generation. Our comprehensive experiments
demonstrate that MKS2 substantially augments the reasoning capabilities of LLMs
in contexts necessitating physical or commonsense knowledge. It also delivers
competitive results on multimodal benchmarks.
|
[
-0.270673871,
-0.3513342738,
0.8826949596,
-0.0005550704,
-0.4580879807,
0.381588757,
-0.3151785731,
-0.347127974,
0.0591440275,
0.3922576606,
-0.3455027938,
-0.4324868619,
-0.6210922003,
-0.1669709235,
0.1509454101,
0.4349749684,
0.0284357816,
0.3379475772,
-0.7819196582,
-0.1537407339,
-0.6058607101,
-0.3343240619,
-0.3272273242,
-0.1456687748,
0.7429602146,
0.5256370306,
0.4313001633,
0.3654691577,
0.5508670807,
0.3426705003,
0.0530826822,
0.8003568649,
-0.4521229863,
0.3559823036,
-0.2167159915,
-0.7121391892,
-0.5885526538,
-0.4036552608,
0.5078418851,
0.242722854,
0.0603535622,
-0.0319788083,
0.2653871179,
0.7223787308,
-0.6573272943,
0.5247907043,
-0.7443293929,
0.1118158847,
-0.0876028463,
-0.4169045687,
-0.3627699614,
0.0052906969,
0.1446250379,
-0.598849833,
-0.2587882876,
0.0704186112,
0.2545146942,
0.2851400375,
-0.4945046306,
-0.059914168,
-0.2679091096,
0.7966082692,
-0.3229307234,
0.5413748622,
0.183776021,
0.4179086685,
0.0580740683,
-0.6750866771,
-0.6380260587,
0.0892679319,
-0.0186231155,
0.4172215164,
-0.1017152146,
0.0886064321,
0.0117747076,
-0.011569716,
-0.3530403376,
-0.1141643748,
-0.3987209499,
-0.2852628529,
0.2693843544,
0.2431863993,
0.1940138787,
-0.4122876525,
-0.7537695169,
-0.0641198829,
-0.7149947882,
0.0125688855,
0.0243086535,
-0.0599646494,
-0.011016326,
0.8022403121,
-0.2095441073,
0.5175949931,
-0.266587913,
-0.517683506,
0.2465587556,
-0.6422394514,
-0.0766572133,
-0.4235005677,
0.3769415617,
0.8354871869,
0.1828250587,
-0.1806263626,
-0.2544072568,
0.0178742725,
0.243580088,
-0.7335621715,
-0.2033480257,
-0.2499877214,
-0.4135703444,
-0.1982251406,
0.098773621,
-0.9487030506,
-0.618116796,
-0.505548656,
0.5303753614,
-0.5715916157,
-0.4026316404,
-0.0473975874,
-0.3569175601,
0.1015945524,
0.5370197892,
-0.9499158859,
-0.0291546192,
0.60546875,
0.5600758791,
-0.2068439722,
-0.2183775902,
-0.1250181496,
0.7851889729,
-0.3034089506,
0.8016619682,
-0.4852409959,
-0.2150903791,
-0.0661485866,
-0.2287669182,
0.136114344,
-0.6392785907,
-0.1578447223,
-0.3149893284,
0.0310680792,
-0.4000440836,
-0.3302249312,
-0.2878192365,
0.5246264935,
-0.2631110549,
0.8810476065,
0.1444942951,
-0.5079883337,
0.5350854397,
-0.3913114965,
-0.2122209817,
0.2605833113,
-0.7782817483,
-0.2392255217,
0.3812223971,
0.2947174609,
0.6031959057,
-0.118051365,
0.2061712742,
-0.2665578723,
0.0513708405,
0.4497451186,
-0.4781069458,
0.091399841,
0.0460961573,
-0.2177593261,
0.2004291415,
-0.435821861,
0.0675215647,
0.0275257807,
-0.5498663187,
-0.2961246669,
0.1364242733,
-0.2902362347,
0.2835883498,
0.5363510847,
-0.3071335554,
0.1394233704,
0.0869079754,
0.2798367739,
1.0522941351,
-0.1880129874,
0.7110951543,
-0.2459048331,
0.2355172783,
0.4964525104,
0.5451447964,
-0.5114908814,
-0.6666570902,
-1.1301534176,
-0.4120371044,
-0.2797476947,
0.479675293,
-1.3849099874,
-0.0421051905,
-0.3832213879,
-0.2282114923,
-0.3334136605,
0.5800995827,
0.4307157993,
0.3542309701,
0.3538514674,
-0.3882221878,
-0.5745711327,
-1.2268391848,
0.0394931808,
-0.1368497014,
0.0574049726,
0.7307934165,
0.2425166667,
-0.4179112017,
0.8989836574,
-0.4803052247,
-0.3505950272,
-0.4636594653,
-0.2661787868,
-0.3490247428,
0.380808264,
0.3073508739,
-0.8442002535,
-0.3070249259,
-0.0081360759,
-1.0595581532,
0.1060218066,
0.0916070789,
-0.1761937737,
0.4489054382,
0.4786358774,
-0.5970600247,
0.3304188848,
0.4559780657,
-0.3640653193,
0.3543405533,
-0.2324497402,
0.1452313364,
-1.2340816259,
-0.3569951952,
-0.2822416425,
-0.2956471741,
-0.3865050673,
0.0994750708,
0.1733165681,
-0.0907119736,
-0.5164926648,
0.4942107201,
-0.6526827216,
-0.4031726718,
-0.171209693,
0.3079673648,
0.2190362066,
0.5550400019,
-0.0142949214,
0.7793731689,
0.8199974298,
-0.2373422831,
0.4030482173,
0.2001393288,
-0.467404902,
0.7129507661,
0.0147965821,
-0.0469919853,
-0.2479061186,
0.109895274,
-0.9156706333,
-0.2425123304,
0.1960374862,
-0.3313641846,
0.3558997512,
-0.0300843678,
-0.7356002331,
-0.2407438308,
-0.3794134855,
0.3612235785,
0.5865117311,
-0.5951519012,
1.0517854691,
0.3087436259,
-0.3664825857,
-0.3807775378,
-0.8870076537,
0.3962734342,
-0.0679085255,
-0.9156662822,
0.0058865962,
-0.1209164485,
-0.2639346719,
0.1294006407,
-0.0921488032,
0.0919011235,
-0.2253667116,
0.1953035146,
0.3970913887,
-0.3649881482,
0.3207924962,
0.0931466967,
-0.2324995548,
-0.1314719915,
-0.5132030845,
0.420417279,
-0.0624650046,
-0.4205933809,
-0.4473680556,
0.3650409281,
0.6285791397,
-0.1886298209,
0.5062640905,
0.5845291615,
-0.053715568,
-0.1699498296,
-0.9179952145,
-0.3294951022,
-0.5398183465,
0.6317462325,
-0.3966742754,
-0.9898570776,
0.0260905046,
-0.3922971785,
-0.2716800272,
-0.049277246,
0.6408655047,
-0.4442487359,
0.8053511381,
0.744130671,
0.2713947594,
0.4980047047,
-0.1804126948,
0.1352072656,
-0.9712623954,
-0.9915762544,
0.3341882229,
-0.5189107656,
-0.0706298798,
-1.2294436693,
0.5416307449,
0.1400663108,
0.108811684,
-0.0563677661,
-0.1717328131,
0.6222249866,
0.6434693336,
0.4374545217,
0.3389118612,
0.3334820271,
-0.3592501581,
-0.3205568492,
-0.9904597998,
-0.4640699625,
1.0444678068,
0.2014326006,
0.8405761719,
0.3131814897,
0.3958318532,
-0.0101466794,
0.00837796,
-0.5815075636,
1.0572371483,
-0.1512980461,
-0.1678318083,
0.0445647947,
-0.3815873265,
-0.3278867602,
0.3340076506,
-0.4653252363,
-0.4865474999,
0.0758541003,
0.2002350986,
-0.192243427,
0.4848626256,
-0.7326794863,
0.4341562688,
-0.436475575,
-0.5708095431,
-0.6113367677,
-0.526303947,
0.4228124321,
-0.0532798655,
0.0609729178,
0.0293147359,
-0.4727366269,
0.4526621997,
-0.0664776564,
1.0949447155,
-0.1918986738,
0.0112054972,
0.251897037,
0.0054469318,
0.3343552351,
0.0480796397,
0.418266505,
0.1304992735,
-0.5859923959,
-0.3088511527,
-0.8029675484,
0.670622766,
-0.5903153419,
-0.6242348552,
-0.072619684,
-0.8336922526,
-0.3547469378,
0.0979456156,
-0.1560860276,
0.6560738087,
0.2966996431,
0.4116923511,
0.9226443172,
-0.3630291522,
0.4207287133,
0.3761850893,
-0.3881419599,
-0.7075759172,
1.1140022278,
-0.0017939546,
0.4895887971,
0.4523206353,
0.0606584959,
-0.2969334126,
-0.5865766406,
-0.5036467314,
-0.0167897716,
-0.9376680851,
-0.4289365113,
-0.6372947693,
-0.0385198109,
-0.3325969577,
-0.2909536064,
-0.198644951,
-0.5666527152,
-0.2329628468,
-0.2183072865,
0.2766229808,
0.8126655817,
-0.3080390692,
0.1954216957,
-0.6693047881,
0.3636351824,
0.79791677,
0.3908302486,
0.1234604642,
-0.0738955066,
-0.3411868513,
-0.1041670516,
-0.3335795105,
-0.5824714303,
0.072840929,
0.0114142569,
0.694087863,
0.6213420033,
-0.4988731146,
0.8167827725,
-0.5184437633,
0.9074966311,
0.7252552509,
-0.6192041039,
0.4611817002,
-0.2124070972,
0.269689858,
0.3970754445,
-0.154689014,
-0.2292990983,
-0.6035730243,
-0.2827374935,
-0.824036181,
0.4743334353,
0.0794018582,
0.1489313245,
0.1212887168,
0.1423930973,
0.104504101,
0.3858162761,
-0.7307865024,
-0.0005754802,
-0.3504447937,
-0.3202879131,
-0.0228773244,
-0.6432672143,
-0.2993964553,
-0.2337846607,
0.4000154436,
-0.2109059244,
0.3649440706,
0.0665952414,
-0.1986748576,
0.1937511116,
0.2207881957,
0.7705820799,
0.7151609659,
0.1328758001,
0.6342990994,
0.260697633,
-0.3806023002,
0.0071673072,
-0.2925729752,
-0.2237386256,
-0.3131460249,
0.3131697178,
0.8978934884,
0.4678994417,
-0.7440238595,
0.5443685055,
0.1336382926,
-0.3034317791,
-0.1198890507,
0.2131217718,
0.3767943382,
0.872048974,
0.482612282,
0.3685083687,
-0.2152191103,
-0.5923097134,
0.3555857241,
0.565915525,
-0.3614489734,
-0.2156073898,
0.5239722133,
0.4264990091,
-0.0086661838,
0.2823254168,
0.0178220384,
-0.5513858795,
0.1934926957,
0.487562418,
0.514859736,
-0.0293199047,
0.1117488146,
0.0588009544,
0.4717066586,
0.2347876728,
0.5012921095,
-0.3099554181,
-0.7752483487,
-0.2914370894,
-0.4917705357,
-0.2362054735,
-0.2552598119,
-0.2881376147,
-0.0075994497,
-0.3647094369,
-0.0402081683,
-0.573551476,
-0.2626582086,
-0.4592600465,
0.0317769982,
0.536889255,
0.7781752348,
-0.4629752338,
0.84007442,
0.5595775843,
-0.3366959095,
-0.5250660181,
-0.2370420247,
0.0489806794,
-1.0564953089,
0.9141782522,
0.1646532267,
-0.1054356918,
-0.07315965,
-0.3775540292,
-0.6339774132,
1.6560814381,
0.2968633473,
-0.7380827665,
0.0348787829,
0.5202838182,
0.1317387968,
-0.4088573158,
-0.1046475098,
0.0786915645,
0.6599301696,
0.3020391762,
-0.4688085914,
-0.0654994026,
-0.0680370554,
0.1174829453,
0.1471271217,
-0.6742265224,
0.5935662389,
-0.5239261985,
-0.0561452247,
0.1443430781,
0.620439291,
0.3956027329,
0.3774499893,
0.490809679,
0.8214850426,
0.6137487292,
-0.1057351008,
0.8233345151,
-0.2153536528,
-0.1001530066,
0.9567638636,
-0.1250161082,
0.8999098539,
0.7498087287,
0.2008535713,
0.3954764009,
0.0827639103,
-0.058380045,
0.7886043191,
-0.1921473444,
-0.6502752304,
-0.5306978226,
-0.0899236202,
-0.2481349409,
0.3921127915,
0.3865793645,
-0.3918962777,
-0.1971470714,
0.2786532938,
-0.2086804211,
-0.0101711974,
-0.471255213,
1.0657342672,
0.2569644153,
-0.4462310076,
0.0033256765,
-0.2804642618,
0.7209644318,
-0.6260908842,
-0.0005210625,
-0.2360764891,
0.3428815305,
-0.0749039873,
-1.0560046434,
0.1537867337,
-0.1326282024,
-0.3193822801,
-0.4724703729,
1.0862181187,
-0.7269230485,
-0.5625315905,
0.3775664568,
0.9011237025,
-0.0648154765,
0.2039711922,
-0.4318568408,
-0.0461448915,
0.0355685763,
-0.0212691277,
0.5335812569,
0.4882727265,
0.1949757785,
0.8141950369,
0.6372847557,
0.0169257633,
0.2901414931,
0.0500033982,
1.1157233715,
-0.4116666913,
-0.2366924584,
-0.9008318186,
0.6385374069,
-0.2257886678,
0.0404551253,
0.926230669,
0.7955991626,
0.5824254155,
-0.107879363,
0.7780807018,
0.1008397564,
0.1031088307,
-0.7919214368,
0.6640740037,
-0.8209849596,
-0.0099868625,
-0.0789081752,
-0.8919841647,
-0.2470458746,
0.3865009844,
-0.059928108,
-0.2440198213,
0.6015046239,
1.0269933939,
-0.135323599,
-0.1706991941,
0.6954544783,
0.2952615321,
0.139025256,
0.6434275508,
1.0588299036,
0.0305817369,
0.7533767223,
-0.0759882703,
-0.2803973854,
-0.0832645297,
-0.630371213,
-0.9379045963,
-0.5791894794,
0.0162617993,
-0.0231218617,
0.1744809747,
0.551831305,
0.6967766881,
-0.1202856153,
-0.0876142085,
0.0740344822,
-0.0484699309,
0.1174362302,
-0.155588761,
0.0357884131,
-0.3447395861,
-0.4199455678,
0.6185049415,
0.9706127048,
0.2308794409,
-0.7181611061,
-0.3156988621,
0.1037275419,
0.0420500599,
1.1556571722,
-0.3619398177,
-0.8029586673,
-0.178599596,
0.0838686451,
-0.146762982,
0.1415390968,
0.7805652022,
-0.9250283837,
0.6284136772,
0.4729309082,
0.5686779022,
0.3790527284,
-0.2941477299,
0.529389441,
-0.7067996264,
0.21314767,
0.0575076081,
0.5896474123,
0.5646152496,
-0.036805518,
0.3772991598,
0.4214813113,
-0.3108156323,
-0.4766680896,
0.3884474635,
-1.2440607548,
-0.3026199937,
1.3536002636,
-0.0216136631,
-0.105688177,
-0.0105026038,
-0.3065872788,
-0.0360672586,
-0.3444924951,
0.5602781177,
0.3415516913,
0.1584593803,
-0.5166924596,
-0.6272682548,
0.2835422158,
0.33782655,
-0.9657378197,
-0.0845075101,
0.5296751261,
0.1741366237,
0.1945985854,
0.6212380528,
-0.1968422681,
0.2525059283,
0.0058115772,
0.0414882191,
-0.4132764637,
-0.5932733417,
0.1251060367,
0.2019501328,
-0.1897350252,
-0.1268617064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15723v1
|
Italian Crossword Generator: Enhancing Education through Interactive Word Puzzles
| 2023-11-27T11:17:29 | 2023-11-27T11:17:29 |
Kamyar Zeinalipour, Tommaso laquinta, Asya Zanollo, Giovanni Angelini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Maggini, Marco Gori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Educational crosswords offer numerous benefits for students, including
increased engagement, improved understanding, critical thinking, and memory
retention. Creating high-quality educational crosswords can be challenging, but
recent advances in natural language processing and machine learning have made
it possible to use language models to generate nice wordplays. The exploitation
of cutting-edge language models like GPT3-DaVinci, GPT3-Curie, GPT3-Babbage,
GPT3-Ada, and BERT-uncased has led to the development of a comprehensive system
for generating and verifying crossword clues. A large dataset of clue-answer
pairs was compiled to fine-tune the models in a supervised manner to generate
original and challenging clues from a given keyword. On the other hand, for
generating crossword clues from a given text, Zero/Few-shot learning techniques
were used to extract clues from the input text, adding variety and creativity
to the puzzles. We employed the fine-tuned model to generate data and labeled
the acceptability of clue-answer parts with human supervision. To ensure
quality, we developed a classifier by fine-tuning existing language models on
the labeled dataset. Conversely, to assess the quality of clues generated from
the given text using zero/few-shot learning, we employed a zero-shot learning
approach to check the quality of generated clues. The results of the evaluation
have been very promising, demonstrating the effectiveness of the approach in
creating high-standard educational crosswords that offer students engaging and
rewarding learning experiences.
|
[
-0.2697258592,
-0.897246778,
0.5129454732,
-0.0836602822,
-0.3536737561,
0.0674488321,
-0.2607361674,
-0.5639656186,
0.0592360571,
0.1438466758,
-0.5073512793,
-0.5537368655,
-0.479780823,
0.2704942822,
-0.5571742058,
1.0554161072,
-0.1043947712,
0.3619336486,
-0.1282604188,
0.0981150642,
-0.3029810786,
-0.230448693,
-0.5705194473,
-0.4509423673,
0.6787693501,
0.4864339828,
0.4192003906,
0.8157369494,
0.4255004227,
0.2468475103,
0.0652660504,
0.1797392219,
-0.5258720517,
0.1739939153,
-0.4013603628,
-0.5498853922,
-0.1490418166,
0.2143988907,
0.1664431244,
0.5478276014,
-0.1302801371,
0.0914012194,
0.2891642153,
0.3990971148,
-0.5230972171,
-0.0649209321,
-0.8281321526,
0.2230361849,
-0.4638625681,
-0.3481016755,
-0.149298355,
-0.3625912666,
-0.0346061774,
-0.7328362465,
0.3688201308,
-0.2257984132,
0.8877610564,
-0.0450952835,
0.0917141065,
-0.9443359375,
-0.5681350231,
0.5235291123,
-0.6524642706,
0.0965272188,
0.1568736136,
0.3492786884,
-0.2042987049,
-0.6982267499,
-0.5142671466,
-0.07352902,
0.3916045725,
0.4267500341,
0.1849304289,
-0.044889763,
0.1831742972,
0.3857719302,
-0.4237998724,
0.0985793397,
-0.2798810303,
0.0220884308,
0.7179432511,
0.4661807716,
0.612377584,
0.0313730165,
-0.2104269415,
-0.1341786832,
-0.9945299029,
0.1637596339,
0.742413938,
0.3822029829,
0.1412217468,
0.8525796533,
-0.3532784879,
0.7557224035,
-0.1032849997,
-0.1004461497,
-0.0710034147,
-0.5513831377,
0.2808822691,
0.3047767878,
0.8147899508,
0.2850344777,
0.4583564103,
-0.32107234,
-0.2879939675,
0.2748321295,
0.1127400324,
-0.8037096262,
-0.1775315106,
-0.0392737761,
-0.2063813359,
-0.4364314675,
-0.1354326904,
-0.6481078863,
0.1957853884,
-0.0840404406,
0.7838648558,
-0.5716853738,
0.2734823823,
0.2760435045,
-0.2610689402,
-0.0989274383,
0.2748990357,
-0.9846266508,
-0.1637217253,
0.5326576829,
0.5496473908,
-0.3594504595,
-0.1982789487,
-0.4815687835,
0.2602621019,
-0.3156467378,
0.7105802298,
-0.7813820839,
-0.4950933456,
0.1782303005,
-0.1478756815,
0.1508639604,
-0.4729452133,
0.4354296625,
-0.208575353,
0.6824285984,
-0.0587525293,
-0.8490203023,
-0.0177225266,
0.3718373477,
-0.4316582978,
0.960793674,
-0.0020178563,
-0.7389167547,
0.3955633938,
-0.7065223455,
-0.4109802842,
0.5362160802,
-0.3251340091,
-0.2893103063,
0.3494767547,
0.2673587203,
0.2084848434,
-0.2218130678,
0.0885805115,
-0.1447382271,
-0.446950227,
0.1598740816,
-0.3333368897,
0.8073933721,
0.1454000771,
-0.6175591946,
-0.2518443465,
-0.7153980732,
0.2021532208,
0.1771201044,
-0.4458096325,
-0.3320860267,
-0.0348201022,
0.1121517569,
0.2158640176,
0.3318900466,
-0.7580305338,
0.0638152957,
-0.4259333611,
0.0382836796,
0.2356842458,
0.0756541863,
-0.152881816,
-0.2748353183,
0.8674877882,
-0.0235248543,
-0.1025508866,
-0.4354066253,
-0.795004189,
-0.6284742355,
0.117429167,
0.5641182661,
0.7462390661,
-1.3055620193,
0.4355511963,
0.0571315922,
-0.5435489416,
-0.7510524988,
0.3113015592,
0.4814727604,
0.3527923822,
0.2780151665,
-0.3206122518,
-0.1940716207,
-0.4330787063,
-0.4504731297,
0.1260702163,
-0.267768234,
0.379278332,
0.5434679389,
0.0949858949,
0.8870286345,
-0.3331047893,
-0.1909262389,
-0.2006511986,
0.5174685121,
0.0066627045,
0.511236608,
0.4085935354,
-0.3512822986,
-0.5531774163,
0.0858135447,
-0.7374722362,
-0.0912006944,
-0.0990459099,
-0.0475784987,
-0.1170432493,
0.0777461231,
-0.3087125719,
0.5652798414,
0.2949211299,
-0.2693709731,
0.3489960134,
-0.1347445846,
0.0333038941,
-1.3521158695,
-0.0364101082,
-0.1665754914,
-0.0323277935,
-0.2978041768,
0.270050019,
-0.3041365445,
-0.3492219746,
-0.4928168654,
0.3779120743,
-0.5696408153,
0.1718011796,
-0.3545282185,
0.5774472356,
-0.0986267999,
0.0509431027,
0.3259811997,
0.7408809662,
0.5386455059,
-0.1758542061,
0.5678519607,
0.063087225,
-0.4868394732,
0.5469161868,
-0.8020070195,
0.1161285117,
0.1324112713,
-0.2323150188,
-0.8097396493,
-0.1304853708,
0.1177093387,
-0.5649263263,
0.1392561346,
0.2171424627,
-0.548381269,
-0.2499340177,
-0.1214550138,
0.2476143241,
0.326138258,
-0.5366697311,
-0.0426776707,
0.2640895545,
-0.3422471583,
-0.3172827959,
-0.4138289988,
0.3096378148,
-0.0938609093,
-0.2554742098,
0.0843799487,
-0.1589752287,
0.0605249703,
0.2139210701,
0.0755261704,
0.0917480588,
0.2681453228,
-0.0910897106,
0.239667967,
-0.1961656064,
0.125108093,
0.2570421994,
-0.0707014799,
0.0621351488,
-0.0621622056,
0.3317520916,
0.2991238832,
-0.416701436,
-0.0617036708,
0.6141591668,
0.1634120643,
-0.1395416111,
0.2391832173,
0.8424937129,
-0.44937554,
-0.4185014367,
-0.2192267925,
-0.3675697148,
-0.4040408731,
0.2765328884,
-0.4575065672,
-1.0292109251,
0.3409941792,
-0.1468754113,
0.0638895184,
0.1811599731,
0.5825299025,
-0.0187079031,
1.139521718,
0.5850512385,
0.2743819654,
0.3702114522,
-0.0657126904,
0.3476756513,
-0.6525390148,
-0.3687898517,
-0.708781004,
-0.3529747725,
-0.6417860985,
-0.2419318259,
0.3350854218,
0.1298455149,
0.3263128996,
0.3605850935,
-0.7927079201,
0.6150688529,
0.6668889523,
0.1059779152,
0.2346524298,
0.2624267638,
-0.5378630161,
-0.1031286344,
-0.7586031556,
-0.5705446005,
1.1306180954,
-0.0388658196,
1.1294952631,
-0.2025928497,
1.207413435,
-0.096810028,
0.1572088748,
-0.8398180604,
0.4895018637,
-0.0830689296,
-0.9329850674,
-0.2969099879,
-0.4668634236,
-0.9869679809,
-0.1589218825,
-0.4199239016,
-0.7614602447,
0.0039998824,
-0.0153859323,
-0.4833839238,
0.233155787,
-0.33758834,
0.7515913248,
-0.5308872461,
-0.8618788719,
-0.1821196526,
-0.3696885407,
0.2302557826,
-0.0429016463,
-0.154537797,
-0.0178766493,
-0.1150584072,
0.6054645777,
-0.1871026903,
0.7133100629,
0.1424997896,
-0.3631069958,
0.5024659634,
0.1771428883,
0.1718932986,
0.1664403081,
-0.1000038907,
0.1207967699,
-0.0740424469,
-0.1923221052,
-0.33247751,
0.7993966341,
-0.5947273374,
-0.6915090084,
-0.2785070837,
-0.8184310794,
0.0121561307,
0.3604197502,
0.7413707972,
0.4571275115,
-0.3487790525,
0.2123345286,
0.6682583094,
-0.248226732,
0.6309150457,
0.4238824844,
0.0338223614,
-0.3999230266,
1.1060726643,
0.3194607794,
0.0569694415,
0.334782362,
0.0326743238,
-0.3018427789,
-0.5755259991,
-0.7153362632,
-0.0353962332,
-0.3209992051,
-0.2601367533,
-0.3023370206,
-0.4609288275,
-0.2228038013,
-0.2928671539,
-0.1219463199,
-0.4670979977,
-0.3730430007,
-0.0153099904,
0.1481827199,
0.89138937,
-0.1372933388,
0.3433471918,
-0.9278866053,
0.273253262,
0.5288175344,
0.3410852849,
-0.2468388677,
-0.2259990126,
-0.4737174809,
0.2826419175,
-0.4767428637,
-0.9240208268,
0.25994578,
0.2564704418,
0.518783927,
0.608422339,
-0.1659502685,
0.4141094089,
-0.7937456369,
1.1055551767,
0.3331478238,
-0.9571529627,
0.6973609328,
-0.4626296163,
0.3874057233,
0.55035007,
0.5298925638,
-0.2436761707,
-0.557372272,
-0.7706730366,
-0.7577084303,
0.5510061979,
0.2768391669,
0.190253213,
-0.2146378458,
0.3767693937,
0.2673359513,
0.4274335802,
-0.5125411153,
-0.1668446809,
-0.3203591704,
-0.4773592949,
-0.0135676283,
-0.1973447204,
-0.1235708669,
-0.1500705034,
0.7770835757,
-0.2082152218,
0.0581009351,
-0.1075133085,
-0.0280291792,
-0.1930626035,
0.3745822608,
0.5958456397,
0.657030344,
-0.0731615499,
-0.1148525551,
-0.0491468981,
-0.5947877765,
0.187659964,
0.1708067507,
-0.4930009842,
0.4701119959,
0.3172818422,
0.7737239599,
0.0760016292,
-0.688631773,
0.3670080304,
-0.1188171729,
-0.1097791195,
-0.1864753962,
0.4843421876,
0.1742338538,
-0.0281731281,
0.2667981088,
-0.4415942132,
0.4394232631,
-0.7314779758,
0.3004552126,
0.6937614679,
-0.4547836781,
-0.3283888102,
0.8186050057,
0.454000026,
-0.7154521942,
0.5286785364,
-0.2952878475,
-0.4790176153,
0.4479761422,
0.8800593019,
1.0529060364,
-0.3730470538,
0.4488099515,
0.5011016726,
0.3766465187,
0.1256462932,
0.4936760664,
-0.3825087845,
-0.8037785888,
-0.2426152676,
-0.4469922781,
-0.5147618651,
0.0880831182,
-0.8035334945,
0.0763304606,
-0.2781016827,
-0.198701039,
-0.2165748626,
0.1846925467,
-0.5839725733,
0.3131571412,
0.3540887237,
0.9299689531,
-0.9237075448,
0.9015574455,
0.9962987304,
-0.4272222519,
-0.8084959984,
-0.0956567749,
-0.1735903323,
-0.8070756793,
0.6119632721,
0.2602111995,
-0.0926358625,
0.1132863835,
-0.7226837873,
-0.3765668869,
0.7852618098,
0.0423265137,
-0.8724418879,
-0.2789262831,
0.5322732925,
0.5390316248,
-0.6167289615,
0.3125591576,
0.4081889987,
0.2801226974,
0.3272838295,
-0.4006755054,
-0.1969383359,
-0.3735605776,
0.1519834697,
0.0359390453,
-0.1224908829,
0.5553781986,
-0.2219211012,
-0.248390004,
0.3249121308,
0.4935832024,
0.222507149,
0.4174484313,
0.1791260839,
1.0447604656,
0.3664340675,
-0.497736156,
0.6662992239,
-0.5977476835,
0.3210811913,
1.2605364323,
-0.2911131382,
0.7419435978,
0.6147152781,
0.1650522947,
0.5432386994,
0.5966486335,
-0.1280165017,
0.3929047883,
0.3005966246,
-0.4509868026,
-0.5767118931,
-0.3238775134,
-0.4776499569,
0.5860087872,
0.565511167,
-0.2834162712,
-0.7577208281,
0.0751424506,
-0.182096526,
0.2744370699,
-0.2206911147,
0.8148010373,
0.1051593497,
-0.5738834739,
0.1794565767,
-0.2280078977,
0.6489580274,
-0.4834305644,
-0.4201668501,
-0.2353328913,
0.1463178396,
0.007091572,
-0.8711387515,
-0.1295529753,
0.3487671912,
0.258705467,
0.0143032586,
0.413236171,
-0.9457037449,
-0.795988977,
0.0387679636,
0.4762441516,
0.2215411067,
0.4629065096,
-0.8528169394,
0.0100534549,
0.0264399145,
-0.0530556105,
0.1134102196,
0.9398784637,
0.3200150132,
0.3842046261,
0.5459544659,
0.4985409081,
0.0487343147,
-0.1565581411,
0.6457049251,
-0.5552563667,
-0.427870512,
-0.5497197509,
0.5354563594,
-0.1119993329,
-0.5767418146,
1.0200990438,
0.6558911204,
1.0759216547,
-0.0889083743,
0.7163991332,
0.0209430791,
0.4797479212,
-0.446995765,
0.8371591568,
-0.6329197288,
0.0269987639,
-0.2330610007,
-0.8232896328,
-0.1584009379,
0.5900653601,
-0.0410087742,
0.0326797478,
0.6633949876,
0.7061299682,
-0.039426446,
-0.0694677308,
0.4159388244,
-0.2466174513,
0.0989742726,
0.7719873786,
0.8637962937,
-0.6147466302,
0.4689249098,
-0.3958516419,
-0.106001325,
-0.2326733172,
-0.7511934042,
-1.2474067211,
-0.5149832964,
-0.3514690697,
-0.2209657282,
0.3313116729,
0.6088145971,
0.3323338628,
-0.8799191713,
-0.3683020473,
-0.1393415928,
0.1892637312,
-0.1542861313,
-0.300280869,
0.1438330412,
-0.5307331681,
-0.9779006839,
0.2912403643,
0.2883048356,
0.1064842567,
-0.3281163275,
0.1793497056,
-0.3137342334,
0.2901189923,
0.4461272061,
0.1702622324,
-0.4342802167,
-0.3599101007,
-0.0199952386,
-0.179799661,
-0.2280209661,
0.6920027733,
-0.6750848293,
0.8838610053,
0.694170177,
0.779505372,
0.2788521945,
-0.1411493272,
0.5413267612,
-0.3663190007,
0.0451812334,
0.2427216321,
0.2510760725,
0.4054971933,
-0.4870111048,
0.495511651,
0.1942304373,
-0.2765401602,
-0.6734603643,
0.2230501026,
-0.4770078361,
-0.0914935917,
0.6916903853,
-0.4606337249,
-0.4082389176,
0.1639791429,
0.0008491447,
0.4462088645,
-0.0969131961,
1.2118037939,
0.8505693674,
0.0523216501,
-0.0612043813,
-0.1526977122,
0.447866261,
0.3335936666,
-0.9846785069,
-0.4703814685,
0.4059764147,
0.3439096808,
0.3404704332,
-0.1814580411,
-0.3184498847,
0.4930654466,
-0.0050164191,
0.3733824193,
-0.1430383027,
-0.3741635978,
-0.2352210581,
0.2175968736,
-0.1730829626,
-0.5781248808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15716v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15716v1
|
Justifiable Artificial Intelligence: Engineering Large Language Models for Legal Applications
| 2023-11-27T10:59:16 | 2023-11-27T10:59:16 |
Sabine Wehnert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, H.4.2; H.3.3; H.5.2
|
In this work, I discuss how Large Language Models can be applied in the legal
domain, circumventing their current drawbacks. Despite their large success and
acceptance, their lack of explainability hinders legal experts to trust in
their output, and this happens rightfully so. However, in this paper, I argue
in favor of a new view, Justifiable Artificial Intelligence, instead of
focusing on Explainable Artificial Intelligence. I discuss in this paper how
gaining evidence for and against a Large Language Model's output may make their
generated texts more trustworthy - or hold them accountable for misinformation.
|
[
0.0276430752,
-0.6187061667,
1.0352851152,
0.0977531001,
-0.016490953,
-0.1251162291,
-0.3071259558,
-0.5883603692,
-0.1368076205,
0.6758447886,
-0.0901669711,
-0.2413301319,
-0.770183444,
0.0675709918,
-0.8893415332,
1.0102899075,
0.0459199324,
-0.0370646939,
-0.242840752,
-0.2808866799,
-0.2152059227,
-0.735296905,
-0.5512681603,
-0.447907418,
0.3033143282,
0.3135516942,
1.0360733271,
0.8463431597,
0.2801750898,
0.403858453,
0.1116640344,
-0.307603538,
-0.419906795,
-0.0551377237,
-0.3665018678,
-0.5607782006,
-0.1935691237,
0.1637362689,
0.6345870495,
0.4850916564,
-0.2741227746,
-0.1018482521,
-0.5261570811,
0.640389502,
-0.3072813153,
0.1579604745,
-0.7121724486,
0.0947300717,
-0.194704175,
-0.0075882864,
-0.6313943267,
-0.451225996,
0.1695557535,
-0.7825679183,
-0.139465183,
0.2872303724,
0.9311255813,
0.4388997555,
-0.3474853933,
-0.6351954937,
-1.0034335852,
0.8082774878,
-1.0620492697,
0.2608516812,
0.4335891902,
0.4748481512,
-0.2842878401,
-0.9093740582,
-0.9266993999,
-0.876177907,
0.0127511211,
0.091885142,
-0.4646082819,
0.1585969329,
0.4462577105,
-0.1277715117,
-0.4255407453,
0.4613496065,
-0.2672077417,
-0.3128379881,
1.0108981133,
-0.1556595117,
0.5155642033,
0.162056908,
0.2148160189,
0.2693146765,
-0.6404765248,
-0.0101847537,
0.4209211469,
0.094256863,
0.0727770999,
0.7564589977,
0.1445751339,
0.3167491555,
-0.1375036091,
-0.0301409308,
-0.0999667719,
-0.2026446313,
-0.3047721386,
0.3562730551,
0.8547465801,
-0.1242857873,
0.5566232204,
-0.2906751335,
-0.3184498847,
0.04861781,
0.403008312,
-0.7133905888,
-0.068500109,
0.4874498248,
-0.7167469263,
-0.3350194097,
0.1001735926,
-0.4618965089,
-0.6131060719,
-0.3917206824,
0.1972643584,
-0.3081019819,
-0.2069425583,
0.1315488815,
-0.24477005,
0.1389611363,
0.4174047112,
-0.6259618402,
0.1265240014,
0.8224393725,
0.3300147951,
0.3175071478,
-0.4858311713,
-0.6041252613,
0.1657349616,
-0.5915258527,
0.5154185295,
-0.6550327539,
-0.0622831248,
0.1570194662,
-0.1772990227,
0.1954517961,
-0.4085055292,
0.62199229,
-0.5146695971,
0.0404514633,
-0.0378466286,
-0.6494714618,
-0.4832883179,
0.0893206447,
-0.5730032921,
0.3178032935,
-0.104837954,
-0.3609609902,
0.5102475286,
-1.1278796196,
-0.7585091591,
0.180370912,
-0.3638495803,
-0.5609817505,
0.2107245624,
-0.3478482366,
0.3112650216,
-0.2805270851,
0.7558150291,
-0.4265811145,
-0.1192673594,
0.4804343879,
-0.5771856904,
1.0820869207,
0.3641148806,
-0.5248429775,
0.2829355597,
-0.7329645157,
-0.2187693119,
0.2454316169,
-0.2641602755,
-0.4236828983,
0.3102620542,
0.0182980523,
0.0864003673,
0.0748023093,
-0.689412117,
-0.1200194061,
-0.5594412088,
0.6770313382,
0.8438425064,
-0.4889193773,
0.4780344367,
-0.2632834017,
0.4028633833,
-0.2356482595,
-0.0994845182,
0.1308747381,
-0.4324509203,
-0.3820073605,
-0.297134012,
0.4919335246,
0.4153011739,
-0.5694960952,
0.1897646189,
-0.3298169672,
-0.3965970874,
-0.4995021224,
0.4214678407,
0.3103709221,
0.3006636202,
-0.1524227113,
0.012612056,
-0.6696283221,
-1.0806360245,
-0.596575737,
-0.359089762,
-0.062646836,
0.2455590814,
0.7289119959,
-0.2934573591,
0.8694663048,
0.1592152119,
0.0762737021,
-0.4398337007,
0.4356073737,
0.2629434168,
0.3772940636,
0.8555499911,
-1.0618424416,
-0.2807689309,
0.3433005214,
-1.0637055635,
-0.0171559155,
-0.453361094,
0.0340572819,
0.1559924334,
0.3512117267,
-0.9032430649,
0.6172288656,
0.0483607687,
-0.6590642333,
0.6926904321,
-0.4409811795,
0.0375160575,
-0.8421370387,
0.1378501058,
0.1437713951,
-0.6033661366,
-0.9491157532,
0.3455328941,
0.021165967,
-0.057967633,
-0.5868933201,
0.5708066821,
-0.3047147691,
-0.0434002876,
-0.5304786563,
0.2536329031,
-0.2138425261,
0.1579685956,
-0.243317306,
0.6800532341,
0.5089417696,
-0.7092984319,
0.4381282032,
0.3047996759,
-0.1522851288,
0.3943254352,
-0.7149001956,
-0.1525089592,
-0.2068411559,
0.0004979569,
-0.2985520363,
-0.6415638924,
0.0652023256,
-0.4755565226,
0.3043413162,
0.0041790213,
-0.5239323974,
-0.5230891705,
-0.171963349,
0.1314044446,
0.5002339482,
-0.5044978261,
1.0658433437,
0.5942347646,
-0.1860042065,
-0.451264292,
-0.8599505424,
0.3069137931,
-0.3585102558,
-0.4132352173,
0.2191572487,
-0.0861688256,
-0.7296327949,
0.1577266455,
0.1224920973,
-0.4009598494,
0.3190478384,
0.4528418779,
0.0257935319,
-0.3811548948,
0.2138358206,
0.0137288654,
0.0716151074,
0.6479103565,
-0.1010078713,
0.1084168479,
-0.098987706,
-0.4093263447,
-0.8845953345,
0.431304574,
1.0591870546,
-0.1001477689,
0.7252116203,
-0.1035387889,
-0.4222878218,
-0.1183691248,
-0.4389182925,
0.2180851102,
-0.508539021,
0.4915905297,
-0.1233455986,
-1.0729438066,
0.4582515061,
-0.0548818558,
0.4465277791,
0.7557306886,
0.8430463672,
0.005453221,
1.1299074888,
0.8765794635,
-0.3783548176,
0.3225560486,
0.2049328387,
0.6561213732,
0.0613466427,
-0.0732212439,
-0.9558103085,
0.1670337468,
-0.6576113105,
0.2266431302,
-0.182911709,
-0.328715682,
-0.4336982071,
0.2974205017,
-0.2570854425,
0.6230344176,
0.6552818418,
-0.2560047507,
0.1351520121,
-0.3049197793,
0.1240427047,
0.4054281414,
-0.6794605851,
-0.8465858698,
1.0729870796,
0.5164196491,
0.5129907131,
0.2312908322,
0.4407690167,
0.5450078249,
0.372517854,
-0.7829837799,
0.4204799235,
-0.1700701863,
-0.8630840778,
-0.4927012026,
-0.4423398077,
-0.8259176016,
-0.297065556,
-0.3863233328,
-0.7668247223,
-0.0621560514,
0.2265553921,
-0.4132998884,
0.3189602196,
-0.8291284442,
0.737460494,
-0.4004605711,
-0.2244319171,
-0.3410102725,
-0.5236314535,
0.4400129914,
-0.523329854,
0.5252254605,
0.0935857967,
0.3879251182,
0.9021110535,
-0.6207498312,
0.6537533402,
-0.078878358,
0.0409607291,
0.4111456871,
0.0396310575,
0.4916633666,
0.0708147138,
-0.2837651968,
0.0066875843,
0.1427434683,
-0.6047316194,
-0.8329035044,
0.5789815784,
-0.647189796,
-1.0054265261,
-0.2452821285,
-0.9322143197,
0.0651651174,
0.5796638131,
-0.1089632735,
-0.012965831,
-0.2840002775,
0.2483231574,
0.5548264384,
-0.1081026345,
0.7026655078,
0.4373618364,
-0.0863014981,
0.0358817317,
0.9686562419,
0.1002057642,
-0.0718661696,
0.0780735165,
0.4395906627,
-0.3651237786,
-0.8466008902,
-0.438182652,
0.1490971893,
-0.5504181385,
0.0771932229,
-0.4044496715,
-0.2506996393,
-0.2927433848,
-0.1860587746,
-0.4084581435,
-0.6621121168,
-0.1361665726,
-0.1529878527,
0.2633040249,
1.062559247,
0.1282128245,
0.1144337952,
-0.794390142,
0.2042580694,
0.358299911,
0.241808176,
-0.196694538,
-0.6722337604,
-0.0669783279,
0.1949723214,
-0.0425414182,
-0.757117033,
0.1991577893,
0.0021538383,
0.875772953,
0.7223402858,
0.0487851091,
0.3715019524,
-0.5878342986,
0.6463270783,
0.2841632664,
-1.2089580297,
0.5125120878,
-0.1520961374,
-0.1731308103,
0.4493837357,
0.3048726916,
0.0008814026,
-0.6610738635,
-0.6462050676,
-0.3877823651,
0.4817464352,
0.4766165018,
0.5640672445,
0.4099921584,
0.6430850625,
0.293043077,
0.2563949227,
-0.8690369725,
0.1581947803,
-0.2882272303,
-0.4977263212,
0.1766863465,
-0.3220318258,
-0.3283166885,
-0.2469639927,
0.6652699709,
-0.0054113409,
0.1462118626,
-0.0730998218,
-0.1312341243,
0.0137378126,
0.3167128861,
0.919490993,
1.0342566967,
0.3421575129,
0.1536902487,
-0.1303394288,
-0.4853738546,
0.2095458508,
0.2600385249,
-0.5975080729,
-0.1026279256,
0.5996915102,
0.6016191244,
-0.3135609627,
-1.0722693205,
0.575555861,
0.0346097536,
-0.6394652128,
-0.4787971973,
0.1026915684,
0.0612279512,
0.3862470388,
0.2231357545,
0.1702807248,
0.0310063642,
-0.715271771,
0.3352521956,
0.487223506,
-0.2837284505,
-0.3743490279,
0.9553081989,
-0.0863516852,
-0.6063851714,
0.5231319666,
-0.0260965619,
-0.6381908655,
0.8124799132,
0.624284029,
0.6597511172,
-0.0297492873,
0.0910246074,
-0.0758256093,
0.4536670446,
-0.2642689049,
-0.0626352429,
0.3010283411,
-0.6829740405,
-0.45515275,
-0.2128616273,
-0.4259727597,
-0.0093749724,
-0.1472759992,
-0.0812113732,
-0.8041770458,
0.0323121771,
0.3942536414,
-0.3180196881,
-0.4724158943,
0.1713787019,
0.0344579928,
0.9042428732,
-0.8096519709,
0.8126438856,
0.7315864563,
-0.6161051989,
-0.9552858472,
0.004694615,
0.0344268829,
-0.6336389184,
0.4097383618,
0.0526003763,
-0.036111258,
-0.2371428758,
-1.0511940718,
-0.405389607,
0.9213575125,
0.7300108075,
-0.3547984362,
-0.0383273773,
0.2489140481,
0.6373128295,
-0.527513206,
0.1108456627,
0.6212040782,
0.7558913827,
0.0463510491,
-0.8101142645,
0.1456814259,
-0.4815638661,
-0.1465730965,
-0.0772748291,
-0.2772686183,
0.4290983081,
-0.364613086,
-0.1712343842,
0.0555772595,
0.8550664186,
0.1697624326,
0.6794093847,
0.2998185158,
0.4333812296,
1.0223853588,
0.1010455787,
1.3772823811,
-0.1189346835,
0.1111779585,
1.1503697634,
-0.4051715434,
0.6147997975,
0.4903885126,
0.0028133297,
0.333052814,
0.2603115439,
-0.2282248288,
0.2084312439,
0.2068520486,
-0.0151033914,
-0.338183254,
-0.1465995014,
0.1591117531,
0.6472566724,
-0.0728590488,
-0.6075149775,
0.0628613979,
0.0886651054,
0.1939909905,
0.5504822135,
-0.4161780477,
0.5109980702,
0.0851642936,
-0.492656678,
0.2290969491,
0.2217064947,
0.212335825,
-0.3669383228,
-0.2869922519,
0.0828631669,
-0.1019410565,
-0.1742241979,
-0.6925866604,
0.3441185057,
0.3886472881,
-0.1263291836,
-0.1784384847,
0.6989497542,
0.176454708,
-0.4796047211,
0.1585817188,
0.3712111413,
0.2405430675,
0.0314858444,
-0.7732692957,
-0.1682847142,
0.0359464139,
-0.3418977559,
0.1159244776,
0.6764578223,
-0.1701856554,
1.019690156,
0.8367798924,
0.1544972807,
0.1711702794,
-0.0820887238,
0.9290852547,
-0.7289728522,
-0.3915359676,
-1.1101080179,
0.4251671731,
-0.2202552259,
0.0168696344,
0.6144843698,
0.5201744437,
0.5265535712,
0.1564341038,
1.0138839483,
-0.1574808061,
0.4064487517,
-0.5061066151,
1.212243557,
-0.5526228547,
0.3350629807,
-0.1027915329,
-0.6032624841,
-0.6126436591,
0.4981799126,
-0.2995016575,
0.0894264281,
0.5693138242,
0.6755826473,
-0.0545647293,
0.0737321675,
0.7129407525,
0.6672198772,
0.429700017,
0.3889813721,
0.7032194138,
-0.0439450182,
0.5168193579,
0.1247805431,
-0.2206674516,
-0.1450314522,
-0.8939498663,
-1.0198867321,
-0.1816892177,
-0.1713344604,
-0.3384101689,
0.0475177988,
0.7017305493,
0.5926790237,
-1.0183905363,
-0.090226233,
-0.376516819,
0.4308778644,
-0.0260768067,
-0.0967349038,
0.1110865176,
-0.0822691768,
-0.7012492418,
0.3884922862,
0.241709888,
-0.0054987026,
-0.2635579705,
-0.3882743418,
-0.2200317979,
0.6570106149,
0.5655698776,
0.7344244123,
-0.9614923,
-0.553150475,
-0.3650182784,
-0.1280279607,
-0.0314952768,
0.675362885,
-0.3389751315,
0.3925331831,
0.2846862972,
1.0215321779,
0.0488359369,
-0.1288632154,
0.8675424457,
0.0838789344,
0.1710266322,
0.3916724324,
0.5864979029,
-0.0713036358,
-0.4912912846,
0.3976292014,
0.006052881,
-0.6587870717,
-0.7797299027,
0.3099027574,
-0.751142323,
-0.4575645924,
0.8296439648,
-0.3956236243,
-0.5808233619,
-0.338424176,
0.0154703846,
0.1628566384,
-0.2451643944,
0.951883316,
0.7769683003,
0.0389600284,
-0.1090966389,
-0.8886882663,
0.327915132,
0.4614506364,
-0.8867268562,
0.0933722779,
0.5862979293,
0.3054445088,
0.2784532011,
0.5157585144,
-0.0917113647,
0.5253472924,
0.0988556594,
0.1430454105,
-0.2843702137,
-0.4105273187,
-0.3369371295,
0.1465584487,
0.4408631623,
0.3419475853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15698v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15698v1
|
Cerbero-7B: A Leap Forward in Language-Specific LLMs Through Enhanced Chat Corpus Generation and Evaluation
| 2023-11-27T10:34:55 | 2023-11-27T10:34:55 |
Federico A. Galatolo, Mario G. C. A. Cimino
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study introduces a novel approach for generating high-quality,
language-specific chat corpora using a self-chat mechanism. We combine a
generator LLM for creating new samples and an embedder LLM to ensure diversity.
A new Masked Language Modelling (MLM) model-based quality assessment metric is
proposed for evaluating and filtering the corpora. Utilizing the llama2-70b as
the generator and a multilingual sentence transformer as embedder, we generate
an Italian chat corpus and refine the Fauno corpus, which is based on
translated English ChatGPT self-chat data. The refinement uses structural
assertions and Natural Language Processing techniques. Both corpora undergo a
comprehensive quality evaluation using the proposed MLM model-based quality
metric. The Italian LLM fine-tuned with these corpora demonstrates
significantly enhanced language comprehension and question-answering skills.
The resultant model, cerbero-7b, establishes a new state-of-the-art for Italian
LLMs. This approach marks a substantial advancement in the development of
language-specific LLMs, with a special emphasis on augmenting corpora for
underrepresented languages like Italian.
|
[
-0.2929265499,
-0.7738978863,
0.2019408941,
0.2942695916,
-0.3363386989,
0.4145431817,
-0.1816359907,
-0.6863248944,
0.4371388555,
0.5871251225,
-0.3206808269,
-0.9147455692,
-0.5314757228,
0.3781189322,
-0.3867581189,
0.8608505726,
0.2817495763,
0.3992785215,
-0.0501066968,
-0.0648342967,
-0.5705410838,
-0.5894709229,
-0.5922033787,
0.0982342362,
0.3776470721,
0.4323680401,
0.7347056866,
0.428426832,
0.4108434021,
0.4091814458,
-0.2706997991,
0.4757947326,
-0.6281161904,
0.1667371392,
-0.0690190196,
-0.4662043154,
-0.7375053167,
-0.4127692282,
0.5913553834,
0.4854694903,
-0.1094412878,
0.0528610945,
0.2319290042,
0.3932515979,
-0.5809762478,
0.0058597047,
-0.9005431533,
-0.2168205082,
-0.1132329553,
-0.0285139624,
-0.3819163144,
-0.3272148967,
-0.2608354092,
-0.4281589389,
0.1967530996,
0.0034206575,
0.5372800231,
0.0052268091,
-0.0470677502,
-0.8543465137,
-0.3709453642,
0.5733977556,
-0.9180952907,
0.3183229268,
0.0811017081,
0.3615913689,
-0.2226834595,
-0.4605479538,
-0.2766758204,
-0.3906565011,
0.0489817187,
0.0399142914,
-0.0726484656,
-0.159907639,
-0.4344744384,
0.5951735973,
-0.4704155028,
0.3733401895,
-0.7005347013,
-0.3651267886,
0.4717212021,
0.1449589878,
0.4545682967,
-0.2114685029,
-0.3460331857,
0.1473169923,
-0.8853732347,
-0.2270379961,
0.7779778838,
0.2335575223,
0.0384359322,
0.2520175576,
-0.3105998337,
0.3868705928,
0.1561235487,
-0.2459454834,
0.3833394647,
-0.1864688098,
-0.2275296152,
0.1333924681,
0.7431284785,
0.2145537138,
0.0421096496,
-0.1424560249,
-0.0354063064,
0.08893843,
0.029514784,
-0.7159858346,
0.1245461628,
0.2873122394,
-0.1978598237,
-0.6922036409,
-0.2092751861,
-0.6870007515,
-0.090135321,
0.0239485484,
0.0215992499,
-0.3501004875,
-0.3085767925,
-0.0113561526,
0.2045990378,
0.31782794,
0.2903687656,
-0.8457525373,
0.1657265127,
0.4917209148,
0.6186913848,
-0.7257038355,
-0.0815006047,
-0.3472010791,
0.2042237818,
-0.6151370406,
0.8689619899,
-0.6050651073,
-0.7197322249,
0.2904505134,
0.0790643245,
0.2182545811,
-0.7120435834,
0.6291770935,
-0.4785994589,
0.3367486298,
0.155607298,
-0.5883157253,
0.0048615322,
0.5244957209,
-0.419763118,
1.2221598625,
-0.0234046411,
-0.4102178514,
0.0986460075,
-0.4012826681,
-0.1647624224,
0.4310102463,
-0.3654489219,
-0.1343624592,
0.0274898708,
0.1969662458,
0.5003116727,
-0.3052843809,
0.4858926535,
-0.5341416597,
-0.2680278122,
0.4861345291,
-0.5126883388,
0.5275022984,
0.3283204734,
-0.2663519681,
0.0363501795,
-0.8333243728,
0.0767342001,
-0.2095673382,
-0.249188751,
0.0164904315,
-0.2956117988,
-0.064215906,
0.1938984692,
0.7306826711,
-0.484205842,
-0.3037804961,
-0.6239763498,
0.2904134393,
0.6806585789,
-0.0631256551,
0.4182536304,
-0.0875892043,
0.538544178,
-0.087062493,
0.4595603645,
-0.2781487405,
-0.4903757274,
-0.9641891122,
-0.3950098455,
0.2257616371,
0.6647173166,
-0.4198777378,
0.6856627464,
-0.1195553914,
-0.6279526949,
-0.5823537707,
0.4015305936,
0.5571750998,
0.0563204326,
0.161854431,
-0.4485190213,
-0.3046733439,
-0.92894274,
0.2397376597,
-0.1098633409,
0.0835874677,
0.0895490125,
0.2134477794,
-0.2864905596,
0.5689957738,
-0.1625605524,
-0.298866123,
-0.5499642491,
-0.2866033614,
0.185429126,
0.5080402493,
0.4685316086,
-0.5596352816,
-0.4577926993,
0.0361020602,
-0.8020322919,
-0.1232270449,
0.1789280772,
-0.3346413076,
0.3514170349,
0.642039597,
-0.2885650694,
0.1781857163,
0.8628755212,
-0.1971236467,
0.3316052854,
-0.279494822,
0.3843316734,
-1.3813738823,
-0.1815012991,
-0.5321213007,
-0.1858436763,
-0.569980979,
-0.0339328237,
-0.1428198814,
-0.3054468632,
-0.9225366116,
0.7541493773,
-0.7208580375,
-0.1707828492,
-0.432869792,
0.3809131682,
-0.1539167613,
0.497849375,
-0.0849435627,
0.5024847388,
0.5723121762,
-0.5332626104,
0.1280108839,
0.2002599239,
-0.2750988305,
0.4456575215,
-0.6545228958,
0.3465279937,
0.1860214472,
-0.1138185337,
-1.1891053915,
-0.0672797784,
0.2007979453,
-0.7748399377,
0.4054840803,
-0.1817943007,
-0.3735851347,
-0.0894334465,
-0.0942091569,
0.0891412571,
0.4744749963,
-0.4108444154,
0.393999368,
0.5493658185,
-0.3354711235,
-0.4243697524,
-0.5156900883,
0.2261228114,
-0.268108815,
-0.7636319399,
0.361718744,
-0.3519971669,
-0.1503171474,
-0.36731565,
-0.0996401161,
-0.03965028,
0.2352207601,
0.2050500512,
0.4369696677,
-0.0371256061,
-0.0503977351,
0.4958609045,
-0.0003854018,
-0.0450651869,
-0.0176587719,
0.6891065836,
-0.1532274336,
-0.4413588941,
-0.2656136155,
0.3549626768,
0.0687617958,
0.0462567396,
0.5448334217,
0.5669198632,
-0.1103372797,
-0.342235297,
-0.8008961678,
-0.0158792157,
-0.5312670469,
0.2434112579,
-0.6342765093,
-1.1790924072,
0.588766396,
0.0561803207,
0.0933365151,
0.4957746267,
0.9223173261,
-0.0609563142,
0.6236762404,
0.5459879637,
0.1055272073,
0.4278183281,
0.095957987,
0.0559915714,
-0.4470062256,
-0.1917926073,
-0.4706145525,
0.0620209835,
-0.8340173364,
-0.5122619271,
0.2314234674,
0.1949240863,
0.1314682215,
0.3630187809,
-0.5320539474,
0.4991529882,
0.275455296,
0.089540273,
0.4999117851,
0.0238198042,
-0.2880992293,
0.2464623153,
-0.6443061233,
-1.0767552853,
1.1228234768,
0.33388713,
0.5422942042,
0.1594936997,
0.913461566,
0.589556098,
0.6578477025,
-0.3818489909,
0.6109063029,
-0.1660265625,
-0.8386160135,
-0.3610750139,
-0.2951093018,
-0.7830615044,
0.4381582439,
0.0170758087,
-0.6072562337,
0.2503489852,
0.1547683477,
-0.1262285113,
-0.098904416,
-0.5896309614,
0.8290431499,
-0.2816264927,
-0.2259775102,
-0.1837094873,
-0.2417682856,
0.3254765272,
-0.0611841008,
0.4014204443,
-0.6730790734,
-0.037485294,
0.6099083424,
-0.1554235965,
1.0299496651,
0.1713724434,
-0.2941811085,
0.6483448148,
0.4314807355,
0.1706586778,
0.3307496607,
-0.1092830673,
0.6653853655,
0.1224695742,
-0.3631807268,
-0.4542981088,
0.9220699668,
-0.6782200933,
-0.8485323787,
-0.1410618871,
-0.2306459248,
-0.3574141264,
-0.011170716,
0.133616671,
0.2970685363,
-0.6460923553,
0.3256097138,
0.4052542448,
-0.3910776377,
0.340690285,
0.7897512913,
-0.1577433199,
-0.8262388706,
0.5466815233,
-0.2259598225,
0.5756772757,
0.4043170214,
-0.0996209234,
-0.2229357809,
-0.5616921186,
-0.6242663264,
0.2503167391,
-0.8283572793,
-0.2952803671,
-0.4043953121,
-0.1850222945,
-0.6945027113,
-0.2277101278,
-0.4307161868,
-0.2829992473,
-0.2140394002,
-0.1746896952,
0.094440721,
0.3667625189,
-0.1525865644,
0.2867667675,
-0.8861087561,
0.0839740038,
0.1351231933,
-0.1368067414,
-0.3257709742,
-0.8097757697,
-0.3180965781,
0.1177426875,
-0.4290411174,
-0.960220933,
0.6594927907,
-0.0540607236,
0.8577069044,
0.3739852309,
-0.1973415464,
0.4469371736,
-0.4130035937,
0.7149909735,
0.3991995454,
-0.938379705,
0.5190330744,
-0.3891861737,
0.0439944565,
0.5242641568,
0.2337282002,
-0.2382814586,
-0.8462739587,
-0.6284306645,
-0.5569148064,
0.2252193987,
0.5536606312,
0.5135849118,
-0.3724671602,
0.200481385,
0.1218839213,
0.191087544,
-0.6292226911,
-0.1633044332,
-0.1070599183,
-0.2822054625,
0.0015089934,
-0.3375730813,
0.1239983439,
0.2052580863,
0.6178762913,
-0.1962901801,
0.3869009316,
0.1739347279,
-0.339726299,
0.3334720135,
0.5860731006,
0.3329832852,
0.7968505621,
-0.041921705,
-0.187373057,
0.5189593434,
-0.2581189871,
0.0163263008,
-0.0284806695,
-0.0820128992,
0.3903593719,
0.1248481348,
0.5915964246,
0.5091920495,
-0.6984453201,
0.2618709803,
0.2515569031,
-0.0607780516,
-0.4621527195,
0.381736964,
0.2459749281,
0.2406676859,
0.365683049,
-0.4743843973,
0.3231589198,
-0.8060509562,
0.1254995167,
0.2222394198,
-0.3396939933,
-0.1441499144,
0.4409299791,
0.5418287516,
-0.2782974243,
0.2092134655,
-0.2426818907,
-0.2667892575,
0.7025542855,
0.5575181246,
0.7397927046,
-0.5931870341,
0.3872421086,
0.4475517273,
0.2630354464,
0.1844791323,
0.1343953907,
-0.1738253683,
-1.0513526201,
-0.1928379834,
-0.7222344279,
-0.7014241219,
-0.1072739214,
-0.5871861577,
0.4843789041,
-0.1563524604,
-0.0954910964,
-0.2654714584,
-0.0061639533,
-0.5955632329,
0.2273426056,
0.1989936978,
0.6874039769,
-0.5678081512,
0.9155277014,
0.2313855737,
-0.3922798038,
-0.4426367879,
-0.5462754965,
-0.3218992949,
-1.1496754885,
0.5758782029,
0.0718333796,
-0.159686476,
-0.1838525236,
-0.3673825562,
-0.9079373479,
1.1553674936,
0.3228473663,
-0.880037725,
-0.1411191374,
0.4149684608,
0.6530746818,
-0.6839493513,
0.3501794636,
0.3521097302,
0.0946856067,
0.2919403911,
-0.868689239,
-0.1086457223,
-0.2114385962,
0.1540308595,
-0.0602639951,
-0.6644822359,
0.3868404627,
-0.0146792717,
-0.1956978738,
0.3614777625,
0.9449326396,
0.4969622791,
0.1483081728,
0.3552916348,
0.2044830918,
0.6209490299,
0.065374434,
0.6481763721,
-0.7459896803,
0.1147802994,
1.3205490112,
-0.2872443497,
0.9878816605,
0.2346871942,
0.0675819516,
0.5556551814,
0.6025700569,
-0.0130348345,
0.2142549157,
0.2900235057,
-0.2617911696,
-0.3187069297,
0.0565951616,
-0.3286662102,
0.528352499,
0.50801301,
-0.6084368825,
-0.0982458889,
-0.0061241221,
0.2521346807,
0.1090150476,
-0.2773793936,
0.787299037,
0.1654201895,
-0.6055714488,
0.5288361311,
0.1100771353,
0.7553347349,
-0.5420356989,
0.2164944559,
-0.7429350615,
0.0816148147,
0.0068352767,
-0.5440787673,
0.4016694725,
0.3392276168,
0.1670493037,
-0.2293735147,
0.6084055305,
-0.5087014437,
-0.7550652623,
0.4689671397,
0.7053634524,
0.6055988669,
0.0653211325,
-0.6677116752,
0.3439925313,
0.0126503082,
-0.0067886831,
0.3353108764,
0.5295342803,
0.0504111946,
0.4900229871,
0.742390871,
-0.0438060611,
0.1572415978,
0.3281556368,
0.6837484241,
-0.4414929152,
-0.5142350197,
-0.7072542906,
0.2969698906,
-0.2270982563,
-0.4497901201,
0.9376975298,
0.667216897,
0.8489153981,
-0.0592336096,
0.4748209417,
0.1299036592,
0.4735382199,
-0.5300247073,
0.6240480542,
-0.2507451177,
0.3076972365,
-0.1760779619,
-0.903688252,
-0.0286076758,
0.3189545274,
-0.2282060832,
-0.0914768055,
0.5610604882,
1.2613021135,
0.2263308465,
-0.3044442832,
0.9963710308,
0.1825297028,
0.1933389157,
0.4255187511,
0.8317046762,
-0.5225263238,
1.0678539276,
0.1639025658,
-0.0573541895,
-0.001100864,
-0.6191603541,
-1.0383701324,
-0.434114486,
-0.2867840827,
-0.3149311841,
0.3356370628,
0.5373632908,
0.6543195844,
-0.828748405,
-0.4122391343,
0.0324655361,
0.0956275761,
0.1968142837,
-0.2115942091,
0.0806138813,
-0.7493997812,
-1.0534498692,
0.5471932888,
0.3598588407,
-0.0726697519,
-0.6335284114,
-0.138045609,
0.2057012767,
0.1596762538,
0.6443865299,
-0.124290809,
-0.7429718375,
0.0702230781,
0.1756673008,
-0.1847455204,
0.2000347823,
0.5049790144,
-0.4523802996,
0.183117941,
0.3220531344,
0.4592160285,
0.5453009605,
-0.3267014921,
0.6130254269,
-0.3638479412,
0.0984254405,
0.1476188302,
0.4344085157,
0.5079080462,
-0.4449427724,
0.3326050937,
0.0604874752,
-0.3343039453,
-0.641704917,
-0.0374053642,
-0.8905397058,
-0.2886507511,
1.4720042944,
-0.3178161979,
-0.3285008371,
0.0410031751,
-0.1960017234,
0.1167793721,
-0.4815647602,
0.9572229981,
0.7299175858,
0.3267122805,
-0.1359582841,
-0.3227515221,
0.3251222074,
0.2703390121,
-1.1833326817,
-0.4448952079,
0.5362522006,
0.5678762794,
0.1059283316,
0.7180218697,
-0.5169426203,
0.2898799479,
-0.1977928281,
0.2037017792,
0.0539745316,
-0.3353528678,
-0.0204380173,
0.3548408449,
0.002958985,
-0.3047717512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15653v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15653v1
|
MoDS: Model-oriented Data Selection for Instruction Tuning
| 2023-11-27T09:33:13 | 2023-11-27T09:33:13 |
Qianlong Du, Chengqing Zong, Jiajun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning has become the de facto method to equip large language
models (LLMs) with the ability of following user instructions. Usually,
hundreds of thousands or millions of instruction-following pairs are employed
to fine-tune the foundation LLMs. Recently, some studies show that a small
number of high-quality instruction data is enough. However, how to select
appropriate instruction data for a given LLM is still an open problem. To
address this problem, in this paper we present a model-oriented data selection
(MoDS) approach, which selects instruction data based on a new criteria
considering three aspects: quality, coverage and necessity. First, our approach
utilizes a quality evaluation model to filter out the high-quality subset from
the original instruction dataset, and then designs an algorithm to further
select from the high-quality subset a seed instruction dataset with good
coverage. The seed dataset is applied to fine-tune the foundation LLM to obtain
an initial instruction-following LLM. Finally, we develop a necessity
evaluation model to find out the instruction data which are performed badly in
the initial instruction-following LLM and consider them necessary instructions
to further improve the LLMs. In this way, we can get a small high-quality,
broad-coverage and high-necessity subset from the original instruction
datasets. Experimental results show that, the model fine-tuned with 4,000
instruction pairs selected by our approach could perform better than the model
fine-tuned with the full original dataset which includes 214k instruction data.
|
[
-0.4755916297,
-0.8402385116,
0.4850537777,
0.0482877307,
-0.4446955621,
-0.372415334,
-0.1163007841,
-0.1798800081,
-0.0729717612,
0.9620774388,
-0.6479340792,
-0.6305466294,
-0.4481590688,
-0.0722891837,
-0.365789175,
0.8032393456,
0.0849856585,
0.1756628454,
-0.3186425269,
0.2749775052,
-0.7163817883,
0.0802315548,
-0.3766877353,
-0.2417824715,
-0.0002630912,
0.8938626051,
0.5163362622,
1.2377538681,
0.4291815758,
0.264740169,
-0.085999772,
0.6757686734,
-0.6802888513,
0.2508463562,
-0.044429969,
-0.4982782602,
-0.5590232015,
0.0003275448,
0.6330822706,
0.5066367388,
0.1178205237,
0.259160161,
0.0040030167,
0.8348124027,
-0.5304194093,
0.0118097868,
-0.6211217046,
0.0025367299,
-0.1757989079,
-0.3878014982,
-0.7167633176,
-0.3957632184,
-0.0513394997,
-0.4568935335,
0.1531766057,
0.2531785071,
0.5355666876,
0.1709673852,
-0.4608151317,
-0.1406690776,
-0.6873253584,
0.9359009266,
-0.8066865206,
0.6238574982,
0.837415874,
0.1308254004,
-0.423845768,
-0.2736537755,
-0.120694086,
-0.2836301923,
0.1324775666,
-0.1275654882,
0.2023364753,
0.1181573346,
0.2410827577,
0.5932025909,
-0.3259912431,
0.2314331532,
-0.5194419026,
-0.1344642341,
0.6831872463,
0.3693164587,
0.1045691594,
-0.2003788203,
-0.4883245528,
-0.0524049252,
-1.1317774057,
0.1329731494,
0.4998882711,
0.3096678853,
0.1169597656,
0.6472579241,
-0.559266448,
1.3548629284,
0.1887765676,
-0.2580413818,
0.0000486944,
-0.4181674421,
-0.4832626283,
-0.3343300819,
0.4411501586,
0.179626748,
-0.0189809557,
-0.072778821,
-0.7089253068,
-0.3972036839,
0.3292206526,
-0.9753448963,
-0.1280389577,
0.0269085523,
-0.6305186152,
-0.331011802,
0.2596894801,
-0.6612452865,
-0.0783544183,
-0.8200543523,
0.1923157722,
-0.5371118784,
0.0025992289,
0.1185970679,
0.3330169022,
0.1548728943,
0.0795566067,
-1.1766867638,
0.1549002081,
0.8141492605,
0.5701310039,
-0.2868417799,
-0.0168111715,
-0.6840962768,
0.1604736298,
-0.4829902351,
0.7807079554,
-1.0152437687,
-0.5461214781,
-0.270419687,
0.0162582248,
-0.1471500993,
-0.4191948473,
0.4984818995,
-0.7881705761,
0.2041662484,
-0.1628588289,
-0.8651868105,
-0.2536280751,
0.0932015404,
-0.8237031698,
0.9209546447,
0.444214344,
-0.4277587235,
0.2471005023,
-0.2337115705,
-0.6269572973,
-0.0591171086,
-0.2011528462,
-0.4645658731,
0.339596957,
0.2013693452,
0.5254434943,
-0.535905242,
0.0239888635,
-0.1393097043,
-0.7570829988,
0.01468335,
-0.4745545387,
0.6289466023,
0.2891978323,
-0.1502111256,
0.1437700093,
-0.9134889245,
0.4855563641,
-0.3645284772,
-0.6686025858,
-0.2948898077,
0.3487118483,
-0.3384318054,
0.0938134268,
0.1784926206,
-0.3387076557,
0.3951566815,
-0.4124616683,
0.3129650652,
0.9306784868,
0.0860022753,
0.4641470611,
-0.5046471953,
0.6765594482,
-0.2788387835,
0.425599575,
-0.1836014092,
-0.3081862628,
-0.8024837971,
-0.2562523484,
0.3869800568,
0.4059703648,
-0.7104482055,
0.5439084768,
-0.0460253209,
-0.294936955,
-0.6455630064,
0.3685206473,
0.570292294,
0.5080744624,
0.3388144076,
-0.0923931673,
-0.4694379866,
-0.8864354491,
0.3632778823,
0.0085374713,
0.0543617941,
0.5906726718,
0.0474546328,
-0.084319286,
0.7600693703,
-0.6390848756,
-0.0606353171,
-0.1422144622,
-0.3011877239,
0.2723116279,
0.3922151029,
0.3305336535,
-0.6683325171,
-0.4070487022,
0.1316906065,
-0.14019683,
-0.187982142,
0.0805041716,
-0.4151017964,
0.0913822204,
0.5734080672,
-0.1153146476,
0.3313922882,
0.6645359993,
-0.3642618358,
0.4836678803,
-0.1262533069,
0.3791915476,
-1.1035411358,
-0.0560567938,
-0.2823837698,
-0.2876566947,
-0.4084568322,
-0.0174915977,
0.2554416656,
0.0997823402,
-0.2618976831,
0.3953764141,
-0.5942717791,
-0.0461019427,
-0.4876597226,
-0.3567179441,
0.0659944788,
0.2933921814,
-0.0831501409,
0.9532512426,
0.6083555222,
-0.7366867661,
0.4341974258,
0.25150913,
-0.6262728572,
0.2126652002,
-0.4641029835,
0.2592676282,
0.0958802253,
-0.2208064049,
-0.7280133963,
-0.1965187639,
0.2258041352,
0.0510752127,
0.4673339725,
-0.3892705142,
-0.3020303845,
-0.1529278904,
-0.0916912928,
0.0703891814,
0.3427313566,
-0.4469430447,
0.444996804,
0.1809155494,
-0.084244512,
-0.3588725626,
-0.2512328923,
-0.4128524065,
0.0923827067,
-0.5665510893,
0.4547400475,
-0.1285512447,
0.1257530302,
-0.0065046288,
-0.3467420936,
-0.2064442784,
0.1176661849,
0.304990828,
0.5161827803,
-0.4120100439,
-0.0494227074,
0.2981936038,
-0.1897221804,
-0.1102466956,
-0.2062122971,
0.4489731789,
0.2305634767,
-0.5728580356,
-0.443574518,
0.2595492005,
0.4575733542,
-0.3649941087,
0.3721285462,
0.1722211838,
-0.0289266836,
-0.6690633297,
-0.6133069992,
-0.3478999436,
-0.470892489,
0.3730353117,
-0.2556263208,
-0.6861816645,
-0.0250044111,
0.0367164761,
0.1429902017,
0.0434119552,
0.3118310273,
0.0383807123,
1.1204162836,
0.7898414731,
-0.3047367334,
0.8288693428,
-0.2711387277,
0.0289386511,
-0.8553590178,
-0.2301046252,
-0.456949085,
-0.3120797873,
-0.3547667563,
-0.3769932687,
0.2992188931,
0.0847756788,
-0.0461079963,
0.2964510322,
-0.5148390532,
0.7573028207,
0.6354410648,
0.4081457853,
0.3192467093,
0.0706329644,
0.1247024313,
0.2572120428,
-0.4076459408,
-0.6378030777,
1.2513228655,
0.1395139247,
0.8824320436,
-0.0106831072,
0.45955953,
0.1479408294,
0.0373564847,
-0.6314007044,
0.6693076491,
-0.4750107527,
-0.5252716541,
-0.3402789533,
-0.636099577,
-0.6635616422,
0.0749085099,
-0.1627405882,
-0.4002065659,
0.0568519719,
0.2871083617,
-0.5410277247,
0.1513481885,
-0.6821988225,
0.6155786514,
-0.2928432226,
-0.1860187054,
-0.3468376696,
-0.4140531719,
0.4920535386,
0.0403800532,
-0.1571416259,
-0.1577264071,
0.1234475002,
0.5472801924,
-0.3263298571,
0.6512618661,
0.0084724585,
-0.0385209098,
0.2380402833,
0.2054032087,
0.5373758674,
-0.0165856201,
-0.4404984415,
-0.2830967307,
-0.0306978039,
-0.1996511072,
-0.5659021139,
0.8519792557,
-0.7331936955,
-0.7440035939,
0.1588922292,
-0.5295174122,
-0.3632964492,
0.3392136991,
0.1775226444,
0.64665097,
-0.0380882472,
0.4617612362,
0.8742645383,
0.116286546,
0.1539384574,
0.730520308,
-0.1423328817,
-0.2513861656,
1.1433119774,
0.0353941955,
0.5553025603,
0.3008266985,
0.1240061745,
0.0781898648,
-0.9122240543,
-0.5994439721,
-0.0964255333,
-0.440640837,
-0.5577757955,
-0.0918846354,
-0.3643153906,
-0.0735455826,
0.0646191463,
-0.3284040987,
-0.2003669739,
-0.7227711082,
0.058220312,
0.2257238179,
0.7512212992,
0.3824556172,
0.4023749232,
-0.71778512,
0.4116944373,
0.2957526743,
0.6078538895,
-0.1891594678,
-0.708861649,
-0.3008681238,
0.1912826747,
-0.5717724562,
-0.8994381428,
0.1793718636,
0.2398852259,
0.5818037987,
0.7079362273,
-0.1600690633,
0.6366015077,
-0.5315371752,
0.2632348537,
-0.3126162291,
-0.6871916056,
0.7458844781,
-0.148652181,
-0.0450317711,
0.666380167,
0.1494500488,
-0.1505829692,
-0.1460735649,
-0.3551665545,
-0.7312160134,
1.0544093847,
-0.029477397,
0.1253061444,
0.1219468787,
0.5626716614,
0.2854588926,
0.0680789649,
-0.1749675423,
-0.2404235899,
0.0592624359,
-0.1629740149,
0.3335993588,
-0.3892671764,
-0.0798099265,
-0.1420316994,
0.885687232,
-0.0578526631,
0.0691665709,
-0.3146526217,
0.0219989084,
-0.4292986393,
0.2775360048,
0.4319821,
0.8959562778,
-0.2713036537,
-0.2264162153,
-0.0869956613,
-0.549790442,
0.1343095154,
0.0352889709,
-0.6665636301,
-0.1852254868,
0.2755711675,
1.1197503805,
0.3537561893,
-0.5550273061,
0.4381577969,
0.1772123426,
0.1279037446,
0.1177448705,
0.8109598756,
-0.1273496598,
0.1713233888,
0.0507579111,
-0.0087352833,
0.0865311697,
-0.311275363,
0.2419193536,
0.5128846765,
-0.1806725264,
-0.295776695,
0.1986600161,
0.3185912967,
-0.3651314378,
0.8297107816,
-0.1894349307,
-0.1917850226,
0.7282071114,
0.7283687592,
0.3984461129,
-0.5259691477,
0.3106186986,
0.2315715998,
0.1661498696,
-0.2884838879,
0.5742111802,
0.1212983951,
-0.570476532,
-0.6046490669,
-0.566458106,
-0.3126884103,
0.4641342759,
-0.8900858164,
0.6626927853,
-0.5261332989,
0.1278054565,
-0.34304896,
0.2012473643,
-0.6621698737,
0.3201054335,
-0.0483445041,
1.0700050592,
-0.8541452885,
1.013250947,
0.4212688208,
-0.1431505978,
-0.8723804951,
-0.1659090221,
-0.0824909061,
-0.903727293,
0.4662743211,
0.011358045,
0.1075494215,
0.1691868752,
-0.4614235163,
-1.0247921944,
1.1810778379,
0.3506114185,
-0.8439667225,
-0.000732804,
-0.2172304988,
0.1536474973,
-0.5987007618,
0.1728301644,
0.7983692288,
0.3679960966,
0.3384883404,
-0.4874951839,
-0.0231151842,
-0.0320921317,
0.0025376333,
0.4035314322,
-0.6001444459,
0.8536676168,
-0.1455307007,
-0.0874273703,
0.1492163688,
0.5593230724,
0.2860279977,
0.0326785222,
0.5879761577,
0.3080293834,
0.5656244755,
0.1198147982,
0.99794662,
-0.4718974829,
0.1399543732,
1.0703778267,
-0.0245914049,
0.8987516761,
0.2627106905,
-0.0776258931,
0.1049837172,
0.7601671219,
-0.1764138192,
0.685301125,
0.0560429431,
-0.1298945397,
-0.5082858801,
0.0728918165,
-0.3910195827,
0.5290265083,
0.3064424098,
-0.5352432728,
0.003818657,
-0.1997144222,
-0.25019297,
-0.1910709441,
-0.324098587,
0.7878300548,
-0.1711305976,
-0.7511534095,
0.4694088697,
0.2317124307,
0.1739370227,
-0.6303129196,
-0.3049477935,
-0.2764406502,
-0.1341519803,
-0.2216482162,
-0.6256737113,
0.0294490904,
-0.170984298,
-0.58625561,
-0.2034548819,
0.6648845077,
-0.4711127281,
-0.5926709175,
-0.0493895859,
0.319147706,
0.0033104797,
0.1465485692,
-0.3756008744,
0.2796799839,
0.3937274218,
-0.5292488933,
0.2420956641,
0.3523850441,
-0.1258220226,
0.6117473245,
0.8139820695,
0.5536341071,
-0.066389747,
-0.0881949738,
1.1664943695,
-0.5596756935,
-0.4227837026,
-0.7361631393,
0.4026315808,
0.0439575203,
-0.4561873674,
0.5090791583,
0.542999804,
0.8479676843,
0.0386559404,
0.6367405057,
-0.0456257798,
0.5714477301,
-0.9917938113,
0.4111904502,
-0.3241963685,
0.6269436479,
0.0784603283,
-1.0821299553,
0.0198171157,
0.6709114313,
-0.4640518129,
0.1397252828,
0.3340267837,
1.0704125166,
-0.4360384643,
0.2753394842,
0.4071558714,
0.099547334,
0.1290719807,
0.5322861075,
0.7163560987,
-0.2051966637,
0.3048028052,
-0.2171292007,
-0.37955001,
-0.481693387,
-0.9051311016,
-0.8685765266,
-0.4886541069,
0.0579815023,
-0.1130184382,
-0.0456032418,
1.1075303555,
1.0247924328,
-0.9124877453,
-0.0414531082,
0.1119208112,
0.4342844784,
-0.289324373,
-0.1365524232,
0.456566751,
-0.4379526079,
-0.6730380058,
0.8044196367,
0.1052169055,
0.0563821271,
-0.2756261528,
-0.1394525915,
0.1382126659,
0.1000703946,
0.4458071291,
0.0915983319,
-0.6063296795,
-0.2282004505,
0.1337323487,
-0.1654975861,
-0.0519504435,
1.0254365206,
-0.5422800183,
0.6213735342,
0.594204545,
0.7393593788,
0.2674901187,
0.092333436,
0.5929843187,
-0.7758511901,
-0.0887531638,
0.3131177425,
0.2339046746,
0.1491054893,
-0.6002166867,
0.3743028343,
-0.1607465148,
-0.6707145572,
-0.7380552292,
0.3104067147,
-0.5667902827,
-0.3039302528,
1.2949836254,
-0.0086761219,
-0.2383296341,
0.0414420776,
-0.3254315853,
-0.0243042745,
-0.2482909858,
0.8831096888,
0.7043853402,
-0.1964357346,
-0.0849856883,
-0.8039618134,
0.5090460777,
0.2831890285,
-0.7450712919,
0.1152349934,
0.7633087039,
0.3884005547,
-0.4116981924,
0.3809159994,
0.099798128,
0.2789342999,
-0.4320931733,
-0.1855961829,
-0.5779769421,
-0.6546751261,
-0.0611674041,
0.0293999556,
0.0780978724,
-0.4060420692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15648v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15648v1
|
Reinforcement Learning from Diffusion Feedback: Q* for Image Search
| 2023-11-27T09:20:12 | 2023-11-27T09:20:12 |
Aboli Marathe
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
Large vision-language models are steadily gaining personalization
capabilities at the cost of fine-tuning or data augmentation. We present two
models for image generation using model-agnostic learning that align semantic
priors with generative capabilities. RLDF, or Reinforcement Learning from
Diffusion Feedback, is a singular approach for visual imitation through
prior-preserving reward function guidance. This employs Q-learning (with
standard Q*) for generation and follows a semantic-rewarded trajectory for
image search through finite encoding-tailored actions. The second proposed
method, noisy diffusion gradient, is optimization driven. At the root of both
methods is a special CFG encoding that we propose for continual semantic
guidance. Using only a single input image and no text input, RLDF generates
high-quality images over varied domains including retail, sports and
agriculture showcasing class-consistency and strong visual diversity. Project
website is available at https://infernolia.github.io/RLDF.
|
[
-0.1182259396,
-0.8556560278,
0.6040250659,
0.1402879208,
-0.1640986949,
-0.1456011832,
0.0021770156,
-0.178508684,
0.0079884641,
0.5997985601,
-0.9810970426,
-0.5132710338,
-0.4645730853,
-0.0714345947,
-0.3574051857,
0.6465058327,
0.0216666721,
0.2413068712,
-0.2491777092,
-0.1899795532,
-0.3857449591,
-0.1022773981,
-1.2446286678,
-0.3154227436,
0.8920784593,
0.0992655605,
0.6699059606,
0.5493094921,
0.0798317567,
0.2774981856,
0.3093884885,
0.3675618172,
-0.6372030973,
0.3664511442,
-0.4397101104,
-0.0498569161,
0.0822364166,
0.0169799719,
0.6927361488,
0.2640187144,
-0.4896766543,
-0.1300019622,
-0.3285012841,
0.9969747663,
-0.8131901026,
0.023375826,
-0.5265654325,
0.454911232,
0.3650947511,
-0.3335692585,
-0.5740562081,
-0.4327794015,
0.1399696618,
-1.0670369864,
0.2977367938,
0.1465293318,
0.841747582,
0.489933759,
-0.3764432967,
-0.3206943274,
-0.8204360008,
0.7525855899,
-0.338521719,
0.4597708583,
0.1404289603,
0.3233728707,
-0.5531603694,
-0.9597378373,
-0.4502966404,
-0.2319054455,
0.1272642463,
0.4856522381,
-0.1367525905,
0.1055100635,
-0.0012657514,
0.3044014871,
-0.4591905475,
0.0572623983,
-0.4177638292,
-0.0532583073,
0.6857066154,
0.1065639704,
0.1515378058,
0.2826441824,
-0.443890065,
-0.5786198378,
-0.6737961769,
0.0679657385,
0.3714942634,
-0.1931511909,
0.2705610991,
0.2677429914,
-0.3664760292,
0.9427047968,
0.247270301,
-0.1594326645,
0.076313965,
-0.1702863276,
-0.1902728975,
-0.2452854663,
0.7260274887,
0.4099563062,
0.1167268157,
-0.2063521594,
-0.4295725822,
0.0249453131,
0.414804697,
-0.6783471107,
-0.3986249864,
0.0216386374,
-0.5046208501,
-0.5555078387,
0.0981061831,
-0.7670863271,
-0.3400390148,
-0.1447405815,
0.5057651997,
-0.2330148816,
-0.3667483628,
0.2391216755,
-0.4132376611,
0.4216540754,
0.6362745166,
-0.7081869841,
0.2129249424,
0.1859160066,
0.6431646943,
-0.3682011366,
-0.3515874445,
-0.8824402094,
0.2626059651,
-0.7013240457,
0.8835052252,
-0.4885751605,
-0.6648027897,
0.1939040422,
0.0731395856,
0.1143269762,
-0.7817806005,
0.3318398893,
-0.8762701154,
0.3784892857,
0.0045314524,
-0.5802536607,
-0.3974449635,
0.0434727296,
-0.6655404568,
0.9898148179,
0.3508458436,
-0.4597922564,
0.8037653565,
-0.6567921638,
-0.3737499118,
0.2432379425,
-0.3182381392,
-0.7172602415,
0.1343171895,
0.1262402087,
0.4309205413,
0.1738089174,
0.0949962661,
-0.4967007935,
-0.1502427757,
0.0860893428,
-0.276888907,
0.1239552274,
0.3607672751,
-0.2698163986,
0.4510637522,
-0.7650681138,
0.1187828407,
0.5118467212,
-0.5462605357,
-0.0639358684,
0.2864362597,
0.0107234875,
0.195750609,
0.0220028721,
-0.3811144531,
0.1309488118,
-0.157131657,
0.3579405248,
0.9029099941,
0.3240610957,
0.6223732233,
-0.2137524784,
0.6637866497,
0.2379920781,
0.2532386482,
-0.2735632062,
-0.312481761,
-0.611138761,
-0.2463524044,
0.3164433241,
0.3139116466,
-1.0193209648,
-0.024790179,
0.0896213651,
0.0560633056,
-0.142010361,
0.0766636878,
0.3715997636,
0.4787884653,
0.2556035519,
-0.558013916,
-0.2867598534,
-0.7136055827,
0.2451228797,
0.0290690288,
0.2864170671,
0.6062429547,
0.3223229647,
-0.3219216764,
0.6800683141,
-0.6945377588,
-0.2856236398,
0.0913889408,
0.1926032752,
-0.1242103577,
0.4777742624,
0.5898096561,
-0.9729120731,
-0.3070957363,
0.1011001021,
-0.6054081917,
0.2130650729,
-0.1768732816,
-0.2798062563,
0.3323043287,
0.6100686789,
-0.3169252574,
0.5590516329,
0.4357447326,
-0.2849111855,
0.5143718719,
-0.7160108685,
0.1956532001,
-0.4501356781,
-0.1926234514,
0.1516108364,
-0.6593139768,
-0.343580097,
0.2652637064,
-0.1214426309,
-0.0334458165,
-0.5113933682,
0.7684879303,
-0.3397747874,
-0.2358646691,
-0.4707118869,
-0.1261821538,
-0.0093720127,
0.6722747087,
0.453365773,
0.7886000872,
0.7176374793,
-0.8959128857,
0.4982257187,
-0.0188261382,
-0.2771480381,
0.5477048159,
-0.6492290497,
0.0621698834,
-0.3533708751,
0.4616168141,
-0.7949110866,
-0.3451443911,
0.5251250267,
-0.2739865482,
0.1873590499,
-0.0653130114,
-0.4710731208,
-0.4282381237,
-0.0615252443,
0.4184387922,
0.7907745242,
-0.8259730935,
0.4749121368,
0.0291453153,
0.2721395791,
-0.3816335499,
-0.2678726315,
-0.3208949268,
-0.2167669088,
-0.3287701905,
0.2324621081,
-0.0213755872,
0.1196953729,
0.2861295938,
0.105032295,
-0.0399227701,
0.0621583275,
0.2723114789,
0.1934684813,
-0.0911485404,
0.1165493503,
-0.008289542,
0.1370564699,
-0.0739826113,
-0.9370353222,
0.1060269699,
0.3046180606,
-0.2972855866,
-0.140786618,
0.3423552513,
0.2301855087,
-0.1922864765,
0.4305912852,
0.9115940928,
0.1026826873,
-0.6064596772,
-0.2242006063,
-0.182870999,
-0.5021483302,
0.3123998642,
-0.1652854234,
-1.0369404554,
0.2826940119,
-0.5417414904,
0.1448098719,
0.2831374407,
0.552040875,
-0.310921371,
1.1626331806,
0.6668789983,
0.5481096506,
0.9036189914,
-0.3268918097,
-0.2116611451,
-0.4226195812,
-0.330247879,
0.1641243547,
-0.3417128325,
-0.3478821516,
-0.4094379842,
0.4278934896,
0.2026715875,
-0.2792356312,
-0.2028376162,
-0.6201120019,
0.5965799093,
0.8230836391,
0.4908870757,
0.0968783721,
0.1750430912,
-0.1986467987,
0.1735405773,
-1.0192044973,
0.160182029,
1.0090378523,
0.1628089398,
0.9981757998,
-0.0159298591,
0.7860351205,
0.6195476651,
0.1674128324,
-0.7231900692,
0.4286333025,
-0.158298254,
-0.1852820069,
-0.3911040127,
-0.4250962436,
-1.1238372326,
0.235610202,
-0.4754678905,
-0.1870673895,
0.2952053547,
0.5910739899,
-0.2949726284,
0.0698400214,
-0.6393033862,
0.7485435009,
-0.1592846215,
-0.6483339667,
-0.4377903044,
-0.3908331394,
0.6522390842,
0.0917539671,
0.05204501,
0.2330818027,
0.0418372191,
0.4075695276,
-0.3582207263,
0.7368247509,
-0.5170161128,
0.0234128181,
0.2336609364,
0.0663831234,
0.5837866664,
0.0649618059,
0.5114483833,
-0.5674831271,
-0.0597279407,
-0.5170547962,
-0.8156971931,
0.5283482671,
-0.638277173,
-0.6320871711,
-0.3051160276,
-0.2245488018,
0.0466244668,
0.1677159518,
0.3589511514,
0.3234624267,
-0.2236173898,
0.0173249748,
1.0881280899,
-0.319878757,
0.3043566048,
0.2052121013,
-0.6724042296,
-0.6038010716,
1.0515083075,
-0.3873007298,
0.2768935859,
0.2808701396,
0.1419906914,
-0.4011741281,
-0.459605813,
-0.6760061383,
0.1901147664,
-0.8052290082,
-0.2046946883,
-0.2305571586,
-0.1170367077,
-0.1510117203,
-0.145101428,
-0.1861683577,
-0.222521916,
-0.4849257767,
0.0702591762,
0.4486944973,
1.1996954679,
-0.2841303051,
0.2373352051,
-0.4181441069,
0.2312542796,
0.7228143811,
0.3405686617,
0.1959822923,
-0.2052785009,
-0.3542748392,
-0.1319855452,
-0.4281462431,
-0.6024582982,
0.3931524754,
0.4855399132,
0.6847342253,
0.3541972935,
-0.0984934494,
0.494869113,
-0.6809992194,
0.8730267286,
0.5795496106,
-0.4851444066,
0.5272251964,
-0.3037879467,
0.2305991799,
0.1780754328,
0.2630226314,
-0.2275161743,
-0.4105060995,
-0.8399845958,
-0.7318018675,
0.4557157755,
-0.2055044174,
0.0158009045,
0.0198115893,
0.6213599443,
0.003543199,
0.0694679171,
-0.7675855756,
-0.1695658118,
-0.5989827514,
-0.0126731806,
0.1358366162,
0.0394365415,
-0.3906464279,
-0.1114349887,
0.6409091353,
-0.1808016151,
0.194068104,
0.5129353404,
0.0352118127,
-0.1452736259,
-0.0998029187,
0.914883554,
0.3668240011,
0.157711938,
-0.000112715,
-0.2138379812,
-0.2561239302,
0.301739037,
-0.3778091371,
-0.4604313374,
-0.0717882439,
-0.0413255244,
1.0006922483,
0.2484699637,
-0.646478653,
0.5835208297,
-0.170411855,
-0.9441230297,
-0.4661589265,
0.58409971,
-0.153377071,
0.4820988774,
0.2446527928,
0.033301454,
0.2359922826,
-0.2222364396,
0.434586972,
0.6130182743,
-0.3594724536,
-0.1126381233,
0.8258538246,
0.0408953875,
-0.0950338542,
0.4092642963,
-0.5345520377,
-0.1901231557,
0.400728941,
0.438457787,
0.8654291034,
0.2116300911,
0.7498896122,
0.4790337682,
-0.2918283641,
-0.4903610349,
0.013944597,
-0.44034639,
-0.7585377097,
-0.3931582272,
-0.552808702,
-0.3767142296,
-0.0784747303,
-0.5285755992,
-0.0068247621,
-0.7838872075,
-0.2113705873,
-0.0721661374,
-0.3948532939,
-0.5978258252,
0.308403343,
0.0196267087,
0.6305682063,
-0.5350701809,
0.9123146534,
0.7743962407,
-0.5089060664,
-0.7022786736,
-0.1287231147,
-0.4162086248,
-0.9322613478,
1.0267920494,
-0.3917879462,
-0.3395093083,
0.2629471719,
-0.9035149813,
-0.5558885932,
1.2874461412,
0.0770669878,
-0.2129863352,
-0.0701132044,
-0.5256178975,
0.2380634099,
-0.6254746318,
-0.2282167971,
0.1994880438,
0.4205995798,
0.7313836217,
-0.1692117602,
-0.2705411017,
0.0685459226,
0.4993615448,
0.0450133309,
-0.6394761205,
0.4873993397,
-0.336648196,
-0.3888685703,
0.193960011,
0.7848925591,
0.3886426687,
0.1879855245,
0.671076417,
0.8672680855,
0.4738969505,
0.0846021101,
0.95986408,
0.0919408649,
0.3103576303,
0.8903030157,
-0.1038159803,
0.7077608705,
0.3602623343,
-0.000335026,
0.7017998695,
0.7542831898,
-0.1939312369,
1.1683861017,
0.2680149674,
-0.2888708413,
-0.2769152224,
0.0072201444,
0.0392004214,
0.0083139585,
0.2213456929,
-0.4391348362,
-0.3456502557,
0.1775415838,
-0.525873661,
0.2065600753,
-0.5286258459,
1.003603816,
-0.1836820841,
-0.7351490259,
0.4763472378,
-0.1095182896,
0.7742657065,
-0.5198461413,
-0.4140082598,
-0.2118501365,
-0.0684313998,
-0.1775203496,
-0.6872578263,
0.2082254291,
-0.4888497591,
-0.2597925961,
-0.3503005207,
0.6875396967,
-0.4824064672,
-0.3817882538,
0.1310029328,
0.3697111011,
-0.0717904866,
0.4961093664,
-0.8019858003,
-0.1070986316,
0.106949456,
-0.2476073951,
0.3643887937,
0.32952407,
0.0975826755,
0.634304285,
0.676147759,
0.2353086025,
0.448040098,
0.048163943,
0.6572765112,
-0.4590801597,
-0.5128546357,
-0.3508716822,
0.2671999037,
0.0166465845,
-0.1837464422,
0.1748979539,
0.2393900156,
1.0115565062,
-0.4766532481,
0.5768613219,
0.1904096454,
0.1382555664,
-0.8764086366,
0.3517125249,
-0.9015399814,
-0.3516738117,
-0.0320921727,
-0.6372588873,
-0.3046771586,
0.7049337029,
-0.1908314675,
0.0388652645,
0.469160974,
0.9005176425,
-0.0665653422,
-0.2825136185,
0.6247068048,
-0.2603371143,
0.1199725568,
0.5161185265,
0.9715221524,
-0.1843916178,
0.3458876312,
0.0591653995,
-0.1270612925,
-0.1043911874,
-0.7593445778,
-0.4242908657,
-0.7054778934,
-0.5067179799,
-0.3869130909,
0.0891731605,
0.5036397576,
1.0245784521,
-0.465834111,
-0.0476710387,
-0.6291640997,
0.1898143291,
-0.4202056825,
-0.2466710359,
0.1101567,
-0.5550132394,
-0.6735167503,
0.2501223683,
0.513081491,
0.2701850832,
-0.6961120963,
-0.5972616673,
0.0140377963,
0.0005636888,
0.5192893744,
0.7348014712,
-0.7714878917,
-0.2472648621,
-0.0958049744,
0.0080989255,
0.0796763897,
0.8216682673,
-0.9816715121,
0.3819388151,
0.2695457935,
0.7156327367,
0.7290130854,
-0.0378286205,
0.6823256016,
-0.6424611807,
0.2584148347,
0.0261797234,
0.2026571184,
0.1893883348,
-0.4901885986,
0.4941290617,
0.4028508961,
-0.6684393883,
-0.5443758965,
0.6969252825,
-0.8161275983,
-0.4105274379,
1.082465291,
-0.3549107015,
-0.5213220716,
0.3547249436,
-0.1508509666,
-0.0529046021,
-0.5282226801,
0.480229944,
0.4617286325,
-0.340491116,
-0.7228342295,
-0.3678380549,
0.6973871589,
0.3209183514,
-0.4797128439,
-0.2425691038,
0.8790413737,
0.2814263105,
-0.1694537401,
0.7738664746,
-0.0920170471,
0.6984187365,
-0.0389261246,
-0.1121637523,
-0.0882428512,
-0.2875438035,
-0.4994285107,
0.1379453242,
0.3804998398,
-0.2359036952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15642v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15642v1
|
InfoPattern: Unveiling Information Propagation Patterns in Social Media
| 2023-11-27T09:12:35 | 2023-11-27T09:12:35 |
Chi Han, Jialiang Xu, Manling Li, Hanning Zhang, Tarek Abdelzaher, Heng Ji
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL
|
Social media play a significant role in shaping public opinion and
influencing ideological communities through information propagation. Our demo
InfoPattern centers on the interplay between language and human ideology. The
demo (Code: https://github.com/blender-nlp/InfoPattern ) is capable of: (1) red
teaming to simulate adversary responses from opposite ideology communities; (2)
stance detection to identify the underlying political sentiments in each
message; (3) information propagation graph discovery to reveal the evolution of
claims across various communities over time. (Live Demo:
https://incas.csl.illinois.edu/blender/About )
|
[
-0.5558511019,
-1.086625576,
0.2859942317,
0.6967849731,
-0.3009545505,
0.3789010346,
-0.2194510549,
-0.2163183093,
0.7046915293,
0.2591497302,
-0.6690067053,
-0.5546218157,
-0.9048228264,
-0.3681777716,
-0.5376492143,
1.2566092014,
0.3124832511,
-0.0173000228,
0.2848999798,
0.0386018492,
0.0780008882,
-0.5026205182,
-0.7379018664,
-0.5394741893,
0.6134642363,
0.2025819719,
0.7862029672,
0.6483058333,
0.3731816411,
0.263164103,
-0.135986954,
-0.2695888579,
-0.9008963704,
-0.0063084192,
-0.0725142509,
-0.5048672557,
0.1908631325,
-0.0118577499,
0.6490906477,
0.3640575111,
-0.2707061768,
0.1077474877,
0.2245419025,
0.8643434048,
-0.6915246248,
0.3025702834,
-0.5881050825,
-0.126546219,
-0.4354032576,
-0.3034886122,
-0.4839870334,
-0.6842321157,
-0.0303346328,
-0.6890541911,
0.3785208166,
-0.1368377805,
1.075696826,
0.1576011479,
-0.473020494,
-0.2084519267,
-0.9605740905,
0.5171605945,
-0.2626116872,
0.1697647721,
0.1118359715,
0.3835399449,
-0.4331918061,
-0.6944705248,
-0.8112432361,
0.4848402441,
0.0628644004,
0.2346097082,
-0.6243534684,
0.1294904351,
0.1506575495,
-0.0363675393,
-0.4023174345,
-0.5477981567,
-0.4579462707,
0.0632325858,
0.526042223,
-0.1522760391,
0.0452014618,
-0.4559504092,
-0.5567952394,
-0.5094185472,
-0.589722693,
0.0539640896,
0.7908293605,
-0.1058207452,
-0.2502374649,
0.6070474982,
-0.1702148318,
0.6865264177,
0.1467964351,
0.3640272021,
0.1953091472,
-0.4047767222,
0.0191233493,
0.2671431005,
0.8573032022,
0.3515063822,
0.0678345188,
0.4793320596,
0.2434488237,
0.3283972442,
0.2129729092,
-0.6582514644,
-0.5518873334,
0.0590664819,
-0.799867928,
-0.5872446299,
0.4374946356,
-0.9252483845,
-0.9561840892,
-0.1945049465,
0.1709864736,
-0.3368453383,
-0.7650107741,
0.1437427402,
-0.8198316693,
0.4103820026,
0.4080891907,
-0.2911138535,
0.2401578128,
0.9634339809,
0.9969004989,
-0.0218156986,
-0.0917687565,
0.0558842123,
0.0645328015,
-0.2744506001,
0.9039729834,
-0.5869986415,
-0.1383349001,
0.0159516297,
-0.1380807012,
0.0854538977,
-0.2894018888,
0.2475247085,
-0.6022691727,
0.0913859382,
-0.2105780691,
-0.5503822565,
-0.2538966537,
0.1990244091,
-0.854264617,
0.8698344231,
0.0274081454,
-1.2743090391,
0.2028125077,
-1.1457986832,
-0.187227577,
-0.014637989,
-0.2617870271,
-0.2634017766,
-0.0663567856,
-0.3518309295,
0.2761396766,
-0.040453542,
0.0991084352,
-0.35776788,
-0.1834869981,
0.3099402785,
-0.4143654108,
1.0771387815,
0.4517160952,
-0.5795814395,
0.2265935093,
-0.5353171825,
-0.3743751049,
0.3531728387,
-0.2811694145,
-0.3616968691,
0.2136530727,
0.2542606592,
0.1999791116,
0.1065764725,
-0.6547567248,
0.3549607396,
-0.0733479485,
0.4956457019,
0.9459486008,
0.5069388747,
0.335303843,
-0.5489347577,
0.378906846,
-0.0498770997,
0.5050509572,
0.0690155998,
-0.8902760148,
-0.6963596344,
0.0581194274,
0.0982404277,
0.4314017296,
-0.8054667711,
0.3011333048,
-0.221160695,
-0.623262763,
-0.7632132173,
-0.0296857022,
0.1165996641,
0.1888507307,
0.0577807799,
0.1772843003,
-0.6385957003,
-0.9662662148,
-0.5927100182,
-0.5427059531,
0.1083017066,
-0.2707493603,
0.2445446402,
-0.2443011701,
0.8617258668,
-0.4267037511,
-0.1058536097,
-0.3894143403,
0.6844204068,
0.3015162051,
0.0518885031,
0.481618613,
-1.4707304239,
-0.5618966818,
-0.1860106438,
-0.2883298397,
0.0820356235,
0.0557444133,
-0.215359509,
-0.0307931155,
0.1411407292,
-0.328614831,
0.6675586104,
1.0058994293,
-0.5066975951,
0.189285472,
0.2477476895,
0.4636119008,
-1.54157722,
-0.1404722929,
0.0571458414,
-0.2284772992,
-0.6987349987,
-0.2636136711,
-0.1979905963,
0.164457351,
-0.5304145813,
0.3296280503,
-0.0566712432,
0.1686770171,
-0.2818287313,
0.0519332439,
-0.0253030192,
0.0903095454,
-0.037086755,
0.469830513,
0.2910450995,
-0.3680905402,
0.3662562668,
0.0325942822,
-0.5996835232,
0.2141741514,
-0.46140486,
-0.0487856418,
-0.5215188265,
0.442037642,
-1.2441450357,
-0.5677388906,
0.3511886001,
-0.5915877223,
-0.1023361385,
-0.2552600205,
-0.724316895,
-0.0097026071,
-0.5016040802,
0.1875079572,
0.405449152,
-0.5164778829,
0.59765172,
0.81771487,
-0.1503130943,
-0.5136007071,
-0.5379772186,
-0.0172364805,
-0.1471778005,
-0.6636745334,
0.1976324618,
-0.120452337,
-0.612976253,
0.1544034332,
0.3257469535,
-0.0271103885,
-0.1641650051,
0.4787785411,
-0.1434148848,
0.1262002736,
0.434876442,
0.0761313736,
0.04490095,
0.0079706758,
0.0577923097,
0.8830114603,
-0.1893743277,
-0.2960665226,
-0.3541716635,
0.4818065763,
0.3115454316,
0.1333695501,
0.9257695675,
0.3211199641,
-0.2289628685,
-0.224966228,
-0.5971658826,
-0.4134352803,
-0.4980099201,
0.2518939972,
0.1325446367,
-0.6314613819,
0.1888839453,
-0.4930635989,
0.064899154,
0.3195155561,
0.5617709756,
-0.1811736524,
1.1876573563,
0.6751927137,
-0.0778109953,
0.8372343183,
-0.4265392721,
0.2110066861,
-0.3190408051,
-0.2036732584,
-0.3971099854,
-0.3517023623,
-0.6631392837,
-0.4574303925,
0.5311779976,
0.1768460423,
-0.0425735898,
0.2295140326,
-0.7001592517,
0.6172136068,
0.4150622487,
0.0715399534,
0.2064247578,
0.0744920224,
0.4174880981,
0.0383547843,
-0.6836766601,
-0.4785331488,
0.6871848106,
0.4000225663,
0.9516499639,
0.0382667668,
0.5775086284,
0.7282736301,
0.6377747059,
-0.6060516834,
0.4388337433,
0.0171912033,
-0.6625672579,
-0.048294995,
-0.3219975829,
-1.0145921707,
0.0378413685,
-0.4402701259,
-0.4912282825,
0.1652301848,
0.4229665995,
0.32683146,
0.3907298446,
-0.6351777315,
0.6820380092,
-0.082210131,
0.0181500129,
-0.4733856022,
-0.74922961,
0.0226128455,
0.2541034818,
0.4093967676,
-0.1098159477,
0.0631324127,
0.9650108218,
0.051156871,
0.9769409895,
-0.1549003124,
0.2705364823,
0.2582143545,
0.0074986932,
0.5621732473,
-0.2104337811,
-0.1930221021,
0.2834365964,
-0.1064593792,
-0.4247554541,
-0.5473537445,
0.6407288313,
-0.8815584183,
-0.3979646266,
-0.2814879417,
-0.2625207305,
0.3536435962,
0.3054077327,
0.6036702991,
0.0106565766,
-0.5915394425,
0.4912636578,
0.7914845943,
0.3237354159,
0.3039702177,
0.3054105341,
-0.2884613574,
-0.305324316,
0.7647639513,
0.0971872658,
0.2758824825,
0.3192571402,
0.5290807486,
-0.1220965683,
-0.1469757557,
-0.2120085359,
0.2665175498,
-0.9692204595,
-0.036787793,
-0.7352676392,
-0.1082557067,
-0.1960327327,
-0.1353043616,
-0.5513697267,
-0.4653270841,
0.1910963356,
-0.1755500436,
0.5258843303,
1.2110497952,
-0.0086086411,
0.7412445545,
-0.3169633448,
0.0646763742,
0.0399076231,
0.1741389185,
-0.5619590282,
0.1197686866,
-0.0514560044,
0.3856838048,
-0.4004029036,
-1.2923814058,
-0.1594217271,
-0.1624483913,
0.2759235203,
0.7424757481,
0.2857710123,
0.2865168452,
-0.1206511185,
0.8143026829,
0.2653220892,
-0.7651175857,
0.7761146426,
-0.3913570642,
0.1551438421,
0.4381960034,
0.7360985279,
-0.5670026541,
-0.6809198856,
-0.8781443238,
-0.6354580522,
0.4381553233,
0.3208834529,
0.1162563786,
-0.0267037973,
0.0241205562,
-0.1057105884,
0.2134913653,
-0.78883183,
-0.5852201581,
-0.4899558127,
-0.1643653661,
0.0877458155,
-0.0065425728,
-0.6560944915,
0.0157553591,
0.658164382,
-0.0247822795,
0.2607210279,
0.0967404172,
0.4998058379,
-0.224103108,
0.1124851406,
0.5004674792,
0.5975073576,
-0.0069600102,
0.207663238,
-0.430480063,
-0.422535032,
0.0872249454,
-0.0510221906,
-0.3669889271,
0.4022405446,
0.2786298096,
0.7802923322,
-0.1605625004,
-0.0048724334,
1.0187767744,
-0.3378465176,
-0.2532941699,
-0.605877459,
0.147891283,
0.3169236183,
0.2453462631,
0.3439837396,
0.1953434646,
0.1512513161,
-0.712737143,
0.0598580018,
0.4030690491,
-0.5641099811,
-0.5600760579,
0.396020472,
-0.0538641401,
-0.5291570425,
0.1109060794,
0.117362231,
-0.5805339217,
0.4637944102,
0.5450012088,
0.6797454953,
-0.373206377,
0.6131201386,
0.1378375143,
0.321479857,
0.0082143145,
0.4169450104,
-0.1642923951,
-0.6712214351,
-0.2777262926,
-0.2739752233,
-0.345561564,
0.1258393377,
-0.4283194542,
0.4900240302,
-0.5356080532,
-0.3844172359,
0.3848966956,
-0.2756848633,
-0.5153308511,
-0.2276864797,
-0.2404396236,
0.9237609506,
-0.963796556,
0.8838247061,
0.7595148683,
-0.1289985031,
-0.5890775323,
0.3154945374,
0.2950383425,
-0.5035487413,
0.5757998228,
0.0200277865,
-0.5247351527,
0.0355155244,
-1.0790709257,
-0.6576544046,
0.8262833357,
0.4021233022,
-0.1758912802,
0.07061667,
0.068232514,
0.3574119806,
-0.3778138459,
0.0364309251,
0.0429590195,
0.6769416332,
0.0458212122,
-0.430547446,
-0.1137088686,
-0.4377652407,
-0.0510703996,
0.5873348117,
-0.8297492862,
0.8638927937,
0.2363798022,
-0.5687472224,
-0.4548738301,
0.2538717389,
-0.0641528219,
0.2580734193,
0.6653104424,
0.2259408236,
0.3799086213,
-0.1710191518,
1.0632221699,
-0.4857766926,
0.3053066432,
0.8419316411,
0.1001269221,
0.7778401971,
0.7174682617,
0.1004022509,
0.9075815678,
0.3586131632,
0.2351550609,
0.4766988754,
0.2789675891,
-0.4992969036,
0.0393732823,
-0.4218890071,
-0.2940467,
0.3984600008,
0.5631323457,
-0.3387050033,
-0.3330441713,
0.1348072439,
0.2662124634,
0.2088176161,
-0.0415991172,
1.0687204599,
-0.2519414723,
-0.6478875875,
0.150743261,
-0.1324423254,
0.449179709,
-0.9674405456,
-0.6277387738,
0.2523871064,
0.1845163703,
-0.2787282765,
-1.0786001682,
0.2818607092,
-0.2524440289,
-0.1965533942,
-0.2815356553,
0.9083839655,
-0.2821070552,
0.0469012596,
0.6815003753,
0.076824896,
0.0701635256,
-0.0348175243,
-0.8704066873,
0.4476775229,
-0.0373704173,
-0.5361851454,
0.1609754711,
0.4095193744,
0.032113269,
0.6492670178,
0.8157804012,
0.322268337,
0.1877082586,
-0.0374125428,
1.210693717,
-0.3036662042,
-0.4828082919,
-0.8078080416,
0.3766383827,
-0.6408417821,
-0.11629989,
0.9122508764,
0.6489616632,
1.0554372072,
-0.0131814834,
1.0009589195,
-0.313985765,
0.540615499,
-0.2883066833,
0.9111599326,
-0.1958383322,
-0.0287805256,
-0.225861311,
-0.9635506272,
-0.1327964067,
0.5355504155,
-0.0493910052,
-0.2788658738,
0.3530216515,
0.8919685483,
-0.0344448462,
0.3345906436,
-0.0310918689,
0.285974592,
0.3890209496,
0.0849006325,
1.1153380871,
-0.1499672532,
0.7214443684,
-0.6278541088,
-0.6150954366,
-0.273783356,
-0.9437251687,
-0.6560822725,
-0.8682355881,
-0.2354016006,
-0.8660456538,
0.0504023321,
0.9434473515,
0.8600316048,
-0.5759487152,
-0.4786313474,
-0.3285110593,
0.4413515031,
0.0424751975,
-0.3815772235,
0.211280629,
0.142750442,
-0.6445710659,
0.009908841,
0.2907055318,
-0.1426832527,
-0.3448787928,
0.0234974902,
-0.5426467061,
0.3587758839,
0.3938859403,
0.3580280542,
-0.5125710368,
-0.2826490402,
-0.1575678885,
-0.0614975132,
0.104655005,
1.1002231836,
-0.4081283808,
0.8547620773,
0.7976618409,
0.5309593678,
0.4780400395,
0.389601469,
0.4866166115,
-0.6907297373,
0.2720523179,
0.2334582806,
0.0854980797,
0.3708808124,
-0.375251025,
0.5310103297,
0.2494555414,
-0.4954374731,
-0.5081190467,
0.489123255,
-0.5866751075,
-0.2595823109,
1.2894661427,
0.1332712024,
-0.4226461649,
-0.3261695504,
-0.3988770247,
0.3403315246,
-0.629376173,
0.9452534318,
0.6847652793,
-0.3414389789,
-0.117365852,
-0.3632305264,
0.6601251364,
-0.0279312041,
-0.7531421781,
-0.1190053001,
0.1843775511,
0.2356638759,
0.6257681847,
0.9324969053,
0.0669540316,
0.1616539657,
-0.1107196286,
0.0285631213,
0.2982666194,
-0.4336074293,
-0.1650220901,
0.1276499331,
-0.0704408213,
-0.2020225525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16203v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16203v3
|
ChatTraffic: Text-to-Traffic Generation via Diffusion Model
| 2023-11-27T08:52:10 | 2024-02-05T02:46:11 |
Chengyang Zhang, Yong Zhang, Qitan Shao, Bo Li, Yisheng Lv, Xinglin Piao, Baocai Yin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Traffic prediction is one of the most significant foundations in Intelligent
Transportation Systems (ITS). Traditional traffic prediction methods rely only
on historical traffic data to predict traffic trends and face two main
challenges. 1) insensitivity to unusual events. 2) limited performance in
long-term prediction. In this work, we explore how generative models combined
with text describing the traffic system can be applied for traffic generation,
and name the task Text-to-Traffic Generation (TTG). The key challenge of the
TTG task is how to associate text with the spatial structure of the road
network and traffic data for generating traffic situations. To this end, we
propose ChatTraffic, the first diffusion model for text-to-traffic generation.
To guarantee the consistency between synthetic and real data, we augment a
diffusion model with the Graph Convolutional Network (GCN) to extract spatial
correlations of traffic data. In addition, we construct a large dataset
containing text-traffic pairs for the TTG task. We benchmarked our model
qualitatively and quantitatively on the released dataset. The experimental
results indicate that ChatTraffic can generate realistic traffic situations
from the text. Our code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/ChyaZhang/ChatTraffic.
|
[
-0.202648446,
-1.253303051,
0.6189790368,
0.4485735595,
-0.3545728922,
0.0610809401,
-0.0793495327,
-0.3991220295,
0.3056795299,
0.4150446057,
-0.6228811741,
-0.5459237695,
-0.5929563642,
-0.121334061,
-1.1062811613,
0.9362044334,
0.139180094,
-0.152965486,
-0.125708282,
0.1688883752,
-0.4924404025,
-0.3143419921,
-0.9773902893,
-0.1362364888,
0.4719988108,
0.3096200824,
0.7422430515,
0.0540818013,
0.3819575906,
0.3198184669,
0.1693990827,
0.3502802253,
-0.4987866879,
0.2709184885,
0.0885151774,
0.2418632656,
0.0277221706,
-0.2435776591,
0.8683600426,
0.5257871747,
-0.4910843372,
-0.3383968472,
-0.0429898575,
0.5908745527,
-0.2497598976,
0.0515669771,
-0.7675151825,
-0.1206104681,
-0.3263827264,
-0.2141321748,
-0.4447838664,
-0.6418250203,
0.3742483854,
-0.5722492337,
0.2823786139,
0.3180081546,
0.7535883188,
-0.0072478759,
-0.8468431234,
-0.5535498857,
-0.9170577526,
0.3706691563,
-0.2113700956,
0.2567948699,
0.1521587074,
0.3650494218,
-0.2964066863,
-0.9377266169,
-0.6605168581,
-0.1701006144,
0.0213581789,
0.4498125613,
-0.2747629285,
-0.2774951756,
-0.1190735176,
-0.0856252983,
-0.8244993091,
-0.3000560105,
-0.6347768307,
-0.0033267238,
0.5471808314,
0.4960028231,
0.1884078681,
-0.0855465084,
-0.7709777355,
0.1100965813,
-0.6366388202,
-0.3227698505,
0.2105425745,
0.3021356463,
-0.3679011464,
0.3848779798,
-0.0433783494,
0.5235158801,
-0.2406486869,
0.3479984105,
0.2205138952,
-0.3951327205,
-0.0428433716,
-0.0316252559,
1.2306163311,
0.1476736814,
0.5263441801,
-0.4064205885,
0.1168209612,
-0.2504877448,
0.5333189368,
-0.8077559471,
-0.1664485186,
0.0879388601,
-0.2210886329,
-0.4775238037,
0.0393319428,
-0.8870218396,
-0.0736781806,
-0.0788318515,
0.2476378232,
-0.5222232342,
-0.546754837,
0.2238965929,
-0.0300498083,
-0.0124024004,
0.448595196,
-0.673630774,
0.2815294862,
0.4728827477,
1.539039135,
-0.5498275161,
-0.2029808611,
-0.2304854393,
0.3626858592,
-0.2181813866,
1.1471894979,
-0.3284726739,
-0.7375283241,
0.2518976629,
-0.0252854396,
-0.1221789718,
-0.1409977823,
0.4269093871,
-0.5247300863,
0.2018856555,
0.2460466474,
-0.5880172849,
0.0351563655,
-0.0594906844,
-0.7922791839,
0.9229641557,
0.2595645785,
-0.9410836697,
0.0898438394,
-0.7749329805,
-0.8662343025,
0.3362950385,
0.1507379711,
-0.843170464,
-0.0732082501,
-0.309899658,
0.2330452651,
-0.2584525347,
0.5303077698,
-0.2628328204,
0.0193809941,
0.3608323932,
-0.4208089709,
0.666097939,
0.3560093045,
0.1921643913,
0.0375756323,
-0.5014280677,
-0.0640859082,
0.1613503993,
-0.2774912119,
-0.2274495363,
0.1885618269,
0.4223477244,
0.0310388282,
-0.0734331831,
-0.5053473711,
-0.1586526781,
-0.2433624566,
0.5126072168,
0.8330314755,
0.1702417433,
0.5180747509,
-0.337053299,
0.5017781854,
0.3281033933,
-0.1201338693,
-0.0316687897,
-0.9807473421,
-0.6325124502,
0.3279965818,
0.4602808058,
0.5042750239,
-0.8798921108,
0.0759181529,
-0.616777122,
-0.5152785182,
0.0261441991,
-0.3807148337,
-0.2822192907,
0.6925609112,
-0.0103282267,
0.0014441318,
-0.4321980178,
-0.3389842212,
0.2747819722,
-0.1473876685,
-0.0304070041,
0.2387417108,
0.3534506261,
-0.1575365365,
0.7913626432,
-0.6361063719,
-0.1034624428,
-0.0800363719,
0.2432517856,
-0.3390482366,
0.5366279483,
0.6149194837,
-0.8183160424,
-0.6769170761,
-0.0340264216,
-0.3349098265,
-0.0316132009,
-0.0192365069,
-0.7770138383,
0.0025843729,
0.5862776041,
-0.5182579756,
0.4526982307,
0.7444915175,
-0.603025496,
0.4169097245,
-0.2859612703,
0.1194374561,
-1.2824107409,
-0.0833411887,
0.16067487,
-0.7924290299,
-0.8034214973,
-0.4262705445,
-0.2516120672,
-0.5049567223,
-0.3372047246,
0.4571581185,
0.1506667733,
0.2422965765,
-0.3160681427,
0.3066183627,
-0.2798118293,
0.2855894566,
0.2667049766,
0.8203489184,
0.6526919007,
-0.7640824914,
0.2097355127,
0.4425196052,
-0.4675692022,
0.2555244267,
-0.6528913975,
-0.0055528088,
-0.1820671558,
0.3024922609,
-1.2943358421,
-0.2049255669,
0.3185874522,
-0.3496421576,
-0.2200189084,
-0.0398559719,
-0.6884509921,
-0.1109135747,
0.3238188028,
0.4815744162,
0.742082417,
-0.3756556809,
0.6106033921,
0.6002056599,
-0.1088954285,
0.3913525641,
-0.7095743418,
0.1196874604,
-0.2928948998,
-0.9276891947,
0.35533306,
-0.2409835607,
0.2401481569,
-0.2844979167,
0.4401265681,
-0.2314005941,
0.0937148929,
0.4970538318,
0.3052847087,
0.160828501,
0.3531334102,
-0.0024853919,
-0.2523008585,
0.310223043,
-0.396378845,
0.6131006479,
0.2649701536,
-0.1221662238,
-0.163749516,
0.5518472195,
0.3055612147,
-0.0170130748,
0.8000404835,
0.5241820216,
-0.088267684,
-0.1461083144,
0.1468026638,
0.0835159421,
-0.4840396345,
0.293230623,
-0.0891445652,
-0.8107421398,
0.2387640923,
-0.524867475,
-0.0764679685,
0.3238881528,
0.684240222,
-0.3478725851,
0.9325204492,
0.6122704744,
0.2353010327,
0.8293966651,
-0.2121976018,
0.2034227997,
-0.2081394345,
-0.5163627267,
-0.5473691821,
-0.198358357,
-0.9645531178,
-0.4059644938,
0.6806731224,
-0.4616574049,
-0.1484313458,
0.171374917,
-0.2947741449,
0.0348608345,
0.423055321,
0.2850226164,
0.343606323,
0.4410526752,
0.0056801247,
0.2673556209,
-0.8398016095,
-0.3185236752,
1.0322921276,
0.0412344821,
0.5055352449,
0.155256778,
0.304403007,
0.6493384242,
0.4845708907,
-0.4238746762,
0.6943380237,
-0.2702893317,
-0.4345861375,
-0.0909750685,
-0.6765393615,
-1.1823328733,
-0.1906169653,
-0.3058748543,
-0.5015690923,
-0.1872293055,
0.1425460726,
-0.1524068117,
0.1122649312,
-0.7215701938,
0.6972991824,
0.1270149201,
-0.3055387139,
-0.3192117512,
-0.4597505927,
0.3312499225,
-0.0427402854,
0.2962872684,
-0.1397399157,
0.0835726634,
0.4657229483,
-0.4294153452,
0.5524504185,
0.0764587596,
-0.1913655251,
0.5463575721,
0.2089782953,
0.756429553,
0.0747174174,
-0.0393109098,
0.207867682,
-0.4362099171,
-0.2700344026,
-0.3661313951,
0.6018415689,
-0.4208421111,
-0.0974676087,
-0.1866049021,
-0.4140911102,
-0.02943369,
0.1129002795,
0.6494383216,
0.520904541,
-0.4843668044,
-0.1894518882,
0.6280456185,
0.1983660758,
0.5311171412,
0.2813571692,
-0.3310627639,
-0.3264811337,
1.0287350416,
-0.2642459869,
0.3785081506,
0.2857465148,
0.1806269884,
-0.32808429,
-0.6085905433,
-0.433224231,
0.010218746,
-0.1625423729,
-0.2483023107,
-0.6847330332,
-0.5172688961,
-0.1802647263,
-0.0321387798,
-0.2224988043,
-0.3568486571,
-0.4611595273,
0.1885270774,
0.5433994532,
0.7481888533,
0.0109544797,
0.8060263395,
-0.5328708291,
0.2311286777,
0.1052454486,
0.377892822,
0.0037781335,
-0.3418482244,
-0.5803524852,
0.216572687,
-0.5242236853,
-0.6866212487,
0.4556138813,
0.0313724019,
-0.1273915917,
0.3001785874,
-0.0925442651,
0.4818789065,
-0.8156426549,
0.6890760064,
0.3291382194,
-0.5356146693,
0.5993451476,
-0.398684442,
0.159693107,
0.0700961873,
0.2984644175,
-0.6238387227,
-0.7824771404,
-0.5103202462,
-0.6726437211,
0.263001442,
0.9233705997,
0.2392743379,
-0.2784961462,
0.2124875188,
0.0744387433,
0.1584730744,
-0.7655457854,
0.0483215079,
-0.3823177516,
-0.3112691045,
0.1333839744,
-0.1540185958,
0.1206441447,
0.0685870796,
0.487742275,
0.0058926269,
0.455721885,
0.0738819987,
0.1623363346,
-0.0686427727,
-0.0095742736,
0.7396236062,
0.420378983,
0.1011757106,
-0.0998728871,
-0.080885388,
-0.6726500988,
0.1030438468,
-0.0155142173,
-0.5754917264,
0.3787399232,
0.112227574,
0.6522325277,
-0.0471320525,
-0.5040838718,
0.4949251115,
-0.2423849702,
-0.4701095223,
-0.5924336314,
0.2267989367,
0.0240906831,
0.1449543536,
0.288821429,
0.1500682384,
0.2440500706,
0.0925112516,
-0.0209005214,
0.5314042568,
-0.4046025872,
-0.2784683406,
1.0869458914,
0.5171583891,
-0.2752301395,
0.6024465561,
-0.1556204706,
-0.2914308906,
0.6279881001,
0.3497643471,
1.0647659302,
-0.0472148098,
0.3395486176,
0.4978493154,
-0.041484233,
-0.1601237059,
0.2136385292,
-0.0746959373,
-0.6738333702,
-0.3067487478,
-0.4097201228,
-0.0961149111,
-0.0865726247,
-0.1369445175,
0.36501351,
-0.1985793263,
-0.5229558349,
-0.1193949059,
-0.1722458303,
-0.3845669925,
0.0624377094,
0.0568228997,
0.863583982,
-0.7834284306,
0.7346247435,
0.3263215125,
-0.087057434,
-0.4204098284,
0.1829716712,
-0.4855486155,
-0.4281044304,
0.3197284639,
-0.0823747963,
-0.174714148,
0.1158829033,
-0.7435774803,
-0.6092028022,
1.0655263662,
0.0146530373,
-0.6445038319,
-0.2188187689,
0.4989170432,
0.4262735546,
-0.5700446963,
0.0765454695,
0.2413575351,
0.309471637,
0.4472754598,
-0.4030156136,
-0.049487818,
0.0740874186,
0.3669635653,
0.2269439697,
-0.8485818505,
0.6101149917,
-0.0962679014,
-0.5226290226,
0.4139278531,
0.725094378,
0.1324204504,
0.2905468941,
0.6164125204,
0.3820359409,
0.4664496183,
-0.357524246,
0.7751036286,
-0.2042719722,
0.3263595104,
0.9062803984,
-0.1412225217,
0.510391295,
0.3695942163,
-0.0907479674,
0.8917840123,
0.5456197262,
0.1541534811,
0.9978469014,
0.0792467147,
-0.4249573052,
-0.3233643174,
0.0051085744,
-0.0632422417,
0.2566330433,
0.2227241546,
-0.1398771554,
-0.4728954136,
0.2266762853,
-0.1387804896,
-0.0255448353,
-0.154412508,
0.8855077028,
-0.2610595226,
-0.5448189378,
0.2088311017,
-0.0233741067,
0.2903609872,
-0.8362146616,
0.0045781871,
-0.2554828227,
-0.1261529326,
0.1388099939,
-1.0556726456,
0.5259435177,
-0.1149971783,
-0.1437590122,
-0.4137824178,
0.6197211146,
-0.6775135994,
-0.618881166,
-0.0562343001,
0.2531124353,
0.0819586143,
0.0548058189,
-0.3364479244,
-0.0783440396,
0.0632091835,
0.051458016,
0.1282975078,
0.9209504724,
0.0901490673,
0.9169615507,
0.5223888159,
0.1516904682,
0.0768457204,
0.1655630171,
0.7399285436,
-0.6840865612,
-0.7954410911,
-0.8050897717,
0.6411467791,
-0.0714753345,
-0.270219475,
0.3483546078,
0.7643344998,
0.2774706185,
0.0102931987,
0.8767366409,
-0.027231792,
0.4771341085,
-0.7032809854,
0.4565238953,
-0.4141409695,
0.1363293082,
-0.1300983727,
-0.3136172891,
0.1831684709,
0.3914279044,
0.0529488511,
-0.0213721562,
0.5343725085,
0.7376958728,
-0.3281670213,
0.4330536723,
0.1346521825,
-0.0372804031,
0.5008428693,
0.814191699,
0.956912756,
-0.5478519797,
0.8897789717,
0.0123954732,
0.1097030491,
-0.2139637768,
-0.8599280715,
-0.8164589405,
-0.9745587111,
-0.3681629002,
-0.615430057,
0.0175885111,
0.259855479,
0.9118528962,
-0.4687943459,
-0.3161163926,
-0.9116812944,
0.2912198901,
0.1699872017,
-0.2543793917,
0.1608514041,
-0.1745172292,
-0.7487054467,
-0.0303547606,
0.1149345711,
0.7603794336,
-0.3237793744,
-0.0315121301,
-0.0807696283,
0.1167631075,
0.5018996,
-0.1575371474,
0.0168053359,
-0.197186321,
-0.3355711102,
-0.233341679,
0.077718094,
1.1421530247,
-0.891325295,
0.1282363385,
0.2039081305,
0.1419589818,
0.9299453497,
0.143005535,
0.8020522594,
-0.8167758584,
0.3232851923,
-0.0153358849,
0.0152433589,
0.1957455575,
-0.2530580461,
0.3715049326,
0.2148668617,
-0.6381193995,
-0.4342827797,
0.3174375594,
-0.9354531169,
-0.1905376017,
1.1534539461,
0.259688288,
-0.2866746783,
-0.2120069414,
-0.0878993496,
0.1287658811,
-0.5896948576,
0.8380993605,
0.4169071913,
0.1196399406,
0.0144784991,
-0.653911531,
0.6194883585,
-0.0359134339,
-1.0182411671,
0.2096369117,
0.5865778327,
0.3469374478,
-0.144807443,
0.6742042303,
0.157151252,
0.2053720951,
-0.1392797679,
-0.4854030013,
0.1731954515,
-0.3341907263,
0.2102144212,
0.2358748019,
-0.5548980832,
-0.2446049303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15626v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15626v2
|
The WebCrow French Crossword Solver
| 2023-11-27T08:45:31 | 2023-12-10T02:11:02 |
Giovanni Angelini, Marco Ernandes, Tommaso laquinta, Caroline Stehlé, Fanny Simões, Kamyar Zeinalipour, Andrea Zugarini, Marco Gori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Crossword puzzles are one of the most popular word games, played in different
languages all across the world, where riddle style can vary significantly from
one country to another. Automated crossword resolution is challenging, and
typical solvers rely on large databases of previously solved crosswords. In
this work, we extend WebCrow 2.0, an automatic crossword solver, to French,
making it the first program for crossword solving in the French language. To
cope with the lack of a large repository of clue-answer crossword data, WebCrow
2.0 exploits multiple modules, called experts, that retrieve candidate answers
from heterogeneous resources, such as the web, knowledge graphs, and linguistic
rules. We compared WebCrow's performance against humans in two different
challenges. Despite the limited amount of past crosswords, French WebCrow was
competitive, actually outperforming humans in terms of speed and accuracy, thus
proving its capabilities to generalize to new languages.
|
[
-0.3704411089,
-0.5195935369,
0.2927642763,
0.4758940041,
-0.1783824116,
0.4299152195,
-0.1366897821,
-0.7796817422,
0.0810029209,
0.433168292,
-0.4242419302,
-0.5023776889,
-0.9737557769,
0.5835166574,
-0.5163385272,
0.3811100423,
-0.2493008971,
-0.1733246148,
-0.3063578308,
0.0262601599,
0.0568764359,
-0.5962495208,
-0.5457903743,
-0.2893756926,
0.5294719338,
0.5326682329,
0.5973688364,
0.5741648674,
0.6164380908,
0.4753448367,
0.3576874733,
0.1327284425,
-0.4048601091,
-0.1872904897,
-0.5530095696,
-0.570836246,
0.0485888161,
0.1890083253,
-0.1469563246,
0.4238442779,
-0.3517925739,
-0.0404971167,
0.1011120155,
0.6713332534,
-0.6804061532,
0.1964077652,
-0.6270584464,
0.0091025764,
-0.2678497434,
-0.4134003222,
0.0503124669,
-0.2246185243,
0.2496229708,
-1.0737589598,
0.8511135578,
0.0372660421,
0.8599296212,
0.3276273012,
-0.0878825337,
-0.6963891983,
-0.604178369,
0.5885058641,
0.0699567795,
0.4372268617,
0.4745559394,
0.6773440838,
-0.1291641593,
-0.5769128203,
-0.6121844649,
0.3346969783,
0.0980857387,
0.0938541293,
-0.6841464639,
-0.2686181366,
0.0505089723,
0.0912802815,
-0.7576153278,
0.086524874,
-0.5200451612,
-0.8155680299,
0.7811722159,
0.1358754039,
0.4891127944,
0.3011913598,
-0.2450514138,
-0.2059380263,
-0.1876419634,
0.2665559351,
0.3136803806,
0.2701224089,
-0.1179682538,
0.440652281,
-0.4094546437,
0.5105291605,
-0.2267470062,
0.108159326,
0.1637761444,
-0.0410163701,
0.530628264,
-0.0147780934,
0.7016144395,
0.8031340837,
0.5177973509,
-0.3469864428,
-0.3429190516,
0.227654323,
-0.0442946292,
-0.4910852611,
-0.3576548398,
0.2627927661,
-0.207430467,
-0.0140753975,
-0.0776907727,
-0.7487453818,
-0.04429546,
0.2802552879,
0.4983855784,
-0.0373977832,
0.1944244653,
0.3904877901,
-0.7871881723,
0.2702418864,
0.4824015498,
-0.5470927954,
0.5317597389,
0.5283990502,
0.8035643697,
-0.3812656701,
-0.2686308324,
-0.8123538494,
-0.1592435539,
-0.1050601453,
1.0047082901,
-0.5183385611,
-0.5605852008,
0.2015526444,
-0.049782481,
0.4010963738,
-0.6996682286,
0.3315324187,
-0.6206931472,
0.2694202065,
-0.4350962937,
-0.3201895356,
0.0292905867,
0.1912532002,
-0.7089621425,
0.6153274179,
0.1191266403,
-0.5925816894,
-0.006768039,
-0.2441937327,
-0.3823354542,
0.1999118179,
-0.1253807545,
0.0176669676,
0.0583062246,
0.5678839684,
0.0851605982,
-0.8776046038,
-0.4971011579,
0.0346794613,
-0.3749247491,
-0.0131768892,
0.1110094339,
0.9716595411,
-0.0390882082,
-0.2402262241,
-0.6553028226,
-0.5409008861,
0.0364252254,
0.3328543007,
-0.2273739874,
-0.3911184669,
-0.2486091554,
0.2684588134,
0.5032892227,
0.3465398848,
-1.154432416,
0.0073992824,
-0.2621686757,
0.327213496,
0.3975451887,
-0.31061396,
0.0461549349,
-0.3131473064,
0.774784565,
-0.24666062,
0.0134415692,
0.2302768975,
-0.9419436455,
-0.4444828629,
-0.1548946798,
0.5245125294,
1.2075695992,
-0.7006296515,
0.127854079,
-0.0632343665,
-0.3953328431,
-0.5656428933,
0.4329778552,
0.5064569712,
0.0516327992,
0.6480512023,
-0.3918964863,
-0.3300041258,
-1.1804839373,
-0.7056229711,
0.0978553519,
-0.1595890075,
0.3923526108,
0.5185582638,
-0.3545463383,
0.8797957301,
-0.7056478262,
-0.4407957792,
-0.1048651934,
0.3914851844,
-0.2274935991,
0.2226626575,
0.4212196767,
-0.6782947779,
-0.6269101501,
0.1309081912,
-0.7387575507,
-0.4059161544,
0.4549303651,
-0.0418002121,
-0.172286436,
0.5309029222,
-0.4253736436,
0.3979759514,
0.823571384,
-0.2953552604,
0.36409989,
-0.2051413506,
-0.1429933906,
-0.8094140291,
-0.2329768091,
0.1475897878,
-0.1921453327,
-0.0983989611,
0.1854421794,
0.0138824135,
-0.2418103665,
-0.1663559079,
0.9753324389,
-0.5708835721,
0.0717287362,
-0.1924879253,
0.6553855538,
-0.0227869153,
0.1852546632,
0.165490672,
0.7695468068,
0.4610959888,
-0.4212141335,
0.862637043,
0.3179863393,
-0.185554117,
0.2754826546,
-0.7748854756,
0.3090124726,
-0.1947646141,
0.1698817909,
-0.965716064,
-0.1128637046,
-0.1318893284,
-0.6005122066,
-0.3382651806,
0.3012264669,
-0.346983701,
-0.6986910701,
-0.1477071196,
0.4133825302,
0.5127191544,
-0.4604278803,
0.450391829,
0.2983342111,
-0.2522235513,
-0.6644663215,
-0.8128013015,
0.2145884186,
0.4900028408,
-0.4354648292,
0.4505653679,
0.0740998983,
-0.4479948878,
0.1615841538,
-0.0818162039,
-0.4643745124,
-0.1514161676,
-0.1569517553,
-0.0141703757,
0.1660505533,
-0.0733890012,
0.1619964391,
-0.4005943239,
0.0886950567,
-0.2441370338,
0.3705595732,
0.1664047241,
-0.3648510575,
-0.3863516748,
0.6045413613,
0.2735240459,
-0.4400247335,
0.3135116696,
0.5612172484,
-0.4117355347,
-0.2826692462,
-0.7512953877,
-0.0533420369,
-0.5175820589,
0.3603883088,
-0.5911691189,
-1.1907441616,
0.7540740371,
-0.1100566909,
0.212611407,
0.5845876336,
0.3779879212,
-0.1464257538,
0.688200295,
0.8030539751,
-0.0560157709,
-0.2514171004,
-0.1389433891,
0.0583850853,
-0.3641364872,
-0.3010862768,
-0.8885076046,
-0.5657434464,
-0.6712168455,
-0.8593587279,
0.2260424793,
0.2456360459,
0.3343098164,
0.7420655489,
-0.6616307497,
0.4478985071,
0.542645514,
0.1687435061,
0.516484797,
0.3227045238,
-0.4741743207,
0.0767775625,
-0.8188970089,
-0.2995586693,
1.0199115276,
-0.0998495743,
0.8250421286,
0.272164166,
0.8377068043,
0.4505670071,
0.0165727474,
-0.63406533,
0.4378508031,
-0.3025957048,
-0.6818754077,
-0.499265492,
-0.3779477179,
-1.2032459974,
0.1236009672,
0.0559447408,
-0.810734272,
0.1472140253,
0.2892816365,
-0.5285822153,
0.0400473736,
-0.4711040854,
0.67770046,
-0.2870179415,
-0.5303105712,
-0.4997963011,
-0.464879334,
0.0040174285,
0.0645337626,
0.4502676129,
-0.0441659428,
-0.4946748316,
0.5195325613,
-0.4159677327,
0.4177090228,
0.1315639615,
-0.2989238501,
0.3748538494,
0.093076691,
0.640042305,
0.1122251526,
0.0330805704,
0.353770107,
-0.1381441355,
-0.8172177672,
-0.6693453193,
0.6596599221,
-0.8747968674,
-0.8705152273,
-0.3931757808,
-0.4235025048,
-0.1607907563,
0.0472305119,
0.8087759018,
0.4749013186,
-0.2521927953,
-0.1226816699,
0.5823548436,
-0.4226755798,
0.4505898952,
0.6712896228,
-0.2867875993,
-0.2333801985,
1.0630270243,
0.0659655631,
-0.0697473586,
0.9988404512,
0.3617668748,
-0.389200747,
-0.1776059717,
-0.6333232522,
0.0061236434,
-0.445112437,
0.0302038509,
-0.891625464,
-0.273792237,
-0.0717845783,
-0.3909636438,
-0.3961189687,
-0.6789264679,
0.1642385721,
0.2974164188,
0.3251623511,
0.5893964171,
-0.2443392873,
-0.0733987764,
-1.1880780458,
0.4847484827,
1.1033263206,
0.339301616,
-0.3575487733,
-0.1946437806,
-0.1495696753,
-0.2494944632,
0.0756543875,
-0.8714116812,
-0.0645633861,
0.113802731,
0.6507614255,
0.191769883,
-0.0669195503,
0.2329699546,
-0.4085590541,
0.6647852063,
0.1538109928,
-0.8663080931,
0.255710572,
-0.3153001368,
0.6220638156,
0.3881662488,
0.579931736,
-0.6113110185,
-0.2458820939,
-0.1540737301,
-0.4348044395,
0.3246837854,
0.5933282971,
0.0849272981,
0.0138467373,
0.318369031,
0.2462970167,
0.1748683751,
-0.2028746158,
-0.2925794721,
-0.3386080861,
-0.081257388,
-0.3019166589,
-0.0283795912,
-0.0357246622,
-0.2874965966,
0.4409787953,
0.0388472192,
0.5018293858,
0.3585548401,
-0.4414265454,
-0.3134488165,
0.1802595258,
0.6115303636,
0.5101460814,
0.0769657418,
0.1041715294,
0.0894264579,
-0.7065036893,
0.122469902,
0.6876262426,
-0.0455533266,
0.1245530695,
0.7999367714,
0.2881322801,
-0.1593051404,
-1.0836832523,
0.5256711245,
-0.2373867631,
-0.4293661118,
0.0131851155,
0.0337682441,
0.1847508699,
0.3099487424,
0.6580615044,
-0.0699443147,
0.337613672,
-0.5623501539,
0.4713143706,
0.6188216805,
-0.4891310334,
-0.2119802088,
0.6461814046,
0.8691803217,
-0.8608661294,
0.4956713319,
-0.6716073751,
-1.1247992516,
0.5521712303,
0.5106886625,
0.9105994105,
-0.3950001895,
0.2554335296,
0.5135648251,
0.5600882769,
-0.0922507867,
0.648344636,
0.0695539415,
-0.9524253011,
-0.199491933,
-0.5249347687,
-0.3232427537,
-0.129605338,
-0.2891207635,
0.0598880164,
-0.4297224283,
-0.042196963,
-0.2415501922,
0.0061076256,
-0.8936094046,
0.0567626953,
0.0600364991,
1.0961261988,
-0.5580800772,
0.3316490352,
1.009508729,
0.1132668555,
-0.4118280113,
0.1460102499,
0.2439669669,
-0.920288384,
0.5609203577,
0.0198368486,
-0.5233269334,
0.2061683685,
-0.3455552161,
-0.7533302903,
0.6762579679,
-0.0141292447,
-1.2068660259,
-0.0269537065,
0.3868145645,
0.3924085498,
-0.0697979778,
0.0169881396,
0.2763457298,
0.2658557296,
-0.1973578781,
-1.183172822,
-0.1422131807,
-0.5126897693,
-0.099491246,
0.2192271948,
-0.8705857396,
0.9173880219,
-0.209838897,
-0.0833560526,
-0.0152963065,
0.5204794407,
0.023482224,
0.0885999426,
0.5763524771,
0.8697162867,
0.5196597576,
-0.0241018273,
0.9584775567,
-0.5933473706,
0.328287214,
0.8762358427,
-0.2187858522,
0.5649890304,
0.2062037885,
-0.3012122512,
0.6449692249,
0.2857705355,
0.2662133574,
0.4159353971,
0.3743667006,
-0.2920779586,
-0.7881801724,
0.0165915936,
-0.2141367942,
0.780477941,
0.2346693128,
0.0582837723,
-0.7006647587,
0.0272925179,
-0.4869313538,
0.6450836658,
-0.1536425352,
0.3049659431,
0.1114497855,
-0.483709693,
0.3026901782,
0.2356206626,
0.5795577168,
-0.3110441267,
-0.3659390509,
-0.1535943151,
0.1901585907,
0.0628253073,
-0.803497076,
-0.0198601242,
0.1584642082,
-0.0668166727,
-0.0227447543,
0.6830142736,
-0.2952512801,
-0.6979709268,
0.6605934501,
0.8813295364,
-0.0329381637,
-0.384437263,
-0.8827828765,
-0.1009192988,
-0.1623730659,
0.0322677307,
0.128051579,
0.549767077,
-0.183799848,
0.9193024039,
0.4805646241,
-0.3477901816,
0.1968079656,
-0.2682106197,
0.7794644237,
-0.510525167,
-0.6405773163,
-0.6159764528,
0.1634673774,
-0.1689891666,
-0.5145549178,
0.7992011309,
1.026027441,
0.8726088405,
0.0504755639,
1.1878386736,
-0.1547285765,
0.6884186268,
-0.139717415,
0.3036841452,
-0.8283397555,
-0.062423382,
-0.1064899564,
-0.8541375399,
-0.0345649123,
0.7509867549,
0.0142331375,
-0.2297553271,
0.6559517384,
0.8040457368,
-0.0125844665,
-0.0736382678,
0.1078953519,
-0.0417971686,
-0.0647153407,
0.5633722544,
0.6930371523,
-0.6062227488,
0.9026022553,
-0.6125785112,
-0.4048594236,
-0.3154276907,
-0.4474830329,
-1.1896452904,
-0.5724964142,
-0.0424081869,
-0.3204957545,
0.3966098428,
1.1460989714,
0.2358395457,
-0.9274346828,
-0.3593870699,
-0.0012563247,
0.2400041074,
-0.448366791,
-0.1298107356,
-0.0603158362,
-0.0535232872,
-0.7947034836,
0.1590760946,
0.39610973,
-0.2083411664,
-0.2761710286,
-0.0693162307,
-0.1622647047,
0.2430092096,
0.6053370833,
0.3933081031,
-0.7184115052,
-0.1887804717,
0.3442514539,
-0.5605956912,
-0.1162686422,
0.9595479369,
-0.724660337,
0.6474508643,
0.6230102777,
0.6633071303,
0.4699981511,
0.1684796661,
0.6197376251,
-0.4154336452,
0.2223629206,
0.3067938387,
0.1257186979,
0.1096857339,
-0.335144937,
0.3677859306,
0.6625196338,
-0.0977833271,
-0.1551349908,
0.2435569465,
-0.6069566011,
-0.4420381486,
0.8100717068,
0.0396768898,
-0.1702683419,
-0.6238384247,
0.0623392724,
0.2259447277,
-0.5018619299,
0.961084187,
0.8991977572,
-0.0274076462,
-0.2873720527,
-0.4758099318,
0.5321506262,
0.1500645727,
-0.4831933379,
-0.2133917809,
0.0257597473,
0.2874055505,
0.4258718491,
0.7439990044,
0.0959109589,
0.5374149084,
0.1948262155,
0.25399369,
0.0226238444,
-0.3562544286,
0.2184209377,
0.2002754211,
-0.3011799455,
-0.1759393364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15623v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15623v3
|
Injecting linguistic knowledge into BERT for Dialogue State Tracking
| 2023-11-27T08:38:42 | 2024-07-03T02:59:32 |
Xiaohan Feng, Xixin Wu, Helen Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Dialogue State Tracking (DST) models often employ intricate neural network
architectures, necessitating substantial training data, and their inference
process lacks transparency. This paper proposes a method that extracts
linguistic knowledge via an unsupervised framework and subsequently utilizes
this knowledge to augment BERT's performance and interpretability in DST tasks.
The knowledge extraction procedure is computationally economical and does not
require annotations or additional training data. The injection of the extracted
knowledge can be achieved by the addition of simple neural modules. We employ
the Convex Polytopic Model (CPM) as a feature extraction tool for DST tasks and
illustrate that the acquired features correlate with syntactic and semantic
patterns in the dialogues. This correlation facilitates a comprehensive
understanding of the linguistic features influencing the DST model's
decision-making process. We benchmark this framework on various DST tasks and
observe a notable improvement in accuracy.
|
[
-0.5187219381,
-0.6906807423,
0.7826088667,
-0.1411932111,
-0.4843952358,
0.0537109151,
-0.4345032871,
-0.1839353442,
0.2876983285,
0.7869192362,
-0.6159276366,
-0.2932538986,
-0.7164720893,
-0.3041739166,
-0.3044825792,
1.2378519773,
0.4745157063,
0.0910670981,
-0.0462169312,
0.3910280168,
-0.1477458328,
-0.5992975831,
-0.3025667667,
-0.4319786131,
0.1534437835,
-0.140149489,
0.5175045133,
0.2820172608,
0.0619239658,
0.3174642324,
-0.4617982805,
0.0587882698,
-0.3393803835,
0.0192279946,
-0.3979037106,
-0.6302357316,
-0.1781135201,
-0.2023383081,
0.5037567616,
0.6487282515,
-0.1899218559,
-0.1129384637,
0.2145273834,
0.4181862175,
-0.4081252217,
0.6854468584,
-0.7932466269,
-0.1155372486,
-0.012101667,
-0.0932022259,
-0.1168896928,
-0.4914931953,
0.8165304661,
-0.4238095284,
0.0705570728,
-0.6200402379,
0.5478492379,
0.505723834,
-0.3749750555,
-0.4053228796,
-0.6304537654,
0.7130789161,
-1.0167857409,
0.2299085408,
0.351834774,
0.0996207148,
-0.2364015579,
-0.5782804489,
-0.6349951625,
-0.0683328137,
-0.1240408048,
0.102803506,
0.0951655805,
0.3040384352,
0.2774339914,
0.219556421,
0.0589119755,
-0.3344291151,
-0.324991107,
-0.203854233,
0.3874028623,
-0.0536533669,
0.2792870402,
-0.6000612378,
-0.3912483752,
0.1894991696,
-0.3135159612,
0.1390616,
0.1930700392,
0.5743028522,
-0.0036995895,
0.4708922505,
-0.0447761416,
0.7781704664,
0.0475821383,
-0.2133511156,
-0.0724281892,
-0.4054870605,
-0.2237874269,
0.1160269156,
0.6471790671,
0.0445405692,
0.2303245217,
-0.0187183991,
-0.2879243195,
-0.0889532194,
0.4471502304,
-0.5461012721,
-0.4298333824,
-0.0798190162,
-0.3165685833,
-0.2851571739,
-0.0051525827,
-0.8323016763,
-0.3578481376,
-0.4381362796,
0.5045070052,
-0.7618550658,
-0.641199708,
0.0608196743,
-0.2675227523,
0.1322545409,
0.406109482,
-1.0267410278,
0.1852661073,
0.8582869768,
0.7971274853,
-0.1778579056,
0.2690458298,
-0.0954525545,
-0.0120930122,
-0.2926469743,
0.722655952,
-0.5846139193,
-0.1189153269,
0.120727025,
-0.1300397366,
-0.2600453198,
-0.1876722127,
0.0870977789,
-0.3854398429,
0.2563974857,
-0.422098577,
-0.7106633186,
-0.5692431331,
0.0201692022,
-0.3544795215,
1.0450322628,
0.0642090738,
-0.5838352442,
0.3384399116,
-0.6944563389,
-0.3515459299,
0.1981735677,
-0.4977104664,
-0.0744155049,
0.3195761442,
0.5133536458,
0.5061579347,
0.0302756224,
0.5361804366,
-0.1470365673,
-0.2486310452,
0.188578546,
-0.3265222013,
0.9998133779,
-0.0046868003,
-0.4364626706,
-0.3434122503,
-0.6273337007,
0.001942873,
-0.2867317796,
-0.4624318182,
-0.3432637751,
0.3182829022,
-0.2254692316,
0.0582748689,
0.2045025527,
-0.8669757247,
0.1374059319,
-0.5031285286,
0.4172276556,
0.7531347275,
0.3244121969,
0.2563432455,
-0.1970990747,
0.3116816878,
0.103703022,
-0.1352505088,
0.0682166815,
-0.6250568032,
-0.813208878,
-0.6710253954,
0.2639084756,
0.5043663979,
-1.0552235842,
0.6558328867,
-0.140750289,
-0.3316062391,
-0.3769876361,
-0.0435448848,
0.3737959266,
0.465472281,
0.2048153579,
-0.4325383604,
-0.2455636263,
-0.7753887177,
-0.0562253296,
-0.1855959892,
-0.1468972564,
0.2789268196,
0.3848142326,
0.1021421403,
1.2492200136,
-0.6599543095,
-0.2907035947,
-0.5415880084,
0.5007398725,
0.4819993079,
0.5064675808,
0.4447794855,
-0.626508534,
-0.2387878746,
-0.0967354476,
-0.613399744,
-0.0886814371,
-0.2002874762,
-0.043050278,
0.0802508891,
0.2791445553,
-0.5008037686,
0.653663516,
0.195954293,
-0.095311895,
0.3746015429,
-0.0378382392,
0.1176039949,
-1.1696981192,
-0.2206283659,
-0.0114141526,
-0.3800863922,
-0.7899113297,
-0.4762442112,
-0.0178827476,
-0.0057947384,
-0.3999571204,
-0.0152919739,
-0.205308035,
-0.3521779776,
-0.1637724042,
0.1851865351,
-0.1369012296,
0.8760710955,
0.5199384689,
0.8676315546,
0.5522608161,
-0.6044466496,
0.3978703618,
0.5429221988,
-0.940243423,
0.5212872624,
-0.3086185455,
0.0501528829,
-0.1109182686,
0.1262670606,
-1.0765211582,
0.2637028396,
-0.0981864259,
-0.4356556535,
0.1643150598,
-0.6320782304,
-0.4000565708,
0.087955229,
0.1429581344,
0.0157106984,
0.5709180236,
-0.4979976118,
0.7614919543,
0.5637866259,
-0.6005303264,
-0.3915748,
-0.4203255773,
-0.0415861234,
-0.0013882605,
-0.2559049129,
0.1687645465,
0.2266694605,
0.0201560166,
-0.1135843769,
-0.3392783999,
-0.3522601724,
-0.0196487177,
-0.0984951034,
0.1989473104,
-0.1627337188,
0.1755527109,
0.1453007013,
-0.0443334058,
0.1531845033,
-0.4854235649,
0.4797115624,
0.1459252089,
-0.254180491,
-0.8436203599,
0.2808504701,
0.7537818551,
-0.1674394011,
0.5236272812,
0.4265379012,
-0.3309696913,
-0.2511692941,
-0.6120069623,
-0.472964257,
-0.3840078712,
0.5037193298,
-0.3490208685,
-0.4983719885,
0.3263836503,
-0.30051741,
0.0721001029,
0.0888666511,
0.4690337181,
-0.4573303163,
1.1111400127,
0.7707983255,
-0.0721191615,
0.9089918137,
-0.2742245197,
0.3022473156,
-1.0502744913,
-0.290004015,
-0.332026124,
-0.0293675959,
-0.4064364433,
-0.45365569,
0.560346663,
0.0305338632,
-0.0383012779,
0.6276028156,
-0.3890883923,
0.0445396006,
0.6827601194,
0.4691286385,
0.2335373312,
-0.1844485253,
-0.3658275604,
-0.2704843581,
-0.5670269728,
-0.2452374548,
0.9707491994,
0.0517037734,
0.8126285672,
0.1937289834,
0.535423398,
0.3577382565,
-0.2126766145,
-0.674901247,
0.6404742002,
-0.245108217,
-0.4271119833,
-0.1878195852,
-0.3871696889,
-0.3568632007,
0.2952756882,
-0.3308902085,
-1.2075716257,
0.3129308522,
-0.047202874,
-0.5063942671,
0.3428939879,
-0.6549054384,
0.5212364197,
-0.3095511496,
0.0119974604,
-0.5164428353,
-0.4619053304,
0.072007902,
-0.204227522,
-0.2647956312,
-0.2981582582,
0.1249795854,
0.777018249,
-0.4805231094,
1.1345031261,
-0.4645845294,
-0.126568988,
0.054545451,
0.1017054468,
0.3729737103,
0.1142451689,
-0.0204002634,
0.246731475,
0.3893375993,
-0.2578541338,
-0.8497044444,
0.3661696911,
-0.6603599191,
-0.5849806666,
-0.4800376594,
-0.7773774862,
-0.4591412544,
0.090440996,
0.0449568443,
0.6999188066,
-0.0356269144,
0.0769112557,
0.9191081524,
-0.4126527905,
0.433665514,
0.5954272151,
-0.0320650861,
-0.351950109,
0.7420236468,
0.0325903818,
0.5106941462,
0.4436298609,
0.0983507186,
-0.5495346785,
-0.5352411866,
-0.3953510821,
0.1737684906,
-0.4395639002,
-0.1850285977,
-0.6675205231,
-0.4290661812,
-0.4248523712,
0.1125686318,
-0.5458375812,
-0.7015450001,
-0.0328661725,
-0.0276263226,
0.5301764607,
1.0881332159,
-0.1055877507,
0.501167655,
-0.5394915938,
0.3124899864,
0.4980306923,
0.2761745453,
-0.2720750868,
-0.3357101381,
-0.2060618401,
0.3526570797,
-0.2157618105,
-0.8837028742,
0.2075485587,
0.2598367333,
0.6517401934,
0.4583147466,
0.1180089936,
0.7458184958,
-0.2657631636,
1.0172952414,
0.1418282241,
-1.2358490229,
0.8953875303,
-0.3573207259,
0.4666133523,
0.3978356123,
0.1985573173,
-0.4325057268,
-0.6455122828,
-0.2891537845,
-0.4194266498,
1.0119745731,
0.2189839482,
0.0728048235,
-0.0246009175,
0.257666707,
-0.0550656915,
0.4775645435,
-0.4501697123,
0.1633157432,
-0.3139874339,
-0.2123289257,
0.0508638881,
-0.2934193313,
-0.1085831374,
-0.4265063405,
0.7787344456,
-0.2203515917,
0.4856355786,
0.2131461352,
-0.3348451555,
0.4468013346,
0.0986736938,
0.5391353965,
0.8064761758,
-0.4033218324,
-0.1607207805,
0.0950903967,
-0.2762362957,
-0.2970837653,
0.113538295,
-0.2070829719,
0.1162192598,
0.2597936988,
0.6151923537,
0.4074423015,
-0.3842362761,
0.6697016358,
-0.0955872685,
0.0231610965,
-0.2794597745,
0.0722351372,
0.0012863368,
0.5718108416,
0.1430137604,
-0.0342151895,
0.0746940225,
-0.4060319364,
0.4829851091,
0.5269564986,
-0.7244576812,
-0.1820205301,
0.1426662654,
0.3768392503,
-0.0881176665,
0.7473037839,
0.162897855,
-0.9627366662,
0.3914010525,
0.4533076584,
0.7536880374,
-0.1399317384,
0.3369664252,
0.2471855134,
0.0786864087,
0.1843575835,
0.3912659883,
-0.6379963756,
-0.8321321607,
-0.5530482531,
-0.7500929832,
-0.3701624274,
0.078539975,
-0.9849534035,
0.1018118337,
-0.3525336981,
-0.171286121,
0.0294090435,
-0.0409562476,
-0.4872422814,
-0.0269209817,
0.1563667208,
0.8749122024,
-0.752168119,
1.095959425,
0.3646353781,
-0.3558920026,
-0.5493528843,
0.1246590093,
0.3011018634,
-0.9832202196,
0.5815157294,
-0.1217592582,
-0.1789654344,
-0.1151873022,
-0.2182213515,
-0.7801263928,
0.6177496314,
0.3772382438,
-0.3950602412,
0.0535235368,
0.1339567751,
0.5412416458,
-0.4677823186,
0.4513143003,
0.8721612692,
0.2036880255,
0.0853547454,
-0.9804252982,
-0.193191126,
0.0535493866,
0.2173540741,
0.3838458359,
-0.1244668886,
0.4513176084,
-0.0658825561,
-0.1653671712,
0.1860019863,
0.4138599038,
-0.383618027,
-0.4429122806,
0.759596467,
0.5677801371,
0.5117593408,
-0.280851692,
0.5381887555,
-0.368583113,
0.4650308788,
1.0946000814,
-0.0474159978,
0.6889916658,
0.4227549434,
-0.0337327346,
0.6976758242,
0.5401970148,
0.1798520088,
1.015407443,
0.1272287965,
-0.4989137053,
-0.5058485866,
-0.1741957515,
-0.1663582623,
0.8259114027,
0.6842554808,
-0.3930891752,
-0.3402992189,
0.1171924844,
0.1343165487,
-0.0660914034,
-0.0865678862,
1.5721396208,
0.0200276766,
-0.8192200065,
0.4127593637,
-0.5126015544,
0.4877897501,
-0.8595144153,
-0.2781471014,
-0.1429898888,
0.2687820494,
0.0601734184,
-0.8222495317,
0.3403457999,
0.0867969692,
-0.0559426211,
-0.4011559486,
0.2499943674,
-0.6695044637,
-0.3631624877,
0.3879242837,
0.5033391714,
0.2972714305,
-0.1427695453,
-0.7307761312,
-0.2161132544,
0.3993238211,
0.0785001889,
0.1297846138,
0.361828804,
0.2556497455,
0.5400827527,
0.6497619748,
0.5417650938,
-0.1366755962,
0.0287792031,
1.025255084,
-0.5015352964,
-0.5311787724,
-0.636492908,
0.5068820715,
-0.3338110149,
-0.1365015954,
0.1543151438,
0.2868650854,
0.6582098603,
0.1805526912,
1.0326098204,
-0.3343035579,
0.7097103,
-0.5568709373,
0.8081274033,
-0.2788995802,
0.3845296204,
-0.3371651471,
-0.8674288988,
0.3068166673,
0.7732872367,
-0.4354513288,
-0.297065109,
0.6422320604,
0.8382376432,
-0.0852012336,
0.4186524153,
0.3349047303,
0.4229551852,
0.4438934326,
0.6281093955,
0.8903414607,
-0.0477923006,
0.4316937327,
-0.471274823,
-0.6079762578,
0.267799139,
-0.8300919533,
-1.1496112347,
-0.944803834,
-0.130207181,
0.0090480382,
0.2355610877,
0.9998872876,
1.1590747833,
-0.8870844841,
-0.2509733737,
0.0731432736,
0.2194304764,
-0.427614361,
-0.2485716343,
0.2477441132,
-0.680208385,
-0.8264926076,
0.5505429506,
0.2811889648,
-0.1298710704,
-0.1246592999,
0.3887903094,
-0.4195154607,
0.1751915962,
0.4689626396,
-0.0592741594,
-0.8743963242,
-0.5244479179,
-0.4777800739,
0.2885419428,
0.0068951505,
1.0370862484,
-0.8630264401,
0.8656691313,
0.4226131737,
0.759532392,
0.7391774654,
0.1307676435,
1.1521536112,
-0.7744833827,
0.0841879323,
0.2593062222,
0.4169303775,
0.2509220839,
-0.4132510722,
0.2063201964,
0.216895178,
-0.3782634139,
-0.4873929322,
0.4217637777,
-0.8911806941,
-0.3094483614,
0.8906828761,
-0.4139668941,
0.1179184839,
-0.4505885243,
-0.0781059191,
0.2302608341,
-0.5387502909,
0.9254624248,
0.7664530277,
-0.4195480645,
-0.3030361831,
-0.5399028063,
0.8751000166,
0.4020783603,
-0.7193903923,
0.0108889686,
0.1411798149,
0.4586830437,
0.1628442854,
0.5090739727,
-0.119549714,
0.156229049,
-0.3132031262,
-0.1018458977,
0.2332604229,
-0.1825379431,
-0.1485232264,
-0.2818790972,
-0.3858543932,
-0.4054230452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15614v1
|
FreeAL: Towards Human-Free Active Learning in the Era of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-27T08:23:08 | 2023-11-27T08:23:08 |
Ruixuan Xiao, Yiwen Dong, Junbo Zhao, Runze Wu, Minmin Lin, Gang Chen, Haobo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Collecting high-quality labeled data for model training is notoriously
time-consuming and labor-intensive for various NLP tasks. While copious
solutions, such as active learning for small language models (SLMs) and
prevalent in-context learning in the era of large language models (LLMs), have
been proposed and alleviate the labeling burden to some extent, their
performances are still subject to human intervention. It is still underexplored
how to reduce the annotation cost in the LLMs era. To bridge this, we
revolutionize traditional active learning and propose an innovative
collaborative learning framework FreeAL to interactively distill and filter the
task-specific knowledge from LLMs. During collaborative training, an LLM serves
as an active annotator inculcating its coarse-grained knowledge, while a
downstream SLM is incurred as a student to filter out high-quality in-context
samples to feedback LLM for the subsequent label refinery. Extensive
experiments on eight benchmark datasets demonstrate that FreeAL largely
enhances the zero-shot performances for both SLM and LLM without any human
supervision. The code is available at https://github.com/Justherozen/FreeAL .
|
[
-0.0486182794,
-0.5441437364,
0.355460763,
-0.0651993454,
-0.2346253991,
0.113577649,
-0.5979726911,
-0.7146193981,
0.0894755274,
0.4531522691,
-0.3061435223,
-0.6585959196,
-0.3158240914,
-0.300263226,
-0.1208660528,
0.9493886828,
-0.2230379581,
-0.0248609241,
-0.3811095357,
-0.4717492461,
-0.2937941551,
-0.4538525641,
-0.6675884128,
-0.6372891068,
0.6671217084,
0.3783099651,
0.7490925193,
0.5440814495,
0.1501989365,
0.1913781911,
-0.1656713039,
0.2366799116,
-0.3829044402,
0.5523661971,
-0.014988401,
-0.7078874707,
-0.6485148668,
0.3496154845,
0.5337200165,
0.9561995864,
-0.1282801777,
0.1354910135,
0.1422342658,
0.684706986,
-0.8359294534,
0.2750232518,
-0.5508657694,
0.0124700526,
-0.1877840161,
0.216445744,
-0.4564777017,
-0.1545313895,
0.0229135454,
-1.003141284,
0.4800544083,
-0.0083459346,
0.6299481392,
0.5094984174,
-0.1878312677,
-0.3818980157,
-0.7948850989,
0.9218789935,
-0.3370197713,
0.562453568,
0.7241501808,
0.2519728839,
0.1080315337,
-0.6091443896,
-0.3618975878,
-0.1502178311,
0.0125414049,
0.1521217823,
-0.2851968408,
0.2229825854,
-0.1425052881,
0.5070207715,
-0.4972542226,
0.1521846652,
-0.2230368853,
-0.0925142989,
0.6546405554,
-0.2185531259,
0.1222275868,
0.308350116,
-0.3228548169,
-0.044198148,
-0.8464080095,
0.1417121738,
0.1761684418,
0.5504407287,
-0.0515384711,
0.2755852938,
-0.3199161589,
0.623116672,
-0.0881160051,
0.074751161,
0.3237461746,
-0.0565377064,
-0.3810940385,
0.08031369,
0.7836837769,
-0.0873950273,
0.0901259258,
-0.5211445689,
-0.3978775442,
0.051294513,
-0.0386663117,
-0.7348429561,
-0.4897340834,
0.1903837323,
-0.1443687528,
-0.2729333341,
-0.3332582414,
-0.4538205862,
-0.3016331494,
-0.3233411014,
0.5014443398,
-0.0126040662,
-0.4016620219,
0.1058892235,
0.3879845738,
-0.1943343729,
0.543058455,
-0.862768054,
0.1772801876,
0.4591716826,
0.8593787551,
-0.0337859094,
0.0235852096,
-1.0354721546,
0.3288474977,
-0.3514617682,
0.7001838684,
-0.3407592773,
-0.3931080699,
-0.1438081414,
-0.1050998122,
-0.0059194989,
-0.6766245961,
0.1531335711,
-0.7343348861,
0.1715973467,
-0.0238556527,
-0.3710097373,
-0.3400923908,
0.1960400641,
-0.8230421543,
1.0039643049,
0.1304909289,
-0.2770769894,
0.3703438938,
-0.8204914927,
-0.1822513193,
0.5713227391,
-0.2433029115,
-0.2072153836,
-0.0423219912,
0.1135972589,
0.4193008244,
-0.287584424,
0.4199385643,
-0.2130004913,
-0.2382816076,
0.1366536915,
-0.2091938555,
0.7936296463,
0.2137747407,
-0.346937716,
0.6294059753,
-0.7868871689,
0.0382964537,
-0.0797858611,
-0.4954238534,
-0.5221491456,
-0.0752981603,
0.0452233478,
0.3091383874,
0.0598381683,
-0.555598855,
0.2917043269,
-0.4467201829,
0.0185901448,
0.5739507675,
-0.0385063738,
0.8582879305,
-0.1850342155,
0.5191153288,
-0.3346497416,
0.1478804052,
0.1534589529,
-0.5085594654,
-0.8947016597,
-0.6644201279,
0.3724101484,
0.522536993,
-0.8219190836,
0.164693594,
-0.0493376628,
-0.4847788215,
-0.8055623174,
0.8500439525,
0.5946449637,
0.1610699445,
0.5595820546,
-0.4465537667,
-0.420540899,
-0.6733121276,
-0.013872778,
-0.1942624897,
-0.2561079264,
0.1272090822,
0.2276340127,
-0.1059135124,
1.1436465979,
-0.3280927539,
-0.676900506,
-0.4290767312,
0.2720719576,
-0.0187452864,
0.4820081294,
0.4374787509,
-0.4434702992,
-0.4854650497,
-0.2364922911,
-0.9480926991,
-0.216747582,
0.0842659324,
-0.0977062955,
0.2211788595,
0.4506891668,
-0.4706452787,
0.3382405937,
0.6408372521,
-0.1974339932,
-0.0376843102,
-0.2129453421,
-0.3983805478,
-0.8877573609,
0.2164203227,
-0.0415443517,
-0.1947633624,
-0.6662433743,
0.07222718,
-0.0245527588,
-0.2426510006,
-0.6414901018,
0.8559396863,
-0.7060703635,
0.1801641881,
-0.3344863653,
0.2796321809,
-0.1928572655,
0.6598036885,
0.211348623,
0.6212365031,
0.3825015426,
-0.427818954,
0.1771372408,
0.1782498062,
-0.3164462149,
0.1407043934,
-0.5477668047,
0.2452155948,
0.0316264778,
0.263780266,
-0.8334410191,
-0.1562669128,
0.2948015332,
-0.2196977884,
0.2940161526,
-0.295746088,
-0.6129404902,
0.2354259491,
-0.122760199,
0.4465692043,
0.337680608,
-0.5442894697,
0.4394555986,
0.3652036488,
0.1353479475,
-0.4763798714,
-0.5406418443,
0.0228695143,
0.1886685044,
-0.2568209767,
0.0682314038,
-0.046949707,
-0.4449123442,
0.144850865,
-0.048767861,
-0.1329413354,
0.3971131146,
0.5397334695,
0.2239709198,
0.0059389835,
0.2135738134,
-0.118512243,
-0.3726328909,
-0.2478842884,
-0.2760289907,
0.2709612548,
-0.2707355618,
-0.3146260679,
-0.5737909675,
0.295858264,
0.4274842739,
-0.4930003881,
0.8009240031,
0.5689539313,
-0.4670341313,
-0.417106539,
-0.2862615585,
-0.0928291604,
-0.4396518767,
0.0944809392,
0.1355123222,
-1.1421715021,
0.2313594967,
0.0271540228,
0.2269292176,
0.2529692948,
0.4424831569,
0.1808202565,
0.8589589,
0.7121546268,
0.1504781842,
0.5599994063,
-0.4943469465,
0.1141925901,
-0.5915026665,
-0.344288528,
-0.2214439958,
-0.4422936141,
-0.0553983152,
-0.7904469967,
0.2375254482,
0.6006866097,
-0.1444903314,
0.022361597,
-0.4643676281,
0.6340914965,
0.6555989385,
-0.0072328588,
0.441032052,
-0.1280629933,
-0.0863159522,
0.0262244288,
-0.6149072051,
-0.4552975595,
0.9067496061,
0.1571009904,
0.6790545583,
0.206670776,
0.7088979483,
0.1706760079,
0.8296730518,
-0.9564113021,
0.7610279322,
0.0288181119,
-0.8733540773,
-0.1007686555,
-0.282789588,
-1.0601255894,
0.261757493,
-0.3828316331,
-0.5962059498,
0.0936401039,
0.3802413642,
-0.3902957737,
0.5962129831,
-0.5012828112,
0.6855548024,
-0.5250982642,
-0.8967698812,
-0.280023247,
-0.7026810646,
0.2054624856,
-0.0847598836,
0.2555982471,
-0.3064395189,
-0.1605309248,
0.8604413867,
-0.1726995111,
1.3148008585,
-0.5881621242,
-0.031670846,
0.5371818542,
0.3332564533,
0.1702797413,
-0.0384420119,
0.0326869301,
0.1000386178,
-0.3992677629,
-0.4518288076,
-0.3246927857,
0.713011682,
-0.9138765335,
-0.2035145313,
-0.4336057901,
-0.8206686378,
-0.2493969053,
0.1439493001,
-0.2479597181,
0.3407165706,
-0.04276333,
0.4178038836,
0.6623019576,
-0.0644438118,
0.670165658,
0.6037805676,
-0.3178334832,
-0.5693240166,
0.9662594199,
0.1878999919,
0.1489649862,
0.4381673038,
0.0547642596,
-0.2797089815,
-0.636294961,
-0.4811423719,
0.3655012548,
-0.7153184414,
-0.3000882566,
-0.4925262928,
0.0912135914,
-0.1792687625,
-0.2900001109,
-0.6163340211,
-0.6834579706,
-0.5102975965,
-0.1115910709,
0.3081051707,
0.8535186052,
-0.1798495203,
0.3647485971,
-0.882925868,
0.0653752834,
0.5112170577,
0.4946841002,
0.263119638,
-0.0987757966,
-0.4838579297,
0.0634452403,
-0.3536546528,
-0.6145136356,
0.4557790756,
0.4081403315,
0.7518146038,
0.4260783792,
0.2429701537,
0.373436749,
0.0061131576,
0.8216444254,
0.2696088552,
-0.8659133315,
0.550270319,
-0.3523162305,
0.2392478585,
0.7676649094,
0.5450713634,
-0.5945404768,
-0.2830489278,
-0.4515856802,
-1.3327864408,
0.7477167845,
0.026057519,
-0.2889151573,
0.0026467002,
0.3692289591,
0.1945078075,
0.2248709798,
-0.8229578137,
-0.1344487667,
-0.1322604716,
-0.2438544184,
-0.2166477144,
-0.0615515411,
-0.2115504146,
-0.1780846715,
0.9724628329,
-0.1573047191,
0.0121842287,
0.0871240422,
-0.5442149639,
-0.382692486,
0.3708420992,
0.3933725059,
0.3759414256,
-0.3999250829,
0.1954411417,
0.0588820577,
-0.211124301,
0.1000981107,
-0.0630862191,
-0.2776284516,
-0.1683415323,
0.3198797107,
0.8641785979,
0.392912209,
-0.7971950769,
0.6027103066,
-0.0875569433,
-0.4659051895,
-0.2552734911,
0.2073332518,
0.1604159176,
0.2834458351,
0.5344411731,
0.0788775086,
-0.4027697444,
-0.2099517584,
0.1924259961,
0.2525078952,
-0.8765918016,
-0.6410345435,
1.0132758617,
0.5879126787,
-0.402992785,
0.5719053745,
-0.4190064669,
-0.2616311312,
-0.0327179208,
0.4504552782,
0.930760026,
-0.2301036119,
0.075356178,
0.3079016209,
0.0758506656,
-0.1598838419,
0.0344520733,
-0.4490106702,
-0.621178925,
-0.6735116243,
-0.610814631,
-0.7072407603,
0.2222696096,
-0.6316744685,
-0.0218923036,
-0.5583267212,
0.2452315986,
-0.3229111433,
0.1733992398,
-0.4877164364,
0.1284959316,
0.3128100932,
0.6666966677,
-0.9917105436,
1.1226922274,
0.954677701,
-0.6612479091,
-0.7306393981,
-0.3914146423,
0.1644473374,
-0.5970978141,
0.7453499436,
0.3530935943,
-0.2555236518,
0.040058732,
-0.5656158924,
-0.6420270205,
1.1666218042,
0.3666891158,
-0.485286653,
-0.1512521058,
-0.0385040678,
0.6351130605,
-0.2663872838,
-0.0288700126,
-0.0343594812,
0.061226584,
0.115926452,
-0.8754023314,
-0.042987179,
-0.2984067798,
-0.4771885574,
0.4006462097,
-0.673704803,
0.6936792731,
-0.080655314,
-0.049840305,
-0.0696584284,
0.7173519135,
0.100086987,
0.5399144888,
0.6828619242,
0.6601346731,
0.9620695114,
0.0443104021,
0.7166295648,
-0.2239447087,
0.2897996604,
1.0920914412,
-0.5726947188,
1.0612927675,
0.370365262,
0.1031553075,
0.2681427598,
0.5267325044,
0.2286843508,
0.5290704966,
0.1059734747,
-0.8515601754,
-0.6002225876,
-0.2305593938,
-0.0610814169,
0.4917458594,
0.4195898175,
-0.0653408542,
-0.4609956145,
0.1847823411,
0.1592642963,
0.1671794355,
-0.3328490853,
0.7876164913,
-0.0732848793,
-0.5610064268,
0.6738943458,
-0.1850307435,
0.8530585766,
-0.6600927114,
0.0891468078,
-0.188747853,
0.5154235363,
-0.1964036226,
-0.4061349332,
0.3222256899,
0.011121437,
-0.2356074154,
-0.6350660324,
0.5678485036,
-0.7871007919,
-0.116063647,
0.5809653997,
0.9029948711,
0.2753679454,
-0.1157276109,
-0.5786880851,
-0.2423122525,
0.0598698892,
-0.3049964905,
0.569796443,
-0.0123431701,
-0.4004745781,
0.6722930074,
0.91346246,
0.125992015,
-0.1258357763,
0.1080705673,
0.8700383306,
-0.2985923886,
-0.2265350074,
-0.4220830798,
0.3004327714,
0.2115759701,
-0.0768383965,
0.5101286173,
0.7566831112,
1.0937248468,
0.1486377567,
0.7098683119,
-0.0065326924,
0.5318037271,
-0.1515535861,
1.1331394911,
-0.6891933084,
0.2909070849,
0.1050512269,
-0.846652627,
-0.8598437309,
0.7187652588,
-0.2550784945,
-0.3075039685,
0.4602928162,
0.7292343378,
-0.0954091027,
0.0103468969,
0.3383073807,
-0.1067568734,
0.5490777493,
0.4611431658,
0.7070816755,
-0.2643270791,
0.8613015413,
-0.5501479506,
-0.3053083718,
-0.0568977259,
-0.8809807897,
-0.8622116446,
-0.5371330976,
-0.4119794071,
-0.1929555386,
0.0840847269,
1.4542609453,
0.8657189608,
-0.8290199637,
-0.4236131012,
-0.1184420884,
-0.0215144847,
-0.3014906645,
-0.1252189875,
0.3922776878,
-0.3518766165,
-0.7382107377,
0.7833845615,
0.0213606209,
0.1185942963,
0.0451303683,
-0.207088992,
-0.5443119407,
-0.3143109381,
0.5732633471,
0.3955441415,
-0.596552968,
-0.178054601,
-0.0522728302,
0.0366070159,
-0.0270263217,
0.889449656,
-1.0369800329,
0.5881179571,
0.370669812,
0.6368012428,
0.5263062119,
-0.2173778564,
0.3135995567,
-1.1600817442,
0.4616416097,
0.3857491016,
0.1349696517,
0.5046025515,
-0.0491534173,
0.7445557714,
0.5067433715,
-0.6869161725,
-0.9265085459,
-0.0206851773,
-1.1457761526,
-0.220299378,
1.1562546492,
-0.2800428867,
-0.1930727065,
-0.3753644824,
-0.0382163748,
0.6295583844,
-0.5031632185,
0.5182827711,
0.392822504,
-0.2520631254,
-0.0226365421,
-0.693277359,
0.4383853972,
0.3925248086,
-0.5725861192,
0.3854886889,
0.6212720275,
0.2659481466,
0.1855054349,
0.63322258,
0.1631290168,
0.1858063787,
-0.1722775251,
0.598311007,
-0.5818805099,
-0.4548149407,
-0.3529874086,
0.3950809538,
0.3482402563,
-0.3207752407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03726v1
|
Interpretation modeling: Social grounding of sentences by reasoning over their implicit moral judgments
| 2023-11-27T07:50:55 | 2023-11-27T07:50:55 |
Liesbeth Allein, Maria Mihaela Truşcǎ, Marie-Francine Moens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The social and implicit nature of human communication ramifies readers'
understandings of written sentences. Single gold-standard interpretations
rarely exist, challenging conventional assumptions in natural language
processing. This work introduces the interpretation modeling (IM) task which
involves modeling several interpretations of a sentence's underlying semantics
to unearth layers of implicit meaning. To obtain these, IM is guided by
multiple annotations of social relation and common ground - in this work
approximated by reader attitudes towards the author and their understanding of
moral judgments subtly embedded in the sentence. We propose a number of
modeling strategies that rely on one-to-one and one-to-many generation methods
that take inspiration from the philosophical study of interpretation. A
first-of-its-kind IM dataset is curated to support experiments and analyses.
The modeling results, coupled with scrutiny of the dataset, underline the
challenges of IM as conflicting and complex interpretations are socially
plausible. This interplay of diverse readings is affirmed by automated and
human evaluations on the generated interpretations. Finally, toxicity analyses
in the generated interpretations demonstrate the importance of IM for refining
filters of content and assisting content moderators in safeguarding the safety
in online discourse.
|
[
-0.1530488431,
-0.9457533956,
0.8892100453,
0.2722911537,
-0.6333616972,
-0.3742547035,
0.2179696411,
-0.6589732766,
-0.3034640849,
0.7395516634,
-0.6356129646,
-0.5704481006,
-0.7437696457,
0.167732507,
-0.3046220243,
1.2045092583,
0.2764618695,
0.0045589865,
-0.3783354461,
-0.2498380244,
-0.1787144244,
-0.3461978436,
-0.4962834716,
-0.3804329038,
0.4970047772,
0.2246959209,
0.9165061712,
0.7672123909,
0.5090332031,
0.275960952,
-0.4601078928,
-0.2930602729,
-0.7465348244,
-0.0195579603,
-0.4751527607,
-0.5727449059,
-0.293933779,
0.497325778,
0.3446489573,
0.7353298068,
0.0782586932,
0.1962437183,
0.0626247674,
0.4244873524,
-0.4288977683,
0.2888883352,
-0.5113640428,
-0.072886534,
0.125110954,
-0.3323811889,
-0.6860647202,
-0.5020768642,
0.3953373134,
-0.5710777044,
-0.0964227319,
0.139565751,
0.7073509693,
0.2090758532,
-0.9058721066,
-0.6028838754,
-0.5671446919,
0.9317473173,
-0.6741073728,
-0.0308848489,
0.4025417864,
0.0919778496,
0.0702134073,
-0.5634124279,
-0.5572906733,
-0.3406352699,
-0.4333741069,
0.24962762,
0.019171061,
0.1148615703,
0.1498183608,
0.1769042611,
-0.0728681311,
-0.3825246394,
-0.46144104,
0.2819007933,
0.7531644106,
0.0831611305,
0.5325548053,
-0.747508347,
-0.6058064699,
0.3206521273,
-0.6654956937,
0.1224067584,
0.4663778543,
0.1545563191,
-0.2103447765,
0.6402157545,
-0.0002868232,
0.5063281059,
-0.0772435069,
0.29964903,
-0.0386517011,
-0.4077880383,
-0.1404866427,
0.0664164275,
0.6064181924,
0.8357035518,
0.7709926367,
0.1405245215,
0.1879879534,
0.3256050646,
0.5093830824,
-0.6335638762,
0.2100257874,
0.2619799972,
-0.8638224006,
-0.8915412426,
0.2085324526,
-0.8268079758,
-0.5600837469,
-0.6102946401,
0.0940094143,
-0.3986473382,
-0.29926157,
0.4199387729,
-0.1334284097,
0.202426523,
0.2983004451,
-0.5752228498,
0.4827829301,
0.7970563173,
0.7118495107,
0.1876028925,
-0.0910002962,
-0.4419064224,
0.4210478961,
0.0268012341,
0.7444012761,
-0.7413997054,
-0.3905289173,
-0.1506735981,
-0.0789430439,
0.1501371711,
0.2966400981,
1.0043942928,
-0.3136464953,
0.1476816535,
-0.225441739,
-0.5710290074,
-0.5125247836,
0.1684362739,
-0.625803411,
0.5349841714,
-0.2933095992,
-0.8417488337,
0.1460533887,
-0.6986105442,
-0.3954502046,
0.0000584536,
0.0106212413,
0.0443967618,
0.53520751,
0.0505584963,
0.4434491396,
-0.3451764882,
0.3071825206,
-0.4082801342,
-0.3441400826,
0.3628540933,
-0.3543297052,
1.1038345098,
0.2349334359,
-0.2738573253,
-0.0175149459,
-0.519711256,
-0.0809673294,
0.0207577664,
-0.063850373,
-0.6223812699,
0.5567260981,
0.2755559385,
0.3595315516,
0.0182486419,
-0.5650108457,
-0.0929430202,
-0.5425385237,
0.5580753088,
0.8417941928,
0.3275750875,
0.4844080806,
-0.3363807201,
0.3336081207,
-0.1698997021,
0.4925967157,
-0.2591155767,
-0.585072875,
-0.4095739424,
0.0796088427,
-0.1524468511,
0.5603227019,
-0.185311377,
0.271348238,
-0.288217932,
-0.3271705508,
-0.6521320343,
-0.0583254583,
0.4296237528,
0.1593917459,
0.2294249088,
0.0922337174,
-0.0379016884,
-0.7983888388,
-0.7630659938,
-0.4880076647,
0.2588785887,
0.3222970963,
0.396830231,
-0.2529576719,
1.0201822519,
-0.5184394717,
-0.1290807426,
-0.1926042438,
0.5530442595,
0.0389531367,
0.5728908777,
0.5085244179,
-1.1427288055,
-0.2967437804,
0.1419264972,
-1.0622229576,
-0.2552346289,
-0.3576543927,
-0.3928902149,
-0.3045157492,
0.4557271004,
-0.4069311321,
0.5904554129,
0.3620741367,
-0.664244175,
0.389536649,
0.0695742443,
0.2791149616,
-0.9193364978,
-0.1374164075,
0.3311297596,
-0.1917781085,
-0.6128760576,
0.3864147067,
-0.3283848763,
0.1190133542,
-0.6303585768,
0.631020844,
-0.4205899537,
0.1827245355,
-0.0710876957,
0.3168881238,
0.3896063268,
0.2693026662,
-0.1052254289,
0.1545714736,
0.3120982945,
-0.4128353,
0.1954539716,
0.3748134375,
-0.1571285427,
0.7737061381,
-0.8865602612,
0.2324865162,
-0.706736505,
0.121156849,
-0.9921318889,
-0.0545403175,
0.5623304844,
-0.4009790421,
-0.2472524196,
-0.4593464136,
-0.4727194607,
0.281234175,
-0.1701210886,
0.4274606109,
0.1770690084,
-0.3157474697,
0.9308566451,
0.3229726851,
-0.3858222067,
-0.2855471373,
-0.5758321881,
0.0294439029,
-0.2974568903,
-0.7893816829,
-0.0298556909,
-0.0319548212,
-0.9469490647,
0.2639395893,
-0.0674769357,
-0.1062132791,
0.2829000056,
0.4856109917,
0.3639628291,
-0.0191260856,
0.1757463664,
0.461176157,
-0.3002126217,
0.4644869864,
0.0878543109,
-0.0749954581,
-0.3312636316,
-0.3041409552,
-0.3804726899,
0.702803731,
0.6008350849,
-0.2406906337,
0.9056021571,
0.0920866579,
-0.4641319513,
-0.052127555,
-0.2784485519,
-0.1021731645,
-0.4397023022,
-0.1402189285,
-0.4472084045,
-0.2871804535,
0.2618562579,
-0.1663656533,
0.1872311383,
0.3629365861,
0.1657558084,
-0.2672374845,
1.2837454081,
0.4385843277,
0.2969332337,
0.4195050299,
0.0304130074,
0.0606722608,
-0.5497826338,
-0.0645159632,
-0.480538398,
0.0121045932,
-0.4501653314,
-0.1371314377,
0.241135478,
0.1970355511,
-0.0478280298,
-0.0700546876,
-0.5051500201,
0.7697681785,
0.3213031292,
0.3871586025,
0.6567281485,
0.0597583316,
-0.1896137595,
-0.1076690406,
-0.0570151471,
-1.3208522797,
0.9747965932,
0.3554871082,
0.7244147062,
0.2116369456,
0.2183331996,
0.4339707196,
0.5886426568,
-0.4965923131,
0.5192920566,
-0.1414364278,
-0.9110510349,
-0.0338149518,
-0.3187284768,
-0.5768944621,
0.4748797715,
-0.4371198416,
-0.8193261623,
0.0341248773,
-0.0352438912,
-0.092224218,
0.0259694215,
-0.8563096523,
1.0238524675,
-0.3208701015,
-0.4569923282,
-0.5457058549,
-0.9449189305,
0.4222176075,
0.1551288068,
0.4595414996,
-0.2392858118,
0.2816444635,
0.1633334756,
-0.0328522772,
1.0775939226,
-0.0453536958,
0.0200610254,
0.4992994666,
0.1692368537,
0.5092671514,
0.300922811,
-0.666731596,
0.2312537283,
0.352177918,
-0.4257729053,
-0.5924035311,
0.440892905,
-0.6598832607,
-0.4796229601,
-0.5569341779,
-0.4406685531,
0.1754003316,
0.1910483539,
0.2199450582,
0.5097142458,
-0.4420731366,
0.1514755338,
0.3117627203,
-0.3214443922,
-0.2120504081,
0.271681428,
-0.1201185361,
0.0249955598,
0.4276678562,
-0.3582348526,
0.5764306784,
0.1695221961,
0.3447808027,
-0.3376125991,
-0.4334998429,
-0.2306824923,
0.3760994077,
-1.2460076809,
0.4011128247,
-0.8466809988,
0.0726763532,
-0.3034183979,
-0.342224896,
0.1677362025,
-0.136869207,
-0.4998755157,
-0.4017042518,
0.4209800959,
1.0828980207,
0.0734049678,
0.6976928711,
-0.7848392725,
0.4331096113,
0.0051991763,
0.2639787793,
-0.2879639268,
-0.0436966605,
0.0057201469,
0.2354396284,
-0.0619754978,
-1.1621869802,
0.1893142909,
-0.0931071341,
0.4040530026,
0.5483340621,
0.130435884,
0.3870063722,
-0.4397475123,
0.4726415277,
-0.1430499852,
-1.2422014475,
0.7490858436,
-0.5189447999,
-0.1015535817,
0.790410161,
0.3508345783,
-0.6985340118,
-0.6955029368,
-0.5281313062,
-0.6300797462,
0.645873487,
0.3717033863,
0.3767966926,
-0.0959734395,
0.7278160453,
0.1860528439,
0.1432055682,
-1.144960165,
-0.059880536,
-0.2259600163,
-0.5639748573,
-0.1557968259,
-0.4060741067,
-0.0690326244,
0.0270865597,
0.4629217982,
-0.1622900218,
0.0466465838,
0.0590642057,
-0.4229026735,
-0.3216649592,
0.3537656665,
0.240463689,
0.7531520128,
-0.2840590477,
0.1667382121,
-0.2468358129,
-0.2785324454,
-0.0562086888,
-0.0637546778,
-0.3670091033,
-0.1432521492,
0.38208583,
0.621195972,
0.4252998531,
-0.3892085254,
0.5255670547,
-0.1461212039,
0.2949551046,
-0.313993752,
-0.074165836,
0.0364263766,
0.1698845029,
0.2281775624,
0.1263207793,
0.228632912,
-0.8553285003,
0.2131970078,
0.3155912161,
-0.4769470692,
-0.4164712131,
0.7830561399,
0.2214859724,
-0.1275217235,
0.5546565056,
-0.2362704128,
-0.4922355711,
0.654542923,
0.243635416,
0.780967176,
0.0618299618,
0.4848997593,
0.2493483722,
0.4738495052,
0.036771819,
0.2819140553,
0.2459065318,
-0.7637998462,
-0.4872872829,
-0.5912126303,
-0.3075141609,
-0.298714757,
-0.8572410941,
0.4057934284,
-0.2827037275,
-0.0145087317,
0.2191374153,
-0.2415462583,
-0.2554502487,
0.206566453,
0.0971877202,
0.6150981188,
-1.1244461536,
0.4239507616,
0.6347765326,
-0.587539494,
-0.5025570989,
0.149376303,
0.3006451428,
-0.3839164376,
0.59060359,
0.3437524438,
-0.2556249499,
0.2334185094,
-0.7933588624,
-0.509873271,
0.7075126767,
0.3050321341,
-0.0768455341,
-0.1947601736,
0.2158990353,
0.5894573927,
-0.544059217,
0.3102435768,
0.4500239193,
0.5775498748,
-0.0216064528,
-0.2228525728,
0.2920550704,
-0.4039360583,
-0.2591410875,
-0.0404356346,
-0.2819307745,
0.9118549228,
-0.0020986374,
-0.4347403347,
0.0231483132,
0.3268766105,
0.2261193395,
0.4596935809,
0.6323960423,
0.0800290182,
0.4037047923,
0.0855865553,
1.2764952183,
-0.2167056501,
0.4235433638,
1.0237497091,
-0.2416270226,
0.4030723274,
0.3255090714,
0.2191377282,
0.6436826587,
0.408254683,
0.0535684191,
0.3806716204,
0.0975381285,
-0.3545098603,
-0.3056324124,
-0.2996741533,
0.0802299455,
0.3828984499,
0.4603551626,
-0.4656069279,
-0.2687476873,
-0.1644229144,
-0.2661574185,
0.3427310288,
-0.4290799201,
0.6868057251,
0.4198893011,
-0.6355333924,
-0.2550621331,
0.1465008706,
0.2457298338,
-0.183442995,
-0.3154842854,
0.1631941795,
0.1149924621,
-0.2297332138,
-0.9246344566,
0.4572419226,
0.1688855588,
-0.0834613591,
-0.6785502434,
1.0237644911,
-0.109333232,
-0.7411043644,
0.4799219072,
0.5541818142,
0.3336035609,
-0.2045156956,
-0.7602159381,
-0.0914979652,
-0.0874574631,
-0.2950707376,
-0.2166606486,
0.625433147,
-0.1253520548,
0.6250828505,
0.7218808532,
-0.0550585464,
0.1775817871,
0.0734586045,
0.5364997983,
-0.857588172,
-0.6247415543,
-0.9171739817,
0.7548517585,
-0.0514632836,
-0.2456638068,
0.5663340092,
0.1115135849,
0.3768058121,
0.2656705976,
0.7356416583,
0.1013591737,
0.31786111,
-0.5492991805,
0.8513950109,
-0.4327209294,
0.1197120473,
-0.5291183591,
-0.8025152087,
-0.0781554356,
0.9209195971,
-0.4840484858,
-0.0814237297,
0.5749722123,
0.2966632247,
-0.0681415051,
0.5997906923,
-0.0328739807,
0.4664103091,
0.2309018075,
0.1521777362,
1.2722123861,
-0.353112787,
0.4819596112,
-0.0145821981,
-0.123077333,
-0.0811503232,
-1.1038784981,
-0.8625435233,
-0.2268202305,
-0.2246724218,
-0.3143375516,
-0.1082218811,
0.7733751535,
0.5017030239,
-0.4954230189,
-0.0713095292,
-0.4206682146,
0.3306460083,
-0.224621892,
-0.2792072892,
-0.0214195792,
-0.0912223756,
-0.8675270677,
0.111381799,
0.1372116059,
-0.0013010788,
-0.2340677232,
0.0430077538,
-0.4571524262,
0.380538851,
0.7381480336,
-0.3831997514,
-0.7791549563,
-0.6082721949,
-0.0632833391,
-0.2102441043,
-0.0374736823,
0.5713855624,
-0.5082247853,
0.4417325258,
0.3108049631,
0.2340111732,
0.4343069792,
0.5855022073,
0.7795883417,
-0.4163707495,
-0.0574294627,
0.2528560758,
0.273679167,
0.1308410168,
-0.7641881704,
0.6412159801,
0.1060094833,
-0.2977406383,
-0.7799504399,
0.4910090268,
-0.9685866237,
-0.4924451113,
1.2996635437,
-0.2193893939,
-0.1762218922,
-0.2995474041,
-0.3154549301,
0.3270781636,
-0.1785436273,
0.757009089,
1.0415582657,
0.2922877371,
-0.1104020327,
-0.8153283,
0.1355059892,
0.2247046232,
-1.0215309858,
0.0644536838,
0.7910041213,
0.2687425911,
0.1067698151,
0.468842417,
-0.1125520393,
0.1656760275,
-0.1114163473,
-0.1266396195,
0.187582776,
-0.1736888289,
-0.3086711466,
0.1620586663,
-0.2856099606,
0.2959651649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15596v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15596v2
|
EgoThink: Evaluating First-Person Perspective Thinking Capability of Vision-Language Models
| 2023-11-27T07:44:25 | 2024-03-28T11:35:55 |
Sijie Cheng, Zhicheng Guo, Jingwen Wu, Kechen Fang, Peng Li, Huaping Liu, Yang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Vision-language models (VLMs) have recently shown promising results in
traditional downstream tasks. Evaluation studies have emerged to assess their
abilities, with the majority focusing on the third-person perspective, and only
a few addressing specific tasks from the first-person perspective. However, the
capability of VLMs to "think" from a first-person perspective, a crucial
attribute for advancing autonomous agents and robotics, remains largely
unexplored. To bridge this research gap, we introduce EgoThink, a novel visual
question-answering benchmark that encompasses six core capabilities with twelve
detailed dimensions. The benchmark is constructed using selected clips from
egocentric videos, with manually annotated question-answer pairs containing
first-person information. To comprehensively assess VLMs, we evaluate eighteen
popular VLMs on EgoThink. Moreover, given the open-ended format of the answers,
we use GPT-4 as the automatic judge to compute single-answer grading.
Experimental results indicate that although GPT-4V leads in numerous
dimensions, all evaluated VLMs still possess considerable potential for
improvement in first-person perspective tasks. Meanwhile, enlarging the number
of trainable parameters has the most significant impact on model performance on
EgoThink. In conclusion, EgoThink serves as a valuable addition to existing
evaluation benchmarks for VLMs, providing an indispensable resource for future
research in the realm of embodied artificial intelligence and robotics.
|
[
-0.7656213641,
-0.8084185123,
0.8255391121,
-0.020576397,
-0.259755522,
0.0084552914,
-0.0231575668,
-0.5808994174,
0.0982101038,
0.424721241,
-0.7067397237,
-0.1647236198,
-0.3381717801,
0.047786504,
-0.3519915044,
0.6678769588,
0.1527450681,
-0.0020327941,
-0.3702734411,
-0.336188674,
-0.4355634451,
-0.4040575027,
-0.1929648668,
0.1467311233,
0.4694531262,
0.251244247,
0.5826919079,
0.4432260394,
0.5542686582,
0.4240711927,
0.3632414341,
0.094152838,
-0.1439237744,
-0.1820456386,
-0.3099498451,
-0.3110977411,
-0.648367703,
0.1918378025,
0.7188353539,
0.7079746723,
-0.0435677543,
0.7084057331,
0.0442077257,
0.8738263845,
-0.5427982807,
0.1090233028,
-0.5061516166,
0.1524369121,
0.0467529856,
-0.0100886263,
-0.1496649384,
-0.2008997947,
0.5799928308,
-0.6116048098,
0.115299575,
0.1519338042,
0.7525092959,
0.5665053129,
0.1314307004,
0.5226621032,
-0.8230712414,
0.4138470292,
-0.4239599407,
0.5573980808,
0.2211960405,
0.6063043475,
0.5721520185,
-0.6978290081,
-0.8669437766,
-0.2579095066,
0.2331873924,
0.2138588727,
-0.3572748303,
0.0097082444,
0.1379897445,
0.1749101281,
-0.7982788086,
-0.1893238425,
-0.5407012105,
-0.086402975,
0.5471627116,
0.2377067804,
-0.1217667907,
-0.2545468211,
-0.485324353,
-0.2301242799,
-0.0796998814,
0.1191088781,
0.2685325444,
0.080583632,
0.2200487107,
0.6264711618,
-0.491001904,
0.9549049735,
0.0515342206,
0.2600274086,
0.2568802536,
-0.4591303468,
-0.4452946484,
-0.6078234911,
0.433700949,
0.5957984328,
0.364118427,
-0.0802134275,
0.0853604302,
-0.1613736153,
0.8802783489,
-0.5670983791,
-0.3258160949,
0.3010169268,
-0.4423309565,
-0.0857253149,
0.0395828485,
-0.5099279881,
-0.4569510221,
-0.6013870239,
0.6828401685,
-0.4276004136,
-0.4306643009,
0.058710359,
-0.0882265344,
0.5174387097,
0.764131546,
-0.3413354456,
0.2853035331,
0.746979475,
0.6823285222,
0.05386151,
-0.7217086554,
-0.3230791092,
-0.407721132,
-0.2864722311,
1.0278209448,
-0.3883458972,
0.0561209992,
-0.3164625168,
-0.1388526708,
0.0368129909,
-0.4511205852,
0.14336209,
-0.0529410876,
0.1642827839,
-0.4984533489,
-0.3584360182,
-0.2595768571,
0.6792746782,
-0.4920906425,
0.7813186049,
0.4149357975,
-0.5855585933,
0.5399234295,
-0.3790818453,
-0.0058042211,
0.724625051,
-0.6159006953,
-0.1702328324,
0.239122048,
0.0260212105,
0.3954200149,
-0.2093642354,
-0.0305164289,
-0.3025978208,
0.0795589238,
0.1471931487,
-0.364828825,
0.5342928171,
-0.0598274954,
-0.3792967498,
0.1665891856,
-0.6393912435,
0.6628625393,
0.181721285,
0.1841688603,
-0.2772455812,
-0.0101934345,
0.0510669947,
0.4066150784,
0.2647531629,
-0.4429883361,
0.1395306289,
-0.3071744442,
0.2718917131,
0.9245555997,
-0.2561823428,
0.258639276,
-0.1598261297,
0.737115562,
-0.1991105378,
0.4582635164,
-0.1118092388,
-0.6209629774,
-0.7031822205,
-0.0565104745,
-0.2464298755,
0.5192643404,
-1.004191041,
0.1185605749,
-0.2678467333,
-0.754191637,
-0.6928660274,
0.0942043141,
0.6045421362,
0.7911999226,
0.4075444639,
-0.613642931,
-0.3155610263,
-1.435374856,
-0.7052077055,
-0.7784883976,
-0.0253247935,
0.4387489855,
0.6122267246,
0.2303552181,
0.9132713675,
-0.4375318885,
-0.2779502571,
-0.2340058684,
-0.034149006,
-0.3009126186,
0.1762657017,
0.7008355856,
-0.7947200537,
-0.2656479478,
-0.0021370477,
-0.6677078605,
0.2194908857,
0.0860792547,
0.0007829727,
0.0080386233,
0.23859106,
-0.4413060248,
0.7502875328,
0.1882068068,
-0.4688382745,
0.656175673,
-0.3974279463,
0.1426448077,
-0.4842060208,
0.1366253942,
0.2623961568,
-0.2904751003,
-0.5366616249,
0.3109407425,
0.0771631747,
0.0557074621,
-0.6381750107,
0.7215687633,
-0.2795633078,
-0.3768482506,
-0.1988464892,
0.3373665214,
-0.0880552754,
0.6223494411,
0.048021622,
0.67241925,
0.4510314763,
-0.4169654846,
0.1575078815,
0.2229713202,
-0.4491916895,
1.042578578,
-0.6516387463,
0.4239861667,
-0.3963848352,
0.0078214658,
-1.0811777115,
-0.2054071128,
0.1973316371,
-0.44310987,
-0.1485515088,
0.113881886,
-0.4993975461,
-0.7773079872,
-0.1821038276,
0.2317150235,
0.0994139612,
-0.1347955018,
0.9598997235,
0.5322976708,
-0.0657306239,
-0.4452077746,
-0.6514621377,
0.1827642173,
-0.0603837445,
-0.5577340722,
0.0905412138,
-0.3552092314,
-0.4005003572,
0.0515916348,
-0.15865089,
-0.0825824887,
0.0937161818,
0.0763411522,
0.3622219265,
-0.0715400651,
-0.1020005941,
-0.4526799023,
-0.104184404,
0.1035504788,
-0.5398212671,
0.2798419595,
-0.9542660713,
-0.3797293603,
-0.2557472885,
0.3146826029,
0.5281217694,
-0.5795912147,
0.442555666,
0.4497959018,
-0.3373073637,
-0.2119193822,
-0.6973562837,
-0.0259749405,
-0.458989203,
0.8289675117,
-0.455904156,
-0.7012385726,
0.2004330903,
0.2961087823,
0.2627613544,
0.1446199715,
0.6300358176,
-0.2319714278,
0.7837183475,
0.9739904404,
0.1325526685,
0.3337646723,
-0.2542096674,
0.1964460611,
-0.8193819523,
-0.2664239407,
-0.1363318712,
-0.4805347621,
-0.273840189,
-0.7303190827,
0.5778669119,
-0.4617688954,
-0.358597368,
0.4660675824,
-0.595517695,
0.6029519439,
0.3929111362,
0.234778434,
0.2275436223,
-0.3270660043,
0.0565400831,
0.0043874676,
-0.472746253,
-0.6424846649,
1.0903927088,
0.162106365,
0.1657707989,
-0.0548628345,
0.2181964666,
0.0953245834,
0.4100179076,
-0.7083725333,
0.8809908032,
0.1555270553,
-0.8736869693,
-0.4679330587,
0.0183771662,
-0.457628727,
0.5119193792,
0.0637961328,
-0.9912340641,
0.0523125157,
0.4756614864,
-0.6399952769,
0.3784632683,
-0.760389924,
0.9949314594,
-0.5034812093,
-0.5453793406,
-0.1615012437,
-0.9052022696,
0.1111252978,
0.0813776702,
0.0461813733,
0.0498644486,
-0.284956187,
0.4104867876,
-0.3640606701,
0.5195717216,
-0.3228175342,
-0.0096341139,
0.3702248633,
0.1628529578,
0.0637753978,
-0.0621580184,
0.2488095015,
0.3434483409,
-0.0640037134,
-0.3315479457,
-0.6681574583,
0.3564349711,
-0.602150321,
-0.7713509202,
-0.2052389979,
-0.2097226232,
-0.4597723782,
0.2563091815,
0.2919153571,
0.2618198991,
-0.4261369407,
0.1053389534,
0.3898276091,
-0.0462231375,
0.2074283659,
0.6550112963,
-0.6128987074,
-0.1042090207,
0.7214990258,
0.3916674256,
0.5151494145,
0.1975639462,
-0.002098894,
-0.025606405,
-0.333216846,
-0.8058155775,
-0.0996616632,
-0.8054744601,
0.1112272143,
-0.8548895717,
-0.2095090747,
0.0569264591,
0.0469740778,
-0.8611850142,
-0.2888291776,
0.3022444248,
-0.2843671143,
0.0210900605,
0.4434826076,
0.1058610454,
-0.1832969785,
-0.3002541065,
0.438228339,
0.6679490209,
0.5160799623,
0.2102012485,
-0.3577022254,
-0.3286395669,
-0.2257784456,
-0.3808090091,
-0.6266973615,
0.1356389225,
-0.0085700843,
0.6520881653,
0.2957377434,
-0.2932071686,
0.7864838839,
-0.8376185894,
0.7907915711,
-0.0855262354,
-0.740852654,
0.4844549596,
-0.1894948781,
0.4167749584,
0.8847603798,
0.1182897016,
-0.2105474919,
-0.4005380869,
-0.7111616731,
-0.7242245078,
0.4624321163,
0.4891375005,
-0.0644144416,
0.1599765271,
0.1029204577,
0.2292665243,
0.4544403255,
-0.4692287743,
-0.4397607446,
-0.5694599748,
0.0878795609,
-0.1924400628,
0.3372937143,
0.1116910949,
-0.7177950144,
0.1140937433,
-0.2529158294,
0.4691070318,
0.5155276656,
0.0107131014,
-0.1490208358,
-0.0704357252,
0.4821833372,
0.9750691652,
-0.0982099026,
-0.0330289118,
0.1413620561,
-0.5340995193,
-0.0215739459,
0.1170780286,
-0.0410325639,
-0.1930484772,
0.2052273452,
0.7313052416,
-0.0874331146,
-0.7858839035,
0.6466382146,
-0.3025191724,
-0.1603991985,
-0.7096248269,
0.0704173297,
-0.1039576679,
0.5451757312,
0.4963111877,
0.5519277453,
0.2427553833,
-0.5915169716,
0.0709510744,
0.3950846195,
-0.459736526,
-0.6549579501,
0.8564925194,
0.0346825346,
-0.5118204951,
0.2094147205,
-0.0159458052,
-0.6513718963,
0.7272511721,
-0.2063163072,
1.3174600601,
-0.106168583,
0.3350346982,
0.3975337744,
0.8188558221,
0.134866491,
0.410280019,
-0.4360092282,
-0.6471551657,
-0.1697707474,
-0.3435419202,
-0.5670019984,
0.2981205285,
-0.6270008683,
0.1018304527,
-0.7119019628,
-0.1898378432,
0.2044697702,
-0.1317940056,
-1.452368021,
0.2976686358,
0.5045259595,
0.6002709866,
-0.4928210676,
0.5531212687,
0.9167832732,
-0.4055920541,
-0.7221388817,
0.1732987911,
0.203618139,
-0.6886604428,
0.5289554596,
0.2426701188,
-0.4504831731,
-0.0374839082,
-0.7946878076,
-0.7728798985,
0.9849838018,
0.2628827989,
-0.4548052251,
-0.1936809123,
-0.0822715983,
0.7211514115,
-0.4042854607,
0.3203880489,
0.5477704406,
0.5877488852,
-0.4818089008,
-1.0772627592,
-0.3143802285,
-0.5696142912,
0.0863903314,
-0.209337011,
-1.0356923342,
0.9045316577,
-0.3976665735,
-0.0923555866,
0.1720193326,
0.7939173579,
0.2142827809,
0.3075800538,
0.6337603331,
0.4437036514,
0.5930131078,
0.2272152603,
1.3146549463,
-0.2128472328,
0.1594109684,
1.232729435,
-0.2851422131,
0.8960456252,
0.5015613437,
-0.2833604515,
0.4084393084,
0.115422599,
0.1621667147,
0.4470176399,
-0.023849884,
0.2157241106,
-0.5393700004,
0.4205835164,
-0.231612429,
0.7252978086,
0.032095287,
-0.1104381457,
-0.102293849,
0.3481670916,
-0.4157154262,
0.2035875618,
-0.3106501698,
0.5972114801,
-0.0782818869,
-0.8482406735,
0.3301154077,
-0.3349204361,
0.1409947425,
-0.3381906748,
0.0469700657,
-0.1100005507,
0.410197109,
0.0942647457,
-0.8944829106,
0.0770338476,
0.2373360395,
-0.1219548136,
-0.3029102981,
0.5887123346,
0.0576794297,
-0.6175174713,
0.1271927208,
0.9059163332,
0.1534769684,
-0.3346833885,
-0.730379045,
-0.135741055,
-0.1325795203,
-0.4187084436,
0.0937136114,
0.5202144384,
0.1161633953,
0.9860758185,
0.1142231002,
-0.0307377577,
0.0804830566,
-0.2414293885,
0.9985877275,
-0.7070612907,
-0.5759530067,
-0.7935794592,
0.7014639974,
-0.126199469,
-0.8423276544,
0.8624000549,
0.5451680422,
1.2615368366,
-0.1424902529,
0.928160429,
-0.2590420246,
0.5949460268,
-0.0270869061,
0.6689724326,
-0.8036437035,
0.058959078,
-0.8088621497,
-0.9409950972,
0.0908616558,
0.8269950747,
-0.4621507525,
0.1989426911,
0.6309820414,
0.3234154582,
0.0875247344,
0.0872890726,
0.4897960126,
0.2714992762,
0.227885291,
0.4861795306,
0.8976205587,
-0.3294599354,
0.3111749589,
-0.4054782391,
-0.258651644,
-0.104000859,
-0.7270153165,
-0.8156676888,
-0.9611962438,
-0.3604449332,
0.0008873604,
-0.185244441,
0.8202405572,
0.8161839247,
-0.1552391499,
0.0579810329,
-0.087498039,
-0.4366027117,
-0.4279682636,
-0.1822766364,
0.0826396495,
0.1914134175,
-0.4903657138,
0.2008461803,
0.7058275938,
-0.2677433789,
-0.9600167274,
0.0582165942,
0.0146885617,
0.1571308672,
0.827242434,
0.357229352,
-0.9632122517,
-0.572213769,
0.2485508472,
0.0925837606,
0.1656332016,
0.5637825131,
-1.3000632524,
0.8583338857,
0.2083876431,
0.6325553656,
0.3765855134,
0.2380647957,
0.3852668703,
-0.3692343831,
0.2300979793,
0.528706491,
0.2072945535,
0.407459408,
-0.0837110355,
0.5625410676,
0.1605048478,
-0.365193069,
-0.7182831764,
0.2598992288,
-0.9694865346,
-0.2358788997,
0.7524837852,
-0.0591777936,
-0.4652831256,
0.0431590043,
-0.3742569685,
-0.2557662427,
0.107593134,
0.7409518957,
0.7871446013,
-0.1159851998,
-0.3690725565,
-0.9941298962,
0.1737204939,
0.4920548499,
-0.8739056587,
0.066688329,
0.5044510365,
0.1173567846,
0.1234977394,
0.7908428311,
0.0207302645,
0.3969143629,
0.0050424547,
-0.0852226391,
-0.1999631524,
-0.6800894141,
-0.0838265494,
0.1880750805,
-0.1282845587,
-0.0677923635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16201v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16201v1
|
Pre-trained Language Models Do Not Help Auto-regressive Text-to-Image Generation
| 2023-11-27T07:19:26 | 2023-11-27T07:19:26 |
Yuhui Zhang, Brandon McKinzie, Zhe Gan, Vaishaal Shankar, Alexander Toshev
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in image tokenizers, such as VQ-VAE, have enabled
text-to-image generation using auto-regressive methods, similar to language
modeling. However, these methods have yet to leverage pre-trained language
models, despite their adaptability to various downstream tasks. In this work,
we explore this gap by adapting a pre-trained language model for
auto-regressive text-to-image generation, and find that pre-trained language
models offer limited help. We provide a two-fold explanation by analyzing
tokens from each modality. First, we demonstrate that image tokens possess
significantly different semantics compared to text tokens, rendering
pre-trained language models no more effective in modeling them than randomly
initialized ones. Second, the text tokens in the image-text datasets are too
simple compared to normal language model pre-training data, which causes the
catastrophic degradation of language models' capability.
|
[
-0.1341224313,
-0.4936216474,
0.4773841202,
0.0667493865,
-0.6450841427,
-0.0253725294,
-0.1046845019,
-0.4537351429,
-0.1301533133,
0.5472698212,
-0.5018097758,
-0.1115555987,
-0.8840960264,
0.3414626122,
-0.3980737925,
1.1013644934,
-0.010072059,
-0.0342224091,
-0.1303222924,
0.2112570703,
-0.7070363164,
-0.473510325,
-0.6547909379,
0.2532553971,
0.1944091618,
0.0943918526,
0.705057323,
0.6847494841,
0.4127608538,
0.3258384168,
0.4035566449,
-0.0408716574,
-0.5535289049,
0.0197135173,
0.1367935538,
-0.3655261397,
-0.1032164991,
0.1063024029,
0.6908146739,
0.4824042022,
0.3512500226,
0.1630025208,
-0.1176605597,
0.4597767889,
-0.6245456934,
0.1737513542,
-0.9980368614,
-0.1374632716,
-0.1496019363,
-0.235534519,
-0.4539117813,
-0.0333366171,
0.1000208333,
-0.7584073544,
0.1129022911,
0.1483986974,
1.2034217119,
0.5756675005,
-0.3646323085,
-0.3113222718,
-0.879969418,
0.4874209464,
-0.7388812304,
0.1394090205,
0.2731285691,
0.0620112345,
-0.0934116393,
-0.9859706759,
-0.6952295899,
-0.296492964,
-0.18317388,
0.0385374241,
-0.3109479845,
-0.0175764915,
0.0495677926,
0.0468508974,
-0.2437001318,
0.2760512531,
-0.1984257251,
-0.1595025957,
0.3217464387,
0.0043046013,
0.460967958,
-0.3966977894,
-0.5872006416,
-0.2346988767,
-0.5180187225,
0.0283280853,
0.2433248907,
0.2989576161,
0.1020881608,
0.3847976327,
0.5205155611,
0.7214344144,
0.2476890832,
0.1156332865,
-0.0693104863,
-0.3706344962,
-0.5158382058,
-0.4972665012,
1.2139894962,
0.2193270028,
0.2550494075,
-0.1333558112,
-0.2638127506,
0.0035273109,
0.2172940075,
-0.8817387223,
-0.221635446,
-0.3011623025,
-0.5194150805,
-0.3588508368,
0.0729877949,
-0.4504648745,
-0.0655788705,
0.1427606046,
0.7955860496,
-0.2550162375,
-0.2187169045,
0.0960286558,
-0.3045244217,
0.2804406583,
0.145762831,
-0.6429361701,
0.2745420039,
0.1510826051,
0.6910575032,
-0.0683175325,
-0.3119781613,
-0.2574099898,
-0.1964865476,
-0.7322781682,
0.9795556664,
-0.6317350864,
-0.5897853374,
-0.0469406061,
0.3516480327,
-0.2131628543,
-0.4077208936,
0.3187856078,
-0.5372472405,
0.5498970151,
-0.1078442559,
-0.3850998282,
0.1425488442,
-0.3954089582,
-0.6388422251,
0.716352582,
0.069801636,
-0.7785708904,
0.7511609793,
-0.4883717299,
-0.3902051449,
0.0723819658,
-0.5998057127,
-0.5574793816,
0.3501520753,
0.2966942489,
0.5110725164,
-0.3584896028,
0.4011643529,
-0.1746346503,
-0.3681645691,
0.1303566247,
-0.5789353251,
0.5066549778,
0.0384248532,
-0.4695035517,
-0.1625071913,
-0.7735486627,
-0.2240447998,
0.4523559213,
-0.0979001373,
-0.4852048755,
0.1448657364,
0.2857284546,
0.526886642,
-0.0029423779,
-0.263371706,
0.3393932879,
-0.2513136566,
0.3349761367,
0.9990718365,
-0.2800390124,
0.6665020585,
-0.2232238203,
0.7199335694,
0.2580103874,
-0.114827849,
-0.6534476876,
-0.3217331469,
-0.8523578644,
-0.3665344417,
0.3640049994,
0.4365872741,
-0.9159715176,
0.1545513272,
-0.431104064,
-0.2583192885,
-0.6763391495,
-0.005046776,
0.4498096108,
0.5981274843,
0.2807563543,
-0.7905393839,
-0.4229250252,
-0.996262908,
-0.5233145952,
-0.2045126855,
0.1112131178,
0.1794402003,
0.3763544559,
-0.0756390765,
0.7511050701,
-0.1602706611,
-0.3337569237,
0.2485594004,
0.4048696458,
-0.2363717407,
0.5994466543,
0.8795667291,
-0.5522946715,
-0.5604453087,
-0.2710076571,
-0.2983968556,
-0.1172631159,
-0.5136864781,
-0.0158146583,
0.3591260612,
0.8579750657,
-0.4532310665,
0.7315062284,
0.655557394,
-0.5189346671,
0.5597481728,
-0.2717714906,
0.1256278157,
-1.1678987741,
0.0770241469,
-0.0513755679,
-0.4266080856,
-0.5670375824,
-0.2410729527,
-0.0122489277,
-0.3280545473,
-0.1995444149,
0.7731255889,
-0.5883762836,
-0.0434549004,
-0.6710272431,
-0.2185380906,
-0.0012951591,
0.3608327508,
0.362393111,
0.8811168671,
0.8496822119,
-0.6358750463,
-0.1740282476,
0.1671808809,
-0.1445916742,
0.3607475758,
-0.6663632393,
0.1082471758,
-0.3567647338,
0.2093634605,
-1.0556298494,
-0.2123442441,
0.2534530759,
-0.4801349044,
0.7611591816,
-0.1881080121,
-0.4738956392,
-0.275000602,
-0.1011991426,
0.6567534804,
0.8098224998,
-0.571580708,
0.5659611225,
0.10050264,
-0.1122272834,
-0.4877005517,
-0.8254919052,
0.1802259684,
0.0246981364,
-0.3608825803,
0.451952368,
0.0518738814,
0.2006654888,
0.4119177759,
0.0909803584,
-0.2785277665,
0.0668841824,
0.3206877112,
0.352969557,
-0.3805513382,
0.5029453039,
-0.1461121589,
-0.2277969271,
0.0621199682,
-0.4842205644,
0.2223234624,
0.1030419543,
-0.3572041094,
-0.662640512,
0.4485718608,
0.6462042928,
-0.1662424356,
0.8786017895,
0.4527873695,
-0.2043670565,
0.1266910434,
-0.3215425014,
-0.0003488926,
-0.4997060597,
0.6260636449,
-0.2358757406,
-0.8092995286,
0.2018561512,
-0.0874837488,
0.1319295317,
0.6311996579,
0.5312184095,
-0.1519746035,
1.1052644253,
0.9062101841,
0.1872184128,
0.8496724367,
0.0739294961,
0.1441620886,
-0.3084371984,
0.1412512958,
-0.4195058048,
0.1013691798,
-0.903206408,
-0.2723459005,
-0.1345489919,
-0.0932625011,
-0.3279825747,
0.3112905324,
-0.5777506828,
0.1967391968,
0.4039077461,
-0.2879702151,
0.0565582328,
0.2680903673,
0.2395525724,
-0.0852886066,
-1.0122812986,
-0.5422734618,
0.9620382786,
0.2024526447,
0.7456880808,
-0.4352445006,
0.4809429049,
0.0255200993,
0.5282631516,
-0.6732592583,
0.3415548503,
-0.5419667363,
-0.5122874379,
-0.163137123,
-0.2653225064,
-1.1372638941,
0.0027240291,
-0.5035378337,
-0.3360311389,
0.4936271012,
0.3916116059,
-0.1886891425,
0.3038843572,
-0.9224070311,
0.8625369072,
-0.349104017,
-0.1022890285,
0.3481983244,
-0.3731873333,
0.2068674117,
-0.5996310711,
0.618432343,
0.1536192894,
-0.0829933882,
0.7270984054,
-0.7411420345,
0.9902227521,
-0.2604585886,
0.0928260088,
0.2682523429,
0.0654201061,
0.4389514327,
-0.2652953267,
0.3037052453,
-0.2741236091,
-0.0457540117,
-0.7791289687,
-0.5896764398,
0.3611888885,
-1.0071690083,
-0.8197490573,
-0.1876417398,
-0.1969231218,
-0.1243266463,
0.2481750697,
0.771538794,
0.2400673032,
-0.0819066092,
-0.0635220259,
-0.0013505472,
-0.3570165634,
0.7076222301,
0.1577544212,
-0.271396488,
-0.3523555696,
0.796782136,
0.1139712781,
0.4395253956,
0.0216612276,
0.0777285099,
-0.1334934533,
-0.3006783426,
-0.2792565525,
0.2072616071,
-0.7364625335,
-0.1651021391,
-0.4949975908,
-0.0715592206,
-0.5311989784,
-0.2075861543,
-0.4655520916,
-0.380480051,
-0.8302455544,
0.1068167314,
0.3955507278,
0.6712238193,
-0.1171634644,
0.610678494,
-0.7729691863,
0.3278567791,
0.5616518855,
0.285472244,
-0.0251881611,
-0.881847322,
-0.2678798139,
-0.1348212659,
-0.0974571034,
-0.9450876117,
0.4079209864,
0.6016715765,
0.2220096141,
0.1643047482,
-0.1821777523,
0.929248631,
-0.769487679,
0.7656956911,
0.4604060948,
-0.9894316792,
0.4916965663,
-0.1103533879,
0.3305309713,
0.3471233249,
0.43935287,
-0.0845486,
-0.399453938,
-0.6832581162,
-0.819914341,
0.4796534777,
0.1605001688,
0.6929456592,
-0.199015826,
0.6253464818,
0.2013562024,
0.0767554864,
-1.2735718489,
-0.1589546353,
-0.810007751,
-0.1489288658,
-0.1958213001,
-0.2778405249,
0.3345440328,
-0.1251949221,
0.5697476268,
-0.1672232747,
0.4032818377,
0.3210339546,
-0.2377539128,
-0.310523808,
0.1100536063,
0.2749361992,
0.0597644448,
0.3143467307,
-0.0783702508,
-0.1630323529,
-0.4660483003,
0.2982688546,
0.2135297954,
-0.264544338,
0.1947125345,
0.5733910203,
1.4308526516,
0.1625143439,
-0.462461412,
0.8886221647,
-0.3649204373,
-0.4993898273,
-0.2210269272,
-0.0415768586,
-0.1708444953,
-0.0134812389,
0.5200916529,
0.2387960702,
-0.3327312171,
-0.4756748378,
0.095845066,
0.5970028639,
-0.5596413612,
-0.4243889749,
0.7872897387,
0.0649216548,
-0.4807895124,
0.4863897264,
0.0035382984,
-0.2323190421,
0.5719947815,
0.8513196707,
0.9507793784,
-0.096832104,
0.2417062819,
0.2005133182,
0.4735971987,
-0.0327154696,
0.0813139156,
0.185298264,
-0.6271498203,
-0.7666071653,
-0.3184878826,
0.3582198322,
0.2835074961,
-0.4556419551,
0.3386175931,
-0.4187321067,
-0.6344913244,
-0.1357815862,
-0.4402875006,
-1.1306912899,
0.424641788,
-0.0518823639,
0.6068211198,
-1.0422229767,
0.6528432965,
0.9016770124,
-0.5139725208,
-0.9626330733,
0.1340442151,
-0.6756847501,
-0.8404598832,
0.8596444726,
0.1254555285,
0.0632324591,
0.3223507404,
-0.8761568069,
-0.7670544386,
0.7316825986,
0.5170224905,
-0.4588671327,
-0.3101276457,
0.1395351589,
0.6336715817,
-0.5584778786,
0.1819903255,
-0.0676867515,
0.2405192554,
-0.0330998302,
-0.8915561438,
0.1079700291,
-0.2240296453,
0.2883395255,
0.0075498438,
-0.4443431795,
0.8603229523,
-0.1965046376,
-0.680650115,
0.025673043,
0.5615705252,
-0.2567732632,
-0.2084259242,
0.6721453667,
0.4100642204,
0.2624894381,
0.1910952777,
1.0525776148,
-0.269936204,
0.2244706452,
1.091779232,
0.0195980426,
0.7956643701,
0.6457378864,
0.0662734285,
0.641426146,
0.6561897993,
-0.1015150771,
0.6313233972,
-0.0156925023,
0.0589010343,
-0.6517831087,
0.0315349214,
-0.2789002955,
0.5109766722,
0.25696823,
-0.7818821073,
-0.1974221021,
0.2728506327,
-0.3111478388,
0.0820499361,
-0.1467425525,
0.749679625,
0.09241274,
-0.4508810341,
0.6498820186,
-0.2136767209,
0.7017079592,
-0.1825333685,
0.1971708685,
0.0158044249,
-0.3713138103,
-0.0242948178,
-0.2949737906,
0.1863067448,
0.1657547057,
0.0024676423,
-0.1904178262,
1.0545347929,
-0.121511735,
-0.6257096529,
0.1442018598,
0.8465989232,
-0.1373534203,
0.172567606,
-0.6741518974,
-0.232012108,
-0.2032614052,
-0.4338457286,
0.3094962835,
0.616731286,
0.0554974973,
0.447740227,
0.7142760754,
-0.023826357,
0.2716657221,
-0.1598890722,
0.9070550203,
-0.665858686,
-0.2179065049,
-0.8991436958,
0.6284114718,
0.2728540897,
-0.1862549335,
0.2320558429,
0.1072365344,
0.8284733295,
-0.361368686,
0.9731774926,
0.0684011728,
0.1072727069,
-0.5596875548,
0.6308704019,
-0.8810591102,
0.0137695819,
-0.302546978,
-0.6072782278,
-0.2628557086,
0.6766535044,
-0.3126580715,
0.231438756,
0.6032156348,
0.727448523,
0.1023660079,
-0.5391659737,
0.4060060084,
0.2701316178,
0.2330207527,
0.2751104832,
0.9623188376,
-0.5286545157,
0.6574656367,
0.1993525028,
-0.1737367809,
-0.0263393018,
-1.304880023,
-0.9857584834,
-0.9045808315,
-0.2451942712,
-0.2437541783,
-0.0624277666,
0.6734396219,
0.8873895407,
-0.3212988079,
0.1971127838,
-0.548402071,
-0.3539819121,
0.3501045406,
-0.1826682985,
0.3464607,
-0.6633693576,
-0.5832667947,
-0.1346332729,
0.257014066,
0.6431213021,
-0.2589506507,
0.276936233,
0.1446301937,
0.3189825118,
0.3698859811,
0.4628844261,
-0.591935277,
-0.2801859975,
0.2636823058,
-0.243651107,
0.2671560049,
0.8781610727,
-1.0413018465,
0.545738399,
0.0704995766,
0.6844166517,
0.3007523119,
-0.2374432385,
0.731893003,
-0.5996818542,
0.4614482522,
0.1687581241,
0.2194302231,
0.2617308795,
-0.2858293951,
-0.2667294443,
0.3192431629,
-0.5089763403,
-0.6380118132,
0.4513502419,
-0.4869558513,
-0.5428223014,
0.9881145358,
-0.1205120012,
-0.4969108701,
0.0710205138,
-0.2893324196,
0.4221228659,
-0.0277117528,
0.6924725175,
0.7119169235,
0.1995341033,
-0.3412465453,
-0.2467344701,
0.771912992,
0.5947085619,
-0.738283813,
-0.1303856522,
0.478371501,
0.2785128355,
-0.0041868072,
1.0896828175,
-0.058629781,
0.2579722404,
0.0798991546,
-0.0241108127,
-0.0157687161,
-0.013004276,
-0.4666326344,
-0.2061406374,
0.5895395279,
-0.140106529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15566v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15566v1
|
SpotServe: Serving Generative Large Language Models on Preemptible Instances
| 2023-11-27T06:31:17 | 2023-11-27T06:31:17 |
Xupeng Miao, Chunan Shi, Jiangfei Duan, Xiaoli Xi, Dahua Lin, Bin Cui, Zhihao Jia
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The high computational and memory requirements of generative large language
models (LLMs) make it challenging to serve them cheaply. This paper aims to
reduce the monetary cost for serving LLMs by leveraging preemptible GPU
instances on modern clouds, which offer accesses to spare GPUs at a much
cheaper price than regular instances but may be preempted by the cloud at any
time. Serving LLMs on preemptible instances requires addressing challenges
induced by frequent instance preemptions and the necessity of migrating
instances to handle these preemptions.
This paper presents SpotServe, the first distributed LLM serving system on
preemptible instances. Several key techniques in SpotServe realize fast and
reliable serving of generative LLMs on cheap preemptible instances. First,
SpotServe dynamically adapts the LLM parallelization configuration for dynamic
instance availability and fluctuating workload, while balancing the trade-off
among the overall throughput, inference latency and monetary costs. Second, to
minimize the cost of migrating instances for dynamic reparallelization, the
task of migrating instances is formulated as a bipartite graph matching
problem, which uses the Kuhn-Munkres algorithm to identify an optimal migration
plan that minimizes communications. Finally, to take advantage of the grace
period offered by modern clouds, we introduce stateful inference recovery, a
new inference mechanism that commits inference progress at a much finer
granularity and allows SpotServe to cheaply resume inference upon preemption.
We evaluate on real spot instance preemption traces and various popular LLMs
and show that SpotServe can reduce the P99 tail latency by 2.4 - 9.1x compared
with the best existing LLM serving systems. We also show that SpotServe can
leverage the price advantage of preemptive instances, saving 54% monetary cost
compared with only using on-demand instances.
|
[
-0.6055535078,
-0.9275363684,
1.06585145,
0.4421768785,
-0.2708476484,
-0.1541265547,
-0.1257028282,
-0.0717795789,
0.120854184,
0.8677326441,
-0.5531225204,
-0.2234064192,
-0.3024021387,
-0.2613686025,
-0.4101299644,
0.3896580338,
0.2444728017,
-0.6060951352,
-0.5889879465,
-0.0516861975,
-0.2557738721,
-0.5566616058,
-0.804156065,
0.0723031685,
0.3475478888,
0.5899242759,
0.6579488516,
0.6873273849,
0.3906776905,
0.4601728618,
0.0267382637,
-0.046484001,
-0.540364027,
0.34825629,
-0.0330652446,
-0.4159760177,
-0.2932819128,
-0.0985378474,
0.6410109997,
0.4758904576,
-0.8248093128,
-0.2369699925,
-0.0027109664,
0.552854836,
-0.7617080212,
-0.0005748342,
-0.6484302878,
-0.0905997083,
-0.6128636599,
0.0143588325,
-0.5083255172,
-0.3460280001,
-0.1011870205,
-1.0156251192,
0.4417708218,
-0.0078887604,
0.7828201056,
0.6129556298,
0.0654634908,
0.2417474687,
-0.8113707304,
0.7552052736,
-0.6133822799,
0.160492748,
0.2064542472,
0.5975167751,
-0.4555192292,
-1.1158684492,
-0.4278327823,
0.0447350703,
0.2137030214,
0.1291754842,
-0.3653232753,
-0.1333748847,
0.2867234349,
0.5454694033,
-0.1687452495,
0.3175917566,
0.1168901175,
-0.070731841,
0.2611922622,
-0.0646631271,
0.1780773848,
0.2695406973,
-0.4813676775,
-0.0099970624,
-1.0643745661,
-0.1285231262,
0.0735438615,
0.2755039632,
-0.085879311,
0.1696979851,
-0.1108640879,
0.7265779972,
0.0119054634,
0.1740063578,
-0.1600620151,
-0.0217599291,
-0.4376873374,
0.0512221977,
0.4696647823,
-0.105450809,
0.0218008831,
-0.0515664071,
0.006307344,
-0.0498168394,
0.4551015794,
-0.8243656158,
-0.2144970745,
0.1494778395,
-0.1677138507,
-0.0679358914,
-0.1425136626,
-0.4650332928,
-0.320558995,
-0.0630911589,
0.1842853129,
-0.2968569994,
-0.2759303153,
-0.0215476137,
0.1922519654,
0.1385003924,
0.7322005033,
-0.5804334879,
0.4097264111,
0.7325571179,
0.8118785024,
0.017167123,
-0.1218719631,
-0.5637225509,
0.1996875107,
-0.1375845373,
1.0807396173,
-0.1409993917,
-0.334433794,
-0.0088895038,
0.3156580627,
0.0325002857,
-0.5309606791,
0.4488545358,
-0.6650829911,
0.0477795191,
-0.4213202596,
-0.6492314935,
-0.0943431556,
0.0427390672,
-0.642013669,
0.6466229558,
0.0496663973,
-0.4565708339,
0.3076188564,
-0.2768447399,
-0.6000176668,
0.6917279959,
-0.055983454,
-0.5477887988,
0.2598409653,
0.2909098268,
0.4414915442,
-0.2599186897,
0.214537546,
-0.4702847004,
-0.3192605376,
-0.1761284471,
-0.20986633,
0.5244781971,
0.3149436414,
-0.4264929891,
0.0719033703,
-0.5362773538,
-0.1287740171,
0.2693301737,
-0.1079582796,
-0.5414555073,
0.675424099,
-0.0760989785,
-0.1687103212,
0.0056385496,
-0.3237481713,
0.2933898568,
-0.2073880285,
0.7133312821,
0.8070204854,
-0.2795113623,
0.5834861398,
0.0615900569,
0.5637825727,
-0.1401622444,
0.4747508764,
-0.2278186083,
-0.2111625522,
-0.8921260238,
-0.8296804428,
-0.2079993337,
0.295158565,
-0.9586869478,
0.2806294262,
-0.2610231042,
-0.3860939443,
-0.50413239,
-0.1139951646,
0.0864442661,
0.4712619185,
0.3332462907,
0.0445467085,
-0.1575544775,
-1.0999981165,
0.2202952355,
0.2928067744,
0.1380392462,
0.5034754872,
-0.0348971002,
0.0207642671,
0.8740022182,
-0.6333952546,
-0.3587569892,
0.0829331577,
-0.2873949409,
0.2535613179,
0.377402246,
0.5655146837,
-0.811000526,
-0.3953834474,
-0.1427103579,
-0.7062869668,
-0.1609421819,
0.0576938204,
-0.1754346937,
0.007465939,
0.7401586175,
-0.6097055674,
0.0961920768,
0.8813186288,
-0.3438574076,
0.3013332188,
-0.5668611526,
0.15338175,
-0.8745506406,
-0.1281619519,
-0.3814695776,
-0.6589627862,
-0.3261544704,
0.2429057062,
-0.0017106486,
-0.35740453,
-0.6587616801,
0.5168731213,
-0.6982831955,
-0.2473929822,
-0.4131982923,
0.1859246194,
0.043619629,
-0.0810263008,
-0.1195009574,
1.0807780027,
0.713045001,
-0.9414566159,
0.2637368441,
0.1334386915,
-0.4337311387,
0.593812108,
-0.6118403077,
0.2918795645,
-0.1001335979,
0.3045339882,
-0.6811357737,
0.1250633448,
0.0031685731,
0.0876142979,
-0.0654624104,
-0.5136238933,
-0.2752943039,
-0.2136388272,
0.294210732,
0.2483867556,
0.6189389229,
-0.6929779649,
0.4780944884,
0.4826978445,
-0.4522435665,
-0.3298906386,
-0.4787621498,
0.1866553724,
-0.2264426798,
-0.5288225412,
0.543751061,
0.0106755616,
-0.2305910736,
0.3428697586,
0.1031599492,
0.1454814374,
0.3745191693,
0.4758632481,
-0.0040102378,
-0.2572427392,
-0.1494178623,
0.0237089153,
-0.3154487908,
-0.3663157523,
-0.6036071181,
0.7521724105,
-0.0387101322,
-0.4356810153,
-0.1437642127,
0.2453006208,
0.7217438221,
-0.1859665215,
0.9329613447,
0.3750376403,
-0.2841750085,
-0.2285301983,
-0.8966920972,
0.0425658002,
-0.5131521225,
0.3388235569,
-0.5221434236,
-1.0568450689,
0.3823061585,
-0.1137347445,
-0.0039293799,
0.3235228062,
0.3173983991,
-0.2974030375,
0.5381584167,
0.6485697031,
-0.104136847,
0.6669310331,
0.0004727204,
0.1508831084,
-0.4460849762,
0.1366680562,
-0.5122347474,
0.1462214887,
-0.380360961,
-0.712251842,
0.18481493,
0.3147957325,
-0.2046106905,
0.2943434119,
-0.453838855,
0.4201894701,
0.5430729389,
0.0329346582,
-0.0071273884,
0.3705767393,
0.09747269,
-0.0248619318,
-0.784412086,
-0.3309741616,
0.4990497828,
0.0614093952,
0.416388154,
0.2003221065,
0.4765820801,
0.676238358,
0.7069019079,
-0.4281406403,
0.667904973,
-0.5114657283,
-0.2152337432,
-0.4010165632,
-0.579623878,
-1.1127618551,
0.5077152252,
-0.21328336,
-0.2851997316,
0.0749412999,
0.2471971065,
-0.2202588469,
0.4256117642,
-0.5272482038,
0.5646053553,
-0.2130157053,
-0.5390247703,
-0.5720929503,
0.0285033062,
0.1547691077,
0.1327040941,
0.3175412118,
-0.2529020905,
0.2532998323,
0.5241873264,
-0.8072273135,
0.3657877743,
-0.6520782709,
0.1669913828,
0.2055151463,
0.0272872094,
0.7693786025,
-0.0380998254,
0.0421134979,
0.0850413218,
-0.2923290431,
-0.8271920085,
-0.3299427032,
1.1014988422,
-0.6815541387,
-0.7452402711,
-0.3975011408,
-0.1714339405,
-0.0604170226,
0.4256847501,
0.1024600714,
0.1453492641,
-0.428940624,
0.1387991607,
0.809930563,
-0.4781266451,
0.5654969811,
0.6277594566,
-0.0569765419,
-0.4264087677,
0.6165536046,
-0.091103971,
0.0958186239,
0.3927287757,
0.0118451212,
-0.3705926538,
-0.7533435225,
-0.2893660367,
0.2926808298,
-0.3265859485,
-0.0588685907,
-0.5839105248,
-0.0711788088,
-0.3615399301,
-0.4118464887,
-0.7503851056,
-0.1171417534,
-0.2549860775,
-0.0972237363,
0.2586703897,
0.2740100026,
0.077142559,
0.8862295151,
-0.6142197251,
0.2234280109,
0.4158951938,
0.2687737942,
-0.0750329345,
-0.3115501106,
-0.0054445625,
-0.2800995111,
0.0568567887,
-0.4190387726,
0.4610154629,
-0.005001816,
0.6517798305,
0.8324711323,
0.0095220469,
0.8647156954,
-0.7123690248,
0.4016600847,
0.2019601166,
-0.7296563983,
0.4290648699,
-0.2749630213,
0.0780581608,
0.5578382015,
0.138011232,
-0.4084763229,
-0.0429447442,
-0.6002032161,
-1.0392034054,
0.6417956948,
0.1592268795,
-0.0510697514,
-0.025577452,
0.5572267175,
-0.0364781283,
0.2212545425,
-0.3415521383,
-0.3516247869,
-0.0473749116,
0.1178614348,
-0.6931002736,
-0.3665455878,
-0.1763961613,
0.0288686864,
0.530856967,
0.1720332056,
0.2659835219,
-0.0172647145,
-0.3329764903,
0.3381262124,
0.2960854173,
0.6041789055,
0.5128709674,
-0.1853964478,
0.3333672881,
-0.2499729693,
-0.3529075086,
0.3383671343,
0.524498105,
-0.6814130545,
-0.2418689877,
-0.0370444283,
1.1057597399,
0.2057786882,
-0.2687868178,
0.4378606975,
-0.2182457298,
-0.0569318347,
-0.6037194133,
0.0105047431,
0.3067414761,
0.2824225724,
0.2420368791,
-0.0180015732,
-0.3021472692,
-0.2108288854,
0.0296313129,
0.4403810799,
-0.3605446517,
-0.1754102707,
0.7565193176,
0.4080235064,
-0.3488686681,
1.0366933346,
-0.0115696257,
-0.2785806358,
0.4166956842,
0.5451261401,
0.6984315515,
-0.4094244838,
0.2872111797,
-0.0142421313,
0.1845392883,
-0.4667260945,
-0.0818640813,
-0.2128349096,
-0.8711341023,
-0.5074303746,
-0.5886159539,
-0.2451580465,
0.1031858027,
-0.5853508711,
-0.0954638198,
-0.5620419979,
-0.3081873059,
-0.325847894,
-0.2132500559,
-0.6980755925,
0.089932099,
0.3358854651,
0.7854796052,
-0.9173322916,
0.8309942484,
0.7152571678,
-0.1582227051,
-0.3260704279,
-0.4679293633,
-0.3667336404,
-0.9654043913,
0.2146710902,
-0.0467997231,
-0.0082195103,
0.4461567998,
-0.5510194898,
-1.0084916353,
0.984100461,
0.5320499539,
-0.8629948497,
0.2083289921,
-0.1364852786,
0.1502479762,
0.079643935,
0.2711209655,
0.2523137629,
0.5835611224,
-0.1475495994,
-0.3586170077,
0.2646080256,
0.0742067546,
-0.0450506546,
0.3295058906,
-0.6433495283,
0.8577314615,
-0.0840535015,
-0.4089566767,
-0.1260567158,
0.5260707736,
0.6059046984,
0.1577797085,
0.8167476058,
0.7877885103,
0.7822027206,
-0.3910607994,
1.201028347,
0.0163765922,
0.3388902545,
0.7986854911,
-0.5474470854,
0.7524948716,
0.7499691844,
-0.463778466,
0.3557927608,
0.5264194608,
0.090646401,
0.738442719,
0.3244937658,
-0.4674914181,
-0.5808295012,
0.0878092796,
-0.3467214406,
-0.17857261,
0.312851429,
0.1004606262,
-0.2607375979,
0.1768418103,
0.0798967853,
0.0672473013,
-0.3562559187,
0.5675179958,
0.1584272981,
-0.7690663338,
0.3046583831,
-0.0220684651,
0.560598135,
-0.6541389227,
0.0892192125,
-0.7001452446,
0.5051102638,
0.0323781297,
-0.2752973139,
-0.1201939285,
-0.2966148257,
-0.3726620674,
-0.5748177171,
0.5927448273,
-0.1262768954,
-0.3814108074,
0.3045369685,
0.3259675205,
0.220164448,
-0.6600296497,
-0.5413118005,
0.087777786,
-0.1125616133,
-0.2119439989,
0.6370646358,
0.1942256987,
-0.1854811907,
0.8928437233,
0.8694142699,
0.5734651089,
0.1757134944,
0.3785661161,
0.6870053411,
-0.6342745423,
-0.8051147461,
-0.5743256211,
0.2399766445,
-0.0328825079,
0.3649085462,
0.6349710822,
0.3758673072,
0.4540583789,
-0.0198667552,
0.796656847,
-0.1240391433,
0.2397081256,
-0.5339583755,
0.8383541703,
-0.5829916,
0.052169688,
0.0289699435,
-1.0280436277,
-0.0194359515,
0.5980394483,
-0.3410952687,
-0.2505483031,
0.5581611395,
0.5308586955,
-0.2131165266,
-0.4302769601,
0.447319001,
0.3172807693,
0.5334409475,
0.4087781608,
0.9243064523,
-0.178582564,
0.3658752441,
-0.1331699044,
-0.3836449981,
-0.2757235765,
-0.9014802575,
-0.1217208132,
-0.2944364548,
-0.3813500702,
-0.2856346965,
0.2787140012,
0.2170924246,
1.0283970833,
-0.6951856613,
-0.0351937711,
-0.4102238715,
0.0658507347,
-0.4610477388,
-0.2541494966,
0.4893630743,
-0.2771790624,
-0.6542462707,
0.6690131426,
0.3964560926,
-0.1352280378,
0.00595687,
0.0915723667,
-0.0050885463,
-0.2037827224,
0.5907766223,
0.5768687725,
-0.4453194141,
-0.0864754468,
-0.2392141223,
-0.1081566662,
-0.0138050355,
0.9064471126,
-0.6993027329,
0.0026767515,
0.1480188817,
0.8032996058,
1.0786516666,
0.3828080297,
0.4250421226,
-0.4206909239,
0.6966653466,
0.1245001256,
0.5388149619,
0.2858837545,
-0.1813907921,
-0.0286761001,
0.437163651,
-0.5783291459,
-0.6995846033,
0.1666721553,
-0.862205267,
-0.4280274212,
0.8315297961,
-0.3967865109,
-0.1422727257,
-0.0650207549,
0.2982536554,
0.0273115151,
-0.2169609964,
0.5183160901,
0.5705052614,
0.0061579598,
-0.5146015286,
-0.39304775,
0.3570618927,
0.5806796551,
-0.9468704462,
0.0978468731,
0.5612020493,
0.458720237,
-0.163192153,
1.0090361834,
0.0093632806,
-0.1668764502,
0.0581130795,
0.4704218805,
-0.3526435792,
-0.3063054979,
-0.1788094193,
0.3776841462,
0.1224016175,
-0.4174367785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15565v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15565v3
|
Evaluating the Efficacy of Hybrid Deep Learning Models in Distinguishing AI-Generated Text
| 2023-11-27T06:26:53 | 2024-01-13T15:09:41 |
Abiodun Finbarrs Oketunji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7, I.2.7
|
My research investigates the use of cutting-edge hybrid deep learning models
to accurately differentiate between AI-generated text and human writing. I
applied a robust methodology, utilising a carefully selected dataset comprising
AI and human texts from various sources, each tagged with instructions.
Advanced natural language processing techniques facilitated the analysis of
textual features. Combining sophisticated neural networks, the custom model
enabled it to detect nuanced differences between AI and human content.
|
[
-0.1348348558,
-0.9138138294,
0.4242955744,
-0.192029953,
0.0303745177,
0.798466742,
-0.2121664584,
-0.9415788651,
-0.0366360918,
0.5786371827,
-0.3163488209,
-0.4266045392,
-0.377578795,
0.5318495035,
-0.4925590754,
0.8771906495,
-0.0167465862,
0.2115959078,
-0.3722664118,
-0.0040001892,
-0.3614598811,
-0.4806407094,
-0.6124503613,
-0.6296803355,
0.3075136244,
0.1603513509,
0.5239577293,
0.5039714575,
0.7113631368,
0.3964290917,
-0.163166523,
0.5835934281,
-0.0612055063,
-0.1744802743,
-0.0457978658,
-0.2905589938,
-0.1337632835,
0.2862345576,
0.7793887258,
0.2751245797,
0.2065327317,
-0.0352453031,
0.1145464852,
0.3851759136,
-0.5898343325,
-0.2213163078,
-0.5012463331,
0.2544757128,
-0.33188802,
-0.1085822061,
-0.5727334619,
-0.3031858802,
0.4029359818,
-0.5230153203,
0.3635689616,
-0.1045759469,
0.9271478057,
0.0491647348,
-0.3774566054,
-0.5991154313,
-1.0536453724,
0.8369113207,
-0.8928456903,
0.063465409,
0.4143922627,
0.117153652,
0.1734193712,
-0.9312797189,
-0.9089269042,
-0.5139397979,
-0.2580131888,
0.2252794057,
0.2259053439,
0.029294271,
0.1758516133,
0.7336145639,
-0.5209156275,
0.632840395,
-0.3915062547,
-0.3376003504,
1.0093306303,
0.3578435481,
0.7919380665,
-0.2152210027,
-0.2118056417,
-0.0963892117,
-0.2495840192,
0.0546676256,
0.6778873205,
0.1148253158,
-0.0889793485,
0.6166562438,
-0.0618430562,
0.6225794554,
-0.1754597574,
-0.2772863507,
0.1196519583,
-0.5180429816,
-0.3941113651,
-0.1094080955,
1.2092468739,
0.2191755027,
0.4601359665,
-0.2266874015,
-0.3285624087,
0.3184651136,
0.4198331237,
-0.3970119059,
-0.263210386,
-0.2689467072,
-0.7510139942,
-0.5277477503,
0.0764561445,
-0.5396465659,
-0.7908883691,
-0.4461568594,
0.2152996361,
-0.4211294949,
-0.3784922957,
0.0252551641,
-0.4243278801,
0.2862802148,
0.0800001249,
-0.8038743138,
0.301181674,
0.5263779163,
0.7083933949,
-0.4441896081,
-0.2596198618,
0.0370777696,
-0.0644060224,
-0.3171590269,
0.8366903067,
-0.6590490937,
-0.3139256239,
-0.0134365307,
-0.49222067,
-0.2653535604,
-0.5814326406,
0.7261632681,
-0.4663844407,
0.5159922242,
0.0007058795,
-0.8603699803,
-0.293553412,
0.1394089758,
-1.0762174129,
1.1682496071,
0.0157367904,
-0.8850295544,
0.5003033876,
-0.7204865813,
-0.8387059569,
0.3378753066,
-0.3462389112,
-0.8195265532,
-0.0146548701,
0.1470519006,
0.472512424,
-0.3140357137,
0.3839961588,
-0.1762546003,
-0.1759164184,
0.5098381042,
-0.5801776648,
0.820138514,
0.2548423111,
-0.5084032416,
0.3891645968,
-1.0026378632,
-0.1642115712,
0.2339818329,
-0.6012349725,
-0.3674776256,
0.1114946231,
0.3452082276,
0.014511425,
0.1691791266,
-0.556439817,
0.0309469011,
-0.337549746,
0.6030732393,
0.4359380305,
-0.0276331399,
0.5173841715,
-0.3679073453,
0.4009975791,
-0.2392226905,
-0.2800929844,
-0.0095259342,
-0.6600185037,
-0.6895291805,
-0.0509988703,
0.4772723615,
0.7551954985,
-0.738150835,
0.7214374542,
0.2218035758,
-0.4264602065,
-0.8530935049,
0.239720419,
0.4902831316,
0.6369399428,
0.2677446604,
-0.2259503752,
-0.5397465825,
-0.9480542541,
-0.4205436707,
-0.0430126451,
0.1771191955,
0.2598519027,
0.6379060149,
-0.3830597103,
0.8463522196,
-0.2164107114,
-0.0791295618,
-0.5996519327,
0.6488835812,
-0.5070596933,
0.619004786,
0.4948935211,
-1.0738351345,
-0.7598269582,
0.176159054,
-0.9418880939,
0.0245542787,
-0.6908454895,
-0.0820960179,
0.0850112513,
0.4615715742,
-0.5976596475,
0.8018401265,
0.086221464,
-0.2093711495,
0.6123663783,
-0.2842915654,
0.201834172,
-1.1192196608,
0.2487371713,
0.4100293517,
-0.1124806404,
-0.6700596213,
0.0127269989,
0.0042579896,
-0.0276832599,
-0.1206681579,
0.4981226623,
-0.3921586573,
0.1660339981,
-0.4319541752,
-0.237275511,
0.2975498736,
0.0103930635,
0.3778837919,
0.6931319833,
0.1288026869,
-0.366355449,
0.2178081721,
0.1551244259,
-0.4114077687,
0.3128684759,
-0.5652624965,
0.4153137207,
0.0312103126,
-0.0078150844,
-1.1559987068,
-0.3825252354,
0.3203427196,
-0.4914234877,
0.3143492341,
0.3553962111,
-0.7154970169,
-0.5190577507,
-0.1580821127,
0.2803341746,
0.3793713748,
-0.1413811147,
0.8502144217,
0.3362998962,
-0.0201252289,
-0.1546064913,
-0.6910358667,
0.2466500401,
-0.1330935359,
-0.5038024783,
0.4745852649,
-0.0825166851,
-0.4575177431,
0.0091363452,
0.5229203105,
-0.3793392181,
0.4497535527,
0.1369185746,
0.3014888763,
-0.4394721389,
-0.1084258407,
0.2379855365,
-0.0622825995,
0.1153253987,
0.0916201919,
0.4454360306,
0.149279207,
-0.0914003104,
-1.133660078,
0.6623991728,
0.6925150752,
-0.5101180673,
1.0073484182,
0.9783925414,
-0.4655553401,
-0.3174274266,
-0.4119667411,
0.0034136164,
-0.4695535004,
0.1350432187,
-0.06259913,
-0.5676324368,
0.3556676507,
0.147071898,
-0.1245440692,
0.7022804022,
0.6187471747,
-0.4038034081,
0.9799121618,
0.9291748405,
-0.1758575141,
0.5375959873,
-0.27514714,
0.2406520545,
-0.5523301363,
-0.4804909527,
-0.5330218673,
-0.5127264261,
-0.4235877693,
0.0963834599,
-0.1769332141,
-0.1907717437,
0.0804978684,
0.0281606726,
-0.8052092791,
0.5154336691,
1.0511567593,
0.2717605233,
0.1856346279,
-0.1302568316,
-0.1140353307,
-0.0188059453,
-0.2657343447,
-0.8022937179,
1.1338372231,
0.3182787299,
0.3822833598,
-0.3557473719,
0.6189057827,
0.9453600645,
0.3003669977,
-0.590747416,
0.4666970372,
-0.1573809832,
-0.598631084,
-0.0414023921,
-0.3912038207,
-0.7879340649,
-0.1204963103,
-0.7902297974,
-0.4069540203,
-0.3031900525,
-0.0183850341,
-0.5808352232,
0.6136497855,
-1.001712203,
0.7365096211,
-0.5125724077,
0.1431292593,
-0.1669862419,
-0.6083263755,
0.1257907748,
-0.0224843845,
-0.2730609775,
0.1826592237,
0.0858614594,
1.0839326382,
0.0550949201,
1.1110810041,
0.3477585614,
0.0327385142,
0.5668798685,
-0.0113010406,
0.0791545957,
-0.214202404,
-0.1465699226,
0.0713713989,
-0.5884230137,
-0.1610224098,
-0.1051168069,
0.3929999769,
-1.047437191,
-0.1541815698,
-0.2894902527,
-0.7362929583,
0.2165633291,
0.5084222555,
0.6273822784,
0.272239238,
-0.3074254692,
-0.0432992503,
0.4671894312,
-0.3641926944,
0.7632213235,
0.2545006573,
0.2498233467,
-0.5252185464,
0.9111204743,
0.0286349971,
0.1010584459,
0.5879738331,
0.301843971,
-0.350854069,
-0.9550082684,
-0.6910247803,
0.2322783768,
-0.5008820295,
-0.0043958668,
-0.5995006561,
-0.6448990703,
-0.5641032457,
-0.304664433,
-0.1307975203,
0.0339455046,
-0.8993402719,
-0.2199484408,
0.0428528041,
1.3516675234,
0.2816492319,
0.3880676031,
-0.8024067283,
0.4481103122,
0.136237368,
-0.0303219073,
0.0983956978,
-0.080341801,
-0.203836605,
-0.0283567682,
-0.4016207159,
-0.9162127376,
0.4513544738,
0.1127720401,
0.6231683493,
0.3065729737,
-0.0662170723,
0.1109487265,
-0.228957206,
0.9078404903,
0.1836859286,
-0.9667502046,
0.6066356897,
-0.3410857618,
0.1467803866,
0.4213526845,
0.5132540464,
-0.2555857301,
-0.2340733707,
-0.6564873457,
-0.5636322498,
0.3289790452,
0.2698373199,
0.0018159908,
0.3258782625,
0.5931893587,
0.372097373,
0.1415688843,
-0.9738478065,
-0.1310828626,
0.3369242847,
-0.5295706391,
-0.048392538,
-0.1872176379,
0.1470094025,
-0.2728098035,
0.2437396944,
-0.0511321872,
0.137894839,
0.0376788788,
-0.2538197637,
-0.05432868,
-0.0170856919,
0.6339347363,
0.5760164857,
0.2960352302,
-0.1350461692,
0.0141846286,
-0.5365723372,
-0.0769712478,
0.154355377,
-0.5384367704,
-0.08412835,
0.8667746186,
0.6485328078,
-0.2939471006,
-0.7247740626,
0.2636974454,
-0.196992293,
-0.2854721844,
-0.2863949537,
0.317446053,
-0.0278209429,
0.1771428436,
0.2973600626,
0.4536169469,
0.426820904,
-0.3789615631,
0.2565018535,
0.3544450402,
-0.2014762461,
-0.3593866229,
0.596149087,
0.4942318499,
-0.9102759957,
0.9253762364,
-0.0491774157,
-0.5965995789,
0.8154873252,
0.5564440489,
1.0641454458,
0.0344476178,
0.4995722473,
-0.0020311291,
0.2102015316,
0.227342099,
0.2551485598,
-0.1435816884,
-0.758931756,
-0.343747288,
-0.5135421157,
-0.3640724421,
0.3767986,
-0.7368198037,
0.1337473243,
-0.6940339804,
-0.2325567603,
0.416857928,
0.1218515486,
-0.6619651318,
0.50684762,
0.7488273978,
0.6388928294,
-1.2459163666,
0.6140589118,
0.7338782549,
-0.414483428,
-0.772639513,
0.1447845846,
0.0298381951,
-0.536653161,
0.2695066035,
0.3971181214,
-0.1306001395,
-0.0944188088,
-0.6172028184,
-0.4546685815,
0.7608652115,
-0.0671104267,
-0.2563144565,
-0.0641169101,
0.4111887515,
0.8671383262,
-0.4751602411,
0.2240935415,
0.6204404831,
0.2006354332,
-0.163541466,
-0.9818533659,
-0.3036946058,
-0.481711328,
-0.2206392884,
0.1113963202,
-0.4709689021,
0.9308785796,
-0.0106228748,
-0.291574955,
0.3453243077,
0.872060895,
-0.0784453228,
0.6572333574,
0.1624978185,
0.7286345363,
1.0651838779,
0.1616134942,
1.0289865732,
0.2388671339,
0.1011007205,
0.8959118724,
-0.4033794403,
0.7823982239,
-0.0218603779,
0.1363694966,
0.8232312799,
0.6309588552,
-0.2039212435,
0.3937921226,
-0.042932827,
-0.3615843356,
-0.104711026,
-0.1938301772,
-0.2696822286,
0.5040841699,
0.3285328746,
-0.7962445617,
0.2240471095,
0.1725529134,
-0.1777766645,
0.4968237877,
-0.2644893825,
1.2506779432,
-0.0108458204,
-0.7434042692,
-0.0382705405,
0.2261468023,
0.7439193726,
-0.2440406978,
-0.0643353164,
0.2006707191,
0.4344764948,
-0.2059929222,
-1.1107503176,
0.3084925115,
0.065757975,
-0.3820555508,
-0.2344151288,
1.1669666767,
-0.2899861038,
-0.7802695632,
0.2410027832,
0.5063402653,
-0.2321802527,
0.1267953068,
-0.9403663874,
-0.0881472006,
0.1337362975,
-0.0023635121,
0.0812422484,
0.3803774714,
0.0338582359,
0.5071078539,
0.8391461968,
0.0157131851,
0.1275850832,
0.1340401471,
0.725097537,
-0.8357571959,
-0.7421549559,
-1.1367577314,
0.6453646421,
-0.5385844111,
-0.7611472011,
0.7430359125,
0.5627928972,
0.7525368929,
-0.126698792,
1.1855754852,
-0.0358526222,
0.5535641909,
-0.4249348938,
1.0421917439,
-0.2626216114,
0.0523619391,
-0.2513025403,
-0.4725621939,
-0.4088818431,
0.5973991752,
-0.4279350042,
0.1496206373,
0.4669955373,
0.4633778334,
-0.0206353068,
0.24211438,
0.0263992939,
-0.3762506247,
0.3724142313,
0.2983798087,
1.2548600435,
-0.2366368175,
0.2040361315,
-0.3337321579,
-0.0404663906,
-0.0902393758,
-0.6802399755,
-1.3680417538,
-0.5521712303,
-0.4547050297,
-0.3637142777,
-0.3347087204,
0.5800943375,
0.7899631858,
-0.7678855062,
-0.0838451385,
-0.1819877326,
0.1026568115,
-0.1165302619,
-0.2379165441,
0.2599389851,
-0.0266881213,
-0.6007718444,
0.2895669639,
0.105763562,
0.24403961,
-0.4484875798,
-0.1709512919,
-0.3987585306,
0.1395720541,
0.3155440688,
0.1094613075,
-0.6109710932,
0.0183883682,
-0.0922346637,
-0.552981019,
0.1539494097,
1.076975584,
-0.6709719896,
0.4155983627,
0.6893520355,
0.9170795083,
0.1520069093,
-0.0346234478,
0.6276941895,
-0.5144643188,
-0.0842320099,
0.7008496523,
0.151987657,
0.6152479649,
-0.784285903,
0.2062604576,
0.5517629385,
-0.5821833611,
-0.6800064445,
0.0167407822,
-0.8129985332,
-0.3297097981,
0.9263238311,
-0.1387573779,
-0.1592991948,
-0.1753479689,
-0.4829931259,
0.3553504348,
-0.1224426404,
0.7743436098,
0.5903847218,
-0.1708360016,
-0.1851681918,
-0.1746602803,
0.4678106308,
0.1305464357,
-1.0158836842,
-0.524987638,
0.3709633946,
0.0946990326,
0.281067878,
0.3095731735,
0.2048910558,
0.3077320457,
0.1663462222,
-0.054034058,
-0.0034611684,
-0.5141400695,
-0.1053830236,
0.2673722506,
-0.285256207,
-0.2385486066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15564v1
|
Boot and Switch: Alternating Distillation for Zero-Shot Dense Retrieval
| 2023-11-27T06:22:57 | 2023-11-27T06:22:57 |
Fan Jiang, Qiongkai Xu, Tom Drummond, Trevor Cohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Neural 'dense' retrieval models are state of the art for many datasets,
however these models often exhibit limited domain transfer ability. Existing
approaches to adaptation are unwieldy, such as requiring explicit supervision,
complex model architectures, or massive external models. We present
$\texttt{ABEL}$, a simple but effective unsupervised method to enhance passage
retrieval in zero-shot settings. Our technique follows a straightforward loop:
a dense retriever learns from supervision signals provided by a reranker, and
subsequently, the reranker is updated based on feedback from the improved
retriever. By iterating this loop, the two components mutually enhance one
another's performance. Experimental results demonstrate that our unsupervised
$\texttt{ABEL}$ model outperforms both leading supervised and unsupervised
retrievers on the BEIR benchmark. Meanwhile, it exhibits strong adaptation
abilities to tasks and domains that were unseen during training. By either
fine-tuning $\texttt{ABEL}$ on labelled data or integrating it with existing
supervised dense retrievers, we achieve state-of-the-art
results.\footnote{Source code is available at
\url{https://github.com/Fantabulous-J/BootSwitch}.}
|
[
0.0419683084,
-0.637406528,
0.729872942,
0.0551858358,
-0.5364791155,
0.284832716,
-0.0466831326,
-0.3051375151,
0.1835575104,
0.211287573,
0.0219182223,
-0.3149671853,
-0.5877843499,
0.0228395462,
-0.7624881268,
1.1791411638,
0.1085238233,
0.0816062316,
0.1166062653,
-0.1225402355,
-0.5868538618,
-0.2462605983,
-0.7464739084,
-0.789488256,
0.7346683741,
0.3815453947,
0.5676461458,
0.4714266658,
0.3457561731,
0.2238713503,
-0.0603338443,
-0.2688440382,
-0.708208859,
0.4384282529,
-0.331123054,
-0.5723436475,
-0.1730162352,
-0.1932808608,
0.6497493386,
0.8877635002,
-0.3087444901,
-0.0810891911,
0.0434121415,
0.8911373615,
-0.9357367158,
-0.4106864631,
-1.1058572531,
0.1313137263,
-0.2134366184,
-0.155453667,
-0.8293364048,
0.0232238639,
0.0741103142,
-0.7694926262,
0.287974745,
0.2571101487,
0.5814849138,
0.3452266753,
-0.6576901078,
0.261649698,
-0.7539265156,
0.7189610004,
-0.2744775116,
0.4921658635,
0.2707841098,
0.2740551829,
-0.0481784455,
-1.0501523018,
-0.2587830424,
-0.2301803678,
-0.0700775981,
0.1785969436,
-0.369669944,
-0.1261756867,
0.0966951698,
0.3584895134,
-0.2620407045,
-0.0037700429,
-0.3880886734,
0.0454382524,
0.5771992803,
0.030530883,
0.0012507102,
0.2982147038,
-0.6092855334,
-0.3426200151,
-0.5642928481,
-0.2437700778,
0.1213436425,
0.2731930315,
0.1807669699,
0.351257056,
-0.4460681677,
0.7604035139,
0.4975917041,
0.5518345833,
0.4730330706,
-0.0157697443,
-0.2782620192,
0.048957251,
0.6765301824,
0.2040382475,
0.041246362,
-0.7800624371,
-0.4971379042,
-0.3499542773,
0.7328627706,
-1.0891802311,
-0.7177964449,
-0.0419920348,
-0.3501189947,
-0.3352974355,
0.0955291688,
-0.9252160788,
-0.452411592,
-0.2008113414,
0.9745557308,
-0.4365403652,
-0.2319986671,
0.3538866341,
-0.5336062908,
0.1802335978,
0.3309897184,
-0.8436915874,
0.4330729544,
0.2989235222,
1.1061331034,
-0.6871506572,
-0.2623921335,
-0.8290425539,
0.0985078663,
-0.518959105,
0.5124763846,
-0.5771723986,
-0.2006087899,
-0.1403723806,
0.2503400743,
-0.1183498204,
-0.5227999687,
0.1337235123,
-1.0272336006,
-0.4315496385,
-0.2113259882,
-0.3007191718,
-0.3546221852,
0.0820630714,
-0.5485411882,
1.1530724764,
0.2530144155,
-0.3873242736,
0.4375907481,
-0.5196805,
-0.8419328928,
0.0356907882,
0.1047523692,
-0.5447877645,
0.3974551857,
0.0997138396,
0.3550496995,
-0.0806384459,
0.0787318274,
-0.352004081,
-0.7908171415,
0.0740614384,
-0.4447998405,
0.8623192906,
0.1103754789,
-0.5274379849,
-0.2578811646,
-0.7856932878,
0.0098971641,
0.2851765752,
-0.1110676154,
-0.7578052282,
-0.1876968294,
-0.0983431265,
-0.3772996962,
0.0008057731,
-0.5685315728,
0.6046357751,
0.0594982877,
0.2106512487,
0.6498872042,
0.126113683,
0.8371037841,
-0.1917947829,
0.2786457241,
0.28820014,
0.0444185734,
-0.0257498883,
-0.2562113702,
-0.8756713867,
-0.1068383604,
0.5967813134,
0.5132781267,
-1.1252304316,
0.1535960436,
0.1312741935,
-0.67590487,
-0.6871970296,
0.0157520697,
0.3354084194,
0.5286653042,
0.8329327106,
-0.5923125148,
-0.1306293905,
-0.6747262478,
-0.0838090777,
-0.1303417087,
-0.2512080967,
0.2371431738,
0.6453158855,
-0.1508773714,
0.6313742399,
-0.9160069823,
-0.2300308347,
-0.0871224552,
0.3698745072,
0.4793975651,
0.5630970597,
0.7543061376,
-0.7899991274,
-0.6973309517,
0.1315271705,
-0.6936801672,
-0.0809079707,
-0.346570462,
-0.4982343018,
-0.3832914233,
0.381119132,
-0.3775627911,
0.5383098125,
-0.0450025909,
-0.4096861184,
0.3979338408,
-0.074009724,
0.3969565928,
-0.7706151009,
0.1814552546,
-0.3036282659,
-0.5304836035,
-0.7375839949,
0.0338007025,
0.2851395309,
0.2552402616,
-0.474667877,
0.5441209078,
-0.7831270099,
-0.1290899664,
-0.3442285657,
-0.1578364223,
0.1904612035,
0.3817857206,
0.019903928,
0.8425713181,
0.9996396899,
-0.7899360657,
0.3891201317,
0.388684243,
-0.2404777706,
0.7031490803,
-0.8795371652,
0.5306742787,
-0.1714847535,
0.0401544534,
-0.971955061,
0.0648993328,
0.148856774,
-0.1475804001,
0.6847739816,
-0.6785715818,
-0.2906044424,
-0.0583755337,
-0.3347243071,
0.6236227155,
0.6082256436,
-0.7766567469,
0.2704150975,
0.1591041833,
-0.0124808485,
-0.4889520705,
-0.6956497431,
0.0852120891,
-0.0447067805,
0.0376795605,
0.6043349504,
-0.189866811,
-0.0499068014,
-0.0463303551,
-0.3696373105,
-0.4781058133,
0.1953690201,
-0.1326991916,
0.4587862194,
-0.2363801003,
0.1641843766,
0.3763477802,
-0.0836312547,
-0.317040056,
-0.3656722307,
0.2767983377,
-0.1613573879,
-0.4375826716,
-0.1810118705,
0.1649228483,
0.470921725,
0.1336386651,
0.7187262177,
0.4877595901,
-0.0935110301,
-0.3107964694,
-0.4092338979,
-0.7016856074,
-0.5076085925,
0.2732349038,
-0.3963015974,
-0.5714982152,
0.3199903667,
-0.1615743488,
-0.0795771629,
0.1389186978,
0.3188408315,
-0.2250770628,
0.7101940513,
0.6369026899,
-0.1560432464,
0.6375806332,
-0.3150041401,
0.0404308699,
-1.0308548212,
-0.1867070645,
-0.2886794508,
-0.963653028,
-0.2221315354,
-0.3211371005,
0.5362311602,
0.3682388365,
-0.2290690392,
0.6666121483,
-0.8323287964,
0.7491288781,
0.6950865388,
0.2841802537,
0.4650153518,
0.0306456704,
-0.2260996103,
0.1107416227,
-0.7987031937,
0.2242337912,
1.3330169916,
-0.0870179906,
1.0597695112,
-0.0814237297,
0.7031806111,
0.4998273551,
0.1952190399,
-0.7227119207,
0.3674079478,
-0.1911456436,
-0.748506248,
-0.3501007557,
-0.4143077731,
-1.0790085793,
0.6205595732,
-0.2034147382,
-0.6641629934,
0.6185933352,
0.0003576023,
-0.4814851284,
0.4856507182,
-0.8034427166,
0.5041252375,
-0.2602858543,
-0.6603770256,
0.1519161463,
-0.8181285858,
0.1494340152,
-0.2531704903,
-0.4599063993,
0.0155868335,
0.0142088048,
0.485545963,
-0.0556257889,
0.761585474,
-0.2683065236,
0.3789486885,
0.1687889546,
0.386288166,
0.5472955704,
0.1616618037,
-0.3256021142,
0.4061118364,
0.030456569,
-0.3792838752,
-0.6526389718,
0.5202800632,
-0.7045451999,
-0.3920990825,
-0.526722014,
-0.5399835706,
-0.0982063785,
0.4848274887,
0.3362392187,
0.1469568759,
-0.0988155082,
0.688460052,
0.7521087527,
0.2106754333,
0.5933081508,
0.951028049,
-0.1733316928,
-0.2363170832,
0.7375279665,
0.0316657685,
0.265984565,
0.4421239793,
0.1034277976,
-0.2476181239,
-0.7268734574,
-0.8147810698,
-0.0095043229,
-0.3019355834,
-0.7175016999,
-0.5455745459,
-0.3053945899,
-0.1124714538,
-0.3384110332,
-0.5846666098,
-0.5134747028,
-0.430436641,
-0.0954905301,
0.6568510532,
0.608289361,
-0.2543676198,
0.5790227056,
-0.6364414692,
0.6488666534,
0.3446626365,
0.3962829411,
0.0435694009,
-0.9323753715,
-0.0485694893,
-0.0248455498,
-0.351677388,
-0.9565561414,
0.0916343927,
0.2813975215,
0.3075787425,
0.3346239924,
0.4889622927,
0.7205858231,
-0.757696867,
0.4571634531,
0.3470159173,
-0.7351637483,
0.4611088932,
-0.0465422049,
0.1952177733,
1.1110197306,
0.5285064578,
-0.2812228501,
-0.1232399717,
-0.2668424547,
-1.0338195562,
0.7818533778,
0.2475596517,
0.170907855,
0.0242637154,
0.5469672084,
0.3935054243,
0.3849848211,
-0.8498421907,
-0.3571284115,
-0.1657640189,
0.2976911366,
0.2925999761,
0.0499544293,
-0.0689746216,
-0.6391674876,
0.8936418891,
-0.1296399981,
0.2216377407,
0.2935822308,
-0.2578867674,
0.0145161767,
0.2273551673,
-0.1006709933,
0.4314845502,
-0.2502682805,
0.3289745748,
0.2300483733,
-0.5197649598,
0.5196304321,
0.0667737201,
-0.823484838,
0.2542760372,
0.0000467762,
0.8910759091,
0.3483259678,
-0.0535361096,
0.6637903452,
0.2436273694,
-0.2111571282,
0.0277380887,
0.1543397456,
-0.2985044718,
0.433434695,
0.6166712642,
0.1318280846,
0.5254194736,
-0.5523537993,
0.5431192517,
0.3491952121,
-0.5321100354,
-0.3794488609,
0.9538965225,
0.1501542181,
-0.2024523169,
0.9466827512,
-0.4538030326,
-0.0159554556,
0.2902560532,
0.8567110896,
1.0549649,
-0.266726166,
0.3872004449,
0.3225211799,
0.2990630865,
-0.369127214,
-0.0268605798,
-0.2174658477,
-0.7402900457,
-0.1338995397,
-0.7097218633,
-0.1973698735,
-0.0114735859,
-1.0467184782,
0.14901416,
-0.1945300549,
-0.1432815939,
-0.1425840259,
-0.3757901788,
-0.4808838665,
0.0543773547,
-0.3566800654,
0.7961437106,
-0.8593247533,
0.8661757708,
0.580606699,
-0.4669528306,
-0.2839694321,
0.210293591,
-0.1897091717,
-0.9847640991,
0.2743279338,
-0.1263018847,
-0.1187061816,
0.1912461966,
-0.4473879635,
-0.6262845993,
1.1980227232,
0.5575056672,
-0.8930465579,
-0.0487011969,
-0.2304803133,
0.3589072526,
-0.0859978274,
0.5136141181,
0.7893796563,
0.2808187306,
0.4606039226,
-0.4854644537,
-0.0033181959,
-0.1867513955,
-0.0069889873,
0.2850058079,
-0.6928238869,
0.5593568683,
-0.4116459489,
-0.0422845073,
0.1194337606,
0.4432959259,
0.1316491365,
0.5765717626,
0.7082794309,
0.5676227808,
0.7291403413,
-0.1017240137,
0.8903713822,
-0.0815084875,
0.2996917367,
1.3072539568,
-0.4704815745,
1.0306881666,
0.6292861104,
-0.1903023124,
0.5073536038,
0.2502512038,
-0.1965858638,
0.9652425647,
0.0759414509,
-0.2137417644,
-0.3388403654,
-0.0344084986,
-0.3799491227,
0.3866603673,
-0.1645724028,
-0.2788892984,
-0.1099937484,
-0.066823341,
0.0485867895,
-0.2456030995,
-0.2216774672,
0.8143668771,
0.2561642826,
-0.5770977139,
0.780238688,
-0.4002226591,
0.5269025564,
-0.5858233571,
-0.2962931097,
-0.3675330877,
0.1539468467,
-0.1759253442,
-0.8478657603,
0.1450484246,
-0.0254655331,
-0.2182518691,
-0.3944483995,
0.7726233006,
-0.4668058455,
-0.6494564414,
0.6670873165,
0.4201152027,
0.2305646539,
-0.2305156887,
-0.490645349,
-0.0752400532,
0.0948639214,
-0.3713407516,
0.4075600505,
0.5439941287,
0.2144475281,
0.4332219958,
0.6386455297,
0.0404343121,
0.2100566924,
0.3507844508,
1.137578249,
-0.5473825336,
-0.1101720855,
-0.709918797,
0.615403533,
-0.2203418016,
-0.2713238597,
0.4226031005,
0.7948399186,
0.7586674094,
-0.1949679554,
0.5753762126,
-0.1783023626,
0.2464116514,
-0.4419782162,
1.0047216415,
-0.8653598428,
0.0611411743,
-0.2102494985,
-1.0540952682,
-0.1893464178,
0.6935348511,
0.0175934434,
0.045940645,
0.7868395448,
0.6079516411,
-0.6271378398,
-0.31946069,
0.5816330314,
0.4980148375,
-0.1492495686,
0.533180058,
0.7587304115,
-0.7792055607,
0.5824996233,
-0.2385407239,
-0.3811080754,
-0.2908992469,
-0.7583559155,
-0.7540147901,
-0.3991080821,
-0.4705380797,
0.0277544837,
0.3934877515,
0.2147884667,
0.9707301855,
-0.9183175564,
-0.0965241194,
-0.1340913624,
0.1158562526,
-0.4629438519,
-0.2568401694,
0.0016843246,
-0.4575222731,
-0.7306485176,
0.8171345592,
0.4121151865,
-0.13530913,
0.3700875938,
0.157671541,
-0.2903816402,
-0.1004290655,
0.5501616597,
0.2097322196,
-0.1580670029,
-0.3794426918,
0.1459517628,
0.290258348,
0.2036813647,
0.7029070258,
-0.9414185286,
0.6121655703,
0.3837334514,
0.917255044,
1.0314971209,
-0.1239350662,
0.4039739668,
-0.846357584,
0.1048854738,
0.433743,
0.4032419622,
0.1373423785,
-0.4270945489,
0.8768581748,
0.4368188977,
-0.6689559817,
-0.8505253196,
0.124753125,
-0.9679914117,
-0.3865248263,
1.1719856262,
-0.0390832648,
0.065824315,
-0.207483992,
-0.0715880468,
0.2034506947,
-0.6430453062,
1.107727766,
0.3931058049,
-0.1042512804,
0.1041861773,
-0.5734049082,
0.009482801,
0.610994637,
-0.5411674976,
-0.0302282888,
0.3297733665,
0.4929736853,
0.0932708383,
0.7082136869,
-0.0201026965,
0.3456033468,
0.0263410583,
-0.059421394,
-0.0742532909,
-0.7824565768,
-0.3590028882,
-0.0540318266,
-0.1476675868,
-0.6448665261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15563v1
|
Noisy Self-Training with Synthetic Queries for Dense Retrieval
| 2023-11-27T06:19:50 | 2023-11-27T06:19:50 |
Fan Jiang, Tom Drummond, Trevor Cohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Although existing neural retrieval models reveal promising results when
training data is abundant and the performance keeps improving as training data
increases, collecting high-quality annotated data is prohibitively costly. To
this end, we introduce a novel noisy self-training framework combined with
synthetic queries, showing that neural retrievers can be improved in a
self-evolution manner with no reliance on any external models. Experimental
results show that our method improves consistently over existing methods on
both general-domain (e.g., MS-MARCO) and out-of-domain (i.e., BEIR) retrieval
benchmarks. Extra analysis on low-resource settings reveals that our method is
data efficient and outperforms competitive baselines, with as little as 30% of
labelled training data. Further extending the framework for reranker training
demonstrates that the proposed method is general and yields additional gains on
tasks of diverse domains.\footnote{Source code is available at
\url{https://github.com/Fantabulous-J/Self-Training-DPR}}
|
[
-0.1637385637,
-0.600274384,
0.2435350269,
0.257695049,
-0.0702823922,
0.1512988806,
-0.3924705088,
-0.546615541,
0.6864910126,
0.3853277862,
-0.5055025816,
-0.0766328499,
-0.4894256294,
0.1429534405,
-0.4903707802,
0.8054136634,
0.4225858152,
0.3112974465,
-0.1485223919,
-0.1487506479,
-0.2362262309,
-0.7110379338,
-0.6145792007,
-0.2732408345,
0.8323981166,
0.1798424423,
0.3914098144,
0.7597001195,
0.5015363097,
0.3596524298,
0.0329963304,
0.4375117123,
-0.7768853903,
0.6319517493,
-0.1634199619,
-0.2888179123,
-0.0678593293,
-0.1361150742,
0.5578033328,
0.5660560727,
-0.1563337892,
0.1138758212,
0.1365352422,
0.8103641868,
-0.8596900105,
0.0588231385,
-0.8745082617,
0.1990784407,
-0.2879622877,
-0.1768889576,
-0.3857141137,
-0.1015077978,
0.1018618345,
-0.6961241364,
0.5564513803,
-0.0369435251,
0.6076742411,
0.5620343685,
-0.156443283,
0.0399183035,
-0.59760952,
0.6695378423,
-0.1935088784,
0.6843091249,
0.4312845767,
0.5022044182,
-0.0523550026,
-1.156842351,
-0.286809057,
-0.2989775836,
0.0099870376,
0.2726713717,
-0.0386673175,
-0.1409681886,
0.2299310267,
0.546779573,
-0.4309549034,
-0.0019281637,
-0.2857368588,
-0.1503339708,
0.7801745534,
-0.0410822928,
-0.0952109173,
0.092807427,
-0.3734044135,
-0.0798693299,
-0.4354856312,
-0.2795918882,
0.4107142091,
0.4013913572,
0.318592459,
0.3077916503,
-0.6691539288,
0.6756678224,
0.3570109904,
0.358222425,
0.424621582,
-0.2231391966,
0.1485988349,
-0.1331817657,
0.8106192946,
-0.0047216732,
0.207071811,
-0.6900733113,
-0.5431451201,
-0.4323635101,
0.5278440118,
-1.0096640587,
-0.8899630308,
-0.0226248838,
-0.5039534569,
-0.3567062318,
-0.2309064716,
-0.9298501611,
-0.3008143008,
-0.3370939791,
0.7446162701,
-0.2756150961,
-0.342872411,
0.035252247,
-0.2194629014,
-0.0915782005,
0.1510000527,
-1.2575088739,
0.3448386192,
0.3498491347,
0.731172204,
-0.120070383,
-0.2383514792,
-0.5461701155,
-0.1175869107,
-0.4392631352,
0.7912897468,
-0.4365379214,
-0.2329517454,
-0.1242044866,
-0.2261859328,
-0.1035560146,
-1.0339263678,
0.2869406044,
-0.7944802046,
0.0069076912,
-0.4332620203,
-0.3608928025,
0.1957943588,
0.1789245456,
-0.8199800849,
1.2879674435,
0.06770996,
-0.446780622,
0.365411073,
-0.4687774479,
-0.3850451112,
0.0132831633,
-0.2512045503,
-0.5323925614,
0.1573264301,
0.2693125606,
0.2328438759,
-0.1008531973,
0.0648602396,
-0.5118243694,
-0.5117845535,
0.3167254329,
-0.392377913,
0.5994455218,
0.490721643,
-0.3653699756,
-0.1966814995,
-0.8131642938,
0.3362910151,
0.3185325861,
-0.380094856,
-0.3129373789,
-0.0928517729,
-0.2933383286,
0.1141179278,
0.3615730107,
-0.6765566468,
0.3593705595,
-0.3872481585,
0.4431635141,
0.4456335604,
0.0953398347,
0.4052694142,
-0.2598054707,
0.233704567,
-0.0795280263,
0.1877736747,
0.0586993173,
-0.1067763939,
-0.7255280614,
-0.4347827435,
0.6978547573,
0.0116891451,
-0.6643416882,
0.2783028185,
-0.2144373804,
-0.5107958913,
-0.7216367722,
0.3638283908,
0.353274107,
0.5228512287,
0.8859127164,
-0.1117440239,
-0.7137249708,
-0.8476820588,
-0.4221469164,
0.168765381,
0.142597571,
0.4700354934,
0.356751591,
-0.0862351507,
0.8887758851,
-0.5810832381,
-0.4227100313,
-0.0645643473,
0.2644656897,
-0.0011704694,
0.7504956722,
0.5411800146,
-0.8098774552,
-0.5616214275,
-0.4194714427,
-0.7723833919,
-0.0799614266,
-0.1411871612,
-0.3418617845,
-0.1514543146,
0.6110596061,
-0.5645902753,
0.2209853083,
0.1711186022,
0.330171138,
0.5122057796,
-0.1437319666,
-0.0877078995,
-0.6990089417,
0.1232711002,
-0.1548865288,
-0.1326868534,
-0.3648463488,
-0.0513718948,
0.1676428169,
-0.0757838711,
-0.0786804184,
0.4998221993,
-0.6813322902,
0.0253722426,
-0.3753593266,
-0.1427767873,
0.0338844955,
0.4608031809,
0.0678747371,
1.0230867863,
0.5350548625,
-0.5755764842,
0.198528409,
0.2524438202,
-0.027631443,
0.2826771736,
-0.7403523326,
0.2064498812,
-0.1054220051,
0.1504492015,
-0.9321681261,
-0.2822472453,
0.2263619453,
-0.5052131414,
0.6381109953,
-0.479499191,
-0.3867602944,
-0.2932208776,
-0.1612156183,
0.5354875326,
0.4649399519,
-1.1637444496,
0.4016524255,
0.3759008646,
0.2434424162,
-0.7706741691,
-0.7259846926,
-0.0372259952,
-0.1420837641,
-0.2644940913,
0.5772486329,
-0.1134000942,
0.1928896606,
-0.1659014821,
-0.3919408619,
-0.5989125371,
0.1553047448,
-0.0157038998,
-0.1601580232,
-0.1168872043,
0.369261384,
-0.0629862174,
-0.1143423617,
0.3464419544,
-0.4055155814,
0.4293487668,
0.0408145338,
-0.2690923512,
-0.3533461988,
0.1373363286,
-0.0478906147,
-0.4723039865,
0.504350543,
0.7342668176,
-0.2927022874,
-0.5761475563,
-0.7423784137,
-0.6621308327,
-0.5666204095,
0.4055445492,
-0.4493126571,
-0.6718958616,
0.3720031679,
-0.1634243429,
-0.2599646747,
0.3752658367,
0.3587870002,
-0.2683104575,
1.1457161903,
0.3143049181,
0.0293823052,
0.7715057731,
-0.6232016683,
-0.140421927,
-0.7701271772,
-0.457898736,
-0.3865449429,
-0.5916776657,
-0.6876189709,
-0.1910687834,
0.1608892977,
0.0166282412,
-0.2915681899,
0.2311343849,
-0.8782129884,
0.6663811207,
0.7208486199,
0.429136008,
0.1686310023,
0.2798295617,
-0.0402295589,
-0.4055405557,
-0.9396034479,
0.2249376327,
1.2338155508,
-0.006206315,
0.9995906949,
0.0143356258,
1.281301856,
0.1733280122,
0.3545716703,
-0.648696959,
0.3023927808,
-0.1003401577,
-0.9095034599,
-0.1933334023,
-0.7658821344,
-1.2883682251,
0.5539606214,
-0.2749657929,
-0.4764840305,
0.5791727304,
0.318898797,
-0.4624840021,
0.1353934854,
-0.5709664822,
0.7632207274,
-0.5601093769,
-0.6892387271,
-0.1373919696,
-0.6300344467,
0.1515309513,
-0.2390528619,
-0.4723645747,
-0.1017700136,
-0.0744044557,
0.6899298429,
-0.3850973547,
0.7777540088,
-0.3994695842,
0.4285872281,
0.4715259075,
0.1187575012,
0.2601051033,
0.1195172593,
-0.3218140304,
0.2637600005,
-0.216405645,
-0.482683301,
-0.9648359418,
0.7744460106,
-0.8743097782,
-0.4109816253,
-0.5609958768,
-0.3963353932,
-0.1899422556,
0.4057938755,
0.3134528995,
0.3907558918,
0.016718965,
0.5155716538,
0.7083957195,
0.2142247111,
0.2784977257,
0.4514214396,
0.0758326277,
-0.7186021805,
1.1999174356,
0.4882073104,
0.0008295426,
0.2309379727,
0.1113640293,
-0.7087393403,
-0.7189145684,
-0.169773981,
0.2692086101,
-0.4529557824,
-0.5470883846,
-0.6906579137,
-0.4283638597,
-0.275375098,
0.2665528357,
-0.8124770522,
-0.5594003201,
-0.3335643411,
0.113372907,
0.0643037781,
0.6084386706,
-0.445677191,
0.3420072794,
-0.4567778409,
0.2749388218,
0.3701213896,
0.4915902913,
0.0439643934,
-0.7209334373,
-0.458576262,
0.1188122928,
-0.4201707244,
-0.6067200303,
0.6492525935,
0.4442784488,
0.7845420241,
0.0535997413,
0.3439904749,
0.9424383044,
-0.3363104463,
0.3994591832,
-0.0898275077,
-0.3845657408,
0.5178234577,
-0.2715839148,
-0.1596980095,
0.9898825884,
0.5764589906,
0.1246509627,
0.1405302435,
-0.7318356037,
-0.9238824844,
0.4844540656,
0.0936210379,
0.3044869006,
-0.2368659824,
0.8837845922,
-0.1236606166,
0.2504749894,
-0.780807972,
-0.3556035459,
-0.5160524845,
-0.1267880797,
0.2642812133,
-0.2885532379,
-0.1950505525,
-0.5210882425,
0.6296694279,
-0.276306808,
0.5277525187,
0.5759443641,
-0.2500791252,
-0.0135298166,
-0.2748903632,
-0.0354121141,
0.2437490672,
-0.3269205391,
0.1432395875,
0.1854245067,
-0.3587240577,
0.1393368095,
0.3644192517,
-0.1459692717,
-0.0500204936,
-0.0398689322,
0.1896372586,
0.3431629837,
-0.3441830277,
0.4659248888,
-0.1037128195,
-0.3677467704,
-0.4970898628,
0.2642154992,
-0.1515126973,
0.4058762789,
0.4714972973,
0.1903692037,
0.5698042512,
0.0201162826,
0.5252982378,
0.5422893763,
-0.4283282161,
-0.2523046434,
0.9125083089,
0.1165652052,
-0.065571107,
0.9410206079,
-0.3382266164,
-0.2367983758,
0.3008159697,
0.8593482375,
0.8816310763,
0.0220999122,
0.0647006258,
0.5630850196,
0.0348361135,
-0.2987413406,
0.3665062487,
-0.3800480962,
-0.5373353362,
-0.3879047632,
-0.5702884197,
-0.3224739432,
0.2153027058,
-0.7160289288,
-0.1131346077,
-0.6084931493,
-0.3537313342,
0.075664863,
0.2110698521,
-0.4196372032,
0.2247690707,
-0.0621420331,
0.727409482,
-0.2414061874,
0.7989162803,
0.5043172836,
-0.5914326906,
-0.5894064307,
0.0494208708,
-0.2725786269,
-0.8387294412,
1.0056542158,
0.2139611542,
-0.1249448732,
0.2787445188,
-0.587264359,
-1.2044154406,
0.9901322722,
0.4789262116,
-0.5698716044,
0.1555574983,
-0.012815576,
0.7222020626,
-0.2178522497,
0.3166182339,
0.2538309097,
0.1690400094,
0.0592967682,
-0.412561208,
-0.0396988168,
-0.3797975481,
-0.1802912056,
0.0026024054,
-1.0089612007,
0.6713921428,
-0.1851707399,
-0.039504379,
0.2945239544,
0.9566794038,
0.0718271583,
0.3299971223,
0.3322620392,
0.5898653865,
0.7606061101,
-0.2157859057,
0.9321144819,
-0.6096663475,
0.4085517228,
1.3387249708,
-0.028657835,
0.8251814246,
0.2111167908,
0.0365470052,
0.3208758831,
0.6691163778,
-0.2374557108,
0.6707795262,
0.3299798965,
-0.1586736739,
-0.6062940955,
-0.0383277088,
-0.4874294102,
0.5865141749,
0.0445466563,
-0.4373142421,
-0.2467882484,
-0.404425174,
-0.3415727317,
0.1032795087,
0.1249059588,
0.7469210029,
0.0512768887,
-0.5457487106,
0.9298296571,
-0.4953330755,
0.7099562883,
-0.5730740428,
0.023407178,
-0.4086005092,
0.364426434,
-0.2375077605,
-0.3511811495,
0.3000600338,
-0.3879117072,
-0.0853714868,
-0.2428610772,
0.7940074205,
-0.4666528702,
-0.1698480099,
0.3735541701,
0.8056647778,
0.1534683853,
-0.4790264964,
-1.0449672937,
-0.1832775027,
-0.1653455049,
-0.3484115303,
0.6494880915,
0.5017274022,
0.3095908761,
0.8302114606,
0.8314474821,
-0.0620077327,
0.2606766224,
0.255055517,
1.0634479523,
-0.6929733753,
-0.2118393183,
-0.5524413586,
0.0821140036,
-0.409673661,
-0.4138895869,
0.7505167723,
0.8432655931,
0.9627544284,
-0.0104157235,
0.5169579387,
0.2005692273,
0.5478118658,
-0.2763487101,
0.8847563267,
-0.740778923,
0.24314785,
0.1757456362,
-0.899956286,
-0.2683987319,
0.9589211345,
-0.2701838315,
0.4778879285,
0.3054212928,
0.9681931138,
-0.1777922958,
-0.1010660455,
0.2717865407,
0.17617549,
0.1649760306,
-0.0135517111,
1.1179888248,
-0.5238952637,
0.6796547771,
-0.746661067,
0.1087548882,
-0.3000660241,
-0.3868062794,
-0.7501206398,
-0.3510017991,
-0.3382362127,
-0.3623808324,
0.3975824416,
0.8790909052,
1.1332017183,
-0.6065072417,
-0.0964936018,
0.0012831504,
-0.219077006,
-0.3359500468,
-0.2630975544,
0.1334202141,
-1.0286326408,
-0.6343864202,
0.794876039,
-0.242846936,
0.1230232343,
-0.1897370815,
-0.0135991368,
-0.1955062598,
-0.1588385552,
0.4010066092,
0.5131704807,
-0.2588384151,
-0.1250891685,
0.2068918198,
-0.1363513619,
0.2433454096,
0.6366692781,
-1.091884017,
0.6077210307,
0.3190886676,
0.8561355472,
0.9968814254,
0.2946248949,
0.2342110723,
-1.0117214918,
-0.1432508677,
0.413102001,
0.2873317003,
0.2715778351,
-0.5327342153,
0.8204088807,
0.4372790754,
-0.8602659106,
-0.8016962409,
0.0185792986,
-0.8050948381,
-0.1272788495,
0.9096344113,
0.0665683523,
-0.1850988418,
-0.1177990288,
0.0277034231,
0.1986089498,
-0.5609875917,
1.3050773144,
0.023454519,
-0.5081494451,
0.1518493146,
-0.4644883573,
0.7125060558,
0.7572718859,
-0.4583331645,
0.1360017657,
0.4744752944,
0.5474414825,
0.2118679881,
0.6950776577,
-0.0687943324,
0.1511552334,
0.2452349663,
0.0346035175,
-0.3309218884,
-0.5708937049,
-0.3060319126,
0.1292445362,
0.0224422719,
-0.3109461069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15548v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15548v1
|
Deficiency of Large Language Models in Finance: An Empirical Examination of Hallucination
| 2023-11-27T05:27:13 | 2023-11-27T05:27:13 |
Haoqiang Kang, Xiao-Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-fin.ST
|
The hallucination issue is recognized as a fundamental deficiency of large
language models (LLMs), especially when applied to fields such as finance,
education, and law. Despite the growing concerns, there has been a lack of
empirical investigation. In this paper, we provide an empirical examination of
LLMs' hallucination behaviors in financial tasks. First, we empirically
investigate LLM model's ability of explaining financial concepts and
terminologies. Second, we assess LLM models' capacity of querying historical
stock prices. Third, to alleviate the hallucination issue, we evaluate the
efficacy of four practical methods, including few-shot learning, Decoding by
Contrasting Layers (DoLa), the Retrieval Augmentation Generation (RAG) method
and the prompt-based tool learning method for a function to generate a query
command. Finally, our major finding is that off-the-shelf LLMs experience
serious hallucination behaviors in financial tasks. Therefore, there is an
urgent need to call for research efforts in mitigating LLMs' hallucination.
|
[
-0.0691927448,
-1.1047273874,
0.6699956059,
0.1758790463,
-0.0578019619,
0.2109317482,
-0.1385617554,
-0.4900838435,
0.3434101045,
0.6915236712,
-0.4773019254,
-0.4975006282,
-0.4753861129,
-0.0219552778,
-0.5064831972,
0.8314737082,
0.005118147,
0.2358617336,
-0.1328510046,
0.2467229962,
-0.43517977,
-0.6337124705,
-0.9099333882,
-0.3609091341,
0.3192079961,
0.1855137348,
0.5000314116,
0.3025969863,
0.635502696,
0.280697614,
-0.0522200391,
-0.0076498822,
-0.8078645468,
0.0976707041,
0.2275716364,
-0.5480694771,
-0.4387796819,
-0.1050118357,
0.4186828434,
0.9668176174,
-0.3021471798,
0.0172154661,
0.1844392866,
0.9996560812,
-0.6783030033,
0.3630339801,
-0.7239534259,
0.0483397208,
-0.0960691869,
-0.413184315,
-0.4103132784,
-0.1760459244,
0.2490512878,
-0.5421203971,
0.2238242477,
0.27675879,
0.7410237789,
0.3373327851,
-0.3951563239,
-0.7045481205,
-0.8016755581,
0.8005992174,
-0.5660644174,
0.3424585164,
0.8299041986,
0.1108267754,
-0.2015939504,
-0.4978452027,
-0.3327759802,
-0.5875537992,
-0.0371764898,
-0.059179455,
-0.179736197,
-0.1124172434,
0.3606782258,
0.3987707794,
-0.4171569645,
0.2167567313,
-0.5917909741,
-0.1535745859,
0.4729982913,
0.2743112445,
-0.1572060287,
-0.2611075938,
-0.3413650692,
-0.2845806181,
-0.7134979367,
-0.1515675485,
0.5336841941,
0.3448004425,
0.0156119587,
0.6183119416,
0.1276374608,
0.445928365,
-0.3074913919,
-0.2351073623,
0.0849251077,
-0.1086831912,
-0.5144602656,
0.2950660288,
0.3382981122,
0.1060386151,
0.2690399289,
-0.2243409455,
-0.557872355,
-0.2568350434,
0.3803266287,
-0.4000708461,
0.0051401099,
0.3286322951,
-0.5494810343,
-0.1909770221,
-0.0243783649,
-0.770096004,
-0.5418932438,
-0.2743255794,
0.5748913288,
-0.2921133339,
-0.0897603035,
0.2633053064,
-0.3153063655,
0.461280793,
0.0001360255,
-0.9723822474,
0.4869700372,
0.8594384193,
0.7472214699,
-0.0201651249,
-0.3280413747,
-0.3978049755,
0.1612658948,
-0.4294982851,
0.6763964295,
-0.4157462716,
-0.6489132047,
-0.0350332819,
-0.2286285758,
-0.2605706751,
-0.8298311234,
0.1409347206,
-0.3891784251,
-0.0816558227,
-0.433124125,
-0.6181514263,
-0.2734350562,
0.1561471671,
-0.5005294681,
0.7440395355,
-0.0403828435,
-0.452067256,
0.298191905,
-0.7070579529,
-0.3033504188,
0.0710048154,
-0.452634871,
-0.3074516356,
0.2860035598,
-0.0601789393,
0.574184835,
-0.4690761864,
0.4053320289,
-0.3700542748,
-0.721380949,
0.6602973342,
-0.4413889349,
0.4231905639,
0.0417064354,
-0.4486734271,
-0.1343727261,
-0.7165993452,
-0.6902953982,
0.517368257,
0.3080209196,
-0.6600157619,
0.123083353,
-0.0034581842,
-0.3363110125,
0.2931447029,
0.0087508298,
0.126252085,
-0.640991509,
0.3237330019,
0.8942361474,
-0.0430873185,
0.2024277896,
-0.4413553774,
0.4081170857,
-0.1220561042,
-0.2097180188,
-0.044886969,
0.0250072572,
-0.6299391389,
-0.1549234092,
-0.0258726403,
0.4662588239,
-0.220765546,
0.0365030877,
0.1091513261,
-0.1665235311,
-0.1698192507,
0.0570326187,
0.0922600105,
0.4889953136,
0.077452831,
0.1009932831,
-0.4604560435,
-1.1178846359,
-0.1662689298,
-0.1850881279,
0.0047431956,
0.4052338302,
0.8145843744,
-0.1611459851,
0.3784528971,
-0.6595010757,
-0.3879926205,
-0.1143966839,
0.2882921398,
0.2698236704,
0.2086554617,
0.6235902309,
-0.6229011416,
0.1463499665,
-0.0439020321,
-0.7092200518,
0.2822710872,
-0.445703119,
0.2516991496,
0.5081430078,
0.6205601096,
-0.4929318726,
0.5592698455,
0.2107273936,
-0.3691637218,
0.5613107681,
-0.2411574721,
-0.0639721677,
-0.6567777991,
0.0737770572,
0.1609398872,
0.1375840455,
-0.4010117054,
-0.1123917326,
-0.2064863592,
0.0642469451,
0.0074127866,
0.6399766803,
-0.4730191827,
-0.4670756459,
-0.5864258409,
0.3626715243,
-0.2766531408,
0.3898798227,
-0.0648658574,
0.8188120723,
0.6589409709,
-0.6580916643,
0.2618611157,
-0.0479532927,
-0.3522500694,
0.2275606841,
-0.5617570877,
-0.0293560158,
-0.2204455584,
-0.0830384791,
-1.194149375,
-0.3514795303,
0.3350488842,
-0.0202968456,
0.1692013741,
0.260165453,
-0.2779702842,
-0.2784109712,
-0.2945515513,
0.12960051,
0.3779718578,
-0.4610978067,
0.4165021479,
0.1821607053,
-0.4174128771,
-0.6283011436,
-0.5753497481,
0.1699380875,
-0.479914248,
-0.4117010236,
0.2124902159,
0.0958344936,
-0.8795708418,
-0.2753856182,
-0.4298343658,
0.152623564,
0.3695243299,
0.1468494385,
0.6785032749,
-0.286890775,
0.2631865442,
-0.2370418757,
0.0448023602,
0.4424478412,
-0.0517007895,
0.6369048953,
-0.061190147,
-0.4568449259,
-0.0688925683,
0.0701852366,
0.4002652764,
0.3111272454,
0.8890282512,
0.1275909096,
-0.3662699163,
-0.3085760474,
-0.8140813112,
-0.3975627124,
-0.4455311,
0.4079264402,
-0.3467223346,
-0.9740413427,
0.7811475992,
0.0040151621,
-0.1822258681,
0.624877274,
0.6073490977,
0.1169541478,
0.5146060586,
0.5948601365,
0.1231653616,
0.1995694786,
-0.3332880735,
0.3995343447,
-0.4585028589,
-0.4859147668,
-0.5492214561,
-0.382484585,
-0.4194099009,
-0.1247249618,
0.2692640126,
0.0630371198,
-0.1680652052,
-0.1285210997,
-0.1606711149,
0.536852777,
0.2558909953,
0.0103913173,
0.2467728704,
0.1562116444,
-0.0051575811,
-0.0382613465,
-0.3436211646,
-0.5724454522,
1.1928446293,
0.4673990607,
0.9116335511,
-0.0509400927,
0.699596107,
0.3251623809,
-0.0647367239,
-0.9877665043,
0.4292345941,
-0.0281127635,
-0.4087927639,
-0.4768486917,
-0.6389375329,
-0.8112052679,
0.148066476,
-0.0418386124,
-1.0166225433,
0.3588413298,
-0.0430299863,
-0.447728157,
-0.0164056309,
-0.4984084964,
0.8677296042,
-0.4218412638,
-0.3908988833,
-0.2539747059,
-0.2081816643,
0.8885707855,
-0.5958940983,
0.3376328051,
-0.0792508572,
-0.0175737049,
0.7820549607,
-0.2986775041,
1.0110359192,
0.034742564,
-0.437497586,
-0.0646695495,
0.0148581937,
0.8188749552,
0.0771778449,
-0.1026074588,
0.0128580015,
-0.0137607269,
-0.3810934424,
-0.5299146175,
0.7754390836,
-0.4977005124,
-0.8401743174,
-0.4829476774,
-0.6474331617,
-0.2200198323,
-0.2708145082,
0.0519119278,
0.1853095889,
-0.4240831733,
0.2825071812,
0.4773516357,
-0.2240224183,
0.5414282084,
0.2442087978,
-0.4857232273,
-0.0604007207,
0.8773679733,
0.2381639928,
-0.054076042,
-0.0326611511,
0.2046590745,
-0.3060356975,
-0.558475852,
0.0869704336,
0.4930097461,
-0.5784370899,
0.0283491332,
-0.5587358475,
-0.2408300191,
-0.6887151599,
-0.1453394145,
-0.3241816759,
-0.2789058983,
-0.5600081086,
-0.2276716232,
0.5788689256,
0.9795081615,
0.0441793464,
0.2240682095,
-0.5893186927,
0.5542610288,
0.0948696211,
0.2391310036,
0.4603014886,
-0.7167431712,
-0.2493931353,
-0.0680019334,
-0.2062577158,
-0.7697048187,
0.5762009621,
-0.1561072618,
0.6322731376,
0.7277161479,
0.13102597,
0.9136108756,
-0.0299596004,
0.5533643365,
0.074417755,
-0.8829672933,
0.1494633406,
-0.1108838841,
-0.0908729434,
0.2356390208,
0.5949371457,
-0.3775444329,
-0.4588335156,
-0.4219686687,
-1.0462372303,
0.6294679046,
0.1246244907,
0.2512677312,
-0.1517387033,
0.5760141015,
0.3756860495,
0.3060503602,
-0.6424542069,
-0.2074985057,
0.0257863104,
0.1652072072,
-0.103808105,
-0.5221911669,
0.010933673,
-0.2680324614,
0.5886748433,
0.0232514273,
-0.0843460038,
0.1958524734,
-0.028366752,
-0.0958839878,
0.1191689074,
0.8529149294,
1.1619642973,
-0.3453136384,
0.0843245834,
0.1888166368,
-0.2605446577,
-0.0811655074,
0.1565113962,
0.0987140834,
-0.1043622941,
0.2705392241,
1.0580329895,
0.4966008663,
-1.0310827494,
0.3336881697,
0.184461534,
-0.4459796846,
-0.7766869068,
-0.018436376,
0.1276883632,
0.4302521348,
0.8675692677,
-0.1876341254,
0.2709422708,
-0.8487362862,
0.0519768223,
0.5899350643,
-0.1029925197,
-0.0714553446,
0.662758112,
-0.2362953424,
-0.2042797208,
0.6878344417,
-0.0631349683,
-0.3501259089,
0.6730044484,
0.6959406734,
0.9569716454,
0.1596134156,
0.1723377407,
0.1217710748,
0.4177904129,
-0.47229141,
0.3158647716,
0.0631465986,
-0.5298419595,
-0.4848131835,
-0.830542326,
-0.4661004841,
0.424772203,
-0.6804897189,
0.1761905104,
-0.3824687302,
-0.104922846,
-0.0314487293,
-0.2046274692,
-0.5244438648,
-0.1952447742,
0.1352320611,
0.6310398579,
-0.5817796588,
0.4507458806,
0.3774080873,
-0.4503261149,
-0.3716329038,
0.1849273294,
0.1298790127,
-0.9570286274,
1.096293211,
0.0531346984,
-0.0989142507,
-0.1616670936,
-0.5892807841,
-0.6470919847,
0.7801659107,
0.2252526283,
-0.815587759,
-0.2755935192,
0.246114552,
0.3852775395,
-0.4720889926,
-0.1945899129,
0.7399186492,
0.6259016991,
0.4651594758,
-0.6419532895,
-0.0127542624,
0.0561820827,
-0.147065267,
0.1572434604,
-0.572820425,
0.7998814583,
-0.3184296489,
0.0731131434,
0.1077674478,
0.5271472931,
0.4591597915,
0.7381210923,
0.2639864087,
0.2592801452,
0.9206939936,
0.0487733744,
1.0837949514,
-0.2723242342,
0.3168892264,
0.8440529704,
-0.6727482677,
0.9684308767,
0.7453231215,
-0.1363579482,
0.0006377871,
0.6182569265,
-0.2801721394,
0.1402835697,
0.5187715888,
-0.1250251383,
-0.3226902187,
0.0630172342,
-0.2441255897,
0.6228013635,
0.4490936399,
-0.475223124,
0.0711000562,
0.245335117,
-0.1009903625,
-0.0408436358,
-0.2393337041,
0.6899572611,
0.4392906725,
-0.2678053677,
0.4863786101,
-0.0848387852,
0.5034868121,
-0.6098880172,
0.0021746098,
-0.5195606351,
-0.0455970429,
0.1193746477,
-0.2177158147,
0.58548522,
0.1160726175,
0.0505665913,
-0.1218289658,
0.6332246065,
-0.0815725625,
-0.6102548242,
0.3757932484,
0.5859501362,
0.5558696985,
-0.1995289028,
-0.3544664383,
0.1740543544,
-0.0693830401,
-0.4407594502,
0.378347367,
0.4912330508,
0.0876516551,
0.6209396124,
0.6637513041,
0.1303755641,
-0.2043055743,
0.1102440506,
0.5702539086,
-1.2841112614,
-0.1585728824,
-1.1744533777,
-0.0871847123,
0.0673867464,
-0.1385707706,
0.8316645026,
0.7277380824,
0.8147494197,
-0.2462926656,
0.459592104,
0.5172389746,
0.1821921617,
-0.9275109172,
0.8330348134,
-0.8792546391,
0.7565358877,
-0.1641483456,
-1.1443715096,
-0.2772226036,
0.6879571676,
-0.5277804732,
0.1386341304,
0.809994638,
0.7954887152,
0.0140519319,
0.1746292412,
0.69817698,
0.5064980388,
-0.4184505045,
0.0312194861,
0.8853597641,
-0.1461108923,
0.5335440636,
-0.2296865582,
0.2257983685,
-0.6278244853,
-0.6617242098,
-0.9018918872,
-0.4084744453,
-0.4058760703,
-0.2693839967,
0.1099635065,
0.9170206189,
-0.0843082219,
-0.6238837242,
-0.7747898102,
0.1801274121,
0.2251218706,
-0.0775575787,
-0.2331914604,
0.4840902686,
-0.590793848,
-0.7082624435,
0.4896700978,
0.5825431347,
0.2839229107,
-0.4790804982,
0.0518194214,
0.1553603113,
0.2071423531,
0.5807033181,
0.0992928296,
-0.8508760333,
0.0101858964,
0.321436137,
-0.1205621511,
0.050848823,
0.9491879344,
-0.3863577247,
-0.0599351041,
0.2720882297,
0.595990777,
0.444093436,
-0.1183981672,
0.4128383994,
-0.3333106339,
0.1779618859,
0.0534632765,
0.5077829361,
-0.0594235137,
-0.389082253,
0.4165021181,
0.3519778848,
-0.462824285,
-0.9429216385,
-0.2193902433,
-0.8573974967,
-0.740913868,
0.8851037025,
0.3576747775,
-0.5665796399,
-0.0205347687,
-0.1758188605,
-0.0731990859,
-0.3287012279,
1.1616457701,
0.9513421655,
0.0282686949,
-0.156235829,
-0.893433392,
0.2726718187,
0.5269396305,
-0.4478259087,
0.4671567082,
0.6560015082,
-0.1265897751,
-0.1186886802,
0.5155677199,
0.0832260847,
0.115370363,
0.2895891666,
-0.0264297444,
0.060670685,
-0.1851587147,
-0.3311414719,
0.2263768315,
0.1043828428,
0.2081993967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15544v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15544v2
|
The effect of source disclosure on evaluation of AI-generated messages: A two-part study
| 2023-11-27T05:20:47 | 2023-11-28T02:04:58 |
Sue Lim, Ralf Schmälzle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) over the last decade demonstrate
that machines can exhibit communicative behavior and influence how humans
think, feel, and behave. In fact, the recent development of ChatGPT has shown
that large language models (LLMs) can be leveraged to generate high-quality
communication content at scale and across domains, suggesting that they will be
increasingly used in practice. However, many questions remain about how knowing
the source of the messages influences recipients' evaluation of and preference
for AI-generated messages compared to human-generated messages. This paper
investigated this topic in the context of vaping prevention messaging. In Study
1, which was pre-registered, we examined the influence of source disclosure on
people's evaluation of AI-generated health prevention messages compared to
human-generated messages. We found that source disclosure (i.e., labeling the
source of a message as AI vs. human) significantly impacted the evaluation of
the messages but did not significantly alter message rankings. In a follow-up
study (Study 2), we examined how the influence of source disclosure may vary by
the participants' negative attitudes towards AI. We found a significant
moderating effect of negative attitudes towards AI on message evaluation, but
not for message selection. However, for those with moderate levels of negative
attitudes towards AI, source disclosure decreased the preference for
AI-generated messages. Overall, the results of this series of studies showed a
slight bias against AI-generated messages once the source was disclosed, adding
to the emerging area of study that lies at the intersection of AI and
communication.
|
[
-0.0393534116,
-0.6697189212,
0.6819983125,
0.0956625566,
-0.1476998478,
-0.2193208635,
-0.2623564899,
-0.8185843229,
0.2383689731,
0.400077939,
-0.2316406369,
-0.3588660359,
-1.0194841623,
-0.0539741628,
-0.538559854,
1.0966979265,
0.3073157668,
-0.0421938561,
-0.3467073143,
0.1161719039,
-0.7731072307,
-0.8610693216,
-0.606159091,
-0.7113981247,
0.7272997499,
0.3730637729,
0.4954124391,
0.5015125275,
0.4247304201,
0.2800799608,
-0.2066428065,
-0.3541419506,
-0.6138222814,
0.1502187997,
-0.2858474553,
-0.7998356819,
0.0797644332,
0.430141449,
0.4118911326,
0.1849709749,
-0.2283271253,
0.2793172598,
0.2130974531,
0.7842074037,
-0.8693434,
0.1057418808,
-0.5469267368,
-0.1222379357,
-0.206492126,
-0.4841409922,
-0.6505973935,
0.0245108139,
0.2929628491,
-0.4938948452,
-0.0362305753,
-0.0994640663,
0.8308401704,
0.379457742,
-0.5802271366,
-0.5702262521,
-1.1281391382,
0.4790500998,
-0.5013731718,
0.1421973258,
0.5607152581,
0.1548670232,
-0.0360683165,
-0.4242191911,
-0.4766449928,
-0.417519331,
-0.2434496582,
0.1644982398,
-0.5437214375,
0.2171201557,
0.0852588713,
0.05274266,
-0.203232497,
0.1714032739,
-0.4034236372,
-0.152782321,
0.8306819797,
-0.071363166,
0.4913296998,
-0.3748653233,
-0.1937776059,
-0.1626560092,
-0.810523808,
0.00401907,
0.2024186552,
-0.1195035502,
-0.2029554844,
0.6973798871,
0.0070541208,
0.3635104597,
0.0402085036,
0.045578327,
0.1387289912,
-0.6976839304,
-0.3969469368,
0.2740007937,
0.9673128724,
0.1305513829,
0.0465776026,
0.2521392703,
0.2318733335,
0.0264487565,
0.4201964736,
-0.7511464357,
-0.0704258084,
0.0700458661,
-0.8430517912,
-0.4245783985,
0.4808812737,
-0.1821950078,
-0.5416426063,
-0.1892783791,
0.5844488144,
-0.1468561888,
-0.0658569857,
-0.1196181774,
-0.4505509734,
0.0006078889,
0.3588835895,
-0.706817925,
-0.0132061141,
0.7627652287,
0.69116956,
0.1943820119,
-0.0309472661,
-0.6038544774,
0.2414564639,
-0.3703021705,
0.8035213947,
-0.5941664577,
-0.5993887782,
-0.2683459222,
-0.24700436,
0.1117481589,
-0.6269522905,
0.4674905241,
-0.3538185358,
0.4400427341,
-0.1869429946,
-0.403519541,
-0.0962642357,
-0.0337073021,
-0.3599422574,
0.331141144,
-0.1339554191,
-0.7536482215,
0.3626207113,
-0.554015696,
-0.4668115079,
0.1510781348,
-0.4925946295,
-0.4010791183,
0.1293509007,
0.0992570519,
0.0948728248,
-0.0971241519,
0.3312230408,
0.0132116554,
-0.4765488207,
0.6565848589,
-1.0114548206,
0.9091519713,
0.2420497686,
-0.7136436701,
0.35796839,
-0.1989834607,
-0.2954106033,
-0.0374406241,
-0.2931838334,
-0.6057031751,
0.0068564457,
-0.3966211081,
0.2427326292,
-0.0548650995,
-0.3962269127,
-0.1395907849,
-0.4439826906,
0.4152894616,
0.9409966469,
0.5017949939,
0.1185155138,
-0.4248377085,
0.5466013551,
0.0484444015,
0.4264103472,
-0.3886304498,
-0.7048076391,
-0.6393895149,
0.1210303605,
0.0885122344,
0.4372132421,
-0.5113441944,
0.4385487437,
-0.205575332,
-0.7198728323,
-0.7306320071,
0.0083390176,
0.6410851479,
0.3997437656,
-0.0217003021,
-0.1670103222,
-0.0096191755,
-1.2240506411,
-0.5617607832,
-0.6328087449,
-0.2393207699,
0.8390408754,
0.14300403,
-0.0331812203,
0.4323886633,
-0.5493221879,
-0.119830668,
-0.1428353935,
0.4190143645,
-0.1927752793,
0.2227474451,
0.5829456449,
-0.6689369082,
-0.5982563496,
-0.2421145588,
-0.3673304021,
-0.0259262957,
-0.285826683,
-0.2244393378,
-0.0513337068,
0.0411982276,
-0.6893988848,
0.7630723715,
0.6738072038,
-0.5879573822,
0.4820302129,
-0.3186131716,
0.5013945103,
-0.8772370219,
0.0459366739,
0.1371293962,
-0.052750472,
-0.6488159299,
-0.345369935,
-0.1810458899,
-0.094633162,
-0.6846009493,
0.5384221077,
-0.3170045018,
0.0484415032,
-0.4944687188,
-0.1188229769,
0.253159374,
-0.1081254184,
-0.1753017008,
1.0574945211,
0.5790070295,
-0.6745682359,
-0.0455776975,
0.4534550905,
-0.4895786643,
0.4185391665,
-0.6568182707,
0.3170800507,
-0.3623504937,
0.539667666,
-0.5995094776,
-0.0773143619,
0.809673667,
-0.9542635679,
0.0568928421,
0.1267084181,
-0.0740605667,
-0.1713406444,
-0.168167159,
0.1063694507,
0.4023541212,
-0.3563718498,
0.096157223,
0.294713825,
-0.0591845512,
-0.5261794329,
-1.0824067593,
0.3101603389,
-0.1639497578,
-0.3182808757,
0.2831094563,
-0.1880058497,
-0.4338047504,
0.0533933342,
-0.1773809493,
0.1920813471,
0.2150518,
0.4705378711,
0.108427532,
0.2599881291,
0.2582109571,
-0.1837978959,
-0.1572640091,
0.60476017,
-0.1002535075,
0.2572388649,
0.2277493328,
-0.5704286098,
-1.0000374317,
0.5074990988,
0.2495634556,
-0.2269776762,
1.0630931854,
0.3468873799,
0.0970410407,
-0.0546112284,
-0.2170577645,
-0.3985494375,
-0.4929276109,
0.1473589689,
0.2451818287,
-0.719681263,
-0.239016667,
0.3314455152,
-0.4037322998,
0.4451659322,
0.6783775091,
-0.22332941,
0.9898043275,
0.7246434093,
-0.2197937071,
0.9155939817,
-0.0140793202,
0.4211092591,
-0.5453838706,
-0.4477614164,
-0.8957264423,
-0.2094523758,
-0.8169745803,
-0.2961912453,
0.5432542562,
-0.295656234,
-0.2130383253,
-0.0850558951,
-0.7470159531,
0.3076618016,
0.8551968932,
0.3484287858,
0.3037909567,
-0.0047244346,
0.587792933,
0.2020587921,
-0.7033601999,
-0.4261521697,
1.2168501616,
0.3540066779,
0.4645206928,
0.0238918047,
0.6402235627,
0.6739014983,
0.7073585987,
-0.7138435245,
0.3513133228,
0.0624441169,
-0.5763449073,
-0.0589562654,
-0.5372572541,
-1.1191958189,
-0.0682665855,
-0.2465178668,
-0.8101428151,
0.2470563054,
-0.0382155441,
-0.1580592692,
-0.0858510658,
-0.9109792113,
0.4150627851,
-0.5075139403,
0.0109317815,
-0.6808991432,
-0.5504172444,
0.3203168213,
-0.0248113796,
0.184051916,
-0.3277897239,
0.1154208332,
0.7881126404,
-0.3430989087,
0.8161422014,
0.0186195225,
-0.049943205,
0.6300862432,
-0.2424589247,
0.5457119942,
0.4351314008,
-0.141360864,
0.5301836729,
-0.3318374455,
-0.1912676543,
-0.7136956453,
0.5625815988,
-1.0307579041,
-1.2009251118,
-0.4112477303,
-0.1554430723,
0.2357134074,
0.3228042424,
0.487354219,
0.1726520509,
-0.0863103867,
0.2219592184,
0.4634598494,
-0.640280664,
0.0965863019,
0.5613789558,
0.1392843127,
-0.2204837054,
0.7568563223,
-0.0333992951,
0.4981000721,
0.4517042637,
0.563539207,
0.0572643206,
-0.4430517852,
-0.1406240463,
0.2452987134,
-0.6215904355,
-0.2054363638,
-0.4201443791,
-0.5522975922,
-0.3256342411,
0.2221953422,
-0.264785409,
-0.0903845504,
-0.436011374,
-0.1585730761,
0.2492331415,
1.027346015,
0.0662950128,
0.2845681608,
-0.9167302251,
0.1718607992,
0.2894927263,
0.2400905043,
-0.0799669921,
-0.2379292548,
-0.3060694933,
0.4183684587,
-0.4184592366,
-1.1306483746,
0.1253499538,
-0.1329332739,
0.6449645162,
0.5533252358,
0.1013989523,
0.1110908911,
-0.0774973035,
1.0913732052,
0.1026119515,
-0.9382104874,
0.7531157136,
-0.3134480119,
0.1893443018,
0.360735327,
0.2461244315,
-0.7114863992,
-0.6932634711,
-0.8438094854,
-0.6269928217,
0.6282769442,
0.6017699242,
0.5277721882,
-0.1079688966,
0.1182292327,
0.2268830091,
0.4083544314,
-0.5961917043,
-0.8155968785,
-0.220085144,
0.3347766995,
-0.045106411,
-0.4557784498,
-0.3103584647,
-0.1201161221,
0.4837965369,
0.436678797,
0.604039073,
0.2707515657,
0.3458393216,
-0.1738053262,
0.6813036799,
0.7809991837,
0.709322691,
-0.0958441198,
0.1367877722,
-0.6000632644,
-0.4964954555,
0.3035650849,
-0.1509457827,
-0.7308708429,
0.1009751707,
0.470004648,
1.0802612305,
-0.4493263662,
-0.6131423116,
0.5783118606,
-0.1345917284,
-0.1068331897,
-0.0810583979,
0.3285521269,
-0.0105471453,
-0.0349198505,
0.3302017152,
0.3957305253,
0.3173635006,
-0.6282666326,
0.155253619,
0.6111010313,
-0.1983316094,
-0.3261575103,
0.8498890996,
0.3342678547,
-0.5289367437,
0.7111107111,
0.20628196,
-0.2626087368,
0.6903722882,
0.3894648254,
0.9467799664,
-0.3229168952,
0.5792244673,
0.2562852502,
0.3826755881,
0.3309056461,
-0.2481769323,
-0.0403825045,
-0.6077132225,
-0.4212854207,
0.104338102,
-0.4317412674,
0.313950181,
-0.4847126007,
0.1648641825,
-0.2125555724,
-0.3357848823,
0.0520558245,
-0.1361062825,
-0.7562149763,
0.0696534142,
0.4196650684,
0.7595677972,
-0.8625341654,
0.6653437018,
0.5333417058,
-0.4661367238,
-0.9423267841,
0.5274766684,
0.1907871366,
-0.5894059539,
0.5004139543,
0.293861717,
-0.038913168,
-0.3144382536,
-0.5670799017,
-1.113709569,
0.9717519283,
0.5032507181,
-0.4203188717,
0.2897892296,
0.1547890007,
0.5974342823,
-0.2385621518,
0.5628352761,
0.3132950366,
0.593919158,
-0.0422958992,
-1.0780901909,
-0.0173521955,
-0.2464483976,
0.0186914559,
0.0139350435,
-0.8898043633,
0.5578048825,
-0.1695021838,
-0.5260788202,
-0.4369598329,
0.6112741828,
0.2110483795,
0.5357804298,
0.1365066022,
0.0338985883,
0.6411496997,
0.4869739711,
1.2834311724,
-0.1942430884,
-0.1087802052,
0.9373318553,
0.0555646084,
0.7572501302,
0.5314264894,
0.0602661148,
0.588796854,
0.422278434,
0.2487869263,
0.5553992987,
0.1009872183,
-0.2478748411,
0.3096478879,
-0.6245442033,
-0.4613414705,
0.6147779822,
0.4786916673,
-0.7533710003,
-0.0106039625,
0.0594703481,
0.1519786865,
0.06103158,
-0.2111301124,
0.9507064223,
0.0685847998,
-0.8347159028,
0.4817589223,
0.102642864,
0.5110798478,
-0.398727566,
-0.1514724791,
-0.1228361279,
-0.2166293412,
-0.2474779785,
-0.8588724136,
0.4730160236,
-0.0007641464,
-0.1199637875,
-0.3401656747,
0.9563624263,
-0.3030676246,
-0.2083632052,
0.2144407332,
0.4692902565,
0.1053764746,
-0.2364347577,
-0.758343637,
0.2117582113,
0.095189184,
-0.4904304743,
0.3382172287,
-0.0873970762,
0.0009741401,
0.7586835027,
0.6936922669,
0.3726686239,
-0.3680865765,
-0.0198773313,
0.8468055725,
-0.5576531887,
-0.5454491973,
-0.8856487274,
0.3406677544,
-0.0684883967,
0.0952130556,
0.8821930289,
0.3457219899,
0.9240921736,
0.1753543913,
1.2749363184,
-0.0259877164,
0.1640889049,
-0.4675210416,
0.9526658654,
-0.1629521698,
0.6703622341,
-0.0145462956,
-0.7940977812,
0.1762352139,
0.065438129,
-0.5483211279,
0.2276412547,
0.5435230732,
0.3653115332,
0.3676557243,
-0.2595682442,
0.0100261234,
0.2728976309,
0.7768169045,
0.4435325563,
0.7998113632,
-0.1279145926,
0.5344466567,
-0.4602130055,
-0.2108066976,
-0.2990146875,
-0.7926650047,
-0.7285516262,
-0.3784067929,
-0.2532148659,
-0.3413933218,
0.1605370194,
0.6918744445,
0.5276680589,
-0.4006916285,
0.123517178,
-0.0261277817,
0.448120296,
-0.3579497635,
-0.2805124521,
0.3660641313,
0.1980720162,
-0.5452125669,
0.350709945,
0.4535070956,
-0.05435545,
-0.4288474023,
-0.1097887531,
0.1220225096,
0.3431406617,
0.4489015639,
0.2164253891,
-0.6957809329,
-0.507522285,
-0.0268696044,
-0.3641872108,
0.4104468524,
0.8353797793,
-0.8134615421,
0.5069989562,
0.631900847,
0.3457244933,
0.2163178325,
0.4949032068,
0.8707327843,
-0.5190681219,
0.1787437797,
0.2264597565,
-0.1719485372,
0.2764452994,
-1.0507068634,
0.1063924059,
-0.0040295543,
-0.5760669708,
-0.4676297307,
0.1751285642,
-0.4705837667,
-0.4842703044,
1.2285616398,
0.1458091587,
-0.221548155,
0.033761017,
-0.3323421776,
0.2738197744,
-0.6317088604,
1.0075052977,
0.6709823608,
-0.4739986062,
-0.2722672522,
-0.7031484246,
0.5570740104,
0.4005432725,
-1.0402909517,
0.1346480548,
0.481498003,
0.2172703743,
-0.034286391,
1.0200651884,
0.1910982877,
0.3089661598,
-0.0802306235,
-0.1427428424,
-0.2293946594,
-0.4157179594,
-0.2998481393,
-0.2315126806,
0.3010418415,
-0.2895116508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16480v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16480v4
|
WsiCaption: Multiple Instance Generation of Pathology Reports for Gigapixel Whole-Slide Images
| 2023-11-27T05:05:41 | 2024-06-27T12:38:12 |
Pingyi Chen, Honglin Li, Chenglu Zhu, Sunyi Zheng, Zhongyi Shui, Lin Yang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Whole slide images are the foundation of digital pathology for the diagnosis
and treatment of carcinomas. Writing pathology reports is laborious and
error-prone for inexperienced pathologists. To reduce the workload and improve
clinical automation, we investigate how to generate pathology reports given
whole slide images. On the data end, we curated the largest WSI-text dataset
(PathText). In specific, we collected nearly 10000 high-quality WSI-text pairs
for visual-language models by recognizing and cleaning pathology reports which
narrate diagnostic slides in TCGA. On the model end, we propose the multiple
instance generative model (MI-Gen) which can produce pathology reports for
gigapixel WSIs. We benchmark our model on the largest subset of TCGA-PathoText.
Experimental results show our model can generate pathology reports which
contain multiple clinical clues and achieve competitive performance on certain
slide-level tasks. We observe that simple semantic extraction from the
pathology reports can achieve the best performance (0.838 of F1 score) on BRCA
subtyping surpassing previous state-of-the-art approaches. Our collected
dataset and related code are available.
|
[
-0.0815119743,
-0.4953254163,
0.8223651052,
0.0113971205,
-0.5106845498,
-0.2218823433,
0.154263705,
-0.5747274756,
0.2526493371,
0.6206935048,
-0.5275539756,
-0.6316801906,
-0.448557198,
-0.0141862137,
-0.6234568954,
0.9993305206,
0.2298179865,
0.1364472955,
-0.1652604192,
-0.2518615127,
-0.2398288995,
-0.0814451501,
-0.6019553542,
-0.0045136213,
0.6164197326,
0.5783483982,
0.5871959329,
0.6475132704,
0.5774272084,
0.3029981852,
0.2300706953,
0.093411386,
-0.158486113,
0.2061285973,
0.0292409342,
-0.2771003246,
-0.5178529024,
0.1243458092,
0.3011585474,
0.6054139137,
-0.5643264055,
-0.0595624521,
-0.3114516139,
0.1935833246,
-0.3915304244,
-0.0745278597,
-0.4460336566,
0.2675732076,
-0.2702779472,
-0.2678421736,
-0.5080592036,
-0.2912471294,
0.1742350608,
-0.7186611295,
0.4474492967,
-0.1390127987,
0.8160333633,
-0.279766202,
-0.4873209,
-0.2178347409,
-0.5275367498,
0.4444314539,
-0.9313821793,
-0.0181120168,
0.0347860344,
0.4768051207,
0.0359564722,
-1.1162620783,
-0.3104880452,
-0.4051174521,
-0.0943939239,
0.4248151481,
-0.1844490618,
-0.1467938125,
0.3131024539,
0.3248209953,
-0.5733551979,
0.1723716557,
-0.7129731774,
-0.5268646479,
0.5933318138,
0.538425386,
0.5380077362,
0.0046947543,
-0.3974129856,
-0.1043686941,
-0.9232789874,
-0.5105326772,
-0.0261735767,
0.0320025459,
0.107895866,
0.4561590254,
-0.1503417641,
0.6638525128,
-0.3174512386,
-0.5574022532,
0.293091476,
-0.1756772846,
-0.1128923744,
0.2549799383,
0.9511762261,
0.1550450325,
-0.1831832528,
-0.3065344691,
0.2908920646,
0.0659376606,
0.567407012,
-1.1071003675,
-0.2560361624,
0.3714831471,
-0.649738431,
-0.7141520381,
-0.2373001426,
-1.0170916319,
-0.340054363,
-0.1184645519,
0.521486342,
-0.5817950964,
-0.1351356655,
0.1152992696,
-0.25697577,
-0.1652709246,
0.5324121714,
-0.6120114326,
0.1939688474,
0.0865837857,
0.7928755283,
0.0934996679,
-0.4502187669,
-1.0524381399,
0.5739755034,
-0.3978682756,
1.0077776909,
-0.5863361359,
-0.5008426309,
-0.1561474502,
-0.0621077083,
-0.0407274701,
-0.2783120275,
0.4179796278,
-0.0679151416,
0.4178721607,
0.0518649779,
-0.3230849802,
-0.1565891951,
-0.1819410175,
-0.506444931,
0.6743106842,
0.2950654924,
-0.663874805,
0.5755254626,
-0.6189361215,
-0.4140934944,
0.4870334566,
-0.3255738616,
-0.3325512111,
0.2091572285,
0.1200700104,
0.4319770634,
-0.2932776213,
0.1820968539,
-0.079263553,
-0.0364419743,
-0.1947845519,
-0.2432876527,
0.4915641844,
0.1760383844,
-0.430144161,
0.1699343324,
-0.8278535008,
-0.0062958067,
0.3146454394,
-0.07729467,
-0.2576971054,
0.2381790727,
-0.1838174164,
0.4959679246,
-0.091424413,
-0.9279683232,
0.4090742171,
-0.1653702408,
0.2790478766,
0.5048347116,
-0.0095796324,
-0.3360664248,
-0.1666524112,
0.4549531341,
0.7034727931,
0.3024385273,
-0.3773640394,
-0.7382335067,
-0.3932519853,
-0.2028892189,
0.2536540031,
0.4565380216,
-0.7622303963,
0.0345776528,
-0.4065315723,
-0.7584555745,
-0.3617704809,
-0.2134509683,
0.4336642325,
0.8269199133,
0.3548080325,
-0.6149138212,
-0.1146487296,
-1.224152565,
0.5767976046,
0.1403507888,
-0.1977531016,
0.4209476113,
0.1956069469,
-0.1590917408,
0.44764027,
-0.9083076715,
-0.506066978,
-0.2926415503,
0.5473953485,
0.0840704963,
0.1591850668,
0.6070997119,
-0.6422721148,
-0.2356662303,
0.122377865,
-0.6067200303,
-0.0987572148,
-0.0989721939,
-0.198186025,
0.1583769619,
0.3756403923,
-0.4963050187,
0.749956727,
0.5955411196,
-0.2324516922,
0.8040117025,
-0.6018924713,
0.4939619899,
-1.2066056728,
0.0943405256,
0.2986239493,
-0.2975657582,
-0.4622027576,
-0.0757713169,
-0.1005939171,
-0.0195285156,
-0.3918408453,
-0.1263684034,
-0.3018019497,
-0.2718977034,
0.0170980711,
0.3175164163,
0.0603984967,
0.3426066935,
0.1808925271,
0.7953001261,
0.7536897659,
-0.6393316388,
0.3836944997,
0.2840647101,
-0.3521785438,
0.1827971786,
-0.5926442146,
0.1099267602,
-0.0339532271,
0.2462729812,
-0.8436300755,
-0.3029140234,
-0.1657952517,
-0.0980596691,
0.3177063763,
-0.1152550429,
-0.5017206073,
-0.6746405959,
-0.3435088992,
-0.003526683,
0.4048984051,
-0.5153586268,
0.3573080897,
0.5027173758,
-0.4423097372,
-0.1524373889,
-0.744846642,
0.2497201115,
-0.1338927746,
-0.5724979043,
0.5904730558,
-0.1213207841,
0.1018627137,
-0.1149010286,
0.1965435296,
-0.1550305039,
-0.2213463187,
0.2032819837,
0.4906848669,
-0.3980157971,
0.0092626186,
-0.0002182621,
-0.0063163503,
-0.3200562596,
0.0232082922,
0.4790396094,
-0.0645181164,
-0.575055182,
-0.1452059299,
0.6555316448,
0.7170769572,
0.003040455,
0.3996278346,
0.5146121979,
-0.3468765914,
0.0220107548,
-0.3943657875,
-0.1520401239,
-0.4147977531,
0.2777200341,
-0.3712026775,
-0.6538879871,
0.4135838449,
-0.2031517327,
0.3952541053,
0.5791166425,
0.6468354464,
-0.0383141004,
1.3274316788,
0.501394093,
-0.0190934762,
-0.065026775,
-0.0960118771,
0.3033527136,
-0.8054407239,
-0.1774228364,
-0.6035439372,
0.0719736218,
-0.4495324194,
-0.1005209535,
0.7661080956,
-0.2871926129,
0.3506997526,
0.5131551027,
-0.884234786,
0.333491683,
0.3935961127,
0.3834779263,
0.2367456555,
0.2419243455,
-0.3167153001,
-0.1568288654,
-0.7682055235,
-0.5511590838,
1.1950595379,
-0.1388756335,
0.3526988626,
0.3233648837,
0.6041783094,
0.2810460627,
0.4093926549,
-0.6372078061,
0.5713687539,
-0.5741888881,
-0.2209622562,
-0.1706800759,
-0.4240964949,
-1.0415171385,
0.5396270156,
0.0397516601,
-1.2639641762,
-0.0225244947,
0.0506356396,
-0.5364980698,
0.3096227646,
-0.6597723365,
0.7642350197,
-0.1088219509,
-0.4418935776,
-0.4020702541,
-0.6534503698,
0.564350605,
0.1408078372,
0.3750066459,
0.0370470136,
0.1306070238,
0.6642482281,
-0.4854300916,
0.5749184489,
-0.0102838017,
-0.2051328272,
0.2616551816,
0.3567257226,
0.1912279129,
-0.124696672,
0.1549269706,
-0.0056146877,
0.1296804994,
-0.1835819483,
0.030046137,
0.6831954718,
-0.2563013434,
-0.3529661596,
-0.2032460719,
-0.3970851004,
-0.3596167862,
0.2131120861,
0.5289378166,
1.2584733963,
-0.2126402557,
-0.126588434,
0.6690616608,
-0.1538036913,
0.7867780924,
0.3044839501,
-0.0254133698,
-0.1072963476,
1.0522421598,
-0.1036020517,
0.0314366408,
0.1397500932,
0.2612854242,
0.0611455478,
-0.7433078885,
-0.8753789067,
-0.0582154952,
-0.4726991057,
-0.3162535727,
-0.7227404118,
-0.2651542425,
-0.4052652121,
-0.0484321527,
-0.2434268296,
-0.4732262492,
-0.1512419879,
-0.0113457106,
0.2517234981,
0.7946681976,
-0.2795019746,
0.1837492734,
-1.157497406,
0.2346201092,
0.3399512172,
0.0074081188,
-0.0805927962,
-0.2633357644,
-0.0996279791,
-0.0935503766,
-0.5521943569,
-1.0138738155,
0.6328647137,
0.2534111142,
0.5818070769,
0.4566195607,
-0.5472155213,
0.5761051774,
-0.5148322582,
0.9286983609,
0.5341259241,
-0.5826701522,
0.9023418427,
-0.5069280267,
0.0851984397,
0.3117230237,
0.3320698738,
-0.4726916552,
-0.4642002285,
-1.0549345016,
-0.8569657803,
1.0061926842,
0.1027868241,
-0.1505170763,
-0.013881878,
-0.08895538,
0.3255465627,
0.0750122219,
-0.4960925877,
0.0995431542,
-0.1753733754,
-0.1952175647,
0.0570867024,
-0.4165956974,
-0.7352828979,
-0.2785556614,
0.565941453,
-0.4556245208,
0.4604408741,
0.3451076746,
-0.1598929167,
-0.0672751814,
0.2994162738,
0.8987352848,
0.8328606486,
-0.0764462501,
0.1184569746,
-0.0257198699,
-0.6683246493,
-0.1855383068,
-0.0690651461,
0.0487669855,
0.159176603,
0.4970038235,
0.3863428831,
0.0925639719,
-0.6523787975,
0.6705896854,
-0.2069017291,
-0.4911513627,
0.1767539084,
0.2230721861,
0.1428970098,
-0.3419222236,
0.415035367,
-0.0023839071,
0.6459797621,
-0.4854546189,
0.4197051227,
0.1033406034,
-0.3676170409,
-0.2226545513,
0.4560304582,
0.1285782456,
0.2938831151,
0.9000517726,
-0.2350662202,
-0.3582139909,
0.9404381514,
0.6567762494,
0.4632368684,
-0.1189261302,
0.6834519506,
0.5370471478,
0.2275477797,
0.1212911308,
0.0761083215,
0.1620581746,
-0.4628656805,
-0.2744493484,
-0.4096571803,
-0.3521282375,
0.3285552263,
-0.5775899887,
0.084136717,
-0.2097985446,
0.1539743096,
0.6931663156,
-0.3091229498,
-0.0168671925,
0.3253148496,
0.1947390437,
0.7498373985,
-0.7432080507,
0.7381557822,
0.4699962437,
-0.5265610814,
-0.9097927213,
-0.1117275283,
0.2369709462,
-0.5265253186,
0.2973810434,
0.2618940473,
0.1510359198,
-0.1803685725,
-0.6299896836,
-0.4882166982,
1.2036459446,
0.0984522551,
-0.5628736615,
0.1922659725,
-0.1001538038,
0.5398244858,
-0.6676428914,
0.5257120132,
0.5383434892,
0.2259130031,
0.3838741779,
-0.9291208386,
0.2115970701,
-0.1448196769,
0.1418313086,
0.1785843968,
-0.5344279408,
0.7158434391,
-0.4608509839,
-0.2421071827,
-0.0016015493,
0.1324703842,
0.2867467403,
0.218311891,
0.2637324035,
0.837310791,
0.4074182212,
-0.1804332137,
1.2443963289,
-0.0605134778,
0.0110284984,
0.702255249,
-0.3354009092,
0.4744839668,
0.1663016081,
-0.2260795832,
0.7094983459,
0.61119169,
-0.134103477,
0.5889183879,
-0.02871163,
-0.3041142225,
-0.2894388735,
-0.0020413171,
-0.2913456261,
0.3622858524,
0.5579042435,
-0.3113547266,
-0.568954587,
0.059219081,
0.0710078627,
-0.383718729,
-0.2021747082,
0.9615368247,
-0.2365135252,
-0.6227288842,
0.1111755222,
-0.0853659436,
0.497546494,
-0.7258974314,
-0.2889862657,
-0.2794662118,
-0.0719323084,
-0.2637293637,
-0.7678786516,
0.3769264817,
-0.1183347926,
0.1788675487,
0.1607143432,
0.6184386015,
-0.3287923336,
-0.591148138,
0.0033182385,
0.3546845019,
0.3760133982,
0.3281919956,
-0.4619625807,
-0.2299336493,
0.1210877076,
-0.191521138,
0.5695598722,
0.2329668999,
-0.0951958448,
0.5438467264,
0.540128231,
0.2157877535,
-0.0556896217,
0.358799845,
0.8548582792,
-0.2811568081,
-0.246055752,
-0.4344929159,
0.5022316575,
-0.5417106152,
-0.5148943067,
0.1444485635,
0.7016162872,
0.2986041605,
-0.0711001456,
0.6611352563,
-0.4441226721,
0.1506816745,
-0.520432353,
0.5856522322,
-0.6339163184,
-0.0484663099,
-0.2011784911,
-0.3702682853,
0.0271967296,
0.1528061032,
0.1813432425,
-0.0476830564,
0.9923089743,
0.8225882053,
-0.3122433126,
0.2271265984,
0.3366300166,
0.2574178278,
0.3223209083,
0.8377000093,
0.395676434,
-0.4618780315,
0.7205244899,
-0.5486656427,
-0.4966637194,
-0.1362434179,
-0.8114246726,
-0.4162379205,
-0.7624025941,
-0.640224278,
-0.2311321497,
-0.1126411259,
0.109000057,
1.1135864258,
-0.7021754384,
0.0727418438,
-0.1384201497,
-0.1799571067,
-0.2340034992,
-0.2511355281,
0.4296855628,
-0.227155298,
-0.4765124321,
0.5733659267,
0.6911617517,
0.0213474203,
-0.0465394855,
0.5031503439,
-0.1162975356,
-0.1440359354,
0.783236444,
0.1866134703,
-0.2546376288,
-0.2207010984,
-0.5074210763,
-0.4167030156,
0.2367561907,
0.8943812251,
-0.648788929,
0.328373909,
0.1420429051,
0.0082446998,
0.7816944718,
-0.3462488055,
0.5168266296,
-0.603541255,
0.1797299087,
0.2681636512,
0.5403640866,
0.0975471511,
-0.6649804711,
0.728736937,
0.2610609233,
-0.2853043079,
-0.6225662231,
0.233101368,
-1.1881252527,
-0.4923844039,
1.0378366709,
-0.1546382904,
-0.1634708643,
0.0332633257,
-0.2401472926,
-0.0751979277,
-0.1758243591,
0.9410457611,
0.35538131,
-0.5824401975,
-0.3688950837,
-0.3392660916,
0.3617416322,
0.1177575588,
-1.2256669998,
-0.2405001968,
0.9632822871,
0.5456836224,
0.3218756318,
0.7186658382,
-0.5813661814,
0.7251644135,
0.3448061347,
0.1050021946,
-0.1039291844,
-0.3557191193,
0.2048469186,
0.4130885899,
-0.3082075715,
-0.2418706417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03725v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03725v1
|
SCStory: Self-supervised and Continual Online Story Discovery
| 2023-11-27T04:50:01 | 2023-11-27T04:50:01 |
Susik Yoon, Yu Meng, Dongha Lee, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
We present a framework SCStory for online story discovery, that helps people
digest rapidly published news article streams in real-time without human
annotations. To organize news article streams into stories, existing approaches
directly encode the articles and cluster them based on representation
similarity. However, these methods yield noisy and inaccurate story discovery
results because the generic article embeddings do not effectively reflect the
story-indicative semantics in an article and cannot adapt to the rapidly
evolving news article streams. SCStory employs self-supervised and continual
learning with a novel idea of story-indicative adaptive modeling of news
article streams. With a lightweight hierarchical embedding module that first
learns sentence representations and then article representations, SCStory
identifies story-relevant information of news articles and uses them to
discover stories. The embedding module is continuously updated to adapt to
evolving news streams with a contrastive learning objective, backed up by two
unique techniques, confidence-aware memory replay and prioritized-augmentation,
employed for label absence and data scarcity problems. Thorough experiments on
real and the latest news data sets demonstrate that SCStory outperforms
existing state-of-the-art algorithms for unsupervised online story discovery.
|
[
0.0074041015,
-0.4848913252,
0.8463292718,
0.7133832574,
-0.3486074209,
0.3728497028,
-0.1794826239,
-0.6670817733,
1.0178745985,
0.1790208817,
-0.5406804085,
-0.3112757802,
-0.4080368578,
-0.0119389445,
-0.5754622221,
0.9138501883,
-0.1809998155,
-0.0464621559,
-0.3025627136,
-0.2425450832,
0.0089474963,
-0.3860937953,
-0.4893574417,
0.2872768641,
0.3625842035,
0.2795693278,
0.3188364208,
1.0044298172,
0.1581647396,
0.2152826935,
0.0840600207,
0.2153547257,
-0.6362792253,
0.6773559451,
-0.2080551684,
-0.1201987043,
0.0259478632,
-0.0540289469,
0.5135026574,
0.3697829545,
-0.3700979948,
0.3035075366,
0.0837043151,
0.7300693989,
-0.7408088446,
-0.0361278988,
-0.4304405749,
0.1105522513,
-0.0571369901,
-0.2697733045,
-0.2557070851,
-0.4830791652,
0.3156658113,
-0.8604027033,
0.6364156604,
0.1520275474,
0.8326376081,
0.186921373,
-0.3335165679,
-0.6614797115,
-0.6706501842,
0.5436720848,
-0.4676288962,
0.3973957598,
0.2795656323,
0.0343609937,
0.0974856764,
-0.8533347249,
-0.3538842499,
-0.0710201934,
-0.1877276897,
0.2521575689,
-0.1347737759,
-0.2881136835,
-0.2078017443,
0.3386009336,
-0.6283189058,
-0.0052827173,
-0.3996911645,
-0.1858217418,
0.6635496616,
0.1541325897,
-0.0534813106,
-0.4152680039,
-0.5598728061,
0.3241331279,
-0.3342019618,
-0.1486445814,
0.3364161253,
-0.0153227346,
0.2279801667,
0.3491900861,
-0.5950215459,
0.2788001895,
0.3511256576,
-0.1050769687,
0.5047152638,
-0.1175588965,
0.2207420617,
0.5184801817,
0.5195406079,
0.6869500279,
-0.3344408274,
-0.4221133888,
-0.3052312732,
-0.0638424531,
0.4919890165,
-0.5969344974,
-0.2381197512,
0.2357835919,
-0.578707695,
-0.7609300017,
0.1132444814,
-0.7196753025,
-0.5527560115,
-0.0653171316,
0.6604833007,
-0.0605130233,
-0.155019179,
-0.0447418243,
-0.3895871043,
-0.2944683135,
0.2584033906,
-0.8365261555,
0.1711216569,
0.2282738239,
1.1813448668,
-0.5907918811,
-0.4742019475,
-0.6008770466,
0.5656146407,
-0.3184813857,
0.8572092056,
-0.1043871567,
0.164401561,
0.0647910163,
0.1920264512,
0.0775265247,
-0.3590867817,
0.3903434873,
-0.2916282713,
0.1251431704,
-0.1471304446,
-0.7639311552,
0.0182183143,
0.1437503844,
-0.607734561,
1.0790442228,
0.3428818583,
-0.9059443474,
0.3571986854,
-0.422495991,
-0.3811715245,
0.0886120871,
0.2647485137,
-0.4231996238,
0.4937919974,
0.3879399896,
0.5688135624,
0.5075511336,
0.7182895541,
-0.4111338854,
-0.5792698264,
-0.0806716159,
-0.2707819939,
0.2918152213,
0.3371288776,
-0.2290689796,
-0.0311735459,
-0.8842682838,
-0.3240716457,
0.3388804197,
-0.2949125469,
-0.3703290522,
0.4072602391,
0.0667483509,
0.0945204422,
0.2384738475,
-0.7652398944,
0.3972752094,
-0.1475872099,
0.7435358763,
0.7877659202,
0.4053994417,
0.6862103343,
-0.3973816335,
0.2216373384,
0.1289220601,
0.3151500225,
-0.7356957793,
-0.1138061583,
-0.9354879856,
-0.0403231755,
0.0160791799,
0.4453595579,
-0.5311538577,
-0.0113274734,
-0.2811665237,
-0.4303534627,
-0.4887203574,
0.0308598988,
-0.142683506,
0.2451507598,
0.5594806075,
-0.078085877,
-0.8079016805,
-0.7111724019,
-0.6091656685,
0.2109188139,
-0.2390809208,
0.1344555318,
0.2474249452,
-0.3218847811,
0.9243723154,
-0.3185460567,
-0.3616275787,
-0.1338627934,
0.3379266858,
0.0578716174,
0.2374835312,
0.3320638537,
-0.6161763668,
-0.2894999683,
-0.310044229,
-0.9334858656,
-0.1808868945,
-0.5708770156,
0.4181427956,
0.3443246186,
0.7377898097,
-0.5080082417,
0.5801307559,
0.4654950798,
-0.2402972877,
0.5485366583,
-0.1800251156,
0.097251758,
-0.9062048793,
-0.4967873394,
-0.0952959061,
-0.4440549612,
-0.3249974251,
0.0775882974,
0.2813458741,
-0.1560451388,
-0.4401149154,
0.602443397,
-0.5378854275,
-0.2970602512,
-0.2020306736,
0.497851491,
-0.0008720667,
0.401417464,
0.1724663675,
0.447609961,
0.4788246155,
-0.717376709,
0.4318524599,
-0.1133187711,
-0.2276522219,
0.4189934731,
-0.4307562709,
-0.1724372804,
-0.3334006965,
0.5407759547,
-0.7264681458,
-0.2840422392,
0.1940795481,
-0.3157052696,
0.0744591057,
-0.1871577948,
-0.4427787364,
-0.3502101898,
-0.5483463407,
0.0460184254,
-0.1949752867,
-0.8177322149,
0.7541936636,
0.3310832679,
-0.2486812025,
-0.2656216025,
-0.5391182303,
0.138639167,
-0.1435463727,
-0.2979168594,
0.3183196485,
0.0646919012,
0.0063129202,
0.2495850027,
-0.5168814659,
-0.1063493043,
-0.042896349,
0.4405122995,
0.1813599169,
-0.1263630986,
0.4378575087,
0.2090760171,
-0.2080146819,
-0.1124499589,
-0.6720210314,
0.2927684486,
-0.1238997132,
-0.0152804609,
-0.4452702403,
0.6343938708,
0.3335170448,
0.0357150026,
0.5927352905,
0.8143096566,
-0.3677863181,
-0.088129431,
-0.7654208541,
-0.1635079235,
-0.4654185474,
0.1666485369,
-0.0955275744,
-1.0751897097,
0.3614524603,
-0.2348998636,
-0.0927398428,
0.6141765118,
-0.0061814366,
-0.4407595992,
0.8739282489,
0.4460398555,
-0.049026221,
0.3036120236,
-0.170505017,
0.1112059429,
-0.429795742,
-0.2765903771,
-0.1769731343,
-0.4481440187,
-0.3418024778,
-0.0093106031,
0.1628730148,
0.1995914727,
-0.1757260114,
0.4213644564,
-0.7323501706,
0.6089248657,
0.557015419,
0.2436198741,
0.6061376929,
0.0191888865,
0.1077925786,
-0.2208487391,
-0.8995089531,
-0.0962779298,
1.0499494076,
0.2307484597,
0.8866153955,
-0.2393463999,
1.0207393169,
0.7844812274,
0.2280201018,
-0.4812780619,
0.0524566248,
0.3136446476,
-0.5390025377,
-0.1479793638,
-0.26447016,
-0.6491474509,
0.0858275741,
-0.4680854082,
-0.771155715,
0.2736899555,
-0.1183598191,
-0.3191868663,
0.4724069536,
-0.7604798079,
0.5705297589,
-0.4588273764,
-0.3312399089,
-0.4354375005,
-0.5834056139,
0.137239337,
-0.0850021094,
0.4094584286,
0.1918411851,
-0.1607346237,
0.7702666521,
-0.1273844689,
0.7241790891,
-0.0220920313,
0.5077735186,
0.30496943,
0.498919189,
0.734649241,
0.3142221868,
0.4429731071,
0.1004704461,
0.1323874146,
-0.7098891735,
-0.3959632218,
1.1364998817,
-0.5872459412,
-0.4361307919,
-0.9496145248,
-0.3549303412,
0.001248845,
0.1830369681,
0.4180466533,
0.4029410481,
0.0131267346,
0.3965812624,
0.6300414205,
0.2586291432,
0.9177273512,
0.5565082431,
-0.4542869627,
-0.3842719793,
1.0648876429,
0.2234894037,
-0.237871483,
0.1903646737,
0.1469603479,
-0.2612921894,
-0.6189517379,
-0.5219973922,
0.2582662404,
-0.4485055506,
-0.425701648,
-1.0338382721,
-0.2133315802,
-0.1911404282,
-0.5000144243,
-0.5577787757,
-0.6622268558,
-0.5674201846,
-0.4141617417,
0.2673226297,
1.0569825172,
-0.3431869745,
0.2932983339,
-0.8640941978,
0.3825840354,
0.3450686038,
0.4309868217,
-0.0232139099,
-0.3564420044,
-0.6006451249,
-0.144045487,
-0.4276667237,
-0.9583019018,
0.4809745848,
0.1553301066,
0.4692862928,
0.7522412539,
0.4440268576,
0.5626504421,
-0.3339247406,
0.797644496,
0.0472348258,
-0.8481324315,
0.6705436707,
-0.5440633893,
-0.0434982106,
0.4719719291,
0.665162921,
-0.4869391322,
-0.3414705098,
-0.7245649695,
-1.0375030041,
0.3370747268,
-0.0306782965,
0.1907439083,
-0.2085140347,
0.4731579125,
0.3268723488,
0.3332501948,
-0.8016922474,
0.0213325974,
-0.7481742501,
0.1034490466,
-0.0217356943,
-0.4712225199,
0.1352166831,
-0.2071399093,
0.603520453,
-0.0547904745,
0.1517079026,
0.5283023119,
-0.4743946195,
-0.1314390302,
-0.1087267026,
0.2168515921,
0.8123708963,
-0.3832318187,
0.0997815058,
0.2287768573,
-0.5765935779,
0.0330295861,
0.0948644206,
-0.2500870526,
0.2840412259,
0.2646463513,
0.6840445995,
0.8601413965,
-0.6918845773,
0.8348955512,
-0.1360144764,
-0.2569497526,
-0.5756318569,
-0.1014433801,
0.2599141598,
0.4493777156,
1.1086004972,
0.2453795969,
0.2391397804,
-0.6157702208,
0.3364741206,
-0.0493423827,
-0.3791362941,
-0.0070661861,
0.7501674294,
-0.0205195397,
-0.3307046592,
0.4426321685,
-0.422518909,
-0.4031624496,
0.0641251504,
0.6702123284,
0.7117089629,
-0.3507098258,
0.6868238449,
0.3170170784,
0.1769667864,
-0.4350526631,
-0.1910687387,
-0.3010371029,
-0.449793905,
-0.0716741532,
-0.6153104901,
-0.2604678869,
0.093077749,
-0.7253712416,
0.1276587397,
-0.2200711966,
0.3487314284,
-0.1593915224,
0.1977937222,
-0.2912549078,
0.1153052747,
-0.2217084765,
0.9070441723,
-0.785985589,
0.5490731001,
0.1238439009,
-0.1570310593,
-0.3654078543,
0.0270618051,
-0.0576181225,
-0.467010349,
-0.2567989826,
0.3114362657,
0.2654329836,
0.1832634211,
-0.6516858339,
-0.9551300406,
1.4328840971,
0.1838304549,
-0.7442167401,
-0.2568072677,
-0.5149817467,
0.48410061,
-0.6119424701,
-0.0473457649,
0.0737562999,
0.3478470445,
0.1742176265,
-0.4222854376,
-0.1019352153,
0.0246932637,
-0.3031955361,
-0.0200321805,
-0.5552376509,
0.649202466,
-0.3985937834,
-0.2808312178,
0.0820385739,
0.7669422626,
0.1217473447,
1.056298852,
0.265448451,
0.7146116495,
0.6941939592,
-0.0561945513,
0.7819472551,
-0.1409022957,
0.5039676428,
1.291719079,
0.0039986335,
0.803614676,
0.4145691395,
0.0624911301,
0.6144055128,
0.8031868935,
-0.1637474149,
0.6851641536,
0.0399307758,
-0.2718272507,
-0.2527772188,
0.050054688,
-0.3509824276,
0.1959933788,
0.3347410262,
-0.1828719229,
-0.3834394515,
0.3434812725,
0.0544218235,
0.0327057913,
-0.4148640335,
0.6499891281,
-0.2180029452,
-0.3129806221,
0.1431190223,
-0.1257871091,
0.6872140169,
-0.575799346,
0.2399376482,
-0.4502601027,
-0.0138409222,
-0.325679332,
-0.6271829605,
0.3033361733,
-0.3633363247,
-0.2918397188,
-0.1371699423,
0.8698276877,
-0.3120113313,
-0.3111565411,
0.249288559,
0.6211776137,
0.0620775037,
-0.4534137547,
-0.3278381824,
-0.0181044843,
-0.2482162118,
-0.3785654008,
0.3496564329,
0.3036287129,
-0.113312982,
0.901650548,
0.7381610274,
0.0376727916,
0.0847925767,
-0.3620887995,
1.055280447,
-0.6666294932,
-0.9847922921,
-0.2858591378,
0.0206581019,
-0.3649477661,
-0.3000921607,
0.7748658657,
1.040784955,
0.7819446325,
-0.151016295,
0.631972611,
0.2414603382,
0.7309751511,
-0.2254670262,
0.694834888,
-0.4373877048,
0.0283702537,
-0.1073510721,
-0.907630682,
-0.2080541402,
0.5230506063,
0.2244173139,
-0.4827695489,
0.9070335031,
0.5189028978,
-0.2799833119,
0.4478096664,
-0.028432576,
0.3963733017,
-0.2195866704,
0.1330937594,
0.8500193357,
-0.3145221472,
0.5947582722,
-0.179125905,
-0.0935709104,
-0.5344887376,
-1.0045278072,
-0.7817758322,
-0.8693672419,
-0.0711484924,
-0.2943795621,
0.3993424177,
0.7881217003,
0.8040305972,
-0.8085591197,
0.119428657,
-0.0955117568,
0.0979013145,
-0.4418478012,
-0.3341723382,
0.4099321663,
-0.4297832251,
-0.165409103,
0.6590678096,
0.4294881523,
-0.1261529177,
-0.4022702277,
-0.177628383,
-0.2529288828,
0.0394956954,
0.5008186102,
0.3743779063,
-0.4146418273,
-0.4668438137,
0.2044271231,
0.0112846326,
-0.0792109296,
1.0038063526,
-1.2725460529,
0.5147311091,
0.2598102987,
0.4494926333,
1.3083286285,
-0.1555123776,
0.1141138524,
-0.7696611285,
0.1118830442,
0.1411379278,
0.233416155,
0.2458047718,
-0.6749936938,
0.5562037826,
0.7055847049,
-0.6608015895,
-0.7825035453,
-0.100510031,
-0.9635763764,
-0.3902931511,
0.7698085904,
-0.1762387007,
-0.150399521,
-0.2410639971,
-0.1042875275,
-0.0595720932,
-0.5875852108,
1.2310180664,
0.5623341799,
-0.080995962,
-0.4525993764,
-0.6788858771,
0.4829975367,
-0.4337528348,
-0.3830011487,
0.0140842665,
0.4009702206,
0.4018403292,
0.1017146036,
0.5253118873,
0.1250730753,
0.2956036627,
0.1474599838,
-0.3829947412,
-0.4824658036,
-0.6229526401,
-0.1540263444,
0.3521143794,
-0.7978566885,
-0.0872712433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15525v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15525v1
|
Overview of the VLSP 2022 -- Abmusu Shared Task: A Data Challenge for Vietnamese Abstractive Multi-document Summarization
| 2023-11-27T04:01:13 | 2023-11-27T04:01:13 |
Mai-Vu Tran, Hoang-Quynh Le, Duy-Cat Can, Quoc-An Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper reports the overview of the VLSP 2022 - Vietnamese abstractive
multi-document summarization (Abmusu) shared task for Vietnamese News. This
task is hosted at the 9$^{th}$ annual workshop on Vietnamese Language and
Speech Processing (VLSP 2022). The goal of Abmusu shared task is to develop
summarization systems that could create abstractive summaries automatically for
a set of documents on a topic. The model input is multiple news documents on
the same topic, and the corresponding output is a related abstractive summary.
In the scope of Abmusu shared task, we only focus on Vietnamese news
summarization and build a human-annotated dataset of 1,839 documents in 600
clusters, collected from Vietnamese news in 8 categories. Participated models
are evaluated and ranked in terms of \texttt{ROUGE2-F1} score, the most typical
evaluation metric for document summarization problem.
|
[
-0.3886326253,
-0.5531258583,
0.5125158429,
0.316812247,
-0.4250722826,
-0.1062601134,
-0.0508087687,
-0.629280746,
0.3365216553,
0.5693664551,
-0.4177892804,
-0.6014468074,
-0.7225248218,
0.1746306419,
-0.6378484964,
1.154181242,
-0.0923882499,
-0.1850940883,
-0.2493730634,
-0.3059746921,
-0.3233298659,
-0.4514959455,
-0.6194267273,
-0.2775684595,
0.3693006337,
0.5843343735,
0.2752219439,
0.6708215475,
0.4121123254,
0.3299317062,
-0.0590391792,
0.1641212404,
-0.3852393925,
0.1389305443,
-0.2532786727,
-0.4081258774,
-0.6832686067,
0.061293263,
0.6941868663,
0.5649434328,
0.0337132663,
0.2903941274,
-0.0691734627,
0.7560688257,
-0.3624315858,
0.1085900813,
-0.3407018483,
-0.2242086083,
0.0842928961,
-0.2748239934,
-0.2493380308,
-0.1938722134,
0.1421743631,
-0.5290346742,
0.1523548663,
-0.3646174669,
1.0603631735,
0.3240078986,
-0.7548062801,
-0.3307316601,
-0.5722067356,
0.6795245409,
-0.4213244915,
-0.0217319131,
0.3486278951,
0.1291376352,
0.2353134453,
-0.5087582469,
-0.3532110453,
0.2632319033,
-0.1818831861,
0.4739580452,
-0.2319770306,
0.0200950615,
-0.0741769001,
0.3659343719,
-0.7506052852,
0.0139402114,
-0.8773345947,
-0.0102164755,
0.9235528708,
0.1106742173,
-0.1659136117,
-0.2943912745,
-0.5128842592,
0.2639666498,
-0.4265301228,
-0.3184125721,
0.18347013,
0.0433774404,
-0.5460263491,
0.8367155194,
-0.6830585599,
0.5812872052,
-0.4213291407,
-0.006328153,
0.669940412,
-0.8674296141,
-0.0389516763,
0.0167127177,
0.4676094651,
0.7444030046,
0.206249848,
0.2336837202,
-0.4908340275,
0.172052905,
0.1594331264,
-0.6143258214,
-0.1496066153,
0.6750453711,
-0.7478890419,
-0.2783991694,
0.1856644154,
-0.5447240472,
-0.217056334,
-0.6958956718,
0.3744824529,
-0.1934135109,
-0.4560291767,
-0.0912090093,
-0.5245263577,
0.0525887534,
0.7283619642,
-0.6644673347,
0.3266558349,
0.7052716017,
1.1138590574,
-0.5366017818,
-0.4694993794,
-0.5869272351,
0.2571139336,
0.15752846,
0.9759209156,
-0.1709934175,
-0.7058224678,
-0.0986501873,
0.2094931304,
-0.0898866951,
-0.4838252068,
0.537894547,
0.0071349763,
0.1566923857,
-0.1787332892,
-0.5957363844,
-0.2965105176,
0.2652906775,
-0.4547526836,
0.8514765501,
0.2003310025,
-0.74890095,
-0.0430103466,
-0.791736424,
-0.4575272202,
-0.0614215583,
-0.191220656,
-0.4501660168,
0.2511985004,
0.0112172216,
0.3415204287,
0.1846369505,
0.0830103159,
0.0962860212,
-0.3172124028,
0.046341341,
-0.1946865916,
0.7034318447,
0.2400833815,
0.0435960889,
0.5200275183,
-0.8114637136,
-0.3854926527,
0.0839910656,
-0.6111899018,
-0.3501436114,
-0.3044537306,
0.4146236181,
0.2269670218,
0.6060479283,
-0.3680286407,
0.3675674498,
0.0112119503,
0.0857410654,
0.7938028574,
0.1064907834,
0.3806331158,
-0.7470705509,
0.3794768155,
-0.0106931385,
0.0083707152,
-0.8350413442,
-0.7298013568,
-0.8281074762,
-0.3537972569,
0.4636199474,
0.8358079791,
-0.446768254,
0.3185656071,
-0.1218426377,
-0.6565039754,
-0.6680790782,
-0.1878984571,
0.3326545358,
0.3394233882,
0.3661303818,
-0.3553041816,
-0.8460814357,
-1.0551878214,
0.1809466779,
-0.1949916631,
-0.1342099309,
0.0076728608,
0.8633806109,
-0.2715986669,
0.6465374827,
-0.5485846996,
-0.4054248333,
-0.2973542511,
0.6266325712,
0.1781537235,
0.5607702136,
0.4993119836,
-0.9952692389,
-0.3206736445,
0.0560291335,
-0.7956552505,
-0.4051742256,
-0.0136982473,
0.1155981123,
0.7554913759,
0.511276722,
-0.7099434733,
0.3808432817,
0.6234428287,
-0.3798869252,
0.6135568619,
-0.4608474076,
0.2430047244,
-1.2259914875,
0.1171876863,
-0.0784773678,
-0.2486682236,
-0.4579089582,
0.0420432203,
-0.1892616451,
-0.1226846129,
-0.3917697668,
0.5685880184,
-0.284650445,
-0.3673100471,
-0.6628744006,
0.2182203382,
-0.15867275,
0.3709471524,
0.4988172054,
0.4063619673,
0.3649858236,
-0.6333050728,
0.3887065947,
0.1163156405,
0.1416586041,
0.7583432794,
-0.7820231915,
-0.1448064148,
-0.1851608753,
0.4515156448,
-0.9863207936,
-0.1374701709,
0.0492210127,
-0.7363189459,
0.0223879609,
-0.0776996166,
-0.3715726435,
-0.0503101945,
-0.467528224,
0.311602056,
0.3013037145,
-0.0927527547,
0.5080237985,
0.6371454597,
-0.5149260163,
-0.5370820761,
-0.5516107678,
0.1417787969,
-0.1800575405,
-0.4577707946,
0.426117301,
-0.0065425755,
-0.3669534922,
0.3602668643,
0.0241647121,
0.0552670658,
0.0871109441,
0.4101946354,
0.2711976469,
-0.1770960987,
0.045618657,
0.1724960506,
-0.5864195824,
-0.0079052821,
-0.1702173948,
0.5890914798,
-0.2451810688,
-0.2091290057,
-0.412406683,
0.7850578427,
0.2959122956,
-0.3479460478,
0.422401458,
0.6783656478,
-0.5318456292,
0.2815105915,
-0.2070655376,
0.0306506976,
-0.3444319665,
0.3407372832,
-0.3485561311,
-0.7313022017,
0.4486702383,
0.0561239123,
0.5465557575,
0.62116611,
0.725525558,
-0.1389870495,
0.7174955606,
0.6610730886,
-0.1458670646,
0.2257879674,
-0.3889409304,
-0.5507095456,
-0.5181165338,
-0.2197469473,
-0.5858467221,
-0.2970891595,
-0.6862679124,
-0.4841191173,
0.3052192926,
-0.242946893,
0.1439100802,
0.3357640505,
-0.3541128933,
0.2393690944,
0.8258062005,
-0.2327830195,
0.6483618617,
-0.2326130569,
0.3409573138,
0.2429656386,
-0.3526085913,
-0.4134469628,
1.1747119427,
0.2590993047,
0.2370738685,
0.1081118956,
1.0075597763,
0.5394567847,
0.0986555368,
-0.7125980854,
0.581117332,
-0.1048853844,
-0.5217115283,
-0.4313457906,
-0.2938601673,
-1.135030508,
0.5379073024,
-0.1771400422,
-0.6295125484,
-0.0769923925,
-0.0578550324,
-0.0587782189,
-0.1957523674,
-0.5880697966,
0.6170246601,
-0.0626576766,
0.1021622568,
-0.5257279873,
-0.8372085094,
0.4388979375,
-0.1235202104,
0.3618463278,
-0.1909650713,
-0.2724775672,
0.7389528751,
-0.2374334484,
0.4912362993,
-0.1552028507,
-0.0099759251,
0.1877387315,
-0.498519361,
0.1824955791,
0.2802777588,
-0.0607843511,
0.1536400616,
-0.1099598184,
-0.6567982435,
-0.0908568501,
0.6833517551,
-0.6318787336,
-0.3930382729,
-0.7851786613,
-0.6162798405,
0.3143305182,
0.3640250862,
0.3083812594,
0.3198099732,
-0.2751686275,
0.0937426388,
0.5325366855,
-0.1561933756,
0.4352405965,
0.7429606318,
-0.4410300851,
-0.4907025993,
1.1494554281,
0.2073122859,
0.1252755225,
0.6008981466,
-0.1178807095,
-0.1652917266,
-0.7331548929,
-0.4463018179,
0.5132728815,
-0.5751819611,
0.0018349454,
-0.8099291921,
-0.4660353959,
-0.4111815989,
-0.2646444142,
-0.4522922337,
-0.8969091177,
-0.1314918101,
-0.1991609633,
0.1027195007,
1.0033127069,
-0.4633671045,
0.2641118169,
-0.8010496497,
0.7970520258,
-0.0236238912,
-0.1416320503,
-0.4133212864,
-0.4117200971,
-0.4455789626,
-0.1121958941,
-0.4292407632,
-0.7261093855,
0.3419440091,
-0.0172614139,
0.4939008951,
0.2935707271,
0.2282138318,
0.1394776553,
-0.1810973734,
0.7907916903,
-0.0185230933,
-0.8186106682,
0.8626770377,
-0.6158999205,
0.8093855977,
0.5920507312,
0.442896992,
-0.5371701717,
-0.6229479909,
-0.5743963718,
-1.1160203218,
0.6399672627,
0.5085055232,
-0.2087074667,
0.1997986436,
-0.0189460889,
0.1136047691,
0.3152222633,
-0.5808448195,
-0.5851650238,
-0.1717903763,
-0.0916038305,
-0.0271895826,
-0.3117805123,
-0.1785741746,
-0.204711616,
0.7706055045,
0.0237838645,
0.2807103097,
0.1952771544,
0.012708188,
-0.0101148756,
0.1704462022,
1.1045925617,
0.7262974977,
-0.3633863926,
0.0810942054,
0.0994314253,
-0.4603430927,
-0.0635434613,
0.5789521933,
-0.3095292747,
0.4954234064,
0.4816368818,
0.6585586071,
-0.074302502,
-0.6907604933,
0.5430500507,
-0.2976224422,
-0.4658678472,
-0.6719924808,
-0.281317234,
0.2714219391,
0.2573550642,
0.6947473288,
0.0303836968,
0.3812410235,
-0.478644371,
0.3884671926,
0.1540269852,
-0.3052243292,
-0.2846277952,
0.6439109445,
0.4885721803,
-0.1540418416,
0.3544363976,
-0.3010543883,
-0.3796599209,
0.7260757089,
0.2788735032,
0.6357758641,
-0.5076779723,
0.3367230594,
0.4255695045,
0.3258399069,
0.0762982965,
0.5662764311,
0.0523837619,
-0.33574754,
-0.2580929697,
-0.4716874957,
-0.6492393613,
0.2999161184,
-0.6452732086,
0.6591999531,
0.1794146448,
0.1730000824,
0.0641464964,
0.0954093486,
-0.1163032576,
0.3444570303,
0.050948631,
0.7391875386,
-0.8288235664,
0.7886007428,
0.864654541,
-0.3178726137,
0.0930047259,
-0.2894099355,
0.3485363722,
-0.5593009591,
0.1366791874,
0.3843649328,
0.1775848567,
-0.2288605422,
-0.0371234678,
-0.6337742805,
1.0841181278,
0.08457461,
-0.2747921944,
-0.2357379198,
0.1025313586,
0.4193355441,
-0.3500522673,
0.0614263788,
0.5416445136,
0.6564408541,
-0.0570006743,
-1.1164935827,
-0.1546373665,
-0.589097321,
-0.488499403,
0.1686879843,
-0.7609544396,
0.9602490067,
-0.3730587065,
-0.1397020221,
0.2171893418,
1.0174992085,
0.5960982442,
0.8551769257,
0.4610291123,
0.5246406198,
0.6149340868,
-0.0810032487,
0.9879834652,
-0.2172569484,
0.2350403219,
1.4759449959,
0.220321551,
0.7361605167,
0.4312144518,
0.0178942792,
-0.0368555002,
0.6074165702,
0.0003641662,
0.3676765561,
0.1951907426,
-0.200358212,
0.1668527275,
-0.5083524585,
-0.6190983653,
0.7638677359,
0.4813605547,
-0.3601572216,
-0.2725282013,
-0.1383721083,
0.1106799245,
0.123936601,
-0.2724862099,
0.7928665876,
0.2837320268,
-0.6521615386,
0.4199247956,
0.4059749842,
0.7012231946,
-0.5655511618,
-0.1661421657,
-0.2026357204,
0.1310230792,
-0.3255539238,
-0.849104166,
0.5996180177,
-0.1013117433,
-0.2002014667,
-0.1081814021,
0.5980579853,
-0.6870564818,
-0.3983644843,
0.1971443892,
0.6049627662,
0.3082094789,
-0.1623602509,
-0.4648639858,
0.2196493,
-0.0529425256,
-0.3248874247,
0.3198259771,
0.4067480862,
-0.0362606123,
0.4544698298,
0.302393347,
-0.000204813,
-0.2852743864,
-0.0597182699,
0.6898862123,
-0.5249760151,
-0.5721513033,
-0.5980600119,
0.5977231264,
-0.3025816679,
-0.5297433734,
0.8114083409,
1.1181762218,
0.8938410282,
-0.0874346793,
1.2935612202,
0.0294303969,
0.6750558615,
-0.4975930452,
0.7474698424,
-0.5962636471,
0.0072603445,
-0.1445011348,
-0.9113221765,
-0.0524839461,
0.3678922057,
0.2281996608,
-0.2975362539,
0.6743882895,
0.3648221493,
0.1067626625,
0.082424745,
0.1617598832,
0.0568853728,
0.1413714886,
0.5817549825,
0.6211990118,
-0.5017567277,
0.4331815541,
-0.3568097651,
-0.2865727842,
-0.4128646255,
-0.6222677231,
-0.7158004642,
-1.0903289318,
-0.4080088139,
-0.180475533,
0.1761353016,
0.7631219625,
0.4529101253,
-0.9080187678,
-0.4992350638,
0.1520200223,
0.3167147338,
-0.1693648994,
-0.265542388,
0.4297089577,
0.0859974623,
-1.1275902987,
0.265160948,
0.3256384134,
0.2244718075,
-0.0975230709,
-0.1075655371,
-0.4163889587,
0.0343695059,
0.777730763,
0.2818905413,
-0.3969551921,
-0.1171161085,
-0.2614539564,
-0.0819430947,
-0.1402471811,
0.6895350814,
-0.6062928438,
0.2971059084,
0.6716919541,
0.4583773017,
0.7485774159,
0.2423255742,
0.7316166759,
-0.7630474567,
0.2916587293,
-0.133823514,
0.433268398,
0.199413836,
-0.1288839579,
0.8845332861,
0.4322029948,
-0.5970708728,
-0.9252980351,
0.2629951537,
-1.4339860678,
-0.4296032786,
1.2558939457,
-0.1108184531,
0.0812487453,
-0.4621680081,
-0.46677351,
0.3941703737,
-0.7873757482,
0.688159585,
0.5665561557,
-0.2437334061,
-0.2391954064,
-0.593621254,
0.2887020111,
0.0410118587,
-1.0542007685,
-0.0732040703,
0.5975703597,
-0.1600757539,
0.2137555182,
0.9858193994,
0.0154974759,
0.529450953,
0.0656533837,
-0.046425987,
-0.2569651604,
-0.5179817677,
-0.2986955345,
0.2765545249,
-0.2593677342,
-0.2599779963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15513v1
|
A Comparative and Experimental Study on Automatic Question Answering Systems and its Robustness against Word Jumbling
| 2023-11-27T03:17:09 | 2023-11-27T03:17:09 |
Shashidhar Reddy Javaji, Haoran Hu, Sai Sameer Vennam, Vijaya Gajanan Buddhavarapu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Question answer generation using Natural Language Processing models is
ubiquitous in the world around us. It is used in many use cases such as the
building of chat bots, suggestive prompts in google search and also as a way of
navigating information in banking mobile applications etc. It is highly
relevant because a frequently asked questions (FAQ) list can only have a finite
amount of questions but a model which can perform question answer generation
could be able to answer completely new questions that are within the scope of
the data. This helps us to be able to answer new questions accurately as long
as it is a relevant question. In commercial applications, it can be used to
increase customer satisfaction and ease of usage. However a lot of data is
generated by humans so it is susceptible to human error and this can adversely
affect the model's performance and we are investigating this through our work
|
[
-0.4683752656,
-1.4208118916,
0.3747676909,
-0.0270196032,
-0.0590442941,
-0.0388890505,
0.3115458488,
-0.5371610522,
-0.2351012677,
0.4919692874,
-0.3939037025,
-0.0161076784,
-0.2078267336,
0.4077122808,
-0.748493433,
0.7975537181,
0.1318657696,
0.0448565744,
-0.534861207,
-0.290199846,
-0.4957107902,
-0.6086280346,
-0.9404240847,
-0.1574160457,
0.0554236844,
0.0391491279,
1.0755339861,
0.1002632678,
0.5117907524,
0.4357555807,
-0.0094991038,
0.1181927919,
-0.0323516652,
0.540964067,
-0.2865612209,
-0.7000780106,
-0.2466257066,
-0.1429990083,
0.300943464,
0.6714673638,
-0.2385536879,
0.1707794964,
0.2208212465,
0.7919468284,
-0.4938265681,
-0.1697815359,
-0.8740260601,
-0.2387236804,
-0.075735949,
0.0122519769,
-0.0410306081,
-0.5800683498,
0.1603723615,
-0.6952773333,
0.2650199831,
0.3185538352,
1.0779101849,
0.4581189156,
-0.3687763512,
-0.6435997486,
-0.6804550886,
0.3640392721,
-0.8174550533,
0.2184673995,
0.3619177639,
0.6067479253,
-0.4627233148,
-0.3955894709,
-0.7431670427,
-0.1477143168,
-0.0622658357,
0.0345499776,
-0.3714109659,
0.0831659436,
0.3151550591,
0.5586684346,
-0.9680506587,
-0.2153100967,
-0.3071395457,
-0.2746590972,
0.7302113771,
0.4805648327,
0.6276176572,
-0.2087488025,
-0.1101980209,
-0.269331038,
-0.4512265325,
0.4767358303,
0.5044852495,
0.16115807,
0.2517070472,
0.5197466016,
-0.7640904188,
0.9811319113,
0.2887813747,
0.1316905618,
0.0217883978,
-0.3433497548,
-0.3521921337,
-0.6298832893,
0.8752686381,
0.3427596092,
0.5022759438,
-0.2016550004,
-0.2606996,
0.335154295,
0.6305139661,
-0.5156689882,
-0.2106485963,
0.2674808204,
-0.1822472066,
-0.4819245636,
0.0598819889,
-0.5971012712,
-0.2172319293,
-0.0003497011,
0.7149387002,
-0.4931507409,
-0.0847893506,
0.1019840837,
-0.1181285605,
0.2757808268,
0.140462324,
-0.5609252453,
0.5210106373,
0.4302589893,
0.5638113022,
-0.1490926296,
0.1035493612,
-0.4925866425,
-0.1986754239,
-0.2850035131,
0.9354754686,
-0.3015540838,
-0.2871427536,
0.0180937592,
-0.1221879721,
-0.213875711,
-0.6679497361,
0.6687400937,
-0.8624513745,
0.5351691842,
0.0343202055,
-0.7537724972,
-0.283418864,
0.4915340245,
-0.8034396172,
0.9297566414,
0.148153618,
-0.9534242749,
0.3364513218,
-0.7147391438,
-0.4766190052,
0.1365792155,
-0.1048036516,
-0.3880500793,
0.0515613444,
0.2594206333,
0.3926277161,
-0.2432887554,
0.2259147614,
-0.2110088915,
-0.3729115725,
0.6527473927,
-0.3695478141,
0.7542925477,
0.5081215501,
-0.2139378637,
-0.2303947955,
-0.6736864448,
0.2359416932,
0.2901696861,
-0.3462307155,
-0.4516261816,
-0.1041013375,
-0.2413142025,
0.2458230555,
0.0653094724,
-0.4718554318,
-0.0004316885,
-0.6621508002,
0.1774884462,
0.25294137,
0.2010682523,
0.2962140143,
-0.5820931196,
0.9513537884,
0.0118497983,
0.0128866071,
-0.160408482,
-0.6165220141,
-0.3854009807,
0.3473545909,
0.6608725786,
0.9871165752,
-1.2278082371,
0.4036698937,
-0.0107832784,
-0.4843414724,
-0.5373189449,
0.182081908,
0.3647290766,
0.7604941726,
-0.0006979439,
-0.4327383339,
-0.2147900462,
-0.9015962481,
-0.4163191617,
-0.4429416358,
-0.4024132192,
0.3160806298,
0.334063679,
0.0179536082,
0.9929669499,
-0.4334232509,
0.3457065225,
-0.2000637501,
0.2439160198,
-0.0405486785,
0.2595743537,
0.4243917167,
-0.9630441666,
-0.3713638186,
-0.4558537006,
-0.7832054496,
-0.3650914729,
-0.1217208579,
-0.1377578229,
0.6438187361,
0.2103496343,
-0.6443558335,
0.9008331895,
0.4583754539,
-0.3695549071,
0.4637575448,
-0.1585903615,
0.3600052893,
-1.1220397949,
0.3226269186,
-0.0710281953,
-0.3217024207,
-0.7375330925,
0.1533435583,
0.0565075763,
-0.1522414386,
-0.3025175333,
0.4021342993,
-0.1721659303,
0.0516166389,
-0.472264111,
0.0943474472,
0.28263399,
0.2155645341,
-0.1174146906,
1.1331737041,
0.3643857241,
-0.9899909496,
0.2641197145,
0.3291250765,
-0.3165353835,
0.5727938414,
-0.9880048633,
0.0219949242,
0.0579413883,
0.2027599961,
-1.3849539757,
-0.3444358408,
0.2761768699,
-0.8495833874,
0.0125794178,
0.3896326721,
-0.7380309105,
-0.5571098328,
-0.2883535028,
0.2831783891,
0.6133923531,
-0.2283509672,
0.2412905246,
0.442085892,
-0.4112436771,
-0.1135965958,
-0.5959160328,
-0.1171745285,
-0.3897974491,
-1.056641221,
-0.2791488767,
-0.3155241311,
-0.4105370641,
-0.151066497,
-0.0037271807,
-0.2764082253,
0.5452415943,
0.2778146267,
0.3286839724,
-0.1259345859,
0.4035910368,
0.1223686337,
0.0203638002,
0.1733535677,
0.23508811,
0.6112277508,
-0.1973624527,
-0.305531472,
-0.4474051595,
0.6729362011,
0.5160245299,
-0.034696199,
0.7153632641,
0.2046521604,
-0.3394996524,
0.1436990201,
-0.600497663,
-0.1876863986,
-0.5412487388,
-0.0021075308,
-0.3744669259,
-0.7163543701,
0.4890669882,
0.1384065747,
0.0970747247,
0.4311033487,
0.3669763803,
-0.3090364039,
1.3740981817,
0.5122546554,
-0.1388638765,
0.2355590016,
0.4727262259,
0.1419616938,
-0.4533912241,
0.3774126768,
-0.6707481742,
-0.0310317986,
-0.6382489204,
-0.0507993363,
0.4164736569,
0.1051564291,
-0.0422038212,
0.3223451972,
-0.6251562238,
0.1068934798,
0.5628907681,
-0.2242706418,
0.3548377752,
-0.0362896845,
-0.346458286,
0.2043311894,
-0.7251594663,
-0.9037111402,
1.1542752981,
0.0584619008,
0.7021862864,
-0.183694765,
0.5139814615,
0.2518684864,
0.129518643,
-0.4544227123,
0.4666848779,
0.1495064646,
-0.9719062448,
-0.5847063065,
-0.432051301,
-1.2100734711,
0.3060880303,
-0.2616991401,
-0.6796294451,
-0.4768351018,
0.2675988972,
-0.6345498562,
0.2433795929,
-0.802121222,
0.59082371,
-0.1821927875,
-0.3869412839,
0.3210855126,
-0.8879239559,
0.3098787665,
0.025069017,
0.1051214263,
0.3017159402,
0.1963301152,
0.81648314,
-0.2111624181,
0.5886512995,
-0.035053283,
-0.3270065486,
0.6644788384,
0.199479416,
0.3197712004,
-0.0247254707,
-0.2917245626,
-0.2316471338,
0.2306069732,
-0.2888605297,
-0.6285316944,
0.3271522224,
-0.531855762,
-0.7737182379,
-0.4604686499,
-0.7680329084,
-0.4552096128,
-0.0472516902,
0.2632604241,
0.2420328856,
-0.2798762321,
0.0586379021,
0.7313022017,
-0.3261551261,
0.2754700184,
0.4201801717,
-0.3351038694,
-0.1935766339,
0.5552138686,
0.1103081629,
0.4024493098,
0.197224915,
0.1244730204,
-0.4272487164,
-0.5204308033,
-0.6926909685,
-0.0156262033,
-0.3207970858,
-0.271163702,
-0.6597347856,
-0.2621078789,
-0.681417346,
-0.0465601459,
0.0223578718,
-0.6753343344,
0.0278922226,
0.012618877,
0.201619342,
0.5695756674,
0.3201114237,
0.1962455809,
-1.0691102743,
0.5281225443,
0.5406591296,
0.1643692851,
-0.1923338771,
-0.3309375942,
0.1183579713,
0.2566663921,
-0.7069286704,
-1.0150299072,
0.2413423359,
0.0003590122,
0.5565555096,
0.2929259837,
0.2661427557,
0.5291904211,
-0.1803918183,
0.9883124828,
-0.2348770648,
-0.731272459,
0.6009486914,
-0.4968222678,
0.7236247659,
1.0338323116,
0.3312277198,
-0.6190604568,
-0.7523851991,
-1.0168659687,
-0.8720746636,
0.396337539,
0.4066128731,
0.0056919358,
0.0689819083,
0.4447401464,
0.487236172,
0.5273172259,
-0.485969305,
-0.0216445681,
0.0424252972,
-0.1950707585,
0.2395614088,
0.0659388825,
0.0689646229,
-0.107934624,
0.7736384273,
-0.0791236609,
0.1116732806,
0.1592372358,
-0.0890698507,
-0.2463739812,
0.4381571412,
0.4754544497,
0.3562688231,
-0.0191635545,
-0.1312424988,
0.3135710061,
-0.3783275187,
-0.0390111506,
-0.0212837961,
-0.5488239527,
-0.0333139673,
-0.0821669027,
0.3333236575,
-0.2087109089,
-0.8425100446,
0.2809199691,
-0.3545282781,
-0.3226014972,
-0.3863891363,
0.5092864633,
0.2617992163,
-0.0192585643,
0.2583104074,
-0.0277893096,
0.4996337891,
-0.4876084626,
0.2453337312,
0.5984117389,
-0.0732651129,
-0.1064035669,
0.7056198716,
0.3758348823,
-0.6482201219,
0.7500090599,
-0.3571024835,
-0.5486667156,
0.4726120234,
0.4137312174,
0.6082492471,
-0.2704665065,
0.1456168145,
0.3731988072,
0.1279108673,
0.0317508429,
0.3280070126,
-0.2708615363,
-0.6410055161,
0.0187810007,
-0.5019611716,
-0.5880335569,
0.1936225146,
-0.76459831,
-0.1731187105,
-0.2209939212,
-0.2771484554,
-0.3136834204,
0.1365034729,
-0.6946225762,
0.5350850821,
0.0822376534,
0.7960953712,
-0.9265091419,
0.6313074231,
0.9869481325,
-0.3379653096,
-0.7592656612,
0.1734640598,
-0.0531885177,
-0.455390811,
0.2838191688,
0.3004829586,
-0.1355825663,
-0.4052976072,
-0.7075661421,
-0.6906883121,
1.1505309343,
-0.219176501,
-0.3398992717,
-0.0825757384,
0.6074399948,
0.8261659741,
-0.0907315165,
0.241629228,
0.6255598664,
0.2751071751,
0.0642160848,
-1.0712982416,
0.0869301781,
-0.579069674,
-0.0104981856,
0.2783096135,
-0.50763762,
0.6503595114,
0.2069238424,
-0.414930135,
0.5064398646,
0.4794548154,
0.5058889389,
0.5753780007,
0.9149479866,
0.5747528672,
0.8403499126,
0.0114630619,
1.0753996372,
-0.3099042177,
-0.0498810597,
0.9582331777,
-0.5578145385,
0.7216799259,
0.6201075912,
-0.1870769709,
0.1689309329,
0.329151541,
0.2367574722,
0.2865979671,
0.4860888124,
-0.0205922294,
-0.3043019176,
0.2400350124,
-0.2121023834,
0.4260790944,
0.373460561,
0.0142538911,
-0.2202319652,
-0.150232628,
-0.1772893965,
0.3194887936,
0.1045123413,
0.8730846047,
-0.0252857357,
-0.9933797121,
0.4749495089,
-0.1890290976,
0.8654235601,
-0.4392712116,
0.1105688214,
-0.1632837057,
-0.0180762745,
0.0771556199,
-0.6621184349,
0.5845680237,
0.235783875,
0.0057218112,
0.0288488474,
1.0691715479,
-0.0467608236,
-0.5431744456,
-0.2301084995,
0.8892039657,
0.150758028,
-0.1894766986,
-0.7487694025,
-0.3780829906,
-0.1965975612,
-0.5173181891,
0.2306175977,
0.3977983296,
-0.277897507,
1.0007236004,
0.392604053,
-0.1170227602,
0.3406329155,
-0.337543875,
0.6517742872,
-0.6055309176,
-0.7502573729,
-0.4373899996,
0.6251024008,
-0.3060540259,
-0.2760774791,
0.8316972852,
0.4160796106,
0.7049713135,
0.0372594185,
0.8401713371,
-0.114395842,
0.9628379941,
-0.280299753,
0.9230659008,
-0.5825834274,
0.222522974,
-0.3136116266,
-0.5927675962,
-0.1734514385,
0.5825428963,
-0.3118724227,
-0.0880753621,
0.5729397535,
0.8123453856,
0.208086729,
0.3838918507,
0.4093505442,
-0.3395692408,
0.2453567535,
0.5289214253,
0.9355168343,
-0.6425147057,
0.7938526869,
-0.2285247296,
0.1110582724,
-0.0820215195,
-0.4571999907,
-0.7303181887,
-0.6575431228,
-0.3528241217,
-0.0989389494,
0.0555258282,
0.4825361073,
0.2877425849,
-0.8386474848,
-0.082300812,
-0.2111276388,
0.0071337176,
-0.0957928076,
-0.3420692682,
0.0084596137,
-0.4083841145,
-0.6189292073,
0.0285265837,
-0.114618361,
0.1767041534,
-0.0135112284,
0.2981490195,
-0.3270862103,
0.3402723968,
0.2864185572,
0.3185276389,
-0.4058653116,
-0.356364429,
0.183381319,
-0.2280147672,
0.0993861556,
0.6013016701,
-1.0049015284,
0.2997968495,
0.8204202652,
0.8615066409,
-0.0668670908,
0.4317328036,
0.753929913,
-0.4733214974,
-0.1517206132,
0.1804283261,
0.1375902593,
0.431918323,
-0.3716412783,
0.5783025622,
-0.1809841394,
-0.7875376344,
-0.5533419847,
0.1623156667,
-0.9217631221,
-0.2742497325,
1.0489356518,
-0.0219305139,
-0.3685769141,
-0.5268937945,
-0.3799307048,
0.4526053071,
-0.409950465,
1.1636966467,
0.9098775983,
-0.3505649865,
0.3042184412,
-0.7029790282,
0.2822152078,
0.7206258774,
-0.9680966735,
-0.2031706274,
0.4303609133,
0.5164610744,
0.226745218,
0.455786407,
-0.2137437761,
0.4813373089,
-0.1238257289,
-0.0728354082,
0.0022800055,
0.1441996247,
-0.4586180151,
0.5237421989,
0.194603622,
-0.4464608729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15509v1
|
A Corpus for Named Entity Recognition in Chinese Novels with Multi-genres
| 2023-11-27T03:08:41 | 2023-11-27T03:08:41 |
Hanjie Zhao, Jinge Xie, Yuchen Yan, Yuxiang Jia, Yawen Ye, Hongying Zan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entities like person, location, organization are important for literary text
analysis. The lack of annotated data hinders the progress of named entity
recognition (NER) in literary domain. To promote the research of literary NER,
we build the largest multi-genre literary NER corpus containing 263,135
entities in 105,851 sentences from 260 online Chinese novels spanning 13
different genres. Based on the corpus, we investigate characteristics of
entities from different genres. We propose several baseline NER models and
conduct cross-genre and cross-domain experiments. Experimental results show
that genre difference significantly impact NER performance though not as much
as domain difference like literary domain and news domain. Compared with NER in
news domain, literary NER still needs much improvement and the
Out-of-Vocabulary (OOV) problem is more challenging due to the high variety of
entities in literary works.
|
[
-0.2924029827,
-0.3740813732,
0.3306470811,
0.0816745684,
0.0767563358,
0.1171401143,
-0.4823772907,
-0.8785874844,
0.4353953302,
0.6320577264,
-0.1246571764,
-0.2097113281,
-0.4073120058,
0.5974989533,
-0.3101767898,
1.1279908419,
0.1169733405,
-0.0429926999,
0.0195015445,
-0.0977882743,
-0.2997789979,
-0.5353919864,
-0.9416182041,
0.0899135694,
0.854581356,
-0.2542692125,
0.3587886095,
0.244457081,
0.7241153121,
0.3886290491,
0.0158042535,
0.2876366377,
-0.144756183,
0.0978778601,
-0.1071840525,
-0.3814743459,
-0.3171419799,
-0.309453845,
0.9102630615,
0.1901988238,
0.2726305425,
-0.1529465467,
0.0634277388,
0.3129630983,
-0.5371909142,
0.0727077648,
-0.437605381,
-0.1142615676,
-0.7143631577,
-0.2459532768,
-0.5424403548,
-0.3100155294,
0.2610192001,
-0.9099223018,
0.4295107424,
0.3456633985,
1.3297852278,
-0.195314467,
-0.5667580962,
-0.300441891,
-0.9182715416,
0.6790300012,
-0.5278929472,
0.263890475,
0.1295837909,
0.09183532,
-0.2546078861,
-0.5607304573,
-0.7821242809,
-0.2388464212,
-0.4380300045,
-0.1940357089,
0.0261752103,
0.0274620801,
0.2699391246,
0.2074086219,
-0.346488446,
0.1006017104,
-0.3205932379,
-0.3720240593,
0.800447166,
0.2896355391,
0.8191165924,
-0.4391108751,
-0.5249207616,
0.1681192666,
-0.5519886613,
0.3312779963,
0.3406146467,
0.1891850829,
0.1896421313,
0.1673437357,
0.0982037187,
0.5432279706,
0.0195131823,
-0.5494701266,
0.3918871582,
-0.2522834837,
-0.0572597943,
0.3434430361,
0.8319969177,
0.3129818141,
0.1883689314,
-0.3130955696,
-0.2475907952,
-0.1217448935,
0.0121397497,
-0.8178098798,
-0.3223122358,
0.2110629082,
-0.4042174816,
0.1117122993,
0.0404327884,
-0.5304724574,
-0.9275745749,
-0.1842586845,
0.1780628115,
-0.7067551613,
-0.5562568307,
-0.2557208538,
-0.6198543906,
0.3661461174,
0.4741361141,
-0.7767717838,
0.1316022128,
0.4376721382,
0.6874915957,
-0.3903288841,
-0.493519932,
-0.2403324693,
0.1802373976,
-0.3659411967,
1.0063611269,
-0.3935961723,
0.1622707993,
-0.1258190572,
0.25652349,
-0.4610641897,
-0.319720149,
0.5909534097,
-0.5741307735,
-0.0690827891,
-0.2734921277,
-0.5927581191,
-0.4812152088,
0.1358436942,
-1.1728187799,
0.866328299,
-0.114344798,
-0.8709680438,
0.5021057129,
-0.345582962,
-0.4579901993,
0.4453194141,
-0.2370283157,
-0.2600326538,
-0.0149500119,
0.1459455937,
0.5691609979,
-0.3628157079,
0.4901808798,
-0.0311665591,
-0.5055583119,
0.6073938608,
-0.0373633392,
0.7924518585,
0.1103134155,
-0.0285816733,
0.0269960854,
-0.8440025449,
-0.0519896746,
0.0272303466,
-0.1579545885,
-1.0938017368,
0.1565286368,
0.904312551,
-0.2121688575,
0.0810723305,
-0.8026453853,
0.1022778079,
-0.3976460695,
0.5161166787,
0.115458928,
0.1455747038,
0.2196836025,
-0.5589827895,
0.3878103793,
0.0525761843,
-0.5053149462,
-0.2054516077,
-0.399831444,
-0.7594345212,
-0.5243356824,
0.84647578,
0.5222347379,
-1.0238310099,
0.3382527828,
-0.1775798351,
-0.6604301333,
-0.5151863694,
-0.4401082098,
0.3229683936,
0.0559611022,
0.3265510499,
0.0146815674,
-0.5258406997,
-0.6334967613,
-0.3817562759,
-0.0439751633,
0.0938988551,
0.0170625504,
0.6113994718,
0.095885016,
1.0160461664,
-0.312926501,
-0.6374794841,
-0.5478520989,
0.0926038027,
-0.1308912486,
0.1589063406,
0.7098340988,
-1.0643957853,
-0.5026448369,
0.1145000532,
-0.6869491935,
0.1262480468,
-0.4681096375,
-0.0083169146,
0.2362939268,
0.4728523791,
-0.4711180031,
0.2449727207,
0.0522158407,
-0.132777974,
0.560714066,
0.0508078523,
0.264303416,
-1.0784459114,
-0.0207847338,
0.1417326778,
0.2165733576,
-0.654879272,
0.2473368645,
0.2674379647,
0.1068277732,
-0.3341430724,
0.842069149,
-0.9677684307,
0.3198376,
-0.0835787356,
0.4477743208,
0.1687175184,
0.4353922307,
0.5291858315,
0.481200844,
0.5414233804,
-0.9653946757,
0.3677383363,
0.0481580608,
-0.6980028152,
0.56264323,
-0.3868949711,
-0.1317910999,
-0.4531114101,
0.2096561044,
-0.9229720235,
-0.2883749008,
0.2378414869,
-0.2529551089,
0.3705884516,
0.0455033444,
-0.4273346961,
0.124350138,
-0.2292558402,
0.4764511883,
-0.0842531323,
-0.3340415657,
0.8208059669,
0.4915487468,
-0.1944171935,
-0.658798039,
-0.5754367709,
0.153530255,
-0.5528408885,
-0.3519738019,
0.8268887401,
0.0526071824,
-0.1084269285,
0.1962792873,
0.4404993057,
-0.3813957274,
-0.1481515318,
-0.0086793089,
0.2957001925,
-0.3815003932,
0.6681424975,
0.0624400973,
0.1344470233,
-0.1835790277,
0.2347628027,
0.2445073873,
0.0697774291,
0.354763031,
-0.3356949985,
0.2526035607,
0.1426558495,
-0.5935340524,
0.5959492326,
0.6293355227,
-0.6158540845,
-0.4125186503,
-0.3866260052,
0.4382863045,
-0.3750140965,
0.3900330961,
-0.6234502196,
-0.6629891396,
0.4513094127,
0.1506803036,
-0.0602439232,
0.7707343102,
0.3065984249,
0.2217722386,
-0.0169125888,
0.5288664699,
-0.0411940254,
0.3035508096,
0.1134339198,
0.2808926105,
-1.0607171059,
-0.1481421143,
-0.5731700063,
-0.3113801181,
-0.727073133,
-0.137864843,
0.1676094979,
-0.0180806685,
0.1144578978,
0.9024893641,
-0.6567294598,
0.5443010926,
0.1104142442,
-0.1403027326,
0.606608212,
-0.0936474279,
-0.0122669265,
-0.3125189543,
-0.0062678927,
-0.4825693667,
0.784997046,
0.1816044599,
0.5775800347,
0.4120004475,
0.7791633606,
0.3278106451,
0.2137802392,
-0.8748486638,
0.494260788,
-0.1625682116,
-0.9087405205,
-0.5043308139,
-0.2350790501,
-1.1426173449,
0.459423393,
-0.2220262289,
-0.8014581203,
0.5258681178,
-0.5912091732,
-0.7890706062,
0.2777881026,
-0.2835372388,
0.6371142864,
-0.3009019196,
0.2566708326,
0.2611506879,
-0.282523185,
0.2759126127,
-0.2209204882,
0.1384581923,
-0.1389995813,
-0.1917531043,
0.7471000552,
0.0295823906,
0.629535377,
0.2106730342,
-0.0867441371,
0.5297676921,
-0.0983305946,
0.082389541,
-0.0514590479,
-0.2391231507,
0.3637014925,
0.1780313253,
0.0601661019,
-0.3575743437,
0.626057744,
-0.5985836983,
-0.0991246924,
-0.8424900174,
-0.3693460524,
0.1438769996,
0.4707091749,
0.800799191,
0.7357575297,
-0.5566819906,
0.2119989991,
0.5181573033,
-0.3022186756,
0.8406942487,
0.4797400534,
-0.3242271245,
-0.3243072331,
1.0102262497,
0.5226909518,
-0.1343025714,
0.976084888,
-0.2517565191,
-0.1346261352,
-0.6152226329,
-0.7540149689,
0.1793854684,
-0.4570533931,
-0.1729637384,
-0.9737846255,
-0.5985636711,
-0.2499542236,
0.0027048851,
0.0542405657,
-0.1816713363,
-0.3091394007,
0.2120785862,
0.5012949705,
0.5699003339,
0.5880886912,
0.1701075435,
-0.8179132938,
0.3189068735,
-0.4067726433,
0.1778491288,
0.1403297633,
-0.4452869594,
-0.2569918036,
-0.5484246612,
-0.0212159827,
-0.9075036049,
0.6251072884,
0.5377348065,
0.3381997645,
0.4881153107,
0.4514977038,
0.582524538,
-0.6809509397,
0.6230997443,
0.1028335467,
-0.6937179565,
0.0752645433,
-0.265416503,
-0.190481618,
0.3453933299,
0.5962772965,
-0.5512202978,
-0.3943429887,
-0.2897547781,
-0.6430214047,
0.5941314697,
0.2699166238,
0.1636117399,
-0.0220758002,
0.1416419297,
0.1738316268,
0.1832001209,
-1.052801609,
-0.26651752,
0.2655025721,
0.0790716633,
-0.0546824932,
0.1074404344,
0.3104953766,
-0.0360138454,
0.5094417334,
0.1418742985,
0.3352012932,
0.4492696822,
-0.115017049,
0.1695966572,
0.4855979979,
0.1559194773,
0.178636983,
0.0419679098,
-0.2161308676,
-0.0360515714,
-0.5000104308,
-0.0648284033,
0.2842568457,
-0.4480172694,
0.2882157862,
0.534743011,
0.6947894096,
0.1507362425,
-0.6450262666,
0.3625852764,
0.05062842,
0.3077411354,
-0.9699262977,
0.2348309308,
0.0552756749,
0.3130406439,
0.3961922228,
0.0812341496,
0.6256606579,
-0.6329113841,
0.1002331451,
0.297654897,
-0.2337206602,
0.0311346054,
0.4172368944,
0.0543074496,
-0.2127485275,
0.5010607839,
-0.665927887,
-0.3617873192,
0.9673695564,
0.4945652485,
0.905107677,
-0.1079338863,
0.3004449308,
0.4830815494,
0.3556233644,
-0.0502435751,
-0.0870977342,
0.3427177668,
-0.9884659648,
-0.1205753759,
-0.8558802009,
-0.1790951043,
0.1852323264,
-0.3204509318,
0.6840046048,
-0.4544037282,
-0.2720390558,
0.6793839335,
0.0033174951,
-0.377446413,
0.1826588511,
0.2803612351,
0.3124920726,
-0.2190724462,
0.9333441854,
0.8431498408,
-0.7620625496,
-0.891990602,
0.2224478573,
0.0248745903,
-0.0517936945,
0.6561726928,
0.4022338092,
-0.0985901952,
0.0990440622,
-0.1554789394,
-1.0704702139,
1.0433979034,
-0.0949500129,
-0.6016790867,
-0.4367393553,
-0.3304503858,
0.8540470004,
-0.7238078117,
0.6765492558,
0.0474628173,
0.4428623617,
-0.1633494943,
-0.9865117669,
0.1247139946,
-0.5013192296,
0.2114460915,
0.5442653298,
-0.8807166219,
1.2446470261,
-0.2704977989,
-0.6016116738,
0.4306666851,
0.8606010079,
0.2092084736,
0.6713103652,
0.3047026098,
0.1934343576,
0.8226742148,
-0.1426720172,
0.8359907269,
-0.0093961991,
0.319429487,
0.9391560555,
-0.4980640113,
0.8670595288,
-0.2010469884,
-0.196280241,
0.9728235602,
0.6661509871,
-0.4966947138,
0.197694242,
0.3593089581,
-0.1731097251,
-0.1174519062,
-0.2593225241,
-0.4708622396,
0.4366129339,
0.3445104063,
-0.3597545624,
0.0655805469,
0.3211430907,
0.1234189644,
0.1560362279,
-0.3273415267,
0.4892077446,
0.1987150311,
-0.584441185,
0.4084645212,
0.4711509645,
0.8543398976,
-0.5325376987,
-0.0768542662,
0.2809046507,
0.1834525615,
-0.4958600998,
-0.3459289968,
-0.0030100711,
-0.2847769558,
-0.2849698365,
0.3953039646,
1.0037798882,
-0.5734696388,
-0.5249025822,
0.576305747,
0.2637340724,
0.451759696,
-0.3337976038,
-0.2341847569,
-0.3119778335,
-0.2629859149,
-0.1879813671,
0.4478549063,
0.9034273624,
-0.2618804872,
0.307978034,
0.3807412684,
0.1293679476,
-0.0314427279,
-0.1032828912,
0.3434703052,
-1.0751751661,
-0.5980132222,
-0.5856124163,
0.1970361471,
-0.0595589727,
-0.763089478,
0.8165276647,
0.3269152939,
0.719604671,
-0.2422661185,
0.775046587,
-0.5264594555,
0.629806459,
-0.4110157788,
1.0046546459,
-0.6758230329,
0.0968859866,
-0.5152871609,
-0.865676403,
-0.2320985198,
0.3334085941,
-0.0781073794,
-0.0137474025,
0.9881245494,
0.5659031868,
0.2191770822,
0.2407724857,
0.2774694264,
-0.0215460118,
-0.1979789734,
0.6670866609,
0.8401891589,
-0.7466967106,
0.3506219387,
0.0456415303,
0.0426645838,
-0.1135983244,
-0.7907794118,
-1.0786141157,
-0.8001249433,
-0.4565019906,
-0.13860856,
-0.0839178339,
0.8181574345,
0.2216680497,
-0.954634428,
-0.1714270562,
0.3838018179,
0.1333328187,
-0.5143653154,
-0.3082663119,
0.4994963408,
-0.218532443,
-1.0146707296,
0.1599205583,
0.0343903564,
-0.5265829563,
-0.1555902809,
0.1372582465,
-0.3365181386,
0.1772082895,
0.5856112838,
0.1735094041,
-1.0286415815,
0.0305975899,
-0.0326126553,
-0.4438538551,
0.0804543272,
0.9554091096,
-0.6130000949,
0.3177282512,
0.481254369,
0.7649368644,
-0.0120784855,
-0.191167295,
0.0781456679,
-0.4535268247,
-0.3555146158,
0.201812923,
0.4626372159,
0.2850658,
-0.9018141627,
0.3905103505,
0.4467810392,
-0.6168628931,
-0.4863900244,
0.0209546145,
-1.0753668547,
-0.2996586263,
1.1597391367,
-0.212704584,
-0.0060841111,
-0.5636572838,
-0.271738559,
0.188598454,
-0.6946940422,
0.2408049554,
1.1833666563,
-0.3797771037,
-0.272824049,
-0.5896528959,
0.5558334589,
0.021784395,
-0.6775761247,
-0.1160486639,
0.5374682546,
0.2761807144,
0.6203532815,
0.8682231903,
-0.1361359507,
-0.0350668095,
0.0889919922,
0.4194414616,
0.1406757087,
-0.6937548518,
-0.1082816347,
0.4930036962,
-0.1540896744,
0.1095628366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15507v1
|
Improving Word Sense Disambiguation in Neural Machine Translation with Salient Document Context
| 2023-11-27T03:05:48 | 2023-11-27T03:05:48 |
Elijah Rippeth, Marine Carpuat, Kevin Duh, Matt Post
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Lexical ambiguity is a challenging and pervasive problem in machine
translation (\mt). We introduce a simple and scalable approach to resolve
translation ambiguity by incorporating a small amount of extra-sentential
context in neural \mt. Our approach requires no sense annotation and no change
to standard model architectures. Since actual document context is not available
for the vast majority of \mt training data, we collect related sentences for
each input to construct pseudo-documents. Salient words from pseudo-documents
are then encoded as a prefix to each source sentence to condition the
generation of the translation. To evaluate, we release \docmucow, a challenge
set for translation disambiguation based on the English-German \mucow
\cite{raganato-etal-2020-evaluation} augmented with document IDs. Extensive
experiments show that our method translates ambiguous source words better than
strong sentence-level baselines and comparable document-level baselines while
reducing training costs.
|
[
-0.2596573532,
-0.5411543846,
0.7417522073,
-0.0220777895,
-0.6978671551,
-0.19221358,
-0.3360062242,
-0.3871048689,
0.1773101389,
-0.1625453085,
-0.6235043406,
-0.3486385643,
-1.2438474894,
0.4231613576,
-0.2688604295,
0.8320814371,
-0.0734721497,
0.1351152956,
-0.2888379395,
-0.5272266865,
-0.4368834794,
-0.5221033692,
-0.4054883122,
-0.3317633867,
0.8436996341,
0.3333943486,
0.7838523984,
0.4328048825,
0.6171486378,
0.3718243241,
-0.4243945777,
0.4579492807,
-0.1956399083,
0.198538065,
-0.2480762899,
-0.3932366073,
-0.3290362358,
-0.0535726435,
0.4315167367,
0.9361076951,
0.0592053309,
-0.0059170783,
-0.0836405307,
0.5163583159,
-0.602566123,
-0.1625532359,
-0.9139003158,
0.0809423625,
-0.398955673,
-0.0994340479,
-0.1903568059,
0.1317421347,
-0.0309587847,
-0.8284598589,
0.2912220955,
0.131513238,
1.247852087,
0.7153791785,
-0.4092822075,
-0.1901904345,
-0.2989755869,
0.5419479609,
-0.539215982,
0.5590041876,
0.5755811334,
0.1972835958,
-0.2836148143,
-0.8439724445,
-0.9165245891,
0.1338559091,
-0.1127482504,
0.3350406289,
-0.3125168085,
0.0710448995,
0.3494475186,
0.2379181534,
-0.4689507484,
0.0403856374,
-0.3251508176,
-0.2289133519,
0.2620349228,
-0.0519351512,
0.0221908614,
-0.3950027227,
-0.2747793794,
-0.1330604404,
-0.3592505157,
-0.3799699247,
0.2893455923,
0.1835901141,
0.2124185562,
0.6081165671,
0.0010722507,
0.7690182328,
0.1483435482,
0.2502477467,
0.5944755673,
-0.2458639145,
-0.2961059511,
0.0862892866,
0.5713018775,
0.542018652,
-0.0789526179,
-0.1861261576,
-0.3498018086,
-0.0255386997,
0.3764570057,
-0.4239881337,
-0.0448711962,
0.2551201284,
-0.1448489577,
0.0825924128,
-0.1089783609,
-0.341522485,
-0.4034864306,
-0.4164235592,
0.4616811574,
-0.8208462596,
-0.090299435,
0.0039837491,
-0.6500358582,
0.0196543261,
0.365437448,
-0.7827838659,
-0.2199927866,
0.4362541139,
0.8612409234,
0.0471298918,
-0.4564060569,
-0.4989288449,
0.1008084267,
-0.3243080974,
0.6088411212,
-0.4051915705,
-0.6004713178,
-0.3681301475,
-0.101623483,
-0.0921957865,
-0.6865454912,
0.5875985026,
-0.5075293779,
0.5399153233,
-0.4612894356,
-0.4089432061,
-0.1326637417,
0.4100723565,
-0.207034409,
1.2363572121,
0.4741376936,
-0.6917666793,
0.5599168539,
-0.8502981067,
-0.4130336344,
0.2194563597,
-0.1615789831,
-0.1182673052,
0.5387334824,
0.0934837312,
0.1064231694,
-0.0301603619,
0.3622952104,
0.0261957664,
-0.2924609184,
0.1686563641,
-0.2903943062,
0.5984842181,
0.4488977492,
-0.2629260421,
0.1614139229,
-0.5870913267,
0.0494958088,
0.1296817958,
-0.0449261852,
-0.9985359907,
-0.3582979143,
-0.0619879477,
0.3195785284,
0.49007985,
-0.224346444,
0.1784074157,
-0.4716196954,
0.4180722237,
0.4716839194,
-0.2443094105,
0.6036660075,
0.2288361341,
0.3437913954,
0.4573797882,
0.1859150976,
-0.0301396679,
-0.5481358171,
-0.8381528854,
-0.2437203974,
0.5959143639,
0.3356743157,
-0.8899790049,
0.6054233313,
-0.2355875224,
-0.1211012751,
-0.7461946607,
-0.0665487871,
0.3354007304,
0.8767348528,
0.5775678754,
-0.0875305012,
-0.4023072124,
-0.9200506806,
-0.176373139,
-0.0687543526,
-0.2330548316,
0.0348865725,
0.4871923923,
-0.4734058678,
0.9515191317,
-0.4209962785,
-0.277094841,
0.2380129099,
0.51210922,
0.0737006441,
0.3806250691,
0.497510612,
-1.2881735563,
-0.1406108141,
-0.051992815,
-0.7746077776,
-0.1865092814,
0.0765167475,
-0.1503310353,
0.2243985981,
0.5645840168,
-0.5648567677,
0.3180982172,
0.4527693391,
-0.3218808472,
0.1599849313,
-0.5617833138,
0.1613487899,
-1.3524441719,
0.2206935883,
-0.3485727608,
-0.1664622575,
-0.4856300354,
0.220555082,
0.4485934079,
-0.0698059946,
-0.4562979937,
0.5986621976,
-0.5736809373,
0.0536245741,
-0.4161908329,
0.629383564,
0.2801904082,
0.2279919684,
-0.085504882,
0.6824484468,
0.3361445665,
-0.6624494791,
0.1812297851,
0.2413498759,
0.1397787631,
0.9487749934,
-0.4490000606,
0.1543390453,
-0.2046544552,
0.0719856024,
-0.7588987947,
-0.1497641802,
0.6849501133,
-0.7370039225,
0.4120467305,
0.1287508756,
-0.5629487634,
-0.401758194,
0.1471545994,
0.4672008455,
0.3188523054,
-0.4247129858,
0.259640187,
0.1277459711,
0.1205370128,
-0.6487295628,
-0.9523165822,
0.4319645166,
-0.3205887079,
-0.3626100421,
0.499165833,
-0.0842694044,
-0.1888620853,
0.0790759549,
-0.494022429,
-0.2583704591,
0.2912746072,
0.2616290152,
0.1607490033,
0.0617724843,
0.4708575904,
0.4851051271,
-0.3881014884,
-0.1378961056,
-0.5269668698,
0.2094049454,
-0.1777539402,
-0.4568769038,
0.1720187664,
0.5603720546,
0.5141515136,
-0.3110921085,
0.6887354851,
0.8692229986,
-0.5619658232,
0.0335631445,
-0.1373941004,
-0.1727733612,
-0.4862884581,
0.3649852276,
-0.8051444292,
-0.7651045322,
0.5051099062,
-0.3127874434,
-0.1724171042,
0.6565611362,
0.2588357627,
-0.3314795792,
0.9418377876,
0.5674604774,
0.2962753177,
0.2660536468,
-0.036961291,
0.3571995795,
-0.8702454567,
-0.2309302986,
-0.5758033991,
-0.4837727547,
-0.2432015091,
-0.623319149,
0.3815335929,
0.4257015288,
0.3135345578,
0.446972698,
-0.7752230763,
0.4370064735,
0.5326182246,
-0.070779413,
0.3121055365,
-0.1570863575,
-0.4965102077,
-0.2910976112,
-0.9150576591,
-0.4396158457,
0.6523543,
0.0174416807,
-0.0063173715,
0.3490104675,
0.7877839804,
0.2095010281,
0.2655160427,
-1.009085536,
0.3104015589,
-0.1378195435,
-0.4374474287,
-0.1745322794,
-0.4930416942,
-1.1914395094,
0.4901850522,
-0.2126939893,
-0.5900883079,
0.3313337266,
0.1304892749,
-0.2480360568,
-0.0740833431,
-0.9976633787,
1.057915926,
-0.2348556221,
-0.0890950784,
-0.0812954381,
-0.8655391335,
0.1613521725,
-0.1859469116,
0.1360163242,
0.0412845351,
-0.3581191301,
0.3698622882,
-0.5949969292,
0.5071097016,
-0.1738703102,
-0.273277998,
0.0537109636,
0.0511991605,
0.4146228433,
-0.1761096716,
-0.3173675835,
0.7192950249,
-0.0155274412,
-0.477938503,
-0.6260883212,
0.4239730239,
-0.5540179014,
-0.6255663633,
-0.6247463822,
-0.8395223618,
-0.210559532,
0.5366209745,
0.706592083,
0.1577245593,
-0.0987945199,
-0.2675974965,
0.6859538555,
0.1146379486,
0.4325394928,
0.5838291049,
0.0959228873,
0.0121183023,
0.7690421343,
0.0591415055,
-0.1267030835,
0.4689042568,
0.1483908147,
-0.7316520214,
-0.7138784528,
-0.7319332957,
-0.043025434,
-0.8153450489,
-0.1739511639,
-0.6450801492,
0.060598325,
-0.3696545959,
-0.146618098,
-0.0501800887,
-0.2596124411,
-0.3796797395,
0.0394885615,
0.426628679,
0.3837920725,
-0.2416605502,
0.5899102688,
-0.9146256447,
0.4862498343,
-0.1121137291,
0.2401301712,
-0.5716919899,
-0.9279254079,
-0.3447245955,
0.1060267016,
-0.0602704212,
-1.1406574249,
0.254583329,
0.063510485,
0.395109266,
0.4713530838,
0.3215118647,
0.8870632648,
-0.5565219522,
0.7550925016,
0.3914939165,
-1.1431421041,
0.69219625,
-0.3288621306,
0.6269541383,
0.6512253284,
0.3296245635,
-0.8074808717,
-0.4918253124,
-0.8776336908,
-1.2275236845,
0.6127205491,
0.1788503528,
0.2631983459,
-0.3231126666,
0.4309461415,
0.1353522688,
0.4416535199,
-0.3875480592,
-0.325671941,
-0.2717749178,
-0.3134533167,
-0.0953857079,
-0.1511094868,
-0.4172905087,
-0.21578224,
0.3775396943,
-0.2243831754,
-0.0349410847,
0.3550614119,
-0.5212574601,
0.1667543203,
0.21589683,
0.7740634084,
0.6068237424,
-0.0968712121,
0.5557335019,
0.3179942667,
-0.3931278586,
-0.0670219362,
0.3285203278,
-0.0975426659,
0.5091558099,
-0.0676997006,
0.6810073256,
0.2194896191,
-0.5096265078,
0.4899645746,
-0.0338049456,
-0.3260576427,
-0.1267699897,
-0.1967869997,
0.0439869277,
0.254627049,
0.3597799242,
0.4903639257,
0.1922041774,
-0.1923383921,
0.2120825648,
0.2214372009,
-0.4027001262,
0.0213330872,
0.6799605489,
0.3642590046,
-0.2554799914,
0.6081821918,
-0.7584519386,
-0.5256614089,
0.3250280917,
0.4230267704,
0.7522528768,
-0.0084614698,
0.0270253848,
0.2165903896,
0.4862044454,
0.0075373128,
0.1254159063,
-0.2219922543,
-0.6283539534,
-0.115889132,
-0.3915196359,
-0.3184542954,
0.0102587212,
-0.63647753,
0.1673004031,
-0.2446798682,
-0.3954282701,
-0.148396492,
-0.2953258753,
-0.4089040458,
0.3279102743,
0.280441761,
0.8208779097,
-0.6610272527,
0.9766610861,
1.0664167404,
-0.399181366,
-0.5549834967,
0.1425532997,
0.0360863172,
-0.7312371135,
0.5549466014,
0.0711434558,
-0.2190604657,
0.1229860559,
-0.2213608772,
-0.5448414087,
0.8590735793,
0.5367150903,
-0.7334463,
0.1885782033,
-0.0527413636,
0.4658870399,
0.1342348903,
0.2451798916,
0.4091203511,
0.9335768819,
0.1835843474,
-0.6428295374,
0.0395864882,
-0.4964404106,
0.0649862364,
0.4073018432,
-0.4093804657,
0.5532407165,
-0.2054271698,
-0.3764811754,
-0.0872168168,
0.67589432,
0.0102165714,
0.6535178423,
0.647669971,
0.7461565733,
1.372682333,
-0.5341236591,
0.9578004479,
-0.151313886,
0.1709308177,
1.3802453279,
0.0332579426,
0.6477416754,
1.0999796391,
0.0376061313,
0.1443639249,
1.1337047815,
-0.0776292831,
0.3372009397,
0.2212516367,
-0.2752127945,
-0.1271544546,
-0.2561914325,
-0.5980901718,
0.4636847079,
0.4486690164,
-0.2848059833,
-0.3493438959,
0.0193110965,
0.1691850275,
0.3536984921,
-0.0897437185,
0.4808858037,
0.1884604394,
-0.6930110455,
0.6628767252,
0.3879083693,
0.7704967856,
-0.8654734492,
0.1439008564,
-0.3730774522,
-0.0583875142,
-0.1739927828,
-0.4674121439,
0.6198167205,
0.0353282802,
-0.5358459949,
-0.3728079498,
0.5651941299,
-0.6126589775,
-0.2785110474,
0.2214539945,
0.7794998288,
0.5402053595,
-0.4843284488,
-0.8171746731,
-0.0922673866,
-0.1764343977,
0.0351926982,
0.351622045,
0.937159121,
-0.1353348792,
0.1463725865,
0.4423817098,
-0.1221551895,
0.1110408753,
0.3086234331,
0.7164086103,
-0.5039902925,
-0.4464763999,
-0.7157585621,
0.5342092514,
-0.1637032181,
-0.7750431299,
0.7525228858,
0.3227774799,
0.8541523218,
0.0073338314,
0.5323945284,
-0.448361069,
-0.1783071309,
-0.3099505603,
0.7941327095,
-1.0167361498,
0.1201265305,
-0.0253533367,
-0.842792809,
-0.4486193657,
0.637362659,
-0.3899264932,
-0.1179710329,
1.0335903168,
0.6491299868,
-0.3056558371,
-0.259198457,
0.6060014367,
0.1090369821,
-0.3104861081,
0.3787853718,
0.7381444573,
-0.5847130418,
0.5940188766,
0.0234830268,
-0.1534298956,
-0.3044787347,
-0.9968179464,
-0.4577005804,
-0.8276403546,
-0.435254246,
-0.3094282746,
0.043859154,
0.6085020304,
0.7631438971,
-0.5172201395,
0.3527823687,
-0.1401275992,
0.4947533607,
-0.4355065525,
-0.2233392,
0.254131943,
-0.7229564786,
-1.174723506,
0.5747930408,
0.2654624581,
0.1311708391,
0.1792034507,
-0.284158498,
-0.2096860707,
-0.1809456348,
0.5231289864,
0.1514721066,
-0.708307445,
-0.2944487929,
-0.0155068636,
-0.2860073745,
-0.0054130014,
0.5238453746,
-0.4556339383,
0.6675550342,
0.3968601525,
0.7342492342,
0.3254531622,
-0.0840041861,
0.4548007548,
-1.2331198454,
0.6234652996,
0.0148864295,
0.4285905957,
0.4127045274,
-0.5153352618,
0.4399556816,
0.5346547961,
0.0608238205,
-0.7976441979,
0.2970601916,
-1.0656797886,
-0.5261280537,
0.8798613548,
-0.22131899,
-0.2394211441,
-0.042114079,
-0.2122215629,
0.5955567956,
-0.3155299723,
0.8181576729,
0.7957231402,
0.1344407052,
-0.0813065022,
-0.4258669019,
0.1542502344,
1.0065331459,
-0.4748341739,
-0.204973042,
0.6523156762,
-0.0204796884,
0.3921529651,
0.4128618538,
-0.1205955669,
0.1826295853,
0.2646830678,
0.1713687479,
-0.3220214546,
-0.2483294755,
-0.5674416423,
-0.0930898115,
0.1808644384,
-0.5995559692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15500v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15500v2
|
Function-constrained Program Synthesis
| 2023-11-27T02:55:34 | 2023-12-04T06:24:02 |
Patrick Hajali, Ignas Budvytis
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
This work introduces (1) a technique that allows large language models (LLMs)
to leverage user-provided code when solving programming tasks and (2) a method
to iteratively generate modular sub-functions that can aid future code
generation attempts when the initial code generated by the LLM is inadequate.
Generating computer programs in general-purpose programming languages like
Python poses a challenge for LLMs when instructed to use code provided in the
prompt. Code-specific LLMs (e.g., GitHub Copilot, CodeLlama2) can generate code
completions in real-time by drawing on all code available in a development
environment. However, restricting code-specific LLMs to use only in-context
code is not straightforward, as the model is not explicitly instructed to use
the user-provided code and users cannot highlight precisely which snippets of
code the model should incorporate into its context. Moreover, current systems
lack effective recovery methods, forcing users to iteratively re-prompt the
model with modified prompts until a sufficient solution is reached. Our method
differs from traditional LLM-powered code-generation by constraining
code-generation to an explicit function set and enabling recovery from failed
attempts through automatically generated sub-functions. When the LLM cannot
produce working code, we generate modular sub-functions to aid subsequent
attempts at generating functional code. A by-product of our method is a library
of reusable sub-functions that can solve related tasks, imitating a software
team where efficiency scales with experience. We also introduce a new
"half-shot" evaluation paradigm that provides tighter estimates of LLMs' coding
abilities compared to traditional zero-shot evaluation. Our proposed evaluation
method encourages models to output solutions in a structured format, decreasing
syntax errors that can be mistaken for poor coding ability.
|
[
-0.1394629925,
-0.5747116208,
0.5745046735,
0.3559326231,
-0.1704636514,
0.2086950243,
-0.318347156,
-0.0847893879,
0.1574434936,
0.560746491,
-0.832444489,
-0.342387408,
-0.1566457599,
0.4208036065,
-0.4471944571,
0.8004257083,
0.0697533786,
-0.1595083475,
-0.4706130028,
0.3884446621,
-0.4203311205,
-0.5506569743,
-0.2102325708,
-0.4679261148,
0.2952037156,
0.5196653605,
0.4090370536,
0.3024489582,
0.2995817661,
0.2808459401,
0.2256924361,
-0.0182385053,
-0.4700492918,
0.0730715543,
0.0014424139,
-0.4698187709,
-0.4634617269,
-0.2200354338,
0.5042477846,
0.5759860873,
-0.0894965082,
0.3460388184,
-0.0041250228,
0.5208594799,
-0.539368093,
0.1912837327,
-0.9030101299,
0.1061897203,
0.0104355784,
-0.3742737472,
-0.4248721302,
-0.2650543749,
-0.2814606726,
-0.5471449494,
0.0180306882,
-0.1682153344,
0.3214131594,
0.3499553502,
0.0515000001,
-0.4143413901,
-0.6408660412,
0.7138776183,
-1.0275658369,
-0.0586504973,
0.1366877705,
0.2541319132,
-0.5086017251,
-0.7654521465,
-0.6347732544,
-0.4084394276,
0.0696310997,
-0.0564389341,
-0.0058384989,
0.0898777768,
0.5439127684,
0.2741577923,
-0.4377724528,
-0.1001813263,
-0.7197831869,
-0.2617641687,
0.7082152367,
0.3889134824,
0.2255012244,
-0.3733568192,
-0.1897962093,
0.3021715879,
-1.1823170185,
0.1219253242,
0.3672038317,
0.327943325,
0.1155354306,
0.8248893023,
-0.2483977079,
0.6609302759,
-0.160528183,
-0.2624112368,
0.0853202567,
-0.4333223104,
-0.4129757285,
-0.2245356441,
0.6583848596,
0.3479323685,
0.2912306488,
0.2181151956,
-0.6165569425,
-0.1196669117,
0.1976916045,
-0.6815701127,
-0.2036073655,
0.4046104252,
-0.3109368086,
-0.3713998199,
-0.0877204537,
-0.4821409881,
-0.3226627409,
-0.2087472081,
0.4602714181,
-0.1642774791,
-0.1178657115,
-0.1044911742,
-0.1318254471,
-0.0692135319,
0.0483982675,
-0.7626840472,
0.066768676,
0.5304534435,
0.6572698951,
-0.0173489414,
-0.2369134277,
-0.5152282119,
0.2422182262,
-0.3334969878,
0.3727819622,
-0.4825842977,
-0.6750251055,
0.1432560682,
-0.1618766785,
0.2894958556,
-0.7684488297,
-0.0161546227,
-0.1709846109,
-0.1807004362,
-0.0933394432,
-0.4063181281,
0.1832676083,
0.0651232079,
-0.4430235326,
0.8102692962,
0.5149688125,
-0.380345881,
0.180081591,
-0.4544409215,
-0.5842316747,
0.2326069623,
-0.4093869925,
-0.3105225563,
0.309686929,
0.0934412852,
0.2644053698,
-0.3462801874,
0.2189760655,
-0.234619841,
-0.4042263031,
0.3307029903,
0.0942486823,
0.6632522345,
0.2141778767,
-0.1424205154,
0.3576308489,
-0.697216928,
0.2792658508,
0.0905627459,
-0.761267364,
0.0776522979,
0.0205884613,
-0.1664285213,
0.0542662218,
0.3791778088,
-0.4210952818,
0.5064078569,
-0.4055759609,
0.7751048803,
0.6094753146,
-0.0608124435,
0.4037290215,
-0.3455771506,
0.8480041623,
-0.3950019777,
0.2449466437,
-0.5452975631,
-0.329642266,
-0.7046599984,
-0.3954325914,
0.1011773199,
0.6239225268,
-0.9506627321,
0.3921263516,
0.0147121958,
-0.1186662838,
-0.1476254314,
0.3804266751,
0.4350486398,
0.4075332582,
0.1917779744,
-0.1951543093,
-0.8705229163,
-0.8918298483,
0.113907285,
-0.2953995764,
-0.2368186861,
0.2334893793,
0.4711268544,
-0.1303573847,
0.8501601815,
-0.5028845668,
-0.1512532383,
-0.6823046803,
-0.0831972435,
0.4629077911,
0.6122819185,
0.2280653864,
-0.4626162052,
-0.3545461297,
-0.1575314403,
-0.4913144708,
-0.5479765534,
-0.2194314301,
0.2321762592,
0.348600179,
0.6171468496,
-0.4890047908,
0.4014950991,
0.4498340786,
0.0664480329,
0.8242362142,
-0.2811032534,
-0.051927343,
-0.9201943874,
0.3123749495,
-0.3790711462,
-0.2358508408,
-0.4111486077,
0.2595372796,
-0.0083200149,
-0.4160693586,
-0.3513320684,
0.3902994394,
-0.5689774156,
-0.1781584322,
-0.3417708874,
-0.1317845732,
-0.165678069,
0.3469139934,
-0.0190172214,
0.827126503,
0.579043448,
-0.4464416504,
0.3925194144,
-0.1432104707,
-0.2330516428,
0.16492109,
-0.8214322925,
0.1311711669,
0.2255218774,
0.2082793713,
-0.8471235633,
-0.4680280685,
0.1623816192,
-0.3085357249,
0.2839357853,
-0.211593017,
-0.4043996334,
-0.5845817327,
-0.3452727497,
0.5437768698,
0.8537281156,
-0.1130629927,
0.3571720123,
0.2626370192,
-0.2772678137,
-0.2980220914,
-0.7513403296,
0.1362496465,
-0.0423211642,
-0.6794352531,
0.3683404028,
-0.2097993344,
-0.1635123342,
-0.1198824123,
-0.1306072921,
0.0549520403,
0.1050917059,
0.1862166673,
0.3845858276,
0.0099574234,
-0.1412036717,
0.1811789423,
-0.1701393872,
-0.0675487146,
-0.5224598646,
0.337759614,
0.1982962936,
-0.4543879032,
-0.1955512613,
0.6660366058,
0.5558152795,
-0.1581088603,
0.1421335191,
0.141096577,
-0.3868738413,
-0.671682179,
-0.3669091165,
-0.2060173601,
-0.5145935416,
0.3526782691,
-0.4051258266,
-0.9385428429,
0.543210268,
-0.0695159808,
0.2587527931,
-0.0082104187,
0.9482802153,
0.1724246591,
0.7620232701,
0.8269664645,
0.1843267828,
0.5345887542,
-0.1380153149,
0.3766426444,
-0.6487804651,
-0.2801061869,
-0.3688596785,
-0.2623063028,
-0.2481902987,
-0.5034490824,
0.6445706487,
0.1826330125,
0.0497067906,
0.5924399495,
-0.7159745097,
0.6131646633,
0.6456404924,
-0.0455010422,
0.1282017827,
-0.0030171603,
-0.2764902711,
0.2026984245,
-0.7710305452,
-0.3673017919,
1.2303743362,
0.1213340014,
0.9239064455,
-0.0241709873,
1.0439692736,
0.4206170738,
0.3470043242,
-0.900216341,
0.7052494884,
-0.0139985466,
-0.5174952745,
-0.2500015795,
-0.4440539479,
-0.6344102025,
-0.1303636432,
-0.0294315368,
-0.9033450484,
-0.1520618498,
0.2972522676,
-0.7047601342,
-0.1550652981,
-0.8586250544,
0.6312155724,
0.0017390851,
-0.384521246,
-0.2179210931,
-0.4828968048,
0.4346293807,
-0.1984484643,
0.1812422574,
0.0420198813,
0.0558709241,
0.2623295486,
-0.6038299799,
0.8160592318,
-0.1468308121,
-0.1126356348,
0.5952950716,
0.3837127388,
0.2707107365,
0.1287475675,
-0.1582836807,
-0.2411560863,
0.1766920388,
-0.2880754173,
-0.5582581162,
0.6522764564,
-0.2949041724,
-1.0614346266,
-0.0053003323,
-0.86856848,
0.0067078052,
0.2886602283,
0.1737420857,
0.6658396721,
0.0127985729,
0.1270919591,
0.1843760312,
-0.3619177639,
0.6896631718,
0.2728897333,
-0.5370662808,
-0.4847497344,
0.8497118354,
0.0384380817,
0.4538209438,
0.1997710615,
0.0503038689,
-0.0809949711,
-0.806881845,
-0.3737148643,
0.0253926199,
-0.6223421693,
-0.4429344833,
-0.020129893,
-0.189375177,
-0.4225516915,
-0.3891841471,
-0.1554335058,
-0.8523440361,
-0.1594546139,
0.1653040051,
-0.1535825133,
0.7995032072,
-0.2271891087,
0.0918404907,
-0.802641511,
0.1261733919,
0.1341807991,
-0.1163153499,
-0.1873193383,
-0.1581451148,
-0.3264940083,
-0.2231791764,
-0.4584511817,
-0.8625614643,
0.3175911009,
0.0717433244,
0.5977924466,
0.0156720746,
0.1185399219,
0.3218548894,
-0.5162514448,
0.9647591114,
0.3826184869,
-1.1345940828,
0.7903906107,
-0.3756128848,
0.3749766946,
0.2587559223,
-0.1077346057,
-0.1414691955,
-0.5034692883,
-0.2192747593,
-0.8976228237,
0.6048710942,
0.4018621743,
0.1371303648,
-0.0821921676,
0.5674122572,
0.0470197536,
0.3537259102,
-0.7681794763,
0.0823237076,
-0.2464877516,
-0.2158378214,
0.2279499918,
-0.2670868635,
-0.2789324522,
-0.2365096211,
0.6189035177,
-0.4631173909,
0.2903063893,
0.3437667191,
-0.0254285783,
-0.130350709,
0.2754876912,
0.7677708864,
1.0416735411,
0.0073072645,
0.1312739104,
-0.1250238419,
-0.0751436874,
0.0641672462,
-0.0135288751,
-0.3911116123,
-0.2433728725,
0.3401594162,
0.3621064723,
-0.1026761606,
-0.8858255744,
0.4313988388,
0.3197943866,
-0.1615274847,
-0.3499325812,
0.3937360942,
0.2291599661,
0.4591691196,
0.5818861723,
-0.1080625802,
-0.0393740311,
-0.6834823489,
0.4069304466,
0.550922215,
0.046029821,
-0.3987889886,
0.5671103597,
0.3472205102,
-0.6742912531,
0.4716078043,
-0.2760443091,
-0.5806903243,
0.8185216188,
0.8763657808,
0.9489206076,
0.0392131843,
0.1725168675,
0.4922322035,
0.3681060374,
0.0764961615,
0.5294536948,
-0.1293938309,
-0.4266729951,
-0.4980105758,
-0.6352769732,
-0.2319317609,
0.0595253967,
-0.3435322642,
0.3765456378,
-0.8763886094,
-0.3599463403,
-0.349958688,
-0.1814818829,
-0.1738468856,
-0.1169203073,
0.2491424531,
0.9913404584,
-0.516430378,
1.0033992529,
0.6533370614,
-0.5668833256,
-0.798476696,
0.0171049349,
0.1609763503,
-0.6455438137,
0.3959767818,
0.0867282823,
0.0228931755,
-0.0775743425,
-0.7305639982,
-0.4553171396,
1.2369538546,
0.4986889958,
-0.4784628451,
-0.0225058515,
0.1584957391,
0.4227589965,
-0.7023349404,
-0.0401125066,
0.5627077222,
0.3663399518,
0.2059243172,
-1.1085056067,
0.3478946388,
-0.2072809786,
0.1712935716,
-0.0153915389,
-0.461707443,
0.8790732026,
-0.6033624411,
-0.0677806064,
0.5587100387,
0.4796833694,
0.5344800353,
0.1467154324,
0.2932549417,
0.1337906569,
0.5903604031,
0.0345570669,
1.0510159731,
-0.3090995848,
0.3930073977,
0.8288331032,
-0.2811442018,
0.6466922164,
0.9304285645,
-0.2562705576,
0.3425690234,
0.2582427263,
-0.10131827,
0.5874909759,
0.6883760095,
-0.2617197037,
-0.4927635789,
-0.0427163951,
-0.2133811116,
0.04211789,
0.2983745337,
-0.345772475,
-0.1356042624,
-0.2198980451,
-0.0998933166,
0.0022886056,
-0.150701344,
0.4036617279,
0.3830615282,
-0.9323865175,
0.8254529834,
0.0855919346,
0.4445174634,
-0.7430453897,
-0.1010768488,
-0.4180954397,
0.2344856262,
-0.4236883521,
-0.6659242511,
0.5766070485,
0.0015407581,
-0.232955873,
-0.160215646,
0.6645659208,
-0.4315312803,
-0.5729970932,
-0.001232063,
0.3526112735,
0.096592553,
0.141162917,
-0.5120897889,
0.319802016,
0.3865762949,
-0.1629972607,
0.276435703,
0.2527810037,
0.0049364963,
0.8083109856,
0.5743690729,
0.0181965604,
0.1389317364,
0.0535713322,
1.0791460276,
-0.3378594518,
-0.2699119747,
-0.8179197311,
0.6834577918,
0.1419643164,
-0.1160411313,
0.4534113407,
0.4697734118,
0.744379282,
-0.3205778301,
1.0725013018,
-0.5760443211,
0.0060370313,
-0.6996459365,
0.4150428176,
-0.7899284959,
0.659260869,
-0.2116579264,
-0.8921975493,
-0.4822840989,
0.548820436,
-0.0321016125,
-0.067412436,
0.7012475729,
1.1143888235,
0.1096191034,
-0.3280892968,
0.4544421136,
-0.0301682781,
0.4617199004,
0.9536272287,
0.9640908241,
-0.0526907109,
0.702996552,
-0.1002013087,
-0.4415875971,
-0.1546979696,
-1.0322192907,
-0.9571484923,
-0.4491553903,
-0.2898280025,
-0.4610184431,
-0.1434378773,
1.0939296484,
0.6644394994,
-0.7205623984,
-0.5141060352,
-0.1524228603,
0.2597092688,
-0.1704580784,
-0.2045294642,
-0.0996949226,
-0.4793791771,
-0.6904150248,
0.577598989,
0.4489509463,
-0.1759576201,
-0.6582761407,
-0.1880296171,
0.1474761963,
0.2423116714,
0.4921315312,
0.4678736031,
-0.6851506233,
-0.289557755,
0.1599181443,
0.0268309172,
-0.0467055105,
1.3047702312,
-0.6305197477,
0.3912476003,
0.826187551,
0.5054516196,
0.3173786402,
0.0110673979,
0.8420875072,
-0.866384089,
0.1218308657,
0.1109912172,
0.4225146174,
0.2894936502,
-0.3644925654,
0.3601443172,
0.3085733354,
-0.5203902125,
-0.8972647786,
0.573607862,
-0.8171309829,
-0.4348168969,
1.3441644907,
-0.3676839471,
-0.2237164229,
0.0018088301,
-0.2577498853,
-0.0154133923,
-0.3603492081,
0.7523049712,
0.5448756218,
-0.3625293672,
0.0655629262,
-0.1982092559,
0.4193894565,
0.195495069,
-0.6891958714,
0.2022458613,
0.7565564513,
0.4888595343,
0.2186059952,
0.943759203,
-0.1901533604,
0.3268907368,
0.0593579747,
0.0802905038,
-0.5872637033,
-0.5182684064,
-0.1305147111,
0.2646491826,
0.1333532929,
0.0795150474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15490v1
|
Optimizing and Fine-tuning Large Language Model for Urban Renewal
| 2023-11-27T02:17:11 | 2023-11-27T02:17:11 |
Xi Wang, Xianyao Ling, Tom Zhang, Xuecao Li, Shaolan Wang, Zhixing Li, Liang Zhang, Peng Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study aims to innovatively explore adaptive applications of large
language models (LLM) in urban renewal. It also aims to improve its performance
and text generation quality for knowledge question-answering (QA) tasks. Based
on the ChatGLM, we automatically generate QA datasets using urban renewal
scientific literature corpora in a self-instruct manner and then conduct joint
fine-tuning training on the model using the Prefix and LoRA fine-tuning methods
to create an LLM for urban renewal. By guiding the LLM to automatically
generate QA data based on prompt words and given text, it is possible to
quickly obtain datasets in the urban renewal field and provide data support for
the fine-tuning training of LLMs. The experimental results show that the joint
fine-tuning training method proposed in this study can significantly improve
the performance of LLM on the QA tasks. Compared with LoRA fine-tuning, the
method improves the Bleu and Rouge metrics on the test by about 5%; compared
with the model before fine-tuning, the method improves the Bleu and Rouge
metrics by about 15%-20%. This study demonstrates the effectiveness and
superiority of the joint fine-tuning method using Prefix and LoRA for ChatGLM
in the urban renewal knowledge QA tasks. It provides a new approach for
fine-tuning LLMs on urban renewal-related tasks.
|
[
-0.3079271019,
-1.0120582581,
0.6149886847,
-0.1875637621,
-0.1663943529,
0.3438059986,
-0.3648302257,
-0.4374057055,
-0.037146464,
0.5785180926,
-0.2654423416,
-0.5457218885,
0.0547689833,
0.1906068623,
-0.2268437147,
0.7160230875,
-0.0720417053,
0.2008257657,
-0.0789065659,
-0.13046664,
-0.7448168993,
0.0535054542,
-1.2586483955,
-0.3159891665,
0.5459625125,
0.5138358474,
0.6119668484,
0.6310198307,
0.3598493338,
0.2579389811,
-0.1371584088,
0.5588824153,
-0.7176341414,
-0.2412686646,
-0.1891155988,
-0.3628250659,
-0.3414929211,
-0.4021645486,
0.6211561561,
0.4680167139,
-0.2866130471,
0.292175293,
-0.0269330405,
0.9895274043,
-0.3677861392,
0.1088785157,
-0.9488279223,
-0.5702039003,
0.1506403536,
-0.5985037088,
0.0198978856,
-0.724678874,
-0.1708552241,
-0.6197628975,
0.2088607848,
0.3124910891,
0.8662353754,
0.2987110019,
-0.2403834015,
-0.0857620388,
-0.85793221,
0.6148310304,
-1.0069361925,
0.1152415052,
0.0353921019,
0.4590025842,
-0.2679550946,
-0.3682257235,
-0.6966661215,
-0.0983996838,
0.1248302683,
0.1867971271,
-0.0227406621,
0.1448343396,
0.1846187115,
0.2976467013,
-0.3783448935,
0.2385051399,
-0.6547661424,
0.2090186924,
0.7068149447,
0.4788576663,
0.0632099211,
-0.0396081284,
-0.5502519608,
-0.0488049537,
-0.9454795122,
0.3369264305,
0.2717993855,
0.5313093662,
0.194314152,
0.21763888,
-0.4972237051,
0.45107463,
-0.2436812073,
-0.216088891,
0.3067373037,
-0.6805378199,
-0.4479036927,
-0.227440238,
0.6597344875,
0.4881023169,
0.4596376419,
-0.1734091192,
-0.4794251621,
-0.2881188989,
0.2168664783,
-0.537481308,
-0.0892826095,
0.3077103198,
-0.1396727264,
-0.1560456157,
-0.3122059703,
-0.6636601686,
-0.2663840055,
-0.8102186918,
0.3597827256,
-0.4205936491,
-0.315564692,
0.6124633551,
0.0818558186,
0.3995878994,
0.8144831061,
-0.8462661505,
-0.0202947147,
0.5414066911,
0.3662231863,
-0.0948781222,
-0.2084795535,
-0.0436957218,
0.1090376675,
-0.4045332968,
0.7988809347,
-0.1919891089,
-0.0118336845,
0.2390770018,
-0.1106629968,
-0.1489656121,
-0.7961794138,
0.3958849609,
-0.7852278352,
-0.1489049047,
-0.1595863849,
-0.3532825708,
-0.2125400603,
0.4727749228,
-0.4286861718,
1.4027382135,
0.2854611576,
-0.4910435975,
0.2841324508,
-0.6642668843,
-0.0332594626,
0.1787452549,
0.2833372355,
-0.4939131141,
0.138754651,
0.2355764061,
0.2822164297,
-0.4588097036,
0.3577793241,
0.0343752168,
-0.2001228184,
-0.0131982854,
-0.2479709834,
0.6349599361,
0.1704587042,
0.045951046,
0.4383721352,
-0.9511469603,
-0.0429520793,
-0.1256038696,
-0.4784920216,
-0.2543307841,
-0.021802064,
0.1222395599,
0.0356274396,
0.6012942791,
-0.6079227328,
0.3987089097,
-0.7401983738,
0.2118811905,
0.5852316022,
0.1705072373,
0.319360286,
-0.7078939676,
0.5674601793,
0.0561038069,
0.1755682379,
-0.0314954631,
-0.3171501756,
-0.8252077699,
-0.1037921011,
0.2146228999,
0.5082714558,
-0.9329728484,
0.2860682309,
-0.417167604,
-0.6794950962,
-0.8869698048,
0.1879005134,
0.0268532187,
0.4123834074,
0.4397418201,
0.2343590856,
-0.5787169933,
-0.678381741,
-0.0135344313,
-0.058659412,
0.2457432002,
0.3275077939,
0.5808386207,
-0.1298734993,
1.1419919729,
-0.4997834265,
-0.3127478957,
-0.0945820808,
0.0110626696,
0.2811039686,
0.1856150031,
0.5599896908,
-0.846191287,
-0.4886113405,
-0.0256382208,
-0.1151076034,
-0.1692589074,
-0.0646444559,
0.0758733526,
-0.002559481,
0.6006608605,
-0.3620194495,
0.130550608,
0.2992498875,
-0.2975497544,
0.8801187873,
-0.3711191416,
0.2565228641,
-1.3914371729,
0.1293068677,
-0.3337267637,
-0.4867278934,
-0.5519673824,
0.3181040883,
-0.209108755,
-0.0966702178,
-0.5312755108,
0.8729429245,
-0.3391521573,
0.1757224798,
-0.436529845,
0.4302897751,
-0.0437395684,
0.4494327903,
-0.0807045996,
0.8772863746,
0.5391126275,
-0.5571885109,
0.4714694619,
0.2421200126,
-0.5823674798,
0.1309880018,
-0.4652724564,
-0.0489723459,
-0.3542725444,
-0.1548650414,
-1.1707892418,
0.005310135,
0.0184599813,
-0.0832960606,
-0.1052381396,
0.1731422544,
-0.7714139223,
-0.5050096512,
-0.221874848,
0.3695118725,
0.3936068714,
-0.4819251895,
0.5518749356,
0.154748112,
-0.0780521631,
-0.1311879605,
-0.1817638725,
-0.1891580224,
-0.4666017592,
-0.562472403,
-0.0908208489,
-0.1873843819,
-0.0859364718,
-0.2797681689,
0.4368061721,
0.003441242,
0.4088599086,
-0.0184790287,
0.1440659612,
-0.1968518347,
0.3922948241,
-0.1659175903,
-0.0083050588,
-0.1037969217,
-0.0186259374,
0.5794821382,
0.0550488271,
-0.1127025858,
-0.1892718673,
-0.0018687757,
0.7430846095,
-0.517803967,
0.7406699657,
0.7112150788,
-0.181523636,
-0.0475416481,
-0.6783067584,
-0.1328357458,
-0.4605312049,
0.4226365089,
-0.2466762513,
-1.0947648287,
0.6863644719,
-0.4338895082,
0.3494199514,
0.3444581628,
0.7438639402,
-0.2246057689,
0.7272871733,
0.632283628,
-0.1667983681,
0.4810240567,
-0.1151369065,
0.3048790991,
-0.8337384462,
-0.1949876398,
-0.7270538211,
-0.2743235826,
-0.3097885549,
-0.3536298871,
0.5008513331,
0.5493568182,
-0.1948904991,
0.3235516846,
-0.3934805393,
0.2573211193,
0.2337562293,
0.0826140121,
0.6527143717,
0.0983954296,
0.2083701044,
0.3533052206,
-0.6951358914,
-0.5689635873,
0.9144358039,
0.5055475235,
0.7142897248,
0.1584669948,
0.4586169422,
-0.0788929462,
0.2037554681,
-0.6634609103,
0.5930427313,
-0.0398995988,
-0.233917132,
-0.7104979753,
-0.4734448791,
-1.2412190437,
-0.0472042114,
-0.4155703485,
-0.7613369823,
0.12331108,
0.1069196165,
-0.7500402331,
0.4020858705,
-0.4003069699,
0.5470405817,
0.040820241,
0.0039467635,
-0.6312302947,
-0.1333797425,
0.0509710573,
-0.44025594,
0.3569456041,
-0.4204517007,
0.2473558038,
0.5535025001,
0.0241153315,
0.6280050874,
-0.2557760179,
-0.668102026,
0.211724773,
-0.3201848865,
0.6439611912,
-0.007530726,
-0.3054684997,
-0.156291768,
0.1270455718,
-0.2635172904,
-0.5618236065,
0.5858550072,
-0.7409536839,
-0.6490027905,
0.2361188531,
-0.8547263741,
-0.4803405702,
0.2045776099,
-0.0256545171,
0.5264110565,
-0.2806602716,
0.1893997639,
0.6226703525,
-0.1389404684,
0.4328237772,
0.9240221381,
-0.5487329364,
-0.4806995094,
0.6883820891,
-0.2402595282,
0.3822010756,
0.447106123,
0.1807757914,
-0.4114595652,
-0.929712534,
-0.4026203454,
0.1252656728,
-0.2282643616,
-0.5254292488,
-0.3864170313,
-0.1986888796,
-0.3267689645,
0.0216748286,
-0.247798264,
-0.1840124726,
-0.2647157311,
0.1768317372,
0.5964005589,
0.6682928205,
0.2904547751,
0.3274798691,
-0.8082892299,
0.3063256443,
0.213458553,
0.1791692078,
0.1416433901,
-0.561847508,
-0.7804941535,
0.4475609362,
-0.2234550714,
-0.5063662529,
0.3434912264,
-0.0565848537,
0.032414943,
0.2759847641,
0.0342367701,
0.6292429566,
-0.5326775312,
0.655429244,
0.035134349,
-0.2897996902,
0.5049851537,
-0.8497035503,
0.6443638206,
0.8689388037,
0.0757809132,
-0.3413307667,
-0.5700967312,
-0.3361467123,
-1.0246193409,
0.3190915287,
0.0191382784,
0.2986652255,
0.0110389851,
0.5215321183,
-0.1837358922,
0.3312537968,
-0.5805190206,
-0.1184906512,
0.2800350785,
-0.1988440007,
0.098470062,
-0.2906658351,
-0.3456258476,
-0.4389353395,
0.9527260065,
-0.3603249192,
-0.06324967,
0.0540328734,
0.2396127582,
-0.3774522543,
0.682890892,
0.5341120362,
0.9669632912,
-0.1653746814,
-0.3433659077,
0.6069628596,
-0.1609001905,
0.23271209,
-0.0295286216,
-0.5073826909,
-0.2758154869,
0.1480253339,
1.0135446787,
0.1549531817,
-0.743876338,
0.4248278141,
0.1064698696,
-0.2177595496,
-0.4757238328,
0.203162998,
0.2465907782,
0.4246748388,
0.5885301828,
0.0666757971,
-0.1029381081,
-0.5879670382,
-0.2098381072,
0.4607515037,
-0.3426687717,
-0.0576094165,
0.47639817,
0.2575117946,
-0.0967973098,
0.4753656983,
-0.2360922247,
-0.3701665103,
0.53844136,
0.5782683492,
0.6472395062,
-0.0853132084,
0.1291920245,
0.5986564159,
0.0561821349,
-0.0892413557,
0.6294142008,
0.4452048838,
-0.9624340534,
-0.617340982,
-1.1130843163,
0.0572060719,
0.3652697504,
-0.534515202,
0.2427684069,
-0.2733434439,
-0.0810964555,
-0.4415831864,
0.3587960303,
-0.5031021237,
0.398080945,
-0.0953304544,
1.4269530773,
-0.8020817041,
0.7307293415,
1.0102616549,
-0.207684949,
-1.2011994123,
0.0154499374,
-0.6321875453,
-0.5670122504,
0.4856234789,
-0.2586545348,
-0.2026797533,
0.5253270268,
-0.4670413136,
-0.9193588495,
1.2912076712,
0.3113827407,
-1.0187551975,
-0.2538469434,
0.3414899111,
0.9018601775,
-0.2102866322,
0.1562613845,
0.4394267797,
0.5902811885,
-0.1069831625,
-1.1625837088,
-0.0278092325,
0.2014846802,
0.1806993037,
0.3298638761,
-0.9042644501,
0.3539301157,
-0.1887519956,
-0.332416445,
0.6670401096,
0.6726673245,
0.2055924982,
0.0438701436,
0.6309124231,
0.7504726052,
0.7736191154,
-0.3121970594,
0.7115058303,
-0.6507398486,
0.5150524974,
0.9601125121,
0.0356523059,
0.9995085597,
0.2312660217,
-0.1467853487,
0.5596384406,
0.4104680419,
-0.132344231,
0.4007412493,
0.2850193679,
-0.1951901168,
-0.277548492,
-0.2564745545,
-0.1792759001,
0.5775025487,
0.1441971809,
-0.0352673344,
-0.4501324594,
0.2900371253,
-0.177385658,
0.2110884786,
-0.6917622685,
0.9908738136,
0.055716984,
-0.685057044,
0.6861248612,
0.0330659859,
0.3500523865,
-0.6499483585,
0.0056340266,
-0.147923559,
0.1719211638,
-0.2098115534,
-0.7833809853,
0.2619887888,
-0.4678668082,
-0.3603650033,
-0.2571506798,
0.6089522243,
-0.8786973357,
-0.2193411291,
0.2946240306,
0.3625705838,
-0.1386593431,
-0.1192316338,
-0.7674254775,
-0.2795462012,
0.1063185111,
0.0378820412,
0.129555881,
0.6259003878,
-0.0396983922,
0.8713963032,
0.8431119919,
0.5795794725,
-0.1883473992,
0.3799027801,
0.9010999799,
-0.581641078,
-0.3161165416,
-0.5792582035,
0.435387969,
0.1871887147,
-0.3830952942,
0.664529562,
0.8302426338,
0.5210129619,
-0.2419740558,
0.4376579821,
0.2447564155,
0.8741195798,
-0.7894852757,
0.6376948953,
-0.6688246131,
0.4118746519,
-0.121032998,
-1.0119581223,
0.0462285355,
0.0167286787,
-0.32758376,
-0.0999663398,
0.4464022815,
1.0764026642,
0.085032098,
-0.2303491235,
0.396086961,
0.4243813157,
0.1645678133,
0.5890997052,
0.831591785,
-0.4950659275,
0.3788749278,
0.3079483211,
-0.0315569863,
-0.1068495587,
-0.6224557757,
-0.7347642779,
-0.6272791624,
-0.3596877754,
-0.2522066534,
0.1521022171,
0.8138956428,
0.5607946515,
-0.8946647048,
-0.0994527936,
-0.0657653436,
-0.1539073884,
-0.2035203427,
-0.3304718435,
0.5825624466,
-0.3951780796,
-0.6925534606,
0.4448844492,
0.2736046016,
0.0199398641,
-0.4759869277,
-0.0405959338,
-0.2759849131,
0.0842855424,
0.4635476768,
0.2585511208,
-0.5438137054,
-0.4132080078,
-0.2104910612,
-0.3001508117,
0.3229501843,
0.6875903606,
-0.9450726509,
0.3602877855,
0.625787735,
0.6527760625,
0.2492568493,
0.3205603957,
0.6879882812,
-0.7869119644,
-0.2260095924,
0.0839151368,
0.2895725071,
0.4531252682,
-0.2762831151,
0.4560829103,
-0.1113313809,
-0.7941231728,
-0.4110047817,
0.1851574779,
-0.8446112871,
-0.1247706711,
1.3436350822,
0.1884278506,
-0.0943419486,
-0.4823798537,
-0.5893508196,
0.3175287247,
-0.4735050499,
1.047988534,
0.3515970409,
0.1187777221,
-0.353607446,
-0.4729800522,
0.9040545821,
0.3904948831,
-1.1348305941,
0.3524463475,
0.2831760347,
0.3265337646,
0.2389316857,
0.8945890069,
0.0765931159,
0.2419319451,
-0.6957722306,
0.0524629466,
-0.1468182653,
-0.1847811192,
-0.2549542189,
0.0108369486,
0.3518476784,
0.2402783483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03724v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03724v2
|
DP-OPT: Make Large Language Model Your Privacy-Preserving Prompt Engineer
| 2023-11-27T02:01:10 | 2024-03-17T23:16:41 |
Junyuan Hong, Jiachen T. Wang, Chenhui Zhang, Zhangheng Li, Bo Li, Zhangyang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as dominant tools for various
tasks, particularly when tailored for a specific target by prompt tuning.
Nevertheless, concerns surrounding data privacy present obstacles due to the
tuned prompts' dependency on sensitive private information. A practical
solution is to host a local LLM and optimize a soft prompt privately using
data. Yet, hosting a local model becomes problematic when model ownership is
protected. Alternative methods, like sending data to the model's provider for
training, intensify these privacy issues facing an untrusted provider. In this
paper, we present a novel solution called Differentially-Private Offsite Prompt
Tuning (DP-OPT) to address this challenge. Our approach involves tuning a
discrete prompt on the client side and then applying it to the desired cloud
models. We demonstrate that prompts suggested by LLMs themselves can be
transferred without compromising performance significantly. To ensure that the
prompts do not leak private information, we introduce the first private prompt
generation mechanism, by a differentially-private (DP) ensemble of in-context
learning with private demonstrations. With DP-OPT, generating
privacy-preserving prompts by Vicuna-7b can yield competitive performance
compared to non-private in-context learning on GPT3.5 or local private prompt
tuning. Codes are available at https://github.com/VITA-Group/DP-OPT .
|
[
-0.3824326694,
-0.6116356254,
0.7912131548,
0.2913473547,
-0.2446567267,
0.1640062481,
-0.2681315243,
-0.0300402809,
-0.2448711991,
0.4995442331,
-0.8792766929,
-0.4936403334,
-0.1507216841,
0.1832518727,
0.0193125289,
0.8519993424,
0.2829333246,
-0.0973708183,
0.0797702447,
0.2408325225,
-0.2668084204,
-0.6099512577,
-0.8829257488,
0.3454506993,
0.3348499835,
0.4212338328,
0.7104848623,
0.7991557121,
0.0827084929,
0.3629403412,
-0.1606595516,
0.3618831336,
-0.4608363807,
0.2148329169,
-0.2828853428,
-0.4967590272,
-0.3524949551,
-0.3038142025,
0.7465720773,
0.3417059183,
0.0378236175,
-0.0605111793,
0.1927866191,
0.5174234509,
-0.6246489286,
0.2514329851,
-0.7730622888,
0.0593930781,
-0.1385267675,
-0.2104650736,
-0.5536215901,
-0.6516354084,
-0.0838471279,
-0.3791113198,
0.2571159899,
0.119290784,
0.4930446446,
0.4664403796,
-0.2119432241,
0.3342957497,
-0.3369544446,
0.6513670683,
-0.6134964228,
0.1691328138,
0.6286160946,
0.3470722139,
-0.3379398584,
-0.2136237919,
-0.2411699593,
-0.4306142926,
0.0890462101,
-0.0151294302,
0.0151410764,
0.1907432377,
0.2833772898,
0.3956501186,
-0.4286399484,
0.6082612872,
0.0388578586,
-0.1881358027,
0.7754837871,
0.3181653917,
0.0604838766,
-0.0170401782,
-0.2577023208,
0.0715868995,
-0.9477066994,
0.1226843446,
0.6658928394,
0.490388751,
-0.2598209679,
0.3106504381,
-0.3115387857,
0.3564964831,
0.4550271332,
0.1501211375,
-0.1436763853,
-0.0114110643,
-0.1637342572,
0.1669621468,
0.8115541935,
0.184422195,
-0.0398634188,
-0.2394328564,
-0.2178226411,
0.0448893607,
-0.0637729615,
-0.7150788307,
-0.259105593,
0.3092451096,
-0.212527886,
-0.6104106903,
-0.2476531416,
-0.9692468047,
-0.9031040072,
-0.3834398985,
0.1805591583,
-0.1254507303,
-0.1216052175,
-0.0142516904,
0.189371869,
-0.2138607353,
0.229073897,
-1.0044218302,
0.3438616991,
0.7802773118,
0.8852303028,
0.0003661672,
-0.1677973568,
-0.8197791576,
0.092888698,
-0.2654549778,
0.2229366601,
-0.383115828,
-0.4745213389,
0.25748685,
0.0913052261,
0.2598202229,
-0.3249563873,
0.3021743298,
-0.5658355951,
0.4291473925,
-0.2997882664,
-0.5169664621,
0.1064388603,
-0.0391411372,
-0.3902010024,
0.6287240386,
0.0006952356,
-0.633712709,
0.1082454249,
-0.572694242,
-0.0337652303,
0.3386303484,
-0.3534327745,
-0.4574451447,
0.3446897268,
0.4780917168,
0.5704553127,
-0.1451141834,
0.3907022774,
-0.4863114059,
-0.2259295285,
0.2369289696,
-0.4473803043,
0.9822001457,
0.1427639723,
-0.7942350507,
0.0834645256,
-0.8029296994,
-0.0225444026,
0.0118652638,
-0.0636693388,
-0.2744584978,
-0.2569695711,
-0.4211479723,
0.0880374685,
0.452932775,
-0.5684294701,
0.3219396472,
-0.6159716249,
0.5389912724,
1.2416784763,
-0.0120986952,
0.6861184835,
-0.2726629972,
0.8070166707,
-0.1292475909,
0.6251468658,
-0.0709904656,
-0.5149300098,
-0.3905133605,
-0.7117006779,
0.0578599907,
0.4076828361,
-0.5493255854,
0.5980296731,
-0.1377106756,
-0.3901055455,
-0.3654407561,
-0.0003338763,
0.3143807054,
0.5499702692,
0.0330508128,
0.290571332,
-0.1674840897,
-0.9418937564,
-0.1218751967,
0.1453224123,
0.0232803654,
0.7014480233,
0.0950666517,
-0.1768479198,
1.0067118406,
-0.6339190602,
-0.3845245242,
0.0776118636,
-0.2481646389,
0.2725845575,
0.4955990016,
0.5511498451,
-0.717892766,
-0.6538532972,
-0.1421850771,
-0.4519276619,
-0.4115200937,
0.022440467,
-0.3188256323,
0.3377423286,
0.2140188813,
-0.5177051425,
0.1348391175,
0.8433732986,
-0.3498551548,
0.1667909175,
-0.5438378453,
0.0938103423,
-1.0895137787,
-0.1301323771,
-0.2475512177,
-0.5313373804,
-0.1069030538,
-0.0335985906,
0.2690963447,
-0.6419929266,
-0.702612102,
0.7003216147,
-0.5835500956,
0.137058571,
-0.3825925887,
0.0308346916,
0.0044754329,
0.4482074678,
0.1497172713,
0.8147586584,
0.9752327204,
-0.7228854895,
0.3065522611,
0.3888760805,
-0.0782653615,
0.3055607975,
-0.4619691968,
0.5312250853,
-0.1338989735,
0.1607805789,
-0.6548112631,
-0.1212635264,
0.3615434468,
-0.038300015,
0.323433727,
-0.2996601462,
-0.62441504,
0.0976239145,
-0.3972354233,
0.1402742863,
0.808103919,
-0.9336275458,
0.3178836703,
0.3776174486,
-0.2929463983,
-0.447253108,
-0.5446994305,
0.0682739019,
-0.5677979589,
-0.6024311781,
0.4936253428,
-0.1691939533,
-0.1524934322,
-0.2726612687,
0.0419329926,
-0.2605302632,
0.2191111594,
0.4870232642,
0.2306881696,
0.0419013798,
-0.0497634262,
0.5365775824,
-0.1338838041,
0.1107203364,
-0.4161062837,
0.3458089232,
-0.0550025366,
-0.0192953739,
-0.5533664227,
0.4910972118,
0.2005175054,
-0.2289688885,
0.9057382941,
0.0454309881,
-0.2208960652,
-0.6356544495,
-0.3375945985,
-0.4239743948,
-0.6554468274,
-0.0351055972,
-0.2071882337,
-0.9329191446,
0.3315798044,
-0.2657426596,
0.0824359804,
-0.1729811132,
0.4527167678,
0.3604206443,
1.1607223749,
0.80930686,
-0.1424297392,
0.7164322734,
-0.058118552,
-0.0251638871,
-0.4679355323,
0.1052320749,
-0.4432684183,
-0.0478501394,
-0.6745189428,
-0.156167239,
0.471085906,
-0.0922087505,
-0.339720428,
0.1895470768,
-0.7338100672,
0.6891344786,
0.4135966003,
0.3987482488,
0.2723200023,
-0.0815182999,
0.0759888291,
-0.1394326687,
-0.5654556155,
-0.5329167247,
0.6736688614,
0.4337521493,
0.7804663777,
0.1632384062,
1.0120767355,
0.1692287475,
-0.0262547918,
-0.2992547452,
0.7985066175,
-0.1930946708,
-0.5523346066,
-0.2096115649,
-0.6954137683,
-0.844022274,
0.0915106162,
0.1826781631,
-0.9490195513,
0.2729398906,
0.3419901431,
-0.5586758256,
0.0709302574,
-0.629709363,
0.6741401553,
-0.3877701461,
-0.6948595643,
0.0300857536,
-0.5479342341,
0.2458173931,
-0.3397412896,
0.1608672589,
-0.0184984487,
-0.1949668974,
0.2708794475,
-0.4125965238,
1.1020348072,
-0.5895020962,
-0.4495936036,
-0.1060184166,
0.290671885,
0.8691874743,
0.8046042323,
-0.1546739489,
0.2263621837,
-0.2161293477,
-0.0514878817,
-0.5407334566,
1.1430741549,
-0.7619345784,
-0.76558429,
-0.3952463865,
-0.3155711591,
-0.3035015464,
0.1320552826,
0.4507766366,
0.448055774,
0.1192105934,
0.0710728541,
0.877971828,
-0.6377438307,
0.5183238387,
0.8005079031,
-0.1576699317,
-0.3520433307,
0.6519659162,
-0.1440096051,
0.1011035293,
0.662768364,
0.6377888918,
-0.9291967154,
-0.4593084157,
-0.4600471854,
0.1253821403,
-0.6360493898,
-0.2650104463,
-0.5344110727,
-0.0268840343,
-0.4037387371,
-0.3661007881,
-0.6369413733,
-0.3143046796,
-0.5591125488,
-0.0433989353,
0.6588320136,
0.2681790292,
-0.2895347178,
0.4027111232,
-0.8468853831,
0.1626023799,
0.0662464052,
0.3085914552,
-0.4526671767,
-0.4564040899,
0.1094656289,
0.1436491162,
-0.1244293302,
-0.8084428906,
0.5826474428,
0.3195929825,
0.4281210899,
0.2483078539,
0.6375648379,
0.2794563472,
-0.5380664468,
0.7388865948,
-0.1955631226,
-1.1633229256,
0.7782719135,
-0.7167699337,
0.2329536825,
0.7641705871,
0.370947063,
-0.1109907404,
-0.4822824299,
-0.5179257393,
-0.8685351014,
0.8387256265,
0.0333669558,
0.3189653158,
0.1171339303,
0.4622483552,
0.5514754653,
0.4436866045,
-0.6978381276,
-0.2769031525,
-0.0557188317,
-0.2429311275,
-0.2266226113,
-0.0058562756,
-0.2533531189,
0.0279051773,
0.5975149274,
-0.2001933753,
0.0860479698,
0.0036266756,
0.1894605756,
0.1279629022,
0.2919654846,
0.4137978554,
0.5586194396,
0.0206765849,
-0.0752346367,
0.0232259687,
-0.2163595259,
0.3355209827,
0.2859250307,
-0.4978640676,
-0.0601823889,
-0.455947876,
0.6871023774,
0.0796208456,
-0.393835634,
0.6042627692,
-0.4194526672,
-0.0022163414,
-0.3747645617,
0.1960708201,
-0.1593595594,
0.2180628031,
-0.0998059288,
-0.1875369698,
0.2010432631,
-0.1893469393,
-0.1475235224,
0.362347573,
-0.0691768304,
-0.2590939701,
0.9119032621,
0.4146744311,
-0.3639191687,
0.5360084772,
-0.3220921755,
-0.3441719115,
0.2907015979,
0.4422157109,
1.1025243998,
-0.2245747596,
0.4218157232,
-0.1001015306,
0.0656613559,
-0.1356573105,
0.4189776182,
-0.2543448508,
-0.2218509167,
-0.1442281008,
-0.4144136012,
-0.4718343914,
0.3312448859,
-0.4342331588,
0.4456098676,
-0.8437309861,
-0.1272569895,
-0.3445412517,
-0.1129257083,
-0.5513482094,
0.0698959082,
0.2657240033,
0.6129200459,
-0.5404829979,
0.7509177327,
0.4997870922,
0.0251287501,
-0.7489821911,
-0.1818409711,
0.0039576255,
-0.632250905,
0.4574570954,
0.213135913,
-0.0616074726,
0.22054331,
-0.383770138,
-0.7169758081,
0.7423511147,
0.9168913364,
-1.1843411922,
0.0725442842,
0.1732203811,
0.4340753257,
-0.0283193924,
-0.023441378,
-0.0061982502,
0.2801006734,
-0.4816854,
-0.887031734,
0.4371583164,
0.2566957176,
0.0237315316,
0.1879117936,
-0.9364357591,
0.6989812255,
-0.0066843182,
-0.3658936024,
0.0918832347,
0.2222632766,
0.3461687863,
0.152695924,
0.4190169275,
0.0500014052,
0.9457119107,
0.149099052,
0.9866473079,
-0.5905736685,
0.2104871422,
0.9937701821,
-0.4345090389,
0.3974507153,
0.2830585539,
0.1543029845,
0.0478732102,
0.689052999,
0.0271587744,
1.0936988592,
0.3602065146,
-0.5688137412,
-0.1964862645,
-0.188382104,
-0.692368567,
0.2954616249,
-0.0824626237,
-0.6058962941,
-0.0224444158,
0.0403935909,
-0.0164449066,
0.2221343219,
-0.5073430538,
0.7285643816,
0.2948473394,
-0.6082592607,
0.5021285415,
0.0535713322,
0.6635910273,
-0.724989593,
0.2940201461,
-0.2399136424,
0.5360800624,
-0.0740843341,
-0.2795350254,
0.121898137,
0.0471583977,
-0.0705501512,
-0.5355668664,
0.4124959409,
-0.205129534,
-0.2393850833,
0.1975780278,
0.3443906605,
0.1964659691,
-0.3367982507,
-0.6762869358,
-0.073973231,
-0.0992394164,
-0.1866006255,
0.6779756546,
0.5857413411,
-0.0299080648,
0.5236549377,
0.5673468709,
0.1407193244,
0.0499995537,
0.2471452802,
0.9648764729,
-0.4984677136,
-1.144325614,
-1.1682727337,
0.3476270437,
0.0047196266,
-0.488805443,
0.9580424428,
0.4643252492,
0.5414590836,
-0.1853290647,
0.9050677419,
0.3010825217,
0.2735430896,
-0.6103482246,
0.8631208539,
-0.3373443484,
0.2403674722,
-0.1872135848,
-0.858248055,
0.0821093544,
0.3932757378,
-0.3985031843,
-0.0927927718,
0.5156783462,
0.9846007228,
0.0816119313,
0.2240982056,
0.3212979734,
-0.044711791,
0.4134693444,
0.583771348,
1.1820440292,
-0.0468098335,
0.2711614072,
-0.6520537138,
-0.5173723102,
0.1151962131,
-1.2958364487,
-1.0489137173,
-0.3258168399,
-0.6175566316,
-0.1112162098,
0.2696964443,
0.834890604,
0.8781304955,
-0.457100004,
0.1666915417,
-0.4878924787,
-0.2242587209,
-0.0875453129,
-0.2032099217,
0.2966190279,
-0.0912564173,
-0.8128963113,
0.8277353644,
0.1734794229,
0.1781260222,
-0.4743879437,
0.0842493847,
0.4975526929,
-0.0717543811,
0.1371900141,
0.1298910826,
-0.316976577,
0.039114777,
0.0321031436,
-0.0091771381,
-0.1109913439,
0.7378411293,
-0.5768588781,
0.1523673832,
0.3486124575,
0.7239906788,
0.2964941263,
0.182979539,
0.8155443072,
-1.0287588835,
0.3344324231,
0.4942113757,
0.2941871881,
0.4114435315,
-1.1552708149,
-0.0230158512,
-0.106778726,
-0.9643004537,
-0.950297296,
0.3347261548,
-0.7712448835,
-0.2174351364,
1.2261607647,
-0.4622160494,
-0.2792408764,
-0.0804675594,
-0.4702549577,
-0.0126983514,
-0.8318731785,
1.0966749191,
0.1764458269,
-0.0494005866,
-0.1533697546,
-0.215030551,
0.8249012232,
0.2935206294,
-0.8605393767,
0.3751469553,
0.6356261373,
0.1606816202,
-0.2090263814,
0.6975550652,
-0.0321644917,
0.0963013321,
-0.0544834211,
-0.5494810939,
-0.5587356687,
-0.3650301695,
-0.8231198788,
0.187310487,
0.0778769851,
-0.4993678331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15480v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15480v2
|
Automatic Time Signature Determination for New Scores Using Lyrics for Latent Rhythmic Structure
| 2023-11-27T01:44:02 | 2024-01-28T19:53:22 |
Callie C. Liao, Duoduo Liao, Jesse Guessford
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD
|
There has recently been a sharp increase in interest in Artificial
Intelligence-Generated Content (AIGC). Despite this, musical components such as
time signatures have not been studied sufficiently to form an algorithmic
determination approach for new compositions, especially lyrical songs. This is
likely because of the neglect of musical details, which is critical for
constructing a robust framework. Specifically, time signatures establish the
fundamental rhythmic structure for almost all aspects of a song, including the
phrases and notes. In this paper, we propose a novel approach that only uses
lyrics as input to automatically generate a fitting time signature for lyrical
songs and uncover the latent rhythmic structure utilizing explainable machine
learning models. In particular, we devise multiple methods that are associated
with discovering lyrical patterns and creating new features that simultaneously
contain lyrical, rhythmic, and statistical information. In this approach, the
best of our experimental results reveal a 97.6% F1 score and a 0.996 Area Under
the Curve (AUC) of the Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) score. In
conclusion, our research directly generates time signatures from lyrics
automatically for new scores utilizing machine learning, which is an innovative
idea that approaches an understudied component of musicology and therefore
contributes significantly to the future of Artificial Intelligence (AI) music
generation.
|
[
-0.3042210639,
-0.6702336669,
0.4992900491,
0.5809226036,
-0.1988536716,
0.4131163955,
0.0774157867,
-0.7285040617,
0.5462298393,
0.4050919414,
-0.9660698771,
-0.6949353814,
-0.2935749292,
-0.001309196,
-0.5039479136,
1.1407847404,
-0.118452698,
-0.5274073482,
0.0777405053,
-0.066612266,
-0.3933031559,
-0.1388520002,
-0.2571794689,
-0.4672517478,
0.531616509,
0.1966125071,
0.0692927241,
0.595597744,
0.4406814277,
0.2424049526,
0.0071469108,
0.2552154064,
-0.0721404105,
0.2487303913,
0.6312451959,
-0.4389669299,
-0.5599733591,
0.7100622058,
0.4983335137,
0.5194276571,
0.0372517593,
0.6439511776,
-0.1696033925,
0.7486539483,
-0.2371326983,
0.4073041379,
-1.0545628071,
0.6468836665,
-0.4484845698,
-0.7757251859,
-0.1320383251,
-0.3947366476,
0.1615435481,
-0.6110042334,
0.3096762598,
-0.1663862914,
0.8216912746,
0.516187489,
-0.1681893468,
-0.5848177075,
-0.7957789302,
0.6788593531,
-0.2175088823,
-0.0675654709,
0.1905733943,
0.7180210948,
-0.1967628151,
-0.4113521874,
-0.3904273212,
-0.4939560592,
0.0723639727,
0.3084965646,
0.0992006958,
-0.3687521815,
0.368239671,
0.2696250081,
-0.5903092623,
-0.3236908615,
0.0324420892,
-0.3211805224,
0.9045598507,
0.3623100221,
0.4583238959,
-0.3451960683,
-0.6229045987,
0.1899880469,
-0.6036046147,
0.6184953451,
0.6332194805,
0.2948734164,
-0.243418619,
0.5940762758,
0.1823519021,
0.6890720129,
0.1685290188,
-0.0668052733,
0.1957066655,
-0.1231123433,
0.1545139253,
0.42709589,
1.1038962603,
0.0422697738,
0.3423701823,
-0.4018885195,
-0.5348699689,
0.4454073012,
0.0504494756,
-0.2783459127,
-0.4395397604,
0.080377467,
-0.6236546636,
-0.4218898416,
0.2055101991,
-0.4069063663,
-0.201625213,
-0.7829535007,
0.4857027829,
-0.4321756959,
0.2060878724,
-0.2666686177,
-0.166148901,
0.1105953306,
0.0367920101,
-0.4543700218,
-0.1308119446,
0.5684984922,
1.0132088661,
0.0636770055,
-0.1714852005,
-0.7052793503,
0.194151625,
-0.4004225731,
0.8376176357,
-0.4475127459,
-0.1832356155,
-0.5405364633,
-0.2453930527,
-0.1811206937,
-0.32773,
0.104386203,
-0.4775654078,
0.187097162,
0.098434329,
-0.671238184,
0.0578629486,
-0.0297308248,
-0.9239450693,
0.7305420637,
0.1626457125,
-0.3315246701,
0.2614250183,
-0.9627239704,
-0.5812484622,
0.0914952755,
-0.164978683,
-0.69293046,
0.3445232511,
0.2102701366,
0.4525505006,
0.1067775413,
0.0502591208,
-0.2389624864,
-0.6064593792,
1.1324595213,
-0.4107895195,
0.8689187765,
0.6318109632,
-0.511910975,
-0.1008622572,
-1.0223677158,
0.3376641273,
-0.0112188384,
-0.4027525783,
0.1646765769,
0.0655431971,
0.3552970886,
0.117716983,
0.2833866775,
-0.4044602215,
0.1184467897,
-0.3747733831,
0.5402114987,
0.6065119505,
0.2084961683,
0.1560916305,
-0.7687783241,
0.669963181,
-0.3916235864,
-0.1071354672,
-0.0316213593,
-0.4694987237,
-0.01387145,
-0.1532110125,
0.3480377495,
0.4614237547,
-0.3422470391,
0.8220071197,
-0.325371623,
-0.7167110443,
-0.4998079836,
0.2399934381,
0.2426046133,
0.394377023,
0.3799817264,
-0.2415598929,
-0.7433396578,
-0.3088670075,
-0.4960033298,
-0.2958826423,
-0.0369805992,
0.296772778,
0.1936971396,
0.2089903653,
1.0445306301,
-0.5070662498,
-0.5700977445,
-0.0665596575,
0.4972077608,
0.2930799723,
0.4357750714,
0.8604910374,
-0.6912317872,
-0.6690722704,
-0.1972969919,
-0.6228414774,
-0.6523039937,
-0.3599847257,
-0.0840736851,
-0.1292435676,
0.3278422058,
-0.2859764099,
0.1873026192,
0.5559285283,
-0.4360287786,
0.5265905857,
0.2304489315,
0.2935207188,
-0.7210877538,
0.2479162961,
-0.1418676674,
-0.0529898629,
-0.4485773742,
-0.330150485,
-0.1698640734,
-0.2091405839,
-0.1172943711,
0.3080636263,
-0.3117871284,
-0.0984745324,
-0.2970558107,
0.0869052559,
-0.0105852177,
0.2723295987,
-0.1596338749,
0.3783963919,
0.130463779,
-0.4190119207,
0.3944301307,
-0.1247791722,
-0.6071878672,
0.3400560617,
-0.6289060116,
0.2209426761,
0.0655819103,
0.1447254866,
-1.0061080456,
-0.2627237439,
0.1225570142,
-1.2129153013,
0.4671834707,
-0.3679329753,
-0.0321908779,
-0.1951009035,
0.0743697211,
0.3786304593,
0.562838316,
-0.2544360161,
0.6515093446,
0.4758005738,
0.1082794443,
-0.3538646102,
-0.6068834662,
0.0990672484,
-0.5133680105,
-0.6712677479,
0.6352389455,
-0.1030978262,
-0.2138170749,
-0.0030809173,
-0.014431214,
0.061470326,
0.5373232961,
0.4655677676,
0.3157971799,
-0.4201418161,
0.1347183287,
-0.0518977791,
-0.4661999345,
0.2463385612,
-0.7330764532,
0.4891811311,
0.1857845634,
-0.1485627741,
-0.8738788366,
0.4319185913,
0.7530544996,
-0.5833336115,
0.2567065656,
0.8960525393,
-0.2957755327,
-0.3467299044,
-0.1374808997,
0.2170383483,
-0.3968773484,
-0.0940871313,
-0.3208974004,
-0.411344856,
0.654351294,
0.2619582713,
-0.0510902926,
0.5803793073,
0.3193430007,
-0.6055256128,
1.0829584599,
0.2882680893,
-0.172198087,
0.8205212355,
-0.4589667022,
-0.1027973816,
-0.5787215233,
-0.3181478679,
-0.5980371237,
-0.84239012,
-0.6235020757,
-0.1482025832,
0.6040269732,
-0.1668335348,
-0.0623127855,
0.1681014597,
-0.5618502498,
0.3285503983,
0.3869287968,
0.0131620653,
-0.0239300188,
0.064362675,
-0.2326728106,
0.0828369707,
0.0149056688,
-0.4697962701,
1.3080188036,
0.1432886869,
0.4690265656,
0.104609713,
0.8944715261,
0.6474659443,
0.1566152871,
-0.7128260732,
0.255898118,
-0.3290116191,
-0.4793590307,
-0.3052557409,
-0.723667264,
-0.6071002483,
-0.53355515,
-0.3912188113,
-0.5618821383,
-0.45271492,
0.3189156353,
-0.3934316635,
0.1295198202,
-0.4314928651,
0.6237439513,
-0.6383571029,
-0.0707577094,
0.3607214391,
-0.5472994447,
-0.0229726639,
-0.1245745569,
0.1535550207,
-0.7019512653,
-0.1031288505,
0.9517153502,
-0.3552791178,
0.6825788021,
-0.5715111494,
-0.1737762094,
0.5730811357,
0.0552188903,
0.518560648,
0.1274166107,
0.0805233493,
0.0426575057,
-0.3006003499,
-0.2515734434,
-0.5823491216,
0.7280593514,
-0.831890583,
0.0774673969,
-0.1473886967,
-0.5623705983,
-0.2013436705,
-0.0647189468,
0.469560802,
0.4973329902,
0.1122899279,
0.1457434446,
0.4154925346,
0.2119837701,
0.6590326428,
0.5145345926,
0.0962692872,
-0.5840663314,
0.8514733315,
0.1874892414,
-0.1625479311,
0.7693459392,
0.4554698467,
-0.5941377282,
-0.6065374017,
-0.50438869,
0.0505436696,
-0.3508261442,
-0.0092263874,
-0.438149333,
-0.1498542726,
-0.4978658557,
-0.0352894068,
-0.1201595291,
-0.5323218107,
-0.1781573147,
0.1892635822,
0.6033158302,
0.5212341547,
0.0333250724,
0.2396807224,
-1.0625342131,
0.5524365902,
0.1998869628,
0.3140951097,
-0.1973039061,
-0.4633657932,
-0.1830043048,
-0.0523693375,
-0.1629997045,
-0.92443645,
0.0825511441,
0.3785479665,
0.3829780817,
0.3058357239,
-0.0594779439,
0.8479723334,
-0.3795017004,
0.7424904108,
0.1102599427,
-1.0545393229,
0.8751604557,
-0.5593686104,
0.06376151,
0.2988089919,
0.1012944877,
-0.5310505629,
-0.368060559,
-0.3790970147,
-0.7547506094,
0.4726609886,
0.4654513597,
-0.1172092706,
0.3647082746,
0.6948705912,
0.315585494,
0.1117026657,
-0.8364768028,
-0.4409382343,
-0.3280049562,
-0.7652198076,
-0.473613441,
0.3072524667,
0.0749698654,
-0.0041941698,
0.4946278334,
-0.1920988709,
0.2224184424,
0.0037339733,
-0.0550477766,
-0.5261734724,
0.0695005581,
0.2668011487,
0.2740780711,
-0.0554901697,
-0.188776359,
-0.4756238163,
-0.6802607179,
0.4595248401,
0.2369487286,
-0.6962618232,
-0.1101675779,
0.7917586565,
0.720238924,
-0.1983429939,
-0.4631620646,
0.2145924866,
-0.0863445401,
-0.0688669011,
-0.9785746336,
0.480684638,
-0.1310896426,
0.2111434937,
0.5090295076,
0.2427492589,
-0.0720572025,
-0.3806401193,
0.3412588537,
0.370020628,
-0.8770426512,
-0.3572888672,
0.7683649659,
-0.3515664637,
-0.3470866978,
0.3594704866,
-0.2041608095,
-0.4781450331,
0.88055408,
0.1959194243,
1.1368536949,
-0.1501743197,
0.1205284819,
0.1746885329,
0.006659464,
0.5475982428,
0.5585801005,
-0.4160377979,
-0.1840177923,
-0.5296247602,
-0.9651199579,
0.0896260068,
0.1453470588,
-0.6143804193,
0.2219351381,
-0.3981091678,
-0.0396907218,
0.3153828681,
0.410294354,
-0.5171761513,
0.3752319813,
0.2088135779,
0.3401721716,
-1.1586126089,
0.395478189,
0.7081229091,
-0.4296362996,
-1.1019282341,
0.2810963988,
0.1459802985,
-0.7240897417,
0.4793278873,
0.3976477385,
-0.1539658308,
-0.0276139919,
-0.5214091539,
-0.7128772736,
0.9801569581,
-0.0862229541,
-0.3743344247,
0.0280699395,
0.273253262,
0.6671671867,
-0.5785087943,
-0.0808031857,
0.5394473076,
0.52779001,
0.2997947633,
-0.3740443289,
-0.2284161597,
-0.653742969,
-0.4978111684,
0.4170276225,
-0.2546974421,
1.0905743837,
-0.0932375491,
-0.1604183167,
0.4245465696,
0.6133556962,
0.2686134279,
0.838671267,
0.594836235,
0.4278587699,
0.7497227788,
-0.4202434719,
0.6214954257,
-0.4273683727,
0.2159924209,
0.9837068915,
-0.1215564236,
0.5143594742,
0.2006641626,
-0.2859684527,
0.6499378085,
0.5825791359,
-0.2377895117,
0.4512698352,
0.5745867491,
-0.2316895425,
-0.3723199368,
0.0685591623,
-0.2386388779,
1.1223562956,
0.3440023661,
-0.6673907042,
0.2795469165,
-0.0989263058,
-0.2064565867,
0.3291207552,
-0.1368101686,
0.8598834276,
-0.1250380576,
-0.7690933347,
0.0826300457,
-0.271574676,
0.1162034869,
-0.6168133616,
-0.1509715021,
-0.0393723845,
0.0842475072,
-0.293831259,
-0.64656353,
0.1490352154,
0.2639795244,
-0.4030365348,
-0.1827709079,
0.3888956308,
-0.4340215027,
-0.7024406791,
0.1898888797,
0.3168928623,
-0.0229058582,
-0.2013297379,
-0.5881141424,
-0.155858025,
-0.1284247339,
0.2407312989,
-0.226079911,
0.7732861638,
0.1269733608,
0.4355267882,
0.8547896147,
0.5996674895,
0.2850137353,
0.2470083237,
0.374392122,
-0.9252481461,
-0.9052814841,
-0.5945364833,
0.3551212251,
0.0893960148,
-0.0874808505,
0.4097561538,
0.5311415792,
0.6028488278,
-0.0170827005,
1.0597559214,
-0.0644949302,
0.7858285904,
-1.0850832462,
1.0670075417,
-0.8337731957,
0.6786623001,
-0.8141860962,
-0.893243432,
-0.3311742246,
0.258190155,
-0.2255880386,
0.2074239403,
0.3559945226,
0.4544416964,
0.1688240469,
0.2069512159,
-0.180004254,
-0.0612559579,
0.5560067296,
1.0752464533,
1.2866902351,
-0.3656496406,
0.683062315,
-0.6506434083,
-0.1338909715,
-0.1053894386,
-1.076233387,
-0.8221662045,
-0.6142114401,
-0.4148940742,
-0.1727843732,
-0.4208046198,
0.995233655,
0.3640491962,
-0.9448999166,
-0.1019520462,
0.0769429132,
-0.0150228953,
-0.4557270408,
-0.2550946474,
0.7061294317,
-0.2588699758,
-0.2941435575,
0.5930424929,
0.2140566111,
0.5500226021,
-0.087349318,
-0.1390145868,
0.2737357914,
-0.2703159153,
0.1688172221,
0.0691246241,
-0.6953269243,
-0.2766675651,
0.3791405261,
0.1889150143,
-0.0516206734,
1.1885390282,
-0.7909600139,
0.3320391476,
0.5026372075,
0.1439671218,
0.0759846494,
0.0384828635,
0.1934273094,
-0.7488098741,
-0.3870979548,
0.4239962995,
0.3820795119,
0.1964704692,
-0.2978947461,
0.1953206658,
0.5662035942,
-0.1472059786,
-0.3989602923,
0.1401196718,
-0.9734742641,
0.0824814439,
0.3925005496,
-0.2534498274,
-0.4726033807,
-0.3181616664,
0.1066544056,
0.4765920043,
-0.1675138026,
1.2092027664,
0.284073174,
-0.4162702262,
0.4871338606,
-0.2782151103,
0.6534495354,
-0.0866304114,
-0.4917292893,
-0.1405752599,
0.6923269033,
0.210998252,
0.3760197461,
0.4844228625,
-0.4477139711,
0.6942794919,
-0.0116011016,
-0.2160390317,
-0.3596968353,
-0.7675981522,
-0.0351068154,
0.6628646255,
-0.109920077,
-0.4089049995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03723v1
|
ChatGPT Application In Summarizing An Evolution Of Deep Learning Techniques In Imaging: A Qualitative Study
| 2023-11-26T23:22:37 | 2023-11-26T23:22:37 |
Arman Sarraf, Amirabbas Abbaspour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The pursuit of article or text summarization has captured the attention of
natural language processing (NLP) practitioners, presenting itself as a
formidable challenge. ChatGPT 3.5 exhibits the capacity to condense the content
of up to 3000 tokens into a single page, aiming to retain pivotal information
from a given text across diverse themes. In a conducted qualitative research
endeavor, we selected seven scientific articles and employed the publicly
available ChatGPT service to generate summaries of these articles.
Subsequently, we engaged six co-authors of the articles in a survey, presenting
five questions to evaluate the quality of the summaries compared to the
original content. The findings revealed that the summaries produced by ChatGPT
effectively encapsulated the crucial information present in the articles,
preserving the principal message of each manuscript. Nonetheless, there was a
slight diminishment in the technical depth of the summaries as opposed to the
original articles. As a result, our conclusion underscores ChatGPT's text
summarization capability as a potent tool for extracting essential insights in
a manner more aligned with reporting than purely scientific discourse.
|
[
-0.4570631385,
-0.487036854,
0.4234290421,
0.1589302868,
-0.6619300842,
0.3192593157,
-0.2539722323,
-0.4535955191,
0.1279529631,
0.095413357,
-0.132593438,
-0.5003653765,
-0.6366721392,
0.1401067078,
-0.7125840187,
1.1989684105,
0.1420889199,
0.1428036392,
0.0078953952,
-0.1653220206,
-0.3969686925,
-0.2528038919,
-0.9473028183,
-0.4179173112,
0.4575883746,
0.1975836605,
0.8010639548,
0.3293803334,
0.9819304347,
0.1578592509,
-0.296930939,
0.3219697475,
-0.4936777651,
0.1542669535,
0.0253191888,
-0.1661078632,
-0.386969924,
-0.074025631,
0.9087738395,
0.8077278733,
-0.0569020845,
-0.1254999042,
0.4494732916,
0.9689227343,
-0.3517618179,
0.2664227784,
-0.2820371687,
0.4573767781,
0.0798123926,
-0.6113307476,
-0.2530727983,
-0.365265131,
0.4796412885,
-0.7269876599,
0.4227833152,
-0.1868227869,
0.9117249846,
0.1505652368,
-0.3072136045,
-0.2237962335,
-0.6822710633,
0.4373373687,
-0.864410162,
-0.0178250596,
0.0165671036,
0.3788529634,
0.0530568585,
-1.0195358992,
-0.309351027,
0.0122029372,
-0.2127189338,
0.537404716,
-0.1118200496,
0.095164068,
0.0537521951,
0.6586411595,
-0.9522942901,
0.0632407293,
-0.6674327254,
-0.1398532838,
0.7411004305,
0.1934278011,
0.1777051538,
0.0294788796,
-0.1715780348,
-0.1257071793,
-0.6363885403,
-0.3593887091,
0.0901676118,
0.0277375188,
-0.1411255598,
0.7357912064,
-0.2839276791,
0.3191434741,
-0.1677553952,
0.0158197284,
0.1749978364,
-0.2686053813,
-0.0925324932,
0.3760401309,
1.119345665,
0.7899556756,
0.061895512,
0.0183240827,
0.0330437906,
-0.2720416188,
0.2250491828,
-0.9498983026,
-0.3341684341,
0.1680273861,
-0.7802348733,
-0.2959400117,
-0.0461485982,
-0.7540156841,
-0.605892539,
-0.3649386168,
0.205525592,
-0.6547822952,
-0.3859296739,
0.2977769375,
-0.4686898589,
0.5726620555,
0.4337902069,
-0.8107937574,
0.3156498671,
0.8603705764,
1.3588434458,
-0.1038266271,
-0.1709298193,
0.0955789983,
-0.0349562503,
-0.4424234629,
1.1297119856,
-0.3335061967,
-0.7651389837,
-0.1356642991,
-0.2349939793,
-0.0847401172,
-0.4178949296,
0.5339515209,
-0.4761486351,
0.3790359497,
-0.2293068618,
-0.6503337026,
-0.4051292539,
0.3226765692,
-0.5237978697,
0.8940600753,
-0.1381444037,
-0.795258522,
0.4714819789,
-0.728091836,
-0.5479053259,
0.2900683582,
-0.2916198075,
-0.5462598801,
0.2400472164,
0.5853933692,
0.7095866799,
0.0478139669,
0.1231481433,
0.027859943,
-0.3388642967,
0.3757042587,
-0.4835989475,
0.5871658921,
0.5126376748,
-0.089499779,
-0.1095026135,
-0.4588522017,
-0.2280927002,
0.1987407058,
-0.2023647726,
-0.1471172422,
0.057861086,
-0.0170635916,
-0.2410394251,
0.0293492302,
-0.437150836,
0.3116357327,
-0.3779670596,
0.5050773621,
0.2323894948,
0.4042010009,
0.5276364088,
-0.4258194864,
0.4056850374,
-0.0192028265,
0.0716687441,
-0.5930559635,
-0.7275469303,
-0.581708014,
-0.1549994946,
0.2571144402,
0.2944734097,
-0.7091779113,
-0.0768737271,
-0.5039380789,
-0.7010392547,
-0.6388811469,
-0.2094305754,
0.2120233923,
0.5834395289,
0.2451757044,
-0.4415271282,
-0.5350233912,
-0.9280644059,
-0.3185739517,
0.0064437031,
-0.2288089395,
0.1231099665,
0.4860197902,
0.1654534787,
0.9127998352,
-0.7220902443,
-0.335226953,
-0.2353655994,
0.6640864015,
0.3511225283,
0.5277928114,
0.6024112105,
-0.9148669243,
-0.6433134079,
0.3237550855,
-1.0751000643,
0.2768042982,
-0.4757780731,
0.2056861967,
-0.0040362505,
0.4328975677,
-0.6529545784,
0.3253698349,
0.1942899078,
-0.040100541,
0.6615772843,
-0.2981466949,
0.4252239466,
-1.2102618217,
0.2461855114,
-0.0534097739,
-0.1649332047,
-0.4907438755,
-0.0917831212,
-0.0541778766,
-0.4731516838,
-0.3972492814,
0.1512814462,
-0.6540504098,
-0.1120724455,
-0.4256419539,
0.1485040337,
0.1913075745,
0.2177355587,
0.3165206909,
0.8348143697,
0.5763477087,
-0.5456371903,
0.1993335038,
0.3332064152,
-0.1844752729,
0.442340225,
-0.8972875476,
0.1401362121,
-0.4781309068,
0.1897692084,
-1.0109719038,
-0.2953865826,
0.3126182556,
-0.8266758919,
0.5490506887,
-0.2446160167,
-0.3234891593,
-0.1155861393,
-0.5383131504,
0.3079978228,
0.6573732495,
-0.1482194662,
0.5377140641,
0.4015780687,
-0.4263493121,
-0.3094070852,
-0.873272419,
0.5433852673,
-0.192457512,
-0.3627816141,
0.2294955403,
0.241360411,
-0.0427780487,
0.2777552009,
0.0665508583,
-0.0473225564,
-0.0238022488,
0.0593688674,
0.046239011,
-0.5867077112,
0.1803848147,
0.0188890211,
-0.1943911165,
0.1313898563,
-0.3269704282,
0.4538857341,
-0.3529491127,
-0.3814810812,
-0.5801805854,
0.6467635036,
0.2892383933,
-0.1667128801,
0.5949401855,
0.909119308,
-0.16868788,
0.2245976925,
-0.3719426394,
-0.0965420678,
-0.423440516,
0.3376959562,
0.1482325643,
-0.9140752554,
0.5173123479,
0.0517796092,
0.2172593027,
0.7173424959,
0.3318980336,
-0.5021834373,
0.7713026404,
0.5282746553,
-0.1046534032,
0.5644355416,
-0.5752404928,
0.5205301046,
-0.9075767398,
-0.3689366877,
-0.461137265,
-0.3910758495,
-0.4807766378,
-0.0875513628,
0.5127930045,
-0.3253965676,
0.0445171595,
0.0382293649,
-0.9186620116,
0.6461071968,
0.5561090112,
0.4155634344,
0.3965424597,
0.1427848041,
0.4819117188,
-0.0767890438,
-0.8017731905,
-0.5731155276,
1.1473981142,
0.2791256011,
0.686721921,
-0.0870358199,
0.783749938,
0.3758063316,
0.2947575748,
-1.0165169239,
0.5011690855,
0.0333786793,
-0.3490263224,
-0.2534858584,
-0.2325393856,
-1.131408453,
0.3874330223,
-0.1349369287,
-0.3093392551,
0.2976809442,
0.1614549011,
-0.5555187464,
0.2816140652,
-0.7996928096,
0.5389198065,
-0.0749046281,
-0.1302538365,
-0.2372710407,
-0.7553529739,
0.3940977454,
0.1780020595,
-0.0481291674,
-0.0848844349,
-0.0957675278,
0.8275284767,
-0.1953692585,
0.9420762062,
-0.0714814737,
0.0853637159,
0.4415006042,
-0.0653856695,
-0.0006271481,
0.0858981982,
0.2951010764,
0.1146931127,
0.0349077173,
-0.5052313209,
-0.5097925067,
0.4570058286,
-0.61145401,
-0.3807345629,
-0.6202631593,
-0.5589619875,
0.0243099425,
0.3787016273,
0.3709484041,
0.6386147141,
-0.2700294554,
0.358617574,
0.7640471458,
-0.2348960489,
0.6824053526,
0.0865131021,
-0.1253986359,
-0.4870427847,
0.9752157331,
0.1405864209,
-0.04439101,
0.5042075515,
0.2997530699,
-0.1408744454,
-1.1375980377,
-0.09050937,
0.1221365258,
-0.6438235044,
-0.3195903301,
-0.7312411666,
-0.3841475248,
-0.5151120424,
-0.3772956729,
-0.3342765868,
-0.5600978732,
-0.3302252591,
-0.0366183966,
0.2099302411,
0.6316447854,
-0.0172357485,
0.4965962172,
-1.0810950994,
0.1722302437,
0.1026489064,
0.1716808975,
0.0422854163,
-0.3716699183,
-0.4446282685,
0.1626308709,
-0.4492563009,
-0.7049951553,
0.6706276536,
0.5403092504,
0.4605593979,
0.458868891,
-0.0647023246,
0.5915564299,
0.029486578,
1.1085225344,
0.2596231103,
-0.3858944178,
0.6481142044,
-0.6732733846,
0.6390168667,
0.4787001014,
0.4593179524,
-0.5992973447,
-0.386739701,
-0.6342471838,
-1.156350255,
0.1963256449,
0.3340532184,
0.2570338249,
0.1110409126,
0.4336103499,
0.091684483,
0.1987089068,
-0.4561165571,
0.0073682484,
-0.5665431023,
-0.2847498357,
-0.0303417835,
-0.4042058289,
-0.1625305861,
-0.0456413962,
0.6740889549,
-0.2141484022,
0.452922374,
0.5285104513,
-0.1989310235,
0.6519888639,
0.2162146419,
0.7328227758,
0.4849261045,
-0.0778099,
0.2624906301,
-0.0677024052,
-0.9858494401,
-0.2424415499,
-0.0081613008,
-0.2787786722,
0.1639128327,
0.7074033618,
0.5423982739,
0.1915980726,
-0.4490483999,
0.4350543022,
-0.3164795935,
-0.6083280444,
-0.1193356141,
-0.133431524,
0.0218476318,
0.2468045205,
0.6676045656,
0.1578981876,
0.7397356033,
-0.1983418465,
0.030092489,
0.3133503497,
-0.4529213309,
-0.2392745167,
0.3902256489,
0.1321490705,
0.088306807,
0.6773316264,
0.0765549466,
-0.3030589521,
0.6183543801,
0.1986980885,
1.0708572865,
0.1845414042,
0.4331168234,
0.4209335446,
0.3503895402,
-0.1234268099,
0.1092803106,
-0.240967676,
-0.6339934468,
-0.536996901,
-0.2990761697,
-0.5939514637,
-0.1216952354,
-0.6560866237,
-0.107487388,
-0.2766446769,
-0.1279143691,
0.2123478502,
-0.1206924915,
-0.3268629313,
0.0934431031,
0.183850199,
0.7556858063,
-0.6570296884,
0.3326650262,
0.6543474793,
-0.6642943025,
-0.6597783566,
-0.3013962209,
0.0086758258,
-0.6113709211,
0.1655875593,
0.0364584737,
-0.014462295,
0.0713617802,
-0.6051691175,
-0.5176436901,
1.0879100561,
0.4114196301,
-0.2695944011,
0.0718066916,
0.2939475179,
0.6959909797,
-0.1011594385,
0.1993469745,
0.4311923981,
0.3345448077,
0.2355730832,
-0.699164629,
-0.0523806363,
-0.4357080162,
-0.0545730144,
0.0643916801,
-0.4429048598,
0.3220587969,
-0.2165569067,
-0.5101578832,
-0.1527955383,
0.6821698546,
-0.1975787729,
0.3334957957,
-0.0730591267,
0.4273577631,
0.6376324296,
-0.2735083997,
1.1048588753,
-0.0618950315,
0.4779731333,
1.0516480207,
0.1426302344,
0.4948653281,
0.6478347778,
-0.092015557,
-0.1720242202,
0.8458029628,
-0.2594506443,
0.6218576431,
-0.2805401087,
-0.4491815865,
0.208141923,
-0.2140453607,
-0.6566922069,
0.3035921156,
0.3895946145,
-0.2679908574,
-0.4560391009,
0.1968346536,
0.1083358601,
-0.088961564,
-0.480547905,
1.1945647001,
0.4041672945,
-0.5497673154,
0.3559539914,
-0.5714877248,
0.4679614007,
-0.5311996937,
-0.1664616168,
-0.4120921195,
0.1066578403,
-0.572625339,
-1.2096517086,
0.7039276958,
-0.26413849,
0.1689869761,
-0.3732368946,
0.8298962712,
-0.1094420999,
-0.3283201456,
-0.3660976887,
0.296223253,
0.3868786693,
-0.1735381782,
-0.3440897167,
-0.0869766548,
-0.1087827757,
-0.3870238364,
0.3212426305,
0.655790329,
0.328137666,
0.6739958525,
0.6309267879,
0.1006340981,
0.0035819323,
-0.0285278782,
1.0936793089,
-0.6693920493,
-0.3626839221,
-0.9884886146,
0.5743687749,
-0.3678359985,
-0.4387423098,
0.7842581272,
0.8986417055,
0.5973198414,
-0.1336810142,
0.9240468144,
-0.0627336055,
0.1558965296,
-0.7376454473,
0.964672029,
-0.2708530724,
0.2110089213,
-0.1608320177,
-0.627453506,
-0.786195755,
0.4218216836,
-0.2945350707,
-0.1561498493,
0.8471969366,
0.5820394754,
-0.0649718195,
0.3333877325,
0.2191895843,
-0.0143496543,
0.4343126118,
0.2197234035,
0.7551710606,
-0.4663156271,
0.5123338103,
-0.2816277444,
-0.0878351182,
-0.2495398372,
-1.0152140856,
-0.7430443764,
-0.5804430842,
-0.5640593171,
0.0268965606,
-0.0973786488,
0.5375868678,
0.6492252946,
-0.6809566021,
0.0580946915,
-0.0951592475,
-0.0846106634,
-0.4365558922,
-0.2303293794,
0.7057662606,
-0.5504187346,
-0.4001637399,
0.0029896663,
0.5017546415,
0.1873250902,
-0.0422641709,
0.1044527963,
0.0596583448,
-0.4490578175,
0.7331478,
0.3734627962,
-0.1551703811,
-0.0210779645,
-0.0816317275,
-0.0533039495,
0.3862552643,
1.0848408937,
-0.5771943331,
0.2781818509,
0.5145130157,
0.8210449815,
0.9544814825,
-0.213145256,
0.6614424586,
-0.5348863006,
0.2135003209,
0.6176372766,
0.4042369127,
0.4377624094,
-0.4409603179,
0.6133478284,
0.0820160359,
-0.6222679019,
-0.6181039214,
-0.2045084536,
-1.403241992,
-0.2069406509,
0.8927708268,
-0.2113882899,
-0.205064252,
-0.1540565342,
-0.6988795996,
0.2244788408,
-0.5115115047,
0.8555604815,
0.385535866,
-0.272428751,
-0.7297886014,
-0.6030023098,
0.3361678421,
0.1459597051,
-0.7119377851,
-0.2498310357,
0.4033200443,
-0.0072535258,
0.1600244045,
0.7121347189,
-0.4253139198,
0.2819902897,
0.2060203254,
0.0407866165,
-0.2726588547,
0.1895704865,
-0.3534314036,
0.4633200169,
0.120760262,
-0.2684209049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03722v1
|
Leveraging AI-derived Data for Carbon Accounting: Information Extraction from Alternative Sources
| 2023-11-26T22:49:41 | 2023-11-26T22:49:41 |
Olamide Oladeji, Seyed Shahabeddin Mousavi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Carbon accounting is a fundamental building block in our global path to
emissions reduction and decarbonization, yet many challenges exist in achieving
reliable and trusted carbon accounting measures. We motivate that carbon
accounting not only needs to be more data-driven, but also more
methodologically sound. We discuss the need for alternative, more diverse data
sources that can play a significant role on our path to trusted carbon
accounting procedures and elaborate on not only why, but how Artificial
Intelligence (AI) in general and Natural Language Processing (NLP) in
particular can unlock reasonable access to a treasure trove of alternative data
sets in light of the recent advances in the field that better enable the
utilization of unstructured data in this process. We present a case study of
the recent developments on real-world data via an NLP-powered analysis using
OpenAI's GPT API on financial and shipping data. We conclude the paper with a
discussion on how these methods and approaches can be integrated into a broader
framework for AI-enabled integrative carbon accounting.
|
[
-0.2300635427,
-0.4269632995,
0.481297195,
-0.3548838496,
-0.1133045033,
0.3990276754,
-0.0402131081,
-1.0839867592,
0.1181839108,
0.6367145777,
-0.2987587154,
-0.2713265717,
-0.3868861198,
0.0100004319,
-0.2496633679,
0.9517608285,
0.0766655579,
0.1418100893,
-0.281149894,
-0.0417551957,
-0.5372272134,
-0.6845382452,
-0.9845096469,
-0.2587883472,
0.3877093792,
0.194660455,
0.8690390587,
0.4159913063,
0.5647627711,
0.1695538014,
0.1442909688,
0.2382079661,
-0.108134754,
-0.2735167444,
-0.1976549923,
-0.2673768699,
-0.2963942289,
0.2971338034,
0.6270598173,
0.6548081636,
-0.118526414,
0.1557364911,
0.1512662321,
0.7353227735,
-0.6857889295,
0.5990082622,
-0.6257575154,
-0.0555285253,
-0.0256545991,
-0.0628577918,
-0.3054047227,
-0.3066058159,
0.1672614813,
-0.6235563159,
0.2358235419,
0.2270047069,
0.6397819519,
0.4655844569,
-0.4826160669,
-0.889931798,
-0.8876459002,
0.4461142123,
-0.7959004641,
0.3814184666,
0.3357614875,
0.3038021028,
0.0945228711,
-1.04750669,
-0.4891795218,
-0.3916877806,
-0.2312761396,
0.3861034513,
-0.1417251825,
-0.0565013401,
-0.1471506208,
0.581081748,
-0.2683116496,
0.2683253288,
-0.3332265317,
-0.3572618365,
0.7353008389,
0.0385641158,
0.2391657531,
0.2043663561,
-0.1546677351,
-0.5198991299,
-0.5335718393,
-0.0157564171,
1.0806236267,
0.7391000986,
-0.4512660801,
0.5721034408,
-0.1143768579,
0.3971148729,
-0.5715148449,
0.4636037648,
0.0775868669,
-0.5366326571,
-0.2010078132,
0.4369523823,
0.2887372375,
0.0606114492,
-0.1041427627,
-0.2280537188,
-0.0910121351,
-0.0023202812,
0.2075763196,
-0.5118619204,
-0.5663028955,
0.2352022529,
-0.4377666414,
-0.3014551699,
0.5847133398,
-0.8927231431,
-0.2751037776,
-0.6167252064,
-0.1511887908,
-0.0038739161,
-0.1813505739,
0.0477334335,
-0.6599333882,
0.5004069209,
0.3065776527,
-0.6721823215,
0.3421125114,
0.7958953381,
0.9340431094,
-0.0643796325,
0.3524041474,
-0.6034981012,
0.2523955107,
-0.28816998,
0.6392486095,
-0.80674088,
-0.2667142153,
-0.1391453296,
-0.1074848995,
0.3068676889,
-0.4437427819,
0.418082267,
-0.6557556391,
0.176765278,
-0.4983738959,
-0.5122237206,
-0.5579026341,
0.1228515282,
-0.879753232,
0.7593652606,
0.2607971728,
-0.4972366989,
0.4521925449,
-0.9411962628,
-0.2316127121,
0.1939737797,
-0.2595766783,
-0.3297532201,
0.051967293,
0.1997003406,
-0.033053454,
-0.6059613228,
0.4083153009,
-0.4768617749,
0.2098141015,
-0.0569407977,
-0.9671605229,
1.1425156593,
0.3289748728,
-0.0170570463,
-0.3018448353,
-0.5671321154,
0.0739090592,
0.021859128,
-0.1914694607,
-0.3509896994,
0.1499151886,
0.205554992,
-0.2203193158,
0.3587281704,
-0.5419546962,
0.3204994202,
-0.2757069767,
0.567625463,
0.9602967501,
0.2828574479,
0.0840862542,
-0.4635857344,
0.4726227224,
-0.2833716273,
-0.0932440311,
0.0766240954,
-0.6007703543,
-0.1903212517,
-0.0794627815,
0.5239693522,
0.5592132211,
-0.4646446109,
0.3626205027,
-0.0712673068,
-0.6117255092,
-0.2972524464,
0.0216528755,
-0.1814851463,
0.5098779798,
0.2704018056,
-0.6754443645,
-0.3998939097,
-0.6206265688,
-0.2606206834,
-0.4391673505,
-0.0968250558,
0.2708956599,
0.5430717468,
-0.104804866,
1.0087704659,
-0.7501316667,
-0.1721045822,
-0.032406535,
0.3075672686,
0.2006519735,
0.9068288803,
0.6149010062,
-1.2067397833,
-0.1237196177,
0.2423847318,
-0.6642961502,
0.3013175726,
-0.580597043,
0.0448634401,
0.0157308131,
0.3514505327,
-0.4798270762,
0.5254852176,
0.3852838874,
-0.2138696611,
0.4860673845,
-0.3557644784,
-0.0564375594,
-0.706058979,
0.2875905633,
-0.1930525452,
-0.0298623871,
-0.3467177749,
0.1169694513,
-0.3514996469,
-0.1621703058,
-0.2068730444,
0.4752961993,
-0.4315473735,
-0.4269118607,
-0.1830378175,
-0.2189179808,
0.1495110095,
0.4196460247,
0.104624182,
0.8204879761,
0.2133155614,
-0.5700107813,
0.5792169571,
0.445245564,
-0.2573228776,
0.2940537035,
-0.4392141402,
0.4158170521,
-0.1124230772,
0.4168539345,
-0.9739906192,
-0.1434953958,
0.4719687998,
-0.4191020131,
0.4026539028,
-0.0310216006,
-0.6608929038,
-0.0246911794,
-0.1425857097,
0.5507453084,
0.3073476255,
-0.5624317527,
0.7282627821,
0.2699202597,
-0.3048350811,
-0.3338013887,
-0.7260701656,
0.3421600163,
-0.0705941617,
-0.1465656906,
0.17321603,
-0.1592329592,
-0.3554886281,
0.3234281242,
-0.5433600545,
-0.1459843367,
0.3201479316,
-0.1919357926,
0.283066541,
-0.1417484283,
0.066496402,
-0.2318493724,
-0.3103201091,
0.2775582075,
-0.5026180148,
0.3625800014,
0.0119386027,
-0.4980455935,
-0.5879082084,
0.4076302648,
0.335894227,
-0.2529880404,
0.6464393735,
0.3613523841,
-0.574742794,
0.2726704776,
-0.1261096448,
0.0694397986,
-0.4779303074,
0.0628960878,
0.0533187352,
-0.5853259563,
0.5650274754,
-0.1711267978,
0.4090420306,
0.6743469834,
0.2987664938,
-0.0821812898,
0.8592410088,
0.9343627691,
-0.2043140829,
0.3560327888,
-0.4215697348,
0.5234033465,
-0.7180964351,
-0.2701984644,
-0.8652011752,
-0.0672345981,
-0.8452731967,
-0.1655460149,
0.2097120136,
-0.0966348797,
-0.2843859494,
0.1231264472,
-0.4946515858,
0.3908964396,
0.5859228969,
-0.0569419563,
0.5509784818,
-0.2353541404,
0.4632660747,
0.2953723371,
-0.5443674326,
-0.4787509441,
0.8642132878,
0.0912811682,
0.4976547062,
0.0084058149,
0.1599401832,
0.7504039407,
0.374767065,
-0.6777723432,
0.0184762068,
-0.1100076064,
-0.8405898213,
-0.1489358544,
-0.5228634477,
-0.6514204144,
-0.2170650363,
0.0887061283,
-0.4510762691,
0.3085955679,
0.1871644706,
-0.2534302771,
0.6945165396,
-0.7608405948,
0.5911447406,
-0.567281127,
0.0909997299,
-0.1430687159,
-0.7127690911,
0.2012865096,
-0.0312441029,
0.1801014096,
-0.0228888188,
-0.1294240803,
0.6354506612,
-0.5227480531,
1.0781333447,
-0.3615406454,
-0.3591557443,
0.6980088949,
-0.1993623227,
0.6850117445,
0.1682529449,
-0.0059530265,
0.5052597523,
-0.0140573923,
-0.4007906914,
-0.5391590595,
0.2661021948,
-0.5794993639,
-0.3317571282,
-0.6644049287,
-0.4174196124,
-0.2598725855,
0.1409384608,
0.1679605544,
0.1639410704,
-0.1869588941,
0.1486051679,
0.0445238762,
0.0129976682,
0.569922626,
0.0981003493,
0.3583642244,
-0.5139302611,
0.8819567561,
0.3050425649,
0.2289436013,
0.6147422194,
0.3349041045,
-0.4511894286,
-0.747125864,
-0.1840092242,
-0.0921021327,
-0.8400817513,
-0.4550836384,
-0.2443702817,
-0.1718650311,
-0.4864543974,
-0.3985511661,
-0.4316729903,
-0.448515296,
-0.4740369916,
-0.4160203636,
0.4134950936,
0.8021553159,
-0.2597030103,
0.4069522023,
-0.9010804892,
0.351405561,
0.2512917519,
0.5151067972,
0.0306174215,
0.2439857572,
-0.3473215699,
0.4865095317,
-0.1591929197,
-0.6556401849,
0.370389998,
0.0019510989,
0.6665173173,
0.3434862494,
0.2292581499,
0.8141472936,
0.1696308106,
0.8834459186,
0.0742254257,
-1.1145780087,
0.1531705707,
-0.0688844696,
-0.1371794343,
0.664249599,
0.3991707861,
-0.5311310291,
-0.2534665763,
-0.8721086383,
-1.1121931076,
0.5175094604,
0.3788233399,
0.0057351957,
0.3300024569,
0.5385088325,
0.4363899231,
0.5272718668,
-0.6708300114,
-0.0161129422,
-0.23297593,
-0.1832072735,
-0.3366870582,
0.5504277349,
0.0115198717,
-0.1318864524,
0.872420609,
-0.4699241221,
0.2005771846,
0.3540727496,
0.0863170475,
0.1013324484,
-0.0633159801,
0.2153421342,
0.6504746675,
-0.3113278747,
-0.1161131933,
0.0168642458,
-0.6783996224,
-0.0793922395,
-0.0594454743,
-0.2565323114,
-0.2804780006,
0.4907755852,
0.4294250906,
-0.445266664,
-0.7923894525,
0.0377644189,
-0.0029393958,
-0.0555447526,
-0.5641217232,
-0.1075944752,
-0.1820559353,
0.291596055,
0.3722454011,
0.4577651918,
0.336137712,
-0.6924164295,
0.2100335807,
0.5903115273,
-0.375636071,
-0.193098709,
0.9336750507,
0.2289435863,
0.0691038296,
1.1543394327,
0.0309496317,
-0.1881168485,
0.9710049629,
0.2959417403,
1.0460926294,
0.3134011328,
-0.0269139837,
0.1454624981,
0.5638191104,
0.1193323582,
0.0527655706,
-0.3808832467,
-0.8540645838,
-0.4898912609,
-0.2520940304,
-0.8815856576,
0.1092049032,
-0.7422082424,
0.1114468649,
-0.8032955527,
0.2720046937,
-0.0503412038,
0.2599696815,
-0.7498269081,
0.1381349713,
0.3588105142,
0.9062227011,
-0.7510836124,
0.3366834819,
0.4449901879,
-0.5102175474,
-0.4624958038,
-0.0656001568,
0.2061462998,
-1.0303287506,
0.1491550505,
0.0529617146,
-0.2613098621,
-0.1091388166,
-0.9067624211,
-0.7355449796,
1.0899684429,
0.4865064919,
-0.4635654986,
-0.029720813,
0.0491692722,
0.3434060812,
-0.4774513841,
0.0750221089,
0.7224916816,
0.8476169109,
0.1142420024,
-0.2633259892,
-0.0647796765,
-0.1774728,
-0.0810101628,
0.3181751072,
-0.8041660786,
0.4440659583,
-0.0764291137,
-0.2610961795,
-0.1555741578,
0.8685890436,
-0.2884811163,
0.5848046541,
0.4981481433,
0.5707611442,
1.1037954092,
0.0924900994,
0.996337831,
-0.0702831149,
0.3300969899,
1.0941820145,
-0.6063511968,
0.5500997901,
0.4112637937,
-0.1716929078,
0.4028544426,
0.7900074124,
-0.2007965595,
0.5618086457,
-0.1083713844,
-0.0472066328,
-0.0455669872,
-0.3593037724,
-0.1917181015,
0.6132357121,
0.3212987185,
0.077817142,
-0.1566017419,
-0.2570558488,
-0.2152207494,
-0.1411547214,
-0.2917651236,
1.0601420403,
0.0240905527,
-0.3229260445,
-0.2887555063,
-0.1386131942,
0.2838778198,
-0.7077283263,
-0.415697664,
0.2280857712,
-0.1894948334,
-0.1327643245,
-0.8663355708,
0.791120708,
-0.0458293967,
-0.0167546067,
-0.6492720246,
0.3781192303,
-0.0589417927,
-0.4421273172,
0.0978221297,
0.4198937714,
-0.0581265874,
-0.1427601129,
-0.5131856203,
-0.2509665489,
0.2479794919,
0.0173412003,
0.2346190065,
0.1485901475,
0.0313681923,
0.2815130353,
1.1910007,
0.121623233,
-0.3688253462,
-0.1345175803,
0.8281949759,
-0.8463866115,
-0.7951061726,
-0.6462289691,
0.4144308269,
-0.1187746003,
-0.2114648968,
0.2784161866,
0.8247298002,
1.1836464405,
0.2691892385,
1.2947566509,
-0.3135018051,
0.0765608773,
-0.8528218865,
0.4100616574,
-0.3617433608,
0.3288658857,
-0.0123920022,
-1.0446180105,
-0.2230031192,
0.350584209,
-0.0741286352,
0.0336716063,
0.4674958289,
0.2613757253,
0.0200674776,
0.4932199419,
-0.1881783456,
-0.0163328294,
0.7598391175,
0.1657918394,
0.6537075639,
-0.2288116664,
0.4717927575,
-0.260699898,
0.0721180737,
-0.0478135645,
-1.1022357941,
-0.0361370891,
-0.570325613,
-0.5577367544,
-0.0528258346,
-0.4757361412,
0.7759403586,
0.3396625221,
-0.9574433565,
-0.3292330801,
-0.5120654106,
0.4184828401,
-0.6727061868,
-0.2207556963,
0.4526347518,
-0.2068630904,
-0.7403243184,
0.3228166699,
0.2700985372,
0.4213873148,
-0.0036873289,
0.025289055,
0.0288682524,
0.0512172207,
0.1343805343,
0.5089731812,
-0.0696082413,
-0.6300302744,
-0.2931684554,
0.3938584328,
0.3527726829,
1.1480383873,
-0.5615124702,
0.3111357987,
0.5955951214,
0.9913105369,
0.5166892409,
0.2064788491,
0.6735293865,
-0.6074358821,
0.203625828,
0.6831472516,
0.3056102097,
0.2200670391,
-0.7481257319,
0.6870003343,
0.3361256123,
-0.4995647371,
-0.7230926156,
0.1463439316,
-1.1052612066,
-0.4453459084,
0.4075894356,
0.0482944623,
-0.0269142278,
-0.3624668419,
-0.0904616788,
0.287227571,
-0.4869491756,
0.4720394611,
0.7979537845,
-0.5486967564,
0.1118477285,
-0.5649310946,
0.3494102657,
-0.0499061383,
-0.9689714909,
0.3984217644,
0.6482889056,
-0.1564708799,
0.2975572348,
0.5837582946,
0.0225730017,
-0.0567772873,
0.3587932289,
-0.1154338568,
0.0841678008,
-0.6277925372,
-0.3358434737,
0.1034492031,
-0.0828451365,
-0.0251555648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15451v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15451v1
|
Uncertainty-aware Language Modeling for Selective Question Answering
| 2023-11-26T22:47:54 | 2023-11-26T22:47:54 |
Qi Yang, Shreya Ravikumar, Fynn Schmitt-Ulms, Satvik Lolla, Ege Demir, Iaroslav Elistratov, Alex Lavaee, Sadhana Lolla, Elaheh Ahmadi, Daniela Rus, Alexander Amini, Alejandro Perez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present an automatic large language model (LLM) conversion approach that
produces uncertainty-aware LLMs capable of estimating uncertainty with every
prediction. Our approach is model- and data-agnostic, is
computationally-efficient, and does not rely on external models or systems. We
evaluate converted models on the selective question answering setting -- to
answer as many questions as possible while maintaining a given accuracy,
forgoing providing predictions when necessary. As part of our results, we test
BERT and Llama 2 model variants on the SQuAD extractive QA task and the
TruthfulQA generative QA task. We show that using the uncertainty estimates
provided by our approach to selectively answer questions leads to significantly
higher accuracy over directly using model probabilities.
|
[
-0.1553221345,
-1.135188818,
0.99678725,
0.1449138671,
-0.0648164675,
0.1075980067,
-0.151888296,
-0.5894012451,
-0.2192799896,
0.6677606702,
-0.7836588025,
-0.3435672224,
-0.5231814981,
0.0080380319,
-0.5761715174,
0.4313499033,
-0.3302227557,
0.1830985248,
-0.0576014705,
0.2033399642,
-0.1578115523,
-0.5619168282,
-0.7211067677,
-0.0721406415,
0.5020598769,
0.2718218565,
0.7592311502,
0.4042601287,
0.617410481,
0.1586210728,
-0.0377525613,
0.0542963706,
-0.3532091379,
0.3862143755,
-0.1953986883,
-0.6854065657,
-0.3257272542,
0.1482248455,
0.700047195,
0.479126364,
-0.2776211202,
0.4002366662,
-0.3015096486,
0.2359102368,
-0.4589076936,
-0.0429531746,
-1.1983337402,
-0.1564094722,
-0.0377779119,
0.2239219099,
-0.5936869979,
-0.4771683514,
0.2229828686,
-0.6533432603,
0.0030737524,
0.0204106569,
0.6749721766,
0.53907758,
-0.4357679784,
-0.2937791646,
-1.0565054417,
0.9735542536,
-0.5480547547,
0.5386068821,
0.6541326642,
0.6286562085,
-0.0563082434,
-0.5112285018,
-0.58011204,
-0.1201246083,
0.5017805099,
0.3295730948,
-0.1795860976,
0.2054531872,
-0.1548907906,
0.1934513897,
-0.3830474615,
0.1139283478,
-0.3082238734,
-0.2624853551,
0.841083169,
-0.0550486445,
0.1267814338,
0.0602166057,
-0.1425843984,
-0.0214624703,
-0.589219749,
0.0921582282,
0.3803295195,
0.189984262,
0.1215478182,
0.7247959375,
-0.2546394765,
0.8142465353,
-0.0061201691,
-0.0678362027,
-0.2358473539,
-0.336299181,
-0.2423259318,
-0.3741596043,
0.4633511007,
0.1180685461,
0.1674278826,
-0.1531422585,
-0.3661928773,
-0.0493505634,
0.2875282466,
-0.6083567142,
-0.0325946398,
0.4621810317,
-0.2543278337,
-0.2437356114,
-0.2629653811,
-0.4260797203,
-0.1063208282,
0.0808454752,
0.4739454687,
-0.4138153493,
-0.1145186648,
0.0268501416,
0.0173393562,
0.5108626485,
0.6600627303,
-0.5758282542,
0.2510786653,
0.4210110903,
0.3145938218,
-0.3839792907,
0.1675741225,
-0.4493428767,
0.3419802487,
-0.6896787286,
0.7984000444,
-0.6536474228,
-0.2881324589,
-0.0215402432,
-0.2985455394,
-0.145235613,
-0.503975451,
0.5983865261,
-1.1335351467,
0.0220145732,
-0.2299923599,
-0.6662279367,
-0.3867173493,
0.4049441218,
-0.5826544166,
0.9777672887,
0.5318443179,
-0.2260245979,
0.1301487982,
-0.3332454264,
-0.021262072,
-0.1474391073,
0.1143653616,
-0.1131341234,
0.0736157447,
0.3815808296,
0.3561703861,
-0.4911158383,
0.416288048,
-0.3754354715,
-0.0576077737,
0.679970324,
-0.6892853975,
0.6232141256,
0.43334952,
0.2883047462,
0.0796568319,
-0.446818918,
0.2983097136,
0.0092149815,
-0.5645430684,
0.0791331828,
0.1063859165,
-0.0969326049,
0.2601078153,
0.5346002579,
-0.6026659012,
-0.0171022862,
-0.3161540926,
0.2255770862,
0.7816465497,
0.1310228705,
0.470035851,
-0.4622856081,
0.8463357687,
-0.1956944764,
0.2137186229,
0.5710123777,
-0.7759242058,
-0.7406201363,
-0.2855896652,
0.3809193671,
0.8502526879,
-0.8094848394,
0.342987597,
0.047631301,
-0.592205286,
-0.7976580858,
0.2203788459,
0.083094798,
0.4550828934,
0.2175662071,
0.1048434898,
-0.4829747379,
-0.8417893052,
-0.126850456,
-0.7701019645,
-0.1299654841,
0.3428090215,
0.2652646601,
-0.2285797298,
0.9309415221,
-0.482817024,
0.1384090632,
-0.4963775873,
-0.2627294362,
0.1688564569,
0.3019576073,
0.5056801438,
-0.7385737896,
-0.5210648179,
-0.1430582553,
-0.5844089985,
-0.1357728839,
-0.1643317193,
-0.3326071501,
0.1703919023,
0.3830528855,
-0.6382133961,
0.335937053,
0.8232837319,
0.0820377991,
0.4666018784,
0.113213852,
0.062970452,
-1.1215848923,
-0.1661014706,
-0.1484825462,
-0.3522159457,
-0.8176749945,
0.2632828355,
0.2451770455,
0.0438014008,
-0.405357033,
0.6818247437,
-0.2431033254,
-0.1013222337,
-0.09551052,
-0.0896529183,
0.0217264276,
0.1178096682,
0.2930378914,
0.9321414232,
0.5330468416,
-0.6289509535,
0.3685637414,
0.3610672355,
-0.3851404488,
0.0487073287,
-0.6807152033,
0.2380508482,
-0.1034820452,
0.0309465975,
-1.1168010235,
-0.3816325665,
0.3084266782,
-0.5522152185,
0.1784425676,
-0.1018649042,
-0.4567172825,
-0.4041899741,
0.011268395,
0.3134159446,
0.5989629626,
-0.1323876679,
0.5587918758,
0.2397807837,
-0.5868327022,
-0.3221371472,
-0.7512914538,
-0.1583330333,
-0.0193177983,
-0.5299253464,
0.182284072,
-0.5188609958,
-0.4060211778,
-0.1569391936,
-0.1612574607,
-0.602594018,
0.4366864562,
-0.1445324421,
0.5007345676,
-0.1380859762,
0.2225431651,
0.3211229146,
0.286137104,
0.1115754694,
-0.1600648314,
0.4781036377,
0.0880450383,
-0.4912827313,
-0.3630876243,
0.6234848499,
0.3579025865,
-0.3667780161,
0.5743297935,
0.3973175287,
-0.4642105103,
-0.2272512764,
-0.7338377237,
-0.2094036639,
-0.450702399,
0.5838096738,
-0.4667600989,
-1.0482991934,
0.8227211237,
0.333680898,
0.0750163198,
0.4431997538,
0.5397971869,
-0.3973049819,
1.1207209826,
0.6199511886,
0.0723994225,
0.3800057471,
0.1505362093,
0.1290529817,
-0.5579268932,
0.0836530179,
-0.5684632063,
0.0751492456,
-0.264454633,
-0.7792163491,
0.4351056218,
0.1634327769,
-0.2135481536,
-0.0288409218,
-0.4574583471,
0.1001845077,
0.5739514232,
0.1689432412,
0.1832289845,
-0.0869307816,
0.3960458338,
0.1309105009,
-0.6380454302,
-0.5509480834,
1.4012733698,
0.4462239146,
0.8286947012,
0.2750036418,
0.5572962165,
-0.0336589739,
0.4958280921,
-0.8555346727,
0.4731304944,
0.0574691035,
-1.1521632671,
-0.6854249239,
-0.3807020485,
-0.6242603064,
-0.022005111,
-0.1262082458,
-0.7287633419,
0.0865189061,
-0.1022597253,
-0.5907334685,
0.2764244378,
-0.5637277961,
0.2852016091,
-0.2185086161,
0.1816854179,
-0.1112823337,
-0.5490817428,
0.3984132409,
-0.5532046556,
-0.1083925292,
-0.4711106122,
-0.3010729849,
0.8233228922,
0.0750757083,
0.7385575175,
0.0281005688,
-0.393101871,
0.712939322,
0.3436337709,
0.6728614569,
0.2217006087,
-0.8657321334,
0.1094989553,
-0.0360344686,
-0.3309077621,
-0.6147170067,
0.2460528612,
-1.0556921959,
-0.9981942177,
-0.1808194816,
-1.1667814255,
-0.5384314656,
0.07459075,
0.0754403695,
-0.1262508631,
-0.0916454196,
-0.0758811831,
0.8855714202,
-0.1605651081,
0.3493776023,
0.6274650693,
-0.1735111773,
-0.3901629746,
0.302177161,
0.2986640334,
0.5460990667,
0.6670745015,
-0.0815765485,
-0.7061892748,
-1.0651038885,
-0.5370922685,
0.1940245181,
-0.7160323262,
-0.1526876986,
-0.5320473909,
-0.5029518008,
-0.6768996119,
-0.193745032,
-0.3511485755,
-0.5404267311,
-0.4825406671,
-0.3202934861,
0.3982503712,
0.6103473902,
0.275831908,
0.4935421944,
-0.8158940077,
0.306918174,
0.6721635461,
0.2350058109,
-0.5645993352,
-0.7704708576,
0.172875613,
0.2282644659,
-0.096304372,
-1.2498310804,
0.4467826784,
0.2814074457,
0.8493104577,
0.1517405063,
0.347422123,
0.4903889298,
-0.2087018043,
0.7250434756,
-0.1580958366,
-0.9265382886,
0.6861549616,
-0.4607625306,
0.0786222816,
0.8108842373,
0.325006932,
-0.2277064621,
-0.5724045634,
-0.5115053058,
-0.4974869192,
0.5788510442,
0.1360176802,
0.0953955054,
0.0624475069,
0.566067934,
0.246801883,
0.4183324277,
-0.701197505,
-0.1202197373,
0.2101372033,
-0.3856940567,
-0.0863157287,
-0.4516844451,
-0.0415479168,
-0.139012605,
0.8055921793,
-0.1570278406,
0.3783567548,
0.2504326701,
-0.1077140644,
-0.170437932,
0.4010565281,
0.289609611,
0.6431206465,
-0.420586884,
0.0781610161,
0.4437004626,
-0.2413104475,
0.3557912111,
0.2249326706,
-0.5837938786,
-0.0618274473,
0.0335980281,
0.3596335351,
-0.3793325126,
-0.784914434,
0.2482540458,
-0.0265372507,
-0.0812211633,
-0.4703812003,
0.0483717136,
0.254832536,
0.2460268587,
0.4298511446,
-0.0405470803,
0.1425263435,
-0.4588644505,
0.2034107447,
0.5202273726,
-0.4884432852,
-0.1291433722,
0.8155686259,
0.1923021674,
-0.0951003432,
0.5785198212,
-0.2635243833,
-0.3594005704,
0.6507835388,
0.6212612391,
0.7370633483,
-0.6794611216,
0.4125277698,
0.1517832726,
0.5421130657,
0.0049196901,
0.6825543642,
0.1005200148,
-1.0581709146,
-0.5088318586,
-0.6620199084,
-0.6479224563,
-0.0143634947,
-0.7568610311,
-0.2459259033,
-0.4808931947,
-0.2734740674,
-0.2199804336,
-0.0445035473,
-0.5060360432,
0.3688474298,
0.2171760798,
0.9274794459,
-0.6743967533,
0.9669410586,
0.8097088337,
-0.1881704926,
-1.0229420662,
0.0691755712,
-0.4057134092,
-1.1003699303,
0.4548519552,
-0.218914777,
0.0208259095,
0.0826468542,
-0.7035048008,
-1.3795740604,
1.0298321247,
0.7264168262,
-0.4588062167,
0.0018036658,
0.4369523823,
0.3233296573,
-0.3435114622,
0.187105909,
0.5327470303,
0.4965279698,
0.0614502579,
-0.9020445943,
-0.0507903062,
-0.0179979168,
0.1677026898,
-0.1356011331,
-0.6315830946,
0.8457787633,
-0.1848838627,
-0.1107597202,
0.3188375831,
0.9294205904,
0.3790656328,
0.0633037239,
0.4638081193,
0.0881117806,
1.0854141712,
-0.1233874112,
1.032268405,
-0.3230685294,
0.0414058194,
0.9010743499,
-0.6203625202,
1.1706609726,
0.6268402934,
-0.2075906694,
0.2265270501,
0.9311923385,
0.3226935863,
0.4191258848,
0.1025093198,
-0.4209763706,
-0.9519817233,
-0.0933241248,
-0.1735008359,
0.5922665,
0.6217716336,
-0.2751838863,
-0.0607742295,
-0.3597915173,
-0.173189193,
0.0513803959,
-0.4424974918,
0.7299489975,
0.0859322026,
-0.8003656268,
0.5415687561,
0.2248534262,
0.4112388194,
-0.7802361846,
0.2460071594,
0.023160575,
-0.1810996085,
0.1866430342,
-0.9548107982,
0.4115978181,
-0.0061383173,
-0.3517643809,
-0.2901552916,
0.8404619694,
-0.580866158,
-1.0092226267,
0.0483481213,
0.8735772967,
0.1066419929,
-0.227784425,
-0.7602775693,
-0.0835826471,
0.2514926791,
-0.2968215346,
0.0989244357,
0.1496344954,
-0.2474274486,
1.0712358952,
0.4481869936,
0.016215248,
0.3725487888,
-0.254891485,
0.6643927693,
-0.3315930068,
-0.391266346,
-0.4135613143,
0.2767971754,
0.1138192415,
-0.1632583737,
0.5978288054,
0.2985295355,
0.5326977372,
-0.1286101341,
1.2468520403,
0.2662787735,
0.6400744319,
-0.5500372052,
0.6307174563,
-0.2869428992,
0.2729650438,
0.0606182031,
-0.9001888037,
-0.1038998589,
0.482298404,
-0.4662637413,
-0.0582438335,
0.3855778575,
0.7805963755,
0.2883884907,
-0.1159486622,
0.5142887235,
0.0978045762,
0.2753020823,
0.7438645363,
0.9158698916,
-0.4075525701,
0.7663480639,
-0.2305564135,
-0.0024927468,
0.0276066717,
-0.5408448577,
-0.6338192821,
-0.4374158084,
-0.4310615361,
-0.1231064349,
0.1691993922,
0.6310835481,
0.7236994505,
-0.8910079002,
-0.1570101082,
0.1027237326,
0.2969139516,
-0.1145165339,
-0.1867256016,
0.1798878759,
-0.1450012326,
-0.8267236352,
0.6145523787,
-0.0279632472,
0.342926532,
-0.1532225311,
0.0672526658,
-0.1584115475,
0.6496859193,
0.3319577277,
0.0026874333,
-0.8234887719,
-0.6215603948,
0.3807596862,
-0.1912915558,
-0.069144696,
0.1964839846,
-0.5087708831,
0.2626731694,
0.4748399556,
0.9443118572,
0.4059160948,
0.1830613017,
0.8244809508,
-0.7971451879,
-0.0324173048,
0.6248034835,
0.2103535533,
0.2133029848,
-0.4509087205,
0.3903821409,
-0.1669784784,
-0.5072821379,
-0.7455593944,
0.5841338038,
-1.1486567259,
-0.3100804985,
1.5170986652,
-0.2349188924,
-0.1912810951,
-0.3570293188,
-0.0031739001,
0.3440428078,
-0.4471794963,
0.5708555579,
0.8070930243,
-0.0872157142,
-0.2419383079,
-0.6950477958,
0.3136445284,
0.5628975034,
-0.9376535416,
-0.0088407705,
0.405123651,
0.3308974504,
-0.0767263249,
0.6986557841,
0.0537306592,
0.3452716768,
-0.1528086364,
0.2042662948,
0.2539435029,
-0.1255106032,
-0.1358444095,
0.2791942656,
0.5422340035,
-0.0604940206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15436v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15436v1
|
Learning to Skip for Language Modeling
| 2023-11-26T21:45:53 | 2023-11-26T21:45:53 |
Dewen Zeng, Nan Du, Tao Wang, Yuanzhong Xu, Tao Lei, Zhifeng Chen, Claire Cui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Overparameterized large-scale language models have impressive generalization
performance of in-context few-shot learning. However, most language models
allocate the same amount of parameters or computation to each token,
disregarding the complexity or importance of the input data. We argue that in
language model pretraining, a variable amount of computation should be assigned
to different tokens, and this can be efficiently achieved via a simple routing
mechanism. Different from conventional early stopping techniques where tokens
can early exit at only early layers, we propose a more general method that
dynamically skips the execution of a layer (or module) for any input token with
a binary router. In our extensive evaluation across 24 NLP tasks, we
demonstrate that the proposed method can significantly improve the 1-shot
performance compared to other competitive baselines only at mild extra cost for
inference.
|
[
-0.2197538167,
-0.8378155231,
0.6043456197,
0.2121911347,
-0.2765734196,
0.1346178949,
0.0962820575,
-0.303078413,
-0.0797325894,
0.3917459249,
-0.6150551438,
-0.2505442798,
-0.6245257854,
-0.3997646868,
-0.467132479,
0.8780519366,
0.1427087784,
0.0053118099,
-0.0266664494,
0.1171856746,
-0.494449079,
-0.3125211,
-1.1777911186,
-0.4461613894,
0.9332759976,
0.2399994582,
0.6225522757,
1.0087908506,
0.1296331435,
0.2303328514,
-0.2706887424,
-0.0656748861,
-0.3309410214,
-0.0883566439,
-0.3091487288,
-0.4882826805,
-0.3425380886,
-0.0485331342,
0.7797768712,
1.0978769064,
-0.0777423158,
0.1103719547,
-0.1247284114,
0.7585785985,
-0.8236625791,
-0.1265384853,
-0.5687766075,
0.1940256655,
-0.4389928877,
-0.2352505177,
-0.5732143521,
0.0295682847,
0.2283642143,
-0.5340795517,
0.0491634607,
-0.1331985742,
0.5972555876,
0.2460705638,
-0.258854866,
-0.09312924,
-0.8630181551,
0.7846149802,
-0.6487195492,
0.5145215988,
0.563231051,
0.2092753798,
0.0678451434,
-0.7267298698,
-0.3303379118,
-0.0323086791,
0.0490863658,
-0.1853014082,
-0.0709641352,
0.2345206887,
0.4085535705,
-0.2119125128,
-0.530574441,
0.3886929154,
-0.4862833619,
-0.0393700451,
0.1304684281,
0.1023709103,
0.2661667168,
0.1303136051,
-0.1615254283,
0.0898593888,
-0.8149690628,
0.1596599966,
0.5693827868,
0.6075652242,
-0.0763111338,
0.2849090099,
-0.1944016814,
1.0596807003,
0.0600837655,
-0.0079948315,
0.1254858077,
-0.3715175688,
-0.1922933608,
-0.0287960675,
0.4298023582,
-0.2996986806,
0.3328490257,
-0.380060792,
-0.0318102092,
-0.1504843831,
0.2543980181,
-0.804372251,
-0.1261759102,
0.3695549965,
-0.2735083997,
-0.0102008414,
-0.4120161533,
-0.4218094051,
0.0882886872,
-0.217226088,
0.4283792973,
-0.4883689582,
0.0108748153,
0.2301477641,
-0.0468981676,
0.2519439757,
0.2235357612,
-0.9898290038,
0.7154928446,
0.6552571058,
1.0576056242,
-0.1858291775,
-0.7704587579,
-1.1614618301,
0.0077778697,
-0.5473115444,
0.5597935915,
-0.6955203414,
-0.3251042962,
-0.1637534648,
-0.2921922207,
-0.1748150885,
-0.3340236247,
0.0075352583,
-0.7772253752,
0.1851458699,
-0.1493543088,
-0.5312164426,
-0.1218950897,
0.0954193473,
-0.548571825,
0.7360954881,
-0.029821692,
-0.6784023046,
0.53444314,
-0.6533789039,
-0.6700518131,
-0.1216063648,
0.0541672446,
-0.1158945709,
0.1511336863,
0.3044534624,
0.3422317505,
-0.1303029805,
0.1199980006,
0.0178470202,
-0.6202415228,
-0.2255208641,
-0.4398156404,
0.8991824985,
0.0747392476,
-0.2921703756,
0.0368688479,
-0.9655518532,
0.0389067382,
0.0033045365,
-0.6911412477,
-0.3945790529,
0.207837224,
-0.0783386901,
0.4622283876,
-0.1146721914,
-0.4420053661,
0.1597785354,
-0.6576042771,
0.1215544492,
0.8956703544,
-0.2682869136,
0.7406630516,
-0.1240359172,
0.6881334186,
0.1808296442,
-0.0431248657,
-0.5764425993,
-0.2734998465,
-0.9477081895,
-0.3491966128,
0.6145876646,
0.5395994186,
-0.647020638,
0.2781812549,
-0.1105056629,
-0.2708500028,
-0.3657056689,
0.2484002411,
0.6605058908,
0.4435905218,
0.4042921066,
-0.3807656467,
-0.4773168564,
-0.4599757493,
-0.3811508715,
-0.2445276976,
-0.1268706918,
0.0612116084,
0.2538480163,
0.2296474576,
0.9842640162,
-0.3793870211,
-0.1544701308,
-0.4416256547,
0.1659096479,
0.3007636666,
0.8697734475,
0.4979523122,
-0.4355902076,
-0.4348012209,
-0.0749371573,
-0.4197176695,
0.0466856919,
-0.3293393254,
-0.1889830828,
-0.0226725191,
0.7406877875,
-0.6130936742,
0.4228506684,
0.414857626,
-0.2303032577,
0.3248283565,
-0.1497937739,
-0.2282645702,
-0.532902956,
0.1944399774,
-0.1852240264,
-0.3776250184,
-0.7763498425,
0.1548351198,
-0.1585220248,
-0.1539432853,
-0.9253678918,
1.0065989494,
-0.4751213789,
-0.1066559777,
-0.2720887661,
-0.2001042217,
0.031875737,
0.5449581742,
0.1366879791,
0.5363061428,
0.9226282239,
-0.9075314999,
-0.1006743908,
-0.0214517098,
-0.1362496316,
0.1637998223,
-0.7928518653,
0.484434098,
-0.3986327946,
0.4344647527,
-0.7799756527,
0.0210212786,
0.2267306447,
-0.3814232051,
0.5014057159,
-0.6205152869,
-0.3511409461,
-0.1614537537,
0.038101878,
0.656688869,
0.5998057127,
-0.4555502236,
0.5598775148,
-0.0223751925,
-0.0863151252,
-0.6543708444,
-0.8013299108,
-0.0869853422,
-0.0162639599,
-0.1196574867,
0.2314260751,
-0.0307688136,
0.1738452762,
-0.1526532471,
0.0341969319,
-0.3578509092,
0.1568098813,
0.0772273168,
-0.048692368,
-0.2441551685,
0.1026895568,
-0.1187110916,
-0.4196739495,
-0.0808831304,
-0.7125743032,
0.8588048816,
0.2895425558,
-0.7110825181,
-0.4270463884,
0.323720336,
0.2414967865,
-0.1768936068,
0.7789760828,
0.4807648361,
-0.4219523966,
-0.1754741073,
-0.3357113898,
0.0003584168,
-0.4661357999,
0.4888016284,
-0.4057970047,
-0.6003164649,
0.5042765737,
0.1002766937,
0.244673118,
0.1428971738,
0.1913668811,
0.1724193543,
0.8130322099,
0.8486520052,
-0.2317316234,
0.6180685759,
-0.15741615,
0.2005435824,
-0.4691548944,
-0.0053163706,
-0.6276758313,
-0.3921888471,
-0.3417918384,
-0.6913027763,
0.0799645931,
0.298655957,
-0.5110946894,
0.0783486813,
-0.0556766056,
0.9625166059,
0.6723416448,
0.1144821346,
0.160752371,
0.1163177267,
-0.3756608665,
0.0905540064,
-1.1178548336,
-0.0126133058,
0.9741590023,
0.3561247587,
0.782556653,
-0.1251626313,
0.7151453495,
0.0029705141,
-0.0282577425,
-0.728277266,
0.4986642599,
-0.3244945407,
-0.7787575126,
-0.579901576,
-0.4604893923,
-0.9120215178,
0.2183835804,
0.1207373291,
-0.9724741578,
0.0984274894,
0.4387029409,
-0.6911606193,
0.4808328152,
-0.5644643307,
0.7359834313,
-0.1267584264,
-0.4464867413,
-0.1863634139,
-0.7970842719,
0.1303388923,
-0.2282976359,
0.1851576865,
-0.0098483684,
-0.1066975445,
0.6595478058,
-0.5045850873,
0.947017312,
-0.4156843722,
0.4507040977,
0.2297338694,
0.2272840291,
0.3977048993,
-0.3484835029,
-0.1443208754,
0.1665138751,
-0.5336074829,
-0.8172916174,
-0.4684858918,
0.4646627307,
-0.4121926725,
-0.2861227989,
-0.2777476013,
-0.2466135621,
-0.2412796617,
0.4167228043,
0.399207145,
0.4731465578,
-0.1131439209,
-0.0212774724,
0.5432614088,
-0.5106306076,
0.8238452673,
0.388767451,
-0.2247371078,
0.0801503062,
0.7357891798,
0.3370850086,
0.4762810171,
0.4908173084,
0.3834916949,
-0.2406642139,
-0.7000597119,
-0.6229522228,
0.1055729836,
-0.7479687333,
0.1184270754,
-0.9523186088,
-0.350248158,
-0.2587397695,
-0.3957006037,
-0.7897174358,
-0.3840197325,
-0.3527710438,
-0.1973821223,
0.1038293242,
0.467674166,
-0.1237588227,
0.7963015437,
-0.796707809,
0.1525025666,
0.3755871356,
0.6627969742,
0.5731467605,
-0.6878752112,
-0.3507093191,
-0.3077473044,
-0.1954233348,
-0.3167244196,
0.182237938,
0.4076360762,
0.5900931954,
0.4977517724,
-0.2655847073,
0.9469999671,
-1.1199457645,
0.7098985314,
0.4585984647,
-1.1854199171,
0.5773406029,
-0.300927192,
0.7262589931,
0.4623858333,
0.6169967055,
-0.3755359054,
-0.1214682385,
-0.5727527142,
-1.1134848595,
0.8663719296,
0.0393188037,
0.329600811,
-0.1496565342,
0.3169555068,
0.0108866058,
0.1164692864,
-0.7902726531,
-0.2360173911,
0.1756238043,
0.2150508761,
-0.1362238526,
-0.1159825474,
0.2343499511,
-0.2909559309,
0.5025929213,
-0.1147356108,
0.0883904099,
-0.1660770625,
-0.2514519691,
-0.195225805,
-0.0300133098,
0.4956042171,
1.0453381538,
-0.0448620878,
0.0962472633,
0.1916143,
-0.1725506037,
0.2836669683,
-0.2767863572,
-0.2902746797,
0.1676998734,
0.6013566256,
1.0200676918,
0.4146414995,
-0.5159345865,
0.4790974855,
0.2485496998,
-0.0693495423,
0.0474441648,
0.1081852317,
0.0984247252,
0.0438725278,
0.2696706653,
0.1016519144,
0.0033301704,
-0.5504785776,
0.4152017236,
0.1539299488,
-0.4384574592,
-0.4101878703,
0.6982457042,
0.0863734409,
-0.4878204763,
0.5346150398,
-0.0954189301,
-0.2519986629,
0.499348402,
0.5937082767,
0.9334263206,
-0.2342961878,
0.1705208421,
0.3414583802,
0.3301708102,
-0.3468983471,
0.0081334189,
0.0154979192,
-0.5703095794,
-0.8233490586,
-0.7993415594,
-0.2297775298,
0.0567296632,
-0.3949448168,
0.3594872653,
-0.9138066769,
0.0320081934,
0.1185490415,
-0.3607352674,
-1.0832375288,
0.4354296625,
0.2219641507,
0.8781998158,
-0.7627119422,
0.9834641814,
0.4594054222,
-0.3058775663,
-0.6018443108,
0.016191069,
0.0084968526,
-0.6593840122,
0.8390051723,
0.0491284393,
-0.196952343,
0.1420967132,
-0.4489430487,
-0.8653151989,
0.4076191485,
0.2050715834,
-0.5801520944,
-0.4851424694,
-0.0121844951,
0.2875603437,
-0.282479912,
0.3600127995,
0.4524883926,
0.2267070115,
0.2942967713,
-0.7631934285,
-0.1197187901,
0.1320356876,
0.0274396725,
-0.0016969574,
-0.4546847641,
1.1703672409,
-0.1727597564,
-0.0454001427,
-0.0995051414,
0.3787313104,
0.1531236619,
0.2650026083,
0.6996901035,
0.3235924542,
0.5154933929,
0.285536617,
1.0873516798,
-0.0249643605,
0.1392526776,
1.3339580297,
-0.1903689057,
0.8493440151,
0.4306152761,
-0.3043154478,
0.1669577956,
0.509247303,
0.5833855271,
0.6850739121,
0.5103461146,
-0.0247078892,
-0.3287066221,
0.2024953514,
-0.1024026945,
0.64053756,
0.1172404438,
-0.2436958104,
-0.508164525,
0.061186485,
0.110825181,
-0.2206080556,
-0.3665475547,
0.6562133431,
0.0559550598,
-0.5569440126,
0.6443627477,
0.041314669,
0.6327973008,
-1.0233790874,
0.0590838343,
-0.3240564466,
-0.0745254457,
0.0452397317,
-0.2291157097,
0.4676773548,
0.1146367267,
-0.2310423553,
-0.4212230742,
0.523651123,
-0.1875741631,
-0.5655379295,
0.418024838,
0.7206990719,
0.2929035127,
0.0097720884,
-0.603105545,
-0.0789449438,
-0.2757173479,
-0.4834339917,
0.5842642188,
0.422129631,
0.0543190241,
0.7666714191,
0.9149200916,
0.3050242066,
0.414031893,
0.1691412926,
0.8910754919,
-0.8477364182,
-0.8553001285,
-1.1054463387,
0.6563909054,
0.1941419393,
-0.4709081054,
0.3736408651,
0.4686157405,
1.0668746233,
0.1138339862,
0.6744830608,
0.1348635554,
0.5008162856,
-0.9003710747,
0.6322776079,
-0.5183247328,
0.3307678401,
-0.4785665274,
-0.9935486913,
-0.4629163742,
0.6991336346,
-0.1158642843,
0.1885219961,
0.6483663321,
0.4695472419,
-0.3823372424,
-0.5264179111,
0.6302592754,
0.0945879743,
0.3204969168,
0.4800052941,
0.6082664132,
-0.2563682497,
0.1443379074,
-0.0315235518,
-0.1030175313,
-0.0102864327,
-1.1574175358,
-0.8663816452,
-0.1223970801,
-0.2512868643,
-0.2152219117,
0.3005791903,
0.9874641299,
1.1837615967,
-0.6760778427,
-0.3088128567,
-0.2969240844,
0.2263602763,
-0.2993509471,
-0.0825456753,
0.2219773978,
-0.6485989094,
-0.7468113899,
0.5177559257,
0.3150511682,
-0.0494187027,
-0.3065297604,
-0.0099282423,
-0.5349628925,
0.3928821981,
0.4570325911,
0.5430802107,
-0.6304445267,
-0.2053190768,
-0.1893129051,
0.1274987161,
0.1107663512,
1.0521535873,
-1.0210438967,
0.4000993669,
0.4411548674,
0.9938908815,
0.6997849345,
-0.1786340922,
0.5356345773,
-1.0996148586,
0.6868066192,
0.2577505708,
0.0395767614,
0.1451497823,
-0.2034484893,
0.2759664059,
0.2503156066,
-0.210234344,
-0.7021228671,
0.2368244529,
-0.5253614783,
-0.4440743625,
0.8645328283,
-0.3367632329,
-0.1437377185,
-0.2410923839,
0.1732985526,
0.089836292,
-0.164404586,
0.3238473237,
0.7607463002,
0.0032291727,
-0.3017714024,
-0.7079571486,
0.4161077738,
0.5907722116,
-0.5362414122,
-0.1370402128,
0.3028480709,
0.3238428533,
0.0261677988,
1.2366453409,
0.1347259432,
0.1859611869,
0.2621821761,
-0.1606850922,
-0.0330371857,
-0.8926822543,
-0.3497554958,
0.1237444207,
0.0174116064,
-0.4169546366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15425v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15425v1
|
Machine-Generated Text Detection using Deep Learning
| 2023-11-26T21:16:01 | 2023-11-26T21:16:01 |
Raghav Gaggar, Ashish Bhagchandani, Harsh Oza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7; I.5.4; I.2.6
|
Our research focuses on the crucial challenge of discerning text produced by
Large Language Models (LLMs) from human-generated text, which holds
significance for various applications. With ongoing discussions about attaining
a model with such functionality, we present supporting evidence regarding the
feasibility of such models. We evaluated our models on multiple datasets,
including Twitter Sentiment, Football Commentary, Project Gutenberg, PubMedQA,
and SQuAD, confirming the efficacy of the enhanced detection approaches. These
datasets were sampled with intricate constraints encompassing every
possibility, laying the foundation for future research. We evaluate
GPT-3.5-Turbo against various detectors such as SVM, RoBERTa-base, and
RoBERTa-large. Based on the research findings, the results predominantly relied
on the sequence length of the sentence.
|
[
-0.2771015167,
-0.7956599593,
0.8781001568,
0.0519042164,
-0.393245995,
0.3526519537,
-0.3407351971,
-0.6406558752,
-0.1190693974,
0.4954629838,
-0.5638788939,
-0.6627326608,
-0.7228007913,
0.5544486046,
-0.6429331303,
0.9206364155,
0.0038123385,
-0.0165724978,
0.1129971594,
0.3408652842,
-0.3896714151,
-0.5933119059,
-0.6069011092,
-0.3654268384,
0.5502662659,
0.2930654883,
0.3691191673,
0.5237855315,
0.5863966942,
0.2356751412,
-0.2282584608,
0.3343032598,
-0.3785506487,
0.3350260258,
0.1788957119,
-0.2105748951,
-0.2019413412,
-0.0115319677,
0.8027697802,
0.2279560566,
0.2792703509,
-0.2267143428,
0.1796867102,
0.7168248892,
-0.3736838698,
-0.0353308953,
-0.793566823,
0.2251010835,
-0.2360955626,
-0.1008599997,
-0.4934823215,
-0.1672973931,
0.1559879631,
-0.2270507067,
0.4634951949,
-0.1566271633,
0.9146358371,
0.2174839973,
-0.466461271,
-0.6081624031,
-0.9121389985,
0.7227793932,
-0.6770486236,
0.2745195031,
0.3104594946,
0.1657651663,
-0.1056099162,
-0.5842190385,
-0.6495979428,
-0.3875187039,
0.1740197986,
0.2575666308,
-0.2170569897,
-0.1035556942,
0.1771633774,
0.485756278,
-0.8514772654,
0.555442214,
-0.0831866041,
-0.1885920912,
0.5733733177,
0.3148653507,
0.2151665837,
-0.1538845003,
-0.1439329684,
0.0951818898,
-0.7392576337,
-0.2831786871,
0.5347118974,
0.3431923091,
0.0084703509,
0.5342205167,
-0.3418049216,
0.5211260319,
-0.2564278841,
0.1493899375,
0.2162180096,
-0.1644186676,
-0.4233988822,
-0.0842714086,
1.1275554895,
0.2769509852,
0.5886205435,
-0.0657872558,
-0.2476822436,
0.0828575566,
0.0420821756,
-1.0664901733,
-0.1560160816,
0.084599562,
-0.4048113823,
-0.6397598386,
0.1192507893,
-0.4299013019,
-0.6942996383,
-0.1510400474,
-0.0324298888,
-0.320922941,
-0.3146095276,
0.448787272,
-0.2042342126,
0.2930923104,
0.1559089124,
-0.8166294694,
-0.1197093502,
0.7793258429,
0.6732282639,
-0.287299782,
0.0630089268,
-0.3362055123,
-0.0010887998,
-0.4064582884,
0.9906100035,
-0.4774996042,
-0.530700624,
0.1158144772,
0.0475353599,
0.2939853668,
-0.5552410483,
0.8874614835,
-0.3788401186,
0.2563874722,
-0.1854850352,
-0.7571859956,
-0.0892369971,
0.2894292474,
-0.7208609581,
0.9561665654,
-0.0209967252,
-0.6171049476,
0.6975136399,
-0.3450503051,
-0.8286950588,
0.2939650714,
-0.2025724351,
-0.8218445182,
0.3781597912,
0.4326629639,
0.8566461802,
-0.4329848289,
0.3796945512,
-0.3955065012,
-0.5048933625,
0.3808275461,
-0.8411536813,
0.5965947509,
0.1943808049,
-0.3850968182,
0.0989255086,
-0.6119109392,
-0.2435005456,
0.3169932067,
-0.5089214444,
-0.0819243938,
0.0232627094,
0.297129482,
0.0265730228,
-0.024695266,
-0.5508473516,
0.2779047489,
-0.3108147979,
0.4563061297,
0.652767837,
-0.0576764829,
0.11036136,
0.0393754579,
0.5674717426,
-0.0954013541,
-0.2062911987,
-0.2442847937,
-0.650662303,
-0.6093699336,
-0.3168641329,
0.3015882969,
0.5782843828,
-0.7209208012,
0.6158946753,
-0.1561754346,
-0.3075590432,
-0.2176329941,
0.1523929983,
0.2757634223,
0.2168336213,
0.1505420655,
0.0826172233,
-0.7238847017,
-0.9293745756,
-0.5110747814,
-0.0938194096,
-0.2011882365,
0.347006321,
0.7332987189,
-0.3333908319,
0.7115886807,
-0.6037310362,
-0.291213125,
-0.4161989987,
0.3260027766,
0.2370447516,
0.2697266936,
0.5426803231,
-0.6886203289,
-0.6818878651,
-0.0723084137,
-0.9331558347,
-0.1762529165,
-0.1035622358,
0.4580307603,
0.2596191168,
0.6225787401,
-0.6175144911,
0.4772104919,
0.3764583468,
-0.2135126889,
0.4732508957,
-0.0099139791,
0.1923971176,
-1.0824631453,
-0.1536673158,
0.3685300648,
-0.4561114907,
-0.6435838938,
-0.2245692611,
0.0399448201,
-0.0272410754,
-0.2342460006,
0.3296743035,
-0.3178076148,
-0.0208950974,
-0.6466354132,
-0.0375213698,
0.1501519531,
0.1030570716,
0.1158443391,
0.9657936692,
0.2156334817,
-0.3876795471,
0.2783189714,
-0.1091257334,
-0.6406825781,
0.2499098927,
-0.691731751,
0.2466292977,
-0.0790547282,
0.3709142506,
-1.1595795155,
-0.2740052342,
0.2806472182,
-0.7083364725,
0.2871513963,
-0.0245755222,
-0.9503886104,
-0.6584662199,
-0.2761945128,
0.2160949707,
0.5306756496,
-0.3370429873,
0.2923259735,
0.3733886778,
-0.0762784928,
-0.3030014932,
-0.7312278748,
0.3918606341,
-0.3313187957,
-0.3955759704,
0.2204900831,
0.0368648507,
-0.1039196327,
-0.2676465213,
0.1436453611,
-0.1303811669,
0.3763927519,
0.0782306716,
0.1047021523,
-0.3895169795,
0.0735357627,
0.036570929,
0.0109786885,
0.109954156,
-0.3784930408,
0.602591455,
-0.125461489,
-0.0243757237,
-0.6818835735,
0.2766844332,
0.478613764,
-0.0492647327,
0.4990307391,
1.1108503342,
-0.4374999106,
-0.1175934374,
-0.5379354954,
-0.0800523311,
-0.5020744205,
0.4591184556,
-0.2502108812,
-1.2931289673,
0.3449853063,
0.1191782281,
-0.4766323268,
0.582564652,
0.7256734967,
-0.1490061879,
1.4456919432,
0.5522501469,
-0.4064804316,
0.3400067389,
-0.1714231968,
0.1725507826,
-0.7446792126,
0.0728974566,
-0.5985920429,
-0.0299908854,
-0.7088145614,
-0.1335339099,
-0.1164295375,
-0.0788953975,
-0.2813206315,
0.292632699,
-0.7527852058,
0.5584211946,
0.4317175448,
0.1919169724,
0.2860773206,
-0.0380860455,
0.0764515549,
-0.0019464887,
-0.2148581892,
-0.6101619005,
1.1632521152,
0.4993709624,
0.5322651267,
-0.0321919583,
0.581628263,
0.5236235857,
0.4873389006,
-0.8688319921,
0.5388351679,
-0.3680231869,
-0.7075060606,
-0.1112740561,
-0.4383003712,
-1.0837898254,
0.0599687099,
-0.2435403466,
-0.6711371541,
-0.2605437636,
-0.2120822221,
-0.316702038,
0.275360465,
-0.553876996,
0.6511406898,
-0.2447863966,
-0.1810196936,
0.0028204573,
-0.3181328475,
0.5288564563,
-0.1108888015,
-0.0639825612,
-0.3419328034,
0.0450408645,
0.6338341236,
0.0591697879,
0.8761412501,
-0.0899217427,
-0.4442605972,
0.3211881816,
-0.0867280588,
0.4434454143,
0.212633431,
0.0828925893,
0.0065384377,
-0.6381997466,
-0.1197537556,
-0.1384178996,
0.6232319474,
-0.4902718067,
-0.5468829274,
-0.3896041512,
-0.6575509906,
-0.0191414114,
0.4328521192,
0.4079485238,
0.2378407121,
-0.3070157766,
0.4137713313,
0.7095854878,
-0.4080348313,
0.5652096272,
0.4026130736,
-0.3848182261,
-0.4353623688,
0.8387200832,
-0.308991909,
-0.0619340949,
0.4317547381,
0.2363122106,
-0.3786557317,
-1.1056851149,
-0.4777464569,
-0.0111075062,
-0.490599364,
-0.2384499162,
-0.6076737046,
-0.229524076,
-0.4704411924,
-0.0234093145,
-0.0947541818,
-0.0801659375,
-0.7537657619,
-0.1550362855,
0.3316220045,
1.0749487877,
0.2520768344,
0.4999980927,
-0.8445360661,
0.4597367644,
-0.0099940049,
0.2575465441,
-0.2502143383,
-0.427059412,
-0.1572481841,
-0.0855426118,
-0.2644667327,
-0.6907947659,
0.5878940821,
-0.1101105586,
0.2444612235,
0.3439671397,
-0.2520004809,
0.1348219514,
-0.5826490521,
0.8574236035,
-0.0395759083,
-0.7972217798,
0.5702344179,
-0.8165175915,
0.2973424792,
0.3869087994,
0.221519202,
-0.1285014302,
-0.5686540008,
-0.3925099671,
-0.5899636745,
0.1611709595,
0.3669443727,
0.1411643028,
-0.1269837916,
0.4268596172,
0.0257326141,
0.2068584114,
-0.7385243773,
0.0757403821,
0.0540563948,
-0.4036076963,
-0.1887836307,
-0.3193805516,
0.4573509097,
-0.0821295828,
0.3956518173,
-0.0929193348,
0.1851753145,
0.1989796162,
-0.1642144024,
0.2989266217,
0.2104490548,
0.9564872384,
0.3240255713,
-0.1681059152,
-0.1872266531,
0.0217848886,
-0.7151936889,
0.0775693208,
0.1780798584,
-0.2124577314,
0.15254502,
0.4808182716,
0.6220796704,
-0.1476118267,
-0.5872834921,
0.4917792082,
-0.2420678288,
-0.4266939759,
-0.3308060467,
-0.1160446033,
0.0023214845,
0.2089726776,
0.5758140683,
-0.1644147485,
0.4168089926,
-0.3407196403,
0.387029171,
0.667958498,
-0.6484213471,
-0.2051849812,
0.6052321196,
0.1898135096,
-0.3619228005,
0.6554356217,
-0.140252471,
-0.9180991054,
0.8414131403,
0.4347211719,
1.2414292097,
0.1013820097,
0.1074068397,
0.0070799086,
0.4262836277,
-0.0600971356,
0.3176151216,
0.1024388447,
-0.8895751238,
-0.6165474057,
-0.4766631722,
-0.2915773988,
0.6086077094,
-0.3991009891,
0.2721047997,
-0.4132552743,
-0.2882097363,
0.1464673132,
0.073283948,
-0.7150946856,
0.2614982724,
0.5677306056,
0.7540136576,
-0.8840250969,
0.8545653224,
0.3112826943,
-0.3762249947,
-0.5377673507,
0.3165119588,
0.1076594219,
-0.8350533247,
0.7744787335,
0.6250200272,
-0.2212655842,
0.1061825752,
-0.6368284225,
-0.2301188409,
0.8897545338,
0.1965011507,
-0.5236266851,
0.069690533,
0.3277874887,
0.5816589594,
-0.4394337237,
0.1197325215,
0.6359221935,
0.4008274972,
-0.115450345,
-0.6725148559,
-0.067414932,
-0.0535400882,
0.0004073628,
0.2001144141,
-0.428599894,
0.7451996803,
0.0354026631,
-0.1805233657,
0.3528766632,
0.8327759504,
0.2567805052,
0.1913256496,
0.3429255188,
0.6529451609,
0.7061020732,
-0.0881510973,
1.0715140104,
0.0004347577,
0.324670434,
0.9644972086,
-0.468598485,
0.5482602715,
0.2070079297,
-0.0512601249,
0.4078372717,
0.7162951231,
-0.3292610645,
0.3479309976,
0.4072216749,
-0.4256675839,
-0.2348907292,
-0.1689245999,
-0.3059777021,
0.3923795223,
0.4899842441,
-0.599531889,
-0.0259343386,
0.0015572613,
-0.0004407513,
0.0828401893,
-0.3553804159,
0.8634150624,
0.091428794,
-0.477399528,
0.3848406076,
-0.0843622461,
0.8469200134,
-0.1305545717,
0.0009879522,
-0.0723708048,
0.4152278602,
0.0248572789,
-1.1236562729,
0.0838423967,
0.2403395325,
-0.1233339831,
-0.2686662674,
1.1369110346,
-0.1452405453,
-0.6230711341,
0.1567136347,
0.4980083108,
0.1313436329,
-0.3985157907,
-0.5879550576,
0.3011452556,
0.0522785969,
-0.2738574445,
0.1356111169,
0.6256606579,
0.2767564356,
0.5335079432,
0.6489626765,
-0.1523686051,
-0.1161446869,
0.3822710812,
0.7422327399,
-0.7280478477,
-0.2239720225,
-1.3476885557,
0.3318884671,
-0.253319025,
-0.272262156,
0.7455117702,
0.8704423904,
0.6891927719,
-0.2113946974,
1.0781493187,
0.3346465528,
0.442509681,
-0.6157559752,
0.7354407907,
-0.3199393451,
0.3780501187,
-0.3254936635,
-0.7545133829,
-0.6603828073,
0.5241060257,
-0.185858652,
0.0169193,
0.6559279561,
0.4673220515,
0.1111543849,
0.1784354597,
0.2562744915,
-0.083044,
0.6313850284,
0.6356192231,
1.1596227884,
-0.5155981183,
0.6641511917,
0.2110708505,
0.0611509532,
-0.2026860565,
-1.1239703894,
-1.3518390656,
-0.4699712396,
-0.2209332287,
-0.4274885058,
0.0659165308,
0.4012673199,
0.4952304959,
-0.7067139149,
0.0370637551,
-0.4701645672,
0.1367129833,
0.181632489,
-0.2336210608,
0.2439659238,
-0.2034823149,
-0.6969120502,
0.5434761047,
0.2600908577,
0.2774147689,
-0.271979332,
0.0731732547,
-0.1322926581,
-0.1041410565,
0.7241012454,
0.0670953393,
-0.6865914464,
-0.5250019431,
0.1636459976,
-0.4134915173,
0.0873607695,
0.9614799619,
-0.7767269611,
-0.0579771698,
0.6443541646,
0.8931104541,
0.6046296358,
-0.2572310567,
0.6578181982,
-0.7294585705,
-0.0109335352,
0.4606280923,
0.3031870723,
0.5484316945,
-0.5286505818,
0.5038193464,
0.3463024497,
-0.7392781377,
-0.8479326367,
0.3379430473,
-0.7956746817,
-0.4277349114,
1.2125397921,
0.0661239624,
0.0042139562,
-0.0660222396,
-0.1690904945,
0.2812819183,
-0.435618937,
0.4836918712,
0.7298547626,
-0.0115076294,
-0.2326517999,
-0.6627396345,
0.549605906,
0.1587879956,
-0.8221872449,
0.0732029602,
0.4354881942,
0.1265121996,
-0.0333008952,
0.5936414003,
0.1623288244,
0.0559000447,
-0.2497794926,
-0.2074356973,
-0.0258915294,
-0.3065318167,
-0.4358198941,
0.063605696,
-0.068790935,
-0.1236613244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15402v1
|
Learning Section Weights for Multi-Label Document Classification
| 2023-11-26T19:56:19 | 2023-11-26T19:56:19 |
Maziar Moradi Fard, Paula Sorrolla Bayod, Kiomars Motarjem, Mohammad Alian Nejadi, Saber Akhondi, Camilo Thorne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-label document classification is a traditional task in NLP. Compared to
single-label classification, each document can be assigned multiple classes.
This problem is crucially important in various domains, such as tagging
scientific articles. Documents are often structured into several sections such
as abstract and title. Current approaches treat different sections equally for
multi-label classification. We argue that this is not a realistic assumption,
leading to sub-optimal results. Instead, we propose a new method called
Learning Section Weights (LSW), leveraging the contribution of each distinct
section for multi-label classification. Via multiple feed-forward layers, LSW
learns to assign weights to each section of, and incorporate the weights in the
prediction. We demonstrate our approach on scientific articles. Experimental
results on public (arXiv) and private (Elsevier) datasets confirm the
superiority of LSW, compared to state-of-the-art multi-label document
classification methods. In particular, LSW achieves a 1.3% improvement in terms
of macro averaged F1-score while it achieves 1.3% in terms of macro averaged
recall on the publicly available arXiv dataset.
|
[
-0.3987912238,
-0.1675614417,
0.4172363281,
0.3216640949,
-0.2529757619,
0.2086506784,
0.0596542843,
-0.6410864592,
0.2759738564,
0.2873439491,
-0.1781816632,
-0.6946017742,
-0.7553201318,
0.4689537585,
-0.3968096673,
1.3386803865,
-0.0457408875,
0.2176934034,
-0.4260617793,
-0.3835925758,
-0.0324652642,
-0.518430233,
-0.5230552554,
-0.5375996232,
1.1247066259,
0.0451393835,
0.009953972,
0.6936702728,
0.4050175846,
0.3867551088,
-0.1019758582,
0.4601586163,
0.0388207324,
-0.122051686,
-0.0642220378,
-0.5176745653,
-0.3265473843,
0.1832290739,
0.5581285954,
0.5497562289,
-0.0021343585,
-0.0689320713,
0.1009102464,
0.7401410937,
-0.5312488675,
0.4613705575,
-0.5093945265,
0.253987819,
-0.238391459,
-0.3821798563,
-0.8105056882,
-0.3207730353,
0.0122398809,
-0.6042770743,
0.3738997877,
0.3204951882,
0.6543686986,
-0.063471593,
-0.6065906286,
-0.2472234815,
-0.24556458,
0.9314149618,
-0.3490866125,
0.4771637619,
0.3862085044,
-0.1650404036,
0.2568847835,
-0.874122858,
-0.1873545647,
0.0304432455,
-0.0580655523,
0.1721570492,
-0.0396414101,
0.0307613518,
0.1248747706,
0.0744263753,
-0.4256480932,
0.2859900594,
-0.8271057606,
-0.2178016901,
0.6041748524,
-0.3409186602,
0.0180007853,
0.0471340306,
-0.6808317304,
-0.3386788666,
-0.267215997,
-0.0066448175,
0.2056943476,
0.5024245977,
0.1388806105,
0.2714463472,
-0.0177447777,
0.7481912374,
0.1554770172,
-0.5871890783,
0.6521100998,
-0.1737954766,
-0.0958181545,
0.4474365413,
0.6761514544,
0.0934223384,
-0.1158787236,
-0.057625398,
-0.0240816902,
-0.4655463099,
0.6055496335,
-0.6464822292,
-0.2707009912,
0.1246339604,
-0.2839348912,
-0.3378957808,
0.2524373531,
-0.5816706419,
-0.7597742677,
-0.3114749789,
0.3984233439,
-0.410241425,
0.2138527632,
-0.0175277162,
-0.3246599734,
0.0303477123,
0.8512484431,
-0.5851653814,
0.1655197442,
0.4623219371,
0.9243634939,
-0.1645122468,
-0.6604983211,
-0.4946044087,
0.1188538596,
-0.1830628663,
1.1362669468,
-0.3959160745,
-0.1688089222,
-0.2114934921,
-0.0520936511,
-0.0841964185,
-0.2355943769,
0.5755268335,
-0.6400301456,
0.2010283619,
-0.1580836922,
-0.5293312073,
-0.253318429,
0.3407655954,
-0.775401175,
0.7394406199,
0.0849163532,
-1.0882343054,
0.3991831541,
-0.2607861161,
-0.5799889565,
-0.0968238041,
-0.0534981675,
-0.7716857195,
0.167394802,
0.2915643454,
0.6184751391,
-0.021661777,
0.0602067634,
-0.3967514634,
0.1186300889,
0.3807299733,
-0.0573944747,
0.3329325914,
0.0868155658,
0.2628646195,
0.1220669597,
-0.6773340702,
0.1443739086,
-0.3425475657,
-0.8068961501,
-0.7462391257,
-0.1159158275,
-0.1863950789,
0.1675089151,
-0.1383073479,
-0.6618089676,
0.2870633602,
-0.1445405483,
0.0230359286,
0.6671279073,
-0.0635788217,
0.6623139381,
-0.4227355719,
0.1793243587,
0.0314222313,
-0.1110704169,
-0.0957313925,
-0.4320452511,
-0.4293925464,
-0.4640459418,
0.7657108903,
0.2482737303,
-0.7339140773,
0.5839044452,
0.0369265825,
-0.7744469643,
-0.3664406538,
0.1922712177,
0.5418874025,
0.6718207002,
0.853628099,
-0.5025699139,
-0.3284035325,
-0.6914221644,
-0.1435925812,
-0.1198029071,
-0.0145371584,
-0.0393739417,
0.594575882,
0.1843418628,
0.6157012582,
-0.7117617726,
-0.7266649604,
-0.0906279385,
0.7339945436,
-0.2307493836,
0.4488402605,
0.3699935377,
-0.9493118525,
-0.5060529113,
0.0851704776,
-0.6500642896,
-0.2254211009,
-0.2544938624,
0.0133373756,
0.1897787005,
0.4383423626,
-0.2276777178,
0.1067231297,
0.3877044916,
0.0453220271,
0.746065557,
-0.2458450794,
-0.1917198002,
-0.8491842747,
-0.309183985,
0.7151486278,
-0.1206388175,
-0.5675051212,
0.0491739623,
0.5104365349,
0.1098175049,
-0.695948422,
0.5928673148,
-0.5697270036,
-0.003261097,
-0.4138899446,
-0.0541246235,
0.5787699223,
0.5215702653,
0.3114563227,
0.3500095904,
0.3086194694,
-0.5845264196,
0.1692779064,
0.0839582086,
-0.4948447347,
0.4783385992,
-0.25035429,
0.0751327872,
-0.6093944311,
0.9675679803,
-0.5567369461,
0.0806640312,
-0.0161331072,
-0.3085496426,
0.6376338601,
0.1350284219,
-0.216991663,
-0.3534404635,
-0.5463348627,
0.1183405146,
-0.1907507926,
-0.3684218824,
0.644397974,
0.358305335,
-0.1329138875,
-0.9296666384,
-0.6340500116,
-0.4109940827,
-0.1873503476,
0.1152586266,
0.6396161914,
0.117713429,
0.2611604929,
0.1213207319,
-0.6302195191,
-0.2681453228,
-0.0724638104,
0.1331297159,
-0.1181932166,
0.1132156625,
0.4295291007,
0.2839789391,
0.0042388025,
-0.1663156748,
-0.6143298745,
0.4366355836,
-0.2652899325,
-0.2165575922,
-0.233714208,
0.3286022544,
0.3598816097,
-0.4770230651,
0.8126642108,
0.9210389853,
-0.3589478135,
-0.4555186927,
-0.3765452206,
0.1203097776,
-0.3950621486,
0.6342601776,
-0.3405278325,
-0.4489083588,
0.1729049385,
-0.15095222,
0.2281164825,
0.5726447105,
0.2414370626,
-0.4156091809,
0.7653691173,
0.7572219968,
-0.2076794058,
0.4448447526,
-0.3383782804,
-0.1242920607,
-0.9212800264,
-0.7558889389,
-1.1339440346,
-0.4153085649,
-0.2496250868,
-0.6082144976,
0.5733435154,
0.3560324013,
-0.1158728376,
0.3624865413,
-0.6451429725,
0.6241341233,
0.6428926587,
0.5073146224,
0.3735721409,
0.2321212143,
-0.0873812586,
0.0673075467,
-0.7019646168,
-0.1520012915,
0.8330414891,
0.3769541681,
0.9841422439,
-0.1894297153,
1.1216032505,
0.4687523246,
0.6394236684,
-0.9070370197,
0.2140025496,
-0.4341639578,
-0.3825860023,
-0.2565911412,
-0.4012847543,
-0.9282526374,
0.6403213143,
-0.3970946074,
-0.613786757,
0.2751301825,
-0.206688121,
-0.2902697325,
0.3418466747,
-0.6370866895,
0.4404098392,
-0.5884124637,
-0.0037402636,
-0.047914803,
-0.5991514921,
0.199371025,
-0.5378638506,
0.4027932882,
-0.0700829178,
-0.11210908,
1.0623744726,
-0.0677845627,
1.040941,
-0.067395933,
-0.0444990769,
0.2991594076,
-0.5021505356,
0.2118840963,
0.0987383276,
-0.2965964079,
0.0759992972,
0.0888384804,
-0.3303154111,
-0.4678193629,
0.4180611074,
-0.9738340378,
-0.1332248002,
-0.8356281519,
-0.2852319181,
-0.1154570505,
0.5411646366,
0.1607171148,
0.5838678479,
0.2079238892,
0.3412356079,
0.8174996376,
-0.3714120984,
0.2438108325,
0.6591277122,
-0.0661458597,
-0.5368144512,
1.0076200962,
0.2675240934,
-0.114123106,
0.9310993552,
0.4051730633,
-0.4042109847,
-0.6079223156,
-0.2141051739,
0.1873833835,
-0.8001568913,
-0.888751924,
-0.9878070354,
-0.3394913375,
-0.4035439789,
-0.2384636253,
-0.2265434116,
-0.2665064037,
-0.3487991095,
-0.2187101692,
-0.0232234448,
0.5588164926,
0.0641835183,
0.2992067635,
-1.0874273777,
0.3046700954,
0.2288257778,
0.2960852981,
0.1425145119,
-0.1638769656,
-0.4000438452,
-0.2620013654,
-0.7220566869,
-0.9934877157,
0.3366756141,
0.5836309195,
0.7505238056,
0.3572281599,
0.3649918139,
0.3805402815,
-0.44326967,
0.3221591413,
0.5772282481,
-0.6198381186,
0.2717289031,
0.1575061828,
0.3601651192,
0.6720429659,
0.9467471838,
-0.4434357882,
-0.4060722888,
-0.4185827076,
-0.9616649151,
0.7726429105,
-0.3526549041,
-0.0116172321,
0.1741007864,
0.1342438012,
0.5926443338,
0.4432050586,
-1.0548686981,
-0.026033612,
-0.0676233992,
-0.2309756279,
0.0933471024,
0.1338487566,
-0.0986700282,
-0.3641203046,
0.7510057092,
-0.4663632512,
0.298594892,
0.3407212496,
-0.1240754351,
0.117336154,
0.3452576995,
0.5008749962,
0.6378816366,
-0.2184917331,
0.4918544888,
0.1156224012,
-0.3152019382,
0.0443816744,
0.2498207092,
-0.079071559,
-0.1754496992,
0.6562289,
0.7766796947,
0.091431126,
-0.0851177648,
0.1993846297,
-0.0042894315,
-0.6200188994,
0.0748786852,
-0.150508076,
-0.1018234417,
0.2866946161,
0.57894063,
0.4461634755,
-0.0137860458,
-0.4684337676,
0.4259437025,
0.207693398,
-0.4008318782,
-0.1068950817,
0.3028437495,
0.2551201582,
0.1126194224,
0.4263578355,
-0.1754839122,
-0.7176189423,
0.5979962349,
0.5670003295,
0.6845180988,
-0.0870728344,
0.5947861671,
0.2871187329,
0.1691519767,
-0.4639014006,
-0.2229568213,
-0.0932513773,
-0.776889503,
-0.3929020464,
-1.31962502,
-0.5541705489,
0.1190845296,
-0.5240926743,
0.1846387982,
-0.3304081261,
-0.1610490084,
0.6307301521,
0.3070862293,
-0.465926379,
0.2865445614,
0.4125700593,
1.0413222313,
-1.0118433237,
1.1175562143,
0.9446642995,
-0.4266638458,
-0.6384744644,
-0.0903024822,
-0.0294454712,
-0.3697004318,
0.5466921329,
0.5032793283,
-0.1074846983,
-0.171901539,
-0.4076362252,
-0.8718129396,
0.8062691689,
-0.2174497247,
-0.233012259,
-0.3332805932,
-0.3025114536,
0.5245431066,
-0.4291546941,
0.1570523381,
-0.0697852299,
0.6051550508,
-0.1221286952,
-0.7523622513,
-0.2667688131,
-0.1027803645,
-0.2266104221,
0.239395991,
-0.7169838548,
0.7825539112,
-0.1312527359,
0.1036270037,
-0.3184843957,
0.9617607594,
0.3376900256,
0.8373457193,
0.5576187968,
0.3487387002,
1.0399314165,
-0.1347577572,
0.9001262784,
0.0710442662,
0.3404445946,
0.8853863478,
-0.3146851659,
0.6268846393,
0.1822813302,
-0.3378792703,
0.5198604465,
0.5823218226,
-0.2992073596,
0.6204662323,
0.3527988791,
-0.0360210761,
0.0794420019,
-0.0806850791,
-0.3811761737,
0.6017063856,
0.4318491518,
-0.2944910228,
-0.3345308006,
0.3153915107,
0.0784684643,
0.0175648443,
-0.4876284301,
0.8268733621,
0.3132545948,
-0.599057436,
0.2714520097,
0.5212810636,
0.8765265942,
-0.8425067663,
0.1900301129,
-0.0591364875,
0.2947396338,
-0.4654231369,
-0.6645504236,
0.2642176449,
-0.156905964,
-0.3481709361,
-0.5037129521,
0.9800864458,
-0.609734118,
-0.6412189603,
0.2518147528,
0.4354698956,
0.0086936457,
-0.1318624169,
-0.7468541265,
-0.2312711328,
-0.0615886003,
-0.4073233902,
0.6860481501,
0.30641675,
-0.2691903412,
0.5138691068,
0.4172303081,
0.1039998904,
0.1089835465,
-0.0965087786,
0.7299650908,
-0.4580565691,
-0.5182612538,
-0.5070974231,
0.157611832,
-0.2479459792,
-0.2081736773,
0.6264338493,
0.647785902,
1.1826376915,
-0.1780177653,
0.7878264189,
-0.142349869,
0.2891162336,
-0.6510769725,
0.6087066531,
-0.8413162827,
-0.1632118672,
-0.2964836359,
-0.8434537649,
-0.6323693991,
0.4493906498,
-0.0112174442,
0.0623663329,
1.1093703508,
0.2229185253,
0.0277069137,
0.1063344106,
-0.0980504677,
-0.1932988763,
0.0786480159,
0.3852284551,
0.4712184966,
-0.2073572576,
0.5283690691,
-0.695509553,
-0.223454833,
0.0763576478,
-0.8683056235,
-0.7461875081,
-0.7278880477,
-0.5823887587,
-0.2723996043,
-0.0535100959,
0.8020240664,
0.8335707188,
-0.7500187755,
0.0334852524,
0.3952396512,
0.3201385438,
-0.6750432849,
-0.1425765008,
0.5625962019,
-0.3736900687,
-0.8567124009,
0.326633513,
0.1003442928,
-0.1480265707,
0.0714576691,
0.0905582532,
-0.4990592897,
-0.225979656,
0.7662702799,
0.4359687865,
-0.3717575371,
0.0008757153,
-0.3461241722,
-0.2926044762,
0.1089612022,
0.8165277243,
-0.7193725109,
0.1544095427,
0.6732959151,
0.6727112532,
0.7560943365,
0.3661707938,
0.0622299239,
-1.3934063911,
-0.0731745958,
0.2058438361,
0.2661485672,
0.1972902268,
-0.0537066162,
0.4099408984,
0.0849434957,
-0.4523442984,
-0.6569409966,
-0.0374993049,
-1.0809611082,
-0.6880069971,
0.8054182529,
-0.3438012898,
-0.3188179135,
0.0176461842,
-0.0912417397,
0.4960055053,
-0.556904614,
0.7832403779,
0.4895189106,
-0.3632746339,
-0.3274876773,
-0.3350341618,
0.2813894153,
0.0162647814,
-0.9178166389,
-0.3041495085,
0.4368277788,
0.0955714956,
0.7591298819,
0.6420627236,
-0.0887552127,
-0.2230810076,
-0.1887161136,
0.2169139832,
-0.3631509542,
-0.8776777983,
-0.1019466296,
0.7287718058,
-0.1281150877,
-0.1044467092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03721v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03721v2
|
Exploring the Robustness of Model-Graded Evaluations and Automated Interpretability
| 2023-11-26T17:11:55 | 2023-12-08T11:16:39 |
Simon Lermen, Ondřej Kvapil
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There has been increasing interest in evaluations of language models for a
variety of risks and characteristics. Evaluations relying on natural language
understanding for grading can often be performed at scale by using other
language models. We test the robustness of these model-graded evaluations to
injections on different datasets including a new Deception Eval. These
injections resemble direct communication between the testee and the evaluator
to change their grading. We extrapolate that future, more intelligent models
might manipulate or cooperate with their evaluation model. We find significant
susceptibility to these injections in state-of-the-art commercial models on all
examined evaluations. Furthermore, similar injections can be used on automated
interpretability frameworks to produce misleading model-written explanations.
The results inspire future work and should caution against unqualified trust in
evaluations and automated interpretability.
|
[
0.181273669,
-0.7550187707,
0.7199422121,
0.1515603662,
0.2670562863,
0.0262863915,
-0.0846088007,
-0.8083176017,
-0.4512954354,
0.4563066661,
-0.1034048125,
-0.37689206,
-0.7375934124,
-0.0906350315,
-0.7221628428,
1.1789841652,
-0.0037037572,
0.3342940509,
-0.3155967295,
-0.0820069313,
-0.267524451,
-0.497165978,
-0.5631781816,
-0.6344723105,
0.2370280325,
-0.0956934392,
1.2384263277,
0.6491421461,
0.7803604603,
0.3267379403,
-0.0023467478,
-0.4500007033,
-0.1591219306,
-0.1941562444,
-0.4703606367,
-0.7878949046,
-0.8139714599,
0.4632202387,
0.5062097907,
0.8241460919,
-0.3197824657,
0.2043828964,
-0.0681608245,
0.4269842505,
-0.789750576,
0.4251253903,
-0.6214321852,
-0.237494275,
0.1601268947,
0.0283746775,
-1.0267074108,
-0.4332304597,
0.2449090779,
-0.5935046077,
-0.2555032372,
0.1192020327,
1.1275703907,
0.3489524424,
-0.4172618687,
-0.585306108,
-0.70936656,
0.810960114,
-0.7428969741,
0.1740644425,
0.5110368133,
0.9085126519,
0.0624907389,
-0.8138142824,
-0.3122652471,
-0.6972873807,
-0.2651667893,
0.1220179722,
-0.3524976671,
0.2903344631,
0.1518034637,
0.6942526698,
-0.3785316646,
0.5062716007,
0.0165033024,
-0.4547162652,
0.7683839202,
0.0995740741,
0.5601655841,
-0.3802595139,
-0.4884013534,
-0.0857188106,
-0.3989952803,
0.3219742477,
0.714879334,
0.2955130339,
-0.0918358341,
0.5732175708,
-0.278743118,
0.8195552826,
-0.0428626686,
0.065810211,
0.0437381044,
-0.3281714022,
-0.4811511636,
-0.341651082,
0.6541994214,
0.6123877168,
0.6475803852,
-0.064318791,
-0.4948379397,
0.4780797958,
0.4136449695,
-0.4778851271,
-0.3462602794,
0.2770534158,
-0.6844134331,
-1.0405795574,
0.0799533948,
-0.5875364542,
-0.3126663864,
-0.1704399586,
0.8853241801,
-0.3491380811,
-0.1536563486,
0.3843144178,
-0.0688899457,
0.0938925445,
0.2115173936,
-0.7469083071,
0.5078558326,
0.6854410768,
0.397637248,
-0.1113440245,
-0.2490116209,
-0.5809804201,
-0.1623466909,
-0.2197655439,
0.8917016387,
-0.7803686857,
0.0209625699,
0.0259269606,
-0.0510310419,
-0.1258936375,
-0.4889024794,
0.719784677,
-0.4949034154,
0.4226178229,
0.3274137974,
-0.5210081339,
-0.2664058506,
0.2777749002,
-0.6078436971,
0.879016161,
0.455247432,
-0.6308573484,
0.5195108652,
-0.7709758282,
-0.1808649004,
-0.116305694,
0.30328843,
-0.2896731198,
0.1257204115,
0.2197183818,
0.2568180263,
-0.0869240612,
0.4523725808,
-0.4303345084,
-0.4530109167,
0.4736663997,
-0.9243605137,
1.0066792965,
0.2116657495,
-0.0879079327,
0.0444756038,
-0.925363481,
0.1392428875,
-0.2944394052,
-0.1903390586,
-0.5389611721,
-0.3358351588,
0.0851786211,
0.1797616184,
0.2031220496,
-0.1116505563,
0.0428464934,
-0.7060257792,
0.3593393564,
0.8742209077,
0.0042774444,
0.5778473616,
-0.4792375267,
0.8518164158,
-0.096251376,
0.5520197749,
-0.2965091765,
-0.4242061675,
-0.5151054859,
-0.3855468333,
0.5012562275,
0.5450483561,
-0.6559035778,
0.3370899856,
-0.3517617881,
-0.6525329947,
-0.4841328859,
-0.1607992798,
0.5859820843,
0.590074122,
0.2116743922,
-0.3600720465,
0.0036095008,
-1.1637334824,
-0.8731897473,
-0.4906282425,
-0.2267407179,
0.1033778787,
0.5179363489,
-0.1612955034,
0.7561863661,
-0.2461917847,
0.3051608503,
-0.0304820854,
0.444865495,
0.1486702114,
0.6606447697,
0.3900013566,
-0.5106859803,
-0.367108196,
-0.082708016,
-0.505687952,
-0.3486874402,
-0.4766463935,
-0.306789577,
0.0179846883,
-0.0455477536,
-0.3026495874,
0.6503733397,
0.5191631913,
-0.3649440706,
0.6878235936,
-0.2558109462,
0.2143371701,
-0.7094236612,
-0.1110836565,
0.1214425787,
-0.4256781638,
-0.6736642122,
0.3894694448,
0.1467669755,
0.3081489205,
-0.4685760736,
0.5701512694,
-0.1778776795,
-0.0908363014,
0.0537817106,
0.0111192903,
0.4378447831,
0.0608341917,
-0.3502402902,
0.5643258095,
0.8796879053,
-0.5419152379,
0.1660300493,
0.0990487933,
-0.5709068179,
0.9406549931,
-0.5540822744,
-0.0118688475,
0.0557208918,
0.4116708338,
-0.7959879637,
-0.3419389129,
0.1975521892,
-0.5421302319,
0.3013592362,
-0.2176877409,
-0.3286597729,
-0.1122838929,
-0.2963621616,
0.1560617089,
0.4968111217,
-0.5443621278,
0.7142746449,
0.0045982865,
0.1156988069,
-0.6018016338,
-0.9710509777,
-0.0236462913,
-0.4719000161,
-0.6348261833,
-0.1221272796,
0.0109225996,
-0.6621780396,
-0.0536336489,
-0.03859476,
-0.3512588143,
0.5994749665,
0.3126392961,
0.510378778,
-0.041311346,
-0.0271238666,
0.2204167992,
-0.2410363257,
0.3159717619,
-0.0238680691,
0.0611003228,
-0.1727794856,
-0.6522103548,
-0.7171407938,
0.1735663563,
0.8075919151,
-0.0705185607,
0.764123559,
0.4003327489,
-0.6222028136,
-0.0724150836,
-0.3910610974,
-0.2815140784,
-0.4860168695,
0.2057093531,
-0.4287629724,
-0.3998661339,
0.5299993157,
-0.0695145875,
-0.1406567246,
0.5572721362,
0.4888064563,
-0.0354372077,
1.5477882624,
0.6693726182,
0.1844207048,
0.2310297042,
-0.0158066396,
0.2748315036,
-0.5660208464,
-0.0955351219,
-0.6112456322,
0.0277997106,
-0.7390791178,
-0.2906725705,
0.0739322081,
0.0288953502,
-0.0459009297,
0.2184392959,
-0.355233252,
0.5801916718,
0.1739429235,
-0.0726767555,
0.5768848062,
-0.1406045705,
-0.0969399586,
0.0323673077,
-0.2820245624,
-1.1330572367,
1.1888900995,
0.7440185547,
0.817328155,
-0.0856500939,
0.213600114,
0.3754737675,
0.9991798997,
-0.8545607328,
0.2045270503,
-0.052449964,
-0.7400678992,
-0.1062086821,
-0.3987737596,
-0.6667553186,
0.1488454938,
-0.1800118536,
-0.947912097,
0.10468743,
0.1511647552,
-0.4037780762,
-0.0898327008,
-1.1977438927,
0.7490299344,
-0.1604123265,
-0.0958466902,
-0.2627081275,
-0.6746646762,
0.5666597486,
-0.3343118727,
0.534245491,
-0.0035027161,
0.1172923669,
0.2813381851,
-0.2436589897,
0.5948358774,
0.0084239291,
-0.4109766781,
-0.0595411584,
0.3527308702,
0.3707318008,
0.2021923959,
-0.7667432427,
0.1424760222,
0.3423681557,
-0.4845344722,
-1.1424525976,
0.4275656044,
-0.4385434985,
-0.6117526293,
-0.4960236549,
-0.7127891183,
-0.2864636183,
0.0761326477,
0.1052850038,
0.7279748321,
-0.2021263838,
-0.2421586365,
0.1001857817,
-0.454603076,
-0.0126695335,
0.5511549711,
-0.4423380494,
0.0167446285,
0.8736966252,
-0.1769425571,
0.9596911073,
0.1986792386,
0.4430076778,
-0.1762367189,
-0.5792755485,
-0.4287557304,
-0.1703720838,
-0.8529959321,
-0.0270862076,
-0.2769812644,
0.0510870293,
-0.2764095664,
-0.2612909973,
-0.2831008732,
-0.814771831,
0.0479953699,
-0.3710755706,
0.087322861,
1.0479980707,
-0.1274430454,
0.2602411509,
-0.5228380561,
0.0327763073,
0.1461945772,
0.5286242366,
-0.1355203688,
-0.7614096403,
-0.148283571,
0.2850874662,
-0.0621011928,
-0.7539924383,
0.2181354165,
0.0214588139,
0.5009337664,
0.6090094447,
0.1082271487,
0.3756163716,
-0.2075229287,
0.7894280553,
-0.2718043625,
-1.3331567049,
0.4572525322,
-0.2962231636,
0.2225727588,
0.7009629011,
0.2892558575,
-0.193876639,
-0.9616156816,
-0.595774889,
-0.516261518,
0.5751569867,
0.122275494,
0.2465363592,
0.2227351367,
0.4342284203,
0.4590220153,
0.0535067134,
-0.8229071498,
-0.0525855459,
-0.0513460226,
-0.3760202825,
0.0150243631,
-0.2263510525,
-0.2903720737,
-0.0769811496,
0.5197786093,
-0.0625616685,
-0.0261856355,
-0.2275556624,
-0.181528911,
-0.0057244129,
0.3602221906,
0.3542304635,
0.829970777,
-0.1703577042,
0.3150034547,
0.0414623134,
-0.4453961849,
0.0224830993,
0.15260607,
-0.1768605262,
-0.302654624,
0.6617699862,
0.6443054676,
0.1974629611,
-0.7291581035,
0.5674409866,
-0.1990631521,
0.0777170882,
-0.0744402707,
-0.0145127764,
-0.4128849506,
-0.0486787111,
0.0052933199,
0.4397831261,
0.4837683141,
-0.7243950963,
0.1737465411,
0.355478406,
-0.5842013359,
-0.3262343407,
0.5915389657,
-0.1068895757,
-0.3009397388,
0.4456886053,
0.0194118079,
-0.5902321339,
0.6110291481,
0.2402583957,
0.6931013465,
-0.3370172381,
0.5464363098,
0.0815919042,
0.5138449073,
-0.0438315645,
0.1091331095,
0.3123812377,
-0.5668817759,
-0.4730921984,
-0.5161936283,
-0.6809842587,
-0.1742711067,
-1.174074769,
0.2581124306,
-0.1606964618,
-0.0791549906,
0.0607889816,
-0.3528146446,
-0.495369792,
0.3914786279,
-0.1887366325,
1.0122977495,
-1.1530059576,
0.6926836967,
0.6936265826,
-0.4327568114,
-1.0813162327,
0.2414785922,
-0.0670796037,
-0.9347242713,
0.5566487908,
0.39393273,
-0.0502838865,
-0.3257612586,
-0.4594824612,
-0.5260099769,
0.8346215487,
0.4350551963,
0.0013836209,
-0.0688740611,
0.1553015411,
0.9302630424,
-0.2840937078,
0.854772687,
0.7971377969,
0.739266932,
-0.2574152052,
-1.1803332567,
0.0818290338,
-0.1531934142,
-0.1733106971,
-0.2708617151,
-0.291809231,
0.6763923764,
-0.0331122205,
-0.2115894109,
0.1791716516,
0.265011847,
-0.1142054722,
0.4022135735,
0.6725001931,
0.515406251,
0.8928123116,
-0.0310410615,
1.6227508783,
-0.2921950221,
0.4007959366,
1.049869895,
-0.1658386737,
0.7733488679,
0.26504457,
-0.1549209505,
0.8569123149,
0.5587139726,
0.0554310493,
0.3822563887,
0.3692743182,
-0.1114289165,
-0.3384265006,
-0.2740644813,
0.0575158894,
0.7058086395,
0.285151124,
-0.4898391366,
-0.1087528989,
0.0476899222,
-0.0642321557,
0.413851738,
-0.0653501749,
0.3882959485,
0.0336767584,
-0.7227323651,
0.4253134429,
0.08762227,
0.5073792934,
-0.284327507,
-0.0927725881,
-0.0246150214,
0.278251797,
-0.3155492544,
-0.65408957,
0.4698321819,
0.0853573307,
0.1216746494,
-0.5550449491,
0.601523757,
-0.1371673644,
-0.6424164176,
0.107541047,
0.4757598341,
0.2476199418,
-0.0487169847,
-0.7241891026,
-0.1310898662,
-0.2049047053,
-0.2561386228,
0.2750410736,
0.2510612905,
-0.2055205554,
1.1131893396,
0.5352993608,
0.0405821763,
-0.0987809449,
0.2962084711,
0.5601765513,
-0.0374590456,
-0.2690168619,
-0.7464468479,
0.6639498472,
0.1016584113,
-0.0343525931,
0.8926414251,
0.3664349616,
0.6199256182,
0.1251815259,
0.5979118943,
0.318969965,
0.2930238545,
-0.6196107268,
0.9501902461,
-0.3765189648,
0.4184162319,
-0.451595366,
-0.5500243902,
-0.2943323553,
0.7406877279,
-0.4438054264,
0.1499747336,
0.8931148648,
0.7330085635,
0.16872181,
0.1686159223,
0.3650809824,
0.3072376251,
0.338039726,
0.4465239942,
1.0872291327,
-0.4916405976,
0.3975965381,
-0.3802776933,
-0.4494334757,
0.015306389,
-1.11239326,
-0.891415,
-0.3613342941,
-0.5349974036,
-0.5041884184,
-0.0237410963,
0.5409526229,
0.5697076917,
-0.8459802866,
0.140532583,
-0.0717048943,
0.3905757964,
-0.3540315032,
-0.3115929067,
0.1725809425,
-0.0775683969,
-1.0531084538,
0.3334799707,
0.2048458904,
0.1302923709,
-0.7405822277,
0.2659960687,
0.1601507515,
0.4368984103,
0.292217195,
-0.2833293378,
-0.7262410522,
-0.6742597818,
-0.1849313825,
-0.1937971711,
-0.0936948955,
0.5186778307,
-0.7818728685,
0.65297997,
0.3019054532,
0.5403583646,
-0.1588563025,
0.1654293537,
1.0226973295,
-0.2398876995,
-0.0622503161,
0.1876671016,
0.1908921897,
0.4169497192,
-0.6668753624,
0.4321686327,
-0.2100598812,
-0.4906843901,
-1.1886708736,
0.339260608,
-0.8679793477,
0.0672489256,
1.0767745972,
-0.3864730299,
-0.0165969748,
-0.2048799992,
0.0254363418,
0.0140281925,
-0.1736615449,
0.9393344522,
1.2381033897,
-0.0446991511,
0.1323292851,
-0.8438845873,
0.3572301567,
0.6066548228,
-0.9575784206,
-0.0145853693,
0.3656327724,
0.3153916001,
0.0996642038,
0.1389471143,
-0.3270896673,
0.2636251748,
-0.0489491075,
-0.2361809164,
-0.0027982213,
-0.1382248998,
-0.8105848432,
-0.0601912551,
0.2908075452,
0.228359282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15316v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15316v2
|
Sibyl: Sensible Empathetic Dialogue Generation with Visionary Commonsense Knowledge
| 2023-11-26T14:35:23 | 2024-05-30T06:18:20 |
Lanrui Wang, Jiangnan Li, Chenxu Yang, Zheng Lin, Hongyin Tang, Huan Liu, Xiaolei Huang, Yanan Cao, Jingang Wang, Weiping Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been a heightened interest in building chatbots based on
Large Language Models (LLMs) to emulate human-like qualities in dialogues,
including expressing empathy and offering emotional support. Despite having
access to commonsense knowledge to better understand the psychological aspects
and causality of dialogue context, even these powerful LLMs struggle to achieve
the goals of empathy and emotional support. As current approaches do not
adequately anticipate dialogue future, they may mislead language models to
ignore complex dialogue goals of empathy and emotional support, resulting in
unsupportive responses lacking empathy. To address this issue, we present an
innovative framework named Sensible Empathetic Dialogue Generation with
Visionary Commonsense Knowledge (Sibyl). Designed to concentrate on the
imminent dialogue future, this paradigm directs LLMs toward the implicit
requirements of the conversation, aiming to provide more sensible responses.
Experimental results demonstrate that incorporating our paradigm for acquiring
commonsense knowledge into LLMs comprehensively enhances the quality of their
responses.
|
[
-0.3260181546,
-0.9665383101,
0.7794017196,
0.2162629068,
-0.1847655028,
-0.1150622293,
-0.1398931295,
-0.2600176632,
0.3665346205,
0.7141342163,
-0.7088738084,
-0.238888368,
-0.4952572286,
0.0162773039,
0.0517579876,
1.1290854216,
0.5570116639,
0.0663674548,
-0.1743982434,
-0.1258444637,
-0.4313325882,
-0.213079825,
-0.7930939198,
-0.2889558077,
0.5268937349,
0.5673761368,
0.7232097387,
0.1174426973,
0.1221001819,
0.2967505157,
-0.1578125358,
0.2311338335,
-0.4924139678,
0.5056732297,
-0.2509366572,
-0.2560202777,
-0.7921918035,
-0.1622067541,
0.2892693579,
0.5369635224,
-0.2350428849,
0.0557624325,
0.2791805267,
0.4636827409,
-0.4876241386,
0.1615670919,
-0.8712439537,
0.2185452431,
0.3554881811,
-0.4113225639,
-0.3752035797,
-0.3309398592,
0.1587461531,
-0.552665472,
-0.1366805285,
0.1036665142,
0.400075078,
0.3818998933,
-0.3540766239,
-0.3695157766,
-0.4560334384,
0.8922421336,
-0.9969648719,
0.0185854211,
0.3624413908,
0.2147346735,
-0.1408826113,
-0.6929003596,
-0.7642217278,
-0.3597476482,
-0.0821805,
0.3632842898,
-0.1599453092,
0.2764396369,
0.2923004329,
-0.0455466732,
-0.2752069533,
0.0624218248,
-0.4110026062,
-0.074683331,
0.6627644897,
0.5983456969,
0.1126347855,
-0.3828202784,
-0.4212454557,
0.2813756168,
-0.5509766936,
-0.0858005434,
0.2810332179,
0.2995224297,
-0.3188781142,
0.4025280476,
-0.0172723159,
0.5548319221,
0.3107091486,
-0.17763713,
0.0350168459,
-0.0235279184,
-0.1818267703,
0.2236946374,
0.6471908092,
0.7084612846,
0.3828149736,
0.1672127545,
-0.1270638853,
0.1478493661,
0.5404719114,
-0.9896235466,
-0.169408977,
0.6610842943,
-0.3783139586,
-0.523778379,
-0.4994939864,
-0.7014369965,
-0.4741619229,
-0.4666416645,
0.1307792068,
-0.4646350145,
-0.4373109937,
-0.1506699175,
-0.0715811551,
0.2692814767,
0.6196181774,
-0.9456734657,
0.0573030151,
0.7204560041,
0.5483937263,
0.2412380427,
-0.1645316035,
-0.6888581514,
0.21709764,
-0.1798771769,
0.7641505599,
-0.7658085227,
-0.5225568414,
-0.1866503507,
-0.2359327972,
0.0435191169,
-0.1352994293,
0.5027306676,
-0.0401345454,
0.3393936455,
0.0243747812,
-0.4351232648,
0.0081428373,
0.713381052,
-0.3148910105,
0.514179945,
0.0061928993,
-0.7418475151,
0.2098356932,
-0.9757369757,
-0.4196686149,
0.274846673,
-0.2796176672,
-0.0048590037,
0.2040126026,
0.2092722654,
0.9227141738,
-0.4476796389,
0.6643884182,
-0.5669990778,
-0.1022005603,
0.3919017613,
-0.7699317336,
0.4556159377,
0.4722754061,
-0.1735483855,
0.0339258052,
-0.3884066045,
0.1735586524,
0.1058673859,
0.1172427014,
-0.1797431111,
-0.1624162048,
0.0643021837,
0.3276503384,
0.1782069206,
-0.5621934533,
-0.2007389814,
-0.5410718322,
0.5092087984,
1.111528635,
0.0692640319,
0.7124430537,
-0.3158004284,
0.5207372308,
-0.1244101003,
0.5129497051,
-0.2428324372,
-0.5074039102,
-0.4563015699,
-0.2798925936,
-0.4239894748,
0.4524983168,
-0.4243396819,
0.4434089661,
-0.236703977,
-0.5626969337,
-0.4752159715,
0.1067034379,
0.4957810044,
0.6208113432,
0.1532743573,
-0.2909764946,
-0.3664375544,
-0.834723711,
-0.3233748674,
-0.3643898368,
0.1170477569,
0.7130863667,
0.1309193373,
-0.1979714185,
0.8681924343,
-0.4586054385,
-0.0336675607,
-0.5739248395,
-0.1582962275,
0.0882040486,
0.4953448772,
0.1423020214,
-1.0383918285,
-0.4347981215,
-0.2123733759,
-0.788358748,
-0.0926836208,
-0.1734092832,
-0.216917783,
0.2180511653,
0.6056528687,
-0.7065894604,
0.2617015541,
0.6225321293,
-0.327991128,
0.1653251946,
0.0936800763,
0.1935364455,
-1.6017448902,
0.12297187,
-0.1109388322,
-0.0625734627,
-0.8156728148,
-0.4704993069,
-0.1915602535,
-0.196743086,
-0.7685608268,
0.9862108827,
-0.0125378836,
0.1744958758,
-0.0939365327,
0.5064634681,
-0.0311034769,
0.6146685481,
0.1843219995,
0.3706158102,
0.3687164485,
-0.5946214199,
0.3902175128,
0.5142842531,
0.2222424746,
1.2024656534,
-0.7282518744,
0.0148806972,
-0.0643347353,
0.445782125,
-0.7743706703,
-0.4552687109,
0.44519642,
-0.6312760711,
0.2031010389,
-0.2341557592,
-0.2584516406,
-0.397816807,
-0.1385875642,
0.1789242774,
0.670163095,
-0.5649828911,
1.1098457575,
0.4952632189,
-0.6696220636,
-0.4558709562,
-0.604434073,
0.0628033131,
-0.3791261613,
-0.7105025053,
-0.1478080302,
-0.3422674835,
-0.4572597742,
-0.1124635413,
0.1009773687,
0.0131479753,
0.1618341058,
0.3650262654,
0.2673349082,
-0.0261434577,
0.3118706942,
0.3246235549,
-0.3379264474,
0.1630794406,
-0.1747990698,
0.6559868455,
-0.3701471984,
-0.4532832503,
-0.5425361991,
0.3200007677,
0.6474743485,
-0.0093287071,
0.5268984437,
0.5384917855,
-0.1481008679,
-0.2525488138,
-0.6654819846,
-0.666328311,
-0.5365799665,
0.3899767101,
-0.2360339016,
-0.8829427361,
0.202723816,
-0.2639167011,
0.240933001,
0.0528759174,
0.6702109575,
-0.2187325656,
1.0471303463,
0.2624134123,
0.1624638289,
0.4445005953,
0.107817471,
0.3970649242,
-1.1116503477,
-0.1567236185,
-0.0885509774,
-0.2195462883,
-0.3791745603,
-0.1410292834,
0.3061279655,
-0.1106744483,
-0.4095798135,
0.1101376489,
-0.4603851438,
0.4857400358,
0.3667343259,
0.1214303076,
0.0326180048,
-0.1944699138,
0.1166954562,
-0.1085948572,
-0.8551840782,
-0.9101623297,
0.9803969264,
0.1331971735,
0.8119894862,
0.1157710478,
0.7422096133,
0.3191881776,
0.4619861841,
-0.6762905717,
0.8414909244,
0.1787851155,
-0.5329350233,
-0.2778004706,
-0.3468482494,
-1.0079338551,
0.1038045064,
-0.2307712436,
-0.9608460665,
-0.2745242417,
0.5921345949,
-0.4239707589,
0.1897764951,
-0.7170413136,
0.7062135339,
-0.3592118919,
-0.6019214988,
-0.4814266562,
-0.9711341858,
0.3324031234,
0.0067002154,
0.0304934159,
-0.3809658289,
0.1391430795,
0.3517983854,
-0.2846402526,
1.3602885008,
-0.317114383,
-0.2464057058,
0.293993324,
0.2935718596,
0.5454841256,
0.3472648263,
-0.0151860928,
-0.2468832731,
-0.150384903,
-0.4712251425,
-0.719181776,
0.7421001196,
-0.4603246748,
-0.7554305792,
-0.0701823756,
-0.5504441857,
-0.4803189933,
-0.0621490777,
-0.0328197889,
0.4115859866,
-0.4985373318,
0.0616700165,
0.717561245,
-0.3896413147,
0.2142873406,
0.593080759,
-0.0004444818,
-0.3929046392,
0.6256484985,
-0.408944875,
0.6386330128,
0.1751509458,
0.4163923264,
-0.3258773088,
0.1275380105,
-0.367833972,
0.0003895638,
-0.7511541843,
-0.3611133695,
-0.9432347417,
-0.0979520977,
-0.4843711555,
-0.7211984992,
-0.5047345757,
-0.4873229861,
-0.2422199249,
-0.1797868609,
0.6859201789,
0.6752718687,
-0.2152149975,
-0.0382901393,
-1.008084178,
0.1360854954,
0.2824961245,
-0.0303668175,
0.306363076,
-0.5057860613,
0.0122741777,
0.1808084249,
-0.4707385302,
-0.4701236486,
0.5407035947,
0.0962090865,
0.6340857744,
0.5684523582,
0.3688322604,
0.4886468947,
-0.4235314131,
0.9328860641,
0.5107725859,
-0.9080120921,
0.8437878489,
-0.3476316929,
0.1090874374,
0.2906110585,
0.1402776837,
-0.6416309476,
-0.7232685089,
-1.0680990219,
-0.9365753531,
0.5566935539,
0.1615627557,
0.7843456864,
-0.2910551727,
-0.0350329317,
0.2243000716,
0.1848066002,
-0.5257549286,
0.1883563697,
-0.2085489333,
-0.4598367214,
-0.0344497412,
-0.0969234332,
-0.3487633169,
0.1845900267,
0.5818220973,
-0.3808471262,
0.40080446,
0.1150993407,
0.0234019402,
-0.0310455915,
0.4649047256,
0.3985036612,
0.0740975663,
0.0869306102,
-0.1229966953,
0.5975622535,
-0.177933231,
-0.2461313307,
-0.1306111664,
0.1654401422,
-0.5374258757,
0.1502264738,
0.716384232,
0.2908874154,
-0.9566124678,
0.6092381477,
0.0297728293,
0.0595913604,
-0.4096979201,
0.3890708983,
0.32389763,
0.6522756219,
0.0104927439,
0.2798267603,
0.0819011778,
-0.40236938,
0.0909822807,
0.3962261081,
-0.3200035691,
-0.3086675107,
0.5368595123,
0.6633399725,
-0.4557235241,
0.6055232286,
0.0256919861,
-0.6272848845,
0.4585728347,
0.6428468227,
0.912612915,
-0.0921403244,
0.281416744,
0.3823109865,
-0.1400705725,
0.1683152467,
0.319714129,
-0.3780952096,
-0.9783477783,
-0.0325336158,
-0.416572988,
-0.6887398362,
-0.2451283783,
-0.7151436806,
-0.0296162087,
-0.5358141065,
-0.1355023682,
-0.4385713637,
-0.2765232325,
-0.7616490722,
0.1758180708,
0.0868974105,
0.6067669988,
-0.7190104127,
0.6117386818,
0.3602055907,
-0.401348263,
-0.9384129643,
0.1680454314,
0.0697770193,
-1.0096032619,
0.7144249082,
0.261577934,
-0.3790367842,
0.0427270643,
-0.7369906306,
-0.3438096941,
1.243622303,
0.2732240856,
-0.4544305801,
0.1190489456,
0.0794392154,
0.4914865494,
-0.4012639225,
0.4056603611,
0.1894973814,
0.543831408,
0.2561780512,
-0.7422170043,
0.195311442,
-0.5430557728,
-0.0023401054,
0.0209782887,
-0.8810631037,
0.3117623627,
-0.5933293104,
-0.1161122695,
0.4715672135,
0.4197952151,
0.420324564,
0.4379647672,
0.4351835549,
0.3470763564,
0.8356086612,
0.0502811521,
0.998703301,
-0.6351453066,
-0.232787922,
1.1736732721,
-0.4787154794,
0.9070242643,
0.6799173951,
0.3018027544,
0.2431135476,
0.2569616735,
0.1119826362,
0.3568944633,
-0.0894536078,
-0.6424806118,
-0.4681086242,
-0.4738898873,
-0.1395819634,
0.4579379559,
0.7074608803,
-0.4796147645,
0.1084214672,
-0.0057869554,
0.0418660156,
0.1931031793,
-0.2448880374,
0.9813711643,
0.395041436,
-0.7635337114,
0.2691998184,
-0.3922216296,
0.7307018638,
-0.5906375051,
-0.0116372025,
-0.4282412231,
0.1024224162,
-0.0181943849,
-1.0552176237,
0.17052643,
0.146670565,
0.0732785836,
-0.3263410628,
0.8789705634,
-0.3164914846,
-0.20719482,
0.3268660009,
0.6712677479,
0.2514494061,
0.3098863661,
-0.8477904797,
-0.2166927904,
-0.0167149175,
-0.3250133693,
0.1490985304,
0.8223996758,
0.1657021493,
0.9403367043,
0.7680518627,
-0.0961668417,
-0.4218620658,
0.0909715965,
0.9394822121,
-0.6760046482,
-0.4518896043,
-0.7093394995,
0.7846189141,
-0.2685573697,
-0.3734332323,
0.5781315565,
0.0435566828,
0.5033355951,
-0.043756213,
0.8380272388,
-0.1405052543,
0.2638788223,
-0.5845638514,
0.7910635471,
-0.6158718467,
0.2585344911,
-0.5111411214,
-0.7399501801,
-0.2421829104,
0.8429920077,
-0.3452119827,
0.1671595424,
0.3204110563,
1.3068361282,
0.0741932467,
0.4355841279,
0.6613974571,
0.3186802268,
0.2303849012,
0.723665297,
1.279204607,
0.1464251429,
0.4813650846,
0.1645908952,
0.0073286793,
-0.154995665,
-0.9557062984,
-0.9589140415,
-0.4697524905,
-0.0059894701,
-0.5304799676,
0.3187318742,
1.4768137932,
0.5644251704,
-0.5222350359,
0.2496083528,
-0.331551224,
-0.2688699067,
0.271966964,
-0.2807651758,
0.088156797,
-0.4607910812,
-0.7851680517,
0.1796782315,
0.5274201632,
0.0851584971,
-0.189654097,
-0.659266293,
0.4175470173,
0.4565706551,
0.6675482988,
0.2072329521,
-0.7471520901,
-0.1553343832,
-0.1962516904,
-0.1513447911,
-0.0546285324,
0.6091960073,
-0.8322732449,
0.306422621,
0.1118223593,
0.4583977461,
0.0316781513,
-0.1404202133,
0.8834454417,
-0.3732738495,
0.232056275,
0.6599064469,
0.3552570343,
0.4644205868,
-0.4393093586,
0.4587894976,
-0.0635039285,
-0.4760552049,
-0.6344978809,
0.6406369805,
-0.9079817533,
-0.1968466192,
1.4099828005,
-0.1103928536,
-0.0482107811,
-0.0053553702,
-0.6349473,
0.0298364908,
-0.7971273065,
0.7458172441,
0.1661075354,
-0.184932813,
-0.22460334,
-0.1466104686,
0.2666208148,
0.6651895046,
-0.7677993774,
0.2544987202,
0.5471961498,
0.0365848057,
-0.0455707014,
0.7899051309,
-0.0074232221,
0.3145487309,
0.265489161,
-0.1180636734,
0.0696047321,
-0.1722659469,
0.1448462009,
-0.1009746045,
0.1067432985,
0.3219024539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15296v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15296v3
|
UHGEval: Benchmarking the Hallucination of Chinese Large Language Models via Unconstrained Generation
| 2023-11-26T13:42:56 | 2024-05-24T03:29:14 |
Xun Liang, Shichao Song, Simin Niu, Zhiyu Li, Feiyu Xiong, Bo Tang, Yezhaohui Wang, Dawei He, Peng Cheng, Zhonghao Wang, Haiying Deng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as pivotal contributors in
contemporary natural language processing and are increasingly being applied
across a diverse range of industries. However, these large-scale probabilistic
statistical models cannot currently ensure the requisite quality in
professional content generation. These models often produce hallucinated text,
compromising their practical utility in professional contexts. To assess the
authentic reliability of LLMs in text generation, numerous initiatives have
developed benchmark evaluations for hallucination phenomena. Nevertheless,
these benchmarks frequently utilize constrained generation techniques due to
cost and temporal constraints. These techniques encompass the use of directed
hallucination induction and strategies that deliberately alter authentic text
to produce hallucinations. These approaches are not congruent with the
unrestricted text generation demanded by real-world applications. Furthermore,
a well-established Chinese-language dataset dedicated to the evaluation of
hallucinations in text generation is presently lacking. Consequently, we have
developed an Unconstrained Hallucination Generation Evaluation (UHGEval)
benchmark, designed to compile outputs produced with minimal restrictions by
LLMs. Concurrently, we have established a comprehensive benchmark evaluation
framework to aid subsequent researchers in undertaking scalable and
reproducible experiments. We have also executed extensive experiments,
evaluating prominent Chinese language models and the GPT series models to
derive professional performance insights regarding hallucination challenges.
|
[
-0.0850228667,
-0.5713478327,
0.5122911334,
0.2379799485,
-0.3115589619,
-0.109331876,
-0.4487234652,
-0.4714426994,
-0.2356866896,
0.9090169668,
-0.4149691164,
-0.5198585987,
-0.2088902146,
0.2756607831,
-0.2966332436,
0.6889423132,
0.1353165954,
0.1951096505,
-0.1183699816,
-0.1384783834,
-0.556483984,
-0.6409041286,
-0.3854143918,
-0.6203025579,
-0.1303052306,
0.0805147961,
0.7188296914,
0.525554359,
0.4761791825,
0.2761212289,
-0.0218499601,
0.3412147462,
-0.5083804131,
0.2418624461,
-0.0080822399,
0.1407215595,
-0.0897927955,
-0.2187971324,
0.8207149506,
0.8936163187,
-0.4087807238,
-0.0466123968,
0.339584887,
0.5502262115,
-0.5313631296,
0.032728605,
-1.0811208487,
0.1765569746,
-0.2556532919,
-0.2152227759,
-0.4679454565,
-0.4633531868,
-0.1236112192,
-0.3139586151,
0.3290276527,
-0.0944116116,
0.7952935696,
0.2945192456,
-0.1200549155,
-0.251545459,
-0.7257403731,
0.636234045,
-0.7791125178,
0.4019634128,
0.0639802292,
0.3246995509,
-0.4425187111,
-0.9024274349,
-0.4959764779,
-0.5825046301,
0.0367021002,
-0.0129287262,
-0.0395440646,
0.054202415,
0.2135588229,
0.4630608559,
-0.7018475533,
0.2028236687,
-0.0518968962,
-0.280415684,
0.704081893,
0.2514439225,
0.195745036,
-0.5398638248,
-0.2402296811,
-0.2968299985,
-0.6722612977,
-0.2901860178,
0.3697466552,
0.3148362041,
0.3982191384,
0.4904360473,
-0.2615278959,
0.3440839052,
-0.1769128442,
-0.0805714056,
0.1986772716,
-0.1142067164,
-0.3293204606,
0.2105144411,
1.0086753368,
0.2319193333,
0.2386788726,
-0.3983429968,
-0.4252681136,
0.0331378728,
0.4497778714,
-0.8628472686,
-0.4311489165,
0.089849852,
-0.3989927173,
-0.3399519026,
0.1208596155,
-1.0824636221,
-0.658131063,
-0.0105128093,
0.4827224612,
-0.1553810984,
-0.1571706533,
0.2292770147,
0.1615006328,
0.1505376995,
-0.1134554148,
-0.9145864844,
0.2044749111,
0.544107914,
0.6453092694,
-0.5025164485,
-0.4820598066,
-0.5348145366,
0.0567025803,
-0.3978972733,
0.6933602691,
-0.3765987158,
-0.5001706481,
0.3861300051,
-0.0318853632,
0.171010837,
-0.9786669016,
1.0886950493,
-0.2505318522,
-0.1912672967,
-0.2310242951,
-0.3820346296,
0.0256639495,
0.0256146137,
-0.571541667,
1.3647377491,
0.2649179399,
-0.6602579355,
0.3906848133,
-0.1329625845,
-0.4657592177,
0.4533821642,
-0.7493990064,
-0.4517970681,
0.2874508202,
0.0528242514,
0.5430502892,
-0.7069647908,
0.6602214575,
-0.1592657417,
-0.4405559897,
0.1761941016,
-0.6909724474,
0.6034309864,
0.2187669128,
-0.8604538441,
0.1201098636,
-1.0673753023,
-0.0344326645,
0.3470319211,
-0.0383562669,
-0.4561218321,
0.0200179089,
0.2024842948,
-0.0047800494,
-0.0815435275,
-0.3640082181,
0.1459061801,
-0.2002308369,
0.0640504584,
0.8054386377,
-0.0044473438,
-0.1940051168,
-0.0123539595,
0.2133943737,
-0.253292948,
-0.0032242723,
0.1464136541,
-0.1715795249,
-0.6974142194,
-0.0075664208,
0.1625557095,
0.2747353613,
-0.7689122558,
0.7106031179,
-0.2616997659,
-0.4754722416,
-0.4954141974,
0.0635516942,
0.3514566123,
0.5239525437,
0.3168183267,
-0.3868810833,
-0.5369138122,
-0.6189051867,
-0.1102563888,
-0.2446475327,
-0.3255953193,
0.1515807807,
0.3973134756,
-0.4119735658,
0.3607556522,
-0.4073655307,
-0.3268069625,
-0.2345291227,
0.520672977,
0.0586037897,
0.2706118524,
0.1547438651,
-0.3909314871,
-0.1545485407,
-0.0688966513,
-1.1120448112,
-0.4855562449,
-0.5911044478,
-0.1085979789,
0.5029866099,
0.5428019762,
-0.6273297071,
0.4046179652,
0.7213615775,
-0.2167260945,
1.0888549089,
-0.5318428874,
0.3045465052,
-0.8272743821,
0.0629456937,
-0.1580930799,
0.1331561655,
-0.5968799591,
0.2413923591,
-0.0742008314,
0.0435613729,
-0.1692262441,
0.2668319046,
-0.6840658188,
-0.2452250719,
-0.4838466048,
0.4029771388,
-0.3034467995,
0.2366052568,
0.1844677925,
0.7092056274,
0.3215528429,
-0.7259822488,
0.436347574,
0.2240849584,
-0.7979072928,
0.432754457,
-0.8088365197,
0.1169536039,
0.2597908378,
-0.0588951632,
-0.8394629359,
-0.2781126797,
0.053461872,
-0.2094432563,
0.1707781553,
0.4090561271,
-0.8124293685,
-0.4635843635,
-0.2188406289,
0.2997791171,
0.8031294942,
-0.9313232303,
0.3466089666,
0.3101826906,
0.2499798983,
-0.4767543375,
-0.5473507047,
0.2773779035,
-0.1934926361,
-0.6524751782,
0.4594726562,
-0.1914433241,
-0.354231298,
-0.1550869942,
-0.1193206161,
0.322580874,
0.0186736807,
0.1412519366,
0.1524525732,
-0.1288828552,
-0.0067144367,
0.0074852859,
-0.0436943397,
0.3408641517,
-0.2100414634,
0.7294524908,
0.1879699677,
-0.5249741077,
-0.1738757342,
0.1065063477,
0.4536832571,
0.0034283504,
0.6339057088,
0.7625643611,
-0.582567811,
-0.5425871015,
-0.7417274117,
-0.2511182427,
-0.5285429358,
0.5207334161,
-0.4802717268,
-0.7717483044,
0.4120874703,
-0.0192044023,
0.0094088521,
0.5914042592,
0.7553531528,
0.4713773727,
0.9716358185,
0.4018026888,
-0.087455444,
-0.2893463671,
0.2781822681,
0.0586717799,
-0.7087350488,
-0.2616818547,
-0.700504303,
0.3403152525,
-0.8020695448,
-0.2656671703,
0.3319425583,
0.073728703,
-0.1131156012,
0.2264333814,
-0.8299285769,
0.3262179196,
0.3371679485,
-0.1949184835,
0.4968069196,
0.1812782139,
-0.3876768351,
-0.1777590066,
-0.4213877022,
-0.6918736696,
0.9079598188,
0.2024555951,
0.9686499834,
0.018713247,
0.4901943505,
0.4407379329,
0.156645909,
-0.3334165812,
0.8010337353,
-0.1125070825,
-0.3324690461,
-0.5520703197,
-0.6391410828,
-1.0573958158,
0.503731668,
-0.1898183227,
-1.05937922,
-0.1764024943,
-0.1838835925,
-0.3101068437,
0.5089678764,
-0.041287031,
0.79252702,
-0.223492682,
-0.5213446021,
-0.0086175827,
-0.3688945472,
0.5710965395,
-0.346459657,
-0.1580650806,
-0.1029633135,
0.3026042283,
0.6659852266,
-0.3183646202,
0.7213457227,
0.1932903081,
-0.4061430395,
0.3112582266,
0.2152277231,
0.6261314154,
0.2428730279,
-0.2169596255,
0.230583936,
-0.0786047205,
-0.0816975236,
-0.1636244655,
0.9040459991,
-0.7101559639,
-0.6682319045,
-0.5759029388,
-0.4593055844,
-0.3198727369,
0.249311313,
0.6314617395,
0.2702248991,
-0.4994052649,
0.1388540566,
0.7237553,
-0.3145443797,
0.479401052,
0.275013566,
-0.2550044358,
-0.4024336934,
0.7240540385,
0.0694510788,
0.0914024785,
0.0491900481,
0.2433163673,
-0.3737611175,
-0.7659880519,
-0.4618687034,
0.2759542167,
-0.7829387784,
0.071845144,
-0.6784881949,
-0.5380812287,
-0.5674692392,
-0.0663375109,
-0.4735926092,
0.1437906474,
-0.3144020438,
0.0765757784,
-0.0270569362,
0.7533519864,
-0.1591479927,
-0.0533082746,
-0.8651627302,
0.3593663573,
0.3162858784,
0.3193327487,
0.1462497562,
-0.7483443022,
-0.1151936278,
-0.1644696593,
-0.3765200078,
-0.8287594914,
0.4234559834,
-0.1877934039,
0.8756931424,
0.521279037,
0.4040892422,
0.5071981549,
-0.4598026276,
0.9248887897,
0.0499546491,
-0.9649149776,
0.1745995134,
-0.3253784776,
0.2338670194,
0.7246997952,
0.2754538059,
-0.6466476917,
-0.3131907582,
-0.5452868342,
-0.6938514709,
0.287705183,
0.4356716871,
0.1020570844,
-0.0028518445,
0.4240452051,
0.3262558877,
0.2432192862,
-0.7979776859,
-0.1613222659,
0.0351761989,
-0.0281968266,
-0.235046491,
-0.4927737713,
0.0228711013,
-0.1893690228,
0.6941384077,
-0.0526290238,
0.128203243,
0.1310545504,
-0.1126937643,
-0.1715221852,
0.1813539416,
0.5358492136,
0.6667665243,
-0.3149389923,
0.1458288133,
0.2184076756,
-0.5115224719,
0.1015384793,
0.193466261,
-0.4184055328,
0.3807958663,
0.220093742,
0.7772901654,
0.0113572218,
-0.8061425686,
0.2255634516,
0.0546073094,
-0.3884845376,
-0.5939747691,
-0.0681862757,
-0.170704186,
0.1350437254,
0.3312571943,
-0.5707895756,
0.1654025614,
-0.5328170061,
0.4635490477,
0.4198128879,
-0.4513298869,
-0.2383951247,
0.928317368,
0.196444869,
-0.2121481746,
0.8841284513,
-0.3858838677,
-0.4099987149,
0.2865458131,
0.5902711153,
1.3201092482,
-0.2817490399,
0.3798834682,
0.5066532493,
0.5661631227,
-0.4728577733,
0.182727322,
0.190638721,
-0.7096179128,
-0.1549311131,
-0.6076799035,
-0.3731875122,
0.6179067492,
-0.6200634837,
0.1517696679,
-0.0717772618,
-0.0439181514,
-0.3052226901,
-0.0969369709,
-0.2890210748,
0.1979718357,
0.1863029301,
0.527092278,
-0.7171702981,
0.7324889898,
0.3267863095,
-0.3164792359,
-0.5875346661,
0.4731976092,
0.0636960343,
-0.6590928435,
0.3809741139,
0.3775862753,
-0.2931928635,
-0.2353964448,
-0.3420144022,
-0.3183460534,
0.9636510015,
0.0876324177,
-0.5856584311,
0.0480567738,
0.5906742811,
0.7651984692,
-0.2883879542,
0.1767564118,
0.961702764,
0.3948663175,
0.1899755895,
-0.6188454628,
0.4741922319,
-0.0284832753,
0.2120555788,
0.1332960278,
-0.7384611964,
0.6677823067,
-0.1646363884,
-0.3938440979,
0.3593245149,
0.8949068785,
0.5706890225,
0.1102608517,
0.5274346471,
0.4117305279,
0.9194622636,
-0.1822288334,
0.6862572432,
-0.3602034152,
0.2317657173,
1.1284188032,
-0.7494907379,
0.6979162693,
0.3743627965,
0.008139791,
0.2002013326,
0.5835525393,
-0.4219676256,
0.4430182576,
0.6720302105,
-0.3499557972,
-0.3001079857,
-0.3360558152,
-0.600916028,
0.4532388151,
-0.0867601186,
-0.2564626336,
-0.0262301415,
-0.1611206681,
0.115439944,
0.2642577291,
0.0412034504,
0.514230907,
-0.0298074763,
-0.8803073764,
0.8901514411,
0.0348923206,
0.6642796993,
-0.59693259,
0.0207497869,
-0.4180157483,
0.3649001718,
0.0292941257,
-0.4773344696,
0.1251331419,
0.1140213683,
0.3715637624,
0.1456959695,
0.6481500864,
-0.3726451397,
-0.5391407609,
0.4487998784,
0.2697384953,
0.2937501669,
-0.223513186,
-0.4221922457,
0.30285272,
0.0899242982,
-0.429071486,
0.3413689733,
0.621342361,
0.0514892563,
0.5651102066,
0.4121174514,
0.2482354939,
-0.167258352,
0.4779137075,
0.6082459688,
-0.7825341821,
-0.1397285163,
-0.8677278161,
0.3238756955,
-0.1288551092,
-0.4901631474,
0.9122152925,
0.4009792507,
1.0191354752,
-0.0674671233,
0.7992367148,
0.2595396042,
0.0843252987,
-0.7109209895,
0.9179922342,
-0.7708803415,
0.476354301,
-0.6246324778,
-1.0066609383,
-0.2462227643,
0.3470076919,
0.306275934,
0.1657526344,
0.9030610919,
0.7673820853,
0.329887569,
-0.0016916619,
0.7526250482,
0.0122335711,
0.281088531,
0.520488739,
0.8714942336,
-0.3399380445,
0.6902087927,
-0.369884491,
-0.1533965468,
-0.0731424391,
-1.002191782,
-1.1792987585,
-0.6277350783,
-0.3067534566,
-0.558789432,
0.1092050746,
0.837816298,
0.3154223859,
-0.7829283476,
-0.5723837614,
-0.1222447529,
-0.3128063977,
-0.3553921878,
-0.1992980242,
0.6089907885,
-0.3137106299,
-0.600340426,
0.229069069,
0.2137595862,
0.1036138758,
-0.6565297842,
-0.137949869,
0.1544510126,
0.2767265141,
0.6237589717,
0.2189748436,
-0.7629832625,
-0.3270455599,
0.0352495834,
-0.2807179689,
-0.0017937259,
0.815359354,
-0.4028444588,
0.4109598994,
0.4298573434,
0.9608578682,
0.2496721596,
-0.0984584615,
0.3839377761,
-0.471437484,
0.0029163035,
0.0790969208,
0.3352897465,
0.4166289568,
-0.2716730535,
0.7858076692,
0.3826500773,
-0.8311089277,
-1.182107091,
-0.0752985775,
-0.7308652997,
-0.3344360292,
1.4613604546,
0.1333233863,
0.0394916981,
0.0229223967,
-0.0247808993,
0.4296862185,
-0.0910972878,
1.2534074783,
0.7362164259,
-0.0151943807,
-0.0652796105,
-0.6094332337,
0.5861970782,
0.5532096624,
-1.0331968069,
0.5282427669,
0.598983705,
-0.2712885141,
-0.0284232926,
0.5172116756,
-0.1778296977,
-0.0099978549,
0.2926338017,
0.5056983232,
0.1800580919,
-0.4193900526,
-0.3127883971,
0.2121979594,
0.1920248121,
0.0519229621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03720v1
|
Negotiating with LLMS: Prompt Hacks, Skill Gaps, and Reasoning Deficits
| 2023-11-26T08:44:58 | 2023-11-26T08:44:58 |
Johannes Schneider, Steffi Haag, Leona Chandra Kruse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models LLMs like ChatGPT have reached the 100 Mio user barrier
in record time and might increasingly enter all areas of our life leading to a
diverse set of interactions between those Artificial Intelligence models and
humans. While many studies have discussed governance and regulations
deductively from first-order principles, few studies provide an inductive,
data-driven lens based on observing dialogues between humans and LLMs
especially when it comes to non-collaborative, competitive situations that have
the potential to pose a serious threat to people. In this work, we conduct a
user study engaging over 40 individuals across all age groups in price
negotiations with an LLM. We explore how people interact with an LLM,
investigating differences in negotiation outcomes and strategies. Furthermore,
we highlight shortcomings of LLMs with respect to their reasoning capabilities
and, in turn, susceptiveness to prompt hacking, which intends to manipulate the
LLM to make agreements that are against its instructions or beyond any
rationality. We also show that the negotiated prices humans manage to achieve
span a broad range, which points to a literacy gap in effectively interacting
with LLMs.
|
[
-0.5838816166,
-0.5826654434,
0.7650178075,
-0.0324042588,
0.1143654436,
0.3611565232,
0.0889389366,
-0.7674601078,
0.0678917766,
0.6087062955,
-0.6471731067,
-0.3139846921,
-0.5842341185,
-0.0669707805,
0.0463945121,
0.4037402272,
0.2100948542,
0.0026497617,
-0.3407940269,
0.2225600183,
-0.6276598573,
-0.8509715199,
-0.7629668713,
-0.5125646591,
0.3873239458,
0.4378883243,
0.7880250216,
0.2326663584,
0.4026746452,
0.3393117487,
-0.3732280433,
-0.0612547882,
-0.4069650471,
0.3718062639,
-0.231952697,
-0.5683534741,
-0.3028268218,
0.2327020168,
0.0266643893,
0.6606661081,
-0.0177779533,
-0.1259447336,
0.0396591611,
0.6999208927,
-0.31751737,
0.1159469783,
-0.9969756603,
0.0331819169,
-0.3574954271,
-0.0191399418,
-0.3826883733,
-0.0564116053,
0.0731159076,
-0.5407903194,
-0.1145529523,
0.1599318534,
0.932472229,
0.3844483793,
-0.5084289908,
-0.4498224556,
-0.2806789875,
0.4162806571,
-0.6341320872,
0.1578647643,
0.6989525557,
0.176719442,
-0.6409930587,
-0.6880822182,
-0.4833698571,
-0.342433244,
-0.1719440222,
0.1654078215,
-0.5608495474,
0.2237232476,
0.4874586165,
0.0281090122,
-0.4130926728,
0.3738225996,
-0.5801352859,
-0.2235210538,
0.8417084813,
0.5042108893,
0.4230929911,
-0.3847497702,
-0.5967842937,
0.3050759733,
-0.7984741926,
0.2937273979,
0.7449611425,
0.1143217236,
0.0784131661,
0.5817077756,
-0.2102336735,
0.7111874819,
-0.1899161637,
0.1633420587,
-0.2494563013,
-0.2424914241,
-0.2125482112,
-0.244194746,
0.8977547884,
0.5024712682,
0.7388816476,
-0.0090336408,
-0.2402965575,
0.1134137437,
0.2804395556,
-0.3675929606,
-0.235139057,
0.1400381178,
-0.3614182472,
-0.3171949983,
-0.0263158884,
-0.847774744,
-0.6211798787,
-0.1408017725,
0.2889817357,
-0.1180351153,
-0.0078119235,
0.1977424324,
-0.085447669,
0.4759131968,
0.4218323231,
-0.8261696696,
0.6434134245,
0.371942848,
0.7942820191,
0.072702989,
-0.5088151097,
0.0005898931,
-0.0232154708,
-0.4314375222,
0.6767954826,
-0.3019452393,
-1.0132255554,
-0.2936585546,
-0.5210080147,
-0.2097420096,
-0.6475797296,
0.4356811643,
-0.6230782866,
0.2506870627,
-0.194529891,
-0.3675727546,
0.2791371644,
0.5951451063,
-0.5175644755,
0.7164952159,
-0.0875248834,
-0.5119492412,
0.1497755349,
-0.8336119652,
-0.3303092122,
0.3456359208,
-0.285689503,
0.108767271,
-0.0523326211,
0.1290097088,
0.2793490887,
-0.3720401227,
0.1459954083,
-0.0887224898,
-0.3367358148,
0.8189031482,
-0.4885980785,
0.8154070973,
0.3573031425,
-0.0231013484,
0.0964221805,
-0.1100153551,
-0.2118628025,
0.2539320588,
-0.4668209255,
0.0678595603,
0.0634481981,
-0.2797482908,
0.4003405273,
0.3643313646,
-0.1386038214,
0.5835452676,
-0.292319566,
0.924472332,
0.996706605,
0.1439632475,
0.2715657055,
-0.6574548483,
0.6419841647,
-0.1616616547,
0.4194464386,
-0.2160717696,
-0.6436350942,
-0.5686405897,
-0.1463096142,
0.1439680904,
0.595023632,
-0.6772785187,
-0.0554126799,
-0.1358759999,
-0.3162314296,
-0.6045739055,
0.1245575547,
0.1200431287,
0.2946415246,
0.0845250711,
-0.0187452324,
-0.1967737675,
-0.7044069171,
-0.5529649854,
-0.5551857352,
-0.2959084511,
0.5662814379,
0.2085611224,
-0.1661258489,
0.9670149684,
-0.3632372022,
-0.359269917,
-0.2501188815,
0.1852982342,
0.0809747204,
0.3690765202,
0.0914926529,
-0.650069952,
-0.4176475108,
-0.0450650416,
-0.4373891652,
-0.1794358194,
-0.3776600063,
0.0206480715,
0.4345339835,
0.8364940286,
-0.746291101,
0.5146882534,
0.3160080314,
-0.4986081123,
0.5580142736,
-0.2049354166,
0.2863635719,
-0.9675994515,
-0.1537030488,
-0.2031903714,
-0.1637122333,
-0.6891117096,
-0.0684878752,
-0.3230530322,
-0.2786858082,
-0.600530982,
0.6089353561,
-0.6593945622,
0.1547867954,
-0.1477832198,
0.4146832228,
-0.1449385881,
0.2842982709,
-0.0751059279,
1.0908526182,
0.4235934019,
-0.4540118873,
-0.0051404517,
0.3259779513,
-0.4080863297,
0.4266586304,
-0.8069088459,
0.3870238662,
0.2775083184,
0.1287129968,
-0.8559795022,
-0.3853190839,
0.4598419964,
-0.6585066915,
0.1167518571,
-0.379862994,
-0.4762979448,
-0.175533548,
-0.437197417,
0.4266751409,
0.572748065,
-0.1059991047,
0.5729964375,
0.4620676935,
-0.3388240635,
-0.4785975516,
-0.6883091927,
0.7602422237,
-0.3445672393,
-0.8332278132,
0.2753112316,
-0.0757627562,
-0.7173209786,
-0.1995074898,
0.1458422989,
-0.0062777908,
0.3670471013,
0.2875159085,
0.4475537837,
0.1104418561,
-0.138203159,
-0.2259729207,
-0.2985355556,
0.2659185529,
0.1443818808,
0.6363340616,
0.0140277352,
-0.5382503867,
-0.1598422676,
0.2278310359,
0.7693067789,
-0.0383929759,
0.6387863755,
-0.2517475784,
-0.3591557145,
0.1420944631,
-0.6640485525,
-0.0290291831,
-0.5198227167,
0.0067641181,
-0.6000964642,
-0.9481886029,
0.6817705035,
-0.268125087,
-0.1540522724,
0.1582808495,
0.553082943,
-0.2763682306,
0.8197372556,
0.2759220898,
-0.0469622537,
0.2018811256,
0.2512595654,
0.1317147911,
-0.6535269618,
-0.632160902,
-0.3661660254,
-0.4319135249,
-0.6233206987,
-0.4923960865,
0.3579213023,
0.4049693644,
-0.1672788113,
0.0538168177,
-0.2571308315,
0.9932547808,
0.5183525085,
0.1935691237,
0.3824016154,
-0.5433293581,
0.0112257507,
-0.203456074,
-0.6897146702,
-0.6461408734,
0.5930241942,
0.323971957,
0.9446744323,
0.3587274253,
0.4732278883,
0.593249917,
-0.0894617662,
-1.0291336775,
0.7481256723,
0.3865805864,
-0.5766376853,
-0.364277631,
-0.6079498529,
-1.1612896919,
0.0973475873,
-0.2560601532,
-1.0138362646,
0.2044940144,
-0.129979223,
-0.0452555232,
0.2781383693,
-0.6375840306,
0.761921227,
-0.5014974475,
-0.3361007571,
-0.0853004009,
-0.8943225741,
0.4609727263,
0.1312977225,
0.3417572379,
-0.4219780266,
-0.1677822322,
0.6599375606,
-0.0916601345,
1.0819498301,
0.0961719304,
0.0885115713,
0.1691720784,
0.4575008154,
0.466394186,
-0.0401629321,
0.1101035625,
0.31906569,
-0.202538684,
-0.6122316718,
-0.3199998736,
0.4939593077,
-0.7758158445,
-1.0538446903,
-0.7184329033,
-0.734310627,
-0.1771043986,
0.0551476069,
0.3094454408,
-0.1169117689,
-0.3376960456,
-0.3147162497,
0.5983217359,
-0.1102697477,
0.3299349546,
0.3434560597,
-0.2240800709,
-0.3531090617,
0.6013001204,
0.1173387915,
0.5561534762,
-0.0676964223,
0.1870902032,
-0.2167391628,
-0.5511926413,
-0.1247602329,
0.1632429957,
-0.8864702582,
-0.4118145704,
-0.4008576274,
-0.2797528207,
-0.4139229357,
-0.5383368731,
0.0892665088,
-0.3180532753,
-0.3923686445,
-0.0763927922,
0.2898823321,
1.0854332447,
-0.0526153743,
0.2876519263,
-0.6997101903,
0.0630208924,
0.3813241422,
-0.0037558239,
-0.0360580608,
-0.3952952921,
0.0000403049,
-0.2083803862,
-0.4113129079,
-1.1152408123,
0.324683696,
-0.3167111874,
0.7486371398,
0.259852767,
0.2702078521,
0.5683043599,
-0.3831758797,
1.2081997395,
0.2323751152,
-1.4201962948,
0.3868178427,
-0.3155364096,
0.1281245798,
0.3847776651,
0.3646936119,
-0.8513453007,
-0.2524448633,
-0.4881972671,
-1.1125632524,
0.6613776684,
0.133458674,
0.2973380387,
0.0989176407,
0.1733047664,
-0.0207692515,
0.0390284769,
-0.8177282214,
0.0220495164,
0.164890945,
0.1348342896,
0.2843496501,
-0.3703821003,
-0.242759794,
-0.0046254382,
0.3578642905,
-0.0326328203,
-0.092926383,
0.0215825308,
-0.1299755126,
0.0694314167,
0.5303592682,
0.668576479,
0.9260901213,
0.2751573324,
0.2892285585,
0.2937876284,
-0.1154421866,
0.1507565528,
-0.033212252,
0.2495543659,
-0.4931200445,
0.4410349429,
0.544819057,
0.2503254116,
-0.9147020578,
0.5131056905,
-0.1732917428,
-0.5970203876,
-0.0143154133,
0.0804192945,
0.3156935871,
0.6234967709,
0.2146144956,
-0.0795485675,
-0.0448468588,
-0.5230389237,
0.2146509439,
0.6399152875,
-0.2390846759,
-0.0414269976,
0.6734588146,
0.3205358386,
-0.785979867,
0.788908422,
0.0242698528,
-0.7816376686,
0.251866281,
0.0781048685,
0.6867553592,
0.0080610644,
0.3384066224,
-0.3343138695,
0.7344720364,
0.0727712661,
0.1527792215,
-0.1742336601,
-0.7215329409,
-0.2980122864,
0.0621055625,
-1.0323141813,
-0.0344106928,
-0.5427662134,
0.3657722771,
-0.3246645629,
-0.1290849,
-0.2901306152,
0.2319326997,
-0.5373991132,
-0.3891552687,
0.1368089169,
1.0897074938,
-0.5120923519,
0.671564281,
0.3807007074,
-0.5126832724,
-0.3888994455,
0.3203141689,
0.0007589716,
-1.0323779583,
0.5281179547,
0.0689351633,
-0.1130435914,
-0.0901068896,
-0.756939888,
-0.2375873774,
1.1178971529,
0.6829929352,
-0.4940565825,
-0.2120063454,
0.3413220048,
0.2704558074,
-0.0239421148,
0.0610826127,
0.7084997296,
0.5696904659,
0.1620958894,
-0.8635523319,
-0.0262282025,
-0.0401920676,
-0.215715766,
0.3035778403,
-0.7694215178,
0.8691424727,
-0.1674771756,
-0.3280397058,
0.0698360875,
0.1693047583,
0.3061921,
0.6240471601,
0.3314464092,
0.2408613563,
0.724083364,
-0.1267143935,
0.8047121763,
-0.2114286721,
0.1798199415,
0.7289854884,
-0.5170797706,
0.6033224463,
0.6028671265,
-0.3081921935,
0.1924809664,
0.8197652698,
0.2129612118,
0.0725997835,
0.5947313309,
-0.4184305668,
-0.263764739,
-0.1940420717,
-0.1153128743,
0.1714653373,
0.4638930261,
0.147558704,
-0.0771172568,
-0.238460049,
0.3403831422,
0.125040099,
-0.1946637332,
1.0781929493,
0.344132781,
-0.3971739709,
0.2775848806,
-0.1437003613,
0.7244539261,
-0.7447082996,
0.0999503657,
-0.3581580818,
-0.2858934402,
-0.0797885135,
-0.9934871793,
0.0946655348,
0.0347833708,
0.071610868,
-0.4273816347,
0.8121381998,
-0.293859601,
-0.2021692842,
0.410297662,
0.8166061044,
0.4064665437,
0.0058587142,
-0.8412204385,
0.2083939016,
-0.2289590687,
-0.4245885909,
0.5071485043,
0.4865435958,
0.0314871781,
0.7598549724,
0.6553847194,
0.1151697189,
0.0332018025,
-0.2771246731,
0.9686812758,
-0.7604597211,
-0.3077529073,
-1.1485060453,
0.5084886551,
-0.0896779224,
-0.4075697064,
0.6702648401,
0.2123050988,
0.8793128133,
0.3368679285,
0.6215138435,
0.2741103768,
0.0137008093,
-0.8964636326,
0.8075249195,
-0.3551378548,
0.5293214917,
0.1502122283,
-0.4084097445,
-0.1301697791,
0.367990315,
-0.3550345302,
-0.003571328,
0.3812308013,
0.5798318982,
0.1543748379,
-0.0406436138,
0.7760049105,
0.0457144007,
0.4780837893,
0.5367693305,
1.3416363001,
0.0857245252,
0.5660331249,
0.0383308269,
-0.0326286219,
-0.1034682095,
-0.7257817984,
-0.9454903603,
-0.3458289206,
0.0692254901,
-0.3146991134,
0.0532136485,
1.0776975155,
0.2866671085,
-0.2705064118,
-0.6481825113,
-0.0488342084,
0.3837901354,
0.2981018722,
-0.2722446024,
-0.1738590151,
-0.4381199181,
-0.6250149012,
0.5497763753,
0.2340200543,
0.3061226904,
-0.5339275002,
-0.2254938632,
-0.1234943718,
0.659430027,
0.358969897,
0.3003543615,
-0.7798426151,
-0.0409426168,
0.125931114,
-0.0477065928,
0.1511581242,
1.1879132986,
-0.8197239041,
0.3697831035,
0.2895835936,
0.7255074382,
0.3905531466,
-0.1274777353,
0.4534147382,
-0.530710876,
0.0527933314,
0.4069546461,
0.1972513795,
0.278653264,
-0.4616676867,
0.5013431907,
0.2031864971,
-0.8272726536,
-0.9000225663,
0.5169225931,
-0.6351991892,
-0.5773199201,
0.7558472753,
-0.0698597804,
0.1630685925,
-0.2725455761,
-0.373064369,
-0.2704900801,
-0.4939272106,
0.8958768845,
1.0431963205,
-0.5406063795,
-0.0867021754,
-0.5404139757,
0.4310685098,
0.1665841341,
-0.9302382469,
0.2219628692,
0.5602869987,
-0.1403596699,
-0.0683367327,
0.8941268921,
0.2330613732,
0.0103205545,
0.147835806,
-0.1920219362,
-0.1766903549,
-0.4232617021,
-0.3599916697,
0.0330125652,
0.4356100261,
-0.1196104214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15218v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15218v4
|
Real-Time Online Stock Forecasting Utilizing Integrated Quantitative and Qualitative Analysis
| 2023-11-26T07:19:10 | 2024-01-02T15:13:44 |
Sai Akash Bathini, Dagli Cihan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.LG
|
The application of Machine learning to finance has become a familiar
approach, even more so in stock market forecasting. The stock market is highly
volatile, and huge amounts of data are generated every minute globally. The
extraction of effective intelligence from this data is of critical importance.
However, a collaboration of numerical stock data with qualitative text data can
be a challenging task. In this work, we accomplish this by providing an
unprecedented, publicly available dataset with technical and fundamental data
and sentiment that we gathered from news archives, TV news captions, radio
transcripts, tweets, daily financial newspapers, etc. The text data entries
used for sentiment extraction total more than 1.4 Million. The dataset consists
of daily entries from January 2018 to December 2022 for eight companies
representing diverse industrial sectors and the Dow Jones Industrial Average
(DJIA) as a whole. Holistic Fundamental and Technical data is provided training
ready for Model learning and deployment. Most importantly, the data generated
could be used for incremental online learning with real-time data points
retrieved daily since no stagnant data was utilized. All the data was retired
from APIs or self-designed robust information retrieval technologies with
extremely low latency and zero monetary cost. These adaptable technologies
facilitate data extraction for any stock. Moreover, the utilization of
Spearman's rank correlation over real-time data, linking stock returns with
sentiment analysis has produced noteworthy results for the DJIA and the eight
other stocks, achieving accuracy levels surpassing 60%. The dataset is made
available at https://github.com/batking24/Huge-Stock-Dataset.
|
[
-0.1873155832,
-0.7580350637,
0.1212647334,
0.4719882905,
-0.3772546649,
0.7535189986,
-0.019733198,
-0.5322002172,
0.2743617594,
-0.0022220488,
-0.4456262589,
-0.5151947737,
-0.2858628631,
-0.2610810399,
-0.2382421345,
0.980219543,
0.1423353851,
0.4076219797,
-0.156459704,
-0.1133747548,
-0.4192038774,
-0.5107790828,
-0.4566038847,
0.0169211365,
0.1450234205,
0.362391293,
0.5426312685,
0.5924023986,
0.5764161944,
0.1985081434,
0.1427178532,
0.2259456664,
-0.3235703707,
0.3438329697,
0.1992967129,
-0.0467654169,
-0.5619823337,
0.0831757113,
0.5202897787,
0.4299288392,
-0.4514074326,
0.5514352322,
0.014784514,
0.578813374,
-0.6188938618,
0.4912987649,
-0.519849956,
0.5315601826,
-0.1744606197,
-0.1441297829,
-0.1012692079,
-0.7784450054,
0.3439461291,
-0.8779144287,
-0.1835520566,
0.2888048589,
1.1244484186,
0.0421401002,
-0.2380604297,
-0.1878065616,
-0.9642756581,
1.0153099298,
-0.5869860053,
0.1812641472,
0.1593480557,
0.631955862,
0.2958113253,
-0.6805314422,
-0.435390681,
0.0132429376,
0.3534483314,
0.4499608576,
-0.0826008096,
-0.4338300526,
0.0898936018,
0.269354701,
-0.5100643039,
0.0547086559,
-0.574463129,
0.2251397073,
0.66218853,
0.1871557832,
-0.1226149499,
0.0574807413,
-0.3569123149,
-0.2252784818,
-0.4070098698,
0.0971797109,
0.32553792,
0.35108006,
-0.2454966456,
0.4080693126,
-0.1334000677,
0.3351229727,
0.1142300591,
-0.0112461802,
0.3122195303,
-0.1183394864,
-0.2147512287,
0.3638513386,
0.7785767317,
0.3117490411,
0.3050754666,
0.0198883209,
-0.0235147998,
-0.1860868335,
0.4046666026,
-0.6350657344,
-0.2099509239,
0.4428128302,
-0.4238857329,
-0.4583465755,
0.541913867,
-1.1025989056,
-0.3995739222,
-0.500736475,
0.3800808191,
-0.2934812009,
-0.2824074626,
-0.1408381164,
-0.3862018883,
0.2462297678,
0.0605593696,
-0.3886604011,
0.0322463997,
0.8848080635,
0.9173677564,
-0.1171598732,
0.1803396195,
-0.76277107,
0.2907595038,
-0.3810786903,
0.568279922,
-0.5888791084,
-0.3843467236,
-0.0483745821,
-0.4969492555,
0.2501025498,
-0.5980499387,
0.2487502992,
-0.6611549854,
0.2665070593,
0.0129896207,
-0.5001962781,
-0.3432540894,
0.3346514702,
-0.5090235472,
1.0649752617,
0.1334630996,
-0.7486101389,
0.4075559378,
-0.7562754154,
-0.3190975189,
0.1630821824,
-0.2142653614,
-0.9440736175,
-0.2502441108,
0.3612826765,
0.7169740796,
-0.4531005919,
0.4093711674,
-0.7948120832,
-0.3530607522,
0.3960125744,
-0.1249197572,
0.4878778458,
0.3502288759,
-0.411962837,
0.0918847024,
-0.9985226989,
0.0642652586,
0.3792310655,
0.189967975,
-0.3815753162,
0.0325956382,
0.1005051583,
0.2186288685,
0.1338078678,
-0.5754370689,
0.2313895822,
-0.3499341905,
0.3094600439,
0.6654264927,
0.2769045234,
0.3085621595,
-0.2422483414,
0.8471884727,
0.3178242445,
0.4272069335,
0.0457615331,
-0.3169382513,
-0.3068001866,
-0.4158639908,
0.3449065089,
0.8600805998,
-0.412846446,
0.4987867475,
-0.4813987613,
-0.6869944334,
-0.4579590857,
-0.2422332615,
0.1543791145,
0.314979434,
0.2495973557,
-0.1221375167,
-0.639120996,
-0.6065737605,
-0.2885297537,
0.1584104747,
-0.3201602101,
-0.0116732623,
-0.1515450925,
-0.0111531438,
1.0321420431,
-0.9651518464,
-0.1675806493,
-0.0087709604,
0.5288379788,
0.5120097995,
0.1994348317,
0.3227339685,
-0.6376588345,
-0.5679255724,
0.0876972228,
-1.111869216,
0.3473830521,
-0.3072883487,
-0.0127936695,
-0.2036648393,
0.3444755077,
-0.2788296044,
0.2390508056,
0.3443641365,
-0.0875175744,
0.2598992586,
0.08380346,
-0.161611557,
-1.4301087856,
0.1238033548,
0.5282996297,
-0.1011963561,
-0.3017545938,
-0.1973177642,
-0.0528981946,
-0.334603399,
-0.302282095,
0.4836853743,
-0.3655618429,
-0.324321717,
0.1039371267,
0.096738264,
-0.0505220927,
0.3724587858,
-0.2158726603,
0.6902397275,
0.5163926482,
-0.5408488512,
0.3681728244,
0.1429764479,
-0.3391948938,
0.3729499876,
-0.5093812943,
-0.0104122544,
-0.0413619354,
0.1587776691,
-0.7579148412,
-0.0451525152,
0.59022367,
-0.4348898828,
0.1418295801,
0.2094337195,
-0.0408578478,
-0.0680478364,
-0.5852290988,
0.146370247,
0.2401259691,
-0.2223026901,
0.617272377,
0.6624124646,
-0.5827158093,
-0.7263198495,
-0.3138887286,
0.0177309252,
-0.249319464,
-0.1388217658,
0.2101340443,
0.0864139423,
-0.6290513873,
-0.1024212241,
0.1686435044,
-0.2813038528,
0.1860926449,
0.571318686,
0.898385644,
0.0299088005,
0.149397701,
0.1480619758,
-0.2790338695,
0.1068594679,
-0.2796949744,
0.261095345,
0.0251752809,
-0.0517439246,
-0.6229003072,
0.1893841475,
0.4967609346,
0.0024248485,
0.8984637856,
0.7567397952,
-0.4319475889,
-0.1305716783,
-0.1400300115,
-0.0507331453,
-0.465348959,
0.1973905861,
-0.2121913135,
-0.5598939061,
0.2994273901,
0.0577094741,
0.3591875434,
0.6028892398,
0.4891118109,
-0.2668502033,
1.0521466732,
0.2545277476,
-0.1007663906,
0.6693429351,
-0.3674359918,
0.501865983,
-0.2835260928,
-0.4015359879,
-0.2666876912,
-0.2776418328,
-0.5679551363,
0.0678202659,
0.5016791224,
-0.1564221531,
-0.4431922734,
0.038129814,
-0.4956509471,
0.1535152495,
0.6188821793,
0.1089926064,
0.2020309269,
0.2605823576,
-0.1280791759,
-0.2885660827,
-0.3610157967,
-0.3158269823,
1.3437677622,
0.4795374274,
0.5116846561,
-0.463450104,
0.1449127793,
0.6403933167,
0.2572822273,
-0.8032149673,
0.3010754287,
0.0757931098,
-0.3523986936,
0.0339602344,
-0.5361375809,
-0.4669573009,
-0.0861566439,
-0.4965820312,
0.0698147118,
0.2966106832,
-0.0856757686,
-0.7052903175,
0.1792820245,
-0.550858438,
0.5626854897,
-0.265602082,
-0.2314632088,
-0.4547667205,
-0.6930123568,
0.3395809233,
-0.3589003682,
0.3189683557,
-0.2488699257,
-0.0293228552,
0.8355489969,
-0.2175782323,
0.5968030095,
-0.1534049213,
-0.0067121298,
0.0772861391,
-0.1352882832,
0.4459425807,
0.1234334782,
-0.2858747244,
0.4790874422,
0.2129298747,
-0.4295635819,
-0.3868783414,
0.5718718171,
-0.9835327864,
0.1526733637,
-0.7912569642,
-0.2747552693,
-0.4774486423,
-0.2820715308,
-0.014110595,
0.4105421007,
-0.1791037023,
0.2266734391,
0.1788188517,
0.0789095983,
0.5738589168,
0.2304560393,
-0.2030767202,
-0.8983578682,
1.3323225975,
0.4642342627,
-0.1941331476,
0.4016363621,
0.2715348899,
-0.3689717352,
-0.2723549008,
-0.2486295104,
0.1464133114,
-0.4130711555,
-0.2968821228,
-0.676194489,
-0.2418738604,
-0.4195744395,
-0.2031205446,
-0.2419467419,
-0.6042117476,
-0.6569885612,
-0.2363028675,
0.3257392347,
0.8701192737,
0.1825769842,
0.3116492927,
-1.4253463745,
0.4521045983,
0.3529167473,
0.134945482,
0.1758541465,
-0.1522535533,
-0.6425498724,
0.1860761493,
-0.6489858031,
-0.5823571086,
0.7957002521,
0.2545262575,
0.2159028798,
0.682363987,
0.2116170377,
0.7263590693,
0.2310774326,
0.5263897181,
0.0628848821,
-0.5708854795,
0.2568743527,
-0.3951652646,
0.1940048188,
0.1946732551,
0.8582734466,
-0.4697498977,
-0.2115927786,
-0.5077317953,
-0.9298763871,
0.5353051424,
-0.0954747349,
-0.2976235449,
0.2523069382,
0.4711256325,
0.4055974185,
0.5558536649,
-0.3429822922,
-0.0650128201,
-0.4472072124,
-0.6753013134,
0.1329322755,
-0.0426584259,
-0.0390129499,
-0.4510444701,
0.7153411508,
-0.1095670685,
0.219596535,
-0.1681985259,
0.077647537,
-0.057955917,
-0.1409644485,
0.1010614187,
1.0000187159,
-0.4088115394,
-0.3917231858,
0.0774645135,
-0.4759465456,
-0.2222360671,
0.0428779013,
-0.1431967467,
-0.199794665,
0.1210402325,
0.4744258225,
0.1699385941,
-0.8480412364,
0.271150142,
-0.2938706577,
-0.0998530462,
-0.7575890422,
-0.2263278812,
-0.155252099,
0.5188110471,
0.8317424059,
0.0565431304,
0.0140999844,
-0.505515635,
0.1216857284,
0.3510516286,
-0.4543848038,
-0.4024914801,
0.6555490494,
0.005213175,
0.224021256,
0.7139955163,
0.0898949057,
-0.3119205832,
0.4446284771,
0.1862386316,
1.0661261082,
0.0857630894,
0.287633419,
0.4720312059,
-0.3678458333,
-0.0452181175,
0.4585898519,
0.1632747352,
-0.5374774337,
-0.435125649,
-0.8095821738,
-0.8270721436,
-0.0851538852,
-0.7763041258,
0.3389499187,
-0.8888011575,
-0.293967098,
-0.0006785016,
0.1623073071,
-0.1912469119,
0.5406498313,
0.0428565852,
0.445907414,
-0.6513528228,
0.4736563563,
0.5592303872,
-0.2971206307,
-0.5071231127,
0.0922016501,
-0.0725582242,
-0.625284493,
0.3555443883,
0.0799452662,
0.0791150257,
0.1512316614,
-0.6299660206,
-0.4786652327,
0.8671192527,
0.1036685556,
-0.7084479332,
0.0383880995,
-0.0846991837,
0.2456191033,
-0.4220944941,
0.2301255614,
0.2323468029,
0.4535204172,
0.3226032853,
-0.3322389126,
-0.2447634488,
-0.2707723975,
-0.3662695885,
0.2298066318,
-0.4878863096,
0.6801139712,
0.2796275616,
-0.1789338887,
-0.5502940416,
0.9453989863,
0.2691145539,
0.5724959373,
0.1788040847,
0.4939727783,
0.6514412165,
0.0277398024,
0.7112432718,
-0.5062504411,
0.2637458146,
0.8472205997,
-0.440077126,
1.2965085506,
0.1868971437,
-0.3406795263,
0.2933687568,
0.7706021667,
-0.170474112,
0.4015644193,
-0.1974845529,
-0.3538359404,
-0.338345319,
-0.2300052643,
-0.4257282019,
0.4040222168,
0.2487968951,
0.1644202322,
0.2203700691,
-0.0048723598,
0.0301224235,
-0.0096896281,
-0.2256709188,
0.8423432112,
0.1266127378,
-0.2345592827,
0.2308032215,
-0.0428320877,
0.6327704191,
-0.5980218649,
0.0016471737,
-0.0511837676,
0.3366363645,
-0.0106221028,
-0.5242199302,
0.486309886,
-0.0899704099,
0.0768436342,
-0.3169832826,
0.5206626654,
-0.0515309572,
-0.8098332286,
0.1554311514,
0.433888346,
-0.2195001543,
-0.3686432242,
-0.5263977051,
-0.179774344,
-0.1919992417,
-0.1834421754,
0.4466574192,
0.1966719329,
-0.0439425409,
0.8632821441,
1.0031785965,
0.1749490798,
-0.0077069998,
-0.3662777543,
0.8789026737,
-1.0635147095,
-0.6456875205,
-0.6842471361,
0.3283193707,
-0.2969542444,
-0.2691366673,
0.699732542,
0.8536134958,
0.443592906,
-0.0136945238,
0.9535723329,
0.338402003,
0.9201344252,
-0.1572196335,
0.6948244572,
-0.3712791502,
0.0774575174,
0.0230493993,
-0.9515626431,
-0.3704176843,
0.2628142238,
-0.3012267351,
-0.3822648525,
0.5020436645,
0.4254145026,
-0.134912625,
0.5058760643,
0.0428609177,
0.2242133021,
0.2939414084,
-0.2502363324,
0.6506710649,
-0.4999655783,
0.5184039474,
-0.4183247089,
-0.1921043992,
-0.4806793332,
-0.9895179272,
-0.4526956379,
-0.3837082088,
-0.3796053529,
-0.2573037148,
0.0226788353,
1.3402541876,
0.3354429305,
-1.0086569786,
-0.4753231108,
0.3228553534,
-0.0808945373,
-0.51620543,
-0.315414995,
0.2885231078,
-0.0702759176,
-0.4815229177,
0.343832165,
0.5546139479,
0.0007780804,
-0.3551900983,
0.1127132624,
-0.2304299623,
0.130654186,
0.711679399,
0.3163144886,
0.0317031257,
0.0775205866,
0.149078384,
-0.0302919578,
0.200800553,
0.5499770641,
-0.6079024076,
0.2208547294,
0.6356722713,
0.6735954285,
0.4536163509,
0.3660280108,
0.814093411,
-0.5202448368,
0.1061383709,
0.2615871131,
0.0468687527,
0.1168474406,
-0.2918465734,
0.2476403713,
0.5148729086,
-0.4088158309,
-0.5911679268,
-0.5236916542,
-1.0411834717,
-0.25519526,
0.650170505,
-0.0141360462,
-0.3319684863,
-0.2327664047,
-0.1731175482,
0.5734683871,
-0.6674469709,
0.9754486084,
0.3940162361,
0.0804905817,
-0.0541257299,
-0.7033292055,
0.1838468164,
-0.0599849075,
-0.8375428319,
-0.136196509,
0.3697640002,
-0.0832282603,
-0.2399210036,
0.1490903944,
0.1107844859,
-0.0609986298,
-0.0491559692,
0.0500603206,
-0.2082255185,
-0.4179656804,
-0.2919640243,
0.7358723879,
-0.2418936342,
-0.5921291709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15211v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15211v1
|
Probabilistic Transformer: A Probabilistic Dependency Model for Contextual Word Representation
| 2023-11-26T06:56:02 | 2023-11-26T06:56:02 |
Haoyi Wu, Kewei Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Syntactic structures used to play a vital role in natural language processing
(NLP), but since the deep learning revolution, NLP has been gradually dominated
by neural models that do not consider syntactic structures in their design. One
vastly successful class of neural models is transformers. When used as an
encoder, a transformer produces contextual representation of words in the input
sentence. In this work, we propose a new model of contextual word
representation, not from a neural perspective, but from a purely syntactic and
probabilistic perspective. Specifically, we design a conditional random field
that models discrete latent representations of all words in a sentence as well
as dependency arcs between them; and we use mean field variational inference
for approximate inference. Strikingly, we find that the computation graph of
our model resembles transformers, with correspondences between dependencies and
self-attention and between distributions over latent representations and
contextual embeddings of words. Experiments show that our model performs
competitively to transformers on small to medium sized datasets. We hope that
our work could help bridge the gap between traditional syntactic and
probabilistic approaches and cutting-edge neural approaches to NLP, and inspire
more linguistically-principled neural approaches in the future.
|
[
-0.2674279809,
-0.5447236896,
0.6505540609,
0.264192611,
-0.0677152872,
-0.4646557868,
-0.2563590109,
-0.36517331,
0.4507293403,
0.5967960358,
-0.5973026752,
-0.1670245677,
-0.6355618834,
0.0392662436,
-0.5034707785,
0.8344169259,
0.0287347548,
-0.0332955495,
-0.2867921293,
-0.092283912,
-0.6373423934,
-0.4821082056,
-0.1254239082,
-0.501331389,
0.3627617955,
-0.2147686779,
0.9079769254,
0.1984442919,
0.5738703012,
0.4256145358,
-0.0868639201,
-0.4424473047,
-0.0459730625,
0.3221500218,
-0.3654486537,
-0.745042026,
-0.0570040569,
0.1108540446,
0.5648002028,
0.9949784279,
-0.3119014502,
-0.1043048501,
0.0656160563,
0.2889901102,
-0.4794276953,
0.4713751674,
-0.7873257399,
0.2347160727,
-0.0778498426,
-0.1786883175,
-0.603610754,
0.0482096784,
0.3425423205,
-0.3948348165,
0.4890022576,
-0.1305048466,
0.6859480143,
0.2957771122,
-0.3605090678,
-0.0080016367,
-0.9682780504,
0.6624465585,
-0.5420665741,
0.4221613407,
0.2014030516,
0.3359809816,
-0.2854269445,
-1.0415337086,
-0.758368969,
-0.3551091552,
-0.527412951,
0.4342947602,
-0.1561811119,
0.1658203453,
0.0115035074,
0.4366135001,
-0.287378788,
-0.0668005869,
0.1070824638,
-0.0371695235,
0.2476222515,
0.1254133284,
0.1362797916,
-0.3763292432,
-0.426371485,
-0.0748631656,
-0.4555053711,
0.0416997559,
0.1342202276,
0.2813352644,
-0.123068735,
0.5910462737,
-0.0568360798,
0.8080580831,
0.1587047875,
0.1292927861,
0.045925878,
-0.0391951874,
-0.1311231554,
-0.1384515911,
0.9021859765,
0.2610566318,
0.2860390544,
-0.5767680407,
-0.20236817,
0.2310019135,
0.5193667412,
-0.4174873531,
-0.3598538935,
-0.0306579955,
-0.3718712926,
-0.3269810677,
0.1027610824,
-0.6303963065,
-0.3147018552,
-0.2638480067,
0.4422554672,
-0.3691081405,
-0.1395144165,
0.0149186216,
0.0404007845,
0.0045438367,
-0.0494281277,
-1.236099124,
0.369133085,
0.3255672455,
0.6719713211,
0.0035205195,
-0.3263067305,
-0.2779216766,
0.1599737704,
-0.2049108595,
0.9205123186,
-0.6836476326,
-0.1895633787,
0.2465945035,
0.1402328908,
-0.1207700148,
-0.497595489,
0.4854467511,
-0.7256533504,
0.3233637214,
0.0227775909,
-0.6050900817,
-0.2764395177,
0.0259001516,
-1.0425913334,
0.5711052418,
0.5042897463,
-0.9951068163,
0.3789946139,
-0.4472979605,
-0.4451340735,
0.3939129412,
-0.4192046523,
-0.2718262374,
0.3349093199,
0.0031081589,
0.3336136043,
-0.3361480832,
0.5900877714,
-0.1589326113,
-0.1875357926,
0.3524760008,
-0.5645121336,
0.5194879174,
-0.1834487766,
-0.3468475938,
0.1379901022,
-0.7309321165,
-0.3461651504,
0.13565965,
-0.328047663,
-0.2436008602,
0.4465028346,
0.3926047385,
0.3063191175,
0.011712254,
-0.4922426939,
0.1449852586,
-0.8826207519,
0.3832387626,
0.4589444399,
0.0223975349,
0.9542753696,
0.1045591459,
0.506313324,
0.2325388342,
-0.0990911052,
-0.2735204101,
-0.4192968905,
-0.5980209708,
-0.0421981774,
0.4823901057,
0.4310255051,
-0.8108511567,
0.6147817969,
-0.2199788392,
0.0007250554,
-0.389590919,
-0.2325144261,
-0.1074856818,
0.6156407595,
0.5562306046,
-0.1828830391,
-0.7288281322,
-1.0960615873,
-0.2105948776,
-0.0530239791,
-0.3358101845,
0.0307851657,
0.3456093967,
-0.1795092374,
1.4519326687,
-0.540851295,
-0.7228236198,
-0.5934187174,
0.1960663199,
0.5013610721,
0.2507336438,
0.5787562132,
-0.8608868718,
-0.1259533018,
-0.2958798707,
-0.662538588,
-0.1478983611,
-0.3493465781,
0.099752605,
-0.1663384885,
0.4295121133,
-1.1602497101,
0.4667267501,
0.6327065229,
-0.4011928439,
0.5587584376,
-0.2320978492,
-0.296099335,
-1.1388409138,
0.0428509898,
-0.0327171832,
-0.24955073,
-0.693405807,
0.0682193115,
-0.0455670916,
0.0187612865,
-0.4146948159,
0.3776631951,
-0.2447394729,
0.0860069469,
-0.2880015671,
-0.1049900427,
-0.0326022543,
0.5044078827,
0.2463528812,
0.6812244058,
0.4615558684,
-0.3559138477,
0.257784605,
0.3001168072,
-0.3011575937,
0.432266742,
-0.7387234569,
-0.3635889292,
-0.2168619186,
0.6686348319,
-0.6707243323,
-0.1599059999,
0.2989593446,
-0.1935608238,
0.3219445944,
0.0001914873,
-0.5988608003,
-0.3411292136,
0.2169772536,
0.2971596122,
0.4020441175,
-0.5524509549,
0.8724755645,
0.4187051952,
0.0935706124,
-0.422498554,
-0.7693799138,
0.1229675785,
0.0055253911,
-0.5248054862,
0.9579014182,
0.371878624,
-0.180477038,
0.2332849205,
-0.0328311101,
-0.0476845428,
0.0813662186,
0.2818098664,
0.1807760447,
-0.227841258,
0.1821124852,
-0.2987460494,
-0.3494314551,
0.2680023909,
-0.4825337827,
0.7248159647,
0.0427020453,
-0.0752633289,
-0.1894107014,
0.5740314126,
0.1829487234,
-0.2479863316,
0.9442487955,
0.4955924749,
-0.5636392236,
-0.326544404,
-0.2885625064,
-0.3001665771,
-0.4943180084,
0.551532805,
-0.3977044225,
-0.8426695466,
0.538017571,
0.0407726988,
-0.1930240542,
0.811452806,
0.7495840192,
-0.3388302028,
0.8570847511,
0.8797354698,
0.0307522323,
0.5765612721,
-0.2968947291,
0.468131423,
-0.5259152651,
-0.0829714611,
-0.0525628626,
-0.2796001434,
-0.7834590673,
-0.3711158335,
0.0691033378,
0.0723136067,
0.1953526288,
0.4971781969,
-0.3680702746,
0.4406423271,
0.5782646537,
-0.0681432113,
-0.1431807727,
-0.1131817773,
-0.3165965676,
-0.1123239174,
-0.6573869586,
-0.3863496482,
0.5896174908,
0.3134939969,
0.5619912744,
0.0447206125,
0.5487616658,
0.14699471,
0.4182826877,
-0.875113368,
0.4652214944,
-0.3579962552,
-0.4966772199,
-0.1141361222,
-0.257666409,
-1.032792449,
0.2321718633,
-0.3611781895,
-0.9468435645,
0.1980351359,
0.1764489859,
-0.3173213899,
0.3069385588,
-0.4676623642,
0.9229911566,
0.3002640009,
-0.255638063,
0.0346140042,
-0.7164773941,
0.176988855,
0.0783120766,
-0.0916410089,
0.2060784549,
0.3147878349,
0.725022316,
-0.4267301559,
0.9819213748,
-0.2610330284,
0.1212152392,
0.5092577338,
0.0742905363,
0.4465021789,
0.1256897599,
0.2143226117,
0.138795808,
-0.2295810878,
-0.0333974473,
-0.7171885371,
0.457339406,
-0.5272437334,
-0.5599690676,
-0.4183104038,
-0.691436708,
-0.2351477295,
0.2691634595,
0.558703959,
0.3543990254,
-0.2208576947,
0.1593185812,
0.4298133552,
-0.1383767873,
0.6444095373,
0.1858825535,
-0.0396518819,
-0.1750507355,
0.6208081841,
0.305639565,
-0.1524874568,
0.8106865883,
0.084963806,
-0.3030869961,
-0.2406378388,
-0.1839538366,
0.1744829863,
-0.8412092924,
-0.2314353883,
-0.7755773067,
-0.5626471639,
-0.1630569547,
-0.1518211663,
-0.2754705846,
-0.4606352448,
-0.3048260212,
-0.1793063581,
0.1544123292,
0.6549357176,
0.1801228672,
0.6847156286,
-0.486782968,
0.3146217167,
0.3653334379,
0.5761449337,
-0.0776809901,
-0.38134408,
-0.3086921573,
-0.3331207931,
-0.422770083,
-1.1019306183,
0.6261314154,
0.2122997493,
0.5550581813,
0.2774565816,
-0.1524468511,
0.0975646675,
-0.9966959953,
0.7763322592,
0.4588398039,
-0.8240056634,
0.3162960112,
-0.3363780975,
0.454841882,
0.4774329066,
0.146317333,
-0.4685333371,
-0.6662823558,
-0.7667562962,
-1.0109302998,
0.5397012234,
0.2710546255,
0.2187367082,
-0.3562049568,
0.2110109031,
0.0503953993,
0.0626211092,
-0.9192650914,
-0.1597345024,
-0.2807586789,
-0.505515635,
-0.2607536018,
-0.3026890755,
0.1318693161,
0.0907260329,
0.1147492304,
-0.0176341794,
0.7257435322,
0.1180494353,
-0.3464629948,
0.2337040454,
0.1926169097,
0.3403529525,
0.2526587248,
-0.3517795801,
0.6507195234,
0.0484737828,
-0.4515639246,
0.1030861363,
0.2377759516,
-0.2838453948,
0.4717059433,
0.5459909439,
0.6834461689,
0.5591333508,
-0.329849124,
0.6396751404,
0.0131981,
-0.1431992203,
-0.5357300043,
-0.1876002997,
0.4822436273,
0.2203179002,
0.354277581,
0.4944718778,
0.3702327311,
-0.2927103937,
0.5326629877,
0.2449831367,
-0.5136580467,
-0.6478312016,
1.0093047619,
-0.0711918324,
-0.5491324067,
0.3088560104,
-0.179379642,
-0.6783798933,
0.4855268896,
0.8308608532,
1.0138210058,
-0.2105993181,
0.2824529409,
0.153018713,
0.1443986893,
-0.2465178072,
0.0695127398,
0.0229060147,
-0.8172394037,
-0.519615829,
-0.8272761106,
-0.2273681909,
-0.0024618495,
-0.4114688933,
0.1593994498,
-0.2849072516,
-0.4331825078,
0.163570866,
-0.5214383602,
-1.0396800041,
0.3742078841,
0.2737027407,
0.5866360664,
-0.9839072824,
0.9103438854,
0.5393198729,
-0.5141240954,
-0.5905119777,
0.2553454936,
-0.4496496618,
-0.3795932829,
0.7897251248,
0.4305829704,
0.0291515142,
-0.0045606601,
-0.2426980734,
-0.973459959,
0.7837979198,
0.4044981599,
-0.6246320009,
0.0015260396,
0.3177327216,
0.773471117,
-0.4550304115,
0.3074802458,
0.4992043674,
0.138795346,
-0.2089205235,
-0.3918814659,
0.1072164923,
-0.1444365382,
0.2624730766,
0.1496012658,
-0.186808303,
0.7148346305,
0.0341023467,
-0.2897176445,
-0.1808504909,
1.0258324146,
0.0322191715,
-0.1481869966,
0.6525403857,
0.5692965388,
0.2609423399,
-0.042763453,
1.120367527,
-0.4983757436,
0.5049898624,
1.2578407526,
-0.0413606167,
0.9715604186,
0.6268931627,
-0.3251120746,
0.5170009136,
0.3036303818,
-0.1253141165,
0.8290254474,
0.2359912992,
-0.3796497583,
-0.0777611658,
-0.1816019714,
0.0092609618,
0.6016507745,
0.1504958421,
-0.7085528374,
-0.2072710395,
-0.0698381215,
-0.3279582262,
0.0874059051,
0.1350517571,
0.487998426,
0.2502739727,
-0.6311076283,
0.1521976441,
0.28563416,
0.7123240829,
-0.5377123356,
0.0289204642,
-0.2538579702,
0.2281126678,
-0.1694636792,
-0.7061790228,
0.5770278573,
-0.3048645854,
-0.5213023424,
-0.3469305038,
0.7095566392,
-0.5113495588,
-0.764315486,
0.5025941133,
0.144513905,
-0.3195705414,
-0.0643445551,
-0.3029842079,
-0.4405106604,
-0.4230078757,
-0.6523246169,
0.3083064556,
0.2801805437,
0.0448041074,
0.3656953275,
0.2643317878,
0.1560168713,
0.0340469517,
0.5605877638,
0.7386324406,
-0.5790849924,
-0.7362183332,
-0.9134705663,
0.5555859208,
0.0579789355,
-0.2324887067,
0.3235267401,
0.1063696817,
0.5225300789,
-0.2552996278,
0.6390981674,
-0.129719913,
0.1138829067,
-0.4121901691,
0.6741014123,
-0.316413492,
0.1049891189,
-0.0832335129,
-1.0931767225,
-0.57613343,
0.7754430771,
-0.356715709,
-0.1518749446,
0.8071955442,
0.5365320444,
-0.0928001031,
0.0695150495,
0.343819499,
0.2309561968,
0.2783997357,
0.4943159521,
0.6823868752,
-0.3761696815,
0.3466642797,
-0.2448292226,
-0.2367656529,
-0.0942557082,
-0.7381878495,
-0.5942691565,
-0.7762244344,
-0.1409381628,
-0.2301515043,
-0.3196469545,
0.760430038,
0.4070152342,
-0.8797233105,
0.0565687604,
-0.5216042399,
-0.0584425963,
-0.4108622074,
-0.2970149815,
0.4253480434,
-0.4757621288,
-0.4347129762,
0.3772326112,
0.3535351455,
-0.1473190039,
-0.3670010567,
0.3662612736,
-0.1319512129,
0.1021772102,
0.6650564671,
-0.2090199739,
-0.7702445388,
-0.3419111669,
0.0653390437,
-0.140588671,
0.1437302083,
0.6891442537,
-1.0396447182,
0.3205001056,
0.5474988818,
0.5673974156,
0.4785264432,
-0.3442886174,
0.8010485768,
-0.7800884247,
0.3876052201,
0.3705636859,
0.6568262577,
0.2381182462,
-0.3037291765,
0.361663878,
0.3586885035,
-0.3574581146,
-0.4731599391,
0.4684597552,
-0.8718076944,
-0.257398665,
0.9439056516,
-0.2009077966,
-0.1642507017,
0.0549687073,
0.1132312939,
0.3819103837,
0.0657328367,
0.836666584,
0.5761305094,
0.2100419998,
-0.2493030131,
-0.6014423966,
0.2777150869,
0.5676730275,
-0.3574519157,
-0.0004274287,
0.1616804898,
0.0554841571,
0.3127692938,
0.458645016,
0.1312010735,
0.0040449286,
0.2267815471,
0.3138713539,
0.3746569753,
-0.3929750621,
-0.2448362559,
0.5822810531,
-0.2348228395,
-0.10492412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15208v1
|
LongStory: Coherent, Complete and Length Controlled Long story Generation
| 2023-11-26T06:24:25 | 2023-11-26T06:24:25 |
Kyeongman Park, Nakyeong Yang, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A human author can write any length of story without losing coherence. Also,
they always bring the story to a proper ending, an ability that current
language models lack. In this work, we present the LongStory for coherent,
complete, and length-controlled long story generation. LongStory introduces two
novel methodologies: (1) the long and short-term contexts weight calibrator
(CWC) and (2) long story structural positions (LSP). The CWC adjusts weights
for long-term context Memory and short-term context Cheating, acknowledging
their distinct roles. The LSP employs discourse tokens to convey the structural
positions of a long story. Trained on three datasets with varied average story
lengths, LongStory outperforms other baselines, including the strong story
generator Plotmachine, in coherence, completeness, relevance, and
repetitiveness. We also perform zero-shot tests on each dataset to assess the
model's ability to predict outcomes beyond its training data and validate our
methodology by comparing its performance with variants of our model.
|
[
-0.1437423378,
-0.6687422395,
0.74168396,
0.6143874526,
-0.3601933718,
0.1598636657,
-0.4621516764,
-0.7523524761,
0.3921979368,
0.6060381532,
-0.5028536916,
-0.3172020614,
-0.2305368036,
0.1163432151,
-0.4892467558,
1.2873961926,
-0.544962585,
-0.0589334741,
-0.2822256684,
-0.1423541456,
-0.5889410377,
-0.4460475743,
-0.4775400162,
-0.2963296771,
0.6923937201,
0.0434110649,
0.8504277468,
0.6347895265,
0.060516078,
0.1905652732,
0.0598031431,
-0.0958251506,
-0.7542086244,
0.5579686761,
-0.2324840724,
-0.2765108049,
-0.4164310396,
-0.3278675079,
0.6050709486,
0.6268061399,
-0.1147536933,
0.1090885252,
0.410592854,
0.6782733798,
-0.7365826368,
-0.1398819983,
0.0033367106,
0.1838274002,
-0.264480412,
-0.0800800323,
-0.5080545545,
-0.2590292394,
0.1219662279,
-0.4958126843,
0.2230461687,
0.1824759841,
0.4843860269,
0.1384658813,
-0.7940142751,
-0.6660513282,
-0.6920512915,
1.1784362793,
-0.53788656,
0.274087131,
0.3605915606,
0.1854331344,
-0.2440387756,
-0.7896999717,
-0.3971211016,
-0.358039856,
-0.1187173799,
0.2587060332,
0.180450663,
0.1268764436,
0.1319410056,
0.1398770809,
-0.6587051153,
0.1228048876,
-0.4439114928,
-0.1060157791,
0.7685928345,
0.1877445579,
0.0552261025,
-0.5662523508,
-0.7630051374,
0.0723257884,
-0.5938708782,
0.116703935,
0.4169412851,
0.0503010415,
0.1039238423,
0.6312888861,
-0.2288338691,
0.6766918898,
-0.1107090861,
-0.4397770464,
-0.0097020268,
-0.3608414829,
-0.0444410816,
0.4634023607,
0.6786410213,
0.5053978562,
0.1204694584,
-0.33651492,
-0.3786638379,
-0.2265575379,
0.083691515,
-0.8243448138,
0.1937642545,
0.3741720617,
-0.29369241,
-0.5170763731,
-0.1849617362,
-0.733818233,
-0.2485526949,
-0.4476180077,
0.4036404192,
-0.4255441725,
0.0237455964,
0.1743521988,
-0.2783534825,
0.1855570674,
0.1834699363,
-0.7872879505,
0.6013585329,
0.5825018287,
1.0057063103,
-0.784503758,
-0.6373067498,
-0.3179514706,
0.6109006405,
-0.4658225477,
0.2811079025,
-0.0234714802,
-0.2266662866,
0.1472329795,
-0.0619354323,
0.3167394102,
-0.1276765019,
0.6609503031,
-0.4378740191,
0.5867006779,
-0.0645926669,
-0.7620708346,
0.1831534356,
0.1982976943,
-0.7094449401,
0.875050962,
0.2106885165,
-0.7064674497,
0.5122058988,
-0.3705554903,
-0.6322590113,
0.0427684337,
0.1002260074,
-0.443364054,
0.2940300107,
0.1236380115,
0.5113704801,
-0.015938649,
0.9433424473,
-0.1151459217,
-0.5225422978,
0.1302700043,
-0.5524219871,
0.568531394,
0.1412056088,
-0.2371744812,
0.1084161922,
-0.7710584998,
0.0766634196,
0.2454055101,
-0.3684132695,
-0.219227016,
0.3312632143,
0.2186377048,
-0.0430633314,
0.3961842358,
-0.6266106963,
0.2047738731,
-0.1029676124,
0.624132812,
0.5427832007,
0.0685368627,
0.5387908816,
-0.4026052356,
0.542091012,
-0.208258763,
0.0731031895,
-0.4407900572,
-0.1296671927,
-0.581312716,
-0.3310825229,
0.118175678,
0.3745567203,
-0.602966845,
0.5046153665,
-0.3748038709,
-0.1643956453,
0.0838125572,
-0.001427728,
0.2654884458,
0.4636139572,
0.4025277197,
-0.1476894319,
-0.5814531446,
-0.6124757528,
-0.2895680666,
0.1212674305,
-0.3836984038,
0.0992819816,
0.6652805209,
0.1626008451,
1.1746799946,
-0.6739417911,
-0.1065296829,
-0.2821095884,
0.1274420172,
0.2539362311,
0.3452706635,
0.433973819,
-0.5601164103,
-0.3348382115,
-0.4994023144,
-0.7528527379,
0.0564602837,
-0.4460158944,
-0.1100466996,
0.3789644241,
0.4230534136,
-1.030644536,
0.5277943015,
0.5190281868,
-0.4269319475,
0.9377141595,
-0.0682883188,
0.0320121758,
-1.3650904894,
-0.0481196493,
-0.3145617247,
-0.6176316738,
-0.4600242376,
0.1409760863,
0.2109765708,
-0.4057483375,
-0.3883690536,
0.91902107,
-0.525365591,
0.0146413082,
-0.1700460166,
0.231457144,
0.3919469714,
0.5628194213,
0.1311071366,
0.5882558823,
0.1561408341,
-0.3173160553,
0.5986821651,
0.0553566031,
-0.6874961853,
0.5083195567,
-0.8027077913,
-0.0029699772,
-0.2168578506,
0.7974669933,
-0.7107764482,
-0.590447247,
-0.2469106019,
-0.2228362113,
0.4143088758,
0.0696793422,
-0.532384634,
-0.5448203683,
-0.4830594063,
0.3024054766,
0.2086843848,
-0.5228313804,
0.2224786431,
-0.1761848181,
-0.3757650256,
-0.6456008554,
-0.863294661,
0.3582138717,
-0.2677114308,
-0.6882871985,
0.4659472704,
-0.1887465864,
0.0211498253,
-0.2734664381,
0.1241680831,
-0.1128612235,
-0.3651637435,
0.2056985945,
0.0405835547,
-0.2365609109,
0.3576671481,
0.4267888069,
0.0098918732,
-0.0024600388,
-0.2676946223,
0.5289393663,
0.1108368412,
-0.1927127838,
-0.1421738267,
0.7402374148,
0.4820569158,
-0.0966348648,
0.7342941165,
0.2955006659,
-0.2772953212,
-0.393560946,
-0.432585597,
0.1351925433,
-0.4478745759,
0.6304973364,
-0.279414624,
-0.97021842,
0.5476522446,
0.0927488804,
0.0412075631,
0.1839366853,
0.3082834184,
-0.1001283005,
0.9482326508,
0.6255960464,
-0.0803638324,
0.2350234389,
0.0707676187,
0.1392691433,
-0.6230419278,
-0.0257446747,
-0.1666828245,
-0.475818783,
-0.1658982635,
-0.304980129,
0.0713447407,
0.7082967162,
-0.3746608198,
0.3557285964,
-0.5597527623,
0.8058741093,
0.2745319307,
0.0030991596,
0.3359102905,
-0.1736410409,
0.1126433462,
-0.1439571083,
-0.2945457399,
-0.4232420921,
0.9833970666,
0.4635325074,
0.8396337628,
0.177833274,
0.9849356413,
0.1516388506,
0.0172360744,
-0.9311105013,
0.364860028,
0.1565364748,
-0.808426857,
-0.6427463293,
-0.2617535591,
-0.7042927146,
-0.1152623743,
0.2368255258,
-0.7552376986,
0.1132963374,
-0.1283423752,
-0.3098449111,
0.1333931834,
-0.5310075283,
0.6440238953,
-0.6670930982,
-0.5834000111,
0.0063799489,
-0.6097573042,
0.3623048663,
-0.3173877597,
-0.2391834706,
0.1566253006,
-0.226220876,
0.6883441806,
-0.4030773342,
0.810372293,
-0.1211365685,
0.0470857956,
0.3105888367,
0.3037650287,
0.7019690275,
0.1627012938,
-0.1603393555,
0.0080624782,
0.1292238683,
-0.5341604352,
-0.3811698854,
0.8184086084,
-0.6001549959,
-0.3468818963,
-0.3784163892,
-0.6350547075,
-0.1279988587,
0.4861299694,
0.515750587,
0.2803474963,
-0.6881231666,
0.4530935884,
0.4541270435,
-0.0868242308,
0.6875920892,
0.0793793872,
-0.5010967851,
-0.5770843625,
0.4747832119,
0.0728279427,
0.2291739136,
0.2105984092,
0.2288869023,
-0.214850083,
-0.4702190459,
-0.5159723759,
-0.0116569679,
-0.4925377667,
-0.4859148562,
-0.3191271424,
-0.3971992433,
-0.2386182845,
-0.7221301794,
-0.3236438036,
-0.3700139225,
-0.2985649705,
-0.2990566194,
0.125644356,
0.6885706782,
0.2368233204,
0.3500619829,
-0.6064403653,
0.3312082291,
0.2905214429,
0.342122823,
0.0098038334,
-0.2486622781,
-0.3393210173,
0.0966683552,
-0.4254781604,
-0.8984557986,
0.4754971862,
0.2910774946,
0.0617370121,
0.3565503955,
0.0185241979,
0.7034677863,
-0.683123529,
1.0427525043,
0.5733362436,
-1.0078552961,
0.5451414585,
-0.5730395913,
0.5504568219,
0.5428648591,
0.3313181996,
-0.4926535785,
-0.2429856211,
-0.0369252451,
-0.9802617431,
0.3409322798,
0.2834921777,
0.369799614,
-0.0514577292,
0.5033698678,
0.3022536039,
0.3066214323,
-1.0217982531,
0.4548058212,
-0.5182596445,
-0.381336987,
-0.1733313203,
-0.5545340776,
-0.2961597145,
-0.0971110836,
0.4013367891,
-0.2881663442,
-0.1475336105,
0.3388940692,
-0.2597655356,
-0.2194046378,
0.3870292008,
0.7098932862,
1.1731745005,
-0.322463721,
-0.16963467,
0.240049988,
-0.436122328,
0.0253270976,
0.0220275335,
-0.2657836378,
0.0676044151,
0.7000165582,
1.0219686031,
0.411744535,
-0.5378172398,
0.7098080516,
0.0729969963,
-0.3397616148,
-0.7148339748,
-0.1323135495,
0.2741443515,
0.1924667209,
0.4185248017,
-0.3067449629,
-0.0479443707,
-0.5279397964,
0.2608074546,
0.0748263896,
-0.3378980756,
-0.2891034186,
0.597461462,
0.206730336,
-0.2507753968,
0.735861659,
-0.0114779426,
-0.2498182207,
0.4775728285,
0.9340088964,
0.8379027247,
-0.1638059616,
0.3127706945,
0.3559454083,
-0.0111438949,
-0.3364622891,
0.1018563583,
-0.3394793272,
-0.4487594664,
-0.6892315149,
-1.1305969954,
-0.2095258236,
0.1019137204,
-0.8726662397,
0.3560381532,
-0.2441260964,
-0.0851138607,
-0.30570665,
0.3795439601,
-0.2847991288,
0.1716702133,
0.1407511681,
1.048751235,
-0.474452585,
0.840718329,
0.0158441663,
-0.140879795,
-0.5068217516,
-0.016945878,
-0.0636255071,
-0.4861620367,
0.3934401572,
0.3434379697,
-0.0750687495,
-0.243145749,
-0.8499345779,
-0.9186398387,
1.5391834974,
0.2586429417,
-0.8254967928,
-0.6514633894,
0.3194281459,
0.7890847325,
-0.355370909,
-0.3839728534,
0.2104248852,
0.369056046,
0.2167534977,
-0.7474313378,
-0.0253497139,
0.281137526,
-0.0384472124,
0.43963328,
-0.5515925288,
0.5932322145,
-0.2075460255,
-0.1453046948,
0.6729351282,
0.7950212359,
0.5464270115,
0.5322001576,
0.2692942321,
0.5246319175,
0.5953446031,
0.0453494079,
1.000839591,
-0.4994884431,
0.3691491485,
1.488684535,
-0.4095612764,
0.9430680871,
0.5628607273,
0.1628959477,
0.5538309813,
0.5015038252,
0.0109010395,
0.482488662,
0.4166326523,
-0.1534058899,
0.0038820545,
0.0717090592,
-0.2065732628,
0.3489414155,
0.1691508293,
-0.3042722046,
-0.048550766,
0.2319660038,
0.283646971,
-0.119536005,
-0.1006462649,
0.4066046476,
0.4467745721,
-0.9337847233,
0.4252360463,
-0.0501627214,
0.6424635649,
-1.0333440304,
0.2292364687,
-0.2576013505,
0.1523262411,
-0.1397569329,
-1.0468417406,
0.223629877,
-0.047099147,
-0.3299375474,
-0.4121873081,
0.6766312122,
-0.6434598565,
-0.3987899423,
0.3648439944,
0.2382085919,
-0.097975187,
-0.1260184795,
-0.5056785345,
-0.0381196029,
-0.0974634513,
-0.6774349213,
0.260080725,
0.3902739584,
-0.3225426376,
0.494927913,
0.5956586599,
0.1651600152,
-0.2480751723,
0.02398712,
0.6449118853,
-0.8950477839,
-0.5867822766,
-0.531309545,
0.4964366257,
-0.3326641619,
-0.623618722,
0.6141313314,
0.7618509531,
0.464394778,
0.0873787329,
0.3280177116,
0.1412135512,
0.4173983634,
-0.4915799797,
0.942042768,
-0.4766226709,
-0.2858943045,
-0.0108179608,
-1.3124117851,
-0.1904594898,
0.1508501619,
0.0336073078,
-0.0195137858,
0.8642321229,
0.4037157595,
-0.078866452,
-0.0518432781,
0.4080699682,
0.2956972718,
0.3672803342,
0.5486280322,
0.7173155546,
-0.2895490229,
0.5349767208,
-0.1748922765,
-0.2015189081,
0.0719140694,
-0.9393351078,
-0.8264857531,
-0.5384740233,
0.221629113,
-0.2251897901,
0.1697369516,
0.2207752317,
0.7834796309,
-0.5976667404,
-0.3613344729,
-0.0687687322,
-0.1330741197,
0.0487059169,
-0.3133119941,
0.4526494145,
-0.148770377,
-0.441270709,
0.5535885096,
0.3221536875,
-0.0005634188,
-0.5500391126,
-0.3247514069,
0.1227760315,
0.3314114809,
0.8457743526,
0.1634242386,
-0.5595120788,
-0.4260134697,
-0.0183100086,
-0.2530931234,
-0.1603761613,
0.8424187303,
-0.7302186489,
0.44842273,
0.5304976702,
0.0115363505,
0.8382303119,
-0.1280362904,
0.7858730555,
-0.9663584232,
0.2964483798,
0.5603087544,
0.3433478475,
0.1954048723,
-0.5449925661,
0.441595614,
-0.2661289573,
-0.924123764,
-0.8669506907,
0.3675611615,
-1.009062171,
-0.6502817273,
0.889107585,
-0.0355696231,
-0.4750458002,
0.1231747642,
-0.140352726,
0.2155204266,
-0.2080284953,
0.6390483975,
0.9315469265,
-0.0543016456,
-0.057904657,
-0.6124649048,
0.6293577552,
0.1850931346,
-0.6160720587,
0.17005831,
0.7246338129,
0.2562005818,
0.3533392549,
0.4931432605,
-0.0239645783,
0.0795415267,
-0.1297305524,
0.0801539719,
-0.111921005,
-0.5685938597,
-0.0900750831,
0.2770168185,
-0.4450505674,
0.3108181953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15198v1
|
ChatGPT and Beyond: The Generative AI Revolution in Education
| 2023-11-26T05:34:22 | 2023-11-26T05:34:22 |
Mohammad AL-Smadi
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The wide adoption and usage of generative artificial intelligence (AI)
models, particularly ChatGPT, has sparked a surge in research exploring their
potential applications in the educational landscape. This survey examines
academic literature published between November, 2022, and July, 2023,
specifically targeting high-impact research from Scopus-indexed Q1 and Q2
journals. This survey delves into the practical applications and implications
of generative AI models across a diverse range of educational contexts. Through
a comprehensive and rigorous evaluation of recent academic literature, this
survey seeks to illuminate the evolving role of generative AI models,
particularly ChatGPT, in education. By shedding light on the potential
benefits, challenges, and emerging trends in this dynamic field, the survey
endeavors to contribute to the understanding of the nexus between artificial
intelligence and education. The findings of this review will empower educators,
researchers, and policymakers to make informed decisions about the integration
of AI technologies into learning environments.
|
[
-0.5242275,
-0.9007038474,
0.3178962469,
-0.0507734902,
0.2968066633,
0.4780896008,
0.004994072,
-0.5076711178,
-0.3781344593,
0.0573145635,
-0.564104557,
-0.0398246534,
-0.8214430213,
-0.3072098494,
-0.9323179722,
0.9691121578,
0.0851813257,
0.1141683459,
-0.5909759998,
0.2591501176,
-0.4734956026,
-0.7213951349,
-0.8081332445,
-0.48741135,
0.3390278816,
0.2078478932,
0.4817580879,
-0.1823128313,
0.7200026512,
0.2661965787,
0.01289488,
0.083290346,
-0.3887568116,
0.0758509934,
0.1617744267,
-0.4702225924,
-0.3039668202,
0.3579030633,
0.7636657953,
0.7326294184,
-0.2815115154,
0.0331742242,
0.4338962436,
0.6828862429,
-0.4533926249,
0.439584136,
-0.1933037043,
0.4124573171,
-0.2284362018,
0.1952848136,
-0.3833140731,
-0.5551118851,
0.3954553604,
-0.6041376591,
0.2538867891,
-0.3231597841,
0.5203117728,
0.2538784444,
-0.3854153454,
-0.2164342403,
-0.911847651,
0.6045781374,
-0.1899507195,
0.6115825772,
0.152676031,
0.5255100131,
-0.1748031825,
-1.1859023571,
-0.660097003,
-0.2564871013,
0.2924610078,
0.6305721998,
-0.211497739,
0.1578077525,
0.1033590734,
0.5848339796,
-0.5773741603,
0.0309987962,
-0.6094792485,
0.1205205172,
0.4570682049,
0.2613496184,
0.6494027972,
0.3158811331,
-0.4172155559,
-0.2818282843,
-0.7524368167,
0.0651361793,
0.2962686419,
-0.1116208062,
-0.066005215,
0.7187797427,
0.136770919,
0.6018588543,
-0.4894375801,
0.3804699183,
-0.1250198036,
-0.4531644583,
0.0170092899,
-0.1072836295,
0.8765851855,
0.2474106252,
0.2027436793,
0.1021655276,
0.01977407,
0.3071688712,
0.2800882757,
-0.7140527368,
-0.5104743838,
-0.0252289735,
-0.1134959236,
-0.348908931,
0.0176385213,
-0.9781658649,
-0.5788439512,
-0.3394086659,
0.0362207666,
-0.5444068313,
-0.3587099314,
-0.0124463066,
-0.3851064444,
0.5325937867,
0.6374222636,
-0.9136773944,
-0.0729907379,
1.0452753305,
0.8906009197,
-0.07190606,
-0.289657414,
0.1590592116,
-0.3630464375,
-0.4590907395,
0.9601292014,
-0.8691189885,
-0.9674540758,
0.3509512842,
-0.5226423144,
-0.3935942054,
-0.3134028614,
0.3882688582,
-0.5369002819,
0.572021544,
0.0472219288,
-0.6804642677,
-0.2994350791,
0.6527917981,
-0.4983083904,
0.9889591932,
0.2786099017,
-0.3660202026,
0.151684016,
-1.04867208,
-0.218764022,
0.2810251117,
-0.3469373286,
-0.5926366448,
-0.1501328349,
0.1517705768,
0.1555116624,
-0.4911251962,
0.3243007064,
0.071441263,
-0.3817514181,
0.2518209517,
-0.9534495473,
1.2011221647,
0.2445485741,
-0.1211030483,
0.0591553822,
-0.345703572,
-0.0430087186,
0.0867996514,
-0.1622630954,
0.0454001911,
0.3763584793,
0.128270179,
0.095740512,
0.2430458069,
-0.4195010662,
0.3692290485,
-0.1406674534,
0.8143720627,
0.5975471139,
-0.0310324058,
0.3056586981,
-0.5493516326,
0.8863997459,
-0.3528172672,
0.5055980682,
-0.2709467411,
-0.9384519458,
-0.5757110715,
-0.0938106701,
0.4294316471,
0.5765997171,
-0.6759033799,
0.234636724,
-0.2216482759,
-0.7643156648,
-0.720941186,
-0.4327900708,
0.0539770201,
0.4100380242,
0.2076290995,
-0.0714387447,
-0.4032682776,
-0.2549202442,
-0.1227587759,
-0.6020495296,
0.0044583506,
0.4368105233,
0.4576670825,
-0.3014670014,
0.8964067101,
-0.3260189295,
-0.2046020925,
-0.229748711,
0.2100667357,
-0.2317415625,
0.5978634357,
0.4676280916,
-1.0239692926,
-0.5455647707,
0.020576546,
-0.7187898755,
0.3837629855,
-0.1826104969,
-0.1730885953,
-0.3166724145,
0.4701239467,
-0.8562501669,
0.4369169772,
0.407058984,
-0.2287799269,
0.635191977,
0.1869794279,
0.5731042027,
-0.9079592824,
-0.0731935576,
-0.2134265006,
0.1922473311,
-0.6095376015,
0.0942575708,
-0.1666125357,
-0.486309588,
-0.2241617441,
0.5439937115,
-0.1711965054,
0.1472868919,
-0.0925147161,
0.3398042917,
-0.0122464839,
-0.0863589719,
-0.1213883907,
1.275578618,
0.6359505653,
-0.2716962397,
0.4176880717,
0.6147484183,
-0.4912902713,
0.5192856789,
-0.6266548038,
-0.0056506996,
0.0179924071,
0.5987927914,
-0.8618292809,
-0.2290896624,
0.5615847707,
-0.7373050451,
0.134160623,
-0.0993930921,
-0.3433248699,
-0.5178704262,
-0.2970179319,
0.4815739989,
0.9231710434,
-0.7774465084,
0.5868906379,
0.4295507669,
-0.141499415,
-0.3418674171,
-0.4086816013,
0.2380046099,
0.009851072,
-0.436956197,
0.271567136,
-0.1871327609,
-0.2610258758,
-0.1768339276,
0.0467189327,
-0.0638545007,
0.2137876004,
0.1239637807,
0.6165974736,
-0.3743797541,
-0.0266852379,
-0.2016557306,
0.0925136581,
0.2943927348,
-0.2126571834,
0.6553632617,
-0.1335359663,
-0.6649421453,
-0.2392999232,
0.2282718271,
0.6171685457,
-0.5284056664,
0.539249301,
0.6110790372,
-0.1519420743,
-0.0811670199,
-0.1562408507,
-0.2837960422,
-0.4462973475,
0.476423502,
0.0742957816,
-0.7640476823,
0.108606413,
-0.2373704463,
0.3647013605,
0.3132587969,
0.2987647951,
-0.3004767597,
0.8994774222,
0.5747126937,
0.0105434936,
0.9244325161,
-0.6459895372,
0.6530457735,
-1.0770249367,
-0.6237561703,
-0.4598592222,
-0.1031884477,
-0.7211306095,
-0.3765167892,
0.4469780922,
-0.2457969636,
-0.1946506202,
-0.1644890308,
-0.8086941838,
0.3431908786,
0.7962073088,
-0.012502037,
0.1189313829,
-0.1590053588,
0.4432198703,
0.2405192107,
-0.6980333328,
-0.3979958594,
1.0162011385,
0.1163440421,
0.2934803367,
0.0290601999,
0.4263231158,
0.5470528603,
0.6128240824,
-0.8316987753,
0.5390426517,
-0.051483918,
-0.8956796527,
-0.4277878404,
0.0237084255,
-0.9944546223,
0.2903099656,
0.013562954,
-0.486299634,
0.0271240212,
0.022769751,
-0.2340996563,
0.5541889071,
-0.7456880212,
0.7607339025,
-0.0616030283,
-0.1549168974,
-0.2325085253,
-0.493893683,
0.4632592797,
0.0672316626,
-0.1074071974,
-0.2295868695,
0.2955303788,
0.864928484,
-0.0947362781,
0.787419796,
0.04142287,
-0.0087400051,
0.7421283722,
-0.376360178,
0.221674934,
-0.1795530617,
0.0264000595,
0.4221327305,
0.0694577694,
-0.397877425,
-0.5072005987,
0.4160046279,
-0.9019321799,
-0.8431953788,
-0.8453637958,
-0.4224334955,
-0.3115537465,
0.0168479811,
0.3364697099,
0.3195830584,
-0.4541969001,
0.0364931002,
0.7575411797,
-0.048824247,
0.446837157,
0.0552193522,
-0.1767022461,
-0.0993585289,
1.2226060629,
0.2621051669,
0.0329604633,
0.1805278957,
0.0370283052,
-0.2458335906,
-0.441436708,
-0.5668982863,
-0.2964709997,
-0.5078684688,
-0.0562082082,
-0.4813265204,
-0.9377344251,
-0.5153179169,
-0.4671703577,
-0.295617491,
-0.3231545687,
-0.3995811939,
-0.0367824547,
0.2821575403,
0.951069653,
0.0961330533,
0.553994298,
-0.5789729357,
0.0557927862,
0.6351882219,
0.2994557619,
0.049212575,
-0.3163755536,
0.0882408842,
0.1780540049,
-0.5920372605,
-0.6158835292,
0.1007917523,
0.3690746129,
0.4696112573,
0.4579440057,
-0.0842598155,
0.4925812483,
-0.5527490973,
1.2691601515,
0.2439611852,
-0.2820667028,
0.4067940712,
-0.3408070803,
0.2083580196,
0.1599912345,
0.4886108637,
-0.794011116,
-0.2802363038,
-0.6577245593,
-0.9934708476,
0.4727310538,
0.2765502334,
0.554784894,
0.1909064949,
-0.1075740755,
0.1798505187,
0.2068546861,
-0.4286331236,
-0.317024678,
-0.4703265131,
-0.186892584,
0.0279139373,
-0.1662104726,
-0.1038366929,
-0.3087706864,
0.7157496214,
0.2931155562,
0.4777726531,
-0.3415503502,
0.1969951242,
0.36844033,
0.3846662343,
0.2191448808,
0.4850265384,
0.19393906,
-0.3098601699,
-0.1168452948,
-0.9000708461,
0.1008945405,
0.4712178111,
-0.5380447507,
-0.2556864917,
0.4041904509,
0.5146184564,
-0.0488534197,
-0.7774249911,
0.4413266778,
-0.1122384444,
-0.1859181225,
-0.8745861053,
0.4804344475,
-0.1985334903,
0.2837606966,
0.2037158757,
0.2790373266,
0.4225999713,
-0.4653121531,
0.1169032231,
0.5596635342,
-0.4818133414,
-0.2523235083,
0.8467099071,
0.207474485,
-0.4288811684,
1.2545663118,
0.2629844248,
-0.4003071487,
0.9806216955,
0.4717202783,
0.9777836204,
-0.0924748704,
0.5768243074,
0.2659621239,
0.154057458,
0.0493912324,
0.0101845367,
-0.3669900894,
-0.7373414636,
0.0552382693,
-0.3806962371,
-0.703115046,
-0.027002275,
-0.3488258719,
0.0356560498,
-0.3234308958,
-0.2641902268,
0.0787822083,
-0.2615621984,
-0.5969298482,
0.2309978604,
0.2707306743,
0.655318439,
-0.6859847307,
0.5725554824,
0.9342213869,
-0.6635958552,
-0.4035007656,
0.1453715712,
0.0360388607,
-0.7674084902,
0.193086639,
0.1261261851,
-0.0188195016,
0.451018095,
-0.6093178988,
-0.7253264189,
0.9745884538,
-0.0596779548,
-0.5226371288,
-0.2428573221,
0.2189225107,
0.5828158259,
0.0104150893,
0.4997066557,
0.7135680914,
0.4313696623,
0.136248976,
-0.3589375913,
-0.7382332683,
-0.3385838866,
-0.0886064097,
0.2836303115,
-0.7903617024,
0.6155584455,
-0.1146923974,
-0.2497622669,
0.1413961798,
0.6926471591,
0.3811347187,
0.5187410116,
-0.0862345397,
0.2927450538,
0.574303627,
-0.5691106319,
0.993271172,
-0.3010585606,
0.1859486401,
0.7590720057,
0.073193565,
0.6157547832,
0.2341369987,
-0.8061164021,
0.4742267132,
0.9010065794,
-0.3178908527,
0.2765361965,
-0.0053938604,
-0.9275705814,
0.0627208799,
-0.338252753,
-0.6204721928,
0.4327867329,
0.7120166421,
0.088629894,
-0.1140011102,
0.3106271029,
-0.028235618,
0.044610776,
-0.4591747224,
0.6286383271,
0.075383462,
-0.8991059661,
0.0022452024,
-0.3522718251,
0.4546574056,
-0.416166693,
-0.4799282849,
-0.3418935239,
-0.1601096541,
0.1170996279,
-1.0458005667,
0.0406937189,
-0.1475504339,
0.0417492837,
-0.4631741345,
0.6643913388,
-0.4530627429,
-0.4699020982,
-0.0484524556,
0.6257948875,
0.0410221368,
0.1404721141,
-0.6139221787,
-0.1247548163,
-0.1829329729,
-0.0728446394,
0.2712100744,
0.3143572807,
-0.0070708296,
0.8633872867,
0.6557517052,
-0.094729647,
0.3433642089,
0.0387114435,
0.7945235968,
-0.361118257,
-0.2282995433,
-0.5929489136,
0.6118621826,
-0.0726214722,
-0.5476355553,
0.5634482503,
0.4734252989,
1.0112973452,
-0.057216581,
1.2472243309,
-0.3204826713,
-0.0053647789,
-0.1995915622,
0.9593949318,
-0.3441868722,
0.0659492835,
-0.0441760123,
-0.6260638833,
-0.1514930874,
0.3954048455,
-0.4911768138,
0.3523977399,
0.2453133315,
0.2379772067,
0.218916133,
0.416061461,
0.4166392386,
-0.2570128441,
0.4692823887,
0.1936359107,
1.3461574316,
-0.4781656265,
0.3705761135,
-0.1929851025,
-0.0454630479,
-0.2030243576,
-0.2725818157,
-0.8065052629,
-0.8090795875,
-0.5065840483,
0.0265314449,
0.3735361695,
0.6078900099,
0.3977375329,
-0.7620880008,
0.0759159848,
-0.3822382689,
0.3081110716,
-0.3087773919,
-0.3017409146,
0.443058908,
-0.5503763556,
-0.9909944534,
0.3080638945,
-0.0072651366,
0.256837368,
-0.4199797809,
0.1995691508,
-0.0917612538,
0.1219846979,
0.9328994751,
0.5750994682,
-0.5378132463,
-0.1623149216,
-0.0149259521,
-0.0824022591,
0.1370334923,
0.6869552135,
-0.7609615326,
0.6414327025,
0.591884315,
0.8069860339,
0.2096277326,
0.0319464505,
0.5544650555,
-0.3386286795,
-0.1286272258,
0.5648209453,
0.0944709331,
0.2682217956,
-0.3245157003,
0.8102877736,
0.3457143903,
-0.7940272093,
-0.8981578946,
0.1377788484,
-0.5744393468,
-0.1271643341,
0.588901639,
-0.1927569062,
0.1148209348,
-0.1062797979,
-0.1199307069,
0.3104183078,
-0.091434814,
1.2938110828,
0.6758565903,
-0.4317684472,
-0.4491509497,
-1.0101886988,
0.5426934958,
0.2492172271,
-0.9865371585,
-0.2232704461,
0.4380690753,
-0.2068736851,
-0.0773193017,
0.3870474696,
-0.2932972014,
0.398473382,
0.3744148612,
0.0796984509,
0.1373170465,
-0.4990034997,
-0.0462865829,
0.1385210603,
0.1061797366,
-0.3532603979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03719v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03719v4
|
Comparative Analysis of ChatGPT, GPT-4, and Microsoft Bing Chatbots for GRE Test
| 2023-11-26T05:27:35 | 2024-04-06T18:37:05 |
Mohammad Abu-Haifa, Bara'a Etawi, Huthaifa Alkhatatbeh, Ayman Ababneh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research paper presents an analysis of how well three artificial
intelligence chatbots: Bing, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, perform when answering
questions from standardized tests. The Graduate Record Examination is used in
this paper as a case study. A total of 137 questions with different forms of
quantitative reasoning and 157 questions with verbal categories were used to
assess their capabilities. This paper presents the performance of each chatbot
across various skills and styles tested in the exam. The proficiency of these
chatbots in addressing image-based questions is also explored, and the
uncertainty level of each chatbot is illustrated. The results show varying
degrees of success across the chatbots, where GPT-4 served as the most
proficient, especially in complex language understanding tasks and image-based
questions. Results highlight the ability of these chatbots to pass the GRE with
a high score, which encourages the use of these chatbots in test preparation.
The results also show how important it is to ensure that, if the test is
administered online, as it was during COVID, the test taker is segregated from
these resources for a fair competition on higher education opportunities.
|
[
-0.6406546831,
-0.9437517524,
0.3190690279,
0.0309665706,
0.3219973743,
0.5972988605,
0.0262109917,
-0.4687609673,
-0.1081395745,
0.09504807,
-0.3124150634,
-0.3800325096,
-0.4251514673,
0.0605511032,
-0.2799587548,
1.1275639534,
0.1042363346,
-0.0114585124,
-0.5128951073,
0.150086984,
-0.8175926805,
-0.4986560345,
-1.0263230801,
-0.3720623851,
0.0878626481,
0.0511779524,
0.8147662878,
-0.4053064287,
1.1366378069,
0.3515397608,
0.3121227324,
-0.2352228314,
-0.5692851543,
-0.0941555053,
-0.0111620715,
-0.4905486405,
-0.4757440388,
0.1834341139,
0.2485167682,
0.0650074035,
0.0432282425,
0.2988694012,
0.0691700131,
0.487575233,
-0.1964900196,
0.313850522,
-0.8038411736,
-0.0816289335,
0.2891190648,
-0.1500254422,
-0.1794647276,
-0.6425392628,
0.178231895,
-0.4652580917,
0.5240747333,
-0.1331994832,
1.3393969536,
0.2574258149,
-0.1725176573,
-0.3141596317,
-0.5779235959,
0.642223537,
-0.5572403073,
0.1481563747,
0.3137894571,
0.8408203125,
-0.3007946312,
-0.8581554294,
-0.2596039474,
-0.6065149307,
-0.1616859883,
0.5638059974,
-0.1957776546,
0.3145701587,
0.0522187874,
0.3881060183,
-1.1862663031,
-0.1701586843,
-0.5532103181,
-0.4154953063,
0.9087849259,
0.0079914788,
0.6580845714,
0.2123506963,
-0.1920868754,
-0.3531596065,
-0.1272296309,
0.0689970627,
0.4183736145,
0.0849510059,
0.0579872355,
0.3222282231,
0.0634130538,
0.6264661551,
-0.2714256346,
-0.3210036755,
0.3231938481,
-0.3620348871,
-0.1944670379,
-0.2090007216,
0.8204307556,
0.450481087,
0.6901979446,
-0.0052838544,
-0.0190208293,
0.3451126814,
0.3500242829,
-0.606890738,
-0.4294637442,
0.3538615108,
-0.4899559021,
0.1883148104,
0.122547619,
-0.8134586215,
-0.0613507666,
-0.1908007115,
0.7155219316,
-0.3729723692,
0.0332678631,
0.1744767874,
-0.61042732,
0.5617324114,
0.3852860034,
-0.5119329691,
0.7254920006,
0.8043578267,
0.7429702878,
-0.3156050444,
-0.163409397,
-0.3015532196,
-0.2957702577,
-0.0010593288,
0.6657946706,
-0.7348982096,
-0.4707813561,
-0.1437683105,
-0.276417762,
-0.6430369616,
-0.5360789895,
0.4045376182,
-0.6873112917,
0.5539112687,
-0.0329017714,
-0.6964703798,
-0.4165981114,
0.6886960864,
-0.3954592049,
1.0346927643,
0.0715714097,
-0.5410060287,
0.0824944004,
-1.1485233307,
-0.1546555758,
0.4336932302,
-0.8147839308,
-0.036921598,
-0.4660445452,
0.1564622372,
0.7158746719,
-0.2728521526,
-0.0455918983,
0.0882759616,
-0.7832891345,
-0.0801229328,
-0.3797873855,
0.524792552,
0.1007758304,
-0.4618262053,
-0.2320565581,
-0.3271866143,
0.296146214,
0.3863968253,
-0.0940913856,
0.2395424396,
-0.1381633431,
-0.3379054964,
0.0748682171,
0.0971457288,
-0.4316550493,
0.1777371168,
0.2213312984,
0.0108871497,
0.3465762138,
0.2000870556,
-0.0289527159,
-0.4162762761,
0.9839732647,
-0.401442498,
0.3339383602,
0.1087988317,
-1.1199324131,
-0.1844335198,
-0.3246783912,
0.3487129211,
1.2260121107,
-0.4493753612,
0.0767039806,
-0.294290483,
-0.7137485147,
-0.5660486817,
-0.2224814147,
0.2938078642,
0.3167506754,
0.2862683833,
-0.3504146934,
0.1304430664,
-0.7941347361,
-0.5621485114,
-0.4000101984,
-0.2648794949,
0.5434151292,
0.7057005167,
-0.0589995869,
0.7822955847,
-0.6630848646,
-0.2422974259,
-0.1717424542,
0.1743277907,
0.0203427933,
0.288482815,
0.7119437456,
-0.9432807565,
-0.5880358219,
0.1684926599,
-0.682056129,
-0.014711475,
-0.301918149,
0.0804871097,
-0.1268073022,
0.2557699084,
-0.3498474658,
0.5366482139,
0.448957473,
-0.4224700928,
0.6343711019,
-0.155119285,
0.6825470924,
-0.540039897,
-0.2025787979,
0.2442508489,
-0.2075715214,
-0.5059174895,
0.010155254,
-0.3057539463,
-0.2363940626,
-0.2537962496,
0.5747973323,
-0.20484218,
-0.2407931685,
0.0858265013,
0.499112308,
-0.2682095766,
0.3018839359,
-0.4232521653,
0.9555372596,
0.4508692324,
-0.365876466,
0.4206289351,
0.2313792855,
-0.1694347709,
0.3980823159,
-0.9291290045,
0.2935722172,
-0.0357185379,
0.1006445363,
-1.3003017902,
-0.1247155443,
0.3229928911,
-0.9108003378,
-0.0285609942,
-0.0758433267,
-0.490809679,
-0.5539357066,
-0.0738565475,
-0.0145489788,
1.0017307997,
-0.0061367182,
0.5935285687,
0.100260444,
-0.3525177538,
-0.3558612466,
-0.6417617798,
0.001495702,
-0.3130467832,
-0.9318057895,
0.2212490737,
-0.0464660786,
-0.4335935116,
-0.0636118278,
0.2735436559,
-0.2505527437,
-0.0619631112,
0.0712354928,
0.3703365028,
-0.1611611247,
0.1228672192,
-0.4722728431,
-0.0504550487,
0.07101091,
0.1640649438,
0.5950223207,
-0.6313060522,
-0.6136667728,
-0.6445174813,
0.1693809032,
0.4979599714,
-0.064081721,
0.4258210957,
1.0041919947,
-0.1401088536,
0.5330055952,
-0.7764822245,
-0.4327586293,
-0.4590097964,
0.3134246767,
-0.5226883888,
-0.8895846009,
0.6802960634,
0.2157182992,
0.1746201813,
0.384009093,
0.5089452267,
0.1048741937,
0.9842666388,
0.1029234082,
-0.3533959687,
0.2530108988,
-0.0955601931,
0.4020112157,
-0.0804487988,
-0.2165258974,
-0.5512938499,
-0.2510821819,
-0.9293994308,
-0.1903710067,
0.3388579786,
-0.360442996,
-0.430865705,
0.0299250912,
-0.6622563004,
0.4616296589,
0.7664702535,
-0.1080951542,
0.2724302411,
-0.1456182748,
0.1446483582,
-0.051848378,
-0.4807369411,
-0.8955410123,
0.7142958641,
0.2580436766,
0.5706452131,
-0.191781655,
0.4011678398,
0.5615155697,
-0.0263915975,
-0.6219545603,
0.8115844727,
0.0131812384,
-0.6988715529,
-0.2719059289,
-0.3217988312,
-0.9132112861,
0.3518132567,
0.233809039,
-0.9996424913,
-0.5029507875,
-0.1347555369,
-0.2415830195,
0.215168193,
-1.0320734978,
0.8983921409,
-0.3302789629,
0.1059417725,
-0.1160484701,
-0.8202058673,
0.1153903678,
0.0544782504,
-0.1331442147,
-0.2582209706,
0.0674619153,
0.8439688087,
0.1112378538,
0.6920369267,
-0.2690850198,
0.2426632941,
0.7347179651,
0.0643755719,
0.3337370157,
-0.0015593295,
-0.1059751734,
0.1681294143,
0.4048486054,
-0.7585198283,
-0.6555665731,
0.4000053406,
-0.876167655,
-0.7158873677,
-0.4520201981,
-0.363266468,
-0.3097244799,
0.0121253552,
0.1370827258,
0.4579379261,
-0.3461019099,
0.039448224,
0.1677541286,
-0.2043852061,
0.3879330456,
0.1003069803,
-0.1858203113,
-0.2426906526,
0.8473985791,
0.1068634316,
0.4473079145,
0.143299669,
0.1422221512,
-0.2292255759,
-0.3039401174,
-0.0862803385,
0.3488119245,
-0.7955443859,
0.2441835701,
-0.6034751534,
-0.4243908823,
-0.5894442201,
-0.3610994518,
-0.1258238107,
0.0414523296,
0.0525638275,
0.1651373953,
0.3832556605,
0.7806776762,
0.3683172762,
0.4425394535,
-0.9436307549,
0.1776026189,
0.4328641593,
-0.0622640252,
-0.2798880935,
-0.4099224508,
0.5350669026,
-0.0755678192,
-0.5812472701,
-0.6804565191,
-0.0250415727,
0.054393556,
0.7481430769,
0.3083249032,
-0.179838419,
0.5493977666,
-0.2633699775,
1.4374164343,
0.0150446808,
-0.5674453974,
0.3329245746,
-0.5799810886,
0.0965107828,
0.8084558249,
0.6901707649,
-0.6083726287,
-0.3372357488,
-0.9212864637,
-0.2612714469,
0.1506851315,
0.6531921029,
0.2946715653,
0.1000862867,
0.2483686656,
0.2070681751,
0.2574473917,
-0.3385602236,
-0.217160359,
0.0444906801,
-0.267839998,
-0.0133843347,
0.114304103,
0.0646198094,
-0.1752885878,
0.5516022444,
-0.0111602824,
0.6149218082,
0.132021293,
0.3787792623,
0.8536587954,
0.2471739501,
0.5970365405,
0.7764787078,
-0.2410866022,
-0.3407824039,
0.1492167562,
-0.9374806285,
0.0567327812,
-0.2132058591,
0.2018719167,
0.0786327645,
0.2605101466,
0.4656444788,
-0.5157515407,
-0.6930015683,
0.7128530145,
-0.2870977521,
-0.4100267887,
-0.3550921977,
0.3285121322,
-0.0956842005,
0.1286453307,
0.2774270475,
-0.0711686015,
0.0771507844,
-0.4768284261,
0.2918546498,
0.4348986447,
-0.3868380487,
-0.2813853621,
0.4759353399,
0.2868368328,
-0.5994600654,
0.8697409034,
-0.5867643952,
-0.6496855021,
0.8752892017,
0.5814453363,
0.5204555392,
-0.1320989728,
0.5510678887,
0.1787752062,
0.3403301239,
-0.1590217054,
0.5640512109,
0.3418012559,
-0.7112098932,
-0.2670293152,
0.0800008625,
-0.743514359,
0.2143337578,
-0.4812439084,
0.086864084,
-0.2029099911,
-0.324562788,
-0.3679527938,
0.1842430681,
-0.9916702509,
0.5354533195,
-0.1402357519,
0.6224017143,
-0.7599369884,
0.0294138752,
1.0124207735,
-0.4119562209,
-0.6340167522,
0.2482490391,
0.0803033113,
-0.9762970209,
0.5070215464,
0.2218687236,
-0.0130177019,
0.2159007788,
-0.3604703546,
-0.5205566883,
0.9433019757,
0.2089551836,
-0.249092564,
0.1171740815,
0.308198303,
0.682166338,
-0.0805480108,
1.0272548199,
0.7802883983,
0.6144618392,
0.1701099873,
-1.1827378273,
-0.1610080451,
-0.2793945968,
-0.3170973957,
0.1018725485,
-0.8913305998,
0.4064898193,
0.0353576764,
-0.1120893359,
-0.2001356632,
0.370097816,
0.3001356423,
0.5739654303,
0.3292171657,
0.1773045659,
0.9643099904,
-0.3020657003,
1.0577088594,
-0.0376427211,
0.3476518095,
0.9228708148,
-0.2783015966,
0.6980025172,
0.2389970571,
-0.6143257618,
0.4155129194,
0.8936108947,
-0.2682648897,
0.189881891,
0.5341110229,
-0.1990268975,
-0.139287591,
0.0080859894,
-0.3827236593,
0.6701902151,
0.1863167733,
0.0303991102,
-0.1826872081,
0.1001497582,
0.0472532064,
-0.1031840667,
-0.276360333,
0.4360686541,
-0.071558319,
-0.6360698938,
0.2556984425,
-0.4924839437,
0.5181176066,
-0.4312638044,
-0.0235836525,
-0.0971912891,
0.1031655669,
-0.0678109229,
-0.8596664071,
0.1084654033,
-0.0122828307,
0.3515288234,
0.2014733851,
1.0959051847,
0.0914098173,
-0.32741189,
0.3140807748,
0.8149349093,
0.9285617471,
-0.3416563869,
-1.0674397945,
-0.2325387597,
-0.0925681293,
-0.1871611029,
0.1605254412,
0.0059647826,
-0.0326968953,
0.8797234297,
0.2272137552,
0.0558655709,
0.2999905646,
0.2613262534,
0.3999915421,
-0.6882649064,
-0.417219013,
-0.8692364097,
0.3716079593,
-0.3574648201,
-0.2851251364,
0.7927888036,
0.5261909962,
0.8240371943,
-0.091328159,
0.9730420113,
-0.0751239806,
0.4218460619,
-0.1869290918,
0.4231806099,
-0.3697526753,
-0.199458912,
-0.3949730992,
-0.8190351129,
-0.2864296436,
0.3603546917,
-0.5628297329,
0.5059619546,
0.8127757311,
0.8407343626,
0.2200941741,
0.2131229937,
0.5913776159,
-0.5108616948,
0.6618524194,
0.4605732858,
0.886428237,
-0.6212579608,
0.6962853074,
0.1791272461,
-0.1844986826,
-0.1560810357,
-0.5740929246,
-1.1854233742,
-0.4142629206,
-0.5467011333,
-0.058594007,
0.1762112826,
0.69748348,
0.2236623913,
-0.63185215,
-0.017357422,
0.0779509172,
-0.1756679267,
-0.2241648734,
-0.3502565622,
0.3605988026,
-0.4957900643,
-0.7448504567,
0.1002266705,
0.1603915393,
0.3643247187,
0.0564510413,
0.0930612683,
-0.0233376212,
0.0703277588,
0.3987496793,
0.0567943566,
-0.5987467766,
-0.5368571281,
0.1916356385,
-0.1855786741,
0.2221048027,
0.5684989095,
-0.6381898522,
0.2787601352,
0.955935061,
0.8927804232,
0.0154813519,
0.6044927835,
0.4398971796,
-0.2880672812,
-0.0687802285,
0.4330229461,
0.1533375233,
0.1593004614,
-0.439917475,
0.8629841805,
0.1961854845,
-1.1159723997,
-0.3273469806,
-0.263946414,
-0.8065965176,
-0.0854306147,
1.2433165312,
-0.2476481646,
0.4596993625,
-0.3016732335,
-0.481680274,
0.0725681856,
-0.5172078609,
0.7024302483,
0.9116623402,
-0.6035890579,
0.1989523619,
-1.3532005548,
0.3491580784,
0.6084619164,
-1.007879734,
-0.7343062758,
0.1073569283,
0.0852432251,
0.2217977643,
0.7626139522,
-0.163200736,
0.1022384092,
0.1024120599,
0.1083121076,
0.281691432,
-0.1081285253,
-0.1433056444,
0.2223280072,
-0.1045665592,
-0.8787807822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15180v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15180v1
|
Benchmarking Large Language Model Volatility
| 2023-11-26T03:54:03 | 2023-11-26T03:54:03 |
Boyang Yu
|
q-fin.TR
|
q-fin.TR, cs.CL
|
The impact of non-deterministic outputs from Large Language Models (LLMs) is
not well examined for financial text understanding tasks. Through a compelling
case study on investing in the US equity market via news sentiment analysis, we
uncover substantial variability in sentence-level sentiment classification
results, underscoring the innate volatility of LLM outputs. These uncertainties
cascade downstream, leading to more significant variations in portfolio
construction and return. While tweaking the temperature parameter in the
language model decoder presents a potential remedy, it comes at the expense of
stifled creativity. Similarly, while ensembling multiple outputs mitigates the
effect of volatile outputs, it demands a notable computational investment. This
work furnishes practitioners with invaluable insights for adeptly navigating
uncertainty in the integration of LLMs into financial decision-making,
particularly in scenarios dictated by non-deterministic information.
|
[
-0.0987885371,
-0.597376883,
0.5689839721,
0.1307839304,
-0.084182702,
0.4289570749,
-0.2595633268,
-0.1863082498,
0.0441296585,
0.43376863,
-0.4673747122,
-0.5867301822,
-1.0161367655,
-0.2124348134,
-0.4137217999,
1.0005203485,
-0.1787578911,
0.0221357495,
-0.2158424109,
-0.0265382137,
-0.1265269965,
-0.4882436991,
-0.6793835163,
-0.2064439207,
0.4877098501,
0.0435513221,
0.7813870311,
0.3501864374,
0.6273517609,
0.2006285191,
-0.0126608936,
-0.1021769717,
-0.602199614,
0.172223404,
0.0073199621,
-0.6909532547,
-0.1522862315,
0.2721832991,
0.6970507503,
0.6647472978,
-0.1899703741,
0.0543582626,
0.0663838461,
0.8156275749,
-0.9212274551,
0.4928547442,
-0.5944862366,
0.1543214768,
-0.3998447359,
-0.2396346778,
-0.493010968,
-0.2127383351,
0.3250135481,
-0.3369273245,
-0.2836199403,
0.1173450053,
0.8044804931,
0.4863211811,
-0.5708044171,
-0.3408763111,
-0.8529112339,
1.0739485025,
-0.8216306567,
0.4584400952,
0.3164700568,
0.1482414752,
-0.1307797879,
-0.3756817281,
-0.1970110536,
-0.0033893865,
0.4376502037,
0.1554410458,
-0.437808305,
-0.2187714577,
0.046688091,
0.3430809975,
-0.2209964544,
0.1037069336,
-0.0793545991,
-0.2114412785,
0.6722390056,
0.1975231618,
-0.0831770375,
-0.0111049218,
-0.0309175029,
-0.5115746856,
-0.5058663487,
0.2351660281,
0.7295040488,
0.499997288,
-0.1394041926,
0.5397418737,
0.1011506319,
0.2760674357,
-0.1621679515,
-0.3037028015,
0.3279761076,
-0.1049171463,
-0.2985261083,
0.0369283706,
0.6844804883,
0.2879806459,
0.145324111,
-0.134640038,
-0.3006936014,
-0.2975768149,
0.2329701632,
-0.8424086571,
-0.0988867804,
0.2039282769,
-0.3096990883,
-0.3605508506,
0.1744622439,
-1.0056259632,
-0.6388251185,
-0.1904056817,
0.266538471,
-0.2570842206,
-0.225460574,
0.3057619929,
-0.3505271375,
0.3760984242,
0.1589733362,
-0.8073026538,
0.2228691429,
0.6899800301,
0.7876698375,
0.0193094201,
-0.0253302511,
-0.7218151689,
0.0460172705,
-0.6899461746,
0.4770666063,
-0.6438673139,
-0.6590619683,
0.2063880414,
-0.520448029,
-0.0213362705,
-0.2755974829,
0.2921512127,
-0.5161442161,
0.1914879084,
-0.4531910419,
-0.4905707836,
-0.227915287,
0.1170177832,
-0.5012982488,
1.0186363459,
0.1085064188,
-1.0532513857,
0.5424405336,
-0.4614676535,
-0.259475261,
-0.3440618813,
-0.2046018839,
-0.4133699238,
0.4606852829,
0.2810144126,
0.3836943805,
-0.6104554534,
0.2418713421,
-0.4003764093,
-0.176102981,
0.735417366,
-0.8368751407,
0.2789464593,
-0.0432659984,
-0.3247369826,
-0.1501586586,
-0.8710989952,
-0.2193371058,
0.1118122935,
-0.1496258527,
-0.525635004,
0.2341347933,
0.086385183,
-0.1891957074,
0.5521709919,
-0.1170735434,
0.0900528207,
-0.4475075305,
0.4953251779,
0.9091727734,
0.0754014328,
0.5868646502,
-0.1606890708,
0.6454458833,
0.3571624756,
-0.0347329266,
-0.0687970892,
-0.1146742478,
-0.7560188174,
-0.2778860629,
0.1713073701,
0.5927016735,
-0.5046595931,
-0.1479397416,
-0.0703085512,
-0.5541878343,
-0.5067360401,
0.332236588,
-0.0048111766,
0.2385424972,
0.1323995739,
0.0212709811,
-0.4899948537,
-0.9121128917,
-0.539629519,
-0.2881418467,
0.0419694185,
0.1561027765,
0.3170471787,
-0.282946676,
0.7888922691,
-0.5869492888,
-0.0176157057,
-0.2139754742,
0.7954039574,
0.5608783364,
-0.0466709435,
0.4935519695,
-0.3385089934,
-0.2946764529,
0.0625514016,
-0.6194869876,
-0.0964241102,
-0.5385501981,
0.0987850055,
0.2842470706,
0.6778277755,
-0.4153834283,
0.3805332184,
0.6389086843,
-0.033672478,
0.3288242519,
-0.2307651639,
-0.0734106377,
-1.1427849531,
-0.2332212478,
0.3711501062,
-0.0309846103,
-0.2763950527,
-0.3008438051,
0.103514649,
0.4101731777,
-0.2006982118,
0.3321834803,
-0.3848709762,
-0.1676242203,
-0.3102347851,
-0.0237952638,
-0.0611518323,
0.1522463709,
-0.3303405344,
1.0911151171,
0.6456592679,
-0.1531888843,
0.0491088182,
-0.2732158899,
-0.4351357222,
0.3623225689,
-0.425929904,
-0.1141047552,
-0.2522239685,
-0.0548826307,
-0.9491870403,
-0.1071147695,
-0.0685755089,
-0.218864724,
0.5525866151,
0.2828168869,
-0.6992709041,
-0.2324487418,
-0.5841004252,
0.1530324817,
0.365011543,
-0.2237493247,
0.7266632915,
0.255037874,
-0.377322793,
-0.7593771815,
-0.8500778079,
0.3192948401,
-0.3604472578,
-0.3246338069,
-0.1086982787,
-0.0009808898,
-0.7653295398,
-0.2499538511,
-0.3815805614,
0.0643790737,
0.291518718,
0.4099893272,
0.3486762941,
-0.3031416833,
0.3061653674,
0.0292895064,
-0.0598365664,
0.3118756115,
-0.3430247307,
0.274294883,
-0.2740573585,
-0.4120965302,
-0.2785178423,
0.3319121301,
0.7058342099,
-0.0402603783,
0.8446744084,
0.4174898565,
-0.0469559245,
-0.3941267431,
-0.5324643254,
0.0481666587,
-0.5338277817,
0.4942829311,
-0.1521858573,
-1.0046292543,
0.6206155419,
0.0416687615,
0.1671078056,
0.7469520569,
0.743499577,
-0.2000894994,
0.87466079,
0.7795767188,
-0.260564059,
0.4885386229,
-0.0640052631,
0.618457377,
-0.460916847,
-0.1407341957,
-0.3737569749,
-0.3413168192,
-0.733840704,
-0.5886887908,
0.1562049836,
-0.093332313,
-0.25368011,
-0.0339573063,
-0.0803978071,
0.3037534654,
0.5670508146,
-0.4497093856,
0.2151129693,
-0.297786206,
-0.1011716351,
-0.4115865231,
-0.3489914238,
-0.5635626912,
1.2350298166,
0.6700156331,
1.2153126001,
0.067700617,
0.6331942081,
0.17800349,
0.3090794086,
-0.7001183629,
0.1702684909,
-0.2432381362,
-0.1212214828,
-0.1966533512,
-0.505474627,
-0.5899717212,
-0.0290762838,
-0.1914852411,
-0.6764404178,
0.3411971033,
-0.2538474798,
-0.3571846485,
0.3634695709,
-0.6154049039,
0.6042799354,
-0.1501497775,
-0.2429586649,
0.1096747145,
-0.1294695139,
0.2850596011,
-0.438087374,
0.5062482953,
-0.1137085333,
-0.2532526553,
0.5270891786,
-0.2017460018,
1.040435791,
0.29583022,
-0.4222800732,
0.0956063047,
0.0512565859,
0.646435082,
0.3412096798,
-0.2975473702,
0.3469308317,
-0.1163281575,
-0.281106025,
-0.4275256097,
0.6500352025,
-1.0874857903,
-0.7188008428,
-0.6409996748,
-1.112118721,
-0.4236399233,
-0.2025199383,
0.3380382359,
0.0661778748,
-0.2000860423,
0.2241508961,
0.589266479,
-0.1848599166,
0.6647067666,
0.4085007906,
-0.1030559465,
-0.3636480868,
0.850741446,
0.3625463545,
0.0999993682,
0.5856019855,
0.1306874901,
-0.4007740915,
-0.6379385591,
0.112489216,
0.1143358722,
-0.8390769362,
-0.0490512438,
-0.6305257678,
-0.2635791302,
-0.4273667037,
-0.2070889026,
-0.6607752442,
0.0234861169,
-0.7675016522,
-0.3791259229,
0.5324065685,
0.9469473958,
-0.0815059915,
0.2214409113,
-0.8244758248,
-0.2139162272,
0.4736485779,
0.3630056381,
-0.0805604532,
-0.4714759886,
-0.6186000705,
0.019462049,
-0.3824557364,
-0.848070085,
0.5916137099,
0.0155182937,
0.5028743148,
0.6558730006,
0.0443672538,
0.5738622546,
-0.1813640445,
0.6653341651,
0.1168298349,
-1.1813534498,
0.3927844465,
-0.4312698841,
0.5375097394,
0.6190392375,
0.1966433972,
-0.4278497696,
-0.8308837414,
-0.2308311909,
-1.035332799,
0.3828854561,
0.0933397636,
0.3498854339,
-0.1330740899,
0.3085595965,
0.0408931375,
0.5655687451,
-0.6570218801,
-0.009009744,
-0.1801604033,
-0.1433816403,
-0.3845896721,
-0.4786506891,
0.0512014478,
-0.0335022062,
0.5330525041,
-0.010763973,
-0.0517398901,
-0.1145570353,
0.0033510998,
-0.0933638513,
0.213999629,
0.4519548416,
0.4066753387,
-0.2119289786,
0.2190870792,
0.1081589088,
-0.2423530966,
-0.2004171461,
0.0039200522,
0.1348796934,
0.0197744817,
0.5637842417,
0.7529719472,
0.4264243841,
-0.9411851764,
0.5466008186,
-0.2712646425,
-0.4545358717,
-0.2739007771,
-0.1227656528,
0.2382574677,
0.6686909795,
0.5993940234,
-0.0083871782,
0.0893236473,
-0.5604736805,
0.095281899,
0.5583691597,
-0.4513288438,
-0.3326985538,
0.63482517,
-0.1764113456,
0.2256286591,
0.585365653,
-0.1414303035,
-0.3998600245,
0.5950649977,
0.1433225125,
1.1085170507,
0.0487385802,
0.1810451895,
-0.0009034847,
0.5510513186,
-0.3068259954,
0.4116082191,
0.3496381938,
-0.6366029382,
-0.6959835887,
-0.705265224,
-0.6146709919,
-0.0435669087,
-0.7662402987,
0.2525808513,
-0.6074488759,
-0.3169926405,
0.1436113715,
-0.1716716737,
-0.7204695344,
-0.0193473082,
0.3502271175,
0.7030920982,
-0.9116160274,
0.5811650157,
0.5150969028,
-0.2817157507,
-0.5629621744,
0.436301142,
0.1705582589,
-0.7578453422,
0.7430914044,
0.2082961798,
-0.0512387156,
-0.4240550101,
-0.4950405061,
-0.8803877831,
0.778390348,
0.4949175119,
-0.7183077931,
0.1710502654,
0.3001194894,
0.6194749475,
-0.3985604048,
0.1676024795,
0.4990017414,
0.5249039531,
0.2969751954,
-0.504332006,
-0.2935127318,
-0.2056591064,
0.1613676697,
0.4319025278,
-0.6258507371,
1.0275243521,
-0.2096513659,
-0.1183063313,
-0.2873201668,
0.8350436091,
-0.1336739063,
0.3358021677,
0.1631787568,
0.5484105945,
0.9271875024,
-0.0393407941,
1.2105278969,
-0.4855314791,
0.3804863989,
1.2036619186,
-0.3557069302,
1.2624207735,
0.7861084342,
-0.3816505969,
0.5275222063,
0.806819737,
-0.0467818826,
0.5444057584,
0.4751232862,
-0.3067878783,
-0.4807069302,
-0.1803239137,
-0.2273222655,
0.4821451604,
0.420761019,
-0.4216176569,
-0.1065535173,
-0.055283796,
0.0743785352,
0.0598531961,
-0.0154473772,
0.7014710903,
0.3894929886,
-0.2459940463,
-0.1016944274,
-0.0518493056,
0.7761076093,
-0.510563314,
0.3750563562,
-0.1848840266,
0.1286937743,
0.1740124673,
-0.7143365741,
0.5807317495,
0.0594470017,
-0.2988096476,
-0.5313692689,
0.224713698,
-0.0690861046,
-0.9934699535,
0.35779953,
0.6413032413,
-0.1597933471,
-0.1913332492,
-0.3317373693,
0.1645429432,
-0.0567325838,
-0.6252264977,
0.4874708652,
0.8079532981,
0.316015929,
0.5127331018,
0.7461684346,
-0.1627666056,
-0.2019917369,
0.1392884254,
0.7147526145,
-0.7570709586,
-0.4381241798,
-1.1119616032,
0.2401216775,
0.1596765518,
-0.2904807031,
0.8068611026,
0.5576306581,
0.530300796,
0.2003988177,
0.9211120605,
0.6968051791,
0.0683831498,
-0.4205224514,
0.5704711676,
-0.6815817952,
0.7395501137,
-0.072515972,
-0.8152137399,
-0.2725989223,
0.4757521152,
-0.6120596528,
-0.1725984365,
0.5998786092,
0.4912155569,
0.3421309888,
0.1540371329,
0.4575948715,
0.508045733,
0.2175911814,
0.3962925971,
0.6451539397,
-0.2741251886,
0.4775620699,
-0.0401507281,
0.0629922226,
-0.2292509824,
-1.3090410233,
-0.9608805776,
-0.3230434358,
-0.5453355908,
-0.2070097476,
-0.0742311403,
0.7843384147,
0.2822026908,
-0.6396389008,
-0.3154646158,
-0.0526507385,
0.1699111611,
-0.0716656521,
-0.2396172434,
0.2280637771,
-0.5482957959,
-0.7944257855,
0.2894367278,
0.8331933022,
0.226158902,
-0.565310955,
0.173064068,
0.1759251356,
0.6137971282,
0.374668628,
-0.1713687032,
-0.5092291236,
-0.0833241865,
0.1909487247,
-0.2929573357,
0.098584801,
0.5687877536,
-0.3025735915,
0.4969385564,
0.4661029279,
0.938190043,
0.5307610035,
-0.5178235173,
0.8110113144,
-0.8051453233,
0.0143597052,
0.0929815993,
0.4676458538,
0.2034865469,
-0.395359844,
0.0929199979,
0.0674130544,
-0.4142384529,
-0.6609013081,
-0.1406107992,
-0.8683114052,
-0.3919104636,
1.2189836502,
0.0197755583,
-0.2539927959,
0.1623660177,
0.2222793102,
-0.0890423283,
-0.739178896,
0.836713016,
1.2421368361,
0.3235071003,
-0.4425386488,
-1.0257798433,
0.0680182055,
0.3842587173,
-0.607453227,
0.108179152,
0.1600456089,
-0.0084496168,
-0.0594735444,
0.2882187366,
0.0519109778,
-0.1078903079,
0.2428650707,
0.0116309561,
0.2374615222,
0.0161975417,
-0.3120796978,
0.3576398194,
0.1850073785,
-0.0584982596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03718v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03718v1
|
Large Language Models in Law: A Survey
| 2023-11-26T00:48:12 | 2023-11-26T00:48:12 |
Jinqi Lai, Wensheng Gan, Jiayang Wu, Zhenlian Qi, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) has significantly impacted the
traditional judicial industry. Moreover, recently, with the development of
AI-generated content (AIGC), AI and law have found applications in various
domains, including image recognition, automatic text generation, and
interactive chat. With the rapid emergence and growing popularity of large
models, it is evident that AI will drive transformation in the traditional
judicial industry. However, the application of legal large language models
(LLMs) is still in its nascent stage. Several challenges need to be addressed.
In this paper, we aim to provide a comprehensive survey of legal LLMs. We not
only conduct an extensive survey of LLMs, but also expose their applications in
the judicial system. We first provide an overview of AI technologies in the
legal field and showcase the recent research in LLMs. Then, we discuss the
practical implementation presented by legal LLMs, such as providing legal
advice to users and assisting judges during trials. In addition, we explore the
limitations of legal LLMs, including data, algorithms, and judicial practice.
Finally, we summarize practical recommendations and propose future development
directions to address these challenges.
|
[
-0.1516417712,
-0.8786461949,
0.9498178959,
-0.0113456054,
-0.3403011858,
-0.0589093119,
-0.517313242,
-0.5359752178,
0.0298617613,
1.0359100103,
-0.2945118546,
-0.4649578035,
-0.6658597589,
-0.055680126,
-0.7817696929,
0.7112460732,
0.1180710196,
0.4011909664,
-0.2261911333,
-0.1981794238,
-0.6091273427,
-0.7176004648,
-0.6154901385,
-0.1674544364,
0.2686391771,
0.2124900371,
0.6073837876,
0.3886477351,
0.8191846609,
0.4961374998,
-0.3211464584,
-0.0342233963,
-0.1274522841,
0.2799683809,
-0.0582804047,
-0.7133768201,
-0.3230283856,
-0.0362167284,
0.729962647,
0.6952801943,
-0.4762051702,
0.0126742749,
-0.5927652121,
0.7360516787,
-0.5410162807,
0.242111966,
-0.7067878842,
0.2636756301,
-0.3412924409,
0.1538407505,
-0.3816985488,
-0.3090581298,
0.0624721944,
-0.3801562786,
-0.3640537858,
0.3728592098,
0.4113207161,
0.468888998,
-0.7723401785,
-0.7139496803,
-1.0449331999,
0.7085847855,
-1.0866123438,
0.3414959013,
0.240420267,
0.5409058332,
-0.5162169933,
-0.8267017603,
-0.705532372,
-0.7941772342,
0.1310990453,
-0.1388624609,
-0.3453216553,
0.1103733629,
0.2569491565,
0.1658963263,
-0.4338608086,
0.7163794637,
-0.2982866466,
-0.0096087791,
0.9225276113,
0.4249442518,
0.4368949533,
0.1230176687,
0.3440633714,
0.1326078027,
-0.7496340275,
-0.0429369807,
0.4169384539,
0.2653533816,
-0.0347480699,
0.8421951532,
0.1160904467,
0.7483336329,
-0.1014445275,
-0.3278066814,
0.0154308723,
-0.2866384685,
-0.2438683063,
-0.0128991958,
1.1132193804,
0.1141145825,
0.4507718086,
0.2824141085,
-0.2885083854,
-0.5166227221,
0.2113120854,
-0.4747045338,
0.3562723696,
0.3361698389,
-0.6478005648,
-0.1801011264,
-0.0405486338,
-0.594948709,
-1.0016731024,
-0.5129535794,
-0.0850557685,
-0.1137054563,
-0.1607390046,
0.2045417279,
0.0578544438,
0.5241745114,
0.5076322556,
-0.7879013419,
0.2862238288,
0.8517010808,
0.5020496249,
0.3328775167,
0.1778221726,
-0.5827417374,
0.0309231337,
-0.5386508703,
0.4094819129,
-0.5244674683,
-0.299910903,
0.5722859502,
0.0034683771,
0.2560998499,
-0.7960362434,
0.5127025247,
-0.6782512665,
-0.1833304167,
0.1083836332,
-0.6771277785,
-0.1164469421,
0.4434821606,
-0.877669394,
0.3526248038,
-0.2174582332,
-0.329407841,
0.4321244657,
-0.8972392082,
-0.7824006081,
0.3620581627,
-0.5297302604,
-0.6429944038,
0.2942890525,
0.0718801171,
0.5192142725,
-0.6582803726,
0.5762395859,
-0.2770369947,
-0.2577642202,
0.337223202,
-0.2899075449,
0.9140505791,
0.3561867774,
-0.2118483484,
0.3438470066,
-0.5499360561,
-0.3581033051,
0.2659454942,
-0.2522820532,
-0.1147507802,
0.4226943851,
-0.0556326136,
0.1861155778,
0.130131647,
-0.4153579175,
0.238421008,
-0.274528265,
0.8272804022,
0.666344285,
-0.1137796864,
0.2586657703,
-0.0221429449,
0.6735421419,
0.0002151373,
-0.0033124695,
-0.0049140761,
-0.5584098697,
-0.5391172767,
-0.0763620809,
0.47954759,
0.6145854592,
-0.5222943425,
0.4779757857,
-0.3587963283,
-0.5072209835,
-0.5370476246,
0.2536121011,
-0.1898845285,
-0.2473637313,
-0.0553001836,
0.0954788178,
-0.4498862326,
-1.0301969051,
-0.3307847381,
-0.4588594437,
0.1475244612,
0.5322564244,
0.5712544322,
-0.2715104818,
0.6714767814,
0.0287904255,
-0.2739619315,
-0.5111089945,
-0.0300098527,
0.3831116259,
0.0916321948,
0.6064931154,
-1.0548036098,
-0.3667615652,
0.3576204777,
-0.7666650414,
0.0403037928,
-0.3366068006,
0.3189283609,
0.1382620186,
0.7691076398,
-0.783028841,
0.30326581,
0.1770513952,
-0.3230049312,
0.5235245228,
-0.2755469978,
0.1082794741,
-0.7735426426,
-0.0625441521,
0.141367808,
-0.4369362593,
-0.7052664757,
0.3019942343,
-0.0759693161,
-0.0281433519,
-0.5737014413,
0.5432620049,
-0.4623040557,
-0.1740754545,
-0.5270323157,
0.1254152954,
-0.625423193,
0.0122705279,
-0.141352728,
0.6185911894,
0.4453846216,
-0.5301624537,
0.8116109371,
0.199927032,
-0.3881314993,
0.4216486514,
-0.4708573222,
-0.069564566,
-0.127486825,
0.2190554589,
-0.4502161741,
-0.4593936503,
0.3077203929,
0.0376007259,
0.4529513419,
-0.1828273386,
-0.9290671945,
-0.7200154662,
-0.1030275673,
0.3572382629,
0.7028993964,
-0.1643514782,
0.8869277835,
0.6850628853,
-0.4247821569,
-0.5587288141,
-0.7629646659,
0.6144469976,
-0.3043479621,
-0.3859685361,
-0.0829388574,
0.0452024788,
-0.7858937383,
0.1227135211,
0.432014972,
0.0460943393,
0.1952583343,
0.271068722,
0.0007291796,
-0.3262845576,
0.2136995643,
-0.1235565692,
0.4089891911,
0.4667055011,
-0.1803708225,
0.5060930252,
-0.0913369134,
-0.6314288974,
-0.6039558649,
0.3132033646,
0.8161937594,
-0.3149519265,
0.5757559538,
0.137960121,
-0.3544017673,
-0.1663965434,
-0.8052537441,
0.3355076313,
-0.4784881473,
0.547100544,
-0.0448976755,
-1.208863616,
0.3840080202,
-0.2781318724,
0.3025458753,
0.6454848647,
1.1040275097,
0.0381864533,
0.748560667,
0.6858029962,
-0.4916413426,
0.6021397114,
0.0647444278,
0.4993765354,
-0.410779506,
-0.1603907943,
-0.6907150745,
0.0361295566,
-0.9004125595,
-0.0900337696,
0.3458237648,
-0.3674022853,
-0.2284457237,
0.1008177325,
-0.0012849333,
0.3353680968,
0.7531399131,
-0.2417088002,
0.2966845036,
-0.2358635515,
0.0501935519,
0.440887779,
-0.5409967899,
-0.6118274927,
1.1950472593,
0.5210377574,
0.723764956,
0.1731354594,
0.5721337199,
0.5034393668,
0.1020361856,
-1.0136500597,
0.8138219714,
-0.4584324062,
-0.7019308805,
-0.4667996168,
-0.5330312252,
-0.7973105311,
-0.0407199971,
-0.3660656512,
-0.6080057025,
-0.0797411576,
-0.1508813947,
-0.4777419269,
0.5498327017,
-0.2706848383,
0.4194460213,
-0.5750446916,
-0.3341721594,
-0.3386541009,
-0.5314965844,
0.487149328,
-0.3496642411,
0.4674934447,
-0.1176483184,
0.1985122859,
0.7223786712,
-0.5915926099,
0.6958942413,
-0.126977548,
-0.4054020047,
0.7450508475,
-0.2876490951,
0.6348963976,
-0.0875465944,
-0.1423051208,
-0.063848041,
0.0274749566,
-0.0402878076,
-0.4575509429,
0.5944759846,
-0.5018905997,
-0.951926291,
-0.4575722218,
-0.7708097696,
-0.1413264275,
0.1929941326,
-0.297911346,
-0.0480189137,
-0.1943374127,
0.3287635148,
0.2852715552,
-0.3506880403,
0.6104348898,
0.5904269814,
-0.2286224067,
-0.2090140283,
0.7555040121,
0.1660376191,
-0.2793676257,
0.0201046877,
0.1336930245,
-0.3642763197,
-1.0767310858,
-0.4225258231,
0.3741272986,
-0.7208183408,
-0.0674022138,
-0.314640969,
-0.3672331572,
-0.5683239102,
0.0483998545,
-0.195399642,
-0.2322061956,
-0.0951252878,
0.2507442534,
0.2727740705,
1.0800104141,
0.3092986941,
0.1376376301,
-0.8040705919,
0.2223237753,
0.3442004621,
0.4299807549,
-0.18341811,
-0.5085541606,
-0.0363979861,
-0.0807133541,
0.0010211815,
-0.3574855924,
0.2112796158,
-0.0452566929,
0.7110692859,
0.4994222522,
-0.180187732,
0.3984448016,
-0.9618150592,
0.8468465209,
0.1533431113,
-0.6823909283,
0.313682735,
-0.3508995771,
-0.0342626683,
0.3711829185,
0.2291252017,
-0.6129909754,
-0.4362488985,
-0.1339717507,
-0.6439656615,
0.5800581574,
0.0442536734,
0.6546095014,
0.353738755,
0.6627290845,
-0.1805006415,
0.3462978005,
-0.7884562016,
0.1357013285,
0.3190805018,
-0.3573079407,
0.1212738305,
-0.1885902435,
0.0143718161,
-0.2323536873,
0.6910201311,
0.1002413779,
0.1003967598,
-0.3127296567,
-0.0979897678,
-0.0722864792,
0.5260420442,
0.7659697533,
0.5212824941,
0.142467916,
-0.2446876764,
0.0904733017,
-0.290086627,
0.2935962379,
0.1019217148,
-0.2880944908,
-0.1595362425,
0.5690035224,
0.6909742951,
-0.3173580468,
-1.1467791796,
0.5748061538,
0.0479793474,
-0.5315791368,
-0.8463567495,
0.0898157209,
0.1957278848,
0.6604598761,
0.2797127068,
-0.3897810876,
0.2121984065,
-0.9088274837,
-0.1514614522,
0.7478834987,
-0.2844797075,
0.2848251462,
0.6761746407,
0.0275151469,
-0.4237769246,
0.6119821072,
-0.0977825448,
-0.3637495339,
0.6542349458,
0.3160183132,
0.6885570884,
0.2883702219,
-0.2332343757,
-0.0923970342,
0.2934710085,
-0.3981004953,
0.1140925363,
0.2329246849,
-0.3984567225,
-0.3798976541,
-0.5127446055,
-0.5353382826,
0.2849597335,
-0.1047612354,
0.3257255852,
-0.6815105081,
-0.2893260121,
0.1557506174,
0.0330236964,
-0.6222245693,
-0.0547838993,
0.5065861344,
0.7523412704,
-0.4100728333,
0.743670404,
0.7901616096,
-0.3905932009,
-0.4292427897,
-0.0824785978,
0.2179986984,
-0.6393761635,
0.5528795123,
-0.1505420208,
0.0304814782,
-0.2170672417,
-0.9919384122,
-0.2801379263,
0.9129543304,
0.183683157,
-1.0035840273,
-0.1386538148,
0.670189023,
0.7931959629,
-0.4050422311,
0.1844318956,
0.6317213178,
0.6648353934,
0.0709507614,
-0.8825604916,
-0.0726679042,
-0.3289036751,
0.0524739847,
0.2187837064,
-0.471947968,
0.7316095233,
-0.0316247009,
0.0236602295,
0.3179485202,
0.5677137375,
0.1860572547,
0.2662070394,
0.484354198,
0.3988452554,
0.6233249307,
-0.0198017228,
1.1207393408,
-0.3046830595,
0.1121283621,
0.9250887036,
-0.715577364,
0.7171338201,
0.4511269927,
-0.2023548931,
0.2805809975,
0.3543212414,
-0.6152552962,
-0.0911405385,
0.7806517482,
-0.2702105939,
-0.3207244873,
-0.3653877079,
-0.0858322829,
0.6077181101,
0.3634679615,
-0.5566034317,
-0.024302138,
0.1085650399,
-0.0762881786,
0.2625518143,
-0.6716887355,
0.8750228286,
0.0868573263,
-0.4981409013,
-0.0974869356,
0.4548109174,
0.5388556719,
-0.4968630672,
-0.186856389,
-0.0753610432,
0.0719535425,
-0.0057417448,
-0.8786033392,
-0.030863924,
0.3253744245,
0.2644003034,
0.0422660112,
0.6533092856,
-0.1648014337,
-0.8072243929,
0.274963975,
0.5364783406,
0.2056986094,
0.0281078015,
-0.6211403608,
0.0018774408,
-0.4706938565,
-0.152191788,
0.143257767,
0.6688382626,
-0.4242828488,
0.9101680517,
0.4592166543,
0.3372600377,
0.2997077405,
0.2005022168,
0.8833476901,
-0.963310957,
-0.1961231381,
-0.9390587807,
0.304602623,
-0.12185359,
0.0070972322,
0.4247116745,
0.3420180678,
0.5929067135,
0.0338287503,
0.8516565561,
-0.0615198426,
0.2688153982,
-0.7997560501,
0.825135529,
-0.5974625349,
0.2918397784,
-0.1615389287,
-0.7831920981,
-0.6270595193,
0.2412844598,
-0.453289181,
0.1810538024,
0.2753885984,
0.5450354815,
-0.0077169635,
-0.12708731,
0.6186255813,
0.2334938049,
0.471151948,
0.4016688466,
1.0115941763,
-0.2086615115,
0.4676008821,
0.2397296429,
0.3060301542,
-0.5796613693,
-0.6180397272,
-0.9796182513,
-0.2085198909,
-0.1056348756,
0.0024637377,
-0.0130231436,
1.0971077681,
0.5337244272,
-0.9709247351,
-0.5056369901,
-0.1102012619,
-0.0929077491,
0.3195436299,
-0.0509335436,
0.1330123395,
-0.3196551502,
-0.7538791895,
0.3886897266,
0.1909331083,
0.0278841369,
-0.4048106968,
-0.0410546735,
-0.5125948787,
0.2514544725,
0.6836791039,
0.3680028319,
-1.016792655,
-0.2457692474,
-0.3272013664,
-0.1918350458,
0.1252070963,
1.093431592,
-0.2305611223,
0.2457534969,
0.2686697543,
1.0276662111,
0.3642130792,
-0.2646304667,
0.5810288191,
-0.1900264025,
0.2274184078,
0.4061945081,
0.8085776567,
0.0034319079,
-0.1994318068,
0.4401946962,
-0.0691245943,
-0.547326088,
-0.6401209831,
0.2043583095,
-0.7878862023,
-0.5244250298,
1.0060483217,
-0.0897901505,
-0.3036260307,
-0.1124086156,
-0.0996798426,
0.1098703891,
-0.1873077899,
0.5850009322,
1.0140862465,
0.0624872036,
-0.2579962015,
-0.9466421604,
0.2033869028,
0.2572453022,
-0.9358680248,
-0.0409777239,
0.7492938042,
0.1118513793,
0.1423421055,
0.4815115035,
-0.2740696073,
0.1851543188,
-0.2093004882,
0.0871282518,
-0.0813296586,
-0.2165305912,
-0.7870726585,
0.2506916225,
0.4669843912,
0.3881144226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15131v1
|
Localizing Lying in Llama: Understanding Instructed Dishonesty on True-False Questions Through Prompting, Probing, and Patching
| 2023-11-25T22:41:23 | 2023-11-25T22:41:23 |
James Campbell, Richard Ren, Phillip Guo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate significant knowledge through their
outputs, though it is often unclear whether false outputs are due to a lack of
knowledge or dishonesty. In this paper, we investigate instructed dishonesty,
wherein we explicitly prompt LLaMA-2-70b-chat to lie. We perform prompt
engineering to find which prompts best induce lying behavior, and then use
mechanistic interpretability approaches to localize where in the network this
behavior occurs. Using linear probing and activation patching, we localize five
layers that appear especially important for lying. We then find just 46
attention heads within these layers that enable us to causally intervene such
that the lying model instead answers honestly. We show that these interventions
work robustly across many prompts and dataset splits. Overall, our work
contributes a greater understanding of dishonesty in LLMs so that we may hope
to prevent it.
|
[
0.0457304642,
-1.0306574106,
0.9007233977,
0.3680862486,
0.0738848075,
0.13227579,
0.0392083004,
-0.4307261109,
0.2620827854,
0.8443604708,
-0.7420484424,
-0.2721809149,
-0.4881519377,
0.0421037413,
-0.1073650569,
0.9289533496,
-0.2047048956,
-0.0075364397,
-0.4429523945,
-0.0278819259,
-0.7770258784,
-0.3944808841,
-0.6606135964,
-0.6352280378,
0.6075688004,
0.7193267941,
0.5848222971,
0.8240565062,
0.3850102127,
0.2988091707,
-0.0138629843,
0.2772180736,
-0.835467875,
0.1735105813,
-0.2226193398,
-1.2074307203,
-0.2374149114,
0.2730215788,
0.1511168778,
0.5541420579,
-0.1970135272,
0.4016680717,
-0.3064976037,
0.2406644076,
-0.6574278474,
0.1821318418,
-0.7288887501,
-0.1850762516,
-0.1779577285,
-0.1339923143,
-0.6106244326,
-0.4018314779,
0.1619095206,
-0.3684849739,
0.3066518009,
-0.2483005673,
0.8169887662,
0.7360345125,
-0.696721971,
-0.5168071389,
-0.6369475126,
0.8077722192,
-0.7461343408,
-0.2783074081,
0.6376169324,
0.4094886482,
-0.2379028499,
-0.5603536963,
-0.4570885003,
-0.2679727376,
-0.2988372743,
-0.1872827113,
-0.3051727712,
-0.1232193261,
0.1901292056,
0.2253178358,
-0.3811242878,
0.2591751218,
-0.0968312323,
-0.4995733798,
0.4735243022,
0.0292379819,
0.3515468538,
0.068418853,
-0.3996786475,
-0.0440518484,
-0.9775711298,
0.2227073908,
0.6304504871,
0.0656344891,
-0.1058852971,
0.5735459924,
-0.1879722923,
0.4420417845,
0.2122621089,
-0.2131341845,
-0.0622804537,
0.0167920291,
-0.1416769773,
0.4756637514,
0.4612392485,
0.2342943698,
0.2566477358,
0.194635585,
-0.3158082366,
0.4606658816,
0.2549468875,
-0.5116829872,
0.0616027005,
0.4370088875,
-0.2418447882,
-0.721365273,
-0.1285640001,
-0.2408206463,
-0.6920411587,
-0.2099316865,
0.3264030814,
-0.0805649012,
-0.3574536145,
0.3035666943,
0.0132121537,
0.5796277523,
-0.0236209296,
-0.4992032349,
0.244186148,
0.7271515131,
0.3972120881,
0.3100962341,
-0.4077574611,
-0.5861283541,
0.236987412,
-0.6849017143,
0.7220403552,
-0.599603653,
0.0327987745,
0.2218936384,
0.0821976811,
0.1763847172,
-0.5139193535,
0.5670315027,
-0.5766192675,
0.2655258179,
-0.666008532,
-0.196485579,
-0.4560008943,
0.3387256563,
-0.5488108993,
0.9797348976,
-0.2511727214,
-0.7078963518,
-0.2485336959,
-0.6007813215,
-0.2521966994,
-0.3344014883,
0.0089695593,
-0.2133550197,
0.1641778499,
0.5724749565,
0.6195158362,
-0.0181326419,
0.3852959871,
-0.0225588176,
-0.5757498145,
0.6848967075,
-0.5852172971,
0.9915904999,
-0.1577306986,
-0.5464972258,
-0.2160211802,
-0.4680542648,
-0.4610289931,
0.3616519868,
0.0977716744,
-0.464246273,
-0.0605225004,
-0.8516831398,
-0.1702489704,
0.4475058317,
-0.576605022,
0.2380569875,
-0.5873488784,
0.3096930981,
0.8169982433,
0.1324198544,
0.3914877772,
-0.2717316747,
0.5391752124,
0.3238755465,
0.2439671606,
-0.3287393153,
-0.5075547099,
-0.9375927448,
0.0585104637,
-0.0094147986,
0.5840975642,
-0.9322024584,
-0.2473467439,
-0.2094730884,
-0.4526052177,
-0.7982673049,
-0.2141015977,
0.7417131662,
0.7705268264,
0.2136507481,
0.0856903046,
-0.2127936929,
-1.1865459681,
-0.1963383257,
-0.2704739571,
0.0413293615,
0.369335711,
0.3677556217,
-0.2614812851,
0.983401835,
-0.4573512375,
-0.3495506346,
-0.0104013467,
0.3547853827,
0.3193726242,
0.2713059783,
0.4619331658,
-0.4642544389,
-0.2874012887,
-0.0702973977,
-0.9207963347,
-0.3305949569,
-0.4350127876,
-0.0050397227,
0.2201323807,
0.3646782637,
-0.6392846704,
0.4303547144,
0.7199439406,
-0.4218157232,
0.6147255301,
-0.0487825088,
-0.1093087569,
-0.7484266162,
-0.3071031868,
-0.3100916147,
-0.3394051194,
-0.7360355854,
0.0497140139,
-0.1286930293,
0.2577691674,
-0.2813281715,
0.3991805613,
-0.7483465075,
-0.2230508327,
-0.2096631676,
0.1760797352,
0.0930050164,
0.4910082817,
-0.2763052583,
0.8433203101,
0.666334033,
-0.386017859,
0.4815544486,
0.3964334726,
-0.118059516,
0.5144317746,
-0.7806982398,
0.579210937,
-0.1893483996,
0.6275933981,
-1.1260052919,
-0.3060016036,
0.5131078959,
-0.6791661382,
0.1780987382,
-0.366291225,
-0.2584576309,
-0.0615048334,
-0.356839031,
0.459531337,
0.2031522542,
-0.7313057184,
0.5195200443,
0.3279235959,
-0.033641737,
-1.1801800728,
-0.8405302763,
0.2117215693,
-0.1211611032,
-0.6321641207,
0.1850628406,
0.2254393101,
-0.3874919415,
-0.2036610544,
-0.1750858426,
0.0573804267,
-0.0208316352,
0.3254696727,
0.1415203959,
-0.4092573524,
-0.0804354697,
0.0801575556,
-0.1971281171,
0.5547289252,
-0.0230781473,
0.5353794098,
-0.1565904766,
-0.4722842872,
-0.5933663249,
0.302323848,
0.4980913401,
-0.3554256558,
0.8070001602,
0.3494606316,
-0.3410583436,
-0.3597440124,
-0.9465888739,
-0.4679262042,
-0.5331782103,
0.1061386764,
-0.4349944592,
-0.8117167354,
0.7707123756,
-0.1191365346,
0.0301744211,
-0.1077120975,
0.474494338,
-0.2546384633,
0.910866797,
0.6798328757,
-0.1794397682,
-0.0926557779,
-0.1035569534,
0.404371798,
-0.6971107125,
-0.1618068814,
-0.3643983305,
-0.3326227963,
-0.7497803569,
-0.6036832929,
0.3442276418,
-0.1570477188,
-0.0814041868,
-0.0562769212,
-0.4068502486,
1.0238016844,
0.3090212643,
0.3292804062,
0.1299231797,
-0.1748580933,
0.0161653124,
0.0442079529,
-0.528847456,
-0.6481932998,
0.7792229056,
0.727196157,
0.5984064937,
0.1571055055,
0.516993165,
0.033905305,
0.3106927276,
-0.7121021152,
0.568979919,
0.2726108134,
-0.4437725246,
-0.2968394458,
-0.2430635691,
-0.9601629376,
-0.1176151857,
0.3586379588,
-0.6188839078,
0.2566580772,
0.186869815,
-0.1260497272,
0.1475488991,
-0.6545081735,
0.3910084963,
0.005337412,
-0.0655745715,
-0.184932068,
-0.8942515254,
0.7192940712,
0.198579371,
0.175982818,
-0.1358531713,
-0.0251633283,
0.529682219,
-0.1129190996,
1.5662921667,
-0.2274438292,
-0.5780719519,
0.2321174145,
0.5465196371,
1.0446870327,
0.1800477952,
0.0303152893,
0.2701200247,
-0.1548093706,
-0.5199811459,
-0.6054618359,
0.7822986245,
-0.8048834801,
-0.8639764786,
-0.3867588639,
-0.6274733543,
-0.3359683752,
-0.1117637157,
0.0317291431,
0.3262132108,
0.1155526116,
-0.1449350119,
1.2732608318,
-0.4886834919,
0.2876203656,
0.5340570211,
-0.1776649356,
0.1660279185,
0.9551281333,
-0.1071994081,
0.2289553732,
0.2366928607,
0.3745602071,
-0.180681169,
-0.0982080624,
-0.0975513384,
0.831117034,
-0.9766540527,
-0.337593019,
-0.208439067,
-0.1622254103,
-0.2452384979,
-0.1632832885,
-0.5569401979,
-0.1518339664,
-0.3537822068,
-0.4035305977,
0.2935859263,
1.0047705173,
-0.0452513918,
0.5796445012,
-0.3884458542,
0.2680731714,
0.515216589,
0.1733773947,
-0.0678752288,
-0.5890057087,
0.1358540803,
0.3690659702,
0.0073922738,
-1.1739810705,
0.0688192025,
-0.1929032803,
0.5585736036,
0.443100512,
0.2115489244,
0.6147009134,
-0.3179982007,
0.8696739674,
-0.1356965452,
-0.9420206547,
0.7185916901,
-0.4050140977,
0.1468855739,
0.119144246,
0.4862224758,
-0.6380357742,
-0.5992677808,
-0.4972495437,
-0.5850172043,
0.6737259626,
0.0304623805,
0.6097673774,
0.1081889048,
0.6384851336,
0.1205306649,
0.0142769404,
-0.9850291014,
-0.612783432,
-0.0175862592,
-0.0138257137,
0.2708151042,
-0.8018863201,
-0.6203218102,
0.176886633,
0.6891170144,
-0.2801899016,
0.5142998695,
0.3001859486,
-0.34049806,
-0.1676386148,
-0.0582889207,
0.8822548389,
0.8707180023,
0.1811383516,
0.3896912336,
0.0884642825,
-0.380961895,
0.1098037735,
-0.3998577893,
-0.1915161908,
0.0508330055,
0.6887632608,
0.723711431,
-0.0606749766,
-0.2360263169,
0.750825882,
0.0262345411,
0.044146888,
-0.2261466235,
-0.0660635158,
0.170029074,
0.355083257,
0.2219240516,
-0.2707722485,
-0.0749416426,
-0.508564055,
-0.110015735,
0.4138686657,
-0.3452157974,
-0.3643572032,
0.3017552197,
0.0786945671,
-0.3086509705,
0.7954447269,
0.056451235,
-0.8220671415,
0.6473022699,
0.6086541414,
0.4489590824,
-0.7087268829,
0.7401842475,
0.2059822828,
0.6640505195,
0.1334744096,
0.2926111817,
0.1499496847,
-0.8919708133,
-0.8191552758,
-0.0943087265,
-0.3610317111,
0.2078958005,
-0.6369281411,
0.0317531414,
-0.1319578141,
0.1494100988,
-0.3519566953,
-0.1546568424,
-0.4367427528,
0.0480083749,
0.2567746043,
0.7102060914,
-0.9319335222,
0.5308048725,
0.4149329364,
-0.241800487,
-0.9330654144,
0.1138844639,
0.150255844,
-1.3502796888,
0.4464097917,
0.3187297285,
-0.2797190547,
-0.0734895319,
-1.2811920643,
-0.8634906411,
1.0974203348,
0.6242797375,
-0.3278564513,
0.1833509654,
0.6658716798,
0.3877248466,
-0.2773990929,
0.3472396135,
0.695219636,
0.3557402194,
0.0496294312,
-0.882119298,
0.3843921721,
0.1774278879,
-0.0913357362,
-0.2237134725,
-0.7072803378,
0.6700442433,
-0.3882721066,
-0.0817343816,
-0.2700382173,
0.5594701767,
0.3221063614,
0.2722166181,
0.4009716213,
0.3271754384,
1.1245988607,
-0.0724881738,
0.9441120028,
0.1839496046,
0.0603193119,
1.2568948269,
-0.3206999898,
0.5147925019,
0.6765143871,
0.1875263005,
0.7735512853,
0.7026959658,
0.1514116675,
0.4463093281,
0.3124842346,
-0.1972022355,
-0.1788339466,
-0.5992600322,
-0.0834954977,
0.6628590226,
0.3881848752,
-0.044320751,
-0.1229503974,
0.0266572367,
0.4418773055,
-0.1473830342,
-0.2715013325,
0.6524974108,
0.0538828,
-0.678098917,
0.5646708012,
-0.014793084,
0.3494617343,
-0.4641986191,
-0.238954246,
-0.7781487107,
-0.1875000596,
-0.2358368337,
-0.7297905087,
0.1103103012,
-0.0951445252,
-0.0931185409,
-0.3104947805,
0.6490718126,
-0.2497290671,
-0.2336251587,
0.0859756768,
0.3877584636,
0.3232549727,
-0.2132098228,
-0.4097338617,
0.0656742007,
0.155955255,
-0.3853163719,
0.1248948053,
0.707128644,
-0.39150244,
1.0539854765,
0.948618114,
0.0975448936,
0.1303580254,
0.0426906087,
0.8036363721,
-0.2520020306,
-0.2603534162,
-0.8126296997,
0.624217093,
0.049349077,
-0.078247197,
0.5238627791,
0.0191403162,
0.7583343387,
0.1365210563,
0.4062687457,
0.3606082797,
0.4158402681,
-0.4883329868,
0.5888854861,
-0.1601335853,
0.6483151317,
0.2112922519,
-0.7761545181,
-0.0139858807,
0.5605885983,
-0.4219126999,
-0.394913584,
0.6792659163,
1.1277270317,
0.0504337102,
-0.1360297054,
0.2884736657,
0.8946571946,
0.3022854626,
0.4198436141,
1.1487697363,
-0.5120583177,
0.5893937349,
-0.3900460303,
-0.276935637,
-0.0320878252,
-0.8890317678,
-0.8640037775,
-0.4233436882,
-0.2904120088,
-0.3002121449,
-0.2628090382,
0.3197066486,
0.3565534651,
-0.5904421806,
-0.1530267447,
0.1716495007,
0.422031939,
-0.1654094905,
-0.2683932781,
0.2560692132,
-0.2698239684,
-0.4151218832,
0.6151872873,
0.0298528261,
-0.0880633593,
-0.6053809524,
0.0273846351,
-0.1551903486,
0.4410870075,
0.2552452385,
-0.0612144545,
-0.9639954567,
-0.4377968907,
0.1455638558,
-0.1454526484,
-0.0290206242,
0.677005887,
-0.8420847058,
0.2561047077,
0.0583474971,
0.6564438343,
0.3611281216,
-0.0987370983,
0.783219099,
-1.1794176102,
-0.0744407028,
0.3297771513,
0.1046767831,
0.3942729533,
-0.8873489499,
0.5447873473,
-0.0707920492,
-0.7269624472,
-1.1376821995,
0.2719393671,
-0.8489332795,
-0.2440832257,
1.2447994947,
-0.3228159845,
-0.3660365641,
-0.1692786962,
-0.311024338,
0.3211016059,
-0.0653860569,
0.9916499257,
0.8647654653,
0.0333824232,
-0.1092726365,
-0.7455570102,
0.4813523889,
0.544336915,
-0.6633294821,
0.2820883989,
0.4563074112,
0.3649362326,
0.2823695838,
0.4819687009,
0.1824396104,
0.2310868353,
-0.1809686571,
-0.1232601553,
-0.1039398536,
-0.3341888487,
-0.4235638678,
-0.1986857206,
-0.2185501456,
-0.2217027247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15110v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15110v1
|
Relevance feedback strategies for recall-oriented neural information retrieval
| 2023-11-25T19:50:41 | 2023-11-25T19:50:41 |
Timo Kats, Peter van der Putten, Jan Scholtes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In a number of information retrieval applications (e.g., patent search,
literature review, due diligence, etc.), preventing false negatives is more
important than preventing false positives. However, approaches designed to
reduce review effort (like "technology assisted review") can create false
negatives, since they are often based on active learning systems that exclude
documents automatically based on user feedback. Therefore, this research
proposes a more recall-oriented approach to reducing review effort. More
specifically, through iteratively re-ranking the relevance rankings based on
user feedback, which is also referred to as relevance feedback. In our proposed
method, the relevance rankings are produced by a BERT-based dense-vector search
and the relevance feedback is based on cumulatively summing the queried and
selected embeddings. Our results show that this method can reduce review effort
between 17.85% and 59.04%, compared to a baseline approach (of no feedback),
given a fixed recall target
|
[
-0.3750409186,
-0.5017761588,
0.3096143305,
0.0599155612,
-0.1624205559,
-0.2578935325,
-0.2287181318,
0.0464724414,
0.7329509854,
0.3113519549,
-0.1891618222,
-0.6015415788,
-0.0305825043,
-0.2095951438,
-0.585095644,
0.9536224008,
0.2608121634,
0.0641126707,
0.0336819105,
-0.0627450868,
-0.7430656552,
-0.8437271714,
-0.3657265007,
-0.2635961473,
0.9506548047,
0.3131920993,
0.3335757852,
-0.0959113613,
0.5230731964,
0.1121942103,
-0.3820798695,
-0.0621387772,
-0.7108314633,
0.2138318568,
-0.3213129342,
-0.5413597226,
-0.2077020705,
0.0384708755,
0.5042255521,
0.3870063424,
-0.2664821148,
0.0948941261,
0.2716710567,
0.9724627137,
-0.8955042362,
-0.4023721218,
-0.5329912305,
0.2704558372,
0.1009946242,
-0.7442623973,
-0.6516298056,
-0.6315492988,
0.3247648478,
-0.4423546493,
0.3895365,
0.0033450571,
0.6983013749,
-0.0261780918,
-0.1159458682,
-0.0800274983,
-0.7753973007,
0.8022664785,
-0.6418119073,
0.2360003442,
0.4247027934,
0.0856542513,
0.1137614399,
-0.4703314006,
-0.4499622583,
-0.2736000419,
0.0079316767,
0.3861626983,
0.217580989,
0.0242212415,
0.2199469954,
0.1582377404,
-0.2881599963,
-0.2254183292,
-0.5014215112,
-0.4379263818,
0.416382134,
-0.1779371202,
-0.151058346,
-0.3442281783,
-0.2767263949,
-0.2238218337,
-0.9602627158,
0.1482203454,
0.0182218291,
0.2004119903,
0.9367159605,
0.7875504494,
-0.1267200559,
0.4396016598,
0.076606147,
0.1655191779,
0.4265773594,
-0.4683853984,
0.0399695672,
0.1348146051,
0.2771766484,
0.6124082208,
-0.2196093202,
-0.2007854879,
-0.5742650032,
-0.1503595859,
0.8758963943,
-0.7725441456,
0.1678585112,
0.1430820376,
-1.083327651,
-0.1637486368,
0.1467010081,
-0.4846460223,
-0.2864625454,
-0.2994357646,
1.0571026802,
-0.5023050904,
0.0225346703,
-0.1982096434,
-0.3015956283,
0.13788715,
0.7499376535,
-0.5155360103,
0.0337755978,
0.4353454411,
0.7674587369,
-0.0588726029,
-0.0271562096,
-0.641307652,
0.0759582371,
-0.1619613022,
0.6948959231,
-0.3508858085,
-0.6508054733,
0.0587711297,
-0.3150129616,
0.0822591931,
-0.7528613806,
0.4730523229,
-0.8655002117,
0.185117349,
-0.7243044972,
-0.5246739388,
-0.6828708649,
0.6948881745,
-0.5579401255,
1.0485574007,
-0.0778816417,
-0.6233116984,
0.3784222901,
-0.2932658792,
-0.6753852367,
-0.1829613,
-0.2194064707,
-0.3661698103,
0.1918828785,
0.3166925907,
0.1421934962,
-0.2341577113,
0.2352092117,
-0.228213802,
-0.7637314796,
-0.2310947925,
-0.0627359748,
0.429687798,
0.2536480725,
-0.6925612092,
0.2908644378,
-0.4358867705,
0.3057561815,
-0.2931766212,
-0.6071036458,
-0.4766471982,
-0.0505243801,
-0.2514815331,
0.1108581871,
0.0413042456,
-0.5305341482,
0.3526654243,
-0.2206055522,
0.199069649,
0.6058098674,
0.1141340286,
0.3533035219,
-0.5602321625,
0.1690518409,
-0.0779103041,
0.2979696393,
-0.088639386,
-0.4427347183,
-1.0460562706,
0.30290851,
0.5853099227,
0.5215705633,
-0.8620220423,
0.495470345,
-0.1215514988,
-0.3479070961,
-0.5798687935,
0.2024303675,
0.3603130281,
0.6906063557,
0.4685310721,
-0.7026904821,
-0.1566192806,
-0.7162475586,
-0.0949334651,
-0.5576019883,
-0.0806465223,
0.6468554139,
0.1733794212,
-0.0479951873,
0.7452228665,
-0.1225886047,
-0.6360003948,
-0.0452910773,
0.2631066442,
0.4421667755,
0.2545251846,
0.6148440838,
-0.8922380209,
-0.1800914109,
-0.4182435572,
-0.5589568019,
0.2512202859,
0.1222962365,
-0.0220693517,
0.2335651815,
0.3524563015,
-0.3282450736,
0.9148807526,
-0.2872366011,
-0.0865864083,
0.1409187317,
-0.4120402038,
0.517608881,
-0.5527615547,
0.6848318577,
-0.2587732971,
0.2144640237,
-0.253570199,
-0.2381901294,
0.2319440544,
-0.0759683326,
-0.1835234165,
0.2874586284,
-0.3313408196,
-0.2236154974,
-0.1585435122,
0.1260374784,
0.0686271265,
0.4921902716,
-0.0018913244,
0.7776932716,
-0.0753690898,
-1.0412093401,
-0.0461266674,
0.2050168216,
-0.3405652344,
0.4208493233,
-0.5626382828,
0.1353625953,
-0.253223002,
0.0690530092,
-1.0914624929,
0.495077014,
-0.1902386099,
-0.5789886713,
0.3686386645,
0.0584147982,
-0.7030506134,
-0.5447655916,
-0.8883863688,
0.1656952202,
0.4374860823,
-0.7111902833,
0.643286109,
0.289262861,
-0.2997478247,
-0.9452587366,
-0.5878845453,
0.0348143019,
0.2554343641,
-0.4480830431,
0.7082546353,
-0.1380384117,
0.1056262702,
0.3366111815,
-0.1338969767,
0.0001793732,
0.1130517796,
-0.1779844016,
0.1528868824,
-0.0708941221,
0.7135642767,
-0.1216992289,
0.043258328,
-0.1502435952,
-0.2555686831,
0.3540194631,
-0.0455574058,
-0.351841867,
-0.3746615946,
0.3005167544,
0.458085686,
-0.0119569208,
0.3636265099,
0.6586143374,
-0.2289479226,
0.2238695174,
-0.991160512,
-0.8066700101,
-0.3449182212,
0.2507896423,
-0.0437624119,
-0.9100346565,
0.5451267362,
0.1796026826,
0.153744176,
0.5814738274,
0.6827093363,
-0.2856577933,
0.7972484827,
0.348205924,
-0.4519122541,
0.8432341218,
-0.3177657127,
0.2502244413,
-0.9081954956,
-0.3291894197,
-0.450261116,
-0.8337095976,
-0.1246728972,
-0.1953775585,
0.4593786895,
0.0130331535,
0.0142034441,
0.2200320661,
-0.9019321799,
0.0559996665,
1.1739546061,
0.3530555069,
0.09063299,
0.113009192,
-0.4775829613,
-0.0853504986,
-0.9880750179,
0.1123380363,
1.5357010365,
-0.0576684363,
0.7471545339,
0.266143918,
1.0001351833,
0.4662526548,
0.6173739433,
-0.9164922237,
0.4718259275,
0.06331411,
-0.6965916753,
-0.2383408546,
-0.5319097042,
-0.8433855176,
0.2371469587,
-0.3388439119,
-0.3547468781,
0.3619747758,
0.1626255363,
-0.6999610662,
0.1955687106,
-0.8530858159,
0.1056964919,
-0.3483223617,
-0.7547020316,
-0.6891356707,
-0.6623296142,
-0.0931579769,
0.166820094,
-0.1522259563,
0.3125039935,
0.028529916,
0.6923991442,
-0.4839882553,
0.5940206647,
-0.464432627,
0.2598979175,
0.6435461044,
-0.0199357681,
0.3759266734,
0.1830770969,
-0.2793709338,
-0.2364479154,
-0.3711462915,
-0.0188654121,
-0.7188669443,
0.8497387171,
-0.5382078886,
-0.7569383383,
-0.2541818321,
-0.2245659232,
0.1822495908,
0.4199229479,
0.3905392885,
0.3445698321,
0.1236885488,
0.532310605,
0.925486505,
-0.2645133138,
0.3076451123,
0.607550621,
-0.2059294134,
-0.7028782368,
1.0149264336,
0.7514325976,
-0.3321178257,
0.6500160098,
0.0604572706,
-0.3511258066,
-0.5531677008,
0.0438733064,
0.0965001136,
-0.6585407257,
-0.3063565791,
-0.548407197,
-0.1146892458,
-0.4895894527,
0.1966857612,
-0.3061182499,
-0.6294363141,
-0.4249015749,
0.2136853784,
0.0414633714,
0.7211498618,
-0.0033065733,
-0.1909506321,
-0.7781823277,
0.3056337833,
0.4655807316,
0.7774949074,
0.3882824779,
-0.4658162594,
-0.1911741942,
-0.4607346356,
-0.633215487,
-0.6135752797,
0.4625533223,
0.1020269468,
0.8551310897,
0.1121335626,
0.2381510139,
0.4220023453,
-0.2306955308,
0.7047846317,
0.0049204594,
-0.619630456,
0.8955775499,
0.0375513621,
0.2764634192,
0.7906454206,
0.1959712505,
-0.3268521726,
0.0308014918,
-0.529525876,
-1.3357776403,
0.4923724532,
0.3813199103,
-0.1061403081,
-0.0932683498,
0.8130671978,
-0.2196556479,
0.5093224049,
-0.3401538134,
-0.2599700391,
-0.2196987867,
0.2873672843,
0.3355704248,
-0.6842899323,
-0.1072449088,
-0.4084104598,
0.9538484216,
0.1028561443,
0.7138761282,
0.8303499222,
-0.241479069,
0.2694332898,
0.336990118,
0.6873396635,
0.3583105206,
-0.6913309693,
-0.0968420729,
-0.1269621104,
-0.5219417214,
-0.0439221933,
0.0384399556,
-0.5949673057,
0.2985195816,
-0.2596866488,
0.2493711114,
0.1746478677,
-0.367905587,
0.5346495509,
-0.3599315584,
-0.2430183887,
-0.1793599725,
-0.0925408453,
-0.2063445449,
0.1309761405,
0.6504793167,
0.0979721472,
0.6277884841,
-0.3445958197,
0.4768666029,
0.3534099758,
-0.6699200273,
-0.0367479026,
0.3593323231,
0.6975501776,
-0.1786989272,
0.8848718405,
0.0722573921,
-0.5503604412,
0.5463733077,
0.2153135091,
0.8926507235,
-0.1724145412,
-0.1791329384,
0.8461408615,
0.4207343459,
-0.3629310131,
0.5480458736,
-0.3875992894,
-0.282335043,
-0.1863622516,
0.1358735263,
-0.5267202854,
0.1141552851,
-0.8377993703,
0.3694423437,
-0.7394452095,
-0.8088923693,
-0.2100786269,
-0.040597599,
-0.3113673329,
0.0978874117,
-0.2360361218,
0.9700913429,
-0.0896900743,
0.6661645174,
0.5086346269,
-0.7418333888,
-0.3731652796,
0.1778641343,
-0.051819738,
-0.4495698512,
0.8509793878,
0.5178186893,
-0.2597137392,
-0.1399734914,
-0.2422717512,
-0.8748793006,
1.1818141937,
0.1842963994,
-0.4762766361,
0.1557790488,
-0.9354403615,
0.5766673088,
0.0090561407,
0.5676577687,
0.063086018,
0.2024335563,
0.0128970863,
-0.810248673,
-0.1608638167,
-0.8666887879,
0.1450940073,
0.1938195676,
-0.6469279528,
0.7931237817,
-0.4035490155,
-0.2274485379,
0.1451111138,
0.4866753221,
0.0069877496,
0.2885191739,
0.3918792605,
0.6215386987,
0.7179092169,
0.1366111785,
1.0834445953,
-0.3855163753,
0.4457414448,
0.9738930464,
-0.3496638238,
1.0859069824,
0.6651307344,
0.0856069028,
0.3680969775,
0.4620103836,
0.0413718373,
0.676782608,
0.2966766655,
-0.0826491416,
-0.1038933098,
-0.3215659261,
-0.6028178334,
-0.191484943,
0.4469451308,
-0.7445126772,
-0.0957072452,
-0.2929977477,
-0.3179177344,
-0.0846639648,
-0.2699206471,
0.9324018359,
-0.1469516754,
-1.0592597723,
0.7893534899,
-0.2618330717,
0.8036876917,
-0.4289013445,
-0.3424586952,
-0.3607235253,
0.2629151642,
-0.256809473,
-0.7873165607,
0.1547980309,
-0.2136663347,
-0.5843621492,
-0.1955892444,
0.7506709695,
-0.1922859997,
0.0179055613,
0.4647653997,
0.1679374427,
-0.1154129207,
-0.1728967726,
-0.6405661702,
-0.213827759,
0.1774287075,
-0.5209289789,
0.2411307693,
0.0589286573,
-0.1168557182,
0.6788700819,
0.4795292318,
-0.1037475616,
-0.2205336541,
0.3572125435,
1.0775104761,
-1.0348924398,
-0.5605676174,
-0.3129881024,
0.0250420216,
-0.2082915604,
-0.124225013,
0.4727849662,
0.5249655247,
0.7137501836,
0.0972898602,
0.8777211308,
-0.0313639119,
0.7991677523,
-0.4560836256,
0.7751131058,
-0.6872892976,
0.6723052263,
-0.0731858388,
-1.1291592121,
-0.520825088,
0.8392978311,
-0.1794219911,
0.3917132914,
0.5366544127,
0.7138769031,
0.3441627026,
-0.0917008147,
0.1829827875,
0.2026257068,
0.3237027228,
0.5135273337,
0.6594509482,
-0.5991125107,
0.7496038675,
-0.2752126455,
-0.0836670175,
-0.9470852017,
-0.7154994607,
-0.7231252789,
-0.2582393587,
-0.079709366,
-0.7592063546,
0.0706329048,
0.7434369922,
0.6035257578,
-0.9039171934,
-0.0852184221,
0.1147036031,
0.2463737875,
-0.1689580083,
-0.2326865494,
0.5116605163,
-0.5947781801,
-0.1284878105,
0.1791598201,
0.5629098415,
-0.2194506228,
-0.0979921892,
0.0461119413,
-0.313621819,
-0.2736977339,
0.6005394459,
0.3287346363,
-0.8209445477,
-0.3645685613,
0.4134930372,
-0.2605940998,
0.1530605555,
0.9687130451,
-1.1237844229,
1.0353565216,
0.9245226979,
0.8020190001,
0.6230582595,
-0.1028807089,
0.6745551229,
-0.6626027226,
-0.0728771016,
0.5969193578,
0.1019932255,
0.1811908185,
-0.453669101,
0.6585572362,
0.4276569784,
-0.4254615903,
-0.4471978843,
-0.0920084938,
-0.7716968656,
0.0395962112,
1.0978200436,
-0.0129420664,
-0.2020011544,
-0.0327018946,
-0.4704524875,
0.0264945216,
-0.7462522984,
1.2620466948,
0.5975575447,
-0.1910193264,
0.0290632118,
-0.2574893236,
0.0647385344,
1.0033277273,
-0.3373710513,
-0.2954561412,
0.3751217127,
0.0577453598,
0.5839844346,
0.7359747291,
-0.4247470796,
0.7650178075,
-0.4642832875,
0.2462871075,
0.1465853006,
-0.3992168605,
-0.3871379793,
0.2711462379,
0.1891203225,
-0.016715046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15106v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15106v1
|
Solving the Right Problem is Key for Translational NLP: A Case Study in UMLS Vocabulary Insertion
| 2023-11-25T19:35:53 | 2023-11-25T19:35:53 |
Bernal Jimenez Gutierrez, Yuqing Mao, Vinh Nguyen, Kin Wah Fung, Yu Su, Olivier Bodenreider
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the immense opportunities enabled by large language models become more
apparent, NLP systems will be increasingly expected to excel in real-world
settings. However, in many instances, powerful models alone will not yield
translational NLP solutions, especially if the formulated problem is not well
aligned with the real-world task. In this work, we study the case of UMLS
vocabulary insertion, an important real-world task in which hundreds of
thousands of new terms, referred to as atoms, are added to the UMLS, one of the
most comprehensive open-source biomedical knowledge bases. Previous work aimed
to develop an automated NLP system to make this time-consuming, costly, and
error-prone task more efficient. Nevertheless, practical progress in this
direction has been difficult to achieve due to a problem formulation and
evaluation gap between research output and the real-world task. In order to
address this gap, we introduce a new formulation for UMLS vocabulary insertion
which mirrors the real-world task, datasets which faithfully represent it and
several strong baselines we developed through re-purposing existing solutions.
Additionally, we propose an effective rule-enhanced biomedical language model
which enables important new model behavior, outperforms all strong baselines
and provides measurable qualitative improvements to editors who carry out the
UVI task. We hope this case study provides insight into the considerable
importance of problem formulation for the success of translational NLP
solutions.
|
[
-0.101367332,
-0.6973809004,
0.8220592141,
0.2119814008,
-0.0900472775,
0.0033917029,
-0.1248942018,
-0.3445088863,
-0.0516107827,
0.5135126114,
-0.2430986762,
-0.3117204309,
-0.5267630816,
0.2783811092,
-0.3216589391,
0.9650714397,
-0.1561157703,
0.0068605505,
-0.4974309504,
-0.2394477576,
-0.6676905155,
-0.4380081296,
-0.343647331,
-0.3579262793,
0.2954461575,
0.1174770892,
0.8774069548,
1.0092847347,
0.8587055802,
0.2428361028,
-0.5543314815,
0.3139154613,
-0.1219283342,
-0.1086538285,
-0.3513660431,
-0.302028209,
-0.472669363,
-0.1441143453,
0.5449990034,
1.0507339239,
-0.5221183896,
-0.0106341364,
-0.0022239606,
0.533164978,
-0.3979719579,
-0.18592906,
-0.3484625816,
0.5155404806,
-0.1585094929,
-0.1950847358,
-0.2332182676,
0.0422620401,
0.3663849533,
-0.7973710895,
-0.0182075463,
0.1026143059,
0.9276841283,
0.177337274,
-0.2965981066,
-0.3621689379,
-0.5805751085,
0.7060248256,
-1.106497407,
0.4377160668,
-0.1176382452,
0.1991886497,
-0.5939122438,
-0.5186511278,
-0.4408286512,
-0.1659846455,
0.0683380067,
-0.0923318714,
-0.1801274419,
-0.0282646324,
0.0035448761,
-0.0032069141,
-0.563139677,
-0.0790722221,
-0.3230225146,
0.0029858791,
0.3978176117,
0.3574854434,
0.2999996841,
-0.1810731441,
-0.1237169132,
0.2470115274,
-0.6924164295,
-0.4861607254,
-0.1623654664,
0.6145941615,
-0.0435197167,
0.7354807854,
-0.2024880499,
0.9493657351,
-0.1914238632,
0.1576325595,
0.4122401476,
-0.6104332805,
-0.0498077758,
0.0389599912,
0.4559957981,
0.1253150403,
0.3683797419,
-0.374804467,
-0.0964589342,
-0.2593196034,
0.6811475754,
-0.3983961344,
0.4280124605,
0.370950222,
-0.1727527082,
-0.4506223202,
-0.1970094293,
-0.3923449218,
-0.2627392411,
-0.3984849155,
0.5743171573,
-0.3047098517,
-0.0986259282,
0.4025269151,
-0.3031125665,
-0.2303713709,
0.0252528097,
-0.3666906953,
0.19275029,
0.7008793354,
0.9262643456,
-0.0587542132,
-0.0998875946,
-0.3928592801,
0.3644636571,
-0.5051924586,
0.6258544922,
-0.2784784138,
-0.4659447372,
0.1757133603,
-0.2545911074,
0.2216818333,
-0.6472368836,
0.3761842549,
-0.382327795,
0.0563429669,
-0.1862615645,
-0.744328618,
0.4030003548,
0.2685053945,
-0.2185027301,
0.7845452428,
0.2339574397,
-0.4463782609,
0.0995328575,
-1.0523313284,
-0.3417333066,
0.2756089866,
-0.2680316865,
-0.1885359138,
0.3409689665,
0.0228747129,
0.426379323,
-0.2089440823,
0.5389429927,
0.0497546531,
-0.0939232484,
0.571176827,
-0.0881707966,
0.8058949113,
0.1823613048,
-0.1946221441,
-0.1916136444,
-0.4963288903,
0.0517991856,
0.1424685419,
-0.4326280355,
-0.4695903957,
0.0226211678,
0.1344825774,
0.1666401327,
0.1659697741,
-0.6446648836,
0.5159710646,
-0.6949385405,
0.3575460613,
0.5537179112,
0.0136165805,
0.3166787624,
-0.129948929,
0.3715321422,
-0.0152479382,
0.2537266314,
0.4158046544,
-0.6535071731,
-0.550619781,
0.1480873823,
0.5272965431,
0.6328657269,
-0.6563789845,
0.5833396912,
-0.3350432515,
-0.4533032179,
-0.6814402342,
0.1210103184,
0.6605564952,
0.6549105644,
0.702998817,
0.0312957317,
-0.4884075224,
-0.9475077391,
-0.2435049862,
0.0679670572,
0.0475004986,
0.3603917658,
0.5089536309,
-0.4546513259,
1.2619419098,
-0.7844171524,
-0.4241996109,
-0.1942831129,
0.3669545352,
0.2325324565,
0.6704944968,
-0.0541332178,
-0.9823367596,
-0.0348123498,
0.1532755196,
-1.0844548941,
-0.4717396498,
-0.2308472395,
-0.267611295,
-0.0609847084,
0.7232977748,
-0.5867620707,
0.3286454976,
0.3773663938,
-0.4501347244,
0.6967784166,
-0.6080224514,
-0.2038561106,
-1.2027037144,
0.1637635827,
0.0477466993,
-0.0433896072,
-0.6730356216,
0.4144668579,
-0.0014955997,
-0.0676748529,
-0.6733506322,
0.4629752338,
-0.4254831076,
0.0948855355,
-0.1979542375,
0.1259869486,
0.1042164788,
0.1167894155,
-0.0966613442,
0.5575764179,
0.2907504737,
-0.781324029,
0.2445770204,
0.5965250731,
-0.1783673614,
0.5033236146,
-0.6223991513,
-0.3317318857,
-0.0316441357,
0.054648459,
-0.3052763343,
0.1115279794,
0.2483252734,
-0.2316811085,
0.244269833,
0.0797248706,
-0.3043582737,
-0.4248969853,
0.1874930263,
0.5447748303,
0.4167889357,
-0.2840149105,
0.3474458158,
0.4078124166,
-0.0469945855,
-0.7019003034,
-0.706989944,
0.4510657489,
-0.0343897343,
-0.2892012894,
0.8300049901,
-0.0904540494,
-0.260394156,
0.4889039695,
-0.1139431596,
-0.0596174598,
0.1254996955,
-0.1126646847,
-0.0330234841,
-0.1796503067,
0.1884305626,
0.1662780195,
-0.4418924749,
-0.115349479,
-0.1442105025,
0.1795764267,
-0.1498302072,
-0.346306622,
-0.4504929483,
0.6831588149,
0.5749948025,
-0.1459883302,
0.5132260919,
0.1456422061,
-0.4605320692,
-0.2787983716,
-0.2663827837,
0.1023027152,
-0.4427065253,
0.5834543109,
-0.3335343301,
-0.494948864,
0.1461067647,
-0.0986413956,
0.180246383,
0.3253538609,
0.3251890242,
-0.2930621207,
1.257605195,
0.521052897,
0.2341024429,
0.1009660959,
-0.3312281668,
0.3145365715,
-1.1613427401,
-0.1791726798,
-0.446750313,
-0.0358109958,
-0.2099541128,
-0.6865475774,
0.5683330894,
0.0628893301,
0.2091066092,
0.5776615739,
-0.5901979208,
0.3804234862,
0.2517121732,
0.0078492565,
0.3368590474,
-0.2269738019,
-0.4191501737,
0.0294990838,
-1.0019661188,
-0.4584597051,
1.0288404226,
0.1430966556,
0.4066978395,
0.2198099047,
0.8264373541,
0.3733279407,
0.3297322392,
-0.7017709017,
0.5636172891,
-0.1964954436,
-0.4948189557,
-0.3165988028,
-0.3857021928,
-1.24883461,
0.2178426385,
-0.3554044962,
-0.4564484358,
0.2632431686,
0.168561101,
-0.6125931144,
-0.0232699122,
-0.3038510084,
0.9878939986,
-0.3015910983,
-0.2152065635,
-0.0682745352,
-0.7505417466,
-0.3001758456,
-0.0360646918,
0.6703977585,
-0.1802049726,
-0.2604835033,
0.8021637201,
-0.6442784071,
0.5091932416,
0.008714729,
-0.251719743,
0.0995025039,
-0.0987182856,
0.2719467878,
-0.0724948645,
0.1025091037,
0.2265050858,
0.1609074473,
-0.3065902889,
-0.6920323372,
0.5304455757,
-0.3339901567,
-0.6989808083,
-0.4641254246,
-0.6856675744,
-0.2390296608,
0.0651242435,
0.2250368446,
0.5380872488,
-0.1988678426,
0.0299806204,
0.6756682992,
-0.1151574105,
0.2016555965,
0.703279376,
-0.4165122807,
-0.0443739705,
1.091835022,
0.4163094461,
0.193090409,
0.2612606585,
0.4554421306,
-0.1402215213,
-0.9134641886,
-0.8549761772,
0.350613445,
-0.3365724981,
-0.2557109296,
-0.5710811019,
-0.2218880355,
-0.493144393,
-0.5987126827,
-0.517547667,
-0.1955667436,
-0.370154351,
0.2747785449,
0.0226453207,
0.5020011067,
-0.3089838922,
0.2975419462,
-1.1995744705,
0.5310544968,
0.1151031256,
0.2696954906,
-0.2515625954,
-0.6046676636,
-0.6772776842,
0.0718103647,
-0.121406503,
-1.1270678043,
0.5631459355,
0.225959748,
0.5714082718,
0.2233452946,
-0.2273304462,
0.8504618406,
-0.8392068148,
0.3936390877,
-0.236114502,
-0.9388969541,
0.4938226342,
-0.3892767429,
0.4148985147,
0.6058180332,
0.293215245,
-0.9123963714,
-0.6035744548,
-0.8201639652,
-1.036190033,
0.3616495728,
0.4303847551,
0.1218847632,
-0.1598468572,
0.5895651579,
-0.3100098968,
0.2658471167,
-0.4154468477,
-0.1225234941,
0.323836416,
-0.3259418309,
0.1610504836,
-0.044516705,
-0.228604883,
-0.2736107409,
0.9783642292,
0.0459747314,
0.2474109381,
0.2968752682,
-0.2295063287,
0.0195905585,
0.2753346264,
0.3244438767,
0.4179650247,
-0.3180214167,
-0.1203045025,
-0.0198199339,
-0.1556527019,
0.120174408,
0.0054164585,
-0.1998203546,
0.123813726,
0.1998108923,
0.2481372505,
0.2497429997,
-1.1110078096,
0.5539520979,
0.3210371435,
-0.1752436906,
-0.1200487688,
-0.1776266396,
0.2242790163,
0.09045434,
0.3627059758,
-0.0271274652,
0.4086740911,
-0.3718610704,
0.3550156951,
0.527870357,
-0.2964689732,
0.0525538139,
0.2405104935,
0.252143383,
-0.5840622187,
0.6000962853,
-0.3883643448,
-0.6265755892,
0.699958384,
0.9740723968,
0.4436731935,
-0.2774836123,
0.1998844892,
0.0961758941,
0.1120162532,
-0.2023207992,
0.2499877065,
0.3421295285,
-0.9723745584,
-0.6396203041,
-0.557544291,
-0.3524618745,
-0.1796503961,
-0.7495363355,
0.0546341725,
0.0270104837,
-0.1577979922,
0.1876923591,
-0.5141453147,
-0.229272455,
0.2522654533,
0.0892529935,
0.8360276818,
-1.0256181955,
0.5689492226,
0.7721084952,
-0.2747070789,
-0.4548347294,
-0.4260518849,
0.080785051,
-0.6087449789,
0.6249952912,
-0.074449949,
0.083256878,
0.1352743357,
-0.2658469379,
-1.0994133949,
0.5555642247,
0.1527185291,
-0.3901094496,
-0.2624540627,
0.2636419237,
0.678083241,
-0.3022535741,
-0.2981230915,
0.5929403901,
0.5516800284,
-0.2834903896,
-0.8458760381,
0.1672849804,
-0.3636240959,
0.1807085723,
0.4889533222,
-0.0995133072,
0.4599567354,
-0.2088013142,
-0.0819389299,
0.1403798759,
0.6161006689,
0.0200925451,
0.0722979903,
0.3142361343,
0.9411515594,
0.5184292793,
0.0928166732,
1.0078743696,
0.0257803835,
0.2187212706,
0.9261977077,
-0.1756058782,
0.876021266,
0.8497686386,
-0.2596026063,
0.3311395049,
0.2625182569,
-0.0534293577,
0.335432291,
0.5515480638,
-0.1757633686,
-0.2585699856,
-0.5462936163,
-0.5730928183,
0.5125809312,
0.613014698,
-0.2146790326,
-0.345859319,
0.3583470583,
-0.0052853595,
0.1652321219,
0.0129986387,
0.7715415955,
-0.0744800791,
-0.4444253445,
0.4544941783,
0.1346012503,
0.5392380953,
-0.5482155085,
-0.2809166908,
-0.0660903677,
-0.0103274602,
-0.1922285855,
-0.5394595265,
0.6091464758,
-0.0167261381,
-0.0756666139,
-0.1210952774,
0.1052180529,
-0.4871009886,
-0.6013351083,
0.0375631973,
0.7323288321,
0.3108115196,
0.0631241649,
-0.7911339402,
-0.1175119728,
-0.0818528906,
-0.1232080087,
0.2853465378,
0.2272529155,
-0.0716993064,
0.677215457,
0.6690394282,
0.4745560586,
-0.1660089791,
-0.1551720202,
0.5764392018,
-0.6725739837,
-0.3709902167,
-0.718295753,
0.6490083933,
-0.1484481394,
-0.4478392899,
0.5125324726,
0.5599813461,
0.4422097206,
-0.0005428073,
0.7072582841,
-0.1408964843,
0.3750777841,
-0.4528072476,
0.6104738712,
-0.8390337825,
0.2614562809,
-0.3021993637,
-0.5594707131,
-0.719353199,
0.7542464137,
0.0434079841,
-0.3280874491,
0.8286038041,
0.8531057835,
0.1980640292,
-0.2182939798,
0.1984977722,
0.3028306365,
0.3906861842,
0.4770564437,
0.5557454824,
-0.4432637095,
0.4217028916,
-0.2908326089,
-0.2115484923,
-0.4306970835,
-1.21476686,
0.0680466592,
-0.4889630973,
-0.6406815648,
-0.3960895836,
0.3738698363,
1.1322234869,
0.6399129629,
-0.7304839492,
-0.341786176,
-0.4597775042,
0.1242136806,
-0.6252335906,
-0.1975505054,
0.2835578322,
-0.5347511172,
-0.5892370343,
0.5936139822,
0.3145123124,
0.211734727,
-0.0004011759,
-0.0060744914,
-0.5672946572,
0.2675273716,
0.4825582802,
0.5150962472,
-0.6647856236,
-0.2177672088,
-0.1082266197,
-0.1187033877,
0.0781591088,
0.7454101443,
-0.7899507284,
0.5817322135,
0.1599000394,
1.0222998857,
0.0180282202,
-0.0948798731,
0.8311730623,
-0.7192453742,
-0.179755047,
0.429430753,
0.3417785764,
0.2226554453,
-0.2859100401,
0.5829125643,
0.3439741731,
-0.367377907,
-1.1036710739,
0.1260071993,
-1.067661047,
-0.6151023507,
1.2171065807,
0.2063357085,
-0.0847477391,
-0.4573922753,
-0.2776303589,
0.4317225814,
-0.140265286,
0.8456080556,
0.6426185369,
-0.3336581588,
0.6435012817,
-0.4141736031,
0.4190957844,
0.9542145133,
-0.7410483956,
0.1748756617,
0.5170500278,
-0.2817634046,
0.5493557453,
0.3673152626,
-0.1410775483,
0.2051014602,
-0.1651362628,
0.169107303,
-0.2614417076,
-0.3842172921,
-0.3848373294,
0.2364399284,
0.0063305316,
0.0795328692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16185v1
|
Enhancing Sentiment Analysis Results through Outlier Detection Optimization
| 2023-11-25T18:20:43 | 2023-11-25T18:20:43 |
Yuetian Chen, Mei Si
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
When dealing with text data containing subjective labels like speaker
emotions, inaccuracies or discrepancies among labelers are not uncommon. Such
discrepancies can significantly affect the performance of machine learning
algorithms. This study investigates the potential of identifying and addressing
outliers in text data with subjective labels, aiming to enhance classification
outcomes. We utilized the Deep SVDD algorithm, a one-class classification
method, to detect outliers in nine text-based emotion and sentiment analysis
datasets. By employing both a small-sized language model (DistilBERT base model
with 66 million parameters) and non-deep learning machine learning algorithms
(decision tree, KNN, Logistic Regression, and LDA) as the classifier, our
findings suggest that the removal of outliers can lead to enhanced results in
most cases. Additionally, as outliers in such datasets are not necessarily
unlearnable, we experienced utilizing a large language model -- DeBERTa v3
large with 131 million parameters, which can capture very complex patterns in
data. We continued to observe performance enhancements across multiple
datasets.
|
[
-0.4673806429,
-0.7889053822,
0.5810658336,
0.0474587604,
-0.5325838327,
0.1442074031,
-0.1307781637,
-0.1849406213,
0.0571691021,
0.4456830025,
-0.4904251695,
-0.8245583773,
-0.8908780813,
-0.1685767323,
-0.2296760827,
1.1969759464,
0.1734320968,
0.1673187912,
-0.503854692,
-0.2699282765,
-0.3605929613,
-0.7436287403,
-0.5075625181,
-0.3409971595,
0.197141096,
0.608400166,
0.521802783,
0.2181016952,
0.7175425291,
0.3230314553,
-0.1515447199,
0.2234578431,
-0.4422136247,
0.2672820091,
0.1051245779,
-0.4031030238,
-0.2931923866,
-0.1205742136,
0.4329613745,
0.5273289084,
0.1223009676,
-0.0314942785,
0.1688934267,
1.2437623739,
-0.3400020897,
0.3173730075,
-0.3281893134,
0.3220929801,
-0.4618688524,
-0.1287107319,
-0.3660562634,
-0.7641491294,
0.3123948574,
-0.123596482,
0.0627649352,
-0.2764881253,
0.566403985,
0.6393512487,
-0.2144511044,
-0.469021976,
-0.3816150427,
0.9410284162,
-0.9768245816,
0.2863861024,
-0.0239732098,
-0.1095151454,
-0.2409660071,
-0.1177421659,
-0.5083065629,
0.0320162252,
0.0786192343,
0.1546382457,
-0.349193871,
0.0349099711,
0.2336312383,
0.2590022385,
-0.5750434399,
0.3648500443,
0.0932718366,
0.0850793347,
0.6469246149,
0.1938913316,
0.0838222876,
-0.3410903513,
-0.0054500797,
-0.3244348168,
-0.0551731288,
0.4384247661,
0.7025892138,
0.4472617507,
0.0356779806,
0.4929982424,
0.0463784002,
0.4074087143,
-0.0900605544,
0.0508668348,
0.5887911916,
-0.1407671422,
-0.322273761,
0.1042684689,
0.5960837007,
0.5404211283,
0.3514744341,
0.0965844467,
-0.1107864231,
0.2544721365,
0.1892883331,
-0.9621228576,
-0.6090523601,
0.3809521794,
-0.9104188681,
-0.5837849379,
-0.058715608,
-1.2523339987,
-0.8930372596,
-0.6384877563,
0.2117916197,
-0.2553590238,
-0.4438740611,
0.0687228814,
-0.3081651032,
-0.2024920732,
0.1184715331,
-0.559656024,
0.2176690698,
0.670674324,
0.6956128478,
-0.2604264319,
0.2006569505,
-0.3679524064,
-0.5857102871,
-0.3964618742,
0.8204303384,
-0.8020309806,
-0.5272225142,
-0.1431771219,
-0.4112092853,
0.1790380627,
-0.5788980722,
0.9716876149,
-0.3935631216,
0.158927232,
-0.4829256237,
-0.8363460302,
-0.3809225559,
0.0735877827,
-0.5434833765,
1.3624690771,
0.2138079405,
-0.9236560464,
0.5310685635,
-0.694683671,
-0.501437068,
-0.0757627562,
0.0258335844,
-0.7879707217,
0.4834584594,
0.2109413296,
0.808655858,
-0.3202929497,
0.1366511583,
-0.356074065,
-0.3918303251,
0.434581399,
-0.3184445202,
0.40800488,
0.1198739335,
-0.3504072726,
-0.0190971252,
-0.737211287,
0.1851389706,
-0.0420659222,
-0.2551722527,
-0.8271858692,
0.1406896561,
-0.0144753484,
0.2424594313,
0.0363132246,
-0.5715516806,
0.0815501586,
-0.6671102047,
0.1016791835,
0.9279219508,
0.0081595369,
0.5385122299,
0.2373749763,
0.4128516614,
0.6445968151,
0.1332099289,
-0.0124043943,
-0.4532482028,
-0.8531932235,
-0.4538694918,
0.3245368302,
0.4331936538,
-0.5680909753,
0.6287118793,
-0.1232345849,
-0.581205368,
-0.76914078,
0.2986800075,
0.3385736942,
0.7336266041,
0.4426123798,
-0.322390914,
-0.6536616683,
-0.7098325491,
-0.4804480374,
0.0184467174,
0.2580323517,
0.2583898604,
0.2604737878,
-0.5366978049,
1.1484894753,
-0.7431775331,
-0.2649664283,
0.0565109812,
0.5468821526,
0.4297190905,
0.3089925647,
0.5956864357,
-0.8096663952,
-0.6116222739,
0.0151458699,
-0.7472965121,
-0.1106562838,
0.1750134379,
0.0580342002,
0.5021378398,
0.3258616924,
-0.1277838051,
0.3137705624,
0.4283026159,
-0.1774856001,
0.1868057549,
-0.0452820808,
0.1290281713,
-0.8694469929,
-0.279268086,
0.5612600446,
0.0223744716,
-0.8078254461,
-0.6524617672,
-0.0126715498,
0.0253056604,
-0.1777259707,
0.1525523216,
-0.0050580739,
0.1161573604,
-0.2721445262,
0.1398350894,
-0.0708795711,
0.42106089,
-0.0132987238,
0.4756391048,
0.739058733,
-0.4896591902,
0.326807946,
0.060088098,
-0.3633245528,
0.7042387128,
-0.4368578196,
0.2236421257,
-0.7108998895,
0.0044917269,
-1.1567242146,
0.138178423,
0.3236116171,
-0.4864740372,
0.2272360325,
0.0238539744,
-0.2370006442,
-0.3360646963,
-0.6358639002,
0.1193832383,
0.410056591,
-0.7312466502,
0.4664189219,
0.5490750074,
-0.2875664532,
-0.5235385895,
-0.4354004562,
-0.1212455183,
-0.4287254512,
-0.3648204803,
-0.1241934821,
-0.1343626827,
-0.3352749646,
0.0453284346,
-0.0259702653,
-0.0173687562,
0.1567424983,
0.2734228671,
0.2250539362,
-0.0341983587,
0.5390984416,
0.2930344343,
-0.1846099347,
0.2523408532,
-0.0068383208,
0.3507806957,
-0.2827000916,
0.0730607212,
-0.5863496065,
0.4008116424,
0.5073258877,
-0.1712422967,
0.5442206264,
0.57117033,
-0.3132456541,
-0.2862131596,
-0.3030754626,
-0.0251338817,
-0.4836739302,
0.4778344631,
-0.3123312593,
-0.6455601454,
0.1285187006,
-0.2534902394,
-0.3058450818,
0.2809121013,
0.3690885901,
-0.3523490429,
1.3705307245,
0.6777385473,
-0.6396009922,
0.6008585095,
-0.2833689749,
0.5920350552,
-0.6521864533,
-0.2942602336,
-0.7420386076,
-0.3205146492,
-0.8726426363,
-0.3670669496,
0.2149690241,
-0.0461638197,
-0.0220488235,
0.0031511809,
-0.8254316449,
0.450638324,
0.4696376026,
0.1040036008,
0.0313945673,
0.0818422139,
0.2945986986,
-0.5571538806,
-0.3353598118,
-0.5929574966,
0.9980819225,
0.5188673735,
0.5701603889,
-0.0657415465,
0.6724507213,
0.6116222739,
0.3771221638,
-0.9234196544,
0.3744781017,
-0.7084774971,
0.0451835208,
-0.278901577,
-0.6606870294,
-0.4973846972,
0.2566536367,
-0.2884120047,
-0.4931468666,
0.5265821815,
0.0064235893,
0.0325025432,
0.0139116552,
-0.8902933598,
0.8629622459,
-0.2264101505,
0.131883651,
-0.109719567,
-0.4466468394,
0.2006115317,
-0.2740412354,
0.2729869783,
-0.1589560956,
0.157973513,
0.7763189077,
-0.0630886257,
0.5959543586,
-0.472425431,
-0.3497978449,
0.1874819696,
-0.2123617679,
0.7546003461,
0.0478574894,
-0.4625176191,
0.2290277928,
-0.2476106733,
-0.1965965927,
-0.7273729444,
0.6828378439,
-0.8327596188,
-0.1533820778,
-0.3393914104,
-0.1140359938,
-0.4213240743,
-0.0322387889,
0.2000194192,
0.3320717216,
-0.15495722,
0.3688541949,
0.8649759293,
-0.173873052,
0.5343421698,
0.2923787236,
0.2869988978,
-0.3883524537,
1.2527706623,
0.1015067846,
-0.3257098198,
0.2727797925,
0.2717616558,
-0.4969931543,
-0.5762456656,
-0.1766008139,
-0.0464632511,
-0.8973433971,
-0.4083034396,
-0.8242767453,
0.312725395,
-0.440988481,
-0.0010515619,
-0.253462106,
-0.1149759963,
-0.6631544232,
-0.2205823511,
0.4226109385,
0.4270153046,
0.1336240619,
0.3348470628,
-0.774805963,
0.1892260164,
0.1928759366,
0.2879636288,
0.1482133418,
-0.3371340632,
-0.2699598372,
0.1121493801,
-0.2625701725,
-0.7373987436,
0.581248641,
0.1516041309,
0.3240543902,
0.5229520798,
0.1267885417,
0.6503273249,
0.0134943761,
0.6071941257,
0.2283308953,
-1.2465046644,
0.6706359386,
-0.1348508149,
0.0175846666,
0.5472629666,
0.4025823772,
-0.4724679589,
-0.3447223008,
-0.4910298884,
-0.8548065424,
0.5862519741,
0.0309532136,
0.2053129077,
0.0300917067,
0.5022138357,
0.200307712,
0.4581365883,
-0.4365759492,
-0.3164702058,
-0.4406111538,
-0.6157057881,
-0.375992775,
-0.2978008986,
0.1606762558,
-0.4264719486,
0.7031521201,
-0.3852052093,
0.0337817855,
0.0593893416,
0.0576057062,
-0.1197032407,
0.2969270051,
0.4992183149,
0.1541957557,
-0.1523004472,
0.053889636,
0.1808073521,
-0.3904585838,
-0.0213789288,
-0.0179957598,
0.1278883368,
0.0382523723,
0.0319901668,
0.7029818892,
-0.1250346154,
-0.7779134512,
0.5489724874,
-0.2975285649,
0.1020979807,
0.0480490439,
-0.1100134999,
-0.2691640258,
0.4834255576,
0.2789265513,
0.2656050026,
0.5688536167,
-0.4190576673,
-0.0549924076,
0.4804030657,
-0.7079091668,
-0.2257665843,
0.2214018852,
0.2724097371,
-0.1660687625,
0.6293652654,
0.0276340395,
-0.7130565643,
0.6193125844,
0.1144143716,
0.8583534956,
-0.0377101637,
0.6232165694,
-0.0855092406,
0.1905016154,
0.0241770446,
0.3489027023,
0.0867817774,
-0.8694036603,
-0.2402143329,
-0.4819203615,
-0.5479912162,
-0.0166306514,
-0.7545363307,
0.132840082,
-0.1625065058,
-0.1902602315,
0.1972909123,
0.3702949882,
-0.5419316292,
0.6541973948,
-0.0196351949,
0.513725996,
-0.981311202,
0.6579374671,
0.7327734828,
-0.1066643,
-0.3376286924,
0.0189418867,
-0.1353238076,
-0.1342129558,
0.664280355,
0.2796053886,
-0.2118024826,
-0.0101748211,
-0.3593745828,
-0.4463568032,
0.4428818822,
0.2839873433,
-0.5323876143,
0.6111820936,
0.1184602976,
0.944039166,
-0.2562006414,
0.0479915589,
0.8631868958,
0.487513423,
-0.229457289,
-0.1079201773,
-0.1089366674,
-0.2270881832,
0.0431862883,
0.5502536893,
-0.5499107838,
0.6979439855,
0.0341768451,
0.1999917775,
-0.3886585534,
0.6979573965,
-0.0193497017,
0.4412878454,
0.5683173537,
0.6750481725,
1.2289530039,
-0.2870006561,
0.7481601238,
0.2177898139,
0.4642480612,
0.7337523103,
-0.369566977,
0.6484795213,
0.2858785987,
-0.0282546356,
0.4294227064,
0.7872676253,
0.0148603134,
0.7467594147,
0.1921232641,
-0.2635672987,
-0.2509557307,
-0.1950305849,
-0.3725868464,
0.4538850188,
0.3266138732,
-0.4538094401,
0.0662631765,
0.4500669837,
0.2218584269,
0.2978883982,
-0.290153116,
0.8696550727,
-0.087788038,
-0.3550794423,
0.1536453962,
-0.0338958353,
0.8530430794,
0.0648147017,
0.0771350041,
-0.3646829128,
0.5924989581,
-0.3042541742,
-0.7185027003,
0.2557995617,
0.0233397335,
-0.3713119626,
-0.3260238171,
0.9367542863,
-0.2006462961,
-0.5233174562,
0.3553420007,
0.2384269834,
0.0787258521,
-0.2095915824,
-0.6715810299,
0.1965190172,
0.007858891,
-0.3009840548,
0.2546008229,
0.7709573507,
0.1737550646,
0.4729617834,
0.5807006359,
-0.0371467993,
-0.3742762506,
0.2198515683,
1.1815167665,
-0.6652909517,
-0.4952133596,
-1.1134150028,
0.4954537153,
-0.3927228749,
-0.3817875385,
0.8375313878,
0.6124436259,
0.6246769428,
-0.1597908139,
0.874004066,
0.2782178819,
0.5921493173,
-0.3616317809,
0.4108696878,
-0.4406847954,
0.1335053444,
-0.9289583564,
-0.7999615669,
-0.3456182182,
0.5410625339,
-0.3288513422,
-0.0508023091,
0.3599244952,
0.6249573231,
0.3905017376,
0.4204949439,
0.2112020254,
0.193236798,
0.4717895091,
0.2463562787,
0.7897993922,
-0.4323536754,
0.2596321702,
-0.2567480505,
-0.3707107604,
-0.3264484704,
-0.9504764676,
-1.0152649879,
-0.5516308546,
-0.5156779289,
-0.2416727543,
0.0191976335,
0.7190350294,
0.4365534484,
-0.8635326624,
0.130612582,
-0.1177404746,
0.4005901217,
-0.1568695903,
-0.3014919758,
0.3408353329,
-0.4334940314,
-0.7924018502,
0.3379685581,
0.3537724018,
0.1366695911,
-0.0885479674,
-0.0770500973,
0.3180665672,
0.2873569429,
0.9315057397,
-0.1931858957,
-0.1729091406,
-0.1820189655,
-0.0041572396,
0.1143055409,
0.0961161852,
0.7967113853,
-0.7549804449,
0.5060916543,
0.5692240596,
0.5062298775,
0.2239892632,
0.3260278404,
0.231716603,
-0.9542108774,
0.0624571592,
0.3713420033,
0.0429239906,
0.397978723,
-0.7075659037,
0.3020460606,
0.0307397768,
-0.5873686671,
-1.098495245,
-0.1725393236,
-0.7905472517,
-0.4155581892,
0.875733912,
0.1109784842,
0.1152187809,
-0.1550414264,
-0.4256075025,
0.1517402977,
-0.6643355489,
0.8714650273,
0.8001076579,
-0.4356039166,
-0.1367188394,
-0.2856739163,
0.7550210357,
0.3877077997,
-1.1739150286,
0.139592126,
0.2786224782,
-0.0282345656,
0.0880084708,
0.3221774697,
0.0136912568,
-0.040396031,
-0.5056884289,
-0.0706031322,
0.334073931,
-0.2716587186,
-0.5912202597,
0.2131284475,
-0.0929635391,
-0.2940028906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15077v1
|
Multilingual self-supervised speech representations improve the speech recognition of low-resource African languages with codeswitching
| 2023-11-25T17:05:21 | 2023-11-25T17:05:21 |
Tolúlopé Ògúnrèmí, Christopher D. Manning, Dan Jurafsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While many speakers of low-resource languages regularly code-switch between
their languages and other regional languages or English, datasets of
codeswitched speech are too small to train bespoke acoustic models from scratch
or do language model rescoring. Here we propose finetuning self-supervised
speech representations such as wav2vec 2.0 XLSR to recognize code-switched
data. We find that finetuning self-supervised multilingual representations and
augmenting them with n-gram language models trained from transcripts reduces
absolute word error rates by up to 20% compared to baselines of hybrid models
trained from scratch on code-switched data. Our findings suggest that in
circumstances with limited training data finetuning self-supervised
representations is a better performing and viable solution.
|
[
-0.3839798272,
-0.0150863342,
-0.0440312773,
0.263382405,
0.0113390563,
0.0294664744,
-0.4585334063,
-0.5427933335,
0.3361876309,
0.6204901934,
-0.3638753593,
-0.0679867193,
-0.5936971903,
0.2115443498,
-0.3675588965,
0.8744180202,
0.004450073,
0.2085343897,
0.1046977788,
-0.3756923676,
-0.3924171925,
-0.9015111923,
-0.5947392583,
-0.4558105469,
0.5008846521,
0.5830875039,
0.5598424077,
0.5522187352,
0.0444887877,
0.2364342362,
0.2576705217,
0.4729509056,
-0.4907887578,
-0.1392318308,
-0.0418446325,
-0.4464446604,
-0.0529510081,
0.2130895108,
0.1934099942,
0.6181799769,
-0.2639499903,
0.0940461829,
0.2947379649,
0.5929148793,
-0.5310681462,
0.4608283937,
-0.6046616435,
0.0384242535,
-0.2813284695,
-0.2826322019,
-0.3870516717,
0.0704942271,
-0.2738378346,
-0.3760779798,
0.2597420812,
-0.5674088597,
0.302573204,
0.3092381954,
-0.3810506165,
-0.2816619575,
-0.7619408965,
0.796762526,
-0.7365606427,
0.6541348696,
0.8305692077,
0.3179183304,
0.2750354707,
-0.7228987217,
-0.3091195524,
0.0350207649,
-0.2096463144,
0.1110801473,
-0.2004860342,
-0.0662792027,
0.1467167586,
0.1148931012,
-0.2981355488,
0.2941498756,
-0.5166684985,
-0.7992013693,
0.7386822104,
-0.0630482435,
0.0446171686,
-0.2684468031,
0.015442715,
-0.1039754376,
-0.4003262818,
0.0924417004,
0.3978425264,
0.8666454554,
-0.2798592746,
0.2242877185,
-0.0714270622,
0.7449980974,
-0.0095385555,
-0.159380272,
0.5542884469,
-0.3004469275,
-0.0631526113,
0.4132860899,
0.6258867979,
0.1467428058,
0.428255409,
-0.1501201987,
-0.1565052122,
0.2921049893,
0.0311211813,
-0.6320405602,
-0.5953789353,
0.0100357989,
-0.4502485991,
0.1418615431,
-0.0907942504,
-0.4909305573,
-0.0947625861,
-0.3868844211,
0.3260233998,
-0.4097999334,
-0.2057145387,
0.1006023586,
0.1472322345,
-0.1172333807,
0.2067367584,
-1.3281267881,
0.2310000211,
0.0993148386,
0.9153436422,
0.1174753532,
-0.2060579509,
-0.7308861017,
0.2524459064,
-0.3551532626,
0.4753276408,
-0.4251604676,
-0.4137254953,
0.1100417599,
0.1764322817,
0.0320404842,
-0.5247207284,
0.3636552691,
-0.2321316451,
-0.2397080064,
-0.0888281465,
-0.4830518663,
-0.0170518383,
-0.268612802,
-0.7058159709,
0.8082236052,
0.0228924733,
-0.4042711556,
0.2310568094,
-0.1751383543,
-0.7035266757,
-0.1161925644,
-0.4521669447,
-0.4696124792,
-0.1413870454,
0.678465724,
0.6670934558,
0.3252443373,
-0.1360291094,
0.0456840657,
-0.1632458419,
0.0466208495,
-0.718249023,
0.7352354527,
0.5067046881,
-0.3090645075,
-0.434795469,
-1.0793136358,
0.2219107151,
0.0702375844,
-0.4519000053,
-0.468768388,
-0.2344991118,
0.2946451604,
0.4303782582,
0.1300236732,
-0.566293478,
0.2961546183,
-0.3352125585,
0.731713295,
0.4615391791,
-0.2738152444,
0.530644834,
-0.0693802536,
0.4538035691,
0.1221627966,
-0.2722041011,
-0.1963862628,
-0.4069883227,
-0.7316845059,
-0.1420883685,
0.5051927567,
0.4961236417,
-0.8594374657,
-0.0087888902,
0.0786568895,
-0.3025810122,
-1.0989427567,
0.4144647419,
0.4922087789,
0.1789425462,
0.6521359086,
-0.1137344018,
-0.8686884642,
-1.0128244162,
-0.2172774822,
0.0764553919,
0.0697176307,
0.2524323165,
0.2203688473,
-0.4088689983,
0.8582820296,
-0.1223997995,
-0.8085231185,
-0.2543627918,
0.3246524632,
0.0686529204,
0.7353512049,
0.5636336207,
-0.7894164324,
-0.4490890205,
0.0227847099,
-0.4228994846,
-0.1134989038,
-0.3665856123,
0.3499796987,
0.3179064095,
0.9389076829,
0.0080952505,
0.2857333124,
1.1270077229,
0.0956307203,
0.2950069904,
-0.4010777771,
0.1110789701,
-0.8652000427,
-0.4463070333,
-0.0700182244,
-0.5464593768,
-0.6848686337,
-0.3770285547,
0.4380370975,
-0.2213459313,
-0.4017796814,
0.2521341145,
-0.7887194753,
-0.1874915063,
-0.247006923,
0.0991891697,
-0.14536421,
0.3273766637,
0.0937321857,
1.1934133768,
0.4879864156,
-0.5437619686,
0.2048941553,
0.4924243093,
-0.4143572748,
0.2182301283,
-0.246620968,
0.3018863499,
0.0918735415,
-0.0027922655,
-0.8613147736,
-0.0739308372,
-0.2643608749,
-0.5631271005,
0.6347770691,
-0.5577382445,
-0.3503644764,
-0.3096129,
0.220949471,
0.518450439,
0.3808825612,
-1.0620549917,
0.3957870007,
0.5821594,
-0.1270956844,
-0.4040448964,
-1.5014193058,
0.1987390518,
0.1589740664,
-0.3057642579,
0.1921185702,
0.2825549245,
0.2363868505,
-0.3168678582,
-0.245162636,
-0.2076710314,
-0.2549381852,
0.143877849,
-0.2226103842,
-0.0510382839,
0.3191948235,
-0.0074887942,
-0.3551026583,
-0.0607581995,
-0.5232384801,
0.5666971803,
0.009149448,
-0.2389164269,
-0.3890348673,
0.3776602149,
0.0812331215,
-0.6199995875,
0.4766601026,
0.5680744052,
-0.3393827975,
-0.266939193,
-0.5283202529,
-0.0952844843,
-0.4925041795,
0.4344533682,
-0.5015870333,
-1.0238758326,
0.5251785517,
0.0409198701,
-0.2412602156,
0.332280606,
0.5507869124,
-0.2369054854,
0.9227849841,
0.6357914209,
-0.3586051464,
0.5112860203,
-0.5248711109,
0.2811473608,
-0.7302904129,
-0.0486334823,
-0.4903870523,
0.036507912,
-0.9209912419,
-0.5900893807,
0.2746207118,
-0.1175751984,
0.2209542692,
0.5873466134,
-0.5728613734,
0.319146812,
0.4939697981,
0.20783481,
0.0916407406,
0.393209666,
-0.0426929742,
-0.2714170218,
-1.0363202095,
-0.2711378634,
0.9725991488,
0.1601583958,
1.1850236654,
-0.0858211964,
1.0536205769,
0.372957617,
-0.2504881024,
-0.6765656471,
0.1325820833,
-0.5952569842,
-0.4764988124,
-0.3842220008,
-0.6017041802,
-0.9793227911,
0.2482401729,
-0.1560431868,
-0.4859022498,
0.5697382689,
0.4341090918,
-0.4615114033,
0.4341942072,
-0.8112888932,
0.6303530931,
-0.0830193609,
-0.0775129646,
-0.3386529982,
-0.398211658,
0.010618113,
-0.1464572549,
0.5377470255,
0.1081345007,
0.3680719733,
0.9894920588,
-0.5032972097,
1.1153614521,
-0.1497407109,
-0.2647486627,
0.484849751,
0.1536414027,
0.4246380031,
-0.0962672904,
-0.0971836373,
0.5292207599,
-0.0118772117,
-0.4264508188,
-0.3833495378,
0.8102520108,
-0.8552503586,
-0.2912540734,
-0.2297888249,
-0.4077563286,
-0.4739571214,
-0.0181511194,
0.2979313731,
0.8974639177,
0.0729416534,
0.1365450621,
0.4057716131,
-0.0002473419,
0.5020437837,
0.4200564027,
0.0774014965,
-0.3587456048,
1.0184085369,
0.6181470752,
0.4304566979,
0.1707117707,
0.0030334473,
-0.2343306094,
-0.4157104194,
-0.3674405217,
-0.0029137211,
-0.9337979555,
-0.4314903915,
-0.7306021452,
-0.3281270266,
-0.570176363,
-0.114941366,
-0.6811314225,
-0.768864572,
-0.472957164,
-0.1791489422,
0.5082064867,
0.5298281312,
-0.847902894,
0.4442775548,
-0.7827217579,
0.4886530638,
0.6534605622,
0.5168310404,
-0.0910632685,
-0.8685785532,
-0.8150994182,
0.2127891481,
0.0623781532,
-0.7472445369,
0.4348971844,
0.5359256864,
0.494014293,
0.1322800219,
-0.0094995825,
0.8898463845,
-0.6890055537,
0.5729468465,
0.4023294747,
-1.0406345129,
0.6274507046,
-0.0810764059,
0.3453724682,
0.4990829825,
0.2440333664,
-0.7178947926,
-0.3371829987,
-0.2903355956,
-0.5705442429,
0.7999742031,
0.2940050364,
0.3675711453,
-0.1321553588,
0.2159133852,
0.1729183048,
-0.2010483593,
-0.7544288635,
-0.5367093086,
-0.6569941044,
-0.0425417498,
-0.4322035611,
-0.3903900087,
0.0686816573,
-0.2167859524,
0.5459905863,
-0.4084113538,
0.2933499515,
0.4035846889,
-0.2258249223,
-0.1329918951,
0.4242083132,
0.0882883444,
0.28044191,
0.0347016081,
0.2129969448,
0.1727161556,
-0.3699472845,
0.4364594817,
0.3016196489,
0.0585495085,
0.1167065799,
0.5840812922,
0.7309766412,
0.3925946355,
-0.1707978398,
0.285066396,
0.0497009903,
-0.0698380023,
-0.0954499021,
0.100189507,
0.0739585906,
0.1437830478,
0.2074237466,
0.3295362592,
0.3403033018,
-0.5756017566,
0.3614630103,
0.1878985018,
-0.3943657875,
0.1165043563,
0.6933174729,
0.3784786761,
-0.1486194283,
0.5598452687,
-0.0006450079,
-0.3523421884,
0.5404231548,
0.700350523,
0.443721056,
-0.6629217267,
0.1607054174,
0.5397617817,
0.4449816048,
-0.1478030682,
0.2616099119,
-0.2793482542,
-0.7713114023,
-0.4433185756,
-0.2325422615,
-0.2230430841,
-0.1131363958,
-1.0217285156,
0.0970786661,
-0.086802274,
-0.2076672912,
0.0029336812,
-0.3061999679,
-0.7837756872,
0.3610562384,
0.4792563915,
0.856451571,
-0.8123555183,
1.2653515339,
0.3654394746,
-0.3956619799,
-0.928524673,
-0.3311871886,
-0.0615765117,
-0.8686473966,
0.6628235579,
0.1976622641,
-0.2731944621,
0.0589569807,
-0.5025026798,
-0.9314559698,
0.6239842772,
0.4931126833,
-1.1175695658,
0.3299377859,
0.3517752588,
0.3567542434,
-0.2448318452,
-0.0149380816,
0.7273834944,
0.084589228,
-0.3401000202,
-1.15345788,
-0.5002501607,
0.0593579896,
-0.0020941116,
0.0676630512,
-0.58729738,
0.6221647263,
-0.3312674761,
-0.2403261513,
-0.076021567,
0.8178390265,
-0.2404872328,
0.0723978579,
0.370079577,
0.2431050539,
0.7474849224,
-0.1922931224,
0.8946148753,
-0.2341460735,
0.4403007627,
1.4105199575,
0.0230832659,
0.7488908172,
0.431905359,
-0.2949473858,
0.2782965899,
0.3261556625,
0.0209132899,
0.8391067386,
-0.0907440931,
0.0721573979,
-0.5703744292,
0.1629315764,
-0.508651197,
0.8091583252,
0.323286593,
-0.1001469865,
-0.1482803226,
0.4909753203,
-0.2060055286,
0.4111375511,
-0.601462543,
0.7688029408,
0.3183547556,
-0.1854515672,
0.9532510042,
-0.1342999786,
0.850011766,
-0.7268673182,
-0.1617894769,
-0.3401601315,
0.0024892259,
-0.4931700528,
-0.728951931,
0.1812640429,
-0.0882572606,
-0.2473038733,
-0.3973296285,
0.5760117173,
-0.8443702459,
-0.5364135504,
0.6686670184,
0.266489625,
0.1289584637,
0.2304332256,
-0.5994586945,
0.0708216727,
0.1879205704,
0.2187149078,
0.2873995006,
0.2853330672,
0.0352537557,
0.7047572136,
0.5933580399,
0.1970741898,
0.1912905872,
0.5931790471,
0.8155257106,
-0.5268041492,
-0.9961874485,
-0.6363315582,
0.1112199128,
0.1308522224,
-0.0296239965,
0.7695628405,
0.4917491972,
1.2370628119,
-0.1979199797,
0.9577773809,
0.1615349501,
0.5208125114,
-0.7964258194,
0.7889410257,
-0.3915674984,
-0.1064568087,
-0.2777498364,
-0.3870894909,
-0.1873506308,
0.9702341557,
-0.1553494185,
0.0587843135,
0.1763785481,
0.7162114978,
-0.2342055291,
-0.1490819603,
0.728641808,
0.3548623025,
0.3132724762,
0.3205085695,
0.5519905686,
-0.5938962698,
0.7459090948,
-0.4489456713,
-0.1555357277,
-0.1357945651,
-0.5978813171,
-0.9243721366,
-0.7212745547,
-0.3121880889,
-0.3414739966,
0.0236244258,
0.9867771268,
1.2013441324,
-1.1304360628,
-0.3656850457,
0.2452523708,
-0.227385357,
-0.3854982257,
-0.1794427335,
0.1603337377,
-0.507681787,
-0.3510399163,
0.6486659646,
0.1668750793,
0.191900596,
-0.2509830296,
-0.1533063948,
-0.0197583102,
-0.0871993229,
0.6930677891,
0.5310174227,
-0.6053727269,
-0.1440006196,
-0.5851073861,
-0.1791905761,
0.331948489,
0.9615340233,
-0.9550596476,
0.7519945502,
-0.088675566,
0.6543902755,
0.7266278863,
-0.3899970055,
0.3980892003,
-0.9179020524,
0.6101831198,
0.1357463598,
0.7107563615,
0.5932148099,
-0.4163664579,
0.4110929668,
-0.1251215786,
-0.4869095385,
-0.3968723714,
0.2829652131,
-0.7490617037,
-0.0936322808,
1.1345748901,
-0.1237570047,
0.0524855368,
-0.2463822216,
-0.4138127565,
0.3209539652,
-0.4773949385,
0.578597188,
0.3850847781,
-0.0356692597,
-0.4212304056,
-0.4686533809,
0.5855764151,
0.3424077332,
-0.5401895046,
0.3599970639,
0.4559145868,
0.2291630656,
0.1635131687,
0.646795392,
-0.0797837973,
0.3444344699,
-0.045802813,
0.2520768344,
-0.2287901193,
-0.2614825666,
-0.7297340035,
-0.2120725214,
-0.0880302042,
-0.3321611881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15055v1
|
Automatically Finding and Categorizing Replication Studies
| 2023-11-25T15:27:10 | 2023-11-25T15:27:10 |
Bob de Ruiter
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL
|
In many fields of experimental science, papers that failed to replicate
continue to be cited as a result of the poor discoverability of replication
studies. As a first step to creating a system that automatically finds
replication studies for a given paper, 334 replication studies and 344
replicated studies were collected. Replication studies could be identified in
the dataset based on text content at a higher rate than chance (AUROC = 0.886).
Additionally, successful replication studies could be distinguished from
failed replication studies at a higher rate than chance (AUROC = 0.664).
|
[
-0.5609657168,
-0.5901244879,
0.8157915473,
0.6760157943,
0.1343296617,
0.106712617,
0.2769605815,
-0.2319463938,
0.5926847458,
0.1520271152,
-0.2611629069,
-0.1190154701,
-0.7424230576,
0.7288333178,
-0.9252474308,
0.9164935946,
-0.2677882016,
0.2463060915,
-0.2007674575,
-0.342484951,
-0.3490515947,
-0.4335002899,
-0.4320419133,
-0.4618268013,
0.7435816526,
0.7307136655,
0.5023536682,
0.6414718628,
0.7769187689,
0.2919425368,
-0.4082377553,
0.4011497498,
-0.4119808078,
0.0032112924,
-0.3086189926,
-0.471249342,
-0.1813564897,
0.3451862037,
0.550573945,
0.9549628496,
0.0699480027,
0.2855530977,
0.0993406326,
0.8196816444,
-0.5980306864,
-0.2283620834,
-0.0800190642,
0.2206917852,
-0.3260140121,
-0.4886543751,
-0.5217787027,
-0.6917892098,
-0.0376927108,
-0.5599659085,
0.6903810501,
0.1087184772,
0.4286239147,
-0.6559816599,
-0.5011612773,
-0.532545805,
-0.8715205789,
0.6990839243,
-0.1669213474,
-0.093731828,
0.4389818311,
0.0615852699,
-0.5246427059,
-0.5962135792,
-0.3854080439,
-0.3046780825,
-0.2515429854,
-0.1125111133,
-0.0029608496,
-0.3325124681,
0.6278733015,
0.588714838,
-0.7344745994,
-0.3701457083,
-0.5491787791,
-0.1801511347,
0.5770302415,
0.2506000102,
0.2028651834,
-0.3848699927,
-0.0709131956,
-0.269444406,
-0.4085722864,
-0.1807281673,
0.2962146699,
-0.0072581326,
0.4007941484,
0.8041508198,
-0.3175476193,
0.1838125885,
0.1943586767,
-0.031098865,
0.3945493102,
-0.6415541172,
-0.1187729836,
-0.042846743,
0.6304205656,
-0.0500047803,
-0.1339506209,
-0.1857576668,
-0.2039250135,
-0.1160690859,
0.3322217464,
-0.2599054575,
-0.1976899207,
-0.1100402996,
-0.6294010878,
-0.404876709,
0.4147288203,
-0.2161029279,
-0.4664756954,
-0.1591231078,
0.7740170956,
-0.3240072131,
-0.3679434955,
-0.3430706561,
-0.8064227104,
-0.1912516654,
0.3069353998,
-0.3383934498,
0.0440447181,
0.4885526597,
1.1813755035,
-0.5254187584,
-0.4057742357,
0.1481838226,
0.0714759976,
-0.6300684214,
0.7925337553,
-0.2883020341,
-0.6631499529,
-0.1656296253,
0.6889142394,
-0.0314674154,
-0.5320119858,
0.5205471516,
-0.6279338002,
0.2020923495,
-0.6806814075,
-0.7866140604,
-0.3530631959,
-0.1211949736,
-1.0972553492,
0.7436115146,
0.1789849699,
-0.9241739511,
0.8398900032,
-0.3814643621,
-0.6019948721,
0.1003005579,
0.2462923378,
-0.747577548,
0.2550727725,
-0.6519697309,
0.2082240283,
-0.0088939443,
0.5195207,
-0.5635153055,
-0.4644969106,
0.3863167465,
-0.1311817169,
1.0277227163,
0.371871978,
-0.3245963454,
-0.0912182555,
-0.8990841508,
0.2286086977,
-0.0818043202,
-0.2608381212,
-0.664436698,
0.0974397659,
0.2296445519,
-0.1297679245,
-0.1474677622,
-0.6942900419,
0.4239706993,
0.3663916588,
0.3361331522,
0.2909174263,
0.3948286176,
0.5341336727,
-0.6465388536,
0.4016448855,
-0.0164913479,
0.0600630417,
0.0051609222,
-0.6076164246,
-0.9191614389,
0.1182515547,
0.2941545844,
0.4652828574,
-0.4141743779,
0.2553064227,
0.0145465788,
-0.532453537,
-0.2074410021,
0.0566707067,
0.4862550497,
0.1582176387,
0.4506535232,
-0.2779467702,
-0.9351314306,
-1.2606124878,
-0.130479753,
0.0872570723,
0.1301796436,
-0.0251401104,
1.2144281864,
-0.2364022881,
1.0369148254,
-0.2232242972,
-0.5532497764,
-0.0337745398,
0.8068512678,
0.1865028888,
0.4474106729,
0.2302904278,
-0.8366214037,
-0.4917232692,
-0.0923912525,
-1.0521653891,
-0.1696374118,
-0.0527843684,
-0.4194094241,
0.1540795267,
0.6885042191,
-0.297511518,
0.8268579245,
-0.0782714039,
-0.0250640698,
0.660379827,
-0.298677206,
0.5047595501,
-0.6163035631,
0.5193209052,
-0.0126712322,
-0.0847169682,
-0.4876720011,
-0.3650282025,
0.3097997904,
0.3855306506,
0.0175156295,
0.0482772291,
-0.8466000557,
-0.0906819999,
-0.4106154442,
-0.2183007747,
-0.1216586083,
-0.2269497961,
0.107418105,
0.6164147258,
0.1161647066,
-0.3682260215,
0.1330137402,
0.254177928,
0.0139942197,
0.3914647102,
-0.4661667347,
-0.1349142343,
-0.0450340137,
0.4397573173,
-0.7476791143,
-0.6258845925,
-0.2408368438,
-0.3739242554,
-0.1255635172,
-0.0749619901,
-0.4214424491,
-0.444666177,
-0.2596234679,
0.3229785264,
0.0749936029,
-0.2137456536,
0.2768914104,
0.1402476281,
0.1082308367,
-0.5190743208,
-0.4254802465,
0.0546801165,
-0.150618881,
-0.2891348898,
0.1015558764,
0.0492863506,
-0.2955659628,
0.1795781851,
-0.1089291498,
-0.0281431954,
0.0385913029,
0.6922302246,
-0.1480923891,
-0.0579927266,
0.2177101523,
-0.1348801851,
-0.1711962968,
0.2032715678,
0.1287270188,
0.2450266927,
-0.1130731404,
-0.1564961076,
-0.2800505161,
0.95042032,
0.6082783937,
0.2787095606,
0.7736080885,
0.1275296807,
-0.303498745,
-0.4517323673,
-0.5138527155,
0.054578606,
-0.4337614775,
-0.0550924465,
-0.1460529119,
-0.5322647095,
0.6097830534,
0.2651809156,
-0.139403373,
0.6980264783,
0.2803316712,
-0.4597674012,
0.9486964941,
0.8003077507,
0.0774881095,
0.4315625131,
-0.1872163415,
0.0983772874,
-0.6174993515,
-0.4003608227,
-0.7008569837,
-0.1532083303,
-0.7126344442,
-0.2452971786,
0.5881391168,
0.4164531231,
-0.2542095184,
0.5410431623,
-0.6613767147,
0.5211546421,
0.9397957921,
0.1691001058,
0.9064770937,
0.0112094879,
0.0427895263,
0.2117215097,
-0.4189286232,
-0.6607615948,
1.2436861992,
0.0366571695,
0.6830924749,
-0.0501063094,
1.1716783047,
0.781722784,
1.0850222111,
-0.4044067264,
0.5375698805,
0.244533062,
-1.0148327351,
-0.4771679342,
-0.413099587,
-1.1154942513,
-0.0592400841,
-0.2543134391,
-0.1895384789,
0.5911487937,
0.1315917373,
0.0148615697,
-0.1114139259,
-0.4778577685,
0.3336563706,
-0.0735632479,
-0.2395994067,
-0.1977359951,
-0.4079903066,
0.5912525058,
-0.3207649887,
0.2619107366,
0.4339345396,
0.6348570585,
1.2752356529,
-0.5206259489,
0.3818631172,
0.0208662432,
0.2190499604,
0.3660564423,
0.3742387295,
0.2067091316,
0.1441393495,
0.1412985623,
-0.3521151543,
0.205211103,
-0.2304680645,
-0.2469753325,
0.642470479,
-0.4152218103,
-0.3822640181,
-0.9923622608,
-0.4040926397,
0.2074007094,
0.2472064197,
0.6202683449,
0.1662666798,
-0.1259175241,
0.387286365,
0.7734411955,
0.0844441801,
0.4550929666,
0.8345607519,
-0.2813053727,
-0.4781964123,
0.862311542,
0.5264678001,
0.2453784943,
0.0648784488,
-0.1570044905,
0.1927215308,
-0.553016305,
0.0899224356,
0.2928567827,
-0.6825220585,
-0.2409419715,
-0.8760810494,
-0.3446959257,
-0.1331635118,
-0.229270339,
-0.2149792165,
-0.21808815,
-0.6377727985,
-0.3359313309,
0.2781469226,
0.8629823327,
-0.597492218,
0.1055104136,
-0.5442796946,
0.4471490383,
0.0048207827,
0.4256908298,
0.0110892877,
-0.4836330414,
-0.3370267749,
-0.2227064073,
-0.3927485943,
-1.3305792809,
0.5653983355,
-0.0328139067,
0.537345767,
0.192627728,
-0.2213500142,
0.8351466656,
-0.1631392539,
0.289894551,
0.1070080251,
-0.7083208561,
0.780795455,
-0.3139674067,
-0.2585887313,
0.636369586,
0.8394201398,
-0.241614446,
-0.4043654203,
-0.888120532,
-0.9768265486,
0.4372411072,
0.3433752358,
-0.6499035954,
-0.1679508388,
0.4560424387,
0.3548659682,
-0.1568464637,
-1.0056862831,
-0.4839619994,
0.2961347103,
0.2062519044,
-0.040346846,
-0.1752480268,
-0.6242127419,
-0.1943379641,
0.8386614919,
0.0609099716,
0.2004075348,
0.6791144609,
-0.467779845,
-0.5365788937,
0.130750984,
0.5293188095,
0.7557134628,
-0.5024696589,
0.1049181819,
-0.3623271883,
-0.5864409208,
0.5281404257,
-0.0992949307,
-0.5248891711,
0.0263207182,
0.7376081944,
0.1115525961,
-0.2000465393,
-0.2816690505,
0.3159338236,
0.1837449521,
-0.3554938436,
-0.7378544807,
0.2146625817,
-0.150206387,
0.1578562707,
0.9100397229,
0.1032659933,
0.5846306682,
-0.8445225954,
0.5417817235,
0.6391955614,
-0.1055912524,
-0.0753644407,
0.4112914801,
-0.0003061499,
-0.4129196405,
0.5787363648,
-0.4085904658,
-0.4218190908,
1.033706069,
0.3331600428,
0.8232750297,
-0.0955316722,
0.6057611704,
0.6140190363,
0.3297865093,
-0.9077659845,
0.3749685585,
0.1506898999,
-0.3687393069,
0.0087279286,
-0.7686151266,
-0.5824586153,
0.2438266575,
-1.0706505775,
0.0695586503,
0.0979889035,
-0.5602047443,
0.4962086678,
0.0362546444,
-0.5015739202,
0.3278422952,
-0.0775873065,
0.8604270816,
-1.5406522751,
0.4381712973,
0.621721983,
-0.5115783215,
-0.5520497561,
-0.5877484083,
0.0747026429,
-0.1495106816,
0.8685923219,
0.045305986,
-0.1609390676,
-0.2627804875,
-0.8351442814,
-1.2372715473,
1.1291592121,
-0.5608285069,
-0.4375154972,
0.1906810105,
-0.046516601,
0.8076043725,
-0.3438501954,
0.592603147,
0.4594795406,
0.6977380514,
-0.2150997221,
-1.0735327005,
0.0347851291,
-0.4238954782,
-0.1577829719,
0.2452679425,
-0.3410846591,
0.9421160221,
-0.3136868179,
-0.3206310272,
0.1204325184,
0.4831594527,
0.3004851937,
1.0517829657,
0.2646065056,
0.3204814494,
0.4292209446,
-0.4804089665,
0.7115324736,
0.3424498737,
0.5571849346,
0.6660549641,
-0.0783604905,
0.4923762679,
0.4902108014,
-0.3365199566,
0.4725390375,
0.8463460803,
-0.2233889401,
0.4362531304,
0.1763691455,
0.2053453922,
-0.2284607589,
0.3672153354,
-0.4600568414,
-0.1040341854,
0.3238663077,
-0.7421606779,
0.1919733882,
0.4540342093,
-0.0416769013,
-0.3463530242,
-0.1519812346,
0.6926196814,
0.1318216175,
-0.9350155592,
0.3726085424,
-0.3023721874,
0.2930015922,
-0.4578394592,
-0.3047976792,
-0.6046046019,
0.1741891205,
-0.6785655022,
-0.9566825628,
0.2843670547,
-0.3591530621,
-0.660030961,
-0.1860981882,
0.370847702,
-0.1281199455,
-0.5624916553,
0.3896192312,
0.6870638132,
0.0116694178,
0.3504923284,
0.0473670363,
0.0478677973,
0.1589020491,
-0.6918298006,
0.4326455593,
0.4080571532,
-0.581307888,
0.8573673964,
0.5945180655,
-0.0375055186,
-0.0966790468,
-0.3314810991,
0.5745331049,
-1.1421343088,
-0.2020133734,
-0.4642728269,
0.2129887789,
-0.3506350517,
-0.4226868153,
1.2453637123,
0.864312768,
0.5330428481,
-0.1992322654,
0.9505730867,
-0.3940802813,
0.8769336939,
0.0209285747,
0.4494674206,
-0.5058856606,
0.2960979342,
-0.4804441929,
-0.7189284563,
-0.1935062855,
0.7434158325,
0.0113293389,
-0.0318739079,
0.939530313,
0.4933860302,
0.0586853698,
0.1416407824,
-0.2990407348,
0.3192800283,
0.3336292505,
0.0930293724,
0.6733836532,
-0.1712135971,
0.2761940062,
-0.5253223181,
-0.5995454788,
-0.530613184,
-0.8686910272,
-0.4974561632,
-0.7921600342,
-0.3270990849,
-0.8003064394,
0.193569243,
0.3342699409,
0.4724337757,
-1.004971981,
-0.1064986512,
-0.420606792,
0.0962684751,
-0.5002263784,
-0.3747574091,
0.4711041152,
-0.0226373188,
-0.4302367866,
0.2723308206,
0.1282061338,
-0.0707604885,
-0.2109030634,
0.4424080253,
-0.1412380785,
0.0360953435,
0.3523920476,
0.6403146982,
-0.3430417478,
-0.2283592224,
0.0189403445,
-0.3441877365,
-0.2317863405,
1.0690486431,
-0.7303807735,
0.4158454537,
0.7885497212,
-0.1592071056,
0.4938265979,
0.1077996641,
0.5168632269,
-0.1673152,
-0.3895773888,
0.3750396967,
0.265304774,
-0.0519941226,
-0.3093418479,
0.7427586317,
0.6124562621,
-0.9811906815,
-1.2376699448,
-0.0625629798,
-1.1287138462,
-0.1034429967,
0.8528994322,
0.0891461223,
0.1247048229,
-0.4271820784,
0.0700669065,
0.1256228685,
-0.1038165465,
1.1571292877,
0.9449303746,
-0.6063555479,
0.1448516548,
-0.3985532522,
0.6396801472,
0.4381019175,
-0.7846529484,
-0.1770355105,
0.5652988553,
0.5585824847,
0.6753588915,
0.4848299623,
-0.042848099,
0.5956014991,
0.0888473839,
-0.22403422,
0.0859322622,
-0.3451036811,
-0.0803473294,
0.5365645885,
-0.4104530215,
0.3420237601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15054v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15054v2
|
Detection of developmental language disorder in Cypriot Greek children using a neural network algorithm
| 2023-11-25T15:23:46 | 2024-02-10T11:05:40 |
Georgios P. Georgiou, Elena Theodorou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Children with developmental language disorder (DLD) encounter difficulties in
acquiring various language structures. Early identification and intervention
are crucial to prevent negative long-term outcomes impacting the academic,
social, and emotional development of children. The study aims to develop an
automated method for the identification of DLD using artificial intelligence,
specifically a neural network machine learning algorithm. This protocol is
applied for the first time in a Cypriot Greek child population with DLD. The
neural network model was trained using perceptual and production data elicited
from 15 children with DLD and 15 healthy controls in the age range of 7;10
until 10;4. The k-fold technique was used to crossvalidate the algorithm. The
performance of the model was evaluated using metrics such as accuracy,
precision, recall, F1 score, and ROC/AUC curve to assess its ability to make
accurate predictions on a set of unseen data. The results demonstrated high
classification values for all metrics, indicating the high accuracy of the
neural model in classifying children with DLD. Additionally, the variable
importance analysis revealed that the language production skills of children
had a more significant impact on the performance of the model compared to
perception skills. Machine learning paradigms provide effective discrimination
between children with DLD and those with TD, with the potential to enhance
clinical assessment and facilitate earlier and more efficient detection of the
disorder.
|
[
-0.32941401,
-0.8850043416,
0.3287701607,
0.3201982081,
-0.1639875621,
0.2865009904,
-0.1484705061,
-0.4213375449,
0.2768839002,
-0.0572057217,
-0.7052741647,
-0.4961932302,
-1.0315886736,
-0.0173027087,
-0.5021574497,
0.4383385479,
-0.0418265723,
0.4572280943,
0.3716747761,
0.0948261172,
-0.1424440145,
-0.3666732907,
-1.440566659,
-0.2641970515,
0.5763977766,
0.318713516,
0.5150834918,
0.9382325411,
0.4384966791,
0.347974658,
-0.4018483758,
0.1253097653,
-0.2668410242,
0.0817743987,
0.0215929132,
-0.1800422817,
-0.5636684299,
-0.0949196741,
0.2227458954,
1.0237476826,
0.133240521,
0.1188719571,
0.257918328,
0.6886601448,
-0.397827208,
0.2183377594,
0.0275368355,
0.8710674047,
-0.4045689702,
-0.0920799524,
-0.0670577139,
-0.3411977887,
0.1533991843,
-0.4086121321,
0.0211109817,
-0.5106515884,
0.3876770735,
0.0159502979,
-0.5017575026,
-0.7241768837,
-0.7039449215,
0.4732390046,
-0.7416148186,
0.4662237465,
0.5297403932,
-0.0484709777,
-0.2969652414,
-0.3569169343,
-0.699092567,
-0.3615173399,
0.243690744,
-0.0545771532,
-0.0496018752,
-0.1476354301,
0.0624355339,
0.026695475,
-0.9459642768,
0.6458820701,
-0.6779040694,
-0.4695070982,
0.4705435634,
0.1306260526,
0.5566701293,
0.0943565071,
0.0489643067,
0.1026511863,
-0.370595932,
0.0534782149,
0.5588750243,
0.6202343702,
-0.1787163615,
0.4256460667,
-0.3950617909,
0.3944674134,
0.2160709351,
-0.2438050359,
0.392485708,
0.0819669962,
-0.0014790903,
0.3049301803,
0.8149561882,
0.0482175723,
0.4747727811,
-0.0486154184,
-0.3301073015,
0.4791732728,
0.0511595048,
-0.4764819443,
-0.2948168218,
-0.0000043892,
-0.5888468027,
-0.6706799269,
-0.2928002179,
-0.8278854489,
-0.5572012663,
-0.202021122,
0.1174620315,
-0.3607298136,
-0.5597118139,
-0.1625766903,
0.2816596329,
-0.089226611,
0.0127415201,
-1.1771515608,
0.4220004082,
0.5009078383,
0.7418383956,
-0.5373790264,
0.0158296097,
-0.2722810209,
-0.3266544938,
-0.5567198396,
0.5069285035,
-0.3038397133,
-0.1272109598,
-0.0286320634,
-0.0287640542,
-0.2280171365,
-0.6191584468,
0.5804786086,
-0.5983300209,
0.1382069439,
0.1902504563,
-0.4614159465,
0.009024132,
0.1299503446,
-0.880987823,
0.7554556727,
0.308540374,
-0.6856291294,
0.6443280578,
-0.5560032725,
-0.4785450101,
0.343151927,
0.0594485216,
-0.4657667875,
0.1643182337,
0.2398390323,
0.2938809991,
0.1868190467,
0.4160900414,
-0.4082318246,
-0.1795565635,
0.0754192695,
-0.7698885798,
0.9157136679,
0.6032275558,
-0.5623252988,
-0.1036211699,
-0.6933398247,
0.2427938879,
0.1415985823,
-0.7291949391,
0.0884041935,
0.0088619078,
0.199382931,
0.3470401168,
0.1781043559,
-0.3783429265,
-0.0151996771,
-0.4246219397,
0.0427489839,
0.5472789407,
-0.1630909145,
0.1882004142,
-0.2328743339,
0.8270609379,
0.4434308112,
0.2541069984,
0.270796597,
-0.7579026818,
-0.7065036893,
-0.0668321028,
0.554897666,
0.6116127372,
-0.6448209882,
0.8551231027,
-0.060551744,
-0.1472987831,
-0.5184890032,
0.1235000417,
0.4472634494,
0.5110600591,
-0.094794184,
-0.5387846828,
-0.7451722622,
-0.6168267131,
0.3466369808,
-0.2497440875,
0.2419547141,
0.2668397129,
0.3952518702,
-0.2118774503,
0.443269074,
0.2065298706,
-0.268779695,
-0.3048253953,
0.0203726366,
0.1430683136,
0.6470929384,
0.2799010873,
-0.7374507785,
-0.5579877496,
0.2525123954,
-0.9478809834,
-0.3495738208,
0.2525491416,
0.4772863686,
0.4824512601,
0.5467215776,
-0.3525601029,
0.6848416924,
0.5901241899,
-0.7290688753,
0.3659825623,
-0.2546339929,
-0.0360148586,
-0.6364315748,
0.1507280618,
-0.0672394484,
-0.2085546255,
-0.8512101173,
-0.1360411346,
-0.0484781675,
-0.08686921,
-0.4464371204,
0.2904999554,
-0.0674366355,
-0.1057424396,
-0.2159723341,
0.1192108542,
-0.4046038091,
0.1248178557,
-0.1072464362,
0.5431864262,
0.5910699964,
-0.7091286182,
0.4409195781,
-0.3214245141,
-0.5553712845,
0.3287465572,
-0.2941695154,
0.1784617454,
-0.0007786552,
-0.2005917579,
-0.9056093097,
0.2487645596,
0.7429392934,
-0.6782420278,
0.2867794633,
-0.0302606598,
-0.4913335741,
-0.6520887017,
0.2067385912,
0.478353709,
0.1380708516,
-0.3276595771,
0.2657207847,
0.5635999441,
-0.5354827046,
-0.4323809743,
-0.5318784714,
0.1381921023,
-0.3693186641,
-0.4965085983,
0.2291838676,
-0.0042854724,
-0.0548385531,
0.0306973793,
-0.0607030354,
-0.3995901644,
0.5962814093,
-0.2594350576,
-0.0970672518,
-0.5315807462,
0.1952846646,
0.1056042463,
-0.3640041947,
0.0175863113,
-0.2846583426,
0.9310195446,
0.1415210664,
-0.2069628239,
-0.8283126354,
0.0877618417,
0.8357485533,
0.0253417138,
0.46124053,
0.6793497801,
-0.5462536812,
-0.3007522523,
0.0770862997,
-0.1269918382,
-0.4890300632,
0.603801012,
-0.408144027,
-0.3139757514,
0.7148923874,
-0.1364210993,
-0.7504246235,
0.3447211981,
0.6365853548,
-0.1811183691,
1.2052955627,
0.7687118053,
-0.4575772285,
0.4022516906,
-0.272595495,
0.1820359975,
-0.6634391546,
-0.1643108577,
-0.4210710824,
-0.5755006075,
-0.5281513929,
-0.0219593402,
0.1472425461,
0.0191888995,
-0.1656398624,
-0.206357941,
-0.4364237487,
0.3730230927,
0.3215717375,
0.2004908472,
0.2441033125,
-0.159063518,
-0.6468396783,
-0.1791184098,
-0.7046578526,
-0.6445335746,
1.5423398018,
0.3580142558,
0.189353928,
0.2138800174,
0.687422812,
0.7542091012,
0.3432190716,
-0.8724503517,
0.4429197311,
-0.1653945595,
-0.4438888431,
-0.3827299476,
-0.4390768111,
-1.1310093403,
0.0231330823,
-0.1947932541,
-0.9821519256,
0.3479393423,
-0.1612992138,
-0.5069677234,
0.2061354518,
-0.5436593294,
0.8801099658,
-0.579597652,
0.0503129214,
-0.2631272078,
-0.3973101974,
0.342269063,
-0.4747621715,
0.2106416821,
0.1142004207,
-0.0062766219,
0.9470947981,
-0.3626030087,
0.6939765811,
-0.3639184833,
-0.2023787796,
-0.1602890193,
0.137712732,
0.0316857584,
-0.1321306229,
-0.245361641,
-0.2384527475,
-0.2241170257,
-0.3162736595,
-0.3989471197,
0.8151352406,
-0.932590425,
-0.1743472815,
-0.5951017141,
-0.449906379,
-0.1165454313,
0.4242785573,
-0.0520622097,
0.2727507651,
-0.1715103835,
-0.2793701887,
0.7127138972,
-0.1588424742,
0.7737860084,
0.5606336594,
-0.5115207434,
-0.2984135747,
0.7391067743,
0.1986412108,
0.1296270788,
-0.1971904635,
0.2205802947,
-0.107443437,
-0.9650961161,
-0.5175852776,
0.0398869589,
-0.5362058282,
0.1668262482,
-0.082518898,
-0.3669004142,
-0.3030868471,
0.2490749955,
-0.2175329179,
-0.5206287503,
-0.4132943153,
-0.159145698,
-0.2583039701,
0.8642010093,
-0.0201753676,
0.2877711654,
-0.3179654181,
0.4087373912,
0.008256739,
0.4025117457,
0.1634318829,
-0.4167027473,
-0.2639446557,
0.1674178541,
-0.5982775092,
-0.8534138799,
0.7580605745,
0.2867493629,
0.4252430201,
0.8250396848,
-0.2511194348,
0.3965466619,
-0.1922520399,
0.3129379749,
-0.1461851895,
-0.7808496356,
0.5142741799,
-0.0255613346,
0.1734067351,
0.1841854602,
0.57898736,
-0.5944703817,
-0.2176492214,
-0.6282730103,
-0.5680851936,
0.9433579445,
0.1140919328,
-0.0314323455,
0.0561823547,
0.2754178345,
-0.094238013,
0.032893613,
-0.4322427511,
-0.4014345109,
0.3156047761,
-0.5125771165,
-0.0199154411,
-0.0234368965,
0.0839797929,
-0.4604963958,
0.5676387548,
-0.1077117771,
0.3201488256,
0.1866139621,
-0.2584325075,
-0.4663166106,
-0.0670863762,
0.6976332068,
0.8414087892,
0.009737201,
-0.1137923002,
-0.0270857867,
-0.6548248529,
0.2002229989,
0.1870568395,
-0.262937665,
0.0187102165,
0.4218403995,
0.5141265392,
-0.198832199,
-0.6290917397,
0.4092683196,
-0.2904728651,
-0.2231457829,
-0.4957283139,
-0.0885131732,
0.1441581249,
0.4704141915,
0.4350342751,
0.0780543014,
0.0644199625,
-0.4351764023,
0.357584089,
0.247812897,
-0.4496873319,
-0.4082978666,
0.2775118649,
0.0138708074,
-0.873893559,
0.9650671482,
-0.3100174665,
-0.7355805635,
1.1007865667,
0.6421579719,
0.7405987382,
-0.4788991809,
0.5243915915,
-0.2410961092,
0.401881218,
0.4685528278,
0.634491086,
-0.0213231724,
-1.0328105688,
-0.2255347222,
-0.6036226153,
0.1320261061,
0.5983133316,
-0.4011933804,
0.0521474667,
-0.7933472395,
-0.4401747286,
0.1669628173,
0.2932983041,
-0.5410572886,
0.4783621132,
0.8258188963,
0.6036039591,
-0.9960636497,
1.0324965715,
0.5776830316,
-0.2111928314,
-0.484755367,
-0.0929980502,
0.2174987644,
-0.6713100076,
1.2781451941,
0.1310678422,
-0.0026479419,
0.159598887,
-0.0463267528,
-0.8767917752,
0.7772898674,
0.1406602561,
-0.3996759057,
0.1136996448,
0.3328499496,
0.8740244508,
-0.6561008096,
0.192815423,
0.7876507044,
0.4550389051,
-0.1325256079,
-1.1791452169,
-0.1629422158,
-0.4530469477,
-0.0438456498,
0.2278975993,
0.0764044449,
0.6116529107,
-0.1875303686,
-0.3054386079,
0.1471488923,
0.3074549139,
0.1948149502,
0.499999702,
0.3956621587,
0.9036810994,
0.983745873,
-0.0647147521,
0.4822377264,
-0.6289399862,
0.2643572092,
0.3692597151,
-0.0192239452,
0.6200992465,
0.3425608873,
-0.1305105835,
0.1801887751,
0.730162859,
0.3531851768,
0.7091220617,
0.4824075401,
-0.368460089,
0.2134358138,
-0.0359161161,
-0.0708788559,
0.3525073528,
0.7521109581,
-0.719502449,
-0.0767998397,
0.2817119956,
0.0757295266,
0.0384308882,
-0.336748004,
0.8199678659,
0.0026665779,
-0.3018860817,
0.6910492778,
0.1806264818,
0.4792411625,
-0.2461434901,
0.1231873557,
-0.320004344,
0.5901623368,
-0.142796725,
-0.3879359066,
0.3003036082,
-0.1576583087,
-0.088842012,
-0.1567805111,
0.4454745054,
-0.3810176849,
-0.7783253193,
0.403678596,
0.7484532595,
0.0325446725,
0.313562721,
-0.7919222116,
0.0746997222,
-0.2135142535,
-0.1014201641,
0.2592612207,
0.6476897597,
-0.3384983242,
1.0038015842,
0.6773928404,
0.6629400849,
0.2623889148,
0.0901575759,
0.7041585445,
-0.3609367609,
-0.4898821115,
-0.826192081,
0.1204518378,
0.1758073717,
-0.5435110927,
0.1781117767,
0.4515029788,
0.7245101929,
-0.0519707836,
0.6480488181,
-0.0929141268,
0.4589826167,
-0.1465085894,
0.9844827056,
-0.1086373329,
0.2526727021,
-0.1724857837,
-0.6443198323,
-0.6173933148,
0.8178904653,
-0.3621807992,
0.1498093903,
0.8912829757,
0.8227862716,
-0.3042584658,
0.0738291815,
0.2351498604,
0.2376487702,
0.3444188237,
0.5585728288,
0.7394174933,
-0.3330569863,
0.1585936397,
-0.4320996106,
-0.4401695728,
-0.0780128911,
-0.5013919473,
-0.5736442804,
-0.3936170936,
-0.2492267042,
-0.0960179195,
0.5239267945,
0.8365491629,
0.6365934014,
-1.0067381859,
-0.4201962352,
-0.2488570958,
0.2346060127,
-0.4478903413,
-0.2393160313,
0.4675463736,
-0.3648288846,
-0.7064899206,
0.6035339832,
0.0719447061,
-0.1085675508,
-0.3369197845,
-0.2164723575,
-0.3150347173,
-0.4231380522,
0.3800139725,
0.3407820761,
-0.5087174177,
-0.0528045259,
-0.4046341181,
-0.1844350696,
-0.0518183187,
0.5162295103,
-0.9925037026,
0.5199540257,
0.300875783,
0.7165393829,
0.2297448665,
-0.2916222215,
0.6475660205,
-0.1646552831,
0.0969634652,
0.5223039985,
0.2601471245,
0.1730865389,
-0.2538884282,
0.1652868539,
0.3281870782,
-0.3229494989,
-0.5224010348,
0.0794893131,
-0.4801514447,
0.1428831816,
0.5762677193,
-0.3111547232,
-0.2640185952,
-0.5318006873,
-0.015411092,
0.3262866139,
-0.3330060542,
1.2172701359,
0.5766867399,
0.0007810983,
-0.2239880413,
-0.3685380816,
0.4564725459,
0.3788449466,
-0.4910567403,
-0.408243686,
0.2295576483,
0.1550047547,
0.0661383346,
0.4941659868,
-0.2143555135,
0.4335780144,
-0.3310678601,
-0.1951554865,
0.068696931,
-0.3895500004,
-0.6387720704,
0.1213895157,
-0.1454006284,
-0.1677254736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15032v1
|
nlpBDpatriots at BLP-2023 Task 2: A Transfer Learning Approach to Bangla Sentiment Analysis
| 2023-11-25T13:58:58 | 2023-11-25T13:58:58 |
Dhiman Goswami, Md Nishat Raihan, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we discuss the nlpBDpatriots entry to the shared task on
Sentiment Analysis of Bangla Social Media Posts organized at the first workshop
on Bangla Language Processing (BLP) co-located with EMNLP. The main objective
of this task is to identify the polarity of social media content using a Bangla
dataset annotated with positive, neutral, and negative labels provided by the
shared task organizers. Our best system for this task is a transfer learning
approach with data augmentation which achieved a micro F1 score of 0.71. Our
best system ranked 12th among 30 teams that participated in the competition.
|
[
-0.4716112614,
-0.5525269508,
0.150894016,
0.9350845218,
-0.3833286762,
0.3635044098,
-0.1060261503,
-0.6959908009,
0.24452281,
0.134491086,
-0.5809715986,
-0.3693012297,
-0.8471999168,
0.0609416105,
-0.0658039302,
1.1461415291,
0.0863379091,
0.0026888449,
0.1383760571,
-0.1094620451,
-0.5967020988,
-0.1875563562,
-0.8890571594,
-0.3891952932,
0.50845474,
0.3050208092,
0.325619638,
-0.3973254859,
0.6227763891,
0.0110797482,
-0.1276254654,
0.1045285091,
-0.4895803928,
0.0089726467,
-0.8656046391,
-0.2913309932,
-0.3321171403,
-0.0309920516,
0.2668572366,
0.8720012307,
0.1375950724,
0.3686579168,
0.2472594231,
0.8677898049,
-0.49664253,
0.4866536856,
-0.412024647,
0.2948337197,
0.0009809245,
-0.3047723472,
-0.5837897658,
-0.6488423944,
0.0454667695,
-0.1316307485,
0.0912062675,
-0.056744203,
0.811434865,
0.233028993,
-0.4191026986,
-0.3518672287,
-0.5383265018,
1.0221010447,
-0.3895003498,
0.2673401535,
0.3520857394,
0.1036652848,
0.1459814459,
-0.1616460979,
-0.4144789577,
0.5581632853,
0.2073649019,
0.3664935827,
-0.1228904724,
-0.1410632133,
-0.0790536627,
0.1058164909,
-0.5732751489,
0.0186481792,
-0.6349570155,
-0.0092577832,
0.9343852997,
-0.1389154643,
-0.0050486624,
-0.3660476208,
-0.5356660485,
0.1477914453,
-0.5621220469,
0.2003602386,
0.0725190118,
0.546438992,
-0.3182820976,
0.5190197229,
-0.1230739728,
0.6958523393,
0.2304709107,
0.0331677943,
0.5024554133,
-0.4700138271,
-0.2188010961,
0.0577778667,
0.6144141555,
0.6373860836,
0.0916906372,
-0.0404199138,
-0.064629823,
-0.2650922537,
0.1497072577,
-0.5291769505,
-0.1060011163,
0.2017622143,
-0.7849710584,
-0.4486562014,
0.1611013114,
-1.2234207392,
-0.5827880502,
-0.3341092169,
0.4073250592,
-0.1616573632,
-0.546243608,
-0.0857444704,
0.01723429,
0.6555570364,
0.6649003029,
-0.8429895639,
0.0846863985,
0.7563067675,
1.033277154,
-0.4329248071,
-0.0451608226,
-0.2203756422,
0.1592973471,
-0.2312725037,
0.9038943648,
-0.2671629786,
-0.4825143814,
0.0422682501,
-0.1051660925,
-0.0588153079,
-0.4654881656,
0.4818319976,
-0.4442313313,
0.0303526893,
-0.6506562233,
-0.5590019226,
-0.4437829852,
0.1824712902,
-0.2677916586,
0.8762121797,
0.3768846691,
-0.7604754567,
0.3721547127,
-0.6723791957,
-0.5647556186,
0.1449930221,
0.1839194596,
-0.0618481971,
0.1477298886,
0.0097031714,
0.7678861022,
-0.1235454753,
0.208052054,
-0.3478641808,
-0.3103148639,
0.1451430321,
0.0635195896,
1.294341445,
0.2117275447,
-0.2770559788,
-0.0923698023,
-0.5690212846,
-0.2159765214,
-0.0891693309,
-0.3410744965,
0.0391054228,
-0.3570034802,
0.2433560193,
0.4471669793,
0.320861131,
-0.8129963279,
0.389162451,
-0.304192394,
-0.1566960812,
0.9396243095,
0.1611165702,
0.3417197764,
-0.250371933,
0.479067713,
-0.1477123052,
0.1650920808,
0.4437800944,
-0.9388076663,
-0.4222060442,
-0.0211074278,
0.1300210357,
0.6920983195,
-0.6706920862,
0.5552303195,
0.006609485,
-0.6553079486,
-0.5808469057,
0.1923387647,
0.0852249786,
0.2896088958,
0.5078252554,
-0.2566617429,
-0.7656846642,
-0.7189269662,
-0.146106571,
-0.3038592637,
0.3516936302,
-0.0753355324,
0.3508524001,
-0.2224428952,
0.7407885194,
-0.4080829322,
-0.569758296,
-0.7295260429,
0.4400005341,
0.4490500391,
0.4216647446,
0.5382275581,
-0.9567252398,
-0.9566482306,
0.1547149569,
-0.7330945134,
-0.5411288738,
0.1550460905,
0.1141965017,
0.6019726396,
0.3828711212,
-0.438398242,
0.3262344599,
0.8365612626,
-0.4395896494,
0.5286785364,
0.5818408728,
0.1373765916,
-1.2160435915,
0.1089348495,
-0.0451854803,
-0.2364869565,
-0.5171855092,
-0.2896398902,
-0.4983668923,
-0.0289420839,
-0.3928717673,
0.7326860428,
-0.0563231297,
-0.2742870152,
-0.4995314777,
-0.1542181224,
-0.0897925198,
0.5169665217,
-0.012923196,
0.4137655795,
0.5818046927,
-0.1082489341,
0.4809176028,
0.3725627661,
-0.0747427568,
0.5819464922,
-0.372944355,
0.0883075073,
-0.0727964342,
0.1107903719,
-1.2407670021,
-0.0015308805,
0.5108036995,
-0.7272442579,
0.4501130581,
-0.2373501509,
-0.3696309626,
-0.1652388573,
-0.363447845,
0.1747442335,
0.4278520346,
-0.3207085133,
0.3029665351,
0.4697159231,
-0.3991547525,
-0.622050941,
-0.7472820878,
-0.1384581625,
0.0594256297,
-0.3309940696,
0.1841088831,
0.0589662045,
-0.1404708326,
0.120657146,
0.2043611109,
-0.0694760978,
-0.1341254562,
0.387804538,
0.0701720491,
0.1357252896,
-0.1013765186,
0.2720743716,
0.0471400321,
0.1789261699,
0.2165835351,
0.8449870348,
-0.2951365411,
-0.0017223029,
-0.5131251216,
0.2325127572,
-0.0048933225,
0.1752390862,
0.9972412586,
0.9079967737,
-0.2938943207,
-0.2395431697,
-0.389472723,
0.2307335883,
-0.408675611,
0.2101223618,
-0.1219848692,
-0.8617468476,
0.3510432839,
0.0407780148,
-0.1619889587,
0.2582432032,
0.903491497,
-0.3317274749,
0.6959674358,
0.8019297123,
-0.1522182673,
0.452239424,
-0.236788407,
0.5025956035,
-0.722920835,
-0.5325596929,
-0.2434755266,
-0.22528781,
-0.7223544121,
-0.4062083364,
-0.1147392318,
0.0793205649,
-0.0213105604,
0.2119485885,
-0.2918567657,
0.198721081,
0.3257572055,
0.2066025883,
-0.0326924138,
-0.0626317412,
0.3642245233,
-0.082178019,
-0.3428077996,
-0.1543654501,
1.0308185816,
0.4527253807,
0.3287175596,
0.1981545985,
0.9122509956,
0.7061505318,
0.4626144171,
-0.8367515802,
0.7371503711,
-0.2488233,
-0.4076358676,
-0.1491915733,
-0.1579969376,
-0.6451199055,
0.0165560674,
-0.0457137115,
-0.7990270853,
0.5201576948,
-0.1764383912,
-0.0291000884,
0.2299084961,
-0.4339364469,
0.6239159703,
0.2631908953,
-0.5715346336,
-0.1836260259,
-0.7728128433,
0.3532504141,
-0.1173071563,
0.4200105071,
-0.2471805513,
0.1699919403,
0.9115606546,
0.1490712613,
0.8385931253,
-0.7542396188,
0.0133290589,
0.2501579523,
0.1386941373,
0.0350184701,
0.0364854038,
-0.2930751741,
0.0980395898,
-0.15021725,
-0.6639876366,
-0.4051728547,
0.4516806006,
-0.7360314131,
-0.162988916,
-0.4748701155,
-0.5941066742,
-0.2915925682,
0.1284532547,
0.1359992176,
-0.0076678046,
0.0536245294,
0.2553319335,
0.3777604103,
-0.2642543614,
0.5344960093,
0.0710906461,
-0.5419260859,
-0.2546541393,
1.1009185314,
-0.0251130965,
0.0356463231,
0.4687213004,
0.275926888,
-0.2948729396,
-0.6539309025,
-0.1219447851,
0.1912919581,
-0.7434457541,
-0.3578134477,
-0.4724804759,
-0.2055238038,
-0.5224461555,
-0.45513767,
-0.5206029415,
-0.5353471041,
-0.145508796,
-0.2456440479,
0.0690038279,
0.8341544271,
-0.6637694836,
0.2595681846,
-0.7445046306,
0.1044749841,
0.1194790527,
0.0895878896,
-0.1434446126,
-0.6499483585,
-0.2824675739,
-0.1418745965,
-0.418024689,
-1.0589439869,
0.5758501887,
0.0975928828,
0.2259884179,
0.2791996598,
-0.1929296851,
0.2404001057,
0.1302920133,
0.9491571188,
0.2674576044,
-0.9387466311,
0.9436933398,
-0.5364391804,
-0.0344185457,
0.7897780538,
0.8591169715,
-0.206062898,
-0.2662296891,
-0.4007953405,
-0.6774000525,
0.5346691012,
0.0491641946,
-0.1030535996,
0.1276020855,
0.3914184868,
0.3438371718,
0.3044208586,
-1.0472359657,
-0.2433628291,
-0.2732010484,
-0.3110485375,
0.1591103524,
-0.3312969506,
0.2197952271,
-0.569470346,
0.7300198078,
0.0210128184,
0.4412484765,
0.0750537515,
-0.049198173,
-0.1770633757,
0.1031551585,
0.328820318,
0.8965560794,
-0.7082542777,
-0.0872487947,
-0.0693517849,
-0.3560934961,
0.1240046024,
0.0355525129,
-0.2434282303,
-0.0999710262,
0.510839045,
0.6734483838,
-0.2305723876,
-0.4026966095,
0.7484353781,
0.1998672485,
-0.1403068006,
-0.1274775565,
-0.2807783186,
-0.0947306976,
0.3319079578,
0.4982864559,
0.2309722453,
0.3581473231,
-0.7693344951,
0.3130341172,
0.1956248581,
-0.7859556079,
-0.6834908724,
0.0856158286,
0.2408460677,
-0.1034795046,
0.2317446619,
-0.6501547098,
-0.7366697788,
0.1851001829,
0.5818049312,
0.8160968423,
-0.5403268933,
0.6198559403,
0.4683619142,
0.3157356679,
0.0735245571,
0.7304992676,
0.1385890692,
-0.9435284734,
-0.6649256945,
-1.0293556452,
-0.5557441115,
-0.1710217148,
-0.849055469,
0.542501986,
-0.596627295,
0.0606301911,
-0.1062865481,
0.1694029272,
-0.4521397054,
0.3852651119,
0.2441607267,
0.5002557635,
-1.316843152,
0.6814164519,
0.9463403225,
-0.4763516486,
-0.6000247002,
-0.0824426338,
-0.0452962257,
-0.5627656579,
1.1252506971,
0.2241960913,
0.097218655,
0.0353940055,
-0.5545523167,
-0.5488464832,
0.8697116375,
-0.0860894024,
-0.186389789,
0.1181984171,
0.1558728516,
0.5672197342,
-0.2132720202,
-0.1129726768,
0.3664723039,
0.4685653448,
0.0492117293,
-0.9103116989,
0.0650940984,
-0.2644504011,
-0.3854521513,
0.0188331716,
-0.8674862385,
0.8199405074,
0.0286810808,
0.0479815006,
-0.3623699844,
0.7169331312,
0.2063399255,
0.4803357422,
0.3544021249,
0.5245630741,
0.4197989404,
-0.066196464,
0.8462181687,
0.113234669,
0.7633257508,
0.9015282393,
-0.4374800324,
0.9393529296,
0.7258039713,
-0.5416600704,
0.4135617316,
0.5462598205,
-0.1784230173,
0.8256143928,
0.0817025229,
-0.1613531262,
0.1189379916,
-0.6500689387,
-0.2902008593,
0.5767127275,
0.3381542563,
-0.0592345484,
-0.1349893659,
0.3839383423,
-0.1522025466,
-0.0140353283,
-0.494019419,
0.8899232745,
0.2596993744,
-0.4189602733,
0.1791822314,
-0.2150478661,
0.7177943587,
-0.2322657555,
-0.1286566406,
-0.1928635836,
0.1753725559,
-0.5091531873,
-1.3510195017,
1.080258131,
-0.2876102328,
-0.2499232292,
-0.4211781919,
0.9956743717,
-0.2254765183,
-0.5844509006,
0.7265040278,
0.5123426914,
0.134330228,
-0.0283550341,
-0.7934927344,
0.3226240277,
0.1891863048,
-0.2736691535,
0.4484777749,
0.3093352318,
0.2237582952,
0.4740737379,
0.3759252727,
0.4718656838,
0.1441045254,
0.1746771634,
0.6811586022,
-0.5664460063,
-0.3180026114,
-0.7156167626,
0.1372753978,
-0.1373283267,
-0.2169731408,
0.8016959429,
0.5453108549,
0.8748317957,
-0.2292965055,
0.88802284,
-0.5723483562,
0.8378453255,
-0.3762179315,
0.5395011902,
-0.4126818776,
0.0179813281,
-0.5535463691,
-1.229716897,
-0.4515669346,
0.6767926216,
-0.3424487114,
-0.2982710004,
0.6503008008,
0.5754347444,
0.0885135159,
0.2101546228,
0.1254536659,
0.0910010338,
0.3554984629,
0.5043732524,
0.9663655758,
-0.5323761702,
0.1665111929,
-0.6798655391,
-0.3739934564,
-0.3431429267,
-0.724639535,
-0.8733060956,
-0.590654254,
-0.4116299748,
-0.4239886701,
0.2028154582,
1.1820807457,
0.2989061475,
-1.0605441332,
-0.3944568634,
-0.0405255631,
0.2717105448,
-0.0716006532,
-0.4102883935,
0.5267446041,
-0.3537870347,
-0.587911427,
0.1936266869,
0.4138030112,
-0.2700282037,
0.0040270011,
0.1944552064,
-0.7308883071,
-0.1902291924,
1.0119519234,
0.1103209034,
-0.2912305295,
-0.541400373,
-0.2392943054,
0.1690742671,
-0.0056513962,
0.5123204589,
-0.2795900404,
0.2502669692,
0.8059627414,
0.7318672538,
0.390298456,
0.2538927794,
0.4548488259,
-0.7602615356,
0.2558096051,
0.4504636228,
0.0814863145,
0.5311701298,
-0.1824083924,
0.7838934064,
0.4876388013,
-0.687368989,
-0.895405829,
0.1600469351,
-1.6467062235,
-0.2679573298,
1.33154881,
-0.1777821034,
-0.0924822241,
-0.4737637043,
-0.2422487438,
0.3563706577,
-0.3506540358,
0.8491345048,
0.6863306761,
-0.4742027223,
-0.271225661,
-0.4365479946,
0.515199244,
0.3480045795,
-0.7878187895,
-0.2365682423,
0.0396231301,
0.1021069065,
0.2321396321,
0.8302258849,
-0.0383496843,
0.2541797459,
-0.3556696475,
0.1462488323,
0.2182364762,
-0.3754558861,
-0.1918325424,
0.4157705307,
-0.0209255125,
-0.0308152959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15029v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15029v1
|
nlpBDpatriots at BLP-2023 Task 1: A Two-Step Classification for Violence Inciting Text Detection in Bangla
| 2023-11-25T13:47:34 | 2023-11-25T13:47:34 |
Md Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we discuss the nlpBDpatriots entry to the shared task on
Violence Inciting Text Detection (VITD) organized as part of the first workshop
on Bangla Language Processing (BLP) co-located with EMNLP. The aim of this task
is to identify and classify the violent threats, that provoke further unlawful
violent acts. Our best-performing approach for the task is two-step
classification using back translation and multilinguality which ranked 6th out
of 27 teams with a macro F1 score of 0.74.
|
[
-0.2539412081,
-0.9776120186,
0.2699367702,
0.9074988961,
-0.0796893537,
0.1097058356,
0.1083587259,
-0.8844153285,
-0.2183528244,
0.3735249639,
-0.5239636898,
-0.3324177265,
-0.8270809054,
0.2084201425,
-0.3615517914,
1.0170793533,
-0.0496996231,
-0.0278315023,
0.4230098724,
0.0706692562,
-0.7720927596,
-0.2805947065,
-0.919511795,
-0.1869750619,
0.5538200736,
0.2131701708,
0.37822932,
0.0900793746,
0.8597869277,
0.1533025354,
-0.1879176348,
0.0853705108,
-0.1391205937,
0.3916653097,
-0.5121386051,
-0.0731371939,
-0.2602217495,
-0.1507228464,
0.2886507213,
0.4126942158,
0.1322075427,
0.1038436741,
0.1107474044,
0.4465897381,
-0.6389371753,
0.2017042935,
-0.2753054202,
0.3818708956,
-0.3666282594,
-0.446603328,
-0.72790277,
-0.4729562104,
-0.131246835,
0.0662916526,
0.0674434006,
-0.0608511493,
0.4854110181,
0.3178467453,
-0.4383845925,
-0.3700709939,
-0.506621182,
0.553530097,
-0.3272833526,
0.4087708592,
0.4651726484,
-0.1282193661,
-0.1974514723,
-0.4824374616,
-0.5209632516,
0.4250160158,
0.099082686,
0.1785059422,
-0.1511373669,
0.2191126645,
0.3084504008,
0.131956622,
-0.8928960562,
0.3571373224,
-0.4384445846,
-0.1874225885,
0.8970234394,
0.2131366134,
0.1981376112,
-0.2381469458,
-0.5113534927,
0.0943320915,
-0.6146775484,
0.1521972716,
0.1737200916,
0.5803647041,
-0.2527540922,
0.5360762477,
0.0820370242,
0.7495821714,
0.0606955774,
-0.3676387966,
0.2765395343,
-0.7265579104,
-0.3236991763,
0.1802270114,
0.9371016026,
0.5104926229,
0.0147901624,
0.0651068389,
0.0070342636,
-0.1185792387,
0.2361579984,
-0.8701434731,
-0.1257988065,
0.3687170744,
-0.5938792825,
-0.3630850017,
-0.1434341222,
-1.15442729,
-0.619386673,
0.1719210595,
0.5111829638,
-0.3697349429,
-0.4348416924,
-0.1044772193,
-0.0527983084,
0.5572786927,
0.6335195303,
-0.9188486338,
0.2254981995,
0.6196830869,
1.0576660633,
-0.2258026898,
-0.329385072,
-0.4365506768,
0.144168511,
-0.4295891523,
0.7904902697,
-0.3254741728,
-0.3444052637,
0.2011607587,
-0.1225179657,
-0.0557634197,
-0.3138384223,
0.7767450809,
-0.3537009656,
-0.0000015914,
-0.2516645789,
-0.3929331005,
-0.3933028579,
0.1906273961,
-0.3397115469,
1.2268636227,
0.0670813471,
-0.9387835264,
0.6608049273,
-0.6353766322,
-0.6727958322,
0.3450386822,
0.0983628333,
-0.4566533267,
-0.2237773538,
0.0972058177,
0.7492186427,
-0.0956235528,
0.225666225,
0.0466595814,
-0.3069388568,
-0.1608288437,
-0.4000060558,
1.1224087477,
0.1755995303,
-0.315687865,
0.2521977723,
-0.5237188339,
-0.0172508955,
-0.084522143,
-0.4942970872,
-0.0008185122,
-0.0903111175,
0.4694915116,
0.5428509116,
0.2571062446,
-0.8745222688,
0.3523447216,
-0.2216945738,
-0.3431238532,
0.807846725,
0.2460758984,
0.0441842489,
-0.2304400057,
0.5425328016,
-0.2361252606,
0.2274513543,
-0.1367098093,
-1.1387214661,
-0.2409099191,
-0.2585630417,
-0.0917749107,
0.9753141999,
-0.6866333485,
0.4284102023,
0.2916152179,
-0.5984473228,
-0.2175368369,
-0.0617368072,
0.5274083018,
0.1948762983,
0.6274802685,
-0.0451794155,
-0.9497277141,
-0.4022152126,
-0.1299228817,
-0.4227194488,
0.3441362977,
-0.3120698631,
0.6742525101,
-0.162735492,
0.6201998591,
-0.2860296965,
-0.6602665186,
-0.5120119452,
0.5326839089,
0.1761393547,
0.3874174654,
0.6058071852,
-1.1759774685,
-0.9406207204,
0.1020731628,
-0.8231236935,
-0.6278796196,
0.1374468803,
0.3322414756,
0.3359537423,
0.7693193555,
-0.1133156866,
0.9105260372,
0.523032546,
-0.487934798,
0.5414148569,
0.2523277104,
0.2813085616,
-0.9582364559,
-0.255890429,
-0.1823815256,
-0.390088439,
-0.8159682155,
0.1659142524,
-0.3284809887,
-0.0892681256,
-0.3624330163,
0.5003671646,
0.0957234353,
-0.1119363829,
-0.2957330644,
-0.1386843324,
-0.3603005707,
0.3746799529,
0.0787988976,
0.599192977,
0.5249203444,
-0.6044549942,
0.5518804789,
0.4933208823,
-0.1431272775,
0.569206357,
-0.3983643353,
-0.1208007783,
0.0258463081,
0.0492605604,
-1.1684617996,
-0.3241343498,
0.4235132933,
-0.4385995269,
0.456907928,
-0.2646801174,
-0.7314213514,
-0.4098798931,
-0.3647948503,
0.3588954508,
0.1807916164,
-0.4356596768,
0.2039499879,
0.5272746086,
-0.3797159493,
-0.6005370021,
-0.8192952871,
0.1474039108,
0.1176228449,
-0.3973038495,
0.2010220289,
-0.2162120044,
-0.1415480226,
-0.3148693442,
0.1141804755,
-0.2696073651,
-0.0470686145,
0.5356407762,
-0.1945744902,
0.1616434902,
-0.0485466942,
0.0941554904,
0.1231549531,
0.1343387961,
0.2444709688,
0.9344804287,
0.0113535514,
-0.0567727089,
-0.6979740858,
0.6217101812,
0.1079605669,
-0.1250506341,
0.6278305054,
0.8969908357,
-0.3321157396,
0.1468582153,
-0.2613688707,
0.2899519503,
-0.4569345117,
0.4213983715,
-0.3596277833,
-0.9185395837,
0.2762871385,
0.0304211844,
0.0318291523,
0.2292332798,
1.0931605101,
-0.0560838878,
0.824657619,
0.8184224963,
0.1385704577,
0.533397615,
0.0314819068,
0.3793927431,
-0.6173997521,
-0.6078438163,
-0.5898475051,
0.0498692133,
-0.8764477968,
-0.4368855059,
0.1548824608,
0.0028392191,
-0.1151489094,
0.519369781,
-0.5322273374,
0.3635432124,
0.1391343921,
0.0832326189,
0.0225667115,
-0.2195086032,
0.1078575701,
-0.1288792789,
-0.3990599811,
-0.074837938,
0.966313839,
0.3765172958,
0.3544821441,
0.4730187953,
0.9310030937,
0.5103473663,
0.2423888892,
-0.8428889513,
0.675442636,
-0.1125411168,
-0.8029598594,
-0.3651537001,
-0.0021987206,
-0.991007328,
0.1970043331,
-0.0333118774,
-1.1913689375,
0.3882297873,
-0.2835715115,
-0.0704808161,
0.3541903198,
-0.366152674,
0.8151592016,
0.1461750418,
-0.4459661245,
-0.1223359406,
-0.7502731681,
0.4332355857,
-0.3503544629,
0.492624253,
-0.1272858977,
0.1897888035,
0.9413063526,
-0.2863101065,
0.6786797643,
-0.3983822465,
-0.2691231966,
0.3212879896,
0.129993856,
0.2304991931,
-0.0027834098,
-0.1681938767,
-0.1092739627,
-0.2543292642,
-0.3405172527,
-0.2122801393,
0.1425983012,
-0.1873352826,
-0.1966333091,
-0.7717189789,
-0.6626996398,
0.1406372935,
0.2951387763,
0.5007159114,
0.3826267421,
-0.0815534815,
0.118238084,
0.6501269937,
-0.2585878372,
0.9402923584,
0.3419639468,
-0.7994340658,
-0.1199798062,
0.7693086863,
-0.1482176781,
0.0084314868,
0.6598293781,
0.0442061611,
-0.3373363316,
-0.8428279757,
-0.1685419977,
-0.2541791201,
-0.7037764788,
-0.4411713481,
-0.6929648519,
-0.2735953033,
-0.6237973571,
-0.2729490697,
-0.2811985612,
-0.0244480856,
-0.0013565568,
-0.1844555289,
0.2411082238,
1.0855542421,
-0.6085633636,
0.3864135146,
-0.486307323,
0.5039914846,
0.1882422715,
0.1045673862,
-0.5004974604,
-0.7493040562,
-0.3466578424,
-0.320489794,
-0.3942605853,
-1.1649217606,
0.5649200082,
0.1778285652,
0.0749183148,
0.2590887845,
-0.0561770946,
0.6086258292,
-0.5008690953,
0.8400251269,
0.2427360862,
-0.7866532803,
1.071267128,
-0.4104861915,
0.1778735965,
0.492320329,
0.7537360787,
-0.3575085402,
-0.4171243906,
-0.219876647,
-0.7250729203,
0.6798732877,
0.1751821637,
-0.1087690368,
-0.0617511831,
0.1220584512,
0.0286114141,
0.0269830581,
-1.0567779541,
-0.3421746492,
-0.0500528552,
0.0212800745,
0.3512015641,
-0.5286333561,
0.2260971069,
-0.4316524565,
0.4122046828,
0.0604890212,
0.5845429301,
0.1974495947,
-0.0569869578,
-0.2768680751,
0.2460512072,
0.5562271476,
0.6547031999,
-0.4812731743,
-0.2082743794,
-0.0477841273,
-0.7398222089,
0.410680145,
0.0742706656,
-0.2111096382,
0.018873414,
0.7054979801,
0.5527842045,
-0.0641013235,
-0.4462269843,
0.9718173146,
0.0508164689,
-0.0438680314,
-0.3054552972,
-0.0553953759,
-0.6815257668,
0.5046452284,
0.5700200796,
0.1170091331,
0.4813497961,
-0.7352902293,
0.6125689745,
0.1004818007,
-0.5433602333,
-0.2179268003,
0.3951125145,
0.0922794193,
-0.4018508196,
0.1655350477,
-0.8409156799,
-0.9597935081,
0.2593891323,
0.7535405755,
0.8444524407,
-0.8924768567,
0.3456254303,
0.5220166445,
0.5664240122,
0.0882597268,
0.9337981939,
0.189818427,
-0.8336513638,
-0.7888137102,
-0.9210978746,
-0.4750861526,
0.0230545141,
-0.7901723385,
0.4785680771,
-0.7385895848,
0.0573754832,
0.1909344792,
0.0791160762,
-0.2670336664,
0.4678420424,
0.2562786043,
0.6419980526,
-1.0957125425,
0.8073664904,
0.66024822,
-0.3738683462,
-0.4974073768,
0.0689648762,
0.13587448,
-0.3222100735,
1.0635939837,
0.3174625933,
0.162278533,
0.0211018082,
-0.7018570304,
-0.4615783095,
0.6625512838,
-0.2381521314,
-0.0884665772,
0.0347161219,
-0.0103607932,
0.451192975,
-0.0207863413,
-0.0078090546,
0.5195116997,
0.6551349163,
-0.0485913604,
-1.2524185181,
0.0144100301,
-0.230727002,
-0.4381048083,
0.4876733124,
-0.6381496191,
1.0646113157,
-0.1036120728,
-0.0752337575,
0.0051290565,
0.5551216602,
0.1767052412,
0.5449568629,
0.1224586517,
0.5312827826,
0.4298554063,
-0.2771324217,
1.0506951809,
0.411141932,
0.424570471,
1.0740276575,
-0.3252064884,
0.8597198725,
0.2405312657,
-0.6630778313,
0.4642585814,
0.6345995665,
-0.2726541162,
0.7311155796,
-0.1404678375,
-0.3266041279,
0.095132567,
-0.5285845995,
-0.1862919182,
0.9178566933,
0.6518252492,
0.119259052,
-0.2091069221,
0.4828609228,
0.0844439194,
0.0980364606,
-0.6088818312,
0.8076716661,
-0.119642809,
-0.3297579885,
0.1983110309,
0.1207131445,
0.761564672,
-0.4277905524,
-0.1708819866,
0.136618495,
0.0985240117,
-0.3240673244,
-1.3675698042,
0.7756296396,
-0.0030928655,
-0.2569040954,
-0.4492252171,
0.8017974496,
-0.4105575085,
-0.1352073699,
0.6610340476,
0.1620876938,
0.3708830476,
-0.1420067251,
-0.6930856705,
0.2674337924,
0.0139378393,
-0.0373587422,
0.2549429536,
0.442727387,
-0.0352243856,
0.5717163086,
0.364539206,
0.0294658318,
0.4682606757,
-0.0709217042,
0.502574563,
-0.5834919214,
-0.3930274248,
-0.8592336178,
0.1205198616,
-0.0379783809,
-0.4354446232,
0.7684918642,
0.6847440004,
0.7579283118,
0.0663880259,
0.7003231049,
-0.6989315748,
0.5059328675,
-0.5784372091,
0.2847013474,
-0.3106302619,
-0.2488972694,
-0.7503573895,
-0.850545764,
-0.6305840611,
0.7751106024,
-0.0361984931,
-0.1267178357,
0.9211916924,
0.4357354045,
0.4225913882,
0.2012678236,
0.43521595,
0.1799920201,
0.3172641993,
0.5045495033,
0.6861523986,
-0.7972447872,
0.3769032657,
-0.4703740776,
-0.1419990063,
-0.4441553354,
-0.7135516405,
-1.0127288103,
-0.6074706912,
-0.3836893737,
-0.2940096557,
0.1750353128,
0.9948961735,
0.3084698021,
-1.0181406736,
-0.2400080264,
-0.0906258598,
0.3249473572,
-0.079372257,
-0.3382679522,
0.366099,
-0.2882060111,
-0.8598833084,
0.5952164531,
0.7228636146,
0.0081448192,
0.1209127381,
0.1483621746,
-1.0324710608,
-0.3805591166,
1.0580215454,
0.2100088894,
-0.4832666516,
-0.5172035694,
-0.45519346,
-0.0366393514,
-0.1463282406,
0.6392121911,
-0.4972667992,
0.4174413085,
0.8280031681,
0.5270505548,
0.4477448165,
-0.2060766071,
0.3961173296,
-1.0417101383,
0.7137879729,
0.4356500208,
0.0579041652,
0.2155280411,
-0.2961660028,
1.0120455027,
0.3403125405,
-0.8541858196,
-1.0667574406,
0.5566573739,
-1.1689217091,
-0.2670160532,
1.0140874386,
-0.3191800416,
0.0027838848,
-0.8729533553,
-0.3036772311,
0.4089111984,
-0.1706122607,
0.3496134281,
0.5611964464,
-0.4793750346,
-0.4858267903,
-0.683716476,
0.7597887516,
-0.0100751417,
-0.7286257744,
-0.0759240836,
0.0887736604,
-0.2573797703,
0.3583076596,
0.7414770126,
0.0158848688,
0.6041401625,
-0.0526006371,
0.085232161,
0.2797228396,
-0.697814703,
-0.1580647826,
0.3194867373,
-0.227279529,
0.0916808024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15023v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15023v1
|
Offensive Language Identification in Transliterated and Code-Mixed Bangla
| 2023-11-25T13:27:22 | 2023-11-25T13:27:22 |
Md Nishat Raihan, Umma Hani Tanmoy, Anika Binte Islam, Kai North, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Identifying offensive content in social media is vital for creating safe
online communities. Several recent studies have addressed this problem by
creating datasets for various languages. In this paper, we explore offensive
language identification in texts with transliterations and code-mixing,
linguistic phenomena common in multilingual societies, and a known challenge
for NLP systems. We introduce TB-OLID, a transliterated Bangla offensive
language dataset containing 5,000 manually annotated comments. We train and
fine-tune machine learning models on TB-OLID, and we evaluate their results on
this dataset. Our results show that English pre-trained transformer-based
models, such as fBERT and HateBERT achieve the best performance on this
dataset.
|
[
-0.0759029537,
-0.8899957538,
-0.3227159977,
0.3798266947,
-0.286121726,
0.5291189551,
-0.2055948079,
-0.8176167011,
-0.0329909138,
0.4753753841,
-0.1653533578,
-0.3930287361,
-0.8579390049,
0.3010802865,
-0.4565037191,
1.105486393,
0.0383800454,
0.0471429974,
0.8086155057,
-0.3926537633,
-0.380580157,
-0.361931771,
-0.5527891517,
0.0828741491,
0.6863406301,
-0.0350836068,
0.7160714269,
0.5163215399,
0.8137172461,
0.3673508763,
0.1849577874,
0.4536622763,
-0.7231645584,
0.1699874997,
-0.4915849268,
-0.0194080826,
-0.0403021201,
-0.4162113965,
0.3546291292,
0.402700752,
0.1257686317,
0.1760850102,
-0.1907490641,
0.3288935721,
-0.9340467453,
0.01664792,
-0.8120666146,
0.0237692893,
-0.4994098842,
-0.1419273764,
-0.7930682302,
-0.698779881,
-0.2309018523,
-0.2118634731,
0.0465547293,
0.0287814643,
0.7943137288,
-0.0499669574,
-0.5481147766,
-0.8009431362,
-0.899564147,
0.7227829099,
-0.5544426441,
0.4036287367,
0.349973321,
0.2629193664,
0.0000570278,
-0.2274817675,
-0.4625304639,
0.3101710081,
-0.2690563798,
-0.0967095494,
-0.4614054859,
-0.0950827524,
0.0797600746,
0.0422428362,
-0.6118069887,
0.2942458093,
-0.8032520413,
-0.0881700367,
0.8214567304,
-0.0887562856,
0.5319123864,
-0.2849361002,
-0.2104994655,
0.2610300481,
-0.5704493523,
-0.2680413723,
0.7154974937,
0.8243581057,
-0.0777588114,
0.4689463973,
0.1317837685,
0.7331938744,
0.2042853236,
-0.2252157331,
0.4933717847,
-0.1612303704,
-0.2882450819,
0.0413544104,
1.0164932013,
0.2677879333,
0.5622485876,
-0.2850813568,
-0.3723104596,
0.0217693616,
0.5693958998,
-0.7212396264,
-0.2782602906,
0.2962051928,
-0.3331205845,
-0.4983507097,
0.0074984403,
-0.8642668128,
-0.7790107727,
0.1721159965,
0.278724432,
-0.6709684134,
-0.4231638908,
-0.1965429783,
-0.1186316684,
0.3375587165,
0.1252985895,
-0.9236928225,
0.0933939293,
0.5506873727,
0.5022227764,
-0.0911392197,
-0.0480199605,
-0.3294404149,
0.1071810499,
-0.5687761307,
0.4152876735,
-0.7837904096,
-0.0687898993,
0.5261583328,
0.0187145434,
0.2222466171,
-0.7601840496,
0.588922441,
-1.1565375328,
-0.0860704556,
-0.0401601978,
-0.0997148827,
-0.0877507702,
-0.1140457243,
-0.5825267434,
0.9298276305,
0.2450747788,
-1.2254300117,
0.3810868561,
-0.5044557452,
-0.7354767323,
0.3680809438,
0.1416765451,
-0.4413616955,
0.1508261859,
0.0296773817,
0.3189837635,
-0.0148937553,
0.1745492816,
-0.171568349,
-0.2842386365,
0.2789421678,
-0.2191513777,
1.3671497107,
0.8949123621,
-0.1303018034,
0.0719252527,
-0.836130023,
-0.078542918,
0.4773195684,
-0.1472001523,
-0.5390045643,
-0.0104102986,
0.3415756822,
0.0065386347,
0.0009130203,
-0.7897202373,
-0.1272351593,
-0.1475361884,
0.1565365195,
0.7416865826,
-0.1591139734,
0.0604745932,
-0.3482712209,
0.5759336948,
0.2891879678,
-0.0678240135,
-0.1843669713,
-0.5265719891,
-0.3095792532,
-0.355493784,
0.4205840528,
0.7452426553,
-0.9913975596,
0.3405301273,
-0.2179661095,
-0.5377493501,
-0.8321998119,
0.1206487343,
0.5318149328,
0.0049916613,
0.3432556391,
-0.2047121674,
-0.8269330263,
-0.7225126624,
-0.3264866471,
-0.2264346182,
0.0251729786,
0.2486263365,
0.2630766034,
-0.2540507019,
0.8809862137,
-0.2392386943,
-0.191612035,
-0.3554205894,
0.5822532177,
-0.1137371063,
0.3509892225,
0.7214163542,
-0.9356254935,
-0.9980317354,
0.2967227697,
-0.6205394864,
-0.7299159169,
-0.0637306347,
0.0861410424,
0.2398082912,
0.2457942516,
0.0978436619,
0.3327563703,
0.5510454178,
-0.0563100763,
0.4707955122,
0.1539718658,
0.5101287961,
-0.9804983139,
-0.1130210161,
0.0340941735,
-0.2541495562,
-0.9730743766,
0.458132118,
0.1866934896,
0.0474231131,
-0.6032934785,
0.3085031211,
-0.2640593946,
0.2852151394,
-0.2278281003,
0.0129359495,
-0.3740371466,
0.2100802213,
0.0653138682,
0.5669878721,
0.3902903795,
-0.1748186946,
0.6282413602,
0.1812810451,
-0.4300659001,
0.499276042,
-0.2792845368,
0.3894022405,
-0.4028784633,
-0.1189767644,
-1.0662477016,
-0.3865999877,
0.5715997219,
-0.5095689297,
0.4299971461,
-0.5887365341,
-0.5623371601,
-0.3856959343,
-0.0204799324,
0.8916783929,
0.4614323974,
-0.6233638525,
0.4998062849,
0.5645705462,
-0.0394177437,
-1.1683782339,
-0.6755962372,
-0.0001908646,
-0.4018475115,
-0.3655172586,
0.0924303383,
-0.0248453617,
-0.3301392794,
-0.3234336078,
0.3306666911,
-0.703420043,
-0.0480648093,
0.3739371002,
0.0739054307,
-0.2388892025,
-0.2186823338,
-0.0513261929,
0.4903079569,
0.1558824927,
0.1557072848,
0.5321916938,
0.1864505112,
-0.1461066008,
-0.2650835812,
0.6538135409,
0.2518601418,
-0.2328555584,
0.7951589227,
0.7418881655,
-0.3866477013,
-0.2209159136,
-0.5104751587,
0.2834934592,
-0.4867273569,
0.5804262757,
-0.3340618908,
-0.580200851,
0.6563456655,
0.1061873659,
0.1201086268,
0.1353235543,
0.6648737192,
-0.0721695647,
0.6016340256,
0.4685419202,
-0.2029690146,
0.4259287119,
0.3012773395,
0.4067211747,
-0.2521737814,
-0.0264057945,
-0.7562301755,
-0.1714353859,
-1.0318596363,
-0.4296603203,
-0.2484751046,
-0.1980286986,
-0.0903852358,
0.6450617313,
-0.244181335,
0.7901380658,
0.1320406795,
0.0732021183,
0.0761607438,
-0.103829734,
0.0384020731,
-0.1105151549,
-0.4045218825,
-0.2505633235,
1.2355158329,
0.4270114303,
0.8238154054,
0.5782334208,
0.6198216081,
0.7323181033,
0.519554019,
-0.4824880362,
0.2569762766,
-0.2215645909,
-1.0878537893,
0.1573920995,
-0.6849756241,
-1.0552997589,
0.1580734551,
-0.1785477847,
-0.8126927614,
0.1291810423,
-0.0265122037,
-0.2658959031,
0.5576706529,
-0.833050251,
0.5968622565,
-0.1510412544,
-0.3395424783,
0.1554914862,
-0.8401340246,
0.4861587286,
-0.6438019276,
0.6631808281,
0.2403213233,
0.2101915479,
0.6176976562,
0.0423782878,
0.8465926051,
-0.0827334374,
-0.3039522469,
0.2539263368,
0.0914422423,
0.1352694929,
-0.4562729597,
-0.1409849823,
0.4495198727,
-0.1875257045,
-0.5679737926,
-0.2844283879,
0.3928657174,
-0.7475497723,
-0.1282792836,
-0.4062108696,
-0.566362679,
0.0132609112,
0.3917215765,
0.2705944479,
0.5703493357,
-0.1601352543,
0.1247143522,
0.6087943316,
-0.4914419651,
0.380728662,
0.5656867623,
-0.6531230807,
-0.3989979029,
1.0367623568,
0.1665223986,
0.2270624638,
0.2934961319,
-0.03936252,
0.00398276,
-0.7279601097,
-0.5973348022,
0.1930846423,
-0.7931265235,
-0.2868170738,
-0.5726543665,
-0.4875188172,
-0.4276544154,
-0.1937692165,
-0.2659059763,
0.0626298487,
0.1063026115,
0.0244319756,
-0.1330996305,
1.2668739557,
-0.0259146839,
0.589247942,
-0.695156455,
0.5211497545,
-0.0435038805,
0.4776297808,
-0.2486951351,
-0.9863411784,
-0.3152668774,
0.0728294477,
-0.2178178877,
-1.3886686563,
0.4280936122,
-0.0641770214,
0.1439191699,
0.7941073179,
0.4130944908,
0.4825284183,
-0.6603779793,
0.4173176587,
0.0406540185,
-0.479391247,
0.2441883385,
-0.5269426107,
0.0778443664,
0.2187501341,
1.0657464266,
-0.4760116935,
-0.650903821,
-0.3385886252,
-0.7632049918,
0.8790192008,
0.2601353824,
0.4563193321,
-0.4552468956,
0.0525647476,
0.3939542174,
0.1758268923,
-1.1310368776,
-0.5875324011,
-0.1506809443,
-0.3016070426,
0.4535417259,
-0.4916104674,
-0.1117071658,
-0.010807056,
0.5143415928,
0.1259285361,
0.2939472198,
-0.4446237683,
-0.5614054799,
-0.3319133818,
0.2292508781,
0.4540457428,
0.8727146387,
-0.3930125833,
0.0410209298,
-0.0338731967,
-0.5098946691,
0.096375607,
-0.1166868433,
-0.173630178,
0.1255143583,
0.2238035947,
0.5422370434,
-0.1093202233,
-0.6566983461,
0.5834708214,
0.0356213301,
0.2365248799,
-0.0066593364,
-0.1547362804,
-0.3615843952,
0.0978602692,
0.6445332766,
0.2338692248,
0.0805858746,
-0.5636882186,
0.2397925407,
0.3703581989,
-0.3968698084,
-0.33937639,
0.2887922525,
0.258474499,
-0.7436921,
0.490023464,
-0.4780947566,
-0.7432889938,
0.2647120655,
0.8598801494,
0.7262175083,
-0.6712696552,
0.3054784536,
0.5056586266,
0.6242948174,
0.7267260551,
0.1540156752,
0.0831614584,
-0.9159116149,
-0.3177917898,
-0.6624376178,
-0.0947999805,
0.2508569658,
-0.7313171029,
0.3869077563,
-0.7351477742,
-0.1291816533,
0.2929237187,
-0.3556078672,
-0.4851804674,
0.1981529444,
0.480024904,
0.5361731052,
-1.3080925941,
0.9001698494,
0.3965936005,
-0.3177263737,
-0.2142745256,
-0.0146177132,
0.0526476912,
-0.8393896222,
0.9597830176,
0.1390288919,
0.0335590243,
-0.0479217283,
-0.4138384163,
-0.373377353,
0.0591897033,
0.1520842612,
-0.0447147302,
0.0428220965,
0.500587523,
0.6415532231,
-0.2953621745,
0.6146184206,
0.4795039594,
0.2077344507,
0.0932647958,
-0.8270992041,
-0.0865726545,
-0.3288389742,
-0.244122684,
0.4251654148,
-0.5410297513,
0.4691704214,
-0.1428783536,
-0.3764875531,
-0.1205559,
0.654214561,
-0.2547521293,
0.091376178,
0.2876091599,
0.3669011295,
0.5316281319,
-0.2100628465,
0.6168032289,
0.0806978866,
0.2451862693,
1.1910024881,
-0.1975270063,
0.7282235622,
0.0707022771,
-0.3773700297,
0.4912330806,
0.4639585614,
-0.0647802576,
0.4443079829,
0.3231240809,
-0.0918340534,
0.3296072483,
-0.2587142289,
-0.1489511281,
0.615514338,
0.4204632938,
-0.4443529248,
-0.2284282595,
0.1187599897,
0.1867650449,
0.153358683,
-0.178081423,
0.9862629175,
-0.3605223596,
-0.2089443654,
0.6014031172,
0.2716300488,
0.7831833363,
-0.6521531343,
0.1989377588,
-0.1634974182,
-0.1134920269,
-0.2986280024,
-0.6072960496,
0.6489599347,
0.2454361767,
-0.0800066888,
-0.1372012198,
0.3358178139,
-0.6393684745,
-0.4436606467,
0.4231988788,
-0.1387098134,
0.2127016187,
0.1942928135,
-0.630453527,
0.3627421558,
0.0647006556,
0.2715006173,
0.2895286083,
0.6718438864,
-0.1160592362,
0.5580602884,
0.3599463701,
0.2307324708,
0.6171198487,
-0.0312429871,
0.6005412936,
-0.4874970615,
-0.2261985689,
-0.782843411,
0.3598249853,
-0.0833981112,
-0.1276716441,
0.7422062159,
0.5582829714,
1.0127087831,
-0.1020618975,
0.8666411638,
-0.4799284637,
0.6591330767,
-0.1620864123,
0.8064497709,
-0.2617682815,
0.0083569568,
-0.6703985929,
-0.6496511102,
-0.3367601335,
0.4653792083,
-0.1813807338,
0.2198276222,
0.7039502859,
0.7481299043,
-0.3346250951,
0.0820570365,
0.4240345359,
0.4180163443,
0.1847264767,
0.3233066201,
0.763620615,
-0.6637243032,
0.5396296978,
-0.4147626758,
-0.2162218392,
-0.4148806036,
-0.7934709191,
-1.02663517,
-0.6949121952,
-0.4979273081,
-0.5034229755,
0.3480090201,
1.0319375992,
0.5944807529,
-1.2572443485,
-0.3417364359,
0.5457636118,
0.1791365594,
0.0072628302,
-0.2072616369,
0.1016354188,
-0.3089420497,
-0.9877388477,
0.1457942426,
0.0849520117,
-0.0967353359,
-0.0079594515,
0.2361237407,
-0.5833415985,
0.3962514102,
0.4659107924,
0.336465776,
-0.7687006593,
-0.4279669225,
-0.3486464322,
-0.2393881679,
0.2168102562,
0.5944250822,
-0.3750201464,
0.8536819816,
0.4427705109,
0.973742485,
-0.1080525219,
0.3145274222,
0.3961538374,
-1.0085788965,
0.2806621194,
0.1800741106,
0.227249071,
0.4477427006,
-0.1669701189,
0.3929636776,
0.1307134479,
-0.5508186817,
-0.924223721,
0.2189491987,
-0.8407571316,
-0.1670985818,
1.2160061598,
-0.4660174549,
-0.1526957303,
-0.6279149055,
-0.2864198387,
0.2729340196,
-0.3850718141,
0.9619678259,
0.6964803934,
0.5639723539,
-0.1218119562,
-0.3651478589,
0.5651131868,
0.2138602138,
-0.4283024967,
0.2632743418,
0.4946224391,
0.1032378376,
0.286564678,
0.2798945606,
-0.0678841174,
0.3018888533,
-0.0757624581,
-0.036636889,
0.1499772221,
-0.4951982796,
-0.183117792,
0.5283583403,
-0.1699338406,
-0.1389873028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15016v1
|
E-CORE: Emotion Correlation Enhanced Empathetic Dialogue Generation
| 2023-11-25T12:47:39 | 2023-11-25T12:47:39 |
Fengyi Fu, Lei Zhang, Quan Wang, Zhendong Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Achieving empathy is a crucial step toward humanized dialogue systems.
Current approaches for empathetic dialogue generation mainly perceive an
emotional label to generate an empathetic response conditioned on it, which
simply treat emotions independently, but ignore the intrinsic emotion
correlation in dialogues, resulting in inaccurate emotion perception and
unsuitable response generation. In this paper, we propose a novel emotion
correlation enhanced empathetic dialogue generation framework, which
comprehensively realizes emotion correlation learning, utilization, and
supervising. Specifically, a multi-resolution emotion graph is devised to
capture context-based emotion interactions from different resolutions, further
modeling emotion correlation. Then we propose an emotion correlation enhanced
decoder, with a novel correlation-aware aggregation and soft/hard strategy,
respectively improving the emotion perception and response generation.
Experimental results on the benchmark dataset demonstrate the superiority of
our model in both empathetic perception and expression.
|
[
-0.5436159372,
-0.8535784483,
0.3533616662,
0.0477237999,
-0.2653643787,
0.0043733693,
-0.0403550752,
-0.3157543838,
0.661223948,
0.3114272952,
-0.6039177179,
-0.3151573539,
-0.3097537756,
0.2350651771,
0.0599381663,
1.0174765587,
0.4724928737,
0.005602058,
-0.1611213982,
-0.104606159,
-0.1456994265,
-0.5596273541,
-0.8314596415,
-0.3228868246,
0.2894817591,
0.7506801486,
0.1335565299,
0.2112364322,
0.5312340856,
0.290732801,
0.0649010763,
0.431812048,
-0.5242647529,
0.2984919548,
0.1985007823,
-0.0580107011,
-1.1620436907,
-0.3560808897,
-0.0574356578,
0.0514091179,
-0.3541898429,
-0.1034532189,
0.0935059786,
0.6841157675,
-0.8242158294,
0.1291976422,
-0.2855440378,
0.1887611449,
0.4049646556,
-0.2863128483,
-0.5168896317,
0.0230031665,
0.0098563423,
-0.4261538684,
0.2442333102,
0.2880550623,
0.497254163,
0.002762452,
-0.7040899396,
-0.3681420684,
-0.4910155833,
0.7310529947,
-0.378897965,
-0.0365421027,
0.2832323313,
0.3323007822,
0.4559579492,
-0.5498169661,
-0.4298347831,
0.0622293912,
-0.0272080973,
0.7539523244,
-0.0344880521,
0.3915788233,
0.139971599,
0.4465504885,
-0.2586938441,
-0.2071917951,
0.2243184596,
-0.1218150705,
0.5741904378,
0.58884269,
0.0697783157,
-0.378028065,
-0.0117311627,
-0.1771448851,
-0.2547641098,
0.1436293721,
0.1599782854,
0.2151580602,
-0.3341370821,
0.3070581257,
-0.0794711635,
0.6708133221,
0.7786488533,
-0.1290094703,
0.3162461221,
-0.2221037,
-0.1790312678,
0.4086579978,
0.6871425509,
0.8731222153,
-0.0188466404,
0.2534595728,
0.1663772166,
0.1226099879,
0.3333128989,
-1.0186834335,
-0.2616160214,
0.5855862498,
-0.468699038,
-0.439094007,
-0.1438300014,
-1.1879816055,
-0.1154554635,
-0.0129171573,
-0.1695415676,
-0.5092846155,
-0.4356531501,
-0.064390488,
-0.1058480069,
0.3471693397,
0.3787388206,
-0.9335758686,
0.2737750709,
0.4918143451,
0.6682293415,
0.2364474088,
0.093404986,
-0.6316409111,
0.3330280185,
0.0866166577,
0.7574998736,
-0.7465640903,
-0.6356443763,
0.0411307812,
-0.2740422785,
0.2202856839,
-0.0290386304,
0.7632091045,
-0.0191240832,
-0.1429232955,
0.0232752841,
-0.3433790803,
-0.038866058,
0.6725360155,
-0.6548584104,
0.5003160238,
0.1785579026,
-0.9904515743,
0.0934853181,
-0.4145802855,
-0.3575510979,
-0.2386397272,
-0.0126943449,
-0.4818540514,
0.1410892606,
0.4442673624,
0.386269182,
-0.6006395221,
0.259678483,
-0.4793481231,
-0.0355822332,
0.0101727871,
-0.1450896412,
0.2083482593,
0.543884933,
-0.1494858861,
-0.2027742565,
-0.8682003617,
0.1316272914,
-0.0496444739,
0.0558494776,
-0.2863291204,
-0.1839136332,
-0.1928136349,
0.3020364344,
0.2817942798,
-0.7473966479,
-0.3034852147,
-0.0474230535,
0.23695077,
0.5172920823,
0.251648277,
0.5439705253,
-0.2577518821,
0.4041385651,
0.443402797,
0.2637837529,
-0.5948348641,
-0.3097968698,
-0.8119668961,
-0.3494309783,
-0.4565378428,
0.5096185803,
-0.3431960046,
0.8996267319,
-0.1607185602,
-0.5810647011,
-0.5003130436,
-0.16015926,
0.8155739903,
0.8432758451,
0.3143509924,
-0.5076901913,
-0.5977693796,
-0.7031034231,
-0.2054111063,
-0.0970774069,
0.1182000712,
0.9734681845,
0.0264804233,
-0.147485584,
0.9206828475,
-0.6691811681,
-0.1934300661,
-0.3713023067,
0.231536746,
0.089254804,
0.5041726828,
0.3584771752,
-0.7094216943,
-0.6953263879,
-0.0450246893,
-0.6333917379,
-0.2092765719,
0.0096257925,
-0.5164153576,
-0.1009232327,
0.1353625208,
-0.3163711727,
0.1664984673,
0.5810235739,
-0.22436966,
0.2756653726,
0.0122178104,
0.5022798777,
-1.4047011137,
0.0024409038,
0.0414157584,
0.1215479001,
-0.7279036641,
-0.2430642247,
-0.0627712309,
-0.1737016737,
-0.277010709,
0.1326780319,
-0.4161963761,
0.1393535733,
-0.0278398916,
0.2114071548,
0.3785106838,
0.5814370513,
-0.0001888668,
0.1272791326,
0.6126080751,
-0.5040810108,
0.4680938721,
0.7307247519,
0.1670237184,
1.2907122374,
-0.5242444277,
0.4032479525,
-0.1747148335,
0.6338068247,
-0.8340570331,
-0.2548567057,
-0.0278515127,
-0.4928815663,
0.4899403155,
0.1823607683,
-0.0946448594,
-0.3311409056,
-0.3448421061,
0.493368268,
0.5595957041,
-0.5779131055,
1.169677496,
0.2098417729,
-0.0779752508,
-0.3800509572,
-0.7848653793,
-0.1294605881,
-0.2692369223,
-0.8085616827,
-0.0651157796,
-0.1907217503,
-0.152280435,
-0.2675616741,
0.3341167569,
-0.1284104437,
-0.1498737484,
0.1631281227,
-0.1110050753,
-0.0482662693,
0.0141486162,
0.398239255,
-0.1702024192,
0.1321919709,
0.4393285811,
0.5436161757,
-0.2642663419,
-0.4949840903,
-0.4504581094,
0.7121394277,
0.5115397573,
-0.2664280832,
0.5233024955,
0.8008398414,
0.032726001,
0.2023212612,
-0.400741905,
-0.4171560109,
-0.4522067904,
0.3626365662,
-0.639569521,
-0.6986504197,
0.5202174783,
-0.4700519145,
-0.0293072872,
0.0572687499,
0.5549685955,
0.2243351191,
1.5889947414,
0.0574804023,
0.141107887,
0.5118348598,
-0.0522867255,
0.7724833488,
-1.4820969105,
-0.0717964545,
-0.34775576,
-0.1322917789,
-0.2835598886,
0.015261516,
0.4865915775,
0.2022679448,
-0.6546522975,
-0.039652694,
-0.5822199583,
-0.0321824141,
0.3000065386,
0.5745004416,
0.2372687757,
0.014226282,
-0.0335658751,
-0.1381527036,
-0.5833373666,
-0.1778890491,
0.9474045634,
0.0442751907,
0.6713018417,
0.3554641306,
0.9579445124,
0.071042195,
0.3928714395,
-0.7833209634,
0.4028244019,
-0.064423047,
-0.2903830409,
0.1458641142,
-0.2871887982,
-0.6361727715,
0.2150927037,
-0.2450194657,
-0.8661714792,
0.0825406313,
0.4812081456,
-0.5487940907,
0.0777038187,
-0.8539949656,
0.3236443102,
-0.1693378687,
-0.7957831621,
-0.3105964959,
-0.7969030142,
0.5525934696,
-0.1507907957,
0.2317634672,
0.051513955,
0.4002940357,
0.3404028118,
-0.4026132822,
0.9645484686,
-0.022110112,
0.1112458929,
0.613011539,
0.4039905369,
0.572281599,
0.1766208559,
-0.3277794123,
-0.2770819962,
-0.6196068525,
-0.3625163734,
-0.6751124859,
0.6395978928,
-0.6961151958,
-0.5416947007,
0.0795143396,
-0.4133396447,
-0.2182086557,
-0.1510515958,
0.2374979407,
0.5861387849,
-0.6026387215,
0.0522009321,
0.3245818019,
-0.2073018849,
0.1336889118,
0.4316695929,
0.1508924365,
-0.8020417094,
0.8431308866,
-0.5947414041,
0.4054511189,
0.367323786,
0.4007015526,
-0.0478034429,
0.3502371013,
-0.161048308,
0.0278781876,
-0.6112481952,
-0.4868012667,
-1.0598466396,
0.0733741224,
-0.8590536118,
-0.7080879807,
-0.4174433053,
-0.1627044827,
-0.3428919315,
-0.3108755946,
0.6632936597,
0.6511427164,
-0.4355609119,
0.5429425836,
-1.1118737459,
0.0931623057,
0.4620265663,
-0.0986564904,
0.3730502725,
-0.235762164,
-0.3228885233,
0.1078580916,
-0.5765554309,
-0.7263033986,
0.7616864443,
0.4954161048,
0.2361119241,
0.8947265148,
0.2736566365,
0.7170619369,
-0.2391437143,
0.9837325215,
0.7084808946,
-1.1269093752,
0.620905757,
-0.25196895,
0.0310345199,
0.2672075629,
-0.0251474865,
-0.3280211091,
-0.2255318165,
-0.8971611261,
-1.0303053856,
0.6710478663,
0.0146185867,
0.1359118968,
-0.3389388621,
0.1014579087,
-0.097031869,
0.1580423564,
-0.1301839501,
-0.1793461293,
-0.4433120191,
-0.3958093226,
-0.1790280044,
-0.3853791356,
-0.3414160609,
-0.212663576,
0.1921388805,
-0.31560269,
0.6713590622,
0.3376683295,
-0.0500588007,
-0.3643448055,
0.1563838869,
0.2319376469,
-0.2590745687,
-0.4014797211,
0.0843052045,
0.0928011537,
-0.2528571188,
-0.069870919,
-0.4766123295,
0.4870857894,
-0.3495256007,
0.1596731395,
0.8221307397,
0.2634052932,
-0.4389045537,
0.5824282169,
-0.1301326901,
0.1331349462,
-0.284078449,
-0.0351636596,
0.0462716222,
0.1453194618,
0.0056927227,
-0.0252493136,
0.3979864717,
-0.3449969292,
0.5153421164,
-0.0288091246,
-0.3809893727,
-0.4121524394,
0.2686329186,
0.8396793008,
-0.2984881997,
0.7923910022,
-0.0307162069,
-0.8690071702,
0.7425438166,
0.8473867774,
0.9472487569,
-0.5922708511,
0.2111468762,
0.9445242286,
-0.327804476,
0.3020976186,
0.3882161379,
-0.3929412067,
-1.0212626457,
0.1093444452,
-0.2920182943,
-0.7113045454,
-0.6211047173,
-1.3534946442,
0.0664319694,
-0.2956190407,
-0.218130514,
-0.6381545663,
-0.2665129602,
-0.6388177276,
0.3092159331,
0.0255622249,
0.4536765218,
-1.0339486599,
0.3637446463,
0.4581901729,
-0.2602046132,
-0.6967917681,
-0.2461720258,
0.0510321632,
-0.8186963797,
0.5130610466,
0.3586526513,
-0.3692213893,
0.4427847266,
-0.39539662,
-0.4188883305,
1.2932230234,
-0.1085879281,
-0.4754185677,
0.1986339688,
-0.1653777063,
0.5850690007,
-1.0665280819,
1.0269554853,
0.7013071179,
0.3205060661,
0.244141683,
-0.5056428313,
0.1667191684,
-0.5189188719,
-0.1268245578,
0.056771107,
-1.2802182436,
0.9975882173,
-0.3688658178,
-0.0328532979,
0.0734635442,
0.3203557134,
0.4467684031,
0.3758610189,
0.404022634,
0.7836735249,
0.4398449957,
0.0620433018,
0.9747496843,
-1.0036361217,
0.3684411645,
1.0995372534,
-0.6222833991,
0.7364845276,
0.4543753266,
0.2958400548,
0.6089650393,
0.4714232981,
0.1357537955,
0.5505616069,
-0.1098815426,
-0.6286699176,
-0.5749381781,
-0.565600276,
-0.2257375121,
0.4276889563,
0.8670104146,
-0.573782742,
-0.138889879,
-0.1562353075,
-0.2872436643,
-0.0703769922,
-0.2529521286,
0.9358536601,
0.2879818678,
-0.6168147922,
0.141576454,
-0.5112014413,
0.5182262063,
-0.3857527375,
-0.229535982,
-0.2331883609,
0.2582310736,
-0.363482058,
-0.5947092175,
-0.0073229624,
0.0484829769,
0.0647366717,
-0.171405226,
0.650008738,
-0.386252135,
-0.0237458609,
0.6631325483,
0.7203893661,
0.1360134929,
0.1723288298,
-0.620318532,
-0.0178699493,
0.0502320752,
-0.4870629311,
0.2018750012,
0.6880078316,
0.5762141347,
0.4299307466,
0.4411173761,
-0.4810684025,
-0.1993623227,
0.2451950163,
0.9147418141,
-0.6839190722,
-0.5187677145,
-0.4509824514,
0.6471350789,
-0.406694293,
-0.2624108791,
0.4537510276,
0.2630940378,
0.2254594713,
-0.0249841306,
0.8076997995,
-0.3153266907,
0.4782910347,
-0.1165115759,
0.2175071388,
-0.5165099502,
-0.1994906515,
-0.519667387,
-0.7418726683,
-0.1553144008,
0.7549788952,
-0.0375156775,
0.2179788053,
0.8474770188,
0.9085170627,
0.0276940428,
0.3489455283,
0.5713784099,
0.2423773557,
0.3819809854,
1.0711292028,
0.6306446195,
-0.3715853095,
0.3610879481,
-0.2504659593,
-0.4197033048,
-0.4739895165,
-0.865540266,
-0.8024459481,
-0.2578456402,
-0.041352693,
-0.6964896917,
-0.2095846236,
0.8479636908,
0.3384451568,
-0.6410319209,
-0.0583477728,
-0.3530628085,
-0.4280768335,
-0.0872516856,
-0.3119697273,
0.0940183103,
-0.216724515,
-0.9529680014,
-0.0542100333,
0.288907975,
-0.1043670326,
0.0076351902,
-0.4856358767,
0.2012470961,
0.1453890204,
0.6280607581,
0.0960727483,
-0.2438095212,
-0.1929184049,
-0.0962425396,
-0.2161002457,
0.306861341,
1.1539900303,
-0.2798624933,
0.6612248421,
0.3794206381,
0.3689702749,
0.3208139241,
0.2749923468,
0.9170213938,
-0.4876559973,
0.1851164401,
0.2606281638,
0.4432545006,
0.3585202694,
-0.6695091724,
0.2764204443,
0.062019933,
-0.6171786785,
-0.4609987438,
0.8007762432,
-1.4027657509,
0.2757446468,
1.0398519039,
-0.5214645267,
-0.3014419377,
-0.0842909142,
-0.4488009512,
0.5702867508,
-0.9234570265,
0.6803233624,
0.4274823964,
-0.7771826982,
-0.2607368827,
0.3649476171,
0.0275213644,
0.6079518795,
-0.6783554554,
-0.0262272507,
0.5503757,
-0.2994022667,
0.3730179667,
0.4676274955,
0.0259176474,
0.1487248242,
0.4786479175,
0.2404278219,
-0.0208245981,
0.0007234463,
-0.2627868354,
0.0759866759,
-0.2638382018,
0.1255186498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14966v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14966v1
|
Walking a Tightrope -- Evaluating Large Language Models in High-Risk Domains
| 2023-11-25T08:58:07 | 2023-11-25T08:58:07 |
Chia-Chien Hung, Wiem Ben Rim, Lindsay Frost, Lars Bruckner, Carolin Lawrence
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
High-risk domains pose unique challenges that require language models to
provide accurate and safe responses. Despite the great success of large
language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and its variants, their performance in
high-risk domains remains unclear. Our study delves into an in-depth analysis
of the performance of instruction-tuned LLMs, focusing on factual accuracy and
safety adherence. To comprehensively assess the capabilities of LLMs, we
conduct experiments on six NLP datasets including question answering and
summarization tasks within two high-risk domains: legal and medical. Further
qualitative analysis highlights the existing limitations inherent in current
LLMs when evaluating in high-risk domains. This underscores the essential
nature of not only improving LLM capabilities but also prioritizing the
refinement of domain-specific metrics, and embracing a more human-centric
approach to enhance safety and factual reliability. Our findings advance the
field toward the concerns of properly evaluating LLMs in high-risk domains,
aiming to steer the adaptability of LLMs in fulfilling societal obligations and
aligning with forthcoming regulations, such as the EU AI Act.
|
[
-0.0067676315,
-0.910381496,
0.5461091995,
0.0636481494,
0.0913485363,
0.3112979829,
-0.4486628473,
-0.5062368512,
-0.415579468,
0.6416230202,
-0.2836027145,
-0.5070504546,
-0.9380833507,
-0.1671887636,
-0.2175677121,
1.0984678268,
-0.1642476171,
-0.2725570202,
-0.3229209781,
-0.143829748,
-0.6631923914,
-0.7784763575,
-0.4164316058,
-0.2658445537,
0.546849966,
0.3157355487,
0.9520281553,
0.6062219143,
0.8045545816,
0.2219201028,
-0.4153487682,
-0.0132509209,
-0.7574208975,
0.151577577,
-0.2640896142,
-0.3121312857,
-0.5383641124,
-0.0323291905,
0.6036555171,
0.9666289091,
-0.3440958858,
0.2891462147,
0.28561607,
0.4999479651,
-0.6050051451,
0.1653246135,
-0.608222127,
-0.1961027235,
-0.1392259896,
-0.1480391175,
-0.5075566769,
-0.4818062782,
0.5124158859,
-0.3858960569,
-0.0561617427,
0.3206067979,
0.807369709,
0.2135431916,
-0.5914477706,
-0.3568785191,
-0.8231351376,
0.5980460048,
-0.7066994309,
0.3905688226,
0.3823898435,
0.1754879802,
-0.4234969914,
-0.6091344953,
-0.1566348374,
-0.3066165149,
0.2154070437,
-0.1976040453,
-0.0295486599,
0.1229213551,
0.2573429644,
0.1184472814,
-0.7272126675,
0.4721394181,
-0.4228995442,
-0.2769376338,
0.6647933125,
0.1475774497,
0.3696116209,
0.0266077965,
-0.3494040668,
-0.0049549523,
-0.9157568812,
-0.0003266039,
0.1602841169,
0.2620472312,
-0.223793298,
0.6458584666,
0.1439449787,
0.5457786322,
-0.3581953645,
-0.3825334907,
0.02469109,
0.0221484378,
-0.0863233209,
0.0268287193,
0.6800432205,
0.4752650857,
0.4836523533,
-0.2332623601,
-0.1438260674,
-0.3244642317,
0.3239448965,
-0.7989917397,
-0.0423663631,
0.1695168614,
-0.2908886075,
0.0183914565,
-0.3090663552,
-0.6754754186,
-0.6238001585,
-0.2615131438,
0.5973019004,
-0.4031483233,
-0.1048836932,
0.60639292,
0.3086252213,
0.1261470765,
0.3035803735,
-0.5685994029,
0.2609252334,
0.9277082086,
0.7823016644,
-0.3825080097,
-0.2596724033,
-0.4607072175,
0.1300494224,
-0.3457333148,
0.5196571946,
-0.4424161017,
-0.3465245068,
0.3302800059,
0.0481816567,
-0.2663629651,
-0.5184854865,
0.8346503973,
-0.5209677815,
-0.1018562466,
-0.1773375422,
-0.7406945825,
-0.1600185782,
0.3489313722,
-0.4234980941,
0.7198734879,
-0.0141060734,
-0.6088657379,
0.2270698845,
-0.3169125915,
-0.5145465136,
0.0415365845,
0.0583686791,
-0.4349192381,
0.0069129351,
-0.2036749274,
0.5880699754,
-0.4432802796,
0.3672907054,
-0.3804855347,
-0.4126327634,
0.5020346045,
-0.7165079713,
0.6599487662,
-0.0283184238,
-0.2113907188,
0.2679543793,
-0.5564134717,
0.1006571278,
0.0666026771,
-0.5244138241,
-0.3252670169,
0.1465499103,
0.0986403674,
0.3636485636,
0.1872013211,
-0.2963610291,
-0.022803532,
-0.4517033398,
0.532581687,
0.7629989982,
0.1690474898,
0.0533023924,
-0.3839465678,
0.6459832788,
-0.3912108243,
0.2252510935,
0.1013122872,
-0.5913276076,
-0.550088644,
-0.1562648565,
0.4356168807,
0.6929050088,
-0.4636375606,
0.5900628567,
-0.5392753482,
-0.4803156257,
-0.2968035936,
0.0554622523,
0.4315490127,
0.2569643855,
0.070793353,
-0.397775054,
-0.1478336155,
-0.6120412946,
-0.3126065433,
-0.3787284195,
0.0650572181,
0.2254899889,
0.6448180079,
-0.2031439841,
0.5810521245,
-0.4561901987,
-0.0277185068,
-0.210209921,
-0.005869966,
0.0153593998,
0.4272918701,
0.2864868939,
-0.6316165924,
-0.3539879024,
-0.0437975153,
-0.4713610709,
0.1494647264,
-0.0800552964,
-0.0693305507,
-0.0037296657,
0.4538404644,
-0.7857709527,
0.2984563708,
0.5799894333,
-0.318274647,
0.6563812494,
-0.3548644483,
0.0763345808,
-0.7871367335,
0.0087075401,
0.0023301325,
-0.1443800628,
-0.7158116698,
0.1609006524,
-0.0386368446,
-0.1279620975,
-0.4930665195,
0.3763587177,
-0.2936507463,
0.0869170502,
-0.1761303395,
0.2134229243,
-0.0847164765,
0.2558303475,
-0.2240079641,
0.8228527904,
0.5994411707,
-0.5101557374,
0.1537349224,
0.386508584,
-0.7163547277,
0.2985643446,
-0.7832589746,
0.153721422,
0.0903990492,
0.0496250167,
-0.7476540208,
-0.5087544918,
-0.1331800967,
-0.216014728,
0.4688006043,
-0.2659632564,
-0.5181913972,
-0.2356024534,
-0.0848952159,
0.2797600925,
0.7210894823,
-0.0966044888,
0.2806904614,
0.6492388844,
-0.444655031,
-0.5918784738,
-0.4741640687,
0.3286630809,
-0.4090690017,
-0.6475126743,
0.039884612,
0.0256332699,
-0.2328428924,
-0.2366767526,
-0.1877388358,
-0.1836667955,
0.4549533725,
0.35255,
0.2710219622,
-0.2873927057,
0.1194577515,
-0.2540287971,
0.0975000635,
0.3455244005,
-0.1055731326,
0.4706206322,
-0.2499604672,
-0.5724374652,
-0.3123788536,
0.3072015643,
0.7556700706,
-0.4457574487,
0.8816770911,
0.3102545142,
-0.4108284414,
-0.1583779007,
-0.4467617869,
-0.0023070727,
-0.4768079221,
0.6019581556,
-0.0719526857,
-1.267408967,
0.387847662,
-0.1497956961,
0.1455143541,
0.2566136718,
0.7465041876,
-0.0829160511,
0.7971804142,
0.5375064611,
0.0372213274,
0.0052722911,
0.2270404696,
0.4793581665,
-0.6210117936,
-0.1785317212,
-0.6581081152,
0.0923099071,
-0.7926138639,
-0.5551783442,
0.6374005675,
-0.1010242477,
-0.3691109121,
0.2069863528,
-0.1237758473,
0.3905265629,
0.1432445943,
0.072930254,
0.2791546881,
-0.2112935036,
0.1495394707,
0.1208594665,
-0.8536704183,
-0.8504833579,
1.0793682337,
0.7325997353,
1.0690408945,
0.3220997453,
0.2485955656,
0.1904014051,
0.2748267353,
-0.9209732413,
0.5504828691,
-0.2104173601,
-0.7570137978,
-0.4411261678,
-0.4913355708,
-0.9594391584,
0.0839032456,
-0.3546027243,
-0.7472601533,
-0.0612105653,
0.082239002,
-0.5048311949,
0.240760535,
-0.644628644,
0.8806424141,
-0.3607194722,
-0.4199766517,
-0.0741827264,
-0.7899246216,
0.338552922,
-0.2456581742,
0.2814494669,
-0.3977969289,
0.035525389,
0.6625127792,
-0.0171904135,
1.0419892073,
0.1837678254,
-0.4761858582,
0.2928711176,
0.212969169,
0.555711329,
-0.0628740788,
-0.0978750288,
0.1360657513,
0.1926142573,
-0.3620400429,
-0.3979532123,
0.6935632229,
-0.6060489416,
-0.8296898603,
-0.384382993,
-0.6235711575,
-0.6588367224,
0.1817715466,
-0.0130718155,
0.3370248377,
-0.3631538749,
0.3553112149,
1.092092514,
-0.4967756569,
0.1419831812,
0.4681408107,
0.0042401426,
-0.0348828286,
0.8521795869,
0.1349845976,
0.6212331653,
0.133194536,
0.227914989,
-0.3181816638,
-0.9043648839,
-0.4013227522,
0.1856934577,
-0.6868786812,
-0.0239610132,
-0.438382268,
-0.4216957092,
-0.2623875141,
-0.0064360918,
-0.39874354,
-0.2585689723,
-0.0129492925,
-0.0953592509,
0.2610725164,
0.6016238928,
0.4505371451,
0.1970168203,
-0.9446536899,
0.0191807672,
0.2140040845,
0.4925652444,
-0.1964208633,
-0.8148332834,
-0.2477294952,
-0.2172991335,
-0.1673027873,
-0.5424560308,
0.0226642359,
0.3155317903,
0.3865652382,
0.1011380926,
0.2234663516,
0.4951820076,
-0.9125837088,
0.6748785377,
0.0522821061,
-0.7154902816,
0.2523114383,
-0.43091169,
0.0915468112,
0.4955881834,
0.5033097863,
-0.6698504686,
-0.3647931218,
-0.3635185957,
-0.9556570053,
0.2547149062,
0.267619431,
0.4209157526,
0.2100777924,
0.4891531467,
0.0784535855,
0.0447516739,
-0.3837141991,
0.0244140457,
0.4374781549,
-0.2254008204,
0.0048608673,
-0.3370256126,
-0.3423334062,
0.0718309879,
0.6136875749,
-0.1062483639,
-0.0485334769,
-0.0699705482,
0.0238166787,
-0.1187741086,
0.6097073555,
0.5771483183,
0.9322203398,
-0.1241432205,
0.0856773257,
0.3050584197,
-0.6397779584,
0.28551808,
0.028251417,
-0.044673942,
-0.2870241106,
0.7583960891,
0.7853984833,
0.1792187542,
-1.1372582912,
0.7351791859,
0.0766562894,
-0.0614884645,
-0.0668095052,
0.4118615687,
0.1100222394,
-0.0104025388,
-0.013409608,
0.0506340116,
-0.1097346768,
-0.5566780567,
0.3406232297,
0.2868641615,
-0.4968968928,
-0.2166845798,
0.5467407107,
0.1704596579,
-0.3409337997,
0.2487585843,
0.0922864527,
-0.423486948,
0.5169907212,
0.3951758742,
0.706697762,
-0.2345708609,
0.1073826626,
0.1068341061,
0.5627154708,
-0.3526672721,
0.1878335029,
0.632243216,
-0.5779243708,
-0.8555888534,
-0.4469634295,
-0.5992966294,
0.2344753444,
-0.7115764618,
0.026252212,
-0.5267510414,
-0.303203851,
-0.1224425063,
-0.2130843848,
-0.4409141243,
0.2547235191,
0.0748572424,
0.9267861247,
-0.652841866,
0.6929255128,
0.6491768956,
0.0805399045,
-0.6576366425,
0.3988348246,
0.0910242274,
-0.6930983663,
0.2428526282,
0.0845563635,
-0.257001251,
-0.3299612701,
-0.5101077557,
-0.8380289674,
0.7882919908,
0.6303163767,
-0.7031005621,
-0.2101556212,
0.3774697483,
0.636356473,
-0.0251236055,
-0.184812218,
0.7393913865,
0.2559455335,
-0.1366699785,
-1.2475667,
0.0727765188,
0.259283632,
-0.0072440389,
0.1004494801,
-0.7785139084,
0.4116087556,
-0.3371259868,
-0.1474970281,
0.0008294039,
0.4834725559,
0.2473548502,
0.2845286131,
0.3885260522,
0.2467217445,
0.803570807,
-0.1139295697,
0.9528930187,
-0.2900938988,
0.3710939884,
1.1124235392,
-0.6524335742,
0.9388797879,
0.2831400335,
-0.2078819126,
0.1269692183,
0.5513663888,
0.2413835078,
0.1340909004,
0.4039052725,
-0.2624790668,
-0.3702838421,
-0.1486766338,
-0.1101116464,
0.5738400817,
0.6047654748,
-0.1241319105,
-0.0163639914,
-0.0268483404,
0.2031648308,
0.0969022512,
-0.1700981408,
0.5388426781,
0.248308748,
-0.5832032561,
0.6927676201,
0.0543299243,
0.294795841,
-0.5784091353,
0.0044612065,
0.12090379,
0.0696047023,
0.0144850845,
-1.0232628584,
0.2853939831,
0.3008563817,
0.1598990411,
-0.1742400825,
0.5905436277,
-0.277200073,
-0.3512086272,
0.2244135439,
0.4894456565,
0.1148970947,
0.1056016982,
-0.6725776196,
0.2259604484,
-0.2162921578,
-0.3773044944,
0.4546844661,
0.6608754396,
-0.1484221965,
0.9951904416,
0.4209873378,
0.1689952016,
0.0311092306,
-0.0438393131,
0.7464624643,
-0.5239280462,
-0.1846419126,
-0.7338047028,
0.3955821097,
0.1609059125,
-0.6300881505,
0.6482980251,
0.5074343085,
0.6599628925,
0.0799551234,
0.7657880783,
0.036753051,
0.4701701701,
-0.7827703953,
0.9324460626,
-0.3405562937,
0.4716171324,
-0.0254418626,
-0.5854968429,
-0.3427285254,
0.2132689953,
-0.4109919071,
-0.021944847,
0.5743194818,
0.6536816359,
0.0481993109,
-0.194849208,
0.4903158247,
0.3975078166,
0.4421859682,
0.5919715762,
0.8598681688,
-0.265597403,
0.5817168951,
0.0749691874,
-0.1882004589,
-0.2236806005,
-0.9219517708,
-0.9801349044,
-0.3078936636,
-0.513476491,
-0.4157917798,
0.2701046765,
0.891900003,
0.6737712622,
-0.7989779711,
-0.2456232607,
0.3399143517,
0.0545782074,
-0.0500721373,
-0.1543177813,
0.5525928736,
-0.2379467785,
-0.4051862061,
0.3174065351,
0.355312556,
0.0019797683,
-0.1875444949,
0.0004162178,
-0.048276756,
0.2798614502,
0.6913417578,
0.1813484132,
-0.6268878579,
-0.685321033,
-0.0275706109,
-0.3230943382,
0.0817967132,
0.6722609997,
-0.0228895154,
0.1509475708,
0.2541143894,
1.0064120293,
0.1445661038,
-0.0472792163,
0.5336824059,
-0.4376398623,
-0.1945449561,
0.3686902821,
0.2641349733,
0.4380356669,
-0.3310572207,
0.3679886162,
0.004476781,
-0.9274965525,
-0.8477752805,
0.2452791333,
-1.0268268585,
-0.1875322014,
1.380219698,
-0.4654955566,
-0.1515412927,
-0.4106352627,
-0.1925609112,
0.0093773743,
-0.1009449586,
0.7921379805,
0.9581989646,
-0.101009585,
0.0421847925,
-1.1393688917,
0.5478003025,
0.4061511457,
-0.8234863281,
0.5081240535,
0.4475266635,
0.5165949464,
-0.0383879542,
0.1895976514,
-0.0900977924,
0.1583962739,
-0.4529253542,
-0.1674607545,
0.3555858433,
-0.3730782568,
-0.319131285,
0.2929747999,
0.4499363303,
0.249110952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14949v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14949v1
|
Vector-Quantized Prompt Learning for Paraphrase Generation
| 2023-11-25T07:13:06 | 2023-11-25T07:13:06 |
Haotian Luo, Yixin Liu, Peidong Liu, Xianggen Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deep generative modeling of natural languages has achieved many successes,
such as producing fluent sentences and translating from one language into
another. However, the development of generative modeling techniques for
paraphrase generation still lags behind largely due to the challenges in
addressing the complex conflicts between expression diversity and semantic
preservation. This paper proposes to generate diverse and high-quality
paraphrases by exploiting the pre-trained models with instance-dependent
prompts. To learn generalizable prompts, we assume that the number of abstract
transforming patterns of paraphrase generation (governed by prompts) is finite
and usually not large. Therefore, we present vector-quantized prompts as the
cues to control the generation of pre-trained models. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that the proposed method achieves new state-of-art results on three
benchmark datasets, including Quora, Wikianswers, and MSCOCO. We will release
all the code upon acceptance.
|
[
-0.1993058026,
-0.7585945129,
0.7088956237,
0.2290938497,
-0.5834239125,
-0.245203808,
0.1192054823,
0.3159243166,
-0.1919478476,
0.5675928593,
-0.4804286361,
-0.7075864673,
-0.2543578446,
0.5139729381,
-0.3775887489,
1.0497351885,
0.080136992,
-0.038166292,
-0.5230734348,
-0.2351352423,
-0.5061166883,
-0.656530261,
-0.3437753916,
0.3546446264,
0.4880080521,
0.3351232111,
0.5164314508,
0.3496424854,
0.0363217443,
0.250469327,
-0.1163685769,
-0.0136400815,
-0.2423585206,
0.5373025537,
-0.1224771962,
-0.4472050965,
0.0849844739,
-0.164709419,
0.622040391,
0.6049599051,
-0.2731204927,
-0.1150569618,
0.3361583352,
0.2228755355,
-0.6744533777,
0.0169953294,
-0.6962581277,
0.0714450255,
0.0097909449,
-0.2329899669,
-0.3092916012,
-0.8381168246,
0.3147114217,
-0.7712704539,
0.4436828792,
-0.1455145776,
0.570977509,
0.0915172994,
-0.5575969815,
-0.2323901653,
-0.4303361773,
0.9584611654,
-0.5576489568,
-0.043447569,
0.2296243608,
0.5607008338,
0.0836267546,
-1.1461514235,
-0.3826212883,
-0.3220533729,
0.193233788,
0.0558244735,
-0.336094141,
-0.056340497,
0.2373397499,
0.2963072658,
-0.5833259225,
-0.0697191134,
-0.265196532,
-0.1033276469,
0.0978175029,
0.3676143289,
0.3772384822,
-0.5900761485,
-0.4492603242,
-0.3618124127,
-0.6238161325,
0.244905889,
0.0494046509,
0.2258163542,
-0.063014932,
0.416195333,
-0.4355588257,
0.6246917844,
-0.172606796,
0.2884851098,
0.1732531339,
-0.495167464,
-0.1391954869,
-0.3976082504,
0.9259542823,
0.2733750641,
0.2468926013,
-0.2289513499,
-0.1719887257,
0.0757532641,
0.0809469372,
-1.0022772551,
-0.2424200624,
0.004784801,
-0.3531374633,
-0.3955556452,
0.039553117,
-1.0625599623,
-0.0927765444,
-0.3917765915,
0.4395565391,
-0.6615401506,
0.1282389015,
0.0088244006,
-0.2675766647,
0.2247085273,
0.337430656,
-0.7167220712,
0.0037365444,
0.4805896282,
0.8235769272,
-0.0068041543,
-0.3501700461,
-0.932457149,
0.0733748004,
-0.4901903272,
0.6637528539,
-0.838616848,
-0.6830893755,
0.1494066119,
-0.3752321899,
0.0890583992,
-0.5353236198,
0.7923389673,
-0.4070564806,
0.2545428872,
-0.6048554778,
-0.5006824136,
-0.002316324,
-0.0487774871,
-0.3818718493,
0.6831617951,
0.2209139168,
-0.5299438834,
0.1828791499,
-0.0940891951,
-0.3347434402,
0.20271945,
-0.4111659229,
-0.3300133944,
0.4137565792,
0.6060475707,
0.5719978809,
-0.5066230297,
0.412732929,
-0.2179836631,
0.0779238418,
0.3147738278,
-0.5216836929,
0.6697324514,
0.5029948354,
-0.0830178559,
0.3018786609,
-0.7648949623,
0.0136256702,
-0.0256916974,
0.0590077378,
-0.3872154653,
-0.2294303477,
-0.237791881,
0.4211256206,
0.0625174344,
-0.3512238264,
0.0259094052,
-0.0328752995,
0.6901871562,
0.6179327369,
0.5965611339,
0.460457772,
-0.3611776829,
1.0346099138,
0.2201714665,
0.1626371443,
-0.4522563517,
-0.3716262877,
-0.3736265004,
-0.2979753911,
0.1895732433,
0.3876770437,
-1.3246059418,
0.3558741808,
-0.2381639183,
-0.3790174127,
-0.4645118415,
-0.0061060037,
0.3319572508,
0.7979950309,
0.689094007,
0.1987041682,
-0.1056220233,
-0.6040836573,
-0.2216656953,
0.3019016683,
-0.4586396813,
0.1225400418,
0.3381685615,
-0.0394385234,
1.0323332548,
-0.3717330694,
-0.093078889,
-0.2911539078,
0.5416457057,
0.0370715819,
0.4702407122,
0.7597202063,
-0.9813024402,
-0.4391970932,
-0.318329215,
-0.82681036,
-0.1832934618,
-0.2169592977,
-0.3910650015,
-0.4981142879,
0.8002796769,
-0.8288427591,
0.1198519543,
0.2765622735,
-0.2309416234,
0.4980279207,
-0.2926049232,
0.2105894238,
-1.4190255404,
-0.1242421865,
-0.0164969247,
-0.1202238128,
-0.4002215266,
-0.033930026,
0.2038024366,
-0.5160599947,
-0.5992581844,
0.1897575706,
-0.383415997,
0.2120540142,
-0.1359652877,
-0.2614596188,
0.2398139089,
0.4280499518,
-0.1929330379,
0.7650793791,
0.911493659,
-1.0153884888,
0.2679775655,
0.5536543131,
-0.2534788251,
0.6904743314,
-0.9862178564,
-0.0323113091,
-0.407979697,
0.2756945491,
-0.8237025142,
-0.2132819593,
0.2753578722,
-0.4665222168,
-0.0523565412,
-0.1019427106,
-0.2925484776,
-0.1742705703,
-0.3528741598,
0.4693999588,
0.9259117246,
-0.5775411129,
0.4667506516,
-0.1615738869,
-0.4965707064,
-0.2592245936,
-0.2546791434,
0.0546299256,
-0.4070090353,
-0.2025675774,
0.3228500187,
-0.1268749535,
-0.0377505533,
-0.011897672,
0.1457187384,
-0.0335327238,
0.1167342663,
-0.0167869851,
0.0225577354,
-0.0502429418,
0.1011657193,
0.6653454304,
-0.0233741365,
0.1232919544,
-0.4969595671,
0.4712373316,
0.0237391554,
-0.1021635607,
-0.4486263096,
0.7492641807,
0.608093977,
-0.7493395805,
0.6124529839,
0.33231318,
-0.1945640445,
-0.23769705,
-0.0104924208,
-0.2248675525,
-0.5092387795,
0.2645952404,
-0.5568800569,
-0.8457301855,
0.3386983871,
0.0073477379,
0.0746770352,
0.4352256954,
0.411262095,
0.1469352394,
1.0577425957,
0.1900319606,
0.3174194396,
0.4457401931,
-0.0778628066,
-0.3026753664,
-0.5242760777,
0.0060051484,
-0.6758651137,
0.0741175041,
-0.4621122777,
-0.5476437807,
0.4805049896,
0.4805166721,
-0.009640459,
0.1511397958,
-0.4578922689,
0.3454326689,
1.0098391771,
0.1889242232,
-0.0606725477,
0.1632799953,
-0.2811044753,
-0.1150228307,
-0.6131055355,
-0.5352115631,
1.0767740011,
-0.1492248923,
0.5682169795,
0.0297021829,
0.8990631104,
0.2396704853,
-0.1416470557,
-0.288112551,
0.6491628289,
-0.1718308032,
-0.0475478508,
-0.3587533832,
-0.7011216879,
-1.1731450558,
0.337331593,
-0.1330527365,
-0.3291815519,
0.3252427876,
0.2133742422,
-0.6312090755,
-0.051279217,
-0.4786149263,
1.0149182081,
0.0324853808,
-0.0903305188,
-0.0264417082,
-0.7388116121,
0.1365620196,
-0.0679454803,
-0.0804457888,
-0.1915887445,
0.093528159,
0.5857029557,
-0.5886160731,
0.6342612505,
-0.3462026417,
0.0318361148,
0.5424704552,
0.0164766517,
0.5389309525,
0.3873982131,
0.0428502858,
-0.1620036811,
-0.1752796322,
-0.6190346479,
-0.6778428555,
0.425414294,
-0.557551682,
-0.5571490526,
-0.0321391225,
-0.284090668,
-0.1871928722,
0.0353994295,
1.0065799952,
0.6799899936,
-0.213609159,
0.3736018538,
0.7565080523,
-0.4880646765,
0.4389334321,
0.0654867813,
0.0290251933,
-0.7700663209,
1.0995213985,
-0.1305845529,
0.3244460821,
0.6911880374,
0.2706287801,
-0.2367515564,
-0.6765905619,
-0.2464402914,
-0.0295227431,
-0.762145102,
-0.3216983974,
-0.9946277142,
0.1537243575,
-0.6896993518,
-0.1895497143,
0.1554343402,
-0.2627015114,
-0.7032005787,
-0.1595901996,
0.5077934861,
0.359318018,
0.0842132419,
0.242807284,
-1.0207912922,
0.7474852204,
0.907568872,
-0.2978783846,
-0.056923423,
-0.4516675174,
0.1495966762,
0.1046501547,
-0.370267272,
-0.9383721948,
0.6398093104,
0.3409084678,
0.5480431914,
0.2668330371,
0.5574490428,
0.2534739673,
-0.6499923468,
0.9089403152,
0.3397064805,
-1.0234959126,
0.7670260668,
-0.5712619424,
0.3646109402,
0.5146589875,
0.553676486,
-0.3725959063,
-0.5831177831,
-0.4184436202,
-0.993068397,
0.2863185108,
0.1945036352,
0.5578098893,
-0.4955165684,
0.2601059079,
0.5520483851,
0.3487614691,
-0.532435596,
-0.0631285682,
-0.6306139827,
-0.494155407,
-0.1370905936,
-0.4059644938,
0.1181396469,
-0.2378150821,
0.2650839388,
-0.1512239277,
0.161864832,
0.1567123681,
-0.3183948696,
0.2771990001,
0.474937886,
0.5981778502,
0.573109448,
0.1460795254,
0.1065976322,
0.0954502597,
-0.1396336108,
0.3476503491,
0.2417551726,
-0.4190589488,
0.2509794235,
0.0395863354,
1.2017008066,
0.2844759822,
-0.495521754,
0.6106821895,
-0.2205591202,
-0.3680922389,
-0.0516799241,
0.0420603268,
-0.0528173968,
0.2456332594,
0.5533056259,
-0.136898458,
0.2955319583,
-0.0580266006,
0.2984848619,
0.3513678908,
-0.0804954469,
-0.4780092835,
1.0828950405,
0.399916172,
-0.1159008071,
0.6945745945,
-0.3539378643,
-0.2710336149,
0.3966084719,
0.2397689074,
1.2550261021,
-0.3185947537,
0.5734003782,
0.3066760898,
-0.1535301507,
-0.1037537009,
0.22283943,
-0.5196542144,
-0.3446453214,
-0.1734435558,
-0.6246175766,
-0.5054851174,
0.0926529244,
-0.9388182759,
0.1964131296,
-0.2547524571,
-0.0131138889,
-0.073104091,
-0.7540428638,
-0.5628038049,
0.106858477,
0.0324956514,
0.4343158603,
-0.823559761,
0.7210941911,
0.5948950052,
-0.5817686915,
-0.5101067424,
0.239335984,
-0.6825512052,
-0.3870485425,
0.5680849552,
0.3027018011,
0.3073926568,
0.5046324134,
-0.5915160775,
-0.6223888993,
0.8524923325,
0.6390957236,
-0.3505879343,
-0.3144862354,
0.1399262995,
0.3570028841,
0.0072506764,
-0.0679409131,
0.1480138898,
0.0051806029,
0.0542749316,
-0.2986190021,
-0.0857104212,
-0.1577305049,
0.4522683024,
0.0219198763,
-0.1502289325,
1.4190043211,
-0.0787711963,
-0.205335319,
0.3241153359,
1.2316982746,
0.4229546189,
-0.1266566366,
0.3207661211,
0.392533958,
0.6845805049,
0.2018852383,
1.1814187765,
-0.1507143825,
0.1047540158,
0.9043775797,
-0.0750266984,
0.6129478216,
0.4405809343,
0.0161265098,
0.4082702398,
0.432297349,
0.0586975031,
0.8143182397,
0.1954143047,
-0.7139248848,
-0.3940893114,
-0.0310623534,
-0.4133214653,
0.026290847,
0.237607941,
-0.4283190668,
-0.4553902447,
0.4862373769,
-0.3294565082,
0.2538048625,
-0.3261808753,
0.6776074171,
0.3089723587,
-0.9168800116,
0.8489491343,
-0.202436626,
0.7026732564,
-0.5971015096,
-0.2315308899,
-0.3357455134,
-0.1208599359,
0.3471741676,
-0.4806396961,
-0.1610133946,
0.0771231726,
-0.1684607863,
-0.4757229686,
0.2589824498,
-0.5294840932,
-0.4278814197,
-0.1174270138,
0.4569573402,
-0.1121609509,
-0.3253966868,
-0.5506541729,
-0.4842297733,
0.0348861776,
-0.3474431336,
0.3138426542,
0.9620149732,
-0.1757849157,
0.4871751666,
0.5616447926,
-0.3330560923,
0.3356485367,
0.021413397,
0.7345459461,
-0.6901383996,
-0.8584951758,
-0.9424574971,
0.3897927403,
-0.0019856778,
-0.6299896836,
0.9732986093,
0.2643438876,
0.5037199259,
-0.500392735,
1.0011271238,
0.2895398438,
0.4557733536,
-0.6980574131,
0.3580048084,
-0.2506317794,
-0.0960569829,
-0.3885546625,
-0.8652743101,
-0.005356336,
0.4433591664,
0.04989608,
0.0675012395,
0.5282559395,
0.4838793576,
0.166189149,
-0.0669113696,
0.4629868865,
-0.2052511722,
0.5133985877,
0.6081034541,
1.1083815098,
-0.1806286871,
0.8677424192,
-0.30048123,
-0.1014206633,
-0.150277555,
-0.7469760776,
-0.8460510373,
-0.7223002315,
-0.4797497392,
-0.1224394292,
-0.0541904196,
0.6797826886,
0.3592292666,
-0.7987713814,
0.192957297,
-0.8764207363,
-0.0920781121,
-0.2184773088,
-0.2403050363,
0.3523844779,
-0.8406019807,
-0.812669754,
0.3290913999,
-0.0040513556,
0.5375214219,
0.1289033443,
-0.0164022222,
0.1506065875,
0.057961069,
0.4779843092,
0.3846792579,
-0.4620020092,
0.0401342474,
0.1397726685,
-0.321041435,
-0.051099252,
0.8359531164,
-0.964004457,
0.1535657644,
0.6070985794,
0.6790621281,
0.2551117539,
0.1015127599,
0.9108139277,
-1.0202592611,
0.104606539,
0.4627500176,
0.3326450884,
0.3071537912,
0.0144999847,
-0.002764282,
0.3163024187,
-0.4384890199,
-0.7456141114,
0.2597432733,
-0.7613379359,
-0.5215310454,
1.2988499403,
-0.2799758315,
-0.1653260738,
0.0366970375,
-0.3442688286,
0.4653484821,
-0.2975225449,
0.430337429,
0.2109452337,
0.3212409019,
-0.140111044,
-0.2263052315,
0.7527089715,
0.6491287947,
-0.8863584995,
0.1831452399,
0.7162700891,
0.1004508957,
-0.27202034,
0.2621638179,
-0.0192681383,
0.5770506859,
-0.110838294,
0.1274903864,
-0.083374463,
-0.2044151723,
-0.6781047583,
0.3035247028,
0.0309533756,
-0.5427978039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14919v1
|
Faster Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding with Confidence-based Pruning
| 2023-11-25T03:38:14 | 2023-11-25T03:38:14 |
Julius Cheng, Andreas Vlachos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Minimum Bayes risk (MBR) decoding outputs the hypothesis with the highest
expected utility over the model distribution for some utility function. It has
been shown to improve accuracy over beam search in conditional language
generation problems and especially neural machine translation, in both human
and automatic evaluations. However, the standard sampling-based algorithm for
MBR is substantially more computationally expensive than beam search, requiring
a large number of samples as well as a quadratic number of calls to the utility
function, limiting its applicability. We describe an algorithm for MBR which
gradually grows the number of samples used to estimate the utility while
pruning hypotheses that are unlikely to have the highest utility according to
confidence estimates obtained with bootstrap sampling. Our method requires
fewer samples and drastically reduces the number of calls to the utility
function compared to standard MBR while being statistically indistinguishable
in terms of accuracy. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in
experiments on three language pairs, using chrF++ and COMET as
utility/evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.027885586,
-0.4610467255,
0.5858845711,
0.2108480334,
-0.2263581008,
0.144733876,
0.0427765064,
-0.0962375328,
-0.0703392997,
0.3162464201,
-0.5136123896,
-0.5457111001,
-0.6031996608,
-0.0344246328,
-0.027761858,
0.6112745404,
0.3294073641,
0.0907474831,
0.0393285602,
0.279450506,
-0.3070485592,
-0.5009690523,
-0.7973446846,
0.0431681499,
0.4909353554,
0.5430940986,
0.8258541226,
0.5756418705,
0.8050575852,
0.2056137472,
-0.1314536184,
-0.1245989874,
-0.4794308841,
-0.1874992549,
0.1432344168,
-0.5481472015,
-0.0701653212,
-0.2714934051,
0.7024587989,
0.8717874289,
-0.4060868025,
0.1889033467,
-0.1211161539,
0.9941965938,
-1.0946683884,
0.2965105474,
-0.5607143044,
-0.1767177582,
-0.2151565552,
-0.6652966142,
-0.7713724375,
-0.4575597942,
-0.0083051296,
-0.1836638004,
0.4112483561,
0.1288855374,
0.6258461475,
0.0978933945,
-0.5816008449,
0.2352149487,
-0.6118705273,
0.8908455372,
-0.4176990092,
0.3887182772,
0.475953877,
0.4301790297,
-0.5141608715,
-0.3042431176,
-0.3529012203,
-0.2016372383,
-0.1445853561,
-0.1069104224,
-0.4282810688,
0.4428119361,
0.2770260572,
0.1944178343,
-0.4967640042,
-0.2312858105,
-0.6445991993,
-0.6896216869,
0.803273499,
0.04454704,
-0.067753911,
-0.4636766911,
-0.083196409,
-0.6797391176,
-0.8538164496,
0.4894089997,
0.5431469083,
0.0655989796,
0.2186338007,
0.6113578081,
-0.3239923418,
0.6094031334,
0.0217602476,
-0.4708135128,
0.2697263658,
-0.1090878993,
-0.17375651,
0.0981331095,
0.7649253607,
0.6807541847,
0.1197437122,
-0.0572861023,
0.0439177938,
0.0499692559,
0.1214905456,
-0.8440031409,
-0.5694667697,
0.1817674935,
-0.5978898406,
-0.3445110023,
-0.1304884702,
-0.6800441742,
-0.2877380848,
0.223053515,
0.5309838653,
-0.8476537466,
-0.0658747628,
0.3341071606,
-0.3573544621,
0.3479399085,
-0.1588246822,
-0.609995544,
0.5235050917,
0.4720626473,
0.7844308615,
0.0592537969,
0.1710966825,
-1.007632494,
-0.0723646805,
-0.5184966922,
0.6149184704,
-0.2059707642,
-0.5918950438,
-0.1080258936,
-0.040726807,
-0.0369029082,
-0.3463380635,
0.6150736213,
-0.3658413291,
-0.1977264434,
-0.2673685849,
-0.3868132234,
-0.279440999,
-0.1813574582,
-0.6296667457,
0.8307402134,
0.2841165066,
-1.0216982365,
0.5684480071,
-0.3614585102,
-0.8468341231,
0.0998862386,
-0.2381422073,
-0.5189614296,
0.4204616249,
0.2652107775,
0.6851587892,
-0.1402837336,
0.4342861772,
-0.3095506132,
-0.4935966134,
0.4757018387,
-0.5529669523,
0.7224254608,
0.1836901456,
-0.2315917611,
-0.0237954017,
-0.9310406446,
0.1064172164,
0.2247464657,
-0.2724484205,
-0.4542621374,
0.4501444399,
0.1507254839,
-0.0117526492,
-0.0721697435,
-0.7119086385,
-0.1759503186,
-0.8201534152,
0.4062254429,
0.603939414,
0.282097578,
0.5022243261,
-0.6509545445,
0.3278855979,
0.117167294,
0.1433623582,
0.0628806949,
-0.6027489901,
-0.5415510535,
-0.3721078634,
0.3654873371,
0.5289366841,
-0.8848936558,
0.4337534308,
-0.5030629635,
-0.4291597307,
-0.8600841761,
-0.1182863563,
0.625084579,
0.3458595276,
0.4207922816,
-0.4941794574,
-0.4289136231,
-1.3600661755,
-0.2464470118,
-0.2730052471,
-0.1074202657,
-0.1329331547,
0.0887787566,
0.043419309,
1.0386608839,
-0.6108211279,
0.1108317748,
-0.4095129371,
0.2455866337,
0.2702981532,
0.7937330008,
0.3987946808,
-0.9257106781,
-0.5323266983,
-0.2429542243,
0.0788050443,
0.2111369818,
-0.2513409257,
-0.1974975914,
0.2396558076,
0.0383892171,
-0.4455541074,
0.6564925313,
0.5571677089,
-0.0103651751,
0.3414254785,
-0.2568881512,
0.2907123864,
-0.9219553471,
0.2763710022,
0.2161164731,
-0.1904419214,
-0.7792001367,
0.0058115763,
0.2988242805,
0.1298812479,
-0.3783043027,
0.2555493414,
-0.5424010158,
0.0907576382,
-0.2603375316,
-0.3436116874,
-0.2292565405,
0.3513513207,
0.3191481233,
0.7499288917,
0.388358742,
-0.8399440646,
-0.2707767189,
0.1147328615,
-0.5424002409,
0.0019505708,
-0.4036880434,
0.039940495,
-0.2607915998,
0.0482291169,
-1.0487062931,
-0.1062622219,
0.3555556536,
-0.6111872792,
0.4276636243,
-0.3750359714,
-0.4924221635,
-0.3437261581,
-0.564504981,
0.2753479779,
0.9601996541,
-0.3987214863,
0.2574789822,
0.4252995551,
-0.5354094505,
-0.717414856,
-0.691437602,
-0.1178588346,
0.0235582385,
-0.7317266464,
0.4807775021,
-0.3668424487,
-0.113117002,
-0.1819746792,
-0.4283650219,
-0.3099597692,
0.1457084715,
0.2708353102,
0.2555255592,
0.16307576,
-0.1322313547,
0.6236872077,
-0.5027253628,
0.0488870963,
-0.1651908606,
0.3635804653,
0.0092798043,
-0.3516917825,
-0.2943514884,
0.4545750618,
0.1998223662,
0.0790089667,
0.9022523165,
0.4153305292,
-0.3316737711,
0.0321280546,
-0.8289808035,
-0.1628403664,
-0.5413065553,
0.1174597144,
-0.6187918782,
-1.0113562346,
0.1142439917,
0.0284801554,
-0.0402024724,
0.2973423302,
0.3358523846,
-0.2132238299,
1.293676734,
1.0210901499,
-0.2302492559,
0.1718606055,
-0.0285430066,
0.4431686401,
-0.4618624151,
-0.1099505499,
-0.4806480408,
-0.3067960739,
-0.6868278384,
-0.5014808774,
0.437679112,
-0.1816222966,
0.1667002738,
0.2459998876,
-0.5313998461,
0.5503356457,
0.9539015889,
0.2445020527,
0.340334028,
0.2071703076,
-0.1959110051,
-0.3345742226,
-1.0975674391,
-0.1962857395,
1.1946042776,
0.2183153778,
0.464435339,
-0.0081583075,
0.8698259592,
0.0002647636,
0.5098048449,
-0.9097669721,
0.5021551251,
0.0841280222,
-0.7516428828,
-0.1277568042,
-0.9845283031,
-1.005977273,
0.2913024127,
-0.2496897131,
-0.7242595553,
0.5587187409,
0.4003838003,
-0.6366786957,
0.1998114884,
-0.5996772647,
0.6445887089,
-0.0224580932,
-0.218535915,
-0.2750407457,
-0.9754446149,
0.5965874791,
-0.0158449356,
0.5567601323,
0.0115292817,
0.1364442855,
0.7864375114,
-0.2146855891,
0.5424515009,
-0.2779916525,
0.1906093806,
0.2638834715,
0.4205903411,
0.5408270955,
-0.0843600631,
-0.0449954867,
-0.1544905305,
0.5408946872,
-0.6342115402,
-0.1324783415,
0.2068947852,
-0.2366631925,
-0.4339905977,
-0.6059733629,
-0.4428817034,
-0.3488859236,
0.0187499039,
0.5499835014,
0.0644007102,
-0.2868374288,
0.4747534394,
0.5889881849,
-0.3459662497,
0.2730942965,
0.5768857002,
0.121763885,
-0.4873026311,
0.8587216735,
-0.1154114902,
0.1856897473,
0.7458607554,
0.197962597,
-0.1254969984,
-0.9277326465,
-0.0306183193,
0.2069678903,
-0.4395133555,
-0.4732195735,
-0.6186915636,
-0.0516912676,
-0.3766050637,
-0.1880060136,
-0.1538012028,
-0.3749265373,
0.4899791777,
-0.2704310417,
0.3032126427,
-0.1978834718,
-0.3836729527,
0.7696182728,
-1.316668272,
0.2175589949,
-0.1135278344,
0.2194644362,
-0.4640611112,
-0.2269627005,
-0.3343732953,
0.0374355577,
-0.045435261,
-1.177695632,
0.7657611966,
0.1188797653,
0.4464983046,
0.4469071329,
0.305172205,
0.6561754942,
-0.6353799701,
0.2583985031,
0.5200124383,
-0.9797030687,
0.4142041504,
-0.0924755111,
-0.0217552707,
0.9980511069,
0.5682960153,
-0.5244349241,
-0.106532678,
-0.8189284801,
-0.7453677654,
0.5767778754,
0.4257008433,
-0.1543827206,
-0.2360184342,
0.267421484,
-0.0654421896,
0.2304267436,
-0.5098413825,
-0.1915765852,
0.3674120009,
-0.3947445452,
-0.4162214994,
-0.4160322547,
-0.1716474444,
-0.2126469463,
0.7648040652,
-0.1228672117,
0.3165449202,
0.3160107732,
-0.2952941656,
-0.3358055353,
0.5206639767,
-0.0114235841,
0.0755672306,
-0.5740672946,
0.1276183277,
0.1623124033,
-0.5037810802,
0.3209489286,
0.2720032334,
-0.3386285007,
0.1477667093,
0.04539207,
0.414752543,
0.5289678574,
-0.9691658616,
0.8783088326,
-0.1704911888,
-0.4733297527,
-0.0021513943,
0.0784930363,
-0.044142101,
0.0665338039,
0.4027516842,
0.3374272585,
0.5851415396,
-0.3590860069,
0.3883451521,
0.4336231947,
-0.1527284384,
-0.1881178319,
0.142701894,
-0.0113377133,
-0.0246255342,
0.4665777981,
-0.4939381778,
-0.2376667261,
0.4793833196,
0.3853413761,
0.7809607983,
-0.2997491062,
0.2586663365,
0.5012540817,
0.8390960097,
-0.25088346,
0.4628469348,
-0.0138192819,
-0.6788891554,
-0.8355272412,
-0.727039516,
-0.3962101936,
-0.013183686,
-0.7715002894,
-0.1184065044,
-0.5016163588,
-0.3751261532,
-0.2905529439,
-0.0043606604,
-0.6014308929,
0.1537255198,
-0.1499931067,
1.0507148504,
-0.6400843859,
0.9034101367,
0.3608049154,
-0.1994514465,
-0.8256152868,
-0.0503019318,
-0.0263083,
-0.4757446945,
0.4388007224,
0.2306582779,
-0.1621784717,
0.1678208709,
-0.5118303895,
-0.9730060101,
1.136362195,
0.4395166039,
-0.8821206689,
0.0439960435,
-0.1839308292,
0.1036154926,
0.0903103352,
-0.1941559762,
0.8147110939,
0.4414189458,
0.1344400644,
-0.6144836545,
0.1356953233,
-0.2297950983,
0.1218096241,
0.4856156111,
-0.1918812245,
0.365449816,
-0.3853000104,
-0.6481868625,
0.1272452474,
0.6217694283,
0.3308847845,
0.4389440119,
0.4974682927,
0.1554373056,
0.7076064348,
0.053510204,
1.1170041561,
-0.4517809749,
0.1451274306,
0.88226372,
-0.0954011306,
1.0624958277,
0.6360766292,
-0.4486078024,
0.1712026298,
0.5874384046,
0.2559919357,
0.7838580608,
0.4048488438,
-0.2139298767,
-0.2792823315,
0.5191679001,
-0.083747007,
-0.1286710054,
0.4241799712,
-0.1827484369,
0.0237717945,
-0.103322044,
0.036195375,
-0.0273274593,
-0.16385369,
0.6151649952,
0.2447862029,
-0.5994400978,
0.3759875894,
0.4898226559,
0.8030517101,
-0.692745626,
0.1923778057,
0.0137714865,
0.2367655337,
-0.089409627,
-0.2916847467,
0.3400803208,
-0.0825799853,
0.0826692656,
-0.0322639383,
1.0249820948,
-0.1796974689,
-0.7105106711,
0.2149498016,
0.4883981347,
0.1103079915,
-0.3361905515,
-0.454644382,
-0.223123312,
-0.0433546565,
-0.1672916114,
0.50721699,
0.1254830062,
0.2970434129,
0.8521885276,
0.9072247148,
0.1180844381,
0.2805296183,
-0.2925391793,
0.6006755233,
-0.6904610395,
-0.3380080462,
-0.7362977266,
0.6235878468,
0.0451066382,
0.1072741151,
0.5133560896,
0.6604286432,
0.6968390942,
-0.2370195687,
0.908018291,
-0.0781499967,
0.384206146,
-0.6655890346,
0.5214688182,
-0.21295771,
-0.0322170034,
-0.1815751791,
-0.8026425838,
-0.4998175204,
1.095857501,
-0.4313283563,
-0.2596701384,
0.9230923653,
0.9825949073,
-0.0035003736,
-0.2542152703,
0.4201947451,
-0.0477328412,
0.0224159025,
0.737547636,
0.5170603991,
-0.3977556527,
0.7292932868,
-0.6567592621,
-0.5312395096,
-0.3354523182,
-0.9133204818,
-0.6008704901,
-0.3330852687,
-0.3412759304,
-0.3258177638,
0.2660447359,
0.9533042312,
0.6152261496,
-0.6836591363,
-0.2471427619,
-0.2408673465,
-0.023881577,
-0.5903829932,
-0.2053571492,
0.2363548577,
-0.3033614755,
-0.4233380258,
0.7060964108,
0.3651647866,
-0.1400710046,
0.1959625185,
-0.1727448553,
0.0606641918,
0.2310220748,
0.453710705,
0.1157921478,
-0.1874014586,
-0.2258218825,
-0.0704834312,
0.0012915031,
0.1241815463,
0.7931861281,
-0.5942518115,
0.2482380122,
0.5794413686,
0.8145558238,
0.6980600953,
-0.1445113569,
0.7682008147,
-0.8049450517,
0.10562215,
0.251265049,
0.4534426033,
0.1878700405,
-0.3929688931,
0.3648884296,
0.2569946051,
-0.29426682,
-0.7054159641,
0.4092982411,
-1.1969225407,
-0.2464165092,
0.7968984842,
0.0396708958,
-0.4147773981,
0.0107730804,
-0.2974183559,
0.1570205539,
-0.5696365237,
0.6392998695,
0.6234557033,
0.0699255243,
-0.2132257223,
-0.5024482012,
0.5809515715,
0.5093955398,
-0.3743889332,
-0.1192522496,
0.681258738,
0.5191865563,
0.1093045622,
1.0562492609,
-0.0917421281,
0.5345176458,
0.164791435,
0.0854392201,
0.1007672325,
-0.3667885959,
-0.4454548359,
0.4315120578,
0.2236109525,
-0.0956723616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14901v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14901v2
|
Code Search Debiasing:Improve Search Results beyond Overall Ranking Performance
| 2023-11-25T02:31:22 | 2024-02-17T01:22:24 |
Sheng Zhang, Hui Li, Yanlin Wang, Zhao Wei, Yong Xiu, Juhong Wang, Rongong Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code search engine is an essential tool in software development. Many code
search methods have sprung up, focusing on the overall ranking performance of
code search. In this paper, we study code search from another perspective by
analyzing the bias of code search models. Biased code search engines provide
poor user experience, even though they show promising overall performance. Due
to different development conventions (e.g., prefer long queries or
abbreviations), some programmers will find the engine useful, while others may
find it hard to get desirable search results. To mitigate biases, we develop a
general debiasing framework that employs reranking to calibrate search results.
It can be easily plugged into existing engines and handle new code search
biases discovered in the future. Experiments show that our framework can
effectively reduce biases. Meanwhile, the overall ranking performance of code
search gets improved after debiasing.
|
[
-0.4174922109,
-0.2637072504,
0.5829744339,
0.1427757889,
-0.2652266026,
0.1916925013,
-0.1561883837,
-0.4351408184,
0.378526032,
0.4319424629,
-0.2862386703,
-0.5429697633,
-0.5088214874,
-0.0164195281,
-0.3269385397,
0.7511517406,
0.0524001792,
0.1982224584,
-0.4096027613,
0.0644701645,
-0.5505928993,
-0.6128615737,
-0.3447830677,
-0.2860923409,
0.3174987733,
0.3530319333,
1.0098887682,
0.6167224646,
0.6471269727,
0.2286437303,
0.0651636049,
-0.2490715086,
-0.6460645199,
0.293068856,
-0.1242301539,
-0.8925518394,
-0.0903417245,
0.2201520205,
0.1081711352,
0.3320612907,
0.0024063003,
0.1916427612,
-0.0109828301,
0.9130789042,
-0.9291732311,
0.1449307948,
-0.6487693191,
0.0268160757,
-0.2977627516,
-0.4130319953,
-0.3722671866,
-0.8117612004,
-0.0468003787,
-0.4641871154,
0.3958210051,
-0.0427597389,
0.4867500365,
0.5624601245,
-0.2751519084,
-0.3265531063,
-0.5676583052,
0.9432118535,
-0.7686202526,
0.3527548611,
0.2757520974,
0.1765954942,
-0.0152766658,
-0.4776240885,
-0.0215278789,
-0.3969636261,
0.0846110284,
-0.2439299226,
0.0079311337,
0.0783040971,
0.3024959266,
0.4956337214,
-0.6489923,
-0.0064998986,
-0.3537792563,
-0.1948979199,
0.7153574228,
-0.2889574468,
0.5611721873,
0.1042408645,
-0.0906243995,
-0.1372181177,
-0.793235302,
0.0015430426,
0.6729007363,
-0.1608088613,
0.4204813838,
0.3697588742,
-0.2624877691,
0.6031918526,
-0.0431983843,
0.248087123,
0.4730475247,
0.0536695309,
-0.0502383672,
-0.0200001374,
0.0045498135,
0.6568537354,
0.5193331838,
-0.4384207129,
-0.3248679042,
0.511772871,
0.85348773,
-0.9255028367,
-0.2577762902,
0.2590488493,
-0.7915119529,
-0.7025160789,
0.2426588833,
-0.9135294557,
-0.5311952829,
-0.2438097447,
0.1517119855,
0.059062317,
-0.2035466582,
-0.0263976306,
-0.4821395576,
0.0448803119,
0.1024992988,
-0.5793266892,
0.0447711349,
0.728463769,
0.6371440291,
-0.016707005,
-0.1220477745,
-0.5367307663,
-0.2205425501,
-0.4885984957,
0.6517472267,
-1.0048912764,
-0.5341299772,
0.1555454582,
-0.4186155498,
0.2441503704,
-0.8180668354,
0.4478583038,
-0.9807828069,
-0.0448827147,
-0.1738131791,
-0.416857183,
-0.183076039,
0.1286236942,
-0.7314117551,
0.9468774796,
0.0620220006,
-0.7448012829,
0.5571317673,
-0.5199698806,
-0.312607944,
-0.1808728129,
-0.4563008547,
-0.206055969,
0.6034032702,
0.4642983377,
-0.149322331,
-0.3830488622,
0.3255994916,
-0.5471568704,
-0.9670926929,
0.0675259829,
0.0232010186,
0.7192835808,
0.5326996446,
-0.655031085,
-0.0724447891,
-0.3204138875,
0.5449509621,
-0.1712860912,
-0.3519697487,
-0.6886947751,
0.3737545311,
-0.1351914257,
0.1816135347,
0.1004278734,
-0.3186979592,
0.5749855638,
-0.6572079062,
0.3227743506,
0.7533274889,
-0.1751997769,
0.7707262635,
-0.2716166377,
0.817045927,
0.0235916302,
0.3611918986,
0.2269353271,
-0.3564109802,
-0.5509492755,
0.0548881702,
0.5423296094,
0.3896739781,
-0.7329637408,
0.226698041,
-0.1552235782,
-0.4025581479,
-0.7761013508,
0.3818201423,
0.510286808,
-0.2027290761,
0.3053298891,
-0.5750931501,
-0.7639564276,
-0.9024479389,
-0.7645875812,
-0.1001837179,
-0.297965467,
0.3577907383,
0.2519171834,
-0.6851553917,
0.9679537416,
-0.8670727611,
-0.2524298429,
0.0361736417,
-0.031801533,
0.2650064826,
0.486959815,
0.721781373,
-1.1097714901,
-0.1588314623,
-0.3555964231,
-0.544988811,
-0.429143697,
0.2016256303,
-0.2233730108,
0.2108944058,
0.5932402611,
-0.0216469616,
0.6240605116,
0.5421498418,
-0.1177577898,
0.3826577663,
0.1619987935,
0.3376384676,
-0.449254632,
0.1674047261,
-0.0298521761,
-0.1128137335,
-0.0256893579,
0.7674919963,
0.148893252,
-0.1776307523,
-0.1284104586,
0.2564775944,
-0.5103802681,
-0.2383320481,
-0.4697356224,
0.1069699079,
0.1549261957,
0.3239620626,
-0.2243935764,
1.0297273397,
0.4575715363,
-0.643992126,
0.1171735823,
-0.0186532959,
-0.5156769753,
0.0727422088,
-0.7207491398,
0.3096233606,
-0.0757823214,
0.3366582096,
-0.8326042891,
0.311870575,
-0.2536247671,
-0.5132384896,
0.0877874494,
-0.4486083686,
-0.2469864339,
-0.5938327909,
-0.8440968394,
0.7130172849,
0.6010738015,
-0.6127181649,
-0.1210998222,
0.5684309006,
0.0075609162,
-0.8035264015,
-0.6157767773,
-0.0304543171,
0.0459535941,
-0.5404644608,
0.6360854506,
-0.1461229175,
-0.3957481384,
-0.0983167589,
-0.4386224449,
-0.3607920706,
0.1696887165,
0.2661459148,
0.1709735692,
0.0040622544,
0.2282569706,
-0.0123434579,
-0.1794130802,
0.1950637847,
-0.4524469078,
0.5581148863,
0.1429402232,
-0.433049947,
0.0705624819,
0.280446887,
0.6388184428,
-0.3917867839,
0.2611298561,
0.1502041221,
-0.2571054697,
-0.2105649114,
-0.8205564618,
-0.2360193133,
-0.4654242396,
0.2039694488,
-0.1409004778,
-0.7136929631,
0.541451931,
-0.0861157179,
-0.1453621089,
0.3187118769,
0.4534383118,
0.3833314478,
1.3665679693,
0.8691395521,
-0.5553885698,
0.590339601,
-0.1922618002,
0.5262774825,
-0.7118186951,
0.0250725448,
-0.9421206117,
-0.5829856992,
-0.9826795459,
-0.4323422313,
0.2336524278,
0.0854461417,
0.013793271,
0.2006125897,
-1.0760588646,
0.8249796629,
0.6440826058,
0.3240047097,
0.1483926773,
-0.0044421521,
-0.3351199031,
-0.1669213474,
-0.2853853405,
-0.3132282495,
1.3089054823,
0.1962300539,
1.0967564583,
0.0876516551,
0.9153628945,
0.6406601667,
0.0779116228,
-0.5065238476,
0.1202751249,
0.0385959521,
-0.8949598074,
-0.0532031059,
-0.5628094077,
-0.4196076691,
0.3053578436,
0.3756700754,
-0.4795365632,
0.4519842565,
0.0948618948,
-0.0989344493,
0.091043219,
-0.7159360647,
0.7175240517,
-0.1872416884,
-0.4706385136,
-0.5141552687,
-0.2204987258,
0.1940862089,
0.1314068437,
0.2855454385,
0.2158773392,
0.0541243181,
0.5373596549,
-0.288249135,
0.5296485424,
-0.3367998898,
-0.2289595902,
0.2046986222,
0.3451930583,
0.4566638768,
0.6023754478,
-0.5031399727,
0.0649353936,
-0.0420633815,
-0.4785599113,
-0.5865426064,
1.0856641531,
-0.5294971466,
-0.5898733139,
-0.3912531137,
-0.0036201952,
0.0568918288,
0.2928946614,
0.4059847593,
0.3884220123,
-0.1821460277,
-0.0078464225,
0.6708692312,
-0.4544191957,
0.2548087835,
0.2723576725,
-0.4924066365,
-0.0922351778,
0.5394756794,
-0.0905126184,
-0.2047321498,
0.3562794924,
0.0093346108,
-0.3242690861,
-0.3661950231,
-0.2361911833,
-0.2901783586,
-0.5545400381,
-0.4327331185,
-0.3570277691,
0.0210260935,
-0.5357106328,
-0.2948113382,
-0.3712387085,
-0.1896102428,
-0.0406322852,
0.0697628558,
-0.045811478,
0.6370066404,
0.1471915096,
-0.0593323968,
-0.5202177167,
0.3818345368,
0.2144180238,
0.8337545395,
0.1383926719,
-0.1642616391,
-0.3559458852,
0.1296524554,
-0.5666952133,
-0.8041545153,
0.2687799037,
-0.2693727016,
0.6236807108,
0.1818564683,
0.2248827815,
0.5694983602,
-0.3063751161,
0.6931723952,
-0.1438940465,
-1.1199456453,
0.6583586931,
0.008550887,
0.3087094724,
0.9897629023,
0.0425408892,
-0.3968902528,
-0.3596922457,
-0.4116396904,
-0.8429917097,
0.3995462954,
0.3025920391,
0.0503425002,
0.1170495301,
0.5520249605,
-0.1147220731,
0.5251476169,
-0.7434738874,
-0.2974717319,
-0.1576859951,
0.224460274,
-0.051257357,
-0.5313484669,
0.0664824545,
-0.417814374,
0.6134045124,
-0.0871960372,
0.5077583194,
0.1756546199,
-0.4548921287,
-0.2673797905,
0.3817000985,
0.4906911552,
0.8515617251,
-0.2783617973,
0.1723002642,
-0.1782520115,
-0.4152941406,
0.0812972859,
-0.1550346166,
-0.1963503063,
0.1414663941,
0.040924646,
0.1940598339,
0.3149337769,
-0.5116675496,
0.6890434027,
-0.0030594869,
0.1793042421,
-0.1623735428,
0.2953092754,
-0.1323164254,
0.0397922583,
0.4450509846,
0.2225995362,
0.7129043341,
-0.510717988,
0.3659371436,
0.5216314793,
-0.3326503932,
0.0582500659,
0.776217401,
0.6351101398,
-0.1647465378,
0.5990977287,
-0.2157228589,
-0.9100432396,
0.8929029107,
0.3786527216,
1.2642240524,
-0.0840286911,
0.0726111084,
0.3119487762,
0.3410786092,
-0.265966773,
0.1189147979,
-0.0831023455,
-0.2017652541,
-0.5710683465,
-0.375744611,
-0.3162213266,
-0.1266441941,
-0.6054987907,
0.3849388361,
-0.2400386184,
-0.1497831792,
-0.1513282806,
0.2465958148,
-0.7620776296,
0.2123734206,
0.0875666514,
1.0351451635,
-0.340372324,
0.7554287314,
0.6774468422,
-0.5661484003,
-0.2306793779,
0.3409177363,
0.0207213424,
-0.6712272763,
0.6413679123,
0.5377690196,
-0.2923948467,
-0.2188877612,
-0.6613062024,
-0.7619199753,
0.6984343529,
0.3019676208,
-0.7186262012,
-0.2378876805,
-0.187228322,
0.4885280728,
-0.3156687319,
0.7752245069,
0.4471922219,
0.5201034546,
-0.6419032216,
-0.8281849623,
-0.0492015369,
-0.4946379364,
0.4883595407,
0.3382450044,
-0.3001766205,
0.6815438271,
-0.1248881072,
-0.0499529839,
-0.0370657183,
-0.0463850871,
0.0473963879,
0.5488550067,
0.2510960996,
0.3516315222,
0.5127567649,
0.0765392557,
1.145390749,
-0.4838165045,
0.6318160295,
0.7491974831,
-0.6192979813,
0.5128506422,
0.5434141159,
-0.1654668599,
0.6378535032,
0.2963554859,
0.0593114495,
0.7084487081,
0.7801317573,
0.1076880023,
-0.2556760609,
0.2373604327,
-0.8123990893,
0.4230750203,
-0.2497334778,
-0.6206880808,
-0.3189240694,
-0.3441205025,
-0.0871429965,
0.3906357288,
-0.1358665377,
0.5249830484,
-0.0639351532,
-0.7415610552,
0.6268606186,
0.1013523787,
1.0023289919,
-0.2427561432,
-0.1294099689,
-0.3551882505,
0.4768093526,
-0.460545361,
-0.3696447909,
0.271661222,
-0.0512625836,
-0.6330676675,
-0.1189368293,
0.7569220662,
0.0479486138,
-0.410260886,
0.6851065755,
0.5220447183,
-0.0679337531,
-0.6325168014,
-0.7014148235,
0.377751708,
0.3788584471,
-0.1947731525,
0.4101233482,
0.0254438855,
0.0372847505,
0.5265562534,
0.4745677114,
-0.1670477539,
-0.2042862028,
-0.0854599401,
1.0010613203,
-0.8028773069,
-0.642157495,
-0.8158083558,
0.0123360148,
-0.1842737943,
-0.1224965528,
0.6000729799,
0.8797625899,
1.0498256683,
-0.2888939381,
0.8496587276,
-0.07687895,
0.430023104,
-0.4908600748,
0.8631381392,
-0.5488339067,
0.6556685567,
-0.5032167435,
-1.2864639759,
-0.3689728081,
0.7647422552,
-0.4405319095,
0.3924626708,
0.5331204534,
0.9704576731,
-0.0836530402,
-0.0984967649,
0.1656578481,
-0.2373659164,
0.4385898113,
0.4835793674,
0.5255130529,
-0.4562670588,
0.4465738535,
-0.2143061757,
-0.2692717612,
-0.5748375058,
-0.8057362437,
-0.6193367839,
-0.1939561814,
-0.1175539866,
-0.3083435595,
0.2275018841,
0.6316094398,
0.6547719836,
-0.7676618695,
-0.1480476856,
-0.2051647902,
0.483795166,
-0.3868186474,
-0.2551330924,
-0.0337052606,
-0.6183196306,
-0.6115319133,
0.2647125721,
-0.0064680534,
-0.6020483375,
-0.3232051134,
-0.1146024168,
0.0780058205,
-0.0676230788,
0.3504539728,
0.0217017587,
-0.4419349432,
-0.1781717837,
0.0529020652,
-0.345125407,
0.1729673445,
1.3597823381,
-1.2500953674,
0.5353250504,
0.6419938207,
0.4655838907,
0.1988629103,
0.0887122229,
0.7641843557,
-0.728207469,
0.0911719874,
0.2006677687,
0.0615884364,
-0.088474825,
-0.6278036237,
0.8388288617,
-0.1485197097,
-0.8206130862,
-0.876134038,
0.3063419759,
-0.4170737863,
-0.5327117443,
1.2595530748,
0.2531326115,
0.0058236783,
0.0052031996,
-0.5131555796,
0.0700309128,
-0.5642297864,
1.0437749624,
0.5285711288,
0.0647759959,
0.2717647552,
-0.5866131783,
0.5672388077,
0.5098661184,
-0.4241842031,
0.0391360857,
0.5837253928,
0.4328692555,
0.2686971426,
0.4252752066,
-0.3982134461,
0.4700893462,
-0.191965878,
0.3294559121,
0.0798110366,
-0.2087746412,
-0.473533392,
0.0528772883,
0.4365634024,
-0.1946372539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14871v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14871v1
|
Tracing Influence at Scale: A Contrastive Learning Approach to Linking Public Comments and Regulator Responses
| 2023-11-24T23:32:13 | 2023-11-24T23:32:13 |
Linzi Xing, Brad Hackinen, Giuseppe Carenini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
U.S. Federal Regulators receive over one million comment letters each year
from businesses, interest groups, and members of the public, all advocating for
changes to proposed regulations. These comments are believed to have
wide-ranging impacts on public policy. However, measuring the impact of
specific comments is challenging because regulators are required to respond to
comments but they do not have to specify which comments they are addressing. In
this paper, we propose a simple yet effective solution to this problem by using
an iterative contrastive method to train a neural model aiming for matching
text from public comments to responses written by regulators. We demonstrate
that our proposal substantially outperforms a set of selected text-matching
baselines on a human-annotated test set. Furthermore, it delivers performance
comparable to the most advanced gigantic language model (i.e., GPT-4), and is
more cost-effective when handling comments and regulator responses matching in
larger scale.
|
[
-0.3815329969,
-0.2148865461,
0.6058088541,
0.2250208855,
-0.3805215657,
-0.213709712,
-0.3078666627,
-0.5586710572,
0.217290014,
0.5001134872,
-0.4247738719,
-0.2059763521,
-0.4947497249,
0.1522173285,
-0.2798081934,
1.2342150211,
0.1860693842,
0.0850889012,
-0.0391647108,
0.2221165597,
0.0756623223,
-0.5368021131,
-0.7148830295,
-0.4651198685,
0.9078996778,
-0.0295081418,
0.2699047923,
0.5906769633,
0.5470780134,
0.3969087303,
-0.3801248074,
-0.1867307574,
-0.5518776178,
-0.6414808035,
-0.3817866445,
-0.3397445679,
-0.1230484992,
0.1785406768,
0.6560240984,
0.5623820424,
-0.0882627293,
0.1866621971,
0.2507317662,
0.609338522,
-0.88312608,
0.3727400303,
-0.4024537802,
-0.2554496229,
0.1477500796,
-0.2636711597,
-0.6192396879,
-0.4888674319,
0.3952892125,
-0.6204724312,
0.1309045255,
-0.0748488978,
0.8351268768,
0.1090974361,
-0.6102237701,
-0.4407579601,
-0.7386521101,
0.5052449703,
-0.8838737607,
0.2150498182,
0.2878209651,
0.0343133882,
0.1228203401,
-1.0734517574,
-0.3802777231,
-0.3767324984,
-0.4538398683,
0.0790430829,
-0.1509173065,
0.0633779615,
0.4087962508,
0.2512427568,
0.1792134941,
-0.0118709272,
-0.5148281455,
-0.1699445397,
0.4207620621,
0.1642374992,
-0.0690429285,
-0.0871050134,
-0.3794482648,
-0.2401885688,
-0.5114585161,
0.2114521712,
0.4596783817,
0.7295950651,
-0.0977189168,
-0.0298731755,
-0.0740269348,
0.605445981,
0.1148436368,
0.3698859811,
0.0137085058,
-0.3504772186,
-0.1979738772,
-0.122495532,
0.7857809067,
0.4523516893,
0.0988355577,
-0.0032304749,
-0.170694977,
-0.042385716,
0.383385092,
-1.1992208958,
-0.4461051524,
-0.4910773337,
-0.5729138851,
-0.5065073967,
0.2849649191,
-1.02787745,
-0.8378738165,
-0.5279428363,
0.6325339079,
0.2632179558,
-0.3102711141,
-0.0899427235,
-0.0248309784,
0.2580753267,
0.3714349568,
-1.2707173824,
0.5167443156,
0.5890491009,
0.7814033031,
0.2851124406,
0.1028523445,
-0.4538642764,
-0.0625097379,
-0.4842743278,
0.8400660157,
-0.6547673941,
-0.3136228621,
0.0661847219,
-0.1926540434,
0.0572604761,
-0.4950177968,
0.3641045094,
-0.5211936831,
0.1272066981,
-0.7219131589,
-0.4477620423,
-0.2710377872,
0.359852612,
-0.7586560249,
0.3762557507,
0.041971691,
-1.099188447,
0.4048310816,
-0.5971795917,
-0.3052551746,
-0.2164474875,
-0.3716398478,
-0.4557721317,
0.0266862754,
0.0770709217,
0.3731142282,
-0.5034427643,
-0.0879607052,
-0.3462353945,
-0.4079675972,
-0.0194635317,
-0.1706543714,
0.8682689071,
-0.1434853375,
-0.577827394,
0.4639199376,
-0.869317472,
-0.1879985631,
-0.4209711552,
-0.7409520745,
-0.3297909796,
0.0718518421,
0.2977984846,
0.2371545434,
0.0395570882,
-0.6298597455,
-0.0405608006,
-0.1459154934,
0.6485270262,
1.1572511196,
0.2468914241,
0.2979207337,
-0.2012509406,
0.0715509132,
-0.164098382,
0.0300006773,
-0.1579072922,
-0.1316810995,
-0.7262868285,
-0.0740430504,
0.36724177,
0.0200603753,
-0.2384992838,
-0.0186532997,
-0.1994414628,
-0.487269491,
-0.4018337131,
0.0239552148,
0.4300475717,
0.6080696583,
0.2769387662,
-0.2329268157,
-0.4970787168,
-0.9369258881,
-0.4167026579,
-0.3140819967,
-0.3550060987,
0.4415165782,
0.5685275197,
0.0265692249,
0.3925119042,
-0.6407228112,
-0.3153518736,
0.3395236135,
0.4316551983,
-0.054105904,
0.3548294902,
0.3656132221,
-0.6367093325,
-0.7074769139,
0.3149837554,
-0.3184844255,
0.0935966671,
-0.1787189841,
-0.0482266359,
-0.5007476807,
0.9871932864,
-0.0444178544,
0.1163680553,
0.5029043555,
-0.4832332134,
0.2794692516,
-0.2161324173,
0.2701776624,
-1.024173975,
0.4012983143,
0.3193337619,
0.0630663112,
-0.5899541974,
-0.1943803281,
0.1932080537,
0.1634664237,
-0.0189679768,
0.2406465411,
-0.3112481236,
0.1550749242,
-0.2647486925,
0.0393066145,
-0.3149224222,
0.6024298668,
-0.0862150267,
0.7261856794,
0.2201195359,
-0.5937668681,
0.17815575,
0.1186479107,
-0.4960038066,
0.7289120555,
-0.563555181,
0.1987140179,
-0.0295591019,
0.393158257,
-1.1543480158,
-0.2058317214,
-0.0639215708,
-0.221673578,
0.145415917,
0.0377671979,
-0.2592755258,
-0.1694814563,
-0.2586068213,
-0.1889118254,
0.4048983157,
-0.7169592977,
0.9283051491,
0.2049231976,
-0.1993793547,
-0.3570847213,
-0.6939533949,
0.0489839166,
-0.1902685016,
-0.248202011,
0.0203393959,
-0.0854626372,
-0.3051404357,
-0.0159173943,
-0.1743170768,
-0.3093051314,
0.1333954334,
0.1843766868,
-0.1112558618,
-0.3331615329,
0.0686327368,
-0.4108747244,
0.1682065725,
0.6653121114,
0.1320719868,
0.0681551993,
-0.2548885345,
0.1564366072,
-0.6919407248,
0.0996208116,
0.6003240347,
-0.0783685371,
0.3950318694,
0.0499298871,
0.0463106669,
-0.432825923,
-0.3517569602,
-0.4165431857,
-0.533257246,
0.381149888,
-0.1821449995,
-0.638406992,
0.4064972401,
-0.3705757558,
0.233113721,
0.3274483979,
0.4808964431,
0.3210710883,
0.8648109436,
1.0148411989,
-0.2387891561,
0.8508192897,
-0.0688943937,
0.0005985119,
-0.6558577418,
-0.3590037227,
-0.7478095889,
-0.3677029312,
-0.7859978676,
-0.1237188652,
-0.1242982224,
-0.350602001,
-0.3388110399,
0.4253020287,
-0.4206201434,
0.6520648599,
0.5406034589,
0.3405706584,
0.2708324492,
-0.1992948204,
-0.0891691893,
0.0749436244,
-0.3481751084,
-0.2966184914,
1.1552078724,
0.2836050391,
0.7707141638,
0.1894316673,
0.526026547,
0.0676760972,
1.1877163649,
-0.7123734355,
0.4072092474,
-0.2769886255,
-0.5086957812,
-0.1410715431,
-0.7026149631,
-0.5298395753,
0.384617269,
-0.4610014856,
-0.6494794488,
0.3038090169,
0.429164201,
-0.2871481776,
0.5359300971,
-0.6375340223,
0.6130865812,
0.1762179285,
-0.5567516685,
-0.306045711,
-0.6262524128,
0.233831495,
-0.1640431583,
-0.0715701357,
0.3114900291,
0.0824908465,
1.0156934261,
-0.3232146204,
1.0847274065,
-0.217590332,
-0.3934954107,
0.0850076526,
-0.4467850924,
0.4661722183,
-0.2321529835,
0.0051422291,
-0.2487911582,
-0.3888914883,
-0.2515466213,
-0.5595477819,
0.8756654263,
-0.7755796313,
-0.373707056,
-0.1748606116,
-0.3974510729,
-0.2441935241,
0.2898722291,
0.2508808374,
0.4057310522,
-0.2998538613,
0.3788999617,
0.4576377273,
0.4017605484,
0.6360698342,
0.7047500014,
0.1652821451,
-0.6593037844,
0.5906772614,
0.0494154021,
0.1310912073,
0.455047965,
0.5160898566,
-0.3732691109,
-0.2489499897,
0.0900858045,
0.2832319736,
-0.8980864286,
-0.0938113481,
-0.2665193081,
0.1640918553,
-0.0633893237,
-0.0909702703,
-0.2513217032,
0.0413876586,
-0.2440324426,
-0.0921699777,
0.0897948742,
1.2644684315,
-0.1874241084,
0.4548891783,
-0.2251741886,
0.0608111285,
0.7929661274,
0.8556199074,
0.3903713822,
-0.5613641143,
-0.2663646638,
-0.2991823852,
-0.1681929976,
-0.6487585902,
-0.2267484665,
-0.0271788035,
0.3622072339,
0.7314921618,
-0.0066857031,
0.629973352,
-0.5050705671,
0.4880968928,
0.3302373886,
-0.9462268353,
0.190430671,
-0.250266999,
0.1491826773,
0.7034747005,
0.4880621433,
-0.3791405261,
-0.2959491313,
-0.4723653793,
-0.7390266061,
0.6236259341,
0.0548117794,
0.4416106045,
-0.0154637191,
0.3854976594,
-0.3287787437,
0.1256541163,
-0.7146781087,
0.0875163078,
-0.0347316489,
0.0559777766,
-0.1417912245,
-0.1979494989,
-0.1996595263,
-0.0666365921,
0.5621114969,
-0.0071930075,
-0.0118403528,
0.1713360697,
0.3109782934,
-0.1815658957,
0.2446347773,
0.8923333883,
0.6508572698,
-0.1989581287,
0.4344108701,
-0.1323437989,
-0.6060044169,
0.0283963941,
0.1037318483,
-0.2026763856,
-0.0721971989,
0.4518574178,
0.622415781,
0.4689966738,
-0.1931716353,
0.547286272,
-0.0701430216,
-0.6428297162,
0.2088862807,
-0.231627062,
0.4905123413,
0.3529625535,
0.1237280667,
0.095476836,
0.2591739595,
-0.597520113,
0.4884563982,
0.2287022769,
-0.9578672647,
-0.3946664929,
0.7223790884,
0.6235941648,
-0.2511125505,
0.5844188333,
0.3126769066,
-0.4351145923,
0.7164509892,
0.606515944,
0.944124639,
-0.3164661229,
-0.0696678236,
0.6660253406,
0.3245099783,
-0.4074926078,
-0.0789241865,
-0.1380741149,
-0.2048726231,
-0.4187799394,
-0.1514618993,
-0.5301552415,
0.3761669099,
-0.9029439092,
0.2318699807,
-1.2242136002,
-0.3801596463,
0.536319077,
0.0636890605,
-0.3994380832,
0.1783732325,
0.1461124718,
0.7837596536,
-1.3029611111,
0.4781003296,
0.604516089,
-0.7839668393,
-0.9439608455,
0.4749660492,
-0.0237874165,
-0.4604465961,
0.688129127,
0.4262301922,
-0.3470832109,
0.003122028,
-0.7501351833,
-0.3985356987,
0.7307119966,
0.1821119189,
-0.7823647857,
0.2600197792,
-0.2989641726,
0.8216868639,
-0.2216527462,
0.1745631397,
0.6025776863,
0.2370784283,
0.1594209373,
-0.7772489786,
0.3037961125,
-0.4242253602,
0.0178844016,
0.5043406487,
-0.8801685572,
1.0921579599,
-0.0867116526,
-0.091828607,
-0.1406449676,
0.6174793839,
-0.2841307223,
-0.0416673273,
0.5980821848,
0.3663630784,
0.6265106797,
0.2081891149,
0.7818496823,
-0.3429986238,
0.5261480808,
1.3644733429,
-0.1364233047,
1.1235345602,
0.7166806459,
-0.0601898842,
0.7375505567,
0.2844201922,
-0.3662140667,
0.7165016532,
0.7679361105,
-0.5563483238,
0.0625043362,
-0.134837538,
-0.026021732,
0.0364157148,
0.014568435,
-0.6915572882,
-0.4142856002,
-0.4041389823,
0.1031768546,
0.6193987727,
-0.6423047781,
0.9206941724,
0.0267820191,
-0.6362568736,
0.2036931962,
-0.1869056076,
0.6362978816,
-0.64858675,
-0.3652202785,
-0.3509696722,
0.5362328291,
-0.2508579195,
-0.5057692528,
-0.0043130904,
0.2159806788,
-0.1969970465,
-0.1534514874,
0.0779768378,
-0.3789542019,
-0.1927985996,
0.5226935744,
-0.415430814,
-0.2306532115,
-0.0363548324,
-0.3528890908,
-0.1747262925,
-0.0064388658,
-0.4843415022,
0.2655138671,
0.341719985,
-0.0294557661,
0.3542768359,
0.4046187699,
-0.0190693848,
-0.2510557473,
0.1161392182,
1.1141605377,
-0.5451949239,
-0.7296028733,
-0.7747709155,
0.422322154,
-0.3966700435,
-0.4466070831,
0.5954262614,
0.4741559327,
0.777780056,
-0.1193360314,
0.8349151015,
0.0834347829,
0.3841183186,
-0.2648151517,
0.6332185268,
-0.220564872,
0.2080953121,
-0.2810269296,
-0.7863231897,
-0.4360451698,
0.8350453973,
-0.5153875947,
0.1123160422,
0.7747761607,
0.7072308064,
-0.188981548,
-0.071447961,
0.1387790591,
0.3386967778,
0.4361870885,
0.5227581263,
0.5366638303,
-0.3555045128,
1.0969339609,
-0.1634092182,
-0.2366346866,
-0.1481759399,
-1.0036174059,
-1.2167377472,
-0.2309925109,
-0.2449379265,
-0.4598655105,
-0.1935616881,
0.7727226019,
0.5715799332,
-0.849901557,
-0.4451355338,
-0.4736198485,
-0.3581158817,
-0.0945514664,
-0.0995942056,
0.5751737952,
-0.1057191491,
-0.5336335897,
-0.0145199979,
-0.0136290565,
-0.0582309626,
-0.2224142104,
0.141585499,
-0.1892282218,
0.4062347114,
0.3436781466,
0.3921483457,
-0.6313371658,
-0.4818147421,
-0.253579855,
-0.3491808474,
0.0527221002,
1.1800061464,
-0.3825384378,
0.5666972995,
0.503536582,
0.7273962498,
0.8031212687,
0.062533319,
0.4626673758,
-0.6393127441,
0.1610666513,
0.0738527626,
-0.0504366495,
0.3987821341,
-0.2790333331,
0.4610137939,
0.0200246982,
-0.4921566844,
-0.3515844047,
0.2208911777,
-0.7694069743,
-0.3703103065,
0.9358005524,
-0.3945237994,
-0.1013827473,
0.2426666915,
-0.3039840162,
0.0049854596,
-0.4124423563,
1.0610417128,
0.7395108342,
0.0306680091,
-0.1445019394,
-0.256105274,
0.7250175476,
0.0866745785,
-0.9300140142,
0.440844655,
0.4614933431,
0.4972196221,
0.3092547357,
0.9256345034,
0.0779386237,
0.2272077501,
0.5160778165,
-0.1311748624,
0.1951223016,
-0.1974800527,
-0.6644803882,
0.2908536196,
0.0748755708,
-0.0058021969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14865v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14865v2
|
Improving Cross-Domain Hate Speech Generalizability with Emotion Knowledge
| 2023-11-24T23:00:36 | 2023-12-17T23:14:37 |
Shi Yin Hong, Susan Gauch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reliable automatic hate speech (HS) detection systems must adapt to the
in-flow of diverse new data to curtail hate speech. However, hate speech
detection systems commonly lack generalizability in identifying hate speech
dissimilar to data used in training, impeding their robustness in real-world
deployments. In this work, we propose a hate speech generalization framework
that leverages emotion knowledge in a multitask architecture to improve the
generalizability of hate speech detection in a cross-domain setting. We
investigate emotion corpora with varying emotion categorical scopes to
determine the best corpus scope for supplying emotion knowledge to foster
generalized hate speech detection. We further assess the relationship between
using pretrained Transformers models adapted for hate speech and its effect on
our emotion-enriched hate speech generalization model. We perform extensive
experiments on six publicly available datasets sourced from different online
domains and show that our emotion-enriched HS detection generalization method
demonstrates consistent generalization improvement in cross-domain evaluation,
increasing generalization performance up to 18.1% and average cross-domain
performance up to 8.5%, according to the F1 measure.
|
[
-0.5517340899,
-0.534491241,
0.2664918303,
0.0557341352,
-0.0371586345,
0.2129520178,
-0.500038147,
-0.6756555438,
0.3129791617,
0.2751684487,
-0.5073927641,
-0.6685889959,
-0.9945275187,
-0.0874102041,
-0.4298247695,
1.2049326897,
0.1524638236,
-0.0787017569,
-0.0369344428,
-0.4143302441,
0.0003029507,
-0.8768140674,
-0.3959616423,
-0.1727595776,
0.7533771396,
0.3968872726,
0.7614329457,
0.2712635398,
0.3228623271,
0.2167907059,
0.2246056199,
-0.1403048784,
-0.5953851342,
0.3313940465,
-0.2328612357,
-0.2328896075,
-0.4940646291,
-0.2514543235,
0.1468369216,
0.0813128501,
-0.1585995108,
0.0694360361,
-0.2365753353,
0.3485725224,
-0.9534503818,
-0.1840147972,
-0.7915267348,
0.2746535838,
-0.3003174961,
-0.1326047927,
-0.141219154,
-0.0931276605,
0.4469938874,
-0.7033757567,
0.4115008414,
-0.017156247,
0.4854295254,
0.3411442041,
-0.1918594986,
-0.4232075512,
-0.7563309669,
0.955820024,
-0.4744822085,
0.7684983611,
0.3728426695,
0.3289913237,
0.3535490334,
-0.3584422171,
-0.4762291908,
-0.0611007474,
0.0743352473,
0.1125296801,
-0.8674790859,
0.271715194,
0.1601651013,
0.2743307948,
-0.7579234242,
-0.0085950978,
-0.0187402293,
-0.4003713131,
0.5904435515,
0.1081413552,
0.4802664518,
0.1681778282,
-0.297867775,
-0.0043176105,
-0.2306035012,
-0.1203149185,
0.8406798244,
0.3670848608,
-0.159957543,
0.2163698822,
-0.2745788097,
0.3109834492,
0.1762580425,
0.1783087254,
0.4987023771,
0.1250948906,
-0.2367092818,
-0.2157137245,
0.4423950016,
0.321084708,
0.5764600039,
-0.6627368331,
0.069122456,
0.4910717309,
0.8359463215,
-0.8223775029,
-0.0469908491,
0.3377492726,
-0.2117938399,
-0.1080869958,
-0.5321666002,
-1.1904639006,
-0.5056604147,
-0.3101194501,
0.2831349075,
-0.4944356382,
-0.5052862763,
-0.0764927641,
-0.3584011495,
-0.190987885,
0.0809742659,
-0.9528915882,
0.2574269176,
0.435021013,
0.3862928748,
-0.602488637,
-0.1604017913,
-0.6026110053,
0.1045517549,
0.1589314342,
0.6248163581,
-0.8981045485,
-0.0685619414,
0.2984877825,
-0.194307968,
-0.0430969298,
-0.7595125437,
0.672876358,
-0.6580821872,
-0.0139299212,
0.2144497931,
-0.3929289579,
-0.2062239945,
0.2461361736,
-0.2913240492,
0.858027339,
0.2698602974,
-0.7217594981,
0.5755858421,
-0.6690201163,
-0.5176169276,
-0.0079587838,
0.1718361527,
-0.5215120912,
0.1487154067,
0.113818787,
0.4746001363,
0.0429041646,
0.2515254021,
-0.6912798285,
-0.1420386732,
-0.2561479509,
-0.0082020974,
0.2932913601,
0.3524120748,
-0.7728372216,
0.3692235649,
-0.6790133715,
-0.1054932177,
0.0339272134,
-0.0579536073,
-0.7337117195,
-0.0817603916,
0.0586880445,
0.1142653972,
-0.1126152426,
-0.771374464,
-0.2417629659,
-0.2503608763,
-0.1245144308,
0.7805169225,
-0.3837391436,
0.3638718724,
-0.1129153147,
0.780770421,
0.3408744037,
0.105555959,
0.579524219,
-0.4810169935,
-0.7254183292,
-0.1701478362,
-0.2480918467,
0.5825445056,
-0.6144276261,
0.1793772727,
-0.0702823848,
-0.4955598116,
-0.3094238639,
-0.0258009657,
0.509488225,
0.3543494344,
0.9087128043,
-0.2802833617,
-1.0711852312,
-0.9293225408,
-0.7928825617,
0.1258369982,
-0.2108785212,
0.2949240506,
0.4394410253,
-0.5982087851,
0.9508937001,
-0.2869543433,
-0.2197547406,
-0.1591670513,
0.4668196142,
-0.5636491179,
0.1152642518,
0.6454553604,
-0.9122353196,
-0.5649520755,
-0.2724905908,
-0.4610818326,
-0.2101922035,
0.4250920713,
-0.3196435571,
-0.0000799296,
0.0111481333,
0.0335416608,
0.5593772531,
0.7384976745,
-0.446642518,
0.679864943,
0.4183534682,
0.368928194,
-0.7533094883,
-0.1532291174,
0.212992236,
-0.1441902071,
-1.1856696606,
-0.0531927533,
-0.2206569165,
-0.0695824102,
-0.7338220477,
0.329506427,
-0.0035783281,
0.0673498213,
-0.2896192968,
0.1421476603,
-0.4536274672,
0.8129846454,
0.340757519,
0.5275357962,
0.5637590885,
-0.7316774726,
0.4061113894,
0.1036118343,
-0.1140662134,
1.0300803185,
-0.1303782463,
0.2848539352,
-0.1581902057,
0.1026879027,
-0.6389660239,
-0.0514731482,
0.3684397936,
-0.5325910449,
-0.0483702049,
-0.1774034649,
0.0380299166,
-0.3117979765,
-0.1497465819,
0.4992822111,
0.2109669298,
-0.4698096514,
0.9433109164,
0.6685971618,
-0.1351276338,
-0.7935757637,
-0.6962293983,
-0.0572575256,
-0.484991014,
-0.6817404032,
0.6430279016,
-0.3634285331,
-0.238315165,
-0.1280976683,
-0.0267673954,
-0.4685516953,
-0.1574638486,
0.4622377455,
-0.177614674,
-0.1057879552,
0.3424417377,
0.0422295593,
0.3145722151,
0.1190446019,
-0.1317108572,
0.5227841139,
0.0189469457,
0.010217824,
-0.1562802643,
0.5718929172,
0.5859951973,
0.0055560595,
0.4719332159,
1.0128097534,
-0.4664232433,
-0.4555881321,
-0.6634960175,
0.0514086522,
-0.3753868937,
0.4932980835,
-0.3689843118,
-1.3991569281,
0.4454384148,
0.1111381873,
-0.1049568951,
0.4338504672,
0.7237116694,
0.2291643918,
0.8406028748,
0.6999180317,
-0.3327716887,
0.4624329805,
0.1340343803,
0.2171062529,
-0.7196082473,
0.0179648697,
-0.5050244927,
-0.3224486411,
-0.2064346373,
-0.4694536626,
0.174353227,
-0.4760051072,
-0.2543703914,
0.3271339536,
-0.5175765753,
0.2703585327,
0.2434278727,
0.032992851,
0.1379971057,
0.4325664341,
0.0098319128,
-0.2695520818,
-0.358523041,
0.051057104,
1.2444400787,
0.2933713198,
0.3077041805,
0.2466016561,
0.4856242537,
0.6597772241,
0.5169984102,
-0.7427906394,
0.0750411227,
-0.4674055576,
-0.7406258583,
-0.3350303769,
-0.5078677535,
-0.7093319297,
0.3236202896,
-0.0146947186,
-0.788625896,
0.19794707,
0.2903003693,
-0.5251550078,
0.5427492857,
-0.5204089284,
0.8893868327,
0.0030064895,
-0.1642055362,
-0.5819250345,
-0.3369759321,
0.4109446108,
-0.1268978566,
0.5061761737,
-0.2126753777,
0.1873938739,
1.1203160286,
-0.1905515045,
0.9787085056,
-0.4426441491,
-0.1781086177,
0.2294683009,
-0.0410863832,
0.3462619185,
-0.5347291231,
-0.2228560001,
0.3081285059,
-0.5610461235,
-0.1782526821,
-0.5609702468,
0.3982315958,
-0.6944359541,
-0.391972065,
-0.0192191377,
-0.7386203408,
-0.7711142898,
-0.1330062598,
0.3460360169,
0.1607990116,
-0.4521941543,
0.0349450186,
0.7112938762,
-0.397994101,
-0.0471540987,
0.6167699099,
-0.0773281232,
-0.3686152995,
1.0164613724,
-0.1348290741,
0.1664476395,
0.2265266478,
0.1813260466,
-0.3611917198,
-0.2562888861,
-0.4602719247,
-0.2005781531,
-0.5549957752,
-0.2106779069,
-1.1194978952,
0.1836329103,
-0.8403494358,
-0.1847860366,
-0.1612410247,
-0.1156230047,
0.0036025078,
-0.0268699173,
0.5078918338,
0.6487666965,
-0.3692124486,
0.4858012199,
-0.5185892582,
0.7789470553,
0.5890740156,
0.5210487247,
0.1768435836,
-1.0483005047,
-0.3547738791,
0.0653252304,
-0.2230771184,
-0.9753782749,
0.5303804278,
0.174163878,
0.4299875796,
0.2564583719,
0.1933988035,
0.812004149,
-0.5572013855,
0.5486846566,
0.220950529,
-1.1171737909,
0.429173857,
-0.2113299668,
0.0522782542,
0.3455908895,
0.794062674,
-0.8011342287,
-0.8273777366,
-0.7053502202,
-0.7030760646,
0.695397377,
0.1636623293,
0.1788842678,
0.2083334774,
-0.211143896,
0.1062626168,
0.2575825155,
-0.5469508171,
-0.4777977765,
-0.4350577295,
-0.2548414469,
0.0247506965,
-0.3122547269,
-0.2047056556,
-0.3167449236,
0.7620962858,
-0.0155383227,
0.2602311969,
-0.1543672681,
-0.3429332674,
-0.2763951421,
0.6279677153,
0.6248144507,
0.3265380561,
-0.1594340801,
0.1300217807,
0.3194566369,
-0.5399444699,
0.1778481007,
0.0639900565,
0.2934266925,
0.0737479702,
0.052890379,
0.8726580739,
0.277767539,
-0.5532262921,
0.726457417,
-0.0483719334,
-0.2336577028,
-0.139017567,
0.0144244134,
0.0112671796,
0.309914887,
0.2894995809,
0.1083725318,
0.3969696164,
-0.3206296861,
0.6370152831,
0.3638557792,
-0.41412884,
-0.3053514659,
0.595394969,
0.2421242297,
-0.0944522843,
0.1211578697,
-0.2478050888,
-1.0433595181,
0.492361635,
0.5768299103,
1.0901740789,
-0.6628373265,
0.3911504149,
0.2748974264,
0.0844311565,
0.5422972441,
0.1509719938,
-0.1375181824,
-1.0265747309,
-0.1576161683,
-0.8409291506,
-0.7415635586,
0.2408092618,
-0.4727570117,
-0.1623836905,
-0.3944623172,
-0.0407403968,
-0.0375774838,
-0.2912652493,
-0.9156538248,
0.5782729983,
0.6024729013,
0.4746692181,
-0.7540866137,
0.7109162807,
0.4033375084,
-0.1023341268,
-0.6791837811,
-0.0668022335,
0.3084578514,
-0.9634064436,
0.7054145932,
0.13514781,
-0.4319732189,
-0.2044702172,
-0.5096632838,
-0.6200319529,
0.4343204498,
0.179239288,
-0.5888861418,
0.2004968822,
0.5351923108,
0.7739413977,
-0.6312456131,
0.3252506256,
0.5197210312,
0.5086571574,
-0.0425051078,
-0.6681646705,
-0.130441308,
-0.0361575969,
-0.2943442166,
0.1279547513,
-0.4075225294,
0.5434762239,
0.128566578,
-0.2821057439,
-0.5251959562,
0.8427076936,
-0.0715961382,
0.4583171904,
0.7822170854,
0.9663059711,
0.7102096677,
0.1559433639,
0.7382270694,
-0.1564864665,
0.1124740466,
1.1440610886,
-0.2016061246,
0.6102961302,
-0.0000102277,
-0.1195479557,
0.7260683179,
0.1729113162,
0.084874168,
0.1587892026,
0.5972557664,
-0.6085423231,
-0.4517776966,
-0.3981512189,
-0.3541834652,
0.4334790409,
0.4042997956,
-0.2891646922,
-0.3829396367,
0.4104578793,
0.1386795938,
-0.0762366652,
-0.3601815403,
0.5846759677,
-0.2107561827,
-0.3496566415,
0.6262752414,
-0.0142745031,
1.3396579027,
-0.6042234898,
0.2235466093,
0.0126359109,
0.0681569725,
-0.4969289303,
-0.531111002,
0.7511025071,
0.583741188,
-0.3497464061,
-0.2027519047,
0.7790557742,
-0.7631105781,
0.1623807251,
0.8520175219,
0.2131461948,
0.2148624659,
-0.7615618706,
-0.541929841,
0.3377412856,
0.0055179228,
-0.1099462733,
0.5622882247,
0.3040095866,
0.2089910209,
0.3542163968,
0.5137683153,
-0.1645504087,
0.26104635,
0.2283516079,
0.7982218862,
-0.5547642708,
-0.40361166,
-0.6799589396,
0.5821757317,
-0.0213606302,
-0.5217703581,
0.524620533,
0.5242441893,
1.0496069193,
-0.1430722624,
1.0806308985,
-0.1447210163,
0.8098920584,
0.0151241403,
0.6231898665,
-0.6890061498,
-0.475662291,
-0.5701598525,
-0.7277500033,
-0.6143378615,
0.2837150395,
-0.550693512,
-0.2167170346,
0.5769795179,
0.8293898106,
-0.1752525121,
0.2543479204,
0.7209441662,
0.1480014026,
0.2326252759,
0.6589432955,
0.5184311271,
-0.354044199,
0.7971248627,
-0.4858158529,
-0.3438256085,
-0.088759385,
-0.533059895,
-0.6837084889,
-0.498707056,
-0.4093249738,
-0.3177660406,
0.3532221615,
0.5673014522,
0.7460463643,
-1.1134536266,
-0.2190951705,
0.4444893897,
0.1284247041,
0.0357213244,
-0.3164110482,
-0.0096081682,
-0.4891091883,
-0.7555469275,
0.6078075767,
0.2092637867,
-0.3140553236,
0.3279604316,
-0.2544209361,
-0.1505362689,
0.1672963947,
0.8844182491,
0.4033015072,
-0.5597344637,
-0.556251049,
-0.2467525005,
0.1061421186,
0.1405497938,
1.0157717466,
-0.5777084827,
0.3020675778,
0.1490093917,
0.912306428,
0.1952817589,
-0.0101547204,
0.3685176373,
-0.880566895,
0.0720673129,
0.4345447719,
0.2299482375,
0.1269523352,
-0.4211291969,
0.3918275833,
0.5068959594,
-0.6074132919,
-0.4419208169,
0.5151546597,
-0.7187747955,
-0.1302421987,
0.9804908037,
-0.1518756151,
-0.0046690912,
-0.3643879294,
0.2034098059,
0.4613389075,
-0.7597901821,
0.5555471778,
0.6493706107,
-0.1398261935,
0.0482123867,
0.0078183543,
0.8413723111,
0.7303156853,
-0.9630813003,
0.5004315376,
0.7075449824,
0.2554260194,
0.291988641,
0.4858456254,
0.1668514013,
0.254259795,
-0.1607290804,
0.5188981891,
0.2808822691,
-0.5567393899,
-0.365611881,
0.5479166508,
-0.7578241825,
0.0057228664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00805v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00805v1
|
Gender inference: can chatGPT outperform common commercial tools?
| 2023-11-24T22:09:14 | 2023-11-24T22:09:14 |
Michelle Alexopoulos, Kelly Lyons, Kaushar Mahetaji, Marcus Emmanuel Barnes, Rogan Gutwillinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
An increasing number of studies use gender information to understand
phenomena such as gender bias, inequity in access and participation, or the
impact of the Covid pandemic response. Unfortunately, most datasets do not
include self-reported gender information, making it necessary for researchers
to infer gender from other information, such as names or names and country
information. An important limitation of these tools is that they fail to
appropriately capture the fact that gender exists on a non-binary scale,
however, it remains important to evaluate and compare how well these tools
perform in a variety of contexts. In this paper, we compare the performance of
a generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) tool ChatGPT with three commercially
available list-based and machine learning-based gender inference tools (Namsor,
Gender-API, and genderize.io) on a unique dataset. Specifically, we use a large
Olympic athlete dataset and report how variations in the input (e.g., first
name and first and last name, with and without country information) impact the
accuracy of their predictions. We report results for the full set, as well as
for the subsets: medal versus non-medal winners, athletes from the largest
English-speaking countries, and athletes from East Asia. On these sets, we find
that Namsor is the best traditional commercially available tool. However,
ChatGPT performs at least as well as Namsor and often outperforms it,
especially for the female sample when country and/or last name information is
available. All tools perform better on medalists versus non-medalists and on
names from English-speaking countries. Although not designed for this purpose,
ChatGPT may be a cost-effective tool for gender prediction. In the future, it
might even be possible for ChatGPT or other large scale language models to
better identify self-reported gender rather than report gender on a binary
scale.
|
[
-0.2427796125,
-0.4518418312,
0.2351600677,
0.3186043501,
-0.0196629539,
0.1603297591,
-0.0727223009,
-0.6320707202,
-0.3614554703,
-0.0427577011,
-0.6039988995,
-0.4449594617,
-0.7313376069,
0.2724750936,
-0.5154880285,
0.8172618151,
0.2425238043,
0.2687798142,
-0.3365526497,
-0.1070619896,
-0.6163996458,
-0.5776882172,
-0.8010154963,
-0.7451127768,
0.0458929092,
0.4092818797,
0.5487598777,
0.1309633851,
0.5469748378,
0.2672923505,
0.0567102395,
0.2205551267,
-0.3432855606,
-0.0628964826,
0.0656695589,
-0.6271874905,
-0.3906040788,
0.3197530508,
0.1820298135,
0.6078643799,
-0.1234461889,
0.4321116209,
0.0785739422,
0.5133843422,
-0.4543358088,
0.3742914498,
-0.3205170929,
0.337190032,
-0.093668133,
0.2050801516,
-0.3314371407,
-0.277712971,
0.4275971353,
-0.4549124837,
0.4843724966,
0.3509941399,
0.6921259761,
0.2736977637,
-0.3634230793,
-0.2589997649,
-1.0108401775,
0.8163505197,
-0.7168267965,
0.4413331151,
0.5053215623,
0.4496696293,
-0.2611852288,
-0.5762099624,
-0.1599289775,
-0.602920413,
-0.0396119691,
0.4257894754,
-0.3194578886,
-0.0235848073,
0.5031839609,
0.1868140548,
-0.8060240746,
0.0748469308,
-0.494140625,
0.1156725138,
0.8529366255,
-0.2298795432,
0.5637538433,
-0.1731206626,
-0.3288119435,
-0.0599294566,
-0.7565072179,
-0.0384075567,
0.3702835739,
0.1625499576,
-0.3742760122,
0.4991222024,
-0.1755685359,
0.3500363827,
0.1651345044,
0.039317593,
0.1854822189,
0.2162604034,
-0.1922467649,
0.3225578964,
0.9632703066,
0.3268010616,
0.4247278273,
-0.4846174717,
0.135774985,
-0.0569768474,
-0.1321887225,
-0.8287954926,
-0.498451829,
0.323451519,
-0.4772863984,
0.1503047347,
0.3570958972,
-0.7678917646,
-0.5904729366,
-0.196128726,
0.3303568959,
-0.3749767244,
-0.2094586492,
-0.2049281001,
-0.7144757509,
0.3784425259,
0.4913924634,
-0.6473009586,
0.3244283795,
0.7016911507,
0.9577118754,
0.0186551251,
-0.0842478648,
-0.4831659198,
-0.3932884634,
-0.3312096894,
0.7383551002,
-0.5166191459,
-0.356479764,
-0.4626982808,
-0.346215874,
-0.234300822,
-0.6425783038,
0.1909824759,
-0.1548881382,
0.3275116682,
-0.2139749378,
-0.5764513612,
-0.0919364542,
0.0548076257,
-0.6032725573,
0.9671292305,
-0.0952827558,
-0.9182399511,
0.7036367059,
-0.6013869643,
-0.146342501,
0.0481656902,
-0.3502259552,
-0.5310434103,
-0.0711029768,
0.4301017523,
0.2656678855,
-0.608211875,
0.2830789089,
-0.4035302401,
-0.4486891031,
0.3555292189,
-0.5984330177,
0.6139811277,
0.0505393669,
-0.6444813013,
-0.1894318163,
-0.6239824891,
-0.2325729579,
0.1111802757,
0.1551322043,
0.1427001804,
0.1717254519,
-0.1582179815,
0.081159912,
-0.1915022582,
-0.5965919495,
-0.0947198048,
-0.3290970325,
0.5706713796,
0.4734763205,
-0.2576980889,
0.3975260258,
-0.2341865897,
0.9050174952,
-0.2181816995,
0.1035011038,
0.1970119625,
-0.8681806922,
-0.3390375972,
-0.4212203026,
0.7144086957,
0.7994051576,
-0.6136354804,
0.1565240771,
-0.2420550883,
-0.7858375907,
-0.3300534487,
-0.0900425836,
0.3527536392,
0.4527794123,
-0.0809385628,
-0.3251950145,
-0.6425276399,
-0.8096091151,
-0.5482796431,
-0.4134227931,
-0.2597797513,
0.4656257331,
0.6543451548,
0.2759168148,
1.053190589,
-0.261493355,
0.024202276,
-0.4644500315,
0.5999914408,
0.1757302284,
0.4756418467,
0.5437953472,
-0.8765172958,
-0.3215467334,
0.0389429964,
-0.8452196717,
-0.2231164128,
-0.109295249,
0.0291598812,
-0.1881997883,
0.2800990939,
-0.2814830244,
0.627098918,
0.7326181531,
-0.3912896514,
0.6760104895,
-0.3811335564,
0.2361700237,
-0.5576623678,
0.4506559372,
0.1031394452,
-0.3778526485,
-0.6899188161,
-0.3429329097,
-0.0447804481,
-0.1769288331,
-0.3647125065,
0.7684184313,
-0.2801446319,
-0.2985413074,
-0.1436481625,
0.0677957982,
-0.1774564236,
0.1404276788,
0.1678096056,
1.0655801296,
0.1506350189,
-0.3716677725,
0.1832193583,
0.4816784263,
-0.4070803225,
0.512370944,
-0.9030094147,
0.331543088,
-0.3401612341,
0.3147703409,
-0.9399847388,
-0.3009369969,
0.5638151169,
-0.7497673631,
0.1002280936,
-0.461971283,
-0.3083652854,
-0.5711593032,
-0.1629299074,
0.3436173499,
0.6524812579,
-0.5553424358,
0.5129222274,
0.2241774052,
-0.1335843652,
-0.7052518725,
-0.8449786305,
0.1755481362,
-0.4267009199,
-0.3232181668,
-0.1847257465,
-0.1610368192,
-0.169613108,
-0.2861721814,
-0.1286497265,
-0.3463681936,
0.2436612695,
0.5442875028,
0.3200188875,
-0.1882809699,
0.1983897686,
-0.1991930604,
-0.1638545841,
-0.1259642839,
0.0419626907,
0.5394220352,
-0.3391675353,
-0.5299621224,
-0.5360227823,
0.2064710557,
0.4019269943,
-0.3042930663,
0.8693982959,
0.7449247241,
-0.0234834459,
-0.1388118863,
-0.5023152828,
-0.1521681249,
-0.3819928169,
0.1806107759,
-0.1018722951,
-0.5622192025,
0.5035142303,
-0.0595563725,
0.13575463,
0.4511546493,
0.2321647853,
-0.1732300222,
1.3206300735,
0.1629322171,
-0.1168228537,
0.4044997692,
-0.2732509673,
0.2787525356,
-0.7346504331,
-0.1039820313,
-0.636138916,
-0.4937596023,
-0.8766117096,
-0.1635778993,
0.351164341,
-0.1486136317,
-0.6459528804,
0.1751164943,
-0.437117666,
0.2219915092,
0.9748800993,
0.1109933779,
0.2843625546,
-0.0388663672,
0.3126554787,
-0.0774761438,
-1.1981829405,
-0.4877703488,
1.079620719,
0.0486630462,
0.7685874104,
-0.0464960858,
0.6124081016,
0.4442433715,
0.5065041184,
-0.5685283542,
0.3128632903,
-0.459623456,
-0.7260012627,
-0.0639091507,
-0.5317566991,
-1.2490766048,
0.3525354266,
-0.2795068324,
-0.8377581835,
0.2555738389,
0.2295031399,
-0.3210741282,
0.1373120993,
-0.8556928039,
0.6232571006,
-0.1736154854,
-0.1136021689,
0.2879178226,
-0.4760613143,
0.4405497909,
0.0530486628,
0.3283303082,
-0.4753673971,
0.1671122015,
0.8616678715,
-0.2611900568,
1.0035974979,
-0.0964739025,
0.3739553392,
0.1733582318,
-0.092038855,
0.1238114014,
0.0390210263,
-0.2569778264,
0.4614215493,
0.1479653418,
-0.3984645903,
-0.4839201868,
0.371473968,
-0.9695674777,
-0.5474783778,
-0.4681794047,
-0.4224542379,
-0.1590907574,
0.0370855927,
0.4468806684,
0.5723171234,
-0.3161198795,
0.1932646483,
0.3033414483,
-0.3263793886,
0.2331628352,
0.0531854071,
0.0034785881,
-0.4390487671,
0.5663248301,
0.2341700643,
0.0528106689,
0.0479769297,
0.430568397,
-0.3164040446,
-0.1508894563,
-0.5757879615,
0.2821401954,
-0.4246509969,
0.0303725656,
-0.3525954783,
-0.2366555333,
-0.30528,
0.0984296799,
-0.3813720047,
-0.4567480683,
0.1799890995,
0.1097626835,
0.2213775367,
0.6240726113,
0.0163573436,
0.3809461594,
-0.6124497056,
0.3601170778,
0.2881762087,
0.1014636606,
-0.0466947369,
-0.2458968163,
0.1923761219,
0.1417442858,
-0.0369590037,
-0.752350688,
0.4373298585,
0.3681294918,
0.5931839347,
0.3755726516,
0.1571705639,
0.6442370415,
-0.4340066314,
1.0545868874,
0.1730892062,
-0.8122708797,
0.4619753957,
-0.1932064146,
0.4405447245,
0.447196275,
0.1116559654,
-0.9102714658,
-0.4317285419,
-0.9295882583,
-0.6962381005,
0.7518119216,
0.6880981326,
-0.1379280537,
0.0657073185,
0.3697958887,
0.4950630963,
0.5625050068,
-0.4651364386,
-0.2990047038,
0.0937227234,
-0.2294920534,
-0.14024508,
0.119915463,
0.1063845977,
0.010259917,
0.7533916831,
0.0173700564,
0.4678135514,
0.4427299798,
-0.0771150365,
0.2140234411,
0.0806055143,
0.1886614412,
0.7986726165,
-0.1315359324,
0.05015276,
0.3088075519,
-0.4380696416,
0.0386721268,
0.1286017299,
-0.2880110741,
0.1359339654,
0.6742188334,
0.8203471899,
0.0637375042,
-0.9619866014,
0.3145586252,
-0.4621872902,
-0.2074043304,
-0.2728665173,
0.1790707856,
-0.0853392184,
0.5215783715,
0.0344882682,
0.1958457977,
0.3052312434,
-0.5276429057,
-0.0586604737,
0.5043796301,
-0.3256896734,
-0.2491433918,
1.0225051641,
0.2383663505,
-0.346939832,
0.8198669553,
-0.0944035128,
-0.5505520701,
0.9676498771,
0.2325044721,
0.8047063351,
-0.2831544876,
0.4892804325,
0.4534201324,
0.2258659154,
-0.3740997314,
0.1258090734,
-0.0905585513,
-0.5452648401,
-0.2979113162,
-0.185794279,
-0.5578092933,
-0.0327879898,
-0.3547912836,
0.0101200612,
-0.335398972,
-0.4536361694,
-0.0832215846,
0.0789980814,
-1.0932437181,
0.1014970914,
0.5957689881,
0.7334489226,
-0.9036104679,
0.1854153574,
0.6961689591,
-0.3041452765,
-0.5702621937,
-0.0223272834,
0.1357191056,
-0.6923757195,
0.8039911985,
0.2868959308,
-0.0317083932,
-0.1804775894,
-0.366499275,
-0.7372496724,
1.2194573879,
0.6362882853,
-0.4088826776,
0.0661600977,
0.5059093237,
0.3058469594,
-0.0304837991,
0.7726734877,
0.5877120495,
0.550934732,
0.3200717568,
-1.2195363045,
-0.3524844348,
-0.1162182912,
-0.0202836934,
-0.0841131806,
-0.7074751258,
0.6144638658,
-0.0778776035,
-0.1901489794,
0.233288601,
0.5518782139,
0.4717963338,
0.67533952,
0.5524274707,
0.1541577578,
1.123262167,
-0.1005745903,
1.0814152956,
-0.0946215615,
0.3740308285,
1.199277997,
-0.1073109433,
0.6328729391,
0.0486239456,
-0.4406532049,
0.240722537,
0.5777727365,
-0.1489574164,
0.1371343583,
-0.031312976,
-0.0650102869,
-0.298951894,
0.1585435569,
-0.2807583809,
0.7062107325,
0.1319257021,
-0.2745464444,
-0.3823900223,
0.0965023786,
0.0892433673,
-0.3641431034,
-0.1002276763,
0.6596477032,
0.2803518772,
-0.7655836344,
0.2647386193,
-0.1659486294,
0.355047673,
-0.5196743011,
-0.0627071336,
-0.2622503638,
0.22831662,
-0.0713106766,
-0.5070486665,
-0.1201532185,
0.2382783294,
0.1627431065,
0.0597314835,
0.9509087205,
-0.3716033995,
-0.7141404152,
-0.0742797777,
0.8257442713,
0.3185169995,
-0.2535054684,
-0.8003822565,
-0.4123495519,
-0.1819957346,
-0.1892861873,
0.1733133048,
0.2083229721,
-0.1007876992,
0.9486554861,
0.548327744,
0.214521423,
0.1188208163,
0.0053276271,
0.0813489109,
-0.3191409409,
-0.4957906604,
-0.9862179756,
0.2963761687,
-0.4244311154,
-0.1655271202,
0.7913053632,
0.5915995836,
0.4460751414,
-0.1281787306,
0.9680035114,
-0.0932712629,
0.195870921,
-0.2521591187,
0.730144918,
-0.3532855213,
-0.0371438488,
-0.0350479335,
-0.6911799908,
-0.4189437628,
0.5560737252,
-0.6613417268,
0.2419995219,
0.2237025201,
0.4044949412,
-0.0899350122,
0.1462421417,
0.2973433137,
0.0792826638,
0.5737745166,
0.2286717445,
0.8073580861,
-0.3715474308,
0.3755522668,
-0.149974227,
-0.3676545024,
-0.3790614009,
-0.8619969487,
-1.1137450933,
-0.3142069876,
-0.4516556859,
-0.0204037186,
0.3582300246,
1.1989371777,
1.0028501749,
-0.6347583532,
-0.2252014875,
-0.011753127,
-0.0133076468,
-0.5359652638,
-0.1033933759,
0.46723786,
-0.2317169905,
-1.0484137535,
0.0640752465,
0.0275364872,
-0.2825350165,
0.1973979175,
0.0279713534,
0.1734200269,
0.1411522031,
0.5700563192,
0.3742360175,
-0.7146435976,
-0.312341243,
-0.1993799061,
0.3493919671,
0.2323788553,
0.5183635354,
-0.8389496803,
0.4789964259,
0.4482379854,
0.2891522348,
0.4734608829,
0.2125115544,
0.8378590345,
-0.6144388914,
0.0586873405,
0.1123073474,
0.3519640565,
0.3561058342,
-0.2195470035,
0.6901810765,
0.2445699871,
-0.6172617078,
-0.44343853,
-0.0790599138,
-0.7143956423,
-0.2832412422,
1.0548251867,
-0.0565857664,
-0.3642774522,
-0.1682680696,
-0.5396156907,
0.4157639742,
-0.5615594983,
0.8405184746,
0.7309933901,
-0.5133653283,
-0.0249607451,
-1.1066507101,
0.2945859134,
0.2491178662,
-0.725723803,
0.2239439785,
0.1182104722,
0.297024101,
-0.2257768363,
0.4322371483,
0.1264116019,
0.3561325371,
0.0222862586,
0.00650409,
-0.0018784705,
0.0379042551,
-0.0845674202,
0.104952991,
0.0920415372,
-0.2200789899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14838v1
|
OpusCleaner and OpusTrainer, open source toolkits for training Machine Translation and Large language models
| 2023-11-24T20:24:00 | 2023-11-24T20:24:00 |
Nikolay Bogoychev, Jelmer van der Linde, Graeme Nail, Barry Haddow, Jaume Zaragoza-Bernabeu, Gema Ramírez-Sánchez, Lukas Weymann, Tudor Nicolae Mateiu, Jindřich Helcl, Mikko Aulamo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Developing high quality machine translation systems is a labour intensive,
challenging and confusing process for newcomers to the field. We present a pair
of tools OpusCleaner and OpusTrainer that aim to simplify the process, reduce
the amount of work and lower the entry barrier for newcomers.
OpusCleaner is a data downloading, cleaning, and proprocessing toolkit. It is
designed to allow researchers to quickly download, visualise and preprocess
bilingual (or monolingual) data that comes from many different sources, each of
them with different quality, issues, and unique filtering/preprocessing
requirements.
OpusTrainer is a data scheduling and data augmenting tool aimed at building
large scale, robust machine translation systems and large language models. It
features deterministic data mixing from many different sources, on-the-fly data
augmentation and more.
Using these tools, we showcase how we can use it to create high quality
machine translation model robust to noisy user input; multilingual models and
terminology aware models.
|
[
-0.185585767,
-0.3891674578,
0.1028382182,
0.4098351598,
-0.1736990064,
0.1028174236,
-0.2313248813,
-0.1382241398,
-0.0405537263,
0.7670557499,
-0.5229326487,
-0.35071522,
-0.466923058,
0.1240582764,
-0.3425401449,
0.8074242473,
-0.3233834505,
0.4883289039,
-0.0084805042,
-0.3161801398,
-0.461419791,
-0.492819041,
-0.6739045978,
-0.5113762021,
0.5360067487,
0.4431924224,
0.6486176848,
0.7029243708,
0.7097671032,
0.3306202292,
-0.0419501178,
0.011064562,
-0.6281002164,
0.4828899503,
-0.1597063094,
-0.6523010135,
-0.3665890992,
-0.329598099,
0.4056004286,
0.6825212836,
-0.0448838249,
0.266633153,
-0.0039144601,
0.8131010532,
-0.4282546639,
0.0493217669,
-0.4410479069,
0.3368093371,
-0.3345820606,
-0.3331415355,
-0.3876170814,
-0.5737206936,
-0.1738033444,
-0.7840097547,
-0.024629334,
-0.0010355837,
0.5294622183,
0.3742371798,
-0.3577736616,
-0.1945787519,
-0.9145757556,
0.8171907067,
-0.4523733556,
0.7261715531,
0.196158722,
0.5080603361,
0.1965278983,
-0.5349824429,
-0.2289594263,
0.0323852748,
-0.0695564821,
0.0394091941,
-0.1735820174,
-0.1617284268,
0.1857091337,
0.8076438308,
-0.9230428934,
0.188760668,
-0.6310443878,
-0.2470916659,
0.3441317976,
0.1860821545,
0.4197415411,
0.3097802699,
-0.3074169457,
-0.2937522233,
-0.9545844197,
-0.1052953154,
0.6505596042,
0.2124974728,
0.0550085157,
0.6713038087,
-0.2117834687,
0.4818783104,
-0.0342042185,
-0.1654731631,
0.5281909704,
-0.2263441086,
-0.1519634277,
0.2593787014,
0.8919160366,
0.2108034492,
0.0560122356,
-0.3385994136,
-0.4155434668,
-0.0935215801,
0.0082900254,
-1.0996171236,
-0.3312872946,
0.373708725,
-0.4246191084,
-0.1613140851,
-0.1273637563,
-0.5292741656,
-0.0959532261,
-0.7987222672,
0.4114319682,
-0.56865412,
-0.414640367,
0.2033596784,
-0.2396584749,
0.1359485984,
0.3582341373,
-0.7364537716,
0.1607137322,
0.6669957638,
0.8806517124,
-0.5319094658,
-0.2770417333,
-0.706839025,
0.1029286608,
-0.2447496504,
0.4755086601,
-0.195777446,
-0.4113901854,
0.0160820298,
0.4077185094,
0.0586161874,
-0.6509589553,
0.715795517,
-0.6904046535,
0.3486990035,
-0.0068550082,
-0.5099216104,
-0.2406525612,
0.2391244173,
-0.8972568512,
1.1623909473,
0.2357005477,
-0.9018930197,
0.4022834897,
-0.7466141582,
-0.3451010883,
0.335393399,
0.1574895382,
-0.1914434284,
0.0546831787,
0.2161318362,
0.2774723172,
-0.3521113992,
0.1618341655,
0.1156653166,
-0.0676985458,
0.0726858079,
-0.5982159972,
0.9841619134,
0.4552468657,
-0.0153252566,
0.3609514236,
-0.6884903312,
-0.0138358241,
-0.0998045132,
-0.7814608812,
-0.205515787,
-0.0987160429,
0.5615808964,
0.2878153324,
0.4070118368,
-0.5514751077,
0.3308169246,
-0.4096458554,
0.40325436,
0.4487802386,
-0.2772757113,
0.3657527864,
-0.1208866686,
0.7053014636,
0.1524038911,
-0.0818192288,
-0.3061515689,
-0.0870327652,
-0.8407173157,
-0.1476384103,
0.4068180621,
1.0844057798,
-1.1680202484,
0.4262485206,
-0.5782213211,
-0.8213863969,
-0.8383673429,
0.555663228,
0.3780164719,
-0.0439845249,
0.3590827584,
-0.4534602761,
-0.4609639347,
-0.6660824418,
-0.2012392581,
0.0316987298,
-0.3116233647,
-0.2063338757,
0.3930362761,
-0.1419145018,
0.6922973394,
-0.284660995,
-0.2685984373,
-0.5572946668,
0.2701357603,
0.2791153193,
0.7998564243,
0.4375838339,
-0.8738345504,
-0.5629663467,
0.3386233151,
-0.6899970174,
-0.027393274,
0.150702849,
-0.0763955563,
-0.0969811827,
0.6206205487,
-0.3137222528,
-0.1488990933,
0.6105327606,
-0.0089733265,
0.5639004707,
-0.2447619885,
0.2564570308,
-1.1577904224,
0.2239689827,
-0.5963729024,
-0.4144624472,
-0.7771808505,
0.1251881123,
0.0153142326,
-0.2481944114,
-0.9287645817,
0.3602366447,
-0.5381946564,
0.1604109854,
-0.1282491088,
-0.3765188754,
-0.0254891347,
0.2694956958,
0.1471305937,
1.1885751486,
0.7199087739,
-0.4350715876,
0.4650027156,
0.3961333632,
-0.5072020292,
0.3579129577,
-0.8493804336,
0.0189954694,
0.0547975637,
-0.2770775259,
-0.5122564435,
-0.4276772439,
0.3489542902,
-0.465836376,
0.2430931777,
-0.3208449781,
-0.6420035958,
-0.3145700991,
-0.0733953714,
0.5237329602,
0.4785059094,
-0.6315177083,
0.3481782675,
0.2670437396,
-0.4396068752,
-0.3703235388,
-0.9410516024,
-0.0027316944,
-0.3562256396,
-0.5359666944,
-0.0086278534,
-0.3007676899,
-0.1252991408,
-0.0019302912,
0.2518379092,
-0.653434813,
-0.0341676883,
0.2587336302,
0.1032741591,
-0.4472043216,
0.1844399571,
0.1368053406,
-0.3914174736,
-0.0274751876,
-0.5058195591,
0.4478711486,
-0.011847008,
-0.547771275,
-0.4742058516,
0.3354797363,
0.9011271,
-0.6480471492,
0.8174203038,
0.6979774237,
-0.0495672002,
0.0295361746,
-0.5186684132,
-0.0672248676,
-0.4727332592,
0.1304123402,
-0.2853321135,
-1.0268998146,
0.2321716845,
-0.1817881614,
0.2287897617,
0.1612938941,
0.8653835058,
0.5222315192,
0.9314495325,
0.5938853621,
-0.1295410693,
0.4442760348,
-0.1860204637,
0.1909871101,
-0.6425827146,
0.0929693058,
-0.4978108704,
-0.0911377817,
-0.1790633351,
-0.4536018968,
0.2969073057,
0.1486296803,
0.1184113547,
0.6115105748,
-0.650046587,
0.7017481327,
0.6718720794,
-0.3029671609,
0.428878963,
0.0172525216,
-0.1014155298,
-0.113536194,
-0.6407148838,
-0.624697268,
1.2350350618,
0.1292235553,
0.6680402756,
0.0638894364,
0.487228483,
-0.0431735292,
0.2616116107,
-0.9545057416,
0.1827269793,
0.037525095,
-0.7624137402,
-0.2158764899,
-0.5780838132,
-0.8829501271,
0.4204932153,
-0.1496220827,
-0.3527799845,
0.2944507599,
0.2736855149,
-0.1366140693,
0.5643325448,
-0.4949295819,
1.0822148323,
-0.3459326327,
-0.4956148863,
0.2215898633,
-0.5087008476,
0.279447943,
-0.1514050066,
0.274602145,
-0.1056601107,
0.2823827863,
0.5117575526,
-0.551990509,
0.435793817,
-0.0894747376,
-0.1181170791,
0.1986650676,
0.4070844948,
0.3090291917,
-0.1305702627,
-0.2668133974,
0.2158572078,
0.008906587,
-0.1318960935,
-0.2493772209,
0.4312283099,
-0.6518939137,
-0.1158524677,
-0.0466736294,
-0.6954755187,
0.2800374031,
0.5190532207,
0.4582435489,
0.4091151655,
-0.4574513733,
0.4817503095,
0.7520642877,
-0.0991910994,
0.1345469207,
0.5981420875,
-0.3327250481,
-0.5557101369,
1.1195693016,
-0.0779033825,
0.3552596569,
0.5484268665,
-0.1889106184,
0.1649576873,
-0.6585515738,
-0.6995308399,
0.0136663988,
-0.4616621137,
-0.0421184972,
-0.5858073235,
0.0283253081,
-0.2748901844,
-0.0584981777,
-0.5251634717,
-0.69775033,
-0.1207986847,
0.0829818025,
0.2785609365,
0.425519377,
-0.1938477904,
0.6183779836,
-1.0716559887,
0.1849510223,
0.121163711,
0.0282461159,
-0.5824328065,
-0.1145327911,
-0.4846870899,
-0.1023332551,
-0.4829534888,
-0.7656505704,
0.6575296521,
0.0374745429,
0.2924591899,
0.7275077701,
-0.0912197605,
0.1382065266,
-0.865044713,
0.7409738302,
0.1135368794,
-0.6719173789,
0.5460996628,
-0.3742064536,
0.1763999462,
0.8660428524,
0.4988070428,
-0.6161490083,
-0.3183274269,
0.0048388126,
-0.885574162,
0.7263484001,
0.3208855689,
-0.2150135338,
0.3900265694,
-0.1721290946,
0.4846002758,
0.3589456677,
-0.7100690007,
-0.1248494387,
-0.1860108227,
-0.1484144479,
-0.2911120653,
0.0476274788,
-0.099853918,
-0.220875904,
1.0092023611,
0.0244591217,
-0.1790238619,
0.0602085926,
-0.426627934,
-0.1510852277,
0.623604238,
0.1787099093,
0.5984030962,
-0.0720895231,
-0.1179008186,
-0.0289301164,
-0.2831393778,
0.5029326081,
0.0389506258,
-0.4076305032,
0.332962811,
0.1881934702,
0.8671617508,
0.1852038801,
-0.8502163887,
0.5068830252,
-0.0049249129,
-0.3301542699,
-0.4847897291,
0.0856939703,
0.3820541501,
-0.0674184933,
-0.1732692122,
0.1830262095,
0.3691906929,
-0.20672369,
-0.1359257698,
-0.0193843395,
-0.5097430944,
-0.4092820287,
0.7627549171,
0.2706837952,
-0.4892871678,
0.4833498597,
-0.3267025352,
-0.5799285769,
0.1702843457,
0.1578499079,
0.8241128922,
-0.5227954984,
0.0399798527,
0.390295893,
0.4777879715,
-0.3316071033,
0.138315767,
-0.0637418702,
-0.489684552,
-0.4574649632,
-0.5846825242,
-0.4065056741,
0.0170222688,
-0.9335596561,
0.246208474,
0.3392555416,
0.1376897693,
-0.164639011,
-0.4970689416,
-0.6620360017,
-0.2856964171,
-0.3485839665,
0.992877543,
-0.9343073964,
0.8567844629,
0.7863898277,
-0.4230314493,
-0.6330168247,
-0.454546839,
0.1624506414,
-0.5298432708,
0.8504105806,
0.2337055802,
-0.0558273047,
0.0268643051,
-0.0827601925,
-0.5100230575,
0.9051120877,
0.493907094,
-0.5734783411,
-0.1140525192,
0.4949503839,
0.3604228795,
0.0099862665,
-0.0046766307,
0.525888145,
0.6513229012,
0.0933990553,
-0.8814628124,
-0.4019194543,
-0.4867317677,
-0.2693847716,
0.5882974863,
-0.1468483955,
0.9968421459,
0.3629260063,
-0.1670913696,
0.2113904059,
0.3520805538,
-0.2537892759,
0.1020949855,
0.474506557,
0.655734539,
0.4979725778,
-0.2529031038,
0.7386738658,
-0.8203487992,
0.2756907642,
1.0818189383,
-0.1751350462,
0.8331865668,
0.5852528214,
-0.116481252,
0.1964259148,
0.4700244963,
0.0255286954,
0.2164947242,
0.1020093262,
-0.2585675716,
-0.4245246351,
0.0365589596,
-0.5592023134,
0.0782185644,
0.4218404889,
-0.178709805,
-0.2906445265,
0.3358373344,
0.033627525,
-0.2223314345,
-0.0340072624,
0.8300606608,
-0.1955683082,
-0.6021706462,
0.502730608,
-0.1194315255,
0.5339058638,
-0.6897204518,
0.1169318184,
-0.0795024633,
0.4143288136,
-0.0065257316,
-0.4781498611,
0.3264167309,
0.0436737798,
-0.1687448621,
-0.6316626072,
0.5117393136,
-0.7889928222,
-0.6690954566,
0.2016350776,
0.7714096904,
0.5145369172,
-0.2160348594,
-0.7302771211,
0.1611788422,
0.0456258543,
-0.3096539974,
-0.2000989765,
0.7008938789,
0.3198637366,
0.6449919343,
0.7829620242,
0.4021740258,
0.1591320336,
-0.1590664238,
0.7844002843,
-0.1434307843,
-0.4771266282,
-0.594262898,
0.5308682919,
0.0234393142,
-0.2645446956,
0.8415008783,
1.0731925964,
0.9286025167,
-0.3644402027,
0.6534050703,
0.2146037668,
0.7400305271,
-0.4708303511,
0.8372175694,
-0.7225824594,
0.1321745515,
0.0900942385,
-1.1097871065,
-0.2714354098,
0.1968816817,
-0.1471651196,
-0.4117425084,
0.4840950668,
0.9639931321,
-0.4714928567,
-0.2315805554,
0.1846369207,
0.2136819661,
0.3439347446,
0.5390610099,
0.8002840877,
-0.2720836997,
0.6530460119,
-0.1540948898,
-0.0760878697,
-0.3602249324,
-0.5973997712,
-0.7712333202,
-0.3033291698,
-0.1448708475,
0.1246721447,
0.0913341343,
1.0851581097,
0.7820733786,
-0.914187789,
-0.5683096647,
-0.2747251689,
-0.0232672431,
-0.1668042094,
-0.265093118,
0.0644703209,
-0.381839335,
-0.7468543649,
0.8173120618,
0.1827756315,
0.1289897263,
-0.3550481498,
-0.2035284191,
0.1358859241,
-0.1377545893,
0.3233531713,
0.3693720102,
-0.3690727949,
0.3138802946,
-0.1772031933,
-0.0298682936,
0.434060663,
0.9905453324,
-0.4881615937,
0.540268302,
0.6638258696,
0.6342204213,
0.3537345529,
-0.2232379764,
0.5686573982,
-0.4891894758,
0.4245350659,
0.132509321,
0.4314107001,
0.5373652577,
-0.1515869498,
0.621391654,
-0.0000365794,
-0.6584516168,
-0.9165657163,
0.2555907071,
-0.6875183582,
-0.1666048616,
0.7330031395,
-0.2599353492,
-0.0651759207,
-0.178302303,
-0.5631990433,
0.1221064404,
-0.2080995291,
0.1465687007,
0.7342771292,
0.2356737405,
0.2302116007,
-0.8741711378,
0.2660757005,
0.2966734767,
-0.9596407413,
0.1196961626,
0.4953790903,
0.2735928595,
0.3158765733,
0.246562168,
-0.0823656693,
0.2743659616,
-0.0340549201,
0.474878639,
-0.2946892381,
-0.3006768823,
-0.4026106894,
0.2449726313,
0.0191469938,
-0.0519579425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14836v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14836v3
|
Custom Data Augmentation for low resource ASR using Bark and Retrieval-Based Voice Conversion
| 2023-11-24T20:16:29 | 2024-01-09T21:37:45 |
Anand Kamble, Aniket Tathe, Suyash Kumbharkar, Atharva Bhandare, Anirban C. Mitra
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
This paper proposes two innovative methodologies to construct customized
Common Voice datasets for low-resource languages like Hindi. The first
methodology leverages Bark, a transformer-based text-to-audio model developed
by Suno, and incorporates Meta's enCodec and a pre-trained HuBert model to
enhance Bark's performance. The second methodology employs Retrieval-Based
Voice Conversion (RVC) and uses the Ozen toolkit for data preparation. Both
methodologies contribute to the advancement of ASR technology and offer
valuable insights into addressing the challenges of constructing customized
Common Voice datasets for under-resourced languages. Furthermore, they provide
a pathway to achieving high-quality, personalized voice generation for a range
of applications.
|
[
-0.5920946598,
-0.4278789163,
-0.0226195268,
0.1765179485,
-0.1457435787,
0.5233725905,
-0.2536074817,
-0.5515785813,
0.395314157,
0.5934203863,
-0.6635254622,
-0.3604097664,
-0.0577774122,
0.3021796048,
-0.2196451426,
0.7171808481,
0.4733034372,
0.086654529,
0.124981083,
-0.2609736621,
-0.56087327,
-0.4735203087,
-0.805079639,
-0.5669017434,
0.2144752145,
0.791493237,
0.6716700196,
0.4455194473,
0.3447209001,
0.2337440103,
-0.1671994478,
0.1177752763,
-0.1169347614,
-0.1849118471,
0.0088732373,
-0.2867195606,
-0.4607894123,
-0.2005808949,
0.4005167484,
0.642832756,
-0.633880496,
0.1704802215,
-0.1153346747,
0.5157225132,
-0.6619493961,
-0.1765749156,
-0.8178317547,
0.0107823666,
-0.3834021688,
-0.3580689728,
-0.4096755087,
-0.5552808046,
-0.0864024013,
-0.5293812156,
0.5990496874,
0.0482599512,
0.7309102416,
0.3890639842,
-0.2497395128,
-0.3762087226,
-1.2582788467,
0.9477766752,
-0.9436028004,
0.4788534045,
0.5823992491,
0.7449112535,
0.2052095234,
-0.5953400135,
-0.5788545609,
-0.2368500382,
-0.1435844898,
0.2128780335,
-0.1558384001,
0.0779002607,
0.0762724429,
0.8084343076,
-0.2599136531,
0.1148106605,
-0.5809574723,
-0.0053419136,
0.8262442946,
0.2425872982,
0.3628638983,
-0.4570527971,
0.1721842885,
-0.277228862,
-0.6211496592,
0.1159633696,
0.4870421588,
0.7248826623,
-0.0800792277,
0.8251981735,
-0.3295780122,
0.7827476859,
0.4425667822,
-0.1753944755,
0.3941578269,
-0.4943560958,
-0.3099676669,
0.8198702931,
0.6730648279,
-0.1602595747,
-0.039376229,
-0.1038560569,
-0.2331972271,
-0.1587003171,
0.2411927432,
-0.615653336,
0.0064622024,
-0.0595627129,
-0.4649551809,
-0.171647042,
-0.1888252348,
-0.5942852497,
-0.2491493225,
-0.4225195348,
0.2985558212,
-0.6157359481,
-0.3174089491,
-0.0031094381,
-0.0175272226,
0.4066335559,
0.3143568337,
-1.0347526073,
0.7719060183,
0.2429576367,
0.7042014599,
-0.0988079384,
0.2032342255,
-0.5092411637,
0.4407474697,
-0.4102286696,
0.7534433603,
-0.9644768238,
-0.7054991126,
-0.2551261783,
-0.2567572892,
0.129076615,
-1.0365265608,
0.7063063979,
-0.4261616468,
0.0394791476,
-0.1140536442,
-0.0652758554,
-0.1548709124,
-0.1499149799,
-0.7253507972,
1.2738271952,
0.324069798,
-0.4624148011,
0.2461789846,
-0.8307816386,
-0.7480095625,
0.1328081042,
-0.0453648493,
-0.08540719,
0.2548832297,
0.4607228041,
0.0731151775,
-0.7430095077,
0.1461968273,
0.2221308202,
-0.3774161339,
0.2079523057,
-0.3144147098,
0.505829215,
0.6590014696,
0.0042997068,
0.0219874531,
-1.2511687279,
0.47497648,
-0.1220497265,
-0.4891570807,
-0.2978838384,
-0.0256197806,
0.4239598513,
-0.0489808694,
0.0942520499,
-0.7531719208,
-0.1073769256,
-0.792145431,
0.2049296647,
0.1394011527,
-0.0025459824,
0.4259855747,
-0.1144228578,
0.4277456105,
-0.3288657069,
-0.0460240245,
0.0912694335,
-0.1059975177,
-0.5532566309,
-0.0753179267,
0.3466385007,
0.7304845452,
-0.655533731,
0.5037087798,
-0.2898195386,
-0.6236690283,
-1.1924394369,
0.1527286321,
0.2448355556,
0.3448787332,
0.663107872,
-0.5000438094,
-0.8369398713,
-0.8712316155,
-0.0976287946,
-0.0461317115,
-0.2470745593,
0.5898144841,
-0.2933529019,
-0.4808150828,
1.2366470098,
-0.5944206715,
-0.4344170094,
-0.6889288425,
0.2062915564,
0.3816870451,
0.6641955972,
0.3133565187,
-0.7886896133,
-0.8044842482,
0.4392545819,
-0.2405277938,
-0.4555581808,
0.090680927,
0.2361400723,
0.2128256559,
0.3582058549,
-0.2689669728,
0.3237013519,
0.4691271484,
0.1819392592,
0.2803268135,
-0.0780219883,
0.5498677492,
-1.2555152178,
0.1003645509,
-0.1765801907,
-0.0784714147,
-0.8399675488,
-0.4474325776,
-0.5514445305,
-0.4136571586,
-0.2936323583,
0.4497593939,
-0.3387720883,
-0.3168703318,
-0.5229157209,
-0.1552015543,
-0.330198288,
0.1275171191,
0.0744514167,
0.9322732091,
0.3593970835,
-0.43273592,
0.5252660513,
0.4666504264,
-0.058280278,
0.6208050251,
-0.8655007482,
0.3610800505,
0.0740046725,
0.00665629,
-0.6261126995,
-0.3639468551,
0.1603923738,
-0.5970543623,
0.3119193614,
-0.3469848931,
-0.7719393373,
-0.2201360613,
-0.0006723069,
0.4252532423,
0.7758699656,
-0.5290194154,
0.6736128926,
0.385289073,
-0.31393978,
-0.2151942551,
-0.8483244777,
0.1930644065,
-0.3016234338,
-0.5150632858,
0.4049552977,
0.0064098639,
-0.0710791498,
0.1011778265,
-0.1008213758,
-0.4138173163,
-0.5803661942,
0.1996405274,
0.0129184723,
-0.3769882023,
-0.0698011145,
0.1747465581,
-0.0955187902,
-0.48389557,
0.2223066241,
0.6170557737,
-0.0202007052,
-0.405181706,
-0.484010607,
0.5361757874,
0.2877390385,
-0.339620322,
0.5245491266,
0.7913951874,
-0.4104685485,
0.0456900746,
-0.8398675919,
-0.0674333721,
-0.5337847471,
0.0650594607,
-0.4721427858,
-0.5691830516,
0.4638701975,
-0.2470959574,
-0.4729193151,
0.3041860461,
0.3221735358,
0.118488878,
1.0243513584,
0.7136139274,
-0.1593190581,
0.5320609808,
-0.1972067803,
0.3677457571,
-1.0554623604,
-0.2254129052,
-0.5523117781,
0.0001515298,
-0.6270944476,
-0.4366797805,
0.2808772922,
0.1002209112,
-0.221279487,
0.5951217413,
-0.8457089067,
0.2963736355,
0.5875842571,
-0.0341947488,
0.5469084978,
0.1626935005,
0.35995996,
-0.2687789798,
-0.7444090247,
-0.4417211413,
0.7479626536,
-0.0107860984,
1.1999661922,
0.0833311826,
0.6055316925,
0.3215909004,
0.0475600921,
-0.8126378655,
0.4204475284,
-0.3771055043,
-0.6759406328,
-0.5445750952,
-0.3655728102,
-0.8145385385,
0.0885399505,
-0.1796950847,
-0.8198726177,
0.3824749589,
0.1339746118,
-0.2231063843,
0.0807646886,
-0.9240803719,
0.4202003181,
-0.1375997365,
-0.0911966115,
-0.5225579739,
-0.5517994761,
0.0759981275,
-0.1289027333,
-0.2544239163,
0.04766481,
0.1124862432,
0.7346547842,
-0.475063622,
0.7074051499,
-0.2170154154,
0.2870316505,
0.7944534421,
-0.3392831385,
0.4416078627,
0.0427192636,
-0.4446234703,
-0.1067353562,
0.0387469269,
-0.172582835,
-0.6497703195,
0.5339983106,
-0.834287405,
-0.3661836684,
-0.193111077,
-0.3944726586,
-0.5319381952,
0.1669136435,
0.3126468956,
0.379822582,
-0.3163869381,
0.2990201116,
0.2777941525,
-0.4279629886,
0.1908292174,
0.8084232807,
0.2478366792,
-0.6976929903,
0.9283166528,
0.1914049685,
0.1907434016,
0.2803502083,
0.2741853297,
-0.3216768205,
-0.5592078567,
-0.4302052259,
0.1811398268,
-0.5500972867,
-0.3531664014,
-0.4637508988,
-0.6476177573,
-0.4970982075,
-0.3089567125,
-0.8145465851,
-0.1301968992,
-0.1216602325,
0.0370982587,
0.6836425066,
0.8361783624,
-0.1914520711,
0.7740507126,
-0.942376852,
0.4692614079,
0.1528516859,
0.3307784796,
0.0927902311,
-0.4455128014,
-0.4108251929,
0.2536910772,
-0.1806880087,
-0.6811283231,
0.7229642868,
0.4329791665,
0.5079984665,
0.0394666158,
0.2219209671,
1.0439842939,
-0.6112260818,
0.4993221462,
0.2467312366,
-1.066642642,
0.9923440814,
-0.2007410228,
0.1073048189,
0.7169111967,
0.0748909637,
-0.4818772674,
-0.156967774,
-0.4792387784,
-0.8575648665,
1.1150194407,
0.3327408433,
0.2319611311,
0.4853748679,
0.2291971743,
0.2807948887,
0.2338623703,
-0.4192639887,
-0.1883094907,
-0.3994101882,
-0.3097991645,
-0.2083492875,
-0.0251018256,
-0.0240282528,
-0.5226678848,
0.5547492504,
-0.1825127304,
0.1414500028,
0.1275742352,
0.1564203054,
-0.2737795711,
0.6819419861,
0.2003413588,
0.0763237625,
-0.4799204171,
-0.1218294874,
0.6437814832,
-0.5574414134,
0.3471001983,
0.109089531,
0.0244849846,
0.1016379446,
0.0897868127,
0.984568119,
0.1203962043,
-0.5297228694,
-0.0069685238,
0.1728814244,
0.3538291454,
-0.56223768,
0.1600666046,
-0.0045141587,
0.0744345412,
0.7059007287,
0.1755597144,
0.3727973998,
-0.5750716925,
0.0642363727,
0.2129674107,
-0.297811389,
-0.4412682056,
0.4678515792,
0.1788359135,
-0.3761885464,
0.3572560251,
-0.0681231245,
0.0497942865,
0.3661809564,
0.9307137132,
0.8211978078,
-0.705798924,
0.1901939958,
0.530239284,
0.2504353821,
-0.0011007024,
0.0555646829,
-0.3133717775,
-0.4090346694,
-0.497533977,
-0.6633847952,
-0.5826936364,
0.2604914606,
-0.919893086,
0.5794653893,
-0.2537792027,
-0.1256361455,
-0.1834444404,
0.0377789028,
-0.4488362968,
0.5452993512,
-0.0257251225,
0.6617809534,
-0.8473017812,
0.9300766587,
0.6350720525,
-0.3334739506,
-0.9213719964,
0.1400721371,
-0.2250222266,
-0.6109458804,
0.763378799,
-0.2270974666,
-0.5657339692,
0.1534879059,
-0.3596896529,
-1.2013219595,
1.0093533993,
0.3655402362,
-0.255327642,
0.0355034992,
0.376170814,
0.8717423677,
-0.3420147002,
0.1775341332,
0.5918282866,
0.4479233027,
0.6080908179,
-1.1521283388,
-0.0372874476,
-0.3363149762,
0.254935652,
-0.0498627387,
-0.5153502226,
0.4304945469,
-0.0483114272,
-0.5863195062,
0.0198710766,
0.467969358,
0.1072016582,
0.4431066513,
0.3936927319,
0.4914933741,
0.4448735118,
0.0558821671,
0.8509240746,
-0.0842049718,
-0.0282987393,
1.0400769711,
-0.4196037054,
0.9825308323,
0.3481563926,
-0.3209555745,
0.3767631948,
0.5041674376,
-0.0403239802,
0.8099759817,
0.1296619475,
-0.3448056877,
-0.061374642,
-0.4489140809,
-0.4295547903,
0.7197674513,
0.4395838678,
0.2366963476,
-0.0989984125,
0.1856001467,
-0.4611952603,
0.1652819216,
-0.2759571075,
1.0348324776,
0.0321026184,
-0.3101324737,
0.7491719127,
0.0062724431,
0.882655561,
-0.6814001203,
-0.0662030205,
-0.0071224137,
-0.0345155187,
-0.6308008432,
-0.6000533104,
0.8296949267,
0.2891097963,
-0.2666701376,
-0.0247562192,
0.7463310957,
-0.4299043715,
-0.5641915798,
0.2794968486,
0.4876909852,
0.0449414998,
0.1917242408,
-0.3805825412,
0.1252735257,
-0.1180415377,
0.2118155807,
0.0736871883,
0.3882640898,
0.0779696777,
0.7015284896,
0.6327359676,
0.4506299198,
0.1315145493,
0.2568504214,
0.7770974636,
-0.7467997074,
-0.3726424277,
-0.4121837616,
0.2650685608,
-0.093295224,
0.0879246593,
0.8014547825,
0.8733112216,
0.7390199304,
-0.2835327387,
0.9470332861,
-0.3010433018,
0.8563643098,
-0.4377866685,
0.6970878243,
-0.5619288087,
0.3669215441,
-0.4284659922,
-0.7775533795,
-0.0298432689,
0.5265262723,
-0.2352410257,
0.1493671685,
0.4051891863,
1.0322822332,
-0.2657984793,
-0.1707401127,
0.3016146719,
-0.2497872412,
0.2179950923,
0.3164083362,
0.8129151464,
-0.5090937018,
0.7914997339,
-0.2186689675,
0.0474441797,
-0.2659215331,
-0.2838087082,
-0.6220064163,
-0.8016385436,
-0.3165792823,
-0.1481655985,
-0.0173936896,
0.9585365653,
0.8518176675,
-1.0265694857,
-0.4876787663,
-0.0698082522,
-0.1798435152,
0.0076809633,
-0.3006608784,
0.1708830446,
-0.1467068642,
-1.016738534,
0.6712096334,
0.1822010279,
0.3018724918,
0.1816415936,
-0.2708869576,
0.0829094425,
0.3029645979,
0.4331228435,
0.5255978107,
-0.8003077507,
-0.1659298092,
-0.0271200854,
-0.1330773234,
0.5467451811,
0.997000277,
-1.0094587803,
0.4615915418,
0.3496930301,
0.5173600316,
0.6212176085,
0.3808927834,
0.5983691812,
-1.0482648611,
0.3229487538,
0.3704739511,
-0.1108601615,
0.7681592107,
-0.4439373612,
0.6070303917,
-0.0520143919,
-0.2085448056,
-1.0748978853,
0.2542977929,
-1.2162464857,
0.2115314156,
1.0008394718,
0.4925066233,
0.0441710912,
-0.1456514299,
-0.678956151,
0.4590312839,
-0.6350693703,
0.5220125318,
0.2973334193,
-0.5255482197,
-0.2984157801,
-0.4733122885,
0.6318748593,
0.1429740489,
-0.8140150309,
0.0171269812,
0.1705732197,
0.0209007785,
0.389526099,
0.793012023,
-0.0747820437,
0.0697035491,
0.1863858104,
0.227017954,
-0.0251680724,
0.0670145899,
-0.2873789668,
-0.1792227775,
0.2697553337,
-0.2095164657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14835v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14835v2
|
Weak Alignment Supervision from Hybrid Model Improves End-to-end ASR
| 2023-11-24T20:14:28 | 2023-11-30T20:18:56 |
Jintao Jiang, Yingbo Gao, Zoltan Tuske
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
In this paper, we aim to create weak alignment supervision from an existing
hybrid system to aid the end-to-end modeling of automatic speech recognition.
Towards this end, we use the existing hybrid ASR system to produce triphone
alignments of the training audios. We then create a cross-entropy loss at a
certain layer of the encoder using the derived alignments. In contrast to the
general one-hot cross-entropy losses, here we use a cross-entropy loss with a
label smoothing parameter to regularize the supervision. As a comparison, we
also conduct the experiments with one-hot cross-entropy losses and CTC losses
with loss weighting. The results show that placing the weak alignment
supervision with the label smoothing parameter of 0.5 at the third encoder
layer outperforms the other two approaches and leads to about 5\% relative WER
reduction on the TED-LIUM 2 dataset over the baseline. We see similar
improvements when applying the method out-of-the-box on a Tagalog end-to-end
ASR system.
|
[
-0.1819409579,
-0.3064633608,
-0.0574558116,
-0.1026715785,
-0.4131642282,
0.0919145048,
-0.3375939727,
-0.3583806157,
0.237288788,
0.4491226971,
-0.2307384163,
-0.3618237376,
-0.4603666663,
-0.0674562082,
-0.4830990136,
1.0466035604,
-0.1635599732,
0.2290039808,
-0.0856718421,
-0.0649548173,
-0.2312444597,
-0.3451454639,
-0.8055531979,
-0.7197428346,
0.2710887492,
0.2597890496,
0.7795270085,
0.7551532388,
0.6192756891,
0.2429524064,
-0.428806603,
0.0466497205,
-0.2715440691,
-0.2051783502,
-0.148437947,
-0.3721555471,
-0.596960783,
-0.1824101657,
0.8233959079,
0.7366221547,
-0.418387711,
0.1192985103,
0.3359550834,
0.4140517414,
-0.6463584304,
-0.3347400725,
-0.4542596936,
0.0328009278,
-0.3141536415,
-0.3433943689,
-0.3578697145,
-0.0050695799,
0.1869564503,
-0.6368829012,
0.317445606,
-0.0273060612,
1.0352517366,
0.6243837476,
-0.4643008411,
0.0501316786,
-1.2804523706,
0.7618677616,
-0.7356649041,
0.7748826146,
0.3972375691,
0.2613220513,
0.0278792698,
-0.3095551431,
-0.5513040423,
0.2188486159,
0.0218978636,
0.4996247888,
-0.0435523652,
0.1790638566,
0.0615499355,
0.5240917206,
-0.4547279179,
0.3424806297,
-0.5691717863,
-0.6851596832,
0.6719470024,
-0.0690887794,
0.0161725972,
0.2677090466,
-0.5048602223,
-0.2707934082,
-0.519451201,
-0.0322360843,
0.487202704,
0.344492197,
-0.3793428242,
0.4832670391,
0.2951467633,
0.7150930166,
0.2900767326,
-0.2696368694,
0.4695484042,
-0.5419973731,
-0.223873347,
0.6134380698,
0.9319987297,
0.4082611203,
0.1706340462,
-0.2998688817,
-0.2388024926,
0.3063185811,
-0.0043753148,
-0.2221470773,
-0.1048272401,
-0.086398676,
-0.4417309165,
0.2290395051,
0.2418475747,
-0.2511686385,
-0.0705489442,
-0.6961733699,
0.5247904062,
-0.4486424923,
-0.0999221429,
0.1763464957,
-0.2120291889,
0.723944068,
0.2302542627,
-0.5964922309,
0.7101124525,
0.4102226496,
0.9101728797,
-0.3270770609,
-0.0137257818,
-0.4535445571,
0.5968136787,
-0.3783991039,
0.5963489413,
-0.1626786143,
-0.3944481015,
-0.4129480422,
-0.1803289056,
-0.2619550824,
-0.8010406494,
0.6965016723,
-0.098743327,
0.3115223646,
0.1608647853,
-0.4318774045,
-0.0798501223,
-0.127463147,
-0.2392860502,
1.1100450754,
-0.2351677716,
-0.6792938709,
0.3856197298,
-0.2190565616,
-0.7545055747,
-0.238500312,
-0.0235273931,
-0.89312011,
-0.0445812456,
0.2226958424,
0.1932813227,
-0.3264384866,
0.2470243126,
-0.1873503327,
-0.482924968,
0.1275715232,
-0.1691065133,
0.8846713305,
0.1054799557,
-0.4045772254,
0.2454001456,
-0.8991026878,
-0.1099872217,
-0.1337803006,
-0.4283893406,
-0.7234446406,
-0.0098203002,
0.2415792793,
0.105698891,
0.0084600206,
-0.6982226968,
0.008384889,
-0.6068873405,
0.1766126305,
0.5337020755,
-0.0200548582,
0.5845555663,
-0.2837023139,
0.2549432218,
0.0688731968,
0.0746981055,
0.3039965332,
-0.4108449519,
-1.0027644634,
-0.2431071103,
0.6104614139,
0.8633138537,
-0.5735037327,
0.9375557303,
-0.0853316039,
-0.3159651756,
-0.9391930103,
0.3654015064,
0.8178769946,
0.5867466927,
0.5607075691,
-0.6603210568,
-0.9302336574,
-0.9373856187,
-0.0815593973,
-0.12171413,
-0.3366889358,
0.1661042869,
0.1463695467,
-0.3007844388,
0.7130048275,
-0.1118242368,
-0.5522927642,
-0.1420034319,
0.04081719,
0.1085834131,
0.9225802422,
0.2049119174,
-0.5034264922,
-0.5209252238,
0.1863405257,
-0.6307644248,
-0.0128770722,
-0.083920747,
-0.2636213899,
0.0206352789,
0.4257242978,
-0.4882725775,
0.4822468758,
0.2422130406,
-0.2028212696,
0.1931227744,
-0.0577884018,
-0.2633679807,
-1.317573905,
-0.0376929566,
0.2625230253,
-0.2279597074,
-0.8684794307,
-0.3678944409,
-0.0335452929,
0.0094039366,
-0.2437313944,
0.1055394486,
-0.4771481156,
-0.3161228299,
-0.0900092945,
-0.1864126027,
-0.0667152479,
0.3065049052,
0.2577227354,
0.6350863576,
0.8206201792,
-0.4973641634,
0.2780346274,
0.2982592583,
0.0739317238,
0.3311413825,
-0.810141921,
0.329172641,
-0.0074975016,
0.4919137061,
-0.8372810483,
0.0125070484,
0.3315103352,
-0.4541443884,
0.8324458599,
-0.0334704481,
-0.4430401623,
-0.2906904817,
-0.2969808877,
0.397405833,
0.5617458224,
-0.49934268,
0.5811713934,
0.3911410868,
-0.016113868,
-0.1891960502,
-0.9679104686,
0.090693891,
-0.4696858227,
-0.3169402182,
0.7161951661,
0.2070768625,
-0.201951772,
-0.2433616668,
-0.2679001093,
0.0480154753,
-0.2979438901,
0.1560788304,
0.3735745549,
-0.447986424,
-0.1112702787,
0.0347316749,
-0.3243718445,
-0.0961091742,
-0.4728383124,
0.3411468565,
0.0602227636,
-0.2039811611,
-1.0456491709,
0.3695611358,
0.2911403775,
-0.2022905052,
0.4272981882,
0.6451286077,
-0.557759285,
0.0192910023,
-0.5356052518,
-0.0922240913,
-0.4539984167,
-0.0568435863,
-0.0498917624,
-0.4140724838,
0.6703386903,
0.2478276342,
-0.1397432387,
0.449100256,
0.4831531346,
-0.3335746229,
0.9993484616,
0.6449355483,
-0.4173305333,
0.48988837,
-0.4047951996,
0.0879528522,
-1.1048250198,
-0.4691082239,
-0.4388847649,
-0.4327638447,
-0.4423640072,
-0.3823498487,
0.4063161314,
0.1105574742,
-0.0642126501,
0.5418131948,
-0.7399951816,
0.0654807985,
0.9396782517,
0.4134658575,
0.121349223,
-0.0847136974,
0.0388826951,
0.0187421031,
-0.6934532523,
-0.2799276114,
0.9581967592,
0.4638084769,
1.0759760141,
0.0931457654,
1.0781693459,
0.104731366,
-0.1386439651,
-0.7554367781,
0.3744177818,
-0.2566165328,
-0.3087573349,
-0.286755681,
-0.5217370987,
-0.61831671,
0.0718885139,
-0.0324519202,
-0.6318127513,
0.4417832494,
0.5050672293,
-0.4473286569,
0.2631401718,
-0.94307971,
0.5461747646,
-0.3274000585,
-0.2452487499,
0.2004747242,
-0.9927490354,
0.1851816624,
0.1656845361,
-0.0997570232,
0.2699817419,
0.009714704,
1.2116128206,
-0.7828449011,
0.9222503304,
-0.1962681115,
-0.2770595849,
0.5612826943,
-0.4181296825,
0.4418236911,
-0.3922390342,
-0.0027274804,
0.1045876816,
-0.3310352564,
-0.2009664178,
-0.4337759018,
0.3665372431,
-0.8755825162,
-0.2004829496,
-0.1939466149,
-0.6750246882,
-0.2423173934,
-0.1316301674,
0.5914879441,
0.4788329303,
0.3484065831,
0.2510993779,
0.7158401608,
-0.0872840434,
0.266184181,
0.3956977129,
0.2425689101,
-0.381067723,
1.077652216,
0.2705405056,
0.382444948,
0.4263277352,
0.3008896708,
-0.3303363025,
-0.542709589,
-0.4286494553,
0.2029363513,
-0.3935336471,
-0.4057031274,
-0.4342379868,
-0.3830924928,
-0.7639397383,
-0.1939390749,
-0.5366849303,
-0.5675107837,
-0.3651743233,
0.0378224142,
0.357504338,
0.2671811283,
-0.1624554396,
0.6555225849,
-0.5220458508,
0.2869727015,
0.0010422815,
0.300055027,
-0.2686158419,
-1.0285264254,
-0.3135511577,
-0.1463587284,
-0.2288059145,
-0.7347024679,
0.2439630181,
0.7392897606,
0.5392534733,
0.6588144898,
0.0832158923,
0.9590568542,
-0.3006033599,
0.4030314684,
0.4773082435,
-0.9977040291,
0.6837596297,
-0.3689030409,
0.5327631831,
0.3737291098,
0.1303648949,
-0.0600174628,
-0.5772584677,
-0.4364402294,
-0.9345840216,
0.705807209,
0.2662426829,
-0.2400806993,
0.5201119184,
0.2216465622,
0.1076250821,
-0.1388644725,
-0.5259184837,
-0.3683978915,
-0.3124824166,
-0.3525235653,
-0.1738117039,
0.0597002096,
-0.1396328509,
-0.5664204955,
1.0491396189,
0.0059303772,
0.3277361393,
0.1228918508,
0.1133735925,
-0.4636905789,
0.2902455032,
0.4126774669,
-0.0481722802,
-0.2496571988,
0.2288813889,
0.3700861037,
-0.3871431053,
-0.0431771651,
0.2941142321,
-0.3570667803,
0.1183118299,
0.4520317316,
0.8920791745,
0.2687996328,
-0.3364003897,
0.3228490055,
0.3156581819,
-0.3274737,
-0.0838880837,
0.0475568883,
-0.0930117816,
0.0165426284,
0.3288773894,
0.1270693988,
0.3946067691,
-0.5594040751,
0.3666361868,
0.3888472617,
-0.533392489,
-0.3749904633,
0.8458704352,
-0.0027977913,
-0.259894222,
0.4711464643,
0.1424736977,
-0.6277416945,
0.4757978618,
0.8809651136,
0.8196679354,
-0.7378129363,
-0.1560945809,
0.2839382589,
0.3090563715,
-0.0452026464,
0.3479370475,
-0.320238471,
-0.6387184858,
-0.3945917189,
-0.5683448911,
-0.5981531143,
-0.0683452785,
-1.1277242899,
0.3811280429,
-0.4520974457,
-0.1597830057,
0.1052620262,
-0.4520147145,
-0.31517905,
0.4320659041,
0.3036105037,
0.3509089351,
-0.9981349707,
0.8700620532,
0.7696838975,
-0.272983104,
-0.860052824,
0.0123612219,
0.2635025084,
-0.5623586178,
0.1991627365,
0.0316476636,
-0.2618328333,
-0.0764427334,
-0.3823471665,
-1.0863274336,
0.9069479108,
0.3125956655,
-0.7257882357,
-0.1115414575,
0.1307392269,
0.6883614063,
-0.1875518411,
-0.2239815742,
0.5691980124,
0.0694757923,
0.4752812684,
-1.5719118118,
-0.1489695311,
-0.4134194851,
-0.0940643176,
0.5298637748,
-0.5261418223,
0.5946806669,
-0.1743322015,
-0.287052393,
-0.2320391238,
0.659807682,
-0.0390789658,
0.5606075525,
0.5899547935,
0.77422297,
0.3323087096,
-0.0973735899,
0.6665286422,
-0.0339860544,
0.1806714237,
1.3880839348,
-0.4096043706,
0.8651527166,
0.6627409458,
-0.1916500777,
0.2794735432,
0.6316693425,
0.0596156046,
0.6974385381,
0.0495624878,
-0.0908645242,
-0.1920018643,
-0.3729537725,
-0.5108034611,
0.5655444264,
0.337952733,
-0.2949335575,
-0.0839901045,
0.1430460066,
-0.3004022837,
0.1362752467,
-0.5090070367,
1.1147594452,
0.2607163191,
-0.2936117947,
0.7572052479,
-0.2431582659,
0.882542491,
-0.4266642928,
0.1936913282,
0.1408867538,
0.3828619123,
-0.4541282952,
-0.4640797079,
0.5259909034,
-0.0145463031,
-0.1240170449,
-0.2893622816,
0.7449027896,
-0.7748350501,
-0.5772747397,
0.4505201876,
0.1621948779,
0.2354877293,
0.3339891732,
-0.5495475531,
0.0455983095,
-0.0955149829,
-0.0238633975,
0.2066811621,
0.0968047082,
-0.0837615132,
0.3780652881,
0.6215783358,
0.211609304,
0.3200906217,
0.3077331781,
0.8788759708,
-0.4556545019,
-0.6222392321,
-0.6204319596,
0.3296510577,
-0.0423138998,
-0.248891741,
0.6645909548,
0.9435588717,
0.9648830891,
0.2935434282,
0.7839685082,
0.0608800985,
0.773509562,
-0.5843353868,
0.4949877858,
-0.544377327,
0.2848028541,
-0.4161815941,
-0.8548550606,
-0.5064977407,
0.5490819216,
-0.1667602807,
-0.0722581521,
0.1612667292,
0.8307717443,
-0.3414318562,
-0.2164851576,
0.2323455215,
-0.024867706,
-0.0728749782,
0.4169615507,
0.6515912414,
-0.8325407505,
0.6488146782,
-0.5029267669,
-0.0573224984,
0.0143393744,
-0.2662120461,
-0.8416428566,
-0.5128822923,
-0.6736038923,
-0.3741286099,
0.1915781051,
0.8836350441,
0.7195144892,
-1.1227972507,
-0.4296618104,
0.0395675227,
-0.1896320581,
-0.3826116025,
-0.2142454982,
0.4638336897,
0.1148421317,
-0.4831530154,
0.6018562913,
0.210016042,
0.4107703269,
0.1234514564,
-0.4503507912,
-0.3154979944,
-0.243754521,
0.1540325433,
0.4244960546,
-0.8583267331,
-0.2743895054,
-0.1662465483,
0.0905434042,
0.200103119,
0.7079465985,
-0.5208389163,
0.475687176,
0.3249366879,
0.4868485332,
0.4826322198,
0.2356138974,
0.7859723568,
-0.8863548636,
0.1267322451,
0.2548952103,
0.4022863805,
0.6134690046,
-0.3381159604,
0.4055886567,
0.3200344741,
-0.3202722967,
-0.8819488883,
-0.1525088996,
-1.2943230867,
0.3611578941,
1.1177847385,
0.187052086,
-0.1212598905,
-0.1736281514,
-0.2328282893,
0.8631193638,
-0.462420851,
0.5514778495,
0.0664142072,
-0.3495799005,
-0.2105638534,
-0.1053108275,
0.1625739634,
0.5883318782,
-0.5958265066,
-0.0560586788,
0.3433200717,
0.1444164664,
0.3632677197,
0.4697496295,
0.0377636291,
0.3344354033,
-0.0475446582,
0.2248007357,
0.1616598964,
-0.2673597634,
-0.5042589903,
-0.2587409317,
-0.1928611845,
-0.6854653955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14808v1
|
Data-to-Text Bilingual Generation
| 2023-11-24T19:05:57 | 2023-11-24T19:05:57 |
Guy Lapalme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
This document illustrates the use of pyrealb for generating two parallel
texts (English and French) from a single source of data. The data selection and
text organisation processes are shared between the two languages. only language
dependent word and phrasing choices are distinct processes. The realized texts
thus convey identical information in both languages without the risk of being
lost in translation. This is especially important in cases where strict and
simultaneous bilingualism is required. We first present the types of
applications targeted by this approach and how the pyrealb English and French
realizer can be used for achieving this goal in a natural way. We describe an
object-oriented organization to ensure a convenient realization in both
languages. To illustrate the process, different types of applications are then
briefly sketched with links to the source code. A brief comparison of the text
generation is given with the output of an instance of a GPT.
|
[
-0.1767392159,
-0.7754656076,
0.4609619081,
1.016910553,
-0.2863121331,
0.0535428561,
-0.1411186457,
-0.5597832203,
0.1938325912,
0.7757327557,
-0.2779270113,
-0.3888290823,
-0.4024061561,
0.4356513619,
-0.4576880336,
1.2715144157,
-0.4149822891,
0.0182058103,
-0.1751004308,
0.0529060848,
-0.4348299503,
-0.6837655902,
-0.8073096871,
-0.3270094991,
0.5510777831,
0.5399368405,
0.8246158957,
0.7336793542,
0.3595179915,
0.2423421293,
0.3450037241,
-0.0165266693,
-0.5056565404,
0.3028228283,
-0.6462350488,
-0.3294988275,
-0.4407451153,
-0.3461209238,
0.9445341229,
0.6528161168,
-0.0090128286,
-0.1597245336,
0.0890451446,
0.5556387901,
-0.2887332737,
0.2307880372,
-0.3492521942,
0.0111273443,
-0.5886315703,
-0.3993932605,
-0.412427932,
-0.500135541,
-0.0030007355,
-0.0648952872,
0.2206611186,
0.0769613087,
0.3585056067,
-0.1378061026,
-0.8641557097,
-0.7487756014,
-0.8526456356,
0.9126855135,
-0.1815703958,
0.5138478875,
0.1629661322,
0.1585181355,
-0.1738923937,
-1.0954738855,
-0.4961962104,
0.0348365419,
-0.1368410587,
0.2714292109,
-0.12568672,
-0.2945753336,
-0.1226238683,
0.7380268574,
-1.0125150681,
-0.1108336374,
-0.5834304094,
-0.3618102372,
0.8053375483,
0.2185377479,
0.6113480926,
-0.1950014979,
-0.4247524738,
-0.2859472334,
-0.4906482399,
-0.3102131784,
0.6195155382,
0.3371464908,
-0.1338553131,
0.833912015,
-0.0026274882,
0.5630802512,
-0.3111103773,
-0.1820327491,
0.3910889328,
-0.4802390933,
-0.090064019,
0.3322742283,
0.9533823729,
0.297947675,
0.1120285243,
-0.4126658738,
-0.3283900917,
-0.0827985629,
0.0176474601,
-0.8418555856,
-0.3657819927,
0.2010717541,
-0.4745334089,
-0.2520932555,
0.2427300066,
-0.9278273582,
0.0532392785,
-0.281573981,
0.0979077965,
-0.2628603876,
-0.434092164,
0.1308425367,
-0.265932858,
-0.0694893226,
-0.0218606405,
-0.751745224,
0.5160566568,
0.2576943338,
0.7348145843,
-0.4232015014,
-0.5908285975,
-0.262796253,
0.4613104165,
-0.1868652701,
0.74937886,
-0.3658944368,
-0.6201005578,
0.0018852548,
-0.0556471385,
-0.0853957012,
-0.5109040141,
0.6670527458,
-0.3701921105,
0.6411494017,
0.0131182196,
-0.3791464269,
-0.186469391,
-0.3574127853,
-0.6263822317,
1.0500277281,
0.2572256923,
-1.1402916908,
0.2506839931,
-0.2320435345,
-0.8081926703,
0.1061064154,
-0.3551639616,
-0.3645361364,
-0.0349998288,
0.23631154,
0.3391385674,
-0.895996809,
0.2105124295,
0.230158776,
0.2137556374,
-0.0843879506,
-0.4745262861,
0.7585354447,
0.2048517764,
-0.2076743692,
-0.163824439,
-0.4648202956,
0.1686497331,
0.2950941324,
-0.9748764634,
-0.1781473607,
0.244908303,
0.9064647555,
0.1859628707,
0.4893831611,
-0.4084106386,
0.1660418808,
-0.4594928026,
0.2993240058,
0.3647219241,
0.3671193719,
0.4434649944,
-0.3852809668,
0.4846343994,
-0.0239696745,
-0.0672878698,
-0.1941574961,
-0.7836655378,
-0.3522207141,
-0.3762978017,
0.1225815415,
1.0288367271,
-1.0848041773,
0.1230131686,
0.1322706938,
-0.3674142957,
-0.0658391193,
0.4364670217,
0.3895070255,
0.349157542,
0.3595809042,
-0.3491298556,
-0.6524272561,
-1.1510409117,
-0.3264327645,
-0.0814466998,
0.1453365088,
0.2548945248,
0.3006652892,
-0.3266763091,
0.8626500368,
-0.4579364955,
0.0147620551,
-0.5663701892,
0.2305036634,
0.1989804357,
0.4314272404,
0.7540491223,
-1.1759741306,
-0.7325878143,
0.2961653173,
-0.8620165586,
-0.4064253867,
-0.0385625325,
-0.3917995989,
0.2776398957,
0.3513124883,
-0.1844057441,
0.3796291053,
0.4892642498,
-0.2575539947,
0.4353573322,
-0.2823364139,
0.1705381125,
-1.5582085848,
-0.0184406992,
-0.0655168965,
-0.3124145567,
-0.6766711473,
0.0019832135,
0.0087899901,
-0.0939342901,
-0.3644682169,
0.7347619534,
-0.5107814074,
0.1629583538,
-0.2950340211,
-0.1207126603,
-0.1995454133,
0.1671599895,
0.4306565225,
0.7110553384,
0.7800919414,
-0.5421887636,
0.707024157,
0.4080834091,
-0.041028589,
0.4409894347,
-0.6210872531,
0.1818451285,
-0.1796176583,
0.2979769111,
-0.4330343604,
-0.4823047817,
0.5184773207,
-0.1790455878,
0.0187597424,
0.0016738904,
-0.6837766171,
-0.4622882903,
-0.0882503688,
0.5608844757,
0.4143050313,
-0.4726679623,
0.326662451,
0.4340333641,
-0.8050792217,
-0.3440952599,
-0.9943871498,
0.1656933874,
-0.168279916,
-0.7590969801,
0.1649434716,
0.0959281027,
-0.1670781076,
-0.0289711654,
-0.0498330258,
-0.4359503388,
-0.7699967027,
0.1794282049,
0.0425648727,
-0.3296160698,
-0.0129117314,
0.4015953839,
0.0005945883,
-0.211468339,
-0.6724563241,
0.585074544,
0.227723375,
-0.1300060898,
-0.3843467236,
0.9546330571,
0.4403917789,
-0.3196761012,
0.7808006406,
0.3891637623,
-0.2698593438,
-0.4328858256,
-0.2299296707,
0.0205250885,
-0.4474323094,
0.2138251215,
-0.5107818842,
-0.3491486311,
0.2587750852,
0.0308937076,
0.1222998202,
0.3734818697,
1.0614556074,
0.1609198153,
0.7634249926,
0.7474471331,
-0.0035977501,
0.2648640573,
0.077291064,
0.290682584,
-0.2009037286,
-0.3879842758,
-0.5641169548,
0.0206147619,
-0.5079427361,
-0.5989282131,
0.3118225038,
0.4721570015,
0.1585059464,
0.4335694015,
-0.487880826,
0.4232056439,
0.6245886683,
0.0953205079,
0.3356311321,
0.7059828043,
-0.1633432359,
-0.1353856921,
-0.9452843666,
-0.7472895384,
1.2997742891,
0.1266057193,
0.5960962176,
0.1585358083,
1.1044324636,
-0.0172221418,
0.1827719063,
-0.5968535542,
0.421085,
-0.2675144374,
-0.5192306042,
-0.0112476023,
-0.7147142887,
-0.8453892469,
0.0593808889,
-0.0500564575,
-0.7881952524,
0.0686896816,
0.1497755051,
0.3344389796,
0.1857412457,
-0.8777549267,
0.8308531046,
-0.3084809482,
-0.7322912812,
-0.312887162,
-0.2587558031,
0.2058879584,
-0.3079608679,
0.0228154138,
0.3636450469,
0.0595805831,
0.6977825165,
-0.3141623437,
0.4068054855,
0.0862905085,
-0.2753103673,
0.4345886111,
0.1637710035,
0.3885521293,
0.4393745065,
-0.138751179,
-0.0210581105,
-0.0257163253,
-0.5762153864,
-0.1076994911,
0.7190884352,
-0.4159971476,
-0.3188604414,
-0.5742381215,
-0.9702473879,
-0.0611716323,
0.3824183345,
0.4252144992,
0.5525306463,
-0.3952254355,
0.0128514236,
0.2132676393,
-0.5164980888,
0.3064682484,
0.3288298249,
-0.606315136,
-0.4299045801,
1.1391842365,
-0.182275027,
0.1232893765,
0.6349075437,
0.0741257519,
-0.4598607123,
-0.4421153069,
-0.4918811917,
0.4340336323,
-0.5323399305,
0.1411023885,
-0.4621222615,
-0.1251345873,
-0.2934440076,
-0.2598754168,
-0.165716961,
-0.4009658098,
0.1774982214,
0.1913702339,
0.2925388515,
0.9700821638,
-0.1438917071,
0.1029051095,
-0.7611719966,
0.5705997944,
0.2002833337,
0.0151390573,
-0.3118762374,
0.2142406702,
-0.0934621096,
0.2554518878,
-0.3346796036,
-1.2376314402,
0.3704419136,
0.1459832788,
0.5640941858,
0.1064737216,
-0.2016773075,
0.0262993556,
-0.5542635322,
0.3841657043,
0.3769110441,
-0.7777591348,
0.7085200548,
-0.5366928577,
0.0891766101,
0.1060862318,
0.4672745466,
-0.5839164257,
-0.5555717945,
-0.3325852752,
-1.2030736208,
1.0184795856,
0.741268754,
-0.128629595,
0.0051839477,
0.0615554191,
0.3947402537,
0.2678556442,
-0.5968107581,
-0.2684893906,
-0.1792085767,
-0.3505917192,
-0.2400198728,
-0.1311356425,
-0.2218431383,
-0.2068870813,
0.6589039564,
0.1526648104,
0.1499591023,
0.3565367758,
-0.2655308247,
0.0991293266,
0.1342300773,
0.2641040385,
0.8401631117,
-0.1117614359,
0.0878416449,
-0.237027958,
-0.8297416568,
0.1588861197,
0.0942072049,
-0.1133732945,
0.2035510838,
0.355645746,
0.7569596171,
-0.1169995889,
-0.5124573708,
0.069607392,
-0.0170925409,
-0.2470574081,
0.0905615836,
-0.2869951725,
0.4001065791,
0.3146791458,
0.3274152279,
-0.1397157013,
0.0079026734,
-0.8274118304,
0.4715312719,
-0.1708969921,
0.3541760147,
-0.1603308171,
0.8303492665,
0.402135253,
-0.3988714218,
0.5213778615,
-0.3401551843,
-0.3937533796,
0.6942149997,
0.9499343038,
0.6371608377,
-0.4510115385,
0.5563794971,
0.1432837099,
0.3137126863,
-0.2728671432,
0.6359431744,
-0.0412824526,
-0.6127769947,
0.0565712713,
-0.8395406008,
-0.2578282058,
-0.1243203133,
-0.6043860912,
0.2482784241,
-0.2946214676,
0.0977259874,
0.2940883934,
-0.2342265844,
-0.5757870674,
0.3045900166,
-0.0258978996,
0.7365553975,
-0.9019396305,
0.902574718,
1.0413037539,
-0.4132902324,
-0.7063055634,
0.2719958723,
-0.1141573489,
-0.4353124201,
0.678180635,
-0.3465217054,
-0.125302285,
0.0304164477,
0.1730524153,
-0.4228574336,
0.8602659702,
0.5066819787,
-0.6432213783,
0.0231398437,
0.6128525138,
0.464864701,
-0.2943273187,
-0.0110028815,
0.4939310849,
0.5165292621,
0.0582010932,
-1.1665996313,
-0.1464698911,
-0.1168135181,
0.0003559414,
0.3149261773,
-0.4116067886,
0.9889974594,
0.280893147,
-0.4446829557,
-0.1439448595,
0.3220615089,
0.0729778782,
0.3921784163,
0.0364433452,
0.4140510857,
0.5510877371,
-0.1060246751,
1.159604311,
-0.5129197836,
0.2533144951,
1.1548199654,
-0.3219587207,
0.5944944024,
0.7015138268,
-0.2199629545,
0.1064826027,
0.3476381004,
0.282222867,
0.391214788,
0.0009057685,
-0.5136868954,
0.1420228928,
0.0934454352,
-0.5308720469,
0.3303229809,
0.3419248462,
-0.5329015851,
-0.6268925071,
0.1181886941,
0.1765241474,
0.2719596922,
-0.2443535477,
0.4532009661,
0.2103911936,
-0.5344617963,
0.3941127658,
0.4561839402,
0.3507222235,
-0.5137423277,
0.2039542347,
-0.2463096082,
0.3062800467,
-0.3801803291,
-0.988394022,
0.5585403442,
0.1842209995,
-0.5453953743,
-0.5895231366,
0.5996178985,
-0.7692915201,
-0.8857523203,
0.5107728839,
0.8755716681,
0.3260433674,
0.0083281519,
-0.6604518294,
-0.0358972587,
0.2050590515,
-0.2976331115,
-0.0692722276,
0.3772166073,
-0.3771110177,
0.385869652,
0.4784188569,
0.4609116316,
0.3827982843,
0.1398481727,
0.6176811457,
-0.3259089291,
-0.6045383811,
-0.6343443394,
0.2168368846,
-0.061321117,
-0.2520640194,
0.8719390631,
1.1048771143,
0.9461644292,
-0.1649832726,
1.1723027229,
-0.4557462335,
0.4667909443,
-0.5547833443,
0.620942831,
-0.363242954,
-0.1376447082,
-0.1035479978,
-1.4843394756,
-0.1232535616,
0.4738056362,
-0.3083415329,
-0.2537518144,
1.1694374084,
0.9274055362,
-0.4354985356,
0.0255418401,
-0.1091079488,
0.2407028526,
0.0589157604,
0.9672854543,
0.5033885241,
-0.4815979302,
0.4772782922,
-0.271495223,
-0.3941125274,
0.2378664762,
-0.5144651532,
-0.9865657687,
-0.7682144046,
-0.2131240666,
-0.3180941939,
0.1924706846,
0.66458112,
0.4203112125,
-0.8075625896,
-0.7720119953,
-0.4164793789,
0.0706552714,
0.0894966125,
-0.2565487027,
0.1745100319,
-0.0844485834,
-1.0225305557,
0.3952437639,
0.4687645435,
0.0389683954,
0.0718006864,
-0.2268692404,
-0.1799237281,
0.2388938069,
0.3588580489,
0.5175281167,
-0.1152049005,
0.3053923547,
-0.4960153401,
-0.1912645996,
-0.1069481,
1.1436578035,
-0.5070587993,
0.4177047014,
0.7953517437,
0.295589298,
0.6558389664,
-0.1882694513,
0.9834020734,
-0.7483876944,
0.7233245969,
0.2830978334,
0.1115339398,
0.2553786337,
-0.2127382755,
0.1598059386,
0.3017654121,
-0.5030200481,
-0.8415570855,
0.4805912673,
-0.6631444693,
-0.3223219514,
1.0480765104,
0.1668565571,
-0.0506273657,
-0.2009971589,
-0.7359431386,
0.3807036579,
-0.3793820739,
0.4380389452,
0.674231112,
0.0340106227,
0.0023988662,
-0.8178493381,
0.5567620397,
0.1633979976,
-0.8384311199,
-0.0347711481,
0.2979080975,
0.2759656012,
-0.0544351377,
0.8298453689,
-0.2054082602,
0.1217010915,
0.2957413495,
0.1661810726,
0.2328669876,
-0.5080714226,
0.0738026574,
0.3219071925,
-0.2355714887,
0.0272086803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14788v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models through Gender and Racial Stereotypes
| 2023-11-24T18:41:16 | 2023-11-24T18:41:16 |
Ananya Malik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Language Models have ushered a new age of AI gaining traction within the NLP
community as well as amongst the general population. AI's ability to make
predictions, generations and its applications in sensitive decision-making
scenarios, makes it even more important to study these models for possible
biases that may exist and that can be exaggerated. We conduct a quality
comparative study and establish a framework to evaluate language models under
the premise of two kinds of biases: gender and race, in a professional setting.
We find out that while gender bias has reduced immensely in newer models, as
compared to older ones, racial bias still exists.
|
[
-0.4475306273,
-0.5024155378,
0.3846657574,
0.2742007077,
0.4372283518,
0.2070217729,
-0.1506630778,
-0.7553579807,
0.0034095941,
0.373092711,
-0.3666413724,
-0.2919659913,
-0.6390932798,
0.0898562223,
-0.5831885338,
0.8334923387,
0.4378769398,
0.5665542483,
-0.2811278701,
-0.213237524,
-0.4881496727,
-0.8066305518,
-1.1489421129,
-0.6340081096,
0.0336247571,
-0.1714816093,
1.1109716892,
0.3911701441,
0.5734981894,
0.2846677899,
-0.5297799706,
-0.1933318824,
-0.3339630067,
0.1498978436,
-0.2448051423,
-0.593970716,
-0.341735661,
0.2964341938,
0.4274242222,
1.0692285299,
0.1503644884,
0.2589274645,
-0.2392631471,
0.7041037083,
-0.6102485657,
0.3593183756,
-0.5436271429,
0.2665342093,
-0.0363752171,
0.1996330917,
-0.378395468,
-0.47900787,
0.368542552,
-0.241726771,
0.3391876817,
0.3301862776,
0.5707756281,
0.0310889706,
-0.5822111368,
-0.1579729319,
-1.0804208517,
0.8466880322,
-1.0124233961,
0.6164290905,
0.4304447174,
0.5264117122,
-0.0526416413,
-0.4262669981,
-0.7381505966,
-0.5844685435,
0.0663091168,
-0.2054027766,
-0.1331649274,
-0.0197492465,
0.4767622352,
0.3063597679,
-0.4490314126,
0.4784939885,
-0.5788538456,
-0.1064857468,
0.8554976583,
0.0222450681,
0.6854578853,
-0.1490439475,
0.1006291956,
-0.0834348202,
-0.5724430084,
-0.341539979,
0.7101664543,
0.2574509382,
-0.0725014135,
0.4613274932,
-0.0526151732,
0.5419245958,
-0.1620413363,
-0.1609688848,
0.3632010818,
-0.0564312972,
-0.0834704489,
-0.0183773432,
0.6547677517,
0.7191405296,
0.8278846741,
-0.1098775119,
-0.1143372282,
0.2368435562,
0.1836389154,
-0.402155906,
-0.0535015315,
0.0270877276,
-0.8033365607,
-0.1753783971,
-0.2431994081,
-1.016920805,
-0.7622055411,
-0.3615849912,
-0.1333798617,
-0.1122070849,
-0.4866398573,
0.0299595166,
-0.4282420576,
0.1943331659,
0.3246183693,
-1.1605176926,
0.331341058,
1.05509758,
0.7915167809,
0.027658537,
-0.0798453689,
-0.0884789526,
-0.372476995,
-0.6092877388,
0.5528258085,
-0.8517758846,
-0.4073429704,
0.2160438597,
-0.4181940854,
0.1490342915,
-0.8644043803,
0.3782682419,
-0.3657482862,
0.3940304816,
-0.2949157059,
-0.3770587146,
-0.1503357142,
0.0590165704,
-0.7621747255,
1.065482378,
0.2916894853,
-0.804820478,
0.8054674268,
-0.6968834996,
-0.2020801455,
-0.1008001864,
-0.3461810648,
-0.347781837,
0.1839766204,
0.1187597364,
0.0301774703,
-0.6011099815,
0.405416429,
-0.6873856187,
-0.1968576759,
0.0502519421,
-0.232666105,
1.2156391144,
0.2567391992,
-0.4096137583,
0.053573925,
-0.4578559101,
-0.3477191627,
0.2228994966,
0.1284602135,
-0.6520922184,
0.2450565547,
-0.0828849897,
0.5305354595,
-0.2081841379,
-0.5400915146,
0.1143438891,
-0.4347652197,
0.6823905706,
0.5656775832,
-0.470739305,
0.7895388007,
-0.2506370544,
0.7978547215,
-0.4577309489,
0.2608577013,
0.3042110503,
-0.6705818176,
-0.9551568031,
0.1215861589,
0.3735475838,
0.4437835217,
-0.5368468165,
0.3036266863,
-0.0355642401,
-0.434340924,
-0.7030915618,
-0.0112011479,
0.2959779203,
0.2552568913,
0.1117178127,
-0.4141738415,
-0.6202679873,
-1.0803650618,
-0.3942881823,
-0.6676319242,
-0.1748501807,
0.392798692,
0.6938169003,
-0.2504960299,
1.0045534372,
-0.2237487435,
-0.0863103345,
-0.4409603775,
0.2087657452,
-0.080107078,
0.5030197501,
1.1226489544,
-0.6164695621,
-0.1025906727,
-0.2686536014,
-0.7071578503,
-0.2970093191,
0.0818863586,
-0.0727760866,
0.1592805684,
0.7565534711,
-0.4901078939,
0.3430573046,
0.6927393079,
-0.5613027215,
0.9105915427,
0.0791274384,
0.0693881661,
-0.6557323337,
-0.0524206199,
0.4138418436,
-0.1555672288,
-0.6300341487,
0.141431585,
-0.3674390912,
-0.2804027498,
-0.2222847193,
0.8202275038,
-0.4345398545,
-0.4956873059,
-0.2443970889,
0.0056878938,
0.0081706643,
-0.0557912253,
0.1317664236,
0.6231624484,
0.3638252318,
-0.3424807787,
0.1848867983,
0.2120353132,
-0.702049315,
0.4206445813,
-0.7673620582,
0.1983636916,
-0.4914836884,
0.3505503237,
-0.723780036,
0.0982371047,
0.0137151508,
-0.5110716224,
0.1713799238,
-0.1328596026,
-0.3926710784,
-0.8282595873,
-0.1844819337,
0.4933437109,
0.5637506843,
-0.2625918388,
0.5506350994,
0.5816322565,
-0.4905421436,
-0.6275927424,
-0.6968607306,
0.0723615587,
-0.124879837,
-0.4691273272,
-0.0910070315,
0.0404481553,
-1.0208185911,
-0.2284487337,
0.0393954813,
-0.1814050972,
0.2430364043,
0.0568682961,
0.2919979393,
-0.3135986924,
0.0378929228,
-0.0630362332,
0.0449628979,
0.3147774637,
-0.0954182744,
0.8731742501,
0.063931182,
-0.2985892594,
-0.2501612902,
0.3098815382,
0.7462525368,
-0.4141548574,
0.9499436021,
0.3610523641,
-0.4247846901,
-0.1288268864,
-0.6629484892,
-0.3135151565,
-0.3948361874,
0.7380526066,
0.0541153178,
-1.0114461184,
0.4506503046,
0.2598040998,
0.3000007868,
0.5607635379,
0.5422946215,
-0.0496840142,
1.3069227934,
0.7819349766,
-0.3732266128,
0.5136340261,
-0.1143572181,
0.5692250729,
-0.682092905,
-0.2534023523,
-0.9450727701,
-0.2375113815,
-0.6427845359,
-0.2379080951,
0.0976432115,
-0.009421628,
-0.4747828245,
-0.0757376626,
-0.3290357292,
0.3933110535,
0.6809843183,
-0.4005964398,
0.0808984935,
-0.1670467705,
0.1039081067,
-0.2213074416,
-0.6574721932,
-0.769697845,
1.1121581793,
0.798897028,
0.3950616419,
0.0277118161,
0.1789535284,
0.6842104197,
0.5254486203,
-0.4578815997,
0.5864040852,
-0.4384535253,
-1.1645587683,
-0.2273466587,
-0.4747549593,
-0.7168525457,
0.3604831696,
-0.6930728555,
-0.7472681403,
0.36754632,
0.2567797601,
-0.1201084852,
0.4751085043,
-0.7479388714,
0.708350718,
-0.1472575217,
0.0144822514,
-0.1681592315,
-0.5094908476,
0.6894271374,
-0.0334439874,
0.5217948556,
-0.5743583441,
0.4475841224,
0.8730710745,
-0.2157859504,
0.7387737036,
-0.2016139776,
-0.120168291,
0.0305502042,
0.2945295274,
-0.0234708786,
-0.1651655883,
-0.544287622,
0.4087777138,
-0.2466357201,
-0.2101008892,
-0.6418228745,
0.3368524015,
-0.8401340842,
-0.5461146832,
-0.4246462584,
-0.6026351452,
-0.1080641896,
0.0114035914,
-0.0441865325,
0.398366183,
-0.2824918926,
-0.0071969773,
0.1748782098,
-0.7521538138,
0.2108245641,
0.3464250863,
-0.5135287642,
0.0397513695,
0.42694965,
-0.122425966,
0.4782528281,
-0.0204202626,
0.288589716,
-0.351249963,
-0.5069345832,
-0.309384197,
0.3174239993,
-0.6454859972,
0.2001617998,
-0.6886511445,
-0.2601925433,
-0.8070341945,
-0.048426196,
-0.4331207871,
-0.4263141751,
0.1163125634,
-0.1696909517,
0.0623696633,
0.7974859476,
0.2217657268,
0.3344331682,
-0.287610054,
0.2851624489,
0.4442268312,
0.1266682595,
0.2001545876,
-0.4663219452,
0.160502702,
-0.039256949,
-0.0009856365,
-0.7659937143,
0.6290075183,
0.162695989,
0.5111691952,
0.3722694218,
-0.1029306203,
0.062758781,
-0.6329042912,
0.9695700407,
0.1963314712,
-0.9983979464,
0.2832919359,
-0.2556729913,
0.1917618066,
0.570166111,
0.4885907173,
-0.8463042378,
-0.6602805853,
-0.5344265699,
-0.7386927605,
0.5010616183,
0.2124006301,
0.3031488359,
-0.106223762,
0.5237759352,
0.2073275149,
0.4939412475,
-0.9400500655,
-0.7130175829,
-0.0558950342,
-0.024880901,
-0.1814659089,
-0.5283312798,
0.1910613328,
-0.2387382835,
0.3989743292,
0.0277040023,
0.3592517078,
-0.4102376401,
0.0144279907,
0.1209795326,
0.4102439284,
0.3232348859,
0.9334503412,
-0.2198690623,
0.0874061286,
0.1723571271,
-0.2586204708,
0.1416002661,
0.0920853913,
-0.5629451275,
0.1616913378,
0.6315212846,
1.0169612169,
-0.088599816,
-0.70293051,
0.4100474417,
-0.0180316176,
-0.2292917669,
-0.3854808211,
0.0484837703,
-0.0426289774,
0.3840917945,
0.205955714,
0.0410117917,
0.3085905313,
-1.0354089737,
-0.1022039503,
0.5765078068,
-0.2250461131,
-0.1263832599,
0.9850127101,
0.5053586364,
-0.552798152,
0.9029248357,
-0.2135145962,
-0.8570899963,
0.8336880207,
0.5940064788,
0.8378916979,
-0.3255823553,
0.3662034273,
0.4160763919,
0.5901718736,
-0.2543886304,
-0.0145965097,
0.3924628496,
-1.0318689346,
-0.5143486857,
-0.7312261462,
-0.4156790376,
0.1432917863,
-0.4982910752,
0.1875069141,
-0.5816807747,
-0.5113051534,
0.2530576587,
-0.2046444416,
-0.6407613158,
0.4077785909,
0.4913672507,
0.8810602427,
-1.2251714468,
0.5115843415,
0.5787168145,
-0.3631393313,
-0.2627055943,
-0.0626522452,
0.1465430111,
-0.8540952206,
1.1492506266,
0.2418404818,
0.1148777008,
-0.4571403563,
-0.3153390586,
-0.8337076902,
0.436706394,
0.5910886526,
-0.7508332133,
-0.4809231758,
0.1196665987,
0.7480939031,
-0.3883708119,
0.7349939346,
0.9793803096,
0.5091201067,
-0.4355139434,
-1.3425803185,
-0.3593894541,
-0.2506371439,
0.2135628164,
0.1248887554,
-0.4214451611,
1.0753158331,
-0.1581255645,
-0.0342566296,
-0.1724620759,
0.7228536606,
0.2211355716,
0.3376848102,
0.7041754723,
0.2136931419,
0.6358184814,
-0.1897263378,
1.2575509548,
-0.207015574,
0.1872174293,
1.0921298265,
-0.4873119295,
0.4591094255,
-0.0685648993,
-0.3907819092,
0.5613395572,
0.4862649441,
-0.0719563663,
0.0051688622,
0.4022384882,
-0.0916238278,
-0.1238712445,
-0.3327488005,
-0.4350939691,
0.7120966911,
0.1899260283,
-0.5734877586,
0.020097414,
-0.0565656088,
0.2162085027,
0.3360650837,
-0.3693396747,
0.5312342048,
0.1267942339,
-0.5594517589,
0.0818618089,
0.1028739661,
0.8134521842,
-0.4185732007,
0.0208914187,
-0.1911582947,
0.0501390547,
-0.0046484871,
-0.5671379566,
0.3774139285,
-0.0378397815,
-0.3849911392,
-0.0722846165,
0.6378874183,
-0.4671745598,
-0.5832973719,
0.4815282822,
0.5037215948,
0.1488771141,
-0.0265624002,
-0.8937637806,
0.1298922747,
-0.0470122211,
0.1702770591,
0.1869819462,
0.0095371138,
-0.2754328549,
1.0821251869,
0.3936229646,
0.4027560949,
0.0844844133,
0.4493736625,
0.3005627394,
-0.6501492262,
-0.577978611,
-0.8697241545,
-0.0249351356,
-0.3223928809,
-0.3916542828,
0.8089647293,
0.462541014,
0.8483327031,
0.1431170702,
0.9396561384,
0.0625917986,
0.4940854013,
-0.4489260614,
0.8199176788,
-0.4360854924,
0.0503742509,
-0.5878337622,
-1.2340550423,
-0.2992866933,
0.864271462,
-0.6681479216,
0.6516550779,
0.4107671082,
0.4562232196,
0.3339926898,
0.2459561974,
0.1173351929,
0.1706848741,
0.4860013723,
0.1393223256,
0.9256808162,
0.0160337351,
0.0049005277,
-0.0799212009,
-0.2301284522,
-0.2473791093,
-0.853908062,
-1.0499007702,
-0.3542575836,
-0.3346982002,
-0.3136947155,
0.2512535453,
1.0883309841,
0.8876200318,
-0.8988543749,
-0.34649086,
0.2549664676,
0.2262150943,
-0.0388760269,
-0.2492676973,
0.1264675409,
-0.1255883276,
-1.0085860491,
0.0998639017,
0.0582061522,
0.0887149051,
-0.6167935133,
0.0441022702,
-0.0616666228,
0.090475738,
0.8079736829,
0.239262864,
-0.5824102163,
-0.2051907629,
-0.4217577875,
0.0073173661,
-0.1406559199,
1.0154052973,
-0.5300546288,
0.4911246896,
0.4964922965,
0.5065329075,
0.171260491,
-0.2015634924,
1.1752233505,
-0.3578312099,
0.3430196345,
0.4913664758,
0.5614712238,
0.5686289072,
-0.0214669686,
0.5455159545,
0.1998626739,
-0.5417446494,
-0.9177571535,
0.2943493724,
-0.3905674219,
-0.5601765513,
1.3130441904,
0.2366514653,
0.0097746607,
-0.31768924,
-0.0939884633,
0.1401156038,
-0.4300508797,
1.0054104328,
0.7184630036,
0.08346726,
-0.0666896999,
-1.0650410652,
0.6651006341,
0.5438389182,
-0.788596034,
-0.1014813632,
0.6918906569,
0.0969236419,
0.1925796121,
0.4657056928,
-0.0756963342,
0.1827874929,
0.059734825,
0.3921136856,
0.2394439131,
-0.3559654951,
-0.2378462851,
0.0350920483,
0.3670655489,
0.225425154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14652v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14652v2
|
One Pass Streaming Algorithm for Super Long Token Attention Approximation in Sublinear Space
| 2023-11-24T18:35:00 | 2024-02-05T18:30:30 |
Raghav Addanki, Chenyang Li, Zhao Song, Chiwun Yang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Attention computation takes both the time complexity of $O(n^2)$ and the
space complexity of $O(n^2)$ simultaneously, which makes deploying Large
Language Models (LLMs) in streaming applications that involve long contexts
requiring substantial computational resources. In recent OpenAI DevDay (Nov 6,
2023), OpenAI released a new model that is able to support a 128K-long
document, in our paper, we focus on the memory-efficient issue when context
length $n$ is much greater than 128K ($n \gg 2^d$). Considering a single-layer
self-attention with Query, Key, and Value matrices $Q, K, V \in \mathbb{R}^{n
\times d}$, the polynomial method approximates the attention output $T \in
\mathbb{R}^{n \times d}$. It accomplishes this by constructing $U_1, U_2 \in
\mathbb{R}^{n \times t}$ to expedite attention ${\sf Attn}(Q, K, V)$
computation within $n^{1+o(1)}$ time executions. Despite this, computing the
approximated attention matrix $U_1U_2^\top \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times n}$ still
necessitates $O(n^2)$ space, leading to significant memory usage. In response
to these challenges, we introduce a new algorithm that only reads one pass of
the data in a streaming fashion. This method employs sublinear space $o(n)$ to
store three sketch matrices, alleviating the need for exact $K, V$ storage.
Notably, our algorithm exhibits exceptional memory-efficient performance with
super-long tokens. As the token length $n$ increases, our error guarantee
diminishes while the memory usage remains nearly constant. This unique
attribute underscores the potential of our technique in efficiently handling
LLMs in streaming applications.
|
[
-0.4253272712,
-0.5757650733,
0.7028409243,
0.235742256,
-0.6668339372,
0.0448123477,
-0.0138310594,
-0.3179131448,
0.6876843572,
0.4235202968,
-0.8464459181,
-0.2211401463,
-0.5489647985,
-0.3678243458,
-0.523684442,
0.6510875821,
-0.0088428771,
-0.1376477033,
-0.0188783966,
-0.4472100139,
-0.1371550113,
-0.584338069,
-0.716745913,
-0.0271251556,
0.7633072734,
0.1713892668,
0.5469171405,
0.6335965991,
0.6249457002,
0.1670200527,
-0.2200357914,
0.1581144035,
-0.8971031308,
-0.0009319833,
0.2063298225,
-0.2807136178,
-0.5145266056,
-0.1476393789,
1.0111334324,
0.5461018682,
0.0786988884,
0.4422819316,
-0.0333827361,
0.8650407791,
-0.7189816236,
-0.2103699297,
-0.343983233,
0.3320371807,
-0.4624983966,
-0.4249642193,
-0.4527199864,
-0.0569809675,
0.0860217288,
-0.7737933397,
-0.0684738532,
0.0549674742,
0.6849035025,
0.5160495043,
0.2198678106,
0.1812445819,
-0.5322319269,
0.8960534334,
-0.9323929548,
0.4366519749,
0.2196952254,
0.3982770145,
-0.3321377337,
-0.8834937811,
-0.6882225871,
0.090039812,
0.2351918519,
0.2708898187,
-0.179705888,
0.0661834702,
0.3580168188,
0.0840024278,
-0.4270116389,
-0.0723607019,
-0.5247816443,
0.1823864132,
0.5114364028,
0.2615958452,
-0.029994186,
-0.0552250743,
-0.7116955519,
0.2739416063,
-0.5631753802,
-0.0613198951,
0.3122614324,
0.1128290743,
-0.0273127519,
0.2430562079,
-0.2358656079,
0.3919920623,
-0.0701195374,
-0.0342569388,
-0.1188260168,
-0.2639914453,
-0.303306818,
-0.0986051038,
0.6472390294,
0.2411591262,
0.2775324285,
-0.1256301254,
0.1706308573,
-0.1813644916,
0.3990527689,
-0.7379159927,
-0.0279792249,
0.4187665582,
-0.522685349,
0.4737125933,
-0.114180401,
-0.8423523307,
-0.3162722588,
-0.2534231544,
0.277854532,
-0.46637398,
-0.0305414405,
-0.0533499233,
0.1811340898,
0.4253986478,
0.3644718528,
-0.7740126252,
0.4879236817,
0.7737799883,
1.184010148,
-0.2700720727,
-0.4377162755,
-0.8630946875,
-0.0333289132,
-0.409008503,
0.7580114007,
-0.5789289474,
0.031959381,
-0.3155346513,
-0.5618368387,
-0.2804335058,
-0.3094183505,
0.2612678111,
-0.9000638127,
-0.1781228334,
-0.0554679073,
-0.6398854852,
-0.1304517388,
-0.1571936309,
-0.6832690835,
0.9288763404,
0.26531744,
-0.8810282946,
0.1742703915,
-0.911231339,
-0.1036073491,
0.3360905051,
0.0206661988,
-0.2145285904,
0.2353893965,
0.2769124806,
0.4910612106,
-0.0289074965,
-0.3090898693,
-0.4012373388,
-0.8449261785,
0.1213259771,
-0.4676730931,
0.6007965803,
0.4137553275,
-0.1829591244,
0.2495573312,
-0.3738705218,
0.191501379,
0.0496769138,
-0.3368320167,
-0.1587388813,
0.0565787032,
0.1913226843,
0.0378955789,
0.1123340651,
-0.6851705313,
0.2618252337,
-0.4125337303,
0.6075643301,
0.9217475057,
-0.0425630622,
0.3819232881,
0.1230615526,
0.7663360834,
-0.0882127061,
0.3914580345,
-0.5849204659,
-0.1541484892,
-0.7706007957,
-0.5099220276,
0.6072625518,
0.2166785896,
-0.4252068102,
-0.0892272219,
-0.5142481327,
-0.3605529368,
-0.5885501504,
0.2864490151,
0.3934118152,
0.0877801403,
0.4585338533,
-0.1734580845,
-0.6158882976,
-0.6966867447,
-0.1439075172,
0.0952142105,
0.0914784521,
0.3152587116,
0.2237945497,
-0.1191537529,
0.9489399791,
-0.5897957087,
-0.410047859,
-0.391923368,
-0.2066692561,
0.3551191986,
0.3099419177,
0.5830268264,
-0.6403662562,
-0.6746583581,
-0.2106657028,
-0.5874235034,
0.1284184158,
-0.2501310408,
-0.2397977263,
0.5512064099,
0.7973482013,
-0.6678749919,
0.8256744742,
0.592798233,
-0.240484044,
0.0525292158,
-0.1882799715,
-0.2721154094,
-0.868819654,
0.0757311732,
-0.2663157284,
-0.3018980026,
-0.6496409178,
0.1995176226,
-0.0783250779,
0.0269716121,
-0.7498916388,
0.7021687627,
-0.5364121795,
-0.0406334512,
-0.3525800705,
0.1921580583,
-0.3954293132,
0.8679080606,
-0.0700110868,
0.5436546803,
0.4515182674,
-0.4179453552,
0.127603218,
-0.0275844671,
-0.1647545397,
0.4900797904,
-0.581410706,
0.4755535126,
-0.574017942,
0.5705155134,
-1.3563600779,
-0.1024066135,
0.2277910858,
-0.5195525885,
0.3345709443,
-0.1493979692,
-0.3817520738,
-0.2885715961,
-0.3701075912,
0.7847785354,
0.3800773919,
-0.7207587361,
0.8216539025,
0.5377432108,
-0.2059489787,
-0.6092190146,
-0.7203887105,
0.1598552614,
-0.0567370728,
-0.4390758574,
0.1334613115,
-0.0339156501,
0.2293580323,
0.0604379103,
-0.3570980728,
0.0647641942,
-0.2429477274,
0.2454508245,
0.1208712012,
-0.1943558455,
-0.1818086952,
-0.054894831,
-0.3111614287,
-0.1332276016,
-0.403104037,
0.7958226204,
0.1122430712,
-0.2858843207,
-0.7874398828,
0.7790742517,
0.8305450082,
0.0459451079,
0.6429482102,
0.6242075562,
-0.472489655,
-0.2647264004,
-0.4899973273,
0.1119123325,
-0.4032566249,
0.4058747888,
-0.455971539,
-0.9161147475,
0.8795611262,
0.4225495756,
0.3287206292,
0.3484663963,
0.3220513761,
-0.2188338935,
0.9753466845,
0.4476414621,
-0.3227505684,
0.7151573896,
-0.5861593485,
0.4376130104,
-1.2379834652,
-0.1274361461,
-0.1176640615,
-0.785256505,
-0.1579584777,
-0.6869606376,
0.3978974223,
0.1318985075,
-0.0602318235,
0.2709050477,
-0.1773895323,
0.6931596398,
0.5953646302,
0.134964779,
-0.0736347437,
0.1080092713,
-0.2099758536,
-0.1081331223,
-1.1099767685,
-0.0741616711,
1.0438462496,
0.6257100701,
0.9461445212,
-0.0173755176,
0.5198540688,
0.3435279429,
0.4041914344,
-0.6849185824,
0.7404733896,
-0.2202148139,
-0.347050637,
-0.6444050074,
-0.4161660969,
-0.7626770139,
0.2692250311,
0.488882333,
-1.0128799677,
0.0465750396,
0.1594360173,
-0.6108424067,
0.604064405,
-0.6819812059,
0.6516829133,
0.2218901217,
-0.393178612,
-0.2630507052,
-0.8047557473,
0.1974725276,
0.052556593,
-0.074514471,
0.0105037922,
-0.0605889745,
1.0436470509,
-0.5278114676,
0.5933348536,
-0.5384965539,
0.2110055536,
0.5497895479,
-0.005002819,
0.414906919,
0.087802574,
0.2965444922,
0.2975867391,
0.1272263229,
-0.8226694465,
-0.7228118181,
0.6684612036,
-0.6010479331,
-0.3609423637,
-0.3930373788,
-0.4358980656,
-0.1607217491,
0.073658891,
0.1379840374,
0.5832515359,
0.1865024567,
0.3297722042,
0.6894003749,
0.0440615118,
0.7655004859,
-0.0141464844,
-0.2828722894,
-0.4394128621,
0.8062485456,
0.4121303558,
0.2645071447,
0.4642641246,
0.0523062758,
-0.6070036292,
-0.5743382573,
-0.5320166349,
0.398617357,
-0.7414549589,
-0.2248625457,
-0.7917028666,
-0.4134330153,
-0.3551518619,
-0.0186110158,
-0.5143727064,
-0.3070031703,
-0.2086048126,
0.0685927719,
0.2556310296,
0.423989296,
0.0065049054,
0.3807382584,
-0.7349447608,
0.4778004587,
0.2551122308,
0.6636694074,
0.4062742591,
-0.8707011938,
-0.4347808063,
-0.2305579931,
0.0614627264,
-0.5685082674,
0.1736513823,
0.1852645576,
0.758965373,
0.569408834,
-0.0589065962,
0.9974035025,
-0.5857183337,
0.7024596334,
0.1086611897,
-0.8793892264,
0.1379008591,
-0.2265827507,
0.7936614752,
0.7412768602,
0.2978997827,
-0.6001901627,
-0.2463060915,
-0.3690072596,
-1.0159804821,
1.0451681614,
0.2442762554,
0.4682502747,
0.0210684389,
0.5227752924,
-0.1917834282,
-0.1251139939,
-0.2826623023,
-0.3387141228,
-0.1871325523,
-0.1435978115,
-0.1758513749,
-0.4979834557,
0.3044646084,
-0.2116292268,
0.453474313,
-0.4221231639,
0.8396435976,
0.4793117344,
0.0197074749,
-0.1722147316,
0.1152686253,
0.855741322,
0.8262955546,
-0.2528342307,
0.2292192429,
0.2827366292,
-0.8497390151,
-0.1545050889,
-0.1318227649,
-0.1406727433,
-0.0201709718,
0.3132152557,
0.8839497566,
0.2455465347,
-0.7905500531,
0.4931979179,
-0.1245106459,
-0.2806329727,
-0.2338338196,
-0.0886312202,
0.1569289416,
0.2712427676,
0.6717346907,
0.0089818221,
-0.1208215803,
-0.2434750646,
0.0730052814,
0.2866929471,
-0.7186213732,
-0.1756086051,
0.8430264592,
-0.1779897511,
-0.2691831589,
0.5357677341,
-0.0073184664,
-0.6234241128,
0.3029868007,
0.3726279736,
1.0649981499,
-0.0508659072,
-0.0843492895,
0.184626624,
0.1482753456,
0.2288110256,
0.4535600841,
-0.312813282,
-0.2880347669,
-0.6553016305,
-0.9780464172,
-0.3776987493,
0.3213012516,
-0.2776865959,
-0.2955333292,
-0.7713074088,
-0.0763510838,
0.1204008013,
-0.0571550541,
-0.3654144108,
0.0206105653,
0.3209851384,
1.2485845089,
-0.2998060882,
0.7404523492,
0.385024488,
0.0822816715,
-0.6416634321,
0.0737785548,
-0.2749772668,
-0.4654842019,
0.5432819724,
0.1771071702,
-0.2974414825,
-0.0431833789,
-0.4715169966,
-1.0622127056,
0.8751098514,
0.3214880526,
-0.5410193205,
0.048882179,
0.1143777519,
0.6455375552,
-0.4427573383,
0.1864637434,
0.4973495603,
0.3075926602,
0.4050971866,
-0.6265048981,
-0.0205074549,
-0.3625190854,
0.1349172443,
0.2360545099,
-1.1295214891,
0.7886648774,
-0.2888935208,
-0.4616454244,
0.1070139632,
1.1617795229,
0.2716826499,
0.2567108274,
0.5693764091,
0.7843466997,
0.3775007427,
0.1567116082,
1.0444818735,
-0.0893386826,
0.4601194561,
1.0195474625,
-0.1481157541,
1.0562452078,
0.9192134738,
-0.4322270751,
0.2927351594,
0.4583583772,
0.4005893171,
0.5754070878,
0.3893977702,
0.0090915794,
-0.2497913837,
-0.0306950472,
-0.0697686821,
0.3678410947,
0.1703698933,
-0.1993257999,
-0.3086297214,
-0.0526820682,
0.0190055259,
-0.1675954759,
-0.5948354006,
0.4659141898,
0.0961670727,
-0.8538922071,
0.6228122711,
-0.1833491623,
0.5096856356,
-0.5898202062,
0.0475886129,
-0.5350820422,
0.3043244183,
-0.1697138399,
-0.6502793431,
0.2963353097,
0.0324641131,
-0.1038449183,
-0.1540121287,
0.5359534621,
-0.2350358665,
-0.4081499875,
0.2991116345,
0.0750799179,
0.3063885272,
-0.1722635925,
-0.4179510474,
0.1617356688,
-0.2377119809,
-0.6670896411,
0.3909020424,
-0.0762967691,
-0.0099892458,
0.7595738173,
0.5791199803,
0.0585589074,
0.7340390086,
0.1203703731,
0.9351593256,
-0.5706611872,
-0.9489529729,
-0.774948597,
0.1751472652,
0.1105553135,
-0.5266619921,
0.5859790444,
0.6643323898,
0.7090703249,
0.1206472889,
0.569121778,
0.0008200119,
0.5403386354,
-0.7273744941,
0.4339540899,
-0.6682353616,
-0.0003769249,
-0.2475354671,
-1.0083687305,
-0.4352133572,
0.3770051003,
-0.2612199187,
0.1068964377,
0.714106679,
0.5442385674,
-0.3171265125,
0.0644972995,
0.3581338525,
0.1114945039,
0.066375114,
0.9663000107,
0.815942347,
-0.6333686113,
0.5724435449,
0.0491044745,
-0.1957929879,
-0.3313667476,
-0.6133203506,
-0.9312605262,
-0.3986280262,
-0.1361668408,
-0.09059266,
-0.0848341137,
0.7597719431,
1.0672827959,
-0.7371153235,
0.1660642177,
0.0085579166,
-0.1109477058,
-0.2779910266,
-0.2282199413,
0.7617217898,
-0.2244546115,
-0.7973119617,
0.2707160115,
0.6849226356,
-0.1400260776,
-0.7192114592,
-0.2093675435,
-0.4183928967,
0.5464839935,
0.4784776866,
0.3679974079,
-0.7277776599,
-0.3175861537,
0.3072379529,
-0.0872459933,
0.1174139231,
0.8465420604,
-0.8115442395,
0.4308268428,
0.7809587121,
0.9290427566,
0.9112203717,
0.1647611707,
-0.1163303405,
-0.5774987936,
-0.0301080514,
0.2181022167,
0.2008430958,
-0.0011135073,
-0.43626827,
0.506331563,
0.1873399168,
-0.4688712955,
-0.8701275587,
0.1075398773,
-1.4508203268,
-0.1857607067,
0.9487189054,
-0.4093396962,
-0.6398486495,
-0.0911705494,
-0.2356037349,
-0.0851413384,
-0.3844314218,
0.6374590993,
0.5827764273,
-0.4357212186,
-0.4212777019,
-0.6870860457,
0.3031385243,
0.6287781596,
-0.4358943105,
0.2532395422,
-0.0191771369,
0.0763354823,
0.3037031293,
1.0639035702,
-0.0741376728,
0.5772222877,
0.0406551957,
-0.4591922164,
-0.1767966449,
-0.6907798052,
-0.4107463062,
0.4599228501,
-0.5165515542,
-0.3516699374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14648v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14648v3
|
Calibrated Language Models Must Hallucinate
| 2023-11-24T18:29:50 | 2024-03-20T02:21:20 |
Adam Tauman Kalai, Santosh S. Vempala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent language models generate false but plausible-sounding text with
surprising frequency. Such "hallucinations" are an obstacle to the usability of
language-based AI systems and can harm people who rely upon their outputs. This
work shows that there is an inherent statistical lower-bound on the rate that
pretrained language models hallucinate certain types of facts, having nothing
to do with the transformer LM architecture or data quality. For "arbitrary"
facts whose veracity cannot be determined from the training data, we show that
hallucinations must occur at a certain rate for language models that satisfy a
statistical calibration condition appropriate for generative language models.
Specifically, if the maximum probability of any fact is bounded, we show that
the probability of generating a hallucination is close to the fraction of facts
that occur exactly once in the training data (a "Good-Turing" estimate), even
assuming ideal training data without errors.
One conclusion is that models pretrained to be sufficiently good predictors
(i.e., calibrated) may require post-training to mitigate hallucinations on the
type of arbitrary facts that tend to appear once in the training set. However,
our analysis also suggests that there is no statistical reason that pretraining
will lead to hallucination on facts that tend to appear more than once in the
training data (like references to publications such as articles and books,
whose hallucinations have been particularly notable and problematic) or on
systematic facts (like arithmetic calculations). Therefore, different
architectures and learning algorithms may mitigate these latter types of
hallucinations.
|
[
-0.2867940366,
-0.6341469288,
0.6999922395,
0.0431067646,
-0.0562809929,
-0.4129241407,
-0.1918194145,
-0.4752686322,
0.2068063915,
0.8562720418,
-0.3523049057,
-0.2072626799,
-0.5976330638,
-0.1512718499,
-0.559057951,
1.0131938457,
0.3550805449,
0.2644796073,
-0.1904371977,
0.0259928498,
-0.6187058091,
-0.9683248997,
-0.1318805963,
-0.4611832798,
0.2073525041,
-0.0087627126,
1.0371574163,
0.319108963,
0.3995574713,
0.2873689532,
0.388659507,
0.0593034178,
-0.6257947087,
0.2028199136,
0.1623107195,
-0.9418187141,
-0.2340708822,
0.1220645681,
0.286647141,
1.0000935793,
-0.2072861344,
-0.29622823,
-0.0053236778,
0.8021092415,
-0.4305649698,
0.1145368293,
-0.8081968427,
0.2447500229,
-0.0143703874,
-0.5271285176,
-0.7984167933,
-0.7538611293,
0.1213472113,
-0.490401417,
0.660734117,
0.0387607552,
0.7600063086,
0.6896691918,
0.0420511439,
-0.462192744,
-0.8843653798,
0.6753740907,
-0.5132291913,
0.5801067948,
0.7346954346,
0.3018931448,
-0.1103256717,
-0.3697031736,
-0.5118727088,
-0.5768028498,
-0.1396330446,
-0.3090623915,
0.0575861894,
0.0357874073,
0.6745426059,
0.2522658706,
-0.6878196597,
-0.1244190484,
-0.5180347562,
-0.5182967186,
0.3947114646,
0.1370890737,
0.3420810997,
-0.024871137,
0.0647109002,
-0.3402818441,
-0.7363688946,
-0.3810959458,
0.6634628773,
0.3659152687,
0.1350279003,
0.5898080468,
0.09075322,
0.5063949227,
0.0000942695,
-0.057110589,
0.5203394294,
-0.0447337516,
-0.0690616518,
0.4714155495,
0.6547673941,
0.1596029401,
0.7523194551,
-0.6124392152,
-0.2538447678,
0.5345618725,
0.6333055496,
-0.8803284764,
-0.5029501319,
0.1291860938,
-0.1193175912,
-0.3033774197,
0.1987154633,
-0.7177008986,
-0.4760195017,
-0.3831755817,
0.6106687188,
-0.4264844656,
-0.0917686597,
0.2823123038,
0.0144477794,
0.1346191764,
0.2958621383,
-0.9114847779,
0.2157698572,
0.4274523258,
0.6169233322,
0.0263942946,
-0.4268015623,
-0.4348745048,
-0.3025815785,
-0.6386905313,
0.7546656728,
-0.3328000903,
-0.2256503552,
0.0648441687,
0.0123129338,
-0.0326135755,
-0.6441285014,
0.2043336779,
-0.457449466,
0.185338974,
-0.3379439414,
-0.3225810528,
-0.2205454409,
-0.1652302295,
-0.7269946933,
0.6457255483,
-0.0813426599,
-0.5639590025,
0.5142771006,
-0.0464134254,
-0.6144501567,
-0.0554624349,
-0.4277423322,
-0.2828000188,
0.3279269636,
-0.2357887626,
0.3153889775,
-0.1222778186,
0.6308181882,
-0.1191173792,
-0.526067853,
0.4018101096,
-0.7446833849,
0.7066722512,
0.2760519683,
-0.6016379595,
-0.140047133,
-0.7727993131,
-0.0684842244,
-0.1309024841,
-0.0500032045,
-0.1862912774,
0.260592252,
-0.1578476876,
-0.0156235127,
-0.0455410369,
-0.2826986313,
-0.0569107011,
-0.6023333669,
0.0107602356,
0.6460875273,
-0.2342985719,
0.2718968689,
-0.8441565037,
0.2723944187,
-0.0511492565,
-0.0906832665,
-0.1334348768,
-0.2967763245,
-0.9102832675,
0.0616410002,
-0.0762433708,
0.6164880991,
-0.6550450921,
0.5043345094,
-0.3485343158,
-0.5958015323,
-0.5218034387,
-0.142249614,
0.1692957431,
0.468551904,
0.3215475082,
-0.334679544,
-0.5380845666,
-0.6266723275,
-0.2359424531,
-0.2455049604,
-0.0314472616,
0.0862845108,
0.4033346772,
-0.1786217391,
0.6810600758,
-0.3156271875,
-0.4111930728,
0.081432119,
0.3860340118,
0.0904833451,
0.3865077794,
0.3958156109,
-0.6590013504,
-0.0704153255,
-0.268376559,
-0.9581030607,
-0.1062837392,
-0.3702424467,
0.1917024404,
0.4688846171,
0.3445747495,
-0.6619511247,
0.6958667636,
0.333709389,
-0.1296790689,
0.6232005358,
-0.4184630811,
0.3322210908,
-0.7119515538,
0.0054306258,
-0.1737587452,
-0.1320679188,
-0.8214506507,
-0.2294759154,
-0.3172425628,
0.0726452991,
-0.2688643634,
0.313531369,
-0.1376124322,
0.0264925361,
-0.4119789898,
0.0469363816,
-0.1809046417,
0.3650587201,
0.2820125222,
0.6964091659,
0.5097571611,
-0.7337827682,
0.2097124904,
0.1261954904,
-0.675837338,
0.2027571648,
-0.4429144859,
0.0934171379,
-0.3474558592,
0.0483570285,
-0.654086709,
-0.3359850049,
0.1069743335,
-0.5162981749,
0.0330204107,
0.5301142335,
-0.5028870106,
-0.0640931278,
-0.1731792539,
0.4578238428,
0.6239798069,
-0.522170186,
0.4272676408,
0.4439305961,
0.3687701821,
-0.5413523912,
-0.922952354,
-0.1020828784,
-0.0271763261,
-0.3614408374,
0.0804215893,
-0.3028349578,
-0.1222833693,
-0.1560296267,
-0.0237519313,
0.1321423799,
-0.0234713629,
0.688775897,
0.2169407457,
-0.1399598271,
0.1312805712,
-0.2911979258,
-0.1576434523,
0.374820292,
0.1056698263,
0.9219602346,
-0.0484148748,
-0.5566515326,
-0.518802762,
0.0063827583,
0.5945204496,
0.2472619563,
0.8190159798,
0.3890881836,
-0.746900022,
-0.1393173635,
-0.8580619097,
-0.6319591403,
-0.4035458565,
0.5453920364,
-0.4490889013,
-0.5247206092,
0.4086154401,
0.5038222075,
-0.1468509883,
0.4850176871,
0.7140587568,
0.2042099088,
1.1802250147,
0.4154569209,
-0.0391302109,
0.1400263757,
-0.0732044354,
0.4680432081,
-0.2631465793,
-0.404142797,
-0.6959614754,
0.1793081164,
-0.9415707588,
-0.1932879835,
0.0856874436,
-0.171709463,
-0.2339845896,
0.2872493565,
-0.5351198912,
0.5613237023,
0.572914362,
0.1891593635,
0.1598688662,
0.2006743103,
0.1417291015,
-0.231840238,
-0.6020784974,
-0.5529615283,
1.0842169523,
0.1748700142,
1.1036973,
-0.1699819416,
0.4353094995,
0.42312482,
0.4122391641,
-0.5922714472,
0.4205473959,
-0.0749242976,
-0.8470653892,
-0.4174185395,
-0.6381276846,
-0.6900170445,
0.0596079864,
-0.188010484,
-0.8512939811,
0.3476767838,
0.2420252562,
-0.3207743168,
0.3035489619,
-0.5140237212,
0.637434721,
-0.3653658926,
-0.1178727001,
-0.2469357997,
-0.5038337708,
0.4642289877,
-0.4499605596,
0.300470531,
-0.1543767303,
0.606048882,
0.7329518199,
-0.4486872256,
0.9025322795,
-0.143533498,
0.0391485915,
0.1523039192,
0.2564205229,
0.4666665792,
-0.2554913461,
-0.1225434467,
0.1393693537,
0.3614273667,
-0.23742944,
-0.6038604379,
0.3987384737,
-0.9480201006,
-0.8184481263,
-0.7704207897,
-0.5369719267,
-0.1970264316,
-0.0745281503,
0.7636094689,
0.3702025115,
-0.2136491686,
0.2089106292,
0.7325581908,
-0.2201092541,
0.0372665897,
0.1142676994,
-0.3834854364,
-0.2553951442,
1.2399804592,
0.2556569278,
0.4598263204,
0.1024995595,
-0.0703977197,
-0.2163962424,
-0.4103915095,
-0.0411145091,
0.3938615918,
-0.8827783465,
-0.006218248,
-0.6156684756,
-0.5783448815,
-0.4360165596,
-0.0780221298,
-0.3469442725,
-0.3486292064,
-0.4641917646,
-0.0201550107,
0.0727166831,
0.5796009302,
-0.2005947977,
0.3761099875,
-0.4333246052,
0.4345244765,
0.2131330669,
0.1676079631,
0.052344013,
-0.7416724563,
-0.179626435,
0.3394132555,
-0.125448063,
-0.8346145749,
0.3691797554,
0.1382177472,
0.5408993959,
0.6593538523,
0.1935132295,
0.5822510719,
-0.5393277407,
0.5699385405,
0.2672662139,
-0.6553411484,
0.3751738369,
0.2433203459,
0.0939358249,
0.748505652,
0.6489160061,
-0.4532122314,
-0.5750115514,
-0.41003111,
-0.3532360792,
0.7224977612,
0.0330498107,
0.6295012236,
-0.1722600609,
0.3255534768,
0.3588942289,
0.2754199803,
-0.9964982271,
-0.2465103418,
-0.5042570829,
-0.1142035052,
-0.232932955,
-0.3232347071,
-0.0098279305,
-0.3269662857,
0.8012464046,
0.1256843358,
0.2255928963,
-0.0028776624,
-0.540258348,
-0.3093596697,
-0.0755198151,
0.6776486039,
0.7674270868,
-0.4112401605,
0.3687088788,
0.0739969239,
-0.6415038109,
0.3161816597,
0.0115858847,
-0.3856532872,
-0.0369482227,
0.4267467558,
1.0674288273,
0.146314159,
-0.7044483423,
0.5235165954,
-0.1048423722,
-0.2100407481,
-0.457213372,
0.4773189723,
-0.4934627414,
0.0035931538,
0.3179151118,
0.3023476303,
-0.0618435517,
-0.6907148957,
0.3487558067,
0.5595493913,
-0.5471448898,
-0.650146544,
0.9333916903,
-0.1950350702,
-0.5567244291,
0.7723834515,
-0.0889725238,
-0.7691238523,
0.3205961287,
0.54743433,
0.8496828675,
-0.5017188191,
0.3598454893,
0.4430671036,
0.6599873304,
-0.4595033228,
0.0739225522,
0.0814607516,
-0.9714265466,
-0.2626706064,
-0.9598634243,
-0.1600045711,
0.3656170368,
-0.47299546,
0.3881454468,
-0.2212794423,
-0.3020838499,
0.0079412181,
-0.1908876747,
-0.676413238,
0.3156085014,
0.1774999797,
0.4858725369,
-1.0888909101,
0.768429935,
-0.1006674767,
-0.4761969149,
-0.4387482405,
-0.0050130929,
-0.2298371345,
-0.6801869273,
0.4679285586,
0.4420310557,
-0.1950788498,
-0.0339823253,
-0.2902474105,
-0.5667785406,
0.5193402171,
0.687779367,
-0.394700408,
-0.3602653742,
0.7056270838,
0.5999820232,
-0.3169457614,
0.2146861702,
0.5874658823,
0.4428534806,
0.1533241868,
-0.5991018414,
0.1475081295,
-0.0139474478,
-0.1691165864,
0.0102411527,
-0.0631037876,
0.7320891023,
-0.4390261173,
-0.3140800595,
0.0430367216,
0.4840391278,
0.1792854071,
0.2137377858,
0.5392754078,
0.5538754463,
0.804880023,
-0.1566444188,
0.9469992518,
-0.5082969666,
0.1216565222,
1.0072790384,
-0.2292705774,
0.5907698274,
0.4888372421,
-0.2470285147,
0.2628723383,
0.6133075953,
-0.1125214398,
0.6672406793,
0.3059082925,
-0.1044144034,
-0.353335768,
0.0290796123,
-0.5861088037,
0.3094763458,
0.1902012527,
-0.3005361557,
0.0318206251,
0.2214906514,
-0.1000223234,
-0.0372379012,
0.2419220954,
0.4430059791,
0.0829708204,
-0.8132804632,
0.7627498507,
-0.4194506705,
0.3349895179,
-0.4278185666,
0.0218395032,
-0.2177276611,
-0.0618306436,
-0.238160938,
-0.16928868,
0.445966512,
-0.1254692823,
-0.2188716233,
-0.049248714,
0.3748542666,
-0.2987875342,
-0.5030702949,
0.177401796,
0.4570028484,
0.5997763872,
-0.2755613923,
-0.043518398,
0.105832018,
0.0360810906,
-0.3324691355,
0.2191617191,
0.3347803056,
0.1321528107,
0.5580426455,
0.53228724,
0.3740541339,
0.2287013531,
0.2427624762,
0.5501973629,
-0.4939091206,
-0.287190944,
-0.9512921572,
0.1913091838,
0.2865580618,
-0.1310702711,
0.4493307173,
0.5881623626,
0.7946794629,
-0.0227161106,
0.5983332396,
0.2058542669,
0.1255855858,
-0.5434518456,
1.050538063,
-0.5622676015,
0.4482166469,
-0.0651547834,
-1.1767838001,
-0.3630923927,
0.9231693745,
-0.4184324741,
0.2577842474,
0.8409425616,
1.0807642937,
0.1745067984,
0.282182157,
0.7435148358,
0.2981588244,
0.1307460368,
0.3367283344,
0.7142467499,
-0.3819817901,
0.3642545938,
-0.4901157916,
-0.1827704906,
-0.3246435523,
-0.5964357257,
-0.96806252,
-1.0108393431,
-0.2705922425,
-0.5897641778,
0.0179749988,
0.6967918277,
0.6985286474,
-1.0098639727,
-0.2889786065,
-0.2330898046,
0.0192859415,
0.2026088387,
-0.2243079692,
0.3109476566,
-0.5645487309,
-0.5689897537,
-0.0403488502,
0.0739586055,
0.2878252268,
-0.5086595416,
-0.1921114028,
0.2173177451,
0.34357059,
0.3723748922,
0.2701975703,
-0.8416021466,
-0.4859854281,
-0.0520764627,
-0.3076094091,
0.226324901,
0.6160350442,
-0.9846836329,
0.6011794209,
0.3488855064,
0.5071448088,
0.4495544434,
-0.3196600378,
0.2810416222,
-0.2560836375,
0.3529123962,
0.2380239666,
0.1630005091,
0.2929849625,
-0.3878401816,
0.2849740982,
0.3147312999,
-0.5507763028,
-1.3405438662,
0.1135772392,
-0.4384559393,
-0.2290370911,
0.7414764762,
0.3005881011,
-0.2289607078,
0.077859655,
0.0636772513,
0.3868162632,
0.1475893706,
1.3890353441,
0.9586341381,
-0.0591797642,
0.1567543149,
-0.8714075685,
0.8318411708,
0.5297585726,
-0.8537304997,
0.1973003,
0.569026053,
-0.1067764238,
0.4053463936,
0.4947385192,
0.1874221712,
0.3459399641,
0.2123952061,
0.2097996771,
0.2723050416,
-0.7471840978,
-0.159006536,
0.059054561,
0.1084863991,
0.1401069164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14583v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14583v1
|
GPT Struct Me: Probing GPT Models on Narrative Entity Extraction
| 2023-11-24T16:19:04 | 2023-11-24T16:19:04 |
Hugo Sousa, Nuno Guimarães, Alípio Jorge, Ricardo Campos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
The importance of systems that can extract structured information from
textual data becomes increasingly pronounced given the ever-increasing volume
of text produced on a daily basis. Having a system that can effectively extract
such information in an interoperable manner would be an asset for several
domains, be it finance, health, or legal. Recent developments in natural
language processing led to the production of powerful language models that can,
to some degree, mimic human intelligence. Such effectiveness raises a pertinent
question: Can these models be leveraged for the extraction of structured
information? In this work, we address this question by evaluating the
capabilities of two state-of-the-art language models -- GPT-3 and GPT-3.5,
commonly known as ChatGPT -- in the extraction of narrative entities, namely
events, participants, and temporal expressions. This study is conducted on the
Text2Story Lusa dataset, a collection of 119 Portuguese news articles whose
annotation framework includes a set of entity structures along with several
tags and attribute values. We first select the best prompt template through an
ablation study over prompt components that provide varying degrees of
information on a subset of documents of the dataset. Subsequently, we use the
best templates to evaluate the effectiveness of the models on the remaining
documents. The results obtained indicate that GPT models are competitive with
out-of-the-box baseline systems, presenting an all-in-one alternative for
practitioners with limited resources. By studying the strengths and limitations
of these models in the context of information extraction, we offer insights
that can guide future improvements and avenues to explore in this field.
|
[
-0.0594297759,
-1.2062501907,
0.8086397648,
0.0194293186,
-0.3652819395,
0.0190960541,
-0.1228507385,
-0.8398903012,
-0.1079935357,
0.2909203768,
-0.2586770356,
-0.2949411273,
-0.6866372824,
0.0218201913,
-0.4523272216,
1.2833255529,
-0.2011446208,
-0.0314258337,
0.0916464403,
0.1608302891,
-0.4284062982,
-0.6176057458,
-0.7139279842,
-0.1942624897,
0.3721914887,
-0.0654279664,
0.6507796645,
0.6441485286,
0.5277082324,
0.1871839762,
-0.142226994,
-0.1569643468,
-0.3646173179,
0.1355578005,
-0.1359020025,
0.0168946423,
-0.4925912917,
0.3587403893,
0.431351006,
0.5796740055,
-0.282151401,
0.1952235997,
0.220719263,
0.2312903255,
-0.2814178169,
0.5205541253,
-0.5903983116,
-0.0757295713,
-0.1959529072,
-0.2366598099,
-0.2672223151,
-0.5399552584,
0.5649491549,
-0.5447300673,
0.2334399819,
-0.0512209535,
1.0683397055,
0.0127736693,
-0.40464288,
-0.6437717676,
-0.8151807785,
0.2897684276,
-0.475664705,
0.2349275202,
0.2252016217,
0.2044570595,
0.0737774819,
-0.9196898937,
-0.4958171546,
-0.3445641696,
-0.3024713695,
0.318703413,
-0.3590034544,
-0.076642707,
0.3730840981,
0.4736141264,
-0.746753335,
0.0364292637,
-0.5359210372,
-0.0720771477,
0.3781106174,
-0.0579261556,
0.4971230626,
-0.584356308,
-0.4887041748,
0.0027444228,
-0.7333871722,
-0.0523632094,
0.5128615499,
0.1108266339,
0.1046835855,
0.7187393308,
0.0497288294,
0.266169697,
-0.3633216321,
-0.109704189,
-0.1045232266,
-0.4747021198,
-0.3657310903,
0.0290179551,
0.8751158714,
0.0797604546,
0.3409873843,
-0.2904120982,
-0.2385919541,
-0.0495374836,
0.2125138789,
-0.7975739837,
-0.4049255848,
0.1108810976,
-0.6064811945,
-0.3496544659,
0.018822141,
-0.8556349874,
-0.1766833663,
-0.1824625432,
0.3088754714,
-0.6342527866,
-0.4517742097,
-0.0203115437,
-0.245488137,
0.2699241936,
0.2945649624,
-1.0282441378,
0.1889383793,
0.7189745903,
0.9381638765,
-0.2767105401,
0.1663803607,
-0.425597012,
0.2170604169,
-0.1643728316,
0.8090705872,
-0.6960238218,
-0.5048620701,
-0.0282742828,
-0.1358509064,
-0.2369985431,
-0.3287488818,
0.7146615982,
-0.5432138443,
0.4442577958,
-0.1727747172,
-0.6948636174,
0.0148578268,
0.2044536173,
-0.7349438667,
1.0661035776,
0.3613010645,
-0.6078831553,
0.5233810544,
-0.6864035726,
-0.2193472981,
0.3081290722,
-0.4863739014,
-0.4430893064,
0.0415170901,
0.3101519942,
0.3723972738,
-0.5356667638,
0.5890716314,
-0.0765472725,
-0.1149859354,
0.1326572895,
-0.6187998652,
0.6792616248,
0.3408637941,
-0.2011967897,
-0.1827553958,
-0.5634136796,
-0.2745065987,
0.3967287838,
-0.5593873858,
-0.2774644792,
0.1539281756,
0.082322821,
0.0990216434,
-0.0736958683,
-0.4189630747,
0.5820823312,
-0.3020483553,
0.5637229681,
0.5554329753,
0.3666023612,
0.3472541273,
-0.174274087,
0.6086708307,
-0.1699929088,
-0.1293101013,
-0.4037269056,
-0.5857183933,
-0.0837327912,
-0.5072547197,
0.4284131229,
0.6207737327,
-0.8878036141,
0.097796537,
-0.4189619422,
-0.4594734013,
-0.4074989259,
-0.2273678631,
0.201269865,
0.893860817,
0.3313195109,
-0.0479764566,
-0.3818743825,
-0.826690495,
-0.4752057493,
-0.4480131269,
-0.4291628003,
0.1992961913,
0.5630410314,
0.1825809628,
1.0739136934,
-0.4890283942,
0.0369783081,
-0.3912527859,
0.4801769853,
0.3327429891,
0.406273365,
0.5070136786,
-0.9504473805,
-0.157753855,
0.0004351056,
-0.9188658595,
-0.2335479558,
-0.1515753716,
0.2580989301,
0.1005998924,
0.2454316467,
-0.7540630698,
0.6412272453,
0.1643112004,
-0.3726761341,
0.737087369,
-0.0761228874,
0.1323134154,
-0.9045948982,
0.2751083672,
0.0788659751,
-0.1688816398,
-0.7311266661,
-0.0860531554,
0.0904230326,
-0.1259301752,
-0.1964238286,
0.6643768549,
-0.5318955183,
-0.1414189786,
0.0008443766,
0.2163687497,
-0.0111968424,
0.500905633,
0.1739331782,
0.7757788897,
0.0675293505,
-0.3234678507,
0.1108466387,
0.298573941,
-0.507533133,
0.4618831873,
-0.6992291808,
0.2244019061,
-0.1252871454,
0.1367257237,
-0.8173030615,
-0.2795924246,
0.4014492929,
-0.3182984293,
0.3683397472,
-0.3475517631,
-0.6611125469,
-0.1547863781,
-0.0366462693,
-0.0081569199,
0.4072001874,
-0.2793815136,
0.6667785645,
0.5671360493,
-0.736771524,
-0.3069602549,
-0.3152059615,
0.1492899805,
-0.4523613453,
-0.4934877753,
0.2051365823,
0.132171616,
-0.3750536144,
0.1640943885,
-0.2228942811,
-0.0899452269,
0.2529448271,
0.0977735594,
0.6237550378,
-0.3212389648,
0.2634588182,
-0.1194037497,
-0.2163584977,
-0.0514280237,
-0.3580756187,
0.4321023226,
-0.256747812,
-0.3410004973,
-0.2091184407,
0.4336638749,
0.1346142143,
-0.3749120533,
0.6713719368,
0.5646277666,
-0.6101725698,
0.3626396656,
-0.6375377774,
-0.0411266871,
-0.3485773504,
0.4151385427,
-0.3407675028,
-0.8848288059,
0.4528200924,
0.0522009507,
0.0668399259,
0.6588410735,
0.6364148855,
0.0025922328,
0.8161176443,
0.464163661,
-0.0761521533,
0.5932829976,
-0.0807118192,
0.2118408382,
-0.6307780743,
-0.2362146974,
-0.6324602962,
0.0039948826,
-0.4449982345,
0.0288297255,
0.4314514399,
0.2352283001,
0.1234516725,
0.3289865255,
-0.3270699978,
0.4150935411,
0.3586550057,
0.0119502265,
0.5729102492,
-0.0070750583,
0.0066966792,
0.0040669139,
-0.5048844218,
-0.9857955575,
0.9224880934,
0.4369740486,
0.3900943398,
0.086333856,
0.2430067956,
0.1422411203,
0.5723375082,
-0.6119342446,
0.2685515881,
0.0558535531,
-0.590348959,
-0.3463618755,
-0.4490554035,
-0.9442976713,
0.2797024548,
-0.2139899135,
-1.1238371134,
0.3379443884,
-0.2357674539,
-0.4570299685,
0.2734006941,
-0.8632429838,
0.8055800796,
-0.0701577216,
-0.3317026496,
0.2183785588,
-0.5646000504,
0.1854419559,
-0.1721788794,
0.1902982742,
-0.2747032344,
0.0380297378,
0.7165091038,
-0.126162082,
0.5504772067,
-0.1260838211,
-0.1538579911,
0.3953589797,
0.1982253343,
0.716817677,
0.2145969123,
-0.1043920144,
0.2124789059,
0.2084537596,
-0.1603275388,
-0.5265536904,
0.1686962098,
-0.5003943443,
-0.5047257543,
-0.2886762023,
-0.373257935,
-0.0910318345,
0.2028860599,
0.2416440099,
0.6344100237,
-0.4559313953,
0.1165445894,
0.2787232697,
0.042335432,
0.7210299373,
0.5282996893,
-0.0024171646,
-0.1959348917,
0.6151345968,
0.3331175447,
0.0277754609,
0.3236087263,
0.0298098698,
-0.1986439377,
-0.7358332872,
-0.3846052885,
0.0731892362,
-0.5005070567,
-0.1639577001,
-0.8351400495,
-0.2709654272,
-0.3055989742,
0.0886257067,
-0.1578506529,
-0.5519316792,
-0.3848969936,
-0.5461636782,
0.013708692,
0.81430161,
0.1618013829,
0.3039289415,
-0.8982654214,
0.1276904494,
0.2078601569,
0.0750702024,
-0.3286810517,
-0.0291698482,
-0.0444437824,
-0.1965623945,
-0.2407045513,
-1.3655376434,
0.5792405009,
-0.0435931459,
0.5951141119,
0.2155366987,
-0.3087768853,
0.5193064213,
-0.5107865334,
0.7473820448,
-0.2177389115,
-0.7480108738,
0.6119022965,
-0.7884390354,
-0.1654967666,
0.4220089316,
0.435187906,
-0.4849785566,
-0.3761774004,
-0.939201653,
-0.8834708333,
0.5947096944,
0.5092105865,
-0.2381444871,
-0.1748213321,
0.787545085,
0.165762946,
0.2699162066,
-0.754758954,
0.2755931914,
0.027017463,
-0.3068233728,
0.2499578446,
-0.4236112833,
0.082898058,
0.2499874681,
0.4785528481,
-0.0623610169,
0.1943786889,
0.4557789564,
-0.2821675539,
0.1267496645,
0.3530587852,
0.1987291425,
0.7910974622,
-0.2439541668,
0.0895965099,
0.0683634207,
-0.6703981757,
-0.1527606696,
0.4656158984,
-0.1364515871,
-0.1325691491,
0.6103080511,
0.6393305063,
0.2841239572,
-0.5554282069,
0.4885986447,
-0.16775693,
-0.0902291462,
-0.1830165535,
0.0241029747,
-0.0937101468,
0.5350590348,
0.5676407814,
-0.2544925809,
0.2468762696,
-0.573754847,
0.2580435872,
0.3744444549,
-0.3367973864,
-0.4773012698,
0.7224206328,
-0.0804387778,
-0.1987127811,
0.7725532651,
-0.1167797372,
-0.2730590403,
0.5190031528,
0.4748004675,
0.8368036151,
-0.1285379827,
0.190962106,
0.2707381845,
0.5335860848,
-0.182157591,
-0.1054917499,
0.0066248798,
-0.6078597307,
-0.4679262042,
-0.559907496,
-0.3778496087,
0.2493149191,
-0.6958903074,
0.2050967366,
0.0501544066,
-0.0090046274,
0.0414199866,
0.1144354269,
-0.7461339831,
-0.0262299664,
0.0907776207,
0.7567725182,
-0.7643760443,
0.8483296037,
0.386580795,
-0.6885610819,
-0.7659506202,
-0.1488414109,
0.1614218652,
-0.7222827673,
0.2758226991,
0.1112862825,
0.3446062207,
0.0500667654,
-0.4830126166,
-0.6186674237,
1.3408623934,
0.4684074819,
-0.3741550744,
-0.536319077,
-0.0907911509,
0.5927639008,
-0.5391148329,
0.4336769283,
0.9442050457,
0.4069013298,
0.1455612779,
-0.9199112654,
0.0579024293,
-0.3827498853,
-0.1858971268,
0.1489129514,
-0.2287330627,
0.8579954505,
0.0449489243,
-0.5566217303,
0.0033415719,
0.5407813787,
0.2180637717,
0.1570426673,
0.3857863843,
0.2223102301,
0.9850728512,
-0.2947075367,
1.2483452559,
-0.1123969704,
0.4354026318,
1.1470474005,
-0.2671041787,
0.6607685685,
0.2580407858,
-0.0736052096,
0.3040041924,
0.8132250905,
-0.1506596357,
0.3786039948,
-0.1965866983,
-0.1030182689,
0.1115664765,
0.0220030285,
-0.304797709,
0.3435287476,
0.5223609805,
-0.391541332,
-0.2615824938,
-0.1730517,
0.3478595018,
-0.4288609326,
-0.0338931791,
0.992904067,
0.0153901177,
-0.7015181184,
-0.1683787853,
-0.0426883437,
0.0444236323,
-0.7272812724,
-0.1638449878,
-0.2060371339,
-0.235192433,
0.0961681306,
-0.6651699543,
0.4417929649,
0.2892626822,
0.083309263,
-0.44014135,
1.0716266632,
-0.3703964353,
-0.3617784679,
0.10512086,
0.8909674883,
0.1593046933,
-0.3457121253,
-0.3981586099,
-0.2384654433,
-0.145824343,
-0.611677289,
0.2104473859,
0.5328778625,
-0.0158416498,
0.2775933444,
0.724930048,
0.3624332249,
-0.2494971603,
-0.1270011812,
0.9020030499,
-0.6959836483,
-0.5462988019,
-1.2276724577,
0.5017617941,
-0.2198054194,
-0.2293527424,
0.5230647922,
0.6291881204,
0.3991462886,
0.3007332385,
0.8496152163,
-0.0460174829,
0.5162069798,
-0.7849771976,
0.6371564269,
-0.1894023269,
0.4562806189,
-0.3868845701,
-0.9149508476,
-0.0212709773,
0.4036346674,
-0.4401685297,
-0.0345461331,
0.8412497044,
0.4191969037,
0.1312541813,
0.5122953653,
-0.0670810044,
0.2652928829,
0.7308465242,
0.3787612915,
0.8847414851,
-0.1225834861,
0.6722804308,
0.2352147996,
-0.3203342855,
-0.0291608386,
-0.9626501799,
-0.6920531392,
-0.6461163759,
-0.1188341454,
-0.1231146604,
0.1453274786,
0.5947870016,
0.3774672151,
-0.4127551913,
0.1850512773,
0.1456074268,
0.1079477295,
-0.0337745249,
-0.2285303473,
0.6597918272,
-0.1883722693,
-0.5788625479,
0.4176136553,
0.5182400942,
0.3246745467,
0.1277776957,
0.4254268706,
-0.1119406596,
-0.0285785347,
0.4650959671,
0.0930406079,
-0.3085839748,
-0.5832110047,
0.0079752225,
-0.1912520528,
0.2416864336,
0.9617967606,
-0.6802279353,
0.2280288488,
0.3045882285,
0.5229567289,
0.7853643298,
0.1748698801,
0.6456871033,
-0.7283941507,
0.0533956885,
0.1595335752,
0.5276979804,
0.1328958869,
-0.3316461742,
1.0780855417,
0.375836283,
-0.5393363833,
-0.6858570576,
0.0075746258,
-0.7336125374,
-0.2387271076,
1.1508926153,
-0.1086044982,
-0.1354242712,
-0.3222782016,
-0.3188249469,
0.3991237879,
-0.3376204669,
0.6926825047,
0.978724122,
-0.1753430516,
-0.0392305404,
-1.1247752905,
0.4524540603,
-0.1151650026,
-1.0132393837,
0.0182440653,
0.4914551675,
0.1667899936,
0.0734690949,
0.9859233499,
-0.3769076169,
-0.0609292611,
-0.0553509258,
-0.118045263,
-0.1244993508,
-0.1520857662,
-0.263471514,
0.595272541,
-0.4099191129,
0.2618530691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14543v1
|
Data-Efficient Alignment of Large Language Models with Human Feedback Through Natural Language
| 2023-11-24T15:20:36 | 2023-11-24T15:20:36 |
Di Jin, Shikib Mehri, Devamanyu Hazarika, Aishwarya Padmakumar, Sungjin Lee, Yang Liu, Mahdi Namazifar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Learning from human feedback is a prominent technique to align the output of
large language models (LLMs) with human expectations. Reinforcement learning
from human feedback (RLHF) leverages human preference signals that are in the
form of ranking of response pairs to perform this alignment. However, human
preference on LLM outputs can come in much richer forms including natural
language, which may provide detailed feedback on strengths and weaknesses of a
given response. In this work we investigate data efficiency of modeling human
feedback that is in natural language. Specifically, we fine-tune an open-source
LLM, e.g., Falcon-40B-Instruct, on a relatively small amount (1000 records or
even less) of human feedback in natural language in the form of critiques and
revisions of responses. We show that this model is able to improve the quality
of responses from even some of the strongest LLMs such as ChatGPT, BARD, and
Vicuna, through critique and revision of those responses. For instance, through
one iteration of revision of ChatGPT responses, the revised responses have
56.6% win rate over the original ones, and this win rate can be further
improved to 65.9% after applying the revision for five iterations.
|
[
-0.3949353695,
-0.6229667664,
0.2817394137,
0.0555888563,
-0.143811509,
0.0469156466,
-0.7784478664,
-0.5603840947,
0.2289693356,
0.4838680923,
-0.4633336365,
-0.4940525889,
-0.3093992174,
0.0400170721,
-0.2566384971,
1.2101917267,
0.0796880871,
0.1020514369,
-0.0716358498,
-0.1485378593,
-0.4128810167,
-0.6058745384,
-0.6156207919,
-0.4815490544,
0.6124854088,
0.5481069684,
0.794449985,
0.7493336797,
0.708357513,
0.2905524075,
0.0340650044,
0.1495817304,
-0.8759846687,
0.1109902561,
-0.3442085087,
-0.4593558908,
-0.4490597248,
0.0031800182,
0.8366618156,
0.7399153113,
-0.4443114102,
0.1423963904,
0.3602208495,
1.04776299,
-0.3883842826,
0.2855440974,
-0.6826114655,
-0.1114248633,
-0.1540837288,
-0.1350862831,
-0.5381194949,
-0.4594715834,
0.1146220714,
-0.6958985329,
0.2710101306,
0.1451411247,
0.7896624804,
0.3947731555,
-0.1679553688,
-0.3488100171,
-0.8106229305,
0.7799423337,
-0.935104847,
0.4662230015,
0.1768047512,
0.4590135813,
-0.5303776264,
-0.4132805765,
-0.4269415438,
-0.4347658753,
-0.0950031579,
0.1191367507,
-0.1236380935,
0.1064620689,
0.163459152,
0.2463226318,
-0.4510745704,
0.4366890192,
-0.1792179495,
-0.2794248462,
0.9154307842,
0.2461134493,
0.0825379342,
-0.1576187015,
-0.2352365404,
-0.502360642,
-0.6232482195,
0.2644355595,
0.5688206553,
0.6401741505,
0.186018303,
0.6954606771,
-0.3856373131,
0.9122681022,
0.2923205793,
-0.175470531,
0.125726983,
-0.3185856342,
-0.101477854,
-0.0585652441,
0.8488899469,
0.5242696404,
0.2337758392,
-0.3523862362,
-0.4887636602,
0.199279815,
0.550237596,
-0.7524584532,
-0.0721688792,
0.0155297909,
-0.4331563413,
-0.2457357347,
0.3008441031,
-0.7163443565,
-0.6125455499,
-0.5118980408,
0.2630516589,
-0.3701061308,
-0.0204685275,
0.2322183549,
0.1646796316,
0.3223894238,
0.4661535919,
-0.9503656626,
0.3979048729,
0.996091485,
0.6087898612,
-0.1826915741,
-0.2809161246,
-0.9331305027,
-0.1719347686,
-0.4127423763,
0.8899912834,
-0.4693431556,
-0.2844958007,
-0.1557608694,
-0.1004123613,
0.007352232,
-0.6744877696,
0.7506796718,
-0.5483038425,
0.2841270268,
-0.3689684272,
-0.8753303885,
-0.070730567,
0.2337988615,
-0.7546746731,
0.8929235339,
-0.0584178343,
-0.9184536338,
0.3013939261,
-0.742500186,
-0.3826195002,
-0.1405759156,
0.121241726,
-0.5316114426,
0.0255126972,
0.3491975665,
0.3697123826,
-0.1857736707,
0.3150389493,
-0.602725029,
-0.4676299989,
0.3646979928,
-0.2400229424,
0.2160909623,
0.2841081619,
-0.3825668693,
0.3832493126,
-0.5804978609,
0.0945199579,
-0.0322552249,
-0.772264123,
-0.1685384363,
0.0941418186,
0.0585550629,
0.058636453,
-0.0306649003,
-0.6210308075,
0.4382574856,
-0.6591154933,
0.3350284994,
0.7629408836,
-0.0635564178,
0.6000916362,
-0.5980605483,
0.6208615899,
-0.2830065191,
0.0330751911,
0.1468037069,
-0.4043296278,
-0.6268050671,
-0.2273894995,
0.5287925601,
0.2082287073,
-0.4175250232,
0.3279755414,
-0.4750523865,
-0.5189371705,
-0.945751965,
0.3820968568,
0.4161053002,
0.6007326245,
0.2826958299,
-0.3234390616,
-0.656627059,
-0.9013438225,
-0.4354383647,
-0.3579478264,
-0.0892432928,
0.3343547285,
0.1638251245,
-0.170396015,
0.9913288951,
-0.3795921803,
-0.2322537452,
-0.2232224643,
0.1508648992,
0.1294361502,
0.1963250041,
0.438390255,
-0.4400247633,
-0.5132382512,
0.0123784188,
-0.3797423542,
-0.2411624044,
0.0590241775,
-0.2952719629,
0.45423159,
0.3137497604,
-0.3881676793,
0.1483465731,
0.5427841544,
-0.2386179566,
0.5040006638,
-0.1588813514,
0.1396693885,
-1.0111074448,
0.1945580095,
0.0663961098,
-0.3841893077,
-0.4530540109,
0.0618000738,
0.0929034799,
0.2093322575,
-0.2119717598,
0.5745387077,
-0.3405830264,
-0.0573813468,
-0.2904261649,
0.3321886659,
-0.3785766959,
0.6404619217,
0.1046842188,
0.6631577611,
-0.039570231,
-0.446310401,
0.3370512128,
0.2120991796,
-0.3690772057,
0.5668363571,
-0.6622215509,
0.4190756083,
-0.3027547598,
0.4461545348,
-0.9594630003,
-0.3568579257,
0.1675542891,
-0.5004590154,
0.1149204001,
0.0194177665,
-0.342245847,
-0.217299059,
-0.4904672503,
-0.1537249237,
0.3113467693,
-0.7284340858,
0.3457409441,
0.3978580534,
-0.1689771116,
-0.6177723408,
-0.3494713008,
0.0346897691,
-0.0662342682,
-0.515576303,
0.2984861434,
-0.2271420062,
-0.2831664681,
0.1181967482,
0.0644512177,
0.3529633582,
0.0889941677,
0.2406719029,
0.3003230989,
-0.0928721875,
0.2960706949,
-0.4493430555,
0.0358831771,
-0.1374187171,
-0.3258687854,
0.5082773566,
-0.3852946758,
-0.4702605009,
-0.3549196124,
0.1680004895,
0.511775136,
-0.1948393583,
0.5641384721,
0.4073420763,
-0.1689756066,
-0.2452704906,
-0.5376161933,
-0.3626198769,
-0.3844486177,
0.4149211347,
-0.0733993724,
-0.9401463866,
0.3553248048,
0.3491989374,
0.2641256154,
0.4523616135,
0.628816843,
-0.2047518194,
1.2195190191,
0.5003388524,
-0.5190050006,
0.5732821822,
-0.0971077979,
-0.11177665,
-0.7308146954,
-0.1952233315,
-0.651902616,
-0.5935698748,
-0.6275879741,
-0.2552038133,
-0.0205450654,
0.0022826658,
-0.1470794976,
0.3443058133,
-0.2918293476,
0.4161905348,
0.7056947947,
0.3518709242,
0.3842094541,
-0.1700757444,
-0.101927489,
-0.1101945564,
-0.8064795136,
-0.5879037976,
1.2247008085,
0.4325334132,
1.0338037014,
0.3037977219,
0.9151871204,
0.1458109617,
0.6275051832,
-1.0072768927,
0.3917364478,
-0.0736220926,
-0.2252502739,
-0.4802106023,
-0.7117708921,
-0.9622363448,
0.0152465748,
-0.4456524253,
-0.4907763004,
-0.2912051678,
0.3311846852,
-0.3053283393,
0.2287608236,
-0.7323518395,
0.6534272432,
-0.1651988477,
-0.3827957511,
-0.2821347713,
-0.6019315124,
0.3632203937,
-0.1008811072,
0.1477983743,
0.1507481933,
0.2129798979,
0.9458264709,
-0.580982089,
0.8318688273,
-0.2001809627,
-0.261092484,
0.1253903359,
-0.1534452438,
0.7720804214,
0.0019125227,
-0.0837429836,
-0.4264654517,
-0.1642572433,
-0.3234748244,
-0.8914875984,
0.6466927528,
-0.8426912427,
-0.5017223358,
-0.1790994704,
-0.5187854767,
-0.4167125821,
-0.0188461244,
0.1425172091,
0.3766205311,
-0.2855970562,
0.354328841,
0.3904368281,
-0.1285786629,
0.2879264057,
0.6001798511,
-0.486294657,
-0.4832509756,
0.6164387465,
0.0382208712,
0.2789349854,
0.3911225796,
0.2589095533,
-0.6689976454,
-0.413552016,
-0.3904101551,
0.3742773831,
-0.606767714,
-0.348782897,
-0.4167491794,
0.0255336389,
-0.3771203756,
0.0646480322,
-0.4201387167,
-0.3957228661,
-0.0601401813,
0.0005638061,
0.271227628,
1.0123018026,
-0.0009346097,
0.1500778794,
-0.7736291289,
0.2207820863,
0.4525554478,
0.5972011685,
0.1587499082,
-0.6102625132,
-0.3115314245,
0.3631468713,
-0.202868551,
-0.8400757313,
0.2412724793,
0.2789406776,
0.7121079564,
0.2668745518,
0.2129094601,
0.7169897556,
-0.2406761646,
0.5547013879,
0.0526229925,
-0.6936362982,
0.3362970054,
-0.3253275752,
0.4569300711,
0.6546141505,
0.1200356856,
-0.8085825443,
-0.568766892,
-0.5171908736,
-0.5172998309,
0.7075132132,
0.0191242304,
-0.1157710776,
0.1661808491,
0.3683074415,
-0.0073147896,
0.0679657087,
-0.3577226698,
0.1334748864,
-0.1357458532,
-0.2777171433,
-0.3139230013,
-0.0031858559,
-0.1271224767,
-0.2053813934,
0.9110924006,
-0.3402229548,
0.1367717534,
0.0064180875,
-0.3555559814,
-0.2378284186,
0.5446840525,
0.6344996691,
0.4115353227,
-0.3181999922,
0.1301189214,
0.0766335949,
-0.3103304803,
0.1176229641,
0.020945603,
-0.0618805736,
-0.1948856264,
0.4785382748,
0.9107304811,
0.3447708189,
-0.6430267692,
0.3566441536,
-0.2873072028,
-0.1481622159,
0.296448797,
0.1617574245,
0.226529032,
0.2889202237,
0.1343788505,
-0.0099068955,
-0.056283392,
-0.6266400218,
0.3186241686,
0.6025141478,
-0.4857427776,
-0.3015489578,
0.6212599874,
0.1786707342,
-0.4994743764,
0.7049586773,
-0.2631190419,
-0.7115519643,
0.2606964409,
0.4573417902,
0.7278311253,
-0.0002895509,
0.3215884864,
0.5317183733,
0.0341475606,
-0.2558642924,
0.0552702434,
-0.024858743,
-0.6899764538,
-0.646107316,
-0.7449082732,
-0.7424184084,
0.0353649743,
-0.7800770998,
0.2817821205,
-0.39586851,
-0.2671167552,
0.1181471124,
0.2640827596,
-0.6597005725,
-0.069511272,
0.1793477684,
0.7989211679,
-0.6116064191,
0.8983229995,
0.8190376163,
-0.4131212234,
-1.2965830564,
0.0810813308,
0.0739065036,
-0.6828060746,
0.6121558547,
0.0596827008,
-0.2413240969,
-0.0414672792,
-0.5532695651,
-0.620300889,
0.7874571681,
0.6278313994,
-0.8072183132,
0.1521099359,
0.0783986896,
0.8731543422,
-0.3302507401,
0.2869419456,
0.5767444968,
0.4610092938,
-0.0020612585,
-1.1059474945,
-0.0100050149,
-0.3665667474,
0.0563887842,
0.4154942334,
-0.5378047228,
0.3454416692,
-0.4240052402,
-0.2844305038,
-0.0496830679,
0.8371362686,
0.24055475,
-0.1390418261,
0.6869570613,
0.6539331079,
0.9569221735,
-0.0022641651,
1.0180872679,
-0.2120683342,
0.5330976248,
1.2433749437,
-0.2236326188,
1.2051501274,
0.4749852419,
-0.1899349093,
0.5311436653,
0.5539470315,
0.1801948249,
0.4214219749,
0.4192813337,
0.0071375915,
-0.259814918,
-0.0236529857,
-0.2236115187,
0.5938662291,
-0.2143261433,
0.0078816628,
-0.1768195331,
-0.1374070644,
0.1279387474,
0.360788554,
-0.1271125227,
1.1355773211,
-0.1763068289,
-1.2076750994,
0.797221303,
0.0246738885,
0.8129775524,
-0.4720679224,
-0.0660223737,
-0.3786103427,
0.3344782293,
-0.2834841907,
-0.8094870448,
0.289323777,
0.193704918,
-0.2601184547,
-0.0134848775,
0.4581283927,
-0.6189007163,
-0.3334160447,
0.302872777,
0.0668737814,
-0.0637573525,
-0.1034055129,
-0.5507368445,
-0.0060570994,
0.0081480332,
-0.3356460333,
0.4910491407,
-0.0866893381,
0.0070169843,
0.7311345339,
0.8004001379,
0.2699886858,
-0.0014606812,
0.127117902,
0.7680233717,
-0.6576640606,
-0.5107854009,
-0.7559714317,
0.2807528377,
-0.1905089915,
-0.065275766,
0.5961387753,
0.5078731775,
0.8340716362,
0.0369949155,
0.7760639191,
0.1892718673,
0.7966708541,
-0.5761976242,
0.6225937605,
-0.3318166137,
0.439789772,
-0.3207861483,
-0.9466190934,
-0.2093928903,
0.4515469074,
-0.2575254738,
-0.1878598332,
0.4800821543,
1.0610055923,
0.1033996791,
0.1047683656,
0.0032249333,
0.0876252055,
0.4530333877,
0.6539863348,
0.7854331732,
-0.1233127639,
0.6018420458,
-0.3146707118,
-0.1781401187,
-0.2890020013,
-0.9535162449,
-0.6686540246,
-0.4361993968,
-0.1774772555,
-0.4914591908,
0.0497849472,
1.4659991264,
0.6697157025,
-0.8837974668,
-0.3846565485,
0.0463073999,
-0.0340233333,
-0.3774701059,
-0.2120588571,
0.3693498373,
-0.522477746,
-0.6578110456,
0.4322557151,
-0.0148150818,
-0.2035684884,
-0.2844225466,
-0.5745572448,
-0.0992491916,
0.0141237322,
0.479011476,
0.3326105475,
-0.7821575999,
-0.582318902,
0.329852879,
-0.367502749,
0.0914359167,
0.7185282111,
-0.796546042,
0.5491829515,
0.5820506811,
0.9494804144,
0.4356812537,
0.3077808917,
0.8158758879,
-0.7264571786,
-0.2256572098,
0.1014365181,
0.281662941,
0.6324858069,
-0.0925647467,
0.5443844199,
0.0870342255,
-0.6784293056,
-0.7208958864,
0.0503329672,
-0.9958043098,
0.0513713621,
1.3611780405,
-0.0474764965,
-0.1984051913,
0.2514424026,
-0.5411794186,
0.3026318252,
-0.6150267124,
1.0248861313,
0.7458444238,
-0.1565746963,
0.0104165608,
-0.2447940707,
0.5234533548,
0.4063593149,
-0.9718521833,
0.2571144104,
0.4934080839,
0.2527362704,
-0.1445057392,
0.6171594262,
0.027829282,
0.2122519165,
-0.4186619222,
0.0608051792,
0.0538486205,
-0.0661209896,
-0.5799220204,
0.0978378728,
0.5102060437,
-0.0729138702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14539v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14539v1
|
CMed-GPT: Prompt Tuning for Entity-Aware Chinese Medical Dialogue Generation
| 2023-11-24T15:10:56 | 2023-11-24T15:10:56 |
Zhijie Qu, Juan Li, Zerui Ma, Jianqiang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Medical dialogue generation relies on natural language generation techniques
to enable online medical consultations. Recently, the widespread adoption of
large-scale models in the field of natural language processing has facilitated
rapid advancements in this technology. Existing medical dialogue models are
mostly based on BERT and pre-trained on English corpora, but there is a lack of
high-performing models on the task of Chinese medical dialogue generation. To
solve the above problem, this paper proposes CMed-GPT, which is the GPT
pre-training language model based on Chinese medical domain text. The model is
available in two versions, namely, base and large, with corresponding
perplexity values of 8.64 and 8.01. Additionally, we incorporate lexical and
entity embeddings into the dialogue text in a uniform manner to meet the
requirements of downstream dialogue generation tasks. By applying both
fine-tuning and p-tuning to CMed-GPT, we lowered the PPL from 8.44 to 7.35.
This study not only confirms the exceptional performance of the CMed-GPT model
in generating Chinese biomedical text but also highlights the advantages of
p-tuning over traditional fine-tuning with prefix prompts. Furthermore, we
validate the significance of incorporating external information in medical
dialogue generation, which enhances the quality of dialogue generation.
|
[
-0.495888263,
-0.873226583,
0.8903419971,
0.068834722,
-0.6736651659,
-0.3565396369,
-0.3791948259,
-0.2091181725,
0.0560729243,
0.4138258696,
-0.7601994276,
-0.5287914872,
-0.2389804721,
0.3443657756,
0.4123261869,
1.3304994106,
0.1936842501,
0.5859358907,
0.2803128958,
0.2078411132,
-0.6329006553,
-0.5046558976,
-1.1787574291,
-0.0163555965,
0.5719696283,
-0.0340295956,
0.8799683452,
0.6384510398,
0.3071291745,
0.1755233854,
-0.0578415059,
0.428055197,
-0.0728341118,
0.1164048314,
-0.2449987829,
-0.0205105599,
-0.6537473202,
-0.0732989311,
0.6314411163,
0.6314499378,
-0.2165641189,
-0.3726663589,
0.0782951117,
0.4567952454,
-0.0037873762,
0.025964044,
-0.8707097173,
0.1147067323,
0.0202781539,
-0.4251537621,
-0.2741839588,
-0.3622048497,
0.4061133564,
-0.8100498915,
0.4873719811,
0.0564223044,
0.9129349589,
0.3958582878,
-0.3228296936,
-0.3077698648,
-0.2190491557,
0.2083741277,
-0.964495182,
0.1125135198,
0.1496703327,
0.1982300133,
-0.2659346759,
-0.7857224941,
-0.5282883644,
-0.5154522061,
-0.033339221,
0.2440539747,
0.3038043678,
0.5912281871,
0.2978334427,
0.4244810939,
-0.5720729828,
0.1322612613,
0.009804897,
-0.1725985557,
0.362321794,
0.3506387174,
0.4222981036,
-0.1405916065,
-0.289011538,
0.1648209989,
-1.0017637014,
-0.169294998,
0.0809495449,
0.4801674783,
0.0412153527,
0.3170088232,
-0.150463447,
0.6636864543,
0.4024712145,
-0.1801199466,
-0.0797219425,
-0.5789063573,
-0.3914443254,
0.1394258738,
0.9446097612,
0.54988271,
0.1451188475,
0.1994879693,
-0.3467183113,
-0.018620193,
0.3038666546,
-1.1619418859,
-0.5784825087,
0.2371942848,
-0.5586946011,
-0.2467761189,
-0.0202766377,
-0.4385418296,
-0.4129651785,
-0.3604340553,
0.1677002162,
-0.6093894839,
-0.30394876,
0.0335562527,
0.1731953174,
0.0119585991,
0.5387628078,
-0.840851903,
-0.1115297005,
0.5437729359,
0.7197024822,
-0.1848013997,
0.1291161031,
-0.6166108847,
-0.048160024,
-0.3282226026,
0.7599426508,
-0.4965413511,
-0.6258901358,
0.0864088759,
0.1032631844,
-0.2365567982,
-0.6679487824,
0.7526016831,
-0.1873029172,
0.472413063,
-0.3784752488,
-0.5600513816,
0.1853794903,
0.2230010927,
-0.2393486202,
0.5543885231,
0.0571598001,
-0.8710797429,
0.552822113,
-0.7352877855,
-0.4710468948,
0.380002737,
-0.3703193665,
-0.4992080033,
-0.0139365429,
0.6335662603,
0.4133162796,
-0.6259410381,
0.748686254,
0.0088773528,
-0.1357910931,
-0.0087671829,
-0.6561881304,
0.5836094618,
0.4408096373,
-0.3015466928,
0.3290267289,
-0.6196047068,
0.1468272954,
0.1534725577,
-0.2860772908,
-0.0277567003,
-0.0363089591,
-0.1314544678,
0.353330195,
0.1500543654,
-0.4200594723,
0.3096195757,
-0.8261625767,
0.3969607353,
0.5225425363,
0.5004141927,
0.0871596634,
-0.3736841977,
0.3919587731,
0.3144898117,
0.1833699793,
-0.5842045546,
-0.7960661054,
-0.4262948334,
-0.2870531976,
0.2720285058,
0.7818208337,
-1.2449897528,
0.4900427461,
0.113009125,
-0.450086832,
-0.6920134425,
-0.2678759098,
0.3557656109,
0.8601753116,
0.3584133983,
-0.2528239787,
-0.2134846151,
-0.7728898525,
-0.1028943136,
-0.2276514918,
-0.3792170584,
0.5842746496,
-0.0261068903,
-0.2303128093,
0.7792627811,
-0.5670793056,
-0.0824733004,
-0.1608121097,
0.03173922,
0.2884387076,
0.6011212468,
0.3214207292,
-0.8644980192,
-0.5784074664,
0.116409488,
-0.4482172728,
-0.3712154031,
-0.4090950489,
-0.0560563058,
0.232933417,
0.1983143091,
-0.7150050998,
0.303869307,
0.3915064633,
-0.3392034769,
0.7156687975,
-0.5852020979,
0.3534822166,
-1.4972140789,
0.0381722301,
0.0396547802,
-0.0309123863,
-0.6314123273,
-0.04261107,
0.1429686844,
-0.3241445422,
-0.3934167624,
0.3881080151,
-0.4297121763,
0.4532574713,
-0.3714680076,
0.2735497057,
-0.1996374875,
0.437369287,
0.3637036979,
0.8896715641,
0.6457253695,
-0.9135106206,
0.3142873049,
0.3158627748,
-0.0508208834,
0.7737436295,
-0.7642387152,
0.1306443065,
0.1220589057,
0.3168270588,
-0.7802956104,
-0.2126329988,
0.4212023616,
-0.4257873893,
0.5428927541,
-0.213755101,
-0.3355463743,
-0.2254461944,
-0.0470663756,
0.3491438031,
0.3876221776,
-0.4539966285,
0.1026445255,
0.2422417104,
-0.6102737188,
-0.1581801325,
-0.0185026117,
0.1292998791,
-0.0636091679,
-0.7731258869,
0.4683227539,
-0.3346855938,
0.1757206172,
-0.332367748,
0.0191163905,
-0.0320754014,
-0.1926838607,
0.0254404899,
0.5440992117,
-0.630892992,
0.2627094388,
0.3801957071,
-0.1691307873,
-0.0034319281,
-0.5935600996,
0.4746907651,
0.2647430003,
-0.3812014461,
-0.4429226518,
0.3729510307,
0.1945933551,
-0.3421589136,
0.6830071807,
0.4871240854,
-0.4039612412,
0.0487902537,
-0.3920123279,
-0.3842707574,
-0.4981920719,
0.5028124452,
-0.3224446476,
-0.8011856675,
0.2176782936,
-0.2933211625,
0.1891482919,
0.5447561145,
0.9476813078,
0.274181962,
1.3350429535,
0.3408623338,
0.1656247526,
0.4065331221,
0.5249194503,
0.1162277907,
-0.6889914274,
0.0556796677,
-0.2737936378,
0.3361608684,
-0.7413639426,
-0.2881072164,
0.7755599618,
-0.1926749945,
-0.2267540097,
0.0886386558,
-0.8419821262,
0.2761832774,
0.4323709607,
0.3049728572,
0.1738132536,
-0.317314595,
-0.5325319767,
-0.2875938118,
-0.7447455525,
-0.4730336368,
0.7265957594,
0.2474760413,
0.52350384,
-0.305829227,
0.3791840076,
-0.2041232437,
0.368825376,
-0.5682804585,
0.3951864243,
-0.1577804387,
-0.5608578324,
-0.1943022609,
-0.6101714969,
-0.9587789178,
0.1904416531,
-0.2499106675,
-0.4454875886,
-0.3019144535,
0.3345811367,
-0.6212538481,
0.2054910511,
-0.6740664244,
0.9039711356,
-0.0783085898,
-0.0683683977,
0.077009365,
-0.7968215346,
0.3044322729,
-0.0992219001,
-0.1992659569,
0.110402368,
0.1354382634,
0.2454519123,
-0.7102446556,
0.6707234979,
-0.4840385616,
-0.3979361653,
0.2887664139,
-0.1503059715,
0.7254591584,
0.646925807,
0.3137668967,
-0.1817231774,
-0.0335457437,
-0.1536248475,
-0.3090071976,
0.5521814823,
-0.392813921,
-0.9167047739,
-0.1080682203,
-0.3449569345,
-0.4229729772,
0.2000824511,
0.7909840345,
0.4964784384,
-0.3201111853,
-0.2739281058,
0.9415927529,
-0.871291399,
0.1088603139,
0.4852874875,
-0.0095061753,
-0.5475629568,
0.7703304887,
-0.0410703979,
0.3765646517,
0.3970789015,
0.1132403165,
-0.1010602862,
-0.6258298755,
-0.8448570371,
0.4112579226,
-0.3947214484,
-0.2582931221,
-0.74631989,
-0.4381506145,
-0.5559088588,
-0.0365353301,
-0.2246838957,
-0.123431012,
-0.365801692,
0.1310851127,
0.1323923618,
0.5774537325,
0.3099401295,
0.383528173,
-0.9032299519,
0.4096469879,
0.074371703,
0.4887583852,
-0.3473228812,
-0.4809568226,
-0.2904029191,
0.1593488753,
-0.4814049304,
-0.9278228283,
0.4621387124,
0.0043701627,
0.4556135237,
0.4485003948,
0.2235791534,
0.4906322956,
-0.9150876999,
1.0320335627,
0.2021028548,
-0.635381341,
0.7578626871,
-0.6918067336,
0.3214921355,
0.2642905116,
0.101304777,
-0.6769268513,
-0.5590773225,
-0.6318872571,
-0.778753221,
0.6055760384,
0.0382646993,
0.0328399539,
-0.3251851797,
0.3432128727,
0.1856052279,
0.2282865793,
-0.3872329593,
-0.3093478978,
-0.2435404509,
-0.2993777096,
0.0677376315,
-0.0642001107,
-0.0440130085,
-0.2089531273,
0.7222740054,
-0.2863551676,
0.4219464064,
0.5734136105,
0.1646714956,
-0.0098547768,
0.2496615499,
0.7518405318,
0.3429799974,
0.0358351842,
-0.4097836018,
0.2360282838,
-0.6848359704,
-0.1719067991,
0.3622477353,
-0.1043703482,
0.2797980309,
-0.1859425455,
0.9276763201,
-0.1429948807,
-0.5549855828,
0.4307808876,
-0.1838317066,
-0.2099445164,
-0.167133078,
0.0508070998,
0.0643372312,
-0.0547047257,
0.1811195016,
0.0571081862,
0.177819103,
-0.1433061659,
0.3179965317,
0.4280236959,
-0.3576154709,
-0.2266941071,
0.969912231,
0.4503284693,
-0.1440660059,
0.6672745347,
-0.2084952891,
-0.50096488,
0.4466642141,
0.633236587,
0.9189953208,
-0.3544989228,
0.0509052277,
0.5461065173,
0.2161470652,
-0.0869987905,
0.0048689493,
0.0728068054,
-0.5666205287,
-0.3800951242,
-0.3204341531,
-0.5830669403,
0.1556216031,
-0.3630514443,
0.399086535,
-0.6339135766,
-0.298700273,
0.006731818,
0.0056415233,
-0.4917178452,
0.5347746015,
0.1511919796,
0.8947127461,
-0.1941151917,
0.9973787069,
0.6608743668,
-0.2739775479,
-1.0390306711,
0.2881910801,
-0.0302751213,
-0.7485800982,
0.1989329904,
0.1627467424,
0.1987838894,
-0.0082580503,
-0.4187528789,
-0.3708137274,
0.9330412149,
0.4105924368,
-0.6054623723,
-0.184755668,
-0.0984978303,
0.5159444213,
-0.5792632699,
0.252294898,
0.3865475357,
0.2833322585,
0.0608590245,
-1.3051298857,
0.3756047189,
-0.3393568695,
0.0652924106,
0.1863668412,
-0.5528799891,
0.9294893742,
-0.2655641437,
-0.4203599393,
0.2926860154,
0.3340159357,
0.3484531939,
0.2293100506,
0.4101063311,
0.0992740318,
0.9203336835,
-0.2047390789,
1.1110855341,
-0.6181703806,
0.0194712635,
0.8149912953,
-0.3153802752,
0.3103570342,
0.1088620946,
-0.0531466752,
0.1120609194,
0.8281700015,
0.0338511467,
0.435850054,
0.1206803471,
-0.5596361756,
-0.1590646505,
-0.0946971402,
-0.7094523907,
-0.187802285,
0.5093591809,
-0.6737341881,
0.1286262572,
-0.1161553115,
0.1215473488,
-0.0480494872,
-0.4286934733,
1.1537175179,
0.1376827508,
-1.1057529449,
0.7587851882,
0.0608000495,
0.7852094769,
-0.6916382313,
-0.0062950458,
-0.1639490426,
-0.0493195988,
0.0122588864,
-0.3945985436,
-0.0964962319,
-0.0109078009,
-0.1457570195,
-0.0479114987,
0.6857529879,
-0.6947575808,
-0.1954006106,
-0.148958385,
0.4816740453,
0.1037463173,
-0.3584856093,
-0.7689033747,
-0.5077722669,
0.2693893015,
-0.3386039436,
0.385550648,
0.989099443,
0.034066461,
0.422149986,
0.6587718725,
0.3503936231,
-0.2535004318,
0.2898681164,
1.0648953915,
-0.7101778984,
-0.691183269,
-0.8320208788,
0.3745836616,
-0.10008654,
-0.5481157303,
0.2658451498,
0.3921168149,
0.5413732529,
-0.1932809502,
0.9075782299,
0.1782854199,
0.6694072485,
-0.7481604218,
0.9205434918,
-0.2500737906,
0.1818899065,
-0.4482987821,
-0.7236725092,
-0.187345624,
0.4876312912,
-0.0721038133,
0.2559060156,
0.8210450411,
0.8408263922,
0.3225310743,
0.1779234707,
0.4880735278,
0.1446588039,
0.3220688403,
0.6997474432,
0.5917826295,
-0.1317383647,
0.468197912,
0.1314345002,
-0.2236562371,
0.0150106903,
-0.7299664021,
-0.9981319904,
-0.5160235763,
-0.2325090915,
-0.2899115384,
0.0692558736,
1.3464699984,
0.5357148647,
-0.7716754079,
0.3893087804,
0.0069431742,
-0.3214256465,
-0.0236697048,
-0.1958733797,
0.3930931687,
-0.6487054825,
-0.7772219181,
0.3313143849,
0.3517724276,
0.2958768606,
0.0946083218,
-0.1559586823,
0.2384111881,
0.0740692317,
0.3142955899,
0.0487125888,
-0.6197021008,
-0.1913054585,
-0.0131006818,
-0.3575451672,
0.3032139242,
1.1193156242,
-0.724116683,
0.3553535938,
0.0248627253,
0.728156209,
0.148832649,
0.1393731833,
1.0784729719,
-0.8515604138,
0.1224582046,
0.2805373371,
0.4178419709,
0.4270231128,
-0.6814254522,
0.2621472776,
0.3473839462,
-0.7473126054,
-0.5831609964,
0.3359321356,
-0.8479018807,
-0.2586010695,
0.9730676413,
-0.2690933347,
0.2179010957,
-0.2825727463,
-1.072897315,
0.6301039457,
-0.5326387882,
0.6353874803,
0.5834766626,
-0.0427080393,
-0.1552832574,
-0.6327425838,
0.9096725583,
0.5728501678,
-0.9122461081,
0.1819806099,
0.4459830821,
0.151858896,
-0.1742455959,
0.8441491127,
-0.107918255,
0.4812846482,
-0.0042783688,
-0.1877347529,
-0.018548103,
0.0480356365,
-0.1139778942,
-0.0833657011,
0.1565591693,
0.0041826311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14530v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14530v3
|
Machine Translation for Ge'ez Language
| 2023-11-24T14:55:23 | 2024-04-15T15:08:43 |
Aman Kassahun Wassie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine translation (MT) for low-resource languages such as Ge'ez, an ancient
language that is no longer the native language of any community, faces
challenges such as out-of-vocabulary words, domain mismatches, and lack of
sufficient labeled training data. In this work, we explore various methods to
improve Ge'ez MT, including transfer-learning from related languages,
optimizing shared vocabulary and token segmentation approaches, finetuning
large pre-trained models, and using large language models (LLMs) for few-shot
translation with fuzzy matches. We develop a multilingual neural machine
translation (MNMT) model based on languages relatedness, which brings an
average performance improvement of about 4 BLEU compared to standard bilingual
models. We also attempt to finetune the NLLB-200 model, one of the most
advanced translation models available today, but find that it performs poorly
with only 4k training samples for Ge'ez. Furthermore, we experiment with using
GPT-3.5, a state-of-the-art LLM, for few-shot translation with fuzzy matches,
which leverages embedding similarity-based retrieval to find context examples
from a parallel corpus. We observe that GPT-3.5 achieves a remarkable BLEU
score of 9.2 with no initial knowledge of Ge'ez, but still lower than the MNMT
baseline of 15.2. Our work provides insights into the potential and limitations
of different approaches for low-resource and ancient language MT.
|
[
-0.5498523712,
-0.9027047157,
0.5596320033,
-0.270922184,
-0.3903263211,
-0.0448531397,
-0.6868623495,
-0.5411438346,
0.0600053594,
0.3675666749,
-0.5523793101,
-0.6226013899,
-0.6944322586,
0.2167557776,
-0.1909654289,
1.1320455074,
-0.2069173008,
0.2622096241,
0.3374569416,
-0.1921495348,
-0.419559598,
-0.5115917921,
-0.6454422474,
-0.696867466,
0.5277861953,
0.6880030036,
0.7986062169,
0.5266001821,
0.46408391,
0.2631075382,
-0.0577559881,
0.2279887199,
-0.4802737534,
-0.3033415377,
0.0305644516,
-0.2730873525,
-0.5824922323,
-0.2131216973,
0.4563761652,
0.6783037782,
0.0063689495,
0.2856036723,
0.1341030449,
0.6601116061,
-0.3835132718,
0.1689273268,
-0.6685166359,
0.1673990786,
-0.5500938892,
0.0338517055,
-0.2091992944,
-0.1306018084,
0.0146633796,
-0.611256361,
0.3805516064,
0.1178882271,
0.9244970679,
0.0378987007,
-0.3132690191,
-0.2202963084,
-0.7689566016,
0.6941814423,
-0.8133842349,
0.1812306046,
0.489043802,
0.4429278076,
-0.263907373,
-0.4787035286,
-0.651381433,
-0.3730264604,
0.0518044941,
0.0411535017,
-0.1090769395,
0.097760722,
0.2085653245,
0.3306476176,
-0.6293066144,
0.184344247,
-0.2488373518,
-0.0915754139,
0.3170213103,
0.159752667,
0.5357656479,
-0.1957222223,
-0.5475965142,
-0.168539986,
-0.7882722616,
-0.3843642771,
0.4187822044,
0.5722718239,
-0.1252527386,
0.5316563249,
-0.3482931256,
0.8631902337,
-0.0832693279,
0.0908160061,
0.3915879428,
-0.3863549232,
-0.1695235968,
-0.1058615595,
0.6677930355,
0.372161299,
0.3413000107,
-0.2982580662,
-0.1554835141,
-0.2301246822,
-0.0912621245,
-0.6378393769,
-0.2295481712,
-0.2754943371,
-0.5072332025,
0.1677000374,
-0.1525450647,
-0.6028416753,
-0.0233044848,
-0.1759263873,
0.6800945401,
-0.7798654437,
-0.1826034188,
0.2249603719,
0.1210702509,
0.2120747715,
0.4889970422,
-0.9433267117,
0.3321954012,
0.4874358773,
0.9915174246,
-0.0033604174,
-0.5855932832,
-0.4867400229,
0.1794349104,
-0.2245618552,
0.5507004857,
-0.2657663524,
-0.2408156246,
-0.1504939646,
0.0373695418,
-0.2881031632,
-0.4486200511,
0.6567232609,
-0.5199075341,
0.1170943975,
-0.2497245967,
-0.3995855749,
-0.6476067901,
0.2917185128,
-0.5456261039,
0.9682356119,
0.3304367661,
-0.3748590946,
0.0749138296,
-0.6115662456,
-0.5801456571,
0.2362076044,
-0.005553266,
-0.1815302372,
0.3061502278,
0.2353753895,
0.4611522555,
-0.3735507429,
-0.0903987661,
-0.2658402622,
-0.5410833359,
-0.1232958511,
-0.435806036,
0.3881303668,
0.3574438095,
-0.3389979005,
-0.1707107574,
-0.3379349113,
0.2345253825,
0.1975011677,
-0.2157347053,
-0.242483899,
-0.0456207469,
0.3511519432,
0.5501546264,
0.2342205346,
-0.5033121109,
0.1970296502,
-0.4631951451,
0.3995704949,
0.4111497104,
-0.2880152166,
0.5036821961,
-0.1778992862,
0.3918674588,
-0.0193880349,
0.0446280204,
0.2598641217,
-0.5575602055,
-0.7339339256,
0.0464904048,
0.4633973539,
0.7664269209,
-1.1313636303,
0.2208447009,
-0.6988031864,
-0.3568163216,
-0.4350660145,
0.4625811279,
0.426620543,
0.5862105489,
0.5815785527,
-0.3140612841,
-0.0217354354,
-1.0219432116,
0.0436176658,
0.1394989938,
-0.2715283334,
0.3127865195,
0.4925639033,
-0.1725949347,
0.294549644,
-0.4136903286,
-0.5522010922,
-0.5185676217,
0.2162533551,
0.3651486933,
0.416224122,
0.5823444724,
-0.6482306123,
-0.7811993957,
0.7756165266,
-0.5347682834,
0.0469092764,
0.2339009643,
-0.0434957854,
0.1433381587,
0.3061538339,
-0.5900462866,
0.0141335307,
0.7724382877,
-0.1578120738,
0.1755771041,
-0.4331639111,
0.404266268,
-1.2639530897,
0.1270826161,
-0.0729801655,
-0.3435976803,
-0.6525131464,
0.203842774,
-0.0626775995,
-0.2326814681,
-0.7575672865,
0.4210160375,
-0.5836923718,
-0.0350094661,
-0.6080111265,
0.4314184487,
-0.3986250758,
0.638515234,
-0.1180497706,
0.8558248281,
0.1787584126,
-0.5090308785,
0.4943740666,
0.2148213089,
-0.1677586287,
0.470118165,
-0.3303819895,
0.5107294917,
0.1931688786,
-0.0240719728,
-0.3097344637,
-0.2388990223,
0.6205168366,
-0.5368206501,
0.5778441429,
-0.5573475957,
-0.7513089776,
-0.2050818801,
-0.082375817,
0.2994316816,
0.5757721663,
-0.2306580991,
0.5224021673,
-0.0111774951,
-0.4833826721,
-0.4698209465,
-0.6498234868,
0.433050245,
-0.1603464037,
-0.7678189278,
0.4009865224,
0.1906777918,
0.0909393653,
0.292064786,
0.0365372524,
-0.1353662312,
0.2278570086,
-0.3055190742,
0.2269864529,
-0.4620044529,
0.0114503996,
-0.1118273363,
-0.2536143064,
-0.3730083406,
-0.4910393953,
0.6595907211,
-0.4336662889,
-0.3017385304,
0.0952551439,
0.4864249825,
0.1679289192,
-0.2104585171,
0.7915351987,
1.0516881943,
-0.6907100677,
-0.1152936518,
-0.3227111697,
0.1222709566,
-0.3761773705,
0.6923751235,
-0.6612419486,
-1.0084199905,
0.5615445971,
-0.2017387748,
-0.1532893181,
0.6061061621,
0.6968690157,
-0.1494068354,
0.9279779792,
0.6851814389,
-0.4226802289,
0.525644362,
0.0435546711,
0.145672366,
-0.7969390154,
0.1248915419,
-0.5159071684,
-0.4422335029,
-0.615472734,
-0.5716819167,
0.3104369044,
0.397788316,
-0.0321514346,
0.6204099655,
-0.1181785688,
0.5408554077,
0.6088548899,
0.2524938881,
0.2642955482,
0.2191114277,
-0.0606223717,
0.071769163,
-0.857190311,
-0.5933516026,
0.9413683414,
0.0668375939,
0.5097910762,
0.2339429706,
0.6626909971,
0.2214289755,
0.432759732,
-0.670707643,
0.3351293802,
-0.5263161063,
-0.5251808763,
-0.381164223,
-0.6175513864,
-0.7384582758,
0.4726133049,
-0.1952812821,
-0.7676902413,
-0.3288801908,
0.1986481696,
-0.3605651855,
0.4872768521,
-0.8367709517,
0.98176229,
-0.3713400066,
-0.2170543671,
-0.2697242498,
-0.7601072192,
0.2255792171,
-0.234719947,
0.1499307752,
-0.3043580949,
0.1181384549,
0.1270064861,
-0.3278891742,
0.5320373178,
0.0075783478,
-0.0566300265,
0.2071503848,
0.1048936695,
0.6075767279,
-0.3683721125,
0.1023380682,
0.4074769914,
-0.1579388678,
-0.4610252082,
-0.4570531249,
0.7210764885,
-0.5893900394,
-0.5344572067,
-0.1378374845,
-0.6011605263,
-0.152442798,
0.3476167321,
0.517778039,
-0.0735296309,
-0.2639044523,
0.0387562551,
0.5344690681,
-0.2443298548,
0.2759035528,
0.4285206497,
0.0447418392,
-0.3628814816,
1.0289413929,
0.2265747488,
0.2696718574,
0.2366017997,
0.0717666745,
-0.0995739028,
-0.7268368006,
-1.1675828695,
0.0877790377,
-0.6518604159,
-0.4129677117,
-0.3815499544,
-0.0119473683,
-0.1165763736,
-0.0409448594,
-0.2237900048,
-0.2893040478,
-0.1481142938,
-0.0021085138,
0.2122350186,
0.5758485198,
-0.0063696764,
0.4063843787,
-1.1928310394,
0.3039834499,
-0.0423728675,
0.2895427644,
-0.1488616467,
-0.5464273095,
-0.6626342535,
0.0756958127,
-0.1426445395,
-1.0014619827,
0.3847172558,
0.3628658354,
0.4925661981,
0.0618740842,
-0.1672410667,
0.6007162929,
-0.9661281109,
0.5988595486,
0.2354702502,
-0.9962190986,
0.3805809021,
-0.5440545082,
0.0670872703,
0.6034488082,
-0.0235692374,
-0.8402713537,
-0.0776201487,
-0.2830339968,
-0.7388333082,
0.810945034,
0.3343220949,
0.40573439,
-0.0453939587,
0.3213011622,
-0.0182855409,
0.1126880795,
-0.7539890409,
-0.2690065503,
0.1021224707,
-0.367566973,
-0.3736288846,
0.077027373,
-0.009073304,
-0.005827527,
0.6900843978,
-0.3115323782,
0.22179012,
-0.0217858013,
-0.5222638249,
-0.3266835511,
0.5981793404,
0.7729418874,
0.2750327587,
0.0195820946,
0.083018221,
0.7046649456,
-0.4243130684,
0.1665981412,
0.5115072131,
-0.4555584192,
0.1210637689,
-0.0038546335,
0.6150483489,
0.1238660589,
-0.2179595977,
0.3762468398,
0.3961311281,
-0.1448371559,
-0.0680676177,
-0.0690170676,
0.2232283652,
0.2810816467,
0.2457596511,
0.002019902,
0.2159885317,
-0.3476262391,
-0.0535303019,
0.3149667978,
-0.2271133959,
-0.4563705325,
0.6082516909,
0.2243424356,
-0.0990960896,
0.7350139022,
-0.27591905,
-0.7478584051,
0.4926870465,
0.5731788278,
0.8967055082,
-0.1230294928,
0.165037632,
0.2261560708,
0.6398457289,
-0.3280084729,
0.1817909181,
0.1091607064,
-0.6910364032,
-0.5792056322,
-0.4508464038,
-0.3251596689,
0.0697125867,
-0.5128729939,
0.2449091077,
0.0344877616,
-0.2930750847,
-0.5379650593,
0.1387469321,
-0.9806140065,
0.0221454185,
0.3030335009,
0.753241241,
-0.84488976,
1.0579769611,
0.8421601057,
-0.5509513021,
-0.6996241212,
-0.1335460097,
-0.1524015963,
-0.7151138186,
0.4981394708,
-0.021906497,
-0.3544332087,
0.324482888,
-0.3489369452,
-0.7290509343,
1.0682212114,
0.5650704503,
-0.5976448655,
-0.0030168549,
0.1270608455,
0.5396276116,
-0.0334099159,
-0.2787610888,
0.3251217306,
0.4375994503,
-0.2637616098,
-1.0309898853,
-0.0894370377,
-0.1991110444,
0.0757702664,
0.663036108,
-0.6238661408,
0.7960396409,
-0.2514185607,
-0.406788528,
0.2850535214,
0.6391704082,
-0.2323373407,
0.3686947227,
0.2751252055,
0.7036241889,
0.5390157104,
-0.2444532663,
1.0330407619,
-0.3184339404,
0.6346529722,
1.1281455755,
-0.2891331017,
0.9598615766,
0.4392090738,
-0.0375558995,
0.2036995739,
0.6359283924,
-0.2040993124,
0.4374194443,
0.2231646478,
-0.5196968913,
-0.3606800437,
-0.003198694,
-0.5567513108,
0.2235070616,
0.2997557521,
-0.3820736706,
-0.4481207132,
0.050281737,
0.1998543888,
0.0132181346,
-0.4437118173,
0.5346688628,
0.3051365912,
-0.2525542378,
0.3120536804,
0.5960480571,
0.6584874988,
-0.590297401,
-0.043496076,
-0.2922503054,
0.1806134433,
0.0434888527,
-0.5132295489,
0.1058776528,
0.2281096429,
-0.1392861754,
-0.0716688558,
0.9487299323,
-0.5769164562,
-0.4348006546,
0.3404159844,
1.1032090187,
0.2804888189,
-0.0765290931,
-0.7477350235,
-0.391084373,
-0.2277090251,
-0.0873749405,
0.412075758,
0.5990163684,
-0.1140010431,
0.5217095613,
0.5731288791,
0.2473638952,
0.1039687768,
0.0717541128,
0.5946880579,
-0.6382892132,
-0.3034240305,
-0.9606863856,
-0.0532299094,
0.2689729333,
-0.2245639563,
0.843482852,
0.3895280957,
1.3154317141,
-0.3282515407,
0.5787836313,
-0.0334085263,
0.0997539833,
-0.7743683457,
0.7637736797,
-0.483599484,
-0.1709760725,
-0.3236041367,
-1.034547925,
-0.226103887,
0.5691686273,
-0.126289323,
0.115432471,
0.5946270823,
0.4341775179,
-0.1553405225,
-0.3764888942,
0.6964665055,
-0.2017488033,
-0.1599821895,
1.1124032736,
0.8103280663,
-0.5468925238,
0.8207778931,
-0.1034650132,
-0.0075083808,
-0.1826538146,
-0.7280097008,
-0.6817090511,
-0.2264762968,
-0.155096069,
-0.2019705027,
0.1351968199,
1.1398162842,
0.4661141336,
-0.7014681697,
-0.0961888582,
0.1674777865,
0.0336902514,
-0.3996745348,
-0.0675973892,
0.2860825062,
-0.312623769,
-0.9294298291,
0.410795331,
0.2948420644,
0.2821300328,
0.1316176206,
-0.2551451921,
-0.0705417767,
-0.3690309823,
0.6792179942,
0.2582928538,
-0.7016341686,
-0.6198197007,
0.1383141726,
-0.3699915111,
0.1244196966,
0.5883299112,
-0.2698041797,
0.2294781953,
0.4091390371,
0.8271497488,
0.5390907526,
-0.1263423115,
0.6529716253,
-0.7621670961,
-0.0689623356,
0.0981382057,
0.540342629,
0.4333257079,
-0.2501041889,
0.6106108427,
0.2263851762,
-0.2740933597,
-0.338993758,
0.3682909608,
-0.6835909486,
-0.0581340492,
1.0065380335,
-0.2801422179,
-0.0764464736,
-0.126728192,
-0.0615974553,
0.4754372835,
-0.0237838179,
0.5213015676,
1.0926916599,
-0.001481018,
-0.133530587,
-1.0500869751,
0.2487584502,
0.4903052747,
-0.6587930918,
-0.1311377883,
0.7150923014,
0.4150797129,
-0.0250220113,
0.5556243658,
-0.1793653816,
0.4181369841,
-0.1396628916,
0.2543380558,
-0.199864924,
-0.11505308,
-0.5466442704,
-0.0854360014,
0.1488796026,
-0.4134067893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14517v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14517v2
|
tinyCLAP: Distilling Constrastive Language-Audio Pretrained Models
| 2023-11-24T14:45:53 | 2024-06-12T11:41:31 |
Francesco Paissan, Elisabetta Farella
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Contrastive Language-Audio Pretraining (CLAP) became of crucial importance in
the field of audio and speech processing. Its employment ranges from sound
event detection to text-to-audio generation. However, one of the main
limitations is the considerable amount of data required in the training process
and the overall computational complexity during inference. This paper
investigates how we can reduce the complexity of contrastive language-audio
pre-trained models, yielding an efficient model that we call tinyCLAP. We
derive an unimodal distillation loss from first principles and explore how the
dimensionality of the shared, multimodal latent space can be reduced via
pruning. TinyCLAP uses only 6% of the original Microsoft CLAP parameters with a
minimal reduction (less than 5%) in zero-shot classification performance across
the three sound event detection datasets on which it was tested
|
[
-0.546738863,
-0.3557576537,
0.5309225917,
0.130091697,
-0.4799441397,
-0.0678053647,
-0.3538168967,
-0.1931850761,
0.0414097011,
0.0320284553,
-0.5392344594,
-0.3250554204,
-0.5581466556,
-0.3472039104,
-0.2958908677,
1.0554096699,
0.1893108934,
-0.2819958627,
-0.0578061007,
-0.4507507384,
-0.317647934,
-0.3804913163,
-0.4151453972,
-0.425581634,
0.2856576145,
0.6548975706,
0.4489440024,
0.1348461062,
0.3930106461,
0.2955856025,
-0.3851964474,
-0.1657736897,
-0.3834034801,
-0.114158988,
0.0402715057,
-0.8174267411,
-0.3356018066,
0.3031087816,
0.4457558692,
0.973791182,
-0.213496685,
0.6251703501,
0.2248626351,
0.4947466254,
-0.6587777138,
0.0074837571,
-0.6779969335,
-0.0365814641,
-0.3128639758,
-0.2264624536,
-0.1936359257,
-0.1010517403,
0.1046645194,
-0.4983302057,
0.5719305277,
0.0501312613,
0.4122957587,
0.4739651084,
-0.2223015726,
-0.0902249813,
-0.7972843647,
0.9293521047,
-0.7235869765,
0.1822199523,
0.3675722182,
0.2817104161,
0.1325832307,
-0.8953050375,
-0.6815658212,
0.0357324593,
0.041876886,
-0.1296664178,
-0.3616511226,
0.1878457665,
0.0021006346,
0.4218656421,
-0.5159281492,
0.0810862631,
-0.6555886269,
-0.2165749967,
0.28622967,
-0.0119523844,
0.1369878948,
0.0707645491,
-0.1939918846,
-0.3507953882,
-0.6041767001,
-0.0317669772,
0.3020733297,
0.3345888257,
-0.2334255725,
0.113793835,
0.1423294544,
0.305432111,
0.0754126459,
-0.4631794095,
0.2106989324,
-0.3732122481,
-0.16199404,
0.22498779,
0.7125784755,
0.3243884146,
-0.0287601966,
0.223799035,
-0.1243479997,
0.4258697927,
-0.1577921212,
-0.8757898211,
-0.8334759474,
0.2034727037,
-0.4754199386,
-0.0892199427,
-0.3104364276,
-0.418643266,
-0.2386564016,
-0.3464314342,
0.3931469917,
-0.4168650508,
-0.214875862,
-0.0264054369,
-0.3760892749,
-0.4516649842,
0.3304727972,
-0.6664713621,
0.4447268546,
0.3842350245,
1.0577968359,
0.0456698164,
-0.1355399936,
-0.5716668963,
0.0515409261,
-0.1141308919,
0.6299701929,
-0.3664376438,
-0.4706127644,
-0.5126565695,
-0.4690286517,
-0.0310453251,
-0.8826780319,
0.3758930564,
-0.2491465956,
0.0569701977,
0.3385539651,
-0.4020458162,
-0.1602105498,
-0.0599280111,
-0.6564763188,
0.54624933,
-0.1088697165,
-0.8946321011,
0.2835556269,
-0.4242810905,
-0.3691004217,
-0.2488411814,
-0.126889661,
-0.4620397985,
0.8570482135,
0.2722443342,
0.1802537441,
-0.4160726964,
0.216207087,
-0.5143886209,
-0.4584656656,
0.0898003727,
-0.6221504211,
0.6642954946,
0.4498291016,
-0.14558433,
0.0232848525,
-1.1545363665,
-0.0533236377,
-0.0495108105,
-0.2808310688,
-0.6555452943,
-0.1657056212,
0.2752601802,
0.2960020602,
-0.0074893595,
-0.559493959,
0.0668910444,
-0.3437421322,
0.6233198047,
0.5244244337,
-0.2096936703,
0.761254251,
-0.0687136427,
0.3777089715,
0.2508235872,
0.2246679664,
-0.0701452941,
-0.1555384845,
-0.6016780734,
-0.6809283495,
0.561113596,
0.2854112089,
-0.7843632698,
0.0824260786,
-0.1558375359,
-0.4581232071,
-0.8368991017,
0.295455575,
0.4705834985,
0.3210635781,
0.1987352073,
-0.2432106882,
-0.6282030344,
-0.8544070721,
0.1277204454,
-0.3372417092,
-0.5126253963,
-0.157076031,
0.3023898005,
-0.0398090743,
0.9023844004,
-0.5503306985,
-0.6709042192,
-0.3209454119,
0.5182271004,
0.3875251412,
0.6338424087,
0.667973876,
-0.8592190742,
-0.5289478302,
-0.2509462237,
-0.3099429011,
-0.4819730222,
0.0450572819,
0.5934380293,
-0.25894472,
0.5609027743,
-0.4944098592,
0.5889468789,
0.8979812264,
0.0540314317,
0.394682914,
-0.3605866432,
-0.1033920944,
-0.6146469116,
0.0645140186,
-0.4175290763,
-0.20039922,
-0.7546777725,
-0.2761642039,
-0.1740520447,
-0.3811072409,
-0.6870142817,
0.4413173199,
-0.6600427032,
0.0585777014,
-0.5812163949,
0.2999269068,
0.066671215,
0.5729663968,
-0.0098925848,
0.6967849135,
0.4935382009,
-0.7363922,
-0.1300254315,
0.1858247668,
-0.3283172548,
0.5725206733,
-0.7280219197,
0.1573345363,
0.0751308352,
0.2385088205,
-1.1939404011,
0.1249350309,
-0.2023475617,
-0.3345150352,
0.3383432627,
-0.2624181807,
-0.5130178332,
-0.3444567025,
-0.6361102462,
0.8979117274,
0.6656186581,
-0.7278743982,
0.3266246021,
0.6278062463,
-0.2424743325,
-0.0258700978,
-0.7280749679,
-0.3306878209,
-0.4293364286,
-0.4121748507,
0.404910028,
-0.2841942012,
-0.2391435057,
-0.1087385491,
-0.4721674621,
-0.2849913538,
-0.0111258272,
0.4190959632,
0.0281225313,
-0.0753464401,
0.1479180455,
0.0405345261,
-0.2933864594,
-0.3410871625,
-0.2241733968,
0.5256336927,
-0.2151615918,
-0.2660029531,
-0.7303043604,
0.3338931799,
0.5313179493,
0.0501957163,
0.4094414115,
0.5794430375,
0.0893693343,
-0.2915048301,
-0.3826534748,
-0.2523032725,
-0.5322617888,
0.1173339859,
-0.3720019162,
-0.9497920871,
0.4990475178,
-0.4229381979,
-0.053092014,
0.2130012661,
0.2782038748,
-0.2692590952,
0.8490946293,
0.6989143491,
0.0269831773,
0.5544525981,
-0.1036482453,
0.0917834342,
-0.7720288634,
0.1971820891,
-0.5334624648,
-0.5571402311,
-0.4242227972,
-0.5870863795,
0.5159701705,
0.1796843261,
0.1076054052,
0.195587486,
-0.5157929659,
0.5420278311,
0.7874440551,
-0.0493606925,
0.2124314159,
-0.0280577913,
-0.08009018,
-0.1935051531,
-0.8937619328,
-0.3202786148,
0.9638980031,
0.2316849232,
0.7699031234,
0.0237137489,
0.9180762768,
0.1549248546,
0.1182496697,
-0.4747061133,
0.4689919055,
-0.3030858338,
-0.633947432,
-0.2116816938,
-0.3939289153,
-0.717879653,
0.4949447811,
-0.0636082441,
-0.7001698017,
0.3880111873,
0.5880870819,
-0.5853072405,
0.2547129989,
-0.8562265038,
0.6343835592,
0.0331115089,
-0.2010768503,
-0.2917952836,
-0.7321314216,
0.4258235395,
-0.2333242893,
0.5708174109,
-0.1643608063,
0.1320026219,
0.9848803282,
-0.8396717906,
0.9794404507,
-0.4368528128,
0.116584681,
0.6775912642,
0.2781018913,
0.2360996157,
-0.1258865148,
0.2757071555,
0.2418287992,
0.3706704676,
-0.2377889007,
-0.5897327662,
0.5616030097,
-0.5017108917,
-0.467707634,
-0.1662288755,
-0.4938209355,
-0.3318766356,
0.0068237665,
0.2846961319,
0.4047134221,
-0.2711285353,
0.3950907886,
0.466001004,
-0.1448584199,
0.6676819921,
0.4492754042,
-0.2350897193,
-0.376635164,
0.9832544327,
0.1538465321,
0.089349173,
0.1580492705,
0.3530159295,
-0.3050568402,
-0.9265341163,
0.2172519267,
0.2368438244,
-0.5133956671,
0.0087683769,
-0.2697642446,
0.2281074673,
-0.3165569305,
-0.0596425496,
-0.788649559,
-0.7919245958,
-0.4397658408,
0.0156765282,
-0.1210050732,
0.2243481874,
-0.6011458039,
0.9450897574,
-0.9420329928,
0.5534431934,
0.4540287554,
0.1840023845,
-0.1363966167,
-0.7490473986,
-0.0615343861,
-0.2306040972,
-0.1706421524,
-0.6224685311,
0.4167258143,
0.5947650075,
0.2822960317,
0.5637697577,
0.5334593654,
0.9273066521,
-0.7020353675,
0.7292474508,
0.8399506211,
-1.0358076096,
0.6481071115,
0.0089416187,
0.5299262404,
1.0255995989,
0.0162828341,
0.0119375298,
-0.3022149503,
-0.9105217457,
-0.934232235,
0.7054700255,
0.4527591765,
-0.128707841,
0.203188166,
-0.2094925642,
0.160864681,
0.5226045251,
-0.3851490021,
-0.1090479791,
-0.0776670426,
-0.2579868734,
-0.3250916898,
-0.4977330565,
-0.3732941151,
-0.5031518936,
0.3872025311,
-0.0197765604,
0.025415184,
-0.0955588147,
-0.4142782092,
0.3388719261,
0.5073994994,
0.560923934,
0.3277871311,
-0.220929116,
0.6996868849,
0.1333949417,
-0.5496679544,
0.3923470676,
-0.1630420536,
0.1225042567,
0.2878755927,
0.4067207873,
0.8660280108,
0.5472841859,
-0.6259928346,
0.6141085625,
-0.1533325464,
-0.1432483047,
-0.0977606624,
0.0625205189,
-0.005145154,
0.392642796,
0.2374585867,
0.1441039443,
0.3783863783,
-0.5865084529,
0.291039139,
0.0533232242,
-0.2894975841,
-0.6725305319,
0.6982223392,
0.2889297307,
-0.1732818633,
0.4727974534,
-0.0206934009,
-0.3258897066,
0.3323648572,
0.4149383605,
0.7307075262,
-0.3213861883,
0.0755596086,
0.0140808001,
0.1744793952,
0.0096183987,
0.0157526322,
-0.5768694282,
-0.3039868772,
-0.0726354197,
-0.7492234111,
-0.3783490062,
0.1417405605,
-0.650775373,
-0.0971113071,
-0.5703236461,
-0.4838610888,
0.2452012002,
0.0175984781,
-0.6810697913,
0.148314923,
0.3394610882,
0.6028577089,
-0.9200056791,
1.0267214775,
0.526006341,
-0.2930729687,
-0.7006248832,
-0.1455384791,
0.2922981083,
-0.3742804229,
0.7633078098,
0.109453924,
-0.2320563346,
-0.2618477345,
-0.594997406,
-0.3736566007,
0.7250133753,
0.650588274,
-0.8861743212,
0.0490858592,
0.047289595,
0.6252391934,
-0.164674595,
0.0369412974,
0.7942811847,
0.396890372,
0.3407113254,
-1.2294791937,
-0.3071965277,
-0.2783726752,
0.1184779927,
-0.0106777372,
-0.4396071732,
1.1619150639,
-0.10440135,
-0.3491460383,
-0.1483662426,
0.6271350384,
0.451063633,
0.7913115025,
0.7535778284,
0.3438265324,
0.7695961595,
-0.0067313081,
0.6212922931,
-0.0700468644,
0.3572470248,
1.6046867371,
-0.1534133703,
0.9247952104,
0.9231575131,
-0.4819895923,
0.1569161564,
0.2924318016,
0.3411077559,
0.8319097161,
0.0360385329,
-0.3036513329,
-0.1862995923,
0.0010136421,
-0.2301747352,
0.5901681185,
0.2599894702,
0.0785740763,
-0.2214003056,
0.4501931965,
-0.0056948219,
0.1231948361,
-0.3692413867,
0.7482679486,
0.3838139176,
-0.271250695,
0.6675329804,
-0.373083055,
0.864227891,
-0.4730454683,
0.1783342063,
-0.3043893874,
0.5100132227,
-0.1628369987,
-0.4115953147,
0.4082433283,
-0.1180763915,
-0.2714108825,
-0.0845425799,
0.6289353967,
-0.5109237432,
-0.113105379,
0.343139261,
0.2707425952,
0.3149492741,
-0.3684956431,
-0.4382758439,
0.2654156685,
-0.013376384,
-0.2525029778,
0.5984665155,
0.524328351,
0.1622984111,
0.4776781797,
0.6232132316,
0.288972348,
0.208412677,
0.0203822814,
0.9439767599,
-0.3854503632,
-0.8749922514,
-0.6362854242,
0.3499650955,
-0.1063121855,
0.0096098296,
0.7052560449,
0.3336336911,
0.6793539524,
-0.3354970217,
0.4934490621,
0.0002486899,
0.5207390785,
-0.3544415236,
0.7626052499,
-0.7495352626,
0.3923304975,
-0.1909018457,
-0.6609714031,
-0.3882361352,
0.4497751296,
-0.0804531872,
-0.2281353623,
0.7226971388,
0.5391768217,
-0.3353760242,
-0.1010938808,
0.6395852566,
0.1490687132,
0.3213213682,
0.557162106,
0.6458857656,
-0.3396244347,
0.7660703659,
-0.4466595352,
-0.2530044019,
-0.2719747722,
-0.6987196207,
-0.9655473828,
-0.5982627273,
-0.4661887288,
0.2286190242,
-0.2208004892,
0.6859859228,
0.9064792395,
-0.9448437095,
-0.1912717074,
0.0585376918,
0.0246722996,
-0.1221076101,
-0.1141816825,
0.5608065128,
-0.2061623186,
-0.7241891026,
0.703389287,
0.2628289163,
0.1485528648,
0.0868320242,
-0.013342822,
-0.1199861318,
0.0629287437,
0.6961109638,
0.5411394835,
-0.4581537843,
-0.2556725442,
-0.7023794055,
0.3094286025,
0.0296624824,
0.9314700961,
-0.7619457245,
0.492773056,
0.4873924553,
0.1476986259,
0.6795499325,
-0.230491057,
0.4216048419,
-1.2871530056,
1.0034251213,
0.2178003341,
0.3198862076,
0.1718794554,
0.4354635179,
0.4612200558,
0.3384956717,
-0.3365621865,
-1.1620448828,
0.0104213459,
-1.1532343626,
-0.5428202152,
0.9058327675,
-0.1976000965,
-0.3860728443,
-0.1562082469,
-0.3841102421,
0.3393829167,
-0.2308092713,
0.625056088,
0.3033025861,
-0.1078355312,
-0.2932835817,
-0.2335879654,
0.6187393069,
0.3370926678,
-0.3672706187,
0.2040410042,
0.5836766958,
0.313908428,
0.5118623376,
0.9809889197,
0.082972385,
0.178850159,
0.4597883523,
0.0884535611,
-0.2939818799,
-0.78913486,
-0.4356499612,
0.7788608074,
0.0963515639,
-0.67271626
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.